This page was generated by rich. It is very poorly optimized for mobile and may take a while to render on a phone.
If your browser won't render part of the page try reloading.
The Epstein Files
I Made Epstein's Text Messages Great Again (And You Should Read Them)
cryptadamus.substack.com/p/i-made-epsteins-text-messages-great
@mastodon  /  @substack  /  @twitter  /  @github
The following views of the underlying selection of Epstein Files are available:
       ************** Not All Epstein Files Are Here! **************       
This dataset includes everything from the 2025 Oversight tranche
as well as a curated selection of the 2026 DOJ tranche
with a particular focus on cryptocurrency
and women who speak Russian.
Abbreviations Used Frequently In These Conversations
Barak
former Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak
BG, Bill
Bill Gates
Brock
Brock Pierce (crypto bro with a very sordid past)
GRAT
Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (tax shelter)
HBJ, Jabor Y
Sheikh Hamad bin Jassim (former Qatari prime minister)
Jared
Jared Kushner
Joi
Joi Ito (MIT Media Lab, MIT Digital Currency Initiative)
KSA
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
LSJ
Little St. James (Epstein's island)
Madars
Madars Virza (co-founder of privacy crypto ZCash)
MBS
Mohammed bin Salman Al Saud (Saudi ruler)
MBZ
Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan (Emirates sheikh)
Mooch
Anthony 'The Mooch' Scaramucci (Skybridge crypto bro)
NPA
non-prosecution agreement
PA
Prince Andrew
Terje
Terje Rød-Larsen
VI
U.S. Virgin Islands
Woody
Woody Allen
External Links
DOJ Epstein Files Transparency Act Disclosures (search)
2025 Oversight Committee Press Release (raw files)
Jmail (read His Emails via Gmail interface)
Carstensen Epstein Archive (findings)
epstein.media (raw document images)
Epstein Bitcoin Emails (crypto)
EFTA Search (search filters)
Epstein Audit (money)
Epstein Exposed
Files Overview (last updated: 2026-03-29)
File Type
Count
Has Author
No Author
Uncertain Author
Size
Emails
4947
4740
207
264
18.84 MB
iMessage Logs
87
66
21
53
1.23 MB
JSON Data
19
n/a
n/a
n/a
1.05 MB
Other
3468
803
2665
14
81.86 MB
Rough Guide to Highlighted Colors
Africa
Asia
Bill Gates
China
Democrat
Epstein
Europe
Ghislaine
Harvard
India
Israel
JEE
Joi Ito
Kathryn Ruemmler
Latin America
Mongolia
Prince Andrew
Republican
Rothschild
Russia
Steve Bannon
Steven Hoffenberg
Trump
USVI
academia
arts
bank
business
crime
crypto
employee
estate executor
finance
friend
girls
government
journalist
junk
kazakhstan
law firm
lawyer
lobbyist
medical
mideast
modeling
publicist
real estate
russian girl
tech
techco
victim lawyer
woo
(if you think there's an attribution error or can deanonymize an (unknown) contact @cryptadamist)
(thanks to @ImDrinknWyn + others for help attributing redacted emails)
EFTA00014822 (Jmail)
[government] fake Austrian 
passport under the name Marius
Robert Fortelni with Saudi 
Arabian home address that 
Epstein used to enter several 
countries, expired in 1987 
[nyp]
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                    Ghislaine Maxwell [epstein] Epstein's girlfriend, daughter of the spy Robert Maxwell 
 Interlochen Center for the Arts [arts] summer camp to which Epstein donated money and where Epstein and Ghislaine groomed victims [npr] 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00090261 (Jmail)
 [misc] letter from Interlochen Center for the Arts to Jeffrey Epstein thanking him for donations
(date: 1997-09-18)
Interlochen Center for the Arts
Memorandum

To: Jeffrey Epstein
From: Interlochen Center for the Arts
Re: Scholarship Lodge Information
Date: 8/26/93

I have instructed Town and Country Log Homes to send you the
blueprints for the proposed scholarship lodges we anticipate
building on campus. Karen Sargent, a noted architect and
Interlochen Alumni from New Jersey, is in the process of modifying
the plans to incorporate wheel chair and handicap accessibility.
She will forward the plans to me upon completion.
The basic plan for one-half of the lodge is priced in the
neighborhood of $125,000 to $150,000, depending on the options
selected. Karen is also working on the cost for modifying the
structure. I will send them on to you upon my return from Colorado
in mid-September.
I have spoken with Dean Boal and our Buildings and Grounds
Director. We believe the area next to Frohlich lodge is the
optimal spot for placement due to its location on the water and
accessibility for handicapped vehicles in the winter.
If you are interested in proceeding with the concept, I will be
happy to send a formal proposal upon my return.
All is well here, but a bit muggy.
Best wishes,
Inteitchen .arts Academy Mierlochen Arts Camp Interlochen Public Radio 88.7 FM/10P 9 FAl
Address: Interim:hen Center or the Arts PG. Box 199 Interlochen, Michigan 49643 -0199
Phone Fa x ILY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000272
GOVERNMENT
EXHIBIT
741
52 20 Cr 330 (AJN)
Interlochen Center for the Arts
0 Interlochen February 9, 1994

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
J. Epstein and Company, Inc.
The Villard House
457 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Dear Jeffrey:
I have talked to you and Ghislaine on several occasions to say thank you. But, I wanted to express in writing my 
personal and professional gratitude for the
very generous gift $20 0 for a new scholarship lodge. It is truly an extraordinary sture.
I thought an update would be appropriate at this time.

1. The contract with Town and Country has been
executed and they have scheduled construction of
the lodge.

2. We are waiting for the temperature to rise above
10-15 degrees so that we can move the
existing buildings and set the foundation. (The
June target date remains at this time.) Design
and construction of the exterior walls is
underway.

3. You have approved the latest set of drawings with
the basement entrance as indicated and approved
the green roof which works for us as well.

4. We are requesting furniture packages from local
vendors that will be both aesthetic and functional
for a rental lodge. When we receive the packages
and corresponding quotes, we will send them on to Ghislaine for her comments and suggestions.

5. We anticipate setting aside all lodge income in the 1994 Camp season and placing the net income in an endowment fund 
so that subsequent repairs,
maintenance and furniture replacement are funded through the endowment. All succeeding income will be placed into the 
Jeffrey Epstein Scholarship
Mierlochen .flits Academy huerlochen Arts Camp Mtedochen Public Radio 88.7 FM: 100.9 FM
Address: Mier/octet; Center inr the Arts PO. Rog 199 Mterlochen, Michigan 49643.0199
Phone Fax mon HLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000218

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
Page 2
February 9, 1994
Fund for deserving and talented students. When
awards are made, Interlochen will notify you, with
respect to the recipients. The recipient will
also be asked to communicate with the donor. If
you would like to met the students, we will help
arrange a meeting on campus as well.

6. At present we are calling the lodge the "Jeffrey
E. Epstein Scholarship Lodge." If you would like
it named in another manner, please contact me with
the appropriate name or wording.

7. Under the charitable contribution act, you are
permitted use of the lodge for two weeks each
year, without any negative implications in respect
to the full tax deductibility of your gift.
Naturally, we would like you to visit the new
lodge this summer. So that we might begin to book
the lodge, I would ask you to consider what two
weeks you would like reserved for your use.
Perlman will be giving his concert on August 7,

1994. I have enclosed the appropriate tax code
for your file.
We have much to discuss as we move towards completion, but I thought this might be helpful.
Jeffrey, we really appreciate all that you do for
Interlochen. Somehow thank you seems inadequate for your
continued commitment and generosity. We are most grateful.
Warmest regards,
e eresiaent
Institutional Advancement
Enclosure
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000219
Interlochen Center for the Arts
February 22, 1994
Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
J. Epstein and Company, Inc.
The Villard House
457 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Dear Jeffrey:
0 Interlochen
On behalf of the Interlochen Board of Trustees, I have been asked
to convey our sincere and heartfelt appreciation for your very
generous crift of $200,000,for  a scholarship lodge. As you have
requested, this soon to be constructed lodge will be handicapped
accessible and designed to meet the ADA requirements. This is
the first such facility on our campus.
We are pleased to accept and acknowledge your significant
commitment to Interlochen and to the students, parents and guests
who visit our campus each year.
You have set the standard for others in creating an aesthetically
pleasing and accessible new scholarship lodge here among the
pines of northern Michigan.
Warmest regards,
James L. Tolley
Chair, Board of Trustees
P'•
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000222
Interlochen Center for the Arts
0 Interlochen
December 23, 1994
Ghislaine Maxwell
,7. FostrIp & rnmnanm Inc.
cite i1 lard Rbuse1
457 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Dear Ghislaine:
Enclosed is the envelope we recently found in cleaning the
Epstein Lodge. Apparently it lodged between the wall and
the dresser. It was not discovered until the unit was moved
for cleaning.
As we discussed, the final week of Camp is August 14 through
the 20th. I have reserved the lodge for Jeffrey's use. In
addition, he has one more week that he can reserve for
himself or guests he may wish to have use it. Attached is a
list of the dry goods that are in storage as part of
Jeffrey's personal inventory. Please advise if we are
missing any items you are aware of being sent here.
Please convey to Jeffrey how pleased we are to have such a
facility on our campus. In fact, the President Elect will
be staying in the lodge until his family's furniture
arrives. It is a remarkable place. We are grateful.
Best wishes for a wonderful holiday season.
Sincerely
Vice President
Institutional Advancement
Enclosures: Inventory listing
Lost envelope
Interlochen Arts Academy Interlochen Arts Camp Interlochen Public Radio 88.7 FM/100.9 FM
Address: Interlochen Center for the Arts P.O. Box 199 Interlochen. Michigan 49643-0199
Phone Fax
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000220
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
Date: 20-Dec-1994 01:57pm EST
From:
Dept: Operations
Tel No:
TO:
CC:
Subject: Epstein inventory linens
The following items of linens have been inventoried for the Epstein
Lodge.
1 ea. Duvet down bed pillow (white)
1 ea. Down comforter (white)
1 ea. Indiana Blanket
1 ea. King size blanket (white)
2 ea. Bean bag standard pillows
4 sets Navy Blue towels (includes hand towel and wash cloth each
set)
6 large white bathsheets
6 sets White towels (includes hand towel and wash cloth each set)
3 sets White King size sheets (includes flat and fitted sheet)
3 sets White pillow shams (2 shams each set)
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000221
Interlochen Center for the Arts
February 21, 1995

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
The Villard House
457 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Dear Jeffrey:
0 Interlochen
It is not difficult to say thank you for your recent gift of
125...D.U,s1r to express our gratitude for your continuing
generosity (for tax purposes, it should be noted that your
contribution was received by Interlochen Center for the Arts
in support of general operations. Interlochen has not
provided any goods or services to you in exchange for your
gift). But, it is difficult to adequately express our deep
sense of appreciation for all that you have done in
furthering the mission of Interlochen over the past four
years. In addition to your personal and significant annual
contributions, you have opened up and hosted several alumni
meetings and receptions (our New York alumni group is now
one of the strongest in the nation) . It all began with our
first meeting at the Villard House. Dr. Tuckerman's recent
endowed gift in your honor speaks to your support and
commitment to Interlochen.
Last year we built the Epstein Lodge, interlochen's first
scholarship lodge in many years. It is our premier guest
accommodation and the first handicapped accessible facility.
Most recently you gave our strong endorsement of
Interlochen to the family as the investigated the
Academy offerings for t eir daughter,
You have done much in the name of Interlochen. We thank
you. If I might borrow from my colleague Dr. Luby, you are
a mensch!
Best wishes for a successful 1995.
Since
Vice President
Institutional Advancement
Interlochen Am Academy Interlochen Arts Camp Interlochen Public Radio 88.7 FM/100.9 FM
Address: Interlochen Center for the Arts P.O. Box 199 Interlochen, Michigan 49643-0199
Phone Fax
CONFIDENTIAL INT 000223
Interlochen Center for the Arts
Interlochen
January 19, 1995

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
Epstein Foundation
457 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Dear Jeff:
On behalf of the students, faculty, and staff at the
Interlochen Center for the Arts, I want to thank you for
your generous contribution of $25,000.
4
As you know, the support dollars received each year
through the efforts of many individuals add up to a wealth
of opportunities for those young students who come to make
Interlochen their artistic home.
Your gift enables us to continue to provide quality
educational opportunities, enhance our tradition of
excellence, and assist in the development of tomorrow's
leaders.
You have made a difference. For that irreplaceable
gift, we thank you.
With warm regards,
Dean Boal Boal
President
arecat terns jertrisr÷sear i ssrf-
haerlochemAnsAardemy Interfochen,fraCump InteM2chenPutWeRaio88.7FW/MU9FW
Addremhorloc*enCmter ortheAra P.O. Bar 199 Inierfochen.Michigon49643.0199
Phone Fur
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000224
March 20, 1996
11 Interlochen Weill COUSIN, Ain Flush'.

Mr. Jeffrey E. Epstein
J. Epstein Foundation
The Villard House
4576 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Dear Jeffrey:
Thank you for the gift of $20,000 received on 3/18/96 designated for the Olympics Fund.
Your gift is the motivation or  at Interlochen, because it is the springboard
for the many things that are happening here.
As we've already shared with you, we are in great need of assistance this year, since the
World Youth Symphony Orchestra will be traveling to Atlanta to perform in Symphony Hall
on July 21 as a part of the opening weekend celebration in the Cultural Olympiad. Your gift
will help provide support for this project. THANK YOU!
Another piece of good news--Interlochen has been announced as one of the "10 Best Camps
in America" as published in the March/April edition of Family Life magazine. The Today
Show on NBC expects to air a piece on the 10 best camps, with emphasis on choosing the
correct one, what to consider, and what to expect. And, Interlochen will be included. So,
the tradition of nurturing young talent to its fullest potential goes on...
Again, thank you for your generosity in selecting Interlochen as the recipient of your
philanthropic endeavors.
Vice President
Institutional Advancement
For tax purposes it should be noted that your contribution received by Interlochen Center for
the Arts is in support of scholarships. Interlochen has not provided any goods or services for
your gift.
:vaccine:ten .Ins Atnaemv • interiociten Arts Camp • Interiochen Naha Raato,18.7 FM/100.9 F•M
Internam Center ..nr the Arts • P.O. Box 199 • Interlochen. Michigan 496434199
Anne: Internet: ionlinteriochen.k12.mus
IDENTIAL INT 000228
In t e r i t, t h ( r. (Mr: t e r f t, r t he /MS
0 Interlochen March 20, 1996

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
Epstein Foundation
457 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Dear Jeffrey:
Werll Como lei Ails testator:
It is with great pleasure that I acknowledge your
recent contribution to the Interlochen Annual Campaign.
Please accept my personal thanks for your gift of $20,000
designated for the Olympic Project.
While we are still struggling through snow and cold
days, summer is never far from our minds. This year, we
have added 2 new programs: we will now offer a creative
writing program and a chamber music program. However, our
big news is that the World Youth Symphony Orchestra will be
going to Atlanta to perform in the opening weekend of the
Olympics.
Again, Ed Downing has been working his magic to present
another record -setting Summer Festival Concert Series. I
hope you will be able to visit our campus and attend these
events.
Thank you again for including Interlochen in your
annual philanthropy. Your gift will go directly toward
helping talented and deserving students through our
scholarship program.
Since
Richard F. Odell
President
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000229
In t eriochen Cen t er for the A r t s

a) Interlochen WOO Cour fo, Atli fltiatiii
August 29, 1996
Mr. Jeffrey E. Epstein
J. Epstein Foundation
The Villard House
457 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Dear Jeffrey:
We gratefully accept and acknowledge your gitglj tafflaieceived 8/26/96. Your
gift allows students to explore their potential as musicians, artists, and actors.
Equipping students with the "Interlochen experience" provides self-discovery through
self-discipline and challenge.
As you well know, camp is an intense, emotional 8 weeks for students. But, it is
wonderful to listen as row after row of tiny practice rooms vibrate with the sounds of
instrumentalists warming up in preparation of the day's audition, performance, or
weekly challenge. It is our hope that as campers go home they will carry a little
piece of Interlochen back to their communities with them.
Jeffrey, let me give my personal and professional thanks for all you do here at-
Interlochen. Your caring and thoughtful input in preserving Interlochen's physical
environment is very much appreciated. The remaining amount of your gift will be
directed to the Annual Fund. Thank you.
Sincere)  Sincerel ,
Vice President
Institutional Advancement
For tax purposes, please note that this gift is a charitable contribution and no goods or
services were exchanged.
• :mion. -nen .Ir
• • nun 1/.,-noin 49#W3."!99
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000226
August 29, 1996

Mr. Jeffrey E. Epstein
J. Epstein Foundation
The Villard House
457 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Dear Jeffrey:
0 II mei-loc.:Ile' Woolf lulu Ur AM ilLithoi
On behalf of the students, faculty, and staff of the
Interlochen Center for the Arts, I would like to thank you
for your contribution oL$1a.,-04341. to our scholarship fund.
The generosity of you and fellow donors enables us to offer
artistic and academic opportunities to students from all
nations, backgrounds, and cultural heritage.
The final camper concert, "Les Preludes," marks the
conclusion of our 69th summer camp season. During the
summer, over 1,800 campers participated in 4 and 8-week
sessions with scholarship support totaling more than
$800,000. Over 500 events during the 1996 Summer Arts
Festival brought thousands of visitors to the campus. Just
a few of the outstanding student performances during August
include the high-schoolers' presentation of the operetta
"Princess Ida" and the intermediate students' presentation
of "Romeo and Juliet."
During the second weekend of August, concerto winners
are recognized for their achievements by performing solos
with the World Youth Symphony Orchestra. As you may have
heard, WYSO was an outstanding representation for
Interlochen at the Olympics through their highly -praised
performance in Atlanta's Symphony Hall on July 21.
Thank you for joining us on campus and experiencing the
magic of Interlochen first hand.
Sincerely, ' •
Richard F. Odell
President
P.S. For tax purposes, please note that this gift was
solely philanthropic. No goods or services were exchanged
in return for this gift.
ri nk aw e( r , se.; Av.' ,4,4d-InterInthot Arts Academy • lmeriorhen Arts Camp • Interlochen Public. Radio SS] PM/100.9
FM
interlochen Center for the Arts • P.O. Mn 199 • Interlchen, Michigan 49643.0199
INT 000230

J. EPSTEIN & COMPANY, INC. THE VILI.ARD HOUSE
NEW YORK. NEW YORK /0022
talTELEPHO,
TELEF
August 26. 1997
iiiler for The Art
Dear..
Please find a check for $50.000 enclosed for Interlochen. This summer was really fun
even though it was only a weekend.
Please use $5,000 of the $50,000 for the scholarship for
Again, thanks for your help.
Sinc y.
Jeffr Epstein
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000232
r f u r t h e .4 r I g
Interlochen C.111/ lei AM Elliot's,
September 18, 1997

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
457 Madison Avenue
New York, NY 10022-6809
Dear Jeffrey:
Thank you, you are very generous! It's difficult to express how pleased I was to fmd
a check for $50,000 in the Federal Express envelope from The Jesse Philips
Foundation.
Per your instructions, $45,000 will be used for operations and scholarship support--
$5,000 will be held in a reserve account for a  South Africa Sctolarship Fund ($3,990
will be used for Camp tuition and $1,010 for travel expense. With your permission, I
will also designate $5,000 for the Presidential Discretionary Fund (from the $45,000
operations monies), which will be used by the President for emergency needs or to
fund a project vital to Interlochen but not anticipated in the regular budget process.
It's difficult to get a sense of this place and see the accomplishments of the students in
a short time; but, I am pleased that you have made some time in your busy schedule.
Please know that I personally and professionally appreciate your generosity and all
that you do for a place that is special to those of us interested in the arts and young
people.
Have a great autumn!
ice President
Institutional Advancement
For tax purposes, please note that this gift is a charitable contribution and no goods or
services were exchanged.
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000234
11 Interlochen Ault : te tt In /tit Siltation
September 18, 1997

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
9 E. 71st Street
New York, NY 100214118
Dear Jeffrey:
I did not mention the student from South Africa, since tax deductible contributions
' to an individual. As I indicated, we have set aside $5,000 for
for the 1998 Camp year. She is aware of your generosity, as I have
spoken with her father. Enclosed is a letter confirming the fund and notification of
your gift.
You clearly have made one young lady extremely happy. She is a talented musician
and we look forward to her return next summer.
THANKS!
Vice President
Institutional Advancement
It ...rittritt, A . r: • Lit,' : Camp • inierlothen 1N.:0;it. Radio 8.¢i rri, IIK9F.11
••:t• P0. A r /99 • hte^h chen..11:rh:v7.0 9643.01rni
Ph, ri
HIGHLY CONFIDENTIAL INT 000235
EFTA00008481 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2002-03-11)
DATE  3 11  ,  2o2,5 CIOC- -NY- '15,-C-1-(S99 3/e- AIM-
CASE ID  5°P- NY -3°2-771
PHOTOGRAPHER_
LOCATION
f),,qtv
luD
ZO6 ns-1-149-1--i-3()
Linc:Ati;

╭────────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ DATE & / | / Abie,                   │
│                                      │
│ Q0C -NY- SISSUS99 = 3/E- MM— (08062. │
│ Beem 2oP- Ny Se TS 7                 │
│                                      │
│ PHOTOGRAPHER                         │
│                                      │
│ LOCATION M D                         │
│                                      │
│ 20d Conchttin Dario                  │
│                                      │
│ Windhoek VA                          │
╰──────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00040687 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2002-10-14)
invoice
EFTA00082601 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2002-10-14)
invoice
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Danny Hillis [tech] computer scientist, artificial intelligence researcher 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01317889 (Jmail)
 [tech] invoice, Danny Hillis
(date: 2002-11-04)
invoice
EFTA00218262 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2003-03-10)
invoice
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Les Wexner [business] CEO of L Brands (The Limited, Victoria's Secret, Abercrombie), gave Epstein a house + power of attorney [wiki] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00006378 (Jmail)
 [misc] message pad with Les Wexner's name
(date: 2003-03-14)
iii.,*,..
I
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR  •
M
OF
PHONE_
TELEPHONED • „Le pone GALL I
CAME WISES YOU' WILL GAM? AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE You RUSH  •
*Sop YOUR CALL SPECIAL, ATTENTION
IMPORTANT•MESAGc
K  R k in r* ,--drireHa l i  n t"
Pin  xv^:A. /.1.I in L i  TIME) (.1 lc: VA, :
. • ,
PHONE
AREA CODE' "WM JDOSNSIcill •
7ELEPH0HE0 ( ..PiEAsiSALI'
GAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN. .. WANTS TO SEE TOP RUSH •  ' • '. • .
FIETURNEP YOUROAM.
I
SPEOIAO.ATTElITION • • .• • 1 ,
MESSAGE j MESSAGE
SIGNED 1184
IMPORTANT NIESSAGE

• 'FOR . • '
Mr7 2 DATE . TI 0 1 1/ RM. t it.
M . c
-0;5 LY---r\--CLI OF 1.
A
PHONE • AREA CODE . NUMBER EXtENSION '

• TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL" . CAME 70 SEE YOU . WILL CALL AGAIN •
worrsTothE YOU 'RUSH  • .
RETURNED YOUR.CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION. •
Ail
• MESSAG
. .
. ,
'SIGNED • 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE'
km 1( 5 C e-g.1......,,...
PATE aliiii tOS TIME ) ,23 tt.=
M 71 nt,-) V. • . • • OF
PHONE  ; AREA Nsioti .
TELEPHONED : . o c pLEA$S.CALL . A
GAME TO SEE ;IOU WILL OALL AGAIN. 1
WANTS To SEEYOU RUSH •
:SEWSNES0 Y0SS ea. SPEGIALATTENtION •
MESSAGE
SIGNED n84
.1

╭──────────────────────────────── Page 2, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────╮
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                               │
│                                                                                 │
│ ronte Feta *                                                                    │
│                                                                                 │
│ way                                                                             │
│ >                                                                               │
│                                                                                 │
│ st aact                                                                         │
│                                                                                 │
│ rd                                                                              │
│                                                                                 │
│ b                                                                               │
│                                                                                 │
│ b                                                                               │
│                                                                                 │
│ ib                                                                              │
│                                                                                 │
│ bade                                                                            │
│                                                                                 │
│ badd                                                                            │
│                                                                                 │
│ @                                                                               │
│                                                                                 │
│ es                                                                              │
│                                                                                 │
│ |                                                                               │
│                                                                                 │
│ IIe                                                                             │
│                                                                                 │
│ DOT                                                                             │
│                                                                                 │
│ JOOG@e GE                                                                       │
│                                                                                 │
│ G@O@s.                                                                          │
│                                                                                 │
│ PHONE,                                                                          │
│                                                                                 │
│ pare ok Aid (Oy tie ALN                                                         │
│                                                                                 │
│ My                                                                              │
│                                                                                 │
│ oF                                                                              │
│                                                                                 │
│ ARERCOOE NONE SET                                                               │
│ ane L_JPCEASE CALL i TELEPHONED. B¢ [PLEASE caLl, ae                            │
│ [GAME TO'SEE YOU Wil GALL AGAIN CaNETO Se vOy | | MLLCALLAGAIN                  │
│                                                                                 │
│ Wants TOSezvou| [Rus [wats tose you | [russ                                     │
│                                                                                 │
│ RETUBNED YOUR GALL| | SPECIALATTENTION RETURNED YOUR CALL |_| SPECIAL ATTENTION │
│                                                                                 │
│ Messace.,                                                                       │
│                                                                                 │
│ MESSAGE                                                                         │
│                                                                                 │
│ SIGNED,                                                                         │
│                                                                                 │
│ SIGNED.                                                                         │
│                                                                                 │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                               │
│                                                                                 │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                               │
│                                                                                 │
│ FoR, rola C selen                                                               │
│ ers rare ere                                                                    │
│ pare ee DA sre 03/10 /0% poe 124 Hh                                             │
│ ot                                                                              │
│ M. ra , MON,                                                                    │
│ or L03 MOen os oF.                                                              │
│ wert — aaa ares rae a                                                           │
│ raenndhen PLEASE CALL, TElEpONED [ox [RENE CALL                                 │
│ [eawe'T0 68 YOU | [wu cALLAGAN cauie To seevoU |_| wmuL cALLAGAN                │
│ wants TO See vou | [RUSH WANTS TO SeEvOU | [pUSH                                │
│ RETURNED YOURCAL| ~~ | SPECIAL ATTENTION RETARD YOUR GL] [SPEOALATIENTON        │
│ F                                                                               │
│ wesinoem wessage                                                                │
│ sane, sione                                                                     │
│ i                                                                               │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00004231 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00218394 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2003-04-21)
invoice
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                    Mark Epstein [jee] brother of Jeffrey [hill] 
                                                                  Robert Goodman [jee] cousin of Jeffrey Epstein 
                                                               Harry Beller [employee] traded Epstein's accounts 
            Ira Zicherman [finance] former Bear Stearns exec, co-trustee of J. Epstein Foundation with Ghislaine 
   Celina Dubin [girls] daughter of Glenn & Eva Dubin, called Epstein 'unc', major beneficiary of Epstein's will 
 Eva Dubin aka Eva Andersson [girls] Epstein's ex-gf now married to Glenn Dubin, doctor at Mount Sinai [nyt/bbg] 
                                    Darren Indyke [lawyer] Epstein's lawyer and estate executor [bbc/yahoo/wiki] 
                                                     Paul Hoffman [lawyer] alternate executor of Epstein' estate 
                              Robert Gold [lawyer] helped Epstein track down money belonging to Spanish families 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01266298 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein death bequests of Jeffrey E. Epstein 2001 Trust amendment removing Jeffrey A. Schantz as trustee naming Ghislaine Maxwell, Ira 
Zicherman as trustees
(date: 2003-06-27)
THE JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 2001 TRUST ONE

I am the Grantor of THE JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 2001 TRUST ONE ("the trust").
Pursuant to Article FIFTEENTH of the trust, I have the power to amend the trust.
I hereby amend the trust as follows:

FIRST
I hereby remove JEFFREY A. SCHANTZ as a co-Trustee of
the trust and designate GHISLAINE MAXWELL and IRA ZICHERMAN as
successor co-Trustees in his place.

SECOND
I hereby delete Article TWELFTH of the trust and substitute in
its place the following new Article TWELFTH:
"TWELFTH
The Grantor makes the following provisions with respect to the
Trustees:

(a) The last acting Trustee is authorized to designate one or
more additional or successor Trustees by a written and acknowledged
instrument. Designations shall be in writing and may be revoked in writing
3167851
by the maker thereof at any time prior to the qualification of the person
designated.

(b) Any Trustee may resign by giving notice to take effect on
the date specified in said notice.
(c) A Trustee may resign or qualify only by a written
instrument mailed or delivered to the Grantor or a Trustee then acting.

(d) No Trustee acting hereunder shall be liable for any loss
or damage which may occur hereunder, unless due to willful default,
deliberate wrongdoing, or willful violation of an express provision hereof

(e) No Trustee at any time acting hereunder shall be required
to (i) give any bond, undertaking, or other security for the faithful
performance of his duties in any jurisdiction, or be liable for the acts or
omissions of any other Trustee, (ii) file periodic reports in or to any court or
(iii) give notice of appointment as Trustee to any court. Each Trustee acting
hereunder is specifically relieved from any and all of the duties which would
otherwise be placed upon him by Chapter 59 of Title 15 of the Virgin
Islands Code.

(f) Any reference herein to the Trustees shall include
survivors, successors and additional Trustees.
316785.1 2
SDNY_GM_C10007876

The Grantor authorizes the Trustees to (i) divide any trust into
separate trusts and (ii) combine separate trusts with substantially similar
provisions."

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned have executed this
agreement on the 27th day of June, 2003.
Jeffrey Epstein, Grantor
Jeffrey Epstein, Trustee
Ghislaine Maxwell, Trustee
Ira Zicherman, Trustee

Territory of the Virgin Islands
District of St Thomas St John

On the 27th day of June in the year 2003, before me, the
undersigned, personally eared JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, personally known
to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the
individual whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and
acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his capacity, and that by
his signature on the instrument, the individual or t person upon behalf of
which the individual acted, executed the instru
d4/
Notary Public
PAUL HOFFMAN 316785.1 3 NOTARY PUBLIC
COMMISSION NO. LNP011-00
COMMISSION WIRES JUNE 2,7 2004
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GJGM_00007877
0200

On the 12 day of August in the year 2003, before me, the
undersigned, personally appeared GHISLAINE MAXWELL, personally
known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the
individual whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and
acknowledged to me that she executed the same in her capacity, and that by
her signature on the instrument, the individual or the person upon behalf of
which the individual acted, executed the instrument.
HARRY I. BELLER
Notary Public. State of New York

No. 018E4853924
Qualified in Rockland County 0,- Not
Commission Expires Feb. 17. 20—P

On the 15 day of July in the year 2003, before me, the
undersigned, personally appeared IRA ZICHERMAN, personally known to
me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual
whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me
that he executed the same in his capacity, and that by his signature on the
instrument, the individual or the person upon behalf of which the individual
acted, executed the instrument.
a  .Th(44  a
Notary Public
ANNA N. VERO
NOTARY PUBUG, Strie 01 New 11:di

No. °IVES:0450
Ounned In Nom Cove A.,
Commission Expires May 14, 20
716785.1
CONFIbENTIAL GJ 000201

AMENDMENT
to
THE JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
2001 TRUST ONE

EF-Dk_00120551

THE JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 2001 TRUST ONE

TRUST AGREEMENT dated November 8, 2001, between JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, as Grantor, and JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN and JEFFREY A. SCHANTZ, as Trustees.

The Grantor hereby transfers to the Trustees the property described in
Schedule A annexed hereto, to be administered and disposed of as provided in this
Agreement.

FIRST
The Trustees shall retain such property, IN TRUST, for the following
purposes:

(a) To pay any part or all of the income and such sums from or any
part or all of the principal of the trust as the Trustees, in their discretion, from time to
time determine for any reason whatsoever to, for, or on behalf of the Grantor. Any
income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal.

(b) On the death of the Grantor, to dispose of the remaining income
and principal of this Trust, including any property received by this trust as a result of the
Grantor's death pursuant to his will or otherwise, as follows:

(a) Ten million dollars ($10,000,000) shall be distributed to the
Trustees of The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2001 Trust Two.

(b) Ten million dollars ($10,000,000) shall be distributed to the
Grantor's brother, MARK LAWRENCE EPSTEIN, if he is then living, or if not to his
issue who are then living.

(c) Ten million dollars ($10,000,000) shall be distributed to JEFFREY
A. SCHANTZ, if he is then living, or if not to his issue who are then living.

(d) The Grantor forgives the following debts:
(1) The indebtedness, if any, owed to the Grantor by his brother, MARK LAWRENCE EPSTEIN;

(2) The indebtedness, if any, owed to the Grantor by his cousin, ROBERT GOODMAN; and
(3) The indebtedness, if any, owed to the Grantor by his friend, ROBERT GOLD.

III

If the 1998 JEFFREY EPSTEIN INSURANCE TRUST does not pay the
sum of at least five million dollars ($5,000,000) on the Grantor's death to issue of the
Grantor's grandparents, as determined by the Grantor's mother, PAULA EPSTEIN and
the Grantor's brother, MARK LAWRENCE EPSTEIN or if they do not survive the
Grantor, by the Grantor's cousin, ROBERT GOODMAN, an amount equal to the
difference between five million dollars ($5,000,000) and the amount paid to such issue of
the Grantor's grandparents from the 1998 JEFFREY EPSTEIN INSURANCE TRUST,
shall be paid by the Trustees to such issue of the Grantor's grandparents who survive the
Grantor, including but not extending beyond the Grantor's second cousins, and in such
shares as shall be determined by the Grantor's cousin, ROBERT GOODMAN. If
ROBERT GOODMAN is the person determining the allocation of this sum, five hundred
thousand dollars ($500,000) shall be paid to him out of the total gift of five million
dollars ($5,000,000), and no further sums are to be allocated by him to himself, his
spouse or his issue.

(3) Upon the death of the beneficiary prior to her thirty-fifth
birthday, to pay the then remaining principal of The Celina Dubin Trust, if any, to her
issue then living, or if she has no such issue to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she is
then living, or if not to the then living issue of EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, or if none to
EPSTEIN INTERESTS; a New York not-for-profit trust.

(a) GHISLAINE MAXWELL shall designate, within thirty days of the
Trustees giving notice to her of the Grantor's residential properties, one of the Grantor's
residential properties as the EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN Property and such residential
property and the tangible personal property, including art, customarily used in connection
therewith shall be distributed by the Trustees to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she is
then living. If such designation has not been timely made by GHISLAINE MAXWELL.,
then the Grantor's Palm Beach residence and the tangible personal property, including
art, customarily used in connection therewith shall be distributed by the Trustees to EVA
ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she is then living. If the Palm Beach residence was not owned
by the Grantor at the time of his death, then EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she is then
living, shall select one of the Grantor's residential properties and such residential
property and the tangible personal property, including art, customarily used in connection
therewith shall be distributed by the Trustees to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN.

(b) The Trustees shall dispose of the balance of such property as
provided in paragraph (c) below if the spouse of the Grantor is then living, or as provided
in paragraph (d) below if there is no spouse of the Grantor then living but there are any
issue of the Grantor then living, or as provided in paragraph (e) below if there is no
spouse or any issue of the Grantor then living.

(c) Any property which is directed any time to be disposed of as
provided in this paragraph shall distributed to the Trustee, IN SEPARATE TRUST, for
the following purposes:

(1) To pay the income to the spouse of the Grantor at least quarter-annually.
(2) The spouse of the Grantor shall have the exclusive and
unrestricted right to use any residences which are part of this trust during her life,
including the right to occupy the property without charge as a personal residence or to
rent such property and receive the income.

(3) To pay to the spouse of the Grantor at any time or times
during the continuance of the trust such sums from or any part or all of the income and
principal as the Trustees may, in their discretion, determine to the advisable and annually
to add to principal any income not paid to the beneficiary.

(4) The Grantor intends that any part of the trust for the benefit
of his spouse with respect to which a QTIP election can be made qualify for the marital
deduction. Accordingly, no authorization, direction, or other provision that would
prevent property passing to the trust for the Grantor's spouse from so qualifying shall
apply to the trust.

(5) Upon the death of the Grantor's spouse, to pay the then
remaining principal of the trust as provided in paragraph (d) below if any issue of the
Grantor are then living, or if not, as provided in paragraph (e) below.

(d) My property which is directed at any time to be disposed of as
provided in this paragraph shall be divided into as many equal shares as there are children
W0172258-11
SDNY_GM_00007B133
of the Grantor who are then living and children of the Grantor who are not then living but
who have left issue then living. One such share shall be set apart for the benefit of each
child of the Grantor who is then living and one such share shall be set apart, collectively,
for the benefit of the then living issue of each deceased child of the Grantor. Each share
set apart collectively for the benefit of the then living issue of a deceased child of the
Grantor shall be further divided into as many equal shares as shall make one equal share
for the benefit of each then living child of such deceased child of the Grantor and one
share, collectively, for the benefit of the then living issue, if any, of any deceased child of
such deceased child of the Grantor. Each share so set apart shall be disposed of as
provided in article SECOND.

(e) Any property which is directed at any time to be disposed of as
provided in this paragraph shall be distributed to the Trustees, IN SEPARATE TRUST,
for the following purposes:

(1) To pay all the expenses of maintaining any residences,
boats and airplanes held in this trust out of the income of the trust and to pay the balance
of the income to GHISLAINE MAXWELL at least quarter-annually.

(2) To pay to GHISLAINE MAXWELL at any time or times
during her life such other sums from or any part or all of the principal of the trust as the
Trustees may, in their discretion, determine to be advisable.

(3) Upon GHISLAINE MAXWELL's death, or upon the death
of the Grantor, if GHISLAINE MAXWELL predeceases the Grantor:
ROI72255-1j

(A) If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN is then living, the
remaining trust assets shall be held by the Trustees, IN SEPARATE TRUST, for the
following purposes:

(i) To pay all the expenses of maintaining any
residences, boats and airplanes held in this trust out of the income of the trust and to pay
the balance of the income to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN at least quarter-annually.

(ii) To pay EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN at any
time or times during her life such other sums from or any part or all of the principal of the
trust as the Trustees may, in their discretion, determine to be advisable.
(iii) Upon EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN's death,
the remaining trust assets shall be disposed of as provided in subsection (4) below.

(B) If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN is not then living,
the remaining trust assets shall be disposed of as provided in subsection (4) below.

(4) Any property required to be disposed of as provided in this
subsection (4) shall be divided into as many equal shares as shall make one equal share
for each child of EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN who is then living, one equal share for
each child of MARK LAWRENCE EPSTEIN who is then living, one equal share (to be
divided into subshares) for the issue, collectively, of each child of EVA ANDERSSON
DUBIN who is not then living, but who shall have died leaving issue then living, and one
equal share (to be divided into subshares) for the issue, collectively, of each child of
MARK LAWRENCE EPSTEIN who is not then living, but who shall have died leaving
issue then living, and such shares and subshares shall be distributed to such persons,
except that any share or subshare of a person then under the age of thirty shall be retained
(00172258.11
SDNY_GM_00007B135
by the Trustees, IN SEPARATE TRUST, for the benefit of such person ("the
beneficiary") for the following purposes:

(A) To pay to the beneficiary at any time or times
during the continuance of the trust such sums from or any part or all of the income and
principal as the Trustees may, in their discretion, determine to be advisable and annually
to add to principal any income not paid to the beneficiary.

(B) To pay to the beneficiary upon attaining the age of
thirty years the then remaining principal, if any.

(C) Upon the death of the beneficiary prior to his
thirtieth birthday, to pay the then remaining principal, if any, to his issue then living, or if
he has no such issue to EPSTEIN INTERESTS.
SECOND
Any property directed to be set apart for the benefit of a living child of the
Grantor ("the beneficiary") or for the benefit of a living issue of any deceased child of the
Grantor ("the beneficiary") and disposed of as provided in this article shall be retained by
the Trustees, IN SEPARATE TRUST, during the life of the beneficiary or until the
earlier termination of the trust, for the following purposes:

(a) In the discretion of the Trustees, to pay any part or all of the
income to the child of the Grantor or issue of a deceased child of the Grantor and
annually to add to principal any income not so paid.

(b) To pay to the child of the Grantor or issue of a deceased child of
the Grantor at any time or times during the continuance of the trust such sums from or
any part or all of the principal of the trust as the Trustees may, in their discretion,
determine to be advisable.
(00172258-II

(c) Upon the death of the beneficiary, the then principal and
accumulated income of the trust for his or her benefit shall be held, IN FURTHER
TRUST, pursuant to the terms set forth in this article SECOND, for the benefit of the
beneficiary's issue then living, or if he or she has no such issue then living for the benefit
of the Grantor's issue then living, except that the share of any issue of the Grantor for
whose benefit a trust is then in existence pursuant to the provisions of this article shall
instead be added to the principal of such trust to be administered and disposed of by the
Trustees as if a part thereof from the inception of the trust. If the Grantor also has no
issue then living, the Trustees shall pay the balance thereof as provided in paragraph (e)
of article FIRST section V.
(d) Notwithstanding any provision in this trust agreement to the
contrary, each trust created hereunder, if not previously terminated, shall terminate on the
twenty-first anniversary of the death of the last survivor of EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN
and the children of EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, in being on the date of the Grantor's
death, and thereupon the principal shall be distributed to the beneficiary of such trust then
eligible to receive the income of the trust.
THIRD
With respect to the charitable dispositions made pursuant to article FIRST,
the Grantor directs that if EPSTEIN INTERESTS or any successor charity is not an
organization contributions to which are deductible for federal estate, gift and income tax
purposes (a "qualified charitable organization") at the time any property is to be paid to
it, or if EPSTEIN INTERESTS or such successor charity shall not then exist, the Grantor
authorizes the Trustees to establish a qualified charitable organization, with JEFFREY A.
100172258.II
SCHANTZ and JOSEPH PAGANO as the members, directors and trustees thereof, and
to instead pay such property to such organization.
FOURTH
If, pursuant to a mandatory distribution of principal, any minor becomes
entitled to any share of the principal of any trust created hereunder, the property
constituting such share shall be retained by the Trustees, IN SEPARATE TRUST, to pay
to such minor any part or all of the income, including income previously accumulated,
and the principal as the Trustees may, in their discretion, determine to be reasonably
necessary for the minor's support, maintenance, education, health or other benefit, or, in
the case of income, accumulate any part or all for his benefit. All income and principal
not previously paid as above authorized shall be paid to such minor upon his attaining the
age of twenty-one years, or in the event of and upon his prior death to his estate.
FIFTH
Any income or principal the Trustees are authorized in their discretion to
pay to a minor may, in the discretion of the Trustees, be paid for the benefit of such
minor to a parent or guardian of such minor, or to the custodian for such minor under the
Uniform Gift to Minors Act, or similar Act, of an appropriate state. The receipt of the
parent, guardian or custodian to whom any income or principal is paid shall be a full
discharge of the Trustees from liability with respect to such payment and from further
accountability therefor.
100172258-1]
CONFIdENTIAL GJ 000211
SIXTH
Wherever the Trustees are directed or authorized to pay income or
principal to any person, the Trustees shall be authorized in their discretion to apply
income or principal to or for the use of such person.
SEVENTH
In exercising any discretion the Trustees, or such of them as are authorized
to act, may, but shall not be required to, consider and accept as correct any statement
which they believe to be reliable made by any person, including a person interested in the
way in which the discretion is exercised. The Trustees, in exercising any discretionary
authority given to them under any provision of this agreement, shall not be required to
take into account any other resources of income or of principal available to the person to
whom a distribution is under consideration.
EIGHTH
The word "issue" as used in this agreement shall mean issue per stirpes.
The word "discretion" as used in this agreement shall mean "sole, exclusive, and
unrestricted discretion." The word "taxes" as used in this agreement shall include all
interest thereon and penalties with respect thereto. Unless the context otherwise requires,
the use of the masculine and feminine shall be interchangeable, and the use of the
singular and plural shall be interchangeable. The words "the Grantor's residential
properties" shall include all residences owned by the Grantor, whether directly or
indirectly, and whether owned in trust, corporate, corporate nominee, limited liability
company, partnership or any other form of ownership.
100172258•II
NINTH
All estate, succession, legacy, generation skipping transfer taxes and
inheritance taxes, federal, state, and other, which may be payable by reason of the
Grantor's death, whether in respect of property passing under this agreement or in respect
of property not passing under this agreement, shall be paid out of the property disposed of
pursuant to article FIRST section V paragraph (b).
TENTH
In extension and not in limitation of authority which the Trustees would
otherwise have pursuant to law or pursuant to other provisions of this agreement, the
Grantor directs that they have the following discretionary powers:

(a) To retain for as long a period of time as they may consider
advisable or proper any property of any kind which may at any time be in their hands.

(b) To sell at public or private sale or to exchange any property which
may at any time be in their hands, without application to court, on any terms which they
may consider advisable or proper, including terms involving an extension of credit for
any period of time and with or without security.

(c) To invest in or otherwise acquire any property, real or personal, of
any kind, without limitation, without being bound by any provision of law restricting
investments by trustees, including but not limited to common and preferred stocks,
domestic or foreign, interests in partnerships and limited liability companies, secured and
unsecured obligations, mutual and common funds, other securities, mortgages,
commodity futures and contracts, repurchase agreements, and interests and options in any
of the foregoing.
(00172258.11
property that is like or different from the property used to make any other distribution to
any other trustee, beneficiary or remainderman.

(k) To operate, repair, alter and improve any real property which they
may hold or in which they may hold an interest or a participation; to erect or demolish
buildings thereon; to enter into leases for such real property or any part thereof or any
interest or participation therein for any period of time; to mortgage such real property or
any part thereof or any interest or participation therein for any period of time; to grant
options with respect to such real property, mortgages and leases or any interest or
participation therein for any period of time; to perform, modify, waive provisions of,
extend, renew, terminate or otherwise act in respect of any such leases, mortgages or
options; to cause such real property or any interest or participation therein or any part
thereof and themselves to be insured against any and all risks; to retain an agent or agents
for any of the foregoing purposes; and to do or omit to do anything of any kind or nature
with respect to any such real property or any part thereof or any interest or option with
respect thereto and the management thereof which they may in their discretion consider
advisable, whether or not such act or omission is hereinabove specifically mentioned,
without being bound by any restrictions which might otherwise be applicable and without
court approval.

(I) To determine, in case of reasonable doubt on their part, whether
any property coming into their hands constitutes income or principal, and whether any
payment or expenditure made by them shall be charged to income or to principal.

(m) To retain any interest in, to invest in and become a member of, any
real estate partnership or joint venture; to comply with all the terms and provisions of
fUOI72258-II
CONFIE5ENTIAL GJ 000214
every real estate partnership or joint venture relating to any investment at any time held
by them; to succeed the Grantor as a member of any such partnership or joint venture,
and to vote, execute consents, exercise all rights and take such other action with respect
to any real estate partnership or joint venture as they, in their discretion, deem advisable.

(n) To become or continue to be an officer, director, or employee of
any corporation, the stock of which may be owned by the Grantor's estate or the trust
created hereunder and as such officer, director or employee to receive a salary, bonus, or
other compensation in reasonable amount for services rendered to said corporation.

(o) To delegate to any one of the Trustees any nondiscretionary power,
including but not limited to the power, singly or with others, to sign checks, withdrawal
slips, instructions for the receipt or delivery of securities or other property, and
instructions for the payment or receipt of money, and the power, singly or with others, to
have access to any safe deposit box or other place where property of any trust created
pursuant to this agreement is deposited.

(p) To transfer any property which they may at any time hold to any
jurisdiction which they deem advisable.
In addition to the foregoing discretionary powers, the Grantor directs that
in the administration of any trust created hereunder, except any trust created for the
benefit of the Grantor's spouse which would otherwise qualify for a marital deduction,
the Trustees shall have discretionary power to permit funds to remain uninvested, and to
retain for an unlimited period of time and to retain property which is not productive of
income.
CONFIDENTIAL 100172258-1i GJ 000215
If any power, authority or discretion granted to the Trustees would operate
to deprive the Grantor's estate in whole or in part of the marital or charitable deduction
afforded under federal or state law, the Grantor directs that such power, authority or
discretion shall not be applicable to any gift to the Grantor's spouse or to any trust
created for her benefit which would otherwise qualify for a marital deduction or to any
property which would otherwise qualify for a marital or charitable deduction and which
constitutes part or all of any such gift or of such trust.
The Trustees shall continue to have all the powers herein vested in them
until the final distribution of all property in their hands.
ELEVENTH

(a) No part of the income or principal of any trust hereunder may be
transferred, assigned, sold or otherwise alienated by any beneficiary, or become subject
to the debts of any beneficiary.

(b) The judgment of the Trustees as to the payment of income and
principal to any person shall be conclusive and shall not be subject to judicial review. It
is the Grantor's intention that the Trustees shall have unrestricted discretion to withhold
income and principal from any beneficiary and that no court shall be authorized to direct
an allowance from the income or principal of any trust to any beneficiary without the
consent of the Trustees.
TWELFTH
The Grantor makes the following provisions with respect to the Trustees:

(a) JEFFREY A. SCHANTZ is authorized to designate one or more
additional or successor Trustees and is further authorized to remove any Trustee acting
hereunder by a written and acknowledged instrument. Designations shall be in writing
(00172258-II
CONFICI NITIAL GJ 000216
and may be revoked in writing by the maker thereof at any time prior to the qualification
of the person designated.

(b) If JEFFREY A. SCHANTZ resigns, or at any time ceases to act as
Trustee, without having designated an additional or successor Trustee, the Grantor
appoints DARKEN INDYKE as Trustee in his place.

(c) Any Trustee may resign by giving notice to take effect on the date
specified in said notice.
(d) A Trustee may resign or qualify only by a written instrument
mailed or delivered to the Grantor or a Trustee then acting.

(e) No Trustee acting hereunder shall be liable for any loss or damage
which may occur hereunder, unless due to willful default, deliberate wrongdoing, or
willful violation of an express provision hereof.

(f) No Trustee at any time acting hereunder shall be required to (i)
give any bond, undertaking, or other security for the faithful performance of his duties in
any jurisdiction, or be liable for the acts or omissions of any other Trustee, (ii) file
periodic reports in or to any court or (iii) give notice of appointment as Trustee to any
court. Each Trustee acting hereunder is specifically relieved from any and all of the
duties which would otherwise be placed upon him by Chapter 59 of Title 15 of the Virgin
Islands Code.
(g) Any reference herein to the Trustees shall include survivors,
successors and additional Trustees.
The Grantor authorizes the Trustees to (i) divide any trust into separate
trusts and (ii) combine separate trusts with substantially similar provisions.
10017225E-11
CONFICitNITIAL GJ 000217
sone_cm_0000ze94
THIRTEENTH
The Grantor, or any other person, with the consent of the Trustees, shall
have the right to make additions to any trust hereunder by will or otherwise by
transferring to the Trustees additional real or personal property.
FOURTEENTH
The Trustees hereby accept the trust and agree to execute it to the best of
their ability.
FIFTEENTH
The Grantor retains the right at any time or times during his life to revoke,
in whole or in part, this agreement and the trust created hereunder and to receive the
entire income and principal.
The Grantor retains the right at any time or times during his life to amend
this agreement and the trust created hereunder.
The Grantor may revoke or amend this agreement and the trust created
hereunder by a written and acknowledged instrument. The right to revoke or amend the
trust shall be a personal right of the Grantor and may not be exercised on his behalf by
any guardian, conservator, committee or other such entity.
This Agreement and the trust created hereunder shall become irrevocable
and unamendable upon the Grantor's death.
SIXTEENTH
If any beneficiary under this trust shall in any way directly or indirectly (a)
contest or object to the probate of the Grantor's will or to the validity of any disposition
or provision of the Grantor's will or of this trust or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any
way directly or indirectly instrumental in the institution or prosecution of, any action,
(00172258-11
proceeding, contest, objection or claim for the purpose of setting aside or invalidating the
Grantor's will or this trust or any disposition therein or provision thereof, then the
Grantor directs that (a) any and all provisions in this trust for such beneficiary and his
issue in any degree shall be null and void and (b) the trust property shall be disposed of as
if such beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all failed to survive the Grantor.
SEVENTEENTH
This Agreement and the trust hereby created shall be construed and
governed by the laws of the United States Virgin Islands applicable to agreements made,
delivered and performed therein.
EIGHTEENTH
This Agreement and the trust created hereunder may be referred to as "The
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2001 Trust ONE."
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned have executed this agreement
as of the day and year first above written.
100172258-11
JEFFREY E. EP
JEFFREY
JEFFREY A. S Z, T tee
19
GJ 000219
SDNY_GM_00007896 CONFIDENTIAL EFTA_00 120568
SCFIEDULE A
CASH $100.00
10017223.11
CONFIDENTIAL C.1 000220
som 0.1000071.7
1317,1101205.59
STATE OF NEW YORK )
) ss.:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
On the 81h day of November in the year 2001, before me, the undersigned, personally
appeared JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis
of satisfactory evidence to be the individual whose name is subscribed to the within
instrument and acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his capacity, and that by
his signature on the instrument, the individual or the person upon behalf of which the
individual acted, executed the instrument.
Notary P
STATE OF NEW YORK )
) ss.:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
LAUREN J. KWINTNER Notary Public, State of New Writ No. 02KW6016688 °unfilled In New York County
Commission Expires November 30. 20 =.
On the gib day of November in the year 2001, before me, the undersigned, personally
appeared JEFFREY A. SCHANTZ, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis
of satisfactory evidence to be the individual whose name is subscribed to the within
instrument and acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his capacity, and that by
his signature on the instrument, the individual or the person upon behalf of which the
individual acted, executed the instrument.
100172258-I)
LAUREN J. KWINTNER
Notary Public, State of New York
No. 02KW6016688
°unfilled in New York County
Commission Expires November 30, 20 £2
EFTA00218870 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2003-11-24)
invoice
╔═════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Barry Diller [journalist] billionaire co-founder of Fox News 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00579398 (Jmail)
 [misc] 
(date: 2003-11-26)
From: "JE Taken by: lesley at 09:24 on 11/26/03"
Date: Sat, 01 Jan 4501 05:00:00 +0000
Barry Diller would like to take a hike on the island. Please organize (Jeffrey said he would
talk to you about this)
EFTA00002550 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2004-02-09)
SN
2S0850VL
its$01
trx-IliffiliC2,9
4
'
HP
MODEL:
D314688976
1111
II
PIO*SI
HP
P/N:
430:65-083
PRODutl
OF
SINGAPORE
CL,Z8976026CWSDK5 I''', flINIgAIINOWIIIIW~NINldllllilfl
+vsoc 1nos
zysiEzr
PART
NUMBER:
IISFBOS
6-035
.
+12
0.3
Ingemrrymittai
LOT
NUMBER:
*A-431
11920-6•
FIRMWARE
Hvoc
"IINNIININNIIINIIHNiIININplllll
.
SeSecsee0F2A2900
SERIAL
NUMBER:
a3m186JP2D•
5791468028
84 • •
•
IIdIIIIIII
P~I~VNdI~Ihpl~Nlllln
II'
GPN:
375863-
010
122422661
EFTA01258746 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2004-07-12)
invoice
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                            LSJ, LLC [epstein] Epstein company Little St. James 
                                                                                     Zorro Management [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                                                      Brahakmana Mellawa [employee] house staff 
                                                                                       David Rodgers [employee] Epstein's pilot 
                                                                                         Doug Schoettle [employee] construction 
                                                                                   Larry E. Morrison [employee] Epstein's pilot 
                                                                                    Lawrance Visoski [employee] Epstein's pilot 
 Miles Alexander [employee] former island property manager, Operations Manager Michaelhouse Balgowan KwaZulu-Natal South Africa 
                                                                  Richard Barnett [employee] logistics for Epstein's properties 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00577389 (Jmail)
 [misc] Jeffrey Epstein memo about reporting responsibilities
(date: 2004-07-26)
Memorandum

To: Rich Barnett, Miles Alexander, <REDACTED>, Lucien Mellawa, Doug Schoettle,
Dave Rodgers, Larry Morrison, Larry Visoski, <REDACTED>, <REDACTED>, Michelle
Campos
CC: Ghislaine Maxwell, Eric Gany
From: Jeffrey Epstein
Date: 7/6/2004
Re: Weekly Report
----------

In order to improve the weekly status reporting to me, the following personnel are
responsible and accountable for timely and accurate reporting in their areas:

• Rich Barnett - 71st Street
• Miles Alexander - LSJ<REDACTED> - Zorro
• Lucien Mellawa - Palm BeachDoug Schoettle - 71st Street Decorating, Construction all locations
• Dave Rodgers/Larry Morrison - Planes: 727 & GIIB

• Larry Visoski - Helicopter/Cars/Electronics
• <REDACTED> - LSJ Construction & Decorating
• <REDACTED> - Purchases made for JE

To refresh your memory, action dates are critical and I want pictures of all
completed projects. All purchase/approval requests must be reviewed by Eric Gany
prior to inclusion in your report. Michelle will print the report for my review. The
quality of your reporting and your ability to get projects accomplished on-time are
very important. I want clear, concise and accurate information on the weekly
reports, so make sure that you spend sufficient time entering and reviewing them.
CONFIDENTIAL 1
EFTA01310850 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill
(date: 2004-10-11)
phone bill
EFTA00039351 (Jmail)
 [government] Program Statement / Memo about BOP Pharmacy Program
(date: 2004-11-17)
Program Statement / Memo about BOP Pharmacy Program
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
              Brett Ratner [arts] director of "Melania", blacklisted from film industry for #MeToo reasons [motherjones] 
                                               Ted Forstmann [finance] private equity, founder of Forstmann Little & co. 
                                                      James C. Kennedy [journalist] media exec, chair of Cox Enterprises 
                             Alina Pușcău [modeling] Victoria's Secret model, dated Epstein, was engaged to Brett Ratner 
                                                                      Elite Models [modeling] well known modeling agency 
                                                                                            IMG Models [modeling] agency 
 Jean Luc Brunel [modeling] MC2 Model Management founder, #MeToo problems, died like Epstein but in a French jail [wiki] 
                                                        Karin Models [modeling] agency in Paris owned by Jean Luc Brunel 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01334058 (Jmail)
 [article] New York Post press snippets about Epstein's attempt to buy IMG Models as well as his relationships with Brett Ratner and Alina Pascau
(date: 2005-01-14)
Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 4
PROBED POL'S SON BLAMES PLOT
New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Jan 14, 2005. pg. 014
Abstract (Document Summary)
IS billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein making a bid for IMG Models? As we reported last summer, Epstein tried
to buy Elite Models when the bankrupt agency was auctioned off. In 2003, we reported that Epstein, who's been
described as "a connoisseur of beautiful women," was talking to Karin Models owner Jean-Luc Brunel about
doing a deal, but it went nowhere. Epstein has also met with Elite's Gerald Marie and 1 Management's Scott
Lipps. Now we hear Epstein has been having talks with fellow billionaire Teddy Forstmann, who paid $750
million for the IMG group a few months ago, about buying the company's modeling division, which reps the likes
of Gisele Bundchen, Kate Moss and Heidi Klum. Reps for IMG and Forstmann deny any such negotiations are
taking place. Epstein's rep did not return calls. Forstmann has been talking to top Hollywood talent agencies
about a possible merger.

PAUL Allen, 51, the bachelor Microsoft co-founder worth $20 billion (according to Forbes), rang in the New Year
with British blonde Kate Reardon, 36 (above), a former fashion director for Tatter magazine who now writes
about jewelry for the Times of London. The couple ushered in 2005 in St. Bans aboard Allen's 413- foot yacht,
"Octopus? equipped with two helicopters and a 60-foot submarine. There were scores of other guests but Allen
seemed mesmerized by Reardon, who had a similareffect on another billionaire, Sir Jimmy Goldsmith. Reardon
attended Goldsmith's funeral in 1997, along with his widow and his second wife. "Conveniently, Allen has a
house In London," said our source.

[TRUMAN CAPOTE], dead for over 20 years, is suddenly a hot property in Hollywood. The author of "Breakfast
at Tiffany's" and "In Cold Blood" is the subject of two new biopics - Warner Independent's "Every Word Is True,"
based on George Plimpton's 1997 oral history, and United Artists' "Capote," based on the landmark 1988 Gerald
Clarke biography. "Capote? due out this fall, stars Phillip Seymour Hoffman, who is talented but a bit burly to
play the "tiny terror." "Every Word" stars relatively unknown Toby Jones with an all-star supporting cast including
Alan Cumming, Anjelica Huston, Sandra Bullock (as "To Kill a Mockingbird" author Harper Lee), Ashley Judd,
Kevin Kline, Gwyneth Paltrow and Sigoumey Weaver. Hollywood columnist Jeffrey Wells reports that "Capote"
has the advantage of Hoffman in the staning role, while "Every Word," which just started filming, is said to have
a much better screenplay.
Full Text (1520 words)
(Copyright 2005, The New York Post. AU Rights Reserved)
THE loose-cannon son of a subpoenaed Bronx state senator claims Republicans are behind a federal probe of
the Bronx Democratic machine because they want to destroy Fernando Ferrer's campaign for mayor.
Efrain Gonzalez III, whose dad, State Sen. Efrain Gonzalez Jr., is one of nine Bronx politicians subpoenaed to
testify, wrote to the Riverdale Review: "The GOP controls the White House, the N.Y. State House and City Hall,
so if they want to attack the members of the Bronx Democratic Party, who is going to stop them?" Fifteen
subpoenas reportedly have been served, six of them to nonprofit organizations that employ relatives of the
elected officials. Young Gonzalez is president of the Latino Affirmation Council, which isn't listed in The Bronx or
Manhattan.

Gonzalez letter to the Riverdale paper said: "Wien my father and the 14 other members were issued
subpoenas, that alone was a message being sent by the GOP, that they will do anything in their power to keep
Mayor Bloomberg in power, because all those members being probed are working to support Ferrer in next
years mayoral race."
The elder Gonzalez's lawyer, "Don't Worry Murray" Richman, told PAGE SIX: "This is the over-excited
imagination of a young man. We do not support these allegations which were not authorized and don't represent
the views of the senator or myself."
In a strange e-mail posted on YonkersTribune.com last fall, after The Post broke the news of the investigation,
young Gonzalez said: "They couldn't find any weapons [of mass destruction], so they said instead of killing more
hftp://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/778885231.html7MAC=d480c38ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11130/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 2 of 4
camels, they are trying to get rid of all the donkeys over here instead . . . they forgot that a Puerto Rican donkey
knows how to climb high mountains, and are stronger than any elephant."
One federal subpoena went to the elder Gonzalez's longtime girlfriend, Lucia Sanchez. Investigators are also
looking into the $1 million in campaign funds Gonzalez has spent over the years in uncontested elections, with
much of the money going to a mystery campaign worker identified in filings as Ricardo Santiago.
"At issue is whether or not borough politicos funneled state and city funds into pet programs to then turn those
funds into salaries for friends and relatives," the Riverdale Review reports.

One of the non-profits being probed is the West Bronx Neighborhood Association, a favorite of Gonzalez's
housed in the same building as his office on the Grand Concourse.
Talent shortfall
THUMB-size thespians looking for a little work would do well to book a trip to London, where dwarf actors are in
short supply. Producers for the BBC's "Doctor Who" are searching for undersize actors to play little blue aliens in
the remake of the classic 1970s sci-fi show. But most of Britain's tiny talents have already been snapped up for
the new "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" movie or to play Gringotts Bank staff in the new "Harry Potter" film.
Executive producer Russell T. Davies complained to London's Daily Mirror: "It's very difficult to employ persons
of restricted growth when these other movies are filming at the same time."
We hear . . .

THAT it could get crowded for the Democrats in 2008. John Kerry has said he won't rule out running again, and
now comes word Tipper Gore is telling friends that Al is eyeing another race himself.
Words of gold
DONALD Trump will be paid a record-breaking $1 million an hour for Learning Annex appearances in three
cities this year. That's over $16,000 a minute. Since it was founded in 1980, the Learning Annex has featured
such celebrity teachers as Sarah Jessica Parker, Tony Robbins, Deepak Chopra and Henry Kissinger. The
previous highest fee was $28,000 - paid to Ron Wood nearly 20 years ago when he was a member of the
Rolling Stones. Trump's "How toSucceed in Real Estate" hits Los Angeles on May 1, Chicago on Oct. 23 and
New York on Nov. 6. Learning Annex president/founder Bill Zanker said, "Last time he taught for us, over 20,000
students came - and this year he's even bigger."
Mogul lusts for model shop
IS billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein making a bid for IMG Models? As we reported last summer, Epstein tried
to buy Elite Models when the bankrupt agency was auctioned off. In 2003, we reported that Epstein, who's been
described as "a connoisseur of beautiful women," was talking to Karin Models owner Jean-Luc Brunel about
doing a deal, but it went nowhere. Epstein has also met with Elite's Gerald Marie and 1 Managements Scott
Upps. Now we hear Epstein has been having talks with fellow billionaire Teddy Forstmann, who paid $750
million for the IMG group a few months ago, about buying the company's modeling division, which reps the likes
of Gisele Bundchen, Kate Moss and Heidi Klum. Reps for IMG and Forstmann deny any such negotiations are
taking place. Epstein's rep did not return calls. Forstmann has been talking to top Hollywood talent agencies
about a possible merger.
Aspen captive
SOCIALITE Denise Rich has fired her yoga instructor after his girlfriend told police that he locked her in a room
of Rich's Aspen mansion for three days over the Thanksgiving holiday. The unidentified woman alleged that
Jules Paxton attacked her first and then locked her in a room when she threatened to call the cops. A
spokesman for Rich said the ex-wife of pardoned tax cheat Marc Rich was traveling abroad during the incident,
but confirmed that Paxton was staying at herhome. "Mrs. Rich has decided to discontinue his services as her
yoga instructor," the rep said.

http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/778885231.61m1MAC=d4130c38ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11/30/2005
SONY GM 02764659
Archives: New York Post Page 3 of 4
Happy holiday
PAUL Allen, 51, the bachelor Microsoft co-founder worth $20 billion (according to Forbes), rang in the New Year
with British blonde Kate Reardon, 36 (above), a former fashion director for Taller magazine who now writes
about jewelry for the Times of London. The couple ushered in 2005 in St. Baits aboard Allen's 413- foot yacht,
"Octopus," equipped with two helicopters and a 60-foot submarine. There were scores of other guests but Allen
seemed mesmerized by Reardon, who had a similareffect on another billionaire, Sir Jimmy Goldsmith. Reardon
attended Goldsmith's funeral in 1997, along with his widow and his second wife. "Conveniently, Allen has a
house in London," said our source.
Super at 14
THE 44 contestants in the Ford Supermodel of the World contest learned evasive maneuvers at the after-party
at the Tunnel, where they met such studs as Jesse Palmer of the Giants, Trevor Ariza of the Knicks, Jamie
(Tom Rich") Johnson and Kelly ("The Apprentice") Perdew. New husband Fabian Basabe showed, too, without
bride Martina Borgomanero, and worked the red carpet. The winner, who also got a $250,000 modeling contract,
was Brazilian Camila Finn (above), all of 14. She might look even better when she grows up.
ITS THE TRUMAN CAPOTE SHOW
TRUMAN Capote, dead for over 20 years, is suddenly a hot property in Hollywood. The author of "Breakfast at
Tiffany's' and "In Cold Blood" is the subject of two new biopics - Warner Independent's "Every Word Is True,"
based on George Plimpton's 1997 oral history, and United Artists' "Capote," based on the landmark 1988 Gerald
Clarke biography. "Capote," due out this fall, stars Phillip Seymour Hoffman, who is talented but a bit burly to
play the "tiny terror." "Every Word" stars relatively unknown Toby Jones with an all-star supporting cast including
Alan Cumming, Anjelica Huston, Sandra Bullock (as "To Kill a Mockingbird" author Harper Lee), Ashley Judd,
Kevin Kline, Gwyneth Paltrow and Sigourney Weaver. Hollywood columnist Jeffrey Wells reports that "Capote"
has the advantage of Hoffman in the starring role, while "Every Word; which just started filming, is said to have
a much better screenplay.
Own show
COURTNEY Fine, a former aide to Mayor Bloomberg who left politics to become an actress, is showcasing "Me
2; a play she wrote about a woman jailed for breaking into the bar where she left her cell- phone. Among those
invited to last night's opening at the Producers Club 2: Victoria Gotti, Amy Fine Collins and Bloomberg's sister
Marjorie Tiven. The show closes after tomorrow's performance.
Never mind
GEORGE Pamham, the lawyer for Andrea Yates, is quick to cash in after winning her a new trial for the murder
of her fwe kids. Pamham, who will try to get Yates off using the insanity defense, is shopping a book, "States of
Mind," which will focus on his favorite tricks for defending female killers: postpartum depression, premenstrual
syndrome and post-traumatic stress. And he'll include similar cases: Clara Harris, who allegedly ran over her
unfaithful husband with herMercedes Benz, and Lisa Montgomery, who strangled Bobbie Jo Stinnett and then
surgically removed her fetus last month.
(Illustration]
-Kate Reardon; Camila Finn SINGER ALICIA KEYS KEEPS HER BOD BUFF BY JOGGING ON THE BEACH
IN BARBADOS YESTERDAY. [ZUMA PRESS] -ANY MAN WHO WINS THE HEART OF NICOLE KIDMAN,
PICTURED HERE IN A SHOOT FOR THE NEW ISSUE OF IN STYLE, IS A LUCKY DOG. HER LATEST
CRUSH, SHE TELLS THE MAG, IS PHILIP ROTH, 71, WHO WROTE THE NOVEL "THE HUMAN STAIN," THE
BASIS FOR HER 2003 FILM. [RUVEN AFANADOR FOR IN STYLE)
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/7711885231.html?MAC=d480c38ad964655614f3d466... 11/30t2005
Archives: New York Post Page 4 of 4
permission.

People: Gonzalez, Efrain Ill, Epstein, Jeffrey, Rich, Denise, Allen, Paul, Reardon, Kate
Section: Page Six
Text Word Count 1520
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pgarchiver.com/nypost/778885231.html?MAC=d480c38ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11(30/2005
MORE HEAT FOR BEL AIR BURGLAR
New York Post. New York, N.Y.: May 26, 2005. pg. 012
Companies: Miami Heat (NAICS: 711211, Sic:7941 )
Section: Page Six
Text Word Count 1671
Document URL:
NOW that his romance with Serena Williams has gone south, randy director Brett Ratner seems to be
settling down with his former gal pal. Model Alina Pascau has been flashing a massive canary-yellow
diamond engagement ring Ratner recently gave her, we're told. Pascau, a Romanian stunner, used to
date reclusive billionaire Jeffrey Epstein. Epstein, who handles Leslie Wexner's fortune, helped land
her a gig modeling
Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 4
MORE HEAT FOR BEL AIR BURGLAR
New York Poet. New York, N.Y.: May 26, 2005. pg. 012
Abstract (Document Summary)
NOW that his romance with Serena Williams has gone south, randy director Brett Ratner seems to be settling
down with his former gal pal. Model Alina Pascau has been flashing a massive canary-yellow diamond
engagement ring Ratner recently gave her, we're told. Pascau, a Romanian stunner, used to date reclusive
billionaire Jeffrey Epstein. Epstein, who handles Leslie Wexner's fortune, helped land her a gig modeling for
Wexner's Victoria's Secret brand, wehear, and paid for her to live in high style. After they broke up she and
Ratner dated for a while before his fling with Williams. "She's beautiful, but dumb as paint," one pal of Pascau
told us. "She never washes her hair and she always has a cellphone glued to her ear. Without Jeffrey she would
never have gotten the Victoria's Secret job." Pascau, who likes high-profile men, also used to bed down with
Formula I driver Eddie Irvine. Ratners rep did not retum calls.

YOU can't watch Arthur Chi'en on WCBS/Ch. 2 any more - the reporter was fired last week for uttering the "f
word" on-air - but you can buy a plethora of products with his face on it Cafepress.com is hawking a line of
Chi'en-branded mugs, T-shirts, buttons, tote bags, messenger bags, barbecue aprons, teddy bears and even a
"Chi'en Classic Thong." Some are emblazoned with the words, 'What the [bleep] is your problem, man? - the
question Chi'en, who thought he was off the air, yelled out to twohecklers. David Yee, who is selling the Chi'en
merchandise, said he was inspired by the popular T-shirts of revolutionary Che Guevara. "Chi'en sort of sounds
like Che," he explained. "People are buying i17 Meanwhile, Chi'en's friend Ian Gerard, the founder of Gen Art,
has circulated an e-mail calling the firing "ridiculous," and urging recipients to complain to various Viacom and
Channel 2 executives. Chi'en tells us he was "devastated" by his dismissal, and says he's currently looking for a
new job. "I've got bigger things to worry about than the shirts, basically," he said.
Full Text (1671 words)
(Copyright 2005, The New York Post. All Rights Reserved)
YOUNG Hollywood can rest easier now that police have arrested the man suspected of committing a string of
burglaries in the Beverly Hills and Bel Air area.

Darnell Riley, 28, was officially busted two months ago in connection with a burglary/robbery at "Girls Gone
Wild" gazillionaire Joe Francis' home in January 2004 - but he's also being investigated for break-ins at the
homes of Paris Hilton, baby oil heiress Casey Johnson, club promoter Tommy Alastra and other L.A. celebs.
A source said the crime ring used a gorgeous Elite model, still at large, to infiltrate the Hollywood party scene:
"She would befriend the men, get the security codes to their homes and then send Riley in."
Just before the 2004 Golden Globes, Francis returned to his Bel Air home as it was being robbed. The intruder
Francis recently identified as Riley held him at gunpoint and stole $300,000 in cash and valuables.
Sources added that Francis was "being blackmailed" Francis would only say, "I can confirm I was robbed at
gunpoint."
When Hilton's home was burgled in September of 2004, it looked eerily similar to the Francis break-in.
At the time, Hilton spokesman Elliot Mintz confirmed that a "very, very professional" gang swiped more than
$100,000 worth of jewelry, cash, video tapes and other items from the Hollywood Hills house Paris was renting
with her sister, Nicky.

After the burglary, more Hilton sex tapes mysteriously appeared, and damaging reports surfaced of a tape
where Hilton supposedly used the "n-word."
Insiders say Hilton paid dearly to make sure the tape was never found. A source said, "She was blackmailed.
She paid $20,000 a month to have that tape not released." Hilton told PAGE SIX via her rep, "Anyone who
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.corninypost/844991031.html?MAC•zbld211354a3eee5270f91258... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 2 of 4
blackmails should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law."
Hollywood insiders say Frankie Muniz and Wes Anderson may also have been burglarized, but their reps deny
it. Steve Coleman, a Los Angeles police officer who worked the case, told PAGE SIX: "Darnell Riley is in
custody and charged with burglary, robbery, and home invasion. This is an ongoing investigation."
Asked if the cops were looking into whether or not Riley had pulled the heists at the homes of Hilton, Johnson
and the others, Coleman said, "That's fair to say."
Wacky lackeys
AND you thought P. Diddy forcing Farnsworth Bentley to hold his umbrella was bad? Mariah Carey retains a
"petite Colombian woman" whose duties include "keeping Mariah's long skirts from touching the floor and
humping around a Louis Vuitton backpack filled with bottled water," reports Stuff magazine. Nefly keeps a
"personal jewelry jockey" to ensure the safekeeping of all his carat- encrusted bling. Ludacris has a minion
whose sole role is to make sure his boss' Gameboy is always loaded with fresh batteries. And rapper N.O.R.E.
has a hype man, Ching Bing, who has just one job: to stand onstage and swing around a towel.
We hear . . .

THAT Eva Longoria - milking her man-eating "Desperate Housewives" image to the max - has taped a spot for
Sirius Satellite Radio where she huskily pants: "Some women have to guess what a man wants, but I know what
a man really wants, something that will keep a smile on his face for a really long time - over 120 channels,
enough to satisfy any man" . . . THAT a visitor to Japan - where extreme modesty and close quarters prevail -
reports that new public toilets have an unusual feature, the Flush Noise button, so that you can conceal the
sound of actual bathroom functions with an artificial flushing noise.
Sightings
DALLAS Cowboys owner Jerry Jones and Washington Redskins owner Dan Snyder powwowing at Caf Milano .
. . BEN Affleck sitting front row at the Red Sox-Blue Jays game in Toronto. then getting mobbed for photos
before escaping through the Sox dugout . . . TRACY Morgan lifting up his shirt a la his character in "The Longest
Yard" to do a striptease for Burt Reynolds, Adam Sandler and Chris Rock at their movie premiere after-party at
Plus, the new lounge in Chelsea . . . HARRY Shearer dedicating his song, "82 Facelifts," to Barbara Walters
during a performance at the Cutting Room.
Romanian babe scores rock
NOW that his romance with Serena Williams has gone south, randy director Brett Ratner seems to be settling
down with his former gal pal. Model Aline Pascau has been flashing a massive canary-yellow diamond
engagement ring Ratner recently gave her, we're told. Pascau, a Romanian stunner, used to date reclusive
billionaire Jeffrey Epstein. Epstein, who handles Leslie Wexner's fortune, helped land her a gig modeling for
Wexner's Victoria's Secret brand, wehear, and paid for her to live in high style. After they broke up she and
Ratner dated for a while before his fling with Williams. "She's beautiful, but dumb as paint," one pal of Pascau
told us. "She never washes her hair and she always has a cellphone glued to her ear. Without Jeffrey she would
never have gotten the Victoria's Secret job." Pascau, who likes high-profile men, also used to bed down with
Formula I driver Eddie Irvine. Ratner's rep did not return calls.
Publicity-hungry
A ROMAN restaurateur is trying to exploit a near-miss with Bill Clinton, who recently canceled a dinner for 18 at
the fashionable Agata e Romeo eatery. Owner Romeo Caraccio is whining to the press that Clinton's people
ordered nearly $2,000 of special food and wines but never canceled, leaving him to take a loss. But his tale is
baloney, says Clinton rep Jim Kennedy. "An advance person made a reservation, canceled it, and compensated
the restaurant for' t," Kennedy said. He quipped, "A restaurant trying to get publicity out of a canceled
reservation? I'm shocked."
latp://pqasb.pqarchiver.conilnypost/844991031.html?MAC=b1d21f354a3eec5270f91258... 11/30/2005
SDNY_GM02764664
Archives: New York Post Page 3 of 4
Protein power
HOW did Shaquille O'Neal prepare for last night's Game 2 of the NBA Eastern Finals pitting his Miami Heat
against the Detroit Pistons? By devouring a 48-oz. porterhouse ($76) at South Beach's trendiest steakhouse,
Prime 112, the night before. The 7-foot-1, 320- lb. center joined fellow carnivores Jamie Foxx and TNT analyst
Charles Barkley, who as usual was trashing the Knicks. There's one menu item Shaq steers dear of - the $20
"Kobe Hot Dog."
Keepin' It real
IS life imitating art? Blond bombshell Katheryn WInnick, who was so good as Ivana Trump in Tuesday nights
"Trump Unauthorized" on ABC, must have liked her brush with real estate fame. The Poses Lois Weiss reports
the actress was seen canoodling with one of the city's top real estate investment-sale brokers, Douglas Harmon
of Eastdil, Tuesday aftemoon, before she got into a black Lincoln in front of 40 W. 57th St., the building where
Harmon is headquartered.
Paris burger ad not for kids?
PARIS Hilton is too hot for Washington. Lawmakers are working behind the scenes to get her sizzling TV ad for
eatery chain Carle Jr. - in which she writhes half-naked on a Bentley, cavorts with a garden hose and sucks her
finger - banished to late night. Sources say several influential pols have quietly told networks the commercial,
labeled "basically soft-core pom" by the Parents Television Council, isn't fit for children and shouldn't air before
10 p.m. The eye-popping ad, in which Paris looks like she's getting ready for her next Rick Solomon, is great
publicity for Carts Jr., which hired the hotel hottie to hawk its new Spicy Burger. The fast- food firm's official
response to those who are seeing red? "Get a life."
Sudden dash
DAMON Dash, with gorgeous wife Rachel Roy in tow, basked in the glory of receiving an AAFA American Image
Award from Kevin Bacon at the Grand Hyatt, but dashed out without offering a donation to the events charity
partner, the Alzheimer's Association. The hip-hop mogul was apparently the only honoree who didn't donate to
the event. Dash's publicist told us he did make a donation - but nobody connected to the event was aware of it.
Axed reporter branded
YOU can't watch Arthur Chi'en on WCBS/Ch. 2 any more - the reporter was fired last week for uttering the "f
word" on-air - but you can buy a plethora of products with his face on it. Cafepress.com is hawking a line of
Chi'en-branded mugs, T-shirts, buttons, tote bags, messenger bags, barbecue aprons, teddy bears and even a
"Chi'en Classic Thong." Some are emblazoned with the words, "What the [bleep] is your problem, man?" - the
question Chi'en, who thought he was off the air, yelled out to twohecklers. David Yee, who is selling the Chi'en
merchandise, said he was inspired by the popular T-shirts of revolutionary Che Guevara. "Chi'en sort of sounds
like Che," he explained. "People are buying it" Meanwhile, Chi'en's friend Ian Gerard, the founder of Gen Art,
has circulated an e-mail calling the firing "ridiculous," and urging recipients to complain to various Viacom and
Channel 2 executives. Chi'en tells us he was "devastated" by his dismissal, and says he's currently looking for a
new job. "I've got bigger things to worry about than the shirts, basically," he said.
Call to mouths
KELLY Osboume thinks her Hollywood Mends are too thin. "Sure they're beautiful in photographs. But when you
see them in person, they look hungry and miserable," she tells Teen Vogue. 'I hate to name names, so I'm not
going to, but there's one in particular I think of often. I saw her last summer and remember thinking, 'You're so
beautiful, you're at the most perfect weight' And then I ran into her in the winter and she literally looked near
death. I was like, 'What are you doing to yourself? You're 18 years old."' Interestingly, the magazine's June/July
issue features shrunken Lindsay Lohan on the cover.
[illustration]
-Shaquille O'Neal; Katheryn Winnick -IN A CONTROVERSIAL TV SPOT, PARIS HILTON REWARDS
http://pgasb.pgarchiver.com/nypost/844991031.html?MAC=b1d21 f354a3eec5270191258... 1150/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 4 of 4
HERSELF AFTER WASHING A BENTLEY IN HER SKIMPY SWIMSUIT. (Jeff Vespa /1.MreImage] -LATINA
LOVELY THALIA CHANNELS ELVIS PRESLEY AS SHE SHOOTS HER NEW VIDEO FOR "AMAR SIN SER
AMADA" IN BROOKLYN. [Sara Jaye Weiss]
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
Companies: Miami Heat (NAICS: 711211. Sic:7941 )
Section: Page Six
Text Word Count 1671
Document URL:
hitp://pqasb.pqarchivencomlnypost/844991031.html7MAC=b1d21f354a3ece5270f91258... 11/30/2005
EFTA00005569 (Jmail)
 [government] photo lineup featuring Epstein
(date: 2005-03-17)
photo lineup featuring Epstein
EFTA01682477 (Jmail)
 [misc] "Important Message" formatted notepad with notes about missed phone calls etc.
(date: 2005-04-01)
"Important Message" formatted notepad with notes about missed phone calls etc.
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                                                Hyperion Air [epstein] Epstein company 
                                           Barbro C. Ehnbom [europe] Swedish pharmaceuticals, SALSS, alleged recruiter of girls [rddt] 
                                               Peter Mandelson [europe] recently arrested former UK ambassador to the US [bylinetimes] 
                        Hapoalim [israel] largest bank in Israel, convicted of enabling tax evasion, fraud, and money laundering [doj] 
                                          Jes Staley [bank] former CEO of Barclays, allegations by multiple Epstein victims [guardian] 
                Scott Shay [bank] Bank Hapoalim, Hyperion Partners, future head of largest US crypto bank Signature Bank (SBNY) [cnbc] 
                  Signature Bank [bank] crypto friendly bank, 3rd biggest bank failure in US history, Ivanka Trump on the board [cnbc] 
                                                                                          Sam Belzberg [business] Canadian businessman 
                                                    Hyperion Partners [finance] Scott Shay, maybe related to Epstein co. Hyperion Air? 
                                                      Nestor 2000 [finance] Paris venture capital fund managed by 360 Capital Partners 
                                            Robin Hood Foundation [finance] anti-poverty non-profit donated to by hedge funders for PR 
 Steve Cohen [finance] NY Mets baseball team owner, SAC capital, beat the insider trading charges that his managers didn't [nyer/wiki] 
                                                             Emad Hanna [lawyer] project controller for Richard Kahn's HBRK Associates 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00257211 (Jmail)
 [crypto] call log shows then Hapoalim director/future crypto bank SBNY founder Scott Shay calling with investment ideas 4 weeks after Hapoalim's 
money laundering bust, also Steve Cohen and Barry Diller [haaretz]
(date: 2005-04-05)
Records Listed For: JEFFREY EPSTEIN from 04/05/2005 to 04/05/2005

From                         Message

reminders       1. Bernard Levy in town. 2. Call Barry Diller 3. Lunch w/Nelson
8:33AM          Peitz tomorrow. 4. Emad in at 7:30 and to leave at 3:00.

<REDACTED>      Via email: I now only need an apt for the night of May 11th. Is that ok?
8:40 AM

<REDACTED>      <REDACTED> called me last night and she was very sick over the
8:44AM          weekend and got IV drip, but she would love to try to see you not
.               this weekend, but perhaps the next. <REDACTED>

Emad            Re: Small Dump Truck for LSJ Miles would like to look Into
8:50AM          purchasing a used dump truck, he currently rents one at a rate of
.               $450 per day as needed and he is anticipating frequent usage
.               going forward.

<REDACTED>      Sent note to Barry Diller re "are you in town this Thursday?"
9:24AM

<REDACTED>      Re does she have any new frelnds you can meet-I was awa over
9:41 AM.        the weekend so I have not spoken to anyone new. But, <REDACTED>
.               will be around later today and I know she really wants to wor .
.               The others should be back around Thursday. Let me know about <REDACTED>

Scott Shay      From Hyperion Partners. I have an investment Idea for you. 516
9:45AM          745 6644 w, 646 408 7001 p

<REDACTED>      Are you coming back to NY today?
9:56AM

Scott Shay      Sorry about that, pls call me again!
10:04 AM

Steve Fox       Via email: I just heard from Mr Van Bower (pool guy); he's in
10:12AM.        Jamaica at the moment, and will be returning to Miami on
.               Thursday morning, so would be able to meet Jeffrey on Thursday,
.               Friday or Saturday this week. Alternatively, he could meet next
.               week on Tuesday or Wednesday. Are any of these dates suitable?

Harry           Mary Reith told me that by the end of this week they will hopefully
10:18AM         know the date and amount of the distribution from the sale of
.               FTC's interest in Nestor 2000. The goal is to make the distribution
.               at the end of April.(However,it is more likely that the distribution
.               would be in mid May)

Bruce Soll      I'm In NY today If you're here.
10:19AM

Barbro          I am going to Sweden on the 18th. I would love to meet with you
10:26AM         prior to that, eithe or the following week. Possibly you
.               would like to meet <REDACTED> as well. She is <REDACTED> sister. In
.               may, the New fem ist of the year will be here. Maybe
.               you would like to hold a BBB dinner on the 25th of May to welcome
.               her and see the other girls. I then leave June 1 for Sweden again.

http://domsrv01/foxhaven/wc.dll?Gmax—MsgDisplay

<REDACTED>      Sent note to Mary Rieth (and copied Jes Staley) re "Tad's Japanese
10:29AM         position is down $600,000. Nestor is a loss of $600,000. Paul Zemsky is
.                now a total loss of 1.3 million. Let's discuss this on our conference call.
.                PS: I had not received a report on Tad's position for the past 6 weeks
.                until yesterday"

<REDACTED>      I've made an appointment for Squishy today at 4:30pm at the PB
.               vet to get an ID chip put in him for traveling abroad. Is this OK?

Von Sanborn     returning your call
11:09 AM

Vanessa Modely  Pls call
11:10AM

Jes Staley      Pls call
11:14AM

Flavio          <REDACTED> Re is he coming to NY at all- I will be there t e eginning o June.
Briatore
11:17AM

G               I left Sheryl Gowdy detailed message on her cell phone.
11:19AM

<REDACTED>      Are you back?
11:27AM

Eric            Re the Letter of Credit: Darren had some problems with the letter
11:27 AM        of credit being too broad and has been working with Morgan to fix
.               the issues, he expects to be done today and then we send It to
.               Mellon bank for their acceptance. Mellon Is Karin Models bank
.               who will issue a line of credit secured by the LOC. I will push
.               to get this done.

<REDACTED>      Re payment of my loan -This Is what I can do for the moment and I
11:32 AM        hope it Is ok. YoU know Chrlstie's pays nothing. I can get you
.               $1000 next week, but then I won't be able to pay you again until
.               probably 2006 when I get another bonus. I just can't afford to take
.               any out of my paycheck. I hope that is 2006 I will be able to pay
.               you $2000 and so on. But basically, it Is going to take me a few
.               years to return the entire $6000.

Mary Rieth      Re our conf call tomorrow -I don't believe we ever came up with a
11:48 AM        time. I am available for you whenever you like, but if I had my
.               preference, it would be before 2:00 (I have a meeting at 2;00,
.               but I could reschedule). Just let me know.

G               Peter Jennings was diagnosed w/ lung cancer. It was announced today.
11:55 AM

<REDACTED>      Name reservations for Maxmira Films, Inc. in DE, CA, and NY all will
.               expire shortly. Would you like to extend the reservations for all or
.               any of these states?

reminder        Call Harvey Fuchs <REDACTED>
1:21PM

<REDACTED>      <REDACTED> for <REDACTED> re when will she be able to send you another
1:31 PM         check

htttp://donisrvOl/foxhaven/wc.dll?Crmax—Msgbisplay
4/5/2005

Darren          I need to speak to you. It's important.
1:56PM

Kary Mack       From CRedit Suisse First Boston. When could we set a meeting?
2:07PM          Mon 18th or Tues 19th was tentatively set. All the directors are
.               holding their schedules open.

Sam Belzberg    Please call
2:11PM

Kary Mack
2:22PM          I'll call you in the end of April to set up meeting.

Steve Cohen     Pls call.
2:23PM

<REDACTED>      I'm working In a basement and my phone Isn't working. Leave me a message.
2:32 PM

Sam Belzberg    It's a $300 million fund, Capri Capital Advisors of Chicago and they
2:37PM          originally had a partner, Charter Mack - part of related companies
.               and Eri Indemnity. THe letter will be out for 3 months. Pls call
.               if you have questions.

Meagan          re the Robin Hood Benefit-the dinner will be held this year on May
2:39PM          25th. Tables sell out quickly and we wanted to know if you Would
.               like to purchase a table again this year. We will be faxing over the
.               invitation (I will forward it on to you in PB)

<REDACTED>      OK on wheels up at noon tomorrow.
3:09PM

<REDACTED>      Did you mean <REDACTED>? I'll have her call you re 9pm tomorrow.
3:11PM

Dr. Moskowitz   I'll call you in five min.
3:16PM

Megan           OK - re you can't attend Robin Hood.
3:17PM

<REDACTED>      <REDACTED> is confirmed for 9pm tomorrow.
3:32 PM

<REDACTED>      Could I pick up some money? I need a hotel room for tonight. I"Il call
3:39PM          back since I don't have a phone.

<REDACTED>      Pls call
3:44 PM

Barbro          I will see you at 4:00 on Thursday. If you want to meet the <REDACTED>
3:44PM          <REDACTED> specifically  I think it would be best to meet with them
.               separately from me. Possibly if you are here Wed,
.               you could meet with them after their work? ION

<REDACTED>      pls call
3:54 PM

http://domsrv01/foxhaven/wc.dll?Gmax—MsgDisplay
4/5/2005

Dr. Bard        Just wanted to see If the girls had a good time at the (I told him
4:02PM          It was an amazing show).

Howard Dolch    Pls call.
4:44PM

<REDACTED>      Calling again to see if I can pick up money.
4:45PM

<REDACTED>      I called Howard Dolch and got his voicemail. i asked that he'll call
5:01PM          back tomorrow.

Howard Dolch    From Lansto Corp. I'm a realtor and I've dealt w/ Ghislaine at one point.
5:08PM          If you can't stay at 457, what do you want? I have a unique
.               52nd/Madison, huge ter place. 8,500 soft  or half. REsidential feel.
.               I will emai floor plan.

Callers         <REDACTED> Bruce Soll, Vanessa Modely, <REDACTED> Howard Dolch
5:10PM

<REDACTED>      I left Bill Karr a message on his cellular to call you.
5:15 PM         this time b/c I was told they are moving offices.

<REDACTED>      I left <REDACTED> a message to call Dennis Hersch,
5:23 PM         <REDACTED> regarding the wine.

Copyright (c) 2000-2004, Epstein Interests, Inc. All Rights Reserved
http://domsrv01/foxhaven/wc.dll?Gmax—MsgDisplay 4/5/2005
4/11/05
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
<REDACTED>

birt in babies

4/11/05
Down Weeks
12 <REDACTED> Saturday
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

Jeffrey E. Epstein

d lath Se IP' I re y -
WIMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR: Jeffrey

M. Mr. Mandelson
OF: 4/5/05
Pls call him back

4/11/05
If you want walk or bike please call her back

4/11/05
<REDACTED>
Pls call back

4/11/05
FOR: J.E.
M: Jean Luc
EFTA00217072 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2005-06-20)
invoice
EFTA00217080 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2005-06-27)
invoice
EFTA00007781 (Jmail)
 [money] paychecks signed by Epstein deposited at Colonial Bank
(date: 2005-08-12)
paychecks signed by Epstein deposited at Colonial Bank
╔══════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
        INS [government] US Immigration and Naturalization Service 
 Valar Ventures [tech] Peter Thiel affiliated fintech venture fund 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00007585 (Jmail)
 [misc] various fedex receipts and realtor notes
(date: 2005-09-20)
e6fr? )
CO•••••••00-• -
CiAlh. -I
Ghislaine Maxwell
Carpenter & Company, Inc.
Charles Square
20 Univentiry Rnad
Cambridge, MA 02138
617 864-2800
Facsimile 617 864-5990
September 19, 2005
Jeffrey Epstein
358 El Brillo
Palm Beach, FL 33480
Dear Jeffrey,
I previewed this house last week. Appropriate for you — off Brattle Street, short
walk to Harvard Square, very good condition which is remarkable for most Cambridge
properties.
If you wish to viewproperty between Tuesday the 201° and Saturday the 24i° call
Gail Roberts at and set up a time with her assistant.. I will return to
Boston on the 24 and can show property after that time. Any questions call me ate-
Sincerely
Real Estate Since 1898
72
100 1
FeC ti Cress US Airbill
1 Fm tie pa  mitt:QM/II Nicjieirsimank
0.1* I l l W ME: Trectira Has
CC
ell Sontere X Marra
I;
et
2
CARPENTER & CO canton
Adam 20 UNIVERSITY RD
A MB R I DGE city_C
Your Internal Billing Rotuma*
wee MA
cs5
zip O2138-5756
3 TO
Recipients
Nana 1Z CI  2pirt-okn. PIM
•
Comm
neraaeints -5 ,5 C6
VW seem SASS. Neat SeleleuSs
Aftell
laeleartele W el SF Pal ellbeelena
ow -1„;Nt 1 l __‘‘  h
L
2pHaa It ISO
❑ FEU FeetiMmite
Recipients Copy
Extern* Pintigli Santa
tdEx Nate Oarnita dKi iiiiitatanclard Dice.*
=moot 0 Fee Eqrssaa. aneestee — Isettentesesteleileestseueses
4b Express RIMS Salo, ANIcars sat PSIS
...seams
u Fear u me," 0 fzdiavol
5 Packaging
FNIE. ❑ FielExPar 0 Fed&
FeloSSOYANISIIIffire Bra
SYS
0 sec 0 Oder
Tuts
6 Special Handling Iodide Mb Sem laiseedl
,....%art`C Cinteam.
teasel eel PSIS Seeds
Se at Osa eyes r.rs.r
SOS SSE leelel= IRS
Ole la NMI I*
S o  ❑ Mt ..  U ernes's
esee MOSS te mamas twee kide 'See
7 Parlial breleto.“ Ma et bellIfielen Peettail lrO
kr%6ertr
8"
[ Recthent Mid POI El Declarant Deashiank
❑ IIM ADdElti =e
.reran eeebelen
0 CARO &WACO*
',bd.:doff :E. • - 4r11-1 1:: 4: r.
TOY P”ketlee 0 , ./,
.6% T,.";:e ttt-‘
Velar lobbleleasleueellideme we— Sul•ffit $n" :"°
if
area
0289717185 gur ""Thimen ierarerrenaWrienH laelf.Weedliee Soar
r•Ittitra tilateitelenlleallA
466
II t

╭─────────────────── Page 3, Image 1 ────────────────────╮
│ NO POUCH NEEDED.                                       │
│ ‘See back for peel and stick application instructions. │
│                                                        │
│ Recipient's Copy                                       │
│                                                        │
│ eck nee a                                              │
│ a Cerner Pieeoniome Cheemteae                          │
│ Fond ee. Cees                                          │
│ ; Pee a                                                │
│ O Rieter Ofszane O feteeereeor                         │
│                                                        │
│ cy CAMBRIDGE _                                         │
│                                                        │
│ 2. Your lateral Billing Reference                      │
│                                                        │
│ 7 Speci oning ————e ———                                │
│ Ea = |] Siteceeetow |) wettest ] mabstoctn,            │
│ fewer | 44 Eee ee pues                                 │
│ fe Sean Lsiiae Eo                                      │
│ tt                                                     │
│ coma es                                                │
│ a heey                                                 │
│                                                        │
│ ee)                                                    │
│ Csi                                                    │
│                                                        │
│ TadPony[_] Gnd                                         │
│                                                        │
│ wile                                                   │
│                                                        │
│ ne ee EE                                               │
│                                                        │
│ fe                                                     │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

IMPORTANT MESSAGE
OF
FHCNE/
MOBILE
trIFS'RAGE
PLEASE CALL
WILL CALL AGAIN
RUSH
SPECIAL ATTENTION

╭── Page 4, Image 1 ───╮
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE    │
│                      │
│ ror                  │
│                      │
│ DATE                 │
│                      │
│ TELEPHONED           │
│ GAME TO SEE YOU      │
│ WANTS TO SEE YOU     │
│                      │
│ | SPECIALATTENTION | │
│                      │
│ RETURNED YOUR CALL | │
╰──────────────────────╯

Jeffrey E. Epstein

╭─── Page 5, Image 1 ────╮
│ Wu ghoul 62 CK -       │
│ peck Sap Yhe (ater     │
│                        │
│ the                    │
│                        │
│ . iS O Ace             │
│ \g.0, Wowol of Whr tte │
│ eet y Ou inte =        │
│ Lone s op              │
│                        │
│ Jeffrey E. Epstein     │
╰────────────────────────╯

4/
Jeffrey E. Epstein
- 4 ckacio_a
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Jeffrey E. Epstein
CIJIPMorganChase
Fax cover sheet
Datem0
September 20. 2005
No. of pages Irci J asp mh; covet sheet
it you do not recefre a dear tremneeion, plea t  cep:
IN .
Telephone
Iron: to:
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Cempsnytaepartment. eirament
ASSET & WEALTH MANAGEMENT
Add..essitccaban. ACICIrtsisfogativni
522 FIITII AVENUE — 3 n  FLOOR
Fax nunber NEW YORK, NY 10036
Pax number
Telephone .
Mess ago:
efe. Mone:
Jeffrey: The deal is not going to work, Feel free to move your money.
I will call you tonight.
Dictated but not reed
CostkvitepiNaree: TIDY PareSid on is Pilencieel 1st ills is, at St ifilivitLeia ddififIC whiSh Ii ie sad= sec. VP ostai 
ilstrie6os INS
Corfettlal o,prMeer labor soWsirdiks nesse is not No trienosa r334det, rad am Per• 14903.1V21.3 1dtrit.td, ematririnon.
derlbvion or cot:ding dtddli fa I. liddh 0rtrtatidary0u Mk dived Ors Mn In era., Stele randy M eseclertrrtnetlian ne 
We:N.1M 3rd ehteredt
true aldind. Third TN.
TOWNHOUSE REPORT IN tiousE USE ONLY
PRINT DATE: 09/19/2005
AGENT: SPB
PAGE X 9
FIFTH & MADISON
9 EAST 67TH STREET 99383
Sale Price:
Cash Required:
Net Income:
Commission:
Occupancy Date:
$10,500,000.00
$0.00
$0.00
2.0%
05/17/2005
Date Lsted:
Last Updated:
Listing Agent:
Updating Agent
Listing Type:
03/2212002
05/17/2005
SIR SIR
SIR
Cob roke
Last Change:
Current Status:
Original Price:
Days On File:
Listing Source:
CLOSED
CLOSED
11,000,000.00
1277
R.O.L.E.X.
Block/La 1382 / 9 Zoning: 4D9 Building Class:
Building Size: 25 x 102 Lot Size: 25 x 102
Units:
Floors:
Total Soft:
11 Elevators:
5 Garden:
Roof Garden:
12,500.0Basement:
Penthouse:
Total
Residential.
Professional:
Commercial: 5
11
BREAKDOWN
Occupied Vacant
DESCRIPTION
25 limestone landmark. Extraordinary development opportunity, unique 1879, 5 sto ry townhouse, built 102 (approx), 
architectural accoutrements, 11-18 ceilings (a pprox), ph structure
on roof.
LAYOUT
GROUND FLOOR : 2 OFFICES/ONE APT.
WALL. 18 CEILS (FORMER LIBRARY). (N) DUPLEX 2 BR APT, BEAUTIFUL CEILINGS, MARBL E WBFP, MAHOGANY CELL. (S) 2ND-BEAUTIFUL
WALL TO WALL, LEADED GLASS WINDOWS, MAH OGANY CEILS. DUPLEX,
2BR, MARBLE FIREPLACE.
EXPENSES:
Real Estate Taxes:
Water 8 Sewer:
Heat:
Electric'
Insurance:
Superintendent:
Other.
TOTAL EXPENSES:
NET INCOME:
SALES PRICE:
$5,000.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$0.00
$5,000.00
$10,500,000.00
1 ,ot ctea tzr aNS
TtralPlus,4NT 0212004
TOWNHOUSE REPORT
co‘
ft,„, —rt. a te%
1\52caaPc- Lo+-C-- tf-A, Tahrerh, •. L.. I - N.-3-rah tot —40
TOWNHOUSE REPORT
EN NOUSE USE ONLY
PRINT DATE: 09/19/2005
AGENT: SPB
PAGE # 3 98282 64 & FIFTH
9 EAST 64TH STREET
REMARKS
SET-UP TO FOLLOW
EXPENSES:
Reel Estate Taxes: $51,039.00 Water 8 Sewer. $0.00 Heat: GEO $0.00 Electric: $0.00 Insurance: $0.00 Superintendent: 
$0.00 Other: $0.00
TOTAL EXPENSES', $0.00
NET INCOME, $0.00
SALES PRICE: $17,800,000.00
RealPlus4NT C 02/2004
TOWNHOUSE REPORT
GHISLAINE MAXWELL

╭──── Page 13, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

ve-Stzsortrao
urea:ANS I in(a.

╭─ Page 14, Image 1 ─╮
│ [ Pia              │
│                    │
│ un grOAMS 109,     │
╰────────────────────╯

t.
tap-111 .
f
I..4

• • e . • ,
.e •
•*. .0k
!rt .
ix
••
a• t.
•
3
• .
•••"" :kir, I
1.*
y.
I •
. •... r t• •

╭─ Page 15, Image 1 ─╮
│ Bo -1q -           │
│                    │
│ eee,               │
╰────────────────────╯
╔════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 358 El Brillo Way [epstein] Epstein's address in Palm Beach 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00007693 (Jmail)
 [misc] driving directions from Epstein's house to <REDACTED>, flight details for Sandy Berger
(inferred timestamp: 2005-09-20 09:31:00)
Driving Directions from 358 El Grillo Way, Palm Beach, FL to http://www 
mapquest.comidirectionsimain.adp?go—li&dor-mvitrrnm=
-:11AAPIWIEST.
Wa 358 El Brillo Way
Palm Beach, FL
33480-4730, US
Total Est. Time:
26 minutes
Maneuvers Distance
Total Time: 26 minutes Total Est. Distance:
&o_i2 siobau alo(8-s of 2
4
19/2005 1 I 29 A'
Driving Directions from 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, FL to http:,AvamapquesLcomMirectionsimain.adp?do=prt&monniets...
Start:
358 El Bulb Way
Palm Beach, FL 33480-4730, US
These dircctiors are Informational only. No represertabon Is made a- warranty given as to heir content, road ccnclkions 
or route t
expeditiousness. User assumes all risk of use. mapCuest and rts suppliers assume no resporsibtlity for any loss or delay
resulting ti
3 of 3 9/20/2005 11:39 AM
/ag Directions from 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, FL to http://www.maciquest.com/dircctionstmaitadp?do—pranayarnat2s...
Start:
358 El Brillo Way
Palm Beach, FL 33480.4730, US Ft Lauderdale, FL US
STe.r-
gargle*,
Oejf
Cerra
bland Rd
These directions are inforrnabonal only. No representation is made or warranty given as to their content, road 
conditions o- mute expeditiousness. User assumes all risk of use.
MapQuest and its suppliers assume no responsibility for any loss or delay resulting use.
3 of 3 9/20/2005 11:36 AM
niktiir3 AM
vsh' ailF let 221 fir:
:aansUiC ..te3 Is1oT ..22.3 islet
9..)nsiattl
eicauensF4
Ac
fp 3
Opr.r7 .(771e,
Jeffrey E. Epstein

(
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Orbitz: Flight Details "Ps:thesvotorbitzeom/SecureNiewmighttnformation2rehievePar...
Delta Air Lints 2067 Operated by DELTA AS SONG
Depart 6:30am New York. NY
morning New York John F Kennedy Intl (JFK)
(SJU)
Anencan Airlines 5140 Operated by AMFRICAN EAGLF/FXECUTIVE
D ar 11:22arn San Juan. Puerto Rico
rncznrng San Juan La Munoz Mann In (SJU)
SIT)
Total roles: 1679 nnieS
9/20/2005 9:31 Am
EFTA01719859 (Jmail)
 [misc] "Important Message" formatted notepad with notes about missed phone calls etc.
(date: 2005-10-03)
"Important Message" formatted notepad with notes about missed phone calls etc.
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                                                       Andrew Cuomo [democrat] governor of New York 
                                                                                         George J. Mitchell [democrat] former US senator from Maine 
                                                                  Radar Magazine [epstein] Epstein company bought by Epstein and Mortimer Zuckerman 
                             Robert Maxwell [epstein] father of Ghislaine, British / Russian / Israeli agent, financial fraudster, mysterious death 
                                                                                       Zorro Ranch [epstein] Epstein company property in New Mexico 
                                                                                                  Prince Andrew [europe] British royal family [cnn] 
                                                                  Sarah Ferguson aka Fergie [europe] former Duchess of York / wife of Prince Andrew 
                                                                                                  Henry Rosovsky [harvard] emeritus dean of Harvard 
                                                                              Martin Nowak [harvard] professor of mathematics and biology [crimson] 
                                                                                                Hernando de Soto [latin america] Peruvian economist 
                                                                   Rebekah Mercer [trump] daughter of algorithmic trading billionaire Robert Mercer 
                                  Dalton [academia] NYC private high school where Epstein got his first job after lying about his credentials [npr] 
                                                                                                 Casey Wasserman [arts] sports marketing and talent 
                                                                                                               Chris Tucker [arts] comedian / actor 
                                                              David Copperfield [arts] famous magician, investigated by FBI for rape and kidnapping 
                                                                                                        Donny Deutsch [arts] television personality 
                                                                           Frederic Fekkai [arts] famous hairdresser Epstein liked his girls to use 
                                                                                            Harvey Weinstein [arts] film producer convicted of rape 
                                                                                                        Julian Schnabel [arts] artist and filmmaker 
                                                                                                                          Kevin Spacey [arts] actor 
                                                                               Steve Tisch [arts] owner of the New York Giants football team [espn] 
                                                                       Woody Allen [arts] filmmaker who married his adopted daughter Soon-Yi Previn 
                                                                                   Robert Morosky [business] vice chairman of Les Wexner'S L Brands 
                                                                          Ronald Perelman [business] owner of Revlon, Trump donor, Israel supporter 
                                                                     Tom Pritzker [business] chairman of The Pritzker Organization and Hyatt Hotels 
                                                                                                John Gotti [crime] boss of the Gambino crime family 
                                                                                                Casey Johnson [employee] boat captain at the island 
                                           Lesley Groff [employee] assistant who managed Epstein's calendar, unindicted co-conspirator [dailybeast] 
                                   Bear Stearns [finance] Wall St. firm that first hired Epstein (and fired him for malfeasance), collapsed in 2008 
                                    James Cayne aka Jimmy Cayne [finance] CEO of Bear Stearns when it collapsed in 2008, executor of Epstein's will 
         Leon Black [finance] Apollo CEO, paid Epstein more than $150 million for "tax advice", serious allegations by multiple Epstein victims [x] 
                   Mortimer Zuckerman [finance] business partner of Epstein, publisher of New York Daily News and US News & World Report [prospect] 
                                             Steven Hoffenberg [finance] Epstein's partner in Towers Financial Ponzi scheme, did 18 years in prison 
                                                                                    Douglas Leese [friend] British arms dealer / defense contractor 
                                                                                                                     Robert Meister [friend] friend 
                                                                                                        Todd Meister [friend] son of Robert Meister 
                                                                                             Warren Eisenstein [friend] childhood friend of Epstein 
                                                                           Paula Heil Fisher [girls] Epstein's ex-girlfriend who works in opera now 
                                                                       Securities & Exchange Commission [government] US financial markets regulator 
                                         Conde Nast [journalist] magazine publisher behind Vanity Fair, New Yorker, Vogue, GQ, Wired, and mnay more 
                                                             David Pecker [journalist] lowlife publisher of National Enquirer and Weekly World News 
                                                     Gawker [journalist] independent news site killed by a Hulk Hogan lawsuit funded by Peter Thiel 
                        Graydon Carter [journalist] Vanity Fair editor when Vicky Ward's reporting on allegations against Epstein was spiked [nyer] 
                           Michael Wolff [journalist] author of "Fire and Fury: Inside the Trump White House", advised Epstein on PR strategy [alj] 
 Vicky Ward [journalist] 2003 reporting on Epstein's crimes was spiked by editors, 2011 reported on how wonderful Epstein + Ghislaine were [npr/vf] 
                                                                                              Alan Dershowitz [lawyer] Harvard Law School professor 
                                                                                              Howard Rubenstein [lawyer] Epstein's former spokesman 
                                                                                              ID Models [modeling] Paolo Zampolli's modeling agency 
     Paolo Zampolli [modeling] ID Models, introduced Trump & Melania, Elite Models deal w/Epstein, golden passports scandal in Dominica, current US 
                                                                                                                 Special Envoy [dominicanewsonline] 
                                                                                André Balazs [real estate] hotelier, CEO of André Balazs Properties 
                                                                      Jeanne M. Christensen [victim lawyer] Wigdor LLP lawyer in Leon Black lawsuit 
                                                                                                                        Deepak Chopra [woo] woo woo 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00260609 (Jmail)
 [article] New York Post collection of articles about Epstein
(date: 2005-11-02)
SIR. BIC
JelTral Epstein in \cn 1,,l, /44 Epstein\
nine-floor. 5I.IIIM-square-
roof loon house. Ile also °ails
a 7.5101-aera• ranch
in \en \lesicii, a house
in Palm Beach. and a
Caribbean
Lately, 3effrey Epstein's
high-flying style has been
drawing oohs and aahs: the
bachelor financier lives
in New Iork's largest
private reside *e, claims to
take only billionaires as
clients, and flies celebrities
including Bill Clinton and
Kevin Spacey on his Boeing

727. But pierce his air of mystery and the picture
changes. VICKY WARD
explores Epstein's investment
career, his ties to retail
magnate Leslie Wexner, and
his complicated past
1.
n Manhattan's
Upper Eaft Side. home to some of the
most expensive real estate on earth. exists
the crown jewel of the city's residential
town houses. With its I5-lbot-high oak door.
huge arched windows, and nine floors. it
sits on—or. rather. commands—the block
of 71st Street between Fifth and Madison
Avenues. Almost ludicrously out of pro-
portion with its four- and five-story neigh-
bors. it seems more like an institution than
a house. This is perhaps not surprising—
until 1989 it was the Birch Wathen private
school. Now it is said to be Manhattan's
largest private residence.
Inside, amid the flurry of mcnscnants
attired in sober black suits and pristine
white gloves, you feel you have stumbled
into someone's private Xanadu. This is
no mere rich person's home. but a high-
walled. eclectic. imperious fantasy that
seems to have no boundaries.
The. entrance hail is decorated not with
paintings but with row upon row of indi-
vidually framed eyeballs: these. the owner
tells people with relish. were imported from
England. where they were made for in-
jured soldiers. Next comes a marble foyer.
which does have a painting, in the man-
ner of Jean Dubuffet ... but the host coyly
refuses to tell visitors who painted it. In any
case. guests are like pygmies next to the
nearby twice-life-size sculpture of a naked
African warrior.
Despite its eccentricity the house is curi-
ously impersonal. the statement of someone
who wants to be known for the scale of his
possessions. Its occupant. financier Jeffrey
Epstein. 50. admits to friends that he likes it
when people think of him this way. A good-
looking man, resembling Ralph Lauren.
with thick gray-white hair and a weathered
face, he usually dresses in jeans. knit shirts.
and loafers. He tells people he bought the
house because he knew he "could never live
anywhere bigger." He thinks 51,000 square
feet is an appropriately large space for some-
one like himself, who deals mostly in large
concepts—especially large sums of money.
Guests are invited to lunch or dinner at
the town house—Epstein usually refers to the
former as "tea," since he likes to cat bite-
size morsels and drink copious quantities of
Earl Grey. (He does not touch alcohol or to-
bacco.) Tea is served in the "leather room:
so called because of the cordovan-colored
fabric on the walls. The chairs are covered
in a leopard print. and on the wall hangs a
huge. Oriental fantasy of a woman holding
an opium pipe and caressing a snarling li-
onskin. Under her gaze. plates of finger
sandwiches arc delivered to Epstein and
guests by the menservants in white gloves.
Upstairs. to the right of a spiral stair-
case, is the "office." an enormous gallery
spanning the width of the house. Strangely.
it holds no computer. Computers belong in
the "computer room" as smaller room at
the back of the house). Epstein has been
known to say. The office features a gilded
desk (which Epstein tells people belonged
to banker J. P Morgan). 13th-century black
lacquered Portuguese cabinets. and a nine-
foot ebony Steinway "D" grand. On the
desk, a paperback copy of the Marquis de
Sades The MAthrtitnes linue was re-
cently spotted. Covering the floor. Epstein
has explained. "is the largest Persian rug
you'll ever see in a private home—so big. it
must have come from a mosque." Amid
such splendor. much of which reflects the
work of the French decorator .Alberto Pin-

to. who has worked for Jacques Chime and
the royal families of Jordan and Saudi Ara-
bia. there is one particularly startling oddi-
ty: a stuffed black poodle. standing atop
the grand piano. 'No decorator would ever
tell you to do that:' Epstein brags to visi-
tors. "But I want people to think what it
means to stuff a dog:' People can't help
but feel it's Epstein's was of saying that he
always has the last word.
In addition to the town house. Epstein
lives in what is reputed to be the largest
private dwelling in New Mexico. on an 518
million. 7.500-acre ranch which he named
"Zorro." "It makes the town house look like
a shack." Epstein has said. He also owns
Little St. James. a 70-acre island in the
U.S. Virgin Islands. where the main house
is currently being renovated by Edward Tut-
tle. a designer of the Amanresorts. There is
also a 56.8 million house in Palm Beach,
Florida. and a fleet of aircraft: a Gulfstrcam

IV. a helicopter. and a Boeing -27. replete
with trading room. on which Epstein re-
cently flew President Clinton. actors Chris
Tucker and Kevin Spacey, supermarket
magnate Ron Burkle. Lew Wasserman's
grandson• Casey Wasserman. and a few oth-
ers. on a mission to explore the problems of
AIDS and economic development in Africa.
Epstein is charming. but he doesn't let
the charm slip into his eyes. They are steely
and calculating, giving some hint at the
steady whir of machinery running behind
them. "Let's play chess:' he said to me. af-
ter refusing to give an interview for this arti-
cle. "You be white. You get the first move."
It was an appropriate metaphor for a man
who seems to feel he can win no matter
what the advantage of the other side. His
advantage is that no one really seems to
know him or his history completely or what
his arsenal actually consists of. He has care-
fully engineered it so that he remains one
of the few truly baffling mysteries among
New York's moneyed world. People know
snippets. but few know the whole.
-He's wry enigmatiC says Rosa NIonck-
ton. the former C.E.O. of Tiffany & Co. in
the U.K. and a close friend since the early
1980s. 'You think you know him and then
you peel off another 'ring of the onion skin
and there's something else extraordinary
underneath. He never reveals his hand.. ..
He's a classic iceberg. What you see is not
what you get."
ven acquaintances sense a
curious dichotomy: les. he
lives like a "modern ma-
haraja." as Leah Kiernan.
one of his art dealers. puts

it. Yet he is fastidiously. a4
most obsessively private—he
lists himself in the phone book under a
pseudonym. He rarely attends society gath-
erings or weddings or funerals: he considers
eating in restaurants like "eating on the sub-
way"—i.e., something he'd never do. There
are many women in his life. mostly young.
but there is no one of them to whom he
has been able to commit. He describes his
most public companion of the last decade.
Ghislaine Maxwell. 41. the daughter of the
late. disgraced media baron Robert Max-
well. as simply his "best friend.- He says
she is not on his payroll, but she seems
to organize much of his life—recently she
was making telephone inquiries to find a
California-based yoga instructor for him.
(Epstein is still close to his two other long-
term girlfriends. Paula Heil Fisher. a for-
mer associate of his at the brokerage firm
Bear Stearns and now an opera producer.
and Eva Andersson Dubin. a doctor and
onetime model. He tells people that when
a relationship is over the girlfriend "moves
up. not down." to friendship status.)
Some of the businessmen who dine with
him at his home—they include newspaper
publisher Mon Zuckerman. banker Louis
Ranieri. Revlon chairman Ronald Perelman.
real-estate tycoon Leon Black. former Mi-
crosoft executive Nathan Myhnold. Tom
Pritzker (of Hyatt Hotels). and real-estate
I•• • vaN "V tA.t A ZCH 2003
personality Donald Trump —sometimes seem not all that clear as to what he ac-tually dots to earn his millions. 
Certainly. you won't find Epstein's transactions
writ-ten about on Bloomberg or talked about in the trading moms. "The trading desks don't seem to know him. It's unusual
for animals 'hat big not to leave any
footprints in the .now." says a high-level investment manager. Unlike such fund managers as George Soros and Stanley 
Druckenmiller, whose client lists and stock
maneuverings act as their calling cards. Epstein keeps all his deals and clients secret. bar one client: bil-lionaire 
Leslie Wexner, the respected chair-man of
Limited BraMis. Epstein insists that ver since he left Bear Stearns in 19131 he as managed money only for 
billionaires—ho depend on him for discretion. "I the
only person crazy enough, or arroeant cnough, or misplaced
enough. to make my limit a bil-lion dollars or more:' he tells peo-ple freely. According to him, the flat fees he 
receives from his clients. combined with his
skill at playing t e currency markets "with very I ge sums of money." have afforded .m the lifestyle he enjoys today. 
Why do billionaires choose him as their
trustee? Because the prob-lems of the mega-rich. he tells peo-ple, are different from yours and mine, and his unique 
philosophy is central to understanding
those problems: "very few people need any more money v ten they have a billion dollars. The key it. not to have it do 
harm more than any-thing else... . You
don't want to lose your money."
VMS
1 e has likened his job to
specifically, one who spe-
cializes
of an architect—more
in remodeling: "I always describe [a billion-
aire) as someone who
started out in a small home and as he became wealthier had add-ons. He added on another addition. he built a mom over 
the garage ... until you have a house that
is usually a mess.... It's a large house that has been put together over time *here no one could foretell the financial 
fu-tu; : and their accompanying needs."
le makes it sound as though his job co:abines the roles of real-estate agent. ac-countant. lawyer. money manager, 
trustee. and confidant. But, as with Jay
Gatsby, myths and rumor swirl around Epstein. Here are some of the hard facts about Epstein—ones that he doesn't mind 
people knowing: He—grew-4m- middle-class
in BR oklyn. His father worked for the city's
parks department. His
parents viewed educa-
tion as "the way out"
for him and his young-
er brother. Mark, now
working in real estate.
Jeffrey started to play
the piano—for which he
maintains a passion—at
live. and he went to
Brooklyn's Lafa!ette High School. He was good at mathematics. and in his early 20s he got a job teaching physics and 
math at Dalton. the elite Manhattan
pri-vate school. While there he began tutoring the son of Bear Stearns chairman Ace Greenberg and was friendly with a 
daugh-ter of Greenberg's. Soon he went to
Bear Stearns. where. under the mentorship of both Greenberg and current Bear Stearns C.E.O. James Caync. he did well 
enough to become a limited partner —a rung
be-neath full partner. He abruptly departed in 1981 because, he has said. he wanted to run his own business.
Thereafter the details recede into shad-ow. A few of the handful of current friends who have known him since the early 
1980s recall that he used to tell them he
was a
UNREAL iSTATE
From top: the "leather
morn" in Epstein's house. where "tea- is seSed
to euests: Epstein at his Zorro ranch in 1991 with his - hest friend." Ghislaine Maxwell:
Epstein in 1979.
"bounty hunter.- recov-
ering lost or stolen mon-ey for the government or for very rich people. He has a license to carry a firearm. For the 
last IS years. he's been running his
business, J. Epstein & Co.
Since Leslie Wexner appeared in his life—Epstein has said this was in 1986: others say it was in 1989, at the 
earliest—he has gradually. in a way that has not
generally made headlines. come to be, ac-cepted by the Establishment. He's a mem-ber of various commissions and 
councils: he is on the Trilateral Commission,
the Council on Foreign Relations. the New York Academy of Sciences, and the Insti-tute of International Education.
His current fan club extends to Cayne. Henry Rosovsky. the former dean of Har-vard's Faculty of Arts and Sciences. and
(4
."....'CM 2003
SPOILS OF SUCCESS
From top: Epstein's '0 -
acre island. Little St.
James. in the U.S. \irgin
Islands—he now calls
it Little St. Jeff: Epstein
with President Clinton in
Brunei. 2002: Leslie
Wexner with his future
wik. Abigail. at the 1990
C.F.D.A. Fashion Awards.
in New York. 1991.
Larn• Summers. Hananfs current presi-
dent. Harvard law professor Alan Dersho-
witz says. "I'm on my 20th book.. . . The
only person outside of my immediate family
that I send drafts to is Jeffrey." Real-estate
developer and philanthropisi Marshall Rose,
who has worked with Epstein on projects in
New Albany. Ohio. for Wexner. says. "He
digests and decodes the information very
rapidly, which is to me terrific because we
have shorter meetings."
Also on the list of admirers are former
senator George Mitchell and a gaggle of
distinguished scientists, most of whom
Epstein has helped fund in recent years.
The• include Nobel Prize winners Gerald
"Jeffrey [knows] when
he is winning.... He will
let youtchoose your
weapon; says Wexner.
Edelman and Nlurray Cell-
Mann. and mathematical
biologist Martin Nowak.
When these men describe
Epstein. they talk about
"energy" and "curiosity." as
well as a love for theoreti-
cal physics that they don't
ordinarily find in laymen.
Gell-Mann rather sweetly
mentions that "there arc al-
ways pretty ladies around"
when he goes to dinner elle:
Epstein, and he's under the impression that
Epstein's clients include the Queen of En-
gland. Both Nowak and Dershowitz were
thrilled to find themselves shaking the hand
of a man named "Andrew" in Epstein's
house. "Andrew" turned out to be Prince
Andrew. who subsequently arranged to sit
in the back of Dershowitz's law class.
Epstein gets annoyed when anyone sug-
gests that Wexner "made him." "I had real-
ly rich clients before." he has said. Yet he
does not deny that he and Wexner have a
special relationship. Epstein sees it as a
partnership of equals. "People have said it
like we have one brain between two of us:
each has a side.-
"I think we both possess the skill of
seeing patterns," says Wexner. "But Jef-
frey sees patterns in politics and finan-
cial markets, and I see patterns in lifestyle
and fashion trends. My skills arc not in in-
vestment strategy, and, as everyone who
knows Jeffrey knows, his are not in fash-
ion and design. We frequently discuss
world trends as each of us sees them."
y the time Epstein met
Wexner, the latter was a
retail legend who had
built a S3 billion em-
pire—one that now in-
cludes Victoria's Secret.
Express. and Bath &
Body Works—from $5.000 lent him by his
aunt. "Wexner saw in Jeffrey the type of
person who had the potential to real-
ize his [kffreysj dreams.- says some-
one who has worked closely with
both men. "He gave Jeffrey the ball.
and Jeffrey hit it out of the park."
Wane!: through a trust. bought
the town house in which Epstein
now lives for a reported S13.2
million in 1989. In 1993. Wex-
ner married Abigail Koppel.
a 31-year-old lawyer. and the
newlyweds relocated to Ohio:
in 1996. Epstein moved in-
to the town house. Public
documents suggest that the house
is still owned by the trust that bought it.
but Epstein has said that he now owns the
house.
Wexner trusts Epstein so completely
that he has assigned him the power of fidu-
ciary over all of his private trusts and foun-
dations. says a source close to Wexner. In

1992. Epstein even persuaded Wexner to
put him on the board of the Wexner Foun-
dation in place of Wexner's ailing mother.
Bella Wexner recovered and demanded to
be reinstated. Epstein has said they settled
by splitting the foundation in two.
Epstein does not care that he comes be-
tween family members. In fact, he sees it
as his job. He tells people. "I am there to
represent my client, and if my client needs
protecting—sometimes even from his own
family—then it's often better that people
hate me, not the client."
"You've probably heard I'm vicious in
my representation of my clients:' he tells
people proudly: Leah Kiernan describes his
haggling over art prices as something like
a scene out of the movie .11ad Mac Be-
yond Thundertiome. Even a former mentor
says he's seen "the dark side" of Epstein.
and a Bear Stearns source recalls a meet-
ing in which Epstein chewed out a team
making a presentation for Wexner as 9
t!
a
e:
h.
dr
304 VAN'13 m4tCH 2003
being so brutal as to be "irresponsible."
One reporter. in fan. received three threats
from Epstein while preparing a piece. They
were delivered in a jocular tone. but the
message was clear: There will be trouble
for your family if I don't like the article.
On the other hand. Epstein is clearly
very generous with friends. Joe Pagano. an
Aspen-based venture capitalist, who has
known Epstein since before his Bear Stearns
days. can't say enough nice things: "I have
a boy who's dyslexic. and Jeffrey's gotten
close to him over the years  Jeffrey got
him into music. He bought him his first
piano. And then as he got to school he had
difficulty . .. in studying . . . so Jeffrey got
him intereste4 in taking flying lessons."
Rosa Monckton recalls Epstein telling
her that her daughter. Domenica. who suf-
fen from Down syndrome. needed the sun.
and that Rosa should feel free to bring her
to his house in Palm Beach anytime.
Some friends remember that in the late
80s Epstein would offer to upgrade the air-
line tickets of good friends by affixing first-
class stickers: the only problem was that the
stickers turned out to be unofficial. Some-
times the technique worked. hut other times
it didn't. and the utmitting recipients found
themselves exiled to coach. (Epstein has
claimed that he paid for the upgrades. and
had no knowledge of the stickers.) Many of
those who benefited from Epstein's largesse
claim that his generosity comes with no
strings attached. "I never felt he wanted
anything from me in return." says one old
friend. who received a first-class upgrade.
E he is a familiar face to many of the Victo-
ria's Secret girls. One young woman reccIls
being summoned by Ghislaine Maxwell to
a concert at Epstein's town house. where
the women seemed to outnumber the men
by far. "These were not women you'd see
at Upper East Side dinners." the woman
recalls. "Many seemed foreign and dressed
a little bizarrely: This same guest also at-
tended a cocktail party thrown by Maxwell
that Prince Andrew attended, which was
tilled. she says. with young Russian mod-
els. "Some of the guests were horrified:
the woman says.
"He's reckless:says a former business
associate. "and he's gotten more so. Mon-
ey does that to you. He's breaking the oath
he made to himself—that he would never
do anything that would expose him in the
pstein is known about town
as a man who loves worn-
en—lots of them. mostly
young. Model types have
been heard saying they are
full of gratitude to Epstein
for thing them around. and
mAICti 200?
media. Right now, in the wake of the pub-
licity following his trip with Clinton, he
must he in a very• difficult place."
ccording to S.E.C. and
other legal documents un-
earthed by Vanity Fair,
Epstein may have good
reason to keep his past
cloaked in secrecy: his real
mentor. it might seem. was
not Leslie Wexner but Steven Jude Hoffen-
berg. 57. who. for a few months before the
S.E.C. sued to freeze his assets in 1993. was
trying to buy the New York Post. He is cur-
rently incarcerated in the Federal Medical
Center in Dewns. Massachusetts. serving a
20-war sentence for bilking investors out of
more than 5450 million in one of the largest
Ponzi schemes in American history.
When Epstein met Hoffenberg in Lon-
don in the 1980s. the latter was the char-
ismatic. audacious head of the Towers
Financial Corporation. a collection agency
that was supposed to buy debts that peo-
ple owed to hospitals. banks. and phone
companies. But HolTenberg began using
company funds to pay oil' earlier investors
and service a lavish lifestyle that included a
mansion on Long Island. homes on Man-
hattan's Sutton Place and in Florida. and a
fleet of cars and planes.
Hoffenbeng and Epstein had much in
common. Both were smart and obsessed
with making money. Both were from Brook-
lyn. According to HotTenbers. the two men
were introduced by Douglas Leese. a de-
fense contractor. Epstein has said they were
introduced by John Mitchell. the late attor-
ney general.
Epstein had been running International
Assets Group Inc. (I.A.G.). a consulting
company. out of his apartment in the Solo
building on East 66th Street in New York.
Though he has claimed that he managed
money for billionaires only. in a 1989 dep-
osition he testified that he spent NO per-
cent of his time helping people recover
stolen money from fraudulent brokers and
lawyers. He was also not above entering
into risky. tax-sheltered oil and gas deals
with much smaller investors. A lawsuit that
Michael Stroll. the former head of Wil-
liams Electronics Inc., filed against Epstein
shows that in 1982 I.A.G. received an in-
vestment from Stroll of 5150.000. which
Epstein put into oil. In 1984. Stroll asked
for his money back: four years later he had
received only S10.000. Stroll lost the suit.
after Epstein claimed in court, among oth-
er things. that the check for 510.000 was for
a horse he'd bought from Stroll. "My net
worth never exceeded lour and a half mil-
lion dollars." Stroll has said.
Hoffcnbcrg. says a close friend. "really
liked Jeffrey... . Jeffrey has a way of getting
under your skin. and he was under Hof-
fenberg's." Also appealing to HotTenberg
were Epstein's social connections: they in-
cluded oil mogul Cece Wang (father of the
designer Vera) and Mohan Murjani. whose
clothing company grew into Gloria Van-
derbilt Jeans. Epstein lived large even then.
One friend recalls that when he took Cana-
dian heiress Wendy Belzberg on a date he
hired a Rolls-Royce especially for the oc-
casion. (Epstein has claimed he owned it.)
In 1987, Hoffenberg. according to sources.
set Epstein up in the offices he still occu-
pies in the Villard House. on Madison Av-
enue. across a courtyard from the restaurant
Le Cirque. Holfenberg hired his new pro-
tege as a consultant at 525.000 a month.
and the relationship flourished. "They tray.
eled everywhere together—on Hoffenberg's
plane. all around the world. they were al-
ways together..' says a source. HotTenberg
has claimed that Epstein confided in him.
saying. for example. that he had left Bear
Stearns in 1981 after he was discovered ex-
ecuting "illegal operations:
Several of Epstein, Lar Stearns contem-
poraries recall that Epstein left the compa-
ny very suddenly. Wthin the company there
were rumors also that he was involved in a
technical infringement. and it was thought
that the executive committee asked that he
resign after his two supporters. Ace Green-
berg and Jimmy Cayne. were outnumbered.
Greenberg says he can't recall this: Cayne
denies it happened. and Epstein has de-
nied it as well. "Jeffrey Epstein left Bear
Stearns of his own volition." says Cayne.
"It was never suggested that he leave be
any member of management. and manage-
ment never looked into any improprieties
by him. Jeffrey said specifically. 'I don't
want to work for anybody else. I want to
work for myself.— Yet. this is not the story
that Epstein told to the S.E.C. in 1981 and
to lawyers in a 198,4 deposition involving a
civil business case in Philadelphia.
In 1981 the S.E.C.'s Jonathan Harris and
Robert Blackburn took Epstein's testimony
and that of other Bear Stearns employees in
part of what became a protracted case
about insider trading around a tender offer
placed on March II. 1981. by the Seagram
Company L..! for St. Joe Minerals Corp.
Ultimately several Italian and Swiss in-
vestors were found guilts. including Italian
financier Giuseppe Tome. who had used
his relationship with Seagram owner Edgar
Bronfman Sr. to obtain information about
the tender oiler.
After the tender offer was announced.
the S.E.C. began investigating trades in-
volving St. Joe at CON II•uf 0 0% Pthi. 1.11
VANI'v is
contains a parody of Affleck and Matt Da-
mon making Good Will Hunting II. Affleck
says to Damon, "What do I keep telling you?
You gotta do the safe picture, then you do
the art picture. Then sometimes you gotta
do the payback picture because your friend
says you owe him. Then sometimes you got-
ta go back to the well."
"Sometimes you do Reindeer Games."
Damon says derisively.
"That's just mean." Affleck whines.
But it's a pretty accurate description of
his career to date. "Ben takes these franchise
properties so he can go and experiment:'
says Harvey Weinstein.
"He believes in trying to stretch himself
and not/keep doing the same thing." ob-
serves Bruce Willis. who starred with Affleck
in Armageddon. "He's an awesome actor.
and I think hes going to do great things."
Several years ago. in a televised interview
on Inside the Actors Studio. Affleck said that
his goal was to make big commercial movies.
He has since revised his ambitions. "That's
an adolescent aspiration. in a way. I'd rather be in movies like Magnolia. which I
think is a towering achievement. I'll con-
tinue to act. but I won't act in a way that
requires me to hang my name out there
and do a lot of publicity. Fit do character
roles and focus on writing and directing. It
doesn't require the same kinds of sacri-
fice, in terms of quality of life and person-
al life. and it's a more holistic approach to
the process. It's become increasingly frus-
trating for me to have my role in the story-
telling process limited to one character. You
have to be respeztful and judicious about
your input when it's somebody else's project:'
Affleck has always impressed colleagues
with his voracious appetite for information
and skills. "He has made it a point to learn
everything he can about how the business
works—not just the craft of acting. but
from the producing standpoint, from the
studio standpoint.- says Jon Gordon. exec-
utive vice president of production at Mira-
max. "He knows how deals work. It's what
sets him apart. If he wanted to run a studio
at some point, he could. He's about as
sharp as they come.-
A ffleck is already juggling his acting with
nscreenwriting and such other commit-
ments as Project Greenlight. the contest he
and Damon started to help launch the ca-
reers of young filmmakers..Alfleck's friends
are certain he'll be directing soon. "There's
no question.' Weinstein says. "Both he and
Matt. I think they're going to rewrite the
rules. These guys can fix anything. There'll
be home runs in both instances:'
But there are other thoughts tickling the
back of Meek's mind as well. A passion-
ate liberal. he campaigned for Al Gore.
cares deeply about political issues. and is
extremely well informed. He entertains him-
self by writing imaginary political speeches
in his head. He would rather discuss mos
in Africa than his movie career.
When Lopez goes to Affleck's mother's
house for dinner. Weinstein reports. "J.Lo
told me that the conversation at the table is
always about politics—about government
initiatives. educational initiatives. what's go-
ing en in the day."
te
to  is Affleck Planning to rc tome the lib-
hralatChaensvdeneterrtabinR:t nalhedthReagioughlt Someday 1
a real nobility to public service. It wont,' be
running for Congress. at least: -I think them s
admits
fun to run on a platform I really ed in, without any of the kind of common. a% people make—without being beholden , the 
win-at-all-costs mentality."
And the invasion of privacy would he nothing new. "What are you going to say about me that hasn't already been said? I 
don't cheat, I don't drink, I don't do
drugs.
I live a clean life: Affleck says, his eves
twinkling.
"He's only 30 years old," says Jennifer
Todd, who co-produced Boiler Room. "Hc
still has an enormous amount of time to
do things."
Time, and drive. - I think he's incredibly
hungry." says Sean Bailey. who founded
the media and production company Live-
Planet with Affleck. Damon. and Chris
Moore. "I think the guy has very grand
aspirations. I don't think he's going to be
content with just being a movie star. He
knows he has the potential to do very big
things."
Such ambitions could 'ise derailed by any
number of miscalculations. including a pri-
vate life that generates too many sensational
headlines, but Affleck has a clear idea of
the ultimate goal. "On my deathbed. I have
to be one who looks back and feels I lived
a good and substantial and meaningful
lire: he says.
In the meantime. howc. zr. there's a wed-
ding to plan.
Jeffrey Epstein
Cil•TIVI ED FROM %tot , a, Bear Stearns
and other firms. Epstein resigned from Bear
Steams on March 1_. The S.E.C. was tipped
oil that Epstein had information on insider
trading at Bear Stearns. and it was therefore
obliged to question him. In his S.E.C. testi-
mony. tgven on April 1. 1981. Epstein claimed
that he had found "otTensive" the way Bear
Stearns management had handled a disci-
plinary action following its discovery that he
had committed a possible "Reg D" viola-
tion—evidently he had lent mom, to his clos-
est friend. I In the 1989 deposuton he said
that he'd lent approximately 5.20.000 to War-
ren Eisenstein. to buy stock.) Such an action
could have been considered improper. al-
though Epstein claimed he had not realized
this until afterward.
According to Epstein. Bear Stearns man-
agement had questioned him about the loan
around March 4. The questioners. Epstein
said, were Michael (Mickey) Tarnopol and
Alvin Einbender. In his 1989 deposition Ep-
stein recalled that the partner who had made
an "issue' of the matter was Marvin David-
son. On March 9. Epstein said. he had met
with Tarnopol and Einbender again. and the
two partners ;cid him that the executive com-
mittee had weighed the offense. together with
previous "carelessness" over expenses. and
he would be fined S2.500.
-There was discussion whether. in tact. I
had ever put in an airline ticket for some-
one else and not myself and I said that it
was possible. ... since my secretary han-
dles my expenses: Epstein told the S.E.C.
In his 1989 testimony he stated that the
"Reg D" incident had cost him a shot at
partnership that year.
What the S.E.C. seemed to be especially
interested in was whether there was a con-
nection between Epstein's leaving and the
alleged insider trading in St. Joe Minerals
by other people at Bear Stearns:
Q: Sir, arc you aware that certain rumors may
have been circulating around your firm in con-
nection with your reasons for leaving the firm?
A: I'm aware that there were mans rumors.
Q: What were the rumors you heard?
A: Nothing to do with St. Joe.
Q: Can you relate what you heard?
A: It was having to do with an illicit affair
with a secretary.
Q: Have you heard any other rumors suggest-
ing that you had made a presentation or com-
munication to the Executive Committee con-
cerning alleged improprieties by other mem-
bers or employees of Bear Stearns?
A: I. in fact, have heard that rumor. but it's been
from Mr. Harris in our conversation last week.
Q: Have you heard it from anyone else?
A: No.
A little later the interview focuses on
James Cayne:
Q: Did you ever hear while you were at Bear
Steams that Mr. Cayne may have trader or im
sider information in connection with 5< '
Minerals Corporation?
A: No.
Q: Did Mr. Clyne ever have any conversation
with you about St. Joe Minerals?
A: No.
Q: Did you happen to overhear any comma-
matC. :003
.relliev Epstein
(ions between Mr. Cayne and anyone else re-garding St. Joe Minerals?
A: No.
And still later in the questioning comes this
exchange:
Q: Have you had any type of business deal-ings with Mr. Cayne?
A: There's no relationship with Bear Stearns. Q: Pardon?
A: Other than Bear Stearns. no. Q: Have you been a participant in any type of business venture with Mr. Cayne?
A: No.
Q: Do you have any expectation of participat-ing ir\ jtany business venture with Mr. Cayne?
Q: Have you had any business participations with Mr. Theram?
A: No: nor do I anticipate any..
Q: Mr. Epstein. did anyone at Bear Stearns tell you in words or substance that you should not divulge anything about St.
Joe Minerals to the staff of the
Securities and Exchange Com-mission?
A: No.
Q: Has anyone indicated to you in any way. either directly or indirectly. :n words or sub-stance. that your compensation
for this past year or any future monies
coming to you front Bear Stearns will be contingent upon your not divulging ithrmation to the Securities and Exchange 
Commission?
A: No.
Despite the circumstances of Epstein's
leaving. Bear Stearns agreed to pay him his
annual bonus--which he anticipated as !..e.
ing approximately S100.000.
The. S.E.C. never brought any charges
against anyone at Bear Stearns for insider
trading in St. Joe. but its questioning seems
to indicate that it was skeptical of Epstein's
answers. Some sources have wondered
why, if he was such a big producer at Bear Stearns. he would have given it up over a
mere 52.500 tine.
Certainly the years after Epstein left the
firm were not obviously prosperous ones.
His luck didn't seem to change until he met
HotTenberg.
nrte of Epstein's first assignments for lief-
tenberg was to mastermind doomed bids
to take over Pan American %Sethi Airways in 1987 and Emery Air Freight Corp. in 1988.
Hoffenberg claimed in a 1993 hearing before a grand jury in Illinois that Epstein came up with the :dea of financing 
these bids through
Towers's acquisition of two ailing Illinois
insurance companies. Associated Life and
United Fire. "He was hired by us to work on the securities side of the insurance companies and Towers Financial, 
supposedly to make a profit for us and for the
companies." Hoffen-berg reportedly told the grand jury. He also alleged that Epstein o.as the "technician: a -
caning the schemes. although. having no
broker's license. he had to rely on others to
make the trades. Much of Hoffenberg's sub-
sequent testimony in his criminal case has
proven to be false. and Epstein has claimed
he was merely asked how the bids could be
accomplished and has said he had nothing
to do with the financing of them. Yct Rich-
ard Allen. the former treasurer of United
Fire. recalls seeing Epstein two or three
times at the company. He and another ex-
ecutive say they had direct dealing with Ep-
stein over the finances. And in his deposition
of 1989. Epstein stated that he was the one
who executed "all" Hoffenberg's instructions
to buy and sell the stock. He called it "mak-
ing the orders." He could not recall whether
he had chosen the brokers used.
To win approval from the Illinois insur-
ance regulators for Towers's acquisition of
the companies. HotTenberg promised to in-
ject S3 million of new capital into them. In
fact. in his grand-jury testimony Hoffenberg
claimed that he. his chief operating officer.
Mitchell Brater. and Epstein came up with a
scheme to steal S3 million of the insurance
companies' bonds to buy Pan Am and Em-
en stock. "Jeffrey Epstein and Mitch Bracer
arranged the various brokerage accounts for
the bonds to be placed with in New York.
and I think one in Chicago. Rodman & Ren-
shaw." Ho0enberg reportedly said. Then.
said Reifenberg. while making it appear as
though they were investing the bonds in
much safer financial instruments. they used
them as collateral to buy the stock. "Ep-
stein was the person in charge of the trans-
actions. and Mitchell Brater was assisting
hint with it in coordination on behalf of the
insurance companies money." HotTenberg
claimed at the time.
At one point. according to Hoffenberg. a
broker forged the documents necessary for a
51.8 million check to be written on insurance-
company funds. The check was used to buy
more stock in the takeover targets. Mean-
while. in order to throw the insurance regula-
tors off. the 51.8 million was rerorted as being
safely invested in a money-market account.
United Fire's former chief financial officer
Daniel Payton confirms part of Reifenberg.;
account. He says he recalls making one or
two telephone calls to Epstein (at Holten-
berg's direction) about the missing bonds.
"He said, 'Oh. yeah. they still exist.' But we
found out later that he had sold those assets
... leveraged them .. . (and! used some mar-
gin account to take some positions in ...
Emery and Pan Am.- says Payton.
Epstein's extraordinary creativity was. ac-
cording to HotTenberg. responsibk for the
purchase by the insurance companies of a 5500.000 bond, with no money down. "Ep-
stein created a great scheme to purchase a
$500900 treasury bond that would not be
shown las] margined or collateralized.-
he reportedly told the grand jury. "It looked
like it was free and clear but it actually
wasn't.- he said.
Epstein has denied he ever had any deal-
ings with anyone from the insurance com-
panies. But Richard Allen says he recalls
talking to Epstein at Hoffenberg's direction
and telling him it was urgent they retrieve
the missing bonds for a state examination.
According to Allen. Epstein said, ?We'll get
them back." He had "kind of a flippant atti-
tude." says Allen. "They never came back."
Epstein. according to HotTenberg. also
came up with a scheme to manipulate
the price of Emery Freight stock in an at-
tempt to minimize the losses that occurred
when HotTenberis bid went wrong and the
share price began to kill. This was alleged to
have involved multiple clients' accounts con-
trolled by Epstein.
Eventually. in 1991. insurance regulators in
Illinois sued Hotrenberg. He settled the case.
and Epstein, who was only a paid consul-
tant. was never deposed or accused of any
wrongdoing. Barry Gross. the attorney who
was handling the suit for the regulators. says
of Epstein. - He was very elusive.... It was
hard to really track him down. There were a
substantial number of checks for significant
dollars that were paid to him. I remem-
ber.... He was this character we never got a
handle on. .Again we presumed that he was
involved with the Pan Am and Emen run
that HotTenberg made. but we never got a
chance to depose him."
"Front the government's discovery in the
main sentencing against HotTenberg it wculd
seem the government was perhaps a bit lazy.-
says David Lewis. who represented Mitchell
Brater. "They went for what they knew they
could get . . and that was the fraudulent
promissory notes (i.e.. the much larger and
unrelated part of Hoffenberg's fraud. based
in New York Statej... . What they couldn't
get. they didn't bother with:'
Another lawyer involved in the criminal
prosecution of HotTenberg says. "In a crim-
inal investigation like that, when there is a
guilty plea. to be quick and dirty about it.
discovery is always incomplete. .. . They
don't have to line up witnesses: they don't
have to learn every fact that might come out
on cross-examination."
Epstein was involved with HotTenberg in
other questionable transactions. Finan-
cial records show that in 1988 Epstein in-
vested $1.6 million in Riddell Sports Inc.. a
company that manufactures football helmets.
Among his co-investors were the theater
mogul Robert Nederlander and attorney
Leonard Toboroff. A source close to this
transaction claims that Epstein told Neder-
lander and ToborotT that he had raised his
share of the money from a Swiss banker. 341
&I/RCN 22)3
■
0
whose identity they could not be allowed to
Just as Nederlander and Toboroff were know. But Hoffenberg has claimed the mon- growing wan' of Epstein. he became in-ey
came from him, and Towers's financial
creasiney involved with Leslie Warier. whom statements for that year show a loan to Ep- he had met through insurance 
executive stein of $400.000. (Epstein has
said he Robert Meister and his late wife. Epstein has can't remember the details and has dis- told people that he met 
Wexner in 1986 in pored the accuracy of
the Towers financial Palm Beach. and that he won his confidence reports.) by persuading him not to invest in the stock 
Around the same time, Nederlander and
market. just as the 1987 crash was approach-Toboroff let Epstein come in with them on a ing. His story has subsequently 
changed. scheme to make money out of
Pennwalt. a When asked if Wexner knew about his con-Pennsylvania chemical company. The plan nection to Hoffenberg. 
Epstein said that he was to group together
with two other parties began working for Wexner in 1989. and that to take a substantial declared position in the "it was
certainly not the same time.-stock.
According to a source. Epstein was Wherever and whenever it was that Ep-supposed tk help Nederlander and Toboroff stein 
and Wexner actually met. there was raise
515 million. lie seemed to fail to find an immediate and strong personal chem-other investors. say those familiar with 
the istry. Wexner says he thinks Epstein
is "very deal. (Epstein has said he was merely an in- smart with a combination of excellent judg-vestor.) He invested SI
million, which he ment and unusually
high standards. Also. told his co-investors was his own money. he is always a most loyal friend." But in his 1989 
deposi-
tion he said that he put
in only 5300.000 of his
own money:. Where did
the rest come from? Hof-
fenberg has said it came
from him. in a loan that
Nederlander and ToborotT
didn't know about.
Two things happened
that alarmed Nederlander
and ToborotT. Afier the
group signaled a possible
takeover. the Pennwalt
management threatened to
sue the would-be r.talers.
Epstein was reluctant ini-
tially to give a deposition
about his share of the
money. telling Toboroff
there were "reasons" he OFFICE SPACE didn't want to. Then. after the opportunity The "office" in Epstein's house. It has
no for new investors was closed.
co-investors computers. but it does have a desk that recall Epstein announcing that he'd found Epstein tells people once
belonged to banker one at last: Dick
Snyde: then C.E.O. of J. P. Monran. and "the largest Persian rue the publisher Simon a Scauster who want- you'll ever 
see in a private home.-ed to put up
approximately 5500.000. (Nei-
ther Epstein nor Snyder can now recall Sources say Epstein proved that he could the investment. Yet in the 1989 
deposition be useful to Wexner as well. with
"fresh" Epstein said that he had recruited Sny- ideas about investments. "Wexner had a cou-der. whom he had met 
socially, into the plc of bad investments, and
Jeffrey cleaned deal.) those up right away? says a former associ-According to a source. ToborolT and Ne- ate of 
Epstein's. derlandcr told Epstein that Snyder
was too Beihre he signed on with Wexner. Epstein Lae. but. without their realizing it. Hoffen- had several meetings with
Harold Levin. then het,: has claimed.
Snyder wrote a check to head of Wexner Investments. in which he HotTenberg and bought out some of his in- enunciated 
ideas about currencies that Levin vestment.
But then Snyder wanted out. found incomprehensible. "In fact." says some-"Nederlander started to get these irate one who
used to work very closely with
%Vex-calls from [Snyder.) who wasn't part of the ner. "almost everyone at the Limited won-deal, saying he was owed all 
(his money." dered who Epstein was: he
literally came says someone close to the deal. Toboroff out of nowhere." a: Nederlander were baffled. "Everyone was 
my:stitied as to what his ::::ually. a
source close to HotTenberg appeal was says Robert Morosky. a former .t'enberg paid Snyder off vice-chairman of the 
Limned.
Much of Epstein's work is related to clean-
ing up. tightening budgets. and effickn-
des. One person who worked for Wexner and
who saw a contract drawn up between the
two men says Epstein is involved in "every-
thing. not just a little here. a little there.
Everything!" In addition, he says. "Wexner
likes having a hatchet man.. .. Whenever
there is dirty work to be done he'd stick Jef-
frey on it.. .. He has a reputation for being
ruthless but he gets the job done."
Epstein has evidently been asked to fire
personal-staff members when needed. "He
was that mysterious person that eyrryone was
scared to death of: says a former employee.
Meanwhile. he is also less than popular
with some people outside Wexner's company
with whom he now deals. "He 'inserted'
himself into the construction process of Les-
lie Wexner's yacht.. . . That resulted in liti-
gation down the road between Mr. Wexner
and the shipyard that
eventually built the ves-
wl." says Lars Forsberg.
a law ar whose firm at
Dickerson and

F. v. ..as hired to deal
with hitt:anon stemming
from the construction
of Wexner's Limitless—
at 315 feet. one of the
largest private yachts in
the world. EY idently. Ep-
stein stalled on paying
Dickers::: and Reily for
wc-k "Ifs probably
once r :‘%:ce in my le-
gal career that I've had
to sue a client for txtyment
of services that he'd re-
quested and wed per-
formed .. . without issue
on the performance." says Forsberg. In
the end the matter was settled. but Ep-
stein claims he now has no recollection
of it.
The incident is ore of a number of disputes
Epstein has become embroiled in. Some arc
thr sums so tiny as to be baffling: for instance.
Epstein sued investment adviser Herbert
Glass. who sad him the Palm Beach house in
1990. for S 13.444—Epstein claimed this was
owed him for furnishings removed Ili MAI:
In 1998 the C.S. Attorney's Office sued
Epstein for illegally: subletting ;he forme
home of the deputy consul general of trar,n
to attorney Ivan Fisher and others. ft,gec
paid 515.000 a month in rent to the ,,
Department. but he charged hin ,,
scr
eye
.
his colleagues $20,000. Though
ih
terms of the agreement are •
court ruled against Epstein.
Wexner offers some into
rot combative "Many
winning and losing." Wexner
has the unusual quality a" n, hen
Jeffrey Epstein
he is winning. Whether in conversations or
negotiations, he always stands back and lets
the other person determine the style and
manner of the conversation or negotiation.
And then he responds in their style. Jeffrey
sees it in chivalrous terms. He does not pick
a fight. but if there is a fight, he will let you
choose your weapon."
One case is rather more serious. Currently.
Citibank is suing Epstein for defaulting on
loans from its privatebanking arm for 520
million. Epstein claims that Citibank "fraud-
ulently induced" him into borrowing the
money for investments. Citibank disputes this
charge.
The legal papers for another case offer a
rare window into Epstein's finances. In 1995.
Epstein stopped paying rent to his landlord.
the nonprofit Municipal Arts Society. for his
office in the silllard House. He claimed that
they were breaking the terms of the lease by
not letting his stall in at night. The case was
eventually settled. However. one of the papers
filed in this dispute is Epstein's financial gate-
ment for 1988. in which he claimed to be
worth 520 million. He listed that he owned
$7 million in securities. SI million in cash.
zero in residential property (although he
told sources that he had already bought the
home in Palm Beach). and 511 million in
other assets. including his investment in
Riddell. A co-investor in Riddell says: "The
company had been bought with a huge
amount of deb!. and it wasn't public. so it
was meaningless :o attach a figure like that to
it ... the price it cost was about 51.2 mil-
lion." The co-investors bought out Epstein's
share in Riddell in 1995 for approximately
53 million. At that time, when Epstein was
asked. as a routine matter, to sign a paper
guaranteeing he had access to a few million
dollars in case of any subsequent disputes
over the sale price. Wexner signed for him.
Epstein has explained that this was because
the co-investors wanted an indemnity against
being sued by. Wexner. One of the investors
calls this "bullshit."
Epstein's appointment to the board of
New York's Rockefeller University in
2000 brought him into greater social promi-
nence. Boasting such social names as Nancy
Kissaiger. Brecke Astor. and Robert Bass.
the board also includes such pre-tminent
scientists as Nobel laureate Joseph Gold-
stein. "Epstein was thrilled to be elected."
says someone who knows him.
After one term Epstein resigned. Accord-
ing to New York magazine, this was because
he didn't like to wear a suit to meetings. A
"ke:.pe tor, fc- the Rockefeller board says

• k : becaiae he had insufficient time
a member recalls that he
was "arrogant" and "not a good fit." The
spokesperson admits that it is "infrequent"
for board members not to be renominated
after only one term.
Still, the recent spate of publicity Ep-
stein has inspired does not seem to have
fazed him. In November he was spotted in
the front row of the Victoria's Secret fashion
show at New York's Lexington Avenue Ar-
mory: around the same time the usual co-
terie of friends and beautiful women were
whisked off to Little St. James [which he
tells people has been renamed Little St. Jeff)
for a long weekend.
Thanks to Epstein's introductions. says
Martin Nowak. the biologist finds himself
moving from Princeton to Harvard. where
he is assuming the joint position of profes-
sor of mathematics and professor of biolo•
• gy. Epstein has pledged at kart 525 million
to Harvard to create the Epstein Program
for Mathematical Biology and Evolutionary
Dynamics, and Epstein will have an office
at the university. The program will be dedi-
cated to searching for nature's algorithms. a
pursuit that is a specialty of Nowak's. For
Epstein this murt be the summit of every-
thing he has worked toward: he has been
seen proudly displaying Harvard president
Larry Summers's letter of commitment as
if he can't quite believe it is real. He says he
was reluctant to have his name attached to
the program. but Summers persuaded him.
He rang his mentor Wexner about it. and
Wexner told him it was all right.
An insatiable. restless soul. always on the
move. Epstein builds a tremendous amount
of downtime into his hectic work schedule.
Yet there is something almost programmed
about his relaxation: it's as if even plea-
sure has to be measured in terms of self-
improvement. Nowak says that, when he
goes to stay with Epstein in the Caribbean.
they'll get up at six and. as the sun rises.
have three-hour conversations about theoret-
ical physics. "Then he'll go off and do some
work. re-appear. and we'll talk some more."
Another person who went to the island
with Epstein. Maxwell. and several beautiful
women remembers that the women "sat
around one night teasing him about the
kinds of grasping women who might want
to date him. He was amused by the idea....
He's like a king in his own world."
Many people comment there is some-
thing innocent, almost childlike about kf•
key Epstein. They see this as refreshing. given
the sophistication of his surroundings. Alan
Dershowitz says that. as he was getting to
know Epstein. his wife asked him if he would
still be close to him if Epstein suddenly filed
for bankruptcy. Dershowitz says he replied.
"Absolutely. I would be as interested in him
as a friend if we had hamburgers on the
boardwalk in Coney Island and talked about
his ideas."
FASHION
Gomm: Mtn Affiedis Double RI. Tobin from Daafe
FL NYC. rd  LA. Of go so tem. polo con; im lags
,eons. col SCO.USA.LESI: Deborah Wcann for An
hlo alw Army/
Pete 11liz Chrome Hearts 'Art from Chrome
Heat. NYC. or cal 212-327.0707; or Rar itan
umgdosses. coil 8&9iluXOTTICA
Nr Peter Cncotti's Emporio Armril
Ma from Emetono Armors bona, noncrindrr
Ralph Lauren suspenders from selected
logo Roan Lauren stares; Cm Meehan for WOlter
Scetaier Management
Page 140: Frier Cincora's tin
by Thomas Pink; tut by
Giorgio ~Innis be in DINT:
Bane cool by mead cow
:-om selected Bran Ø
Page lit: Lem Gleaner ard
Maw Raytbzwg styled by :aha
Hennos.
Per  IliO: Stned by Angelo Groff kr Ennis. Inc.
Pep Usk For Ame Havoc*, Gina Simnel Designs
sew& °rotate> or medal ante.. Cad 978.499-2niS
Page 220: Bernadette Peters's
Donna Kn. New York dress
-am Dorm: Cyr Nee Yon
ro-es ranee-co ard eergatet
agocknas V.:, Paul smith
women cow-am Hem Send*.
NYC. ana c. LA. Chanel
nee"( as gases from Chanel
acensguearfarenne. cx cat 800-550-0005:
Narcissi Rodriguez shoes korn Al Kohl Sonia
Nsorma. ara Copra Combat. RC:
Lumberton Trues nordbog by speed order
Fergdor 17,:::-.ss NYC Ghorlia 9 09e riF N : 800iSST034
Page 223: Agnes flnickset's Torn Ford For as
Saint Laurent Fire Gauche dress hem `fun Sm—
We< :overt FN. Gaucke bos; a.,es
NYC. and *eaten
Peg* 226: Dynn Cannon
shred af IsCIO %teaser* tam
and eon br Doke &
Gobbano, from Doke
CaboOnd. Berertr Kiln. prism's/
by Wendy Walidda horn lr‘ends
Jimmy Choo. iron, a nn..
Ni kes 276-7 7 -h.:Alec( s Gums min from
an dues «at aga ra yes 9.jyys Corn
Venom boot 'ran
Wood barques
norkhrde. or go fa
rm. ~acorn.
a col 88.8-3SERSACF
Pars 27S-79:
(Noble RI Lows
`ram Dautord k. NYC and LA. or go to
am coo cons Chrome Hearts kong isbend sha
fem Chanse Heats NYC. ar
coil Z2-327.0107 for
Ray-Elan %mg/asses. call 883-
LUXOTTCA
Page 281: Tommy Hilfiger
lochs from Tommy Hager stores
naldmde. or col 800-
TCAMAY4U. Double RL T.s-m
from Double RIL NYC and LA.
on go to wetaolaccen kw Lem's morn coil
800-USA-LEN
146 VA • 'T f [AIR
MATCH 20J3
Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 1
SOCIETY GIRL AT TWITS' END
Neal Travis. New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Dec 1, 2000. pg. 009
Abstract (Document Summary)
THINGS may be turning sour for gal-about-town Ghislaine Maxwell, daughter of the fat and fraudulent former
owner of the Daily News, the late Robert Maxwell. I hear that some of the 39-year-old Ghislaine's friends on the
Manhattan and London party circuit are cutting her because she's had so much adverse press over her
relationship with Prince Andrew, Fergie's ex, with whom she recently attended a downtown S&M-themed party.
Her relationship with "Randy Andy" is said to be platonic, but the socially prominent women in Ghislaine's "set"
have recently sworn off any kind of publicity.
Full Text (328 words)
Copyright New York Post Corporation Dec 1, 2000
THINGS may be turning sour for gal-about-town Ghislaine Maxwell, daughter of the fat and fraudulent former
owner of the Daily News, the late Robert Maxwell. I hear that some of the 39-year-old Ghislaine's friends on the
Manhattan and London party circuit are cutting her because she's had so much adverse press over her
relationship with Prince Andrew, Fergie's ex, with whom she recently attended a downtown S&M-themed party.
Her relationship with "Randy Andy" is said to be platonic, but the socially prominent women in Ghislaine's "set"
have recently sworn off any kind of publicity. A series of lacerating articles - and the publication of the vapid
"Bright Young Things," written by one of their own, Brooke de Ocampo - has portrayed this crowd as a bunch of
twits living off their trust funds.
Ghislaine's own funds are something of a mystery. Her father lavished money on her and set her up in at least
one business in New York. But Maxwell's own ill-gotten gains were seized after he took a dive off his yacht,
which was named for her. There are plenty of British pensioners who lost their only means of support in the
crash of Maxwell's house of cards and who find it obscene that Ghislaine manages to own an apartment on the
Upper East Side and a mews house in London.
She is said to be on some kind of retainer from mysterious New York financier Jeffrey Epstein, who reportedly
has holdings in several major companies. Epstein also likes the company of attractive young women, and ifs
said that Ghislaine has been very good about introducing him to some of her pals.
Ghislaine and her two elder sisters don't talk about where their money is coming from, but they are said to be
heavily involved in some kind of Internet company. It would be awful luck for Ghislaine if her social standing
were diminished at the same time as tech stocks are going down the toilet.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
People: Maxwell, Ghislaine
Section: Neal Travis' New York
Text Word Count 328
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/68887782.html?MAC=af7992aa59df1218bd1903e43... 11/30/2005
MURKY WORLD OF CLINTON PAL
New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Oct 20, 2002. pg. 010
People: Epstein, Jeffrey, Clinton, Bill, Trump, Donald J, Boardman, Samantha, Truman, James
Section: Page Six
Text Word 1147
Count
Document URL:
Leslie Wexner, founder and chair of the Limited clothing-store chain, bought the place in 1989 for
$15,000. [Jeffrey Epstein]'s mentor and one of his clients, Wexner is rumored to have sold the palatial
digs to him for just $1. Epstein quickly spent $10 million to gut the place and completely redo the
interior.
SOCIALITE Samantha Boardman ditched her beau, Conde Nast editorial director James Truman
Aichives: New York Post Page 1 of 3
MURKY WORLD OF CLINTON PAL
New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Oct 20, 2002. pg. 010
Abstract (Document Summary)
Leslie Wexner, founder and chair of the Limited clothing-store chain, bought the place in 1989 for $15,000.
[Jeffrey Epsteinj's mentor and one of his clients, Wexner is rumored to have sold the palatial digs to him for just
$1. Epstein quickly spent $10 million to gut the place and completely redo the interior.
SOCIALITE Samantha Boardman ditched her beau, Conde Nast editorial director James Truman, last year for
man-about-town Todd Meister. According to our spies, Boardman ditched Meister after she caught him in
flagrante with a 19-year-old coed. But don't feel too bad for her. Women's Wear Daily reports Boardman has a
new man - Vanity Fairs Graydon Carter. Truman must not be too pleased. When Boardman dumped him, he
needed to recuperate at a Buddhist retreat upstate. Editorial meetings at Conde Nast must be a hoot these
days.
"DISCO Bloodbath" author James St. James is following up his notorious tell-all about killer club kid Michael Alig
with another true-crime tome. He's shopping around "Killer Grandpa," his investigation into a lynching that his
grandfather led in 1935. "My grandfather was a sheriff in Fort Lauderdale, and he lynched a black man that
allegedly raped a white woman," James told us. "About 100 people gathered to watch, and they passed a gun
around and everyone took a shot at the body. It became this big town secret, and I write about what really
happened." James, a 1980s club kid who fell in with Alig's inner circle, is played by Seth Green in "Party
Monster," the movie adaptation of "Disco Bloodbath." But James said he was "shocked" when he watched a few
scenes of Green mincing it up with Macaulay Culkin, who plays Alig. "I didn't know I was so gay! I thought I was
more like Steve McQueen, but Seth is flouncing around the whole time. Seth is much cuter than me, actually,
and looks better in drag."
Full Text (1147 words)
(Copyright 2002, The New York Post. All Rights Reserved)
PAGE SIX'S scoop last month that mysterious money manager Jeffrey Epstein had flown Bill Clinton, Chris
Tucker and Kevin Spacey to Africa on his private 727 has sent journalists all over town trying to find out just who
Epstein really is.
Vanity Fair has a reporter on his trail, but New York magazine beats them to the punch with a feature this week
on Epstein's strange history.
Epstein, 49, a former Dalton School math teacher from Coney Island, is said to manage $15 billion for super-
wealthy clients he'll only take on if they have at least $1 billion in assets.
"According to people who know him," New York reports, "if you were worth $700 million and felt the need for the
services of Epstein & Co., you would receive a not-so-polite no-thank-you."
Noted mergers/acquisitions lawyer Dennis Block of Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft recalls trying to give
Epstein a client whose funds were below the $1 billion cutoff.
"I sent him a $500 million client a few years ago and he wouldn't take him," Block reports. "Said the account was
too small. Both the client and I were amazed. But that's Jeffrey."
Most Wall Streeters, however, aren't even certain what Epstein actually does for a living. "My belief is that Jeff
maintains some sort of money-management firm, though you won't get a straight answer from him," says one
powerful investor. "He once told me that he has 300 people working for him, and I've also heard he manages
Rockefeller money. But one never knows. It's like looking at the Wizard of Oz."
Some say that Epstein once quit his seat on the board of the Rockefeller Institute because he hates wearing a
suit, supposedly telling a friend, "It feels like wearing a dress?
http://pqasb.pqarehiver.com/nypost/222493931.html?MAC=90db373aedcblc36a203f8bd... 11/30/2005
AfIchives: New York Post Page 2 of 3
One power player who doesn't find Epstein to be all that hard to figure is Donald Trump.
"I've known Jeffrey for 15 years," The Donald tells the magazine. "Terrific guy. He's a lot of fun to be with. It is
even said that he likes beautiful women as much as I do, and many of them are on the younger side."
Another thing Epstein - who's said to pocket at least $75 million a year in fees - and Trump have in common is a
taste for extravagant living. Epstein lives in a 45,000-square-foot, eight-story mansion on East 71st Street.
Leslie Wexner, founder and chair of the Limited clothing-store chain, bought the place in 1989 for $15,000.
Epstein's mentor and one of his clients, Wexner is rumored to have sold the palatial digs to him for just $1.
Epstein quickly spent $10 million to gut the place and completely redo the interior.
"I don't want to live in another person's house," Epstein told New York.
Blind dater
CHRIS Noth wasn't lonely on a recent trip to London. The "Law & Order hunk was set up on a blind date with
Rose Keegan, an actress and the daughter of historian Sir John Keegan. The two spent much of the evening at
the Century Club, and they were chaperoned by Kyle MacLachlan, who is pals with Noth from their days on the
set of "Sex and the City." MacLachlan is in London co-starring in a play with hemp-happy Woody Harrelson.
'Rockets' soars
"ROCKETS Redglare!" - a posthumous tribute to the late East Village actor and downtown icon - won the Grand
Jury Prize for Best Documentary at the New York International Independent Film and Video Festival. Directed by
Luis Fernandez De La Reguera, it features interviews with Rockets' pals Willem Dafoe, Matt Dillon, Jim
Jarmusch, Steve Buscemi and Julian Schnabel. Rockets, the beloved 350-pound former bodyguard of punk
legend Sid Vicious who appeared in several of Buscemi's and Jarmusch's movies, died last year after years of
drug abuse.
Bizarre union
BOB Crane was a sex addict, but his second wife, Pat Crane, didn't care. "He treated women like the rest of the
world treats toilet paper. Who's going to be jealous of toilet paper?" she told "20/20" contributing correspondent
Chris Connelly. Despite Crane's penchant for seducing other women and documenting his trysts on film and
videotape, Pat insists: "We had a wonderful sex life. We had a wonderful marriage." Crane was bludgeoned to
death in 1978 with a camera tripod.
Plot device
GAY writers love PAGE SIX. Everyone's favorite gossip column is prominently featured in the new novel "The
Night We Met," a romantically swishy comedy by Rob Byrnes about a guy and his mafioso boyfriend. After
making references to this page and The Post throughout the book, Byrnes even attempts to replicate one of our
items in the climax. Byrnes' fictional item may lack the flawless prose of a real PAGE SIX scoop, but he does
have us outsmarting yet another mendacious mouthpiece.
Change partners
SOCIALITE Samantha Boardman ditched her beau, Conde Nast editorial director James Truman, last year for
man-about-town Todd Meister. According to our spies, Boardman ditched Meister after she caught him in
flagrante with a 19-year-old coed. But don't feel too bad for her. Women's Wear Daily reports Boardman has a
new man - Vanity Fair's Graydon Carter. Truman must not be too pleased. When Boardman dumped him, he
needed to recuperate at a Buddhist retreat upstate. Editorial meetings at Conde Nast must be a hoot these
days.
Well protected
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/222493931.html?MAC=90db373aedcb1c36a203f8bd... 11/30/2005
"Archives: New York Post Page 3 of 3
SEAN "Puffy" Combs confirmed our account of how Heath Ledger scuffled with his bodyguards at the
VH1Nogue Awards after-party Combs threw at Lotus. "Heath is from Australia, and he parties hard now,"
Combs told "Access Hollywood." The two became pals on the set of "Monster's Ball." "He's coming at me, he's
like, 'Puff, people don't know that we're the best of friends,' so it's like my security held him up for a second . . .
and I was like, 'No, that's my brother.'" Sins of his grandfather
"DISCO Bloodbath" author James St. James is following up his notorious tell-all about killer club kid Michael Alig
with another true-crime tome. He's shopping around "Killer Grandpa," his investigation into a lynching that his
grandfather led in 1935. "My grandfather was a sheriff in Fort Lauderdale, and he lynched a black man that
allegedly raped a white woman," James told us. "About 100 people gathered to watch, and they passed a gun
around and everyone took a shot at the body. It became this big town secret, and I write about what really
happened." James, a 1980s club kid who fell in with Alig's inner circle, is played by Seth Green in "Party
Monster," the movie adaptation of "Disco Bloodbath." But James said he was "shocked" when he watched a few
scenes of Green mincing it up with Macaulay Culkin, who plays Alig. "I didn't know I was so gay! I thought I was
more like Steve McQueen, but Seth is flouncing around the whole time. Seth is much cuter than me, actually,
and looks better in drag."
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
People: Epstein, Jeffrey, Clinton, Bill, Trump, Donald J, Boardman, Samantha, Truman, James
Section: Page Six
Text Word Count 1147
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.cominypost/222493931.html?MAC=90db373aedcblc36a203f8bd... 11/30/2005
v 'Pi/chives: New York Post Page 1 of I
HOTSHOT EPSTEIN NOT SO HOT: VF
PAUL THARP. New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Feb 4, 2003. pg. 036
Abstract (Document Summary)
[Jeffrey Epstein), a 50-year-old Ralph Lauren lookalike who claims to manage a billionaires-only fund, has made
headlines for his high- society lifestyle; among his attention-grabbing moves was flying President Clinton and
Kevin Spacey to Africa on a private jet.
The article says that when Epstein worked for [Steve Hoffenberg], he cooked up some of Hoffenberg's
questionable financing deals - a claim Epstein has denied.
Full Text (249 words)
(Copyright 2003, The New York Post. Al! Rights Reserved)
Jeffrey Epstein - a self-proclaimed billionaire who hobnobs with moguls and pledged $25 million to Harvard - is
actually a small potatoes ex-bounty hunter with a questionable financial background, says a report.
Epstein, a 50-year-old Ralph Lauren lookalike who claims to manage a billionaires-only fund, has made
headlines for his high- society lifestyle; among his attention-grabbing moves was flying President Clinton and
Kevin Spacey to Africa on a private jet.
But a report in the March issue of Vanity Fair, on newsstands this week, unmasks Epstein's mystery image.
Epstein wasn't exactly the top gun at Bear Stearns, as he claims - and left the firm amid a swirl of rumors and an
SEC violation, the article said.
His mentor in high finance was Steve Hoffenberg, the bill collector turned hustler now serving 20 years in prison
for running the nation's costliest Ponzi scheme, the report says.
The article says that when Epstein worked for Hoffenberg, he cooked up some of Hoffenberg's questionable
financing deals - a claim Epstein has denied.
Epstein has also been involved in numerous lawsuits, including one in which Citibank is suing him for defaulting
on $20 million in loans from its private banking arm.
Epstein and his lawyer, Jeffrey Schantz, couldn't be reached for comment on the article.
The article said that Epstein keeps all his deals and clients secret, except for one - retail magnate Leslie
Wexner, who calls Epstein "smart . . . [with] high standards . . . and a loyal friend."
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
People: Epstein, Jeffrey, Hoffenberg, Steve
Section: Business
Text Word Count 249
Document URL:
http://pciasb.pqarehivenconilnypost/283218771.html?MAC=cd5f1b288a6f3a0603f273e6... 11/30/2005
HOTSHOT EPSTEIN NOT SO HOT: VF
PAUL THARP. New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Feb 4, 2003. pg. 036
People: Epstein, Jeffrey, Hoffenberg, Steve
Section: Business
Text Word Count 249
Document URL:
?IVO:MO(50
[Jeffrey Epstein], a 50-year-old Ralph Lauren lookalike who claims to manage a billionaires-only
fund, has made headlines for his high- society lifestyle; among his attention-grabbing moves was flying
President Clinton and Kevin Spacey to Africa on a private jet.
The article says that when Epstein worked for [Steve Hoffenberg], he cooked up some of
Hoffenberg's questionable financing deals - a claim Epstein hal denied.
•
Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 4
PROBED POL'S SON BLAMES PLOT
New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Jan 14, 2005. pg. 014
Abstract (Document Summary) •
IS billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein making a bid for IMG Models? As we reported last summer, Epstein tried
to buy Elite Models when the bankrupt agency was auctioned off. In 2003, we reported that Epstein, who's been
described as "a connoisseur of beautiful women," was talking to Karin Models owner Jean-Luc Brunel about
doing a deal, but it went nowhere. Epstein has also met with Elite's Gerald Marie and 1 Management's Scott
Lipps. Now we hear Epstein has been having talks with fellow billionaire Teddy Forstmann, who paid $750
million for the IMG group a few months ago, about buying the company's modeling division, which reps the likes
of Gisele Bundchen, Kate Moss and Heidi Klum. Reps for IMG and Forstmann deny any such negotiations are
taking place. Epstein's rep did not return calls. Forstmann has been talking to top Hollywood talent agencies
about a possible merger.
PAUL Allen, 51, the bachelor Microsoft co-founder worth $20 billion (according to Forbes), rang in the New Year
with British blonde Kate Reardon, 36 (above), a former fashion director for Tatter magazine who now writes
about jewelry for the Times of London. The couple ushered in 2005 in St. Barts aboard Allen's 413- foot yacht,
"Octopus," equipped with two helicopters and a 60-fobt submarine. There were scores of other guests but Allen •
seemed mesmerized by Reardon, who had a similareffect on another billionaire, Sir Jimmy Goldsmith. rZeardon
attended Goldsmith's funeral in 1997, along with his widow and his second wife. "Conveniently, Allen has a
house in London," said our source.
[TRUMAN CAPOTE], dead for over 20 years, is suddenly a hot property in Hollywood. The author of "Breakfast
at Tiffany's" and "In Cold Blood" is the subject of two new biopics - Warner Independent's "Every Word Is True,"
based on George Plimpton's 1997 oral history, and United Artists'"Capote," based on the landmark 1988 Gerald
Clarke biography. "Capote," due out this fall, stars Phillip Seymour Hoffman, who is talented but a bit burly to
play the "tiny terror." "Every Word" stars relatively unknown Toby Jones with an all-star supporting cast including
Alan Cumming, Anjelica Huston, Sandra Bullock (as "To Kill a Mockingbird" author Harper Lee), Ashley Judd,
Kevin Kline, Gwyneth Paltrow and Sigourney Weaver. Hollywood columnist Jeffrey Wells reports that "Capote"
has the advantage of Hoffman in the starring role, while "Every Word," which just started filming, is said to have
a much better screenplay.
Full Text (1520 words)
(Copyright 2005, The New York Post. All Rights Reserved)
THE loose-cannon son of a subpoenaed Bronx state senator claims Republicans are behind a federal probe of
the Bronx Democratic machine because they want to destroy Fernando Ferrer's campaign for mayor.
Efrain Gonzalez III, whose dad, State Sen. Efrain Gonzalez Jr., is one of nine Bronx politicians subpoenaed to
testify, wrote to the Riverdale Review: "The GOP controls the White House, the N.Y. State House and City Hall,
so if they want to attack the members of the Bronx Democratic Party, who is going to stop them?" Fifteen
subpoenas reportedly have been served, six of them to nonprofit organizations that employ relatives of the
elected officials. Young Gonzalez is president of the Latino Affirmation Council, which isn't listed in The Bronx or
Manhattan.
Gonzalez Ill's letter to the Riverdale paper said: "When my father and the 14 other members were issued
subpoenas, that alone was a message being sent by the GOP, that they will do anything in their power to keep
Mayor Bloomberg in power, because all those members being probed are working to support Ferrer in next
year's mayoral race." •
The elder Gonzalez's lawyer, "Don't Worry Murray" Richman, told PAGE SIX: "This is the over-excited
imagination of a young man. We do not support these allegations which were not authorized and don't represent
the views of the senator or myself."
In a strange e-mail posted on YonkersTribune.com last fall, after The Post broke the news of the investigation,
young Gonzalez said: "They couldn't find any weapons [of mass destruction], so they said instead of killing more
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/778885231.html?MAC=d480c38ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 2 of 4
camels, they are trying to get rid of all the donkeys overbere instead . . . they forgot that a Puerto Rican donkey
knows how to climb high mountains, and are stronger than any elephant."
One federal subpoena went to the elder Gonzalez's longtime girlfriend, Lucia Sanchez. Investigators are also
looking into the $1 million in campaign funds Gonzalez has spent over the years in-uncontested elections, with
much of the money going to a mystery campaign worker identified in filings as Ricardo Santiago.
"At issue is whether or not borough politicos funneled state and city funds into pet programs to then turn those
funds into salaries for friends and relatives," the Riverdale Review reports.
One of the non-profits being probed is the West Bronx Neighborhood Association, a favorite of Gonzalez's
housed in the same building as his office on the Grand Concourse.
Talent shortfall
THUMB-size thespians looking for a little work would do well to book a trip to London, where dwarf actors are in
short supply. Producers for the BBC's "Doctor Who" are searching for undersize actors to play little blue aliens in
the remake of the classic 1970s sci-fi show. But most of Britain's tiny talents have already been snapped up for
the new "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" movie or to play Gringotts Bank staff in the new "Harry Potter" film.
Executive producer Russell T. Davies complained to London's Daily Mirror: "It's very difficult to employ persons
of restricted growth when these other movies are filming at the same time."
We hear . . .
THAT it could get crowded for the Democrats in 2008. John Kerry has said he won't rule out running again, and
now comes word Tipper Gore is telling friends that Al is eyeing another race himself.
Words of gold
DONALD Trump will be paid a record-breaking-$1 million an hour for Learning Annex appearances in three
cities this year. That's over $16,000 a minute. Since it was founded in 1980, the Learning Annex has featured
such celebrity teachers as Sarah Jessica Parker, Tony Robbins, Deepak Chopra and Henry Kissinger. The
previous highest fee was $28,000 - paid to Ron Wood nearly 20 years ago when he was a member of the
Rolling Stones. Trump's "How toSucceed in Real Estate" hits Los Angeles on May 1, Chicago on Oct. 23 and
New York on Nov. 6. Learning Annex president/founder Bill Zanker said, "Last time he taught for us, over 20,000
students came - and this year he's even bigger."
Mogul lusts for model shop
IS billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein making a bid for IMG Models? As we reported last summer, Epstein tried
to buy Elite Models when the bankrupt agency was auctioned off. In 2003, we reported that Epstein, who's been
described as "a connoisseur of beautiful women," was talking to Karin Models owner Jean-Luc Brunel about
doing a deal, but it went nowhere. Epstein has also met with Elite's Gerald Marie and 1 Management's Scott
Lipps. Now we hear Epstein has been having talks with fellow billionaire Teddy Forstmann, who paid $750
million for the IMG group a few months ago, about buying the company's modeling division, which reps the likes
of Gisele Bundchen, Kate Moss and Heidi Klum. Reps for IMG and Forstmann deny any such negotiations are
taking place. Epstein's rep did not return calls. Forstmann has been talking to top Hollywood talent agencies
about a possible merger.
Aspen captive
SOCIALITE Denise Rich has fired her yoga instructor after his girlfriend told police that he locked her in a room
of Rich's Aspen mansion for three days over the Thanksgiving holiday. The unidentified woman alleged that
Jules Paxton attacked her first and then locked her in a room when she threatened to call the cops. A
spokesman for Rich said the ex-wife of pardoned tax cheat Marc Rich was traveling abroad during the incident,
but confirmed that Paxton was staying at herhome. "Mrs. Rich has decided to discontinue his services as her
yoga instructor," the rep said.
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.conVnypost/778885231.html?MAC=d480c38ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 3 of 4
Happy holiday
PAUL Allen, 51, the bachelor Microsoft co-founder worth $20 billion (according to Forbes), rang in the New Year
with British blonde Kate Reardon, 36 (above), a former fashion director for Tatler magazine who now writes
about jewelry for the Times of London. The couple ushered in 2005 in St. Barts aboard Allen's 413- foot yacht,
"Octopus," equipped with two helicopters and a 60-foot submarine. There were scores of other guests but Allen
seemed mesmerized by Reardon, who had a similareffect on another billionaire, Sir Jimmy Goldsmith. Reardon
attended Goldsmith's funeral in 1997, along with his widow and his second wife. "Conveniently, Allen has a
house in London," said our source.
Super at 14
THE 44 contestants in the Ford Supermodel of the World contest learned evasive maneuvers at the after-party
at the Tunnel, where they met such studs as Jesse Palmer of the Giants, Trevor Ariza of the Knicks, Jamie
("Born Rich") Johnson and Kelly ("The Apprentice") Perdew. New husband Fabian Basabe showed, too, without
bride Martina Borgomanero, and worked the red carpet. The winner, who also got a $250,000 modeling contract,
was Brazilian Camila Finn (above), all of 14. She might look even better when she grows up.
ITS THE TRUMAN CAPOTE SHOW
TRUMAN Capote, dead for over 20 years, is suddenly a hot property in Hollywood. The author of "Breakfast at
Tiffany's" and "In Cold Blood" is the subject of two new biopics - Warner Independent's "Every Word Is True,"
based on George Plimpton's 1997 oral history, and United Artists'"Capote," based on the landmark 1988 Gerald
Clarke biography. "Capote," due out this fall, stars Phillip Seymour Hoffman, who is talented but a bit burly to
play the "tiny terror." "Every Word" stars relatively unknown Toby Jones with an all-star supporting cast including
Alan Cumming, Anjelica Huston, Sandra Bullock (as "To Kill a Mockingbird" author Harper Lee), Ashley Judd,
Kevin Kline, Gwyneth Paltrow and Sigourney Weaver. Hollywood columnist Jeffrey Wells reports that "Capote"
has the advantage of Hoffman in the starring role, while "Every Word," which just started filming, is said to have
a much better screenplay.
Own show
COURTNEY Fine, a former aide to Mayor Bloomberg who left politics to become an actress, is showcasing "Me
2," a play she wrote about a woman jailed for breaking into the bar where she left her cell- phone. Among those
invited to last night's opening at the Producers Club 2: Victoria Gotti, Amy Fine Collins and Bloomberg's sister
Marjorie Tiven. The show closes after tomorrow's performance.
Never mind
GEORGE Parnham, the lawyer for Andrea Yates, is quick to cash in after winning her a new trial for the murder
of her five kids. Parnham, who will try to get Yates off using the insanity defense, is shopping a book, "States of
Mind," which will focus on his favorite tricks for defending female killers: postpartum depression, premenstrual
syndrome and post-traumatic stress. And he'll include similar cases: Clara Harris, who allegedly ran over her
unfaithful husband with herMercedes Benz, and Lisa Montgomery, who strangled Bobbie Jo Stinnett and then
surgically removed her fetus last month.
[Illustration]
-Kate Reardon; Camila Finn -SINGER ALICIA KEYS KEEPS HER BOD BUFF BY JOGGING ON THE BEACH
IN BARBADOS YESTERDAY. [ZUMA PRESS] -ANY MAN WHO WINS THE HEART OF NICOLE KIDMAN,
PICTURED HERE IN A SHOOT FOR THE NEW ISSUE OF IN STYLE, IS A LUCKY DOG. HER LATEST
CRUSH, SHE TELLS THE MAG, IS PHILIP ROTH, 71, WHO WROTE THE NOVEL "THE HUMAN STAIN," THE
BASIS FOR HER 2003 FILM. [RUVEN AFANADOR FOR IN STYLE]
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.conilnypost/778885231.html?MAC=d480c38ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11/30/2005
*Archives: New York Post Page 4 of 4
permission.
People: Gonzalez, Efrain Ill, Epstein, Jeffrey, Rich, Denise, Alien, Paul, Reardon, Kate
Section: Page Six
Text Word Count 1520
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.cora/nypost/778 8 8523 1.htrar/MAC=d4 8 0c3 8ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11/0/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 4
PROBED POL'S SON BLAMES PLOT
New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Jan 14, 2005. pg. 014
Abstract (Document Summary)
IS billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein making a bid for IMG Models? As we reported last summer, Epstein tried
to buy Elite Models when the bankrupt agency was auctioned off. In 2003, we reported that Epstein, who's been
described as "a connoisseur of beautiful women," was talking to Karin Models owner Jean-Luc Brunel about
doing a deal, but it went nowhere. Epstein has also met with Elite's Gerald Marie and 1 Management's Scott
Lipps. Now we hear Epstein has been having talks with fellow billionaire Teddy Forstmann, who paid $750
million for the IMG group a few months ago, about buying the company's modeling division, which reps the likes
of Gisele Bundchen, Kate Moss and Heidi Klum. Reps for IMG and Forstmann deny any such negotiations are
taking place. Epstein's rep did not return calls. Forstmann has been talking to top Hollywood talent agencies
about a possible merger.
PAUL Allen, 51, the bachelor Microsoft co-founder worth $20 billion (according to Forbes), rang in the New Year
with British blonde Kate Reardon, 36 (above), a former fashion director for Tatler magazine who now writes
about jewelry for the Times of London. The couple ushered in 2005 in St. Barts aboard Allen's 413- foot yacht,
"Octopus," equipped with two helicopters and a 60-foot submarine. There were scores of other guests but Allen
seemed mesmerized by Reardon, who had a similareffect on another billionaire, Sir Jimmy Goldsmith. Reardon
attended Goldsmith's funeral in 1997, along with his widow and his second wife. "Conveniently, Allen has a
house in London," said our source.
[TRUMAN CAPOTE], dead for over 20 years, is suddenly a hot property in Hollywood. The author of "Breakfast
at Tiffany's" and "In Cold Blood" is the subject of two new biopics - Warner Independent's "Every Word Is True,"
based on George Plimpton's 1997 oral history, and United Artists' "Capote," based on the landmark 1988 Gerald
Clarke biography. "Capote," due out this fall, stars Phillip Seymour Hoffman, who is talented but a bit burly to
play the "tiny terror." "Every Word" stars relatively unknown Toby Jones with an all-star supporting cast including
Alan Cumming, Anjelica Huston, Sandra Bullock (as "To Kill a Mockingbird" author Harper Lee), Ashley Judd,
Kevin Kline, Gwyneth Paltrow and Sigoumey Weaver. Hollywood columnist Jeffrey Wells reports that "Capote"
has the advantage of Hoffman in the starring role, while "Every Word," which just started filming, is said to have
a much better screenplay.
Full Text (1520 words)
(Copyright 2005, The New York Post. A!! Rights Reserved)
THE loose-cannon son of a subpoenaed Bronx state senator claims Republicans are behind a federal probe of
the Bronx Democratic machine because they want to destroy Fernando Ferrer's campaign for mayor.
Efrain Gonzalez III, whose dad, State Sen. Efrain Gonzalez Jr., is one of nine Bronx politicians subpoenaed to
testify, wrote to the Riverdale Review: "The GOP controls the White House, the N.Y. State House and City Hall,
so if they want to attack the members of the Bronx Democratic Party, who is going to stop them?" Fifteen
subpoenas reportedly have been served, six of them to nonprofit organizations that employ relatives of the
elected officials. Young Gonzalez is president of the Latino Affirmation Council, which isn't listed in The Bronx or
Manhattan.
Gonzalez Ill's letter to the Riverdale paper said: "When my father and the 14 other members were issued
subpoenas, that alone was a message being sent by the GOP, that they will do anything in their power to keep
Mayor Bloomberg in power, because all those members being probed are working to support Ferrer in next
year's mayoral race."
The elder Gonzalez's lawyer, "Don't Worry Murray" Richman, told PAGE SIX: "This is the over-excited
imagination of a young man. We do not support these allegations which were not authorized and don't represent
the views of the senator or myself."
In a strange e-mail posted on YonkersTribune.com last fall, after The Post broke the news of the investigation,
young Gonzalez said: "They couldn't find any weapons [of mass destruction], so they said instead of killing more
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/778885231.html?MAC=d480c38ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 2 of 4
camels, they are trying to get rid of all the donkeys over here instead . . . they forgot that a Puerto Rican donkey
knows how to climb high mountains, and are stronger than any elephant."
One federal subpoena went to the elder Gonzalez's longtime girlfriend, Lucia Sanchez. Investigators are also
looking into the $1 million in campaign funds Gonzalez has spent over the years in uncontested elections, with
much of the money going to a mystery campaign worker identified in filings as Ricardo Santiago.
"At issue is whether or not borough politicos funneled state and city funds into pet programs to then turn those
funds into salaries for friends and relatives," the Riverdale Review reports.
One of the non-profits being probed is the West Bronx Neighborhood Association, a favorite of Gonzalez's
housed in the same building as his office on the Grand Concourse.
Talent shortfall
THUMB-size thespians looking for a little work would do well to book a trip to London, where dwarf actors are in
short supply. Producers for the BBC's "Doctor Who" are searching for undersize actors to play little blue aliens in
the remake of the classic 1970s sci-fi show. But most of Britain's tiny talents have already been snapped up for
the new "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" movie or to play Gringotts Bank staff in the new "Harry Potter" film.
Executive producer Russell T. Davies complained to London's Daily Mirror: "It's very difficult to employ persons
of restricted growth when these other movies are filming at the same time."
We hear . .
THAT it could get crowded for the Democrats in 2008. John Kerry has said he won't rule out running again, and
now comes word Tipper Gore is telling friends that Al is eyeing another race himself.
Words of gold
DONALD Trump will be paid a record-breaking $1 million an hour for Learning Annex appearances in three
cities this year. That's over $16,000 a minute. Since it was founded in 1980, the Learning Annex has featured
such celebrity teachers as Sarah Jessica Parker, Tony Robbins, Deepak Chopra and Henry Kissinger. The
previous highest fee was $28,000 - paid to Ron Wood nearly 20 years ago when he was a member of the
Rolling Stones. Trump's "How toSucceed in Real Estate" hits Los Angeles on May 1, Chicago on Oct. 23 and
New York on Nov. 6. Learning Annex president/founder Bill Zanker said, "Last time he taught for us, over 20,000
students came - and this year he's even bigger."
Mogul lusts for model shop
IS billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein making a bid for IMG Models? As we reported last summer, Epstein tried
to buy Elite Models when the bankrupt agency was auctioned off. In 2003, we reported that Epstein, who's been
described as "a connoisseur of beautiful women," was talking to Karin Models owner Jean-Luc Brunel about
doing a deal, but it went nowhere. Epstein has also met with Elite's Gerald Marie and 1 Management's Scott
Lipps. Now we hear Epstein has been having talks with fellow billionaire Teddy Forstmann, who paid $750
million for the IMG group a few months ago, about buying the company's modeling division, which reps the likes
of Gisele Bundchen, Kate Moss and Heidi Klum. Reps for IMG and Forstmann deny any such negotiations are
taking place. Epstein's rep did not return calls. Forstmann has been talking to top Hollywood talent agencies
about a possible merger.
Aspen captive
SOCIALITE Denise Rich has fired her yoga instructor after his girlfriend told police that he locked her in a room
of Rich's Aspen mansion for three days over the Thanksgiving holiday. The unidentified woman alleged that
Jules Paxton attacked her first and then locked her in a room when she threatened to call the cops. A
spokesman for Rich said the ex-wife of pardoned tax cheat Marc Rich was traveling abroad during the incident,
but confirmed that Paxton was staying at herhome. "Mrs. Rich has decided to discontinue his services as her
yoga instructor," the rep said.
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/778885231.html?MAC=d480c38ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 3 of 4
Happy holiday
PAUL Allen, 51, the bachelor Microsoft co-founder worth $20 billion (according to Forbes), rang in the New Year
with British blonde Kate Reardon, 36 (above), a former fashion director for Taller magazine who now writes
about jewelry for the Times of London. The couple ushered in 2005 in St. Baits aboard Allen's 413- foot yacht,
"Octopus," equipped with two helicopters and a 60-foot submarine. There were scores of other guests but Allen
seemed mesmerized by Reardon, who had a similareffect on another billionaire, Sir Jimmy Goldsmith. Reardon
attended Goldsmith's funeral in 1997, along with his widow and his second wife. "Conveniently, Allen has a
house in London," said our source.
Super at 14
THE 44 contestants in the Ford Supermodel of the World contest learned evasive maneuvers at the after-party
at the Tunnel, where they met such studs as Jesse Palmer of the Giants, Trevor Ariza of the Knicks, Jamie
("Born Rich") Johnson and Kelly ("The Apprentice") Perdew. New husband Fabian Basabe showed, too, without
bride Martina Borgomanero, and worked the red carpet. The winner, who also got a $250,000 modeling contract,
was Brazilian Camila Finn (above), all of 14. She might look even better when she grows up.
ITS THE TRUMAN CAPOTE SHOW
TRUMAN Capote, dead for over 20 years, is suddenly a hot property in Hollywood. The author of "Breakfast at
Tiffany's" and "In Cold Blood" is the subject of two new biopics - Warner Independent's "Every Word Is True,"
based on George Plimpton's 1997 oral history, and United Artists' "Capote," based on the landmark 1988 Gerald
Clarke biography. "Capote," due out this fall, stars Phillip Seymour Hoffman, who is talented but a bit burly to
play the "tiny terror." "Every Word" stars relatively unknown Toby Jones with an all-star supporting cast including
Alan Cumming, Anjelica Huston, Sandra Bullock (as "To Kill a Mockingbird" author Harper Lee), Ashley Judd,
Kevin Kline, Gwyneth Paltrow and Sigourney Weaver. Hollywood columnist Jeffrey Wells reports that "Capote"
has the advantage of Hoffman in the starring role, while "Every Word," which just started filming, is said to have
a much better screenplay.
Own show
COURTNEY Fine, a former aide to Mayor Bloomberg who left politics to become an actress, is showcasing "Me
2," a play she wrote about a woman jailed for breaking into the bar where she left her cell- phone. Among those
invited to last night's opening at the Producers Club 2: Victoria Gotti, Amy Fine Collins and Bloomberg's sister
Marjorie Tiven. The show closes after tomorrow's performance.
Never mind
GEORGE Pamham, the lawyer for Andrea Yates, is quick to cash in after winning her a new trial for the murder
of her five kids. Parnham, who will try to get Yates off using the insanity defense, is shopping a book, "States of
Mind," which will focus on his favorite tricks for defending female killers: postpartum depression, premenstrual
syndrome and post-traumatic stress. And he'll include similar cases: Clara Harris, who allegedly ran over her
unfaithful husband with herMercedes Benz, and Lisa Montgomery, who strangled Bobbie Jo Stinnett and then
surgically removed her fetus last month.
[Illustration]
-Kate Reardon; Camila Finn -SINGER ALICIA KEYS KEEPS HER BOD BUFF BY JOGGING ON THE BEACH
IN BARBADOS YESTERDAY. [ZUMA PRESS] -ANY MAN WHO WINS THE HEART OF NICOLE KIDMAN,
PICTURED HERE IN A SHOOT FOR THE NEW ISSUE OF IN STYLE, IS A LUCKY DOG. HER LATEST
CRUSH, SHE TELLS THE MAG, IS PHILIP ROTH, 71, WHO WROTE THE NOVEL "THE HUMAN STAIN," THE
BASIS FOR HER 2003 FILM. [RUVEN AFANADOR FOR IN STYLE]
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/778885231.html?MAC=d480c38ad9d4655614f3d46d... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 4 of 4
permission.
People: Gonzalez, Efrain Ill, Epstein, Jeffrey, Rich, Denise, Men, Paul, Reardon, Kate
Section: Page St(
Text VVord Count 1520
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/778 88523 1.html?MACri:14 8 0c3 8ad9d465 561 4f3 d46d... 11/30/2005
MORE HEAT FOR BEL AIR BURGLAR
New York Post. New York, N.Y.: May 26, 2005. pg. 012
Companies: Miami Heat (NAICS: 711211, Sic:7941 )
Section: Page Six
Text Word Count 1671
Document URI,:
NOW that his romance with Serena Williams has gone south, randy director Brett Ratner seems to be
settling down with his former gal pal. Model Alina Pascau has been flashing a massive canary-yellow
diamond engagement ring Ratner recently gave her, we're told. Pascau, a Romanian stunner, used to
date reclusive billionaire Jeffrey Epstein. Epstein, who handles Leslie Wexner's fortune, helped land
her a gig modeling
Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 4
MORE HEAT FOR BEL AIR BURGLAR
New York Post. New York, N.Y.: May 26, 2005. pg. 012
Abstract (Document Summary)
NOW that his romance with Serena Williams has gone south, randy director Brett Ratner seems to be settling
down with his former gal pal. Model Alina Pascau has been flashing a massive canary-yellow diamond
engagement ring Ratner recently gave her, we're told. Pascau, a Romanian stunner, used to date reclusive
billionaire Jeffrey Epstein. Epstein, who handles Leslie Wexner's fortune, helped land her a gig modeling for
Wexner's Victoria's Secret brand, wehear, and paid for her to live in high style. After they broke up she and
Ratner dated for a while before his fling with Williams. "She's beautiful, but dumb as paint," one pal of Pascau
told us. "She never washes her hair and she always has a cellphone glued to her ear. Without Jeffrey she would
never have gotten the Victoria's Secret job." Pascau, who likes high-profile men, also used to bed down with
Formula I driver Eddie Irvine. Ratner's rep did not return calls.
YOU can't watch Arthur Chi'en on WCBS/Ch. 2 any more - the reporter was fired last week for uttering the "f
word" on-air - but you can buy a plethora of products with his face on it. Cafepress.com is hawking a line of
Chi'en-branded mugs, T-shirts, buttons, tote bags, messenger bags, barbecue aprons, teddy bears and even a
"Chi'en Classic Thong." Some are emblazoned with the words, "What the [bleep] is your problem, man?" - the
question Chi'en, who thought he was off the air, yelled out to twohecklers. David Yee, who is selling the Chi'en
merchandise, said he was inspired by the popular T-shirts of revolutionary Che Guevara. "Chi'en sort of sounds
like Che," he explained. "People are buying it." Meanwhile, Chi'en's friend Ian Gerard, the founder of Gen Art,
has circulated an e-mail calling the firing "ridiculous," and urging recipients to complain to various Viacom and
Channel 2 executives. Chi'en tells us he was "devastated" by his dismissal, and says he's currently looking for a
new job. "I've got bigger things to worry about than the shirts, basically," he said.
Full Text (1671 words)
(Copyright 2005, The New York Post. Al! Rights Reserved)
YOUNG Hollywood can rest easier now that police have arrested the man suspected of committing a string of
burglaries in the Beverly Hills and Bel Air area.
Darnell Riley, 28, was officially busted two months ago in connection with a burglary/robbery at "Girls Gone
Wild" gazillionaire Joe Francis' home in January 2004 - but he's also being investigated for break-ins at the
homes of Paris Hilton, baby oil heiress Casey Johnson, club promoter Tommy Alastra and other L.A. celebs.
A source said the crime ring used a gorgeous Elite model, still at large, to infiltrate the Hollywood party scene:
"She would befriend the men, get the security codes to their homes and then send Riley in."
Just before the 2004 Golden Globes, Francis returned to his Bel Air home as it was being robbed. The intruder
Francis recently identified as Riley held him at gunpoint and stole $300,000 in cash and valuables.
Sources added that Francis was "being blackmailed." Francis would only say, "I can confirm I was robbed at
gunpoint."
When Hilton's home was burgled in September of 2004, it looked eerily similar to the Francis break-in.
At the time, Hilton spokesman Elliot Mintz confirmed that a "very, very professional" gang swiped more than
$100,000 worth of jewelry, cash, video tapes and other items from the Hollywood Hills house Paris was renting
with her sister, Nicky.
After the burglary, more Hilton sex tapes mysteriously appeared, and damaging reports surfaced of a tape
where Hilton supposedly used the "n-word."
Insiders say Hilton paid dearly to make sure the tape was never found. A source said, "She was blackmailed.
She paid $20,000 a month to have that tape not released." Hilton told PAGE SIX via her rep, "Anyone who
http://pqasb.pgarchiver.com/nypost/844991031.html?MAC=b1d21f354a3eec5270f91258... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 2 of 4
blackmails should be prosecuted to the full extent of the law."
Hollywood insiders say Frankie Muniz and Wes Anderson may also have been burglarized, but their reps deny
it. Steve Coleman, a Los Angeles police officer who worked the case, told PAGE SIX: "Darnell Riley is in
custody and charged with burglary, robbery, and home invasion. This is an ongoing investigation."
Asked if the cops were looking into whether or not Riley had pulled the heists at the homes of Hilton, Johnson
and the others, Coleman said, "That's fair to say."
Wacky lackeys
AND you thought P. Diddy forcing Farnsworth Bentley to hold his umbrella was bad? Mariah Carey retains a
"petite Colombian woman" whose duties include "keeping Mariah's long skirts from touching the floor and
humping around a Louis Vuitton backpack filled with bottled water," reports Stuff magazine. Nelly keeps a
"personal jewelry jockey" to ensure the safekeeping of all his carat- encrusted thing. Ludacris has a minion
whose sole role is to make sure his boss' Gameboy is always loaded with fresh batteries. And rapper N.O.R.E.
has a hype man, Ching Bing, who has just one job: to stand onstage and swing around a towel.
We hear . . .
THAT Eva Longoria - milking her man-eating "Desperate Housewives" image to the max - has taped a spot for
Sirius Satellite Radio where she huskily pants: "Some women have to guess what a man wants, but I know what
a man really wants, something that will keep a smile on his face for a really long time - over 120 channels,
enough to satisfy any man" . . . THAT a visitor to Japan - where extreme modesty and close quarters prevail -
reports that new public toilets have an unusual feature, the Flush Noise button, so that you can conceal the
sound of actual bathroom functions with an artificial flushing noise.
Sightings
DALLAS Cowboys owner Jerry Jones and Washington Redskins owner Dan Snyder powwowing at Caf Milano .
. . BEN Affleck sitting front row at the Red Sox-Blue Jays game in Toronto, then getting mobbed for photos
before escaping through the Sox dugout . . . TRACY Morgan lifting up his shirt a la his character in "The Longest
Yard" to do a striptease for Burt Reynolds, Adam Sandler and Chris Rock at their movie premiere after-party at
Plus, the new lounge in Chelsea . . . HARRY Shearer dedicating his song, "82 Facelifts," to Barbara Walters
during a performance at the Cutting Room.
Romanian babe scores rock
NOW that his romance with Serena Williams has gone south, randy director Brett Rather seems to be settling
down with his former gal pal. Model Alina Pascau has been flashing a massive canary-yellow diamond
engagement ring Rather recently gave her, we're told. Pascau, a Romanian stunner, used to date reclusive
billionaire Jeffrey Epstein. Epstein, who handles Leslie Wexner's fortune, helped land her a gig modeling for
Wexner's Victoria's Secret brand, wehear, and paid for her to live in high style. After they broke up she and
Ratner dated for a while before his fling with Williams. "She's beautiful, but dumb as paint," one pal of Pascau
told us. "She never washes her hair and she always has a cellphone glued to her ear. Without Jeffrey she would
never have gotten the Victoria's Secret job." Pascau, who likes high-profile men, also used to bed down with
Formula I driver Eddie Irvine. Ratner's rep did not return calls.
Publicity-hungry
A ROMAN restaurateur is trying to exploit a near-miss with Bill Clinton, who recently canceled a dinner for 18 at
the fashionable Agata e Romeo eatery. Owner Romeo Caraccio is whining to the press that Clinton's people
ordered nearly $2,000 of special food and wines but never canceled, leaving him to take a loss. But his tale is
baloney, says Clinton rep Jim Kennedy. "An advance person made a reservation, canceled it, and compensated
the restaurant for it," Kennedy said. He quipped, "A restaurant trying to get publicity out of a canceled
reservation? I'm shocked."
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/844991031.html?MAC=b1d21f354a3eec5270f91258... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 3 of 4
Protein power
HOW did Shaquille O'Neal prepare for last night's Game 2 of the NBA Eastern Finals pitting his Miami Heat
against the Detroit Pistons? By devouring a 48-oz. porterhouse ($76) at South Beach's trendiest steakhouse,
Prime 112, the night before. The 7-foot-1, 320- lb. center joined fellow carnivores Jamie Foxx and TNT analyst
Charles Barkley, who as usual was trashing the Knicks. There's one menu item Shaq steers clear of - the $20
"Kobe Hot Dog."
Keepin' it real
IS life imitating art? Blond bombshell Katheryn Winnick, who was so good as Ivana Trump in Tuesday night's
"Trump Unauthorized" on ABC, must have liked her brush with real estate fame. The Post's Lois Weiss reports
the actress was seen canoodling with one of the city's top real estate investment-sale brokers, Douglas Harmon
of Eastdil, Tuesday afternoon, before she got into a black Lincoln in front of 40 W. 57th St., the building where
Harmon is headquartered.
Paris burger ad not for kids?
PARIS Hilton is too hot for Washington. Lawmakers are working behind the scenes to get her sizzling IV ad for
eatery chain Carl's Jr. - in which she writhes half-naked on a Bentley, cavorts with a garden hose and sucks her
finger - banished to late night. Sources say several influential pols have quietly told networks the commercial,
labeled "basically soft-core porn" by the Parents Television Council, isn't fit for children and shouldn't air before
10 p.m. The eye-popping ad, in which Paris looks like she's getting ready for her next Rick Solomon, is great
publicity for Cad's Jr., which hired the hotel hottie to hawk its new Spicy Burger. The fast- food firm's official
response to those who are seeing red? "Get a life."
Sudden dash
DAMON Dash, with gorgeous wife Rachel Roy in tow, basked in the glory of receiving an AAFA American Image
Award from Kevin Bacon at the Grand Hyatt, but dashed out without offering a donation to the event's charity
partner, the Alzheimer's Association. The hip-hop mogul was apparently the only honoree who didn't donate to
the event. Dash's publicist told us he did make a donation - but nobody connected to the event was aware of it.
Axed reporter branded
YOU can't watch Arthur Chi'en on WCBS/Ch. 2 any more - the reporter was fired last week for uttering the "f
word" on-air - but you can buy a plethora of products with his face on it. Cafepress.com is hawking a line of
Chi'en-branded mugs, T-shirts, buttons, tote bags, messenger bags, barbecue aprons, teddy bears and even a
"Chi'en Classic Thong." Some are emblazoned with the words, "What the [bleep) is your problem, man?" - the
question Chi'en, who thought he was off the air, yelled out to twohecklers. David Yee, who is selling the Chi'en
merchandise, said he was inspired by the popular T-shirts of revolutionary Che Guevara. "Chi'en sort of sounds
like Che," he explained. "People are buying it." Meanwhile, Chi'en's friend Ian Gerard, the founder of Gen Art,
has circulated an e-mail calling the firing "ridiculous," and urging recipients to complain to various Viacom and
Channel 2 executives. Chi'en tells us he was "devastated" by his dismissal, and says he's currently looking for a
new job. "I've got bigger things to worry about than the shirts, basically," he said.
Call to mouths
KELLY Osboume thinks her Hollywood friends are too thin. "Sure they're beautiful in photographs. But when you
see them in person, they look hungry and miserable," she tells Teen Vogue. "I hate to name names, so I'm not
going to, but there's one in particular I think of often. I saw her last summer and remember thinking, 'You're so
beautiful, you're at the most perfect weight.' And then I ran into her in the winter and she literally looked near
death. I was like, 'What are you doing to yourself? You're 18 years old.'" Interestingly, the magazine's June/July
issue features shrunken Lindsay Lohan on the cover.
[Illustration]
-Shaquille O'Neal; Katheryn Winnick -IN A CONTROVERSIAL TV SPOT, PARIS HILTON REWARDS
http://pciasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/844991031.html?MAC=b1d21f354a3eec5270f91258... 11/30/2005
f.rehives: New York Post Page 4 of 4
. •
HERSELF AFTER WASHING A BENTLEY IN HER SKIMPY SWIMSUIT. [Jeff Vespa / Wrelmage] -LATINA
LOVELY THALIA CHANNELS ELVIS PRESLEY AS SHE SHOOTS HER NEW VIDEO FOR "AMAR SIN SER
AMADA" IN BROOKLYN. [Sara Jaye Weiss]
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
Companies: Miami Heat (NAICS: 711211, Sic:7941 )
Section: Page Six
Text Word Count 1671
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/844991031.html?MAC=b1d21f354a3eec5270f91258... 11/30/2005
RADAR COMEBACK - ROSHAN GETS BIG-TIME BACKERS WITH BANKROLL
KEITH KELLY. New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Oct 19, 2004. pg. 037
People: Roshan, Maer, Zuckerman, Mort, Epstein, Jeffrey
Companies: Radar Media LLP
Section: Business .
Text Word Count 484
„Document URL:
4.(astalt akeloTegg 2u! aril)
Maer Roshan's Radar magazine is making another comeback - this time with backers who may be
willing to bankroll him with millions.
Roshan had tried to get [Mort Zuckerman) and company to back Radar after the New. York bid fell
apart, but at first nothing came of the talks.
"That deal just didn't work out on terms that were acceptable to us," said Doug Hand, ...
• Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 2
RADAR COMEBACK - ROSHAN GETS BIG-TIME BACKERS WITH BANKROLL
KEITH J. KELLY. New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Oct 19, 2004. pg. 037
Abstract (Document Summary)
Maer Roshan's Radar magazine is making another comeback - this time with backers who may be willing to bankroll him with
millions.
Roshan had tried to get [Mort Zuckerman] and company to back Radar after the New York bid fell apart, but at first 
nothing came of the talks.
"That deal just didn't work out on terms that were acceptable to us," said Doug Hand, an attorney who handled the 
negotiations with Zuckerman and [Jeffrey
Epstein] on Roshan's behalf.
Full Text (484 words)
(Copyright 2004, The New York Post. All Rights Reserved)
Maer Roshan's Radar magazine is making another comeback - this time with backers who may be willing to bankroll him with
millions.
How many millions is open to debate.
Mort Zuckerman, owner of the Daily News and U.S. News & World Report, has teamed with Jeffrey Epstein as the primary 
backers of a new and improved Radar, set to
launch as a monthly in April 2005.
Radar put out only two issues before it ran out of money last year, with the third issue stranded on the drawing board.
"It's not a Daily News or a U.S. News publication," said Roshan. "It's a new publishing company."
Radar Media LLP, the previous company, is selling assets only to the new company.
The old company will be dissolved and there is already a dispute as to how the money will be divvied up among the still 
unpaid creditors, which includes
freelancers.
"I don't know if it will be possible to pay everyone in full," said Michael North, the attorney handling the 
dissolution.
But Roshan insisted, "There is no reason to assume they won't be paid."
It's not the first time that Roshan has talked with Zuckerman about a magazine venture.
Zuckerman, Epstein and a collection of media heavyweights that included Harvey Weinstein, Nelson Pelt and media critic 
Michael Wolff had tried to buy New York
magazine but lost out to Bruce Wasserstein at the eleventh hour.
Roshan was being talked about as a potential editor in chief.
Roshan had tried to get Zuckerman and company to back Radar after the New York bid fell apart, but at first nothing came
of the talks.
Roshan next turned to a French Moroccon businesswoman, Maria Drain, but after a brief flurry of publicity, she faded.
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/716729581.html?MAC=b465a1b44f88a88e53d9c38c... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 2 of 2
"That deal just didn't work out on terms that were acceptable to us," said Doug Hand, an attorney who handled
the negotiations with Zuckerman and Epstein on Roshan's behalf.
How much is committed this time is open to speculation.
One source said that it would take a miniumum of $20 million to launch a magazine but more realistically, it
would take several times that over a five or six year period.
Talk magazine, where Roshan was deputy editor near the end of its run, cost its joint venture partners Miramax
and Hearst about $55 million before it shut down in early 2002 after nearly two and a half years of publication.
"I can't tell you the commitment," said Hand of the new backers. "It's significant and we're happy with it."
Said Roshan, "Just because we have backers, doesn't mean we're going to turn into Talk. We're still going to be
lean. We'll have the funding to do what we like, but I'm not interested in town cars."
He said he hopes to have about a half million in circulation eventually for the new Radar.
[Illustration]
-MAER ROSHAN Patience pays off. -MORT ZUCKERMAN Ponies up $$.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
People: Roshan, Maer, Zuckerman, Mort, Epstein, Jeffrey
Companies: Radar Media LLP
Section: Business
Text Word Count 484
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/716729581.html?MAC=b465a1b44f88a88e53d9c38c... 11/30/2005
• Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 3
RADAR HITS RELAUNCH TARGET - PARTY HIGHLIGHT: GAWKER'S
DENTON GETS PIE IN EYE
Keith J. Kelly. New York Post. New York, N.Y.: May 20, 2005. pg. 034
Abstract (Document Summary)
CONTROVERSY flared at the Radar launch party when [GAVVKER] founder Nick Denton was hit with a creamy
gooey pie as he sidled up next to magazine founder Maer Roshan for a photo op.
Denton then promptly dumped his glass of red wine on Roshan's head. Roshan professed to be as surprised as
anyone (and in fact was one of several bystanders hit with splatter from the Unknown Pie Guy). They later
retreated to Roshan's hotel suite, Roshan changed clothes and even let Denton shower.
SMASHED: Gawker's Nick Denton smiles after getting pied at the Radar relaunch party. Maer Roshan (top,
right), the mag's founder, was nearby. [Suzanne Boyd], Suede editor before it folded, was also at the soiree.
[VVirelmage, Marina Gamier]
Full Text (876 words)
(Copyright 2005, The New York Post. All Rights Reserved)
CONTROVERSY flared at the Radar launch party when Gawker founder Nick Denton was hit with a creamy
gooey pie as he sidled up next to magazine founder Maer Roshan for a photo op.
Gawker, a media-centric Web site which for weeks has had been needling Radar and its self promoting founder,
sarcastically calling it, "Radar, the Greatest American Magazine Launch."
The photo op was seen as a chance to make nice between Roshan and Denton to prove they were willing to let
bygones be bygones, blah, blah.
Then the peace accord was ruptured as a burly unknown person broke through the throng and smashed the
custard pie squarely into the face of Denton and dashed out, leaving no clue as to his identity. He was wearing
an English-soccer style shirt and a New York Knicks hat.
Denton, his face and clothes a mess from the ambush, assumed he had been set up by Roshan. (In an early
version of the event that he posted on his own Web site, he insisted he had only been hit with a glancing blow
from the pie tosser, but had to retract that version when photos turned up).
Denton then promptly dumped his glass of red wine on Roshan's head. Roshan professed to be as surprised as
anyone (and in fact was one of several bystanders hit with splatter from the Unknown Pie Guy). They later
retreated to Roshan's hotel suite, Roshan changed clothes and even let Denton shower.
He also rummaged around and found a T-shirt and pants for Denton to wear for the rest of the night.
Denton, despite the good turn done by Roshan still feels it was a set-up by event planner Nadine Johnson.
"It is pretty clear it was one of Nadine Johnson's hires," said Denton. "It was nicely staged, but the execution left
a lot to be desired since Maer was hit too."
"What baffles me is why they would want their launch event hijacked by that kind of publicity?" asked Denton. "I
heard Mort Zuckerman slipped in the goo," said Denton.
"He had to have the whole thing explained to him, including what a blog is."
Daily Snooze owner Zuckerman and billionaire financier Jeffrey Epstein were both on hand, but were out of
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/842504731.html?MAC=7bce35a1ce53b22e38507a31... 11/30/2005
• Archives: New York Post Page 2 of 3
range when the pie started flying. The two billionaires are 50-50 partners in the venture.
Drew Kerr, a spokesman for Roshan, and the party planner, both deny that it was a Radar plant.
"No one was hired by anyone to throw a pie," said a spokesperson for Johnson.
On the business side, William Holiber, the president of U.S. News & World Report, which is also owned by
Zuckerman, was on hand.
Media Ink on April 8 reported that he had been drafted into action when launch publisher Linda Sepp, a
Zuckerman pal, was given the boot weeks before the launch.
At the time, a Zuckerman spokesman was insisting that Holiber was only helping out on Radar in an "informal
and advisory role" and had no official title on Radar.
But when the debut issues were handed out, there was Holiber, proudly pointing out his designation as Radar's
president.
Sepp was nowhere in sight at the party or on the masthead but a former Sports Illustrated associate publisher,
Grayle Howlett was, handing out his very own Radar publisher card.
Also on hand was Suzanne Boyd, who was the editor-in-chief of Time Inc.'s short-lived urban-fashion magazine
Suede.
She quit the publishing company and took a buyout on the remaining year of her two-year contract rather than
accept a position as an editor-at-large in magazine development.
That move is considered a blow to Time Inc. A company spokesman confirmed that she had declined the
company offer.
The statuesque fashion editor had been running Flare, the Toronto- based fashion bible of Canada for 7 years
when she was picked by Ed Lewis, then the head of Essence Communications, and Isolde Motley, the corporate
editor of Time, to launch Suede, which was envisioned as a hot new fashion magazine for women of color.
Boyd arrived in March of last year and cranked out the first issue by the end of the summer - considered a
breakneck pace in magazine land.
As the launch was progressing, Time was in the process of negotiating to convert Essence Communications into
a 100 percent- owned subsidiary by buying out Lewis.
Suddenly, in the weeks before the buyout was finalized, a stunned Boyd got the word that the plug was being
pulled on the new magazine after publishing only two issues.
In its public announcement, Time Inc. had insisted that it was only suspended, but the staff was let go.
Now Boyd, the last link, has quit the company and is weighing her options.
Insiders believed that Time Inc. was disappointed by the costs and the lower-than-hoped-for newsstand sales of
the first two issues.
Industry sources say the biggest obstacle to Suede's funding may have been the losses that Life magazine was
piling up as a weekly insert into daily newspapers.
[Illustration]
SMASHED: Gawker's Nick Denton smiles after getting pied at the Radar relaunch party. Maer Roshan (top,
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/842504731.html?MAC=7bce35alce53b22e38507a31... 11/30/2005
• • Archives: New York Post Page 3 of 3
right), the mag's founder, was nearby. Suzanne Boyd, Suede editor before it folded, was also at the soiree.
[Wirelmage, Marina Gamier]
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
Companies: Time Inc(Ticker.TL, NAICS: 511120, Duns:00-121-3446 )
Section: Business
Text Word Count 876
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/842504731.html?MAC=7bce35alce53b22e38507a31... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 4
SINGLING OUT APPLE'S TOP STUDS
Richard Johnson. New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Dec 28, 2003. pg. 012
Abstract (Document Summary)
ANDRE BALAZS, 46. The ever-smiling hotelier - who owns The Mercer in Soho, Chateau Marmont and the
Standard in L.A., the Raleigh in Miami, Sunset Beach on Shelter lasland, and a new place in St. Barts -just split
from his wife Katie Ford. Pro: Recently was reported skinny-dipping. Con: Seems to be giving Uma Thurman
more than his shoulder to cry on.
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, 50. Mystery billionaire was a math teacher at Dalton just a few years ago. Then he started
handling Leslie Wexner's money. Now he lives in Manhattan's biggest mansion. Pro: Has a private plane which
he used to take Bill Clinton to Africa. Con: Was one of Mort Zuckerman's partners in failed attempt to buy New
York magazine. CHRIS BARISH, 30. The son of Planet Hollywood tycoon and movie producer Keith Barish
recently sold out his interest in three Las Vegas nightclubs to Kirk Kerkorian for $10 million. Pro: You'll never
have to wait on line or pay for a drink at Marquee, his new club. Con: You might never get to sleep before 3 a.m.
JIMMY RODRIGUEZ, 41. Since dropping out of high school, he's built a four-restaurant empire with eateries in
the Bronx, Harlem, Sutton Place and City Island. Pro: Is pals with hip-hop stars, Yankees and Knicks. Con: Is
pals with hip-hop stars, Yankees and Knicks.
Full Text (1905 words)
(Copyright 2003, The New York Post. All Rights Reserved)
New York has the smartest, toughest, most ambitious men in the world, and some of them are still single - or
newly single, having gotten divorced. We went through our multiple data bases, interviewed the experts, polled
our readers, and came up with this definitive PAGE SIX list of the city's most eligible guys.
They come from all sorts of backgrounds and generations, with different talents and widely divergent incomes.
The only thing they have in common is they like women.
We rejected some men because they seem to be in long-term romances heading toward marriage, others
because it seems they'll never marry. To the many men who think they belong on the list, there's always next
year.
DEREK JETER, 29. The Yankee shortstop's sex-symbol status has only grown since he was stalked by Mariah
Carey, and mocked in American Express ads for his propensity to party. Pro: Great seats for the World Series.
Con: Demands near-perfection - at least visually - in his dates.
ED SKYLER, 30. Tall, dark, super-serious mayoral press secretary went to Collegiate, then the University of
Pennsylvania. His sister is a successful playwright. Pro: He can give you a private tour of City Hall and Gracie
Mansion. Con: A romantic evening would end early bcause Skyler works 18 hours a day, starting before dawn.
JOHN UTENDAHL, 46. He's 6-foot-3, with movie star looks - and he is chairman and CEO of Utendahl Capital
Partners, the largest minority-owned investment bank in America. Pro: Plenty of closet space in his Brooklyn
Heights townhouse and his weekend place in Quogue. Con: Plan on being a golf widow - he runs a charity
tournament every year in Boca Raton, Fla.
JEREMY SHOCKEY, 23. The Giants' tight end became a fan favorite with his first tackle-breaking game. Now
he's the biggest local gridiron personality since Joe "Willie" Namath. Pro: Quite single despite his friendship with
babelicious Britny Gastineau. Con: His big mouth often misfires, as when he blasted Giants fans because they
had the nerve to boo him and his disappointing teammates.
ANDRE BALAZS, 46. The ever-smiling hotelier-who owns The Mercer in Soho, Chateau Marmont and the
Standard in L.A., the Raleigh in Miami, Sunset Beach on Shelter lasland, and a new place in St. Barts -just split
from his wife Katie Ford. Pro: Recently was reported skinny-dipping. Con: Seems to be giving Uma Thurman
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/519943651.html?MAC=dd6e0556b501381b7046b79... 11/30/2005
Aichives: New York Post Page 2 of 4
more than his shoulder to cry on.
ETHAN HAWKE, 33. The adulterer/actor finally shed his pretty-boy image this summer, brazenly cheating on
wife Uma Thurman. Pro: Plenty of women would like a shot at taming this rogue bull. Con: Might guilt you into
reading one of his weak novels.
ROCCO DiSPIRITO, 37. The dashing owner of Union Pacific and star of his own reality show has cooked for
just about every hip hottie in town. Pro: He might be ready to settle down in the next few years (Yeah, right).
Con: If you haven't already dated him, one of your friends has.
ANDRE 3000, 28. With this year's smash hit "Hey Ya," the fun half of hip-hop duo Outkast has gone from cult
figure to mainstream superstar. Pro: His minimalist posse includes as few as four members. Con: Recently
moved to Brooklyn and might not realize that only the lamest of the lame frequent Williamsburg nightspots.
PHARRELL1A/ILLIAMS, 30. Pop production whiz's maddeningly catchy beats legitimized Justin Timberlake, and
cameos of his Curtis Mayfield-like falsetto are becoming ubiquitous on hits by Jay-Z and others. Pro: Makes
more than you do in a year to tweak a Britney Spears song. Con: Approaching a P. Diddy-like level of
oxerexposure.
JIMMY FALLON, 29. We don't know if it's his cuddly demeanor or uncanny impersonation skills, but the resident
hunk on "Saturday Night Live" is catnip to the ladies. Pro: Likes to play the jukebox at Hell's Kitchen dive bars.
Con: If he stays over your house, make sure to have extra hair product for his artfully mussed 'do.
DAMON DASH, 32. Brash CEO of Rocawear clothing line and Roc-a- Fella Records also owns a film company,
vodka line, nightclub, and he's undoubtedly planning a new project as you read this. Pro: One of the city's
reigning rapresarios. Con: Is prone to obnoxious harangues against his underlings or those who question his
importance.
JULIAN CASABLANCAS, 25. Doe-eyed son of Elite Models founder John Casablancas sings for hot rock band
The Strokes. Pro: His band is actually good. Con: Wears "ironic" 1980s concert T-shirts by Def Lepard and
Michael Jackson.
SHEPHERD SMITH, 39. Next to the blustery Bill O'Reilly, this Southern-fried anchorman is probably the most
recognizable face on the top-rated Fox News Channel. Pro: His sprawling Lower East Side pad has a pool table.
Con: A road rager who was arrested in 2000 for hitting a reporter with his car in a dispute over a parking space
in Tallahassee, Fla.
PAOLO ZAMPOLLI, 33. Italian owner of ID Models can usually be found sitting in a corner banquette of
whatever club just opened surrounded by a bevy of beauties. Pro: Throws great parties in his downtown loft.
Con: If you're not 5-foot-11 with cheekbones that cut glass, he probably won't remember your name.
ADRIEN BRODY, 30. Haunted-looking actor famously kissed Halle Berry while accepting his Oscar for "The
Pianist." Pro: Makes moody trip-hop music under the alias, "A. Ranger." Con: Is serious with girlfriend Michelle
Dupont, a music-industry personal assistant.
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, 50. Mystery billionaire was a math teacher at Dalton just a few years ago. Then he started
handling Leslie Wexner's money. Now he lives in Manhattan's biggest mansion. Pro: Has a private plane which
he used to take Bill Clinton to Africa. Con: Was one of Mort Zuckerman's partners in failed attempt to buy New
York magazine. CHRIS BARISH, 30. The son of Planet Hollywood tycoon and movie producer Keith Barish
recently sold out his interest in three Las Vegas nightclubs to Kirk Kerkorian for $10 million. Pro: You'll never
have to wait on line or pay for a drink at Marquee, his new club. Con: You might never get to sleep before 3 a.m.
BILLY CRUDUP, 35. The hunky actor dumped Mary LouiseParker when she was 81/2 months pregnant and
ran off with Claire Danes, but that might not last too long either. Pro: Critics loved his performance in Tim
Burton's "Big Fish." Con: A true heart-breaker.
LENNY KRAVITZ, 39. The super-modelizer had a big hit with "Let Love Rule," but hasn't fallen in love himself
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/519943651.html?MAC=dd6e0556b501381b7046b79... 11/30/2005
' isichives: New York Post Page 3 of 4
since the end of his marriage to Lisa Bonet that produced a daughter, Zoe, 15. Pro: Has a beautiful loft
downtown he rented to Nicole Kidman, who then statrted dating him. Con: The funky fashions make him seem
narcissistic.
DONALD TRUMP JR., 25. The first-born son of The Donald and his first wife Ivana is following in his fathers
footsteps, not only developing buildings, but taking center stage to sell the apartments. Pro: Weekend flights
down to Mar-a-lago on the family jet. Con: his dad, who owns Miss Universe, has extremely high standards
when it comes to the female form.
CHRIS HEINZ, 30. The billionaire ketchup heir has captured the attention of many Manhattanites, including
Gwyneth Paltrow (pre- Chris Martin). Pro: Tall, dark and handsome, he even has a sense of humor. Con: Likes
lost causes - he quit his banking job to work for his stepfather John Kerry's foundering campaign.
JONATHAN TISCH, 50. The charming Loews hotel chain chairman is a regular on the social and charity circuit.
Back on the market and looking for a date after breaking off his wedding to Jill Swid. Pro: Has deep pockets and
hotels in every port. Con: Notoriously marriage- phobic.
ANDREW CUOMO, 46. After a nasty split with his wife Kerry Kennedy, the failed gubernatorial candidate has
been quietly dating again. Pro: He's capable and articulate and has nowhere to go but up from here. Con:
Sometimes comes off as arrogant and self-absorbed.
CHARLES ROCKEFELLER, 30. The tall, blond Rockefeller heir has got looks, money, and impeccable manners
and, duh! . . . he's a Rockefeller! Pro: Occasionally entertains at the dynastic estate, Pocantico Hills. Con: Is it
boyish charm, or just boyish?
MARCUS SAMUELSSON, 33. The studly chef/owner of Aquavit - who once made People magazine's Sexiest
list - has a new eatery, Riingo, in the new Alex Hotel. Pro: He cooks and does dishes! Con: All chefs keep late
hours, and they fraternize after hours with the waitresses.
JONATHAN KRAMER, 29. Grungy artist has been making a living out of painting since he was in college. Not
new to the spotlight (he did date Sophie Dahl), Kramer can be found frequenting Rene Risque concerts. Pro: Is
good company and may offer to paint you. Con: Likes to travel around town on a skateboard - with no sidecar for
a date.
DAN ABRAMS, 36. The MSNBC newsdude, the son of legendary First Amendment lawyer Floyd Abrams, is one
of the few talking heads smart enough to cover legal issues. Pro: Your mother will love him. Con: MSNBC
ratings are so low, no one gets to see him.
JAMIE JOHNSON, 23. The Johnson & Johnson heir burst onto the scene last year at Sundance with his
documentary "Born Rich," which showed the pathetic underbelly of his - and his pals' - "blessed" lives. Pro: The
kid's got talent! Con: He sold out his friends, and that nasal voice could cut glass.
ROFFREDO GAETANI, 50. The strapping former boxer is an Italian count distantly related to a pope. He was a
close friend of late Fiat chairman Gianni Agnelli, who set Roffredo up with Ferrari dealerships. Pro: The old world
charm is such that he kisses women's hands. Con: Has been very busy, especially with models. Ivana Trump
was just his most famous conquest.
REP. ANTHONY WEINER, 38. The Brooklyn Democrat is ambitious and hard-working, and had the good sense
to hire the extremely capable Serena Torrey as one of his aides. Pro: Being touted as a possible candidate for
mayor. Con: Could be cruelly described as a pencil- necked geek.
ERIC VILLENCY, 28. Dashing president and creative director of Maurice Villency, a chain of furniture stores
founded by his grandfather in 1932. Pro: He sponsors fashion designers so he gets front-row seats to all the
shows. Con: Seems serious with his girlfriend of over a year, gorgeous Olivia Chantecaille.
ADAM CLAYTON POWELL, 41. The state assemblyman resembles his legendary father, the congressman for
whom a boulevard in Harlem is named. His mother was a famous beauty in Puerto Rico, where young Adam
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/519943651.html?MAC=dd6e0556b501381b7046b79... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post 4 Page 4 of 4
grew up. He plans someday to oust his nemesis, Rep. Charlie Rangel, and take over his seat. Pro: Has a yacht
at City Island where he entertains bikini babes. Con: Has a tendency to back losers.
FREDERIC FEKKAI, 44. Handsome French haircutter has charmed the pants off Libet Johnson, Patricia Duff
and other blondes too numerous to mention. Meanwhile, he's been branding his name and marketing hair care
products. Pro: You'll never have a bad hair day. Con: He might be a bit spoiled. One rich girlfriend supposedly
gave him a Gulfstream jet, and it wasn't even Christmas.
JIMMY RODRIGUEZ, 41. Since dropping out of high school, he's built a four-restaurant empire with eateries in
the Bronx, Harlem, Sutton Place and City Island. Pro: Is pals with hip-hop stars, Yankees and Knicks. Con: Is
pals with hip-hop stars, Yankees and Knicks.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
Companies: Apple Computer Inc(Ticker:AAPL, NAICS: 334111, Duns:06-070-4780 )
Section: Page Six
Text Word Count 1905
Document URL:
http://pgasb.pgarehiver.com/nypost/519943651.html?MAC=dd6e0556b50138167046b79... 11/30/2005
THE TITLE FIGHT: NEW YORK - THE MAGAZINE, THAT IS - AWAITS NEW OWNER
KEITH KELLY. New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Dec 14, 2003. pg. 031
People: Kravis, Henry, Deutsch, Donny, Weinstein, Harvey, Wolff, Michael, Zuckerman,
Mort
Section: Business
Text Word 441
Count
Document URL:
BIDDER: David Pecker's American Media BIDDER: Investor group of U.S. News and World
Report boss Mort Zuckerman, Miramax co-Chairman [Harvey Weinstein], Cablevision CEO Jimmy
Dolan, bigtime adman [Donny Deutsch] and New York Columnist [Michael Wolff].
The editing question has mostly centered on the Zuckerman team. Since Wolff bought in Deutsch and
[Jeffrey Epstein], the New York mag columnist undoubtedly expects to be picked as some ...
' Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 2
THE TITLE FIGHT: NEW YORK - THE MAGAZINE, THAT IS - AWAITS NEW
OWNER
KEITH J. KELLY. New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Dec 14, 2003. pg. 031
Abstract (Document Summary)
BIDDER: David Pecker's American Media BIDDER: Investor group of U.S. News and World Report boss Mort
Zuckerman, Miramax co-Chairman [Harvey Weinstein], Cablevision CEO Jimmy Dolan, bigtime adman [Donny
Deutsch] and New York Columnist [Michael Wolff].
The editing question has mostly centered on the Zuckerman team. Since Wolff bought in Deutsch and [Jeffrey
Epstein], the New York mag columnist undoubtedly expects to be picked as some kind of editorial uber boss.
Weinstein is in the coalition but is still smarting over the drubbing he took in Wolff s book, "Autumn of the
Moguls."
Full Text (441 words)
(Copyright 2003, The New York Post. All Rights Reserved)
In the weeks to come, the city's chattering classes will be consumed with handicapping who'll be editor-in-chief
of New York magazine after Henry Kravis and Primedia get through selling it.
Nobody was talking officially last week, pending a deal as final bids arrived Thursday. The consensus is the
highest offer is for about $55 million - coming from a motley team of millionaires and billionaires around Mort
Zuckerman.
The coalition includes: Zuckerman, the owner of the Daily News and U.S. News & World Report; billionaire
financier Nelson Pet; mysterious money manager Jeffrey Epstein; ad executive Donny Deutsch, Miramax co-
chairman Harvey Weinstein; and non-cash contributors Michael Wolff of New York magazine and possibly Jim
Dolan, CEO of Cablevision.
The other two rival bidders are almost diametrically opposite: Bill Curtis' Curtco Media publishes super-upscale
glossies, The Robb Report and Worth. American Media publishes the downmarket supermarket tabloids
National Enquirer, Star and Globe, plus health and fitness magazines such as Men's Fitness and Shape.
"Whoever the editor is has to have a strong point of view," offers Clay Felker, who launched the magazine as an
independent weekly in 1967. It was not a particularly bright time in the city. But Felker and his young writers took
on the challenges, exposing the best and the worst of the city. "We believed the city was the imperial center of
the United States and possibly the world," he said.
The editing question has mostly centered on the Zuckerman team. Since Wolff bought in Deutsch and Epstein,
the New York mag columnist undoubtedly expects to be picked as some kind of editorial uber boss. Weinstein is
in the coalition but is still smarting over the drubbing he took in Wolff s book, "Autumn of the Moguls."
Weinstein is thought to favor Radar founder Maer Roshan as editor. New York Observer Editor Peter Kaplan's
name has surfaced - but he and Wolff have had a public feud.
A deal on the winning bid could be announced early next week. The announcement would probably be delayed
until after the annual New York Awards, being staged tomorrow at the Four Seasons.
The world has changed and the question now is: can the new owners regain that old glory - or will there be too
many sacred cows in the ownership mix?
As one observer asked as the Zuckerman coalition emerged as the favorite, "Who will be left to make fun of?"
Henry Kravis, watch out.
http://pqasb.pciarchiver.com/nypost/503203971.html?MAC=8562d59151d6ab55b4753a2... 11/30/2005
•
Archives: New York Post Page 2 of 2
[Illustration]
BIDDER: David Pecker's American Media BIDDER: Investor group of U.S. News and World Report boss Mort
Zuckerman, Miramax co-Chairman Harvey Weinstein, Cablevision CEO Jimmy Dolan, bigtime adman Donny
Deutsch and New York Columnist Michael Wolff.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
People: Kravis, Henry, Deutsch, Donny, Weinstein, Harvey, Wolff, Michael, Zuckerman, Mort
Section: Business
Text Word Count 441
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.comlnypost/503203971.html?MAC=8562d59151d6ab55b4753a2... 11/30/2005
Archives: New York Post Page 1 of 4
BILL, STARS ENJOY AFRICAN TREK
New York Post. New York, N.Y.: Sep 25, 2002. pg. 010
Abstract (Document Summary)
JASON Mewes is alive and well. Mewes, who played the long- haired, drug-loving "Jay" in Kevin Smith's
"Clerks," "Mali Rats," "Chasing Amy" and "Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back," was reportedly on the lam or even
feared dead after his friends told the Chicago Sun-Times they hadn't seen him in 10 months. An arrest warrant
had been issued for him after he violated probation on a heroin conviction. But last month, Mewes made an
appearance at a film festival in Malibu to promote his new indie movie "RSVP," and he'll host a talent show Oct.
17 at Marshall University in Huntington, W.Va. "The rumors of his death are greatly exaggerated," chuckled
Mewes' agent, Nancy Oeswein. "I just got off the phone with him. He's certainly not in hiding. He just moved to
L.A." For some folks, living on the Left Coast is as good as being dead.
IS Sen. John McCain going to quit the Republican Party and become the running mate of Sen. John Kerry in the
2004 presidential race? McCain's chief political adviser, John Weaver, has become a Democrat and is now
working for Dick Gephardt. McCain's new legislative director, Christine Dodd, last worked for a liberal
congressman - a Democrat. Now Kerry of Massachusetts, who has made clear his plans to run in 2004, is
making overtures towards McCain. A rumored head- to-head between Kerry and McCain is said to be scheduled
at McCain's cabin in Sedona, Ariz., next month. And for "Man of the People," the new McCain biography by Paul
Alexander, Kerry provided a blurb that reads more like a love letter. After noting that McCain's 2000 presidential
campaign "set the standard for honor, dignity, courage, and truth," Kerry declares: "I have had no greater
privilege in all my life than finding and then standing on common groundwith John McCain, and I look forward to
fighting side by side with him on yet another day to make our country stronger."
Full Text (1634 words)
(Copyright 2002, The New York Post. Al! Rights Reserved)
CALL it "The Three Amigos' Most Excellent African Adventure."
Former President Bill Clinton is on a trip through Ghana, Nigeria, Rwanda, Mozambique and South Africa with
Oscar-winning actor Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker, the star of "Rush Hour" and its sequel.
The three are being flown around Africa on the private plane of financial wizard Jeffrey Epstein. The secretive
Epstein handles the billions of Leslie Wexner, head of the retail empire that includes The Limited, Victoria's
Secret and Express.
How Clinton, who took off on Saturday, hooked up with his traveling companions is a mystery - as is his
relationship to Epstein. Little is known about Epstein except that his offices are in the landmarked Villard House
across from Le Cirque, and he once employed Ghislaine Maxwell, daughter of the late British press lord Robert
Maxwell, in an unspecified capacity.
But Tucker is playing America's first black president in "Mr. President," a movie he's been working on since
1999. Tucker has already shot footage of Clinton, Nelson Mandela, and Bahrain's crown prince endorsing his
candidacy, and the comic accompanied U2 frontman Bono and Treasury Secrtary Paul O'Neill on their debt-
relief tour of Africa this summer.
At the Congressional Black Caucus' annual awards dinner earlier this month, Clinton mentioned that Tucker had
asked to visit him in the Oval Office to prepare for playing the first black president.
"I didn't have the heart to tell him that I've already taken the position," Clinton joked. In an October 1998 essay in
The New Yorker, author Toni Morrison argued that Clinton, "white skin notwithstanding, [isj our first black
president."
Kevin Spacey has no presidential aspirations we know of. Last we heard, he wanted to portray Bobby Darin. He
might be bored during some parts of the trip.
http://pciasb.pqarchiver.corninypost/195152701.html?MAC=8282d8da105ae0258d6d213f... 11/30/2005
' Archives: New York Post Page 2 of 4
In Ghana, Clinton will launch a new initiative with Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto to give deeds and land
titles to poor people who now have no legal status and are considered squatters.
In South Africa, Clinton will deliver a speech and join Mandela in promoting prevention of AIDS. Clinton will also
meet in that country with the first class of Clinton Democracy Fellows -11 young South African men and women
who just completed three months in the U.S.
Clinton will also meet with the presidents of the other nations on his itinerary.
Perfect angel
THE producer of Tara Reid's latest flick says she's a perfect angel and that Us Weekly misquoted him as saying
that he and the bar- friendly hellcat "went out drinking all the time." J. Todd Harris, producer of "Heaven's Pond,"
blasts Us in a letter to the editor: "I specifically said that our working relationship with the actress was nothing
short of spectacular." He also shoots down the mag's source who claims Reid needed to have a baby sitter
escort her out every night tomake sure she didn't wake up with any regrets.
We hear . . .
THAT eyebrows are flexing over tonight's U.N. black-tie dinner honoring Muhammad Ali, Mayor Bloomberg and
Paul and Heather Mills McCartney. Seems Heather insists on being referred to as "Lady Heather Mills
McCartney" . . . THAT Steve Martin, Paul Morrissey, Glenda Bailey and Elizabeth Kieselstein-Cord attended last
night's 15th anniversary party of Modern Painters magazine at the Cheim and Read Gallery.
Headlines heal
SARAH Ferguson, the former Duchess of York, credits the media for keeping her weight down. Once dubbed
the "Duchess of Pork" by the British press, the now stunning and skinny Weight Watchers rep says every time
she thinks of pigging out, she remembers the old headlines. Among those she cited during an appearance at an
Albany Weight Watchers seminar, according to The Post's Kenneth Lovett: "Fat, Selfish, Greedy Fergie" and "82
Percent Would Rather Sleep With a Goat." "It does help me when I read articles that [say] the 'slim svelte
Fergie,' " Ferguson said. "I don't want them to have a go at me again. I'm tired of that."
Lost actor pops up in L.A.
JASON Mewes is alive and well. Mewes, who played the long- haired, drug-loving "Jay" in Kevin Smith's
"Clerks," "Mall Rats," "Chasing Amy" and "Jay and Silent Bob Strike Back," was reportedly on the lam or even
feared dead after his friends told the Chicago Sun-Times they hadn't seen him in 10 months. An arrest warrant
had been issued for him after he violated probation on a heroin conviction. But last month, Mewes made an
appearance at a film festival in Malibu to promote his new indie movie "RSVP," and he'll host a talent show Oct.
17 at Marshall University in Huntington, W.Va. "The rumors of his death are greatly exaggerated," chuckled
Mewes' agent, Nancy Oeswein. "I just got off the phone with him. He's certainly not in hiding. He just moved to
L.A." For some folks, living on the Left Coast is as good as being dead.
Sex sells
ABERCROMBIE & Fitch has outdone itself. The store chain's new "magalog," a catalog disguised as a
magazine, is even more salacious than past efforts, with a naked Heidi Klum on the cover - one hand hiding her
nipples, the other holding a Santa hat over a naked man's crotch. The tag line reads: "180 pages of sex and
Xmas fun! Heidi Klum adds inches, Spike Lee catches it on tape, Larry Flynt breaks tapes, Heidi Fleiss gets
what she wants, streetcorner Santa brawls and more!" One spy said: "There is a ton of bums and breasts inside.
Everyone is naked." The quarterly, targeted at teens and college students, will be featured on "Entertainment
Tonight" later this week.
Janney's' jam
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/195152701.html?MAC-8282d8da105ae0258d6d213f... 11/30/2005
• Archives: New York Post Page 3 of 4
THE ex-fianc of Emmy-winning "West Wing" star Allison Janney (above) is being evicted from her Central Park
West pad. Janney has been illegally subletting the rent-stabilized, $1,100- a-month apartment to former beau
Dennis Gagomiros, says Keith Rubenstein, a lawyer for landlord Michael Tauber. "We are starting the eviction
process," says Rubenstein, who estimated the "fair market" value of Janney's joint at $3,000 a month. Janney's
lawyer, Sam Himmelstein, insists Janney "surrendered possession" of her pad several weeks ago to the
landlord. "Her ex-fianc belives that he has the succession rights to the apartment, but she has nothing to do with
that," he said.
Flasher chic
WONDER why Stella McCartney never took her black satin coat off during the opening of her boutique last
Friday? She had nothing under it but a very sexy bra and satin knickers. The highlight of the afterparty at
Gaslight was Stella, Gwyneth Paltrow and Usher singing karaoke for the likes of Bono, Britney Spears, Liv Tyler,
Debbie Harry, Russell Simmons, Graydon Carter, Christy Tur lington, Karolina Kurkova, Helena Christensen and
others too fashionable to mention.
Dueling Dems
DON'T invite Ed Koch and Pete Grannis to the same political party. The former mayor has no use for the
assemblyman who has represented the Upper East Side for 28 years. The feud began with Koch's endorsement
of Andrew Eristoff, a Republican challenger for the State Senate seat currently occupied by Democrat Liz
Krueger. Grannis observed in community weekly Our Town: "Our former mayor seems to have a thing for
Republicans and an aversion to endorsing women of either party." Now Koch has responded in a letter to Our
Town to Grannis' "gutter attack" and "vile comments." Koch lists no fewer than 9 women he's endorsed for
election over the years, plus seven women he appointed to office, and concludes, "I am sure Grannis has
harbored thoughts of higher office, indeed ran for Congress and lost. I doubt that he will ever attain higher office,
and I truly believe he does not deserve the office he currently holds and has held for 28 years."
Single again
THIS year's ladies' man, Matthew Perry, is single again. After squiring around Amanda Peet, Jennifer Capriati
and a host of other hot young things this summer, the "Friends" star was on the prowl Sunday night. After losing
the Emmy to his co-star Matt LeBlanc, Perry and Hank Azaria showed up in fine spirits to the Glamour!
Entertainment Weekly post-Emmy party at the Mondrian in Los Angeles and flirted with a gaggle of girls. "He
was so excited he startedto sweat and had to massage his head," said our spy. Perry eventually left alone.
MCCAIN MUTINY IN WORKS?
IS Sen. John McCain going to quit the Republican Party and become the running mate of Sen. John Kerry in the
2004 presidential race? McCain's chief political adviser, John Weaver, has become a Democrat and is now
working for Dick Gephardt. McCain's new legislative director, Christine Dodd, last worked for a liberal
congressman - a Democrat. Now Kerry of Massachusetts, who has made clear his plans to run in 2004, is
making overtures towards McCain. A rumored head- to-head between Kerry and McCain is said to be scheduled
at McCain's cabin in Sedona, Ariz., next month. And for "Man of the People," the new McCain biography by Paul
Alexander, Kerry provided a blurb that reads more like a love letter. After noting that McCain's 2000 presidential
campaign "set the standard for honor, dignity, courage, and truth," Kerry declares: "I have had no greater
privilege in all my life than finding and then standing on common groundwith John McCain, and I look forward to
fighting side by side with him on yet another day to make our country stronger."
[Illustration]
-Allison Janney, Stella McCartney -Just call him David Cop-a-feel. Modelizing magician David Copperfield
seems to have cast his spell over two babealicious blondes. We caught Copperfield holding hands with Marilyn
Gurna (above), 21, an Estonian-born assistant manager at Nello's. Copperfield has been wooing the gorgeous
Gurna for a few weeks now, but it didn't stop him from stepping out with another squeeze (below) on Madison
Avenue just a week earlier. Lawrence Schwartzwald (above); Adam Nemser/PHOTOLink (below) [color] -
Matthew Perry. LFI [color]
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/195152701.html?MAC=8282d8da105ae0258d6d213f... 11/30/2005
' Archives: New York Post Page 4 of 4
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction or distribution is prohibited without
permission.
People: Clinton, Bill, Tucker, Chris, Epstein, Jeffrey, McCain, John, Kerry, John F
Section: Page Six
Text Word Count 1634
Document URL:
http://pqasb.pqarchiver.com/nypost/195152701.html?MAC=8282d8da105ae0258d6d2131.. 11/30/2005
' An Interview with Jeffrey Epstein Page 1 of 5
News & Commentary
by Judson Cox
An Interview with Jeffrey Epstein August 01, 2005 01:24 AM EST
NCC: Mr. Epstein, thank you for granting this interview. It is nice to put a
personality with the name I quoted so often during the 2004 campaign. I believe
your efforts were essential in stopping John Kerry from becoming president.
In my opinion, you and your fellow Veterans for Truth accomplished a great service
on behalf of our national security in that effort - now you are engaged in another
effort on behalf of our security.
Could you tell our readers a bit about your background, and remind us of your role
in the 2004 presidential election?
I'd like to begin by thanking you for this opportunity. In the autumn of 2003, I sold
my company which ended my twenty-one year mortgage banking career. I •
previously supervised residential lending, in the Tri-state area, for Great Western
Bank. I was promoted to SVP after initiating an FBI / OTS investigation that resulted
in the incarceration of an Attorney and several real estate professionals who
conspired to commit mortgage fraud.
I'm quite proud of my prior affiliation with Vietnam Vets for the Truth (VVT). Last
year, I directed media relations for the organization and was responsible for
breaking the story regarding John Kerry's photo adorning the hallway of the
communist "War Crimes" museum in HCM City, Vietnam. I considered it a true honor
to serve both VVT's president, Capt. Larry Bailey, and a whole generation of patriotic
Americans - Vietnam veterans who honorably answered their nation's call and were
united by a noble cause. That is, to prevent an opportunistic phony from securing
the reins of our nation and becoming our next Commander-In -Chief.
NCC: Now, you are involved in The People's Truth Forum; what is nature and
purpose of that group?
The People's Truth Forum is a non-partisan, fact-based organization whose mission
is to educate the American people on controversial topics of national security. Our
primary objective is to disseminate critical information that is not readily available,
via conventional channels, to concerned citizens. We always deal in facts and our
sources are always, credible.
NCC: Tell us about your upcoming symposium, "The Radical-Islamist Threat to World
Peace and National Security" - what is the goal of this program, who is involved and
what should the attendees expect to learn from it?
Several short months ago, the "Peoples Truth Forum" (PTF) set out on an
extraordinary mission - one of energizing a grass-roots initiative to disseminate the
truth regarding "radicalized" factions of Islam and the threat posed by these barbaric
terrorists to Western Society and our very way of life
As you stated, "PTF" is sponsoring an educational symposium titled, "The Radical
Islamist Threat to World Peace and National Security." It will take place on
September 21, 2005 in Southington, Connecticut. This symposium will delve into the
minds of those who use terror as a tool. It will paint a profile of those who would
slaughter innocents and it will educate both professional and average citizen on how
terrorism threatens our way of life today.
All participating speakers are noted experts on the subject matter of Radical Islam
and the threat that it poses to every American Citizen
Harvey Kushner, PhD., noted author, lecturer, professor and internationally
http://www.theconservativevoice.com/articles/artiele.htinl?id=7247 11/2/2005
An Interview with Jeffrey Epstein Page 2 of 5
recognized authority on terrorism. Dr. Kushner has advised and provided training to
numerous government agencies, including the FBI, FAA, INS, and U.S. Customs. He
is a frequent guest of all major television networks and is often quoted by news
media worldwide.
Brigitte Gabriel, a prominent Arab-American journalist, will provide a first-hand
account of her experience with Islamic Jihad. Ms. Gabriel, a Christian native of
Southern Lebanon, survived a bombing in which her family's home was reduced to
rubble by radical Muslim forces. Prompted by the serious wounding of her mother,
the family sought medical treatment in Israel - a place of refuge where the
generosity and compassion of the people overwhelmed them.
Robert Spencer, the director of Jihad Watch (www.jihadwatch.org), is the author of
Onward Muslim Soldiers: How Jihad Still Threatens America and the West (Regnery)
and Islam Unveiled: Disturbing Questions About the World's Fastest Growing Faith
(Encounter). He is coauthor, with Daniel Ali, of Inside Islam: A Guide for Catholics
(Ascension), and editor of the essay collection The Myth of Islamic Tolerance: How
Islamic Law Treats Non-Muslims (Prometheus). His latest book, The Politically
Incorrect Guide to Islam (and the Crusades), will be available August 8 from
Regnery Publishing.
Laura Mansfield is an author and counter -terror analyst. She uses her knowledge of
the Arabic language and of Islamic culture and history to investigate jihad and
jihadists both in the US and throughout the world.
The location we have procured is of the highest quality and can accommodate in
excess of 1200 guests. We expect to have a large contingent of first responders in
the audience and are experiencing great interest, from this demographic, in both the
tri-state area and Southern New England. Surprisingly, a number of guests are
planning to fly in from California, Texas and Florida.
No doubt, the symposium will sound a potent, nonpartisan alarm - a warning which
is intended to serve as a "wake-up" call to all those in attendance. We cannot afford
to embrace apathy or political correctness, not with this subject.
NCC: I've read that the "First Responders" are very much involved in the
symposium; why do those on the front lines of the domestic War on Terror so
strongly support your efforts?
Early on, a number of law enforcement agencies and military personnel signed up
for our weekly newsletters. Feedback from several Sheriff's departments and Marine
Corp Officers was encouraging since they proposed to incorporate some of our
material into their training programs. PTF was recently contacted by a DO) official
who praised our efforts and intends to both publicize the event and be in
attendance.
Bernie Kerik, New York City's former Police Commissioner and Congressman Tom
Tamcredo (R-CO) both endorsed the event and are planning to be in attendance,
schedule permitting.
NCC: The People's Truth Forum put together some ads to publicize the symposium;
could you describe these ads?
The 60- second commercial was formulated to advertise the symposium. In
summary, it began with Allahu Akbar (the Arabic phrase for praising god) and stated
that these were the words heard in the cockpits of those four jets that crashed into
the World Trade Center, Pentagon and a field in Pennsylvania. Then, the questions
were posed as to what could have been going through the minds of those terrorists
that day and what would have driven them to commit such an evil acts. . Next, we
invited people to attend the symposium to find those answers and provided contact
information.
http://www.theconservativevoice.com/artieles/article.html?id=7247 11/2/2005
' An Interview with Jeffrey Epstein Page 3 of 5
NCC: CBS has refused to run your ads, claiming that they are "too controversial"
and "too emotional." What is it about these ads that they find so objectionable?
That's the million dollar question... Initially, I thought that the incorporation of
Arabic might have appeared to be less than politically correct. In hindsight, I believe
that educating the public to the threat of radical Islam doesn't fit CBS's leftist
agenda - an opinion supported by their latest posting of an "AP" article on terrorism.
Once again, CBS was duped. They posted a faulty Fatwa, on their news site, which
was issued by a questionable Islamic organization with reputed ties to terrorism. If
the article wasn't bad enough, they chose to accompany it with a picture of a Muslim
man praying next to an American flag. CBS redesigned the flag by replacing the
stars with a crescent. Many of us consider this to be the ultimate act of desecration -
something particularly offensive when our servicemen are dying overseas.
NCC: Is this simply a case of political correctness run amok, or is something else
behind it? Could the reasons be more partisan in nature, or might they fear angering
Islamic pressure groups such as CAIR?
In consideration of ABC's recent firing of conservative talk show host Michael
Graham, I believe something far more sinister might be in play. The "MSM" is
partisan and is committed to undermining the war effort and our support for the
State of Israel. Just weeks ago, the BBC began to generically label Islamist terrorists
as "bombers". Not to be outdone, The New York Times, America's greatest liberal
rag, decided to revise history by showing respect for a barbaric butcher. Accordingly,
Abu Musab Zargari, the SOB who not only fathered the "IED" but is responsible for
the loss of thousands of military and civilian lives, is now being referred to as a
Jordanian fighter.
I have been told that media-related organizations are intimidated by the treat of
legal action from groups like CAIR. Additionally, rumors have it that several talk
show hosts are fearful of reprisal by Islamist extremists - especially when dealing
with topics concerning Iran.
NCC: Mr. Epstein, of recent weeks we have witnessed horrific terrorist attacks in
London and the Middle East - are we any safer here?
Relying on the opinions of those counter -terrorism experts which I consult with, the
answer would be no. We've come a long way but not far enough. Unfortunately, we
will suffer from horrific attacks over the coming years. Any labeling of the current
conflict as a war on terrorism is a misnomer. We are engaged in a struggle between
two diametrically opposed cultures. A religious war was declared on the West by
Islamic extremists who are committed to our very destruction. We can expect this
war to last for decades and no military options should be taken off the table. If and
when the Islamo-fascists secure nuclear weaponry, they will use them.
NCC: Are we more or less vulnerable than pre-9/11, and why?
I believe that we are significantly more vulnerable now because the Jihadists learned
much from our response to the attacks... They tested American resolve and
discovered how quick we were to forget even the most horrendous acts committed
against us. Just consider how our "enemies from within" set out on their treasonous
quest to "Vietnamize" the war effort in Iraq. We're currently engaged in fighting a
war on two fronts - a war which is our to lose if not supported on the home front.
I believe that the treat we are now facing is far more dangerous than that posed by
the Third Reich in the thirties. The Nazis were regionalized and for the most part in
uniform. Our Islamist enemies are widely disbursed and disguised within our own
borders. With a global population in excess of 1.2 billion Muslims, consider the
consequences of only having a mere 10% of them or 120 million sworn to our
http://www.theconservativevoice.conilartieles/article.html?id=7247 11/2/2005
An Interview with Jeffrey Epstein Page 4 of 5
destruction.
Last week, one of my associates questioned a Muslim foreigner as to whether he or
his "brothers" could be trusted. In response, the man emphatically stated "NEVER"
adding "that they are taught to be great neighbors and obey the laws of the
countries In which they reside until they are called up. Then, they will slice your
throats as easily as they came to your BBQ's"
NCC: If the goal of the symposiums sponsored by The People's Truth Forum Is to
further efforts against terrorism and enhance our security, why would anyone
oppose your efforts?
Our country is divided and many amongst us refuse to recognize the existence of
evil. Naive ideologues contend that Islamic "freedom fighters" are lashing out at the
West - and especially Americans - because of the provocative nature of Western life
or the Western presence in Islamic States. To hold these contentions is to be blind to
the truth either through ignorance or deliberate oversight.
NCC: Are those who hamper our security not complicit in our danger?
If we choose to ignore the facts as presented - that radical Islamists are waging war
against the free West and especially the United States of America - then future
deaths at the hands of terrorists must find the blood of the slaughtered on our hands
as well.
NCC: What should America do to protect ourselves against Islamic terrorism?
All efforts must be made to reverse the tide. Muslims, of questionable repute -
meaning having known ties to terrorism, have infiltrated various institutions across
America. They have gained access to the highest levels of government and are
exerting influence on policy making In Washington. These people must be exposed
and incarcerated. Additionally, our politicians must be held accountable for their
actions as well.
NCC: What can our readers do to help you and The People's Truth Forum in your
efforts to make America safer? How can we help get those ads on the air?
Time is not on our side with respect to CBS's questionable behavior. At this juncture,
trying to convince them to run the commercials would waste valuable energy and
resources. However, I am committed to publicizing the matter in hopes of waking up
the American people to CBS's dubious agenda.
Most importantly, everyone should immediately make reservations to attend the
symposium and encourage their associates and relatives to do likewise. If you can't
make it, please consider donating toward the event. Contributions received will
benefit law enforcement officers and others through reduced ticket prices.
Clearly, time is of the essence for the security and well-being of the greatest nation
on earth is at stake.
Reservation forms are available on our website: www.peoplestruthforum.com
Again, thank you Mr. Epstein. Daily, Americans must choose between vigilance and
complacency; you are doing a great service in educating us about the threats to our
nation and way of life. Keep up the good work.
http://www.theconservativevoice.com/artieles/artiele.html?id=7247 11/2/2005
', An Interview with Jeffrey Epstein Page 5 of 5
As a free people and a constitutional democracy, Americans have a duty to be active
in our governance. Our duty does not stop at the ballot box. I urge our readers to
remain vigilant against all threats to our society, learn about our enemies and take
an active role in defending our nation. Mr. Epstein is the epitome of what it means to
be a good and responsible citizen. I encourage each of you to help Mr. Epstein and
The People's Truth Forum in their Paul Revere - like mission to alert America to the
dangers we face.
Judson Cox is Editor in Chief of The North Carolina Conservative, a state-wide,
Christian Conservative newspaper. Please visit www.northcarolinaconservative.com
for news, commentary and exclusive interviews.
0 2005 The Conservative Voice. All rights reserved. Some portions ©The Associated Press.
http://www.theconservativevoice.com/articles/article.html?id=7247 11/2/2005
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 MCC [government] Metropolitan Correctional Center, jail where Epstein died 
         Joshua Cooper Ramo [lobbyist] co-CEO of Henry Kissinger Associates 
     Mohammed bin Salman aka MBS [mideast] prince of Saudi Arabia [cbsnews] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00195963 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein's financial transactions and account balances at Bear Stearns less than two years before it collapsed in 2008
(date: 2005-12-31)
Statements
CLEARED THAGVG/I ITS
yriseLLY 0H0¢0 SUBSOIAlly
BUR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSITE wentbearstearns.com
What's In This Statement
Financial Summary  3
Your Portfolio Holdings  3
Transaction Detail  4
Your Portfolio at a Glance
NET CREDIT BALANCE
lllII.11IiIlllllll I ll
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
0/0 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
137,909 Cash $ Equivalent H
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD $137,909
NET EQUITY LAST STATEMENT
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT
137,131
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on tile for your account.
Market Value of Your Portfolio
I 5137.909
$137.131
Current market value
Last statement's market value
I fir
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD December 1.2005
THROUGH December 30.2005
ACCGUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAMER On File
LAST STATEMENT NOyernter 30.2005
Tai Pornir/ Mr GfOrmormool palms only Nis ro trended as  downer
Tin statsensrA should be retailed for your records Soo mono ma Ice nonant reconaran
027 l2GLOS09:00 00I
U any information regarding
2005interest, dividends.
miscellaneous income. gross
proceeds or original issue
discount is required to be
reported to the IRS for this
account, a Consolidated Form
1099wi11 be mailed to you by
January 31.20D6or a 1042S
by March 15,2006.
V899
CLEMIE0 TIIIICV01 ITS
0"E0 SUBSI0SAIlv
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 ol 4
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
027 12,31005:09:00 001 V899
CLEARED TRACOGH nS
valCtLY CAMuE0 SUBSIDIAAY
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
3 c/
Cash Flow Analysis Income Summary
THIS PERICO DRS PENCO YEM TO DATE
Opening Balance $137,131.41 U.S. Govt. Bond Int. 0.00 4.718.243.44
Govt. Agency Int. 0.00 6.167.659.06
Dividends/Interest 778.08
Corp. Bond Int. 0.00 1,279,184.80
Amount Credited $778.08 Credit Balance Int. 778.08 12,704.04
Reverse Repurchase Int. 0.00 1.636.307.17
Net Cash Activity 778.08
Total $778.08 $13,814.098.51
Closing Balance $137.909.49
Bond Purchase Int. 0.00 -6.596,679.06
Repurchase Int. Exp. 0.00 -1,761,173.79
Cash Balance Summary
OPOONG CLOSING Portfolio Composition
Margin 137,131.41 137,909.49
CashiCash Equivalent 137,909
Net Cash Balance $137.131.41 $137.909.49 Total $137.909
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
oEscainou
CASH BALANCE
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
SYMBOXCUS1P
PMPXET ESTIMATED CUAPEM
OUANTITY PRIGS vALUE ANWAL INCOME vac Ni
137.909
$137,909
027 12,31.05:09:W 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT Puce December 1.2005
THROUGH December 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAMER On File
LAST STATEMENT November 30.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash & Equivalent
100%
UntEnded prima, clenc.1* 000t balance omit ,  shod
maim vaios TrA alocatxn warm": Is clorhod
Irom to attscla (radon WAIT oF ,oue
V899
CLEARED TRIICtiGH nS
YnIQIY OmnE0 SUBSIDIAnY
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Steams & Co. Inc.
4 C/
Your Portfolio Holdings (continued)
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS $137.909
Transaction Detail
INTEREST
DATE CESCRPTION
12/01/05 AVG BAL 137,131RT 3.288
021 OFFICE INTEREST 1105
SYMOCIJCVW DUMMY RATE IV DENT AMOUNT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* December 1.2005
THROUGH December 30.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEBER On File
LAST sTATEmENT November 30.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
375.77
12/30/05 AVG BAL 137.507RT 3.397
021 OFFICE INTEREST 1205
402.31
TOTAL $778.08
End of Statement
027 12.31.0S:09:C0 001
CLEARED IHRMIGH ITS
7010U.Y OHEE0 SUEINOMAy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSITE wovw.bearstearns.cOm
What's In This Statement IIIIMIIMIIIaITII I ll
Financial Summary   3 FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
Your Portfolio Holdings   3 0/0 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Transaction Detail   4 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE 63
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Your Portfolio at a Glance Market Value of Your Portfolio
NET CREDIT BALANCE 137,131 Cash a Eqtivalent
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD $137,131
NET EQUITY LAST STATEMENT 132,001
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT 5,130
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on file for your account.
^ 't(ttorlI)
Ill  $137.131
$132.001
iNg Current market value
Bal Last statements market value
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD NOTPTION 1.2005
THROUGH Noyernter 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On NE
LAST STATEMENT °Ste 31.2005
TI'n S'anirY .6 CO, nrcemebonel osmoses caly Xis rat riended as a ta. Oman
Ths ustseners shot/a as reared for your records See reverse sea for frowner< ricemanat
027 1ZOIGS:07:35 001 vase
GEARED 110.100044 ITS
WHOLLY OMAE0 $1.1090MAv
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 oi 4
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
021 1201.135:07:35 001 Y990
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
wilCu.Y omko SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
3 v/
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PERIOD
Income Summary DRS PERIOD YEAS TO DATE
OpeningBalance $132,001.23 U.S. Govt. Bond Int. O.OO 4.718.243.44
Govt. Agency Int. O.OO 6.167.659.O6
Dividends/Interest 5,13O.18 Corp. Bond Int. O.OO 1,279,184.8O
Amount Credited $5,130.18 Credit Balance Int. 5,13O.18 11,925.96
Reverse Repurchase Int. O.OO 1.636.3O7.17
Net Cash Activity 5.13O.18
Total $5.13O.18 $13 813 320.43
Closing Balance $137,131.41 Bond Purchase Int. O.OO -6.596,679.06
Repurchase Int. Exp. O.OO -1.761,173.79
Cash Balance Summary
OPEr. nG CLOSING Portfolio Composition
Margin 132,OO1.23 137,131.41 CashtCash Equivalent 137.131
Net Cash Balance $132,001.23 $137,131.41 Total $137.131
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
oescae-mu
CASH BALANCE
TOTAL CASH 8 CASH EQUIVALENTS $137,131
SITIBOSCuSIP
/MRKET ESTIMATED CURRENT
°DRURY PRICE VALUE MM.% INCOME VELD 1%4
137.131
027 12.0146:07:35 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD November 1.2005
THROUGH November 30.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER On Fite
LAST sTATELTENT Goober 31.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash & Equivalenl-
10O%
ItMtvittO V0MOnt Oen,* Oat "nonce *nee toe
male vela, Tea eloveran ;event'', tepee."
Iron Vo 00191.ve motel otte al >et pane",
vase
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
IMICELY omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
4 C/
Your Portfolio Holdings (continued)
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS $137.131
Transaction Detail
INTEREST
DATE DESCRIPTION
11/01/05 AVG BAL 1984.653RT 3.002
021 OFFICE INTEREST 1005
STMEICIJCUSIP OUMMTY RATE I%1 DENT AMOUNT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD November 1.2005
THROUGH November 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On Fite
LAST STATEMENT Ociober 31.2005
CREPT AMOUNT
5,130.18
TOTAL $5,130.18
End of Statement
027 1201OS:07:35 001 Y898
GUARS THROLGH ITS
wisestr OnNE0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSITE wonv.hearsteams.com
What's In This Statement IIIltlllltllral111 I ll
Financial Summary   3 FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
Your Portfolio Holdings   4 0/0 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Transaction Detail   4 61OO RED HOOK QUARTER
STE B3
ST THOMAS VI OO8O2
Your Portfolio at a Glance Market Value of Your Portfolio
NET CREDIT BALANCE 132,OO1 Cash& Equivalent
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD
SI32.001
$114.805
$132,001 MN Current market value
NA Last statements market value
NET EQUITY LAST STATEMENT 114,8O5
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT 17.196
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on file for your account.
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* October 1.2005
THROUGH October 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER I...AMER On File
LAST STATUTES' September 30.2005
SIKTNT SHYTTOTT 11 for N0THISonal SINN, only It Ism< NESS asst.. &warners
The stationers should be titans TN your words Ss mom td o for npolart ricesIon
027 11/01,05:06:34 001 V897
CLEARED 'THROUGH RS
YRIOLLY ORAEO SUBSIDIARY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 of e
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
027 lbOIG5:081W 001 V897
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY icim.co SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
3 c/
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PERIOD
Income Summary DC PERIOD YEAS TO DATE
Opening Balance $114,805.20 U.S. Govt. Bond Int. 0.00 4.718.243.44
Govt. Agency Int. 0.00 6.167.659.06
Securities Sold 119,604,887.50 Corp. Bond Int. 0.00 1.279.184.80
Dividends Interest 521.39 Credit Balance Int. 521.39 6.795.78
Miscellaneous 152,754.39 Reverse Repurchase Int. 32.231.25 1.636.307.17
Amount Credited $119,758,163.28 Total $32,752.64 $13 808 190.25
Securities Bought -100,472.656.25 Bond Purchase Int. 0.00 -6.596,679.06
Funds Withdrawn -63.185.00 Repurchase Int. Exp. 0.00 -1,761,173.79
Miscellaneous -19,205,126.00
Amount Debited $-119,740,967.25
Portfolio Composition Net Cash Activity 17,196.03
CashtCash Equivalent 132,001
ClosingBalance $132,001.23
Total 5132.001
Cash Balance Summary
OPENNIG CLOSING
Margn 114.805.20 132,001.23
Net Cash Balance $114,805.20 $132,001.23
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO °CMOS! 1.2005
THROUGH October 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLIUMER Ofl Ale
LAST STATEMENT Seplefiltet 30.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash & Equivalen1-
100%
UnttNitied 'roans 0en,* oelet "nonce *nee "toe
male vela, The elevehm ;event'', 6, de•ued
Iron Vo etnol.te market rat), pi >es patio",
027 1101 ,0S:06:3A 001 V897
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OM ED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
4 c,
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
DESORPTION
CASH BALANCE
TOTAL CASH 8, CASH EQUIVALENTS $132.001
SIMBOLOUSIP
MAPXEI ESTIMATED CUAPENT
SUANTITY PRICE VALUE NVUAL INCOME VELD 1%)
132,001
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS $132.001
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Octoter 1.2005
THROUGH Octoter 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MASSER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT SMNOTIMI 30.2005
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESORIPTIN SY/A0O-CUSP OJANTITY PRICE DENT AMOUNT CREDO AMOUNT
10/13/05
10/13/05
09/16/05
09/07/05
BOUGHT
CANCEL SELL
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJGTD
SEMI 005
FNMA 30YR1FNMA)GTD
SETT, i 0x05
BS
MIN
50.000.000
50.000.000
100.32031
100.62500
50,160,156.25
50,312,500.00
11011.05.500%
57170000 BS
AS OF 09/07t05
TO CA. PREVIOUS SELL
027 11.0145:00:3.1 001 .897
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACT/3N OESCRIPTION
10/13/05 09/16/05 CANCEL BUY FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
maitSEIT.10/05 05.500%
7250000 BS
10/13/05 09/07/05 SOLD
AS OF 09/I6105
TOM PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT. 045
1011.005.50015
57170000 BS
C'A_
DEPOSITS AND WITHDRAWALS
Dt.-E TRAAISACTCN DESCRPTION
10/12/05 FND WIRED MOAN FNDS WIRED TO
CLEARED TuRouom ITS
%%ore 0‘m,E0 SUEISIOany
Beer Ster
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* October 1.2005
THROUGH October 31.2005
Accouvr NUMBER
TAXPAYER KIDDER On File
LAST STATEMENT Septenter 30. 2005
SYX4EIOLCUS, OVAMITY PRICE DEIST AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-50.000,000 100.32031 50,160,156.25
-50.000.000 100.62500 50,312,500.00
3-100,472,656.25 $100,472,656.25
DEMI *mum
63.185.00
CREDIT AMOUNT
TOTAL $-63,185.00
INTEREST
DATE OESCRIPTION
10/03/05 AVG BAL 224,631RT 2.785
021 OFFICE INTEREST 0905
SYMEICLiCUSIP OUNITITY RATE Ix./ CENT AMOUNT CREW AMOUNT
521.39
TOTAL $521.39
027 11)01tOS:08:34 001 Y897
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OMEO SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
6 c/
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETTLEMENT TIMDE
DATE CATE
10114/. JOURNAL ADP CD
FITM-PR F2633219010
10131/49
TRANSACTION DESCRPXON
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD &IOW 1.2005
THROUGH October 31.2005
=OMNI NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Fite
LAST STATEMENT September 30.2005
SYMEICOICUSIP OVANNIY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
10114,E INTEREST ADP CD
DUE 12/31/2049 8,625
NMI
19.100.000.00
32.231.25
TOTAL $19.132.231.25
MISCELLANEOUS
DATE wow IRMSACTON DESCRIPTOR DES ,T AMCW4T GRECO AmOuni
10/06/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY A/C 410.64
10/13/05 JOURNAL FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D 152,343.75
SER,I 0/05
5,500 DUE 10101/35
MBS NET 10/13/05
10/17/05 JOURNAL FINAL REDEMPTION 19.203.776.00
10/21/05 JOURNAL 9)05 SPEC PART 2 CLR FEES 1.350.00
TOTAL $-19,205.126.00 $152.754.39
End of Statement
07/ I IVIGEGM34 001 v897
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOO.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSIIE wenv.bearstearns.cOm
What's In This Statement
Financial Summary  3
Your Portfolio Holdings   4
Transaction Detail   4
Trades Not Yet Settled   36
Your Portfolio at a Glance
NET CREDIT BALANCE 114.805
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD $114,805
llllllllllllllllll I ll
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
C.I0 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE 63
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Market Value of Your Portfolio
Cash a Eque,aiem _lc Si 14.805
E sA $221.488
Filed „
NET EQUITY LAST STATEMENT
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT
3.443,744
-3,328,938
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on file for your account.
Ctrellnri ,
NM Current market vase
gig Last statements market value
$3.188.141
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Sept/WIWI 1.2005
THROUGH Septernter 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On He
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
St Tin unInursin fc• Nonnabenal peposes ply it is ra etentINI as a ta. cloonto
Tin outornorc should Do Honed for your words Soo canna tel Ice moron riconaton
02? CIOT .896
CLEARED 'THROUGH RS
WHOLLY OBAED SUBSIDIARY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 U186
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
027 10,01,0511:50 001 V896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
3 c/ lb
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PERIOD
Income Summary DC PERIOD YEAR TO DATE
Opening Balance $221.487.52 U.S. Govt. Bond Int. 198.148.87 4.718.243.44
Govt. Agency Int. 775.394.53 6.167.659.O6
Securities Sold 1,385,266,7O8.58 Corp. Bond Int. 136.678.49 1.279.184.8O
Dividends Interest 1,182,572.79 Credit Balance Int. 951.82 6,274.39
Miscellaneous 745.735.38 Reverse Repurchase Int. 8O.288.31 1.604.075.92
Amount Credited $1,387.195.016.75 Total $1 191 462.O2 $13 775 437.61
Securities Bought -1,385,814,343.72 Bond Purchase Int. -203.722.59 -6.596,679.06
Dividends Interest Charged -275.121.67 Repurchase lnt. Exp. -260.593.74 -1,761,173.79
Miscellaneous -1,212.233.68
Amount Debited $-1,387,301,699.07
Portfolio Composition Net Cash Activity -1O6.682.32
Castileash Equivalent 114,8O5
ClosingBalance $114.8O5.2O
Total 5114.805
Cash Balance Summary
OPENING CLOSING
Margn 221,487.52 114,805.20
Net Cash Balance $221,487.52 $114,8O5.2O
027 05:11:50 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AILICER On File
LAST STATEMENT AUgUST 31.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash 8 Equivalenl-
10O%
le/ogled Grote 0en,* oat bloom *NW lope
male< wive, The eloml✓r move n, to ee•uee
lown Ve etnel.te market rat), el >ev peekee
CLEARED THROWN ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
4 CI
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
DESCioniOn
CASH BALANCE
SIMBOLCUSIP
IMRXE1 ESTIMATED CURRENT
QUANTITY VALUE ANWOL INCOME Y13.0
114.805
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS 8114806
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS $114.805
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEROT) SEDIETDOT 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAMER On Fite
LAST STATEMENT AufmST 31.2005
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION oEscromon SYMeoccum2 OVAMITY PHCE DENT AMOUNT crew AMOUNT
09/01105 08/31105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 18.000.000 100.11719 18,021,093.75
04,000% FA 28 ACCR. INT. 1,9138.95
RIP(
GVER REF ft Al
09102/05 09/01105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 5.000.000 101.70313 5,0115.19625
04,260% FA
TO MATURITY
15 ACM INT, 10,394.02
GVER REF # G2442669 Al
09.02/05 09/01105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10.000.000 100.49219 10,049,218.75
04,000% FA
MATURITY
28 ACCR. 9[1, 2.209.94
GVER REF tt G2443875 Al
027 1001005:11:SO 001 V8SC
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MOLLY CALY*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSAC11071 DESCRIPTION STMEPOLCUSV OVANTITY ',FEE DEW AMOUNT CREDIT MADUNT
09/02/05 09/01105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY 143TE 10.000.000 100.55469 10655.468.75
04.000% FA 28 ACM INT. 2209.94
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2443878 Al
09107/05 09/06105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -10.000.000 100.35156 10.035.156 .25
04.000% FA 28
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 7.734.81
OVER REF # G2494731 Al
0908105 09107/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MOM -5.000.000 101.06250 5.053.125.00
4.250% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 13.858.70
MATURITY
GVER REF or G2503140 Al
09718/05 PRINCIPAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPaSt0i09 Milli 6.399
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000 DUE 12101/34
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 09-15-05
09113/05 09/12/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE Milli -20.000.000 100.17188 20,034,375,00
04.000% FA 28
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 28.72928
GVER REF # G2552394 Al
091465 0810365 CANCEL SELL FNMA-30YR(FNMAJG1D 10608000 98.20313 8828312.50
SETT.09105
7150000 BS
AS OF 08/03105
TO CA. PREVIOUS SELL
0914105 08/31105 BOUGHT FNMA-30YR#NMA)GTD VIM 10.000.000 99.09375 9.909.375.00
SE 7.09)05
1. S1ean $PCmitkl EAR
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER00 September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUYT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER GM File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
1011.05.000tt
57020000 BS
027 100105:11:50 001 V896
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WHOLLY omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
6 4' a:
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
09/14105 08/11105 CANCEL SELL
09/14105 08/11105 BOUGHT
09/14105 08117105 CANCEL SELL
09/14105 08/17105 BOUGHT
09/14105 08/19/05 BOUGHT
09/14105 08119105 CANCEL SELL
DESCRIPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT.09105
1111005.000%
AS OF 08/11105
TO C)3. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G7D
SETT.09 05
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.09105
05.000%
AS OF 08/17/05
TO C/3. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30YR(TNMA)G1D
SETT 09'05
05.000%
FNMA-30YR(TNKIA)G1D
SEROUS
05.000%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)01D
SETT 09105
05,012.3'.
57090000 BS
AS OF 08/19/05
TO C/3. PREVIOUS SELL
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD &Vent& 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
STMOOLCUSP GUMMY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT A/A0cNT
50,000.000 98.15625 49.078.125 .00
BS
50.000.000 98.17188 49.085.937.50
BS
50.000.000 98.30078 49.150.390.63
BS
50.000.000 98.3828' 49.191.406.25
BS
50.000.000 98.49219 49.246.093.75
BS
50.000.000 98.55078 49.275.390.63
027 100105:11:50 001 VEISC
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
?RIMY (AM,ED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE ¶RANSAcnom
09/14105 08/03105 SOLD
09114(05 08:31105 CANCEL BUY
09/14105 08111105 SOLD
09,14/05 0811.05 CANCEL BUY
09/14105 08117105 SOLD
09/14105 08117105 CANCEL BUY
DESCRIPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJEITD
SETT.09105
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)01D
SETT.09105
.1111.05.000%
AS OF 08/31/05
TO CAL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.09105
05.000%
FNMA-33YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.09105
~ 05.000%
AS OF 08 11105
TO C)3. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-33YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.09105
imam 05.000%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)01D
SETT 09105
05.000%
57170000 BS
AS OF 0817105 TO C)3. PREVIOUS BUY
I
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD &VETO& 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AELAA3ER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
SYMBOL:CUSP CIVANTITY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT atm PAWN
BS
-10.000.000
-10.000.000
98.20313
99.09375
9.820212.50
9.909.375.00
BS
-50.000.000 98.15625 49.078.125 90
BS
-50.000.000 98.17188 49.085.937 .50
BS
-50.000.000 98.30078 49.159390 .63
BS
-50.000.000 98.38281 49.191.406 .25
027 M0105:11:50 001 V896
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WHOLLY omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
8 c/ lb
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
09/14105 08/19/05 CANCEL BUY
09/1445 0811945 SOLD
09/14105 08/03/05 CANCEL SELL
09/14105 09/07105 BOUGHT
09/1445 09/01105 BOUGHT
09/14105 08/03105 CANCEL SELL
DESORPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJOID
SETT.09105
05.000%
7060000 BS
AS OF 08/19/05
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMASDYNFNMNGID
SETT.09/05
000005.000 1::
57090000 BS
FNMA-30Y114FNMAAID
SETTS/9035
05.500%
7170000 BS
AS OF 0&03.D5
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30Y114FNMA)GID
SETT 09/,05
05.500%
57140000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
SETT.09'65
57020000 es
FNMA-30YREFNMAJOID
SETT 09//05
05.500:
7190000 BS
AS OF 08/03105
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
STME/OUCUSP amain ProcE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-50.000.000 98.49219 49.246.093 ,75
-50.000.000 98.55078 49.275.390 ,63
1.000.000 100.28516 1.002.851.56
50.000.000 100.75781 50.378.906.25
50.000.000 10107188 50.585.937.50
99.000.000 100.26563 99.262.968.75
027 1001,05:11:50 001 •.ESC
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
yrtiOLLY EMIED SUBSIOally
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
09/14105 08/0345 SOLD
0911 4/05 09/07105 CANCEL BUY
09/14105 09/01105 CANCEL BUY
0914/05 08/03(05 SOLD
09/4/05 08115(05 BOUGHT
09/14/05 08123(05 BOUGHT
OESCRPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJOTD
iiiis0SEIT.09//05 5.500%
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJEVID
SETT.09//05
11.0 105.500%
AS OF 09/07/05
TO C)3. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)01D
SETT.09//05
05.500%
AS OF 09/01105
TO C/3. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-90YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT 09605
05.500%
FNMA-30YR(FNMAXITD
SETT.09.105
100 506.000%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)010
SETT 09/05
06,000%
7020000 BS
I
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.200S
SYMBOL:CUSP OVAMITY Pea DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT MAOUNT
BS
-1.000.000
-50.000.000
100.28516
100.75781
1.002.851.56
50.378.906 .25
BS
-50.000.000 101.17188 50.585.937.50
BS
-99.000.000 100.26563 99.262.968 .75
BS
50.000.000 10%96090 50.980.468.75
BS
SIM 50.000.000 102.04688 51.023.437.50
027 100105:11:50 001 11896
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WHOLLY omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
10 a at.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
09/14105 08/16/05 CANCEL SELL
09114/05 08123405 CANCEL SELL
09/14405 08:15405 CANCEL BUY
09.414105 0823405 CANCEL BUY
09/14105 08116405 SOLD
09.414105 08123405 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)OID
SETT.09105
06.000%
AS OF 08/16/05
TO C)3. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G7D
SETT.091)5
100000 1506.000 ,,
AS OF 08423405
TO Cd. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.09405
1.101 506.000,4
AS OF 08/16405
TO C)3. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMAOSID
SETT.09/05
06.000%
AS OF 08/23105
TO C)3. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
SETT.09/05
01. 003506.000% 7090000
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.09405
06.000%
57140000 BS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD &Vent& 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
STIABOLCUSP CVANTITY lava DEBIT AMOUNT CFEOIA/lOcter
50.000.000 102.08594 51.042.968.75
BS
50.000.000 102.09375 61.046.876.00
BS
-50.000.000 101.96094 50.980,468 .75
BS
-50.000.000 102.04688 51.023 437 .50
BS
-50.000.000 102.08594 51.042.968;75
BS
-50.000.000 102.09375 61.046.875 .043
027 1001005:11:50 001 VEISC
CLEARED IHRCUGH ITS
wilDtLY 01\,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/3N 0E5CertiON SYMEPOLCUS, DAVIT" PRICE COW AMOUNT cnEccr saute
09/16/05 09/15/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -20.000.000 100.60938 20,121,875.00
04.250% FA 15
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 73,913,04
GVER REF # G2583645 Al
09,16/05 09/15405 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE EMI -20.000.000 100.60938 20,121,875.00
ff
04.250% FA 15
MATURITY
ACCR. INT, 73,913,04
GVER REF # G2583646 Al
091 6/05 09/15+05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10.000.000 100.26563 10.026.662.50
04.000% FA 28
MATURITY
ACM INT, 17,679.56
GVER REF # 62583659 BI
09/1605 09115105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 50.000.000 100.26563 50.132.812,50
04.000% FA 28 ACM INT. 88,397.79
0 MATURITY
GVER REF N G2583659 Al
091 6/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109 -1
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000 DUE 12/01/34
09/19105 09/14105 SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL PATO ASSOC -14.505.776 5.34375 77e152,43
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE ACCR. INT, 41,956,91
101057200000 BS
09/19105 09/16/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 20,000.000 99.89063 19.978.125.00
04.250% FA 15
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 80.842.39
GVER REF # 02594476 Al
/. S1PBms $PCmiI e; EAR
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1,2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
027 TOOT 0511:50 001 V896
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WHOLLY ow‘co SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
12 O 0.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
09/20,05 09/16105 SOW
09,20.435 09,11545 SOLD
09120105 09/15105 SOW
0912045 09/15105 SOLD
09,2045 0916105 SOLD
09,20:05 0911545 SOLD
09,20:05 0911545 SOLD
DESORPTION
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
i llini ii57320000 BS
SY1A301XLISP PIECE
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD SEDIETtet 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
DEIST AMOUNT mac AnouNr
FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-13
S RCR-NO FLTR
111.1104.3"
7240000 BS
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
110.03.3"
7230000 BS
FANNIE MAE CMCvSERIES 2003-52
KS-L0 FUR
03.458%
7280000 BS
EDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
EWES 346 CLASS 1
7390000 BS
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
: ""967250000 BS
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
1. 105 03.590%7260000 BS
TO AIN PREVIOUS MONTHS FACTOR
AS OF 09,1545
-18,252,042
-23.543,127
79.89063
9,87500
14,561,670.75
2,324.88379
ACCR. INT. 71.262.10
-11.861.918 6,96875 826.627,47
ACCR. INT. 27$67.10
-16.565.865 6,96875 1.154.433.75
ACCR, INT. 39.789.14
MIS -19.328.957 79.76563 15.417.863 .44
-44.000.000 11.15625 4.908.750.00
-23.661.075 6,03125 1.421.027.35
027 1001005:11:50 001 .896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BOIR
STffiRNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
=MD R
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTK•N
09120(05 09/15(05 SOW
09120(05 09,1 6(05 SOLD
09120(05 09,1 6(05 SOLD
09120(05 09,1 6(05 SOLD
0912045 09,9 5(05 SOLD
0920(05 09115(05 SOW
09120(05 09116(05 SOLD
DESORPTION
GOVERNMENT 144TØ MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
11.11117 "7270000 BS
TO ADJ PREVIOUS MONTHS FACTCR
AS OF 09/15(05
FEDERAL 144T1ONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
IIM0 500.001%
7380000 BS
FEDERAL 144TØ MIG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
05.000%
7350000 BS
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 25TH
FEDL HOME LOAN MIG CORP#S10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
05000%
7360000 BS
FREDDIE MAC CMGSERIES 2886
SC-VO RIR
03531%
7290000 BS
AL1ERNA1ivE LOAN TRUST
SERIES 2004-3008 CLASS 1-A-8
01458%
7300000 BS
FEDL HOME LOAN MIO CORPeSt0i10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
06000%
7370000 BS
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 25TH
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
SIME10..CLISP Gummy PRTCE DEW AMOUNT CREW ~UHT
-14,296,550 4,53125 647,812.46
SIM -25.900.765 79,29688 20.538.497 86
MINK -8.757.972 22.67188 1.985.596.53
ACCR. INT. 23.111,32
-27.588.703 23.04688 6.358.334.08
ACCR, INT, 72.803,52
-8.074.610 7,28125 587.932.59
ACCR, INT, 3.960,82
-35.363.806 1,45313 513.880.31
ACCR, INT, 35.823 p5
-16271.372 20.07813 3.266.986.53
ACCR, INT, 51.526,01
027 MOLDS:11:SO 001 V89G
CLEARED THROWN ITS
WHOLLY omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
14 o
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION SYUDOLCUSP OJANTITY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CFEDIA/lOcter
09/20105 PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN -172,307
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SF'
3,590 DUE 12/20/29
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 09-20-05
09/21+05 091l5.'05 CANCEL SELL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
imusSERIES 2004-5 CLA03SS.16Pot
7250000 BS
11.111 44,000.000 11.15625 4.908.750.00
AS OF TD 09/15/05 SO 09/204135
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
09/21105 09(15105 SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN -44.0110,000 11,15625 4.908.750.00
4 imilosSERIES 2604-5 LASS PS
7250000 BS
AS OF TD 09/15105 SD 09/20/05
AS OF 09/1905
09,21/05 0911 5+05 CANCEL SELL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 23.561.075 6,03125 1.421.027.35
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
03410%
7260000 BS
AS OF TD 09/15105 SD 09/20/05
TO C/3. PREVIOUS SELL
09,21105 09/I 905 SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN -23.561.075 6,03125 1.421.027.35
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
03,410%
7260000 BS
AS OF TD 09/15/05 SO 09/204135
AS OF 09/15/05
0921105 0915105 CANCEL SELL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN SIM 14,296.650 4,53125 6,12.812;16
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
03,410%
7270000 BS
AS OF TD 09/151135 SD 09/20/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
027 1001005:11:SO 001
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WHOLLY onneo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
15 CI r.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION marine 20.100.005 P ouninw PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CM= maJtAir
09/21105
09121/05
09/26+05
09/264)5
09/15/05 SOLD
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
PRINCIPAL
PRINCIPAL
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
03,410%
7270000 BS
AS OF TD 09/15105 SD 09/20/05
AS OF 09/15105
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
3,358 DUE 01/25/33
FANNIE MAE CMCUSERIES 2003-52
KS-110 RJR
3,458 DUE 07/25117
FEDERAL NATIONAL WO ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001 DUE 07/01/34
FEDL HOME LOAN MI6 CORN/610'09
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5,000 DUE 12/01/34
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
3,410 DUE 12/20129
ADJUST POSffION
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
PAIN FUD 08-05 PAD 09-25-05
REPO P 8I 0,0000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
WE 11/01/33
PAIN FUD 08-05 PAD 09-25-05
REPO P 8I 0,0000
MIN
-14,296,550
.1
-2
4,53125 647,812,46
457.764 AO
682.254.70
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMJUSER C'n File
LAST STATEMENT Au9Jst 31.2005
027 1:S0 OBI v896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
wilDtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE wesAcnoN
09/26/05 PRINCIPAL
DESORPTION
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
O.001 DUE 07/01/30
PAIN RID 08-05 P,D 09-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
09126005 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
O.001 DUE 07/01/30
PRIN RID 08-05 PAI 09-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
09,27+05 09/15+05 CANCEL SELL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
03.403%
7260000 BS
AS OF TD 09/15/05 SD 09/20/05
TO C/Pl. PREVIOUS SELL
09,27105 09/15/05 SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
1.1.03.403%
7260000 BS
AS OF TD 09/15/75 SD 09/20405
TO ADJ PREVIOUS MONTHS FACTOR
STMEIOLCUS,
I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT! NUMBER
TAXPAYER PAGER On Fa
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2006
°AWRY PACE DEBIT AMOUNT CREW AAIDUNI
209,767.60
482,465,48
23.561.075 6.03125 1.421.027.35
-23,561.075 6.03125 1.421.027 .37
TOTAL 3452.032.222.57 $881,454.219.11
INTEREST
DATE DESCRPTION
00'01105 AVEI EIAL 424.880 TIT 2.601
021 OFFICE INTEREST 0805
SYTTECIJCUSIP OUPARRY RATE D4/ MINT MOM CREDIT AMOUNT
951.82
09/15105 FEDL HOME LOAN WIG COAP/S10109
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INTEREST PAYMENT 09-15.05
5.0000 1.942.56
027 1001,05:11:60 001 V896
CLEARED IHRCUGH ITS
wisCtLY O1\,EO SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAIA3ER On File
LAST STATEMENT Aufm81 31.2005
DATE DESCFOPTION STME/CliDIZIP QUANTITY RATE I% DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/15/05 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CCAPHS1OiO9 5.0000 36.908.38
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT R/D 08-05 ND 09-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
09115405 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG COAPPS10i09 MIK 5.0000 77.701.85
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 08-05 PiD 09-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
09./15+05 FREDDIE MAC CMOSF.FUES 2886 UM. 3.5310 25432.52
SC-I/O RTR
DUE 07/15/2019 3,531
INT R/D 08-05 PiD 09-15-05
REPO P S I 3,7287
0911905 FEDL HOME LOAN WIG CORP/410110 6.0000 84.306.97
SERES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2035 6,000
INT RID 08-05 PiD 09-15-05
REPO P &I 6,0000
0912045 GOVERNMENT FATIONAL MTG ASSN OMNI 3.3400 48.995,76
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 3,340
INT R/D 08-05 PAD 09-20-05
REPO P S I 3,3406
0972045 GOVERNMENT ANTIONAL MTO ASSN 3.3400 73.49344
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02120/2033 3,340
INT R/D 08-05 PAD 09-20-05
REPO P S I 3,3406
0920••05 GOVERNMENT MOCHA/ PATO ASSN 3.5900 71 399.08
SERES 2004.30 CLASS SIJ
DUE 02/20/2032 3,590
INT R/D 08-05 Pin 09-20-05
REPO P S I 3,5906
027 TOOT 0511:50 001 Y896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1,2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AILMA3ER Co File
LAST STATEMENT August 31. 2005
DATE DESORPTION STMEICIJCV5IP WANIITY RATE I%) DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 3.5903 71.399.08
SERIES 200040 CLASS SU
DUE 02/20/2032 3.590
INT RID 08-05 Ki 09-20-05
REPO P & I 3.5906
0972045 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3.5980 43,293;18
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
DUE 12/20/2029 3.590
INTEREST PAYMENT 09-20.05
0912645 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3.4030 71 399,08
SERES 200040 CLASS SU
DUE 02/20/2032 3.403
REV INT FOR 9/20/2005 PD
BAD POSITION
0912645 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 5.0000 37 094.87
SERES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5400
INT RID 08-05 Ki 09-25-05
REPO P & I 5.0000
09/30/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC 43.403.95
SEEMS 2000-041 CLASS SE
DUE 05/20/2030 0.000
FITM CR INT FOR 9404005 P
D
TOTAL S-71.399.08 5616.523.95
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRMSACIION DESCRFMON SvMBOLCusJp 0.:NYTIT, COIT AMOUNT
09/01105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 8.058,484 5,923,000.00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001 DUE 07/01/34
FITM F2133186 AZ
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
CREDIT AMOUNT
027 IGOIDS:II:SO 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YilICtLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
19 c? :tt.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON SYMEMOCUSIP QUANTITY OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/01/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -8.058.484 5.958.000 .00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001
FITM At
REPO
09/01105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 8.058.484 5.958.000 .00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001
FITM WA2
REPO A
09/01/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL 1,110 ASSN -8.058484 8958.000 .00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001O
FITM r A3
REPO A
09/01105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL KITG ASSN IMF -8.902.768 500 000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000
FITM B3
REPO A
09/01105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4.902.768 1.677.000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
FITT., W31
REPO A
09:0185 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL WO ASSN 8.902,768 1.677.000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000 FONT B2 REPO
0901x05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 8.902,768 1.850.000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000 DUE 07/01/34
FITM F2133186 BZ
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER C'n File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
027 1001,05:11:50 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
wisCtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
=Pm 20
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SCITLELENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTION
09/01/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG OORP#S10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5,000
F1TM 30.2
TERM MENT
09/01105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CCePt/ST 0i09
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
5,000
F1TM WI REPO A
09/01105 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
FILMpr. Az 4,250 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
09/01105 JOURNAL UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE
FILM Al
4,250 15
REPO AGREEMENT
09/01105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 08131/2007 4.000
4,000 W
FITM Al
RESALE
0901,05 DELIVERED OWED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 08131/2007 4,000
4,000Rialt7 Em
FILM AZ
TERM ENT
0901.05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS
DUE 07/01/2034 0.001
FILM F2133186 AZ
REPO INTEREST
09.01/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5.000
FILM F2133186 BZ
REPO INTEREST
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
SYLIBeucesty OWATTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
8.858,010 500.000.00
-8.858.010 1.706.000.00
20.000.000 20.225.000.00
20.000.000 20.350.000.00
50.000.000 50.312.500 .00
-68.000.000 68.255.000 ,00
19.024,35
5.942.10
027 TOOT 0511:50 001 V896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YRICtLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEmENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYMEMCUSIP QUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09101105 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTO CORPaS10109 1,605.97
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 11.0. 5.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
09/01/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 1.797.78
DUE lib 4.250
FITM AZ
REPO I
09/01105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE IMF 6.294.63
DUE 08W 4.000
FITM
RESALE
09102105 JOURNAL UNITED SURY NOTE 20.000.000 20.350.000 .00
FITM A2
4.250 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
0902/05 JOURNAL SURY NOTE -25.000.000 25.468.750.00 Al
FITM Al
4.250 IS
REPO  AGfiEEMENi
09032105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 30.000.000 30.225.000 .00
DUE 08t3 I 2037 000
4.000 in
FITM Al
RESALE
0902105 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -50.000.000 50.312.500 .00
DUE 08131/2007 000
4.000 7
FITM A2
TERM ENT
00/02/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 1.825.85
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD &VETO& 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 3 t . 2005
DUE 081 4250
ATM A2
REPO I
027 05:11:50 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WNW.? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
22 c1 7i.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEnlimee
DATE
MADE
DATE TIWISACION
INTEREST
DESERTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE Oil. 1.000
0906105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE IV
ATM C2
TERM ENT
0906105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11Ailli r
ATM At
REPO
0906105 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DUE I II. 0.000
ATM C2
REPO I
09/07105 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 08/312037 4.000
4.000F..7
FITM A2
TERM EMENT
09107/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 08131/2007 4.000
4.000 ENS
FITM Al
RESALE
09107/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE oats  try))
SYM0ClCUse, OVAARITY DEBIT AMOUNT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEROO &Ventre' 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER C'n File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
4.500.17
19,911211 14.274.000 .00
-19.911.211 14.856.000 .00
37,370.12
-30.000.000 30.225.000 .00
40.000.000 40.300.000 .00
13.500.50
09.08/05 JOURNAL F AS NOTE
FILM Al
4.250 15
REPO AGREEMENT
-20.000.000 20.175.000 .00
027 MOLDS:II:SO 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SATE/COAL/SIP OUAMITY 003IT *Mum CREDIT AMOUNT
090845 JOURNAL IMMO STATES TREASURY NOTE 25.000.000 25,468,750 .00
FITM p l . A2
4,250 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
09108105 INTEREST UMTEO STATES TREASURY NOTE 12.076.43
DUE 110 4.250
F1114 A2
REPO I
09/12/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN -18.252.042 13.360.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FITTA Cl
REPO At
09/12/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN MIS 18.252.042 13.401.000 AO
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FITM RIFIC2
TERM ENT
09/12/05 JOURNAL FANNIE A.44E CMOSERIES 2003.13 23,543.127
S RCR-I/0 FLTR
4.358
FITM
TERM ENT
09/12/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CAAOSERIES 2003.13 NMI -23,543.127 1,775,000.00
S RCR-I/0 FLTR
4FIT14.358 AI
REPO A
09/12/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL WC ASSN -19,328.957 14.132.000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
FITM Al
DUE 11101.
REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
027 100105:11:50 001 ?SSC
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMETO TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYMEMICUSIP QUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/12105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MIR ASSN 19,328.957 14.856.000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
ATM AZ
DUE 1 TRIOS
TERM MEAT
09/12105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN WC OCAPeS10109 -18,392.469 3.667.000.00
SERIES 227 CLASS
"00
FITM Al
REPO A
09/12/05 JOURNAL FEDL NOME WAN MTG CORPeS10109 MIS 18,392.469 3,938.000.00
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
F51114.000 BZ
TERM Fielln iellerMENT
09/12105 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN WC CCAPtiStOt 10 NEM -16,271.372 2.777.000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000
FITM 81
REPO A
09/12/05 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTG OORPOSIO1m 16,271.372 3,124,000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.0001.5
FITM AZ
TERM MEAT
09/12/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN 43,504,86
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 01  0.000
FITM DZ
REPO I
09/12,05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN MIN 9.334.52
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
DUE 11j. 0.000
ATM AZ
REPO I
027 IGOIDS:l I:SO 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TM&
DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION STMBEISCUSIP QUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/12:05 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CORPAS10109 12.784.28
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 1 5,000
RANT BZ
y ea
REPO I
09/12105 INTEREST FEDL N0ME LOAN MTG CORPASIOA 10 10.141.72
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE Oil. 6.000
RANT AZ
REPO I
09/13,95 JOURNAL FREDOIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886 8.249,152
SC-I/O FUR
3.728301 I 19
FIRA A2
TERM AAENT
09113:05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMGSERIES 2886 -8.249.152 444,030,00
SC-I/0 FLTR
3.728 19
FIRM Al
REPO A
09/13:05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -40.000.000 40.300.000 ,00
DUE 08131/2007 4.000
4.0001101 w
RANT
TERM
A2
EMENT
0911345 RECEIVED OWED STATES TREASURY NOTE 60.000.000 60.375.000 ,00
DUE 08131/2007 4.000
4.000 .K 7
RANT
RESALE
A
T
0911345 INTEREST UNTIED STATES TREASURY NOTE 21.258.25
DUE 0111 .1400
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD &VETO& 1,2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31. 2005
027 IGOI 05:11:SO 001 V896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
26 cl A.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACRON DESCRPRON SYME/CLCUSIP OVANillY DEBIT AMOUNT
09/14105 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE GAO/SERIES 2033-52 9.276,884 458,000.00
KS-I/0 FUR
3,458 17
FITM AZ
TERM ENT
09/14105 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CAtiOSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/O FUR
3,458 17
FITM Al
REPO A
09114.,05 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/0 FUR
DUE cairo. 3.458
FITM AZ
REPO I
09/15 05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/0 FLTR
3,458 17
FITM AZ
TERM ENT
09/1505 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CAtiOSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/0 FUR
DUE 07/11. 3.458
FITM AZ
REPO I
09/16/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CAtiOSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/0 FLTR
3,458 17
FIN Al
REPO A
09/16.05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE 2MOSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/O FUR
3,458 17
FITM Al
REPO A
FINANCAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERO(' September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER C'n File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
-9.276.884 478,000.00
1.442.70
7.288.980 384.000.00
1.249.92
-9.276.884
-7.288.980 373,000.00
027 1001,05:11:50 001
CLEARED 114ROuGH ITS
wisCtLY CAM,E0 SUEISIOally
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
=Pm 27
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SERLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TIWISACRON DESCRPRON STMOCCCUSIP CVANT11Y OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/16105
09/16105
09./I6/05
09/16x05
09/16/05
09/16105
09/16105
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
RECEIVED
JOURNAL
DELIVERED
INTEREST
FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES
KS-I/0 FUR
3.458
FITM
TERM
FREOOIE MAC CMOSERIES
SC-D0 RJR
3.531p1.019
FITM
REPO
FREOOIE MAC CMOSERIES
SC-D0 RJR
3.531 /
FITM
TERM
IMMO STATES TREASURY
DUE 08115/2015
4,250 DOC
FITM
RESALE
UMTEO STATES TREASURY
4.25
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
LIMTEO STATES TREASURY
DUE 08131/2007
4.000)111C7 Em
FITM
TERM
FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES
KS-I/0 FUR
2003.52
A2
ENT
Al
A2
ENT
NOTE
Al
NOTE
1S
NOTE
4.000
A2
ENT
2003-52 NMI
9.276.884
-8.074.610
8.074.610
20.000.000
20.000.000
-60.000.000
478,000.00
444.030.03
20.175.000.00
20.175.000.00
105.43
60.375.000.00
I,Sean SPemit' GoI
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
DUE 071  3.468
FITM A2
REPO I
027 IGOI 05:11:50 001 V896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
wisCtLY 01\,E0 SUETSIOTAlly
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
=Pm 28
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER Gn File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTOR DESCRPSON STMEICL,CVSTP MAMMY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/16/05 INTEREST FREOOIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886 146.89
SC-D0 FUR
DUE OA. 3.531
FITM A2
REPO I
09/16/05 INTEREST Utile) STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE O8! 4,250
FITM A2
REPO I
09/16/05 INTEREST UNiTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 08/1#1. 1.000 MEE
3.155.15
15.563,33
09/19105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN -23.861.866 1.079.000.00
SERIES 2004.30 CLASS SU
3.590 14.2 FITM Al
REPO A
09/19105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2004.30 CLASS SU
3.590R11032
FITM AZ
TERM MENT
23.861.866 1.216.000 .00
09/19105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN -18.052.048 12.922.000 .00
SERIES 352 CLASS
0.001
FITM Al
REPO
09/19105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS
0.001R.I t
FITM t AZ
TERM ENT
18.052,048 13.289.000 00
09/19105 DELIVERED ANTED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 08/15 2015 4250
4.2503i.5
FILM A2
TERM EMENT
-20,000,000 20.175.00000
027 TOOT 0511:50 001 V896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
VOIDS? OAAED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
29 ci r.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AXAMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
SETTLEMDIT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTION SYME/CIAUSIP OVANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09119/05 INTEREST GOVERN/ANT NATIONAL MM ASSN 018.19
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
DUE 02:  3.590
FITM AZ
REPO I
09/19105 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS I
DUE 07  0.001
HIM AZ
REPO I
09/19/05 INTEREST UPSET) STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE WOO 1.250
09/20105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL NM ASSN
SERIES 329 CUSS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FITM RPRIPM Ce TERM NT
09/20105 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CAOSERIES 2003-13
S RCR-1/0 FLTR
4.358
FITM
TERM ENT
0912045 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOMERIES 2003-52
KS-1/0 FUR
3.458 17
FITM A2
TERM MENT
09/2045 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-52
KS-ItO FLTR
3,458 I7
FITM A2
TERM MENT
45,005.41
4.573,00
18.252.042 13.360.000 ,00
23.543.127 1.775.000 ,00
9.276.884
7.288.980 373,000,00
027 T0,01,05:I I:SO 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
30 ci r.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SE111.0.00 TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYMEMICUSIP QUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09120/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MFG ASSN 19,328,957 14.132.000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11R10).
FONT A2
TERM MENT
09/20+05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MM ASSN 26.400.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
3,340
FIRM 1.12
TERM ENT
09/20,05 JOURNAL CAVEMAN,' NATIONAL MFG ASSN EMI 17,600.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
FITMARGN A2
3,34ORDES.
TERM NT
09/20,05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MAO ASSN 23,561.075 1 079.000,00
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
3,590311.32
FITM A2
TERM MENT
09/20,05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MFG ASSN 7.848.716 5.958.000.00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001
FIRM Jatti lil4
TERM ENT
09/20,05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL WO ASSN 18.052,048 12.922.000 ,00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,0013.141
FM A2
TERM MENT
09/20,05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MFG ASSN 8.757,972 500 000,00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
Ric
FIRM
Ofilinn34 84
TERM RIMMAAENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1,2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
027 IGOIDS:l I:SO 001 "896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE
09120/05
09/2045
09120/05
TRNISACSON DESCRPRON SYMEMICUSIP QUANTITY
JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MT0 ODRPaS10109 8.736.422
JOURNAL
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
PC/IllirA 2TERM MENT
FEDL HOME LOAN MIG OCAAPPSIOT 09 18.392.469
JOURNAL
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
ITM 31. 34A2 FITM
TERM MENT
FREDOIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886 8.074.610
JOURNAL
SC-PO FUR
3.531R14.19
RIM A2
TERM AAENT
FEDL HOME LOAN MIG CCAPtiStOt 10 16,271.372
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000
FITM
TERM ENT
09/2045 JOURNAL ADP CD
FITM-PR
0920/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MFG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 0110. 0.000
FITM C2
REPO I
09.2045 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003.13
S RCR4i0 FLTR
DUE 03:100. 4.358
FITM A2
REPO I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
1.706.000 .00
3,667,000.00
2.777.000.00
ISM
16.500.000,
11,727,11
1.558.06
027 10,01,05:II:SO 001 'esse
CLEARED 1HROuGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTION SYME/CVOUSIP OVANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/20105 INTEREST FANNIE ILME OMO(SERIES 20D3-52 165.78
09/20+05 INTEREST
KS4/0 FUR
DUE 07:10. 3.458
FITM A2
REPO I
FEDERAL NATIONAL IMO ASSN 12.404.76
09/20(05 INTEREST
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE I 1 0.000
FR114 A2
REPO I
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL LNG ASSN 120.19
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
DUE 02:11. 3.690
RUNT A2
REPO I
09120(05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL LNG ASSN MIN 1.439.37
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
DUE 0710 0.001
FR114 A2
REPO I
09120(05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN NMI 12326.44
0912045 INTEREST
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
DUE 073.1 0.001
FITM A4
REPO I
FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN 1.034.44
09/2045 INTEREST
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 0:1001. 6.000
FRM 64
REPO I
FEDL 43ME LOANI.ITGOORP#S10109 3.218.81
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERO(' &VETO& 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
DUE 12oil l  5.000
FITM A2
REPO I
027 10,01,05:1 I:SO 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
33 0 :tt.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYME/MCUSIP OWARITY OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/20/05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTO COAPaS10109 3,529.52
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE Ills  5.000
ATM A2
REPO I
0920105 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTO CORPHS10110 2.437.59
SERIES 228 CLASS
DUE 02.01. 6.000
ATM 82
REPO I
09231 JOURNAL ADP CD lilt 16.500.000.00
FiTm-PR F2633219012
31/49
09/23/05 JOURNAL ADP CD NIB 16.500.0001
FITI1/44-PR F2633219013
/0131/49
09123,1 JOURNAL ADP CD 16.500.000.00
FITM-PR F2633219014
10131/49
09/23+05 JOURNAL ADP CD 17.400.000
FITM-PR F2633219015 A Ax Iola 1/49
0%232 INTEREST ADP CD 5.127.60
DUE 12/31/2049 025
09.26,1 JOURNAL ADP CD 17.400.000.00
FITM-PR F2633219016
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAASER Cn File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
12/3 1/49
027 10,01,05:1 I:SO 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD &VETO& 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTTON STMOCCOUSIP CVANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
09/26/05 JOURNAL ADP CD 17.400.000 a
Frthil-PR F2633219017
10)31(49
09124 JOURNAL ADP CD
FrthePR F2633219018
10131(49
17.400.000.00
09/26/05 JOURNAL ADP CD
FITIO-PR F2633219019
/0/41149
19.200.000
me. INTEREST ADP CD
DUE 12(31/2049 8,625 FIULPR 3219016
5.437.50
09128(05 JOURNAL ADP CD
FITIO-PR F2633219018
1(49
19.100.000
09/282 JOURNAL ADP CD
FrthePR F263321901A
fl ax fNIF 19)31(49
09281 INTEREST ADP CD
DUE 12(31/2049 8,625
ill..3321901A
TOTAL
19.200.000.00
4.033.33
$-533.985.843.74 5504.378.538.31
027 100105:11:50 001 Y896
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
YAIOU.Y OunED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
35 o
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS
DATE
1.00AT TRANSACTEY4 DESCRIPTION DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
09/01105 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 119.924.00
09102105 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 114.810.00
09/06+05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 164.532.50
0907105 JOURNAL FR CMOY NC 66.530,00
0910EPOS JOURNAL FR CMOY NC 76.804 .38
0909105 JOURNAL FR CMOs! NC 5.112.50
09/13/05 JOURNAL FR CMOY NC 116.022.50
09113/05 JOURNAL FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G O 108.593.74
SETT.09/DS
5000 DUE 09t01/36
ABS NET 09113/05
0911 3/05 JOURNAL FNMA-30YR(FNMAJOTO 699.023.44
SETT.09805
5400 DUE 09/01/3S
MBS NET 09113/05
09114/05 JOURNAL FNAAA-30YR(FNAAAJOTO 86.937.50
SETT.09/DS
6.000 DUE 09/01/35
MBS NET mums
09/16,SS JOURNAL FR CMOY NC 396.328.50
0920/05 JOURNAL 8/05 SPEC PART 2 CLR FEES 5.360.00
TOTAL S-1.212.233.68 $745.735.38
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERO(' September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAMER On File
LAST sTATELIENT August 31.2005
027 NM 051 1:50 001 V896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
viiiCtl.Y 0%1T,*0 SUBSIO4Ally
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Trades Executed Pending Settlement
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE lIANSACRON
10/13105 09/16105 BOUGHT
10/13+05 09/07/05 SOLD
DESCRIPTION 0.100...CLISP comm . emu
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID 50,000.000 .00 100.3203
SETT. 10/05
05.500%
57250000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID -50.000.000 ,00 100 .6250
SETT.10/05
05.500%
57170000 BS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD September 1.2005
THROUGH September 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAMER On File
LAST STATEMENT August 31.2005
OM AMOUNT
SO, 160.156 .25
CM= AMOUNT
50.312.500 .00
TOTAL S50.160.156.25 550.312.500.00
The above non m nci applar In wt 011w socll  01 MC stalamoni.
End of Statement
027 T0,0105:11:50 001 V896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WICALY OMAX0 SUBSIDIARY
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
S mear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSITE wenv.bearstearns.com
What's In This Statement
Financial Summary 3
Your Portfolio Holdings  4
Transaction Detail  7
Trades Not Yet Settled  33
Your Portfolio at a Glance
TOTAL VALUE OF SECURITIES THIS PERIOD 3.188.141
LONG ACCRUED INTEREST 34.115
NET CREDIT BALANCE 221.488
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD $3,443,744
NET EOLOTY LAST STATEMENT 3,241.555
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT 202.189
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on file for your account.
III111111111111111 I ll
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
CIO JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Market Value of Your Portfolio
5221.488 Cash Equvalent 1.$11.712
Fixed
Income
$3.188.141
$3.204.048
IIIII Current market value
au Last statements market value
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jug 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER en Ede
LAST STATEMENT 11// 29. 2005
Tin summary E lot Scdeseortel poem cely. It a not NOM as. tat doused
Ain scateatero NNW M retaned to, your records Soo worn Sr Tor irrexclott yeoman=
027 0B 01,05:13:28 001 Y895
GEARED IHROUGH ITS
YAIOtlY OMAE0 $1.10540MAY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 o135
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
027 0201,05:12:211 001 Y895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SUBSTAARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
3 a1 >s
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PEPICO
Income Summary THS PERIOD YEAS TO DATE
Opening Balance $11.711.77 U.S. Govt. Bond Int. 461.711.95 4.520.094.57
Govt. Agency Int. 627.049.58 5.392.264.53
Securities Sold 1.146.377.233.41 Corp. Bond Int. 168,705.12 1.142.506.31
Dividendsllnterest 1,258,464.71 Credit Balance Int. 998.06 5,322.57
Miscellaneous 1.174.993.98 Reverse Repurchase Int. 150,243.08 1.523.787.61
Amount Credited $1.148.810.692.10 Total $1 408 707.79 $12 583 975.59
Securities Bought -1,147,503,302.86 Bond Purchase Int. -752.302.99 -6.392.956.47
Dividendsllnterest Charged -752.302.99 Repurchase lnt. Exp. -208.934.41 -1.500.580.05
Miscellaneous -345.310.50
Amount Debited $-1.148.600,916.35
Portfolio Composition Net Cash Activity 209.775.75
Cashstash Equivalent 221,488
ClosingBatance $221.487.52 Fixed Income 3.188,141
Total $3.409.629
Cash Balance Summary
OPENING CLOSING
Margin 11,711.77 221,48732
Net Cash Balance $11,711.77 $221.487.52
027 0001.135:13:39 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Jug 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MASSER OK File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash 8 Equivalent
s%
— Fixed Income
94%
UnWo0tel Grown aeocne Oat bane, melte shol
ma*, < vela, The elopers. re-cents-de I, otopme
item to etnel.te merlon rat), el )VV P.,6010
V895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SUBSIDIARy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
4 o ;$s
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
DESCPJP1ON
CASH BALANCE
SGMCLO.E1P
/AKAKET ESTIMATED CURRENT
Oil/daffy PACE VALUE ANNUAL INCOME YELD 14)
221.488
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS 5221.485
FIXED INCOME
Government & Agency Obligations
DESCRIPTION SGMOLCUSP
ACCT
TYPE OUANTITY PACE MARKET VALUE
ACCRUED
INTEREST
EsrmsTE0
ANNUAL NCOLIE
CIMR5W
YELL/ iN)
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN 14.468.859 5.9466 860.404 15.870 519.432 60.3707
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
DATED DATE 05/21/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 12/20/2029 3,90%
FACTOR .88845284
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC MRGN 14,505.776 6,1364 890.134
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DATED DATE 06/23.04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 05120/2030
FACTOR .90308336
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN 11,861.919 6,8431 811.726 6.638 398.323 49.0711
SERIES 2003.49 CLASS SW
DATED DATE 04/30/03
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 01/2512033 3.358%
FACTOR — .48800907
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAMER On File
LAST STATEMENT JuD 29.2005
027 OSOIXIS:13:Ze 001 .895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
wisCtLY OW,E0 SUOSIOMAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Your Portfolio Holdings (continued)
Government & Agency Obligations (continued)
DESLR "'ION SINEOLCUSP
ACCT
TYPE °UMW PRICE IAARKET VALLE
ACCRUED
MEREST
(STEAMED
ANNUAL INCOME
CURFENT
TED 19/
FEN. HOME LOAN MTG CORP/SIMS MRGN 466.211 21,4063 99.798 1.943 23,311 23,3582
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DATED DATE 11/01/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 12/01/2034 5400%
FACTOR - .93242216
Total Government& Agency Obligations 62,682,062 $24451 $941,068
Corporate Bonds
ACCT ittRuE0 ESTMAIW DATENT
DESCRIPTION $9.30UCUSP TYPE GUMMY PRICE IAARXET VN.LE entFEST ANNUM. INCOME YEW Phi
ALTERNATNE LOAN TRUST MRGN 35,363,806 1,0876 526,079 9.660 579.966 110,2431
SERIES 2004-30CB CLASS I -AS
DATED DATE 12/27/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 02/25/2035 1440%
FACTOR — 48409516
RATING: MOODY MA S&P MA
Total CorporateBonds $528,079 $9,660 1679,968
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 13.166.141 $34.115 $1.521,032
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAWR On File
LAST STATEMENT JO/ 29.2005
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLDING$ACCRUED INTEREST $34.115
YOUR PORTFOLIONOLDINGSESTIMATED ANNUAL INCOME $1.521.032
YOUR PRICEDPORTFOLIOHOLDINGS $3.409.629
027 OltIOS:12:29 001 VERE
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
YiIICtLY CA1T,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.outstanding as of date of statement
PM:WS& REPURCHASE PROM PURCHASE PRIM ACCRUED REPO CUNITIN
START DATE DATE RATE PRINCPAL MEREST* (FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTOR
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO JuR 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NURSER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 0729/05 OPEN 0.000 -50.000.000 SERIES 2003-13 CLASS 4.3587 oa25133
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIPS
(REPO) 08/01/05 09/01/05 3.730 -5.923.000 -19.024 -10.000.000 SERIES 352 CLASS PO 07101/34
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIP
(REPO) 08/01/05 09/01/05 3.730 -1.850.000 -5.942 -10.000.000 SERIES 353 CLASS 10 5.0000 07/01/34
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 08/01/05 09/01/05 3.730 -500.000 -1.605 -9.500.000 SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5,0000 12/01/34
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 08/12/05 09/12105 3.770 -13.401.000 -28.067 40.000.000 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 12/01132
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 08/12/05 09/12/05 3.770 -14.274.000 -29.896 -30.000.000 SERIES 346 CLASS PO 11/01/33
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 08/12/05 09/12/05 3.770 -3.938.000 -8.247 -20.000.000 SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU SOLD FREDOIEMAC STRIP
(REPO) 08/12/05 09/12/05 3.770 -3.124.000 -6.543 -20.000.000 SERIES 228 CLASS 10 6.0000 02/01/35
YOU SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 08/15/05 09/14/05 3.780 458.000 -817 -14.000.000 SERIES 2003-52 CLASS 3.4587 07/25/17
YOU SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 08/15105 09/15105 3.780 -384.000 -685 -11.000.000 SERIES 2003-52 CLASS 3.4587 07/25/17
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIPS
(REPO) °mates 09/19/05 3,810 -13.289.000 -19.689 -23.000.000 SERIES 352 CLASS PO 07/01/34
027 090I.0503:29 001 V891
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OWNED $UB9DAAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
7 s. ss
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.inc.outstanding as of date of statement (continued)
KROUSE(
START DATE
REPURCHASE
DATE
PRICING
RAM
PURCHASE atice,
PRINCIPAL
ACCRUED REPO
MEREST'
GUNFTITI
(FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTION
YOU SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MEG ASSOC
(REPO) 08/18/05 09/19/05 3,810 -1,216,000 -1.801 -27.112,874 SERIES 2004-30 CLASS 3,5906 02/20/32
YOU PROVIDED GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MEG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 08/26/05 OPEN 0,000 -26.400.000 SERIES 2004-5 CUSS P 3,3406 02/20133
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
(REPO) 08/29105 OPEN 0,010 -1 -9.724.538 SERIES 2886 CLASS SC 3,7287 07/15/19
YOU SOLD USTR 4,2500 08115/I5
(REPO) 08131/05 09401/05 3,200 -20.225.000 -1,797 -20.000.000
YOU SOUGHT USTR 4,0000 08/31/07
(REVERSEI 08:31,05 09(01/05 3.320 68.255.000 6.294 65030.003
TOTAL REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS £413.235.000 $6.294
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Jug 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAWR On File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
TOTAL REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS
As el sialcmool dam
$48.932.001 3424.113
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
STATEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRSTION
08101105 07/29(05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NDTE
04,125% MN 15
MATURITY
GVER REF tt G2105081 Al
SIMBOLCUSIP WANT& APACE DM AMOUNT
10,000,000 98,78125 9,878,125 ,00
ACCR, INT, 87.432,07
CREDIT APADutil
027 CGOI.05:I3:28 001 "895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHEEL? OMS*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
08/01105
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
07/28105 SOLD
OESORPTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE
03.875% JJ 31
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2O93006 B1
08101105 07/28/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY N3TE
03.875% JJ 31
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2O93006 Al
08/11/05 08/03105 BOUGHT FNMA-30YR(FNMA)OID
imwitSEIT.08/04 05.500%
7160000 BS
08/1 1105 07/15+05 CANCEL SELL FNMA-33YR(FNMA)OTD
amosSEIT.01VO4 05.500%
7180000 BS
AS OF 07/15+05
TO C/3. PREVIOUS SELL
S THEIOLCUSV
03,11.05 07:07.05 CANCEL SELL FNMA-33YR(FNMA)ETID
SETT.08/04
05.500 1
57310000 SS
AS OF 07/07105
TO C/3. PREVIOUS SELL
-23.000.000
PAIGE
99.80469
ACCR. INT.
ile3 Co
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERTOO Jug 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT JUN 29. 2006
DEBIT AMOUNT CREW MOW
22.955078 .13
2.421.87
-50.000.000 99.80469
ACCR. INT.
49.902.343 .75
5.264.95
1.000.000 100.45313 1.004.531 .25
30.000.000 100.82031 30.246.093.75
30.000.000 100.96875 30.290.625.00
OM 1105 07/29105 CANCEL SELL FNMA-30YR(FNMA)ETID
SETT O8104
05.500%
57090000 BS
AS OF 07+29.05
TO C/3. PREVIOUS SELL
40.000.000 100.50781 40.203.125.00
027 09,01,OS:10:28 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHCELY GMB*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE
Oen 1/05 07/11/05
08/1 1105 07/08105
OM 1/05 07/08/05
08111/05 08/0345
08/11/05 08/0345
08/11/05 07/15/05
TIANSAC110,1
BOUGHT
OESCRETION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)OTD
SETT.08104
040005.500% 57110000 BS
CANCEL SELL FNMA-30YRTHMAJO1D
05.500%
7250000 BS
AS OF 07/08105
TO C)3. PREVIOUS SELL
CANCEL SELL FNMA-30YRTNMA)G1D
SETT.08/04
05.500%
7250000 BS
AS OF 07/08/05
TO C)3. PREVIOUS SELL
BOUGHT FNMA-30YRTNMA)G1D
SETT 08104
05.500%
7180000 BS
CANCEL BUY FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT.0004
101.5 C6.5e"7160000 BS
AS OF 08/03105
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
SOW FNMA-30YRTNKIMG1D
SETT.08/04
01.11105.500
57180000 BS
itkl Co
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2006
THROUGH August 31.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER MASER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
SYMBOLCUS, OVANDO' ProcE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMSUNT
50.000.000 100.88281 50,441,406.25
VIM 50.000.000 100.96094 50.480.468.75
Mill 50.000.000 100.96094 50.480.470 .00
99.000.000 100.43750 99.433.125.00
-1.000.000 100.45313 1.004.531.25
-30.000.000 100.82031 30.246.093 .75
027 09,01,136:13:29 001 '.89S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOM.? GMB*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
089 1/05 07/07105 SOLD
0891105 07/29105 SOLD
08111/05 07/11105 CANCEL BUY
08 , l 1,05 07:0505 SOLD
08 ,11105 07/08105 SOLD
08111105 08/03105 CANCEL BUY
OESCRETION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)OM
SETT.08104
1~05.500%
57310000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)010
isaisSEIT.0844 05.500%
7090000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G10
SETT.08/04
1~05.500%
57110000 BS
AS OF 07/11105
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G10
SETT.08/04
1011.05.500%
57250000 BS
AS OF 07:0895
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G10
SETT.08104
, 05.500%
57250000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G10
SETT:38/04
05.500%
7180000 BS
AS OF 08/03105
TO CM. PREVIOUS BIN
itkl Co
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERTOO Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUIMER On File
LAST STATEMENT J011 29. 2005
SYMBOT.CUS, DANTint PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-30.000.000 100.96875 30290,625.00
-40.000.000 100.50781 40.203,125 90
-50.000.000 100.88281 50.441.406 ,25
-50.000.000 100.96094 50.480.468 .75
-50.000.000 100.96094 50.480.470 .00
-99.000.000 100.43750 99.433.125 .00
027 09,01,136:13:09 001 '.89S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
(AM,ED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE
esittes 0&03l05
comes 07/21105
08/11115 08/03/05
08/11115 07/21/05
08/11115 08/10.'05
08/12105 08111105
08/12/05 08/11105
TRANSACTION
BOUGHT
OESCRIPTION
FNMA 30Th GTO
SETT, 08/05
INNS 05.000%
7990000 BS
CANCEL SELL FNMA 30Th GTO
SETT, 08/05
~ 05.000%
57190000 BS
AS OF 07/21105
TO It PREVIOUS Sal.
CANCEL BUY FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT, 08/05
111. 505.003%
7990000 BS
AS OF 08/03105
TO It PREVIOUS BUY
SOLD FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT 08/05
05,000%
57190000 BS
BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04125% MN
MATURITY
GVER REF N G2222986 Al
BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04,125% MN
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2234235 Al
SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04125% MN
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2234830 Al
kf ,
FINANCAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* NEN 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAWR Cfl File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/29. 2005
SYMBOL:CUSP CAMMITY Pea DENT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
10.000.000 98.34766 9.834.765,63
10.000.000 98.59375 9.859.375 MO
-10.000.000 98,34766 9.834.765,63
-10.000.000 98.59375 9.859.375.00
5.000.000 98.06250 4.903.125.00
15 ACCR, NT, 49.320,65
30.000.000 98.25000 29.475.000.00
15 ACCR, NT, 299.28668
-30.000.000 98.34375 29,503,125.00
15 ACCR, INT, 299.286,68
027 0901,051 3:28 001 '.89S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOM.? (MSC> SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION OESCRETION STMEIOLCUSV OVANTITY nnicE DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT AMSUNT
08/12/05 08/11/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 15.000.000 99,56250 14.934.375,00
DUE 07/31/2007 03,875% JJ 31 ACCR. 18.953,80 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 4,108 % M MATURITY
GVER REF V G2233644 Al WWEB
08/1 5105 08/12105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10.000.000 99,70313 9.970.312,50
03,875% JJ 31
MATURITY
ACCR. WT, 15794,84
GVER REF # G2245038 Al
08/15105 06 112105 SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE NMI -20.000.000 99,65500 19.931.000 .00
03,875% JJ 31
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 31.589,67
GVER REF  #/02215035 A3
AS OF 08/12/05
08/16105 08/15/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -5.000.000 98,72266 4.936.132,81
04,125% MN 15
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 52.122,96
GVER REF V G2273023 Al
08/16105 08/15105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 5.000.000 99,90625 4.995.312.50
04,250% FA 15
MATURITY
ACCR. WT, 677.45
GVER REF # G2273026 Al
08/16105 08/15105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -10.000.000 99,68750 9.968.750,00
04,250% FA 15
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 1.154,89
GVER REF  #/02273919 Al
08/17/05 08/16105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10 030.000 100,25000 10.025.000.00
04,250% FA 15 ACCR. 2.309.78
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2285068 Al
itkl Co
FINANCAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER NADER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT JUN 29. 2005
027 09,01,136:13:09 001 '.89S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OwNED SUSDCHAAy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
13 O
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION Dues priON SIMEO-CUSP CAJANTID PRCE
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER RUMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT J011 29.
DEPT AMOUNT
CREDIT MOUNT
08717/05 08/16/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -10,000.063 99.73438 9.973.437.50
03.875% JJ 31 ACCR, INT. 17.900.82
. 0 MATURITY
GVER REF It G2284269 Al
08/18105 08117105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 25.000.000 99,83984 24.959.960.94
04.250% FA 15
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 8.661.68
GYER REF # G2294678 Al
08/18/05 08/17105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -25.000.000 100.07813 25.019.631 .25
04.250% FA 15
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 8.661.68
GYER REF # G2292609 Al
08/1 9/05 08/18105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10.000.000 100.26563 10.026.562.50
04.250% FA 15 ACM INT. 4.619.57
MATURITY
GVER REF es G2303843 Al
08/1 9/05 08/18105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE EMI -10.000.000 100.12500 10.012.600 .00
04.250% FA 15
0 MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 4.619.57
GVER REF It 02303360 Al
08122/05 08/19/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10,030.000 100.31250 10,031,250.00
DUE 08/15/2015 04,250% FA 15
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS ACCR, INT, 8.08424
YIELD 4.211 % TO MATURITY
GYER REF # G2313898 Al WWEB
08.22/05 08/19105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 25.000.000 100.34375 25,085,937.50
DUE 08/15/2015 04.250% FA 15 ACM INT, 20.210.60 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 4.207 % TO MATURITY
GYER REF # G2348702 S1
AS OF 08/19/05
027 000145:13:29 001 Y893
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
y/NO.E.Y Cms*0 SUEISIOany
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
ilkl Co
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 NEN 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION OESCRETION STMEIOLCUSV CIJANTITe PRCE
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WISNER On File
LAST STATEMENT J011 29.
DEBIT AMOUNT
GRIM MIDUNT
08(22/05 08/19/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -25.000.000 100.26563 25.066.406.25
04.250% FA 15 ACCR, INT. 20,210.60
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2313522 Al
08(22/05 08/19105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE 10.000.000 99.75000 9.975.000.00
03.875% JJ 31 ACM T. 23.165.76
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2313868 Al
0822/05 PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN -166.188
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
3.770 DUE 12/20/29
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 08-20-05
08(22/05 PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC -150.917
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DUE 05/20/30
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 08-20-05
0824105 08/23105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10.000.000 100.57813 10.067.812.50
04.250% FA 15 ACCR. M. 10.394.02
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2354385 Al
08/24105 08/23105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -10.000.000 100.40625 10.040,625 (00
04.250% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 10,39442
0 MATURITY
GVER REF At G2352709 Al
08125/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 128,288.70
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PRIN WC( 07-05 PA) 08-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
027 020145:12:29 001 11895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHCXLY OWNED SUBSDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
15 ci
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
08/25M5
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
PRINCIPAL
DESCRPTION
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
WE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN RID 07-05 PM 08-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
08(25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
3.358 DUE 01125/33
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 08-25-05
08/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
WE 11/01/33
KIN RID 07-05 PM 08-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
09025/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
WE 11/01/33
PAIN RID 07-05 PM 08-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
09025/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001 DUE 07/01/34
PAIN RID 07-05 PA 08-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
0845 105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001 DUE 07/01/34
PAIN RID 07-05 PA) 08-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
08125/05 PRINCIPAL ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST
SERIES 2004-3008 CLASS 1-A-8
1.640 DUE 02125P35
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 08-25-05
STUD0ALISP OJAturre PEKE
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO Jug 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WOOER GT1 File
LAST STATEMENT JUN 29. 2005
DENT AMOUNT CR= AMOUNT
384,866.10
-325.337
168.299.20
336.598.40
241.100.60
654.531.38
-985.861
027 00010S:13:29 001 1896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHEEL? (MSC> SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE mANssicnom OESCRPTION STMOOLCUMP OVANDO, PRCE DEBIT AMOUNT GRECO ARVUNT
08(26105 08/25105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 18.000.000 99.77344 17.959.218.75
03.875% JJ 31
MATURITY
ACCR, 4#279.89
GYM REF # 02373905 at
08,26+05 08/25/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 50.000.000 99.77344 49.886.718,75
03.875% JJ 31 ACCR. WT. 136.888,59
MATURITY
GYM REF # G2373905 Al
08,29105 08126+05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 5.000.000 100.79688 5.039.843,75
04.250% FA 15 AC08. INT. 8.084,24
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2382619 Al
08,2945 08126/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE EMI -5.000.000 100.65625 5.032.812.50
DUE 08/15/2015 04.250% FA 15 ACCA. INT. 8.084.24 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 4.169 % TO MAttIRITY
GVER REF # 02412240 Al WINES
AS OF 08726105
08,30,05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMUSERIES 2886 111111111 SC-VO RTR
3.728 DUE 07/15/19
08,31105 08/30/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 5.000.000 100.67188 5,033,593,75
04.250% FA 15 ACM. NE 9,239,13
MATURITY
GVER REF # 02422297 Al
08,31105 08130.'05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 15.000.000 99,97656 14,996.484,38
04.000% FA 28
MATURITY
GYM REF # 02423132 Al
027 09,0105:13:39 001 11896
,iIk1 Co
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Ju// 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER KINDER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT JUN 29. 2005
CLEARED IFIROuGH ITS
ViHC‘LY en‘v.eo SUEISID4ARY
BEAR
STD;RNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
FINANCiAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEAK* JuB 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANS/CT/DM °ESCAPISM SIMBEACEIMP CAJUVrity PRZE
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AVISER
LAST STATEMENT
DENT AMOUNT
On FAA
J01129. 2005
CREPT MAJUNT
08/31105 08/30105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -15.000.000 99,99219 14.998.828.13
04,000% FA 28
MATURITY
GVER REF it 62423964 Al
08,31/05 08/25105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY LADTE ~I -18.000.000 100,00000 18.000.000 .00
04,000% FA 28
MATURITY
GVER REF Tt 62373906 BI
0841/05 08/25105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY LADTE ~I -50.000.000 100,00000 50.000.000 .00
04,000% FA 28
MATURITY
GVER REF tt 62373906 Al
TOTAL 14340,259621.44 3879.689.952.28
INTEREST
DATE OESCRPTHEN SYMBOLICUSIP OMMAITY RATE I%1 DENT AMOUNT [PEW AMOUNT
08101/05 AVG BAL 467,110 RT 2.481
021 OFFICE INTEREST 0705
08/15105 FEDL HOME LOAN ATM CORPMS 10109
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5,000
INT RID 07-05 P/D 08-15-05
REPO P &I 5,0000
08/I 5105 FEDL HOME LOAN VATG CORN/610109
SERES 227 CLASS n
DUE 1210112034 5,000
INT RID 07-05 P/D 08-15-05
REPO P &I 5,0000
998,06
5,0000 1.967,86
5,0000 37.389,40
027 096166:13:29 001 V895
CLEARED 1KROUGH ITS
vusou.v cuw.E0 8,18504.4ov
BEAR
STD;RNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
r. ql
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYERm.493ER OnfIle
LAST STATEMENT AA/ 29. 2005
DATE DESORPTION SYMEIWCUSIP a/Pinny RATE 1%/ DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
08115405 FEDL HOME LOAN MI6 CCIVWS10109 5.0000 78.714.53
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT R/D 07-05 PAD 08-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
08/15+05 FREDDIE MAC CMDSER1ES 2886 3.9110 11.317.04
SC-VO RIR
DUE 07/15/2019 3,911
INT R/D 07-05 Pit 08-15-05
REPO P & I 3.9118
5/05 FREDDIE MAC CMDSERIES 2886 3.9110 16.196.21
SC-VO RTR
DUE 07/15/2019 3,911
INT R/D 07-05 PM 08-15-05
REPO P & I 3,91 18
OM 5+05 TEDL HOME LOAN IRTG GORP#S 10110 6.0000 87.142.06
SERES 228 CLASS ID
DUE 02/01/2035 6.000
INT R/D 07-05 PAD 08-15-05
REPO P &I 6.0000
0822/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MID ASSN MIN 3.5200 51.626,67
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 3.520
INT R/D 07-05 PAD 08-20-05
REPO P &I 3.5200
0822/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTE1 ASSN 3.5200 77.440.00
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/2012033 3.520
INT R/D 07-05 PAD 08-20-05
REPO P & I 3.5200
08/22/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MIG ASSN INS 3.7700 75.876.80
SERES 2004-30 CLASS SU
DUE 02/2012032 3,770
INT R/D 07-05 PM 08-20-05
REPO P & I 3.7700
027 090183533:29 001 v895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWX*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTER EST (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jug 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMMER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29. 2005
DATE DESORPTION SYMEIMICUSIP QUANTITY RATE ITN DEW AMOUNT MEM AMOUNT
08022t5 GOVERNMENT SAMNA/ MTO ASSN 3,7700 45.978.44
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
DUE 12/20/2029 3.770
INTEREST PAYMENT 08-20.05
08/22/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSOC MEI 46.046.44
SERES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DUE 05/20/2030 0.000
INTEREST PAYMENT 08-20.05
08125/05 FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003.13 4,3580 91 514,47
S RCA-I/0 RTR
DUE 03/254033 4.358
INT RID 07-05 PAD 08-25-05
REPO P S I 4.5400
08,25/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 3,3580 35.952,40
SERES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DUE 01/25/2033 3.358
INTEREST PAYMENT 08-25.05
08125:05 FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003.52 3.4580 22.557.38
KS-W3 RTR
DUE 07/25/2017 3.458
INT RID 07-05 PAD 08-25-05
REPO P 8I 3.6400
0812905 FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003.52 3.4580 28.709,39
KS-I/O RTR
DUE 07/252017 3.458
INT RID 07-05 PA 08-25-05
REPO P 8I 3.6400
0802905 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 5.0000 37.648,21
SERES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 07-05 PM 08-25-05
REPO P 8I 5.0000
027 OSOITTS:l3:09 001 VII9S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED $UB9OIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
20 s! s!.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
DATE DESCRIPTION
08/25/05 ALTERNATIVE LOPN TRUST
SERES 2004-3008 CLASS 1-A-8
DUE 02/25/2035 1.640
INTEREST PAYMENT 08-25.05
TOTAL $794.752.74
CREDIT AMOUNT
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTION SYMBOL.CUSJP 0.:NYHTY MIT AMOUNT
0801105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN -8.299.585 5.923.000.00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001 DUE 07/01/34
FITM F2133186 Al
REPO AGREEMENT
08101105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN 8.299,585 6,373.000 00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
?int
FITM
osigne sz
TERM RatraaMENT 08101+05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN IMMO 9.035,569 1.737.000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000
FITI14 31.2
TERM ENT
08101+05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -9.035.569 L850.000,00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 DUE 07/01+34
FITM F2133186 81
REPO AGREEMENT
0841+05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CalP4S10109 8.973,456
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
SYMBOUtuSTP OVAATIIIY RATE 1%4
1.6400
DEBIT AMOUNT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NASSER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
49.677.40
5.000
FITI14 310 34A2
TERM DENT
027 M01.05:13:28 001 '.1193
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED $00901ARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACDON DESCRPRON
08.101105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPaS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSITAIMM AlairAl
REPO
0801105 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05/192015 4.125
4.1253101i5
FITM A2
TERM EMENT
08101105 RECEIVED TINTED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 07131/2007 3.875
3.875 1117
FILM AI
RESALE T
08 101/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
DUE 07310 0.001
FITM BZ
REPO I
08 101/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 0710 5.000
FITM A2
REPO I
0801105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05/1. 1.125
ea/ yes JOURNAL UNITED A E
FITM A
4.125
A l
, 15
REPO AGREEMENT
SYME/CIALOSIP
FINANCAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER OR Fee
LAST STATEMENT Jilt 29. 2005
QUANTITY OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-8.973,456 500.000.00
-10.000.000 10.025.000 .00
73.000.000 73.000.000.00
20.053,71
5.465,76
6.970.16
-5.000.000 4.931,250 .00
027 000105:13:29 001 V893
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
wilCu.Y OwNEO SUBODIARy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
22 a v.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON
08112105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL WM ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
TERRARM Ant / NT
08/I2+05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
TERMRW  RMINM AZENT
08/I 245 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MICI ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM Milli DI
REPO A
SYMEICIJCUSIP CVANTRY DEBIT AMOUNT
4.677.451 3,562,000.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
14.032.355 10.686.000 po
-18.709.806 13.401.000.00
08/I2105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
FITM CZ
TERM MENT
08/I2105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL WO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
FMB AZ
TERM MENT
6.637,070 5.060.000 .00
13,274.141 10.120.000.00
08/12105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
ATM CI
REPO A
08/12105 JOURNAL FEDL WItIE LOAN tin CORPoSt0i09
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000 '
FITM AZ
TERM MENT
-19.911.211 14.274.000 .00
18.648.443 3,788.000.00
027 09,01.05:13:29 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY 01VNE0 SUBODIARv
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON
08/12/05 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CORP9S10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSITTAMM AlarB1
REPO
08/12105 JOURNAL FREOOIE MAC CMO,SERIES 2886
SC-/0 FUR
3.911 1#1 4.19
FITM Al
REPO A
08112+05 JOURNAL FREOOIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886
SC-/0 FUR
3.9113.119
FITM AZ
TERM MENT
08112+05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG OCAPt/S Ot 10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.00031.35
FITM BZ
TERM AAENT
08112+05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPOS10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000 jos s RIM Al
REPO A
2+05 RECEIVED UNTIED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 07+31/2007 3.875
3.875 DOW
FITM Al
RESALE
08112+05 DEUVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 07/31,2037 3.875
3.13751 . 7
FITM A2
TERM t WENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jug 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jug 29.2005
Symectocuse OUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-18.648.443 3.938.000.00
-3.471.600 182,000.00
3.471,600 197,000.00
16,861.393 2,818.000.00
.16 861.393 3.124.000.00
58.000.000 58.000.000.00
-73.000.000 73.000.000.00
027 OSOIXIS:13:Ze 001 •.'893
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OWNED SUEISTDIAAy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
24 c? »
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEM.EmENT TFLTDE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRITTON SYMEICIAUSIP MUNDY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
08112/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN 10,980.85
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 01 i  0.000
MITA AZ
REPO I
08/12105 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MID ASSN 32,942,56
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE Ojai. 0.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
08/12105 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN 15,598,86
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11 0.000
FITM CZ
REPO I
08/I 2105 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MITI ASSN BIM 31.197,71
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11 0.000
RIM AZ
REPO I
08/12105 INTEREST FEDL !CAE LOAN MTG CCAP#S10109 11,677,56
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 1 5,000
FITM A2
REPO I
08.1 2/05 INTEREST FREDDIE MAC CMCASERIES 2886 VIM 607.31
SC-I/0 FLTR
DUE 07/10 3.911
FITM AZ
REPO I
08112)05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPoS10t 10 Inn 8.687.27
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
DUE 02) 6.000
RIM BZ
REPO
027 090105:13:28 001 '.1193
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
yniCu.Y MINED SUBSTCHAFTy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
25 i »
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRNISACOON DESCRPTICH SYMOCIAUSIP OVANDO, OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
08112/05 INTEREST UWE° STATES TREASURY NOTE 66,713.89
DUE 07i2J_2061.7_ _1875
aim RIP 0815105 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003.52 MIS 7.436.499
KS-ItO FOR
3.640R1117
FIRM A2
TERM GENT
0815105 JOURNAL FANNIE El.* CMOGERIES 2003.52 SIM -7A36.499 384,000.00
KS-I/0 FUR
3.6401117
FIRM Al
REPO
0815105 JOURNAL FANNIE RAE CAANSERIES 2003.52 -9.464.635 458,000.00
KS-I/0 FUR
3.64011117
FITM At
REPO
08/1 5105 JOURNAL FANNIE El.* CMOISERIES 2003.52 9.464.635 509.000.00
KS-I/0 FUR
3.6403".17
FITM AZ
TERM MENT
owl sros JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN -26.400,000 2.333.000.00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
3.520
FIRM AI
REPO A
0815105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 26.400,000 2.440.000.00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER ALTMSER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
3.520
FITM 311.2
TERM ENT
027 000145:13:29 001 11895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOALY OUS*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STURNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
=Pm 26
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYMOCtiCtISIP CAINTur DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
08/I 5105 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -58.000.000 58.000.000 .00
DUE 07/31/2007 3.875
3.875 7
FITM A2
TERM e ENT
08/I 5105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE VIM 68,000.000 68.085.000.00
DUE 07/31/2007 3.875
3.875 Dilit7
FITM
RESALE
Al
T
08/I5/05 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003.52 1.633.32
KS-I/0 FLTR
DUE 07:10. 3.640
FITM Q
REPO I
08/15105 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 8.007.27
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE Oa.  3.520
FITM AZ
REPO I
08/15105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIN 11 116.67
DUE 07/11 1.875
081I8'05 JOURNAL FREOOIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886 4.856.023
SC-D0 FUR
3.72831ill 9
FITM A2
TERM MENT
08/16/05 JOURNAL FREOOIE MAC CMOGERIES 2886 .4.856.023 258.000.00
SC-00 FLTR
3,728 19
FITM AI
REPO
08/16/05 JOURNAL WINED TATE TREASURY NOTE 5.000.000 4.931.250 .00
FITM A2
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
4.125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
027 OtiOlitIS:13:29 001 11895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
?RIMY CAM,*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STURNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
=Pm 27
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TIVINSACTION DESERTION SYMOCCCUSIP MAMMY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
08/16105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 5.000.000 5.000.000,00
DUE 08t15,2015 4.250
4,250 DOC
F1TM Al
RESALE
081 6105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 510,93
DUE 4.125
FILM A2
REPO I
08/17105 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -5.000.000 5.000.000.00
DUE OS/19201S 4.250
5 4.2SORMI EI
F1TM A2
TERM EMENT
08117105 JOURNAL UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE -5.000,000 5.000.000.00
FILM Al
4.250 15
REPO AGREEMENT
08117105 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -68.000.000 88.085.000.00
DUE 07+31/2007 3.875
3.875 7
FILM A2
TERM ENT
08117105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 78.000.000 78.195.000,00
DUE 07+31+2007 3,875
ROA Al
3,875 la?
RESALE T
08117105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 452.78
DUE 03+0110 1250
02.+17+05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10,477,53
DUE 07+VS 1.875
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER On File
LAST STATEMENT JuN 29.2005
027 0901.05:13:211 001 V89S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WIICU.Y OWNED SUEIRDMAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
28 I ))
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEM.EmENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTICH
08/18.05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2004.30 CLASS SU
3.770RIli r
FITM C2
TERM MENT
08.18(05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MM ASSN
SERIES 2004.30 CLASS SU
3.770M2
FITM Al
REPO
MI 695 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001
FITM AI
REPO P.
08/18/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MFG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.0013.4
FITM A2
1TERM MENT
08/18/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL KM ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
DUE 073.0 0.001
FITM A2
REPO I
08022)05 JOURNAL UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE
FITM A2
4.250 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
084245 JOURNAL UNITED T SURY NOTE
FITM Al
4.250 15
REPO AGREEMENT
0842/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 07t3 I 2007 3.875
3.875 00.7
FITM Al
RESALE T
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WIESER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
SYMEOCIAUSIP QUANTITY CEBU AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
24,151,766
-24.151,766 1.216.000.00
-18,534,514 13.289.000.00
ISM 18,534.514 13.954.000.00
3136FD(C9 43.617,88
5.000.000 5.000.000.00
-15.000.000 15.037.500 .00
68.000.000 68.170.000.00
027 ORDIXIS:IS:al 001 va9S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMY*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
=Pm 29
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE DINCADRON DESCRPDON STIABOLcoste CVANTIlY 01931T AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
08/22/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -78.000.000 78.195.000 .00
DUE 07/31/2007 3.875
3.875 30. 7
FITM A2
TERM t EMENT
08/22/05 INTEREST LINTS) STATES TREASURY NOTE NMI 2.348.61
DUE O8! 4,250
FITM A2
REPO I
08/22/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE NEI 31.864.46
DUE Ole 1.875
08/26105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN -26.400.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
3.340
FITM G REPO A
08/26105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT STATIONAL MTO ASSN 26.400.000 2.333.000 .00
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
3.340
FITM A2
TERM MENT
08/26105 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -68.000.000 68.170.000 .00
DUE 07+31/2007 3.875
3,875 7
FITM A2
TERM ENT
08/26105 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 2.694.61
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
DUE 02.11 3.340
FITM A2
REPOT
08/26+05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 22.647.59
DUE 07/312=7_ _S.875
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jug 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT 2UP/ 29.2005
027 090105:13:28 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OtVNE0 SUEIRDIARy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON
08,29105 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CORPaS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5,000
FITM AWE TERM MEAT
0849(05 JOURNAL FREOOIE MAC CMO,SERIES 2886
SC4/0 FUR
3,728 1#1 4.19
FITM Al
REPO A
0802945 JOURNAL FREOOIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886
SC4/0 FLTR
3,72831019
FITM A2
TERM AAENT
08029/05 JOURNAL FREOOIE MAC CMO,SERIES 2886
SC4/0 FLTR
3,728 19
FITM A2
TERM ENT
08029/05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPOS 10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE Ills 5.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
08029435 INTEREST FREOOIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886
SC4/0 FUR
DUE 07:1 3228
ATM A2
REPO I 110 1
08029/05 INTEREST FREDDIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886
SC4/0 FLTR
DUE 07.6 3.728
ATM A2
REPO I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jug 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Ale
LAST STATEMENT AS/ 29.2005
SYMECIAUSIP PAUCITY OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
466,211 96.000,00
43249,152
3.393.128 182.030.03
Min 4.856,023 258.000.00
NMI 307.52
324.01
353.10
027 0901 XIS:13:311 001 "895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WNW?? OWNED $U89DIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLETAENT
DATE
08,31105
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTICAT
JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
ATM pm A2
4.250 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
08,31105 JOURNAL
ATM
4.250
REPO AGREEMENT
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
Al
WANTITT
15.000.000
Men AMMO
15,037,500.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER whiSER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
-20.000.000 20.225.000 .00
08,31105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 08/31/2007 4.000
4D00
Al FITM A
RESALE T
68,000.000 68.255.000 .00
0841105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 08311. 4.250
FRM A2
REPO I
11,925,57
TOTAL $407.995.684.41 $466.948.993.08
MISCELLANEOUS
DATE
I.030AT TRANSACTION
08101105 JOURNAL
DESCRIPTION
FR CMDY NC
DOW AMOUNT CREDIT NADUNI
134,475.00
08102)05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 45,575.00
08103/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 29.425 p0
08105.05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC
0810845 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC
8.673.61
128.764,50
08.0945 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 83.571,00
027 OltlitIS:13:29 001 $895
CLEARED IHR00GH ITS
WHOM.? OBBSO SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS (continued)
DATE
MCDDAY TRANSLCTEXI
0811 1105 JOURNAL
DESCRIPTION
FMIA3OYR(FMN)GTO
SETT,08/04
5,500 DUE 08101/34
MBS NET 08/11/05
DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMMO
341,250,00
08/1 1/05 JOURNAL FNMA 30YR OTD
SETT, 08/05
5,000 DUE 08101/35
MBS NET 08/11/05
24,609,37
08/12105 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 183878,50
owists JOURNAL FR CMDY A/C 163.615,50
0211645 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC
0824/05 JOURNAL
28.494,50
TO CMDY NC MEM 130.387,50
0,82905 JOURNAL JULY 05 CLR FEES PART u 2.450.00
0212905 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 7,25080
082945 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 94.837,50
08/30/05 JOURNAL
TOTAL
FR CMDY NC 118947,50
8345,310.50 41,174,993,96
itkl Co
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AANMER OII Ale
LAST STATEMENT Jul/ 29.2005
021 09,01A3S:13:29 001 11896
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
INTICtLY OWNED $ORSIOIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
33 c?
Trades Executed Pending Settlement
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTION
09/01105 08/31105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY N3TE
04.000% FA 28
RUT'
GVER REF # Al
OSVICOS 08111105 BOUGHT FNMA-30YFONMA)GID
SETT,09/05
lailli#006.000%
57230000 BS
09(l COS 08/17105 BOUGHT FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
sErLogros 0. 10005.000% 67170000 BS
0904/05 08/ I W05 BOUGHT FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
sErLogros
57060000 BS
09/14105 08/31105 BOUGHT FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
SETT 09/05
05,000%
57020000 BS
09/14105 08/03+05 SOLD FNMA-30YFONMAAID
SETT 09/05
05,000%
57150000 BS
09/14105 08/11105 SOLD FNMA-30YR(FNMA)01D
SETT 0905
F 05.000%
57170000 BS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT! NUMBER
TAXPAYER KUMMER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT Juy 29, 2005
STIVEICXXLISS' MAMMY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREC0 AMOUNT
18,000,000.00 100.1171 18,023,082.70
50.000.000 p0 98.1718 49.085.937.50
50.000.000.00 98.3828 49.191.406.25
50.000.000.00 98.4921 49.246.093.75
10.000.000.00 99.0937 9.909.375.00
-10.000.000,00 98.2031 9.820.312.50
-50.000.000 .00 98.1562 49.078.125 .00
027 M01.05:13:28 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
yniCu.Y °NIXED SUEINDMAy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
34 c!
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
09/14105 08/17105 SOLD
0914105 08/19/05 SOLD
0914105 08/03/15 SOLD
0914105 08/03105 SOLD
09/14105 08/15/05 BOUGHT
0914105 08/23/05 BOUGHT
0914105 08/16105 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.09/05
05,00096
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)610
SETT.09/05
101011106.000%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)610
SETT.09/105
/1101.05.500%
FNMA 30TRtFNMA)310
SETT,OS 05
lippici5.500%
FNMA-3cnitFNMAAID
SETT 09;05
06.000%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT 09/05
06.000%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)010
SETT 0905
. 06.000%
57090000 BS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT Jut/ 29. 2005
S0.180..CuSP PR CE DEOIT AMOUNT Crag MOUNT
BS
-50.000.000 .00
-50.000.000 ,00
98.3007
98.5507
49.150.390 .63
49.275.390 ,63
BS
-1.000.000,00 100.2851 1.002.851.56
BS
-99.000.000.00 100.2696 99.262.968 .75
BS
50.000.000.00 101.9609 50.980.468.75
BS
50.000.000.00 102.0468 51.023.437.50
BS
-50.000.000 .00 102.0859 51.042,968 .75
027 09,01.05:13:28 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
valCu.Nr °mai SUBSCIAAv
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
35 c?
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION
09/14105 08/23105 SOLD
TOTAL
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* JuN 30.2005
THROUGH August 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER On File
LAST STATEMENT JUP/ 29.2005
DESCRIPTION SIIMOOLCuS.P OUANTITY PR CE DEOIT AMOUNT
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G10
SETT.09/05
lai.06,000%
57140000 BS
-50,000.000.00 102,0937
CREPT AlKuNT
51.046.875.00
1277.459.801.45 $35967968232
Tho above woos m 1101applarinary oil*/ sactI  olihd stalornont
End of Statement
027 09,01'05:13:28 001 Y895
GUARD) THROUGH ITS
yo•oxsy (Hoof.° SUBSIDIARY
BUR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSITE vomv.bearstearns.com
What's In This Statement
Financial Summary  3
Your Portfolio Holdings   4
Transaction Detail   7
Trades Not Yet Settled   31
Your Portfolio at a Glance
TOTAL VALUE OF SECURITIES THIS PERIOD
LONG ACCRUED INTEREST
NET CREDIT BALANCE
3,204,048
25,795
11,712
llllllllllllllllll I ll
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
0/0 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Market Value of Your Portfolio
cash & Equivain $359,985
NET EQUITY TIPS PERIOD $3,241,555
NET EQUITY LAST STATEMENT
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT
3,835,574
-594,020
There are no 'Stop loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on tile for your account.
Rxecl
Income
204.048
$3.442.68
Current market Sue
NE Last statements market value
Bear SZOS'n5 Secyyt
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEF000 Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul/ 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMEIER On Fee
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
SIK TOT Pang R for offroloholsol pflosts Gay Rasta sltrilled as  domenoN
ststernorg should be Maned TN your words S.. rooms Ws fee npolart ricernHco
027 07/300500:09 00l
CLEARED 'THROUGH RS
WHOLLY OBAED SUBSIDIARY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 U132
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
027 07,3005:10:09 001 V895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SLIEINDMAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
3 c/ ;t2
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PEFICO
Income Summary PEFICO YEAS TO DATE
Opening Balance $359,965.49 U.S. Govt. Bond Int. 554.34 a02 4.236.006.89
Govt. Agency Int. 497.289.51 4.609.911.42
Secudties Sold 854,425,255.21 Corp. Bond Int. 175.881.40 968,584.32
Dividends Interest 1,211,189.06 Credit Balance Int. 77900 4,324.51
Miscellaneous 1,113,665.86 Reverse Repurchase Int. 0.00 1.163.243.87
Amount Credited $856,750,110.13 Total $1 228 292.93 $10 982 071.01
Secudties Bought -855,443,996.18 Bond Purchase Int. -491.945.30 -5,640.653.48
Funds Withdrawn -71.745.00 Repurchase Int. Exp. 000 -1.098.448.85
Dividends/Interest Charged 491.945.30
Miscellaneous -1,090.677.37
Portfolio Composition Amount Debited $857.098,363.85
CashtCash Equivalent 11,712
Net Cash Activity -348.253.72
Fixed Income 3.204,048
Closing Balance $11,711.77
Total $3215,760
Cash Balance Summary
OPEtin0 CUZGINO
Margin 359.965.49 11,711.77
Net Cash Balance $359,965.49 $11,711.77
027 07,3000S:10:09 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH July 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER Ausa3ER OII File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash & Equivalenti
1%
Fixed Income
99%
UmPocied crown Pena* 0ell eebnoo onto PNI
male vela, The elaNsaa INNemar Ia de•ued
Iran Vo etnalxe mole rat), oi >vv palkno
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
mow? OwNED $UB9OIAAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
4 c/ ;t2
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
oTsCRP-iou
CASH BALANCE
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS $11.712
S•meCLOStP
fAAPKET ESTIMATED Cul:PENT
OuANTITy PACE vALuE NWJAL Inte )E1.0
11.712
FIXED INCOME
Government & Agency Obligations
DESCRIPTION
ACC'
SYFECLOJSP TYPE OLuunly PRICE IAARKET VALLE
ACCRUED
MEREST
ESTMATEO
*NAVAL MOM
CONTENT
YIELD DM
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN 14,635.047 5.8146 850.969 13,794 551,741 64.8368
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
DATED DATE 05121/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 12/20/2029 3.770%
FACTOR — .89865757
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC MRGN 14,656.693 6.0902 892.616
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DATED DATE 06123104
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 05120/2030
FACTOR — .91247898
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN 12,187,256 7.4140 903.557 4.793 431.429 47.7478
SERIES 2003.49 CLASS SW
DATED DATE 04/30/03
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 01/25/2033 3.540%
FACTOR — .50139372
Total Government& Agency Obligations $2,647.142 $18,587 $983.170
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMBER Cfl File
LAST sTATELIENT June 30.2005
027 07.301Z:10:09 001 VS95
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOM.Y 01VIVE0 SUBSTEHART
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
5 c, ;t2
Your Portfolio Holdings (continued)
Corporate Bonds
DESCITIPTION SHABOLOASP
ACCT
TYPE OLIANTITY PRICE MARKET VALUE
ACCR-TO
MEREST
ESTATE'S)
ANNUAL INCOME
CURRENIT
yet/ IV
ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST
SERIES 2004-3008 CLASS I -A-8
DATED DATE 12/27/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 02/25/2035 1.785%
FACTOR — .90874168
RATING: MOODY AM S&P AM
Total CorporateBonds
MRGN 36.349,667 1.5321 556.906
$556.906
7.208
57.208
648,842
5648.842
116.5084
TOTAL FIXED INCOME $3.204.048 525.795 $1.632.012
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLDINGSACCRUED INTEREST $25.795
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLDINGSESTIMATED ANNUAL INCOME $1.632.012
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS 53.215.760
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Auk, I . 2005
THROUGH Jul, 29. 2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER /AMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.outstanding as of date of statement
PUROTASE/
START DATE
REPURCHASE
DATE
PR CO/5
PA'S
PURCHASE PRICE/
PRIPICIAAL
ACCRUED REPO
MEREST'
COWEN
(FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTOR
YOU SOW GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 06/27/05 OPEN 0.010 -1 -27,112,874 SERIES 2004-30 CLASS 3.7700 02/20/32
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
(REPO) 06/27/05 OPEN 0.010 -1 -5,724,538 SERIES 2886 CLASS SC 3.9118 07/15/19
YOU SOW FANNIE MAE STRIPS
(REPO) 06/30/05 08/01/05 3.540 -6.373.000 -20.053 -10,000,000 SERIES 352 CLASS PO 07/01/34
021 0740131:10:09 001 11195
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SUBSDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
6 c, ;t2
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.inc.outstanding as of date of statement (continued)
PLACKASS REPURCHASE PRICING PURCHASE PRICE; ACCRUED REPO OUPARITY
START DATE DATE RAM PAINCPAL MEREST' (FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTION
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER RAMER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIP
(REPO) 06/30/05 08/01/05 3.540 -1,737,000 -5.465 -10,000,000 SERIES 353 CLASS 10 5.0000 07/01/34
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 07/12/05 08/12/05 3.580 -10.686,000 -21,253 -30.000,000 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 07/12/05 08/12/05 3.580 -10.120.000 -20,127 -20.000.000 SERIES 346 CLASS PO 11/01/33
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 07/12/05 08/12/05 3.580 -3.562.000 -7.084 -10.000.000 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
(REPO) 07/12/05 08/12/05 3.580 -197.000 -391 -4.000.000 SERIES 2886 CLASS SC 3.9118 07/15/19
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 07/12/05 08/12/05 3.580 -5.060.000 -10.063 -10.000.000 SERIES 346 CLASS PO 11/131/33
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 07/12/05 08/12/05 3.580 -3.788.000 -7.533 -20.000.000 SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU SOW FREDDIEMAC STRIP
(REPO) 07/12/05 08/12/05 3.580 -2.818.000 -5.604 -20.000,000 SERIES 228 CLASS 10 6.0000 02/01/35
YOU SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 07/13/05 08/15/05 3.580 -2.440.000 -4.610 -26.400,000 SERIES 2004-5 CLASS P 3.5200 02/20/33
YOU SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 07/14/05 08/15/05 3.610 -509.000 -918 -14.000.000 SERIES 2003-52 CLASS 3.6400 07/25/17
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 07/14/05 OPEN 0.000 -11.000.000 SERIES 2003-52 CLASS 3.6400 07/25/17
027 07.30,0S:10:09 001 1,1996
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY 01MNIEO $UB9OIAAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
7 c/ ;t2
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.inc.outstanding as of date of statement (continued)
PLFICNASS REPURCHASE
START DATE DATE
PRICING
RATE
PURCHASE PRICE, ACCRUED REPO
PAINCPAL MEREST'
CAMARITY
(FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTION
FANNIE MAE STRIPS
SERIES 352 CLASS PO 07101/34
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Pk
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 07/18/05 08/18/05 3.630 -13.954,000 -19.698 -23.000,000
YOU PROVIDED
(MARGIN) 07/29/05 OPEN 0.000 -50.000,000
FEDERAL. NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
SERIES 2003-13 CLASS 4.5400 Oa/25.133
YOU SOW
(REPO) 07/29/05 08/29/05 3.720 -96.000 -29 -500,000
FEDERAL. HOME LOAN STRIP
SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU PROVIDED
(MARGIN) 07/29/05 OPEN 0.000 -9.500.000
FEDERAL. HOME LOAN STRIP
SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU BOUGHT
(REVERSE) 07/22/05 OPEN
TOTAL REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS
2.640 10.025.000 6.970 10.000.000
USIA 4.1250 05115/15
$10.025.000 $6.970
TOTAL REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS 5.61.340.002 $-122.828
'As Cl siltrran: <WO
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION
07/01/05 06/30/05 SOLD
DESORPTION S10.480...CuSp
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
1040.7.625% JO 30
. MATURITY
OVER REF # 01813788 BI
QUANTITY
.15,000.000
PRCE
99.99770
ACCR. INT.
DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT WONT
14.999.655.00
1.477.58
027 023001210:09 001
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION OESCRPTION STIA1306'COSP OVANTITY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CARON AMOUNT
07/01/05 06/30/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -50.000,000 99.99770 49,998,850.00
03.625% JO 30 ACCR. INT. 4,925.27
MATURITY
GYER REF or G1813788 Al
07/01/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN ISM -1
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 DUE 07/01/34
ADJUST POSITION
07/01/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -1
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 DUE 07/01/34
07/05/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN NMI 1
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 DUE 07/01/34
07/06/05 07/05/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MEN -15.000.000 100.13281 15,019,92187
04.s25ss Mn IS ACCR. INT. 87,432.07
MATURITY
GYER REF # G1864824 Al
07/06/05 07/05/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 6.000.000 99.48828 5,969,296.88
03.600% MN 31 ACCR. INT. 20.655.73
MATURITY
GYER REF # G1864858 Al
07/07/05 07/06/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE NMI -10.000.000 100.34375 10,034,375.00
04.126% MN TS ACCR. INT. 59,408.97
0 MATURITY
GYER REF # G1872700 Al
07/11/05 07/08/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 15.000.000 100.35156 15.052.734.37
04.126% Mn IS ACCR. INT. 95.839.00
MATURITY
GYER REF # G1894318 Al
027 0740.135:10:09 001 Y895
CLEARED TuRouGH ITS
Ls/Kw, CHIT*/ SUSSIOally
Beer Rev,
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 .88/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On Ale
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/ON
07/11/05 07/08/05 BOUGHT
07/11/05 07/08/05 SOLD
07/12/05 07/11/05 SOLD
07/14/05 06/06/05 CANCEL SELL
07/14/05 06/07/05 CANCEL SELL
07/14/05 06/03/05 BOUGHT
DESCRIPTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05/31/2007 03,500% MN 31
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 3,762 % TO MATURITY
GVER REF it G1893571 A3 WWEB
EMAIXVCUSP
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 06/30/2007 03,625% JO 30
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 3,751 % TO MATURITY
GVER REF # G1893570 A3 WEB
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04,125% MN IS
MATURITY
GvER REF # G1923743 Al
FNMA 30YR TBA GTD
SETT, 07/05
57140000 BS
AS OF 06/06105
TO C/3. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR TBA GTD
SETT, 07/05
001. 1105,000% 57140000 BS
AS OF 06/07105
TO CM. PREvIOLIS SELL
FNMA 30YR TBA GTD
SETT, 07/05
05000%
7110000 BS
cvmany ProcE
28.000.000 99.52344
ACCR. INT.
CLEARED TAIROuGH ITS
miCm.', OM R(' SUBSIMAny
Beer Ster
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
ACCOUNT! NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On FIIB
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
DEBIT AMOUNT
27,866,562.50
109,781.42
CREPT AMOUNT
-28,000,000 99.76172
ACCR. INT.
27,933,281.25
30.339.67
-15,000,000 100.01563
ACCR. INT.
15,002,343.75
97,520.38
15,000,000 99.59375 14.939.062.50
15.000.000 99.59375 14.939.062.50
15.000.000 100.21875 15.032.812.50
027 OB3005:10:09 001 Y895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
mow? MATEO SUBSOMAy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
10 c!
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
07/14/05 05/06/05 CANCEL SELL
07/14/05 06/23/05 BOUGHT
07/14/05 06/06/05 SOLD
07/14/05 06/07/05 SOLD
07/14/05 06/03/05 CANCEL BUY
07/14/05 05106/05 SOLD
CESCRIMON
FNMA 30YR TBA GM
SETT, 07/05
AS OF 05/06/05
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR TBA GM
SETT, 07/05
05,000
FNMA 30YR TBA GM
SETT, 07/05
05.000
AS OF 06/06435
FNMA 30YR TBA GM
SETT, 07/05
FNMA 30YA TEA GM
SETT, 07/05
101.11055005
AS OF 06/03105
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA 30YR TBA GM
SETT, 07/05
101101 505.0005
7440000 BS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERTOO Mc I . 2005
THROUGH Jul, 29. 2005
AcconT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAUER On FIIB
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
STIMOTOUSIP GUMMY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CPI= MONO
BS
30,000,000
30.000.000
98.51953
99.96094
29,555,859.38
29.988.281.25
BS
-15.000.000 99.59375 14,939,062.50
BS
MEI -15.000.000 99.59375 14,939,062.50
BS
-15,000,000 100.21875 15,032,81250
BS
MEI -30,000,000 98.51953 29,555,859.38
027 D7F3005:10:09 001 V895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SUBSTDMAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
11 Ci K.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/ON
07/14/05 06/23/05 CANCEL BUY
07/14/05 05/06/05 CANCEL SELL
07/14/05 05/19/05 BOUGHT
07/14/05 05/23/05 BOUGHT
07/14:05 07,07:05 BOUGHT
07/14/05 05/26/05 CANCEL SELL
OESCRPTION
FNMA 30YR TaA GM
SETT. 07/05
ows1505.000% 7210000
AS OF 06123/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YRIFNMAIGTD
591,07105 c6.500%
AS OF 05/06,05
TO CM. PREYICUS SELL
FNMA-30YRIFNMAIGID
SETT,07/06
05,500%
FNMA-30YRIFNMAIGTD
SETT,07.136
FNMA-30YRIFNMAIGTD
SETT,07,05
iii00105.500%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT,07105
05,500%
AS OF 0&26/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* JUT/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER wie3ER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
SYMBOLGUSV %Wm PINCE DEW AMOUNT OEM AMOUNT
BS
-30.000,000 99.96094 29,988,281.25
30,000.000 100.51563 30,154,687.50
BS
30,000.000 100.86719 30.260.156.25
BS
30,000.000 101.00000 30.300.000.00
BS
30,000.000 101.11719 30,335,156.25
BS
60,000.000 100.95313 60.571.875.00
BS
027 07.30,0S:10:09 001 "895
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/3N
07/14/05 05/06/05 SOLD
07/14/05 05/19/05 CANCEL BUY
07/14/05 05/23/05 CANCEL BUY
07/14/05 07/07/05 CANCEL BUY
07/14/05 05126105 SOLD
07714/05 06/06/05 BOUGHT
DESORPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)OID
tomTh os.500%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT.07 05
05.500%
AS OF 05 19,05
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
05.500%
AS OF 05/23105
TO C73. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT.07/05
1.1005,50054
AS OF 07/07105
TO C73. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
SETT.07t06
05.500%
FNMA 30 YR G10
SETT. 07 05
AS OF 06:0605
CLEARED D4ROuGH ITS
wisCtLY OW,E0 SUEISIOally
Beer Stea,n
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29. 2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WIDMER OR File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
SYMOOMCUSIP OVANTITY Pma DEIST AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
-30.000,000 100.51563 30,154,687.50
BS
-30.000,000 100.86719 30,260,156.25
BS
-30.000.000 101.00000 30,300,000.00
BS
-30.000.000 101.11719 30,335,156.25
BS
NMI 60 000.000 100.95313 60.571.875.00
BS
50,000.000 102.60547 51,302,734.38
BS
02/ 073: Otr:10:03 001 7895
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSICTON
07/14/05 06/03105 CANCEL SELL
07/14105 06/06/05 CANCEL BUY
07/14/05 06/03105 SOLD
07/15/05 07/14/05 SOLD
07/15/05 JOURNAL
07/15/05 JOURNAL
07/18/05 JOURNAL
GUMPTION
FNMA 30 YR GM
SETT, 07/05
06.000%
7070000 BS
AS OF 06/03105
TO CR PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30 YR GM
SETT, 07/05
100/0006,0034
57180000 BS
AS OF 0510005
TO CxL PREVICUS ELM
FNMA 30 YR GTO
SETT, 0705
0110.006.000%
57070000 BS
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04.125% MN IS
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # 61953286 Al
FANNIE MAE CMG/SERIES 2003-52
KS-VO RTR
3,785 DUE 07/2917
ADJUST POSITION
FANNIE MAE CMOtSERIES 2003-52
KS-PO RTR
3.785 DUE 07/25/17
FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003.52
KS-PO RTR
3.785 DUE 07/25117
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wHOtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
Beer Stea•nt. Se •it' •
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER ABJURER Cfl File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
SITIOD,GuSro GUMMI/ PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT MO/ A/IOLNT
50,000,000 102.79688 51,398,437.50
MIN -50.000.000 102.60547 51.302.734.38
-50.000.000 102.79688 51.398.437.50
-3.000.000 99.56250 2.986.875.00
ACCR. INT. 20,512.91
MIS -1
-1
02/ 0/ 32 05.101:9 001 Y895
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTKIN OESCRIPTION SYMOOLICUSP OVANTITY PRICE OBIT AMOUNT GRECO AMOUNT
07/20/05 07/19/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -5.000.000 99.14063 4,957,031.25
04,12S% MN IS ACCR. INT. 36,990.49
MATURITY
GYER REF # 62002321 Al
07/20/05 PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN ISM -159,999
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
3,940 DUE 12/20/29
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 07-20-0S
07/20/05 PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC -145,015
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DUE 05/20/30
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 07-20-0S
07/22/05 07/21/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -5,000,000 98.93750 4.946.875.00
04,126% MN IS ACCR. INT. 38.111.41
MATURITY
GVER REF # 62025180 Al
07/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 118.834.50
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN RID 06-05 PID 07-25-05
REPO P 8I 0,0000
07/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 356.503.50
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
PRIN RID 06.05 PA) 07-25-05
REPO P 8I 0,0000
07/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -301,362
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
3685 DUE 01/25/33
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 07-25-05
CLEARED THRouom ITS
%snort (Am,*0 SUOSIOany
Beer Sean
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
*scow! NUMBER
TAXPAYER /AJMER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
027 M3005:10:09 001 V89S
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION CESCRVTION SY1A3011CUSA' CAPARITI ',FEE DEIST AMOUNT OREM MCUNT
07/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 159,318.90
SERIES 348 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01133
PRIN RID 0645 ND 07-25-05
REPO P S i 0,0000
07/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 318,637.80
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01133
PRIN RID 06-05 PM 07-25-05
REPO P S i 0,0000
07,25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MIS 219,038.40
SERIES 352 CLASS I
0,001 DUE 07/01/34
PRIN RID 06-05 ND 07-25-05
REPO P S i 0,0000
07/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 503,788.32
SERIES 352 CLASS I
0,001 DIE 07/01/34
PRIN RID 06-05 PM 07-25-05
REPO P S i 0,0000
07/2_5/05 PRINCIPAL ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST -704£74
SERIES 2004-3008 CLASS I -A-B
1,785 DUE 02/25/35
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 07-25-05
07/29/05 07/28105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 20.000.000 99.37220 19,874,440.00
03,625% Jo 30 ACCR. INT. 57.133.15
MAR
GyER REF 62094228 A3
AS OF 07/2845
07/29105 07128/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 23.000.000 99.35156 22.850.859.38
03,625% JD 30 ACCR. INT. 65.703.12
MATURITY
GVER REF # 62092992 al
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
/MOLLY OW,E0 SUEISIOally
Beer Stea,n
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul! 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KUMMER Cfl Ale
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
02/ D7/3005:10:09 001 7895
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
07/29/05
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
07/28/05 BOUGHT
DESCRIPTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03,625% TO 30
MATURITY
GVER REF # G2092992 Al
SY/ABOLICUSP COWRY
50,000,000
AC,CR. INT.
PRICE
99.35156
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WIIC(LY OMED SOSO/AIM
Beer Ner
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29. 2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NuMER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
DEBIT AMOUNT
49,675,781.25
142,832.88
CREW' MONO
TOTAL $-530.559.744.69 $536.710.173.30
DEPOSITS AND WITHDRAWALS
DATE WANSACTPX
07/13/05 FND WIRED /ADM
DESER VIER
DATE DESCRIPTION
07/01/05 AVG BAL 425,265RT 2.198
021 OFFICE INTEREST 0605
INTEREST
NOSWIRED TO
N
07/15/05 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5,000
INT RID 06.05 PAD 07-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
07/15/05 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5,000
INT RID 06.05 PA) 07-15-05
REPO P &I 5,0000
SYMEIWCUSIP
MIN
11111.
DEBIT AMOUVT
71.745.00
OIWITTTY RATE N
CREDIT AMOUNT
DEBT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
779.00
5.0000 39.80151
5.0000 79.60703
07/ 0/ 30 0 :IOCiS 00I Y895
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (conlinued)
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
viNCtLY CA11,E0 SUOSIOMTiv
Beer Stern !it
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MASSER Cfl File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
DATE OESCRIPTION SYMBEIJCUSIP OWARITY RATE 1%) DEBIT AMOUNT CREW AMOUNT
07/15/05 FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886 4.0800 12,000.87
SC-/0 FUR
DUE 07/15/2019 4,080
INT FM 06-05 PAD 07-15-05
REPO P 8I 4,0800
07/15/05 FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886 1.1111M 4.0800 17.174.86
SC-1/0 FUR
DUE 07/15/2019 4,080
INT RID 0805 PA) 07-15-05
REPO P 8I 4,0800
07/15/05 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG COREUS10110 6.0000 89/98.51
SERES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2035 6,000
INT RID 06-05 PAD 07-15-05
REPO P &I 6,0000
07/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3.6900 54.120.00
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/2012033 3.690
INT RID 06-05 PA) 07-20-05
REPO P &I 3,6900
07/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3.6900 81.180.00
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/2012033 3,690
INT RID 06-05 PA) 07-20-05
REPO P 8I 3,6900
07/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN MEM 3.9400 80.213.91
SERES 2004-30 CLASS SU
DUE 02/20/2032 3,940
INT RID 0805 PA) 07-20-05
REPO P 8I 3,9400
07/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3.9400 48,577.07
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
DUE 12/20/2029 3940
INTEREST PAYMENT 0t-20.05
07/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC 48.59814
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DUE 05/20/2030 0,000
INTEREST PAYMENT 07-20.05
027 07,3005:10:09 001 V895
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
vinCtLY (A1T,E0 SUOSIOMTiv
Beer Sown !it
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jul/ I . 2005
THROUGH Jul, 29. 2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAMER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
DATE DESORPTION SYMBOAUSIP OUANTITY RATE ICt DEBIT AMOUNT cafP1 AMOUNT
07/25/05 FANNIE MAE CMG/SERIES 2003-13 4.6850 48,392.65
S RCR-VO RTR
DUE 03/25/2033 4.685
INT RID 06-05 PA) 07-25-05
REPO P 8I 46856
07/25/05 FANNIE MAE CMOJSERIES 2003-13 1.1= 4.6850 48.392.65
S RCR-VO RTR
DUE 03/25/2033 085
INT RID 06-05 PA) 07-25-05
REPO P 8I 46856
07/25/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3.6850 38356.92
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DUE 01/25/2033 3.685
INTEREST PAYMENT 07-25.05
07/25/05 FANNIE MAE CMG/SERIES 2003-52 3.7850 23.816.25
KS-I/O RTR
DUE 07/25/2017 3.785
INT RID 06-05 PA) 07-25-05
REPO P 8I 3.7856
07/25/05 FANNIE MAE CMG/SERIES 2003-52 3.7850 30.311.59
KS-I/0 RTR
DUE 07/25/2017 3,785
INT RID 0605 P/D 07-25-05
REPO P 8I 3.7856
07/25/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN IMO 5.0000 38.20931
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 06-05 PA) 07-25-05
REPO P 8I 5.0000
07/25/05 ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST 1.7850 55.137.24
SERES 2004-3008 PASS 1-A-8
DUE 02/25/2035 1.785
INTEREST PAYMENT 07-25-05
TOTAL $834.470.31
027 07,3005:TU09 00I V895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SUBSCIAFW
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
19 C? :€2
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRNX
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRrION SYMBOLCVSIP aMAITIW DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
07/01/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 65.000.000 65.162.500.00
DUE 06130/2007 3,625
FITM Al
3,625 0.i7
RESALE T
07/06/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE -13.000.000 13.097.500.00
ATM Al
4,125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
07/06/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE 28.000.000 28.210.000.00
ATM A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
07/06/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 28.000,000 28.035.000.00
DUE 05131/2007 3,500
3,500 D
FITM AlA
RESALE T
07/06/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -34,000.000 34.127.500.00
DUE 05/31/2007 3,500
36 F)101007
FRM00 A2
TERM EE1AENT
07/06/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MOM 28,304.03
DUE 05/111. 4.125
ATM A2
REPO Mr
07/06/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 21.149.57
DUE 05/11,20g7_ _3.500
07/07/05 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -3.000.000 3.022.500.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29. 2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On Ale
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
ATM  Al
4.125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
027 07.300S:10:09 001 V895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
valour MINED $UESIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
20 c!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
07/07/05
TWOS
DATE TRANSACTION
JOURNAL
DESORPTION
UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE
FIRM A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
07/07/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 051  4.125
FONT A2
REPO I
07/11/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
FIRM A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
07/11/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
FIRM Al
4,125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
07/11/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05+31/2007 3,500
3,50011.7 w
FITM A2
TERM ENT
07/11/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 06+30/2007 3,625
3,625 7
FITM A2
TERM EEMENT
07/11/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 06+30'2007 3,625
3,625 li
FIRM AlA
RESALE T
07/11/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05)10b 4,125
FIRM A2
REPO I
SYMEICIAUSIP OvANiin
13,000.000
DEBIT AMOUNT
13,097,500.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
1.055.08
3.000.000 3.022,500.00
-18.000.000 18.090.000.00
-28,000.000 28.035.000.00
-65000000 65.162.500.00
93.000,000 93,116,250.00
1.022.61
027 07.30,0S:10:09 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED $UBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
21 c!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
07/11/05
TMDE
DATE TRANSACTION
INTEREST
DESCRVION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05=2007_ "_3500
07/11/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05=0,7_ 3625
"I"
0711205 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 0101/33
STRIP
FRM Al
REPOAl
0711205 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MT0 ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
TEMMRM RPRIPM AZENT
0711205 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MT0 ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM Mr Al
REPO A
0711205 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTS ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 0001/33
STRIP
TEMARM RIPIPM AINT
0711205 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-13
S FOR
4,886 ilit3
FIRM Al
REPO A
SYMEICIAUSIP OvANiire DEBIT AMOUNT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH JUN 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAyER WIASER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
8,099.00
47.74963
-4.805.740 3.562.000.00
4.805.740 3.652.000.00
.14A17,221 10,686,000.00
14,417,221 11,102,000.00
42,393.489 946000.00
027 07.30,0S:10:09 001 .895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
valour OwNED $U89DIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Job. 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION STMBOL,Cvsl, OUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
07/12/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13 12.393,489 984,000.00
S RCR-I10 FLTR
4,685
FILM RIII0 3,2
TERM MENT
07/12/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CUSS 1
DUE IU
FILM C1
REPO
07/12/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CUSS 1
DUE I 1
FITM CZ
TERM ENT
07/12/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CUSS 1
DUE I 1
FITM A2
TERM ENT
07112;05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CUSS 1
DUE I 1
FITM !Ili. Al
REPO A
07112;05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109
SERIES 227 CUSS 10
5,000
FITM 3.t1.2
TERM MENT
07/12/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109
SERIES 227 CUSS 0
5,000
FITM
REPO  Aft
-6.805.369 5.060.000.00
6,805,369 5,241,000.00
13,610.739 10,000,000.00
.13,610.739 10,120,000.00
18,891.486 3,756,000.00
.18,891 A86 3,788,000.00
027 07.30,0S:10:09 001 VE195
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED $UB9OIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Mg 1.2005
THROUGH July 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER OnFIle
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTICH SYMBOLCVSIP WANinv DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
07/12/05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886 -3.529,667 197,000.00
SC-I/0 FUR
4,080piii#19
FITM AI
REPO
07/12/05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886
SC-I/O FLTR
4,080 19
FITM AZ
TERM MENT
07/12/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORMS 10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 13
6,000311.35
FITM BZ
TERM MENT
07/12/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORMS10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 10135
FITM 81
REPO A
07112/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
FITM Al
4,125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
07/12/05 JOURNAL UNITED &AWRY NOTE
FITM A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
07/12/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 01301 0,000
FITM AZ
REPO I
3,529.667 206,000.00
17,428.411 Z762,000k0
-17,428,411 2.818.000.00
-3.000.000 3,011,250.00
18,000.000 18,090,000.00
8.521.33
027 07.30,0S:10:09 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
24 c? €2
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TR;MACRON DESCRPTION SYMEIMICUSIP OVAArrin DEBIT AMOUNT
07/12/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 33,760.08
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE Ol  0.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
0711205 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13
S RCR-1/0 FLTR
DUE 4.685
FITM AZ
REPO I
07/12/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DUE I JO  0.000
ATM CZ
REPO I
07/12/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE IV 0000
FITM AZ
REPO I
07/12/05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109
SERIES 227 CUSS 0
DUE lap 5.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
0711205 INTEREST FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886
SC-U0 FLTR
DUE 07:111 4.080
FITM AZ
REPO I
0711205 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S 10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 0
DUE 0 6.000
FITM BZ
REPO I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul/ 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYERNM/ER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
2.991.36
15.932.64
23.333.33
11.418.24
626.24
8.396.48
027 07,3005:10:09 001 7895
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED $UESIOIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
25 c!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Juk. 29.2006
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLAIIER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYMEICIJCUSIP OVANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
07/12/05
07/13/05
07/13/05
07/13/05
07/14/05
07/14/05
07/14/05
INTEREST
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
INTEREST
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
UNITED STATES TREASURY
DUE 05/11.
FITM
REPO I
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS
3.690 W3
FITM
REPO A
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS
3.690
I14 FIT 31. 31.2
TERM
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS
FITM
DUE 02:11.
REPO I
FANNIE MAE CMG/SERIES
KS-U0 FUR
3,785
FITM
TERM
FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES
KS-I/0 FUR
3,785 'WI
FITM
REPO A
FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES
KS-ItO FLTR
RIM3,785
RESALE
NOTE
4,125
A2
MTG ASSN
PS
Al
MTG ASSN
PS
MENT
MTG ASSN
PS
3,690
A2
2003-52
A4
MENT
2003-52
AI
2003-52
Al
MIS
-26.400.000
26.400.000
17,157,930
-7.549A89
9.608.440
1,557.75
2,515,000.00
4.708.64
509.000.00
2.440.000.00
027 07.30,0S:10:09 001 VE195
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
=Pm 26
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION
07/14/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOiSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/0 FUR
3,785
07/14/05 JOURNAL FANNIE WE CMOSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/O FLTR
3,785 17
FITM AI
REPO A
07/14/05 JOURNAL FANNIE WE CMOSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/O FLTR
3,785 17
FITM A2
REPO A
07/14.:05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMCVSERIES 2003-52
KS-I/0 FLTR
3,785 17
Find AI
REPO A
0715/05 JOURNAL UNITED REASURY NOTE
ATM A2
4125 .15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
07/15/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 053110 4,125
FITM A2
REPO I
07 18 05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001
FITM WI REPO A
07 18 05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001
FITM BZ
TERM ENT
STMECLCVSIP
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
wisCI.LY CAM,*0 SUEISIOally
Beer Stea•nt. Se •it' •
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Julj 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMSER On Flk
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
°PARITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-9,608,440 509600.00
-9.608A40 509600.00
9.608.440 509,000.00
-9.608.440 509,000 00
3.000.000 3.011,250.00
736.92
-16089645 13.954.000.00
19.089.045 14.345.000.00
027 07/3006:10:09 001 '.89S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED $UB9OIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
27 c?
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TMDE
DATE DATE TRANSACRON DESORPTION
07/18/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
DUE 0710 0.001
FILM 82
REPO I
07/20/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE OS/192015 4.125
FIRM4.125 15
AI
RESALE
07/22/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05/152015 4.125
4.125)1001 E5
RIM A2
TERM EMENT
07/22/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05+152015 4.125
4.125 SIC
FITM Al
RESALE
07/22105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE Ds/
l
07/28/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FILM WI REPO A
07/28/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FS.000ITM 31.C2
TERM ENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Juit 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
ME/MCl/SIP OVANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
44,118.84
MI= 5,000,000 5.025.000 00
MIN -5.000.000 5.025.000 00
10.000.000 10,025,000.00
353.15
-9.445743
9,445,743 1,861,000.00
027 07.300S:10:09 001 '.1195
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
valour Coma) $UB9OIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAyER TAJMEER On Ale
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE DINCACDON DESCRPT1CH SYMEMICUSIP WNW', CESIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
07/28/05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109 5,123.95
SERIES 227 CLASS IO
DUE I AO 5000
ATM C2
REPO I
07/29/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13
S RCR-110 FLTR
4,540
FIRM 31111I32
TERM MENT
07129/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CM0SERIES 2003-13
S RCR.ItO FLTR
4.540
FRM AI
REPO A
07/29/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13
S RCR.ItO FLTR
FRM .540 Fla n
TERM ENT
07/29/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORD#510109
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
5,000
FITM 31.42
TERM ENT
07/29/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5,000 .134
ATM Al
REPO A
07/29/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
5,000
RP
REPO  A
12.094,423
-24.188,846
12,094.423 946,000.00
9,445,743
-8.973A56
.472,287 96,000.00
027 07.30,0S:10:09 001
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
=Pm 29
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON SYMOCCOUSIP CVANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
07/29/05
07/29/05
07/29/05
DELIVERED
INTEREST
INTEREST
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 06(30/2007 3,625
3.62510.7 Em
FITM A2
TERM ENT
FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13
S RCR-110 FLTR
DUE Cet 4,540
FITM A2
REPO I
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 06ile i  i ,625 MEE
-93.000.000
1,599.27
93.116.250.00
132.949.31
TOTAL $-325,376,196.79 $318,091,800.66
MISCELLANEOUS
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
OMP*0 SUEISIOMAY
Beer &ter
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Jul, 1.2005
THROUGH July 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
DATE
IAODAY TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION DEW AMOUNT CREDIT AMAJUNT
07/01/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 159,218.50
07/05/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 258,350.50
07/06/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 160,897.50
07/08/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 183,564.74
07/11/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 107,686.00
07/13/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 6,430.00
07/13/05 JOURNAL FNMA 30YR IBA GTD 526,171.87
SETT, 07105
5,000 DUE 07/01/35
NIBS NET 07/13105
07/ 0/ 30 0:00:03 001 V89S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WIICU.Y OWNED SUB9DIAFW
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
30 o
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS (continued)
DATE
won TRANSACTOR DESCRIPTON DWI AMOUNT CRECIT AMUNT
07/13/05 JOURNAL FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD 168,750.00
SER.07/05
5.500 DUE 07101/35
MBS NET 07/13405
07/14/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 11,709.00
07/14/05 JOURNAL FNMA 30YR GTO 95,703.12
SETE 07/05
6.000 DUE 07101/35
MBS NET 07/14/05
07/15/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY A/C  4390.00
07/18/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 66,750.00
07/19/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 50,375.00
07/22/05 JOURNAL JUNE 05CLEAR FEES 1.500.00
07/22/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 104,275.00
07/26/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC  23.563.00
07/27/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 3,900.00
07/28/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 64,025.00
07/29/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC  207.084.00
TOTAL $.1.090.677.37 51.113.665.86
02?
STATEMENT PERIOD Job. 1.2005
THROUGH Jul/ 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AVEOER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
01.300S:10:09 001 WIDS
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WIICU.Y OWNED $UB901AAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Trades Executed Pending Settlement
SETTLEMENT TRADE DATE DATE 7RANSACTON DMA mon
08/01/05 07/29/05 BOUGHT
SYMBOL:CUSP
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH JUT/ 29. 2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLAMER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT June 30,2005
°WHY FPoCE DEBIT AMOUNT OREM MIDUNT
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10.000.000.00 98.7812 9,965,557.07
04.126% MN IS
TY
GVER REF Gi1005081TUA1
oatrims 07/28/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.87S% JJ 31
I . O WTUFUTY
OVER REF # G2093006 BI
movos 07/28:05 SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03,87S% JJ 31
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G2093006 Al
cam /05 07/11/05 BOUGHT FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT,08, 04
~ 05.600%
57110000 BS
cenvos 07/07/05 SOW FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT,08,04
05,500%
57310000 BS
0811/05 07/08/05 SOLD FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GM
sErr.oaro4
05.500% 57250000 BS
08111/05 07/08/05 SOLD FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT,08.04
101.006.600%
57250000 BS
AS CF 070505
-23,000.000.00 99.8046 22.957.500.00
-50.000.000.00 99.8046 49.907.608.70
50.000.000.00 100.8828 50.441.406.25
-30.000.000.00 100.9687 30.290.625.00
-50,000.000.00 100.9609 50.480.470.00
-50,000.000.00 100.9609 50.480.468.75
027 07.30,0S:10:09 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SIXISCIAAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
32 c? €2
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE DATE DATE TRANSACTION CE RPT10,4
08/11/05 07/15/05 SOLD FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT08.04
0 11006.500%
08/11/05 07/29/05 SOLD FNMA-30YR(FNMAJGTD
SETT 08/04
05,500%
08/11/05 07/08/05 CANCEL SELL FNMA-30YR(FNMAJGTD
SETT,08/04
05,500
AS OF 07/08,135
08/11/05 07/21/05 SOLD FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT, 08/05
~ 05,000%
TOTAL
The abc•vr. <0 Inn %Veal m ry on* eeJnn 01 Iftri 1/a/v-nert
End of Statement
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO Jul/ 1.2005
THROUGH Jul, 29. 2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WAXIER On File
LAST STATEMENT June 30.2005
SOA80..00SP OuANTITY PRICE DEMI AMOUNT CREPT RAMO
-30,000.000.00 100.8203 30.246.093.75
BS
-40,000.000.00 100.5078 40,203,125.00
BS
-50.000.000.00 100.9609 50,480,470.00
BS
es
-10,000.000.00 98.5937 9.859.375.00
$110.887.433.32 $284.425.266.20
027 07.300S:10:09 001 Vel%
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SUESIOMIty
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSIIE wenv.bearstearns.cOm
What's In This Statement ImIgIIIII I II
Financial Summary 3
Your Portfolio Holdings  4
Transaction Detail  8
Trades Not Yet Settled  31
Your Messages  33
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
0/0 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Your Portfolio at a Glance Market Value of Your Portfolio
TOTAL VAWE OF SECURITIES THIS PERIOD 3,442,681
LONG ACCRUED INTEREST 32,928
NET CREDIT BALANCE 359,965
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD
Cash 8 Equvialent $359•965h 5122.206
Fated
Income
$3.442.681
$3.052.376
MI Current market va:ue
$3,835,574 EN Last statements market value
NET EQUITY LAST STATEMENT 3,201,652
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT 633,923
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on tile for your account.
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCGCNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Flk
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2006
SIM 1Wit stiftnata fa ^formational asnyoses only Itasca evaded &sates clowned
This stationed should be retailed for your records See reverse ode for inpolare rtcHnatan
027 07.01.05:10:02 001
Confirmation: Unless we hear
from you to the contrary. it is
our understanding that any
free credit balances in your
account are being maintained
to facilitate your intention to
invest such amounts through
us.
V8931P
CLEARED 'THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY ORAEO SUTTGOMAv
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 01 34
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
027 MIMS:10:42 001 Y002IP
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WUCU.? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
3 Cl :14
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PERIOD
Income Summary MS PERIOD YEAR TO DATE
Opening Balance $122,205.83 U.S. Govt. Bond Int. 219,620.41 3.681.663.87
Govt. Agency Int. 714.775.88 4.112.621.91
Securities Sold 717,693,800.08 Corp. Bond Int. 197.231.04 792,702.92
Dividends Interest 1,131,949.13 Credit Balance Int. 321.80 3,545.51
Miscellaneous 1,878,994.73 Reverse Repurchase Int. 81,098.16 1.163.243.87
Amount Credited $720,704.743.94 Total $1 213 047.29 $9 753 778.08
Securities Bought -718,737,452.51 Bond Purchase Int. -208.273.77 -5.148,708.18
Dividends/Interest Charged -208,273.77 Repurchase Int. Exp. -215.571.53 -1.098,448.85
Miscellaneous -1,521.258.00
Amount Debited 5.720,466,984.28
Portfolio Composition Net Cash Activity 237,759.66
Cash/Cash Equivalent 359,965
ClosingBatance $359,965.49 Fixed Income 3.442,681
Total 53.802.646
Cash Balance Summary
OPENNO CLOSING
Margn 122,205.83 359,965.49
Net Cash Balance $122205.83 $359,965.49
027 07.019510:42 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEIMER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash 8 Equivalent-
I— Fixed Income
91%
Untivaed cone's Oenole debt baboce emit ,  OM
male vela, The elocatir percent'', is Ormed
Iron Vo etnol.te mrkel vSue of ,o to palioo
V893IP
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
inAPxET ESIIMATED O:AP£M DESCPO')O/1 s•MBCL O-SIP OUANTIT1 PACE eA1.01. Amt,AL NXIIE 'SO I%)
CASH BALANCE 359.965
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS $359.965
FIXED INCOME
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wuCtLY CA1T,E0 SUBSIDIARY
Beer Stea•nt. Se •it' •
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERO) June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WINER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
Government & Agency Obligations
DESDPICTION ACC.S17/ECLCUSP 1-1q PEACE 'TAPPET VALLE ACCRUED MEREST ESTEEMED ANNUAL NCOEIE
WRIT
VELD O41
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN 14.795.046 5.5884 826.803 16.191 582,925 70.5035
SERIES 2004-035 CUSS SP
DATED DATE 05121/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 12/20/2029 3.940%
FACTOR — .90848224
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC MRGN 14.801.708 6.7511 999.284
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DATED DATE 06/2304
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 05,20/2030
FACTOR - .92150716
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN 12.488.618 7.1598 894.164 6.393 460.206 51.4677
SERIES 2003.49 CLASS SW
DATED DATE 04/3003
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 01/25.'2033 3.685%
FACTOR - .51379199
027 O7N1MS:1O:42 001
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Your Portfolio Holdings (continued)
Government & Agency Obligations (continual:
OLSCR., 'ION 20a3OLCUSP TIPL °UMW PRICE IAARKET VALUE
ACCRuE0 MEREST
ESTedAREO ANNUAL INCOME
CuRRGVr YELD ITN
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DATED DATE 07/01/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 07/01/2034 5000%
FACTOR — .97992876
Total Government& Agency Obligations
MRGN 1 20.6563
$2,720,251 $22,584 $1,043,131
Corporate Bonds
DESCRIPTION STEMOUOJSP
ACCT
TYPE CIUMITIN PRICE MARKET VALUE
ACCRUED
INTEREST
ESTEEMED
ANNUAL INCOME
CURFEW
YEW
ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST
SERIES 2004-3005 CLASS 1-A-8
DATED DATE 12/27/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 02/25/2035 2.010%
FACTOR — .92636353
RATING: MOODY MA S&P MA
Total CorporateBonds
MRGN 37,054,541 1.9496 722.430
$722,430
10,344
$10.344
744,796
$744,796
103.0959
TOTAL FIXED INCOME $3,442,681 $32,928 $1,787,927
CLEARED limouGH ITS
TACITLY CARTED SUODOTAIIT
Beer Star TTI T
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERMO June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER Mach On Fae
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLDING$ACCRUED INTEREST $32,928
YOUR PORTFOLIONOLDINGSESTIMATED ANNUAL INCOME $1.787.927
YOUR PRICEDPORTFOLIONOLDINGS $3,802,646
027 07MITTIS:10:42 001 WINIP
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y CAM*0 SUBSIONITY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
6 C/ :14
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc. outstanding as of date of statement
MMUS& REPURCHASE PRONG PURCHASE PRIES ACCRUED REPO CUANTIn
START DATE DATE RATE PAINCPAL MEREST' (FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTION
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NA UER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
YOU SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 06/10(05 07/12/05 3.420 -984,000 -1.963 -25.000,000 SERIES 2003-13 CLASS 4.685603/25133
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 06/10(05 07/12/05 3.420 -11.102,000 -22.148 -30.000,000 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 06/10(05 07/12/05 3.420 -5.241,000 -10.455 -10.000,000 SERIES 346 CLASS PO 11/01)33
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 06/10(05 07/12/05 3.420 -3.756.000 -7.493 -20.000,000 SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU SOLD FREDDIEMAC STRIP
(REPO) 06/10/05 07/12/05 3.420 -2.762.000 -5.510 -20.000.000 SERIES 228 CLASS 10 6.0000 02/01/35
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
(REPO) 06/10/05 07/12/05 3.420 -206.000 -410 -4.000.000 SERIES 2886 CLASS SC 4.0800 07/15/19
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 06/10/05 OPEN 0.000 -25,000,000 SERIES 2003-52 CLASS 3.7856 07/25/17
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIPS
(REPO) 06/16/05 07/18/05 3.460 -14.345,000 -20.680 -23,000,000 SERIES 352 CLASS PO 07101/34
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 06/17/05 07/12/05 3.360 -3.652,000 -4.771 -10,000,000 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 06/17/05 07/12/05 3.360 -10,000,000 -13.066 -20,000,000 SERIES 346 CLASS PO 11/01/33
YOU SOLD USTR 4.1250 05/15/15
(REPO) 06/22/05 OPEN 2.800 -28,210.000 -16.134 -28.000.000
027 07,0105:10:42 001 V891D
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
7 C/ :14
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.inc.outstanding as of date of statement (continued)
MICHAS&
START DATE
RENRCHASE
DATE
PRiCe4
RATE
PURCHASE PRICE;
PRINCPAL
ACCAuE0 REPO
MEREST'
GUMMY
(FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTOR
YOU SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 06/23(05 07/13/05 3.370 -2,515,000 -1.883 -26.400,000 SERIES 2004-5 CLASS P 3.6900 02/20/33
YOU SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 06/27/05 OPEN 0.010 -1 -25.000.000 SERIES 2003-13 CLASS 4.6856 03/25/33
YOU SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 06/27/05 OPEN 0.010 -1 -27,112,874 SERIES 2004-30 CLASS 3.940002/20/32
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
(REPO) 06/27/05 OPEN 0.010 -1 -5,724,538 SERIES 2886 CLASS SC 4.0800 07/15/19
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIPS
(REPO) 06/30/05 08/01/05 3.540 -6,373,000 -626 -10,000,000 SERIES 352 CLASS PO 07/01/34
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIP
(REPO) 06/30/05 08/01/05 3.540 -1.737.000 -170 -10.000.000 SERIES 353 CLASS 10 5.0000 07/01/34
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 06/30/05 08/01/05 3.540 -1.861,000 -183 -10.000.000 SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU BOUGHT USTR 3.5000 05/31/07
(REVERSE) 06/27/05 OPEN 2.310 34.127500 10,115 34.000.000
TOTAL REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS $34.127.500 $10.115
TOTAL REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS $.92.744.003 S.105.492
•As CC ililtrant arx
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER PARSER On Fite
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
027 MOMS:W:42 001 V8911>
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
CLEARED 114nouGH ITS
TensEm.Y GUTTED SUBSIDIARY
Beer Sown TT: T
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUYT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WINGER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION STIA3OUCUSV CVATAITITY ProcE DEEM AMOUNT CREDIT MONO
06/01/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -1
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
OUE 11/01133
06/02/05 05/27/05 BOUGHT ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST MEI 37.701.414 2.15625 812,936.74
SERIES 2004.3008 CLASS 1-A.8 ACCR. INT. 14,734.97
57050000 BS
06/02/05 06/01/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MEI 25.000.000 100.07031 25,017,578.13
03,500% MN 31 ACCR. INT. 4,781.42
MATURITY
GVER REF # 01524054 Al
06/03/05 06/02/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 40.000.000 101.82813 40,731,250.00
04.125% MN IS ACCR. INT. 85.190.22
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1535384 Al
0610/05 06/09/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -25.000.000 99.73438 24,933,593.75
03.500% MN 31 ACCR. INT. 23,907.10
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1605088 Al
06/13/05 06/10/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MEM -17.000.000 100.89063 17.151.406.25
04.125% MN 15 ACCR. INT. 55,261.55
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G1642765 Al
AS OF 06/10/05
06/14/05 06/13/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE EMI 4.000.000 100.34375 4,013,750.00
04.125% MN IS ACCR. INT. 13,451.09
MATURITY
GVER RE? It  G1644185 Al
027 07JOIDIS:10:42 001 Ye9301
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WITOM.Y GMED SUBSIDIAny
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
9 C/ :14
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SIOIDOLCUSIP CAMPENTE EKE DENT AMOUNT OREM AMOUNT
06/16/05 06/10105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -17,000.000 100.89844 17,152,734.38
e 04.125% MN 15 ACCR. INT. 55,261.54
. 0 MATURITY
GVER REF It 01672882 Al
ORIGINAL SD 06/1305
AS OF 06116,05
06/17/05 06/14/05 SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN EMI .10.321.800 81.81250 8.444.522.75
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
IWO* 57200000 BS
0617/05 06/14/05 BOUGHT FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 13.929.377 82.01563 11.424.265.93
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
57130000 BS
06/20/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -1
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
OUE 01/01/33
STRIP
06/20/05 PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 1111M -153,742
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SF'
4.110 DUE 1212029
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 06-20-05
06/20/05 PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC -139.052
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DUE 05 020/30
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 06-20-05
06 ,22105 06/21/05 SOLO UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -20.000.000 100.37500 20.075.000.00
04.125% MN 15 ACCR. INT. 85.190.22
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1722863 Al
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
027 07i01.136:10:42 001 Y893iP
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR DESCRIPTION SW00ECUSP OVANTITY PRiCE DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT MASUNT
06/27/05
06/27/05
06/27/05
C6,27/05
C6,27/05
C6,27/05
06/27/05
06/28/05
06/24/05 BOUGHT
PRINCIPAL
PRINCIPAL
PRINCIPAL
PRINCIPAL
PRINCIPAL
PRINCIPAL
JOURNAL
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03,500% MN 31
. MATURITY
GVER REF # G1753133 Al
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PRIN RID 05-05 PA3 06-25-05
REPO P 8I 0,0000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PRIN RID 05.05 PA 06-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
3,910 DUE 01/25/33
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 06-25-05
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01133
PRIN RID 05-05 PA 06-25-05
REPO P 8I 0,0000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001 DUE 07/01/34
PRIN RID 05-05 PM 06-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST
SERIES 2004-3008 CLASS 1-A-8
1,785 DUE 02/25/35
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 06-25-05
FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13
S RCII-1/0 FLTR
MI=
20.000,000
ACCR. INT.
-244.441
-646.873
99.83594 19,967,187.50
51.639.34
289,16720
298,41823
145,914.10
371.609.85
CLEARED IHROuGH ITS
mEOLLY OUT*0 SODOMITE,
BOW Steam Tir T
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
=COURT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MASSER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
4,685 DUE 03/25/33
027 070)1,136:10:42 001 I/8931P
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE
06/30/05 06/28/05
06/30/05 06/28105
06/30/05 06/28/05
TRANSACTION
BOUGHT
DESCRIPTION
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SEAMS 352 CLASS 1
1011.1 500.001%
7180000 BS
SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
05.000%
7100000 BS
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 251H
BOUGHT FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109
SERIES 227 U455 10
Qy1AE■
15057.104:1
BS
TOTAL
INTEREST
DATE DESCRPTION
06/01/05 AVG BAL 200,424RT 1.864
021 OFFICE INTEREST 0505
06/15/05 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 05-05 PM 06-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
06/15/05 FREDDIE MAC CMCVSERIES 2886
SC-I/O RTR
DUE 07715/2019 LOBO
INT RID 05-05 ND 06-15-05
REPO P &I 4.2100
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
YiliCtLY OW,E0 SUBSIDIARY
Beer Ster T
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERO) June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MANNER On Re
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
50.100-.CuSP OtIONTITC Pala DEBIT AMOUNT CROW MONO
8,518,623 83.45313 7,109,057.52
-9,170.234 20.59375 1,888,495.25
ACCR. INT. 36,935.67
9,552,843 21.17188 2.022,516.00
ACCR. INT. 38.476.73
5-111,306,815.59 $91,007,418.84
QUANTITY RATE IPA mot AMOUNT CnEDrl AMOUNT
321.80
5.0000 80,303.34
4.0800 12.618.14
027 ODOIA3S:10:42 001 LOUP
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
CLEARED THRouom ITS
yniCyty OmYEO SUEIROany
Beer Sean
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMMER On File
LAST sTATEmENT May 31.2005
DATE DESORPTION SYMBOAUSIP PAMIR, RATE BYI DEBIT AMOUNT CREW AMOUNT
06/15/05 FREDDIE MAC CMO/SER1ES 2886 4.0800 18,058.26
SC-VO RTR
DUE 07/15/2019 4,080
INT RID 05-05 Pin 06-15-05
REPO P &I 4.2100
06/15/05 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110 6.0000 91,828.76
SERES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02,01/2035 6,000
INT RID 05-05 PA 06-15-05
REPO P &I 6,0000
06/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 1.1111111. 3.8600 56,613.33
SERES 2004-S CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 3,860
INT RID 05.05 PA 06-20-05
REPO P 8I 3,8600
06/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3.8600 84,920.00
SERES 2004-S CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 3,860
INT RID 05.05 PAI 06-20-05
REPO P &I 3,8600
06/20M5 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4.1100 84.591.78
SERES 2004-30 CLASS SU
DUE 02/20/2032 4,110
INT RID 05-05 PM 06-20-05
REPO P 8I 4,1100
06/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN MEW 4.1100 51,199.60
SERES 2004-035 CLASS SP
DUE 12/20/2029 4,110
INTEREST PAYMENT 06-20.05
06/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC MIS 51,172.10
SERES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DUE 05120/2030 0,000
INTEREST PAYMENT 06-20.05
06/27/05 FANNIE MAE CMG/SERIES 2003-13 4.9100 25,851.29
S RTR
DUE 03/25/2033 4,910
INT RID 05-05 PM 06-25-05
REPO P 8I 4,9100
027 07'01MS:10:02 001 Y893IP
BW
STD;RRNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
%THOU.? ORY.E0 STICIDO/ARY
Beer Sier
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER RUMMER On FM
tar STATEMENT May 31.2005
DATE DESCRPTION SYMIXIXCUSIP OWAMW MEN DEMTAMOUNT CREW AMOUNT
06/27/05 FANNIE MAE CMG/SERIES 2003-13 4.9100 25,851.29
S RCR-MO RIR
DUE 03/25/2033 4.910
INT RID 05.05 PA) 06-25-05
REPOP 8I 4.9100
06/27/05 FANNIE MAE CMCVSERIES 2003-13 4.9100 51.702.58
S RCR-VO RIR
DUE 03/25/2033 4,910
INT RID 05.05 PA) 06-25-05
REPOP 8I 4.9100
06/27/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN ~I 3.9100 41.488.55
SERES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DUE 01/25/2033 3.910
INTEREST PAYMENT 06-25.05
06/27/05 FANNIE MAE CMG/SERIES 2003-52 ~I 4.0100 58.317.45
KS-RO RIR
DUE 07/25/2017 4.010
INT RFD 05.05 PA) 06-25-05
REPOP &I 4.0100
06/27/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 5.0000 77.405.30
SERES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5,000
INT RID 05.05 PA) 06-25-05
REPO P 8I 5.0000
06/27/05 ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST 1.7850 63.149.48
SERES 2004-30CB CLASS 1-A-8
DUE 02/25/2035 1.785
INTEREST PAYMENT 06-25.05
TOTAL $875,393.05
027 OX0145202 001 MOW
CLEARED IHROuGH ITS
WHOLLY OLWEI> SUBSIDIAny
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
14 0 '31
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETTLEMENT TRMX
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTICII SYMEICIJICUSIP OVAMITY CESIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
06/01/05
06/01/05
06.01/05
06/02/05
06 02 05
06/02/05
06/03/05
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
RECEIVED
DELIVERED
INTEREST
JOURNAL
FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886
SC-DO FLTR
0,21010.19
FITM A2
TERM MENT
FREDDIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886
SC-VO RJR
4,210 DUE 07/I 5119
FITM F1523444 Al
REPO AGREEMENT
FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886
SC-VO RJR
0,210 19
FITM AI
REPO A
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05/3I/2007 3,500
3,500 OW
FITM Al
RESALE
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE DWI/2007 3,500
3,50 30. 7
FITM A2
TERM e EEMENT
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE ose3.uoplz"M  _.moo
FREDDIE MAC CMCVSERIES 2886
SC-VO FUR
1,210 DUE 07/15/19
FITM F1523404 A2
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
MI=
8,743,867
-5.147.247
-3.596.620
29.000.000
-54,000.000
5,147,247
29,072,500.00
209,000 00
54.000.000.00
8,445.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERGO June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
027 OTGIEIS:10:42 001 Y8927
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WUCU.? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
15 0 'm
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
SETTLEMENT TMDE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON SYMBOucestp Gummy OW AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
06/03/05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMCVSERIES 2886 -5.147,247 288,000.00
SC-1/0 FLTR
4,2100.0019
FITM Al
REPO
06 03 05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
FITM A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
06 03 05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
FITM Al
4,125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
06/03/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 053110. 4,125
FITM A2
REPO I
06/10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FITM REM 02
TERM MEAT
06/10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
FITM AM. Al
REPO
0610;05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOiSERIES 2003-13
S RCR-I10 FLTR
4,910
FITM WI REPO A
38.000.000 38.095.000.00
78.000.000 79.462.500.00
19.661.25
14.773.724 10.851.000.00
-14,773.724 11.102.000.00
-6.318.034 492.000.00
027 07.01,05:10:42 001 VOIR
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
16 C!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TWISACRON DESCRPTXR1 SYMECIJICUSIP IXJANTITI DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
06/10/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13 6.318.034 525,000.00
S RCR-110 FLTR
4.910
FITMNIP
TERM MENT
06/10/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13 -12.636.068 984,000.00
S RCR-I(0 FLTR
4,910
FITM 1.1
REPO A
06/10/05 JOURNAL FANNIE WE CMCSERIES 2003-13 12.636.068 996.000.00
S RCR-I10 FLTR
4,91031 3
FITM A2
.TERM MENT
06/10/05 JOURNAL FANNIE ME CMO/SERIES 2003-52 MIK .17,451.605
FLTR
4.010 7
FITM Al
lilt
REPO A
06/10/05 JOURNAL FANNIE WE CMO/SERIES 2003-52 17,451.605 1,008,000.00
KS-Ito FUR
4.010 17
FITM A2
TERM ENT
06/10/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-52 .17A51.605 1.014.000.00
KS-I/0 FLTR
4.010 17
FITM Al
REPO A
0610/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMCVSERIES 2003-52 17,451.605 1,014,000.00
KS-I/O FLTR
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLAISER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
4 010 17
Flat A2
REPO A
027 07.014510:42 001 VOIR
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OMBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
17 C!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE DATE DATE TWISACTION DESORPTION
08110/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN SERIES 346 CLASS 1 DUE 11 FRM A2 TERM ENT
06/10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN SERIES 346 CLASS 1 DUE I V ATM CI REPO A
06/10/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU 4.110 3.2 FITM BI REPO A
08110/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU 4.1103.32 HIM BZ TERM MENT
08110/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109 SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.000 F1TM WI REPO A
08/10/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109 SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5,000FITM 3. 34C2 TERM MENT
0610,05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMUSERIES 2886 SC-A3 FUR 4 210 19 HIM Al REPO A
SYMBOLICuStE MAMMY MINT AMOUNT
6.964.688 3.800.000.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
.6.964.688 5.241.000.00
-24.698.329 1,297,000.00
24,698.329 1.340.000.00
.19,105.686 3.756.000.00
19,105.686 3,951,000.00
.3.596.620 206,000.00
027 07i01,05:10:02 001 Y89.31R
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
18 cI m
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPSCR1
06410/05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886
SC-YO FLTR
4.210111019
FITM AZ
TERM MENT
06/10/05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMCVSERIES 2886
SC-YO FLTR
4,210 19
FITM AZ
TERM MENT
06/10/05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMQ SERIES 2886
SC-YO FUR
4.210 11.19
FITM Al
REPO A
06/10/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510110
SERIES 228 CLASS 0
6,000
FITM 11.31
REPO A
06/10/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 0
6,000
FITM Filar3Z
TERM MENT
06/10/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05131/2007 3,500
3,500W 7
FITM A2
TERM e WENT
0610;05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05131/2007 3.500
3 SOO
F
lat Al
RESALE
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NL1M8ER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
SYMEICIJICUSIP °UNDID DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
3,596,620 209,000.00
5.147,247 288,000.00
-5.147.247 296.000.00
-17,959.702 2.762.000.00
17,959.702 3,000,000.00
-29,000.000 29,072,500.00
54.000.000 54,067,500.00
027 ODOIXIS:10:42 001 WIRIP
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OMBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
19 CI
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TWISACRON DESCRPRON SYMBOL,CvStP DVANNlY OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
06/10/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -54.000.000 54.067.500.00
DUE 05131/2007 3.500
3.500 DOH
06/10/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 54,000.000 54,067,500.00
DUE 05(31/2007 3.500
3.500 7
FITM A3
RESALE
06/10/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -54.000.000 54.067,500.00
DUE 05(3I/2007 3.500
3.500 01.K7
FITM A4
RESALE T
06/10/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MI= 54.000.000 54.067.500.00
DUE 05/31;2007 3.500
3.500
RIM AS
1111)7
RESALE T
06/10/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 29.749.82
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE Mai" 0,000
RIM OZ
REPO I
06/10/05 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13 721.88
S RCR443 FLTR
DUE 031 4.910
FITM AZ
REPO I
06/10/05 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13 1.911.49
S RCR-I(0 FLTR
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NV's:1ER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
DUE 03/ 49I 0
RIM AZ
REPO I
027 07JOIA3S:10:42 001 ',SUP
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TR/MACRON DESCRPRON SYMBOLDVSIP OVANDO DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
06/10/05 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CMO/SER1ES 2003-52 2,210.88
KS-I/0 FLTR
DUE 073  4.010
FITM AZ
REPO I
06/10/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 5.556.44
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DUE 11 0.000
FITM A2
REPO I
06/10/05 INWREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 2.939.07
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
DUE 0Z 4.110
FITM BZ
REPO I
06/10/05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109 5.777.24
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
DUE 17 . 6.000
FITM CZ
REPO I
06/10/05 INTEREST FREDDIE MAC CMCVSERIES 2886 171.90
SC-I/O FUR
DUE 07:1110 4.210
FITM AZ
REPO I
06/10/05 INTEREST FREDDIE MAC CMCVSERIES 2886 184.24
SC-n3 FUR
DUE 07.01. 4.210
FITM AZ
REPO I
0610105 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110 4.386.67
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AILAITER On Fee
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
DUE 0 6000
FITM BZ
REPO1
027 07.01/05:10:42 001 VOIR
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
21 Ci N
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESERTION SYMECIJEUSIP WNW, DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
06/10/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 16.918.58
DUE 05e=2001.7_IMP  "_3.500
06/13x05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CIAO:SERIES 2003-13 6,318,034
S RCR-Ii0 FLTR
4,910
FITM A2
TERM MENT
06/1=5 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13 -6318034
S RCR-1/0 FLTR
4,910
FITM At
REPO A
06/1=5 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 26.400.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
3,860
FITITA
TERM ENT
06/13/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN MIK 26.400.000 2.000.000.00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
3,860
FITM Bi
REPO A
06.(13/05 JOURNAL UNITED TATE TREASURY NOTE -61.000.000 61.152.500.00
FITM Al
4,125 15
REPO  AGREEMENT
06/13M5 JOURNAL UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE 78.000.000 79,462,500.00
FITM A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
06113x05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 30,681.35
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WhISER On Fite
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
DUE 051 lli 4.125
FITM A2
REPO I
027 07,0105:10:42 001 VOIR
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
22 Ill
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS
SETTLEMENT
DATE
06/14/05
TATDE
DATE TRANSACTION
JOURNAL
DESCRPOCH
UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE
FITM A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
(continued)
06/14/05 JOURNAL UNITED FILM
4,125
REPO AGREEMENT
EASURY NOTE
Al
06/14/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 051 4,125
ATM A2
REPO I
06/16/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM Jim CI
REPO A
06 ,1665 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM REM EZ
TERM MENT
06 ,1665 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-13
S RCR-00 FUR
4,91030 . 3
ATM A2
TERM MENT
06 ,16 ,05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-13
S RCR-I/0 FUR
4,910 IN
F1TM A3
REP  OSA
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLAISER On Fite
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
STMISOLCvSty CAJNOITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDO AMOUNT
61.000,000 61,152,500.00
-65.000,000 65.081.250.00
2,072.39
SIM -15,246,375 11,253,000.00
15,246,375 11.334.000.00
6,318,034
MIS -6.318.034
027 MOMS:10:42 001 T89.31P
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YiHOLLY OMED SUOSIDIAny
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
23 c! '31
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TWISACKIN DESCRP111711
06/16/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOiSERIES 2003-13 S RCR-I/0 FLTR 4,910m r FITM Al REPO 06/16/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE 
CMO/SERIES 2003-13 S RCR-I/0 FLTR 4,910 FITM
REPO A 06/16/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN SERIES 352 CLASS 1 0,001 FITM BI REPO A 06/16/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL 
NATIONAL MTG ASSN SERIES 352 CLASS 1 0,001
FITM DZ TERM MENT 06 16 05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN SERIES 353 CLASS 2 5,000 FITM 1.3 REPO P. 06,1605 JOURNAL 
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN SERIES 353
CLASS 2 5,000 ..34 FITM Al
REPO A 06,16,05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN SERIES 353 CLASS 2 5,000 FITM WA2 REPO A
SYMBOL:Cl/SIP
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005 THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLAISER On PIM LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
OUNYTITY 01931T AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUR'
-6.318,034 507,000.00
6.318,034 507,000.00
-19.592.834 14,345,000.00
19,592.834 14.434.000.00
-18,340.469 2.700.000.00
-18,340.469 3.703.000.00
18,340.469 3,703,000.00
027 07i01.135:10:42 001 Y893iP

╭───────────────────── Page 141, Image 1 ─────────────────────╮
│ OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT                               │
│                                                             │
│ STEARNS                                                     │
│                                                             │
│ 2a ase                                                      │
│                                                             │
│ Transaction Detail (continued)                              │
│                                                             │
│ REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS | (continued │
│                                                             │
│ —                                                           │
│ FINANCIAL TRUST GOING                                       │
│                                                             │
│ "HYPAVER NUMBER On Fle                                      │
│                                                             │
│ os Tes JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CHOSERIES 2008-13                 │
│                                                             │
│ ‘oeitéi05 “ToURNA FANNIE MAE CMOISERIES “2003-13            │
│ S Romo FLIR                                                 │
│                                                             │
│ 28r0                                                        │
│ Fi. me                                                      │
│ PAG                                                         │
│                                                             │
│ ui                                                          │
│                                                             │
│ SEAS 952 CLASS 1                                            │
│ Soap                                                        │
│ Fi ca                                                       │
│                                                             │
│ ‘oBTeIOs “TOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL Mii ASSN                 │
│ SEAS 952 CLASS 1                                            │
│                                                             │
│ Soap                                                        │
│ Fi ‘tz                                                      │
│ TERM RO RREEMENT                                            │
│                                                             │
│ ‘oeitéi05 “ToURNA FEDERAL” NATIONAL MTG ASSN                │
│ SEAS 253 CLASS 2                                            │
│                                                             │
│ ‘oBTeIOs “TOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL Mii ASSN                 │
│ SERIES 953 CLASS 2                                          │
│ S000                                                        │
│                                                             │
│ Fin. fo                                                     │
│                                                             │
│ oaliaias" “oui FEDERAL NATIONAL its KSSH                    │
│ SEAS 953 CLASS 3                                            │
│ S.o00                                                       │
│ Fi                                                          │
│ POAG                                                        │
│                                                             │
│ fe                                                          │
│                                                             │
│ 18,034                                                      │
│                                                             │
│ 18.840 469                                                  │
│                                                             │
│ 8'S40;469                                                   │
│                                                             │
│ {8.340469 3,708,000.00                                      │
│                                                             │
│ e8i8038 '507-000.60                                         │
│                                                             │
│ 181582,834 ‘(4.434'500.00                                   │
│                                                             │
│ 507,000.00                                                  │
│                                                             │
│ S760.000.65                                                 │
│                                                             │
│ ‘S76 000.6                                                  │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
=Pm 24
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TWC3ACRON DESCRPRON
06/16/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
F CZ
TERM MENT
06,16i05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
FITM AI
4,125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
06 16 05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
FITM A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
06/1&05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 013.01 0.000
FITM EZ
REPO I
06/16/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
DUE 07 0001
FITM DZ
REPO I
06/16/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07.0 5.000
FITM CZ
REPO I
06/16(05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 051 4025
FITM R2
REPO I
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wisCtLY EAM,E0 SUEISIOally
Beer Steam. Se •it' •
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEF000 June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER OR He
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
STMECL,CVSIP DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
18,34°4°1'110,46i; 3,844,000.00
-48.000,000 48.060.000.00
65,000.000 65.081.250.00
32,109.85
40.892.32
10.890.27
5,260.73
027 01i01,06:10:42 001 V893IP
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
INHOU.Y 01M*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
25 c131
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WhISER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
SETTLEMENT MIX
DATE DM TWCACRON DESORPTION SYMEICIJCUSIP WAWITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
06/17/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -4,924,574 3.652.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM INF  Al
REPO A
06/17/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FITM
C2
TERM FOIMPAENT
06/17/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-52
KS-I/0 FUR
4,010 17
FITM A2
TERM ENT
06/17/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-52
KS-I/0 FUR
4,010 7
FITM A3
TERM MENT
0617/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS
DUE I 1
FITM MIR A3
REPO A
06;17/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL IvITG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS
DUE II
FITM  Al
REPO A
06/17/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE lila.
FITM A2
REPO A
15,246.375 11.253.000.00
17,451,605
-17451.605
-13929377 10.000.000.00
-13,929377 10.342.000.00
13.929,377 10,342,000.00
027 07,0105:10:42 001 VOIR
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WHOLLY OLWEI> SUOSIDIAny
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
26 ci '31
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTION SYMEICMCUSIP CVANTITY OEINT AMOUNT
06/17/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 1,081.54
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 013101 0,000
FITM C2
REPO I
06/22(05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
FITM Al
4,125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
06/22(05 JOURNAL UNITED T EASURY NOTE
FITM A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
06/22(05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 0531111 4,125
FITM A2
REPO I
06/23/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
3,690 •
FITM 82
TERM MENT
06/23/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
3.690
FITM Al
REPO A
06/23/05 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/10 3,690
ATM 82
REPO I
06/27/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSSERIES 2003-13
S RCR-I/0 FLTR
4,910
FITM INCI14
TERM ENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERGO June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
-28.000.000 28.210.000.00
48,000.000 48.060.000.00
10.439.70
26.400.000 2.000.000.00
-26.400.000 2.515.000.00
1.872.22
6.196.744
027 07GIEIS:10:42 001 Y893E
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
yalCu.Y OmED SUBSIDIAny
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
27 131
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON
06/27/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOiSERIES 2003-13
S RCR-I(0 FLTR
4,910Amr
FITM 81
REPO
06/27/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-13
S RCR-I(0 FLTR
4,910
FITM 31.2
TERM MENT
06/27/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-13
S RCR-I10 FLTR
4,910)0 . 3
FITM A2
TERM MENT
06/27/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13
S RCR-I0 FLTR
4,910M
RIM A E S
TERM ENT
06/27/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004.30 CLASS SU
3,940 all#32
FIRM C1
REPO A
06/27/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004.30 CLASS SU
3,94031.1
FITM 82
TERM ENT
0627/05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886
SC-VO RJR
4 0
Firm80
REPO A
Al
SYMBOLCvSp
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
CUMIN) , DEBIT AMOUNT CREOr AMOUNT
-12.393A89
6.196.744 492,000.00
12.393.489 984,000.00
-12,393A89 984,000.00
-24,430.632
24,430.632 1,297,000.00
-5.051,428
027 MOMS:10NQ 001 Y893ip
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WUCU.? OMBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
28 c1 m
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION MERVIN:1H SYMEMICUSIP OUNYTIN DEEM AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
06/27/05 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886 5,051,428 296,000.00
SC-/0 FLTR
4,080314p r
FITM A2
TERM MENT
06.+27/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 34,000.000 34,127,500.00
DUE 05+31/2007 3,500
3,500 7
REM Al
RESALE
T
06/27/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -54,000.000 54.067,500.00
DUE 05+3I/2007 3,500
3,500a7
FITM A6
TERM EMENT
06/27/05 INTEREST FANNIE WE CMO/SERIES 2003-13 794.58
S RCRA+0 FLTR
DUE 03ii+ll 4,910
FITM A2
REPO I
06/27/05 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13 1.589.16
S RCRA+0 FLTR
DUE 03:1101. 4,910
FITM A2
REPO I
06/27/05 INTEREST FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13 NMI 1,589.16
S RCRA+0 FLTR
DUE 4,910
FRM A3
REPO I
0627/05 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 2.094.66
SERIES 2004.30 CLASS SU
DUE 02i 3.940
ATM 62
REPO I
027 07.01,0510:42 001 VOIR
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OBBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
29 ci
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRAM3ACRON DESCRITTON SYME/CIAUSIP QUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
06/27/05 INTEREST FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886 478.04
SC-YO FUR
DUE 073.0 4.080
FITM A2
REPO I
062725 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MEM 55.734.58
DUE 09 3,500
FITM A6
RESALE
0&30;05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MT2 ASSN -8.518.623 6.373.000.00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001
FITM W31
REPO A
0&30105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MT2 ASSN -9.170234 1.737.000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
FITM WI REPO A
0620/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MT2 ASSN SIM 18,340.469 2,700,000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
FITM A4 TERM MENT
0620135 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN IvITG CORP#S10109 -9.552.843 1,861,000.00
SERIES 227 CLASS 13
5,000 II
Find C1
REPO A
0&30:05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL IvITG ASSN 3.633.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07.0i. 5.000
FITM A4
REPO i
TOTAL $-607.638.910.69 $626.942.937.32
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMSER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
027 07'014S:10:42 001 M2931P
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS
DATE
MOM TPAISMTITN DESCRIPTION
06/01/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC
DEBIT AMOUNT CREW AMOUNT
203,925.00
06/02/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC  469,445.00
06/03/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC
06/07/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC
ostosros JOURNAL TO CMDY NC
0610/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC
06/13/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC
570,183.00
35,468.23
0614/05 JOURNAL
88.767.00
144,391.50
897,315.00
TO CMDY NC 130,858.50
0615/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC  79.985.00
06/16/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC
06/17/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC
06/21/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC
06/23/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC  317,653.00
06/24/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC a
06/28/05 JOURNAL MAY 05CLEARING FEES
06/29/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC
06/30/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC MN
TOTAL
6,611.00
228,374.50
42,660.00
6,065.00
2,250.00
75,990.50
100,310.50
$--1,521,258.00 $1.878,994.73
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YTTICLLY ODT*0 SONO/ARV
Reel Siea'n
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERMO June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER PURSER OR FM
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
021 OZOIMS:10:42 001 WINIP
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
INHOU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Trades Executed Pending Settlement
SETTLEMENT TRADE DATE DATE TRANSMIlal
07/01/05 06/30/05
07/01/05 06;30/05 SOLD
07/14/05 06/03/05 BOUGHT
07/14/05 G6/23,05 BOUGHT
07/14/05 05106:05 SOLD
07114105 G6.06:05 SOLO
07/14/05 06/07/05 SOLD
DESORPTION
UNITED TATES TR U YN
03.62514.1D 30
GVER REF # Gi813781181
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03,625% JD 30
1-L . 0 MATURITY
OVER REF # G1813788 Al
FNMA 30YR TBA GTD
SETT, 07x05
~ 05,000%
57110000 BS
FNMA 30YR TBA GTD
SETT, 07105
000005.000% 57210000 BS
FNMA 30YR TBA GTD
SETT, 07105
05.000%
57440000 BS
FNMA 30YR TM GTD
SETT, 07+05
57140000 BS
AS OF 06+0605
FNMA 30YR TBA GTD
SETT, 07/05
57140000 BS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER OII File
LAST STATEMENT May 31,2006
SYMBOL/RUM' OHNTITY EPoCE DEBT AMOUNT OREM APADUNT
-15.000,000.00 99.9977 15,001,1 .58
-50,000.000.00 99.9977 50.003.775.27
11111 15,000,000.00 100.2187 15,032,812.50
30,000,000.00 99.9609 29,988,281.25
-30.000.000.00 98.5195 29.555.859.38
BIM -15,000.000.00 99.5937 14.939.062.50
-15,000.000.00 99.5937 14.939.062.50
027 07,0105:10:42 001 VOIR
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
32 c?
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SEGIEMENT DATE TRADE DATE TRANSACTION
07/14/05 06/07/05 CANCEL SELL
07/14,05 05/19/05 BOUGHT
07/14/05 05/23/05 BOUGHT
07/14/05 05/06/05 SOLD
07/14/05 05/26/05 SOLD
07/14/05 06/06,05 BOUGHT
DESCAPIION
FNMA 30YR TM GTE)
SETT, 07/05
10141/105,000%
57140000 BS
AS OF 06/07/05
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT,07/06
111.11 105,500%
57050000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT,07/06
10.005,500%
57100000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT,07/06
10101.06,500%
57450000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT 07/06
05,500%
57180000 BS
FNMA 30 YR GTO
SETT, 07105
57180000 BS
AS OF 06/06106
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
meaty', OMYED SURSICally
Beer Mar yi
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
a/MO.EGSP GUANTITY PRCE DENT AMOUNT CREPT MhauNT
-15,000,000.00 99.5937 14,939,062.50
30000000.00 100.8671 30,260,156.25
MIN 30000000.00 101 30200,000.00
11111 -30.000.000.00 1005156 30.154.687.50
-60.000.000.00 100.9531 60.571.875.00
11111 50.000.000.00 102.6054 51.302.734.38
027 07'01MS:10:02 001 Y0931P
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
INHOU.Y ow•co SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
33 c?
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
STATEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE
07/14/05 06/03/05 SOLD
TRANSACT/ON CESCRPTION STM8D.EuSP CIJANTITY PACE
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEROT June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WITMER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
DEBIT AMOUNT C=£:\
FNMA 30 YR GTO
SETT. 07105
7070000 BS
-50.000.000.00 102.7968 51.398.437.50
TOTAL $171,823.046.88 $266.563.892.23
The chow Fades cb eel eppew in eery ann. sedge PI Ihn :Warm*
Your messages
Bear Stearns receives payments or other remuneration from the advisers,
distributors or other affiliates of certain of the mutual funds available through
Bear Stearns. Such payments or remuneration are for administrative,
technological or other services provided in connection with fund accounts and
are generally calculated based on the amount of assets held in the accounts,
Such payments or other remuneration are in addition to shareholder servicing
and distribution fees that Bear Stearns may receive. Funds whose affiliates do
not make payments to Bear Stearns, including funds that may pay a higher or
lower return, may be available to you.
NOTICE OF CHANGE PURSUANT TO TRUTH IN LENDING SEC RULE 100-16
Effective no earlier than thirty (30) days from your receipt of this statement,
the annual rate of interest charged on any credit extended to you by Bear
Stearns for the purpose of purchasing, carrying or trading in any security or
other property shall be based on either the Bear Stearns Margin Basis Rate,
the Bear Stearns Fed Funds Rate or the London Interbank Offering Rate
("UBOR"), as notified to you upon request. The Bear Stearns Margin Basis Rate
will be quoted daily by Bear Stearns at our main office in New York, Factors
affecting the determination of the Bear Stearns Margin Basis Rate will include
the short•term market interest rates quoted by money center banks and the
Federal Reserve and the rate that Bear Stearns is charged for borrowing
money. The Bear Stearns Fed Funds Rate is the rate for U.S. dollar funds, as
quoted by an independent broker of such funds selected by Bear Stearns for
the last transaction completed prior to 9:30 a,m, (Eastern Time) on the
business day on which such rate is determined. The annual rate of interest will
be no more than 3% above the Bear Stearns Margin Basis Rate or 4% above
either the Bear Stearns Fed Funds Rate or LIBOR and will appear on your
monthly statements.
027 07/01.135:10:02 001 Y893IP
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
If Bear Stearns makes changes in any of the credit terms and conditions
described herein or if a change is required by law, we will notify you of such
change within a reasonable period of time, unless such change results in the
same or a higher rate to you, in which case we will provide you at least 30
days' prior written notice, The annual rate of interest you are charged is tied to
the Bear Stearns Margin Basis Rate, the Bear Stearns Fed Funds Rate or
LIBOR and may fluctuate with those rates, The changes in rates resulting from
this fluctuation will be made without prior notice to you (as contrasted with
changes in the credit terms and conditions, notice of which will be provided as
described above),
Except as described above, the Truth in Lending disclosure previously provided
to you remains in effect,
End of Statement
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
Yn10t4Y OUT,E0 SUBSIOIMIT,
Beer Stewn
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* June 1.2005
THROUGH June 30.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT May 31.2005
027 07i0litio0:42 001 vekuP
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHCU.Y 01M.IED SUNK/MI/iv
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
S mear. Stearns Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSITE weny.bearstearns.com
What's In This Statement
Financial Summary 3
Your Portfolio Holdings  4
Transaction Detail  7
Trades Not Yet Settled  37
Your Portfolio at a Glance
TOTAL VAWE OF SECURITIES THIS PERIOD
LONG ACCRUED INTEREST
NET CREDIT BALANCE
3.052,376
27,070
122,206
IIII II 111111111U I I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
0/0 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Market Value of Your Portfolio
Cash 8 Equivalent $122.206
$180,992
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD $3,201,652
NET EQUITY LAST STATEMENT
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT
3.131.368
70.283
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on file for your account.
Axed $3.052.376
Income   $2.900.677
Current market Sue
NE Last statement's market value
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKIO *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AVNER On File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
SI T T/1111•Tduri A Xs dOrmacuol hnoses only I Is ra @lorded as  &ant
staternurC should be Massed for your words See worm a for Doodad' nrcautire
027 06,01135:09:00 001
GEARED 11. .100044 ITS
WHOLLY OMAE0 $1.1090MAY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 o168
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
021 0601.05:09:03 001 Y878
CLEARED IHRCUGH ITS
(MT,E0 SUOSIOally
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PERIOD
Income Summary RAS PERICO YEAR TO DATE
Opening Balance $180,992.40 U.S. GOA. Bond Int. 766,042.23 3.462.043.46
Govt. Agency Int. 823.071.67 3.397.846.03
Securities Sold 1,056,491,072.96 Corp. Bond Int. 106.943.92 595,471.88
Dividends/Interest 1,696,447.33 Credit Balance Int. 389.51 3.223.71
Miscellaneous 936,131.00 Reverse Repurchase Int. 88,412.07 1.082.145.71
Amount Credited $1,059,123,651.29 Total $1 784 859.40 $8 540 730.79
Securities Bought -1,056,980,245.53 Bond Purchase Int. -514.432.42 -4.940,434.41
Funds Withdrawn -71.505.00 Repurchase Int. Exp. -240.018.09 -882,877.32
Dividends/Interest Charged -514.432.42
Miscellaneous -1,616.254.91
Portfolio Composition Amount Debited $.1.059,182A37.86
CashiCash Equivalent 122,206
Net Cash Activity -58.786.57
Fixed Income 3.052,376
ClosingBalance $122,205.83
Total $3.174.582
Cash Balance Summary
OFEts NO CLC61/10
Margin 180,992.40 122,205.83
Net Cash Balance $180.992.40 $122,205.83
027 0601.0S:09:CO 001
I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash 8 Equivalent--
3%
— Feed Income
97%
Untivoecl P0,00, 5 00°0* debt balance omit, Or, male wive, Tha elocalxn percents-0 ts Or.st.0 from V0 Mnal.te markei 
value palbn
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
valour omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
4 o Jtl
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
DESCPAPTION
CASH BALANCE
SrAISCLOJSIP IMAMS ESTIMATED CuRRENT OurdaiTy PACE VALUE !Mu& MCCUE VELD mi
122.206
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS $122.208
FIXED INCOME
Government & Agency Obligations
DESCRIPTION SWMOLCUSP
ACCT
TYPE DUMMY PRICE MARKET VALLE
ACCRUED
INTEREST
EstmArE0
ANNUAL INCOME
CuRRISC
YEAR
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN 14.948.788 6.4165 959.183 18.772 614.395 64.0540
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
DATED DATE 05/21/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 12/20/2029 4.110%
FACTOR - .91792270
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC MRGN 14.940.760 7.2678 1.085.871
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DATED DATE 06/23/04
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 05/20/2030
FACTOR - .93016410
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN 12.733.059 7.9111 1.007.321 8.298 497.863 49.4245
SERIES 2003.49 CLASS SW
DATED DATE 04/30103
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 01/2512033 3.910%
FACTOR - .52384850
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
Accamy NUMBER
TAXPAYER M.aCR On File
LAST sTATEmENT Aprll 29.2005
021 060i.05:09:03 001 ••878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MOLLY OMP.E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
5 ,) Jtl
Your Portfolio Holdings (continued)
Government & Agency Obligations (continued)
DESORPTION
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DATED DATE I 1&1:03
BOOK ENTRY CNLT
DUE 11/01,2033
FACTOR — 1.00000000
Total Government& Agency Obligations
S!NEOLUISP MX'
TYPE
MRGN
°IMPIETY
PRICE MARKET VALLE
83,1641
$3.052.376
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER M/03ER OE File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
ACCRUED ESTEEMED OURFIGVT
INTEREST ANNUAL INCOME YELD PO
$27.070 51.112.258
TOTAL FIXED INCOME $3.052.376 $27.070 51.112.258
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLDINGSACCRUED INTEREST 527.070
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLDINGSESTIMATED ANNUAL INCOME $1.112.258
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS 83.174.582
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc. outstanding as of date of statement
PLRO-MSE/
START DATE
REPURCHASE
DATE
PROMS
RATE
PURCHASE PRICE)
PRI/OPAL
ACCRUED REPO
MEREST•
QUANTITY
(FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTOR
YOU PROVIDED GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 04/25/05 OPEN 0,000 -26A00.000 SERIES 2004-5 CLASS P 3.8600 02)20133
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 05/11/06 06110)05 3.290 -10.851400 -20,824 -30.000.000 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 12(01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 05/16/05 06/16105 3.290 -11.334.000 -16.572 -30.959.779 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 12(01/32
027 DE01.135:09:03 001 V878
CLEARED IHRCUGH ITS
wHG.13 OUT*0 SUGROany
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.Inc. outstanding asof date of statement (continued)
PIACl/ASV REFIJRCHPSE
START DATE DAZE
PACING
RATE
PURCHASE PRIM ACCRUED REPO
PRINCPAL MEREST'
GUANTITY
(FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTCN
I,Sean SPCmit' Go'
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERO) *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ALUMNI NUMBER
TAXPAYER PANDER On File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 05/16/05 0611905 3.290 -14.434.000 -21.105 -23.000.000
FANNIE MAE STRIPS
SERIES 352 CLASS PO 07/01/34
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 05/16/05 0916/05 3.290 -3.844.000 -5.620 -20.000.000
FANNIE MAE STRIP
SERIES 353 CLASS 10 5.0000 07/01/34
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 0917/05 06/10/05 3.290 -1.008.000 -1.381 -25.000.000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
SERIES 2003-52 CLASS 4.0100 07/2917
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 0917/05 06/10/05 3,290 -1.340.000 -1.836 -27.112.874
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS 4,1100 02/20/32
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 05/20/05 06/10/05 3.290 -996.000 -1.092 -25.000.000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
SERIES 2003-13 CLASS 4.9100 03/2933
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 05/25/05 06/10/05 3.290 -3.800.000 -2.430 -10.000.000
FANNIEMAE STRIP
SERIES 346 CLASS PO 11/01/33
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 05/25/05 0611905 3.290 -3.951.000 -2.527 -20.000.000
FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 05/25/05 06/10/05 3.290 -3.000.000 -1.919 -20.000.000
FREDOIEMAC STRIP
SERIES 228 CLASS 10 6.0000 02/01/36
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 06.25/05 OPEN 4010 -1 -9.724.538
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MIG CORP
SERIES 2886 CLASS SC 4,2100 07/15/19
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 05/26/05 06/10/05 3.300 -525.000 -288 -12.500.000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
SERIES 2003-13 CLASS 4.9100 03/2933
YOU PROVIDED
(MARGIN) 0926/05 OPEN 0,000 -12.500.000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
SERIES 2003-13 CLASS 4,9100 03/25/33
027 MOOS:09:03 001 V878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
7 c. nn
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.inc.outstanding as of date of statement (continued)
PUREWSS,
START DATE
REPURCHASE
DATE
PRICING
RATE
PURCHASE RICO
PRINCPAL
rOCAUED REPO
MEREST'
GUMMY
(FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTION
YOU SOLD USTR 4,1250 05/15/15
(REPO) 05/27105 OPEN 2.640 -38.095.000 -14.984 -38.000,000
YOU BOUGHT USTR 3,5000 05/31/07
(REVERSE) 05/31/05 OPEN 2.830 54.000.000 4.245 54.000.000
TOTAL REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS 354.000.000 34245
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MANNER On File
LAST STATEMENT AprII 29.2005
TOTAL REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS 1-93.178.001 1-90.578
•As ce ,llµmnnl die
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR CESCRPTION SNA00. Cusp 0,ANDre PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
05.02105 04/27105 BOUGHT GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC 15.073.792 7,15625 1,078,718.27
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
OS. 57160000 BS
ACCR, ENT, 21,153.55
05102/05 04/28)05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -50,000.003 100.05469 50.027,343 .75
killiir3.625% AO 30
. MATURITY
ACCR. INT. 9.850.64
OVER REF o 01181006 Al
0510645 PRINCIPAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORN/Stet 10 -236.730
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6400 DUE 02/01/35
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 05-15-05
027 DS01.05:09:03 001 V878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
O‘M‘ED SUEISIDaTve
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
05/00105 05/06+05 SOLD
05109/05 05/06005 BOUGHT
05/11105 06:06.95 BOUGHT
05/12105 03/31105 BOUGHT
05/12105 04/12105 BOUGHT
05/12105 04/07105 CANCEL SELL
CESCFCETION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 02/15/2015 04.000% FA 15
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 4.262 % TO MATURITY
GVER REF V G1267694 A3 WWEI3
SYMEIOLCUSV CVANillY PRICE
I
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLIMER ON File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
DEBIT AMOUNT CREW MOM
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03,625% AO 30
MATURITY
GVER REF to G1261032 Al
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
Ofilli s04.210%
7720000 BS
AS OF 05/06/05
FNMA-30YRTFNMAIGTO
SETT.05/04
011i 05.000%
57140000 BS
FNMA-30YRTFNMA)G10
SETT.05104
1.111 505.000%
7300000 BS
FNMA-30YRIFNMAIGTO
SETT.05/05
1011005.000%
57220000 BS
AS OF 0407105
TO CV. PREVIOUS SELL
-20.000.000 97.92188
ACCR. INT,
19,584,375.00
183,425.41
30.000.000 99.82813 29,948,437.50
ACCFL INT, 26,596.47
15.096.208 6.90625 1,042,581.89
ACCR. INT. 37,073.77
EMI 20.000.000 97.49219 19,498,437.50
VIM 20.000.000 98.13281 19.626.562.50
MIK 40.000.000 97.92188 39.16.8.750.00
027 0601.05:09:03 001 '.878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YOICtLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
9 o Jtl
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
05/12105 03/31105 CANCEL BUY
05/12/05 04/12/05 CANCEL BUY
05112105 04/07/05 SOLD
05/12/05 03/31105 BOUGHT
05/12/05 04/12/05 BOUGHT
091245 04/07105 CANCEL SELL
OESCRIPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)ITO
SETT,05/05
1.005,000 , ,
57140000 BS
AS OF 03/31105
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT,05.05
101100105,000 ,,
57300000 BS
AS OF 04/12/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30W4FNMAATO
SETT,05;04
Mai 05,000%
57220000 BS
FNMA 3crRrFNMA)GID
SETT OE 05
05,500%
57150000 BS
FNMA-30YRTNMNGTO
SETT,05,G5
0. 0405.500% 57400000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)010
SETT 05105
05,500'.
57210000 BS
AS OF 04!07.05
TO CH. PREVIOUS SELL
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLIAMER On File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
STIADOLCUSP GUMMY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-20,000,000 97.49219 19,498,437.50
-20.000.000 98,13281 19.628.562 .50
-40.000.000 97.92188 39.168,750 .00
20.000.000 99.89063 19.978.125.00
20.000.000 100,37500 20.075.000.00
40.000.000 100,25781 40.103.125.00
027 06014S:09:C0 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MOST OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
10 r!33
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
05112105 03/31105 CANCEL BUY
05/12105 04/12/05 CANCEL BUY
05112:05 04i07 105 SOLD
05/12/05 06,06105 SOLD
05/13/05 06/12/05 SOLD
05/13/05 06/12/15 SOLD
DESORPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJOTD
SETT.05/05
NW 05.5004
5715001)0 BS
AS OF 03/31105
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-SOYFOFNMA)G1D
SETT.05/05
10010105.500I,
57400000 BS
AS OF 04/12/05
TO C/3. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YRIFNMAJOID
ETT.05105
57210000 BS
FEDL ROME LOAN MIG MAP/410110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
06,000%
7430000 BS
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 25TH
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
AO 30
MATURITY
GVER REF V G1325905 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.625% AO 30
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # 01325601 Al
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO *1130.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLPOER On File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
STIAEOLCUSP CVANTITY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT MCC AMOUNT
-20.000.000 99.89063 19.978,125 ,00
-20.000.000 100.37500 20.075.000 00
-40.000.000 100.25781 40.103.125.00
-18.365.752 20.43750 3.753.500.73
ACOR, INT, 33.670,55
-10.000.000 99.95313 9.995.312.50
ACCR. INT. 12,805.71
-15.000.000 99.95313 14.992,968 ,75
ACOR, INT. 19,208.56
027 0601.135:09:011 001 '.1178
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MOLLY ODS*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
11 -
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
05113105 05(12105 SOLD
05/13/05 JOURNAL
05/16105 05/13105 SOLD
05/16105 05/13105 BOUGHT
05/16105 JOURNAL
05/17/05 05712105 BOUGHT
05117705 05/12/05 BOUGHT
OE SCRVTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE
lailk03.625% AO 30
MATURITY
GVER REF tt G1325547 Al
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP/S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000 DIVE 02101735
ADJ POS
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04.000% FA
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1333411 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04.125% MN IS
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1333415 Al
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORHAST 0170
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000 DIVE 02101/35
ADJ POSITION
FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-52
KS-VO RTR
.11.1 504.080%
7260000 BS
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-30 CLASS SU
04,210%
57300000 BS
AS OF 0512.05
I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERGO *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUIGER On File
LAST STATEMENT *II 29.2005
SYMBOLCUMP OJAMIW ANN OMIT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
-20.000.000 99.94531
ACCR. INT.
19.989.062 .50
25.611.41
NMI -2
40.000.000 98.57031 39.428.125.00
ACCR, IN% 397.790.06
INS 40,000.000 99.73047 39.892.187.50
ACCR, 4,483.70
MIN .1
17,728.728 8.03125 1,423,838.51
ACCR, INT. 44,203.63
24,954.730 7,28125 1,817,016.29
ACCR, 78,794.56
027 06016S:09:CO 001 118 78
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
?RIMY OW,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
05/18/05
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
05713105 BOUGHT
CESCRPTION
FREDDIE MAC CMOSERIES 2886
SC-I/0 RTR
7130000 BS
05/18/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 DUE 02101/35
STMEIOLCUSP GUMMY Plea
8.743.867 8,50000
ACCR.
I. SIean $PCmitkf EAR
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEREIO *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
DEBIT AMOUNT
743,228.73
3,067.64
CHEM AMOUNT
05/20/05 05(19105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03,625% AO 30
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1393740 Al
-13,000,000 100.05469
ACCR. INT,
13.007,109 ,38
25.611,41
05120105 05/19105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04.125% MN IS
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1393587 Al
-10,000,000 100.29688
ACCR. INT.
10.029.687.50
5.604,62
05120105 PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2004-035 CLASS SP
4210 DUE 12/20/29
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 05-20-05
-147,420
05:2045 PRINCIPAL GOVERNMENT RATIONAL MTO ASSOC
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DUE 05,20/30
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 05-20-05
-133,032
05:23+05 05:26.05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03625% AO 30
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1404847 AS
AS OF 05/20105
50.000.000
ACCR, INT,
99.97656 49.988.281.25
113.281,25
05.2345 05(2045 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.625% AO 30
0 MATURITY
GVER REF tt G1403009 Al
-20.000.000 99.96094
ACCR, INT,
19.992.187 .50
45.312,50
027 DE,DI.05:09:03 001 '.878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHEEL? EMBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION CESCRPTION SYMBOLED-SIP PACE DEBIT AMOUNT CREW AMOUNT
05/24105 05/23/05 SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE -13.000.000 100.03125 13,004,062,50
I~3.625% AO 30
MATURITY
ACCR, INT. 30.733.70
OVER REF # G1434596 Al
05/24105 05/23105 SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIK -10.000.000 100.58203 10.058203 .13
04.125% MN 15 ACCR, INT. 10,088.31
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1434606 Al
05:25105 05/24105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 3.000.000 100.89063 3.026.718.75
04.125% MN IS ACCR. INT. 3,362.77
0 MATURITY
OVER REF # 01443571 Al
05125105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 296.514.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN RID 04.05 Pit 05-25-05
REPO P S I 0.0000
05125105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 306.000.26
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN FUD 04.05 PAD 05-25-05
REPO P S I 0.0000
05125105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MIN -250.651
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
3.980 DUE 01/25/33
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 05-25-05
05125105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 13.79764
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
CUE 11/01/33
PAIN R/D 04.05 Pit 05-25-05
REPO P S I 0.0000
I
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLIN3ER On
LAST STATEMENT 29.2005
027 060105:09:CO 001 '.878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
viNOttY 0%1T,*0 SUBSIOIAlly
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
14 -
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION STMEIOLCUSV °WIT( PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREW PAC146
05/2905 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 137,824,76
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01/33
PRIN FUD 04-05 PAD 05-25-05
REPO P d I 0,0000
05/25105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 346.726,61
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001 DUE 07/01/34
PAIN RID 04.05 Ki 05-25-05
REPO P S I 0,0000
05.27105 0926/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY TOTE Miff 11.000.000 99.99609 10.999.570.31
AO 30
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 29.256,12
GVER REF # G1464298 Ell
05/27105 05/26105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY 143TE 50.000.000 99.99609 49.998.046 ,88
01001013,625% AO 30
MATURITY
GVER REF # G1464298 Al
ACC/, 611, 132.982,33
OS.27105 05/26105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE 15.000.000 100,37109 1E055.664,06
04,125% MN 15
MATURITY
ACM, 617, 20.176,63
GVER REF # G1464643 Al
05.27105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 1
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01/33
ADJUST POSITION
05/27.05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 1
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01133
05.27105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPHSIOTO9 1
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000 DUE 12/01/34
ADJUST POSITION
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD &X1130.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLIMER ON File
LAST STATEMENT Apdl 29.2005
027 DS,OT.05:09:03 001
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
15 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR DESCRIPTION STMOOLCUSP OUPARRY PRICE DEIST AMOUNT CROW AMOUNT
05/27105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000 DUE 02/01/35
ADJUST POSITION
05/31105 05/26/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY N3TE 36.000.000 99.74219 35.907.187.50
03.500% MN 31
MATURITY
GYER REF V G1464831 Al
05/31105 05/26/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -15.000.000 99.74219 14.961.328 .13
03.500% MN 31
MATURITY
GYER REF V G1464297 BI
05/31105 05/27105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY N3TE -25.000.000 99.71875 24.929,687 .50
DUE 05/31/2007 03.500% MN 31
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 3.647 % TO MATURITY
OVER REF # G1472531 A3 WWEB
AS OF 05727105
05/31105 05/26/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE EMI -50.000.000 99.74219 49.871.093 .75
03.500% MN 31
MATURITY
OVER REF # G1464297 Al
TOTAL $-399.8$5.909.86 1473.974.623.67
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO *1130.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER PURSER On File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
027 0601.05:09:03 001 Vi978
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
16 ci
Transaction Detail (continued)
DEPOSITS AND WITHDRAWALS
EWE TRANSACT Cr. DESCRIrICH
0525:05 FNO WIRED MOAN G./168194 FNDS WIRED TO
IMO/ BANK
C#264533
TOTAL S.71,606.00
INTEREST
DATE DESCRIPTION SYMBOL CUSIP OUANTITT RATE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
05.02105 AVG BAL 244.990 F1T 1.908 389.51
021 OFFICE INTEREST 0405
05/16105 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109 5.0000 6.066,95
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/0112034 5.000
INT RID 04-05 PA:1 OS-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
05/16105 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG OCAP#S10109 5.0303 10.111 .58
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 04-05 ND 0S-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
05/16105 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109 5.0000 10,1 11.58
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/0112034 5.000
INT RID 04-05 ND 05-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
05/16/05 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109 Miff 5.0000 20.223.15
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 04-05 PM 05-15-05
REPO P 8, I 5.0000
027 06005:09:02 001 vale
DEBIT Amotivr CREDIT AMOUNT
71.505.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMBER ON File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
CLEARED TEIROuGH ITS
wHCLLY OGYRO SURROMIly
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
r. SIean $PCmitkf EAR
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERO) *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MANNER On Ale
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
DATE DESCRIPTION SYMEICIJCV5IP OVANTRY RATE IP4 CENT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
05/16/05 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CCAPMS10109 5.0000 34.379.36
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 04.05 PA) CS-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
05/16105 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORN/610110 ISM 6.0000 14.129.41
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2035 6.000
INT RID 04.05 PAD 05-15-05
REPO P &I 6.0000
091645 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG 00AP#S10110 OMNI 6.0000 32 968.62
SERES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2035 6.000
INT RID 04.05 PAD 05-15-05
REPO P &I 6.0000
05/16105 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510110 NMI 6.0000 47.098.03
SERES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2035 6.000
INTEREST PAYMENT 05-15.05
05/16105 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORN/610110 6.0000 94.196.06
SERES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2035 6.000
INT RID 04.05 PAD 05-15-05
REPO P &I 6.0000
05/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3.9600 58.080.00
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/2012033 3.960
INT RID 04.05 PA) 05-20-05
REPO P &I 3,9600
05/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3.9600 87.120.00
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 3.960
INT RID 04-05 PA) 05-20-05
REPO P &I 3,9600
027 060105:09:03 001 11878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MELLY EIDS*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD 30.200S
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
DATE DESCRIPTION SYMECLGUSIP PANNUN RATE 141 reed AMOUNT MEDI AMOUNT
05120/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 4.2100 87.549,51
SERIES 200440 CLASS SU
DUE 02/20/2032 4,210
INT RID 04.05 PM 05-20-05
REPO P 8I 4,2100
05120/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN ISM 4,2100 52.962,53
SERES 2004-035 CLASS SP
DUE 12/20/2029 4,210
INTEREST PAYMENT 05-20.05
05120/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSOC 52.883.89
SERES 2004-041 CLASS SE
DUE 05/202030 0,000
INTEREST PAYMENT 05-20.05
05/25/05 FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003.13 4.9800 53e71,96
S RCA-I/O RTR
DUE 03/25/2033 4,980
INT RID 04.05 PA 0S-25-05
REPO P 8I 4,9800
05.25/05 FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003.13 4,9800 53 471,96
S RCA-I/0 RTR
DUE 03/25/2033 4,980
INT RID 04.05 ND 05-2545
REPO P 8I 4,9800
05.25(05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 3.9800 43.062.64
SERES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DUE 01/25/2033 3,980
INTEREST PAYMENT 05-25 OS
0525/05 FANNIE WE CMO/SERIES 2003.52 4.0800 60277,68
KS-V0 RTR
DUE 07/25/2017 4,080
INT RID 04.05 ND 05-25-05
REPO P 8I 4,0800
027 0601.05:09:03 001 11878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? CTMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
19 c?
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
DATE MORMON
05125/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07101/2034 5000
TNT R/D 04-05 PA9 05-25-05
REPO P & I 5.0000
TOTAL
SY/ABOLCUS,P QUANTITY RATE Ice!
5:0000
DEBIT AMOUNT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On FM
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
OREM AMOUNT
78.180.13
5896.734.56
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTICN
05.02,105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 00+3012007 3.625
3,625 7
FITM Al
RESALE
05:03105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN PAM CORPitS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
5 0
HIM00 RiplirA2
TERM MENT
05.03105 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN 1,116 CORP4S10.109
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
5,000 1.f4
FITM Al
REPO A
OS03105 JOURNAL FEDL ACME LOAN MTG COSH/5101n)
SERIES 228 CLASS 0
HIM
000)035
A2
TERM AAENT
05103/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTO CORP8S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 DUE 02/01/35
ATM FI233173 41
REPO AGREEMENT
SVMBCLCUSIP 0.:NYHTY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT MIOUNT
IIIIININ
NMI
50,000.000
1.456.066
.1.456.066
6.593,724
-2.354.901
50.125.000.00
312.000.00
027 0601.05:09:03 001 '.1178
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
20 c1>x
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRITMON SYME/CLCUSIP OvANTIN DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
05/03105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPFTS10110 -4.238.822 747,000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6FITMMI300.0r 5A1
REPO
05104105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN 660.862 473,000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE I JON
FITM AZ
TERM MENT
05104/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -660,862 479,000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
FITM lisp Al
REPO A
0504x05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN EMI 1.214,03
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 1 Jill 0,000
FITM AZ
REPO I
05109(05 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTE1 CCAPFTS10110 2.295.719
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 DUE 02/01/35
FITM FI233173 A2
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
05109(05 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTEI CORPFTSTOT 10 NNW -2.295.719 423,000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS D
6F.000ITM WWI
REPO A
05109(05 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE SIM -40.000.000 39.400.000.00
FITM j  Al
4,000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
05109(05 JOURNAL UNITED TALES TREASURY NOTE 60.000.000 59.400.000.00
RIM A2
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
4,000 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
027 0601.05:09:03 001 Yale
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
imiCtLY OmED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
21 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRCH SYMEICASCUSIP OUN0ITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
05109105 RECEIVED UNITS) STATES TREASURY NOTE 20.000.000 20.000.000 .00
DUE 04+30/2007 3.625
FITM Al
3.625 Dia11(7
RESALE T
05109+05 DEUVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -50,000.000 50.125.000.00
DUE 04+30'2007 3.625
FILM A2
3.625.01t7 Em
TERM ENT
05109+05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 41,365,50
DUE 4.000
FITM A2
REPO I
05109+05 INTEREST LRCM STATES TREASURY NOTE MEE 26,594,10
DUE 04+W ei gi  1.625
05/11105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 15.062.892 10.583.000 .00
SERIES 329 CUSS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FITM A2
TERM MENT
Rpm"
05/11+05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MFG ASSN .15,062.892 10.851.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FITM INF  DI
REPO A
05.111:05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN ISM 6.463,537 4,553.000 .00
SERIES 346 CUSS 1
DUE II FITM Q
TERM MENT
027 0601.05:09:03 001 v878
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER•00 April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT A/3r11 29.2005
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY 01MAED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCREMON SYMEICIJCUSIP
05/11/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MD ASSN
05111105 JOURNAL
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
FILM IMF' C1
REPO A
FEDL ICIlE LOAN MTG COAPPSIOt 09
05/11:05 JOURNAL
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
FAISITMM R..A2
TERM DENT
FEDL ICA WAN MI5 CORPeS °tee
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FA4SIT4300 411. 111134A2
TERM Fon igiligMENT
05/11/05 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MIG OCAPeS10709 NMI
05/11/05 JOURNAL
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5,000
FEM A2
TERM ENT
FEDL Wee LOAN MTG CORPOS 10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
06 1 05 JOURNAL
05 11 05 JOURNAL
5.000 11.34
FITM B1
REPO A
FEDL NOME LOAN MI6 °CAPPS t Ot 10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000
FITM *WI REPO A
FEDL !CM LOAN MI6 CORPoS10t10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000 ..35
FITM Al
REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD WI 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLAISER On Fee
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
OTTANDre DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-6.463.537 4.666.000 .00
1 445 460 312.000.00
2.409,100 536.000.00
4.818,200 1,143,000.00
-8.672.760 1.887.000.00
-1.836.575 333,000.00
-2.295.719 415,000.00
027 0601.05:09:03 001 •.1178
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIDST OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
23 c! aA
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON SYMEOMICUSIP OVAMIN OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
05/11105
05/11/05
MVOS
0511.05
OS 11r05
0511 /05
JOURNAL
INTEREST
INTEREST
INTEREST
INTEREST
INTEREST
INTEREST
FEDL 1.1011E LOAN MTG CORPNS10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000
FITM R.1.2
TERM MENT
FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 01.0 0.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE I 1 0.000
ATM AZ
REPO I
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG COAPTIS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
DUE Isis 6,000
FITM AZ
REPO I
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG COAPOS10839
SERIES 227 CLASS
DUE 17.10 5,000
FITM
REPO I
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPOS 10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE I 6,000
FITM AZ
REPO I
FEDL ItME LOAN MTG CCePttS 10ii 0
SERIES 228 CLASS I0
NMI
2.295.719 423,000.00
27,603.99
11,875,74
228,11
I .222.08
2.981,32
77,31
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD WI 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER ROASTER On File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
DUE 0 6.000
FRM AZ
REPO I
027 0601EIS:09:02 001 Y878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
24 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETUMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACRON DESCRPRON
05/12105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP8S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000
FITM RII.32
TERM MENT
05/12105 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MIG CalPeS101 10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 01.  6,000
FILM 82
REPO I
05113+05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN 1.11G 0C41PaS10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 11.5
FITM Al
REPO A
05113 05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04+30/2007 3,625
3,625.tir m
FITM A2
TERM ENT
MI 3 05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04+3012007 3,625
3,625 INC
FITM Al
RESALE
0511345 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTG COAP4S10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FS.000ITM AI
REPO A
05/13+05 JOURNAL FEDL !CAE LOAN WC CORN'S i0109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5,000R.
FITM
TERM MENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* W130.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT Apill 29.2005
SYME/CLCUSIP PAUCITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
18,365,752 3.665.000,00
INN 8.741,03
-918.287 162,000,00
INK -20.000.000 20.000.000,00
INK 65,000.000 65.182.500,00
INN -2.409.100 516.000,00
NMI 2.409,100 556,000,00
027 0601.05:09:03 001 V878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YOICALY 01MAED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
25 0 ))
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCROniON SYMECLoCUSIP OUANTITT DEBIT AMOUNT
05113105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04+39L.2.00L7_ _3.625
05113/05 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CCAP#S10109 Miff 1.459,50
SERIES 227 LASS 13
DUE 12.0 5.000
ATM AZ
REPO I
05116105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN SIM 15,544.793 11.174.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STFUP
FILM a_CZ
FILM EE
6,05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN .15,544.793
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01+01/33
STRP
ATM imp El
REPO A
0596 :05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -19.964.443
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001
RIM 11.81
REPO A
05/I6 05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN 19.964.443 14.660.000,00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001RWI
FITM AZ
TERM ENT
05 16:05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN .18,577.270
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 IOW
FILM CI
REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* W130.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER musette On File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
CREDO AMOUNT
5.394.44
11.334.000.00
14.434.000.00
3.844.000.00
027 060iieS09:03 001 ••1178
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
26 I ))
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SCM.EmENT TMDE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON SYME/CLCUSIP °WRY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
05/16105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MD ASSN 18,577.270 4,211.000 )00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
MA 31.2
TERM MENT
05/16105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPeS10109 INN -8.190.940 1,729.000 .00
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
5.000
RIM W31
REPO A
05.16.95 JOURNAL FEDL XOTdE WAN 1410 CORPeS10109 INN 8.190,940 1.837.000,00
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
F145114300 Oalleasi3452 TERM Fon ieligAAENT
0S96 t05 JOURNAL FEDL ROME LOAN WC CCAPaStOt 10 NMI 2.754,862 528.000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000
FITM
TERM ENT
05.1 6 05 JOURNAL FEDL ROME LOAN MTG CORPoS ioi m 4.132.294 747.000,00
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
FITM
AZ6,0001.5
TERM MENT
091645 JOURNAL FEDI. ROME LOAN MI6 °CAPPS tOt 10 4887.157 1,190.000,00
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6FITA4.000
REPO A
*Mr
05/16105 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIN 40.000.000 39.400.000,00
FITM Hip A2
4.000 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
05/16/05 JOURNAL LIMED TALES TREASURY NOTE .40.000.000 39.900.000,00
FITM Al
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On FIk
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
4.125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
027 06014S:09:M 001 7878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIDST OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
27 o
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACDON DESCRITMON SYME/MICUSIP OWNTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
05116/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 30,598.14
05/16,65 INTEREST
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 01.01 0.000
ATM CZ
REPO I
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 33,880,89
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
DUE 07301 0.001
ATM AZ
REPO I
OS/16.95 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 1111111 11,531,12
0916.05 INTEREST
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 073.0. 5.000
ATM AZ
REPO I
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG OCAPPS10709 3.955.67
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 171.0. 6.000
FITM BZ
REPO I
05 116.05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG GailutStOt 10 NMI 887.48
05116,05 INTEREST
SERIES 228 CLASS 0
DUE Oil. 6.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG COBH/SIDIIC .136.96
051605 INTEREST
SERIES 228 CLASS Co
DUE 0 ' 6.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
uraTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE 18,758,78
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD *II 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
DUE 02/1 4.000
ATM A2
REPO I  1
027 0601.05:09:03 001 •e878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
28 c!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION
05/17105 JOURNAL FANNIE MME GAO/SERIES 2003.52
KS-I/0 FUR
FITM Al
REPO
05/17105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2004.30 CLASS SU
4,210 110.2
FITM 81
REPO A
05/17105 JOURNAL FEDL /ME WAN lin CORPOS10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 lair5
FITM AI
REPO A
0518x05 JOURNAL FREOOIE MAC CMO,SERIES 2886
SC-I/0 FLTR
4,210 II.19
FITM Al
REPO A
05120105 JOURNAL FANNIE MME CATO/SERIES 2003.13
S RCR-1/0 FLTR
4,980
FITM JOINE2
TERM ENT
0520105 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CA401SERIES 2003.13
S RCR-1/0 FLTR
4,980
FRM AI
REPO A
05.20105 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CarteSERIES 2003.13
S RCR-1/0 FLTR
4,980 Si
FITM Alr
REPO A
SAileCrAusar
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* *1130.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT ApTII 29.2005
CA//MM DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-17,728,728 1.008.000 ,00
-24.954.730 1.340.000,00
-6.428.013 1.113.000,00
-8.743.867 594.000,00
25.769.620
.12,884.810
.12,884.810 996,000,00
027 0601.05:09:03 001
CLEARED THROUGH 11S
YAICU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
29 c?))
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMEMENT MADE
DATE DATE TV0S3ACSON DESCRPSON
05/20105 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04/30/2007 3.625
3.625 R)aitic Em
FILM A2
TERM ENT
09/20105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04/302007 3.625
3.625 011i r
FILM Al
RESALE T
05/20/05 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
FILMApp. Al
4.125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
0512005 JOURNAL MATEO TALES TREASURY NOTE
FILM A2
4.125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
SYMEICIAUSIP
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
MAMMY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-65.000.000 65.162.500.00
78.000.000 78.292.500.00
-30.000.000 29.925.003.00
40.000.000 39.900.000 .00
09/20105 INTEREST MATEO STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04/W. 1.625
27,241,55
05120/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05/1116 A 1 2 5
FILM
REPO Ihr
12,889,92
05/23/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04/30/2007 3.625
3.625 Cla17
FILM Al
RESALE T
48.000.000 48.180.000.00
09/23/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04/30/2007 3.625
3.625 a 7
FILM A2
TERM EEMENT
-78.000.000 78.292.500.00
027 E601.05:09:03 001 '. 878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
INIICtLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
30 ci ))
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
nice
DATE
TMOE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRFTION ST1.10CliCtISIP OTHATTITY Oen ;wow CREDIT AMOUNT
05/23/05 INTEREST malt° STATES TREASURY NOTE 17,681,06
DUE 04/30=" II  l7_ •-3.625
lb
0924/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MEM -48.000.000 48.180.000.00
DUE 04/302007 3.625
RIM A2
3,625)117
TERM EMENT
05/24105 RECEIVED LINiTED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIS 61.000.000 61.305.000 ,00
DUE 04/30/2007 3,625
RIM Al
3,625 1S t
RESALE T
05124105 JOURNAL UtaTED TATES TREASURY NOTE MIS -20.000.009 20.050.000.00
FITM Al
4,125 15
REPO AGREEMENT
06/24105 JOURNAL UNiTED ASURY NOTE 30.000.000 29.925.000.00
FITM A2
4.125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
05/24/05 INTEREST mei STATES TREASURY NOTE 602.25
DUE OM '  1,625
05/24/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 9.800,44
DUE OS/ 4,125
FITM A2
REPO I
0512905 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 647.064 479.000,00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE I 1
FITM A2
TERM MENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NumeER On File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
027 Da0i.05:09:02 001 va7a
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
yniCu.Y OmED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
31 cI>x
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRFRON SYMeCt,CUSIF OVANTITY OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
05/2905 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MD ASSN -7.110,602 3.800.000 .00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
FILM Al
DUE 11AMil i
REPO
05125105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN VIM 6.463.537 4.666.000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
FILM C2
DUE 11.I.
TERM MENT
06/26/05 JOURNAL FEDL ICA WAN MI6 CORPeSt0i09 2.409,100 516.000.00
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
S4300411. 1" 134A2 FILM
TERM MENT
0512905 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTG 0C4IPeS10709 Min 8.190,940 1.729.000,00
SERIES 227 CLASS I0
S4300FILM 31111 462
TERM AAENT
0512905 JOURNAL FEDL !ME LOAN MTG CORPOSI0109 8.672,760 1,887.000,00
SERIES 227 CLASS I0
S.000FILM 30. 462
TERM MENT
092905 JOURNAL FEDL !ME WAN MI6 CORP#S10t09 -19,272.801 3.951.000,00
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
FSITMJ"  WC1 REPO A
092905 JOURNAL FREDOIE MAC CMOSER1ES 2886 .8.743.867
SC-L'0 FUR
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On Fee
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
4.210 19
FILM Al
REPO A
027 060i,05:09:03 001 V878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIDST OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
32 ci
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACRON DESCRSTON SYMEMCUSIP PARTIN DEBIT AMOUNT
092905 JOURNAL FREDDIE MAC CMO,SERIES 2886 8.743.867 594,000,00
SC-1/0 RJR
4,210RIII19
FITM A2
TERM MENT
05.'25/05 JOURNAL FEDL FINE LOAN MIG CORPt/S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 0
6F,000
A2
TERM MENT
05:25,05 JOURNAL FEDL TOME WAN TAM CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 5
FITM A2
TERM MENT
0512905 JOURNAL FEDL HOME WAN MTG OCANIS10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,0003.035
FITM A2
TERM MENT
0512905 JOURNAL FEDL TOME LOAN MTG CORPoSioi 10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,00011.35
FITM A2
TERM MENT
05125/05 JOURNAL FEDL TOME LOAN MI6 OCAPPS10110
SERIES 228 CLASS TO
6,000
FITM  glidaliPsA2 TERM RelrE IMMENT
05125/05 JOURNAL FEDL /CM LOAN MIG CCAP8S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 11.35
FITM 81
REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLAISER On File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
918,287 162.000,00
1.836.575 333.000,00
2.295.719 415.000,00
6.428,013 1,113.000,00
6.887,157 1,190.000,00
.18,365.752 3,000.000 ,00
027 0601.05:09:03 001 Y878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
?imply OMYRO SUBSIOARy
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
=Pm 33
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS
SETTLErADR
DATE
0925/05
TMDE
DATE TRANSACTION
JOURNAL
DESORPTION
UMTEO STATES TREASURY NOTE
ATM Amp A2
4,125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
(continued)
05/25/05 JOURNAL
Frrm 4.125
REPO AGREEMENT
UMTEO STATES TREASURY NOTE
Al
STMECLCvSly MAMMY
20.000.000
own /MUM
20,050,000.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD *11 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
CREDO' AMOUNT
23.000.000 23,143,750.00
05/25/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS
DUE 11.0 0.000
FRM A2
REPO I
919.28
05/25/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DUE 11!  0.000
ATM C2
REPO I  a
5.969.89
0925/05 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN LUG CCAPaS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 13
DUE Ilia 5.000
ATM A2
REPO I
565.88
05.025/05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTO CCAPRS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE flai l  5.000
ATM 62
REPO I
1.422.10
05.025/05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTO CCAPRS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE I los  5.000
ATM 52
REPO I
2,414.31
05/25105 INTEREST FREDDIE MAC CMO/SERIES 2886
SC-90 FUR
DUE Oil. 4.210
ATM A2
REPO I
380.00
027 0601.05:09:C0 001 11878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION STMEIWCUSIP QUANTITY OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
05/25105 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTO CORPaS10110 177,66
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 07jaris 6,000
FITM A2
REPO I
05125105 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CORPI.S10t 10 EMI 426,05
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE lip 6,000
ATM A2
REPO I
06/2906 INTEREST FEDI. NOME LOAN MTG 00APdStOi 10 530,97
SERIES 228 CLASS 13
DUE 07.0 6,000
FITM A2
REPO I
0512905 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CORP#S1OI 10 813,73
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 0711. 6,000
FITM A2
REPO I
0512905 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CORPoS oi IC 978,78
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE Oak. 6.000
FITM A2
REPO I
0512905 INTEREST UMTEO STATES TREASURY NOTE NMI 1.598,43
DUEOSJ 4,125
FITM A2
REPO I
092905 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CmOSERiES 2003-13 12,636.068
S RCR-1,0 FOR
4,910
A2 RIM
A 3
. TERM MENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* W130.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On File
LAST STATEMENT ApT11 29.2005
027 0601.05:09:03 001 Y878
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BUR
STBMZNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
35 c.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCAAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* WI 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER Ai/' ER On File
LAST STATEMENT *11 29.2005
ROWAN' TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRITTON SYMBOL,OVSIP OV$NTIW DEBIT AMOUNT cnEor AMOUNT
05,26/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMG/SERIES 2003.13 -6.318.034
S RCRAŽO FLTR
4.910Aliiiiir
FITM Al
REPO
05/26105 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003.13
S RCR-I10 FLTR
4.910 1133
FITM Al
REPO A
05127/05 DELIVERED UNTED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04t302007 3.625
3.625. 117
FITM A2
TERM e EMENT
05/27105 JOURNAL LINiTED STATES TREASURY NOTE
FITM Hip A2
4.125 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
05127105 JOURNAL TINTED YATES TREASURY NOTE
FITM Al
0.125 .15
REPO AGREEMENT
-6.318.034 525.000.00
-61.000.000 61.305.000.00
23.000.000 23.143.750.00
-38.000.000 38.095.000.00
05.27105 INTEREST MATEO STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 04/111 .625
10,898.67
0527'05 INTEREST UNIDO STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05ini. A€.125 21
FITM
REPO Ihr
3.613.00
027 0600S:09:CO 001 V878
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wisCtLY OW,E0 SUEISIOally
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
=Pm 36
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE 1TIANSACRON DESCRIMON
05/31705 RECEIVED MATEO STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 05131/2007 3.500
3.500 lik•
FIRM Al
RESALE
STMEICISCUSIP OUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT
54.000.000 54000000 .00
I STean SPCmit' GoI
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT Amon April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER PANDER On File
'Ayr STATEMENT *11 29.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
TOTAL $857.808.788.09 $593,316.16207
MISCELLANEOUS
DATE
MODAY TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
OS02)05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 153.010.50
05/03/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY A/C 79.838.50
05/04105 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 107.505.00
OS06+05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC MI. 158.04/1.41
05/0945 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 70660.50
05/1045 JOURNAL FR OMER NC 109.576.00
OS/12)05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 173.287.00
05/12105 JOURNAL FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTO 43.750.00
SER.05/05
5.000 DUE 05101/35
MBS NET 05112/05
05/12105 JOURNAL FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTO 50000.00
SER.05/05
5.500 DUE 05101/35
MBS NET 05112/05
05/16105 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 106.290.00
05/I 845 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 21.651.00
0919)05 JOURNAL TO GAM NC 611.641$0
027 0601,06:09:02 001 YSTS
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OM.E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD WI 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS (continued)
DATE
maw TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION DEBT AMOUNT
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AVUSER ON File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
CTECIT AMOUNT
05120+05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 156.062.50
05/23/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 127.115.50
05/24105 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 154.789.50
05/2905 JOURNAL APR 05 SPEC CLEARING FEES 1.600,00
05/2905 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 274.164.00
05/2645 JOURNAL CORRECT PRIOR ENTRY 5125 300.00
APR OS SPEC CLEAR FEES
05/26.105 JOURNAL TO CMDY AC 56.300.00
0527105 JOURNAL FR CMDY AC 95.850.00
05131:05 JOURNAL FR CMDY AC 960.00
TOTAL S.1.616254.91 $936.131.00
Trades Executed Pending Settlement
SETRE1AENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION STME/OUCUSP CAJANMY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT GRECO AMOUNT
0602105 05/27105 BOUGHT ALTERNATIVE LOAN TRUST 37.701.010 .00 2.1562 827.671.71
SERIES 2000-300B CLASS I -A-S
02.080%
57050000 BS
027 0601.05:09:03 001 YB78
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
38 0
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
07/14105 05/06/05 SOLD
07/14105 05/19/05 BOUGHT
07/14105 0523/15 BOUGHT
07/I4/05 05/06105 SOLD
07/I4/05 05/26705 SOLD
TOTAL
DESCRPTION
FNMA 30YR TBA OTD
SETT. 07105
01/411005.000%
57440000 BS
FNMA-30TR(FNMA)GID
SETT.07/06
layillia05.500%
57050000 BS
FNMA-30TR(FNMA)GID
SETT.07/06
57100000 BS
FNMA 300LiFNMAIGID
SETT,0706
57450000 BS
FNMA 30YRiFNMAIGTD
SETT,07 06
F 05.500%
57180000 BS
The chore Peons cti nol (ppm in airy cling saban o1 Iho staIerneet
End of Statement
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD April 30.2005
THROUGH May 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAIIIIER On File
LAST STATEMENT April 29.2005
SWEID..CUSI> OJANTIP PRCE DEPT AMOUNT MCP AMOUNT
-30.000.000 .00 98.5195 29.555.859 .38
30.000.000.00 100.867l 30.260.156.25
30.000.000.00 101 30.300.000.00
-30.000.000.00 100.5156 30.154.687 .50
-60.000.000 ,00 100.9531 60.571.875 .00
$61.387.827.96 ST 20.282.421.88
027 060105:09:03 001 T178
CLEARED 1HRCO3H ITS
WHOLLY 01MNIED SUBSIDIARY
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
S mear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSITE wymr.bearstearns.com
What's In This Statement
Financial Summary 3
Your Portfolio Holdings  4
Transaction Detail  7
Trades Not Yet Settled  36
Your Portfolio at a Glance
TOTAL VAWE OF SECURITIES THIS PERIOD 2.900.677
LONG ACCRUED INTEREST 49.699
NET CREDIT BALANCE 180,992
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD S3,131,368
NET EOINTY LAST STATEMENT 3.471,276
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT -339,907
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on file for your account.
IIIIIIIIII1111111 I I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
CIO JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Market Value of Your Portfolio
Cash a Equvalent -IP $180.992
tr $77.668
Fixed
Income  411677
.............. $1335.615
IN Current market vane
gig Last statements market value
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD April 1. 2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT MVO 31.2005
St no. S'ennirY r; awnabomi Reposes My It Is rid vendedacne. dee:wore
Tres statecnore should be Maned ex your records. Soo renews.* tot topodare nrconatco
027 043005:11:24 001 1877
GEARED IHROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMAIED $1.1190MAv
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 oi 37
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
027 04 ,3005:11:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YilICtLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
3 o
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PERIOD
Income Summary PERIOD YEAS TO DATE
Opening Balance $77.667.54 U.S. Govt. Bond Int. 185.544.78 2.696.00t23
Govt. Agency Int. 552.438.36 2.574.774.36
Securities Sold 1,359,111,947.26 Corp. Bond Int. 113.515.89 488,52726
Dividends Interest 852.373.23 Credit Balance Int. 874.20 2,83420
Miscellaneous 2,204,993.35 Reverse Repurchase Int. 167.202.34 993,733.64
Amount Credited 81,362,169,313.84 Total $1 019 575.57 $6 755 871.39
Securities Bought -1,358,335,855.07 Bond Purchase Int. -925.716.62 -4.426,001.99
Dividends/Interest Charged -925.716.62 Repurchase lnt. Exp. -242.166.81 -642,85923
Miscellaneous -2,804.417.29
Amount Debited $-1.362.065.988.98
Portfolio Composition Net Cash Activity 103,324.86
CashtCash Equivalent 180,992
ClosingBalance $180,992.40 Fixed Income 2.900,677
Total $3,081,669
Cash Balance Summary
OM. NG CLOSING
Margin 77.667.54 180,992.40
Net Cash Balance $77,667.54 $180,992.40
027 04.3005:11:24 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* 1.2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WESER On File
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash & Equivalent-,
5%
— Fixed Income
95%
Umeeled Graces emote OW beam", *eke Veil
male valve Tea oloteee revenue, 0 Owed
Icon to enaLte market rate pi >ye peen"
CLEARED THRouGH 115
ieniCu.Y OmED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
4 cI '3?
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
DESCPrION
CASH BALANCE
S.-AiSCLOSIP
IAAPJ<ET ESTIMATED CuRRENT
OurdaiTy pi:DcE vALuE !Mu& MCCUE VELD is.)
180.992
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS $180.992
FIXED INCOME
Government & Agency Obligations
ACCT
DESCRPRON SWA3OLCUSP TYPE
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* 1. 2005
THROUGH WI 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST sTATELIENT Mardi 31.2005
ACCRUED ESTRUM CURRAN
PRICE MARKET VALLE MEREST ANNUAL INCOME YEID
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DATED DATE 04/30/03
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 01/25/2033 3.980%
FACTOR .53416049
12,983,710 8,0124 1,040.305 5.741 516,752 49.6731
FEN. HOME LOAN NIG CORP#STCH TO MRGN 9.419,607 19.7500 1.860.372 43.958 565.176 30.3797
SERIES 228 CLASSIC
DATED DATE 02/01A35
ROOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 02/01/2035 6.000%
FACTOR .941%062
Total Government& Agency Obligations $2.900.677 $49.699 $1.081.928
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 52.900.677 $49.699 $1.081.928
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLOINGSACCRUED INTEREST $49.699
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLOINGSESTIMATED ANNUAL INCOME $1.081.928
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS $3.081.669
027 04,3005:11:24 001 Y877
CLEARED IHRCUGH ITS
WHOLLY ODYED SOMMER,
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.outstanding as of date of statement
PLROOSS REPURCHASE PROM PURCHASE PRICE; ACCRUED REPO CAPMMY
START DATE DATE RATE PRINCPAL MEREST' (FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTOR
I it' Go'
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD *II 1.2005
THROUGH Apt1 29.2005
=DEMIST NUMBER
TAXPAYER PAAOER On File
LAST STATEMENT Minh 31.2005
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 02/07105 OPEN 0.000 -50.000,000 SEES 2003-13 CLASS 4.9800 oa25133
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 04/04/05 05/04/05 3.080 473,000 -1.133 -910.000 SEES 346 CLASS PO 11101133
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 04/11105 05/11/05 3.130 -10.583.000 -19.322 -30.000.000 SEES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 04/11105 05/11/05 3.130 -4.553.000 -8.313 a090.000 SEEMS 346 CLASS PO 11101/33
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 04/11/05 05/11/05 3.130 -1.143.000 -2.086 -5.000,000 SEES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 04/13105 05/13/05 3.150 -556.000 -924 -2.500,000 SEES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 04/15105 05/16/05 3.180 -11.174.000 -16.779 -30.959.779 SEES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIP
(REPO) 04/15/05 05/16/05 3.180 -4.211.000 -6.323 -20.000.000 SEES 353 CLASS 10 5.0000 07/01/34
YOU SOLD FREDOIEMAC STRIP
(REPO) 04/15/05 05/16/05 3.180 -3.665.000 -5.503 -20.000.000 SEES 228 CLASS 10 6.0000 02/01/35
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIPS
(REPO) 04/20/05 05/16/05 3.200 -14.660.000 -15,637 -23.000.000 SEES 352 CLASS PO 07/01/34
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 04/22105 05/16/05 3.230 -1.837.000 -1.648 -8,500,000 SEES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
027 04/30.01:11:24 001 4/77
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
6 o
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.inc.outstanding as of date of statement (continued)
PURCHASE/ REPURCHASE PRICING PURCHASE HIVE£ ACCRUED REPO WINTRY
START DATE DATE RATE PAINCTPAL MEREST' (FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTION
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 ARM 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER PMUSER CR Fite
LAST STATEMENT M&Ch 31.2005
YOU SOLD FREOCHEMAC STRIP
(REPO) 04/22/05 05/16105 3.230 -528,000 -473 -3.000,000 SERIES 228 CLASS 10 6,0000 02/01/36
YOU PROVIDED FREDDIEMAC STRIP
(MARGIN) 04/22,05 OPEN 0,000 -7.000.000 SERIES 228 CLASS 10 6,0000 02/01/36
YOU PROVIDED GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 04/25105 OPEN 0,000 -26.400.000 SERIES 2004-5 CLASS P 3,9600 02/20/33
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 04,25/05 05711105 5,130 -536.000 -534 -2.500.000 SERIES 227 CLASSIC sp000 12/01/34
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(MARGIN) 04,25105 OPEN 0.000 -1,500,000 SERIES 227 CLASSIC 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU SOLD USTR 4,0000 02/15/15
(REPO' 04:29;05 OPEN 2.750 -59.400.000 -13.612 -60.000.000
TOTAL REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS $0 $0
TOTAL REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS S-113.319.000 $42,287
'As ct skyorrom dr.*
027 01,30'05:11:24 001 YS77
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wisCtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIOally
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTKIN
04/01105 03/31/05 BOUGHT
04101105 03/31105 SOLD
04/01/05 03/31105 SOLD
04/07/05 PRINCIPAL
04108/05 04/07105 BOUGHT
04/13/05 03/1645 BOUGHT
04/13105 03/14105 BOUGHT
DESORPTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
1.0.3.000% M 30
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0901002 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.750% MS 31
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0901006 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.750% MS 31
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G0901006 BI
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORN/5101M
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000 DUE 02101/35
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 04-15-05
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 02/15/2015 04.000% FA 15
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 4.412 % M MATURITY
GVER REF # G0970029 A7
AS OF 04/07105
FNMA 30111 OTO
SETT. 04/05
Wit. 5.10:00 %7 0 BS
NMA 30 fR GTD
SETT. 0405
05.000%
57280000 BS
I it' GoI
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* *II 1.2005
THROUGH WI 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMMER Cfl File
LAST STATEMENT MVO 31,2005
STMEIOLCUMP CIVANTRY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT GRECO' AMOUNT
50,000,000
ACM INT.
98.73047 49,365,234.38
377.071.82
MIS -30.000.000 99.91406 29.974,21B .75
ACCR, INT. 3.073.77
-50.000.000 99.91406 49.957.031 .25
ACCR, INT. 5.122.95
MIN -335.609
El= 40.000.000 96.73438 38,693,750.00
ACCR. 229,834.25
MIMI 5.000.000 97.93359 4.896.679.69
10.000.000 97.71094 9.771.093.75
021 04.3C•OS:l 1:24 ODI vs>,
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WHOLLY omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
8 ci
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/DTI
04/1395 03/08(05 CANCEL SELL
04/1345 0310945 CANCEL SELL
04/13:05 03115(05 BOUGHT
04/13(05 03/14105 CANCEL SELL
04/13/05 03/18/05 CANCEL SELL
04/13(05 03/18(05 CANCEL SELL
OESCRPTION
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 04/05
05.000 +:
AS OF 03.08(06
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 0495
AS OF 03/09(05
TO CA. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT, 04/05
1101 505.000%
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT 04/05
05.000%
AS OF 03/14(05
TO CA. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 04(05
illilik s05.000%
AS OF 03(18(05
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 04/05
05.000
AS OF 03/18(05
TO CA. PREVIOUS SELL
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* *II 1.2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMMER Cn Flle
LAST STATEMENT Ukiah 31.2005
STUE/OLCUSP OVANTITY ma DEBIT AMOUNT CFEDI A/lOcter
BS
10.000.000 98.48875 9.846.875.00
NMI 15.000.000 97.92188 14.688.281.25
BS
20.000.000 97.57813 19.515.625.00
BS
20.000.000 97.65625 19.531.250.00
BS
20.000.000 97.91016 19.582.031.25
BS
20.000.000 97.92188 19.584.375.00
BS
027 04300S:11:24 001 .87?
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
WHOLLY omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
9 ci P:•
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
04/13/05 03/09105 CANCEL SELL
04/13/05 03/0845 CANCEL SELL
04/13105 03/21105 BOUGHT
04/13/05 03130:05 BOUGHT
04/13/05 03/16/05 CANCEL BUY
04/13105 03/14105 CANCEL BUY
DESORPTION
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT. 04/05
05.000i
AS OF 03,09 OS
TO CAL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR OM
SETT, 04'05
06.000
AS OF 03/138t05
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT, 04/05
1011111.05.000%
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT 04/05
05.000%
FNMA 30YR Om
SETT, 04/06
05.000%
AS OF 03l6:05
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA 301R GTO
SETT. 04105
101.1.05.000%
57280000 BS
AS OF 0114'05
TO CXL PREVIOUS MN
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* APII 1.2005
THROUGH &XII 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMMER Cn File
LAST STATEMENT Ukiah 31.2005
10.100..CuSP OVANMY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CFEDI A/lOcter
20.000.000 97.99219 19.598.437.50
BS
20.000.000 98.53125 19.706.250.00
BS
40.000.000 97.75000 39.100.000.00
BS
50.000.000 97.39844 48.699.218.75
BS
-5.000.000 97.93359 4.896.679.69
BS
-10.000.000 97.71094 9.771.093.75
027 04300S:11:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROWN ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
10 II?
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
04/13/05 03/08/05 SOLD
04/13/05 03/0945 SOLD
04113/05 03/15+05 CANCEL BUY
04/13+05 03/14105 SOLD
04/13+05 03/18+05 SOLD
04/13+05 03/18+05 SOLD
04/13+05 03/09/05 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT, 04/05
05.033%
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 0405
, 05.000%
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT, 04/05
111.1.5.000%
AS OF 03/1545
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA 30YR COD
SETT, 04/05
00/0005.000%
FNMA 30YR 01D
ETT, 04 ,05
05.000%
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 04;05
FNMA 30YR WO
S . 04;05
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD ADM 1.2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
SIMEID:CuSP 0,AWNT,
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLM3ER
LAST STATEMENT
PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT
OR File
MVO 31.2005
CREDO AMOUNT
BS
40,000.003 98.46875 9.846.875.00
11111 -15.000.000 97.92188 14.688.281 .25
BS
11111 -20.000.000 97.57813 19.515.625 .00
BS
-20,000.000 97.65625 19.531.250 .00
BS
-20.000.000 97.91016 19.582.031 .25
BS
-20.000.000 97.92188 19.584,375 .00
BS
NMI -20.000.000 97.99219 19.598.437 .50
05.000%
57320000 BS
027 04300S:11:24 001 .87?
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY CIMS*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
04/13105 03/08/05 SOLD
04/13105 03/21105 CANCEL BUY
04/13105 03,030105 CANCEL BUY
04113105 03/14105 BOUGHT
04/13105 03/1645 BOUGHT
04/13105 03/08/05 CANCEL SELL
OESCRPTION
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 04/05
05.000%
7670000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 04/05
1.1005.000%
57140000 BS
AS OF 03/21/05
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 04/05
05.000%
7320000 BS
AS OF 03/30/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS BIN
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT 04/05
05.500%
57290000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT, 04/05
7240000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT 04/05
05.500%
8150000 BS
AS OF 03.08105
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
I
FINANCAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* * 11 1. 2005
THROUGH Apt1 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER PAINTER On File
LAST STATEMENT MVO 31.2005
SYMEIOLCUS, oawrin PRCE DEBIT AMOUNT CREWE MOINE
-20.000.000 98.53125 19106,250 .00
-40.000.000 97.75000 39.100000 .00
-50.000.000 97.39844 48.699.218 .75
5.000.000 100.13281 6.006.640.63
5.000.000 100.26563 5.013.281.25
10.000.000 100.70703 10.070.703.13
021 04.3C•Otr:11:24 ODI Y87/
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y onneo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
12 ci ((
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACI109
04/13/05 03/09105 CANCEL SELL
04/13/05 03109.'05 CANCEL SELL
04/I 3.85 03/29105 BOUGHT
04113.85 03(30(05 BOUGHT
04/13/05 0311485 CANCEL BUY
04/13(05 03/16105 CANCEL BUY
OESCRIPTION
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT, 04/05
AS OF 03(09(05
TO CAL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT, 04105
05,500
AS OF 03409(05
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT, 0405
illiga0105.503t.
As OF 032905
FNMA 30YR GT D
SE II , 04.05
1111.05.503%
FNMA 30YR 010
ETT, 0405
05.500%
AS OF 03/14/05
TO CXL PREVIOUS BIN
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT, 04/05
1.01105.503 ,4
57240000 BS
AS OF ca mos
TO Ca PREVIOUS BIN
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* )9310 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
SIN00...CLISP OHNTITY PRICE
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER NASSER
LAST STATEMENT
DEBIT AMOUNT
Cn File
Merck 31.2005
CFEOIA/hOcter
15.000.000 100.28125 15.042.187.50
BS
20.000.000 100.34766 20.069.531,25
BS
20,000.000 101.48438 20.296.875.00
BS
35.000.000 99.81250 34.934.375.00
BS
-5.000.000 100.13281 5.006.640.63
BS
Siff -5,000.000 100.26563 5.013.281.25
027 04300S:11:24 001 .87?
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
Yi/IDALY OBS*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
04/13105 03/08/05 SOLD
04/13105 03/09/05 SOLD
04113+05 03/09.05 SOLD
04113105 03/29.'05 CANCEL BUY
04/13:05 03:30:05 CANCEL BUY
04/13+05 03/29.'05 CANCEL SELL
0E5CnenON
FNMA 30Th GTO
sSEIT. 04/05 05.500%
8150000 BS
FNMA 30Th 010
SETT, 04/05
05.50054
7390000 BS
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT, 04/05
7280000 BS
FNMA 30YR OTO
7130000 BS
AS OF 0129. 105
TO C)3. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT, 04/05
05.500%
7390000 BS
AS OF 0340.105
TO CIO- PREVIOUS BIN
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)01D
SETT 04'05
06.000%
57090000 BS
AS OF 03.29 05
TOGO. PREVICUS SELL
1. SIean $PCmitkf EAR
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Apt1 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
SYMBOL:CUSP CLANTITe PRCE
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER PAINTER
LAST STATEMENT
DEBIT AMOUNT
On File
MVO 31.2005
clear SCUM
-10.000.000 100.70703 10.070.703 .13
-15.000.000 100.28125 15.042,187 .50
-20.000.000 100.34766 20.069.531 .25
-20.000.000 101.48438 20.296.875 .00
Illiff -35.000.000 99.81250 34.934.375 .00
SIM 20.000.000 101.71875 20.343.750.00
021 04.3C•OtKI 1:24 ODI vs>,
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? 011X.E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
04713/05 03/30/05 CANCEL SELL
04/I 345 04/06/05 BOUGHT
04/13/05 04/07105 BOUGHT
04/I 3/05 03/2945 SOLD
04/13/05 03/30:05 SOLD
04/13/05 04/06.05 CANCEL BUY
OESCRPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
SETT.04105
06.009,
AS OF 03,30,05
TO CAL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SEIT.04.05
01.111 506.000,
FNMA-30YR(FNMAXDO
SETT.04/05
06.000%
FNMA-30YR(ENMA)GID
SETT.04105
FNMA-30)41(FNMA)G1D
SETT.04/05
06.000%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
SETT.04/05
06.000%
AS OF 040685
0 CxL PREVIOUS BUY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD April 1. 2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLP9ER OfiFile
LAST STATEMENT Muth 31,2005
XIMEICLCUSP CSAV4MY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CRUM AAIDUNr
20.000,000 101,92188 20,384.375,00
BS
20.000.000 102.45313 20.490.625.00
BS
20.000.000 102.64063 20.528.125.00
BS
-20,000.003 101.71875 20.343,750,00
BS
as
-20.000.000 101.92188 20.384.375,00
-20.000.000 102,45313 20.490.625,00
BS
027 04900511:24 001 VS77
CLEARED THROWN ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
15 0 )?
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION SYMEICL.00SP CVANTITY PRia DEIST AMOUNT CREW AMOUNT
04/13/05 04/07105 CANCEL BUY FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETL04105
06.000% -20.0043.000 102.64063 20,528,125.00
57250000 BS
AS OF 04/07/05
TO CAL PREVIOUS BUY
04/13/05 04/12)05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 20.000.000 100.10156 20,020,312.50
03.750% MS 31 ACCR, MT. 26,639.34
MATURITY
GVER REP N G1021009 Al
04/18/05 0312945 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR OTO 20.000.000 101.48438 20.296.875.00
SETT, 04/05
05.500%
57130000 BS
04/18/05 0329)05 CANCEL BUY FNMA 30YR OTD
siosSEIT. 04/05 05.500%
7130000 BS
Milli -20,000.000 101,48438 20.296.875 MO
AS OF 03)2945
TO C)1. PREVIOUS BUY
04/18/05 03115+05 CANCEL SELL FNMA-15YR(FNMA- %GTO 20.000.000 97.74219 19.548.437.50
SETT,04105
7250000 BS
AS OF 03/15/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
04/18/05 03/14105 BOUGHT FNMA- I 5Y11(FNMA-I5)GTD 20.000.000 97.77344 19.554.687.50
SETT.0406
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* *II 1.2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER HUNTER On File
LAST STATEMENT MVO 31.2005
0.01004.500 ,4
57040000 BS
027 04300S:11:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIMI? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SEMWENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
04/18105 03/09105 CANCEL SELL
04/18/05 03/08105 BOUGHT
04/18+05 03115+05 SOLD
04/18+05 03114+05 CANCEL BUY
04/18+05 03/09/05 SOLD
04/18+05 03/08105 CANCEL BUY
OESCRIPTION
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)1TD
SETT,04105
01.01 04,500%
AS OF 03,09,05
TO C/3. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-15YRIENMA. 151GT0
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTO
SETT,04+05
04,500%
FNMA- I SYNFNMA. 151GT0
SETT,04105
AS OF 03/14+05
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-15YR(FNMA. StOTO
SETT,04105
' 7590000
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTO
SETT 04105
04500%
7680000 BS
AS OF 03/08105
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* April 1.2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT AMMO 31.2005
snieoucuse OUNERTE PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDI A/lOcter
20,000,000 97,96313 19.590.625,00
BS
20.000.000 98,54688 19.709.375,00
BS
-20.000.000 97,74219 19.548.437 ,50
BS
-20,000.000 97,77344 19.554.687 ,50
BS
-20.000.000 97,95313 19.590.625 ,00
BS
-20.000.000 98,54688 19.709.375 ,00
027 04300S:11:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
17 a
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSICTON
04/18+05 03/29,05 BOUGHT
04/18/05 034045 BOUGHT
04/18105 04/06105 CANCEL SELL
04/18105 04/07105 CANCEL SELL
04/18/05 0128 ,05 CANCEL BUY
04/18/05 03/30105 CANCEL BUY
DESCRIPTION
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)0T0
05.500%7130000 BS
AS OF 03+29/05
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTO
SETT.04105
1011.5 05.5"7110000 BS
FNMA-ISYR(NMA-15)GTO
05.50096
7540000 BS
AS OF 04/06105
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-15YR(FNMA- I SGTO
SETT:34105
05,500%
57290000 BS
AS OF 04/07+05
TO CA. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA- SYNFNItIA- StGTO
05.500%
7130000 BS
AS OF 03+29105
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-1501(FNMA-15}0T0
SETT:34105
illare 05.500%
57110000 ES
AS OF 0380105
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* April 1. 2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAMER Cn Flle
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
SYMEIO.CuSP CANNTITV PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CFEOIA/lOcter
Asir
20.000,000
20.000.000
101.48438
101,64063
20.296.875.00
20.328.125 .00
lilt 20.000.000 102.06250 20.412.500.00
20.000.000 102.17188 20.434.375.00
-20.000.000 101.48438 20.298,875 ,00
-20,000.003 101.64063 20,328,125.00
027 04300S:11:24 001 '.87?
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
18 ci
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE
04/1&05 04/06105
04/18s35 04/07105
04/18/05 04/15/05
04/19/05 04/18+05
04/20105 04/1845
0422/05 04/21105
04/2905
TRANSACTION
SOW
SOW
DESCRIPTION STMEIELCuSP MANI Ir.'
FNMA-151Ft(FNMA-15)0TD
maisSEIT.04105 05.500%
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTO
SETL04/05
BS
-20.000.003
-20.000.000
.1005.500%
57290000 BS
BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE
DUE 02/15/2015 04.000% FA 15
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
ericE
102.06250
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMER Cfl File
LAST STATEMENT MVO 31.2005
DEW AMOUNT MCAT AMOUNT
20.412.500 .00
102.17188 20.434.375 ,00
5.000.000
ACCR,
97.71876
VIEW 4.286 % TO MATURITY
GYER REF # G1053517 A3 WWEB
SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -15.000.000 98.05469
04.000% FA 15
MATURITY
GYER REF # G1081006 Al
ACCR, INT,
BOUGHT FEDERAL NATIONAL WO ASSN 20.311.170 78.68750
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
00.001%
57040000 BS
SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -T0,000.000 97.62600
04.000% FA 15
. . 0 MATURITY
ACCR,
GYER REF # G1111026 Al
PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PRIN RID 03-05 ND 04-25-05
REPO P S I 0.0000
4.885.937,50
34.260.14
14.708.203.13
104.419.88
15.982.352.30
9.762.500.00
72.928.18
405,707.10
027 0430,0S:11:24 001 "877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WNW.? OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
19 o
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTOR DESCRPTION SIMEIO:CLISP OJANNTe PFPCE
STATEMENT PERIOD
THROUGH
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AILIMER
LAST STATEMENT
DEBIT AMOUNT
*II 1.2005
*11 29.2005
CR Fite
Much 31.2005
CREDIT MnOvio
04/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 418,686.74
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
WE 01/01/33
STRIP
F'RIN RID 03-05 PAD 04-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
04,25'05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -342.955
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
4.150 DUE 01/25/33
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 04-25-05
04,25105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 16.920.27
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01/33
PRIN RID 03-06 ND 04-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
04,25105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 38.860.83
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01/33
PAIN RID 03-05 PAD 04-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
04/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 130.15,5.90
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01/33
PAIN RID 03-05 ND 04-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
04,2805 04/27/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY N3TE VIM 10,000.000 100,28125 10,028,125.00
DUE 0131/2007 03.750% MS 31 ACC/, INT. 28,688.52 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 3.596 % TO MATURITY
OVER REF # G1173441 A3 WWEB
04,2905 04/2845 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10,000.000 98.78125 9,878,126 .00
04.000% FA IS ACC/, INT. 80,662.98
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G1181014 Al
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
027 0430CS:11:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
viHOLY OW ,E0 SUOSIOATiv
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
04/29105
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/DTI
04/28/05 BOUGHT
OESORPTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.750% MS 31
MATURITY
GVER REF # GI 181005 Al
SY1A301XLISP GUMMY PRICE
50,000,000 100.30078
ACCR. M.
I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMER On File
LAST STATEMENT MVO 31,2005
DEBIT AMOUNT
50.150.390 .63
148.585.57
CREDO MOM
TOTAL $416.1102,404.18 5722.470.28920
INTEREST
DATE DESCRIPTION STAIDOUCUSIP OUPATITY RATE o4 CENT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
04101105 AVG SAL 528.740 RT 1.920 874.20
021 OFFICE INTEREST 0305
04/154)5 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP/410109 USE 5.0000 34.736.63
SEEMS 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 03.05 ND 04-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
04/1905 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG 00AP/410109 5.0000 46.996.61
SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 03.05 ND 04-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
04/1905 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP/S10110 6.0000 48.776.08
SERES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2035 6.000
INT RID 03-05 PA) 04-15-05
REPO P &I 6.0000
04/18'05 FEDL HOME LOAN MTG OCAP#S Ot 10 6,0000 48.776.08
SERES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2036 6.000
INT RID 03-05 PA) 04-15-05
REPO P S I 6.0000
02/ 043005:11:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y omen SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
21 0 'J.(
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* *11 I. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AVSMER Oil File
LAST STATEMENT MATO 31.2005
DATE DESCRIPTION STMSELCUSIP WARM' RATE IY4 DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
04/15/05 FEDL HOME LOAN WIG OORPPS10i 10 6.0000 48.776.08
SERES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2035 6.000
INT RID 03-05 PAZ( 04-15-05
REPO P &I 6.0000
04/15/05 FEDL HOME LOAN WIG CORPPS10i 10 INN 6.0000 48.776.08
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 02/01/2035 6.000
INTEREST PAYMENT 04-15.05
04/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN NMI 4.1000 14.691.67
SEEMS 2004-5 CUSS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4.100
INT RID 03-05 PM 04-20-05
REPO P SI 4.1000
04/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN NMI 4.1000 60.133.33
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4.100
INT RID 03-05 PA) 04-20-05
REPO P I 4.1000
04/20(05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN NMI 4.1000 75.508.33
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4.100
INT RID 03-05 ND 04-20-05
REPO P I 4.1000
04/25/05 FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003.13 5.1500 113.515.89
S RCA-60 RTR
DUE 03/25/2033 5.150
INT RID 03-05 PM 04-25-05
REPO P SI 5.1500
04/25/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MIS 4.1500 46 088.05
SERES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DUE 01/25/2033 4.150
INTEREST PAYMENT 04-25.05
027 043005:n:24 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
22 c,
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
DATE DESORPTION
04125105 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5.000
INI ND 03-05 P/D 04-2S-0S
REPO P 8I 5.0000
TOTAL 4866,824.45
ST/ABOLOUS,P QUANTITY RATE Ice!
5.0000
DENT AMOUNT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO ADM 1.2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAUMER Ofl File
LAST STATEMENT MATO 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
79.179.42
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYMBOLCUSiP 0.:NYNT, DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
04/01105
04ADVOS
04/01105
04,0405
04:04/05
DELIVERED
PECENED
INTEREST
JOURNAL
JOURNAL
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3,000
ATM 310Ir2
TERM EEMENT
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 03/31:2037 3.750
3 750 7
FITM
RESALE
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/ 1000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
RIM A2
DUE 11A.
TERM MENT
FEDERAL NATIONAL 1,11G ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
MIMI
-50,000.000
80,000.000
677.782
-677.782
80.000.000.00
49.875.000.00
37.752,60
473,000.00
ATM Al
REPO A
027 04300 Si 1:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
23 )7
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPT1ON
0410846 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
ATM A2
TERM MENT
04/08/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS
DUE 11Aiii r
FILM Al
REPO
0403/06 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL 1,116 ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 1:11.
RIM Al
REPO
0410&06 JOURNAL UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE
FILM A2
4.000 , 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
04108/05 JOURNAL MATEO TREASURY NOTE
F1TM Al
4.000 16
REPO  AGREEMENT
STMOWCUSIP
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* April 1.2005
THROUGH WI 29.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEEDER On Rile
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
OUNCITif OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
1.517,805
.1.089.333
.428A71 297,000.00
30.000.000 28.800.000.00
-70.000.000 67,660,000.00
04108/05 INTEREST IMMO STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE OAK. 4.000
RI nM
REPO I
22,200,00
04/11105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIOALAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
FILM imp Al
REPO A
-15,359.406 10.583.000.00
027 04,30,05:11:24 ROI Y877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
%MELLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
24 c?
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TIUNSACTION DESCRPRON
04/11/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL NM ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM A2
REPO
04/11/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM mop A3
REPO A
04/11+05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL WO ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01133
STRIP
ATM  A2
TERM MENT
SYME/C1JCUSIP WARM' Calf AMOUNT
15.359.406 10,583,000 .00
FINANCAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
-15,359.406 10.583.000 00
15,359.406 11.902.000.00
04/11+05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
ATM A2
TERM MENT
04/11+05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
ATM A2
TERM MENT
1.089,333
428.471 297.000.00
04111/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL WC ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
ATM A2
TERM MENT
04/11105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL 1110 ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
ATM Al
REPO A
5.083,557 3,608.000 .00
-6.601.362 4,553.000 .00
027 04300S:l 1:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
25 )./
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION
04/11105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.100 • .
FITM Al
REPO A
04/11105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MM ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.100
FITM
TERM MENT
0411:05 JOURNAL FEDL /OA WAN MIGOORPoSt0i09
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FITM ITM 411." 134A2
TERM ForA IMMENT
04/11105 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MIG OCAP4S10709
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000 WI
FITM Al
REPO A
04/11105 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CORPoS 101 Oe
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000 WM
FITM Al
REPO A
04,11,05 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MI6 °CAPPS tOt 10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000
FITM AI
REPO A
04 11 05 JOURNAL FEDL ACME LOAN MI6 00APaS10t10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.00030 . 5
FITM A2
TERM MENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO AP.11 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On FIN
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
SYMODUCUSIP MANTON, 0193IT AMOUNT CREDIT Amour
-22,100.003 2,142,000.00
ISM 22.100.000 2.601.000.00
11.163.178
-6.309.622
.4.853.556 1.143.000.00
.9.419.606 1,955,003.00
ISM 9.419,606 2,018.000.00
027 0430,0S:11:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
26 IJi
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACDON DESCRPRON SYMEMICUSIP GUMMY 01931T AMOUNT
04/11/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 83.208.20
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 01  0.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
04/11105 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 1 Jill 0.000
ATM AZ
REPO I
04711/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS
DUE 11  0.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
04711/05 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/101. 4.100
FITM AZ
REPO I
04/11/05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG 024iPt/StOt 10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE la* 6.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
04/13/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPOS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000
FITM
TERM MENT
04/13/05 JOURNAL FEDL 104E LOAN MTO CORPHS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000 1034
FITM Al
REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD April 1. 2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER ON PIM
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
77.22
8.474.79
18.183.88
3.206.38
6.309,622
-3,882.844
027 04300S:11:24 001 .87?
CLEARED 1.4ROuGH ITS
viiiCti.v OW,*0 SUCISIOally
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
=Pm 27
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON
04/13105 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CORP#S 10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSITAIMM Alair Al
REPO
04/13/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 03+31/2007 3.750
3.750 INC
FITM Al
RESALE
04/13+05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 03+31/2007 3.750
3.75011li c
RIM A2
TERM EMENT
04/13/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 03/.1 1.750
04114+05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
FSITMMN AllirA
REPO
04114+05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
FIRM
Diniali3456
TERM PAIMIL IMENT
04 14 05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MICI ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 0731.i. 5.000
FIRM 86
REPO I
STMEIWCUSIP
I,Sean SPCmit' GoI
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Aim' 1.2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On FIk
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
°WRIT, OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-2.426,778 556.000.00
60.000.000 60.300.000,00
-80.000.000 80.000.000.00
66.555,56
-18,763,230 3.500.000 .00
18,763,230 4.429.000 .00
5.628.52
027 04/3/1.05:11:24 001 1,1977
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
OmED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTTON SYMEICIALOSIP CVANTITT DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
04/15105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL WC ASSN -15.850.794 11.174.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STFUP
FITM Cl
REPO
04/15105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 15,850.794 11.248.000 .00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FITM viEtZ
TERM ENT
04/15105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MFG ASSN NNE 18,763.230 3,500.000 .00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
FILM AZ
TERM MENT
04/15105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MFG ASSN .18,763.230 4,211.000 00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
FRM AI
REPO
04/15..05 JOURNAL FEDL !the LOAN MTG Ca:Win10i 10 ININ -9.419.606
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000
EISA Al
REPO
04/15105 JOURNAL FEDL !CAE LOAN MTG OCAPeStOt 10 NNE 9.419,606 100.000,00
SERIES 228 CLASS I0
6,00031035
FILM AZ
TERM AAENT
04/15105 JOURNAL FEDL !the LOAN MTG 0011PoSlOt 10 9.419,606 1.955.000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS I0
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO April 1. 2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
6,0003.035
EISA A2
TERM MENT
027 0430,0S:11:24 001 Y877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
29 )7
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON SYMEMICLISIP QUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT
04/15105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPaS10110 9.419.606 2,013,000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000
FITM 11.2
TERM MENT
04/15105 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MI6 CCAPeSt Ot 10
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000
FITM 81
REPO A
04/I 5)05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MFG ASSN 28.401.20
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 013101. 0.000
FITM BZ
REPO I
041 505 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL I.110 ASSN 296.53
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07110. 5.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
04/15105 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTG OCAPt/StOt 10 135.56
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE 010 6.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
04/15105 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTG OORPOS101 to 679.91
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DUE lit* 6.000
FITM A2
REPO I
04/15105 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MIG CORPS 10710 5.082.82
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO APOI 1. 2005
THROUGH /Vol 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Ale
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
-18.839.11 3.665.000.00
DUE 0 6.000
FITM AZ
REPO I
027 04300S:l 1:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIDIS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
30 CI
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEDLEMEN1 TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACRON DESORPTION Smectocuser OUANTITT men AMOUNT criEcor AMOUNT
04/18/05 JOURNAL MTN) STATES TREASURY NOTE 70.000.000 67,550,000,00
FITM pm A2
4,000 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
04/18105 JOURNAL USTE0 TA TE TREASURY NOTE -75.000.000 74.062.500.00
FITM Al
4,000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
04/18105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 32,949,39
DUE 01111 4,000
FITM A2
REPO I
04/19105 JOURNAL UNITED SURY NOTE -60.000.000 59.100.000.00
FITM Al
4,000 5
REPO AGREEMENT
04/19/05 JOURNAL OWED SURY NOTE 75,000.000 74.062.500.00
FITM A2
4,000 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
04/19105 INTEREST UMTEO STATES TREASURY NOTE 822.92
DUE 02/ 4000
FITM A2
REPO I
04,20.05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN BIM -20,311.170 14.539.000.00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0F,M.0.14
IT001 Al
REPO A
04.20,[05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL 1,116 ASSN SIM 20,311.170 14.539.000.00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0F,M10034
IT001 A2
REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO April 1. 2005
THROUGH WI 29.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEIDER On File
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
027 04300S:11:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
31 c,
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMDET TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON
04/20/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MIG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001 1034
FIRM A3
REPO A
04/22+05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN PUG CORP#S10109
SERIES 227 CLASS D
"00  10 . 4
FIRM 81
REPO A
0422+05 JOURNAL FEDL TOME LOAN hITGOORPOS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSITMXIN  41. 1111134A2
TERM Fon igligMENT
04/22+05 JOURNAL FEDL TOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.0003.035
FIRM A2
TERM AAENT
04/22+05 JOURNAL FEDL TOME LOAN MTG GORPOSIO1I0
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 wows FIRM Al
REPO A
0422+05 JOURNAL FEDL TOME LOAN MIG CORP1S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS D
6FITM.000 AI
REPO A
0422+05 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
ATM j  Al
4,000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
04/22+05 JOURNAL UNITED TALES TREASURY NOTE
FIRM A2
4,000 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT REMO APE11 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER ARARIER On FIk
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
SYMBOL:VAR, °PARITY OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-20.311,170 14.660.000 .00
-8.251.045 1,837.000 .00
NMI 8.251,045 2.032.000.00
NMI 9.419,606
NMI -6.593.724
-2.825.881 528.000.03
MIN -50.000.000 49.062.500.00
NMI 60.000.000 59.100.000 .00
02/ 0430,06:11:24 001 V877
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
2HICELY OME*0 SUBSIOMEn,
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
=Pm 32
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* &N11 1.2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEDIMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTOR DESCRIPSON STLASCLCVSIP cumin?
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On FOS
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
0031T AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
04/22/05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG OCAP#S10109 3,471.33
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE Il  5.000
RIM AZ
REPO I
04/22105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 7.633.75
DUE 021 4.000
ATM n REPO I
04/25105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN SIM 4.300.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
3FITIN F)10. 33A2
TERM MENU
04/25105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN MIK -26.400.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
F3116°  Al
REPO A
04/25105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN MIK 22.100,000 2.142.000.00
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
3FITIN R)1100 33A2
TERM MENT
04,25105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPoS10109 3.882,844
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSITMXIM
TERM MENT
04 25 05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG 00APdS10109 INN -1.456966
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000
F1TM WI REPO A
027 04400S:11:24 001 .871
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YOICALY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
33 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT WADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION svuecajvuslP Cowan DENT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
04/25105 JOURNAL FEOL NOME LOAN MTG OORP#S10109 -2.426,778 536.000.00
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSITMMN AllirAl
REPO
04/26105 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 2.607.29
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02:110 3.960
ATM A2
REPO I
04/2845 RECEIVED UNTIED STATES TREASURY NOTE 50.000.000 50.375.000.00
DUE 03:31/2007 3.750
3,750 Clikt7
RIM Al
RESALE T
04/2845 DELIVERED LIMTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE -60.000.000 60.300.000.00
DUE 03/31/2007 3.750
3,7501101C7 Em
FITM A2
TERM ENT
04/2845 INTEREST IMMO STATES TREASURY NOTE MIN 59 228,00
DUE 03/0 1760
CW29,65 JOURNAL MATEO TATES TREASURY NOTE 50.000.000 49.062.500.00
ATM A2
4.000 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
04/2945 JOURNAL UNITED 1 ASURY NOTE -60.000.000 59.400.000.00
FITM Al
4,000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
04/2945 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -50.000.000 50.375.000 .00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD RPM 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER ON PIM
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
DUE 03/31/2007 3.750
3,75031.07
FITM A2
TERM EEMENT
027 0430,0S:11:24 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTICIT SYMEICASCUSIP OUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
moms
04/29105
INTEREST
INTEREST
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 027 4.000
FITM A2
REPO I
TINTED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE OW. 1.750
19.107.12
3.666.18
TOTAL S-S42.459.166.81 $636.827202.34
MISCELLANEOUS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* )14ATI1 1. 2005
THROUGH *11 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT March 31.2005
DATE
MD DAY TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION DEPT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
04//01/05 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC 301.525.00
04/07105 JOURNAL TO CMDY NC MIS 288.806.75
04106/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 61.362.50
04/11105 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 118.787.50
04/12/05 JOURNAL FNMA-3OYR(FNMAKiTO 290.625.00
SETT.O41O5
6.000 DUE 04101/35
MBS NET 04/12/05
04/13/05 JOURNAL MAR 05 SPEC CLEARING FEES 9.150.00
04/13/05 JOURNAL FNMA 3OYR OTD 554.882.81
SETT, 04/05
5.000 DUE 04101/36
MBS NET 04/13/05
04/13/05 JOURNAL FNMA 3OYR OTD 228.125.00
SEM 04/05
5.500 DUE 04101/35
MBS NET 04/13105
027 0430,0S:11:24 001 sa177
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
ynipsY CpmED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
35 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS (continued)
DATE
won TRANSACTOI DESCRIPTION  MINT AMOUNT CREPT MAPINT
04/14105 JOURNAL TO CADY AC 319,187.50
04/14105 DELIVERED FRM 700.000.00
TRIP
POOL 0021445 COUPON 5.0000
FINANCING NET PAIRCfF DIFF
04/14105 RECEIVED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 DUE 07/01/34
DUE 07 00
TRIP
POOL 0021445 COUPON 5,0000
700.000.00
04/IS:OS JOURNAL FNMA-I SYR(FNMA-15)010
SER.04/05
4.500 DUE 41/20
MBS NET 04/15105
125.000.00
04/18/05 JOURNAL TOCMDYAC 348.087.50
04/1845 JOURNAL FMMA-15YR(FNMA-15)611) 221.875.00
SETT.0445
5.500 DUE 04/01/20
MBS NET 04/18/05
04,2005 RECEIVED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001 DUE 07/01/34
DUE 07mh»nu n n01
TRIPS
POOL 0021422 COUPON 0,0000
121.000.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD April 1. 2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER ALIMER On File
LAST STATEMENT Mardi 31.2005
027 04300S:11:24 001 Van
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
MIDAS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
36 /,/
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS (continued)
DATE
CDAY TRANSAG11,1 DESCRIPTION DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
04/20105 DELIVERED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 121.000,00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001 DUE 07101/34
DUE 07/01/2034 0,001 FITLI 1452191
TRIPS
POCt 0021422 COUPON 0,0000
04/22/05 JOURNAL REV ENTRY 2.905 30.973,04
04/22/05 JOURNAL 04 TREAS REBATE A0 2-9 30.973,04
04/22/05 JOURNAL FR CMOY ANC 146,575,00
04/27105 JOURNAL FR CMOY ANC 21.412,50
04/2905 JOURNAL TO CMDY A/C 270.062.50
TOTAL 92.804.417.29 $2204.993.35
Trades Executed Pending Settlement
SETTLEI.IEN1 TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION OESCRETION
05/02105 04/27105 BOUGHT GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSOC
SIMEID.CUSP
SERIES 2004-041 CLASS SE
ISO 57160000 BS
STATEMENT PERK* April I. 2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT Minn 31.2005
CAW/MY Pala DEBIT AMOUNT
16073.792,00 7,1562 1.099.871,82
CREW AAIDUNT
05/02105 04/28/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY N3TE
• 03,625% AO 30
. 0 MATURITY
GVER REF # GI181006 Al
-50.000.000 00 100,0546 50.037.194 .29
027 0.300501:24 ON V87/
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
37 c?
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
sentEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/3N
05/12/05 03/31105 BOUGHT
05/12)05 04/12)05 BOUGHT
0912105 04107/05 SOLD
05/1 2/05 03/31105 BOUGHT
05/12/05 04/12/05 BOUGHT
05/12/05 04/07105 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
SETT.OSt00
01111105.000%
57140000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
SETT.05/04
0. 00105.000% 57300000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJOID
SETT.05/04
57220000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJOID
SETT.0S/0S
57150000 BS
FNMA-3cnitFNMAAID
SETT 05:05
05.500%
57400000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT 05f0S
05.500%
57210000 BS
TOTAL
The thew *eon cti not ewers on eny other eaten o1 lee stelemert
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD RPM 1. 2005
THROUGH April 29.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER ARAMER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT Mirth 31.2005
SiM80..CuSP 0.:ANNT. PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT AlKUNT
20.000.000.00 97.4921 19.498.437.50
20.000.000.00 98.1328 19.626.562.50
.40.000.000 ,00 97.9218 39.168,750 ,00
20.000.000.00 99.8906 19.978.125.00
20.000.000.00 100.3750 20.075.000.00
-40.003.000 ,00 100.2578 40.103.125 .00
580.277.996.82 $129.309.069.29
027 04/30,06:11:24 001 Y077
CLEARED IHROLGH ITS
wHOLLY °MED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEEISITE wmv.bearstearns.com
What's In This Statement
Financial Summary  3
Your Portfolio Holdings   4
Transaction Detail   6
Trades Not Yet Settled   35
Your Portfolio at a Glance
TOTAL VALUE OF SECURITIES THIS PERIOD
LONG ACCRUED INTEREST
NET CREDIT BALANCE
3,335,615
57,993
77,668
1111111111111I Ill I I I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
0/0 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Market Value of Your Portfolio
Cash 8 Equvralenr 777.668
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD $3,471,276
NET EOUITY LAST STATEMENT 1,517,425
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT 1,953,851
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on file for your account.
1336.828
Fated
Income ft  11.175.677
MO Current market value
gag Last statements market value
13.335.615
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 Wirth 1.2005
THROUGH Mint 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAWR On Pile
LAST STATEMENT PeOrualy 28.2005
SIM1W6 PordurY la dOsmaxdol psrposes only I Is net derided anti, dcarnta
staternsd should Do marled for your worth Soo worn Sofa- monad reconorum
027 0601.136:09:09 001 Y876
CLEARED 'THROUGH 05
WHOLLY 00AE0 SUBSIDMA7
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 oi 4o
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
021 0.01650970 001 7870
CLEARED IHRCUGH ITS
WHOLLY odhco SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
3 C/
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PEPI00
Income Summary MS PERI® YEAR TO DATE
Opening Balance
Securities Sold
Dividends Interest
Miscellaneous
Amount Credited
$336,827.64
956,588,364.34
992,974.47
2,751,164.59
$960,332,503.40
U.S. Govt. Bond Int.
Govt. Agency Int.
Corp. Bond Int.
Credit Balance Int.
Reverse Repurchase Int.
Total
178.611.89
693.096.31
120.062.77
1.203.50
323.157.29
$1 316 131.76
2.510.456.45
2.022.336.00
375,012.07
1,960.00
826,531.30
$5 736 295.82
Securities Bought -955,829.656.15 Bond Purchase Int. -1.309.848.42 -3.500,285.37
Dividends/Interest Charged -1,309.848.42 Repurchase lnt. Exp. -177.727.19 -400,692.42
Miscellaneous -3,452.158.93
Amount Debited $-960.591.663.50
Portfolio Composition Net Cash Activity -259.160.10
CashtCash Equivalent 77.668
ClosingBatance $77,667.54 Fixed Income 3.335,615
Total $3.413.283
Cash Balance Summary
OPENS'
Margin 336.827 64
CLOSING
77,667.54
Net Cash Balance $336,827.64 $77.667.54
027 O4,0u05:09:49 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash & Equivalent
2%
UnsPa0aLl imams deo* debt beano, anot ,  shy,
market yews he alocabon perceenne is clewed
Korn to absolute marital value of
1/876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y onne0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
ciiisceenou
CASH BALANCE
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS $77&68
SOTTECL CLSIP /MPXET ESTIMATED [LAPIN(
OIJANTITT PACE VALUE NWJAL IntWE )E101%)
77.668
FIXED INCOME
Government & Agency Obligations
DESCRIPTION s•idect.c.usa ACC-TYPE CLU.% • PRICE 1AARKET VALLE ACCRUED /MEREST ESTIAMED ANM.M1 iNCOME
CURFEW'
YEW IV
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2003.49 CLASS SW
DATED DATE 04/30/03
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 01/25/2033 4.150%
FACTOR — $4826993
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
DATED DATE 0201/05
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 02/01,2035 6.000%
FACTOR — .97552156
Total Government& Agency Obligations
MRGN
MRGN
13.326.665
9,755.215
8.3078 1.107.158
22.8438 2.228.457
$3,335,615
48.776
557.993
553,057
585.313
$1.138.370
49.9529
26.2654
TOTAL FIXED INCOME $3.335.615 $57,993 $1.138.370
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLOINGSACCRUED INTEREST $57.993
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLOINGSESTIMATED ANNUAL INCOME $1,138,370
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS $3.413283
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAWR OR File
LAST STATEMENT Feminine 28.2005
027 IMOIMS:ISMS 001 '.870
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions
with Bear,Stearns& Co.Inc.outstanding as of date of statement
PLOCHASEr RENFINAFF PRICING PURCHASE PRICE; ACCRUED REPO CAMAITITY
START DATE DATE PATE PRINCPAL MEREST* (FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTOR
CLEARED 1.4ROuGH ITS
viiiCti.v OMEO SUCISIOally
Beer Szer
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO March 1.2005
THROUGH Muth 31.2005
Acccurn NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMMER On He
LAST sTATEmENT February 28.2005
YOU SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(REPO) 01/13/05 04/11/05 2.860 -2,601,000 -16.117 -22.100,000 SERIES 2004-5 CLASS P 4.1000 02/20/33
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 01/13/05 04/11/05 2.860 -11.902,000 -73.752 -30.000,000 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 02/07/05 OPEN 0.000 -50.000,000 SERIES 2003-13 CLASS 5.1500 03/25/33
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 03/14/05 04/11/05 3.020 -3,608,000 -5.448 -7.000,000 SERIES 346 CLASS PO 11(01/33
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 03/16(05 04/15/05 3.030 -11.248,000 -15.147 -30,959,779 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FREDDIEMAC STRIP
(REPO) 03116/05 04/15/05 3.030 -2,013,000 -2.710 -10.000,000 SERIES 228 CLASS 10 6.0000 02/01(35
YOU PROVIDED FANNIEMAE STRIP
(MARGIN) 03/21/05 OPEN 0.000 -2.090.000 SERIES 346 CLASS PO 11/01/33
YOU SOLD USTR 4.0000 02/15/15
(REPO) 03/22/05 OPEN 1.990 -28.800.000 -15.120 -30.000.000
YOU SOLD FREDO1EMAC STRIP
(REPO) 03/22/05 04/11/05 2.860 -2.018.000 -1.603 -10.000.000 SERIES 228 CLASS 10 6.0000 02/01/35
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(REPO) 03/23/05 04/22/05 2.050 -2.032.000 -1.041 -8,500,000 SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(MARGIN) 03/23/05 OPEN 0.000 -11,500,000 SERIES 227 CLASS 10 5.0000 12/01/34
027 D.01.06:09:49 001 Y876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MICELY CMY.E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
6 C/ 4(1
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.inc.outstanding as of date of statement (continued)
MACHU& REPURCHASE PRONG PURCHASE MCC ACCRUED REPO GUMMY
START DATE DATE PATE PRINCIPAL MEREST* (FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTOR
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAUER On Flk
LAST STATEMENT Pebuary 28. 2005
YOU PROVIDED FANNIEMAE STRIP
(MARGIN) 03/28/05 OPEN 0.000 -910,000 SERIES 346 CLASS PO 11/01133
YOU PROVIDED GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 03/29/05 OPEN 0.000 -4.300,000 SERIES 2004-5 CLASS P 4.1000 02/20/33
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIP
(REPO) 03/30/05 04/15/05 3.050 -4.429.000 -750 -20.000.000 SERIES 353 CLASS 10 5.0000 07/01/34
YOU SOLD FREODIEMAC STRIP
(REPO) 03/30/05 04/15/05 3.050 -100.000 -16 -10.000.000 SERIES 228 CLASS 10 6.000002/01/35
YOU BOUGHT USTR 3.0000 12:31/D6
(REVERSE) 03/21/05 OPEN 2.380 49.875.000 37.752 50.000.000
TOTAL REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS $49.875.000 $37.752
TOTAL REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS 5-68.751.000 5.131104
'As c ILVVroaell <WO
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTOR
03/01/05 02/28/05 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA 15
. MATURITY
OVER REF # 00591007 Al
STMEICECU5P OVAMire pr.cE
.3D00.000 109.72266
ACCR. INT.
DEER AMOUNT CMCAT ATFOUNT
3,291,679.69
6.236.19
027 01.0105:09:49 001 •.876
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION SY1A3011CUSV QUANTITY PRCE Mier AMOUNT CHEM AMOUNT
03/01/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -1
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DUE 1001/33
03/02/05 03/01/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10.000,000 96.92188 9.692,187.50
04,000% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 16.574.59
MATURITY
REF # 60601000 Al
03/02/05 03/01/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -10,000,000 96.89063 9,689,062.50
04 00051 FA 15 ACCR. INT. 16,574.59
MATURITY
GYER REF # 00601005 Al
03/04/05 03/03/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MI= 10.000.000 96.95313 9,695,312.50
04,000% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 18.784.53
MATURITY
AVER REF # G062t002 Al
03107/05 03/04/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -5.000.000 97.11719 4,855,859.38
04,000% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 11,049.72
MATURITY
AVER REF # G0631009 Al
03109/05 03/08/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10.000.000 96.95313 9.695.312.50
04,000% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 24.309.39
MATURITY
AVER REF # 0067! 033 Al
03109/05 03/08105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MEM 5 000 000 96.96875 4,848,437.50
04.000% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 12,154.70
0 iJATuRinr
GVER REF #60671016 Al
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wilEtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIOMAY
Beer Ster T
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMER OR Fee
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
021 04,01.05:09:4S 001 V876
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
8 o
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
03/14/05 03/03/05 CANCEL SELL
03/14/05 03/04/05 BOUGHT
03/14/05 02/03/05 CANCEL SELL
03/14/05 02/10/05 CANCEL SELL
03/14/05 03/01/05 CANCEL SELL
03/14/05 02/17/05 BOUGHT
OESCRPTION
FNMA 30YR. GM
sSEIT, 03/05 05.500%
AS OF 03103/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR. GM
SETT, 03/05
immo05,500% 57110000
FNMA 30YR. GM
iimosSETT, 03/05 05.500%
AS OF 02103/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR. GTO
05.500%
AS OF 02/10105
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR. GTO
SETT, 03/05
05.500%
AS OF 03/01105
TO CA. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR. GM
SETT, 03/05
11.005.500 ,
57360000 BS
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WIIC(LY OMS*0 SUBSIDIARY
Beer Szewn Tir
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH Marsh 31.2005
ACCOUVT NUMBER
TAXPAYER BANNER OR Ale
LAST STATEMENT Februiuy 28.2005
STMEOLCUSE CATMINT PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CABO MONO
10.000.000 100.81641 10,081,640.63
BS
10.000.000 101.06250 10.106.250 00
BS
EMI 10,000,000 101.51563 10,151,562.50
BS
10.000.000 101.67188 10.167.187.50
BS
15.000.000 100.68750 15.103.125.00
BS
15 000.000 101.55859 15,233,789.06
021 040i.05:09:0 001 V876
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
03/14/05 02/09/05 BOUGHT
03/14/05 03/03/05 SOLD
03/14/05 03/04/05 CANCEL BUY
03/14/05 02/03/05 SOLD
03/14/05 02/10/05 SOLD
03/14/05 03/01/05 SOLD
03/14/05 02/17/05 CANCEL BUY
DESORPTION
FNMA 30YR. GM
ISS .505.500%
FNMA 30YR. GTO
SETT, 03/05
05.500%
FNMA 30YR. DID
SETT, 03/05
05.500%
AS OF 03/04105
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA 30YR. GM
SETT, 03/05
05,500%
FNMA 30YR. GM
SETT, 03/05 cum%
FNMA 30YR. GM
SETT, 03/05
111.105.500%
FNMA 30YR. GTO
SETT, 0305
001100105.500 ,
AS OF 02/17105
TO C)3. PREVIOUS BUY
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MELLY EIDS*0 SUBSIDIARY
Reef Sear
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On Fee
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
SYMBEVOUSP GUMMY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT GRECO AMOUNT
20,000,000 101.82422 20,364,843.75
BS
-10,000,000 100.81641 10.081.640.63
BS
-10,000,000 101.06250 10.106.250.00
BS
-10,000,000 101.51563 10,151,562.50
BS
10.000.000 101.67188 10.167.187.50
BS
VIM -15.000.000 100.68750 15.103.125.00
BS
-15.000.000 101.55859 15,233,789.06
BS
021 04,01.05:09:40 001 .876
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
10 c? 4:r
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
03/14/05 02/09/05 CANCEL BUY
03/14/05 03/01/05 CANCEL SELL
03,14,05 03,03:05 CANCEL SELL
03/14/05 03/04/05 BOUGHT
03/1405 02/03,105 BOUGHT
03/1405 02/17/05 BOUGHT
CESCRPTION
FNMA 30YR. GTO
SETT,
k03/05 05.500%
AS OF 02/09/05
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YRIFNMAIGTD
SETT.03105
1.005.003 ,.
AS OF 03/01/05
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT.03/05
000505.000,:: 7650000
AS OF 0310345
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SE T.0305
0.0005.0Co3v:
FNMA-30YR(ENMA)GTO
SETT.03,05
05.000,4
FNMA 30YR(FNMA)GTO
SETT.03 05
05.000 .
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
YiNCtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
Beer Sear T
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER 'UMBER OR Ale
LAST STATEMENT Pedals). 28.2005
SYMOOLCUSIP 0.10/4111Y PRCE DEW AMOUNT VIEW AMOUNT
-20,000,000 101.82422 20,364,843.75
BS
10.000.000 98.35156 9.835,156.25
BS
10,000.000 98.53516 9.853.515.63
BS
MEI 10.000,000 98.77734 9.877,734.38
BS
10 000.000 99.43750 9,943,750.00
BS
10.000.000 99.54297 9,954,296.88
BS
02/ 0401.05:09:49 001 7876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YOICtLY 01MAED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR OESCRPTION STMEIEL.CuSA OVANTry PACE DEBIT AMOUNT CRECIT AMOUNT
03/14/05
03/14/05
03/14/05
03/14/05
03/14/05
01/14/05
02/10/05
03/01/05
03/03/05
03/04/05
02/03/05
02/17/05
CANCEL SELL
SOLD
SOLD
CANCEL BUY
CANCEL BUY
CANCEL BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SET .03105
1.11.15 °576.0700000096 BS
AS OF 02/10/05
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30YR(FNWOGTO
SETT.03105
57060000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNWOGTD
00#1.5SEITMICIS °5.°00%7650000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNWOGTO
SET .03105
05.000%
57120000 BS
AS OF 03/04105
TO CA. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNWOGTO
SETT.03/05
010.11 5057;0:
0%0 as
AS OF 02/03/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJGTO
SETT.03 os
VIM
10,000.000
-10.000,000
-10,000,000
-10.000,000
-10.000,000
-10.000.000
99.73828
98.35156
98.53516
98.77734
99.43750
99.54297
9.973.828.13
9,835,156.25
9,853,515.63
9,877,734.38
9.943.750.00
9.954.296.88
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUTA3ER On File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
05,000
57300000 BS
AS OF 0217 OS
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
027 01101.05IYA49 001 .R7e
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
0314/05 02/10/05 SOLD
03/14/05 02/03/05 BOUGHT
03/14/05 02/09/05 CANCEL SELL
03/14/05 02/03/05 CANCEL BUY
03/14/05 02/09/05 SOLD
03/14/05 03/11/05 SOLD
03/14/05 03/11/05 BOUGHT
OESCEM'TION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GID
SETT43105
05400%
7670000 BS
FNMA 30YRIFNMATGTD
SETT, 03/05
06,000%
7730000 BS
FNMA 30YR(FNMA) GTD
SETT, 03/05

010. 506.00014 7340000 BS
AS OF 024945
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR(FNMA) GTD
SETT. 03/05
06400%
7730000 BS
AS OF 02/03105
TO CxL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA 30YRIFNMATGTD
SETT. 03/05
0110 5 06.000%
7340000 BS
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS I
0000I%
57110000 BS
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.125% II 31
3. MATURITY
GVER REF # 00701010 Al
CLEARED THRouGH iTs
Tempi:, GMT*/ SUEISIOTAny
Beer Styr Tir T
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Marsh 1.2005
THROUGH Minh 31.2005
ACCOUST NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
STIIEKVCUSP GUMMY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT GRECO AMOUNT
-10,000,000 99.73828 9,973,828.13
20,000,000 103.01563 20403,125.00
20,000,000 103.18750 20437,500.00
-20,000,000 103.01563 20,603,125.00
-20.000.000 103.18750 20.637.500.00
-4.978.135 76.45313 3.805.940.34
8.000.000 98.94531 7,915,625.00
ACCR. NT. 29.005.52
027 0•01.06.49:49 001 7876
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCATTION 10.180..CIISP Gowan' viva DEBIT AMOUNT CREPT AMSUNT
03/15/05 03/14/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 25.000.000 98.80078 24,700,195.31
03,000% JD 30 ACCR. INT. 153,314.92
. MATURITY
GVER REF # 60731012 Al
03/16/05 03/14/05 SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MEI -7,882.556 77.21875 6,086,811.75
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
01 1111/57300000 BS
03/16/05 03/14/05 BOUGHT FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510110 MEI 9.755,215 22.78125 2.222.360.05
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
06,00054 ACCR. INT. 24.38204
57200000 BS
AS OF 03/14105
ACCRUES CH 1ST. PAYS ON 25TH
03/16/05 03/15/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE  _10.000,000 95.67188 9,567,187.50
04,000% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 32,044.20
MATURITY
GVER REF # 60741007 Al
03/18/05 03/16/05 SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MEI -2,979,264 77.59375 2,311,723.34
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
iii57230000 BS
03/18/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MEM -1
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
ADJUST POSITION
03/21/05 03/18,105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 25,000.000 98.84375 24,710,937.50
03,000% JD 30 ACCR. INT. 165,745.86
. 0 MATURITY
GVER REF # 60771013 Al
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
valCsLY 0‘1T,*0 SUBSIO4ARY
Beer Steam. SO •it' •
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH Much 31.2005
ACCOUVT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAKER On File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
021 0401.05:09:46 001 V676
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACT/DR OESCRPTION SYMBISUCLISTP civomily Pma
TAXPAYER K1. ER On Fie
LAST STATEMENT PeOrtliVy 28.2005
DEBIT AMOUNT GRECO ANCTUNT
03/21/05 03/18/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 50.000.000 98.84375 49,421,875.00
JO 30 ACCR. INT. 331,491.71
Ri MATURITY
GvER REP it 0077i0t3 Eti
03/21/05 03/18/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 50,000,000 98.84375 49,421,875.00
03,000% JO 30 ACM. INT. 331,491.71
MATuRITY
GYER REe#60771013 CI
03/21/05 03/18/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 13,000,000 95.98047 12.477.460.94
04,000% FA 15 ACCR. NT. 48,839.78
MAIVRITY
GYER REF e 60771006 Al
03/21/05 03/18105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE IMO 13.000,000 96.03125 12.484.062.50
04,000% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 48,839.78
0 MATuRITY
GYER REF # 60771000 Al
03/21/05 JOURNAL EDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -1
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
WE teal/33
03/22/05 03/18/05 SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -14.252.296 25.62500 3,652,150.94
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
iiii 5057,104000000% ss ACCR. INT. 41,569.20
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 25TH
03/22/05 03/18105 BOUGHT FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110 MIS 9.755.215 22.48438 2,193,399.26
SERIES 228 CLAS0S71.0108000%
ss ACCR. NT. 34,143.25
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
?RIMY (AM,ED SUBSIDIARY
Beer Roe) Tir T
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Meat 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 25TH
021 0401.05:09:49 001 V876
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACT/3N
03/22/05 03/21/05 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04.000% FA 15
. 0 MATURITY
OVER REF # 60801006 Al
MVOS 03121;05 SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
05,000%
57270000 BS
ACCRUES CH 151. PAYS ON 25TH
03/23/05 03/21/05 BOUGHT FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
06.000%
57310000 BS
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 25TH
03/24/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5,000 DUE 12/01/34
ADJUST POSITION
03128/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN RID 02-05 ND 03-25-05
REPO P 81 0.0000
0328/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
WE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN RID 02-05 ND 03-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
03/28/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
WE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN RID 02-05 ND 03-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
SOA80..CLISP OVANTITY
-26.000,000
PRICE
95.82813
ACCR. INT.
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MELLY EIDS*0 SUBSIDIARY
Reef S;Bun
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER 'UMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT FebruEuy 26.2005
DEBIT AMOUNT CREC0 AMOUN1
24,915,312.50
100,552.49
-14.252,296 25.93750
ACCR. INT.
3.696.689.37
43.548.68
9.755,215 23.03125
ACCR. NT.
2.246.748.09
35.769.13
199.741.03
238.243.25
285.891.90
021 04010509:4S 001 Y876
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION OESORPTION SiM130...CuSP °WITT PLACE DEBIT AMOUNT CPEDIT ATAOUNT
0328/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN .241.672
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
4,350 DUE 01/25/33
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 03-25-05
03/28305 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 12,62220
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
WE 11/01/33
PAIN RID 02-05 ND 03-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
0328/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 25.244.40
SERIES 346 CLASS
WE 11/01/33
PRIN RID 02-06 ND 03-25-05
REPO P 81 0.0000
03/28/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 59,227.25
SERIES 346 CLASS
WE 11/01/33
PRIN RID 02-05 PM 03-25-05
REPO P 81 0.0000
03128/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 97.093.85
SERIES 346 CLASS
WE 11/01/33
PAIN RID 02-06 PN 03-25-05
REPO P 81 0.0000
03/28/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 85.727.46
SERIES 352 CLASS
0.001 DUE 07/01/34
NUN RID 02-06 ND 03-25-05
REPO P 81 0.0000
03/30/05 03/28/05 SCLO FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -14.252.296 26.34375 3,754,589.32
SERIES 353 CLASS 2 ACCR. MT. 57,405.08
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wHOtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIOMTve
Beer Stea•nb SO •it' •
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMER CD File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
7120000 BS
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 25111
021 0401.05:09:4S 001 V876
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
YAICU.Y OmnE0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
17 0 4:r
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION ST1.1001XUSIP °WHINY FOCE DEBIT AMOUNT CFECCT A/hOcter
03/30/05
03/31/05
03/28/05 BOUGHT FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
10111115 067.10100000096 BS
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 25TH
JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 DUE 07/01,34
9,755.215 23.90625
ACM. INT.
-1
2,332,106.23
47.150.21
TOTAL 5-412A06.610.51 $273.687.675.03
INTEREST
DATE DESORPTION STMEOALTSIP OuMffilY RATE IST DENT AMOUNT CREO11 AMOUNT
03/01/05
03/15/05
03/15/05
03/21/05
AVG BAL 860.06ORT 1.799
021 OFFICE INTEREST 0205
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109 NMI SERES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 02-05 P,D 03-15-05
REPO P &I sp000
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE 12/01/2034 5,000
INT RID 02-05 P,D 03-15-05
REPO P &I 5.0000
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4.351
INT RID 02-05 P,D 03-20-05
REPO P SI 4.3518
5.0000
5.0000
4.3510
027 OA.ONO5:O9:49 001
1.203.50
24,673.31
57,571.07
15.594.20
Yralt
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERO° March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
AcccuNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WEISER On hie
LAST STATEMENT PeOcuag 28.2005
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
yinCELY ODY*0 MJEINDany
Beer Siewn
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WESER On File
LAST STATEMENT Fetuses)/ 28.2005
DATE DESCRIPTION STMECUOUSIP OUNIRITY RATE PE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
03/21/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4.3510 63,827.43
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4951
TNT RID 02-05 PA) 03-20-05
REPO P 8I 49518
03/21/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4.3510 80,146.94
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4,351
INT RID 02-05 PA) 03-20-05
REPO P 8I 49518
03/28/05 FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003-13 5.3500 120,062.77
S RCA-I/0 RTR
DUE 03/25/2033 5950
INT RID 02-05 PA) 03-25-05
REPO P 8I 59500
03/28/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4.3500 49.1&5.22
SERES 2003.49 CLASS SW
DUE 01/25/2033 4950
INTEREST PAYMENT 03-25-05
03/28/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 5.0000 119.803.93
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5,000
INT RID 02-05 PA) 03-25-05
REPO P 8I 59000
03/28/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN IMO 5.0000 139,771.25
SERES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5900
INT RID 02-05 PA) 03-25-05
REPO P 8I 59000
TOTAL $671,839.62
027 OAOI XIS:09:4S 001 Y878
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
MOST ORRED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
19 c? 4:I
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETILEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPECII SIDAEICtiCUSIP WNW( DEBIT AMOUNT CREDO' AMOUNT
03/01/05 JOURNAL UNITED TATE TREASURY BONDS 3,000,000 3,322,500.00
ATM A2
5.375 1
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
03/01/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS 1,568.04
DUE 02/11. 5,375
NM A2
REPO I
0304;05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4.300.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.351
RIM r2
TERM MENT
03/04/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN MEM -4.300.000 444.000.00
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
FITM AI
4.351 *U
REPO A
03/04/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE 30.000.000 29.475.000.00
FITM 52
4,000 , 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
03/04/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE -40.000.000 38,800,000.00
FRM Al
4.000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
03/04/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 23,645.50
DUE OA. 4,000
RIM n
REPO I
03/07/05 JOURNAL UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE -35,000.000 34.125.000.00
NM Al
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD MUM 1.2005
THROUGH MUER 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
4.000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
027 0401.05.09y1S 001 Y876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WIICtLY omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
20 c! 4:
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
03/07/05
TWEE
DATE TRANSACTION
JOURNAL
DESORPTION
UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE
FITM A2
4.000 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
03/07/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 023111. 4,000
FITM n REPO I
01/09M5 JOURNAL FITM UNITED EASURY NOTE
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
01/09M5 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
FITM Al
4.000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
01/09X15 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 01/31/2007 3,125
3.125)11(7 w
RIM A2
TERM ENT
03/09/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 01/31/2007 3,125
3,125 7
FIN A3
TERM ENT
01/09/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 02/101. 4,000
FITM A2
REPO I
03/09/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE OW/ 1,125
SVIABEIJCUSIP OVANTITY
40,000.000
DEBIT AMOUNT
38.800.000.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Mann 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
1.584.33
35.000.000 34,125,000.00
-40,000.000 38.500.000.00
-8.000.000 7.990.000.00
8,000,000 7.990.000.00
2.644.69
5.166.87
027 0401.05:09:4S 001 V876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MICALY ONT.E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
21 0 4:I
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TMIDE
DATE DATE TRATISACRON DESCRPRON SYMEMJCUSIP CAMMily DEIST AMOUNT CREW' AMOUNT
03/09/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 5.166.87
DUE 011 3.125
ATM A3
RESALE
03/10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -11,014,443 7.646.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM Al
REPO
AIM.
03,10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 11.014.443 8.514.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FMA RIFIRM AI TERM NT
0310105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN VIM -13,137.594 9,120,000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM Al
REPO Si
03/10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 13.137.594 9.695.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
TERRARM ENT
03/10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN Miff 3.180.365
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE II,
ATM A2
TERM MENT
03/10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -3.180.365 2,202,000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE I 1
FITM lip Al
REPO A
FINANCAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT Febuary 28.2005
027 0:01.05:09:49 001
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
=Pm 22
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION STMBOL,CvStp WWII/ DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
03/10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -4,978,135 3,395,000.00
SERIES 352 CLASS
0,001
FFONT r Al
REPO A
03/10/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4,978,135 3.784.000.00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0.001
FITM AZ
TERM MENT
03/10/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 7.486.69
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE Oj 0.000
ATM AZ
ai
REPO I
03/10/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 18.475.38
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 01 0,000
FITM AZ
REPO i
03/10/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL LOG ASSN 8,211.28
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
DUE 07.0. 0.001
NM AZ
REPO i
03/14 ,05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -5,213.713 3.608.000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DUE 11.
FiTM Al
REPO A
03/14/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MIK 5,213,713 3,972,000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE I1Rill e
ATM AZ
TERM MENT
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
VASCO.? OMT,*0 SURSIOIARY
Beer Siert. Se •it' •
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WIRIER On File
LAST STATEMENT Fetnia4 28.2005
07/ 0401.0593:49 001 'Ws
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
IMICALY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
23 ci 4:
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETILEMENT WADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIEMON SYLABC1JCUSIP OMMITIN DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
03/14/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4,978,135 3,395,000.00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
0,001 4
FITM 31.2
TERM MENT
03/14/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIS -8,000,000 7.990.000.00
DUE 01/31,2007 3,125
3,125)01/11,7
FITM A4
TERM AGREEMENT
03/14/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MIS 8.311.41
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE Ili. 0,000
FITM A2
REPO I
03/14/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 1,131.67
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
DUE 071. 0,001
FITM A2
REPO I
03/14/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 7.739.20
DUE 01/ 3125
RIM A4
RESALE
oatist5 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN .300.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4,351
FITM AI
REPO
0315;05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4,300,000 444,000.00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
FINANCAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER000 March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT PeOruaty 28.2005
4,351
K
FITM A2
TERM ENT
027 0401.135:09A1S 001 Y876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YITIOlLY °MED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
24 c? 4:
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TIMISACRON DESORPTION SYMECLOCUSIP °GAMIN DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
03/15/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 175,000,000 174,562,500.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3,000
3,000
FITM Al
RESALE T
03/15/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIN -200,000.000 200.000.000.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3,000
3,000
FITM RW2
TERM EEMENT
03/15/05 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 400.22
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 4,351
FRM A2
REPO I
03/15/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE I Z. i ,000 243,944.44
03/16/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 11,014,443 7,646,000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FRM Mr A2
TERM MENT
03 ,16 ,05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN NNE 13,137,594 9,120,000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
ATM air A2
TERM MENT
03 ,16 ,05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -16,269.480 11.248.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01t01/33
STRIP
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Match 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Fda
LAST STATEMENT PeOEUEUX 28.2005
ATM 81
REPO A
027 0401.05:0:49 001 Y876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YiliCtLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
25 c! 4:
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYMBOLCvStP Gummy DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
03/16/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S 10110 -9.755,215 2,013,000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6Fam,000plair m
REPO
03/16/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE -30.000.000 28.650.000.00
FITM Al
4,000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
03/16/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE 40.000.000 38.500.000.00
FITM A2
4,000 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
0316/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MEN 3.823.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 013.0. 0,000
FITM A2
REPO I
0316/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 4.560.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE 01,10 0,000
FITM A2
REPO I
03/16/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 6.684.03
DUE 02:1110 4,000
FITM A2
REPO I
03/18105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN NMI .201.100
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
FITM IMF Al
REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER000 March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Pole
LAST STATEMENT Fehruant 28.2005
027 0401A3S:09:4S 001 'WE
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
ORY.E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
26 4:I
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETILEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION STIAEICIJCUSIP CUMIN DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
03/18/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 3,180,365 2,202,000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DUE II
FITM A2
TERM ENT
03/18/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MI= 1,468.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11t 0,000
FITM A2
REPO I
03/21/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 201.100
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DUE IAS I
FITM A2
TERM MENT
01 ,21/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -1.556.665
SERIES 346 CLASS
DUE I I
FITM Al
REPO A
01 ,21/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MIK 1.355.565 1.000.000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS
DUE II
FITM A2
TERM ENT
01 ,21/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 50.000.000 49.875.000.00
DUE 12131/2006 3,000
F3ITM.000 l Al
RESALE T
03/21/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -175.000.000 174.562.500.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3,000
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER000 March 1.2005
THROUGH Mirth 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT Psalm/ 28.2005
3,000
FITM AWL
TERM EEMENT
027 0401.05:09:4S 001 Y876
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
=Pm 27
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS
SETTLEMENT
DATE
03/21/05
TRADE
DATE TRMISACSON DESORPTION
JOURNAL UNITED TATE TREASURY NOTE
ATM A2
4.000 15
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
(continued)
01+21/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
ATM Al
4,000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
03/21/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11r  0.000
FILM A2
REPO I
03P21/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE I21.1 1.000
03/21/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 02:111. 4.000
ATM A2
REPO I
03/22/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
RIM A2
TERM MENT
03/22/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
4.100
FITM Al
REPO A
03/22/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000
FFONT Alr
REPO A
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
OMY*0 SUBSIOTAIly
Beer Sten. Se •it' •
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER000 March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On Edo
LAST STATEMENT Febuary 28.2005
SYTABIELGyMP I:COMM DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOURS'
30.000.000 28,650,000.00
EWE .56,000.000 53.830.000.00
MEM 1.926.67
MI= 71,473.65
WEE 10.035.46
MEM 4.300.000
MEM -4,300,000 427..000.00
14252,296 3.322.000.00
021 0401.05:09:49 001 Yeas
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
=Pm 28
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wisCtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
Beer Stea•nt. Se •it' •
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* Mirth 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER OR PIM
LAST STATEMENT Pebruaiy 28.2005
STATEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTICH STMEICLCVSIP DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
03/22/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 14,252.296 3,322,000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
ovNTin
5 . 00  0FITM . i 1 rn
REPO A
03/22/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000 Ai
FITM AS
REPO A
03/22/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000 lai
RIM r A3
REPO A
03/22/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 SW
RIM A4
REPO A
03/22/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000
FITM RIMIC36
TERM ENT
03/22/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S 10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,0001.35
FITM Al
REPO
03/22/05 JOURNAL F111 E4 II EASURY NOTE
A l
R
,000 Is
REPO AGREEMENT
03/22/05 JOURNAL UNITED EASURY NOTE
RIM A2
4.000 15
TERM  REPO AGREEMENT
-14,252,296 3.322.000.00
-14,252,296 3.400.000.00
14,252,296 3,400,000.00
28,504.592 6,406,000.00
-9.755,215 2.018.000.00
-30.000.000 28.800.000.00
56.000.000 53.830.000.00
027 0.01.05:09:4S 001 '.876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
29 c? 4:
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTION
03/22/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07111. 5.000
FITM B6
REPO I
03/22/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 02t 4.000
FITM A2
REPO I
03/23/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
FIRM
0.111134A6
TERM MENT
03/23/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSIT114"0 310KA2
TERM ENT
03/23/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000
FITM 30. 34A2
TERM MENT
03123/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S 10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5,000 W
FITM A 1
REPO A
03/23/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#510109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000 lai
FITM A r
REPO A
SIMADDUICUSIP OVANTITT MIT AMOUNT
34,606.64
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUmBER On File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
3,887.72
14.252.296 3,322,000.00
13,731.183
5.884.792
-11,279,186
-8.336.790 2.032.000.00
027 0401.05:09:49 001 .876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MOST ORY.E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
30 c? 4:
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SET1LEIAENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION
03/23/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CUSS 2
DUE 07310 5,000
FITM A6
REPO I
03/28/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
FRM A2
TERM MENT
03/28/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CUSS 1
DUE 11
FITM Al
REPO A
0312&05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CUSS 1
DUE 1 Jai 0,000
FITM A2
REPO I
03/29/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4,100
FITM Al
REPO
03/29/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4,100
FRAM R111.2
TERM MENT
0329 ,05 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
DUE 02i 4.100
FITM A2
REPO I
STMDECCUSIP OUNGITY CENT AMOUNT
263.91
FINANCAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD Mann 1.2005
THROUGH MUM 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
677.782 500,000.00
.677.782
1.135.56
-4.300.000
4.300.000 427 000 00
253.23
027 0401.135:09:4S 001 'We
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
31 c! 4:I
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMENOrt TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION
03/30/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
ATM W1
REPO A
03/30/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
FITM W32
REPO A
0380/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000
FITM B3
REPO A
0380r05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000 11.1
ATM 84
REPO A
03.30105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
FITM W35
REPO A
03.30105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5,000
ITFI14 WAtt
TERM MENT
033005 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S 10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000
FITM
REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
SYMBOLCVSP OUAARITY MINT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
49.003061 4.429.000.00
SIM 19.003.061 4,429,000.00
-19,003,061 4.429.000.00
19.003,061 4,429,000.00
-19.003.061 4.429.000 00
EMI 33,255.358 7,351,000.00
Mit -9.755,215 100,000.00
027 0401.05:09:4S 001 0876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MICELI? ORY.E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
32 0 4:
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SERLEMENT TOLE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIGTH
03/30/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S 10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000
FITM Marl
REPO A
03/30/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S 10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000
FITM W2
REPO A
0380/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000 M ir
F1TM A3
REPO A
0380ros JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6,000
FILM
REPO A
03/30/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 073110 5000
FITM A4
REPO I
SYMEICIECvStP
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WARIER On File
LAST STATEMENT Fenian/ 28.2005
COWIN DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-9.755,215 2,062,000.00
9.755,215 2.062.000.00
-9.755215
9,755,215
35,623.76
TOTAL 5544.732.894.06 5683,221,824.16
MISCELLANEOUS
DATE
1.13GAT TRAAISACTEN DESCRIPTOR
03/09/05 DELIVERED 20653766
ISILIPON 4.0000
FINANCING NET PAIROFF DBE
DEBIT AMOUNT CTECIT
189.59
027 0.01.05:09:49 001 '.876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
33 0 4:
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS (continued)
DATE
MOAT TRANSACTCN
03/11/05 JOURNAL
DESCADMON
FNMA 30YR. GTD
SETT. 03/05
5.500 DUE 03101 /35
MEG NET 03/11/05
DEBITAMOUNT CREW MOUNT
201,367.18
03/11/05 JOURNAL FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SER.03105
5.000 DUE 03/01/35
MBS NET 03/11/05
113.281.25
03/14/05 JOURNAL FNMA 30YR(FNMA) GTD
SETS, 03/05
6.000 DUE 03/01/35
MEG NET 03/14/05
34,375.00
03/15/05 JOURNAL FEB 05 SPEC CLEARING FEES
03/21/05 JOURNAL
5.450.00
TO CMDY AIC 892.060.50
03/22/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY 34.812.50
03/22/05 RECEIVED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 DUE 07101/34
DUE 07/01+2034 5.000
TRIP
POOL 0021445 COUPON 5,0000
78.000.00
03/22/05 DELIVERED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 78.000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 DUE 0701/34
DUE 07,01:2034 5.000
T 0916370
TRIP
PCO. 0021445 CCUPCN 5,0000
03/23/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY AC  267,100.00
03/24/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY At
03/28/05 JOURNAL
98,562.50
FR CMDY 6.462.50
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH Mirth 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT PeOnnity 28.2005
027 0601.05:09:49 001 V876
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS (continued)
DATE
MaIMT TIRMISACTION DESCRIPTION EMTAMOUNT CREMT AMOUNT
03/29/05 JOURNAL FR CMDY NC 69,662.50
03/30/05 RECEIVED FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110 100,000.00
SERIES 228 CIASSIO
6,000 DUE 02+01/35
DUE 02 1191YNc A n00
STRIP
POOL 0034145 COUPON 6,0000
03/30/05 RECEIVED FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110 2.062.000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS*
6.000 OUE 0201:35
DUE 02 OD
CSTRIP
POD.. 0034145 CCUPCN 6.0000
03.+30/05 DELIVERED FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110 100,000.00
SERIES 228 CLASS 10
6.000 DUE 02101.35
DUE OZfTl9n3c x000
STRIP
POOL 0034145 COUPON 6,0000
03/30/05 DELIVERED FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10110 2.062.000.00
SERIES 228 CIASSIO
6,000 DUE 02+01/35
DUE MAT1191YLc a n00
STRIP
POOL 0034145 COUPON 6,0000
TOTAL 3-3,452,158.93 $2,751,164.59
CLEARED IHROuGH ITS
viiiCti.v OW,*0 SUCISIOally
Beer &ter
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH Minh 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAKER On File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
027 C40145:09:0 001 Y876
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Trades Executed Pending Settlement
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION
04/01/05 03/31/05 BOUGHT
04/01/05 03.31/05 SOLD
04/01/05 03/31/05 SOLD
04/13/05 03/14/05 BOUGHT
04/13/05 03/15/05 BOUGHT
04/13/05 03/16/05 BOUGHT
04/13/05 03/21/05 BOUGHT
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03,000% JD 30
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G0901002 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03,750% MS 31
0 MATURITY
GVER REF Ft 60901006 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03,750% MS 31
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G0901006 81
FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT, 04105
00100.06.000% 57280000 BS
FNMA 30YR GM
SETT, 04105
05,000%
57140000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT, 04105
101.1105,000%
57130000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT, 04/05
05.000%
57140000 BS
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wisE0. 11 OUT,*0 SUBSIOTAlly
Reef Siva rr 'if
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACEOUST NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAKER On File
LAST STATEMENT February 28.2005
SYMBOL:CU-MP °WIN PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREC0 WONT
50.000.000.00 98.7304 49.742.306.20
Mir -30.000.000.00 99.9140 29.977.292.52
Mil -50.000.000.00 99.9140 49.962.154.20
10.000.000.00 97.7109 9.771.093.75
VIM 20.000.000.00 97.5781 19.515.625.00
11111 5.000.000.00 97.9335 4,896,679.69
EMI 40.000.000.00 97.7500 39.100.000.00
027 04LOIXIS:09:4S 001 2876
B
STUURR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE DATE DATE TRANSACTION CESOMPTION
04/13/05 03/30/05 BOUGHT
041 3105 03/08/05 SOLD
04/13/05 03/08/05 SOLD
04/13/05 03/09/05 SOLD
04/13/05 03/09/05 SOLD
04/13/05 03/14/05 SOLD
04/13/05 03/18/05 SOLD
STMOOLCUSE>
CLEARED TiTRoue,' ITS
%%Ore ERMCD SCUMMY',
Beer Sown id
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUEIBER On File
LAST STATEMENT Febnialy 28.2005
CAMA/TITY PR CE DEBIT AMOUNT CPECKI AMOuNI
FNMA 30YR GTD 50.000.000.00 97.3984 48,699,218.75
SETT, 04105
57320000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT 04105
05,000%
58030000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT, 04105
05.000%
57670000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT, 04105
10100105000%
57380000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT, 04,.05
05,000%
57320000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT, 04105
57080000 BS
FNMA 30YR GTD
SETT, 04/05
7000000 BS
-10.000.000.00 98.4687 9.846.875.00
-20.000.000.00 98.5312 19.706.250.00
-15.000.000.00 97.9218 14,688,281.25
-20.000.000.00 97.9921 19,598,437.50
-20.000.000.00 97.6562 19,531,250.00
-20.000.000.00 97.9101 19,582,031.25
027 041)0165:09:4S 001 Y8713
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
37 c? 4:I
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOM.? (AMC/ SUBSIDIARY
Beer Sier
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH Marsh 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WhISER On Ale
LAST STATEMENT EMNUEly 28.2005
SETTLEMENT DATE TRADE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SM100.,CuSP OuANTITY AXE DEOIT AMOUNT CREPT AlKuNT
04/13/05 03/18/05 SOLD FNMA 30YR GTD -20.000.000.00 97.9218 19.584.375.00
SETT, 04105
57050000 BS
04/13/05 03/14/05 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR GTD 5.000.000.00 100.1328 5.006.640.63
SETT 04105
05,500%
57290000 BS
04/13/05 03/16/05 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR GTD NMI 5.000.000.00 100.2656 5,013,281.25
SETT, 04105
larnitiii05,500%
57240000 BS
04/13/05 03/29/05 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR GTD 20.000.000.00 101.4843 20.296.875.00
SETT, 04105
Itaill05,500%
57130000 BS
AS OF 03/29/05
04/13/05 03/30/05 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR GM 35.000.000.00 99.8125 34.934.375.00
SETT 04105
05,500%
57390000 BS
04/13/05 03/29/05 CANCEL BUY FNMA 30YR GM NMI 20.000.000.00 101.4843 20,296.875.00
SETT, 04105
57130000 BS
AS OF 03/29/05
04/13,05 03/08/05 SOLD FNMA 30YR GTD -10.000.000.00 100.7070 10.070.703.13
SETT, 04105
58150000 BS
027 DAV 06.49:49 001 '.876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? 0111,(D SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT PeOlUary 28.2005
SETTLEMENT DATE TRADE DATE TRANSACTION CESCRPTION 20/00..CuSP OuANTITY PRCE DEOIT AMOUNT CREPT MORO
04/13/05 03/09/05 SOLD FNMA 30YR GTD -15,000.000.00 100.2812 15,042,187.50
SETT, 04105
05,50016
57390000 BS
04113/05 03/09/05 SOLD FNMA 30YR GTD -20,000.000.00 100.3476 20.069.531.25
SETT 04105
05.500%
57280000 BS
04/13/05 03/29/05 SOLD FNMA-30YR(FNMAJGTO -20,000.000.00 101.7187 20.343.750.00
SETT,04/05
57090000 BS
04/13/05 03/30/05 SOLD FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD -20.000.000.00 101.9218 20.384.375.00
SETT,04/05
06.000%
57150000 BS
04/18/05 03/29/05 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR GTD 20,000,000.00 101.4843 20.296.875.00
SETT, 04,05
05,500%
57130000 BS
04/18/05 03/29/05 CANCEL BUY FNMA 30YR GTD 20,000,000.00 101.4843 20,296,875.00
SETT, 04105
57130000 BS
AS OF 03/29/OS
04/18105 03/08105 BOUGHT FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTD 20,000,000.00 98.5468 19,709,375.00
SETT,04/05
00. 4 04.500% 57680000 BS
027 0401.05:09:49 001 '.X7S
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIDST ORT.E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
39 c? 4:
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SETTLEMENT DATE TRADE DATE TRANSACTION
04/18/05 03/14/05 BOUGHT
04/18/05 03/09/05 SOLD
04/18/05 03/15/05 SOLD
04/18/05 03/29/05 BOUGHT
04/18/05 03/30/05 BOUGHT
0512/05 03/31/05 BOUGHT
DESCRIPTION
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTD
SETT,04/05
01,50016
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTD
SETT 04/05
04,500%
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTD
SETT,04/05
FNMA 15YR(FNMA 15)GTD
SETT,04 OS
AS CF 03:29:05
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTD
SETT 04:05
05,500%
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJOID
SETT,05/04
100/005,000%
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD March 1.2005
THROUGH Minh 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER ARAISER On FM
LAST STATEMENT PeOrualy 28.2005
SO,100..CuSP OUANTITY PPICE DENT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
BS
20,000,000.00 97.7734 19,554,687.50
-20,000.000.00 97.9531 19.590.625.00
BS
-20,000.000.00 97.7421 19.548.437.50
BS
20.000.000.00 101.4843 20.296.875.00
BS
20.000.000.00 101.6406 20.328.125.00
BS
20.000.000.00 97.4921 19.498.437.50
BS
027 0410105:09:4S 001 Y876
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
40 c? 4:
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION CECRPTION
05/12/05 03/31/05 BOUGHT
Sr/A80-CUSP
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* March 1.2005
THROUGH March 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER ARAISER On File
LAST STATEMENT Febniary 28.2005
OuANTITY PRICE DENT AMOUNT Ca£O.T AMOLNT
FNMA-30YR(FNNIA)GYD 20.000.000.00 99.8906 19,978,125.00
SETT,05:05
1000005.500%
57150003 BS
TOTAL $376.638.595.27 $368.120,306.10
The Mot, yak., Co inn %Veal m a, 011µ.. ee.t n
End of Statement
027 DIDIOSITYSMS 001 V876
CLEARED 1HRCOGH ITS
IMICtLY OHGED SUBSIDIARY
B
STURUR NS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
S mear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSITE veemr.bearstearns.com
What's In This Statement
Financial Summary 3
Your Portfolio Holdings  4
Transaction Detail  7
Trades Not Yet Settled  37
Your Portfolio at a Glance
TOTAL VALUE OF SECURITIES THIS PERIOD 1.175.677
LONG ACCRUED INTEREST 4.920
NET CREDIT BALANCE 336.828
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD $1,517,425
NET EOLIITY LAST STATEMENT 11,740.244
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT -10,222.820
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on file for your account.
11111111111111111 I I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
=JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE 63
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Market Value of Your Portfolio
Cash 8 Equvalent _6336.828
$976.344
Fixed
Income
175.677  (Criall   (nal))
$10.656.868
Current market va_ue
MIN Last statements market value
I fel r
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO February 1.2006
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOLNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WINER On File
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
TMETEETETelsTor eleccourbeal dowses otitis not INOMMEI as a tat doaevert
Tin Abend shood M retaned for your records Soo worn Sr faffeSCROft rdormalpn
027 CGOINS:11:09 001 van
CLEARED 'THROUGH RS
WHOLLY OBAED SUBSIDIARY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 o13$
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
027 03OLO5:11:09 001 van
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? EMBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
3 o •Je,
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PEFICO
Opening Balance $976,344.40
Securities Sold
Dividends Interest
Miscellaneous
1,577,818,284.36
2,846,165.17
86,598.03
Amount Credited $1.580.751,047.56
Securities Bought
Dividends/Interest Charged
Miscellaneous
-1,579,710,263.75
-1,601,047.44
-79.253.13
Amount Debited $-1.581,390,564.32
Net Cash Activity -639.516.76
ClosingBalance $336,827.64
Cash Balance Summary
OFth CLOSING
Margin 976.344.40 336,827.64
Net Cash Balance $976,344.40 $336,827.64
Income Summary TAS PERICO YEAS TO DATE
U.S. Govt. Bond Int.
Govt. Agency Int.
Corp. Bond Int.
Credit Balance Int.
Reverse Repurchase Int.
2,046,727.15
673.909.66
124.771.86
756.50
267.946.52
2.331.844.56
1.329.239.69
254.949.30
756.50
503.374.01
Total $3 114 111.69 $4 420 164.06
Bond Purchase Int.
Repurchase lnt. Exp.
-1.601.047.44
-104.943.86
Portfolio Composition
CashtCash Equivalent
Fixed Income
-2.190,436.95
-222,965.23
336,828
1.175,677
Total $1.512.505
027 030705:11:09 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEffico February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KINSER On Ale
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
Your Portfolio
Allocation
jCash & Equivalent
23%
Fued Income
7%
Untivaecl croons Oen,* Oat Dionp, *nee Or,
male wive, The eincom ;event'', If  dewed
Icon to '0191A* motel itbe al >ov Mtn"
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
4 o nn
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
DESCPJPION
CASH BALANCE
S•MSCLOSIP
PMPXET ES1ILIATED CURPENT
OUMITJTY PACE VALUE WSJ& IniCCuE vat I%)
336.828
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS S338.828
FIXED INCOME
Government & Agency Obligations
DESCRPRON SWA3OLCUSP
ACCT
TYPE DUMMY PRICE MARKET VALUE ACCRUED MEREST EsrAtanm ANNUAL INCOME
CURREM YEID Ity
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DATED DATE 04/30/03
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 01/25/2033 4.350%
FACTOR - .55821251
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS I
DATED DATE 11/01/03
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 11/01/2033
FACTOR — 1.00000000
Total Government& Agency Obligations
MRGN
MRGN
13,568,337
8,6649 1,175.676
78.8359
$1,175.677
4.920
34.920
590.223
3590.223
50.2029
TOTAL FIXED INCOME $1,175.677 34.920 3590.223
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLOINGSACCRUED INTEREST $4,920
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLOINGSESTIMATED ANNUAL INCOME $590.223
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS 81.512.505
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NA DER OR PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
027 0101G5:11:09 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YiNCtLY 0‘11,E0 SUBSIOMAY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions
with Bear, Stearns& Co. Inc.outstanding as of date of statement
PACK'S& FIEFURCHPSE PRICING PURCHASE RIM ACCRUED REPO GUANTIN
START DATE DAM ROE PAINOPAL MEREST' (FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTOR
I it' GoI
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MADER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
YOu SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MEG ASSOC
(REPO) 01/13105 04/11105 2.860 -2.601.000 -9.711 -22.100.000 SEES 2004-S CLASS P 4,3518 02/20/33
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 01/13/05 04/11/05 2.860 -11.902.000 -44.440 -30.000.000 SEES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIP
(REPO) 01/13/05 04/11/05 2.860 -6.406.000 -23.919 -30.000.000 SEES 353 CLASS 10 5,0000 07/01/34
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIP
(REPO) 01128/05 04/11/05 2,860 -7.351.000 -18.687 -35.000.000 SEES 353 CLASS 10 5,0000 07/01/34
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 02/07/05 OPEN 0,000 -50.000.000 SEES 2003-13 CLASS 5.3500 03,125/33
YOU PROVIDED GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 02/09/05 OPEN 0,010 4.300.000 SEES 2004-5 CLASS P 4,3518 02/20/33
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIPS
(REPO) 02/10/05 03/10105 2,790 -3.784.000 -5.571 -5.500.000 SEES 352 CLASS PO 07/01/34
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 02/10/05 03/10/05 2,790 -8.514.000 -12.536 -20.959.779 SEES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 02/15/05 03/14/05 2,790 -3.972.000 -4.309 -7.000.000 SEES 346 CLASS PO 11/01/33
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(MARGIN) 02/16/05 OPEN 0,000 -14,000.000 SEES 227 CLASS 10 5,0000 12/01/34
YOU PROVIDED FEDERAL HOME LOAN STRIP
(MARGIN) 02/17/05 OPEN 0,000 -6.000,000 SEES 227 CLASS 10 spoof) 12/01/34
027 03,01,05:11:09 001 Y872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIDALY OUS*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.Inc. outstanding asof date of statement (continued)
PURCHASE/
START DATE
REPURCHASE
DATE
PRICING
RATE
PURCHASE PRIC£I
PRINCPAL
ACCRUED REPO
MEREST'
GUAPMTY
(FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTION
YOU SOLD UST/ 4,0000 02/15/15
(REPO) 02/18/05 OPEN 2.270 -29.475.000 -20.730 -30.000,000
YOU SOLD UST/ 5,3750 0'2/15/31
(REPO) 02/22/05 OPEN 2520 -3.322.500 -1.568 -3.000.000
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 02/25/05 03/24/05 2.890 -1.000.000 -321 -1.820,000 SERES 346 CLASS PO 11/01/33
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 02/28/05 03/10/05 2.780 -9.695.000 -748 -25.000.000 SERES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 02/28/05 03/28/05 2.920 -500.000 -40 -910.000 SERES 346 CLASS PO 11/01/33
YOU PROVIDED FANNIEMAE STRIP
(MARGIN) 02/28105 OPEN 0.000 -4.270.000 SERES 346 CLASS PO 11/01/33
YOU BOUGHT UST/ 3,125001/31/07
(REVERSE) 02/23/05 OPEN 2.200 7.990.000 1.207 8.000.000
YOU BOUGHT UST/ 3,0000 12/31/06
(REVERSE) 02/24/05 OPEN 2.400 200.000.000 65.000 200.000.000
TOTAL REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS
I,Sean SPCmit' GoI
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
*COMM NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER OR FOR
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
1207.990.000 186.207
TOTAL REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS 148.522.500 1-142580
As ct sLmaraoni date
027 0101GS:11:09 001 7872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
7 cl nn
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER MASER On FIN
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
SETTLEmENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/0,J c,Eyba pHON SAIEICLCUSP OuAmire PRGE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
02/01105 01/31105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE .15,000.000 99.68750 14.953.125 .00
03.125% JJ 31
0 MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 1.294.89
GVER REF # G031 1009 Al
02/04105 02/03+05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE NMI -25.000.000 99.60156 24.900.390 ,63
03.125% JJ 31
0 MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 8.632.59
GVER REF P G0341008 Al
0=7+05 02/04+05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 9.000.000 101.32422 9.119.179.69
04.250% MN 15
0 MATURITY
ACM INT, 88.756.90
GVER REF # G0351017 Al
02/07+05 02/04+05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 12.000.000 101.59375 12.191.250.00
DUE 1111 5+2014 04.250% MN 15 ACM INT. 118.342.54 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 4.050 % TO MATURITY
GVER REF 0 G0355379 A3 wwEe
02/07+05 02/04+05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIN 16.000.000 99.49219 15.918.750.00
03.000% JD 30 ACM INT. 50.386.74
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # 60351009 Al
02/07+05 02/04+05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE NNW -20000.003 99.71094 19.942.187 ,50
03.625% JJ 15 ACCR. INT. 46.063.54
. 0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G0351013 Al
02/07105 02/04+05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -15.000.000 99.75391 14.963.085 ,94
03.125% JJ 31
0 MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 9.064.22
GVER REF 0 60351035 Al
027 03,01G5:11:09 001 '.1172
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
?RIMY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BUR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
0207105 PRINCIPAL
02,08105 02/07105 BOUGHT
02/08/05 02/07105 SOLD
0209/05 02/08105 BOUGHT
0209105 02/08105 SOLD
02/10105 01/11105 CANCEL SELL
02/1005 01/18105 CANCEL SELL
OESCRIPTION
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
STRIP MTG SERIES 322 CL PO
0.001 DIE 03/01/32
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 02-25-05
UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA 15
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0381001 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA 15
MATURITY
GVER REF N G0381002 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA 15
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0391000 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA 15
MATURITY
GVER REF V 00391003 Al
FNMA-30YR(FNMAJOID
SE1T,02105
II.005.500%
57220000 BS
AS OF 01/11105
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-30YRtFNMA)OID
tSEIT.02/05 c6.500%
7000000 BS
AS OF 01/18/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
(.Sean $PCmiI e; EAR
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUVT NUMBER
TAXPAYER isiuDOER OR File
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
Ou.wrir, PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CHEM AMOUNT
-95.853
10,000.000 114.47266 11,447,265.63
ACCR, NT. 258,525,81
-10,000.000 114.54688
ACCR,
11.454,687 .50
258.525,82
10430.000 114.75000 11.475.000.00
ACCR, OJT, 259.986.41
-10.000.000 115.79688
ACCR. INT,
11.579,687 ,50
259.986.41
10,000,000 101.25000 10.125000.00
10.000.000 101,51563 10.151.562,50
02/ 03OI,D5;n:09 001 V872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICELY GMB*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
02/10/05 01/20/05 BOUGHT
02/10105 02/03105 BOUGHT
02/10105 01/11115 SOLD
02110/05 01/18105 SOLD
02/10.05 01/20/05 CANCEL BUY
02/10,105 02/0345 CANCEL BUY
OESCRIPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)OM
Th 05.500%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)OTD
sSEIT.02/05 05.50096
FNMA-8DYR(FNMA)OTD
SETT.02$35
1~05.500%
FNMA-80YR(FNMAATD
amistsEr.0.05 (6.500%
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)610
SETT.02r05
110111.11 505.500%
AS OF 01/20,105
TO C)3. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)610
imiosSEIT.02/05 05.500%
7720000 BS
AS OF 02103/05
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
I.Sean $PCmiI e; EAR
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEW° Estrum)/ 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER WINER On FIB
LAST STATEMENT January 31,2005
SYMBOLCUS, °VANITY Pea DEBIT AMOUNT CROW AMMO
BS
10.000.000 101.73017 10,173,046.88
10.000.000 101.80469 10.18D468 .75
BS
-10.000.000 101.25000 10.125,000,00
BS
-10.000.000 101.51563 10.151.562 ,50
BS
-10.000.000 101.72047 1D173.006 ,88
BS
-10.000.000 101.80469 1D180.468 ,75
027 OCTOI:05:i 1:09 001 VS72
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y oonco SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
10 c! 33
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
02/10105 01/2066 BOUGHT
02/10/05 01/2045 BOUGHT
02/10105 02/03105 CANCEL SELL
02/10105 01/20105 CANCEL BUY
02/10105 01/20.05 CANCEL BUY
02 0 OS 02/03105 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
FNMA-30YR(FNMNGID
SETT:32/0S
# 1505.000,::
AS OF 01/20105
FNMA-30YRIFNMAIGID
SET .02105
05.000%
FNMA-30YR(FNLINGID
SETT.02:06
05.000%
AS OF 02/03105
TO CXL PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA-306I(FNMA)GID
591.02.05
06.000%
AS OF 01/20105
TO CXL PREVIOUS BIN
FNMA-30YRIFNMAAID
SEIL02)05
101101 506.000%
AS OF 01/20105
TO CXL PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA-306I(FNMA)GID
SETT.02105
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER issASER ON PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
ST/ADOLCUSP QUANTITY PR9CE DEBIT AMOUNT CFEOIA/lOcter
BS
10.000.000
10.000.000
99,65234
99,65234
9.965.234,38
9.965.234,38
BS
10.000.000 99,70313 9,970,312 ,50
BS
-10.000.000 99,65234 9.965.234,38
BS
-10.000.000 99.65234 9.965.234.38
BS
MIK -10.000.000 99,70313 9.970.312.50
05.000%
7760000 BS
027 010105:11:09 001
CLEARED IHROuGH ITS
yniCLE.Y OMED SUOSIOany
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
11 o
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE -RANSIC11371
02/10/05 1230 ,04 CANCEL SELL
02/10/05 12/16'04 BOUGHT
02/10.05 01/11105 BOUGHT
02/10.05 02/03/05 CANCEL SELL
02/10.05 12/30.04 SOLD
02/10.05 12/16/04 CANCEL BUY
DESORPTION
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT, 02105
1.111 506,000
AS OF 12/30/04
TO CA. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR OTO
SETT. 02,05
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT, 02'05
06,000%
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT, 02/05
AS OF 02/03/05
TO CA. PREVIOUS SELL
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT, 0265
011. 506,000%
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT 02/05
06,000'.
7320000 BS
AS OF 12/16104
TO It PREVIOUS BUY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WAGER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
SYNEKILCUSP OUNPITV PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CAEG7
10,000,000 102,98438 10.298.437.50
BS
10.000.000 103,03125 10.303.125.00
BS
MIN 20.000.000 103,03125 20,606,250.00
BS
20.000.000 103,23438 20.646.875,00
BS
-10.000.000 102,98438 10.298.437 .50
BS
-10.000.000 103,03125 10.303.125 .00
027 0001.05:11:09 001 sea72
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
12 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
02/10105 01/11105 CANCEL BUY
02/1045 02/03+05 SOLD
02/10.'05 01/31+05 BOUGHT
02/1045 02/0945 BOUGHT
02/111105 02/09.'05 BOUGHT
02/16'05 02/00'05 SOW
02/11105 0=3 ,05 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 02105
01/1006.000%
57210000 BS
AS OF 01/11105
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 02'06
7740000 BS
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
00.001%
57900000 BS
TO ADJ PREVIOUS MONTHS FACTOR
AS OF 01/31105
UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA IS
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0401000 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA 15
. MATURITY
GVER REF # G0401030 Al
UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA 15
. v TO MATURITY
GVER REF # G0401005 A3
FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S02684
SEFUES 218 CL PO
1 111. 111157420000 BS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER issaMER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
STIADOLCUSP OUNWITY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREW MOUNT
-20,000,000 103.03125 20.606,250 .00
-20.000.000 103.23438 20.646.875 ,00
5.063.863 80.75000 4.089.069.53
10.000.000 114.71875 11.471.875.00
ACM, INT. 261.447,01
10.000.000 115.63281 11.563.281 .25
ACCR, OJT, 261.447,01
EMI -10.000.000 115.07813 11,507,812.50
ACCR, INT, 261.447.01
.11,250.106 86.56250 9.738.373.44
027 MOLDS:T1:09 001 V872
CLEARED THROuGH ITS
wilDtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BUR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION OESCRIPTION STMEIOLCUSV %MARRY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDO MORD
02/11/05 02/10/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 10.000.000 101,56250 10,158,250.00
laili4.250% MN 15
MATURITY
ACM. INT, 103.314,92
GVER REF #130411021 Al
02/11105 02/10/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY N3TE -5.000.000 101,84375 5,092.187.50
04.250% MN 15 ACCR, INT. 51.657.46
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0411011 Al
02/11105 JOURNAL ANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003-13
S RCA-VO FLTR
5.470 DUE 03/25/33
ADJUST POSITION
02/14/05 02/10105 BOUGHT FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 5.310.807 83.79688 4,450,290.63
SEFUES 346 CLASS 1
IMIIII57250000 BS
ovittis 029 0(05 BOUGHT FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S10109 9.869,325 23,75000 2,343,964.90
SERIES 227 CLASS 10 ACCR, INT, 17,819.62 ilail05,000%
7360000 BS
02/14105 02/11105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE -10.000.000 99,52734 9.952.734.38
OUE 12/31/2006 03.000% JD 30 ACCR, INT. 37.292.81 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 3261 % TO MATURITY
GVER REF # G0422831 A3 WWEB
02/14/05 02/11105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY N3TE -15.000.000 99,47656 14.921.484 ,38
03.000% JD 30 ACCR, INT. 55.939.22
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0421020 Al
021405 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#502684
SERIES 218 CL PO
OUE 02/01/32
I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT Puma.) February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMER On File
LAST STATEMENT January 31,2005
021 CGDIDS:l 1:09 001 V872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
?RIMY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
14 -
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continue)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
02/15105
TRADE
DATE TRANSACI1DN
12/30/04 BOUGHT
OESCRIPTION
FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15$1TD
limmis891.02.05 05.500%
7230000 BS
02/15105 12/16/04 CANCEL SELL FNMA-15YR(FNMA-15)GTO
tousSEIT.02/05 05.500%
7330000 BS
AS OF 12/16/04
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
02,1505 12:3004 CANCEL BUY FNMA-I SYR(FNMA-I 5)GTD
SETT.02/05
05.500%
7230000 BS
AS OF 12/30/04
TO C)3. PREVIOUS BUY
SYMBOL:CUSP OVANTITY
11.000.000
PRICE
102.97656
I.Sean $PCmiI e; C0
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER•oo February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUVT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MaER OTl File
LAST STATEMENT January 31,2005
DEBIT AMOUNT
11,327.421 .88
GRECO' AAIDUNT
11.000,000 103.10938 11.342.031 .25
-11.000.000 102.97656 11.327,421 ,88
02/15/05 12/16+04 SOLD FNMA-15YR(FNMA. I SIGTO
SETT 02/05
05.500%
7330000 BS
-11,000.000 103.10938 11.342.031 ,25
02/15+05 02/11105 BOUGHT FEDERAL NATIONAL WO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
111. 1057150000 BS
02/15/05 02/11105 BOUGHT FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPttS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
05.000%
57140000 BS
5.310.807 83.34375 4.426.226.03
9.869.325
ACM, INT,
23.81250 2,350,133.23
19.190.36
02/15105 02/14/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA 15
MATURITY
GVER REF tt G0451004 Al
-2.000.000 113.91797 2,278,359.38
021 CGDIDS:l 1:09 001 .872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY ome0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
15 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DEseg pno‘r SUM:CUSP CRANTITY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREW Nan
02/15105 02/14105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE .15,000.000 101,22266 15,183,398 .44
04.250% MN Is
. 0 MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 162,016.57
OVER REF # G0451016 A3
02/15+05 02/14105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE 5.000.000 99.57813 4.978.906.25
03.12S% JJ 31 ACCR. 6.474.46
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G0451020 Al
02/15+05 02/14115 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE IIIIIII, 20.000.000 99.60156 19.920.312.50
03.12S% JJ 31
0 MATURITY
ACCR, 25.897.79
GVER REF # 00461008 Al
02/I &OS 02/14105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 50.000.000 99.60156 49.800.781 .25
03.125%.1J 31 ACCR, INT. 64.744.48
MATURITY
GVER REF # 00451008 BI
02/15105 02/14105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE IIIIIIII -35.000.000 99.58594 34.85.5,078 .13
03.125% JJ 31
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 45,321 .13
GVER REF # G0451012 Al
02/15105 PRINCIPAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG ODAPPS02884 35.717.02
SEFUES 218 CL PO
DUE 02/01132
F'RIN RID 01-0S PAD 02-1S-OS
REPO P 8I 0.0000
02/15105 PRINCIPAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#S02684 226.522.48
SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 02/01/32
PAIN RID 01.05 Pin 02-1S-OS
REPO P 8I 0.0000
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WAGER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
027 OCUOLOSI 1:09 001 Y872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
wilDtLY GLARED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
02/15105
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
PRINCIPAL
DESCRIPTION
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
SERIES 2483 Q. SL
4.410 DUE 03/15/32
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 02-1585
02/15405 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL /ME LOAN MTG CORP
SERIES 2530 CLASS SE
4.810 DUE 02/15/32
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 02-1585
MOM CLOW
-308,611
Pam
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUE93ER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
DEIRT AMOUNT CRECir Anoxia
-342.355
0015/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
SERIES 2526 CLASS SI
4.410 DUE IY2+15/32
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 02-1585
-146,854
02/16105 02/14105 SOLD FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
STRIP MTG SERIES 322 CL PO
00.001%
57720000 BS
-3.576.277 86.12500 3.080.068.74
0016105 02/15105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
' 05.375% FA 15
0 MATURITY
OVER REF N 60461000 Al
10.000.000 113.59375
ACM INT.
11.359.375 .00
1.484.81
02,1685 0221505 SLID UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
05.375% FA 15
. 0 0 MATURITY
OVER REF # 60461014 Al
-10.000.000 113.80078
ACCR, INT.
11.380.078 .13
1.484.80
02/16105 02/15405 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04.250% MN 15
0 MATURITY
GVER REF N G0461008 A3
3.000.000 101.19922
ACM INT.
3.035.976.56
32.755.53
02/17+05 02/14+05 SOW FEDERAL HUE LOAN MIG CORP
SERIES 2483 CL SL
04.410%
56240000 BS
AS OF 02.E 14x05
-1.682.201 7,15625
ACCR, INT.
120.382.57
412.14
027 0101G5:11:09 001 van
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY omen SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
17 r!
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION STIADOECUSP GUMMY PRICE DENT AMOUNT own PAIDUN1
02/17105 02/14105 SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP -10,944,806 7.15625 783,237,68
SERIES 2483 Q. SL
04,410% ACCR, INT. 2.681,48
56230000 BS
AS OF 02/14105
02/17105 02/14105 SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP -10.944.807 9.40625 T.029.495,91
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO ACCR, INT. 3.289.52 05.520%
57330000 BS
02/17105 02/14105 SOW FEDERAL HONE LOAN MTG CORP INN -2.447.844 8.00000 95.827.54
SERIES 2530 CLASS SE
04,810% ACCR, INT, 654,12
56220000 BS
AS OF 02/14105
02/17105 02/14105 SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN WG CORP NMI -12.239.221 8.00000 979.137,72
SERIES 2530 CLASS SE
04,810%
56210000 BS
ACCR, INT, 3270,59
AS OF 0211405
02,T7,05 405 SOLD FEDERAL IONE LOAN MTO CORP -6.300.059 7.15625 490.847,99
SERIES 2526 CLASS SI
04,520% ACCR, INT, 1.543,52
57310000 BS
02/17105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN WC CORPHS10i09
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5,000 DUE 12/01/34
02/16.05 02/17105 SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS -2.000.000 112,18359 2.243.671.88
05,375% FA 15
. MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 890.88
OVER REF it 00481004 Al
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
027 03,01:05:11:09 001 .872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y ome0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
18 0 0,
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DEseg prioN SYMEIGGLISP 07ANTID Fma DEW AMOUNT CREW AMOUNT
02/18105 02/17105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY MOTE .10,000.000 100.48438 10.048,437,50
04.260% MN IS ACCR. INT. 111,533.15
. 0 MATURITY
GVER REF # 00481014 Al
02/18105 02/17105 SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -35.000.000 100.48614 35.170,147 ,95
04.250% MN IS
0 MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 390.366,02
GVER REF P G0481028 Al
02/18/05 02/17105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIS 35.000.000 98.56250 34.496.875.00
04.000% FA 15 ACCR. 11,602.21
MATURITY
GVER REF # 00481022 Al
02/18105 02/17105 SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE AIM -5.000.000 98.51563 4.925.781.25
JJS 4.
0u
04.000% FA 15
MATURITY
ACCR. INT, 1.657.46
GVER REF # G0481033 Al
02/22/05 02/18105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS -3.000.000 111.11328 3.333.398.44
05.375% FA 15
. 0 MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 3.118.09
GVER REF # 00491015 Al
02/22/05 02/18.'05 SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -10,000.000 99.26563 9.926.562.50
03.000% JD 30
. 0 MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 43.922.65
GVER REF # G0491014 Al
02/23/05 02/22/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 7.000,000 99.42969 6.960.078.13
03.125% N 31 ACCR, INT. 13.898A8
0 MATURITY
GVER RE? Is 00531007 Al
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
027 OCTOLOSI 1:09 001 Y872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
yasEtLY OUTGO SOSIDany
BUR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION STMEICILEUSP OVANTITY Pma DEBIT AMOUNT CREW Nap 4T
02/24105 02/23/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -5.000.000 99.26172 4.963.085.94
03.000% JD
MATURITY
30 ACCR, INT, 22.790.05
GVER REF # 605/1021 Al
02/24105 02/23/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 5.000.000 98.18359 4.909.179.69
04.000% FA 15 ACCR. INT. 4.972.37
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0541017 Al
02/24/05 02/23/05 SOW UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE EMI -5.000.000 97.98438 4.899.218.75
04.000% FA
MATURITY
15 ACCR, INT, 4.972.38
GVER REF # G0541032 Al
02/25105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NOTIONAL MTG ASSN 95.853.00
STRIP MTG SERIES 322 CL PO
0401 DUE 03/01/32
PRINCIPAL PAYMENT 02-25-05
02/25/05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NOTIONAL MTG ASSN MIS 184.177.56
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN RID 01.05 Pit) 02-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
02/25105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NOTIONAL MTG ASSN 219.679.75
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN RID 01-05 PAD 02-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
02/25105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NOTIONAL MTG ASSN 263.615.70
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
PAIN RID 01-05 PA:102-25-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
I. SIean $PCmitkf EAR
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERGO February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On File
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
02/ 0101005:11:09 001 .872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MOW, (AM,ED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
20 c?
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
0025/05
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
PRINCIPAL
DESCRIPTION
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
4,470 DUE 01/25/33
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 02-25-05
02/28105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11/01/33
Gummy
-222,841
PRICE
/.Sean $PCmiI e; EAR
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUUSER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
DEW AMOUNT CHEM MONO
-1
TOTAL $-403,120.067.73 8452,722,308.78
INTEREST
DATE OESCRPTION SYMEICIJCUSIP OVPAMTY RATE I% DENT AMOUNT MEDI AMOUNT
02/01105 AVG BAL 584.550 RT 1503 756.50
021 OFFICE INTEREST 0105
02/15105 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP 4.4100 48.724,16
SERES 2483 CL SL
DUE 03/15/2032 4,410
INTEREST PAYMENT 02-15-05
02/15/05 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP 5,4100 51.576,60
SERES 2488 CLASS SO
DUE 03/15/2032 5,410
INT RID 01-05 PA) 02-15-05
REPO P 8I 5,5200
0015105 FEDERAL NOME LOAN MTO CORP 4,8100 61.620,62
SERES 2530 CLASS SE
DUE 02/15/2032 4,810
INTEREST PAYMENT 02-15-05
02/15/05 FEDERAL 109ME LOAN MTO CORP 4,4100 24.283,37
SERES 2526 CLASS SI
DUE 02/15/2032 4,410
INTEREST PAYMENT 02-15-05
027 03,01G5:11:09 001 .872
CLEARED IHRCUGH ITS
wisCtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MASSER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
DATE OESCRenON STIABOLCuSiP cc$NTIW RATE lid DEBIT AMOUNT CREW AMOUNT
02/1&05 UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS 5.3750 268,750.00
DUE 02115/2031 5.375
INT RID 02-05 ND 02-15-05
02/22/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL WO ASSN 4.4500 15,845.33
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4.450
INT RID 01.05 PA) 02-20-05
REPO P S I 4.4500
02/22/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL WO ASSN 4.4500 81,954.17
SERES 2004-5 CUSS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4.450
INT RID 01-05 PA) 02-20-05
REPO P S I 4.4500
02/23/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 4,4500 65.266,67
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4.450
RITA CA INT FOR 2/20/2005
PD
02/25/05 FANNIE MAE CMO/SERIES 2003.13 6.4700 124.771.86
S RCA-40 RTR
DUE 03/25/2033 5.470
INT RID 01-05 ND 02-25-05
REPO P d I 5.4700
02/25/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL WO ASSN 4.4700 51.372.14
SERES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DUE 01/25/2033 4.470
INTEREST PAYMENT 02-25-05
02/25/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 5.0000 120.60640
SERES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5.000
INT RID 01-05 PA) 02-25-05
REPO P & I 5.0000
027 0101GS:11:09 001 van
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
22 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
DATE DESCRIPTION
02/25105 FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERES 353 CLASS 2
DUE 07/01/2034 5.000
INT ND 01-05 PM 02-25-05
REPO P 8I 5.0000
TOTAL 51,058,398.85
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SVMBCLCUSIP 0.:ANT1T1 DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT M.IOUNT
02/01105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 15.000.000 15.000.000.00
DUE 01/31/2007 3.125
3,125 7
FITM Al
RESALE
02404/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 17.600.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4,4
FITM50 3.11 312
TERM MENT
02/04105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MM ASSN -17.600.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4,450 DU
FITMARGN Al
REPO AGR
0204x05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 25.030.000 25.000.000.00
DUE 011312007 3.125
3 125 7
FITM Al
RES
ALE
0207/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP NEM Ilk 304
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
SY/ABOLCUS,P
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER WESER NAM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
MAMMY RATE IF! DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
5.0000 140,707.93
5,520 2
FITM Al
REPO A
027 OCUOTOS:l 1:09 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
23 0 H,
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACDON DESCRSMON
02/07/06 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
58203.7
RIM ‘ A2
TERM ENT
02407/05 JOURNAL FANNIE MAE CMOSERIES 2003.13
S RCR-I/0 FLTR
FITM Al
REPO A
02/07105 JOURNAL DIVED STATES TREASURY NOTE
ATM Am A2 4.250 , 14
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
02/07/05 JOURNAL UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE
ATM Al
4.250 14
REPO AGREEMENT
SYMeadttRIP WARM DEBIT AMOUNT
11..,304 849.000.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER•00 February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NumeER On He
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
-27.372.255
31.000.000 31.465.000.00
-52.000.000 53.1 05.000.00
02/07/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 160.000.000 160.000.000.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
FITM 1.111
RESALE
02'07/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
FITM RW2 m
TERM ENT
-176.000.000 176.220.000.00
02/07/05 JOURNAL UNITED SURY NOTE
FITM A2
8625 10
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
20.000.000 19.925.000 .00
02/07105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 01/31/2007 3.125
3,125 I lk
FITM M B
RESALE T
5.000.000 4.999.999 89
027 COVIDS:l 1:09 001 .872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIDIS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
24 ci ))
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TIMISACRON DESORPTION STMEICCCUSIP OWArrny OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
02/07/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -15,000,000 15.000.000.00
DUE 01/31/2007 3.125
FITM A2
3.125 R E7DA
TERM ENT
02/07105 DEUVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -25,000.000 25.000.00003
DUE 0191/2007 3.125
FITM A2
3.125 Rillf7
TERM EIAENT
02/07105 RECEIVED UMW STATES TREASURY NOTE 50.000.000 49.999.999.99
DUE 0191/2007 3.125
3.125 CIMK7
FITM A1A
RESALE T
02/07105 INTEREST FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP Milli 657.97
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
DUE 03:11. 6.520
ATM 102
REPO I
02/07105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIN 12.192,69
DUE 11J  4250
FRM A2
REPO I
02/07105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 64,271,35
DUE ISO 1.000
02/07/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 7.372.25
DUE ON. 3.625
ATM A2
REPO I
02/07/05 INTEREST WEED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE cote  1,125 3,229.17
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
027 MOLDS:T1:09 001 '.872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
IMPLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
25 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMEMDE TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESERPRON SYMeCtoCUSIP OULMITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
02/07/05 INTEREST UNTIED STATES TREASURY NOTE 4,604.17
DUE 01/=.00.7_"II  _3.125
NM 02/09105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL NM ASSN -4.300.000
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
4,450
FITM AI
REPO A
02/09105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL NIG ASSN MEM 4.300.000 500,000,00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4,450 •
FITM A2
TERM AAENT
02/09105 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL NM ASSN MIN 465.00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 4,450
ATM A2
REPO I
02/10105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MIG ASSN 111111 11,214.184 8,409.000 .00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
TERRARM RIIIIM AZENT
0210,05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN -11,214.184 8.514.003.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
ATM Al
REPO
AMIE.
02 10:05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN -5.063.863 3.784.000 00
SERIES 352 CLASS 1
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT RER•00 February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER OR PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
0,001
RIM AT
REPO A
027 03,0L05:11:09 001 VE172
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
26 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT Puce February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NumeEn ON FIk
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCnincti SymeCtictive OVAARITT Oen ;wow CREDIT AMOUNT
02.110/05 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
ATM ligi t Al -10.000000 11.762.500.00
5.375
REPO AGREEMENT
02/10/06 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN SIM 6.046.90
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE Ojai. 0.000
FITM A2
REPO I
02/11,05 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE IMO 52.000.000 53.105.000.00
ATM Hui A2
0.250 , 14
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
02/11106 JOURNAL UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE SIM -57.000.000 58.140.000 .00
FITM Al
0.260 10
REPO AGREEMENT
02/11105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPNS02680 1.532.264 1,199,000.00
SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 0
ATM 30,A2 TERM ENT
02/11105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG OCAPNS02684 9.717,841 7.600.000.00
SERIES 218 CI. PO
DUE 0
FITM 3011 0 A2
TERM ENT
02/11/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 11.181.66
DUE Ile 4.250
FITM A2
REPO I
02/11/06 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN 14113 OCAPNS02680 I .300.92
SERIES 218 CI. PO
DUE 0 0.000
ATM A2
REPO I
027 030IDS:l 1:09 001 V872
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
yniCtLY OmE0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMETO TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION
02/11105 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MTG OCAPPS02684
SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 07 . 0.000
ATM A2
REPO I
02/14105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 'Ti lt,.
ATM Al
REPO
02/14105 JOURNAL FEDL NNE LOAN MI6 OORPteS10109
SERIES 227 CLASS ID
5.000 1.r4
FITM Al
REPO A
02/I 4105 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000
FITM MirA2
TERM EMENT
02/I 4105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000
FITM AI
RESALE T
02/14,05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/3=13ry 3.1:100
Mir 02/15105 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
5.410)00132
FITM A2
TERM MENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
STMEKCCUSIP GUMMY OMIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-5.310.807
13.110.00
3.963.000.00
NM. -9.869.325 2.156.000.00
NMI -160.000.000 160.000.000.00
185.000.000 185.000.000.00
67,066,67
10,944.807
027 010L05:11:09 001 van
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y 0015E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
28 cl 33
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSAMON DESORPTION
02/15105 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
5.410 /
HIM Al
REPO
02/I 5105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS
DUE 11Aiii r
FITM Al
REPO
02/16'05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MIG CORIANSIOi09
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
5.000 11.4
FIRM Al
REPO A
0215105 JOURNAL 104TE0 STATES TREASURY BONDS
FIRM Al
5.375
REPO AGREEMENT
02/15105 JOURNAL LINTER ATE TREASURY 80NDS
FIRM A2
5.375 1
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
SYklifiCtiCtdie
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
°Herrin DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-10,944807 310000.00
-5.310.807 3.972.000 .00
-9.869.325 2.125.000.00
-8.000.000 9.087.000.00
10.000.000 11.762.500 AO
02/15105 JOURNAL UNITED TATES 1 SURY NOTE
FIRM Al
4.250 14
REPO AGREEMENT
-42.000.000 42.840.000.00
02/15105 JOURNAL LIMTEO SIAJESJREASURY NOTE
FITM 42
4.250 14
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
57,000.000 58.140.003.03
02/15105 DELIVERED LINiTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 01/31/2007 3.125
3.125.. 7
FIRM A2B
TERM EEMENT
-5.000.000 4.999.999 .99
027 0201,05:11:09 001 V872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIPS? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
29 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYMOCloCUSIP PANTRY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
02/15105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 15.000.000 15.075.000 .00
DUE 01131/2007 3.125
3,125 FITM
FITM A3 RERSi F T
02115+05 DEUVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -50.000.000 49.999.999.99
DUE 01131/2007 3.125
FITM A2A
3.125soi r
TERM EMENT
02/15/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS 3.777.07
DUE OZila 5.375
FITM A2
REPO I
02/15105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 1111111 13,436,80
DUE 4250
FITM A2
REPO I
02/15/05 INTEREST UNTIED STATES TREASURY NOTE 1,569.44
DUE 01!  3.125
FITM A26
RESALE
02/15/05 INTEREST UNTIED STATES TREASURY NOTE 15,694,44
DUE Ole 3.125
FITM A2A
RESALE
02/16/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP 10.944.807 310,000,00
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
5,410
FITM 30.2
TERM ENT
02/16!05 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP -10.944.807 310,000,00
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NumeER OR He
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
5.410
FITM 31.3
TERM ENT
027 03,0IDS:l 1:09 001 V872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MOST ORBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
30 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMENENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACDON DESORPTION SYMEICAGUSIP OUNNTITT DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
02/16(05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 22.100.000 2.601.000.00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.450
FILM Fi lmes TERM ENT
02/16/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN -22.100.000 2.601.000.00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.450
EOM 31.16
TERM ENT
02/16'05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CCAPeS10i09 MIK -13.817.056
SERIES 227 CLASS
FSITMMN AWAI
REPO
02/1695 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTO CORP#S10109 -5.921.595 1.285.000.00
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSITMXIN  laAI
REPO
02/1695 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CORPoSi wog MIK 9.869.325 2,125,000.00
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FS.000ITM F rA2
TERM MENT
02/16.05 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MI6 OCAPeS10109 9.869,325 2,156,000.00
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSITMMN R rA2
TERM MENT
02/16435 JOURNAL MATEO STATES TREASURY NOTE
ATM A2 MIK 42.000.000 42.840.000.00
4.250 14
(rip TERM REPO AGREEMENT
02/16/05 JOURNAL LIMTE0 TALES TREASURY NOTE INK -45.000.000 45.900.000 .00
FILM Al
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
4.250 14
REPO AGREEMENT
027 0101:05:11:09 001 van
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
31 cl ))
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACDON DESORPTION SYMEMICUSIP DUAARITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
02/16/05 INTEREST FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
DUE 03! 5,410
FITM 012
24.03
REPO I
02/16(06 INTEREST FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP 24.03
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
DUE 03!  6.410
FIN A3
REPO I
02/16)05 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL KIM ASSN EMI 7.025.69
SERIES 2004-S CLASS PS
DUE 02:1101 4.460
FIN AS
REPO I
02/16)05 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MI13 ASSN 7.025.69
SERIES 2004-S CLASS PS
DUE 02/1101 4.450
FITM A6
REPO I
02/16)05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPFES10t09 164.69
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE I 6.000
FIN A2
all
REPO I
02/16)0S INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORN/Mine MIS 334.18
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE I 5.000
FITM A2
IREPO
wo
02/16435 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE SIM 261.80
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER•00 February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER ON FIk
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
DUE I 1;40 4.260
FITM A2
REPO I
027 0101G5:11:09 001 van
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
32 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEnLEmENT Ma
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON ME/MCl/SIP "m DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
02/17/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP8S10109 -5.921,595I1Y
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
FSITMMN AllirAl
REPO
02/17105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP8S10109 5.921,595 1.285.000.00
SERIES 227 CLASS 0
5.000
FITM Fitle2
TERM ENT
02/17105 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP 10,944.807 310,000.00
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
5.410 2
FITM A4
TERM ENT
02/17+05 INTEREST FEDL HOME LOAN MTG OCAPPS10109 NMI 99.59
SERIES 227 CLASS 10
DUE IWO 5.000
ATM A2
REPO I
02/17,05 INTEREST FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP 48.05
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
DUE 031ll 5.410
RIM A4
REPO I
02/18105 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS
ATM jimAl -6.000.000 6,712,500.00
5.375 1
REPO AGREEMENT
02/18105 JOURNAL LIMTED TATS I SURY BONDS 8.000,000 9,087,000.00
ATM A2
5.375 1
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
02 18 05 JOURNAL UNITED SWAY NOTE 45,000.000 45.900.000.00
ATM A2
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEF000 February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER OR He
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
4.250 14
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
027 03,01,05:1 1:09 001 V872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
MIMI? OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
33 ci ).
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
scnumeil Tux
DAN DATE TV0C3ACSON DESORPTION SYMEICESCUSIP OIJANTIlY OMIT ;wow CREDIT AMOUNT
02/18/05 JOURNAL MTN) STATES TREASURY NOTE -30.000.000 29.475.000 AO
FITM Hip Al
4.000 15
REPO AGREEMENT
02/18/05 INTEREST UNiTE0 STATES TREASURY BONDS 1.807.30
DUE ODA, 5.375
FITM A2
REPO I
02/18/05 INTEREST utaTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE 3.060.00
DUE 11/111 4.250
FITM A2
REPO I
02/22/05 JOURNAL DICED ASURY BONDS
mu Al
-3.000.000 3,322.500 .00
5.375 31
REPO  AGREEMENT
02/22/05 JOURNAL UMTE0 ASuRY ECK'S 6.000.000 6,712,500.00
FITM A2
5.375 31
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
02/22/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -185.000.000 185.000.000.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000
FISH Rililarr
ENT TERM
m
02/22/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE EMI 195.000.000 194.756.250.00
DUE 12/31/2006 MOO
3.000 WIC6
FITM Al
RESALE T
02/22/05 INTEREST OWED STATES TREASURY BONDS 1.790.00
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
DUE 02/ 5.375
DUMB A5
REPO I
027 03,01G5:11:09 001 Y872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
ValCtLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
34 O
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEGLEMENT
DATE
02/22/05
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
INTEREST
DESERTION
UMTEO STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/31200E_III . ._3.000
IS
02/23/05 RECEIVED LIMTEO STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 01/31:2007 3.125
3.125 1.1)7
FILM Al
RESALE T
02/23/05 DELIVERED LINTS) STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 01/31/2007 3.125
3.1251.1r Em
FILM A4
TERM ENT
02/23105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 01/S 3.125
FILM A4
RESALE
SYMEIELGUSIP OUNGITY 003n ;wow
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD PEtruilly 1.2006
THROUGH FeoluNy 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
CREDIT AMOUNT
84.740,28
8.000.000 7,990,000.00
-15.000.000 16.075.000 .00
3.400.25
02/24/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000
FILM RIMIC2 m
TERM ENT
-195,000,000 194.758.250.00
02/24105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000 FILM
elkittl
RESALE
200,000,000 200.000.000.00
02/24105 INTEREST LIMITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE ISO 1.000
23,370.75
02/25/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MI6 ASSN
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 1110.
FILM Al
REPO
-3.929.997
027 0201005:11:09 001 Y1172
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YiDIMLY OMED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
35 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE DIANSACRON DESCRFRON RIME/MCl/SIP CUANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
02/2905 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN -1.380.809 1.000.000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
ATM Al
REPO
02/25/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 5.310807 3.963.000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
ATM A2
DUE I TRIS
TERM MENT
02/25105 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MI6 ASSN 3136FCBC9 3.378.46
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE I Jill MOO
ATM A2
REPO I
02/28105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN NMI 3.929,997
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
ATM A2
DUE I Ja i
TERM MENT
02/28105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MM ASSN -3239.592
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
NM  Al
REPO A
02/28/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL KIM ASSN -690.404 500 000.00
SERIES 346 CLASS 1
DUE 11
NM Al
REPO
02/28105 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN -13,375,837 9.696.000.00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
ATM Al
REPO
027 03,0L05:11:09 001 VE172
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
ValCtLY EMBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
SEMEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TFMNSACRON DESCRPRON SYMBCOJCUSIP "m DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
02/28/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL WO ASSN 13.375,83711Y 10.014,000 .00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
TERRARM RIIIIIM AZENT
02/28/05 INTEREST FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN 3136FAWE6 24 058,64
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
DUE Mill 0,000
FITM A2
REPO I
TOTAL S-1.178.191243.46 91.126.885.746.12
MISCELLANEOUS
DATE
ma OAT TROMSACTESAI
02/09105 JOURNAL
DESCRIPTION
04 TREASURY REBATE ARM
DENT AMOUNT CREPT NACLA1
30.973,04
02/09105 JOURNAL FNAAA-30YR(FNAAMOTO
SETL02/05
5500 DUE 02101/35
ABS NET 02/09/05
76.953,13
02/10/05 JOURNAL FNMA-30YR(FNMA)OTO 5.078,12
SETL02/05
5,000 DUE 02101/34
MBS NET 02/10/05
02/10,05 JOURNAL FNMA 30YR GM 35.937.50
SETT, 02/05
6,000 DUE 02101/35
MBS NET 02/10/05
02/14/05 JOURNAL JAN OS SPEC CLEARING FEES 2.300.00
027 OCTOLOST 1:09 001 Yen
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y onneo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
37 0
Transaction Detail (continued)
MISCELLANEOUS (continued)
DATE
MOAT TITMISACTOI DESCRIPTION DEBIT AMCW41 MAT AAIDUNT
02/15105 JOURNAL FNMA SYR(FNMA-I 5)07D 14,609.37
SETT.02/05
5.500 DUE 02101/20
TABS NET 02/15/05
TOTAL 4-79.253.13 $86.544.43
Trades Executed Pending Settlement
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCCUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AMBER On PIM
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
SETTLEMENT
DATE TRADE DATE "RAUSACTKIN CESCP pi3O% SYMBOLCUSP WWII" PIECE DENT AMOUNT CREDO AMOUNT
03101/05 02/28/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY BONDS -3.000.000,00 109,7226 3,297.915,88
05.375% FA 15
MA RITY
OVER REF # G659%0711
03/1 4/05 02/0995 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR. GTD 20.000.000.00 101.8242 20.364.843.75
SETT, 03,05
F 05.500%
57310000 BS
eatiates 02/17/05 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR. GTD 15.000.000.00 101.5585 15,233.789.06
SETT 03,05
F 05.500%
57360003 BS
03/1 0/05 02/0345 SOLD FNMA 30YR. GTD -10.000.000,00 101.5156 10.151,562 ,50
SETT, 03,05
- 05.500%
57710000 BS
027 0101,05:11:09 001 'e872
CLEARED 1HROuGH ITS
YAIOU.Y ORB.G0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
38 c?
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SETREMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
03/14105 02/10105 SOLD
03/I 4105 02/03105 BOUGHT
03/14/05 02/17105 BOUGHT
03/14105 02/10105 SOLD
03/14105 02/03105 BOUGHT
03/14105 02/09105 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
FNMA 301/1.010
SETT, 03105
pi psi 05.500%
57610000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.03/05
11011.1106,000%
57750000 BS
FNMA-30YR1FNMA)G1D
SETT.03/05
/11001005,000%
57300000 BS
FNMA 301RtFNMAIGID
SETT, 03 os imam osmen.
57670000 BS
FNMA 301F8FNMA) 010
SETT 03105
06,000%
57730000 BS
FNMA 9DYR1FNMA) 010
SETT 03105
06800%
57340000 BS
TOTAL
The chore Peons 4o nol apps in airy olhc. eaten o1 this slairntet
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD February 1.2005
THROUGH February 28.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAGER On File
LAST STATEMENT January 31.2005
SYMEIOLCUSP OJANTIP PRCE DEOIT AMOUNT CREPT AMOUNT
-10.000.000,00 101,6718 10,167.187 .50
10.000.000,00 99,4375 9.943.750 80
10.000.000,00 9%5429 9.954.296,88
-10.000.000,00 99,7382 9.973.828,13
20.000.000,00 103,0156 20803,125,00
-20.000.000.00 103,1875 20.637.500 80
378.099.804.89 554,227,994.01
027 0:110I105:11:09 001 9872
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y omeo SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVE GNMA GOVT BOND
VISIT OUR WEBSITE wswi.bearsteams.cOm
What's In This Statement
Financial Summary
Your Portfolio Holdings
Transaction Detail
Trades Not Yet Settled
Your Portfolio at a Glance
11111111111111111 I I
3 FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
4 0/0 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
7 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
26 STE B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
TOTAL VAWE OF SECURITIES THIS PERIOD 10,656,868
LONG ACCRUED INTEREST 107,032
NET CREDIT BALANCE 976,344
Market Value of Your Portfolio
Cash 8 Equwalent $976344
5732.186
NET EQUITY THIS PERIOD $11,740,244
NET EOUITY LAST STATEMENT 12,063,068
CHANGE SINCE LAST STATEMENT -322,824
There are no 'Stop Loss' orders or other pending buy
or sell open orders on file for your account.
Ned
Income
10.656.868
I $11.218594
Current market yak*
egm Last statements market value
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2035
ACCMIST NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
SIK TRY Tying a  TIOTHIMAND pwpons MESS rc4 "Eroded as a U. ex mliste
TNT ststerneC should be Maned for your records Su worm THIT for greaten rdormalpn
027 0201GS:07:16 001 vary
CLEARED 'THROUGH RS
WHOLLY OBAED SUBSIDIARY
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
2 oi 27
STATEMENT BACKER IS PRINTED ON THIS PAGE
027 02,01,05:07$5 001 V870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
3 c. 2?
Cash Flow Analysis
THIS PERSTO
Income Summary MS PEWS YEAR TO DATE
Opening Balance $732,186.31 U.S. Govt. Bond Int. 285.117.41 285,117.41
Govt. Agency Int. 655,330.03 655,330.03
Securities Sold 1,327,851,391.84 Corp. Bond Int. 130.177A4 130,177.44
Dividends/Interest 1,070,624.88 Reverse Repurchase Int. 235.427.49 235.427.49
Miscellaneous 4,687.50
Total $1,306,052.37 $1.306.052.37
Amount Credited $1.328.926,704.22 Bond Purchase Int. -589.389.51 -589,389.51
Securities Bought -1,327,991,635.74 Repurchase Int. Exp. -118.021.37 -118,021.37
Funds Withdrawn -72.724.00
Dividends/Interest Charged -589.389.51
Miscellaneous -28.796.88 Portfolio Composition
Amount Debited $-1.328.682,546.13 CashCash Equivalent 976.344
Fixed Income 10.656.868
Net Cash Activity 244.158.09
Closing Balance $976,344.40 Total $11.6331.
Cash Balance Summary
WINN° CLOSNO
Margin 732,186.31 976,344.40
Net Cash Balance $732.186.31 $976,344.40
027 02,01 ,05:07:55 001
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31. 2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER nusii3ER On FIk
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2000
Your Portfolio
Allocation
Cash & Equivalent,
8%
Uetivaed conees 0en,* debt bebnce ender seal
male vela, Ma slocatich reverter is de•ved
ewe Vo ebeol.te mere', value of f%/ palloo
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
INHOU.Y ORBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
4 c/ 2?
Your Portfolio Holdings
CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS
DESCDPION
CASH BALANCE
SrsilICLOSO MARKET ESTILIAIED CuRRENT OWNTiTY PiBCE VALUE ANNUAL iNCONE VELD
976.344
TOTAL CASH & CASH EQUIVALENTS 5974.344
FIXED INCOME
Government & Agency Obligations
DESCRPRON SIRSOLCUSP
ACV'
TYPE DUMMY PLACE IAARKET VALLE
ACCRUED
MEREST
ESTMATW
ANNUAL iNCOME
CURREN,
VELD IV
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP MRGN 15.029,420 9,5203 1.430.842 32.862 739.447 51.6792
SERIES 2530 CLASS SE
DATED DATE 10/11/02
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 02/1&2032 4,920%
FACTOR — .25049034
FEDERAL ROME LOAN MTG CORP MRGN 6.446.913 8,6637 558.539 12.951 291.400 52,1718
SERIES 2526 CLASS SI
DATED DATE 10/01/02
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 0'2/15/2032 4.520%
FACTOR — .25049033
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN MRGN 3.672.130 84.8828 3.117.007 3 37 0.0012
STRIP MTG SERIES 322 CL PO
DATED DATE 03/01/02
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 03/01/2032 .001%
FACTOR - 1.00000000
FECES& HOME WAN MTG CORP MRGN 12,935.618 &2178 1.063.020 25.987 584.690 55,0027
SERIES 2483 CL SL
DATED DATE 07/02/02
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 03/1512032 4.520%
FACTOR - .22424606
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER M.aER On File
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
027 0201,05D7:SS 001 "870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
INTIOU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
5 O 2?
Your Portfolio Holdings (continued)
Government & Agency Obligations (continued)
N:C" DESCDPnON SweCLCuSP nPt
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DATED DATE 04/30/03
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE 01/25/2033 4.470%
FACTOR — .56738039
Total Government& Agency Obligations
OLIANTITY
MRGN 13.791.178
ACCRUED PRICE MARKET VALUE !MEREST
8,1254 1.120.583 10.274
87288.991 $82,o77
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER AA.103ER On FIM
LAST STATEMENT DELETED& 31.2004
ESTIAMED CURRSVr ANNUAL WOW YELD NG
616.466 55,0130
52232.040
Corporate Bonds
DESCRP1ON SOMCLCUSP
FANNIE MAE CMG,SEIRIES 2003-13
S ROR-ItO FUR
DATED DATE 02/2503
BOOK ENTRY ONLY
DUE Oa/2512033 5,470%
FACTOR — .54744510
Total CorporateBonds
ACC' TYPE
MRGN
DUMMY
27.372,254
ACCOJED
PRICE IMRXET VALUE NTEFEST
12.3003 3.366.877 24.955
$3.166.877 $24.955
ESTIMATED
ANMJAL INCOME
1.497.262
$1.497.262
CURFENT
VELD PM
44,4704
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 510.656.868 $107.032 $3.729.302
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLOINGSACCRUED INTEREST 5107.032
YOUR PORTFOLIOHOLOINGSESTIMATED ANNUAL INCOME 5-3.729.302
YOUR PRICED PORTFOLIOHOLDINGS $11.633..
027 020105:07:55 001 Y870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIDALY OUS*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions
with Bear, Stearns& Co. Inc.outstanding as of date of statement
PURCHASE/ FIEFURCHASE PRICING PURCHASE RIM ACCRUED REPO CAONTRY
START DATE DATE RATE PAINCPAL INTEREST' (FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTION
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEF000 January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MAKER OR File
LAST sTATEmENT December 31.2004
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 01/13105 04/11105
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MEG ASSOC
2.860 -2.601,000 -3.926 -22.100,003 SEES 2004-5 CLASS P 4.4500 02/20/33
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 01/13/05 04/11/05 2.860 -11.902.000 -17.965 -30.000.000 SEES 329 CLASS PO 12/01/32
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIP
(REPO) 01/13/05 04/11/05 2.860 -6.406.000 -9.669 -30.000.000 SEES 353 CLASS 10 5.0000 07/01/34
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 01/19/05 02/18+05 2.700 -7.600.000 -7.410 -43.190.000
FHLMC- STRIP PRNCAPAL ONLY
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 01/28/05 02/2/3/05 2.790 -10.014.000 -3.104 -25.000.000 SEES 329 CLASS PO 12/01132
YOU SOLD FANNIE MAE STRIP
(REPO) 01/28+05 04/11/05 2.860 -7.351.000 -2.335 -35.000.000 SEES 353 CLASS 10 5.0000 07/01134
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 01/28+05 02/28+05 2.790 -1.199.000 -371 -6.810.000
FHLMC- STRIP PRINCIPAL
YOU SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MEG ASSOC
(REPO) 01/28+05 02/28+05 2.790 -500.000 -155 -4.300.000 SEES 2004-5 CLASS P 4.4500 0920/33
YOU PROVIDED GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MEG ASSOC
(MARGIN) 01/28+05 OPEN 0.000 -17.600.000 SEES 2004-5 CLASS P 4.4500 0920/33
YOU SOLD FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
(REPO) 01/28/05 02/2/3/05 2.790 -849.000 -263 -50.000.000 SEES 2488 CLASS SO 5.5200 03/15/32
YOU SOLD USER 3.6250 01/15/10
(REPO) 01/31/05 OPEN 2,420 -19.925.000 -1.339 -20.000.000
027 0201,05:07:55 001 Ya70
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YRIOU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
7 2?
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase Transactions (continued)
with Bear,Stearns& Co.inc.outstanding as of date of statement (continued)
PURCHASE/
START DATE
REPURCHASE
DATE
PRICING
RATE
PURCHASE PRIES
PRINCPAL
ACCRUED REPO
MEREST'
GUMMY
(FACE AMOUNT) CUSP DESCRIPTION
YOU SOLD
(REPO) 01/31/05 OPEN 2.170 -31.465.000 -1.896 -31.000,000
USTR 4,2500 11/15114
YOU SOLD FANNIEMAE STRIP
(REPO) 01/31/05 02/10/05 2.760 -8.409.000 -644 -20.959,779 SERIES 329 CLASS PO 1201,32
YOU BOUGHT
(REVERSE) 01/31/05 OPEN 1,930 176.220.000 9.447 176.000.000
USTR 3,0000 1213106
TOTAL REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS $176.220.000 $9.447
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERKO January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NURSER On File
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
TOTAL REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS 1-108.221.000 $-49.077
As Cl 214IPTOM <WO
Transaction Detail
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR CESCMPTION SYMBOLCUSiP GUMMY PRICE DEBT AMOUNT CREDO MOUNT
01107/05 01/06105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE 10,000,000 99,86719 0986.718,75
04.250% MN IS ACM *It 62,223.76
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0061006 Al
01107105 01/06105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE MEN 10.000.000 99.87109 9087,109.38
04.250% MN
0 MATURITY
15 ACCR, NIT, 62,223.75
GVER REF # G0071000 Al
AS OF 01106/05
027 0201 ,05D7:SS 001 •••870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
wilDtLY CAM,E0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
8 c12•
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/3N CESCRIPTION STIADOLICUSP oawrin PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT MEM AMOUNT
01/07/05 01/06/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE .40.000.000 99.69531 39.878.125 ,00
03.000% JD 30
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 23,204.42
GVER REF # G0061007 Al
01/07105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -114.994
STRIP MTG SERIES 322 CL PO
0.001 DUE 03/01/32
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 01-25-05
01/11105 01/10/05 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -15.000.000 99.58984 14.938.476 ,56
03.000% JO 30
MATURITY
ACCR, INT, 13.674.04
OVER REF # 00101017 Al
01/13/05 01/07105 BOUGHT FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN 16.314.621 80.34376 13.107,778 .31
SEFUES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
1/1.57450000 BS
01/13+05 01/07+05 BOUGHT FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN EMI 28.945.632 25.12500 7,272,590.12
SERIES 353 CLASS 2 ACM Mt 48,242.72 05.000%
57440000 BS
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 25TH
01/13+05 01/12+05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE MIK 10,000.000 100.12109 10,012,109.38
04.250% MN 15 ACCR, INT. 69,267.95
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G0121006 Al
01/13A)5 01/12/05 SOLD NITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -30.000.000 99.60938 29.882.812 .50
DUE 12/31+2006 03.000% JD 30 ACCR. INT. 32.320 SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS .44
I
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATELIER, PERIOD January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KUMMER On File
LAST STATEMENT December 31, 2004
IELD 3206 % TO MATURITY
GVER REF # G0125168 A3 wwEe
027 0201 05:07:55 001 V870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOM.? EIMS*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
01/18105
TRADE
DATE TRANSACT/3N
01/14105 SOLD
DESCRIPTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY MUTE
04.250% MN 15
0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G0141001 Al
01/18/05 01/14105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE
03.000% JD 30
MATURITY
OVER REF it G0141002 Al
01/18/05 01/14105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY N0TE
03.625% JJ 15
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0141003 Al
01/18(05 PRINCIPAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPitS02684
SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 02/01/32
PRIN RID 12-04 PM 01-15-05
REPO P 8I 0.0000
01/18105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL FINE LOAN MTG CORP
SERIES 2483 Q. SL
4.520 DUE 03/15132
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 01-15-05
01/18105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP
SERIES 2530 CLASS SE
4.920 DUE 02/15/32
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 01-15-05
STMEIOLCUMP OVAMITY
-9.000.000
PRICE
100.20313
ACCR, INT.
,itkl CA,
FINANCa TRUST CO INC
STATEmENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMER On File
LAST STATEMENT December 31, 2004
DEBIT AMOUNT GRECO' AMOUNT
9,018.281 .25
67,624.31
-15.000.000 99.57031
ACCR. INT.
14.935,546 ,88
22.375.69
20.000.000
ACCR, 1L
99.61719 19.923.437.50
6.008.29
381.961.00
-470.084
-498.652
01/18105 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP
SERIES 2526 CLASS Si
4.520 DUE 02115/32
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 01-I 5-05
-213.898
01/19105 01/18105 SOLD UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
04.250% MN 15
0 MATURITY
GVER RE? # G0181001 Al
-9.000.000 100.12500
ACCR, INT.
9.011.250.00
68.680.94
021 0201 0507:55 001 .870
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
valOLLY ORBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
10 c! 27
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
01/19105 01/18/05 SOLD
01/19105 01/18105 BOUGHT
01/20/05 12/07104 CANCEL SELL
01,20.05 12/15/04 BOUGHT
01/20+05 12/07+04 SOLD
01/2005 12/15+04 CANCEL BUY
0 I '2005 12/0704 BOUGHT
Dues P1104
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.000% JO 30
0 MATURITY
GVER REF ft G0181005 Al
$0.100..00$-P OuANTir, PRCE
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PEF000 January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
*scow! NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On File
LAST STATEMENT December 31, 2004
DEW AMOUNT OEM AMOUNT
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.625%11 15
0 MATURITY
GVER REF P G0181009 Al
ONMA-30YRONMATOTO
SETT:01105
57310000 BS
AS OF 12/07104
TO C/3. PREVIOUS SELL
ONMA-30YRTGNMATGTO
)00000as591.01/05 0:0000:0
BS
GNmA-30vR(GMAA)GTO
SETT.01.85
• • 05,500%
57310000 BS
ON MA-30YR(GMAA)GTO
SE T.01105
7020000 BS
AS OF 12/15/04
TO C/3. PREVIOUS BUY
ONMA-30YRONMATOTO
SETT.011105
57780000 BS
.16,000.000 99,52344
ACCR, INT.
15.923,750,00
25,193,37
NIS 20.000.000 99,48828 19.897.656.25
ACM, M. 8.011.05
7.000.000 101.96875 7.137.812,50
7.000.000 102.35156 7.164.609,38
-7.000.000 101.96875 7.137.812,50
VIII -7.000.000 102.35156 7,164.609,38
10,000.000 103.54688 10.354.687.50
027 020I ,05:07:55 001 .870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OBBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
11 o
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
01,20/05
TRADE
DATE mAtisAcnoti
12;i5 .04 CANCEL SELL
OESCRIPTION
ONMA-30YR(GNIAAJOTO
SETT.01//05
7030000 BS
AS OF 12/15/04
TO CM. PREVIOUS SELL
01,20/05 12/07104 CANCEL BUY GNMA-30TR(GNMAIGTO
SETT.01//05
57780000 BS
AS OF 12/07/04
TO CM. PREVIOUS BUY
01/2005 12/15/04 SOW GNMA-30YRONMAJOTO
SETT.01/A35
1.0.5 06.0"7030000 BS
01/21,05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN PAM CORP#S02684
SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 02/01/32
ADJUST POSITION
01/2905 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
STRIP MTG SERIES 322 CL PO
0,001 DUE 03/01/32
PRINCIPAL PAYMENT 01-25-05
01/2905 PRINCIPAL FANNIE MAE ONO/SERIES 2003-13
S RCR-10 FLTR
5.582 DUE 03/25/33
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 01-25-05
01.25,05 PRINCIPAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
4.582 DUE 01/25/33
PRINCIPAL REDUCTN 01-25-05
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUNSER DII File
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
STIABOLCUSP OWARITY PRICE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDI A/lOcter
10.000.000 103.59375 10.359.375.00
-10.000.000 103,54688 10.354.687.50
.10.000.000 103.59375 10,359,375.00
-1
INININ 114.994.05
MIN -610.357
NMI -307.521
027 02,0I 005:07:5S 001 .870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
leni0M.Y Oune0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
12 r!
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT
DATE
01/28,05
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTOR
01/26105 BOUGHT
DESORPTION
FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SEAMS 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
IMI.58050000 BS
01/28/05 01/2645 BOUGHT FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
illit s05.000%
8060000 BS
ACCRUES ON 1ST. PAYS ON 2501
01/28/05 01/27/05 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 11/1512014 04.250% MN IS
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS
YIELD 4,224 % TO MATURITY
OVER REF V G0272927 A3 ri ViE8
01,31105 01/27/05 BOUGHT FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
STRIP
00111 1,57200000 BS
01,31105 01/2645 SOLD GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-2 CLASS S8
04,720%
7450000 BS
SY/ABOLICUSIP OUPPRTIY
13,595,517
PRICE
82.03125
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUVT NUMBER
TAXPAYER IMAGER On File
LAST STATEMENT December 31, 2004
DEBIT AMOUNT
11.152.572,95
GREGG AAIDUNr
33.769.904
ACCR,
24.21875 8.178.648,71
126.637,14
10.000.000 100.20313
ACCR, NT.
10.020.312.50
86.878.45
11.398.361 8196875 9.343.094.60
-39.801.752 9,00000
ACCR, INT,
3,582,157.76
78276,79
01,31105 01,28105 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NNE
04.250% MN IS
MATURITY
GVER REF # G0281002 Al
01,31105 01/2845 BOUGHT UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.000% JD 30
. % 0 MATURITY
GVER REF # G0281000 Al
9.000.000 100.90234
ACCR, INT,
9.081.210.94
81.360,49
15.000.000
ACCR, WT,
99.58594 14.937.890.63
38.535,91
027 02010507:55 001 .870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAIOU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
13 c! 27
Transaction Detail (continued)
INVESTMENT ACTIVITY (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRAusg,Bon
01/31/05 01/28/05 SOLD
j.ESLF pno”
UNITED STATES TREASURY 1431E
r 03,625% JJ 15
. MATURITY
G.ER REP tt G•281001 Al
STIUBOLGUEV OVANTITY PRCE
-20.000.000 99,76563
ACCR, INT.
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
AGLOW! NUMBER
TAXPAYER isafuSER On File
LAST STATEMENT December 31, 2004
DEW AMOUNT CREDIT MOM
19.953,125 ,00
32.044,20
TOTAL 1,188,507,003.91 $193.000.39158
DEPOSITS AND WITHDRAWALS
DATE TFONSACTCN DESORPTION DEEM AMOUVT CREDIT AMOUNT
01,05,'05 FND WIRED MDA# GY154679 FNDS WIRED TO 72.724,00
FLEET NATIONAL BMW
AC2387604020 NY#35491
TOTAL $.-72,724.00
INTEREST
DATE DESORPTION STIABOLDLISIP OUANTITY RATE DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
01/18/05 FEDERAL NOME LOAN MTO CORP 4.5200 51.360,60
SERIES 2483 CL SI.
DUE 03/15/2032 4.520
INTEREST PAYMENT 01-15.05
01/18/05 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP 5,5200 54.201,35
SEEMS 2488 CLASS SO
DUE 03/15/2032 5.520
INT R/D 12-04 P/0 01-15-O5
REPO P & I 5.5975
01/18/05 FEDERAL WA* LOAN MTO CORP 4,9200 64.667)5
SERES 2530 CLASS SE
DUE 02/15/2032 4.920
INTEREST PAYMENT 01-15-05
027 02,01,05:07:55 001 '.1170
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
14 o
Transaction Detail (continued)
INTEREST (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER MASER (Nine
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2000
DATE DESCRIPTION SYMEICIJCUSIP DOWNY RATE ITN DEBIT AMOUNT CREDO AMOUNT
01/18105 FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP 4.5200 25,519.23
SERES 2526 CLASS SI
DUE 02/15/2032 4.520
INTEREST PAYMENT 01-15-05
01/18105 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL TATO ASSN 4.7930 166998.04
SERES 2004-2 CLASS SB
DUE 01/16/2034 4.793
INT RID 01-05 PA) 01-16-05
REPO P I 4.7931
01/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL WO ASSN 4.5400 82.855.00
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4.540
INT RID 12-04 PM 01-20-05
REPO P SI 4.5400
01/20/05 GOVERNMENT NATIONAL TATO ASSN 4.5400 83.611.67
SERES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/20/2033 4.540
INT RFD 12-04 PA 01-20-05
REPO P d I 4.5400
01/25105 FANNIE K1AE CMO/SERIES 2003.13 5.5820 130.177.44
S RCR-VD RTR
DUE 03/25/2033 5.582
INTEREST PAYMENT 01-25-05
01/25/05 FEDERAL NATIONAL NM ASSN 4.5820 53.839.40
SERIES 2003-49 CLASS SW
DUE 01/25/2033 4.582
INTEREST PAYMENT 01-25-05
TOTAL $707.230.6e
027 020105:07:55 001 V870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
VOICtLY ORTNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
15 c!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS
with Bear,Stearns& Co. Inc.
SETTLEMENT TRACE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTCN SYMEICIJCUSIP awn" DEBIT ;wow CREDIT AMOUNT
01/07/05 JOURNAL LIMTEO STATES TREASURY NOTE -20.000.000 20.050.000.00
FONT crimp Al
4.250 14
REPO AGREEMENT
01/07/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE INIIIIII -75.000.000 75.000.000 .00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000 DUE 12/31/06
RIM F3660898 A2
TERM RESALE AGREEMENT
01/07/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE IIIIIIII 115.000.000 115.000.000 .00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3Flar DOIAI
RESALE T
01/07/05 INTEREST MATED STATES TREASURY NOTE IIIIIIII 25.416.67
DUE 12131/2006 .000
F3660898
INTEREST
01110105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG COAH/S02684 -11,512,346 8.628.000.00
SERIES 218 CL PO
FILM Al
DUE Ojai.
REPO
01/10/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MIG OC6P4S02684 11.512,346 9.478.000 .00
SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 0
FILM A2
TERM ENT
01/10105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 21.900,000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.540 DUE 02/20/33
FILM F3573210 A2
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
01/10105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN -21.900.000 500.000.00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERICO January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2035
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER On File
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
4FRA4.540 AI
REPO A
027 020105:07:55 001 V870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
INTIOU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
16 a 2?
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESORPTION SYMEMICUSIP CVANTITY DEBIT AMOUNT 01/10105 INTEREST FEDL NOME LOAN MT0
OUIPeS02684 53,550.70 SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 07".. 0.000 ATM A2 REPO I 01/11105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE DUE 12)31/2006 3.000 3.000 FITM 1111(21C 
RESALE T 01/11105 RECEIVED UNITED STATES
TREASURY NOTE DUE 12)31/2006 3.000 3,000FITM 4111111106A 1 A RESALE M iltregIT
01/11.'05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE DUE 12131/2006 3.000 3.000 FITM AIB RESALE 01/11.'05 DELIVERED UNITED 
STATES TREASURY NOTE DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3,000 FILM JWA2 TERM e EMENT 01/11/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE DUE 12i3.1.2.OD6_ _3.000 Fir III01/13105 
JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL 1.110 ASSN SERIES
329 CLASS PO DUE 01)01,33 STRIP FILM yip Al REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005 THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER TAXPAYER NLAIBER On Rile LAST STATEMENT December 31.2000
CREDIT AMOUNT
30,000.000 29.999.999 .99
50.000.000 49.999.999.99
50.000.000 49.999.999.99
-116.000.000 115.000.000.00
25,491.67
.16,314.621 11.902.000 .00
027 02,01,05:07:S5 001 .870

╭──────────────────────────────────── Page 321, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────────────╮
│ OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT —                                                            │
│                                                                                            │
│ BEAR Bear, Stearns & Co. Inc. i =m                                                         │
│ STEARNS | ene His coe                                                                      │
│                                                                                            │
│ 16 ae                                                                                      │
│ Transaction Detail (continued)                                                             │
│ ( ) —aw ne                                                                                 │
│ "HYPAVER NUMBER On Fle                                                                     │
│ REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS | (continued ast srarewent December 91,2004 │
│ ovrons INTEREST EDL HOME LOAN MTG CORPHSOREES '53.50,70                                    │
│ ‘ont ti08 ‘STATES TREASURY NO} ” '36:000,600 25388, 565 55                                 │
│                                                                                            │
│ DUE 12312008 3,000                                                                         │
│ 5.300                                                                                      │
│                                                                                            │
│ 3:000                                                                                      │
│                                                                                            │
│ ny                                                                                         │
│ <                                                                                          │
│                                                                                            │
│ ‘STATES TREASURY NOI '$6.000,000 48 338,585 55                                             │
│                                                                                            │
│ ours                                                                                       │
│ DUE 12312008 3,000                                                                         │
│ 5.300                                                                                      │
│ Fin’ ny                                                                                    │
│ call                                                                                       │
│ ‘ont ti08 ‘ELIE; ‘STATES TREASURY NO} ” "178,000,600 195 '660,000-60"                      │
│                                                                                            │
│ DUE 12312008 3,000                                                                         │
│ 5.300                                                                                      │
│                                                                                            │
│ Fin                                                                                        │
│ TERM                                                                                       │
│                                                                                            │
│ Ey                                                                                         │
│                                                                                            │
│ iain                                                                                       │
│ i                                                                                          │
│                                                                                            │
│ ours “OUaNAL areas estes “i'803'000 "00"                                                   │
│ SERIES 929 CLASS PO                                                                        │
│ Bozownies                                                                                  │
│ sine                                                                                       │
│                                                                                            │
│ oa                                                                                         │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
17 C! 27
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEmENT TRADE
DATE DATE nvecMCnON DESCRencti
01/13105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL LIM ASSN
SERIES 2004-2 CLASS SB
4.7933.4
FITM A2
TERM / MENT
01/13/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MM ASSN
SERIES 2004-2 CLASS SB
4.793 WI
FITM Al
REPO A
01/I 3105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL KIM ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
ORTm.540 Ditaire33 Az
TERM RortTMENT
01/1305 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MM ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.540
FIRE 11.1
REPO A
01:13,05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.540
FITM
REPO A
01/13/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4, 0FI V 033 A 3
REPO A
01/13/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000
FITM B1
REPO A
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PER100 January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2000
SYMP./Q/51P OMMITIN COON AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
40,307,282
MIS -40.307.282 2,830.000.00
EMI 22.100.000 2,500,000.00
-22.100.000 2.601.000.00
EMI 22.100.000 2.601.000.00
Mill -22.100.000 2 601.000.00
-28,945.632 6,406.000,00
027 02,01 ,05G7:55 001 '.870
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
YAICU.Y OMBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
18 ul V
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
sEntEmetir
DAN
01/13/05
Gum
DATE
01/13/05
01/13/05
01/13105
01/13/05
01/13105
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On He
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
TVOC3ACRON DESORPTION SYMeCtocusie MAMMY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDO AMOUNT
JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 20.000.000 20,050.000 .00
FITM pig A2
4,250 14
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
JOURNAL WITTED STATES TREASURY NOTE -30.000.000 30.150.000 .00
FITM Al
4.250 4
REPO AGREEMENT
DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -30.000.000 29.999.999.99
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000
FITM FINCALC
TERM e ENT
DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -50.000.000 49.999.999.99
DUE 12/3112036 3.000
3.000FlarE6
FITM A2A
TERM e EMENT
DELIVERED LIMTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE -50.000.000 49.999.999.99
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3,000
TA FIT A2B
TERM EMENT
FM1r
RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 160,000,000 160.000.000 .00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000
FITTA Al
RESALE
01/13105 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02:111 4.540
FITM A2
REPO I
3.987.50
01/13105 INTEREST LIMITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE AO. 4.250
M A2 FIT
REPO I
5.719.82
027 meiVS:07:55 ROI '.870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
19 nr
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMOIT
DATE
01/13/0S
TRADE
DATE TRNISACRON
INTEREST
DESCRPTICH
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 11 10 3.000
ATM A2C
RESALE
01/13105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
DUE 12/W 3.000
ATM A2A
RESALE
OVANTITy DEBIT ;wow
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NLAISER On FIk
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
CREDIT AMOUNT
3.183.33
5,305.55
01113/05 INTEREST
01/18105 JOURNAL
0N18,[05 JOURNAL
01/18/05 JOURNAL
01/18/05 JOURNAL
Oil SUS DELIVERED
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 5,30.5.6.5
DUE 12/W1f#, 3.000
ATM A2B
RESALE
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL EGG ASSN
SERIES 2004.5 CLASS PS
4.540
FITA4 *WI
REPO A
-21.900.000
GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN 21.900.000 500.000.00
SERIES 2004-S CLASS PS
4.540 Oillia33
FITM A2
TERM RIlint iMMENT
UNITED ASuRY NOTE -21.000.000 21.157.500.00
ATM Al
4.250 14
REPO AGREEMENT
UNITED SURY NOTE 30.000.000 30.150.000.00
ATM i42
4.250 14
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -160.000.000 160.000.000.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000
ATM Jett
TERM EMENT
027 020105:07:55 001 Y870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
WHOLLY OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
20 c!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEMEMENT WADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION MERVIN:RI STMOCCCUSIP DVANilie MIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
01/18/05 RECEIVED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 175,000.000 175.000.000.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000
FILM WI
RESALE T
01/18105 JOURNAL UNITED TATES TREASURY NOTE -20.000.000 19.875.000.00
FILM Al
3.625 / 10
REPO AGREEMENT
01/18105 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 293.33
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
DUE 02/0 4.540
FILM A2
REPO I
01/18105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 8.006.50
DUE 11:1111. 4.250
ATM A2
REPO I
01/18/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 44,000,00
DUE ISO 1000
01/19115 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN MTG CCAPPS02684 -1.567.981
SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 0
FILM Al
REPO:lir
01/19.'05 JOURNAL FEDL /CAE LOAN MTG COAH/S02684 -9.944.364 7,600,000.00
SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 0
FONTlair Al
REPO A
01/1945 JOURNAL FEDL NOME LOAN 1410 CORPNS02684 11,512.346 8.628.000 .00
SERIES 218 CL PO
li/14FIT402/1 1,2
TERM RIML IMMENT
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2035
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER On FOP
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2000
027 0207 0507:55 001 •.'870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
21 c!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NumBER On Ale
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE WiNSACRON DESCRPTICR SYMEICIAUSIP WANTin DEBIT ;wow CREDIT AMOUNT
01/19/05 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -12.000.000 12.120.000.00
ATM pig Al
4.250 14
REPO AGREEMENT
01/15105 JOURNAL LISTED TATE T SURY NOTE Mir 21.000.000 21.157.500.00
FITM A2
4.250 14
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
01119 x05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -175.000.000 175,000400.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3.000
ATM 31162 m
TERM ENT
01/19435 RECEIVED MATED STATES TREASURY NOTE 191.000.000 191.000.000.00
DUE 12+31/2006 3.000
3.000
FITM .0121
RESALE T
01/19:05 JOURNAL LISTED TALE TREASURY NOTE 20.000.000 19.875.000 .00
ATM A2
3.625 ,10
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
01/19005 JOURNAL UNITED ASURY NOTE -40.000.000 39.750.000 .00
ATM Al
3,625 r10
REPO  AGREEMENT
01/1905 INTEREST FEOL HOME LOAN MID CORP#S02684 5.694.48
SERIES 218 CI PO
DUE Oil. 0.000
ATM A2
REPO I
01/19,05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 1.057.88
DUE 11/ 4250
ATM A2
REPO I
027 020105:07:55 001 Y870
CLEARED 114ROuGH ITS
wisCt13 CMT,*0 SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
=Pm 22
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASE AND REVERSE REPURCHASE TRANSACTIONS (continued)
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATELIER, PEF000 January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2035
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
EEMEMENI TFPOE
DALE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTION SYMIKLCVSIP OUPARITif DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
01/19/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 6,076,39
DUE 12/3,L2GOL •_3.000
01/19105 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 1MM 955.10
DUE 01/111, 3.625
FITMF
REPO INr
01/28/05 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG COAP#S02684 1.567,981
SERIES 218 CL PO
DUE 0
FITM 31111 AA2
TERM ENT
01/28105 JOURNAL FEDL HOME LOAN MTG CORP#502684 -1.567,981 1,199,000 .00
SERIES 218 Cl. PO
DUE 021
FITM Al
REPO A
01/28105 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTG CORP IT III.304
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
5.520R.1132
FITM A2
TERM MENT
01/28/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP IT al.304 849,000.00
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
5.520 ilt2
FITM A
RESALE T
01/28/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP .11...304 849.000.00
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
5,520 Clin
01/28/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL HOME LOAN MTO CORP 3C4 849.000.00
SERIES 2488 CLASS SO
5,5203.32
FILM AI
REPO
021 020105:07:55 001
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
23 cIv
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRMISAGMON DESCRPOON SAleClocusie OUAMITY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
01/28/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -13.595.517 10.014.000 .00
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01/01/33
STRIP
FITM Al
REPO
Ansi
01/28 05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN INNS 21,900.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.450
FITM 31WE2
TERM ENT
01/28/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MO ASSN EMI -17,600.000
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.450
FIRE Al
REPO
01/28/05 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTG ASSN -4.300.000 500.000.00
SERIES 2004-5 CLASS PS
4.450
FITM 110.1
REPO A
01/28/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MTG ASSN -33.769.904 7.351.000.00
SERIES 353 CLASS 2
5.000 li
FITM A r l
REPO A
01/28+05 JOURNAL LINiTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE 12,000.000 12.120.000.00
FITM A2 ell.
4.250 / 14
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
01/28/05 JOURNAL LIMTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE -22,000.000 22.247.500 .00
FITM Jim Al
4.250 14
REPO AGREEMENT
01/28/05 INTEREST LINiTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE 5.679.57
DUE I ling& 4,250
FILM A2
REPOT i
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUmSER On FOS
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
027 02,01,05:07:S5 001 Y870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPRON SYMOCIAUSIP DUMMY DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
01/31/05 JOURNAL FEDERAL NATIONAL MKT ASSN -11.398.361 8.409.000 AO
SERIES 329 CLASS PO
DUE 01101/33
STRIP
FITM Al
REPO
01/31105 JOURNAL GOVERNMENT NATIONAL MTO ASSN 39,801.752 2.830.000.00
SERIES 2004-2 CLASS SB
0.720
FITM 31.2
TERM ENT
01/31105 JOURNAL UMTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE 22.000.000 22.247.500 AO
FITM pig A2
0.250 / 14
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
01/31105 JOURNAL UMTE0 STATES TREASURY NOTE -31.000.000 31.465.000 .00
FITM Hip Al
0250 , 14
REPO AGREEMENT
01/31/05 RECEIVED OWED STATES TREASURY NOTE NMI 176.000.000 176,220,000.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3FITMJ:1°Ci 1 W A
RESALE T
01/31/05 DELIVERED UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -191.000.000 191.000.000.00
DUE 12/31/2006 3.000
3,000
AI FIT FIWA2
TERM EMENT
01/31/05 JOURNAL UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE -20.000.000 19.925.000)30
FITM Al
3.625 , 10
REPO  AGREEMENT
01,31,{05 JOURNAL UNITED ATE TREASURY NOTE 40,000.000 39.750.000.00
FITM A2
3.625 .10
TERM REPO AGREEMENT
027 020T 0507:&S 001 •.'870
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER OR Pile
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2000
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
25 c!
Transaction Detail (continued)
REPURCHASEAND REVERSE REPURCHASETRANSACTIONS (continued)
SEnLELENI TAME
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRPTION SYMEICIAUSIP OUNNIN DEBIT AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
01,31/05 INTEREST GOVERNMENT NATIONAL Mkt ASSN 4.046,90
SERIES 2000-2 CLASS SB
DUE 01311.1 0.720
FRM A2
REPO I
01/31/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 3.633.76
DUE I I1 0.250
ATM A2
REPO I
01/31/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE EMI 120,648.33
DUE 12/.0 .000
01/31/05 INTEREST UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE 25,395.83
DUE 01:110 3.625
FRM A2
REPO I
TOTAL 3-1.140.074.021.34 31.135.214.427.46
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERK* January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2035
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER NUMBER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2000
MISCELLANEOUS
DATE
'MAT TPANSACTO1 DESCRIPTCN DEBT AMON, STEM AMOLter
01/19/05 JOURNAL DEC 04 SPEC CLEARING FEES 2.000.00
01/19/05 JOURNAL GMAA-30YFt(ONMA)GTO 26,796.88
SETT.01/05
5.500 DUE 01115/35
MBS NET 01/19/05
01/20/05 JOURNAL GAMA-30YR(GNMA)GTD 4,687,50
SETT.01//05
6.000 DUE 01/15/35
MBS NET 01/20/05
TOTAL S-28.796.88 84.687.50
027 02,01,05:07:55 001 2870
CLEARED THROUGH ITS
YAICU.Y OWNED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns 8 Co. Inc.
26 c? 27
Trades Executed Pending Settlement
SETTLEMENT
DATE
TRADE
DATE TRANSACTION
02/01/05 01/31105 SOLD
02/10/05 01/20105 BOUGHT
02/10+05 01/11105 SOLD
02/10105 01/18105 SOLD
02/10105 01/20105 BOUGHT
02/10105 01/20105 BOUGHT
02/10/05 01/20,105 CANCEL BUY
DESCRPTION
UNITED STATES TREASURY NOTE
03.126% JJ 31
0 MATUFUTY
GVER REF # G0311009 Al
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.02/06
67390000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)G1D
SETT.02/06
(16.500%
67220000 BS
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT.02/06
67000000 BS
FNMA-3cna(FNItIA)G1D
SETT 02/05
05.000%
57000000 BS
AS OF 01120/06
FNMA-30YR(FNMA)GTD
SETT,02 05
0.100005.000%
57000000 BS
FNMA-30YRIFNMA)G1D
SETT.02/05
101.1105.000%
57000000 BS
AS OF 01/20/05
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERM January 1.2005
THROUGH January 31.2005
ACCOUNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER 'RAISER On File
LAST STATEMENT 0000MDEI 31.2004
ST/Mel:GUS* OJAArrilY PACE DESK AMOUNT CREDIT AMOUNT
-15.000.000,00 99.6875 14.964.419 .89
10.000.000 p0 101,7304 10.173.046 p8
-10.000.000,00 101,2500 10.125,000 ,00
-10.000.000.00 101.5156 10.161,562 ,50
10.000.000.00 99.6523 9.965.234.38
10.000.000.00 99.6523 9.965.234.38
10.000.000,00 99.6523 9.965.234.38
027 020105:07:55 001 V870
CLEARED THRouGH ITS
INNOU.Y OmBED SUBSIDIARY
BEAR
STEARNS
OFFICE SERVICING YOUR ACCOUNT
Bear. Stearns & Co. Inc.
27 c? 27
Trades Executed Pending Settlement (continued)
SETTLEMENT TRADE
DATE DATE TRANSACTION DESCRFIX3N
02/10105 12/16+04 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 02/05
57320000 BS
02/10105 01/11105 BOUGHT FNMA 30YR GTO
SETT. 02105
~ 06.000%
57210000 BS
02/10815 12/30814 SOLD FNMA 30YR GM
SETT, 0205
1.0106.000%
57220000 BS
02/15+05 12/30104 BOUGHT FNMA 15YRtFNMA 15)3TD
SETT,02 05
57230000 BS
02/15/05 12/16104 SOLD FNMA.15TRIFNMA-15,0TO
SETT,02.05
F 05.600%
57330000 BS
FINANCIAL TRUST CO INC
STATEMENT PERIOD January 1.2006
THROUGH January 31.2005
AccouNT NUMBER
TAXPAYER KAISER On Pile
LAST STATEMENT December 31.2004
STMOD-CUSP OJANTin PRICE DEMI AMOUNT CREPT RAMO
10.000.000.00 103.0312 10.303.125.00
20.000.000.00 103.0312 20.606.250 .00
-10.000.000,00 102.9843 10.298,437,50
11.000.000.00 102.9765 11.327.421.88
-11.000.000,00 103.1093 11.342.031 .25
TOTAL $72.340.312.52 $66.836.685.52
The chore Fads M nol room m se oiler semon oi iler stommtet
End of Statement
027 0201.06:07:65 001 M970
EFTA00005386 (Jmail)
 [misc] heavily redacted photo album, lot of photos of girls
(inferred date: 2006-01-01)
heavily redacted photo album, lot of photos of girls
╔══════════ new names in next file ═╗
 NES LLC [epstein] Epstein company 
╚═══════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00006069 (Jmail)
 [money] W-2 tax form issued for <REDACTED> employee whom Epstein paid $185,323
(date: 2006-01-01)
W-2 tax form issued for <REDACTED> employee whom Epstein paid $185,323
EFTA00006100 (Jmail)
 [misc] Palm Beach Police fax machine activity log 2005-12-28 to 2006-01-04
(inferred timestamp: 2006-03-29 14:36:47)
Palm Beach Police fax machine activity log 2005-12-28 to 2006-01-04
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                    Joscha Bach [academia] cognitive science / AI research 
                  Western Union [business] international money transmitter 
 Alfredo Rodriguez [employee] Epstein's butler, stole Epstein's black book 
                        Janusz Banasiak [employee] Epstein's house manager 
      Juan Alessi [employee] Epstein's live in house manager in Palm Beach 
                       Haley Robson [girls] recruited by Epstein at age 16 
                   Joseph Recarey [government] Palm Beach Police detective 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01333100 (Jmail)
 [government] Palm Beach Police interview of Haley Robson and other victims, see quote: "He told her the younger the better"
(date: 2006-05-01)
'DOTSumby
/ L I T T sl i t
ARREST / NOTICE TO APPEAR I MEM 3 Request lot ~ant
animas Referral Avon 2 N T A 4 Raquesi la Cope
r1 3 3,..onir F---,,...„ OAI Wes
r• Awl 5 I 0 i 0 1 6 i 0 i 0
AWAY Nom
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
ACIONY RAM Nowbec IN.TAI nay)
716H i 14 1 I I_ 1 111 1)
I Weere., SI ,  iniany nio  0J kasdenolislar OS Orafer01 to Pe AY OA Tragic Gerfamearrx 0 t Ore
I Weapon Soled
EMIR Twa
Mricie
Oewence , -......_ 1 /wallas (ANNA (Wore Nan* 44 Bosneael
1:13 °115 "g ar t i  1±, -"ten tat rt\a
InCkna I
One oi ANS fr .. Cl. Anon 80Caing Ogle Ilcalng TM AN dM Ja1111M LOCAIOn M µaye
Name (Last Fr* M4310 . (Nam. DOB. Sot Sac v. Lie I
Race a., OeNOI OM (.:)
r.....,v d, : =1=1 \ P4 -I" t t 7 t CA. it / SSW  Wnar .
t.72f,„2- 1 4. C,
Eye Cow
1- 4 ,:t.
NarCcOar
r,,11. , )
Completion
t ile '. r  1 ,Sc.', IMO; Tanoos Uralue Physical haat Goes, 13,pa. onaQoa)
..
r  Sins I Flavor
= tintenc• 6 § I LDillYdrencw 0 o Local Address (Yew. Ao Mat eo (CNN (SUS) (2.2) Z A!
Perna
( )
Posdarda Typo
Cry 3 %ad. 2 Carney 4 Ox of SSMCa a PecmerworAdana ISVINI. An Mn .' )  (C44 ) (SINN (Zvi
D ‘ it. - -• • .7.1 e: " :: • e " V \I 1% '
Phone
( )
AdcgesS Sauta
Bursas au I'S INN RAN
at Norte. Stale I Wrap
44
Placa& fwet OK Sine) O a.>har
fo 00 /P:dg 41  N• 414 4. 4. AIM. learsjillilliMPM Su Dale a Br:. - 0 I Masted 3 *coy OA AI L . 4 LIAOrneano,
5 Arvenia Co4N44wciini NN. Gast Jam lAddN) Woe Omni ann i Amsted 3 To," lit AI Lip 4 Arsciwnwo
5 ann.*
Iire r CusxsnQ  Name (Lull (Fill) (Meaty AnIONYA
§
IMO,*
C I Appals* (Sem AN Wand.) IOW 191.4) Rot &dram Phone
( I
TOT JAC Dale Time
The stove gins was poled try Odoleedent Wier 000•Afaccs Pawls The Old and taw OWN. Ma Rid Sabo. Anemias neap the An•Me 
Cain Gehl 10II (Moe* 355.2S2S) !Named
dany charge of acblvaa
0 Yge. OY !Meta) 0 Ma Odayded r".Preview CaSw? IDeetnploe
Ow OW
el Ropey Wu* el Roomy
Z 00,1 N. i

R. R.5  II Capone ,  M
Produce anti. h io pinglEPO 8 AMY M P. raphiwn ialat C Crain U Ur knoan
7 One, P P9s$444
I  Ur
4 A A tisitat E Halal ai = n
°coats Sinus None! VCIaloan OAD Omica EAHCAPON.
a,- , Lr ...‘ • i .. , :...7. C)41.J rj, ,..A ? -). /IVO- 44.
i 000/neSik
"nitt.«
"Wan
ii t b i-1 1.1 Q.  I It ) ) . ,
V •
dm , Ada rm. ty,
KJ i--.)
Annual / UM
r ira_L ,:f *: 9 ,) Warrare / Capes Neater Bard
r ittett;bolotoma , .
kir ,- a( i > 1,..„; .. 14  t'l le  i l i  -.1 , v•...,..i A k j
i
t
Sins NSA MAWS
i.  Ce4V -I
• .,..). . . 111C - I I
Wilson ci ORD •
Drop AtiNly fOrw Award GJMI COMM 0
"
I
( 2 )
Wattenl f Nadu • Bond
CAMP OeSCridon GaFIM
0 Y N
Susie NOWA Water
i ) 1•I I I I Id I I I I )._
Notion, ot ORD /
Jni 0 Away LINg Tall liAnNAV/LIM 011ans• • WAN / CN, Wind ,  bOrd
age DedCrchda Cara i tOrlic
Y ON
;alum No410.• Nn , woraltie
I I LI I I I 1(1 I I I )
of ORD I
Aug Ataxia rn.9 Typo !Amount/Urn I Cense • Wanani /Caps.. Nan., 8 nd
3 Inid0400 Ho. I
ManO•VeYkapeatanat n Can
D MM.:axiom NO
Loolgoa (Court Room Matta AGSM)
`Ind need ndd SOS in Cowl DA WWI
comoty wan rdtrucrons on Rena* Side
Caul OM, end Tome
Mont On YFY Tim. AM. PIA 1GREE TO APPEAR AT THE TIME AND RACE OESKINATED TO ANSWER DIE OFFENSE CHARGED OFI 10 PAY TIE 
FINE SUBSCRIBED UNDERSTAND THAT SHOULD!
WILLRALY FA 10 ',PEAR BEFORE THE COuRT AS REQUIRED ClY TNG NOT)CE TO APPEAR, THAT MAY BE teELD IN CONTEMPT OF COURT MCA 
WARRANT FOR JAY ARREST SHALL et ISSUED
Screase of Defedal (A .'stint end PO/Old id44/Xedf) AA' Dale &Enid
XEICN one, ARANY
Ana.
see. dMM‘ Nan* µaakeaorl IPMaild by Massa)
) 040 0HOus
1 SLAW&
O RessireaNnal
O Otter:
enaivoikka4.NI no •
CET . r 11:1
(PRINT)
PAGE
--OF_
Wm Demo LD. Pow* TranSPOMOOVAO ID.' AGONY
hare S le MS Antoci Kowa .in an
DISTRIBUTION: METE— COURT COPY GREEN — STATE ATTORNEY YELLOW — AGENCY P.M. — JAIL GOLD . DEFENDANT (Pt T.A's Can

╭─────────────────────────────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ ARREST / NOTICE TO APPEAR, Faves 3 Regeater wean — FZ] do                                              │
│ “Jwvenie Reteral Report BNA 4 Renmatecaoe” | 2 “                                                       │
│                                                                                                        │
│ ia                                                                                                     │
│ bach ptr ES RSTO NATO                                                                                  │
│ i PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 7 ia                                                                    │
│                                                                                                        │
│ e[noy 510,0,6,0,0 8h} Ji Mm                                                                            │
│ pps cata 2.01 PAM Seace Pouce pePaRe                                                                   │
│ B Es a —_]                                                                                             │
│                                                                                                        │
│ Fee oem vole ae Pe [RR PR [Reo                                                                         │
│ _ ati Sic Short ere ttt ae —                                                                           │
│ manainiincen ~ | fee fF                                                                                │
│ j ta Fy 28tFom |                                                                                       │
│ ree ae ‘ peal po                                                                                       │
│                                                                                                        │
│ pssst nt on os a om                                                                                    │
│                                                                                                        │
│ es A TOT er aa co aaa a                                                                                │
│ ‘| mi                                                                                                  │
│ a ea aaa                                                                                               │
│                                                                                                        │
│ Pecan oe                                                                                               │
│                                                                                                        │
│ SSE TSA AAT RE TAS RD Gs OSS DISS SLT TS Te                                                            │
│ PREAH BeFone We CB MG REGED 8 MOT WO MPPEAR THAT hn SERED CONTENU OF COUN ROA BORRANT PORN CST BL BORE │
│                                                                                                        │
│ Spano Oona nels Poon COROST Daa Some                                                                   │
│ a a | a a Tare ten roby ee)                                                                            │
│                                                                                                        │
│ Yoargnas 0) Resa                                                                                       │
│ uaa" Gomer                                                                                             │
│                                                                                                        │
│ a oa id ial linet                                                                                      │
│ TT TTT TT _—                                                                                           │
│                                                                                                        │
│ SDNY_GM_02763055                                                                                       │
│                                                                                                        │
│ SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER PARAGRAPHS 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, and 17                                         │
│                                                                                                        │
│ EFTA_00249897                                                                                          │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department
Agency ORIN FLO 500600
Police Caseth 05-368 (2)
Defendant:
Race/Sex: White Female
DOB: 05-25-1975
Charges: Principal in the I" Unlawful Sexual Activity with a Minor (4) counts
Principal in the 1" Lewd and Lascivious Molestation (I) count
From March 15, 2005, through February 2006, the Palm Beach Police Department conducted a sexual
battery investigation involving Jeffrey Epstein, Sworn taped statements were
taken from five victims and seventeen witnesses concerning massages and unlawful sexual activity that took place
at the residence of Jeffrey E stein 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach. Several of the victims were recruited by and
brought to the residence by to perform massages for Epstein for whicateceived
monetary compensation. During the visit they would be introduced to Epstein's assistant, who in
turn would record their telephone numbers and name. The victims would be brought to Epstein's bedroom to
provide the massage. Epstein would enter the room and order the victims to remove their clothing to provide the
massage. As the victims complied and provided the massages, Epstein would rub his fingers on their vaginas.
On occasion, Epstein would introduce a massager/vibrator and rub the victims vaginas as they provided the
massage. On three separate occasions, Epstein had intercourse and inserted his penis/fingers in the victims
vaginas. At the conclusion of the massages the victims were paid sums of money ranging from $200 - $1,000.
The facts, as reported, are as follows:
On 03/15/2005, A fourteen year old white female, hereinafter referred to as dob and
her family reported unlawful sexual activity which occurred at a residence within the Town of Palm Beach.
reported that a subject known to her as "Jeff' had touched her vaginal area with a vibrator/massager while within
his residence. "Jeff' was later identified as Jeffrey Epstein through a photo line up.
During a sworn taped interview tated that dob a cousin ol=
boyfriend and classmate at orked for a wealthy man and did sexual favors for
him. She also admitted tha i had offered her an opportunity to make mone . During the beginning of
the month February 2005 plained that she was first approached by o o with her to Epstein's
house. ted that Robson on with a Hispanic female, later identified a ick her up at
her father's house on a Sunday vas not sure of the exact dates but knew it was a Sunday. told her
father that they were going shopping but in reality drove them to Palm Beach. During the drive a
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Florida
County of Palm Beach
Signa u 7 r esting Officer
Signature of Police Officer (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 0 01/2006
Page I of 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORM FL 500600
conversation occurred between_and■ whereas reportedly tol at if Jeff asked her age,
she should say she was eighteen. It was ater confirmed by th father that icked his daughter up
on February 6, 2005. According to father, Midrov pi k up truck.
l escribed Epstein's house as a two•story pink house with a Cadillac Escalade parked in the
driveway. She recalled that Jeffs house was on a dead end street. Upon arriving at the houseMstated that
they walked up a driveway, past what appeared to be a small guard/security room. A male approaching them
asking asking what they wante stated they were there to see Epstein. The male allowed them to continue
walking up to the house fated the man told them that Epstein was not there but was expected back. He
allowed them to enter the house, via the kitchen. He offered them something to drink while they waited inside.
Short) thereafter, Epstein and his assistant, described as white female with blond hair and later identified as
entered the kitchen. Epstein introduced himself Edescribed Epstein as being
approximately forty-five years old, having a long face and bushy eyebrows, with graying hair.
and Epstein left the kitchen leavingEalone in the kitchen. They returned a short time later.
They all spoke briefly in the kitchen. :as instructed to followMupstairs.Mecalled walking up a
flight of stairs, lined with photographs, to a room that had a massage table in it. Upon entering the room there
was a Jar throom to the right and a hot pink and green sofa in the room. There was a door on each side of
the sofa. ecalled there being a mural of a naked woman in the room, as well as several photographs of
naked women on a shelf. told the victim that Epstein would be up in a second.
Epstein entered the room wearing only a towel and told.to take off her clothes.. stated Epstein
was stem when he told her to take off her clothes.Msaid she did not know what to do as she was the only one
there in the room so she took off her shirt leaving her bra on. Epstein had removed his towel and told thcMto
g stake off everythin . fated Epstein was nude when he took his towel off, placing it on the floor as he laid
down on the table. i tated she then removed her pants leaving her thon antics on. Epstein then instructed
her to give him a massage pointing to a specific lotion for her to use. A began to give Epstein the massage,
he told her to get on his back=tated she straddled herself on Epstein's back whereby her exposed buttocks
were touching Epstein's bare buttocks. Maid Epstein was specific in his instruction to her on how to massage
him, telling  her to go clockwise or counter clockwise. Epstein then turned over and instruct o massage his
chest. as now standing on the ground and resumed massaging Epstein's chest area. tated Epstein held
onto the small of her back as she massaged his chest and shoulder area. Epstein then turned to his side and
started to rub his penis in an up and down motion. Epstein then pulled out a purple vibrator and began to
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Florida
County of Palm Beach
Signal ing Officer
Signature of Police O icer (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: /2006
Page 2of 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORI4 FLO 500600
rnassagMvaginal area. Stated there was no penetration as the vibrator was on top of her underwear.
M etalled Epstein ejaculating because he had to use the towel to wipe himself as he got off the table. Epstein
then left the room and got dressed. She went back downstairs where she met with id she
was paid three hundred dollars in cash from Epstein. Before she left, Epstein aske to leave her phone
number. Asnd 'ere leaving the houseatoldElshe received two hundred
dollars that day for bringing Cr.
During the course of the investigation, parental consent was granted for o assist with the
investigation. At our directio onducted controlled taped phone calls to cellular telephone
'Evoke with in an attempt to arrange another meeting with Epstein.esked
what did she need to do to make more money. gtated, "the more you do, the more you get paid."
had subantly called bacMnd left a voice mail message for her indicating that she had set up an
"fitment fo
oice mail.
o go to Epstein's house at 1 l :00 am on April 5, 2005. This message was recorded from
Based on the above, trash pulls were established at Epstein's residence with Supervisor Tony Higgins of
the Sanitation Bureau of the Town of Palm Beach. The trash pull from April 5 2005 revealed a tele one
message for Epstein which stated Manlname at 11:00 am. This was the time frame had
informed.to be ready to go work at Epstein's house.
On October 3, 2005, Sgt Frick and I went to residence and viewed her vehicle parked in the
driveway, a red Dodge Neon. Sgt. Frick and I knocked on the door and met with was
told that we were investigating a claim involving Jeffrey Epstein of El Brillo Way, in Palm Beach. was
asked if she would accompany us back to the police station for further questioning. She was also told that at the
conclusion of the interview she would be returned home. voluntarily came with us back to the Palm
Beach Police Department.
Upon our arrival at the police station, _was brought to the interview room in the Detective Bureau
where I obtained a taped, sworn statement. I began the interview by asking_ how she became
acquainted with Epstein.astated that approximately two years ago, just after she turned ars of age,
she was approached by a friend named=at the Canopy Beach Resort in Rivera Beach. was asked
if she wanted to make money. She was told she would have to provide a massage and should make $200.00.
M thought about the offer and agreed to meet with Jeffrey.
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
net Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
Signature of Police Officer (F(S.S. 117.10)
Page3of 22
State of Florida
County of Pal Beach
Signat 'ng Officer
Date: /2006
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
<REDACTED> (Unknown last name) and <REDACTED> (Unknown last name) picked <REDACTED> up and she was taken to Epstein's 
house. Upon her arrival to the house she was introduced to Epstein in
the kitchen of the house. She was also introduced to a white female known to her as <REDACTED>. She was led upstairs to 
the main bedroom known to her as Jeff Epstein's
bedroom. <REDACTED> arranged the massage table and covered the table with a sheet. She brought out the massage oils and 
laid them next to the massage bed. hen left the
room and informed off would be in, in a minute. Jeff entered the bedroom wearing only a towel. He removed the towel and 
laid nude on the massage table. He laid
on the table onto his stomach and picked a massage oil for to rub on him. During the massage, Stated "He tried to touch 
me and I stopped him." I asked how he
tried to touch her. astated that Epstein grabbed her buttocks and she felt uncomfortable. told Epstein, I'll massage you
but I don't want to be touched. stated
she performed the massage naked. At the conclusion of the massage, Epstein paid $200.

After the massage Epstein stated to <REDACTED> that he understood she was not comfortable, but he would pay her if she 
brought over some girls. He told her the younger the
better. Robson stated she once tried to bring a 23 year old female and Epstein stated that the female was too old. 
<REDACTED> stated that in total she only
remembers six girls that she brought to see Epstein, each time she was paid $200. Robson stated she had brought the 
followin girls <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
(a 16 yr old female) <REDACTED> (a 16 year old female) and <REDACTED>. <REDACTED> said that at the time she brought 
these girls to Epstein's house they were all 14
through 16 years of age. I asked <REDACTED> which one was the youngest. <REDACTED> advised <REDACTED> was the youngest 
as she was fourteen when the massage occurred. <REDACTED> stated every girl she brought knew what to expect when they
arrived. They were told they would provide a massage, possibly naked, and allow some touching. I asked her it 'as aware.
She stated every girl she brought knew
what to expect. She explained she knew that <REDACTED> wanted to make money. She approached <REDACTED> and explained 
about goin to work for Jeff. <REDACTED> agreed and
arrangements were made to bring her to Epstein's house on a weekend. <REDACTED> stated that she and <REDACTED> (Later 
identified as <REDACTED> picked <REDACTED> up at her house.
<REDACTED> stated that at that time she was driving a red pickup truck. They traveled to Epstein's house and entered 
through the kitchen door. They met with the
house chef and Epstein's assistant as <REDACTED> introduced <REDACTED> to Epstein while were in the kitchen area.
<REDACTED> led <REDACTED> upstairs and Epstein went upstairs. When the massage was ovet <REDACTED> returned to the 
kitchen area.
tat she was paid $200.00 for bringinno Epstein's house. stateceold her she was
paid $300.00 for the massage.
stated thattwas the last person she brought to Epstein's house. She had changed her cellular
number to avoid being contacted ba She continued stating that she had no direct contact with Epstein
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this P' day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Florida
County of al • Beach
-te t
Signatu ting Officer
Signature of Police ficer ( .S.S. 117.10) Date: 0 t 1/2006
PageMof 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORM FLO 500600
when he was going to travel to Palm Beach. said when Epstein announces to his assistant, he is traveling to Palm 
Beachalliwould then contact ro arrange girls to
"work" for Epstein. stated that once her parents discovered that she was visiting Epsteinaihsapproved of the encounters 
with him and she stopped. further stated
that Mstill tries to call house and leaves messages.
Sgt Frick entered the room and explained athat based on her own statements, she had implicated herself by bringing 
underage girls to Epstein's house. Sprovided
cellular telephone numbers for the girls she had mentioned previously. Additionally, she also provided possible 
addresses and areas in which they lived.
was being taken home in the vehicle, a tape recorder was placed within the vehicle to record any conversations within 
the vehicle. During the drive back to her
home, made the comment " I'm like a Heidi Fleiss." (Hollywood Madam who sent girls to clients for sexual favors in 
California). was dropped off at her house
without incident.
On October 3, 2005, Sgt Frick and I went to speak wit sixteen year-old female who was
brought to Epstein's residence by We met wit other at their front door. We explained the gaping investigation and asked 
to speak witligs we had information that
she had "worked" for Jeff. MrsEntroduced us to her and allowed us entry into the home. We sat in the dining room and met
wit Date of Bin s she was under the age
of eighteen, M as advised we would be speaking with her. She express it er daughter had information, she wanted to 
assist. We intervieweMwho
denied havin any inappropriate encounters with Jeff (Epstein). She stated she had gone to Jeff's house with
approximately eight months ago and sat in the kitchen with the house chef, but nothing happened.
As the parents were present during the interview, we felt thatawas withholding information from us. She made
several comments as to putting the entire incident behind her. I left my tele hone number and advised should she ifr
wish to speak with me a air to telephone me. Sgt Frick and I thanked Mrs or her time and left the area. She
stated she would as gain after we left as to what happened at Epstein's house. I informed her that'll had
my telephone number and hopefully she would call.
^^  ^ tober 4 2005 Det Dawson and I drove to th   Mul
dot During a sworn taped statement taped a proximately a year ago
when she was seventeen years old a wa tated she knows
S ecause they both atten She was told she could make money working
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
ftSignature of Police fficer .S.S. 117.10) Date: t t 1/2006
State of Florida
County P m Beach
Page Sof 22
Signat ling Officer
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORD FLO 500600
for Jeff. She was told she would have to provide a massage to Jeff. stated upon her arrival to the house she was brow ht
to the kitchen area by They met with
the house c of who was already in the kitchen area. tated would wait for her in the kitchen.lawas introduced toa.Jeff's 
assistant, who brought her upstairs to
the master bedroom.Mrepared the room and massage table for a massage. Epstein entered the room wearing only a towel and 
she provided a massage_stated she kept
her clothes on during the masse e. She advised sometime (hiring the massage, Epstein grabbed her buttocks and pulled her
close to him. said she was
uncomfortable sl lie incident involving Jeff. At the conclusion of the massage, she was paid $200.00 for the massage. I 
askaf she has any formal training in
masse which she replied no. I asked her iareeeived any monies for taking her to perform the massage. stated Robson had 
received money for taking her there but
was unsure in the amount.
returned to Epstein's house on another occasion with Robson and another
she waited in the kitchen with while —vas taken upstairs by
massage once as she was uncomfortable with the whole experience.
stated
tated she only did the
conclusion of the interview, the tape was stopped. I was informed that had attempted to reach ia cell pho voice mail 
messa e n October 4, 2005 at 10:59 am,
revealed a female voice who identified herself as who requeste to call her back reference the police quesjjgBj
provided the incoming telephone number as stated she inadvertently tol
about the police investsinvestigation because= had called her to tell her about how she just received a rental car from 
Jeff Epstein trad called her to tell her
that she was given a rental car, a 2005 Silver Nissan Sentra, to utilize to visit fa". visit E stein. sked her what was 
oin on at the house that the police
would be asking questions tat hen called Jeff and and asked what was going on reference the ongoing police 
investigation. According. tr tas since then been
trying to contact her to ask about the olice uestions. I instructednot to contact Sarah and do not provide any more
information tots she would notify Jeff Epstein and what was transpiring.
On October4, 2005, I made telephone contact witlinwho had left several messages for me to contact
her. During the message, she advised she was not completely truthful when we met in person but would like to
speak with me to advile what had happened. She further advised she did nothato speak of this incident in
front of h other. At approximately 3:48 pm I made telephone contact wit During a taped recorded
tc,,,ELtstein .o twice. Sh desowseecause they both. atlipcl
if
statement tated the following: approximately a year ago, when she took her
e first
time she weiii, drove to the house. They entered throng the kitchen area where she was
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed State of Florida
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by County of Pal Beach
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
(riCe.* Signatur ng Officer
Signature of PoliceOfficei(F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05 /2006
Page‘of 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN PLO 500600
introduced teand Epstein. She was taken upstairs to a bedroom by who set the room up with a
massage bed and brought out the oils to use. Epstein then entered the room wearing a towel. He laid on the
table and picked out a lotion fort rub on him. At one point during the massage he tried to remove her shirt
at which point she became very upset and discontinued the massage. Bot nd E stein had a verbal
disagreement, at which time she left without being paid. She got with who was si
kitchen and told her "let's go." advised she received no money for that day
' .
so said tha
had told her if she was uncomfortable with what was going on, to let him know and he'll stop. She knew that the
moreyou do the more you get paid. advised that several weeks later she agreed to be taken a second time
by Once they arrived at the residence sat in the kitchen and took her
upstairs to the master bedroom again. set the room up with a massage bed and brought out the oil to
use. Epstein then entered the room wearing a towel. He laid on the table sciEicked out a lotion fo o rub
on him. At one point during the massage he tried to touch her buttocks. AMas wearing tight jeans and had a
tight belt on Epstein was unable to t u her buttocks. Epstein then rolled onto his back during the massage and sh
then attempted to touch her breasts hen became upset again and told Epstein she didn't want to be touched.
Miscontinued the massage and was paid $200.001.0hen went downstairs whey was waiting
for her. She told she w ted to leaveMaid she never returned to the house rated she is aware
that her friend was also at the house and had a problem with Epstein.
I later research ob and met with her at her residence. During a sworn
statement stated the following: on or about November 4 e was approached at -a fellow student. asked f she wanted to make
money.
She agreed and was told she would provide a massage to wealthy man in m Beach. picked her up
and drove her to a house in Palm Beach. She was brou t in  o the kitchen area of the house. She further stated
that fellow   udents and came with them. They were
brought into the kitchen where she was introduced to Epstein and other females stated she was
introduced to a female helper of Epstein, the female was described as white female (unknown name ), with
blond hair. She stated that the assistant was familiar with_ The assistant brought her upstairs into a
master bedroom area. The assistant set up the massage table and put out lotions to be used. She told-
Epstein would be available in a minute. Epstein entered the room wearing only a towel. Epstein removed his
towel, and laid naked on the massage table and picked a lotion to rub on his thighs and back. further
stated durin the massage, Epstein asked her to remove her clothes. She complied and removed her pants and
blouse. didn't remember if she had removed her bra but feels that she did. vas certain that she
stayed in her thong underwear. continued the massage and at one point she climbed onto the massage
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
net Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Florida
County of Palm Beach
Signatur ring Officer
Signature of Police Ofd// fiber (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05 006
Paee7 of 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIM FLO 500600
table, straddling Epstein to massage his back. While doing this her buttocks were touching Epsteins. was instructed to 
return to the ground at which time
Epstein turned to have his chest rubbed. dvised she was sure he was masturbating based on his hand movements going up 
and down on his penis area, id not want to
look at his penis area because she was uncomfortable. Epstein removed a large white vibrator which was next to the 
massage table and turned it on fated Epstein
began rubbing the vibrator over her thong underwear on her vaginal area. Shortly therea er, Epstein ejaculated and 
removed himself from the table. He walked
over to where the shower was and opened the glass door. She waited as he was taking a shower in her direct view. When I 
aske.Mow old she was when this occurred,
she stated she had just turned seventeen. At the conclusion of the shower was d either $350.00 or $400.00. She stated 
she wasn't sure, but knows it was close to
$400.00. rated she never returned to provide a massage for Epstein.
At approximately 2:10 pm, Det Dawson and I met with■ dob at her residence. AMI was only seventeen years of age, I had 
notified her mother, that she would be
interviewed reference an ongoing investigation in Palm Beach. I assured her that her daughter was not a suspect. I 
explained the possibility of her being either
a witness or victim. !advised she wanteclMo cooperate and consented to the interview.
During a sworn taped statement,.stated the following: at the age of sixteen du *rig the month of September 2004, she was
approached by for a chance to make
money. as friends with
d knew the same people. had been previously told by her friends !roma.
id for Epstein. called a person known toes IM and sc uled the appointment. ickedem and drove her to Palm Beach to a 
street called "Brillo Way'. They drove to
the end of the street and entered a large driveway. ThsJntered the kitchen area of the house and met with Epstein. vas 
introduced to Jeff Epstein. edMipstairs
to the main bedroom area and set up the room with a massage table and set out the oils ated le going up the stairs and 
into the bedroom she observed numerous
photographs of naked young girls. dimmed the lights and turned on soft music. exited the room and Epstein entered the 
room wearing only a towel. Epstein picked
oils and instructed her to nib his legs, under his buttocks, back and chest area. Epstein asked her to get 
comfortable... advised she did not remove her
clothes. She was wearing tight jeans and a cropped tank top ex sung her belly area. During the massage, Epstein removed 
his towel and laid on the massage table
naked. As tibbecl
Epstein's chest area, he attempted to reach down her pants to touch her buttocks area however was unable to due so due 
to the tightness of the jeans and a tight
belt.lilladvised Epstein began to masturbate as she rubbed
his chest. Epstein moaned as she rubbed his chest. She observed he was continuing to masturbate and
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this In day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
- 0 400 1
Signature of Policeallifficer (F.S.S. 117.10)
1'ageSof 22
State of Florida
County of Pal Beach
Signatur ting Officer
Date: 05/ rr 006
SDNY_GM_O2763O63
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
iattempted to reach up her tank top and touch her breastMpulled back and Epstein stopped, how v ii e
kept masturbating until he climaxed. He cleaned himself with the towel he was previously wearing was
paid $200.00 for the massage and left the area. She met withMwho was waiting in the kitchen area and
left the house.
lien ex lathed she never provided another massage for Epstein. She did however, go to the house
wi they took another friend of Robson's. Madvised she was present when
ent to wor or Epstein. She advised she rode over and sat in the kitchen area with to
wait for <dvised while they waited fa the house chef prepared lunch for them as it was
almost lunchtime when they went. Whetnas finished with the massa a. they left the area. I asked'. f
MMver told her what would be expected when she provided a massage. IM stated yes, old her
that a massage would be expected ssibly naked and possibly some touching involved. as no formal
training in providin massages. spoke about a third and last time she went to Epstein's house
ye another girl sixteen years of age) who i=friend, to Epstein's house. tatedMknew that
ad made money massaginglwein and wanted to make money h took them in the kitas
area of the house and introduced=to and loo apstairs to the main bedroom
advised she doesn't know what
her to
happened did
pstein's house and recommendin
did not speak about w at apiiiin the room Meceived
$100.00 from or going with
On October 6, 2005, at 11:45 am, I met with °b1= ,  explained to her why we there to interview her. She advised she was 
aware of the ongoing investigation.
stated she had previoual scen wi o told her she was interviewed by detectives. Dim
sworn taped statement tated she knew that worked for Jeff Epstein in Palm Beach.
advised she originally had been taken to the Epstein house by whom she met when they both
attended She began going to the house when she was sixteen years of age and
stated she had been there a lot of times to provide massages over the past two years. I asked her if she had
formal training in providing massages, whic=tated she had not. =advised she was told what was
expected of her by providing massages and she wo e to remove clothing but if she felt uncomfortable just a
to say so and Epstein would stop pushing the issue began providing massages and advised she kept her
clothes on. She considered Epstein a pervert and he kept pushing to go further and further.Mxplained she
keep telling him she had a boyfriend and would not be right to her boyfriend. It wasn't until recently that sw i e
gan removing her clothes and staying in her thong underwear to provide a massage...explained
and
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Flo ida
Coun of P m Beach
Signatur esting Officer
Signature of PoliceOfficer (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05/11/2006
Pageiof 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
Epstein wanted to be rubbed on his back and recently he began turning over and have her rub his chest as he
masturbated. He would try to touch her breasts as she rubbed his chest. Mtated "Jeff would try to get away
with more and more on each massage". Mated E stein would try to touch her more and on one occasion m i l
he attempted to use a massager/vibrator on her. drove to the house for the original massage.
left her cell phone number and every time Epstein would come into town, .would call her for an
appointment to "work". Each time she went, would meet her at the kitchen door area. She would bring
her upstairs and prepare the massage table wised Epstein would ask her uestions about herself. Epstein
knew she was a soccer player and would be attending-I  asked'f Epstein knew her real
age. 11istated Epstein did and didn't care. The most recent massage she provided was on October 1, 2005.
During the massage, she asked Epstein if she could borrow one of his vehicles to visit her family and boyfriend in
Orlando, Florida. Epstein had told her she could borrow one of his vehicles but later stated he would rent her a
car. She continued with the massage as Epstein grabbed her buttocks and caressed the buttocks cheeks. I
asked f she was wearing undergarments to which she replied her thong underwear. Once he tried to touch
her breasts, she would pull away from him and he would stop. 'as asked if he ever used a vibrator on her.
=was aware of the vibrator but advised she never would allow him to use the vibrator on her.. She described
the vibrator as the large white vibrator with a huge head on the tip of the vibrator. She stated he kept the vibrator
in a closet near the massage table.
. .
S tated that on October 3, 2005, she was contacted by Epstein's assistant, who informed her
that Jeff E stein had rented her a new Nissan Sentra and she should come by the house to pick it up.
informed he would have the car for a month-stated Epstein knew her car was not working properly
and that she had missed appointments in the past because of her car being inoperable....explained the car is
currently parked next to th ym field. I asked her if she ever took an one to the house—
explained she took friend of hers who attend who has
relocated to Orlando to attend college. I asked if she ever allowed another female in the room dvised no
one was brought into the room with her.
At the conclusion of the interview, Det Dawson and I went to the gym area o and
located the Silver Nissan Sentra bearing Florida tag X98-APM . The vehicle is registered to Dollar Rent a Car
out of the Palm Beach International Airport. The vehicle was rented by Janusz Banasiack, later learned to be
Epstein's houseman, and paid with Epstein's credit card.
On September 11, 2005, w/Mdob was arrested by the Palm Beach Police Department
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
K—Iee#
Signature of Police ef ncer (P.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05 I /2006
State of Florida
County of Pal t each
Signatur Ling Officer
Pagel0of 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORM FLO $00600
for misdemeanor possession of marijuana. During the arrest old the arresting officer that she had information about 
sexual activity taking place at the
residence of Jeffrey pstein. Additionally, during the ongoing trash pulls
from Epstein's residence, discarded papers were found which contained tame and cell phone number.
On October, 11, 2005, Det Dawson and I met withand obtained a sworn taped statement. explained she had been going to 
Epstein's house since 2002, when she was
sixteen years of age. Since then she has gone to the house hundreds of times. stated h n ., ." She explained that on tI
e
irst visit she was brought to the house by fello classmate,
aid she was brought through the kitchen area where she me' for the first time. led to t  master bedroom, Epstein s room.
xplained that as she was walking up the
stairs she observed several photographs of naked women along e walls and tables of the hous urther explained that she 
was brought into the bedroom,
where_prepared the room by setting up the massage table and provided the oils for her to rub on Epstein.Mxplained she 
remembered the steam room area, which
contained two large
showers. Epstein entered the room from the steam room area and introduced himself. Epstein lay on the table and told her
to get comfortable. emoved her skirt
and kept her shirt on. Epstein then instructed her to remove her shirt. emoved her shirt and remembered she was not 
wearing a bra. tated she provided the
massage wearing only her panties. She continued rubbing his legs, thighs and feet. advised he turned over onto his back.
Epstein touched her breasts and be an
to masturbate. Epstein ejacu ated which meant the massage was over. At the massage vas p 0. They walked together 
downstairs when . and cre waiting. ated
received an unknown amount of money for taking her to pstem. Epstein instructed to leave her ce u ar to ephone number so
that he could
contact her when he is in town.
-stated that during her many visits a routine was established between her and Epstein. She would enter the house and get
naked in the bedroom. She would then
start with a back massage. Epstein would roll on to his back and allow her to massage his chest areaMstated Epstein 
would then began to masturbate himself and
at the same time would insert his fingers in her vagina and masturbate her with his fingersaxplained Epstein
would continue this process until he ejaculated. He would then utilize a vibrator/masse  on her vagina unti
climaxed. advised that during her frequent visits Epstein asked for her real age stated she was sixteen. Epstein advised
her not to tell anyone her real age.
advised that things escalated within the home as Epstein
would instruct and paMo have intercourse with his female friend, xplained the
intercourse included using strap on dildos, large rubber penis' and other devices that Epstein had at his disposal.
Epstein would watch them have intercourse and masturbate himself . Occasionally, Epstein would then join in
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this I" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Florida
County of Palm :each
Signature ng Officer
Signature of Police Officer (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05/ 006
Pagel' of 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
during the female on female intercourse and provide oral sex to bothtnd This occurred during
the timentras sixteen years of age.
vised this continued to escalate during two years. The routine became familiar toa Epstein's
assistant would telephone her every time Epstein was in the Town of Palm Beach and would place
appointments for her to visit and work for Epstein. Each time something new was introduced, additional monies
were produced and offered forMo allow the acts to happen.=onsented to perform all these acts but was
adamant that there was an understanding with E in that no vaginal penetration would occur with his penis.
explained that Epstein's penis was deformed. xplained that his penis was oval shaped.Mlaimed when
Epstein's penis was erect, it was thick toward e ttom but was thin and small toward the head portion
called Epstein's penis "egg-shaped." tated Epstein would photo aph and her naked and
having sex and proudly display the p otographs within the home. tated during one visit to Ei
provided the massage in which
stein's house
in which she provided a massage to E tein his female friend as also present
and her would fondle each others breasts and kiss for Epstein to
enjoy. Towards the end of this massage, Epstein grabbe turnedat  her over onto her stomach on the
m e table and forcibly inserted his penis into her vagina. tated Epstein began to pump his penis in her
vagina. e upset over this. She said her head was being held against the table forcibly, as he continued
to pump inside her. She screamed "No!" and Epstein stopped. She told him that she did not want to have his
penis inside of her. Epstein did not e'ai sculate inside of her and apologized for his actions and subsequently paid
her a thousand dollars for that visit. fated she knows he still displays her photographs through out the house.
On October 12, 2005, Det Dawson and I met wi
a sworn taped statement, that nothing happened between her and Epstein.
interview. I assured her that I have spoken with other people who advise
occasions she nrovided a massage to E • ught to the Epsteinhouse in March of
2005. smate approached ed her if she
wanted to "work". ade the arrangements wit Epstein's assistan ho has no formal
training in providing massages, stated she provided a massage, fully clothed for $200.00 . As I sensed hesitancy
wers, I ask
who stated during
p ed nervous during the
erently a tated on several
f she had been contacted by anyone from Epstein's organizations or his house.
stated she was interviewed already by a private investigator for Epstein. He identified himself as "Paul"
'red about the police investigation, and left his telephone number 305-710-5165 for additional contact.
ovided no additional information, as it appeared her responses were almost scripted.
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed State of Florida
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by County of Palm each
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
.- / €1
Signature/ g Officer
Signature of Police Officer (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05/01
Page gif 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
t ime, approximately two months ago. She was approached b a irl
ommate, for an opportunity to make some quick money
quick cash to make the rent that month. She agreed to go to the ho,
the massage would have to be done in her underwear. She advi
house. They walked into the kitchen area, and took the stairs upstairs.
On November 6, 2005, at approximately 3:30 pm, I met wit dob at the
Palm Beach Police Department. was identified as a potential witness/victim through information
obtained during the trash pulls. During the sworn taped statement advised she was at Jeffrey Epstein's
who was dating
Silladvised she needed to make some
e had been told b that
rove with her and brought her into the
er stated she was brought
into a master bedroom area. She advised she recalled seeing portraits of naked women throughout the room. A
massage table was already out near the sauna/shower area in the master bedroom. E tein entered the room
wearing only a towel and introduced himself as "Jeff." At Epstein's direction da -emoved their
clothing down to their panties, Epstein laid on his stomach area and they provided a masse e on his legs and feet
area. I askedMif she had any formal massage training and she replied "no." dvised she was
topless and the panties she wore were the bo shorts lace panties. She an ntinued the massage until the im
last ten minutes of the massage, Epstein, tol' o leave the room so that uld finish the massage.
of dressed, and left the room as E stein turned over onto his back. Epstein then removed the towel and
ar naked . E stein uested the b his chest area tated as she did this, Epstein, began
masturbating. tated Epstein p down her boy short panties, and he produced a large white vibrator
with a largehea . e stated it was within his reach in a drawer in his master bathroom. He rubbed the vibrator
on her vaginal arealMadvised he never penetrated her vagina with the vibrator. He continued to rub her
vagina with the vibrator as he continued to masturbate. tated she was very uncomfortable during the
incident but knew it was almost over. Epstein climaxed and started to remove himself from the table. He wiped
himself with the towel he had on previously and went into the shower area. of dressed and met with
n the kitchen area. Epstein came into the kit ovid 200.00 for bringin
clik rpaid $200.00 t or roviding the massage.was tol v her telephone number wi
for future contact ovided her cellular telephonember. was asked if she was recently
contacted about this investigation by anyone from the Epstein organization. She repli called but it was
for work. She stated she was called by  for her to return to " " r Epstein. stated "work" is
the term used byMto provide the massages and other things. dvised she declined as she was not
comfortable in providing that type of "work."
On November 7 2005 Det Sandman and I met wi dob During a
sworn taped statement ted she met Jeffrey Epstein thou hen they were still
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
Signature of Police Officer (R.S.S. 117.10)
Page f3of
State of Florida
County of Pal Beach
Signatu ing Officer
Date: 05/01/2006
SDNY_GM 02763068
EF1'A_00249910
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
attendi Robson would approa who wished to work for Epstein.
stated she was offered to work for Epstein but declined. xplained that "work" ve
massages. She was asked about any formal training in providing massages which she said "no." aid
she accompanied=and other females who were taken to Epstein's house to provide massages.
further stated she had been to the house approximately 4 or 5 times in the past  ear. She accompanied Robson /
with Each time the girls were taken
over, they were previously told they would have to provide a massage, possibly naked. They were also told that
shoulci• si require them to do anything extra, and they were not comfortable just to tell him and he would
stop. tated received $200.00 for each girl she ht over to massage Jeffrey Epstein.
When I asked which girl appeared to be the youngest, she replied who was really young, fifteen years old at
the most.aurther stated each time she went to the house, she sat in the kitchen and waited with Robson
until the massage was over. She further stated that the cook would make lunch or a snack for them as they
waited. I asked her if there was anything that caught her attention within the home. .tated there were a
lot of naked girls in photographs throughout the house.
On November 8, 2005, at approximately 2:00pm , I met wit do!  the
a roximatel two years ago when she was first approached by a classmate at
$ e ad met t •Palm Beach Police Department. During a sworn taped statemen
Robson approached her about working for Epstein and providing a massage to him for $200.00.
had made the arrange  me however wa unable to take her the day the arrangements  were made.
a e iso attended and was familiar
with Epstein. recalled she was brow t there and entered through the back kitchen door. She had met
with an assistant and another assistant roughs her upstairs as she observed several
photographs of naked females throw hour the house. stated Epstein came in the room, wearing only a
towel, and laid on the table. tated out the oils he wanted her to use and requested she
remove her clothing t the massage. tated that on the first massage she provided she did not
remove her clothing. tated she had returned several times after that. Each time she returned it was
more than a massage. Epstein would walk ster bedroom/bathroom area wearing only a towel. He
would masturbate as she provided a massag tated she was unsure if he climaxed as he masturbated
under the towel. Additionally, she never looked below his waist. She claimed that Epstein would convince her to
remove her clothes. She eventually removed her clothes and stayed in her thong panties. On occasion, Epstein
would use a massager/vibrator, which she described as white in color and a large head. Epstein would rub the
vibrator/massager on her vaginal area as he would masturbate. .fated she had been to the house
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Flonda
County of Pal Beach
Signatu Ling Officer
Signature of Police officer (P.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05 i /2006
Paget of 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORM FLO 500600
numerous times. added she has no formal trainin in providing a massage. she
two females during her visits to provide massages. tated she brought a girl nam an
rom tined she received $200.00 for eac girl she brou t.
On November 8, 2005, I met wi /F at the Palm Beach Police
Department. During a sworn taped statement, tated she had met Jeffrey Epstein approximately one year
ago. She was approached by a sub'ect known to er asead asked her if she wanted to make money
providing massages to Epstein ad heard that several girls from were
.
doing this and making money.i e agreed and was taken to the house by tad introduced her to=
and Epstein and brow ht her upstairs to a master bedroom where a table was prepared and the proper
oils were selected. eft the room and waited downstairs for her stated Epstein entered t
wearing a towel an 81 on his stomach. She provided a massage wearing only her thong panties.
advised Epstein had masturbated every time she provided a massage. She stated Epstein continued to
masturbate until he climaxed. Once that occurred the massage was over. She felt the whole situation was weird
but she advised she 00 for providing the massage. She also stat as paid $200.00 by
Epstein for bringing tated she had gone a total of 15 times to Epstein's residence to provide a
massage and things ha esca ated rom just providing a massage. Epstein began touching her on her buttocks and
grabbed her closer to him as he masturbat . Epstein also grabbed her breasts and fondled her breasts with his
hands as she provided the massage tated on one occasion, while she was only seventeen years of age, he
offered extra monies to have vaginal intercourse. She stated this all occurred on the massage table stated
Epstein penetrated her vagina with his penis and began having intercourse with her until he reached the point of
climax. Epstein removed his penis from her vagina and climaxed onto the massage table. eived
$350.00 for her massage. I asked her if she had any formal training in providing masse es tated she did
not. ntinued to state on o r occasion, Epstein introduced his girlfriend into the massage.
brought into room wit to provide a massage. Epstein had them kiss and fondle each other
aroun the breasts and buttocks as they provided a massage to Epstein. Epstein, watched and masturbated as
this occurred. On other occasions E stein, introduced the large white vibrator/massager in the massage. Epstein
stroked the vibrator/massager or vagina as she provided the massage.
On November 14, 2005, Det Sandman and I met will  ob During a
sworn taped statement she advi ed going to the house approximately one year ago and has been there
approximately five or six times so stated she was sixteen years old when she first went to Epstein's
house. On her first visit she was brought by a fellow student fro known to her
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
Signature of Folic Officer (F.S.S. 117.10)
Page ig,f 22
State of Florida
County of Pal Beach
Signatur Officer
Date: 0 006
Probable Cause Affdavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
VIas Esposito stat brought her into the house and she was introduced to hen
brou t er upstairs into a mas r om, located within the bedroom stated she met Epstein in the
' bathroom. He laid on the table and picked the massage oils. She provid e massage as he laid naked on the
massage bed. She stated she rubbed his calves and back area. Upon the massage, Epstein removed
himself from the massage table and paid her $300.00 for the massage. said each subsequent time she
went to the house, she was notified byl hat Epstein was in town and would like her to "work".
ed she returned to the house and was again led upstairs by She provided the massage,
lc ot asked if she ever removed her clothing to rovide a massage. stated it was not
until the third time that she went that she removed her clothing tated she was notified by that
Epstein wanted
providing the massage when Epstein asked her to remove her clothing. moldier pants, shirt and
her to come to work. She arrived at the house and was led u stars by She started
bra. She stayed in her thou antics and continued rubbing Epstein. ps in ed over onto his back and she
rubbed his chest area tated she knew he was masturbating himself as she providing the massage. '
ated she be rev e climaxed based on his breathing. She did not want to view either the climax or
i mi
e act at he was masturbating stat breathing relaxed he got up and told her to get
dressed. She was paid S300.00 for her services. stated on the last time she went to provide a
massage, she was notified by .ci come ehouse and "work". tated she was now
dating her current boyfriend and did not feel comfortable going. She recall i was approximately January 2005.
She said she went, already thinking that this would be the last time. She went upstairs ' the master mill
bathroom. She met with Epstein, who was wearing only a towel, and laid onto the
tablet Epstein caught her looking at the clock on several occasions. Epstein asked her if she was in a urry.
stated her boyfriend was in the car waiting for her.Srther stated that Epstein got upset as he wasn't
enjoying the massage. She told him that she didn't want to continue and she would not be back. Epstein told her
israted although she had a falling ou wt pstein, she still received a Christmas bonus from Epstein.
ito leave as she was ruining his massage. k dvised she had no formal training in providing any massages.
Western Union revealed money was sent from Jeffrey Epstein on December 23, 2004. eceived
stated she was wired money from Western Union for her Christmas bonus. Sub a results from
$200.00 from Epstein for her Christmas bonus.
On November 15, 2005, Det. Sandman and I met willMdob During a sworn taped
statement ated she met Jeffrey E. Lein over a ear a h was sixteen years of age and was
approached b fello student, who informed her that she could
make $200.00 providing a massage to Epstein. ad informed her that she would have to provide this
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this r day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Florida
County of Palm each
Signature/ rr. ing Officer
Signature of Pol ce Officer (F.5.5. 117.10) Date: 05/0 06
Pagettpf
SDNY_GM 02763071
EF1'A_002499B
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
Inassa s MEinade the arrangements with Epstein and his assistants and tookEto the
stated d she entered through a glass door that led into a kitchen. She was taken upstairs b to a
master bedroom. She recalled the master bathroom had a la a ink couch, sauna and matching shower.
Epstein entered into the room wearing only a towel. moved their clothing remaining only in
thong underwear. r stated that Epstein Jai on his chest on the table. The oils were selected on which
ones to use. Bo Mrovided the massage on his le , back and feet. Forty minutes into the
massage, Epstein turned over onto his back and uest it downstairs in the kitchen area for
masturbating a bbed Epstein's chest. the room, left and Epstein began tated Epstein continued
ot dresseMtartiii rubbings  Epstein's the Epstein instructed=o finish the massage. A
masturbating until he climaxed on the towel he was wearing. When asked if he had removed the towel she stated
he turned the towel around so that the opening would allow him to expose himself. After he cleaned himself off
with the towel he instruc e massage was done and to get dressed and meet with him downstairs.
iof lressed and met with E e kitchen area. She was paid $200.00 dollars for providing the massage.
tated she was aware the Is° received monies for the same thing. The second time she went to the
house she was again approached b
massage
vi wanted to return to the house liovide
greed and the arrangemen were made beor her to return to the house. tatedlill
drove her to the house and knocked on the same lass door which leads to the kitchen area. They were al owed
bathroom area
entry into the lila on
eft
e staff members.
is time to do the massage alone. Epstein entered the room again wearing only a
ed her upstairs to the master bedroom and master
towel. Megan removing er clothing as she did the last time she was at the house. Epstein i ed her to
he began
masturbating.
to and legs, Epstein then turned over onto his back. rub his chest an
get naked. He laid on the table onto his stomach asMegan massy his legs and back. finished
with Epstein's back
masturbating. As rub abed his chest, Epstein leaned over and produced wager/vibrator. He turned it on
and began rubli
In
agina and masturbating himself at the same time. stated she continued to rub his
chest as this was occurring. She described the vibrator/massager as large grey with a large head. Epstein
rubbed her vagina for approximately two to three minutes with the masse te tor. He then removed the
vibrator from her vaginal area and concentrated on masturbating himself. tated Epstein climaxed onto the
towel again and informed her that the massage was done of dressed and met wiavho was waiting
in the kitchen area. She received $200.00 for the massage 'cl she never returned to the house and had no
desire to return to the house. :as asked if she received an formal massage training. She advised she had
no formal training. was asked if Epstein knew her real age. stated he knew, as he asked her Questions
about herself and Mgh school. He was aware she attended, and is still attending
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
Signature of Poll Offic (F.S.S. 117.10)
Pave &of '')7
State of Florida
County of Pal Beach
Signatur ing Officer
Date: 05/51%006
EF1'A_00249914
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORM FLO 500600
During the course of the investigation a search warrant was executed at Jeffrey Epstein's home located at
358 El Brillo Way in Palm Beach. While in the home I observed the pink and green couch within the master
bedroom area just as the girls previously mentioned. The stairway, which is located from the kitchen area to the
master bedroom area, is lined with photos of naked young girls. Additionally, numerous photographs of naked
young females, some of which appeared to be the girls I previously interviewed, were on display throughout the
house. Also located in the house were various phone message books. The telephone message books have a
duplicate copy (Carbon Copy) which, once a phone message is written into the book, the top copy is then torn
on the perforated edge and the carbon copy is left in the book. First names of girls, dates and telephone numbers
were on the copy of the messages. I recognized various numbers and names of girls that had already been
interviewed. The body of the messages were time of the day that they called for confirmation of "work." Other
names and telephone numbers were located in which the bod of the messages were, "I have girls for him" or "I
have 2 girls for him." These messages were taken by ho si ned the bottom of &sages.
During the execution of the warrant, I located a transcript for •pstein's
bedroom desk. This desk had stationary marked Jeffrey E Epstein. I located a wood colored armoire beside
Epstein's bed that contained a bottle of "Joy Jelly," which is used to provide a warm massage. Several massage
tables were located throughout the second floor of the residence, including a massage table found in Epstein's
bedroom. On the first floor of the residence I found two covert cameras hidden within clocks. One was located
in the garage and the other located in the library area on a shelf behind Epstein's desk. A computer was located
which was believed to contain the ima es from the covert cameras. The computer's hard drive was reviewed
which showed several images o and other witnesses that have been interviewed. All of these
images appeared to come from the camera positioned behind Epstein's desk.
On D ember 13, 2005, Dct. Dawson and I met witlMob During a sworn taped
statement, ted that when she was sixteen years old she was taken to Epstei use to provide a massage
for money tated it was before Christmas last ear (2004) when an associate pproached her and
asked if she ne ed to make money for Christmas.Snade arrangements to tak o the e and drove
M o the house to "work." They were encountered by a white female with long and hair. was unable to
remember the name of the white female with blond hair but knew she was Epstein's assistant. c was led
upstairs by the white female who explained that there would be lotions out already and Epstein would choose the
lotion he wanted her to use. She was led through a spiral staircas ch led to a master bedroom and
bathroom. The massage table was already set up in the bathroo escribed the bathroom as a large
spacious bathroom with a steam room and shower beside it as introduced to Epstein who was e
phone when she entered the room. Epstein was wearing a white towel and laid on his stomach so tha may
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1' day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
Of Signature of Folic Office (F.S.S. 117.10)
Page nor 22
State of Florida
County of Pal Beach
Signatu Ling Officer
Date: 0 6
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency OWN FLO 500600
massage his feet and calves. started the massage with the oils Epstein chose and rubbed his feet and calves.
Epstein got off the phone an requested she massage his back as welIM:iegan rubbing his back and got to
the small of his back. Duri rubbing of his back, Epstein asked her to t mfortable. He requested she
remove her pants and shirt emoved her shirt and pulled her pants off. stayed in her bra and thong
panties. As she finished massaging the small of Epstein's back, he then turn onto his back. Epstein
instructs o rub his chest and pinch his nipples. As she began to rub his chest. Epstein asked her questions
about hersel remembered telling him she attends . Epstein asked her if
she was sexually active. Befo uld answer, he a so asked what sexual position does she enjoy
stated she was shy and didn't like to ng about those things. She continued rubbing his chest. Epstein reached
up and unsnapped her bra from the front. xplained the bra she us a front snapping device. Epstein
rubbed her breasts and asked her if she like having her breasts rubbed. aid "no, I don't like that." Epstein
then removed his towel and laid on th aked exposing his penis t He began touching his penis and
masturbated as he touched her breasts xplained Epstei then touched her vaginal area by rubbing her
vagina with his fin the outside o er thong panties. ensed up and stated Epstein was aware that she m
was uncomfortable stated that Epstein said to her, "Re ax, I'm not going inside." She further explained
Epstein comment to er how l  ' ul and sexy she was. Epstein then moved her thong panties to one side ir
and began stroking her clitoris. aid, "He commented how hard my clit was." He then inserted two fingers in
her vagina and was stroking her within her vagina. She tried pulling back to pull out his fingers from within her
vagina. Epstein removed his fingers from within her vagina and apologized for puttin his fingers inside her.
During this time, he kept his hand on her vaginal area and continued to rub her vagina stated he rubbed her
•really hard as he was masturbating. aid he climaxed onto the towel he had been previously wearing and got
up from the table. Epstein told her ere was $200.00 dollars for her on the dress thin the master bathroom.
Epstein also told her that there was an additional $100.00 that was to be given to r bringing her there to
massage him. Epstein told her to leave her telephone number with his assistant as he wanted to see her again.
Epstein stated his assists Id contact her to w gain soon. I asked her if she ever received any formal
massage training to whic tated she did not tated it was the only time she ever went to work for Jeff
and knew what happened to her was wrong. Shefurther stated that she had never been contacted for any
additional work.
On January 9, 2006, I located and interviewed another victimEdo as identified
as a potential victim/witness from information obtained during trash pulls from Epste" '
met Pnctein when the was fifteen years of age. She was approached by a friend from
to be taken to Jeffrey Epstein's house to work. She was origina y to • s wou a e
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
Cc /f eSignature of Poll e Offic (F.S.S. 117.10)
Pagenof 22
State of Florida
County of Palm each
Signature/ g Officer
Date: 05/0 06
he
of modeling lingerie.
told.° get comfortable.
not wear a bra that evening.
Epstein tol
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department
Agency ORIN FLO 500600
to model f e for a wealthy Palm Beacher..vas taken to Epstein's house located on El BrilloWay.
introduce o Jeffre E stein. Epstein had ' rsonal chef prepare dinner fonand At the
conclusion o inner d Epstein broug pstairs into a master bedroom area bserved a large
massage table with a s ee on it. Epstein cntere ough a door and exited wearing only a towel.
infonneMhat the were going to provide a massage on Epstein ft sked why were they doing this instead
x lained tcathat this was his routine and to rub his calves and feet. Epstein had
emoved her pants and blouse. tated she stayed only in panties as shc did
stated while rubbing his calves an feet, Epstein turned over onto his back.
tated that as she started rubbing his chest, Epstein
hat if she told anyone what happened at his house that bad things could
prepared the room for the massage. E
clothing and provide the massage nak gan rubbing his feet and calves and Epstein turn
back. Epstein rubbed her vagina with his forgers. Epstein began to masturbate himself with an upwards and
downward motion on his penis. Epstein continued to touch her vagina with one hand and masturbate with the
other hand. Once Epstein ejaculated onto level he was wearing, the massage was over: vas paid
$200.00 for the massage. Epstein again tol ot to speak of what happened at his house or bad things would
happen wanted to notify authorities however she was afraid of what would happen to either her or her
family.
o rub his chest and rub his nipples.
began masturbating himself . Epstein touched her breasts and stroked her vagina with his fingers. Epstein
continued to masturbate himsel a  he stroked her vagina. Epstein ejaculated on his towel and paica200.00
stein tol
ere brought home by Epstein's houseman an' vas afraid that Epstein knew where
ated that several days later she received a telephone call from who coordinated for
eturned to the house and was brought to Epstein's bedroom area by ho
jpgntered the room wearing only a towel. Epstein ha move her
over onto his
During the course of the investigation, several subjects were identified as a potential witness/victim
through information obtained during the trash pulls, physical surveillance and telephone message books retrieved
from the search warrant. While conducting research on the subjects, I discovered that the females were age
eighteen or older. Interviews were conducted on the consenting adults whose statements provided the same
massage routine when they went to "work" for Epstein. The females would be notified b and
made appointments for the females to "work" for Epstein. The females would come to Epstem's ouse and were
led upstairs, through a stairwell from the kitchen area, by to Epstein's bedroom. Epstein would then
enter the room wearing only a towel, and ask them to get comfortable. The females would then provide the
massage naked as Epstein would either touch their vaginas with his fingers and/or utilize the massager/vibrator on
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Florida
County alm each
Signature/Ai - n Officer
Signature of Polic Officer (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05/01
Pagv_cpf 22
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
their vaginal area. He would masturbate during the massage and upon his climaxing, the massage would end. The
girls were then paid two or three hundred dollars for the massage.
On November 21, 2005 I interviewed Jose Alessi, a former houseman for Jeffrey Epstein. Alessi stated
he was employed for eleven years with Mr. Epstein, from approximately 1993 through 2004. Alessi stated he
was the house manager, driver and house maintenance person. It was his responsibility to prepare the house for
Epstein s arrival. When asked about cooks or assistants, Alessi stated they traveled with Epstein on his private
plane. I asked Mr. Alessi about the massages that have occurred at Epstein's home. Alessi stated Epstein
receives three massages a day. Each masseuse that visited the house was different. Alessi stated that towards
the end of his employment, the masseuses were younger and younger. When asked how young, Mr. Alessi
stated they appeared to be sixteen or seventeen years of age at the most. The massages would occur in Epstein's
bedroom or bathroom. He knew this because he often set up the massage tables. I asked if there were things
going on other than a massage. Alessi stated that there were times towards the end of his employment that he
would have to wash off a massager/vibrator and a long mbber penis, which were in the sink after the massage.
Additionally, he stated the bed would almost always have to be made after the massage.
On January 4, 2006 I interviewed another former houseman, Mr Alfredo Rodriguez. During a sworn
taped statement, Mr. Rodriguez stated he was employed by Jeffrey Epstein for approximately six months, from
November 2004 through May of 2005. His responsibilities as house manager included being the butler,
chauffeur, chef, houseman, run errands for Epstein and provide for Epstein's guests. I asked Rodriguez about
masseuses coming to the house. Rodriguez stated Epstein would have two massages a day. Epstein would have
one massage in the morning and one massage in the afternoon everyday he was in residence. Rodriguez stated
he would be informed to expect someone and make them comfortable until either or Epstein would
meet with them. Rodriguez stated once the masseuses would arrive, he would allow them ent into the kitchen
area and offer them something to drink or eat. They would then be encountered by either or
Epstein. They would be taken upstairs to provide the massage. I asked Rodriguez if any of the masseuses
appeared young in age. Rodriguez stated the girls that would come appeared to be too young to be masseuses.
Ile stated one time under Epstein's direction, he delivered a dozen roses to  for
one of the girls that came to provide a massage. He knew the girls were still in high school and were of high
school age. I asked Rodriguez about the massages. lie felt there was a lot more going on than just massages.
He would often clean Mr. Epstein's bedroom after the alleged massages and would discover massagers/vibrators
and sex toys scattered on the floor. He also said he would wipe down the vibrators and sex toys and put them
away in an armoire. He described the armoire as a small wood armoire which was on the wall close to Epstein's
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
State of Flor .da
County i f P m B ach
Signature/ g Officer
Signature of Poli Office (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05/01 06
Page21of 22
SDNV_GM_02763076
Probable Cause Affidavit
Palm Beach Police Department Agency ORIN FLO 500600
bed. On one occasion Epstein ordered Rodriguez to go to the Dollar rent a car and rent a car for the same girl
he brought the roses to, so that she could drive her self to Epstein's house without incident. Rodriguez said the
girl always needed rides to and from the house. Rodriguez produced a green folder which contained documents,
and a note Wth Mr. Epstein's stationary with direction to deliver a bucket of roses to
=N ate .gh school drama performance. Also in that same note was direction to rent a car for
direction to extend the rental contract.
During the course of the investigation, subpoenas were obtained for cell .hone and home phone records
from several victims and witnesses along with the cell phone records of An anal sis of these
records was conducted which found numerous telephone calls were ma .e .etween and the victims.
These records indicate the dates the calls were made arc consistent with the dates and times t ey
victims/witnesses stated they were contacted. Specificall The phone records showed called
!luring the exact times and dates when vie(' dvised the incident occurred. also coordinated
the encounters wit uring the time frame the girls
stated they occurred.
Pursuant to a lawful subpoena I obtained Epstein's private plane records for 2005 from Jet Aviation.
The plane records show arrival and departure of Epstein's lane at Palm Beach International airport. These
records were corn .a  to the cell phone records of This comparison found that all the phone calls
=Shade to and the victims were made in the days just prior to their arrival or during the time Epstein
was in Palm Beach.
Jeffrey Epstein, who at the time of these incidents was  fifty one years of age, did have vaginal intercourse
either with his penis or digitally witli lwho were minors at the time this occurred, and
who at the time of the incident was fifty two ears of age, did use a vibrator on the external vaginal area ofEa
fourteen year old minor. Therefore, as coordinated and aided in the recruitment of minors to
frequent Epstein's house so that sexual services were provided to Epstein, scheduled the said minors to return to
the work for Epstein, secured their appointments for the purpose of sexual activity and lewd and lascivious acts
and arranged the bedroom for said minors, there is sufficient probable cause to charge with four
counts of Principal in the Is' degree Unlawful Sexual Activity with a Minor, in violation of Florida State Statute
794.05(l) , a second degree felony and there is sufficient probable cause to charge her with Lewd and
Lascivious Molestation, in violation of Florida State Statute 800.04 (5), a second degree felony.
The foregoing instrument was sworn to or affirmed
before me this 1" day of May, 2006 by
Det Joe Recarey, who is personally known to me.
7- 11
Signature of Politic Officer (F.S.S. 117.10) Date: 05/0
State of Florida
County f Palm Beach
Signature ng Officer
Pageant 22
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                                      JEGE, Inc. [epstein] Epstein company 
 Alex Acosta [republican] oversaw Epstein's 2007 sweetheart deal, Labor Secretary under Trump, resigned over Epstein [npr] 
                                              Sarah Kellen [employee] now Sarah Vickers, named co-conspirator [dailybeast] 
                   Nadia Marcinko aka Emma Marcinko aka Nadja Marcinkova [girls] Lolita Express pilot [archive/dailybeast] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00194840 (Jmail)
 [legal] DOJ criminal indictment of Jeffrey Epstein
EFTA00009622 (Jmail)
 [girls] handwritten notes from a victim interview transcribed by Claude AI
(date: 2006-07-19)
<REDACTED> s GJ Test.          7/19/2006

<REDACTED> dob          16 yrs

<REDACTED> - Loxahatchee

2005 <REDACTED>          9th grade

<REDACTED> was outside          asked to date <REDACTED>

1/10/19 <REDACTED>

~~talked in depth~~

met for first time the night before went to JE
11:30 ish 10
do you want to make $200
meet my friend Jeff  bighouse
but you have to give massage 45 min + that's all you have to do get $200

<REDACTED> told <REDACTED> + <REDACTED> went to Bathroom to argue
came back out <REDACTED> called Jeff on the phone.
1 assistant answered the pho...

Jeff asst answered phone - <REDACTED> had someone to give massage Lady asked how old I was
she told the lady 18 + went to <REDACTED>

Its $200     didn't care what
<REDACTED> - Lady trying to verify 18 Yes
Graduated from <REDACTED>     Known <REDACTED> for a long time
& the next morning

<REDACTED> + another girl     - going to Mall he <REDACTED> didn't care

<REDACTED> asked dad for $     yeh sure fine ok

House in Palm Beach
all got out of car     gate at back door     security guard the saw us     the <REDACTED> asked us where...
Page 3

<REDACTED> said Jeffrey
Went to kitchen     waited 15 min

JE + asst     walked in back door

shook hands     met both JE asst.

(A) JE     chose gonna go first

JE said how about you
<REDACTED>     upstairs     "asst lady"

walked me up there stripping out all this picture

She pulled out massage table me     front of couch     blanket over table     opened drawer     whole bunch of lotions  
+ pick some out
She told me keep bra + panties on + get undress

No <REDACTED>  told her I thought a massage keep your clothing
stay in the room
I came in the room     HE + shook hands
Came back in the room
JE: old 50ish

initially   guy golfy   khaki pants pullover
t-shirt + jeans     thong     bra

hesitant     thinking what's going on.
I didn't care cause I wanted $200
He laid on massage table     He said grab any 3 lotions
Started to give him
What M.S.     did you go to told     him she was 16 Not
do you like to do     small talk <REDACTED>
Sat on table     15-20 minute conversation     another house in NY

He asked if I wanted to make an extra $300
Straddle him
massage over -
but if you're not comfortable giving a massage can I <REDACTED> on you  ~~anything~~
<REDACTED>     said ok
JE left + came back

<REDACTED>     kind of like a <REDACTED>
grabbed that + layed down back on table     ~~old~~ ~~old~~ hands

Give me a     massage on chest use the <REDACTED>     10 minutes or so ( after     a couple ~~of~~ minutes ( on 
<REDACTED>

(A) <REDACTED> said if he did that he would have to pay her extra money if he >
Page 6

<REDACTED>     not she would have to didn't     tell her     ~~get~~ ~~over~~ do her clothes at He <REDACTED>     you 
get paid

<REDACTED>

Yes     Saw <REDACTED>

He opened wallet     got the   $200

He told her to write Name + #

after that left the room

I didn't see him <REDACTED>

I was scared to tell

<REDACTED>     her body not his body
Went down by herself    got 1st  No didn't do anything  but <REDACTED>  $200 ~~too~~

Page 7
I figure it was probably because she brought me

What happened     I got $300 I was excited

What did you have to do with him
If you do this you get that
Laughing ~~in~~     Thanks for fully me I was going to ~~much~~ ~~go~~ ~~many~~ Oh sorry.
Didn't plan it

If you ever need money
Oh yeh     - everybody

I did not ever go back to house

at school my best friend I told her if you ever want to make 300.-o massage Told <REDACTED>     <REDACTED>

Page 8
<REDACTED>     telling everybody I confronted her     altercation get into a fight <REDACTED>

Spreading rumors about me Let me see in your purse you don't have to lie Stefand I worked at <REDACTED>

I didn't think it was her business and     why would tell on myself

You don't have to lie I knew what happen
Everything came out

<REDACTED>     then I didn't want to tell them what had happened,

I <REDACTED>

<REDACTED> Family Setty a lot problems

No     the only <REDACTED>     sometimes
Page 9

<REDACTED>     Have you ever da[ting] <REDACTED> Survey -     Yeh
<REDACTED>     not anymore
14 birthday     my dad
I did <REDACTED>     lots of time

$250,000     its a joke
tall skinny     dark hair
Page 10
EFTA00522943 (Jmail)
 [misc] Epstein's medicine cabinet includes fertility drugs, two kinds of benzos (like Xanax), low level opioids, ED drugs, stimulants, and syringes
(approximate date: 2006-07-27)
Emergency
-Medrol pack 4mg
-Depo-Medrol
-Epipen Adult
-Benadryl
-Zantac
-Claritin

Cardiovascular

• Plavix /Clopidogrel 75mg x 20tab
• Eliquis 5mg x 60 tab
• Nitrostat /Nitroglycerin 0.4mg x 100 tab
• Enoxaparin Sodium injection 40mg/0.4m1
• Atenolol 25mg
• Toprol XL 25mg

Antibiotics
-Augmentin 875mg/ Amox-clav 875-125 x 20 tab
-Vibramycin 100mg/ Doxycycline Hyclat x 20 cap
-Cipro 500mg/ Ciprofloxacin HCI x 10 tab
-Bactrim DS/ Sulfamethoxazole-T x 14 tab
-Flagyl/ Metronidazole 500mg x 21tab
-Garamycin/ Gentamicin Opth. solution 0.3%
-Cortisporin/ Neomycin-Polymixin 5 ml
-Zithromax/ Azithromycin 250mg x 6 tab
-Cephalexin 500mg
-Clarithromycin 500mg/Biaxin
-Cefuroxime Axetil 500mg/Ceftin
-Suprax 400mg

Cold, cough, flu
-Termometer
-Robitussin cough/ Adult tussah 237m1
-Benzonatate 200mg x 20cap
-Sudafed
-Sudafed PE
-Cepacol for sore throat
-Colludol: sore throat spray
-Chloraseptic
-Mucinex D
-Mucinex DM
-Afrin nasal spray
-Vicks vapornhaler

Gastrointestinal
-Imodium A-D 2mg x 24 tab
-Pepcid/ Famotidine 10mg
-Prilosec/ Omeprazole 20mg x 28tab
-Pepto-Bosmol tabs
-Tums
-Pepto-bismol
-Phosphate oral saline laxative
-Dexilant

NSAIDs
-Aspirin 325mg
-Aspirin 81mg
-Aspirine 1000mg
-Motrin / Ibuprofen 800mg
-Advil
-Diclofenac

Pain
-Ultram/Tramadol 50mg x 30tab
-Fioricet 50-325-40/ Butalb-Acetamin-Ca x 30 tab
-Maxalt 10mg/ Rizatriptan 10mg x 4 tab
-Tylenol Extra strength 500mg x 50 caplets
-Tylenol regular sterngth 325mg
-Lamaline (acetaminophen +opium+caffeine)
-Prontalgine (acetaminophen+codeine+caffeine)

Asthma
-Proair HFA 90mcg x 8.5gm
-Advair 250-50 Disk x 60b1s
-Flonase
-Montelukast/Singulair

Antihistamine
-Zyrtec
-Levocetirizine 5mg tab

Misc
-Zofran/Ondansetron HCI 4mg x 30tab
-Trueplus glucose 4 x 50tab
-Stendra/avanafil tab
-Diflucan/fluconazole 150mg tab
-Metformin 500mg tab
-Crestor/rosuvastatin calcium 10mg tab
-Adcirca 20mg tab
-Nuvigil 50mg
-Clonazepam/Klonopin 0.5mg tab
-Tamsulosin HCl/Flomax 0.4mg
-Gabapentin/Neurontin 300mg
-Ativan 0.5mg
-Clomiphene Citrate 50mg tab
-Famvir/Famcilovir 500mg x 20tab
-Antivert/Meclizine 12.5mg x 30tab
-Atorvastatin 10mg tab
-Atorvastatin 20mg tab
-Lasix/ Furosemide 20mg x 5tab
-Murine ear drops

Supplements
-Vitamin C 500mg
-Vitamin D3 2000 IU
-Vitamin B12 1000 mcg
-Vitamin B12 500 mcg spray

Topical, syringes
-Lotrimin/Clotrimazole 1% cream
-Elocon/ Mometasone furcate 1% cream
-Neosporin Ointment/ Triple antiriotic 28.4gm
-Silver Sulfadiazine cream 1%
-Bacitraycin
-Itch-X
-Zinc oxide ointment
-Orajel
-Abreva (coldsore, blister treatment)
-Dentemp
-Bandaids
-BD 5m1 syringes
-BD 3m1 Syringes
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Deutsche Bank [bank] favoured bank of Epstein, the Trump family, and Russian money launderers [ft] 
                           Cantor Fitzgerald [crypto] Howard Lutnick's financial firm [cryptadamus] 
        SDNY [government] Southern District of New York, federal prosecutors covering New York City 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01582043 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Deutsche Bank / Cantor Fitzgerald transaction
(inferred date: 2006-08-01)
Statement of Account ALL AMOUNTS IN EURO "'
TYPE DATE TRANSACTION
01 08/01 JOURNAL
01 08/01 SOLD
TYPE DATE TRANSACTION
01 08/01/06 INTEREST
li!t CREDIT SUISSE
INV REP
20ST
ACCOUNT TAXPAYER ID. STATEMENT PERIOD PAGE
746FY UNDISCLOSED 08/01/06 TO 08/31/06 3 OF
TRADING ACTIVITY FOR THE MONTH
QUANTITY DESCRIPTION
1,304 DEUTSCHE POSTBANK AG
OFFSHORE ARRANGING FLIP
TO 736EY0 FROM 746FY0
-1,304 DEUTSCHE POSTBANK AG
DONE AT CANTOR, FITZGERALD
CO.
INCOME ACTIVITY FOR THE MONTH
DESCRIPTION
FUNDS DEPOSITED HAVE EARNED
CREDIT INT 8 AVG RATE 2.940
FOR 31 DAYS
FROM 07/01 TO 07/31
CLOSE 8AL 6414.20 CR
AVG BAL 6413.61 CR
CREDIT SUISSE SECURITIES ( USA) LLC
ELEVEN MADISON AVENUE
NEW YORK NY 10010-3629
PRICE
56.30000
DEBIT CREDIT
73,305.08
73,305.08
DEBIT CREDIT
TEL: 212-325-2000
FAX: 212-538-5540
16.18
13
Confidential Treatment Requested by JPMorgan Chase JPM-SDNY-00061537
EFTA00003868 (Jmail)
 [government] photo lineup featuring Epstein
(date: 2006-08-09)
photo lineup featuring Epstein
EFTA01086463 (Jmail)
 [money] Mortimer Zuckerman's art collection valuations
(inferred date: 2006-08-15)
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Weege,
William
Louisville
Series: Apollo
and Ben Brush
Frame 12/1/1983 $2,000.00 Aspen, 418
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
$4,000.00
Highby,
Wayne
Fortress
Rocks Bay
Object 12/1/1983 $3,000.00 Aspen, 418
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
$12,000.00
Warner,
Deborah C.
Wetland
Series II
Object 2/1/1984 $2,000.00 Washington,
DC USN
$2,000.00
Janeiro, Jan Kimono Form Object 12/1/1983 $1,000.00 Aspen, 418 $3,200.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Page 1 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Al-Hilali, Neda Groucho's Object 12/1/1983 $2,000.00 Aspen, 418 $2,000.00
1938- Picnic Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
T
ksikarox
Weege, Untitled #697 Object 12/1/1983 $2,000.00 East Hampton, $4,000.00
William 21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
i Brill, Glenn Lets Jest Frame $0.00 East Hampton, $4,000.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
McCafferty, Svadhyana Object
Jay
12/1/1983 $4,500.00 East Hampton, $4,500.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
Page 2 of 70
1.4 -11•4
14 SI" 4' it•
varStlanatilid I
imil.40•Insi Si W.“
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Hughto,
Margie
Odyssey Object 10/1/1984 $2,800.00 Aspen, 418
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
$12,000.00
Hughto,
Margie
Iris Mist Object $0.00 Aspen, 418
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
$6,500.00
Thorpe, Hilda Message Object 12/1/1983 $3,000.00 Aspen, 418 $3,000.00
Multiple -
Landscapes
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Karma, Elena Sky Trumpet Object 12/1/1983 $0.00 Aspen, 418 $5,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Page 3 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Soldner, Paul Untitled Object $0.00 Aspen, 418 $14,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Morris, William Standing Object $0.00 East Hampton, $12,000.00
Stone 21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
Morris, William Untitled Object 12/1/1983 $3,500.00 East Hampton, $12,000.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
Lindquist, Sculptural Object
Melvin Vase
$0.00 Aspen, 418 $10,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Page 4 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
■ Daley, William Shang Play Object 12/1/1983 $3,000.00 Aspen, 418 $28,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
v.
Genn, Nancy Saville Frame $0.00 Aspen, 418 $9,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Woodman, Ming
Betty Memories -
Three Part
Vase
Object $0.00 East Hampton, $20,000.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
Chihuly, Dale Sea Form Object $0.00 New York , $12,000.00

(b. 1941) Series 950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 5 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Bacerra, Ralph Birds Object $0.00 East Hampton, $6,000.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Brill, Glenn Zoot Alors Frame 12/1/1983 $0.00 Aspen, 418 $3,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Saxe, Adrian Antelope Jar, Object
Celadon
Trophy
$0.00 East Hampton, $25,000.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Bean, Bennett Untitled Object $0.00 Aspen, 418 $6,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Page 6 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Hill, Clinton Dutch Whore Object 12/1/1983 $2,500.00 Aspen, 418 $8,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Dillingham, Tall necked Object $0.00 East Hampton, $1,500.00
Rick Orange Pot 21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Warner, Wetland Object 2/1/1984 $2,000.00 Aspen, 418 $2,000.00
Deborah C. Series I Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Yarmolinsky, Transilience Frame $0.00 Washington, $1,000.00
Sirpa DC USN
Page 7 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Lieberman, Untitled, 1979- Frame $0.00 Aspen, 418
Louis 1980 Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
$500.00
Nevelson, Six Pointed Frame $0.00 East Hampton, $10,000.00
Louise (1899- Star, 1980 21 Drew Lane,

1988) East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Zucca, Edward Twelve-legged Object 12/1/1983 $5,000.00 Aspen, 418 $5,000.00
Table Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Lyman, Marie Paper Robe: Frame $0.00 Aspen, 418
Shades of a Wrights Road,
Former Aspen, CO,
Personae 81611, US
$500.00
Page 8 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Al-Hilali, Neda Pleated Piece Frame 12/1/1983 $1,300.00 Aspen, 418 $1,300.00
1938- Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Anker. Snake Frame 12/1/1983 $900.00 Aspen, 418 $900.00
Suzanne Charmer
Series (#2)
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Noland,
Kenneth
(1924)
Winds Object 12/1/1983 $12,000.00 Aspen, 418
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
$12,000.00
Anker,
Suzanne
Snake
Charmer
Series
Frame 12/1/1983 $900.00 Aspen, 418
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
$900.00
81611, US
Page 9 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic Location
Acquisition Name
Price
Current
Domestic
Value
Hill, Charles Nerdy
Christopher
Frame 12/1/1983 $3,000.00 Aspen, 418 $20,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
O'Banion,
Nance
Iridescent Object
Rain: Light,
Iridescent
Rain: Dark
12/1/1983 $1,100.00 Aspen, 418
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
$1,100.00
Desk $0.00 Washington,
DC USN
$0.00
Kirshen-Cole, C.C. Nitara Frame
Stephanie
12/1/1983 $2,800.00 Aspen, 418 $2,800.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Page 10 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Kirshen-Cole, Jagat Jawal Frame
Stephanie
12/1/1983 $2,800.00 Aspen, 418 $2,800.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Female Mask Object 9/29/1987 through Sheila
Maynes
$185.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$300.00
Okuyi Dance Object Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $150,000.00
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 11 of 70
01
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Maternity Object Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $125,000.00
Figure with Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
Diving Bowl York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Kete Dance Object 4/7/1997 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $150,000.00
Mask Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Hook Piece Object 2/14/1988 Phyllis Hattis $145,000.00 New York , $3,000,000.00
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 12 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Maji Mask (Ibo Object
Mask)
6/3/1988 Phyllis Hattis $8,500.00 New York , $65,000.00
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
"Welcome" Object 1/9/2006 Phyllis Hattis $55,000.00 New York , $75,000.00
Mask Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Lwalwa Mask Object 1/9/2006 Phyllis Hattis $45,000.00 New York , $75,000.00
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 13 of 70
•
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Bird
(porpianong)
Object 10/16/1990 Phyllis Hattis $132,500.00 New York ,
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$1,000,000.00
Ahrens, Wick Whale Object 6/11/1998 Allan Stone $3,500.00 East Hampton, $3,500.00
Gallery, New 21 Drew Lane,
York East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Bowl 6/1/1981 Gift from 10 $0.00 New York ,
King David 950 Fifth
Antiquities Avenue, PH,
Ltd., New York,
Jerusalem New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$0.00
Page 14 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Arman (1928 - French Horns Object
2005)
10/24/1988 Phyllis Hattis $9,000.00 New York , $150,000.00
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Arman (1928 - Saxophones Overall
2005)
10/24/1988 Phyllis Hattis $9,000.00 Aspen, 418 $150,000.00
Fine Arts, New Wrights Road,
York Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Vase $0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$7,800.00
Page 15 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Vase $0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$7,800.00
Twelve Blue- Object
and-white
Figures
Representing
Signs of
Zodiac
6/10/1986 The $2,959.00 New York ,
Underground 950 Fifth
Jeweler Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$2,574.00
Statue of Jizo Object 4/8/1986 Sugimoto
Bosatsu Works of Art
$114,000.00 New York , $500,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 16 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic Location
Acquisition Name
Price
Current
Domestic
Value
Buddha Head
and Shoulders
Object 4/15/1978 Weisbrod & Dy
Limited, New
York
$13,000.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$35,000.00
Avery, Milton
(1893 - 1965)
Avery's Palette Sheet 10/6/1977 Harcus
Krakow
Gallery,
Boston
$10,800.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$200,000.00
Calder,
Alexander
Planets in a
Cage
Framed 11/19/1986 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts, New
York
$19,360.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$250,000.00
Page 17 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Calder, Runners Framed 11/19/1986 Phyllis Hattis $27,830.00 New York , $300,000.00
Alexander Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
I• • •
.,
Calder, Far Out White Object 5/17/1985 Barbara $125,000.00 New York ,
Alexander Lily Krakow 950 Fifth
Gallery, Avenue, PH,
Boston New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$4,500,000.00
Calder, A Suite of Object 6/30/1992 Phyllis Hattis $57,500.00 New York , $250,000.00
Alexander Pocket Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
Mobiles York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 18 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Calder, A Suite of Object 6/30/1992 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $250,000.00
Alexander Pocket Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
Mobiles York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Calder, A Suite of Object
Alexander Pocket
Mobiles
6/30/1992 Phyllis Hauls $0.00 New York ,
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$250,000.00
Calder, Explosive Object 12/11/1997 PaceWildenste $600,000.00 New York , $3,500,000.00
Alexander Object in, New York 950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 19 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Calder, The
Alexander Venomous
Potato
Object 5/27/1998 Crane Kalman $120,000.00 New York ,
Gallery, 950 Fifth
London Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$250,000.00
Caro, Anthony Table Piece Object
CCCLXXIX
11/1/1978 Krakow
Gallery
$5,500.00 New York , $125,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Chagall, Marc Les Amants Object
(1887 -1985) (En bleu)
2/1/1989 Phyllis Hattis $700,829.50 New York , $3,500,000.00
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 20 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Chihuly, Dale Macchia Object 7/1/1998 $30,000.00 New York , $30,000.00

(b. 1941) 950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Christo (b. Running Framed 7/29/1976 Sculpture to $3,600.00 East Hampton, $70,000.00

1935) Fence Wear, Inc., 21 Drew Lane,
New York via East Hampton,
Barbara New York,
Krakow 11937, US, Fir
Gallery N/A, N/A, N/A
Blue and
White Vase
3/31/1977 Jin Po Kok & $0.00 New York ,
Siu's Trading 950 Fifth
Co., Hong Avenue, PH,
Kong New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$21,012.00
Page 21 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Blue and Overall 3/31/1977 Jin Po Kok & $0.00 New York , $21,012.00
White Vase Siu's Trading 950 Fifth
Co., Hong Avenue, PH,
Kong New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Carpet Object 3/25/1987 M. Gomez $80,000.00 New York , $190,000.00
Associates, 950 Fifth
Inc. New York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Grandfather Object 1/1/1985 through Bieriy $3,450.00 East Hampton, $0.00
Clock Drake 21 Drew Lane,
Associates, East Hampton,
Boston New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Page 22 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Vase
;4 OI..'  . f•
O.'
$0.00 New York
Office, Boston
Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, Fir
18
$900.00
Pewter
Tankards (3),
Platters (2) &
Candlesticks
(2)
Small Tankard 1/1/1985 Acquired $1,580.00 East Hampton, $0.00
through Bierly 21 Drew Lane,
Drake East Hampton,
Assoicates, New York,
Boston 11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Degas, Edgar Danseuse Object
Saisant la
Reverence
11/16/1995 Phyllis Hattis $26,450.00 New York ,
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$200,000.00
Page 23 of 70
CTh4.
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
de Kooning, Untitled IV Image
Willem (1904 -
1997)
2/23/2000 Mitchell-Innes
& Nash
$775,000.00 New York , $7,000,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
--s tam :-= - 7"rs
7 4,4
Diebenkom, Ochre
Richard (1922
- 1993)
print 5/5/1984 Leslie Feely $4,075.00 East Hampton, $55,000.00
Fine Art, New 21 Drew Lane,
York East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Diebenkom, Ocean Park # Image 1/7/2000 Leslie Feely $1,450,000.00 New York , $10,000,000.0
Richard (1922 127 Fine Art, New 950 Fifth 0
- 1993) York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 24 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Diebenkom, Spoon & Letter Image $0.00 East Hampton, $75,000.00
Richard (1922 21 Drew Lane,
- 1993) East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Diebenkom, Landscape Object 11/28/2005 Leslie Feely $2,575,000.00 New York , $6,000,000.00
Richard (1922 with Freeway Fine Art, New 950 Fifth
- 1993) York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Dine, Jim Frosted Night Image
Robe I
$0.00 New York , $75,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 25 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Dine, Jim Red Etching Image
Robe
3/15/1977 Harcus $1,200.00 New York , $10,000.00
Krakow 950 Fifth
Gallery, Avenue, PH,
Boston New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Dine, Jim Carnegie Hall Image
Heart
$0.00 New York
Office, Boston
Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, FIr
18
$7,500.00
Mummy $0.00 New York , $25,000.00
Cartonnage 950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 26 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Estes, Richard Holland Hotel Image 3/22/1984 Barbara $5,500.00 New York $27,000.00
Krakow Office, Boston
Gallery, Properties,
Boston Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, FIr
18
Fassbender, Water
Adolf Diamonds
Image 6/6/2000 Howard $6,500.00 Lazy Z $9,000.00
Greenberg
Gallery, New
York
I
Frankenthaler, Ponti Framed 5/9/1975 Harcus, $1,100.00 New York
Helen Krakow, Office, Boston
Rosen, Properties,
Sonnabend Inc., 599
Gallery, Lexington
Boston Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, FIr
18
$5,500.00
Page 27 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Console Table Object 91911987 Newell Gallery $7,500.00 $0.00
Inc., New York
■w Door with Object
Base
$0.00 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
$0.00
Side Chair 5/7/1987 M. Gomez $2,550.00 $0.00
Associates,
Inc. New York
Armchairs $0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$0.00
Page 28 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Armchairs $0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$0.00
Stand 5/7/1987 M. Gomez $8,000.00 New York ,
Associates, 950 Fifth
Inc. New York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$0.00
Stand $0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$0.00
Page 29 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Writing Table Object 5/21/1987 M. Gomez $19,500.00 New York ,
Associates, 950 Fifth
Inc. New York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$0.00
Eil Tray Table Object 5/21/1987 IE. Gomez $6,800.00 CitiGroup
Associates, Center
Inc. New York Storage, 153
E. 53rd Street,
New York, NY,
10022, US, Fir
Basement - C2
$0.00
EEI
Console Object 1/1/1985 through Bierly $3,800.00 East Hampton, $5,094.00
Drake 21 Drew Lane,
Associates, East Hampton,
Boston New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Fruitwood Object through Bierly $4,200.00 East Hampton, $7,000.00
Server Drake 21 Drew Lane,
Associates, East Hampton,
Boston New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Page 30 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Server 1/1/1985 through Bierly $3,400.00 East Hampton, $6,000.00
Drake 21 Drew Lane,
Associates, East Hampton,
Boston New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Pine Hutch Base 1/1/1985 through Bierly $2,300.00 East Hampton, $2,875.00
Drake 21 Drew Lane,
Associates, East Hampton,
Boston New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
English 1/1/1985 Acquired $2,875.00 East Hampton, $0.00
Comishware through Bierly 21 Drew Lane,
Dishes Drake East Hampton,
(Display in Associates, New York,
Pine Hutch) Boston 11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Rain Drum Object 1/1/1985 through Bierly $1,400.00 East Hampton,
Drake 21 Drew Lane,
Associates, East Hampton,
Boston New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
$1,750.00
Page 31 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Giacometti, Le Model Object
Alberto and Creevers
Diego (Lampadaire
Figure)
3/8/1985 Phyllis Hattis $23,100.00 New York , $300,000.00
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Giacometti, Le Model Object 3/8/1985 Phyllis Hattis $24,200.00 New York , $300,000.00
Alberto and Creevers Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
Diego (Lampadaire York Avenue, PH,
Figure) New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Giacometti, Lampadaire a Object
Alberto and l'etoile
Diego
12/9/1985 Phyllis Hattis $17,166.67 New York , $175,000.00
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 32 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Giacometti, Lampadaire Object
Alberto and Surrealiste
Diego
12/9/1985 Phyllis Hattis $17,166.67 New York , $150,000.00
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Giacometti, Lampadaire a Object
Alberto and l'etoile
Diego
12/9/1985 Phyllis Hattis $17,166.67 New York , $175,000.00
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Giacometti, Lampe
Alberto and trepieds a
Diego l'etoile
Object 12/9/1985 Phyllis Hattis $17,166.67 New York , $75,000.00
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 33 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
1 Giacometti, Large Table Object 12/9/1985 Phyllis Hattis $17,166.67 New York , $130,000.00
Alberto and Lamp with Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
Diego Tower Motif California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Giacometti, Table Lamp Object
Alberto and with Tower
Diego Motif
12/9/1985 Phyllis Hattis $17,166.67 New York , $130,000.00
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Giacometti, Profile Image 11/19/1986 Phyllis Hattis $15,730.00 New York ,
Alberto Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$75,000.00
Page 34 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Giacometti, Console au Object
Diego Juliet,
cameleon,
renard et
chiens
5/14/1999 Christie's, New $310,500.00 New York , $600,000.00
York 950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Giacometti, Table aux Object 3/13/2000 Greenberg $95,000.00 East Hampton, $95,000.00
Diego torsades, Van Doren 21 Drew Lane,
modele carre Gallery, St. East Hampton,
Louis New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Gilliam, Sam Ray I
(1933-)
Image 11/18/1986 $0.00 Aspen, 418 $5,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Page 35 of 70
IN;)
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Gorky, Arshile Untitled Image 6/11/1998 Allan Stone $250,000.00 New York , $500,000.00
(1904-1948) Gallery, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Gottlieb, Pictograph Canvas Size 8/15/2006 Phyllis Hattis $500,000.00 New York , $1,500,000.00
Adolph (Pink and Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
Blue) York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Hockney, Celia Seated Image 11/3/1983 Barbara $6,500.00 New York , $10,000.00
David (1937- ) in an Office Krakow 950 Fifth
Chair Gallery, Avenue, PH,
Boston New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 36 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Hoffman,
Josef (1870-
1956)
Oval Tray Object 1/12/1998 Historical
Design Inc.,
New York
$4,750.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
$4,000.00
12-15, N/A,
N/A
James,
Christopher
Priscilla's
Room
Image 3/30/1979 Harcus
Krakow
Gallery,
Boston
$178.75 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
$550.00
S
N/A, N/A, N/A
James,
Christopher
Northfield Inn
Door
Image 3/30/1979 Harcus
Krakow
Gallery,
Boston
$178.75 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
$500.00
N/A, N/A, N/A
James,
Christopher
Priscilla's
Dream
Image 3/30/1979 Harcus
Krakow
Gallery,
Boston
$178.75 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
$500.00
N/A, N/A, N/A
Page 37 of 70
Artist Name
James,
Christopher
Kline, Martin
(1961- )
Kraft, Polly
Financial Report
Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic
Acquisition
Price
Location
Name
Current
Domestic
Value
Northfield Inn Image 3/30/1979 Harcus
Krakow
Gallery,
Boston
$178.75 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
$500.00
New Bloom Image 1/25/2000 Marlborough
Gallery, New
York
$5,000.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$25,000.00
Table Top with
Pears
Image 4/2/1986 Fischbach
Gallery, New
York
$5,500.00 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
$8,000.00
Paperwhites Image $0.00 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
$4,500.00
Page 38 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Lanel, Luc Dinanderie Object 1/12/1998 Historical $8,500.00 New York ,
(1893-1965) vase Design Inc., 950 Fifth
New York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$7,500.00
Lanel, Luc Vase Object 1/12/1998 Historical $10,500.00 New York , $9,000.00
(1893-1965) Design Inc., 950 Fifth
New York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Lanel, Luc Copper Vase Object
(1893-1965)
1/12/1998 Historical
Design Inc.,
New York
$5,500.00 New York , $6,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 39 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
pi
p
Leger, Jaune II
Fernand (1881
-1955)
Image 10/20/1985 Phyllis Hattis $6,500.00 Aspen, 418 $12,000.00
Fine Arts, Wrights Road,
California Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Leger, Composition Image 1/5/1984 Barbara $6,000.00 New York , $8,500.00
Fernand (1881 aux Deux Krakow 950 Fifth
-1955) Personnages Gallery, Avenue, PH,
Boston New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Leger, Le Coquillage Image 4/7/1997 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $9,500,000.00
Fernand (1881 Jaune Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
-1955) York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 40 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Lichtenstein, Landscape 7 Image 11/8/1973 Harcus $475.00 New York , $6,000.00
Roy (1923- Krakow 950 Fifth

1997) Gallery, Avenue, PH,
Boston New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Lichtenstein, Modem
Roy (1923- Painting with

1997) Green
Segments
Image 9/24/1997 Leslie Feely $625,000.00 New York , $8,000,000.00
Fine Art, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Lipchitz, Study fora Image 11/28/1988 Phyllis Hattis $12,100.00 New York , $12,000.00
Jacques (1891 Sculpture Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
-1973) York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 41 of 70
Artist Name
Lipchitz,
11 Jacques (1891
-1973)
Liu. Dan
Louis. Morris
(1912-1962)
Financial Report
Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic Location
Acquisition Name
Price
Current
Domestic
Value
Figure Group
with Bull
Overall 7/31/2000 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts, New
York
$33,000.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$45,000.00
Vertical Rock
Painting
Object 11/25/1996 Liu Dan, New
York
$41,000.00 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
$45,000.00
2=13 Image $0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$500,000.00
Page 42 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Mangold, Blue/ Black Image 4/30/1999 PaceWildenste $18,000.00 Lazy Z $45,000.00
Robert (1937-) Five Panel in, New Yolk
Zone Painting
(Study)
I.NE WO%
IN MI*
Masson, Une Saison en Object 11/25/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $6,500.00
Andre (1896- Enfer Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
1987) York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Massad, G. Iris Image 2/8/1997 Tatistcheff and $25,000.00 East Hampton, $30,000.00
Daniel (1946-) Company, 21 Drew Lane,
New York East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
Massad, G. Iris: Study Image 6/18/1998 Tatistcheff and $4,500.00 East Hampton, $5,000.00
Daniel (1946-) Company, 21 Drew Lane,
New York East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
Page 43 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Matisse, Henri Le Cauchemar Sheet size 1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $15,000.00 New York , $15,000.00
(1869- 1954) de ('elephant Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
(from the Jazz California Avenue, PH,
suite) New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Matisse, Henri Le Coeur Sheet 1/2/1985 Phyllis Hafts $0.00 New York , $15,000.00
(1869- 1954) (from the Jazz Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
suite) California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Matisse, Henri Le Loup (from Sheet
(1869- 1954) the Jazz suite)
1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $15,000.00
Fine Arts. 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 44 of 70
1
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Matisse, Henri Cirque (from Framed
(1869- 1954) the Jazz suite)
1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $15,000.00
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Matisse, Henri Monsieur Sheet 1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $9,500.00
(1869- 1954) Loyal (from the Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
Jazz suite) California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Matisse, Henri L'avaleur de Sheet 1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York , $9,500.00
(1869- 1954) sabres (from Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
the Jazz suite) California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 45 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic
Acquisition
Price
Location
Name
Current
Domestic
Value
Matisse, Henri
(1869- 1954)
untitled (from
the Jazz suite)
Sheet 1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts,
California
$0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$1,500.00
t. g erff :
r.
1••••••"- -
Matisse, Henri
(1869- 1954)
untitled (from
the Jazz suite)
Sheet 1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts,
California
$0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$1,500.00
Matisse, Henri
(1869- 1954)
untitled (from
the Jazz suite)
Sheet 1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts,
California
$0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$1,500.00
r.a itle• :fir
A..'  5: 7
Page 46 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Matisse, Henri untitled (from Sheet
(1869- 1954) the Jazz suite)
g tmirr:  ittSte .f .
C'Anir
g,r a,
t r
Pr:Zi -
sti 4". rea'reC; rte ,
1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York ,
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$1,500.00
"zz
Matisse, Henri untitled (cover Sheet 1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York ,
(1869- 1954) page from the Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
Jazz suite) California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$1,500.00
Matisse, Henri untitled (from Sheet
(1869- 1954) the Jazz suite)
1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York ,
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$1,500.00
Page 47 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Matisse, Henri untitled (from Sheet
(1869- 1954) the Jazz suite)
der '  • --tr.;
ECE• tS
1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York ,
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$1,500.00
Matisse, Henri untitled (from Sheet
(1869- 1954) the Jazz suite)
1/2/1985 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 New York ,
Fine Arts, 950 Fifth
California Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$1,500.00
Matisse, Henri Arabesque image
(1869- 1954)
7/31/1987 Phyllis Hattis $30,000.00 New York , $30,000.00
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 48 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic Location
Acquisition Name
Price
Current
Domestic
Value
Matisse, Henri
(1869- 1954)
Tete de
Femme a la
Collarette
Sheet $0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, NIA,
N/A
$250,000.00
Matisse, Henri
(1869- 1954)
Deux Femmes
a la Banquette
Sheet $0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, NIA,
N/A
$350,000.00
Matisse, Henri
(1869- 1954)
Fbrilege des
Amours de
Ronsard
11/25/1985 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts, New
York
$0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, NIA,
N/A
$20,000.00
,"•• \ HI)
Page 49 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Matisse, Henri
(1869- 1954)
Poemes de
Charles de
Orleans
Object 11/25/1985 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts, New
York
Domestic Location Current
Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
$0.00 New York , $8,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Matisse, Henri Studies of the Plate
(1869- 1954) Female Figure
$0.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$0.00
Merkin, Tragedies of image 6/12/1975 Harcus, $1,250.00 East Hampton, $10,000.00
Richard (1938- Streets Krakow, 21 Drew Lane,
2009) Rosen, East Hampton,
Sonnabend New York,
Gallery, 11937, US, Fir
Boston N/A, N/A, N/A
Page 50 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Mihaesco, Untitled Framed
Eugene
$0.00 New York
Office, Boston
Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, Fir
18
$2,000.00
Miro, Joan Le Hibou Framed 6/24/1988 Phyllis Hattis $48,000.00 New York $60,000.00
(1893-1983) Blasphemateu Fine Arts, New Office, Boston
York Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, Fir
18
Miro, Joan Constellations Object
(1893-1983)
11/25/1985 Phyllis Hattis $4,000.00 New York , $75,000.00
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 51 of 70
•
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic
Acquisition
Price
Location
Name
Current
Domestic
Value
Misrach,
Richard (1949
- )
6.7.98 5:40 am Image
(View From
My Front
Porch)
6/8/2000 Robert Mann
Gallery, New
York
$3,200.00 Lazy Z $7,000.00
Misrach,
Richard (1949
-)
2.21.98 4:46 Image
(View From
My Front
Porch)
6/8/2000 Robert Mann
Gallery, New
York
$3,800.00 Lazy Z $7,000.00
Misrach,
Richard (1949
- )
10.31.98 5:18 Image
pm (View
From My Front
Porch)
6/8/2000 Robert Mann
Gallery, New
York
$1,200.00 Lazy Z $5,000.00
Misrach,
Richard (1949
- )
10.31.98 Image
5:22pm (View
From My Front
Porch)
6/8/2000 Robert Mann
Gallery, New
York
$1,600.00 Lazy Z $5,000.00
Misrach,
Richard (1949
- )
2.16.98 Image
4:55pm (View
From My Front
Porch)
6/8/2000 Robert Mann
Gallery, New
York
$1,600.00 Lazy Z $5,000.00
Page 52 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Misrach, 6.15.1998 Image 6/8/2000 Robert Mann $1,600.00 Lazy Z $5,000.00
Richard (1949 5:48am (View Gallery, New
- ) From My Front York
Porch)
Modigliani, Head of a Image 41611978 Harcus $21,000.00 New York , $350,000.00
Amedeo (1884 Woman Krakow 950 Fifth
-1920) Gallery, Avenue, PH,
Boston New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Moore, Henry The Artist's Framed
(1898-1986) Hands
3/13/1987 Phyllis Hattis $25,000.00 New York , $25,000.00
Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 53 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Motherwell, St. Michel II Sheet 9/28/1979 Harcus $2,068.00 New York , $6,500.00
Robert (1915- Krakow 950 Fifth

1991) Gallery, Avenue, PH,
Boston New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Motherwell, Gesture Paper Image
Robert (1915- Painting #9
1991)
$0.00 East Hampton, $55,000.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Motherwell, St. Michael III Image 6/1/1979 Harcus $1,000.00 Aspen, 418 $6,500.00
Robert (1915- Krakow Wrights Road,

1991) Gallery, Aspen, CO,
Boston 81611, US
Nevelson, Dawn Column Image
Louise (1899-
1988)
$0.00 East Hampton, $175,000.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Page 54 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Nevelson, Untitled
Louise (1899-
1988)
Image 5/9/1975 Harcus, $7,500.00 Aspen, 418 $25,000.00
Krakow, Wrights Road,
Rosen, Aspen, CO,
Sonnabend 81611, US
Gallery,
Boston
Nick, George MFA, Oriental Image 3/29/1984 The Harcus $7,500.00 East Hampton, $7,500.00
(1927- ) Collection Gallery, 21 Drew Lane,
Boston East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Nick, George Commonwealt Image 11/20/1982 Harcus $3,850.00 New York $30,000.00
(1927- ) h Triptych Krakow Office, Boston
Gallery, Properties,
Boston Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, Fir
18
Page 55 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Noland, Pacific Coast Framed
Kenneth Series #149
(1924)
$0.00 Aspen, 418 $5,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Noland, Via Sea Image
Kenneth
(1924)
$0.00 New York , $250,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Noland, Last Curtain Framed 11/17/1986 Phyllis Hattis $25,000.00 Aspen, 418 $250,000.00
ir -- 1  Kenneth
(1924)
Fine Arts, New Wrights Road,
York Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Page 56 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Noland, Cherry Shade Image
Kenneth
(1924)
5/12/1983 Leslie Feely $20,000.00 New York $200,000.00
Fine Art, New Office, Boston
York Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, Fir
18
Olitski, Jules Esprit de Image Harcus $6,545.00 Aspen, 418 $35,000.00
(1922- ) Baron Ochs 8 Krakow Wrights Road,
Gallery, Aspen, CO,
Boston 81611, US
Peretz, Anne Untitled Image
(1938-)
$0.00 Aspen, 418 $3,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Page 57 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Picasso, Pablo Femme au Framed
(1881-1973) Fauteuil No. 1
(state 3)
$0.00 New York , $125,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Picasso, Pablo Le Modele Plate
(1881-1973)
10/1/1973 Obelisk $3,500.00 New York , $12,000.00
Gallery, Inc., 950 Fifth
Boston Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Picasso, Pablo Minotaure Framed 2/19/1985 Leslie Feely $14,000.00 New York , $105,000.00
(1881-1973) Caressant une Fine Art, New 950 Fifth
Dormeuse York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 58 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic
Acquisition
Price
Location
Name
Current
Domestic
Value
Picasso, Pablo Mousquetaire
(1881-1973)
Image 11/28/1988 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts, New
York
$143,000.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$850,000.00
Picasso, Pablo
(1881-1973)
Minerva Image 2/15/1990 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts, New
York
$225,000.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$600,000.00
Picasso, Pablo
(1881-1973)
Degas
Imaginant
Plate 2/23/1987 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts, New
York
$4,500.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$9,000.00
Page 59 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic
Acquisition
Price
Location
Name
Current
Domestic
Value
Picasso, Pablo Couple Nu
(1881-1973)
Image 2/10/1989 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts, New
York
$145,000.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$250,000.00
Picasso, Pablo Paloma
(1881-1973) Asleep
Image 11/21/1997 PaceWildenste
in, New York
$4,000,000.00 New York,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$25,000,000.0
0
Picasso, Pablo Nature morte a
(1881-1973) la pomme
Paper 8/15/2006 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts, New
York
$125,000.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$125,000.00
Page 60 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic Location
Acquisition Name
Price
Current
Domestic
Value
Porter,
Katherine
(1941- )
#1 Framed 5/9/1975 Harcus,
Krakow,
Rosen,
Sonnabend
Gallery,
Boston
$1,000.00 New York
Office, Boston
Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, FIr
18
$3,000.00
Porter,
Katherine
(1941- )
Untitled Framed $0.00 New York
Office, Boston
Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, FIr
18
$25,000.00
Reed. Paul
(1919- )
In & Out E Object 1/4/1987 Phyllis Hattis
Fine Arts. New
York
$16,000.00 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
$15,000.00
Page 61 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Reed, Paul 17 - D Image 11/17/1986 Phyllis Hattis $5,600.00 Aspen, 418 $5,600.00
(1919- ) Fine Arts, New Wrights Road,
York Aspen, CO,
81611, US
fiRen, Xiong Flowers of the Image 1/12/1987 Christie's,
(1923-1957) Four Seasons Hong Kong
$0.00 New York , $150,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Ren, Yi (1840- Zhong Kui Image 1/12/1987 Christie's, $0.00 Aspen, 418 $75,000.00
1896) Hong Kong Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Rodin, La Mort Object 6/9/2006 Phyllis Hattis $85,000.00 New York , $85,000.00
Auguste (1840 Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth
-1917) York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 62 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Rothko, Mark No. 215 Object 5/2/2000 Richard Gray $5,450,000.00 New York , $66,000,000.0
1903-1970 (Unititled) Gallery, New 950 Fifth 0
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Ruhlmann, one pair wall Object 6/13/1987 Christie's, New $38,500.00 New York ,
Jacques Emile sconces York 950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$41,676.25
Ruscha, Pool
Edward (1937
-)
Image 3/22/2000 John $55,000.00 East Hampton, $300,000.00
Berggruen 21 Drew Lane,
Gallery, San East Hampton,
Francisco New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Page 63 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Ruscha, Us
Edward (1937
-)
Image 11/21/1998 The Remba
Gallery,
California
$4,000.00 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
$14,000.00
Ruscha, Dogs & Reeds Image 11/21/1998 The Remba $4,050.00 East Hampton, $15,000.00
Edward (1937 Gallery, 21 Drew Lane,
- ) California East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Serra, Richard T.W.U. # 9 Image
(1939- )
11/17/1986 Phyllis Hattis $0.00 Aspen, 418 $45,000.00
Fine Arts, New Wrights Road,
York Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Serra, Richard Out-of-Round Image 3/11/2000 Arts,
(1939- ) III New York
$165,000.00 Aspen, 418 $225,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Page 64 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic Location
Acquisition Name
Price
Current
Domestic
Value
Shatter, Susan St. George
(1943- ) Rooftops
Image 5/9/1975 Harcus,
Krakow,
Rosen,
Sonnabend
Gallery,
Boston
$900.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$5,500.00
Stella. Frank The Hyena
(1936- )
Image 7/10/1989 Phyllis Flatus
Fine Arts, new
York
$130,000.00 New York
Office, Boston
Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, Fir
18
$15,000.00
Stella, Frank The
(1936- ) Counterpane
image $0.00 New York
Office, Boston
Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, Fir
18
$15,000.00
Page 65 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic Location
Acquisition Name
Price
Current
Domestic
Value
Stella, Frank Going Aboard image
(1936- )
$0.00 Aspen, 418 $15,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Stella, Frank Ahab's Leg image
(1936- )
$0.00 Aspen, 418 $15,000.00
Wrights Road,
Aspen, CO,
81611, US
Stella, Frank The Whale as Image
(1936- ) a Dish
$0.00 New York , $15,000.00
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
I Stella, Frank The Quarter image
(1936-) Deck
$0.00 East Hampton, $15,000.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Page 66 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Stella, Frank Moby Dick Image
(1936- )
$0.00 New York $15,000.00
Office, Boston
Properties,
Inc., 599
Lexington
Avenue, Suite
1800, New
York, NY,
10022, US, FIr
18
Stella, Frank Pergusa Three Image
(1936- )
4/6/1984 Leslie Feely $22,000.00 New York , $80,000.00
Fine Art, New 950 Fifth
York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Stella, Frank Flin Fon III Image 5/8/1990 Sotheby's, $451,000.00 New York , $2,500,000.00
(1936- ) New York 950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 67 of 70
5
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Stella, Frank La penne di hu Object
(1936-)
$0.00 East Hampton, $150,000.00
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Steinberg, Middle Class Image 5/18/1984 Phyllis Hattis $12,100.00 New York , $45,000.00
Saul (1914- Riot Fine Arts, New 950 Fifth

1999) York Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Steinberg, S.T. Image 11/8/1978 Christie's $5,800.00 New York , $45,000.00
Saul (1914- 950 Fifth

1999) Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
Page 68 of 70
Artist Name
Steinberg,
Saul (1914-
1999)
1 Stella, Joseph
(1877-1946)
Stella, Frank
(1936- )
Financial Report
Title Dimension
Description
Acquisition Acquired
Date From
Domestic Location
Acquisition Name
Price
Current
Domestic
Value
Two Pyramids Image 6/15/1984 Leslie Feely
Fine Art, New
York
$15,000.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$45,000.00
Pink Flower Image 6/28/1983 Harcus
Krakow
Gallery,
Boston
$14,025.00 New York ,
950 Fifth
Avenue, PH,
New York,
New York,
10021, US, FIr
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$35,000.00
Segseg Object 1/10/2006 Paul Kasmin
Gallery
$173,400.00 East Hampton,
21 Drew Lane,
East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, FIr
N/A, N/A, N/A
$160,000.00
Page 69 of 70
Financial Report
Artist Name Title Dimension Acquisition Acquired Domestic Location Current
Description Date From Acquisition Name Domestic
Price Value
Toulouse- Bruant a I' image $0.00 East Hampton, $90,000.00
Lautrec, Henri Eldorado 21 Drew Lane,
(1864-1901) East Hampton,
New York,
11937, US, Fir
N/A, N/A, N/A
Warhol, Andy Mao Image 7/15/1974 Harcus, $650.00 New York , $45,000.00
(1928-1987) Krakow, 950 Fifth
Rosen, Avenue, PH,
Sonnabend New York,
Gallery, New York,
Boston 10021, US, Fir
12-15, N/A,
N/A
$20,973,151.5 $165,241,443.
2 25
Page 70 of 70
EFTA00000476 (Jmail)
 [money] photo of JEFFREY EPSTEIN CASH DISBURSEMENTS
(date: 2006-09-01)
photo of JEFFREY EPSTEIN CASH DISBURSEMENTS
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                         Bill Richardson [democrat] former governor of New Mexico 
 Eliot Spitzer [democrat] prosecutor / NY governor who went after big banks, prostitution scandal 
                                       Wexner Children's Trust [business] Les Wexner organization 
   Barry Krischer [government] prosecutor in charge of Epstein's sweetheart deal in 2006 [pbpost] 
               Michael Reiter [government] Palm Beach Police chief who first caught Epstein [bbc] 
                          Jack Goldberger [lawyer] Epstein criminal defense attorney on 2008 case 
                                Roy Black [lawyer] Epstein criminal defense attorney on 2008 case 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00067272 (Jmail)
 [article] The Jeffrey Epstein Archives comtemporaneous history
(inferred timestamp: 2006-09-05 12:12:00)
Jeffrey Epstein Archives
Jeffrey Epstein Story in the New York Times Is Very, Very Strange

We keep re-reading the story on Jeffrey Eostein in the New York Times trying to decide what it is that
makes it read so queer. It's not just that it took the paper so long to come around with a story. It's not just
that this story appears now with almost no breaking news hook. There's something weird about the
structure of the thing.
The headline. "Questions of Preferential Treatment Are Raised in Sex Case Against Money Manager" We're
already off onto a meta-story story here. A more straight forward report would be headed "Accusations of
Sex Crimes Made Against Money Manager." The limes, however, goes with the secondary question—
whether or not Epstein is getting preferential treatment in the case.
The lede. Abby Goodnough begins not with the charges against Epstein but with the image of poke
sneaking around through his garbage and phone records. This is how you might begin a screenplay about
Epstein but in a news story, well, it has the effect of pushing Epstein's alleged misdeeds into the
background.
The body In what follows, the Times devotes a total of 437 words to the allegations against Epstein,
around 250 words to allegations that Epstein received preferential treatment and around 236 words to
quoting or summarizing the arguments of Epstein's lawyers. So, if the story itself is pretty balanced between
the actual allegations and the allegations about the allegations, why does the headline and the lead imply
the real story here is about the treatment of Epstein rather than what he's alleged to have done?
Maybe the possibility of a corrupt prosecution is more interesting to the limes but surely it deserves to be
placed behind the coverage of the allegations themselves. Are ink-and-paper journalists so convinced that
the "cover-up is worse than the crime" that they don't care so much about the crimes anymore?
Look. We're glad the Times finally decided the story was fit to print—although we wonder what could have
possibly taken them so long. And what's more, we wonder why they're coverage is so, well, poorly focused.
[DealBreakees Jeff Epstein Archive]
Posted by John Carney at 12:12 PM on September 05, 2006 I Remark I comments (0)1 TrackBacks (0)
As It Turns Out, Jeffrey Epstein Actually Exists
There were a few moments now and then when we started to wonder whether we were hallucinating
Jeffrey Epstein. After all, if the New York Times wasn't reporting on the story it couldn't really be happening,
could it? This is the paper that printed dozens upon dozens of articles on the Augusta National Golf Club's
exclusion of women—complete with howler headlines breaking non-news such as "CBS Refuses Not To
Show Masters"—and if they've got room for that sort of thing, surely at some point over the summer they
might have found room to print one story about the prostitution charges against the mysterious money
manager. The only explanation could be that it wasn't really happening.
So you can imagine our relief Sunday morning when we woke up to discover that we had been right all
along. The Jeffrey Epstein story is happening. It is news worthy. It is fit to print. And we know all this
because it is, finally, in the New York Times.
Case Against
Posted by
Permalink I
Jeffrey
His Campaign Check
Questions of Preferential Treatment Are Raised in Sex
.Money Manager [New York Times]
John Carney at 10:19 AM on September 05, 2006 I
Comments (4)I  TrackBacks (0)
`,Epstein's Taint: Spitzer Returns
Jeff Epstein cannot seem to catch a break. Yesterday more New Mexican politicians dumped his campaign
contributions. Today the New York Sun reports that Eliot Spitzer sent back a whopping $50,000 contribution
from Epstein. When even politicians don't want your money, you know you are in serious trouble. And
Epstein cannot even call his usual masseuses to relieve the stress.
Candidate Spitzer Returns $100.000 In Tainted Campaign Contributions [New York Sun]
Posted by John Carney at 10:09 AM on August 18, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (01 I TrackBadcs (01
More New Mexican Pols Dumping Epstein Money
The ickieness of Jeff Epstein crept quietly into New Mexican politics but it's now being loudly kicked out.
New Mexico's Democratic Land Commissioner candidate Jim Baca announced earlier today in DealBreaker's
comment section that he will donate to charity the money his campaign got from Epstein. Santa Fe Sheriff
Greg Solano—who got $2000 from Epstein—has decided to make $1000 donations to two local charities,
despite the fact that his primary campaign left him in debt. Both men have reportedly denied ever having
met Epstein.
Baca to return billionaire's cash  [The New Mexican]
Sheriff Greg Solano's DealBreaker Comment [DealBreaker]
Jim Baca's DealBreaker Comment [DealBreaker]
Posted by John Carney at 02:35 PM on August 17, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (0) 1 TrackBacks (0)
Does Ken Stevens Have A Secret? The Jeffrey Epstein
Connection
The Limited Brands—the parent company of Victoria's Secret, Limited Express and Bath & Bodyworks—is
losing its CFO, Ken Stevens. After only two months in the post, Stevens is resigning to "spend more time
with his family."
Are people really still saying that? We mean, it could possibly be true but it's such a cliche in the worlds of
business and politics that even if it were true, you wouldn't want to say it. If a dog actually ate your
homework, would you ever try to explain to the teacher that a dog ate your homework?
Here s another, completely speculative theory sparked by Stevens' lame explanation. The
CEO of the Limited is Les Wexner, who just happens to be Jeffrey Epstein's only confirmed client. We can
imagine that these days it would be uncomfortable running the financial aspects of a company whose chief
was so closely connected with Epstein. Is there a connection between Epstein's legal troubles and Stevens'
resignation? Unfortunately, Stevens did not return calls from DealBreaker seeking clarification.
I imfral Brands. "Who Has a Secret'"  [10Q Detective]
Posted by John Carney at 01:00 PM on August 17, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (2) I TrackBacks (0)
Why I'm Keeping Jeffrey Epstein's Money: Sheriff Greg Solano
Explains
The short answer: because being sheriff makes him poor.
Steve Terrell, political reporter for The Santa Fe New Mexican called me tonight to get my comments on the
indictment. He asked me whether I would be returning the money he donated to my campaign. I received
the $2000 donation in August of 2005 and used it for the June 2006 Primary Campaign. I completed the
June Primary having spent all donations and actually ending the campaign over $2000 in debt. That debt
means that the remaining money was paid out of my pocket. So the short answer is there is nothing left to
return. It is now nearly a year since I recieved the donation and the campaign for Sheriff is over and done.
As I have no Republican opponent I will not have to wage a General Election Campaign. I did not plan on
any further fundraising although some who read in my campaign reports that I had ended with a debt
offered to raise some additional money to dear the debt. If I did have the money I probably would return it
or give it to a charity as the $2000, returned to Mr. Epstein who is a billionaire would probably not mean
much to him.
Billionaire Donor In Palm Beach Sex Scandal [Sheriff Greg Salono Blog]
Posted by John Carney at 10:09 AM on August 17, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (5) I TrackBacks (0)
Jeffrey Epstein's Legal Immunity: Maybe It's Politics
Jeffrey Epstein has some powerful friends but it seems he's made some pretty vocal enemies as well. Last
night Bill O'Reilly apparently delivered his "Memo" on the subject of the Epstein prosecution—charging
prosecutor Krischer with political bias. The gist of it is that Krischer was the prosecutor responsible for
bringing charges of drug abuse against Rush Limbaugh, but now seems to be going easy on Epstein. You
get the picture—tough on Republicans, easy on Democrats. Here's O'Reilly on the Epstein situation.
Politics does play a role in local prosecutions, no question about it. And when you examine how much time
and effort state attorney Krischer put into trying to ruin Rush Limbaugh as opposed to what he's doing now
in the far more serious case of Jeffrey Epstein? Many, many questions come to mind and none of those
questions reflect well on Barry Krischer.
Ugh. We hope this isn't what is going on. There's nothing more boring than a debate about political biases.
Another Outrageous Legal Situation in Florida [FoxNews.Com]
Posted by John Carney at 04:06 PM on August 16, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (0) I TrackBacks (0)
Epstein's Defense Tactic —Smear Everyone
It's tough to tell from our safe remove in lower Manhattan exactly what's been going on down in Palm
Beach between the prosecutors and the police. The Florida prosecutors didn't charge Jeffrey Epstein
directly—perhaps because Epstein's legal dream team intimidated-them convinced them that the girls police
had interviewed were not credible witnesses—and the grand jury chose only to indict Epstein for solicitation.
While that charge is still a felony, it is far less serious than the sex with minors charges police had sought.
What's more, the grand jury neglected to charge Epstein's assistant , who is alleged to have
had an instrumental role in setting up the sessions with underage girls, with anything at all. Frustrated with
the local prosecutors, the police have now turned the case over to the FBI in an attempt to have federal
prosecutors bring more serious charges.
So, of course, Epstein's lawyers have gone beyond smearing the girls who allegedly spent time nearly naked
rubbing lotion into the money manager while he rubbed one out into a towel. They are also attacking Palm
Beach Police Chief Epstein, Michael Reiter, 53. They've referred to the chief's pursuit of Epstein as
"craziness," and characterized his dispute with prosecutors as "childish." Someone has also been spreading
rumors that Reiter is involved in a "messy divorce"—which is disgusting non-sequitur that seems clearly
intended to intimidate Reiter into back off the case.
As we said, it's tough to tell exactly what is going on from this remove. But the Palm Beach Post, which is
one of the few mainstream newspapers covering this story in any detail, recently printed a story that seems
to refute the smears against Reiter. It paints as a well-respected professional. Oddly enough, however, the
prosecutor Reiter has sought to have removed from the case, State Attorney Barry Krischer, also seems to
be well respected. As we said, it's hard to tell what is going on down in the world of Palm Beach.
But what's not hard to see is that the Epstein defense has developed a pattern—painting everyone accusing
Epstein of crimes as disrespectable.
Police chief's reputation helps discredit attacks [Palm Beach Post}
Posted by John Carney at 03:27 PM on August 16, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (0) I TrackBacks (0)
Jeffrey Epstein Sex Scandal Roils New Mexico Politics
Stick another pin into your map tracking the scandal surrounding Jeffrey Epstein. The governor of New
Mexico, Bill Richardson, is donating the campaign contributions he got from Epstein to local charities, a New
Mexico newspaper is reporting.
Epstein is said to own one of the largest private home in New Mexico, a 26,700-square-foot hilltop fortress
mansion on his Zorro ranch.
Epstein's been pretty active in New Mexican politics. He reportedly donated $50,000 for Richardson's 2002
campaign and another $50,000 to Richardson's re-election campaign this year, $15,000 to attorney general
candidate Gary King, $10,000 to state land commissioner candidate Jim Baca and $2,000 to Santa Fe
County Sheriff Greg Solano. King says he'll dump the Epstein tainted money, Baca said he is discussing it
with his campaign manager and Sheriff Solano says he has already spent the money and doesn't have any
to return.
A note to King and Baca—you might think twice about actually giving the money back to
Epstein. As we noted before who knows what he's going to use it for. Better to follow Richardson's
example—and we're not saying he picked up the idea from DealBreaker but we secretly suspect he did—and
give the money to charity.
(4nvernor In dump rash from billionaire  [The New Mexican]
Posted by John Carney at 01:25 PM on August 16, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (3) I TrackBacks (0)
FBI Mulling Jeffrey Epstein Investigation
Jeffrey Epstein may be headed for more legal trouble. The New York Post's Dan Mangan is reporting that
the FBI is considering a probe into the alleged sex crimes of the mysterious money manager. Epstein was
indicted by a Palm Beach grand jury for solicitation in connection with paying local teenage girls for
massages during which he allegedly required them to strip down to their panties while he masturbated and
touched them with vibrators. It is also alleged that in at least one incident he paid a girl $1,000 after he
forcibly penetrated her. Epstein is also alleged to have employed a "sex slave" he allegedly claimed to have
purchased from her family in eastern Europe to have sex with one of his untrained masseuses while he
watched.
Palm Beach police, frustrated with what they reportedly view as a lack of dedication on the part of local
prosecutors, have turned information over to the FBI. Mangan breaks news in his story by getting word
from an FBI investigator that the feds are indeed following up on the case.
Mystery Mogul's Teen-Sex Secret Bared in Probe [New York Post]
More of DealBreaker's Jeffrey Epstein Coverage [Archives]
Posted by John Carney at 09:49 AM on August 16, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (0) 1 TrackBacks (0)
Jeffrey Epstein: The Story So Far
This morning's Palm Beach Post carries a lengthy article on Jeffrey Epstein. It mostly tracks what you've
already read here or elsewhere but is worth reading if you haven't followed all the details. Among the
highlights:
Background.

• Jeffrey Epstein's early career at Dalton and Bear Stearns.
• His earlier disputes with former business partners and Citigroup.

• Rumors that he left Bear Stearns under an SEC inquiry cloud.
• Also rumored to have been a spook of some sort.

• Mentored by Steven Hoffenberg "now serving a prison term after 'bilking investors out of more than $450
million in one of the largest Ponzi schemes in American history.'

• His real estate: private island, huge townhouse in Manhattan, gigantic in new Mexico and a alleged
teenage-petting-zee mansion in Palm Beach.

• Powerful friends: top scientists, former Harvard president Larry Summers, Daily News publisher Mort
Zuckerman and Bill Clinton.

• Thought to have 15 clients but only one is known—the Wexner family, founders of The Limited clothing
stores.
Women.

• Long linked to media mogul Robert Maxwell's daughter Ghislaine Maxwell.
• Said to have also dated a former Miss Sweden and a Romanian model.
The Case.

• Investigation began after a mother heard her daughter discussing trips to Epstein's place and contacted
police.

• Private investigators working for Epstein contacted witnesses during the investigation.
• Disputes arose between prosecutors and police.

• An early plea bargain which would have kept Epstein out of jail fell apart.
• Alan Dershowitz flew to Palm Beach to paint the girls making the allegations against Epstein as lying,
thieving, drug and alcohol abusing and unreliable.
• The "Heidi Fleiss" of Palm Beach is alleged to have brought six girls between ages 14 and 18 to Epstein's
house for massages.
While admitting that Epstein had girls over to administer massages, Epstein's camp maintains he is innocent
of any criminal wrong-doing. One of his lawyers even insists Epstein will emerge from the case with his
reputation untarnished.
leffrey Fpstein rrAved hig hom- , elite friends - and, investigators say underage girls [Palm Beach Post]
Posted by John Carney at 10:02 AM on August 14, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (6) I TrackBacks (0)
Clearly, This Is When A Private Plane Comes In Handy
Jossip—which along with DealBreaker, Gawker and the Palm Beach Post is just about the only media outlet
covering the Jeffrey Epstein story—notes that terrorists have totally screwed any plans Epstein might have
had to fly commercial this weekend. No batteries or liquids allowed on planes?
Which more or less means Jeffrey Epstein's weekend is totally fucked. How can he enjoy a night of petting
zoo on his private jet without massage oils and working vibrators? Talk about inconvenience.
Ah. Poor innocent Jossip. Epstein doesn't fly commercial and you can bring whatever you want onto your
private jet. This is what private planes are for. So even terrorists can't fuck with your travel plans.
[Note: As we've said before everything seems dirty when it is about Epstein, even perfectly ordinary
phrases like "comes in handy." Even "Palm Beach Post" is kind of icky and we're not sure why. We're sorry.
That's not out fault. It's either Epstein's or those lying little drug addict sluts.]
[Another note: Shouldn't we have gone with some version of "If Epstein cant travel with lube and vibrators,
the terrorists win?"—El. Uhm, are we still using that joke? If that hasn't jumped the shark, I just threw up
in my mouth a little. Very funny. If we can still do these '- Ed' jokes, f mink we can still do the terrorists win
jokes —Ed. I hope meta is still funny.]
Terrorists Totally Ruin Jeffrey Epstein's Weekend [Jossip]
Posted by John Carney at 04:22 PM on August 10, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (2) I TrackBacks (0)
Epstein Got Off Too Easy, Palm Beach Post Says
y didn't prosecutors charge Jeffrey Epstein with more serious crimes? The police reports
include allegations of sexually-tinged massages with girls as young as 14, human trafficking and something
that seems a lot like rape to us. But he gets slapped with nothing more than a single solicitation charge
after prosecutors referred the case to a grand jury.
So what happened? It seems that EpsteirfsitgiunterecLiegateam crafted an ingenious and original
"drunk, drug-addled lying sluts" defense and intimidated the prosecutors out of bringing charges. Here's
how the Palm Beach Post puts it:
The girls, Mr. Dershowitz told prosecutors, had written on myspace.com about smoking marijuana and
drinking alcohol. But if the girls have a credibility problem, what about Jeffrey Epstein? Mr. Goldberger, told
The Post: "Mr. Epstein absolutely insisted anybody who came to his house be over the age of 18. How he
verified that, I don't know." And prosecutors took him at his word?
A more charitable way to look at the situation is that prosecutors may have been hesitant to put teenage
girls on the stand knowing that Epstein's lawyers would likely turn his trial into a forum for attacks on their
characters, sexual history and allegations of drug use and prostitution.
Massaging the system [Palm Beach Post]
Posted by John Carney at 01:15 PM on August 10, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (0) I TrackBacks (0)
Jeffrey Epstein Fights Back: "These women are liars."
Jeffrey Epstein has launched an army of lawyers and publicists to clear his name and smear the girls who
have accused him of sexual improprieties and solicitation, the Palm Beach Post reports this morning. Here's
a quick look at the line coming out from Epstein's camp.
In Epstein's army: attorneys Jack Goldberger, Alan Dershowitz and. Roy Black. New York publicist Dan
Klores and an unnamed Los Angeles publicist.
The spin: these girls are liars, thieves and drug-users. The Palm Beach police are on a childish vendetta.
What Epstein's camp admits: Epstein did have young women over to his house to administer massages.
There is no explanation for why he was paying untrained girls upwards of $200 for massages.
What they're denying: That Epstein had any knowledge the girls were underage or that Epstein had sex with
any underage girls.
There's a gap between what has been alleged and what is being denied, and that gap might be informative.
Even if Epstein didn't 'have sex' with the girls, did he have them strip and did he masturbate while they
massaged him?
Ugh. Suddenly we're back in Clinton-Lewinsky territory, trying to guess at what the meaning of 'sex' is.
Eostein camp calls female accusers liars [Palm Beach Post]
Posted by John Carney at 10:01 AM on August 08, 2006 I Permalink I fronments (31 i TrackBacks (0)
Joe Francis and The Girls Gone Wild Theory of Jeff
Epstein
Joe Francis, the man who built an empire on young girls exposing themselves for his "Girls Gone Wild"
videos, offers a completely self-serving theory about entrepreneurialism and sex to a writer for the LA Times
magazine.
"Sex sells everything," he says. "It drives every buying decision .. . I hate to get too deep and philosophical
here, but only the guys with the greatest sexual appetites are the ones who are the most driven and most
successful."
This was crap when we first heard it as the feminist theory of capitalism—that successful businessmen were
simply acting out their rape fantasies on the economy. And it's truly disgusting crap coming from anyone
who does the things Joe Francis is alleged to have done in the article—assaulting a reporter, getting a
teenager drunk and more•or-less raping her, and generally being an ass. No idea about how much of this
story is accurate but if even if it's dimes-from-dollars, it's awful stuff.
We couldn't help but remember that Jeffrey Epstein is reportedly interested in alternative theories of
evolutionary psychology. Maybe he and Joe should get in touch with each other.
'Baby. Give Me a Kiss' [L.A. Times Magazine]
Posted by John Carney at 12:01 PM on August 07, 2006 I Permalink I rOMMPiliC (7) 1 TrackBacKs (0)
Today in Jeffrey Epstein: He Thinks You Are An Insect.
We feel awful for letting you down yesterday. An entire day without a post on Jeffrey Epstein. No one
should have to tolerate that kind of neglect. Unless, you know they get their news from the New York
Times.
A blogger at Verum Serum asks whether Epstein's interest in alternatives to evolutionary psychology and the
work of E.O. Wilson might offer an insight into his alleged behavor:
My question about all this is simple. Is there a connection between the two threads in Jeffrey Epstein's life?
Between his scientific beliefs about human nature and his behavior toward women (and girls)? Put another
way, when you see people as something akin to insects, does that alter your behavior toward them? When
you see human trust and kindness as merely adaptive behaviors, does that render you less trustworthy or
less kind?
Well answer all four questions. Yes. Yes. Yes. No.
Patron of Evolutionary Science Kept Sex Slave [Verum Serum]
Posted by John Carney at 02:56 PM on August 04, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (4) I TrackBacks (0)
Pretty Much Most of the News That's Fit to Print So Long As It's
Not About Jeffrey Epstein
Its three o'clock already and we haven't even mentioned Jeffrey Epstein. We'd feel like we
were neglecting our journalistic duties but that might make the nice folks at New York Times feel lazy.
They've never once mentioned Jeffrey Epstein since the sex scandal broke, as Jossip points out.
So, fine. We are going to be obsessive ...And we are going to point out — yet again — that a very rich and
powerful man was accused of some really terrible things ... and the New York Times has officially let a week
go by without a single mention of his name.
Come on, Jossip. That's unfair. We're sure they mean to get around to the story. It's just so hard to find
room in the paper when it is so packed with hard news.
Jeffrey Epstein Still Immune From New York Times Coverage: Day 7 [Jossip]
Posted by John Carney at 03:00 PM on August 02, 2006 I Permalink I CommPnts (0) I TrackBacks (0)
Jeffrey Epstein and Those Nobel Prize Winning Orgiasts
As we mentioned earlier today over on the very, very much Not Safe For Work Moneyshot blog, the
pseudonymous Shermon McCoy claims that he's been at Jeffrey Epstein parties in which Nobel prize winners
and various wealthy folks were all surrounded by young, "nude eastern european girls, frolicking with them,
and then proceeding into one big orgy party." Uhm, okay. So who were these Nobel prize winners? So far
we haven't been able to confirm anything.
But we have uncovered published reports about a boondoggle-orgy-physics symposium in St. Thomas that
Epstein organized, which was attended by Nobel prize winners Gerardus't Hooft, David Gross and Frank
Wilczek, and physicist Stephen Hawking. We don't want to suggest that Hawking got all freaky with
Epstein's alleged sex•slave. Or that anyone did anything wrong or unbecoming. Or that any of these physics
guys have ever had sex with anyone, for that matter.
But the story does suggest it wasn't all equations and string theory.
Delegates from the University of the Virgin Islands and Antilles School also attended the reception, where a
few free spirited physicists braved the dance floor.
"There is no agenda except fun and physics, and that's fun with a capital 'F,-  Epstein said.
Before the Epstein story broke we might have read that with a straight face. Now we cannot help but
wonder exactly who these "delegates" were. Were they professors? Or students? And why do we think that
the capital "F" wasn't just for fun?
That's probably completely unfair. But like we said before. In light of the allegations, everything we read
about Epstein seems creepy.
Physicists Debate Gravity at St. Thomas Symposium  [St. Thomas Source]
Posted by John Carney at 06:05 PM on August 01, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (9) 1 TrackBacks (0)
Epstein Update: Nobel Prize Wide Shut
STAM.L.• (041UCT"Ow
EYES WNNE SNIT
similar to Eyes Wide
According to the anonymous author of TheMonevShot Shermon McCoy (bar), our
flood-the-zone coverage of Jeffrey Epstein's alleged personal pubescent predilictions
is entirely based on one thing: we're jealous!
All these people are, I suspect, just slightly jealous that they were never invited to a
Epstein party." Being one of those privy to just such an event- barely-legal (I hope!)
Russian girls and all- I can say that I understand why. There really is nothing else I
have ever experienced quite like it. Nobel prize winners, a bunch of people intimately
involved in ... cough! cough! Numerix cough! and cough! Prediction Company cough!
cough!, Jeff himself, and some rich people who really don't matter- all surrounded by
18-, 19-, and 20- (again, I hope!) year old nude eastern european girls, frolicking
with them, and then proceeding into one big orgy party. It was really strikingly
Shut. Without the costumes, that is.
Well, Sherman, we'll admit that we're jealous of your blog idea. Porn and finance! At the same time! Two
great tastes that go great together. Why didn't we think of thatrc"
But more importantly, we're deeply curious about which Nobel prize winners have been known to frolick
sans tweed with nude Eastern European girls. And we're curious about the rich people who don't matter as
well. C'mon! Give us a hint!
.* Well, that's a little presumptuous, Sherman.
No, seriously. Why didn't we think of that? Minkin? Carney?
Dealbreaker and More Jeffrey Epstein (NSFW) [TheMoneyShot]
Posted by Elizabeth Spiers at 12:00 PM on August 01, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (14  I TrackBacks (0)
The Perfect Storm, DealBreaker Style
We've been spending some time trying to dear away the murk and shine some light into the shadows of
Jeffrey Epstein's financial dealings in an effort to provide some, uhm, actual financial reporting related to
the sex candal encircling the mysterious money manager. There's not much that is publicly available but
we're still digging.
What we have discovered, however, is a brief document amending a credit agreement for RELIANT
PHARMACEUTICALS, INC. The amendment replaces the administrative agent for the credit. But what caught
our eye was the confluence of three DealBreaker subjects all in the same documents.
The signature pages include lines for Morgan Stanley CEO John Mack, who is scheduled to appear before
the SEC in connection with allegations of insider trading at Pequot Capital, as well at Jeffrey Epstein, who
signs as trustee of the Wexner Children's Trust II, part of the financial empire of The Limited founding
family. And the agent who is being replaced? Goldman Sachs, where alleged insider trading crooks
Eugene Plotkin and David Pajcin worked (not to mention the alma mater of that other DealBreaker
obsession, Hank Paulson).
Now this is no doubt just a coincidence, and not really a conspiracy to make our heads explode. We should
probably just take a deep breath and then post a Venn Diagram illustrating the connections but our
diagramist is in meetings off-site.
One additional thought: this is probably the last time you'll see Epstein's name coupled with the words
"trust" and "children" any time in the near future.
Reliant Consent, waiver and amendment [SEC]
osted by John Carney at 05:01 PM on July 31, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (0)
rackBacks (0)
effrey Epstein's Been Around Young Girls Before
Does the fact that Jeffrey Epstein taught high school math and physics at Dalton for three
ears creep anyone else out? Unless you've been depending on the New York Times for your
news, by now you know that Jeffrey Epstein has been charged with felony solicitation of
prostitution rather than even more serious charges of molestation and sex with minors. But the facts alleged
in the police affidavit released on the Smoking Gun dearly spell out a taste for getting young, high school
age girls to co-operate in some pretty raunchy scenarios. This raises the question: how long has this been
going on?*
Did you go to Dalton in the mid•seventies? Epstein taught there from 1973 through 1975, when he left to
take a job at Bear Stearns. We'd love to hear from you if you remember Epstein from those years, whatever
your impressions—good, bad, ugly or totally perverse. Unless otherwise indicated, we'll keep your
comments completely anonymous. Send your comments to tips(at)dealbreaker(dot)com.
[* Editors Note: We know, we know. It may not have gone on at all. Everyone is innocent until proven
guilty. God loves all his little creatures. The allegations and charges are serious, though, and we don't think
irs too early to start asking these questions.]
Posted by John Carney at 03:39 PM on July 31, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (2) 1 TrackBacks (0)
On further reflection, maybe giving money back to Jeffrey
Epstein isn't such a good plan
Why are Mark Green and Eliot Spitzer handing $60,000.00 over to alleged money manager cum massage
masturbator Jeffrey Epstein? It's pretty standard procedure these days for politicians to send back
contributions from donors accused of crime or mired in scandal, and we guess allegations of soliciting
prostitution, paying for naked massages from teenagers, human trafficking and all around pervy weirdness
qualify. But is sending the check back really the right move here? Wouldn't it be better to donate the money
to a worthy cause, such a home for sexually abused children? Why should Epstein be enriched by these
allegations?
Let's put it this way. By sending back Epstein's $10,000 donation, Attorney General candidate Green just
bought Epstein SO sessions with local highshool girls at $200 a pop.
Dirty donor to get 10G back: Grow  [Daily News]
Posted by John Carney at 11:33 AM on July 31, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (0)I  TrackBacks (0)
Meet Jeffrey Epstein's Other Girl
Sex Slave Trade
e're told that the dirty little nymph in this picture is S the
ersonal assistant of Jeffrey Epstein who is alleged to have arranged
ny of her boss's alleged naked massage sessions with teenage girls.
he woman in this picture bears a striking resemblance to confirmed
ictures of =, including one where she is ictured aIlin around
ith Epstein's alleged eastern European sex-slave
could not be reached for comment.
ore pictures of (probably) on the link below.
? [Strobe Models)
osted by John Carney at 10:47 AM on July 31, 2006 I permalink I
omments 1 TrackBacks (0)
nother Jeffrey Epstein Victim? Naughty
May Be A Victim of International
Our earlier post on was written on the assumption that unlike the young girls Jeffrey
Epstein is alleged to have paid to strip and massaged him while he pawed at them and masturbated into a
towel, the eastern european blonde was a different kind of participant. Older, more sophisticated, at least a
little leery and wearing stap-on dildos. That sort of thing. Just the sort of woman you'd Imagine an evil
villain would keep as his mistress.
As it turns out, that sort of woman probably only exists in fiction. Gawker is now reoottinq that according to
a previously unpublished Palm Beach police document, Epstein bragged that he purchased from her
family in Yugoslavia, and that she was his sex slave. So she may be another victim of Epstein's alleged sex-
and girls-for-money racket.
The weird thing is that seems to have at least Did Epstein set up
his alleged sex slave as a real estate agent? Isn't being a sex slave at least a full time job?
[Oh. And yeah. Alleged. Alleged. Allegedallegedallegedallegedtoinfinity. Epstein hasn't been found guilty of
anything and it's up to the government to prove its case against him.]
Exclusive: Jeffrey Epstein's Sex Slave [Gawker]
Posted by John Carney at 04:38 PM on July 28, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (2) I TrackBacks (0)
Meet
E r stein Scandal
Star Girl of the Raunchiest Part of
iithout a doubt, the absolutely raunchiest part of the E
fadavit stars a mysterious young woman named "=
" Lesbian strap-on raunchiness, ending in
ornething that sounds to us a little bit like ra . We get all
he details but no explanation of who is or what
ler relationship with Epstein was. She's not one of his high
chool victims, and doesn't seem to have talked to the police.
But it somehow seems fitting that this mysterious money
anager to the billionaires would have an unknown Czech sex
ppet lying around somewhere.
where
far left) is palling around with Epstein's pimp assistant
(right).
ere she looks very respectable. Not at all like the "large
ubber penis" wielding girl we know from the affadavit. Surely
here's a more representative photo.
Of course there is. After the jump, check out looking a little more, uhm, severe, sexy and ready to get
it on. And we'll throw in the raunchy portion of the affadavit below for your, uhm, reading pleasure.
Continue reading "Meet Star Girl of the Raunchiest Part of Epstein Scandal" »
Posted by John Carney at 11:11 AM on July 28, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (8) I TrackBacks (0)
In Retrospect, Everything Ever Said About Jeffrey Epstein
Seems Creepy
If you spend even a few moments reading the probable cause affidavit detailing mysterious money manager
Jeffrey Epstein's alleged penchant for paying naked teenagers to massage him while he, uhm, whacked-off,
everything else you read about him starts to seem creepy too.
There's the now famous line in New York magazine's profile. You know, the one where Donald Trump is
quoted as saying about Epstein, "He's a lot of fun to be with. It is even said that he likes beautiful women
as much as I do, and many of them are on the younger side. No doubt about it -- Jeffrey enjoys his social
life." Wow. That's awkward now.
But it doesn't stop there. One thing that's clear from the affidavit is that Epstein's assistant is
alleged to have played a central role in procuring the high school girls who rubbed him down for a couple of
hundred dollars a pop. She's said to have called the girls when Epstein was in town, got them situated in his
bedroom and even passed around refreshing beverages for the girls to enjoy.
As it turns out, one of the rare journalism interviews Epstein has given involved his executive assistants. The
New York Times story "Working for Top Bosses on Wall St. Has Its Perks" (cough, pimping, cough) is now
hidden safely from prying eyes behind the Times Select firewall but Deal&eaker has boldy shelled out the
Abe Lincoln to bring the story to our readers. After the jump, we bring you the excerpts with emphasis and
nasty asides added.
Continue reading "In Retrospect, Everything Ever Said About Jeffrey Epstein Seems Creepy" x.
Posted by John Carney at 09:33 AM on July 28, 2006 I Permalink I Comments (4) I TrackBacks (0)
© 2006 - Dealbreaker.com - 11 Beach St, 3rd Floor, New York, NY 10013 I Privacy Policy I Terms of Service
EFTA00023055 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI evidence of notes left about newly recruited underage girls by girls giving massages
(inferred date: 2007-01-29)
Exhibit C
1
(Rev. 01-31.2003) • •
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: PRIORITY
To: Albuquerque Santa Fe RA
San Juan
From: Miami
Squad PB-2, PBCRA
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
Date: 12/06/2006
St. Thomas RA
(Pending)
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Synopsis: To set leads for captioned investigation.
Details: On 07/24/2006 the Federal Bureau of Investigation
(FBI), Palm Beach County Resident Agency (PBCRA), began
investigating Jeffrey Epstein, a part-time resident of Palm
Beach, alona with!
PBCRA obtained  information t om
the City of Palm Beach Police Department (PBPD)I
Epstein
Following the ceceipt of the case files from the PBPD,
PACPA honan intprviPwinnI I
I who reported a similar
series of events. In particular, ( 'described how contact
was made via telephone, primarily' 1 I
•
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b7D
CONFIDENTIAL
ale.- rim.- losoto- V/

• 1
To: Albuquerque Et: Miami
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 12/06/2006
•
b6
b7C
b7D
mat by Fnetnin
nd some
instances. Eosteid
On most
exam le, t 'Epstein
During the course of PBPD's investigation, a search
warrant for Epstein's home was obtained and executed. Many of
Epstein's belongings were removed from the home prior to the
execution of the search warrant - for example, the computer
processing units (CPUs) were removed from the house but the
computer screens, keyboards, cords, etc. were left behind. The
missing CPU's were never recovered.
During the search, several telephone message pads were
recovered. These message pads show messages taken from several of
the girls who were interviewed and admitted to engaging in sexual
massages or other sexual activity with Epstein. The messages
contained text such as "I have a female for him" and "has girl
for tonight." Some of the messages from  the girls weri addresse
to E stein and others were addressed tot
Additional messages recovered during the search
con aine ext confirming appointment times.
During the PBCRA's investigation,'
that 'would contact i
2
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_02050813

• .
To: Albuquerque AL: Miami
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 12/06/2006
•
(nle  investigation revealed tnac
the flights to Palm Beach, I tould contact somi of
w4= rail nhnnm Tha mn cana N nta ovidonno that
In addition to the home in Palm Beach, Epstein also
maintains a residence in the U.S. Virgin Islands, New York and
New Mexico.
To date, the PBCRA continues.to develop witnesses and
victims from across the United States. Due to the media coverage,
unknown status of the state investigation, vulnerability of the
young female victims, and political influences, the AUSAs and
Case Agents have a target date of January 2007 for indictment.
Based on the ongoing criminal investigation, the PBCRA
is requesting the assistance in establishing Epstein's criminal
activity utilizing interstate commerce and the travel in
interstate commerce to engage in illicit sexual conduct and
prostitution. Prior to conducting captioned leads, it is
requested that the lead agents) contact  SAj
FBI Miami, West Palm RA, I I or SAI
'for investigative direction and
questions.
3
b6
b7C
b7D
L CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_02050814
EFTA00009632 (Jmail)
 [government] grand jury proceedings FBI agent testimony
(date: 2007-02-06)
1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
2 WEST PALM BEACH DIVISION
8 IN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR
12 Grand Jury #07-103 (WPB)
West Palm Beach, Florida 13 Tuesday, February 6, 2007
15 TESTIMONY
16 OF
21 APPEARANCE:
22 ASSISTANT U. S. ATTORNEY
, FOREPERSON
23 , COURT REPORTER
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Ltrp n ( (52
1 PROCEEDINGS
2 - - -
3 The sworn testimony of I. was taken
4 before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach Division,
5 701 Clematis Street, West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County,
6 State of Florida, on the 6th day of February, 2007.
7 , Registered Merit Reporter and Notary
8 Public was authorized to and did report the sworn
9 testimony.
10 Thereupon,
12 a witness of lawful age, having been first duly sworn by
13 the foreperson, testified on her oath as follows:
14 BY MS.
15 Q Special Agent , please state and
16 spell your name for the record.
17 A It is I. and I work for
18 the FBI in Palm Beach County.
19 Q Can you spell your last name, please.
20 A I'm sorry, it is
21 Q And I know we have some people in the back
22 having trouble hearing you. You said that you work for
23 the FBI. Can you tell the Grand Jury what particular
24 group you are employed with?
25 A I am with the Violent Crimes Squad here in
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 Palm Beach County, I work primarily crimes against
2 children, but have been an agent for the last
3 approximately 10 years.
4 Q Have you received specialized training in the
5 area of crimes against children?
6 A Yes, I have.
7 Q As part of your employment with the FBI have
8 you been involved in an investigation of Jeffrey
9 Epstein?
10 A Yes, I have.
11 Q And can you tell us who Jeffrey Epstein is?
12 A Jeffrey Epstein is an investment advisor who
13 has a part-time residence in the town of Palm Beach, he
14 has got multiple residences across the country to
15 include a ranch in New Mexico, an island in the Virgin
16 Isles, and multiple aircrafts, two airplanes and a
17 helicopter to be exact, and --
18 Q And where is his primary residence?
19 A His primary residence, he has an office in New
20 York, but his primary residence I believe is the island.
21 Q In the Virgin Islands?
22 A Yes.
23 Q He also has a home in New York, correct?
24 A Yes.
25 Q How is it that you started investigating
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 Mr. Epstein?
2 A The Palm Beach Police Department in March of
3 2005 initiated an investigation on Mr. Epstein involving
4 multiple underage females that had visited Mr. Epstein's
5 residence and had performed sexual massages or massages
6 for Mr. Epstein of a sexual nature.
7 Mr. Epstein paid the underage females anywhere
8 from 200 to 5400, that investigation was around an 8 to
9 10-month investigation, and at that point we became
10 involved in about July of 2006.
11 Q And once the case was presented to you by the
12 Palm Beach Police Department did the FBI open its own
13 investigation?
14 A Yes, yes, we initiated our investigation in
15 July of 2006, we took a look at focusing in on the
16 underage minors and in our investigation we interviewed
17 many of the girls that were underage and we did an
18 independent investigation issuing Grand Jury subpoenas
19 as well as administrative subpoenas getting different
20 documents of financial records, telephone analysis,
21 flight manifests, looking to see if Mr. Epstein engaged
22 in sexual activity with these females.
23 Q All right. And just so the Grand Jury is
24 clear, were some of the girls who went to Mr. Epstein's
25 house 18 or older?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 A Yes.
2 Q And then there were some that were under the
3 age of 18, correct?
4 A Yes.
5 Q And as part of the federal investigation did
6 you have to investigate what we call the interstate
7 nexus aspect of the case?
8 A Yes.
9 Q And can you explain to the Grand Jury what
10 that is?
11 A we looked at -- Mr. Epstein, as I mentioned
12 earlier, has two aircrafts, and we focused in on the
13 year 2004, 2005, he took approximately 60 trips to his
14 residence in Palm Beach, the majority of that time
15 focusing in on his assistant's cell phone, which his
16 assistant's name is , we took a look at her
17 cell phone records and the majority of the times that
18 Mr. Epstein would fly into Palm Beach mrs. -- Ms.
19 would contact many of our underage victims either prior
20 to coming into Palm Beach, the day of, the day before,
21 even the day after, and certainly throughout the time
22 that Mr. Epstein was at his residence in Palm Beach.
23 Q And from the interviews of the girls that have
24 been conducted, what was the subject of those telephone
25 calls?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 A Can you restate the question?
2 Q Sure. From the interviews of the girls that
3 have been conducted, what was the subject matter of the
4 telephone calls from
5 A would schedule the underage girls
6 to come and work, perform the massages for Mr. Epstein,
7 so she was responsible, she as well as another
8 assistant, , they were his personal
9 assistants who would set up appointments for Mr. Epstein
10 for the girls to come and perform their sexual massages.
11 Q All right. Is also considered a
12 target of this investigation?
13 A ves, she is.
14 Q And I will just -- I will spell
15 for the Grand Jury. The first name is
16 and the last name is spelled
17 and does ms. have a new last
18 name?
19 A yes, she does, she is married and her name is
21 Q Is Ms. at least a subject of
22 this investigation, in other words, you are
23 investigating her activity?
24 A we are looking at that.
25 Q In addition to those two assistants, from the
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
(
interviews of the girls, is
associated with Mr. Epstein
involved in this activity?
there anyone else who is
who is thought to be
been referred to as his A has
5 companion, girl friend, personal assistant, she through
6 the testimony of the girls has engaged in sexual
7 activity with at least three of the underage minors.
8 Q And is SO Ms.
a subject of the is also at least
investigation, correct?
11 A Yes, she is.
12 Q Now, as part of this investigation you
13 mentioned that subpoenas were issued on behalf of either
14 the old Grand Jury or this Grand Jury.
15 can you run through what subpoenas have been
issued and what documents have been received in response
to that?
18 A Sure. we issued a Grand Jury subpoena to
19 Colonial Bank and we received financial records on
20 credit card accounts and individuals.
21 we subpoenaed washington mutual and they did a
22 search and were unable to locate records at this time.
23 we issued a Grand Jury subpoena for Capital One and
24 served that and that is still unresolved at this time as
25 far as them providing documents to us.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 we have subpoenaed Chase Credit Card and we
2 have received documents from Chase. We have subpoenaed
3 two businesses that Mr. Epstein has at least partial
4 ownership or associated to, Hyperion Air, Inc. and JEGE,
5 Inc., they were issued subpoenas and they have provided
6 documentation to us.
7 we have subpoenaed Mr. , who is a
8 pilot of Mr. Epstein's, and we have received
9 documentation from Mr. . We have subpoenaed DTG
10 operations, who is doing business as Dollar Rent-A-Car,
11 and we have received car rental agreements and financial
12 records from that business.
13 We have subpoenaed Royal Palm Beach High
14 school and have received documentation regarding the
15 students' records. we have subpoenaed three or four of
16 the victims, being the first, and we have
17 received a bathing suit from
18 we issued a Grand Jury subpoena to
19 , we actually have issued three subpoenas,
20 and we are still working on resolving her Grand Jury
21 material as well as testimony.
22 we have issued a subpoena, we
23 have issued -- she also is one of our underage victims.
24 We've issued Reimer Employment Agency a Grand Jury
25 subpoena and we have received documentation, that is an
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 employment agency located on the island of Palm Beach.
2 we have subpoenaed the Palm Beach Police
3 Department for their evidence in this case and we have
4 received that. By the way, that is the only thing that
5 I did not bring with me today, I brought everything
6 else, but it is rather a lot of evidence, so we will
7 probably be bringing that to you another time.
8 we have issued the Clerk of Courts of the
9 State of Florida for Grand Jury transcripts in the state
10 matter and we have received those. we have issued the
11 Good Samaritan Hospital for billing records and we have
12 received those.
13 we have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to the
14 Dalton School located in New York and at this time they
15 do not have the records we have requested or could not
16 locate those.
17 we have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to Extra
18 Touch Flowers located here in west Palm Beach and we
19 have received documentation from them. we issued a
20 Grand Jury subpoena to Bill Hammond, another pilot for
21 Mr. Epstein, we have spoken with him.
22 We have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to
23 , another one of Mr. Epstein's pilots, and we
24 have received documentation as well as spoken to him.
25 we have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 , who is the property manager currently for
2 Mr. Epstein at his Palm Beach residence, and we have
3 received documentation as well as spoken to him, and we
4 have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to
5 and have received some documentation and are still
6 awaiting a response.
7 Q Now, you mentioned that you didn't bring with
8 you the evidence that you received from the Palm Beach
9 Police Department, but did you bring with you all of the
10 other evidence that was received in response to the
11 subpoenas?
12 A I have.
13 Q And is that evidence in the two boxes that are
14 here in the front?
15 A Yes.
16 Q we will bring all of this back to you when we
17 present the indictment, but would anyone like to look at
18 any of the documentation today?
19 A GRAND JUROR: what does the documentation
20 constitute, basically, the subpoenas?
21 THE WITNESS: It is primarily business
22 records, flight manifests, stuff that came from him
23 traveling to and from Palm Beach, credit card
24 records, the businesses as far as the rental
25 agreement which involves some of the underage girls
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
(
1 with the rental cars, and flower shop, you know.
2 A GRAND JUROR: will we have an opportunity
3 later to go through these if we need to?
4 MS. : Yes, we will bring them when
S we present the indictment. Yes, ma'am.
6 A GRAND JUROR: If I should hold this for
7 later let me know, she mentioned the hospital
8 records were subpoenaed, could more information
9 about why they were subpoenaed be provided at this
10 time?
11 BY MS.
12 Q You can answer that.
13 A One of the girls that was an underage -- that
14 was underage at the time that is involved with
15 mr. Epstein has had a baby and we were interested and
16 wondering if possibly he was the father of that baby,
17 which at this time we do not believe he was.
18 A GRAND JUROR: Thank you.
19 MS. : A question?
20 A GRAND JUROR: Did the flight manifest show
21 passengers on the plane?
22 THE WITNESS: Yes, they do.
23 A GRAND JUROR: Were any of the passengers the
24 underage girls that were a target of the
25 investigation?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 THE WITNESS: At this time we have not
2 associated any of these underage girls as being the
3 passengers. The flight manifests, sometimes the
4 pilot if they did not know who the passenger was
5 would put one passenger or one female, one male,
6 these were private planes and they, you know, may
7 not have felt like they can go up and ask, but we
8 don't have any evidence at this time to believe
9 that they were any of our victims.
10 MS. : Any follow-up? Any other
11 questions from the Grand Jury? ves, ma'am.
12 A GRAND JUROR: The records that you
13 subpoenaed from the high school, what were they
14 used for or why were they instrumental in the
15 investigation?
16 THE WITNESS: Those are the girls' school
17 records and we are just looking at the girls'
18 records.
19 A GRAND JUROR: Absenteeism?
20 THE WITNESS: Just looking at some of their
21 grades and performances and how they did in school.
22 MS. : Ladies and gentlemen, before
23 we continue, the witness has mentioned a few names
24 of the minors and that is confidential information,
25 obviously everything that you hear within these
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 walls is confidential.
2 BY MS. -:
3 Q NOw, Special Agent , after -- in
4 addition to issuing the subpoenas, you mentioned that
5 one of the subpoenas was to the Palm Beach Police
6 Department. Did you review any of the evidence that
7 they collected?
8 A Yes.
9 Q And can you, for example, did the Palm Beach
10 Police Department interview any girls?
11 A Yes, they did, they interviewed several of the
12 girls, most of the girls, they took taped statements
13 from the girls either in the form of a tape-recorder or
14 through video.
15 Q And you have reviewed some of those
16 interviews, correct?
17 A Yes, we have.
18 Q And has the FBI performed any interviews?
19 A Yes, we have, we have performed interviews of
20 past and current employees of Mr. Epstein as well as
21 focusing in on the girls, the girls that were underage
22 at the time of the sexual activity, we wanted to
23 determine with these girls, again, the sexual activity
24 that took place with Mr. Epstein as well as how old they
25 were at the time, if they traveled with Mr. Epstein, any
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 gifts that they may have gotten, so we did reach out to
2 several of the underage minors and gathered more
3 information from them.
4 Q And through the FBI's investigation has the
5 FBI identified additional victims that perhaps the state
6 police officers did not know about?
7 A Yes, we are still trying to identify, get
8 first names of girls and going back and looking through
9 school yearbooks and attempting to try to locate friends
10 of friends, so we are still in the process, when you
11 interview one of the girls and you ask if any of their
12 friends went, they sometimes will give you other names,
13 so we are in the process of still uncovering victims and
14 reaching out and interviewing additional girls that we
15 believe possibly were underage at the time of this
16 sexual activity.
17 Q If I could ask you to step outside.
18 (The witness was excused from the Grand Jury
19 room.)
20 (Questions posed by the Grand Jury.)
21 (The witness was recalled to testify before
22 the Grand Jury.)
23 BY MS.
24 Q Special Agent , one of the Grand
25 Jurors asked whether there was any evidence of force or
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 coercion.
2 A when talking to the girls they were told that
3 they may have to -- they were going there to perform a
4 massage, possibly model lingerie, they went there
5 sometimes on multiple occasions and they may start off
6 wearing their clothing and then he would instruct them
15 far as coercion, they were paid $200 to $400 to perform
16 these massages.
17 They are not trained in performing massages,
18 they don't -- they are not masseuses, but yet if you ask
19 if they were coerced, they were paid quite a bit of
20 money for 30 to 45 minutes work.
21 Some of the girls, being that they were minors
22 going to his residence, got in over their heads and did
23 not always return or come back, some of our victims did
24 not come back after, you know, the did o down '
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
16 •
6 Q And was there one instance where Mr. Epstein
7 actually engaged in vaginal intercourse with a girl
8 against her will?
14 Q A Grand Juror asked how old Mr. Epstein is.
15 A He was 45 at the time that we are looking at
16 him at that time period.
17 Q A Grand Juror asked if you know the proportion
18 of girls who were underage versus 18 or older.
19 A The majority of the girls that we are looking
20 at are victims, well, all of our victims that we are
21 looking at were under the age of 18.
22 As far as all of the girls that have been
23 interviewed, the majority definitely were under 18. To
24 give you a number, i would have to go and count, but I
25 would say in the state investigation there were over 25
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 girls identified and more than a majority would have
2 been under the age of 18.
3 Q A Grand Juror asked whether we have obtained
4 Mr. Epstein's DNA and whether there was any DNA testing
5 of the baby that you spoke of earlier.
6 A No, we have not.
7 Q A Grand Juror asked how Mr. Epstein would make
8 contact with the girls, was this done via computer or in
9 some other method?
10 A I am sorry, , his personal
11 assistant, would contact, or on some occasions
12 would also contact the girls via their cell
13 phone and we have message pads from the residents that
14 also indicate the girls calling the home in response to
15 some of those phone calls, so they would call,
16 would call, the majority of the calls were made
17 by to the girls arranging for these, you
18 know, can you come at this time, can you come at that
19 time.
20 Q And is the cellular telephone a facility of
21 interstate commerce?
22 A yes, it is.
23 Q And then one of the Grand Jurors asked whether
24 the assistants knew that the girls were underage or
25 committed sex acts.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 Did anybody, have you interviewed anybody who
2 affirmatively told you that they told fill. their
3 age or what was going on behind closed doors?
4 A No, no, not at this time, not at this time.
5 Q And what leads you to believe that she, for
6 example, knew or should have known what was
7 going on?
8 A There are so many girls that
9 contacted to give Mr. Epstein massages that have no
10 training in massages, and that was aware
11 that girls were bringing other girls, you know, their
12 friends to do these massages.
13 was also making appointments for
14 legitimate massages for Mr. Epstein from legitimate
15 masseuses that would come and give him massages, so the
16 number of girls, their appearances at the time would
17 lead us to believe that had knowledge that
18 these girls were underage.
19 Q All right. Thank you very much. Those were
20 all the questions from the Grand Jury.
21 A GRAND JUROR: Actually, I have two more,
22 but.
23 MS. : Okay.
24 A GRAND JUROR: what was the actual age range
25 of these girls?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 THE WITNESS: 14 to I mean.
2 A GRAND JUROR: The other one was, how did Ms.
3 actually originally get these girls, how
4 were they brought in, I mean how were they, you
5 know, because you said she called them when he was
6 arriving, but how did these girls come into this in
7 the first place?
8 A GRAND JUROR: Could she speak louder?
9 MS. : Special Agent , we
10 just had a request that you speak louder
11 A GRAND JUROR: 14 and what?
12 THE WITNESS: Our victims were 14 to 17, but
13 we have girls that are 18, we have girls that are
14 20, we have girls that are in their early 20s, and
15 your question was?
16 A GRAND JUROR: How did she originally get
17 them in in the first place?
18 THE WITNESS: We are focusing in on 2004,
19 2005, we have some evidence to show that this
20 activity was taking place even earlier than that,
21 certainly to include 2003 if you look at the
22 message pads, but focusing in on 2004, 2005, the
23 chain started with one of our minors and from that
24 minor who goes to the house, Mr. Epstein tells
25 her -- sees that she is maybe not comfortable with
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 doing the massage the way he would like it and
2 tells her that she could bring other girls to do
3 the massages and she in fact if she brought another
4 girl she would be paid $200 for just bringing
S another girl, so there starts the chain, and
6 Mr. Epstein would ask the girls or would ask
7 the girls for their phone numbers so each time, you
8 know, if one of the girls brought a girl and he
9 liked her he would ask for her phone number, ask
10 her to leave the phone number, or
11 would get the phone number and then that girl would
12 maybe bring, because if you brought somebody you
13 didn't have to do the massage, but you also got
14 paid for bringing a new person, so not only if you
15 did the massage would you get anywhere from 200 to
16 400, but if you brought a new female you would
17 receive 200 or $400.
18 A GRAND JUROR: Do you know how she solicited
19 that original minor?
20 THE WITNESS: I don't. Well, I know that
21 minor was approached by two individuals and we have
22 interviewed one of those individuals who we can
23 connect back to Mr. Epstein four years, possibly,
24 prior to this, and stated that his job was actually
25 to drive some of the girls to the residence and
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 that's pretty much where we start off.
2 MS. Would the Grand Jury like
3 Special Agent to maintain the records
4 that we received in response to the subpoenas?
5 A GRAND JUROR: Maintain versus what?
6 A GRAND JUROR: What is our choice?
7 MS. : I don't know that there is. I
8 guess I could maintain them, but I don't believe we
9 have secure storage in here.
10 Would you like Special Agent to
11 maintain custody?
12 A GRAND JUROR: Yes.
13 MS. : You should have something to
14 swear her in as a custodian.
15 (The witness was sworn in as the custodian of
16 records.)
17 MS. : Thank you, ladies and
18 gentlemen, I am the last person for today, so you
19 guys are free to go and we will see you probably in
20 a couple of weeks, we will be seeing a lot of you.
21 (The witness was excused from the Grand Jury
22 room.)
23 (The testimony of the witness concluded
24 before the Grand Jury.)
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
(
1 CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
4 I certify pages 2 through 21 are a true
5 transcript of my shorthand notes of the testimony of
6 • .. before the Federal Grand Jury,
7 west Palm Beach, Florida on the 6th day of February,
8 2007.
10 / 914-11"1 A PAY
11 -Notary Public
12 Commission #DD0282274
13 Expires May 8, 2008
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
(
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ann Marie Villafana [government] Southern District of Florida (SDFL) U.S. Attorney 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00223910 (Jmail)
 [government] grand jury proceedings FBI agent testimony
(date: 2007-02-06)
1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
2 WEST PALM BEACH DIVISION
8 IN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR
10  /
12 Grand Jury #07-103 (WPB)
west Palm Beach, Florida
13 Tuesday, February 6, 2007
21 APPEARANCE:
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
Exhibit 17
PROCEEDINGS
The sworn testimony of
before the Federal Grand
was taken
Division, Jury, west Palm Beach
5 701 Clematis Street, West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County,
6 State of Florida, on the 6th day of February, 2007.
7 NANCY SIEGEL, Registered Merit Reporter and Notary
8 Public was authorized to and did report the sworn
9 testimony.
10 Thereupon,
11 E.
12 a witness of lawful age, having been first duly sworn by
13 the foreperson, testified on her oath as follows:
14 BY MS.
15 Q Special Agent please state and
16 spell your name for the record.
17 A It is and I work for
18 the FBI in Palm Beach County.
19 Q Can you spell your last name, please.
20 A I'm sorry, it is
21 Q And I know we have some people in the back
22 having trouble hearing you. You said that you work for
23 the FBI. Can you tell the Grand Jury what particular
24 group you are employed with?
25 A I am with the violent Crimes Squad here in
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 Palm Beach County, I work primarily crimes against
2 children, but have been an agent for the last
3 approximately 10 years.
4 Q Have you received specialized training in the
5 area of crimes against children?
6 A Yes, I have.
7 Q As part of your employment with the FBI have
8 you been involved in an investigation of Jeffrey
9 Epstein?
10 A Yes, I have.
11 Q And can you tell us who Jeffrey Epstein is?
12 A Jeffrey Epstein is an investment advisor who
13 has a part-time residence in the town of Palm Beach, he
14 has got multiple residences across the country to
15 include a ranch in New Mexico, an island in the virgin
16 Isles, and multiple aircrafts, two airplanes and a
17 helicopter to be exact, and --
18 Q And where is his primary residence?
19 A His primary residence, he has an office in New
20 York, but his primary residence I believe is the island.
21 Q In the virgin Islands?
22 A Yes.
23 Q He also has a home in New York, correct?
24 A Yes.
25 Q How is it that you started investigating
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 Mr. Epstein?
2 A The Palm Beach Police Department in March of
3 2005 initiated an investigation on mr. Epstein involving
4 multiple underage females that had visited Mr. Epstein's
5 residence and had performed sexual massages or massages
6 for Mr. Epstein of a sexual nature.
7 Mr. Epstein paid the underage females anywhere
8 from 200 to $400, that investigation was around an 8 to
9 10-month investigation, and at that point we became
10 involved in about July of 2006.
11 Q And once the case was presented to you by the
12 Palm Beach Police Department did the FBI open its own
13 investigation?
14 A Yes, yes, we initiated our investigation in
15 July of 2006, we took a look at focusing in on the
16 underage minors and in our investigation we interviewed
17 many of the girls that were underage and we did an
18 independent investigation issuing Grand Jury subpoenas
19 as well as administrative subpoenas getting different
20 documents of financial records, telephone analysis,
21 flight manifests, looking to see if Mr. Epstein engaged
22 in sexual activity with these females.
23 Q All right. And just so the Grand Jury is
24 clear, were some of the girls who went to Mr. Epstein's
25 house 18 or older?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
25 calls?
cell phone records and the majority of the
Mr. Epstein would fly into Palm Beach mrs.
would contact many of our underage victims
A Yes.
Q And then there were some that were under the
age of 18, correct?
A Yes.
Q And as part of the federal investigation did
you have to investigate what we call the interstate
nexus aspect of the case?
A Yes.
Q And can you explain to the Grand Jury what
that is?
A we looked at -- Mr. Epstein, as I mentioned
earlier, has two aircrafts, and we focused in on the
year 2004, 2005, he took approximately 60 trips to his
residence in Palm Beach, the majority of that time
focusing in on his assistant's cell phone, which his
assistant's name is we took a look at her
times that
either prior
to coming into Palm Beach, the day of, the day before,
even the day after, and certainly throughout the time
that Mr. Epstein was at his residence in Palm Beach.
Q And from the interviews of the girls that have
been conducted, what was the subject of those telephone
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
A can you restate the question?
Q Sure. From the interviews of the girls that
have been conducted, what was the subject matter of the
telephone calls from
A would schedule the underage girls
6 to come and work, perform the massages for mr. Epstein,
7 so she was responsible, she as well as another
8 assistant, they were his personal
9 assistants who would set up appointments for Mr. Epstein
10 for the girls to come and perform their sexual massages.
11 Q All right. Is also considered a
12 target of this investigation?
13 A Yes, she is.
14 Q And I will just -- I will spell
15 for the Grand Jury. The first name is
16 the last name is spelled and
17 and does ms. have a new last
18 name?
19 A Yes, she does, she is married and her name is
21 Q Is ms. at least a subject of
22 this investigation, in other words, you are
23 investigating her activity?
24 A we are looking at that.
25 Q In addition to those two assistants, from the
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 interviews of the girls, is there anyone else who is
2 associated with Mr. Epstein who is thought to be
3 involved in this activity?
4 A as been referred to as his
companion, girl friend, personal assistant, she through
the testimony of the girls has engaged in sexual
activity with at least three of the underage minors.
Q And . So Ms.
is also at least a subject of the
investigation, correct?
A yes, she is.
Q Now, as part of this investigation you
mentioned that subpoenas were issued on behalf of either
the old Grand Jury or this Grand Jury.
Can you run through what subpoenas have been
issued and what documents have been received in response
to that?
A Sure. We issued a Grand Jury subpoena to
Colonial Bank and we received financial records on
credit card accounts and individuals.
We subpoenaed washington Mutual and they did a
search and were unable to locate records at this time.
we issued a Grand Jury subpoena for Capital One and
served that and that is still unresolved at this time as
far as them providing documents to us.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 we have subpoenaed Chase Credit Card and we
2 have received documents from Chase. we have subpoenaed
3 two businesses that Mr. Epstein has at least partial
4 ownership or associated to, Hyperion Air, Inc. and JEGE,
5 Inc., they were issued subpoenas and they have provided
6 documentation to us.
7 we have subpoenaed Mr. David Rogers, who is a
8 pilot of mr. Epstein's, and we have received
9 documentation from Mr. Rogers. we have subpoenaed DTG
Operations, who is doing business as Dollar Rent-A-Car,
and we have received car rental agreements and financial
records from that business.
13 we have subpoenaed Royal Palm Beach High
14 school and have received documentation regarding the
15 students' records. We have subpoenaed three or four of
16 the victims, being the first, and we have
17 received a bathing suit from
18 we issued a Grand Jury subpoena to Tatum
19 Miller, we actually have issued Tatum three subpoenas,
20 and we are still working on resolving her Grand Jury
21 material as well as testimony.
22 we have issued subpoena, we
23 have issued -- she also is one of our underage victims.
24 we've issued Reimer Employment Agency a Grand Jury
25 subpoena and we have received documentation, that is an
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 employment agency located on the island of Palm Beach.
2 we have subpoenaed the Palm Beach Police
3 Department for their evidence in this case and we have
4 received that. By the way, that is the only thing that
5 I did not bring with me today, I brought everything
6 else, but it is rather a lot of evidence, so we will
7 probably be bringing that to you another time.
8 we have issued the Clerk of Courts of the
9 State of Florida for Grand Jury transcripts in the state
10 matter and we have received those. we have issued the
11 Good Samaritan Hospital for billing records and we have
12 received those.
13 we have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to the
14 Dalton School located in New York and at this time they
15 do not have the records we have requested or could not
16 locate those.
17 we have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to Extra
18 Touch Flowers located here in west Palm Beach and we
19 have received documentation from them. We issued a
20 Grand Jury subpoena to Bill Hammond, another pilot for
21 Mr. Epstein, we have spoken with him.
22 we have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to Larry
23 visoski, another one of Mr. Epstein's pilots, and we
24 have received documentation as well as spoken to him.
25 we have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to Janusz
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 Banasiak, who is the property manager currently for
2 Mr. Epstein at his Palm Beach residence, and we have
3 received documentation as well as spoken to him, and we
4 have issued a Grand Jury subpoena to
5 and have received some documentation and are still
6 awaiting a response.
7 Q Now, you mentioned that you didn't bring with
8 you the evidence that you received from the Palm Beach
9 Police Department, but did you bring with you all of the
10 other evidence that was received in response to the
11 subpoenas?
12 A i have.
13 Q And is that evidence in the two boxes that are
14 here in the front?
15 A Yes.
16 Q we will bring all of this back to you when we
17 present the indictment, but would anyone like to look at
18 any of the documentation today?
19 A GRAND JUROR: what does the documentation
20 constitute, basically, the subpoenas?
21 THE WITNESS: It is primarily business
22 records, flight manifests, stuff that came from him
23 traveling to and from Palm Beach, credit card
24 records, the businesses as far as the rental
25 agreement which involves some of the underage girls
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 with the rental cars, and flower shop, you know.
2 A GRAND JUROR: will we have an opportunity
3 later to go through these if we need to?
4 MS. Yes, we will bring them when
5 we present the indictment. Yes, ma'am.
6 A GRAND JUROR: If i should hold this for
7 later let me know, she mentioned the hospital
8 records were subpoenaed, could more information
9 about why they were subpoenaed be provided at this
10 time?
11 BY MS.
12 Q You can answer that.
13 A One of the girls that was an underage that
14 was underage at the time that is involved with
15 Mr. Epstein has had a baby and we were interested and
16 wondering if possibly he was the father of that baby,
17 which at this time we do not believe he was.
18 A GRAND JUROR: Thank you.
19 MS. A question?
20 A GRAND JUROR: Did the flight manifest show
21 passengers on the plane?
22 THE WITNESS: Yes, they do.
23 A GRAND JUROR: Were any of the passengers the
24 underage girls that were a target of the
25 investigation?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 THE WITNESS: At this time we have not
2 associated any of these underage girls as being the
3 passengers. The flight manifests, sometimes the
4 pilot if they did not know who the passenger was
5 would put one passenger or one female, one male,
6 these were private planes and they, you know, may
7 not have felt like they can go up and ask, but we
8 don't have any evidence at this time to believe
9 that they were any of our victims.
10 MS. Any follow-up? Any other
11 questions from the Grand Jury? Yes, ma'am.
12 A GRAND JUROR: The records that you
13 subpoenaed from the high school, what were they
14 used for or why were they instrumental in the
15 investigation?
16 THE ITNESS: Those are the girls' school
17 records and we are just looking at the girls'
18 records.
19 A GRAND JUROR: Absenteeism?
20 THE WITNESS: Just looking at some of their
21 grades and performances and how they did in school.
22 MS. Ladies and gentlemen, before
23 we continue, the witness has mentioned a few names
24 of the minors and that is confidential information,
25 obviously everything that you hear within these
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 walls is confidential.
2 BY MS.
3 Q Now, special Agent after -- in
4 addition to issuing the subpoenas, you mentioned that
5 one of the subpoenas was to the Palm Beach Police
6 Department. Did you review any of the evidence that
7 they collected?
8 A Yes.
9 Q And can you, for example, did the Palm Beach
10 Police Department interview any girls?
11 A Yes, they did, they interviewed several of the
12 girls, most of the girls, they took taped statements
13 from the girls either in the form of a tape-recorder or
14 through video.
15 Q And you have reviewed some of those
16 interviews, correct?
17 A Yes, we have.
18 Q And has the FBI performed any interviews?
19 A Yes, we have, we have performed interviews of
20 past and current employees of Mr. Epstein as well as
21 focusing in on the girls, the girls that were underage
22 at the time of the sexual activity, we wanted to
23 determine with these girls, again, the sexual activity
24 that took place with Mr. Epstein as well as how old they
25 were at the time, if they traveled with Mr. Epstein, any
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 gifts that they may have gotten, so we did reach out to
2 several of the underage minors and gathered more
3 information from them.
4 Q And through the FBI'S investigation has the
S FBI identified additional victims that perhaps the state
6 police officers did not know about?
7 A Yes, we are still trying to identify, get
8 first names of girls and going back and looking through
9 school yearbooks and attempting to try to locate friends
10 of friends, so we are still in the process, when you
11 interview one of the girls and you ask if any of their
12 friends went, they sometimes will give you other names,
13 so we are in the process of still uncovering victims and
14 reaching out and interviewing additional girls that we
15 believe possibly were underage at the time of this
16 sexual activity.
17 Q If I could ask you to step outside.
18 (The witness was excused from the Grand Jury
19 room.)
20 (Questions posed by the Grand Jury.)
21 (The witness was recalled to testify before
22 the Grand Jury.)
23 BY MS.
24 Q Special Agent one of the Grand
25 Jurors asked whether there was any evidence of force or
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 coercion.
2 A when talking to the girls they were told that
3 they may have to -- they were going there to perform a
4 massage, possibly model lingerie, they went there
5 sometimes on multiple occasions and they may start off
6 wearing their clothing and then he would instruct them
7 to remove their clothing, the girls either performed
8 these massages in the nude or keeping their underwear
9 on.
10 As they went back again and again on some of
11 the occasions the girls would take off more and more of
12 their clothing, so when they first started they may be
13 fully clothed and then when they came back he would
14 instruct them to remove more of their clothing, so as
15 far as coercion, they were paid $200 to $400 to perform
16 these massages.
17 They are not trained in performing massages,
18 they don't -- they are not masseuses, but yet if you ask
19 if they were coerced, they were paid quite a bit of
20 money for 30 to 45 minutes work.
21 Some of the girls, being that they were minors
22 going to his residence, got in over their heads and did
23 not always return or come back, some of our Iictims did
24 not come back after, you know, they did go down to their
25 thong underwear and Mr. Epstein did perform sexual acts
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 either by -- and I didn't get into that, but either by
2 stroking their vagina on the outside of their panties or
3 sometimes inside their panties as well as fondling them,
4 and the girls, many of our victims did not realize that
5 that was what was going to happen.
6 Q And was there one instance where Mr. Epstein
7 actually engaged in vaginal intercourse with a girl
8 against her will?
9 A Yes, he did, one of our victims who had been
10 going there over a lengthy period of time had told
11 Mr. Epstein on several occasions that he was not to do
12 that and he did turn her around, threw her on the
13 massage table and penetrated her.
14 Q A Grand Juror asked how old Mr. Epstein is.
15 A He was 45 at the time that we are looking at
16 him at that time period.
17 Q A Grand Juror asked if you know the proportion
18 of girls who were underage versus 18 or older.
19 A The majority of the girls that we are looking
20 at are victims, well, all of our victims that we are
21 looking at were under the age of 18.
22 As far as all of the girls that have been
23 interviewed, the majority definitely were under 18. To
24 give you a number, I would have to go and count, but I
25 would say in the state investigation there were over 25
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 girls identified and more than a majority would have
2 been under the age of 18.
3 Q A Grand Juror asked whether we have obtained
4 mr. Epstein's DNA and whether there was any DNA testing
5 of the baby that you spoke of earlier.
6 A No, we have not.
7 Q A Grand Juror asked how Mr. Epstein would make
8 contact with the girls, was this done via computer or in
9 some other method?
10 A I am sorry, his personal
11 assistant, would contact, or on some occasions Adriana
12 mucinska would also contact the girls via their cell
13 phone and we have message pads from the residents that
14 also indicate the girls calling the home in response to
15 some of those phone calls, so they would call,
16 would call, the majority of the calls were made
17 by to the girls arranging for these, you
18 know, can you come at this time, can you come at that
19 time.
20 Q And is the cellular telephone a facility of
21 interstate commerce?
22 A yes, it is.
23 Q And then one of the Grand Jurors asked whether
24 the assistants knew that the girls were underage or
25 committed sex acts.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
3 age or
4 A
6 example,
7 going on?
22 but.
Did anybody, have you interviewed pnyhntiv who
affirmatively told you that they told heir
what was going on behind closed doors?
No, no, not at this time, not at this time.
And what leads you to believe that she, for
knew or should have known what was
A There are so many girls that
contacted to give Mr. Epstein massages
training in massages, and that
that have no
was aware
that girls were bringing other girls, you know, their
friends to do these massages.
IIIIIIIpas also making appointments for
legitimate massages for Mr. Epstein from legitimate
masseuses that would come and give him massages, so the
number of girls, their appearances at the time would
lead us to believe that had knowledge that
these girls were underage.
Q All right. Thank you very much. Those were
all the questions from the Grand Jury.
A GRAND JUROR: Actually, I have two more,
MS. VILLAFANA: Okay.
A GRAND JUROR: what was the actual age range
of these girls?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 THE WITNESS: 14 to I mean.
2 A GRAND JUROR: The other one was, how did Ms.
3 Kellen actually originally get these girls, how
4 were they brought in, I mean how were they, you
5 know, because you said she called them when he was
6 arriving, but how did these girls come into this in
7 the first place?
8 A GRAND JUROR: Could she speak louder?
9 Special Agent Kuyrkendall, we
10 just had a request that you speak louder.
11 A GRAND JUROR: 14 and what?
12 THE WITNESS: Our victims were 14 to 17, but
13 we have girls that are 18, we have girls that are
14 20, we have girls that are in their early 20s, and
15 your question was?
16 A GRAND JUROR: How did she originally get
17 them in in the first place?
18 THE WITNESS: We are focusing in on 2004,
19 2005, we have some evidence to show that this
20 activity was taking place even earlier than that,
21 certainly to include 2003 if you look at the
22 message pads, but focusing in on 2004, 2005, the
23 chain started with one of our minors and from that
24 minor who goes to the house, Mr. Epstein tells
25 her -- sees that she is maybe not comfortable with
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 doing the massage the way he would like it and
2 tells her that she could bring other girls to do
3 the massages and she in fact if she brought another
4 girl she would be paid S200 for just bringing
5 another girl, so there starts the chain, and
6 Mr. Epstein would ask the girls or would ask
7 the girls for their phone numbers so each time, you
8 know, if one of the girls brought a girl and he
9 liked her he would ask for her phone number, ask
10 her to leave the phone number, or
11 would get the phone number and then that girl would
12 maybe bring, because if you brought somebody you
13 didn't have to do the massage, but you also got
14 paid for bringing a new person, so not only if you
15 did the massage would you get anywhere from 200 to
16 400, but if you brought a new female you would
17 receive 200 or $400.
18 A GRAND JUROR: Do you know how she solicited
19 that original minor?
20 THE WITNESS: I don't. well, I know that
21 minor was approached by two individuals and we have
22 interviewed one of those individuals who we can
23 connect back to Mr. Epstein four years, possibly,
24 prior to this, and stated that his job was actually
25 to drive some of the girls to the residence and
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (9S4) 467-8204
1 that's pretty much where we start off.
2 the Grand Jury like
3 o maintain the records
4 that we received in response to the subpoenas?
5 A GRAND JUROR: Maintain versus what?
6 A GRAND JUROR: What is our choice?
7 MS. VILLAFANA: I don't know that there is. I
8 guess I could maintain them, but I don't believe we
9 have secure storage in here.
10 would you like Special Agent to
11 maintain custody?
12 A GRAND JUROR: Yes.
13 MS. You should have something to
14 swear her in as a custodian.
15 (The witness was sworn in as the custodian of
16 records.)
17 MS. Thank you, ladies and
18 gentlemen, I am the last person for today, so you
19 guys are free to go and we will see you probably in
20 a couple of weeks, we will be seeing a lot of you.
21 (The witness was excused from the Grand Jury
22 room.)
23 (The testimony of the witness concluded
24 before the Grand Jury.)
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
1 CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
4 I certify pages 2 through 21 are a true
5 transcript of my shorthand notes of the testimony of
6 before the Federal Grand Jury,
7 west Palm Beach, Florida on the 6th day of February,
8 2007.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE (954) 467-8204
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Perry Bard [friend] Palm Beach chiropractor, phone number came up in Epstein victim investigations, left $3 million in Epstein's will 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00186835 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ subpoena of Perry Bard
(date: 2007-03-13)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ OLY-38            │
╰───────────────────╯

United States District Court SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TO: Perry Bard, DC
Health First Chiropractic Center
West Palm Beach, FL 33409
SUBPOENA TO TESTIFY
BEFORE GRAND JURY
FGJ 07-103(WPB)-Tues./No. OLY-38
SUBPOENA FOR:
PERSON DOCUMENTS OR OBJECTS)
YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear and testify before the Grand Jury of the United States District
Court at the place, date and time specified below.
PLACE:
United States District Courthouse
701 Clematis Street
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 '
ROOM:
Grand Jury Room
DATE AND TIME:
March 13, 2007
1:00 pm*
YOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you the following document(s) or object(s):
All documents refining or relating to Jeffrey Epstein, including but not limited to billing statements,
record of payments, appointment books, treatment notes, and correspondence.
*Please coordinate your compliant d confirm the date and time , and location of
ce with Special Agen Federal Bureau of Investigation, Telephone:
This subpoena shall remain in effect until you are granted leave to depart by the court or by an officer acting
on behalf of the court.
CLERK

(EY) DEPUTY CLERK
DATE:
March 2, 2007
This subpoena is issued upon application
of the Unit tates of America
•If not applicable, enter "none."
Name Address and Ph e Number of Assistant U.S. Attorney
ssistant U.S. Attorney
500 So. Australian Avenue, Suite 400
West Palm R -6235
T
Fa
To to used b thu of AO110 FORM ORD-227
JAN.86
EFTA00007253 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill
(date: 2007-03-23)
phone bill
EFTA00007301 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering Blackberry phone logs for 2005
(date: 2007-03-23)
phone bill covering Blackberry phone logs for 2005
EFTA00006085 (Jmail)
 [misc] Front of House Managers Report including ticket sales
(inferred date: 2007-03-29)
Front of House Managers Report including ticket sales
EFTA00009586 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2007-04-24)
Transcript
April 24, 2007
f LA- Si'
oQ n st i scat
`v 1 &cmJvWS
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY-O00368
3501.182-031
Pagc I of 35
I
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR
TESTIMONY,
Federal Grand Jury 07-103
Federal Building
U.S. Courthouse
West Palm Beach, Florida
Tuesday, April 24, 2007
APPEARANCES:
roreperson
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LIC.

(954) 467-8204. .
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-OJ TESTIMONY -000389
3501.182-031
Page 2 of 35
• 1
The sworn testimony of was
taken before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm
Beach Division, Federal Building, U.S. Courthouse,
Palm Beach County, State of Florida, on'Tuesday,
April 24, 2007.
Paula E. Angelocci, Certified Court
Reporter and Notary Public, State of Florida,
Official Reporting Service, LLC, 524 South Andrews
Avenue, Suite 302N, Fort Lauderdale, Florida,
33301, was authorized to and did report the sworn
testimony.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000370
3501.182-031
Page 3 of35
(Witness enters the Grand Jury Room.)
THE FOREPERSON: You do solemnly swear
that the testimony you give will be the
truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the
truth, so help you God?
THE WITNESS: I do.
THE FOREPERSON: Thank you. Please be
seated.
EXAMINATION
BY III
Q Good afternoon, Ms. . Could you
state and spell your name for the record?
A
And where do you currently live?
A I live -- do you want me to give the
address?
Q Sure.
,'West Palm Beach,
Florida 33412.
Q Okay. And you are living with your
parents now?
A Yes.
Q Were you served with a subpoena to
appear before the grand jury today?
A Yes.
CONFIDENTIAL
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 167-8204
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000371
3501.182-031
Page 4 of 35
Q And do you understand that an order was
signed by a judge compelling you to appear and
answer questions?
A Yes.
Q And that order states that what you tell
the grand jury won't be used against unless you
perjure yourself?
A Yes.
Q Do you understand that you are under
oath, and if you don't tell the truth --
A I can go to jail, yes.
Q Okay. Let's start with where you went
to high school.
A
Q How old are you today?
A Twenty-one.
Q And what is your date of birth?
A
.Q What year did you graduate from
A 2004.
Q And where are you currently working?
A I currently am not working.
Q But you are
A
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM204J TESTIMONY -000372
3501.182-031
Pagc 5 of 35
Q Where will that be?
A Fort Lauderdale, Coral Springs.
Q What type of position will that be?
A
Q Have you worked since the time that you
graduated from high school?
A Uh-huh.
Q Can you tell the grand jury what type of
jobs you have had?
A I worked at
worked in a club up in Orlando as as
well. I have also worked at a sports bar as a
waitress.
Q when you were in high school, where did
you work?
A and
▪ And do you know Jeffrey Epstein?
A Yes, I do. .
Q Can you tell the grand jury how you
first came to meet Mr. Epstein?
A I met Epstein through two acquaintances,
and , and I met them at a beach resort.
They made a proposition to me. Later then I
picked them up and they gave me directions to the
house and that's where I was formerly introduced
CONFIDENTIAL
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000373
3501.182-031
Page 6 of 35
4'
to Mr. Epstein.
Q . Okay. And Let me just go back over that
a little bit. You mentioned that you had two
acquaintances, and , and you met them at
a beach resort, correct?
A Yes.
Q And you said that they made a
proposition to you. What was that exactly?
A had asked me if I wanted to make
money and she was working for this guy, Epstein,
in Palm Beach. So I told her I was interested and
she further went into detail about massaging him,
that you would have to take off articles of
clothing and there would be touching and fondling
involved.
Q How old were you when this happened?
A About 16.
Q And how old was
A Same age.
Q And how did you know MIF
A We went to together.
Q And she was in your same grade in high
school?
A Yeah.
Q And you mentioned that had
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000374
3501.182-031
Page 7 of 35
(
previously worked for Epstein or was currently
working for Epstein?
A Yes, that's right.
Q So they explained this proposal to you
and you said that you would be interested?
A Yes.
Q What happened next?
A Within a couple of days to a week I
picked them up and I went to his house to work for
him and I was introduced to , who is his
assistant. She took me upstairs to Epstein's
bedroom and that's where the massage took place.
I was naked and he tried fondling me and
I wouldn't have it, so after the massage he gave
me another proposition to bring girls to the house
and for every girl that I brought I would make
$200.
Q All right. We'll go back over that a
little more slowly. I know this is a lot of
information. So let's go back to the proposition
that and made to you.
Did they say you would be paid for
massaging Mr. Epstein?
A Yes.
Q And how much would you be paid?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000375
3501.182-031
Pagc 8 of 35
S
a
A $200.
Q Now you said that they had told you that
you might have to take your clothing off?
A They told me that I was expected to take
my clothing off and that there would be fondling.
Q Okay. And what -- did they explain
what fondling meant?
A Just that he'd be touching me.
Q Okay. And so you agreed to do that and
you went to Mr. Epstein's home?
A Correct.
Q And where was that located?
A Palm Beach, Brillo Way.
Q B-R -I -L -L -O?
A Yes.
Q And when you arrived at the home, you
said that you were driving with and IIII?
A That is correct.
Q Tell us how you got into the house.
A We went through a gate on the side of
the house that led to the back and we just rang
the doorbell and answered the door and we
were standing in the kitchen and then
brought me upstairs.
Q Okay. Now did you have any -- did
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
NIM20-GJ TESTIMONY-OOO376
3501.182-031
Page 9 of 35
tell you anything about what you would do when you
got upstairs?
A No, she never discussed that with me.
Q Did she say anything to you about taking
your clothes off?
A No, she never discussed that with me.
Q Okay. When you arrived upstairs, you
said that you went into a bedroom?
A That is correct. •
Q What was in the bedroom?
A It was a bedroom that had a door that
led to then I want to say a bigger more than just
a bathroom. It was a bigger room with like a
pretty large size walk-in closet, a shower, a
steam shower, and then two sinks . on the right, and
in the middle laid the massage table, and then to
the left there was two couches.
Q And so the massage table was already set
up when you arrived?
A That is correct.
Q Okay. And after
bedroom, what did she do?
led you up to the
A She had left and that's when Epstein
came in.
Q Okay. And when Mr. Epstein came in,
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000377
3501.182-031
Page 10 of 35
what was he wearing?
A He was wearing a towel.
Q Okay. And nothing else?
A Nothing else.
Q And what did he do?
A He laid on the table and that's when the
massage began and later on he -- when he got in, I
took off my clothes and I was just wearing my
bottoms, and he later tried to touch me and he
grabbed my butt, and that's when. I had a problem.
I told him that I didn't feel comfortable.
So later he took the towel off and he
was laying on his back and he
asking me to
and then after that everything
was done.
Q Okay. So when Mr. Epstein
then the massage or whatever was over?
A Yes, it was.
Q And once that happened, what did he do?
A Just got up and dried himself off and
then walked me downstairs.
Q And you got dressed as well?
A That's right.
Q And when you got back downstairs, what
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000378
3501.182-031
Page 11 of 35
happened?
A I went back into the kitchen and he
pulled and aside and then we just left.
Of course, I got paid.
Q Okay. And tell us where you got paid,
who paid you, and how much you received?
A Epstein paid me. I received 200, but I
cannot recall if it was upstairs that he paid me
or if he waited until I got back downstairs.
Q Okay. And when he paid you the $200,
was it in small bills, large bills?
A Big bills, 100s.
Q Okay. So two 100 dollar bills. And you
said that he pulled and aside. Do you
know what that was about?
A He would never pay them in front of me.
He always was funny about that. So I'm sure it
was just paying them for bringing me.
Q Okay. And you mentioned that you told

Mr. Epstein that you were uncomfortable with him
touching you?
A That's correct.
Q And what bec .ame of that?
A Later on before I left he had addressed
me to not massage him anymore, but asked me if I
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000379
3501.182-031
Page 12 of 35
could bring girls over, and for every girl that I
brought to the table he would pay me $200.
• Q Okay. So you weren't comfortable with
4 him touching you, so you weren't going to do any
5 more massages?
6 A No.
7 Q He wanted you to find other girls?
8 A That's correct.
9 Q And he wanted girls that would let him
10 touch them?
11 A Uh-huh. •
12 Q After that first massage, did you
13 perform any other massages at his house?
14 A Absolutely not. .
15 Q Did you bring girls?
16 A That's correct.
17 Q Tell us how you started to bring girls
18 to Mr. Epstein's house.
19 A Just girls that I met in high school,
20 acquaintances, people that I just said hi and bye
21 to. A lot of them actually heard about it through
22 a couple of girls that I brought and they were
23 interested.
24 Some of the girls asked me about it.
25 Just girls in school I'd talk to, just get on the
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC
(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000380
3501.182-031
Page 13 of 35
subject. They had no problem with it.
Q Okay. So when you found a girl that you
thought would be interested, what exactly would
you tell her?
A I asked them if they were interested in
making extra money and that I knew an older
wealthier man in Palm Beach who liked to have
massages and they would get paid $200.
The more they did, the more they make,
and I would explain to them in detail what was
expected of them when they showed up at the house
and I also told them that if they are under age
just lie about it and tell him that you are 18
Q Let's talk first about what you said
that you tell them what was expected of them.
A Yes.
Q First of all, why did you tell them
that?
A Because that's what I was told
O By whom?
A and
Q Okay. And did Jeffrey Epstein ever
address you about don't bring girls over here if
they don't know what's going to happen?
A Absolutely.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC (954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000381
3501.182-031
Page 14 of 35
1 Q Okay. So all the girls were supposed to
2 know that when they got there they would be
3 undressing?
4 A They would be undressing. There would
5 be. touching. There would be fondling. He was
6 very big on that. He told me never to bring a
7 girl over unless they knew what was expected.
8 Q Okay. And did you also tell them that
9 he would
10 A I didn't really talk to them about that.
I didn't know if he did it with everybody or it
was just with me that he did that.
Q But you told them that they all would
have to be partially naked or fully naked?
A Partially to fully naked and there would
be touching and fondling.
Q Okay. How many girls do you think you
took to Mr. Epstein's house?
A Seven, between seven to ten.
Q Okay. And were there any -- in addition
to this rule about the girls had to know what was
expected, did Mr. Epstein have any other rules in
terms of what the girls looked like or what he
liked?
A No.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MNI20-GJ TESTIMONY -000382
3501.1g2-031
Pagc 15 of 35
Q Okay. Were there girls that you brought
that he didn't like?
A There were a few girls he wasn't crazy
about. He didn't really like. He didn't favor.
for instance, 23, he thought she was kind
of too old.
Q Okay. So you brought a girl named
who was 23 years old?
A Yes.
Q And you were told that she was too old?
A Yes.
Q Did you ever bring her back?
A No.
Q What about any other girls that he
didn't like?
A This other girl T went to high school
with, III, she was maybe a year younger, and him
and her got . I told
her in detail what was expected and she, to me,
was all for it and then when she got there,
decided she didn't want to perform what was
necessary. So they got
and after that I never really brought her
Q Okay. And did either Jeffrey Epstein
CONFIDENTIAL
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY-000383
3501.182-031
Page 16 of 35
1 1
or say anything to you about what happened
with III?
A He had made a comment just about
had asked -- he had asked me for someone to come
over and work and when I suggested III, he kind of
nodded, not really interested. He told me to find
somebody else. So I assumed that meant he really
didn't care for her.
Q Okay. Now the -- you mentioned
who was 23. What was the age range of the other
girls that you brought to Mr. Epstein's home?
A High school, 16 to 18.
Q Were there any girls who were younger
than that?
A Yes.
Q
A
Q And how was she?
A' She was 14.
Who was that?
Q Okay. Now you were interviewed by the
Palm Beach Police Department?
A That's correct.
Q And during that interview, you told them
that there were two ways to make money with
Jeffrey Epstein. Can you explain to the grand
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000384
3501.182-031
Page 17 of 35
a
jury what those two ways are?
A The more you did is the more you make.
Basically, the more clothes that come off, the
more you let him touch you, the more you just let
him have his way with you is the more that you
would make, otherwise, you would be demoted down
to bringing girls over and just making money that
way.
Q And that's what you were doing?
A That's correct.
Q Was bringing girls?
A That's correct.
Q If you could explain to the grand jury
how you would go about making an appointment for a
girl to come and give a massage?
A His assistant there would call me either
before they got into town or while he was in town
and either she would ask me for a particular girl,
preferably one that he favored, or if I couldn't
get a hold of that girl just bring somebody over
to work.
I would call the girl. She would okay

it. I would call back, confirm it, set an
appointment, and then the next couple of days we'd
go.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000305
3501.182-031
Page 18 of 35
Q And was the person that you always
made the appointment with?
A Always.

• Do you remember ever talking to Jeffrey
Epstein on the telephone?
A Never. The only time I talked to him
was physically in person at his house.

• Okay. was really the person that
you had to• --
A Deal with.
Q Okay. Now you mentioned that sometimes
would request a specific girl?
A That's correct.
Q Did she give you any reason why he
really liked this girl or just is this girl
available? What would happen on those calls?
A If it was a specific girl, she would
call me and just ask: Can this girl work? She
would never give me a reason. She would never go
into detail. It was just: Can she work, yes or
no?
work?
Q And was saying to you can she
A I can't recall if those were her exact
words. I can't remember if it•was: Can she come
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
•
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY-OOO386
3501.182-031
Pagc 19 of 35
1 over and massage or can she work? / don't recall
2 the exact words.
3 Q Okay. And once you made those
4 appointments then who would normally take you and
5 the girls to the house?
6 A I would.
7 Q Okay. And you would drive?
8 A I would drive.
9 Q And were all -- wa's this always taking
10 place at Mr. Epstein's home?
11 A Yes.
12 Q On Brillo Way?
13 A That's correct.
14 Q When you spoke with on the
15 telephone, did you were all of these
16 conversations about setting up these appointments/
17 A when I would talk to
18 Q Yes.
19 A Yes. It would be pure business whenever
20 I talked to
21 Q So you didn't have any sort of friendly
22 relationship?
23 A No friendly relationship, never
24 socialized unless I was at the house. It wasn't
25 like that at all.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000387
3501.182.031
Page 20 of 35
1 Q Okay. Now when you would bring a new
2 girl over to the house, what would you do?
3 A Walk up the same way towards the back of
4 the house. They would let us in. I could sit in
'5 the kitchen with the girl. I would either wait
for to come in or Jeffrey. Most of the time
it was
would bring the girl upstairs
while I waited downstairs. After the massage, the
girl would come downstairs. I would get paid and
then we would leave.
Q Tell us how you would get paid when you
were the person who brought the girls.
A What do you mean how I would get paid?
Q Who would pay you?
A Jeffrey Epstein would pull me aside
whether it be in his, I guess, living room slash
office. He would just make sure that when he paid
me, it was just me and him, nobody else was
around.
• And how much would you get paid for each
girl?
A $200-
Q And again with the two 100 dollar bills?
A Always 100 dollar bills.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000388
3501.182-031
Pap 21 of 35
Q Did you ever see the girl who actually
did the massages get paid?
A No, I never saw them get paid. He never
paid us in front of each other
Q Okay. Did the girls ever tell you that
they did get paid or how much they got paid?
A Most of the time.
Q Okay. And how much money would each
girl get paid?
A It ranges.
Q From?
A It ranges from 200 to some got paid 300.
Like I said, the more you do, the more you make.
There were a couple of girls that got paid 300,
400, and then there were a couple of girls that
got paid 200 maybe even 100.
Q Now you mentioned that usually
would take the girl upstairs?
A That's correct.
Q Were there ever instances where you took
the girl upstairs?
A Very rarely. I think it happened once
or twice where was doing something or she
would need me to go upstairs and set up. I would
just go upstairs. I would show her where the
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY-000389
3501.182.031
Page 22 of 35
.13
massage table was.
I would set it up for them. I would
show them where the towels were, put the towels on
the massage table and then I would tell them
Jeffrey would be in, in a minute and then I would
walk back downstairs and wait in the kitchen.
Q Okay. And when you were in these other
instances where you led the girl upstairs, besides
the massage table, did you ever see any other
implements that were used during the massage?
A I think there were maybe a few occasions
where I would walk upstairs to show the girl or
maybe it was even when I first massaged him, there
was like a white
jury?
on the table or a white
Q And can you describe that to the grand
A What it looked like?
Q What it looked like, yes.
A
The
the top of it was
It was like a . It was really
. It was white. I think
maybe like pink. It was
that's all I remember.
Q Okay. And did any of the girls ever
tell you that that
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
NIM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000390
3501.182-031
Page 23 of 35
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Q Okay. Now I'm going to run through the
names of some girls that you brought just to
confirm with the grand jury that you brought them.
A Okay.
A That's correct.
Q
A Correct.
A Correct.
Q
A Yes.
A Yes.
Q
A Yes.
Q And then there is another girl,
A never, ever, ever worked for
Jeffrey. She accompanied me to his house I think
once or twice and waited in the kitchen with me,
but she never worked for him.
Q Okay. But she was somebody that you
brought along with you?
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000391
3501.182.031
Page 24 of 35
A That is correct.
Q On visits?
A Yes.
Q Okay. In addition to those girls
that -- who I just named, you mentioned a woman,
, who is 23?
A Uh-huh.
Q Were there any other girls that you
recall bringing to Jeffrey Epstein's house?
A I cannot recall bringing anybody else.
Q Okay. Now one of those girls that we
mentioned .was correct?
A Yes.
Q And you told the police that Jeffrey
liked the best?
A Yes.
Q How old was
A She was around the same age as me, maybe
a grade lower than me.
Q Okay.  So she was under age?
A Yes, correct.
Q And all of those girls who names I read
were under age when you brought them there?
A Except for
• Okay. What did look like?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000392
3501.182-031
Page 25 of 35
A was . She kind of looks
but she's , maybe. She
had a . She had
Q Was she thin or heavy?
A No. She was maybe -- she had a
figure, maybe a little than me.
Q And how tall do you think she was?
A About 5'5, 5'6.
Q Okay. And you knew that Jeffrey liked
because he would specifically request her?
A There was a few occasions that he would
specifically ask for her, correct.
Q Okay. And you mentioned that some of
the girls told you about the
correct?
A Yes.
Q Did some of girls tell you what happened
inside of that bedroom?
A A few of them did.
Q Let's talk first about
A Okay.
Q Did she tell you what happened?
A All that she really told me was that
they got into . He had tried
CONFIDENTIAL
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000393
3501.182-031
Page 26 of 35
) 1
fondling her. She wasn't having it, and then she
only got paid $100 and she felt like she was being
ripped off.
Q Okay. What about , did
she tell you about what happened?
A Yes.
Q What did she explain to you?
A , on the way home, had told me she
got paid $300, and basically let him
and
Q Okay. And she told you those things?
A She told me those things.
Q That he had and
had ?
A That's correct.
Q Okay. And that was -- when did she tell
you that?
A Right when we got outside into the
truck.
Q As you were driving away?
A That's correct.
Q Do you remember which other girls told
you about the
A I can't recall. I know there was
another one that said something about the
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000394
3501.182-031
Page 27 of 35
massager, but I wasn't really paying attention.
Q Now when you first went and gave Mr.
Epstein the massage, did he ask for your telephone
number after you were finished?
A No, did.
did. And she took down your
telephone number?
A She took down my name and my telephone
number.
• After that, how was all contact made
with you?
A
• Directly to you?
A Directly toward me.
Q Okay. So were there any more instances
where she went either through or to
reach you?
A Absolutely not.
Q Okay. Now when you brought girls over
was it the same thing where they would ask for the
girl's name and number?
A Yes.
Q And when that happened, would they
continue to go through you to set up appointments?
A Most of time they went through me.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000395
35o .I s, _03
Fag,: 2N or 35
Actually 99.9 percent of the time they went
through me. On a few occasions, the girls that
they liked the best, for instance, , after
a while me and stopped contact with each
other and Jeffrey just went strictly through her.
Q Okay. And when an appointment was made
directly with the girl, you wouldn't necessarily
know about it?
A I would not necessarily know about it.
Q And when the appointment was made
directly with the girl then you wouldn't get paid,
correct?
A Correct.
Q Did you hear or do you know whether some
girls that you brought, brought more girls?
A Yeah, I'm sure of it.
Q Okay. When did you first meet
Was it that day that you went to give the
massage?
A That's correct.
Q And how did you first meet her?
A Just walking in the kitchen and waiting
for somebody whether it be Epstein or
came and introduced herself as and I
learned that she was Epstein's assistant.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000398
3501.182-031
Page 29 of 35
Q And you said that she was the one who
took you upstairs on the first day?
A That's correct.
Q And we were talking earlier about how
appointments would be made for you to bring
additional girls, correct?
A Yes.
Q How far in advance would call you
to make appointments?
A It depends. Sometimes she would call me
a few days in advance. Jeffrey is going to be in
town tomorrow or this weekend, have a couple of
girls lined up or have a girl lined up. So it
would be anywhere between a couple of days to a
weekend.
Q Okay. Did you ever talk with or
did ever tell you anything about what
Jeffrey liked to do with the girls?
A Absolutely not. We never discussed
that.
Q Did you ever talk with her about a rumor
that you had heard that a girl had intercourse
with Jeffrey?
A One day I was talking on the phone with
and I addressed her with it, asking her
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000397
3501.182-031
Page 30 of 35
about a rumor I heard of a girl sleeping with
Jeffrey, having intercourse, and making $1 ,000,
and she denied it and said that he doesn't do that
kind of thing, he just plays with them.
Q Okay. So she said that he didn't have
intercourse, he just liked to play with the girls?
A That's correct.
Q And when you spoke with the police, you
said that Jeffrey liked to
A That's correct.
Q What led you to believe that?
A He just did it. I just learned that
Epstein just
. It was like the new thing for him, and
it just started happening and more and more girls
were making comments.
Q So did know that he was
A Not that I know of. I didn't say
anything and I don't think she had an idea. I
think she knew there was playing going on. I
don't think she knew of what sort.
Q . Okay. So she knew that something sexual
was going on., but not necessarily what that
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000398
3501.182-031
Page 31 of 35
entailed?
A Correct.
Q Okay. Did Jeffrey or or anyone
else who worked for Mr. Epstein ever ask you for
proof of someone's age?
A Never.
Q Did they ever specifically instruct you
that you shouldn't bring girls who were under age
to the house?
A Never.
Q And when you spoke with the police
department you said that at some point Jeffrey
said the younger the better?
A That's correct.
Q And even after that he never said to you
but make sure that they are over 18?
A We never discussed age. He never made a
comment about age except for that one time
about her being too old. He never told me to go
find under aged girls, but at the same time never
said make sure they are over 18. It was never
discussed.
Q Okay. All right.
I'm going to ask you to
step outside for a minute and I will find out
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000399
3501.182-031
Page 32 of 35
BY
if the grand jury has questions. Thank you
very much.
(Witness exits the Grand Jury Room.)
* *
(Witness enters the Grand Jury Room.)
Q Hs. I have to remind you that
8 you are still under oath. There were just two
1'0
follow-up questions. The first one is something
that I think you spoke about earlier, but who
first asked you to find other girls?
A Who first asked me to first other girls?
Q Yes.
A That would be Epstein.
Q Okay. So Jeffrey asked you himself,
Jeffrey Epstein himself asked you?
A Yes.
Q Okay. And then the other question was:
Are you currently in contact with anyone who works
for Mr. Epstein or himself?
A I don't talk to any of the females that
I once brought over there. I haven't been in
contact with Epstein for years. He tried
contacting me a few times.
I haven't contacted him back. I refuse
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY-000400
3501.182-031
Page 33 of 35
,33
1,6
to talk to him. I refuse to talk to any of the
girls that were involved. However, I did live
with one of the girls in Orlando for a couple
months to a year. I haven't spoken to her in over
a year either.
Q Okay. So after and just so the grand
jury has a sense here, we are talking about the
2004 to 2005 period is when you were bringing
girls over?
A That's correct.
Q So since then
A I don't -- to be honest with you, I
think it was more 2003, 2004.
Q Okay.
A My junior senior year.
Q Okay. But anyhow it .was a couple of
years ago?
A Several years ago.
Q Okay.
Is there any follow up
on either of those points? Yes,
A GRAND JUROR: Was it Jeffrey Epstein
himself trying to contact you or
THE WITNESS: I don't know if it wasliim
directly. I know that his number showed up
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY-000401
3501.182-031
Page 34 of 35
on my house phone. I'm assuming because
gill. was there, I'm assuming that she is the
one that has been trying to contact me in the
past years. Epstein never talked directly to
me on the phone.
: Any other follow up?
Okay. Thank you, IIIIII Thank you for
coming.
(Witness was excused.)
CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
I, Paula E. Angelocci, Certified Court
Reporter and Notary Public, do certify that the
transcript is a true and correct transcription of
my stenotype notes of the testimony of
taken before the Federal Grand Jury,
West Palm Beach, Florida.
AULA E. AANGHIQICCI, CSR #4869
Certified Court Reporter
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC
(954) 467-8204
CONFIDENTIAL
MM20-GJ TESTIMONY -000402
3501.182-031
Page 35 of 35
(
(
EFTA00009440 (Jmail)
 [legal] FBI agent testimony on subpoenas of JP Morgan, Western Union, Adult Video Warehouse
EFTA00001487 (Jmail)
 [misc] architectural drawing of one floor of Epstein's NYC residence
(inferred date: 2007-07-03)
architectural drawing of one floor of Epstein's NYC residence
╔════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 William Riley [lawyer] private investigator 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00222943 (Jmail)
 [government] grand jury proceedings FBI agent testimony, see quote: "I believe that certain items were purposely removed from Mr. Epstein's home in 
anticipation of an execution of a search warrant"
(inferred date: 2007-07-29)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
IN RE GRAND JURY SUBPOENAS FGJ 07-103(WPB)
DUCES TECUM NUMBERS
OLY-63 and OLY-64 UNDER SEAL
EX PARTE AFFIDAVIT OF
being duly sworn, state that the following is true and correct to the best of my
information and belief:

1. I am currently employed as a Special Agent with the Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI") and have
been so employed for the past years. I am assigned to the Miami Division, West Palm Beach Field Office,
and for the past years, I have been assigned to investigate mostly child exploitation cases.

2. In early 2006, Detective Joseph Recarey with the City of Palm Beach Police Department ("PBPD")
contacted me about the investigation of Jeffrey Epstein's solicitation of minors to engage in prostitution and his
lewd and lascivious conduct with minors. The FBI opened a case file in 2006, and I am the case agent
assigned to the investigation.

3. At around the same time that the FBI opened its investigation, the U.S. Attorney's Office began a grand
jury investigation. I am one of the agents on the Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 6(e) list, that is, someone
who is authorized to have access to the fact of the investigation and the materials related thereto.

4. As part of the grand jury investigation, a subpoena was issued for all of the physical evidence obtained
by PBPD during the course of its investigation, including the evidence seized when PBPD executed the search
warrant at Jeffrey Epstein's home in October 2005.

5. From my review of the photographs from the execution of the search warrant and my conversations
with Detective Joseph Recarey, I believe that certain items were purposely removed from Mr. Epstein's home in
anticipation of an execution of a search warrant. This includes the three computers which are the subject of
grand jury subpoena numbers OLY-63 and OLY-64.

6. I believe that the computers will be helpful to the grand July investigation in several ways. First, one
of the possible crimes that Mr. Epstein has committed is the travel in interstate commerce for the purpose of
engaging in illicit sexual conduct with a minor, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 2423(b).
Another possible offense is the use of a facility of interstate commerce to persuade, induce, or entice a minor to
engage in prostitution or other illicit sexual conduct, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section
2422(b). From other items recovered during the PBPD investigation and the FBI's own investigation, I know
that some member or members of Mr. Epstein's staff maintained a calendar on one of the computers in the
household, and maintained other computer files with telephone messages. A telephone is a facility of interstate
commerce, so evidence of the use of the telephones to arrange appointments for sexual activity is evidence of a
violation of Section 2422(b). The calendars also showed other types of appointments and travel plans, which
could be evidence that the purpose of Mr. Epstein's travel was to engage in sexual activity with the teenagers he
recruited from Royal Palm Beach High School, [list other high schools]. Based upon the investigation, I believe
that someone other than Mr. Epstein prepared the computerized calendar and telephone messages. Thus, Mr.
Epstein would not be required to authenticate any such documents recovered from the computer.

7. The second way that the computers will assist the grand jury is the possibility that photographs of the
crime victims may appear. I know from Detective Recarey that, at one time, Jeffrey Epstein had a security
system that automatically downloaded images from surveillance cameras onto a computer. Detective Recarey
learned about that in 2005, a period when I know, from my investigation, that Mr. Epstein was
actively involved in lewd and lascivious conduct with the minor females. To the extent that Mr. Epstein tries to
deny that any or all of the victims ever visited his home, video footage of them at the house would rebut such a
claim.

8. Also, during the FBI's investigation, I interviewed a young woman, "." who had known Mt Epstein
several years ago, when she was in her late teens/early twenties. The woman was a struggling artist who
specialized in painting nude portraits of her family members, including her younger siblings. Prior to preparing
a portrait, the artist would take several photographic studies. Jeffrey Epstein was very interested in her work and
her photographs, and also expressed an interest in the artist's younger sister, m," who was only years' old at
the time. Mr. Epstein paid fao travel to one of his homes, located in New Mexico. During that visit, Mt
Epstein touched inappropriately =  and asked her to touch him while he was nude. After learning of this, gt,
confronted Mr. Epstein and cut off all contact with him. When `2" checked her belongings, she learned that
some of the nude photographs had been taken from her and '2" believes that Mr. Epstein took them. Although
the nude photographs were artistic rather than pornographic, I believe that this shows a potential interest by Mt
Epstein in child pornography, and, therefore, I would like a computer expert to review Mr. Epstein's computer
for possible child pornography. I have interviewed 'I" and about their experiences and both have
expressed a fear of speaking publicly against Mr. Epstein for fear of reprisals against them or their family.
Accordingly, the computer's contents may be the only admissible evidence of Mr. Epstein's interest in child
pornography at trial (assuming that such evidence is discovered).

9. The information related to the computers also would be helpful to the grand jury in trying to determine
whether: (a) there was a "leak" at the State Attorney's Office; (b) whether Jeffrey Epstein was involved in
obstruction of justice through the tampering with or destruction of evidence; and (c) as evidence of knowledge of
guilt based upon case law that states that attempts to flee or hide or destroy evidence can be considered as
evidence of a guilty mind.

10. With respect to the computers that are the subject of the pending grand jury subpoenas, through the
grand July investigation I was asked to interview Janusz Banasiak, the property manager for Jeffrey Epstein's
Palm Beach home. Banasiak worked in that position during the time of the execution of the search warrant. I
asked Banasiak whether he had removed the computers from the Epstein household. He stated that he had not,
and that a" and a private investigator had come to the house and taken the computers away. I know from
the investigation that In isialM, nee who sometimes worked as a personal assistant
to Jeffrey Epstein. is considered a target of the investigation, but neither nor Epstein is aware of that
classification at this time. From the physical description of the private investigator, I knew that Banasiak was
referring to Paul Lavery, a private investigator who had traveled to the homes of several victims.

11. A grand jury subpoena was served on Mr. Lavery at his office in Miami. Mr. Lavery hired an attorney
and initially refused to respond to the subpoena. Eventually, based upon conversations between Assistant United
States Attorney and counsel for Mr. Lavery, I was allowed to interview Mr. Lavery by
telephone. During that interview, Mr. Lavery stated that he had traveled to Jeffrey Epstein's home in the fall of
2005 and that a woman (whom he believed was a) had given him the computer equipment, already in
boxes. Lavery stated that he had the computers for a few days, probably over a weekend, before he delivered the
computers to William Riley. Lavery stated that he did not tamper with the computers while they were in his
possession.

12. Based upon the interview of Paul Lavery, grand jury subpoenas were prepared for William Riley and
the Custodian of Records of his firm, Riley Kiraly. Riley Kiraly is an independent private investigation firm,
with its own offices in Miami, Florida. Attached hereto as Exhibit K-1 are copies of printouts from the Riley
Kiraly website, explaining the services offered. Neither Mr. Riley nor Riley Kiraly works exclusively for Roy
Black or any other lawyer or law firm.

13. I personally served the subpoenas on William Riley at his offices. He did not indicate whether he still
had custody of the subpoenaed computers. Based upon the foregoing facts, I believe that Mr. Riley either
currently has the computers in his possession or knows who has them. At the very least, Mr. Riley can tell the
grand July to whom he delivered the computers.
FURTHER AFFIANT SAYETH NAUGHT.
Special Agent
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this day of July, 2007.
Notary Public
EFTA00222970 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings
EFTA00038915 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of minor victim, claims Epstein knew she was 14
(inferred date: 2007-08-13)
08/13/2007
Pursuant to a federal investigation regarding the sexual
exploitation of minors, was interviewed by the
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). After being advised of the identity
of the interviewing agents and purpose of the interview,
voluntarily provided the following information:
, at age 14, was introduced to Jeffrey Epstein by a 17
year old girl named Last Name Unknown( began dating
in December 2000. former boyfriend
and father of her child, was friends with boyfriend
Soon after began dating approached at a
party and asked her if she would like to make $300.00. explained
that
massage.
told she could make a lot of money real fast.
She needed to dress sexy and provide a massage for an hour and she would
make $300.00. told that Epstein might ask her to remove
her shirt but she could keep her bra on. told , "If you
don't like something let me know." told she would
massage Epstein with her.
met Epstein for the first time when she traveled to his
Palm Beach residence with noticed an older lady with
short black hair and an unknown accent at Epstein's residence.
led to the upstairs steam room area of the residence.
and met Epstein upstairs, he was wearing only a towel. Epstein
told she was pretty. Epstein asked her age.
uttered "four" and then said 17. Epstein responded by saying, "so you are
fourteen." was previously instructed by to tell Epstein
she was 17. He told that they would not tell anyone.
and simultaneously performed the massage on
Epstein. massaged his legs while massaged his back. Ten
to 20 minutes prior to the end of the massage, Epstein stated to
"take off your shirt" and "take off your pants."
undressed to her bra and panties. Epstein asked
around the massage table at which time he reached for
sat on a couch located in Epstein's steam room area. As
could make $300.00 by providing a man in Palm Beach with a
located
and
paid
one
and
got naked and
to walk
watched,
and Epstein had sexual intercourse on the massage table which was
directly in front of the couch where was
were looking at as they were having
$300.00 at the end of the massage. Epstein
for her cell phone number.
stated has
occasion, Epstein indicated to
has started
and called to s
III. Epstein re
On
boyfriend
the car while
on one occasion.
chedule
turned
seated. Epstein
sex. Epstein
also asked
been missing for a long time. On
that was in Thailand
a family of her own.
obtained Epstein's phone number from a telephone book
a massage session by leaving a message with
call.
second visit to Epstein's residence, her former
drove her to Epstein's residence. waited in
entered the residence alone.
She sat in the kitchen and the chef asked if she was
has met Epstein
hungry. was there and led her upstairs. placed towels on the
massage table. disrobed to her underwear and massaged Epstein.
Epstein touched her breasts and he began masturbating. was paid
$300.00 at the conclusion of the massage.
went to Epstein's residence over 100 times for
approximately three years beginning when she was 14 years old. She
regularly used Yellow Cab to travel to Epstein's residence. would
call from New York to schedule the massage appointments for
Epstein. Massage appointments were usually scheduled for the evening.
removed her bra during every massage session after her second
visit. Near the end of the massage sessions Epstein would ask to
undress. Epstein would ask, "Are you going to get comfortable?" At a
later occasion he stated, "Why are you going to keep your panties on?" He
offered her an additional $100.00 for her to remove her panties.
was paid $400.00 on two occasions.
Of all the massages provided to Epstein, only three were
"regular" massages. The others involved, at a minimum, Epstein
masturbating. Epstein requested to pinch his nipples while he
masturbated. He always climaxed, fully exposed. stated Epstein
has a hairy body and that his penis is unusual. Epstein's urethra is
located on the side of his penis instead of on the tip. never
touched Epstein's penis.
During a massage session which took place a couple of months
after first visit, Epstein introduced an unidentified female to
He stated, "I'd like you to meet my friend." and the
unknown female both got down on their knees on the floor and the
unidentified female began providing oral sex to as Epstein
simultaneously had sexual intercourse with the unidentified female. The
much English and was described as being
stated she would recognize the
unidentified female didn't speak
tan and having dark brown hair.
unidentified female.
Epstein has touched •
not penetrate vagina. He touched her vagina on two occasions
and both times backed away from him. On one occasion, Epstein
attempted to use a massager on vagina and she told him, "We
aren't doing all that." wanted the money but did not want Epstein
to touch her. took Xanax to ease her anxiety. also
stated that she smoked marijuana and used cocaine during the time period
she was providing massages to Epstein. After did not allow
Epstein to touch her vagina he began paying her $200.00 for the massage
sessions.
breasts and vagina. Epstein did
According to , if a girl felt uncomfortable and did not
want to comply with Epstein's requests he would ask them to bring other
girls. He asked , "Do you have any friends that might be
interested." He also asked if she had any younger friends.
Epstein paid $100.00 for each girl she brought.
, age 22, went to Epstein's residence one time. Epstein
to remove her clothing. She was uncomfortable with the
III was paid $200.00.
tried to get her
situation and only stayed for half an hour.
Epstein did not express any further interest in
received gifts from Epstein to include Victoria's Secret
bras and underwear, massage oils and a book titled "Massage for Dummies."
The items were sent to by Epstein via FedEx when she lived at
Suwanee Drive, West Palm Beach, Florida. Epstein also gave two
tickets to a concert featuring the band Incubus at the Sound Advice
Amphitheater. called to inform her that Epstein left the
concert tickets for her. Two older ladies brought the tickets to
at the amphitheater. voluntarily provided the "Massage for
Dummies" book she had received from Jeffrey Epstein to the interviewing
agents. A copy of the executed FD-597 Receipt for Property was provided to
and the original FD-597 was placed in a 1A envelope of case file.
The item provided was entered into evidence.
Epstein offered to take to Paris, France. He told her
he had to go to Paris for business and asked her if she wanted to come with
him. She declined the offer.
stole $200.00 from Epstein one day to "get back at him"
for making her friend, , feel uncomfortable. was
uncomfortable because she was left alone with Epstein during a massage
was paid $300.00
and left with $500.00 including the extra $200.00 she had taken.
did not know the extent of interaction with Epstein.
and friends but their relationship ended when
had an boyfriend
Last Name Unknown(
has a son.
session after Epstein requested to leave.
to Epstein.
were best
affair with
recruited
stated
o provide massages
went to
Epstein's residence once with did not know the extent
of interaction with Epstein but believed more may have happened
between and Epstein. mother worked in the adult
industry.
On one occasion, when was approximately 16 years old,
called and told her Epstein wanted to take photographs
of her. took a series of nude photographs of at Epstein's
Palm Beach residence. posed by the pool, by the intracoastal
waterway, in the living room, in the upstairs bathroom and in the balcony
area. used a digital camera to take the photographs. was
paid $500.00 for posing but never received any of the photographs.
also indicated to that Epstein takes pictures of the girls.
Although never observed any hidden cameras at Epstein's
residence, she felt like there were hidden cameras there.
that Epstein had many laptop computers.
stopped going to Epstein's residence because she had
other things to do that were more important to her. She stated she always
felt dirty when she left Epstein's residence. She felt that she was taken
advantage of. Epstein told he would never tell on her.
heard rumors that there were people watching Epstein's
residence from a house across the street.
At age 16, became pregnant and subsequently traveled to
Georgia in June 2003. Her son was born on March 12, 2004. The baby's
father is
, a friend of , brought a girl named III
III to provide a massage to Epstein. never met
stated
address is
Possible former house:
provided the following telephone numbers: Mother's cell,
cell,
aunt),
email
mentioned that during one of her visits to Epstein's
residence she spoke to over the telephone.
EFTA00007087 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                     Matthew I. Menchel [government] former prosecutor who dined with Epstein [law] 
                                    Landon Thomas Jr [journalist] New York Times financial reporter 
    Jay Lefkowitz [lawyer] Kirkland & Ellis partner, Epstein criminal defense attorney on 2008 case 
                     Ken Starr [lawyer] head of the Monica Lewinsky investigation into Bill Clinton 
                                                   Lilly Sanchez [lawyer] criminal defense attorney 
                                                 Martin Weinberg [lawyer] criminal defense attorney 
 Stephanie Thacker [lawyer] West Virginia attorney who defended Epstein, now a federal judge [wboy] 
                         Robert Josefsberg [victim lawyer] represented Australian victim (Giuffre?) 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00235326 (Jmail)
 [legal] long and chummy conversation between Epstein defense attorneys and Florida prosecutors, see quote: "spending some quality time with Title 18 
looking for misdemeanors"
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Henry Jarecki [lawyer] owner of neighboring island, psychiatrist, precious metals trader, film producer [hollywood/wiki] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00089546 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein last will and testament codicil naming Henry Jarecki, James Cayne, Paul Hoffman as executors
(date: 2007-09-20)
1, JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, of Little St. James Island, United States Virgin
Islands, declare this to be my last will and testament.
FIRST
I hereby revoke all my prior wills and codicils.
SECOND
I give all my property to the Trustees of The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2001 Trust
One created pursuant to an agreement dated November 8, 2001, by JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, as Grantor, and JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN and JEFFREY A. SCHANTZ, as
Trustees, to be added to the principal thereof and disposed of as provided thereunder.
THIRD

(a) I appoint JEFFREY A. SCHANTZ and PAUL HOFFMAN as
Executors of this will.
(b) I authorize JEFFREY A. SCHANTZ to designate one or more
additional or successor Executors. Designations shall be in writing and may be revoked
in writing by the maker thereof at any time prior to the qualification of the person so
designated. I authorize JEFFREY A. SCHANTZ to remove any Executor acting
hereunder by a written and acknowledged instrument.

(c) Any reference in this will to my Executors shall include additional
and successor Executors.
(d) No one acting hereunder as Executor shall be required to (i)
furnish any bond. undertaking or other security in any jurisdiction, (ii) file periodic
reports in or to any court or (iii) give notice of appointment as Trustee to any court. Each
Trustee acting hereunder is specifically relieved from any and all of the duties which
(00172266-1) GJ_000 1 03
would otherwise be placed upon him by Chapter 59 of Title 15 of the Virgin Islands
Code.

(e) Each Executor acting hereunder shall be entitled to receive the sum
of One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100,000) as compensation for such services.
FOURTH
Unless the context otherwise requires, the use in this will of the masculine
and feminine shall be interchangeable, and the use of the singular and plural shall be
interchangeable.
FIFTH
In extension and not in limitation of the powers and authority which my
Executors would otherwise have pursuant to law or pursuant to the other provisions of
this will, I direct that they have the following discretionary powers:

(a) To retain for as long a period of time as they may consider
advisable or proper any property of any kind which may at any time be in their hands.

(b) To sell at public or private sale or to exchange any property which
I may own at the time of my death or which may at any time be in their hands, without
application to court, on any terms they may consider advisable or proper, including terms
involving an extension of credit for any period of time and with or without security.

(c) To invest in or otherwise acquire any property, real or personal, of
any kind, without limitation, without being bound by any provision of law restricting
investments by executors, including but not limited to common and preferred stocks,
secured and unsecured obligations, mutual and common funds, other securities,
mortgages, and interests and options in any of the foregoing.
(00172266-Ij 2 G1_000104

(d) To acquire and retain property without regard to any principles of
diversification.
(e) To permit funds to remain uninvested, and to retain for an
unlimited period of time and to acquire and retain property which is not productive of
income.
(0 To acquire, exercise, sell or abandon conversion, subscription and
other rights and options, and to grant options for any period of time.

(g) To hold securities in the names of nominees or in such form as to
pass by delivery.
(h) To pay any gift or bequest in whole or in part at any time after my
death, either before or after the expiration of any period authorized or provided by law for
the payment of same and without deducting any discount or interest from a gift or
bequest paid prior to such time or paying interest on a gift or bequest paid after such time.

(i) To employ attorneys, accountants, investment advisers, security
analysts, brokers. agents, clerks, bookkeepers, stenographers and assistants, and to pay on
a regular basis the fair and reasonable value of their services, and in connection with this
power an Executor who is an attorney, an accountant or a broker or any firm of attorneys,
accountants or brokers of which an Executor is a partner or employee may be retained on
behalf of my estate and compensated for services rendered.

(j) To borrow money for any purpose, including, but not limited to,
the payment of taxes, and to pledge or mortgage property as security for money
borrowed.
100172266-li 3 G.1 000105

(k) To lend money or other property to any person, corporation,
partnership, trust or other entity, including a beneficiary hereunder even if such
beneficiary is an Executor, this power to include the power to lend, without interest,
income to or for the benefit of principal and principal to or for the benefit of income.

(I) To pay any gift or bequest and to distribute income or principal in
cash or in kind or partly in each. Such payments and distributions may be made to any
legatee or beneficiary with property that is like or different from property used to pay any
other gift or bequest or make any other distribution to any other legatee or beneficiary.
The value of any property distributed in kind shall not be reduced to reflect any expenses
or taxes that may be incurred by the recipient in or as a result of a disposition of such
property. The decision of my Executors with respect to the property selected to pay any
gift or bequest or make any distribution shall be conclusive and no recipient shall have
the right to object thereto.

(m) To determine, in case of reasonable doubt on their part, whether
any property coming into their hands constitutes income or principal, and whether any
payment or expenditure made by them shall be charged to income or to principal.

(n) To operate, repair, alter and improve any real property which they
may hold or in which they may hold an interest or participation; to erect or demolish
buildings thereon; to enter into leases for such real property or any part thereof or any
interest or participation therein for any period of time; to mortgage such real property or
any part thereof or any interest or participation therein for any period of time; to grant
options with respect to such real property, mortgages and leases or any interest or
participation therein for any period of time; to perform, modify, waive provisions of,
100172266-II 4 G.1_000106
extend, renew, terminate or otherwise act in respect of any such leases, mortgages or
options; to cause such real property or any interest or participation therein or any part
thereof and themselves to be insured against any and all risks; to retain an agent or agents
for any of the foregoing purposes; to set up a reserve or reserves for depreciation and/or
obsolescence, and to do or omit to do anything of any kind or nature with respect to any
such real property or any part thereof or any interest or participation therein or any lease
or mortgage thereon or option with respect thereto and the management thereof which
they may in their discretion consider advisable, whether or not such act or omission is
hereinabove specifically mentioned, without being bound by restrictions which might
otherwise be applicable and without court approval.

(o) To retain any interest in, to invest in and to become a member of,
any real estate partnership or joint venture, to comply with all the terms and provisions of
every real estate partnership and joint venture relating to any investment at any time held
by them, to succeed me as a member of any such partnership or joint venture, and to vote,
execute consents, exercise all rights and take such other action with respect to any real
estate partnership or joint venture as they, in their discretion, deem advisable.

(p) To retain any interest in oil, gas or mineral leases; to contract to
make and make, execute and deliver oil, gas or mineral leases, on such terms and with
such reservations of royalties or interests as they may deem proper; to amend ratify and
confirm any and all oil, gas or mineral leases made by me or by them; to sell and convey
any interest in oil, gas or other minerals; and to execute division orders relating to any
such interest and to the oil, gas or other minerals produced therefrom.
[00172266-II 5 GJ 000107

(q) To become or continue to be an officer, director or employee of
any corporation, stock of which may be owned by my estate and as such officer, director
or employee to receive a salary, bonus or other compensation in reasonable amount for
services rendered to said corporation.

(r) To determine whether to claim any deduction available to me or
my estate on estate tax or on income tax returns in such manner as they may deem
advisable and without making any adjustment between income and principal or among
beneficiaries on account of any such determination.

(s) If more than one Executor is acting, to delegate to any one of my
Executors any nondiscretionary power, including but not limited to the power, singly or
with others, to sign checks, withdrawal slips, instructions for the receipt or delivery of
securities or other property, and instructions for the payment or receipt of money, and the
power. singly or with others, to have access to any safe deposit box or other place where
property of my estate is deposited.

(t) To transfer any property which they may at any time hold to any
jurisdiction which they may deem advisable.

(u) My Executors shall continue to have all the powers herein vested
in them until the final distribution of all property in their hands.
SIXTH
If any beneficiary under The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2001 Trust One ("the
trust") shall in any way directly or indirectly (a) contest or object to the probate of my
will or to the validity of any disposition or provision of my will or of the trust or (b)
institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or indirectly instrumental in the
institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest, objection or claim for the
(00172266-I) 6 GJ 000108
purpose of setting aside or invalidating my will or the trust or any disposition therein or
provision thereof, then I direct that (a) any and all provisions in the trust for such
beneficiary and his issue in any degree shall be null and void and (b) my estate, whether
passing under my will or the trust or pursuant to the laws of intestacy, shall be disposed
of as if such beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all failed to survive me.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto subscribed my name and
affixed my seal to this my Last Will and Testament, consisting of  9  typewritten
pages, on all of which I signed my name for greater security and identification, at
M. </it-Crn-Pre-d
n.
Islands on the  i /  day of December, 2001.
, U.S. Virgin
SIGNED, SEALED, PUBLISHED and DECLARED by JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, as and
for his Last Will and Testament in our presence; and we thereupon, at his request and in
his presence. and in the presence of each other, have hereunto subscribed our names as
attesting witnesse d our respective places of residence on the day of its execution.
residing at
9t-a-xvx.e- 13- 4-xwit-  residing at
residing at
(00172266-I) 7 GJ_000 1 09
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me by the said JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN,
Testator, and  etc, le g. is fa ', i t,  3-#4 4 "'lel?' di -441nel  and
/94, An," 4/y „  ;Witnesses, the  t  day of December, 2001.
Before me, the undersigned authority, on this day personally appeared JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, Testator, and  etc lie g. 177,4  re !it, 1 0 if re el n a -,  and
dot esh ne li r y ale  , respectively, whose names are subscribed to the
foregoing instrument in their respective capacities, and all of said persons being by me
duly sworn, the said Testator declared to me and to the said witnesses, in my presence,
that the said instrument is his LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT and that he has willingly
made and executed it as his free act and deed for the purposes therein expressed; and that
the said witnesses, each on his oath, stated to me in the presence and hearing of said
Testator that the said Testator had declared to them that the said instrument is his LAST
WILL AND TESTAMENT, and that he executed the same as such and wanted each of
them to sign it as a witness; and upon their oaths, each witness further stated that they did
sign the same as witnesses in the presence of the said Testator and at his request; and that
said Testator was at the time eighteen years of age or over and of sound mind; and that
each of said witnesses was then at least eighteen years of age.
SUBSCRIBED AND AND SWORN TO before me by the said JEFFREY E. EVSTEIN,
Testator, and Lt ec, le A, de  ,  ofe nn  and
Oa, 11 el, Lily de n  , witnesses, the  //al  day of December, 2001.
9 7 2s ,raZra-j
Notary Public }
Barbara Mignon Weatherly Notary Commission No. LNP-027-00
Commission Expires November 21, 2004
(00172266.1) 8 G1_000110
FIRST CODICIL
to
LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT
of
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
CO 000111
I, JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, of Little St. James Island, United
States Virgin Islands, having made my last will and testament dated
December 11, 2001, declare this to be a first codicil thereto.
FIRST
I hereby delete Article THIRD of my will and substitute in its
place the following new Article THIRD:
"(a) I appoint HENRY JARECKI and JAMES CAYNE as
Executors of this will. If either HENRY JARECKI or JAMES CAYNE fails
to qualify or ceases for any reason to act as Executor, I hereby designate
PAUL HOFFMAN as successor Executor to act in his place.

(b) Any reference in this will to my Executors shall include
successor Executors.
(c) No one acting as Executor shall be required to (i) furnish
any bond, undertaking or other security in any jurisdiction, (ii) file periodic
reports in or to any court or (iii) give notice of appointment as Trustee to any
court. Each Trustee acting hereunder is specifically relieved from any and
all of the duties which would otherwise be placed upon him by Chapter 59
of Title 15 of the Virgin Islands Code.

(d) Each Executor acting hereunder shall be entitled to
receive the sum of One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100,000) as
compensation for such services."
316766.1
GJ_000112
SECOND
In all other respects I ratify and republish my said last will and
testament.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto subscribed my
name and affixed my seal to this my first codicil to my Last Will and
Testament, consisting of t —typewritten pages, on all of which I signed
my name for greater security and identification, at
U.S. Virgin Islands on the 2-1 day of , 2003.
(L.S.)
JEF
SIGNED, SEALED, PUBLISHED and DECLARED by JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, as and for a first codicil to his Last Will and Testament in our
presence; and we thereupon, at his request and in his presence, and in the
presence of each other, have hereunto subscribed our names as attesting
witnesses and our respective places of residence on the day of its execution.
MALI Act
WieladL-
TegnA r /3 IR O/2.N1
316766.1 2
G.1_000113
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me by the said JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, Testator, and,DANNt WALLPCZ  ,
and 7TheimiNg 4. Row  , witnesses, the  .2Y__ day of
2003.
Before me, the undersigned authority, on this day personally appeared
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, Testator, and atlel-Ne. DJALLAC.E
-Asey-maths- • Rao/  and  -Itonne_ laienr.an
respectively, whose names are subscribed to the foregoing instrument in
their respective capacities, and all of said persons being by me duly sworn,
the said Testator declared to me and to the said witnesses, in my presence,
that the said instrument is a first codicil to his LAST WILL AND
TESTAMENT and that he has willingly made and executed it as his free act
and deed for the purposes therein expressed; and that the said witnesses,
each on his oath, stated to me in the presence and hearing of said Testator
that the said Testator had declared to them that the said instrument is a first
codicil to his LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT, and that he executed the
same as such and wanted each of them to sign it as a witness; and upon their
oaths, each witness further stated that they did sign the same as witnesses in
the presence of the said Testator and at his request; and that said Testator
was at the time eighteen years of age or over and of sound mind; and that
each of said witnesses was then at least eighteen years of age.
316766.1 3
GJ_000114
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me by the said JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, Testator, and  194/Ane tia Hal,  ,  Tern') 4 in .e R. 466744,
and Tenn e ere,,,, 44,  witnesses, the ,27deday of  Q-uo.te  , 2003.
Barbara Mignon Weatherly
Notary Commission No. LNP-027-00 Commission Expires November21,2004
316766.1 4
G.1_000115
I, JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, of Little St. James Island, United
States Virgin Islands, having made my last will and testament dated
December 11, 2001 and a first codicil thereto dated June 27, 2003, declare
this to be a second codicil thereto.
FIRST
I hereby delete paragraph (a) of Article THIRD of my will and
substitute in its place the following new paragraph (a) of Article THIRD:
"I appoint HENRY JARECKI, JAMES CAYNE and
LAWRENCE NEWMAN as Executors of this will. If HENRY JARECKI,
JAMES CAYNE or LAWRENCE NEWMAN fails to qualify or ceases for
any reason to act as Executor, I hereby designate PAUL HOFFMAN as
successor Executor to act in his place."
SECOND
In all other respects I ratify and republish my said last will and
testament and the first codicil thereto.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto subscribed my
name to this my second codicil to my Last Will and Testament on ther'd
of he ce ,, 4,
358376.1
, 2004.
G.1_000116
SIGNED, SEALED, PUBLISHED and DECLARED by JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, as and for a second codicil to his Last Will and Testament in our
presence; and we thereupon, at his request and in his presence, and in the
presence of each other, have hereunto subscribed our names as attesting
witnesses and our respective places of residence on the day of its execution.
Atme........1.<
ple .L.ea-e4-4",. :et )1.C4c.c75s0....,.
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me by the said JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, Testator, and  onmeN /ND A taAeatce Nfr✓N4*
, witnesses, the 5' day of  Decent,-  ,
2004.
358376.1
LAUREN J. KWINTNER Notary Public, State of New York No. 02KW6016686 Qualified in New York County Commission Expires 
November 30, 20
GJ 000117
Before me, the undersigned authority, on this day personally appeared
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, Testator, and  li4mew K. /4'67X 4•'  „ el
.041 tettliC CV 4.1 /-74 /V  and
respectively, whose names are subscribed to the foregoing instrument in
their respective capacities, and all of said persons being by me duly sworn,
the said Testator declared to me and to the said witnesses, in my presence,
that the said instrument is a second codicil to his Last Will and Testament
and that he has willingly made and executed it as his free act and deed for
the purposes therein expressed; and that the said witnesses, each on his oath,
stated to me in the presence and hearing of said Testator that the said
Testator had declared to them that the said instrument is a second codicil to
his Last Will and Testament, and that he executed the same as such and
wanted each of them to sign it as a witness; and upon their oaths, each
witness further stated that they did sign the same as witnesses in the
presence of the said Testator and at his request; and that said Testator was at
the time eighteen years of age or over and of sound mind; and that each of
said witnesses was then at least eighteen years of age.
Testator
h GA
)ce . e wt. t •-•
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me by the said JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, Testator, and  o444c# H. /MD We i f.,,4 4.4 ea,eO.1C4-  APeo.mm 4,
and , wit e ..5'cl  day d e
2004.
358176.1
Notary P
LAUREN J. KWINTNER
Notary Public, State of New York
No. 02KW6016686
Qualified in New York County„ , o
Commission Expires November 30-ttvusu
I, JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, of Little St. James Island, United
States Virgin Islands, having made my last will and testament dated
December 11, 2001, a first codicil thereto dated June 27, 2003, and a second
codicil thereto dated December 3, 2004, declare this to be a third codicil
thereto.
FIRST
I hereby delete paragraph (a) of Article THIRD of my will and
substitute in its place the following new paragraph (a) of Article THIRD:
"I appoint HENRY JARECKI, JAMES CAYNE and.
LAWRENCE NEWMAN as Executors of this will. If HENRY JARECKI,
JAMES CAYNE or LAWRENCE NEWMAN fails to qualify or ceases for
any reason to act as Executor, I hereby designate DARREN K. INDYKE as
successor Executor to act in his place."
SECOND
I hereby delete paragraph (d) of Article THIRD of my will and
substitute in its place the following new paragraph (d) of Article THIRD:
"(d) Each Executor acting hereunder shall be entitled to receive
the sum of Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) as
compensation for such services."
360075.)
G.1_000119
11-111CD
In all other respects I ratify and republish my said last will and
testament and the first codicil and second codicils thereto.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto subscribed my
name to this my third codicil to my Last Will and Testament on the /‘ e4day
of jec , 2004.
SIGNED, SEALED, PUBLISHED and DECLARED by JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, as and for a third codicil to his Last Will and Testament in our
presence; and we thereupon, at his request and in his presence, and in the
presence of each other, have hereunto subscribed our names as attesting
witnesses and our respective places of residence on the day of its execution.
\it
0.7:1  "tt '2C- 4-40 —An er-r.._
360075.1
2
GJ_000 1 20
e ore me, e un ersigne , on
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, Testator,  MA'ReA) a. himyte  and
4,04Gyce-- wekm-mv  , respectively, whose names are subscribed to
the foregoing instrument in their respective capacities, and all of said
persons being by me duly sworn, the said Testator declared to me and to the
said witnesses, in my presence, that the said instrument is a third codicil to
his Last Will and Testament and that he has willingly made and executed it
as his free act and deed for the purposes therein expressed; and that the said
witnesses, each on his oath, stated to me in the presence and hearing of said
Testator that the said Testator had declared to them that the said instrument
is a third codicil to his Last Will and Testament, and that he executed the
same as such and wanted each of them to sign it as a witness; and upon their
oaths, each witness further stated that they did sign the same as witnesses in
the presence of the said Testator and at his request; and that said Testator
was at the time eighteen years of age or over and of sound mind; and that
each of said witnesses was then at least eighteen years of age.
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me by the said JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, Testator, and  hen  .1,-,dxice  and LGwve cc ketwoon,
witnesses, the  Ito  day of 104
Notary P
360075.1
LAU EN J. KWI','NER Notary ublic, State of New York o.
Yo Yo 66 86 Qualified in 2New rk CountyCommission Expires November 30, 20 (
GJ_000121
Third Codicil to
••••••••
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
LAWRENCE NEWMAN, ESQ.
1633 BROADWAY • 46''' FLOOR
NEW YORK. NY 1O019-67O8
TELEPHONE

╭──── Page 20, Image 1 ─────╮
│ Third Codicil to          │
│                           │
│ ast Will                  │
│                           │
│ (ant )—                   │
│                           │
│ Gestament                 │
│                           │
│ (Ca Ey                    │
│                           │
│ JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN        │
│                           │
│ Lawrence Newman, Esq.     │
│ 1633 BROADWAY + 46™ FLOOR │
│ NEW YORK, NY 10019-6708   │
│                           │
│ |                         │
│                           │
│ GI_000122                 │
╰───────────────────────────╯

I, JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, of Little St. James Island, United
States Virgin Islands, having made my last will and testament dated
December I I, 2001, a first codicil thereto dated June 27, 2003, a second
codicil thereto dated December 3, 2004, a third codicil thereto dated
December 16, 2004, and a fourth codicil thereto dated September 5, 2007,
declare this to be a fifth codicil thereto.
FIRST
I hereby delete paragraphs (b) (c) and (d) of Article THIRD of
my will and substitute in its place the following new paragraphs (b) (c) and

(d) of Article THIRD:
"(b) Any reference in this will to my Executors shall include
additional and successor Executors.

(c) No one acting hereunder as Executor shall be required to
(i) furnish any bond, undertaking or other security in any jurisdiction, (ii)
file periodic reports in or to any court or (iii) give notice of appointment as
Trustee to any court. Each Trustee acting hereunder is specifically relieved
from any and all of the duties which would otherwise be placed upon him by
Chapter 59 of Title 15 of the Virgin Islands Code.
509420.1
GJ_000 1 23

(d) Each Executor acting hereunder shall be entitled to
receive the sum of Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000) as
compensation for such services."
SECOND
In all other respects I ratify and republish my said last will and
testament and the first codicil, second, third and fourth codicils thereto.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have hereunto subscribed my
name to this my fifth codicil to my Last Will and Testament on then/Clay of £c 7'1
, 2007.
JE IN
(L.S.)
SIGNED, SEALED, PUBLISHED and DECLARED by JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, as and for a fifth codicil to his Last Will and Testament in our
presence; and we thereupon, at his request and in his presence, and in the
presence of each other, have hereunto subscribed our names as attesting
witnesses and our r spective places of residence on the day of its execution. /
v2 :2-4.+-re C-C kaa -3-in sr..
509420.1 2
GJ_000124
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me by the said JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, Testator, and  DA gem K. bvo yfre  and  L £o C nit e weiehr,44;
witnesses, the  .2c tc day of  .r.g/, /coact,  , 2007.
509420.1 3
ota
UREN J. KWINTNER
N ary Public, State of New York

No. 02KW6016686
Qualified in New York County ,,— ommission Expires November 30, 20
GJ 000125
Sreare die SoAK
enewry ap New. ypszle
Before me, the undersigned authority, on this day personally appeared
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, Testator,  DAdse tit/ K. /Noyiee  and
4 4 wk. EA/Ce ,v4 -• &AMA/ , respectively, whose names are subscribed to
the foregoing instrument in their respective capacities, and all of said
persons being by me duly sworn, the said Testator declared to me and to the
said witnesses, in my presence, that the said instrument is a fourth codicil to
his Last Will and Testament and that he has willingly made and executed it
as his free act and deed for the purposes therein expressed; and that the said
witnesses, each on his oath, stated to me in the presence and hearing of said
Testator that the said Testator had declared to them that the said instrument
is a fourth codicil to his Last Will and Testament, and that he executed the
same as such and wanted each of them to sign it as a witness; and upon their
oaths, each witness further stated that they did sign the same as witnesses in
the presence of the said Testator and at his request; and that said Testator
was at the time eighteen years of age or over and of sound mind; and that
each of said witnesses was then at least eighteen years of age.
eramaraii•c-r2
SUBSCRIBED AND SWORN TO before me by the said JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, Testator, and  44,4efew Minya  and  LA 4 A is A/c6- Alf 40H0444
witnesses, the .to it  day of J ;Cider- 07.
509020.1
Notary
UREN J. KWINTNER
ry Public, State of New York
No. 02KW6016686
Qualified in New York County
Commission Expires November 30, 20 IQ
GJ 000126
EFTA00016349 (Jmail)
 [government] grand jury proceedings charge list
(approximate date: 2008-02-01)
JANE DOE #1 a
COUNT/O.A. DATE DEFENDANT(S) CHARGE
O.A. 2 3/12/04 EPSTEIN Conspiracy to entice a minor to
engage in prostitution
O.A. 3 3/12/04 EPSTEIN Conspiracy to entice a minor to
engage in prostitution
O.A. 95 2/6/05 EPSTEIN Conspiracy to entice a minor to
engage in prostitution
O.A. 96 2/6/05 EPSTEIN Conspiracy to entice a minor to
engage in prostitution
O.A. 97 2/6/05 EPSTEIN Conspiracy to entice a minor to
engage in prostitution
O.A. 117 3/30/05 Conspiracy to entice a minor to
engage in prostitution
O.A. 120 3/31/05 Conspiracy to entice a minor to
engage in prostitution
O.A. 122 3/31/05 EPSTEIN Conspiracy to entice a minor to
engage in prostitution
O.A. 123 4/1/05 EPSTEIN Conspiracy to entice a minor to
engage in prostitution
Ct 5 3/7/04 -
3/11/04
EPSTEIN Enticement of a minor to engage in
prostitution
CONFIDENTIAL GRAND JURY MATERIAL PAGE 1 OF 1 JANE DOE # 1
EFTA00002196 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2008-05-01)
Schedule
0  HP OfficeJet Pro 8720
Serial Number: CN68F060C1
40 IP Address: 192.168.119.6
EC-8E-B5-01 -8F-28
Lai  DIRECT-a -HP 011Icelet Pro 8720
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                            Ben Goertzel [academia] AI researcher, Humanity+ chairman, iCog Labs, funded by Epstein 
                                                                           Brian Greene [academia] physicist at Columbia University 
                                                                             David Grosof [academia] MIT Sloan School of Management 
                                                Elkhonon Goldberg [academia] Neuropsychologist, arranged Moscow University meetings 
                                                   Lawrence Krauss [academia] theoretical physicist with #MeToo problems [atlantic] 
                                                                                                    Lee Smolin [academia] physicist 
                                                                               Mark Tramo [academia] professor of neurology at UCLA 
                                                Roger Schank [academia] AI pioneer, Teachers College, Columbia University, deceased 
                                                                                      Barry Josephson [arts] American film producer 
                                                                                   Daniel M. Rosenberg [arts] film producer [jpost] 
                                                                             Barry W. Zelin [business] Axiom Capital [epsteingraph] 
                                                                                    Ed Razek [business] Victoria's Secret executive 
 Nicole Junkermann [business] German countess / ex-model, NJF Capital/JunkermannGroup, investor in Revolut, gambling, China [yahoo] 
                                                               Steve Griffis aka Steve from downstairs [employee] building employee 
                                                                                               Ben Bram [finance] Watermill Trading 
                 Andrew Farkas [friend] heir to Alexander's department store fortune, recently claimed he barely knew Epstein [nyt] 
     Jonathan Farkas [friend] son of Andrew Farkas, heir to department store fortune, spouse of Trump's ambassador to Malta [yahoo] 
                                        Terry Kafka [friend] CEO of Impact Outdoor (highway billboards), lifelong friend of Epstein 
                                                     Steven Victor MD [medical] dermatologist who treated Epstein's girls [nyt/bbg] 
                                                                                Faith Kates [modeling] Next Models co-founder [wwd] 
                                                                                               Naomi Campbell [modeling] supermodel 
                                                                                 Peggy Siegal [publicist] socialite, movie promoter 
                                                               Anthony Barrett [real estate] Ossa Properties (Mark Epstein company) 
                                                                               Daniel Rosenberg [real estate] real estate developer 
                                                     David Mitchell [real estate] New York real estate developer, Mitchell Holdings 
                                                                                       Kira Titenva [real estate] real estate agent 
                                                                                   Alysia Riabenkova [russian girl] Russian painter 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00306074 (Jmail)
 [misc] approved mail list during Epstein's 2009 incarceration in Palm Beach
(approximate date: 2008-06-01)
List of People Who Need JE's Address!

Jeffrey Epstein
Jacket # 0338617, Dorm T Special
PO BOX 24716, West Palm Beach, Florida, 33416

You can only send letters/postcards via USPS. You MUST write his Jacket # on the envelope and letter, below
his name or else he will not receive it!! JACKET #: 0338617 Dorm T Special. No Fed Ex or the like. No
Packages. Nothing on glossy paper, if you want to send a picture it must be on regular paper and there must
be writing on the back of the picture (suggestion: write the letter on the back of the picture) Jeffrey can
receive books but the titles must first be cleared. PLEASE DO NOT SEND ANY BOOKS UNTIL THE TITLE
AND AUTHER HAS BEEN APPROVED! Please email me the title and author of a book you think Jeffrey would
enjoy, I will have it cleared and get back to you. My email address is ( ) If your book title
Is cleared, you must adhere to the following instructions: Books can only be rec'd if sent from Amazon,
Barnes and Noble, Borders or the like. They must be sent direct to Jeffrey from the dealer and they can only
be soft cover-NO HARD COVER BOOKS! You cannot send a book personally. Be sure to include Jeffrey's
jacket # on the packing slip! He Is only allowed 5 books at a time. On the other hand, he can receive mail, so if
you would like to send him "papers" (ie: research papers, chapters of a book, printed article on copy paper,
etc) that would be great

I also set up an email address for him (jeevacation@gmail.com)

Ben Goertzel- done
Peggy Siegel- done
Mark Tramo- done
Lee Smolin- done
Jonathan Farkas- done
Faith Kates- done
<REDACTED> - done

Dr. Goldberg-done
<REDACTED>
Lawrence Krauss- done
David Grosof- done
Henry Rosovslcy- done
Philip Diaz- done
<REDACTED>
David Mitchell- done
Terry Kafka - done
Barbro Ehnbom-done
Ira Zicherman- done
<REDACTED>
<REDACTED>
David Stearn- done
Ghislaine- done
Nili- done
Naomi Campbell- done
Martin Nowak- done
Ed Razek- done
Nicole Junkermann- done
Barry Josephson- done
Roger Schank- done

Dr. Victor- done
<REDACTED>
Alysia- done
Patricia Neville- done
Daniel Rosenberg- done
<REDACTED>
Steve (from downstairs). done
Real Estate Kira- done
<REDACTED>
Ben Bram- done
Brian Greene- done
Barry Zelin- done
Sam Belzberg- done
<REDACTED>
Anthony Barrett- done
<REDACTED>
<REDACTED>
Kira Titenva (Real Estate Kira)- done
<REDACTED>
<REDACTED>
<REDACTED>
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                         Marvin Minsky [academia] mathematician, early AI researcher 
                              Stephen Hanson [friend] restaurauteur, estate executor 
           Richard Kahn [lawyer] Epstein's accountant and estate executor [bbc/wiki] 
                         Dasha Grupman [russian girl] recruiter of girls for Epstein 
 Nathan Myhrvold [tech] former CTO of Microsoft, co-founder of Intellectual Ventures 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00315076 (Jmail)
 [government] visitor list during Epstein's 2009 incarceration in Palm Beach
(approximate date: 2008-06-01)
Visitor List

Lesley Groff
Rich Kahn
Mark Tramo
Warren Eisenstein
Lawrence Krauss
Lee Smolin
Jonathon Farkas (wants to come in October)
<REDACTED>
David Grosof (he could come anytime btwn the 14th-22nd of July)
Henry Rosovsky
Larry Summers
Marvin Minsky
Steve Griffis (the guy who works in our building downstairs)
Steve Hanson
Harry Beller
Dasha Grupman
Faith Kates
Nathan Myhrvold
Barry Zelin
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                     Financial Trust Company [epstein] Epstein financial trust 
                                             New York Strategy Group [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                Gavin Andresen [crypto] core bitcoin developer 
                                       Perry Lang [employee] Epstein's personal chef 1998-2002 
        Adriana Ross aka Adriana Mucinska [girls] assistant, named co-conspirator [dailybeast] 
                 Anthony Figueroa [girls] boyfriend of a victim, paid $200 per girl to recruit 
      Cecilia Steen [girls] Epstein assistant, moved to Dubai to work for money launderers (?) 
                                  Saige Gonzalez [girls] victim, gave evidence against Epstein 
                                                             SDFL [government] law enforcement 
                 MC2 Model Management [modeling] Jean Luc Brunel and Epstein's modeling agency 
                               Jack Dorsey [tech] co-founder of Twitter and Block (FKA Square) 
                              Brad Edwards [victim lawyer] Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler attorney 
                Jack Scarola [victim lawyer] Searcy Denney Scarola Barnhart & Shipley attorney 
 Scott Rothstein [victim lawyer] Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler attorney, ran massive Ponzi scheme 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00225378 (Jmail)
 [government] SDFL NYC travel authorization
(date: 2008-06-20)
Memorandum
Subject
Memorandum seeking Travel Authorization
Operation Leap Year
Dote
June 20, 2008
TO
Rolando Garcia, Deputy Chief
Criminal Division
Karen Atkinson, Chic
Northern Division
From

A. Marie Villaf
Assistant U.S. A
I. INTRODUCTION
This memorandum seeks travel authorization to travel to New York from June 19 to June 20,
2008, in connection with Operation Leap Year.
II. THE PROPOSED TRAVEL AND ITS PURPOSE
As you know, we plan to present a final indictment to the grand jury in approximately two
weeks. Since our original planned indictment, we have learned about a series of victims in New
York and the ssible involvement of Epstein's two New York-based assistants, and
The inclusion of New York victims would be a great benefit to the indictment, and
we would like to interview some key people in New York in order to include that evidence in the
indictment.
Accordingly, I propose to travel to New York on the afternoon of Thursday, June 19 to
conduct interviews on Friday, June 20, 2008.' FBI Special Agents Nesbitt Kuyrkendall and Jason
Richards also will be traveling, although they may stay longer.
First, we would like to interview She has been identified by two victims
as someone who recruited numerous others to Epstein's New York residence. We know that Lacerda
was going to Epstein's home when she was 14, and it is possible that she was going there as early
as 13. This trip is contingent upon approval from the Justice Department of our immunity request
for Lacerda. Yesterday I spoke with someone at the Witness Immunity Unit who stated that we
'I may decide to stay in New York on Friday night in order to see a college friend. If I do,
I will pay for the hotel room on Friday night and any difference in the airfares.
EXHIBIT B-132
Case No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA P-008379
should have the approval by early next week.'
In addition, a witness here in the Palm Beach area came forward recently to inform the FBI
about a link between Epstein and the MC Modeling Agency. The witness stated that Epstein and
the head of MC2, Jean Luc Brunel, worked together to obtain fraudulent visas to bring potential
models to the United States. The witness stated that Epstein selected some of the underage girls to
come to the United States even though Brunel never intended to use them as models so that Epstein
could engage in sexual activity with them. Brunel's name appears on several of the message pads
recovered during the search of Epstein's home. Some of the messages describe young girls that he
would like Epstein to meet (including a I6-year-old who would "teach Russian" to Epstein). The
FBI previously tried to interview Brunel, but he refused to speak with them. The Palm Beach
witness has told the FBI that a former MC2 employee is willing to speak with the FBI about the
fraud.
Yesterday, the FBI in New York arrested two Bear Stearns employees for securities fraud
related to Bear Stearns hedge funds involved in the subprime loan crisis. Epstein has been reported
as one of the creators of those hedge funds in financial news sources. The agents here are contacting
the New York agents to determine if Epstein is a target/subject of the New York investigation and
also to find out whether the two employees are cooperating and would be willing to speak with us.
For the foregoing reasons, I recommend that the Office approve the costs of a hotel room and
a flight for my travel to New York.
'-Travel plans will not be made until the immunity is confirmed.
-2-
Case No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA P-008380
‘A0/10 (Ho 04/07)Suboxra Co Testify Before Grand Any
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
TO:
SUBPOENA TO TESTIFY
BEFORE GRAND JURY 01.1031MPB1-Tues. No. OLY-05/2
SUBPOENA FOR:
e PERSON I DOCUMENT(S) OR OBJECTS)
YOU ARE HEREBY COMMANDED to appear and terrify before the Grand Jury of the United States District
Court at the place, date, and lime specified below,
PLACE
United States District Court
701 Clematis Street
West Palm Beach. Florida 33401
COURTROOM Grand Jury Room
DATE AND TIME
71112008 10:30 am
YOU ARE ALSO COMMANDED to bring with you the following document(s) or object(s):*
ALL DOCUMENTS AND INFORMATION REFERENCED IN THE ATTACHMENT TO THIS SUBPOENA.
U Please see additional information on rei •
This subpoena shall remain in elf
behalf of the court.
This subpoena is issued on application
or the of A
• Ilea applicable. eat 'none"
In by the cowl or by an officer acting on
NAME ADDRESS AND PHONE NUMBER OF ASSISTANT U S ATTORNEY
AnnMarie C. Villaf aria , Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 South Australian Avenue, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401-6235
Tel (561) 820.8711, ext 3047
Case No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA P-008381
ATTACHMENT TO GRAND JURY SLBPOENA OLY-85/I
ADDRESSED TO
PLEASE BRINGTHE. FOLLOWING DOCUM ENTS, FILMS, AND INFORMATION WITH YOU
TO YOUR GRAND JURY APPEARANCE:

1. Any and all notes, letters, cards, ifts, a ments, hoto ra hs, or other items that u
"' received from Jeffrey Epstein,
Lesley Groff, Ghislaine Maxwell. and/or any other employee or associate o Je rey Epstein.

2. An and all hot a hs, whether printed or di ital, ofJeffrey Epstein,
. Cecilia Steen,  Ghislaine Maxwell, and/or any
other employee or associate o Jeffrey Epstein.

3. Any and all e-mails, instant messages, chats, text messages, voiccmails or tele hone
10111t received from Jeffrey Epstein.
. Lesley Groff, Ghislaine Maxwe a or any of r
employee or associate o Je rey Epstein.

4. A list of all telephone numbers (cellular and "land line"), c-mail addresses, screen
names, addresses, and any other contact information that you have for the following persons during
the period of January I, 2003 to the present:

a. yourself;
b. Jeffrey Epstein;
c.
d.
e.
f.
g.
h. Ghislaine Maxwell;
i. any person(s) who introduced you to Jeffrey Epstein and/or Ghislaine
Maxwell;
any person(s) whom you introduced to Jeffrey Epstein and/or Ghislaine
Maxwell;

k. any person(s) who communicated with you to arrange appointments to meet
with Jeffrey Epstein and/or Ghislaine Maxwell.

5. Any billing statements for telephone service (cellular and "land line") for any
telephone you used during the period of January I, 2003 to the present.
Case No. 08-80736-CV-MARRA P-008382
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Fernandez, Aida I. (USAFLS) <afernandez@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 9:23 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Grand Jury on 6/26 and 7/1
Ok - got it - thx
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 9:19 AM
To: Fernandez, Aida I. (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Grand Jury on 6/26 and 7/1
Hi Aida. Thank you for asking. We will be presenting the witness testimony after the indictment. (I would like
to do the indictment in the morning and the witness in the afternoon, if possible.)

A. Marie Villafaiia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Fernandez, Alda I. (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 9:18 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc: Ball, Shawn (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Grand Jury on 6/26 and 7/1
I assume you will be presenting your witness testimony first? Pls advise so that I know the order in which to
present them next week.
Pls advise.
Thx.
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 9:09 AM
To: Fernandez, Aida I. (USAFLS)
Cc: Ball, Shawn (USAFLS)
Subject: Grand Jury on 6/26 and 7/1 EXHIBIT B-133
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014979
Hi Aida — I think you already have this, but, if not:
Can you put me down for a half-hour on Thursday, 6/26, in the morning, for an indictmen-
And, on 7/1 can I have 2 hours in the morning for an indictment on Operation Leap Year. Witness will be
Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, FBI. It will be sealed.
Also on 7/1, I will need 2 hours for witness testimony on Operation Leap Year. Witness will be
Thank you!

A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014980
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 1. 11
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS); Kuyrkendall, E N. (MM) (FBI); Richards, Jason R. (MM)
(FBI)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Trip to New York, etc.

Ok. Marie, hoping to hear from DAG's office today giving the green light. Let's talk when that decision is
made.
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 9:15 AM
To: Kuyrkendall, E N. (FBI); Richards, Jason R. (FBI)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Subject: Trip to New York, etc.
We will not be interviewing in New York. Her attorney gave a copy of the grand jury subpoena to
Epstein's lawyers. They, in turn, promptly sent it on to Washington complaining, yet again, about me. So, I do
not want to do an interview with him present, and we will have to put her in the grand jury.
Given that, let's take the New York section out of the indictment so we can present the indictment Tuesday
morning. Then we can do interview in the afternoon with plans to supersede. It probably makes sense
to wait on the rest of the interviews until we hear whadMI has to say, so let's plan to do the New York trip
in a few weeks.
Bob — I will revise everything accordingly and send it down to you. We have another girl from Florida, so I
will replace our New York Jane Doe with her.
A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014981
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Brendan White <brendan@whiwhi.com>
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 10:38 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Ms. Villafana:
I understand that there has been a recent development with respect to Mr. Epstein in that he intends to plead guilty in
Florida state court on Monday pursuant to a deferred prosecution agreement with your office that has already been
executed. Since this would seem to obviate any need for Ms. Lacerda to testify, please let me know what is going on with
respect to this Tuesday. Do we still need to come down there and, if so, will she receive court-ordered
immunity? Thanks.
Brendan White
--- Original Message --
From: Vilfacana. Ahn Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Brendan White
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 2:09 PM
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
Please feel free to make your own travel arrangements, but if you would like Ms. Lacerda's travel costs to be
reimbursed, they must be made through the government's approved agency on the approved carriers.
Regarding the immunity, at this point, without a written proffer from you regarding the substance of her
anticipated testimony, I believe that the more prudent course will be to question Ms. Lacerda to determine the
limits of her Fifth Amendment exposure and, if necessary, to apply to the Court at that time. If you provide me
with a written proffer that summarizes her anticipated testimony and explains how she will be exposed to
criminal liability, then I can make the motion ahead of time. Your written statement would be treated as an
attorney statement made in the course of confidential plea discussions and related negotiations, and would be
governed by Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(0 and Fed. R. Evid. 410.

A. Marie Wolin
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 3340]
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White [mailto:brendan@whiwhl.com]
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 1:45 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc Ball, Shawn (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
We will be there, and I will make the travel arrangements. I am assuming that this will be done in connection with an
order of immunity. Please let me know if that is correct so I can advise Ms. Lacerda. Thanks.
Brendan White 08-80736-CV-MARRA
P-014991
EXHIBIT B-I34
— Original Message ---
From: Villafana. Arm Marie C. (USAFLS1
To: Brendan White
Cc: Ball Shawn (USARSI
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 11:27 AM
Subject: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:

Ms. Lacerda will need to appear before the grand jury on July 1m to give testimony. Please contact my
assistant, Shawn Ball, at 561 820-8711, ext. 3037, to make travel arrangements. I expect that Ms. Lacerda's
testimony will begin either in the late morning or early afternoon, but she should be available for the whole
day.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafaiia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014992
l's
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) <Avillafana@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 10:55 AM
To: Brendan White
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
If Mr. Epstein enters a guilty plea in accordance with that agreement on Monday, then the subpoena will be
withdrawn. At this point, I have not received confirmation that the change of plea is going to occur, nor have I
received information confirming that the plea will be in conformance with our agreement. As such, at this time,
1 still intend to present Ms. Lacerda's testimony to the grand jury on Tuesday. With respect to the immunity
question, I refer you to my e-mail of June 2314, which is shown below.
If the situation changes, I will contact you.
Thank you.
A. Marie Villafaiia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White [mailto:brendan@whiwhl.com]
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 10:38 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Ms. Villafana:
I understand that there has been a recent development with respect to Mr. Epstein in that he intends to plead guilty in
Florida state court on Monday pursuant to a deferred prosecution agreement with your office that has already been
executed. Since this would seem to obviate any need for Ms. Lacerda to testify, please let me know what is going on with
respect to this Tuesday. Do we still need to come down there and, if so, will she receive court-ordered
immunity? Thanks.
Brendan White
--- Original Message ---
From: Villafana. AM Marie C. (USAFLS).
To: Brendan White
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 2:09 PM
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
Please feel free to make your own travel arrangements, but if you would like Ms. Lacerda's travel costs to be
reimbursed, they must be made through the government's approved agency on the approved carriers.
08-80736-CV-MARRA
P-014993
Regarding the immunity, at this point, without a written proffer from you regarding the substance of her
anticipated testimony, I believe that the more prudent course will be to question Ms. Lacerda to determine the
limits of her Fifth Amendment exposure and, if necessary, to apply to the Court at that time. If you provide me
with a written proffer that summarizes her anticipated testimony and explains how she will be exposed to
criminal liability, then f can make the motion ahead of time. Your written statement would be treated as an
attorney statement made in the course of confidential plea discussions and related negotiations, and would be
governed by Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(0 and Fed. R. Evid. 410.

A. Marie Villafalla
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White [rnailto:brendan@whiwhl.com]
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 1:45 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Made C. (USAFIS)
Cc: Ball, Shawn (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
We will be there, and I will make the travel arrangements. I am assuming that this will be done in connection with an
order of immunity. Please let me know if that is correct so I can advise Ms. Lacerda. Thanks.
Brendan White
Original Message --
From: Villifena. Ann Mane C. (USAFLS)
To: Brendan White
Cc: Ball, Shawn (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 11:27 AM
Subject: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
N t

Ms. Lacerda will need to appear before the grand jury on July In to give testimony. Please contact my
assistant, Shawn Ball, at 561 820-8711, ext. 3037, to make travel arrangements. I expect that Ms. Lacerda's
testimony will begin either in the late morning or early afternoon, but she should be available for the whole
day.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014994
I I Fax 561 820-8777
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014995
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Brendan White <brendan@whiwhi.com>
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 11:26 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
Thanks.
---- Original Message ---
From: Villafana. Anny.Matie C. (USAFLS)
To: Brendan White
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 10:55 AM
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
•
If Mr. Epstein enters a guilty plea in accordance with that agreement on Monday, then the subpoena will be
withdrawn. At this point, 1 have not received confirmation that the change of plea is going to occur, nor have I
received information confirming that the plea will be in conformance with our agreement. As such, at this
time, I still intend to present Ms. Lacerda's testimony to the grand jury on Tuesday. With respect to the
immunity question, I refer you to my e-mail of June 23rd, which is shown below.
If the situation changes, I will contact you.
Thank you.
A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White [mailto:brendan@whiwhi.com]
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 10:38 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Ms. Villafana:
I understand that there has been a recent development with respect to Mr. Epstein in that he intends to plead guilty in
Florida state court on Monday pursuant to a deferred prosecution agreement with your office that has already been
executed. Since this would seem to obviate any need for Ms. Lacerda to testify, please let me know what is going on
with respect to this Tuesday. Do we still need to come down there and, if so, will she receive court-ordered
immunity? Thanks.
Brendan White
-- Original Message --
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS1
To: Brendan White
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 2:09 PM
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance 08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014996
Dear Mr. White:
Please feel free to make your own travel arrangements, but if you would like Ms. Lacerda's travel costs to be
reimbursed, they must be made through the government's approved agency on the approved carriers.
Regarding the immunity, at this point, without a written proffer from you regarding the substance of her
anticipated testimony, I believe that the more prudent course will be to question Ms. Lacerda to determine the
limits of her Fifth Amendment exposure and, if necessary, to apply to the Court at that time. If you provide
me with a written proffer that summarizes her anticipated testimony and explains how she will be exposed to
criminal liability, then I can make the motion ahead of time. Your written statement would be treated as an
attorney statement made in the course of confidential plea discussions and related negotiations, and would be
governed by Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(1) and Fed. R. Evid. 410.

A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White [mallto:brendan@whiwhi.com)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 1:45 PM
To: VIllafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc: Ball, Shawn (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
We will be there, and I will make the travel arrangements. I am assuming that this will be done in connection with an
order of immunity. Please let me know if that is correct so I can advise Ms. Lacerda. Thanks.
Brendan White
— Original Message ---
Villarana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Brendan White
Cc: Ball. Shawn (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 11:27 AM
Subject: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
A*.

Ms. Lacerda will need to appear before the grand jury on July 1St to give testimony. Please contact my
assistant, Shawn Ball, at 561 820-8711, ext. 3037, to make travel arrangements. I expect that Ms. Lacerda's
testimony will begin either in the late morning or early afternoon, but she should be available for the whole
day.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafafla
Assistant U.S. Attorney
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014997
10$
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014998
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Brendan White <brendan@whiwhi.com>
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 3:00 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
I've learned from Mr. Epstein's attorney that the plea is scheduled to take place on Monday morning. In understand, of
course, that you need confirmation of this before withdrawing the subpoena, but it might make logistical sense to 
consider
putting the contingent appearance off for another week at this point, to avoid our having to make an unnecessary trip to
Florida. Although I am confident that things will proceed as scheduled, should there be a problem, we would then be able
to appear at a later date.
Brendan White
Original Message ---
FrcimiVillafand: ArineMorie,C. tUSAR.S1.4..
To: Brendan White
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 10:55 AM
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
If Mr. Epstein enters a guilty plea in accordance with that agreement on Monday, then the subpoena will be
withdrawn. At this point, I have not received confirmation that the change of plea is going to occur, nor have I
received information confirming that the plea will be in conformance with our agreement. As such, at this
time, 1 still intend to present Ms. Lacerda's testimony to the grand jury on Tuesday. With respect to the
immunity question, I refer you to my e-mail of June 23Id, which is shown below.
If the situation changes, I will contact you.
Thank you.
A. Marie Villafafla
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White (mallto:brendan@whiwhi.com)
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 10:38 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Ms. Villafana:
I understand that there has been a recent development with respect to Mr. Epstein in that he intends to plead guilty in
Florida state court on Monday pursuant to a deferred prosecution agreement with your office that has already been
executed. Since this would seem to obviate any need for Ms. Lacerda to testify, please let me know what is going on
with respect to this Tuesday. Do we still need to come down there and, if so, will she receive court-ordered
immunity? Thanks.
08-80736-CV-MARRA
P-014999
Brendan White
-- Original Message --
;From: Villafana, Ann Marie.C. fUSAFLSI
To: prendan White
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 2:09 PM
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
Please feel free to make your own travel arrangements, but if you would like Ms. Lacerda's travel costs to be
reimbursed, they must be made through the government's approved agency on the approved carriers.
Regarding the immunity, at this point, without a written proffer from you regarding the substance of her
anticipated testimony, I believe that the more prudent course will be to question Ms. Lacerda to determine the
limits of her Fifth Amendment exposure and, if necessary, to apply to the Court at that time. If you provide
me with a written proffer that summarizes her anticipated testimony and explains how she will be exposed to
criminal liability, then 1 can make the motion ahead of time. Your written statement would be treated as an
attorney statement made in the course of confidential plea discussions and related negotiations, and would be
governed by Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(0 and Fed. R. Evid. 410.

A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White imallto:brendanOwhlwhl.com]
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 1:45 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc: Ball, Shawn (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
We will be there, and I will make the travel arrangements. I am assuming that this will be done in connection with an
order of immunity. Please let me knoie if that is correct so I can advise Ms. Lacerda. Thanks.
Brendan White
-- Original Message -
From: Villeanie. Ann Mile C. (USAFISI
To: Brendan White
Cc: Ball. Shawn fUSAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 11:27 AM
Subject: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
k t •

Ms. Lacerda will need to appear before the grand jury on July 1st to give testimony. Please contact my
assistant, Shawn Ball, at 561 820-8711, ext. 3037, to make travel arrangements. I expect that Ms. Lacerda's
testimony will begin either in the late morning or early afternoon, but she should be available for the whole
day.
Thank you. 08-80736-CV-MARRA P-015000

A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
4+,
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-015001
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) <AVillafana@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 6:41 PM
To: Brendan White
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
I have not received any such confirmation. At this time, we are still on for July 1m. I recommend that you make
your travel plans for Monday afternoon or evening and if things change, I will call you right away.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White [mailto:brendan@whiwhi.com]
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 3:00 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
I've learned from Mr. Epstein's attorney that the plea is scheduled to take place on Monday morning. In understand, of
course, that you need confirmation of this before withdrawing the subpoena, but it might make logistical sense to 
consider
pulling the contingent appearance off for another week at this point, to avoid our having to make an unnecessary trip to
Florida. Although I am confident that things will proceed as scheduled, should there be a problem, we would then be able
to appear at a later date.
Brendan White
---- Original Message ----
FrormtVillefina, Aim Marie C. (USAE.LSr:.:
To: Brendan White
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 200810:55 AM
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
If Mr. Epstein enters a guilty plea in accordance with that agreement on Monday, then the subpoena will be
withdrawn. At this point, I have not received confirmation that the change of plea is going to occur, nor have I
received information confirming that the plea will be in conformance with our agreement. As such, at this
time, I still intend to present Ms. Lacerda's testimony to the grand jury on Tuesday. With respect to the
immunity question, I refer you to my e-mail of June 23id, which is shown below.
If the situation changes, I will contact you.
Thank you.
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-015002

A. Marie Villain&
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White [malito:brendan@whlwhl.com]
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 10:38 AM
To: Vlllafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Ms. Villafana:
I understand that there has been a recent development with respect to Mr. Epstein in that he intends to plead guilty in
Florida state court on Monday pursuant to a deferred prosecution agreement with your office that has already been
executed. Since this would seem to obviate any need for Ms. Lacerda to testify, please let me know what is going on
with respect to this Tuesday. Do we still need to come down there and, if so, will she receive court-ordered
immunity? Thanks.
Brendan White
Original Message --
Freim: Vil Ana &Wert (USAFLS)
To: Brendan White
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 2:09 PM
Subject: RE: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:
Please feel free to make your own travel arrangements, but if you would like Ms. Lacerda's travel costs to be
reimbursed, they must be made through the government's approved agency on the approved carriers.
Regarding the immunity, at this point, without a written proffer from you regarding the substance of her
anticipated testimony, I believe that the more prudent course will be to question Ms. Lacerda to determine the
limits of her Fifth Amendment exposure and, if necessary, to apply to the Court at that time. If you provide
me with a written proffer that summarizes her anticipated testimony and explains how she will be exposed to
criminal liability, then I can make tte motion ahead of time. Your written statement would be treated as an
attorney statement made in the course of confidential plea discussions and related negotiations, and would be
governed by Fed. R. Crim. P. 11(0 and Fed. R. Evid. 410.

A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Brendan White (mailto:brendan@whiwhi.com]
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 1:45 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc: Ball, Shawn (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Grand Jury Appearance
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-015003
We will be there, and I will make the travel arrangements. I am assuming that this will be done in connection with an
order of immunity. Please let me know if that is correct so I can advise Ms. Lacerda. Thanks.
Brendan White
---- Original Message ---
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Brendan White
Cc: Ball, Shawn (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 200811:27 AM
Subject: Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White:

Ms. Lacerda will need to appear before the grand jury on July l g to give testimony. Please contact my
assistant, Shawn Ball, at 561 820-8711, ext. 3037, to make travel arrangements. 1 expect that Ms. Lacerda's
testimony will begin either in the late morning or early afternoon, but she should be available for the whole
day.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villajaiia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-015004
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Brendan White [brendan@whiwhi.com)
Sent: Monday. June 30. 2008 11:20 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Cancellation of Grand Jury Appearance
Thank you for letting me know. I will inform Ms. Lacerda.
Brendan
-- Original Message ---
From: Villafana. Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Brendan White
Cc: Ball. Shawn (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 30, 2008 10:59 AM
Subject: Cancellation of Grand Jury Appearance
Dear Mr. White: At this time, the subpoena of Ms. Lacerda is withdrawn. If that should change, I will contact
you.

A. Mark Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
EXHIBIT B-135
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Thursday, January 31, 2008 7:33 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
Subject: Epstein
Hi Jeff and Alex — We just finished interviewing three of the girls. I wish you could have been there to see how
much this has affected them.
One girl broke down sobbing so that we had to stop the interview twice within a 20 minute span. She regained
her composure enough to continue a short time, but she said that she was having nightmares about Epstein
coming after her and she started to break down again, so we stopped the interview.
The second girl, who has a baby girl of her own, told us that she was very upset about the 18 month deal she
had read about in the paper. She said that 18 months was nothing and that she had heard that the girls could get
restitution, but she would rather not get any money and have Epstein spend a significant time in jail.
The FBI's victim-witness coordinator attended and she has arranged for counseling for several of the girls.
Please reach out to Alice to make her decision. These girls deserve so much better than they have received so
far, and I hate feeling that there is nothing I can do to help them.
We have four more girls coming in tomorrow. Can I persuade you to attend?

A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Tracking: EXHIBIT
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014573
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, March 19. 2008 2:30 PM
To: Weinstein, David (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Epstein update
Why is this allowed to continue? Al least put us out of our misery quickly if that is what is going to happen!
A. Marie lillaleala
Assistant 11.5. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave. Suite 400
West Palm Beach. FL 33401
Phone 56 I 209-I 047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Weinstein, David (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, March 19, 2008 2:29 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Epstein update
Thank you for silently keeping me in the loop.
Outrageous.
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, March 19, 2008 2:16 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS); Garcia, Rolando (USAFLS)
Subject: Epstein update
Hi Jeff and Bob — I am hoping that you have an update from Drew. I wanted to fill you in on recent events.
Yesterday we did the first half of the grand jury presentation on the indictment. Many of the grand jurors
expressed thanks for our return. After a break as 1 walked into the room, I overheard one juror telling another
that he had been concerned that we were going to "whitewash" this case and not charge it.
Epstein's lawyers arc using the civil lawsuits as an excuse to harass a number of the victims. One girl, who is a
scholarship student at a local university, was hauled into the Dean of Students office to be served with a
subpoena for a deposition. It is scheduled for Monday.
A national crime victims service organization has received a grant from the Justice Department to provide legal
representation to victims. They have agreed to provide counsel for our victims. The only problem is that the
lawyers are located in Maryland. But they will try to find pro bono lawyers here to help out.
I also told Bob that one of our victims tried to commit suicide last week. The FBI's victim-witness coordinator
is doing her best to get counseling for all of our needy victims, but I just can't stress enough how important it is
08-80736-CV-MARRA
EX1 II BIT C-2
P-014781
for these girls to have a resolution in this case. The "please be patient" answer is really wearing thin, especially
when Epstein's group is still on the attack while we are forced to wait on the sidelines.
Your guidance is needed.
Thank you.

A. Marie Yillafalia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL. 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014782
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, March 19, 2008 4:34 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS); Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS); Garcia,
Rolando (USAFLS)
Cc: Kuyrkendall, E N.
Subject: Victim Subpoena
Ili everyone — I just spoke with the subpoenaed victim. The subpoena was issued in connection with the state
criminal case, which, as you know, doesn't involve most of the victims in our case (including the girl who was
subpoenaed). The state attorney's office told us from the beginning that their case has been resolved. He is
going to plead to the solicitation of adults for prostitution charge, so this seems to be a clear effort to find out
about our case through the state case.

A. Marie Villain
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Tracking:
1313 EXHIBIT C-3
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014783
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Saturday, March 22, 2008 8:51 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS); Garcia, Rolando (USAFLS)
Subject: Epstein
Hi all - So sorry to bother you on a Saturday, but I am hoping that I can persuade you to reach out to Drew
about Epstein's investigators harassing the girls. Nesbitt received a frantic call today about Epstein's
investigators bothering the parents of one of the victims. According to the victim, he demanded to see the
victim and when he saw her, he told the victim that they had video of the girl and were planning to put it on the
internet. We don't believe that Epstein actually has video of any of the girls, and Nesbitt has calmed the girl
down, but this activity seems to be getting more aggressive. Remember also that Epstein is using the state
criminal case to subpoena depositions of victims in the federal case (who are not part of the state indictment) to
get information about our investigation. These actions do not seem consistent with what Epstein's attorneys are
supposed to be trying to work out with Drew in DC. Any chance Drew will ask Epstein's people to call off
their dogs until he makes his decision?

4. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Tracking: 1256
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014790
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Saturday, March 22, 2008 9:43 PM
To: Kuyrkendall, E N.
Subject: Message from Jeff
Hi Nesbitt — I contacted Jeff and Bob about the harassment issue and Jeff also recommended calling the police.
When Twiler calls on Monday can she provide the non-emergency police numbers for the local police
departments where the girls are located and ask them to call the police directly if they are getting harassed? I
think we should be documenting this stuff with someone other than you.
Thank you.
A. Marie Mal -aft
Assistant U.S. Attorney
561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014795
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, May 23, 2007 4:20 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Jeffrey Epstein
Let's talk before this is sent, please.
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, May 23, 2007 3:45 PM
To: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: FW: Jeffrey Epstein
Karen — What do you think?
Hi Jeff and Mau — I just want to again voice my disagreement with promising to have a meeting or having a
meeting with Lefcourt or any other of Epstein's attorneys. As I mentioned, this is not a case where we will be
sitting down to negotiate whether a defendant will serve one year versus two years of probation. This is a case
where the defendant is facing the possibility of dozens of years of prison time. Just as the defense will defend a
case like that differently than they would handle a probation-type case, we need to handle this case
differently. Part of our prosecution strategy was already disclosed at the last meeting, and I am concerned that
more will be disclosed at a future meeting.
My co-chair, John McMillan, who has prosecuted more of these cases than the rest of us combined and who
actually worked on the drafting of some of the child exploitation statutes, also opposes a meeting. We have
been accused of not being "strategic thinkers" because of our opposition to these meetings, but we are simply
looking at this case as a violent crime prosecution involving stiff penalties rather than as a white collar or public
corruption case where the parties can amicably work out a light sentence.
With respect to the "policy reasons" that Lefcourt wants to discuss, those were already raised in his letter
(which is part of the indictment package) and during his meeting with Andy and myself. Those reasons are: (1)
he wants the Petit policy to trump our ability to prosecute Epstein, (2) this shouldn't be a federal offense, and

(3) the victims were willing participants so the crime shouldn't be prosecuted at all. Unless the Office thinks
that any of those arguments will be persuasive, a meeting will not be beneficial to the prosecution, it will only
benefit the defense. With respect to Lefcourt's promised legal analysis, that also has already been
provided. The only way to get additional analysis is to expose to the defense the other charges that we are
considering. In my opinion this would seriously undermine the prosecution.
The defense is anxious to have a meeting in order to delay the investigation/prosecution, to find out more about
our investigation, and to use political pressure to stop the investigation.
I have no control over the Office's decisions regarding whether to meet with the defense or to whom the facts
and analysis of the case will be disclosed. However, if you all do decide to go forward with these meetings in a
way that is detrimental to the investigation, then I will have to ask to have the case reassigned to an AUSA who
is in agreement with the handling of the case.
A. Marie Villafaila
Assistant U.S. Attorney
EXHIBIT C-4
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Lourie, Andrew (USAFLS)
Sent: Tuesday, May 22, 2007 6:33 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: FW: Jeffrey Epstein
fyi
From: Lourie, Andrew (USAFLS)
Sent: Tuesday, May 22, 2007 6:32 PM
To: 'Gerald Lefcourt'
Subject: RE: Jeffrey Epstein
I have your letter. I think we are on the same page, but to be sure I do want to clarify that we spoke the other week 
and
I did say that if you want to meet with me again, I am ready to do so. The wording of your letter, however, suggests
implicitly that I agreed to contact you before a decision is made to seek an indictment of Mr. Epstein. If that was your
understanding, then please allow me to clarify. Our investigation is ongoing and if we decide to seek an indictment, we
don't intend to call Mr. Epstein's representatives to let him know that. Of course, in the interim, if you would like to
make a presentation to us, we are willing to listen.
Along those lines, given the fact that we have already met once, with schedules being what they are, it makes sense for
our criminal chief, Matt Menchel, to be included when you make another presentation, rather than working up the
chain incrementally. I realize you were being respectful in not attempting to leapfrog over me, which I appreciate. I
will pass on your request to meet with the U.S. Attorney as well, but can't commit for him one way or another. When
you have some dates in mind, let me know and I will try to set up a meeting in Miami.
From: Gerald Lefcourt [mailto:GBL@lefcourtlaw.com]
Sent: Tuesday, May 22, 2007 2:05 PM
To: Lourle, Andrew (USAFLS)
Cc: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS); Lilly Ann Sanchez
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein
Andy, attached is a letter seeking meetings, as discussed with you, but with others if it is not resolved. Thanks for 
your
attention. Could you email back so that I know you have received this letter?
Gerald B. Lefcourt
Gerald B. Lefcourt, P.C.
148 E. 78th Street
New York, New York 10021
.0400
Fax
obkalercourtlaw.com
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Menchel, Matthew (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, May 14, 2007 10:52 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS); Lourie, Andrew (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Operation Leap Year
Marie,
You will not have approval to go forward tomorrow with an indictment or to poceed by complaint. Alex has your memo
and lefcourt's letter but he is out of the district at the US Attorney's conference for the next several days.
I'm having trouble understanding - given how long this case has been pending - what the rush is. This is obviously a 
very
significant case and alex wants to take his time making sure he is comfortable before proceeding.
Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld
Original Message
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) <AVillafana@usa.doj.gov>
To: Lourie, Andrew (USAFLS) <Alourie@usa.doj.gov>; Menchel, Matthew (USAFLS) <MMenchel@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Mon May 14 10:38:15 2007
Subject: Operation Leap Year
Good morning: I just received a call that Epstein's plane is flying from the Virgin Islands to Newark now, so it looks 
like
Epstein is going to show up for his court appearance tomorrow. Can you let me know if the indictment is going
tomorrow or, if not, whether we are authorized to proceed by Complaint?
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafaha
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
EXHIBIT C-5
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: VIHelena. Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Friday, October 05, 2007 4:48 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Subject: FW: Proposed Letter to Special Master
Attachments: PROPOSED Letter to Special Master.pdf; Special Master Proposal.pdf; Ltr from Lefkowitz to
Villafana (Oct. 5, 2007)212135690_4)1)OC
li i Jeff Can I please just indict him? Can you give me a call on my cell phone? 561 601-2301. Since they
object to using a Special Master. we have two options — we can just choose the lawyer ourselves or as part of
our selection process. we can deal with the Special Master ourselves and, upon receiving the Special Master's
choice. provide that name to the defense, understanding that they may then reject the selection.
The other issues, regarding paying the attorney, clearly violate the terms of the agreement, which specifically
state "if any of the individuals elects to file suit."
A. Mark Villafafta
Assistant U.S. Attorney
561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Jay Lefkowitz [mailto:Reficowit@kirkland.com]
Sent: Fri 10/5/2007 11:03 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc: Lourie, Andrew; owlmgw@worldnet.att.net; glewis@lewistein.com
Subject: RE: Proposed Letter to Special Master
Marie.
Attached is a letter responding to your latest proposals. For your convenience, I've also attached your prior e-mails 
and
attachments regarding this matter so that you can easily see what I am responding to (see the chain below). If you are
available, I'm free to talk at 5:30 this evening. We can use my usual call-in number at (866) 462-0164. The code is
'4464970'.
Thanks,
Jay
"Villatana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLSr
cAnn.Marie.C.Vifialaniausdoi.00v>
10/05/2007 07 48 AM
To -Jay Letkormts" clletkomMakirkland corny
cc
Subject RE. Proposed Letter to Special Master
EXHIBIT C-6
Good morning, Jay. We need to resolve the attorney issue today. It has been weeks since
execution of the contract, and there is no need for further delay.
As far as the five attorney names that we will be providing, I propose Bert Ocariz,
Katherine Ezell at Podhurst Orseck, Stuart Grossman, Ed Rogers, and Walter Cobath.
If you would like to use the same Special Master to resolve fees disputes as well as to
handle the selection of the attorney, I recommend that w tired 11th Circuit
Judge Joseph Hatchett instead of Judge because of Judge
illie
health problems.
:No one has contacted Judge Hatchett yet, but one of the District udges in Miami
mentioned him as a good choice. )
I am available for a conference call between 9:00 and 10:00, and between 3:15 and 6:00.
Please call me on my cell (561 601-2301) and let me know which of those times works best
for you.
Thank you.
From: Jay Lefkowitz (mailto:JLefkowitz@kirkland.com)
Sent: Wed 10/3/2007 4:26 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Proposed Letter tc Special Master
Marie - I, too, am interested in speed. But I really need to go over this and then
discuss with Jeffrey. So please do not send this to any Special Master before we discuss
the next steps.
Thanks -- Jay
"Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)" <Ann.Marie.C.Viliatana@usdoj.gov>
10/03/200 7 04:24 PM
To
"Jay Lefkowitz" <JLefkowitz@kirkland.com>
cc
Subject
Proposed Letter to Special Master
Hi Jay - To move things along, I also have enclosed the proposed text of a letter to the
Special Master.
<<PROPOSED Letter to Special Master.pdf»

A. Marie Villafafla
Assistant "J.S. Attorney
561 209-1047
Fax 561 920-8 77 '7
"ViIlafana, Ann Mario C. (USAFLS) -
cAnn.Marie.S.Villalanageusdoiciov>
10/03/2007 04 24 PM
To "Jay lentowaz ciLefltovnizattkirkiand corn,
cc
Subject Proposed Letter to Special Master
Hi Jay — To move things along. I also have enclosed the proposed text of a letter to the Special Master.
«PROPOSED Letter to Special Master pdf»

A. Mark Villafaik
Assistant U.S. Attorney
561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
"Vilialana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)"
4Ann,Mario.C.Villaranalausdoickur>
10/03/2007 03 18 PM
To "Jay Lefkowitz" <JLetkomtzrekirsiand corn>
cc
&beset Memo in POF lomat
Hi Jay — In case you can't open the other version, here it is in pdf.
<<Special Master Proposetpdf»
A. Mark Vilkfafia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana. Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 5:58 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Letter from Jay Lefkowitz
Welcome to my world. I love the way that they want to interpret this agreement. First, during the negotiations, I
repeatedly told Jay that we could not bind the girls to Epstein's desired out-of-court settlement strategy and. 
therefore. the
agreement could not try to bind them in that way.
The 550,000/S150,000 thing is a complete red herring, and Jay keeps calling it a "limit," when it is actually a floor, 
not a
ceiling.
It also looks like they are planning to ask for and receive a sentence far lower than the one we agreed to. Has
anyone talked to Barry about this? Maybe this is the real reason for the delay in entering the guilty plea? We
also have to contact the victims to tell me about the outcome of the case and to advise them that an attorney will
be contacting them regarding possible claims against Mr. Epstein. If we don't do that, it may be a violation of
the Florida Bar Rules for the selected attorney to "cold call" the girls.
Their complaint about the 24-year-old concerns me only because their continued dragging out of this matter is
ly going to foreclose other girls. The language of the agreement with Epstein and the letter to Judge i iissib
both refer to persons we have identified as victims as defined in 2255, it says nothing about whether the
gir s claims are necessarily valid. I have no idea whether the girl who currently is 24 either wants to sue
Epstein or has any viable state or other federal claims -- that is why we are TRYING to get them a lawyer. And
they have always known that most of the girls are now over the age of 18 -- goodness -- the time period of the
violations was from 2001 to 2005 and it is now the end of 2007!
Why don't we agree to mutual recission and indict him?
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Tue 10/23/2007 5:13 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: FW: Letter from Jay Lefkowitz
Wait to you see this one.
From: Jay Lefkowitz (mailto:JLefkowitz@kirkland.com]
Sent: Tuesday, October 23, 2007 4:57 PM
To: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
Cc: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Subject: Letter from Jay Lefkowitz
Dear Alex and Jeff,
Here is my response to Jeffs email from late yesterday.
Please let me know if you want to speak later this evening. I am also available any time tomorrow.
2687 EXHIBIT C-7
Thanks -- Jay
The information contained in this communication is
confidential, may be attorney -client privileged, may
constitute inside information, and is intended only tor
the use of the addressee. It is the property of
Kirkland & Ellis LLP or Kirkland 6 Ellis International LLP.
Unauthorized use, disclosure or copying of this
communication or any part thereof is strictly prohibited
and may be unlawful. If you have received this
communication in error, please notify us immediately by
return e-mail or by e-mail to postmastetikirkland.com,  and
destroy this communication and all copies thereof,
including all attachments.
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Sloman. Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, October 22, 2007 5:26 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS); Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
Subject: Fw: Epstein
Fyi
Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld
Original Message
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
To: 'flefkowitz@kirkland.com. <JLefkowitz@kirkland.com>
Sent: Mon Oct 22 17:23:30 2007
Subject: Re: Epstein
I l
I have not spoken to him b ' was our intention to assign the decision to
select a lawyer to Judge not for him to represent the girls. We do not
want to select the lawyer w o l represents the girls. I don't know who said he'd do
it but it wasn't us.
Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld
Original Message
From: Jay Lefkowitz <JLefkowitz@kirkland.com>
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Cc: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS); Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Mon Oct 22 17:10:00 2007
Subject: Re: Epstein
Jeff -- I will review these materials this evening and be in touch with you
tomorrow with the expectation of wrapping this up by nd of the day. One
question I have, however, is why you say that Judge is a non-starter. I
understood that he was ready, willing and able to serve as the attorney
representative. If you have had conversations with him and that is not the case,
please let me know.
I will go over the other issues you raise in your email and will look forward to
speaking tomorrow.
Thanks -- Jay
"Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)" <]eff.Sloman@usdoj.gov>
10/22/2007 04:40 PM
To
"Jay Lefkowitz" <JLefkowitz@kirkland.com> cc
"Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)" cAlex.Acosta@usdoj.gov>, "Villafana, Ann Marie C.
(USAFLS)" <Ann.Marie.C.Villafana@usdoj.gov> Subject
Epstein
Jay,
The Judge issue is a non-starter. We've beaten that horse to death.
Regarding your contention that "the attorney representative be told clearly that

Mr. Epstein has agreed to pay the lawyer's hourly rate only for the time he or
she spends working to effectuate settlements for the identified women," Alex and
I agree that paragraph 7C is sufficient, Regarding the other points, we have
made the following concessions:

1. Regarding the language concerning a lawyer whose firm is
sizeable enough to litigate multiple trials simultaneously, I have removed
paragraph 4 on page 3 of the letter.

2. Regarding the 150k statutory limit language, I have included a
footnote which should satisfy your concern.
3. Regarding language there may be discovery to test the claims
of alleged "victims", please see new paragraph 4 on page 3 which now states as
criteria that the firm should have "Experience litigating against large law firms
and high profile attorneys who may test the veracity of the victims' claims."
I have attached the Addendum and the revised letter to Judge Jay, this
needs to be concluded. Alex and I believe that this is as far w can go.
Therefore, please advise me whether we have a deal no later than COB tomorrow,
Tuesday, October 23, 2007. Thanks,
Jeff
Original Message
From: Jay Lefkowitz [mailto:]Lefkowitz@kirkland.com]
Sent: Friday, October 19, 2007 4:05 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Subject: Re:
Jeff -
I have reviewed your proposed language and wanted to raise a few areas of
concern.
First, I am not sure why we are not just asking Judge to represent these
women. If he is available, that would save us a whole a itional layer of
process. I had thought that was initially the idea. I am not sure why you seem
to be moving in another direction.
I also cannot understand why the draft affirmatively requests that J select
a lawyer whose firm is sizeable enough to litigate multiple trials
simultaneously. That seems to be directly at odds with the purpose of the
agreement, which is to facilitate out of court settlements. Indeed, to the
extent any woman were to elect to bring an action against Mr. Epstein, she would
not only be free to select any lawyer of her choice, but would be restricted from
using the lawyer representative in this capacity due to the conflicts of
interests that would cause. This part of your proposed language is of
signficiant concern to me.
Your letter also indicates the 150k statutory limit without reference to the
pre-existing 50G limit. To be sure, any of the women are free to seek whatever
settlement they want, but given the question that exists about the statutory
amount, the letter should not state definitely that it will be 150k.
In addition have omitted a few important items from your proposal. Given
that Judge or any other potential attorney representative should understand
the scope o e work, the language should make clear that there may be discovery
to test the claims of alleged "victims."
Finally, I think it is important that the attorney representative be told clearly
that Mr. Epstein has agreed to pay the lawyer's hourly rate only for the time he
or she spends working to effectuate settlements for the identified women.
Jay
Original Message
From: "Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)" [Jeff.Sloman@usdoj.gov]
Sent: 10/17/2007 01:58 PM AST
To: Jay Lefkowitz
Subject: RE:
<<071015 Special Master Letter2.wpd» Jay,
Here's our proposed letter to the special master.
Jeff
Original Message
From: Jay Lefkowitz [mailto:JLefkowitz@kirkland.com]
Sent: Tuesday, October 16, 2007 9:26 AM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Subject:
Jeff - is there a time today we can speak?
How about 430 pm?
***********************************************************
The information contained in this communication is
confidential, may be attorney-client privileged, may
constitute inside information, and is intended only for
the use of the addressee. It is the property of
Kirkland & Ellis LLP or Kirkland & Ellis International LLP.
Unauthorized use, disclosure or copying of this
communication or any part thereof is strictly prohibited
and may be unlawful. If you have received this
communication in error, please notify us immediately by
return e-mail or by e-mail to postmaster@kirkland.com, and
destroy this communication and all copies thereof,
including all attachments.
#4********#4 , ###tt4c#4***********####*********************###
#********####4 , 4, **************###*t#ti,*#*#44 , *********4.44.44 2k#
The information contained in this communication is
confidential, may be attorney-client privileged, may
constitute inside information, and is intended only for
the use of the addressee. It is the property of
Kirkland & Ellis LLP or Kirkland & Ellis International LLP.
Unauthorized use, disclosure or copying of this
communication or any part thereof is strictly prohibited
and may be unlawful. If you have received this
communication in error, please notify us immediately by
return e-mail or by e-mail to postmaster@kirkland.com, and
destroy this communication and all copies thereof,
including all attachments.
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MARIE VILLAFANA
Exhibit # Date Description
I 5/1/2006 Letter from Chief Rcitcr to State Attorney Krischer
2 5/23/2006 File Opening Documents
7/3/2007-
7/13/2007
Emails between Criminal Chief Matt Menchel and AUSA Villafaiia regarding plea
negotiations.
4 7/31/2007 Tenn Sheet for Epstein Non-Prosecution Agreement
5 Undated File folder entitled 'Meeting Timeline' with contents
6 7/24/2006 Letter from Chief Reiter to victims informing them of FBI investigation
7 7/26/2006 South Florida Sun-Sentinel Article Regarding Chief Reiter's referral of case to FBI
8 8/2/2007
Lilly Ann Sanchez email to Matt Menchel with attached letter containing counter-
proposal for plea to two years of 'supenised custody.'
8/24/2006-
10/24/2006 Entails betweenJim Eisenberg and Marie Villafana regarding #28
10/30/2006-
10/31-2006
Emails between Marie Vitt:liana and Guy Lewis regarding Lewis respresentation
of Epstein
II
11/8/2006-
I/8/2007
Emails between Marie Villatana and Lilly Ann Sanchez regarding Sanchets
representation of Epstein
12 8/4/2006 Victim Notification Letters
13 WI1/2006 Victim Notification Letters
1/17/07-
2/1/07
Correspondence between Lilly Ann Sanchez, Gerald Lelcourt, Andrew Laurie,
A. Marie Villafrina, and John McMillan regarding 2/1/2007 Meeting
11/13/06-
1/22/07 Subpoenas to Adrian Mucinska and research re 6001 immunity
16 9/26/2006 Memo regarding Changes to Child Exploitation Statutes in Tide 18
17 2/6/2007 Transcript of Kuyrkendall Testimony
18 2/27/2007 Transcript of Kuyrkendall Testimony
19 3/15/2007 Victim Notification Letter
20 3/20/2007 Transcript of Kuyrkendall Testimony
21 4/24/2007 Transcript of Kiwrkendall Testimony
22 4/24/2007 ' I 't a irseript of #37 Testimony
23 5/8/2007 Presentation Materials
24 5/8/2007 Transcript of Kuyrkendall Testimony
25 5/8/2007 Transcript of Richards Testimony
5/14/07-
5/21/07 Emats between Andrew Laurie, Mau MencheLjeff Sloman, mid Marie Villakula
27 5/15/2007 Transcript of Kuyrkendall Testimony
5/22/07-
5/24/07
Emails between Andrew Laurie, Gerald Lel-court, Man Mencheljeff Sloman,
Marie Villafaiia, Lilly Ann Sanchez, and Karen Atkinson regarding second
meeting with counsel for Epstein
29 5/22/2007 Transcript of Kuyrkendall Testimony
30 6/7/2007 Victim Notification Letters
6/14/07-
6/21/07
Entails between Marie Villafaiia, Karen Atkinson, Andrew Laurie, Mau Menchel,
and Jeff Martian regarding addendum to Pros Memo, grand jury presentation,
changes to indictmer it. and meeting with counsel for Epstein.
32 6/25/2007
Letter from Gerald I efcourt tojeffrey Montan and Andrew Laurie regarding
6/26/2007 meeting and emails and notes regarding same.
PRIVILEGED and CONFII)ENTIAL Page 1 of 10 CONTAINS 6(c) MATERIAL
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MARIE VILLAFANA
Exhibit 41 Date Description
33 7/6/2007
Letter from Gerald l.efcourt and Alan Dershonia toJeffrey Sloman and Andrei
Londe arguing against federal prosecution.
34 7/13/2007 Letter from Roy Black to Marie Villa' la with handwritten attorney Lourie notes
35 7/25/2007
latter from Gerald l.efrourt and Alan Dershowia to Matthew Menchel arguing
that no charge can or should be made under 18 U.S.C. S 2422(b).
36 7/26/2007
Email from Marie ViIlafaria to Matt Menchel and Andrew Lourie regarding
proposed changes to indictment.
7/27/2007 -
8/8/2007 Research regarding 18 U.S.C. S 2255
38 7/81/2007
Email from Marie ViKaiak toJeff Molnar], Man Menchel, and Andrew Lourie
summarizing proposed plea terms as per Menchel recommendation
7/81/07-
8/3/07
7/31/2007.8/3/2007 Entails between Jeff Montan, Matt Moretti, Andrew Louric,
and Marie VilLafaria regarding plea negotiations, including draft response to
Nutter counsel regarding proposed agreement
40 8/2/2007
Letter front Lilly Ann Sanchez to Matthew Menchel containing counter-proposal
of 2 years' supervised custody with two additional years of probation and internal
correspondence regarding same.
I I 8/3/2007
Letter from Matthew Menchel to Lilly Ann Sanchez rejecting counterproposal,
setting a deadline of 8/17/2007, and advising that LISA Acosta was not inclined to
meet with counsel for Epstein, and internal entails regarding same.
I.? 8/6/2007
Entails from Marie Villafaila to Cyndee Campos, Frederica Devlin, and Jeff
Sloman to determine whether Malt Matchers 8/3/2007 letter went out before he
resigned from the U.S. Attorney's Office.
43 8/7/2007
Entails between Drew Oosterbaan, Andrew Laurie, Marie Villafafia, Alex Acosta,
Jeff Slontan, and Cyndee Campos regarding request front Epstein's counsel for
meeting with CEOS and background of case
l 1.
9/4/07-
9/6/07
Entails betweenJeff Molnar', Marie Villafak, Andrew Laurie, Drew Oosterbaan,
and Rolando Garcia regarding planned meeting with Epstein defense team and
need to confer with victims.
I. 9/10/2007
Entails betweenJeff Sloman, Marie Villafafia,John McMillan, and Andrew
Larne regarding USA Acosia's inquiry regarding the state grand jury investigation
IS
9/10/07-
9/19/07
Entails between Alex Acosta, Jeff Montan, Andrew Laurie, Rolando Garcia,
Karen Atkinson, Marie Villafafia, andJohn McMillan regarding plea negotiations
9/10/07-
9/11/07
Entails from Marie Viktoria to Gerakl I cfcourt with proposed Non-Prosecution
Apvements
PI
9/11/07-
9/13/07
Entails between Marie Vilkdafia and Drew Oosterbaan regarding proposed Non-
Prosecution Agreement, including research on proposed tnist fund.
9/ 1 2/2007-
9/24/2007 Entails between Marie Villafidia and Jay I.elkowitz re plea negotiations
50 9/21/2007 Research re Florida Statutes
51 9/23/2007 Entails between Alex Acosta and Jay Lelkowitz re pica negotiations
PRIVILEGED and CONFIDENTIAL. Page 2 of 10 CONTAINS G(e) MATERIAL
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MARIE VILLAFANA
Exhibit (t Date Description
52 9/24/2007 Signed non-prosecution agreement
53 6/18/2007 Letter to Gerald Lefcourt re subpoena to NES, LLC and Jute 26, 2007 meeting
54 5/21/2007 Email regarding guidance on grand jury presentation
55 12/3/2007
Entails from Marie VillafaLfia to Alex Acosta regarding research on proposed trust
fund.
56 3/22/2007
Entails between Marie Villafafia and IRS supervisor regarding money laundering
research
57 Case regarding nunicy laundering and aiding & abetting
58 2/12/2007
Entails between l'illafafia and Lilly Ann Sanchez regarding employee
representation with Lourie and Villafafia handwritten notes
59 5/21/2007 Subpoena to Paul A. Lavery
60 6/18/2007 Subpoena to Witham Riley
61 «18/2007 Subpoena to Riley Kiraly
62 7/18/2007
Email from Villafaita to Matt Menthe! regarding Roy Black objection to
subpoenas addressed to William Riley and Riley Kiraly
63 7/19/2007 Entails between A/Malaita, Menthe!, and Loire regarding service of target letters.
64 7/26/2007
Email from Villarafia to Man Menthe) and Andrew Londe regarding
reconunended revisions to indictment
8/1/2007-
8/2/2007 Entails between Menthe! and Villakdre regarding plea negotiations
66 9/10/2007
Proposed Non-Prosecution Agreement provided to Gerald Leleourt on
9/10/2007
67 9/11/2007
Proposed Non-Prosecution Agreement incorporating Acosta edits provided to
Gerald Lefeourt on 9/11/2007
6/18/2008-
6/19/2008
Entails between Villafafia, Krischer, Atkinson, Senior, Acosta, Sloman. and
Garcia regarding Epstein's case with state court and how it might breach the NPA
69 12/14/2007 Draft letter to Kriseher front Acosta regarding Epstein filing as sex oftender
9/16/2008-
9/17/2008
Entails between Villarafia, Krischer, Belohlavek, Garcia, Sloman, and Atkinson
regarding Palm Beach Daily News requesting copy of the NPA and discussion
71 «30/2008 Entail front Drew Oosterbaan rc Epstein guilty plea
72 11/14/2007
Entail from Villafafia to Stomata regarding meeting with State Attorney's Office
about work release and sex offender registration
12/6/2007-
12/7/2007
Entails between Lamm Belohlavek, Marie Villafafia, and Jeff Sloman regarding a
factual proffer for state plea
74 12/14/2007 Email from Villafafia to Acosta and Sloman regarding hl. Stat. 796.03 and 2255.
75 12/14/2007 Email front Villafafia to Acosta with three letters requested by Acosta
11/15/2007-
11/16/2007
Entails between Richards, Villafafia, Slontan, Garcia, Acosta, and Atkinson
regarding work release
6/27/2008-
«28/2008
Entails between Vilkifafia, Goklberger, and Black regarding issues with state plea
agreement
78 «17/2008
Entail from Villafaita to Acosta, Sloman, Senior, Atkinson, and Garcia
summarizing meeting with Krischer regarding Epstein's attempt to negotiate a new
plea deal
PRIVILEGE') and CONFIDENTIAL Page 3 of 10 CONTAINS 6(c) MATERIAL
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MARIE VILLAFANA
&hint # Date Description
79 6/27/2008
Entail from 3rillafaita to Montan summarizing conversation with Goldberger that
Epstein would serve sentence in confinement '24-bouts-a-day
80 6/29/2008 Email from Kuyrkendall to Villafana regarding work release
81 7/3/2008
Email from Villafiula to Sloman providing update on meeting with Col Gauger at
PBSO regarding work release
11/20/2008.
1 iip2 mow
Entails between Villafafia, Senior, Acosta, Slontan, Atkinson, and Garcia
regarding Epstein work release
83 12/9/2008 Research materials regarding Epstein's work release application
84 12/11/2008
VilLiana letter to Capt. Sleeth, Palm Beach Sheriffs Office, mganling Epstein's
work release application
85 6/9/2009
Vadatla Memorandum to Sloman, Senior, Garcia, awl Atkinson seeking
permission to declare breach with attachments awl proposal breach letter
86 6/9/2009 Signed indictment package
87 6/12/2009 Villafaiia letter to Goldberger providing notice of breach of NPA
88 6/15/2009
Villafana letter to Lclkowitz, Black, and Goldberger regarding history of Epstein's
performance under the NPA
89 6/17(2009
Villafaila letter to Lelkowitz regarding monitoring future performance under the
NPA
90 9/1/2009
Black letter to Montan seeking approval for Epstein to transfer community control
to the Virgin Islands
91 9/18/2009
Villafaila letter to Black explaining Olfwe's concerns about Epstein's application
for transfer to the Virgin Islands
A-1 Timeline of Events
B-1 Chart addressing Question B.2
11-2 11/19/2007 Plea notification letter datal 11/19/2007
B-3 11/27/2007
Plea notification letter dated 11/27/2007 at 7:11 pm (formatting problem
convening from Word Perfect)
B-4 11/28/2007 Victim notification letter prepared II/28/2007 at 9:42 pm
B-5 12/1/2007 Victim notification letter prepared 12/1/2007 at 7:50 pm
1.6 12/7(2007 Victim notification letter prepared 12/7/2007 at 9:10 pm (formatting problem)
13-7 11/19/2007 Research rc Florida Statute 921.143
B-8 11/28/2007 Email chain between Jay Lelkowitz an dJeff Sloman forwarded to Marie Villaftula
B-9 11/29/2007 Letter from Jay Lelkowitz to Alex Acosta re CVRA - victim notifwation letter
B-10 II/30/2007 Letter from Alex Acosta to Jay Lefkowia rc Victim Notification letter
B-11 12/5/2007
Letter from Ken Starr and Jay I adkowitz to Alex Acosta requesting updated draft
victim letters
B-12 12/6/2007 Letter from Jeff Mont an to Jay Lefkowitz attaching victim notification letter
B-13
12/6/2007-
12/7/2007 Internal entails about need to notify victims of upcoming plea
PRIVILEGED and CONFIDENTIAL. Page 4 of 10 CONTAINS 6(c) MKITRIAL
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MANE VILLAFAHA
Exhibit # Dale Description
B-14 12/7/2007 Victim notification letters and envelopes that were never sent
13-15 12/7/2007 Letter from Lilly Ann Sanchez with 1/4/2008 plea date
13-16 12/14/2007
Draft Victim Notification Letter prepared I WI4/2007 at 9:57 pm (formatting
problem)
13-17 12/14/2007
Email from Marie Villafana to Alex Acostadcff Sloman, Rolando Garcia, and
Karen Atkinson with victim letter attached
B-18 12/17/2007
Email from Marie Villafana to Jeff Sloman reiterating concerns about failure to
notify victims
13.19 12/19/2007
Entails between Alex Acosta,JeffSloman, and Marie Villafafta with draft and final
letter to Lilly Ann Sanchez, including promise not to provide victims with notice
of state change of plea hearing.
13-20 19/11/2007
Email from Marie Villafana toJeff Sloman and Alex Acosta regarding call with
Jim Eisenberg
13.21 12/21/2007 Letter from Jay Lefkowitz to Alex Acosta re wanting to sec victim list
B.22 12/26/2007
Letter from Jay Lelkowitz. to Alex Acosta re right to review victim notification
letter and belief that it should come from State Attorney's Office
13.23
3/10/2008.
3/12/2008
Entails regarding Epstein attempts to contact victims and finding counsel for
victims
13-24 5/15/2008
Letter from Drew Oosterbaan toJay Lelkowitz denying challenge to federal
prosecution
13.25 3/14/2008 Revised indictment package
B-26 3/18/2008 Grand jury presentation materials and transcript
13-27 3/14/2008
Entails between Marie Villafana, Rolando Garcia, Karen Atkinson, Frederica
Devlin, and Shawn Ball rc complete indictment package for Robert Senior review
B-28 3/28/2008 Letter from Ken Starr to DAAG SW Mandelker with additional objections
B-29 4/29/2008 Summary chart and outline for grand jury presentation
B-30 4/29/2008 Draft Indictment
15-31
10/9/2007-
3/25/2008
FBI Interview Reports of— (10/05/2007, 3/20/2008, and 3/25/2008), #2
(10/10/2007), #14 (10/26/2007), #33 (10/02/2007), #20 (10/25/2007), #21
(10/0W2007), - (10/0W2007), — (10/02/2007), #40 (6/12/2007), and #35
(10/02/2007)
13-32 5/19/2008
Letter fromMI .310mm toJay Lefkowitz settingJune 2, 2008 deadline to comply
with tenns and conditions of the NPA
5/19/2008-
512712008 Ken Starr/Whitley letters to Deputy Attorney General Mark Filip
13-34
5/27/2008-
6/13/2008
Internal entails after CEOS letter rejecting appeal where Marie Villafana asks to
indict andJeff/Alex advise Epstein will be given chance to perform
13-35 5/19/2008 Correspondence between Alex Acosta,Jeff Slomah, and Jay Lelkowitz
1336 5/19/2008 Email from Alex Acosta toJay Lefkowitz responding to Lefkowitz email
1337 5/19/2008
Kirkland & Ellis LIP, Response to letter by FAUSA Sloman dated 5/19/2008 -
10 pages (RFP8)
B-38 5/27/2008
Emails between Bob Senior, Jell Montan, Marie Villafana, and Karen Atkinson
regarding indictment review and no further plea negotiations
B39 5/27/2008
Emails between Marie Villarafia and Karen Atkinson regarding report of new state
pica deal
PRIVILEGED and CONFIDENTIAL Page 5 of 10 CONTAINS 6(c) MATERIAL
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MARIE V1LLAFANA
&Wait # Date Description
B-40 5/29/2008
Email from Jell Sloman to Marie Villafafta, Bob Senior, Karen Atkinson, E.
Nesbitt KtnTkendaII, and Jason Richards informing them that l)AG Filip agreed
to review matter and that grand jury presentation was canceled
13-41 8/28/2008
Letter front Michael Danchuk to Marie Villafaila regarding victim representation
and filing suit against Epstein in state court
13-42 4/9/2008 Mai is Villafana letter to Richard II. Willits (formatting problem)
13-43 6/18/2008 Marie Villalana handwritten notes re calls with Brad Ed wards and Roy Black
B-44 6/23/2008 John Roth letter to Kan Starr and Jay Lelkowitt
13-45 6/24/2008 Em.ias between Roy Black, Jack Goldberger, and Marie Villafaiia re wrap up
13-46 6/25/2008
Email from Jcff Montan to Marie Villafafia regarding conversation about 225.5
issue and enui of guilt' plea
1147 6/25/2008
Email from Jeff Sloman to Marie %Adana with attached revised victim
notification letter
13-48 6/25/2008
Entails between Marie Villafaila,JcITSIontan, Bob Senior, Karen Atkinson, and
Alex Acosta regarding draft of notification of victim list for Jeffrey Epstein counsel
with attached drafts
13-49 6/23/2008
Entails betweenJeff Sloman, Bob Senior, and Marie Vitt& instructing Marie
Villafana to inform Epstein's attorneys that lie had untiLlune 30 to enter a guilty
plea and Villafaita email to Lelkowitz re same.
13-50 6/26/2008 Fax from FBI with final victim list
B-51 6/27/2008 Confirmation from police and Epstein's counsel of plea on 6/30/2008
13-52 6/27/2008 Email from Villafaiia to Sloman inquiring about conversation with Chief Reiter.
13-53 6/28/2008
Entails between Villafafm andJeff Montan regarding Chief Reiter providing
notifications to victims.
B-54 1W7 /2007
Email fmmJeff Montan to Marie Villafana instructing her not to send victim
notification letter
13-55 6/30/2008
Notes from calls with attonwys M. Danchuk, R. Willits, J. Herman, B. Edwards.
T. Leopokl, and M. Dutko
13,56 6/80/2008 Draft notification of identified victims letters
13-57 7/8/2008 Letter from Marie %Palatal., to Jack Goldberger re victim notification letter
1348 7/8/2008 Letter from Jack Goklberger to Marie Villafaiia that he will respond on 7/9/2008
8.59 7/9/2008
Email from Marie Villafafta to Alex Acosta, Jeff Stoma, and Karen Atkinson re
Goldberger letter
11-60 7/9/2008
letter from Marie Villafana to Jack Goldberger regarding notification of identified
victims
13.61 7/9/2008
Letter fromJack Goldberger to Marie Villafaita re notification of identified
victims
B-62 7/10/2008
Letter front Marie Villafana to Jack Goldberger informing him that victim
notifications will be provided on a rolling basis
11-63 7/10/2008
letter front Marie Villafana to Goldberger with final notification of identified
victims
PRIVILEGED and CONFIDENTIAL Page 6 of 10 CONTAINS 6(e) MATERIAL
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MARIE VILLAFANA
Exhibit # Date Description
11-61 7/10/2008 Letter fromJack Goldberger to Marie Villafana requesting list of all victims
11-65 7/10/2008
Email from Jeff Sloman to Marie Villafafta, Alex Acosta, Karen Atkinson, E
Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and Jason Richards regarding proposed response to Jack
Goldberger
15-66 7/9/2008 Victim Notification Letters to inditiduals #35 and 43
13-67 7/10/2008 Victim Notification Letters to individuals #3, 8, 17, 25, 26, 37, and I I
B-68
7/14/2008-
7/15/2008
Emails between Marie Villafana, E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall,Jason Richards. and
Twiler Smith re FBI victim notifications
15-69
7/18/2008-
7/21/2008
Emails between Marie Villafana, Jeff Montan, E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Jason
Richards, Dexter Lee, and Karen Atkinson rc preparation of victim notificatiot I
letters and victim contact list and victims that Miler still needs to make contact
with
13-70 7/21/2008 Victim Notification Letters to individuals NI, 2, 4, 9, IS, 14, 21, 23, 30, 32, and 38
B-71 8/5/2008
Email from Marie Villafaffa to Alex Acostajeff Montan, Bob Senior, and Karen
Atkinson regarding analysis ofJeffrey Epstein agreement, with attached 6/24/2008
email from A. M. Villafafia to R. Black midi. Goldberger and attached Epstein
agreement
13-72 8/5/2008
Email from Alex Acosta to Marie Villafatla, Bob Senior, Jeff Simian, Dexter Lee,
and Karen Atkinson with attached suggestions to Superseding Non-Prosecution
Agreement
13-73 8/7/2008
Email from Roy Black to Marie Villafana responding to 8/7/08 email providing
notification of possible compelled disclosure of the Non-Prosecution Agreement
B-74 8/6/2008
Email response from Bob Senior to Marie Villafaila regarding Roy Black's
response to email
B-75 8/12/2008
Email response from Bob Senior to Marie Villafana to request for conference call
prior to call with Roy Black
B-76 8/13/2008
Email from Bob Senior to Karen Atkinson, Alex Acosta, Jeff Montan, Dexter
Lee, and Marie Villalatla regarding Epstein and call with Jay' Lefkowitz
B-77 8/13/2008
Email response from Alex Acosta to Karen Atkinson, Bob Senior, Jeff Sloman,
Dexter Lee, and Marie \Walt regarding final version of agreement
B-78 8/13/2008 Letter front Marie Villafana to  Lefkowitz regarding performance of the NPA
13-79
8/13/2008-
8/15/2008
Email chain between Alex Acosta, Karen Atkinson, Bob Senior, Jeff Montan,
Dexter Lee, and Marie Villafana regarding scope of Epstein agreement and
correspomletwe and telephone conference with Jay Lefkowitz
B-80 8/14/2008
Email fromJay Lefkowitz to Marie Villafatia and Karen Atkinson re follow up
point regarding victims
15-81 8/15/2008
Etnail from Bob Senior to Alex Acosta, Marie Villalafia,Jeff Sloman, Dexter Lee,
and Kamen Atkinson questioning whether offer shoukl be withdrawn as opposed
to considering it a nullity
B-82 8/15/2008
Email chain between Marie Villafana, Alex Acosta,JeffSbman, Bob Senior,
Karen Atkinson, and Dexter Lee re drat response to 8/15/2008 email fromJay
Lefkowitz regarding implementation of the NPA
PRIVILEGED and CONFIDENTIAL Page 7 of 10 CONTAINS 6(c) MATERIAL
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MARIE VILLAFANA
Exhibit # Date Description
B-83 8/15/2008 Letter from Marie Villafaiia to Jay Lelkowitz and Roy Black re terms of NPA
8-84 8/18/2008 Letter fromJay tellowitz to Marie Villafana regarding restitution
B-85 8/21/2008
Letter from Marie Villafaila to Jay I elkowilz and Roy Black re Special Master and
draft Notification of Identified Victim
B-86 8/22/2008
Letter from lay Lelkowitz to Marie Villafana regarding misstatements in 8/21/08
VilliditIR letter
B-87 8/26/2008 Letter from Marie Villafaila to Jay Lelkowitz and Roy Black re victim's list
8-88 9/2/2008
Letter from Jay Lclkowitz to Marie Villafana agreeing that Goldberger should be
listed as the contact person for civil suits and re victim representativeJosefsberes
fees
B-89 9/2/2008
Mailed Amended Victim Notification letters to #1 )12, #3 (via Richard H. Willits),
#4, #13, #8 friaJeffrey Herman), #9, #10, #11, #14, #16, #I7 (via Theodore
Leopold), #20, #21, #23, #24, #25 (viaJelfrey Herman), #26 biaJellity Herman),
#30, #31, #32, #33, #37 (via Michael E. Dutko), #38, #44 biaJeffni Herman)
8-90 9/W2008
Victim notification letters to #36, #35 (via Brad Edwards), #42, #43 (via Brad
Edwards)
B-9I 9/12/2008 Notification of Identified Victim letter #39
B-92 9/15/2008 Mailed victim notification letters for #I8 and #32
15-93
9/17/2008-
11/4/2008 Entails and coorespondence with 'Ilie Florida Bar re victim notifications
B-94 11/14/2008 Notification of Identified Victim letters to #20, #40
13-95 12/4/2008
Email from Karen Atkinson to Marie Villafaila in response to draft letter notifying
victims of Epstein's work release
B-96 12/5/2008
Email from Marie Villafaila to victim's attorneys with attached Work Release
Notice
15-97 12/8/2008
Notification of NVotk Release letters to Spencer Kuvin,Jack Scuola, Michael
Dutko, #11,1439 and #40
B-98 12/9/2008
Notification of Work Release letters to #4, #10, #16, #I8, #23, #24, #33, #38, #30
(personal note), #42
B-99
12/12/2008-
12/29/2008 Entails with attorneys for victims regarding Epstein work release
11-100 12/12/2008 Notification of Work Release letter to #42
B-101 12/12/2007
Entails between Marie Villafana, Frederica Devlin, and Bob Senior regarding
planning indictment review
B-102 1/7/2008
Email From Marie Villafaaa to Alex Acosta,Jeff Montan, Bob Senior, Karen
Atkinson, and Rolando Gant regarding proposed additional investigative steps in
Epstein case
13-103
1/9/20081/14/2008
Entails between Marie Villafaiia, Drew Oosterbaan, Myesha Braden, Nesbitt
Kuyrkendall, an dJason Richards regarding assigning a CEOS attorney to the
investigation, meeting with the CEOS attorney and victims in Florida, the results
of the meetings and planned additional meetings, and revisions to the indictment
in light of the meetings
II -104 1/10/2008
Email chain between Myesha Braden and Marie Villafaita regarding meeting on
1/11/2008
B-10.5 1/14/2008
Entail chain between Myesha Braden, Marie Villafafia, E. Nesbitt Kuyrkeimlall,
and Jason Richards regarding meeting and additional 302s
PRIVILEGED and CONFIDENTIAL. Page 8 410 CONTAINS 6(e) MATERIAL
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MARIE VILLAFANA
Exhibit It Date Description
B-106 1/I7/2008 Agents compile evidence for Bob Senior indictment review
B-107 1/25/2008
Email chain between Myesha Braden and Marie Villafafia regarding victim's
names in indictment
B-108 1/31/2008 Additional grand jury subpoenas
B-109
1/28/20082/1/2008
Entails between Marie Villafana,Jeff Sloman, Alex Acosta, Nesbit Kuyrkendall,
Jason Richards, and Alan Santiago regarding results of additional victim-witness
interviews and requesting intervention with CEOS to move review process along
B-I 10
2/12/2008-
2/22/2008
Entails between Marie Villafana, E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Jason Richards, and
Myesha Braden re information for indictment/ongoing investigation
B-111
2/20/2008-
W21/2008
Entails between Drew Oosterbaan, Marie Villatana, Robert Senior,Jeff Montan,
Sigal Mandelker, Karen Atkinson, Alex Acosta, Rolando Garcia and Myesha
Braden regarding status of CEOS plans to meet with counsel for Epstein and
status of indictment review
B-112 245/2008
Email chain between Marie Villafana and Caroline regarding use of Grand
Jury
B-113 2/25/2008
Email from Marie Villafafia toJeffSlontan, Bob Senior, Rolando Garcia, Karen
Atkinson, and Myesha Braden re staying with same grand jury or present to a
different gnmd jury
13-114 2/26/2008
Email front Marie Villatana to Myesha Braden re CEOS independent review and
concern about victim's mulles being released
B-115 2/26/2008
Email response from Marie Villatalia to Jeff Sloman and Bob Senior with
concerns regarding allowing Epstein to keep the same deal as before
13-116 2/27/2008
Email chain between Marie Villatana, David Weinstein, and Bob Senior re email
to the Civil Rights Chief
B-117 2/2W2008
Email chain between Marie Villatanajason Richards, and E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall
regarding further investigation
B-118 2/29/2008
Entails betweenJeff Montan, Marie Villatafia, Robert Senior, and David
Weinstein regarding continuing investigation and status of CEOS review
B-119 3/12/2008
Email from E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall to Marie Villafafia re affidavit for memory
cards
B-I20 3/17/2008 Two search warrants for digital camera memory cards
13-121 3/5/2008
Entails between Marie Villafafia and E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall with attached email
to Alex Acosta, Jeff Montan, Drew Oosterbaan, Robert Senior, Myesha Braden,
Rolando Garcia, and Karen Atkinson regarding meeting in DC, additional
information to prepare for meeting, and new information from ongoing
investigation
B-122 3/14/2008
Entails between Marie Villafafia, Rolando Garcia, Karen Atkinson, Frederica
Devlin, and Shawn Ball regarding complete indictment package for Robert Senior
fatal review
B-123 6/3/2008 Letter from Jeff Sloman to Deputy Attorney General Mark Filip with auachmems
B-124
4/21/2008-
5/9/2008
Emits between Marie Villataila,Jeff Sloman, Karen Atkinson, Bob Senior, E.
Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Jason Richards, and Drew Oosterbaan re status of grand jury
presentation. and ongoing investigation, and delay
PRIVILEGED and CONFIDENTIAL. Page 9 of 10 CONTAINS 6(c) MATERIAL
EXHIBITS TO WRITTEN RESPONSE OF A. MARIE VILLAFASA
Exhibit N Date Description
5/15/2008- Entails between Marie Villafana, Karen Atkinson. Bob Sentor,JeliSloman. am I
13-125 5/27/2008 agents regarding indictment review and status of investigation
13-126 5/30/2008 FBI-302 of 5/28/08 Interview of Individual #35
6/2/2008 4:25 pm Draft letter from Jeff Sloman to Deputy Attorney General
13-127 6/2/2008 Mark Hip
6/3/2008 10:40 am Draft letter fromJcff Sloman to Deputy Attorney General
B-128 6/3/2008 Mark Hip
Entails between Villafana and Kuyrkendall re subpoena issued to victimfwitness
13-129 6/6/2008 and need for additional subpoenas
13-130 6/17/2008 Application for 6001 immunity for grand jury witness
Letter from Matthew W. Friedrich, Acting Assistant Attorney General.
B-131 6/24/2008 authorizing application for a court order granting 6001 int:marl
B-B2 6/20/2008 Request to travel to York for witness interviews in June 2008 and subpoena
Entails between A. Marie Villafaria, E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, J. Richards, K.
Atkinson, and R. Senior regarding grand jury time, witness subpoena, and
B-133 6/23/2008 indictment
6/23/2008- Entails between Marie Villalirna and attorney for grand jury witness regarding
1 t-I34 6/26/2008 immunity and travel for grand jury appearance
Entails between Marie Villafana and attorney for grand jury witness withdrawing
13-135 6/30/2008 subpoena
c'- i 1/31/2008 Email from Marie Villafana to Jeff Mon tan and Alex Acosta regarding victims
Email chain between Marie Villafana, David Weinstein,Jeff Montan, Bob Senior,
Karen Atkinson, and Rolando Garcia with Epstein update from grand jury
presentation and grant front theJustice Department to provide legal
C-2 3/19/2008 representation to victims
3/19/2008-
C-3 3/22/2008 rattails regarding victims being harassed by Epstein's investigators
Draft of entail to be sent to Jeff and Matt stating that Villalana disagrees with
promising to have a meeting with Lel-court or any of Epstein's other attorneys.
5/22/2007-
Believes the prior meeting disclosed prosecution strafe*. and holding another
meeting will disclose even more. If meeting is held, Villafalia will ask to have the
case reassigned. Attached email correspondence between Andrew Lourie and G.
O4 5/23/2007 Lefcourt
Email from Matt Menchal to Marie Villatana and Andrew Louric regarding not
C-5 .5/14/2007 having approval to proceed with an indictment or complaint
10/3/2007- Entail chain between Marie Villafana, Jeff Montan, and Jay Lefkonitz regarding
C-6 10/5/2007 appointing special master
10/16/2007- Entails between Marie Villafana,Jeff Montan, Alex Acosta, and* Lelkowitz
C-7 10/28/2007 regarding Special Master
PRIVILMED and CONFIDENTIAL. Page 10 of 10 CONTAINS 6(e) MATERIAL
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
5/1/2006
State Attorney • ga y E B
' Krischer
Michael S.
Reiter, Chief of
Police for Town
of Palm Beach
Letter urging State Attorney to proceed with probable cause affidavits and cast
filing packages or to recuse himself
i
5/23/2006 File Opening Documents for Operation Leap Year 2
7/24/2006
Michael S.
Reiter, Chief of
Police for Town
of Palm Beach
Letter noting that Palm Beach Police Chief was unhappy with State Attorney's
handling of case and was referring matter to the FBI for investigation
7/26/2006 South Florida Sun-Sentinel Article Regarding Chief Reiter's referral of case to
FBI
_
8/2/2006 Subpoena to Colonial Bank (return date 8/18/06)
8/2/2006 Subpoena to Washington Mutual (return date 8/18/06)
8/2/2006 Subpoena to Capital One (return date 8/18/06)
8/2/2006 Subpoena to Chase (return date 8/18/06)
8/2/2006 Subpoena to Hyperion Air, Inc. (return date 8/18/06)
8/2/2006 Subpoena to JEGE, Inc. (return date 8/18/06)
8/2/2006 Subpoena to David Neville Rodgers (return date 8/18/06)
8/2/2006 Subpoena to DTG Operations d/b/a Dollar Rent-a-car (return date 8/18/06)
8/2/2006 Subpoena to Royal Palm Beach Community High School (return date
8/18/06)
8/2/2006 Subpoena to Custodian of Records 15th Judicial District (return date 8/18/06)
8/4/2006
Victim Notification letters to Individuals #6, #9, #10, #11, #13, #15, #17,
#18, #20, #23, #24, #25, #26, #27, #28, #29, #30, #31, #32, #38, #39,
#41, #42, and #44
1:!
8/11/2006 Victim Notification letters to Individuals #4, #5, #6, #9, #12, #13, #15, #19.
#26, #28, #29, #31, #32, #34, #38, #39, #43, and #44
8/15/2006 Subpoena to (withdrawn) (return date 8/25/06)
Privileged Confidential Page 1 of SI Contains 6(e) Material
CVUIDIT A 1
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
8/15/2006 Subpoena to Individual #4 (return date 8/25/06)
8/15/2006 Subpoena to Individual #28 (return date 8/25/06)
8/15/2006 Subpoena to Individual #44 (withdrawn) (return date 8/25/06)
8/23/2006 Subpoena to Individual #4 (return date 9/1/06)
8/23/2006 Subpoena to Individual #28 (return date 9/1/06)
8/23/2006 Subpoena to Reimer Employment Agency (return date 9/1/06)
8/23/2006 Subpoena to Evidence Custodian Palm Beach Police Department (return date
9/1/06)
8/24/2006 Villafalia Jim Eisenberg Email re Individual #28 9
8/28/2006 Subpoena to Custodian of Records State Attorney's Office (return date
9/15/06)
8/28/2006 Subpoena to Custodian of Records 15th Judicial District (return date 9/15/06)
9/13/2006 Subpoena to Good Samaritan Hospital (return date 9/ 22/06)
9/21/2006 Subpoena to The Dalton School (return date 9/29/09)
9/26/2006
Acosta,
Mulvihill,
Sloman, Noto,
Waters, L°urie' Stefin, Atkinson,
Garcia, Brown,
Boscovich,
Martinez
Villafaila Memo regarding changes to Child Explotation Statutes in Tide 18 16
10/19/2006 Subpoena to Individual #28 (return date 10/27/06)
10/24/2006 Email chain between Villafaiia and Jim Eisenberg discussing Individual #28 9
10/30/2006 Villafatia Guy Lewis Email re representation of Jeffrey Epstein 10
10/31/2006 Villafatia Guy Lewis Email chain to set up call 10
11/8/2006 Lourie, Villafana ' cc: Menchel Sloman Email re Lilly Ann Sanchez/representation of Jeffrey Epstein
Privileged Confidential Page 2 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
11/13/2006 Subpoena to Bill Hammond (pilot) (return date 12/1/06)
11/13/2006 Subpoena to Larry Visoski (pilot)(return date 12/1/06)
11/13/2006 Subpoena to Janusz Banasiak (property manager)(retum date 12/1/06)
11/13/2006 Subpoena to Adriana Mucinska (former assistant) (return date 12/1/06) 15
I 1/15/2006 A. Marie
Villafalia
Lilly Ann
Sanchez
Gerald Lefcourt from New York and Lilly Ann Sanchez will be dealing with
the U.S. Attorney's Office in the Jeffrey Epstein matter 11
11/16/2006 Lilly Ann
Sanchez

A. Marie
Viilafan_a Request for documents and information necessary to the investigation
11/17/2006 Subpoena to Extra Touch Flowers (return date 2/6/07)
11/21/2006 Lilly Ann
Sanchez

A. Marie
Villafaria Requesting a meeting to discuss 11/16/06 letter 11
11/29/2006 Lilly Ann
Sanchez
A. Marie
Villafafia
AUSA Villafatia will be out of district and will not be available for meeting
during the proposed dates, but will schedule the meeting when she returns. 11
I 2/1/2006 A. Marie
Villafalia
Lilly Ann
Sanchez
Will check on the document requests and will schedule the meeting in the new
year. 11
12/18/2006 Subpoena to Janusz Banasiak (property manager) (return date 1/12/07)
12/18/2006 Subpoena to (former assistant) (return date 1/12/07) 15
12/18/2006 Subpoena to Anthony Figueroa (return date 1/12/07)
1/5/2007 A. Marie
Villafatia
Lilly Ann

cl. inchez Request for dates and times to schedule meeting 11
1/8/2007 Lilly Ann
Sanchez
A. Marie
Vaifan_a Request for documents prior to setting meeting 1
1/17/200 - Lilly Ann
Sanchez
Andrew Lourie
Client wants to cooperate with the investigation, but requests for documents
were overly broad. Provided shortened and narrowed list and request for
documents to be provided by 1/25/07, so they could be reviewed prior to
2/1/07 meeting.
Privileged Confidential Page 3 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
1/18/2007 A. Marie
Villafaiia
Lilly Ann
Sanchez
Because of the Palm Beach Police Department and the State Attorney's . investigation for almost two years, Epstein hired
counsel for all employees so
contact Ms. Sanchez for contact information for the attorneys.
I /22/2007 Andrew Lourie Sanchez
Looking forward to the 2/1/07 meeting and expect to send documents
previously provided to the Palm Beach County State Attorney's Office by
1/25/07.
I I
1/22/2007 Research re NPAs and 6001 immunity I c
1/23/2007 Lilly Ann
Sanchez
A. Marie
Nrillafafia
Request for a list of the individuals who have accepted Epstein's offer of
payment for representation and the names of their attorneys.
2/1/2007 A. Marie
Villafafia
Gerald B.
Lefcourt Talking points and documents for 2/1/07 meeting 4
2/5/2007 A. Marie
Villafatia
Gerald B.
Lefcourt
Production of debit/credit card statement regarding Epstein's birthday and a
purchase at Guys and Dolls made by Individual #18.
2/6/2007 Grand Jury Testimony of E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall I -
2/12/2007 A. Marie
Villafana
Lilly Ann
Sanchez
Emails between Villafana and Lilly Ann Sanchez regarding employee
representation with Laurie and Villafana handwritten notes 58
2/14/2007 Subpoena to Colonial Bank (return date 3/6/07)
2/14/2007 Subpoena to Palm Beach National Bank (return date 3/6/07)
2/14/2007 Subpoena to Western Union (return date 3/6/07)
2/14/2007 Subpoena to Western Union (return date 3/6/07)
2/14/2007 Subpoena to JP Morgan Chase (return date 3/6/07)
2/20/2007 Meeting (US: Andy Laurie, Marie Villafana, and Junior Ortiz, DEF: Lilly
Sanchez and Gerald Lefcourt)
2/23/2007 A. Marie
Villafaiia
Gerald B.
Lefcourt
Excerpts of drafts of transcripts from recorded interviews of various witnesses
taken during state's investigation.
2/27/2007 Grand Jury Testimony of E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall 18
3/2/2007 Subpoena to Thomas Rofrano (return date 3/13/07)
3/2/2007 Subpoena to Johanna Sjoberg (return date 3/13/07)
3/2/2007 Subpoena to Christina (return date 3/13/07)
3/2/2007 Subpoena to Palm Beach County Health Dept (return date 3/13/07)
3/2/2007 Subpoena to Perry Bard, DC (return date 3/13/07)
Privileged Confidential Page 4 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit # 3/15/2007 Victim Notification letter to Individual #4 19 3/16/2007 Subpoena to Individual #29
(return date 3/27/07)
3/20/2007 Grand Jury Testimony of E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall 20 3/20/2007 Subpoena to Individual #32 (return date 4/3/07)
3/22/2007 Villafatia Stefan Cassella Email re money laundering question 56
4/4/2007 Subpoena to Individual #37 (return date 4/17/07)
4/16/2007 Subpoena to Chase Bank USA, NA Atm: Jeff Sehr (return date 4/24/07)
4/16/2007 Subpoena to Adult Video Warehouse (return date 5/1/07)
4/16/2007 Subpoena to Eve's Garden (return date 5/1/07)
4/17/2007 Subpoena to Individual #28 (return date 5/1/07)
4/20/2007 Subpoena to Adult Video Warehouse (return date 5/1/07)
4/24/2007 Grand Jury Testimony of Special Agent E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall 21 4/24/2007 Grand Jury Testimony of Individual 
#37 22
4/24/2007 Subpoena to New York Strategy Group, LLC Custodian of Records (return
date 5/8/07)
4/24/2007 Subpoena to Hyperion Air, Inc. Custodian of Records (return date 5/8/07)
4/24/2007 Subpoena to JEGE, Inc. (return date 5/8/07)
5/8/2007 Grand Jury presentation materials 23 5/8/2007 Grand Jury Testimony of E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall 24 5/8/2007 Grand 
Jury Testimony of Jason Richards 25
5/10/2007 A. Marie
Villafatia
Jack A.
Goldberger Response to subpoenas JEGE, Inc. and Hyperion Air, Inc..
5/14/2007
Marie Villafatia
and Andrew
Lourie
Matthew
Menchel
Email re Operation Leap Year with email from Villafatia to Lourie and
Menchel (5/14/07) attached 26/C-5
5/15/2007 Grand Jury Testimony of Special Agent E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall 27 5/16/2007 Subpoena to American Express TRS 
Co., Inc. (return date 5/29/07)
5/17/2007 A. Marie
Villafafia
Jack A.
Goldberger
Extension of compliance deadlines until 5/29/07 for subpoena responses for
JEGE, Inc. and Hyperion Air, Inc.
Privileged Confidential Page 5 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
5/18/2007 Matthew
Menchel

A. Marie
Villafatia
Email informing Menchel of intent to subpoena Roy Black's private
investigator and steps taken to obtain DOJ authorization 26
5/21/2007
Matthew
Menchel and Jeff
Sloman

A. Marie
Villafatia Email seeking guidance on grand jury presentation 26/54
5/21/2007 Subpoena to Paul A. Lavery (return date 5/29/07) 59
5/22/2007 Andrew Cootie Gerald B.
Lefcourt
Letter requesting to meet with Matthew Menchel and Jeffrey Sloman and \ lc\
Acosta prior to an indictment being filed
5/22/2007
Matthew
Menchel and Jeff
Sloman; cc: A.
Marie Villafalia
Andrew Laurie Email re letter received from Gerald Lefcourt discussing a meeting to discuss
Epstein investigation
5/22/2007 Grand Jury Testimony of Special Agent E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall '()
5/23/2007 Karen Atkinson A. Marie
Villafaila
Draft of email to be sent to Sloman and Menchel stating that Villafatia
disagrees with promising to have a meeting with Lefcourt or any of Epstein's
other attorneys. Believes the prior meeting disclosed prosecution strategy and
holding another meeting will disclose even more. If meeting is held, Villafaiii
will ask to have the case reassigned. Attached email correspondence between
Andrew Laurie and G. Lefcourt
28/C-4
5/31/2007 Subpoena to J. Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation, Inc. (return date 6/21/07)
5/31/2007 Subpoena to J. Epstein & Company, Inc. (return date 6/21/07)
5/31/2007 Subpoena to Epstein Interests (return date 6/21/07)
5/31/2007 Sub_poena to Financial Trust Company, Inc. (return date 6/12/07)
5/31/2007
Subpoena to Royal Palm Beach Community High School (return date
6/12/07)
6/1/2007 Gerald B.
Lefcourt

A. Marie
Villafaiia
Subpoenas for J. Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation, Inc., J. Epstein & Co.,
Inc., Epstein Interests, and Financial Trust Company, Inc.
6/1/2007
Folder entitled "(Victims) Additional 302's" containing reports of interviews
conducted in June 2007, October 2007, and March 2008
Privileged Confidential Page 6 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
6/7/2007 Victim Notification letters to Individuals #3, #9, #31, #38, #40, and #43 30
6/7/2007 Subpoena to Park A. Cadillac Limo Service (return date 6/26/07)
6/11/2007 Subpoena to Individual #40 (return date 6/26/07)
6/11/2007 Subpoena to All Star Taxi and Limo Service (return date 6/26/07)
6/11/2007 Subpoena to Airport Executive Towncar Service Dan Tischler (return date
6/26/07)
6/12/2007 A. Marie
Villafafia Gerald Lefcourt
Production response to 5/31/07 subpoenas to J. Epstein Virgin Islands
Foundation, Inc., J. Epstein & Co., Inc., Epstein Interests, and Financial Trust
Company, Inc.
6/13/2007 Subpoena to Majestic Theatre (return date 6/06/07)
6/13/2007 Subpoena to Broward Center for the Performing Arts (return date 6/26/07)
6/13/2007 Subpoena to Kravis Center for the Performing Arts (return date 6/26/07)
6/14/2007 31
6/14/2007-6/21/2007 Emails between Marie Villafaiia, Karen Atkinson,
Andrew Lourie, Matt Menchel, and Jeff Sloman regarding addendum to Pros
Memo, grand jury presentation and changes to indictment, and meeting with
counsel for Epstein
6/18/2007 Gerald B.
Lefcourt

A. Marie
Villafaiia
tt. Leer thanking Lefcourt for accepting service of subpoena addressed to the
Custodian of Records of NES, LLC and requesting acceptance of subpoena
issued to New York Strategy Group, Inc.
6/18/2007 Subpoena to William Riley (return date 7/10/07) 60
6/18/2007 Subpoena to Riley Kiraly (return date 7/10/07) 6I
6/18/2007 Subpoena to NES, LLC (return date 7/10/07)
6/21/2007 Matthew
Menchel

A. Marie
Villafafia
Email re Meeting next week with emails from Menchel to Villafaiia (6/21/07)
and Viliafaiia to Menchel (6/21/07) attached
,
6/22/2007 Subpoena to Guys and Dolls (return date 7/10/07)
6/25/2007
Jeffrey Sloman
and Andrew
_ Lourie
Gerald B.
12fcourt
Letter containing overview of position of Epstein's counsel and the materials
planned to present at 6/26/07 meeting with handwritten attorney (Villafatia)
notes
Privileged Confidential Page 7 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
6/25/2007
Man Mcnchel
and Marie
Villafatia
Andrew Lourie Email entitled "Thoughts on Lefcourt's letter" 32
6 /26/2007
Meeting (US: Jeff Slotnan, Matt Manche', Marie Villafaila, Junior Ortiz,
Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, DEF: Alan Dershowitz, Roy Black, Gerald Lefcourt and
Lilly Sanchez)
6 2-  2007
Subpoena to Live Nation Theatrical/Broadway Across America (return date
7/10/07)
7/1/2007 Sanchez,
Lefcourt Villafana Email re oustanding subpoenas and planned meeting for 7/11/07
7/3/2007
7/3/2007-7/13/2007 Email chain between Matt Menchel and Marie Villafalia
regarding disagreement on Menchel's plea negotiations and written request for
meeting between USAO management and victims
7/3/2007
7/3/2007-7/4/2007 Emails between Marie Villafaiia and Andrew Lourie
regarding extension of time to respond to subpoenas requested by Lilly Ann
Sanchez and possible resolution of case
7/6/2007
Jeffrey Sloman
and Andrew
Lourie
Gerald B.
Lefcourt and
Alan
Dershowitz
Follow-up letter to 6/26/07 meeting including facts, law, and policy that
should inform any decision made on how and whether to proceed 33
7/13/2007 Villafaila Roy Black Letter with handwritten attorney (Lourie) notes 34
7/13/2007 Matthew
Menchel

A. Marie
Villafana
Email re Epstein with email from Menchel (7/5/07), Villafana to Marche'
(7/4/07) and Sloman to Villafana (7/3/07) attached 3
7/16/ 2007 Black Villafatia Response to letter regarding subpoena to Paul Lavery for computer equipment
removed from Epstein's residence
7/16/2007
Matt Menchel
and Andrew
Lourie
A. Marie
Villafatia
Email regarding correspondence from Roy Black and Motion to Quash Lavery
subpoena
7/17/2007
Motion of Jeffrey Epstein to Intervene and Quash Grand Jury Subpoenas and
Incorporated Memorandum of Law
Privileged Confidential Page 8 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
7/17/2007
Affidavit of Roy Black, Esq., in Support of Motion of Jeffrey Epstein to
Intervene and to Quash Grand Jury Subpoenas and Incorporated
Memorandum of Law
7/18/2007
Andrew Laurie
and Matt
Menchel
Marie Villafana Email from Villafafia to Matt Menchel regarding Roy Black objection to
subpoenas subpoenas addressed to William Riley and Riley Kiraly
7/19/2007 Villafana Mille Levy
(USAPAE)
Email regarding comments to Rule 16 about disclosing identifying information
about victims
7/19/2007
Email chain between Marie Villafaiia, Andrew Lourie, Matt Menchel, S/A
Jason Richards and S/A Eliasib Ortiz regarding potential service of target
letters
7/1 9/ 2007 Preparing Motion for Post-indictment protective order
7/24/2007 Subpoena to Rachel Eve Lockwood (return date 8/14/07)
7/25/2007 Matthew
Menchel
Gerald B.
Lefcourt and
Alan
Dershowitz
Document entitled: "Data that strongly supports the arguments made that no
charge can or should be made under 18 U.S.C. § 2422(b)" 35
7/26/2007
Matt Menchel
and Andrew
Laurie
Marie Villafatia Email regarding proposed changes to indictment 3e 6 I
7/26/2007
Meeting where Criminal Chief Menchel announces that USA Acosta will offer
a two-year state plea. Present: Matt Menchel, Marie Villafafia, Andy Lowrie
(phone), Valerie Parlave, Junior Ortiz, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and Jason
Richards
7/27/2007 Research re 18 U.S.C. § 2255 37
7/31/2007
Jeff Sloman,
Matt Menchel,
and Andrew
Laurie
Marie Villafafia Email summarizing proposed plea terms as per Menchel recommendation 4 and 38
7/31/2007
Meeting (US: Jeff Sloman, Matt Menchel, Marie Villafatia, Andy Laurie,
Nesbitt Kuyrkendall and Jason Richards, DEF: Roy Black, Gerald Lefcourt
and Lilly Sanchez)
Privileged Confidential Page 9 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
7/31/2007
U.S. Response to Motion of Jeffrey Epstein to Intervene and to Quash Grand
Jury Subpoenas and Cross-Motion to Compel and Sealed Document Tracking
Form with Sealed, Ex Parte Declarations
7/31/2007
7/31/2007-8/3/2007 Email chain between Jeff Sloman, Matt Menchel,
Andrew Lourie, and Marie Villafaiia regarding plea negotiations 39
8/1/2007
8/1/2007-8/2/2007 Emails between Menchel and Villafaiia regarding plea
negotiations
8/2/2007 Matthew
Menchel
Lilly Ann
Sanchez
As discussed at meeting, Epstein is prepared to resolve the matter via state
forum. Proposal of 2 years supervised custody with two additional years of
reporting to probation
8 and 40
8/2/2007
Emails between Matt Menthe', Jeff Sloman, Andy Louric, and Marie Villafana
regarding letter received from Lilly Ann Sanchez
8/3/2007 Lilly Ann
Sanchez
Matthew
Menchel
2 year term of incarceration is a non-negotiable minimum and U.S.Attomey
Acosta is not inclined to meet with counsel for Epstein. Epstein must advise
of his decision by 8/17/07.
8/3/2007
Matt Menchel,
Andrew Louie,
Jeff Sloman,
Karen Atkinson
Marie Villafaria Email regarding draft response to correspondence from Epstein counsel and
planned investigative steps if agreement cannot be reached i I
8/6/2007
Cyndee Campos,
Frederica Devlin
and Jeff Sloman
Marie Villa feta Emails regarding Matt Menchel's correspondence prior to his departure ; ,
8/6/2007 Subpoena to Individual #3 (return date 8/21/07)
8/6/2007 Subpoena to Individual #43 (return date 8/12/07)
8/7/2007 Andy Lourie Marie Villafana Email regarding deadline set for Epstein plea and Epstein's plan to demand a
meeting with CEOS I 1
8/7/2007
Email chain between Marie Villafalia, Cyndee Campos, and Alex Acosta
regarding meeting to discuss Epstein matter
41,
Privileged Confidential Page 10 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
8/7/2007 Email chain from Jeff Sloman to Andrew Oosterbaan, Marie Villafaiia, and
Alex Acosta regarding Epstein meeting 43
8/7/2007
Reply of Jeffrey Epstein to United States' Response to His Motion to
Intervene and to Quash Grand Jury Subpoenas and Cross-Motion to Compel
and Sealed Document Tracking Form
8/8/2007 Andrew
Oosterbaan Marie Villafaiia Email regarding plea negotiations, guideline calculations, and assistance in
preparing case for trial 43
8/8/2007 Research re 18 U.S.C. § 2255 37 8/15/2007 Subpoena to Bear Stearns (return date 9/4/07)
8/16/2007 Subpoena to Adam Perrylang (return date 9/4/07)
8/16/2007 Subpoena to Lesley Groff (return date 9/4/07)
8/16/2007 Subpoena to Jean -Luc Brunel (return date 9/4/07)
8/16/2007 Subpoena to Harry Beller (return date 9/11/07)
8/16/2007 Subpoena to Eric Gany (return date 9/11/07)
8/17/2007 Motion of William Riley and Riley Kiraly for an Extension of Time Nunc Pro
Tunc to File Their Reply and Proposed Order
8/17/2007
Reply of William Riley and Riley Kiraly to the Government's Response to the
Motion to Intervene and to Quash Grand Jury Subpoenas and Cross Motion
to Compel
8/23/2007 A. Made
Villafaiia Gerald Lefcourt Letter that he cannot accept service for Eric Gany
8/28/2007 A. Marie
Villafaiia
Nathan Z.
Dershowitz
Left messages with Sarah Kellen and to request if he can
accept service on their behalf
8/30/2007
Jeff Sloman,
Andrew Laurie,
Drew
Oosterbaan,
John McMillan,
Karen Atkinson
Marie Villa fana I imail regarding press coverage of meeting with Ken Starr
Privileged Confidential Page I I of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
8/30/2007
United States Surreply to Replies filed by Witness William Riley and
Intervenor Jeffrey Epstein re Motion to Quash Grand Jury Subpoenas and
Scaled Document Tracking Form and Supplemental Ex Parte Declaration
8/31/2007
Meeting (US: Drew Oosterbaan, Marie Villafalia, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall and
Jason Richards)
9/4/2007 Jeff Sloman Marie Villafaiia
9/4/2007-9/6/2007 Emails between Jeff Sloman and Marie Villafalia
regarding planned participation of FBI ASAIC at 9/7/07 meeting with
Epstein defense team
9/6/2007 A. Marie
Villafaiia Gerald 121Court Beller and Gany are represented by Nat Dershowitz. NES is working on
getting the extra documents requested and the certification.
9/6/2007 Nathan Z.
Dershowitz

A. Marie
Villafana Questioning representation of Sarah Kellen and
9/6/2007 Nathan Z.
Dershowitz
A. Marie
Villafaiia
Subpoena for Leslie Groff to appear for Grand Jury on 9/ 18/07 and
anticipated topics
9/6/2007 Nathan Z.
Dershowitz

A. Marie
vigafana Subpoenas for Harry Beller and Eric Gany to appear before GJ on 9/11/07.
9/7/2007 9:31 am draft Plea Agreement
9/7/2007 9:43 am draft Non-Prosecution Agreement
9/7/2007 1:15 pm draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
9/ 7/2007 1:17 pm draft Plea Agreement
9/7/2007
Meeting (US: Alexander Acosta, Drew Oosterbaan, Jeff Sloman, Marie
Villafalia, and John McMillan, DFF: Kenneth Starr, Jay Lefkowitz, and Lilly
Sanchez)
9/10/2007 5:17 pm draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
9/10/2007 J. Sloman A. Marie
Villafaila Email re negotiations 46
9/10/2007 J. Sloman, J.
McMillan
A. Marie
Villafaiia Email re state grand jury proceedings 45
9/10/2007 Jeff Sloman,
Andrew Laurie
A. Marie
Villafatia Email re FBI 45
9/10/2007 Lefcourt Villafafia Email with 4 page NPA attached (RFP3) 47
Privileged Confidential Page 12 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
9/10/2007 Proposed Non -Prosecution Agreement provided to Gerald Lefcourt on
9/10/2007 66
9/10/2007 9/10/2007-9/11/2007 Emails between Marie Villafidia, Alex Acosta, and Jeff
Sloman regarding modifications to the proposed Non -Prosecution Agreement 46
9/10/2007
9/10/2007- 9/ 14/2007 Emails between Marie Villafatia, Andrew Lourie, Jeff
Sloman, Karen Atkinson, Rolando Garcia, Shawn Ball, and Alex Acosta
regarding final plea negotiations, finalizing details with State Attorney's Office
and final revisions to indictment package
9/11/2007 A. Lourie A. Marie
Villafatia Email re meeting with G. Lefcourt with attached correspondence 46
9/11/2007 A. Lourie A. Marie
Villafaiia Email re revised Agreement with attached correspondence 46
9/11/2007 A. Marie
Villafalia . A Lourie Email re scheduling a meeting regarding finalizing the agreement with attached
corresondcnce 46
9/11/2007 A. Marie
Villafatla A. Oosterbaan Email re negotiations with attached correspondence 48
9/11/2007 A. Marie
Villafatia Andrew Lourie
Email regarding revised agreement - Plea to the 3 specified charges, a 30
month sentence, split 20 in jail and 10 in "community control," and agree that
the girls are victims for purposes of damages. Also includes deadlines for a
plea and sentencing date
9/ 11/2007 A. Oosterbaan A. Marie
Villafaiia Email re status of negotiations with attached correspondence 48
9/11/2007 Lefcourt Villafatia Email with 4 page NPA attached .1-
9/11/2007 Proposed Non -Prosecution Agreement incorporating Acosta edits provided to
Gerald Lefcourt on 9/11/2007 67
9/11/2007
Emails between Marie Villafatia, John McMillan, Drew Oosterbaan, Nesbitt
Kuyrkendall, and Jason Richards regarding changes to the draft indictment and
status of plea negotiations
9/11/2007 2:13 pm draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
Privileged Confidential Page 13 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
9/12/2007 A. Marie
Villafatia
Nathan Z.
Dershowitz Ms. Groff will proceed by interview.
9/12/2007
Meeting (US: Andy Lourie, Rolando Garcia and Marie Villafafia, DEF: Jay
Lefkowitz, Gerald Lefcourt and Jack Goldberger, STATE OF FLORIDA:
Barry !Casket and Latina Belohlavek)
9/12/2007

A. Marie
Villafalia; cc:
Andrew Lowrie
Jay Lefkowitz
Email in response to A. Marie Villafafia's email stating that the Office is
satisfied in principle with the agreement, but uncomfortable with the
recommended federal charge due to jurisdiction. Response states that defense
understands the concerns and will work to come up with a mutually acceptable
solution.
9/13/2007

A. Acosta, J.
Sloman, R.
Garcia, K.
Atkinson, A.
Lourie
A. Marie
Villafafia Email re plea negotiations 46
9/13/2007 A. Lourie A. Marie
Villafatia Email re plea negotiations with attached correspondence i6
9/13/2007 A. Lourie A. Marie
Villafafia Email re charging strategy with attached correspondence 46
9/13/2007 A. Marie
Villafatia A. Lourie Email re final negotiations with attached correspondence 46
9/13/2007 A. Marie
Villafafia A. Oosterbaan Email re setting up trust fund k.<
9/13/2007 A. Marie
Villafaila Jay Lefkowitz Misdemeanors 403, 1512(d) and 47 U S.0 223(a)(1)(B) 4')
9/13/2007 A. Marie
Villafaiia Lourie Assault on the plane or conspiracy 46
9/13/2007 A. Oosterbaan A. Marie
Villafaiia Email re trust agreement with attached correspondence 4S
Privileged Confidential Page 14 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
9/13/2007
Andrew Lourie,
Alex Acosta, Jeff
Sloman, Rolando
Garcia, Karen
Atkinson
Manic vfflafitha
in1. ails regarding plea to federal charges recommending 18 U.S.C. 403 or
1512g, or 47 U.S.C. 223(a)(1)(B); response that Epstein was only willing to
plead to assault on the plane; and rejection of facts supporting assault on the
plane charge
9/13/2007 K. Atkinson, S.
Bak). McMillan

A. Marie
Villafatia Email re indictment package In
9/13/2007 R. Garcia, J.
slornan
A. Marie
Villafaria Email re conference call with J. Lefkowitz 46
9/13/2007 Subpoena to Wolf Camera (return date 9/25/07)
9/13/2007 6:36pm draft Plea Agreement
9/13/2007 6:55pm draft Information
9/13/2007 9/13/2007-9/14/2007 Entails regarding Marie Villafaria research regarding
victim trust fund set up in Alaska child exploitation case t•-•
9/13/2007 Additions to pros memo/indictment - Individuals #3, #43, #38, #26, and
#39
9/14/2007 A. Marie
Villafaiia A. Loupe Email re charging strategy with attached correspondence ;6
9/14/2007 A. Marieviihfaria Jay Lefkowitz requesting draft to include 403 in lieu of 1512 .1()
9/14/2007

A. Marie
Villafatia, A.
Acosta , R.
Garcia, A.
Lowrie, K.
Atkinson, S. Ball
J. Sloman Email re finalizing documents 46
Privileged Confidential Page 15 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
9/14/2007

J. Sloman, A.
Acosta, A.
Lourie, It.
Garcia, K.
Atkinson, J.
McMillan, S. Ball
A. Marie
Villafafia Email re plea negotiations In
9/14/2007 Lefkowitz Villafatia Email - 1 page with two plea agreements attached, nine pages total ;9
9/14/2007
Villafafia,
Acosta, Garcia,
Laurie
Sloman Proposed plea agreement and information - Lourie will help finalize .16
9/14/2007 8:47 am draft Information
9/14/2007 8:53 am draft Plea Agreement
9/14/2007 9:38 am draft Information
9/14/2007 9:48 am draft Plea Agreement
9/15/2007 2:29 pm draft Information
9/15/2007 2:46 pm draft Plea Agreement
9/15/2007 Lefkowitz Villafafia Email with attached Information and Plea Agreement 49
9/ 16/2007 Lefkowitz Villafaila Email re 11th Circuit cases on simple assault and found language with attached
Epstein Plea Offer
9/16/2007 Villafafia Lefkowitz Email with attached 5 page Agreement 49
9/ 16/2007
Email chain between Lefkowitz and Villabfia regarding changing the
documents to 1512 and language in the plea agreement 46
9/16/2007 12:00 pm draft Information
9/16/2007 12:09 pm draft Plea Agreement
9/16/2007 12:21_pm Lefkowitz proposed Agreement
9/16/2007 4:42 pm draft Plea Agreement
9/17/2007 A. Acosta A. Marie
Villafafia Email re negotiation 46
9/17/2007 A. Marie
Vi&fails
Al Acosta Please make sure Lefkowitz understands that the Non -Prosecution agreement
ex provided is only a draft and will still need final approval. 46
Privileged Confidential Page 16 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
9/17/2007 A. Marie
Villafana
. Jay Lefkowttz Email requesting obstruction proffer that is already drafted and inquiring
whether deferred prosecution agreement would be made public 49
9/17/2007

A. Marie
Villafalia and
Roy Black; cc:
Gerald Lefcourt,
John McMillan,
Karen Atkinson,
and Andrew
Lourie
. Jay Lefkowitz
Response to email that Jenny from Judge Marra's office spoke with the Judge
and he agreed to take the matter off the calendar. If a plea agreement is
reached, USAO will withdraw the subpoena and Mr. Black will withdraw his
Motion to Quash.
9/17/2007

A. Marie
Villafaiist, R.
Garcia, A.
Lourie, K.
Atkinson, J.
McMillan
A. Acosta Email re draft Agreement with attached correspondence 46
9/17/2007 Jay Lefkowitz A. Marie
Villafaiia
Options for plea: 1. Original agremeent where Epstein pleads only to state
charges and serves his time in state, except that we can agree to only 18
months imprisonment. 2. Epstein pleads guilty to the state charges and also
pleads to either two obstruction counts or to one count of violating 47 U.S.C.
223(a)(1)(B), with a joint non -binding recommendation of 18 months, so that
he can serve his time federally. 3. I go back to the U.S. Attorney and ask him
to agree to an ABA-plea to a 371 count (conspiracy to violate 2422(b)) with a
binding 20-month recommendation so that he can serve all of his time in a
federal facility. 4. Epstein pleads guilty to one obstruction count and serves
part of his time federally and part state.
9/17/2007 Leflcowitz Villafaha- Email informing of removal of hearing on Motion to Quash from Judge
Marra's calendar 49
Privileged Confidential Page 17 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
9/17/2007 R. Garcia, A.
Lourie

A. Marie
Villafaiia Email re negotiation strategy 46
9/ 17/2007 11:39 am draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
9/17/2007 11:42 am draft Non-Prosecution Agreement
9/17/2007
Rolando Garcia
and Andrew
Louric

A. Marie
Villafana- Emailre Epstein providing update re plea negotiations 46
9/17/2007
9/17/2007-9/19/2007 Entails between Marie Villafaiia, Rolando Garcia,
Andrew Lowrie, Alex Acosta, Karen Atkinson, and John McMillan regarding
negotiations of a federal plea and a non-prosecution agreement
9/18/2007

A. Acosta, A.
Louric, R.
Garcia, K.
Atkinson, J.
McMillan
A. Marie
Villafafia Email re negotiating strategy 16
9/18/2007 A. Marie
Villafatia
Acosta, Lourie,
Garcia
Epstein negotiations - you spent 12 hours working on drafts and you are
advising that the end of negotiation is nearing 46
9/18/2007 A. Marie
Villafatia
. I av Lefkowitz '
Email chain regarding draft agreements. Lefkowitz suggests plead to one count
of 1512, serve 12 months plus 1 year home confinement/supervised release,
followed by 2 years of probation with 6 months being community control.
Villafalia advises that USAO will not go below 18 months of prison/jail time.
9/18/2007
Rescheduled date for hearing on motion to quash subpoena for computer
equipment (initially set for 9/13/2007)
9/18/2007
Andrew Louie,
Rolando Garcia' Karen Atkinson

A. Marie
Villafana I:mail re Draft Agreements with email from Jay Lefkowitz (9/18/07) attached 49
9/18/2007 10:45 am draft Plea Agreement
9/18/2007 12:07 pm draft Plea Agreement
Privileged Confidential Page 18 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit # 9/18/2007 12:22 pm draft Plea Agreement
9/18/2007 1:37pm draft Information
9/ 18/2007 Garcia, Villafaiia Lourie Email stating new terms that Louric negotiated with Lefkowitz
9/19/2007

A. Laurie, R.
Garcia, K. A. Marie
Villafana Email re negotiating strategy with attached correspondence l6
9/19/2007 A. A. Marie
Villafaiia A. Laurie Email re Epstein with internal U.S. Attorney's Office emails attached 46
9/19/2007 A. Marie
Villafaria Jay Lefkowitz Forwarded to Laurie and R. Garcia - draft plea agreement issues l6
9/19/2007
Andrew Lourie,
Rolando Garcia,
Karen Atkinson
A. Marie
Villafana
Email re Draft Plea Agreement with email from Lefkowitz to Villafana
(9/19/07) and Lefkowitz to Villafana (9/19/07) attached 46
9/ 19/2007 Research re Federal Bureau of Prisons Designations
9/19/2007 11:46 am draft Information
9/20/2007 Belohlavek,
Krischer Villafana Email chain discussing proposed joint meeting with Epstein's counsel to
finalize all agreements
9/ 20/2007 Lourie Villafana Email forwarding federal plea agreement incorporating Acosta and Laurie
comments
9/20/2017 Laurie Villafalia Email chain discussing factual proffer in support of federal plea
9/20/2017 Acosta, Laurie Villafafia Email summarizing call with Lefkowitz in response to Lefkowitz call to Acosta
9/20/2007 1:17pm draft Plea Agreement
9/20/2007 3:52 pm draft Plea Agreement
9/20/2007 Villafafia Lourie Email stating that Lefkowitz wants to remove registration requirement
9/20/2007 Villafana Laurie Email asking Villafana to call Lefkowitz and inform him that Epstein must
plead to registrable offense
Privileged Confidential Page 19 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
9/21/20(17 Lowrie, Garcia Villafaiia
Email informing Laurie of conversation with Lefkowitz about sex offender
registration issue
9/21/2007 Villafafia,
Belohlavek Krischer Email summarizing SAO negotiations with Goldberger, including
Goldberger's request that Epstein not have to register as a sex offender
9/21/2007 Lourie, Garcia Villafana Email containing revised agreement incorporating some of Lefkowitz's
language and highlighting 7755 negotiations
9/21/2007 Research re Florida Statutory Authorities and Bibliography 50
9/21/2007 2:05 pm draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
9/21/2007 Villafaiia, Garcia Laurie Response to email about Leficowitz's proposed language regarding
immigration proceedings
9/21/2007 4:47 pm Epstein state plea jpl edits (Lefkowitz)
9/23/2007
Acosta, Laurie,
Sloman,
Villafatia
Lefkowitz
Email admitting that defense based their agreement to plead to 796.03 on a
"mistaken assumption" and requesting that Epstein not have to register as a
sex offender
9/23/2007 Lefkowitz,
Laurie, Villafaiia Acosta Email response to Lefkowitz instructing Lefkowitz to deal directly with Laurie
and Villafatia in negotiating agreement 51
9/23/2007 3:56 pm draft Non-Prosecution Agreement
9/23/2007 6:50 pm draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
9/23/2007 8:49 pm draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
9/24/2007 Acosta Sloman, Lowrie,
Garcia, Villafaiia Email containing Acosta edits to Agreement
9/24/2007 Villafaiia Lefkowitz Email - 1 page with nine page NPA (3 signature pages) attached
9/24/2007 Weinberg,
Laurie, Garcia Villafafia Email containing Acosta's final edits and asking to discuss potential victim
representative
9/24/2007
Acosta, Sloman,
Laurie, Garcia,
Atkinson
Villafafia Email containing final agreement as approved by both parties
Privileged Confidential Page 20 of 5 I Contains 6(c) Nlaterial
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit # 9/24/2007 9:04 am draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
9/ 24/2007 10:12 am draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
9/ 24/2007 2:14 pm draft Non-Prosecution Agreement
9/24/2007 4:20 pm draft Non -Prosecution Agreement
9/ 24/2007 NPA signed 32
9/24/2007 Acosta, Garcia,
Lourie Villafaiia Email containing signed agreement
9/ 25/2007 Scheduled date for Federal Indictment
9/30/2007 9/30/2007-10/1/2007 Email chain between Villafafia and Lefkowitz re
telephone call with attached emails from 9/23/07, 9/16/07, and 9/15/07
10/1/2007 Folder entitled "(Victims) Additional 302's" containing reports of interviews
conducted in June 2007, October 2007, and March 2008
10/1/2007 10/1/2007-10/31/2007 Additional negotiations regarding selection of Special
Master
10/1/2007 10/1 /2007-10/31 /2007 JD#1 Notified regarding signing of NPA
10/1/2007 10/1/2007-10/31/2007 Investigation continues to try to identify addl victims
10/2/2007 Add'l client of Brad Edwards interviewed. She refuses to provide information.
(She provides information on a later date).
10/ 3/ 2007 Lefkowitz Villafafia Email - 2 pages with one page attachment, Proposal for Selection of Attorney
to Represent Victims C-6
10/5/2007 Villafafia Lefkowitz Email - 3 pages with four page unsigned letter from Lefkowitz to Villafafta C-6
10/5/2007 Sloman Villafafia Email forwarding letter from Lefkowitz re special master process C-6 10/7/2007 VilLsfaiia 
Sloman Email chain including
correspondence between Sloman and Sanchez
10/8/2007 Sloman Lilly Ann
Sanchez Letter - 3 pages
10/9/2007 Villafaiia Sloman Email attaching correspondence from Sanchez regarding Special Master
Process
10/9/2007 illy Ann LS
anchez Villafafia Email - 1 page with two page letter from Villafaha to Sanchez attached
Privileged Confidential Page 21 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
10/9/2007-
3/25/2008
FBI Interview Reports of ----- (10/05/2007, 3/20/2008, and 3/25/2008), #2
(10/10/2007), #14 (10/26/2007), #33 (10/02/2007), #20 (10/25/2007),
#21 (10/03/2007), (10/03/2007), (10/02/2007), #40
(6/12/2007), and #35 (10/02/2007)
B-31
1(1/10/2007 A(. ).t., Lefkowitz Letter - 6 pages
10/16/2007-
10/23/2007
Emails between Marie Villafafia, Jeff Sloman, Alex Acosta, and Jay Lefkowitz
regarding Special Master C-7
10/22/2007 Lefkowitz Sloman Email - 3 pages with four page draft letter to Judge and two page
Addendum to the NPA, attached
10/23/2007 Acosta Lefkowitz Letter - 3 pages
10/23/2007
Sloman,
Villafafia Acosta Response to Leflcowitz's letter noting specific misrepresentation
10/24/2007 Lefkowitz,
Acosta, Villafana Sloman Email - 1 page with two page Addendum to the NPA, and four page draft
letter to Judge , attached
10/25/2007 Lefkowitz Cyndee
Campos Email - 1 page with letter to Judge attached
10/25/2007 The Hon.
Edward B. Jeffrey Sloman Background information to Special Master to appoint attorney for victims
10/29/2007
Deadline date for Epstein's plea and sentencing according to Non -Prosecution
Agreement
10/30/2007 Villafafia Sloman Email attaching final addendum
10/30/2007 Final executed Addendum to the Non-Prosecution Agreement
10/31/2007 Lefkowitz Sloman Email - 2 pages
11/1/2007
USAO extends deadline for Epstein's plea and sentencing per request of
Epstein's counsel
11/1/2007 Research re State Work Release
Privileged Confidential Page 22 of 5I Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
11/2/2007
Research re Florida Administrative Code Chapter 33-601. Classification of
Central Records: 33-601.602 Community Release Programs and 33-601.606
Placement of Inmates into Community Release Programs
11/5/2007 Lefkowitz Sloman Letter - 2 pages
11/8/2007 Jeffrey Sloman Jay Lefkowitz response to 11/5/07 letter stating that Epstein is complying fully with the
Non Prosecution Agreement (with Villafana handwritten notes)
11/13/2007 Jay Lefkowitz Jeffrey Slomantwo
Response to 11/8/07 letter stating that a guilty plea and sentencing more than
months beyond the original deadline is unacceptable. The agreement as to
the terms of the plea and sentencing and the new date for the change of plea
and sentencing is to be provided by 11/16/07.
11/14/2007 Jeffrey Sloman Villafana Email regarding meeting with State Attorney's Office about work release and
sex offender registration - ,
11/15/2007
Villafaiia,
Sloman, Garcia,
Acosta,
Atkinson
Jason Richards 11/15/2007-11/16/2007 Emails regarding research on work release - 6
11/16/2007 Sloman Lefkowitz Email - 1 Page
11/19/2007
Research re Florida Statute 921.143 Appearance of victim, next of kin, or law
enforcement, correctional, or correctional probation officer to make statement
at sentencing hearing; submission of written statement and Victim Notification
Request Form
B-7
11/19/2007 Plea Notification Letter B-2
11/23/2007 Unscheduled meeting between Jay Lefkowitz, Alan Dershowitz and Jeff
Sloman. (Drop in by Lefkowitz and Dershowitz)
11/26/2007 Jason Richards PBSO D/S Harold Elliott Research re work release: PBSO Post Orders for the Work Release 
Program
Privileged Confidential Page 23 of 5I Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
11/27/2007 Lefkowitz,
Acosta, Villafatia Sloman Email responding to Lefkowitz's statement in his letter that he needs to
conduct "due dilligence" on selection of Podhurst firm
11/27/2007 Plea Notification Letter at 7:11 pm )3-3
11/28/2007
A. Marie
Villafaiia, A.
Oosterbaan, R.
Garcia
A. Lourie Email re non-prosecution agreement with attached correpondence
11/28/2007
Alice S. Fisher,
Assistant
Attorney
General
Starr Letter - 3 pages re 18 U.S.C. 2255
11/28/2007
Lefkowitz,
Acosta, Sloman' Lourie,
Oosterbaan
Villafana Email regarding Epstein's plan to appeal to DC and proposed victim
notification letter
B-8
11/28/2007 Victim notification letter prepared 11/28/2007 at 9:42 pm B-4
11/29/2007 A. Marie
Villafalia Jeffrey Sloman
Request to draft letter that sets forth brief history and nature of the case,
followed by a chronology of the plea negotiations and vetting with CEOS that
results from those meetings, and how the civil resolution evolved.
11/29/2007 A. Marie
Villafaiia Jeffrey Sloman
Forward of email chain between Jeff Sloman and Andrew Lourie advising that
defense backtracked on two issues: They originally agreed to plead to the state
felony that they thought was unregisterable (but did not tell us knowing we
thought it was), but then discovered they were wrong and tried to get out of it.
They tried several times to knock down the jail time after agreeing to the time.
11/29/2007 Acosta Lefkowitz Letter - 4 pages, 4 page CVRA proposed notice letter attached B 9
Privileged Confidential Page 24 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
11/30/2007 Jay Lefkowitz R. Alexander
Acosta
Need to confer with A. Marie Villafafia and Jeffrey Sloman regarding
11/29/07 letter. Counsel has objected to several steps taken by the USAO to
effectuate the terms of the agreement and if Epstein is dissatisfied with the
Agreement, we stand ready to unwind the Agreement.
B I()
11/30/2007 Kenneth Starr Alex Acosta
Letter in response to 11/28/2007 letter to Assistant Attorney General Fisher.
Outlines the history of negotiations with various counsel for Epstein
illustrating how the Non -Prosecution Agreement was reached. Request to
provide definitive statement signed by Epstein of his intention to abide by
each and very term of the Agreement by dose of business on 12/14/2007, or
will proceed with prosecution.
11/30/2007 Research re CVRA
12/1/2007 Victim notification letter prepared 12/1/2007 at 7:50 pm B-6 12/3/2007 Acosta Villafaiia Emails regarding 
research on proposed trust fund 55
12/4/2007 Kenneth Starr R. Alexander
Acosta
Response to 11/28/07 letter regarding concerns of Non -Prosecution
Agreement. The intent is to place the victims in the same position as they
would have been had Epstein been convicted at trial.
12/5/2007 R. Alexander
Acosta
Kenneth Starr
and Jay
Lefkowitz
Epstein reaffirms Non -Prosecution Agreement. Have no knowledge of
deadlines. Request for updated draft victim letters B-11
12/6/2007 Jay Lefkowitz Jeffrey Sloman
Concern about Epstein's failure to set a timely plea and sentencing date. Still
have no received the terms of the Plea Agreement with the State Attorney's
Office. There has been no contact with the press from our office or the FBI.
Letters to victims will be sent through the mail. Attached revised crime
victim's rights letter
It 12
12/ 6/ 2007 Lefkowitz Acosta Letter and facsimile transmission cover sheet re victim notification latter , B-12
12/6/2007 Lefkowitz Sloman Letter - 4 pages, 4 page CVRA proposed notice letter attached
12/6/2007 Starr Acosta Letter - 7 pages
Privileged Confidential Page 25 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
12/6/2007
Emails between Marie Villafana, Andrew Lourie, Cyndee Campos, Jeff
Sloman, Alex Acosta, Karen Atkinson, and Nesbitt Kuyrkendall regarding
correspondence from Ken Starr, request for a meeting with Epstein counsel,
and need to notify victims of upcoming plea
12/6/2007
12/6/2007-12/7/2007 Emails between Marie Villafatia, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall,
Jason Richards, Jeff Sloman, Cyndee Campos, Annette Castillo, Karen
Atkinson, and Shawn Ball regarding request from State Attorney's Office for
draft plea proffer
B-13
12/6/2007 Villafana Belchlank 12/6/2007-12/7/2007 Emails between Villafana, Sloman, and Belohlavek
regarding a factual proffer for state plea 73
12/7/2007 Acosta, Fisher,
Sloman
Starr//.
Lefkowitz
Letter stating the defense will respond to Acosta letter by 12/10/07, and
attaching " the independent ethics opinions of Judge Herbert J. Stern and Joe
D. Whitley"
12/7/2007 Alan Dershwitz Herbert J. Stem Letter - 27 pages
12/7/2007 Kenneth Starr R. Alexander
Acosta
Independent ethics opinions of Judge Herbert J. Stem and Joe D. Whitley
regarding the federal investigation of this matter and the Section 2255
component of the Agreement.
12/7/2007 Lilly Ann
Sanchez Jeffrey Sloman
Signed Affirmation of the Non-Prosection Agreement and Addendum. Plea
and sentencing hearing scheduled for 1/4/08 at 8:30 am before Judge Sandra
McSorley.
R I s
12/7/2007 Sloman Lilly Ann
Sanchez
Letter -1 pages with Affirmation signed by Epstein and Notice of Heating,
State of Florida I. Jeffrey Epstein, attached
12/7/2007 Victim notification letter prepared 12/7/2007 at 9:10 pm B-6
12/7/2007 Unmailed victim notification letters B-14
12/10/2007
Contacted counsel for JD#2/Individual #25 (paid for by Epstein) to
determine if he still represented JD#2/Individual #25 and whether he should
receive upcoming victim notification
B-19
12/11/2007 Sloman and
Acosta Villafatia Email regarding call with Jim Eisenberg 8-20
Privileged Confidential Page 26 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
12/11/2007 R. Alexander
Mona
Kenneth Starr
and Jay
Lefkowitz
2 separate letters to address problems with case. Letter 1 - Federal
Investigators relied upon tainted evidence. Improper involvement and
conduct of Federal authorities (specifically names Villafana). Letter 2 - Section
2255 and background of negotiations
12/11/2007 Epstein counsel object to including JD#2/Indivival #25 as "victim" and begin
their appeals to Washington, DC
12/12/2007 Complete indictment package marked "Originals 12/12/07"
12/12/2007 Emails between Marie Villafatia, Frederica Devlin, and Bob Senior regarding
planning indictment review B-1(il
12/12/2007 Revised indictment package finalized
12/13/2007 Lefkowitz Villafaiia Letter - 5 pages
12/14/2007
Alex Acosta, Jeff
Sloman, Rolando
Garcia, and
Karen Atkinson
Mane Villafana Email with draft letters to State Attorney's Office and victims B I -
12/14/2007 Draft Crime Victims' Rights - Notification of Resolution of Epstein
Investigation letter B I 6
12/14/2007
Research re Florida Procurement and Sentencing Guidelines (745 So.2d 979,
761 So.2d 474397 So.2d 741, 715 So.2d 274, 919 So.2d 695, 701 So.2d 1181,
711 So.2d 1290)
12/14/2007 Draft letter to Krischer from Acosta regarding Epstein filing as sex offender 69
12/14/2007 Acosta; Sloman Villafan-a Email regarding Fl. Stat. 796.03 (procuring minors for prostitution) and 18
U.S.C. 2255 74
12/17/2007 Acosta Lefkowitz Email responding to inquiry from 12/14/07 meeting about why defense had
waited so long to go to DC
Privileged Confidential Page 27 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
12/17/2007 Acosta Starr, Lefkowitz
110-page letter addressing inapplicability of procurement statute to Epstein's
conduct, State Attorney's Office's belief that Epstein should not have to
register inapplicability of 18 USC 2422 to Epstein's conduct; and reiteration of
2255 concerns. Attachment: 7/6/07 Lefcourt letter Sloman, Menchel, Lourie,
and Villafafia with attachments
12/17/2007 Jeff Sloman Marie Villafafia Email inquiring about case status and informing Sloman regarding agent
concern about victim notification
B-18
12/19/2007
Alex Acosta, Jeff
Sloman, and
Janice
LaClainche
Marie Villafasia Email regarding challenge to state charge raised by Epstein counsel during
12/14/2007 meeting
B-19
12/19/2007 Lilly Ann
Sanchez Acosta Follow up letter from 12/14/07 meeting
12/20/2007
Emails between Marie Villafafia and Jeff Sloman regarding inquiries from State
Attorney's Office regarding Epstein plea to state charge and facts supporting
state plea
12/21/2007 11. Al
Acostaer
exand Jay Lefkowitz
Knowledge of "list" of alleged victims is limited. Proposal deprives Epstein of
his opportunity to test the validity of these women's claims that would have
been extensively tested at trial.
B-21
12/26/2007 R. Alexander
Acosta Jay Lefkowitz
We do not object that some form of notice be given to the alleged victims. We
request the opportunity to review the notification. Believe they should be sent
by State Attorney's Office instead of USAO. More arguments about 2255
language.
B-22
1/2/2008 Alex Acosta and
Jeff Sloman Marie Villafafia Email regarding renewed plea negotiations for federal plea agreement
1/2/2008 Alex Acosta and
Marie Villafaria Jeffrey Sloman Email regarding telephone conversation with State Attorney's Office about
delay in Epstein state plea
Privileged Confidential Page 28 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
1/2/2008
Emails between Alex Acosta, Marie Villafatia, and Jeff Sloman regarding
requests from Alex Acosta to Marie Villafafia for information related to the
handling of the investigation by the State Attorney's Office
1/3/2008
I :.mails between Marie Villafatia, Alex Acosta, and Jeff Sloman regarding Alex
Acosta telephone conference with Jay Lefkowitz where Lefkowitz admitted
that he never intended to have Epstein plead guilty to an offense that required
sex offender registration
1/4/2008 Scheduled date for Epstein's self surrender according to the Non -Prosecution
Agreement
1/7/2008
Alex Acosta, Jeff
Sloman, Robert
Senior, Karen
Atkinson, and
Rolando Garcia
Marie Villafatia Email regarding proposed additional investigative steps in Epstein case B-102
1/8/2008 Trial date set for State of Florida vs. Epstein
i 9 , fiw,
1/9/2008-1/14/2008 Emails between Marie Villafaila, Drew Oosterbaan,
Myesha Braden, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and Jason Richards regarding assigning a
CEOS attorney to the investigation, meeting with the CEOS attorney and
victims in Florida, the results of the meetings and planned additional meetings,
and revisions to the indictment in light of the meetings.
B-103
1/10/20” , Email chain between Myesha Braden and Marie Villafaila regarding meeting
on 1/11/2008 B-104
1/14/2008
Marie Villafatia,
E. Nesbitt
Kuyrkendall,
Jason Richards
Myesha Braden Email chain regarding meeting and additional 302s B-105
1/17/2008 Agents compile evidence for Bob Senior indictment review B-106
Privileged Confidential Page 29 of 5I Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
1/25/2008
Email chain between Myesha Braden and Marie Villafana regarding victim's
names in indictment
B-107
1/31/2008 Add'l grand jury subpoenas prepared and served B-108
1/31/2008
1/28/2008-2/1/2008 Emails between Marie Villafafia, Jeff Sloman, Alex
Acosta, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Jason Richards, and Alan Santiago regarding
results of additional victim-witness interviews and requesting intervention with
CEOS to move review process along
B 109
1/31/2008 Sloman, Acosta Villafafia Email regarding victims C-1
2/12/2008
2/12/2008-2/22/2008 Emails between Marie Villafatia, E. Nesbitt
Kuyrkendall, Jason Richards, and Myesha Braden re information for
indictment/ongoing investigation
B-110
2/19/2008 Complete indictment package, including 3rd Supplement to Pros memo
2/20/2008
2/20/2008-2/21/2008 Emails between Drew Oosterbaan, Marie Villafafia,
Robert Senior, Jeff Sloman, Sigal Mandelker, Karen Atkinson, Alex Acosta,
Rolando Garcia and Myesha Braden regarding status of CEOS plans to meet
with counsel for Epstein and status of indictment review
B-111
2/25/2008 Lefkowitz Sloman Email providing deadline for Epstein to perform
2/25/2008
Email chain between Marie Villafafia and Caroline Heck regarding use B 11,
of Grand Jury
2/25/2008
Jeff Sloman, Bob
Senior, Rolando
Garcia, Karen
Atkinson, and
Myesha Braden
Marie Villafafia Email re result of conferring with Caroline Heck about whether or not
to continue presentation to same grand jury or p to a different grand jury B 111
2/26/2008 Myesha Braden Marie Villafafia Email re CEOS independent review and concern about victim's names being
released B
-I 14
Privileged Confidential Page 30 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
2/26/2008 Sloman, Senior Villafatia Email response with concerns regarding allowing Epstein to keep the same
deal as before R I I;
2/27/2008 Lefkowitz Sloman Email - 2 pages
2/27/2008 Email chain between Marie Villafatia, David Weinstein, and Bob Senior re
email to the Civil Rights Chief B Ill,
2/28/2008 Entails between Marie Villafafia and Susan Roe regarding related investigation,
potential investigatory leads, and CEOS review
2/28/2008 Email chain between Marie Villafain, Jason Richards, and E. Nesbitt
Kuyrkendall regarding further investigation R 1 i -
2/29/2008 Acoqa Lefkowitz Email - 1 page
2/29/2008 Emails between Jeff Sloman, Marie Villafafia, Robert Senior, and David
Weinstein regarding continuing investigation and status of CEOS review li I I',
3/1/2008 ' FBI Reports of March 2008 interviews of additional wimess/victitn located in
New York
3/1/2008 Folder entitled "(Victims) Additional 302's" containing reports of interviews
conducted in June 2007, October 2007, and March 2008
3/5/2008
Emails between Marie Villafain and E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall with attached
email to Alex Acosta, Jeff Sloman, Drew Oosterbaan, Robert Senior, Myesha
Braden, Rolando Garcia, and Karen Atkinson regarding meeting in DC,
additional information to prepare for meeting, and new information from
ongoing investigation
B 121
3/7/2008 Lefkowitz Oosterbaan Email - 2 pages
3/10/2008 Lefkowin Oosterbaan Email - 2 pages
3/10/2008 Oosterbaan Lefkowitz  Email - 1 page
3/10/2008
3/10/2008-3/12/2008 Emails between Marie Villafatia, Robert Senior,
Myesha Braden, Krishna Patel, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, E.J.Yen, and Karen
Atkinson about Epstein attempts to contact victims and finding counsel for
victims
B-23
3/12/2008 Sub oena to ---- return date 4/15/08
3/12/2008 Subpoena to (return date 4/15/08)
3/12/2008 Villafalia Kuyrkendall Email re affidavit for the memory cards B-119
Privileged Confidential Page 31 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
.3/12/2008
3/12/2008-3/17/2008 Emails between Marie Villafatia, Nesbitt Kuyrkendall
and E.J. Yera regarding search warrant application and execution of search
warrant
3/13/2008 Sigal Mandelker Lefkowitz Email - 2 pages (CEOS)
3/14/2008
Emails between Marie Villafaila, Rolando Garcia, Karen Atkinson, Frederica
Devlin, and Shawn Ball regarding complete indictment package for Robert
Senior final review
B-27/B-
3/14/2008 Revised indictment package B-25
3/17/2008 Search warrants for digital camera memory cards B-120
3/18/2008
Grand Jury presentation materials and testimony of Special Agent E. Nesbitt
Kuyrkendall
B-26
3/19/2008
Email chain between Marie Villafaiia, David Weinstein, Jeff Simian, Bob
Senior, Karen Atkinson, and Rolando Garcia with Epstein update from grand
jury presentation and grant from the Justice Department to provide legal
representation to victims
C-2
3/19/2008
3/19/2008-3/22/2008 Emails regarding victims being harassed by Epstein's
investigators
( ;
3/20/2008 Vilialana Richard H.
Willits Letter that he is representing Individual #3
3/21/2008 Responses to addil_grand jury subpoenas received
3/25/2008 Planned grand jury presentation (moved to 4/15/2008 then to 4/29/2008)
3/28/2008 Sigal Mandelker Starr Letter - 5 pages (CEOS) B-28
3/28/2008 Villafalia Danchuk Letter advising of representation of Individual #3 and that a lawsuit has been
filed in Palm Beach County Circuit Court B-41
4/1/2008 Jay Lefkowitz Jeffrey Sloman Draft letter regarding termination of agreement
Privileged Confidential Page 32 of 51 Contains 6(c) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
4/2/2008
Emails between Marie Villafatia, Alex Acosta, Jeff Sloman, Karen Atkinson,
Robert Senior, Rolando Garcia, and Nesbitt Kuyrkendall regarding efforts by
Jay Lefkowitz and Ken Starr to speak with Alex Acosta and instructions to
direct question to Marie Villafaila and Karen Atkinson
4/8/2008 Sigal Mandelker Starr Letter - 4 pages (CEOS)
4/9/2008 Willits Villafalla Letter in response to 3/28/08 letter from Willits B-42
4/21/2008
4/21/2008-5/9/2008 Emails between Marie Villafaiia, Jeff Sloman, Karen
Atkinson, Bob Senior, E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, Jason Richards, and Drew
Oosterbaan re status of grand jury presentation, and ongoing investigation,
and delay
B-124
4/22/2008
Office of
Professional
Responsibility
A. Marie
Villafafia Letter re Self-Report of Allegation of Conflict of Interest
4/28/2008 Sigal Mandelker Starr Letter - 4 pages (CEOS)
4/29/2008 Operation Leap Year Revised Indictment Summary chart (by Victim) and
Grand Jury presentation Operation Leap Year B-29
4/2 9/ 2008 Draft Indictment 8-30 5/6/2008 Subpoena to Leigh Ann Murray (return date 5/6/08)
5/14/2008 Asst Atty
General Fisher Starr Letter - 4 pages (CEOS)
5/15/2008 Jay Leflcowitz Andrew G.
Oosterbaan Federal prosecution would not be improper or inappropriate. It -24
5/15/2008 CEOS and DAAG Fisher complete review of Epstein's appeal
5/15/2008
5/15/2008-5/27/2008 Emails between Marie Villafatia, Karen Atkinson, Bob
Senior, Jeff Sloman, and agents regarding indictment review and status of
investigation
B-125
5/19/2008 Acosta Lefkowitz Email - 3 pages B-35
5/1 9/ 2008 AttvDeputy  ' General Filip Starr/Whidey Letter - 8 pages 8-33
Privileged Confidential Page 33 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
5/19/2008 Lefkowitz Cyndee
Campos Email - 1 page with 5/19/08 letter attached B-35
5/ 19/2008 Lefkowitz Sloman Letter - 6 pages B-35
5/19/2008
Lefkowitz, cc:
Sloman and
Villafatia
Acosta Response email to Lefkowitz's 5/19/08 email re Drew Oosterbaan letter,
which is attached
B-36
5/19/2008
Kirldand & Ellis LLP, Response to Letter by FAUSA Sloman dated
5/19/2008 - 10 pages
B-37
5/19/2008 Lefkowitz Sloman Letter setting June 2, 2008 deadline to comply with terms and conditions of
the NPA
B-32
5/27/2008 Honorable Mark
Filip, DAG Kenneth Starr Request for independent review of Epstein matter B-33
5/27/2008
Emails between A. Marie Villafana and Karen Atkinson regarding report of
new state plea deal for J. Epstein
11-39
5/27/2008
Emails between A. Marie Villafaiia, Robert Senior, Jeff Sloman, and Karen
Atkinson regarding potential renewed plea negotiations for J. Epstein and
plans to review and review updated indictment package
R ', K
5/27/2008-
6/13/2008
Internal emails after CEOS letter rejecting appeal where Marie Villafaiia asks
to indict and Jeff/Alex advise Epstein will be given chance to perform
B m
5/28/2008 Atkinson,
Villafana, Garcia Villafana, Sloman Email chain regarding information from Barry Krischer, the State Attorney
5/28/2008 Lefkowitz Sloman Email - 1 page
5/28/2008 Soman,
Villafana Atkinson Email chain regarding Epstein's request to do less time than 18 months
5/29/2008
Villafalia, Senior;
cc: Atkinson,
Kuyrkendall,
Richards
Sloman Email regarding DAG decision to consider Epstein's "appeal" and that GJ for
Tuesday is off
B-40
Privileged Confidential Page 34 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
5/30/2008 FBI-302 of 5/28/08 Interview of Individual #35 13-126
6/2/2008 Villafatia Sloman Draft letter to DAG B-127
6/3/2008 Honorable Mark
Filip, DAG Kenneth Starr Submission with documents for independent review
6/3/2008 Starr/Whitley John Roth Letter - 1 page
6/3/2008 Honorable Mark
Filip , DAG Sloman 2nd draft letter to DAG B 12'1
6/3/2008 Draft letter to Deputy Attorney General Mark Filip regarding reasons to
approve continued prosecution of J. Epstein B-128
6/6/2008 Emails between Marie Villafafia and E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall and subpoena
issued to victim/witness and need for additional subpoenas B-129
6/17/2008 Application for 6001 immunity for grand jury witness B-130
6/17/2008
Acosta, Sloman,
Senior,
Atkinson, Garcia
Villafalia Email summarizing meeting with Krischer regarding Epstein's attempt to
negotiate a new plea deal 78
6/18/2008 Villafafia Senior Email regarding call with Roy Black and response that Washington has not
made a final decision
6 18/2008
Emails between A. Marie Villafafia, Robert Senior, Alex Acosta, Jeff Sloman,
Rolando Garcia, and Karen Atkinson regarding telephone conference with
Roy Black about allowing.). Epstein to accept state plea to 60 days'
imprisonment
6/18/2008 Notes from call to Brad Edwards, counsel for #43, and notes from message to
Roy Black and message from Roy Black B-43
6/19/2008 Barry Krischer;
Karen Atkinson \ ill.it.ina Email re wrapping up the case 68
Privileged Confidential Page 35 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
6/19/2008 Honorable Mark
Filip, DAG Kenneth Starr Additional documents for independent review
6/19/2008 John Roth Stephanie D.
Thacker Letter - 14 pages
6/20/2008 Request to travel to New York for witness interviews in June 2008 and
subpoena B-132
6/23/2008 Lefkowitz/ Starr John Roth Letter - 1 page 8-44
6/23/2008
Emails between Jeff Sloman, Bob Senior, and Marie Villafatia instructing
Marie Villafaiia to inform Epstein's attorneys that he had until June 30 to enter
a guilty plea and Villafafia email to Lefkowirz re same
B-49
6/23/2008
Villafaiia,
Kuyrkendall,
Richards, cc:
Atkinson
Senior Email regarding New York Jane Doe and awaiting a response from DAG's
office
6/23/2008
Emails between A. Marie Villafafia, E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, J. Richards, K.
Atkinson, and R. Senior regarding grand jury subpoena to victim/witness,
revisions to indictment, planned grand jury presentation, and plans to
supersede indictment
IS Ill
6/23/2008 DAG Filip completes review of Epstein's appeal
6/23/2008 6/23/2008-6/26/2008 Emails between Marie Villafaiia and grand jury witne,
regarding immunity and travel for grand jury appearance
B 13d
6/24/2008 Letter from Matthew W. Friedrich, Acting Assistant Attorney General
authorizing application for a court order granting 6001 immunity P, 1 'd
6/24/2008 Villafaiia Sloman Email re discussion about going to the change of plea regarding Jeffrey
Epstein
6/24/2008 Villafaiia; cc:
Jack Goldberger Roy Black Email chain regarding wrap up call B-45
Privileged Confidential Page 36 of 5 I Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
6/25/2008 Villafafia Sloman Email regarding having telephone discusion about 2255 issue and to discuss
plea 8
6/25/2008 Villafafia Sloman Email with revised victim notification letter IS-47
6/25/2008
Emails between A. M. Villafaria, J. Sloman, R. Senior, K Atkinson, and A.
Acosta regarding draft of notification of victim list for J. Epstein counsel with
attached drafts
8-48
6/26/2008 Black and
Goldberger Villafafia Email re proposed plea agreement and date and time of change of plea
6/26/2008 Villafaria Sloman Email regarding factual proffer
6/26/2008 Fax from FBI with victim list B-SO
6/27/2008 Black and
Goldberger Villafaria Letter regarding plea agreement between Epstein and SA and that the
proposed sentencing provision does not comply with the terms of the NPA
6/27/2008 Black and
Goldberger Villafaria Emails between Villafana and Black/Goldberger about problems with state
plea agreement 77
6/27/2008 Counsel for Epstein advise USAO of Epstein state court change of plea on
6/30/08 BSI
6/27/2008 AUSA Villafafia notifies Attorney Edwards of upcoming change of plea and
urges his clients to attend
6/27/2008 USAO notifies Palm Beach Police Chief Reiter of upcoming change of plea.
He states intention to notify as many victims as possible of hearing. 8-53
6/27/2008 Research re State Work Release
6/27/2008 Sloman,
Atkinson Villafalia Email inquiring about conversation with Chief Reiter B-52
6/27/2008 Sloman Villafafia Email summarizing conversation with Goldberger that Epstein would serve
sentence in confinement "24-hours-a-day" 79
6/28/2008
Emails between A. M. Villafalia, J. Sloman, A. Acosta, and IL Senior regarding
correspondence with J. Goldberger and proposed change to state plea
agreement
6/29/2008 \ 'illafafia Kuyrkendall Email regarding work release 80
Privileged Confidential Page 37 of Si Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
6/30/2008 Villafatia Mycsha Braden Email chain regarding Epstein sentencing
6/30/2008 Villafatia Susan Roc Email chain regarding news article
6/30/2008 Villataria Ted Leopold Email chain with response to 6/30/08 email from Villafana with contact
info don
6/30/2008 Emails between Marie Villafana and attorney for grand jury wimess
withdrawing subpoena B-I35
6/30/2008
Epstein enters guilty plea in state court in accordance with NPA.
JD#1/Individual #43, JD#2/Individual #25, and counsel do not appear. ASA
and counsel for Epstein disclose to state court judge existence of NPA, which
is later incorporated into state court record.
6/30/2008 Notcs from calls to Michael Danchuk and Richard Willets, Jeff Herman, Brad
Edwards, Ted Leopold, and Mike Dutko B-55
6/30/2008 Research re State Work Release
6/30/2008 Draft notification of identified victims letters to Guy Lewis, Jack Goldberger,
and Roy Black
B 5(
6/30/2008 Villafafia Oosterbaan Email regarding Epstein guilty plea and sentencing 71
6/30/2008 2008-2009 Epstein serves prison term
7/1/2008 Smachetti Villafana Email response stating that Villafana handled Epstein case but did not come
up with the 18-month deal
7/1/2008 Villatatia Anne Schultz Email regarding Epstein plea
7/1/2008 Villatatia Smachetti Email chain regarding Epstein case
7/3/2008
Col. M. Gauger,
Palm Beach
Sheriffs Office

A. Marie
Villafana Email re Epstein work release with attachment
7/3/2008 Sloman Villafaila Email re victim's lawyer
7/3/2008 Villafatia Brad Edwards
and Jay Howell Letter advising of representation of Epstein victims
7/3/2008 Villatafia Ted Leopold Email advising client names
Privileged Confidential Page 38 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
7/3/2008 Villafafia; cc:
Acosta c.1/01),In Email response to 7/3/08 email from Villafafia regarding victims' lawyer
7/3/2008
Emails between A. M. Villafafia, J. Sloman, and A. Acosta regarding telephone
conference with B. Edwards and regarding meeting with Sheriffs Office about
work release program
s I
7/7/2008 JD#1/Individual #43 files "Emergency Petition"
7/7/2008 Notes from calls to Mike Dutko, Brian Poulton, ASA, and Ted Leopold
7/7/2008 Notes of phone call with Roy Black held some time between 7/7/08 and
9/19/08
7/8/2(07;
D. Lee, A.
Acosta, J.
Sloman
A. Marie
Villafafia
Email regarding victim notification letter provided to counsel for J. Epstein on
11/28/2007 with attachment
7/8/2008 Goldberger Villafafia Letter re victim notification letters B-57
7/8/2008
Lee, Sloman, cc:
Villafafia,
Jacobus
Acosta Email with attached second draft of response in Jane Doe case
7/8/200s Villafafia Goldberger Letter that he will respond on 7/9/08 B-58
7/9/2008
1 costa, Sloman,
Atkinson; cc:
Kuyrkendall and
Richards
Villafaila Email regarding response to Goldberger letter B-59
7/9/2008 Goldberger Villafafia Response to Goldberger's 7/9/08 letter re notification of identified victims B-60
7/9/2008
Lee, Villafalia,
Acosta; cc:
Atkinson,
Jacobus
Sloman Email chain regarding confidentiality provision and filing under seal for victim
response
7/9/2008 Villafafia Goldberger Letter re Notification of Identified Victims B-61
7/9/2008 Victim Notification letters to Individuals #35 and #43 via Brad Edwards B-66
Privileged Confidential Page 39 of SI Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
7/9/2008 Govt responds to "Emergency Petition"
7/10/2008 Goldberger Villafafia Letter stating that government will provide victim notifications on a rolling
basis B-62
7/10/2008 Villafalia Goldberger Letter requesting list of all victims B-64
7/10/2008 Goldberger Villafatia Letter with final notification of identified victims B-63
7/10/2008
Villafafia,
Acosta,
Atkinson, cc:
Kuyrkendall,
Richards
Sloman Email regarding proposed response to Goldberger B 65
7/10/2008
Victim Notification letters to Individuals #3 (via Richard H. Willits), #8 (via
Jeffrey Herman), ##17 (via Theodore J. Leopold), #25 (via Jeffrey Herman),
#26 (via Jeffrey Herman), #37 (via Michael E. Dutko), and #44 (via Jeffrey
Herman)
B-67
7/11/2008 Hearing before Judge Marra
7/14/2008
7/14/2008-7/15/2008 Emails between A. M. Villafaria, E. Nesbitt
Kuyrkendall, J. Richards, and T. Smith regarding FBI victim notifications and
guidance regarding language to use and information to provide
B 6',
7/17/2008
Villafafia,
Acosta,
Atkinson, Lee
Sloman Email chain with revised draft of Tein letter
7/17/2008 Letter to Tein with attached fax cover sheet and transmission report
7/17/2008 Tein and
Goldberger Villafaila Letter re Notice of Continued Pendency of Federal Criminal Action
7/18/2008
7/18/2008-7/21/2008 Emails between A. M. Villafacia, J. Sloman, E. Nesbitt
Kuyrkendall, J. Richards, D. Lee, and IC Atkinson regarding preparation of
victim notification letters, victim contact list, filing of victim notification letter
in a civil proceeding, and contact by B. Edwards with one victim opining that
sentence imposed was insufficient
B-69
Privileged Confidential Page 40 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
7/19/2008 Emails with other AUSAs in other districts and documents regarding
disclosing identifying information about victims
7/21/2008 Goldberger Villafafia Letter with 11 additional victim notification letters
7/21/2008 Villafaila Goldberger Letter with attached Motion for Return of Property
7/21/2008 Villafaiia Kuyrkendall Email with list of victims that Twiler still needs to make contact with It 6')
7/21/2008 Villafaiia Tein Letter in response to 7/17/08 letter from Villafaiia
7/21/2008 Victim Notification letters to Individuals #1, #2, #4, #13, #9, #14, #21, #23,
#30, #32, and #38
7/21/2008 Villafaiia; cc:
Senior Sloman Email response to Vilkfaiia's 7/21/08 email regarding Motion for Return of
Property in State Court
7/22/2008 Villafaiia K tz% rkcndall Email chain regarding victim addresses
7/22/2008
Emails between A. M. Vitiate's, A. Acosta, J. Sloman, R. Senior, K. Atkinson,

E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, and J. Richards regarding 7/21/2008 letter from M.
Tein announcing plan to stay the civil suits against J. Epstein and notification
that B. Reinhart is counts! of record for S. Kellen in civil suits
7/23/2008 Emails between A. M. Villafaria and D. Lee regarding correspondence with
counsel for]. Epstein and notice of breach
7/25/2008 Emails between A. M. Villafaria and K. Atkinson regarding extension of grand
jury to allow for continued representation of J. Epstein case
7/30/2008 Villafaiia Atkinson Email regarding contact with Roy Black
7/30/2008 Villafaria Roy Black Email chain regarding call relating to the performance of the criminal Non-
Prosecution Agreement
8/1/2008
Lee, Acosta; cc:
Villafaiia,
Jacobus, Senior
Sloman Email chain regarding Jane Doe litigation
8/2/2008 Lee, Villafaiia Acosta Email re: Letter from Brad Edwards
8/5/2008
A. Acosta, J.
Sloman R. ,
Senior, and K.
Atkinson
A. Marie
Villafalia
Email regarding analysis of Jeffrey Epstein agreement, with attached
6/24/2008 email from A. M. Villafaiia to R. Black and J. Goldberger and
attached Epstein agreement
It - 1
Privileged Confidential Page 41 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
8/5/2008
Villafaiia, Senior,
Sloman, Lee, cc:
Atkinson
Acosta Email with attached suggestions to Superseding Non -Prosecution Agreement B-72
8/6/2008
Villafatia,
Acosta, Sloman,
Atkinson
Senior Email regarding filing in state court case
8/7/2008 Villafana Roy Black Email responding to 8/7/08 email providing notification of possible
compelled disclosure of the Non -Prosecution Agreement B-73
8/6/2008 Villafatia Senior Response regarding Roy Black's response to email B-74
8/12/2008 Villafafia Senior Response to request for conference call prior to call with Roy Black B-75
8/13/2008
Atkinson,
Acosta, Sloman,
Lee, cc: Villafaiia
Senior Email re Epstein and call with Jay B-76
8/13/2008
Atkinson,
Senior, Sloman,
Lee, cc: Villafafia
Acosta Email response regarding final version of agreement B-77
8/13/2008 Lefkowitz Villafafia Letter regarding performance of the N PA 8-78
8/13/2008 Research re PBSO rules and regulations
8/13/2008
8/13/2008-8/15/2008 Emails between A. Acosta, K. Atkinson, R.. Senior, J.
Sloman, D. Lee, and A. M. Villafafia regarding scope of Epstein agreement
and correspondence and telephone conference with J. Lefkowitz
B-79
8/14/2008 Villafana -;enior Email response to 8/14/08 email from Villafaiia advising Dexter disagrees
with strategy
8/14/2008 Villafana, cc:
Atkinson Lefkowitz Email re Follow up point regarding victims B-80
8/14/2008 Status Conf before Judge Marra
Privileged Confidential Page 42 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
8/15/2008
Acosta,
Villafafia,
Sloman, Lee,
Atkinson
Senior Email questioning whether offer should be withdrawn as opposed to
considering it a nullity 13-81
8/15/2008
Email chain between Villafaiia, Acosta, Sloman, Senior, Atkinson, and Lee re
draft response to 8/15/2008 email from Jay Leflcowitz regarding
implementation of the NPA
13-82
8/15/2008 Lefkowitz and
Black Villafaiia Letter re terms of NPA 13-83
8/15/2008 Villafatia, cc:
Atkinson Le&owitz Email re Follow up point with attached entails from 8/14/08
8/18/2008 Villafaiia Leflcowitz Letter re restitution 13-84
8/21/2008 Leflcowitz and
Black Villafafia Letter re Special Master and draft Notification of Identified Victim B-85
8/22/2008 Villafatia Lefkowitz Letter re misstatements in 8/21/08 Villafafta letter B-86
8/22/2008 Draft Victim Notification letter to Michael E. Dutko re Individual #37
8/25/2008 Emails between A. M. Villafafia, A. Acosta, J. Sloman, R. Senior, K. Atkinson,
and D. Lee regarding letter received from J. Leflcowitz
8/26/2008 Lefkowitz and
Black Villafatia Letter re victim's list B-87
8/26/2008 Villafaiia, cc:
Acosta, Senior Sloman Email regarding changes to letter to Jay
9/2/2008 Villafatia Lefkowitz Letter agreeing that Goldberger should be listed as the contact person and re
Josfsberg's fees B-88
9/2/2008 Emails between A. M. Villafaiia, D. Lee, R. Senior, and J. Sloman regarding
revised victim notification
Privileged Confidential Page 43 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
Mailed Amended Victim Notification letters to Individuals #1, #2, #3 (via
9/2/2008
Richard H. Willits), #4, #13, #8 (via Jeffrey Herman), #9, #10, #11, #14,
#16, #17 (via Theodore Leopold), #20, #21, #23, #24, #25 (via Jeffrey B-89
Herman), #26 (via Jeffrey Herman), #30, #31, #32, #33, #37 (via Michael E.
Dutko), #38, #44 (via Jeffrey Herman)
9/3/2008 Victim notification letters to Individuals #36, #35 (via Brad Edwards), #42,
#43 (via Brad Edwards) B ()c
Email chain regarding Epstein and recommendation on working with same 9/8/2008 Villafana Susan Roe team
Michael 9/12/2008 Villafatia Danchuk Letter requesting copy of the settlement agreement
9/12/2008 Notification of Identified Victim letter. Individual #39 B-91
9/15/2008 Michael
Danchuk Villafafia Letter in response to 9/12/08 letter from Danchuk
9/15/2008 Mailed victim notification letters for Individuals #18 and #32 B-92
9/17/2008- Emails and coorespondence with The Florida Bar re victim notifications B-93 11/4/2008
9/16/2008- Emails between Villafafia, Krischer, Belohlavek, Garcia, Sloman, and Atkinson 70
9/17/2008 regarding Palm Beach Daily News requesting copy of the NPA and discussion
9/17/2008
Lefkowitz,
Black, and Villafatia Letter re Palm Beach Daily News requesting information about the NPA
Goldberger
9/17/2008
Villafaila,
Acosta, Senior,
Lee, Atkinson
•1( )man Email chain regarding obligation to sealing NPA
9/19/2008 Notes of calls to Bob Josefsberg
Email agreeing with Villafalia's 10/8/08 email that a copy of the Response to 10/8/2008 Villafatia Senior Jane Does' 
Motion to Unseal the NPA should be mailed
to Epstein's attorneys
Privileged Confidential Page 44 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
19/8/2008 Villafaiia Slornan Email response to Villafafia's 10/8/08 email advising to send a copy of
pleading to Roy and Jay
10/8/2008
Villafaiia, Roy
Black, cc:
Atkinson, Lee
Lefkowitz
Email thanking Villafaiia for fowarding United States' Response to Petitioners'
Motion to Unseal the Non -Prosecution Agreement with attached email from
10/8/08
10/16/2008
Villafaiia, Roy
Black, cc:
Atkinson, Lee
Lefkowitz Email thanking Villafaila for forwarding the reply brief filed by Brad Edwards
with attached 10/16/08 email
10/2 3/ 2008
10/23/2008-5/27/2008 ? Emails between A. Marie illafafia, Nesbitt
Kuyrkendall, and J. Richards regarding plans to meet to prepare for indictment
presentation, service of grand jury subpoenas, interviews of additional
witnesses, and plea negotiation issue
10/27/2008 Villafafia Myesha Braden Email chain titled Things to do in West Palm
11/4/2008 Villafafia Senior Email thanking Villafatia for her 11/3/08 email advising she spoke with the
Florida Bar
11/4/2008 Correspondence from Florida Bar Ethics Counsel regarding Florida Ethics
Rules involved in distributing victim notification letters
11/14/2008 Notification of Identified Victim letters to Individuals #20, #40 B 9 I
11/17/2008 Villafaiia Lefkowitz Email chain regarding meeting
11/19/2008
Villafaiia; cc:
Katherine W.
Ezell and Amy
Eden
Robert C.
Josefsberg Email with list of Epstein victims and representation
11/20/2008 Villafaiia Senior Email response to Villafaiia's 11/20/08 email advising that Epstein is on work
release and request to indict him 82
11/21/2008
Villafaiia,
Acosta, Sloman,
Atkinson; cc:
Garcia
Senior Email advising Jeff Sloman is in agreement with approach and next steps 82
11/24/2008 Roy Black Villafafia Letter re work release program and research
Privileged Confidential Page 45 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
11/26/2008 Villafafia and cc:
Atkinson Roy Black Email stating that Jeffrey Epstein has not breached his Non -Prosecution
Agreement by performing work release
11/26/2008
Emails between A. M. Villafafia, J. Sloman, and R. Senior regarding email from
It. Black about work release
12/3/2008 Villafalia Lefkowitz Email that he will not be attending meeting with Roy Black
12/4/2008 Villafatia Atkinson Email with attached draft letter to notify victims of Epstein's work release B-95
12/4/2008 Villafaiia; cc:
Sloman Roy Black Email with attached Motion to Correct Sentence
12/5/2008 Brad Edwards,
Esq. Villafaiia Email with attached Work Release Notice B-96
— 12/5/2008 Herman Villafafia Email with attached Work Release Notice B-96
12/5/2008
Lefkowski,
Villafaiia; cc:
Atkinson
Roy Black
Email response to 12/5/08 email from Villafafia advising that Brad Edwards
filed the Non-Prosecution Agreement in the Jane Doe case and has asked the
Court to unseal it
12/5/2008 Robert C.
Josefsberg Villafana Email with attached Work Release Notice B-96
12/5/2008 Ted Leopold Villafatia Email with attached Work Release Notice B-96
12/5/2008 Villafalia Sloman Email advising no objections to the draft letter for work release notice
attached to Villafafia's 12/4/08 email
12/5/2008 Willits Villafaiia Email with attached Work Release Notice B 96
12/8/2008
Spencer Kuvin,
Jack Scarola,
Michael Dutko,
#11, #39
Villafalia Email with attached Work Release Notice p, ir
12/8/2008 Notification of Work Release Letter to Individual #40 It ')-
12/8/2008 Florida Statute 796.03 Procuring person under age of 18 for prostitution
12/8/2008 Florida Statute 775.0837 Habitual misdemeanor offenders
Privileged Confidential Page 46 of 51 Contains 6(c) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
12/8/2008 Florida Statute 796.07 Prohibiting prostitution, etc.: evidence; penalties;
definitions
12/9/2008 Notification of Work Release letters to Individuals #4, #10, #16, #18, #23,
#24, #33, #38, #30 (personal note), #42 B-98
12/9/2008 Research re false statements on Epstein's application for work release 83
12/10/2008 Villafaria Senior Email requesting to speak with Villafafia regarding article about Epstein's work
release
12/10/2008 Villafafia Sloman Email re Epstein work release letter
12/11/2008
Captain David
Sleeth, Palm
Beach Sheriffs
Office
A. Marie
Villafaiia
Letter regarding Work Release Application of Jeffrey Epstein stating that there
are some inaccuracies and omissions in Mr. Epstein's file.
‘.\ 4
12/11/2008 Villafafia, cc:
Senior Sloman Email advising a copy of the letter should be sent to Mr. Black
12/11/2008 Villafaiia ,
Sloman Senior Email chain regarding sending copy of letter to Mr. Black
12/12/2008 Villataria; cc: . Mitch Kitroser Spencer Kuvin Email response advising he will consult with client in 
response to Villatalia's
12/11/08 email re: Epstein work release
12/12/2008 Notification of Work Release letter to #42 8-100
12/12/2008-
12/29/2008 Emails with attorneys for victims regarding Epstein work release It 'F)
12/15/2008
Villafaiia,
Sloman,
Atkinson, cc:
Kuyrkendall,
Richards
Senior Email chain regarding articles about Epstein
2/3/2009 Roy Black Josefsberg Email re payment
Privileged Confidential Page 47 of SI Contain): 6(c) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
2/11/2009
Amy Ederl,
Evelyn Sheehan,
Katherine W.
Ezell, Bert
Patton
Josefsberg Email chain regarding payment and client's position
2/13/2009 Josefsberg Lefkowitz Letter re invoices are for services exceeding scope of services for which
Epstein agreed to pay for
2/20/2009 Lefkowitz Josefsberg Response to 2/13/09 Lefkowitz letter
3/3/2009 Josefsberg Lefkowitz Response to 2/20/09 Josefsberg letter
6/8/2009 Robert Critton Katherine W.
Ezell Letter re payment
6/9/2009 Sloman, Senior, Garcia, Atkinson Villafana Memorandum re Operation Leap Year: Request to Provide Notification 
of
Breach 85
6/9/2009 File folder entitled "6/9/09 Signed Indictment" containing signed indictment
package dated 6/9/2009 with corrections 86
6/9/2009 Indictment package signed again for presentation on 6/16/2009
6/11/2009 Villafatia Katherine W.
I lizell Email re letter from Critton Denying any fees and hearing on 6/12/09
6/12/2009 Goldberger \ illafafia Letter re violation of NPA 87
6/12/2009 Villafaila 1.efkowitz
Letter re response to Villafaila 6/12/09 letter giving notice of breach with
attached Defendant Jeffrey Epstein's Notice of Withdrawal of Arguments I
through VII of the Defendant's Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs First Amended
Complaint
6/12/2009 File folder entitled "6/12/09 Victim Notif. Log: containing chart with victim
contact information and attorney notes regarding dates and type of contacts
6/12/2009 Transcript of Motion Hearing before judge Marra
6/15/2009
Lefkowitz,
Black, and
Goldberger
N'illafatia Letter regarding history of Epstein's performance under the NPA 88
Privileged Confidential Page 48 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
6/15/2009 Villafalia Lefkowitz Letter re Josefsberg's fees
6/16/2009 Villafafia KaKatherine
Ell W. Email with attachment
6/17/2009 Lefkowitz Villafafia Letter in response to Lefkowitis 6/15/09 letter ,..,)
6/19/2009 Villafafia Lefkowitz Letter re discussion regarding ongoing obligations per NPA
7/6/2009 Villalatia Spencer Kuvin Letter requesting copy of NPA
7/7/2009 Lefkowitz Villafarla- Letter in response to 6/19/09 letter
7/8/2009 Villafafia Critton Letter rc NPA with attached Defendant Epstein's Motion to Dismiss
Plaintiffs Complaint (Jane Doe #8)
7/31/2009 Villafatia Spencer Kuvin Letter with follow up request for NPA
8/4/2009 Spencer Kuvin Villafana Letter in response to request for NPA
8/5/2009 Respondent BB's Motion to Supplement the Record (4D09-2554)
8/20/2009 Jeffrey Epstein's Response to Motion to Supplement the Record (4D09-2554)
9/1/2009 Roy Black A. Marie
Villafaria
Draft of letter regarding breach of Non Prosecution Agreement with
handwritten attorney (Villafana) notes
9/ 1/2009 Sloman Roy Black Letter re Epstein wanting to transfer his supervision from State of Florida to
the Virgin Islands 90
9/17/2008 Draft of letter regarding transfer of supervision to the Virgin Islands with
attorney
9/ 18/2009 Black Villafana Letter in response to transfer of supervision to the Virgin Islands (Villafafia) Letter
notes
9/29/2009 Hon. Jeffrey
Colbath
Adam Horowitz Letter that Epstein violated his No -Contact Order on 9/16/09 by coming
within 10 feet of Horowitz's client, Individual #44, Jane Doe No. 4.
10/21/2009 Villafafia Roy Black Response to 9/18/09 letter
10/29/2009 Open file and request USAO# (2009R02690, Operation Stolen Globe)
Privileged Confidential Page 49 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
12/9/2009 Villafafia Roy Black Letter in response to 11/02/09 letter re Epstein's place of employment with
attached Complaint against Scott Rothstein and Bradley J. Edwards
1/4/2010 Villafafia Spencer Kuvin Letter re computer seized by FBI
1/20/2010 Villafalia Roy Black Letter re attorney's fees
1/21/2010 Villafatia Roy Black Email re 1/20/10 letter
2/11/2010 Roy Black Villafafia Letter in follow up to meeting held week prior
2/18/2010 Villafatia Roy Black Letter in response to 2/11/10 letter from Villafatia
3/4/2010 Roy Black and
Martin Weinberg Critton Letter on thoughts and issues concerning NPA
3/5/2010 Sloman, . Villafana, Senior Roy Black Letter renewing request for clarity as to what legal issues civil counsel
can . itigated without causing breach
of NPA
3/29/2010 Sloman,
Villafana,  Senior Roy Black Letter re Motion to Dismiss
4/2/2010 Roy Black Villafafia Letter re obligation to victims
7/1/2010 7/1/2010-7/31/2010 Epstein completed term of house arrest
9/8/2010 Administrative Order closing case
3/20/2011 Letter from Acosta re Epstein case
7/29/2011 Villafalia Lefkowitz Letter in response to 7/27/11 letter from Villafafia
8/1/2011
Emails between Richard Sudder, Assistant General Counsel, Executive Office
for United States Attorneys, and Benjamin Greenberg, First Assistant U.S.
Attorney, Southern District of Florida, regarding Formal Notice of Office-
wide Recusal of Southern District of Florida dated July 28, August 3, August
24 and August 29, 2011
Privileged Confidential Page 50 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION TIMELINE
Date To From Re: Exhibit #
8/24/2011
Wilfredo Ferrer
(U.S. Attorney,
SDFL), Robert
O'Neill (U.S.
Attorney,
MDFL),
Benjamin
Greenberg
(FAUSA,
SDFL), and Lee
Bentley
(FAUSA,
MDFL)
Richard Sudder
Email regarding Formal Notice of Office-wide Recusal of Southern District of
Florida. Cc's David MSODAG), Jay Macklin (USAEO), Thomas
Anderson (USAEO), Tapken (USAEO), and James Read (USAEO)
Privileged Confidential Page 51 of 51 Contains 6(e) Material
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
FGJ 07-103(WPB)
U.S. District Judge Donald M. Middlebrooks
IN RE:
GRAND JURY PROCEEDINGS
SEALED ORDER GRANTING APPLICATION FOR PERMISSION TO DISCLOSE
GRAND JURY MATERIAL
THIS MATTER has come before the Court on the United States' Sealed Application for
Permission to Disclose Grand Jury Material and for Entry of a Protective Order. The Court has
considered the Motion and finds that:

(I) the United States has shown a "particularized need" for the limited disclosure of
materials related to matters occurring before the Grand Jury;

(2) the United States has shown that the disclosure is "in connection with a judicial
proceeding," that is, in connection with an administrative proceeding conducted by the Justice
Department's Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR) arising out of a decision by United
States District Judge Kenneth A. Marra in the matter of Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2I United
States, S.D. Fla. Case No. 08-80736-Civ-Marra;

(3) the materials are needed to avoid an injustice in another proceeding, that is, the
OPR administrative proceeding and any referrals to state bar authorities, other government
agencies for law enforcement purposes, courts, and grand juries in accordance with OPR's Policies
and Procedures;
(4) the need for disclosure is greater than the need for continued secrecy; and
(5) the request is structured to cover only the needed materials.
Accordingly, the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida,
including Assistant United States Attorney A. Marie Villafafia, and the Justice Department's
Office of Professional Responsibility may disclose to attorney Jonathan Biran matters occurring
before the grand jury necessary to: (a) allow AUSA Villafafia to respond to OPR's written
questions; (b) prepare for OPR's interview of AUSA Villafarla; and (c) participate fully in OPR's
interview of AUSA Villafaiia.
Disclosure shall be limited as set forth in the attached Protective Order.
To the extent that AUSA Villafafla's May 10, 2019 Response to OPR's written questions
and any drafts thereof disclosed any material that arguably referred to matters occurring before the
grand jury, this Order is entered nuns pro tune to authorize those disclosures to Mr. Biran.
This Order and the attached Protective Order shall be SEALED, except that copies may be
provided to the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida, which may provide
copies to OPR and attorney Jonathan Biran.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Done and Ordered in West Palm Beach, Fl ay of May, 2 19.
Certified Copies Furnished to:
AUSA A. Marie Villafaila
ALD M. MIDDLEBROOKS
UNITED STATES DISTRICT TT 1111W
Certified to be a true and
correct copy of the document on file
Angola E. Noble, Clerk,
Distri C
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
FGJ 07-103(WPB)
U.S. District Judge Donald M. Middlebrooks
IN RE:
GRAND JURY PROCEEDINGS
SEALED PROTECTIVE ORDER
This matter came before the Court on the United States' Sealed Application for Permission
to Disclose Grand Jury Material and for Entry of a Protective Order. Having granted the
Application to Disclose Grand Jury Material in a separate Order, the Court hereby enters the
following Protective Order, which governs the conditions for disclosure, maintenance, and
destruction of any material containing "matters occurring before the grand jury" (hereinafter
referred to as "grand jury material").
Accordingly, it is HEREBY ORDERED THAT:

1. The government is authorized nunc pro tune to produce to attorney Jonathan Biran
of Baker Donelson grand jury material relevant to his representation of Assistant U.S. Attorney A.
Marie Villafafia that is necessary to: (a) allow AUSA Villafafia to respond to OPR's written
questions; (b) prepare for OPR's interview of AUSA Villafaila; and (c) participate fully in OPR's
interview of AUSA Villafafia.

2. The government and Mr. Biran shall make efforts to minimize the amount of grand
jury material produced to or maintained by Mr. Biran. Mr. Biran shall not be given copies of
subpoenas, documents produced in response to subpoenas, transcripts, proposed or completed
indictments, prosecution memoranda, or items prepared for use in front of the grand jury, but these
Page 1 of 2
items may be shown to Mr. Biran and discussed in preparation sessions and during interviews.

3. Any hard copies of grand jury material provided to Mr. Biran shall not be
photocopied and shall be securely maintained.

4. Any digital copies of grand jury material provided to Mr. Biran shall be encrypted.
5. Any grand jury material provided to Mr. Biran can only be reviewed by him and
not by anyone else in his firm.
6. At the conclusion of the OPR proceedings and any related proceedings wherein Mr.
Biran represents AUSA Villafaha, all grand jury material in Mr. Biran's possession shall be
destroyed. Hard copy documents must be shredded and electronic documents must be deleted
and purged.
DONE AND ORDERED this  ,i li day of May,
Certified to be a true and correct copy of the document on file
Angela E. Noble, Clerk,
U S. Distr ct C
ALD M. MIDDLEBROOKS
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
I certify that I have read and agree to be bound by the terms of this Protective Order:
Date:
Jonathan Biran, Esq.
Baker Donelson
Page 2 of 2
STATEMENT OF A. MARIE VILLAFARA IN RESPONSE TO
APRIL 2, 2019 LETTER FROM JEFFREY It RAGSDALE
To the extent possible, I have provided all information relevant to your inquiry, including
applicable documents. Due to the passage of time, updates to various software and hardware, and
the crash of my work laptop several years ago, I no longer have every piece of relevant material
and my memory may be imperfect.' I have organized the response to conform with the April 2,
2019 letter from Jeffrey R. Ragsdale to Jonathan Biran. Please note that there were numerous oral
and written communications between others at the U.S. Attorney's Office and the Justice
Department with counsel for Mr. Epstein. While in some cases I was told of the communications
or cc'ed on emails or letters summarizing the communications, for many conversations, meetings,
and emails, I do not have knowledge of what occurred.
Introduction
The investigation of Jeffrey Epstein and a series of co-conspirators, named "Operation
Leap Year," officially began in May 2006. In theory, it was supposed to conclude on September
24, 2007 with the signing of a "Non-Prosecution Agreement" ("NPA").2 As will be discussed
below, the investigation presented several issues of first impression and challenges related to
obtaining evidence and securing the cooperation of witnesses. Nonetheless, I felt certain that the
agents, my co-counsel, 'it a very strong case ag three
rsonal assistants — Adriana Ross, a/k/a " and
The case was presented for federal investigation by the Palm Beach Police Department
after they felt that Jeffrey Epstein's legal team had put inappropriate pressure on the Palm Beach
County State Attorney's Office to file only misdemeanor charges. Allegations of misconduct had
been leveled against the local detective and the Police Chief and they reported being followed and
harassed. As described below, the defense attorneys employed the same tactics at the federal level
against myself and the FBI.
With regard to the exhibits, whenever possible, I have used copies of original documents
or "scanned" originals that were made at the time. In some cases, all that I have are the electronic
documents (i.e., the Word Perfect letter that was printed, signed, and mailed or faxed). Because
our computers no longer have Word Perfect, I have used "Quick Print" which has distorted the
formatting. If I am providing something that I know is a "draft," I note that either in the text or in
the exhibit list. The fact that something does not contain a signature does not mean that it is a
draft, it just means that it was printed from the electronic version and I no longer have (or never
had) a copy of the original. For example, I often drafted letters for the signatures of Andrew
Lourie, Jeff Sloman, and Alex Acosta. Their assistants would have maintained the signed
originals. In some cases, I would be provided with copies and sometimes I would not. I would
usually notate my electronic files with "final" to know which was the final version, or the last-
modified version.
2 For reasons set forth below, the investigation continued due to Epstein's post-NPA
conduct.
Page 1 of 58
Once the USAO opened the file, Epstein took the same approach that had been used with
the State — at each level of review, he hired an attorney with a personal connection to the
AUSA/USAJDOJ Attorney who was conducting the review. The attorneys raised a series of
challenges to the veracity of the victims and the veracity of the state investigators, as well as quasi-
Petite-policy arguments. When those failed, more formal legal analysis and federalism policy
arguments were presented.
Throughout this process, I wanted to keep my investigation as confidential as possible. For
example, I did not see the benefit of telling Epstein's counsel that we had uncovered additional
victims, that we had been able to corroborate victims' accounts, or the legal theories that we were
pursuing. My objections to making these disclosures were all overruled. Also, unbeknownst to
me, at least one supervisory AUSA was engaging in plea discussions with counsel for Epstein
without consulting with me, the agents, or the victims. These discussions led to the creation of the
NPA — an agreement that allowed Epstein to plead guilty to state charges in exchange for immunity
for federal prosecution by the USAO for the Southern District of Florida.
After the NPA was signed on September 24, 2007, when I attempted to notify the victims
and enforce the agreement, the attacks became more personal. Epstein's attorneys raised the same
policy arguments — which could have been raised prior to signing the NPA — as high as the DAG's
Office, and coupled them with claims of prosecutorial misconduct. As these attacks occurred, the
USAOU.S. Attorney Alex Acosta and later First Assistant U.S. Attorney Jeff Sloman offered
Epstein the option of simply "unwinding"3 the NPA — after all, he had never performed any part
of it. In my mind it was unfathomable that Epstein would be allowed to spend months attacking
not just the validity of our investigation and the validity of the NPA, but also making false
allegations of prosecutorial misconduct against myself and FAUSA Sloman and still be allowed
the benefit of what was, in my opinion, an unreasonably favorable agreement. Since everyone
from the U.S. Attorney down to me agreed that the case was headed for a trial, the investigation
continued, including identifying additional victims, conducting interviews, issuing grand jury
subpoenas, drafting revised indictment packages, and presenting testimony to the grand jury.
Epstein's clear intent to go to trial was on display during this period as he deposed victims
identified only through the federal investigation in the guise of taking discovery in the state case.
On June 23, 2008, John Roth in the DAG's Office issued his letter denying Epstein's final
appeal. While USA Acosta allowed Epstein the benefit of the NPA, Epstein still tried to avoid
several key parts of the NPA's terms, and would have escaped them but for my insistence.
On June 30, 2008, Epstein entered his guilty plea in state court and was sentenced to 18
months' in the county jail in accordance with the terms of his state plea agreement and the NPA.
Not long thereafter, I learned that Epstein had applied for work release and the Palm Beach County
Sheriff's Office had granted the application. Prior to Epstein's guilty plea, the issue of work
release had been specifically discussed with Epstein's counsel and they informed us that Epstein
would not seek work release. The agents and I also met with the Sheriff's Office in advance of
the plea and had been told that Epstein would not be eligible for work release. Accordingly, I
provided my Notice of Breach, but was told by defense attorney Roy Black that, despite those
specific conversations, USA Acosta himself agreed that Epstein would be eligible for any program
3 "Unwinding" was USA Acosta's term for mutual rescission — the USAO could file its
charges and Epstein would have no obligations to plead guilty in state or federal court.
Page 2 of 58
that the state offered, including work release. Because of this, I had to withdraw the Notice of
Breach and could only write a letter to the Sheriff's Office pointing out all of the false statements
contained in Epstein's application for work release and letters to the victims informing them that
Epstein was in work release status. The Sheriff's Office never responded to or acknowledged my
letter.
On June 9, 2009, I prepared what I believe was the last Memorandum requesting
authorization to issue a Notice of Breach and to indict Epstein. The Office authorized issuance of
the Notice of Breach, and the Indictment Packs es was re-reviewed a roved, and signed, with
arrest warrants for Jeffrey Epstein, and The Notice of Breach
was served on June 12, 2009 at a hearing on pstein's Motion to Dismiss one of the civil suits
filed by one of the victims identified during the federal investigation. Once again, Epstein was
allowed to "cure" his breach, and we were not allowed to file the indictment.
There were strong internal disagreements on a number of subjects, including: the handling
of the meetings with Epstein's counsel; plea negotiations; the NPA generally; the failure to consult
with the victims; continuing plea negotiations in the face of Epstein's clear bad faith; the refusal
to defend me against personal attacks from Epstein's attorneys; the agreement to put off seeking
Epstein's computer equipment; the consultations with Epstein's attorneys regarding victim
notifications; the handling of the "appeals" to Washington; allowing delays during those "appeals,"
while Epstein's attorneys were harassing the victims and their family members; attempts by
Epstein to renegotiate the term of imprisonment; attempts by Epstein to renegotiate the payment
of damages to the victims and attorneys' fees to their attorney representative; allowing Epstein to
participate in the work release program after specifically discussing it during plea negotiations;
and repeatedly allowing Epstein to "cure" intentional breaches of the NPA. These were kept
internal as I tried to deal professionally with opposing counsel.
In the midst of all of the post-NPA back-and-forth with Epstein, was the Jane Doel United
States litigation.° Despite the Office's request to be recused from the case, the Justice Department
decided that there was no conflict of interest and I was tasked with serving as co-counsel. The
Office asserted attorney-client, executive, work product, and deliberative process privileges, so all
of the internal disagreements, pros memos, and indictments were not disclosed while all of my
communications with opposing counsel (often at the behest of supervisors) were disclosed. After
an initial flurry of filings, Brad Edwards, as counsel for the named plaintiffs, stated on the record
that he believed that setting aside the NPA would not benefit his clients, and he sued Epstein on
behalf of a number of victims under the NPA. I did what I could to assist Mr. Edwards, other
attorneys, including Mr. Josefsberg, the attorney selected by the Special Master, and the Court, to
locate victims, provide signed copies of the NPA, and answer questions. After all of the civil suits
between Epstein and the victims were settled through the spectre of breaching the NPA, Mr.
Edwards re-initiated the Jane Doe' United States litigation, asserting that his clients wanted to
4 A few days after Jeffrey Epstein entered his guilty plea in state court, attorney Brad
Edwards filed suit on behalf of one of the victims identified in the federal investigation (later
expanded to include a second victim who had been identified in the state investigation), alleging
violations of the Crimelictims' Rights Act. The suit, which is still pending, is captioned Jane
Doe I and Jane Doe 2 United States, 08-80736-CV-KAM.
Page 3 of 58
set aside the NPA and see Mr. Epstein federally charged due to violations of the Crime Victims'
Rights Act.
In response to your questions, I have attempted to distill the past 13 years of emails, letters,
research, pleadings, and conversations into a coherent document and attach the most relevant
items. Given the sheer volume of materials involved here and the passage of time, while I have
worked diligently to answer your questions as fully as possible, I certainly could have missed
something amongst the thousands of pages of emails, drafts, and hard copy and electronic
documents. If there are additional items or topics that need further explanation or more
documentation, I can delve further.
A. The Non-Prosecution Agreement
1. Describe the circumstances under which the investigation of Jeffrey Epstein
was referred to the USAO, including when, why, how, and by whom the
referral was made. Explain why the USAO decided to initiate a federal grand
jury investigation into this matter, including what federal interests were
perceived to be involved, and identify the individuals participating in the
decision.
Some time in early 2006, FBI Special Agent E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall approached me about
an investigation being conducted by the Town of Palm Beach Police Department ("PBPD"). I do
not know how or when S/A Kuyrkendall was first contacted about the matter.
The first mentions of the investigation were just passing comments during meetings on
other matters. S/A Kuyrkendall and I were working on a number of different child exploitation
matters at the time, along with ICE Special Agent David Malone. I remember generally that S/A
Kuyrkendall mentioned an investigation of a wealthy man who lived on Palm Beach and recruited
minors for sexual activity. During these casual conversations, I do not believe that Mr. Epstein's
name was mentioned. If it was mentioned, it held no significance for me. I recall that S/A
Kuyrkendall mentioned that PBPD had reached out to her because the Palm Beach County State
Attorney's Office was leaning towards not charging the case at all or letting the defendant plead
to a misdemeanor charge of solicitation of prostitution. At some point I told S/A Kuyrkendall that,
if PBPD wanted to look into federal charges, I would need more information about the allegations
and I encouraged her to set up a meeting. I recall S/A Kuyrkendall telling me that PBPD wanted
to give the State Attorney's Office the opportunity to properly charge the case before presenting it
for federal investigation and prosecution.
In May 2006, I met with S/A Kuyrkendall and PBPD Detective Joe Recarey in the 4th Floor
Conference Room at the U.S. Attorney's Office in West Palm Beach. I do not recall whether S/A
Malone was present. Detective Recarey summarized the investigation into state criminal sexual
conduct involving Epstein and his personal assistants. Briefly, Epstein, through his personal
assistants, recruited girls and young womens — mainly from a local high school — to travel to his
residence on Palm Beach to perform erotic massages. Although they had no massage training, the
5 I use these terms deliberately. "Girls" refers to females under the age of 18 and "young
women" refers to females over the age of 18. When I refer to both groups jointly, I will use the
term "females."
Page 4 of 58
girls and young women were coached to massage Mr. Epstein in various states of undress. The
sexual activity varied and included: Mr. Epstein masturbating himself at the end of the massage;
having the females masturbate him; Mr. Epstein fondling the females' breasts and genitalia; using
sex toys on the females; digital penetration of the females; sexual intercourse with Mr. Epstein;
and Mr. Epstein observing while one of the girls had sex with one of his assistants. At the end of
each "massage" session, Mr. Epstein or one of his assistants would pay the female involved. If
the female involved in the massage was brought to Mr. Epstein's residence by a "recruiter," then
the "recruiter" also would be paid.
Detective Recarey did not have any information regarding any of the females traveling
interstate or internationally to engage in sexual activity, but Det. Recarey reported that Mr. Epstein
and his assistants traveled in and out of the Palm Beach International Airport on Epstein's private
airplane. Det. Recarey stated that flight logs he had seen sometimes referred to passengers as
"females," without names or ages, so it was possible that girls could have been on board, but Det.
Recarey had not been able to confirm that. Det. Recarey stated that a search warrant had been
executed on Mr. Epstein's residence and evidence had been seized, including message pads
showing calls from females confirming that they would be coming to "work," which was the
euphemism used for giving a "massage" — another euphemism for engaging in sexual activity for
money. Det. Recarey also reported that it had appeared that Mr. Epstein had been "tipped oft"
about the coming search warrant because all of the computer CPUs had been removed from the
residence — the keyboards and screens were still in place, just the CPUs had been taken. Det.
Recarey also reported that some surveillance cameras were in place but they had only recovered a
limited amount of surveillance video. Det. Recarey stated that between 20 and 30 females had
been identified [NB: I believe that he told me the exact number, I just don't recall that number
now].
S/A Kuyrkendall and Det. Recarey asked me whether there were federal criminal charges
that could be pursued. I remember getting up from the conference room, walking to my office,
and getting my code book and walking back. I looked through 18 U.S.C. §§ 2422 (enticement of
minors into prostitution/illegal sexual activity) and 2423 (travel for purposes of engaging in illegal
sexual conduct).6 We talked through those statutes and the additional investigation that would be
required to prove that they had been violated, but I told them that, if the evidence was there, it was
a case that could be prosecuted federally.
Det. Recarey then told me that his boss - PBPD Chief Michael Reiter — was still pressing
the State Attorney's Office to arrest Epstein. d p ' of probable cause
affidavits for the arrests of Jeffrey Epstein, and charging a large
number of state criminal violations. Chief Reiter ad asked the Palm Beach County State Attorney,
Barry Krischer, to authorize the arrests and he had refused. According to Det. Recarey, pressure
had been brought to bear on SA Krischer by Epstein's attorneys, who included Guy Fronstin and
Jack Goldberger (two personal friends of Krischer), and Alan Dershowitz. Det. Recarey stated
that he and Chief Reiter were concerned that Epstein would be charged only with a misdemeanor
or perhaps would not be charged at all.
6 As the investigation progressed, I looked into other federal crimes, but at that first
meeting, I only remember looking at §§ 2422 and 2423.
Page 5 of 58
I recommended that we begin the process of investigating whether there was a
jurisdictional basis for federal charges, and S/A Kuyrkendall and Det. Recarey concurred. Det.
Recarey asked that Chief Reiter be given an additional opportunity to convince the State Attorney
to charge Epstein.' I explained that opening a case file and beginning a federal investigation would
not preclude the State Attorney from charging Epstein.
I then prepared the paperwork to open a file. The investigation was dubbed "Operation
Leap Year" because there were approximately 29 young women and girls who had been identified
through the State investigation.
There were several aspects of the case that involved federal interests. First, as to the
substantive crimes that Epstein was accused of committing, they involved the victimization of
minor females through the use of facilities of interstate commerce (telephones and airports); and
Epstein was traveling interstate and internationally to come to the Southern District of Florida to
commit those offenses. During the course of the investigation, I often said that, if there were a
trial, I would tell the jury that Jeffrey Epstein traveled to Florida to use Royal Palm Beach High
School as his personal brothel. Second, the removal of the computer equipment from Epstein's
home prior to the execution of the search warrant suggested possible public corruption at the Palm
Beach County courthouse (where the search warrant application was signed) and also raised the
possibility that Epstein may have been involved in the manufacture and/or possession of child
pornography. Eradication of child pornography was a particular focus of Project Safe Childhood;
its production and storage on computer equipment involved the use of items produced in interstate
and foreign commerce; and child pornography was often distributed through facilities of interstate
and foreign commerce. Third, Det. Recarey was suggesting that political or other pressure was
being placed on an elected official (the State Attorney) to avoid or minimize criminal exposure for
a person who committed numerous state crimes related to the exploitation of girls and young
women. Setting aside the issue of prostitution, the sexual activity involving girls under the age of
16 could be charged as sex battery in the state. Ignoring those crimes suggested possible public
corruption or, at the least, a miscarriage of justice.
With regard to the logistics of opening the case file, the opening of files in West Palm
Beach is relatively informal. In instances where an agent approaches a line AUSA directly (either
because it is a duty matter or because the investigation is within the AUSA's area of expertise),
the line AUSA will give his or her assistant the details of the case for the LIONS file-opening
paperwork and then give a brief oral explanation of the case to his/her supervisor along with the
paperwork. If the supervisor agrees that a file should be opened, he or she will normally sign the
LIONS form on the spot and hand the file back to the AUSA. In this case, I prepared a file jacket;
my assistant did the LIONS paperwork; I signed the conflict form; briefed my supervisor, Karen
Atkinson; and she signed the LIONS paperwork assigning the case to me. This all occurred either
on the day of the meeting with Detective Recarey and S/A Kuyrkendall or within a few days
thereafter. Attached hereto as Exhibit 2 is the file opening paperwork and file jacket showing that
the case was opened in LIONS on May 23, 2006.
I do recall that at some time relatively soon after the file was opened, I did something that
I had never done before or since. I initiated a meeting with the U.S. Attorney and the First
7 Although I did not know it at the time, on May I, 2006, Chief Reiter sent a letter to State
Attorney Krischer asking Krischer to consider recusing himself from the case. (Exhibit 1.)
Page 6 of 58
Assistant, Alex Acosta and Jeff Sloman, where I traveled to Miami and told them about the case.
I recall that I explained the case and how the PBPD believed that Epstein had used political or
other pressure to avoid serious punishment in Palm Beach County state court. That possibility
troubled me greatly; hence, my request to meet with executive management. Messrs. Acosta and
Sloman had the same reaction that I had the first time that Det. Recarey told me about Mr. Epstein
— if I have never heard of him, how much influence could this person have? I remember
specifically saying to them that I expected the case would be time and resource-intensive and I did
not want to invest the time and the FBI's resources if the Office would just back down to pressure
at the end. Messrs. Acosta and Sloman assured me that, if there was sufficient evidence to support
the case, Mr. Epstein would be charged appropriately.8
2. Describe in detail your role, and the role of each other person in the USAO,
the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), and elsewhere within the
Department of Justice — collectively herein "the government" — who was
involved in the assessment of the viability and strength of the federal case
against Mr. Epstein and in the decision to negotiate a pre-indictment
resolution of the case.
My Role
I was the line AUSA assigned to the case. In conjunction with the case agents, I handled
all aspects of the grand jury investigation — deciding what subpoenas to issue; whom to interview;
whom to call to testify before the grand jury; what lines of inquiry to pursue to support various
legal theories; I conducted legal research to support charges; I reached out to others throughout the
Department and the federal government for information on previous investigations of Mr. Epstein,
and for legal guidance on various aspects of the case (e.g., OEO, CEOS, SEC, SDNY, and
AFMLS); along with the FBI agents and the FBI Victim-Witness Coordinator, I had direct contact
with victims via interviews, meetings, and consultations regarding safety/privacy/mental health
concerns; and I handled all court proceedings related to the investigation. When I felt that
sufficient evidence had been collected to prove Mr. Epstein's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, I
drafted a prosecution memorandum, indictment, and related documents. I revised those documents
in response to comments from those in the supervisory chain of command and, as explained below,
after additional evidence was secured. I participated in some (but not all) of the meetings between
members of the USAO and counsel for Jeffrey Epstein. I prepared briefing materials for
management in preparation for those meetings and in response to issues raised during those
meetings.
Normally the assigned line AUSA handles plea negotiations, and I recommended that I
enter into negotiations that would result in a joint federal and state resolution (i.e., a plea to federal
8 I do not have a contemporaneous memorandum and cannot find the date of the meeting.
In a July 13, 2007 email exchange between myself and Criminal Chief Matt Menchel, I describe
the meeting as follows: "I summarized the case and the State Attorney's Office's handling of it.
I acknowledged that we needed to do work to collect the evidence establishing a federal nexus,
and I noted the time and money that would be required for an investigation. I said that I was
willing to invest that time and the FBI was willing to invest the money, but I didn't want to get to
the end and then have the Office be intimidated by the high-powered lawyers. I was assured that
that would not happen." (See Exhibit 3.)
Page 7 of 58
charges in federal court and a plea to state charges in state court). I was reprimanded for doing so.
Thus, as will be discussed in more detail below, I played no role in the decision to enter into a
Non-Prosecution Agreement in exchange for Jeffrey Epstein's entry of a guilty plea to a state
charge requiring a sentence of 18 months' imprisonment or Epstein's plea to federal charges
resulting in a maximum sentence of 18 months' imprisonment (as will be explained below,
Epstein's counsel repeatedly changed their minds about whether to take the federal route or the
state route). Although I was tasked with drafting the agreements and Information, all of the
documents were repeatedly and substantively revised by various supervisors, and I was responsible
for incorporating those edits. I also was asked to sign the Non-Prosecution Agreement.
When Epstein sought to have the Non-Prosecution Agreement set aside by "appealing" the
matter to CEOS, the AAG, and the DAG, I handled the continued investigation of Epstein,
including working with the FBI to identify additional victims, issue additional grand jury
subpoenas, and prepare an updated indictment package. At the request of the U.S. Attorney, I also
responded to inquiries from CEOS, the AAG, and the DAG's Office and drafted submissions on
behalf of the USAO in response to arguments raised by Epstein's attorneys.
I believe that I prepared a first draft of the Addendum to the Non-Prosecution Agreement,
but others took the laboring oar on that document. I drafted numerous victim notification letters
and responded to defense objections to those letters. I drafted the letter to the Special Master with
the USAO's recommendations for the qualities to look for in the attorney representative for the
victims. I monitored Epstein's compliance with the Non-Prosecution Agreement and served
several breach notices.
U.S. Attorney's Office Personnel
AUSA Karen Atkinson (now retired): AUSA Atkinson was my direct supervisor. She
reviewed indictment packages and other court-related matters and provided guidance and
served as a "sounding board" for many of my concerns. As will be explained below, AUSA
Atkinson did not participate in many of the meetings between the USAO and Epstein's
counsel because Epstein's counsel "skipped her" in the chain of command, directing their
communications to MAUSA9 Andrew Lourie, Criminal Chief Matt Menchel, First
Assistant Jeff Sloman, and U.S. Attorney Alex Acosta. AUSA Atkinson did participate in
meetings with the Palm Beach Sheriff's Office about Epstein's work release and several
conference calls with defendant attorney Roy Black and others about Epstein's breaches of
the Non-Prosecution Agreement.
MAUSA Andrew Lourie (now in private practice): MAUSA Lourie was my second-
line supervisor and head of the West Palm Beach office. Over the objection of myself and
my co-counsel, he granted the request of Epstein's attorneys to meet to allow Epstein's
attorneys to argue that the USAO should decline the matter. That began the series of
meetings between all levels of the USAO and Epstein's counsel. MAUSA Lourie reviewed
my work; asked me to conduct some specific research; and reviewed drafts of our responses
9 The Managing Assistant U.S. Attorney ("MAUSA") is the head of the West Palm Beach
Office.
Page 8 of 58
to legal arguments raised by Epstein's counsel. MAUSA Lourie also participated in
conversations with the State Attorney, and directly participated in negotiations of the
language to be used in the Non-Prosecution Agreement, federal Plea Agreement, and
Information. He had numerous conversations with counsel for Epstein outside of my
presence when they objected to my refusal to agree with their changes. MAUSA Lourie
also communicated with the U.S. Attorney about the negotiations. He would then
communicate changes from the defense and the U.S. Attorney to me to incorporate. Later,
when Epstein's attorneys appealed to AAG Alice Fisher, Mr. Lourie was on detail as AAG
Fisher's Chief of Staff and facilitated the meeting between Epstein's counsel and the AAG.
AAG Fisher's written response was issued while MAUSA Lourie was still her Chief of
Staff. I do not know who drafted the written response.
Acting MAUSA Rolando Garcia (still with the USAO): When MAUSA Lourie was on
detail with AAG Fisher's Office, Rolando Garcia was named the Acting MAUSA. He
participated in at least one meeting with Epstein's attorneys and the State Attorney. Mr.
Garcia also was involved in some of the negotiations regarding the language of the Non-
Prosecution Agreement. He later reviewed at least one of the iterations of the indictment
package and signed the indictment that was supposed to be presented to the grand jury in
June 2009.
Criminal Chief Matthew Menchel (now in private practice): Criminal Chief Menchel
was the third line supervisor of the matter. Generally, West Palm Beach indictments are
reviewed and approved by the MAUSA and are not reviewed by Miami. However, unusual
or especially significant indictments are reviewed by the Criminal Chief. Criminal Chief
Menchel reviewed and commented on the first proposed indictment package. His
comments were incorporated into a revised indictment, and he possibly reviewed those
changes. Criminal Chief Menchel participated in numerous meetings on the case, and had
private conversations regarding resolution of the matter with Lilly Ann Sanchez, counsel
to Mr. Epstein. Ms. Sanchez had formerly served as Deputy Chief in the Major Crimes
Section at the USAO while Mr. Menchel was Chief of Major Crimes. As discussed below,
on July 26, 2007, Criminal Chief Menchel announced to the investigative team that U.S.
Attorney Acosta had decided to offer a two-year plea to Mr. Epstein. On August 3, 2007,
Mr. Menchel sent a letter to Ms. Sanchez regarding that plea offer. Mr. Menchel left the
U.S. Attorney's Office on that date to become a partner at Kobre & Kim in New York.
First Assistant Jeffrey Sloman (now in private practice): FAUSA Sloman (later U.S.
Attorney Sloman) was involved in telephone calls and meetings with counsel for Mr.
Epstein; when Epstein's attorneys were dissatisfied with my proposed language for the
Non-Prosecution Agreement, victim notification letters, letters to the Special Master, etc.,
they would frequently contact FAUSA Sloman directly to complain. FAUSA Sloman
handled the bulk of the negotiations of the Addendum to the NPA. Epstein's attorneys
later complained that FAUSA Sloman was biased because his daughter had been the victim
Page 9 of 58
of a crime. One of Epstein's attorneys also falsely accused FAUSA Sloman (and me) of
promising money to a victim in exchange for her willingness to accuse Epstein.
U.S. Aftorney R. Alexander Acosta (now Secretary of the U.S. Department of Labor):
USA Acosta served as the head of the U.S. Attorney's Office throughout the investigation
of Jeffrey Epstein, including the decision to enter into a Non-Prosecution Agreement,
negotiation of its terms, and attempts to enforce its terms. When Epstein's attorneys were
dissatisfied with answers they received from me, MAUSA Lourie, and FAUSA Sloman,
they would frequently contact USA Acosta directly. USA Acosta was directly involved in
reviewing and revising the documents, including sending exact wording that he wanted
incorporated into the agreement. There were some communications between USA Acosta
and counsel for Epstein that I was not aware of at the time. For example, I did not know,
until after I had sent a breach notice, that USA Acosta agreed that Epstein could be
considered for work release. At some point after the NPA was signed, USA Acosta was
recused from the Epstein matter.
AUSA John McMillan (still at USA0): Early in the investigation, I asked AUSA
McMillan if he would serve as co-counsel on the case. Before I joined the West Palm
Beach Office, AUSA McMillan had handled the bulk of the child exploitation cases in
West Palm Beach. He and I discussed how to structure the investigation and he joined me
in opposing meeting with Epstein's attorneys prior to the completion of the investigation.
He attended some of the meetings with Epstein's attorneys. When the Office overruled
our positions and when it appeared that the case was not going to be charged, AUSA
McMillan decided that he should focus on other cases.
AUSA Bruce Reinhart (now U.S. Magistrate Judge): AUSA Reinhart was my office
neighbor and colleague. At one point early in the investigation (I believe before I asked
AUSA McMillan to serve as co-counsel), I sought AUSA Reinhart's counsel on strategies
for how to handle Epstein's personal assistants — whether they should be charged or if we
should seek immunity for them. Not long thereafter, AUSA Reinhart came to me and said
that he was best friends with one of Epstein's attorneys, Jack Goldberger, and accordingly
could not discuss the Epstein case with me any further. AUSA Reinhart left the U.S.
Attorney's Office for private practice and later represented one of Epstein's assistants in
the civil suits filed by Epstein's victims.
AUSA Toni Barnes (now retired): Asset Forfeiture AUSA assigned to the Epstein case.
I had a few brief meetings with AUSA Barnes to talk about the asset forfeiture aspects of
the case. We discussed the charges under consideration and Epstein's assets that could be
subject to forfeiture. AUSA Barnes had direct contact with the agents and the FBI's asset
forfeiture coordinator about information/evidence that she needed to pursue forfeiture.
AUSA Barnes provided the asset forfeiture language in the proposed indictments.
Page 10 of 58
SLC Dexter Lee (still at USAO): SLC Lee was not directly involved in the Epstein
investigation or negotiation of the NPA, but he has been lead counsel in the Jane Doe'.
United States litigation. SLC Lee had contact with USA Acosta regarding his recusal, and
with FAUSA Sloman and myself regarding self-reports to OPR about accusations of
misconduct raised by Epstein's counsel. I also had contact with SLC Lee regarding a
Florida Bar Complaint filed by a civil attorney for some of the victims who complained
that my victim notification letters amounted to inappropriate business referrals to the
attorney selected by the Special Master.1°
Appellate SLC Anne Ruth Schultz (still at USAO): SLC Schultz was not directly
involved in the Epstein investigation or negotiation of the NPA. It is my understanding
that USA Acosta asked SLC Schultz to check my legal analysis. I also understand that
Criminal Chief Matt Menchel contacted SLC Schultz about moving me to Appeals after I
pointed out actions that I considered to be in violation of the Ashcroft memo and victims'
rights legislation. I also understand that SLC Schultz may have knowledge of USA Acosta
providing my prosecution memorandum to Criminal Appellate Chief Patty Stemler at Main
Justice.
Shawn Ball (still at USAO): My legal assistant during most of the Epstein investigation
and its aftermath. She assisted with preparing indictment packages, victim notification
letters, grand jury subpoenas, travel, expert witness contracts, and other items.
Cyndee Campos/Annette Castillo (both still at USAO): Executive assistants to AUSA
Acosta and FAUSA Sloman. They compiled correspondence between the USAO and
counsel for Epstein; scheduled meetings; and dealt with inquiries from the press and DOJ.
They may have information related to correspondence or communications between the
Executive Division and Epstein's counsel that I am unaware of.
FBI Personnel
S/A Nesbitt Kuyrkendall (retired from FBI): Lead case agent on Operation Leap Year.
She presented the case to the USAO, handled the bulk of the interviews, served subpoenas,
and testified before the grand jury. She communicated directly with victims and hand-
delivered the original victim notification letters. S/A Kuyrkendall also participated in
meetings with some of the senior members of the USAO and counsel for Epstein.
1° The Florida Bar determined that my victim notification letters, which are included in the
exhibits and advised the victims that they had the absolute right to select another attorney if they
so desired, were not inappropriate solicitations and did not violate the Florida Bar Rules. The
attorney who filed the complaint, Jeff Herman, later resigned from the Florida Bar due to
disciplinary action taken against him.
Page 11 of 58
S/A Jason Richards (still at FBI): Co-case agent with S/A Kuyrkendall. Became lead
case agent during the post-guilty plea period (i.e., the interview of
responding to FOIA requests, etc.). He conducted interviews, prepared reports, analyzed
records, and communicated directly with victims. S/A Richards also participated in
meetings with some of the senior members of the USAO and counsel for Epstein.
S/A Tim Slater (still at FBI): Co-case agent with S/A Kuyrkendall until he was
trans I e conducted interviews, including the original telephone interview
with where she asked that the FBI have no further contact with her. He
also prepared reports and analyzed records.
Group Supervisor Eliasib ("Junior") Ortiz (still at FBI): GS Ortiz supervised S/As
Kuyrkendall, Richards, and Slater. He also participated in meetings with some of the senior
members of the USAO and counsel for Epstein.
ASAC Valerie Parlave (still at FBI): ASAC Parlave supervised GS Ortiz. She attended
the July 26, 2007 meeting where Criminal Chief Menchel announced the two-year plea
offer.
S/A Pryor: S/A Pryor participated in the interview of in
Australia.
S/A Gavin Gumbiner (still at FBI): S/A Gumbiner was the case agent on Operation
Stolen Globe, which involved the investigation of Alfredo Rodriguez (Jeffrey Epstein's
butler), who tried to sell evidence to Brad Edwards.
Group Supervisor Michael Donohoe (retired from FBI): GS Donohoe replaced GS
Ortiz as head of the violent crime group during the post-guilty plea period. He supervised
S/As Richards, Pryor, and Gumbiner.
Victim-Witness Coordinator Twiler Smith: Ms. Smith sent letters to victims, met with
them in person. and assisted in finding counseling and other services for them.
Justice Denar ment Personnel
CEOS Deputy Chief Gelber (still at DOJ): Ms. Gelber was part of the team
that reviewed the case and the NPA when Epstein "appealed" to DOJ. Ms. Gelber also is
familiar with my work from a prior case that she and I worked on together as well as other
PSC cases where I have consulted with her.
CEOS Chief Drew Oosterbaan (now private in-house counsel): Mr. Oosterbaan
reviewed and opined on the case and the NPA when Epstein "appealed" to DOJ. He also
attended meetings in the SDFL with myself, the case agents, USAO supervisory staff, and
Page 12 of 58
counsel for Epstein. I conferred with Mr. Oosterbaan about charging, staffing, and victim-
related issues.
CEOS Trial Attorney Myesha Braden (now at a non-profit): I first had contact with

Ms. Braden when conducting research regarding some of the legal issues raised by the case
(she was the CEOS Duty Attorney on the day that I called). After AUSA McMillan left
the case, I contacted Mr. Oosterbaan about having a CEOS Trial Attorney co-chair the case
and asked if Ms. Braden was available. She participated in interviews, discussed case
strategy, and reviewed pros memos and indictments.
Criminal Appellate Chief Patty Stemler (still at DOJ): At various times, I have heard
that USA Acosta provided my pros memo to Chief Stemler and asked her to review my
legal analysis. I have never asked Chief Stemler whether this actually occurred. SLC Anne
Schultz may know whether this occurred.
AAG Alice Fisher (now in private practice): After CEOS rejected the "appeal" from

Mr. Epstein's attorneys, they asked for further review by AAG Fisher. She met with the
attorneys and prepared a written opinion rejecting Epstein's arguments.
Senior Associate Deputy Attorney General John Roth (now private in-house counsel):
Following AAG Fisher's rejection, Epstein's attorneys asked for review by the DAG. I do
not know whether Epstein's counsel met with the DAG, but they did present arguments to

Mr. Roth, who was Chief of StafPSr. Associate Deputy Attorney General. Mr. Roth wrote
a letter rejecting Epstein's arguments.
Deputy Attorney General Mark Filip (now in private practice): Mark Filip was the
Deputy Attorney General to whom Mr. Epstein's arguments were addressed. As noted
above, I do not know if Mr. Filip met with Epstein's counsel, or if the meetings were only
held with Mr. Roth.
Others Whose Counsel I Sought During the Case:
Assistant U.S. Attorney Susan Roe (still an AUSA in Seattle): AUSA Roe was not
involved in the Epstein investigation. During the pendency of the Epstein investigation,
she began investigating David Copperfield, who was a friend of Epstein, and we conferred
with each other about strategy. I informed AUSA Roe of the difficulties in convincing the
Office to prosecute Epstein.
Attorney Advisor Tammie Gregg (still at DOJ): Ms. Gregg is a friend from my days at
Dorsey & Whitney. She joined the Justice Department before I did and we have stayed in
contact over the years. She had experience with USA Acosta when he was the head of the
Civil Rights Section at Main Justice so I turned to her for advice in handling the Epstein
situation.
Page 13 of 58
Assistant U.S. Attorney E.J. Yera (still at DO.)): Mr. Yera and I were dating at the time
of the Epstein investigation. (We are now married.) He was a more senior AUSA who
was familiar with some of Epstein's counsel. I sought his advice on some of the issues —
legal and non-legal — that arose during the case.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Lynn Kirkpatrick (still at the USAO): Ms. Kirkpatrick and I
are friends from my time in Miami. She was a supervisor in Miami although not in my
chain of command. I would often speak or email with her just for advice.
3. Explain fully the process and circumstances leading to the decision to resolve
the case through a non-prosecution agreement (sometimes referred to by
defense counsel and the government as a deferred prosecution agreement, but
described herein as the non-prosecution agreement). Explain why the
government initially prepared to resolve the case through a federal plea
agreement, but ultimately did not require Mr. Epstein to enter a plea in federal
court. The explanation should identify the parties involved in the decision, the
individual(s) responsible for all final decisions regarding the non-prosecution
agreement and its terms, and the basis for the decision to resolve the case
through a non-prosecution agreement.
Let me preface with some background on how I normally handle investigations and
prosecutions. When undertaking investigations, my normal practice is to meet with agents, confer
with them about an investigative plan, and work together until the case is ready for indictment. I
update my supervisors along the way, seek advice or guidance from supervisors and colleagues if
an issue is especially complex or novel, and get approval for actions as required by the USAM,
but I have always focused on learning as much as possible about the subject area, the defendant,
and the facts related to the alleged crime — I want to be the subject matter expert in the courtroom.
Then, once all of those items are completed, I prepare a comprehensive prosecution memo and
proposed indictment, which are submitted for review.
I believe strongly that investigations — especially child exploitation investigations — should
be conducted as covertly as possible in order to protect the victims' privacy; to avoid harm to the
accused's reputation if the accusation is determined to be false; and to maintain the sanctity of the
investigation. In Mr. Epstein's case, these concerns were heightened for several reasons. First,
victims identified during the state investigation had expressed fears of Epstein and building trust
with them would require assurances that Epstein would not find out that they were talking with
federal investigators. Second, the victims were between the ages of approximately 15 and 20" --
ages when women and girls might minimize or deny sexual abuse to avoid being labeled as "sluts."
Third, Epstein had made allegations in the state case that the victims were only after money and
that investigators were only after fame. Maintaining the investigation's confidentiality would
delegitimize both of those allegations. It also would avoid interference/intimidation by Epstein
and his counsel.
" They had been 14 to 17 years old at the time of the sexual activity, but time had passed.
Page 14 of 58
My confidentiality rule extends to pm-indictment communications with defendants and
their attorneys. In cases where defendants are considered a flight risk, I generally have no contact
pre-indictment. If proven, the crimes under investigation created a statutory presumption that the
defendant was a risk of flight and a danger to the community, and Epstein had virtually unlimited
resources to flee.' 2
Our effort to maintain the confidentiality of the investigation was thwarted almost
immediately by PBPD Chief Reiter. On July 24, 2006, Chief Reiter sent letters to some of the
victims identified in the state investigation informing them that the State Attorney's Office had
decided to proceed on a single charge of solicitation of prostitution. (Exhibit 6.) Chief Reiter
encouraged the victims to contact the State Attorney's Office with any complaints about the
handling of the matter. Chief Reiter then felt the need to disclose that he did "not feel that justice
has been sufficiently served by the indictment that has been issued. Therefore, please know that
his [sic] matter has been referred to the Federal Bureau of Investigation to determine if violations
of federal law have occurred." (Id.). While Chief Reiter did not mention the USAO, Epstein's
counsel certainly understood that engaging the FBI meant engaging the USAO. Chief Reiter's
actions were published in the local newspaper. (Exhibit 7.)
Because the federal investigation had been exposed by Chief Reiter, there was no ability
to operate covertly, so we began serving subpoenas on persons and entities affiliated with Epstein.
Beginning on August 2, 2006, a number of grand jury subpoenas were issued for bank information,
information related to travel on Epstein's airplanes, school attendance records, rental car
information, and other information that would corroborate statements made by victims (see Exhibit
A-1). A subpoena also was issued for all of the evidence collected by the PBPD (see id.). Victim
notification letters also were prepared that contained my contact information for the federal agents
to provide to the victims identified during the PBPD investigation. (Exhibits 12 & 13.) As victims
were interviewed by the federal agents, they would be provided with a copy of the notification
letter. As additional victims were identified throughout the investigation, more letters were
prepared. (Exhibits 19 & 30.) Subpoenas also were prepared for testimony and evidence from
some victims who were believed to possess physical evidence that could corroborate contact with
Epstein. (See Exhibit A-1.)
One of the subpoenaed victims was Individual #28, who is referred to as Jane Doe #2 in
the Jane Doe' United Stales litigation. When approached for an interview, Individual #28 refused
to speak with the agents, and I remember S/A Kuyrkendall telling me that she felt that Individual
#28 had tried to run over her foot as Individual #28 drove away. Individual #28 contacted Epstein
when she received the letter and subpoena; Epstein put her in touch with his attorney, Jack
Goldberger; and Goldberger had his friend, Jim Eisenberg, serve as Individual #28's lawyer while
Epstein paid Eisenberg's fees. Individual #28 later told Brad Edwards that someone (Epstein,
Goldberger, or Eisenberg) told her that "the government" planned to take away her baby. I don't
know if that is true, but Eisenberg insisted that Individual #28 would not speak to us without 6001
immunity. (Exhibit 9.) Once it was granted, Individual #28 spoke of Epstein in glowing terms
12 To minimize the risk of flight, I conducted research on extradition and the FBI placed a
travel watch Epstein, but especially in light of Epstein's ownership of an airplane capable of
intercontinental travel and his foreign residences, the investigative team considered Epstein to be
a substantial flight risk.
Page 15 of 58
and in a way contradicted by other witnesses and evidence. The hiring of Eisenberg, the insistence
on 6001 immunity — something that I had never faced before or since for a child victim — and the
false exculpatory statements — all showed me how the defense would be approaching this case.
The subpoenas and interviews apparently concerned Epstein because soon after I began
trying to set up Individual #28's testimony, Epstein hired former U.S. Attorney Guy Lewis, who
began contacting me by phone and email, asking to meet with me. I declined to meet because it is
my policy not to meet during the pendency of a child exploitation investigation. Mr. Lewis
expressed his client's willingness to cooperate with the investigation. (Exhibit 10.)
When Mr. Lewis was unable to set a meeting, Epstein hired Lilly Ann Sanchez, another
former AUSA from the Miami USAO. Ms. Sanchez began calling and emailing me in early
November 2006. (Exhibit 11). Ms. Sanchez also expressed Epstein's interest in "cooperating"
with the investigation. I knew that feigned cooperation would be used to ask for pre-trial release,
so I tested the veracity of the offer of cooperation by asking for documents that would disprove
many of Epstein's defenses.13 Sure enough, Ms. Sanchez objected to the requests as "overbroad."
I politely declined the request for a meeting and then delayed setting up the requested meeting so
that I would have time to complete the investigation. My co-counsel, John McMillan, and I agreed
that a meeting at this early stage offered no benefit for us and only benefitted the defense.
When Ms. Sanchez could not set a meeting with me, she skipped my immediate supervisor
and contacted MAUSA Andy Lourie whom she knew from their time together in Miami. MAUSA
Lourie told AUSA McMillan and me that he had agreed to meet with Ms. Sanchez and Gerald
Lefcourt. AUSA McMillan and I told MAUSA Lourie that we had made a conscious decision not
to meet with Epstein's attorneys and that we were opposed to a meeting. It was the first of many
disagreements between management and the line AUSAs. MAUSA Lourie told us that we were
"non-strategic thinkers" (his words) and that the meeting would result in convincing Sanchez and
Gerald Lefcourt to bring Epstein in for an interview. It was condescending and, in our opinion,
showed a lack of understanding of sex offenders generally and a lack of knowledge of this case.
Gerald Lefcourt has represented Martha Stewart — the last thing he would do is bring his client in
to face a possible "perjury trap."
In the middle of this period, which started in November 2006 and ran through January
2007, USA Acosta and I traveled to Washington, DC at the beginning of December 2006 for the
inaugural Project Safe Childhood Conference. Although I did not attach much significance to this
at the time, in preparing this response, I began wondering whether the following event was
orchestrated by Epstein and his counsel. During one of the first presentations at the conference, I
was in a large auditorium and the speaker asked the audience a question. A man in the row in front
of me introduced himself as the State Attorney from Palm Beach County (Barry Krischer) and
answered the question. I had never met Mr. Krischer. After the seminar ended, USA Acosta came
over and we all introduced ourselves. Mr. Krischer proceeded to deride PBPD Chief Reiter and
the victims in the Epstein case — referring to them by name and talking about how some were paid
thousands of dollars, used alcohol and drugs, and looked over 18. I tried to guide the two out of
13 For example, Epstein claimed that the massages were legitimate "medical" massages, so
I wanted to see if he was taking tax deductions for medical expenses and getting other
complementary medical treatment. Epstein also claimed that he was traveling to Florida to visit
family and to maintain Florida residency. I asked for calendars and other documentation.
Page 16 of 58
the auditorium to a more private area because I did not think it was a conversation meant for public
consumption but they would not move. As the PSC Coordinator, I had overseen the invitations
for the law enforcement representatives from the S.D. Fla., and Mr. Krischer had not been on the
list. So I now wonder whether this "random" meeting was staged by Epstein.
As you will see from the timeline (Exhibit A-1), in late January 2007, I created a file folder
entitled "Research re NPAs and 6001 immunity." (Exhibit 15.) This was not research related to
Non-Prosecution Agreements in connection with resolving the case against Epstein. In November
poenas were served on two other Epstein employees — Janusz Banasiak
Both initially asked for immunity. After speaking with Banasiak's
attorney, r. anasi was satisfied with a standard Kastigar letter, but Ms. Mucinska's attorney
was insistent on formal immunity, and as noted above, so was Individual #28. I don't believe that,
prior to this investigation, I had ever prepared a request for 6001 immunity, so I was researching
the process.
The meeting with Ms. Sanchez and Mr. Lefcourt was set for February 1, 2007. As noted
above, despite Ms. Sanchez' statements of Epstein's willingness to cooperate, she complained that
my document requests were "overbroad," so MAUSA Lourie and I drafted a more specific list
(Exhibit 14).14 Ms. Sanchez also asserted that Epstein had hired attorneys for all of his current
and prior employees, but refused to provide me with a list of those employees and attorneys,
wanting me to give her essentially a roadmap of my investigation. I refused (Exhibits 14 and A-
1). Instead, the agents and I continued to press forward with our investigation and I continued my
extensive legal research in preparation for the meeting with Sanchez and Lefcourt.
Although materials were supposed to be provided in advance, the "talking points" for the
meeting with Sanchez and Lefcourt did not arrive until the morning of the February 1, 2007
meeting (Exhibit 14 at 8-32). The main themes were:

1. the PBPD investigation was biased;
2. the conduct at issue was "entirely local";
3. Epstein did not know the victims were under 18;

4. none of the girls traveled in interstate commerce;
5. Epstein's travel was not for the purposes of engaging in illegal sexual activity;
6. victim and witness credibility issues weighed against filing charges; and
7. the Petite policy precluded prosecution (id.).
While the letter covered all of these topics, I recall the meeting was focused primarily on
challenges to the victims' credibility (e.g., one victim's MySpace page showed her smoking
marijuana and posing provocatively); allegations of police overreaching; and the lack of evidence
that Epstein knew the victims were under the age of 18.
MAUSA Lourie, AUSA McMillan, and I were unpersuaded by the letter and the
presentation, but I agreed that I should carefully review transcripts of the recorded statements given
to PBPD for Brady issues." Since witness credibility was clearly at the fore, I undertook efforts
" The requested documents and items were never provided.
15 As the investigation continued and we located and identified more victims, we eventually
made a strategic decision that the initial indictment should exclude the group identified by the
Page 17 of 58
to corroborate our victim statements and to undermine Epstein's potential defenses through
subpoenas for a wide variety of documents (see Exhibit A-1). Subpoenas also were issued to some
victims for photographs, gifts, and other records of direct or indirect contact with Epstein (see id).
Presentation of background information to the grand jury began in February 2007 (Exhibits 17,
18, and 20).
I continued to research potential charges against Epstein. Again, knowing how Epstein's
attorneys would likely approach any trial in this matter, I wanted to prepare both a strong offense
— by including all relevant charges for jury consideration and possible plea negotiations — and a
strong defense — by including charges that would allow the admission of the widest range of
relevant evidence. With that mindset, I researched money laundering and racketeering offenses in
Chapter 95 because I knew that prostitution was a racketeering offense (see Exhibit 56). In
addition to the IRS, I conferred with an attorney at the Asset Forfeiture and Money Laundering
Section in DC who opined that Epstein's conduct could be a violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1960 and 2
or another currency offense because he caused the interstate transmission of funds related to
prostitution (see Exhibit 57).16
The investigation continued at a brisk pace with Epstein's attorneys frequently seeking
reviews from Messrs. Lourie and Menchel (see, e.g., Exhibit 58). [NB: They completely excluded
my immediate supervisor, Karen Atkinson, throughout the process.] Because of this, and because
the grand jury was very interested in the case, I tried to keep the Miami office up to date on what
was happening. There also had been little feedback from Miami to the proposed indictment that
had been provided in late April/early May. So, for example, on May 14, 2007,1 emailed Menchel
and Lourie about Epstein's travel and asked whether I would be permitted to present the indictment
the following day or proceed by way of criminal complaint (Exhibit 26 at 1). Mr. Menchel made
clear that neither would be allowed (id.).
That Friday, May 18, 2007, I emailed Chief Menchel again, notifying him that we had
learned that the computers missing from Epstein's home at the time of the execution of the state
search warrant were removed by a private investigator working for attorney Roy Black. After
conferring with CCIPS, the Witness Immunity Unit at OEO, and my immediate supervisor, I
planned to issue a grand jury subpoena for the equipment (id. at 2). I explained why the request
was different than a subpoena to an attorney and how I would avoid seeking privileged information
(id). I specifically asked Mr. Menchel if he had any comments or concerns but received no
response (id) 17
On Monday, May 21, 2007, I wrote to Chief Menchel and FAUSA Sloman for "guidance"
and "a sense of the direction where we are headed" (id. at 3). Again, no response. On that day,
PBPD and save them for a superseding indictment, if needed. At this point, however, the
investigation was focused mainly on the same group.
16 I mention this because my efforts to collect financial documents to support potential
money laundering charges —and also to corroborate victim statements — were later used as evidence
of my "overreaching."
17 Again, I mention this because it would later be used — by Epstein's counsel and Chief
Menchel — as evidence of overreaching.
Page 18 of 58
having heard nothing in response to my 5/18/2007 email, I issued the subpoena to the private
investigator (Exhibit 59).
The following day, May 22, 2007, Mr. Lefcourt sent a letter to MAUSA Lourie stating:
I understand from you that in the next month or two a decision will be made by
your office whether to seek an indictment of Mr. Epstein. This will confirm that,
prior to any such decision being made, I and other attorneys on behalf of Mr.
Epstein will be given an opportunity to meet with you.
Additionally, . . . if our meeting does not resolve the matter, we would like an
opportunity to make a presentation first to Matthew Menchel, Chief of the Criminal
Division, and Jeffrey Sloman, First Assistant United States Attorney, and then,
again, if no resolution is reached, the opportunity to meet with United States
Attorney Alexander Acosta.
(Exhibit 28.)
AUSA McMillan and I were not part of the conversation where MAUSA Lourie disclosed
the timeline to Mr. Lefcourt, so I was surprised by the letter, which sought multiple opportunities
to meet with members of the Executive Division. Mr. Lourie responded, again, without meeting
with AUSA McMillan or me, stating: "I think we are on the same page . . . I did say that if you
want to meet with me again, I am ready to do so. The wording of your letter, however, suggests
implicitly that I agreed to contact you before a decision is made to seek an indictment of Mr.
Epstein. If that was your understanding, then please allow me to clarify. Our investigation is
ongoing and if we decide to seek an indictment, we don't intend to call Mr. Epstein's
representatives to let him know that. Of course, in the interim, if you would like to make a
presentation to us, we are willing to listen. ..." (Id.).
I strenuously objected and drafted an email setting forth the reasons why (id.). I shared it
with my supervisor and she advised me not to send it. I orally advised MAUSA Lourie that I
objected to meetings, delays, and strategic disclosures in a case like this one — a child exploitation
case with a large number of victims. Nevertheless, the meeting was set for June 26, 2007. As I
predicted, the defense asked Mr. Menchel for a list of our legal theories. I told him that I did not
want to share them, and Mr. Menchel directed me to give the defense the list anyway. On June
18, 2007, I sent a letter to Gerald Lefcourt listing all the charges under investigation (Exhibit 53).
On June 14, 2007, I emailed the supervisory chain an addendum to the prosecution memo,
asked about whether they wanted me to revise the indictment, and asked what materials they
wanted prepared in advance of the June 26, 2007 meeting (Exhibit 31 at 1). I don't believe I
received any responses.
On June 21, 2007, I emailed Chief Menchel again asking who would be attending the June
26, 2007 meeting and how I could best prepare (id. at 3-4). I noted that he had been communicating
directly with Ms. Sanchez about the meeting (id.).
On June 25, 2007, Gerald Lefcourt provided written arguments for why Epstein should not
be charged federally (Exhibit 32). The following day, Alan Dershowitz, Roy Black, Gerald
Lefcourt, and Lilly Ann Sanchez presented their arguments to FAUSA Sloman and Chief Menchel.
S/A Kuyrkendall, her supervisor, and I also attended (Exhibit 5). At some point during the
Pagc 19 of 58
meeting, Chief Menchel told the defense attorneys that they needn't address the money laundering
statutes. I think he referred to them as "silly," without even having the benefit of my conversations
with IRS and AFMLS and my legal research.18 So Epstein's counsel focused on the child
exploitation statutes. They falsely insisted that the use of the interne was needed for a 2422(b)
charge and that some sort of force, fraud, or coercion was required for a 1591 charge because 16-
and 17-year-old girls were "adults." They stated that there was no federal law prohibiting sex with
children and one would be unconstitutional.
After the meeting, MAUSA Lourie and I analyzed the materials (Exhibit 32). We both
concluded that the defense had overstated the strength of their position (id.). MAUSA Lourie felt
that the 2422(b) charges were stronger than the 2423(b) charges because we would need proof that
having a sexual massage was a motivation for Epstein's travel (id.). My research showed that
different circuits had different standards of proof on the "purpose of travel" element (id). I never
received any feedback from Chief Menchel or FAUSA Sloman regarding Lefcourt's written
presentation, but after the June 26, 2007 meeting, I was left with the impression that we were
continuing towards indictment.
On July 3, 2007, at 6:26 a.m., I sent an email to Jeff Sloman, Matt Menchel, and Andy
Lourie advising them about calls I had received from Lilly Ann Sanchez seeking to delay subpoena
responses and their plans to present our Office with additional analysis as well as their planned
resolution with the State Attorney's Office (Exhibit 3). I informed everyone of my proposed
response regarding the subpoenas and that I intended to invite Lilly Ann Sanchez to call me to
discuss a resolution of the federal investigation that could include concurrent time, i.e., a plea to a
federal charge with a recommendation that the federal sentence would run concurrently with the
state sentence (See id.) I asked whether anyone had had different conversations with any attorneys
for Epstein so that there would not be any miscommunication.
Later that afternoon, Matt Menchel sent me an email (using Jeff Sloman's Blackberry) that
read, "I told Lily that a state plea with jail time and sex offender status may satisfy the usa. It was
a non-starter for them Matt". (Id.) Because I was in trial, I did not see Mr. Menchel's email, so
my proposed email to Ms. Sanchez went out on July 4's at 4:07p.m. (Id) After my email to Ms.
Sanchez went out, I saw Mr. Menchel's email, and I responded with a vehement objection, telling
him that I believed his plea offer was "completely unacceptable to the FBI, ICE, the victims, and
me [and that these] plea negotiations violate the Ashcroft memo, the U.S. Attorney's Manual, and
all of the various iterations of the victims' rights legislation." (Id) I asked for the opportunity to
make a presentation addressing the strengths of the case and the points raised by Epstein's
attorneys — I felt that it was unfair that Epstein had been given numerous opportunities to meet
with the management of the USAO and the victims had never had a similar chance (Id)
Mr. Menchel responded by reprimanding me, stating, "[a]s you well know, the US Attorney
has not even decided whether to go forward with a prosecution in this matter, thus you should have
respected his position before engaging in plea negotiations." (Id) I had not engaged in any plea
negotiations, Mr. Menchel had. Mr. Menchel also wrote, directly contrary to what USA Acosta
and FAUSA Sloman told me at the initial meeting in Miami, "it was made clear to you by the US
Attorney and the First Assistant from the time when you were first authorized to investigate Mr.
Epstein that the office had concerns about taking this case because of petit [sic] policy and a
18 Epstein's lawyers seized on this later.
Page 20 of 58
number of legal issues. Despite being told these things, you prepared a pros memo and indictment
that included a definitive date for indictment." (Id.) Mr. Menchel also told me that my arguments
that he had violated the Ashcroft memo, the USAM and other policies were not well taken because,
as "Chief of the Criminal Division, I am the person designated by the US Attorney to exercise
appropriate discretion in deciding whether certain pleas are appropriate and consistent with the
Ashcroft memo and the USAM — not you." (Id.) Mr. Menchel also told me that I could not dictate
a meeting. (Id.)
On July 6, 2007, Gerald Lefcourt sent another letter further explaining why Epstein should
not be charged with violations of § 2422(b) (Exhibit 33). Most of the letter raised policy arguments
and the letter ended by expounding on Mr. Epstein's good works (id.).
On July 13, 2007, after I finished my trial, I responded to Mr. Menchel's reprimand, noting
my frustration over the Office's failure to provide me with any guidance on its position on the
matter.19 I pointed out that I had handled this case the same as I had handled all of my other cases,
by working with the agents to gather evidence and preparing an indictment package that
established not just probable cause but proof beyond a reasonable doubt. I re-iterated that I was
"asking to have the same courtesy that was extended to the defense attorneys extended to the FBI
and an Assistant in the Office. ... [And,] my first and only concern in this case . . . is the victims.
If our personality differences threaten their access to justice, then please put someone on the case
whom you trust more, and who will also protect their rights." (Id.) Mr. Menchel never responded;
nor did he allow me to make my requested presentation to USA Acosta. I do not know whether
he shared my request with FAUSA Sloman or USA Acosta.
Also on July 13, 2007, I received a letter from Roy Black complaining about the grand jury
subpoena seeking Epstein's computer equipment (Exhibit 34). I shared the letter with MAUSA
Lourie (his handwritten notes appear on the Exhibit) and together we drafted a letter in response
(Exhibit 32 at 4). On July 16, 2007, Lilly Ann Sanchez sent my letter to Mr. Lourie, writing that
"Gerald Lefcourt and I would like to speak to you further regarding [my letter] since we do not
believe that Marie's letter was responsive to the issues raised by Roy Black." (Exhibit 32 at 1).

Mr. Lourie and I had a conference call with Ms. Sanchez and Mr. Lefcourt and informed them that
they would have to file a motion to quash the subpoena. We then advised Mr. Menchel of the
history (Exhibit 62).
On July 19, 2007, I sent an email to MAUSA Lourie and Chief Menchel asking for
permission to serve target letters on three of Epstein's personal assistants and for guidance on
language to be used in the target letters (Exhibit 63). Mr. Menchel responded that he was out of
the District "but let's hold off on these until we decide what course of action we are going to take
on epstein which should happen next week" (id.).
19 For example, on May 21, 2007, I wrote to Chief Menchel and FAUSA Sloman: "I have
time set aside with the grand jury tomorrow, and I am wondering if you have a sense of the
direction where we are headed — i.e., approval of an indictment something like the current draft, a
complaint to allow for pre-indictment negotiations, an indictment drastically different from the
current draft? I am concerned about confusing the grand jury, which is never a good thing. Any
guidance?" (Exhibit 54). I did not receive a response.
Page 21 of 58
After these exchanges and being reprimanded by Criminal Chief Menchel for raising those
objections, I was not consulted again about a pre-indictment plea. On July 26, 2007, agents and
supervisory personnel from the FBI and I traveled to a scheduled meeting with Chief Menchel in
Miami. That morning, before departing for Miami, I sent an email to Mr. Menchel and MAUSA
Lotuie that read, "in advance of our meeting this afternoon, I wanted to let you know my thoughts
about some of the recommended changes [to the indictment] that we had discussed the last time I
was in Miami . . ." (Exhibit 64). The FBI agents, their supervisor, their ASAIC, and I met with

Mr. Menchel. Criminal Chief Menchel entered the meeting and announced to us that "Alex
[Acosta] has decided to offer a two-year state plea." We were not asked our opinions and the
meeting ended soon thereafter (see Exhibit 5). I remember feeling stunned. I don't remember
saying anything at the meeting.
In an attempt to provide some benefits to the victims and protections to the public, I asked
that two terms be added to this two-year deal: (1) that the victims be provided compensation via
18 U.S.C. § 2255 as a substitute for restitution because Epstein was pleading to state charges; and
(2) that Epstein be required to plead guilty to an offense requiring sex offender registration. The
Office agreed to add these two terms. On July 31, 2007, I finalized a term sheet, entitled
"CONFIDENTIAL PLEA NEGOTIATIONS: TERMS OF EPSTEIN NON-PROSECUTION
AGREEMENT." (Exhibit 4.) On the same date, it was provided to counsel for Epstein. Present
at the meeting for the government were FAUSA Jeff Sloman, Criminal Chief Matt Menchel,
MAUSA Andy Lourie, S/A Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, S/A Jason Richards, and myself, and for Epstein
were Roy Black, Gerald Lefcourt, and Lilly Ann Sanchez. (See Exhibit 5.) At the meeting, counsel
for Epstein stated that their client would not consider a plea that required state jail time. During
the meeting, Matt Menchel suggested a plea to a federal charge that would allow Epstein the
opportunity to serve his sentence in a federal facility.
I was told that USA Acosta did not want to do a federal plea that bound the court to a two-
year prison term, so I would have to find a charge or charges that resulted in a two-year statutory
maximum. On August 1, 2007, Mr. Menchel advised that the counter-offer that Epstein's attorneys
had promised did not arrive, and I told him that I had found a federal charge that could result in a
2-1/2 year statutory maximum (Exhibit 65).
On August 2, 2007, Lilly Ann Sanchez sent a counter-proposal directly to Criminal Chief
Matt Menchel and, in her email, stated that a copy would also be hand-delivered to USA Acosta
(Exhibit 8.) The counter-proposal essentially called for home confinement, no sex offender
registration, and an agreement to pay damages via 18 U.S.C. § 2255 (Exhibit 40). Ms. Sanchez
also asked for a meeting with the U.S. Attorney (id.).
On August 3, 2007, Mr. Menchel sent a letter rejecting the counter-proposal, advising that
a minimum of two years' imprisonment was needed to vindicate the federal interest, and that USA
Acosta was not inclined to have a meeting (Exhibit 41). Mr. Menchel provided a deadline for
August 17, 2007 to accept the plea offer (id). That was Mr. Menchel's last day of employment
with the USAO before he entered private practice in New York.
Mr. Epstein's attorneys were incensed that USA Acosta had set a deadline of August 17,
2007 and would not meet with them, so they demanded a meeting with CEOS Chief Drew
Oosterbaan (Exhibit 43). Mr. Oosterbaan agreed to travel to Florida to meet with USA Acosta and
Epstein's attorneys (id.). Mr. Oosterbaan also traveled to West Palm Beach to meet with the agents
and myself to go through the evidence and our analysis of the statutes (Exhibit 5). Before he came
Page 22 of 58
to West Palm Beach, I advised Mr. Oosterbaan that I had worked with CEOS Trial Attorney
Myesha Braden on some of the legal issues and that, if there were a trial, I was hoping she might
be able to assist (Exhibit 43).
In preparation for the planned meeting on September 7, 2007, FAUSA Sloman emailed me
to ask what the status of the plea negotiations were. I wrote:
Here is the term sheet and guidelines calculation that we provided at the last
meeting. You and Matt and I had also discussed a possible federal plea to an
Information charging a 371 conspiracy, with a Rule 11 plea with a two-year cap,
but I think Matt must have asked Alex about it and it was nixed. Just to be prepared
for tomorrow, I was just starting to draft a Rule 11 Plea agreement in case Alex
changes his mind and a formal non-prosecution agreement containing the state plea
terms. . . . There are three concerns that I hope we can address tomorrow. . . .
[including] that the agents and I have not reached out to the victims to get their
approval, which as Drew politely reminded me, is required under the law.
(Exhibit 44).
On September 7, 2007, USA Acosta, FAUSA Sloman, CEOS Chief Oosterbaan, AUSA
McMillan, and I met with Kenneth Starr, Jay Lefkowitz, and Lilly Ann Sanchez (Exhibit 5). At
the meeting, Mr. Starr focused primarily on federalism/policy arguments, and Mr. Epstein's
background. I remember Mr. Starr thanking me for bringing § 2255 to their attention and that it
would allow a state resolution that still provided the equivalent of federal restitution.
Following the meeting, there were communications between Gerald Lefcourt, USA
Acosta, and MAUSA Lourie that I was not privy to. The fact of the conversations was mentioned
in later emails. Based upon those communications, on September 10, 2007, I was asked to send

Mr. Lefcourt an office response to Lefcourt's counterproposal (see Exhibit 47 ("Gerry: As per
your discussion with U.S. Attorney Acosta, I have attached the Office's written
counterproposal.")). I sent Mr. Lefcourt a Non-Prosecution Agreement that required Epstein, inter
alia, to:

(1) plead guilty to three state felony offenses, including lewd and lascivious battery on a
child; solicitation of minors to engage in prostitution; and engaging in sexual activity
with minors at least sixteen years of age;

(2) make a binding recommendation (with the State Attorney's Office) for the Court to
impose a thirty-month sentence consisting of 20 months in prison followed by 10
months of community control;

(3) waive his right to appeal his conviction and sentence;
(4) concede that victims identified by the United States were victims for purposes of 18
U.S.C. § 2255; and

(5) plead guilty by September 28, 2007 and be sentenced by October 15, 2007.
(Exhibit 66).
The following day, FAUSA Sloman forwarded to me USA Acosta's email with USA
Acosta's revisions to the NPA (Exhibit 46). At FAUSA Sloman's request, I incorporated the
changes and sent the new version to Mr. Lefcourt (Exhibits 47 and 67). On September 12, 2007,
MAUSA Lourie, Rolando Garcia, and I met at the State Attorney's Office with State Attorney
Page 23 of 58
Krischer, ASA Belohlavek, Jay Lefkowitz, Gerry Lefcourt, and Jack Goldberger (Exhibit 5). The
purpose of the meeting was to finalize and coordinate the terms of the state and federal agreements.

Mr. Lefkowitz still expressed some interest in having Epstein serve his time in a federal facility,
rather than a state one, and I remember Mr. Goldberger saying that because Mr. Epstein's home
was on Palm Beach Island and touching the Intracoastal Waterway, it was somehow in
"international waters" and federal jurisdiction. Other items that were discussed were: (1) that the
state crime that Epstein agreed to plead guilty to was one requiring sex offender registration; and

(2) that Epstein would be incarcerated 24-7 during the 20-month period of imprisonment. We left
the meeting with an understanding that Epstein's counsel would contact us about whether Epstein
wanted to plead to federal charges pursuant to a plea agreement or proceed with the Non-
Prosecution Agreement. With that in mind, on September 13, 2007, I sent an email to USA Acosta,
FAUSA Sloman, MAUSA Lourie, Rolando Garcia, and Karen Atkinson advising them that I had
researched three potential federal charges that could be used for Epstein, but they would all result
in a 24-month maximum. If Epstein's counsel rejected those charges because of the 24-month
exposure, I recommended reconsidering a binding Rule 11 plea "rather than try to create violations
out of whole cloth" (Exhibit 46 at 19). I provided a proposed plea agreement and information
containing two counts of violations of 18 U.S.C. § 403.
Mr. Lourie wrote to me later on September 13, 2007, "He is going to give us an assault on
the plane or we can do conspiracy"20 (Exhibit 46 at 21). I responded, "It would still have to be a
conspiracy to commit an assault on a plane. I just want to make sure that we have something that
is factually accurate. Just trying to plan ahead" (id). At Jay Lefkowitz's request, MAUSA Lourie
and I scheduled a conference call with him for early on the morning of September 14, 2007 (id. at
25). Mr. Lourie did not attend the conference call, and on the call, Jay Lefkowitz asked me to
consider allowing Epstein to plead to charges that required only 12 months' imprisonment. I
recommended 24 months' imprisonment. Lefkowitz said his client would plead to obstruction of
a witness and one count of assault on an airplane (id. at 29). Despite Mr. Lourie's earlier agreement
to the assault on an airplane charge, he then decided that the "assault sounds like a stretch and
factually sort of silly" (id. at 31).
I then went back to Mr. Lefkowitz with four options: (1) a plea only to state charges with
18 months' imprisonment; (2) federal and state pleas with a recommendation for concurrent time
so that Epstein could serve his time in a federal facility; (3) a § 371 plea with a binding
recommendation of 20 months' imprisonment (if USA Acosta approved it); or (4) an agreement
that had a plea to one federal charge followed by one state charge (id. at 33). We continued to
negotiate issues about how to provide restitution to the victims, and each iteration of the
agreements seemed to move us further apart. As shown in Exhibit 46, each time Mr. Lefkowitz
tried to reduce the period of incarceration; he tried to replace the state charge with one that did not
require sex offender registration; and he kept changing the damages/restitution provisions to make
it more difficult for the victims to obtain compensation; he removed the appeal waiver; he included
an agreement that we would recommend an incorrect calculation of the guidelines. It was simply
bad faith negotiations. I would point out how terms that were specifically rejected were re-
inserted, and the Office would just send me back to the table.
2° This somehow resulted in 18 months' imprisonment. I do not recall how the prison term
was decreased from 20 months on September 11, 2007 to 18 months on September 13, 2007.
Page 24 of 58
The agreement was finally completed and signed on September 24, 2007.

4. Explain fully the process and circumstances leading to the development of the
following terms of the non-prosecution agreement:

a. an 18-month period of incarceration in a state facility, including the
basis for the determination that it sufficiently satisfied the federal
interest in the case;
As noted above, the only information that I received was from Mr. Menchel's
announcement that USA Acosta had decided to offer a two-year state deal. I do not know how
Messrs. Menchel and Acosta determined that two years' incarceration sufficiently satisfied the
federal interest in the case. During one meeting, Epstein's attorneys raised the possibility of a
state-court plea with home confinement. USA Acosta specifically rejected the suggestion, noting
that confinement in Mr. Epstein's home was not equivalent to incarceration. As discussed above,
the 24-month term was reduced to 20 months and then, finally, to 18 months.
b. victim restitution, including why and how to address victims' rights
through 18 U.S.C. § 2255;
The federal crimes that were under investigation all called for mandatory or discretionary
restitution under 18 U.S.C. §§ 3663 and 3663A.2' Gelber and Drew Oosterbaan from
CEOS are experts in this area, but as PSC Coordinator, ew that restitution in child exploitation
cases was a hot-button issue at the time.
The District of Alaska USAO had a multi-victim child exploitation case with a wealthy
defendant (Boehm) where they had set up a trust fund with a bank and a trustee. With Drew
Oosterbaan's help, I explored setting up a similar situation in the Epstein case (Exhibit 48), in
connection with using a guardian ad litem ("GAL") for the victims,22 if there had been a plea to
federal charges. In cases like the Epstein cases, using a GAL seemed the most prudent course
because, to the extent that the victims' interests ever diverged from the government's, the GAL
could advocate on behalf of the victims. Thus, there are several emails between myself and Jay
Lefkowitz about the appointment of a GAL and the possibility of a restitution trust fund similar to
the Boehm case out of Alaska. I obtained the trust fund agreement and spoke with the AUSA in
21 Mandatory restitution under § 3663A requires a conviction for a "crime of violence, as
defined in [18 U.S.C. §1 16." At the time, these cases would have been considered crimes of
violence because sex trafficking, even via fraud or coercion, would likely be considered to
"involve() a substantial risk that physical force against the person . . . or another may be used in
tthe course of committing the offense." 18 U.S.C. § 16(b). Post-Johnson v. United Sta , U.S.
135 S. Ct. 2551 (2015), a court might decide differently. See, e.g., Menendez Whitaker,
908 F.3d 467 (9'b Cir. 2018). Even if not a crime of violence, a Court has the author; to impose
an order of restitution when sentencing a defendant convicted of any offense under title 18 for any
losses sustained by a victim as a result of the offense. 18 U.S.C. § 3663(aX1)(A), (B)(i)(I). And
the court also can order restitution to persons other than the victim of the charged offense if the
parties so agree. 18 U.S.C. § 3663(a)(1)(A).
22 I had been the first prosecutor in the S.D. Fla. to apply to the court for guardians ad litem
for victims in child exploitation cases, so I was familiar with the procedure.
Page 25 of 58
Alaska. The trust fund agreement was very complex and required a bank to agree to serve as the
holder of the corpus and a trustee to oversee the administration of the trust, as well as the Court to
enter an order setting up the trust and a mechanism for resolving disputes amongst beneficiaries
or between a beneficiary and the trustee.
In light of the amount of details and the number of victims involved, and the simple fact
that, if there was only a state plea, there would be no federal judge to undertake the process, I knew
that there was no way to accomplish a trust fund like Boehm within the confines of the NPA. In
the Boehm case, there was a much smaller number of victims and, if I remember correctly, the
victims were younger. The Alaska AUSA was able to confer with Boehm's victims and obtain
their consent to the trust agreement procedure in advance of entering into the plea agreement. The
Alaska AUSA also obtained the defendant's agreement to proceed ex pane. Our situation was
quite different. There were more victims with disparate interests. In my emails, I made it clear
that I could not bind the victims to such a procedure because I did not represent them. For example,
how would the USAO decide on the size of the corpus of the trust? Would the USAO hire expert
psychologists to evaluate the victims and economists to quantify their losses? If the USAO picked
a number, would that preclude a victim from bringing a state tort claim? Would every victim
receive the same amount? This is not how criminal restitution works — normally after a guilty
plea, the Court's Probation Office works with victims to calculate losses, and issues are litigated
at sentencing or within 90 days after sentencing. Lefkowitz was asking the USAO to pick a number
virtually out of thin air to use as the corpus of the trust for a group of victims who were not clients
of the USAO. We also would have to locate an independent bank to serve as the hold of the corpus.
Given how difficult negotiating simple plea terms had been, I believed that creating an agreement
of this sort was legally and logistically impossible.
When Epstein's attorneys approached USA Acosta in December 2007 and suggested that
I rejected the Trust proposal for nefarious reasons, I outlined all of the concerns that I had
previously expressed to Mr. Lefkowitz (Exhibit 55).
Once I was instructed that Epstein would be allowed to plead to state charges, I wanted to
do what I could to place the victims and the community in the same position where they would
have been in Epstein had pled to a federal offense. If Epstein had pled to one of the federal offenses
under investigation, he would have been required to register as a sex offender and pay restitution
to all victims of the federal offense. With regard to the restitution piece, I knew that the state
investigation had not included all of the girls and young women whom we had identified and I was
concerned that Epstein would avoid his restitution obligations if not forced to pay.23
As part of my duties as PSC Coordinator, on September 26, 2006, I had prepared a memo
to management summarizing the Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006 (the
"Adam Walsh Act") (Exhibit 16). One of the provisions of the Adam Walsh Act that I noted was
an amendment to 18 U.S.C. § 2255: "Section 2255 has been expanded to allow a person who,
while a minor, was a victim of various child exploitation offenses, to pursue a civil action for
personal injury damages — regardless of when the personal injury occurred. It also raises the
presumptive damage amount to $150,000." (Id. at 7.) Although this was an amendment, I was
unaware of § 2255 prior to preparing this September 2006 memo. The first few times I brought it
23 In fact, the State Attorney's Office did not seek or obtain restitution for any victims in
the state case, not even the two victims that were the basis of the state charges.
Page 26 of 58
to the attention of others, they thought I was mis-citing 28 U.S.C. § 2255 and I had to explain that
there actually was an 18 U.S.C. § 2255, which was a civil provision within the criminal code.
I do not know when I first discussed the possibility of using § 2255 as a replacement for
the victims' lost restitution benefits, but I know that I conducted research on § 2255 cases on July
27, 2007 (Exhibit 37). That was the day after the meeting where Criminal Chief Menchel had
announced that USA Acosta had decided to offer Epstein a two-year state plea (Exhibit 5).
Language regarding § 2255 was included in the plea agreement term sheet provided to
Epstein's counsel on July 31, 2007 (Exhibit 38). The issue must have been raised in advance of
the meeting, because that was the first meeting attended by Ken Starr, and he specifically thanked
me for bringing § 2255 to their attention. On August 2, 2007, Lilly Ann Sanchez sent a letter to
Criminal Chief Menchel making a series of counterproposals including: "Application of 18 U.S.C.
§ 2255" (Exhibit 40 at 2). Ms. Sanchez went on to explain:
18 U.S.C. 2255 provides that any minor who suffers injury as a result of the
commission of certain offenses shall recover actual damages and the cost of any
suit. It is important to note that Mr. Epstein is prepared to fully fund the identified
group of victims which are the focus of the Office — that is, the 12 individuals noted
at the meeting on July 31, 2007. This would allow the victims to be able to
promptly put this behind them and go forward with their lives. If given the
opportunity to opine as to the appropriateness of Mr. Epstein's proposal, in my
extensive experience in these types of cases, the victims prefer a quick resolution
with compensation for damages and will always support any disposition that
eliminates the need for trial (id. at n.1).
Thus, the use of § 2255 as a replacement for restitution was not controversial — it was
promoted by Epstein's own attorneys, including Mr. Starr. At one point during negotiations, Mr.
Lefkowitz started advocating for a trust fluid like the one used in Boehm, mostly, I believe, to try
to place a cap on his damages exposure. I offered some potential solutions, including asking the
federal court to appoint a guardian ad litem who could work with Epstein's counsel to see if the
victims would be willing to agree to a Trust Fund, and I would facilitate those efforts, but I simply
would not agree to something that I legally could not promise — a binding resolution for victims
whom I did not represent.
Eventually, Mr. Lefkowitz made some changes to the § 2255 language but it remained
quite close to the original proposal contained in the July 31, 2007 term sheet.

c. immunity for co-conspirators, including unidentified co-conspirators;
and
In looking through the drafts of the agreements, the immunity provision does not appear in
any of the federal plea agreements that I drafted. Its first appearance is in a version of the NPA
proposed by Jay Lefkowitz along with a proposed promise that the government would not seek
immigration sanctions against any of the co-conspirators. It was initially rejected, and then after
several iterations, Lefkowitz revised it to the language that appeared in the final NPA.
The final language was: "In consideration of Epstein's agreement to plead guilty and to
provide compensation in the manner described above, if Epstein successfully fulfills all of the
terms and conditions of this agreement, the United States also agrees that it will not institute any
Page 27 of 58
ges against an co
,
em, including but not limited to
Adriana Ross, or " (Exhibit 52 at 5). To the extent
that there was a "criminal organization," the Office and the investigators considered Epstein to be
the head of that organization. He was certainly the most culpable individual, and we did not
foresee any scenario where we would defer prosecution against Epstein but proceed to prosecute
his subordinates. Also, while the agreement included the language "including but not limited to,"
at the time that the NPA was signed, with the possible exception of Ghislaine Maxwell, the
investigation had not disclosed any co-conspirators other than those listed.
I recall that there was extensive discussion of Lefkowitz's proposed immigration language,
but I do not recall much discussion of this language for the reasons stated above.
d. the October 2007 addendum, including its purpose.
During the negotiation of the NPA, I had been admitted to the hospital for surgery. After
the surgery, I returned to the office almost immediately to try to complete the negotiations. When
the NPA was signed, I sought permission to take a leave of absence to address my health concerns.
While I was away, the Addendum was negotiated. While I conducted some of the drafting, I
believe that FAUSA Sloman handled the bulk of the negotiations and drafting.
My understanding was that the USAO wanted to formally assign its right to select the
attorney representative for the victims to a Special Master. The NPA stated that the USAO would
select the attorney representative in consultation with and subject to the good faith approval of
Epstein's counsel. I had provided Epstein's counsel with a list of attorneys, none of whom I had
ever met, that I had culled from consulting with one of the district judges24 and some AUSAs,
including Mr. Yen, who I was dating at the time. After getting that list of names, I did my own
research to determine who would be good fits for the type of litigation that I expected they would
face — both in terms of the tactics of Epstein's lawyers and the special challenges of dealing with
emotionally fragile victims. I provided that culled list to Jay Lefkowitz and disclosed that,
although I had no financial interest, the list included a friend of a good friend of mine (I did not
describe Mr. Yera as my "boyfriend"). Even with that disclosure, Mr. Lefkowitz selected Mr.
Yera's friend. Before the matter went any further, FAUSA Sloman decided that the Office should
use a Special Master to make the selection, rather than pick anyone — even a panel of attorneys
leaving the final selection to Epstein's counsel. Despite that, Mr. Lefkowitz and Guy Lewis — who
knew both Mr. Yera and his friend — claimed that there was a financial interest and that I had tried
to create the procedure for financial gain.25
24 Epstein's lawyers suggested that I had ex parte communications with a judge. I simply
asked for recommendations from a judge that I was friendly with; I did not disclose anything about
the background of the case.
25 Mr. Lewis knew that Mr. Yera also was an AUSA and, therefore, was not partners with
another lawyer. When that was patently obvious, Epstein's lawyers falsely claimed that they were
"law school roommates." Both had graduated from law school more than fifteen years before, and
had not been roommates. Ironically, one of the reasons why Epstein's legal team approved the
selection of Robert Josefsberg was that Josefsberg and Alan Dershowitz were law school
classmates — somehow there was no "financial interest" attributed to them.
Page 28 of 58
Rather than simply elect to use a Special Master to exercise its right to make the attorney
representative selection, the USA() believed that it should formalize the assignment in writing.
5. To the extent not evidenced in e-mails or other correspondence, identify and
describe all interactions with defense counsel — such as phone conversations,
meetings, or communications by private e-mail — that you or any other
member of the government had regarding the investigation, potential
prosecution, or negotiation of a resolution of this case. If at any point you
became concerned about the nature of any member of the government's
interaction with defense counsel, describe the interaction and explain when
and why you became concerned.
My communications with opposing counsel occurred primarily via email. Most of those
communications were via office email, and some were from my home email. All of my home
emails were collected and produced as part of the Jane Doe litigation. Negotiations were occurring
at nights, on weekend, and while I was recuperating from surgery, and this occurred during a time
when out of office access to email was very limited. I believe that only supervisors had Blackberry
devices at that time.
The meetings that I attended are catalogued on the meeting timeline (Exhibit 5). I believe
there was one other meeting soon after Epstein entered his guilty plea, when I went to Jack
Goldberger's office and met with him and Mike Tein (Guy Lewis' law partner) about the victim
list. Other than that, I do not recall any in-person meetings.
I had a couple of telephone conversations with Lilly Ann Sanchez and Guy Lewis at the
start of the investigation that were very brief. Jeff Sloman and/or Andy Lourie was on some of
these. I had telephone conversations later during the investigation with Lilly Ann Sanchez, Gerry
Lefcourt, Roy Black, and Nate Dershowitz about subpoena responses. Karen Atkinson and Andy
Lourie were on some of those calls. I had telephone conversations with Jay Lefkowitz about plea
negotiations and scheduling meetings. Andy Lourie, Rolando Garcia, and Jeff Sloman were on
some of those calls. I had numerous calls with Roy Black and Jack Goldberger about breaches of
the NPA. Karen Atkinson was on most of those telephone calls.
From emails and conversations, I know that Messrs. Acosta, Sloman, Menchel, and Lourie
had numerous emails and conversations (mostly via telephone and possibly some in person) with
members of the defense team. USA Acosta had contact with Ken Starr, Jay Lefkowitz, Gerry
Lefcourt, and Alan Dershowitz. FAUSA Sloman had contact with Alan Dershowitz, Gerry
Lefcourt, and Lilly Ann Sanchez. Criminal Chief Menchel had contact with Lilly Ann Sanchez
and Gerry Lefcourt. There may have been other meetings that I was unaware of. I was concerned
about the level of contact and the lack of consideration of the sanctity of the investigation. It was
imperative to keep the investigation confidential to protect not just the victims' privacy rights, but
to keep them from the harassment of overly aggressive lawyers. I felt that there were leaks of
case-related facts and strategy, as well as personal matters that undermined my ability to deal with
the defense and that ultimately was used by the defense to defame me and Mr. Sloman with senior
members of the Department of Justice.
Page 29 of 58

6. Provide a detailed description of all settlement negotiations conducted in this
matter in which you took part or of which you were otherwise aware, including
all terms of settlement that were discussed, considered, and rejected during
the negotiations. Identify all individuals who participated in those
negotiations, including government personnel and defense counsel. In each
case, identify all participants and describe the discussions that occurred.
Please see my response to Question A.3.
7. Describe the interactions by you, or anyone else within the USAO, with any
employees of the Palm Beach County State Attorney's Office concerning the
federal or state investigation of Mr. Epstein, the terms of a proposed resolution
of the case, and the terms of the federal non-prosecution agreement, including
the terms of Mr. Epstein's incarceration.
As noted above, my first interaction with anyone from the Palm Beach County State
Attorney's Office about the Epstein case was at the Project Safe Childhood Conference in
Washington, DC, when State Attorney Barry Krischer introduced himself to USA Acosta and me
and started railing against the victims and the case.
My next interaction was with ASA Lanna Belohlavek at some later date. I was in her
office, I believe on another matter, and I mentioned the case. She said that she "hated" the case
and that she "hated" prostitution cases. She stated that some of the girls were not really victims
because they had been paid "thousands of dollars." I was a bit taken aback because Ms. Belohlavek
was the supervisor of the division charged with prosecuting child sex offenses, including child
prostitution cases and, by definition, child prostitutes receive money.
Although not personal interactions, I also had collected and reviewed the state grand jury
transcript, indictment, and the state investigative materials. I had conferred with former ASAs
about the use of the grand jury in the case, which was very unusual. In Florida, only capital cases
need to be presented to a grand jury — all other cases can proceed by Information — and one ASA
in Palm Beach County handles the presentation of all of the cases to the grand jury. This case was
unusual because it was presented to a grand jury unnecessarily and it was not presented by the
regular grand jury ASA. The State Attorney also had told the press that a variety of charges had
been presented to the grand jury and the jurors had selected the lowest charge of solicitation of
prostitution (with no designation of age). The transcript gave no indication that multiple charging
options were presented, and the jurors were only provided with evidence about one victim, not all
of the victims who had been the subjects of the investigation.
I believe that the next interaction was on September 12, 2007, when I attended a meeting
at the State Attorney's Office with Andy Lourie and Rolando Garcia. Jay Lefkowitz, Gerald
Lefcourt, and Jack Goldberger attended on behalf of Mr. Epstein, and State Attorney Krischer and
ASA Lanna Behlolavek were present. At some point in the past, one of Epstein's attorneys had
falsely told State Attorney Krischer that a person from the USAO had referred to the SAO as "a
joke." Messrs. Lourie and Garcia and I had to spend the first several minutes of the meeting
convincing State Attorney Krischer that no one had ever said such a thing. After crossing that
hurdle, we got to the core of the meeting, which was whether the SAO was in agreement with
filing charges and seeking a sentence consisting with the terms of the NPA — that is, a plea to an
Page 30 of 58
offense that required sex offender registration — namely, procuring a minor for prostitution in
violation of Fl. Stat. 796.03; and a sentence totaling 18 or 20 months' imprisonment.26 I recall
that either Mr. Lourie or I asked Ms. Behlolavek to confirm that § 796.03 required sex offender
registration, and she said that it did. Epstein's attorneys also said that it did. We also specifically
discussed that Epstein would be confined for the term of imprisonment. State Attorney Krischer
said that a term of imprisonment of longer than one year usually required placement in a state
penitentiary, but there was a way to structure the sentence as a split sentence so that Epstein would
be housed at the Palm Beach County Jail. And we again confirmed that Epstein would remain in
custody at the jail, not home confinement or any other type of release and we were told that he
would be in jail. We also discussed wrapping the matter up quickly because of the extensive
delays.
On September 23, 2007, Jay Lefkowitz sent an email to Alex Acosta essentially admitting
that, during the meeting on September 12, 2007, Epstein's attorneys and Ms. Behlolavek all
believed that a conviction for Fl. Stat. 796.03, procurement of minors for prostitution, did not
require sex offender registration — despite our specific inquiries (see Exhibit 51 ("I write to follow
up on our conversation on Friday and to ask you to reconsider your decision to require that Mr.
Epstein plead guilty to a registerable state charge. It appears that there was a misunderstanding at
the meeting I had with Messrs. Laurie, Krischer, Goldberger, Lefcourt, Ms. Villafana and Ms.
Belohlavek. . . . Before the meeting, Mr. Krischer, and Ms. Belohlavek, a sex prosecutor for 13
years, told us that solicitation of a minor, under 796.03, is not a registerable offense. However, as
it turned out, 796.03 is a registerable offense and our discussion at the meeting was based on a
mistaken assumption." (emphasis added)).
On December 6, 2007, ASA Behlolavek contacted me to draft a factual proffer and advised
that Epstein would be entering a guilty plea on December 21, 2007 (Exhibit 73). I did some
research on 796.03 and prepared a draft that I shared with FAUSA Sloman, but he decided not to
share the information with Ms. Behlolavek (see id).
While drafting this response, I searched my electronic files for Mr. ICrischer's name and
discovered a document entitled "071214 Acosta Ltr to Krischer.wpd" (Exhibit 69). I do not recall
drafting this letter, although I located a cover email stating that I drafted this and two other letters
for USA Acosta's signature that were directed to the State Attorney's Office (Exhibit 75). I do
not know if any of the letters were ever sent to Mr. Krischer.
In May 2008, Rolando Garcia had a discussion with State Attorney Krischer and Krischer
advised that he and Jack Goldberger had reached a new agreement for Epstein of 90 days in jail
(Exhibit B-39).
On June 17, 2008, Karen Atkinson and I spoke with State Attorney Krischer. He
complained that we had not been communicating with him, and we told him that Epstein's counsel
had blocked the channels of communication (Exhibit 78). Krischer said that he and Jack
Goldberger had reached a new agreement where Epstein would plead guilty to "attempted lewd
conduct" and be sentenced to 60 days in the County Jail followed by two years of community
confinement (id.).
26 As noted above, I do not recall the exact date when USA Acosta agreed that 18 months'
imprisonment was sufficient.
Page 31 of 58
On June 19, 2008, I sent an email to State Attorney Krischer advising him that we had
spoken with Roy Black about wrapping up both the state and federal /times (Exhibit 68). I reminded
State Attorney Krischer that the signed NPA required a plea to the current state indictment and to
an information charging an offense that requires sex offender registration, namely procuring
minors to engage in prostitution, with a sentence of at least 18 months' imprisonment (id.).
I attended the change of plea on June 30, 2008 but did not have any contact with any
member of the SAO that day. Later, when the issue arose regarding whether or not Epstein was
taking the position that the NPA included USA Acosta's December 2007 letter, I contacted Ms.
Behlolavek and SA Krischer to obtain a copy of what Epstein's counsel had filed in state court.
In September 2008, I had communications with Mr. Krischer about a suit filed in state court
to unseal the NPA (Exhibit 70).
At some point, Mr. Krischer sent me an email about wanting to buy me a cup of coffee. I
was not able to find the email while preparing this response, but with additional time, I can
probably locate it. I don't believe I ever answered Mr. Krischer. I know I never met him for
coffee.
I recall that in many of Epstein's letters to the Justice Department, there were complaints
of a lack of coordination between the USAO and the SAO. That lack of coordination was not
caused by the government agencies, but, rather, by the tactics of Epstein's counsel. For example,
Epstein's counsel insisted that I should conduct a completely independent review of the evidence
so that I would not be tainted by bias from the PBPD or the SAO. When I did so and reached a
conclusion that they did not like, Epstein's attorneys insisted that Criminal Chief Senior and that
CEOS conduct similarly sterile reviews free from the "taint" of me and the federal agents. If Ms.
Atkinson and I or the agents and I reached out to the SAO to discuss how the NPA should be
worded to insure that we were getting correct information from Epstein's attorneys, we were
accused of "infringing on the SAO's discretion." Yet, that "lack of coordination" that Epstein's
attorneys caused, was later held up to the DAAG, the AAG, and DAG, as violations of the Petite
policy's state-federal coordination requirement.

8. Describe any research conducted by you, or anyone else within the USAO, into
law or policy regarding any of the following issues:

a. The propriety of permitting a person to plead guilty to state court
charges in exchange for an agreement by the USAO to refrain from
federal prosecution. In your response, you should identify any USAO
or Department policies that were considered by the USAO, and any
effort by the USAO to obtain guidance or approval from the
Department to use a non-prosecution agreement to resolve this case.
I did not do any research on this point. I do not know whether USA Acosta or Criminal
Chief Menchel conducted any research or obtained any guidance or approval from the Department.
Page 32 of 58

b. The propriety of including in a non-prosecution agreement with Mr.
Epstein a provision that the federal government would forgo
prosecution of any potential co-conspirators of Mr. Epstein, including
unidentified co-conspirators.
I do not recall doing any research on this particular point, other than discussing with
MAUSA Lourie that we would not pursue an investigation into Epstein's subordinates after closing
the investigation of Epstein.
c. The propriety of including in the non-prosecution agreement a
provision incorporating 18 U.S.C. § 2255.
As noted above, I became familiar with § 2255 through my work as the PSC Coordinator.
I also was aware, as set forth in the victim notification letters that I prepared, that, under the CVRA,
I was obligated to use my "best efforts" to protect the victims' rights to "full and timely restitution
as provided in law." 18 U.S.C. § 3771(a)(6). As I discussed above, restitution in child exploitation
cases was an issue of growing concern, so I was mindful that this plea mechanism that Criminal
Chief Menchel had devised with Lilly Ann Sanchez would extinguish, the victims' right to
restitution. That was one of the reasons why, on July 4, 2007, I wrote to Mr. Menchel that I
believed the plea proposal violated the victims' rights legislation.
When Mr. Menchel announced in late July that USA Acosta was going forward with the
two-year state plea offer despite those concerns, I undertook my best efforts to still afford those
restitution rights to the victims identified through the federal investigation. Immediately after the
meeting where Mr. Menchel announced to me and the investigative team that USA Acosta
intended to offer a state plea, I delved further into the requirements for claims under § 2255
(Exhibit 37). While § 2255 is a civil damages statute, not a criminal restitution provision, the
criminal restitution statutory scheme recognizes that there is some overlap. See 18 U.S.C. §
3664(j)(2)(A), (1). Section 2255 also provides for attorneys' fees, just as courts can use court funds
to appoint guardians ad litem for minor victims in criminal cases who can advocate for restitution
for the victims. My review of the legislative history led me to conclude that the inclusion of a
provision under § 2255 would be the best way to protect the victims' right to restitution. CEOS
Chief Oosterbaan described the agreement as "a very significant result that will serve the victims
well" (Exhibit 71).
I should note that a plea to one of the federal crimes under investigation — with a 24-month
binding sentencing recommendation — would have achieved USA Acosta's desired outcomes (24
months' imprisonment" and sex offender registration); would have provided federally mandated
restitution for the victims; and would have provided victims with court-funded representation via
the guardian ad litem program for those who needed it. All of these contortions were brought
about by the decision to use a state plea to resolve a federal investigation.
27 As noted above, I was never told the source of the 24-month figure. In my opinion, a
straight § 371 plea, with a five-year statutory maximum, was a significant concession.
Page 33 of 58
d. How the Florida state judicial system would address issues pertaining
to the terms of Mr. Epstein's incarceration, including designation of an
appropriate facility, the availability of work release (or any similar
release condition), and the availability of other privileges. Identify
whether such research was conducted before or after the non-
prosecution agreement was signed, and whether it was conducted
before or after Mr. Epstein entered his state court plea. Describe any
communications you or other USAO personnel had with
representatives of the Palm Beach County State Attorney's Office,
other law enforcement, or local corrections officials regarding these
matters.
One of my concerns about using a state forum to resolve this case was that it left our Office
with no control over the process. We also did not have any members of our team who had
experience with the Palm Beach County state courts — Criminal Chief Menchel had been a state
prosecutor in New York before joining the USAO; I had been in private practice. Similarly, no
one else involved in the process had been an ASA or even a criminal defense attorney in Palm
Beach County. The defense team, on the other hand, included Roy Black and Jack Goldberger,
who had extensive state court criminal experience in Palm Beach County. Any litigator will tell
you that knowing the Court is a key component of success, so we were placed at a distinct
disadvantage. It was exacerbated by defense counsel's tactics of prohibiting coordination between
the USAO and the SAO — which somehow was successful.28 It also required the USAO to place
an inordinate amount of trust in the SAO, when one of the reasons for opening the federal
investigation was the concerns that undue influence had been brought to bear on the State
Attorney.29
The loss of control did not just end with the Court proceedings, it included how the sentence
would be executed. Federal sentences are executed by the U.S. Marshals and the Bureau of
Prisons. All are housed within the Department of Justice and have clearly written rules and
regulations. BOP is used to housing wealthy, politically-connected offenders and would be less
likely to be unduly influenced by Epstein.
I attempted to build some certainty back into the agreement through several provisions.
First, I selected the state statutes that Epstein would have to plead guilty to and conducted my own
research to confirm that they required sex offender registration. Second, I included language that
28 Epstein's team was equally successful in DC, where they dictated who could and could
not participate in the "independent review" at CEOS. For example, Myesha Braden, who had not
yet joined the Leap Year team, was excluded from consideration because she had disagreed with
Lilly Ann Sanchez about the handling of an obscenity case while Ms. Sanchez was an AUSA.
29 According to PBPD Chief Reiter, the State Attorney initially planned to file no charges
against Epstein. Following complaints, the SAO planned to charge Epstein with a misdemeanor
solicitation of adult prostitution charge. Then, after the police chief complained further, the State
Attorney assertedly presented "multiple charges" to the grand jury, and they "elected" to return an
indictment charging one felony count of soliciting adult prostitution. The State Attorney did not
intend to charge an offense requiring sex offender registration and was only seeking a sentence of
probation.
Page 34 of 58
he would have to plead guilty, not nolo contendere. Third, I researched different terms that Florida
courts would use that appeared to impose a term of incarceration, but really imposed something
else, and prohibited those sentences ("Epstein shall be sentenced to consecutive terms of twelve
(12) months and six (6) months in county jail for all charges, without any opportunity for
withholding adjudication or sentencing, and without probation or community control is lieu of
imprisonment" (Exhibit 52 at 3 (emphasis added)). Fourth, I included a waiver of the right to
challenge the Information and an appeal waiver. Fifth, I included a requirement that Epstein would
have to provide the USA° with a copy of his plea agreement with the SAO before he signed it.
Sixth, I required Epstein to use his best efforts to enter his guilty plea within approximately 30
days and an agreement that that term (like all others) was material. Seventh, I included an
agreement that Epstein would not be afforded any gain time benefits different from any other
inmate, and that he would provide an accounting of gain time if asked. Finally, "breach of any
one of these conditions allows the United States to elect to terminate the agreement and to
investigate and prosecute Epstein and any other individual or entity for any and all federal
offenses" (id. at 6).
In addition to the terms of the NPA, the agents and I also did our best to make sure that
Epstein would be serving jail time like anyone else. Prior to the September 12, 2007 meeting at
the State Attorney's Office, I spoke with Andy Lourie and emailed Jeff Sloman about research I
had conducted on Florida sentencing practices to avoid "trucks up the sleeves of the defense"
(Exhibit 46 at I.) Normally a defendant who is sentenced to a term of prison in excess of 12
months must go to a state prison. The Office did not object to "splitting" Epstein's sentence into
two pieces — 12 months followed by 6 months — so that he would be eligible to be housed at the
Palm Beach County Jail. All of us were, however, insistent that Mr. Epstein would actually serve
out his term at the jail like any other prisoner. At the September 12, 2007 meeting with the State
Attorney's Office, this issue was specifically addressed, and State Attorney Krischer assured us
that Epstein would be at the Palm Beach County Jail (it is referred to as "Gun Club" because it is
located on Gun Club Road). I remember that they discussed that Epstein would be kept in solitary
confinement "for his own safety."
After that meeting, the case agents went to meet with the jail about the issue of work
release. I do not recall the exact date. On November 14, 2007, I sought FAUSA Sloman's
permission to meet with State Attorney Krischer after ASA Behlolavek stood up the agents a few
times. The purpose of my meeting was "to clear up the issue regarding sex offender
registration/work release and also should be able to tell us whether a plea and sentencing can be
scheduled this month" (Exhibit 72). FAUSA Sloman and Acting MAUSA Rolando Garcia had
conversations with the State Attorney and Jay Lefkowitz who both confirmed that Epstein would
"be a sex offender and he'll be treated like any other sex offender" (Exhibit 76 at 2). On November
16, 2007, the case agents met with ASA Belohlavek who said that Epstein would be housed at the
Palm Beach County Jail, so the Palm Beach Sheriff's Office would be in charge of whether Epstein
would be eligible for work release (id. at I). Special Agent Richards confirmed on November 16,
2007 that Epstein would not qualify for work release as a sex offender unless the judge specially
ordered it (id.).
As noted above, when we learned that Epstein's attorneys were negotiating a new deal with
the State Attorney's Office, Karen Atkinson and I firmly informed Epstein's attorneys and the
State Attorney's Office that there was a signed agreement. While they were free to negotiate
whatever they wanted, the terms they were discussing violated the NPA.
Page 35 of 58
In June 2008, when Epstein had exhausted his appeals to the DAG, in accordance with the
NPA, I asked to see the plea agreement that his attorneys had negotiated with the State Attorney's
Office to insure that it was consistent with the NPA (Exhibit 77). After a number of requests to
Roy Black and Jack Goldberger, I finally received the document (id.). After conferring with an
AUSA who had previously worked at the Palm Beach County SAO, and with FAUSA Sloman, I
informed Messrs. Goldberger and Black that the agreement was insufficient because it did not
specify that the defendant was supposed to serve his sentence in a custodial setting (id.). After
providing the written notice, Mr. Goldberger agreed to make the change (id) Goldberger also
called me and "'swore' [his word] that Epstein would be in custody 24-hours-a-day during the
community confinement portion of the sentence" (Exhibit 79).
The agents also confirmed with local officers that the language in the state plea agreement
suggested that Epstein would be at the Palm Beach County Detention Center, a/k/a the Palm Beach
County Jail, and that, during their meeting with PBSO Col. Gauger several months before, he had
assured them that Epstein would be ineligible for work release (Exhibit 80). Nonetheless, we
decided that we would go meet with the Colonel together. Karen Atkinson joined us, and we
learned that, despite the language in the agreement, Epstein was housed at the stockade rather than
the jail (a lower security "camp-style" facility) (Exhibit 81). Gauger also told us that Epstein
would be eligible for work release and will be placed on work release — directly contradicting what
he had told the agents a few months before (id. ).30 We asked Col. Gauger to let us know if Epstein
did, in fact, apply for work release.
We never received any notice of Epstein's application. Instead, on November 20, 2008,
when Gauger stopped by to see Karen Atkinson on another matter, he told her that Epstein had
been on work release for the past few weeks (Exhibit 82). S/A Kuyrkendall spoke with the work
release coordinator who told her that he was led to believe that the USAO and FBI knew that
Epstein had applied for the program. He also said that he had been threatened with being sued if
he didn't allow Epstein to participate (id) I reviewed my emails and notes of conversations with
Black, Goldberger, and other defense counsel about Epstein being incarcerated for the MI 18
months (except for credit for "gain time"). Criminal Chief Senior advised me to determine if there
was sufficient support to show a breach. After correspondence with Roy Black and a telephone
conference with Mr. Black and Jay Lefkowitz, we were advised that USA Acosta had informed

Mr. Leflcowitz3I that Epstein could be considered for any program that was available to other
prisoners. At that point, I was unable to press forward with a breach, so I conducted an in-depth
review of Epstein's application and found numerous false statements that, in my opinion, should
have made the Sheriffs Office reverse its position regarding work release. I drafted a letter
cataloguing all of the misstatements and conflicts of interest (e.g., Epstein's work release
supervisor was one of his employees who lived in New Jersey) and submitted it to the Sheriff's
Office (Exhibits 83 and 84). I never received a response from the Sheriff's Office.
30 Gauger also said that Jack Goldberger had threatened that "Ken Starr and the whole
crew" would sue the jail if Epstein received less favorable treatment than others (id).
31 1 do not recall whether Alan Dershowitz or Ken Starr also was present for this meeting,
but no one else from the USAO was present.
Page 36 of 58
9. Describe all efforts made by you, or by anyone else within the USAO, to ensure
that Mr. Epstein complied with the terms of the non-prosecution agreement
(including its addendum) that he signed. Include in your response a discussion
of all breaches of the agreement by Mr. Epstein of which the USAO was aware,
and explain why the USAO decided not to rescind the agreement as a
consequence of such non-compliance, who was involved in that decision, and
how the decision was made.
Many instances of notices of breach have been catalogued throughout this letter, as well as
my efforts to force Epstein to abide by the terms of the NPA prior to declaring a breach (e.g.,
resisting efforts to change the state plea to one that did not require sex offender registration;
requiring Epstein's counsel to provide us with copies of the state plea agreement before the plea;
requiring the appointment of the attorney-representative who representative the victims; etc.). The
attempt to declare a breach in connection with Epstein's application for work release is discussed
above.
In June 2009, Epstein and his lawyers tried to dismiss a lawsuit filed in the Southern
District of Florida by the attorney-representative on behalf of one of the identified victims that
raised a single claim under 18 U.S.C. § 2255. I prepared a lengthy memorandum analyzing why
Epstein's actions were a breach and seeking permission to serve a breach letter (Exhibit 85). The
Office approved the request to serve the breach letter. At the same time, the indictment package
was re-reviewed and approved (Exhibit 86). The notice of breach letter was served on June 12,
2009 (Exhibit 87). Epstein promptly "cured" the breach, but I took the opportunity to catalogue
his past breaches and advised that continuing on that course of conduct would no longer be
tolerated (Exhibit 88). Perhaps sensing that the Office's patience had waned, perhaps having
gained a greater understanding (through the civil litigation) of the strength of the potential criminal
case, Epstein's counsel expressed a greater interest in avoiding problems. While I demurred on
their request that I essentially offer "advisory opinions," I suggested that Mr. Epstein should "take
all of his obligations seriously and elect to err on the side of caution in making decisions that relate
to the performance of his duties" (Exhibit 89).
In consideration of my warnings, Mr. Black contacted the USAO to advise us in advance
that Mr. Epstein was seeking to transfer his community control to the Virgin Islands and wanted
our position (Exhibit 90). Having the experience of all of the false statements on Epstein's
application for work release, I immediately sought the application from Mr. Goldberger, but it was
never provided. I became concerned that Epstein's attorneys would use the delay engendered by

Mr. Goldberger's failure to provide me with the application as a bar to any objection, so I provided
a letter with preliminary objections (Exhibit 91). I noted that: "Throughout the negotiation of the
NPA, representations were repeatedly made by you and your colleagues that Mr. Epstein would
serve his complete sentence, including community control, in Palm Beach County. During his
change of plea and sentencing, Mr. Epstein told the Court that he intended to remain in Palm Beach
County during his period of community control — a fact that was important to Judge Pucillo in
making her decision whether or not to accept the plea agreement. Mr. Epstein's presence in Palm
Beach County was important to the Court, our Office, and, presumably, the State Attorney's
Office, because it allowed all of these entities to monitor Mr. Epstein's performance of his
obligations. Relocating to the Virgin Islands, where Mr. Epstein lives on a private island without
any independent law enforcement presence, would eliminate that ability" (id.). Following my
letter, Mr. Epstein did not follow through on his application to transfer to the Virgin Islands.
Page 37 of 58

10. Identify any cases in which you have been involved as an AUSA, or of which
you were otherwise aware, that were resolved through a non-prosecution
agreement.
I have not been involved in, nor am I aware of, any other cases that have been resolved via
a non-prosecution agreement. On one occasion, in my eighteen years with the Justice Department,
I recommended a Pre-Trial Diversion agreement for a doctor who wrote and filled a small number
of fraudulent opioid prescriptions that she took herself for her post-cancer pain. The
recommendation was vetted and approved through the chain of command in accordance with
Department policy (the USAM) and the USAO's Criminal Circular.
B. CVRA Compliance
1. Describe your understanding of any USAO, Department, or FBI policy or
practice regarding victim notification rights, obligations, or procedures that
were in effect from the time the federal investigation of Mr. Epstein began to
the time that he entered his state plea, including the applicability of the CVRA
to cases resolved through non-prosecution agreements, and identify the
source(s) of such understanding. Explain when and how you became aware of
such policy or practice. Describe your prior experience notifying victims
under the CVRA. Explain whether and how victim notifications in the Epstein
case departed from the USAO's general practice.
My understanding of USAO/DOJ victim notifications policies that were in effect in 2006-
2007 had come from my own work on PSC cases. I do not recall receiving any training from the
USAO on the CVRA or the AG's Guidelines on Victims' Rights prior to the Epstein case. I was
familiar with the CVRA, the Victims' Rights and Restitution Act, and other pieces r victims'
rights legislation, primarily from two prior cases that I had handled. In United States O'Neil, I
had litigated the Office's first case where a defendant objected to a victim impact statement. It
was a case where a 41-year-old man gave a lethal overdose of heroin to his 23-year-old girlfriend.
The victim's mother, other family members, and the owner of the rehab center where the defendant
had recruited the victim all asked to address the Court. I cited the CVRA and other statutes to
support the Court's authority to hear from them. The second case was United States' Oliver,
which was the Office's first case seeking the appointment of a guardian ad litem (GAL). Through
these cases, I researched statutes, cases, the USAM, and the AG Guidelines. I recall that the
Guidelines were often described themselves as a floor, not a ceiling. See, e.g., Attorney General
Guideline for Victim and Witness Assistance (May 2005) at 8 ("A strong presumption exists in
favor of providing rather than withholding assistance and services to victims and witnesses of
crime."). Like most PSC prosecutors and investigators, the agents and I treated the AG's
Guidelines as a floor and tried to provide a higher standard of contact.
That is why, during the Epstein investigation, victim rights notification letters were
provided at the first meeting between the agents and victims encouraging victims to contact me
directly with questions and concerns. Throughout the investigation, I tried to meet in person with
as many victims as possible and talk through their concerns. Many were afraid of Mr. Epstein;
many were afraid that their reputations would be ruined; almost all wanted to just put the episode(s)
behind them. Some had not even told their parents about what had happened and did not want
Page 38 of 58
their parents to know. Several girls needed counseling and at least one attempted suicide. S/As
Kuyrkendall and Richards, Victim-Witness Specialist Smith, and I all worked to find counseling
for those who wanted it through Palm Beach County Victim Services, and I reported the issues to
Karen Atkinson, Andy Lourie (when he was still in West Palm Beach), and Jeff Sloman. I also
recall sending and receiving emails regarding the emotional toll on the victims when agents and I
enquired into the status of the indictment review.
With regard to specific office procedures at the time of the Epstein investigation, there was
no victim-witness coordinator in West Palm Beach and no standardized way to do any victim
notifications prior to indictment. Our Office's procedure — which was still being developed at the
time of the Epstein investigation — required a victim list to be submitted along with the indictment
package. That victim list would be used to notify victims of upcoming court proceedings — to the
extent that those upcoming court dates appeared in the case tracking system used at the time.
Conferring with victims regarding plea negotiations could not happen through that victim
notification system, so my practice, when possible, was to ask agents to work with me to contact
victims about a potential plea. I also asked agents to work with me to notify victims of court dates
because I knew there was a delay with the victim notification system. For example, often a
defendant will decide the day before or the day of calendar call or trial to plead guilty. If it is a
case with victims, like a bank robbery case, the agents and I will do our best to contact the victims
to advise and confer, and to invite the victims to appear at the change of plea if they wish. The
victims also are informed that they will have the opportunity to give a victim impact statement for
purposes of sentencing.
In child exploitations cases where there has been a lot of contact with the victims, these
last-minute interactions are less likely. I usually discuss potential plea scenarios with the
parents/victims/GALs in advance and the judges aren't as rushed. The exception is child
pornography possession/distribution cases, where the victims often are not identified prior to the
plea.32 Especially during the time of the Epstein investigation, the procedures for identifying
victims in child pornography cases were in their infancy. Now, victims from many child
pornography "series" have been identified and have attorney contact information for purposes of
restitution. CEOS' Gelber is the national expert in this area.
To summarize, my understanding of my obligation was: to do my best to notify victims of
upcoming court proceedings and to make them feel welcome to — but not obligated to — participate
(unless subpoenaed, of course); to guard their privacy and help them navigate the process to come
out as unscathed as possible; to insure their safety from interference from the defendant; to listen
to their desires in terms of prosecution, plea, and sentencing and balance that with the other factors
that go into prosecutorial discretion33 in making decisions about the case; and to be mindful that
decisions that I and the Office made would impact them. I understood that conferring with the
victims did not mean that I had to agree with them or that they could override an Office decision.
For example, in the Oliver case, we had a plea offer for a lengthy sentence. The victim's father
believed that we should take the case to trial. The GAL and I did not believe that, given the age
32 These are cases where the defendant is not believed to be involved in the production of
the child pornography.
33 Those other factors include the need to do justice, to deter the defendant and others, and
to consider the impact of the prosecution on the local and national community.
Page 39 of 58
of the defendant, it made sense to put the victim, who was, I believe, 9 years' old at the time,
through the stress of a trial. After conferring with my supervisor, we decided to go forward with
the change of plea. The victim's father and the GAL made victim-impact statements and, in the
end, the judge imposed a sentence of 140 years' imprisonment followed by lifetime supervised
release.
With regard to the Epstein investigation in particular, the handling of victim notifications
varied from my understanding and my practice in two significant ways. First, it never occurred to
me that this was not a situation where conferring with the victims was required. I specifically
informed the Office in writing on two occasions and orally on other occasions, that I thought the
victims should be consulted before entering into the Non-Prosecution Agreement.34 The first of
these written reminders was in July 2007 when I learned that Criminal Chief Menchel had engaged
in plea discussions with Lilly Ann Sanchez. (Exhibit 3.) The second was in early September 2007
after my discussion with CEOS Chief Drew Oosterbaan regarding this subject. (Exhibit 44.) Later,
I believe after the NPA was already signed, Jeff Sloman told me that the Office had taken the
position in other cases that there is no obligation to confer in the absence of the filing of a federal
case, but I don't recall discussing that at the time. 35 I had never before used a non-prosecution
34 As I noted in my filings in the Jane Doe' United States litigation, I had concerns about
informing the victims that part of the negotiations involved securing for them the right to obtain
damages from Epstein until we knew that Epstein would, in fact, enter into and perform his
obligations under the NPA. As stated above, during the State investigation, Epstein's counsel had
frequently accused the victims of faking or exaggerating their statements for purposes of civil
damages claims. In a deposition for one of the civil suits, one of Epstein's lawyers later falsely
accused Jeff Sloman and me of telling a victim that she could get damages from Epstein if she told
the FBI that Epstein had assaulted her. (I can locate and redact this transcript.) I nevertheless
believed that we could and should have discussed other aspects of the NPA with them — that is,
the state guilty plea, sex offender registration, and the sentence. The AG Guidelines specifically
take into account situations like this, so I could have discussed jail time, sex offender registration,
avoiding trial, the right to address the court at sentencing, but, applying my discretion, decided not
to tell them about the monetary portion of the agreement. See 2005 AG Guidelines at 30 ("In
determining what is reasonable [in notifying identified victims about prospective plea
negotiations] the responsible official should consider factors relevant to the wisdom and
practicality of giving notice and considering views in the context of the particular case, including,
but not limited to, . . . [w]hether the victim is a possible witness in the case and the effect that
relating any information may have on the defendant's right to a fair trial.").
35 Regardless of that position, as noted earlier, the decision to resolve the case through a
non-prosecution agreement was made by Chief Menchel, and his email of July 5, 2007 informed
me that he was the person vested with the discretion to vary from any Department policy and that
he had undertaken his actions with USA Acosta's knowledge. I relied upon their knowledge of
the CVRA and exercise of discretion on this issue. (See Exhibit 3; see also 2005 AG Guidelines
at 10-11 ("Pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 10607(a), the Attorney General is request to designate persons
in the Department of Justice who will be responsible for identifying the victims of crime and
performing the services described in that section. These persons are referred to as 'responsible
officials' in the statute and throughout these AG Guidelines. . . . Responsible officials may delegate
their responsibilities under these AG Guidelines to subordinates in appropriate circumstances, but
Page 40 of 58
agreement or deferred prosecution in favor of state prosecution in the way that the Epstein case
was handled. I believed that the fairest course was to consult with the victims before the execution
of any agreement.
The second significant departure from my regular practice was the victim notification
procedure. Never before or since have I shared "drafts" of victim notifications with counsel for
the defendants. The CVRA places the entire burden of complying with the Act on the government
and the court and provides that a "person accused of the crime may not obtain any form of relief
under this Chapter." 18 U.S.C. § 3771(d)(1) (2004). But, in this case, I was required to provide
draft victim notification letters, rewrite them due to objections from defense counsel, and refrain
from sending them altogether. My protestations appear in my emails, and were shared with the
agents, my legal assistant, and my supervisors.
With regard to FBI policies and practices, I understood that the FBI had its own victim
notification procedures. I had previously worked with Twiler Smith on other cases (and worked
with her on other cases after the Epstein investigation). I did not know the details of what FBI
included in its letters or when they were sent. I did not instruct FBI on what to send or when to
send it. My general rule is to tell agencies to follow their regular procedures. I don't remember
saying anything different in this case. I did not see any FBI letters in this case prior to collecting
the FBI letters to Brad Edwards' clients in connection with the Jane Doe I United States litigation.
I did not instruct the FBI to include the language about the case being under investigation and that
they should be patient.
2. Identify all victims in this case to whom written or oral notifications were
made, when and how each notification was made, and the contents of the
notifications. Explain why notifications were made to some victims, and not
to others, and who was responsible for those decisions.
On the attached chart (Exhibit B-1), I listed all of the individuals identified as victims
during the state investigation, the federal investigation, or after Epstein entered his state guilty
plea, but who were brought to my attention by various attorneys. The chart lays out how and when
each was contacted. Due to the passage of time, it is impossible for me to give exact dates and the
exact content of each conversation. Also, there are some victims that I specifically remember
meeting with. There are some that I know I did not meet with. There are others that I believe I
met with, but I am not certain. I have qualified my answers on the chart accordingly.
On August 4, 2006, I prepared 24 Victim Notification Letters for victims who had been
identified during the state investigation. (Exhibit 12.) These were provided to Special Agent
Kuyrkendall to hand-deliver to victims during interviews. I decided to prepare these letters and I
decided on the content of those letters.
On August 11, 2006, 18 amended letters were prepared. (Exhibit 13.) These letters
clarified that the recipients were victims and/or witnesses, since we had not yet been able to
confirm that they were minors during the time of their encounters with Epstein and we were still
working to confirm federal jurisdiction. People who had already received the August 4, 2006
responsible officials remain obliged to ensure that all such delegated responsibilities are
discharged. The Attorney General designates the following responsible officials: .. . For cases in
which charges have been filed—the U.S. Attorney in whose district the prosecution is pending."))
Page 41 of 58
letters did not receive August 11, 2006 letters. If an August 11, 2006 letter was prepared, I believe
that meant that the agents had not yet made contact with the person and the agents discarded the
August 4, 2006 letter. We included letters for witnesses who we knew were over the age of 18 to
advise them to contact us if they felt they were being harassed because the agents had learned of
potential harassment during the early set of interviews. I decided to prepare these letters after
discussing the issue with Special Agent Kuyrkendall and I decided on the content of those letters.
Although I do not have a clear recollection of this, I believe that a new letter was issued
for Individual #4 because the agents had difficulty interviewing her and did not want to provide
her with a letter that was several months old. On June 7, 2007, I simply printed the same letter
with a new date and signed it. (Exhibit 30.) I do not believe that the August 11, 2006 letter was
ever provided to her. The same explanation applies for the June 7, 2007 letters for Individuals 9,
31, 38, and 43. (Exhibit 30.) Individuals 3 and 40 were not identified until several months into
the federal investigation. Victim notification letters were prepared for them on June 7, 2007.
(Exhibit 30.) I decided to prepare these letters after discussing the issue with Special Agent
Kuyrkendall and I decided on the content of the letters.
As discussed above, in July 2007 and September 2007, I raised in writing the need to confer
with the victims regarding the proposed agreement with Epstein. I also raised the issue in internal
conversations with supervisors, agents, and others. I was told that I could not discuss the matter
with the victims. (See Exhibits 3 and 44.)
After the Non-Prosecution Agreement was signed, I drafted a notification letter to inform
the victims of the terms of the agreement and the date of the state court proceedings. After several
delays, the state plea and sentencing date was set for December 9, 2007. On November 19, 2007,
I prepared the draft notification that appears at Exhibit B-2 based upon my reading of the NPA and
research I had conducted on state law. (See Exhibit B-7.) Several blanks appeared because we
were still waiting for Epstein's counsel to confirm that Epstein would pay the fees of the attorney-
representative selected by the Special Master.
A second draft of the plea notification letter was prepared on November 27, 2007 at 7:11
p.m. for Jeff Sloman's review. (Exhibit B-3.96 On November 28, 2007 at 9:42 p.m. a third draft
was prepared for Jeff Sloman's review. (Exhibit B-4). This version was shared with counsel for
Epstein. (Exhibits B-8). On November 29, 2007, Jay Lefkowitz, counsel for Epstein, objected to
the victim notification letter in a letter to USA Acosta. (Exhibit B-9). USA Acosta asked Mr.
Lefkowitz to discuss the matter with Jeff Sloman and me. (Exhibit B-10).
On December 5, 2007, Kenneth Starr and Jay Lefkowitz wrote a letter to USA Acosta
requesting an updated victim notification letter incorporating their objections. (Exhibit B-11). On
December 6, 2007, Jeff Sloman sent a letter to Jay Letkowitz, which attached another proposed
victim notification letter. (Exhibit B-12). There was significant internal correspondence regarding
my concerns that the Government needed to meet its obligation to inform the victims of the
upcoming plea. (Exhibit B-13). After providing a final draft to the Miami office on December 7,
36 This document was converted from Word Perfect, which caused the formatting
problems.
Page 42 of 58
2007, (Exhibit B-63'), later that day, my legal assistant and I prepared 32 victim notification letters
and envelopes to send. (Exhibit B-14). At 5:08 pm, I received an email from Jeff Sloman that
said, "Hold the letter" (Exhibit B-54).
On December 10 007, I contacted Jim Eisenberg, counsel for Individual # 28, who is Jane
Doe #2 in the Jane Doe I  United States suit. As noted on the attached chart, Mr. Eisenberg was
paid for by Mr. Epstein. I told Mr. Eisenberg that I was preparing victim notification letters and
needed to know if he was still representing Individual #28. He said that he was and instructed me
to send the letter to him. My continued designation of Individual #28 as a victim, based upon the
statements of other witnesses and the documentary evidence collected by federal and state agents,
was one of the main bases that Epstein's counsel used to support their allegations of prosecutorial
misconduct with officials at the Department of Justice. (See Exhibit B-20.) Based upon those
attacks, which relied upon the videotaped statement given by Individual #28, I was instructed by
either Jeff Sloman or Alex Acosta, not to consider Individual #28 as a victim for purposes of the
NPA because she was not someone whom the Office was prepare to include in an indictment.
On December 7, 2007, Lilly Ann Sanchez sent a letter to Jeff Sloman fmally providing the
USAO with the date and time of the change of plea for Mr. Epstein. (Exhibit B-15). Based upon
that information, on December 14, 2007, I prepared another version of the victim notification
letter. (Exhibit B-I 638). I provided a copy via email to Alex Acosta, Jeff Sloman, Rolando Garcia,
and Karen Atkinson. (Exhibit B-17). On December 17, 2007, I sent an email to Jeff Sloman
inquiring about the status of the case and informing him that the agents also were expressing their
concerns about the delays in victim notifications. (Exhibit B-18). Over my objection, my request
to send the victim notification letter was not approved, and on December 19, 2007, USA Acosta
sent a letter to Lilly Ann Sanchez stating, "I understand that the defense objects to the victims
being given notice of [the] time and place of Mr. Epstein's state court sentencing hearing. I have
reviewed the proposed victim notification letter and the statute. ... We will defer to the discretion
of the State Attorney to determine if he wishes to provide victims with notice of the state
proceedings, although we will provide him with the information necessary to do so if he wishes."
(Exhibit B-19.) Although I did not know it at the time, in preparing this response, I noticed that,
in FAUSA Sloman's June 3, 2008 letter to DAG Filip, he stated that the quoted language was
proposed by USA Acosta "in consultation with DAAG Mandelker." (Exhibit B-123 at 7.)
On December 21, 2007, attorney Jay Lefkowitz expounded on a new challenge — that Mr.
Epstein had not been provided with a list of the victims and an opportunity to challenge the list
prior to signing the NPA. I made clear verbally and in writing that I would not expose the victims
to further harassment while Epstein was clearly trying to wheedle his way out of pleading guilty
and going to prison. As I told Mr. Lefkowitz, I had devised a system to address this concern prior
to the signing of the NPA; since Epstein's team of attorney's had not requested the right to see and
challenge the list, I had not offered it. A few days later, Lefkowitz again wrote to the U.S. Attorney
stating that he did not think our Office should provide any notifications; they should come only
" This document was converted from Word Perfect, which caused the formatting
problems.
38 This document was converted from Word Perfect, which caused the formatting
problems.
Page 43 of 58
from the State Attorney's Office. Lefkowitz insisted on the right to review the letters. (Exhibit
B-22).39
The matter was tabled while Epstein was allowed time to raise his federal jurisdiction,
sufficiency, and prosecutorial misconduct challenges with CEOS, the DAAG, and the AAG.
While everything was supposed to be "on hold" pending those reviews, I learned that Epstein was
trying to contact some of the victims — victims who would have been represented if Epstein had
performed his obligations under the terms of the NPA. I then worked to find pro bono counsel for
those victims (Exhibit B-23).
On May 15, 2008, CEOS, DAAG Mandelker, and AAG Fisher completed their review,
finding that our case against Epstein was neither improper nor inappropriate (Exhibit B-24). By
that time, a revised indictment package had already been reviewed and approved (Exhibits B-25
through B-28). Additional victims also had been identified through the continued investigation
(Exhibits B-29 through B-31).
On May 19, 2008, FAUSA Sloman wrote to counsel for Epstein giving Epstein two weeks
to enter his guilty plea in state court in accordance with the terms of the NPA (Exhibit B-32).
Rather than performing, Epstein sought continued review, again alleging prosecutorial
misconduct and challenging both the sufficiency of the evidence and the federal interest in the
case. At this point, Epstein sought review from Deputy Attorney General Mark Filip (Exhibit B-
33), and he hired Joe Whitley to join his defense team. I was informed that Epstein's deadline to
enter his guilty plea would be extended again, and we continued preparing for indictment (Exhibits
B-34 through B-37). So, on May 27, 2008, Bob Senior, who took Matt Menchel's place as
Criminal Chief, Jeff Sloman, who had taken over for USA Acosta due to his recusal from the
Epstein matter, Karen Atkinson, and 1 all had an email exchange agreeing that there would be no
further negotiations and that the case would be indicted (Exhibit B-38).
At the same time, the agents heard that Epstein was trying to strike a new deal with the
State Attorney's Office — one that would require less jail time (Exhibit B-39) (discussed below).
While the DAG completed his review, I was told that the grand jury presentation would be
delayed again (Exhibit B-40). I was then tasked with drafting the USAO's letter to DAG Filip in
response to Epstein's challenges.
While the case was being investigating and prepared for indictment, I did not prepare or
send any victim notification letters — there simply was nothing to update. I did not receive any
victim calls during this time. I did receive communications from two attorneys. In March 2008,
I received a letter from attorney Richard Willits, advising me that he represented Individual #3 and
that he had filed suit on her behalf against Epstein in Palm Beach County Circuit Court (Exhibit
B-41). I responded, acknowledging his representation (Exhibit B-42). On June 18, 2008, I
livreceived a call from attorney Brad ards, who told me that he represented Individual #43, who
is also Jane Doe #1 in the Jane Doe United States lawsuit. Mr. Edwards expressed an interest
in assisting with the case. We were still waiting to hear about whether we would be moving
" On the State side, Lefkowitz has consistently taken the position that there were only two
victims related to the state offenses. Thus, if only the State provided notifications, only two victims
would receive notices of the hearing and Epstein would avoid a full sentencing hearing.
Page 44 of 58
forward to indictment. I invited him to send whatever information he could and expressed that
time was of the essence (Exhibit B-43). Given the uncertainty of the situation — Epstein was still
challenging our ability to prosecute him federally, pressing allegations of prosecutorial
misconduct, and trying to negotiate better plea terms, while the agents, my supervisors, and I were
all moving towards indictment — I did not feel comfortable sharing any information about the case.
It also is my practice not to talk about status before the grand jury. For those reasons, and because
I had never met Mr. Edwards, I listened more than I spoke.
Early on June 23, 2008, FAUSA Sloman emailed Criminal Chief Senior saying that, if the
USAO received the go-ahead from the DAG's Office, I should immediately notify Epstein's
attorneys that Epstein would only have until June 3011' to comply with the September 246
agreement or be held in breach. Later that day, Mr. Senior responded, cc'ing me, instructing me
to send out that notification (Exhibit B-49). On June 23, 2008, DAG Filip completed his review,
and John Roth sent a letter to Attorneys Starr and Lefkowitz stating their finding that there was no
abuse of discretion and no misconduct (Exhibit B-44). I immediately sent an email to Jay
Lefkowitz in accordance with Mr. Senior's instructions (Ex. B-49). The following day, Roy Black
and Jack Goldberger, as local counsel for Epstein, contacted me to wrap up the details of
performing pursuant to the terms of the NPA (Exhibit B-45). On June 25 and 26, 2008, there were
a series of internal communications regarding victim notification letters and providing Epstein
with a final list of victims (Exhibits B-46, B-47, B-48). I provided my draft victim notification
letter to FAUSA Sloman and USA Acosta (Exhibits B-47, B-48).4° Since Mr. Acosta had agreed
in December 2007 that we would not provide written notice of the state change of plea, the written
victim notifications were prepared to be sent immediately following Epstein's guilty plea. The
FBI was working on finalizing the victim list to disclose to Epstein (Exhibit B-50). I requested
permission to make oral notifications to the victims regarding the upcoming change of plea, but
the Office decided that victim notifications could only come from a state investigator, and Jeff
Sloman asked PBPD Chief Reiter to assist (Exhibit B-52).
On Friday, June 27, 2008, we received notification that Epstein's change of plea and
sentencing would occur the following Monday, June 30, 2008 (Exhibit B-51). I made two calls to
try to spread the word about the state change of plea. Following up on FAUSA Sloman's call from
the previous day, I called Chief Reiter and asked him to notify the victims (Exhibit B-53). I also
called Brad Edwards as counsel for Individuals 35 and 43,41 and strongly encouraged him and his
clients to attend. He said that someone would try to be there. I had not been authorized by the
Office to disclose the terms of the NPA, so I could not be more explicit in my conversation with
him (Exhibit B-54).
After the change of plea on June 30, 2008, I made calls to the attorneys whom I knew
represented identified victims in civil suits to confirm that they wanted me to send their clients'
victim notification letters to the attorneys (Exhibit B-55). Also, as directed by my Office, I
40 Exhibits B-47 and 8-48 consist of emails with draft victim notification letters attached.
Due to changes in word processing systems, some of the attachments, as well as other drafts, have
formatting issues when they were printed. My original draft was prepared on 6/25/2008 at 3:57
pm. I revised it at 5:23 p.m. that same day. I received a revised version from USA Acosta and
FAUSA Sloman at 6:00 p.m. on June 25111.
41 Mr. Edwards also was representing Individual #28 at the time, but I did not know that.
Page 45 of 58
provided a draft of the proposed victim notification letter to counsel for Epstein (Exhibit B-56). I
was concerned that Epstein and his counsel were again creating a potential problem. USA Acosta
had taken the position that the final NPA consisted of three documents — the 9/24/2007 NPA, the
10/29/2007 Addendum, and the 12/19/07 letter from USA Acosta to Lilly Ann Sanchez. I prepared
victim notifications (and, later, a Declaration in the Jane Doe litigation) based upon this
understanding. When Epstein entered his guilty plea, Judge McSorley required him to file his
federal Non-Prosecution Agreement with the Court since that formed part of the consideration for
the state plea. I wanted to confirm that Epstein was taking a consistent position with the State
Attorney's Office, Judge McSorley, and the USAO, so I asked for a copy of what was filed in the
State Court. This led to multiple letters with counsel for Epstein before I could finalize the victim
notification letters (Exhibits B-57 through B-65). On July 9, 2008, I finally sent the first two
victim notification letters to two of Brad Edwards' clients, Individuals 35 and 43 (Exhibit B-66).
Whenever I sent a victim notification letter, a redacted version of the letter also was sent to Jack
Goldberger, counsel for Jeffrey Epstein. I was not authorized to send a victim notification letter
to Individual # 28 or to include her on the list of persons provided to Epstein because she was not
a person that the Office was prepared to name in an indictment.42
On July 10, 2008, I sent victim notification letters to a number of other represented victims,
Individuals 3, 8, 17, 25, 26, 37, and 44 (Exhibit B-67). The FBI also asked for some assistance of
language to use in its own victim notifications (Exhibit B-68), and I was waiting for contact
information for the unrepresented victims (Exhibit B-69). On July 21, 2008, I sent victim
notification letters to a group of unrepresented victims, Individuals 1, 2, 4, 9, 13, 14, 21, 23, 30,
32, and 38 (Exhibit B-70). There were some unrepresented victims who did not receive
notification letters on July 21, 2008 because the FBI had not been able to confirm mailing
addresses by that time — Individuals 10, 11, 16, 18, 20, 24, 31, 33, 36, 39, 40, and 42.
In August 2008, the issue of "which version of the NPA controls" finally came to a head.
On August 5, 2008, in the context of a Notice of Breach, I pressed my Office to clarify the issue
(Exhibit B-71). The decision was made to require Epstein to elect either the 12/19/07 letter or not,
but to make it clear in writing (Exhibits B-73 through B-82). On August 15, 2008, I wrote to Roy
Black and Jay Lefkowitz confirming their position that the final agreement consisted only of the
NPA and Addendum (Exhibit B-83). By discarding USA Acosta's December 2007 modification,
the original terms providing for the attorney representative for the victims came back into effect,
and the victim notification letters for the unrepresented victims were even more important. Mr.
Lefkowitz responded on August 18, 2008 with "objections" in advance to the language of the
victim notifications (Exhibit B-84). On August 21, 2008, I responded to Mr. Lefkowitz with a
draft victim notification letter corresponding to the language contained in the NPA and Addendum
and noted the importance of promptly providing corrected information to the victims (Exhibit B-
85). The following day, Mr. Lefkowitz sent a letter with indeterminate objections to the letter
(Exhibit B-86). I responded by pointing out that the language in the victim notification letter was
taken verbatim from the NPA and Addendum (Exhibit B-87).
On September 2, 2008, Mr. Lefkowitz finally confirmed that Mr. Goldberger would be the
designated recipient for victim notifications and that Mr. Epstein would pay the attorney
representative's fees (Exhibit B-88). I immediately started distributing victim notification letters.
42 That decision was made by USA Acosta and/or FAUSA Sloman. I do not know which.
Page 46 of 58
On that date, Notification Letters were sent directly to Individuals 1, 2, 4, 9, 10, 11,43 13, 14, 16,
20,44 21, 23, 24, 30, 31, 32,45 33, and 38, and via counsel to Individuals 3, 8, 17, 25, 26, 37, and
44 (Exhibit B-89). On September 3, 2008, Notification Letters were sent via counsel to Individuals
35 and 43, and via FBI Legal Attaches to Individuals 36 and 42 (Exhibit B-90). On September
12, 2008, I sent a Notification Letter to Individual 39 (Exhibit B-91). On September 15, 2008, I
sent Notification Letters to Individuals 18 and 32 (Exhibit B-92).
Soon thereafter, I received a letter from Jeffrey Herman, one of the civil attorneys who
represented a number of victims, notifying me that he had complained to the Florida Bar that the
Victim Notification Letters violated the Florida Bar rules against solicitation. He had filed
complaints against myself and against Robert Josefsberg — the attorney-representative selected by
the Special Master. On September 18, 2008, I wrote to the Florida Bar asking for an Ethics opinion
(Exhibit B-93). I did not feel that I could send out any additional notifications until I received a
response to that inquiry. The Florida Bar eventually issued a letter reviewing the relevant rules
that (a) contacts with represented and unrepresented persons required by law are permitted and (b)
business solicitation prohibitions are limited to those motivated by pecuniary gain. Thereafter, I
issued notification letters to Individuals 20 and 40 on November 14, 2008 (Exhibit B-94).
I only issued one other set of victim notifications: when I learned that Epstein had been
allowed out on work release. While it technically was not required, I knew that the State
Attorney's Office had not provided the notice, so I wanted to provide the victims with at least the
option to take advantage of "exclusionary zones.i 46 On December 4, 2008, I drafted a work release
notice, which was approved by my office (Exhibit B-95). The following day, I sent work release
notices to attorneys for Individuals 1, 2, 3, 8, 13, 14, 17, 20, 21, 25, 26, 28, 31, 32, 35, 35, 43, and
44 (Exhibit B-96). On December 8, 2008, I sent work release notices to attorneys for Individuals
7, 9, 17, and 37, and I sent notices directly to Individuals 11, 39, and 40 (Exhibit B-97). On
December 9, 2008, I mailed work release notices directly to Individuals 4, 10, 16, 18, 23, 24, 30,
33, and 38 (Exhibit B-98). On December 11, 2008, I followed up with the attorneys about whether
any of their clients wanted to take advantage of the "Exclusionary Zone" option in Epstein's GPS
unit (Exhibit B-99). There was a bit of correspondence and telephone calls about this, but
ultimately none of the victims elected to participate in this. On December 12, 2008, I send the
work release notice to Individual #42 (Exhibit B-100).
I am not aware of any other notices provided to victims in connection with this case.
43 The letter was returned on September 12, 2008, and Individual #11 was contacted by
phone. She came to the office and picked up the letter in person on September 16, 2008.
44 The letter was returned on September 15, 2008. A new letter was sent on November 14,
2008 to a corrected address.
45 The letter was returned on September 11, 2008. A new letter was sent on September 15,

2008. At Individual #32's request, a copy was sent to her and with a copy to Jeffrey Herman, Esq.
46 "Exclusionary zones" can be programmed into a GPS tracking unit to send an alarm if a
prisoner on work release enters into a prohibited area — e.g., a four-block radius of a victim's
residence.
Page 47 of 58
3. Identify all individuals within the USAO and FBI who had a role in
determining whether, when, how, and to which victims to provide victim
notifications in the Epstein case and explain what decisions were made and the
basis for them.
Greater detail is provided in the answer to Item B-2, above, and the exhibits referenced
therein. Normally the line AUSA is the person who handles deciding who should receive victim
notifications. Prior to indictment, the line AUSA has responsibility for those notifications, in
conjunction with the case agents. Post-indictment, a victim list is provided to the victim-witness
coordinator who is supposed to issue letters (again, I do not know how automated that was in 2006-
2008). In this matter, I made the decision to make contact with victims early and I decided on the
content of the introductory letters as well as the recipients of those letters. At the time of plea
negotiations, Criminal Chief Menchel made the decision that he had the authority to vary from the
general policy of conferring with victims before entering into a plea. I do not know the basis for
that decision (see Exhibit 3). His email to me said that the decision was made with USA Acosta's
concurrence. I do not know the veracity of that statement. I know that, even after Chief Menchel
left the USAO, as the plea negotiations continued, when I re-raised the issue of conferring with
the victims after discussing it with CEOS Chief Drew Oosterbaan (see Exhibit 44), the Office still
did not confer. I do not know the basis for this decision.
Regarding providing notifications of the date of the change of plea, I drafted several
iterations of a notification letter and also asked to provide oral notifications. USA Acosta decided
that the USAO should not provide any notifications of a state court proceeding. From the
correspondence that he drafted, the basis for doing so was that it was a state proceeding, not a
federal one, so the notice should come from the State Attorney's Office.
With regard to the FBI, my understanding is that Twiler Smith, the victim specialist, in
conjunction with Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, the case agent, had primary responsibility for making
victim notifications and the content of those. I do not know if anyone else within the FBI played
any role in those decisions, and, with regard to their standard victim notification letters, I do not
believe that anyone from the USAO played any role. I know that the FBI deferred to the USAO,
and to USA Acosta's decision not to confer with the victims in advance of signing the NPA. I also
know that the FBI also deferred to USA Acosta's decision not to inform the victims of the state
court plea.

4. Identify any effort made by the government to notify the victims, either in
writing or through other means, that it intended to enter into a non-
prosecution agreement with Mr. Epstein, or had entered into such an
agreement. For all such efforts, identify the victims notified, when, and by
whom. If some or all of the victims were not notified about the non-
prosecution agreement, explain why and identify the individuals responsible
for the decision.
Greater detail is provided in the answer to Item B-2, above, and the exhibits referenced
therein. In short, while I requested permission to confer with the victims in advance of entering
into the NPA, that permission was denied. So no one notified the victims that the government
intended to enter into a non-prosecution agreement. Immediately after the government entered
into the NPA, I prepared notification letters, but the U.S. Attorney decided that these letters also
should not be sent out. The case agents made oral notifications to two identified victims in October
Page 48 of 58
2007, but they became concerned that it appeared that Epstein was going to renege on the NPA.
The agents suspected that, at trial, Epstein would allege that the agents had told the victims that
they could get money from Epstein. So they decided to suspend the notifications until Epstein was
indicted or his "challenges" to the NPA and the investigation were settled.
5. Explain why victims who received victim notification letters after the non-
prosecution agreement was first signed in September 2007 were notified in the
letters that the federal investigation of Jeffrey Epstein "is currently under
investigation." Explain whether you, or other government personnel,
considered whether the statement was accurate in light of the non-prosecution
agreement; describe the process leading to the decision to so advise the victims;
and describe any discussions among government personnel concerning the
statement and its accuracy, occurring before or after it was made.
The letters containing the quoted language were prepared by FBI victim-witness specialist
Twit Smith and I was unaware of them until they were collected in connection with the Jane
Doe United States litigation. I do not recall ever discussing the wording of the FBI's letters
prior to their distribution. The decision to issue the letters and the wording of those letters were
exclusively FBI decisions.
Even though I was unaware of the language at the time, there is no doubt that from the
perspective of the agents and myself the matter was, in fact, "currently under investigation." The
NPA was signed on September 24, 2007. The letters that Judge Marra referred to in his order were
dated January 10, 2008 and May 30, 2008. During the period that the letters were sent, Epstein
was asserting that: (a) there was insufficient evidence to charge him with any offense; (b) there
was no basis for federal prosecution and that federal prosecution violated the Petite policy; (c) I
had engaged in prosecutorial misconduct during the investigation and resolution of the matter; (d)
Jeff Sloman had engaged in prosecutorial misconduct during the investigation and resolution of
the matter; (e) Special Agent Kuyrkendall had engaged in misconduct during the investigation of
the matter; and (f) the NPA violated public policy because of its inclusion of the provision for §
2255 damages in lieu of mandatory restitution. Setting aside items (a) through (e), if the
Department agreed with item (1) or if Epstein accepted USA Acosta's invitation to "unwind" the
NPA and proceed to trial, we were faced with a target who had committed numerous identified
crimes and had unlimited resources to flee the jurisdiction. The investigative team wanted to be
prepared to arrest him as quickly as possible with the strongest criminal case at the ready. I also
believed that either the U.S. Attorney or someone at DOJ would stop allowing Epstein to use the
NPA as both a sword and a shield — attacking terms that Ken Starr had once thanked me for
recommending while keeping the USAO from indicting Epstein.
On December 12, 2007, Criminal Chief Senior and I finalized a revised indictment package
to present to the grand jury (Exhibit B-101). On January 7, 2008, I sent an email to my entire
advisory chain — up to the U.S. Attorney — laying out a series of steps in furtherance of the
investigation (Exhibit B-102). Next, I secured the assignment of a CEOS attorney, Myesha
Braden, as co-counsel, and she immediately traveled to West Palm Beach to participate in
interviews to familiarize herself with the case and to re-connect with the victims to prepare them
for potential trial testimony (Exhibits B-103, B-104). On January 14, 2008, Ms. Braden and I went
over charging and investigative strategy, as well as her next trip to West Palm Beach (Exhibit B-
105). I also asked the agents to compile the evidence so that it would be more manageable for
Page 49 of 58
Chief Senior's ongoing indictment review (Exhibit B-106). Ms. Braden, the agents, and I
continued working on the best way to charge the case, and collecting evidence to corroborate
witness statements (see Exhibit B-107). On January 31, 2008, another group of grand jury
subpoenas was prepared and served (Exhibit B-108). On January 31 and February 1, 2008, Ms.
Braden, the agents and I re-interviewed a series of victims (Exhibit B-109). As you can see from
Exhibit B-109, it wasn't simply the agents and I who thought that the investigation was ongoing,
the supervisory chain (up to and including the U.S. Attorney and the Chief of CEOS) was aware
that: (1) victim and witness interviews were occurring; (2) grand jury subpoenas were being issued;
and (3) an indictment package was being revised and reviewed.
In February 2008, I was focused on working with the agents and Ms. Braden to finalize a
revised indictment package and having it reviewed and signed by my supervisors (Exhibit B-110).
On February 20, 2008, I sent an email to USA Acosta, FAUSA Sloman, CEOS Chief Oosterbaan,
Criminal Chief Senior, and others in the supervisory chain letting them know that I had provided
the final indictment package to my immediate supervisor the previous day (Exhibit B-I 11). I also
informed Ms. Braden that I reserved time with the grand jury on March 11, 2008 and asked her to
attend on that date (id). On February 25, 2008, I conferred with my immediate supervisor and
with one of our Senior Litigation Counsel, who also was one of our Professional Responsibility
Officers, about whether there was any reason to re-present the case to a different grand jury
(Exhibit B-112). I provided the result of my inquiry to FAUSA Sloman, Criminal Chief Senior,
the West Palm Beach supervisors, and Ms. Braden (Exhibit B-113). My supervisor completed her
review the following day (see Exhibit B-114).
Also on February 26, 2008, FAUSA Sloman informed me that he had told attorney Jay
Lefkowitz that, if CEOS rejected Epstein's position, Epstein would be allowed "one week to abide
by the terms and conditions of the September 24, 2007 Agreement" (Exhibit B-115). I wrote to
FAUSA Sloman telling him that I could not understand why Epstein would be allowed to plead to
the same terms in light of Epstein's false allegations and in light of the new evidence we had
uncovered, including six confirmed additional victims and three potential new victims in New
York (id.). I don't recall receiving any response.
Despite that communication to Epstein's counsel, the Office continued towards indictment.
On February 27 and 28, 2008, FAUSA Sloman, Criminal Chief Senior, Civil Rights Chief
Weinstein, and I communicated about the USAM requirement that DOJ's Civil Rights Section be
consulted when violations of 18 U.S.C. § 1591 are included in an indictment (Exhibit B-116). I
continued reviewing records received in response to grand jury subpoenas and the agents continued
working towards identifying additional witnesses and victims (Exhibit B-117). The following day,
I advised the same gentlemen about identifying another New York witness/potential victim and
her upcoming planned interview and inquired about the status of CEOS' review (Exhibit B-118).
In March 2008, there were several developments in the investigation. The case agent and
I decided to present search warrants for memory cards that the Palm Beach Police Department had
collected. They had been reviewed by the PBPD near the time they were collected and no images
of child pornography had been seen, but a forensic examiner had recently opined that forensic
examination might result in the recovery of deleted images. I advised that a new forensic
examination would require search warrants, so they were prepared and executed (Exhibits B-119,
B-120).
Page 50 of 58
On March 5, 2008, I updated the Office supervisory chain and CEOS Chief Oosterbaan on
a number of case developments (Exhibit B-121). In that email, I noted that, if we were not going
to proceed, we needed to be mindful of the state statute of limitations, to allow the PBPD to present
charges to the Palm Beach State Attorney's Office (id). I also reported on the status of indictment
review and my plan to start presenting to the grand jury on March 18, 2008, so that the grand jury
would have sufficient time to hear all of the evidence and reflect on it before voting on an
indictment (id.). On March 14, 2008, the head of the West Palm Beach office completed his review
of the indictment package and it was forwarded to Criminal Chief Senior for final review and
approval (Exhibits B-25, B-122). On March 18, 2008, I began my grand jury presentation (Exhibit
B-26). The planned continued presentation to the grand jury was postponed while we awaited
CEOS' review. I expressed my concerns about the impact on the ongoing investigation (Exhibit
B-124).
In mid-May, 2008, CEOS completed its review, finding that a federal prosecution of
Epstein's conduct was factually and legally sound (Exhibit B-24). The agents and I immediately
prepared to go back to the grand jury (Exhibit B-125). My supervisors also immediately prepared
to review and finalize an indictment incorporating the results of the continued investigation
(Exhibit B-38). The agents continued locating and interviewing more victims (see, e.g., Exhibit
B-126). When DAG Filip agreed to consider Epstein's challenges, the planned grand jury
presentation was canceled (Exhibit 8-40).
Even after that delay, the agents and I pressed on. In June 2008, even as I was assisting
with the USAO's submissions to DAG Filip (Exhibits B-123, B-127, and B-128), the agents and I
were working on additional grand jury subpoenas and obtaining 6001 immunity for a witness
(Exhibit B-129). On June 17, 2008, I applied for, and received permission to seek DOJ approval
for 6001 immunity (Exhibit 8-130). On June 24, DAAG Mandelker's designee granted the
application (Exhibit B-131). I also received permission to travel to New York with the agents to
conduct additional witness interviews (B-132). Time with the grand jury was scheduled and the
supervisory chain was informed of those plans as well as the status of the application for 6001
immunity (Exhibit B-133). I also was corresponding with counsel for the witness about her travel
for the grand jury appearance, which was scheduled for July I, 2008 (Exhibit B-I 34). Even when
the witness' attorney told me that Epstein would be pleading guilty on June 30, 2008, I would not
release the witness (id). I formally withdrew the subpoena on June 30, 2008, following Jeffrey
Epstein's entry of his guilty plea in state court (Exhibit B-135).
These activities took us up to the time of Jeffrey Epstein's June 30, 2008 guilty plea. From
September 2007 until the end of June 2008, the agents and I: collected additional evidence;
reviewed that evidence; interviewed new victims and witnesses; re-interviewed previously
identified victims and witnesses; identified new crimes and charges; developed new charging
strategies; drafted supplemental pros memos; revised the indictment package; and presented new
evidence and testimony to the grand jury. Although I did not know that Victim-Witness Specialist
Smith's letters contained the language that the Epstein case was "currently under investigation,"
from my perspective, that language was absolutely true and, despite being fully advised of our
ongoing investigative activities, no one in my supervisory chain ever told me that the case was not
under investigation.
Page 51 of 58
C. General
1. As to all of the foregoing matters, identify any disagreements or concerns
expressed by government personnel as to these matters, the parties involved,
how the disagreements were resolved, and any concerns you had about any
such resolution and the individuals, if any, with whom you discussed your
concerns.
I raised a multitude of concerns during the investigation, negotiations, and enforcement
periods. They ranged from the explicit — my July 2007 email exchange with Matt Menchel about
his violations of the USAM, CVRA, and Ashcroft Memo (Exhibit 3) — to the subtle — repeated
requests to just meet with the victims. Here is one especially poignant request from January 31,
2008:
Hi Jeff and Alex - We just finished interviewing three of the girls. I wish you could
have been there to see how much this has affected them.
One girl broke down sobbing so that we had to stop the interview twice within a 20
minute span. She regained her composure enough to continue a short time, but she
said that she was having nightmares about Epstein coming after her and she started
to break down again, so we stopped the interview.
The second girl, who has a baby girl of her own, told us that she was very upset
about the 18 month deal she had read about in the paper. She said that 18 months
was nothing and that she had heard that the girls could get restitution, but she would
rather not get any money and have Epstein spend a significant time in jail.
The FBI's victim-witness coordinator attended and she has arranged for counseling
for several of the girls.
Please reach out to Alice to make her decision. These girls deserve so much better
than they have received so far, and I hate feeling that there is nothing I can do to
help them.
We have four more girls coming in tomorrow. Can I persuade you to attend?
(Exhibit C-1.)
Many of the disagreements have been catalogued above, but I will try to collect them into
general categories in chronological order.

a. I did not want to meet with counsel for Epstein (Lilly Ann Sanchez and Gerald Lefcourt)
prior to completing my investigation. My co-counsel (John McMillan) agreed with me.
Our supervisor, Andrew Lourie, overruled us.

b. AUSA McMillan and I did not want to have a subsequent meeting with another set of
attorneys for Epstein, including Lilly Ann Sanchez, Gerald Lefcourt, Alan Dershowitz, and
Roy Black, that would also include Criminal Chief Matt Menchel. Over my objections,

Mr. Menchel also instructed me to provide defense counsel with a list of the federal statutes
that we had under consideration. Mr. Menchel asked me to provide all of my evidence to
the defense and only withdrew that instruction when I reminded him that federal statutes
Page 52 of 58
protected child victims' identities. I told my supervisor, Karen Atkinson, my concerns and
that I thought I should ask to have the case reassigned, and she counseled against it (Exhibit
C-4).

c. Ms. Atkinson, the agents, and I all tried to impress upon the others that, due to the nature
of the crimes under investigation, time was of the essence — Epstein was accused of
committing sexual offenses against dozens of minor girls. Our expert witness, as well as
our own experience, led us to believe that Epstein would not cease his criminal behavior
voluntarily. We also knew that Epstein was continuing to travel extensively using his
private airplanes, and that he would have the ability to flee to a jurisdiction that did not
extradite if he knew that charges were coming. At one point in May 2007, after the
indictment had been reviewed on several levels, we knew where Epstein would be and I
asked to arrest him on a criminal complaint. Criminal Chief Menchel responded that he
was "having trouble understanding — given how long this case has been pending — what the
rush is." (Exhibit C-5). There was another instance a month or two later where we knew
that Epstein was traveling to serve as a judge for a beauty contest and I again asked for
permission to prepare a criminal complaint. Criminal Chief Menchel's denial of the
request was even more emphatic.

d. In July 2007, Mr. Menchel and I exchanged strong words when he reported that he had
engaged in plea negotiations without the input or knowledge of the agents, victims, or
myself (Exhibit 3). My objections included:

i. The failure to meet and consult with the victims, agents, and me before
deciding what plea offer to extend.

ii. Offering a plea to a state offense. There was never any explanation of why
a federal investigation would be resolved with a state plea, and I understood
that a state plea would remove all control over the plea and sentencing
procedure.
iii. Starting the negotiations at only 24 months' imprisonment, which was
unreasonably low and not in keeping with any of the federal crimes under
investigation.07

iv. Sending the message to defense counsel that plea negotiations would be
handled by the executive division rather than the line prosecutor and the
West Palm Beach supervisory team.

e. From the beginning of the federal investigation, the agents and I had pushed to get the
computer equipment that Epstein had removed from his home prior to the execution of the
state search warrant. When Epstein's counsel had stated that Epstein wanted to
"cooperate" with the federal investigation, we asked that they turn it over voluntarily; they
never did. We sought it via grand jury subpoena and they moved to quash the subpoena.
Every time the matter was set for a hearing, Epstein's counsel would ask the Office to agree
47 Mr. Menchel's responsive email in July 2007, suggested that, in light of the statement
by Ms. Sanchez that 24 months' imprisonment was a "non-starter," we would be able to re-set plea
negotiations at a higher number, but that never happened.
Page 53 of 58
g.
to "continue" the hearing pending our "plea negotiations." I repeatedly recommended
moving forward on the computer equipment because it was obvious that they did not want
to turn it over and the equipment likely contained hard evidence of travel, contact with
victims, obstruction of justice, and possibly child pornography offenses. Instead, the
Office continuously agreed to put off the hearing and even when Epstein's attorneys tried
to use the existence of the pending motion to quash as a basis to stay some of the victims'
civil suits.

f. Once I was informed that I had to devise a plea agreement with a sentencing cap of 24
months' imprisonment, I drafted a plea to a conspiracy to violate 18 U.S.C. § 2422, in
violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371 — one of the crimes that had been the subject of the
investigation and that was included in the indictment. That crime was a felony with a five-
year statutory maximum, and the guidelines would have exceeded the five-year max, so
the plea agreement would have had to be a binding plea pursuant to Fed. R. Crim. P.
11(c)(1)(C), which is what I drafted. I was informed by Mr. Lourie that USA Acosta did
not want to do a (c)(1)(C) plea, so I had to find charges that would result in a two-year
statutory maximum. This resulted in me having to research misdemeanors and find facts
that would fit those misdemeanors. I thought it was totally inappropriate. Luckily, Andy
Lourie finally stepped in and told Lefkowitz that we would not agree to a misdemeanor
charge unrelated to the crimes that we had investigated.
Throughout the drafting of the NPA, every time Jay Lefkowitz and I reached an impasse,
he and/or Ken Starr would appeal to Andy Lourie, Jeff Sloman, or Alex Acosta, making it
impossible to hold a firm line or keep a singular negotiating strategy. I tried to work from
the Office's standard plea agreement language, but even after language was agreed to, it
would be rewritten by Mr. Acosta.

i. I strenuously objected to the reduction of the prison term from 24 months
to 18 months.
ii. I objected to the clear efforts at delay for no reason other than delay (for
example, going back and forth from a federal plea to a state plea and back
to a federal plea — all the while asking me to provide copious drafts).
iii. At various points, it was apparent that Epstein was not engaging in good
faith plea negotiations and I asked to terminate the negotiations and proceed
to indictment. Every time, Mr. Acosta refused. For example, near the end
of the negotiations, Mr. Lefkowitz tried to "slip in" a citation to a different
state crime that did not require sex offender registration. When I brought
this to Mr. Leflcowitz's attention, he admitted that, despite their explicit
agreement that Mr. Epstein would plead guilty to a crime that required sex
offender registration, they originally believed that the crimes listed in the
NPA did not require registration. When they realized their error — and the
Epstein would, indeed, have to register, they tried to replace the statute with
a different one. This was the clearest example of bad faith amongst many,
yet I was told that I had to continue working with Mr. Lefkowitz to finalize
the agreement. USA Acosta told me that he did not want to punish Epstein
for the bad behavior of his attorneys — even though Epstein clearly was
directing every aspect of his defense.
Page 54 of 58
J.

iv. I told FAUSA Sloman and USA Acosta that I did not want to sign the NPA
because I did not think that it was "my" agreement. USA Acosta asked me
to sign it.

h. After the NPA was signed, USA Acosta continued to concede points that had already been
decided. For example, he agreed to the preparation of the Addendum. He then made a
number of concessions regarding the letter to the Special Master, including a statement that
we would not vouch for the veracity of the victims, despite the fact that these were victims
that we intended to include in an indictment. These were all areas that were the subject of
a signed, binding agreement. On October 5, 2007, and October 23, 2007, I against asked
for permission to proceed to indictment (Exhibits C-6, C-7).

i. After the Addendum was signed, USA Acosta wrote in the 12/19/2007 letter to Lilly Ann
Sanchez that he had "considered defense counsel arguments regarding the Section 2255
portions of the Agreement. ... During the course of negotiations [our] intent was reduced
to writing in Paragraphs 7 and 8, which as I wrote previously, appear far from simple to
understand." (Exhibit B-19). I raised concerns about undermining an Agreement entered
into by our Office and giving away one of the protections that had been negotiated for the
victims — representation by an attorney selected by the Special Master.
I raised concerns about delays in entering Epstein's guilty plea and sentencing. These were
portrayed as "professional courtesies" but it quickly became obvious that the NPA was
signed with no intention of actual performance — it was simply a way for Epstein to buy
time to avoid indictment and intimidate victims.

k. I raised objections to the multiple "appeals" to DC and the delays that those entailed. USA
Acosta explained that "every defendant" has the right to appeal to DC and raise federalism
concerns. I explained that the objections should have been raised prior to signing the NPA,
not after, and, if they were legitimate "policy questions," Epstein should agree that he
would not use the time to harass and intimidate victims.

1. As detailed above, after the NPA was signed, the agents and I repeatedly raised concerns
about the Office's deference to the defense's objections to providing notification to the
victims of the resolution of the investigation and the date and time of the Epstein's plea
and sentencing.

m. On February 26, 2008, I learned that, if CEOS conducted its review and concluded the
federal prosecution of Epstein was appropriate, the Office was going to allow Epstein to
plead guilty pursuant to the NPA with no additional terms or conditions, despite the fact
that additional victims had been located during the ongoing investigation. I wrote to
FAUSA Sloman and expressed my view that this was an unjust result (Exhibit B-115). I
re-raised this objection every time the Office allowed Epstein another opportunity to
maintain the benefits of the NPA even as he was attacking the NPA's legitimacy.

n. On March 19, 2008, I informed the supervisory chain up to FAUSA Sloman of the toll that
the delay was taking on the victims and the grand jury. In particular, one of the grand
jurors had told another that he was concerned that we were going to "whitewash" the case
and not charge it. Epstein was using the delay to harass the victims, and one of the victims
tried to commit suicide. I wrote how the "FBI's victim-witness coordinator is doing her
Page 55 of 58
best to get counseling for all of our needy victims, but I just can't stress enough how
important it is for these girls to have a resolution in this case. The `please be patient'
answer is really wearing thin, especially when Epstein's group is still on the attack while
we are forced to wait on the sidelines. Your guidance is needed." (Exhibit C-2) I followed
up on March 19 and 22, 2008 to let everyone know that Epstein was subpoenaing victims
and was using particularly aggressive means of service — having the Sheriff's Office serve
the subpoenas at the places of work, calling them into the Dean's Office at their colleges,
etc. I explained that Epstein was issuing these subpoenas in the context of the state criminal
case — even though these victims were not named victims in the state criminal case, and I
asked FAUSA Sloman to try to have Epstein's attorneys stop this contact as it was
inconsistent with Epstein's alleged interest in resolving the matter (Exhibit C-3). I do not
believe that anyone contacted Epstein's attorneys about this. I worked to secure pro bono
counsel for as many victims as possible so that Epstein would only be able to contact them
through counsel (id.). My concerns about the victims' mental health were brought to the
attention of management in emails and telephone calls throughout the entire period from
2006 through 2008 and probably into 2009.

o. Even after Epstein enter his guilty plea and was sentenced, there were a number of material
breaches. Every time I tried to enforce the agreement and enforce the Office's authority to
proceed to indictment, the Office would accept Epstein's excuse that he received "bad
advice" from his attorneys and then he would "cure" the breach. With regard to the work
release, either Roy Black or Jay Lefkowitz informed me that USA Acosta had agreed, after
the NPA was signed, that Epstein would be allowed to participate in work release like any
other state prisoner — in direct contravention of discussions and communications that Karen
Atkinson and I had with the defense. I was not allowed to invoke this as a breach.

2. Identify any occasion during which you were or felt pressured, intimidated,
threatened, coerced, or in any other manner inappropriately influenced to
take a position or action in the Epstein case with which you disagreed or which
caused you concern, and the individuals, if any, with whom you discussed such
concerns.
Throughout this memo, I have listed a number of disagreements. In broad categories, I
disagreed with: (1) meeting with defense counsel before the investigation was completed and
disclosing to them our charging strategy; (2) members of the Executive Division engaging in plea
and strategy discussions outside the presence of the prosecution team and encouraging defense
counsel to avoid the prosecution team; (3) entering into pre-indictment plea negotiations; (4)
agreeing to delay the litigation regarding Epstein's computer equipment while pursuing plea
negotiations; (5) entering into an agreement deferring federal prosecution; (6) entering into any
agreement that required a sentence of only 18 months' (or even 24 months') imprisonment; (7)
agreeing to a length of a sentence and then trying to find a charge with a statutory max to match;
(8) reaching an agreement without conferring with the victims, the agents, or even the prosecution
team; (9) refusing to hear from/meet with the victims even after meeting repeatedly with Epstein's
representatives; (10) during the drafting of the NPA, allowing Epstein's attorneys to complain
directing to the First Assistant and U.S. Attorney when they were dissatisfied with answers from
the line AUSA and West Palm Beach supervisors; (11) repeatedly overruling my efforts to hold
Epstein to the original terms, including reducing the term of imprisonment from 24 months down
to 18; (12) dismissing my repeated warnings that the attorneys were not negotiating in good faith
Page 56 of 58
and were delaying for strategic reasons; (13) repeatedly ceding our discretion to the defense, for
example, agreeing that they could review and comment on victim notification letters and decide
whether or not we could provide notice; (14) even after the NPA was signed, continuing to water
it down, with the Addendum, the 12/19/07 Acosta letter, and then later offering Epstein the option
of not having to provide the attorney-representative for the victims; (15) refusing to allow the
agents and Ito notify the victims about the terms of the NPA and about the change of plea; (16)
allowing Epstein to continue to enjoy the benefits of the NPA even after he failed to promptly
perform its terms and filed specious delays in order to try to negotiate better terms or win a battle
of attrition; (17) refusing to defend me from the false allegations of prosecutorial misconduct; (18)
refusing to step in and protect the victims from harassment from Epstein's attorneys when Epstein
was "appealing" to DC; and (19) allowing Epstein to repeatedly breach the NPA and then claim
that he just got bad advice from his lawyers and "cure" the breaches.
At various times during the investigation, negotiations, etc., I spoke with a number of
people about my disagreements with the Office, including my supervisor, Karen Atkinson, my co-
counsel, John McMillan, Special Agents Kuyrkendall and Richards, AUSAs Lynn Kirkpatrick,
Susan Roe, E.J. Yera, and DOJ Trial Attorneys Tammie Gregg and Myesha Braden. On several
occasions, I drafted emails about re-assigning the case because the Office's handling of the matter
was so contrary to my methods. I shared at least one of these with Ms. Atkinson (Exhibit C-4).
She counseled against sending it. The agents asked me not to leave the case because they believed
that, if I left, the case would simply disappear. I couldn't disagree with them.
Criminal Chief Menchel's response to my email in July 2007 was, in my mind,
inappropriate and meant to intimidate. It is, quite frankly, unheard of, for a Criminal Chief to
engage in plea negotiations without the line AUSA's knowledge, much less blessing. And the
offer that was made was inexplicable. To this day, I do not understand the NPA — 24 months/18
months — it is a completely random amount of time. Allowing a federal defendant to plead guilty
to state charges also is completely unheard of. No one has ever explained to me where the idea
originated from. For Mr. Menchel to suggest that my judgment was questionable or that I was
unable to handle "major" cases was obviously meant to "put me in my place." In my July 13, 2007
response to Mr. Menchel, I wrote:
With respect to your questions regarding my judgment, I will simply say that
disagreements about strategy and raising concerns about the forgotten voices of the
victims in this case should not be classified as a lapse in judgment. This Office
should seek to foster spirited debate about the law and the use of prosecutorial
discretion. I know of other instances where disagreements about the application of
the law to different defendants and defense attorneys has resulted in a call for the
resignation of the AUSA who dared to challenge the Executive Office's
conclusions. I find that very disheartening. However, my first and only concern in
this case (and my other child exploitation cases) is the victims. If our personality
differences threaten their access to justice, then please put someone on the case
whom you trust more, and who will also protect their rights.
After my response to Mr. Menchel, I know that he spoke with Anne Ruth Schultz, who
was Chief of Appeals at the time, about moving me to the Appellate Section.
The results of the disagreements catalogued above were communicated to me (orally or via
e-mail) as decisions of the Executive Division. They sometimes followed extensive debate. They
Page 57 of 58
sometimes followed no debate. I was sometimes heard on the issue; other times I knew nothing
about it until I received the directive. There were times that I learned of communications between
defense counsel and the Executive Division where concessions were made only after the decision
was made. Many of these decisions were incorrect, in my opinion, but I did not believe that they
were illegal. As a line AUSA, I was duty bound to follow the directives of the U.S. Attorney,
which I did. I do not know that following a direct order from the Executive Division would qualify
as coercion — even if it follows very strong objections.
I felt strongly that we should have conferred with the victims before entering into the NPA
and that we should have informed them of the change of plea and sentencing. I felt strongly that
Epstein's attorneys were given unprecedented access to members of the Executive Division, and
that the victims were given no access -- I could not even talk with them about plea negotiations or
notify them about the plea hearing. At one point, my assistant and I had letters and envelopes
ready to be stuffed and put through the franking machine and we received notice from Miami that
they could not go out. While I felt that conferring was the right thing to do, as noted above, the
AG Guidelines vest discretion in the U.S. Attorney, so I could not say that USA Acosta's decision
was illegal. I also believed that, because the resolution of the federal case rested on Epstein's state
guilty plea, the federal victims were entitled to notice of the state hearing. But I could not say that
USA Acosta's decision that the CVRA was limited to notice of federal proceedings was illegal.
I think that pressure was brought in more subtle ways. For example, I believe that one of
the reasons why USA Acosta did not take an aggressive stance against the prosecutorial
misconduct claims against me was because he disliked my insistence on pushing the case forward.
After the NPA was signed, USA Acosta recommended that I transfer to the Civil Division.
I agreed to meet with them and talk about their work. Despite USA Acosta's recommendation, I
decided not to follow his recommendation, and I stayed in the criminal division.
Please advise if further information is needed.
Sincerely,
dal Marta rilliskrages.

A. Marie Villafaila
Page 58 of 58
BAKER,DONELSON 100 116111 STREET • BALTIMORE, MARYLAND 21202 • 410.685.1120. bakerdonelson.com
JONATHAN BRAN
Direct Dial: 410.862.1073
E-Mail AddresallkitAN@bakerdonelson.com
May 10, 2019
VIA EMAIL °N4"
Laura Ingersoll
Counsel, Office of Professional Responsibility
U.S. Department of Justice
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, N.W. — Room 3266
Washington, D.C. 20530
Re: OPR Investigation Relating to Jeffrey Epstein Federal Criminal Investigation
Dear Ms. Ingersoll:
Attached please find the written response of Assistant United States Attorney A. Marie
Villafafia to the letter of Jeffrey R. Ragsdale, dated April 2, 2019, regarding the criminal
investigation of Jeffrey Epstein. AUSA Villafafia separately has sent you encrypted disks
containing the exhibits referenced in her written response, and has emailed other exhibits that
were not included on the disks.

Mr. Ragsdale's letter also requested background information concerning AUSA
Villafafia's professional background and experience. The remainder of this letter provides that
information.
A native of Minnesota, A. Marie Villafafia graduated from Cornell University and the
University of California, Berkeley, School of Law. She was admitted to the California Bar in
1995, to the Minnesota Bar in 1997, and to the Florida Bar in 2005. She is currently an active
member of the Florida Bar, and maintains inactive status in California and Minnesota.
Ms. Villafafia began her legal career as a judicial law clerk to the Honorable David F.
Levi, United States District Judge for the Eastern District of California, from 1993 to 1994. Ms.
Villafafia then worked in private practice for seven years, including as a litigation associate at
Morrison & Foerster in San Francisco and a trial associate with Dorsey & Whitney, LLP, in
Minneapolis, Minnesota, and London, England. Ms. Villafafia remained in civil practice,
specializing in intellectual property litigation until 2001, when she was hired by the United
States Attorney's Office in Miami.
While she enjoyed civil practice, Ms. Villafafia for many years had wanted to be an
Assistant United States Attorney. Two early career mentors — Judge Levi and Portia Moore from
Morrison & Foerster — had worked at U.S. Attorney's Offices and they, like many former
4822.5464-M66vI
2865555.000127 05/102019
ALABAMAFLORIDAGEORGiALOUISIANAMARYLAND • M1SS!SSIPPI• SOUTH CAROLINATENNESSEETEXASVIRGINIAWASHINGTON, D.C.
Laura Ingersoll
May 10, 2019
Page 2 of 7
AUSAs, described the job as the best of their careers. Ms. Villafafia also wanted to serve her
community. She was in the first generation of her family to graduate from college. She is the
only member of her family to get an advanced degree. Personal experiences left her deeply
committed to wanting to create safer communities for victims of crime. After several years of
waiting for an opening at the USAO in Minneapolis, when Ms. Villafafia's brother moved to the
West Palm Beach area, she applied for a position at the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern
District of Florida.
On September 10, 2001, Ms. Villafafia began serving as an Assistant United States
Attorney in the Southern District of Florida. She did a rotation through the Appellate Section
and then joined the Major Crimes Section from late September 2001 until January 2004. While
in that unit, she handled reactive cases and short-term investigations and cases, including
narcotics, firearms, child exploitation offenses, immigration matters, credit card fraud, bank
robbery, violent offenses, and supervised release violations. While serving in that unit, she was
also selected as one of the Southern District of Florida's first Project Safe Neighborhood
prosecutors.
In January 2004, AUSA Villafafia transferred to the West Palm Beach Office. In 2006,
the U.S. Department of Justice initiated Project Safe Childhood, and, in recognition of her
expertise in child exploitation matters, AUSA Villafalia became the Southern District of
Florida's first Project Safe Childhood coordinator. From 2004 through early 2009, AUSA
Villafaha handled the bulk of the child exploitation cases in West Palm Beach, as well as other
cases involving violent crime, gangs, narcotics, firearms, immigration, and white collar matters.
In March 2009, AUSA Villafafia was selected as the first Chief of the Special
Prosecutions North Section, which was a new section in the Fort Lauderdale Office that would
work on Project Safe Childhood and Project Safe Neighborhood prosecutions. In late 2010,
when a new U.S. Attorney was sworn in, AUSA Villafafia asked that she be transferred back to
the West Palm Beach Office, because the daily commute to Fort Lauderdale was both taxing and
time consuming and it was exacerbating a then undiscovered medical condition from which she
was suffering.
Since 2010, AUSA Villafafia has been assigned to the West Palm Beach Office and is
now the liaison to the Greater Palm Beach County Health Care Fraud Task Force. Since
returning to West Palm Beach, AUSA Villafafia's caseload has shifted more towards economic
crimes, but she has worked on a wide array of cases including insurance fraud, varying types of
health care fraud, human trafficking, drug diversion, and bank fraud.
According to CourtLink, AUSA Villafafia was counsel of record in 445 criminal matters
in the Southern District of Florida. This number does not include all of the 2255 petition and
appeals AUSA Villafafia has handled, but does include search warrants and pen registers that she
sought. Of these approximately 445 cases, a number of matters are noteworthy:
4822.5464.6166x1
2865555.000127 05/10,2019
Laura Ingersoll
May 10, 2019
Page 3 of 7
As the Southern District of Florida's first Project Safe Childhood Coordinator, she
personally handled dozens of child exploitation cases.
It appears from a review of Westlaw and Courtlink research, that AUSA Villafafia was
the first prosecutor in the Southern District of Florida to convince the court to recognize the
rights of a victim's family to appear and speak to the Court about the proper sentence:

• U.S.'. William Charles O'Neil, 04-Cr-80040
The victim's mother remains in touch with AUSA Villafafia to this day.
From Westlaw and Courtlink research, it appears that AUSA Villafafia was the first
prosecutor in the Southern District of Florida to advocate for the appointment of a guardian ad
litem for minor victims in connection with a criminal prosecution.
• U.S.'. Jimmy Oliver, 06-Cr-80023
• U.S.'. Marion Yarbrough, 07-Cr-80099
From Westlaw and Courtlink research, it appears that AUSA Villafafia was the first
prosecutor in the Southern District of Florida to charge enticement of a minor based upon use of
a cellular phone.
U.S.'. McDaniel, 06-Cr-80058
From Westlaw and Courtlink research, it appears that AUSA Villafafia was the first
prosecutor in the Southern District of Florida to charge a violation of the child pornography
advertising statute.
U.S.'. Frank Grasso, 05-Cr-80111
From Westlaw and Courtlink research, it appears that AUSA Villafafia was the first
prosecutor in the Southern District of Florida to charge failure to register as a sex offender.
AUSA Villafafia trained other prosecutors and agents on how to investigate and prosecute those
cases.
U.S.'. Alfonso Diaz Cardenas, 07-Cr-80108
AUSA Villafafia assisted in the drafting of Eleventh Circuit Pattern [Criminal] Jury
Instructions related to child exploitation offenses, including clarifying that, in cases of actual
contact with a child, there is no requirement of proving the defendant's knowledge of age.
4822-54644166v1
2865555-000127 05/10/2019
Laura Ingersoll
May 10, 2019
Page 4 of 7
According to inquiries with DOJ's Health Care Fraud Section, Ms. Villafaila was the first
prosecutor in the nation to charge sex trafficking in connection with a health care fraud case.
U.S.'.0  Kenneth Chatman, 17-Cr-80013 (subject of an American Greed episode,
CNBC, Season 12, Episode 10 "Florida Rehab Gone " July 2, 2018)
Chatman was the first of several cases to target fraud in connection with substance abuse
treatment. To date, AUSA Villafafia has convicted 30 individuals, including six licensed
medical or mental health professionals, for related offenses:
II U.S. . Kenneth Chatman, et al., 17-Cr-80013
O U.S. . Barry Gregory, 17-Cr-80033
I
fl U.S. . Richard Botero, et al., 17-Cr-80070
O U.S. . Tovah Lynn Jasperson, et al., 17-Cr-80194
U U.S.'. Jeffrey Williams, 17-Cr-80195
U U.S. . Albert Jones Saye, l7-Cr-80229
O U.S. . John Skeffington, et al., 18-Cr-80018
O U.S. . Anthony Jackson, 18-Cr-80040
U U.S. . Lanny Fried, 18-Cr-80100
O U.S.'. 13osco Vega, 18-Cr-80101
fl U.S.'. Mark Hollander, 18-Cr-80102
O U.S.'. Larry Weisberg, 18-Cr-80108
U U.S. I. Kenneth MI -Kolb, 18-Cr-80121 I
O U.S. . Arman Abovyan, et al., 18-Cr-80122
fl U.S.'. Hamilton Wayne, et al., 18-Cr-80165
O U.S.'. Ethan Wayne, 18-Cr-80168
The Chatman case resulted in AUSA Villafafia being awarded the 2018 Council of the
Inspectors General on Integrity and Efficiency Award and the 2017 National Healthcare Anti-
Fraud Association Investigation of the Year Award. This series of investigations has been
nominated for this year's FBI Director's Award and the Florida Insurance Fraud Education
Committee's Award.
At the request of DOJ's Office of Legislative Affairs, AUSA Villafafia has provided
advice on Congress' recent legislation on fraud involving sober homes and treatment facilities.
4822-5464-6166%1
2865555-000127 05/10/2019
Laura Ingersoll
May 10, 2019
Page 5 of 7
AUSA Villafafia's prosecution of a member of Guatemala's Kaibil military branch led to
war crimes investigations and prosecutions of numerous high-ranking military and political
figures in Guatemalan and international courts, and resulted in her receipt of the Justice
Department's 2011 National Crime Victims' Rights Service Award. The case was the subject of
an award-wining documentary entitled "Finding Oscar" and numerous television shows and
podcasts.
U.S.'. Gilberto Jordan, 10-Cr-80069
AUSA Villafafia prosecuted the leader and numerous members of the Krazy Locos street
gang in Palm Beach County (an MS-13 affiliate) for two murders in connection with
racketeering activity and numerous firearms, drug, and sex trafficking offenses.
U.S.'. Jonathan a, et al., 09-Cr-80091
U.S.'. Ivan Santiago, 09-Cr-80135
U.S.'. Itzel Candela-Campos, 10-Cr-80042
AUSA Villafafia prosecuted 57 individuals, including 21 medical professionals, for
charges related to staged accidents and chiropractic clinic fraud. According to information
received from victim insurance companies, the prosecutions resulted in a 50% decrease in
fraudulent auto insurance claims in Palm Beach County as well as changes to state legislation.
AUSA Villafafia received the Attorney General's Award for Fraud Prevention and the [EOUSA]
Director's Award for this series of cases. She also received Prosecutor of the Year awards from
the Coalition Against Insurance Fraud and the Florida Insurance Fraud Education Committee for
her work in these cases.

• U.S.'. Vladimir Lopez, et al., 11-Cr-80106
• U.S.'. Ketty a, et al., 11-Cr-80211
• U.S.'. Obelio Rodriguez, et al., 12-Cr-80107

• U.S.'. Yuliet Tapanes, et al., 12-Cr-80108
• U.S.'. M Adams, 12-Cr-80112
• U.S.'. Iris Roca, 13-Cr-80109

• U.S.'. Olinda Rodriguez, 13-Cr-80110
AUSA Villafafia successfully handled the appeal in the matter of U.S.'. Damian Baston
(14-14444 (11th Circuit)), arguing for full restitution for victims of sex trafficking and for the
right of the United States to prosecute sex trafficking that occurred outside the United States but
originated in the United States.
4822-5464.6166v1
2865555-000127 05/10/2019
Laura Ingersoll
May 10, 2019
Page 6 of 7
From Westlaw and Courtlink research, it appears that AUSA Villafaha was the first
prosecutor in the Southern District of Florida to charge violations of the federal money
transmitting statute.

• U.S. 1 Nolaco-Argueta, 02-Cr-20465
Significant Sentences:
130 years' imprisonment for Jimmy Oliver, who had molested numerous female
family members over several decades. (06-Cr-80023)

• Life plus 135 years for Jonathan , head of the Krazy Locos gang, for
ordering two murders and an attempted murder in aid of racketeering and other
offenses (09-Cr-80091)
Life imprisonment plus 35 years for Manuel Medina for murder in aid of
racketeering and other offenses (09-Cr-80091)
40 years' imprisonment for Marion Yarbrough, who had enticed a Florida girl to
board a bus to Kentucky where he repeatedly abused her sexually (07-Cr-80099)
40 years' imprisonment for Mark Joseph Harvey, who was found in possession of
over 1 million images of child pornography, organized in files by age and subject
matter, and who had previously sexually abused family members (09-Cr-80023)

• 30 years' imprisonment for Ivan Isidro Santiago, co-head of the Krazy Locos
gang, for his role in two murders and an attempted murder in aid of racketeering
and other offenses (09-Cr-80091 and 09-Cr-80135)
27.5 years for Kenneth Chatman, who had forced female patients of his substance
abuse treatment program into prostitution (17-Cr-80013)

• 25 years for Frank Grasso, who used social media to advertise for child
pornography (05-Cr-80111)
• 20 years for Jonathan Earl Clark on charges of enticement of a minor and child
pornography (08-Cr-80067)

• 20 years for Eric Runyan on charges of distribution of obscenity to a minor and
enticement (12-Cr-80115)

• 19 years for Alejandro Tomas for aiding and abetting murder in aid of
racketeering (09-Cr-80091)
• 15 years for Christopher -Chamberlain on a charge of aggravated assault
in connection with the Krazy ocos case (09-Cr-80091)

• 14 years for Lucas Phelps on charges of enticement of a minor and transmission
of obscene material to a child. Phelps had previously been adjudicated delinquent
on three counts of sexual battery. (05-Cr-80020)
4822-54644166A
2865555-000127 O5/102019
Laura Ingersoll
May 10, 2019
Page 7 of 7

• 12 years for John Walsh on charges of distribution of child pornography (05-Cr-
80185)
• 11 years for Silverio Macedonio-Gregorio for aiding and abetting murder in aid of
racketeering and other offenses (09-Cr-80091)

• 10 years for Thomas Bohannon on charges of enticement of a minor (05-Cr-
80023)
• 10 years for Gilberto Jordan on charges of false statements on immigration
application for failing to disclose his involvement in war crimes in Guatemala
(10-Cr-80069)
• 8 years for Christopher Prindle for possession of child pornography (04-Cr-
80156)
If you have any questions about any of the above information and the information
included AUSA Villafafia's attached letter, please contact me at your convenience.
Very truly yours,
BAKER, DONELSON, BEARMAN,
CALDWELL & BERKOWITZ, PC
/s/
Jonathan Biran
JB/smr
Enclosures/Attachment
cc: AUSA A. Marie Villafafia
4822.5464-0166x1
2865555-000127 05/10/2019
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (56!) 820-8777
July 10, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
THEODORE J. LEOPOLD, ESQ.
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
Jutx 10, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 2
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider thatit is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
St ough this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that your client,
is an individual whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim o. an
enumerated offense.
Should your client decide to file a claim against Jeffrey Epstein, his attorney, Jack
Goldberger, asks that you contact him at Atterbury Goldberger and Weiss, 250 Australian
Avenue South, Suite 1400, West Palm Beach, FL 33401.
Please understand that neither the U.S. Attorney's Office nor the Federal Bureau of
Investigation can take part in or otherwise assist in civil litigation; however, if you do file a
claim under 18 U.S.C. § 2255 and Mr. Epstein denies that your client is a victim of an
enumerated offense, please provide written documentation of that denial to the undersigned.
Please thank your client for all of her assistance during the course of this investigation
and express the heartfelt regards of m self and Special Agents Kuyrkendall and Richards for
the health and well-being of Ms.
R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By:
cc: Jack Goldberger, Esq.
...••••••••
. MARIE VELLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561)8204711
Facsimile: (56!) 8204777
July 10, 2008
VIA FACSIMILE AND U.S. MAIL
Theodore J. Leopold, Esq.
Ricci—Leopold, P.A.
2925 PGA Boulevard, Suite 200
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Re: Jeffrey Epstein/Saige Gonzalez: NOTIFICATION OF
IDENTIFIED VICTIM.
Dear Mr. Leopold:
• By virtue of this letter, the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of Florida asks that you provide the following notice to your client,
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach CoUnty (Case Nos. 2006-d-009454/OOOOAB and 2008-cf-
009381AXXXMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by an additional six months' imprisonment, followed by twelve months of
Community Control 1, with conditions of community confinement imposed by the Court.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
U.S. Department of Justice FILE COPY i
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
.14.•411 Mr.
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 10, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
JEFFREY HERMAN, ESQ.
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM ANGELIQUE GARCIA (NEE CAVALLARO)
JULY 10, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 2
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that your client,
), is an individual whom the United States was prepared to name as a
victim of an enumerated offense.
Should your client decide to file a claim against Jeffrey Epstein, his attorney, Jack
Goldberger, asks that you contact him at Atterbury Goldberger and Weiss, 250 Australian
Avenue South, Suite 1400, West Palm Beach, FL 33401.
Please understand that neither the U.S. Attorney's Office nor the Federal Bureau of
Investigation can take part in or otherwise assist in civil litigation; however, if you do file a
claim under 18 U.S.C. § 2255 and Mr. Epstein denies that your client is a victim of an
enumerated offense, please provide written documentation of that denial to the undersigned.
Please thank your client for all of her assistance during the course of this investigation
and express the heartfelt regards of myself and Special Agents Kuyrkendall and Richards for
the health and well-being of Ms. Garcia.
R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By: C/ "Z.
A. MARIE VILLAFANA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
cc: Jack Goldberger, Esq.
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave.. Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561)820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 10, 2008
VIA FACSIMILE AND U.S. MAIL
Jeffrey Herman, Esq.
Herman & Mermelstein, P.A.
18205 Biscayne Boulevard
Suite 2218
Miami, Florida 33160
Re: Jeffrey Epstein/Angelique Garcia (née Cavatiara):
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
Dear Mr. Herman:
By virtue of this letter, the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of Florida asks that you provide the following notice to your client, Garcia.
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454AXXXMB and 2008-cf-
009381AXX3CMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by an additional six months' imprisonment, followed by twelve months of
Community Control 1, with conditions of community confinement imposed by the Court.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Bohn Beach, FL 33401
(561)820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 10, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
RICHARD WILLITS, ESQ.
NCYFIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM ANDRIANO
JULY 10, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 2
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that your client,
is an individual whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim of an
enumerated offense.
Should your client decide to file a claim against Jeffrey Epstein, his attorney, Jack
Goldberger, asks that you contact him at Atterbury Goldberger and Weiss, 250 Australian
Avenue South, Suite 1400, West Palm Beach, FL 33401.
Please understand that neither the U.S. Attorney's Office nor the Federal Bureau of
Investigation can take part in or otherwise assist in civil litigation; however, if you do file a
claim under 18 U.S.C. § 2255 and Mr. Epstein denies that your client is a victim of an
enumerated offense, please provide written documentation of that denial to the undersigned.
Please thank your client for all of her assistance during the course of this investigation
and express the heartfelt regards of m self and Special Agents Kuyrkendall and Richards for
the health and well-being of Ms.
R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By:
A. MARIE V1LLAFAN- A
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
cc: Jack Goldberger, Esq.
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney'
Southern District of Florida
.500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561)820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 10, 2008
VIA FACSIMILE AND U.S. MAIL
Richard H. Willits, P.A.
2290 10th Avenue North, Suite 404
Lake Worth, FL 33461
Re: Jeffrey Epstein/Carolyn  NOTIFICATION OF
IDENTIFIED VICTIM
Dear Mr. Willits:
By virtue of this letter, the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of Florida asks that you provide the following notice to your client,
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454/OOaMB and 2008-cf-
009381AXXXMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by an additional six months' imprisonment, followed by twelve months of
Community Control 1, with conditions of community confinement imposed by the Court.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
•
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
Jply.10, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
EXHIBIT B-67
BRAD EDWARD$, ESQ.
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
JULY 9, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 2
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less." •
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that your client,
is an individual whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim of an enumerated
offense.
Should your client decide to file a claim against Jeffrey Epstein, his attorney, Jack
Goldberger, asks that you contact him at Atterbury Goldberger and Weiss, 250 Australian
Avenue South, Suite 1400, West Palm Beach, FL 33401, (561) 659-8300.
Please understand that neither the U.S. Attorney's Office nor the Federal Bureau of
Investigation can take part in or otherwise assist in civil litigation; however, if you do file a
claim under 18 U.S.C. § 2255 and Mr. Epstein denies that your client is a victim of an
enumerated offense, please provide notice of that denial to the undersigned.
Please thank your client for all of her assistance during the course of this examination
and express the heartfelt regards ofAlself and Special Agents Kuyrkendall and Richards for
the health and well-being of Ms. M.

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By:
A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
cc: Jack Goldberger, Esq.
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401

(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 9, 2008 .
VIA FACSIMILE
Brad Edwards, Esq.
The Law Offices of Brad Edwards & Associates, LLC
2028 Harrison Street, Suite 202
Hollywood, Florida 33020.
Re: Jeffrey Epstein/Courtney NOTIFICATION OF
IDENTIFIED VICTIM
Dear Mr. Edwards:
By virtue of this letter, the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of Florida asks that you provide the following notice to your client,
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454A=MB and 2008-cf-
009381AXXXMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by an additional six months' imprisonment, followed by twelve months of
Community Control 1, with conditions of community confinement imposed by the Court.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
U.S. Department of Justice FILE COPY
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 9, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
BRAD EDWARDS, ESQ.
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM a RIVERA
JULY 9, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 2
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that your client,
M , is an individual whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim of an
enumerated offense.
Should your client decide to file a claim against Jeffrey Epstein, his attorney, Jack
Goldberger, asks that you contact him at Atterbury Goldberger and Weiss, 250 Australian
Avenue South, Suite 1400, West Palm Beach, FL 33401, (561) 659-8300.
Please understand that neither the U.S. Attorney's Office nor the Federal Bureau of
Investigation can take part in or otherwise assist in civil litigation; however, if you do file a
claim under 18 U.S.C. § 2255 and Mr. Epstein denies that your client is a victim of an
enumerated offense, please provide notice of that denial to the undersigned.
Please thank your client for all of her assistance during the course of this examination
and express the heartfelt regards of m self and Special Agents Kuyrkendall and Richards for
the health and well-being of Ms.

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By:
cc: Jack Goldberger, Esq.
A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561)820-8711
Facsimile: (561)820-8777
July 9, 2008
VIA FACSIMILE
Brad Edwards, Esq.
The Law Offices of Brad Edwards & Associates, LLC
2028 Harrison Street, Suite 202
Hollywood, Florida 33020.
Re: Jeffrey EpsteinMIM NOTIFICATION OF
IDENTIFIED VICTIM
Dear Mr. Edwards:
By virtue of this letter, the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of Florida asks that you provide the following notice to your client,
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation ofprostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-ef-009454AXXXMB and 2008-cf-
00938 1 AXXXMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by an additional six months' imprisonment, followed by twelve months of
Community Control 1, with conditions of community confinement imposed by the Court.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to whichEpstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 9, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
EXHIBIT B-66
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Thursday, July 10, 2008 5;15 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Mane C. (USAFLS); Acosta. Alex (USAFLS): Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Cc: Kuyrkendall, E N. (FBI); Richards, Jason R. (FBI)
Subject: Re: Proposed response to Goldberger's letter
Fine
Original Message
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS); Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Cc: Kuyrkendall, E N. (FBI); Richards, Jason R. (FBI)
Sent: Thu Jul 10 17:12:26 2008
Subject: Proposed response to Goldberger's letter
Please let me know if this is alright to fax out today. I can see no reason for
us to disclose any of the additional information that they have requested.
The message is ready to be sent with the following file or link attachments:
080710 Response to Goldberger ltr re notification.wpd
Note: To protect against computer viruses, e-mail programs may prevent sending or
receiving certain types of file attachments. Check your e-mail security settings
to determine how attachments are handled.
EXHIBIT 8-65 543
indicated in your letter of December 13, 2007)?
Fifth, please recall that Mr. Sloman wrote to Judge on October 25, 2007 that "The
United States takes no position as to the validity of any such claim under this statute." To
avoid any appearance that the United States is endorsing or encouraging litigation by the
identified individuals, we believe that such a statement should be included in any
notification letter.
I look fonyard to receiving your input on these issues. Until then, I remain,
JackA. Goldberger
JAG/na
cc: Jeffrey E. Epstein
• JOSEPH R.ATFERBURY
t JACK A. GOLDBERGER
JASON S.WEISS
' Board Certified Criminal TrialAttomey
Member of New Jersey & Florida Bars
July 10, 2008

A. Marie C. Villafana, Esq.
Assistant United States Attorney
500 S. Australian Avenue
4th Floor, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
SENT VIA E-MAIL 8 FACSIMILE
(561) 820-8777
Re: Jeffrey E. Epstein
Dear Ms. Villafana:
Thank you for your letter of yesterday. Kindly allow me a few follow-up points.
First, we respectfully request a reasonable opportunity to review and comment on a draft
of the modified notification letter you intend to mail before you send it.
Second, we respectfully ask that you provide us with the identity of the victims' rights
organization described in your letter; the name and contact information of the person at
that organization with whom the Government has been communicating; copies of any
communications with that organization and the pro-bono lawyers/groups who were
recommended by that organization; and a description of any non-written communications
that the Government has had with that organization and the pro-bono lawyers/groups.
Third, while we appreciate your offer to disclose the names of the lawyers currently
representing the individuals when you have finished compiling all of that information, we
would be very grateful if you would provide any contact information you do have, on a
rolling basis.
Fourth, would it be possible for you to advise us of the full name of the minor to whom you
have referred by initials, as well as the identities of the three individuals whom the
Government notified about the deferred-prosecution agreement shortly after its signing (as
EXHIBIT B-64
One Cleartake Centre, Suite 1400 250 Australian Avenue South West Palm Beach. FL 33401
p 561.659.8300 f 561.835.8691 www.agwpa.com
JACK GOLDBERGER, ESQ.
JULY 10, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 2
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that the individuals identified
below are individuals whom the United States was prepared to name as victims of an
enumerated offense.
Identified Individuals
Fayth Pentek
By:
cc: Karen Atkinson, AUSA
Sincerely, (
•

R. Alexander Acosta
United States Attorney
A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant United States Attorney
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 3340!

(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 10, 2008
VIA CERTIFIED MAIL
. Jack A. Goldberger, Esq.
Atterbury, Goldberger & Weiss, P.A.
One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400
250 Australian Ave S.
West Palm Beach, FL 33401-5015
Re: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Mr. Goldberger:
FINAL NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454AXXXMB and 2008-cf-
00938 I AXXXMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by an additional six months' imprisonment, followed by twelve months of
Community Control I, with conditions of community confineinent imposed by the Court.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida FILE COPY
SOO South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach. FL 3340!

(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 10, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
EXHIBIT B-63
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida

A. Marie VIHafalia
500 S. Australian Ave, 4th Floor
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
(561) 8204711
Facsimile (561) 8204777
FACSIMILE COVER SHEET
TO: Jack Alan Goldberger
DATE: July 10. 2008
FAX NO. 561-835-8691 # OF PAGES:  2
PHONE NO.  561 659-8300  RE: Jeffrey Epstein
FROM: A. MARIE VILLAFARA, Assistant U.S. Attorney
PHONE NO.  561 209-1047
COMMENTS:
r.
* * * TRANSMISSION RESULT REPORT ( JUL.10:200B 5:26PM ) * * *
• . TTI USAO WPB FL
DATE TIKE ADDRESS MODE TIME PAGE RESULT PERS. NAME FILE __________----___
JUL.10. 5:26PM 5618358691 TES 0'24" P. 2 OK 434
: BATCH L : SEND LATER S : STANDARD A-: ASYNC MODE
C CONFIDENTIAL
e : FORWARDING
D : DETAIL 1 -: MIL_STD MODE
P : POLLING M : MEMORY
E ECM > : REDUCTION F FINE
G RICOH -MG3/COMPATIBLE MODE
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561)820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 10, 2008
VIA FACSIMILE
Jack A. Goldberger, Esq.
Atterbury, Goldberger & Weiss, P.A.
One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400
250 Australian Ave S.
West Palm Beach, FL 33401-5015
Re: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Mr. Goldberger:
In response to your letter of today's date, copies of the victim notifications are being
mailed to you on a rolling basis. For those victims who have counsel, the attorneys' contact
information will be included. As you will see, the letter makes clear that neither the U.S.
Attorney's Office nor the Federal Bureau of Investigation can take part in or otherwise assist
in civil litigation. The Office feels that is a sufficient statement of its position and we will
not include the language that you have requested.
Also, a final list of victims has been sent to you today via Certified Mail. That list is
identical to the draft provided to you on June 30th, except that it also includes the full name
of the minor victim.
By:
cc: Karen Atkinson, AUSA
Sincerely,

R. Alexander Acosta
United States Attorney,
A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant United States Attorney
EXHIBIT B-62

(c) You eliminate from any notification any language that is currently contained in
the "acknowledgment" section of the June 30, 2008 memorandum; and
(d) You supplement the notification with the Government's previously made
representation that it is not vouching for the =un ity of any claim by any identified
individual. See Letter from J. Sloman to E. (10/25/07).
Second, please note also that we do not understand your request that Mr. Epstein and his attorneys
execute the rider / acknowledgment contained within your June 30 hand-delivered draft.
Specifically, we do not believe that the Non-Prosecution Agreement requires Mr. Epstein's execution
of any such additional stipulation. Because we want to ensure that Mr. Epstein continues to strictly
comply with the letter of the parties' agreement, we respectfully ask that you explain why you
believe that the Non-Prosecution Agreement requires execution of your stipulation.
Our understanding of the Non-Prosecution Agreement is that it does not require Mr. Epstein to
"acknowledge" anything not already contained within the four corners of the written agreement. The
agreement certainly contains no written term obligating that he "waive any evidentiary challenge to
the introduction of a copy" of any "Notification of Identified Victims" in "any judicial proceeding
between any identified individual" and Mr. Epstein, as your memorandum currently requests.
Further, please note that your June 30 stipulation, as drafted, is not limited to Section 2255
proceedings. Rather, your June 30 draft requires Mr. Epstein to waive evidentiary challenges in "any
judicial proceeding" - - which clearly exceeds the bounds of the parties' written agreement.
Third, I would respectfully request that you provide me with the names of the "pro bono lawyers"
who, you indicated to me at our June 30 meeting at my office, were intending to represent certain
persons identified on your June 30 draft notification, as well as any knowledge that the Government
has as to how they were selected, and what communications the Government has had with them to
date.
Finally, please know that it is Mr. Epstein's firm intent to fulfill strictly each term and condition of
his Non-Prosecution Agreement with the Government. Nothing in this letter should be construed,
however, as waiving any defense that may be available to Mr. Epstein under the parties' written
agreement.
I look forward to your response. Until then, I remain,
V trul yours,
a A. Goldberger
cc: Jeffrey Epstein
ty.st
July 9, 2008

A. Marie C. Villafana, Esq.
Assistant United States Attorney
United States Attorney's Office
500 South Australian Avenue
41" Floor, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
SENT PIA E-MAIL & FACSIMILE

(561) 820-8777
Re: Jeffrey E. Epstein
Dear Ms. Villafana:
Writgrc*: 4 14 s itA.,V4
tA:41:e.

• JOSEPH R.ATTERBURY
•t JACK A.GOLDBERGER
JASON S.WE1SS
•Board Certified CriminalTrial Attorney
t Member of New Jersey & Horlda Ben
Thank you for your letter to me dated July 8, 2008 and the draft document dated, e-mailed and faxed
to me at my office on June 30, 2008, styled "Notification of Identified Victims." I would like to
address a few related issues.
First, please note that we have several requests concerning any such notification. Specifically, we
request that:

(a) Any notification be sent to any individual by mail (or served upon their attorney,
to the extent known), and we respectfully object to any service by hand, a method of
service which carries the concomitant risk of conversations regarding the notification
that potentially would place the federal authorities in a position of being advocates
for civil litigation;

(b) Any notification be effectuated by a separate mailing to each individual without
the inclusion of any language that appeared on the second page of your June 30, 2008
memorandum; i.e. rather than including in each notification a large section listing
"identified individuals" with redactions other than the name of the recipient (which
we contend would be a clear and impermissible signal to any individual that the
notification is a broad notification to numerous other alleged victims). Rather, a
simple one page notification directed only to the recipient, and limited to the
information currently on the first page of your draft memorandum would suffice.
One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400 250 Australian Avenue South West Palm Beach, FL 33401
p 561.659.8300 f 561.835.8691 www.agwpa.com EXHIBIT B-6I

P. 1
* * * TRANSMISSION RESULT REPORT ( JUL. 9.2008 4:05PM ) * * *
TTI USA° WPB FL
DATE TIME ADDRESS MODE TIME PAGE RESULT PERS. NAME FILE
JUL. 9. 4:04PM
• : BATCH L : SEND LATER S : STANDARD
A-: ASYNC MODE
5618358691 TES 0'36" P. 3 OK 412
C : CONFIDENTIAL @ : FORWARDING D DETAIL
1-: MIL_STD MODE
P : POLLING
E : ECM F : FINE
G-: RICOH-MG3/COMPATIBLE MODE
M : MEMORY
> : REDUCTION
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
A. Marie Villafalia
500 S. Australian Ave, 4th Floor
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
(561) 820-8711
TO:
Facsimile (561) 820-8777
FACSIMILE COVER SHEET
Jack Alan Goldberger
DATE: July 9, 2008
3 FAX NO. 561-835-8691 # OF PAGES:
PHONE NO. 561 659-8300 RE: Jeffrey Epstein
FROM: A. MARIE VILLAFARA, Assistant U.S. Attorney
PHONE NO. 561 209-1047
COMMENTS:
JACK GOLDBERGER, ESQ.
JULY 9, 2008
PAGE 2
was prepared to include in an indictment. This means that, pursuant to Justice Department
policy, these are individuals for whom the United States believes it has proof beyond a
reasonable doubt that each of them was a victim of an enumerated offense. There will be no
statement one way or the other regarding the validity of any claim.
You have asked for an explanation of why I believe the Acknowledgment portion is
required by the terms of the Agreement. Under a strict reading of the Agreement, it is not
required, other than to Acknowledge that the United States has performed its obligation of
providing Mr. Epstein with a list of identified victims following his guilty plea and
sentencing. The purpose of the Acknowledgment was to create one single document
incorporating the parties' agreement on'the single topic of the right to proceed under 18
U.S.C. § 2255. This would avoid litigation regarding the victims' rights to have access to
the original Non-Prosecution Agreement. Without such an express Acknowledgment by Mr.
Epstein that the Notice contains the substance of that Agreement, I believe that the victims
will have a justification to petition for the entire agreement, which is contrary to the
confidentiality clause that the parties have signed. If you believe that particular words are
objectionable, I am happy to consider a modification.
As I mentioned to you last week, I will provide you with the names of the attorneys
currently representing the victims when we have compiled all of that information. Some of
the victims are represented by attorneys from the South Carolina Victim Assistance Network
and the Maryland Crime Victims Resource Center, both of which were recommended by a
victims' rights organization that receives grants from the Justice Department.
If you have any suggestions for a modification of the Acknowledgment, please let me
know.
Sincerely,
R. Alexander Acosta
United States Attorney
By:
cc: Karen Atkinson, AUSA
A. Marie Villafatia
Assistant United States Attorney
O.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561)8204711
Facsimile: (561)8204777
July 9, 2008
VIA FACSIMILE
Jack A. Goldberger, Esq.
Atterbury, Goldberger & Weiss, P.A.
One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400
250 Australian Ave S.
West Palm Beach, FL 33401-5015
Re: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Mr. Goldberger:
Thank you for your letter of today's date regarding theproposed Victim Notification.
Let me address some of the items in your letter.
We have no objection to doing individual mailings. The Notification was drafted in
that way in order to minimize the number of documents that Mr. Epstein would sign. Now
that you have raised an objection to signing the Acknowledgment, each notification will list •
only the victim who is being notified.
In light of Mr. Epstein's refusal to sign the Acknowledgment, the Acknowledgment
portion has been deleted and the notification has been slightly modified in order to provide
more complete information and it has been formatted as a letter rather than a more formal
"Notification" document.
We will not be including any statement that the U.S. Attorney's Office is not vouching
for the veracity of any claim. As you know, the U.S. Attorney's modification of the 2255
portion of the Agreement now limits our victim list to those persons whom the United States
EXHIBIT B-60
Recipient Road
Acosta. Alex (USAFLS) Read: 7/9/2008 1:26 PM
Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS) Read: 7/9/20081:05 PM
Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Kuyrkendall, E N. (FBI)
Richards, Jason R. (FBI)
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, July 09, 2008 1:04 PM
To: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS); Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Cc: Kuyrkendall, E N. (FBI); Richards, Jason R. (FBI)
Subject: Response to Goldberger Letter
Here are my thoughts:

1. Notification only by mail: For those girls who are currently not represented (or for whom we do not know of
any representation), we intend to contact the victims by telephone to tell them of the resolution and to get mailing
addresses to send the written notification or to determine if they have secured counsel to send it to them. For the
girls who are represented, contact will be made by telephone followed by the mailing of the notification. I think a
"live" thank you is the least that is required at this point and a "check in" to make sure that girls who need
counseling are getting it. (FBI has already arranged counseling for several girls.) In any written response to Mr.
Goldberger, I would simply ignore this request.

2. Separate mailings: I have no objection to this change. The notice was drafted the way it was so that Epstein
would only have to sign one document rather than 33. Since he isn't going to sign any, that change is fine with
me.

3. Notification limited to the information on the first page of the draft notification: In light of Epstein's refusal
to sign the acknowledgement, I think some additional explanation is required. I will prepare that revision and
send to you shortly.

4. Eliminate the Acknowledgement portion: I have no objection to this.
5. Supplement the notification with our previous statement that we are not vouching for the veracity of any
claim: I would reject this request and, in our response to Goldberger, state that we have limited our list to those
whom we were prepared to name in an indictment and, accordingly, we believe that there is proof beyond a
reasonable doubt that each was a victim of Epstein's.

6. Explain why the acknowledgement is required: In our response to Goldberger, I think we should explain that
the acknowledgement language was meant to create a means for proving the existence of the agreement without
having to provide copies of the Non-Prosecution Agreement, which contains a confidentiality clause. While I
have no objection to revising the language, I think that Epstein's position will lead to litigation regarding the need
to disclose the full agreement, which is contrary to the parties' interest in confidentiality. I agree that we cannot
force him to sign the acknowledgement, but he must accept the consequences of that decision.

7. Names of pro bono lawyers and information regarding their communications: I have already advised Mr.
Goldberger that I will provide him with the names and contact information of attorneys who represent the victims,
so I have no objection to that. I also have no objection to telling him that they were recommended by the Crime
Victims Rights Advocacy Group based upon a referral from the Justice Department. Other than that, I have no
intention of disclosing any "communications" that I had with them.
I will take a crack at revising the victim notifications and drafting a response to Goldberger. Any other thoughts I 
should
incorporate?

A. Marie Villajafia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
561 209-1047
EXHIBIT B-59
Tracking:
v v4. vv L.VV4.4 4 VI.4 vl • N., I II
July 8, 2008

A. Marie Villafana, AUSA
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Avenue, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
I slit IIV, N.4,44 1 U04-JULOU I
' JOSEPH R.ATTERBURY
• I JACK A. GOLDBERGER
JASON S.WEISS
I &NA Conified CrinainaI Trul Aourney
Mentes.' of New Nati & Florida Roe
Re: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Marie,
I am out of the office today. I will response to your fax of July 8, 2008 by return of fax tomorrow.
Very truly yours,
‘ 41Jack A. Goldberger
Dictated hut not mid
JAG/na
One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400 250 Australian Avenue Solid) West Palm Beach, FL. 33401
p 561,659.8300 f 561.835.8691 www.agwpa.com
„III ,IV, QV I I. I %).1I-I UO I r. ul
ATTERBURY, GOLDBERGER & WEISS, P.A.
250 Australian Avenue South
Suite 1400
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401

(561) 659-8300
Fax: (561) 835-8691
FAX TRANSMITTAL COVER SHEET
DATE: July 8, 2008
TO: A. Marie Villafana, Assistant U.S. Attorney
FAX NO.: 561-820-8777
FROM: Nayanira, Assistant to Jack A. Goldberger, Esquire
REMARKS: Jeffrey Epstein
TOTAL PAGES: 2  , Including cover sheet
*** PLEASE NOTE - CONFIDENTIALITY WARNING ***
THIS MESSAGE IS INTENDED FOR THE USE OF THE INDiDUAL OR ENTITY TO WHICH IT IS
ADDRESSED AND MAY CONTAIN INFORMATION THAT IS PR EGED. CONFIDENTIAL AND EXEMPT
FROM DISCLOSURE UNDER APPLICABLE LAW. If the reader of this message is not the Intended recipient or
the employee or agent responsible for delivering the message to the Intended recipient, you are hereby notified
that any dissemination, distribution or copying of this communication Is strictly prohibited. If you have received this
communication in error, please notify us immediately by telephone, and return the original message to us at the
above address via the U.S. Postal Mail Service. Thank you for your cooperation.
EXHIBIT B-58
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
A Marie Villafalta
500 S. Australian Ave, 4th Floor
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401

(561) 820-8711
Facsimile (561) 820-8777
FACSIMILE COVER SHEET
TO: Jack Alan Goldberger
DATE: July 8. 2008
FAX NO. 561-835-8691  # OF PAGES:  3
PHONE NO.  561 659-8300  RE: Jeffrey Epstein
FROM: A. MARIE VILLAFARA. Assistant U.S. Attorney
PHONE NO. 561 209-1047
COMMENTS:

P. 1
* * * TRANSMISSION RESULT REPORT ( JUL. 8.2008 2:11PM ) * * *
TTI USA() WPB FL
DATE TIME ADDRESS MODE TIME PAGE RESULT PERS. NAPE FILE
JUL. 8. 2:10PM 5618358691 TES 0'34" P. 3 OK 398
* : BATCH C : CONFIDENTIAL P : POLLING M : MEMORY L : SEND LATER y01 : FORWARDING E : ECM > : REDUCTION
R F : FINE
\DE G-: RICOH-MG3ICOMPATIBLE MODE
JACK 9OLDBERGER, ESQ.
JULY 8, 2008
PAGE 2
to pursue damages. If the United States learns that a civil suit has been filed against Mr.
Epstein and he has denied that one of these victims is entitled to proceed under 18 U.S.C.
§ 2255, that will be considered a breach of the Non-Prosecution Agreement and the United
States will proceed accordingly.
Sincerely,

It. Alexander Acosta
United States Attorney
I ly :
A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant United States Attorney
cc: Karen Atkinson, AUSA
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 8, 2008
VIA FACSIMILE AND ELECTRONIC MAIL
Jack A. Goldberger, Esq.
Atterbury, Goldberger & Weiss, P.A.
One Clearlake Centre, Suite 1400
25i.) Australian Ave S.
West Palm Beach, FL 33401-5015
Re: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Mr. Goldberger:
In accordance with the terms of the Non-Prosecution Agreement, on June 30, 2008,
the United States Attorney's Office provided you with a list of thirty-one individuals "whom
it was prepared to name in an Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr.
Epstein." Yesterday, I provided you with the identification of another victim whom I had
erroneously left off of that list. At the time the list was provided, Special Agent Kuyrkendall
and I impressed upon you the need to finalize this last piece of the agreement as quickly as
possible so that we could fulfill our victim notification obligations. In deference to your
vacation, we allowed you a week to provide us with any objections or requested
modifications to the list and/or the Notification language. Yesterday, I contacted you via
telephone and e-mail, but received no response.
Accordingly, the United States hereby notifies you that it will distribute the victim
notifications tomorrow, July 9, 2008, to each of the thirty-two identified victims, either
directly or via their counsel. A carbon copy of each notification will be provided to you, and
the notification will list you as the contact person for any civil litigation, if the victim decides
EXHIBIT B-57
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JUNE 30, 2008
PAGE 3 OF 3
that an exact copy of this Notification will be provided to each identified individual, except
that the names of all other identified individuals will be redacted, and I hereby waive any
evidentiary challenges to the introduction of a copy of this document—even in redacted
form—in any judicial proceeding between any identified individual and myself.
Dated:
Jeffrey Epstein
Witnessed by:
Roy Black, Esquire
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JUNE 30, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 3
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that the individuals identified
below are individuals whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim of an
enumerated offense.
Identified Individuals
Dated:

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By:
A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I have received this Notification from my attorney, Roy Black, Esquire, have read it
and discussed it with my attorney, and I hereby acknowledge that it accurately sets forth my
understanding and agreement with the Office of the United States Attorney for the Southern
District of Florida regarding the notification and rights of identified victims. I understand
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Roy Black
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave.. Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 3340!
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454AXXXMB and 2008-cf-
009381A,DOUvD3) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by eighteen months' of Community Control 1, the first six months of which must
be served iniprisoned at the Palm Beach County Detention Facility.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less." •
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Roy Black
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401

(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JUNE 30, 2008
PAGE 3 OF 3
that an exact copy of this Notification will be provided to each identified individual, except
that the names of all other identified individuals will be redacted, and I hereby waive any
evidentiary challenges to the introduction of a copy of this document—even in redacted
form—in any judicial proceeding between any identified individual and myself.
Dated:
Jeffrey Epstein
Witnessed by:
Roy Black, Esquire
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JUNE 30, 2008
PAGE 2 GP 3
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that the individuals identified
below are individuals whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim of an
enumerated offense.
Identified Individuals
Dated:

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By:
A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I have received this Notification from my attorney, Roy Black, Esquire, have read it
and discussed it with my attorney, and I hereby acknowledge that it accurately sets forth my
understanding and agreement with the Office of the United States Attorney for the Southern
District of Florida regarding the notification and rights of identified victims. I understand
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein Initials of Roy Black
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 8204777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454MOOUVIB and 2008-cf-
00938 1 AXXKM:B) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by eighteen months' of Community Control 1, the first six months of which must
be served imprisoned at the Palm Beach County Detention Facility.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Roy Black
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401

(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JuNE 30, 2008
PAGE 3 OF 3
that an exact copy of this Notification will be provided to each identified individual, except
that the names of all other identified individuals will be redacted, and I hereby waive any
evidentiary challenges to the introduction of a copy of this document—even in redacted
form—in any judicial proceeding between any identified individual and myself.
Dated:
Jeffrey Epstein
Witnessed by:
Roy Black, Esquire
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JuNE 30, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 3
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that the individuals identified
below are individuals whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim of an
enumerated offense.
Identified Individuals
Dated:

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By:
A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I have received this Notification from my attorney, Roy Black, Esquire, have read it
and discussed it with my attorney, and I hereby acknowledge that it accurately sets forth my
understanding and agreement with the Office of the United States Attorney for the Southern
District of Florida regarding the notification and rights of identified victims. I understand
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein Initials of Roy Black
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 8204777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454AXXXMB and 2008-cf-
00938 lAXXYMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by eighteen months' of Community Control 1, the first six months of which must
be served imprisoned at the Palm Beach County Detention Facility.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Roy Black
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Pahn Beach. FL 33401

(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JUNE 30, 2008
PAGE 3 OF 3
understand that an exact copy of this Notification will be provided to each identified
individual, except that the names of all other identified individuals will be redacted, and I
hereby waive any evidentiary challenges to the introduction of a copy of this document—even
in redacted form—in any judicial proceeding between any identified individual and myself.
Dated:
Jeffrey Epstein
Witnessed by:
Jack Goldberger, Esquire
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JUNE 30, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 3
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that the individuals identified
below are individuals whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim of an
enumerated offense.
Identified Individuals
Dated:

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By:
A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
el
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I have received this Notification from my attorney, Jack Goldberger, Esquire, have
read it and discussed it with my attorney, and I hereby acknowledge that it accurately sets
forth my understanding and agreement with the Office of the United States Attorney for the
Southern District of Florida regarding the notification and rights of identified victims. I
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Jack Goldberger
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
S00 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561)820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454AXXX1v1B and 2008-cf-
00938 lAXIOCKB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by eighteen months' of Community Control 1, the first six months of which must
be served imprisoned at the Palm Beach County Detention Facility.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"My person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list, of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Jack Goldberger
U.S. Department of Justice
United Stales Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401

(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JUNE 30, 2008
PAGE 3 oF• 3
that an exact copy of this Notification will be provided to each identified individual, except
that the names of all other identified individuals will be redacted, and I hereby waive any
evidentiary challenges to the introduction of a copy of this document—even in redacted
form—in any judicial proceeding between any identified individual and myself.
Dated:
Jeffrey Epstein
Witnessed by:
Guy Lewis, Esquire
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JUNE 30, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 3
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that the individuals identified
below are individuals whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim of an
enumerated offense.
Identified Individuals

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
Dated: By:
A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
I have received this Notification from my attorney, Guy Lewis, Esquire, have read it
and discussed it with my attorney, and I hereby acknowledge that it accurately sets forth my
understanding and agreement with the Office of the United States Attorney for the Southern
District of Florida regarding the notification and rights of identified victims. I understand
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Guy Lewis
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos.. 2006-cf-009454/OO(Xle and 2008-cf-
009381AXXXMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by eighteen months' of Community Control I, the first six months of which must
be served imprisoned at the Palm Beach County Detention Facility.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. My judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Guy Lewis
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 3340/

(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561)820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW, THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE
TREATED AS CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT
BE DISCLOSED EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL PROCEEDING.
N0TIFICATI0N OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JUNE. 30, 2008
I'AGE 3 OF 3
that an exact copy of this Notification will be provided to each identified individual, except
that the names of all other identified individuals will be redacted, and I hereby waive any
evidentiary challenges to the introduction of a copy of this document—even in redacted
form—in any judicial proceeding between any identified individual and myself.
Dated:
Jeffrey Epstein
Witnessed by:
Guy Lewis, Esquire
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
Jun 30, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 3
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that the individuals identified
below are individuals whom the United States was prepared to name as a victim of an
enumerated offense.
Identified Individuals
Dated:

It. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
By:
A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
ACKNOWLEDGMENT  •
I have received this Notification from my attorney, Guy Lewis, Esquire, have read it
and discussed it with my attorney, and I hereby acknowledge that it accurately sets forth my
understanding and agreement with the Office of the United States Attorney for the Southern
District of Florida regarding the notification and rights of identified victims. I understand
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Guy Lewis
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454MOCKMB and 2008-cf-
00938 1 AXXXMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by eighteen months' of Community Control I, the first six months of which must
be served imprisoned at the Palm Beach County Detention Facility.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same
rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein
had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense. For purposes
of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall provide Mr. Epstein's
attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in an
Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial
authority interpreting this provision, including any authority determining
which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is
the intent of the parties to place these identified victims in the same position
as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no
less."
Initials of Jeffrey Epstein  Initials of Guy Lewis
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (561)820-8777
June 30, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
EXHIBIT B-56
r
30 —
mice-aer (Auk- r- RVicuvt. GaRel -S
5„ i 5Fz. - 24.00
CC U t A
a 3)5 13/ - 2-2-0()
r
4n, fk
_idtricazit
7/ — i ---I.,17- --q‘22- 773
fa---1:5 4grcarc- UpfctL—
Siztol CAthgt4dA qc V 2 94 4 - 754' 4/
TM -"S-
NNITeak Lg./420a ---(5:55MPO* C.,,gt-i- C:51515-
got 31 ( - Bvt-tkcolloblilrick-flow—C44e) ge 4,71: 2-3V3
—
1'1 rrl
1 . gt-2--
• Sil l
EXHIBIT B-55

╭─────────── Page 234, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ _ [ | Fens, Be - ;                       │
│ DNiichoet Divehi + Ridirot Wilkes        │
│ St _                                     │
│                                          │
│ ST, Herren 305 F-22000                   │
│ Cee” Y07-737/-                           │
│                                          │
│ | Brad Guards _ WY 244 - =P5 1           │
│ se oS oo                                 │
│                                          │
│ = a Lene CSD C8Y- SO                     │
│                                          │
│ ~ Be 31 (367 -Fiopeld Q.rice ayo. Gira ; │
│ |e AT -2383                              │
│                                          │
│ pe Dydic. PE 2500                        │
│                                          │
│ EXHIBIT B-55                             │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────╯

U.S. Department of Justice
Washington, D.C. 20530
June 23, 2008
Jay Lefkowitz, Esq.
Kenneth Starr, Esq.
Kirkland and Ellis LLP
777 South Figueroa Street
Los Angeles, CA 90017
Gentlemen:
This Office has completed a thorough review of the U.S. Attorney's handling of the matter
involving your client, Jeffrey Epstein. We have received and reviewed your letters of May 19,
June 3 and June 19, 2008, the attachments to the June 19 letter, as well as your submissions to
the Criminal Division and the U.S. Attorney's Office. Additionally, we have reviewed an
extensive set of materials provided by the U.S. Attorney's Office and conferred with a number of
highly experienced Department attorneys about this matter. The Deputy Attorney General has
also been briefed.
As you know, the Department of Justice vests considerable discretion in its U.S. Attorneys, and
the Deputy Attorney General will intervene in only the most unusual of circumstances. We do
not believe such intervention is warranted here. Even if we were to substitute our judgment for
that of the U.S. Attorney, we believe that federal prosecution of this case is appropriate.
Moreover, having reviewed your allegations of prosecutorial misconduct, and the facts
underlying them, we see nothing in the conduct of the U.S. Attorney's Office that gives us any
reason to alter our opinion.
cc: Alex Acosta
Sincerely,
John Roth
Senior Associate Deputy Attorney General
EXHIBIT B-44
EXHIBIT B-45

╭────── Page 236, Image 1 ───────╮
│ Chy og AMCY e-rail 1 Black ard │
│ Golloug                        │
│                                │
│ EXHIBIT B-45                   │
╰────────────────────────────────╯

Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Tuesday, June 24, 2008 3:08 PM
To: Roy BLACK
Subject: RE: FW: Jeffrey Epstein
Hi Roy -- Is this the best number to call? (305) 371-6421

A. Marie Villafaha
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Original Message
From: Roy BLACK [mailto:RBLACK@royblack.com]
Sent: Tuesday, June 24, 2008 3:02 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc: jack goldberger
Subject: Re: FW: Jeffrey Epstein
Marie that is a good time. I also want to conference Jack Goldberger into the
call. This will be a wrap up call. Roy
>>> "Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)"
<Ann.Marie.C.VillafanaPusdoi.gov> 6/24/2008 12:23 PM >>> Dear Roy:
Jeff Sloman contacted me and asked me to return your call regarding the Epstein
matter. I am forwarding to you an e-mail that I sent to Jay Lefkowitz last
night.
Karen and I can call you at 3:30 to speak about your list of issues.
If that time does not work, please let me know what times you are available.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 5:55 PM
To: lefkowitz@kirkland.com; Jay Lefkowitz
A
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Mr. Lefk6witz:
I understand that the Deputy Attorney General has completed his review
of the Epstein matter and has determined that federal prosecution of

Mr. Epstein's case is appropriate.
Accordingly, Mr. Epstein has until the close of business on Monday,
June 30, 2008, to comply with the terms and conditions of the agreement
between the United States and Mr. Epstein (as modified by the U.S.
Attorney's December 19th letter to Ms. Sanchez), including entry of a
guilty plea, sentencing, and surrendering to begin his sentence of
imprisonment.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at the number
shown below.

A. Marie Villafaha
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Tuesday, June 24, 2008 4:05 PM
To: Roy BLACK; Jack Goldberger
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein Agreement
Dear Roy and Jack:
I am just writing to re-state that it is the Government's position that we have a signed, binding agreement and
that there is no need for further modification.
Please keep us informed of the date and time of the change of plea and sentencing.
"Thank you.

A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Tracking:
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Roy BLACK <RBLACK@royblack.com>
Sent: Tuesday, June 24, 2008 3:13 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: FW: Jeffrey Epstein
yes.
>>> "Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)"
<Ann.Marie.C.Villafana@usdoj.gov> 6/24/2008 3:08 PM >»
Iii Roy -- Is this the best number to call? (305) 371-6421

A. Marie Villafafla
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Original Message
From: Roy BLACK [mailto:RBLACK®rovblack.coml
Sent: Tuesday, June 24, 2008 3:02 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc: jack goldberger
Subject: Re: FW: Jeffrey Epstein
Marie that is a good time. I also want to conference Jack Goldberger
into the call. This will be a wrap up call. Roy
>>> "Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)"
<Ann.Marie.C.Villafana@usdoj.gov> 6/24/2008 12:23 PM >>>
Dear Roy:
Jeff Sloman contacted me and asked me to return your call regarding
the
Epstein matter. 1 am forwarding to you an e-mail that I sent to Jay
1.efkowitz last night.
Karen and I can call you at 3:30 to speak about your list of issues.
If that time does not work, please let me know what times you are
available.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafafla
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820.8777
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 5:55 PM
To: lefkowitz@kirkland.com; Jay Lefkowitz
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Mr. Lefkowitz:
I understand that the Deputy Attorney General has completed his review
of the Epstein matter and has determined that federal prosecution of

Mr. Epstein's case is appropriate.
Accordingly, Mr. Epstein has until the close of business on Monday,
June 30, 2008, to comply with the terms and conditions of the
agreement
between the United States and Mr. Epstein (as modified by the U.S.
Attorney's December 19th letter to Ms. Sanchez), including entry of a
guilty plea, sentencing, and surrendering to begin his sentence of
imprisonment.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at the
number
shown below.

A. Marie Villafafta
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Roy BLACK <RBLACK@royblack.com>
Sent: Tuesday, June 24, 2008 3:02 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc: jack goldberger
Subject: Re: FW: Jeffrey Epstein
Marie that is a good time. I also want to conference Jack Goldberger
into the call. This will be a wrap up call. Roy
>>> "Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)"
<Ann.Marie.C.Villafana®usdoj.gov> 6/24/2008 12:23 PM >>>
Dear Roy:
Jeff Sloman contacted me and asked me to return your call regarding the
Epstein matter. I am forwarding to you an e-mail that I sent to Jay
Lefkowitz last night.
Karen and I can call you at 3:30 to speak about your list of issues.
If that time does not work, please let me know what times you are
available.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafalla
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 5:55 PM
To: lefkowitz@kirkland.com; Jay Lefkowitz
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAF S)
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Mr. Lefkowitz:
I understand that the Deputy Attorney General has completed his review
of the Epstein matter and has determined that federal prosecution of

Mr. Epstein's case is appropriate.
Accordingly, Mr. Epstein has until the close of business on Monday,
June 30, 2008, to comply with the terms and conditions of the agreement
between the United States and Mr. Epstein (as modified by the U.S.
Attorney's December 19th letter to Ms. Sanchez), including entry of a
guilty pica, sentencing, and surrendering to begin his sentence of
imprisonment.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at the number
shown below.

A. Marie Villafafla
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS) <1Sloman ®usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, June 24, 2008 9:14 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Jeffrey Epstein Agreement
Let's talk about going to the COP
Original Message
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Roy BLACK <RBLACK@royblack.com>; Jack Goldberger <jgoldberger©agwpa.com>
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Sent: Tue Jun 24 16:04:55 2008
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein Agreement
Dear Roy and Jack:
1 am just writing to re-state that it is the Government's position that we have a signed, binding agreement and that 
there is no need for
further modification.
Please keep us informed of the date and time of the change of plea and sentencing.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFIS) <1Sloman@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 8:46 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFIS)
Subject: Re: Jeffrey Epstein Agreement
I have a des apptmt @ 10:45 in ftm laud so call me on my cell.
— Original Message --
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Wed Jun 25 08:39:31 2008
Subject: RE: Jeffrey Epstein Agreement
Hi Jeff— I think I have designed a solution to the 2255 issue and I will call you to discuss the plea. I am still 
finishing up these search
warrants. As soon as they are done, I will give you a call.

A. Marie Villafafta
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
— Original Message—
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Tuesday, June 24, 2008 9:14 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Jeffrey Epstein Agreement
Let's talk about going to the COP
— Original Message --
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Roy BLACK <RBLACK®royblack.com>; Jack Goldberger <jgoldberger@agwpa.com>
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Sent: Tue Jun 24 16:04:55 2008
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein Agreement
Dear Roy and Jack:
I am just writing to re-state that it is the Government's position that we have a signed, binding agreement and that 
there is no need for
further modification.
Please keep us informed of the date and time of the change of plea and sentencing.
Thank you.

A. Marie Villafafta
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
EXHIBIT B-46
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS) clSlomangiusa.doj.gov>
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 6:05 PM
Cc: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Fw. Revised Victim Notification
Attachments: U.wpd
This simplifies it. What do u think?
---- Original Message --
From: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Wed Jun 25 18:00:14 2008
Subject: RE: Revised Victim Notification
What do you think
<<U.wpd>>
«LLANO»
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 5:43 PM
To: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
Subject: FW: Revised Victim Notification
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 5:25 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS); Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Revised Victim Notification
Hi Jeff -- I have tried to phrase it in a way that suggests that, since Epstein has performed certain provisions, it is 
now our turn to
perform.
<< File: Revised Victim Notification.wpd >>

A. Marie Villafafla
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
EXHIBIT B-47
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS) <JSIoman@usa.dolgov>
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 6:05 PM
Cc: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Fvr. Revised Victim Notification
Attachments: U.wpd
This simplifies it. What do u think?
--- Original Message --
From: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Wed Jun 25 18:00:14 2008
Subject: RE: Revised Victim Notification
What do you think
«U.wpd>>
«U.wpd>>
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 5:43 PM
To: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
Subject: FW: Revised Victim Notification
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 5:25 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS); Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Revised Victim Notification
Hi Jeff— I have tried to phrase it in a way that suggests that, since Epstein has performed certain provisions, it is 
now our turn to
perform.
« File: Revised Victim Notification.wpd >>

A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
08-80736-CV-MARRA 96
EXHIBIT B-48
P-014982
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) <AVillafana@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Thursday, June 26, 2008 8:31 AM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Subject: RE Revised Victim Notification
Jeff — tam running off to grand jury. I will call as soon as I get back, probably around 9:45. Thanks.

A. Marie Villafaha
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
----Original Message---
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 6:05 PM
Cc: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Fw: Revised Victim Notification
This simplifies it. What do u think?
— Original Message ---
From: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Wed Jun 25 18:00:14 2008
Subject: RE: Revised Victim Notification
What do you think
<<U.wpd»
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 5:43 PM
To: Acosta, Alm (USAFLS)
Subject: FW: Revised Victim Notification
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Wednesday, June 25, 2008 5:25 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS); Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Revised Victim Notification
Hi Jeff— I have tried to phrase it in a way that suggests that, since Epstein has performed certain provisions, it is 
now our turn to
perform.
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014983
« File: Revised Victim Notification.wpd >>

A. Marie Villarada
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 8204777
08-80736-CV-MARRA
P-014984
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach FL 33401
(361)820-8711
Facsimile: (561)820-8777
July 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a
plea of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of
prostitution) and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th
Judicial Circuit in and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009495AXXXMEB and
2008- ) and was sentenced to a term of eighteen months' imprisonment
to be followed by years of probation.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions.
One such condition to which Epstein has agreed is the following:
"My person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense
enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the
same rights to proceed under Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr.
Epstein had been tried federally and convicted of an enumerated offense.
For purposes of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall
provide Mr. Epstein's attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was
prepared to name in an Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by

Mr. Epstein. Any judicial authority interpreting this provision, including
any authority determining which evidentiary burdens if any a plaintiff must
meet, shall consider that it is the intent of the parties to place these
identified victims in the same position as they would have been had Mr.
Epstein been convicted at trial. No more; no less."
Through this letter, this Office hereby provides Notice that the individuals
identified below are individuals whom the United Stats was prepared to name as a victim
of an enumerated offense.
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014985
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JULY 2008
PAGE 2 OF 3
Identified Individuals
Jane Doe #1
Jane Doe #2
Jane Doe #3
Jane Doe #4
Jane Doe #5
Jane Doe #6
Jane Doe #7
Jane Doe #8
Jane Doe #9
Jane Doe #10
Jane Doe #11
Jane Doe #12
Jane Doe #13
Jane Doe #14
Jane Doe #15
Jane Doe #16
Jane Doe #17
Jane Doe #18
Jane Doe #19
Jane Doe #20
Dated:  By:

A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I have received this Notification from my attorney, Roy Slack Esquire, have read it and discussed it with my
attorney, and I hereby acknowledge that it accurately sets forth my understanding and agreement with the Office of the
United States Attorney for the Southern District of Florida. I understand that an exact copy of this Notification will 
be
provided to each identified individual, except that the names of all other identified individuals will be redacted, and 
I
hereby waive any evidentiary challenges to the introduction of a copy of this
document-even in redacted form-in any judicial proceeding between any identified
individual and myself.
Jane Doe #21
Jane Doe #22
Jane Doe #23
Jane Doe #24
Jane Doe #25
Jane Doe #26
Jane Doe #27
Jane Doe #28
Jane Doe #29
Jane Doe #30
R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014986
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JULY 2008
PAGE 3 OF 3
Dated:
Jeffrey Epstein
Witnessed by:
Roy Black, Esquire
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014987
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561)8204711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
July 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a
plea of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of
prostitution) and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution), in the 15th
Judicial Circuit in and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009495AXXXtv1B and
2008- ) and was sentenced to a term of eighteen months' imprisonment
to be followed by years of probation.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, and pursuant to the terms of
the deferred prosecution agreement between Epstein and the United States Attorney's
Office for the Southern District of Florida (hereinafter referred to as "the Office"), the
Office hereby provides notice to Epstein that the following is a list of individuals whom
the Office was prepared to name as victims in an Indictment charging Epstein with
violations of federal statutes enumerated in Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255
(hereinafter referred to as "identified individuals").
The terms of the deferred prosecution agreement provide that the identified
individuals shall have the same right to seek damages pursuant to Title 18, United States
Code, Section 2255, as they would have had if Mr. Epstein had been tried and convicted
of those enumerated offenses in a federal court. Section 2255 provides, in relevant part:
Any person who, while a minor, was a victim of a violation of section . . .
2422, or 2423 of this title and who suffers personal injury as a result of such
violation, regardless of whether the injury occurred while such person was a
minor, may sue in any appropriate United States District Court and shall
recover the actual damages such person sustains and the cost of the suit,
including a reasonable attorney's fee. Any person as described in the
preceding sentence shall be deemed to have sustained damages of no less
than $150,000 in value.
Thus, pursuant to the deferred prosecution Agreement between the Office and
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014988
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED terms
JULY 2008
PAGE 2 OF 3
Epstein, the Office hereby provides Notice to the identified individuals that each of them
is a person who, while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense enumerated in
Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, committed by Epstein. The Office further
provides Notice to the identified individuals that, pursuant to the Agreement between the
Office and Epstein, a copy of this document may be introduced in a judicial proceeding
between any such identified individual and Epstein, and that any judicial authority
interpreting this Notification, including any authority determining what evidentiary
burdens, if any, a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is the intent of Epstein and the
Office to place the identified individuals in the same position as they would have been
had Epstein been convicted of those federal offenses.
Identified Individuals
Jane Doe #1
Jane Doe #2
Jane Doe #3
Jane Doe #4
Jane Doe #5
Jane Doe #6
Jane Doe #7
Jane Doe #8
Jane Doe #9
Jane Doe #10
Jane Doe #11
Jane Doe #12
Jane Doe #13
Jane Doe #14
Jane Doe #15
Jane Doe #16
Jane Doe #17
Jane Doe #18
Jane Doe #19
Jane Doe #20
Dated:  By:

A. MARIE VILLAFARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I have received this Notification from my attorney, Roy Black Esquire, have read it and discussed it with my
attorney, and I hereby acknowledge that it accurately sets forth my understanding and agreement with the Office of the
United States Attorney for the Southern District of Florida. I understand that an exact copy of this Notification will 
be
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014989
Jane Doe #21
Jane Doe #22
Jane Doe #23
Jane Doe #24
Jane Doe #25
Jane Doe #26
Jane Doe #27
Jane Doe #28
Jane Doe #29
Jane Doe #30
R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIMS
JULY 2008
PAGE 3 OF 3
provided to each identified individual, except that the names of all other identified individuals will be redacted, and
hereby waive any evidentiary challenges to the introduction of a copy of this
document-even in redacted form-in any judicial proceeding between any identified
individual and myself.
Dated:
Jeffrey Epstein
Witnessed by:
Roy Black, Esquire
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014990
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Senior. Robert (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 5:30 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Cc: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Subject: FW: Epstein
I agree. Marie can you make this communication today please. Thank you.
Original Message
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 6:45 AM
To: Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Subject: Epstein
Bob,
If we get the go-ahead, I think Marie should immediately notify Lefkowitz that JE
has until COB Monday June 30 to comply with the 9/24 Agreement as modified by the
USA's 12/17 letter otherwise the Office will deem him in breach. What say you?
Jeff
EXHIBIT B-49
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Monday, June 23, 2008 5:55 PM
To: lefkowitz@kirkland.conY: Jay Leffcowitz
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Mr. 1-efkowitz:
I understand that the Deputy Attorney General has completed his review of the Epstein matter and has
determined that federal prosecution of Mr. Epstein's case is appropriate.
Accordingly, Mr. Epstein has until the close of business on Monday. June 30, 2008, to comply with the terms
and conditions of the agreement between the United States and Mr. Epstein (as modified by the U.S. Attorney's
December I9th letter to Ms. Sanchez), including entry of a guilty plea, sentencing, and surrendering to begin his
sentence of imprisonment.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at the number shown below.
A. Marie Villafaaa
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Tracking:
Amenold, Jennifer
Andriano,
Britan
wegel,
iciliano, Jennifer
mythe,
elasco, Shady
Wild, Courtne
lis,
20'd itila
3/14 Recently identified. Law Enforcement has not interviewed.
17 No recollection regarding ever going to Epstein's residence or providing massage to Epstein
17 Original interview stated that she modeled lingerie for Epstein.
117 Uncooperative. Law Enforcement has not interviewed.
5/16 Uncooperative - confirmed age she provided massage but said Epstein did not touch her or masturbate.
17 Left 2 messages. Original Interview to FBI stated that she was 18 and she did not admit to providing massages.
15 Inconsistent statements to Law Enforcement Uncooperative.
tVa No contact with Epstein nor did she know anyone associated with Epstein.
EXHIBIT B-50
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana. Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Friday. June 27, 2008 3:48 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS): Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Cc: Nesbitt Kuyrkendall (E.Kuyrkendall@ic.fbi.goy); Jason Richards (Jason.Richards2
@ic.fbi.gov)
Subject: Epstein Plea
Wow, am I good. Here it is already. I think our faxes crossed in cyber-space. Sorry for the poor quality, that is how it
came to me.
Epstein
Plea001.pdf
;4. :Marie fliltafaiiii
idIssistant US. .'A tiorney
561 209-1047
781 EXHIBIT B-5I
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Friday. June 27, 2008 3:40 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Atkinson. Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: 080627 Goldberger Black Itr.pdf
Here is the letter that I just faxed over.
Police checked the docket and it is on at 8:30 for a "status conference." It also looks like the required
procurement of minors charge has been filed. Will keep you posted.
Iberger Black Itri
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Friday, June 27, 2008 10:14 AM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Still haven't heard anything
How did things go with Chief Reiter?

A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
Tracking: EXHIBIT B-52 797
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Saturday, June 28, 2008 12:56 PM
To: Villeama,AnnblarieC.(JSAFLS)
Subject: Re: Chief reiter
Good
Original Message
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Sat Jun 28 11:21:34 2008
Subject: Chief reiter
Jeff. I spoke with the chief this morning. He is going to notify victims about
the plea.
EXHIBIT B-53
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Sent: Friday, December 07, 2007 5:08 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Epstein
Hold the letter
Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld
Original Message
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
Sent: Fri Dec 07 17:05:56 2007
Subject: Epstein
Hello - Any word? Am I free to send out the victim notification letter? And, is
it alright to send copies of the victim notification letter to Mr. Josefsberg?
A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
500 S. Australian Ave, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Phone 561 209-1047
Fax 561 820-8777
EXHIBIT B-54
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014420
r callziai artezza-
-Lesii k lenre
stakilsaf_ra_liut-gv 111MJ. ; Aka_ _ a _stgi 1/2
RS  251 4 -  9;544_
I1: 50 aa16.12,_LA aimd_ a-to el
---a , _Can----411AXIBLOCICS
ibiat0121 /S_ _ crednACh6<15...!.
'ILAtainAl2/2eA. " _We
2.Lthe#__16 1
vt _ A i_J-A4_nistad__
/1/4 _trasiai•
11%52- Fax EQCL12ak
calt  • -
EXHIBIT B-43

╭─────── Page 264, Image 1 ───────╮
│ Tare (8) 20088                  │
│                                 │
│ Brook couna Bx Courtrws         │
│ WW) fh pag cat                  │
│ — Tau lhe Ae url                │
│ | elle to st eee                │
│ Y                               │
│                                 │
│ (eld laos 45 24h G54            │
│                                 │
│ soa Auer A. ook | place         │
│ oy OE a pecs                    │
│ Rolowdlo's wstrucho’ floy canie │
│ Sapaueadlalls” Use ma a         │
│                                 │
│ pe ie agg |                     │
│                                 │
│ on ois                          │
│                                 │
│ EXHIBIT B-43                    │
╰─────────────────────────────────╯

Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Brad Edwards (be@bradedwardslaw.com]
Sent: Thursday, June 19, 2008 11:34 AM
To: Villafana. Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: Jeff Epstein
Hi Marie,
I have information and concerns that I would like to share. While I understand that you are limited in what you can
discuss. I would like to meet with you and discuss my plans. This would be beneficial to you and me. Let me know if you
are interested in meeting and talking. My schedule is free next Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday, July 23-25. If any of
those days are open for you, then I will go to you and can meet you at any time convenient for you. I am scheduling to
meet with my client again next week in your area anyway, so it would be no problem for me to meet you on the same
day. I look forward to hearing back from you.
Sincerely,
Brad Edwards, Esquire
Law Office of Brad Edwards & Associates
2028 Harrison Street
Suite 202
Hollywood, Florida 33020
Telephone: 954414-8033 (Broward)
305-935-2011 (Miami-Dade)
Facsimile: 954-924- 1530(Broward)
305/935-4227 (Miami-Dade)
e-mail: be@bradedwardslaw.com
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL:  The information contained in this e-mail message is intended for the
use of the individual or entity to which it is
addressed and may contain information that is proprietary, privileged, confidential, and exempt from disclosure
under applicable laws. If the reader of this
message is not the intended recipient, or the employee or agent responsible for delivery to the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, printing,
reproduction, disclosure or dissemination of this communication may be subject to legal restriction or sanction.
j.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Reach, FL 33401
(561)820-8711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
April 9, 2008
VIA FACSIMILE
Richard H. Willets, Esq.

Mr. Michael Danchuk
2290 10th Avenue North, Suite 404
Lake Worth, FL 33461
Re: Carolyn El
Dear Messrs. Willits and Danchuk:
Thank you for your letter of March 28, 2008, regarding
Pursuant to the strict rules of grand jury secrecy, I am not able to prow e you wt e
information that you have requested. I believe that some of the information you are
seeking is available from ublic sources on the intemet. We also do not have any
photographs of Ms.
I regret that I cannot be of more assistance. I would appreciate it if you would
keep me updated on the course of the civil litigation.
Sincerely,

R. Alexander Acosta
United States Attorney
A. Marie Vitfafaka
Assistant United States
Attorney
cc: E. Nesbitt Kuyrkendall, FBI EXHIBIT B-42

A. Maria Di Ilafana, F-sq.
March 28, 2008
Paga 2
We look forward to hearing from you on whether you can assist us.
Thank you for your assistance.
Sincerely,
Michael Danchuk
Legal Administrator/Paralegal
MD/
cc :
chard H.  Esq.
Richard H. Willits, P.A.
Board Certified Civil Trial Lawyer
2290 10th Avenue North, Suite 404
Lake Worth, Florida 33461
Office: (561) 582-7600 Fax: (561) 588-8819
March 28, 2008
A. Maria Dillafana, Esq.
US Dept. of Justice
500 S. Australian Ave., Suite 400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Re: Our Client:
Defendant: Je ey Epstein
Dear Ms. Dillafana:
Please be advised we have been retained to represent EM as a result of a relationship
with Mr. Epstein.
As we understand you are investigating this matter, we wanted you to be aware of our involvement.
We have filed a lawsuit in Palm Beach County Circuit Court under Ms. initials, C.M.A.
We are using the initials to try to keep publicity on this matter limited for Ms. Andriano's benefit.
Possibly, you can help us with one of the problems that we are having. We have not been able to
serve Mr. Epstein, and his attorney will not accept service on his behalf
We had discussed this with FBI Agent Elizabeth Kirkdale, and she suggested that we contact you to
see if you could provide us the information we are requesting.
We are trying to locate Mr. Epstein's airplane "tail registration number" for the 727 plane that he
has. If you have this information and can provide it to us, it would be greatly appreciated.
Also we understand that either the FBI or your office may have photographs taken of Ms.
by allegedly for Mr. Epstein.
If you do have these photographs, we, of course, would request that they be preserved and also
copies made for us.
If there are any copy charges involved, we would be happy to reimburse your department.
EXI-I1B1T 8-41
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS) <JSIoman@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Thursday, May 29, 2008 9:29 AM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS); Kuyrkendall, E N. (MM) (FBI); Richards, Jason R. (MM) (FBI)
Subject: RE: Epstein
No telling how long the DAG's office will take to decide. Tuesday is off.
—Original Message—
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Thursday, May 29, 2008 9:03 AM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS); Kuyrkendall, E N. (FBI); Richards, Jason R. (FBI)
Subject: Epstein
Hi Jeff and Bob. I received Jeff's e-mail stating that the DAG agreed to meet with epstein's people. Does this mean that
Tuesday is
off? I need to let the gj coordinator know.
Also, I am sure that you remember in. She was the person whom we initially classified as a victim until epstein's 
attorneys
complained. Well. nesbitt ha inigted a girl who was I4 or I5 when she first went to epstein's house who reports that 
epstein
told her that he had sex with. probably would have been 15 or 16 when this conversation occurred.) The girl also reports
that she told epstein her true age and epstein told her that he doesn't care about age.
I know that cpstein's people will, no doubt, continue to tell the dag and others that epstein didn't know about the 
girls' ages so I
thought you should know.
Please let me know about tuesday so I don't needlessly spoil nesbitt's sunday. And, any chance the case was discussed 
with the ag
when he was in town?
Thanks.
EXHIBIT B-40
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) <AVillafana@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, May 27, 2008 1:20 PM
To: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Epstein
Please tell me you that you are joking. Maybe we should throw him a party and tell him we are sorry to have bothered 
him.
Original Message
From: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Tue May 27 10:27:10 2008
Subject: Epstein
Don't know what is up but Barry talked to Rolando and according to Rolando said something about 90 days in jail. Rolando
is talking
to Jeff-he said. K
08-80736-CV-MARRA EXHIBIT B-39
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Senior, Robert (USAFLS) <RSenior@usa.doi.gou>
Sent: Tuesday, May 27, 2008 5:09 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Epstein
Perfect. Enjoy your trip. Wc'rc in good shape (so far).
Original Message
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Tuesday, May 27, 2008 3:56 PM
To: Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Epstein
Hi bob. I get back on saturday. I will spend sunday with nesbitt and monday with you. I will be there by 10:00 unless 
you need me
there earlier.
Original Message
From: Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS); Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Sent: Tue May 27 15:24:50 2008
Subject: RE: Epstein
Marie, are you back ? We need to spend some time together on the indictment. I was planning on Monday because I thought 
you
were back that day but if you're already back let me know. By the way, Jeff and Alex have been very clear that we are 
not negotiating
with this guy any more in any way.
Thx. Bob
----Original Message
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFI.S)
Sent: Tuesday, May 27, 2008 2:54 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Epstein
Hi jeff. Karen sent me an email about epstein wanting to do less time. I hope that his request will be denied. The 
original deal was
supposed to be 2 years so he has already gotten a big break. Plus we have identified more victims since we agreed to the
18 months.
Please keep me posted. Thanks.
EXHIBIT B-38
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014927
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) <AVillafana@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, May 27, 2008 3:56 PM
To: Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Subject: Re: Epstein
Hi bob. I get back on saturday. I will spend sunday with nesbitt and monday with you. I will be there by 10:00 unless 
you need me
there earlier.
---- Original Message
From: Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS); Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Sent: Tue May 27 15:24:50 2008
Subject: RE: Epstein
Marie, are you back ? We need to spend some time together on the indictment. I was planning on Monday because I thought 
you
were back that day but if you're already back let me know. By the way, Jeff and Alex have been very clear that we are 
not negotiating
with this guy any more in any way.
Thx. Bob
Original Message-----
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Tuesday, May 27, 2008 2:54 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Ce: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Epstein
Ili jeff. Karen sent me an email about cpstein wanting to do less time. I hope that his request will be denied. The 
original deal was
supposed to be 2 years so he has already gotten a big break. Plus we have identified more victims since we agreed to the
18 months.
Please keep me posted. Thanks.
08-80736-CV-MARRA
P-014926
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
From: Senior, Robert (USAFLS) <RSenior@usa.doj.gov>
Sent: Tuesday, May 27, 2008 3:25 PM
To: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS); Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: RE: Epstein
Marie, are you back ? We need to spend some time together on the indictment. I was planning on Monday because I thought 
you
were back that day but if you're already back let me know. By the way, Jeff and Alex have been very clear that we arc 
not negotiating
with this guy any more in any way.
Thx. Bob
Original Message
From: Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Tuesday, May 27, 2008 2:54 PM
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Senior, Robert (USAFLS)
Cc: Atkinson, Karen (USAFLS)
Subject: Epstein
Hi jeff. Karen sent me an email about cpstein wanting to do less time. I hope that his request will be denied. The 
original deal was
supposed to be 2 years so he has already gotten a big break. Plus we have identified more victims since we agreed to the
III months.
Please keep me posted. Thanks.
08-80736-CV-MARRA P-014925
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
make an independent decision not adversely affected by conclusions that over and over have
proven, witness by witness, allegation by allegation, to be inaccurate and unwarranted and not an
appropriate basis for the exercise of federal prosecutorial authority.
RFP MIA 000440
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
role. They said they would only advise on an abuse of discretion standard. Making the
outcome a foregone conclusion. Furthermore, in response to the February 25 e-mail,
which attempted to establish a schedule to limit the entire review process (the defense has
repeatedly suggested that the misconduct was intertwined with the investigation and
would therefore seek higher review), Mr. Lefkowitz e-mailed Mr. Acosta directly. On
February 29, 2008, Mr. Sloman responded to Mr. Lefkowitz's e-mail to Mr. Acosta,
stating that Mr. Sloman was acting out of frustration, but "[p]lease be assured that it has
not, and never has been, this Office's intent to interfere or restrict the "review process"
for either Mr. Epstein or CEOS. I leave it to you and CEOS to figure out how best to
proceed and will await the results of that process." As stated above, CEOS determined
that it would not review many of the defense's objections and as to the remainder of those
objections, its review would be limited (contrary to Mr. Acosta's assurances), which left
the need, supplemented by the defense's subsequent request, for a more thorough review
of critical issues by others at the Department of Justice. Mr. Sloman's re-imposition of
the (albeit modestly extended) timetable was an obvious attempt, in violation of his
February 29 agreement, to thwart the request made by the defense to the Deputy Attorney
general, to complete the review process that Mr. Acosta bad promised.

11. "DELAY."
Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• In a section entitled "Delay." Mr. Sloman states that "the SDFL again agreed to
accommodate Epstein's request to appear in state court for plea and sentencing on
January 4, 2008."
Id., p. 3.
The Truth:

• Curiously, Mr. Sloman fails to mention correspondence from the U.S. Attorney stating
that delay of that date would be "inevitable" as the defense has raised "serious questions"
about the propriety of the prosecution. Strikingly, in that same section, Mr. Sloman
claims that "the Agreement did not contemplate a staggered 'plea and sentencing,'"
despite quoting, three sentences earlier, from the Agreement's staggered requirement
that Epstein plead and be sentenced by October 26, and "begin serving his sentence not
later than January 4, 2008."

• • •
We are, like most attorneys seeking Department review, without access to the USAO
prosecution summaries or other submissions to the Department. Given the substantial issues that
have been raised in this and other submissions, we request that you conduct a de novo review
that goes beneath the face of any conclusions being advocated by the USAO; instead, we seek a
review that is based on the transcripts of witness testimony themselves so that the reviewer can
RFP MIA 000439
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
this same individual would nevertheless be entitled to engage an attorney paid for by Mr.
Epstein to recover $150,000 of damages from Mr. Epstein under § 2255 without ever
alleging any injury. In fact, the defense was told that the only question Mr. Epstein
would be permitted to ask before paying the girls is " have you ever met Epstein.". Thus,
the Deferred Prosecution Agreement places identified individuals in a far better position
than they would be in if Mr. Epstein were convicted at trial.

9. ASSIGNMENT OF RIGHT TO SELECT LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE.
Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• "Prior to any issues arising concerning the implementation of the 2255 provision, the
SDFL unilaterally agreed to assign its responsibility to select the attorney representative
for the alleged victims to an independent third-party."
See Tab I, May 19, 2008 Letter from J. Sloman, p. 4, f.3.
The Truth:

• That such an assignment was the SDFL's "unilateral" decision is false. Before the
SDFL decided to assign selection of the "attorney representative" to an independent third
party, AUSA Marie Villafana had already proposed an "attorney representative." She
had proposed local products-liability lawyer, Humberto Ocariz, and claimed he bad been
recommended by a "good friend in the Appellate Division." Ms. Villafana's account was
misleading, as it omitted that this "good friend" was her live-in boyfriend, and that Mr.
Ocariz was his former law-school roommate. When we discovered this independently,
we objected. Only then did the SDFL propose assigning the selection process to an
independent special master and agree to amend the Deferred Prosecution Agreement.
Thus, while it may be true that the SDFL assigned its selection responsibility to avoid the
appearance of favoritism, it did not do it "unilaterally," but, rather, only after Epstein
uncovered the Office's misleading disclosure and apparent conflict-of-interest.

10. TIMETABLE FOR MOVING FORWARD.
Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• "On February 25, 2008, I sent you an e-mail setting forth a timetable for moving forward
in the event that CEOS disagreed with your position. That time is now."
Id., p. 6.
The Truth:

• Mr. Sloman provides only part of the history of this case in order to justify his improper
actions. He had stated he would close the investigation if CEOS told him to. However,
CEOS at our very first contact said that under no circumstances did they see that as their
RFP MIA 000438
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP

8. ALL IDENTIFIED VICTIMS BE PUT IN SAME POSITION AS IF EPSTEIN
HAD BEEN TRIED.
Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• "The Agreement provides for a method of compensation for the victims such that they
would be placed in the same position as if Epstein had been convicted of one of the
enumerated offenses set forth in Title 18, United States Code Section, 2255."
Id.
The Truth:

• Mr. Sloman continues to mischaracterize the highly irregular provisions of the Deferred
Prosecution Agreement. The SDFL did not merely attempt to preserve the compensation
rights of those it identified as victims; it attempted to create compensation rights for those
it identified, without imposing on them the burden of proving that they were in fact
victims under § 2255.
o In the Deferred Prosecution Agreement, the SDFL required Mr. Epstein to waive
the right to contest liability under 18 U.S.C. § 2255 as to a list of individuals that
the SDFL would not disclose to Mr. Epstein until after he was sentenced and to
pay for an attorney to secure compensation under § 2255 for those undisclosed
individuals, or if they decided to sue Mr. Epstein.
o § 2255 ordinarily provides individuals with a right to recover minimum guaranteed
damages of $150,000, without having to prove actual damages, only if: (I) they
were victims of an enumerated federal offense, including offenses under 18 U.S.C.
§§ 2422 and 2423, (2) they were minors at the time of the offense, and most
importantly (3) they were personally injured as a result of the offense.
o The defense has confirmed examples of women who testified that they were not
victims of Mr. Epstein and suffered no personal injury. These women were,
nevertheless, on the list of "victims" identified by the government. . In fact, when
confronted with the testimony of a women who denied both being a victim and
incurring personal injury, Ms. Villafana actually acknowledged such testimony.
To justify inclusion of that woman on the government's list, however, Ms.
Villafana then challenged her own witness's credibility.

• For this reason, it is false to state that these "identified" individuals are in the same
position that they would have been had Epstein been convicted at trial. Had there been a
trial, Mr. Epstein would have had a right to confront these individuals through cross-
examination. Any individual that did not establish that she was a minor victim of conduct
that satisfied each element of an enumerated statute under § 2255,or that she suffered
personal injury, would not qualify for any treatment under § 2255. However, under the
Deferred Prosecution Agreement, as an "identified individual" on the government's list,
RFP MIA 000437
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
Agreement to Defer Prosecution to the State, an agreement without precedent and fraught
with substantial practical and legal hurdles to its implementation.

6. THE SDFL DID NOT DEFER TO THE STATE.
Sloman's Letter:

• "(Tihe SDFL indicated a willingness to defer to the State the length of incarceration."
Id., p. 2.
The Truth:

• The SDFL neither deferred to the State, nor even discussed with the State, the length of

Mr. Epstein's incarceration. In a letter to the defense, Criminal Division Chief, Matthew
Menchel rejected the sentence contemplated by the State's plea agreement, writing that
"the federal interest will not be vindicated in the absence of a two-year term of state
imprisonment." See Tab 40, August 3, 2007 Email from M. Menchel. Of course, this
position is contrary to Section 9-2031D of the U.S. Attorney's Manual (indicating that
the "result" of a state prosecution is "presumefdf' to have vindicated the federal interest).
It is understandable, therefore, that Mr. Sloman might want to retreat from it now.
Indeed, the final Deferred Prosecution Agreement (DPA) restricts the state-court judge
from exercising any of his rightful discretion and to specifically prohibit the judge from
offering probation, community control or any other alternative in lieu of incarceration.
DPA, 1) 2(a).
7. SUGGESTION OF ADDITIONAL STATE PLEA
Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• The parties considered: "as suggested by [the defense], a plea to state charges
encompassing Epstein's conduct." See Tab 1, May 19, 2008 Letter from J. Sloman, p.2,
1 2.
The Truth:

• It was the government, and not the defense, that suggested a plea to state charges to
resolve the federal investigation. Andrew Lourie proposed declining prosecution in favor
of the state. Although Mr. Epstein and the State Attorney's Office had already reached
a plea agreement, in August 2007, Mr. Sloman and AUSA Marie Villafana warned that
they intended to prosecute Epstein federally unless his counsel (i.e., not the U.S.
Attorney's Office) sought more stringent conditions to the State's proposed plea
agreement. These stringent conditions included, among other things, the two-year prison
term demanded by Mr. Menchel (discussed above) and a charge requiring him to register
as a sex offender.
RFP MIA 000436
•
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
describes the additional charge to which Mr. Epstein is required to plead guilty
under the Deferred Prosecution Agreement as "procurement of minors to engage
in prostitution" or "solicitation of minors to engage in prostitution." The former
is an offense for which Mr. Epstein would be required to register, but one for
which the state has no evidence to charge Mr. Epstein and the SDFL refuses or is
unable to provide evidence that it claims it has. The latter requires no
registration, but it is the offense which, over and over again, Ms. Villafana
insisted upon including in the Deferred Prosecution Agreement, and is one which
the State believes is appropriate. The inconsistency between the description of
the offense required by the SDFL, the elements of an offense that can be justified
on the facts of this case and the SDFL's requirement that the offense be a
registrable one has created substantial confusion.
o As a result of this confusion, in December 2007, both the defense and the state
requested that the SDFL provide the factual allegations to enable Mr. Epstein and
the State to create a truthful factual recitation of a registrable offense required by
the Deferred Prosecution Agreement, but, to date, the SDFL has failed to do so
without any explanation.

• Mr. Sloman refuses to provide the requested factual allegations, which the State cannot
furnish, and now demands a two week deadline to comply. Thus Mr. Sloman has
unreasonably imposed a deadline with which he himself has made it impossible for Mr.
Epstein to comply.
5. WAIVER OF APPEAL TO ASSISTANT ATTORNEY GENERAL FISHER.
Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• "[T]he SDFL provided you with 30 days to appeal the decision to the Assistant Attorney
General of the United States Alice Fisher" and "you chose to forego an appeal to AAG
Fisher."
Id., p. 2.
The Truth:

• Mr. Acosta tolled an August 17 deadline, acknowledging that there were "serious issues"
about the case that needed to be discussed, and scheduled a meeting with the defense for
September 7, 2007. At the September 7, 2007 meeting, with Drew Oosterbaan in
attendance, the government dismissed the defense's objections and set a September 21,
2007 deadline to finalize a non-prosecution agreement or the defense would face an
already-drafted 53-page indictment, purportedly identifying 40 minors, with a guideline
range of 188 months.

• Facing Ms. Villafana's threatened draconian indictment, without the claimed offer of the
right to raise objections in an appeal to AAG Fisher, the defense chose to negotiate an
RFP MIA 000435
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
evidence that Mr. Epstein routinely and daily receives massages from adults. Only a
small percentage of the masseuses turned out to be minors. The majority of those minors
interviewed by law enforcement admitted to lying directly to Epstein about their ages
(not "unbeknownst to Epstein"), and inventing further false details to substantiate their
lies. Indeed, the civil attorney for several of these women admitted at his recent press
conference that they lied to Mr. Epstein about their ages. Numerous witnesses testified
that Mr. Epstein asked that all masseuses be over the age of 18. Further, the evidence is
undisputed that Mr. Epstein's assistants scheduled the massages and Mr. Epstein did not
know which masseuses his assistants had scheduled on a particular day, until the massage
took place. We admitted that there was sexual conduct, and argued—not that it was
"innocuous" as Mr. Sloman alleges—but that it was mostly Mr. Epstein's own self-
pleasuring, which did not satisfy the requisite federal element of criminal sexual conduct
(which is, in turn, defined by state law). These are important distinctions and show that

Mr. Sloman has misrepresented the record about the most basic part of our defense.
4. SLOMAN DEMANDS AN UNREALISTIC DEADLINE TO COMPLY WITH AN
AGREEMENT HE UNILATERALLY MODIFIES.

Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• "Unless [Mr. Epstein] complies with all of the terms and conditions of the [Deferred
Prosecution] Agreement, as modified by the United States Attorney's December 19,
2007 letter to Ms. Sanchez by close of business on Monday, June 2, 2008, the SDFL will
elect to terminate the Agreement." Id., p.1
The Truth:

• The Deferred Prosecution Agreement was never modified by U.S. Attorney Acosta's
December 19, 2007 letter. Oddly, Mr. Sloman acknowledges this on page 4 of his May
19 letter, where he writes that Mr. Acosta "proposed" this modification and that "[Mr.
Lefkowitz] rejected these proposals." Thus, Mr. Sloman is threatening to terminate the
Deferred Prosecution Agreement, unless Mr. Epstein complies with a unilateral
modification that Mr. Sloman concedes was never agreed to by defense counsel.

• Orchestrating the information, plea and sentencing requirements of the Deferred
Prosecution Agreement within the extremely limited two-week timeframe imposed by
Mr. Sloman's June 2, 2008 deadline would have been difficult enough.

• More importantly, as explained below, the SDFL has refused to provide the defense with
information it requires to enable Mr. Epstein to comply with the additional plea and
sentencing requirements of the Deferred Prosecution Agreement (let alone, by the June 2
deadline arbitrarily imposed by Mr. Sloman).
o The Deferred Prosecution Agreement requires Mr. Epstein to plead guilty to and
be sentenced for an additional offense which requires that he be registered as a
sex offender. In different places in his May 19, 2008 letter, Mr. Sloman
RFP MIA 000434
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
See Tab I, May 19, 2008 Letter from J. Sloman, p. 4, 1 1.
The Truth:

• The defense engaged in days of negotiation and made 14 separate substantive objections
to the unprecedented notification letter that Mr. Sloman threatened to send to an
undisclosed list of "victims." The eventual transmission of this highly misleading letter
was only halted by an appeal to AAG Fisher. Among those substantive objections
(which related to far more than the "time and place" of the state's sentencing hearing)
were:
o Sending the letter would contravene the government's commitment to take no
position regarding potential claims of government witnesses. See Tab 39,
November 28, 2008 Email from J. Lefkowitz to J. Sloman.
o The letter cited to an inapplicable statute (the Justice for All Act of 2004) as its
justification for being sent. Id. AUSA Acosta later conceded that the citation to
this statute as a justification was wholly incorrect.
o The letter wrongly advised all recipients that Mr. Epstein would be required to
register as "a sexual predator for the remainder of this life."
o The letter amounted to an invitation to civil litigation against Mr. Epstein,
advising recipients that they had the right to seek civil damages from Mr. Epstein,
and in an underlined instruction, stated that if they chose an attorney other than
the one chosen by the government they would be required to pay his fees, but if
they chose the government's choice, Mr. Epstein would be required to pay the
fees.
3. MISCIIARACEERIZATION OF OUR ARGUMENTS.
Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• Mr. Sloman's letter misleadingly characterizes our substantive defense of the
government's investigation as, "the investigation merely produced evidence of relatively
innocuous sexual conduct with some minors who, unbeknownst to Mr. Epstein,
misrepresented their ages."
See Tab I, May 19, 2008 Letter from J. Sloman, p. 2.
The Truth:

• We never made such a claim. To the contrary, we argued that sworn statements we have
taken of the alleged victims demonstrate that law enforcement has presented versions of
their testimony that are necessarily sensationalized and fictionalized. We presented
RFP MIA 000433
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
■ The defense immediately raised concerns regarding the non-independence
of the review when told that it would be Mr. Oosterbaan tasked with
providing the review, but was told that when Mr. Oosterbaan rendered his
prior opinion, "he was not really up to speed on the facts"
o CEOS' review was not de novo:

• By letter dated May 15, 2008 (four days before Mr. Sloman's letter), Mr.
Oosterbaan advised Mr. Lefkowitz that CEOS reviewed the matter only
for abuse of discretion:
alhe question we sought to answer was whether U.S.
Attorney Acosta would abuse his discretion if he
authorized prosecution in this case.
See Tab 38, May 15, 2008 Letter from D. Oosterbaan, p. I (emphasis
added). See also, id., p. 2 ("Mr. Acosta would not be abusing his
discretion if he decided to pursue such a course of action.'); and p. 5
("Mr. Acosta would not be abusing his prosecutorial discretion should he
authorized federal prosecution of Mr. Epstein.").

• For the factual record of its "abuse of discretion" review, CEOS relied on
the very same prosecution memo that it had already reviewed in rendering
its prior opinion, stating:
As you know, our review of this case is limited, both factually and
legally. We have not looked at the entire universe of facts in this
case.
See Id., p. 1 (emphasis added).

• Nor did CEOS review any facts related to the irregular provisions in the
Deferred Prosecution Agreement or the numerous complaints of
prosecutorial misconduct, both of which are inextricably intertwined with
the impropriety of the investigation. Id. at 1.

2. NOTIFICATION OF WITNESSES.
Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• Mr. Sloman dismissed the totality of the defense's objections to the inappropriate
notification the SDFL proposed to send to its witnesses, stating merely that:
"[Y]ou objected to victims['] being notified of time and place of Epstein's
stateNcourt sentencing hearing."
RFP MIA 000432
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
Response to Letter by FAUSA Sloman Dated May 19, 2008
In a May 19, 2008 letter to Jay Lelkowitz (See Tab I), SDFL First Assistant U.S.
Attorney Jeffrey Sloman provided what purported to be a summary of the events that have
occurred during the investigation of Mr. Epstein. Mr. Sloman's letter is fraught with
inconsistencies, false and misleading characterizations and outright falsehoods. The comparison
below between the false assertions in Mr. Sloman's letter and what actually transpired is only the
tip of the iceberg. We respectfully submit that Mr. Sloman's letter alone demonstrates the
degree to which the record of facts have been distorted and these distortions have permeated this
unprecedented investigation.
1. "INDEPENDENT" AND "DE NOVO" REVIEW.
Mr. Sloman's Letter:

• "[W]e obliged your request for an independent de novo review of the investigation and
facilitated such review at the highest levels of the Department of Justice. " Tab 1, May
19, 2008 Letter from J. Sloman, p. 5, 1 3.
The Truth:

• CEOS' review, concluded in May 2008, was neither independent nor de novo.
o CEOS' review was not "independent:"

• Drew Oosterbaan, who conducted the review on behalf of CEOS, had
already reviewed the prosecution memo on this matter eight months
earlier. During a meeting with defense counsel at the United States
Attorney's Office in Miami (the "USAO") in September of 2007, he
opined that he so believed in the prosecution that he "would try the case
myself"

• Indeed, Mr. Sloman acknowledges that Mr. Oosterbaan had previously
opined on this matter, stating:
This particular attack on this statute [18 U.S.C. § 2242(b))
had been previously raised and thoroughly considered and
rejected by . . . CEOS prior to the execution of the
[Deferred Prosecution] Agreement [in September 2007].
Id., p. 5 (emphasis added).
• The statute Mr. Sloman referred to (§ 2422(b)) lies at the heart of the
Epstein investigation. Thus, according to Mr. Sloman, Mr. Oosterbaan
was tasked with reviewing his own prior decision regarding applying the
key statute under which the SDFL proposed prosecuting Mr. Epstein.
Exhibit B-37
RFP MIA 000431
Gmail - Fw: confidential communication Page 4 of 4
Letter from CEOS.TIF
360K
Gmail - Fw: confidential communication Page 3 of 4
deliberately lied about their age because they knew Mr. Epstein did not want anyone under 18
in his house directly undercuts the claim that Mr. Epstein willfully blinded himself as to their
ages. Willful blindness is not a substitute for evidence of knowledge nor is it a negligence
standard. It requires proof beyond reasonable doubt of deliberate intent and specific action to
hide one's knowledge. There is absolutely no such evidence of that here, so it is not even a jury
issue. Furthermore, willful ignorance cannot constitute the required mens rea for a crime of
conspiracy or aiding and abetting.
Through the recent witness statements, we have also discovered another serious issue that
implicates the integrity of the federal investigation. We have learned that FBI Special Agent
Kurkendayl attempted to convince these adult women, now in their twenties, that they were in
fact "victims" even though the women themselves strongly disagreed with this characterization.
This conduct, once again, goes to the heart of the integrity of the investigation. Ina sworn
statement, Ms. was highly critical of the overreaching by federal law enforceMent officers
in this case. She testified—in no uncertain terms—that she does not, and never did, feel like a
"victim," despite the fact that the FBI repeatedly tried to convince her otherwise.
I am mindful of the fact that we have a state court date of July 8 on which either to enter a plea
or to commence trial. As I review the trial options with Mr. Epstein, I certainly want to make sure
I do everything within my power to obviate a need for trial through a reasonable alternative
resolution. Although it is clear that CEOS is not directing a prosecution here, and has stated
only that you have the authority to commence such a prosecution, I am well aware that the
decision whether to proceed, subject to any further process in Washington, is now within your
discretion. I think the new facts should greatly influence your decision and accordingly, I hope
you will agree to meet with me, both to discuss the new evidence and to discuss .a resolution to
this matter once and for all: I am available to meet with you at your earliest convenience
subject to our mutual availability.
Respectfully,
Jay._
****** ***** ************ ***** ** **** tr**** ************* ** *****
The information contained in this communication is
confidential, may be attorney-client privileged, may
constitute inside information, and is intended only for
the use of the addressee. It is the property of
Kirkland & Ellis LLP or Kirkland & Ellis International LLP.
Unauthorized use, disclosure or copying of this
communication or any part thereof is strictly prohibited
and may be unlawful. If you have received this
communication in error, please notify us immediately by
• returrie-mail or by e-mail to postmaster@kirkland.com, and
destroy this communication and all copies thereof,
including all attachments.
Gmail - Fw: confidential communication Page 2 of 4
paragraph, that he cannot conclude that a prosecution by you in this case "would be an abuse
of discretion" is hardly an endorsement that you move forward.
Moreover, as you know, Drew made clear that the scope of his review did not extend to the
other significant issues we have raised with you, such as the undo interest by some members of
your staff with the financial and civil aspects of this matter, or with the inappropriate discussion
one member of your Office had with a Senior reporter at the New York Times. (In fact, I have
met with that reporter and have reviewed copious notes of his conversation with Mr. Weinstein).
At this stage, we have no alternative but to raise our serious concerns regarding the issues
Drew refused to address with the Deputy or, if necessary, the Attorney General, because we
believe those issues have significantly impacted the investigation and any recommendation by
your staff to proceed with an indictment. That being said, it would obviously be much more
constructive and efficient if we could resolve this matter directly with you in the advance of
further proceedings in Washington.
Because it is clear that national policy, as determined by Main Justice, is not driving this case,
the resolution of this matter is squarely, and solely, your responsibility. I know you want to do
the right thing, and it is because you have made clear to me on several occasions that you will
always look at all of the relevant and material fads that I call the following to your attention.
New information that has come to light strongly suggests that the facts of this case cannot
possibly implicate a federal prosecutorial priority. Due to established state procedures and
following the initiation of multiple civil lawsuits, Mr. Epstein's counsel was able to take limited
discovery of certain women in this matter. The sworn statements provided by these women all
confirm that federal prosecution is not appropriate in this case.
The consistent re resentations of witnesses such as lain
and the civil complainants and their attorneys, con irm e
ollowing key points: First, t ere was no telephonic communication iliet the requirements of
§ 2422(b). For example, as many other witnesses have stated, Ms. testified in no unclear
terms that there was never any discussion over the phone about her coming over to Mr.
_.._____Epstein's home to engage in sexual activity: "The only thing that ever.occurredmi any of these_
phone calls [with Sarah Kellen or another assistant] as 'Are you willing to come over,' or,
'Would you like to come over and give a massage." Tr. A at 15. Second, the underage
women who visited Mr. Epstein have testified that they lie about their age in order to gain
admittance into his home and women who brought t nderage friends to Mr. Epstein
counseled them to lie about their ages as well. Ms. stated the following: "I would tell my
girlfriends just likelailliapproached me. Make sure you tell him you're 18. Well, these girls
that I brought, I know that they were 18 or 19 or 20. And the girls that I didn't knoll" I don't
know if they were lying or not, I would say' make sure that you tell him you're 18." Tr. at

22. Third, there was no routine or habit suggesting an intent to transform a massage into an
illegal sexual act. For instance, Ms. stated that Mr. Epstein "never touched [her]
phy ' and that all she did was "massage[ ] his back, his chest and his thighs and that was
it." Tr. at 12-13. Finally, as you are well aware, there was no force, coercion, fraud,
violence, rugs, or even alcohol present in connection with Mr. Epstein's encounters with these
women.
The civil suits confirm that the plaintiffs did not discuss engaging in sexually-related activities
with anyone prior to arriving at Mr. Epstein's residence. This reinforces the fact that no
telephonic or Internet persuasion, inducement, enticement or coercion of any kind occurred.
Furthermore, Mr. Herman, the attorney for most of the civil complainants, was quoted in the.
Palm Beach Post as saying that "it doesn't matter" that his clients lied about their ages and told
Mr. Epstein that they were 18 or 19. In short, the new evidence establishing that the women
Gmail - Fw: confidential communication Page 1 of 4
sil Ann Marie Villafana<
Fw: confidential communication
1 message
Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS) < Ann.Marie.C.Villafana@usdoj.gov> Thu, May 22, 2008 at
3:38 AM
Original Message
From: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
To: Sloman, Jeff (USAFLS); Campos, Cyndee (USAFLS); Villafana, Ann Marie C. (USAFLS)
Sent: Mon May 19 12:40:32 2008
Subject: FW: confidential communication
For your records.
From: Jay Lefkowitz [mailto:JLefkowitz@kirkland.com]
Sent: Monday, May 19, 2008 10:54 AM
To: Acosta, Alex (USAFLS)
Subject: confidential communication
Dear Alex:
I am writing to you because I have just received the attached letter from Drew Oosterbaan. In
light of that letter, and given the critical new evidence discussed below, I would like to request a
meeting with you, mindful of our July 8 deadline, at your earliest opportunity. Given your
personal involvement in this matter to date, and the fact that at this juncture it is clear that
CEOS has referred the matter back to you, I respectfully request that you not shunt me off to
one of your staff. You and I have both spent a great deal of time on this matter, and I know that
we both would like to resolve this matter in a way that bestows integrity both on the Department
and the process.
In our prior discussions, you expressed that you were "not unsympathetic" to our various
federalism concerns, but stated that because you serve within the "unitary Executive," you.
believed your hands were tied by Main Justice. You were also extremely gracious in stating that
you did not want the United States to be "unfair". Although CEOS limited its assessment to the
federal statutes your Office had brought forth and to the application of th6se laws to the facts as
presented, it is abundantly clear from Drew's letter that Main Justice is not directing this
prosecution. In fact, CEOS plainly acknowledged that a federal prosecution of Mr. Epstein
would involve a "novel application" of federal statutes and that our arguments against federal
involvement are "compelling." Moreover, the language used by Drew in his concluding
EXHIBIT 6-36
JAY P. LEFKOWITZ, ESQ.
May 19, 2008
PAGE 6 OF 6
Conclusion
On February 25, 2008,1 sent you an e-mail setting forth a timetable for moving forward in
the event that CEOS disagreed with your position. That time is now. As you know, my February 25'
email stated that I would give you one week to comply with the terms and conditions of the
Agreement, as modified by the USA's December Irletter to Ms. Sanchez. In light of the upcoming
Memorial Day weekend, I have decided to extend that timetable to the close of business on Monday,
June 2, 2008, which is a full two weeks.
Sincerely,

R. Alexander Acosta
United States Attorney
By:
Jeffrey H. Sloman
First Assistant United States Attorney
cc: R. Alexander Acosta
United States Attorney

A. Marie Villafana
Assistant U.S. Attorney
Karen Atkinson
Assistant U.S. Attorney
JAY P. LEFKOWITZ, ESQ.
May 19, 2008
PAGE 5 OF 6

C. "Mr. Epstein Does Not Believe He Is Guilty Of The Federal Charges Enumerated
Under Section 2255."
At our December 14, 2007 meeting at the U.S. Attorney's Office in Miami, counsel for
Epstein announced, inter alia, that it was a "profound injustice" to require Epstein to register as a
sex offender and reiterated that no federal crime, especially 18 U.S.C. Section 2422(6), had been
committed since the statute is only violated if a telephone or means of interstate commerce is used
to do the persuading or inducing. This particular attack on this statute had been previously raised and
thoroughly considered and rejected by the SDFL and CEOS prior to the execution of the Agreement.
You also argued that the facts were inapplicable to the contemplated state statutes and that Epstein
should not have been allowed to have been induced into the Agreement because the facts were not
what he understood them to be, It should be noted that the SDFL has never provided you with any
evidence supportig its investigation. This is not, and has never been, an Alford plea situation (see
North Carolina Alford, 400 U.S. 25, 91 S.Ct. 160 (1970)). Ultimately, you requested an
independent review.
Subsequent to the above-mentioned meeting, the SDFL received three letters from you and/or

Mr. Starr which expanded on some of the themes announced in the December 14th meeting.
Essentially, you portrayed the SDFL as trying to coerce a plea to unknown allegations and incoherent
theories. On December 17, 2007, you decreed that Epstein's conduct did not meet the requirements
of solicitation of minors to engage in prostitution (Fl. Stat. Section 796.03) one of the enumerated
crimes Epstein had previously agreed to plead guilty to; that Epstein's conduct does not require
registration under Florida law; and the State Attorney's Office does not believe the conduct is
registrable. On December 21, 2007, you rejected the USA's proposed resolution of the 2255
provision because you "strongly believe that the provable conduct of Mr. Epstein with respect to
these individuals fails to satisfy the requisite elements of either 18 U.S.C. Section[s] 2422(b) ... or
2423(b)." In your December 26, 2007 correspondence you stated that "we have reiterated in
previous submissions that Mr. Epstein does not believe he is guilty of the federal charges enumerated
under section 2255" and requiring "Mr. Epstein to in essence admit guilt, though he believes he did
not commit the requisite offense."
As the SDFL has reiterated time and time again, it does not want, nor does it expect, Epstein
to plead guilty to a charge he does not believe he committed. As a result, we obliged your request
for an independent de novo review of the investigation and facilitated such a review at the highest
levels of the Department of Justice. It is our understanding that that independent review is now
complete and a determination has been made that there are no impediments to a federal prosecution
by the SDFL.
JAY P. LEFKOWITZ, ESQ.
May 19, 2008
PAGE 4 OF 6
B. Method of Compensation and Notification.
During this same time period, you and others, including the former Solicitor General of the
United States Kenneth Starr, took issue with the implementation of the methodology of
compensation (hereinafter "the 2255 provision")) and the SDFL's intention to notify the victims
under 18 U.S.C. Section 3771 (you objected to victims being notified of time and place of Epstein's
state court sentencing hearing). In response, the SDFL offered, in my opinion, numerous and various
reasonable modifications and accommodations which ultimately resulted in United States Attorney
IL Alexander Acosta's December 19, 2007 letter to Lilly Ann Sanchez. In that letter, the United
States Attorney tried to eliminate all concerns which, quite frankly, the SDFL was not obligated to
address, let alone consider. He proposed the following language regarding the 2255 provision:
C
"Any person, who while a minor, was a victim of a violation of an offense enumerated in
Title 18, United States Code, Section 2255, will have the same rights to proceed under

Section 2255 as she would have had, if Mr. Epstein been tried federally and convicted of an
enumerated offense. For purposes of implementing this paragraph, the United States shall
provide Mr. Epstein's attorneys with a list of individuals whom it was prepared to name in
an Indictment as victims of an enumerated offense by Mr. Epstein. Any judicial authority
interpreting this provision, including any authority determining which evidentiary burdens
if any a plaintiff must meet, shall consider that it is the intent of the parties to place these
identified victims in the same position as they would have been had Mr. Epstein been
convicted at trial. No more; no less."
Regarding the issue of notice to the victims, USA Acosta proposed to notify them of the
federal resolution as required by law; however, "[w]e will defer to the discretion of the State
Attorney regarding whether he wishes to provide victims with notice of the state proceedings,
although we will provide him with the information necessary to do so if he wishes." As you know,
you rejected these proposals as well. See December 26, 2007 correspondence from Jay Lefkowitz
to USA Acosta.
3 Prior to any issues arising concerning the implementation of the 2255 provision, the SDFL
unilaterally agreed to assign its responsibility to select the attorney representative for the alleged victims
to an independent third-party. This was done to avoid even the appearance of favoritism in the selection
of the attorney representative. As a result, on October 29, 2007, the parties executed an Addendum
wherein it was mutually agreed that former States District Court Judge Edward B. would
serve as the independent third-party. Judge selected the venerable law firm of Podh r nd
Josefsberg to represent the approximately 34 a eged identified victims.
JAY P. LEFKOWITZ, ESQ.
May 19, 2008
PAGE 3 OF 6
of the guilty plea and sentence no later than October 26, 2007; and (5) the start of the above-
mentioned sentence no later than January 4, 2008.
Furthermore, and significantly, Epstein agreed that he had the burden of ensuring compliance
of the Agreement with the Palm Beach County State Attorney's Office and the Judge of the 15*
Judicial Circuit and "that the failure to do so will be a breach of the agreement" (emphasis added).
Post-Execution of the Agreement
Within weeks of the execution of the Agreement, you sought to delay the entry of Epstein's
guilty plea and sentence. After the SDFL agreed to accommodate your request, counsel for Epstein
began taking issue with the methodology of compensation, notification to the victims, and the issues
that had been previously considered and 'ejected during negotiations, i.e., that the conduct does not
require registration and the contemplated state and federal statutes have no applicability to the instant
matter.
A. Delay.
The Agreement required that "Epstein shall use his best efforts to enter his guilty plea and
be sentenced not later than October 26, 2007. The United States has no objection to Epstein self-
reporting to begin serving his sentence not later than January 4, 2008." Agreement, pages 4-5,
paragraph I 1 (emphasis added). After the Agreement was executed, the SDFL accommodated your
request to extend the October 26th plea deadline to November 20'° based upon, what seemed to be,
reasonable scheduling conflict issues.' By early November, you represented that the presiding state
court judge would not "stagger the plea and sentencing as contemplated in the Agreement."Although
the Agreement clearly did not contemplate a staggered "plea and sentencing," the SDFL again agreed
to accommodate Epstein's request to appear in state court for plea and sentencing on January 4,
2008.2
I "Accordingly, I have now confirmed with Mr. Epstein's Florida counsel that the state's
attomey's office and the court will be available to have him enter his plea on November 20. So we will
plan to proceed on one that date." October 18, 2007 email from Jay Lefkowitz to USA R. Alexander
Acosta.
On the same day, Mr. Lefkowitz confirmed with First Assistant Jeffrey H. Sloman that this
postponement " will not affect when Epstein begins serving his sentence."
2 Correspondence from Jay Lefkowitz to FAUSA Sloman dated November 8, 2007 ("the judge
has invited the parties to appear for the plea and sentencing on January 4*, we do not anticipate any delay
beyond that date.")
JAY P. LEFKOWITZ, ESQ.
May 19, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 6
Background
The Agreement was the product of months of negotiations. Specifically, you requested and
received numerous meetings, at the highest levels of the SDFL and DOJ's Child Exploitation and
Obscenity Section (CEOS) concerning claims that (a) the investigation merely produced evidence
of relatively innocuous sexual conduct with some minors who, unbeknownst to Epstein,
misrepresented their ages; (b) the authorities investigating Epstein engaged in misconduct; (c) the
contemplated federal statutes have no applicability to this matter; and (d) the federal authorities
disregarded the fundamental policy against federal intervention with state criminal proceedings.
After careful review, the SDFL ultimately rejected those claims. Subsequent to its decision, however,
but before proceeding any further, the SDFL provided you with 30 days to appeal the decision to the
Assistant Attorney General of the United States, Alice Fisher. As you recall, you chose to forego an
appeal to AAG Fisher, and instead pursued a negotiated resolution which, ultimately, resulted in the
execution of the Agreement.
The Negotiation Phase
During negotiations, you tried to avoid a resolution that called for incarceration and
registration as a sexual offender — both of which would be triggered by a successful federal
prosecution. The SDFL believed and continues to believe that should this matter proceed to trial,
your client would be convicted of the federal statutes identified in the Agreement. In order to achieve
a global resolution, the SDFL indicated a willingness to defer to the State the length of incarceration;
however, it remained adamant that Epstein register as a sex offender and that all victims identified
during the investigation remain eligible for compensation. In order to achieve this result, the parties
considered two alternatives, a plea to federal charges that limited Epstein's sentencing exposure, or,
as suggested by you, a plea to state charges encompassing Epstein's conduct. Ultimately, the parties
agreed to, inter cilia, a plea to the state charges outlined in the Agreement, registration and a method
of compensation.
The Agreement
The crux of the Agreement defers in favor of the State federal prosecution of Epstein for his
sexual conduct involving those minor victims identified as of September 24, 2007, in exchange for
a guilty plea to a state offense that requires registration as a sex offender; a sufficient term of
imprisonment; and a method of compensation for the victims such that they would be placed in the
same position as if Epstein had been convicted of one of the enumerated offenses set forth in Title
18, United States Code, Section 2255. Specifically, the Agreement mandates, inter cilia, (1) a guilty
plea in Palm Beach County Circuit Court to solicitation of prostitution (Fl. Stat. Section 796.07) and
procurement of minors to engage in prostitution (Fl. Stat. Section 796.03) (an offense that requires
him to register as a sex offender); (2) a 30-month sentence including 18 months' incarceration in
county jail; (3) a methodology to compensate the victims identified by the United States; (4) entry
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
Fern Assistant U.S. Attorney
DELIVERY BY FACSIMILE
Jay P. Lefkowitz, Esq.
Kirkland & Ellis LLP
Citigroup Center
153 East 53rd Street
New York, New York 10022-4675
Re: Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Mr. Lefkowitz,
99 N.E. 4 Street
Miami. FL 33132
On 961.9110
May 19, 2008
I am in receipt of your e-mail dated May 19, 2008 to the United States Attorney. The U.S.
Attorney would like me to advise you that all communications and inquiries related to the Epstein
matter, will be handled by AUSA Marie Villafana and/or her supervisor, Karen Atkinson, so he does
not intend to respond to your e-mail or calls unless AUSA Villafana and/or her supervisors advise
him otherwise. Furthermore, you make reference to "our July 8 deadline." Respectfully, the United
States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida ("SDFL") has never agreed to any such
deadline. Should you decide to provide the SDFL with any additional information, please do so
through AUSA Villafana, and, in her absence, AUSA Atkinson.
On September 24, 2007, your client, Jeffrey Epstein, in consultation with Gerald Lefcoun,
Esq. and Lilly Ann Sanchez, Esq., as well as numerous other nationally-renowned lawyers, including
but not limited to Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz, former Independent Counsel and
Solicitor General of the United States Kenneth Starr, just to name a few, entered into a global
resolution of state and federal liabilities faced by your client ("the Agreement") with the SDFL.
Although you and other members of the defense team have since claimed that the Agreement was
the product of adhesion, the following facts demonstrate that Epstein knowingly and voluntarily
entered into the Agreement in order to avoid a federal indictment regarding his sexual conduct
involving minor victims. Despite the fact that by signing the Agreement, Epstein gave up the right
to object to its provisions, the SDFL bent over backwards to exhaustively consider and re-consider
your objections. Since these objections have finally been exhausted and Epstein has previously
expressed his intent to not comply with several of the terms and conditions of the Agreement as set
forth below, the SDFL hereby notifies you that unless he complies with all of the terms and
conditions of the Agreement, as modified by the United States Attorney's December 19, 2007 letter
to Ms. Sanchez by close of business on Monday, June 2, 2008, the SDFL will elect to terminate the
Agreement.
05/19/08 MON 15:50 FAX 305 530 6440 EXECUTIVE OFFICE IiM001
TRANSMISSION OK
********smss*******
*s* TX REPORT *as
4444441:4444**********
TX/RX NO 3494
CONNECTION TEL 912124464900
SUBADDRESS
CONNECTION ID

ST. TIME 05/19 15:47
USAGE T 03'03
PGS. 7
RESULT OK
U.S. Department of Justice
United Stoles Attorney
Southern District of Florida
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
99 NE 4" STREET
MIAMI, FLORIDA 33132-2111
Jeffrey H. Sloman
First Assistant U.S. Attorney
305 961 9299
Cyndee Campos
Staff Assistant
305 961 9461
305 530-6444 fax
FACSIMILE TRANSMISSION
COVER SHEET
DATE: May 19, 2008
TO: Jay P. Lefkowitz, Esquire
FAX NUMBER:
SUBJECT: Epstein
NUMBER OF PAGES, INCLUDING THIS PAGE: 7
EFTA00210074 (Jmail)
 [legal] letter from Kirkland & Ellis to SDFL
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                                                 Mark Zeff [arts] MARKZEFF, interior designer (???) 
                                                                       Emma Sergeant [girls] painter introduced to Ghislaine by Robert Hanson [bbc] 
                                                                                                                    R. Couri Hay [publicist] PR (?) 
      Svetlana Pozhidaeva aka Sophia Platt [russian girl] Epstein assistant, FSB feeder school (MGIMO) student, visa recommended by Sergey Belyakov 
                                                                                                          (FSB) & David Blaine [newsground/dossier] 
                                                                                             Bill Gates [tech] ex-Microsoft, Gates Foundation, bgC3 
                                                                     MySpace [tech] early social media, Epstein's creeptastic account data was lost 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00177459 (Jmail)
 [legal] letter from SDFL to Robert Josefsberg with victim notifications, Palm Beach police investigation, affidavit
╔════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Steven Pinker [harvard] psychology professor [buzzfeednews] 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00727491 (Jmail)
 [legal] Darren Indyke memo about Epstein whining that his highly paid lawyers couldn't get him off
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                                  Florida Science Foundation [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                                                            Alberto Pinto [employee] interior designer 
                                                                       Linda Pinto [employee] interior design at Alberto Pinto Cabinet 
                                                                  Valdson Vieira Cotrin [employee] Paris driver, annual trip to Brasil 
                                                   Glenn Dubin [finance] Highbridge Capital Management, married to Epstein's ex-gf Eva 
 Jennie Saunders [friend] co-founder of Core Club, Dangene and Jennie Enterprise, accused of recruiting underage girls [crainsnewyork] 
                                                      Paul G. Cassell [victim lawyer] professor at University of Utah, victim advocate 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01099834 (Jmail)
 [legal] letter from Brad Edwards to DOJ filed in Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States (multiple letters)
EFTA00008417 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2008-10-20)
.; • 5.1222 Request10 112048 1832 08112/2319 NYCO22211. PC Derivative Coni One cl) Seagate Barroomla 102008 MOO, 
ST1000OM003, SIN W1O3826E. containing ttitt Clone Copy o4 1812 hard
ague (Seagate Constellation FS fOOGP HOD St5ClNt.4OO11 Srm 21#4,110': 'ad via 1x-1 ;'N OODFC,  •
'V. •
JR • . •
,
r r  ... * • a
• • .
• ••
• 1 .
••• t qi . 4. li  • •
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                            Adam Bly [journalist] editor of SEED magazine 
                                   Jackie Perczek [lawyer] Epstein criminal defense attorney on 2008 case 
              Jessica Cadwell [lawyer] paralegal to Robert D. Critton Jr. whom Epstein appears to recruit 
                                                                  Michael J. Pike [lawyer] Epstein lawyer 
                                                 Robert D. Critton Jr. [lawyer] criminal defense attorney 
 Chris Poole aka "moot" [tech] founder of 4chan, the discussion board where QAnon originated [4chan/wiki] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00223149 (Jmail)
 [legal] letter from Roy Black to SDFL non-prosecution agreement and more
EFTA00000001 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2009-01-19)
DATE ___17-/_ 42-/
CASE ID ReA 412Y 19 --- -1----
9e_a_St
PHOTOGRAPHER
LOCATION
- FBI

╭─── Page 1, Image 1 ────╮
│ a Lato 19              │
│ 3IE-NY- 303757         │
│                        │
│ CASE ID                │
│                        │
│ PHOTOGRAPHER ee        │
│ LOCATION i] East VW —— │
│ New Yor, AY            │
╰────────────────────────╯
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                  Bella Klein [russian girl] one of Epstein's accountants, from Russia 
 Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler [victim lawyer] shady law firm, Rothstein ran $1.2 billion Ponzi scheme & was Roger Stone's partner [wiki] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00727684 (Jmail)
 [legal] <REDACTED> v. Jeffrey Epstein: sworn testimony, list of co-conspirators
EFTA00210921 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in Jane Doe #2 v. Jeffrey Epstein
EFTA01107189 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in Jane Doe #2 v. Jeffrey Epstein
EFTA00002698 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2009-06-04)
Little St. James Island
Cabanas, Pavilions, Pool & Screening Room
mss-  - •
!ice
!'"
06/04/2009 Y.' c- Development Progress Package
ant' part selection & planting plan
Ron -n r,niShCS
e, re'r • ,
it
—.oak
mei  CA 90405
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                           Jeepers Inc. [epstein] Epstein company (children's amusement park) [x] 
 D.B. Zwirn [finance] hedge fund manager whose fund collapsed in 2008 with investments from Epstein and Glenn Dubin [bbg/reuters] 
                                                   D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund [finance] hedge fund that failed in 2008 
                         Clifford Chance [law firm] law firm where Maria Prusakova (and Miranda Mako?) did an internship in Paris 
                                                           HBRK Associates [lawyer] Richard Kahn's company, managed Epstein money 
                                                                            David Boies [victim lawyer] Boies Schiller Flener LLP 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01166616 (Jmail)
 [money] many emails about Jeepers, Inc., Financial Trust Company, D.B. Zwirn, etc. in rough format showing Harry Beller working for Epstein
(approximate date: 2009-07-01)
To: Hubsher, Else From Lee, David Notes: Tax advisor, was just forwarding fyl --Original Message--- Front Hubsher, Elbe 
Sent: Wednesday, December 06, 2006 6:39
PM To: Lee, David Subject: Re: Jeffrey When are they in and who do we want them to meet? How much the ------Sent bunny 
bad:Berry Wireless Device --- OrIgInal
Message Front Lee, David To: Cutler, Lawrence D.: Hubsher. Else Sent: Wed Der n6 18:01:43 2006 Subject: FW: Jeffrey
Redacted for Privilege
March 26, 2009 D.B.Zwlrn Special Opportunitlairgald ,LP.- Quarterly Commentary
Thank you for your interest n D.B. Zwirn &Co., L P. Attached please find the nost recent Investor conyrcnta for the D.& 
' unties Fund LP. , egards, D.B.
Zwirn&Co., L P. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phones Fax
May 05, 2009 D.* Zwim Special OpliortunItlesFUlUI, Ltd. - Investor CommUnkatIon
Attached please find an important confrontation that was sent to the Shareholders or the D. B. Zwin Special 
Opportunities Find, LW. This confrontation for your
Information only and requires no action on your part. We will send a sinter corrrnunicatbn a hie to the tinted Partners 
of the D.B. Zvirn Special Opportunities
Fund, LP. shortly. If you , plea bsher a Regards, D.B. Zwirn &Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 
Fax
ia lOgr 2009  • nsiro.S.Peollil Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Investor Communication
Attached please find an Irrportant oorrmmicatbn regarding the D.8. Zwirn Special Opportunties Fund L P. This 
communication requits a response no
P
later than May 22, 2009. If you have a ' co rat  Regards, D.B. New &Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 
1015 hone Fax
Mar 1512009 .lterninder: D.C. Zwirn Special Opportunkies Fund, LP. - Consent forms due before 1000 am. on May 22, 2009
Dear Investor: This is a reminder that consent forms oust be received before 10:00a EST on May 22, 2009. If you would 
lice to discuss the consent, please feel
free to contact Else Hubsher Thank you, D.  Zwirn & Co., LP.
May 20,2009: Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Consent forms due before 1000 a.m. on May 22,2009
Dear Investor: We have not received your consent form This is a reminder they oust be received before 10:00 a.m New YOrk
tine on May 22, 2009. If you would Ike
to discuss the consents, please feel free to contact Else Hubsher at Thank you, D.8. Zwirn & Co., L P. •
May 27, 2009 Zwirn spedal Opportunities Funds Investor Communication
Dear Investor, We are pleased to Worm you that as of 10:00 AM today, the deadline for subtitling proxies h respect Of 
the notices sent to Investors in each of
o. B. Avlm Special Opportuntles Fund, L P., D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, Ltd., D.& Zwirn Asia/Peat Special 
Opportunities Fund, L P. and D.B. Nera
SPellalOpportunties (TE) Fund, LP., we had received a sufficient number of proxies for each fund to constitute a quorum 
and to approve the varbus netters for
which consent was requested In connection with the replacement of D. a Zwim & Co., LP. as hvestment rrenager to the 
funds with an affiate of Fortress Investment
Group U.C. We note that, for a B. 2wirn Special Opportunties Fund, Ltd., the vote w0 be mated at the shareholders' 
meeting scheduled for May 26, 2009 and, once
finalzed, we expect rrenagerrent of the funds wit be transferred to Fortress at the cbsing pursuant to the transactbn 
documents desalbed In the consent
ckxtrents. We would kite to thank al Investors in the Funds for their thoughtful consldemtbn of al natters rebted to the
transaction and bok forward to our
onlfinued support as we neke the transition. Regards, 0.* 2WIM &CO, LP.
Oetipbek 0;20136; InVeStorkiirt: DO pi rti;lee `064try Gruss
Notes: Tiled tang but no one answered.
Nov ember 20;2006 investoi*W6 PG Departure Round 2
Notes: DL - Jt 12: I (1pn Mark ebvrtz called DavO Endyck, )E'S attorney
Jaspers. inc. Activity
MOW
Conf identia I VRF 00000001
Redacted for Privilege
04.******••11.4•01•1****0.04.4.1•Ilint•******* 11.*****F•lalfl•
lleaSury Circular 230 Notts: Any U.S. federal tax advice included In this
COranunkation was not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used, for the
purpose of avoiding U.S. federal tax penalties. lic***************a************••••••••• ****** ********* ** ****** 
*******3•11.•••••••
NOTICE
This egret massage 6 Intended only for the named recipient(s) above. It nay
contain confidential inforrratlan that ts prWleged or that constitutes attorney
work product. U you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that
any dissemination, distributbn or copying of this e-mail and any attacivrent(s) is
strictly prohibted. If you have received this a-nal in error, please Immediately
notify the sender by replying to tbs e-riell and delete the message and any
altachment(s) from your system Thank you.
EaW W 1ei:A47
May 06, 2005 Deardrn a ICKApill Estimates (logged e-mall from Woykowski, Ta Ha h received on 5/6/206513658 PM)
Notes: Front Woykowst Tabh
To:
CC: Subject: DB Zarin tk3CK April Esthetes Body: Harry, Ire recently started working with
Alyson on Investor Relations here . . Abyson has asked me to contact you with an April estimate for our funds. A rough 
conservative
esthete for net performance h the D.& Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. for the month of April 2005 Is +100bps. A 
rough estimate for net
performance in the 1CK Partners, LP. for the month of AM 2005 6 -1.6%. Please let rre know If I can be of any further 
assistance.
Ptah Woykovisid Zwlm tit Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone
MobileFax:
July 20, 2005 DaZ Wili‘Pilirl Mt Financial 2fiale I:company (lopped e-mall from Woykowski, Tomah received on 7/20/2005
1149i54 At4). ,., . ..

Notes: Front Woylcowski, Taal/ To: 'Harry Beier WM CC: Subject: C82 fees pall by Financial Trust Conpany Body: Mr. 
Baler, As you
requested, please see below. Please let us know a else. Talah W kowsld Investor
Relations D.& Zwlm &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 17th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone: Fax:
Front Law, UAnne Sent: Wednesday, Jug 20, 200511:40 AM To: Way c: Gnss, . . .

Company 2004 management fees $1,262,140 2004 Incentive fees $2,756,039 2005 Ulm Jute milt fees $1,049,413 2005 thru June
Incv fees
$1,454,990
JuhiZO005 Re
urgent,._;;.'
,.  • .

Notes: Front Woykowskl, Tenth To: Woykowsld, Talah CC: Gruss, Perry Subject: RE Urgent Body: Financial mist Company 2004
management fees
$1,262,140 2004 incentive fees $2,756,039 2005 thru June merit fees $1,049,4132005 thru lune incv fees $1,454,990 Front 
Woylabokir
Tabh Sent Wednesday, July 20, 200511:33 AM To: Law, U Anne Cc Gruss, Perry Subject: Urgent Importance: High U Anne, 
Harry Beier just caled
again. Apparently, it is urgent that he find out what Financial Trust Company has paid h management and performance fees
for 2004 and 2005. Is there
any way you could get the e,  ma asap? Thanks so nuch.

Fax:Zaurtn &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 17th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone illillilliiiiiiiiiiii elatsms a  a
A 4 140;k8 11.S. ; . • piiii 4: • • . Notes: Front Alinonsicy, Alyson To: 'Many Beier A  CC: Airmnsky, Alyson Subject: 
DBZ #s Body: Mr. Seller, I understand
that you
recently spoke with Mark Bianchini of JCK Partners, a  proved you with July perfonrence and capital account balance 
information for Financial
Thist's3CK investment. As he mentioned, we have centralzed Investor Relations for both DBZ and JCK with Allyson and I so
please feel free to contact
one of us next month when you need these nun-tiers. tato wanted to mention that 082 does not yet have a Jug performance 
estimate or capital account
balance for Financial Trust's Investment. We generaly have a very rough perforrinnce estimate by the 5th business day of
the rronth, which I can provide
to you over the phone, and a are Mated estimate 10-15 business days kto the month which 6 disseminated via eat. Capital 
account balances are
generated after performance has been flnaltted, and 1 amable to provide you wth those toners as soon as they become 
avalable. Please let rre know If
you wish to be contacted with a rough perfomnnce estimate once we have one. Thank you for your the and I look forward to
spealtrig with you soon.
Tabh Woyinwsirt Investor Relations D.B. Zwlm &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 17th Floor New York, NY 10151
Phone: Fax:
.7550 •
Confidential VFW 00000002
Notes: Front Waykows$3, Tath To: 'Harry Beller (hanyOrwsglemmy CC: Almansky, Meson Subject: DBZ #5 Body: Mr. Beller, I 
underStand that you
recently spoke with Mark filanchlni of JCK Partners, and that he provided you wth July performance and capital account 
balance inforrretbn for Financial
Trust's )CK twestment. As he mentioned, we have connoted Investor Relations for both DBZ and JCK with AIlyson and I so 
please feel free to contact
one 01 us next month when you need these numbers. I also wanted to mention that OBZ does not yet have a Jut performance 
esthete or espial account
balance for Financial Theses Investment. We generaly have a very rough performance esthete by the 5th business day of 
the rronth, which I can provide
to you over the phone, and a more final:red estimate 10.15 business days into the month whidi is disseminated via enrol.
Capital account balances are
generated after performance has been 'hated, and I am able to provide you with those numbers as soon as they become 
available. Please let ti e know f
you cosh to be contacted wth a rough performance estimate once we have one. Thank you for your the and I look forward to
speaking with you soon.
Toth Woykowski Investor Relations D.B. Ziven &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 17th floor New York, NY 10151
Phone Fax:
August 08, 2005 FW: DB Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP
Notes: Front Alirrensky, Atyson To: Subject: FW: DB Zwin Special Opportunities Fund, IP Body: Harry, Here are rough
approximations for 08 ZWrn. I am wa ng or u rs or JCK Partners - ISEsend them to you as soon as I have thern Thanks, 
Atyson Front
Law, U Ame Sent: Monday, August 08, 2005 3:28 PM To: Afirrensky, Myron Cc: Blanchlni, Mark Subject: FW: 0432wirn Special
Opportunities Fund, LP
Attached Is the statement 06/30/05. Ebbw breaks-out ham estimate for the 6 months ended June 30, 2005 Dhildend Income 
24,774 Interest Income
7,408,366 Short Tenn Capital Loss 642,969 Fund Expenses (236,459) !Management fee (839,532) Unrealized Loss (1,169,649)
August 19, 2005 Readdress (logged e-mail from Harry Baler received on 8/19/2005113614 AM)
Notes: Front Harry Beller To: Woykowski, Toth CC: Subject: RE: address Body: Talah My address ts: New York Strategy
Group 457 Madison Ave t r New York NY 10022 Att: Fa -Original Message-- Front Woykowsld, Talah
Veit° Sent: Thursday, August 18, 2005 6:10 PM To: bject: address it Beier, Could I trouble
you for your rming address? Thank you h advance. h Woykosysb Investor Relations D.B. Zwirn &

Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 17th Floor New York, NY 10151 Plane: Fax: e-mall message
Is Intended only for the named redpient(s) above. It rrey contain con en forntitbn U you are tlatendednot redolent, you 
are hereby notified
that any use, dissemination, distrbutbn or copying of this e-nel and any attachment(s) s sok* proNlited. Zwirn & Co., 
LP. reserves the right to
archive and mentor al e-mall cormunicatbris through Is networks. If you have received ths e-rrel in error, please 
kwreellatet notty the sender by
repyhg to the e-nel and delete the rressage and any attachnent(s) from your system Thank you.
August 19, 2005 RE: address (logged e-mail from Harry Beller received on 8/19/2005113614 AM)
Notes: Front Harry Beier 41 .11. To: Woykowsid, Toth CC: Subject: RE: address Body: Talah My address 6: New York 
Strategy
Grou 457 Madison Ave 4 floor New York NY 10022 Att: Harry Beller Message---- Front Woykosysid, Talah
Sent: Thursday, August 18, 2005 6:10 PM To Subject: address Mr. Beier, Coukl I trouble
you In advance. lotions D.B. Zwlm &
Co. 745 Ftth Avenue, 17th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone: Fax: The e-mail massage
6 Intended only for the named redpiant(s) above. It may contain co n one . y re recipe , you are hereby notified
that any use, dIsserdnation, distrbutbn or copying of ths e-rml and any attachment(s) 6 strictly prohibited. D.B. been 
&Co., LP. reserves the right to
archive and mentor al e-nel comrunk2tbns through is networks. If you have received tNs eercel 01 error, please 
intnediately notify the sender by
repaying to this e-nel and delete the rressage and any attachrrent(s) fromyow system Thank you.

August 31, 2005 FTC 7/31 Cap Acct Balance (logged e-mail from Woykowski,TaBah received on 8/31/20051:23:01 PM)
Notes: Front Woykowskl, Talah To: 'Harry Beer CC: Subject: FTC 7/31 Cap Acct Balance Body: Mr. Baer, As you requested, 
the
metal account balance h  D.& &dm Special pew cell  /In • 111 , fur Financial Trust Company as of 7/31/05 IS about 
$108,025,987. Please let we
know W I can be of any further assistance. elation D.B. Zwlm &Co. 745 Mb
Avenue, 17th Floor New York, NY 10151 Pisa Fax:
September 08, 2005 D.R. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. -- Management and Incentive Fees (logged e-mail from Law,
LiAnne
received on 9/8/2005 122938 PM)
Notes: Front Law, LI Anne To: CC: Alirrensky, Mysore Woykowskl, Talah Subject: D.B. ZWIrn Special Opportunities Fund, 
LP. --
Management and Incentive Fees ; Mr. r: As requested, the Fran:lie TtuSt Company ineurred $ 1,232,813 in management fees 
from Jan 2C05
thru July 2005. The accrued IncentNe alocatien for the period is $ 1,830,240
November 02, 2005 DB Zwirn Info (togged e-mail from A limansky, Alyson received on 11/2/2005 7,4926 PM)
Notes: Front Afrrensky, Alyson To: CC: Subject: DB Zwim info Body: many - here k the kilo you requested: Below 
breaks-out Income
esthete for the 3 month ended Sept 30, 2005 (all net of Incentive): Dividend Income 1,032,288 Interest Income 3,063,767 
Short Term CapealGain
998,847 Fund Expenses (213,286) Management Fee (447,806) Unmated Loss (20,841)
November 02, 2005 RE: Harry Beller (logged e-mail from Law, U Anne received on 11/2/2005 657S8 PM)
Notes: Front Law, U Anne To: Airrensky, Allyson CC: Woykawski, Tallah Subject: RE: Harry Beier Body: Here's the info 
that he usually requests at the end
of the quarter: Below breaks-out income esth ete for the 3 months ended Sept 30, 2005 (al net of Ixentwe): °adend 
Incorre 1,632,288 Interest
Income 3,063,767 Short TermCapital Gain 998,847 Fund Expenses (213,286) Management Fee (447,806) Unrealized Loss 
(20,841)
Front Alimansky, Alyson Sent: Wednesday, November 0 To: law, U Anne
Subject: Harry Beller Harry Beller from Financial Trust wants estimated tax amount - do you have thls7 Hs numbers or you
can give info to
Ere and I am happy to call him thanks
genuary 09, 2006 Financial Trust Company
To: Abmnsky, Alyson; Woykowsid, Talah; Cho, Justki Front Bianchini, Mark Notes: Mr. Beller Caled me for the capital 
balance in the JCK Onshore fund. I
prey I a new erred address: HYPERUNK
"nano Thanks -- -- Marla BlanchinUCK Partners LP. 745 Fifth
Avenue 17th Floor New York, NY 10151 T  F: E: HYPERLJNK -maRo
7anuary 09, 2006 RE: Financial Trust Company
Confidential VRF 00000003
January 10, 2006
To: Woylcoviski, Talah Front FAXCOM Fax Server Notes: <file://Wbzco.corrigloballocal‘shared\specoppsgnvestor 
RelattrisThwestor
Correspondence \Filancial Must Company \ FTC Annual Investment rbssficaton Ack 1.10.06.pdf> FAXCOM RECEIVED FAX REPORT
---- Received The : 01/10/200616:32 Result : OK Description : Al pages received OK Resut Code : 0000 Pages Received:
0004 Bad Pages : 0000 Remote TSI : Connect Trre : 0064 Seconds Fax the : 3 Routing ID : 9226 Baud Rate : 14400 Bps The
fax 6 lack:tied as a PCF docurrent attachrrent.
January 11, 2006 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, La - Q4 NYS Letter
To: Front DM & Co. Investor Relations Notes: Dear Harry, Attached please find inportant correspondence regarding 2005 
New York
State source ncome and the possibility of filing composite tax returns it certain states. For your convenience, there 
are separate attachments relatiog to
New York State sourced Income for each of your enUtles kwested In D.B. Zwirn Special OpportunlUes Fund, LP. Please note 
that this S dated matern,
which may requite action by January 15, 2005. Thank you for your the. end Regards, D.& &ran &Co. «composite return 
letter. pdf»«CT-2658
-E for 2006ff. » «IT -2658-6 for 2006ff.pdf» cfIe://V4b2t0.cenAglobahlocahshareThsPececesfiewestor Relations \ Investor
Correspondence Finandal Trust Company \Financial Trust Company Q4 NYS Letter.pdf>
February O6,2006 Capital Account Balance for Financial Trust Company
To. CC: Alirrensky, Alyson; Woykovisid, Tallish Notes: Mr. Beier, The capital account balance for Flnandal Ttust 
Conpany,  as
of 1, was about $114,379,190. Please let us know If you need anything else. Maras. ee Justin
Justin Cho D.& 2wirn &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue 18th Fbor New Y• NY 10151 tel fax: met HIPERLINK
To: ejanchini, Mark; AThensky, Alyson; Cho, Justin Notes: FYI - Mark transferred Mr. Beler to me and I advised that 
capital account balances for CEZ were
not yet ready and provided him ivith current rough estimate. I have updated the database and distnbutbn Ist with his new
erred address. Thanks Mark
I a Ian Woykowsid Investor Relations D.B. 2\Mm &Co. 745 Pith Avenue, 1 /tit Fbor New York, NY 10151
• HYPERL1N
Front fiery:NM, Mark Sent: Monday, January 09, 2006 12:25 PM To: /Threnskr, Alyson; Woykowsid,
amen; arc, : Fnanaar i rust Company Mr. Beler Cafed rre for the capital balance in the JCK Onshore fund. I vided the 
Decenber 30
ending a al balance verbs . He also stated that he has a new enal address: HYPERUNK
S o
f: e: HypeRuThrInks --- --- Mark). BkinchinOCK Partners LP. 74 venue r w or .
K
Annual Investment Classification Acknowledgment for FTC reed via fax 1.10.06
February 06, 2006 Capital Account Balance for Financial Trust Company
To: lobelleranysgralconi CC: Alrrensiry, Alyson; Woykowsld, Torah Front Cho, Justin Notes: his. Beller, The 
capitalaccount balance for Froncial
Trust Cowpony, W. as of December 31, 2005 was about 5114,379,190. Please let us know if you need anything BestA_JustIn
315th Cho D.B. ban &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue 18th Fbor New York NY 10151 tel: emit
HYPEFUNK "mato
April 14, 2006 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Q1 Tax Information
To: Front 06Z &Co. Investor Relations Notes: <fie://t dbzco.conAglobahleCafgharechspecoppslOperationslAccountingTaxt2006
\ Q1
2006 UBTWOF letters Ina nee' Trust Co Q106 NYS letter.pdf> Dear Harry, Attached please fird irrportant correspondence 
regarding 2006 New Yo-k
State sourced Income. Please note that ths ts dated material, which may require action by Aprl 17, 2006. Thankyou for 
your the. Kind Regards, D.O.
Zwin &Co.
April 18, 2006 Explanation for Distribution on K-1
To: CC: Afirensky, Allyson; Butchkowsk, Aka Notes: Mr. Beller, I JuSt tried to cal your office and understand I nissed 
you for the
day. [received your message and wanted to get back to you regarding the distrbutbn noted h item 19 on the 2005 Schedule 
K-I for Finandal Trust
Comore.. I have spoken with our Accounting Department and they confimithe $9,805 Is a NJ State Tax Withholding that we 
pay out on behalf of FTC.
These types of pay-outs are noted as a rederrptbn or dIstrbutkm. If this does not seem right, please let me know as soon
as possible and we will get in
touch with our auditors to conOnn further details. Thank you for your the. lath Woykowski Investor
Relations D.B. 2YrIm &Co. 745 Firth Avenue, 17th Floor New York NY 10151 Phone: HYPERUNK
"mato
April 27, 2006 Cell Harry
To: I3utchkowsld, Also Notes: Harty Beler Is associated with our largest LP Thestor, Randal Trust Company. He has a few 
questions regarding the K-1
they received. I'm not sure Thre got them all, but basically he wants more Inforrretion about the following. Could you 
(or David) call him to discuss and
resolve asap? Thanks so much. -guaranteed payments/self errpbyrrent -US Treasury Interest - he cant find on K-I -what 
kind of PFIC hcorre and how
does it affect Mn? -schedule of taxes for other states (besides Ft)) -NYC WITTax and where s that reflected
Woykowsid Investor Relations D.B. Zwirn &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 17th Floor New York, W 10151 Phone: Fax:
HYPERUNK "mato
June 06, 2006 D.S. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. Q2 Tex Information
ToiRmitim4Frorrt Di32 &Co. Investor Relations Notes: <fle:/AVAuco.comlsiobal bcakshanoThspeamps \OperationsThaounting \ 
Tax \ 2006
\Q20 U lette inandal Trust Company Q2 06 NYS letter.pdf> Dear Harry, Attached please find inportant correspondence 
regarding 2006
Q2 New York State sourced Income. Please note that this S dated naterbl, which nay require action by June 15, 2006. 
Thank you for your tine. Kind
Regards, D.B. Zwirn &Co.
July 06, 2006 Financial Trust - Mr. Beller
To: Woykowski, Talah CC: Cho, Justin From Bianchini, Mark Notes: Talon, Would you be able to five Mr. Beier a cal when 
you have a chance. lie is
looking for an estimate and it seers he s not aware. ----------------- Mark). BianchialCK Partners, LP. 745 Fifth 
Avenue, 17th Floor New York, NY
10151 T F: E: HYFERL1NK 'mato
September 11, 2006 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Q3 Tax Information
To: fi bekrenysginall.coni Front DB2 & Co. Investor Relations Notes: 
<file:/Mdbzco.conAgbbakbcakshared\specopps\OperationslAcoounting‘Tax;2006
\Q3 2006 UBINPDF LettersWinandal Trust Conpany Q3 06 NYS letter.pdf> Dear Harry, Attached please find Irportant 
correspondence regarding 2006
Q3 New York State sourced Intone. Please note that this 6 dated material, whith nay require action by September 15, 
2006. Thank you for your Uwe.
Kind Regards, D.& Avim &Co.
Confidential VRF 00000004
October 24, 2006 Q3 Tax Breakdown - NYS
To: hbellerenyseneecom Notes: <file://Wlbzco.comitgbballocaeshared\speccipps1,Investor Ftelatbne \ Investor 
CorrespondericeWklancialTruSt
Corrpany \ Copy of Financial Trust Conpany Inc - Q3 2006.xls> le Harry, Please see the attached breakdown of your NYS 
sourced Income as Indicated In
the Q3 letter. I hope Eva was able to amide you with the Information you were looking for, however, feel free to contact
rre if you have further
uestions. Best  Cara Howe D.& Zwin &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151 T:
F
«Copy of Fina " MUNK Attachments:
onpany Inc - Q3 2 .x >
October 24, 2006 RE Harry Baer tax from Eva
To: Howe, Cara CC: Warren, Clifford; Woyirowslid, Talbh Front So, Eva Notes: Cara, Henry Beier asked ne for a breakdown 
of his NYS sourced income
as becated in his Q3 send the information to lentoday. Hit e-rrel
actress Is HYPERLINK I just t is rrore appropriate to send the
hfonnktkin through kwest s re eon instead of sending t dkectly fromthe tax department. Please let rre know if you have 
any questions. Regards,
Eva Front Howe, Cara Sent: Monday, October 23, 2006 6:56 PM To: So, Eva Subject: Harry Beier tax <HYPERUNK
ine://dbzco.com/gbbatriockeshared/specopps/Operatlions/Accounting/Tax/2006/Q3%202006%2OUBT/PDF%20LettetS/Fhancelies20Tru
sti620Corrpany%
20Q30.62006%2ONYS6.520letter.pdfile://114tizai.com\ globaelocaeshared seecopps \ Operations \ Accounting \ Tax \ 2006 
\Q3
<eb://dInco.cornighbaelemeshared/sPeCoPps/Operatbns/Accounting/Tax/21106/Q3%202006%20OBT/POIR620Letters/Finandal9620Trst
%
20Conpany%20Q3%2006%20NY5%201etter. pdf> 2006 terneDf Letters \I:Inertial Trust Company Q3 06 NYS letter. pdf>
Yolk, MI 10151 1: F:
Attachments: «Financial Trust Company Inc
- Q3 2006.xls»
November 05, 2006 Q3 2006 Capital Account Statement for Financial Trust Company
To: Notes: <fle://Wibeee.Coneglobaelocaeshared\specopps\OperattnekACcounthg\Investois\Onshore Statenents \ 2006\2006 Q3
Sta me 'nerd \ LP rrel merge Q3 2006 Filandal Trust Corrpany.pdf> Attached phase end the 2006 Q3 capital account 
statement for the
investment in the D.B. barn Special Opportunities Fund I free ou have any questions. Yours truly, D.& Zwie &Co.,
LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phon Fax IReedbzw.com Attachments: «tP mini merge Q3
2006 Financial Trust Conpany.pdf»
December 06, 2006 ReJeffrey
To: Hubsher, Else Front Lee, David Notes: Tax advisor, was just fotwdkig fyl --Original Message--- Front Hubsher, t3se 
Sent: Wednesday,
Decanter 06, 2006 6:39 PM To: Lee, David Subject: Re: Jeffrey When are they h and who do we want them to meet? How rruch
time
— Sent from rry EtackBerry Wireless Device —Original Message-- Front Lee, David To: Cutler, Lawrence D.; Hubsher, Elise 
Sent: Wed Dec 06
18:01:43 2006 Subject: FW: Jeffrey
HYPERLINC
Redacted for Privilege
December 28, 2006 Assignment form for the 12/31/05 full transfer from Financial Trust Company Inc. to Jeepers Inc. reed 
via Pax
To: Woykowsid, Talah Front FAXCOM Fax Server Notes: FAXCOM RECEIVED FAX REPORT Received The : 12/20/2006
16:29 : OK Desaiptbn : Al pages received OK Resat Code : 0000 Pages Re0elved: 0005 Bad Pages : 0000 Remote
1St : Connect The : 0072 Seconds Fax fine : 3 Roiling ID : 9226 Baud Rate : 14400 Bps The fax Is included as a PDF
docurren a ac mein. Attachments: «P4SG1_0617782130150176.pdf»
December 28, 2006 DBZ Subscription Documents for Floandel Trust Company
May411 stiM ionccurrents for Financial Dust Company, Inc. and btknk subscription documents to be completed for the 
transfer from Mandel Thist
To: CC: Lebowtz, Seth Notes: Darren and George, Per the request of Seth Lebowitz, attached please find the
Company, Inc. to Jeepers Inc. Please let ore know if ou have any questions. R rds, Nicole Whte Investor Relations D.& 
Zwkn &Co. 745 Fifth
Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone: Fax: nicoie.whiteedbmo.com Attacments: «Financial Trust
Company, Inc. 2002 05.pdf » «08Z LP Sub Does . »
December 28, 2006 FW: Revisions (SL provides email addresses for attorney and tax accountant)
To: White, Nicole Front Lebowtz, Seth Notes: here t is. the sub does goes to both non-DBZCO addresses on DPeenul below. 
Their names are Darren
Indyke and George Delon, and they are the attorney and tax accountant, respectively, for the inveStor (net Streit ou 
need this for the IR database, but
e t). thanks Front Proshan, David Sent: Wednesday, Decanter 27, 2006 6:43 PM To: Cc
coca .

; Lebowitz, Seth Subject: RE: Revisions Darren and George: Please see the needled, whkh is marked to show the changes to
the prior
rrent is subject to our continukig review (including on tax matters). Seth w0 sand you subsatitbn documents tomorrow 
morning, along
with the subscription docurrents previously executed the a nor. Best regards, Dave David A. Proshan
December 28, 2006 RE FAX received from
To: Hubsher, Else; Lebowitz, Seth CC: WOykowskl, Tallah; Howe, Cara; White, Nicole Front Prostian, David Notes: Lees 
hold the until we are final - SL
and I are sal working on t - thank you --Original Message---- From: Hubsher, Eise Sent: Thu 28, 2006 5:17 PM To: 
Proshan, Day d;
Lebowitz, Seth Cc Woykowsid, Takh; Howe, Cam; White, No  Subject: FW: FAX received f David and Seth please let us bow 
ewe
accept this transfer and if there k any hvolienient you need from us. ----Original Message— Utah Sent: Thursday, 
Decanter 28,
2006 5:13 PM To: White, Nicole; Howe, Cara Cc: Hubsher, Bee Subject: EW: FAX received fro This boles Bee an Assignment 
form for
Financial Trust Co. I'm not farnaar wth what is going on there so please handle accordingly. I have receipt.
Investor Relations D.& Zwirn &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue New Y NY 10151 Phone:
Fax: ---Orighal Memage---- Front FAXCOM Fax Server [mato Sent.

Thixsday, Decanter 28, 2006 4:30 PM To: Woyloweld, Fatah Subject: FAX received fro FAXCOM RECEIVED FAX REPORT ----
------ Received The : 12/28/2006 16:29 Result : OK Description : page.% r tithed OK Resut Code : 0000 Pages
Received: 0005 Bad Pages : 0000 Remote TS! IIIIIIIIII Connect The : 0072 Seconds Fax fine : 3 Routing ID : 9226 Baud
Rate : 14400 Bps The fax k  as a POF docurren a a rent.

December 29, 2006 Financial Trust Co making full transfer on 12/31/06 to]eepers Inc. in Din LP - sub docs raced via fax 
& Seth
handling logistics
ConLclenhaI VRF 00000005
To: Woykowskl, Talah From FAXCOM Fax Server Notes: FAXCOM RECEIVED FAX REPORT   Received Toe : 12/29/2006
11:45 Result : OK Descriptbn : Al pages received OK Result Code : 0000 Pages Received: 0047 Bad Pages : 0000 Renote
151 Connect The : 0807 Seconds Fax the : 1 Rotting 1D : 9226 Baud Rate : 14400 Bps The fax 6 included as a PDF
document attachment Attachments: «MSG1_061.2291659060225.pdf»
December 29, 2006 Financial Trust Company Inc. making 12/31/05 full transfer to Issuers Inc. - sub does reed via Fax
To: White, Nicole Front Woykowski, Talah Notes: FAXCOM RECEIVED FAX REPORT ---------- Received Tire : 12/29/2006 11:4.
Result : OK Description : Al pages received OK Result Code : 0000 Pages Received: 0047 Bad Pages : 0000 Renate 1St
Connect The : 0807 Seconds Fax he : 1 Routing ID : 9226 Baud Rate : 14400 Bps The fax Is included as a PDF document
attachment.

December 31, 2006 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Restated 12/31/01S CapitalReplant Statement
To: 'Beier, HarrysJeepers, Inc. CC: From C8Z &Co. Investor Relations Notes: <fie://
WItuco.com\ globahlocal \shared \SPeCOpps OperationS \ Accounting \ InvestorsiOnshore StaterrentS \ 2006 2006 Q4 POST 
AUDIT Statements12006 Q4 POST
AUDIT Statements \ LP 2006 Q4 Restatement - Jeepers Inc.pdf> Attached please (Ind your restated 12/31/06 capital account
statement. The restatement
reflects the broad of audit adjustments to your capital account and is the final 12/31/06 statement. Please note that we
do not expect to restate K-1 tax
docurrervs for 2006. The pelt adjustments prime* reflect changes Si bookkeeping tens surnrartzed Si the March 26, 2007 
Investor connuntathen
and discussed In the footnotes to the 2006 audited Thence' statements. The audit adjustments reduce the capital account 
fromthe original, reported
amount. The adjustment amount wit vary among capital accounts based upon the thing of original arid subsequent 
Subscriptbns. As reported Si the
audited francial statements, the Fund return for 2006, including the audit adjustments, 515.64%. With the oonclusbn of 
the 2006 audit and the
enhancements over the past eighteen months In systems, potties, controls and procedures that have been Implemented by a 
highly experienced teamof
Industry professionals, we beteve we now have the Infrastructure Si oboe to meet the Fads needs and scale our bushess. 
Looking ahead, we expect to
expedte the release of financial kionretkin on a mere nom-abed tImeframe. We of course remain open to any questions you 
may have and we
encourage you to schedule an operational due diligence vest to become more familiar with the infrastructure 
rrodficatIons and irprovements we have
Introduced. We look forward Si 2008 to corithuing to provide attractive Mk adjusted returns from our bead diversified 
portfolio. We thank you for your
patienCe and support. Best Regard, D.& ZWIrn & Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151 T: F:
Attachments: «LP 2006 Q4 Restatement - Jeepers Inc.pdt>>
January 08, 2007 Rt Financial Trust Co dam
Redacted for Privilege ----Original Message-- Front FAXCOM
Fax Server Into Sent: Monday, January 08, 2007 6:09 PM To: Woykowski, Talah Subject: FAX received FAXCOM RECEIVED
FAX REPORT   Received Tae : 01/08/2007 17:56 Result : OK Description : All pages received OK Result
Code : 0000 Pages Received: 0050 Bad Pages : 0000 Remote TSI : Conned The : 0769 Seconds Fax line : 1 Rotting ID : 9226
Baud Rate : 14400 Bps The fax Is Included as a PDF document attachment.
January 08, 2007 revised Jaspers inc. does
To: Woykowsld, Talah From FAXCOM Fax Server Notes: FAXCOM RECEIVED FAX REPORT ------------ Received Tim : 01/08/2007
17:56 Result : OK Desaiption : Al pages received OK Result Code : 0000 Pages Received: 0050 Bad Pages : 0000 Remote
151 : Conned The : 0769 Seconds Fax Me : 1 Routhg ID : 9226 Baud Rate : 14400 Bps The fax Is included as a PDF document
atmchment. Attachments: «MSG1_0701082309110757.pdf»
January 10, 2007 FW: Financial Trust Co does
Redacted for Privilege
----Original Message From FAXCOM Fax
Server [motto Sent: Monday, January 08, 2007 6:09 FM To: Woykowslcl, Talah Subject: FAX received FAXCOM RECEIVED FAX
REPORT   Received Th e : 01/06/2007 17:56 Result : OK Description : AU pages received OK Result Code :
0000 Pages Received: 0050 Bad Pages : 0000 Renate T51 : Connect The : 0769 Seconds Fax toe : 1 Routing ID : 9226 Baud
Rate : 14400 Bps The fax Is raided as a PDF document attachrrent.
January 10, 2007 RE: Financial Trust Co docs
Redacted for Privilege
---Orignal Message— From FAXCOM Fax Server IneinSent: Monday, January 08, 2007 6:09 PM
To: Woykowski, Talah Subject: FAX received FA/COM RECEIVED FAX REPORT ------------- eceNed The : 01/08/2007 17:56
Result : OK Description : Al pages received OK Result Cede : 0000 Pages Received: 0050 Bad Pages : 0000 Remote 151 :
Connect The : 0769 Seconds Fax the : 1 Routing ID : 9226 Baud Rate : 14400 Bps The fax 6 included as a PDF document 
attachment.
Confidential VRF 00000006
January 11, 2007 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Revised Q4 Tax Information for Jaspers Inc
To: BCC: So, Eva; Lebowitz, Seth Notes: <flle:/fldbzca.comAgbbakbacakshared\specopps\OperatbnsiAccounting\Tax12006‘Q4
2006 UST \PDF lettersVeepers Inc • 4Q NYsourced Income letter. pdf> Dear Marry, Attached please rtid revised 
correspondence regarding 2006 Q4 New
York State sourced Income. Our deepest apologies for the asinfornetbn contained h our previous correspondence on this 
natter. Thank you for your
tire. land Regards, D.B. Zwtn &Co. Attachments: <Ceepers Inc - 4Q NYsourced incorm letter. pdf»
January 11, 2007 Releepers Inc. tax withholding
Redacted for Privilege
January 11, 2007 RBJeepers Inc. tax withholding- Eva confirms that $ was withheld for Jaspers
To: Lebowitz, Seth; Woykowsid, Tallith; Butchowski, Alta CC: Warren, Gifford; McGrath, Brian; Proshan, David Front So, 
Eva Notes: Seth, We
certainly withheld $966,609 of NYS taxes In Q4 2006 fromleepers Inc. The letter to Jeepers would need to be changed. 
TaltalVAlsa, Please let us know
who Is going to change the letter to reflect the tax withheld on behalf of Jeepers Inc.. Thanks, Eva Front Labovitz, 
Seth Sent: Thursday,
January 11, 2007 2:54 PM To: So, Eva Cc Warren, Clifford; McGrath, Ben; Proshan, David Subject: FW: Jeepers Inc. tax 
withholding Eva: see bebw.
I'm glad I figured out that Cuff and Brian are out of town. Let ire know if you have any questions or want to discuss. 
thanks Seth Front
Lebowitz, Seth Sent: Thursday, January 11, 2007 2:24 PM To: McGrath, Oren; Warren, ClIford Cc Proshan, David Subject: 
Jeepers Inc. tax wahholiing
Brian and CIO: I got a cat from the lawyer for Jeepers, Inc. today (I believe he called several other people here as we 
saying that Jeepers received a NY
state withhokling letter for tax year 2006 stating that Jeepers was exenpt from withholding. This is obvlotsly a nistake
given the background, but can you
please confirm that we actualy are withholding (or have withheld) al the 2006 taxes for Jeepers so I can get back to the
lawyer. Also, wet need to send
them a corrected letter stating that we did withhold and the amount of NYS source Income and tax vethheld. I can have IR
send the letter out, but the data
is needed from you guys. Thanks. Seth
February 12, 2007 December Cap Balance
To: Belles, Hany>Fbancial Trust Conpany Q. Epstein &Co.) lig ) CC: Lee, David CCC: Hubsher, Elise Notes: Many, I spoie 
with David
Lee and he would be happy to speak with you on a1 netters re to D.B. Zwirn and Co. We recognize that you are an 
irrportant investor and reel that
David, as President, Is the appropriat matters relating to your account. David ls prepared to speak with you regardng 
any tax questions
you may have. lie can be reached at rd Cara Howe D.&
Zwim & Co. 745 Filth Avenue New York, NY 10151 T: MIS F: HIPC NK "mato
February 12, 2007 Jeepers Inc - Dec Cap Acct Balance
To: Beler, HarreFinandal Trust Conpany (3. Epstein & Co.) Notes: Harry, The capital account balance for Jeepers Inc as 
of
12.31.06 was approxhately 8134,368,361. Please note that the previous number given verbally was preliminary. Let me blow
f I can provide you with
add* Cara Howe D. B. Zwin &Co. 795 Ffth Avenue New York, NY
M 10151 F HYPERUNK "rrailto: <iraltoicara.
February 14, 2007 D.B. ZwVn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Quarterly Account Statement
To Front 082 &Co. Investor Relatbrs Notes: <fle://
Wlbeco.contiglobalVocaRsharez&specoppA0perations‘Accounting \Investors \Onshore Statments \2006 \ 2006 Q4 StatementsV24 
LP Statenents&F' Ebel Q4
Statement - Jeepers Inc..pdf > Attached please find the 2006 Q4 capital account statement for your kwestrrent in the D.&
Zwim Special Opportuntizs
Fund, LP. Please feel free to contact us f you have any questions. Best Regards, D.B. balm &
745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151 TillirMF
February 14, 2007 FW: Redemption Schedule
To: Lee, David CC: Hubsher, Buse; Howe, Cara; Cho, Justin Notes: For Financial Trust Conceders Inc. Inv Made Mt 
Liquidity Available for
Rederrptbn 9/1/02 $10m 2 Yr Ronne 6/30/08 9/1/02 $10m 2 Yr Rolling 9/30/0812/1/02 $30m 2 Yr Roling 12/31/08
6/1/03 810m 2 Yr Roling 6/3W07 1/1/05 820m 3 Yr Rang 3/31/08 Let me know l e you need anything else.
Tallith Woykowsld We Prelent - Investor Relations D.& Zwirn &Co. 745 Ffth Avenue New York, NY 10151
Phone: HYPERUNIC 'Yrettoi
<melt From Anderson, Kelly Sent: Wednesday, February 19, 2007 9:15 AM To: Woykowsld, Talah; Howe,
Cara; Cho, Justin Subject: Rederrptbn Schedule Impo • • nee • schedule for Jeepers, Inc. Key Anderson D.& Zwim & Co.
745 •• • Fax HYPERLINK
"mato cnulto
February 15, 2007 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Tax Information
Confidential VRF 00000007
TO: libellerenysgnelcord Front DOZ &Co. Investor Relations Notes: 
<file://Mdbzco.00nkgbbaklocakshared\specoppS\OperatbnsLAccounting\Tax‘2006 1,LP 2006 Tax
Composite Letter 1, IETTEFLSVeepers Inc Coat/site Tax Letter.pdf> Dear Harty, Attached please find important 
correspondence regarding 2006 tax Woman:Xi. If
applicable to your investment in the as. brim Special Opportunties Fund, LP., please respond by February 28, 2006. 
Thankyou
fosiowa gards,13.5. Zwtn &Co  745 Pith Avenue New York, NY 10151 T:
Attachments: <Ceepers Inc. (Mandel Trust).pdf»
February 22,2007 Complaint - FW: Redemption Schedule
To: Howe, Cam Front Hasher, Eke Notes: Please log under Jeepers and their corrpiart fie. ----Original Message----- Front
Lee, David Sent:
Wednesday, February 21, 2007 5:15 PM To: liubsher, Ekse Subject: RE: Redemption Schedule Schedule below is right, la 
send you the current 12/31/ NAV —Original
Message— Front Feaster, Ekse Sent: Wednesday, February 21, 2007 5:14 PM To: Lee, David Subject: Fw: Redemption Schedule
IripOrtanCe: High DO you have the most recent versbn sent or read to Jeepers I don t want DZ to have a copy that differs
from vat we sent last -----
Sent from rry filackBerry Wreiess Device ---- Original Message --- Front Woykowsld Talah To: Hubsher, Else Sent: Wed Feb
21 17:02:26
2007 Subject: FW: Ftoienptbn Schedule [Mn Is asking me (or the 3eepers ra-off schedule. I am about to give him that 
noted below (wth corrected last
One) but wasn't sure F you ever obtained current tranche values fromAccounting, or any other progress was nude on the 
following. Please advise -
thanks. FOr Financial West Co/Jeepers Inc. Inv Made Art li quidity Available for Redenption 4/1/02 $10m 2 Yr Rare 
6/30/08
9/1/02 $10m 2 Yr Rolling 9/30/08 12/1/02 $30m 2 Yr Rang 12/31/08 6/1/03 SlOm 2 W Rang 6/301071/1105
$20m 2 Yr Rolling 3/31/07
February 22, 2007 FW: Zwlrn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Tax Information
To: Outchkowski, Aksa; Surrberac, Robert; Hubsher, Ekse; Zwirn, Dan; Cutler, Lawrence 0.; SInclet Stuart Front Lee, 
David Notes: <fle://
Wtzoo.coniglobalacakshared specopps Investor RelationsVnvestor CorrespondenceVeepersVeepers Inc. (Financial Trust).pdf> 
Please, we crust
remove references to Financial Trust, the owner of the LP Interests Is Jeepers Inc.   Front Bursa, Alicia Sent: 
Thursday, February 22, 2007 3:52
PM To: Lee, David Subject: FW: D.B. Nem Special Opportunities Fund, LP. -Tax Intonation FYI - Harry called again about 
this.... Front Boar,
Veronica Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2007 3:41 PM To: Bursar, Aida Subject: FW: D.B. Zwin Special Opportunities Fund, 
LP. - lax InfommUon

W. Beaty cared for David the and forwarded me this errel to request al the Wometbn to be resent to him but without 
stating anything about Financial
Trust. Thank you, Veronica Front Harry Baler praRo Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2007 3:40 PM To: Bow,
Veronica Sub' • FIN- D I Opponuntles Fund, LP. - Tax Infometion Front D8Z Investor Relations
[mato Sent: Thursday, February 15, 200712:48 PM To: Harry Beler Subject: as. Zwin Special Opportunities Fund, LP.
- Tax In ornat on ear Harry, Attached please find Important correspondence regarding 2006 tax Inforrreton. If applicable
to your Investment In the

D. & Zwtn Special Opportunities Fund, LP., please respond by February 28, 2006. Thank you for your tirre. Kind Regards 
D.& Zwirn
745 Fh Avenue New York, NY 10151 aMel. F:
This eyrol rressage Intended only for the named recipient(s)
above-
It nay contain confidential ome you are not the intended recipient, you
are hereby nottued that any use, disseninatlon, dttrbution or copying of this c-not and any attachment(s) Is stitlji 
prohibited. 0.8. Zwtn &Co., LP.
reserves the right to archive and monitor al e-mail communications through Is network. If you have received this e-nel 
in error, please immecrately notify
the sender by replying to this e-mad and delete the message and any attachment(s) from your system Thank you.
February 22, 2007 Inners Redemption - Complaint
To: Howe, Cara Front Hubsher, Eke Notes: <fle:/AWIRCO.00ithgbbalacalVilared6PeCoPPAIINestor ReitrialiRCultRatilskleePers
IncVeepers_12_31_06.xls> Please bg
under leepers and also under their carob ht fie. . Front
C. Lee President D.& Zwirn &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 fa
Lee, David Sent: Wednesday, February 21, 2007 5:28 PM To: Hubsher, Else Cc ' • ' • , Lawrence D. : Jeepers David
Attachrrents:
<cleepers_12_31_06.xis»
February 22, 2007 RE: D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Tax Information
To: Lee, David; Hasher, Llise Front Howe, Cara Notes: <roc/A \ daco.coagbbabbcakshared specopps \Investor Relations \ 
Investor
CorrespondenceVeepersVeepers Inc Conposte Tax Lettere/dr > Please see attached before we send to Harry. Front Lee, David
Sent:
Thursday, February 22, 20079:24 PM To: Hubsher, Elise; ButchkOwSld, Aka; Sumberac, Robert; Zwtn, Min; Cutler, Lawrence 
O.; Sindet Stuart Cc:
Howe, Cara Subject: RE: D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Tax Inforrratbn ok Front Hubsher, else Sent: 
Thursday, February 22,
2007 9:23 PM To: Lee, David; Butchhowski, Alba; Surrberac, Robert; Zwin, Dan; Cutler, Lawrence D.; Wel, Stuart Cc: Heat,
Cam Subject: RE: &EL
Zwin Special Opportunities Fund, L P. - Tax Inforrmtbn Apologies ...I reread the entice ear chaln...we will take Finanal
Trust out of the docureent. We wt send
t badcto you DC and you can send it to Harry teller. Front Lee, David Sent Thursday, February 22, 2007 9:00 PM To: 
Butchkowsid,
Alsa; Surrberac, Robert; Hubsher, Eke; ZwIrn, Dan; Cutler, Lawrence D.; Snag, Stuart Subject: FW: D.B. Zwin Special 
Opportunties Fund, LP. - Tax
Inforrretbn Please, we mist remove references to Financial Trust, the owner Of the LP interests is Jeepers Inc. Front 
Bursor, ARM Sent:
Thursday, February 22, 2007 3:52 PM To: Lee, David Subject: FW: D.B. Zwtn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Tax 
Informatbn FYI - Reny caled agar'
about this.... From Bocu, Veronica Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2007 3:41 PM To: Bursor, Aida Subject: FW: D.B. Zwirn 
Special Opportunities
Fund, L P. - ic Infornetbn Hi, Pt Baer called for David Lee and forwarded no  this oral to request all the Information 
to be resent to halibut
wthout stating anything about Financial Trust. Thank you, Veronica Front Harry Belem (mato: Sent: Thursday,
February 22, 2007 3:40 PM To: emu Veronica u : FW: as. Zwin Spate Opporturdles Fund, LP. - Tax Information Front DeZ 
&Co.
Investor Rations Veto Sent: Thursday, February 15, 2007 12:48 PM To: Harry Beier Subject: D.& Zwim Special
Opportunties Fund, LP. - ax n 011111 n ear rry, Attached please find important correspondence regarding 2006 tax 
information. If applcabie to
your Investment In the D.& Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP., please respond by February 28, 2006. Thank . Kind R 
ids D. &
745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151 F:
This e-mall message s intended only for the named reclpient(s) above. It nay contain confidential inforrretbn. If you 
are not the
intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, disseninatbn, castrbution or copying of this a-nal and any 
attachrrent(s) is strictly prohibted.
D.& Zwirn & Co., L P. reserves the right to archbe and mentor all e-nol cormuntations through its menorahs. If you have 
received this e-mail In error,
please larediately notify the sender by replying to this e-mill and delete the message and any attachrrent(s) fromyour 
system Thank you.
February 27, 2007 0.8.2wlm Special Opportunities Fund, LR - Tax Information
To: Beller, HarreFinanclalTrust Conpany (1 Epstein & Co.) CC: Hubsher, ElSe Notes: Harry, Attached please find Important
correspondence regarding 2006 tax Cam  Cam Howe D.B. Zwin &Co. 745
Fifth Avenu New Yor NY 10151 T: F: WIIIMMITYPERUNK
<mete A c ne 5: cleepers Inc Composite Tax I etter.prif »
February 27, 2007 RE: 0.8.2wirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Tax Information
Confidential VRF 00000008
To: Howe, Cam; Hubsher, Elie Front Lee, David Notes: ok Front Howe, Cara Sent: Thursday, February 22, 20079:36 PM To: 
Lee, David;
Hubsher, Else Subject: RE: D.B. Zwkn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Tax Information Please see attached before we 
send to Harry.   Front
Lee, David Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2007 9:24 PM To: Hubner, Else; Butchkowsld, Alma; Surrberac, Robert; Zwim, Dan; 
Cutler, Lawrence D.;
Slad e Stuart Cc Howe, Cara Subject: RE: D.B. Zwlm Special Opportunties Fund, LP. -Tax Infonretion ok   Front Hasher, 
®se Sent:
Thursday, February 22, 20079:23 PM To: Lee, David; ButdtkcnyskL Ma; Surrberac, Robert; Theta, Den; Cutler, Lawrence 0.; 
SIndel, Stuart Cc Howe,
Cara Subject: RE: D. B. Zwin SpedatOpportuntles Fund, LP. - Tax Infomtation Apologies ...I reread the entire erred 
chah...we wg take FinancialTrust
out of the document. We MI send t back to you Oland you can send t to Harry Refer. Front Lee, David Sent: Thursday, 
February 22, 2007
9:00 PM To: Whiner/ski, Alsa; Surnberac, Robert; Hubsher, Elbe; Zwkn, Dm; Cutler, Lawrence D.; Sind* Stuart Subject: FW:
D.B. Zwkn Special
Opportunities fund, L P. - Tax Infonretbn Please, we mist rerrove references to Financial Must, the owner of the LP 
Interests is Jeepers Inc.
Front Bursor, Alice Sent: Thursday, February 22, 2007 3:52 PM To: Lee, David Subject: FW: 2Mm Special Opportunities 
Fund, LP. - Tax Infonnatbn
FYI - Hwy called again about this.. . Front Bow, Veronica Sent Thursday, February 22, 2007 3:41 PM To: Bursor, Ma 
Subject: FW: D.B.
Them Special Opportunties Fund, LP.. - Tax Woman Mr. Biter called for David Lee and forwarded me this errel to req
be resent to him but without stating anything about Financial Trust. Thank you, Veronica Front Harry Beier (rreltm
Sent: Thursday, February 22, 20073:40 PMTo: Bow, Verona Subject: FW: D.& 2Mm Spode' Opportunities Find, LP. -Tax 
Information
Front DBZ &Co. Investor Relations Dmilto:Investor.Relatonseribrco.com) Sent: Thursday, February 15, 2007 12:48 PM To: 
tarry Beier Subject: D.B.
ZWIM Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Tax Infoirretbn Dear Harry, Attached please find krportant correspondence 
regarding 2006 tax information. If
appicable to your investment in the LLB. Zwkn Special Opporhmtles Fund, LP., please respond by February 28, 2006. Thank 
y r Kna da o 745 Fifth Avenue New York,
NW 10151 T: FM.=
This e-rrel messages Intended only for the named recipient(s) above. It ney contain confidential inform n. y u are not 
the
intended recipient, you are hereby notified that any use, dissemination, distribution or copying of this erred and any 
attachnent(s) 6 grit* prohtted.
D.B. Zwkn &Co., LP. reserves the right to archive and nontor all e-rrell cormunkatons through its networks. If you have 
received this c-net in error,
please (mediate)/ notify the sender by repNing to this e-urei and delete the message and any attathment(s) from your 
system Thank you.
February 28, 2007 2006-2007 Composite Return Election Form for Jeepers Inc. - rec'd via Fax
To: McGrath, Brian CC: Witte, Neale Front Bocu, Veronica Notes: <fle://\\dbzw.com\ globatacal \ shared \ specopps \ 
investor Relatkins\Invesbor
Correspondence kennel Trust CormanyVeepers Inc 06 Conposte Tax Bectbn.pdf> ----Original Message--- Front FAXCOM Fax 
Server
(Matto: Sent: Wednesday, February 28, 200712:35 PM To: Bow, Verona Subject: FAX received FAXCOM RECEIVED FAX
MIFOR ----------- RaOmdTime:W/0200712:33 Resut : OK DesCription : AI pages received OK Resut Code
0000 Pages Received: 0003 Bad Pages : 0000 Retitle TSI : Conned The : 0057 Seconds Fax ire : 3 Routing ID : 9068 Baud
Rate : 14400 Bps The fax is included as a PDF document attachment.
March 03, 2007 RE:Revised LF Q4 Statements for 3eepers, Petrus, Fine Family
To: Howe, Cara; Hither, Erse; Sindell, Stuart CC: Lebowitz, Seth; White, Nicole; Woykowsid, Tata Front Lee, David Notes:
go ahead and send from IR
Front Howe, Cam Sent: Fray, February 23, 20076:22 PM To: Hubsher, Else; Sinai, Stuart; Lee, David CC Lebowitz, Seth; 
Whte, Mole;
Woy beige Tallah Subject: Revised IP Q4 Statements for )eepers, Petrus, Fine Fan* Al of the Q4 LP statements have gone 
out with the exception of
the these Investors. Please advise if you %souk! Lie this to cone from IR or t you would Ike to tale care of these. See 
attached. (Please note the Fine
Farnk LP statements not attached. We II nd this n .
745 Fifth Avenue New York NY 10151 T: F HYPERLINK -mato
Cam Howe D.B. Thera &Co.
<ita t°
April 06, 2007 FW: LP tax estimates
To: McGrath, Brian CC: Lee, David; Howe, Cara Front Hubsher, Elise Notes: Thought you night be able to help wth this. 
David we are starting to send
these out and hope to have al investors with the exception of )eepers and employees out by Mon. Additional work needs to
be done for enpbyees so that
the incentiwe and rrgrrt fees are backed out. ---------- Sent from mi Blackarry Wireless Device ---- Original Message 
Front Lee, David
To: Epstein, Aaron; Flood, Brad Cc: Surrberac, Robert; Hubsher, Else Sent: Fri Apr 06 10:22:40 2007 Subject: LP tax 
estimates When are they going out?
a ? If n t can I have a breakdown of % of Intone? David C. Lee President D.B. ZwIrn &Co. L.P. 745 Fifth Avenue 18th 
Floor New York, NY 10151
fax
April 11, 2007 Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Estimate
To: Surrberac, Robert; Lee, David CC: Howe, Cara Front Hubsher, Else Notes: Ok to send? -------------- Sent from in/ 
Bledgerry Wheless
Device -- Original Message -- Front McGrath, Then To: Hubsher, Else; Howe, Cam; White, Nicole Cc. Sunterac, Robert; So, 
Eva; Warren, Clifford
Sent: Wed Apr 11 17:55:04 2007 Subject: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Btkrete Elise, We spoke earfer today with Bob Son Jeepers Inc
& he is OK forts to
proceed and send the 2006 K-1 Esthete. I have attached t to ths e-nab. Please let us blow if yo loos. Bra
=Brat Attachments: <<Jeepers Inc. - 2006 K-1 Estimates for DBZ SOF LP 1.pdf>
McGrath, CPA Senior Tax D.B. zwlm &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue New York NY 10151 Deed: Fax: Mobile:
April 11, 2007 Deepen - 2006 K-1 Estimate
To: Hubsher, Elise; Howe, Cara; White, Nab CC: Surrberac, Robert; So, Eva; Warren, afford Front McGrath, Brian Notes 
Else, We spoke eerier
today with Bob S on Jeepers Inc & he is OK for us to proceed and send the 2006 K-1 Esthete. I have attached it to this 
email Please let us know if
sees c. Thanks • n • , CPA Senior Tax Ma r a Than &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151 Direct
Ro
<ireilto:brmgrat co.ccm> Atte men : « eepers Inc. - 2006 K-1 Esthetes for DBZ SOF LP 1. pdf»
April 12, 2007 2006 Tax Estimate - Jeepers Inc.

To: Beier, Harri*Fhancial Trust Company (J. Epstein & Co.) (harryarlYSIXCem) CC: Hubsher, Elise; Lee, David Notes: 
<fle://
\ \dbzoo.contgbbaklocakshareckspecopps \ Operatbns1Accounting \Tax \2006 \Tax Comphanoe WP's & PWC Requests \K-1 
Investor Tax Estkretes \LP - Been
06 K-1 Letters to InvestorsVEEPERS Inc \ Thepers Inc. - 2036 K-1 Esthetes for DBZ SOF LP 1.pdf> Harry, Please see the 
attached 2006 tax estimate for
Jeepers Inc. We expect to send out the final ICI early summer. Please contact ether David Lee or Else Hubsher If you 
have any questions. mart you,
Cara Zwi'n <nii &o Co 745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151 T:
.
F: HYPERLINK 'alto Attachments:
nc. - 2006 K-1 Esthetes for DBZ SOF »
April 12, 2007 FW: Jaspers - 2006 K-1 Estimate
Confidential VRF 00000009
To: Howe, Cam Front Hubsher, Else Notes: Please send to Harry Beier and cc rre and U. —Original Message--- Front Lee, 
David Sent: Thursday,
April 12, 2007 11:56 AM To: Hubsher, Ekm Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Esthete th e ---OrigInal Message--- Front 
Hubsher, Etse Sent Thursday,
Apra 12, 2007 11:52 AM To: Lee, David Subject: FW: leepers - 2006K-1 Esthete DL..ls this suffident arts for CH to send 
to Harry Beier? ---Orighall
Message--- Front Howe, Cara Sent: Thursday, Aprl 12, 2007 11:41 AM To: Hubsher, Else Subject: FW: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 
Esthete Am I okay to send
to Harry Beier ---- Original Message—  Front tee, Mind Sent: Thursday. Alarl 12, 200710:49 AM To: Fbod, Brad; Sunterac, 
Robert; Hubsher, Else
Cc Howe, Cara Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2006 K-I Esthete ok --Original Message— Front Fbod, Brad Sent: Thursday, April 12, 
2007 10:43 AM To:
Sunterac, Robert; Hubsher, Elise; Lee, David Cc: Howe, Cara Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Estivate The K-1 statement 
plus his portion of Unrealized is
$110k less than the year end statement The Is reasonable glven the data that we used for the K-1 esthetes. NY state tax 
s not referenced on the K-1
esthete, however I discussed with Brian McGrath and the relathe nurrbers makes sense. Federal taxable hone as reported 
on the K-I esthete a higher
than the NY source that we have estimated for len So, we are good to go. ----Original Message--- Front Sarberac, Robert 
Sent: Thursday, April 12,
2007 8:56AM To: Hubsher, Erse; Lee, David Cc Howie, Cam; Eked, Brad Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Esthete Pt 
coordinate wth Brad ---Original
Message---- Front Hubsher, Else Sent: Thursday, Aprl 12, 2007 7:41 AM To: Lee, David; Surrberac, Robert Cc Howe, Cara 
Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2006
K-1 Esthete Ok. CH can check the nos we sent at year end. We wi not send this out until we do so. DL do you want to send
thls once checked or should
we? --Original Message---- Front Lee, David Sent: Thursday, Aprl 12, 2007 7:28 AM To: Hubsher, Else; Sunterac, Robert Cc
Howe, Cara Subject:
RE: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Esthete Yes, someone pease double deck total krone and nY state tax notch Ns year end statement 
first? ---Original
Message--- Front Hubsher, Ste Sent: Wednesday, Aprl II, 20076:20 PM To: Survberac, Robert Lee, David Cc Howe, Cara 
Subject: Fw: Jeepers
2006 K-1 Esthete Ok to send? ----- ---- Sent from ny Biackerry Wireless Device — Original Message --- Front McGrath, 
Brian To:
Hubsher, Erse; Howe, Cam; Whte, Mole Cc Sunterac, Robert; So, EVa; Warren, Clifford Sent Wed Apr 11 17:55:04 2007 
Subject: Jeepers - 2006 K-1
Esthete Else, We spoke earlier today wth Bob S on leepers Inc & he Is OK for us to proceed and send the 2006 K-1 
Esthete. I have attached t to this
e-m3L Please let blow quest n Ertin T. McGrath, CPA Senior Tax Ma D.B. Zwlm &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue
New York NY 101 us 51 Direct: Fax: MoblelliMillErret <rialto
Apr112, 2007 RE: leepers - 2006 K-1 Estimate
To: Fbod, Brad; Surd:erect Robert; Hubsher, Else CC: Howe, Cara Front Lee, David Notes: ok Message---- Front Eked, Brad 
Sent:
Thursday, April 12, 2007 10:43 AM To: Sterberac, Robert; Hubsher, Else; Lee, David Cc: Howe, Cara Subject: RE: leepers •
2006 K-1 Esthete The K-i
statement plus his portion of Unrealized is $110k less than the year end statement. This is reasonable given the data 
that we used for the K-1 esthetes.
NY state tax is not referenced on the K.1 esthete, however 1 discussed wth Brian McGrath and the relathe numbers makes 
sense. Federal taxable income
as reported on the K-1 esthete is higher than the W source that we have estirmted for him So, we are good to go. 
Message--- Front
Surrberac, Robert Sent: Thursday, Aprl 12, 2007 8:56 AM To: Hubsher, Else; Lee, David Cc: Howe, Cam; Flood, Brad 
Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2006 K-I
Esthete Pk coordinate with Brad ----Original Message-- Front Hubsher, Elise Sent: Thursday, Apri112, 2007 7:41 AM To: 
Lee, David; Surrberac,
Robert Cc Howe, Cara Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2036 K-1 Esthete Ok. CH can check the nos we sent at year end. We wi not 
send this out until we 63 so.
DL do you want to send this once checked or shoukt we? —Original Message--- Front Lee, David Sent: Thursday, April 12, 
2007 7:28 AM To:
Hubsher, Erse; Sunterac, Robert Cc Howe, Cara Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Esthete Yes, scaeone pease double check 
total Wont and nY state
tax notch his year end statement first? --Original Message--- Front Hubsher, Else Sent: Wednesday, Apr1111, 2007 6:20 PM
To: Surrberac, Robert
Devil CC: Howe. Can Subject: Fw: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Esthete Ok to send?  Sent from in/ Bladd3erry Wireless Device
Orighal Message --- Front McGrath, Bran To: Hubsher, Ease; Howe, Cam; White, Nicole Cc Sunterac, Robert; So, Eva; 
Warren, Clifford Sent: Wed Apr
11 17:55:04 2007 Subject: leepers - 2006 K-1 Estimate Else, We spoke earlier today with Bob S on leepers Inc & he Is OK 
for us to proceed and send the
2006 K-I Esthete. I have attached it to this e-rrel. Please let us know if b • n Br n T h CPA Senior Tax
Co. 745 Frei Avenue York, k, NY 10151 Direct: Fax: Mobile: Ent
April 12,2007 Mir:tapers - 2006 K-1 Estimate
To: Lee, Davki; Hubsher, Else; Flood, Brad CC: Howe, Cara Front Surrberac, Robert Notes: Brad: Pb perrormthe atecls DI. 
pointed out below. Thanks -
—Original Message--- Front Lee, David Sent: Thursday, April 12, 2007 7:28 AM To: Hubsher, Elise; Surrberac, Robert Cc 
Howe, Cara Subject: RE:
Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Esthete Yes, someone pease double deck total home and nY state tax notch his year end statement fist?
Message--
- Front Hubsher, Else Sent: Wednesday, April 1 1, 2007 6:20 PM To: Surrberac, Robert; Lee, David Cc: Howe, Cam Subject: 
Fw: leepers - 2006 K-1
Esthete Ok to send? -  Sent from ny ElackEtny Wireless Device -- Original Message -- From McGrath, Brian To: Hubsber, 
Eire;
Howe, Cara; Whte, No* CC Surrberac, Robert; So, &a; Warren, Clifford Sent: Wed Apr II 17:55:04 2007 Subject: Jeepers - 
2006 K-1 Esthete Else,
We spoke earlier today with Bob S on leepers Inc & he is OK for us to proceed and send the 2006 K-I Esthete. I have 
attached k to this eireL Please let
us
Cirect Fax: n tobte.
a
Errral mato
D.B. Avenue New York, NY 10151
April 12, 2007 RE Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Estimate
To: Lee, David; Sunterac, Robert CC: Howe, Cara Front Hubsher, Use Notes: Ok. CH can theca the nos we sent at year end. 
we WI not send this out
until we don DI do you want to send this once checked or should we? —Orighal Message— Front Lee, David Sent: Thursday, 
April 12, 2007 7:28
AM To: Hubsher, Else; Sunterac, Robert Cc Howe, Cara Subject: RE: Jeepers • 2006 K-1 Esthete Yes, someone pease double 
deck total intone and nY
state tax notch his year end statement first? --Original Message-- Front Hubsher, Else Sent: Wednesday, April 11, 2007 
6:20 PM To: Surrberac,
Robert Lee, David Cc Howe, Cara Subject: Fw: leepers - 2006 K-1 Estimate Ok to send? ----_-------------•---- Sent from 
ny blackball/ Wireless Device
-- Original Message -- Front McGrath, Bran To: Hubsher, Use; Howe, Cara; Whte, Nicole Cc: Surrberac, Robert; So, Eva; 
Warren, Clifford Sent: Wed
Apr 11 17:55:04 2007 Subject: Jeepers - 2006 K-I Esthete Elise, We spoke earlier today vrth Bob S on leepers Inc & he is
OK for us to proceed and send
the 2006 K-1 Esthete 1 have attached t to this e-rreL Please let us know r n CPA Senior
' &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151 Direct: Fax: Mobile: Erret
<rmit° 11.11.11.111
AprU 12, 2007 RE Jeeps,* - 2006 K-1 Estimate
To: Hubsher, Elbe; Surrberac, Robert CC: Howe, Cara Front Lee, David Notes: Yes, someone pease double check total income
and nY state tax notch his
year end statement fist? -----Original Message From Hubsher, Use Sent: Wednesday, krill, 2007 6:20 PM To: Surrberac, 
Robert Lee, David Cc
Howe, Cara Subject: Fw: lepers - 2006 K-I Esthete Ok to send? --------- Sent from ny Blackberry Wheless Device — 
Original Message -
-- Front McGrath, Ben To: Hubsher, Else; Howe, Cara; White, Nicole Cc: Sunterac, Robert; So, Eva; Warren, Erhard Sent: 
Wed Apr 11 17:55:04 2007
Subject: leepers - 2006 K-I Esthete Elise, We spoke earlier today wth Bob S on Jeepers Inc & he is OK for us to proceed 
and send the 2006 K-I
Esthete. I have attached It to this e-rrel. Please let us know uest n . Thanks Ben Brian T. McGrath, CPA Senior Tax Mena
r
D.& Zw'nue New York, NY 10151 Diect: Fax: Mobile:
<mato
April 12, 2007 ItEr 3espers - 2006 K-1 Estimate
Confidential VRF 00000010
To: Sunterac, Robert; Hubsher, Elise; Lee, David CC: Howe, Cara Front Flood, &ad Notes: The K-1 statement pass his 
portion of Unrealized is $11Ok
less than the year end statenent. This is reasonable given the data that we used for the K-1 estimates. NY State tax is 
not referenced on the K-1
estimate, however I discussed with than mairath and the ramie nun0ers rrekes sense. Federal taxable Income as reported 
on the K-1 estimate is higher
than the NY source that we have estimated for him So, we are good to go. --Origami Message-- Front Sunterac, Robert 
Sent: Thursday, April 12,
2007 8:56AM To: Hubsher, Eke; Lee, David Cc. Howe, Cara; Flood, Brad Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Esthete Pb 
coordinate will Brad ----Original
Message-- Front Hubsher, Eke Sent: Thursday, Apd 12, 2007 7:41 AM To: Lee, David; Sunterac, Robert Cc: Howe, Cam 
Subject: RE: Jeepers - 2006
K-i Etiolate Ok. CH can deck the nos we sent at year end. We MI not send This out until we do so. DL do you want to send
this once checked or should
we? --Original Message-- Front Lee, David Sent: Thursday, Aprl 12, 2007 7:28 AM To: Hubsher, Elise; Surrberac, Robert Cc
Howe, Cam Subject:
RE: Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Estimate Yes, someone pease double check total Income and nY state tax match his year end 
statement fast? ---Origkial
Message-- Front Hubsher, Eke Sent: Wednesday, April 11, 2007 6:20 PM To: Surrberac, Robert; Lee, David Cc: Howe, Cara 
Subject: Fw: Jeepers -
2006 K-1 Estimate Ok to send? Sent from ny Bad eery Wireless Device --- Original Message --- Front McGrath, Brian To:
Hubsher, Else; Howe, Cam; White, Nicole Cc Surrberac, Robert So, Eva; Warren, Clifford Sent: Wed Apr 11 17:55:04 2007 
Subject: leepers - 2006 K-1
Estimate Eke, We spoke earlier today with Bob S on Jeepers Inc & he is OK for us to proceed and send the 2006 K-1. 
Estimate. I have attached a to this
eereL Please let us know if ou have a re-questialdrian Briaraf rilh, Avn
New York, NY 10151 Direct: Fax Noble: Erret <mete
April 12, 2007 RE. Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Estimate
To: Hubsher, Eke; Lee, David CC: Howe, Cam; Flood, Brad Front Sumberac, Robert Notes: Ms coordnate with Brad ---Origeol 
Message Front
Hubsher, Eke Sent: Thursday, Apr/ 12, 2007 7:41 AM To: Lee, David; Sun0erac, Robert Cc Howe, Cara Subject: RE: Jeepers -
2006 K-1 Esthete Ok
CH can check the nos we sent at year end. We Ml not send this out until we do so. DL do you want to send this once 
decked or shouki we? —
-Original Message-- Front Lee, David Sent: Thursday, April 12, 2007 7:28 AM To: Hubsher, Eke; Sunterac, Robert Cc: Howe,
Cara Subject: RE:
Jeepers - 2006 K-1 Estimate Yes, someone pease double check total income and nY state tax match his year end statement 
first? —Original Message---
- Front Hubsher, Eke Sent: Wednesday, April 11, 2007 6:20 PM To: Sunterac, Robed; Lee, David Cc Howe, Cam Subject: Fw: 
Jeepers - 2006 K-1
Esthete Ok to send? Sent from ny ElackElerry Wireless Device —Original Message ---From McGrath, Brian To: HubSher, Eise;
Howe, Cam; White, Moak Cc Surrberac, Robert So, Eva; Warren, Clifford Sent: Wed Apr 11 17:55:04 2007 Subject: Jeepers - 
2006 K-1 Estimate Eke,
We spoke earlier today wth Bob Son Jeepers Inc & he is OK for us to proceed and send the 2006 K-1 Estimate. I have 
attached ft to this e-rred. Please let
us knrw  r ou have any quesUons. Thank Bean th, r ax Mana er D.& Zwin &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151
Direct: Fax: litIologe Bret
April 13, 2007 D.B. Zwlrn Special Opportunkles Fund, LP. - Q1 Tax Information - Jeepers Inc.

To: 13eler, Harry*Financial Trust ConpanY Epstein &Co.) (harryanysgilcoom)' Front 1782 & Co. Investor Relations Notes: 
<fle://
dbzco.corMglobahlocahshared specopps OperatbrteAccounting We:020070;11 MS Ur - Wthhelitpdf letters \ Q1-2OO7 08.2 SOF LP
MS WH Letter -
Jeepers Inc. pdf > Harry, Attached please find important correspondence regarding Q12007 New York State sourced ilCOrre.
Please note that this is
dated material, wh ion by hank you for your tire. lOnd ands D.B. Zwkn &Co., LP. 74 F Av , 18th Floor
New York, NY 10151 Phone Fax HYPERLIMemailto <matte
May 31, 2007 Harry Seller's new email address
To: Lee, David CC: Howe, Cara Front I-kosher, Elise Notes: Ok we nail  reseed ----- Sent from ny BtackBerry Wireless 
Device —
Original Nesse -- Front Lee Yid To: Hubsher, Eke Sent: Thu May 31 12:15:31 2007 Subject: RE: 2006 Tax Estimate • Jeepers
Inc. harry has new
errel address   Front Hubsher, Elise Sent: Thursday, May 31, 2007 8:35 AM To: Lee,
David; Surrbe , e : : 2006 Tax attrate • Jeepers Inc.   Front Howe, Cara Sent: Thursday,
May 31, 2007 8:25 AM To: Hubsher, Else Subject: FW: 2006 Tax Estimate -Jeepers Inc. Front Howe, Cam
Sent: Thu 4/12/2007 12:14 PM To: &der, Harry•Financial Trust Company (3. Epstein &Co.) Mperc Hu ,teher Else; Lee, David 
Subject:
2006 Tax Estimate - Jeepers Inc. Harry, Please see the attached 2006 tax estimate for Jeepers e expect to send out the 
final K1 early semen
Please contact ether David Lee or Else Hubsher I you have any questions. Thank you, Cara
Cara Howe Investor Relations D.B. Zwlrn &Co. 745 Filth Avenue New York, NY 10151 Tit F:
June 08, 2007 D.B. Zaino Special Opportunkies Fund, LP. - Q2 Tax Information
To: lieller, leanyffinandalTruSt COrrparry (J. Epstein &Co.) (hanydnysglccom)' CC: tee, David; Hubdter, Ek e Front DEI2&
Co. Investor Relations
Notes: Harry, Attached please find important correspondence regarding Q2 2007 New York State sourced Incorre. Please 
note that lit is dated material,
which by Ju Fax you for your time. LP. 18th Floor New York, NY
10151 Fax HYPERUNK"mailto malt Attadurenis: <<Jeepers
Inc.. »
June 08, 2007 D.B.Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. • Q2 Tax Information
To: hbelleranysgrratcorn CC: Lee, David; Hubsher, ase; Whte, Nicole Front DEG &Co. Investor Relations Notes: Harry, 
Attached please find
npurtant correspondence regarding Q2 2007 New York State sourced Income. Please note that this is dated neterbl, which 
rre uire action by
2 Thank you for your Urne. lend R D LP. 7 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 one
Fax HYPERLDIrmalto <trait° Attadwents: <<Jeepers Inc.. »
June 08, 2007 FW:JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE
To: White, NiXrie; Have, Cara; Hubsher, Eke; Sunterac, Robert; Warren, Cifford Front Lee, David Notes: Ciff, can we 
double check that their
guestimates correct given the NYS C-corp? Front White, Nicole Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007 4:50 PM To: Lee, David Cc: 
Howe, Cara; Hubsher,
ENse Subject: JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE David, Please approve the attached eerail to Harry Felker for Q2 tax Infometion 
for Jeepers. Once approved
do you want to send it or  from 7 estor Relatbns D.& amen & Co. 745 Filth Avenue, 18th Floor New
York NY 10151 Phone: Fax: Attachments: «Errbeddedlent D.B. Zwtn Special Opportunities
Fund, LP. • Q2 Tax Inforrretion>>
June 08, 2007 JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE
To: lee, David CC: Hone, Cara; Hubsher, Else Notes: David, Please approve the attached eiral to Harry Beier for Q2 tax 
WormatIon for Jeepers.
Once approved do you want to send it or shout' we send from the IR inbox? Thanks Neale White Investor Relations D.B. Nen
& Co. 745 Ffth Avenue,
18th Floor New Veer, NY 10151 Fborie: Fax: Attadvrents: «Mbeddedterrt D.B. Zwirn Special
Opportunities Fund, LP. - Q2 Tax inforniation»
June 08, 2007 RE:JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE
Confidential VRF 00000011
To: Lee, David; White, Nicole; Howe, Cara; Hubsher, Else; Sterberac, Robert CC: McGrath, Brian; So, Eva Front Warren, 
Clifford Notes: thet esthete
was done on the same basis as all, which could nerdy be 110% of last year's From Lee, David Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007 
6:14 PM To: White,
Nicole; Howe, Cara; Rasher, Else; Sunterac, Robert; Warren, Clifford Subject: FW: JEERERS - PLEASE APPROVE Off, on we 
double died that their
guestirrete k correct given the NYS C-corp?   Front White, Nicole Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007 4:50 PM To: Lee, David Cc:
Howe, Cam; Hubsher,
Elise Subject: JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE David, Please approve the attached e-nel to Harry Baler for Q2 tax lifforrretion
for Jeepers. Once approved
do you want to send it or nd front 7 . estor Relations MB. Zvekn & Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New
York NY 10151 Phone: Fax:
June 08, 2007 Re:JFEPERS - PLEASE APPROVEok to send then
To: Warren, Orford; White, Nicole; Howe, Cam; Hubsher, Eke; Surrberac, Robert CC: hk:Grath, &km; So, Elsa Front Lee, 
David Notes:
-- Sent from my BlackBerry Wireless Handheld ---Original Message -- Front Warren, Orford To: Lee, David; White, Male: 
Howe, Cam; Hubder,
Else; SurrberaC, Robert Cc: McGrath, Brian; So, Eva Sent: Fri Jun 08 18:34:59 2007 Subject: RE: JEEPERS • PLEASE APPROVE
thet estimate was done on
the same basis as al, which could merely be 110% of last year's   Front Lee, David Sent: Friday, June 08, 2007
6:14 PM To: White, Nicole; Howe, Cam; Hubsher, Eke; Surrberac, Robert; Warren, Clifford Subject: FW: JEEPERS - PLEASE 
APPROVE Cif, on we
double check that the! guestlmte k correct given the NYS C-corp?  From White, Nicole Sent: Friday, June 08,
2007 4:50 PM To: Lee, Davkl Cc Howe, Cam; Hubsher, Elise Subject: 3EEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE David, Please approve the 
attached e-rrel to Harry
Beier for Q2 tax tforrretIon for Jeepers. Once approved do you want to send It or rom the IR bbox? ThaN Ntole White 
Investor
Relations D.& Zwlm &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York NY 10151 Phone: Fax:
June 18, 2007 D.B.ZwIrn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Quarterly Account Statement
To: Feller, Harry*leepers, Inc. CC: Lee, David; Hubsher, Else Front DR & Co. Investor Relabons Notes: <fle://
WINco.com\ globallocakshared \ specopps \ Operatsons \ Accounting \ Investors \Onshore Staterrents \ 2007 1, LP 
Statements \Q1 07 LP StaterrentsV Q107
Statenent - Jeepers Inc. pcff > Harry, Attached please find the 2007 Q1 capital account staterrent for your invesbnent h
the D.B. ZwIrn Specbl
SMOpportu Fu . f to contact us if y rds, D. ,& Dam &Co. LP. 745 Nth Avenue New York, NY
10151T: F
I
HYPERL1NK "make: sneRo . Attedurents: «CP Q107
Statement - Jeepers Inc. > >
June 18, 2007 Jeepers Inc statement - Q12007
To: Lee, David CC: Surrberac, Robert; Hubsher, Eke; White, Nicole Notes: David - Can you please confirm that we on send 
the attached Jeepers Q1
statement to Harry Can Howe D.& ZwttoiliailSew York, NY 10151
T F: = —
FrYPE*LIWITBUI MA
<nulit Attadvrents:
«id? 91 07 Statement- Jeepers Inc.pd» «2007 tented urn iy.x »
July 26, 2007 D.E. Zwlrn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - 2006 Estimated K-1- Jumpers Inc.
To: Feller, Harry”eepers, Inc. (hbelerOnysgrrellcom)' Front D8Z &Co. Investor Relations Notes: <file://
Mdb1Co•CorrkgbbablocaRSharecRSpecoppS \ Operations \ Accountkig \Tax \ 2006 \Tax Coherence WP's & PWC Requests \K-1 
Investor Tax Esthetes 1 LP - Rev
Btim 06 K-1 to Investors dtd 7-25-07Vee pets Inc. - DBZ SOF IP - 06 Rev EsteiK-1.pdf> Harry, Please see the attached 
2006 estknabad K-1. Please
note that the attac detai i we provided to you In AptRegards, D.& avirn &Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor
New York,NY 10151 h Phone Fax IROdb2CO.COm AttaChinents: <sleepers Inc - DM SOF LP - 06 Rev EstimK-1.pdf>>
July 26, 2007 RE: JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE (DL approves revised K-1 estimate)
To: White, Nicole CC: Howe, Cara; Hubsher, Fdse Front Lee, David Notes: ok _ _ Front White, Woe Sent: Thursday, July 26,
2007 5:57 PMTo:
Lee, David Cc: Howe, Cara; Mather, Else Subject: HERBS - PLEASE APPROVE DaviTd, Please approve the attached draft enal 
to Harry Beller with
Jeepers Inc's reused K- ed we Nicole White D.& Zwin &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New
York NY 10151 Phone: Fax:
August 16, 2007 D.B. Zwlrn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Quarterly Account Statement
To: Seller, Hamystepers, Inc. Front C&Z &Co. Investor Rebtbns Notes: Harry, Attached please did the 2007 Q2 capital
account statement for your !we wen IIPIIPPESpecial Opportunr• Please feel free to contact us if you have arty questions.
Best
Regards, MB Zwtn &Co., LP. 745 Firth Avenue New York, NY 10151 T: : <ft://
Widco.comitioballocaksharedspecoppstpperations \ Accounting \ Investors \Onshore Staterren.s..tatenents\Q2 07 LP 
Staterrents \ PDF
Staterrents \IP 07 Q2 Staterrent - Jeepers Inc.pdf >
August 16, 2007 RE:3espers - Please approve
To: Howe, Cam Front Lee, David Notes: ok to go Front Howe, Cam Sent: Thursday, August 16, 2007 3:43 PM To: Lee, David Cc
Hubsher,
Eke; Whte, Mode; Lau, Kt Subject: Jeepers - Please approve David - Please approve the attached quarterly staterrent 
email to Harry 8e1er before we
&Co. 745 Filth Avenue New York, NY 10151 T:
ii F: LINICrreitt <mato
September 07, 2007 D.B.IvArn Special Opportunities Fun, . - x relation
To: &eller, Harry'Jeepers, Inc. IMIII.. Front DBZ & Co. Investor Rebtbns Notes: <file://
\\dbzco.corriglobakkocakshared\specopps pera ns ccounting \Tax \ 2007Q3 2007 UGIALETIEFtS\WIDIHELCApdf lettersUeepers 
Inc. - 3Q 2007
NYS.pdf > Harry, Attached please find important correspondence regarding Q3 2007 New York State sourced incorre. Please 
note that this is dated
material, whit may re ' e action September 17 2007. Thank you for your tine. ., LP. 745 Fifth Av
New York, NY 10151 Phone Fax HYPEREMIC-mato ttachrrents <nee
: «Jeepers Inc. - 3 007 NYS. > >
September 07, 2007 lEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE
To: Lee, David CC: Howe, Cara; Lau, id; Hubsher, Else Notes: David, Please approve the attached draft erre' to Harry 
Eder with Jeepers Inc's Q3
2007 NYS Lettersa irgaaageoved we • Nicole White D.B. Zwirn &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY
10151 Phone: Ell Fax: Attachments: «Errteddedtem 0.6 Zwl'n Special Oppontinties Fund, LP.
-Q3 Tax Inform:ion > >
September 07, 2007 RE:JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE (DL approves Q32007 NYS Letter)
Confidential VRF 00000012
September 16, 2007
To: White, lecole Front Lee, David Notes: ok   Front White, Nicole Sent: Friday, September 07, 2007 3:34 PM To: Lee, 
David Cc: Howe, Cara;
Lau, Mt; Hubsher, Else Subject: JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE David, Please approve the attached draft ermi to Harry Beier 
wth keen Inc's Q3 2007 WS Le er (wed we
awl send it f m Cripple White D.B. Zwirn &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone: Fax:
September 16, 2007 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - 2006 Estimated K-1 - Jaspers Inc.
To: 'Beier, Harry•leepers, Inc. ' Front 0132 & Co. Investor Relations Notes: <fie://
\\clbsco.conAgiolmaboaasharethspecepps peratici ccounting \ Tax \ 2006thwestor K-1 Esthetes 9-14-07Meepers Inc. - 
2006K-1 Esttn9-14-07.pdf>
Harry, Please see the attached 2006 esti-rated K-1. Please note that the attached •nt detal provided to you hinny. 
Regards D.B. 2Wirn &Co.
P.
745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New r W10151 Phone Fax HYPERLINK
Trait ttachorents <mato : «leepers Inc. - 2006 K-1 Estkn9-14-07.pdf»
Ret3EEPERS - PLEASEAPPROVE (DI. approves 2006 Estimated K-1)
To: White, Nicole Front tee, David Notes: Ok ----------- Sent from ny re-vaderry Wireless Handheld  Orighai Message -- 
Front White,
Nicole To: Lee, David Cc Hubsher, Else; Howe, Cara Sent: Sat Sep 15 22:41:30 2007 Subject: JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE 
David, Please approve the
attached draft enell to Harry Beier with Jeepers Ines 2006 Esemated - ved • Node Whte D.B. Zavhi &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 
18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone:
Fax:
October 02, 2007 Second email address for Many Beller - pis send IC•1 correspondence
To: Be David Notes: HYPERLINK
"Yreao <rtaRo > as secon ary errel for Harry Beier David C. Lee Presklent D. B.
ZwIn'i & Co. LP. /45 Ffth Avenu 1 tin r New York
"rrelto misito
fax HYPERLDE
October 13, 2007 D.S. Zvern Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - 2006 K-1
To: 'Beier, Harrysleepers, Inc.k  CC: 'Beier, Harrysleepers, Inc. ( Mit Front EC &Co. Investor Relations
Noies: <file://VdthiC0.0009 OpexatIonsVtocounting We/12006 R FINAL K-1 FOR DISIRIB ON OCT 131f \188
-FINANCIAL TRUSTCOMPANY, INC.pdf> <fle:/Mdteco.comlalobaabcaasharetaspecoeps1Operations\AccountWax\2006\INVESIOR FINAL 
K-1.'S FOR
DISTRIB ON OCT 131Thin1-3EEPERS INC..pdf> To the kwestors of D.& Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP.: Attached please 
find your 2006 Schedule
K-1. As Of the date of &suing your Schedule K-1, there are a number of pending adjustments that adi affect the GAAP 
basis financial staten-erits. Cue to
the pending adjustments, the book income and ending capital account balances, when fibbed, wit likely be dfferent than 
the amounts reflected on your
Schedule K-1. For this reason, we have hdkated that the metal account on your Schedule K-1 is not presented on a GAAP 
basis (Part II, Information
About the Partner, Item N, Partner's capital account analysis, has been diethed 'Other (explain)" rather than TIAAP'). 
We do not believe the pendkag
adjustments to have a material lnpact on the tax term reported on your 2006 Schedule K-1. However, we cannot predict 
with certainty that such
adjustments will not require us to amend the 2006 tax return and issue revLsed Schedule K-1's, or request an admhistr to
correct a
previously fled tax return. Please consult your tax advisor. If y , ph II Cliff men at . Sincerely, IX 8.
Zwkn & Co., LP. 745 Ffth Avenue 18th Floor New Y NY 10151 Phone Fax HYPERUNK
"BLOCKED::81.00ICED:Tralto Attadvrents: «188-FINANCIA RUST C , INC.ptlf» «001-JEEPERS
INC.pdf»
December 18, 2007 JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE
To: Lee, David CC: Howe, Cara; Hubsher, Elise Notes: David, Please approve the attached draft erred to Hany Beier with 
Jeepers InCS restated
Thanks, Nicole White D.  ZwIrn &Co. 745 Fitt Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone: Fax:
12/31/06 capital account statement. I have attached their eerier statement for your reference. will send t from the IR 
lnbox.
Attachments:  «Enbeddeditent D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Restated 12/31/0...count Statement»
«LP Final Q4 Revised Statement • Jeepers Inc.pdf»
December 18, 2007 Re JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE
To: White, Nicole CC: Howe, Cara; Hubsher, Elise Front tee, David Notes: ok From White, Kathie Sent: Tuesday, Deoerrber 
IS, 2007 3:03 AM
To: Lee, David Cc Howe, Cara; Hubsher, Bse Subject: JEFFERS - PLEASE APPROVE David, Please approve the attached draft 
erre. to Harry Beier with
Jeepers Inds restated 12/31/06 capital account statement. I have attached their earlier statement for your reference. 
Once a ed
the IR inbox. Thanks Nicole  Whte D.& Zwkn &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone: Fax:
December 18, 2007 FM JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE (DL approves restated 12/31/06 capital account statement)
To: White, Ncole CC: Howe, Cam; Hubsher, Ease Front Lee, David Notes: ok From: White, Nicole Sent: Tuesday, December 18,
2007 3:08 AM
To: Lee, David Cc Howe, Cam; Hubsher, Else Subject JEEPERS - PI PACS APPROVE David, Please approve the attached draft 
enel to Harry Beier with
kepers Ines restated 12/31/06 capital account statement. I have attached their earlier statement for your refe . 
approved w wsend m
the IR . Than Nicole White D.& Zwkn &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York NY 10151 Phone: Fax:
January 04, 2008 DA Zviim Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Tax Information
To: 'Beier, Hany'lleepers, Inc. ' CC: Beier, liarreJeepers, Inc (JEDennOattgbbainet)' Front DEC & Co. Investor Relations
Notes: Harry, Attached please find Important correspondence regarding 2007 tax hforrretbn. If applicable to your 
irwestment in the OB. Zwkn Special
Opportunities Fund, LP., please respond by February 1, 2008 for the WS Nonresident Partner Withholding and February 28, 
to Reis
Electbns. Thank ou for our time. and Regards, D.B. Zeta &Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York NY 10151 Phone
Attachments: «leeperS Inc - 2007 ConpOdte Electbn.pdf» «NYS Non-Res Withholding n -
11. fpcall»
January 10, 2008 leepers - Please approve
To: Lee, David CC: Hubsher, Fiese; White, Nicole Notes: DL - Can you please approve sending the attached tax errei to 
Jeeps
Cara Howe D.B. brim York, NY 10151 T: F:
HYPERUNIC 'trait° neap Attachments: « arm D..,
SpeCal Opportunities Fun, L.P. - Q4 lax inforraticir
February 13,, 2008 Jeepers, Inc. redemption notice reed - DBZ does required
Confidential VRF 00000013
February 13, 2008
To: Howe, Cara Front FAXCOM Fax Sewer Notes: cfle://\\dozco.comi tgbbehbcansharechspecoppsUnvestor FtelationsLInvestor
CorrespondenceVbandal 'Mist ConpanyVeepers Inc Redemption Notice 2.13.08.pdf> FAXCOM RECEIVED FAX REPORT
Received Time : 02/13/2008 12:56 (GMT-05:00) Resut : OK Description : Al pages received OK Result Code : 0000 Pages 
Received: 0004
Bad Pages : 0000 Remote 1SI : Conned Time : 0363 Seconds Fax line :1 Routing ID : 9652 Baud Rate : 14400 Bps The fax b
kW uded as a PDF document attachment. Attachments: «LGA-WFX-01_0802131757193317. pdf > >
March 27, 2008 2007 Tax Eakins - Jeepers
To: Beier, Harryaleepers, Inc. MW CC: Beier, Han-yodeepers, Inc. Front Schumacher, Suzanne Notes:
chle://Wdb2c0.com\gbbahlocahs pspperatbnsLAccountIng \Tax \ 2007LlnY petters -081 SOF LP 3.26.08
EstirretesVeepers Inc. - DBZ SOF LP - 2007 Estim K-I.pdf> Please see the attached 2007 tax estrrate. We ex to send out 
the final K-I In the
sumer. Sincerely, D.B. Zwlm &Co., LP. 745 Pith Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone ax HYPERLIME
labdced::EILOCICED::mit0 Attachments: «Jeepers Inc. D82 SOF Us - 2007 Estim >
April 11, 2008 JEEPERS - PLEASE APPROVE
To: lee, Davkl CC: Hubsher, Elise; Schumacher, Suzanne Notes: David, Please approve the attached draft email to Harry 
Beier wth Jeepers Inc's 1
2008 NYS Letter. Thanks, Nicole White D.B. Zwirn & Co. 745 FifthAvenue, 18th Floor New York NY 10151 Phone Fax
Attadirrents: «Enbeddedaent D.EL Zwin Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Q1 Tax Inform ion»
April 11, 2008 Re JEEPERS- PLEASE APPROVE (Pt approves email)
To: White, Nicole CC: Hasher, Efse; Schumacher, Suzanne Front Lee, David Notes: ok Front White, Nicole Sent: Friday, 
Apri 11, 2008 10:17
AM To: Lee, David Cc Hubsher, Eke; Schumacher, Suzanne Subject: JEEPERS - PI FASE APPROVE David, Please approve the 
attached draft erred to
h Joe rs Ines 1 2 Cole White 08. Zwkn &Co. 745 nth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone:
Fax:
June 25, 2008
To CC: Hubsher, Else; Howe, Cara; Jean Paul Hama Notes: Darren, Thank you for the attached nottkation to withdraw 
Jeepers,
Inc segments b the D.B. Zwkn Specbl Opportunities Fund LP. In order to process these redemptions, we wF need you to 
complete the attached
Request for Withdrawal of Interests form lOntly note, one document mist be =Meted for each available redemption date. 
The April 1, 2002 investment
IS available June 30, 2008, the September 1, 2002 kwestment is avalabie September 30, 2008, the December 1, 2002 
Investment is available December 31,
2008, the January 1, 2005 Investment k avaiable March 31, 2009 and the June 1, 2003 investment is avatable June 30, 
2009. Once the redenptbn
documents have been fully completed, please forward copies to or to review before sen0ig the originals to GbbeOp. F rut 
should you
Nicole White D. EL Zwen &CO. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone: Fax:
Attachrrents: «LGA-WFX4/1_0802131757193317.pdf» «DBZ Us Rederrption 12 07.
Redemption notice for Simper, Inc - reed via Fax
Performance
To: CC: Ferraro, Alicia Notes: May perfonrence numbers are not yet Malted. We we send the monthly performance emei as 
soon
as the numbers are avato We. The erre' wit be sent from D. B. Zwin Invest r Else Hubsher Managing Director Investor 
Relations & Marketing
D.B. Zwkn & Co. 745 Fifth Avenue 1&h Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone: E-iraN: HYPERUNK
'nit <maim
July 17, 2008 Current Wire Instructions
Notes: Dear Mr. Beier, We are In the process of updating our records and request that you please send us the current 
wire instructions for the following
account Invested In D.& ZovinS IOpportunities Fund LP.: perS Inc. Thank you, Suzanne Suzanne Schumacher D. B. Zwkn &Co. 
745 Finn
Avenue New York, NY 10151 T: F:
July 18,2008 Updated Wire Instructions for le opera Inc.- reed via email
Front Harry Beller Notes: Suzanne The Mowing are wiring instructions for Jeepers Inc: Bank Name: Ctibank, N.A.
*: M -3I86
For Cued • Bear Stearns a Co. Account New York NY ABA No.: 021-000-089
From Schumacher, Suzanne We  Sent: Thursday, July 17, 2008 5:34 PM To: Harry Balder Subject: Current Wire
Instructions Dear Mr. Bekr, We
For F • • .
ur records and request that you please send us the current wire Instructions for the
Account tr: 2-1-4 Thanks Harry
following account Invested In D.B. ZwIrn les • rs Inc. Thank you, Suzanne Suzanne Schurrecher D. B. ZWIrn &Co.
745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151 T F: This e-nel messages Intended only for the named recipient(s) above.
It nay contain confidential information. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notl fled that any use, 
dissemination, distribution or coiling
of this e-mail and any attachment(s) is Aridly prohibited. as Zwlrn &Co., LP. reserves the tilt to archive and mentor 
all e-rrei communications
through its networks. If you have received this e-ma I in error, please knnediateiy notify the sender by replying to 
this e-nod and delete the message and
any attachnent(s) from your system Thank you.
August 04,2008 Communications
Front davklleeedbzOo.COm Sent: 8/4/2008 8:17:31 AM To: Cc: Subject:
Communications Dear Harry: I received a telephone message as rre to cal you. In light of the threats of itigatbn made by
Jeffrey Epstein and
Jeepers, please rreke future communications to no  and anyone else at D.B. Zwkn & Co., L P. In walla. We wl respond 
directly to any such
comruntations or, ir appropriate, refer them to counsel. Sincerely, David Lee
August 04, 2008 Communications - Must be In va
Front Lee, David To: Beier, HarreleeperS, Inc. ' Cc Hubsher, Else; Howe, Cara Sent: Mon Aug 04 08:17:31 2008 Subject:
Comrunicatbris Dear Harry: I received a telephone message as am to call you. In light of the threats of itigatbn nude by
Jeffrey Epstein and
Jeepers, please make future corrrrunkatlans tone and anyone else at D.B. Zwkn &Co., LP. In writing. We w0 respond 
directly to any such
communication or, if appropriate, refer them to counsel. Sincerely, David Lee
August 22, 2008 D.8.2%Ini & Co, LP. - Investor Correspondence
We are current)/ n the process of updating our Investor records. If you would like to be removed ' ut an erred to
Thank you, MB. brim &Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151 T: F;
August 22, 2008 D.B.Zydrn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Quarterly Commentary
Confidential VRF 00000014
Attached please find the mast recent Investor commentary for the D.& Zwim Special Opportunkes Fund, LP. Please t us know
if ou have an uestbns Regards, D.&
Zwirn &Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone Fax
August 25, 2008 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Performance Information
Dear Investor. For the month ended July 31, 2008, D. 8. Zwkn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. posted an unaudited net 
return of -1.37%, brhging its
year-to-date net return to -11.83% Best Regards, D.B. Zwirn & Co., LP. Inportant Discbsures Performance is an unaudited 
rate of return based
on the market value of OIL Zwin Special Opportunities Fund, LP. (the "Fund"). Perfomence includes capital contributions 
and withdrawals, as applcable,
is net of fees and expenses and Includes the reinvestment of earnings. The returns are calculated net of rrenagerrent 
fees of 2% and an allocation/Incentive fee
of 20%. The Fund's fees nay be rrodWied or waived for certain investors. Please refer t0 the Fund's offering rrenorandum
for rrore
inforrmtbn regarding the Fund's fees. It should be rated that as a resat of certain factors Including among others, an 
investor's elgibby to participate in
"new Issues,* an investor's actual performance and actual fees nay differ born those reflected by the Fund. Investors 
should refer to their quarterly capital
account balance statement to determine their actual perforrronce return and the fees applied to their capital account. 
The Fund's unaudited rate of return
rmy Include prior period accounting adjustments, reciasstications and other items not relating to hvestment performance.
Future adjustments nay be made
to the returns, if deemed appropriate. The Fund contented operations on May 1, 2002. The Fund's market value has been 
detenrised in accordance with
the vakiation methodobgy set forth In the Fund's offering rrerrorandum It should be rioted that certain of the Fund's 
kwestments have been valued using fat
vakiatbn as deternined by the General Partner or third party sources. Past perfomence is no guarantee of future returns.
-Misdate b being
provided on a confidential basks by MB. Aviv &Co., LP. ('DB2 & Co?) solely for the informatbn of those persons to whomit
5 transmitted. This data is
proprietary information of DM &Co. and nay not be reproduced or otherwise citsserrinated in whole or In part without 
DelZ &Co.'s prior wrtten consent.
The kiforrretlon set forth herein does not purport to be complete and no obibatbn to update or otherwise revise such 
Hourellon Is being assured. No
person in any jurislictbn nay beat this tiforrretion as constituting ether an offer to sell or a solictation of an offer
to buy any interest in the funds. A
prospective subscrber mist rely solely on the terns of, and disclosure of Monteith In, the Fund's final offering 
rrerrorandum and related deponents,
which constitute the only bash on which subscriptions rmy be rrede. The Fund is a high-ft* investment vehicle that ls 
avalable only to quaMed individuals
or entities that are wiling to assure above average risk and anted !guilty. An Investment In the Fund is specula We and 
Involves a high degree of Mk The
terns and risk factors of the Fund are set out in is Confidential Memorandum which is avalable to qualified prospective 
Investors upon request.
September 08, 2008 D.8. Zwim Special Opportunities Fund, L,P. - Q3 Tax Information
Front Investor.Relations@dbzco.com Sent: 9/8/20082:50:52 PM To: Subject: D.B. Zerim Special
Opportunities Fund, LP. - Q3 Tax Information Attached please find important correspondence regarding Q3 2008 New York 
State sourced hone. Meese
note that this is dated material, which may recur • terrbe y Regards, all &Wm &C0., LP. 745
Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 PhOne Fax
September O8, 2008 MN: Jaspers- LP Investment
From Yang, Bo Sent: Monday, September 08, 2008 11:47AM To: Hubsher, Else Cc: Witte, Nicole; Cutler, Lawrence D. Subject:
RE: leepers - LP
Investment Hi, Erse, Below are details per your request: The value of Jeepers' June 1, 2003 Investment orighaly for 
610,000,000 - on June 30,
2007 and on December 31, 20076/30/07 $17,927,40912/31/07 $18,482,6527/31/08 $16,296,786 The vakie of ieepers' January 1,
200$
kwestrrert originally for $20,000,000 - on March 31, 2007 and on December 31, 2007. 3/31/07 $27,093,673 12/31/07 
$29,215,482 7/31/08 $25,760,289 Please let me
bow Y you have any meshes. Thanks, Bo Front Hubsher, Eke Sent: Monday, September 08, 200810:46
AM To: Yang, lb Cc White, Nicole; Cutler, Lawrence D. Subject: Jeepers - IP invesbyent lb, Can you provide the (oilmen 
hfometbri The value of
Jeepers' June 1, 2003 investment originally for $10,000,000 - on June 30, 2007 arid on December 31, 2007 The value of 
Jeepers' January 1, 2005
investment originaly for $20,000,000 - on March 31, 2007 and on Decenter 31, 2007. Thanks Eke Hubsher Mana ' Died*: 
Investor Relations
Marketing D.B. Zwkn & Co. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Flom New York, It' 10151 Phone: Erre!:
<motto
September 12, 2008 Re: Pis Approve - leepers
Front Sent: 9/12/2008 7:00:15 AM To: Subject: Re: P5Approve • Jeepers Ok
Sent from my Flip/ reless Handheld Front Howe, Cara To: tee, David Cc: Flutist:et, Ebe; Schurrocher, Suzann Sent Fri Sep
12
00:05:05 2008 Subject! P5 Approve - Jeepers David - Can you please approve the attached K-1 email to be sent to Jeepers?
Cara Howe U.R. /v.tn 8. Co 745 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10151
mato:
October O4, 2008 0.8. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Performance Information
Confidential VRF 00000015
Dear Investor, To better reflect the dissolution process inflated on March 31, 2008, in addelon to provking monthly and 
year-to-date net returns, we will
include a treasure which we believe better quantifies the performance of the recovery process. The metric, caged 
'Recovery Percentage," will reflect the
percent of March 31, 2008 value that has been Merbuted to Investors pus the current value of assets in the portfobo at 
current valuation levels. Upon
final cash cfrstrixekin, at the conclusion of the Mid down process, the Recovery Percentage wl reflect the percentage of
March 31, 2008 NAV that has
been returned to kited partners. From March 31, 2008 through August 31, 2008, Recovery Percentage for the D.& Zwirn 
Special Opportunities Fund,
LP. ("the Fund) totaled an unaudited 83.50%. For the month ended August 31, 2008, the Fund posted an unaudited net 
return of -6.68%, bringing its
year-to-date net return to -17.72%. Best Regards, D.B. Zwirn & Co., LP. Inportant DiSdoSureS Performance is an unaudited
rate of return based on
the market value of D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. (the Turd). Performance includes capital contributions 
and withdrawals, as applicable, is
net of fees and expenses and hdudes the reinvestment of earnings. The return are calculated net of rronagerrent fees of 
2% and an alocation/incentive
fee of 20%. The Fund's fees nay be modified or waived for certain Investors. Please refer to the Fund's offering 
memorandum for more information
regarding the Funds fees. It should be noted that as a result of certain factors incUdIng antng others, an Investors 
digitally to participate in -new issues,'
an investor's actual perfomance and actual fees tiny differ fromthose reflected by the Fund. Investors should refer to 
their quarterly capital account
balance statement to determine that actual performance return and the fees applied to their capital account. The Funds 
unaudited rate of return tiny
incitrie prior period acmunting adjustments, reclassifications and other kerns not relating to investment perforrrence. 
Future adjustments nay be made to
the returns, if decried appropriate. The Fund commenced operations on May 1, 2002. The Fund's rrerket van has been 
determined n accordance with the
vakation methodology set forth In the Funds offering memorandum It should be noted that certain of the Fund's 
Investments have been valued mew fair
valuation as deterrnned by the General Partner or third party sources. Recovery Percentage equals the sumo( al cash 
distrbutions slice March 31, 2008
plus the current month end NAV of the Fund, Onded by the March 31, 2008 NAV, expressed in percentage tents. Recovery 
Percentage wi reflect the
percent of March 31, 2008 NAV returned to investors ONLY when the final cash distnbution s made to investors. Prior to 
the final cash distribution the
Recovery Percentage is slimly a measure of cash delnbutions plus current valuation of the portfolio as a percentage of 
the March 31, 2008 NAV and should
not be relied upon as an assurance of actual recovery. Past performance s no guarantee of future returns. This data s 
being provided on a confidential
basis by D.& Zwtn &Co., LP. (108Z & Co.') solely for the Information of those persons to whom it k transmtted. Thk data 
is proprietary inforrmtion of
DE2 & Co. and Trey not be reproduced or otherwise disseminated In whole or in part without Cf2 &Co.% prior written 
consent. The ktonretion set forth
herein does not purport to be complete and no obligation to update or otherwise revise such information is being 
assumed. No person it any judwictIon may
treat tills infant-ethyl as constituting ether an offer to sell or a soildtation of an offer to buy any Interest in the 
funds. A prospective subscriber must
rely
solely on the tents of, and disdosme of reformation it, the Fund's final offering rrerrorandtrn and related documents, 
which constitute the only basis on
whkh subscriptions nay be mode. The Fund S a high-dsk investment veltle that k available only to quaffed Indtvtluals or 
entities that are willing to
assure above average risk and kited Ibukity. An Imestnent in the Funds speculative and involves a high degree of risk 
The terms and risk factors of
the Fund are set out in its Confidential Memorandum which is available to queried prospective Investors upon request.
October 20, 2008 D.B. Zwirn & Co., LP. - Investor Communication
Attached please find an important investor communkatbn that was sent to the shareholders of the D.& Zwirn Special 
Opportunities Fund, Ltd. Ths
comiunicaton t provided for your infontation on . As an investor is the IL& Zvotn Spectal Opportunities Fund, LP. no 
action k required. If you have
lease
Fax
at Regards, D.& twin &Co., L.P. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151
Phorx
October 27, 2008 D.B. Zwlm & Co., L.P. - Investor Communication
Attached please rind an Investor comrunicatbn that was sent to the shareholders of the IX& Zwtn SpedalOppartmitits F .
"a d for ur of me only. Regards, D.B. Zwin & Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Die".
Fax
November 11, 2008 D.B. Zwirn & Co, LP. - Deferral Vote Announcement
Dear Investor: Effective as of the close of business on Monday, November 10, 2008, D.B. Zwkn Special Opportunities Fund,
ltd. (the "Fund") received
the requisite consent from shareholders of the Fund to amend the Fee Deferral Agreement between 0. 8. Zwim &Co., LP. 
('DEIZCO') and the Fund.
Pursuant to the amendment, the distribution of the 2004 deferred fees wt be accelerated as follows: 0) 90% of the 2004 
deferred fees wi be paid from
the Fund to DBZCO within 30 days of the end of the current fiscal year; and (I) the remaking bakince fromthe deferral 
amount we be pad to DIIZCO In
2009 upon completion of the 2008 audited financial statements for the Fund, but no later than DeCentes 31, 2009 and 
adjusted for cha
12/31/08 NAV resu from Regards, D.B. Zwirn & Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151
Phone Fax
November 24 2008 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Performance Information
Confidential VRF 00000016
Dear Investor, To better reflect the dlssolutbn process stated on March 31, 2008, in addtion to providing monthly and 
year-to-date net returns, we Wil
Include a measure which we believe better quantifies the performance of the recovery process. The nettle, called 
'Recovery Percentage," will reflect the
percent of March 31, 2008 value that hes been distributed to hi/esters plus the current value of assets n the portfolio 
at current valuation levels. Upon
final cash distribution, at the conclusion of the wind down process, the Recovery Percentage wil reflect the percentage 
of Mardi 31, 2008 NIAV that has
been returned to kited partners. From Mardi 31, 2008 through September 30, 2008, Recovery Percentage for the D.& Zwen 
Special Opportunities
Fund, LP. ("the Fund") totaled an unaudted 71.62%. For the month ended September 30, 2008, the Fund posted an unaudted 
net return of -14.24%, bringing Its
year-to-date net return to -29.43%. Best Regards, D.& ben & Co., LP. Important Disclosures Perfonnance Is an unaudted 
rate of
return based on the rrerket value of D.& Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. (the "Fund"). Performance includes 
capital contributbris and withdrawals,
as applicable, Is net of fees and expenses and hdudes the reinvestment of eamings. The returns are calculated net of 
management fees of 2% and an
allocation/incentive fee of 20%. The Fund's fees nay be nodded or waived for testa Metes. Please refer to the Fund's 
offering memorandum for more
infonretion regarding the Fund% fees. It should be noted that as a result of certain factors including among others, en 
InveStors eagbility to paditipate h
"new Issues," an investort actual perforrrence and actual fees new differ from those reflected by the Fund. InveStors 
shoukl refer to their quarterly capital
account balance statement to detemlne their actual perfoarance return and the fees applied t0 their capital account. The
Fund's unaudted rate of return
may Include prior period accounting adjustments, reclassikatbns and other tens not relating to Investment perfarrence. 
Future adjustments nay be rrede
to the returns, If deemed appropriate. The Fund commenced operations on May 1, 2002. The Fund's market value has been 
detemined n accordance wth
the valuation methodology set forth in the Fund's offering memorandum It sherd be noted that certain of the Fund's 
investments have been valued using
fa valuation as determined by the General Partner or third party sources. Recovery Percentage equals the sum of al cash 
distrbutkins rare March 31,
2008 plus the current month end NAV of the Fuld, divided by the March 31, 2008 NAV, expressed in percentage terns. 
Recovery Percentage we reflect
the percent of March 31, 2008 NAV returned to Investors ONLY when the Thal cash thstrOution is made to Investors. Prior 
to the final cash distnbution the
Recovery Percentage is simply a measure of cash distributbns plus current valuation of the portfolio as a percentage of 
the Mardi 31, 2008 NAV and should
not be relied upon as an assurance of actual recovery. Past peforrrance Is no guarantee of Mute returns. This data 5 
being provided on a
confidential bash by D.B. Zwirn &Co., LP. r DBZ &Co.") solely for the information of those persons to vAiomitts 
transnItted. This data Is proprietary
Infonretbn of DBZ & Co. and trey not be reproduced or otherwise disseminated in whole or n part without DOZ &Co.'s prior
written consent. The
hfornation set forth herein does not purport to be complete and no obligation to update or otherwise revise such 
Infomation 5 being assumed. No person
ki any junsdictbn nay treat this Information as consttuting ether an offer to set or a sedation of an offer to buy any 
Interest in the funds. A prospective
subscrber mist rely solely on the tens of, and d5closure of information in, the Fund% foal offering memorandum and 
related documents, which constitute
the only basis on with subscriptions nay be node. The Fund is a high-risk hvestrrent vehicle that 5 ovate bie only to 
quaff led individuals or entities that
are wing to assure above average risk and limited liquidity. An investment in the Fund is specutatim and iwokes a high 
degree of risk. The terns and risk
(actors of the Fund are set out h its Confidential Memorandum which s ovate bie to quated prospectwe Investors upon 
request.
December 03, 2008 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Quarterly Commentary
Thank you for your Interest in D.B. Zwirn &Co., LP. Attached please find the rrost recent Investor comnonta for D.B. 
Zwirn s Aim o mimes
Fund, LP. Best Regards, D.B. Zwirn & Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone Fax
December 08, 2008 Company Name Change to: HBRK Associates Inc.

Front Harry Beier (rmilto Sent: Monday, Decenter 08, 2008 2:06 PM To: Harry Beier Subject: Just to clergy. I amstil
wth the sane organization. i Just changed Ions and the naive of the firm Thanks Harry Please update your records wth the
following
contact Inforrretbri for me: KIRK Associates Inc PO Box 400 New York NY 1015 t • -327
Harry Beier HORK Associates Inc. tel fax
I •
December 10, 2008 Harry request DL fax number
Front Lee, David • 10, 2008 10:20 AM To: 'Harry Beier' Cc: Hubsher, Ease Subject: RE: Front
Harry Beier [mew Sent: Wednesday, Cecenber 10, 2008 1 • • Subject: RE: David Please
provide ire with your fax minter Thanks Harry F rit Dav mato: Sent: Monday, December 08, 2008
6:40 PM To: Harry Beier Cc: Hubsher, Bse; Lebowitz, Seth; Subject: RE: Hany, Just for our records, an you provide us
sorrethhg &D]alfroman authorized signatory hdlcating that you are still authorized on behat of leepers? Front Harry 
Beier
[rrelto:hbeller@hbricassofetes.com] Sent: Monday, December OB, 2008 2:06 PM To: Harry Bele Subject: Just t0 clarify. I 
am set wth the same
organization. Oust changed locations and the name of the firm Thanks Harry ate your
information for me: HBRK Associates Inc PO Box 4 10150 Tel it : Fax a :
Harry Beller HBFtK Associates Inc tel fax Thts e-rrell message Is
intended only for the named rechient(s) above. It nay contain confidential Inforrretbn. you are no a en a recipient, you
are hereby notl fled
that any use, dissemination, distribution or copying of this circle and any attachment(s) is strictly prohibited. D.B. 
Zwirn &Co., LP. reserves the right to
archive and monitor al e-rreil cormunkatIons through is networks. If you have received this e-rml h error, please 
knrediately notify the sender by
reptylng to thls e-moll and delete the message and any attachment(s) fromyour system Thank you.
December 30, 2008 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Performance Informer:10n
Confidential VRF 00000017
Dear Investor, To better reflect the desoktion process initiated on Mardi 31, 2008, In addition to providing monthly and
year-to-date net returns, we via
include a measure which we befeve better quantifies the performance of the recovery process. The metric, called 
'Recovery Percentage," WI reflect the
percent of Mardi 31, 2008 value that has been distributed to investors pis the current value of assets in the portfolio 
at current valuation levek. Upon
final cash distribution, at the conclusion of the wind down process, the Recovery Percentage will reflect the percentage
of March 31, 2008 MV that has
been returned to linked partners. From March 31, 2008 through October 31, 2008, Recovery Percentage for the DB. Zwim 
Specie Opportunities Fund,
LP. ("the Fund") totaled an unaudted 61.88%. For the month ended October 31, 2008, the Fund posted an unaudited net 
return of -13.60%, bringing
Its year-to-date net return to -39.03%. Best Regards, 0.8. Zwim &Co., LP. Important rack/sures Performance k an unaudted
rate of return based
on the market value of D.B. Zwirn Special °ego:turtles Fund, LP. (the "Fund). Performance includes capital cortnbutbns 
and withdrawals, as applicable,
is net of fees and expenses and includes the reinvestment of earniros. The returns are calculated net of manage-rent 
fees of 2% and an
alocatioryincentwe fee of 20%. The Fund's fees nay be modified or visaed for certain investors. Please refer to the 
fund's offering rrororandum for more
information regarding the Fund's fees. it should be noted that as a resut of certain factors inckiding among others, an 
Investor's eligibility to participate in
'ow Issues," an investor's actual performance and actual fees nay differ from those reflected by the Fund. Investors 
should refer to their quarters' captal
account balance statement to determine their actual performance return and the fees applied to that capital account. The
Fund's unaudited rate of return
nay Include prior period accounting adjustments, reclassifications and other tens not relating to investment 
performance. Future adjustments may be node
to the returns, I deemed appropriate. The Fund co/merged operations on May 1, 2002. The Fund's racket value has been 
determined h accordance with
the valuation methodobgy set forth h the Fund's offering memorandum It should be noted that certain of the FurdS fl 
eamerits have been valued using
fair valuation as detenrined by the General Partner or third party sources. Recovery Percentage equals the sum of al 
cash distributions since Mardi 31,
2008 plus the current month end NAV of the Fund, divkled by the March 31, 2008 NAV, expressed in percentage terns. 
Recovery Percentage will reflect
the percent of March 31, 2008 NAV returned to Investors ONLY when the final ash distrbutian is node to Investors. Prior 
to the final cash distribution the
Recovery Percentage is stray a measure of cash distributions plus current valuation of the portfolio as a percentage of 
the March 31, 2008 NAV and should
not be maxi upon as an assurance of actual recovery. Past perfonrence h no guarantee of future returns. This data is 
being provided on a
confidential bask by D.B. Zwirn & CO., LP. (Tel & solely for the informatbn of those persons to whom t k transmitted. 
This data k proprietary
Intonation of DK & Co. and nay not be reproduced or otherwise disseminated in whole or In part without 08Z & Co.'s prior
written consent. The
kdonration set forth herein does not purport to be antlete and no obligation to update or otherwise revise such Maranon 
is berg assumed. No person
In any jurisdiction nay treat this InfOnnition as consUtutIng ether an offer to sel or a solicitation of an offer to buy
any Interest in the funds. A
prospective
subscriber nest rely 5/Mayon the tents of, and ascbsure of Inforrretion In, the Fund's final offering memorandum and 
related documents, which consttute
the only bass on which ateatitions nay be nude. The Fund is a high-risk iwestrrent vehicle that is available only to 
qualified iONkluats or enttes that
are willing to assume above average risk and Filled Icoldily. An investment In the Fund is speculative and involves a 
high degree of risk. The terns and risk
factors of the Fund are set out n its Confidential Memorandum which is available to qualified prospective investors upon
request.
December 31, 2008 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Investor Communication
As the end of the year is upon us, we are asiOng each of our investors to review the Privacy Policy of 0.B. barn &Co., 
LP. This requires no further action
and t r r formation n ar! Kind Regards, D.B. Zwirn &Co., LP. 745 Mb Avenue, 18th Fluor New York, NY 10151
Phone Fax
January 02, 2009 Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Performance Information
Dear Investor, To better reflect the dissolution process stated on March 31, 2008, in addition to provklIng wont* and 
year-to-date net returns, we we
include a measure which we believe better quantities the perfomance of the recovery process. The metric, caned 'Recovery
Percentage," wit reflect the
percent of March 31, 2008 value that has been diarbuted to Investors plus the Current value of assets in the portfolio 
at current valuation ievets. Upon
final cash distnbutbn, at the concision of the wind down process, the Recovery Percentage Vri reflect the percentage of 
March 31, 2008 NAV that has
been returned to Inked partners. From March 31, 2008 through November 30, 2008, Recovery Percentage for the D.B. Zwirn 
Special Opportunities
Fund, LP. ("the Fund") totaled an unaudited 59.09%. For the month ended November 30, 2008, the Fund posted an unaudted 
net return of -4.54%,
bringing its year-to-clate net return to -41.80%. Best Regards, D.B. &An & Co., LP. Important DaCbsureS PerfOrnence is 
an unaudited rate of
return based on the market value of D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunabs Fund, LP. (the *Fund). Perfornence includes captal 
contributions and withdrawals,
as appicable, is net of fees and expenses and Includes the relnyestrrent of earnings. The returns are tabulated net of 
management fees of 2% and an
alocatIonfincentike fee of 20%. The Fonts fees nay be modified or walled for certain Investors. Please refer to the 
Fund's offering memorandum for more
infornetion regarding the Fund's fees. It should be noted that as a resut of certain factors including arming others, an
investors eligibility to participate In
'Yew issues," an Investors actual performance and actual fees nay differ from those reflected by the Fund. Investors 
should refer to their quarterly captain
account balance statement to detemine their actual perforrrence return and the fees appled to their capital account. The
Fund's unaudted rate of return
nay Include prior period accounting adjustments, recrasslications and other tens not relating to Investment performance.
Future adjustsrants nay be made
to the returns, If deemed appropriate. The Fund corrmenced operations on May t, 2002. The Fund's market value has been 
determined n accordance with
the valuation methodology set forth in the Fund's offering memorandum It should be noted that certain of the Fumes 
investments have been valued using
fat valuation as determined by the General Partner or third party sources. Recovery Percentage equals the sum of all ash
distributions since Mardi 31,
2008 plus the current month end NAV of the Fund, divided by the March 31, 2008 NAV, expressed in percentage terns. 
Recovery Percentage we reflect
the percent of March 31, 2008 MY returned to investors ONLY when the Mal cash distribution is nude to Investors. Prior 
to the final cash astrbution the
Recovery Percentage Is skrply a treasure of cash distributions plus current valuation of the portfolio as a percentage 
of the Mardi 31, 2008 NAV and should
not be reed upon as an assurance of actual recovery. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns. This data k 
being provided on a
confidential basis by D.B. Zwirn & Co., L P. CC& &Co.") solely for the information of those persons to whomt is 
transmitted. This data is proprietary
hfonretion of 082 & Co. and nay not be reproduced or otherwise dissenbated in whole or n part without DB2 &Co.'s prior 
vrtaten consent. The
Wornatbn set forth herein does not purport to be conpkte and no obligation to update or otherwise revise such 
Information k being assumed. No person
n any jurisdiction nay treat this (Maranon as constituting ether an offer to set or a sok:Ration of an offer to buy any 
interest in the funds. A prospective
subscnber nut ray solely on the term of, and dhcbsure of information in, the Fund's final offering rrenvrandum and 
related documents, which consttute
the only basis on which subscriptions nay be made. The Fund is a high-risk kwestment vehicle that is available only to 
Quaked irokviduals or enttes that
are willing to assume above average risk and kited liquidly. An investment in the Fund k speculatWe and involves a high 
degree of risk. The terns and risk
factors of the Fund are set out In its Confidential Memorandum which is avertible to quaffed prospective Investors upon 
request.
January 12, 2009 D.B.ZvArn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Q4 Tax Information
Attached please find inportant correspondence regarding Q4 2008 New York State sourced income. Please note that this is 
dated material, which may
r ' e action lama 15 2009. Thank you for our tine. lend Regards, D.B. Zwin & Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New 
York, NY 10151
Phone Fax
January 13, 2009 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Tax Information
Attached please find inportant correspondence regarding 2008 tax Information. Piece bruary 2 . Thank you f ur .
Regards, D.B. Zwirn &Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, fa' 10151 Phone Fax
Fe Bruen/ 09, 2009 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Performance Information
Confidential VRF 00000018
Dear Investor, To better reflect the dissolutbn process heated on Mandl 31, 2008, n addition to providing rranthly and 
year-to-date net returns, we wit
indude a treasure which we believe better quartiles the performance of the recovery process. The metric, ailed Recovery 
Percentage," ivi reflect the
percent of March 31, 2008 value that has been distrixted to Investors plus the current value of assets h the portfolio 
at current valuation levels. Upon
final cash distribution, at the conclusion of the wind down process, the Recovery Percentage tvi retied the percentage 
of March 31, 2008 NAV that has
been returned to limited partners. From March 31, 2008 through December 31, 2008, Recovery Percentage for the D.B. Zwirn
Special Opportunities
Fund, LP. ("the Fund") totaled an unaudted 48.06%. For the month ending Dec enter 31, 2008, the Fund posted an unaudted 
net return of -18.65%.
For the year ending December 31, 2008, the Fund posted an unauc*ed net return of -52.65%. Best Regards, D.B. Zwkn & Co.,
LP. Inportant
Disclosures Performance Is an unaudited rate of return based on the market value of D.& Zwirn Specal Opportunities Fund,
LP. (the "Fund').
Performance incbdes capital contributbns and wthdrawas, as appIcable, is net of fees and expenses and wades the 
reinvestment of earnings. The
returns are cakulated net of rronagerrent fees of 2% and an allocatbn/incentive fee of 20%. The Fund's fees nay be 
modified or waked for certain
investors. Please refer to the Fund's offering memorandum for more inforrn3tion regarding the Fund's fees. It should be 
noted that as a resat of certain
factors including among others, an investor's elgibity to participate in "new issues," an investor's actual performance 
and actual fees rray direr from those
reflected by the Fund. Investors should refer to their quarterly capital account balance statement to determine their 
actual performance return and the fees
applied to their capital account. The Fund's unaudited rate of return may include prior perbd aocounUng adjustments, 
reassifkatIons and other tea
not relating to investment perfornence. Future adjustments nay be mode to the returns, I deemed appropriate. The Fund 
commenced operations on May
1, 2002. The Fund's market value has been detemined in accordance with the valuation methodology set forth in the Fundt 
offering memorandum It
should be noted that certain of the Fund's imestnents have been valued ushig fair valuation as deterated by the General 
Partner or third party sources.
Recovery Percentage equals the sum of al cash distributions since Mardi 31, 2008 plus the current month end NAV of the 
Fund, divided by the March 31,
2008 NAV, expressed in percentage tern. Recovery Percentage will reflect the percent of March 31, 2008 NAV returned to 
Investors ONLY when the final
cash distribution s node to investors. Prior to the final cash distribution the Recovery Percentage is sirnply a measure
of cash distrtutions plus current
valuation of the portfolio as a percentage of the March 31, 2008 NAV and should not be relied upon as an assurance of 
actual recovery. Past
performance is no guarantee of future returns. This data s being provkled on a confidential basis by DS Zwim &Co., LP. 
('DBZ &Col solely for the
Inforrretbn of those persons to whom t is transntted. This data s proprietary InfomotIon of DBZ & Co. and rmy not be 
reproduced or otherwise
disseminated in whole or in part without 082 & Co.'s prior written consent. The information set forth heron does not 
purport to be complete and no
obligatbn to update or otherwise revise such information is being assumed. No person n any jurisdiction stay treat this 
infortrotbn as constituting either an
offer to sel or a solicitation of an offer to buy any interest in the funds. A prospective subscriber mat rely 'piety on
the terns of, and disclosure of
information in, the Fund's final offering memorandum and related documents, with constitute the only basis on which 
subscriptbns nay be made. The
Fund is a high-risk investment vehicle that is evadable only to qualified individuals or entities that are WAIN to 
assume above average risk and tinted
liquidity. An investment in the Fund is speculative and involves a high degree of risk. The terns and risk factors of 
the Fund are set out In Its Confidential
Memorandum which s available to queened prospective investors upon request.
March 26, 2009 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Quarterly Commentary
Thank you for your Interest In D.B. Zwirn &Co., LP. Attached please find the nest recent investor co nta for the Oa Zwim
S ;0 ties
Regards, D.&been &Co., LP. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone Fax
March 27, 2009 2008 Tax Estimate
Please see the attached 2008 tax ' expect h final K-1 in the surarer. Sincerely, D.B. &rim &Co., L.P. 745 Firth Avenue,
18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone Fax -
April 09, 2009 Jaspers Settlement Agreement and Release dated April 8, 2009
From..LENINSent: 4/9/2009 7:42:37 AM To: Subject: FW: futy executed
Jeeps Epstein [attach Has the DBZ signatures. Pbase store n complaint and also In Investor correspan0enee and Protr 
stier
estor R Zan &Co. 745 Fret Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone:MEM= Cat
<mato From Lee, David Sent: Thursday, Aprl 09, 2009 7:20 AM To: Hubsher, Elise;
Surrberac, Robert; Lebowitz, er, MarcSub . : FW: fur executed leepers/Epstein doc attached From Bowen, tindsley Sent:
Wednesday, April 08, 2009 6:09 PM To: Cc: Lee, David; Cutler, Lawre . f E in • a ched
Bowen D. B. Zwim &Co. 745 Fifth Avenue floor 10 New York, NY 10151 Tel: Fax
<mato
April 13, 2009 D.B. ZsArn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Q1 Tax Information
Attached please find important correspondence regarding Q I 2009 New York State sourced incent. Pbola: note that this is
dated material, which
require action by A ' 15 20 . Thank ou for our time. grid Regards, D.B. ZwIrn &Co., LP. 745 Firth Avenue, 18th Floor 
Newtons, NY 10151
Phone Fax
April 13, 2009 RV: D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Q1 Tax Information
Front Sent: 4/13/21093:27:02 PM To: Subject: FW: D.& Zwim Special Opportunities Fund, LP. • Q1 Tax
Inform en   roe &Co. Investor Relations Sent: Monday, April 13, 2009 3:20 PM
To: Subject: D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Q1 Tax Infonratbn Attached please fbd important
correspondence regarding Q I 2009 New York State sourced icon. Please note that this &dated material, rah by A
Thank ou for our tire. laid Regards, OB. Zwen &Co., L.P. 745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phoneliii.
Fax
April 29, 2009 Zwtrn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - 2007 Audited Financial Statements
We are pleased to announce that the 2007 dudted Una ncla state n-ents for the D.B. &dm Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. 
are cantle and attached for
your review. Please note that we regard the and rted financial stair as confidential u ants. lid Regards, D.& ZwIrn 
&Co.,

LP. 745 Fith Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone Fa
May 04, 2009 D.B. Zwlm • Co., L.P. - 2008 Bernard National- CEO Audit
We are pleased to announce that the 2008 audited financial statements for Bernard National Loan Investors, Ltd. are 
conpiete and attached for your
review Please note that we regard the audited i 1 as pro • ta and confidential documents Old Regards, D.B. Zwkn &Ca, LP.
745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151 Phone Fax-
May 05„ 2009 2wIrn Special Opportunities Fund, Ltd. - Investor Communication
Confidential VRF 00000019
Attached please find an important connunication that was sent to the Shareholders of the D.EL Zwlm Special Opportunities
Fund, Ltd. This connunkatlon
k for your informatbn only and requires no action on your part. We we send a sitter corrrrunicatb tinted Partners of the
D.B. Nan
special Opportunities Fund, L P. shortly. If you have a uestlons, please contact Else Hubsher at Regards, 0.8. Zwim 
&Co., L P.
745 Fifth Avenue, 18th Fbor New York, NY 10151 Phone Fax
May 06, 2009 DS. ZwIrn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Performance Thformation
Dear Investor, To better reflect the dissoiutbn process Mated on March 31, 2008, In ackltion to providing monthly and 
year-to-date net returns, we wi
kidutie a measure whth we beieve better quantifies the performance of the recovery process. The metric, caged -Recovery 
Pereentage," wJl retied the
percent of Mardi 31, 2008 value that has been distributed to arrestors plus the current value of assets In the portfolio
at current valuation levels. Upon
f 'nal cash distnbution, at the concision of the wind down process, the Recovery Percentage wl reflect the percentage of
March 31, 2008 NAV that has
been returned to anted partners. From March 31, 2008 through February 28, 2009, Recovery Percentage for the a & Zwim 
Special Opportunties Fund,
LP. ("the Fund, totaled an unaudited 41.64%. For the month ending February 28, 2009, the Fund posted an unaudted net 
return of -1.72%, bringMg
its year-to-date net return to 4.97%. Best Regards, D.& Zwin &Co., LP. Important Disclosures Performance is an unaudted 
rate of return based
on the market value of a& avim Special Opportunties Find, LP. (the "Fund,. Performance includes capital contributions 
and withdrawals, as applicable,
is net of fees and expenses and Includes the reinvestment of earnings. The returns are cakubted net of management fees 
of 2% and an
alxation/hcentive fee of 20%. The Fund's fees nay be modtle0 or waived for certain investors. Please refer to the Fund's
offering memorandumfor more
intonation regarding the Fund's fees. It should be noted that as a resut of certain factors incbding arrorvg others, an 
Investor's eigbility to participate in
'new issues," an investor's actual performance and actual fees nay direr from those reflected by the Fund. Investors 
should refer to their quarterly capital
account balance statement to determhe their actual pertorrrance return and the fees applied to thee capital account. The
Fund's unaudited rate of return
nay Include prior period accounting adJustnents, reclassifications and other kerns not relating to hvestrnent 
performance. Future adJuStments nay be nude
to the returns, tl deemed appropriate. The Fund commenced operations on May 1, 2002. The Fund's rrerket value has been 
determined h accordance with
the valuation methodology set forth ki the Fund's offering rrentrandurrs It should be noted that certain of the Fund's 
investments have been valued using
fat valuation as detentied by the General Partner or third party sources. Recovery Percentage equals the sum of al cash 
cfstrtutions since March 31,
2008 plus the current north end NAV of the Fund, derided by the March 31, 2008 NAV, expressed in percentage tents. 
Recovery Percentage WI reflect
the percent of March 31, 2008 NAV retuned to investors ONLY when the final cash distribution is made to Investors. Prior
to the final cash distrbutim the
Recovery Percentage is simply a measure of cash distrbutbns plus current valuation of the portfolio as a percentage of 
the Mardi 31, 2008 NAV and should
not be reled upon as an assurance of actual recovery. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns. This data is 
belie provided on a
confidential basis by D.B. Zwirn & Co., LP. CD& & Ca") solely for the Wom'ation of those persons to whom It Is 
transmitted. This data s proprietary
Information of DBZ & Co. and nay not be reproduced or otherwise dineninated in whole or n part without DOZ & Co.'s prior
written consent. The
information set forth beret, does not purport to be derplete and no obegation to update or otherwise revise such 
information is being assumed. No person
in any Jurtsdictbn trey treat this Information as constituting ether an offer to sell or a satiation of an offer to buy 
any Interest In the funds. A prospective
subscrber mist rely solely on the terns of, and disclosure of information b, the Fundb final offering memorandum and 
related documents, which constitute
the only basis on which subscriptions nay be made. The Fund is a high-risk hvestrnent vehicle that is reelable only to 
quailed indviduab or entities that
are wiling to assume above average risk and limted lquidty. An investment in the Fund is speculative and Invokes a high 
degree of risk. The terns and risk
factors of the Fund are set out In its ConfidenUal Memorandumwhich is available to quail ied prospective investors upon 
request.
May 08, 2009 D.B. Zwlrn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Investor Communication
Attached please find an Vrportant comruntatbn regarding the 0. B. Zwin Special Opportunities Fund L.P. The communication
requires a response no
Else Hubsher at Regards, Zwim &Co., LP. 745 Ffth
Avenue, 18th Floor New York, NY 10151noll  aiMPhone Fax
se contact later than May 22, 2009. If you have a
May 15, 2009 Reminder: D.B. Zwirri Spedal Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Consent forms due before 1000 am. On May 22, 2009
Dear Investor: This is a reminder that be received before 10:00a EST on May 22, 2009. If you would Ike to discuss the 
consent,
please feel free to contact Else Hubsher a Thank you, all Zwin & Co., L.P.

May 20, 2009 Reminder: DA Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. - Consent forms due before 1000 am. on May 22, 2009
Dear Investor: We have not received your consent form This is a reninder they must be received before 10:00 ears New 
York tine on May 22, 2009.
If you would Ike to discuss the consents, please feel free to contact Elise Hubsher a Thank you, DS. brim & Co., LP.
May 22, 2009 D.B.Zwirn Special Opportunities Funds Investor Communication
Dear Investor, We are pleased to Inform you that as of 10:00 AM today, the deaden for submitting proxies h reaped of the
notices sent to Investors n
each &a& Zwin Special Opportunties Fund, LP., D.& Zwim Special Opportunties Fund, Ltd., as. ZMn Asia/Pacific Special 
Opportunities Fund, LP.
and D.& Zwtn Special Opportunities (TE)Furel, LP., we had received a sufficient number of proxies for each fund to 
constitute a quorum and to approve
the various natters for width consent was requested in connection with the replacement of 0.8. Zwlm &Co., LP. as 
investment manager to the funds with
an aff Bate of Fortress Investment Group LLC. We note that, for D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunties Fund, Ltd., the vote 
will be finalized at the shareholders'
meeting scheduled for May 26, 2009 and, once Mated, we expect management of the funds w0 be transferred to Fortress at 
the casing pursuant to the
transaction documents described in the consent documents. We would Ike to thank al Investors in the Funds for their 
thoughtful consideration of al
matters related to the transaction and look forward to your continued support as we make the transition. Regards, a B. 
zwirn & Co., L P.
May 26, 2009 D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. - Performance Information
Confidential VRF 00000020
Dear Investor, To better reflect the diSSOluUon process initiated on March 31, 2008, n addtbn to providing monthly and 
year-to-date net returns, we MI Include a
neasure which we beleve better quantifies the performance of the recovery process. The metric, called 'Recovery 
Percentage," will reflect the percent of March
31, 2008 value that has been dlstrbuted to investors plus the current value of assets In the portfolio at current 
valuation levels. Upon
final cash distributbn, at the conclusion of the wind down process, the Recovery Percentage we retied the percentage of 
March 31, 2008 NAV that has been
returned to anted partners. From March 31, 2008 through March 31, 2009, Recovery Percentage for the D.B. 2Wim Special 
Opportunties Fund, LP. ('the Funt) totaled
an unaudited 40.15%. For the month ending March 31, 2009, the Fund posted an unaudited net return of -3.58%, bringing is
yearto-date net return to -8.38%. Best
Regards, D.B. beim &Co., LP. Important Discbsures Perfomence B an unaudted rate of return based on
the market value of D.& Zwtn Special Opportunities Fund, LP. (the "Fund"), Perforrmnce teludes capital contrbutions arid
wthdrawals, as applcable,
net of fees and expenses and includes the rekwestment of earnings. The returns are calculated net of management fees Of 
2% and an alotation/ncentive fee of 20%.
The Fund's fees nay be modified or waived for certain investors. Please refer to the Fund's offering nerroramium for 
rrore bforrretbn
regarding the Fund's fees. It should be noted that as a result of certain factors including among others, an investoes 
eligibility to partidpate In "new
issues,"
an investors actual performance and actual fees nay differ from those reflected by the Fund. Investors should refer to 
their quarterly capital account
balance statement to deterrrine thek actual performance return and the fees applied to thee capital account. The Fund's 
unaudited rate Of return ney
Include prior period accounting adjustments, reclassifications and other items not relating to twestment paten:ranee. 
Future adjustnareS nay be made to the
returns, if deemed approprbte. The Fund cormenced operations on May 1, 2002. The Fund's market value has been determined
in accordance with the
valuation nethodotogy set forth in the Fund's offering rremorandurn. It shouli be noted that certain of the Fund's 
investrrents have been valued using fat
vaketion as deterrrined by the General Partner or third party sources. Recovery Percentage equals the sum of all cash 
dIstrIbutbns since March 31, 2008 plus the
current month end NAV of the Fund, divided by the Mardi 31, 2008 NAV, expressed in percentage terms Recovery Percentage 
wit reflect the
percent of March 31, 2008 NAV returned to investors ONLY when the final cash dttrbutbn is nude to investors. Prior to 
the final cash distribution the
Recovery Percentage is slimly a treasure of cash distributions plus current valuation of the portfolio as a percentage 
of the Mardi 31, 2008 NAV and should
not be raid upon as an assurance of actual recovery. Past performance s no guarantee of future returns. This data s 
being embed on a
confidential bas5 by D.& ZvArn &Co., IS ("DR &Co.") solely for the information of those persons to whom it s 
transmitted. This data 5 proprietary information of
082 & Co. and nay not be reproduced or otherwise disseminated in whole or in part without DR & Co.'s prior batten 
consent. The
infatuation set forth herein does not eurPOrt to be cenplete and no obligation to update or otherwise revs such Worstion
is being assumed. No person
n any Jurisdiction nay treat this kiforrretion as constlbrting either an offer to sel or a solicitation of an offer to 
buy any Interest In the funds. A
prospective
subscriber must re?), solely on the terns of, and disclosure of information in, the Fund's final offering memorandum and
related documents, which constitute
the only basis on whkh subscriptions may be made. The Fund is a high-risk kwestrrent vehicle that 5 avabble only to 
qualified individuals or entitles that
are vale to assure above average risk and limed (quirky. An Investment In the Fund Is speculative and invobes a high 
degree of risk. The terms and risk
faders of the Fund are set out in as Confidential Memorandum wiled) s avaiatde to qualified prospective Investors upon 
request.
June 01, 2009 Fortress Value Recovery Fund ("VRF") - Investor Communication
Dear Investor, We have successf illy transferred the nonage: rent of al four D.B. Zwlrn Special Opportunities Funds to 
Fortress VRF Advisors I LLC, an
Investment ranger affiliated with Fortress Investment Group. We thank you for your broad partIcipatbn In the kwestrrent 
manager replacement process.
Attached Is the ADV Part II for FIG LIE for your review as well as our new contact information. We look forward to 
catdrn u with ou in the coning
weeks. New Contact Information: Else Hubsher Cara Howe Nicole
Whte EL Best Rep or Relations Fortress VRF Investor Relations Fortress Investment
Group 1 5 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10105
July 01, 2009 Fortress Value Recovery Fund - Investor Communication
alillitor
Please rate new
Fortress VRF Investor Relations
and ma her
Cara HO t Whit
Fortress Investment Group 1345 Avenue of the Americas New York NY 10105
EWE /C .
May 10, 2005
Notes:
itatieiniCkal May 01, 2002 Initial Subscription (05.01.02) of $10m Into DBZ LP
Notes: <file://Mcliatco. corn \ giabahlccal \ shared specopps \Operations \ Accounting \ Investors \ Sub Docs \DBZ LP \ 
2002 05 \ Financial Trust Conpany, Inc.
2002

05. pdf>
September 01, 2002 Add" contribution (09.01.02) of $10mm Into DBZ LP
Notes: <file://edbzco.com \ gbbareocahsharecespecopps \Operations \ Accounting \ Investors \Sub Does \ tP12002 09 
\Financial Trust Company, Inc. 2002
09. pd >
December 01, 2002 Add'i contribution (12.01.02) of $30mm Into DBZ LP
Notes: <Ile:// \ \ dbzco.com \ globai \ tear\ shared \ scecopps \ Operations \ Accounthig \ Investors \Sub Does \ DEIZ 
Ute2002 12 \FinancialTrust Company, Inc.
2002
12.pdr>
June 01, 2003 Adel contribution (06.01.03) of 610mm Into DBZ LP
Notes: <fk:// \ \ db2co.contolobalbocaeshared \ specopps \Operations \ Accounting \ Investors \ Sub Does \ Dee LP \2003 
Offinancial Trust Company, Inc. 2003
06.pdf>
3-40 4H Si ;2004. Q2 2004.Capital Account Statement for Financial Trust Company
Notes: <Stu \ dteeacomlelobalVocakshared \spsopps \Operations \ Accounting \ Investors \Onshore Staterrents\2004 \Q2 
2004 staterrentse P letters in
• P0F12004 06 30 LP merged document 1 Financial Trust Cosa fry. pdf> - . •
September 01, 2004 Historical notes
Notes: 6/1/Pi-Invested SIOM onshore Invested $6011 onshore 10/20/03 -too early to ask for more money
September 30, 2004 Q3,2004 Capital Account Statement for financial Trust Company
Notes: cfie:/A \ dbzco.configloballocaeshared \specopps \ Operations \ Accounting \ Investors \Onshore Statements \ 2004
\Q3 2004 statements \ LP Letters in
PDC \2004 09 30 LP merged document 1 Financial Trust Company. pdf >
Consent received for LP OM changes
Confidential VRF 00000021
December 31, 2004 Q4 2004 Capital Account Statement for Financial Trust Company
Notes: <nie:// \ dtmco. mm \ globakbcaktharethspecopps \Operatbris1AccountLig \ investors \ Onshore Statements \2004 \ 
f24 2004 statements \ LP Letters n
PDF \ 2004 12 31 LP merged document 1 Financkg Trust Conpany.pdf>
January 01, 2005 Adti'l contribution (01.01.05) of $20inin Into DIM LP
Notes: <fee:// \ \dbzco.com \globakbcaksbarethspetOPPS \Opera tbns \AccouMing \ Investors \Sub Docsg2432 LP \2005 01 \ 
Financiil Trust Company 2005
01.pdf>
January 11, 2005 Side Letter - (1/11/05)
Notes: cflle:/AMDICO.COMMiabaNOCalIsharedSPecopps\InvestOr Relations \ Side notes \ FTC (1.11.05). pdf>
March 31, 2005 Q12005 Capital Account Statement for Financial Trust Company
Notes: cfie://Wibzco.com\gbbaklocaksharethspecopps \Operations \Accounting \ Investors \ Onshore Statements \ZOOS \2005 
Q1 staterrentsRP Letters in
POF \ 2005 03 311P merged document 1 Financial 'Dust COmPanY.Pdf>
May 12, 2005 Original consent received for LP OM changes
NULL
June 30, 2005 Q2 2005 Capital Account Statement for Financial Trust Company
Notes: <fle:/AMbzoa.conhcibbaNixahstrareMspecopps \OperaUons \Accounting \ Investors \Onshore Statements \2005 \ 2005 Q2
staterrents \ LP Letters In
PDF \ 2005 06 301P merged document revised 1 Financial Dust Corrpany.pdf >
September Oa, 2003 Q3 WS letter - (9/8/05)
Notes: <file:// \\ dbzco.00m\gbbal\locakshared specopps \NYS 3Q ettersWinancial Trust Co Q3 WS letter. pdf>
September 13, 2005 2005 Cremation C.ertMcate
Notes:
September 15, 2005 Skle Letter (FTC) - (1/11/05)
Notes:
September 21, 2005 Q3 WS Letter (FTC) - (9/8/05)
Notes:
September 30, 2005 cp 2005 Ca pota I Account Statement for Financial Trust Company
Notes: <fie:// \ Wbzoo.corrtglobalgatakshared \specopps \ Operatians \ Accountinggnvestors \Onshore StaterreMs \ 
20051,2005 Q3 statementsgP Letters in
PDF 9005 09 30 II/merged document 1 Financial Trust Company. pdf>
December 31, 2005 Q4 2005 Capital Account Statement for Financial Trust Company
Notes: <fle://11dbzco.com\globalgocaksharethspecopps \Operatians \Accountinggniestors \ Onshore Staterrents\2005\2005 Q4
statements \LP Letters in
POF\LP final verged letters Q4 2005 1 Financial Trust Conpany.pdf>
January 01, 2006 Transfer In (01.01.06) of $114,379,190 Into DB2 LP
Notes: <fie:// \ \dbzco.corrkglobafgacatsharethspeoppps \ OperationsiAccounting \ Investors \ Sub Does \D& LP \2C06 
OWeepers Inc 2006 01. pdf>
January 11, 2006 Q4 WS Latter - (01.11.06)
Notes: <fle://g. dbzw.coirtglobargacal\sharecaspecopps \Operatbns \Accounting \Tax \NYS 4Q Letters 2005 \ Non-withheld \
Financial Trust Company Q4 NYS
Letter.pdf>
March 31, 2006 Q1 2006 Capital Account Statement for Financial Trust Company
Notes: <fte://\\dbzco.com \globallocal\sharediSfiet0PFts \Operations \Accounting \ Investors \Onshore Statements \2006 \
2006 Qi statements \ LP Letters in
PDF1U/ final mitjt41 letters Q1 2006 1 Fhancbl Trust Co. Of>
October 09, 2006 Investor Alert: Departure of Perry Gruss
Notes: Tied callnig but no one answered.

January 04, 2007 Seth called to advise TW of what S taking place with Jeffrey Epstein's interest In DB2 LP. He has a tax
issue so
we have retroactively transferred FTC's interest to Jeepers Inc as of 1/1/06.

Notes: Not offloalyet, until we receive the Nil), notarved sub dos which are coning next week FTC transfered is kiterest
in lP to their wholly owned
subsidiary Jeepers. All sub;ect to receipt to fay notarized doa - Seth vre (inward once he receives them
January 10, 2007 Original Jeepers Inc 12/31/05 transfer doa rec'd via inter -office mall from Seth
NULL
February 20, 2007 Jeffrey Epstein requests full withdrawal of Jeepers account on 3/31/07 - eligibility to be reviewed 
(rec'd via
certified mail)
Notes: <fie:// \ \ clbzod.con't globakbcakshareckspecoppsgnyestor Relations \Investor CorreSpondence \Finandal Trust 
ConeanyVeepers Inc. Withdrawal
Request 2.14.07.pdr>
March 02, 2007 Original 2006-2007 Composite Return Election Form rec'd vie IOM
NULL
Confidential VRF 00000022
44.0-04 ittoototciAmlim34140900-4?#f
October 80; SIM. ' • Iiereibir Alert PG De parttinittOund'i
Notes: DZ caned Harry Beier. Send otter re: upgrade of infrastructure
November 20, 2006 Investor Alert: PG Departure Round 2
Notes: DZ -3E 12:10pm Mark Ekwitz cared David Endycic, attorney
February 22, 2008
NULL
January 13, 2009
Mkt
Investor Alert: Funds Wind Down and F7 Articles (SL)
Pdpinwoiliz "4,00000,
Brigitte, BM and CH/NW spoke with Harry & explained the income and withholding B's reported on the Q4 NYS
non-resident tax letter that was distributed.
June 10, 2009 Call with Harry (EH)
Relayed to Harry Beier estimated unaudited 12/31/08 balance of $41,707,011. I-  %dray/at the staterrents for a more "off
iclar nuneer. He asked when he
could expect to receNe Its redemption ant We discussed the leverage and the fact that the secured credtors would be paid
lint ood then the redeemers.
Also note that the revised year end balance for 2007 post audit was $95,228,091
Confidential VRF 00000023
EFTA00725932 (Jmail)
 [legal] <REDACTED> v. Estate of Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell: response to Defendant interrogatories
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                       Arthur Gensler [employee] architect 
 Gary Gensler [government] ex-Goldman Sachs, future SEC Chair under Biden, taught MIT course on blockchain 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00605620 (Jmail)
 [property] Arthur Gensler contract for architectural work
(date: 2009-10-06)
Gensler
2500 Broadway
Suite 300
Santa Monica CA 90404
USA
October 6, 2009

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
LS), LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters, Suite B-3
St. Thomas, Virgin Islands 00802
Subject: Agreement for Architectural Services
For Epstein Interests
Little St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Gensler Project Number 05.7112.000
Dear Mr. Epstein:
This Agreement is between Mr. Jeffrey Epstein ("Client") and M. Arthur Gensler

Jr. and Associates, Inc. ("Gensler") for architectural services.
A. PROJECT
A.1 Project Description. The project is located on Little St. James Island, a
private Island off the coast of St. Thomas.
The project indudes five main areas:

1. New construction of a Pool Area and subterranean Screening Room, including:
13,700 SF Pool Deck with 2,100 SF Pool, 2,500 Covered Porch, 500 SF Shade
Structure, 820 SF Cabana, 350 SF Cabana, two 700 SF Pavilions, a 3000 SF
Screening Room, and associated Mechanical and Support spaces.

2. New construction of a 1,200 SF AN Garage building.
3. Exterior façade alterations and a new roof for the Main Residences.

4. New Dock House building on an existing dock.
5. Landscaping for the Service Road and Office Path.
A.2 Project Budget. Client and Gensler will review Client's budget goals for the
Project at the commencement of design. During design, Client and Gensler will
monitor the Project Budget, and Client will adjust it to reflect changes in the
program requirements, design, and level of design detail, or adjust the program to
be consistent with the Project Budget.
A.3 Project Schedule. Gensler will develop a Project Schedule of important
milestones for Client's review and approval. During design, Gensler and Client will
monitor the Project for conformance with the Schedule, and Gensler will notify
Client of any necessary changes in the Schedule. The following milestones are
presently projected:
Gensler
Little St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 2

a) Commencement of Basic Services (approximate dates, to be confirmed, pending
authorization by Client to proceed with each phase):
• Schematic Design (approx 6 weeks): December 2008
• Design Development (approx 8 weeks): April 2009
• Construction Documents (approx 12 weeks): September 2009

b) Commencement of Construction (approx 8 months): January 2009
c) Substantial Completion or Occupancy: August 2010

B. SCOPE OF SERVICES PROVIDED BY GENSLER
Client and Gensler will provide the names of their Project team members, including
the primary contact person and the person authorized to make decisions.
8.1 GENSLER'S BASIC SERVICES
Gensler's Basic Services include design services for the Project, and design
services for the following building systems or components:

a) Architectural Design.
b) Interior Design (Screening Room only).
c) Structural Engineering.
d) Mechanical, Electrical and Plumbing Engineering (within 5' of the building
perimeter).

e) Acoustical Engineering (Screening Room).
f) Audio/Visual System Design for sound and projection equipment (Screening
Room only).

g) General lighting design.
h) Landscape design (pool deck and service road areas).
i) Swimming Pool Design

j) Waterproofing System Design
Refer to Attachment B for additional information regarding specific scope in each
portion of the project.
phase One - Design

1. Schematic Design. Based on the approved Conceptual Design and Client's
authorization to proceed, Gensler will develop the Schematic Design, consisting
of:

a) Site plan;
b) Building elevations;
c) Typical building sections;
d) Floor plans;
e) Outline description of building systems included in Gensler's scope of services,
prepared by Gensler's consultants;

1) Preliminary project description;
g) Perspective views of 3D "Sketch -up" model.
Gensler will provide two copies of the Schematic Design Documents and will meet
with Client one time (location TBD) to present and review the material.
Gensler
Little St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 3

2. Design Development. Based on the approved Schematic Design and Client's
authorization to proceed, Gensler will proceed with Design Development, to further
develop the design, including:

a) Site plan;
b) Building elevations;
c) Building sections;
d) Floor plans of each typical and unique level;

e) Preliminary designs of building systems included in Gensler's scope of services,
prepared by Gensler's consultants;

f) Reflected ceiling plans of common spaces;
g) Exterior lighting;
h) Interior lighting;
i) Architectural treatments, including materials palettes;

j) Key details;
k) Preliminary interior finishes;
I) Additional perspective views of 3D "Sketch -up" model as necessary to describe
the project.
Gensler will provide two copies of the Design Development Documents and will
meet with Client one time (location TBD; additional meetings as necessary to
resolve design Issues) to present and review the material.

3. Construction Documents. Based on the approved Design Development
Documents, authorized adjustments to the Project Budget, and Client's
authorization to proceed, Gensler will provide Drawings and Specifications intended
to be used for constructing the Project, including:

a) Site plan;
b) Building sections and elevations;
c) Enlarged plans and elevations of special areas;
d) Floor plans of each typical and unique level;

e) Roof and penthouse plans;
1) Design details;
g) Finish plans and finish schedules;
h) Engineering drawings of systems Included in Gensler's scope of services,
prepared by Gensler's consultants;

i) Reflected ceiling plans;
k) Specifications.
Phase Two - Implementation
1. Bidding or Negotiation. Gensler's assistance will be limited to architectural
matters. Gensler will assist with Client's assessment of pricing and contracting
strategies, and selection of vendors. No meetings are included in this phase.

2. Permit Applications. Gensler will assist Client in connection with filing
documents required by governmental authorities having jurisdiction over the
Project. The Client will provide an "expediter" to submit the drawings for all
required approvals, and coordinate with authorities having jurisdiction. Gensler
Gensler
Uttle St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 4
will secure an Architectural License in USVI, through reciprocal agreements
between the US and USVI. Gensler Consultants will secure similar licenses, if
required by local agencies.
3. Construction Administration. Gensler will assist Client with Construction
Administration. Gensler's Construction Administration services will begin with the
award of the Construction Contract and end thirty (30) days after Substantial
Completion or when Gensler signs the Contractor's final payment application,
whichever occurs first.
3.1 Meetings and Site Visits. Gensler will visit the Project site during
construction to attend job meetings and to walk through the Project as often, in
Gensler's professional judgment, as is appropriate to become generally familiar
with the progress and quality of the Work, and to determine whether the Work is
in general conformance with the aesthetic design intent. Gensler's fee for Basic
Services includes eight one-day site visits during active construction. If Gensler
observes Work that does not conform to the Construction Documents, Gensler
will recommend that Client reject it. Gensler will also recommend inspection or
testing of the Work if Gensler believes it is appropriate.
3.2 Communications During Construction. Client and Contractor shall
communicate with each other, and with Gensler's consultants, through Gensler.
Gensler will maintain logs of documents received, reviewed, and/or issued by
Gensler.
3.2.1 Requests for Information. Upon Client's or Contractor's request for
information, Gensler will provide written or graphic interpretations and
clarifications of the Construction Documents.
3.2.2 Bulletins. Gensler will use its Bulletin form to: a) authorize minor
changes in the Work; b) issue supplemental instructions related to the Work; c)
confirm Field Orders; and d) request proposals for changes in the Work.
3.2.3 Submittals. Gensler will review and take appropriate action on Samples,
Product Data, Shop Drawings, and other submittals that the Construction
Documents require Contractor to submit ("Submittals"), to determine whether
those items and Contractor's proposed methods of fabrication are generally
consistent with the aesthetic design intent. Gensler will conduct up to two (2)
reviews of any Submittal as a Basic Service.
3.3. Changes. Gensler may authorize minor changes in the Work if they are
consistent with the aesthetic design Intent and do not involve an adjustment in
the Project Budget or Schedule.
3.4. Contractor's Payment Applications. Gensler will review Contractor's
monthly payment applications and make recommendations to Client regarding
amounts due. Gensler's approval of a payment application shall represent to
Gensler
Little St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 5
Client that, to the best of Gensler's knowledge, information, and belief, the Work
has progressed to the point indicated and is consistent with the aesthetic design
Intent.
3.5 Substantial Completion. Gensler will conduct one field review, and if
necessary, one follow-up field review, to observe whether the Work is
substantially complete. These field reviews are included within the eight visits
noted in Item 3.1 above. When Gensler determines that the Work is
substantially complete, Gensler will issue the Certificate of Substantial
Completion.
3.6 Final Completion and Project Close -Out. No later than thirty (30) days
following Substantial Completion, Gensler will conduct one field review, and if
necessary, one follow-up field review, to observe Contractor's completed punch
list items. When Gensler believes that the Work has been sufficiently completed
in conformance with the Construction Documents, Gensler will approve
Contractor's final payment application.
B.2 CAD FORMAT AND STANDARDS. Gensler and its consultants will use
AutoCAD 2004 or 2006 and Gensler's CAD Standards. At the completion of the
Project, Gensler will deliver electronic files of Gensler's Construction Documents
and Bulletins. Gensler will translate CAD files provided by Client and/or Client's
consultants as an Additional Service.
B.3 GENSLER'S ADDITIONAL SERVICES. Gensler will provide services
beyond Basic Services ("Additional Services") if requested by Client and
confirmed in writing by Gensler. Additional Services include, but are not limited
to, value engineering, professional models or renderings, Client -requested
revisions that are inconsistent with prior approvals or instructions, and
preparation or review of record drawings.

C. SCOPE OF SERVICES PROVIDED BY CLIENT
C.1 SERVICES PROVIDED BY CLIENT OR OTHERS. The following services
may be required on the Project, and shall be provided by Client, Client's
consultants, or others:

a) Consulting services other than those included in Gensler's scope above.
b) Civil Engineering, including shoring, excavation, grading, drainage, on-site
and off-site utilities, septic systems, exterior pavement and curbs for parking,
drives, and street connections five feet beyond the building perimeter.

c) Soils or Geotechnical Engineering.
d) Fire Alarm and Detection Systems Engineering (fire sprinkler system, fire
alarm system).

e) Design Services related to utilities to be supplied to the building, including
water supply and storage, electrical supply and transformers, propane, and
septic systems
0 Furniture, fixtures and equipment, and other Owner-supplied items.

g) Indoor air quality consultant services.
Gensler
Little St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 6

h) Services for telephone, security systems and other special wiring and
equipment.
I) Services for off-site work.

j) Special exterior lighting and illuminated signage services.
k) Special acoustical considerations, analysis of existing structures, and analysis
and testing of this project during and after construction.

I) THX, Imax or other specialty presentation design standards/
m) Custom lighting.
n) Custom art work and murals.

o) Design-build services (pool);
C.2 CLIENT FURNISHED INFORMATION. The following is a partial list of
information to be provided by the Owner (additional information may be required
as the project proceeds):

a) Site survey (AutoCAD format), with location of property lines, setbacks,
easements, topography (1' elevation increments), main utilities, roadways,
other structures, and any other information that may be pertinent to the
Project, to be provided by a licensed surveyor.

b) As-built drawings of existing surrounding buildings.
c) Soils and Geology reports, for determination of design criteria for building's
foundations and location of septic systems.

d) Civil Engineering, including shoring, grading and drainage systems design.
e) Any criteria from the Owner related to the design and layout of the auditorium,
casework and equipment, sound and projection systems, screens, seating, or
any other programmatic requirements.

f) Information related to Owner-provided furniture, fixtures or equipment.
g) Planning, zoning and easement information, if required.

h) Requirements and restrictions from all governing agencies if applicable.
i) Security, computer, and telephone systems information.
C.3 CLIENT'S REQUIREMENTS OF CONTRACTOR. Client will, through the
Construction Contract, require Contractor to:

a) Provide access to Work;
b) Provide the Submittal Schedule for Gensler's approval and provide required
Submittals in accordance with the Schedule;

c) Review Submittals, identify any changes, and approve before submitting to
Gensler;
d) Follow proper procedures for requests for substitutions;

e) Maintain logs of all documents Issued to and received from all other parties;
f) Provide required certificates or statements of performance characteristics;

g) Complete punch list Items within thirty (30) days of Substantial Completion;
h) Provide to Client record drawings, maintenance manuals, written warranties,
and related documents within thirty (30) days of Substantial Completion.
Gensler
Little St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 7

D. COMPENSATION
Compensation to Gensler for Basic Services, Additional Services, and Reimbursable
Expenses shall be as described below. When Gensler's compensation is based on
hourly rates, the rates shall be those set forth in Gensler's Standard Hourly Billing
Rates (attached).
D.1 Basic Services. Compensation for Basic Services shall be on
basis, billed as indicated below.

1. Pool Area (includes landscape at service road and office path): $937,750
2. AN Garage: $ 20,000
3. Existing Main Residence: $ 23,500

4. Dock House: S 22.000
$1,003,250
Refer to the Attachment B, Scope and Fee Summary, for additional information.
a lump sum
D.1.1 Initial Payment. An initial payment shall be paid upon commencement of
each phase of Gensler's and our Consultants' services.

a) Schematic Design Phase: $50,000 plus 50% Consultants' SD Fee
b) Design Development Phase: $50,000 plus 50% Consultants' DD Fee

c) Construction Documents Phase: $100,000 plus 25% Consultants' CD
Fee
d) Construction Administration Phase: $25,000 plus 25% Consultants' CA Fee
The initial payment shall be held as a retainer for each phase, to be credited
against the final invoice for each phase. If the final invoice for any phase is less
than the amount of the retainer held, the difference shall be returned to the
Client after all appropriate credits have been made.
D.2 Additional Services. Compensation for Additional Services (if not agreed
upon as a lump sum amount) shall be based on Gensler's Standard Hourly Billing
Rates. Additional Services shall include, but not be limited to, the following:
Making revisions in Drawings, Specifications, Project Manual or other documents,
when such revisions are, through no fault of the Architect: (a) inconsistent with
approvals or instructions previously given by Client, including revisions made
necessary by adjustments in Client's program, Project Budget or Project location;

(b) required by the enactment, revised interpretation, jurisdictional differences in
interpretation, or revision of codes, laws or regulations subsequent to the
preparation of such documents, or additional costs caused by delays resulting
from such; or (c) due to changes required as a result of Client's failure to render
decisions in a timely manner. In addition, professional renderings or models
(other than Sketch -Up format computer modeling done by Gensler) produced by
others are deemed to be an Additional Service.
Gensler
Little St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 8
D.3 Reimbursable Expenses. Compensation for Reimbursable Expenses
incurred by Gensler in connection with the Project shall be based on amounts
invoiced to Gensler, plus twelve percent (12%).
D.4 Consultants. Additional Consultants' fees, beyond those already Included
in this Contract, shall be compensated based on amounts invoiced to Gensler,
plus fifteen percent (15%).
D.5 Progress Payments. Progress payments shall be made monthly. Where
Gensler's fee Is based on a lump sum, progress payments for Basic Services shall
be based on the percentage of services provided during the previous month, as
indicated below.

• Schematic Design: Initial Payment as indicated above; balance due at the
end of the phase.
• Design Development: Initial Payment as indicated above; balance due at
the end of phase.
• Construction Documents: Initial Payment as indicated above; billed
monthly as percentage complete.
• Construction Administration: Initial Payment as indicated above; balance
billed monthly as percentage complete.

E. AGREEMENT AND ACCEPTANCE
E.1 Agreement. This Agreement is comprised of and incorporates the following
documents, in order of precedence:

a) amendments and modifications signed by both parties;
b) This Letter of Agreement;
c) The attached Standard Terms and Conditions (STC);

d) The attached Gensler Standard Billing Rate Schedule (Attachment A);
e) The detailed fee summary (Attachment B);

f) The attached Scope Diagrams dated March 20, 2009.
Where a portion of one document is amended by another of higher precedence, all
unmodified portions shall remain in effect.
Gensler
li ttle St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 9
E.2 Effective Date. The effective date of this Agreement shall be deemed the
date Gensler started to provide services on the Project (the date we received the
Schematic Design Phase initial payment), on or about January 13, 2009.
By Gensler By Client
Warwick Ian Wicksman, AIA  fel&
Dv AtmAin (Signature)
Principal, it 91 ° 47
(Title) (Date)
On behalf of Andrew P. Cohen
Executive Director - Santa Monica
California Registration Number
(Printe
09
atur

LS. (Title)
cc: Andrew P. Cohen, Robert Jernigan, hilla Leiserowitz, Joe Harris
Gensler
Little St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 10
Attachment A: Gensler Standard Hourly Billina Rates
Warwick Wicksman Project Principal/Project Manager $230.00
Tom Sze Project Designer $180.00
Bob Anderson Project Architect $150.00
Senior Professional Staff $140.00 - $200.00
Intermediate Professional Staff $85.00 - $135.00
Junior Professional Staff $60.00 - $80.00
Our rates are reviewed annually based upon an assessment of the market value
of the position/function.
Gensler
Little St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 11
Attachment B: Scope and Fee Summary

I. Pool Area:
New Construction Includes East and West Cabanas, North and South Pavilions, Grand Stair,
Pool, Pool Deck, and Basement . Architectural services include shell/core services for all areas,
and Interior Design services at the Screening Room only.
SD DD CD CA Total
Gensler $100,000 $96,000 $222,000 S95,000 $513,000
Structural $9,375 $11,500 $32,625 $6,000 $59,500
MEP $10,500 $16,250 S24,000 $25,000" $75,750
Acoustical $4,500 $6,000 $15,000 $4,500 S30,000
Lighting S5,000 $7,500 $17,500 $5,000 S35,000
AN S8,000 S10,000 $29,000 $5,000 $52,000
AN THX
Certification Not included Not included Not included Not included Not included
Waterproofing $4,000 $5,250 $13,250 $4,000 $26,500
Landscape $12,500 S24,000 $36,500 Not included $73,000
Pool $14,500 $14,500 $29,500*** $14,500*** $73,000
Total $168,375 $191,000 $419,375 $159,000 $937,750*
Consultant fees are broken down by phase for convenience only. Actual phasing of consultant
services may vary with required sequences of coordination.

• Plus standard reimbursable expenses.
• * Allowance, to be billed hourly
*** Pool CD/CA Services pending further review by the Owner.

2. ATV Garage
New construction. Assumes all design services are performed in conjunction with the Pool
Area work described above, and are integrated into one set of documents with he Pool Area.
SD DD CD CA Total
Gensler Included in
Item 1 above S4,000 S8,000 Included in
Item I above $12,000
Structural Included in
Item 1 above SI,000 $2,000 Included in
Item 1 above $33 ,000
MEP 51,000 S1,000 $3,000 Included in
Item 1 above S5,000
Total $1,000 $6,000 $13,000 $20,000*
Consultant fees arc broken down by phase for convenience only. Actual phasing of consultant
services may vary with required sequences of coordination.

• Plus standard reimbursable expenses.
Gensler
Uttle St. James Pool Area and Screening Room
Agreement for Architectural Services
September 18, 2009
Page 12

3. Existing Main Residence, Existing Pavilions, Existing Master Bedroom Suite:
Renovation. Main Residence and Pavilion scope includes new roofing, column covers,
cornice/gutter, and new HVAC systems. Master Bedroom Suite scope is new HVAC only.
Scone does not include any remodeling or expansion of existing buildings.
SD DD CD CA Total
Gensler Included in
#1 above
Included in
#1 above
Included in
#1 above
Included in
#1 above
Included in
#1 above
Structural - - - - S3 500**,
MEP 55,000 55,000 510,000 Included in
#1 above 520,000
Waterproofing - - - - Included in
#1 above
Total 55,000 $5,00 S10,00 _ S23,500*

• Plus standard reimbursable expenses.
**Allowance to be billed hourly.

4. Dock House:
New construction over at existing dock. Scope includes Archi ectural Schematic Design
only, and DD/CD review of Construction Documents prepared by others.
SD DD CD CA Total
Gensler $15,000 $2,000" $5,000" Not included $22,000
Total S15,000 2,000** 55,000 0 - 522,000*

• Plus standard reimbursable expenses.
"Allowance to be billed hourly.
5. Landscaping at Service Road and Office Patb:
Includes landscape design for these areas, and coordination by the Architect.
SD DD CD CA Total
Gensler Included in
#1 above
Included in
#1 above Not included Included in
#1 above
Included in
#1 above
Landscape Included in
#1 above
Included in
#1 above Not included Not included Included in
#1 above
Total included in
#1 above
Included in
#1 above Not included Not included Included in
#1 above
• Plus standard reimbursable expenses.
STANDARD TERMS AND CONDITIONS
OF THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN CLIENT AND ARCHITECT
FOR ARCHITECTURAL / INTERIORS SERVICES (STC)
Gender
Article 1- Definitions and General Provisions
1.1 Parties. The terms "Client" and 'Architect" include each party's
authorized representatives, officers, directors, shareholders, and
employees.
1.2 Project Budget. The Project Budget Includes the construction
budget furniture, furnishings. equipment costs, and cost of all goods
and services to be furnished by Client Contractor, and any of their
subcontractors or consultants, and contingency allowances.
1.3 Days or Tune. Time periods refer to calendar days. unless
otherwise stated.
Artkle 2 - Architect's Services
2.1 Architect's services shall be performed as expeditiously as is
consistent with professional skill and care and the orderly progress of
the Work.
22 Limitations of Construction Responsibilities. Architect shall not
have coned over, or charge of, and shall not be responsible for,
construction means, methods, schedules, or delays, or for safety
precautions and programs in connection with the Work.
Article 3 - Client's ResponsIbilit les
3.1 information. Client shall provide full Information regarding the
requirements for the Project
32 Legal and Financial Information. Client shall furnish Architect
with: (a) a legal description of the property; (b) the name and address
of the property owner; and (c) the name and address of any
construction lender(s).
3.3 Surveys. Client shall furnish surveys fully describing physical
characteristics, legal limitations, and utility locations for the Project
site.
3A Existing or Base Building Information. Upon request, Client shall
provide information, drawings, specifications, and other documents
that describe the existing utility services, site conditions, build-out and
base building construction. and systems in or with which the Project is
to be located or integrated.
35 Client's Consultants. When requested by Architect, or required
by authorities having jurisdiction over the Project, Client shall famish
the services of geotedinical, civil, and environmental engineers and
any other services required by the scope of the Project.
3.6 Tests. Client shall furnish structural, mechanical, chemical, air,
and water pollution and hazardous materials tests, and other
laboratory and environmental tests, inspections, and reports required
by law or by authorities having jurisdiction over the Project, or
reasonably requested by Architect.
3.7 Legal. Accounting, and Insurance Seivices. Client shall furnish
all legal, accounting, and insurance counseling services as may be
necessary for the Project.
3.8 Cheat's Services and Information. Architect shall be entitled to
rely upon the accuracy and completeness of the services, Information,
surveys, and reports provided by Client, Contractor, or any of their
subcontractors or consultants.
I GerosierSTCOaozzo
Artkle 4 • Construction Cost
4.1 Construction Cost. The Construction Cost shall be the total cost
or estimated cost to Client of all Project elements designed or specified
by Architect.
4.2 Estimates. Architect cannot and does not warrant or represent
that bids or negotiated prices will not vary from Client's Project Budget
or from any cost estimate or evaluation prepared or reviewed by
Architect.
4.3 Fixed Limit. No fixed limit of Construction Cost shall be
established as a condition of this Agreement by the funishing•
proposal, or establishment of a Project Budget.
Article 5 - Use of Architect's Documents and Data
5.1 The Drawings, Specifications, and other documents (collectively
'Documents, and any computer tapes, disks, electronic data, or CAD
files (collectively 'Data') prepared by Architect are instruments of
service and shall remain Architect's property. until such time as Client
has paid all amounts to which Architect is entitled under this
Agreement, after which condition precedent all right, title and
ownership interest in the Documents and Data shall transfer and
accrue to Client including all copyrights and other proprietary rights
and interest, with the exception of standard constructions details or
specifications included as part of the Documents or Data. the
origination of svhich preexisted this Agreement ("Preexisting
Intellectual Property"). Notwithstanding the foregoing or anything
express or implied to the contrary, Architect shall hold and remain the
owner of all rights, title and interest in Preexisting Intellectual
Property.
52 Upon completion of Architect's services and payment of all
amounts due Architect, Client may retain copies or reproducibles of
the Documents and/or Data for information and reference n
connection with Client's use and occupancy of the completed Project
5.3 Client agrees to indemnify and hold Architect harmless from
and against any and all claims, liabilities, wits, demands, losses,
damages, costs, and expenses (including reasonable attorneys' fees
and costs of defense), together with interest thereon, accruing or
resulting to any persons, firms, a other legal entities. on account of
any damages or losses to property or persons, including death or
economic loss, arising out of the unauthorized use, re-me, transfer or
modification of the Documents and/or Data.
Artkle 6 • Claimsand Disputes
6.1 Mediation. Claims, disputes, or other matters in question
between the parties shall be subject to mediation under the auspices of
a recognized professional mediation service prior to undertaking any
legal action. The cost of the mediation service shall be borne equally
by the parties.
62 Attorneys' Fees. In any proceeding following unsuccessful
mediation, the prevailing party shall be entitled, in addition to such
other relief as may be granted, to a reasonable sum for attorneys' fees
and costs of defense.
6.3 Mutual Indemnification. Architect agrees to Indemnify and hold
Client harmless from and against any and all claims, liabilities, suits,
demands, losses, damages, costs, and expenses (including reascnable
attorneys' fees and costs of defense), together with interest thereon, to
Page 1 of 2
the extent caused by the negligent acts. errors, or omissions of
Architect, its consultants. or anyone for whose acts either of them may
be legally liable. Client agrees to indemnify and hold Architect
harmless Pram and against any and all claims, liabilities, suits, demands.
losses, damages, costs, and expenses (including reasonable attorneys'
fees and costs of defense), together with interest thereon, to the
extent caused by the negligent acts, errors, or omissions of Client its
contractors or consultants, or anyone for whose acts any of them may
be legally liable.
Ankle 7 - Termination
7.1 Termination by Either Party. This Agreement may be terminated
by either party, with or without cause, upon not less than seven (7)
days written notice should the other party fail substantially to perform
In accordance with the terms of this Agreement
72 Failure to Make Payments. Client's failure to make payments to
Architect in accordance with this Agreement shall constitute
substantial nonperformance and cause for termination or suspension.
7.3 Compensation Upon Termination. In the event of termination,
Architect shall be compensated for services performed prior to
termination, together with Reimbursable Expenses then due, and
TeflitifietielMapensesrwhith-shall--beallwed-asafehlfetere.pew,e9
*edit ettributoble-teierrninetien,
Artkle 8 Payments to Architect
8.1 Hourly Rates. Where services are to be compensated on an
hourly basis, compensation shall be based on the flat hourly rates set
forth in Architect's and Architect's consultants' standard rate
schedules, which are subject to periodic adjustment
82 Reimbursable Expenses. Reimbursable Expenses are in addition
to compensation for Basic and Additional Services and include
expenses incurred by Architect and Architect's consultants n the
interest of the Project, including, but not limited to the following:

(a) Data communications, telecommunications, reproduction,
shipping, handling, and delivery.
(b) Mileage, tolls, cab fares, and parking.

(c) Renderings, models, computer modeling. mockups, and
photography.
(d) Sales taxes and other transactional taxes, and fees paid for
securing approval of authorities having jurisdiction over the Project.

(e) Authorized out-of-town travel (business class unless upgrade is
preapproved by Client), Including travel time, outof-town living
expenses (business class hotel unless upgrade is preapproved by
Client), and long-distance communications.
(f) Additional Insurance coverage or limits requested by Client in
excess of that normally provided by Architect and Architect's
consultants.
8.3 Progress Payments. Progress payments for Basic and Additional
Services and Reimbursable Expenses shall be due and payable upon
receipt of Architects invoices. Disputes or questions regarding an
invoice or a portion of an invoice shall not be cause for withholding
payment for the remaining portions due. Amounts unpaid thirty (30)
days after the issue date of Architect's invoice shall be assessed a
service charge of one and one-half percent (1-1/21s) per month.
8A Time Extensions. This Agreement anticipates that Architect's
services will proceed continuously in accordance with the Project
schedule. if. and to the extent that, time limits set forth In the caging
schedule are extended more than onehurdred and eighty (180) days
beyond the dates outlined in the Project Schedule in the agreement,
Architect's compensation shall be equitably adjusted.
I Giesler STC 080220
85 Change In Project Scope. If portions of the Project are deleted
or otherwise not constructed, compensation for those portions of the
Project shall be payable to the extent services are performed on those
portions.
Article 9 - Miscellaneous Provisions
9.1 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by the law of
the location of Architect's office identified in the Letter of Agreement.
9.2 Property Insurance Waivers. Client shall cause Architect and
Architect's consultants to be named as Additional Insureds on
Contractor's General Liability Policy and any property insurance
purchased for the period of construction of the Project. Such insurance
shall be endorsed to provide a waiver of the insurers' rights of
subrogation against Architect and Architect's consultants.
9.3 Mutual Waiver of Consequential Damages. The parties hereby
waive, as against each other. any daims for incidental, special,
exemplary Cl consequential damages.
9A Successors and Assigns. Neither party shall assign this
Agreement or any right or cause of action arising out of this
Agreement or the performance of obligations hereunder without the
written consent of the other.
9.5 Entire Agreement. This Agreement represents the entire and
integrated agreement between Client and Architect and supersedes all
price negotiations, representations, or agreements.
9.6 Third Parties. Nothing contained in this Agreement shall create
a contractual relationship with, or a cause of action in favor of, any
third party.
9.7 Professional Credits. Architect shall not, without Client's prior
written approval, use or include the Client's name or any
representations of the design of the Project, including, without
limitation, photographs of the interiors and exteriors, among
Architect's professional materials, including, without limitation.
promotional materials, professional publications and competition
submissions.
9.8 Latent Conditions. In the event that the Project includes any
remodeling, alteration, or rehabilitation work, Client acknowledges
that certain design and technical decisions shall be made on
assumptions based on avallatk documents and visual observations of
existing conditions.
9.9 Areas and Measurements. Areas and measurements provided by
Architect are derived from drawing dimensions or field measurements
and are not intended to be used as the basis for calculating rent or for
other similar purposes.
9.10 Hazardous Materials, Client acknowledges that Architect has no
expertise in, and is not being retained for the purposes of,
investigating. detecting, abating. replacing, reniediating, or removing
any items, products, or materials containing hazardous substances.
9.11 Design/Build by Contractor. Architect and its consultants shall
have no responsibility for the design, technical adequacy or accuracy,
Installation, or performance of any Design/Build portions of the
Pmfec't
912 Separate Consultants. Architect's coordination of its services
with Client's and Contractor's subcontractors or consultants shall be
limited to that necessary for consistency of Architect's documents with
those of such subcontractors or consultants.
Pigs loll
7
rAm TO OFFICE:
NOSCAPE DESIGN ONLY ♦
EXISIING MAIN RESIDENCE
/
mows..
- -----.., •
t
KEY NOTES
gS•SSIISMINO -a —
41111••••••
JUNO
NEW NORTH AND SOUTH pmnuoms.
NEW WEST AND EAST CABANAS,
NEW POOL AND POOL DECK, AND
EW SCREENING ROOM. WITH
BASEMENT BELOW
MEET NOTES
Little St. James Celts Onm Twin Swaim WII• Nina*.
lalabsowpon sole
and
NOT SHOWN.
HELIPAD GARAGE
- ARCHITECTURE. STRUCTURE, MEP ONLY
SIIIF Pt AN I
SCHEMATIC DESIGN
b•••••••••-Pt _
STE PLAN WS OP NS
by
A00.50 --
_J

╭─ Page 15, Image 1 ─╮
│ tl                 │
│                    │
│ ui                 │
│ i                  │
│                    │
│ ]                  │
│ fi                 │
│ tt                 │
│                    │
│ soumey 1§ 9f"T     │
╰────────────────────╯

r
Expi
00
ii6eAttialsr LEVEL: [A
LAUNDRY ROOM. IT ROOM
STORAGE, OFFICE
, , t . 0 0 1
I r II
l l 1.-Agn,Th. IL 4:tiLtuv Iw I
VI r .4 rE g il
i g s - d ..,.,Ir- WI 9 -"o
P  el, — Ir• — JAI-- I- Iiil- -or - .1 I
.,e,ichtta e
ztatts einamt, ,,, ...i. aza 8; I _rt,,,t,,„o4l 0 i 0 r. ,, ., _ r  _ezez.gazet ....0 ._ . i!._. _ Ha _ -,,,
I
0II
.-i _ i_.5 —Pa a- k - -a- - a
- r
ft  __ 7. Z 1 } ri l&c=  • I F I -L----------- ---...ft . _ I %E------ r- ii , - - tg- - - - it_ _,.....=
I I
I I I ri.._,u, ....r.
- -c2"- — - 4-4.--r- --rThil ---- el-- -- 4- 1•11-Ir 't--- r - - - -r-T--
_- - ,, I ' 'I
r I — I ' 1 r I,
I P a°  /I  eJ_Li-i
i I I, I
e_ L -h • L-1 JL. J i i L J I'
Li R
IT nnnn:
L -
i I
nnnry r I . i I
I 0 uuuu t uuuu
I I I I iII I - - . L.2, c= 4- -i I-  1 I ri '!  is i r ri L TT Li:Th - fi r J
_ - — • -41-- -t—LJ-Rda ll - L J L F- J
I III , ------!.. . tr.. - - - i . lut .  , r♦ I I
6 oI® GO 0 I
0 0 i n
I 'Cr'
Pr ENT LEVEL:
NaTIAL EXPANSION
KEY NOTES
SHEET NOTES
ASE AREAS
LL NEW SCOPE.
CHITECTURAL, STRUCTURAL NEP
ATERPROOFING ALL AREAS.
OOL! EQUIPMENT ROOM.
V S ACOUSTICAL. SCREENING ROOM • BOOTH
IGHTING: SCREENING ROOM.
LANDSCAPE: SERVICE ACCESS AREA.
INTERIOR DESIGN' SCREENING ROOM ONLY.
FLOOR PLAN GROUND LEVEI 1
Little St. James Cast.
Gem Pinlieeti Rta„,
PIA • Irian.. awn bus yarn nnechl
(lender
IMICEMEtaa
V•••
SCHEMATIC DESIGN
•
VMS Sea
be,••••
ILOORPLAN %MSC ROOS
A02.00

╭─── Page 16, Image 1 ───╮
│ Ta ennowe WHOS         │
│                        │
│ it                     │
│ i                      │
│                        │
│ EOE]                   │
│                        │
│ 1n00u 11'nOoY AON BOY] │
│ "BAST ANSWSSVB OMX)    │
╰────────────────────────╯

MASTER BEDROOM
SUITE:
NEW HVAC ONLY
0
FLOOOR  • GROUND LEVEL
NAM RESIDENCE:
NEW EXTERIOR COLT AN
COVERS AT EXISTING
STRUCTURE. NEW BEAM COVER,
CORNICE. NEW ROOFING NEW
SOUTH EXTERIOR STEPS. NEW
TWAC THROUGHOUT. KITCHEN
ADDITION BY OTHERS
= D
'
at
KEY NOTES
Oasesansaines
0)••••••••
easena...•••••••••••
musessuromomm maw
EW CABANAS. PAVILIONS
AND GRAND STAIR:
RCHRECTURE
STRUCTURE MEP. ALL
I
0 ACOUSTICAL CR AN.
INTERIORS
ATERPROOFING AT ROOF
D EXTERIOR WALLS.
SHEET NOTES
T
Little St. James Oiris Oa Pavillon SO/waft Rpm
Pail& Le/am M.  la pea necdel
YMNM
ID
SCHEMATIC DESIGN
lfr
_J

╭─ Page 17, Image 1 ─╮
│ 3                  │
│ 3                  │
│ H                  │
│ i                  │
│ 3                  │
│                    │
│ iil                │
│                    │
│ |                  │
│                    │
│ i                  │
╰────────────────────╯

---
EXISTING PAVILIONS: NEW ROOFING/ GUTTERS. NEW WAG. SEE GROUND LEVEL PLAN FOR OTHER SCOPE.
FLOOR PLAN • ROOF LEVEL
KEY NOTES
0
it EJEDRO-OIA ••••••••••••••••••••• ...C. NO OTHER SCOPE.
MAIN RESIDENCE:NEW ROOFING/GUTTERS. NEW HVAC SEE CROWD LEVEL PLAN FOR OTHER SCOPE.
IiIIIIiI EW CABANAS AND PAVILIONS: I. NEW. SEE GROUND LEVEL RAN FOR SCOPE.
I
SHEET NOTES
Little St. James Cabana
Nal 'awash&
sown.. Rom
Pea 1. 14. 1.0•4 Ilea los path stee40
one
was
SCHEMATIC DESIGN
ROOF Puui
be
A02.02
EFTA00008486 (Jmail)
 [misc] chain of custody evidence envelope
(date: 2009-11-02)
Oalady-ELSUR
idence
Envelope
pA
(Itev.1-17-00
i'C :.
IR
Original

.

0
Magnetic
Tape
Case
I Da:

Case
Agt.:
Tape/Disk':
Agt
SUpetviSing
Title
III
Intercepts:
O
Duplicate
O
Computer
Disk
O
Enhanced
Original
O
Printed
Material
O
Court
Authorized
Intercept
- SourcerSymbole:

i4
Consensual
Monitoring
Intercept
- CAIN
Of
assigned):
lin
5314P
Telephonic
(TCM)
O
NonteIephonic(NTCM)
If
NTCM
Specify
Device
Used:

ED
Recording
of
an
Interview
O
Volumeeredroubpoenaed
Medium
- Not
FBI
ELSUR
O
Other
Type
of
Recordin
'Interception,
Specify:

intercept
Date:
alga
0
el

Place:
lilt
SI
IJIA
1FL
Data
Transferred
for
Permanent
Storage
-
Date:
/ I/0
4
0 el

Time:
5:
O
Consensual:
List
Interceptees
Below
O
Court
Authorized:
Enter"
See
Log"
Below
Ifte)4
4:--/
-1—fi
rctrte-
04
I
o
A ("ei
nlyAci

Accented
Custody
Signature: Date:
I / to?.
/0
1
7•Tme.
Reason:

fr../i
v/'e.

•
r.
•
A
Signature Date: Reason:

Mils
C;
ytbya
2-D
WI
Signature
Signature:
Date:
imc.
Date:

/
3
D

ime:
__ILka
zt
Reason:

40
1

Reason:

IAEA);
)
D
07
.4
Time:
—
a

Date:
Signature📅
erne:

2
Lit)/
Signature.
Reason:

y
S
Signature: Date:

Reason:
III 0'90

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ revenaL           │
╰───────────────────╯
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Susman Godfrey [lawyer] law firm representing Epstein as president of Jeepers, Inc. in litigation against D.B. Zwirn 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00591276 (Jmail)
 [money] letter from Susman Godfrey to Fortress Investment Group concerning Jeepers, the children's theme park owned by Epstein, see quote: "I 
represent Jeepers, Inc., Financial Trust Company, Inc., and Jeffrey Epstein"
(inferred date: 2010-01-14)
SUSMAN GODFREY L.L.P.
A REGISTERED LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP
5TH FLOOR
654 MADISON AVENUE
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10065.8404
12121 336-6330
FAX (2 12> 336-6340
SUM 5100
1000 Lasinua Sinn
HOUSTON. nx•-• 77002-5006
SUNS 5100
001 14616 STRUT
DALLAS TV"As 75202.3775
STEPHEN D. Sus.0.6
Dona Dm.
January 5, 2010
Fortress VRF Investor Relations
Fortress Investment Group
1345 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10105
figvrfir®fortress.com
Suns 050
1001 Amnon 0/ INC Stall
LOS AWNILLs CAupDlau 00067-6020
DIRECT DIAL FAX
&Mu
San 3800
1201 11660 AwAue
Burns, WASHINGTON 05101.3000
Re: D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P. (n/k/a Fortress Value Recovery Fund I LLC)

Dear Fortress VRF Investor Relations:

I represent Jeepers, Inc., Financial Trust Company, Inc., and Jeffrey Epstein (collectively
"Jeepers").

Pursuant to Paragraph 7 of the Settlement Agreement and Release dated April 8, 2009
("Agreement") among D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund ("Fund"), L.P., Jeepers, Inc.,
Financial Trust Company, Inc., and Jeffrey Epstein, Jcepers has provided Jeepers' Cancellation
Declaration to the names and addresses listed in Paragraph 22 of the Agreement.
Jeepers recognizes that the name of the Fund has changed and its mailing address may have
changed as well. According to Jeepers' records, however, it never received any notice pursuant
to Paragraph 22 of "any change of person to be notified or change of address." Nevertheless,
Jeepers is providing you with the enclosed copy of the Jeepers' Cancellation Declaration as a
courtesy.

If you believe that this notice should have been sent to a different person or address, please
contact me immediately, so that Jeepers can respond before the deadline for providing the
Jeepers' Cancellation Declaration, which we believe is January 14, 2010. Please let me know of
any concerns by email and hand delivery to my address above.
999625v1/0I1585
Fortress VRF Investor Relations
Fortress Investment Group
January 5, 2010
Page 2
For the avoidance of any doubt, this letter should not be construed in anyway as qualifying the
enclosed Jeepers' Cancellation Declaration. Jeepers position is that the enclosed notice is
effective, final and irrevocable.
Sincerely,
JAM/4 t ..142Ataal Stephen D. Susman
Enclosure
cc: Darren Indyke
999625A/011585
JEEPERS, INC.
January 5, 2010
Via Hand Delivery and Federal Express
D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P.
do David Lee
D.B. Zwirn & Co., L.P.
745 Fifth Avenue
18th Floor
New York, NY 10151
Re: Settlement Agreement and Release
Jeepers' Cancellation Declaration
Dear D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P.:
Pursuant to Paragraph 7 of the Settlement Agreement and Release dated April 8, 2009
("Agreement") among D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, L.P., Jeepers, Inc., Financial
Trust Company, Inc., and Jeffrey Epstein, this notice constitutes "Jeepers' Cancellation
Declaration." The result hereof is that the Agreement is null and void and the releases, waivers,
promises, covenants, and other provisions contained therein are of no effect.
Cc: Alan R. Glickman, Esq.
Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP
919 Third Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Jeffrey Epstein
President
EFTA01108807 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Jane Doe vol. III of IV
(date: 2010-02-09)
Page 336
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL
CIRCUIT IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO:502008CA028051XXXXMB AB
Plaintiff,
-vs-
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
AND
Defendants.
VOLUME III OF IV
VIDEO-CONFERENCED VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OFIIII.
Tuesday, February 09, 2010
10:09 - 5:05 p.m.
250 Australian Avenue South
Suite 1500
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
Reported By:
Cynthia Hopkins, RPR, FPR
Notary Public, State of Florida
Prose Court Reporting
Job No.: 1296

(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
}
Page 337 Page 339
1 APPEARANCES:
2 On beJulf ofthe Plaintiff lig! and Jane Dot 3 BRAD J. EDWARDS,
FARMER, JAFFE, WEISSItla EDWARDS 4
I
On of tbe Jeffrey Epstein:
ROBERT D. CROTON, JR., ESQUIRE
MARK T. LUTHER. ESQUIRE LUITIER ea COLEMAN, LLP
• 2 On bed o • • licfrroYEPslele: .3 JACK ALAN GOLDBERGER, ESQUIRE ER Fe WEISS. PA 14
16 17
20 21
22 23
24 25
ALSO PRESENT: kffrey Epstein, via video conference
Daniel Downey, Videograplicr
Visual Evidence, Incorporated
1 PROCEEDINGS
3 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: This is the 9th day of
4 February, 2010. The dine is approximately
5 10 imIty.m. This is the videotaped deposition
6 OM. in the matter of M. versus Epstein.
7 This deposition is being held at 250 South
8 Australian Avenue, West Palm Beach, Florida.
9 My name is Daniel Downey, I am the
10 videographer representing Visual Evidence,
11 Incorporated. Will the attorneys please
12 announce their appearances for the record.
13 MR. EDWARDS: Brad Edwards on behalf of
15 MR. LUTTLER: Mark Luttier with the firm
16 of Burman, Critton, Luther & Coleman on behalf
17 of Mr. Epstein.
18 MR. CRITMN: Bob Critton on behalf of
19 Mr. Epstein.
20 Thereupon,
22 Having been first duly sworn or affirmed, was
23 examined and testified as follows:
24 THE WITNESS: I do.
INDEX VOLUME I
Page 338
6 WITNESS: DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS
8 BY MR. LUTHER 4
11.
12 NO EXHIBITS MARKED
(561) 832-7500
Page 340
1 DIRECT EXAMINATION
2 BY MR. LLTIT1ER:
3 Q. Good morning, Ms... We're here for the
4 continuation of your deposition that was started on
5 September 24th, 2009. Do you understand that you're
6 still under oath today?
7 A. Yes, sir.
8 Q. Have you had an opportunity to reviewa
9 transcript of that portion of your deposition which
10 has been completed thus far?
11 A. Yes, sir.
12 Q. Have you reviewed the full transcript?
13 A. Yes, sir.
14 Q. And were there any corrections in your
15 testimony?
16 A. Were there any corrections in my testimony?
17 Q. In other words, when you read it did you
18 see anything that was incorrect?
19 A. No, sir.
20 Q. Do you recall whether or not you silted
21 the transcript indicating that all of it was
22 accurate?
23 A. I signed, yes.
24 Q Do you know if the original got sent
25 anywhere or do you stil I have it or dicliou just
2 (Pages 337 to 340)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 341
1 give it to your lawyer?
2 A. I gave it to my attorney.
3 Q. And you signed it without any corrections?
4 A. Yes, sir.
5 Q. Have you ever been to Mr. Edwards' former
6 law firm's office in Fort Lauderdale? That would be
7 the firm of Rothstein, Rosenfeldt & Adler.
8 A. What is this address? Is this address on
9 Andrews?
10 Q.
1/ A. No.
12 Q. Have you ever been to a law firm where
13 Mr. Edwards was practicing while he's been
14 representing you where there are other lawyers
15 besides himself present?
16 A. No.
17 Q. Does the name Rothstein ring a bell to
18 you? Do you know who that is?
19 A. No.
20 Q. Do -- have you ever met with anyone else
21 other than your lawyer with respect to the merits of
22 this lawsuit and whether or not you believed you
23 were likely to recover money in this case?
24 A. No.
25 Q. Has anyone ever approached you arid --
Page 343
shown to third parties and they had been asked
whether or not they wanted to purchase an interest
in your lawsuit?

A. No.
Q. No one had called you and advised you that
your files were being shown to anybody?
A. No.
Q. Have you had any discussions with anyone
about that issue?

A. No.
Q. And when I say anyone I mean
representative of the Florida Bar Association; have
you had any discussions with anybody from the
Florida Bar?

A. No, sir.
Q. Any discussions with anybody from the FBI
about that specific issue?
A. About what issue, about getting —
. Q. About someone attempting to purchase an
interest in your lawsuit.

A. No.
Q. Anyone from the State Attorney's office?
A. No.
Q. Okay. Prior to coming here today, have
you had an opportunity to review a transcript of a
Page 342
1 other than your lawyer -- and discussed with you the
2 merits of this case or whether or not you believed
3 you were likely to recover money?
4 A. No.

Q. Have you been advised that — or let me
6 strike that. Have you been provided any information
7 that your case and the information contained in it
8 was made available to third parties to review to
9 determine whether or not they wanted to purchase an
10 interest in the outcome of your case?
11 A. No.
12 Q. Have you, prior to me just asking you that
13 • question, did you know that that had occurred?
14 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the fonn.
15 THE WITNESS: Excuse me?
16 MR. EDWARDS: I objected to the form of
17 the question. It assumes that it did occur.
18 BY MR. LUITIER:
19 Q. Before I asked you that question, did you
20 know that that had occurred.
21 A. Sr, I'm not really understanding what you're
22 saying.
23 Q. All right. Let me repeat it.
24 . A. Okay.
25 Q. Did you know that your case tiles had been
Page 344
1 hearing that was held before the court on
2 November 3rd, 2009, upon your motion to terminate
3 the continuation of this deposition?
4 A. Excuse me?
5 Q. Prior to coming here today have you been
6 provided an opportunity to review a transcript of a
7 hearing that was held before the court on
8 November 3rd, 2009, on your motion to limit this
9 deposition?
10 A. I'm not understanding this.
11 Q. You know what a transcript is, don't you?
12 A. A transcript, yes.
13 Q. This would have been a transcript or
14 written record of a court hearing that we had in
15 case on November 3rd, 2009, that concerned the
16 conducting of this deposition. Have you seen any
17 such transcript?
18 A. A transcript of what?
19 Q. Of that court hearing.
20 A. Of what court hearing?
21 Q. The one that was held on November 3rd,
22 2009.
23 A. That we recently just did, my last deposition?
24 Q. No. The, the hearing was held on
25 November 3rd, 2009. The subject matter of the

(561) 832-7500
3 (Pages 341 to 344)
PROSE COURT. REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
.3
11.
Page 345
hearing was a motion that was filed by your lawyer
to limit the continuation of this deposition.

A. Yes. I knew that we were going to have
another deposition.
• Have you seen the transcript of that
hearing wherein the judge gave some specific
direction to you and your conduct in the
continuation of this —

A. Yes.
Q. deposition?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. So you're aware of that?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Are you still living at the same
address that you gave me at the last deposition?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who else is living with you there now?
A. My son.
Q. Anyone else?
A. No, sir.
Q. Has anyone else lived with you at that
address since your deposition on September 24th,
2009, other than your son?

A. No, sir. Since November, actually, Thomas
Souder, he had moved, he lived with me until
6 .
Page 347
was 13 years old. And on that note, he took it from
there to just comfort me through the, through the pain
that I was going through and that I have been going
through.

Q. Did any of these discussions concern
anything else?
A. No, sir.
Q Have you, since your deposition on
September 24th, 2009, had any type of contact with
anyone else who has filed asuit against

Mr. Epstein?
A. Yes.
Q. M.  Who have you had contact with?
A
Q. Anyone else?
A. No, sir.
Q. And when I, I use the word contact, by
that I mean could be face-to-face contact, could be
a conversation, could be some sort of computer,
computer message, a text, Twitter, e-mail, any kind
of commuter — anything like that, could it be, it
could be something in writing. Do you understand
that's What I mean by communication?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. And so the only person since September
,8
Page 346
January 1st, 2010.
Q. And am I correct  told us at your
last deposition that was then your
current boyfriend?

A. Yes.
Q. Has that relationship changed now?
A. Yes.
Q. He is no longer your current boyfriend?
A. Correct

Q. Is the apartment that you currently live
in, is that a rental apartment?
A. Yes.
Q. Is that rental apartment in your name?

A. Yes.
Q. Bite was the situation that caused
you and to part company?
A. It was mutual.
Q. Was there any domestic violence involved?

A. No, sir.
O• Did you have any discussions with
at any time about this lawsuit?
A. Yes.
• 6
Q. What discussions did you have? 2

A. Well, he's saw the news and I pretty much told 24
him that Jeffrey F nC t in has been mol ting MP since I 25 r.! ,

Q. And when did you have communication with
Page 348
24th, 2009,. that. yo_u had any contact with that has a

Ms. Lan cry?
suit pending against Mr. Epstein is E.?
A. Yes, sir.
put her microphone on?
actually getting all of this.
THE WITNESS: No.
THE WITNESS:

MR. CRITION: No, Mr
MR. LUU1ER:
MR. CRITTON: Oh,
MR. LUTIIER: Yeah.
MR. CRITTON: Okay.
MR. LUITIER: And when did you
VIDEOGRAPHER: I can pick her up.

MR. EDWARD: You can pick — Okay.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: That's fine.
MR. LUTT1ER: That would be a good idea.
MR. EDWARDS: Let's make sure we're

MR. LUTTIEFt: Start over.
MR. EDWARD: We don't need that.
3 BY MR. LUTTEER:
MR. CRITTON: What.did she say?

MR. EDWARD: Fm sorry. Does she need to
4 (Pages 345 to 348)
(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (.561). 832-7506 . '
Page 349
1 A. We are awriates. We're friends. When did I
2 have a conversation with ha?
3 Q. Yes. Well, I don't want to limit it to a
4 conversation. When did you have communication with
her?
A. I have communication with her frequently but
7 we don't talk about the Jeffrey Epstein case. My
8 attorney is not her attorney. We don't choose to talk
9 about it.
10 Q. When you said you are associates, what do
11 you mean?
12 A. Well, I have my life and she has her life.
13 Q. Well, you said that you were associates
14 and then you said friends. But you used the term
15 associates.
16 A. We are friends.
17 Q. Do you have any kind of business
18 relationship with her?
19 A. Not at all.
20 Q. Did you mean the word associates to mean
21 something other than just merely being social
22 friends?
23 A. We are friends.
24 Q. Do you have any kind of relationship with
25 her other than simply friends?
Page 351
1 and we can confine (sic) in each other if anything. But
2 as in confining, I mean all I have to do is look in her
3 eyes and'we just know the pain that we've went through.
4 Q. Am I going to assume correctly that the
5 word you mean is confide, you confide in each other?
6 You tell each other -
7 A. No, I told you, as when I confine in her, it's
8 as simple as we will go to a bar. We'll look at each
9 other in our eyes and we just realize the pain that
10 Jeffrey has caused us.
11 Q. Do you have any other discussions with her
12 or have you had any other discussions with her in
13 more detail than that?
14 A. I have know that she has an attorney and I
15 have mine. But other than that, we definitely don't
16 talk about the case because ifs negative. We already
17 know what we went through.
18 Q. Has she indicated to you whether she's
19 been in contact with other people that have pending
20 claims again Mr. Epstein?
21 A. No, sir.
22 Q. Has she indicated to you whether or not
23 she has sought any professional help? By that I
24 mean a mental health professional, psychologist,
25 psychiatrist, that thing, that type of thing?
Page 350
1 A. We're just fiends. 1
2 Q. You have no common joint venture that 2
3 you're pursuing? 3
4 A. No. 4
5 Q. No business that you're pursuing? 5

A. No. 6
7 Q. Are you-all in clubs together? 7
8 A. We go out sometimes.
9 Q. By clubs I meant — I don't know what 9
10 clubs women are in no, Junior League or 4-H, that 10
11 type of thing. I don't mean nightclubs. Are 11
12 you-all in any organizations together? 12
13 A. No. 13
14 Q. Okay. Does — 14
15 A. We go out to a bar once in a blue moon. 15
16 Q. With what degree of frequency do you have 16
17 contact with her? 17
18 A. I call her and tell her I love her once a 18
19 week. 19 -
20 Q. Is that something unique to your 20
21 relationship with her? 21
22 A. Yes. 22
23 Q. And what is it about your relationship 23
24 with her that's unique? 24
25 A. We've been fighting the Jeffrey Epstein case 25

(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT
Page 352
A. No, sir.
Q. There were some other — Ms..., is
that, is that an individual that you took to

Mr. Epstein?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And on how many occasions did you take her
to Mr. Epstein?
A. Around four times,

Q. And did she go alone after that?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And did she tell you how many times she
went?
A. No, sir.

Q. Has she indicated to you any intent to sue
you for taking her to Mr. Epstein?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did the discussion ever come up?

A. No, sir.
Q. Do you feel responsible in some part for
taking her to Mr. Epstein if she claims that she was
somehow damaged as a result of going to sec him?

A. No, sir.
Q. And did you tell her when you first took
her to Mr. Epstein that nothing bad was going to
hapeen, that she wasn'tring to be asked to do
5 (Pages 349 to 352)
REPORTING AGENCY, INC . (561) 832-7506
Page 353
1 anything she didn't want to do?
2 A. Correct.
3 Q. Did you tell her exactly what to expect
4 when she went?
5 A. No.
6 Q. And did she -- after she went the first
7 time, did she indicate to you anything about the
visit?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. What did she say?
11 A. She told me she did not like it.
12 Q. That would be on the first visit?
13 A. Yet
14 Q. Did she say Mr. Epstein did anything or
15 forced her to do anything that she didn't want to
16 do?
17 A. Mr. Epstein always told us don't tell anybody.
18 He just wanted us to find girls. So, whatever
19 transpired between her and Mr. Jeffrey Epstein, i
20 don't -- I'm not sure.
21 MR. LUTHER: Move to strike as not being
22 responsive to the question. My question was,
23 if you will read back what my question was to
24 the witness.
25 (Tbe requested portion of the record was
Page 355
1 anything at all that she didn't want to do that he
2 insisted that she do?
3 A. No. All she told me is that she was afraid of
4 him and she did not want to go back.
S Q. And so what did you tell her after this
first visit where you took her there and told her
7 that she could be as comfortable as she wanted and
8 she reported to you that she felt that she had to do
9 whatever Mr. Epstein wanted her to do?
10 A. Weil, I said why don't we go again and make
11 some money.
12 Q. So, it was you that encouraged her
13 notwithstanding whatever reservations she told you
14 to go back to Mr. Epstein?
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. And you told her let's do that because you
17 wanted to make money; is that correct?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. And after the second visit, did Ms. • 20 tell you that, anything about her visit with

21. Mr. Epstein?
22 A. She told me the same thing. She was very
23 quiet about it. She said I do not want to go back.
24 Q. And notwithstanding that comment did you
25 take her back a third time?
Faye 3
1 read by the reporter.)
2 THE WITNESS: Yes.
3 BY MR. LUTTIER:
4 Q. What did she tell you?
5 A. She said that she felt very obligated to do
6 what Mr. Jeffrey Epstein had asked her to do.
7 Q. And what did she say Mr. Epstein asked her
8 to do?
9 A. Take off her clothes.
10 Q. And you had told her before she went that
11 that was going to be requested of her, right?
12 A. Brom what I remember, I told her that, that
13 she would be in a room and we were going to massage his
14 thighs. And then oncel left the room you can be as
15 comfortable as you want to be with him.
16 Q. And did she say anything other than that
17 occurred?
18 A. Excuse me?
19 Q. Did she say anything other than that
20 occurred?
21 A. She said she wasn't comfortable.
22 Q. And did she say that she told Mr. Epstein
23 that?
24 A. No, she was scared of him.
25 Q. She indicate that she told Mr. Epstein %el

(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT
1.0
11.
Page 356
A. Yes.
Q. And what did you tell her after she told
you she didn't want to go back?

A. I was stubborn and I said let's go back, and
please make some more money.
Q. So, would it be a fair statement to say
that you coerced her into going back?

A. Yes.
Q. Now, why would you coerce a friend of
yours to go back?
A. Well, when you're -- at that time I was 14.
And when you're 14 and you're poor, a young lady is
going to do anything for money especially when you're
intimidated by a man who lives in an island that was
highly, highly known of. And i was very intimidated by
Jeffrey, and he always wanted me to bring girls. And he
told me, make sure you have a girl for me. So, at that
time, I would only, at that specific time i would only
have

Q. Had you been brought up with any kind of
moral upbringing from your parents?
A. Yes.
Q. And had you been taught as a, as a child
from as far back as you can remember not to do
things that were wrong?
6 (Pages 353 to 356)
REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 357
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. And you discarded your upbringing and
3 decided in order to make money you would tell your,
4 one of your good friends that notwithstanding her
5 reservations about going back to Mr. Epstein that
b you wanted her to do that; is that correct?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. Other than Ms. E telling you that she
9 felt that she was obligated to do what Mr. Epstein
10 wanted her to do, did she tell you anything about,
11 anything else about her conversations or
12 interactions with Mr. Epstein at any time?
13 A. She told me that if Jeffrey told her if she
14 was to tell anybody, she would be in trouble.
15 Q. Did she tell you anything else?
16 A. No.
17 Q. Now, at some point in time before you
18 filed this lawsuit, the FBI came to visit with you?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Is that correct?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. And they took a sworn statement from you,
23 correct?
24 A. At what time?
25 Q. They took a sworn statement sometime
Page 359
Eisenberg at the statement representing you,
correct?

A. Yes.
Q. Okay. And did you tell the FBI what you
just told me about the conversations you had with
el ?A. No.

Q. In fact what you told the FBI was exactly
the opposite, was it not?
A. Correct.
Q. Now, there are a number of other people
who in the first deposition you said you had contact
with in the past. So, I want to make sure we
haven't missed anybody with respect to my question
about communications with them since September 24th
of '09. There was a lady you referred to in your
previous deposition by the name of At the
time of your prior deposition you sae you
know her last name. Do you now know her last name?

A. No, sir.
Q. Say what?
A. No, sir.
Q. Does the name Msound familiar to
you?
A. No, sir.
Page 358
1 before you filed this lawsuit?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q And you were represented by a lawyer at
4 that sworn statement; is that right?

5. MR. EDWARDS: Object, I object to the
6 form. And I know that it's not your intention
7 to rehash the entire first deposition, but I
8 think this area was covered. So, to the extent
9 that it wasn't, then obviously the inquiry can
10 proceed, but we're not going to rehash the
11 entire event as it happened in the first
12 deposition.
13 MR. LUTHER: I have no intention to.
14 BY MR. LUTHER:
15 Q. You were represented by a lawyer at that
16 time, correct?
17 A. On Jeffreys behalf?
18 Q. No, on your behalf. There was a lawyer
19 there who represented to the FBI that he was your
20 lawyer, is that right?

21. MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
22 THE WITNESS: I am not understanding this,
23 sir. •
24 BY MR. LIMITER:
25 Q. There was a fellow by the name of James
Page 360
1 Q Have you had any communications with this
2 lady since your September 24th, '09,
3 deposition
4 A. No, sir.
5 Q Have you had any communications with a
6 lady by the name of Jane Doe II since your September
7 24th, '09, deposition?
8 A. No, sir.
9 Q. Have you had any communications with a
10 lady by the name of Jane Doe since your September
11 24th, 2009, deposition?
12 A. No, sir.
13 Q. On your last deposition, you indicated to
14 us that at some point in tune Ms. Jane Doe,'
15 believe, had watched your son for you on some
16 occasion?
17 A. Yes. About two occasions.
18 Q. Okay. Other than those two occasions that
19 you've described in the previous deposition, has
20 Ms. Jane Doe ever watched your son since then or on
21 any other occasion?
22 A. No, sir.
23 Q Since your September 24th, '09, deposition
24 have you ever had anybody else watch your son or has
25 he always been with you since then?

(561) 832-7500
7 (Pages 357 to 360)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
1 A. I have a,1 have a babysitter.
2 Q. And who is your babysitter?
3 A.
zs
Page 361

A. I'm not really sure how to spell --
Q. Where—
A. — her
Q. WherenaZ4IMI reside?
A. She resides in the, in the acreage. I'm not
positive what the address is.

Q. With what degree of frequency since
September 24th, '09, have you utilized her services
to watch your son?

A. Very frequently. Ever since December, I mean
January 1st, 2010, she watches my son regularly.
Q. Is there like certain days of the week she
automatically watches him?

A. No.
Q. And, and why -- is the frequency with
which she watches your son since January of 2010
greater than the frequency with which you had people
8.
Page 363

A. Yes, or at night as well.
Q. Whose shows do you sell? What line of
shoes? . .
A. I sell BCBG, Jessica Simpson. Coach. I can
pretty much get any shoe.

Q. And where do you get the shoes?
A. Igo to Macy's. Igo to the clearance rack.
I buy them for really cheap, and 1 sell them for what
they are originally.

Q. So, you would go into a Macy's, if there
was a clearance and buy a half a dozen pairs of
shoes?
A. Yes. •

Q. Without knowing what anybody's size was?
A. Correct.
Q. In other words you don't get somebody's
order first and go fill the order?

A. I could do that but I really don't — I would
rather go there and buy a bulk of shoes with whatever
size. And if someone is interested in a nail salon, you
know, and if ifs their size, then they'll buy it

Q. When did you first start selling these
shoes?
A. January I st, 2010.
Q. And did somebody introduce you to this
Page 362
1 watch your son prior to that date?
2 A. Excuse me? Can you —
3 Q. Why is she watching your son frequently
4 since January 10?
5 A. So I can work.
6 Q. Okay. Where are you working?
7 A. I sell Mary Kay, shoes, lingerie, and clothes.
8 Q. Mary Kay shoes?
9 A. Lingerie and clothes.
10 Q. Lingerie and what else?
11 A. And clothes.
12 Q. Is that, is that all of that Mary ICay
13 items; that is Mary Kay has a line of shoes, or are
14 you saying —
15 A. No.
16 Q. — that you sell Mary Kay cosmetics, plus
17 you sell shoes, plus you sell lingerie, plus you •
18 sell clothes?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. All right And do you — what hours do

23. you work?
22 A. Well, 1 just, it's on my own hours. I will go
23' to tanning salons to see if anybody wants to buy. I
24 will go to nail salons.
25 Q. Is this all during the day?
Page 364
1 business?
2 A. No.
3 Q. This is something you came up with on your
4 own?
5 A. Yes.
6 • Q. Okay. Who do you sell lingerie for?
7 A. I go to different areas. I go to, I will go
8 to strip clubs and sell lingerie if they want it. My
9' girlfriends. I sell lingerie to. Valentine's is coming
10 up. I will be selling a lot of lingerie soon.

11. Q. Who do you get the lingerie from?
12 A. Igo to local adult stores and I go to the
13 clearance and I buy them in bulk, and then I sell them
14 for the original or more price.
15 Q So and when do you go to these strip
16 clubs, during the day or at night?
17 A. Both.
18 Q. And what do you do at these strip clubs?
19 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form You tan
20 EMSWer.
21 THE WITNESS: Yeah, I walk In with my
22 duffel bag MI oldie items I like to sell,
23 and the women get to choose what they wait to
.24. buy
25.
8 (Pages 361 to 364)
:(561) 832-7500 PROSE ,COURT REPORTING' AGENCY, INC. . (561) 832-7506
Page 365
1 BY MR.. LUITIER:
2 Q. Do you dance at any of these strip clubs?
3 A. No, sir.
4 ' Q. Have you danced anywhere since September
5 24th, 2009?
6 A. No, sir.
7 Q. Have you worked in any adult establishment
8 of any kind or nature since September 24th, 2009?
9 A. Not in a strip joint, no.
10 Q. Okay. Well, have you worked in any other
11 kind of adult establishment other than a strip joint
12 since September 24th, '09?
13 A. Yes.
14 Q. Where have you worked?
15 A. I have worked for my private clientele.
1.6 Q. What do you mean by "private clientele"?
17 A. I have worked, I have been company to a few
18 men that I have met ever since the last deposition, and
19 I provide company for than.
20 Q. The last time you told us you had worked
21 for an escort service. Do you recall that?
22 A. Correct
23 Q. Is this in essence the same thing you're
24 still doing?
25 A. No.
Page 367

Q. So, what you are telling the ladies and
gentlemen of the jury is somebody pays you three to
$500 an hour just to be in your company and not to
have any sex with you?
MR.. EDWARDS: Object to the fonn.
BY MR. LUTTIER:

Q. Is that right?
MR. EDWARDS: And just so that the record
Is clear, the wage claim, the loss wages and
loss of earning capacity has been withdrawn in
the case.
You can answer the question, if you
understand the question.
BY MR. LUTTIER:

Q. Is that right.
A. What was the question?
Q. So you're telling the ladies and gentlemen
of the jury that men pay you three to $500 an hour
just for your company but you have no sex with them;
is that correct?

MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
111E WITNESS: Correct.
BY MR. LUTHER:
Q. Or is sex an additional charge?

A. No, I don't have sex with them.
Page 366
1 Q. Are you working for an escort service now?
2 A. No.
3 Q. Have you been working for an escort
4 service since September 24th, 2009?
5 A. No, sir.
6 Q. Do you advertise your services somehow?
7 A. No, sir.
8 Q. So, how do you — how do these people know
9 to retain your services?
10 A. Word of mouth.
1 Q Okay. And how do they get word of mouth?
12 A. I have one client, Bobby, and he has referred
13 me to three other clients.
14 Q. And what's the difference between what you
15 are doling with these clients and what you did with
16 the escort service?
17 A. Well, the difference is is that I don't
18 perform any sexual acts. It's pretty much just I am
19 company if — they pay me for my company.
20 Q. Well, how much do they pay you for your
21 company?
22 A. It ranges anyway, any any price is from 300
23 to 500.
24 g 300 to 500 what?
25 A. An hour.
Page 368
1 Q. Have you ever — or when did you start
2 this little escort service that you're describing
3 now?
4 A. Well, I don't know what your definition of
5 escort is. It's pretty much I offer my company to got
6 paid. January 5th, 2010.
7 1 Q. And how did you fix on the date
8 January 5th?
9 A. I had met a gentleman named Bobby in CityPlace
10 and we sat down for a drink and we just started talking.
11 Q. Had you gone there to meet him?
12 A. No, I just went there by myself. And I
13 just —
14 Q. Did you meet him in an establishment at
15 CityPlaoe?
16 A. I met him at Carousel.
17 Q. Okay. That's a restaurant and a bar
18 there?
19 A. It's a restaurant, correct.
20 Q. Okay. Is that Can Can --
21 A. Can Can Carousel (sic).
22 Q. Motive or motif?
23 A. Can Can Carousel.
24 Q. Right The waitresses are in cancan
25 outfits and dance on the tables or something like
9 (Pages 365 to 368)
(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 369
1 that?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. And were, were you there -- why were you
4 there?
5 A. I was just — Igo out by myself sometimes
6 just to recuperate and have a nice drink and a nice
7 dinner by myself. I am single.
8 Q. So, were you there for dinner or were you
9 there for something else?
10 A. I was there fora drink.
11 Q. So you went to the bar?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. And this fellow happened to be at the bar?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. And it wasn't, it wasn't prearranged. He
16 just happened to be at the bar?
17 A. Correct
18 Q. Okay. And then how did it evolve from you
19 sitting next to this person who you had no contact
20 with prior to that, right?
21 A. Correct.
22 Q. To suddenly he was lining up escorts for
23 you, or lining up people for you to escort?
24 A. He did not line up escorts for me at that --
25 or, I don't know what your definition of escort is. But
Page 371
1 males approximately your age would ask you out to a
2 movie or something like that on a date. Has that
3 happened to you?
4 A. Yes. With these men, yes.
5 Q. So, what these people -- you consider
6 these people dates; is that what you're telling me?
7 A. Yes, we go out to the movies. We go out to
8 eat dinner.
9 Q. How many dates did you have as a youth
10 where people paid you three to 5500 an hour —
11 A. Sir --
12 Q just to have the opporttmity to date
13 you?
14 A. Ever since Jeffrey Epstein --
15 MIL EDWARDS: Object to the form.
16 THE WITNESS: -- I have never hung out
17 with anyone my age. He has taught me that
18 older men have money, and that's all I know.
19 BY MR. LUTTIER:
20 Q. Is that, is that something that you had to
21 be taught that is this was some particularly unique
22 thing that you learned from Mr. Epstein, older men
23 have money?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And do you believe that statement Is true,
Page 370
1 he didn't line anybody up at that specific time. We, I
2 just — I was just at the bar and he just so happened to
3 be at the bar as well, and we started talking. I was
4 alone. He was alone. He is an older man He told me
5 he was married, and he said that he would love to enjoy
6 my company.
7 Q. And what did you say?
8 A. I said sure.
9 Q. Is it, is it now your practice to go out
10 with older married men without their wives so they
11 can enjoy your company?
12 A. Sure.
13 Q. And what do you think those older married
14 men have in mind?
15 A. I don't know what they have in mind but with
16 the four customers I do have, I know what they have in
17 mind.
18 Q. These clearly aren't dates, right? These
19 are not —
20 A. They —
21 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
22 • BY MR. LUTFIER:
23 Q. When I say a date, I assume that there
24 have been times in your life, and maybe I am wrong
25 and cornett me ifl an wrong, where a male, young
Page 372
1 older men have money?
2 A. As of right now, yes.
3 Q. No such thing as older men without money,
4 right?
5 MR EDWARDS: Form.
6 THE WITNESS: White collar men have money.
7 BY MR. LUITIER:
8 Q. White collar. You mean the color of the
9 shirt they wear? What you did mean by white collar?
10 A. Successful men.
11 Q. You mean you've figured out how to look at
12 an older man and determine whether or not he is
13 likely to have money?
14 A. Yes, Jeffrey has definitely showed me the
15 ambiance and the, the way a man should look to where
16 they have money.
17 Q. Well, how did he teach you that?
18 A. Well, I was with hlm since I was 13, 14, 15,
19 16, going onto 17, and I pretty much have an eye for
20 that
21 Q. What do you mean when you say you were
22 with him for that period of time?
23 A. I was with Jeffrey —
24 Q. But I mean -
25 A. -- seeing Jeffrey.
I
(561) 832-7500
10 (Pages 369 to 372)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 373 Page 375
1 Q. — did you and he go out to dinner? 1 A. Well, I sat down and I talked to him and we
2 A. No. 2 had a nice conversation. And he pretty much told me
3 Q. Didn't — maybe I misunderstood something 3 that he has a wife, but he would lilts to take me out to
4 from your last deposition, but didn't you simply go 4 dinner as much as, you know, as much as possible.
5 to Mr. Epstein's house -- 5 Q. Well, did you ask him — did that seem
6 A. Correct. 6 unusual or strange to you?
7 Q. to perform massages? 7 A. At this time in my life, no.
8 A. Correct That's in the past B Q. Because you had worked as an escort in an
9 Q. So, he wasn't taking you out in public to 9 escort service for a substantial period of time in
10 movies or dinners or shows or things like that 10 the past, right?
11 correct? 11 A. Correct
12 A. No, but he has sent me out with a couple of 12 MR. EDWARDS: Object to form.
13 girls to buy a movie, he's rode me around in his car. 13 BY MR. LUTHER:
14 Q. So, how did he show you how to identify an 14 Q. And you knew what married men that wanted
15 older man that you believe has money? 15 to go out with young women really meant, correct?
16 A. Well, as a younger girl when I am 13, and 14, 16 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
17 and 15 years old, and I am going to a mansion once or 17 THE WITNESS: Correct.
18 twice a day, and I see that environment, subconsciously 18 BY MR. LUTHER:
19 you, you, you learn that 19 Q. And you knew that's exactly what Bobby had
20 Q. So, what you have done is you believe you 20 in mind, right?
21 have acquired a skill and that skill is how to look 21 A. No, be told me he did not want to have sexual
22 and figure out whether or not older men have money, 22 intercourse. He just wanted company. He's an old man
23 correct? 23 that has an old wife and he just simply wants a young
24 A. Jeffrey taught me that — 24 woman to have company with.
25 Q. That wasn't my question. 25 Q. And you think it's perfectly acceptable to
Page 374 Page 376
1 A. — lifestyle. 1 charge him — what do you charge him, by the way,
2 MR. LUTTIER: Move to strike, not 2 300 or 500 an hour?
3 responsive. Would you read my question back to 3 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
4 her? 4 THE WITNESS: Whatever he wants to give
5 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form. And the 5 me.
6 answer was responsive to the question. 6 BY MR. LUTHER:
7 THE WITNESS: I believe it was. 7 Q. Well, what's your — what do you tell him .
8 MR. LUTHER: Go ahead and read back my 8 the charge Is?
9 question. 9 A. I don't tell him anything. Whatever he wants
10 (The requested portion of the record was 10 to give me. 300 most of the time.
11 read by the reporter.) 11 Q. How many times have you gone out with him?
12 MIL LUITIER: Now, would you answer — 12 A. Around five times now.
13 THE WITNESS: Correct 13 Q. Okay. Tell us where you have gone.
14 MR. LUTHER: Okay. 14 A. We've went to several, actually we went to
15 BY Mft. LUTTIER: 15 several hotels.
16 Q. Now, how did you know when you were 16 Q. What do you mean several hotels?
17 sitting there — strike that. Was this individual 17 A. We've been to La Quinta.
18 who I believe you said his name was Bobby that you 18 Q. What is there at La Quints?
19 met at the Carousel bar, was he one of those 19 A. A hotel room.
20 individuals that you identified as an older man with 20 Q. Is there a bar them or something?
21 money? 21 A. No, it's just a room.
22 A. Correct. 22 Q. You went to a hotel room with him?
23 Q. And how were you able to determine sitting 23 A. Correct, because he has wife and I can't go to
24 at a bar meeting this stranger for the first time 24 his house to have company with hint
25 that he was an older man with money? 25 Q. So, what exactly did you and Bobby do at

(561) 832-7500
11 (Pages 373 to 376)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 377
1 the La Quinta?
2 A. 'just gave him company.
3 Q. Okay. Well, how do you, to use your
4 phrase, give him company?
5 A. Like I am giving you company right now, l talk
6 to him. He confines in me and we have conversations.
7 Q. And where do you do this, in his hotel
8 . room?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And why wouldn't you just do that out in
11 public if that's all you were doing?
12 A. We have done that out in public.
13 Q. Well, why would I don% understand why
14 Bobby took you to the La Quinta and took you into a
15 hotel room if all you were —
16 A. How can you not understand that?
17 Q. — if all you were going to do is share
18 company? Had you suggested to him that you should
19 get a motel room?
20 A. No.
21 Q. Was that his idea?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. Did he tell you why he thought you should
24 get a motel room?
25 A. So, we can have silence instead of always
Page 379
1 happened.
2 MR. EDWARDS: Form
3 BY MR. LUITIER:
4 'Q. What is Bobby —
5 A. That is what happened.
6 Q. What is Bobby's last name?
7 A. Oh, l have no idea.
8 Q. When you, weren't you at all concerned
9 about going out with a stranger? Didn't you want to
10 know at least what his name was?
11 A. I bow his name is Bobby.
12 Q. Is that all thought you needed to know?
13 A. That's all I felt I needed to know.
14 Q. Where does he live?
15 A. I don't know. I don't care where he lives and
16 I don't want him to know where I live. He has a wife.
17 Q. How, how did, how did you and he meet at
18 the La Quinta? Did he come pick you up someplace?
19 Did you pick him up?
20 A. No, we just drove there.
21 Q. Is, was this a prearranged place to meet?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. All right. And how did that
24 prearrangement occur?
25 A. Well, I gave him my number and he calls me.
Page 378
being at a restaurant.

Q. How were you dressed on that occasion?
A. Just like this.
Q. Did you at any time in the hotel room
undress?

A. No.
Q. Partially or completely?
A. No.
Q. Did you ever place your hands on Bobby —
A. No.
Q. ' — while you were in the motel room?

A. No.
Q. Did he ever place his hands on you?
A. No.
Q. Any kissing?
A. No.
Q. So, Bobby here pays you $500 or $300 to go 17
to a La Quints and literally sit across the room 18
from him; is that right? 19

A. Yes. 20
MR. EDWARDS: Form. 21
THE WITNESS: Some people have money like 22
that. 23
BY MR. LUITIER: 24

Q. At least that's what you're saying 25
Page 383
Q. And he says —
A. I do not have his number.
Q. And what did he say?

A. Hi, would you like to meet at the La Quinta.
Q. And you say sure?
A. Yes.
Q. And do you do that during the day, do you
do that during the day or at night?

A. At night — or during the day, sorry.
Q. Well, which was it?
A. Day.
Q. And what La Quinta was this?
A. On Okeechobee.

Q. Out by the Turnpike?
A. Correct.
Q. And who selected the hotel?

• A. Bobby.
Q. And what's Bobby do?

A. I have no idea.
Q. Did you ever ask him?
A. No.
Q. Did you ever ask him anything about him.
A. He talks about his wife. No, we just have
nice conversations.
. As far as you're concerned this is 'ust

(561) 832-7500
12 (Pages 377 to 380)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506'
Page 381
strictly a business deal, right?

A. Yeah, and a friendship as well.
Q. Where else have you gone with Bobby?
A. Out to eat.
Q And you said you went about five times.
So if once to the La Quinta, and the other four
times were out to eat?
• A. No, we went to the La Quinta again.

Q. Same La Quinta?
A Yes.
Q. Same room?
A. No.
Q. Okay. So La Quinta times two?
A. Okay.
Q. And where did you go to eat?

A. To the Carousel again.
Q. Anyplace else?
A. We went to — and then the fifth one is New
York.
Q.' And when did you go to New York?

A. February 2nd through the 4th.
Q. Of 2007?
A. Correct.
Q. Tell me how that occurred. Bobby just
calls you up and says — well, go ahead and tell me
Page 383
1 A. Oh, I don't know the address. I know it's
2 near Grand Central Station.
3 Q. So, so, all Bobby said was I'm going to
4 New York, and, and do you want to go book a flight?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. Did he say that you were going to do
7 anything when you got to New York or did he just say
8 go take a trip to New York?
9 A. He said take a trip to New York. And he said
10 I will meet you at Anna's. You know, I will meet you at
11 Anna's one time and Mars it.
12 Q. Did you know this Anna before you went?
13 A. No.
14 Q. Had you —
15 A. I just thought it was a nice opportunity to go
16 to New York.
17 Q. So, what are you 22 now?
18 A. Twenty-one.
19 Q. Twenty-one. So, and how long had you
20 known Bobby at that point in time?

23. A. Oh, since January, January 5th, 2010.
22 Q. So, you had known him for less than a
23 month?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q You met him kt a bar?
Page 382
1 what occurred.
2 A. Bobby calls me. He says, well, you can, I'm
3 going to New York with my wife and I said okay. He says
4 you should come sanetime. I said all right. He said if
5 you would like to, you can, you can book yourself a
6 flight. So, I had booked myself a flight to New York.
7 Q. Well, this is like — this was last
8 Tuesday?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. I mean, does he tell you — well, you were
11 just flying into New York. New York City is a big
12 city, a big state. Does he tell you where you're
13 going or anything?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. Where were you going?
16 A. He has a friend Anna that owns a condo, and I
17 stayed with her for two days.
18 Q. I'm going to guess that Anna is not his
19 wife.
20 A. No.
21 Q. Who's Anna? What age is she, your age?
22 A. No, she's an older woman.
23 Q. What do you mean by older?
24 A. She's probably in her 40s.
25 Q. Does anybody else — where was this condo?

(561) 832-7500
Page 384
A. Uh-huh.
Q. You knew — didn't know his last name?
A. No.
Q. You know nothing about what he does?

A. No.
Q. Don't know if he's got a criminal
background?
A. No.
Q. Literally you know nothing about him?

A. Correct.
Q. Other than you believe he has a lot of
money?
A. Correct
Q. He says go to New York and stay with a
friend of mine named Anna?

A. Correct.
Q. You don't know who Anna is?
A. No.
Q. Never met her?
A. No.
Q. Don't know how old she is?
A. No.
Q. Don't know what she does for a living?
A. No. •
Q Don't know if she has a criminal
13 (Pages 381 to 384)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. . (561) 832-7506
Page 385
1 background?
2 A. Correct.
3 Q. You buy yourself a ticket, pay for a
4 ticket?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. You get on a plane and you fly to New
7 York?
8 A. Correct.
9 Q. You go to La Guardia? La Guardia Airport,
10 is that where you want in?
11 A. J.F.K.
12 Q. You go into J.F.K. You get in a cab?
13 A. Correct.
14 Q. You give them the address of wherever Anna
15 is or did somebody come pick you up from the
16 airport?
17 A. No, Thad, I had an address on a piece of
18 paper, and I gave him, the taxi --
19 Q. The cab driver?
20 A. — driver, yeah.
21 Q. So, you go to this Anna place, this Anna
22 lady's, woman's residence?
23 A. Yes, her condo.
24 Q. And you have never seen her?
25 A. No.
Page 387
1 A. I told Bobby I would rather have a girl go
2 with me because I don't want to go by myself. I would
3 Lilco to enjoy New York with a friend of mine.
4 Q. Well, why were you afraid to go alone?
5 A. I wasn't afraid to go alone. I just would
6 rather go with a friend instead of myself.
7 Q. I just want to make sure I understand
8 this. You had no fear or trepidation about going on
9 this trip?
10 A. Of muse I did a little bit, but it was an
11 opportunity for me to go to New York and I took it.
12 Q. Okay. What happens when you get to New
13 York, and you ring the doorbell at this lady's,
14 Anna's condominium or apartment or whatever she
15 lived.
16 A. I introduce myself. introduces herself
17 to Anna and it was nice.
18 Q. What does Anna say toyou? Does she
19 say —
20 A. HIi, welcome, come in.
21 Q. And does she say, ever tell you what her
22 relationship to Bobby is?
23 A. No. She said Bobby's a friend.
24 Q. And so do you stay at this condominium?
25 A. Yes.
Page 386
1 Q. All right. And what do you do? Do you
2 get to her condominium and just go ring the
3 doorbell?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. Did anybody else go with you on this trip?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Who else went th you?
8 A. My girlfriend,M.
9 Q. I thought I asked you earlier whether you
10 had any communications with anyone since September
11 24th who's flied a claims against Mr. Epstein. You
12 said, no, other than •
13 A. Oh, well, •, that's, this is her attorney
14 as well.
15 Q. But she's got a claim going against
16 Mr. Epstein with —
17 A. Fm sony. I didn't think about that
18 Q. — the same lawyer you have.
19 A. I thought you mgelsomeone.
20 Q. Okay. Now, so . is going on this trip?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. Does... know old Bobby?
23 A. No.
24 . Q. Did Bobby tell you to bring . along
25 too?
Page 388
1 Q. And, and who-all is staying in this
2 condominit
3 A. JustM., I, and Anna.
4 Q. Does there — what time do you get to New
5 York?
6 A. Well, we missed our flight, so we — I am
7 pretty sure we got there around 4. I'm guessing.
8 Q. Ballpark. Does there come a time that
9 Bobby hooks up with you someplace?
10 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
11 THE WITNESS: He went to Anna's house on
12 Wednesday.
13 BY MR. LUTFIER:
14 Q. Is Anna's house the same as the
15 condominium yodre staying in?
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. Okay. So he comes to where you're
18 staying?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. But he doesn't come on Tuesday, the day
21 you come up. He comes on. Wednesday?
22 A. Correct.
23 Q. So, what do you all do on Tuesday after
24 you get there?
25 A. We just han out havi a good time —

(561) 832-7500
14 (Pages 385 to 388)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. • (561) 832-7506
Page 389
Q. Sit around in a condominium?

A. — drinking champagne. Yeah.
Q. Did you go out --
A. I'm in New York
Q. — and see — do you go out and see the
city Of just —

A. YetALI went out to the see the city. I
walked. and I walked around by ourselves. We ate
hot dogs, dressed in New York clothes, and we just went
sightseeing.

Q. You said you were drinking champagne?
A. We had a couple of glasses of champagne on
Wednesday with Bobby.

Q. That's Wednesday. Okay. Well, I am going
to get to Wednesday. Let's stay on Tuesday.
Tuesday is the day you fly up there. Champagne on
Tuesday?

A. Yeah, we were tired. No, not —
Q. Any drinking going on any time on Tuesday?
A. Na that I recall. I was very tired. So —

Q. Okay. And —
A. Tuesday, Tuesday night S and I did go out
to a restaurant, Angelo's. So, yes, I did have a
Merlot.

Q. Did Bobby go?
Page 391
1 Q. Did you, did you go out shopping with this
2 fellow? Did he go buy you stuff while you were in
3 New York?
4 A. With Bobby?
5 Q. Bobby, yeah-
6 A. No.
7 Q. He pay — did he gigisup your dinner tab?
8 A. No. !writ to - IM and I had took a taxi
9 to Angelo's.
10 Q. Right.
11 A. We heard that was a good restaurant. And
12 actually we, we met up with a guy there that I have no
13 idea who he is but he was by himself and he offered to
14 buy us dinner.
15 Q. And what was his name?
16 A. I don't even ber.
17 Q. So, you and ago to New York You go
18 to a restaurant. You meet a person who would be,
19 who was an absolute stranger to you and —
20 A. Yes, we're in New York having a good time.
21 Q. And he says, why don't you girls have
22 dinner with me and you say fine?
23 A. Yes. He was alone and obviously saw two hot
24 girls and offered for, to pay a tab for dinner, yeah.
25 Q. Okay. What do you mean by hot girls?
Page 390
1 A. No.
2 Q. Okay. So where is Angeles in
3 relationship to where you're staying?
4 A. I don't know NOW York, sir, sir.
5 Q. Did you walk there or did you have to get
6 a cab?
7 A. We, we got a cab.
8 Q. All right. So, you go to, you go out to
9 dinner. By the way, who is paying for all of this?
10 A. What do you mean?
11 Q. Who paid for the trio Who paid for the
12 flight ticket to begigavith?
13 A. I paid for III% flier and Bobby had paid
14 for my
15 Q. Did you go first class?
16 AL NO.
17 Q. So, how much did you pay for
18 flight?
19 A. 478.
20 Q. And you just took her along just because
21 she was a friend of yours?
22 A. Yes, she's a very good friend of mine.
23 Q. And then when you got up there, I assume
24 you didn't pay anything to stay at kolta's place?
25 A. No.

(561) 832-7500
Page 392
1 A. Two good looking girls —
2 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
3 THE WITNESS: — walking in Angelo's,
4 definitely not from New York. We weren't
5 wearing all black.
6 BY MR. LUTHER:
7 Q. What did you do after dinner?

A. We went right back to the hotel.
9 Q. Did this fellow take you?
10 A. No, we took a taro.
11. Q. And when you say hotel you mean the condo?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. Okay. And then the next day do you hook
14 up with Bobby?
15 A. Wednesday, yes.
16 Q. And what do you do when you — when does
17 he hook up with you?
18 A. He came over in the mid day, maybe around
19 1:00, and we had a couple of glasses of champagne and —
20 Q. With Anna?
21 A. No, not with Anna.
22 Q. Was she gone from the condo?
23 A. No, she was there.
24 Q. Okay. But you guys didn't have champagne
25 in the condo?
15 (Pages 389 to 392)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 393
1 A. Yes, we drank champagne in the condo.
2 Q. Bobby nd you —
• 3 A.
4 Q. — an . But Anna, She was there but
5 didn't have champagne, or she wasn't there?
6 A. I, I don't believe she had champagne. She was
7 there, yes.
8 Q. Okay. All right. All right. So you guys
9 have some champagne and what happens next?
10 A. We had a conversation. We just hung out, had
11 a good time, watched TV.
12 Q. Did you ever go anywhere?
13 A. No.
14 Q. So, Bobby comes to this condo, stays
15 there. You guys are there and then at some point he

16. leaves?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. When does he leave?
19 A. Couple of hours later.
20 Q. What do you-all do the rest of the day?
21 A. We just hung out.
22 Q. What does that mean?
23 A. We hung out in the condo.
24 Q. Did you ever go out that day?
25 A. That day, yes. We walked down the same street
Page 395
1 take you out to dinner?
2 A. Yeah.
3 Q. And so you go with him?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. Again you don't know anything about the
6 PO
7 A. No.
8 Q. And how old is this fellow?
9 A. I don't know.
10 Q. Older than you?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q Okay. Did he look lie he had money?
13 A. I didn't care if he had money or not. i just
14 wanted to see the town.
15 Q. Okay. Just an opportunity?
16 A. Exactly.
17 Q. So, you and . go with this fellow to,
18 out to dinner?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. And he picks up the tab?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. And where do you guys go then?
23 A. He actually took us to see the Statue of
24 Liberty. We did not go on the boat. We just actually
25 saw it from —
23.
Page 394
that we walked down -- I think it's Grand Central
Station. I'm not sure because I'm not from there, but
we went sightseeing.

Q. Okay.
A. A little sightseeing, nothing special.
Q. Did you have a meal out again?
A. No. On Wednesday, on Wednesday, yes, at
night. Yes, on Wednesday night.

Q. Where did you go and with whom?
A. We went with -- oh, my goodness. i can't
remember his name but someone from New York and he took
us to Saigon Grill.

Q. Well, who was this individual?
A. We didn't know him either.
Q. Where did you meet him?
A. II. and I were just looking for opportunities
to go and look around town.

Q. Did you meet him in a bar earlier in the
day or was it somebody that Bobby knew --
A. No, on the street.

Q. -- or setup? You met this guy on the
street?
A. Yeah, we were walking.
Q. Two hot girls walking down the street in
New York You ran into this guy and he offers to

(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT
1 Q. Did you ever during this time that he was
2 buying you dinner and taking you to the Statue of
3 Liberty manage to get his name?
4 A. I did know his name but I don't remember it.
5 Q. Get a phone number from him and call him?
6 A. No, I gave him my phone number.
7 Q. Okay. When you pass out your phone
8 number, do you have like a card that you give
9 people?
10 A. No.
11 Q. You just scribble it on an envelope or
12 napkin or something?
13 A. Or they put it in their phone.
14 Q. Have you ever had business cards?
15 A. I have in '07, '08, but it wasn't for any
16 escort or any personal company like that. It was
17 actually for, to sell shoes and purses.
18 Q. To sell shoes and purses for who?
19 A. For myself.
20 Q I thought you said you just started the
21 shoe business in January of 2010.
22 A. I didn't say I just started it. i've
23 always — I do it once in a while just to make extra
24 money.
25 Q. Is it — did you do it with a business
Page 396 i
16 (Pages 393 to 396)
REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
. 3
Page 397
name or —

A. No, I just wrote III on the card and then my
number and then I said if you're ever interested in any
shoes or purses, give me a call.

Q. Has there ever been any type of — I'm
going to call it a business cant You know what a
business card is?

A. Yes.
Q. Has there ever been any type of business
card that contained a number which is a number at
which you could be reached with either your name on
it, your real name, or any other name that you used
for any purpose whatsoever? Does any such card
exist in the world?

A. Yes. There was a card that said al and then
my old number.
Q. Okay. And is that the only thing that was
on that card?

A. The only thing with two kissy marks.
Q. Now I want to make sure you understand my
question. Other than that card is there any other
business card that's ever existed from the beginning
of the world until now that had your phone number on
it —

A. Uh-huh.
Page 399
1 Q. And you say three years ago. Are you --
2 does that mean it was in the year 2007?
3 A. Yeah, beginning of '07.
4 Q. .For what period of time did you dispense
5 those cards, give them out?
6 A. I didn't really dispense a lot of them at all.
7 1, maybe like for a five month period. I didn't really
8 dispense them at all.
9 Q. And who did you give them to?
10 A. Back three years ago I would give them to
11 potential clients.
12 Q. What do you mean potential clients?
13 A. Potential clients.
14 Q. What kind of clients?
15 A. To run escort.
16 Q. This is when you were working for an
17 escort service?
18 A. No, I was working for myself.
19 Q. You were a self-employed escort?
20 A. Yes, self, yeah.
21 Q. And what, and what were you doing business
22 as? What was your name? Did you have a name for
23 your business?
24 A. No.
25 Q. And why were you using a fake name?
Page 398

Q. — and a name?
A. Yes.
Q. — whether it was your real name or some
stage name or some other name that you've used?

A. Yes, there has been.
Q. Okay. There mere a bunch of those,
weren't there?
MR. EDWARDS: Form.
THE WITNESS: What do you mean a bunch of
those?
BY MR.. LUTTIER:

Q. Go ahead. Tell me about the other cards
that existed.
A. One card, it was a black card. This was
probably three years ago. Yes, three years ago. It
had, rm pretty sure, a fake name on there and a number
to contact me and that's it.

Q. And what else was on the card?
A. I think it was roses. I'm not sure.
Q. What else, what other words were on the
card?
A. No words. Just my name and my number.
Q. And do you remember the name that you
used?
. A. If anything it mould be
Page 400
1 A. Why use my real name?
2 Q. Any other reason why you were using a fake
3 name?
4 A. Yeah, because I don't want stalkers.
5 Q. Now at the time you were using this card,
6 you would give that to prospective escorts; that is
7 males that would pay you money to go out with you,
8 right?
9 A. Correct.
10 Q. And again were you did you figure out
11 how to target what you thought were older men with
12 money?
13 A. Col I ei.t.
14 Q. Now, when you were using the card that
15 said Taneal, not only were you going out with these
16 individuals but you would pertain' sexual acts with
17 these individuals, did you not?
18 A. Correct.
19 Q. What — and you say this went on for a
20 five-month period roughly?
21 .A. Dispensing of the cards.
22 Q. For what period of time, though, were you
23 conducting your own escort' ervice?
24 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
25 THE WITNESS: I can't tell you that.
•(561) 832-7500
17 (Pages 397 to 400)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. . (561) 832-7506
Page 401
1 BY MR. LUTDER
2 Q. Well, was It throughout the whole year —
3 A. I've always before January 2010, I've always
4 been independent in some way or another except when I
5 was with or 11 months.
6 Q. What do you mean by you were independent?
7 You mean you were, you were running your own escort
8 service?
9 A. No, I was running me.
10 Q. Okay. But I mean what you were running
11 was an escort service with one person, that being
12 you?
13 A. Correct
14 Q. All tight. Now, was there a particular
15 clientele that you targeted while you were operating
16 as your one-man or one-woman escort service?
17 A. Old men.
18 Q What, old men?
19 A. Yep.
20 Q. You liked older men better than younger
21 men?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. And why did you like older men better?
24 A. Beeanse Jeffrey had money, so I assumed that
25 older men had money.
Page 403

Q. Okay. Did you ever get paid $2000 a day
when you were working for yourself?
A. No.
Q. What's the most you recall getting paid
when you worked for yourself?

MR. EDWARDS: Form.
THE WITNESS: On advise of counsel I am
invoking my Fifth Amendment rights under the
United States Constitution.
BY MR. LUMER:

Q. And what why would you be invoking your
right under the Fifth Amendment? Do you think you
committed some kind of crime?

A. On advice of counsel I am invoking my Fifth
Amendment tights wider the United States Constitution.
Q. Tell the ladies and gentlemen of the jury
what acts and activities you engaged in with these
older men that you had targeted and thought were
rich for which you got paid between $50 and $2,000?

A. Between what dates?
Q. While you were operating your own escort
savice.
A. Between what dates?
Q. Well, let's take, you said it was 2007.
So, let's take 2007.
Page 402

Q. So, you, your reason for picking old men
was you thought they were rich?
it Correct.
Q. And that's what you wanted was rich
people?

A. Correct.
Q. And how much would you get paid by these
clients?
A. Anywhere froni $50 to — sir, I don't recall
what I made. I can't I can't answer that question
truthfially.

Q. Well, you said in your last deposition,
but I don't know if this is while you were working
on your own escort service or when you were working
for somebody else, that you made as much as $2,000 a
day; do you recall that?

MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
THE WITNESS: Correct
BY MR. LUTHER:
Q. Okay. All nee. So, is that while you
were working for somebody else's escort service or
is that while you were self-employed in your own
escort service?

A. I did that together. I worked for escort
services and I've also worked for nwself.
L7
Page 404
A. Sexual intercourse, oral, and just strictly
company, naked company.

Q. Naked company?
A. Correct
Q. Meaning?
A. Sitting there naked and talking, having a
conversation.
Q. So, a customer would pay you — by the way
when you were running your own escort service, how
would you actually meet the client? Would they come
pick you up, would you pick them up, that kind of
thing?

MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
THE WITNESS: I would meet them at their
house.
BY MR. LUTITER:
Q. Okay. Was that typically what you did,
you would go to a client's house?

A. Correct.
Q. And so some of these clients that you went
to, all of whom were, fit within the category of
rich older men?

A. Correct.
Q. .You— some of them you would just go, go
in and disrobe and sit in their house and talk to

(561) 832-7500
18 (Pages 401 to 404)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. 1561) 832-7506
Page 405
them?
2 A. Correct. Or take a bath, either/or.

Q. Take a bath with them or alone?
A. With them or without them.
5 Q. Would you get calls from individuals whom
6 you had never met before?
7 A. Correct.
8 Q. And then would you have some clients that
9 would be repeat business that would call you again?
10 A. Correct.
11 Q. How would you know if someone called you
12 on the phone whether or not that's, anything about
13 the person?
14 A. How would I know?
15 Q. If the person called you on the phone,
16 would they typically just give you an address and
17 say come meet me there?
18 A. Correct.
19 Q. So how — what did you know about this
20 person before you went to their home?
21 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
22 THE WITNESS: That he has a penis and that
23 he has money.
24 BY MR. WITTER:
25 Q. And how would you be able to ascertain he
Page 407
1 discussion about dollars, how much? •
2 A. If you want to pay my phone bill, I can give
3 you naked company. If you want to pay my son's tuition,
4 I can give you naked company. Bargaining, you know.
5 Q. Would the, would the person actually do
6 that, sort of barter and actually pay your phone
7 bill as opposed to giving you the money? Is that
8 just the amount of money that he would give you is
9 what your phone bill was?
10 A. It would go either way.
11 Q. So, let's —
12 A. rd say, hey, I need my phone bill paid; you
13 can pay my phone bill.
14 Q. Let's use the example of your son's
15 tuition.
16 A. Ifit-huh.
17 Q. Is that, is that an actual event where you
18 told somebody I need my son's tuition paid?
19 A. Yet
20 Q. Okay. And how much was the tuition
21 roughly?
22 A. It's $400 a month.
23 Q. Okay. So you go to this client and you
24 say I need to have my son's tuition paid. That's
25 400 bucks a month. Now, are you — did you
21.
Page 406
bad money?

A. I'm not working for free.
Q. Well, would you have a discussion up front
in the first phone call about money?

A. Sometimes.
Q. Because these are people --
A. I don't hie to talk over the phone. I would
rather talk in person.

Q. Okay. But these would be people that you
had, they had gotten your number someplace but you
had never met the first time, right?

A. Correct
Q. Okay. So then, so a guy calls. You talk
to hint You say you don't want to talk money the
first phone call, so then you go to his house?

A. Coned.
Q. Do you have a discussion with him at that
point in time about money?
A. Correct.
Q. Okay. And, and what would that discussion
be?

A. 1 can accommodate you with whatever your needs 22
are, and you can accommodate me with whatever my needs 23
are. . 24

Q. And would you, would you have a specific 25
Page 408
communicate him that you needed just one month's
paid or more than one month?

A. If they want to pay one month, great, if they
want to pay two, greater.
Q. I mean, what did the client say to you
when you say I need my son's tuition paid?

A. He would either say, yes, I agree, or, no, I
don't agree.
Q. Okay. So. he says, yes, I will agree.
How does that determine, how do you determine what
specific acts you're going to engage in?

A. Whatever he wants. Does he want sexual
intercourse in 'O7. Does he want oral sex in 2007, or
does he just want simple company?
Q So, it didn't, it didn't matter. It
wasn't like certain things cost more so to speak?

A. No, I, no, I just went with the flow.
Q. Okay. What -- and, and you had no
concerns about that?
A. Of course. I am always in fear for what I do.

Q. I mean, did you use like a condom?
A. Yes.
Q. MI right: What was the, what event can
you recall that was the most expensive event you
performed, or the one for which you got paid the

(561) 832-7500
19 (Pages 405 to 408)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 409
1 most money? What did you do for the maximum amount
2 of money that you ever got paid for doing this?
3 A. Is that relevant?
4 Q. Yeah.
5 A. Okay.
6 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the fonn.
7 THE WITNESS: Okay. On advice of counsel
8 I am invoking my Fifth Amendment rights under
9 the United States Constitution.
10 BY MR. LUTTIER:
11 Q. Well, let me ask you this way: You said
12 that you could be anything from naked company to
13 sexual intercourse or oral sex, right?
14 MR. EDWARDS: I'm sorry. What was the
15 question?
16 MR. LUTTIER: it could be anything
17 from naked —
18 MR. EDWARDS: No. What was the question
19 on the table.
20 MR. LUTTIER: The effect of it was the one
21 that you got paid the most for, what did you do
22 is what I asked.
23 THE WITNESS: Yeah.
24 BY MR. LIUTTEER:
25 Q. So what did you do —
Page 411
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. Okay. How, how was that arranged.
3 A. I, I really didn't do a lot of those. If
4 anything two. How was that arranged?
5 Q. Yeah.
6 A. A guy would get a girl. I would go to his
7 house and there would be a girl there.
8 Q. And what would you typical, typically get
9 paid for this?
10 A. I don't — Whatever he wants to give me. I'm
11 not sure.
12 Q. And what acts would you-all, the throe of
13 you engage in?
14 A. We could either sit there and sit in our
15 panties and talk with each other or I would fondle the
16 girl or we would just give oral. It depends. I've
17 already told you.
18 Q. What do you mean we would just give oral?
19 A. The girl that be had called.
20 Q. Well, you, you and the other girl would
21 give oral to each other?
22 A. No. Oral sex for him.
23 Q. Did you ever perform oral sex on another
24 woman ever?
25 A. Yes.
8 9
Page 410

MR. EDWARDS: You can answer.
THE WETNESS: Is that convenient, I mean
MR. EDWARDS: Answer it.
THE WITNESS: From, the first thing that
comes to my mind in 30 minutes I got paid close
to two grand.
BY MR. LUTTIER:

Q. For doing what?
A. Sexual intercourse.
Q. Just straight sexual intercourse?
A. Correct.
Q. Did you have anal intercourse with
anybody?

A. No way.
Q. Sex with other females?
A. Have I ever?
Q. Yeah.
A. Yeah.
Q. Okay. Did you ever do it when you were
employed as an escort service?

A. Have I ever done it in what year?
Q. As part of this escort — well, let's talk
about we're talking about the time when you were
self-employed.
Page .41._
1 Q. Okay. Do you recall when the first time
2 you did that was?
3 A. No.
4 Q. Do you remember how old you were?
5 A. No.
6 Q. Was it prior to your 15th birthday?
7 A. Was it before my 151h birthday?
8 Q. Yell
9 A. I don't recall.
10 Q. Do you remember who it was with?
11 A. No.
12 Q. Have you performed oral sox on women on
13 mom than one occasion?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. Do you remember the names of any of the
16 women that you performed oral sex gat.
17 A. Is this like business or like —
18 Q. And do yo l when the first time you
19 had oral sex with was?
20 A. No.
21 Q. Do you have any fear at all about fl ?
22 A. As in --
23 Q. Anything. Does she scare you? Are you
24 afraid of her at all?
25 A. No.

(561) 832-7500
20 (Pages 409 to 412)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 413
1 Q. And you have knownM. pretty much all
2 your life?
3 A. Since 1 was 13.
4 Q. And did you have oral sex with her before
5 you ever met Jeff Epstein?
6 A. No.
7 Q. And how did it come about that you and she
8 decided to have oral sex?
9 MR. EDWARDS: Form. You can answer if you
10 know.
11 THE WITNESS: When do I recall the last?
12 BY MR. LIJ1T1ER: .
13 Q. How did it come about that you and she
14 decided at some point to have oral sex?
15 A. I don't know. We were probably — I really
16 can't recall that. I don't know. I don't remember.
17 Q. Now, you said that this is the first time
18 that you had oral sex with a female, correct, is the
19 time you had it with.. or was that did I —
20 A. I did not say that was my first time.
21 Q. Was this the first time that you had sex,
22 oral sex with a female?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Okay. Let's go back to the first time you
25 had sex.
Page 415

Q. Well, I am taking on the first occasion.
Was it just two —
A. I don't remember the first occasion. I don't
remember the first girl.

Q. Do you remember about how many -- did it
happen with any degree of frequency?
MR. EDWARDS: Font).
THE WITNESS: No.
BY MR. LUMbR.:

Q. This was consensual, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. All your oral sex with other people was
oonsanual?
A. Yes.
Q. By the way, have you ever been raped?

A. By Jeffrey Epstein.
Q. And how were you raped by Jeffrey Epstein?
A. Well, he took advantage of me since 1 was 13,
14, 15, and then 17 years old, he took advantage of me.

Q. Do you know what the definition of rape
is?
A. What's the definition of rape?
Q. I am just asking, do you know what the
definition of rape is?
A. Well, to me the definition of rape is taking
Page 414
1 A. I told you I don't remember.
2 Q. Well, let me ask you a question here.
3 A. Okay.
4 Q. I asked you if it was before you were 15.
5 You said you didn't recall. Does that mean it may
6 have been before you were 15 --
7 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
8 BY MR. LUITIER:
9 Q. — or you just don't know?
10 A. !just don't know.
11 Q. And you — was that a significant event in
12 your life —
13 A. No.
14 Q. — the first time you had oral sex with a
15 female?
16 A. No.
17 Q. It was no big deal?
18 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
19 ME WITNESS: No.
20 BY MR. LLTITMR:
21 Q. Do you remember anything about the event?
22 A. Pussy in my face.
23 Q. Was it just the two of you or more people
24 involved?
25 A. Sometimes, sometimes not. I don't know.
Page 416
1 advantage of a person who doesn't want to be taken
2 advantage of.
3 Q. So, when you say you were raped by Jeffrey
4 Epstein, that's the definition you're using?
5 A. Correct.
6 Q. Jeffrey Epstein never had sexual
7 intercourse with you, right?
8 A. Nope.
9 Q. Never penetrated an orifice of your body?
10 A. Yes, he did.
11 Q. What orifice did he penetrate?
12 A. He, he penetrated my vagina.
13 Q. With what?
14 A. With his forgers, with a vibrator.
15 Q. With, with a vibrator. Tell — describe
16 thls vibrator that you say he penetrated your
17 orifice?
18 A. It was about a foot long and the head of it
19 was about the size of a small plate, pretty big, pretty
20 powerful right onto my vagina.
21 Q. Did you say onto or did you say he
22 penetrated your vagina?
23 A. He penetrated my vagina with his fingers. He
24 also penetrated my vagina with the vibrator.
25 Q. So, the vibrator you just described you
(.561) 832-7500 .
21 (Pages 413 to 416)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 417
1 said had this big head, that was inserted into your
2 vagina?
3 A. It was not inserted. It was --
4 Q. Placed on the outside of your vagina?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. Did you achieve an organism when this
7 happened?
8 A. Nope.
9 Q. And then you say he insetted his forgers
10 into your vagina?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. And on how many occasions did that happen?
13 A. I've been to Jeffrey Epstein's house so many
14 times, I caret recall how many times he's inserted his
15 fingers into my vagina.
16 Q. Was — had you had intercourse, or excuse
17 me, had you had any type of sexual contact with a
18 male before your first sexual encounter with a
19 female?
20 A. Excuse me?
21 Q. Had you had any sexual encounter with a
22 male before your first sexual encounter with a
23 female?
24 A. !have had an encounter sexually with a man or
25 with a boy before I had any type of sexual acts with a
Page 419
1 A. No.
2 Q. Are you sure?
3 A. Was that before Jeffrey Epstein, no.
4 Q. Are you sure of that?
5 A. Positive.
o Okay. And at the time who wale
7 a (phonetic) to you?
8 A. Boyfriend.
9 Q. Had you been dating him for some period of
10 time or just somebody you happened upon?
11 A. Yeah, we were dating.
12 Q. And what specific acts did you and he
13 engage in, just sexual intercourse?
14 A. 'Yes.
15 Q. Did you ever perform oral sex on him?
16 A. Yeah.
17 Q. And did he perform oral sex on you?
18 A. I — probably.
19 Q. And do you have any idea how long'
20 the time you had your first sex wit
21 alli et:nd when you had your first encounter with a
22 female?
23 A. No.
24 Q. But by the time you were 15 you had had
25 sex with males and sex with females?
25 Q. And was that before Jeffrey in?
Page 418
woman.

Q. Okay. And do you remember the first time
you had sex with a male?
A. Excuse me. Yes.
Q. When was that?

A. I was probably just turning, just -- I, I was
14.
Q. Just turning 14?
A. I was 14.
Q. Do you know — you started by saying "just
turning.° If I remember correctly — I can look up
your birthday here. Lees see. Your birthday is
July 26, 1988?

A. Correct.
Q.. So, with whom did you have this first
sexual encounter with j male?
A. His name wasIM.
Q. And what sexual encounter did you have?

A. Sexual intercourse.
Q. Just straight sexual intercourse?
A. I lost my virginity.
Q. Ci_yca. This is, and is this guys last
name =?

A. Yes.
Page 420
1 A. Yeah. Yes.
2 Q. Did your sex with females consist of
3 anything other than oral sex on each other?
4 A. Just oral.
5 Q. Did you guys use any kind of dildos,
6 vibrators, toys, or anything like that?
7 A. No.
8 Q. You never did that?

A. No.
Q. When was last time you had sex with a
female?
A. I don't remember.
Q. So, did you have sex with. when yet
were in New York?

A. No.
When was the last time you had sex with
A.
Q.
Year?
A.
Q. A.
Q. A.
I don't remember. That was years ago.
Have you had sex with a female in the last
This year, no.
Well, what I mean, '10. How about '09?
Sure. •
Do you know how many times?
No.
22 (Pages 417 to 420)

(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (.561) 832-7506
23.
9 that?
10 A. Yep.
11 Q. Let me guess: You accused him of getting
12 it from someplace else and giving it to you?
13 A. Uh-huh, yes.
14 Q. And what did he say, didn't happen?
15 A. He said lees get it fixed.
16 Q. So you got treated?
17 A.
18 Q. when you first were
19 pregnant with your son, have you ever had any other
20 sexual!
25 Q. Have you had herpes?
Page 421

Q. And were they all females that you knew?
A. I've only done this a couple of times. Yes,
it was females I knew.

Q. Were these -- did you ever have any female
escort service clients?
A. Yeah, that's what I am talking about.

Q. In other words instead of a man calling
you, a female would call you?
A. No.
Q. That's what I meant.

A. No.
Q. So, the females were only in conjunction
with a male calling you?
A. Correct.
Q. All right. How many, roughly, I !mow you
don't know exactly, in 2007, how many clients did
you have in your escort business?

A. I have no idea.
Q. Hundreds?
A. Maybe.
1 A. No.
6 A.
7 Q. Did you get treatment for it?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. What was the treatment?
10 A. What was the treatment?
11 Q. Yeah.
12 A. A Lap.
13 Q. And who performed it?
14 A.
15 Q.
16 A.
17 Q. And where is he?
18 A. Benoist Farms and Okeechobee, Palm Beach, Palm
19 Beach Doctors.
20 Q. Olaty. Hes a gyno?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. Has he been your gyno for a long time?
23 A. Yeah.
24 Q. Is he still your gyno?
25 A. Yeah.
Page 422
And do you remember the first time you got Q it?
A.
A.

Q. A.
Q.
Yes.
When was that?
When I got p with my son.
And did Mr. give it to you?
Yes.
Did you have an argument with him about
(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT
Page 423
Q.

A. Witam iti mmumet
A.
A.
A.
A.
A.
Page 424
When did you get, first get.?
Oh, '07.
Do you know who you got it from?
Yes.
Another boyfriend?
Yeah.
Just had one bout Ma?
Excuse me --
Just had one occasion ofM?
Yes.
Any other sexually transmitted diseases?
No.

Q. Never have -- have you ever been tested
for herpes?
A. Yes.
Q. Tested for Aids?
A. Yes.
Q. Anybody ever accuse you of transmitting a
sexually transmitted disease to them?

A. No.
Q. What was your reaction first of
all, how long did you date Mr. INN, the father
of your child?
23 (Pages 421 to 424)
REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 425
1 A. A year.
2 Q. Was your pregnancy planned with him?
3 A. No.
4 Q. Can we assume that you-all were having
5 sexual intercourse without the benefit of any kind
6 of contraception?
7 A. We had sexual intercourse without condoms.
8 Q. Ended up getting pregnant the first time
9 or was it —
10 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
11 THE WITNESS: I don't know when I had —1
12 know that when I went to the doctor that I was
13 already two months pregnant
14 BY MR. LUTTIER:
15 Q. Is this when you were like 15?
16 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
17 THE WITNESS: I was 16.
18 BY MR. LUTHER:
19 Q. Sixteen. Okay. And when you first went
20 to the doctor and you were two months re artt, is
21 that when you found out you ?
22 A. Yeah.
23 Q. Is that wit °tavern to the doctor was
24 because you had  and then while you were
25 there —
Page 427
THE WITNESS: But it was a miracle.
BY MR. LUTTIER:

Q. Well, I mean, you're happy to have your
child, right?
A. So
A. It was a one-night stand with a cop and the
condom had broke. I was contemplating whether to keep
the baby or not, but I didn't want that child to not
have a father.

Q. By then you'd had your son?
A. Yeah.
Q. And you recognized at that point at least
the, the joys of having a boy, correct?
J.
Page 426

A. No, I, I figured out that I was late on my
period for two months. So, I figured that 1 was
pregnant, took a pregnancy test and went to the doctor
to get checked out, and they told me I had....

Q. And what was reaction when the dos
said you had
A. Hurry up. Get me cured. I need to have this
baby healthy.

Q. Was it upsetting to you?
A. Yeah, of course.
Q. I, I mean, did you think among other
things that your, that, that your then boyfriend,
the father of your child must have been out having
sex with somebody other than you?

A. Before he was, yeah. But when we were dating,
no.
Q. And did you all — what kind of argument
did you and he have about that?

A. I just told him we need to get I wasn't
worried about hint. I was worried about my child. We
needed to get it cured and we did.

Q. Now, being pregnant at 16, I — is it safe
to say that's not what you planned in life?
A. It's not what I planned.

MR. EDWARDS: Object to form.
(561) 832-7500
Page 428
A. Yes. I would have loved to have that baby.
Q. So, what sort of thought process, what
sort of emotional turmoil, if any, did you go
through in making the decision that you were going
to abort the child in February of '09?

A. It was very hardthfam il S
would want m child
And I didn't feel at that
time since I'm working in the business how could I have
worked and made money to support my son plus another
baby without a father.

Q. What do you mean working in the business?
You mean as an escort?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you discuss it with the father?

A. It was a one-night, it was a one-night stand
with a cop.
Q. I mean did you tell him that you were
pregnant by him?

A. No.
Q. So this fellow doesn't even know that you
were carrying his child?
A. No.
24 (Pages 425 to 428)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 429
A.

Q. So you must have had an idea that you were
pregnant for a couple of months?
A. Of course.
Q. Any thought process that you had about not
telling the father of the child?

A. It was a one-night stand with a cop. I don't
even know him.
Q. Well, you must have known him long enough
to have sex with him, right?

MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
THE WITNESS: I was out that night drunk
and so was he. He picked me up, and we had
sex, condom broke. I found out I was pregnant
three weeks later and that's that.
BY MR. LUTTIER:
When were you-all? Where did you hook up
with each other?

A. Dr. Feelgoods.
Q. Down on Clematis?
A. Yes.
Q. Had you ever met the guy before?
A. No.
Q. Did you know, do you know his name?

A. No.
I 7
Page 431
have it over at
A. Yes.
Q. Who took you them?
A. My friend T.J.
And who is T.J.?
A. A friend of mine.

Q. Male or female?
A. Male.
Q. Okay. Would you describe that as a
traumatic event for you. making that decision and
in
light of having had , your son?

A. Of course. Of course.
Q. That's all right Any time during the
25 deposition you realize that yottve told me something
Page 430
1 Q. How is it that you ran into a guy that you :
2 never met before and ended up having sex with him?
3 A. He was a cop. I was drunk.
4 4 Where did you have sex?
5 A. In the car.
6 Q. In the parking, in the parking lot on
7 Clematis?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. Back seat?
10 A. Yeah. Front seat, back seat, trunk. Just

11. kidding
12 Q.. And did you have any, did you have airy
13 second thoughts or any, any regrets about not
14 telling the fellow?
15 A. [can't find him. If I would have found him,
16 I would have told him.
17 Q. Do you know what police department he was
18 with?
19 A. No.
20 in i 7 Did you cry about it,
22 A. Yes.
23 . Did ou to any kind of counseling about
25 A. No.

(561) 832-7500
Page 432
1 wrong, just let me know.
2 A. Okay. Sony.
3 Q. There's no tricks?
4 A.
I
I
13 MR. EDWARDS: Fenn.
14 THE WITNESS: No.
15 BY MR. LUTTIER:
16 Q. Was that a, was it an upsetting event for
17 you?
18 A. No.
19 Q. You were happy to have that happen?
20 A. Yeah.
21 MR. LUTTIER: Okay. I want to take a
22 break and go to the bathroom.
23 THE VIDEOGRAPIJER: Going off the record at
24 11:42 a.m.
25 (A brief recess was held.)

Q. Was that a planned pregnancy?
A. Nope, I just, I just recently started dating
him.
25 (Pages 429 to 4 32)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 433
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are back on the
record at Linmitt 11:54
By

Q. The same gynecologist take care of you for
that?
A. No, Itthawntwala
A. No.
Q. Do you know among the people that you know
that also went to Jeffrey Epstein, do you know of
other girls that have had abortions?
A. No.
Q. Do you know if.. has had an abortion?
A. No.
Q How about
Page 435
1 restricted every time because he has a wife.
2 Q. Okay. And you've had any kind of sexual
3 encounter at all with Bobby, not even the least
4 little bit?
5 A. No. •
6 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
7 BY MR. LUTHER:
8 Q. So, you wart on this New York trip. Did
9 you get reimbursed for your expenses?
10 A. No.
11 Q. Who bought your plane ticket?
12 A. I told you.
13 Q. But did, did you put the money but first
14 and get reimbursed, or did he buy it for you at the
15 front end?
16 A. Lipoid for it first, and then I got
17 reimbursed when I got to New York.
18 Q. Okay. And how, he* did he reimburse you?
19 A. When he got to the hotel, he gave me the
20 money.
21 Q. Cash?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. Okay. So, how much did you get for that,
24 400 bucks?
25 A. It was like 450.
Page 434
1 MR. EDWARDS: I'm sorry, who did you,
2 what -
3 MR. LUTHER: I means l m sorry.
4 MR. EDWARDS:
5 1HE WITNESS: You mess up a lot of names.
6 MR. LUTHER: There'd a bunch of them.
7 THE WITNESS: No.
8 BY MR. LUTHER.:
9 Q. You don't know?
10 A. I have no clue if they did, no.
11 Q. Now, back with Bobby on this trip to New
12 York, do, do you, now do you recall the name of
13 either of the gentlemen that bought you dinner?
14 A. No.
15 . Q. Do you remember Bobby's last name?
16 A. I don't ever think Bobby ever told me his last
17 name.
18 Q. And does Bobby live in New York or does he
19 live down here?
20 A. I think he lives in both places.
21 Q. And, and you have a cellphone, don't you?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. Don't you have Bobby's number in
24 cellphone?
. 5 A. No. I give him my number and he calls me
Page 436
1 Q. Okay. Did you get reimbursed for any of
2 your other expenses, any money that you spent in New
3 York, any dinners or anything at all?
4 A. No.
5 Q. So, so, he gave you $400 to go to fly to
6 New York, period?
7 A. Yes.
. 8 Q. Did you get paid a fee for the time you
9 spent with him? Didn't you say you spent an
10 afternoon sitting there?
11 A. Yeah, yeah. He, when he came over and we hung
12 out, be gave me like $200.
13 Q. Well, that's, that was a bargain. I mean,
14 that was below your regular hourly rate?
15 A. He just gave it to me. He's litre, here, go
16 shopping, do whatever.
17 Q. Did he give — okay. So, so, all you got
18 was 400 reimbursement and 200 when he came over and
19 hung out?

20. A. Yeah.
21 Q. That's all the money you got from him for
22 this New York trip?
23. A. Yet
24 Q. Did he buy you any gills?
25 A. No.
26 (Pages 433 to 436)
(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, 'INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 437
Q. Did he allow you to go out and buy
2 anything on his charge accounts, charge cards,
3 anything like that?
1 A. I wish.
5 Q. Did you go, did you do any shopping while
6 you were -- I mean, most women go to New York, they
7 shop.
8 A. I did. I went to DSW and I just bought two
9 shirts.
10 Q. How about these other fellows that bought
11 you dinner, did you charge them anything for your
12 company?
13 A. No.
14 Q. Dia. get paid any money?
15 A. With —yeah, Bobby gave her, I am pretty
16 sure — I don't blow how much he gave her but I know he
17 gave her somethin
18 Q. And is. iMr. a customer or Bobby a
19 customer °fir as well?
20 A. No.
21 Q. noose. do the same thing you do?
22 A. No.
23 Q. How about .., is she in the escort
24 similar business to you?
25 A. No, no, no.
Page 439
1 was like our master.
2 Q. All you know is what she told you she did,
3 right?
4 A. Yes. And then Jeffrey also told me that she
5 came back many times after that
6 Q. Now, have you ever prior to today told
7 anybody this rendition of the story that, that you
8 were afraid of Jeffrey?
9 A. I have told ruyattomey I am afraid of
10 Jeffrey. ve told... I am afraid of Jeffrey. I
11 have toIM.4 I am afraid of Jeffrey. Pretty much
12 everyone knows I am afraid of Jeffrey and
13 Q. Would it be a true statement that you
14 didn't tell anybody you were afraid of Jeffrey until
15 after you filed the lawsuit?
16 A. I didn't say a word because I was afraid that
17 my son was going to be taken way from me.
18 Q. So my statement's correct, you never told
19 anybody you were afraid of Jeffrey Epstein until you
20 filed this lawsuit?
21 A. I didn't say anything. .I didn't say a word.
22 Q. And in fact when you were questioned by
23 the FBI -
24 A. I told my son's father I was afraid of Jeffrey
25 Epstein.
Page 438
1 Q. How, how much time do you spend hanging
2 without.. in a physical --
3 A. I told you.
4 Q. I mean physically with her as opposed to
5 maybe talking on the phone?
6 A. When we do get to see each other, the last
7 time I saw her it was like 30 minutes.
8 Q. If, if she told you she didn't want to go
9 to Epstein's, you took her I think you said four
10 times. But you said she kept going after that,
11 right?
12 A. I guess so.
13 Q. Did she ever tell you why she kept going?
14 A. I 'mow that she was scared. Jeffrey told her,
15 you know, don't, don't tell anybody. And he was like
16 our master. Whatever he told us to do, we did. We were
17 scared to tell anybody else, and he would be constantly
18 calling us on the phone, give me another girl, give me
19 another girl, give me another girL
20 So, my mentality at that age, I was
21 afraid and lc I thought this guy had so much power.
22 He has this big mansion. He has this big boat. He
23 hes this big house. You know, I,1 was scared so I
24 did anything and. and all those girls did
25 anything that whatever Jeffrey told us to do. He
Page 440

Q. When you were questioned by the FBI, you
specifically told them that Jeffrey Epstein was a
nice guy and you didn't have any fear of him?

A. Yeah, and then the next day I told my son's
father I'm definitely afraid of Jeffrey Epstein and I'm
scared my son's going to taken away from me.

Q. Well, speaking of having your son taken
away from you, you said in your last deposition you
were familiar with the agency called DCF?

A. Yes.
MR. EDWARDS: Form.
BY MR. LUTTIER:
Q. That's Department of Children and
Families?
A. Yes.
Q. And what was your involvement with them?

MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
THE WITNESS: I had a — there was a
domestic violence. My ex-boyfriend had, went
crazy and wherrmy child was sleeping, he
battered me.
BY MR. LUTITER:

A. boyfriend was this?
Q. And when did this happen?
(561) 832-7500
27 (Pages 437 to 440)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 441
1 A. I want to say '06.
2 Q. And specifically what did he do?
3 A. [guess he was like high on coke and he came
4 in and he threw me on the ground a couple of times and
5 defended myself by hitting him in the nose which made
6 him bleed. And there was blood all over the house.
7 So, when DCF came ova, they
8 practically told me that if this happens again then,
9 you know, I am going to have to go to parenting
10 classes and I am going have to be vet), careful of
11 the kind of people I bring around my son.
12 Q. Where did this event occur?
13 A. In Holiday Plaza.
14 Q. Holiday Plaza is what?
15 A. The trailer that I had my son in.
16 Q. Okay. So this was a trailer that you
17 owned or actually your dad owned it, right?
18 A. Yeah.
19 Q. So, in your trailer, let's, let's be a
20 little more specific. Mr. Riedel, when you say he
21 threw you on the ground, describe what he actually
22 did.
23 A. He threw me on the ground.
24 Q. Did he hurt you?
25 A. It didn't really hurt to fall on the ground
Page 443

Q. What is it that you want to do.
A. I would love to be a normal person who hangs
out with people my age and do what I went to college
for.

Q. What do you mean do what you went to
college for?
A. I would like to be an esthetician, a massage
therapist.

Q. Have you finished your massage therapy
school?
A. Yes.
Q. When did you get, when did you finish
that?

A. in late '09.
Q. Did you pass the test?
A. Not the nationals.
Q. Did you get, did you have to take a local
test or a state test?

A. Yes.
Q. Did you pass that?
A. I didn't take it yet.
Q. Okay. So you finished your course work
but you haven't taken the test, right?
A. Yes.
Q. So why didn't you take test?
Page 442
1 but he pushed me around.
2 Q. Were you afraid?
3 A. A little bit.
4 Q. Scared?
5 A. I was scared that my son was going to wake up.
6 Q. Did he threaten you?
7 A. No, he just threw  on the ground a couple of
8 times, and I didn't like it so I ptur.hed him in the
9 nose, and then he decided to spit blood all over the
10 trailer and that was it. And then DCF, I called the
11 cops and that's when DCF got involved because if there
12 is a domestic violence, then if there is a child
13 involved, then DCF comes.
14 Q. Okay. You said back when you were talking
15 about this fellow Bob — by the way, this business
16 that you have, that you're doing, these various
17 things, whether ifs selling Mary Kay, selling
18 shoes, selling lingerie, selling clothes or going
19 out with these men that pay you money, are all of
20 those things that you're currently doing for money
21 things that you have selected to do?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. And out of everything that you could do in
24 the world, are these the things that you want to do?
25 A. No.
Page 444
1 A. Why didn't I?
2 Q. Yeah.
3 A. Because I am so involved in this money right
4 now. I am involved in making money so my son can go to
5 Christian school and try to better myself with this kind
6 of money. This is all I know. Since I was I3, Jeffrey
7 trained me to make money like this and this is all I
8 know. So, it's kinds of scary going into something that
9 I don't know.
10 Q. Well, Jeff never told you how to make
11 money, did he?
12 A. Yes, he did tell me how to make money.
13 Q. What did he tell you to do?
14 A. To get naked so he can masturbate and
15 ejaculate all over himself and he will pay me money.
16 Q. But he didn't tell you to go out and do
17 that fora living, did he?
18 A. Oh, when I started working at a jack shack
19 when I was 15 years old, he encouraged me to do that.
20 Q. What jack shack was that?
21 A. That was Jamie's photo studio.
22 Q. What's a jack shack so the jury will
23 appreciate that?
24 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
25 TIE WITNESS: That is a place where

(561) 832-7500
28 (Pages 441 to 444)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 495
1 gentlemen go to get happy endings.
2 BY MR. LUITIER:
3 Q. What do you mean by happy endings,
4 masturbating?
5 A. Yes.

Q. Do you massage them first or just
give just —
A. No.
Q. So, these are men that come in and you,
you masturbate them until they ejaculate, is that
the idea?

MR. EDWARDS: Object to form.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
BY MR. LUT1TER:
Q. And yoU were doing that at 15, were you?

A. Yep.
Q. And that was at -- what was the name of it
Jamie's Studio?
A. Yes.
Q. And where was that located?
A. Congress and Okeechobee.
Q. And did you apply for that job?
A. Yes.
Q. Who did you apply with?
A. Mariah.
Page 447
1 Q. And how did he know this person?
2 A. 'Through a friend.
3 Q. And did you, did suggest that you
4 go see her and do this?
5 A. No.
6 Q. Well, why did introduce you to her?
7 A. We were all playing cards one day and she told
8 me that her, her stage name is Vivian. I just
9 remembered. Vivian told me that I can make a lot of
10 money and I was, I was afraid.
11 So when I went back to Jeffrey, I
12 talked to him about it. And I said, well, there is
13 this place that  be working at and it's pretty
14 much the same thing that were doing here. And he's
15 tile go for it; you should have a great time, you
16 know. And he encouraged me to do it.
17 Q. And when you were interviewed by the FBI.
18 did you tell them that?
19 A. No.
20 Q. Have you ever told anybody that story
21 until today?
22 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the fonn,
23 attorney-client privilege.
24 MIL LUTHER: Other than your lawyer.
25 Mt EDWARDS: Other than me if you have
I
Page 446
1 Q. And how did you know Mariah?
2 A. Through a friend.
3 Q. What friend?
4 A. It was a stage name. It wasn't even her real
5 name. I don't even remember.
6 Q. What was the stage name, Mariah or the
7 friend?
8 A The friend
9 Q. Okay. When you say a stage name, stage
10 where? What stage?
11 A. It was a fake name.
12 Q. Okay. But stage name means she was
13 working someplace. Was she working at —
14 A. She was working at Jamie's photo studio.
15 Q. Okay. But this is somebody you knew that
16 was already working there?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. And, and was it somebody you went to
19 school with?
20 A. No.
21 Q. How did you know her? How did you meet
22 her?
23 A. Throughm 's ather.
24 Q. That's=
25 A.
Page 448
1 told anybody else that you can answer.
2 THE WITNESS: No, I have not told anybody
3 else that.
4 BY MR. •
5 Q. Youtrrold, that you were going to do
6 it, didn't you?
7 A. Yeah, well, heard the conversation.
8 Q. Right
9 A. And knew I was doing it.
10 Q. And heard the conversation where
11 Vivian said you could come do this fora lot of
12 money?
13 A. Y.
14 Q. And then you went and applied for the job?
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. You didn't tell that Jeff Epstein
17 made you do it, did you?
18 A. No, because I was afraid of Jeffrey Epstein.
19 Jeffrey Epstein told me not to say anything to anyone,
20 just bring him girls.
21 Q. So, but, but you will admit nobody forced
22 you to go interview and get that job, did they?
23 A. Correct.
24 Q. You decided to do it because you wanted to
25 make more money?
(561) 832-7500
29 (Pages 445 to 448)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 449
1 A. Correct
2 • Q. You knew —
3 A. Because I couldn't find anymore girls for
4 Jeffrey.
5 Q. Well, you knew it was wrong. You were 15
6 years old, right?
7 A. Correct, but Jeffrey taught me that lifestyle
8 is the lifestyle to go.
9 Q. That was .-
10 A. III want a mansion, if I want a pool, ill
11 want food on my table, if I want nice clothes, if I want
12 to live a luxury life, why not make money. I could
13 hen* find anymore girls for Jeffrey at that time. So
14 Jeffrey said, go ahead, go. And he even said bring me
15 girls from that place.
16 Q. Well, what you figured out was to have
17 fancy things in life, it took money to get them,
18 right?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Jeffrey didn't teach you that? You
21 figured that out?
22 A. Yes, he did.
23 Q. How did he teach you that?
24 A. Because he would tell me when I am sitting
25 there and massaging him: 'would say what do you do for
Page 451
1 on how to make any kind of money.
2 Q. Well, why didn't you go off and be a brain
3 surgeon because if Mr. Epstein told you that he was
4 a brain surgeon, that's how he got these things?
5 A. Because I am sitting there 13 years old naked
6 in front of an old man while he ejaculates and gives me
7 $200 and then gives me $200 an hour later for bringing
8 another girl and then he gives me 200 the next day for
9 . bringing another girl and then I accumulate a thousand
10 dollars in a week. And then I accumulate another
11 thousand dollars the next week, why would I want to be a
12 brain surgeon right then and there?
13 Q. That was your choice, right?
14 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
15 THE WITNESS: When I am 13 years old, can
16 I beat:fah) surgeon?
17 BY MR. LUIT1ER:
18 Q. Was it your choice at that point that you
19 wanted to continue to do what you were doing?
20 MR. EDWARDS: Object, form.
21 THE WITNESS: He was my master. Whatever
22 he told me to do, he — I did.
23 BY MR. LUITIER:
24 Q. How, how did he — once you walked ota of
25 his house, you could have done anything you wanted,
Page 450
a living. He would say I was a brain surgeon. I would
say really. Okay, so that's how, that's how you got all
this stuff when I was massaging him. And he says, yeah,
you know, successful men, that's why you have successful
things.

Q. Okay. So, what he told you was to be
wealthy and happy you need to be a brain surgeon.
That's what he told you, right?

A. He didn't say you had to be a brain surgeon.
He just said you need to make money.
Q. Well, no, I thought what you just said was
when you sat and talked to him he said I ern a brain
surgeon and that's how you got these things.

A. I asked him, what do you do for a living. He
said I am a brain surgeon.
Q. So, you concluded that if you were a brain
surgeon, you can acquire these things, right?

A. No, I concluded that if you make lots of
money, then you an have nice things.
Q. Okay. But I mean you would know that, I
mmm—

A. No.
Q. It's just common sense.
A. No, it's not comment sense because I was a
little girl living in a trailer park, and I had no idea
8 9 10
Page 452
couldn't you.

A. He scared me. lie said don't tell anybody what
we're doing.
Q. Other than you claiming that he said that
to you, how did he restrict you from doing anything
you wanted to do?

A. He said I will be caning you; please, make
sure you have a girl for me.
Q. Did you —
A. If you don't have a girl for rile, then I am
going to be mad.

Q. Well, did you ever just say, no, I don't
want to do it anymore?
A. I had told him, Jeffrey, I don't a have girl and he, he would be mad. He said don't ever do that
again.

Q. My question —
A. I would be in his house, and if I brought him,
if I didn't bring him a girl, and if I just came alone,
he would say don't ever do that to me again.

Q. My question is did you ever tell him, no,
I don't want to do this anymore?
A. No, I didn't say that. I was scared to say
that to him.

Q. Well, you were so afraid that while you
30 (Pages 449 to 452)
(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. .'(561) 832-7506
Page 453
1 were goiroMr a n, you were living with this
2 boyfriend MIE weren't you?
3 A. I was living with my father.
4 Q. Well, you were living with
5 fora good bit of the time when you first went to
6 Mr. Epstein's?
7 A. Correct.
8 Q. And he knew exactly what you were doing,
9 didn't he?
10 A.. Correct.
11 Q. Because you told him?
12 A. Correct.
13 Q. And told you as long as
14 you're bringing home money, go ahead and do it,
15 didn't he?
16 A. No.
17 Q. Did he say anything like that?
18 A. No.
19 Q. What did he say about the fact that being
20 your girl — you being his girlfriend, that you were

21. going --
22 A. He didn't say anything. He said -- he didn't
23 care.
24 Q. He didn't care but you ran it by him?
25 A. He was an alcoholic. He didn't care. He
Page 455
1 A. Great. She said you can start tomorrow.
2 Q. And did you mention you were 15?
3 A. No.
4 Q. Did you show her a fake ID?
5 A. No.
6 Q. You did have a fake ID at that point?
7 A. Nope.
8 Q. Asa matter of fact you told the FBI you
9 had a fake ID, didn't you?
10 A. Yeah, when I lied in my first deposition.
11 Q. And of course you would have known lying
12 to the FBI was a bad thing to do?
13 A. I had no fake ID. I have never had a fake ID
14 and when f was 15, I told her I was 19. She said you
15 can -
16 Q. So, tell me about your first *soda.
17 Maly, Made (sic) says to you, yeah, you can go to
18 work here?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Does she give you any instruction about
21 what you're to wear, what you're to do, fill out
22 paperwork, or anything like that?
23 A. No, l told her I was instructed by a guy which
24 was Jeffrey Epstein and I know what I am doing.
25 Q. Okay. So what did you do? Did you report
Page 454
lived. He paid the bills. We lived in a trailer.

Q. And you ran it by him. You said this is
what I am doing and this is what I am getting paid
and he said he didn't care?

A. Yes.
Q. And then along came this opportunity after
this card game for you to go to work in what you
call a jack shack, right?

A. Because I could hardly find any more girls for
Jeffrey, so, yeah, and he encouraged me to bring girls
from the jack shack to him.

Q. And encouraged you to go
take that job, too --
A. Not at all. had nothing to do.
He was not my master. I was not intimidated by

Q. You wanted to get that extra money, didn't
you?
A. Yes, I dld.
Q. Okay. So, now you're 15 and you go to see
Vivian. Or, no, you go see this Marie at this —

MR. CRITTON: Mariah.
BY MR. LUTHER:
Q. Mariah at Jamie's studio. How did that
,25 interview go?
(561) 832-7500
Page 456
1. for work one day?
2 A. Excuse me?
3 Q. Did you report for work one day?
4 A. Yes, I went to work.
5 Q. Morning, night, when?
6 A. In the morning.
7 Q. Okay. And what did you do?
8 A. When a client came in, I would put a condom on
9 him and I would jerk him oft
10 Q. This is in some room that they had there?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. And is that all you did?
13 A. Yes.
14 Q. Were you fully clothed?
15 A. No.
16 Q. What were you wearing?
17 A. I kept my panties on.
18 Q. Okay. So you were topless?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. And so a guy would come in, somebody you
21 didn't know at all, right?
22 A. Correct.
23 Q. And you would, you would jerk him off?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. All right. And bow many of those would
31 (Pages 453 to 456)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 457
1 you do a day?
2 A. One, two, three, or four.
3 Q. And how much did you get paid for that?
4 A. $40.
5 MR. EDWARDS: Object to form.
6 BY MR. LUTTIER:
7 Q. And did you ever do anything other than
8 that?
9 A. I gave oral sex there.
10 Q. How much did you get for that?
3.1 A. Ninety.
12 Q. So you got more money for that than you
13 did for just Jerking the guy off?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. And how much money would you make in a
16 day?
17 A. I don't know because ifs not — I am not
18 working on a salary. I am not working on a set price
19 here. Whatever client came in, if a client came in and
20 he wanted me to jack him off, then I would make $40 for
21 that day.
22 Q. Okay.
23 A. If a client, two clients came in, and they
24 both wanted oral sex, I would make 180.
25 Q. Okay. And they would pay you cash?
Page 459
1 Q. Would people schedule appointments with
2 you?
3 A. No.
4 MR. CRITTON: We have to change the tape.
5 MR. LUTT1ER: Okay.
6 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record at
7 12:16 p.m. This is the end of Tape 1.
8 (A discussion was held off the record.)
9 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: We're back on the
10 record at 12:18 p.m. This is the start of
11 Tape 2.
12 BY MR. LUTHER:
13 Q. Was Jamie's studio the first business of
14 that nature that you worked at?
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. Now, you had, you had masturbated males
17 before you worked at Jamie's studio, right?
18 A. Jeffrey, I have not masturbated but I've
19 worked for Jeffrey.
20 Q. But no, you — my question was you had
21 masturbated males prior to working at Jamie's
22 studio, hadn't you?
23 A. Not for money.
24 Q. That wasn't my question. You had
25 masturbated—
Page 458

A. Cash.
2 Q. Put the money in your pocket?
3 A. Put the money in my pocket but I had to pay
4 Mariah.
5 Q. How much did you have to pay her?
6 A. From what I recall $30.
7 Q. Per client?
8 A. It depends on — day. So, it was, Iwotdd
9 charge them $100 for the room, and I would have to pay
10 her 60 and I would get 40 for just to jack someone off.
11 Q. Now, did you have regular clients that
12 would come?
13 A. Yeah.
14 Q. How many days a week did you work there?
15 A. Maybe four.
16 Q. And how long would a day be?
17 A. Seven hours.
18 Q. You'd literally sit there for seven hours?
19 A. Literally sit there for seven hours.
20 Q. And how long, how many clients would you
21 see in seven hours?
22 A_ I told you this once before, one, maybe two,
23 maybe three, maybe four.
24 Q. Ina seven-hour period?
25 A. Yes.
Page 460
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. All right. Do you remember when you first
3 masturbated your first male?
4 A- No.
5 Q. Do you remember who it was?
6 A. I told you,
7 Q. Well, hadn't you, in fact, masturbated a
8 male before you ever went to Jeffrey Epstein?
9 A. Have I masturbated a male before Jeffrey
10 Epstein? I was 13. Yeah.
11 Q. And do you remember how far before? Was
12 it like a year or so before that?
13 A. No, it was like right before Jeffrey.
14 Q. And that you had seen, by that time in
15 your life you had seen people perform masturbation
16 on males, had you not?
17 A. No.
18 g Had you seen pornography before that?
19 A. I think I like took a look at it one time and
20 it was not forme.
21 g Did you ever tell anybody ever in your
22 life that your mother showed you pornography to
23 teach you how to please men?
24 A. No.
25 Q. Did you ever make that statement or

(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT
32 (Pages 457 to 460)
REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 461
1 anything similar to that statement to anyone at any
2 tune in your entire life?
3 A. No. Why the heck would my mother.--
4 Q. Did, did you ever tell anyone at any time
5 in your life that your mother was a prostitute?
6 A. No.
7 Q. So, when you went to see Jeffrey Epstein
8 for the first time and you said he masturbated in
9 your presence, that wasn't the first time you'd seen
10 that done, right?
11 A. Excuse me?
12 Q. When you went to Jeffrey Epstein for the
13 first time and you say he masturbated in your
14 presence that, that wasn't something you had not
15 seen before?
16 MR. EDWARDS: Object to form.
17 MR. LUTTIER: It was not something that
18 you had — it was not something you had not
19 seen. Let me rephrase it. You'd seen —
20 MR. EDWARDS: I'm confused.
21 BY M. LUTHER:
22 Q. You had seen a male masturbate before you
23 went to Jeffrey Epstein for the first time, hadn't
24 you?
25 A. Yes.
Page 463
1 sit here right now.
2 A. I was with my, my boyfriend all 2000, all
3 2009.
4 Q. 5 A.
6 Q.
7 2009?
8 A.
9 Q. You are absolutely sure of that?
10 A. Yeah.
11 Q. Have you ever allowed anyone to take your
12 car and go to what you've described as a jack shack?
13 A. I definitely let people use my car.
14 Q. Have you ever allowed anybody to take your
15 car to a jack shack?
16 A. I let people use my car. If they decide to go
17 to a jack shack, I don't know.
18 Q. In the year —
19 A. I am a nice person. I lend, !lend my car
20 out, yes, I do.
21 Q. In the year 2010, okay, which is now a
22 little over 30 days old —
23 A. Uh-huh.
24 Q. — have you been to ajack shack?
25 A. I've been to gentlemen's clubs to sell my
Doesn't change my question.
I didn't work at a jack shack 2009.
Have you ever been in one since January of
No.
Page 462

Q. Now, after Jamie's studio, did you ever
2 work at any other establishment that was a similar
3 type of establishment to that?
4 A. Yes, and we went through this the last
5 deposition.
6 Q. Okay. Well, which ones did you work in?
7 You might remember you asserted a lot of objections
8 last time.
9 A. Okay. Weil, you name them off to me and I
10 will tell you.
11 Q. So, which ones. I can give you a list of
12 them. Just tell me the last one you worked at.
13 A. Name them off to me. I can't remember.
14 Q. When was the last one that you worked at?
15 A. I cannot remember.
16 Q. I want, I want to be fair to you.
17 A. Okay.
18 Q. Let's start with this, let's start in the
19 year, from January 1 of 2009 to the present tell me
20 which establishment you worked at that are similar
21 to Jamie's studio?
22 A. 2009?
23 Q. What you referred to as jack shacks.
24 A. 2009?
25 Sys, January I of 2009 to the minute you
Page 464
1 shoes and my purses and my —
2 Q. What gentlemen's club?
3 A. I've been to Spearmint Rhino. I've been to
4 Flashdance. I've been to Pompano Cheetah. I've been to
5 any strip club 1 can drive by.
6 Q. Well, you — would you go to those in the
daytime or would you go there at night?
8 A. Bold, am. and p.m.
9 Q. Well, let's start, lees start with the
10 bottom one, Pompano Cheetah.
11 A. Okay.
12 Q. You haven't been to it lately, have you?
13 A. No.
14 Q. Not open now, is it?
15 A. Oh, I don't know if it's open or not.
16 Q. Did you go to it since January of 2010?
17 A. No.
18 Q. Okay. Have you gone to Flashdance since
19 January, 2010?
20 A. To sell stuff. yes.
21 Q. Well, we're going to get to why you went
22 there. But you admit that you went to Flashdance
23 since January of 2010?
24 A. Yep.
25 Q. And how many times have you been there?

(561) 832-7500
33 (Pages 461 to 464)
PROSE COURT. REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 465
A. A few times.

Q. And how many is a few?
A. A few, like three, four.
Q. Okay. And was it in the day or night?
A. Flashdance, at night.

Q. Okay. And what did you do on each of the
occasions when you went there?
A. i walk in there. One time I just went there
to hang out.

Q. I don't know what you mean by just to hang
out?
A. Just to hang out to have a couple drinks.
Q. Okay. Now, Flashdance is a topless bar?

A. Yes.
Q. So, and this is in 2010?
A. Yeah.
Q. And why would you just be going to a
topless bar to hang out and have drinks. Did you
have friends you were meeting there?

A. No.
Q. So, you just picked out of all of the bars •
in Palm Beach County, you elected, the one you
wanted to go to was the Flashdance topless bar?

A. Yes.
Q. And why was that?
Page 467
1 A. Who cares if I went to Flashdance.
2 Q. There are a lot of bars out there that are
3 dose to - •
.4 A. What does it matter if I went to Flashdance or
5 not. What does it matter if I went to Flashdance that
6 night or not? Really, what does it matter?
7 Q. I can't answer your question. I am just
8 taking a deposition.
9 A. Okay.
10 Q. So, you can't articulate any reason why
11 you went to Flashdance?
12 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
13 THE WITNESS: I went to have a couple of
14 drinks.
15 BY MR. LUTTIER:
16 Q. And who did you join for this?
17 A. I am allowed to do that.
18 Q. • And who did you have drinks with?
19 A. Me, myself, and I.
20 (Loud noise at the window.)
2/ THE WITNESS: Holy -
22 BY MR. LUTTIER:
23 Q. Did you tip anybody?
24 A. No.
25 Q. Did you talk to anybody you knew there?
Page 466
1. A. It was the decision I made that night
2 Q. So, you were comfortable going into a
3 topless bar, right? i mean, you worked in than
4 before, right?
5 A. Yeah
6 Q. So, then you thought going in that and
7 watching women get naked and dance for men and do
8 lap dances and all that was all okay, right?
9 A. I sit at the bar. I don't have to watch the
10 women. i have a couple of drinks and I leave.
11 Q. Well, why would you pick a topless bar as
12 opposed to the Carousel at CityPlace, for example?
13 A. Because my house is closer to there.
14 Q. Okay. And you're going to tell me that's
15 the only bar near your house?
16 A. No, but I would rather be around, you know, at
17 that time maybe I wanted to be around people my age
18 rather than, you know, an older man that time. I don't
19 know.
20 Q. Well, Clematis Street right down here in
21 West Palm Beach is full of bars with people your
22 age.
23 A.. Yeah, but it's not close Flashdance is
24 closer to me.
25 Q. Well, there's a lot of bars out there
Page 468
1 A. Yeah, I talked to a couple of people that I
2 knew.
3 Q. And who was that?
4 A. There was one girl Marium, but I don't even
5 know if that's her real name. And then a couple guys
6 that I've seen. They're associates, i mean, I saw in
7 the past.
8 Q. What do you mean by associates?
9 A. Like people that i don't, that are not my
10 friends, that i just saw in the past.
11 Q. Well, !mean, do you use the word
12 associate to define somebody that you just
13 physically saw?
14 A. Associates, people I have talked to before.
15 Q. So, you would characterize everybody in
16, this room as just an associate because you've talked
17 to us?
18 A. Yeah, like if I saw her, I would say I know
19 her.
20 Q. Were these individuals that you saw there.
21 these couple of guys, people that you had done
22 business with?
23 A. No.
24 Q. And Murium, how did you know her?
25 A. From a snip club.
(561) 832-7500
34 (Pages 465 to 4 6 8)
PROSE COURT REPORTING' AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 469
1 Q. What club?
2 A. Flashdance.
3 Q. Well, that's the club you were in?
4 A. Yeah.
5 Q. And how did you know her before that?
6 A. From Flashdance.
7 Q. Okay. And, and you had made her
8 acquaintance because of what?
9 A. She came up to me when I was at Flashdance one
10 day and said, hi, how are you, and we started a
11 conversation.
12 Q. Did you ever dance at Flashdance?
13 A. No.
14 Q. Okay. Spearmint Rhino, when is the last
15 time you were there?
16 A. Couple of days ago.
17 Q. Let's see now. Today is February 9th so
18 that would be what day?
19 A. I don't 'mow. Like three days ago.
20 Q. Okay. And what other places, adult type
21 places are located near Spearmint Rhino?
22 A. There is Cheetah's down the road. There's a
23 couple of, I know there's a couple shops that I stopped
24 by that I don't know the names. I know there is
25 another, there is like a new Lauren's that I've walked
Page 471
1 in there and I spend five minutes. If they don't want
2 anything, they tell me to go. And then sometimes I will
3 go in there and, you know, f will sell stuff for two
4 hours, or I could stay there all night long and sell
5 stuff.
6 Q. For what period of time were you there
7 Saturday night?
8 A. Saturday night I probably arrived at like 8:00
9 and left at closing.
10 Q. Which is what time?
11 A. Five, I want to say 5 or 6.
12 Q. That's 5 a.m., isn't it?
13 A. Yeah.
14 Q. So you were there for nine hours?
15 A. Yeah.
16 Q. Wait, two, seven hours?
17 A. Yeah.
18 Q. According to you selling shoes and
19 lingerie and Mary Kay, right?
20 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
21 THE WITNESS: Correct.
22 BY MR. LUTTMR:
23 Q. All right. So tell us how much you sold.
24 A. I sold a couple shoes.
25 Q. Dollar volume.
Page 470
1 into on Forest Hill and Military. I will even walk into 1
2 like island Jack's and try to sell my shoes and purses. 2
3 Igo anywhere. I go to nail salons. 3
4 Q. Well, how often do you go to Spearmint 4
5 Rhinos? 5
6 A. I go to Spearmint Rhino frequently. 6
7 Q. How frequently? 7
8 A. Like once a week. 8
9 Q. And for what reason did you go Spearmint 9
10 Rhino once a week? 10
11 A- To sell my shoes, my purses, my lingerie„ my 11
12 Mary Kay. 12
13 Q. Any other reason? 13
14 A. No. 14
15 Q. Sella lot of Mary Kay to the dancers? 15
16 A. Yeah. 16
17 Q. Now, you say two days ago. Today is the 17
18 9th. So, are you referring to Sunday night you were 18
19 at Spearmint Rhino's? 19
20 A. Sunday night What did I do on Sunday night? 20 •
21 What was I doing Sunday night? No, !think it was 21
22 Saturday, Saturday night. 22
23 Q. Okay. And how long were you at Spearmint 23
24 Rhino's Saturday night? 24
25 A. 1 stayed there fora while. I, sometimes I go 25

(561) 832-7500
Page 472
A Forty —
Q. 5100 worth of stuff?
A. $40 shoes, $50 shoes. Lingerie, I sold a lot
of that.

Q. How much dollar wise, $100 worth?
A. Are you trying to, like, get to know, like,
how much I make?
Q. I just want to know how much —

A. How much do you make?
Q. — for this, you know, for this period of
time that you were there until 5 a.m. in the
morning?

A. I don't know. I didn't write it down. I'm
sorry.
Q. Well, you must keep track of it, right?
A. No, I don't.

Q. Don't you report it for tax reasons?
MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
THE WITNESS: No, no, I don't.
BY MR. LUTHER:

Q. You don't report tax on this?
A. I, listen, I don't have any documents of how
much I bring in from my shoes and stuff.

Q. Well; you know you've got to pay taxes on
money Lou earn, don't you?
35 (Pages 469 to 472)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 473
1 A. Yeah.
2 Q. Okay. So, how do you keep a record of It?
3 A. It's in my head. !know --
4 Q. Fora year?
5 A. Why not? Yeah. I can estimate.
6 Q. What we you going to do at the end of the
7 year in tenns of reporting your sales and how
8 much --
9 A. Idoit.
10 Q. -- how much income you've made so you can
11 report properly to the IRS what you owe in taxes?
12 A. Idoit.
13 Q. How?
14 A. I just told.
15 Q. In your head you remember a year's worth
16 of sales?
17 A. ram pretty good at that, yeah.
18 Q. You've got no documents?
19 A. No.
20 Q. Okay. But that would be kind of lilce your
21 tax returns in '07 and '08 when you said you were
22 making $20,000 a year cleaning houses while you were
23 making $2,000 a night as an escort, right? Imam,
24 they probably wouldn't be very accurate, would they?
25 MR. EDWARDS: Fenn.
Page 4.:
1 A. Yeah.
2 Q. And, and, and who are the names of the
3 ones you had drinks with?
4 A. Star, Mercedes.
5 Q. And how do you know Star and Mercedes?
6 A. From Spearmint Rhino.
7 Q. Ever dance with them?
8 A. No.
9 Q. Okay. What else did you do while you were
10 there?
11 A. I just told you that's all! did was hang out
12 and sell my stuff.
13 Q. Okay. Now, the week immediately before
14 that, the previous week, starting February 1st, were
15 you at Spearmint Rhino's at any time?
16 A. Yeah.
17 Q. Okay. And when was that?
18 A. I can't tell you the specific dates.
19 Q. Okay. Well, how many times during that
20 week were you there the first week of February?
21 A. I know I stopped by there ]ice practically
22 every day because some, some people would give me
23 requests like 1 want a pink, you know, a pink top or a
24 blue top so —
25 g And
Page 474

MR. LUITIER: You do recall —
2 THE WITNESS: Okay. So what's you're
3 question.
4 BY MR. LUTTIER:
5 Q. I want to know how much you sold in
6 lingerie that night.
7 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
8 THE WITNESS: $150.
9 BY MR. LUIT1ER:
10 Q. Okay. So we have got $150 and maybe 40 or
11 50 in shoes. Any purses?
12 A. No.
13 Q. • Okay. So you were there for, what, seven,
14 eight hours, and you made, you sold $200 worth of
15 stuff?
16 A. Yeah.
17 Q. Okay. And what else did you do while you
18 were there?
19 A. Hung out.
20 Q. What do you mean by "hang out*?
21 A. I had a couple of drinks with the bouncers and
22 with the girls.
23 Q. What girls would those be?
24 A. The girls that work there.
25 Q. Dancers, right?
Page 476
1 A. — I would bring them whatever they wanted.
2 Q. And how long, on those orrasions you went
3 how long did you stay there?
4 A. Anywhere between an hour to five hours.
5 Q. Okay. And how much, in that whole week
6 how much stuff did you sell?
7 A I probably sold $500 worth of stuff.
8 Q. Now, are there other business
9 establishments in the same center where Spearmint
10 Rhino's is located?
11 A. Yeah, it's like a strip mall.
12 Q. What other places are there? What other
13 adult type entertainment places are in that same
14 strip mall as Spearmint Rhino's?
15 A. I have no idea because I don't go there.
16 Q. Have you ever been in any of those?
17 A. No.
18 g Do you have a name that you use these days
19 other than, than your given name?
20 A Sometimes.
21 Q. What name would that be?
22 A. Lynn.
23 Q. How about any other names?
24 A. That's it.
25 Q. All ri$trt. I want to make sure we're
(561) 832-7500
36 (Pages 473 to 476)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY,' INC. (5 6 1) 832 -75 0 6
Page 477
1 clear. I want to give you an opportunity.
2 A. Okay.
3 Q. Frail February 1st of 2010 —
4 A. February 1st 2010.
5 Q. Better yet I am going to back that up.
6 From January 28th, 2009, until today, that's the
7 period of time I am --
8 A. January 28th, 2009.
9 Q. — asking you about. Have you ever been
10 in any other business establishment that's located
11 in the strip mall where Spearmint Rhino's is?
12 A. Nope. I've just been in Spearmint Rhino and
13 everything affiliated with that.
14 Q. Well, okay, well, what do you mean
15 everything affiliated with that; other businesses
16 affiliated with it?
17 A. No, just Spearmint Rhino.
18 Q. Like the business right next to it, do you
19 know what the name of that business is?
20 A. No.
21 Q. What other businesses are there that are
22 affiliated with Spearmint Rhino?
23 A. There's--
24 MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
25 THE WITNESS: — Spearmint Rhino and then
Page 479
1 Q. But you would have no — I want to make
2 sure we're clear. You would have no earthly idea
3 why anyone would ever report that you were in
4 someplace other than Spearmint Rhino that's located
5 in that same location; is that right?
6 A. I have no earthly idea?
7 Q. Right, you have no idea because you were
8 never in anyplace there, is that right?
9 A. Correct.
10 Q. When was the last time you were in a
11 facility that you would call a jack shack?
12 A. I don't know. I've been in a couple of places
13 like the old Lauren's — it's a new Lauren's on Forest
14 Hill and Military selling shoes.
15 Q. No, I said when was the last time you were
16 in a place you would characterize as a jack, as a
17 jack shack?
18 A. That's that, the old Lauren's.
19 Q. So, you would call Lauren's a jack shack?
20 A. I think that's what they do.
21 Q. Now, eject( shack is not occupied by
22 dancers, right?
23 A. I'm not sure. Fm not positive.
24 Q. So-
25 A. I'm not going to speak for them. I don't
Page 478
there is like in the back there is a little
2 thing back there in Spearmint Rhino and they
3 have a different, it's, it's just different,
4 ifs affiliated differently.
BY MR. LUTHER:

Q. Any other place that you were?
A. I said no like five times.
8 Q. Okay. Do you know of a, what you have
9 called a jack shack that's located right next door
10 to Spearmint Rhino?
11 A. No.
12 Q. Have you ever heard of a place called I
13 think it's called Fantasies?
14 A. No.
15 Q. Never heard of that?
16 A. No.
17 Q. Have you ever been in that place?
18 A. No..
19 Q. Could you think of any reason why anyone
20 would report that you were in that location during
21 the period of time that I just said?
22 A. Is it in, is it next to Spearmint Rhino?
23 Q. Yep.
24 A Oh, well, then maybe I should go there and
25 sell shoes.
Page 480
1 know.
2 Q. Why would you be in Lauren's if ifs a
3 jack shack trying to sell shoes?
4 A. Because women love shoes.
5 Q. Any other jack shacks you have been in
6 within the last two years?
7 A. I stop at every place l know. I stop, like I
8 will drive down Military Trail or I will drive down
9 Okeechobee Trail and if there's a nail salon, if there's
10 a tanning salon, if even people are walking out of CVS,
11 if there is a shop which is a, what you're calling a
12 jack shack, if there is anything like that, women
13 affiliated, I will go there and try to sell Mary Kay.
14 Q. Since January of'09, have you performed
15 any services in a facility that you've termed a jack
16 shack?
17 A. Since January '09, no.
18 Q. January I of'09. You're absolutely sure
19 of that? There is no doubt in your mind. It's
20 not —
21 A. I was with
22 Q. Wait a minute. It's not something you,
23 you just can't remember. You're emphatically
24 denying that ever happened; is that right?
25 MR. EDWARDS: Form.
.(561) 832-7500
37 (Pages 477 to 480) .
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 481.
1 THE WITNESS: As of right now I do not
2 remember of any time through January of '09
that I was in an tick shack, no, because I was
4 With
5 BY MR. LUTHER:

Q. Have you ever worked
A. And he took care of me.
a Q. -r at Abby's?
9 A. On advice of counsel I am invoking my Fifth
10 Amendment rights under the United States Constitution.
11 Q. Would Abby's qualify as a jack shack?
12 A. I don't 'mow.
13 Q. For what period of time did you work at
14 Abby's?
15 A. I never said t worked at Abby's.
16 Q. Well, did you work at Abby's?
17 A. On advice of counsel I may invoke my Fifth
18 Amendment rights under the United States Constitution.
19 Q. Okay. So did you work in Abby's in, since
20 January 1 of 2009?
21 A. Excuse me?
22 Q. Did you work in Abby's since January 1 of
23 2009?
24 A. No.
25 Q. Have you worked in Whispers?
Page 483
to it.
THE WITNESS: On advice of counsel I am
invoking my Fifth Amendment rights under the
United States Constitution.
BY MR. LUTHER:

Q. Did you masturbate males in Angels of Palm
Beaches?
A. On advice of counsel I am invoking my Fifth
Amendment rights under the United States Constitution.

Q. Nobody forced you to work at Angels, did
they?
A. On advice of counsel lam invoking my Fifth
Amendment rights under the United States Constitution.
Q.
A.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Did you work at Flirts?
Yes.
When did you work at Flirts?
In early '08.
And what did you do at Flirts?
Did I private sessions.
And what is Flirts?
Flirts is one-on-one private sessions.
Where is it located?
Purdy and Military.
What do you mean by private sessions?
Pretty much naked company.
Page 482

1. A. Nope.
2 Q. Have you worked in Angels of the Palm
3 Beaches?
4 A. On advice of counsel I am invoking my Fifth
5 Amendment rights under the United States Constitution.
6 Q. What did you do at Angels of Palm Beaches?
7 A. On advice, on advice of counsel I am invoking
8 my Fifth Amendment rights under the United State
9 Constitution.
10 Q. There were other girls that went to
11 Jeffrey Epstein's that worked at Angels with you,
12 weren't there?
13 A. No, not that I know of.
14 Q. How much was, what was your split in your
15 pay when you worked Angels of Palm Beaches? How
16 much did you have to pay to the house and how much
17 did you keep?
18 A. I never said I worked there.
19 Q. I know you didn't say that. I5a just
20 asking you the question. I notice that you're not
21 denying that you got any money.
22 A. Excuse me?
23 Q. You're not denying that you worked there,
24 right?
25 MR. EDWARDS: Stick to that. Just stick
Page 484
1 Q. What do you mean by that?
2 A. Naked company.
3 Q. So, describe what would go on there. What
4 did you do there.
5 A. Company being naked. A gentleman would conic
6 in and you sit there nude or in panties and bra and you
7 get paid for company.
8 Q. Well, lust of all, let me -- let's break
9 this down. He would come in and you would take him
10 into a room?
11 A. Correct.
12' Q. And what was in this room?
13 A. Chairs, sofa, lights.
14 Q. Anything else?
15 A. An ashtray.
16 Q. And what would you —
17 A. Table.
18 Q. What did you do for your clients that came
19 into these rooms?
20 A. I just told you. Let's say it again. I would
21 bring a guy in and then I would either be in my bra and
22 panties or just my panties and a guy would pay to have
23 my naked company.
24 Q. And what else would occur?
• Nothing.
38 (Pages 481 to 484)
(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING. AGENCY,. INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 485
1 Q. Any, any physical touching ever?
2 A. Nope.
3 Q. What would the guy do? You would just be
4 sitting there naked.
5 A. The guy was not allowed to do anything.
6 Q. And how much would somebody pay you for
7 this?
8 A. It was SLOG to get in the door.
9 Q. Okay. And how much of that money did you
10 get to keep?
11 A. Forty.
12 . Q. And did you ever do anything with anybody
13 in Flirts other than simply sit there either in your
14 panties and bra or just your panties?
15 A. No.
16 Q. How many other similar establishments did
17 you work in?
18 A. A couple of them.
19 Q. What were their names?
20 A. I don't recall.
21 Q. Did you, have you advertised your services
22 before in any type of publication or online website
23 or things Ince that?
24 A. Personally, no. People have took my picture
25 without my consent and done it, but no.
Page 487
/ like this to certain people. And they used my ad, used
2 my picture for their ad.
3 Q. Well, was —
4 A. Not my fault
5 Q. -- it more than one picture that had been
6 taken when you went to your girlfriend's?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. Now, you knew when your girlfriend was
9 taking the picture that you were going to use the
10 picture for something? .
11 MR. EDWARDS: Object to form.
12 THE WITNESS: No, not at all. I take fun
13 pictures all the time.
14 BY MR. LUTHER:
15 Q. So, fun pictures where you just stand
16 around topless with your hands --
17 A. Yeah, I am 21 years old. I'm having film
18 Like you've never done it.
19 Q. Well, when were these pictures taken?
20 They weren't taken when you were 21, were they?
21 A. No. They were taken when I was like maybe 18
22 Q. Okay. And so, for what purpose were the
23 pictures taken?
24 A. Just for fun.
25 Q. Okay. Just you and a friend whose name
Page 486
1 Q. Well, how do you know that?
2 A. Because I've saw it and I'm --
3 Q. What -
4 A. -- having -- I am trying to actually get that
5 resolved right now because ifs wrong.
6 Q. What did you see?
7 A. I saw supposedly someone posting me as an
8 escort on, on websites.
9 Q. What websites?
10 A. I'm not — I don't recall.
11 Q. Well, was your picture there?
12 A. Yeah, and it was not supposed to be.
13 Q. And what were you wearing in the picture?
14 A. A thong and like my hands like this, topless.
15 Q. Topless?
16 A. Yeah.
17 Q. So, it was a picture you had posed for?
18 A. Yeah, but not like in a shop or anything.
19 Q. What do you mean not like in a shop?
20 A. Not in a jack shack.
21 Q. Well, where had you posed for the picture?
22 A. At a house, like at my girlfriend's house.
23 Q. Which girlfriend?
24 A. I don't recall. These pictures were so long
25 ago. But someone got a hold of diem and things happen
Page 488
1 you can't remember?
2 A. No.
3 Q. You can't remember her name?
4 A. Nope.
5 Q. Was there anybody else there with you?
6 A. Actually one girl's name was Brittany.
7 Q. Brittany what?
B A. I don't know.
9 Q. Another person that's got a claim against
10 Mr. Epstein?
11 A. No.
12 Q. Okay. When did you notice that your
13 picture was up on a website?
14 A. I had — lwas going on eraig's List to !bid
15 furniture. And I, I was just curious and I was looking
16 at — 'went to the adult section and it caught me by
17 surprise that it said like I saw my picture on there
18 for, for an establishment.
19 Q. What establishment was that?
20 A. I 'mow one was for Abby's.
21 Q. And you had worked at Abbys, right?
22 A. No.
23 .Q. And in fact you had run ads on Craig's
24 List under the exotk or erotic --
25 A. No, I did not.

(561) 832-7500
39 (Pages 485 to 488)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
1 1
2 2
3 3
4 4
5 5
6 6
7 7
8 8
9 9
10 10
11 11
12 12
13 13
14 14
15 15
16 16
17 17
18 18
19 19
20 20
21 21
22 22
23 23
24 A. No. 24
5 Q.  Now, you said, back with Bobby, you said 25
Page 489

Q. — service?
A. I have never run ads. You have asked me this
three times. I have never run an ad. I've never
advertised myself. People have took my picture and
decided upon themselves to run their ad with my picture
on it.

Q. Why would —
A. False advertising.
Q. Why would they want to do that?
A. Probably because a good looking girl and
they wanted, you know, men to come into the shop.
Q So, when did you first discover that your
picture was on this website?

A. About a year ago.
Q. And what did you — you said you were
doing something to straighten it out. What have you
done?

A. I called an attorney.
Q. And who was that?
A. It doesn't matter.
Q. Yeah. Who did you call?
MR. EDWARDS: You can tell him who.
That's about it.
THE WITNESS: Brad Edwards.
Page 491
1 that you went to, I guess the Carousel a couple of
2 times and La Quinta a couple times and New York?
3 A. Yep.
4 Q. And you said that there were, you had
5 several other clients. I think you said three but I
6 could be wrong. He had referred you three other
7 clients. Do you recall that testimony?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. And who are the other clients?
10 A. There is Jeff and then two Johns.
11 Q. And, and who is Jeff?
12 A. Jeff is a man.
13 Q. Okay. And how many times have you been
14 out with him?
15 A. Three times.
16 Q. And where did you go with him?
17 A. La Quint&
18 Q. Is it just coincidental -- at the same
19 hotel that you went with Bobby?
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. Just coincidentally you went to the same
22 hotel?
23 A. Yeah.
24 Q. And what did you do with Jeff at the
25 La Quints?
Page 490
BY MR. WITTER:

Q. And is there a lawsuit filed?
MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form Any
other questions are going to attorney-client
privilege. I am not going to let her answer
any of the substance of that conversation after
the fact that she called me and she's disclosed
that.

MR. LUTHER: !just want to know if there
is a lawsuit filed. That would be public
record.
MR. EDWARDS: Right. You can look it up
in public record. I am not going to let her
tat

MR. WTTIER: Well, l think she gets to
answer.
BY MR. LUTTIER:
Q. Is, is there a lawsuit filed?
MR. EDWARDS: Don't answer,
attorney-client
BY MR. L

Q. Is there -- have you written a demand
letter to a defendant?
IP'
Page 4'•
A. Just nude company.
Q. You were nude for that one?

A. Yep, nude, nude company.
Q. Have you ever been nude with Bobby?
A. No.
Q. Has he ever asked you to be nude?

A. No.
Q. Any reason why you haven't been nude with
him?
A. Because he didn't ask for it.
Q. Did this guy Jeff ask for it?

A. Yeah.
Q. And how much did y0u get paid for by him
for that?
A. 200.
Q. An hour?
• A. Yes.
Q. And how many hours would you be there?

A. One.
Q. So, tell the ladies and gentlemen of the
jury what you did on this occasion when you went to
the La Quints to give Jeff nude company.

MR. EDWARDS: Object to the form.
THE WITNESS: Jeff and I went to La Quinta
and we sat down on the bed. And I took

(561) 832-7500
40 (Pages 489 to 492)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 493
clothes oft and he would sit there smoking
cigarettes, and we would just talk about life.
BY MR. LUTITER:

Q. Well, what do you — was that the first
time you met Jeff?
A- Yes.
Q. Had you had a face-to-face meeting with
him before you went to the La Quinta for the first
time?

A. No. He was a referral from Bobby.
Q. Okay. So, you knew nothing about him?
A. No.
Q. The first time he called you didn't even
know his name until he identified himself?

A. Yep.
Q. !she married?
A I think so.
Q. How old is he?
A. I have no idea, older.
Q. Older man?
A. Maybe around your age.

Q. Okay. Well, that's pretty old. I am
going to qualify for Social Security soon. Did he
look like a rich guy?

A. Yeah.
1.
Page 495
of what I do.
Q. Well, why would you do it if you were
scared?
A. Because it's all I know.

Q. All right. So, and you, at two other
times you went to see this Jeff right?
A. Yeah.
Q. When was the second time, where did you
110?

A. We went to a hotel in Royal Palm.
Q. Well, there's not many out there. Which
one did you go to?
A. I forgot. Royal Palm Inn, I don't know.

Q. What you do that time?
A. Same thing.
Q. Nude company?
A. Yeah.
Q. Did he ever touch you?
A. No, I don't do that anymore. I have four
clients.

Q. And what do you do if he says he wants
some sex?
A. I will tell him go find another girl.
Q. What if he just wants you to masturbate
him?
Page 494
1 Q. Did he look like Mr. Edwards?
2 A. No.
3 MR. EDWARDS: Just like you.
4 THE WITNESS: No not like you either.
5 BY MR. LLM'IER:
6 Q. So, had you decided -
7 A. You don't look rich.
8 Q. — this guy was, was a wealthy guy?
9 A. Sure.
10 Q. Was there anything else that made you
11 decide he was wealthy other than the fact that he
12 was an older guy?
13 A He had a nice car. He had nice clothes.
14 Q. And therefore you said I am happy to go
15 sit in a room naked with him and get paid 200 bucks
16 from him?
17 A. Yeah.
18 Q. You wanted the money.
19 A. Yeah.
20 Q. Good deal, right?
21 A. That's what I do fora living.
22 Q. Didn't scare you?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Didn't bother you?
‘35 A. Actually it did scare me. I am alwap scam!!

(561) 832-7500
Page 496
A. Masturbate him?
Q. Yes.
A. Isn't that sex?
Q. I don't know. I don't know what's your
definition. Depends on who you are.

A. Sex, the definition of sex is, you know,
touching somebody.
Q. Okay. What if you're touching yourself:
is that —

A. Yeah.
Q. — what you call sex?
A. Yes.
Q. So did you ever masturbate in front of
these guys?
A. No, I sat there naked.

Q. Do they get to take pictures or anything?
A No.
Q. Okay. So you went to the hotel in Royal
Palm Beach again for an hour?
A. Yes.
Q. How much did you get, $200?
A. Yes.
sm.... I
Q. Okay. And then what was the third time'?
A. Third time same hotel, Royal Palm.
Same thing?
41 (Pages 493 to 496)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 497 Page 499
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. Do anything else?
3 A. Same thing.
4 Q. When was the last time you were there with
5 Jeff?
6 A. Before New York.
7 Q. Like the first week of February of 2010?
8 A. Yeah, I don't know the dates.
9 Q. Either the last week of January 2010 or
10 the first week of February 2010. Within the last
11 ten days?
12 A. Maybe.
13 Q. Okay. And when was the time — all right.
14 So you were with Bobby last week. You were with
15 this guy within the last ten days. Now, how about
16 John One, how many times have you been with John
17 One?
18 A. Once.
19 Q. One time. and when was that?
20 A. Right after I saw Jeff.
21 Q. The last time?
22 A. Uh-huh.
23 Q. So —
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. So, that's been within the last ten days?
1 A. Probably.
2 Q. Think he's got a lot of money?
3 A. Yeah.
4 Q. And what did you do for him?
5 A. Same thing I did for Jeff.
6 Q. Sat around nude in a room?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. And how much did you get paid?
9 A. 200.
10 Q. For an hour?
11 A. Yeah.
12 Q. And has he made an appointment for another
13 time or just one?
14 A. He calls me whenever he wants me.
15 Q. Has he called you since that — you said
16 you went in the last ten days. Has he called you
17 since then?
18 A. No.
19 Q. Do you got any appointments scheduled now
20 as you sit here?
21 A. No.
22 Q. With anybody?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Okay. Then there was another John.
25 A. Uh-huh.
Page 498
1 A. From what I remember, yes.
2 Q. Okay. And where did you meet him?
3 A. At a hotel.
4 Q. What hotel?
5 A. It's on Okeechobee near the Turnpike or near
6 the, near the 95. I don't remember the name.
7 Q. The Marriott?
8 A. Ifs -- I'm not sure but ifs near 95.
9 Q. By the Tri-Rail station?
10 A. It's near 95.
11 Q. As in like right down the street from this
12 building?
13 A. It's, no, it's, it's east -- it's west of,
14 west of, west on Okeechobee.
15 Q. Yeah, but you said near 1-95?
16 A. Closer to 1-95 than the Turnpike, yeah.
17 Q. East of Military Trail?
18 A. East of Military Trail. It might have been.
19 I'm not, I'm not positively sure.
20 Q. Okay. So, did, did you know anything
21 about John before you met him in this hotel?
22 A. No.
23 Q. And is, is he an older man?
24 A. Of course.
25 R. Married?
Page 500

Q. And how many times have you been with that
John?
A. One other time.
Q. One other time or is this, is this with
the first John?

A. Second John.
Q. Okay. Second John.
A. One time at the same La Quinta. Or not the
La Quinta the behind the La Quinta there is a, ifs
like 180 to get a room. I don't know what it's called.

Q. On what road, on Okeechobee?
A. Yeah. Ifs behind the La Quinta on the west
side of the La Quinta.
Q. Okay. Older guy?

A. Yeah.
Q. You think he's wealthy?
A. Yes.
Q. Married?
A. Probably.
Q. How much -- what you did you do for him?

A. Same thing.
Q. Sat around in a room nude?
A. Yeah.
Q. Got paid 200?
A. Yes.
42 (Pages 497 to 500)
(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. (561) 832-7506
Page 501
1 MR. WITTER: We might as well rake a
2 break now.
3 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record at
4 12:54 prn.
5 (A luncheon recess was held from 12:54 to
6 1:48 p.m.)
7 4, • •
B
(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
43 (Page 501)
(561) 832-7506
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                  Doug Band [democrat] assistant to Bill Clinton 
                        Ehud Barak [israel] former prime minister of Israel, Epstein business partner [dropsite] 
                                                  Igor Zinoviev [russia] Epstein's bodyguard, former MMA fighter 
 Story Cowles [employee] Epstein's male assistant, named co-conspirator, nephew of Emilia and Pepe Fanjul [rddt] 
              Sergio Cordero [modeling] modeling agent MC2 Model Management, business partner of Jean Luc Brunel 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00182418 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Jane Doe #2 v. Jeffrey Epstein
(date: 2010-03-15)
5 JANE DOE,
6 Plaintiff,
7 vs.
8 JEFFREY EPSTEIN, et al.,
9 Defendants.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
Case No. 08-CV-80893-CIV-MARRA/JOHNSON
13 DEPOSITION OF
Volume 1 of 1
14 Pages 1 through 138
Videotaped
17 Monday, March 15, 2010
10:13 a.m. - 12:42 p.m.
18 U.S. Legal Support
515 East Las Olas Boulevard, 3rd Floor
19 Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301
Stenographically Reported By:
22 Janet L. McKinney, RPR, FPR, CLR
23 Registered Professional Reporter
24 Florida Professional Reporter
25 Certified LiveNote Reporter
1 APPEARANCES:
2 ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF:
3 FARMER, JAFFE, WEISSING, EDWARDS,
FISTOS & LEHRMAN
4 425 North Andrews Avenue
Suite 2
5 Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301-3268
BY: BRADLEY EDWARDS, ESQ.
8 ON BEHALF OF THE DEFENDANT JEFFREY EPSTEIN:
BURMAN, CRITTON, LUTTIER &
COLEMAN, LLP
303 Banyan Boulevard
Suite 400
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
, ESQ.
ON BEHALF OF OTHER PLAINTIFFS IN RELATED CASES:
MERMELSTEIN & HOROWITZ, P.A.
18205 Biscayne Boulevard
Suite 2218
Miami, Florida 33160
ROBBINS, TUNKEY, ROSS, AMSEL,
21 RABEN & WAXMAN, P.A.
2250 Southwest Third Avenue
22 4th Floor
Miami, Florida 33129
BY: STUART S. MERMELSTEIN, ESQ.
ON BEHALF OF THE WITNESS:
24 BY: ALAN S. ROSS, ESQ.
25 Also Present: Sean McGuire, Videographer
U.S. Legal Support
INDEX
Page
Direct Examination By Mr. Edwards 7
4 Cross-Examination By Mr. Mermelstein 111
Redirect Examination By Mr. Edwards 127
5 Recross-Examination By Mr. Mermelstein 133
7 Certificate of Oath 137
8 Certificate of Reporter 138
10 EXHIBITS
11 PLF'S
12 No. Description Page
14 1 Jane Doe 102 v. Jeffrey Epstein 33
15 complaint
16 2A-2G Telephone messages 62
17 3 Handwritten notes 72
18 2H Telephone message 87
19 4 Gawker.com photo with story 127
22 WITNESS'S
23 No. Description Page
25 1 Target letter 4
Videotaped deposition taken before JANET L
McKINNEY, Registered Professional Reporter, Florida
Professional Reporter, Certified LiveNote Reporter and
Notary Public in and for the State of Florida at Large
in the above cause.
(Whereupon, Witness's Exhibit 1 was marked for
identification.)
VIDEOGRAPHER: We are now on the video record.
Today is Monday, the 15th day of March, 2010. The
time is 9:13 a.m. (sic) . We are here at 515 East
Las Olas Boulevard, 3rd Floor, Fort Lauderdale,
Florida, for the purpose of taking the videotape
deposition of taken in Case Number
08-CIV-80893, Jane Doe M. Jeffrey Epstein, et al.
The court reporter is Janet McKinney; the
videographer is Sean McGuire, both of U.S. Legal
Support.
Will counsel and all present please introduce
yourself and the court reporter will swear the
20 witness.
21 MR. EDWARDS: Brad Edwards. I represent the
22 plaintiff, Jane Doe also "Jane Doe"; EW, "EW"; LM,
23 "LM"
24 MR. MERMELSTEIN: Stuart Mermelstein. I
25 represent Jane Doe Numbers 2 through 8.
1 MR. PIKE: Michael Pike on behalf of Jeffrey
2 Epstein.
3 MR. ROSS: And good morning, my name is Alan
4 Ross. I represent the witness,
5 THE REPORTER: Would you raise your right
6 hand, please.
7 Do you solemnly swear or affirm the testimony
8 you're about to give will be the truth, and nothing
9 but the truth, so help you God?
10 THE WITNESS: I do.
11 MR. ROSS: Before the deposition begins and in
12 an effort to streamline the process of getting
13 through this deposition on behalf of the witness we
14 have had marked as Witness Exhibit Number 1 an
15 August 31, 2007 letter from the ' tates
16 Attorney's Office addressed to through
17 her then counsel, Bruce Lyons, which is called a
18 target letter identifying her as a target of a
19 federal Grand Jury investigation in the Southern
20 District of Florida and outlining a number of
21 offenses that were the subject matter of
22 investigation.
23 As a result of that, it is anticipated that
24 some of the questions that may be asked during the
25 course of this deposition she may invoke her Fifth
1 Amendment privilege against self-incrimination.
2 And in order to streamline this we've agreed prior
3 to beginning this that she will simply answer "I
4 refuse to answer." The parties will understand and
5 the record will reflect that she is invoking her
6 Fifth Amendment privilege against
7 self-incrimination.
8 If there is some other privilege,
9 attorney -client privilege or some other objection
10 that I may have to a question, I'll specifically
11 state it. But her answer "I refuse to answer" will
12 be on Fifth Amendment grounds if that's acceptable
13 to everyone.
14 MR. EDWARDS: It's acceptable.
15 MR. MERMELSTEIN: It's acceptable.
16 MR. PIKE: Acceptable.
17 MR. ROSS: Okay. Madam court reporter has
18 already marked the exhibit, and I'll leave that
19 with her.
20 MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
1 THEREUPON:
3 having been first duly sworn or affirmed, was examined
4 and testified as follows:
5 DIRECT EXAMINATION
6 BY MR. EDWARDS:
7 Q. Can you tell us your full -- full name.
8 A. .
9 Q. At some point in time you were known as
10 ; is that correct?
11 A. Correct.
12 Q. And when did that change?
13 A. Well, I got married and initially I stayed
14 with my name and then -- because immigration kind of
15 made a mistake of not changing my name when I first
16 came to this country. And at some point when I was
17 removing my conditional residency I made sure that this
18 mistake is corrected. I do not recall exact time when
19 that happened.
12 A. I was invited by modeling agency on a business
13 visa.
14 Q. What modeling agency?
15 A. Elite Models.
16 Q. And who was the connection at Elite Models
17 that invited you?
18 A. Actually it was my husband. I met him in
19 Europe and at the time he -- he knew that agency and I
20 was modeling in Europe and he showed my pictures and
21 they invited me.
22 Q. How long have you been modeling?
23 A. Since about I was 16 years old.
24 Q. Since 16, so mid-90's? Late 90's?
25 A. Probably around '98, '99, I believe.

Q. Okay. And what agencies did you model for in
Europe?
A. I was with -- in Poland I was with Ricardo Guy
that eventually change the name to J and B Models. I
was also represented by Ricardo Guy in Milan. Then on
my second trip to Milan an agency called Women.
I was then represented in Japan by agency --
oh, that's -- you just mean Europe or --

Q. Well, you can continue.
A. Yeah. I was represented in Japan by agency
Zucca. I was in South Korea, I do not recall the name
of the agency. I was represented in Taiwan by Fashion
Management.

Q. Okay. And these were all agencies that you
worked for or worked with prior to coming to the United
a 9
a 9
States?

A. Not all of them. Some of them I worked --
already been United States and traveling.
Q. Okay. But sometime around 2002 you were
invited by Elite Models to come to the United States to
model?

A. Correct.
Q. And at the time -- well, where are you from?
A. I'm Polish.
Q. Okay. So at the time you were a Polish
citizen?

A. Yes.
Q. So in order to come to the United States you
needed to get a work visa?
A. I was invited actually just to kind of get a
feeling if I will be suitable. So I came on a business
tourist visa which is, I believe, B1/B2.

Q. Okay. And where did you first go when you
came to the United States, what state?
A. Florida.
Q. And what city in Florida?

A. Miami.
Q. And what did you do for your two weeks when
you first arrived in Miami, Florida?
A. I do not recall.

Q. Okay. But did you do any modeling?
A. Well, like I would see some photographers, the
agency would send me like on all calls to see
photographers to kind of introduce me as a model.

Q. And why did you make the decision to go with
Elite Models in the United States when you already were
modeling in --

A. Um-hum.
Q. -- Europe?
A. Well, you know, just to expand it was
something that I did. And I decided to take a year off
after I graduated from high school and -- you know,
just to expand the modeling -- the modeling
possibilities, opportunities.

Q. Where did you graduate from high school?
A. In Warsaw, Poland.
Q. What year?
A. 2002, I believe.
Q. And do you have any college? Have you gone to
college after that?

A. I have an associate degree from Miami Dade
College -- Miami Dade College, and I'm pursuing a
bachelor degree right now.

Q. When did you get your associate's degree from
Miami Dade?
A. 2008. Summer of 2008.
Q. And you're pursuing a bachelor's degree right
now?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
program?
Yes.
From where?
Florida International University.
In what?
Accounting.
How long have you been in the accounting
1 A. Since fall 2008.
2 Q. And when do you expect to graduate?
3 A. Fall 2010.
4 Q. Are you a full-time student or part-time?
5 A. I'm a full-time student at this time.
6 Q. When you first arrived in Miami, Florida in
7 fall of 2002 did you decide during that two weeks that
8 you were going to stay permanently?
9 A. No.
10 Q. Okay. Did you go back to Poland?
11 A. Yes, I have. I have -- I went back for
12 Christmas.
13 Q. Okay. Poor question. Going back to 2002 I'm
14 trying to just understand how it was that -- you came
15 over here on a two-week business visa, but eventually
16 you ended up staying for a longer period of time,
17 correct?
18 A. Right.
19 Q. Okay. And how did that come about, just tell
20 me?
21 A. Well, I got romantically involved with my
22 current husband and so when -- you know, we just
23 started dating, we got engaged, and that's how, you
24 know, our relation evolved -- evolved, and eventually,
25 you know, I got married and -- and stayed.
1 Q. Okay. And since coming to the United States
2 have you always lived in Miami, Florida?
3 A. No.
4 Q. All right. Where else have you lived in the
5 United States?
6 A. New York.
7 Q. Where in New York?
8 A. Manhattan.
9 Q. What was the address in Manhattan where you
10 lived?
11 MR. ROSS: I'm going to advise you to invoke
12 privilege.
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. Okay. Have you -- are you familiar with an
15 address at 301 East 66th Street in New York?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 MR. PIKE: May we take a break for a second?
18 May I speak with you?
19 MR. ROSS: Sure.
20 VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the record, 10:22 a.m.
21 (Recess taken at 10:22 a.m.)
22 (Deposition resumed at 10:23 a.m.)
23 VIDEOGRAPHER: On the record, 10:23 a.m.
24 MR. ROSS: Brad, let me just interrupt for a
25 moment.
1 MR. EDWARDS: No problem.
2 MR. ROSS: Just to be sure, when the witness
3 answers "I refuse to answer" to be clear the full
4 statement that she's not saying for the sake of
5 saving time is that she's invoking her Fifth
6 Amendment right against self-incrimination. Just
7 to be clear.
8 MR. EDWARDS: That's what I've understood all
9 along.
10 MR. MERMELSTEIN: That's what I understood.
11 MR. ROSS: Okay, fine. Go ahead.
12 MR. EDWARDS: This is just for the sake of
13 brevity --
14 MR. ROSS: Exactly.
15 MR. EDWARDS: -- and let's move it on.
16 BY MR. EDWARDS:
17 Q. All right. So I'm going to ask the question
18 again, I don't remember whether you'd responded yet,
19 but are you familiar with the address in Manhattan
20 301 East 66th Street in New York?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Okay. How long did you live in -- well, what
23 was the first address that you lived in in Miami?
1 Q. South Shore. Okay.
2 A. Um-hum.
3 Q. Have you ever had your deposition taken
4 before?
5 A. No.
6 Q. Okay. You're doing very well so far. There's
a couple rules I didn't explain but mainly because
you're doing very well. I just have to wait for you to
finish your answer; you have to wait for me to finish
my question. We have one court reporter. She can only
take down one of us. Give us an answer that we all
understand. Nodding of the head or shaking the head
are easy to do and I get what you're saying, but she
doesn't. Ah-ha or un-ah are things that are commonly
said. They look the same on paper.
If I ask a bad question which could happen, as
already happened and probably will again, just tell me
"I don't understand the question," I'll ask it again --

A. Okay.
Q. -- all right?
1 A I'm sorry, I don't understand your question.
4 . e , since -- since came ve ere,
5 always stayed there whether being in Miami traveling
6 back and forth, and I live currently at this address.
7 Q. Okay. What was the first time that you moved
8 from that address to live elsewhere?
9 A. I do not recall.
10 Q. Okay. I know that you told me you lived in
11 New York City and we're not going to discuss -- I'm
12 assuming you're not going to answer a lot of questions
13 about New York City, but at what time period did you
14 move there? Was it right after you got here two weeks,
15 a year later? I'm just trying to get a year as to when
16 you moved to New York?
17 MR. ROSS: I'm going to instruct you not to
18 answer.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Okay. Do you know a guy by the name of Jean
A.
Q.
Correct.
How long did you live at that address?
21 Luc Brunel?
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Where are your parents?
24 A. They're in Warsaw, Poland.
25 Q. And since you've been in the United States
1 have they come to the United States?
2 A. Yes, they have visited me.
3 Q. Have they ever met Jeffrey Epstein?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. Have they ever met Jean Luc Brunel?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Where are you currently employed?
8 A. I pursue -- I go to school full-time, I do not
9 work.
10 Q. Are you also still in the modeling business
11 though?
12 A. No, I'm not.
13 Q. And when was the last time you did any
14 modeling?
15 A. It would be late spring, early summer of 2006
16 I went on a trip to Taiwan.
17 Q. And why did you stop modeling at that time?
18 A. I wanted -- I always kind of knew that it's
19 something that I'm going to be doing and I just decided
20 to go and pursue a college degree.
21 Q. Okay. Is it something that you ever plan to
22 go back to, modeling?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Are you involved at all with the modeling
25 industry?
1 A. No.
2 Q. I mean, helping to recruit models, helping
3 others to recruit models, anything like that?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Do you ever -- do you currently talk to
6 Mr. Brunel?
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. When is the last time that you talked to
9 Jeffrey Epstein?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Do you know a woman by the name of Ghislaine
12 Maxwell?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. Do you know someone by the name of
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. Do you know a person named ?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein have anything to do with
20 you moving to New York City?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Did you ever live in a place in New York City
23 owned or controlled by Jeffrey Epstein?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. Are you familiar with the modeling agency MC
1 Squared?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Do you know of underage females being
4 transported into this country to work for the modeling
5 agency MC Squared?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Do you know of those underage females being
8 given work visas and staying at the 301 East 66th
9 Street address?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Can you say whether you have observed
12 Mr. Brunel or Mr. Epstein engaging in sex with underage
13 females?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Do you know where Mr. Brunel lives?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. Is it true that Mr. Brunel stays in the 301
18 East 66th address frequently with underage females?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. At what point were you hired to work for
21 Mr. Epstein?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 MR. EDWARDS: You can still answer the
24 question. Mr. Pike is making a legal objection.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. And how did -- how did it come about that you
2 began working with Jeffrey Epstein?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. What did Jeffrey Epstein pay you in salary?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. What was the time period that you worked for
9 him?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Why did you stop working for him?
12 MR. PIKE: Form.
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. What initially were you hired to do?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 Q. Has Jeffrey Epstein ever paid you to stay
18 quiet or keep quiet about what went on in his house?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. Have you talked to or
about the things that went on in Jeffrey
23 Epstein's house?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. Did you sign a confidentiality agreement with
2 Jeffrey Epstein?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 Q. Did that confidentiality agreement outline
6 what you should say to authorities should he be caught
7 with underage females?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. Is there another book or manual or written
11 memorialization of what you, as an employee of Jeffrey
12 Epstein, should do if confronted by law enforcement?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Are you invoking your Fifth Amendment right
16 because you believe you could be prosecuted?
17 MR. ROSS: Invoke.
18 A. I refuse to answer.
a 9
8 9

Q. Are you also invoking because you're scared to
testify against Jeffrey Epstein?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.

Q. When did you first learn that Jeffrey Epstein
had a sexual obsession for underage females?
A. I refuse to answer.

MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. Isn't it true that you have seen Jeffrey
Epstein sexually interacting with females as young as
12 years old?

A. I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. Is it true that you have observed Jeffrey
Epstein's sexual obsession to include the age range 12
to 17?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Epstein?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Do you know if
Jeffrey Epstein when she was underage?
MR. PIKE: Form.

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. What have you been told about Jeffrey
Epstein's sexual obsession with underage minor
children?

MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
Have you ever had sex with Jeffrey Epstein?
I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Have you ever been paid for sex with Jeffrey
had sex with

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Isn't it true that Jeffrey Epstein interacted
sexually with underage minors on an everyday basis?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And most of the time Mr. Epstein would
interact with underage minors at least two times a day;
is that true?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Can you explain to the jury how Mr. Epstein
would access new underage minor females for sex every
day?
A.
Q.
to bring
A.
Q.
to bring
A.
Q•

MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
How many assistants did Jeffrey Epstein hire
him underage minor females for sex?
I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Were you one of those assistants that helped
him underage minor females?
MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
I know that the laws in Poland are probably
different than they are here, but are you familiar with
the Florida Statutes that protect children against
sexual offenders or sexual predators?
4 MR. ROSS: Invoke.
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. Let me just read you the lewd or lascivious
7 molestation statute and then I'm going to ask you some
8 questions about it.
9 It says: "A person who intentionally touches
10 in a lewd or lascivious manner the breasts, genitals,
11 genital area or buttocks or the clothing covering them
12 of a person less than 16 years of age or forces or
13 entices a person under 16 years of age to so touch the
14 perpetrator, commits lewd or lascivious molestation, a
15 second degree felony."
16 After hearing that statute isn't that
17 something -- isn't that a crime that you know
18 Mr. Epstein to have committed on an everyday basis
19 while you were working for him?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. And that's a statute that he violated with
23 more than 100 underage females; is that true?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. When did you become aware that Mr. Epstein was
2 a child molester?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. Have you ever seen him with a female under the
6 age of 12?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. Have you ever known Jeffrey Epstein to have
10 sex with an adult?
11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. Does he -- is he sexually attracted to adults?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. When was the first time you learned of
17 Mr. Epstein getting a massage from an underage minor
18 female?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. I realize some of these questions may sound
22 repetitive but during this case we've learned of key
23 terms that different people on Mr. Epstein's let's say
24 payroll or inner circle recognize or talk about. So
25 when I talk about "massages", do you know what that
1 term means?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. Isn't "massage" the word that was told by
5 Jeffrey Epstein to all of his employees to refer to
6 whatever acts he engages in with underage females in
7 his bedroom?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. At this point -- were you -- were you ever in
11 the bedroom with him when he was engaging in sexual
12 acts with underage females and calling them "massages"?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Did you ever participate in any of the sexual
16 acts that Jeffrey Epstein was having with underage
17 females?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Now, just so that the record is clear there is
21 not a single piece of evidence that ever indicates that
22 you were involved with underage females, I'm not even
23 implying that and I realize that you invoking it may --
24 may give the wrong light and that's not -- that's not
25 my intention, so -- but were you ever aware of
participating in sex with underage females?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Have you read the police reports related to
4 the criminal investigation into Mr. Epstein?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. And you're aware of this 87-page police report
7 that details numerous females that indicate that they
8 were involved sexually with Mr. Epstein when they were
9 minors?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 Q. Did anyone instruct you to use the code word
13 "massage"?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. And when referring to these underage minor
16 females that would come over to Mr. Epstein's house did
17 anybody also tell you to use the term "work"?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 Q. Meaning when somebody would call to schedule
21 one of these underage females for a massage isn't it
22 true that they would say "It's time to come to work"
23 and schedule a specific appointment?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. Is there a book or manual or is it written
2 anywhere that the -- that sex with underage minors is
3 to be referred to as a "massage"?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 Q. Were there ever team meetings, for lack of a
7 better word, where Jeffrey Epstein and possibly
8 Ghislaine Maxwell, , yourself, would talk
9 about this organization of obtaining underage girls for
10 Jeffrey Epstein for sex?
11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. What methods does Jeffrey Epstein use to gain
14 access to underage minor females for sex?
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. What is your understanding of Jeffrey
18 Epstein's involvement with the modeling industry?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. Have you ever modeled for MC Squared?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. Has Jeffrey Epstein ever promised you anything
25 related to a modeling career?
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Have you ever talked to Jean Luc Brunel about
4 modeling?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. Have you ever talked to Jean Luc Brunel about
7 his desire to have sex with underage females?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. Isn't it true that Jean Luc Brunel has been in
10 trouble for years for having sex with underage minors
11 in Europe?
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. Are you familiar with The McIntyre Reports?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Okay. Are you familiar with reports done on
16 modeling agencies back in the 80's and 90's related to
17 agency owners having sex with underage minors?
18 MR. ROSS: Answer the question.
19 A. No, I'm not.
20 Q. Okay. Did you ever hear of Jean Luc Brunel's
21 reputation for having sex with underage girls?
22 MR. ROSS: Invoke.
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. Do you know how Jean Luc Brunel knows Jeffrey
25 Epstein?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 Q. Isn't their connection the obsession for
4 underage minor females?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Based on your observations of Jeffrey Epstein
8 would you categorize his obsession for underage minor
9 females as an addiction?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. Isn't it true that Ghislaine Maxwell delivers
13 underage minor females to Jeffrey Epstein?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Have you ever had a sexual relationship with
17 Ghislaine Maxwell?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. Do you know what Ghislaine Maxwell does in
20 general for Jeffrey Epstein?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Have you seen photographs of underage minor
24 females in Jeffrey Epstein's patrol -- control or
25 possession?
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Were there surveillance cameras, hidden
4 surveillance cameras inside Jeffrey Epstein's home?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Did those surveillance cameras capture
8 underage minor females naked?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. And didn't Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine
12 Maxwell watch those surreptitiously obtained videos of
13 underage minor females?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. And those videos and photographs of underage
17 minor females were saved on Jeffrey Epstein's computers
18 in his house, right?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. Have you seen those photographs and videos on
22 Jeffrey Epstein's computers?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. Who have you talked to related to the criminal
1 investigation into Jeffrey Epstein?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 MR. ROSS: In addition, attorney -client
5 privilege.
6 Q. And I certainly would -- do not want to know
7 anything you talked to your attorney about, I
8 apologize.
9 A. (Nods.)
10 Q. Why was it that you were named as a
11 co-conspirator of Jeffrey Epstein's in the
12 non-prosecution agreement?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Do you feel like a victim of Jeffrey
16 Epstein's?
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. Do you feel like Jeffrey Epstein brainwashed
20 you to some extent?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Do you feel any remorse for any role that you
24 may have played in having underage minor females at
25 Jeffrey Epstein's house for him to molest them?
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Have you known Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey
4 Epstein to keep sex slaves?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. Do you know somebody named ?
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. Have you met ?
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 MR. EDWARDS: All right. Let me go ahead and
11 mark as -- as Plaintiff's Exhibit 1 a lawsuit that
12 was filed by Bob Josefsberg on behalf of Jane Doe
13 102 v. Jeffrey Epstein just for the purposes of
14 asking the witness some questions.
15 MR. ROSS: I've seen it.
16 (Whereupon, Plaintiff's Exhibit 1 was marked
17 for identification.)
18 Q. Have you ever read the lawsuit Jane Doe 102 M.
19 Jeffrey Epstein?
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. In the lawsuit it indicates the plaintiff was
22 15 years old when Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein
23 had a threesome with this underage minor female. Are
24 you aware of that?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. And Jeffrey Epstein and/or Ghislaine Maxwell
3 obtained and purchased passports for 15-year -old Jane
4 Doe 102 to transport her to Palm Beach, New York City,
5 Santa Fe, Los Angeles, San Francisco, St. Louis, as
6 well as Europe, the Caribbean, and Africa; are you
7 aware of that?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 Q. It's also alleged that Jeffrey Epstein in
11 addition to molesting Jane Doe 102 along with Ghislaine
12 Maxwell forced her to have sex with other models,
13 actresses, and celebrities?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 Q. It also indicates that Jeffrey Epstein
17 transported other minor girls from Turkey, the Czech
18 Republic, Asia, and other countries. Are you aware of
19 that?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Is Jeffrey Epstein involved in the
23 international child sex trade?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. Is Jean Luc Brunel his partner in that
2 international child sex trade?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. Are you aware that after -- that Jeffrey
6 Epstein forced Jane Doe 102 to have sex with other
7 adult male peers including royalty, politicians,
8 academicians, businessmen and/or other professional and
9 personal acquaintances of Jeffrey Epstein's?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. Is that something that he did with girls other
13 than Jane Doe 102?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Aren't you familiar with Jeffrey Epstein's
17 practice of pimping out underage minor females to other
18 people that have the same sexual obsession with
19 underage minors?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. And doesn't he benefit financially from that
23 sex trade?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. Jane Doe 102 ultimately escaped from him and
2 left to Australia, is that your understanding?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 Q. Have you ever spoken with Jane Doe 102?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. On one of Epstein's birthdays a friend of
8 Jeffrey Epstein sent to him 12 -- three 12-year -old
9 girls from France who spoke no English for Epstein to
10 sexually exploit and abuse and after doing so he sent
11 them back to France the next day. Are you familiar
12 with that?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Isn't that something that is fairly common for
16 Mr. Epstein?
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 Q. Who are the friends that send to Jeffrey
20 Epstein underage minor females for his birthday so that
21 he can abuse?
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 Q. Is one of those friends Jean Luc Brunel?
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. Have you ever met Prince Andrew?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Has Prince Andrew been involved with underage
4 minor females to your knowledge?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. Have you ever met Alan Dershowitz?
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. When Alan Dershowitz stays at Jeffrey
9 Epstein's house isn't it true that he has been at the
10 house when underage minor females have been in the
11 bedroom with Jeffrey Epstein?
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. Has -- are you familiar with the media
14 publication or online resource RadarOnline?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Is that something that you assisted
17 Mr. Epstein with when he purchased RadarOnline?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. And do you know his business partner in that
20 endeavor?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Isn't it also true that he used RadarOnline as
23 another way to gain access to underage minor females
24 for sex?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. Have you been to all of Jeffrey Epstein's
3 properties?
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. Certainly you've been to the property at 358
7 El Brillo Way, correct?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. Have you been to his property in Manhattan?
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 MR. PIKE: Form.
13 Q. And have you been to his island in -- it was
14 Little St. James, I believe he calls it Little
15 St. Jeff's now?
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A. I refuse to answer.
a A.

Q. And have you witnessed underage child sex
orgies on that island?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.

Q. Do you know a female named Jeletzia?
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Do you know where Jeletzia lives these days?

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. What is your understanding of
role in Jeffrey Epstein's life?
A. I refuse to answer.

MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. Isn't it true that she gets paid just to bring
him underage minor females for sex?
MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A. I refuse to answer.

Q. And additionally, she schedules the
appointments for underage minor females for him to
molest?
A. I refuse to answer.

MR. PIKE: Form.
You know
I refuse to answer.
Does she still work
I refuse to answer.
Was she an underage
Epstein's?
I refuse to answer.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Jeffrey
A.

Q. Through discovery we've talked to
witnesses about, you know, Jeffrey Epstein
that work for him. I don't know if you'll
answer any of these questions but I'll ask
one at a time.
?
for Ghislaine Maxwell?
minor child victim of
numerous
and people
be able to
them anyway
Is somebody who travels with
Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And when Jeffrey Epstein is coming to town
doesn't he call his number one assistant?

MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
Q. And at some point in time, it looks like in
early 2005 or late 2004, you were also an assistant of
Jeffrey Epstein's, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And how was it that you transitioned from
being involved in modeling to being an employee of
Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Other than arranging for underage minor
females to come to Jeffrey Epstein's house did you do
anything else for Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Did you ever fly on Jeffrey Epstein's
airplane?
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Did you witness Jeffrey Epstein abuse --
3 sexually abusing underage minor females on his
4 airplane?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Did you know that it was illegal for Jeffrey
8 Epstein to interact sexually with underage minor
9 females?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. Did you ever object to Jeffrey Epstein
13 interacting sexually with underage minor females?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Would Jeffrey Epstein get angry at you if you
17 did not have an appointment set for him with an
18 underage minor female?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. Has Jeffrey Epstein contacted you in the last
22 year?
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 Q. Has contacted you within the last
1 year?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Has anybody that is associated with Jeffrey
4 Epstein's party contacted you in the last year?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. By that I mean to include Ghislaine Maxwell,
8 , any of these people, have they contacted
9 you within the last year?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. Are you familiar with the names of some of the
13 underage minor females?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Are you familiar with LM?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. Do you remember what LM looked like?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. Are you familiar with EW?
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. Do you remember what EW looked like?
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Are you familiar with Jane Doe?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. These are all females that were underage minor
1 females that Jeffrey Epstein interacted with sexually
2 during a time when you were working for him; isn't that
3 true?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 Q. And LM was somebody that went over to Jeffrey
7 Epstein's house and was molested at a young age by him
8 more than 100 times; is that true?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. And EW was also somebody who went over to
12 Jeffrey Epstein's house when she was between 14 and
13 16 years old more than a hundred times; isn't that
a 9
a 9
true?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And Jane Doe was somebody that went to Jeffrey
Epstein's house more than 15 times to be molested by
Jeffrey Epstein when she was 14 and 15 years old; is
that true?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Is it also true that LM brought to Jeffrey
Epstein's house between 50 and 75 other underage minor
females for Jeffrey Epstein to molest?

A. I refuse to answer.
MR. ROSS: Form.
Q. Are you aware of Jeffrey Epstein's for lack of
a better word "ritual" with these underage minor
females in his bedroom?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Wouldn't it generally begin with Jeffrey
Epstein placing a call to or yourself and
telling you that he's going to be in town at the Palm
Beach mansion?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And then isn't there a list of underage minor
females stored in the computer system?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And that computer system is interconnected
from his New York home, his New Mexico home, his
island, his home in France, and West Palm Beach; is
that correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And have you seen that list of underage minor
females stored in the computer system?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And isn't it true there are over a thousand
girls at any given time between the age range of 12 and
17 all of which have been molested by Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And when Mr. Epstein would call and tell you
the time that he was going to be in town it would then
be your job to get an underage minor female to his
house and set a specific appointment for that person;
is that correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And he would tell you the exact time of day
that he wanted his two or three appointments to molest
underage minor females?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And you would go into the computer system and
call the person that he told you he wanted to see for
that day; is that correct?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. And that may be
1 or somebody local that you would call on the telephone
2 and tell them to come work at a specific time?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. And didn't Mr. Epstein tell you that the way
6 you need to tell these girls is that they are working
7 so that they do not feel that they have the option to
8 decline?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. I mean, the psychology of it all was explained
12 in detail by Jeffrey Epstein; isn't that correct?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. And once the girls were inside the bedroom
16 Jeffrey Epstein said that he can take care of the rest,
17 correct?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. And the underage minor female would show up at
21 the house and be greeted at the door by either
22 yourself, the house manager, or correct?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. Many of these underage minor females including
1 my three clients, LM, EW, and Jane Doe you met
2 personally, right?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 Q. And then you would lead them upstairs to his
6 bedroom and leave him alone in the bedroom, leave my
7 client alone in the bedroom?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. And let's take LM, and she went there many
11 times between the ages of 13 and 16. If she was taken
12 up to his bedroom she would be left alone in the
13 bedroom until Jeffrey Epstein arrived, correct?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. And Jeffrey Epstein would appear usually naked
17 and order for her to take her clothes off?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 Q. And then Mr. Epstein would lay face down on
21 the massage table would usually be the next step,
22 correct?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. And you know this ritual because at some point
1 in time Jeffrey Epstein showed you exactly what he does
2 with each of these girls in the bedroom, correct?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. So after about -- he would order the underage
6 minor female to begin massaging him, correct?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. And then he would roll over and begin to
10 masturbate with his right hand, correct?
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. And then he would begin also grabbing the
13 breasts, buttocks, and vagina area of these underage
14 minor females, correct?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 Q. And his ritual was so specific that with each
18 of them he would demand that they pinch his nipples
19 very hard, right?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. That's a fetish that you know that Jeffrey
23 Epstein has, right, he likes his nipples pinched very
24 hard?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. And as he's masturbating with one hand and has
3 his other hand groping or inserting his fingers into
4 the underage minor's vagina he's also telling them to
5 pinch his nipples, correct?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. And this continues -- and sometimes this
9 escalates to him using vibrators, correct?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. And have you seen vibrators in the Palm Beach
13 mansion house?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. And other times he orders to
17 participate in these encounters with underage minor
18 females; is that correct?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Are you familiar with
21 strapping on dildos to have sex with these underage
22 minor females?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. And when Miss Marcinkova would have sex with
1 the underage minor females Jeffrey Epstein would watch
2 and continue to ejac -- continue to masturbate,
3 correct?
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. Has he ever asked you to participate in these
7 threesomes with underage minor females?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 Q. Have you ever participated in sex with
11 underage minor females at the direction of Jeffrey
12 Epstein?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. The -- this whole experience that I am
16 explaining right now is identical every single time
17 with these underage minor females; isn't that your
18 understanding?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. And this whole experience is what he has
22 taught you and the other employees to call a "massage",
23 correct?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. And it always ends with him ejaculating?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 Q. And then he offers 200 to $300 cash to the
5 underage minor female, correct?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. And then he also gives them another another
9 option to make money which is each time you come to my
10 house and we engage in this sexual interaction I will
11 give you $200, but each female you bring me like you,
12 between the age range of 12 and 16, I will pay you $200
13 per person.
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 Q. Is that something you're familiar with?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. And LM at that offer was one of the girls who
18 brought him 75 plus underage minor females, correct?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. And so he's basically created a pyramid of
22 underage minor females where the computer system has a
23 thousand of these females ready to come over to work
24 for him?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. Do you know what Jeffrey Epstein does for a
3 living?
4 A.
5 Q. aside from interacting
6 sexually females?
8 A.
9 Q. his money
10 where he
11 A.
16 into
17 females?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. Do you know Martin Nowak?
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. Is that also somebody that would interact
22 sexually with underage minor females?
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. Do you know Leslie Wexner?
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. Is that somebody you've met before?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Has Mr. Epstein himself interacted sexually
I refuse to answer.
Does he do anything
with underage minor

MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
Do you know how it is that he made
is purported to be a billionaire?
I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. Do you know David Copperfield?
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Is David Copperfield somebody that would come
town and interact sexually with underage minor
4 with Leslie Wexner?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. When Mr. Epstein was being investigated
8 criminally how did you first learn about that?
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. At some point in time he was tipped off that
11 his home -- that a search warrant was going to be
12 executed on his home, correct?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. And just a month before the execution of that
16 search warrant -- less than a month before the
17 execution of that search warrant he ordered you to do
18 something with certain evidence, didn't he?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. In fact, there were at least three very key
22 computers that contained a lot of the information that
23 I've been asking you about. You're familiar with those
24 computers that were in his house, correct?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. And he ordered you to come over and take those
3 computers out of his house, correct?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 Q. And you could basically take the local
7 database that exposed this criminal enterprise that
8 I've been talking about dealing with sex with underage
9 minor vehicles -- underage minor females and you could
10 take the evidence from his home, correct?
11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. And you've seen the material that's on those
14 computers, correct?
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. And if I were to look at those computers it
18 would display exactly what I've been describing to you
19 today, right?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. And you went to his house with a male,
23 correct?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 Q. There was one other guy with you that helped
2 that assisted you to take these computers from his
3 home; is that right?
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. Where did you take those?
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. Did you take those -- was it Bill Reilly that
9 went to the home?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Do you know who Bill Reilly is?
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. He's one of the investigators hired by Roy
14 Black to represent Jeffrey Epstein?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Did you take those computers ever to your
17 house?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. And I uess the house that I would be talking
20 about is the have those
21 computers ever been to that house?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. Were you nervous about the fact that you were
25 taking these computers out of the home at a time when a
1 search warrant was imminent?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Did you ever question when you were directed
4 to take these computers from his home?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. How much additional money or bonus were you
7 paid to take the computers that we're talking about out
8 of Jeffrey Epstein's house?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Would those computers reveal criminal activity
12 of only Jeffrey Epstein or of others?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Did you talk with about the
16 criminal investigation into Jeffrey Epstein and others?
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 Q. Well, at some point in time what's been marked
19 as Defense Exhibit 1, you received a Grand Jury
20 investigation target letter, correct?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Well, we have it right here. I'm familiar
23 with it. I know you got the letter and I know that,
24 you know, the substance of it you're not going to tell
25 me about. But this letter is dated August 31st, 2007,
1 the search warrant was executed on his home back in
2 October of 2005. So during those two years leading up
3 to this target letter who did you talk to?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. Did you --
6 MR. ROSS: And privilege. Attorney -client
7 privilege.
8 Q. Okay. In addition to your attorney did you
9 talk to anybody else about the criminal investigation?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. And Bruce Lyons was your initial computer --
12 computer -- was your initial attorney in this case,
13 correct?
14 MR. ROSS: You can answer yes or no.
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. Okay. And that was an attorney that was hired
17 for you by Jeffrey Epstein?
18 MR. ROSS: Invoke.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Someone that was paid for by Jeffrey Epstein
21 to represent you?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. So once he hired you a criminal attorney then
25 it seemed like you did something wrong?
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. You hadn't actually gone into any relationship
4 with Jeffrey Epstein with the intent to commit crimes,
5 did you?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. You didn't know that he was a child molester
8 when you first met him, did you?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Were you impressed by his money and his
12 lifestyle?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. Did you think that he could get you further in
15 life if you would just listen to what he said?
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 Q. At this point in time you have no contact with
19 him as a child molester, do you?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein assist in getting you a
23 visa?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 Q. Has he done any favors for your family?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 Q. Is he paying for your college?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 Q. Right now is he paying for your college?
8 MR. ROSS: Invoke.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein ever talk to you about the
12 chances of him going to prison?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein ever talk to you about
16 what he intended his defenses to be to the criminal
17 actions he committed against these underage minors?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 Q. Did he tell you that he would spend as much
21 money as possible to intimidate and harass these
22 underage minor victims?
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 Q. Did he tell you that he would destroy their
1 credibility?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Did he tell you that he could scare them to go
4 away?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 MR. PIKE: Form and form to the last question.
7 MR. EDWARDS: All right. Let's see, what did
8 I say, I said this was --
9 MR. ROSS: 1.
10 MR. EDWARDS: -- Plaintiff's 1 and we're going
11 to write on the back of it and then -- okay.
12 Q. Jeffrey Epstein kept message pads near all of
13 his phones in his home, right?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. And those are message pads that have a carbon
17 copy back side to them, you're familiar with them?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. And this is for anybody who takes a message
21 they write it down that somebody called, the reason for
22 calling, the time that they called?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. And many a times anytime that Jeffrey Epstein
1 was in town there were at least two scheduled
2 "massages" for lack of a better word, with Jeffrey
3 Epstein and these underage minor females, correct?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 Q. And do you have the -- and there was a
7 particular scheduling book that contained these
8 appointments with -- between Jeffrey Epstein and
9 underage minor females, correct?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. And it was your primary responsibility to
13 assist in setting these appointments up,
14 right?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 Q. It took at least two or three full-time
18 employees to keep up with Jeffrey Epstein's addiction
19 to underage minors, correct?
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 Q. did pretty much the same thing up
23 in New York, right?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. And you're familiar that there is this group
2 of girls in New York that were summoned to his home for
3 generally the exact same thing as the Palm Beach girls?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. All right.
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 Q. I'm going to show you an exhibit here, we'll
8 mark it as -- you know what, it's a bunch of message
9 pads, I'm going to mark it as 2A, -B, -C, -D, whatever.
10 So we'll say 2A.
11 (Whereupon, Plaintiff's Exhibit 2A through 2H
12 were marked for identification.)
13 Q. Do you recognize it?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Okay.
16 MR. PIKE: May I see that?
17 MR. EDWARDS: Sure.
18 Q. Do you recognize the handwriting on it?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. It indicates " hasn't confirmed
21 for 11 yet, so she is keeping on hold in case
22 doesn't call back."
23 What does that message mean?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 Q. an underage minor female that Jeffrey
2 Epstein was going to molest at 11:00, correct?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. And if wasn't available then you had
6 another underage minor female named that could
7 step in her place and fulfill that role for Jeffrey
8 Epstein, correct?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. All right. 2B is another message pad and I'm
12 going to -- we'll stop skipping the process of moving
13 this on and I'm assuming you're not going to be able to
14 answer as to whether or not you -- you recognize that
15 either, right?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. Okay. This is a message from 9/4/05, so
18 September 4th, 2005, 7:25 p.m. saying "-
19 cancelled . She would like to speak to you I
20 believe about college," and a telephone number. And
21 then a question from you, "Should I schedule anyone
22 else?" What did that message mean?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. That another typical ploy of Mr. Epstein's,
1 that he would promise these girls something in order to
2 get them to allow him to sexually abuse them?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. Because he certainly did not want them to tell
6 the police, correct?
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. And did you have many meetings about what to
9 do if any of these girls told the police?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 Q. Was it always known that Jeffrey Epstein would
13 hire everyone attorneys and tell everyone just not to
14 talk?
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. And at the same time then he could employ a
18 bunch of investigators, dig up a bunch of dirt on these
19 girls, and intimidate them and scare them to go away,
20 correct?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. And Jeffrey Epstein doesn't like -- he didn't
24 like any of these underage minor females, right?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. In fact, it was the opposite, he liked to hurt
3 them; isn't that true?
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. And after they came forward if they told the
7 truth he was dead set on hurting them even more,
8 correct?
21 Can you tell us what that message means?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. It's another underage minor female that
25 Jeffrey Epstein's going to molest at 4 p.m., correct?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. And when I say "molest", you know, he may say
3 "massage", I mean, that's -- that's something
4 interchangeable, right?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. It's the routine that I described in detail
8 that is identical with every single girl every single
9 time, correct?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. And it's basically as far as he can get with
12 this underage minor female without her crying or
13 screaming or running out of the house?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Did you ever see any of the girls cry or
17 scream or run out of the house?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Did you have a personal relationship with any
21 of these underage minor females?
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. There's another message here from 9/10/05,
24 same day later in the day, 10 p.m. saying " will
25 be at 11. Do you want me to cancel ri
1 Do you know what that message means?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. What is this?
5 There's another message from 9/11/05 saying "I
6 got a car for," and then the name is blotted out. The
7 State Attorney's Office blotted the names of minors out
8 sometimes in their file. So do you -- do you know --
9 can you fill in that blank?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Do you know if this was the car that he rented
12 for Jane Doe 4?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. All right. Or the car that he rented for AH?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 Q. You're familiar with both of those people,
18 right?
19 A. I refuse to answer.

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And that's also a feeling that Ghislaine
Maxwell shared as well, correct?

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And that's something that she also told you,
"Don't worry. If we get caught we have it covered and
we'll just attack these little girls."

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. All right. There's another message from
9/10/05. n says Lauren confirmed for 4 p.m."
8 9
a 9
Q.
Jeffrey
A.
4.
message
In fact,
Epstein's
I refuse

MR. PIKE
9/3/2005
for
AH was somebody that was over at
house many times, correct?
to answer.
Form.
. Message from saying "I left
to confirm for 11 a.m. and
for 4:30 p.m."
Do you remember leaving that message?

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And this is --
MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. It's his typical schedule where he schedules
one underage minor female to molest in the morning and
one in the afternoon, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. I mean, considering this is -- have you ever
worked anywhere else where there is somebody sexually
molesting underage minor females on a daily basis like
this?
A.
Q.
parents
A.
4.
and say
A.
Q.
A.

MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
At some point in time did you tell your
that this was happening?
MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
Did you ever talk to anybody else in the house
"Hey, look, this is not right"?
I refuse to answer.
Do you feel sorry for these girls?
I refuse to answer.

Q. And you say you do or you do not remember AH?
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Okay. And do you know what happened up in the
bedroom between AH as a minor and Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Well, this is what she tells police: "She
arrived at the house, went upstairs to the bedroom.
She advised she immediately removed her clothing and
and Epstein were already naked in the
bedroom. AH explained that and she
had a sexual encounter that included kissing, touching,
and oral sex. AH remembered that she climaxed and was
removing herself from the massage table. Epstein then
turned AH onto her stomach on the massage table and
inserted his penis into her vagina. AH stated Epstein
began to pump his penis in her vagina. AH became upset
over this. She said her head was being held forcibly
against the bed as he continued to pump inside her.
She screamed 'No,' and Epstein stopped. He would
normally pay her $200, but for this he apologized and
paid her a thousand dollars for that visit."
Are you familiar with that encounter?

A. I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. Do you remember a time when AH as a
16-year -old I believe at this time left her house
left the house visibly upset?
MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. She advised that she was ripped and torn in
7 her vagina area and had difficulty walking to the car;
8 do you remember that?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. These message pads were message pads that were
12 taken from trash pulls outside of Jeffrey Epstein's
13 home and for the most -- well, there's so many messages
14 here, but most of them are by somebody other than
15 yourself. So my question is who are the other people
16 that would take messages for Jeffrey Epstein for
17 underage minor females to come to the house?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. And the messages include CL, "Can I come work
21 today?"
22 What does "work" mean?
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 Q. That means come to your house and get paid for
1 Jeffrey Epstein sexually molesting this person while
2 she was underage; is that correct?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 Q. And it was also pretty frequent that the girls
6 would come in tandem, isn't that true, two at a time?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. And one being the girl that would bring the
10 new girl there, would wait downstairs while the new
11 girl was upstairs getting molested but then getting
12 paid?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. How did Jeffrey Epstein explain himself to you
16 as to why he did this?
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. Do you know when it is that he first became
20 sexually obsessed with underage minor females?
21 MR. PIKE: Asked and answered.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 Q. Did you know that he was a school teacher at
25 the Dalton School?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. And at that point in time -- well, are you
3 aware of him molesting underage minors while he was a
4 teacher there?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. There's another note that's not a message pad
7 which I guess I will -- since it has your name on it I
8 will mark it as what are we on -- 3 -- wait, C
9 MR. ROSS: 3.
10 MR. EDWARDS: I messed up.
11 MR. ROSS: 3.
12 (Whereupon, Plaintiff's Exhibit 3 was marked
13 for identification.)
14 Q. Look at that while I fix what I've messed up
15 over here.
16 MR. ROSS: I'm going to show this to the
17 witness.
18 MR. EDWARDS: Yes. Yes.
19 Q. Do you recognize that document?
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. There are a lot of different things on here
22 that don't necessarily relate to you. At least I can't
23 tell that they do. But it does indicate "-
24 parents are going to the embassy on the 23rd."
25 Do you remember when that happened?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. Why did your parents go to the embassy?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. More importantly why was Mr. Epstein concerned
5 that your parents were going to the Embassy?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. Was -- at that point in time was Mr. Epstein
9 assisting your parents with anything?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Are your parents citizens of the United
12 States?
13 MR. ROSS: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Are you?
16 A. No.
17 Q. Has Mr. Epstein ever offered to get you a visa
18 for the United States?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 Q. Do you know Raer Roshan?
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. That was Jeffrey Epstein's partner in
24 RadarOnline, correct?
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. And if I showed you every single message pad
2 here would you be able to answer any of the questions
3 about any of the messages that were left at Jeffrey
4 Epstein's house?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 MR. EDWARDS: Okay. That saves us a lot of
7 time.
8 MR. ROSS: It did.
9 Q. Have you ever met Bill Clinton?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Is Bill Clinton -- was Bill Clinton a friend
12 of Jeffrey Epstein's?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. Is Bill Clinton somebody who Jeffrey Epstein
15 has ever procured underage minor females for?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 Q. And just -- and just for, you know, the sake
19 of what the evidence shows, there's no evidence that I
20 have that indicates that that happened, but if you were
21 going to answer that question I'm willing to ask it.
22 Have you met him at Jeffrey Epstein's house in
23 Palm Beach County?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. You have flown on Jeffrey Epstein's airplanes
2 numerous times, correct?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. As well has Bill Clinton and you're aware of
5 that, right?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. Have you ever seen the flight logs from
9 Jeffrey Epstein's airplanes?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. And on many times it is Bill Clinton, Secret
13 Service agents, Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell,
14 , and others. Have you -- do you know
15 about those flights?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 Q. And have you ever witnessed sex on any of
19 Jeffrey Epstein's flights?
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 Q. Do you know Emmy Taylor?
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. Is that somebody that is Ghislaine Maxwell's
25 sex slave?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. And isn't it typical for Jeffrey Epstein to
3 have a sex slave that flies with him on the airplane?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 Q. And one of the qualifications is that the
7 section slave be underage, correct?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. And if the sex slave is 15 years old isn't it
11 your understanding and based on your observations that
12 he will even make them dress as if they're 11 or 12?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 Q. Do you know President Andres Pastrana?
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 Q. Do you know him as somebody who has had sex
19 with underage minor females brought to him by Jeffrey
20 Epstein?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Have you ever heard of Ehud Burak?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 Q. Is that another person that Epstein -- Jeffrey
2 Epstein procures underage minor females for?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. You've met Naomi Campbell I'm assuming?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Anytime separate and apart from any dealings
8 with Jeffrey Epstein have you met her in the modeling
9 industry? That's a model, right?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 MR. ROSS: You can answer the question.
12 A. No, I have not.
13 Q. Okay. Do you know Todd Meister?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. Joel Pashcow?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. You've been to their houses?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. Do you know Aline Weber?
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. Have you ever stayed at the 301 East 66th
22 Street places with Aline Weber?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. And typically aren't there at least 16
1 underage minor females staying at those various
2 condominiums located at 301 East 66th Street?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. And those females get work visas to say that
5 they're models, but actually they are prostituted out
6 by Jeffrey Epstein and John Luc Brunel, correct?
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 Q. And various businessmen and politicians around
10 New York and Washington, D.C. go to those apartments
11 frequently to have sex with underage minors; is that
12 true?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. Do you remember a flight on December 3rd, 2004
15 that you took with Jeffrey Epstein,
16 , and somebody with initials SH
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 Q. -- from JFK to PBI?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 Q. Do you remember that?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Who is SH?
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. Is that an underage minor?
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. Do you remember a flight that you took
2 December 27th with and Jeffrey
3 Epstein?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. What airport is this, TIST?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Do you know Doug Band?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. Isn't that Bill Clinton's assistant?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. You've been on the airplane with him before?
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. Have you been on the airplane with Bill
14 Clinton before?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Who is ?
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 Q. That's somebody you've flown with on Jeffrey
19 Epstein's plane on numerous occasions, correct?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. In fact, during the year 2005 you flew on
Jeffrey Epstein's plane would you say more than 50
times?

A. I refuse to answer.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Jeffrey
MR. PIKE: Form.
And you flew to his
I refuse to answer.

MR. PIKE: Form.
You flew to New Mexico?
I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
You flew to New Jersey?
MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
Several of the flights
Epstein, and
those flights?

MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
Who's Adam Perrylang?
I refuse to answer.
Is that somebody that
with?
A.
Q.
with any
A.
Q.
sex
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
island, right?
are just yourself,
. What did you do on
you were made to have
I refuse to answer.
Did Jeffrey Epstein ever make you have sex
females?

MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
Did he ever make you have sex with any of his
friends?
MR. PIKE: Form.

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Who is Sandy Berger?
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. That's somebody else that was affiliated with
7 Bill Clinton at one point in time, correct?
8 A. I refuse to answer.

Q. A close friend of Jeffrey Epstein's?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. He called the house within three weeks of the
search warrant being executed. Did he tip off Jeffrey
Epstein?
A.
Q.
minors?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.

Q. Have you flown on the airplane with Alan
Dershowitz before?
MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
Is he somebody that's involved with underage
I refuse to answer.
Do you know Igor Zinoviev?
I refuse to answer.
Andrea Metrovich?
I refuse to answer.
A.
Q.
been on
A.
Q.

MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
And Jean Luc Brunel is somebody who you have
the airplane with several times, correct?
I refuse to answer.

MR. PIKE: Form.
And when Jean Luc Brunel is on this airplane
8 there are underage minor -- minor females on the
airplane with you, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Is there a back room to this airplane? Is
there any sort of separation or is it all one big room?

MR. PIKE: Form.
I refuse to answer.
So if Jeffrey Epstein and Jean Luc Brunel are
in sex acts with underage minors did you --
I refuse --
Sorry -- did you observe any of those acts?
I refuse to answer.

MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. And on numerous of the flights the flight logs
indicate someone's name then oftentimes initials, but
sometimes it would just say "three females". Do you
know why?
A.
Q.
engaged
A.
Q.
A.
A.
Q.
A.

Q. Do you know Jo-Jo and Lynn Fontanella?
A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. They're the house managers up at the mansion
8 up in Manhattan, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And they assist Mr. Epstein in engaging in
underage sex with minors in New York, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. They also maintain a pretty close relationship
with the police?

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And that's a big component also, right, that
Jeffrey Epstein has -- is friendly with the law
enforcement, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Like law enforcement would do favors for not
only Jeffrey Epstein but his various assistants. If
you were speeding around the neighborhood they wouldn't
give you a ticket, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Was it ever your job to call the police
department and ask if any police reports were on file
or anybody complained about the activities at Jeffrey
7 Epstein's house?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Have you ever gone physically to the police
department?
A. I refuse to answer.

Q. Was there a flight where you flew alone with
Jean Luc
A.
Q.
Andrew?
I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Who's ?
I refuse to answer.
Brunel?
I refuse
Have you
to answer.
ever flown on the plane with Prince
MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Do you know
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. That's another model that Jeffrey Epstein
23 knows, correct?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 Q. Somebody that he had engaged in sex with when
2 she was underage?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. She actually got a modeling contract out of
5 it?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. Why does Jean Luc Brunel and Jeffrey Epstein
9 fly together so often?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. And why does Ghislaine Maxwell also fly so
13 often with Jeffrey Epstein and Jean Luc Brunel?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 Q. Isn't it true that all three of them are
17 obsessed and addicted to sex with underage minors?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 MR. PIKE: Brad, how much longer do you have?
21 MR. EDWARDS: How long? You want to take a
22 break?
23 MR. PIKE: Yeah.
24 MR. EDWARDS: Sure. It's going a lot faster
25 than I thought it would.
1 VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the record, 11:33 a.m.
2 (Recess taken at 11:33 a.m.)
3 (Deposition resumed at 11:43 a.m.)
4 VIDEOGRAPHER: On the record, 11:43 a.m.
5 BY MR. EDWARDS:
6 Q. All right. There's one more message that I
7 wanted to ask you about. As I mentioned, I'm not going
8 to go through all of the messages that I have, but
9 there's one from 9/4/2005, 9:08 a.m. from . "Is
10 it okay for to stop by and drop something?"
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 MR. PIKE: Form.
13 Q. So what were your hours working for Jeffrey
14 Epstein?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. I mean, some of these messages are 9:00 in the
17 morning and others are as late as 8:30 or 9 at night.
18 So what were your hours?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Another message from 9/4 also, same day,
21 ," I think, "confirmed an 11 a.m., is at
22 4:30 p.m."
23 MR. MERMELSTEIN: I think that's one you did.
24 MR. EDWARDS: Oh, yeah? Okay.
25 Q. All right. Do you remember that message?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 MR. EDWARDS: Do you care how I attach it
3 since it's --
4 MR. ROSS: No.
5 MR. EDWARDS: I'll attach it as whatever it
6 is.
7 MR. ROSS: 4.
8 MR. EDWARDS: 2 -- well, I'll just go 2H since
9 it's a message. You don't have a problem with
10 that? 2H?
11 MR. ROSS: Whatever.
12 (Whereupon, Plaintiff's Exhibit 2H was marked
13 for identification.)
14 Q. Do you still consider Jeffrey Epstein a
15 friend?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 Q. Did you ever think of Jeffrey Epstein as a
19 friend?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Other than the people that I've mentioned
23 of -- you know, President Pastrana and Ehud Burak and
24 Prince Andrew did you meet any other people of royalty
25 being friends with Jeffrey Epstein?
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Can you tell us any of the other folks that
4 Jeffrey Epstein would supply underage minor girls to?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Do you know a man by the name of Glenn Dubin?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. Do you know his wife?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. His wife at some point in time was associated
12 with Jeffrey Epstein; is that correct?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. And her name's Eva Dubin; is that right?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Do you know ?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Is that somebody who also worked for Jeffrey
23 Epstein?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein ever get a legitimate
2 massage from somebody that's a masseuse?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. The underage females that we've talked about
6 particularly, LM, EW, and Jane Doe, those girls were
7 not prostitutes, were they?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. These were just girls who were in 8th, 9th,
10 10th grade in high school, right?
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. These were girls that you knew had never
13 committed prostitution in the past, right?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. And that goes for all of these girls on the
16 phone list of underage minors to call, these were not
17 prostitutes, correct?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. You never called a prostitution or escort
20 service for Jeffrey Epstein, did you?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. And as well you never called a legitimate
24 massage parlor for Jeffrey Epstein, correct?
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 Q. He devised this scheme of having underage
3 minor girls bring him other underage minor girls so
4 that he could gain access to his target age group, 12
5 to 16 years old, correct?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Have you heard Jeffrey Epstein say "The
8 younger the better?"
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. And did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that it made
11 him happy the younger the girl was?
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 Q. The less developed the girl is the more
15 excited Jeffrey Epstein gets; is that true?
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 Q. Do you ever plan to talk to Jeffrey Epstein in
19 the future?
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 Q. Would you ever work for him again?
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. Why didn't you stop working for him sooner?
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 Q. Did you -- well, you knew that it was illegal
3 what he was doing at the time you were doing it,
4 correct?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. Did you know that you were part of a large
7 child molestation ring?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. Did you ever tell anyone while you were
11 working for him that you wanted to stop?
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 Q. Did you continue working there because you
15 were just scared to stop?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 Q. Were you in fear of what Ghislaine Maxwell or
19 Jeffrey Epstein might do to you if you quit performing
20 your services for his child molestation ring?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein ever threaten you?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
a
a 9

Q. Did Ghislaine Maxwell ever threaten you?
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. How was it decided who would call which girl?

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And by that, just so it's clear, like I said,
there's going to be many, many, many message pads, I
have not counted them, but a lot created by either
yourself or someone named Janusz Banaziak or
, Alfredo Rodriguez, ,
, various people that we know to have been
employed at Jeffrey Epstein's home. And it seems that
on one particular day may call several girls, you
may call several girls, may call several girls.
Who is directing which -- which of you, which of the
assistants is going to call the underage minor to give
them an appointment?

A. I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. And what would happen on the occasions where
Jeffrey Epstein says he's going to be in town and then
he's ultimately not in town but a girl shows up anyway?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Weren't you just told just to pay her to keep
her happy?
A. I refuse to answer.

Q. And isn't part of the whole scheme that these
girls were typically told "Don't tell anybody what goes
on inside this house," right?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that because
these girls are young and they're poor and they're
underprivileged type girls they're likely not going to
say anything anyway? Isn't that what he told you?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Did Ghislaine Maxwell talk to you about that
as well?
A. I refuse to answer.

MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. Have you seen Jeffrey Epstein angry?
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Isn't it true that he's very nice and engaging
as long as he gets his way and gets you to cooperate,
right?

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. But if he doesn't get his way he gets very,
very angry and mad and scary; isn't that true?

A. I refuse to answer.
Q. And you've seen both sides of him, right?
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. In fact, you know of girls who were 13 years
old and cooperated with everything he said because they
felt they had no choice up in that bedroom, right?
A. I refuse to answer.
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 Q. And you also know girls who resisted and were
9 yelled at and told to grab their money and get out of
10 there, right?
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. Wouldn't you agree that that house upstairs
13 can be somewhat confusing in how it's -- how it's laid
14 out?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. In fact, there's a stairwell that starts from
17 the kitchen, there's a door and it almost blends in in
18 the kitchen with the other closets, correct?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 Q. But you open that door and there's a stairway
22 that twists it seems to the left and there's another
23 door at the top of that stairway, right?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. And then when you exit that stairway you take
1 a right and you head towards a little hallway that
2 eventually leads into Mr. Epstein's bedroom, right?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. And if it's your first time in that bedroom as
5 a 14-year -old girl and you don't like what's happened
6 up there would you agree that it's a tough way to find
7 your -- a place to find your way out of?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. Did Jeffrey -- didn't Jeffrey Epstein tell you
11 that he would act as a father -type figure to these
12 girls?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 Q. And he would propose that what they are doing
16 for him or with him despite the law is okay?
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 Q. And they could continue to make a lot of money
20 if they would come over and be his sex victims, right?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. And you were aware when my client, LM, was
24 pregnant at 16 years old that Jeffrey Epstein bought
25 everything on her baby registry, right?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 Q. Was it you or that took all of
4 the gifts over to her home?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. I believe it was in a -- did
8 Jeffrey Epstein own a Mercedes?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. And do you remember when loaded
12 up the Mercedes with all the baby gifts and took it to
13 my client's trailer?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. And that was so that while LM -- that was to
16 thank her while she was pregnant she continued to bring
17 him 13-, 14-, and 15-year -old girls to molest, correct?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Because LM would no longer qualify as somebody
21 he'd be sexually interacting with as she was pregnant,
22 correct?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. Because the only real disqualifications for
1 interacting sexually with Mr. Epstein are if you have
2 tattoos, right?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. If you're African -American or black?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. You've never known him to interact with an
7 African -American or black girl, have you?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. If you've been pregnant?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. Or if you are pregnant, correct?
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. But certainly he was not above having a
14 pregnant 16-year -old girl bringing him underage minor
15 females, correct?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. In fact --
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 Q. -- it was his belief that he was doing her a
20 favor in that he was giving her money for providing a
21 service, correct?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. Is it Jeffrey Epstein's belief that he did
25 these girls a favor?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. I mean, doesn't he think that these girls are
3 lucky that he ever -- that they ever -- that he ever
4 allowed them out of their trailer and into his mansion,
5 correct?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 Q. We've defined the molestation statute or at
9 least I read it to you earlier and now we've talked
10 about this scheme of Jeffrey Epstein gaining access to
11 this number of underage minor females. At the time
12 when you were working for him did you recognize him as
13 a serial child molester?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Do you know of anybody that ever worked for
17 him that quit working for him because of what he was
18 doing?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 Q. Do you know Michael Friedman?
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Is that somebody you ever met there?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. What countries does Jeffrey Epstein typically
1 bring underage minor females from?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Do you know why he chooses the countries that
4 he chooses to import underage minor females from?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 Q. Was -- do you know how old
was when she came to this country?
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. Have you had conversations with
about Jeffrey Epstein bringing her to this
12 country?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. She's been described by some as his
15 Yugoslavian lesbian sex slave. Is that something that
16 is an accurate description based on the observations
17 you have?
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 Q. Did you ever engage in any lesbian sex with
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Has ever had sex with Jeffrey
24 Epstein?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. Do you know how it is that met
3 Jeffrey Epstein?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. Do you know Story Cowles?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. You know who Sergio Cordero is?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. Well, that's somebody who also assists
10 Mr. Epstein in bringing him underage minor females for
11 sex, correct?
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 Q. And Khalid Monroe, you know who that is?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Also somebody that through MC Squared or some
17 affiliation with that modeling agency would help for
18 Jeffrey Epstein to gain access to underage minor
19 females for sex, correct?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. And do you know of trips that Mr. Cordero,
23 Mr. Brunel, and Mr. Epstein took to Brazil specifically
24 for the purposes of Mr. Epstein engaging in sex with
25 12-year -old girls?
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Are you -- you are aware that Jeffrey Epstein
4 pled guilty to two felonies related to his sexual
5 interactions, correct?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Okay.
8 VIDEOGRAPHER: Excuse me, counsel.
9 MR. ROSS: I object on privilege grounds --
10 attorney -client privilege grounds.
11 MR. EDWARDS: Okay, fine. I was trying to get
12 into an area we may get answers.
13 VIDEOGRAPHER: Could I just get you to put
14 your phone on the table? I'm starting to get
15 interference.
16 MR. ROSS: The phone?
17 VIDEOGRAPHER: Yes, sir.
18 MR. EDWARDS: You got a secret phone?
19 VIDEOGRAPHER: It's anytime it receives any
20 kind of information.
21 MR. ROSS: Oh, okay, yeah, it's --
22 VIDEOGRAPHER: It's not that it's ringing.
23 MR. ROSS: Right. It's not doing it now.
24 VIDEOGRAPHER: I apologize for the
25 interruption.
1 Q. All right. I ask you that question because
2 there was also something called a non-prosecution
3 agreement. Are you familiar with that document?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 MR. ROSS: Attorney -client privilege.
6 Q. And that is also a document that included your
7 name as a co-conspirator; are you familiar with that?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 MR. ROSS: Attorney -client privilege.
10 Q. And that is because of your involvement with
11 calling on the telephone underage minors to bring them
12 to Jeffrey Epstein's house, correct?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. Or for your involvement in scheduling
15 appointments in Jeffrey Epstein's appointment book for
16 underage minor -- underage minor females to be involved
17 with Jeffrey Epstein sexually, correct?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. It is certainly not because you sought out
21 this child molestation ring in hopes of rising to the
22 top, correct?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. Didn't you do everything that you did that
1 anybody could ever say is illegal at the direction of
2 Jeffrey Epstein?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. And if it wasn't at the direction of Jeffrey
5 Epstein it was at the direction of Ghislaine Maxwell or
6 , correct?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. I mean, those things were not things that you
10 would have done but for being under the supervision of
11 Jeffrey Epstein; isn't that right?
12 MR. PIKE: Form.
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. And you continued to do these things either
15 out of fear or because you were just impressed with
16 Jeffrey Epstein's lifestyle?
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 Q. Aren't you angry for him involving you in this
19 criminal activity?
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 Q. Do you ever intend in the future to talk about
23 what he did and what he involved you in?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. Wouldn't you like to separate yourself being
2 the person that you are from this person who brought
3 you into this mess?
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. Is Jeffrey Epstein paying for your attorney
7 now?
16 Q.
17 Jeffrey
1 you know?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 Q. Since being on house arrest has Jeffrey
5 Epstein continued to engage in sex with underage minor
6 females?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. Knowing that his habit was more than -- was at
10 least two underage minor females for sex every single
11 day do you believe that he stopped?
12 MR. PIKE: Form.
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. Isn't it your belief that he will continue to
15 do that once all of these cases are over?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 Q. Isn't it true that Jeffrey Epstein believes
19 that he is entitled to have sex with whomever he wants
20 including 12-, 13-, 14-year -old girls?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Do you know whether he continues -- do you
24 know whether he intends to continue to molest underage
25 minors within the United States?
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Do you know Mike Sanka?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. That's somebody else that assisted Jeffrey
6 Epstein in gaining access to underage minor females
7 that were foreigners, correct?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 Q. He's also involved in the modeling agency,
11 too, correct?
12 MR. PIKE: Form.
13 A. I refuse to answer.

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
MR. ROSS: Well, actually you can answer.
A. No, my parents help me.

Q. Are you aware of Jeffrey Epstein's closest
friends now?
A. I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Who are the people that you believe are
Epstein's enemies?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Did you ever find out that Jeffrey Epstein and
Ghislaine Maxwell had been targeting and preying upon
underage females for sex for more than a decade?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Who is Jeffrey Epstein's girlfriend now, if
14 Q. That's a friend of or former friend of Jean
15 Luc Brunel's?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. How many times has Jean Luc Brunel shown up at
18 Jeffrey Epstein's house with underage minor females?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. And when that would happen isn't it true that
22 they would have orgies with these underage minor
23 females?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. What was done -- or let me ask it a different
2 way. Strike that.
3 Where is the scheduling book for the massage
4 appointments for Jeffrey Epstein?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Is that something else that was removed from
8 the home prior to the search warrant being executed?
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 Q. Do you know how it is that -- well, did
12 Jeffrey Epstein ever tell you that because of the
13 people he knew he would not be going to prison for the
14 crimes that he committed?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 Q. And is it your understanding that Ken Starr
18 had played a major role in devising the non-prosecution
19 agreement or having the government agree not to
20 prosecute Jeffrey Epstein for his crimes against
21 minors?
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 Q. Is it also your understanding that Bill
25 Clinton played somewhat of a role in helping Jeffrey
1 Epstein out of the trouble that he would have been in
2 related to his sexual interactions with minor females?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that you need to
6 cooperate if you want the protection that me and my
7 connections can give you for this activity?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. You admit that you called LM on the telephone
11 for her to come to Jeffrey Epstein's house to be
12 molested by Jeffrey Epstein when she was an underage
13 female?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 MR. PIKE: Form. Asked and answered twice.
16 Q. Do you agree that you called EW on the
17 telephone for the purposes of her coming to Jeffrey
18 Epstein's house for him to sexually molest her?
19 MR. PIKE: Same objection.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. And do you agree that you called Jane Doe and
22 told her to come to your house to work, meaning for
23 Jeffrey Epstein to sexually molest her?
24 MR. PIKE: Asked and answered.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. The first trial that is set in these cases is
2 in July of this year. Do you intend to be in the local
3 area?
13 n presume a i needed to find you or
14 locate you or anything else I could go through your
15 attorney?
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. Okay. Who do you live at that address with?
18 MR. ROSS: You can answer.
19 A. With my husband and my mom-in-law and his
20 sister as well.
21 Q.
22 A.
23 Q.
24 A.
25 Q. And who else lives at the house with you, I'm
1 sorry?
2 A.
3 Q.
4 A.
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. Have you told your parents?
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. Are your parents in the country now?
11 MR. ROSS: You can answer.
12 A. No.
13 Q. Do they have plans to come back?
14 MR. ROSS: You can answer.
15 A. They may visit, I'm not sure.
16 Q. But on a permanent basis they're in Poland?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. Okay. What's the address where they are in
19 Poland?
20 A.
21 Q. She's great. I'm sure she got that.
22 A. Would you like me to spell it out?
25 MR. EDWARDS: One way to never find a witness
1 is just move to Poland. There's no way.
2 MR. ROSS: Couldn't get anyone to type the
3 subpoena.
4 MR. EDWARDS: Right, exactly. All right. I
5 don't have any other questions for you. Thank you.
6 THE WITNESS: Thank you.
7 CROSS-EXAMINATION
8 BY MR. MERMELSTEIN:
9 Q. Okay. Mrs. Ross, I have some questions for
A.
4.

MR. ROSS:
Yes.
Okay. And what address will you be at?
MR. ROSS: You can answer.
You can answer.
you. Your husband, what does he do for a
living?

A. He's a Ph.D. student.
Q. And what is he a Ph.D. in?
A. He works on bone marrow transplant immunology.

Q. So is he a medical doctor?
A. He's scientist. He's working on his Ph.D.
degree.
Q. And which school is he working on his Ph.D.
at?

A. University of Miami.
Q. And how long has he been doing that?
A. I cannot recall when he started but we were
already married. Maybe one or two years into my
marriage. I do not recall the exact time.

Q. And I believe you testified that you met him
in Europe, correct?
A. Correct.
Q. And did he have a different employment or
profession then?

A. Yes.
Q. What was he doing then?
7 A. Well, at that time he was serving in the
entertainment business. He was DJing and -- yeah.
When I met him he came to Europe for a DJ event. DJing
event.

Q. And where was that in Europe?
A. He went to Spain and then I was in Monaco at
the time and he knew the people that I was there with
and we were introduced. That's where we met.

Q. And did he have connections to modeling in the
United States?
A. Yes.
Q. And how did he have those connections?

A. I'm -- you know, I'm not sure. I don't know
at this time, but he knew agencies here and he was
doing, I believe, some photographic work as well
himself.

Q. So he was a DJ and a professional
photograph -- photographer?
A. Yes. You may say so, yes.
Q. And a scientist as well?
A.
Q.
agencies
A.
Yes.
Did he do work for particular modeling
in the United States?
I mean, do you -- I don't understand your
question. Do you mean like --
7 Q. Well, did he perform work or services for
8 particular modeling agencies in the United States?
9 A. Well, I believe he would hire models from
10 modeling agencies, yes.
11 Q. He would hire models?
12 A. Yes, for -- you know, that's how -- how it
13 works. You hire a model from a modeling agency for a
14 particular job, a client that you may have.
15 Q. So as a photographer he would hire models for
16 a particular modeling agency?
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. And do you know which modeling agencies he
20 typically worked with?
21 A. Well, I presume Elite Models because, you
22 know, he had connection and he invited me. I think
23 just various Miami Beach -- you know, Miami, South
24 Beach modeling agencies.
25 Q. Did he work for MC Squared?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. In 2004 and 2005 you were employed by Jeffrey
3 Epstein, correct?
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 Q. And as an employee of Jeffrey Epstein you were
7 under his instruction and supervision, correct?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 MR. PIKE: Let's go off the record for a
11 second.
12 MR. MERMELSTEIN: Sure.
13 VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the record at 12:12 p.m.
14 (Discussion off the record.)
15 MR. MERMELSTEIN: I'll be brief on the general
16 questions.
17 VIDEOGRAPHER: On the record, 12:14 p.m.
18 BY MR. MERMELSTEIN:
19 Q. And as an employee of Jeffrey Epstein were you
20 also subject to the -- to the instructions and
21 supervision of Ghislaine Maxwell?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A. I refuse to answer.
24 Q. And as an employee of Jeffrey Epstein did you
25 work under the supervision and instruction of his
1 primary assistant
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. Okay. Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that --
5 that he recruited from western Palm Beach County
6 underage girls to come to his Palm Beach mansion for
7 sexual activity?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. And did Jeffrey Epstein have a computer
11 database at his Palm Beach mansion where he listed
12 underage high school girls in Palm Beach County and
13 their contact information so that he could have these
14 underage minors come to his house for sexual activity?
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. And did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that the
18 reason he brought in underage minors from western Palm
19 Beach County is because he anticipated they would be
20 impressed, in awe, and intimidated by his wealth?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. And as young girls who were impressed and in
24 awe and intimidated of his wealth they would do what he
25 asked them to do?
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. And as young underage girls who were
4 impressed, intimidated, and in awe of his wealth they
5 would be unlikely to -- to complain to authorities that
1 Epstein a massage?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. When Jane Doe 7 -- let me strike that.
5 Do you know Jane Doe 7?
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. When Jane Doe 7 was a minor female did you
8 call Jane Doe 7 to schedule appointments for her to
9 come to the Epstein house in Palm Beach to give Epstein
10 a massage?
11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. When Jane Doe 7 was a minor female did you
14 receive calls from Jane Doe 7 while you were at the
15 Epstein house for her to come to the house by
16 appointment and give Jeffrey Epstein a massage?
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 A. I refuse to answer.
19 Q. The computer database that Jeffrey Epstein
20 maintained girls from western Palm Beach County who
21 would come to the house in Palm Beach to give Epstein a
22 massage, did that computer database include the name
23 and contact information for Jane Doe 2?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
1 Q. Do you know who Jane Doe 2 is?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Do you know who Jane Doe 5 is?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. Did the computer database that Epstein
6 maintained on his computers in his home have the name
7 and contact information for Jane Doe 5 so that Epstein
8 could contact her for -- for massages in his Palm Beach
9 home?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. Do you know the name Jane Doe 6?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. Did the computer database that Epstein
15 maintained in his home of underage girls who he would
16 have come over for massages and sexual activity did
he was engaging in sexual activity with them?

A. I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Q. Okay. Did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you to
call girls on the telephone to schedule appointments
for them to come to his Palm Beach house for massages
which were, in fact, to be sexual activity?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Prior to May 2005 did you call Jane Doe 4 to
schedule appointments for her to come to the Epstein
house to engage in -- to give Jeffrey Epstein a massage
which would, in fact, be sexual activity with Jeffrey
Epstein?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A. I refuse to answer.
Q. Okay. Prior to May 2005 while you were at the
Epstein house in Palm Beach did you receive calls from
Jane Doe 4 regarding the scheduling of an appointment
for her to come to the Epstein house to give Jeffrey
17 that computer database include the name and contact
18 information for Jane Doe 6?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Do you know the name Jane Doe 3?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Did the computer database that Jeffrey Epstein
23 maintained in his home include the name and contact
24 information of Jane Doe 3 so that he could contact Jane
25 Doe 3 to come to his Palm Beach home and give him a
1 massage which would become sexual activity?
2 A. I refuse to answer.
3 Q. Did the computer database that Jeffrey Epstein
4 maintained in his home include the name Jane Doe 4?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q. Do you know Jane Doe 4?
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. Did the -- did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that
10 he maintained the contact information for Jane Doe 4 in
11 his computer database in his home so that he could
12 contact her to come to his Palm Beach mansion for
13 massages?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Did you know for a fact that the computer
17 database included the name Jane Doe 4 so that Jeffrey
18 Epstein could contact her and she would come to the
19 Palm Beach mansion to give Jeffrey Epstein a massage?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. Did you know that the computer database that
23 Jeffrey Epstein maintained his home contained the name
24 and contact information of Jane Doe 7 --
25 A. I refuse -- sorry.
1 Q. I'm sorry -- so he would contact Jane Doe 7
2 and have her come to his house to give him a massage?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 Q. Are you aware that the computer database that
5 Jeffrey Epstein maintained in his home contained the
6 name Jane Doe 8 so that he could contact Jane Doe 8 and
7 have him come to the house in Palm Beach for purposes
8 of giving him a massage?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 Q. You removed three computers from the Palm
12 Beach house with another gentleman prior to the search
13 warrant being issued by the Palm Beach police; isn't
14 that correct?
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 MR. PIKE: Form. Asked and answered.
17 Q. And Jeffrey Epstein instructed you to remove
18 those computers; is that correct?
19 MR. PIKE: Form, asked and answered.
20 A. I refuse to answer.
21 Q. And Jeffrey Epstein told you that the reason
22 he was instructing you to remove the computers was to
23 hide his sexual activities with underage minors from
24 the authorities?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. As an employee of Jeffrey Epstein did you know
3 Janusz Banaziak?
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 Q. Was Janusz Banaziak also an employee of
7 Jeffrey Epstein?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. When Janusz Banaziak testified that you and
11 another gentleman removed the three computers from
12 Jeffrey Epstein's home he was telling the truth,
13 correct?
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 Q. Did you observe Jeffrey Epstein persuading,
17 inducing, or enticing underage girls to engage in
18 sexual activities with him?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Did you -- strike that.
21 Did you observe Jeffrey Epstein persuading,
22 inducing, or enticing girls who came to his house for
23 the purpose of giving him a massage to engage in sexual
24 activity with him?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that he induced,
3 persuaded, or enticed underage girls to engage in
4 sexual activities with him when they came to his Palm
5 Beach mansion to give him a massage?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A. I refuse to answer.
8 Q. Would you instruct -- when you spoke to
9 underage girls to schedule appointments for massage in
10 Epstein's home would you instruct these girls to lie
11 about their ages and say they were 18 years old when
12 you knew that they were younger than 18?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you as to what to
15 say to the girls who you contacted by telephone to make
16 appointments to schedule massages in Epstein's home?
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 Q. And would Jeffrey Epstein tell you to have the
20 girls who you contacted by the telephone to make
21 appointments to come to the mansion to give Jeffrey
22 Epstein massages, that they should -- that these girls
23 should lie about their ages to Jeffrey Epstein?
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 A. I refuse to answer.
7 Q.
8 4 would
9 massage
10 A.
12 Q.

Q. Prior to May 2005 are you aware that Jeffrey
Epstein had numerous appointments with Jane Doe 4 for
her to come to the mansion to come to give him a
massage?

A. I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Prior to May 2005 are you aware that Jane Doe
come to the mansion to give Jeffrey Epstein a
on a frequent and regular basis?
I refuse to answer.
MR. PIKE: Form.
Are you aware that prior to May 2005 Jeffrey
13 Epstein engaged with -- engaged in sexual activities
14 with Jane Doe 4 at the Palm Beach mansion 50 to a
15 hundred times?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 MR. PIKE: Form.
18 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that on
19 numerous occasions he -- when Jane Doe 4 was an
20 underage minor he touched her breasts?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that on
24 numerous occasions when Jane Doe 4 was an underage
25 minor he touched and groped her buttocks?
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you on numerous
3 occasions when Jane Doe 4 was an underage minor that he
4 rubbed Jane Doe 4's vagina?
5 A. I refuse to answer.
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that on
8 occasions prior to Jane Doe 4 turning the age of 18
9 that he performed oral sex on Jane Doe 4?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A. I refuse to answer.
12 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that on
13 numerous occasions prior to Jane Doe 4 reaching the age
14 of 18 he would place a vibrator on Jane Doe 4's
15 genitals?
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that prior to
19 Jane Doe 4 becoming 18 years of age he would masturbate
20 in her presence?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 MR. PIKE: Form to the last question.
23 MR. MERMELSTEIN: Hum?
24 MR. PIKE: Form to the last question.
25 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that prior to
1 Jane Doe 7 reaching the age of 18 years old he would
2 touch her breasts?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that prior to
6 Jane Doe 7 reaching the age of 18 he would grope her --
7 grope Jane Doe 7's buttocks?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A. I refuse to answer.
10 Q. And did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that
11 prior to Jane Doe 7 reaching the age of 18 he would rub
12 Jane Doe 7's vagina?
13 A. I refuse to answer.
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 Q. Do you know who is?
16 A. I refuse to answer.
17 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you to call
on numerous occasions to recruit underage girls
19 to come to the Palm Beach Mansion to give Jeffrey
20 Epstein a massage?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you on numerous
24 occasions to contact for the purpose of
25 scheduling underage girls for appointments to come to
1 the Palm Beach mansion and give Jeffrey Epstein a
2 massage?
3 A. I refuse to answer.
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein advise you that
was his contact in western Palm Beach County
7 high schools for the purpose of recruiting underage
8 girls to come to the Palm Beach mansion where he would
9 then engage in sexual activity with them?
10 A. I refuse to answer.
11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 Q. Did instruct you on how to
13 contact underage girls for the purpose of bringing them
14 to the Palm Beach mansion for massages and what to say
15 to these young girls?
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 Q. Did train you in how to contact
19 girls and recruit them to come to the Palm Beach
20 mansion and -- and provide Jeffrey Epstein with
21 massages?
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 Q. Was one of your primary duties scheduling
25 regular appointments, at least two per day, for Jeffrey
1 Epstein to have underage girls come to the mansion to
2 give him a massage?
3 MR. PIKE: Asked and answered, form.
4 A. I refuse to answer.
5 MR. MERMELSTEIN: Okay. That's all I have.
6 MR. PIKE: I have no questions.
7 MR. EDWARDS: I only have a couple.
8 I'll go ahead and mark this as Number 4.
9 (Whereupon, Plaintiff's Exhibit 4 was marked
10 for identification.)
11 REDIRECT EXAMINATION
12 BY MR. EDWARDS:
13 Q. This photograph appears to be Jeffrey Epstein,
14 yourself, and Maer Roshan in this photograph taken from
15 an internet newspaper. Can you tell me where that
16 picture was taken?
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 MR. PIKE: May I see that, counsel?
19 Q. Was this related -- this event, was it related
20 to MC Squared?
21 A. I refuse to answer.
22 Q. All right. What is -- I know that you told us
23 that you're not employed now because you're in school.
24 What was your last employment?
25 A. I was working at the local CPA firm.
1 Q. Excuse me?
2 A. CPA firm.
3 Q. Okay. What was the name of that CPA firm?
4 A. William Owens, CPA, P.A.
5 Q. William Owens. And is that in Miami?
6 A. Correct.
7 Q. Where did you work prior to that?
8 A. I worked for maybe less than a month at a
9 clothing store.
10 Q. What clothing store?
11 A. Club Monaco.
12 Q. Where's that?
13 A. South Beach.
14 Q. Where in South Beach?
15 A. It's on Collins Avenue and I believe maybe 6th
16 and 8th, I'm not sure.
17 Q. Okay. Why'd you leave there?
18 A. The clothing store?
19 Q. Correct.
20 A. Because I got the accounting job.
21 Q. And that's what you want to be you said?
22 A. Yes, um-hum.
23 Q. Okay. And I suppose that you left the
24 accounting firm because you went to school to finish
25 your degree?
1 A. Well, I was working part-time and going to
2 school part-time and it just became too challenging.
3 The accounting program is very demanding, so I wanted
4 to dedicate myself to study.
5 Q. How long were you at this accounting firm
6 Williams Owens -- William Owens?
7 A. Maybe two and a half years about maybe.
8 Something like that.
9 Q. All right. So we're in -- when was it that
10 you left there?
11 A. May of 2009.
12 Q. Okay. May '09, so that brings us back to late
13 2006 or something when you started there?
14 A. Yes. That would be about right, yes.
15 Q. And then it was sometime earlier than that in
16 2006 when you were at the clothing store?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. And you were there for about a month?
19 A. About, yes.
20 Q. Give or take
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. -- a week or so?
23 Where -- where did you work prior to the
24 clothing store Club Monaco?
25 A. I was modeling.
1 Q. And where were you modeling?
2 A. In Miami. New York.
3 Q. For what agency?
4 A. In Miami I was with Elite Models. I was with
5 Michele Pommier --
6 Q. Who's that?
7 A. Michele Pommier Agency.
8 Q. Okay. How do you spell the last name?
9 A. P-O-M-M-I-E-R. And then --
10 Q. Okay. That was in Miami?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. And then what agency did you work through in
13 New York?
14 A. ID Models.
15 Q. Excuse me?
16 A. ID Models.
17 Q. ID?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. Just in the letter I --
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. -- letter D?
22 And who was the person that got you hooked up
23 at ID Models?
24 A. My husband had that contact.
25 Q. Okay. How long did you work with ID Models?
1 A. I'm trying to think. I do not recall exact
2 timeframe.
3 Q. All right. Well, if the clothing store was
4 sometime late 2006 are we talking about earlier in the
5 year 2006 when you were working with Elite in Miami and
6 ID Models in New York?
7 MR. ROSS: I'm going to ask you to invoke.
8 THE WITNESS: I'm sorry?
9 MR. ROSS: You should invoke with regard to
10 this timeframe you're talking about now.
11 MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
12 A. I refuse to answer.
13 Q. Okay. Can you tell me about any job that you
14 had modeling or otherwise prior to working at ID Models
15 or with Elite?
16 A. Recall -- just name any
17 Q. Any -- what was your -- what employment did
18 you have just prior to working with Elite Models and ID
19 Models?
20 A. I was working as a model in Europe. I
21 graduated from high school in 2002 and I dedicated that
22 year to modeling and so I was modeling. I did not have
23 employment.
24 Q. All right. So just so I understand you were
25 modeling in Europe, you came over here in 2002.
1 A. Um-hum.
2 Q. There's a period of time from 2002 through
3 2006 where -- you know, 2006 you start with ID Models
4 and again with Elite. I know when you came over here
5 in 2002 you were with Elite also, right?
6 A. I'm sorry, you're confusing me with the
7 timeframe.
8 Q. I'm confusing myself, how about that. Let's
9 start over.
10 2002 you come over to the United States,
11 you're working at Elite?
12 A. Yes, I've been invited by Elite.
13 Q. Okay. And then if I understand you correctly
14 over time you continue to work with or through Elite?
15 A. Well, I've been, you know, changing agencies
16 throughout the period.
17 Q. Okay. What are some of the other modeling
18 agencies you have worked for or with?
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. Okay. The only other names of modeling
21 agencies that you can answer are ID Models and Elite;
22 is that correct?
23 THE WITNESS: Should I?
24 MR. ROSS: Well, she's already answered also
25 Michele Pommier.
1 MR. EDWARDS: But I thought that was somebody
2 through Elite, like they're --
3 MR. ROSS: No, no, no, Michele Pommier is a --
4 MR. EDWARDS: Different, okay.
5 Q. All right. Is there anybody else that you're
6 able to -- to tell me where you worked?
7 MR. ROSS: Invoke as to any further
8 information.
9 THE WITNESS: I'm sorry?
10 MR. ROSS: Invoke your privilege.
11 A. I refuse to answer any questions.
12 MR. EDWARDS: All right. That's all I got.
13 MR. MERMELSTEIN: Can I just follow up a
14 couple?
15 RECROSS-EXAMINATION
16 BY MR. MERMELSTEIN:
17 Q. In what has been marked as Exhibit 2C is a
18 phone message from you to Adri -- from you to Jeffrey
19 Epstein dated September 10th, 2005 at 1:15 p.m.
20 And the message that you left was "Lauren
21 confirmed 4 p.m.", is that correct?
22 A. I refuse to answer.
23 Q. Is the Lauren referred to in this message
24 ?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A. I refuse to answer.
2 Q. And did you schedule Lauren --
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 Q. -- to come to the Palm Beach
5 mansion as an underage female to give Jeffrey Epstein
6 massages?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A. I refuse to answer.
9 Q. Also what has been marked as Exhibit 2F is a
10 phone message from you to Jeffrey Epstein dated
11 September 11th, 2005 at 9:15 a.m. And the message was
12 that you got a car for a particular person. Do you
13 recall that?
14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 A. I refuse to answer.
16 Q. Is the car that you obtained on
17 September 11th, 2005 for Jane Doe 4?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A. I refuse to answer.
20 Q. And Jane Doe 4 is a girl who had been coming
21 to the Palm Beach mansion to give Jeffrey Epstein a
22 massage and engage in sexual activities with him for a
23 substantial period of time; is that correct?
24 A. I refuse to answer.
25 Q. And also what has been marked as Exhibit 2H --
1 actually --
2 MR. EDWARDS: Is that G?
3 MR. MERMELSTEIN: Are they similar?
4 MR. EDWARDS: Yeah, I guess they blocked out
5 names on one of them and they didn't on the other.
6 MR. MERMELSTEIN: Right. Okay.
7 Q. And what has been marked as Exhibit 2G is a
8 message from you to Jeffrey Epstein dated
9 September 3rd, 2005 at 8:50 p.m. And the message you
10 left is, quote, "I left message for to confirm
11 for 11:00 a.m. and for 4:30 p.m."
12 Did you, in fact, leave that message?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A. I refuse to answer.
15 Q. And this message that you left confirmed an
16 appointment for Jane Doe 4 for 4:30 p.m., correct?
17 A. I refuse to answer.
18 MR. MERMELSTEIN: All right. That's all I
19 have.
20 MR. ROSS: Waive.
21 MR. MERMELSTEIN: All right.
22 VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the record, 12:42 p.m.
23 THE REPORTER: Are you ordering?
24 MR. EDWARDS: Yes.
25 MR. PIKE: I want a copy, a mini, no ASCii,
1 and no word index.
2 MR. MERMELSTEIN: I'll take a copy with a
3 mini.
4 (The deposition was concluded at 12:42 p.m.)
5 (Reading and signing of the deposition was
6 waived by the witness and all parties.)
8 9
1 CERTIFICATE OF OATH
2 STATE OF FLORIDA
3 COUNTY OF BROWARD
5 I, Janet L. McKinney, Registered Professional
6 Reporter, Florida Professional Reporter, Certified
7 LiveNote Reporter, Notary Public, State of Florida,
8 certify that personally appeared before me
9 on March 15, 2010 and was duly sworn.
10 Signed this 21st day of March, 2010.
14 Janet L. McKinney
Registered Professional Reporter
15 Florida Professional Reporter
Certified LiveNote Reporter
16 Notary Public, State of Florida
Commission No.: DD552183
17 Expires: June 2, 2010
1 CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
2 STATE OF FLORIDA
3 COUNTY OF BROWARD
5 I, Janet McKinney, Registered Professional
6 Reporter, Florida Professional Reporter, Certified
7 LiveNote Reporter, certify that I was authorized to and
8 did stenographically report the deposition of
, pages 1 through 138; that a review of the
10 transcript was not requested; and that the transcript
11 is a true record of my stenographic notes.
12 I further certify that I not a relative,
13 employee, attorney, or counsel of any of the parties,
14 nor am I a relative or employee of any of the parties'
15 attorneys or counsel connected with the action, nor am
16 I financially interested in the action.
17 Dated this 21st day of March, 2010.
Janet L. McKinney, RPR, FPR, CLR
20 Registered Professional Reporter
Florida Professional Reporter
21 Certified LiveNote Reporter
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Conchita Sarnoff [journalist] journalist Epstein attempted to bribe [conchitasarnoff] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00316182 (Jmail)
 [article] Conchita Sarnoff
(inferred date: 2010-03-29)
Behind
Sweetheart Deal
Pedophile
0
0
Email
Print
Jeffrey Epstein's
• Play Video Presidential Transition Video:Obama lauds Chile's transition to
democracy AP
Conehita Sarno — Fri Mar 25 8:17 am ET
NEW YORK — ❑ ocuments obtained by The Daily Beast reveal how
pedophile hedge fund mogul Jeffrey Epstein escaped a hefty jail sentence despite overwhelming
evidence of sex crimes with dozens of young girls. Conchita Sarnoff and Lee Aitken on how the fear
and intimidation experienced by victims during pre-trial proceedings, combined with a ferocious,
protracted campaign to undermine the prosecution, culminated in a set of charges that became a
virtual slap on the wrist.

It is proving difficult for hedge fund manager and registered sex offender Jeffrey Epstein to avoid the glare
of media scrutiny — British tabloids most recently cried foul over the shabby royal comportment of Prince
Andrew in agreeing to be the guest of an acknowledged pedophile. But the larger mystery surrounding
Epstein, who completed a 13-month sentence for soliciting prostitution from a minor in 2010, has remained
unsolved: How did the hedge fund mogul manage to finesse the kinds of sex-crime allegations typically
associated with a hefty prison sentence?
For the first time, the U.S. attorney who oversaw the Epstein prosecution in Florida's Southern District is
commenting publicly on the case, in a letter released exclusively to The Daily Beast. This letter, along with
other correspondence unearthed in our reporting, sheds new light on the no-holds-barred battle waged by
Epstein's lawyers to evade the full exercise of prosecutorial power.

Some of the most shocking allegations against Epstein surfaced only after the conclusion of an FBI probe,
in civil suits brought by his victims: for example, the claim that three 12-year-old French girls were
delivered to him as a birthday present. But the feds did identify roughly 40 young women, most of them
underage at the time, who described being lured to Epstein's Palm Beach home on the pretense of giving a
"massage" for money, then pressured into various sex acts, as well as the "Balkan sex slave" Epstein
allegedly boasted of purchasing from her family when she was just 14. More recently, a big cash payment
from Mail on Sunday coaxed one of Epstein's main accusers out of anonymity to describe what she claims
were her years as a teenage sex toy. This victim, produced a photo of herself with Prince
Andrew in 2001 and reported that Epstein paid her $15,000 to meet the prince. Then 17 years old, she
claims that she was abused by Epstein and "loaned" to his friends from the age of 15
Sex crimes of the kind alleges took place typically carry a term of 10 to 20 years in federal prison.
Yet when all was said and done, Epstein served his scant year-plus-one-month in a private wing of the
Palm Beach jail and was granted a 16-hour-per-day free pass to leave the premises for work. A Daily Beast
examination into the inner workings of the Epstein defense strategy reveals how the fear and intimidation
experienced by victims during pre-trial proceedings, combined with a ferocious, protracted campaign to
undermine the prosecution — summed up as "the best defense is an all-star offense" — culminated in a set of
charges that became a virtual slap on the wrist for the globe-trotting financier. Fear and intimidation
experienced by victims dining pre-trial proceedings, combined with a ferocious, protracted campaign to
undermine the prosecution, culminated in a set of charges that became a virtual slap on the wrist.
"Over the past weeks, I have read much regarding Mr. Jeffrey Epstein," are words opening an extraordinary
letter written by R. Alexander Acosta, who served as U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Florida
during Epstein's criminal investigation. Mr. Acosta goes on to detail how, in 2005, a young girl first
brought sex-crime allegations to the Palm Beach Police Department, which sought felony charges against
Epstein. Subsequently, however, the State Attorney agreed to charge him "only with one count of
aggravated assault with no intent to commit a felony," Acosta writes. He notes that such a charge would
have resulted in no jail time, no registration as a sexual offender, and no responsibility for restitution to
Epstein's underage victims.

Frustrated by the State Attorney's decision, the police referred the case to the FBI, which handed it to the
U.S. Attorney General's office. After reviewing the charges, federal prosecutors "agreed that the state
charge was insufficient," Acosta writes. In a script that could have been lifted from Law and Order, his
team gave Epstein two choices: "plead to more serious state felony charges...or else prepare for a federal
felony trial."
The next passage is where things really get interesting: "What followed was a year-long assault on the
prosecution and the prosecutors." Epstein had assembled a world-class legal team, including Alan
Dershowitz, Kenneth Starr, and Roy Black (best known for having defended William Kennedy Smith
against rape charges in Palm Beach.) "One member of the defense team warned me that the office's excess
zeal in forcing a good man to serve time in jail might be the subject of a book if we continued," Acosta
writes. In his view, excessive zeal more aptly described the actions in Epstein's camp: "Defense counsel
investigated individual prosecutors and their families," seeking to unearth personal issues that might lead to
disqualification of members of Acosta's team. The defense also "often failed to negotiate in good faith.
They would obtain concessions as part of a negotiation and agree to proceed, only to change their minds,
and appeal the office's position to Washington."
Undeterred, Acosta stuck to his position that Epstein must agree to the three criteria he had laid out: jail
time, registration as a sex offender, and restitution to victims.

Acosta's account is supported by a second document obtained by The Daily Beast — a five-page letter
written by Assistant U.S. Attorney to another of Epstein's lawyers, Jay Leftwwitz,
during the period when both sides were hammering out the eventual plea agreement. "The indictment was
postponed for more than five months to allow you and Mr. Epstein's other attorneys to make presentations
to the office to convince the office not to prosecute," writes, conjuring the Si ra:of pushback
apparently central to the team's strategy. - Those presentations were unsuccessful." also mentions
her efforts to insure that Epstein would serve time in a federal "prison camp" and not a state prison, which
would be a far rougher environment, particularly for a child molester.

marshals these facts in the process of strenuously disputing apparent charges of misconduct by
the defense: "I continued to work with you in a professional manner even after I learned that you had been
proceeding in bad faith for several weeks — thinking that ... you would 'fool' our office into letting Mr.
Epstein plead to a non-registerable offense."
At another point in her letter, refers to an apparent allegation of self-dealing in the selection of an
outside attorney who would represent the 40-odd victims identified in the FBI probe. In a somewhat
unusual arrangement, Epstein agreed not to contest his liabilit in an civil suits brought by these victims —
and in fact to pay for lawyers to represent them. In her letter, denies any personal interest in the
choice of attorney and goes on to say, "your attacks on me and on the victims establish why I wanted to
find someone whom I could trust with safeguarding the victims' best interests in the face of intense
pressure from an unlimited number of highly skilled and well paid attorneys."
Responding to a request for comment on Acosta's account of events, Roy Black wrote The Daily Beast on
Thursday that, "I can't reply to a letter I haven't received...I can't give a reasoned response without
examining the files and being able to refresh my recollection of events that occurred years ago." Black
went on, "I do not believe any of the things you mention occurred except for the fact we did exercise our
right to appeal to the Department of Justice to determine if a federal crime had been committed." (Other
Epstein attorneys contacted by The Daily Beast did not respond. The U.S Attorney's office for the Southern
District of Florida had no comment.)
Why did Acosta decide to voice his opinions now? In part, he clearly is reacting to ongoing criticism that
Epstein's puny punishment did not fit his crimes. "Some may feel that the prosecution should have been
tougher," Acosta writes. "Evidence that has come to light since 2007 may encourage that view. Many
victims have since spoken out...physical evidence has since been discovered."
Acosta may also have chosen to come fonvard now because, on Monday, attorneys for a number of those
victims filed suit under the Victims Crimes Rights Act to challenge the "non-prosecution agreement" that
ultimately resulted from all the wrangling, claiming that they were not consulted. The U.S. Attorney's
office, now led by Wifredo A. Ferrer, has indicated it will file a response to the suit on April 7.
In his letter, Acosta also takes issue with the way Epstein's sentence was carried out: "Although the terms
of confinement in a state prison are a matter appropriately left to the State of Florida...without doubt, the
treatment that he received while in state custody undermined the purpose of a jail sentence." Indeed,
Epstein's brief confinement likely reinforced a perception that he had merely succumbed to a nuisance suit.
Such a gross misapprehension would help account for the apparent ease with which Epstein has rejoined
the ranks of a social elite. Katie Couric, Woody Allen, and George Stephanopoulos, among others, attended
a dinner party he hosted for Prince Andrew in December, and New York authorities seem to be either
unaware or unconcerned that his Upper East Side home is within 1,000 feet of an Episcopal pre-school, in
violation of sex-offender laws.

Yet a source tells The Daily Beast that Epstein's legal troubles may not be over. It is possible that, as an
outgrowth of the 2007 Florida investigation, federal investigators are now looking into allegations of
money laundering and other financial misdeeds. notes at the end of her letter to Lefkowitz: "You
accuse me of broadening the scope of the investigation without any foundation for doing so by adding
charges of money laundering and violations of a money transmitting business to the investigation. Again, I
consulted with the Justice Department's Money Laundering Section about my analysis...the duty officer
agreed with my analysis."
Conchita Sarnoff has developed multimedia common
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                         Paul Barrett [finance] Alpha Group Capital 
 Bennet Moskowitz [lawyer] represented the Epstein estate executors 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00314248 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(date: 2010-04-07)
PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL
Schedule for April 7th and 8th

Wed. April 7th
**Pinto to come to house today at sonic point** Pinto
9:20 ARRIVAL to Teterboro
10:30 to arrive 71st ( )
11:30 TENATIVE appt w/ (waiting for response)
12-2:00 Lunch with Tom Pritzker at 71s'
Tom: (312) 420-8101p
12ish Appt w/Alberto Pinto at 71"
Pinto:
1:30 to arrive ( )
2:00 Appt w/Bill Murphy at 71st
2:15 Appt w/Steve Susman at 71"
Steve:
3:00 Appt w/George Delson at 71"
George:
4:30 Appt w/Jes Staley at 71s'
Jes:
5:15 CONF CALL w/Steve and Harry Susman
Dial:
Meeting #: *3778300*
Time: 5:15pm EST
5:30 Appt w/Leon Black at 71''
Leon:
7:00 appt wl at 71st
9:00 TENATIVE appt w/ and at 71st
Thurs. April tith
8:30 TENATIVE appt w/ (waiting for response)
9:30-11:00 Appt w/Dangene (Jennie Saunders) btwn
65/66
Jennie Saunders:
11:00 to arrive 71St ( )
11:15 Appt w/Bennet Moskowitz at 713'
Bennet:
11:30 Appt w/Rich Kahn at 71st (LET RICH KNOW)
12:30 Appt w/Henry Jarecki at 71st
Henry:
2:00 to arrive (she can stay until 4:30)
2:00 Appt wi and friend at 71"
MI:
3:00 (TENATIVE) appt w/Jonathon Farkas at 71"
Jonathon: (p)
4:00 appt w/M + 1 at 71st
4:45 Appt w/Jeff Matusow and Paul Barrett at 71st
Jeff: 212 622 7053 (= IIIIMI )
5:15 IF NEEDED appt w/George Delson at 71" (if needed)
George:
6:15 DEPART for Teterboro
7:30 Wheels up to PB
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 John Brockman [journalist] literary agent and author specializing in scientific literature [publ] 
                              Jaron Lanier [tech] inventor of VR, dreadlocks, medieval instruments 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01246559 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Jane Doe #2 v. Jeffrey Epstein
(date: 2010-04-09)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
CASE NO. 08-CIV-80119-MARRA/JOHNSON
JANE DOE NO. 2,
Plaintiff,
-vs-
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
VOLUME III OF III
Related cases:
08-80232, 08-08380, 08-80381, 08-80994
08-80993, 08-80811, 08-80893, 09-80469
09-80591, 09-80656, 09-80802, 09-81092
VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
10:37 - 6:51 p.m.
250 Australian Avenue South
Suite 1500
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
Reported By:
Rachel W. Bridge, RPR, FPR
Notary Public, State of Florida
Prose Court Reporting Services
Job No.: 1484
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0cd8-4599-a2a0-6d38827b68t6
3501.125-027
Page 1 of 21
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO. 502008CA028058XXXXMB AD
• I
Plaintiff,
- vs - VOLUME III OF III
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
10:37 - 6:51 p.m.
250 Australian Avenue South
Suite 1500
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
Reported By:
Rachel W. Bridge, RPR, FPR
Notary Public, State of Florida
Prose Court Reporting Services
Job No. : 1484
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge I
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0cd8-4599-a2a0-6d38827b68t6
3501.125-027
Page 2 of 21
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE 15TH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO. 502008CA028051XXXXMB AB
~•,
Plaintiff,
-vs-
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
VOLUME III OF III
VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
10:37 - 6:51 p.m.
250 Australian Avenue South
Suite 1500
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
Reported By:
Rachel W. Bridge, RPR, FPR
Notary Public, State of Florida
Prose Court Reporting Services
Job No. : 1484
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge I
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0cd8-4599•a2a8-6d38827b68c6
3501.125-027
Page 3 of 21
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE No.502008CA037319XXXXMB AB
Plaintiff,
- vs - VOLUME III OF III
JEFFREY  EPSTEIN
AND
Defendants.
VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF
Wednesday, March 24, 2010
10:37 - 6:51 p.m.
250 Australian Avenue South
Suite 1500
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
Reported By:
Rachel W. Bridge, RPR, FPR
Notary Public, State of Florida
Prose Court Reporting Services
Job No. : 1484
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge I
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0cd8-0599•a2a8-6d38827b68c6
3501.125-027
Page 4 of 21
Page 381 Page 383
APPEARANCES: 1 - - -
2 On behalf of the Plaintiff.:
SPENCER T. KUVIN. ESQUIRE INDEX
LEOPOLD KU WIN 2 - - -
2925 PGA Boulevard
suite No 3 WITNESS: DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECRO
S Palm Beach Gardens. Florida 33410 4
Phone: 561.515.1400 5 By Mr. Garcia 383
On behalf of the Plaintiffs. ..... and 6 By Ms. Ezell 386
lane Doe: 7 8
9 MATMEW WE1SSING. ESQUIRE 8 - - -
FARMER. JAFFE MUSSING. EDWARDS 9 EXHIBITS 10 F1STOS & LEIIRMAN. P.L
425 North Andrews Avenue 10 - - -
11 Suite 2 11 EXHIBIT PAGE Fort Lauderdale Florida 33301
12 Phone: 12 Exhibit 16 389
13 On behalf gallant Does I through a: 13
14 ADAM D. HOROWITZ. ESQUIRE
MERMELSTEIN & HOROWITZ. P.A. 14
15 18205 Biscayne Boulevard 15
Suite 2218
Miami. t i 16
Phone: 17
MI 18 On behalf ol the Plunk''' . 101. 102 and 103:
19 KATHERINE W. I,MELL. ESQUIRE 19
AMY JOSEFSBERG EDERI. ESQUIRE 20 20 POIMURST OILSECK
25 Wem Flatlet Sheet 21
21 SWIG MO
Miami.ii iiii
22 Phone: 23
21 Wu telephone! 24
25 25
Page 382 Page 384
I Appearances continued._ 1 PRODEEDINGS
2 On behalf of the Plaintiff. Jane Doe II: 2 - - - 3 ISIDRO MANUEL GARCIA. ESQUIRE
GARCIA. ELKINS & BOERRINGER 3 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are now on the record
4 224 Daum Avenue. Suite 900 4 It is 5:42 .m. and I'm on media number three.
West Palm Fl Beach ida 33401
Phone: 5 MR. If I could just put something
6 6 quickly on the record before we start. 7 On behalf of the Defendant: 7 I know Mr. Garcia said he had a couple of 8 
JACK ALAN GOLDBERGER. ESQUIRE
ATTERBURY. GOLDBERGER & WEISS. P.A. 8 additional questions. which I have no objection to
9 250 Australian Avenue South 9 him asking. but it is 5:42 and we've been going Suite 1400
lo West Pa Floridaida 33401-5012 0 almost seven hours with Ms. Kellen.
Phone: 11 And I know Ms. Ezell has questions and she has
11 12 got her one client she has to ask questions about. 12
13 On behalf of t • W. • • 13 I understand that, but I hope we can focus on going
1 4 14 forward to areas that have not already been covered
15 so we can actually get out of here tonight. because
■ 16
at some point we really do have to go. and I would
like to get this over with today.
17 18 So with that. Mr. Garcia. if you have some
19 19 additional questions. I have no objection to you
20 ALSO PRESENT: 20 asking that.
21 Jessica Cadwell. Paralegal 21 MR. GARCIA: Thank ou.
Burman. Critton. Lanier & Coleman. P.A. 22 CROSS - continued 22
23 Joseph Kozak. Videographer 23 BY MR. GARCIA:
Prose Court Reporting Services 24 Q. Have you ever had a different hair color? 24
25 25 MR. . Asking it at any time in her
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
5 (Pages 381 to 38 4)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-04:418-4599-4240-6d38827b88c6
3501.125-027
Page 5 of 21
Page 385 Page 387
1 life she's ever dyed her hair a different hair 1 Q. And you are sure that you only had it up for
2 color? 2 about ten minutes?
3 MR. GARCIA: Yes, or if she's dyed her hair 3 MR. Did you mean literally ten
4 now or if that's her natural color. Let's start 4 minutes or just for a brief period of time?
5 with that. 5 THE WITNESS: A very brief period of time.
6 BY MR. GARCIA: 6 MR. You can answer Mr. Garcia's
7 Q. Is that our natural color? 7 question.
8 MR. : Answer that. 8 BY MR. GARCIA:
9 THE WITNESS: Yes. 9 Q. Can you be more specific? Are we talking
10 BY MR. GARCIA: 10 about ten minutes for a day or ten minutes in a week or
11 Q. What is your natural color, so the transcript 11 a month?
12 will reflect it? 12 A. Maybe a day. Maybe two days.
13 MR. We have a video, so I think 13 Q. Okay.
14 it's clear. 19 MR. GARCIA: Oka that's all I have. Thanks.
pretty
THE WITNESS: Brown. 15
.
CROSS (
16 BY MR. GARCIA: 16 BY MS. EZELL:
17 Q. Have you ever dyed your hair or colored your 17 Q. Ms. Kellen. my name is Katherine Ezell. I'm
18 hair blonde or any type of shade of light, lighter 18 here with Amy Josefsberg Merl. We represent Jane Doc
19 shade? 19 103. We also represent three clients who have not yet
20 MR. : You mean at any time in her 20 filed. Some of the questions may be repetitive. but I
21 life has she done that? 21 believe we have the right to ask them with regard to our
22 MR. GARCIA: Yes, sir. 22 clients. So with that said. we'll move along as fast as
23 THE WITNESS: Yes. 23 we can.
24 BY MR. GARCIA: 24 Why did you take down your Facebook page?
25 Q. For what period of time? 25 A. I think it's a stupid site. I don't
Page 386 Page 388
1 A. I don't recall. 1 understand it. I don't understand the point of it.
2 Q. And how long have you gone back to your 2 Q. Do you have e-mail?
3 natural color brown? 3 A. Yes.
4 A. It's been a long time. I don't recall exactly 4 Q. And what is our e-mail address?
5 the dates. 5 MR. • Instruct the witness not to
6 Q. Do know somebody named Craig Greczyn. G-r-e-c. 6 answer based on Fifth Amendment privilege.
7 as in cat. z as in Zorro, y-n? 7 THE WITNESS: At the advice of counsel. I must
a A. No. 8 invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
9 Q. He's a student at SUNY University, S-U-N-Y. in 9 BY MS. EZELL:
10 Courtland. 10 Q. Have ou. have ou done e-mail under the
11 A. No idea. 11 address
12 Q. Do you know Kofi Sansculotte. K-o-f-i. 12 A. Can you repeat that? I'm sorry.
13 S-a-n-s-c-u-1-o-t-t-e? 13 . Have ou used e-mail with the address
A. No.
Q. And Michael Daley?
15 A. No.
16 A. No. 16 Q. Have ou used e-mail with the address
17 Q. I tried to see if I could Google your Facebook 17 .
18 it down 18 MR. • Hold on a second. I'm going tc page. and you thought you took after about ten
19 minutes. I did come up with three or four Sarah 19 instruct the witness not to answer any questions
20 Kellens. I'm not sure if it's the same one that you 20 about any e-mail addresses that she may or may not
21 are, but are you sure that you've taken it down? 21 have had in the past based on her Fifth Amendment
22 A. Yes. 22 privilege.
23 Q. And do you have any idea when you took it 23 THE WITNESS: At the advice of my counsel. I
24 down? 24 must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
25 A. Maybe a year ago. 25
6 (Pages 385 to 388)
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-Occ18-4599-a2a0-8d38827b88c8
3501.125-027
Page 6 of 21
Page 389 Page 391
1 BY MS. F7Fit i . 1 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Okay.
2 Q. With regard to the Facebook page again, why 2 MS. EZELL: This is the second page.
3 did you start it up if you thought it was a stupid site 3 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Okay.
4 and didn't know how to use it? 4 MS. EZELL: And here's the third page.
5 A. I was just curious. 5 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Okay.
6 Q. Did anyone help you do that? 6 MS. EZELL: And just for identification
7 A. No. 7 purposes. those are Bates stamped SAO 496
a Q. Did anyone tell you to take it down? 8 through -- I'm sorry. 495 through 497. If you
9 A. No. 9 would pass that down, please. to the witness.
10 Q. You were asked about any licenses. Have you 10 BY MS. EZELL:
11 never held a real estate license? 11 Q. Doyou recognize this. Sorry?
12 A. Never. 12 MR. : Are you asking about all three
13 Q. Do you hold any licenses in any states other 13 pages simultaneously or one page at a time?
14 than Florida? 14 MS. EZELL: All three simultaneous.
15 MR. : When you say licenses, you mean 15 MR. : Okay.
16 professional as opposed to a driver's license or 16 BY MS. EZELL:
17 some other sort of a license? 17 Q. This appears to be. the first page appears to
18 MS. EZELL: Yes. 18 indicate that this was obtained from the driver's
19 THE WITNESS: I don't have a license anywhere 19 license authority in
20 for anything. 20 MR. : The first page we have looks
21 BY MS. EZELL: 21 like it's a printed page.
22 Q. Do you have a driver's license? 22 MS. EZELL: Ri ht.
23 A. Yes. 23 MR. : From -- oh, I see. Okay. never
24 Q. And in what state? 24 mind.
25 MR. : I instruct her not to answer 25
Page 390 Page 392
1 based on her Fifth Amendment privilege. 1 BY MS. EZELL:
2 THE WITNESS: At the advice of counsel. I must 2 Q. It's from the supervisor driver license clerk
3 invoke m Fifth Amendment privilege. 3 in the city and county of Do you see that?
4 MR. You can roll your eyes all you 4 A. Yes.
5 want. Mr. Horowitz. It's my client's right. 5 Q. Do you recognize that application. pages two
6 She'll invoke it if she needs to. 6 and three?
7 MR. HOROWITZ: I was shaking my head, not 7 MR. : Page two is a printout of what
8 rolling my eyes. The Fifth Amendment assertion as 8 appears to be a driver's license. Page three
9 to whether a person has a driver's license is 9 appears to be a fingerprint.
10 ridiculous. It is ridiculous. 10 Is that what you are asking her, if she
11 MR. You can have that opinion. am 11 recognizes this?
12 if you want to bring that up to the judge, I'll be 12 MS. EZELL: Yes, uh huh.
13 happy to explain to the judge why it's a valid 13 MR. : I instruct her not to answer
14 invocation. I disagree with you. 14 those questions.
15 MS. EZELL: It is certainly a record that the 15 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
16 government has and can be accessed. 16 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
17 MR. That's true. 17 BY MS. EZELL:
18 (The document was marked Exhibit 16 for 18 Q. Even thou h this is a public record?
19 identification.) 19 MR. : Well, if it's a public record
20 BY MS. EZELL: 20 or not, she doesn't have to admit or authenticate
21 Q. I'm going to show you in a moment what I have 21 it for you. You can prove it some other way. She
22 premarked as Exhibit 16. 22 has a Constitutional right not to admit or
23 MS. EZELL: Actually, it's Composite 16. It's 23 authenticate the document for you. and that's what
24 three pages. I'll show it before I give it to the 24 she is invoking.
25 witness. 25
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
7 (Pages 389 to 392)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0c68-4599-a2a0-8d38827b68c8
3501.125-027
Page 7 of 21
Page 393 Page 395
1 BY MS. F7Ft i • 1 BY MS. EZELL:
2 Q. Didyou ever hold a driver's license? 2 Q. Did you at one time hold
3 MR. Same instruction. It's been 3 in -- I won't pronounce it ri ght, but ?
4 asked and answered. 4 THE REPORTER: Could ou spell --
5 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 5 MS. EZELL: It's I believe.
6 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 6 MR. : I instruct the witness not to
7 BY MS. F7Ft t • 7 answer based on her Fifth Amendment privilege.
8 Q. Do you currently hold a driver's 8 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
9 license? 9 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
10 MR. It's been asked and answered. 10 BY MS. EZELL:
11 same instruction. 11 Q. Were ou born on ?
12 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 12 MR. : Same instruction.
13 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 13 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
14 BY MS. EZELL: 14 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
15 Q. Is that not your picture on the second page of 15 BY MS. EZELL:
16 that exhibit? 16 Q. Doyou see a sr nature there for
17 MR. Same instruction. 17 MR. : Just asking if she sees a
18 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 18 signature on the paper --
19 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 19 MS. EZELL: That says
20 BY MS. EZELL: 20 THE WITNESS: I see it.
21 Q. Do ou see the ran 21 BY MS. EZELL:
22 MR. She's just asking if you see 22 Q. Is that our si attue?
23 that on the document. 23 MR. : Instruct the witness not to
24 THE WITNESS: Yes. 24 answer based on her Fifth Amendment privilege.
25 25 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
Page 394 Page 396
1 BY MS. F7Ft i • 1 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
2 Q. And haven't you testified today that that is 2 BY MS. EZELL:
3 your name? 3 Q. Do you drive an automobile in Palm Beach
4 MR. The testimony will speak for 4 County?
5 itself. Next question. 5 MR. Let me understand the question.
6 BY MS. EZELL: 6 Are you asking if she ever drives a vehicle in the
7 Q. You ma answer. 7 county or if she drives a vehicle registered in the
a MR. Next question. 8 county?
9 MS. EZELL You are instructing her not to 9 MS. EZELL: If she drives a vehicle in Palm
10 answer that uestion? 10 Beach Count .
11 MR. I am. 11 MR. You can answer that. In other
12 BY MS. EZELL: 12 words, did you drive a car here today?
13 Q. What was your address at the time that that. 13 THE WITNESS: Yes.
14 that you a lied for a license then? 14 BY MS. EZELL:
15 MR. Object to the form, assumes 15 Q. You were asked earlier if you have ever been
16 facts that she has not acknowledged. that she ever 16 to Palm Beach as opposed to West Palm Beach where we ar
17 applied for this license, and I'll instruct her not 17 today. and I believe you answered yes.
18 to answer. 18 A. Uh huh.
19 BY MS. EZELL: 19 Q. Where have you been in Palm Beach?
20 Q. Is thepost office box -- 20 MR. I instruct her not to answer
21 MR. Hold on. let her answer or not 21 based on her Fifth Amendment privilege.
22 answer. 22 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
23 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 23 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
24 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 24 BY MS. F7In T -
25 25 Q. When was the last time you were on Palm Beach
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
8 (Pages 393 to 3 9 6)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0468-4599-a2a0-6d38827b68c6
3501.125-027
Page 8 of 21
Page 397 Page 399
1 island, if it's an island? 1 BY MS. F7F1 I •
2 MR. Objection, it's been asked 2 Q. Do ou know Glenn Dubin?
3 before, and I'll instruct her nor to answer for the 3 MR. : It's also asked and answered,
4 same reason. 4 but Inlet her answer it again.
5 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 5 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
6 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 6 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
7 BY MS. EZELL: 7 BY MS. F7FI 1 •
8 Q. Haveyou ever heard of Jeffrey Epstein? 8 Q.
9 MR. Objection, instruct the witness 9 MR. Same instruction, objection to
10 not to answer based on her Fifth Amendment 10 the form, assumes facts that she has not
11 privilege. 11 acknowledged. so there is no foundation for the
12 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 12 question.
13 I must invoke m Fifth Amendment right. 13 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
14 MR. It's also been asked and 14 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
15 answered. 15 BY MS. F7Ft I •
16 BY MS. EZELL: 16 Q.
17 Q. Do you read the newspapers?
18 A. Na really. 18 MR.
19 Q. Have you read any newspapers in the last four 19 MS. EZELL:
20 years in Palm Beach County? 20 MR. Objection to form. Once again,
21 A. I'm sure I have. 21 assumes facts that she has not acknowledged. that
22 Q. Have you read the Palm Beach Post? 22 there is no foundation. Instruct her not to answer
23 A. No, I don't. 23 the question.
24 Q. What newspapers do you read? 24 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
25 A. New York Times. New York Post. That's about 25 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
Page 398 Page 400
1 it., on occasion. 1 BY MS. EZELL:
2 Q. And have you ever — do you watch the news on 2 AreQ.  you an onl child?
3 TV. local news? MR. It's been asked and answered o
4 A. No. 4 responded to, and I'll instruct her once again to
5 Q. When you did your Facebook page. whose 5 respond.
6 computer did you use? 6 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
7 A. My own. 7 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
8 Q. What kind of computer do you own? 8 BY MS. EZELL:
9 A. An Apple computer. 9 Q. I believe you stated that you had changed your
10 Q. Is it a laptop? 10 hair color at some point in your life.
11 A. Yes. 11 Have you changed it in the last five years?
12 Q. How long have you had that computer? 12 A. I don't recall exact years and dates.
13 A. I don't recall. 13 Q. I'm sorry?
14 Q. Doyou know Eva Andersson? 14 A. I don't recall exact years and dates that I
15 MR. Objection, it's been asked and 15 have.
16 answered. 16 Q. Have you been a blonde at some point in the
17 MS. EZELL: I think it was asked whether or 17 last, in the last eight years?
18 not she had been on a plane with her. 18 A. Most likely.
19 MR. I believe she was asked if she 19 Q. At more than one time? In other words, have
20 knew who Eva Andersson was, but she can go ahead 20 you gone back and forth between being a brunette and a
21 and respond to the question. I instruct her not to 21 blonde or were you a blonde for a certain period of
22 answer. 22 time?
23 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 23 A. I think I went back and forth at one point.
24 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 24 Q. Have you ever either had an office or worked
25 25 at an office in thi. building. which is One Clearlake
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
9 (Pages 397 to 4 00)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
90561499-0.48-4599-a2a0-6d38827b68c6
3501.125-027
Page 9 of 21
Page 401 Page 403
1 Centre? 1 BY MS. EZELL:
2 MR. Instruct the witness not to 2 Q. Do you consider yourself a citizen of the
3 answer based on her Fifth Amendment privilege. 3 United States?
4 THE WITNESS: At the advice of counsel. I must 4 MR. : You can answer that.
5 invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 5 THE WITNESS: Yes.
6 BY MS. EZELL: 6 BY MS. EZELL:
7 Q. Have you ever gone to that office on a daily 7 Q. And of what state do you consider yourself to
8 basis with Jeffrey E rein? 8 be a citizen?
9 MR. Objection to form. There is no 9 MR. That was just asked and
10 foundation, because she hasn't acknowledged going 10 answered.
11 to an office in this building. 11 MS. EZELL: I asked about residency.
12 Also objection as to the implied knowledge of 12 MR. : I apologize.
13 Mr. Epstein. Instruct her not to answer. 13 THE WITNESS: What's the difference?
14 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 14 MR. : Instruct the witness not to
15 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 15 answer the question based on Fifth Amendment.
16 BY MS. EZELL: 16 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
17 Q. Have you ever had anything to do with a 17 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
18 company called the Florida Science Foundation? 18 BY MS. EZELL:
19 MR. Instruct the witness not to 19 Q. Have you changed your residency in the last
20 answer based on Fifth Amendment. 20 three years?
21 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 21 MR. Residency for which? I just
22 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 22 want to be clear. Ms. Ezell. You mean legal
23 BY MS. EZELL: 23 residency or where she actually lives residency?
24 Q. Your middle name is :. is that correct? 24 MS. EZELL: Well, let's do both.
25 A. Correct. 25
Page 402 Page 404
1 Q. 1 BY MS. EZELL:
2 MR. It's been asked and answered 2 Q. Have you changed your legal residency in the
3 twice. You can answer it a ain. 3 last five years?
4 THE WITNESS: 4 A. I don't think so.
5 BY MS. F7Ft I • 5 Q. Have you changed the place you live in the
6 Q. Thank you. 6 last five years?
7 Where do you. of what state are you a 7 MR. Instruct her not to answer that
8 resident? 8 question based on Fifth Amendment.
9 MR. Instruct the witness not to 9 THE WITNESS: At the advice of counsel, I must
10 answer based on Fifth Amendment. 10 invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
11 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 11 BY MS. EZELL:
12 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 12 Q. Have you changed your citizenship. your state
13 BY MS. EZELL: 13 citizenship in the last fi ve years?
Where vote? Q.  do ou
MR. Same instruction.
MR. : Again, for purposes of voting
and other things or just --
16 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 16 MS. EZELL: Yes, whatever things citizenship
17 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 17 entitles one to do.
18 BY MS. EZELL: 18 MR. If you understand the question
19 Q. Are ou registered to vote? 19 you can answer it.
20 MR. It's been asked and answered. 20 THE WITNESS: I don't recall really ever
21 I'll instruct her not to answer again, or to answer 21 changing -- I didn't know that you could change
22 it, to respond to it. I should say. 22 your citizenship of a state.
23 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 23 BY MS. EZELL:
24 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 24 Q. Well, if you move from one state to another.
25 25 you might change your voter's registration. time you
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
10 (Pages 401 to 4 0 4)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-04:68-4599-a2a0-6d38827b68c6
3501.125-027
Page 10 of 21
Page 405 Page 407
1 done that? 1 THE WITNESS: At the advice of my lawyer, I
2 MR. You can answer. 2 must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
3 THE WITNESS: No. 3 BY MS. EZELL:
4 BY MS. EZELL: 4 Q.
5 Q. Are you a resident of or citizen of the US
6 Virgin Islands currentl ?
7 MR. Do you understand? You can
a answer it. 8 Q. Have you ever been involved in modeling for M
9 THE WITNESS: No. 9 Squared?
10 BY MS. EZELL: 10 MR. • Instruct the witness --
11 Q. Do ou taxes in any state? 11 objection to the form, assumes knowledge of an
12 MR. Answer that yes or no. 12 entity by the name of MC Squared which the witness
13 THE WITNESS: Yes. 13 has not acknowledged or have any knowledge of. so
14 BY MS. F7Ft I • 19 there is no foundation for the question.
15 Q. In what states do you pay taxes? 15 Ed instruct her not to answer based on her
16 MR. Instruct her not to answer that 16 Fifth Amendment privilege.
17 question based on Fifth Amendment. 17 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
18 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 18 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
19 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 19 BY MS. EZELL:
20 BY MS. EZELL: 20
21 Q. Doyou ownproperty in any state?
22 MR. It's a yes or no question. You
23 can answer that.
24 THE WITNESS: No.
Page 406 Page 408
1 BY MS. EZELL:
I 2 Q. Is that a no?
3 A. No. I
4 Q. Have you owned property in any state in the 4 BY MS. EZELL:
5 last five years? 5 Q. And what happened to those, where are those
6 A. No. 6 pictures?
7 Q. Are you taking any prescribed medication at 7 A. I have them.
8 this time? 8 Q. And who is your boyfriend?
9 MR. You can answer the question. 9 MR. : Hold on a second.
10 THE WITNESS: 10 Instruct the witness not to answer based on
11 BY MS. EZELL: 11 her Fifth Amendment privilege.
12 Q. I'm so 12 BY MS. EZELL:
13 A. 13 Q. Is that your current boyfriend who took the
14 Q. Anything else? 14 pictures?
15 A. No. 15 MR. • You can answer that.
16 Q. You didn't take anything before this 16 THE WITNESS: No.
17 deposition today? 17 BY MS. EZELL:
18 A. No. 18 Q-
19 •.
20 MR. • At this point this is getting
21 into her privacy rights beyond the scope of
22 Q. And for what company or organization did you 22 anything I think that's relevant to this case. I'm
23 model at 18? 23 going to ask you to move on.

MR. Instruct her not to answer the 24 MS. EZELL: Are you instructing her not to
question based on her Fifth Amendment privilege. 25 answer?
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
11 (Pages 405 to 4 08)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-Occla-4599-a2a0-6d38827baace
3501.125-027
Page 11 of 21
Page 409

MR. I am. I am.
BY MS. EZELL:
Q. Do you have all copies of those pictures or
have they been distributed?

A. I hope I have all copies.
Q. Would you please -- I have a little difficulty
hearing you.
A. So
24 Q. Who introduced you to Jeffrey Epstein?
25 MR. Instruct the witness not to
Page 411
THE WITNESS: I don't — I don't get it. It's
vague. I don't understand the question.
BY MS. EZELL:

Q. Are you not aware of an organization that
limits its membership to billionaires?
A. No. I'm not.
MR. : Instruct the witness not to
answer based on her Fifth Amendment privilege, and
that's also been asked and answered several times.
THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
BY MS. EZELL:

Q. By whom are ou currently employed?
MR. : Objection. also been asked ant
answered several times. Instruct her not to
answer.
THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
BY MS. EZELL:
Q. Are you employed by an individual or by a
corporation?
MR. : Same instruction.
THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
Page 410
1 answer based on her Fifth Amendment privilege.
2 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
3 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
4 BY MS. EZELL:
5 Q. Have you ever been to a social event in New
6 York that is restricted to billionaires?
7 A. Sorry. can you repeat that?
8 Q. Yes. Have you ever been to a social event
9 that's held annually in New York restricted to
10 billionaires?
11 A. I've never heard of such an event, no.
12 Q. Have you ever been to such an organization in
13 California?
14 A. No. I, I have never heard of such an event
15 like that, so I don't know.
16 Q. Have you never seen your picture taken and
17 displayed in rint media at such an event?
18 MR. Objection to the form. It's
19 not established she has any idea what event or what
20 kind of event this would be.
21 BY MS. EZELL:
22 Q. An annual event involving millionaires
23 billionaires, excuse me.
24 MR. Objection to the form. There
25 is a lack of foundation for the question.
Page 412
1 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
2 BY MS. EZELL:
3 Q. Do ou receive a W2?
4 MR. : Same instruction.
5 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
6 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
7 BY MS. EZELL:
8 Q. Do ou receive a 1099?
9 MR. : Same instruction.
10 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
11 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
12 BY MS. EZELL:
13 Q. Does anyone claim you as a dependent on their
14 tax returns?
15 MR. Anyone other than herself?
16 MS. EZELL: Yes.
17 THE WITNESS: No.
18 BY MS. EZELL:
19 Q. Have you ever signed a confidentiality
20 agreement?
21 MR. : With anyone?
22 MS. EZELL: Yes.
23 MR. HOROWITZ: Instruct the witness not to
24 answer based on her Fifth Amendment privilege.
25 TI IL WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
12 (Pages 409 to 4 12)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0ca-4599-a2a0-6d38827b68c6
3501.125-027
Page 12 of 21
Page 413 Page 415
1 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 1 implicitly. Instruct the witness not to answer.
2 BY MS. EZELL: 2 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
3 3 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
I 4 BY MS. EZELL:
A. Have I what? I'm so 5 Q. Do you know Juan Alessi?
6 6 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
7 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
8 A. I don't recall ever saying those words. 8 BY MS. EZELL:
9 Q. Is it true that you will do anything Jeffrey 9 Q. Doyou know Alfredo Rodriguez?
10 Epstein asks? 10 MR. : It's been asked and answered.
11 MR. : Objection to the form. compounc 11 Go ahead and answer it again.
12 question. Assumes knowledge of Jeffrey Epstein. so 12 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
13 I instruct the witness not to answer. 13 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
14 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 14 BY MS. EZELL:
15 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment privilege. 15 Q. I think you also might have been asked if you
16 BY MS. EZELL: 16 know Januscz Banasiak.
17 Q. In 2005 and '6. did you have a designated 17 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
18 computer in Mr. E rein's home on El Brillo Way? 18 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
19 MR. : Objection to form. it's 19 BY MS. EZELL:
20 compound and assumes knowledge of Mr. Epstein and 20 Q. Are ou a hoto rapher?
21 of a location on El Brillo Way. so I instruct the 21 MR. : Objection to the form, its
22 witness not to answer. 22 ambiguous. Amateur photographer? Professional
23 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 23 photographer? Can you clarify?
24 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 24 BY MS. EZELL:
25 25 Q. Do you enjoy photography?
Page 414 Page 416
1 BY MS. EZELL: 1 A. Yes.
2 Q. Did you have on a computer at El Brillo Way a 2 Q. What kind of camera do you have?
3 list of contact information and pictures of numerous 3 MR. Instruct the witness not to
4 women? 4 answer the question.
5 MR. Objection to the form, it's 5 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
6 compound and it is lack of foundation based on the 6 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
7 prior question and answer. 7 BY MS. EZELL:
8 Instruct the witness not to answer. 8 Q. Do you know Maria Akssi?
9 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 9 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
10 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 10 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
11 BY MS. EZELL: 11 BY MS. F7PT 1 -
Q. Did you and Ghislaine Maxwell share that
information on both of our computers?
Q. Have you ever known Jeffrey Epstein to give
caniems to young women who come to his home to give hin
14 MR. Objection to form, assumes 14 massages?
15 knowledge of a person by the name of Ghislaine; 15 MR. Objection to the form. standing
16 Maxwell. 16 objection. lack of foundation as to Mr. Epstein and
17 Also lack of foundation based on the prior two 17 to his home. Instruct the witness not to answer.
18 answers. Instruct the witness not to answer. 18 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
19 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 19 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
20 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment privilege. 20 BY MS. F7Pr T -
21 BY MS. EZELL: 21 Q. Have you been encouraged in your pursuit of
22 22 photograph • b Mr. E tein?
■ 23 MR. : Same objection previously
24 MR. Objection to form, lack of 24 stated.
25 foundation, assumes knowledge of Sir. Epstein 25 THE WITNESS: At the in‘truction of my lawyer.
13 (Pages 413 to 416)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge (IM M)
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0.48-4599-a2.a0-6d381327b118c6
3501.125-027
Page 13 of 21
Page 417 Page 419
1 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 1 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
2 BY MS. EZELL: 2 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
3 Q. Have you ever taken pictures of any of the 3 BY MS. EZELL:
4 young women who have visited the Epstein mansion to 4 Q. Have you. have you ever photographed any of
5 provide massa es? 5 the young women who visited or visit the Epstein home tc
6 MR. Objection to form, compound. 6 provide massy es to Mr. Epstein?
7 lack of foundation. Instruct the witness not to 7 MR. Objection to form. its been
8 answer. 8 asked and answered.
9 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 9 Also lack of foundation and standing
10 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 10 objection. Same instruction.
11 BY MS. EZELL: 11 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
12 Q. Are you aware of any hidden cameras on the 12 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
13 premises? 13 BY MS. EZELL:
14 MR. Which premises? 14 Q. Have you ever photographed any minor girls who
15 MS. EZELL At the El Brillo Way address of 15 are either nude or nude?
16 Mr. Epstein. 16
partial)
MR. That's also been asked and
17 MR. Objection to form, lack of 17 answered. I instruct her once again not to answer
18 foundation, compound. Instruct the witness not to 18 the question.
19 answer. 19 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
20 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 20 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
21 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 21 BY MS. EZELL:
22 BY MS. EZELL: 22 Q. Have you ever been aware of something called
23 Q. Did you ever meet a young woman named M.? 23 the Edge Grou ?
24 A. At the instruction of my lawyer, I must invoke 24 MR. Consult.
25 my Fifth Amendment right. 25 THE WITNESS: At the advice of my lawyer, I
Page 418 Page 420
1 Q. Were you sometimes designated or requested by 1 must invoke the Fifth Amendment right.
2 Mr. Epstein to buy gifts for the young women who would 2 BY MS. EZELL:
3 come to the home to
iv:
him massages? 3 Q. Is that the name of a group that's, whose
4 MR. Objection to form, lack of 4
e
membershi is made u of billionaires?
5 foundation. Instruct the witness not no answer. 5 MR. : Objection to form. lack of
6 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 6 foundation. Instruct the witness not to answer.
7 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 7 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
8 BY MS. F7Ft I • 8 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
9 Q. Were you aware that Mr. Epstein gave .. a 9 BY MS. EZELL:
10 digital camera and encouraged her in her pursuit of 10 Q. Did you attend a function of the Edge Group in
11 photograph ? 11 February of 1902 -- I'm sorry. 2002?
12 MR. : Same objection stated to the 12 MR. : Object to form, there is a lack
13 previous question and same instruction. 13 of foundation. Instruct the witness not to answer.
14 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 14 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
15 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 15 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
16 BY MS. F7F1 f • 16 BY MS. EZELL:
17 Q. Have you ever met a young woman named ? 17 Q. Have you attended several functions since 2002
18 A. At the instruction of my lawyer. I must invoke 18 of the Edge Grou • ?
19 my Fifth Amendment right. 19 MR. : Objection to the form, because
20 Q. Were you ever aware that Mr. Epstein gave 20 there is no foundation for her having any knowledge
21 a regular camera and encouraged her in her pursuit of 21 of an entity called the Edge Group. so I'll
22 photograph ? 22 instruct her not to answer.
23 MR. : Objection to form, assumes 23 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
24 certain facts, lack of foundation, compound. 24 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
25 Instruct the witness not to answer. 25
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
14 (Pages 417 to 420)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
90561499-0468-4599-82.80-66388271368c6
3501.125-027
Page 14 of 21
Page 421 Page 423
1 BY MS. F7IFI I • 1 is a lack of foundation of her having any
2 Q. Are you a member of the Edge Group or do you 2 interaction with anyone at any home owned by
3 go as the guest of Mr. E stein? 3 Mr. Epstein, whoever he may be. Instruct her not
4 MR. Again, there is no foundation 4 to answer.
5 for the question because there is no. there is no 5 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
6 connection of her to this organization, and I'd 6 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
7 instruct her not to answer. Form objection. 7 BY MS. EZELL:
8 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 8 Q. Were you the one who routinely would get out
9 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 9 the lotion, towels, and massage equipment once you
10 BY MS. F7IFI I • 10 arrived at the massy e room with the girl?
11 Q. Do you know Ghislaine Maxwell's e-mail 11 MR. Same objection to the form.
12 address? 12 same objection stated to the previous question.
13 MR. Instruct the witness not to 13 It's been asked and answered as well.
14 answer, objection to form, lack of foundation as to 14 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
15 her knowledge of anyone named Ghislaine Maxwell. 15 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
16 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 16 BY MS. EZELL:
17 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 17 Q. Does Mr. Epstein particularly like any
BY MS. F7IFI I • 18
particular massy e oils?
MR. • Objection to the form. standar
objection. no foundation as to her knowledge of ?
or a•Do you know a=I
21 A. At the instruction of my lawyer, I must invoke 21 anything relating to Jeffrey Epstein. Instruct her
22 my Fifth Amendment right. 22 not to answer.
23 Q. Did you participate in a sort of routine 23 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
24 involving young women who would come to the house. 24 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
25 Mr. Epstein's house on El Brillo Way to provide 25
Page 422 Page 424
1 massages? 1 BY MS. EZELL:
2 MR. That's been asked and answered 2 Q. Was it your general practice to leave the girl
3 several times. object to the form, lack of 3 alone either just before or when Mr. Epstein would com
4 foundation as to any knowledge relating to Epstein 4 into the room?
s or El Brillo Way. Instruct her not to answer. 5 MR. : Objection to the form, again
6 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 6 assuming multiple facts and the same question. none
7 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 7 of which have any foundation. Instruct her not to
a BY MS. EZELL: 8 answer.
9 Q. Was it routine practice for you to come and 9 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer
10 meet the girl after she arrived at El Brillo Way to 10 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
11 provide a massage for the sexual gratification of 11 BY MS. EZELL:
12 Mr. Epstein? 12 Q. Who paid the girls who came to El Brillo Way
13 MR. : Objection to form, it's 13 to provide massages and other sexual favors for
14 compound. There is a lack of foundation. Instruct 14 Mr. Epstein?
15 the witness not to answer. It's been asked and 15 MR. : Same objection as to form as
16 answered several times. 16 previously stated to the last three or four
17 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 17 questions. Same instruction to the witness.
18 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 18 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer
19 BY MS. EZELL: 19 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
20 Q. Was it your practice to then lead the young 20 BY MS. EZELL:
21 woman who had come to give Mr. Epstein a massage up a 21 Q. Who was responsible for keeping the supply of
22 stairway that is behind a door in the kitchen of the 22 cash in the house from which the girls were paid?
23 home on El Brillo Wa ? 23 MR. : Same objection as to form and
24 MR. : Objection to the form, it's 24 lack of foundation. Instruct the witness not to
25 compound. assuming many facts. It's not, and there 25 answer.
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
15 (Pages 421 to 424)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0a18-4599-a2a0-6d38827868c6
3501.125-027
Page 15 of 21
Page 425 Page 427
1 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer 1 MR. Objection to the form, lack of
2 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 2 foundation. Instruct the witness not to answer.
3 BY MS. EZELL: 3 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
4 Q. Was it your practice or habit to get the 4 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
5 telephone numbers and contact information of each girl 5 BY MS. EZELL:
6 before she left El Brillo Way? 6 Q. Did you ever text with Jane No. 103 about her
7 MR. Same objection as to form as 7 coming to Mr. E rein's house?
8 stated to the last series of questions. Same 8 MR. : Same instruction. same
9 instruction. 9 objection.
10 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer 10 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
11 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 11 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
12 BY MS. EZELL: 12 BY MS. EZELL:
13 Q. Going back to that stairway that led from the 13 Q. Were you aware that Jeffrey Epstein was
14 kitchen up to the massage room, was there a time when 14 helping Jane No. 103 with her college application?
15 there were photos of nude girls all the way up that 15 MR. : Objection to the form, lack of
16 stairway? 16 foundation as to any knowledge as to Jeffrey
17 MR. Same objection as to form an 17 Epstein. so therefore it's compound and ambiguous.
18 lack of foundation as to any basis to question this 18 Instruct you not to answer.
19 witness on anything having to do with a home own 19 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
20 by Mr. Epstein or any staircase or any pictures on 20 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
21 a staircase. So instruct her not to answer. 21 BY MS. EZELL:
22 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer 22 Q. Did you ever hear Mr. Epstein tell Jane No.
23 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 23 103 that he would help her even with the financing of
24 BY MS. F7Ft i • 24 her college, of her education?
25 Q. Do you recall a time when all those 25 MR. Same objection stated to the
Page 426 Page 428
1 photographs were removed? 1 previous question. Objection to form and lack of
2 MR. : Objection to the form. lack of 2 foundation. Instruct the witness not to answer.
3 foundation. same objection as the previous series 3 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
4 of questions. Same instruction. 4 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
5 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 5 BY MS. EZELL:
6 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 6 Q. Do you recall -- and I believe it's in
7 BY MS. FM I - 7 Exhibit 4, if we could pull Exhibit 4, please. If I
a Q. Did you ever text girls about coming to 8 could just look at it for a moment, please.
9 provide massy es for Jeffrey Epstein? 9 MR. : Certainly.
10 MR. : Objection as to form, lack of 10 MS. EZELL: Thanks. Oh. good, it's on the
11 foundation as to any knowledge of Jeffrey Epstein. 11 front.
12 Instruct her not to answer. 12 BY MS. EZELL:
13 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 13 Q. The first page of Exhibit 4, I'd ask you to
14 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 14 look at that. Doyou recognize that handwriting?
15 BY MS. EZELL: 15 MR. : That was asked and answered
16 Q. Do you know how to text? 16 about six hours ago. She said no.
17 A. Yes. 17 You can answer it again.
18 Q. And how long have you been texting? 18 THE WITNESS: No.
19 A. Twelve years. 19 BY MS. EZELL:
20 Q. Twelve years? That's great. You are way 20 Q. Were you aware that Mr. Epstein ordered roses
21 ahead of me. I still don't know how. 21 to be delivered to Jane No. 103 at the stage of her high
22 Do you know a young woman named Jane No. 103? 22 school after a la ?
23 A. At the advice of my counsel. I must invoke my 23 MR. : Objection to the form, lack of
24 Fifth Amendment right. 24 foundation, standing objection.
25 Q. Did you ever drive Jane No. 103 anywhere? 25 TIM WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
16 (Pages 425 to 428)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0cd8-4599-a2a043438827b68c8
3501.125-027
Page 16 of 21
Page 429 Page 431
1 I must exercise my Fifth Amendment right. 1 MR. : Same instruction. same
2 BY MS. EZELL: 2 objection.
3 Q. Do you recall telling — no, sorry. 3 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
4 Did you and Jane No. 103 become friendly? 4 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
5 MR. Object to the form, lack of 5 BY MS. EZELL:
6 foundation as to any relationship with Jane No. 103 6 Q. Did, did you give yourself Jane No 103 any
7 or knowledge of a person named Jane No. 103. 7 gifts?
a Instruct the witness not to answer. 8 MR. : I'm sorry. can you rephrase?
9 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 9 BY MS. EZELL:
10 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 10 Q. Didyou ourself give Jane No 103 any gifts?
11 BY MS. F7Fil I • 11 MR. : Objection to the form.
12 Q. Do you remember that Jane No. 103 came to 12 Instruct the witness not to answer the question.
13 Mr. Epstein's home on or about July 23rd. 2004? 13 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
14 MR. Object to the form, leading. as 14 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
15 well as previously stated objection to the last 15 BY MS. EZELL:
16 question. 16 Q. Did you ever buy gifts for Jeffrey Epstein to
17 BY MS. EZELL: 17 give to Jane No 103?
18 re Q. And do ou member -- 18 MR. : Objection to form.
19 MR. Hold on. 19 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
20 MS. EZELL Sorry. 20 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
21 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 21 BY MS. EZELL:
22 I wish to invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 22 Q. Did you ever receive massages at the El Brillo
23 BY MS. F7Ft I • 23 Way house?
24 Q. Do you remember that Jane No. 103 continued tc 24 MR. : Objection to form, lack of
25 come to Mr. Epstein's house and indeed came over 100 25 foundation. Same instruction.
Page 430 Page 432
1 times over about a •ear and a half? 1 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
2 MR. : Object to the form for reasons 2 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
3 previously stated in the last several questions. 3 BY MS. EZELL:
4 Instruct her not to answer. 4 Q. Did you receive massages given by
5 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 5 ?
6 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 6 MR. Objection to the form. lack of
7 BY MS. F7FI I • 7 foundation as to any knowledge of a person named
8 Q. Do you remember calling to tell Jane No. 103 8 Lack of knowkdge as to any. lack
9 that Mr. Epstein would be coming in town and would like 9 of foundation as to any connection to EA Brillo
10 to see her? 10 Way. Instruct the witness not to answer.
11 MR. • Objection to form, instruct the 11 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
12 witness not to answer. 12 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
13 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 13 BY MS. EZELL:
14 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 14 Q.
15 BY MS. F7FII 1 :
16 Q. Did you overhear Mr. Epstein himself call Jane 16 MR. It's been asked and answered.
17 No. 103 at her home? 17 objection to form.
18 MR. : Objection to the form, lack of 18 MS. P7PI T • No. I didn't ask about Monterey.
19 foundation as to any knowledge of Jeffrey Epstein. 19 California
20 Instruct her not to answer. 20 MR. You asked about any Edge Group
21 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 21 meetings in California. and she said she has no
22 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 22 idea what the Edge Group is.
23 BY MS. F7Ft 1 • 23 MR. GARCIA: I thought she took the Fifth on
24 Q. Did you and Jane No. 103 ever go shopping 24 that.
25 together? 25 MR. I thought she said she didn't
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
17 (Pages 429 to 432)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0a18-4599-a2a0-6d38827b68c6
3501.125-027
Page 17 of 21
Page 433 Page 435
1 know what the Edge Group was, but whatever. you car 1 BY MS. F7FI I •
2 answer the question. 2 Q. Do you want to respond? I didn't give you
3 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 3 time.
4 I must choose to invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 4 MR. : I've instructed her not to
5 BY MS. EZELL: 5 answer the question. Let's move on.
6 Q. Do ou know Max Brockman? 6 BY MS. EZELL:
7 MR. : I'm sorry. can you repeat? 7 Q. Do you recall a dinner at El Brillo Way
8 BY MS. EZELL: 8 attended by David Copperfield where Jane No. 103 was a
9 Q. Do ou know a Max Brockman? 9 guest?
10 MR. : I believe that was asked and 10 MR. : Objection to the form, lack of
11 answered already. but -- 11 foundation, and a standing objection as to her
12 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 12 knowledge of anything involving El Brillo Way or
13 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 13 Jeffrey Epstein. Instruct her not to answer.
14 BY MS. EZELL: 14 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
15 Q. Have you ever been photographed with Max 15 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
16 Brockman at an Edge Science dinner? 16 BY MS. F7FI I •
17 A. At the instruction of my lawyer. I must invoke 17 Q. What is the relationship between Jeffrey
18 my Fifth Amendment ri ht. 18 Epstein and David Co rfield?
19 MR. : You should let me -- I need to 19 MR. : Objection to form, lack of
20 object to the form of the question first, but go 20 foundation as to her knowledge of either one of
21 ahead. I know we all want to get out of here. Go 21 those people. Instruct her not to answer.
22 ahead. 22 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
23 THE WITNESS: Say it again. 23 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
24 MR. : No. you are okay. Go ahead, 24 BY MS. F7FI I •
25 Ms. Ezell. Thank you. 25 Q. To your knowledge, do they recruit girls for
Page 434 Page 436
1 BY MS. EZELL: 1 one another?
2 Q. Do you know whether Jeffrey Epstein attended 2 MR. : Object to the form. compound
3 the Edge Science dinner in Monterey, California? 3 and again, lack of foundation. Instruct her not to
4 MR. Objection to the form, lack of 4 answer.
5 foundation. Instruct the witness not to answer. 5 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
6 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 6 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
7 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 7 BY MS. EZELL:
8 BY MS. F7Ft I • 8 Q. To your knowledge. are they involved in any
9 0 9 sexual traffickin of oung women?
10 MR. : Object to the form for the
11 reasons previously stated. Also calls for a legal
12 conclusion as to what sexual trafficking is.
13 At what a e were those photographs taken? 13 Instruct her not to answer.
14 MR. I'm going to instruct her not 14 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
15 to answer that. It has nothing to do with 15 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
16 anything. It's not reasonably calculated to lead 16 BY MS. EZELL:
17 to discoverable evidence. We can move on. 17 Q. I believe you asked about Allen Dershowitz
18 BY MS. EZELL: 18 earlier.
19 Q. Were you in any way damaged by that 19 MR. : Twice.
20 experience? 20 BY MS. EZELL:
21 MR. Same instruction. Let's move 21 Q. And were instructed not to answer.
22 on. 22 MR. : Twice.
23 BY MS. EZELL: 23 BY MS. EZELL:
24 Q. Do ou have an regrets? 24 Q. All right. I'm going to ask again on behalf
25 MR. . Same instruction. Move on. 25 of my client. Are you aware or the friendship betw cell
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
18 (Pages 433 to 436)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d149941ed11-4599-a2a0-6d38827b68e6
3501.125-027
Page 18 of 21
Page 437 Page 439
1 Allen Dershowitz and Jeffrey Epstein? 1 BY MS. EZELL:
2 MR. : And for the third time. I'll 2 Q. Do you know that when David Coppetheld is in
3 object to the form and instruct her not to answer 3 town. he gives Jeffrey Epstein tickets and Jeffrey gives
4 the question. 4 some to your women to attend those shows?
5 THE WITNESS: For the third time. I take the 5 MR. Object to the form, multiple.
6 advice of my lawyer and invoke my Fifth Amendment 6 compound question. and a complete lack of
7 right. 7 foundation. Instruct the witness not to answer.
8 BY MS. EZELL: 8 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
9 Q. When Allen Dershowitz comes to Palm Beach. he 9 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
10 stays at the El Brillo mansion, doesn't he? 10 BY MS. EZELL:
11 MR. : Objection to the form. There 11 Q. And do you know that those girls are invited
12 is no foundation for her having any knowledge of 12 back stage after the show?
13 anything having to do with a person by the name of 13 MR. . Same objection. complete lack
14 Allen Dershowitz. I instruct her not to answer. 14 of foundation, and standing objection previously
15 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 15 stated.
16 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 16 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer.
17 BY MS. EZELL: 17 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
18 Q. When Allen Dershowitz. or has Allen Dershowitz 18 BY MS. EZELL:
19 ever been there when oung ladies came to give massages' 19 Q. Do you remember on or about, in or about March
20 MR. : Same objection stated to the 20 of 2005 having conversations with one of the young women
21 previous question. Same instruction. 21 who came to the house to give massages about her
22 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 22 conversations with Jane No. 103?
23 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 23 MR. Objection to the form, standing
24 BY MS. F7F/ i - 24 objection. lack of foundation. Instruct the
25 Q. Has Allen Dershowitz ever been the beneficiary 25 witness not to answer, because the question implies
Page 438 Page 440
1 of those masse es? 1 that she has any knowledge at all of El Brillo Way.
2 MR. Same objection and same 2 BY MS. EZELL:
3 instruction. 3 Q. Same question -- sorry.
4 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 4 A. At the instruction of my lawyer. I must choose
5 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 5 to invoke my Fifth Amendment privilege.
6 BY MS. EZELL: 6 Q. Same • uestion as to March of 2006.
7 Q. Do you know John Casablanca? 7 MR. Same objection and same
8 A. Never heard that name before. 8 instruction.
9 Q. Have you ever heard of a world-famous 9 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
10 illusionist whose stage name is David Copperfield? 10 I must choose to invoke my Fifth Amendment
11 MR. That's also been asked at least 11 privilege.
12 three times. I'll instruct her again not to answer 12 BY MS. EZELL:
13 the question. 13 Q. Do you have an  of a conversation
14 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 19 in which one of the = women told Jane No. 103 that
15 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 15 those girls who, those girls who would help Jeffrey in
16 BY MS. EZELL: 16 regard to the investigation would be compensated and
17 Q. Have you ever gone to one of David 17 those who would not or who would hurt him in the
18 Copperfield's shows? 18 investigation would be dealt with?
19 MR. Objection to form, lack of 19 MR. : Objection to the form, lack of
20 foundation as to knowledge of any person by the 20 foundation, compound question. Instruct the
21 name of David Copperfield. Instruct her not to 21 witness not to answer, because the question implies
22 answer. 22 some knowledge of anything relating to a person by
23 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 23 the name of Jeffrey Epstein.
24 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 24 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
25 25 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
19 (Pages 437 to 4 40)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-04:48-4599-a2a0-8d38827b88e8
3501.125-027
Page 19 of 21
Page 441 Page 443
1 By MS. F7Fil I: 1 BY MS. EZELL:
2 Q. Do you know John Brockman? 2 Q. Did you escort those underage girls to the
3 A. At the instruction of my lawyer. I must invoke 3 massage room where the defendant would enter and urg
4 my Fifth Amendment right. 4 the girls to remove their clothes?
5 Q. Do you know of someone named Brockman being 5 MR. : Objection to the form, asks a
6 the editor and publisher of a publication of the Edge 6 compound question. several questions within one.
7 Foundation? 7 Also assumes knowledge of a person by the name
8 MR. : Object to the form. There is 8 of Jeffrey Epstein and a massage room, so there is
9 no foundation that she has any knowledge of any 9 no foundation. Instruct the witness not to answer.
10 entity by the name of the Edge Foundation, and I 10 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
11 would instruct her not to answer the question based 11 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
12 on her Fifth Amendment privilege. 12 BY MS. EZELL:
13 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 13 Q. Did you ever tell the girls to remove their
14 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 14 clothes?
15 BY MS. F7F11 • 15 MR. : Same objection and the same
16 Q. Did you participate in a scheme by Jeffrey 16 instruction.
17 Epstein to recruit underage girls to come to his 17 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
18 residence to .rovide massages? 18 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
19 MR. : Objection to the form, calls 19 BY MS. EZELL:
20 for a legal conclusion. Also has no foundation as 20 Q. And did you sometimes deliver cash from the
21 to any knowledge of a person by the name of Jeffrey 21 defendant to the underage girls after they performed the
22 Epstein. and because it calls for a legal 22 massage?
23 conclusion. I'll simply instruct her not to answer 23 MR. : That's been asked at least
24 the question at all. Move on. 24 three or four other times.
25 25 MS. EZELL: I'm asking on behalf of my client.
Page 442 Page 444
1 BY MS. F7Ft I • 1 MR. I understand, but we've been
2 Q. Did you assist, support. and facilitate 2 here for over an hour. and we can't just keep going
3 Jeffrey Epstein's child exploitation enterprise? 3 over. If they have been asked in the deposition.
4 MR. Once again, objection the 4 your clients can have the benefit of the answer,
5 question. calls for a legal conclusion as to what 5 but we've been here now for almost eight hours and
6 is an enterprise, which is a term of art in the 6 you still --
7 criminal law about which this witness has no 7 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer,
8 knowledge. and it's a legal conclusion not likely 8 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right.
9 to lead to discoverable evidence. So I would 9 BY MS. EZELL:
10 instruct her not to answer the question at all. 10 Q. Did you ever take pan in delivering cash from
11 BY MS. EZELL: 11 the defendant to the procurers of the underage girls who
12 Q. Did arrange times for underage to 12 came for the massy e a intments?
you girls
come to Jerrie tein's residence?
MR. Objection to form, standing
MR. : Objection to the form. The
term procure is a legal term of art, and I'll
15 objection previously stated. 15 instruct the witness not to respond to the question
16 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer, 16 at all.
17 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment privilege. 17 BY MS. EZELL:
18 BY MS. EZELL: 18 Q. Did you. did you by using the telephone assist
19 Q. Did you arrange. transport, or yourself 19 Jeffrey Epstein in enabling himself to commit sexual
20 transport underage girls to or from Jeffrey Epstein's 20 on, and acts of lewdness in the presence of
21 residence? 21
a  women?
22 MR. Same objection. same 22 MR. : Same as the previous
23 instruction as the last question. 23 instruction. Instruct the witness not to answer
24 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 24 the question at all, because it results in a legal
25 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment privilege. 25 question. not a factual question. so it's not
20 (Pages 441 to 4 4 4)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge (IMMMI)
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0cd8-4599-a2a0-6c1391327b68c6
3501.125-027
Page 20 of 21
Page 445 Page 447
1 reasonably designed to lead to discoverable 1 deposition or you may waive reading and allow the
2 evidence. 2 court reporter to simply type it up and distribute
3 BY MS. F7Ft I • 3 it to the lawyers who order it.
4 Q. Did you facilitate these acts as well as 4 Do you choose to read or waive?
5 assisting Mr. E rein in avoiding police detection? 5 THE WITNESS: Waive.
6 MR. Same instruction. 6 MS. EZELL: Thank you.
7 BY MS. EZELL: 7 MR. Thank you.
8 Q. Do you know when and by whom the computers 8 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Oka . this concludes
9 were removed from the El Brillo mansion? 9 today's videotape deposition of The
10 MR. Objection to the form, lack of 10 time is l8:51.
11 foundation, and it also assumes knowledge of a 11 (Witness excused.)
12 place known as the El Brillo mansion. So instruct 12 (Deposition was concluded.)
13 the witness not to answer the question based on the 13
14 Fifth Amendment. 14
15 THE WITNESS: At the instruction of my lawyer. 15
16 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 16
17 BY MS. F7Fr I • 17
18 Q. Was Jane No. 103 invited to just come and hang 18
19 out at the El Brillo mansion? 19
20 MR. Objection to the form, same as 20
21 the previous question. It assumes knowledge of a 21
22 place known as the El Brillo mansion and a person 22
23 by the name of Jane No. 103. It is compound and 23
24 lacking in foundation. 24
25 THE WITNESS: at the instruction of my lawyer, 25
Page 446 Page 448
1 I must invoke my Fifth Amendment right. 1 CERTIFICATE
2 THE STATE OF FLORIDA 2 BY MS. EZELL: 3 COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
3 Q. Have you called any girls under the age of 18 4
4 in Palm Beach or West Palm Beach in the last six years? 5 I. Rachel W. Bridge. Registered Professional
Reporter. Florida Professional Reporter and Notary 5 MR. For any purpose? 6 Public in and for the State of Florida at 
large, do
6 MS. EZELL: Yes. hereby certify that I was authorized to and did report
7 said deposition in stenotype: and that the foregoing 7 THE WITNESS: Can you repeat the question? pages am a true and 
correct transcription of my
8 BY MS. EZELL: 8 shorthand notes of said deposition.
9 Q. Have you called any girls under the age of 18 9 I further certify that said deposition was
10 in Palm Beach or West Palm Beach in the last six years? 10
taken at the time and place hereinabove set forth and
that the taking of said deposition was commenced and
11 MR. You can answer that yes or no. completed as hereinabove set out.
it 12 if you know. I further certify that I am not attorney or
13 THE WITNESS: I don't think so. 12 counsel of any of the panics. nor ant I a relative or
14 MS. EZELL: I don't have any other questions. 13
employee of any attorney or counsel of party connected
with the action. nor am I financially interested in the 1 5 Thank you. action.
16 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: All set? 14
The foregoing certification of this transcript 17 MR. Yes. 15 does nor apply to any reproduction of the same by any
18 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: This concludes today's means unless under the direct control andfor direction
videotape deposition of

MR. Hold on. I'm sorry, one last
of the certifying reporter.
Dated this 9th day of April.
21 thing. Since you're the last defense person or 19
2022 plaintiffs lawyer standing. I guess you need to 21 RR. FPR
23 advise her she has the right to read or waive on 22
24 the record. 23
24 25 MS. EZELL: You do have the right to read this 25
Electronically signed by Rachel Bridge
21 (Pages 445 to 4 48)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
CONFIDENTIAL
905d1499-0,48-4599-a2a0-6d3882713418e6
3501.125-027
Page 21 of 21
EFTA00181769 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Jane Doe #2 v. Jeffrey Epstein questions about Story Cowles
(date: 2010-04-13)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
CASE NO. 08-CV-80893-CIV-MARRA/JOHNSON
JANE DOE,
Plaintiff,
vs.
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, et al.,
Defendants.
/
Related Cases:
08-80119, 08-80232, 08-80380, 08-80381,
08-80994, 08-80811, 08-80893, 09-80469,
09-8-591, 09-80656, 09-80802, 09-81092
VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF
TAKEN ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF
DATE: April 13, 2010
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
April 13,2010
INDEX
WITNESS DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS
BY MR. EDWARDS 5 98
BY MR. HOROWITZ 65
BY MR. LANGINO 77
BY MS. EZELL 8I
10 EXHIBITS
11 PLAINTIFF'S
FOR IDENTIFICATION
I Message dated August 21,2005.
PAGE
APPEARANCES (CONTINUED)
2 LEOPOLD-KUVIN
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
3 II. B. and CI'.
2925 PGA Boulevard, Suite 200
4 Palm Beach Garden, Florida 33410
Tel: (561)515-1400
BY: ADAM J. LANGINO, ESQ. 5
PODHURST, ORSECK
Attorneys for Jane Does I and 3
City National Bank Building, Suite 88
9 25 West Saida Street
Miami, Florida 33130
10 Tel: (954)463-4346
BY: KATHERINE W. EZELL, ESQ.
12 BURMAN. CIUTTON, LUTITER & COLEMAN, LIP
Attorneys for Defendant Jeffrey Epstein
13 303 Banyon Boukvard. Suite 400
West Palm Beach. Florida 33401
14 Tel: (561)842-2820
BY: DAVID YAREMA, ESQ.
15 ROBERT turret'', ESQ.
AlTERBURY, GOLDBERGER & WEISS
17 Co-Counsel for Defendarus
One Clearbke Court
18 Suite 1400
West Palm Beach. Florida 33401
19 Tel: (561)659.8300
BY: JACK A. GOLDBERGER. ESQ.
ALSO PRESENT:
JESSICA CADWELL
JOE ROVNER. Videographer
(U.S. Legal)
1 The videotaped deposition of —
2 in the above-entitled and numbered
3 cause, was taken before me, TERRI BECKER, a
4 Registered Professional Reporter and Notary
5 Public for the State of Florida at Large, at 444
6 West Railroad Avenue, in the City of West Palm
7 Beach, Palm Beach County, in the State of
8 Florida, beginning at the hour of 10:00 o'clock
9 a.m., pursuant to the Notice in said cause for
10 the taking of said deposition which is annexed to
11 the court file herein, on behalf of the PLAINTIFF
12 in the above-entitled action pending in the
13 above-named court.
14 The appearances at said time and place
15 were as follows:
16 FARMER, JAFFE, WEISSING, EDWARDS,
FISTOS & LEHRMAN, PL
17 Attorneys for Plaintiffs Jane Does,
L.N. and E.W.
18 425 North Andrews Avenue
Suite 2
19 Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301
Tel: (954) 524-2820
20 BY: BRADLEY J. EDWAltDS, ESQ.
MERMELSTEIN & HOROWITZ, P.A.
22 Attorneys for Plaintiffs Jane Does,
numbers 2 through 8
23 18205 Biscayne Boulevard
Suite 2218
24 Miami, Florida 33160
Tel: (305) 931-2200
25 BY: ADAM D. HOROWITZ, ESQ.
1 THEREUPON,
3 being by Terri Becker lint duly sworn to tell
4 the whole truth, as hereinafter certified,
5 testified as follows:
6 DIRECT EXAMINATION
7 BY MR. EDWARDS:
8 Q Can you tell us your name.
0 Q What Is your date of birth?
1 A February 21, 1985.
2 Q What is your Social Security number?
3 A Under advice of my counsel, I invoke my
4 privileges under the Fifth and Sixth Amendments
5 to the United States Constitution and
respectfully decline to answer the question.
Q Where were you born?
A I'm sorry, though I would like to answer
your question, I must invoke my Fifth and Sixth
Amendment privileges and refuse to answer your
questions.
Q What is your current address?

MR. GOLDBERGER: There is going to be a
continued, obviously, you anticipate I'm
sure, continued invocation of Fifth
2 (Pages 2 to 5)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
B
Amendment privileges. If it is okay with
all counsel, to shorten things, I'll simply
have the witness say "Fifth." if that
satisfies everyone's interest.

MR. EDWARDS: That is fine with me.
MR. GOLDBERGER: Okay, with that Cathy?
MS. EZELL: Yes.
MR. HOROWITZ: Yes.
A The Fifth.
Q Do you know a lady by the name of
Maritsa Vazques?
A The Fifth.
Q Is this somebody who helped to falsify a
visa for you?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A The Fifth.
9 Q reask the question, what's your 9 Q Do you know Evelyn Velasaques?
10 current address? 10 A The Fifth.
11 A Fifth. 11 Q Were you ever a working model in the
12 Q Are you currently living at 358 El 12 United States?
13 Brillo Way with a man named Jeffrey Epstein? 13 A The Fifth.
14 A The Fifth. 14 Q Can you tell us your parents' names?
15 Q Are you also familiar with all address in 15 A The Fifth.
16 New York, 301 East 66th Street? 16 Q Flow is it that you have supported
17 A The Fifth. 17 yourself financially, since you have been in this
18 Q When Mr. Epstein was incarcerated in 18 country?
19 jail, you went to visit him on numerous 19 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
20 occasions; is that correct? 20 A The Fifth.
21 MR. YAREMA: Objection. 21 Q Have you supported yourself financially?
22 A Thc Fifth. 22 A The Fifth.
23 Q When you went to visit him you indicated 23 Q What is the last grade you completed in
24 to jail personnel your address was 301 East 66th 24 school?
25 Street, apartment 8-D in New York City, New York; 25 A The Fifth, I take the Fifth Amendment.
7 9
1 Is that correct? 1 Q Are you in school now?
2 MR. YAREMA: Objection. 2 A The Fifth.
3 A Fifth. 3 Q Have you ever attended any school in the
4 Q Isn't it true when Mr. Epstein was In 4 United States?
5 jail, you visited him on more than 50 occasions? 5 A The Fifth.
6 MR. YARE•MA: Form objection. 6 Q Ilave you ever been employed since
7 Q True? 7 residing in the United States?
8 A The Fifth. 8 A The Fifth.
9 Q Flow long have you been in the United 9 Q Is Jeffrey Epstein your sole means of
10 States, Ms. 10 financial support today?
11 A The Fifth. 11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
12 Q Who brought you to the United States? 12 A Thc Fifth.
13 MR. YAREMA: Form objection. 13 Q Since coming to this country, hasn't
14 A The Fifth. 14 Jeffrey Epstein always been your sole means of
15 Q What is your current status In this 15 financial support?
16 country? 16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
17 A The Fifth. 17 A The Fifth.
18 MR. YAREMA: Form objection. 18 Q Flow much does Jeffrey Epstein pay you
19 MR. GOLDBERGER: Let me take a half a 19 today?
20 second. 20 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
21 (Witness and her counsel confer.) 21 A The Fifth.
22 Q Are you a U.S. citizen? 22 Q What does every Epstein pay you for?
23 A The Fifth. 23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
24 Q What type of visa are you here on? 24 A The Fifth.
25 MR. YAREMA: Form objection. 25 Q Does he pay you specifically to be his
3 (Pages 6 to 9)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
10 12
1 sex slave?
2 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
3 A The
4 Q Are you aware that the reports about you
5 indicate that you were brought to the United
States by Jeffrey Epstein when you were roughly
13 or 14 years old to be his Yugoslavian lesbian
sex slave?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A The Fifth.
Q Is that true?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A The Fifth.
Q Have you performed any services for
Jeffrey Epstein aside from being his sex slave?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A The Fifth.
Q What Is your sexual orientation?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.

MR. GOLDBERGER: I'm going to instruct
the witness not to answer that question. It
serves no purpose other than to harass or
intimidate her, so in addition to Fifth
Amendment privileges, I'm objecting on
privacy grounds.
1 Epstein's sex slaves?
2 MR. YAREMA: Object to the Iona
3 A Fifth.
4 Q What does it mean to be Jeffrey
5 Epstein's sex slave?
6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
7 A Fifth.
8 Q Are you aware that Jeffrey Epstein reads
9 books on how to be a proper master to his sex
10 slave?
11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
12 A Fifth.
13 Q What has Jeffrey Epstein done to train
14 you to be his sex slave?
15 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
16 A Fifth.
17 Q What do your parents think about you
18 being Jeffrey Epstein's sex slave?
19 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
20 A Fifth.
21 Q When did you first learn that Jeffrey
22 Epstein had a sexual obsession for underage minor
23 females?
24 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
25 A Fifth.
1 A I take the Fifth.
2 Q I represent a lady named, a young female
3 named E.W.; you know who that is, right?
4 Ma. YAREMA: Object to the form.
S A The Fifth.
6 Q Jeffrey Epstein made you have sex with
7 E.W., didn't he?
8 MR: YAREMA: Object to die form.
A The Fifth.
Q You did, in fact, engage in sexual
activity with E.W. when she was only 16 years
old; isn't that true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A The Fifth.
Q Back to my original question: And I'll
ask you this way: Do you consider yourself
heterosexual, bi-sexual, or can you answer that
question?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
MR. GOLDBERGER: Seine objection. Do not
answer the question.
A Fifth.
Q How did you meet Jeffrey Epstein?
A Fifth.
Q When did you become one of Jeffrey
Q How many times has Jeffrey Epstein made
you have sex with underage minor females?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Do you enjoy sex with underage minor
females?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q What is the youngest child that Jeffrey
Epstein has forced you to have sex with?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Does Jeffrey Epstein today still make
you have sex with underage minor females?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q How ninny underage minor females has
Jeffrey Epstein made you have sex with, since you
were over the age of 18?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A The Fifth.
Q Prior to turning 18, Is it true that
Jeffrey Epstein made you have sex with many other
children in kid-type orgies?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form
4 (Pages 10 to 13)
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
14 16
1 A Fifth.
2 Q Has Jeffrey Epstein also made you
3 perform sexually on his friends?
4 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
5 A Fifth.
6 Q Do you know David Copperfield?
7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
8 A Fifth.
Q Have you ever been made to perform
sexually on David Copperfield?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you know Prince Andrew?
A Fifth.
Q Have you ever been made to perform
sexually on Prince Andrew?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q When was the first time that you knew
Jeffrey Epstein molested underage girls?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein molest you when you
were underage?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Have you read the nonprosecution
agreement between the government and Jeffrey
Epstein?
A Fifth.
Q Are you aware that inside that document
you are labeled as a co-conspirator of his crimes
against children?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Isn't it true that your role was to lure
or procure underage minor females to Jeffrey
Epstein for him to molest, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q You also scheduled appointments for
Jeffrey Epstein, so there would be designated
times for Jeffrey Epstein to molest underage
minor females, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A The Fifth.
Q As well, you participated in various sex
acts with underage minor females, thus molesting
them yourself; is that correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
B
A Fifth.
Q I'm assuming you understand why you're
here today, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A The Fifth.
Q For allegations related to Jeffrey
Epstein interacting sexually with numerous
underage minor females; that's something you
know, right?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A The Fifth.
Q That's something In addition to the
civil lawsuits, there were criminal cases
involving the same conduct, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q You were n part of that criminal
investigation, in fact, you were a co-conspirator
of Jeffrey Epstein's; is that right?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q What crimes did you conspire to commit
with Jeffrey Epstein against underage minor
females?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you understand that Jeffrey Epstein's
interaction with underage minor females is
illegal? Do you understand that?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A The Fifth.
Q Do you understand that the Lewd and
Lascivious Molestation Statute in Florida
indicates a person who intentionally touches in a
lewd or lascivious manner, the breasts, genital
area or buttocks, or the clothing covering them,
of a person less than 16 years of age, or forces
or entices a person under 16 years of age, to so
touch the perpetrator, commits lewd or lascivious
molestation? Are you aware of that statute?
A Fifth.
Q That is a statute that you know Jeffrey
Epstein to have violated; is that true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A The Fifth.
Q That's a statute that you yourself have
violated; is that true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A The Fifth.
Q You've observed Jeffrey Epstein violate
5 (Pages 14 to 17)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
18 20
that statute on many underage minor females,
true?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the tbnn.
A The Fifth.
Q Have you ever discussed with Jeffrey
Epstein that the fact that he is a child
molester?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Have you asked Jeffrey Epstein why he
has made you interact with underage minor females
in a sexual manner?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q During the litigation of these civil
eases, has Jeffrey Epstein indicated to you an
intent to continue to molest children?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Is it your intent to continue to commit
sex crimes against minors?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
A Fifth.
Q in addition to your being named as a
co-conspirator of Jeffrey Epstein regarding his
co-conspirator in the non-prosecution agreement
related to Jeffrey Epstein's crimes against
minors?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you know
IIIMP A Fifth.
Q These are all people who also
participated in Jeffrey Epstein's scheme to lure
underage females to him for sex; is that true?
MIL YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q You and these other co-conspirators
played various roles to make sure Jeffrey Epstein
was able to engage in sexual contact or conduct,
with underage minor females on an everyday basis;
is that true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Since the time you first met Jeffrey
Epstein, has his appetite for underage minor
females always been the same?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
1 crimes against minors, there Is also a person
2 ram. listed as a co-conspirator.
3 Do you know IMM?
4 A Fifth.
5 Q This is somebody who lives with you and
6 Jeffrey Epstein; is that true?
7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
8 A Fifth.
9 Q And is somebody who you
10 know to be Story Cowles's girlfriend; is that
11 true?
12 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonts.
13 A Fifth.
14 Q She's spoken with Story Cowles about
15 this case on numerous occasions; is that true?
16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
17 A Fifth.
18 conversations with Story
19 Cowles and your observations of them, you believe
20 would implicate you in a crime and that's why
21 you're able to take the Fifth as to that
22 question?
23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
24 A Fifth.
25 Q Who is Lesley Croft, also listed as a
Q By that I mean, have you observed
Jeffrey Epstein to interact sexually with
underage minor females literally on a daily
basis?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Wasn't it one of your specific job
duties to make sure that he had different
underage minor females to molest on a daily
basis?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q In addition to the improper sexual
contact between Jeffrey Epstein and underage
minor females at the West Paint Beach house, you
have observed similar improper and illegal
contact by Jeffrey Epstein in his New York
mansion, as well, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q In fact, he operates a very similar
scheme up there, in that he schedules these
appointments with underage minor females, under
the guise that it is going to be a massage; is
that correct?
6 (Pages 18 to 21)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
22 24
1 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form?
2 A Fifth.
3 Q When he is in New York, he has contact
4 with underage minor remain for the purposes of
5 sexually molesting them as well; is that
6 correct?
7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
8 A Fifth.
Q When he is in his ranch In New Mexico,
similarly, Jeffrey Epstein is engaging in sex
with underage minor females front that local area
as well, and that's something you've observed?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Filth.
Q On his island, particularly, lie has
flown underage minor females to the island for
underage kid-type orgies; is that true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q You're shaking your head Indicating, at
least to me, indicating that you may not agree
with what I'm saying, and I would love to give
you the chance to explain it to us.

MR. GOLDBERGER: I appreciate that, but
don't —
when Jeffrey Epstein commits these crimes against
children?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
A Fifth.
Q Is there any way for you to escape being
his sex slave?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
A Fifth.
Q Have you ever wanted to cooperate with
the authorities, so that you could escape being
his sex slave?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Do you represent to others that you arc
his girlfriend or his sex slave, or some other
designation?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the toms.
A Fifth.
Q Isn't it true that you recently
represented to the Probation Officer that you
were his live-in girlfriend?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q When Probation calls the house, are you
told to tell Probation that he is in the swimming
1 MR. EDWARDS: Read too much into it?
2 MR. GOLDBERGER: Exactly. Don't go
3 there. Just ask the questions and we will
4 move right along.

MR. EDWARDS: I agree, Jack, I just know
6 if this is played for a jury, I don't went
7 the jury to interpret her shaking her head
8 as a "No," and then her pleading the Fifth.
9 MR. GOLDBERGER: I appreciate that.
10 Don't take anything as to any head movements
11 or any body movements at all. Just ask the
12 questions and we will let the video speak
13 for itself.
14 Q How many of these — you know what an
15 orgy is, don't you?
16 A Fifth.
17 Q And how many of these orgies, as I'm
18 calling them, where there are numerous underage
19 minors having sex with each other and with
20 Jeffrey Epstein, have you observed on Jeffrey
21 Epstein's island?
22 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
23 A Fifth.
24 Q Is part of your role as Jeffrey
25 Epstein's sex slave, to not tell the authorities
pool or doing some other activity that would not
allow him to come to the telephone?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the foam
A Fifth.
Q Isn't it true you're under strict orders
to tell Probation that?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Isn't ft true you've heard Jeffrey
Epstein tell you on numerous occasions, regarding
the age of the girls that he wants to his house,
for the purposes of sexually molesting, the
phrase he uses is "the younger the better,"
true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q I asked you earlier about E.W. out of
turn as a result of an objection related to your
sexual orientation, but I'll talk specifically
about E.W. right now. You know who that is,
right?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q That is somebody you observed Jeffrey
Epstein to call for the purposes of getting her
7 (Pages 22 to 25)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
to his house to sexually molest; is that right?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q The first time she went to Jeffrey
minor females?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q You have received oral sex from underage
5 Epstein's house was in 2002 when she was only 14 minor females?
6 years old; is that true? 6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 7 A Filth.
8 A Fifth. 8 Q All of these sexual acts with minor
9 Q In fact In 2002 you were only 18 years 9 females involving you happened in the presence of
10 old or so yourself; is that right? 10 Jeffrey Epstein?
11 A Fifth. 11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
12 Q And E.W. is somebody you observed at 12 A Fifth.
13 Jeffrey Epstein's house on more than 100 13 Q During your interaction with underage
14 occasions between 2002 and 2005, a time period 14 minor females in a sexual manner, isn't it true
15 between 14 and 17 years of age for her; is that 15 that Jeffrey Epstein would participate in the
16 right? 16 sexual acts and the act would be over upon
17 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 17 Jeffrey Epstein ejaculating, correct?
18 A Fifth. 18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
19 Q And each time E.W. was summoned to 19 A Fifth.
20 Jeffrey Epstein's house, it was for the purposes 20 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you, that when
21 of Jeffrey Epstein sexually molesting her, 21 E.W. was an underage minor female, he forced her
22 correct? 22 to give him oral sex?
23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn. 23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
24 A Filth. 24 A Fifth.
25 Q If it was not Jeffrey Epstein personally 25 Q Do you remember E.W. coming over, a
27 29
1 calling E.W., you observed to call 1 young girl, with braces on, and going up into
2 E.W. for the purposes of her coming over and 2 Jeffrey Epstein's bedroom on numerous occasions
3 pleasing Jeffrey Epstein sexually, correct? 3 to be sexually molested?
4 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 4 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
5 A Fifth. S A Fifth.
6 Q And do you remember the instance where 6 Q Do you know when it was that Jeffrey
7 Jeffrey Epstein instructed you to lay down naked 7 Epstein developed his plan or scheme to gain
8 and engage in a threesome with E.W. and Jeffrey 8 access to hundreds of underage minor females for
9 Epstein? 9 the purposes of his sexual gratification?
10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
11 A Fifth. 11 A Fifth.
12 Q Do you remember that that during that 12 Q Were you a part of the planning of that
13 threesome, Jeffrey Epstein demanded E.W. to 13 scheme of Jeffrey Epstein's to gain Recess to
14 straddle you and otherwise engage sexually with 14 underage minor females?
15 you while Jeffrey Epstein was using vibrators 15 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
16 and/or dildos on you? 16 A Fifth.
17 MR. YAREMA: Object to the font 17 Q Do you know Ghislaine Maxwell?
18 A Fifth. 18 A Fifth.
19 Q in addition to your sexual interactions 19 Q Is that somebody who helped Jeffrey
20 with E.W., isn't it true that you have used 20 Epstein to devise the scheme to allow him access
21 strap-on dildos and vibrators on other underage 21 to various and n variety of underage minor
22 minors at Jeffrey Epstein's direction? 22 females?
23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
24 A Fifth. 24 A Fifth.
25 Q You have given oral sex to underage 25 Q Is somebody that was also
8 (Pages 26 to 29)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
30 32
involved in the planning of this scheme to gain
access to underage minor females?
MR. YAREM A: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q When is the first time that you observed
Jeffrey Epstein's method of enticing or Inducing
underage minor females into sexual acts with him
inside his bedroom?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Isn't it true that after an underage
minor female was brought to Jeffrey F.pstein's
house, typically or Adriana or
yourself would lead that underage minor female to
Jeffrey Epstein's bedroom and leave them alone in
the room; is that true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Then Jeffrey Epstein would appear either
naked or wearing a towel; is that true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q This is his habit or method of
operation, every single time, and that's
something that he has told you about his sexual
a
sex toys on you, correct?
A Fifth.
Q And he has instructed you to use sex
toys and vibrators on other underage minor
females, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q You have observed Jeffrey Epstein
digitally penetrate the vagina of underage minor
females, including E.W., correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q As part of his plan to avoid detection
by law enforcement, you have observed Jeffrey
Epstein to pay these underage minor females to he
quiet, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q And this is something that he has told
you he does, for the purposes of grooming these
underage minor females, and avoiding law
enforcement detection, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A . Fifth.
Q Jeffrey Epstein has talked to you about
1 interaction with underage minors; is that true?
2 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
3 A Fifth.
4 Q And he would direct or demand or
5 instruct the underage minor female to remove her
6 clothing; is that true?
7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Then he would perform one or more lewd
or lascivious or sexual acts on the underage
minor female. Is that true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q And you have observed Jeffrey Epstein
engage in sexual interaction with underage minor
females on hundreds and hundreds of occasions,
correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q And you have observed Jeffrey Epstein
using vibrators and sexual toys on underage
minors, true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q In fact, he has also used vibrators and
1 the psychology of brainwashing or grooming
2 underage minor females to perform for him
3 sexually, hasn't he?
4 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
5 A Fifth.
6 Q And Sarah Kellen has also spoken with
7 you about the methodology behind gaining access
8 to and grooming underage minor females for sex?
9 MR. YAREMA: Object to form.
10 A Fifth.
11 Q Isn't it true that Chislaine Maxwell and
12 yourself and had access to a master
13 list of underage minor females names and phone
14 numbers so that they could be called?
15 MR. GOLDBERGER: Time out. Are you
16 talking to mc, counsel?
17 MR. HOROWITZ: Nodding my head, back at
18 you. You were nodding at me.
19 MR. GOLDBERGER: I wasn't nodding at
20 you. I'm not talking to you, I'm not
21 communicating with you.. I don't know what
22 you think we are doing here. You said "It
23 is true," and I have no idea what you are
24 talking about. Don't interrupt the
25 deposition, okay?
9 (Pages 30 to 33)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
MR. HOROWITZ: I think you interrupted. 1
A Fifth.
2 MR. GOLDBERGER: I didn't do a thing -- 2 Q In addition to that system, isn't it
3 MR. EDWARDS: I don't know what's 3 true that Jeffrey Epstein traffics underage minor
4 happened here. It has deteriorated here for 4 females through a modeling agency?
5 no reason whatsoever and has nothing to do 5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
6 with me or the witness. 6 A Fifth.
7 MR. GOLDBERGER: You're 100 percent 7 Q Is a modeling agency that he is involved
8 correct. 8 in with Jean Luc Brunel; you know who that is

MR. EDWARDS: Can we go back to it. 9 right?
10 MR. GOLDBERGER: Absolutely. 10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the loan.
11 MIL EDWARDS: Perfect. 11 A Fifth.
12 The silent fight disrupted me. I lost 12 Q Arc you familiar with MC-2 or MC -Squared
13 where I am now. 13 Modeling Agency?
14 MR. GOLDBERGER: Sony. 14 A Fifth.
15 MR. EDWARDS: Can you read it back. 15 Q You know Jean Luc Brunel, right?
16 THE COURT REPORTER: Certainly. 16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
17 (The record was read.) 17 A Fifth.
18 MR. EDWARDS: I'll rephrase the 18 Q Is Jean Luc Brunel somebody that you
19 question. 19 have been made to perform on sexually?
20 Q Isn't it true that yourself, Chislalne 20 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
21 Maxwell and had access to a master 21 A Fifth.
22 of list of underage minor females names and phone 22 Q Jean Luc Brunel is somebody that you
23 numbers so they could be called for the purpose 23 know to also be a child molester, true?
24 of coming to Jeffrey Epstein's house to be 24 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
25 sexually molested? 25 A Fifth.
35 37
1 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 1 Q This is somebody who for years the
2 A Fifth. 2 public has known of Jean Luc Brunel as a child
3 Q How many underage minor females are on 3 molester, true?
4 that master list? 4 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 5 A Fifth.
6 A Fifth. 6 Q In fact, that is the only thing Jeffrey
7 Q Are there photographs of these underage 7 Epstein and Jean Luc Brunel have in common, is
8 minor females on that master list? 8 their obsession for underage minor females,

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 9 correct?
10 A Fifth. 10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the four.
11 Q Is that master list saved on a computer 11 A Fifth.
12 system, as has been testified to in the past? 1.2 Q And the modeling agency is but one other
13 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn. 13 mechanism used by Jeffrey Epstein to gain access
14 A Fifth. 14 to underage minor females for sex, true?
15 Q Has Jeffrey Epstein talked to you about 15 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
16 the success of his scheme to procure underage 16 A Fifth.
17 minor females? 17 Q I read you the statute earlier on Lewd
18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 18 and Lascivious Molestation, Chapter 800.04, and
19 A Fifth. 19 that's something that you have witnessed Jeffrey
20 Q By that, I mean, the method where he 20 Epstein violate on hundreds of occasions,
21 molests an underage minor female, then offers 21 correct?
2 them additional money if they will bring hint 22 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
3 other underage minor females to molest; are you 23 A Fifth.
4 familiar with that system? 24 Q And something that you have witnessed
5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 25 Jeffrey Epstein specifically violate, against
10 (Pages 34 to 37)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
E.W., true?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Also a statute you have witnessed
Jeffrey Epstein violate against then minor,
LM.?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
Epstein's house, and he is using all resources to
try to intimidate and harass her; Is that true?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q in fact, has he talked to you about his
tactic of intimidating and harassing any victims
that come forward against him, regarding the
8 A Fifth. a sexual abuse that they endured by him?
9 Q In fact L.M. was somebody that Jeffrey 9 MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
10 Epstein liked or likes; isn't that true? 10 A Fifth.
11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn. 11 Q Would you agree that Jeffrey Epstein
12 A Fifth. 12 contributed to the delinquency of these various
13 Q L.M. was somebody Jeffrey Epstein met 13 minors that he sexually abused?
14 when she was only 13 years old and began sexually 14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
15 molesting her the first day that he met her, 15 A Fifth.
16 true? 16 Q in addition to abusing them, he also
17 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 1.7 encouraged them to return to him to receive more
18 A Fifth. 18 sexual abuse and encouraged them into a life of
19 Q L.M. was one of his main girls, as he 19 prostitution, true?
20 would call them; is that true? 20 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
21 MR. YAREMA: Object to the lone. 21 A Fifth.
22 A Fifth. 22 Q Flow many underage minor females have you
23 Q L.M. procured for him or brought for him 23 observed Jeffrey Epstein engage in sex acts with
24 to his house, over 50 girls between the ages of 24 on any of his airplanes?
25 12 and 15 years old; is that true? 25 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
39 41
1 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 1 A Fifth.
2 A Fifth. 2 Q Have you engaged in sexual acts with any
3 Q Each of these girls, aged 12 to 15, you 3 underage minor females on Jeffrey Epstein's
4 observed come into the house, go into Jeffrey 4 airplanes?
5 Epstein's bedroom and leave the house after being 5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
6 sexually molested, true? 6 A Fifth.
7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 7 Q How many tines has Jeffrey Epstein
8 A Fifth. 8 talked to you about the reasons why he sexually
9 Q And in addition to L.M. being sexually 9 abuses minors?
10 molested herself, she was enticed or coerced into 10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
11 bringing her friends over, to also be sexually 11 A Fifth.
12 molested, true? 12 Q Didn't he tell you that it is his intent
13 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 13 to harm these minors in hopes of gaining
14 A Fifth. 14 psychological advantage over them?
15 Q Has Jeffrey Epstein talked to you about 15 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
16 an FBI statement that was given by L.M.? 16 A Fifth.
17 A Fifth. 17 Q Are you aware that Jeffrey Epstein pled
18 Q lie has also told you that that FBI 18 guilty to two felonies related to his Interaction
19 statement that was favorable for him is 19 with minors?
20 completely false; isn't that true? 20 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
21 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 21 A Fifth.
22 A Fifth. 22 Q And as a result he was incarcerated, and
23 Q Has he spoken to you about the fact that 23 as we spoke about earlier, you visited hint in
24 she is now telling the complete story and 24 jail on more than 50 occasions, correct?
25 accurate account as to what happened at Jeffrey 25 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
11 (Pages 38 to 41)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
42 44
6'
A Fifth.
Q Aren't your observations with Jeffrey
Epstein's interactions with E.W., wouldn't you
agree he coerced her into a life of prostitution?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q And based on your observations of
Jeffrey Epstein's interactions with L.M.,
wouldn't you agree that Jeffrey Epstein coerced
her into a life of prostitution?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q And with respect to Jane Doe and E.W.
and L.M., wouldn't you agree that Jeffrey Epstein
forced these girls to be a prostitute for him?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Would you agree that Jeffrey Epstein's
actions against E.W., L.M. and Jane Doe, were
intentional, deliberate and reckless?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Would you agree that that intentional,
deliberate and reckless conduct by Jeffrey
Epstein against L.M., E.W. and Jane Doe was
Q Do you profit from sex trafficking or
children?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you know Sergio Cordero?
A Fifth.
Q
A
Q
criminal enterprise that Is designed to molest
underage minor females, to be organized?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Is your role in that criminal
arrangement to molest underage minor females, to
help organize?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q As part of that organization, isn't it
true that you, as well as various staff members,
took meticulous messages regarding appointments
and scheduling underage minor females to come
over to be sexually molested?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Do you know Mike Sanka?
Fifth.
Would you consider Jeffrey Epstein's
likely to cause severe emotional distress?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q And isn't it a fact that Jeffrey Epstein
has specifically told you that it Is his intent
to cause severe emotional distress, as it
weakened his victims?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Ilas Jeffrey Epstein talked to you about
your role in what he calls a criminal enterprise?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Has lie talked to you about his
organization being a criminal enterprise, that
you need to help protect?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q What does Jeffrey Epstein do for a
living?
A Fifth.
Q Does he profit from international sex
trafficking of children?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
1 Q These were message pads that had a
2 carbon copy that were positioned or stationed in
3 several places around Jeffrey Epstein's home near
4 the telephone; you're familiar with those,
5 right?
6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
7 A Fifth.
8 Q Since I'm assuming that you are going to
9 take the Fifth on each and every question related
10 to any messages, I will show you only one, which
11 will be marked, this one page, as Plaintiff's
12 Exhibit 1. The date on the message that I will
13 be showing you is 8/21, August 21, 2005.
14 (Message dated August 21,2005 was
15 marked as Plaintiff's Exhibit number I for
16 identification, as of this date.)
17 MR. EDWARDS: Do you want to see it
18 first?
19 MR. GOLDBERGER: (Counsel examines
20 document and hands it to the witness.)
21 Q Would you look at the exhibit, please,
22 if you can see it? I don't know if you can see
23 it over your coffee.
24 A I can see it.
25 Q Okay. Do you recognize it?
12 (Pages 42 to 45)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
A Filth.
Q That particular message indicates it is
from You're the only In the
house; is that correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q This is a call from you indicating that
'1= cannot work today be
Ghisiaine Maxwell's sexual interaction with Jane
Doe-102 when she was a minor?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
Q This is one of many underage minor
females that was trafficked basically around the
globe to be sexually exploited and abused; is
that correct?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
here at 4:00 p.m.;" Is that right? 9 A Fifth.
10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form? 10 Q Was that typical of Jeffrey Epstein and
11 A Fifth. 11 Ghisiaine Maxwell to sexually abuse minors on
12 Q Who Is =? 12 Jeffrey Epstein's airplane?
13 A Fifth. 13 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 14 A Fifth.
15 Q That's an underage minor female that was 15 Q And also typical of Ghislaine Maxwell
16 scheduled to be molested at Jeffrey Epstein's 16 and Jeffrey Epstein to prostitute or pimp out
17 house? 17 underage minors to friends?
18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the Iona. 18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
19 A Fifth. 19 A Fifth.
20 Q You scheduled that act of molestation; 20 Q By "friends," lent talking specifically
21 is that right? 21 about people of royalty, politicians,
22 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 22 academicians, businessmen and other professional
23 A Fifth. 23 or personal acquaintances?
24 Q And Britney will be at the house at 4:00 24 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
25 pan. Britney is another underage minor female; 25 A Fifth.
47 49
1 is that correct? 1 Q Were you with Jeffrey Epstein on his
2 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 2 birthday when one of his friends sent to him
3 A Fifth. 3 12 — sorry, three 12-year olds for the purposes
4 Q That's somebody else that you were 4 of Jeffrey Epstein sexually abusing them?
5 scheduling to come to his house at 4:00 p.m. for 5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
6 Jeffrey Epstein to engage in sexual acts with 6 A Fifth.
7 her, while she was an underage minor, true? 7 Q How many occasions have you observed
8 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 8 Jeffrey Epstein to receive as gifts front friends,
9 A Fifth. underage minor females for the purposes of hint
10 Q Do you know Les Wexner? 10 sexually abusing them?
11 A Fifth. 11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
12 Q That's somebody that you know owns and 12 A Fifth.
13 operates the Victoria's Secret, the Limited? 13 Q These three 12-year olds were from
14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 14 France. Were they sent to hint on his birthday by
15 A Is that a question? 15 Jean Luc Brunel or by somebody else?
16 Q Is that somebody that you know to own 16 MR. YAREMA: Object to form.
17 Victoria's Secret or operate Victoria's Secret? 17 A Fifth.
18 A Fifth. 18 Q Have you ever been made to engage in sex
19 Q Do you know if Jeffrey Epstein still 19 with 12-year olds?
20 talks with Leslie Wexner? 20 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
21 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 21 A Fifth.
22 A Fifth. 22 Q Is it true that Jeffrey Epstein makes
23 Q Do you know Jane Doe-102? 23 you dress up as a 12-year old?
24 A Fifth. 24 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
25 Q Are you aware of Jeffrey Epstein and 25 A Fifth.
13 (Pages 46 to 4 9)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
Q As part of being Jeffrey Epstein's sex
slave, isn't it true that he asks you or requests
of you to dress younger than 12 at times?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Have you seen naked photographs of the
underage minor females with whom Jeffrey Epstein
has engaged in sex acts?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Are there hidden cameras in any of
Jeffrey Epstein's homes, that you know to have
taken surreptitious videos or photographs of
underage minors?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Does Jeffrey Epstein still watch
pornography to this day?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Does Jeffrey Epstein watch homemade
pornographic videos of underage minors engaging
in sex orgies on his island?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
1 A Fifth.
2 Q Do you know Bill Riley?
3 A Fifth.
4 Q Have you seen the flight logs front
5 Jeffrey Epstein's private airplane flights?
6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Are you aware that you're listed as a
passenger on many flights, along with Jeffrey
Epstein on his private airplane?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
2 A Fifth.
Q Certainly comes as no surprise to you,
since you were on his airplane on numerous
occasions, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q On September 22,2003, you were listed
as being on a flight with Ma Jeffrey
0 Epstein, S.H. and B.T. My question
is who is S.H. and who is B.T.?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the font.
A Fifth.
Q Do you know
A Fifth.
1 Q Prior to the search warrant being
2 executed, you are aware that at least three
3 computers were taken at Jeffrey Epstein's
direction, from Jeffrey Epstein's house, to avoid
5 detection by law enforcement, correct?
6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
7 A Correct.
8 Q Adriana and some other person
took those computers to avoid Jeffrey Epstein —
to avoid the authorities obtaining the evidence
contained on those computers, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Who are the persons along with Adriana
took the computers front Jeffrey
Epstein's house prior to the execution of the
search warrant?
YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Where are those computers today?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Were they taken by his investigator,
BM Riley?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
1.0
Q That's somebody that you're familiar
with, because you have been to Jeffrey Epstein's
house on many occasions with
correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q In fact, do you remember there being a
burglary of Jeffrey Epstein's house where he
actually called the police to investigate the
burglary?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q And during the police investigation
inside Jeffrey Epstein's house, you were speaking
with both in person, at Jeffrey
Epstein's house, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Correct.
Q Is this another person that Jeffrey
Epstein, when she was a minor, violated
sexually?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you still speak withl ?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
14 (Pages 50 to 53)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
A Fifth.
Q Do you know Bill Clinton?
A Fifth.
Q You have been on Jeffrey Epstein's
airplane with Bill Clinton?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
Jeffrey Epstein specifically flew to Palm Beach
for the purposes of engaging in sex acts with
Jane Doe?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Generally, isn't it true Jeffrey Epstein
7 A Fifth. 7 would fly front place to place for the purpose of
8 Q Isn't take true you have been on Jeffrey
Epstein's airplane with Doug Band, Bill Clinton's
8 engaging in sexual activity with minors at his
destination?
10 righthand man? 10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
1/. MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn. 11 A Fifth.
12 A Filth. 12 Q Isn't it true that he employed numerous
13 Q Have you witnessed improper sexual 13 people for the sole purpose of scheduling
14 activity between Jeffrey Epstein and minors, 14 appointments with underage minor females at each
15 while he was in the presence of Bill Clinton? 15 destination he landed?
16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fowl. 16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
17 A Fifth. 17 A Fifth.
18 Q How many times have you ridden on the 18 Q What is Jeffrey Epstein's relationship
19 airplane with Jean Luc Brunel? 19 with Sandy Berger?
20 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 20 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
21 A Fifth. 21 A Fifth.
22 Q Each time that Jean Luc Brunel visits 22 Q Do you know what Jeffrey Epstein's
23 Jeffrey Epstein's house, does he bring underage 23 relationship is with Alan Dershowitz?
24 minors to Jeffrey Epstein's house to engage in 24 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
25 sex with? 25 A Fifth.
55 57
1 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 1 Q That's somebody who you know to have
2 A Fifth. 2 stayed at Jeffrey Epstein's house on many
3 Q Do you know Glenn Dubin? 3 occasions, correct?
4 A Fifth. 4 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
5 Q Do you know Aline Weber? 5 A Fifth.
6 A Fifth. 6 Q And also somebody who you know to have
7 Q Is that somebody that was a sexual abuse 7 been at the house when E.W. was in Jeffrey
victim at one point In time of Jeffrey Epstein 8 Epstein's bedroom getting sexually abused,
9 and Jean Luc Brunei? 9 correct?
10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
11 A Fifth. 11 A Fifth.
12 Q Between 2002 and 2005 when E.W. was 12 Q Alan Dershowitz is also somebody that
13 abused by Jeffrey Epstein sexually, isn't it true 13 you also know to have been at the house when L.M.
14 that Jeffrey Epstein took flights to Palm Beach 14 was being sexually abused in Jeffrey Epstein's
15 for the purposes of sexually abusing E.W.? 15 bedroom, correct?
16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn. 16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
17 A Fifth. 17 A Fifth.
18 Q And between those same years of 2002 and 18 Q Generally, Alan Dershowitz is familiar
19 2005, Isn't It true that Jeffrey Epstein took 19 with Jeffrey Epstein's habit of engaging in
20 airplane flights to Palm Beach front places 20 sexual acts with minors on a daily basis,
21 outside of the State, to engage in sexual acts 21 correct?
22 with L.M.? 22 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 23 A Fifth.
24 A Fifth. 24 Q When Alan Dershowitz was in town,
25 Q From 2003 through 2005, isn't it true 25 Jeffrey Epstein did not break his schedule for
15 (Pages 54 to 57)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
I1
Alan Dershowit, meaning he continued to sexually
abuse minors despite Alan Dershowitz being a
guest in the house?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Alan Dershowitz never engaged in any
sexual activity with these underage minors; isn't
that true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Have you been made to have sex with
Ghislaine Maxwell?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you know Emmy Taylor?
A Fifth.
Q Similar to you being Jeffrey Epstein's
sex slave, is Emmy Taylor, or was Emmy Taylor
Ghislaine Maxwell's sex slave?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Ghislaine Maxwell is somebody who you
know to be bi-sexual, true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q What was the purpose of that flight?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did you sign a confidentiality agreement
with Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q When is the last time that you observed
Jeffrey Epstein have sex with a minor?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Since being on probation, has Jeffrey
Epstein been able to, or has he flown to his
Island?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q To your knowledge, has Jeffrey Epstein
flown to New York while on probation or community
control?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Isn't it true that he has flown both to
New York and to his island, and you have
accompanied hint on those trips, since he was on
community control?
1 Q You know that Ghislaine Maxwell engaged
2 in sexual acts with underage minor females, true?
3 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
4 A Fifth.
5 Q This is yet another friend of Jeffrey
6 Epstein's that is into the act of molesting
underage minor females, right?
8 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Nov, you are the next participant In
that activity, meaning you have been groomed to
enjoy and appreciate the acts of sex with
underage minors, true?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Has Jeffrey Epstein instructed you to
lie to his Probation Officer in any way?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Mr. Visoskl testified that you took a
helicopter flight within the last year with
Jeffrey Epstein to Miami. Do you remember that
flight?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Isn't It also true that Jeffrey Epstein
has Indicated to you that he will always engage
in sex acts with underage minor females?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q In fact, that's something that he has
told you, that he believes he Is entitled to do;
isn't that right?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Isn't It true that Jeffrey Epstein
believes and has told you that if he doesn't
physically force the underage minor female into
any act, then he is entitled to engage in sex
with any underage minor female despite the age?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the lone.
A Fifth.
Q What is the youngest female you have
witnessed or observed Jeffrey Epstein to engage
in sex with?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you have a bank account at Chase Bank
16 (Pages 58 to 61)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
62 64
1 in New York?
2 A Fifth.
3 Q And the money In that bank account under
4 your name is money that was given to you by
5 Jeffrey Epstein, correct?
6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
7 A Fifth.
8 Q For the passed ten or so years, you have
9 lived with Jeffrey Epstein under his control,
10 right?
11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
12 A Fifth.
13 Q You get to lead the life of a
14 millionaire, and to lead that life, you were only
15 required to be Jeffrey Epstein's sex slave and to
16 bring Jeffrey Epstein other slaves?
17 MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
18 A Fifth.
19 Q Is this 301 East 66th Street apartment
20 still an apartment that you frequent today?
21 MR_ YAREMA: Object to the form.
22 A Fifth.
23 Q And you're familiar with the nine or ten
24 apartments that Jeffrey Epstein owns or controls
25 up there at 301 East 66th Street, aren't you?
Q That's somebody who these days refers to
himself as Jeffrey Epstein's personal assistant,
right?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q That's somebody who you know to work for
or at the Florida Science Foundation, which is
owned by Jeffrey Epstein, correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q It Is also somebody that you know to
have stayed at Jeffrey Epstein's house with
correct?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q This is somebody that has been
involved — Story Cowles is somebody who's been
involved sexually with for at least
a year, right?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q In fact, you know that they took a trip
around the world together and during that trip
they discussed Jeffrey Epstein and his
interaction with underage minor females,
1 MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
2 A Fifth.
3 Q At any given time, there are between 8
4 and 16 underage minors living in or staying at
5 those apartments?
6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
7 A Fifth.
8 Q On the various passenger lists on
9 Jeffrey Epstein's airplane, where it will list,
10 for instance, Jeffrey Epstein,
going from Florida to St.
Thomas, then generically, female, female; would
you know who those female, females are?
MR_ YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Are those females listed generically
rather than specifically because they are
underage minor females engaging in sex with you
or Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Is Story Cowles someone that you see on
a regular basis at Jeffrey Epstein's house?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
A Fifth.
correct?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
A Fifth.
MR. EDWARDS: Done. I don't have
anything else.

MR. GOLDBERGER: Okay.
MR. HOROWITZ: I do, why don't we take a
short break.
MR. GOLDBERGER: We are stopping at
I I:50.

MR. HOROWITZ: What?
MR. GOLDBERGER: 11:50.
MR. HOROWITZ: I kind of remember that
e-mail.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the video record.
(Pause in the proceedings.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are back on the
video reconl at 11:18 a.m.)
(At this time Robert Critton joined the
proceedings.)
CROSS EXAMINATION
BY MR. HOROWITZ:
Q Ms.  between 2001 and 2006,
did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you to place
telephone calls to arrange for girls under the
17 (Pages 62 to 65)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
S
age of 18 to come to his home for his sexual
gratification?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Between 2001 and 2006 did you, In fact,
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that he
sexually abused Y.L. in his Palm Beach home in
2004?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
6 place telephone calls to arrange for girls under A Fifth.
7 the age of 18 to come to Jeffrey Epstein's home 7 Q Did you ever instruct a girl named
8 for his sexual gratification? a to bring other underage girls to Jeffrey
9 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 9 Epstein's home for Jeffrey Epstein's sexual
10 A Fifth. 10 pleasure?
11 Q Are you personally aware that a girl 11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
12 named M.L. came to Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach 12 A Filth.
13 home in late 2004? 13 Q In 2004 did you communicate by telephone
14 YAREMA: Object to the form. 14 with nor the purpose of bringing
15 A Fifth. 15 V.1.. to Jeffrey Epstein's home for sexual
16 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you he 16 activity MR. YAREMA: Object to the fora.
17 sexually abused M.L.? 17 A Fifth.
18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 18 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you to
19 A Fifth. 19 communicate with for the purpose of
20 Q Isn't It true in late 2004 you made 20 making arrangements for Y.L. to come to his home?
21 arrangements by telephone to bring M.L. to 21 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
22 Jeffrey Epstein's home? 22 A Fifth.
23 MIL YAREMA: Object to the form. 23 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you it was his
24 A Fifth. 24 intent during the course of Y.L.'s visit to his
25 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you to 25 home to persuade, induce or entice her to engage
67 69
1 communicate by telephone to arrange for M.L. to 1 in sexual activity with him?
2 come to his home for his sexual gratification? 2 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
3 ML YAREMA: Object to the form. 3 A Fifth.
4 A Fifth. 4 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that he
5 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein inform you that M.L. 5 had succeeded in, in fact, persuading, inducing
6 would be giving him a massage that was sexual in 6 or enticing Y.L. to engage in sexual activity
7 nature? 7 with hint?
8 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 8 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth. 9 A Fifth.
10 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you it was his 10 Q Are you personally aware that a teenage
11 intent during the course of M.L.'s visit to his 11 girl named came to Jeffrey Epstein's Palm
12 home to persuade, induce or entice her to engage 12 Beach home on multiple occasions between 2003 and
13 in sexual activity? 13 2005?
14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fount 14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
15 A Fifth. 15 A Fifth.
16 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that, in 16 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that he
17 fact, he succeeded in persuading, inducing or 17 sexually abused
18 enticing M.L. to engage in sexual activity with 18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
19 him? 19 A Fifth.
20 MR.. YAREMA: Object to the form. 20 Q At any time prior to May of 2005, did
21 A Fifth. 21 Jeffrey Epstein instruct you to place telephone
22 Q Are you personally aware that a girl 22 calls to for the purpose of arranging for
23 named Y.L. came to Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach 23 her to come to his home and engage in sexual
24 home on multiple occasions in 2004? 24 activity?
25 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 25 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
18 (Pages 66 to 69)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
70 72
1 A Fifth.
2 Q Did you, in fact, communicate by
3 telephone with for the purpose of arranging
4 for her to come to his home for sexual activity?
5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
6 A Fifth.
7 Q At any time prior to May of 2005, did
8 you place a telephone call to
wherein you arranged for M. to come to Jeffrey
Epstein's home for sexual activity?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Prior to May of 2005, did you ever
observe speaking with by
telephone to arrange for N. to come to Jeffrey
Epstein's home?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that it was
his intention to sexually abuse M. during the
course of her visits to his home?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that he
succeeded in engaging in sexual activity
in either 2001 or 2002?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did you, in fact, call A.G. to come to
Jeffrey Epstein's home and give him a massage in
a sexual nature in 2001 or 2002?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Dld you either observe or overhear-
- speaking with A.C. on the telephone to
arrange for A.C. to conic to Jeffrey Epstein's
home for a massage of a sexual nature?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the Iona.
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you it was his
intent during the course of A.G.'s visit to his
home to persuade, induce or entice her to engage
in sexual activity?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Didn't Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that
he succeeded in persuading, inducing or enticing
A.G. to engage in sexual activity with him at his
home while she was still a minor?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
while she was still a minor, at his home?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the loon.
A Fifth.
Q Are you personally aware that n teenage
girl named an A.C., came to Jeffrey Epstein's
Palm Beach home in approximately 2001 or 2002?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that he
sexually abused A.C.. at his home while she was
still a child?

MR. YAREMA: Object to die fonn.
A Fifth.
Q In 2001 or 2002, did inform
you that she received a telephone call in which
she was referred to A.C., who would be willing to
tome to Jeffrey Epstein's home for sexual
activity?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
(Whereupon, at this point in the
proceedings, Robert Griffon left the
deposition room.)
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you to call
A.C. to come to his home and give him a massage
A Fifth.
Q Are you personally aware that a girl
named M. came to Jeffrey Epstein's home in
approximately August 2004?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the font
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that he
had sexually abused when she was only 13
years old?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q In 2004 did you participate In a
telephone call wherein you arranged for M. to
come to Jeffrey Epsteln's home for the purpose of
giving him a massage that was to be sexual in
nature?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you to
communicate by telephone and make arrangements
for M. to come to his home for sexual activity
while she was still a child?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you it was his
19 (Pages 70 to 73)
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
intention during the course of M.'s Ash to 1
MR. YAREMA: Object to the (ben.
2 his home to persuade, induce or entice her to 2 A Fifth.
3 engage in sexual activity with him? 3 Q Did you participate in a telephone call
4 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 4 wherein you arranged for J.M. to come to Jeffrey
5 A Fifth. 5 Epstein's home for a massage?
6 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that, in 6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
7 fact, he SUCCCC(iCli in persuading, inducing and 7 A Fifth.
a enticing M. to engage In sexual activity with 8 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein instruct you to
9 him while she was still a child at his home? 9 participate In a telephone call wherein you were
10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 10 to arrange for J.M. to come to his home for
11 A Fifth. 11 sexual activity?
12 Q Are you personally aware that a girl 12 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
13 named F.P. came to Jeffrey Epstein's boost In Palm 13 A Fifth.
14 Beach on multiple occasions between 2003 and May 14 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you it was
15 of 2005? 15 his intention during the course ofJ.M.'s visit
16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 16 to his home, to engage her in sexual activity
17 A Fifth. 17 while she was still a child?
16 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you that he 18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
19 sexually abused F.P. at his home between 2003 and 19 A Fifth.
20 May of 2005? 20 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein admit to you he had,
21 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 21 in fact, persuaded, enticed and engaged J.M. in
22 A Fifth. 22 sexual activity at his home while she was still a
23 Q Prior to May of 2005, did you receive a 23 child?
24 phone call from a girl named wherein 24 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
25 she told you she ,vas bringing F.P. to Jeffrey 25 A Fifth.
75 77
Epstein's home to give him a massage? 1 MR. HOROWITZ: No other questions at
2 MR. YAREMA: Object to the Form. 2 this point.
3 A Fifth. 3 MR. LANGINO: I have less than ten
4 Q At any time prior to 2005, did Jeffrey 4 minutes of questioning.
5 Epstein instruct you to communicate with I= 5 MR. GOLDBERGER: Fine, that will bring
6 by telephone to make arrangements for F.P. 6 us right to the break.
7 to conic to his home? 7 CROSS EXAMINATION
8 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. BY MR. LANGINO:
A Fifth. 9 Q I'm Adam Langino and I represent B.R.
10 Q Prior to F.P.'s visits to Jeffrey 10 and C.L.
11 Epstein's home, did Jeffrey Epstein tell you it 11 Do you know an individual named B.B.?
12 was his intention to induce, entice and engage 12 A Fifth.
13 F.P., to engage in sexual activity with him? 13 Q Do you know an individual named C.L.?
14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 14 A Fifth.
15 A Fifth. 15 Q Have you seen B.B. at the defendant's
16 Q After F.P.'s visits to Jeffrey Epstein's 16 Palm Beach property?
17 home, did Jeffrey Epstein tell you that he 17 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
18 succeeded in enticing, engaging and persuading 18 A Fifth.
19 F.P. to engage in sexual activity with him while 19 Q Have you seen C.L. at the defendant's
20 she was still a child? 20 Palm Beach property?
21 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 21 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
22 A Fifth. 22 A Fifth.
23 Q Arc you personally aware that n teenage 23 Q Have you ever engaged in a sexual act
24 girl named J.M. came to Jeffrey Epstein's Paint 4 with B.B.... B.B.?
25 Beach home in approximately 2001 or 2002? 5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
20 (Pages 74 to 77)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
A Fifth.
Q Have you ever engaged in a sexual act
with C.L.... C.L.?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did you ever observe the defendant,
with the defendant was consensual?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you know if C.L.'s sexual activity
with the defendant was consensual?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
7 Jeffrey Epstein, with 8.6.? 7 A Fifth.
8 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 8 Q When you participated in sexual acts
9 A Fifth. 9 with each minor, how did you feel?
10 Q Did you ever observe the defendant, 10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
11 Jeffrey Epstein, with C.L.? 11 A Fifth.
12 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form? 12 Q In your heart, did you know it was
13 A Fifth. 13 wrong?
14 Q Have you ever physically touched B.B.? 14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form, and in
15 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 15 addition this is irrelevant and has already
16 A Fifth. 16 been addressed by Judge Hafele as an
17 Q Have you ever physically touched C.L.? 17 inappropriate question. That's my
18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 18 objection.
19 A Fifth. 19 A Fifth.
20 Q Has the defendant ever made a statement 20 Q During this time period did you feel
21 to you about B.B.? 21 confused?
22 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 22 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
23 A Fifth. 23 MR. GOLDBERGER: Same —
24 Q Has the defendant ever made a statement 24 MR. YAREMA: Same objection.
25 to you about C.L.? 25 A Fifth.
79 81
1 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 1 Q Are you currently in love with the
2 A Fifth. 2 defendant?
3 Q Has ever made a statement 3 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn, same
4 to you about B.B.? 4 objection. That question has no relevance
5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 5 to this... it is inappropriate per Judge
6 A Fifth. 6 Hafeic's order.
7 Q Has ever made a statement 7 MR. GOLDBERGER: Also involves privacy
8 to you about C.L.? 8 rights of my client. I instruct her not to
9 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 9 answer the question.
10 A Fifth. 10 A Fifth.
11 Q Have you ever communicated with B.B.? 11 Q Have you ever been in love with .Jeffrey
12 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 12 Epstein?
13 A Fifth. 13 MR. GOLDBERGER: Same objection.
14 Q Have you ever communicated with C.L.? 14 MR. YAREMA: Same objections.
15 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 15 A Fifth.
16 A Fifth. 16 MR. LANGINO: Thank you.
17 Q Did you know that B.B., B.B. was a minor 17 CROSS EXAMINATION
18 at the time of sexual abuse? 18 BY MS. EZELL:
19 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 19 (Discussion off the record.)
20 A Fifth. 20 Q Good morning, Ms. I'm

21. Q Did you know CL... C.L. was a minor at 21 Katherine Ezell and I represent Jane Doe 103,
22 the time of the sexual abuse? 22 whose name is A.H., which shall appear as A.il. in
23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 23 the deposition.
24 A Fifth. 24 Are you aware that in 2004 and 5, there
25 Q Do you know if Ma's sexual activity 25 was a sort of hidden staircase that would take
21 (Pages 78 to 81)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
one from the kitchen upstairs to the master
bedroom and massage area?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you recall there being nude
photographs on the staircase?
Q Do you recall that Jeffrey Epstein would
join in by performing oral sex on one or the
other of you — you or AM.?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Do you recall that also happening,
7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 7 meaning the oral sex, being performed on the
8 A Fifth. 8 massage table --
9 Q Did you know AM.? 9 MR. YAREMA: Objection.
10 A Fifth. 10 Q -- to AM.?
11 Q Did A.H. come to the house at 358 El 11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
12 Drillo Way to provide a massage to Jeffrey 12 A Fifth.
13 Epstein? 13 Q Were you present one day when Jeffrey
14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 14 Epstein held A.H. down on the massage table and
15 A Fifth. 15 while holding her inserted his penis into A.H.'s
16 Q Did that massage become sexual in 16 vagina?
17 nature? 17 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 18 A Fifth.
19 A Fifth. 19 Q Do you recall he stated that he wanted
20 Q Did All. become a regular visitor at 20 you to observe this?
21 Jeffrey Epstein's house? 21 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
22 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 22 A Fifth.
23 A Fifth. 23 Q Do you recall that A.H. had rules,
24 Q Do you remember that she came maybe 24 lines, that she had stated Jeffrey Epstein was
25 hundreds of times? 25 not to cross, in their encounters?
83 85

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 1 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
2 A Fifth. 2 A Fifth.
3 Q Do you recall that she was under the age 3 Q Do you recall that A.H. had forbidden
4 of 18 at the time she was coming to Jeffrey 4 any kind of vaginal penetration?
S Epstein's home? 5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 6 A Fifth.
7 A Fifth. 7 Q Do you recall that A.H. refused to touch
8 Q Were you younger than A.H. at the time? 8 Jeffrey Epstein's penis?
9 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 9 MR. YAREMA: Object to the Conn.
10 A Fifth. 10 A Fifth.
11 Q Do you remember occasions when you and 11 Q Do you recall that day when Jeffrey
12 Jeffrey Epstein were already in bed when A.H. 12 Epstein held A.II. on her stomach on the massage
13 arrived? 13 table and began pumping his penis into her
14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 14 vagina, that she screamed "No"?
15 A Fifth. 15 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
16 Q Do you recall Jeffrey Epstein 16 A Fifth.
17 instructing A.H. to remove her clothes and join 17 Q Do you recall that upon her screaming,
18 the two of you in bed? 18 Epstein stopped anti apologized?
19 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 19 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
20 A Fifth. 20 A Fifth.
21 Q Do you recall that you and Jeffrey 21 Q Do you recall that Jeffrey Epstein paid
22 Epstein bringing sex toys in bed for you and A.H. 22 her $1,000 for that visit?
23 to use on each other? 23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
24 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 24 A Fifth.
25 A Fifth. 25 Q Did you engage In sex with A.H. when she
22 (Pages 82 to 85)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
was under 18?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
end of a play performance during her senior year?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
3 A Fifth. 3 A Fifth.
4 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein watch you and A.H. 4 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Counsel, can we stop
5 having sex while he masturbated? for one minute?
6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 6 MS. EZELL: Sure.
7 A Fifth. 7 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the video reatrd
a Q Are you aware that A.H.'s activities 8 11:43 a.m.
9 with Jeffrey Epstein escalated further and 9 (Short pause.)
10 further as time went on? 10 (Whereupon at this point in time, Mr.
11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 11 Langino left the proceedings.)
12 A Fifth. 12 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
13 Q Did you sec Jeffrey Epstein use 13 record I:43 a.m.
14 vibrators and strap-on — use vibrators on A.H.? 14 CROSS EXAMINATION (CONTINUED)
15 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 15 BY MS. EZELL:
16 A Fifth. 16 Q Were you present in October 2005 when
17 Q Did you and A.II. engage in sex with 17 the Palm Beach Police Department raided Jeffrey
18 strap-on penises? 18 Epstein's home?
19 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 19 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
20 A Fifth. 20 A Fifth.
21 Q Did you see Jeffrey Epstein perform oral 21 Q You and others were aware that there
22 sex on A.H. numerous times? 22 would be a raid at that time; were you not?
23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
24 A Fifth. 24 A Fifth.
25 Q Did Jeffrey Epstein pay A.H. an 25 Q Who Informed you that there would be a
87 89
1 additional 5200 to perform oral sex on you? 1 raid on the house?
2 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 2 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
3 A Fifth. 3 A Fifth.
4 Q Do you recall that each time a new toy 4 Q Did you participate in the removal of
5 or activity was introduced when A.H. was there to 5 nude photographs, sex toys, computer records from
6 give massages, Jeffrey Epstein paid A.H. 6 358 El Brillo Way prior to the raid?
7 additional money? 7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
8 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn. 8 A Fifth.
9 A Fifth. 9 Q Do you know who removed those objects at
10 Q Would Jeffrey Epstein masturbate while 10 that time?
11 watching you and A.H. perform sexual acts? 11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
12 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn. 12 A Fifth.
13 A Fifth. 13 Q Do you remember that at times Jeffrey
14 Q Do you recall that Jeffrey Epstein 14 Epstein paid A.II. to just sleep in his bed in the
15 provided A.H. with gifts of purses and 15 nude?
16 bathingsuits? 16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
17 MR. YAREMA: Object to the forum 17 A Fifth.
18 A Fifth. 18 Q Do you recall at times lie paid her to
19 Q Do you recall that .Jeffrey Epstein 19 just cuddle with him?
20 provided A.N. with a blue 2000 Dodge Neon which 20 MR. YAREMA: Object to the rem].
21 had been rented for her? 21 A Fifth.
22 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 22 Q Did you ever drive A.N. to or from 358
23 A Fifth. 23 El Brillo Way?
24 Q Do you recall that Jeffrey Epstein 24 MR. YAREM A: Object to the font
25 ordered that roses be delivered to A.H. at the 25 A Fifth.
23 (Pages 86 to 89)
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
90 92
1 Q Did you ever know to drive 1 he would pay her 1,000 or $1,500 if she would
2 A.II. to or from 358 El Brill° Way? 2 lose ten pounds?
3 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 3 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
4 A Fifth. 4 A Fifth.
Q Do you remember the houseman at that 5 Q Did you know A.H. to be a good student?
6 time as being Alfredo Rodriguez? 6 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the font. 7 A Fifth.
8 A Fifth. 8 Q Did It appear that you that A.H. was
Q Do you remember Alfredo Rodriguez being 9 smart?
10 instructed to drive A.II. to or from 358 El Brine 10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
11 Way? 11 A Fifth.
12 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 12 Q Did you observe that A.II. was concerned
13 A Fifth. 13 about her grades?
14 Q Do you recall a time when Alfredo 14 MR YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
15 Rodriguez discovered A.H. asleep upstairs naked? 15 A Fifth.
16 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 16 Q Do you recall Jeffrey Epstein expressing
17 A Fifth. 17 interest in college ambitions?
18 Q Were you aware Jeffrey Epstein 18 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
19 repeatedly asked AM. to allow him to photograph 19 A Fifth.
20 her in the nude? 20 Q Have you known Jeffrey Epstein to brag
21 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn. 21 about donations he's made to colleges like NYU,
22 A Fifth. 22 Columbia, Harvard and Wharton?
23 Q Did you allow Jeffrey Epstein to take 23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
24 photographs, nude photographs of you? 24 A Filth.
25 MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn. 25 Q Do you know that A.H. wanted very much
91 93
1 A Fifth. 1 to go to school in New York at NYU or at
2 Q Do you recall a time when A.H. gave In 2 Columbia?
3 and did allow Jeffrey Epstein to photograph her 3 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
4 while nude? 4 A Fifth.
5 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 5 Q Did you know that Jeffrey Epstein
6 A Fifth. 6 promised to help her get info one of those
7 Q Did you ever see any of those 7 schools?
8 photographs taken by Jeffrey Epstein of A.H. in B MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
9 the nude? 9 A Fifth.
10 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 10 Q Do you know whether he did help?
11 A Fifth. 11 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
12 Q Do you know whether those photographs 12 A Fifth.
13 were ever developed? 13 Q Do you know whether he offered to pay
14 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 14 some of her college expenses?
15 A Fifth. 15 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
16 Q Do you know what kind of camera Jeffrey 16 A Fifth.
17 Epstein liked to use when taking photographs of 17 Q Did you ever observe Jeffrey Epstein
18 women posing in the nude? 18 working with A.II. on her college applications?
19 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form. 19 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
20 A Fifth. 20 A Fifth.
21 Q Did you ever hear here Jeffrey Epstein 21 Q Did you ever see A.H. Just hanging out
22 tell A.II. that she needed to lose ten pounds? 22 at Jeffrey Epstein's house studying while nude?
23 MR. YAR•M A: Object to the form. 23 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
24 A Fifth. 24 A Fifth.
25 Q Did you ever hear here him tell her that 25 Q Did you know that Jeffrey Epstein gave
24 (Pages 90 to 931
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
94 96
1 A.H. airline tickets and theater tickets in New
2 York?
3 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
4 A Fifth.
5 Q Did you and A.H. ever go shopping
6 together?
7 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
8 A Fifth.
Q Did you call A.H. once and ask her to go
shopping with you for Jeffrey Epstein on his
birthday?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Did you and A.N. purchase adult sex toys
to use for Jeffrey Epstein's birthday, as a show,
for him?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the coml.
A Fifth.
Q Are you aware that Jeffrey Epstein told
A.H. he would pay her to bring other young girls
to give him massages?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Do you know that Jeffrey Epstein paid
A.H. 5200 for each girl that she brought to him,
A The Fifth.
Q Do you know if typically girls who
Epstein knew, were given tickets to go to the
show, then invited back stage?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the font).
A Fifth.
THE VIDE•OGRAPHER: Can you speak up?
THE WITNESS: (Adjusts microphone.)
Q Did A.H. ever tell you that David
Copperfield tried to feel her butt during dinner?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the (ann.
A Fifth.
Q Did you ever hear Jeffrey Epstein
telling any of the young women who came to give
him massages, that he was a brain scientist?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did you know A.D.?
A Fifth.
Q And from now on I will use the initials
A.D. Do you know that A.D. visited Jeffrey
Epstein at 358 El Brillo Way some 15 to 20 times?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form?
A Fifth.
Q Did you ever interact with A.D. while
to give hint a massage?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
MR. GOLDBERGER: I guess we will have to
take a break now, if that's all right with
you.

MS. EZELL: Okay.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: I I:50 a.m., going off
the video record.
MR. GOLDBERGER: I will be done at I:15
so we can go until 1:30.
(Pause in the proceedings.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are back on the
video record at 1:36 p.m.
CROSS EXAMINATION (CONTINUED)
BY MS. EZELL:
Q Ms. did you ever have dinner
at Jeffrey Epstein's house, with David
Copperfield as a guest, when A.H. was present?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A The Fifth.
Q Have you met David Copperfield?
A Fifth.
Q Have you ever been given tickets to go
see one of his shows?
she was there to give a massage?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did you know that at the time she was
visiting Mr. Epstein and providing massages, she
was under the age of 18?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Firth.
Q Do you recall being introduced to A.D.
by Mr. Epstein?
MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Do you recall that Jeffrey Epstein
instructed you and A.D. to kiss and fondle each
other around the breasts and buttocks while
massaging him?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A Fifth.
Q Did you ever see Mr. Epstein use a large
vibrator/massager on A.D.?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
A Fifth.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein ever ask you to
purchase a digital camera for him to give A.D.?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
25 (Pages 94 to 97)
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
98 100
1 A Fifth.
2 Q Did you know that Jeffrey Epstein gave
3 A.D. a digital camera?
4 MR. YAREMA: Object to the form.
5 A Fifth.
6 MS. EZELL: I don't have any other
7 questions. Thank you.
8 MR. GOLDBERGER: You still have your
microphone on. You must have something on
your mind. Brad.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q Ms.MM. through the whole day
you've taken the Fifth on just about every single
question. Is there any reason why we should not
presume that the answer to these questions would
incriminate you?

MR. YAREMA: Object to the fonn.
A The Fifth.
Q The reason that you have taken the Fifth
is because the questions you have been asked
would have been answered in the affirmative and
you're afraid of prosecution for your
involvement, true?

MR. GOLDBERGER: Don't answer that
THE STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH)
I. TERRI BECKER, a Registered
Professional Reporter and Notary Public for the
Suite of Florida at Large, do hereby certify that
I tied the videotaped deposition of
the WITNESS, called by the PLAINTIFF
in the above•entitled action; that the witness
was duly sworn by mc; that the foregoing pages.
numbered from Ito 104, inclusive, constitute a
true record of the deposition by said witness.
I further certify that I ant not attorney
or counsel or any of the pities, nor a relative
or employee of any attorney or counsel connected
with the action, nor financially interested in
the action.
WITNESS MY HAND and official seal in the
City of West Palm Beach, County of Palm Beach,
State of Florida. this 19th day of April 1010.
TERRI BECKER, Registered
Professional Reporter and
Notary Public, State of Florida
at Large. My Commission expires
March 13,2011.
question. It interferes with the
attomey/client relationship that I have
with Ms. and any discussions she
and I may have had would come under that
privilege.
You can try and dance around that, but
I'm simply not going to allow her to answer
that question. If you want to bring it up
with the Judge, you cart.

MR. EDWARDS: Thanks, Jack.
MR. GOLDBERGER: Okay.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the video record
at I:41 p.m.
THE COURT REPORTER: You're ordering
this, Brad?

MR. EDWARDS: Yes. Copies?
MS. EZELL: Yes.
MR. YAREMA: Yes:
THE COURT REPORTER: And Adam wanted it;
is that right?

MR. EDWARDS: Yes.
(Time noted: 1:45 p.m.)
S The foregoing certificate was
6 acknowledged before me this
7 day of 2010.
THE STATE OF FLORIDA)
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH)
?'7
Notary Public, State of Florida.
My commission No.
Expires March 13, 2011.
26 (Pages 98 to 101)
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
102 104
do hereby
certify that I have read the foregoing transcript
of my deposition given on April 13,2010; that
together with the correction page attached hereto
noting changes in form or substance, if any, it
is true and correct.
MARCINKOVA
I do hereby certify that the deposition
of was submitted to the witness
for reading and signing; that after she had
stated to the undersigned Notary Public that she
had read and examined her deposition, she signed
the same in the presence of the undersigned
authority on the day of 2010.
U.S. LEGAL SUPPOliT
Registered Professaonal !reporters
444 West Railroad Avenue
Sok 300
West Palm Beads Elcala 33401
IS611335.0220
Aiwa 19.2010
ATTERBURY GOLDBERG. WEISS
One fkarlake Crew. Stria 1400
250 Australian Avenue South
West Palm Beach. Oxide 33901
ATIENTION: JACK GOLDBERGER. ESQ.
In Re: DOE EPSTEIN
Depositica at _-
12 One Mt Goldberger.
13 Since counsel have agreed that you nay
have the witness read and sip your copy of the
19 deposition, far your conthoience, withal
herewith you will fib an Ennui Sheet for the
15 winese use is Malin my changes to the
deposition.
Thank you for slur prompt anemias
Conhally Yon.
It US LEGAL SUPPORT
20 TERRI BECKER. R.:yawed
Professiewal Regatta. Wary
21 Public. State offloads at
Urge. My coincnission wises
22 March 13.2011.
23 CC: &Sky Edwards. Esq.
Adam Horowitz. Esq.
24 Katherine Eull. Esq.
David Venom. Esq.
1 ERRATA SHEET
2 In Re: DOE I EPSTEIN
3 DO NOT WRITE ON TRANSCRIPT
ENTER CHANGES HERE:
5 PACE LINE CHANGE REASON
THE STATE OF FLORIDA)
19 COUNTY OF PALM BEACI I)
20 I DO IlEtUit3Y CERTIFY111AT
appeared before me and slated that she has read
21 her deposilion: further, 11101 this Erna Shed
was signed in my presence on this day
22 of 2010.
27 (Pages 102 to 104)
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 1
A
able19:21 20:16
60:13
above-entitled
3:2,12 100:8
above-naiad 3:13
Absolutely 34:10
abuse40:8,18
48:11 55:7
58:2 70:20
79:18,22
abusod40:13
48:6 55:13
57:8,14 66:17
68:3 69:17
71:10 73:8
74:19
abuses41:9
abusing40:16
49:4,10 55:15
academicians
48:22
access 29:8,13
29:20 30:2
33:7,12 34:21
37:13
accompanied
60:24
account39:25
61:25 62:3
accurate 39:25
acknowledged
101:6
acquaintances
48:23
act28:16 46:20
59:6 61:16
77:23 78:2
action3:12
100:8,15,16
actions42:19
activities86:8
activity11:11
25:1 54:14
56:8 58:7
59:11 67:13
67:18 68:16
69:1,6,24
70:4,10,25
71:18 72:18
72:23 73:21
74:3,8 75:13
75:19 76:11
76:16,22
79:25 80:4
87:5
acts 16:23 28:8
28:16 30:7
31:10 40:23
41:2 47:6
50:8 55:21
56:2 57:20
59:2,12 61:5
80:8 87:11
Alan 3:25 4:5
77:9 99:19
104:23
addition10:23
15:12 18:24
21:13 27:19
36:2 39:9
40:16 80:15
additional 35:22
87:1,7
address 5:22
6:10,15,24
addressed 80:16
Adjusts 96:8
admit66:16 68:2
69:4,16 71:9
72:21 73:7
74:18 76:14
76:20
Adriana20:6,6
30:13 51:8,14
adult 94:14
advantage41:14
advice 5:13
affirmative
98:22
afraid 98:23
age13:19 17:12
17:13 25:11
26:15 61:17
66:1,7 83:3
97:6
aged 39:3
agency 36:4,7,13
37:12
ages 38:24
agree22:21 23:5
40:11 42:4,9
42:14,18,23
agreed104:13
agreement16:3
20:1 60:4
airline 94:1
airplane48:12
52:5,10,14
54:5,9,19
55:20 63:9
airplanes40:24
41:4
all:7
Alan56:23 57:12
57:18,24 58:1
58:2,6
Alfredo 90:6,9
90:14
Aline55:5
allegations 15:6
allow25:2 29:20
90:19,23 91:3
99:7
ambitions 92:17
Amendment 5:20
6:1 8:25
10:24
Amendments 5:14
Andrew14:13,16
Andrews 3:18
and/or27:16
annexed 3:10
answer5:16,18
5:20 10:21
11:17,21 81:9
98:16,25 99:7
answered 98:22
anticipate 5:24
apartment 6:25
62:19,20
apartments 62:24
63:5
apologized 85:18
appear 30:19
81:22 92:8
appearances 3:14
4:1
appearad103:20
appetite 20:22
applications
93:18
appointments
16:16 21:23
44:21 56:14
appreciate 22:24
23:9 59:12
approximately
71:6 73:4
75:25
Aprill:20 2:1
100:19 102:3
104:4
area17:11 22:11
82:2
arrange 65:25
66:6 67:1
70:15 72:11
76:10
arranged70:9
73:13 76:4
arrangement
44:15
arrangements
66:21 68:20 •
73:20 75:6
arranging 69:22
70:3
arrived 83:13
Ashley46:8,12
aside 10:15
asked18:10
25:17 90:19
98:21
asks 50:2
asleep 90:15
assistant 64:2
assuming15:2
45:8
attached102:4
attended 9:3
attention 104:8
104:16
ATTERBURY4:16
104:6
attorney 100:12
100:14
Attorneys 3:17
3:22 4:2,8,12
attorney/client
99:2
August2:12
45:13,14 73:4
Australian 104:7
authorities
23:25 24:10
51:10
authority 102:20
Avenue 3:6,18
104:2,7
avoid32:13 51:4
51:9,10
avoiding 32:21
aware10:4 12:8
16:6 17:15
41:17 47:25
51:2 52:8
66:11 67:22
69:10 71:4
73:2 74:12
75:23 81:24
86:8 88:21
90:18 94:19
A.D 96:18,21,21
96:25 97:9,14
97:20,24 98:3
A.071:5,10,16
71:25 72:4,10
72:11,16,23
A.H81:22,22
82:9,11,20
83:8,12,17,22
84:3,10,14,15
84:23 85:3,7
85:12,25 86:4
86:8,14,17,22
86:25 87:5,6
87:11,15,20
87:25 89:14
89:22 90:2,10
90:15,19 91:2
91:8,22 92:5
92:8,12,17,25
93:18,21 94:1
94:5,9,14,20
94:25 95:19
96:9
a.m3:9 65:18
88:8,13 95:8
B
back11:15 33:17
34:9,15 65:17
88:12 95:13
96:4
Band 54:9
bank4:8 61:25
61:25 62:3
Banyon4:13
bass:142:7
basically48:5
basis20:17 21:4
21:10 57:20
63:23
bathingsuits
87:16
Beach3:7,7 4:4
4:13,18 21:15
55:14,20 56:1
66:12 67:23
68:3 69:12
71:6 74:14
75:25 77:16
77:20 88:17
100:2,18,18
101:2 103:19
104:3,7
Becker3:3 5:3
100:3,21
104:20
bed83:12,18,22
89:14
bedroom29:2
30:8,15 39:5
57:8,15 82:2
began 38:14
85:13
beginning 3:8
behal£1:13 3:11
believe19:19
believes 61:9,14
Berger 56:19
better25:13
Bill 51:24 52:2
54:2,5,9,15
birth 5:10
birthday49:2,14
94:11,15
Biscayne3:23
bi-sexual11:17
58:23
blue 87:20
body 23:11
books12:9
born 5:17
Boulevard 3:23
4:3,13
braces29:1
Brad98:10 99:15
Bradley 3:20
104:23
brag 92:20
brain 96:15
brainwashing
33:1
break57:25 65:8
77:6 95:5
breasts 17:10
97:15
Brillo6:13
82:12 89:6,23
90:2,10 96:22
bring 35:22
54:23 62:16
66:21 68:8
77:5 94:20
99:8
bringing 39:11
68:14 74:25
83:22
Britney46:8,24
46:25
brought7:12
10:5 30:12
38:23 94:25
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 2
Brunel 36:8,15
36:18,22 37:2
37:7 49:15
54:19,22 55:9
Building4:8
burglary 53:8,10
BURNAIN4:12
businessmen
48:22
butt96:10
buttocks17:11
97:15
B.B4:3 77:9,11
77:15,24,24
78:7,14,21
79:4,11,17,17
79:25
B.T52:20,21
C
C5:2
CADWELL4:22
ca1125:25 27:1
38:20 46:7
70:8 71:15,24
72:4 73:13
74:24 76:3,9
94:9
called 33:14
34:23 53:9
100:7
calling 23:18
27:1
calls 24:24
43:11 65:25
66:6 69:22
camera 91:16
97:24 98:3
cameras 50:11
carbon45:2
case1:2 19:15
cases1:10 15:13
18:16
Cathy 6:6
cause3:3,9 43:1
43:6
CC104:23
Centne4:17
104:6
Certainly 34:16
52:13
certificate
101:5
certified5:4
certify100:5,12
102:2,14
103:20
chance 22:23
CHANGE 103:5
changes102:5
103:3 104:15
Chapter37:18
Chase 61:25
child13:9 18:6
36:23 37:2
71:11 73:22
74:9 75:20
76:17,23
children13:24
16:8 18:17
24:2 43:23
44:2
citizen7:22
City3:6 4:8
6:25 100:18
civi115:13
18:15
Clearlake4:17
104:6
client 81:8
Clinton 54:2,5
54:15
Clinton's54:9
clothes 83:17
clothing17:11
31:6
coerced 39:10
42:4,9
coffee45:23
COLRMA114:12
college 92:17
93:14,18
colleges 92:21
Columbia 92:22
93:2
Dome 25:2 39:4
40:7 44:22
47:5 66:1,7
67:2 68:20
69:23 70:4,9
70:15 71:17
71:25 72:4,11
73:14,21 75:7
76:4,10 82:11
99:4
cows 52:13
coming 9:13 27:2
28:25 34:24
83:4
commission
100:22 101:15
104:21
commit15:22
18:20
commits17:14
24:1
common 37:7
communicate 67:1
68:13,19 70:2
73:20 75:5
communicated
79:11,14
communicating
33:21
community60:18
60:25
complete 39:24
completed 8:23
completely 39:20
computer 35:11
89:5
computers 51:3,9
51:11,15,20
concerned 92:12
conduct15:14
20:16 42:24
confer7:21
confidentiality
60:4
confused80:21
connected 100:14
consensual 80:1
80:5
consider11:16
44:9
conspire 15:22
constitute
100:10
Constitution
5:15
contact20:16
21:14,17 22:3
contained 51:11
continue 18:17
18:20
continued4:1
5:24,25 58:1
88:14 95:15
contributed
40:12
control 60:19,25
62:9
controls 62:24
convenience
104:14
conversations
19:18
cooperate 24:9
Copies 99:16
Copperfield14:6
14:10 95:19
95:22 96:10
copy45:2 104:13
Cordero44:5
Cordially 104:17
correct6:20 7:1
15:3,14 16:13
16:19,24
21:18,25 22:6
26:22 27:3
28:17 31:17
32:1,5,10,16
32:22 34:8
37:9,21 41:24
46:4 47:1
48:7 51:5,7
51:11 52:15
53:4,16,18
57:3,9,15,21
62:5 64:8,13
65:1 102:6
correction 102:4
counse15:13 6:2
7:21 33:16
45:19 88:4
100:13,14
104:13
country 7:16
8:18 9:13
County3:7 100:2
100:18 101:2
103:19
course 67:11
68:24 70:21
72:16 74:1
76:15
courtl:1 3:11
3:13 34:16
99:14,19
covering17:11
Cowles19:14,19
63:22 64:17
Cowles's19:10
co-conspirator
15:18 16:7
18:25 19:2
20:1
co-conspirators
20:14
Co-Counse14:17
crims19:20
crimes15:22
16:7 18:21
19:1 20:2
24:1
criminal 15:13
15:17 43:11
43:15 44:10
44:14
Critton4:12,15
65:19 71:22
cross2:3 65:21
77:7 81:17
84:25 88:14
95:15
cuddle89:19
current 5:22
6:10 7:15
currently 6:12
81:1
C.F4:3
C.L77:10,13,19
78:3,3,11,17
78:25 79:8,14
79:21,21 80:4
D3:25 5:2
deily21:3,9
57:20
dance 99:6
date1:20 5:10
45:12,16
dated2:12 45:14
David4:14 14:6
14:10 95:18
95:22 96:9
104:24
Davies52:20,24
53:3,15,24
day 38:15 50:18
84:13 85:11
98:13 100:19
101:7 102:20
103:21
days 64:1
Dear104:12
decline 5:16
defendant4:12
78:6,10,20,24
80:1,5 81:2
Defendants1:8
4:17
defendant's
77:15,19
deliberate 42:20
42:24
delinquency
40:12
delivered 87:25
demand 31:4
demanded27:13
Department 88:17
deposition1:13
3:1,10 33:25
71:23 81:23
100:6,11
102:3,14,18
103:21 104:10
104:14,15
Dershowitz 56:23
57:12,18,24
58:1,2,6
designated 16:17
designation
24:16
designs144:10
despite 58:2
61:17
destination 56:9
56:15
detection 32:13
32:22 51:5
deteriorated
34:4
developed29:7
91:13
devise 29:20
different21:8
digital 97:24
98:3
digitally 32:9
dildos27:16,21
dinner95:17
96:10
direct2:3 5:6
31:4
direction 27:22
51:4
discovered 90:15
discussed18:5
64:24
Discussion81:19
discussions 99:3
disrupted 34:12
distress43:1,6
DISTRICT1:1,1
document16:6
45:20
Dodge 87:20
Doe1:4 42:13,19
42:25 56:3
81:21 103:2
104:9
Doe-102 47:23
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 3
48:2
doing25:1 33:22
donations 92:21
Doug 54:9
dress49:23 50:3
drive89:22 90:1
90:10
Dubin 55:3
duly5:3 100:9
duties 21:8
E
earlier25:17
37:17 41:23
East6:16,24
62:19,25
Edwards 2:5 3:16
3:20 5:7 6:5
23:1,5 34:3,9
34:11,15,18
45:17 65:4
98:12 99:10
99:16,21
104:23
either30:19
72:1,9
ejaculating
28:17
E1 6:12 82:11
89:6,23 90:2
90:10 96:22
Emmy58:15,18,18
emotional43:1,6
employed 9:6
56:12
employee 100:14
enclosed104:14
encounters 84:25
encouraged 40:17
40:18
endured40:8
enforcement
32:14,22 51:5
engage11:10
20:16 27:8,14
31:15 40:23
47:6 49:18
54:24 55:21
61:4,16,21
67:12,16
68:25 69:6,23
72:17,23 74:3
74:8 75:12,13
75:19 76:16
85:25 86:17
engaged41:2
50:8 58:6
59:1 76:21
77:23 78:2
engaging22:10
50:22 56:2,8
57:19 63:18
70:25 75:18
enjoy13:5 59:12
ENTER103:3
entering104:15
enterprise 43:11
43:15 44:10
entice 67:12
68:25 72:17
74:2 75:12
enticed39:10
76:21
entices 17:13
enticing 30:6
67:18 69:6
72:22 74:8
75:18
entitled 61:9,16
Epstein1:7 4:12
6:13,18 7:4
9:9,14,18,22
10:6,15 11:6
11:23 12:8,13
12:22 13:1,10
13:13,18,23
14:2,20,23
15:7,23 16:4
16:13,17,18
17:18,25 18:6
18:10,16,25
19:6 20:15,22
21:2,14,17
22:10 23:20
24:1 25:10,25
26:21,25 27:3
27:7,9,13,15
28:10,15,17
28:20 29:7,20
30:19 31:14
31:20 32:8,15
32:25 35:15
36:3 37:7,13
37:20,25 38:5
38:10,13
39:15 40:11
40:23 41:7,17
42:9,14,25
43:4,10,19
47:6,19,25
48:10,16 49:1
49:4,8,22
50:7,17,21
51:9 52:10,20
53:20 54:14
55:8,13,14,19
56:1,6 57:25
59:16,22 60:5
60:9,13,17
61:3,13,21
62:5,9,16,24
63:10,19 64:8
64:24 65:24
66:16,25 67:5
67:10,16 68:2
68:18,23 69:4
69:16,21
70:19,24 71:9
71:24 72:15
72:21 73:7,19
73:25 74:6,18
75:5,11,17
76:8,14,20
78:7,11 81:12
82:13 83:12
83:16,22 84:1
84:14,24
85:12,18,21
86:4,9,13,21
86:25 87:6,10
87:14,19,24
89:14 90:18
90:23 91:3,8
91:17,21
92:16,20 93:5
93:17,25
94:10,19,24
96:3,13,22
97:5,10,13,19
97:23 98:2
103:2 104:9
Epstein's12:1,5
12:18 15:19
17:2 20:2,10
23:21,25 26:5
26:13,20
27:22 29:2,13
30:6,12,15
34:24 39:5
40:1 41:3
42:3,8,18
44:9 45:3
46:16 48:12
50:1,12 51:3
51:4,16 52:5
53:2,8,14,16
54:4,9,23,24
56:18,22 57:2
57:8,14,19
58:17 59:6
62:15 63:9,23
64:2,12 66:7
66:12,22
67:23 68:9,9
68:15 69:11
70:10,16 71:5
71:17 72:5,11
73:3,14 74:13
75:1,11,16,24
76:5 82:21
83:5 85:8
88:18 93:22
94:15 95:18
Errata103:1,21
104:14
escalated86:9
escape24:5,10
Esg3:20,25 4:5
4:10,14,15,19
104:8,23,23
104:24,24
et1:7
Evelyn 8: 9
everyday 20:17
everyone's 6:4
evidence 51:10
Exactly23:2
EXAMINATIONS:6
65:21 77:7
81:17 88:14
95:15 98:11
examined102:18
examines45:19
executed 51:2
execution 51:16
exhibit 45:12,15
45:21
EXHIBITS 2:10
expenses 93:14
expires100:22
101:15 104:21
explain 22:23
exploited48:6
expressing 92:16
Ezell 2:8 4:10
6:7 81:18,21
86:6,15 95:7
95:16 98:6
99:17 104:24
e-mail 65:14
E.W3:17 11:3,7
11:11 25:17
25:20 26:12
26:19 27:1,2
27:8,13,20
28:21,25
32:10 38:1
42:3,13,19,25
55:12,15 57:7
F
fact11:10 15:18
18:6 21:21
26:9 31:25
37:6 38:9
39:23 40:5
43:4 53:7
61:8 64:22
66:5 67:17
69:5 70:2
72:4 74:7
76:21
false 39:20
falsify 8:5
familiar 6:15
35:24 36:12
45:4 53:1
57:18 62:23
FARMER 3:16
favorable 39:19
FBI 39:16,18
February 5:11
feel 80:9,20
96:10
felonies41:18
female 11:2
26:21 30:12
30:14 31:5,11
35:21 46:15
46:25 61:15
61:17,20
63:12,12,13
females12:23
13:2,6,14,17
15:8,24 16:12
16:19,23 17:3
18:1,11 20:11
20:17,23 21:3
21:9,15,23
22:4,11,16
28:1,5,9,14
29:8,14,22
30:2,7 31:16
32:5,10,15,21
33:2,8,13
34:22 35:3,8
35:17,23 36:4
37:8,14 40:22
41:3 44:11,15
44:22 48:5
49:9 50:7
56:14 59:2,7
61:5 63:13,16
63:18 64:25
Fifth5:14,19,25
6:3,11,14,17
6:22 7:3,8,11
7:14,17,23
8:1,4,8,10,13
8:15,20,22,25
8:25 9:2,5,8
9:12,17,21,24
10:3,10,13,17
10:23 11:1,5
11:9,14,22,24
12:3,7,12,16
12:20,25 13:4
13:8,12,16,21
14:1,5,8,12
14:14,18,22
15:1,5,11,16
15:21 16:1,5
16:10,15,21
17:1,6,16,20
17:24 18:4,9
18:14,19,23
19:4,8,13,17
19:21,24 20:5
20:8,13,20,25
21:6,12,20
22:2,8,14,19
23:8,16,23
24:4,8,13,18
24:23 25:4,8
25:16,23 26:3
26:8,11,18,24
27:5,11,18,24
28:3,7,12,19
28:24 29:5,11
29:16,18,24
30:4,10,18,22
31:3,8,13,19
31:24 32:2,7
32:12,18,24
33:5,10 35:2
35:6,10,14,19
36:1,6,11,14
36:17,21,25
37:5,11,16,23
38:3,8,12,18
38:22 39:2,8
39:14,17,22
40:4,10,15,21
41:1,6,11,16
41:21 42:1,6
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 4
42:12,17,22
43:3,9,13,18
43:21,25 44:4
44:6,8,13,18
44:25 45:7,9
46:1,6,11,13
46:19,23 47:3
47:9,11,18,22
47:24 48:9,14
48:19,25 49:6
89:3,8,12,17
89:21,25 90:4
90:8,13,17,22
91:1,6,11,15
91:20,24 92:4
92:7,11,15,19
92:24 93:4,9
93:12,16,20
93:24 94:4,8
94:13,18,23
14:25 15:4,10
15:15,20,25
16:9,14,20,25
17:5,19,23
18:3,8,13,18
18:22 19:7,12
19:16,23 20:4
20:12,19,24
21:5,11,19
22:1,7,13,18
69:8,14,18,25
70:5,11,17,22
71:2,7,12,19
72:2,7,13,19
72:25 73:5,10
73:17,23 74:4
74:10,16,21
75:2,8,14,21
76:1,6,12,18
76:24 77:17
genita117:1O
getting25:25
57:8
Ghislaine29:17
33:11 34:20
48:1,11,15
58:12,19,22
59:1
gifts49:8 87:15
girl 29:1 66:11
49:12,17,21 95:3,21,23 23:22 24:3,7 77:21,25 78:4 67:22 68:7
49:25 50:5,10 96:1,6,12,17 24:12,17,22 78:8,12,15,18 69:11 71:5
50:16,20,25 96:19,24 97:3 25:3,7,15,22 78:22 79:1,5 73:2 74:12,24
51:13,19,22 97:8,12,18,22 26:2,7,17,23 79:9,12,15,19 75:24 94:25
52:1,3,7,12 98:1,5,14,19 27:4,10,17,23 79:23 80:2,6 girlfriend19:10
52:17,23,25 98:20 28:2,6,11,18 80:10,14,22 24:15,21
53:6,12,23 fight34:12 28:23 29:4,10 61:3 82:3,7 girla14:20
54:1,3,7,12 file3:11 29:15,23 30:3 82:14,18,22 25:11 38:19
54:17,21 55:2 financial 9:10 30:9,17,21 83:1,6,9,14 38:24 39:3
55:4,6,11,17 9:15 31:2,7,12,18 83:19,24 84:4 42:15 65:25
55:24 56:5,11 financially8:17 31:23 32:6,11 84:11,17,21 66:6 68:8
56:17,21,25 8:21 100:15 32:17,23 33:4 85:1,5,9,15 94:20 96:2
57:5,11,17,23 findl04:14 33:9 35:1,5,9 85:19,23 86:2 give22:22 28:22
58:5,10,14,16 fine 6:5 77:5 35:13,18,25 86:6,11,15,19 71:25 72:5
58:21,25 59:4 first5:3 12:21 36:5,10,16,20 86:23 87:2,8 75:1 87:6
59:9,15,19,25 14:19 20:21 36:24 37:4,10 87:12,17,22 94:21 95:1
60:3,7,11,16 26:4 30:5 37:15,22 38:2 88:2,19,23 96:14 97:1,24
60:21 61:2,7 38:15 45:18 38:7,11,17,21 89:2,7,11,16 given 27:25
61:12,19,24 FISTOS3:16 39:1,7,13,21 89:20,24 90:3 39:16 62:4
62:2,7,12,18 Flagler4:9 40:3,9,14,20 90:7,12,16,21 63:3 95:24
62:22 63:2,7 flew56:1 40:25 41:5,10 90:25 91:5,10 96:3 102:3
63:15,21,25 flight52:4,19 41:15,20,25 91:14,19,23 giving67:6
64:5,10,15,21 59:21,23 60:1 42:5,11,16,21 92:3,6,10,14 73:15
65:3 66:4,10 flights52:5,9 43:2,8,12,17 92:18,23 93:3 Glenn55:3
66:15,19,24 55:14,20 43:24 44:3,12 93:8,11,15,19 globe48:6
67:4,9,15,21 Floridal:1 3:5 44:17,24 45:6 93:23 94:3,7 go23:2 34:9
68:1,6,12,17 3:8,19,24 4:4 46:5,10,14,18 94:12,17,22 39:4 93:1
68:22 69:3,9 4:9,13,18 46:22 47:2,8 95:2,20 96:5 94:5,9 95:11
69:15,19 70:1 17:8 63:11 47:14,21 48:3 96:11,16,23 95:24 96:3
70:6,12,18,23 64:7 100:1,5 48:8,13,18,24 97:2,7,11,17 going5:23 10:20
71:3,8,13,20 100:19,22 49:5,11,16,20 97:21,25 98:4 21:24 29:1
72:3,8,14,20 101:1,14 49:24 50:4,9 98:18 102:5 45:8 63:11
73:1,6,11,18 103:18 104:3 50:15,19,24 Fort3:19 95:8 99:7
73:24 74:5,11 104:7,21 51:6,12,18,21 forward4O:7 GOLDBERG1O4:6
74:17,22 75:3 flown22:16 51:25 52:6,11 Foundation64:7 Goldberger4:16
75:9,15,22 60:13,18,22 52:16,22 53:5 France49:14 4:19 5:23 6:6
76:2,7,13,19 f1y56:7 53:11,17,22 frequent62:20 7:19 10:20
76:25 77:12 follows3:15 5:5 53:25 54:6,11 friend59:5 11:20 22:24
77:14,18,22 fond14,97:14 54:16,20 55:1 friends 14:3 23:2,9 33:15
78:1,5,9,13 forbidden85:3 55:10,16,23 39:11 48:17 33:19 34:2,7
78:16,19,23 force61:15 56:4,10,16,20 48:20 49:2,8 34:10,14
79:2,6,10,13 forced13:1O 56:24 57:4,10 further86:9,10 45:19 65:6,9
79:16,20,24 28:21 42:15 57:16,22 58:4 100:12 103:21 65:12 77:5
80:3,7,11,19 forces17:12 58:9,13,20,24 F.P74:13,19,25 80:23 81:7,13
80:25 81:10 foregoing100:9 59:3,8,14,18 75:6,10,13,16 95:4,10 98:8
81:15 82:4,8 101:5 102:2 59:24 60:2,6 75:19 98:25 99:11
02:10,15,19 form7:6,13,18 60:10,15,20 104:8,12
02:23 83:2,7 7:25 8:7,19 61:1,6,11,18
.
G good81:20 92:5
83:10,15,20 9:11,16,20,23 61:23 62:6,11 gain29:7,13 government16:3
83:25 84:5,12 10:2,9,12,16 62:17,21 63:1 30:1 37:13 grade8:23
84:18,22 85:2 10:19 11:4,8 63:6,14,20,24 gaining33:7 grades92:13
85:6,10,16,20 11:13,19 12:2 64:4,9,14,20 41:13 gratification
85:24 86:3,7 12:6,11,15,19 65:2 66:3,9 Gardens4:4 29:9 66:2,8
86:12,16,20 12:24 13:3,7 66:14,18,23 Generally 56:6 67:2
86:24 87:3,9 13:11,15,20 67:3,8,14,20 57:18 Groff19:25
87:13,18,23 13:25 14:4,7 67:25 68:5,11 generically groomed59:11
88:3,20,24 14:11,17,21 68:16,21 69:2 63:12,16 grooming32:20
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 5
33: L,8
grounds10:25
guess 95:4
guest58:3 95:19
guilty41:18
guise21:24
H
habit30:23
57:19
Hafele 80:16
Hafele's81:6
68:7,14,19
70:8 74:24
75:5
half 7:19
HAIND100:17
hands45:20
hanging 93:21
happened 28:9
34:4 39:25
happening 84:6
harass10:22
40:2
harassing40:6
harm41:13
Harvard 92:22
head22:20 23:7
23:10 33:17
hear 91:21,25
96:13
heard 25:9
heart 80:12
held84:14 85:12
helicopter59:21
help43:16 44:16
93:6,10
helped8:5 29:19
hereinafter 5:4
hereto 102:4
herewith104:14
heterosexual
11:17
hidden 50:11
81:25
holding 84:15
home45:3 66:1,7
66:13,22 67:2
67:12,24 68:3
68:9,15,20,25.
69:12,23 70:4
70:10,16,21
71:1,6,10,17
71:25 72:5,12
72:17,24 73:3
73:14,21 74:2
74:9,13,19
75:1,7,11,17
75:25 76:5,10
76:16,22 83:5
88:18
homemade 50:21
homes 50:12
hopes41:13
Horowitz2:6
3:21,25 6:8
33:17 34:1
65:7,11,13,22
77:1 104:23
hour3:8
house 21:15
24:24 25:11
26:1,5,13,20
30:13 34:24
38:24 39:4,5
40:1 46:4,17
46:24 47:5
51:4,16 53:3
53:8,14,16
54:23,24 57:2
57:?,13 58:3
63:23 64:12
82:11,21 89:1
93:22 95:18
houseman 90:5
hundreds29:8
31:16,16
37:20 82:25
I
idea33:23
identification
2:11 45:16
illegal17:4
21:16
implicate 19:20
improper 21:13
21:16 54:13
inappropriate
80:17 81:5
incarcerated
6:18 41:22
including32:10
inclusive 100:10
incriminate
98:17
INDEX2:2
indicate10:5
indicated 6:23
18:16 61:4
indicates17:9
46:2
indicating 22:20
22:21 46:7
individual77:11
77:13
induce 67:12
68:25 72:17
74:2 75:12
inducing 30:6
67:17 69:5
72:22 74:7
inform 67:5
71:14
informad88:25
initials 96:20
inserted84:15
inside16:6 30:8
53:14
instance 27:6
63:10
instruct10:20
31:5 65:24
66:25 68:7,18
69:21 71:24
73:19 75:5
76:8 81:8
instructed 27:7
32:3 59:16
90:10 97:14
instructing
83:17
intent18:17,20
41:12 43:5
67:11 68:24
72:16
intention 70:20
74:1 75:12
76:15
intentional
42:20,23
intentionally
17:9
interaot18:11
21:2 96:25
interacting 15:7
interaction 17:3
28:13 31:1,15
41:18 48:1
64:25
interactions
27:19 42:3,8
interest 6:4
92:1/
interested
100:15
interferes99:1
international
43:22
interpret 23:7
interrupt 33:24
interrupted 34:1
intimidate 10:23
40:2
intimidating
40:6
introduced87:5
97:9
investigate 53:9
investigation
15:18 53:13
investigator
51:23
invited 96:4
invocation 5:25
invoke 5:13,19
involved30:1
36:7 64:17,18
involvement
98:24
involvos81:7
involving 15:14
28:9
irrelevant 80:15
island22:15,16
23:21 50:23
60:14,23
J3:20 4:5
Jack4:19 23:5
99:10 104:8
JAFFK3:16
jail 6:19,24 7:5
41:24
Jans1:4 3:17,22
4:8 42:13,19
42:25 47:23
48:1 56:3
81:21
Jean36:8,15,18
36:22 37:2,7
49:15 54:19
54:22 55:9
Jeffrey1:7 4:12
6:13 9:9,14
9:18 10:6,15
11:6,23,25
12:4,8,13,18
12:21 13:1,9
13:13,18,23
14:2,20,23
15:6,19,23
16:3,12,17,18
17:2,17,25
18:5,10,16,25
19:6 20:2,10
20:15,21 21:2
21:14,17
22:10 23:20
23:20,24 24:1
25:9,24 26:4
26:13,20,21
26:25 27:3,7
27:8,13,15,22
28:10,15,17
28:20 29:2,6
29:13,19 30:6
30:12,15,19
31:14,20 32:8
32:14,25
34:24 35:15
36:3 37:6,13
37:19,25 38:5
38:9,13 39:4
39:15,25
40:11,23 41:3
41:7,17 42:2
42:8,9,14,18
42:24 43:4,10
43:19 44:9
45:3 46:16
47:6,19,25
48:10,12,16
49:1,4,8,22
50:1,7,12,17
50:21 51:3,4
51:9,15 52:5
52:9,19 53:2
53:8,14,15,19
54:4,8,14,23
54:24 55:8,13
55:14,19 56:1
56:6,18,22
57:2,7,14,19
57:25 58:17
59:5,16,22
60:5,9,12,17
61:3,13,21
62:5,9,15,16
62:24 63:9,10
63:19,23 64:2
64:8,12,24
65:24 66:7,12
66:16,22,25
67:5,10,16,23
68:2,8,9,15
68:18,23 69:4
69:11,16,21
70:9,15,19,24
71:5,9,17,24
72:5,11,15,21
73:3,7,14,19
73:25 74:6,13
74:18,25 75:4
75:10,11,16
75:17,24 76:4
76:8,14,20
78:7,11 81:11
82:12,21 83:4
83:12,16,21
84:1,13,24
85:8,11,21
86:4,9,13,21
86:25 87:6,10
87:14,19,24
88:17 89:13
90:18,23 91:3
91:8,16,21
92:16,20 93:5
93:17,22,25
94:10,15,19
94:24 95:18
96:13,21
97:13,23 98:2
JESSICh4:22
job21:7
J0114:22
join83:17 84:2
joined 65:19
Judge80:16 81:5
99:9
jury 23:6,7
J.M75:24 76:4
76:10,15,21
K
K5:2
Katherine4:10
81:21 104:24
Kellen 19:2,3,9
27:1 29:25
30:13 33:6,12
34:21 52:19
63:10 64:13
64:18 70:14
71:14 72:10
79:3,7 90:1
Kellen's19:18
kid-type13:24
22:17
kind65:13 85:4
91:16
kiss 97:14
kitchen 82:1
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 6
knew14:19 96:3
know8:2,9 11:3
14:6,13 15:9
17:17 19:3,10
20:6 23:5,14
25:20 29:6,17
33:21 34:3
36:8,15,23
44:5,7 45:22
47:10,12,16
47:19,23
50:12 52:2,24
54:2 55:3,5
56:22 57:1,6
57:13 58:15
58:23 59:1
63:13 64:6,11
64:22 77:11
77:13 79:17
79:21,25 80:4
80:12 82:9
89:9 90:1
91:12,16 92:5
92:25 93:5,10
93:13,25
94:24 96:2,18
96:21 97:4
98:2
knowledge 60:17
known37:2 92:20
L
labeled16:7
lady8:2 11:2
landed56:15
Langino2:7 4:5
77:3,8,9
81:16 88:11
large3:5 97:19
100:5,22
104:21
lascivious 17 : 8
17:10,14
31:10 37:18
late 66:13,20
Lauderdale 3:19
law 32:14,21
51:5
lawsuits 15:13
lay27:7
lead30:14 62:13
62:14
learn12:21
leave 30:15 39:5
left71:22 88:11
Lega14:23 104:1
104:18
LEHRMAN 3:16
LEOP0LD-KUVIN
4:2
Les47:10
lesbian 10:7
Lesley 19:25
Leslie 47:20
lewd17:7,10,14
31:9 37:17
lie 59:17
life40:18 42:4
42:10 62:13
62:14
liked38:10
91:17
likes38:10
Limited47:13
LINE 103:5
lines84:24
list33:13 34:22
35:4,8,11
63:9
listed19:2,25
52:8,18 63:16
lists 63:8
literally 21:3
litigation 18:15
lived 62:9
lives19:5
live-in 24:21
living 6:12
43:20 63:4
LLP4:12
local22:11
logs 52: 4
long7:9
look45:21
lose91:22 92:2
lost34:12
love22:22 81:1
81:11
Luc 36:8,15,18
36:22 37:2,7
49:15 54:19
54:22 55:9
lure 16:11 20:10
LUTTIER4:12
L.M38:6,9,13,19
38:23 39:9,16
42:8,14,19,25
55:22 57:13
L.N3:17
N
M5:2
main38:19
making68:20
man6:13 54:10
manner17:10
18:12 28:14
mansion 21:18
Narch100:23
101:15 104:22
1:13
2:4 3:2 5:9
7:10 63:11
65:23 81:20
95:17 98:13
99:3 100:7
102:1,8,15
103:15,20
104:10
Maritsa 8:3
marked45:11,15
massage 21:24
67:6 71:25
72:5,12 73:15
75:1 76:5
82:2,12,16
84:8,14 85:12
95:1 97:1
massages87:6
94:21 96:15
97:5
massaging 97:16
master12:9
33:12 34:21
35:4,8,11
82:1
masturbate 87:10
masturbated 86:5
Maxwell 29:17
33:11 34:21
48:11,15
58:12,22 59:1
Maxwell's48:1
58:19
MC-Sgpared36:12
MC-2 36:12
mean12:4 21:1
35:20
meaning 58:1
59:11 84:7
means 9:9,14
mechanism 37:13
meet11:23
members44:20
MERMELSTEEN3:21
message2:12
45:1,12,14
46:2
messages44:21
45:10
met20:21 38:13
38:15 95:22
method 30:6,23
35:20
methodology 33:7
meticulous 44:21
Mexico 22:9
Miami3:24 4:9
59:22
microphone 96:8
98:9
NIke44:7
millionaire
62:14
mind 98:10
minor12:22 13:2
13:5,14,17
15:8,23 16:12
16:19,23 17:3
18:1,11 20:17
20:22 21:3,9
21:15,23 22:4
22:11,16 28:1
28:5,8,14,21
29:8,14,21
30:2,7,12,14
31:5,11,15
32:4,9,15,21
33:2,8,13
34:22 35:3,8
35:17,21,23
36:3 37:0,14
38:5 40:22
41:3 44:11,15
44:22 46:15
46:25 47:7
48:2,4 49:9
50:7 53:20
56:14 59:2,7
60:9 61:5,15
61:17 63:18
64:25 71:1
72:24 79:17
79:21 80:9
minors18:21
19:1 20:3
23:19 27:22
31:1,22 40:13
41:9,13,19
48:11,17
50:14,22
54:14,24 56:8
57:20 58:2,7
59:13 63:4
minute 88:5
minutes77:4
model 8:11
modeling 36:4,7
36:13 37:12
molest14:23
16:13,18
18:17 21:9
26:1 35:23
44:10,15
molestation 17:8
17:15 37:18
46:20
molested 14:20
29:3 34:25
39:6,10,12
44:23 46:16
molester18:7
36:23 37:3
molesting16:23
22:5 25:12
26:21 38:15
59:6
molests35:21
money35:22 62:3
62:4 87:7
morning 81:20
move 23:4
movements 23:10
23:11
20:7
51:8,15
multiple 67:24
69:12 74:14
M.L 66:12,17,21
67:1,5,11,18
N
N5:2,2
1:13 2:4
3:1 5:9 46:3
46:3 63:11
100:6 102:1,8
102:15 103:15
103:20 104:10
naked27:7 30:20
50:6 90:15 .
name 5:8 8:2
62:4 81:22
named 6:13 11:2
11:3 18:24
19:2 66:12
67:23 68:7
69:11 71:5
73:3 74:13,24
75:24 77:11
77:13
names8:14 33:13
34:22
National4:8
nature67:7 72:6
72:12 73:16
82:17
near45:3
need43:16
needed 91:22
Neon 87:20
never 58:6
new6:16,25,25
21:17 22:3,9
60:18,23 62:1
87:4 93:1
94:1
nine 62:23
nodding 33:17,18
33:19
nonprosecution
16:2
non-prosecution
20:1
North 3:18
Notary 3:4 100:4
100:22 101:14
102:17 104:20
noted 99:22
Notice 3:9
noting102:5
nude82:5 89:5
89:15 90:20
90:24 91:4,9
91:18 93:22
number 5:12
45:15
numbered 3:2
100:10
numbers 3:22
33:14 34:23
numerous 6:19
15:7 19:15
23:18 25:10
29:2 52:14
56:12 86:22
Nr092:21 93:1
O
05:2
Object8:7,19
9:11,16,20,23
10:2,9,12,16
10:19 11:4,8
11:13,19 12:2
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 7
12:6,11,15,19
12:24 13:3,7
13:11,15,20
13:25 14:4,7
14:11,17,21
14:25 15:4,10
15:15,20,25
16:9,14,20,25
17:5,19,23
18:3,0,13,18
18:22 19:7,12
19:16,23 20:4
20:12,19,24
21:5,11,19
22:1,7,13,18
23:22 24:3,7
24:12,17,22
25:3,7,15,22
26:2,7,17,23
27:4,10,17,23
28:2,6,11,18
28:23 29:4,10
29:15,23 30:3
30:9,17,21
31:2,7,12,18
31:23 32:6,11
32:17,23 33:4
33:9 35:1,5,9
35:13,18,25
36:5,10,16,20
36:24 37:4,10
37:15,22 38:2
38:7,11,17,21
39:1,7,13,21
40:3,9,14,20
40:25 41:5,10
41:15,20,25
42:5,11,16,21
43:2,8,12,17
43:24 44:3,12
44:17,24 45:6
46:5,10,14,18
46:22 47:2,8
47:14,21 48:3
48:8,13,18,24
49:5,11,16,20
49:24 50:4,9
50:15,19,24
51:6,12,18,21
51:25 52:6,11
52:16,22 53:5
53:11,17,22
53:25 54:6,11
54:16,20 55:1
55:10,16,23
56:4,10,16,20
56:24 57:4,10
57:16,22 58:4
58:9,13,20,24
59:3,8,14,18
59:24 60:2,6
60:10,15,20
61:1,6,11,18
61:23 62:6,11
62:17,21 63:1
63:6,14,20,24
64:4,9,14,20
65:2 66:3,9
66:14,18,23
67:3,8,14,20
67:25 68:5,11
68:16,21 69:2
69:8,14,18,25
70:5,11,17,22
71:2,7,12,19
72:2,7,13,19
72:25 73:5,10
73:17,23 74:4
74:10,16,21
75:2,8,14,21
76:1,6,12,18
76:24 77:17
77:21,25 78:4
70:8,12,15,10
70:22 79:1,5
79:9,12,15,19
79:23 80:2,6
80:10,14,22
81:3 82:3,7
82:14,18,22
83:1,6,9,14
83:19,24 84:4
84:11,17,21
85:1,5,9,15
85:19,23 86:2
66:6,11,15,19
86:23 87:2,8
87:12,17,22
88:2,19,23
89:2,7,11,16
89:20,24 90:3
90:7,12,16,21
90:25 91:5,10
91:14,19,23
92:3,6,10,14
92:18,23 93:3
93:8,11,15,19
93:23 94:3,7
94:12,17,22
95:2,20 96:5
96:11,16,23
97:2,7,11,17
97:21,25 98:4
98:18
objecting1O:24
objection 6:21
7:2,6,13,18
7:25 11:20
25:18 80:18
80:24 81:4,13
84:9
objections 81:14
objects:09:9
observations
19:19 42:2,7
observe 70:14
72:9 78:6,10
84:20 92:12
93:17
observed 17:25
21:1,16 22:12
23:20 25:24
26:12 27:1
30:5 31:14,20
32:0,14 39:4
40:23 49:7
60:8 61:21
obsession12:22
37:0
obtaining 51:10
obviously 5:24
occasions 6:20
7:5 19:15
25:10 26:14
29:2 31:16
37:20 41:24
49:7 52:15
53:3 57:3
67:24 69:12
74:14 83:11
October88:16
offered 93:13
offers 35:21
Officer 24:20
59:17
official 100:17
okay 6:1,6 33:25
45:25 65:6
95:7 99:11
o1d1O:7 11:12
26:6,10 38:14
38:25 49:23
73:9
olds49:3,13,19
once94:9
operate47:17
operates 21:21
47:13
operation30:24
ora127:25 28:4
28:22 84:2,7
86:21 87:1
order81:6
ordered 87:25
ordering 99:14
orders 25:5
organization
43:15 44:19
organize44:16
organized44:11
orgies13:24
22:17 23:17
50:23
orgy23:15
orientation
10:18 25:19
original11:15
ORSECK4:7
outside55:21
overhear72:9
owned 64:8
owns47:12 62:24
o'clock3:8
P
pads45:1
page2:11 45:11
102:4 103:5
pages 100:9
paid85:21 87:6
89:14,18
94:24
Palm3:6,7 4:4
4:13,18 21:15
55:14,20 56:1
66:12 67:23
68:3 69:11
71:6 74:13
75:24 77:16
77:20 88:17
100:2,18,18
101:2 103:19
104:3,7
parents 8:14
12:17
part15:17 23:24
29:12 32:13
44:19 50:1
participant
59:10
participate
28:15 73:12
76:3,9 89:4
participated
16:22 20:10
80:8
particular46:2
particularly
22:15
parties100:13
passed 62:8
passenger52:9
63:8
pause 65:16 88:9
95:12
pay 9:18,22,25
32:15 86:25
92:1 93:13
94:20
pending3:12
penetrate 32:9
penetration 85:4
penis84:15 85:8
85:13
penises 86:18
people 20:9
48:21 56:13
peroent34:7
Perfect34:11
perform14:3,9
14:15 31:9
33:2 36:19
86:21 87:1,11
performance 88:1
performed10:14
84:7
performing 84:2
period26:14
80:20
perpetrator
17:14
person17:9,12
17:13 19:1
51:8 53:15,19
personal48:23
64:2
personally 26:25
66:11 67:22
69:10 71:4
73:2 74:12
75:23
personnel 6:24
persons 51:14
persuade 67:12
68:25 72:17
74:2
persuaded76:21
persuading 67:17
69:5 72:22
74:7 75:18
PGA4:3
phone 33:13
34:22 74:24
photograph 90:19
91:3
photographs 35:7
50:6,13 82:6
89:5 90:24,24
91:8,12,17
phrase 25:13
physically 61:15
78:14,17
piop48:16
Pc 3:16
place 3:14 56:7
56:7 65:24
66:6 69:21
70:8
places:45:3
55:20
Plaintiff 1:5,13
3:11 100:7
Plaintiffs 3:17
3:22 4:2
Plaintiff's2:11
45:11,15
plan29:7 32:13
planning29:12
30:1
play 88:1
played20:15
23:6
pleading23:8
please45:21
pleasing27:3
pleasure 68:10
pled41:17
PODHURST4:7
point55:8 71:21
77:2 88:10
police 53:9,13
08:17
politicians
48:21
poo125:1
pornographic
50:22
pornography
50:18
posing 91:18
positioned45:2
pounds 91:22
92:2
presence 28:9
54:15 102:19
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 8
103:21
present4:21
84:13 88:16
95:19
presume 98:16
Prinos14:13,16
prior13:22 51:1
51:16 69:20
70:7,13 74:23
75:4,10 89:6
privacy10:25
81:7
private 52:5,10
privilege 99:5
privileges 5:14
5:20 6:1
10:24
probation24:20
24:24,25 25:6
59:17 60:12
60:18
proceedings
65:16,20
71:22 88:11
95:12
procure 16:12
35:16
procured 38:23
professional 3:4
48:22 100:4
100:21 104:1
104:20
profit43:22
44:1
promised93:6
prompt104:16
proper12:9
property 77:16
77:20
prosecution
98:23
prostitute 42:15
48:16
prostitution
40:19 42:4,10
protect43:16
provide 82:12
provided87:15
87:20
providing 97:5
psychological
41:14
psychology 33:1
public 3:5 37:2
100:4,22
101:14 102:17
104:21
pumping85:13
purchase 94:14
97:24
puxpOse10:22
34:23 56:7,13
60:1 68:14,19
69:22 70:3
73:14
purposes 22:4
25:12,25
26:20 27:2
29:9 32:20
49:3,9 55:15
56:2
purses 87:15
pursuant3:9
P.A3:21
p.m46:9,25 47:5
95:14 99:13
99:22
question 5:16,19
6:9 10:21
11:15,18,21
19:22 34:19
45:9 47:15
52:20 80:17
81:4,9 98:15
99:1,8
questioning77:4
questions 5:21
23:3,12 77:1
98:7,16,21
quiet32:16
R
R5:2
raid88:22 89:1
89:6
raided88:17
Railroad 3:6
104:2
ranch22:9
read16:2 23:1
34:15,17
37:17 102:2
102:18 103:20
104:13
reading 102:16
reads12:8
reask6:9
reason 34:5
98:15,20
103:5
reasons41:8
recall 82:5 83:3
83:16,21 84:1
84:6,19,23
85:3,7,11,17
85:21 87:4,14
87:19,24
89:18 90:14
91:2 92:16
97:9,13
receive40:17
49:8 74:23
reoeived28:4
71:15
reckloss42:20
42:24
recognize45:25
record 34:17
65:15,18
81:19 88:7,13
95:9,14 99:12
100:11
records 89:5
RECROSS 2:3
REDIRECT 2:3
98:11
referred 71:16
refers 64:1
refuse 5:20
refused 85:7
regarding18:25
25:10 40:7
44:21
Registered3:4
100:3,21
104:1,20
regular 63:23
82:20
related1:10
15:6 20:2
25:18 41:18
45:9
relationship
56:18,23 99:2
relative100:13
relevance 81:4
remember 27:6,12
28:25 53:7
59:22 65:13
82:24 83:11
89:13 90:5,9
removal 89:4
remove 31:5
83:17
removed 89:9
rented 87:21
repeatedly 90:19
rephrase 34:18
reported100:6
Reporter 3:4
34:16 99:14
99:19 100:4
100:21 104:20
Reportors104:1
reports10:4
represent11:2
24:14 77:9
81:21
represented
24:20
requests 50:2
required 62:15
residing 9:7
resources40:1
respeot42:13
respectfully
5:16
result25:18
41:22
return40:17
ridden 54:18
right11:3 15:9
15:19 23:4
25:20,21 26:1
26:10,16 36:9
36:15 45:5
46:9,21 59:7
61:10 62:10
64:3,19 77:6
95:5 99:20
righthand 54:10
rights 81:8
Riley51:24 52:2
Robert4:15
65:19 71:22
68:8,14
68:19 70:8
74:24 75:6
Rodriguez 90:6,9
90:15
rolel6:11 23:24
43:11 44:14
roles 20:15
room 30:16 71:23
roses 87:25
Ross 20:6
roughly 10:6
ROVNER4:22
royalty48:21
rules84:23
S
867:11 68:24
72:16 74:1
75:10,16
76:15 79:25
80:4 84:15
86:8 92:17
Sandy 56:19
Sanka44:7
Sarah19:2,3,9
19:18 27:1
29:25 30:13
33:6,12 34:21
52:19 63:10
64:12,18
70:14 71:14
72:9 79:3,7
90:1
satisfies 6:4
saved35:11
saying22:22
schedule 57:25
scheduled 16:16
46:16,20
schedules 21:22
scheduling 44:22
47:5 56:13
scheme 20:10
21:22 29:7,13
29:20 30:1
35:16
school 8:24 9:1
9:3 93:1
schools 93:7
Science 64:7
scientist 96:15
screamed85:14
screaming 85:17
sea1100:17
search 51:1,17
second7:20
Secret47:13,17
47:17
Security 5:12
see45:17,22,22
45:24 63:22
86:13,21 91:7
93:21 95:25
97:19
seen50:6 52:4
77:15,19
senior88:1
sent49:2,14
September 52:18
Sergio44:5
serves 10:22
services 10:14
severe43:1,6
sex10:1,8,15
11:6 12:1,5,9
12:14,18 13:2
13:5,10,14,18
13:23 16:22
18:21 20:11
22:10 23:19
23:25 24:6,11
24:15 27:25
28:4,22 32:1
32:3 33:8
37:14 40:23
43:22 44:1
49:18 50:1,8
50:23 54:25
56:2 58:11,18
58:19 59:12
60:9 61:5,16
61:22 62:15
63:18 83:22
84:2,7 85:25
86:5,17,22
87:1 89:5
94:14
sexual10:18
11:10 12:22
18:12 20:16
21:13 25:19
27:19 28:8,14
28:16 29:9
30:7,25 31:10
31:15,21 40:8
40:18 41:2
47:6 48:1
54:13-55:7,21
56:8 57:20
58:7 59:2
66:1,8 67:2,6
67:13,18 68:9
68:15 69:1,6
69:23 70:4,10
70:25 71:17
72:6,12,18,23
73:15,21 74:3
74:8 75:13,19
76:11,16,22
77:23 78:2
79:18,22,25
80:4,8 82:16
87:11
sexually 14:3,10
14:16 15:7
21:2 22:5
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 9
25:12 26:1,21
27:3,14 29:3
33:3 34:25
36:19 38:14
39:6,9,11
40:13 41:8
44:23 48:6,11
49:4,10 53:21
55:13,15 57:8
57:14 58:1
64:18 66:17
68:3 69:17
70:20 71:10
73:8 74:19
shaking 22:20
23:7
Sheet103:1,21
104:14
shopping 94:5,10
short 65:8 88:9
shorten 6:2
show45:10 94:15
96:4
showing45:13
shows 95:25
sign60:4 104:13
signed102:18
103:21
signing102:16
silent34:12
similar 21:16,21
58:17
similarly 22:10
simply6:2 99:7
single 30:24
98:14
Sixth 5:14,19
slave10:1,8,15
12:5,10,14,18
23:25 24:6,11
24:15 50:2
58:18,19
62:15
slaves12:1
62:16
sleep 89:14
smart92:9
Social 5:12
sole 9:9,14
56:13
somebody8:5
19:5,9 25:24
26:12 29:19
29:25 36:18
36:22 37:1
38:9,13 47:4
47:12,16
49:15 53:1
55:7 57:1,6
57:12 58:22
64:1,6,11,16
64:17
sorry5:18 34:14
49:3
sort81:25
South 104:7
SOUTHERN1:1
speak23:12
53:24 96:7
speaking 53:14
70:14 72:10
specific21:7
specifically
9:25 25:19
37:25 43:5
40:20 56:1
63:17
spoke41:23
spoken19:14
33:6 39:23
St 63:11
staff 44:20
stage 96:4
staircase81:25
82:6
State 3:5,7
55:21 100:1,5
100:19,22
101:1,14
103:18 104:21
stated84:19,24
102:17 103:20
statement39:16
39:19 78:20
78:24 79:3,7
Statesl:1 5:15
7:10,12 8:12
9:4,7 10:6
stationed45:2
status7:15
statute17:8,15
17:17,21 18:1
37:17 38:4
stayed 57:2
64:12
staying 63:4
stomach 85:12
stop88:4
stopped85:18
stopping 65:9
story19:10,14
19:18 39:24
63:22 64:17
straddle 27:14
strap-on27:21
86:14,18
Street4:9 6:16
6:25 62:19,25
strict25:5
student92:5
studying 93:22
submitted 102:15
substance102:5
succeeded 67:17
69:5 70:25
72:22 74:7
75:18
success 35:16
Suite 3:18,23
4:3,8,13,18
104:2,6
summoned 26:19
support9:10,15
104:1,18
supported8:16
8:21
sure5:25 20:15
21:8 88:6
surprise 52:13
surreptitious
50:13
swimming24:25
sworn5:3 100:9
system35:12,24
36:2
S.H52:20,21
T
table84:8,14
85:13
tactic40:6
take7:19 8:25
11:1 19:21
23:10 45:9
54:8 65:7
81:25 90:23
95:5
taken 1:13 3:3
50:13 51:3,23
91:8 98:14,20
talk25:19
talked32:25
35:15 39:15
40:5 41:8
43:10,14
talking 33:16,20
33:24 48:20
talks47:20
Taylor58:15,18
58:18
Teala52:20,24
53:3,15,24
teenage 69:10
71:4 75:23
Tel 3:19,24 4:4
4:10,14,19
telephone 25:2
45:4 65:25
66:6,21 67:1
68:13 69:21
70:3,8,15
71:15 72:10
73:13,20 75:6
76:3,9
tell 5:3,8 8:14
23:25 24:25
25:6,10 28:20
41:12 67:10
67:16 68:23
70:19,24
72:15 73:25
74:6 75:11,17
91:22,25 96:9
telling39:24
96:14
ten 62:8,23 77:3
91:22 92:2
Terri3:3 5:3
100:3,21
104:20
testified 5:5
35:12 59:20
Thank81:16 98:7
104:16
Thanks 99:10
theater94:1
thing 34:2 37:6
things 6:2
think12:17
33:22 34:1
Thomas 63:12
three49:3,13
51:2
threesome 27:8
27:13
tickets 94:1,1
95:24 96:3
time 3:14 14:19
20:21 26:4,14
26:19 30:5,24
33:15 54:22
55:8 60:8
63:3 65:19
69:20 70:7
75:4 79:18,22
80:20 83:4,8
86:10 87:4
88:10,22
89:10 90:6,14
91:2 97:4
99:22
times13:1 16:18
41:7 50:3
54:18 82:25
86:22 89:13
89:18 96:22
today 9:10,19
13:13 15:3
46:8 51:20
62:20
told24:25 30:25
32:19 39:18
43:5 61:9,14
74:25 94:19
touch17:14 85:7
touched 78: 14, 17
touches17:9
towel 30:20
town 57:24
toy 87: 4
toys 31:21 32:1
32:4 83:22
89:5 94:14
trafficked48:5
trafficking
43:23 44:1
traffics 36:3
train12:13
transcript 102:2
103:3
tried 96:10
trip 64:22,23
trips 60:24
true7:4,7 10:11
11:12 13:22
16:11 17:18
17:22 18:2
19:6,11,15
20:11,18
22:17 24:19
25:5,9,14
26:6 27:20
28:14 30:11
30:16,20 31:1
31:6,11,22
33:11,23
34:20 36:3,23
37:3,14 38:1
38:10,16,20
38:25 39:6,12
39:20 40:2,19
44:20 47:7
49:22 50:2
54:8 55:13,19
55:25 56:6,12
58:8,23 59:2
59:13 60:22
61:3,13 66:20
98:24 100:11
102:6
truth 5:4
try40:2 99:6
turn25:18
turning13:22
two41:18 83:18
type7:24
typical48:10,15
typically 30:13
96:2
U
underage 12:22
13:2,5,14,17
14:20,24 15:6
15:23 16:12
16:18,23 17:3
18:1,11 20:11
20:17,22 21:3
21:9,14,23
22:4,11,16,17
23:18 27:21
27:25 28:4,13
28:21 29:8,14
29:21 30:2,7
30:11,14 31:1
31:5,10,15,21
32:4,9,15,21
33:2,8,13
34:22 35:3,7
35:16,21,23
36:3 37:8,14
40:22 41:3
44:11,15,22
46:15,25 47:7
48:4,17 49:9
50:7,14,22
54:23 56:14
58:7 59:2,7
59:13 61:5,15
61:17 63:4,18
64:25 68:8
undersigned
102:17,19
understand15:2
17:2,4,7
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
Page 10
Unitedl:1 5:15
7:9,12 8:12
9:4,7 10:5
upstairs 82:1
90:15
use 32:3 83:23
86:13,14
91:17 94:15
96:20 97:19
104:15
uses 25:13
U.S4:23 7:22
104:1,18
■
V5:2 103:2
104:9
vagina 32:9
84:16 85:14
vaginal 85:4
variety29:21
various 16:22
20:15 29:21
40:12 44:20
63:8
Vazguss8:3
Velasagues8:9
vibrators 27:15
27:21 31:21
31:25 32:4
86:14,14
vibrator/nee...
97:20
victim55:8
victims40:6
43:7
Victoria's 47:13
47:17,17
video 23:12
65:15,18 88:7
88:12 95:9,14
99:12
Videographer
4:22 65:15,17
88:4,7,12
95:8,13 96:7
99:12
videos 50:13,22
videotaped1:13
3:1 100:6
violate17:25
37:20,25 38:5
violated17:18
17:22 53:20
visa7:24 8:6
visit6:19,23
67:11 68:24
72:16 74:1
76:15 85:22
visited7:5
41:23 96:21
visiting 97:5
visitor82:20
visits 54:22
70:21 75:10
75:16
Visoski 59:20
vs1:6
:3,8,13,21
74:1,8
:11,17,22
70:3,9,14,15
70:20,25
w
W4:10
want 23:6 45:17
99:8
wanted24:9
84:19 92:25
99:19
wants25:11
warrant 51:1,17
wasn't21:7
33:19
watch 50:17,21
86:4
watching87:11
way6:13 11:16
24:5 59:17
82:12 89:6,23
90:2,11 96:22
weakened43:7
wearing 30:20
Weber 55:5
WEISS4:16 104:6
WEISSING 3:16
went 6:19,23
26:4 86:10
West3:6,6 4:9
4:13,18 21:15
100:18 104:2
104:3,7
Werner47:10,20
Wharton 92:22
whatsoever 34:5
willing71:16
witness 2:3 6:3
7:21 10:21
34:6 45:20
96:8 100:7,8
100:11,17
102:15 104:13
104:15
witnessed 37:19
37:24 38:4
54:13 61:21
women 91:18
96:14
work46:8 64:6
working8:11
93:18
world 64:23
wouldn't42:3,9
42:14
WRITE 103:3
wrong80:13
Yarams4:14 6:21
7:2,6,13,18
7:25 8:7,19
9:11,16,20,23
10:2,9,12,16
10:19 11:4,8
11:13,19 12:2
12:6,11,15,19
12:24 13:3,7
13:11,15,20
13:25 14:4,7
14:11,17,21
14:25 15:4,10
15:15,20,25
16:9,14,20,25
17:5,19,23
18:3,8,13,18
18:22 19:7,12
19:16,23 20:4
20:12,19,24
21:5,11,19
22:1,7,13,18
23:22 24:3,7
24:12,17,22
25:3,7,15,22
26:2,7,17,23
27:4,10,17,23
28:2,6,11,18
28:23 29:4,10
29:15,23 30:3
30:9,17,21
31:2,7,12,18
31:23 32:6,11
32:17,23 33:4
33:9 35:1,5,9
35:13,18,25
36:5,10,16,20
36:24 37:4,10
37:15,22 38:2
38:7,11,17,21
39:1,7,13,21
40:3,9,14,20
40:25 41:5,10
41:15,20,25
42:5,11,16,21
43:2,8,12,17
43:24 44:3,12
44:17,24 45:6
46:5,10,14,18
46:22 47:2,8
47:14,21 48:3
48:8,13,18,24
49:5,11,16,20
49:24 50:4,9
50:15,19,24
51:6,12,18,21
51:25 52:6,11
52:16,22 53:5
53:11,17,22
53:25 54:6,11
54:16,20 55:1
55:10,16,23
56:4,10,16,20
56:24 57:4,10
57:16,22 58:4
58:9,13,20,24
59:3,8,14,18
59:24 60:2,6
60:10,15,20
61:1,6,11,18
61:23 62:6,11
62:17,21 63:1
63:6,14,20,24
64:4,9,14,20
65:2 66:3,9
66:14,18,23
67:3,8,14,20
67:25 68:5,11
68:16,21 69:2
69:8,14,18,25
70:5,11,17,22
71:2,7,12,19
72:2,7,13,19
72:25 73:5,10
73:17,23 74:4
74:10,16,21
75:2,8,14,21
76:1,6,12,18
76:24 77:17
77:21,25 78:4
78:8,12,15,18
78:22 79:1,5
79:9,12,15,19
79:23 80:2,6
80:10,14,22
80:24 81:3,14
82:3,7,14,18
82:22 83:1,6
83:9,14,19,24
84:4,9,11,17
84:21 85:1,5
85:9,15,19,23
86:2,6,11,15
86:19,23 87:2
87:8,12,17,22
88:2,19,23
89:2,7,11,16
89:20,24 90:3
90:7,12,16,21
90:25 91:5,10
91:14,19,23
92:3,6,10,14
92:18,23 93:3
93:8,11,15,19
93:23 94:3,7
94:12,17,22
95:2,20 96:5
96:11,16,23
97:2,7,11,17
97:21,25 98:4
98:18 99:18
104:24
year59:21 64:19
68:1
years10:7 11:11
17:12,13 26:6
26:9,15 37:1
38:14,25
55:18 62:8
73:9
York6:16,25,25
21:17 22:3
60:18,23 62:1
93:1 94:2
young11:2 29:1
94:20 96:14
younger 25:13
50:3 83:8
youngest13:9
61:20
Yugoslavian 10:7
Y.L67:23 68:3
68:15,20,24
69:6
$1,00085:22
$1,500 92:1
$20087:1 94:25
08-CV-80893-...
1:2
08-801191:10
08-80232 1:10
08-803801:10
08-80381 1:10
08-80811 1:11
08-808931:11
08-809941:11
09-8-5911:11
09-804691:11
09-806561:11
09-808021:11
09-810921:11
12:12 4:8 45:12
45:15 100:10
1,00092:1
1:1595:10
1:3095:11
1:3695:14
1:4199:13
1:4388:13
1:4599:22
10:00 3:8
10026:13 34:7
10381:21
104 100:10
11:1865:18
11:4388:8
11:50 65:10,12
95:8
12 38:25 39:3
49:3 50:3
12-year49:3,13
49:19,23
131:20 2:1 10:7
38:14 73:8
100:23 101:15
102:3 104:22
14 10:7 26:5,15
14004:18 104:6
1538:25 39:3
96:22
1611:11 17:12
17:13 63:4
1726:15
1813:19,22 26:9
66:1,7 83:4
86:1 97:6
18205 3:23
19 104 : 4
U.S. Legal Support

(561) 835-0220
Page 11
19th 100:19
1985 5:11
2 3:10,22
20 96:22
200 4:3
2000 87:20
2001 65:23 66:5
71:6,14 72:1
72:6 75:25
2002 26:5,9,14
55:12,18 71:6
71:14 72:1,6
75:25
2003 52:18 55:25
69:12 74:14
74:19
2004 66:13,20
67:24 68:4,13
73:4,12 81:24
2005 2:12 26:14
45:13,14
55:12,19,25
69:13,20 70:7
70:13 74:15
74:20,23 75:4
88:16
2006 65:23 66:5
2010 1:20 2:1
100:19 101:7
102:3,20
103:22 104:4
2011 100:23
101:15 104:22
MI:12 5:11
45:13,14
22 52:18
2218 3:23
25 4:9
250 104:7
2925 4 : 3
34:8
300 104:2
301 6:16,24
62:19,25
303 4:13
305 3:24
33130 4:9
33160 3:24
33301 3:19
33401 4:13,18
104:3,7
33410 4:4
3513 6:12 82:11
89:6,22 90:2
90:10 96:22
4:00 46:9,24
47:5
400 4 :13
425 3:18
444 3:5 104:2
45 2:12
463-4346 4:10
52:5 81:24
507:5 38:24
41:24
515-1400 4:4
524-2820 3:19
5614:4,14,19

561) (335-0220
104:3
65 2:6
659-8300 4:19
66th 6:16,24
62:19,25
77 2:7
8 3:22 63:3
8-D 6:25
8/2145:13
800.04 37:18
812:8
842-28204:14
98 4:8
931-2200 3 : 2 4
954 3:19 4:10
982:5
U.S. Legal Support
(561) 835-0220
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 David Stern [friend] Epstein's partner in various businesses including Asia Gateway Ltd. 
                                                        Aleksandra Eriksson [girls] (???) 
 Daniel Siad [modeling] model scout funded by Epstein to recruit in eastern Europe [wiki] 
                                               Anastasiya Siroochenko [russian girl] girl 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00507334 (Jmail)
 [misc] Skype log of conversation with Aleksandra Eriksson, Anastasiya Siroochenko, Catherine, Daniel Siad, David Stern, Emad Hanna, Jade Huang, Nadia
Marcinko, sexysearch2010, sophiembh
(inferred timestamp: 2010-05-30 18:29:25)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
• NYC024328.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024328.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
• Calendar Items
• Calls
• Contacts
• Messages
• Top Contacts
• User Accounts
Case
Data:
Messages
(1-100 of
14749)
Skype
2010-02-17 22:01:53 (UTC) [1]
Sender: ( sophiembli. m
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), ( sophiembh )
<voicemail alt=""><message length="33"></message></voicemail>
Skype
2010-02-18 16:14:53 (UTC) [1]
Sender: alert_source:skypepaid ( alert_source:skypepaid )
Participants: alert_source:skypepaid ( alert_source:skypepaid ), Self (jeevacation )
<alert><partner><name>skypepaid</name><id>2</id>
<event>dc:ui/alerts/partners/2/2</event>chistory>dc:ui/alerts/partners/2/3</history>
<header>dc:ui/alerts/partners/2/5</header>clogo>x<llogo><Jpartner>
<expiry> 1267719271</expiry><message>
<header_caption>Notification<Jheader caption>cheader_title>Password successfully
changed<theader_title>cheader_subject></header subject/
<header_cancel>Closeclheader_cancel><header later><Jheader later><content>Your
new Skype password has been set.<br/><br/>You can now <a
href=&quot;httpfe://track.skype/e/click?
m=713 1000001423767424&amp;go=myaccount&amp;x=cm_minc%3DT 73-_-A-
-180210-_-myaccount&quot;>access your Account</a>, view your call history or change
your account settings. </content><footer>If you have any problems, visit our <a
href=&quot;http://track.skype.com/e/click?
m=7131000001423767424&amp;go=help&amp;x=cm_mmc%3DT_73-_-A-_-180210-_-
help&quot>help section</a>.</footer><button_caption><Jbutton_caption><button_uri>
</button_uri><type>I</type><window_size>1<Jwindow_size><Jmessage></alert>
Skype
2010-02-18 23:31:16 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Nadia (
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Nadia ( )
Skype
2010-02-18 23:3anC) [1]
Sender: Nadia ( )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Nadia (
ball and i are ready in the kitchen
Skype
[1] 2010-02-18 23:31:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Nadia (
)
)
Skype
2010-04-16 17:51:44 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Daniel Siad ( fashionhdtv )
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), Daniel Siad ( fashionhdtv ),
fashionhdtv added jeevacation to this conversation
Skype
[1] 2010-04-20 02:08:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), Daniel Siad ( fashionhdtv ),
Skype
[1] 2010-04-29 21:47:58 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: sexysearch2010 ( sexysearch2010 ), Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
2010-04-30 11:19:21 (UTalin
Sender: Anastasiya Siro ( )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
good morning ! <ss type="smile">:)<Jss>
Skype
[1] 2010-04-30 11:19:28 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
Skype
[1] 2010-04-30 11:19:40 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
good morning
Skype
[1] 2010-04-30 11:48:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: (
Skype
[1] 2010-04-30 11:48:16 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: (
), Self (jeevacation )
), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2010-04-30 11:55:43 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2010-04-30 11:55:52 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
2010-04-30 13:12:42 (UTC
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
after milano???
Skype
2010-04-30 13:12:56 UTC) 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
taht is beg of june
Skype
[1] 2010-04-30 13:13:09 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
where are yiou
when?
okl
Skype
2010-04-30 13:13:18 UTC) 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
ok!!
Skype
2010-04-30 13:13:32 UTC) 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
you are still in palm beach??
Skype
2010-04-30 13:13:39 UTC) 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self( jeevaeation )
everything ok?
Skype
[1] 2010-04-30 13:13:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Yes
Skype
2010-04-30 13:13:44 (UTC) 111
Sender: IMErS
Participants:
how is nadia?
Skype
[1] 2010-04-30 13:13:53 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: (
), Self (jeevacation )
), Self (jeevacation )
grea
Skype
[1] 2010-05-21 02:44:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-21 02:46:49 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
wehre are you?
Skype
2010-05-21 03:00:50 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
home
Skype
2010-05-21 03:01:12 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
r u thr?
Skype
2010-05-21 03:04:18 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
r u still in miami or did u leave to go somewhere else
Skype
2010-05-23 20:01:46 (UTC) llli
Sender: Anastasiya Siro ( )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
Skype
2010-05-23 20:01:53 (UTC) [l]
Sender: Anastasiya Siro ( )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
<a
href="http://wvvw.dramadesk.cotn/press098.html">http://wvvw.dramadesk.com/press098.htmicia>
Skype
[1] 2010-05-23 20:01:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
Skype
[1] 2010-05-23 22:25:34 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
Skype
[1] 2010-05-23 22:25:34 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
are you there
Skype
[1] 2010-05-23 22:25:38 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
Skype
2010-05-24 02:41:00 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Skype
2010-05-24 02:41:04 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
hi
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 02:41:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Skype
2010-05-24 05:28:05 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Skype
2010-05-24 05:28:13 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
how come u just disappeared
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 05:28:19 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 09:15:24 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
traveled
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 09:15:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 09:15:43 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 09:39:47 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
no skype
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 09:49:14 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
i will gladly send you tickets to miami today or tomorrow if you can stay with your friend.
We can then see if pb works at the last moment.
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 09:50:52 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 09:51:27 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
do you want to come to pb, wed ? or fri?
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 09:51:33 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
Skype
2010-05-24 17:01:26 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
write to me instead this internet is slow
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 17:02:26 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
have you spoken to your friend? if you would like , i will organize you a ticket to miami,
then according to my plans you could comeand visit if i m in pb
Skype
2010-05-24 17:03:23 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
are you going to be going to new york at all
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 17:03:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
not this week maybe next for one day
Skype
2010-05-24 17:04:31 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
ok
Skype
2010-05-24 17:05:57 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
i dont really enjoy staying in miami beach so i would only come to see u but if id have to
say most of the time in miami maybe we should pick another better time
Skype
2010-05-24 17:06:05 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
i mean i dont know how busy you are
Skype
2010-05-24 17:06:13 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
whatever you think is onvinient
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 17:06:43 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
ok , lets wait until later today
Skype
2010-05-24 17:06:49 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
ok
Skype
2010-05-24 17:36:26 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Emad Hanna ( ehanna1958)
Participants: Emad Hanna ( ehanna1958), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 17:36:48 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Emad Hanna ( ehanna1958), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 20:22:26 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 20:22:26 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
when would you want to come. wed?
Skype
[1] 2010-05-24 20:22:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Skype
2010-05-24 23:51:25 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
no, tomorrow, because id only be able to stay til thursday couse her and her boyfriend and
leaving on thursday and she is not in her apartment any more i think she rent it out or
something
Skype
2010-05-25 00:38:11 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
let me know what you think
Skype
2010-05-25 00:39:12 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
call my cell please
Skype
[1] 2010-05-25 02:07:03 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
i tried to call.
Skype
2010-05-25 02:09:33 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
hey
Skype
2010-05-25 02:09:36 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
r u there
Skype
[1] 2010-05-25 02:09:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Yes
Skype
[1] 2010-05-25 02:09:52 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
should i try the cell again
Skype
2010-05-25 02:09:53 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraerilcsson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
sorry i left phone in car and walked back to get it and s aw missed call
Skype
[1] 2010-05-25 02:12:40 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
my security detail requires your passport number and jennifers full name.
Skype
2010-05-25 02:13:07 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
what do you mean
Skype
2010-05-25 02:13:25 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
jennifer bowman
Skype
[1] 2010-05-25 02:13:42 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
i need your passport details . number birthdate , etxx
Skype
2010-05-25 02:14:30 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
aleksandra erikssonl. passport nr
Skype
[1] 2010-05-25 02:17:38 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
ok
Skype
2010-05-25 02:32:36 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
will someone pick me up from the airport
Skype
2010-05-25 02:32:51 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
and should i come to u tomorrow or on wednesday
Skype
[1] 2010-05-25 02:33:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
yes„ the secretarys will send you tomorrow.
Skype
2010-05-25 02:36:02 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Aleksandra Eriksson ( aleksandraeriksson )
ok
Skype
2010-05-27 11:56:02 C 1
Sender: Catherine (
Participants: Catherine ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
2010-05-27 12:07:16 UTC 1
Sender: Catherine (
Participants: Catherine ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Ohh...I've missed your call <ss type="sad">:(c/ss> now I'm with my little nephew i will
call you back in an hour or write a letter later <ss type="heart">(h)</ss>
Skype
[1] 2010-05-27 12:07:28 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation
Participants: Catherine ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-27 12:12:36 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation
Participants: Catherine ( ), Self (jeevacation )
ok
Skype
2010-05-28 16:05:47 =U 1.
Sender: David Stem ( )
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), David Stem (
Skype
2010-05-28 16:23:14 =U 1.
Sender: David Stem ( )
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), David Stem (
sent F the message
Skype
[1] 2010-05-28 16:23:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), David Stem ( )
Skype
2010-05-28 16:23:49
Sender: David Stem ( )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), David Stem (
will let you know once i hear back from her
Skype
2010-05-28 16:24:01 UT( C)[1]
Sender: David Stem ( )
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), David Stem (
I will be back in London after the weekend
)
)
Skype
2010-05-29 11:20:33 C 1
Sender: (
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), )
Skype
2010-05-29 11:20:50U _C 1
Sender: (
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), )
are you there?
Skype
[1] 2010-05-29 11:20:55 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), )
Skype
2010-05-29 11:21:05 C 1
Sender: (
Participants: Self (jeevacation ), (
can i call now?
Skype
2010-05-29 17:27:49 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Jade HUANG (jadehjhuang )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Jade HUANG ( jadehjhuang )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-29 17:27:59 (UTC)
)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Jade HUANG (jadehjhuang )
Skype
[1] 2010-05-30 18:29:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
Skype
[1] 2010-05-30 18:31:06 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Self ( jeevacation ), Anastasiya Siro (
I told you , when you were in palm beach that the only thing i asked was that you be 100%
truthful with me, you said no problem.. I said that if you wanted to keep something private
, of course just tell me its private„ but don't bullshit me. i have no patience or tolerance . I
wish you good luck
Notes
[1] Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
[1] Source File /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Case Data: Messages (Index) Case Data: Messages (101-200 of 14749)
EFTA00728793 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jane Doe #2 v. Jeffrey Epstein: harassment by private investigators
╔══════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Robert Couturier [employee] interior designer 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00108853 (Jmail)
 FBI report about Epstein investigation
(inferred date: 2010-07-29)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Title: (U//FOLIO) EC REQUESTING NEW YORK DIVISION Date: 09/01/2010
TO CONDUCT INTERVIEW
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 72-MM-113327 (U) RODRIGUEZ, ALFREDO - SEE SUB
Details:
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 09/02/2010
To: New York Attn: C-20
SSA
SA
From: Miami
PB-2/PBCRA
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafted By: J:cjp
Case ID #: 72-MM-113327 (Pending)
Title: ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ;
OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE
Synopsis: EC requesting New York Division to conduct interview
of ROBERT COUTURIER
Title: (U//FOLIO) EC REQUESTING NEW YORK DIVISION TO CONDUCT INTERVIEW
Re: 72-MM-113327, 09/01/2010
Details:
In October 2009, Miami Division opened an obstruction
of justice case against ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ. RODRIGUEZ was the
previous house manager and butler to Palm Beach County resident
JEFFREY EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN was the subject of child prostitution,
31E matter, worked by Miami Division beginning in 2006.
Investigation of EPSTEIN revealed that he brought underage girls
to his home to perform massages and paid them to engage in sex
acts with himself and one another. The U.S. Attorney's Office
entered into a non-prosecution agreement with EPSTEIN where
EPSTEIN pled guilty tO state offenses in Florida state court.
EPSTEIN was sentenced to a period of state prison followed by
community supervision as a registered sex offender. EPSTEIN
completed his community supervision in July 2010.
EPSTEIN's victims filed suit against EPSTEIN in state
and federal court seeking damages in civil litigation. During the
discovery process, RODRIGUEZ was deposed by attorney BRADLEY
EDWARDS who represented several of the victims. After his
deposition, RODRIGUEZ contacted EDWARDS and advised that he had
lists of additional victims that he had not previously disclosed
2
Title: (U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING NEW YORK DIVISION TO CONDUCT INTERVIEW
Re: 72-MM-113327, 09/01/2010
to law enforcement during the criminal investigation or after
being served with a subpoena in the civil case. RODRIGUEZ advised he
would
not turn the information over to the attorney but
instead wanted monetary compensation. In November 2009, RODRIGUEZ
attempted to sell the information to a UCE for $50,000.00, which
resulted in the above captioned case.
Approximately three weeks ago, information was provided
to Miami Division, PBCRA, that ROBERT COUTURIER, an interior
designer and architect based in New York, was hired by EPSTEIN
for remodeling and design services at EPSTEIN's residence located
in the Virgin Islands. COUTURIER reportedly designed a bedroom in
EPSTEIN's island residence with decor and furniture appropriate
for teenage girls, with pink furnishings and bunk beds. In
addition, COUTURIER reported seeing EPSTEIN in the company of
what appeared to be an underage girl. It is unclear whether the
underage girl with EPSTEIN was observed at the Virgin Island
residence or at EPSTEIN's Palm Beach County home. EPSTEIN and
COUTURIER may be currently involved in civil litigation against
one another for services COUTURIER provided.
It is requested that New York Division interview
3
Title: (U//FOLIO) EC REQUESTING NEW YORK DIVISION TO CONDUCT INTERVIEW
Re: 72-MM-113327, 09/01/2010
COUTURIER regarding work and services he performed for EPSTEIN
and COUTURIER's observation of potential underage girls in
EPSTEIN's company.
Descriptive Data:
Main Subject
Name -
Last: Couturier
First: Robert
Race: W
Sex: M
Address(es) -
House #: II
Street Name:
Street Suffix: II.
City: New York
State: New York
Postal Code:
Country: USA
Phone #: (business)
Phone #: (cellular)
4
Title: (U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING NEW YORK DIVISION TO CONDUCT INTERVIEW
Re: 72-MM -113327, 09/01/2010
LEAD(s) :
Set Lead 1: (Action)
NEW YORK
AT NEW YORK, NEW YORK
Request for New York Division to interview ROBERT
COUTURIER.
* *
.•
5
EFTA00108858 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2010-07-29)
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 09/02/2010
To:New York Attn: C-20
SSA
SA
From: Miami
PB-2/PBCRA
Contact:
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 72-MM-113327 (Pending)
Title:
OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE
Synopsis: EC requesting New York Division to conduct interview of
Details:
In October 2009, Miami Division opened an obstruction of
justice case against was the previous
house manager and butler to Palm Beach County resident JEFFREY
EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN was the subject of child prostitution, 31E matter,
worked by Miami Division beginning in 2006. Investigation of EPSTEIN
revealed that he brought underage girls to his home to perform
massages and paid them to engage in sex acts with himself and one
another. The U.S. Attorney's Office entered into a non-prosecution
agreement with EPSTEIN where EPSTEIN pled guilty tO state offenses in
Florida state court. EPSTEIN was sentenced to a period of state prison
followed by community supervision as a registered sex offender.
EPSTEIN completed his community supervision in July 2010.
EPSTEIN's victims filed suit against EPSTEIN in state and
federal court seeking damages in civil litigation. During the
discovery process, was deposed by attorney
who represented several of the victims. After his deposition,
contacted and advised that he had lists of
additional victims that he had not previously disclosed to law
enforcement during the criminal investigation or after being served
with a subpoena in the civil case. advised he would not turn
the information over to the attorney but instead wanted monetary
compensation. In November 2009, attempted to sell the
information to a UCE for $50,000.00, which resulted in the above
captioned case.
Approximately three weeks ago, information was provided to
Miami Division, PBCRA, that
architect based in New York, was hired by EPSTEIN for remodeling and
design services at EPSTEIN's residence located in the Virgin Islands.
COUTURIER reportedly designed a bedroom in EPSTEIN's island residence
with decor and furniture appropriate for teenage girls, with pink
furnishings and bunk beds. In addition, COUTURIER reported seeing
EPSTEIN in the company of what appeared to be an underage girl. It is
unclear whether the underage girl with EPSTEIN was observed at the
Virgin Island residence or at EPSTEIN's Palm Beach County home.
EPSTEIN and COUTURIER may be currently involved in civil litigation
against one another for services COUTURIER provided.
, an interior designer and
It is requested that New York Division interview COUTURIER
regarding work and services he performed for EPSTEIN and COUTURIER's
observation of potential underage girls in EPSTEIN's company.
Descriptive Data:
Main Subject
Name -
Last: Couturier
First: Robert
Race: W
Sex: M
Address(es) -
House #: II
Street Name:
Street Suffix: St.
City: New York
State: New York
Postal Code: 10012
Country: USA
Phone #: (business)
Phone #: (cellular)
LEAD(s) :
Set Lead 1: (Action)
NEW YORK
AT NEW YORK, NEW YORK
Request for New York Division to interview
• •
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                     Island Global Yachting [business] Andrew Farkas organization 
             James P. McGee [business] Newgrange plans for USVI political control 
            Newgrange [business] planned Epstein's Virgin Islands media influence 
 Yacht Haven Grande [real estate] marina owned by Epstein and Andrew Farkas (???) 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00586992 (Jmail)
 [misc] Newgrange contract with Island Global Yachting
(approximate date: 2010-08-01)
Newgrange
CONSULTING • SOFTMARE • COMMUNICATIONS

AGREEMENT
This letter of agreement between Island Global Yachting, an entity organized in the U.S.
Virgin Islands with a regular place of business located at XYX, hereinafter referred to as the
"CONTRACTOR" and the Newgrange Consulting Group LLC, an incorporated business
entity organized under the laws of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts with a regular place
of business located at 43 Charles Street, Suite 3, Boston, MA 02114, hereinafter referred to
as the "CONSULTANT", do hereby agree as follows:

1. CONSULTANT will provide marketing, public relations, media relations, public
affairs and strategic consulting services for the CONTRACTOR.

Specifically, CONSULTANT shall be responsible for providing the following services on
behalf of CONTRACTOR:

Task 1— Overall public relations planning and marketing counsel for Island Global
Yachting pertaining to the Yacht Haven Grande property;

Task 2 — Assist CONTRACTOR with local media relations and overall public
relations and marketing strategies in order to increase customer traffic to Yacht
Haven Grande;

Task 3 — Provide support of governmental and public affairs activities in support of
the Yacht Haven Grande property;

Task 4 — Work with CONTRACTOR to develop a marketing plan to raise awareness
of CONTRACTOR'S goals and objectives in the media and with other stakeholders.

2. CONSULTANT shall not be required to perform services on an hourly basis.
Delivery of services shall be the sole criteria for CONSULTANT'S responsibilities
under Paragraph 1.

3. CONTRACTOR agrees to pay the following sums for the aforementioned services
enumerated in Paragraph 1:

a. CONTRACTOR shall pay the CONSULTANT for marketing, public
relations, media relations, government relations and strategic consulting
services;

b. The payment for services referred to in Paragraph 3a will be in the form of a
monthly payment as follows:
The CONTRACTOR shall pay the CONSULTANT the sum of $15,000 on the
fifteenth of each month beginning August 15, 2010.
Newgrange Consulting Group • N2 Innovations • Newgrange Strategies
43 Charles Street Suite 3 • Boston, MA 02114 • Phone: (617) 227.8080 • Fax: (617) 227-8090
•

d. CONTRACTOR shall reimburse CONSULTANT for all authorized expenses
incurred during this contract including travel, printing, production, etc.

4. CONSULTANT and CONTRACTOR shall have the right to terminate this
Agreement upon thirty (30) days written notice.

5. Tax and workers compensation liability: CONSULTANT agrees to hold
CONTRACTOR harmless from any and all liability for withholding state or federal
income, federal social security or Medicare tax, federal or state industrial accident
contributions, and any other employer's tax liability now or subsequently imposed on
CONTRACTOR, as may involve CONSULTANT'S business relationship with
CONTRACTOR.

6. Waiver of Claims: CONSULTANT waives all claims against CONTRACTOR, which
CONSULTANT may now have or may subsequently acquire for unemployment
compensation under the laws of the United States or the Commonwealth of
Massachusetts.

7. Relationship of the parties. The parties intend that an independent contractor -
employer relationship be created by this contract. The conduct and control of the
work will lie solely with the CONSULTANT; however, the CONSULTANT shall
perform such work in accordance with currently prevailing standards in the
community for similar work.
Signed this day of August 2010:
Consultant, Principal
James P. McGee
Newgrange Consulting Group
Signed this day of August 2010:
Contractor, Principal
Andrew Farkas
Island Global Yachting
EFTA00108851 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from Steven Hoffenberg re: Epstein and the murder of Arthur Shapiro
(date: 2010-09-02)
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 09/02/2010
To: Newark Attn: Trenton RA
From: Miami
PB-2/PBCRA
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 72-MM-113327 (Pending)
Title: ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ;
OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE
Synopsis: EC requesting Trenton RA to conduct interview of federal
inmate, , regarding captioned investigation.
Details: In October 2009, Miami Division opened an obstruction of
justice case against ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ. RODRIGUEZ was the previous
house manager and butler to Palm Beach County resident JEFFREY
EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN was the subject of child prostitution, 31E matter,
worked by Miami Division beginning in 2006. Investigation of EPSTEIN
revealed that he brought underage girls to his home to perform
massages and paid them to engage in sex acts with himself and one
another. The U.S. Attorney's Office entered into a non-prosecution
agreement where EPSTEIN pled guilty to lesser state offenses in
Florida state court. EPSTEIN was sentenced to a period of state prison
followed by community supervision as a registered sex offender.
EPSTEIN's victims filed suit against EPSTEIN in state and
federal court seeking damages in civil litigation. During the
discovery process, RODRIGUEZ was deposed by attorney
who represented several of the victims. After his deposition,
RODRIGUEZ contacted and advised that he had lists of
additional victims that he had not previously disclosed to law
enforcement during the criminal investigation or after being served
with a subpoena in the civil case. RODRIGUEZ advised he would not turn
the information over to the attorney but instead wanted monetary
compensation. In November 2009, RODRIGUEZ attempted to sell the information to a
UCE for $50,000.00, which resulted in the above
captioned case.
Also during the civil litigation, ' law firm
contacted as a potential plaintiff's witness against
EPSTEIN. is a federal inmate at Fort Dix Federal
Correctional Institution (FCI), inmate number 35601-054.
was a former business associate or acquaintance of EPSTEIN.
is serving a 20-year sentence for his role in a Ponzi scheme and
securities fraud that was worked by the New York field office, 196C-
NY-235483. Through correspondence, advised ' firm
that he had information regarding JEFFREY EPSTEIN being involved in
the murder of a Columbus, Ohio attorney named ARTHUR L. SHAPIRO.
SHAPIRO was killed on March 6, 1985 in the Columbus area. The case
remains unsolved. A review of ACS does not reflect offered
this information as a proffer during the 196C matter. It should be
noted that appears to have a history of mental illness.
Since his incarceration, he has filed civil rights complaints
regarding the facilities he has been assigned to.
It is requested that Trenton RA interview for
information regarding JEFFREY EPSTEIN and his involvement or knowledge
of the murder of SHAPIRO.
Descriptive Data:
Reference
Name -
Last:
First:
Race:
Sex:
Address(es) -
House 4: ■
LEAD(s) :
Set Lead 1: (Action)
NEWARK
AT TRENTON, NJ
To interview federal inmate,
35601-054, regarding the murder of ARTHUR SHAPIRO.
* *
, BOP number
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                          Tom Barrack [trump] long time friend of Trump, US ambassador to Turkey 
                     Daniel Kahneman [academia] Nobel economic sciences laureate and cognitivie psychologist (?) 
                                                                 Michael Ovitz [arts] former president of Disney 
                                            Tommy Mottolla [arts] former CEO of Sony, ex-husband of Mariah Carey 
                                                                    Reid Weingarten [lawyer] Steptoe LLP partner 
                                                                       Bernard Kruger [medical] Epstein's doctor 
 Boris Nikolic [tech] biotech partner of Bill Gates in bgC3 / Bill Gates Ventures, Epstein estate executor [wsj] 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00298379 (Jmail)
 [misc] RSVP list for Yom Kippur dinner
(date: 2010-09-18)
Dinner
September 18th
*Eva and Glen Dubin Yes-5 Total Guests (2 Adults, 3 Kids)
Yes-Note sent Sept. 7
*Alan Dershowitz + 1 Yes-2 Total Adults (wife)
*Peggy Siegel Yes-Note sent Sept. 7
"Jonathon Farkas Yes-2 Total Adults (wife)

Dr. Jarecki "he thinks so" -Note sent Sept. 7
"Dr. Richard Axel Yes (wife, Cori) -2 Total Adults
*Leon Black Yes- 2 Total Adults (wife)
"Mort Zuckerman Yes-1 Adult (maybe 1 child) He will arrive late
"David Mitchell Yes-4 Total (2 Adults, 2 Kids)
"Jes and Debra Staley Yes-2 Total Adults (Debra -wife)
Yes-5 Total (2 adults, 3 Kids)
"Reid Weingarten Yes-2 Total Adults
"Marvin/Gloria Minsky Yes-2 Total Adults
"Ron & Elka Altbach Yes 1 Total Adult (Ron ONLY, Elka not in town)
"Steve Hanson & Family Yes 4 Total (2 Adults, 2 Kids)
*Joel Paschow Yes-2 Adults
lean Luc Brunel Yes-Note sent Sept. 7
*Rony &Catherine Shimony Yes-1 Adult (Rony only)
*Ghislaine Yes-2 Adults
"John Brockman Yes (2 Adults- Andrian Kreye is his guest)
Tommy Mottola Yes (2 Adults)
Story Yes (1 Adult)
Danny Kahneman & Anne Treisman Yes (2 Adults)
Reid Weingarten
Dr. Woody Merrill
Dr. Bernard Kruger
Vera Wang
Benny Shabtai
Lisa and Donald JacksonYes (2 Adults)
Mark Packer Maybe
Maybe
Yes (2 Adults)
Yes (2 Adults)
YES (2 Adults, 2 Kids)
Yes (2 Adults)
Katie Couric
Gerald Goldsmith
Charlie Rose
Frederic Fekkai
Allen Grubman
Henry Rosovsky
Skip Stein
Nathan Myhrvold
Boris Nikolic
Peter Mandelson
Andrew Farkas
Joe Pagano
Jay Lefkowitz
Sen. George Mitchell
Michael Ovitz
Tom Barrack
Tom Pritzker No-China w/ Hyatt BOD
Michael Wolf??(maybe) DID NOT INVITE
Email sent Sept. 2, Note sent Sept. 7
No
No
No
No
No
No
No (will be in LA, if plans change he will come!)
No (Alas, I won't be able to make it)
No (he will be in China)
No (he will be flying home from China)
No
No
No- shofar blower for synagogue
No
No
No
Wanted to touch base to let you know the Yom Kippur Breakfast Jeffrey will be hosting on Saturday
Sept. 181° will begin at 7pm at his home. As a reminder, he lives at 9 East 71.1, Street between 5th and
Madison. Please let me know how many guests will be in your party.
Please 6e reminded
Jeffrey Epstein Cooks forward to seeing you tomorrow evening at 7: 0 Op nt
'Yom Kippur Breaking of the East Dinner
9 East 71st Street (between 5th and Wadison)
Je said if senator Mitchell confirms, then invite Larry Summers and Ehud Barak and tell them both that
senator Mitchell will be coming.
I want to make sure you know this would be a Yom Kippur break-fast dinner and Jeffrey hopes that if his
guest can't make the dinner that they could stop by for desert. It's a rare Yom Kippur to coincide with a
Saturday!
Hello Frederic. Jeffrey Epstein would like to hold a Yom Kippur break-fast at his home in NY on
Saturday Sept. 18th. He understands this is a very special day and hopes you could attend the
dinner...however, if you could not make dinner, possibly you could join for dessert. This is a very
unusual Yom Kippur to coincide with a Saturday!
Please let me know if you would be able to attend.
Thank you,
Assistant to Jeffrey Epstein
From Jay Leflcowitz: Thanks. I would love to attend. But I believe we will be in westhampton beach for
yom kippur. I am the shofar blower for the synagogue there, so I don't expect to be in the city.
Otherwise, it would have been great fun to join.
From Allen Grubman: Mi The Grubman's have an extremely large family and do a large break-fast
every year at home. Thank you so much for this very kind invitation. Regretfully, we have to decline.
Kindly,Merrie Assistant to The Grubman's
John Brockman: Called to say he hates Yom Kippur and tries to be out of New York on this date. He
suggested doing a party on Sunday Sept. 150 ...he thinks you will have a better showing. He is in Napa
now, back on Monday. He said he will give you a call.
Melanie from Leon Black's Office: they usually go to Ronnie Heyman' s to break fast, but
I will ask Leo
Ghislaine: Grr - I'll be in Europe - I would have Loved too though
Thanks
Mort Zuckerman: Yes It looks good Thanks Mz
Tom Pritzker: In China w Hyatt BOD until Sept 19.
: Of course

Dr. Jarecki: I think so
Dr. Axel: Richard would very much like to attend dinner on Saturday, September 18th. I have put the
date in his calendar. Cori will come as well.
╔═══════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                Len Blavatnik [russia] oligarch 
 Stephen Schwarzman [finance] CEO of Blackstone 
        Wes Clark [government] military general 
   David Gergen [lawyer] Harvard Kennedy School 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00298515 (Jmail)
 [misc] guest list for a get together with Ehud Barak
(date: 2010-09-21)
EHUD BARAK
Tuesday, September 21

Jeffrey Epstein is having Ehud Barak, the Israeli Defense Minister, over to his house on Tues night the
21st. very private , no agenda. He thought you might like to join in, IF you want to speak directly to
Jeffrey I can have him call you, if you give me a time.
Jeffrey lives at 9 East 71s, Street between Soi and Madison...timing of dinner is in discussion.
Please let me know if you would be available.
Thank you,
Assistant to Jeffrey Epstein

Tom Barrack             Spoke & emailed             No
Arthur Saltzburger      Spoke & emailed             No
Steve Schwarzman        Spoke & Emailed 9-16        No
David Gergen            LM & Emailed 9-16           No - very disappointed
Len Blavatnik           Emailed 9-16                No
Jes Staley              Emailed 9-16                Office requested time of party
Tom Pritzker            Spoke & Emailed 9-16        No
Charlie Rose            Spoke & Emailed 9-16        No
Larry Summers           Emailed 9-16                Yes-maybe by 8pm or so
Mayor Michael Bloomberg Emailed Patty 9-18
Ron Perelman            Spoke to assistant & emailed No-Ron will be out of town
General Wes Clark       Spoke to him                Maybe (depends if party runs late)
Walter Isaacson         Spoke & Emailed             No-he will be on a plane to Chicago
Lloyd Blankfein         Spoke & Emailed             Probably No
EFTA00108872 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about Steven Hoffenberg info request
(date: 2010-10-25)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Title: (U//FOUO) REQUESTIN INFO RE:STEVEN Date: 10/25/2010
HOFFENBERG AND BERRY LESTER KESSLER
Drafted By: Missing
Case ID #: -2-MM-113327 (U) RODRIGUEZ, ALFREDO - SEE SUB
Details:
72-MM-113327
October 26, 2010
Attention: Bureau of Prisons
Dear Office of General Counsel:
Pursuant to an ongoing investigation, FBI Miami is
requesting information regarding current or former BOP inmates.
FBI Miami is requesting all information including the date in
custody, all facilities where the inmates were assigned and dates
in such facilities, projected date of release, and date of death,
if applicable, regarding the following two (2) inmates;

1. BOP number 35601-054, white male
2. BERRY LESTER KESSLER, BOP number 61264-061, male,
believed to be deceased.
Questions regarding this request can be addressed to SA
. Your assistance with this matter is
Title: (U//FOLIO) REQUESTIN INFO RE:STEVEN HOFFENBERG AND BERRY LESTER
KESSLER
Re: 72-MM-113327, 10/25/2010
greatly appreciated.
Special Agent in Charge
By: Supervisory Special Agent
.•
2
EFTA00206732 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jane Doe v. Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein: statement of facts
╔═════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Brice Gordon [employee] property manager 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01248259 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Robert Couturier
(date: 2010-11-16)
https://Sentinclibinet.thi/appe"ca, memt/indcx-scrialsprcvicw.html?d...
Filing and Security I V
Pnmary Case: 12 UM 713327
Serial Number: 53
Serialized: 11/16/2010
Category: Full Investigation
Initiated: 10/28/2009
Details
Case 710e: (U) ROD91GUEZ,
ALFRED - SEE SUB
Serial I: 53 Type: F0302
From: To: MIAM,
Document Title: ROBERT COUTURIER
Approval Date: 11/16/2010
Classification: SN
Contents
11/17/2010
ROBERT COUTURIER, business address New
York. NY 1 1 i ss phone nd cellular pho e
number was Interviewed at his design studio at
above listed location. After being advised of the identity of the
interviewing agent, and the nature of the interview. COUTURIER
provided the following information:
COUTURIER first met JEFFREY EPSTEIN sometime between
1985-1988 and he was introduced to EPSTEIN by YSABEL GOL SMITH. At
that time, s looking for a designer to decorate his pa
located at  Street, Manhattan, NY. COUTURIER was
interviewed for the job but EPSTEIN did not hire him on that
occasion.
COUTURIER and EPSTEIN travel in the same social circles
and there is a lot of gossip surrounding EPSTEIN. The talk is
mostly about how much he enjoys the company of young girls a
women. COUTURIER stated that EPSTEIN always made him feel
uncomfortable and strange when he was around him so COUTU ER was
friendly and courteous to him but does not consider EPSTEIN his
1/17/20192:27 PM
350(.183-058
Paget of 7
Scrials https://scintinelfbinet.fbitappsi gmtfindex-serialspreview.htmrd...
friend.
There is no doubt that EPSTEIN is very intelligent and
can carry a conversation about any subject but there is something
about him that is weird and off.putting He is incredibly wealthy
and COUTURIER believes that most people around him do not talk too
much about him because that type of wealth usually buys power.
Although people might have information about EPSTEIN they might be
reluctant to talk; it is easier to excuse his bad behavior or turn
a blind eye to it.
COUTURIER stated that about six or seven months ago a
woman by the name of MM, who is EPSTEIN's assistant.
called him and asked if he would consider taking on the challenge
of decorating EPSTEIN's place in Manhattan and if he would also
consider decorating his place in the US Virgin Islands (USVI)
COUTURIER advised these are just two of the homes he currently owns
but EPSTEIN also has an apartment in Paris. France and a huge ranch
somewhere in the Midwest in the U.S.
COUTURIER stated that by this time, he had heard of
EPSTEIN's incarceration and thought that EPSTEIN had "paid his debt
to society' and maybe things had changed with him so he went into
the meeting trying to be objective. EPSTEIN also stated that to be
honest. he would be making a lot of money if he took the project.
The first meeting took place sometime in Apnl or May
2010 and EPSTEIN's assistant, showed him the overall
plans of the USVI house. Although EPSTEIN was supposed to attend
the meeting he could not make it so handled it
air later, EPSTEIN. and his other assistant
LAST NAME UNKNOWN (LNU) all flew from Palm Beach. FL to the
house on the USVI after the initial meeting.
Sometime in June 2010. COUTURIER and EPSTEIN plus his
assistants, flew to the USVI on EPSTEIN's private plane. They took
it from Palm Beach to the island and stayed there for a day and a
half. EPSTEIN was very excited and appeared to be like a kid with
a new toy. COUTURIER recalls that EPSTEIN kept the house very cold
and his bedroom was white but had no lights in the room. it was
dark and very austere. The focal point of the room was an enormous
bed.
EPSTEIN also showed him another room in which he wanted
to place four beds and wanted to have it decorated in a very
colorful palette for his girls EPSTEIN told COUTURIER him that he
does not have any friends and that he does not really like people.
EPSTEIN stated that he has girls coming to spend time with him in
the island. EPSTEIN then lamented that 'The girls* are only
interested in Facebook and MySpace and that he wanted the space in
this bedroom to be comfortable and have access to the Internet as
they were online so much COUTURIER did not ask how old these
girls were or anything about them. He did not ask him any personal
2 ofi5 1/172019 2:27 PM
3501.183-058
Page 2 of 7
Serials https://sentinel.thinet.fbiappsicastmgmUindez-serialspreview.html?d...
questions
COUTURIER stated that on the tight back he grew
increasingly uncomfortable. Although he did not see any of the
young girls that EPSTEIN was talking about he was not sure if he
could do this job for him. COUTURIER added that every time he met
with EPSTEIN he had his assistants there who are all very
attractive young women and others unknown to him but all appeared
to be over the age of 18.
EPSTEIN also showed COUTURIER his home on 71th street in
Manhattan. NY as he wanted him to decorate that place also.
COUTURIER showed him a massage room where he had photographs
("artistic wantons" according to COUTURIER) of young women in
the nude, ranging from age 15 through 20 all hanging from the walls
of this massage room. COUTURIER did not ask him any questions
about this room and moved on to the rest of the house.
COUTURIER then came back to New York and started out
drawing plans and although he did not have a contract, EPSTEIN did
give him a check for $50.000.00 as a deposit for his services.
COUTURIER stated that his plans went back and forth
between his offices and EPSTEIN's people but EPSTEIN never seemed
happy. COUTURIER sent some of his associates back to the USVI to
take measurements and adjust his plans and EPSTEIN was pleased in
some aspects but was still highly critical.
COUTURIER then deaded that this was not the right job
for him. COUTURIER stated that in the back of his mind. he wanted
to have "a way our should he decide that he could not work with
EPSTEIN which was why he did not have a formal contract signed
EPSTEIN was very diffiant to work with and COUTURIER found that
EPSTEIN had not changed his pattern of behavior obviously if he was
having the home in the USVI decorated for girls to stay with tern.
This did not sit well with COUTURIER. He then wrote EPSTEIN a note
apologizing for not being able to take on this job. COUTURIER
Stated that he could not just drop everything or any of his
projects whenever EPSTEIN wanted him at the site (USVI). EPSTEIN
was very persistent but COUTURIER was firm in his decision.
In July 2010. EPSTEIN tried to sue him for his deposit
and he has many attorneys at his disposal who are very aggressive
COUTURIER'S attomey stated that if they decided to litigate this
case, it was going to be a long process. COUTURIER decided to
settle and returned $15.000.00 to EPSTEIN to save himself the
hassle of litigation.
COUTURIER stated that EPSTEIN and were a couple but
had broken up At one point COUTURIER had spoken t.
about her breakup with EPSTEIN. She told him. "I have seen him do
homfic things" but d:d not elaborate. still his
assistant and they are on friendly terms COUTURIER stated he
believed that although very pretty, was now too old for
1/17/1019 2:27 PM
3501.183-058
Page 3 of 7
Serials hupsillscntinclAbinctibi apes ca mgmt/index-scrialsprevicwhtml?d...
EPSTEIN even though she is in her 30s.
COUTURIER stated there are people in New York who are
outraged about EPSTEIN's lenient sentence for his sex trafficking
charges. One person who has followed the story and written about
JEFFREY COUTURIER is CONCHITA SARNOFF, writer for 'The Beast'
online newspaper, phone number . AMY FIENNE-COLLINS
also wrote an article for *Vanity Fair on child prostitution but
the article met with much resistance.
COUTURIER concluded by saying that although this would
job would have generated a lot of income for his company, he simply
could not do it and although he tried to remain objective, his
conscience would not let him continue this project.
COUTURIER provided the following information regarding
JEFFREY EPSTEIN's contacts:
ASSISTANTS
=M (NY)
NU (NY)
Palm Beach)
KAREN LNU (USVI)
BRICE LNU USVI)
OTHER EMPLOYEES.
RICHARD BARNET (Butler in NY)
DARREN INDYKE (Attorney)
RICH KAHN
(Accountant)
COUTURIER also provided the following information for
JEFFREY EPSTEIN.
New York Residence, 9 East 71st Street
New York, NY
jeevacation@gmail.com
Palm Beach Residence: 358 El Bulb Way
Palm Beach, Ft. 33480
4015 1/17/2019 2:27 PM
3501.183-058
Page 4 of 7
Ser.:A https://sentinel.thinetibilappstav mgmVindex-serialspreview.html?d...
Indexing
No Entities to display.
Intelligence
Intelligence Value: No Intelligence Value
Potential IIR/SIR? No
Sentinel Tags: No Sentinel Tags Selected
Can you identify the No
source of this
information?
Routing
5 of 5
Drafted By:
Nro
v
1/17/2019 2:27 PM
3501.183-058
Page 5 of 7
Serials https://sentinelibinet.fbitappsk gmt/index-scrialspreview.html?d...
Filing and Security V
Primary Case: 72-MM-113327
Serial Number: 56
Serialized: 09/17/2010
Category: Full Investigation
Initiated: 10/28/2009
Case Title: (U) ROD - GUEZ,
ALFRE - SEE SUB
Details V
Serial
From:
Document Title: INTERVIEW RE.
Approval Date: 9/17/2010
Classification: SN
Contents 11/16/2010
56 Type: FD302
To: MIAMI
ANDREA COROOVES BUSTILLO. date of birth,
social security number. -
-Delray Beach, Florida. 33444, was intery d
at the Palm Beach County Resident Agency (PBCRA) After bei
advised of the identity of the interviewing agents and the purpose
of the interview. provided the following information.
attended High School during her
freshman and sophomore years of high school and was home s• ed
during her junior and senior years. Dunng her high school years.
resided with her family in her parents' home located
oxahatchee Florida =Ms home
phone number dunng that time period was . The ne
number, belonged to her friend.
MM was a friend ofIMMIN who was approximately on year
older than herillillits friend CHAZ Last Name Unknown (L U)
introduced and a TONY LNU. TONY LNU s described
as approximately 1819 years old at the time met him,
approximately 5'11T5' tall, tan with black hair which was longer
on top and no tattoos or pierongs. CHAZ LNU lived in Royal Pal
Beach near a fami store, andl and met TO LNU at
I of 2 1/172019 2:28 PM
3501.183-058
Page 6 of 7
Serials https://sentinelibinctibilapps/ mpnVindex-serialspreview.htmrd...
CHAZ LNU's home
TONY LNU approached and advised he knew a way
she could make money by giving a massage to an older man. TONY LNU
gave a phone number to call to set up the massage. At some
later time. called the number and set up the massage
appointment. MOM. drove ...Into a residence located on Palm
Beach. The first floor of the home was a living area and kitchen.
emained downstairs while went to the upstairs of
the residence. Approximately 3-4 girls were also present at the
home when- and were there. could not
provide a physical description of the girls. The upstairs was brown
or black in color and furnishings. and the area was a bedroom and
bathroom. A massage table was set up in the room, and towels were
laid out. An unidentified older man appeared in the room, wearing a
towel could not recall the name of the man. was
shown a photograph of JEFFREY EPSTEIN. identified EPSTEIN
as the man who appeared in the room wearing a towel. ESPTEIN laid
on the massage table on his stomach, an n:iegan the
massage. and EPSTEIN engaged in conversation, and when the _
discussion turned toffs age,I did not correct
EPSTEIN when it was mentioned that th e was 18 years old. After
approximately twe minutes. EPSTEIN rolled onto his back for a
chest massage. stated. 'it got weird,' when EPSTEIN began
masturbabng under the towel. backed away when EPSTEIN
attempted to touch her, and she replied she had a boyfriend. At
that point, the massage ended, and EPSTEIN paid $200.00.
two one hundred dollar bills that he retrieved from his wa
wetlI e wed EPSTEIN was mad or angry at how the massage
ended reported that she did not have contact with EPSTEIN
after the occasion.
Indexing I se
No Entities to display.
Intelligence
Intelligence Value: No Intelligence Value
Potential IIR/SIR? No
Sentinel Tags: No Sentinel Tags Selected
Can you identify the No
source of this
information?
Routing
Drafted By:
V
I/17/2019 2:28 PM
3501.183-058
Page 7 of 7
╔════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 CHS [government] Confidential Human Source, FBI speak for a tipster 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00005716 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2010-11-26)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Title: (U) DELTA SERIAL:
Drafted By: Missing
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY
Date: 11/25/2010
Details: UNCLASSIFIED FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION CHS REPORTING
DOCUMENT Form Classification: UNCLASSIFIED Source Id: Date:
2010-11-26 Case Agent Name: Field Office: Jacksonville
Squad: 10 Date of Contact: - - icipants/Witnesses: SA
Type of Contact: In Person Location Country: UNITED STATES City:
Jacksonville State: Florida Date of Report 2010-11-26 Substantive Case
File Number: 31E-MM-108062 Source Reporting: Source information received
to date on referred to Miami Division on 11/26/2010 re
31E-MM-108 D
.•
EFTA00005717 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2010-11-26)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Title: (U) DELTA SERIAL:
Drafted By: Missing
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY
Date: 11/25/2010
Details: UNCLASSIFIED FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION CHS REPORTING
DOCUMENT Form Classification: UNCLASSIFIED Source Id: Date:
2010-11-26 Case Agent Name: Field Office: Jacksonvill
Squad: 10 Date of Contact: 2010-11-12 Participants/Witnesses: SA
Type of Contact: In Person Location Country: UNITED STATES City:
Jacksonville State: Florida Date of Report 2010-11-26 Substantive Case
File Number: 31E-MM-108062 Source Reporting: Source information received
to date on referred to Miami Division re 31E-MM-108062 on
11/26/2010. UNCLASSIFIED
.•
EFTA00005705 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2010-12-10)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
CHS REPORTING DOCUMENT
Form Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Source Id:
Date: 2010-12-10
Case Agent Name:
Field Office: Jacksonville
Squad: 10
Date of Contact: 2010-12-10
Participants/Witnesses:
Type of Contact: In Person
Location
Country: UNITED STATES
City: Jacksonville
State: Florida
Date of Report 2010-12-10
Substantive Case File Number: 31E-MM-108062
Source Reporting:
Source provided current email address for as
Source also has received 8 current photographs of that were
forwarded by to ATP-Jacksonville recently.These will be forwarded to
MM under separate cover.
EFTA01248266 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Steven Hoffenberg
(date: 2010-12-10)
https://sentinel.fbinet.fbi/apps/casemgmt/index-ssdalspreyiew.html?d...
Filing and Security
Pnmary Case: 72 MM-113327           Case Title: RODRIGUEZ,
Serial Number: 50                               ALFREDO - SEE SUB
Serialized: 10/13/2010
Category Initiated: Full investigation 10/28/2009

Details
Serial N: 50 Type: F D302
From: NEWARK To: MIAMI
Document Title: STEVEN HOFFENBERG INTERVIEW 10/12/2010
Approval Date: 10/13/2010
Classification: U
Contents 10/13/2010

STEVEN HOFFENBERG, inmate number 35601-054, 5756
Handle & Pointwat Road. Fort Dix Federal Correctional
Instrtutan, Fort Dix, New Jersey was contacted on October 12
2010. After having been advised of the identities of the
interviewing agents. HOFFENBERG, provided the following
information.

HOFFENBERG stated he would not answer questions about
Jeffrey Epstein or the murder of Arthur L Shapiro without having a
court appointed attorney present during questioning. He added tha
he was willing to cooperate and answer questions once a court
appointed attorney was provided. He refused to answer any other
questions at this time and referred the interviewing agents to a
March 2003 Vanity Far article and a website, Tower Investors corn
He advised that he had pending civil matters against the Bureau of
Pnsons, amongst others. HOFFENBERG did not comment on his as
of knowledge. or when he became aware of information pertaining
Epstein or Shapiro. At this time the agents ended the interview.
I of 2 I 1/17/2019 2:27 PM
3501.183-059
Paget of 6
Serials Mtps://sentieeltbinetibi/appsicas
Indexing
No Entities to display
Intelligence
Intelligence Value: No IntelIrgence Value
Potential lIFOSIR? No
Sentinel Tags: No Sentinel Tags Selected
Can you identify the No
source of this
information?
Routing
Drafted By:
Approved By:
mgmt/index-scrialspreview.html?d...
V
1/172019 2:27 PM
3501.183-059
Page 2 of 6
hupsi/sentinel.fbinet.fbVapps/ gtmtrmdex-serialspreviesvAtml?d...
Filing and Security V
Primary Case: 72-MM-113327
Serial Number: 57
Serialized: 11:Y26,2010
Category: Full Investigation
Initiated: 10/28/2009
CaseMee: (U) ROD IGUEZ,
ALFRED -SEE SEE SUB
Details V
Serial #: 57 Type: INSERT
From: To: MIAMI
Document Title: INTERVIEW OF DET RE
Approval Date: 10/262010
Classification: SN
Contents 72.MM-113327
CJP:qp
The following investigation was conducted by Special Agent
on October 26. 2010
Detective Columbus Ohio Police
De rtment Columbus, Ohio, phone,
as interviewed telephonically regarding the homiade
investigation of Arthur Shapiro i advised that Shapiro
was a Columbus attorney who was killed in the mid.1980's in
ColumbusSas not one of the onginal detectives
assigned to the case but came on board in the mid-1990'S after a
oty commission was formed to investigate allegations of
misconduct by the city's then pokce chief. As a result of the
commission's investigation, documents relating to the Shapiro
homicide were seized from a commander's office
involved in the homiode investigation at that time. It was
determined that Shapiro was involved in misconduct and fraudule t
business activity with the firm where he was employed.
Specifically, it was believed Shapiro was helping businessmen
purchase companies that were facing bankruptcy and creating
illegal tax shelters believed Shapiro had been
I/17/2019 2:32 PM
3501.183-059
Page 3 of 6
Serials https:✓sentinel.tbinet.tbi'apps'ca• mgmvindex-serialsprovicw.htintid...
subpoenaed to testify before a federal grand jury regarding those
business activities and was to appear before the grand Jury the
day after he was killed. Regarding the circumstances of his
death. Shapiro was seen meeting with an unknown man believed to
be the killer in his vehicle first in a shopping center and then
in a Columbus cemetery. In the cemetery. Shapiro fled from the
vehicle to a nearby condominium complex where he was shot
multiple times. Shapiro's car was later found in the shopping
center parking lot Investigation revealed that Barry Kessler, a
business associate of Shapiro'S, was seen meeting with a man at
Kessler's office fitting the description of the man seen with
Shapiro before he was killed. A secretary of Kessler saw Kessler
meeting with the man in his office with a suitcase or briefcase
of money. Kessler was subsequently convicted of murder for
pecuniary gain in federal court in Honda relating to a life
insurance policy of a business associate. Though no sufficient
evidence to charge Kessler was uncovered, believed
Kessler was complicit or responsible for Shapiro's death. In the
mid-1990'S, prominent Columbus business man Leslie VVexner's name
was published in thilopaper, alleging some aninection to
the Shapiro's death found no evidence connecting Wexner
to the homicide case. In addition, -investigation has
revealed no connection between the homicide of Shapiro and
Jeffrey Esptein to date.
Indexing
No Entities to disp ny
Intelligence
Intelligence Value: No Intelligence Value
Potential IIRJSIR? No
Sentinel Tags: No Sentinel Tags Selected
Can you Identify the No
source of this
information?
Routing
Drafted By:
1/1720192:32 PM
3501.183-059
Page 4 of 6
https://sentinellbinetfb9appsica mgmVindex-serialspreview.htmrd...
Filing and Security I V
Primary Case: 72-MM-113327
Serial Number 58
Serialized: 10/26/2010
Category: Full Investigation
initiated: 10/28/2009
Details
Caserta*: (U) ROD IGUEZ.
ALFRE - SEE SUB
Serial 0: 58 Type: INSER I
From: To: PAIAM,
Document Title: INTERVIEW REAUSA
Approval Date: 1026/2010
Classification: SN
Contents 72-MM-113327
CJP:cjp
figation was conducted by Special Agent
on October 26. 2010
Assistant United States Attorney U.S.
Attorneys Office.
was interviewed telephonically
regarding Arthur Shapiro advised that Shapiro was a
target of a tax fraud case being prosecuted by the U.S.
Attorney's office. Specifically, the case was an administrative
case investigated by the IRS. whereby fraudulent or bogus tax
shelters were created. Shapiro was an attorney, and Beny Kessle
was an accountant and co-defendant in the case. Prior to
Shape-US death. Shapiro. his attorney, and had agreed tc
a negotiated plea agreement whereby Shapiro was to plead guilty
to tax fraud could not recall if Shapiro's cooperation
against co-defendants was a condition of his plea agreement
Shapiro was killed pnor to him entering a guilty plea in the
case. Co-defendant Kessler eventually pled guilty to the tax
fraud. Attorney John Zoned( (phonetic) represented Berry Kessle
I/17/2019 2:32 PM
3501.183-059
Page 5 of 6
Serials https://sentincl.lbinct.tbiiapps (ca mgmOindex-scrialsprevicuthtml?d...
2 of 2
in the tax case. and informed Zonack of Shapiro's
intention to plead guilty prior to Shapiro's death. was
unfamiliar with the specifics of Shapiro's murder and was not
involved in the case but understand many in the Columbus area
suspected Kessler of the murder yes unsure 4 there was
a third co-defendant in the tax fraud case
Indexing
No Entities to display
Intelligence
Intelligence Value: No Intelligence Value
Potential IIFUSIR? No
Sentinel Tags: No Sent:nal Tags Selected
Can you identify the No
source of this
information?
Routing
Drafted By:
V
I'172019 2:32 PM
3501.183-059
Page 6 of 6
EFTA00002539 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2011-01-01)
ILO 2 Default Network Settings
Server Serial Number: MX0824A1RJ
III II 1 I 'Hindi
User Name: Administrator
: ILOMX0824A1R1
1 11I NIfirl1151dilic
Password:
Mil
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 OpenCog [academia] AI research in Hong Kong overseen by Ben Goertzel and funded in part by Epstein 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01114164 (Jmail)
 [academia] "OpenCog Road Map 2011-2023" by Ben Goertzel
(approximate date: 2011-01-01)
http://opencog.org/roadmap/
This document gives a very high level roadmap for OpenCog development in the next 12 years — all the
way from here to advanced human -level AGI! For a more specific roadmap regarding the next 2 years,
please consult the wiki.
1 OpenCog Roadmap: 2011-2023
This high-level roadmap charts a course from the current state of the OpenCog system to a full-blown
human -level AG!. Each step along the roadmap is discussed in the Building Better Minds  manuscript.
First some obvious caveats:

• Planning on this broad a level, for a project funded by a complex combination of sources with
various goals of their own, is necessarily uncertain. Some tasks will inevitably be carried out
sooner or later than this schedule projects.

• This schedule represents an effort to balance ambition with realism. For instance, many important
aspects of the tasks here scheduled for 2013.2014 could be initiated now, but are deferred due to
staff limitations, and prioritization of other aspects. If appropriate additional funding is achieved
some of the 2013 tasks may be started sooner. All in all, if the premises underlying the schedule
are correct, then it also follows that the schedule could be accelerated somewhat with sufficient
funding. However, not much effort has gone into figuring out exactly how much it could be
accelerated.

• The possibility of proceeding along this roadmap is predicated on the AGI concepts and designs
described in Building Better Minds being at least approximately correct. If those ideas are
profoundly incorrect or incomplete then the timeline may be substantially revised and extended.
Without further ado, we present the OpenCog project timeline ... beginning with a very brief recap of the
project's history then proceeding to the present and future.
2001-2007: Development of Future OpenCog Code &
Designs within Novamente LLC • The initial OpenCog code was created in 2008 via extracting and cleaning up portions of 
the
Novamente Cognition Engine (NCE), a proprietary Al codebase developed within Novamente
LLC

• While primarily a research system, the NCE had also been used in practical applications for
government and corporate customers, in areas including data analysis, bioinformatics, natural
language processing, uncertain logical inference and the control of animated characters

• The Novamente Cognition Engine itself was inspired by (though significantly different from)
earlier work at Webmind Inc. on a system called the "Webmind Al Engine", developed during
1997-2001 by Webmind Inc.'s R&D staff which at times numbered over 40 researchers &
developers
2008-2010: Initial Development of OpenCogOpenCog was created in 2008 via a collaborative effort between Novamente LLC
and the
Singularity Institute for Artificial Intelligence

• Initial release comprised a core "Mind OS" platform including a knowledge store and scheduler
and networking facilities, plus multiple Al components including initial versions of the PLN
probabilistic learning system, the MOSES automated program learning system, and the RelEx
language comprehension system (and more)
2011-2012: A Proto-AGI Virtual Agent • Integrated "toddler -level" intelligence for video game / virtual world 
characters.

• Focus on robustness, flexibility and adaptive, interactive learning — this is not a good old-
fashioned "Blocks World"

• Simple English language dialogue, e.g. answering questions about its environment and state,
taking instructions, asking clarifying questions when the instructions aren't understood, etc.

• Integration with OpenBiomind for inference-based meta-learning — the ability to learn about the
learning process.

• Inferential analysis of spatio-temporal scenes, e.g. the ability to answer questions about the
relationship between entities without directly observing them.

• Integration with DeSTIN for object and event recognition in image and video data.
• Release of OvenCog v I D.
2013-2014: A Complete, Integrated Proto-AGI Mind • Collective cognition — allowing multiple intelligent agents in an 
embodied environment to
selectively share knowledge and learn from each other's experience.

• Abstract generalization — extension of inference and program learning systems to utilize higher-
order functions.

• Robot control (e.g. humanoid robots, perhaps others) — integration with motion planning and
hierarchical control systems, with testing in the BLISS robot lab.

• Experiential language learning — experience-based modification of all levels of the NLP system.
• Connection of OpenCog to a massive, scalable knowledge store including a permanent OpenCog
instance that new OpenCog instances can synchronise with on initialization.

• Scalable inference and question answering on a large knowledge base, imported from databases
and via automated NLP analysis of large corpora.

• Research and development into a generic probablistic rule engine that seeks to unify a number of
independent rule engines within OpenCog.

• Release of OpenCog v2.0.
• Seek to establish OpenCog as a key learning component within at least 6 Universities teaching
advanced academic courses in Al.
2015-2016: Advanced Learning and Reasoning • Virtual world based Al agents that flexibly acquire language and knowledge 
from human
participants.

• Abstract inference that can integrate scientific knowledge derived from research papers with
knowledge derived from analyzing scientific datasets (initially prototyped in the area of
bioinformatics).

• Humanoid robotic control outside the robot lab within rich environments.
• Initial experimentation with automated control of laboratory equipment, e.g. gene sequencers or
microarrays.

• Full implementation of feedback mechanisms to allow cognitive control of lower-level perceptual
and motor functions.

• Initial experimentation with mathematical theorem-proving.
2017-2018: AGI Experts • Creation of an OpenCog-based artificial scientist, operating a small molecular biology 
laboratory
on its own, designing its own experiments and operating the equipment and analyzing the results
and describing them in English.

• Creation of an OpenCog-based service robot, which carries out basic household tasks in a manner
driven by English-language communication, and knowledge sharing with the network of other
robots.

• Creation of an OpenCog-based virtual assistant, which accompanies its employer into various
online spaces and augmented realities, providing intelligent guidance as needed.
2019-2021: Full -On Human Level AGI • Integration of special-purpose intelligent agents from 2017.2018 into a single 
OpenCog-based
mind kit.

• Risk-assessment of goal stability under self-modification, with consultation from the Singularity
Institute for Artificial Intelligence.

• Instruction of the integrated OpenCog mind in basics of computer science and programming, to
enable it to improve aspects of its own implementation.
2021-2023: Advanced Self-Improvement

• Further instruction in computer science, to enable more significant self-improvement of codebase.
• Further investigation into Al risk and goal stability. Trial self-improvement loops in constrained
environments.

• Training in further areas of science, industry, etc.
Note: While considerations of Al ethics (the assurance that a powerful AGI will remain beneficial to
humanity, and that AGI development will also be ethical from the AGI's point of view) are only
specifically mentioned from 2019, we intend to keep these factors in mind throughout the development of
OpenCog.
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                        FINRA [government] Financial Industry Regulatory Authority 
 OFAC [government] Office of Foreign Assets Control, agency in charge of sanctions 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01480940 (Jmail)
 [money] JP Morgan due diligence report on MC2 Model Management, see quote: "two outstanding federal tax liens totaling $593,789"
(approximate date: 2011-01-01)
Confidential Due Diligence Report

Our searches revealed the following:

MC2 Models Management LLC

• Company records search revealed records found.
Tax ID not provided.
Address confirmed.
Reference the "Liens and Judgments" section to view the (Liens/Judgments) found for MC2 Models
Management.
The following derogatory information was reported.
MC2 Model Management LLC has two outstanding federal tax liens totaling $593,789 ($443,728 +
$150,061).

• Corporate records search revealed no records found.
State of domicile: not confirmed.
• Other databases (RDC/MIS) revealed no records found.

• Internal database search revealed no records found.
• State court searches revealed no records found.

• Federal court searches revealed no records found.
• Publications revealed records found. Due to the amount of news stories found, search parameters had to
be adjusted.
The following derogatory information was reported.
MC2 Model Management received 51 million from Epstein in 2005. It is unknown if the money was
given as a secret investment or payment for services as a procurer.
Jean Luc Brunel, owner of MC2 Model Management and Jeffrey Epstein engaged in racketeering
that involved luring in minor children for sexual play for money. In addition, Brunel was a frequent
passenger on Epstein's private jet and often visited Epstein in jail.
MC2 Model Management was issued a citation by the Florida Business and Professional Regulation
for acting as a talent agent without a license.

• Regulatory sanctions search revealed no records found.
• FINRA/NFA database searches revealed no records found.
A search of OFAC did not reveal any matches.
Confidential - This report is not to be disseminated or photocopied to any third party
without the express consent of Global Security & Investigations.
1309811B.doc 3
Confidential Treatment Requested by
JPMorgan Chase
CONFIDENTIAL
JPM-SDNY-00003182
╔═════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Erika Kellerhals [lawyer] Epstein attorney in Virgin Islands 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00304809 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(approximate date: 2011-01-05)
January 5th, Wednesday
10:00 Appt w/George Delson
12:15 Leon Black at the house for a walk
1:00 Appt w/Steve Hanson (take a walk up Madison?)
1:30 Call Erika Kellerhals
3:00 Go see Dr. Jarecki
4:00 Igor to arrive
5:00 appt w/Dangene and Jennie (at Core Club 66 e. 55th street bet
Park and Madison
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                              C.O.U.Q. Foundation [epstein] Epstein financial trust 
                                      Island Grounds Inc. [epstein] Epstein company 
                                   Zorro Development Corp [epstein] Epstein company 
 Cecile de Jongh [usvi] Virgin Islands first lady 2007-2015, Epstein office manager 
                             Allangie Clifton [employee] construction at the island 
                                  Anthony Jules [employee] landscaper at the island 
                             Benford B. Lewis [employee] construction at the island 
                                Brian K. Bates [employee] maintenance at the island 
                           Cuthbert Titre [employee] pool maintenance at the island 
                                  Danny Vicars [employee] electrician at the island 
                              Dupson Donissaint [employee] landscaper at the island 
                               Gerry Francis Titre [employee] painter at the island 
                           Guy Vicars [employee] building maintenance at the island 
                      Jennaine Ruan [employee] IT Manager at Southern Trust Company 
                                   John Werntz [employee] maintenance at the island 
                                Josue A. BrIto [employee] engineering at the island 
                            Justina de la Cruz [employee] housekeeper at the island 
                                    Karl Henry [employee] engineering at the island 
                                 Maria Rosario [employee] housekeeper at the island 
                        Peter St. Omer [employee] landscaping foreman at the island 
                                      Phillip Blaize [employee] boats at the island 
                                 Pierre Jules [employee] construction at the island 
                                     Renol Mede [employee] landscaper at the island 
                       Sheridon Emanuel Elizee [employee] engineering at the island 
                  Thomas J Melnick [employee] construction supervisor at the island 
                              William B. Hague [employee] engineering at the island 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00709105 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein employee payroll 2010
(approximate date: 2011-01-15)
JEE 2010 Payroll & Benefits
Analysis per entity
.                           Total
Entity                      Employees   % of Total      Totals
1 Island Grounds Inc.       69          30%             2,838,379
2 DKI PLLC                  2           17%             1,664,253
3 HBRK Associates           5           11%             1,024,972
4 LSJ LLC                   10          10%             907,648
5 Financial Trust           10          9%              855,056
6 NES LLC                   7           8%              717,374
7 JEGE                      3           5%              479,471
8 Gary Kerney               1           4%              368,413
9 Lafayette Contractors     3           3%              320,688
10 Zorro Development Corp.  3           2%              162,606
11 Palm Beach               2           1%              116,294
12 Paris                    1           1%              82,755
TOTALS                      116         100%            9,537,909

Top 10 Paid Employees           Total Cost  % of Total
1 Darren Indyke                 1,530,331   16.0%
2 Gary Kerney                   368,413     3.9%
3 Richard Kahn (as of Jan 2011) 313,238     3.3%
4 Larry Visoski                 303,203     3.2%
5 Harry Beller                  301,702     3.2%
6 Igor                          211,120     3.3%
7 Cecile                        194,709     2.0%
8 Jeanne Brennen                187,254     2.2%
9 Emad                          167,771     1.8%
10 Bella                        157,302     1.6%
TOTALS                          3,735,042   40.48%
ISLAND GROUNDS INC.
Employoo
Hire
Date
Position
Old
Rate
Lou
Increases
Lurrent Rate
Zulu
Annual
Salary
Payroll
taxes
Total
cost
Addison
D.
Alfred
(Bricko)
6/18/2008
Construction
11.70
5/24/2010
13.00
28,730
2,786
31,516
Allangie
Clifton
(Clement)
12/8/2009
Construction
25.00
55,250
4,815
60,065
Amilcar
T.
Charles
11/22/2010
Engineering
23.00
50,830
4,477
55,307
Angel
L.
Feliciano
(Angelo)
3/1/2010
Engineering
25.00
55,250
4,815
60,065
Angel
Figueroa
8/23/2010
Painting/Electrical
15.00
33,150
3,124
36,274
Anthony
Casimir
(Laga)
5/21/2001
Maintenance
12.15
26,852
2,642
29,494
Anthony
Jules
(Tony)
5/4/2006
Landscaping
13.05
28,841
2,794
31,635
Augustin
St.
Rose
7/29/2009
Landscaping
10.00
22,100
2,279
24,379
Augustus
K.
Henry
12/29/2009
Construction
25.00
55,250
4,815
60,065
Basillia
Morales
-Mercado
(Dulce)
3/29/2002
Housekeeper
12.60
27,846
2,718
30,564
Benford
B.
Lewis
(Benny)
7/19/2010
Construction
21.00
46,410
4,138
50,548
Bernard
Christopher
(Jah
Batty)
4/18/2007
Boats
10.80
23,868
2,414
26,282
Blenvenido
Gomez
Morales
10/5/2009
Construction
10.00
22,100
2,279
24,379
Brian
K.
Bates
2/28/2007
Maintenance
22.50
49,725
4,392
54,117
Carlos
Thomas
(Rodriguez)
9/29/2008
Construction
20.70
45,747
4,088
49,835
Cuthbert
Titre
(Smiley)
5/3/1999
Engineering
13.50
29,835
2,870
32,705
Danny
Vicars
5/24/2010
Construction
32.50
71,825
6,083
77,908
Dupson
Donissaint
(Baseais)
9/5/2006
Landscaping
10.80
28,080
2,736
30,816
Eddison
Lewis
(Danny)
7/19/2010
Construction
21.00
46,410
4,138
50,548
Ellice
Francis
6/22/2009
Construction
10.00
22,100
2,279
24,379
Eric
A.
Benjamin
10/7/2009
Construction
20.70
45,747
4,088
49,835
Fabien
Regis
(Regis)
12/18/2006
Construction
13.50
1/18/2010
18.00
39,780
3,631
43,411
Felix
de
la
Cruz
9/13/2010
Painting/Electrical
12.15
26,852
2,642
29,494
Francis
James
7/17/2006
Construction
16.69
36,885
3,410
40,295
Georges
Paul
(Tifire)
4/18/2007
Construction
10.80
23,868
2,414
26,282
Gerry
Francis
Titre
8/27/2001
Painting/Electrical
12.15
26,852
2,642
29,494
Giseme
Dalce
7/13/2009
Landscaping
10.00
26,000
2,577
28,577
Givon
J.
St.
Omer
9/20/2010
Painting/Electrical
12.00
26,520
2,617
29,137
Gregory
Snider
8/16/2010
Construction
18.00
10/25/2010
20.70
45,747
4,088
49,835
Guy
Vicars
8/16/2010
Construction
11.00
24,310
2,448
26,758
Hernando
Cuellar
9/29/2008
Construction
20.70
45,747
4,088
49,835
Huxley
Casimir
11/18/2008
Construction
10.80
23,868
2,414
26,282
Irvin
Ocasio
Flores
(Alberto)
12/14/2009
Engineering
20.00
44,200
3,969
48,169
Jn
Bernard
Ville
Guerre
4/19/2007
Construction
10.80
23,868
2,414
26,282
John
Werntz
9/2/2010
Maintenance
25.00
55,250
4,815
60,065
ISLAND
GROUNDS
INC.
Employee
Hire
Date
Position
Old
Rate
Lulu
Increases
Lurrent Rate
zou
Annuai
Salary
Payroll
taxes
Totalrost
Joseph
Frith
12/7/2009
Construction
20.70
45,747
4,088
49,835
Josue
A.
Brito
10/27/2010
Engineering
13.00
28,730
2,786
31,516
Juan
Carlos
Encarnacion
Cruz
1/5/2010
Construction
25.00
55,250
4,815
60,065
Justina
de
la
Cruz
10/5/2009
Housekeeper
12.00
26,520
2,617
29,137
Karl
Henry
1215/2005
Engineering
11.70
25,857
2,566
28,423
Kenneth
Riedener
9113/2010
PaintinglElectrical
21.00
46,410
4,138
50,548
Kerel
Dawn
Holmes
Eubanks
10/20/2010
Painting/Electrical
22.00
48,620
4,307
52,927
Lionel
Giraudel
(Kert)
12/29/2009
Construction
18.00
39,780
3,631
43,411
Luis
Reyes
1/12/2010
Construction
12.00
26,520
2,617
29,137
Maria
Rosario
(Keiry)
9/6/2010
Housekeeper
12.00
26,520
2,617
29,137
Mark
A.
Javaine
(Santini)
12/13/2010
PaintinglElectrical
12.00
26,520
2,617
29,137
Martin
Aberdeen
10/7/2009
Construction
20.70
45,747
4,088
49,835
Melvin
Ocasio
Flores
(Enrique)
12/14/2009
Construction
20.00
44,200
3,969
48,169
Menard
Leatham
Jr.
12/7/2009
Construction
20.70
45,747
4,088
49,835
Michael
A.
Ricker
(Mike)
12/14/2009
Boats
25.00
55,250
4,815
60,065
Miguel
A.
Brito
10/12/2010
Engineering
13.00
28,730
2,786
31,516
Omer
Renat
5/24/2006
Construction
18.00
6/21/2010
19.80
43,758
3,936
47,694
Patrickson
Benjamin
10/6/2008
Construction
20.70
45,747
4,088
49,835
Peter
Elie
(Cephas)
10/6/2008
Construction
20.70
8/30/2010
22.80
50,388
4,443
54,831
Peter
St.
Omer
8/27/2001
Landscaping
Foreman
18.90
6/21/2010
20.80
45,968
4,105
50,073
Phillip
Blaize
6/22/2009
Landscaping
10.00
22,100
2,279
24,379
Pierre
Jules
(Jules)
8/27/2001
Construction
22.95
6/21/2010
25.25
55,803
4,857
60,659
Quaille
Casimir
6/22/2009
Construction
10.00
22,100
2,279
24,379
Randy
Marcellin
1/30/2007
Construction
17.10
37,791
3,479
41,270
Renol
Mede
11/30/2009
Landscaping
10.00
9/7/2010
12.50
27,625
2,701
30,326
Ronald
Bazil
7/13/2009
Construction
15.00
33,150
3,124
36,274
Sandino
Brito
(Manoio)
6/18/2008
Construction
22.50
49,725
4,392
54,117
Shane
Rogers
11/2/2009
Construction
23.00
50,830
4,477
55,307
Sheridon
Emanuel
Elizee
10/5/2009
Maintenance
10.00
22,100
2,279
24,379
Siewlal
Manickchan
(Trini)
10/9/2007
Construction
19.80
43,758
3,936
47,694
Stephen
Liverpool
6/14/2010
Construction
20.00
44,200
3,969
48,169
Stephen
Shillingford
4/18/2007
Construction
10.80
1/18/2010
18.00
39,780
3,631
43,411
Velinord
Thomas
1/2/2007
Construction
10.20
22,542
2,312
24,854
Wellington
Eusebe
(Potie)
2/13/2007
Construction
16.69
1/18/2010
18.00
39,780
3,631
43,411
TOTALS
2,598,983
239,395
2,838,379
DKI PLLC COMPENSATION & BENEFITS
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Darren Ind ke Hire date: 4/15/1996
Salary - NYSG / DKI 1,714,900 1,462,163 1,448,615 1,432,000
Salary - FTC 60,000 240,000 197,308 43,846
Tax Free Distributions - DKI PLLC - 125,000  150,000 -
Legal Fees (paid by JEE) 150,000
401k -7% 15,500 16,000 -
Health / Dental / Life 16,426 16,426 18,766 20,676
Payroll Taxes 30,446 27,091 27,329 27,522
Gifts - - ipad--> 887
Parking 5,400 5,400 5,400 5,400
Loan - NYSG LLC 150,000 -
Total 2,142,672 1,892,081 1,847,418 1,530,331
Lesley Groff Hire date: 2/8/2001
Salary 60,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 108,000 108,000
Bonus 10,000 5,000 6,000 6,000
Gym 2,232 2,017 1,942 2,085 -
Education - - - 14,650
Simple IRA -3% 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800 1,800
Payroll Taxes 5,600 7,393 7,531 7,717 7,940 8,138 8,138
Health / Dental / Life 13,476 13,584 13,680 13,836 13,836 15,612 17 784
Other 300 561 200 1,136 599 10,000 <-
Medical - - - 1,068 9,750
Total 93,408 150,355 151,153 153,642 168,575 141,750 133,922
use of car / cell phone and home phone
OLD FORMAT: 60k paid by NES & 60k by Epstein Interests
NEW FORMAT: entire salary paid by DKI PLLC
OLD FORMAT: Work Schedule Tuesday - Thursday plus Friday's from home
NEW FORMAT: Work Schedule Monday - Friday
Total DKI PLLC Compensation plus Benefits - 2010 1,664,253
HBRK ASSOCIATES COMPENSATION & BENEFITS
NYSG NYSG
2004 2005
NYSG
NYSG
NYSG
HBRK
HBRK
Emad Hanna Hire date: 11/8/2004
Salary 85,000 92,000 95.000 105,000 105,000 94,500 105,000
Bonus 3,000 10,000 10,000
Education 7,175 8,475 9,430 13,168
Education - Loan 13,298
Simple IRA -3% 2,850 3,150 3,450 3,150 2,835 3,150
Payroll Taxes 6,958 7,103 • 7,248 7,413 7,229 8,033
Health / Dental / Life 14,184 14,232 14,400 14,400 17,700 19,944
Contributions from COUQ 5,000 15,000 4,000 3,000
Loans forgiven 50,000 40,000 15,000
20k Loan Emad is paying @ 560 per month 18,346
Total 85,000 123,992 201,660 192,573 142,393 150,432 167,771
Paid by NES from 2004 to 2008
2/8/2010 - JEE approved salary to go back to amount before 10% paycut
NOTE: Not included above is additional cost of approximately $3,000 per month for Emad to work from STT
Harry Beller Hire date: 9/2/1991
Salary 190,000 200,000 200,000 225,000 225,000 202,500 202,500
Bonus 50,000 75,000 75,000 -
Education 36,505  42,390 71,680 64,975 69,259 ' 72,666 56,432
401k -7% 13,000 14,000 15,000 20,500 20,500
IRA 3% - - - 3,038 3,038
Payroll Taxes 8,205 9,205 9,828 10,395 9,618 16,200 16,200
Health / Dental / Life 15,000 15,096 15,125 15,300 15,300 ' 18,600 20,832
Transportation 6,938 9,520 2,760 2,700 2,700 ' 2,700 2,700
Total 269,648 340,211 389,393 413,870 342,377 315,704 301,702 •
50% of Harry's salary (101,250) is paid by DKI PLLC
Richard Kahn Hire date: 10/17/2005
Salary 180,000 195,000 215,000 215,000 193,500 215,000
Bonus 2,000 25,000 25,000
401k -7% 15,000 15,500 15,500
IRA 3% 5,805 6,450
Education 1,100 10,000
Health / Dental / Life. 15,144 15,168 15,336 15,336 18,636 21,048
Payroll Taxes 8,219 8,770 9,060 9,008 9,006 9,690
Medical 16,356
Total 205,363 275,294 279,896 254,844 228,047 262,188
2/8/2010 - JEE approved salary to go back to amount before 10% paycut
10/29/2010 - JEE approved as of 1/1/2011 salary and education per annum increase to 250,000 and 25,000
costing JEE an additional 51,050 per annum 2011 total cost 313,238
HBRK ASSOCIATES COMPENSATION & BENEFITS
NYSG NYSG NYSG NYSG NYSG HBRK HBRK
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Bella Klein  Hire date: 10/11/1999
Salary 65,000 70,000 90,000 100,000 100,000 90,000 100,000
Bonus 5,000 5,000 10,000 10,000 -
Education - 14,554 12,000 25,920 19,830 17,390 25,000
401k -7% 4,900 5,250 7,000 7,700 7,700
IRA 3% - - - - - 2,700 3,000
Payroll Taxes 5,600 6,000 7,030 7,175 7,340 6,885 7,030
Health / Dental / Life 14,076 14,184 14,196 14,340 14,340 17,640 19,872
Transportation  - 2,620 2,400 2,400 2,400 2,400 2,400
Total 94,576 117,608 142,626 167,535 151,610 137,015 157,302
2/8/2010 - JEE approved salary to go back to amount before 10% paycut
Scott Dennet Hire date: 12/14/2010
Salary 120,000
Health / Dental / Life 7,512
Payroll Taxes 8,498
Total 136,010
Paid $10,000 advance which will be paid off over next 5 paychecks (10 weeks time)
Total HBRK Associates Compensation plus Benefits - 2010 1,024,972
LSJ EMPLOYEE SALARIES
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Brice Gordon Hire date: 4/15/2003
Salary 68,250 71,663 75,000 82,500 82,500 74,25.0 74,250
Bonus 6,825 7,500 10,000 10,000 - -
Simple IRA -3% 2,252 2,375 2,550 2,775 2,475 - -
Payroll Taxes 6,006 6,333 6,800 7,400 6,600 5,940 5,940
Payroll Deduction for additional health cost (616)
Health / Life 5,460 5,784 5,508 4,860 4,860 5,820 8,187
Total 88,793 93,655 99,858 107,535 96,435 86,010 87,761
Raise to 82,500 was 4/2/2007
Moved from Zorro to LSJ payroll as of 4/12/2010
Salary 68,250 71,663 75,000 82,500 82,500 74,250 74,250
Bonus 6,825 7,500 10,000 10,000  - -
Simple IRA -3% 2,252 2,375 2,550 2,775 2,475 - -
Payroll Taxes 6,006 6,333 6,800 7,400 6,600 5,940  5,940
Payroll Deduction for additional health cost (1,537)
Health / Life 5,460 5,784 5,508 4,860 4,860 5,820 10,182
Total 88,793 93,655 99,858 107,535 96,435 86,010 88,835
Raise to 82,500 was 4/2/2007
Moved from Zorro to LSJ payroll as of 4/12/2010
Aaron Mcginnis Hire date: 5/4/2005
Salary 65,000 70,000 95,000 95,000 85,500 85,500
Bonus 4,000 10,000 10,000 - - -
Payroll Taxes 5,520 6,400 7,723 7,578 7,440 7,440
Health / Dental / Life 15,324 15,456 15,588 15,588 7,961 8,451
Total 89,844 101,856 128,311 118,166 100,900 101,391
Raise to 95,000 was 2/19/2007
Carlos Rodrigues Hire date: 8/24/2005
Salary 50,000 55,000 65,000 65,000 58,500 58,500
Bonus 3,000 10,000 10,000
Education 4,382
-
5,750
-
9,464
-
7,070
Payroll Taxes 4,240 5,200 6,000 5,200 4,680 4,680
Health / Dental / Life 7,980 7,992 8,004 8,304 17,482 18,745
Total 65,220 78,192 93,386 84,254 90,126 88,995
Casey Johnson Hire date: 8/20/2007
Salary 47,999 48,000 50,000 60,000
Payroll Taxes 3,840  3,840 4,000 4,800
Health / Dental / Life 15,132 15,600 17,341 18,758
Total 66,971 67,440 71,341 83,558
LSJ EMPLOYEE SALARIES
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
William Hague Hire date: 6/1/2008
Salary 76,000 68,400 68,400
Payroll Taxes 6,080 5,472 5,472
Health / Dental / Life 11,664 12,810 13,325
Total 93,744 86,682 87,197
William Rowles (start date 1/15/07)
Salary 125,000 125,000 112,500 112,500
Payroll Taxes 7,703 7,858 7,986 8,265
Automobile - Parking & Insurance - 6. 00 per month 7,200 7,200 7,200 7,200
LSJ Health Insurance - - - 16,610
Life / Disability Benefits 1,344
Health Insurance - 250 per month 3,000 3,000 3,000 -
Total 142,903 143,058 130,686 145,919
Moved from Lafayette to LSJ payroll as of 6/20/2010 so he can have health insurance benefits
Daniel Joseph (gala Hire date: 2/24/2010
Salary 50,000
Payroll Taxes 4,000
Health / Dental / Life 17,571
Total 71,571
Manuel J Gonzalez Hire date: 5/2/2008
Salary 45,000
Payroll Taxes 3,600
Health / Dental / Life 3,572
Total 52,172
Moved from Island Grounds to LSJ payroll as of 1/1/2010
Gary Moses Hire date: 10/28/2008
Salary 76,500 76,500 ' 76,500
Payroll Taxes 6,120 6,120 1 6,120
Health / Dental / Life 15,960 16,232 ' 17,630
Total 98,580 98,852 100,250
LSJ Compensation & Benefits - 2010 907,648
FINANCIAL TRUST
Employee
Increase
Hire Date Date Salary Payroll taxes Simple IRA Health insurance Tuition Total cost
3%
Ann M. Rodriguez 06/09/2003 7/16/2010 40,000 3,214 1,200 12,122 56,536
Cecile R. de Jongh 04/03/2000 110,000 8,375 3.300 19,959
•
-
53,076 194,709
Daphne L. Wallace 06/12/2000 8/27/2010 53,000 4.209 1,590 11.458 70,257
Jeanne Brennan Wiebrac 08/01/2000 1/1/2010 150,000 8.955 4.500 23.799 187,254
Jermaine A Ruan 03/01/2000 45,000 3.597 1,350 15,118 65,065
Leon A. Casey, Sr. 01/01/2000 50,000 3.979 1,500 41,409 96,888
Loretta McDonald Morrell 03/01/2000 25,000 2,067 750 11,602 39,419
Monique Harry 12/01/2009 12/1/2009 46,000 3.673 1.380 16,401 67,454
Una R. Pascal 11/03/2003 8/27/2010 53,000 4.209 1.590 18.677 77,475
Totals 572,000 17,160 170,544 53,076 855,056
NOTE: JEE and DKI not included above
Jeffrey E. Epstein 190,000 9,677 11,175 210.852
Darren Indyke 43,486 3.522 47.008
TOTAL COST WITH JEE & DKI 1,112,917
SENT TOTAL TO SUMMARY SHEET WITHOUT JEE AND DKI SINCE MCI INCLUDED IN HIS TOTALS AND JEE PAYING HIMSELF
Salary Payroll taxes Simple IRA Health insurance Tuition Total cost
Employee Hire Date
3%
Ann M. Rodriguez 06/09/2003 34,0001 2,755 1020 11,553 6,883 56,211
Cecile R. de Jongh 04/03/2000 110,0001 8,375 3300 19,017 90,099 230,790
Daphne L. Wallace 06/12/2000 45,500, 3,635 1365 11,724 62,224
Jeanne Brennan Wiebrac 08/01/2000 98,000 7,651 2940 19,017 47,595 175,203
Jermaine A. Ruan 03/01/2000 45,000. 3,597 1350 15,628 2,991 68,566
Leon A. Casey, Sr. 01/01/2000 50,000 3,979 1500 32,232 87,711
Loretta McDonald Morrell 03/01/2000 25,000 2,067 750 11,058 38,875
Monique Harry 12/0172009 on Lafayer 40,500, 3,252 4,320 48,072
Una R. Pascal 11/03/2003 46,000 3,673 1380 19,017 4,059 74,128
Totals 494,000 13,605 143,565 151,627 841,781
NOTE: DKI not included above
Jeffrey E. Epstein 01/01/2000 0
Darren Indyke 197,308, 9,531 10,634 217,473
TOTAL COST WITH OKI 1,059,254
NES COMPENSATION & BENEFITS
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Richard Barnett Hire date: 12/18/1995
Salary 105,000 105,000 105,000 115,000 115,000 103,500 103,500
Bonus 5,000 15,000 15,000 15,000
Education 10,160 3,155 2,835
Simple IRA -3% 3,300 3,600 3,600 3,900 3,450
Payroll Taxes 7,045 7,320 7,580 7,930 8,020 8,280 8,280
Health / Dental / Life 14,196 7,152 1,392 1,440 1,440 1,320 1,320
Other - parking 150 2,400 3,600 3,600 3,600 3,600 3,600
Charity 5,000 5,000 5,000
Union 13,194 27,040 27,040 30,368 31,616 32,864
Total 144,851 153,666 171,367 181,745 166,878 148,316 149,564
Joio Fontanilla Hire date: 2/1/1992
Salary 43,000 48,000 52,000 60,000 60,000 54,000 54,000
Bonus 5,000 20,000 20,000 20,000
Education 21,198 22,153 24,065 4,975 8,635 2,775 5,025
Simple IRA -3% 1,440 2,040 2,160 2,400 1,800
Payroll Taxes 3,840 5,440 5,760 6,400 4,800 4,320 4,320
Health / Dental / Life 5,568 5,892 5,412 5,256 5,256 6,156 6,636
Other 4,474 5,643 2,100 2,100 1,200 1,200
Car - 1998 suburban 4,575
Total 84,520 109,168 109,397 101,131 82,591 68,451 71,181
Cost of House in 2006: 497,700 / Furniture & Shipping
Lynn Fontanilla Hire date: 2/1/1992
Salary 43,000 45,000 48,000 50,000 50,000 45,000 45,000
Bonus 2,000 5,000 10,000 10,000
Simple IRA -3% 1,350 1,500 1,740 1,800 1,500
Payroll Taxes 3,600 4,000 4,640 4,800 4,000 3,600 3,600
Health / Dental / Life 5,448 5,772 5,316 5,136 5,136 6,096 6,576
Other 433 396 8,082
Total 55,398 61,705 70,092 79,818 60,636 54,696 55,176
Doug Schoettle Hire date: 9/2/1991
Salary 209,800 209,800 209,800 209,800 209,800 60,000 60,000
Simple IRA -3%
Payroll Taxes 8,492 8,622 8,883 9,087 9,087 6,915 6,915
Health / Dental / Life 7,200 7,524 7,056 6,876 6,876 6,240 6,840
Total 225,492 225,946 225,739 225,763 225,763 73,155 73,755
3/16/2009 Salary went from 188,820 (salary after 10% paycut) to 60,000
Doug was not paid the first 5.5 months of 2010 then did a catch up payment
11/25/2010 payroll stopped
NES COMPENSATION & BENEFITS
2004 2005 2006
Hire date:
NES start ay
Salary 50,000
Bonus 5,000
Simple IRA -3%
Payroll Taxes 4,400
Dental / Doctors
Other(gifts) 575
Education
Health / Dental / Life 5,880
Reimbursed exp / Ferrair procee'
55,000
10,000
5,200
8,085
17,088
6,204
25,000
60,000
50,000
3,300
7,435
3,362
16,179
5,736
Total 59,975 126,577 146,012
2007 2008
85,000 85,000
25,000
3,300 2,550
7,640 7,278
2,168 8,355
27,529 14,634
1,530
5,568 5,568
131,000
157,735 254,385
NOTE: Florida rent of 4,000 per month not included above
2009 2010
76,500 76,500
T,154 7,154
195 390
34,602 17,127
6,528 7,116
124,979 108,287
Ictort Zinoviev  Hire date: 11/17/2005
Salary 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 r 108,000 108,000
Simple IRA -3% - -
Payroll Taxes 7,320 7,320 7,320 7,320 8,424 8,640
Health / Dental / Life 7,200 14,424 14,460 14,460 16,980 20,100
Other training---> 3,150 1,816 1,816 1,816 1,816
Education - - - 35,911 29,714 29,201
Car 43,360 43,361 43,362 43,363
Total 134,520 144,894 186,956 222,868 208,296 211,120
Salary
Simple IRA -3%
Payroll Taxes
Health / Dental / Life
Other
Doctors / Dentists
Education
Total 90,148 48,291
I .
25,000 25,000
2,000 2,000
5,820 6,360
12,849 14,931
2,479
42,000
■ was formerly employed by earning $50,000 per annum
NES payroll start date
Total NES Compensation plus Benefits - 2010 717,374
JEGE/Hyperion
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Dave Rogers Hire date: 7/1/1991
160,000
5,000
6,133
4,950
7,973
14,904
165,000
10,000
32,687
5,250
8,378
14,952
175,000
10,000
23,607
5,550
8,728
15,156
175,000
12,407
5,250
8,583
15,156
50,000
13,763
4,000
17,556
50,000
41,000
7,280
19,800
Salary 165,000
Bonus 8,000
Education 10,617
Simple IRA -3% 5,190
Payroll Taxes 7,958
Health / Dental / Life 14,820
Total 211,585 198,960 236,267 238,041 216,396 85,319 118,080
$41,000 approved by JEE however Dave wanted to defer income until 2011
Larry Visoski Hire date: 7/1/1991
Salary 170, 000 175,000 180,000 200,000 180,000 180,000 180,000
Bonus 10, 000 10,000 15,000 15,000
Education 6, 048 50,840 54,249 56,830 62,296 42,362 21,998
Education Loans 25,000 41,000
Simple IRA -3% 5,400 5,550 5,850 6,450 5,400
Payroll Taxes 8,060 8,263 8,668 9,163 8,655 8,655 8,655
Health / Dental / Life 14,940 15,024 15,132 15,276 15,276 17,676 19,920
New Mexico Expenses 11,070 27,403 5,725 7,876
Gift - Insurance Expense 6,398
Other - Auto / Boat 16, 169 12,288 16,100 16,761 14,075 14,548 17,356
Total 230,617 276,965 295,000 330,550 313,104 293,966 303,203
Larry Morrison Hire date: 2/19/2001
Salary 136,000 136,000 140,000 40,000 40,000 36,000 36,000
Bonus 6,000 6,000 8,000
Simple IRA -3% 4,260 4,260 4,440 1,200 1,200 1,080 1,080
Payroll Taxes 7,509 7,509 7,596 3,200 3,200 2,880 2,880
Health / Dental / Life 14,700 14,784 14,820 13,584 13,584 15,984 18,228
Total 168,469 168,553 174,856 57,984 57,984 55,944 58,188
3/5/2007 moved to part time status -salary reduction (health,medical,dental still received)
Total Compensation & Benefits - 2010 479,471
Gary Kerney
Medical
Payroll Life & Total
Employee  Salary  Taxes Dental Housing  Travel Cost
1 Gary Kerney 301,213 (A) (A) 50,400 16,800 368,413
TOTALS 301,213 50,400 16,800 368,413
(A) Payroll Taxes and Health Insurance are included in Salary
Lafayette Contractors LLC
2008 2009 2010
Thomas J. Melnick (start date 4/7/08)
108,000
7,921
12,000
108,000
8,076
12,000
Salary 108,000
Payroll Taxes 7,611
Auto / Health Insurance reimbursement 12,000
Total 127,611 127,921 128,076
5/1/2009 - JEE approved salary to go back to amount before 10% paycut
Albert Adams (start date 11/16/09)
Salary 83,200 83,200
Payroll Taxes 6,656 6,656
Auto / Health Insurance reimbursement 6,000 6,000
Total 95,856 95,856
Loren Nickbarq (start date 11/13/09)
Salary 83,200 83,200
Payroll Taxes 6,656 6,656
Auto / Health Insurance reimbursement 6,900 6,900
Total 96,756 96,756
TOTAL LAFAYETTE COMPENSATION & BENEFITS 320,688
Zorro Development Corp. Employee Salaries
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Salary
Simple IRA -3%
Payroll Taxes
Health / Life
Bonus
Total
Hire date:
44,000 46,000
1,380 1,470
3,680 3,920
12,300 12,312
2,000 3,000
48,000
1,545
4,120
12,324
3,500
53,000
1,695
4,520
12,480
3,500
53,000 47,700 47,700
1,590
4,240 3,816 3,816
12,480 15,528 17,052
63,360 66,702 69,489 75,195 71,310 67,044 68,568
Wendy Nun
Salary
Simple IRA -3%
Payroll Taxes
Health / Life
Bonus
Total
Steve Chavez
Salary
Bonus
Simple IRA -3%
Payroll Taxes
Health / Life
Total
Hire date: 1/10/2005
28,500
2,400
5,172
1,500
31,000 32,500
1,035 1,080
2,760 2,880
4,884 4,248
3,500 3,500
32,500 29,250 29,250
2,600 2,340 2,340
4,248 5,208 5,688
37,572 43,179 44,208 40,323 36,798 37,278
I JEE Approved $5,000 bonus to be paid January 1, 2011
Hire date: 10/19/2009
37,000 37,000
2,960 2,960
15,276 16,800
55,236 56,760
Total Zorro Compensation & Benefits - 2010 162,606
JEE - Palm Beach Salaries
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Janus Banasiak Hire date: 1/24/2005
Salary 57,000 60,000 65,000 65,000 58,500 58,500
Bonus 5,000 10,000 10,000 - - -
Simple IRA -3% - 2,100 2,250 1,950 - -
Payroll Taxes 4,960 5,600 6,000 5,200 4,680 4,680
Health / Life 5,580 5,508 5,304 5,304 5,604 6,048
dental 2,550 1,185 1,213 233 220 308
Total 75,090 84,393 89,767 77,687 69,004 69,536
Salary 35,000 36,000 40,000 42,000 42,000 37,800 37,800
Bonus 500 3,000 5,000 5,000
Simple IRA -3% - 1,170 1,350 1,410 - -
Payroll Taxes 2,840 3,120 3,600 3,760 3,360 3,024 3,024
Health / Life 12,180 13,452 13,464 8,952 8,952 9,372 5,784
dental 250 230 160 100 150
Other - 463 - -
Total 50,520 56,992 63,877 61,352 54,472 50,296 46,758
Total Palm Beach Compensation & Benefits - 2010 116,294
PARIS SALARIES
EUROS EUROS EUROS EUROS EUROS EUROS
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Valdson - Salary I
Salary 26,000 28,244 30,000 30,000 27,000 27,000
Extra Payroll 26,000 27,828 30,000 30,000 27,000 27,000
Food Allowar 7,300 7,300 7,300 7,300 7,300 7,300
Total Euros 59,300 63,371 67,300 67,300 61,300 61,300
Total Annual Salary at US$ @ 1.35 rate 82,755
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Brock Pierce [crypto] sex crime history, Bannon partner at IGN, Tether co-founder, friend of Yair Netanyahu [protos/cryptadamus/wiki] 
                                                                      Lazard [finance] UK financial advisory and asset management firm 
                                                                                              Eric Schmidt [tech] former CEO of Google 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02005667 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Clearstone Online Gaming Fund pitch deck
(approximate date: 2011-02-01)
CLEARS TONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL
EIFTA_R1,050.753
DISCLAIMER
THESE MATERIALS ARE PROVIDED FOR CONVENIENCE ONLY AND MAY NOT BE
RELIED UPON. PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS IN ANY FUTURE CLEARSTONE FUND
MAY RELY ONLY UPON THAT FUND'S PRIVATE PLACEMENT MEMORANDUM OR
AN OFFICIAL SUPPLEMENT THERETO. EXISTING INVESTORS MAY ONLY RELY
ON EACH FUND'S OFFICIAL FINANCIAL REPORTS. AND ONLY TO THE EXTENT
SPECIFIED IN THAT FUND'S LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT. WITHOUT
LIMITING THE GENERALITY OF THE FOREGOING, ANY PROJECTIONS OR
OTHER FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS CONTAINED HEREIN ARE BASED
UPON CLEARSTONE MANAGEMENT'S CURRENT BELIEFS AND EXPECTATIONS
AND ARE NOT GUARANTEES OF FUTURE PERFORMANCE. PROSPECTIVE AND
EXISTING INVESTORS MAY NOT RELY ON, AND CLEARSTONE MANAGEMENT
UNDERTAKES NO OBLIGATION TO UPDATE ANY SUCH PROJECTIONS OR
FORWARD LOOKING STATEMENTS.
Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential 2 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
STATE OF VENTURE CAPITAL
@Copyr,g1.2.011,1,...d.s.MIJ CLEARSTONE
rUNn
EIFIA,_0050.755

╭───────────── Page 3, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ STATE OF VENTURE CAPITAL                   │
│                                            │
│ 11 | Private and Confidential 3 CLEARSTONE │
│ ONLINE GAMING FUND                         │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────╯

A DECADE AFTER THE DOT COM
BUBBLE BURST, THE VENTURE
CAPITAL MARKET IS NOW POISED
FOR BREAKOUT PERFORMANCE
CLEARSTONE
EFFA,1_00504758
CONDITIONS HAVE IMPROVED
CONSIDERABLY, HELPED BY
A REDUCTION IN CAPITAL
AND FIRMS...
CLEARSTONE
EFFA,1_00504757
VENTURE CAPITAL FUNDRAISING IS DOWN
67% IN 2010 VS 2007
$90
$80
$70
$60
$50
$40
$30
$20
$10
$0
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
» VC IT funding commitments back to 1996 levels
(D Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential 6
Source: DowJones VentureSource
CLEARSTONE
ONl INE GAMING FUND
ONLY THE STRONGEST FIRMS SURVIVED THE
POST BUBBLE SHAKE OUT
Active Information Technology Investors
# of Active Firms
1000 •
0 Hum 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
■ >3 Deals/yr
■ <=3 Deals
» Active Investors Down
- 712 active investors in 2000 versus 313 in 2009, a 56% decline
» Average Fund Size Increased
$165MM in 2000 versus $200MM in 2009
(D Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential 7
Source: DowJones VentureSource
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
STRONG PUBLIC MARKET APPETITE FOR
GROWTH STORIES

No. of Venture-Backed OPO's
57 57
2005 2006 2007
■
2008 2009
2010 2011E
A new generation of large market cap tech companies will
increase the field of potential acquirers
Source' NVCA and Clearstone analysis. Selected IPO's shown in 2011. Linkedln and
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential
Skype have filed for IPO. Facebook, Zynga and GroupOn IPO are market speculation.
8 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
MORE SO THAN EARLIER TECH
CYCLES, PRIVATE INVESTORS ARE
BEING REWARDED FOR POTENTIAL
BREAK OUT VALUE AT IPO
CLEARSTONE
EFFA,1_00504761

╭─────── Page 9, Image 1 ───────╮
│ MORE SO THAN EARLIER TECH     │
│ CYCLES, PRIVATE INVESTORS ARE │
│ BEING REWARDED FOR POTENTIAL  │
│                               │
│ BREAK OUT VALUE AT IPO        │
│                               │
│ EFTA_R1_00504761              │
╰───────────────────────────────╯

MORE VALUE ACCRUING TO VENTURE
INVESTORS, NOT PUBLIC SHAREHOLDERS
Pre-Money IPO Valuations
$70 Public investors
$50 participated in 99% of the $40 terminal value of these
$30 companies $12
$10 $0.23 $0.44 $0.70
$70
Cisco Ammon M iansoft V M man Goode Factook
Earlier Tech New Tech
Cycles Cycle
Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential
Source: Facebook Pre-Money IPO valuation $70B per
SharesPost private market exchange - February 2011
10 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
WHY ARE EARLY STAGE
COMPANIES CAPTURING
MORE VALUE?
CLEARSTONE
EIFTA_R1_005WEI3
CAPITAL MARKETS ARE MUCH BETTER
INFORMED
Hedge Fund Industry Growth
r.
6.>) q?' 4° 4° 6.;\ 00 45 C:5 e?' 4° C! 45
=Number of Hedge Funds SAUM
12,000
10,000
8,000 `)
6,000
4,000
2,000
Better informed investors driving efficiency in the pricing of
growth stories
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 12
Source: Hedge Fund Research
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
COMPANIES HITTING CRITICAL MASS FASTER
DUE TO INTERNET GROWTH
c1/0 Global
19.0%
Users 1998 vs. 2008 Number of Internet Users (millions)
China I 2.1
298.0
84.6 14.7% United States 230.6
16.9 6.1% Japan 96.0
Brazil 2. 5 4.6% 72.0
3.9% 8.1 Germany • 1998
I 1.4 India
62.0
51.8 3.3% • 2008
m
8.0
3.0% Britain 46.7
2.9% 1.2 Russia 1. 45.3
2.7% France 42.3
2.3% South Korea
3.1
36.8 Source: International Telecommunication Union.
World TelecommunicationllCT Development Report
ID Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential 13 CLEARSTONE
ONI.INE GANIING FUND
GLOBAL GAINS ARE CAUSING COMPANIES TO
GO GLOBAL EARLIER IN THEIR LIFECYCLE
$5.7
$1.2
\\ ........1 ‘000 2010
•China GDP
$0.0
$2.0
2000 2010
I/Brazil GDP
31L,
$0.5
2000 2010
•India GDP
» 2.5 year old GroupOn already has 35 international offices
(di Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential 14
..rmrce: International Monetary Fund
Amounts in (STrillions)
CLEARSTONE
CLEARSTONE WAS THE EARLIEST
AND MOST SUCCESSFUL FUND
TARGETING THE CONSUMER
INTERNET SECTOR
15 CLEARSTONE
1•11'," ""
EFFA,1_00504787
FORTUNE MAGAZINES TOP FIVE
PERFORMING PRIVATE EQUITY FUNDS
>>
Fortune magazine produced an article on September 171h, 2010 presenting
"The 5 best and 5 worst private equity funds"
The source for the article was the California Public Employees Retirement
System (CaIPERS)
- CaIPERS is the nations largest private investor
— Funds judged by net IRR
Top 5 performing private equity funds
— Clearstone Venture Partners 1-B (1999): 154.7%
— T3 Partners II (2001): 95.6%
— GCP California Fund (2003): 91.9%
- WLR Recovery Fund II (2002): 79.5%
- Permira Europe I (1997): 74.5%
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 16 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
WHY WAS THE FIRST
CLEARSTONE SECTOR FOCUSED
FUND SO SUCCESSFUL?
17 CL EA RSTONE
A DIFFERENT INVESTMENT APPROACH
>>
Conventional Fund Strategy
— Invest across a range of sectors, with capital weightings for each sector
determined ad hoc and post closing of the fund
— Rely on a few mega hits to drive fund returns
— Fund's investment focus heavily dependent on each partner's personal
interests, network, and capacity to do more deals
Clearstone Sector Fund Approach
— Become `hub of the wheel' for all investments by positioning the entire
fund's resources around one sector
— Switch from `wild-catting' for big hits to funding numerous ideas within a
known big hit market
— Combine traditional venture capital investing with a highly successful
incubation practice
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 18 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
MANY BENEFITS ACCRUE TO SECTOR
FOCUSED FUNDS
>)
>>
>)
First fund in the sector which caused the fund to become synonymous with
the sector
Always on the short list of the best entrepreneurs and fellow venture firms
Sector focused meant sector smart
- Assembled the nascent industry's best advisors and thinkers
— Developed deep and comprehensive understanding of the industry eco-
system
— Anticipated the industry's future needs — and funded those opportunities
early
Knew the acquirers and their strategic priorities
Nature of sector focused fund allows for stage agnostic investing providing a
balanced portfolio with providing earlier liquidity
— Seed (up to 10 year liquidity cycle), Series A/B (up to 7 year liquidity
cycle), and Pre-IPO (under 24 months)
© Copynght 2011 1 Private and Confidential 19 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
THE CLEARSTONE ONLINE GAMING
FUND IS APPLYING THE SAME
STRATEGY FOR AN EQUALLY
INTERESTING MARKET
20 CLEARSTONE
EIFT,,0050.772
THE CLEARSTONE ONLINE GAMING FUND
>)
>7
Investment focus
— Online gaming sector
— Primarily private companies (15+ investments)
— 3 year investment time frame
Fund size
- $150M cap
— $50M first close (5+ investment opportunities identified)
Key Terms
- 2.5% management fee with 20% carried interest
2% general partner contribution
— Key man provision
— No fault divorce clause
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 21 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
RATIONALE FOR A FUND TARGETING THE
ONLINE GAMING MARKET
Participate in the massive value creation — and value shifts — created by the
explosive growth in online gaming
Represents the biggest near term investment opportunity known to the fund's
principals
No gaming focused funds with few venture capitalists deeply familiar with the
sector
Global investment opportunities with robust exit options
Ability to create a concentrated global stage agnostic portfolio designed to
capture the value caused by the industry's growth while providing greater
liquidity than typical venture funds
- Clearstone has a presence in most major gaming markets allowing us to
invest globally (Southern California, Northern California, Europe, Middle
East, Asia and India)
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 22 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
CLEARSTONE ONLINE GAMING FUND
PRINCIPALS
>)
William Quigley (Los Angeles) — Managing Director
— 14 years experience as venture capitalist and board member — co-founder
of Clearstone Venture Partners (successor firm to idealab Capital
Partners)
— Invested in numerous seed and early stage companies. IPOs include
eMachines, eMusic, Meru Networks, MP3.com, PeopleSupport,
Tickets.com
— USC, Disney, HBS, Kauffman Fellow, Mid Atlantic VC
Brock Pierce (Los Angeles) — Managing Director
- 13 years experience as an entrepreneur raising more than $200m
- Founded Affinity Media, IGE, ZAM, Titan Gaming, EverTune,
RevenueAPEX, Digital Entertainment Network, myTaste
— Acquired more than 30 companies including Xfire, IMI, SkyHi, Thottbot,
Wowhead, Allakhazam, Player Auctions, Mysupersales
- Advisor to the China Youth League
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 23 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
CLEARSTONE ONLINE GAMING POTENTIAL
FUND PRINCIPALS
Keith McCurdy (Bay Area) — Managing Director
23 years experience in the game business as a senior executive EA,
board member of game companies (both public and private), and CEO of
multiple game startups
12 years at industry leader Electronic Arts as VP Online, VP Technology,
VP Product Development, and Director of Advanced Technology Group
Direct operating experience in console, PC, MMO, mobile, casual, and
social games
Raised venture capital from five venture funds as CEO and several more
as a board member (all gaming based startups)
Michael Robertson (San Diego) — Venture Partner
Raised more than $100M and orchestrated transactions with a combined
value of nearly a billion dollars in public and private markets
Founded MP3.com (sold to UMG), DAR.fm, Linspire (sold to Xandros),
Gizmo5 (sold to Google)
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 24 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
EFT&.R1_00504778
CLEARSTONE ONLINE GAMING POTENTIAL
FUND PRINCIPALS
Rachid Sefrioui (Paris) — Venture Partner
12 years experience as venture capitalist and board member — founder of
Fina Ventures
Invested in New.net, RF Magic, asip, Reef, Entropic, Apogee, CyOptics,
Atrenta, General Photonics, OEwaves, Sequoia Communications
University of Cleveland, McKinsey, Bowco Investment Management,
Wafabank
Louis Hsieh (Beijing) — Venture Partner
20 years experience as private equity investor, investment banker, CFO,
and board member
President of New Oriental Education (NYSE: EDU)
Former UBS MD and Head of TMT Asia Pacific, board member of Perfect
World (NASQAD: PWRD)
MBA HBS, JD Berkeley, Stanford, JP Morgan, Credit Suisse First Boston,
White & Case
›, Jim Armstrong (Los Angeles) — Member of the Investment Committee
A OCD Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential 25 CLE RST NE
ONLINE GANIING I
POTENTIAL VENTURE ADVISORS
John Pleasants — President of Disney Interactive, Former CEO of Playdom,
COO of Electronic Arts
John Schappert— COO of Electronic Arts
Sean Ryan — Head of Facebook Games
Steve Chang — President of Zynga Game Studio
Neil Young — President of Ngmoco/DeNA
John Batter— Co-President of Dreamworks Interactive
David Wallerstein— EVP International of Tencent
Ed Fries — Founder of Xbox
Howard Marks — Founder of Activision, Acclaim, Former SVP for Playdom
Nolan Bushnell — Founder of Atari and Chuck E Cheese
Jeffrey Pollack — Former Commissioner of the World Series of Poker
© Copyright 201 I 1 Private and Confidential 26
POTENTIAL VENTURE ADVISORS
Wade Davis — Chief Strategic Officer of Viacom, Co-Founder of Think
Equity, Lazard
Jack Kennedy— EVP of Digital Media for News Corp
Steve Eskenazi — Former Managing General Partner of Walden Ventures
Shawn Fanning — Founder of Napster, Snowcap, Path
Brad Serwin — COO of Playdom, Former General Counsel of Sands Resorts
Karl Meta — Founder of Playspan
Shervin Pishevar— Founder of SGN and prominent angel investor
John Borthwick— Founder of Betaworks, EVP of Time Warner
Mike Huskins — Executive Recruiter for Facebook, Zynga, Glam
Ross Levinsohn — EVP of Yahoo Americas
© Copyright 201 I 1 Private and Confidential 27 ( 1 \
TRENDS DRIVING GROWTH IN THE
ONLINE GAMING MARKET
Copy,51.1011 28 CLEARSTONE
rUN.
EIFIA,1_0050.780
GLOBAL GAMING MARKET IS EXPECTED TO
HIT $87 BILLION BY 2014
Global Video Games Sector Revenue ($B)
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010E 2011F 2012F 2013F 2014F
Clearstone
"-- Online Gaming
Fund focus area
■ Console games ■ Online games ■ Mobile games 0 PC games ■ In-game Advertising
The console gaming market is flat, with overall market growth
being driven by online and mobile games
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 29
Source: Digi-Capital
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
ONLINE GAMING IS CREATING MASSIVE
VALUE, FASTER THAN EVER IN HISTORY
facebook.
Valued at $67B
40% Traffic Game-related
(Social Network)
Tencentaill
$55B Market Cap
$3.2B 2010 Run-rate
(Social Gaming Network)
Copyri.10Il l Pivate and co men.
zynga
Valued at VIM
275M Monthly Actives
(Social Game Publisher)
MEXCIN
Valued at $10B (est.)
Revenue 2010: $860M (est.)
(Game Publisher)
STEAM
B in Game Sales
30M Users
(Etailer of Games)
DeNA®
Valued at $5.5B
$1.50 2010 Run-rate
(Mobile Game Publisher)
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
EIFIA_.31_0050.782
DISTRIBUTION AND BUSINESS MODEL
UNDERGOING MAJOR TRANSITION
The Old Model (1980+)
Played On
Consoles
Retail
Packaged Software
The NEW Model (2010+)
Played On
Internet
Free-to-Play
Virtual Goods
Copyright 201 I 1 Private and Confidential
(Ni tido)
SPA
Console/PC
4 zynga
0:1
e"'N
..,14.44). •
-roc 72
SONY
Ze rl iMpe
9INARE ENIX
AtItYir4o•4
umartrz -
ekt4-... 1+4, rtf.t.t T •
wont :r GAM(
(C) play f ish 0 DeNA 0 il,, Ill
MIXON
0 facebook
P e ar spilgames NW is. the,:w-ff.
M.MIIIMI ‘e -.. C'`'`Nk : — -
"lexHca? O mayoral ( . rencrot Mt G O1... Z Nrritaga
Web/Mobile
JAOC:
131 W,rack
JOY PORT
Source: OFC Intelligence & iGaming Business
CLEARSTONE
ONI.INE GAMING 11:ND

╭──────────────── Page 31, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ DISTRIBUTION AND BUSINESS MODEL                  │
│ UNDERGOING MAJOR TRANSITION                      │
│                                                  │
│ The Old Model (1980+) Console/PC                 │
│                                                  │
│ Consoles                                         │
│                                                  │
│ Retail \                                         │
│ Packaged Software htm nnn nnn nnn nnn nennnnne © │
│ The NEW Model (2010+) A208 ED sxingeom           │
│ ve re                                            │
│                                                  │
│ Played On                                        │
│                                                  │
│ mtomet aN Conic SABE                             │
│ YAHOO! Qpiaydom —(* Tencenran SG                 │
│ = = re                                           │
│ Free-to-Play |                                   │
│ Virtual Goods Web/ Mobile                        │
│ © Copyright 2011 | Private and Confident 3       │
│                                                  │
│ Oplayfish @ pena @                               │
│ — @ i we,                                        │
│ H                                                │
│                                                  │
│ JAQEX                                            │
│                                                  │
│ VACA                                             │
│                                                  │
│ PB wertase JOYPORT RI                            │
│ wee tebces                                       │
│                                                  │
│ EFTA_R1_00504783                                 │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

THE MARKET HAS REALIZED THE VALUE
SHIFT FROM RETAIL TO FREEMIUM
0 Tencentaill zynga
Year Founded 1982 1998 2007
Value $7B Market Cap $55B Market Cap Valued at $10B
Revenue $3.7B $3B $1.8B*
Copynght 2011 1 Private and Confidential
Source. CrunchBase, Goo& Finance. Forbes, company filings, equity research
Forecast 2011 Revenue
32 CLEARSTONE
[)MANE GAMING FUND
SOCIAL NETWORKING AND ONLINE GAMING
NOW ACCOUNT FOR 33% OF TIME ONLINE
Share of Time Online
Classified/
Auction
3%
Multi-category
Entertainment
3%
Software
Manufacturers
3%
Search
4%
ideos/Movies
4%
E-mail
8%
Portals
4%
Instant
Messaging
4%
» Social networks and online games grew 31% in 2010 and now
account for 33% of all time online
(D Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential 33
Source: Nielsen as of June 2010
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
SOCIAL NETWORKING DRIVING MASS
MARKET ADOPTION OF ONLINE GAMES
Rank Name Category Monthly Active
Users (MAUs)
1 City Ville
2 Farm Ville
3 Badoo
4 Texas Hold'Em Poker
5 Causes
6 BandPage
7 FrontierVille
Games
Games
Dating
Games
Philanthropy
Utility
Games
» Facebook's userbase is 662MM
93M
50M
46M
38M
22M
19M
19M
» 4 of the top 7 and half of the top 40 Facebook applications are
games
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 34
Source: AppData, March 2011
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
MOBILE GAMING IS THE FASTEST GROWING
SEGMENT OF THE ONLINE GAMING INDUSTRY
(1) 400
.O 300
Cumulative Units Shipped: Apple's iOS &
Google's Android iOS
Android
Total
cz,c; „, O co 0 2' co°  e .O°  coe'
Smart-phone proliferation is putting a "game console" in millions of
consumers' pockets
Apple has generated over 10 billion app downloads; over 70% of all
mobile consumer applications downloaded are mobile games Source: Gartner
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 35 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
CONNECTED TVs - GROWING OPPORTUNITY
FOR ONLINE GAMING
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
1.6 5.0
» One third of US households are expected to have connected
TVs by 2015 opening up a large potential market for online
gaming US connected TV households (millions)
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Connected TVs as a
percent of HDTVs sold
each year
—Percent of total US
households with
connected TVs
(cumulative)
© Copyright 201 I 1 Private and Confidential
9.9 16.0 23.3
32.2 43.2
Source: Forrester
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
REPRESENTS A WORLDWIDE PHENOMENON
•••,•
• •••
iff zynga.
GameStop
Microsoft
facebook
FULL
744 )
PakerStars
oPiaYlech
TriQ  PartvGANiim;
lernios.
viottoifirrnov_ z _._
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential
OUBISOFT .
cki4com
5173.COM
7wx1412' f-O.G PIIVWCT .11091.0
SHAMA GAMES
OA NrrEase
ww••1113•co•
ILN. EXCIN
NHN
SONY
(Nintendo)
DeNA.
Tencent Nig
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
CHINESE FIRMS BECOME MORE ACQUISITIVE
DUE TO GOVERNMENT'S 5-YEAR PLAN
>>
))
>)
))
China recently released its 12th 5-year plan
covering 2011 to 2015
The new plan contains a huge push towards
globalization, with a provision for 500,000 Chinese
companies to have international offices by 2015
Government wants creative companies (including
gaming firms) to increase share of GDP from less
than 2% today to 5% by 2015
Chinese gaming companies likely enter global
markets via acquisition
- This trend has already begun with Tencent's
$472M acquisition of Riot Games
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 38
Creative
Industries Share
of GDP
5%
2% I II
2011 2015 Source: China Daily
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GANIING FUND
TARGET RICH ENVIRONMENT WITH A
DIVERSE GROUP OF ACQUIRERS
Company Acquired By Category Acquisition
Price
Playdom Disney Casual Gaming $763.2M
Riot Games Tencent Free-to-Play Developer $472M
ngmoco DeNA Mobile Gaming Platform $400M
Playfish EA Casual Gaming $300M
Playspan Visa Payment System $190M
Slide Google Casual Gaming $182M
Wagerworks IGT Online Casino Gaming $90M
Mochi Media Shanda Casual Gaming Network $80M
Jambool Google Payment System $70M
$2B in M&A and financing in the trailing 12 months with activity
accelerating
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 39
Source; TheFunded
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GANIING FUND
EFT&.R1_00504791
HISTORY OF CLEARSTONE
Copy,51.1011 40 CLEARSTONE
EIFTA,1_00506792

╭──────────────────────── Page 40, Image 1 ─────────────────────────╮
│ HISTORY OF CLEARSTONE                                             │
│                                                                   │
│ CLEARSTONE                                                        │
│ © Copyright 2011 | Private and Confidential 40 ONLINE GAMING FUND │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

SOME OF OUR NOTEWORTHY INVESTMENTS
Pa,yPal
rubcori
Apture?
B i I I Desk idealab ALPTX vast
EINETZERO
O -1
Kazeon
Cigihetr.
. frame •  ibrzr
60 PEOPLE SUPPORT
©Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential
CIO
emachines
S A
* ov erture ve
Wedding
$9 NOVARIANT.
COMPOSITE
sui
eToys
GM MiStiihIl
Meru
CLEARSTONE
GAMING 1TND
THE CLEARSTONE TEAM
Team of 13 investment professionals with significant venture, operating and
technical experience
- William Quigley— Fund I, II, Ill, Online Gaming Fund
- Jim Armstrong — Fund I, II, Ill, Online Gaming Fund
— 15 yrs VC exp, UCLA, U of Texas MBA, Austin VC
— Bill Elkus — Fund I, II, Ill
— 28 yrs PE/VC exp, Harvard JD, MIT Sloan MBA, BCG
- Brock Pierce — Online Gaming Fund
- Sumant Mandal — Fund II, Ill
- 10 yrs VC exp, 7 yrs operating exp in India, Kellogg MBA
- Keith McCurdy — Online Gaming Fund
- Michael Robertson — Online Gaming Fund
- Rachid Sefrioui— Online Gaming Fund
- Louis Hsieh — Online Gaming Fund
— Vish Mishra — Fund II, Ill President of TiE
- David Stern — Fund III
— 4 yrs VC exp, Idealab, Universal, various Bay Area startups
© Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential 42 LEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING POND
HISTORICAL PERFORMANCE OF THE
CLEARSTONE FUNDS
Portfolio Investments Made 83
Number of Exits 36
Aggregate Cost of Exits $ 217M
Aggregate Proceeds on Exits $ 942M
Portfolio Companies Today 20
Aggregate Cost of All Investments $628M
Value/Cost $ 1.233B / $ 628M
IRR (Gross) Greater than 100%
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 43
Source: Overall fund performance as of December 2010
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
RECENT CLEARSTONE EXITS AND
PORTFOLIO COMPANY EVENTS
N I e R\u P/ f 1W0PKS
IbInternet
Brands
P MIMOSA I SYSTEMS
INTEGRIEN
Kazeon
© Copyright 2010 I Private and Confidential
Clearstone led Series A investment in Meru
Networks, a wireless equipment company,
went public in 2010 with a $300M market cap
Clearstone public company Internet Brands
taken private by Hellman and Friedman for
$640M
Clearstone digital content archiving
company acquired by Iron Mountain for A IRONMOUNTAIN'
$110M
Clearstone real time predictive analytics
company acquired by VMWare for $100M
Clearstone incubated eDiscovery software
company acquired by EMC for $100M
vmwa re
E MC 2where information lorry
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
EFT&.R1_00504796
RECENT CLEARSTONE EXITS AND
PORTFOLIO COMPANY EVENTS
)nokeena,,,„
rubcori
Al
e Copyright 1010 I Private and Confidential
Clearstone online media delivery company
Juniper acquired by Juniper Networks for $70M
Clearstone incubated ad network acquired
Newscorp's Fox Audience Network (FAN)
Multi-year agreement with Alcatel Lucent to be
exclusive provider of next generation cellular
backhaul technology for major US wireless
networks
45 CLEARSTONE
ONI.INI; GAMING 11:ND
PROPRIETARY INVESTMENT
OPPORTUNITIES AVAILABLE TO THE
CLEARSTONE ONLINE GAMING
FUND
46 CLEARSTONE
INVESTMENTS OPPORTUNITIES: oe xffiwE
XFIRE
>>
>>
Xfire
- Acquired Xfire from Viacom in August 2010 (Viacom paid $110M in 2006)
Xfire is the leading social gaming platform for hardcore garners
- 18m registered users with $40M invested in the Xfire infrastructure
— Growing organically at 225,000 new users per month
— Game recommendation engine and monetization platform
— Focus on the Free-to-Play games market ($7B market by 2015)
— Growing list of network partners including: Riot Games, GamersFirst,
Funcom, SGlnteractive
— Eric Schmidt and many other prolific angel investors
Opportunity to lead the Series A
- Spun out of Viacom by Brock Pierce and William Quigley
Brock Pierce, William Quigley, and John Maffei have assigned their Pro Rata
rights to the fund
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 47 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
INVESTMENTS OPPORTUNITIES:
TITAN GAMING
Titan Gaming
Titan Gaming is a skill based casual game publisher
Skill gaming is the most lucrative business model in the video game industry
Skill gaming monetizes game play by powering tournaments for cash and
virtual currency
Games may integrate and leverage the Titan Platform within 1 day
Over 150,000 hours in platform development
Over 500,000 tournament matches since launching Dec. 2 nd, 2010
Growing list of AAA network launch partners (Playdom, Lockerz, Xfire, ZAM)
Raised $1M in 2010 from Eric Schmidt and many other prolific angel
investors
Opportunity to lead the Series A
Acquired by Brock Pierce and William Quigley
Brock Pierce, William Quigley, and John Maffei have assigned their Pro Rata
rights to the fund
e. Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 48 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING ;
INVESTMENTS OPPORTUNITIES:
ITEMBAY
Itembay
— Itembay is the second largest secondary market trading platform for virtual
goods South Korea
— Itembay has systemwide revenues north of $400M annually
- Itembay is about to merge with IMI (a subsidiary of IMI Exchange) in
Korea
- Combining the businesses will substantially increase the operating
profits of both businesses by rationalizing pricing in line with other
industries
>>
Stage: Pre-IPO
Opportunity: Term sheet signed to buy 6% of the company well below market
pricing
Relationship: Brock Pierce has orchestrated the merger and is close friends
with the founder
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 49 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
INVESTMENTS OPPORTUNITIES:
IMI EXCHANGE
>> IMI Exchange
— IMI Exchange is the largest global secondary market trading platform for
virtual goods with operations in South Korea (Itemmania)and China
(SkyHi)
— IMI Exchange has systemwide revenues north of $500M annually
— Industries most experienced management team
Current Investors: Oak Investment Partners and Goldman Sachs
Stage: Pre-IPO
Opportunity: Invest in upcoming round and secondary positions
Relationship: Brock Pierce is the founder and board member
© Copyright 201 I 1 Private and Confidential 50
INVESTMENTS OPPORTUNITIES: )
REVENUE APEX RevenueAPEX
))
Revenue APEX — Financing the Internet Media and Gaming Properties
- Specialty finance business focused on a large sector that lacks access
to traditional bank financing
— Market: Internet Advertising, Gaming, Mobile Apps, and Direct
Response Marketing Industries
- Market size: $50B
— Financing mechanism: Asset based lending, invoice discounting /
factoring, business cash advance
- Double-digit IRRs available at scale
— Proprietary underwriting and origination processes developed
Opportunity to lead the Series A
- Brock Pierce and William Quigley are founders
Brock Pierce, William Quigley, and John Maffei have assigned their Pro
Rata rights to the fund
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 51 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
INVESTMENTS OPPORTUNITIES:
LATE STAGE DEALS
» Opportunity to buy secondary market shares in:
OSP' NEXDN
Piker
Stars.
Copyright 2011 1 Private and Confidential 52
GAMES
517aCOM
CLEARSTONS
ONI.INI; GAMING FUND
PLEASE CONTACT
WILLIAM QUIGLEY
FOR MORE INFORMATION
c .1011 ,Pinte•nd conaema 53 CLEARSTONE
EIFTA_R1_00504805
APPENDIX
© Copyright 201 I 1 Private and Confidential 54 CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
ONLINE GAMING VERTICALS
Copy,51.1011 56 CLEARSTONE
rUNn
EIFIA_R1_00504907

╭───────────────── Page 55, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ ONLINE GAMING VERTICALS                            │
│                                                    │
│ © Copyright 2011 | Private and Confident 55 Gee eo │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

ONLINE GAMES: $30B MARKET BY 2014
Estimated Worldwide Market
Size of Social Games $B
z'o'
s$1 ss
© Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential
Video game distribution has
shifted from console to online and
mobile
Shift has created opportunities
throughout the value chain, from
game developers, to middleware,
to distribution platforms
Companies are experiencing 2O1O profitable growth with 20% - 50% 2015
margins and YoY revenue growth
rates of 100%+
Market size expected to be
$30.6B by 2014 (21.3% CAGR)
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
ONLINE GAMES: SOCIAL NETWORKING
DRIVING MASS MARKET ADOPTION
>) Casual gaming has become one of the
world's fastest growing phenomena
Zynga has 258M MAUs
— Zynga's CityVille acquired 100MM
MAUs in 41 days
40% of Facebook users playing games
Four of the top ten Facebook
applications are games
Development costs of less than $500K
are significantly lower than console
game development costs
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 57
Source: AppData
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
MOBILE GAMES: $13B MARKET BY 2014
Mobile Games Revenue
($B)
c' 44 \ 86 O ‘7,O „zpi O (22 ‘2,O „1,O qp qp
Copyright 201 1 I Prwa ce and Confidential
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
Apple alone has generated over 10
billion app downloads from its app store
Apps = Games. 70% to 80% of all
mobile consumer applications
downloaded are mobile games, and
60% to 70% of these downloaded
games are free
Mobile gaming revenues are being
driven by micro-payments, advertising
and download fees
Mobile gaming to reach $13.1 B by 2014
(12.3% CAGR)
In Japan 53% of 2009 spending
occurred on a mobile phone
Source. Gartner & Digi-Capital
CL EARS TONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
MOBILE GAMES: FASTEST GROWING
SEGMENT OF THE ONLINE GAMING INDUSTRY
))
>)
))
>>
Developed world mobile broadband penetration
via 3G and 4G networks is increasing rapidly,
from 5% in 2005 to 51% in 2010
Globally nearly 500M people were accessing the
internet through mobile devices in 2009, up from
only 100M in 2005, projected to be 1.4B by 2014
101.2M smart-phones shipped during Q4 2010
which represented an 89% growth Y/Y
Smart-phone users spending 47% of their time
accessing maps, games, social networks,
utilities, and more
Seven out of the top ten paid apps are games
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 59
Sources: AppsFire. Canalys. International Telecommunication Union. PwC
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
MMOS: 20 MILLION GLOBAL SUBSCRIBERS
MMO Subscribers (M)
Copyright 2011 l Private and Confidential 60
MMOs have over 20M global subscribers,
and numbers are expected to reach 30M
by 2012
Slower growing historical MMO market
relied on subscription revenues
Market is shifting to browser -based
games with "freemiunn" models, a
business model that allows majority of
users free play, while the minority pay for
virtual goods with micro-payments
Market size $8B in 2010
$3.6B in revenues generated by
companies serving the South America,
North America, and European markets
in 2010 Source: Digi-Capital, MMOData.net
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
MMOS: GROWTH MARKET WITH HEAVY
USAGE
MMOs are video games with thousands of
simultaneous players
MMO gamers are the most hardcore garners,
with each player spending an average of 5.5
hours a week playing massively multiplayer
online games, compared to 4.9 hours for
console players and 4.8 for casual garners
Hardcore garners tend to be 35+ years old
and highly monetizable
Fantasy MMOs such as World of Warcraft
dominate the market, but the recent success
of other genres suggest a large greenfield
opportunity
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 61
Source: Digi-Capital, Gamesindustry.com
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING ITIND
CONSOLE & PC GAMING: RETAIL BUSINESS
TRANSITIONING ONLINE
ta 30
7N zo
a)
62 CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential
The console game market is mature,
and undergoing change as more
games are being distributed online
and via PCs
Games are coming unbundled from
traditional gaming consoles such as
Nintendo's Wii and Microsoft's Xbox.
Nevertheless, the market is expected
to grow as manufactures release
their 8'" generation platforms in 2014
The console market size is $28.2B in
2009 growing to $36.8B by 2014
(5.5% CAGR)
PC gaming market size $3.8 billion in
CLEARSTONL
ONLINE GAMING FUND
CONSOLE & PC GAMING: RETAIL
BUSINESS TRANSITIONING ONLINE
>>
54% of US households own a console or
handheld system
Nintendo's Wii currently dominates the
7th generation market with 46% unit
volume market share, followed by
Microsoft's Xbox at 28%
Next, 8th, generation of consoles to
release in 2014
Concern exists about 9th generation
consoles due to rise of downloadable
content via providers such as OnLive
PC gaming market expected to shrink
due to the meteoric rise of online games
and wireless games
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 63
Source: Nielsen & Digi-Capital
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
FREE 2 PLAY (F2P) GAMES: FREEMIUM
TREND EXPECTED TP BECOME DOMINANT
1.5
0.5
Free to Play Market ($B)
2015 2009
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 64
Market grew 89% to $250 million in
2009, up from $132 million in 2008
Revenue growth being driven by
willingness of consumers to buy
virtual goods and ease of payment
options (e.g. Visa's PlaySpan or
Facebook's Credits)
Converting free players to paying
ones is a key business model driver
Profitable conversion rates can be as
low as 9% or as high as 40%
English based F2P games: $250
million in 2009, expected to reach $2
billion by 2015 (34.1% CAGR)
Source: DFC Digi•CaPtal.
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING l'UND
FREE 2 PLAY (F2P) GAMES: FREEMIUM
TREND EXPECTED TO BECOME DOMINANT
F2P games defined as games that
require a downloadable client
Video gaming is quickly evolving to
"freemium"
- Bring players in the front door with
zero friction then monetize them
with models such as virtual goods,
offers, ads and subscriptions
A growing young gamer population who
are familiar with F2P games
Increased number of major AAA titles
and brands switching to F2P
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 65
GAME S
turbine
Source: Digi-Capital
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING I I
VIRTUAL GOODS: DOMINANT BUSINESS
MODEL FOR F2P GAMES
2.5
1.5
0.5
US Virtual Goods Market
($B)
■ 2008 2009 2010 20
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 66
The worldwide virtual goods market
is several times larger than the $1.6
billion number in the U.S. for 2010
The virtual goods market started
earlier in Asia and has continued
to skyrocket in that region
US virtual good revenues $500MM
in 2008 growing to $2.1 BB in 2011
Secondary market trading for virtual
goods is a $2.7B market in 2010,
growing to $4B by 2012
18% CAGR globally, 30% CAGR
in China
Source: Inside Network.
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
EFT&.R1_00504818
VIRTUAL GOODS: DOMINANT BUSINESS
MODEL FOR F2P GAMES
>)
Virtual goods is the dominant model for
the F2P market
58% of F2P players purchase in-game
digital goods
The median F2P expenditure on virtual
goods is $75 per person
In-game currency, virtual gifts,
weapons, and wearables are the most
popular types of virtual goods
North American women over the age
of 25 are spending the most money on
virtual goods
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 67
O playspan
5173.COM
Source: VGMarket, PlaySpan
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
SKILL GAMING: REAL MONEY WAGERING
IS A GROWING TREND
Online Skill Gaming Market
($B)
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential
2010 2014
>>
))
>)
Skill games are competitive
online games, where winning is
determined by skill rather than
chance
Skill games are by definition not
games of chance, enabling
them to operate in U.S.,
European and Asia-Pacific
markets
Skill based market targets
women 35+ years old
Online skill gaming market
generating $382M globally in
2009, expected to rise to $472M
in 2010, and $957M by 2014
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
SKILL GAMING: RESEMBLANCE TO
SUCCESSFUL ONLINE GAMBLING BUT LEGAL
>>
>>
>>
Online skill games include a variety of business
models: scaled commission fee (rake), entry fees
for tournaments, interest on players fund invested
and micro-transactions
Skill-based gaming fits perfectly in these over
arching industry trends and has an extremely high
ARPU
Wagering between friends is already prevalent
— but inconvenient
Fastest emerging business model in Asia
- 20% of video game revenue in Taiwan
generated by skill gaming
— 10% of video game revenue in China generated
by skill gaming
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 69
n , f *441
-ntrt9 scorn
A / 0,, v 1 0,1 I An," rio ell
I= OP OW
a V R
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
ONLINE GAMBLING: ENORMOUS MARKET
POISED FOR LONG TERM GROWTH
$40.0
$35.0
$30.0
$25.0
$20.0
$15.0
$10.0
$5.0
Global Online Gaming Yield ($B)
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010E 2011E 2012E
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 70
The U.S. outlawed online gambling
in 2006, making Europe the largest
legal online gambling market
Regardless of legality, 2008 Internet
gambling revenue for offshore
companies was estimated to be
$5.9B from players in the U.S. and
$21 B from players worldwide
» The global legal online and offline
gambling market totaled $335B in
Online gambling's share of the total
gaming market to reach 9%
penetration and increase to $34
billion by 2012 (11% CAGR between
2008 and 2012) CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
ONLINE GAMBLING: ENORMOUS MARKET
POISED FOR LONG TERM GROWTH
>)
>)
))
Online gambling uses the Internet and
mobile devices to enable wagering, casino
games, poker, lotteries, and bingo
Continues to cannibalize offline gambling
and surpassed offline in terms of growth
Currently legal in many parts of the world
today and legislation in the US likely to
open some or all of the largest gambling
market in the world
Live online casino and inplay sports betting
has increased at a CAGR of over 172%
since 2006
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 71
Piker
Stars. CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
GAMIFICATION: INCORPORATING GAMING
MECHANICS INTO BUSINESS MODELS
>>
))
>)
New industries emerging utilizing
gaming as a business model rather
than a product
Gaming is one of the most lucrative
business models and can be applied
to other industries
Game mechanics are being
incorporated into many products to
increase engagement
Facebook is interesting because of
games
Lottery mechanics being combined
with e-commerce with companies like
Bidfire, Swoopo, and Big Deals
CD Copyright 2011 I Private and Confidential 72
D BigDeal
CLEARSTONE
ONLINE GAMING FUND
EFTA00005711 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2011-03-17)
Embassy of
the United States of America
Office of
the Legal Attache
US Consulate
Sydney NSW 2000
Tel.
File No. 31E-MM-108062
14 March 2011
Coordinator
International Network Coordination and Support Team (INCS)
Serious & Organised Crime
Australian Federal Police
Canberra, ACT Australia
Via email:
Interview of U.S. Citizen
Dear Mr.
Re:
The Federal Bureau of Investigation Miami Field Office (FBI Miami) is
assisting the Palm
Beach Police Department in Florida with an ongoing investigation into JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, a US
citizen.. Along with associates, EPSTEIN is believed to have manipulated underage
girls from local
high schools to perform massages and sexual acts at his residence. The victims were
usually recruited
by other underage females and after performing various acts were paid sums of money
in the $200-
$1000 . Investigation in Miami identified a victim named married
name
born is a U.S. citizen and the victim of
a sex
crime; she is not considered a subject, nor is she facing charges in the
investigation described below.
FBI Miami believes was working at a local resort when she was
approached to
meet EPSTEIN at his residence. agreed and soon began traveling with EPSTEIN
to
various locations outside the state of Florida. Several witness have corroborated
travel
with EPSTEIN. FBI Miami also has evidence EPSTEIN paid and provided her an
apartment in exchange for sex. In addition to the accounts of travel, FBI Miami has
obtained a witness
statement from one of EPSTEIN's victims. This victim, who was 14 at the time of the
incident,
observed EPSTEIN have sexual intercourse with who was 17 at the time.
EPSTEIN later
indicated to this victim that was in and had started a family of
her own.
In 2008, FBI Miami conducted investigation which determined was residing in
Australia.
Accordingly, FBI Miami coordinated with the FBI Legal Attache Office in
Canberra for a letter to be delivered to notifying her she was a victim of
a crime.
is believed by FBI Miami
Valley, New
South Wales 2261, telephone
On 03/04/2011,
(USAO) in West
Palm Beach, Florida and expressed her willingness to speak further with
investigators about her
activities with EPSTEIN. In further conversations with the USAO, indicated
EPSTEIN
had instructed her to have sex with numerous associates in the both the United
States and overseas.
identified several subjects by name and indicated she had records to support
her
allegations. further advised she could identify several other women that
were underage and
had engaged in sexual situations with EPSTEIN. Finally,
personnel to
the U.S. Consulate in Sydney, Australia on Thursday, 17 March 2011, to be
interviewed in detail and
to provide copies of the records she possesses regarding the above investigation.
, Glenning to currently reside at
, email
contacted the United States Attorney's Office
agreed to meet FBI
REQUEST OF AFP
The AFP is respectfully notified that FBI Miami intends to fly two
agents familiar with the
details of the above investigation to Sydney, Australia. These agents will meet
at the U.S.
Consulate in Sydney, Australia to conduct an in-depth interview on Thursday, 17
March 2011
regarding the investigation described above. FBI personnel may contact via
her mobile
telephone number of for final coordination of the interview. FBI
personnel will not
otherwise conduct operational activity in this investigation.
Please refer to the above captioned Legal Attache file number when
contacting this office
regarding this matter. Inquiries and/or responses should be directed to Assistant
Legal Attache
office telephone number Ma, mobile telephone number
or e-mail addresa.
be sent via e-mail.
As always your assistance in this matter is greatly appreciated.
It is requested that written responses
Sincerely yours,
Legal Attache
By:
Assistant Legal Attache
EFTA00005714 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2011-03-17)
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 03/22/2011
To: Criminal Investigative Attn:
Violent Crime Section
CAC Unit
International Operations Attn:
Asia Unit
Miami Attn:
Squad PB-2
From: Canberra
Sydney Sub Office
Contact:
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID ii: 31E-MM-108062 (Pending)
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
GHISLAINE MAXWELL;
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Synopsis: To document liaison and investigation in Australia
and to cover lead set in referenced serial.
Reference: 31E-MM-108062 Serial 235
Details: On 03/12/2011 in referenced serial, Miami provided
an overview of captioned matter and advised
(PROTECT IDENTITY), a victim of captioned subjects, currently
resides in Australia. On 03/04/2011, had contacted
the United States Attorney's Office in West Palm Beach,
Florida to express willingness to provide information
pertinent to captioned matter.
An interview of was subsequently arranged to
occur at the U.S. Consulate in Sydney, Australia. Miami
conducted coordination for and
1111to travel to Sydney to conduct the interview of
Miami set a lead in referenced serial for Canberra
to facilitate the interview of in Australia.
On 03/14/2011, Canberra developed a letter to the
Australian Federal Police (AFP) advising of an FBI interview
of to take place at the U.S. Consulate in Sydney,
Australia on 03/17/2011. The writer contacted
, Coordinator, AFP International Network
Coordination and Support Team, via telephone and confirmed AFP
awareness and concurrence for this interview.
On 03/16/2011, Sydney Sub-Office personnel briefed
and on logistical arrangements made for
the interview of On 03/17/2011, and II
conducted the interview of at the U.S.
Consulate, Sydney. Following the interview,
advised the writer had photos at her residence which
could be pertinent to captioned matter. was willing
to be further interviewed at her residence and provide the
photos.
On 03/17/2011, the writer telephonically contacted
regarding FBI agents conducting a further interview
of at her residence. concurred with this
course of action. The writer, and then
traveled to residence, , Glenning
Valley, New South Wales, Australia, completed the additional
interview and obtained the relevant photos.
Canberra considers covered the lead set in
referenced serial.
LEAD(s):
Set Lead 1: (Info)
ALL RECEIVING OFFICES
Read and clear.
* *
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Virginia Giuffre [girls] one of Epstein's first public accusers, died by suicide 
                                            Gul'sum Osmanova [russian girl] (???) 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01699136 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Virginia Giuffre and other victims, "Turkish girl" might be Gul'sum Osmanova
(date: 2011-03-17)
Serials hups://sentinel.fbinetfbi/apps/casemgmt/index-serialsprevieochtml?...
manager. described the ranch manager as a white male, 30-
40 years of age, dark hair and dressed like a cowboy. When she
arrived at the ranch, there was some discussion about where she
was going to stay on the property and Epstein made it clear that
she would be staying with them. stated she was the only
guest at the ranch other than the staff. surmised Epstein
and Maxwell were a couple, because of their interactions and
behaviors.
During her visit, Epstein and Maxwell took to •
town for some shopping. They purchased food, hair wash and other
miscellaneous products to include a pair of cowboy boots. The
price of the cowboy boots was over $100.00. They spent a
significant amount of time horse back riding on the ranch.
During the evenin Epstein asked i would provide him a
foot massage. was taken back by the request and Maxwell
agreed to give a demonstration. Initially, Maxwell was
rubbing one foot the other. Eventually, Maxwell
concluded her demonstration and was doing it alone. During
the foot massage, Epstein, Maxwell and. were making small
talk. At one point, Epstein asked if she had ever had a
massage. stated th e had not, and Maxwell stood up and
stated she would give one (meaning a massage). Maxwell
lead to a room with a massage table set up. Maxwell told
to take her clothes off and get on the table. felt
uncomfortable with removing her clothing; however, she did so
leaving only her underwear on. wrapped herself in a sheet
and laid down on the massage table. remembers observirs
several massage oils In the room. Maxwell began massaging
on her back and legs. Sometime during the massage, Maxwell
instructed to roll over and Maxwell pulled down the sheet,
exposing her breasts. Epstein was always near by and continued
to hold a conversation with throughout the massage.
was very self-conscious and uncomfortable with Epstein looking
at her exposed body. Epstein asked. if she liked the
massage by stating "aren't massages great." Maxwell corn leted
the massage by rubbing her upperad No
other sexual activity occurred and removed herself from
the table and got dressed.
The next morning, E stein came into her room and got
into bed with her. was wearing her pajamas and Epstein was
wearing sweat pants and a. tee shirt. Epstein got under the
covers and stated he felt like 'cuddling". During the cuddling,
Epstein was constantly hugging and "spooning" her. Epstein spent
some time talking about what they were going to do that day.
Maxwell did enter the room and observe Epstein in the bed and
under the covers with
During that day, Es and Maiwell took. on a
tour of the ranch. remembers there being some type of old
western set located on the ranch. Additionally, Maxwell assisted
with her term paper for one of her high school classes and
3 of 5 II/30/2018 12:19 PM
Serials https://sentinel.fbinet.fbi/apps/casemgmt/index-serialspreview.html?...
complete some note cards. The chef prepared dinner and all three
ate together..ln the evening, Epstein and Maxwell took.. to
a movie, Primal Fear. While waiting for the movie, Epstein and
Maxwell were acting very silly and overly sexual with each
other. Byway of explanation, explained, they were
continually poking, playing and touching each other. Once inside
the movie, they purchased  and cokes while Epstein sat
between Maxwell and During the movie, Epstein reached
.over and held hand. Epstein continually stroked and
caressed her
held
point, he placed his hand on her thigh
leaving it there for an extended period of time.
After returning to the ranch that night, stated
Epstein came into her room and sat on the bed with her. Epstein
stoked her hair and told her how beautiful and pretty she was.
At this point in the interview. became visible disturbed
and was unable to recall the remainder of events for that
evening at the ranch. Before she left the ranch, Epstein
provided with a pair of his sweat pants.
After returning home to Phoenix, Epstein called at
least once to see how she was doing. During the summer of the
captioned year, Epstein and Maxwell sent, via mail, a ticket and
several hundred dollars to for her travel to Th i nd.
explained that she volunteered for an
organization providing North American youths an opportunity to
volunteer in community service overseas.
explained she never told anyone initially,
because th e did not want to mess things up for I=S
who was employed by Epstein. She further explained that
she very young and did not want to ruin her sponsored summer
trip volunteering for Additionally, she thought
of Epstein and Maxwell as role models and parental figures.
Indexing V
No Entities to display.
Intelligence
Potential IIRISIR? No
Sentinel Tags: No Sentinel Tags Selected
4 of 5 11/30/2018 12:19 PM
Serials https://sentinel.fbinedbi/apps/casemgmt/index-serialspreview.lam I?...
Can you identify the No
source of this
information?
Routing V
Drafted By:
5 of 5 11/30/2018 12:19 PM
Serials • https://sentinel.fbinetibi/apps/caseingmt/index-serialspreview.html?...
MAI \Ike k (f eSV'S
Filing and Security
Primary Case: 31E-MM-108062 Case Title: (U) EPSTEIN,
JEFFREY I=
MI/ Serial Number: 119
Serialized: 08/07/2007
Category: Full Investigation
Initiated: 07/25/2006
Details
Serial #: 119 Type: FD302
From: To: MIAMI
Document Title: INTERVIEW OF
Approval Date: 8/7/2007
Classification: SN
Contents 08/13/2007
Pursuant to a federal investigation regarding the sexual
exploitation of minors, IM=INES was interviewed
by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). After being advised
of the identi of the interviewing agents and purpose of the
interview, voluntarily provided the following information:
at age El was introduced to Jeffrey Epstein by
a year old girl named Last Name Unknown LNU
be n dating n December 2000
former boyfriend and father of her child, was friends
with o riendMILNU. Soon after= began
datin approached at a party and asked
her if th e would like to make $300.00: explained that
= could make $300.00 by providing a man in Palm Beach with a
massage.
told she could make a lot of money real
fast. She needed to dress sexy and provide a massage for an hour
I of 5 11/30/2018 12:14 PM
Serials https://sentinel.thinet.fbilappsicasemgmt/index-serialspreview.html?...
and she would make 5300.00. told that Epstein
might ask her to remove her shirt but she could keep her bra on.
told "If you don't like something let me know -
told she would massage Epstein with her
met Epstein for the first time when she traveled
to his Palm Beach residence with noticed an
older lady with short black hair and an unknown accent at Epstein's
residence. led to the upstairs steam room area
of the residence. and met Epstein upstairs. he
was wearing only a towel. Epstein told she was pretty.
Epstein asked her age. uttered lour" and then
said 17. Epstein responded by saying, so you are fourteen."
was previously instructed by to tell Epstein she
was 17. He told that they would not tell anyone
and simultaneously performed the
massage on Epstein. massaged his legs while
massaged his back Ten to 20 minutes prior to the end of the
massage. Epstein stated to
"take off your pants "
to her bra and panties. Epstein asked
massage table at which time he reached for
sat on a couch
located in Epstein's steam room area. As
watched. and Epstein
table which was located directly in front of the couch where
was seated E stein and
as they were Epstein paid
of the massage.Epstein also asked
number.
"take off your shirr and
got naked and undressed
to walk around the
on the massage
were looking at
$300.00 at the end
for her cell phone
stated has been missing for a long
time. On one occasion. Epstein indicated to
was in Thailand and has started a family of her own
that
obtained Epstein's phone number frnm a telephone
book and called to schedule a massage session by leaving a message
with LNU. Epstein returned call.
On second visit to E stein's residence, her
former boyfnen ove her to Epstein's residence.
aited in the car while entered the residence
alone. ihas met Epstein on one occasion. She sat in the
kitchen and the chef asked if she was hungry. le was there and
led her upstairs. IM placed towels on the massage table.
disrobed to her underwear and massaged Epstein. Epstein
was paid touched
$300.00 at the conclusion of the massage.
went to Epstein's residence over 100 times for
approximately three years beginning when she was years old. She
regularly used Yellow Cab to travel to Epstein's residence In
2 of 5 11/30/20113 12:14 PM
Serials https://sentinclibinct.tbi/apps/cascmgmt/index-scrialsprevicw.htmr...
would call from New York to schedule the massage
appointments for Epstein. Massage appointments were usually
scheduled for the evening. removed her bra during every
massage session after her second visit. Near the end of the
massage sessions Epstein would ask to undress. Epstein
would ask. "Are you going to get comfortable" At a later occasion
he stated. "Why are you going to keep your panties on?" He offered
her an additional $100.00 for her to remove her panties.
was paid $400.00 on two occasions.
Of all the massageS provided to Epstein. only
three were "r •ular' massages. The others involved. at a minimum.
Epstein E stein re uested
stated Epstein has a hairy bod and that
Epstein's
never touched Epstein'..
During a massage session which took place a couple of
months after first visit, Epstein introduced an
unidentified female to He stated "I'd like you to meet
my friend." and the unknown female both got down on their
knees on the floor and the unidentified female began
as Epstein
The unidentified female didn't speak
much English and was described as being tan and having dark brown
hair. stated she would recognize the unidentified female.
Epstein has touched
Epstein did not
on two occasions and both times backed away from him. On
one occasion. Epstein attempted to
and she told him. 'We aren't doing all that."
wanted the money but did not want Epstein to touch her
took Xanax to ease her anxiety. also stated that she
smoked marijuana and used cocaine during the time period she was
providing massages in. After
Epstein to  began paying her $200 00 for the
did not allow
massage sessions.
According to if a girl felt uncomfortable and
did not want to comply with Epstein's requests he would ask them to
bring other girls. He asked "Do you have any friends
that might be interested." He also asked if she had any
younger friends. Epstein paid.. $100.00 for each girl she
brought.
LNU, age 22. went to Epstein's residence one time.
Epstein tried to get her to remove her clothing. She was
uncomfortable with the situation and only stayed for half an hour.
M INU was paid $200.00. Epstein did not express any further
interest inaLNU.
3 of 5 11/30/2018 12:14 PM
Serials https://sentinel.fbinetfbi/apps/easemgmt/index-serialsPreview.html?...
received gifts from Epstein to include
Victoria's Secret bras and underwear, massage oils and a took
titled "Massage for Dummies." The items were sent to.. by
Epstein via FedEx when she lived at Suwanee Drive, West Palm Beach,
Florida. Epstein also gave two tickets to a concert
featuring the band Incubus at the Sound Advice Amphitheater.
called to inform her that Epstein left the concert tickets
for her. Two older ladles brought the tickets to
at the amphitheater.
voluntarily provided the "Massage for
Dummies" book she had received from Jeffrey Epstein to the
interviewing agents. A cop of the executed FD-597 Receipt for
Property was provided to and the original FD-597 was
placed in a 1A envelope of case-file. The items provided
was entered into evidence.
Epstein offered to take to Paris, France. He
told her he had to go to Paris for business and asked her If she
wanted to come with him. She declined the offer.
stole $200.00 from E stein one da to "get back
at him` for making her friend, feel uncomfortable.
was uncomfortable because she was left alone with Epstein
during a massage.session after Epstein requesteds to leave.
left with $500.00 including
did not know the extent
were
had an affair
was paid $300.00 and
the extra $200.00 she had taken.
of s interaction with Epstein.
best friends but their rela en
with boyfrien
recruited Last Name Unknown(LNU) to provide
massages to Epstein. stated a LNU has a El
went to Epstein's residence once watts LNU.
didnot know the extent of LNU's interaction with Epstein but
believed more may have happened between LNU and Epstein.
ME
LNU's mother worked In
On one occasion, when was approximately years
old, called and told her Epstein wanted to
talfi ol t raphs of her. took a series of nude otographs
o at Epstein's Palm Beach residence.
the pool, by the intracoastal waterway, in the Ilvl
upstairs bathroom and in the balcony area.
camera to take the photographs. was paid $500.00 for
posing but never received any of the photographs. also
indicated to that Epstein takes pictures of the girls.
Although never observed any hidden cameras at E stein's
residence, she felt like there were hidden cameras there.
stated that Epstein had many laptop computers.
posed by
room, in the
used a digital
stopped going to Epstein's residence because she
had other things to do that were more important to her. She stated
she always felt dirty when she left Epstein's residence.
4 of 5 11/30/2018 12:14 P/v1
Serials httpS://sentinelaineMbi/appsicasemgmt/index-serialspreview.html?...
She felt that she was
taken advantage of. Epstein told
never tell on her.
he would
heard rumors that there were people watching
Epstein's residence from a house across the street.
At age `_`and subsequently
traveled to Georgia in June 2003. Her
N st.1 a friend ol=M brought a girl
named *LNU to provide a massage to Epstein. never met
MU.
provided the following telephone numbers:
Mother's cell, Possible former house:
cell, ; AEI
Stepfather
email address is
mentioned that during one of her visits to .
Epstein's residence she spoke to Michael Jackson over the
telephone.
Indexing
Intelligence
No Entities to display.
Potential IIR/SIR? No
Sentinel Tags: No Sentinel Tags Selected
Can you identity the No
source of this
information?
Routing
Drafted By:
V
5 of 5 11/30/2018 12:14 PM
Serials https://sentinel.fbinetibi/appskasemgmt/index-serialspreview.html?...
Filing and Security
Primary Case: 31E-MM-108062
Serial Number 162
Serialized: 05/31/2008
Category: Full Investigation
Initiated: 07/25/2006
Case Title: (U) EPSTEIN,
JEFFREY
Details V
Serial #: 162 Type: EC
From: NEW YORK To: MIAMI
Document Title: TO DOCUMENT SERVICE OF GRAND JURY SUBPOENA TO l=
Approval Date: 5/31/2008
Classification: SN
Contents
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 05/31/2008
To: Miami Ann: PB-2/PBCRA
SA
From: New York
C-20
Contact:
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062 (Pending)
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
GHISLAINE N. MAXWELL;
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION;
I of 3 I I 130/2018 II:09 AM
Serials https://sentinel.thinet.fbi/apps/easemgmt/index-serialspreview.html?...
Synopsis: To document service of Grand Jury Subpoena to
Enclosure(s): For the Miami Division the following documents
have been enclosed:

1. One original and two copies of FD-302 reflecting
interview with dated 05/29/2008.
2. One original Grand Jury Subpoena return dated
05/29/2008 in a 1-A envelope.
Details: On May 29, 2008, Special Agents (SAs)
and of the Federal Bureau of Investigation
(FBI) met with IMM. at her residence at 4103 31st
Avenue, Astoria, New York.
IMS was advised of the identity of the interviewing
agents and before a ants could state the purpose of the
interview, stated she did not want to speak to the agents
and wanted to speak to her attorney. then provided
agents with her attorneys business card. attorney as
listed on the business card is
Law Firm New York, NY 10075, telephone
number
Agents explained they were not there to arrestIMF
and stated she was not a target of any FBI investigation bu: were
there to interview She was then provided with a copy of
a Grand Jury Subpoena issued by the Southern District of Florida,
United States District Court, 701 Clemantis Street, West Palm
Beach, Florida 33401 to appear before the grand jury on Jine 3,
2008.
MI stated that she would speak to her attorney and
understood the consequences of not showing up to the rand jury
in Florida. Agents provided contact information for
should th e later want to contact agents regarding this matter.
It should be noted that . did call SA
later that same day and stated she wanted to know why agents
wanted to talk to her so that she in turn could consult her
attorney in this matter. SA re ied that this was
regarding JEFFREY EPSTEIN. SA then asked well
you are familiar with JEFFREY EPSTEIN right?, then
answered "OK...", and then asked about travel arrangements to
Florida for grand jury.
MS was then referred to the printed material that
was included with the subpoena regarding her travel and answered
questions..= added that her
was in town and her uncle was also supposed to visit and stay
2 of 3 11/30/2018 11.09 AM
Serials https://sentinel.fbinetibi/appskasemgint/index-serialspreview.html?...
with her but she would do her best to make arrangements for them.
She added that her husband (last name not provided) would
probably be traveling with her. provided no further
information at this time.
The return of service for the Grand Jury Subpoena was
placed in a 1-A envelope.
Indexing
Intelligence
No Entities to display.
Potential IIR/SIR? No
Sentinel Tags: • No Sentinel Tags Selected
Can you identify the No
source of this
information?
Routing
Drafted By:
Approved By: •
V
V
3 of 3
11/30/2018 11:09 AM
PD-3020tms440 -1 of 12-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
-
4

•
Onactat..Bccoal
Diadem ,/  07/05/2013
maiden name IIIIIII, date of birth
Social Security Account Number , United States Citizen and
Australian Permanent Resident, residence
was interviewed at the United States
Consulate in Sydney, Australia. was advised of the identity of the
interviewing agents and purpose of the interview. Present during the
interview was Federal Bureau of Investigation Special Agent
husband, and via telephone, Assistant
United States Attorney provided the
following information:
was born in Sacramento, California to parents
e
and
father, IIIIIIIIIII date of birth
currently resides in California and her mother, date of birth
currently resides in Colorado. moved to Palm
Beach County, Florida with her parents when she was four years old and
returned to California at a e 11. She returned to Flo ida at age 'Nand
was in West Palm Beach,
Flo .
she was
approximately years old, and while living on the streets in Miami,
Florida, she met R0N EPPINGER. EPPINGER was in his 60's and owned an
escort service called "The Perfect 10." EPPINGER recruited young
Yugoslavian females to become escorts and would arrange for them to obtain
fraudulent United States passports. . EPPINGER had seven to nine females
between the ages of 16 and 24 living with him at his three bedroom
apartment in downtown Miami, Florida. EPPINGER had a modeling agency that
helped him recruit young females, and he was not shy about producing
pornography. EPPINGER frequently produced pornography of lesbian sexual
activity. EPPINGER liked young girls and kept them on a specific diet to
keep them thin. EPPINGER engaged in sexual activity with from the
first day they met throughout their four to six month relationship.
EPPINGER was training to be an escort and referred to her as. "his
baby." EPPINGER.gave a life off of the streets which made her feel
Investigation on 03/17/2011  at Sydney, Australia (In Person)
Fikg 31E-MI4-108062
bY II
Date dratted 07/05/2013

FD-302a (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of ,on 03/17/2011 ,page 2 of 12
like she was locked into the relationship. EPPINGER gave
pharmaceutical drugs toward the end of their relationship.
EPPINGER was well connected in wealthy social circles and had many
famous clients. Some of the clients would take the escorts to a club or
dinner before engaging in sexual activity with the women. Some clients
were known to rent yachts as a place to take the women.
relationship with EPPINGER ended while she was at a private
ranch near Ocala, Florida. telephonically contacted a childhood
friend from a telephone at the ranch.
knew from elementary school and called him at the home telephone
of and told she was
very lonely, and asked her why she did not leave EPPINGER.
EPPINGER learned of telephone conversation with and
became angry. EPPINGER entered the recreational vehicle (RV) was
staying in at the ranch and yelled, "What are you doing to me?" He did not
strike her but was loud and intimidating toward her. He had someone pack
her belongings and told her she was going to live with another man.
EPPINGER sent her by limousine to a man she knew as Charlie LNU whc was
the owner of the club HOT CHOCOLATES in Fort Lauderdale, Florida.
felt that she was sent to CHARLIE LNU as a favor but did not know the
specifics of the arrangement. engaged in sexual activity with
CHARLIE LNU who was described as a white male in his 40's. stated
CHARLIE LNU was aware of her true age. stayed with CHARLIE LNU for
approximately one or two weeks before the police located her and returned
her to her parents. was interviewed by a male detective.
parents were still married at the time and lived near Royal Palm
Beach, Florida. believed there was an FBI investigation related to
EPPINGER and that he fled the country. She never saw EPPINGER again after
he transported her to CHARLIE LNU.
In approximately June 1998 or 1999, began working at Donald
Trump's Mar-A-Lego Club in Palm Beach, Florida. father worked at
Mar-A-Lago as a and was able to hel her ain
employment as a and later as a at the
club. started studying for her GED and wanted to become a massage
therapist. In August, was reading an anatomy/massage book and was
approached by GHISLAINE MAXWELL at Mar-A-Lago. MAXWELL explained that she was looking for a traveling masseuse. MAXWELL 
offered to pay her $200 per
hour and help her get her masseuse accreditation. MAXWELL explained that she and her companion, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, 
traveled around the world.
consulted her father about the opportunity and at approximately
5:00 p.m. the same day, her father drove her to a residence at El Brillo
FD-302.2 (Rev. 05-03:10)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of ion 03/17/2011 Jona  3 of 12
Way, Palm Beach, Florida. MAXWELL spoke with father and told him
it was a wonderful opportunity for met the housekeepers,
and also known as JOHN and MARY. was led
upstairs by MAXWELL and observed numerous photographs throughout the house
of young women in the nude or wearing bikinis. Some of the photographs
appeared to be professional and others were snapshots. All of the women in
the photographs were beautiful and described as model types.
Once upstairs in EPSTEIN's'bedroom, EPSTEIN was already on the massage
table lying on his stomach face down. EPSTEIN was nude or partially covered
with a towel. MAXWELL instructed to wash her hands prior to
beginning the massage. The massage began and MAXWELL demonstrated massage •
techniques to
During the course of the massage, MAXWELL and EPSTEIN questioned
about her past, including her was also
asked if she took birth control.
EPSTEIN then rolled over onto his back on the massage table and was
completely nude. MAXWELL undressed and began to undress EPSTEIN
and MAXWELL laughed at the printed pattern of underwear.
was given instruction and be an and
. Both
MAXWELL and EPSTEIN MAXWELL also
on engaged in with
EPSTEIN, whereby EPSTEIN while he lay on his back on the
massa e table with
continued until EPSTEIN neared the
facing him. EPSTEIN did not wear The
Just
prior to EPSTEIN and
EPSTEIN
At the conclusion, MAXWELL instructed to obtain two warm wash
clothes. One wash cloth was used to clean EPSTEIN's and the
second was to be laid on his enital area to hel him relax.
described EPSTEIN's EPSTEIN
and then moved to the steam room and shower where massaged
EPSTEIN's feet and cleaned him with soap and a loofah in the shower.
At the conclusion of the shower, went downstairs and MAXWELL
paid $200.00 in cash which believed was obtained from a
black duffel bag from EPSTEIN's office. was also present.
Arrangements were made for to return to the house the following day after work: cellular phone number was given to 
EPSTEIN and
MAXWELL.
F13.302; (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of .On 03/17/2011 .page 4 of 12
. The same routine and pattern of massages and sexual activity between
EPSTEIN, MAXWELL, and continued for between one and two weeks. At
times, MAXWELL on The
were pink or black in color and were
EPSTEIN's bed. EPSTEIN and MAXWELL offered
job at Mar-A-Lago and travel with EPSTEIN full
was also discussion of receiving massa
be paid $200.00 per day for travel and $200.00
Early in her relationship with EPSTEIN,
was 17 years old at the time.
England and was introduced as MAXWELL's assistant.
kept in a drawer near
the option to quit her
time as his masseuse. There
ge training. was to
per hour for massages.
met who
was from an area outside of London,
soon began traveling with EPSTEIN. For the initial six months,
traveled with EPSTEIN around the United States and Caribbean,
including California, New York City, New Mexico, and various business
trips. During those trips, EPSTEIN continued to engage in sexual acts with
Six to nine months after began working for EPSTEIN, EPSTEIN
informed that she would get her first massage client. was
introduced to III LNU former model, and her husband, in
Palm Beach Florida. LNU was a former girlfriend of EPSTEIN's and was
met the couple at a condominium next to the
Breakers hotel. The condominium was bought for LNU by EPSTEIN and was a
unit that required the use of a elevator to access it. In the condominium,
provided a normal massage to LNU. Shortly thereafter, IIIILNU
went to sleep in another room and provided an erotic massage to
undressed and on
and also engaged in with
cleaned in a similar fashion as she cleaned EPSTEIN. She was
paid cash by totaling several hundred dollars. In addition, EPSTEIN
paid for her encounter with the following day. was 16
years old at the time she with
advised that introduced her to the drug Xanax.
She explained that Xanax helped her escape from reality but allowed her to
still function normally. Xanax helped her go forward with what she was
doing with EPSTEIN and others. Her habit went from two pills per day up to
eight pills per day.
second client was an academic of some sort described as an
older American male with a white beard and glasses. EPSTEIN sent
from Miami International Airport to his private island in the United States
Virgin Islands (USVI) by commercial airline. was picked up at the
airport by MILES ALEXANDER and then taken to the island by boat.
FD402aUtoo.05-08-IM
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of .O, 03/17/2011 .page 5 of 12
pointed out that GHISLAINE MAXWELL had a helicopter that she would
frequently fly in the USVI. EPSTEIN instructed to entertain the
client as if she was the man's girlfriend. The client was goofy and wanted
to ride jet skis and participate in other island activities besides the
sexual activity that was expected. spent two days on the island
with the client. assumes the client also traveled to the USVI
commercially.
During the following several months, traveled internationally
with EPSTEIN. Prior to her traveling abroad, EPSTEIN assisted in
getting her passport. got passport photographs of herself and
provided them to EPSTEIN. The remaining paperwork was taken care of by
EPSTEIN or someone on his behalf. traveled to Paris, France, the
South of France, London, England, Africa, and Spain. While in Paris,
recalled staying at a hotel overlooking the Champs-Elysees.. While
traveling with EPSTEIN, traveled on EPSTEIN's private planes
including a 727 aircraft and a black plane. During the international
travel, EPSTEIN and engaged in sexual activity in all locations. At
times, would engage in sexual activity with EPSTEIN and other
girls, and at times, she would while EPSTEIN was
present. Rarely a day would pass where EPSTEIN and would not engage
in some type of sexual contact.
"Mail on Sunday" journalist SHARON CHURCHER contacted through
girlfriend, MMand explained that she was following
the JEFFREY EPSTEIN case and wanted to talk to S about EPSTEIN,
MAXWELL, and PRINCE ANDREW (ANDREW ALBERT CHRISTIAN EDWARD), DUKE OF YORK.
CHURCHER told that she wanted a quick story about PRINCE ANDREW and
offered a contract. agreed to the contract for her story
and was paid $140,000 for the story, $10,000 when the article was printed,
and another $10,000 to be wired into account in May 2011. The
contract prevented from talking to any other press for a specified
period. advised that she provided CHURCHER with detailed
information that she did not believe CHURCHER would publish.
met after began working .for EPSTEIN.
was one of EPSTEIN's very close girls, though she was not around
EPSTEIN as much as frequently traveled with EPSTEIN and
was pursuing an acting career in California. EPSTEIN got rid of
because she had a cocaine habit. One of the house maids at EPSTEIN's
island found cocaine, and EPSTEIN sent back to the UNITED STATES.
was a couple of years older that
One of EPSTEIN's associates, JEAN LUC BRUNEL, was a model recruiter and was frequently around EPSTEIN. BRUNEL would 
bring girls to EPSTEIN. Many
FD-302a (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E—MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of tom 03/17/2011 jaw  6 of 12
of the girls BRUNEL brought to EPSTEIN had poor English language skills and
appeared to be very young. estimated some of the girls were as
young as 16 years old. The young girls were promised modeling contracts or
acting careers.
EPSTEIN promised an acting career. At age 16,
met at a blue waterfront beach cottage in Malibu, California that
EPSTEIN had purchased for believed she and were
approximately the same age. and had a sexual encounter as
directed by EPSTEIN. i was also recruiting additional females for
EPSTEIN. On the taxi ride back to the airport, EPSTEIN bragged that he had
just purchased a girl from her mother. The girl was Czechoslovakian or
Yugoslavian, and her father had recently passed away. EPSTEIN owned a
residence in the Los Angeles area near a famous former model. He had also
purchased residences for other unknown females.
EPSTEIN was very selective and preferred young, compliant, beautiful,
fun girls with no tattoos or piercings. EPSTEIN did not like African •
American females. EPSTEIN liked to be nurtured, and would dress
him, rub his toes, and brush his hair. EPSTEIN did not want to ask for
what he wanted.
A Turkish girl named frequently traveled with EPSTEIN.
in love with EPSTEIN. was say rself and would not
with EPSTEIN. Although would not
she would frequently engage in with EPSTEIN.
became jealous of and EPSTEIN ended his relationship with
If a girl became clingy and exhibited feelings for EPSTEIN, he would end
the relationship.
EPSTEIN wanted to have a child.with
the he wished to continue to be with other women. provided an
erotic massage to in New York,
were close friends and had regular contact.
creep.
was
though EPSTEIN explained
New York. EPSTEIN and
described as a
An unknown individual sent EPSTEIN three 12 year-old girls from France
as a birthday gift. saw the three girls when she arrived at
EPSTEIN's Palm Beach residence. The girls provided EPSTEIN with an erotic
massage. IIIIIII had foreplay with the girls as directed by EPSTEIN.
said that day was a low stage in her relationship with EPSTEIN
because she could not believe EPSTEIN's excited expression. The young girls
seemed to have been re ed for w ' ' EPSTEIN. The 12 year-old girls had never
FD-302a (Rev. 05.0&I0)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of 03/17/2011 page 7 of 12
saw the girls again. believed the girls may have been provided by
JEAN LUC BRUNEL because BRUNEL was at the residence at the time, but
was not certain of BRUNEL's involvement.
had a picture of herself she wanted to give EPSTEIN for his
birthday. MAXWELL did not like the photo and took more photographs of
in an alluring pose. MAXWELL frequently took nude or alluring
photographs of the girls around EPSTEIN. The photographs were often
artistic pornographic photographs. MAXWELL had a professional camera and
printed numerous photographs that filled multiple boxes at MAXWELL's
residence EPSTEIN had purchased for her in 1999 or 2000. EPSTEIN did not
take photographs of the girls himself but enjoyed the photographs given to
him by-MAXWELL.
described some of the unique interior areas of EPSTEIN's
Manhattan residence. The first floor had a surveillance room that displayed
approximately 50 cameras on the premises. Also on the first floor was a
study where many photographs were displayed. The home was dimly lit,
castle-like, and decorated in an ornate fashion. The floors were tan
marble, and the main staircase was marble with a wooden railing. In
addition to the main staircase, there was a hidden staircase that led to
EPSTEIN's massage loom on the second floor. In the hidden stairwell, there
were eyeballs embedded into the wall along the staircase. The dimly lit
massage room, which referred to as "the dungeon," had a massage
table in the middle of the room and a separate corridor with a shower and
sauna that led to other rooms. attorneys indicated that some of
the activity that occurred in "the dungeon" may have been recorded. The
guest rooms were located on the third and fourth floors, which was where
stayed. The top floor was EPSTEIN's room and had a large glass
atrium above the shower.
While in New York, also stayed at an apartment on 66th street
that EPSTEIN provided. was aware of EPSTEIN having additional
apartments in the same building. According to SHARON CHURCHER, the
apartment building on 66th street was owned by MARK EPSTEIN.
advised that she had a photograph of the interior of the 66th Street
apartment among other photos of her time with EPSTEIN.
advised that some of her photographs that were provided to her
civil attorneys by her family were not returned. .One of the missing photos
depicted wearing a pink dress while seated on a quad bike.
LNU was an Asian female that formerly lived in the Greenwich
Village area of New York and engaged in sexual activity with EPSTEIN.
M2-302a(Rmi. 05.08-10)
31E-MM-106062
Continuation of FD-302 of
LNU and
the girls.
.On 03/17/2011 .Page 8 of 12
went shopping together and purchased clothing and
explained that EPSTEIN enjoyed
EPSTEIN had computers in his office, study, and library. She recalled
him having at least one desktop computer. MAXWELL had several laptop
computers.
EPSTEIN used as a driver to bring females to the Palm
Beach residence. EPSTEIN thought was a schmuck.
boyfriend at the time, and he would frequently drive her to
EPSTEIN's residence. did not mind what was doing because
of the money she was getting from EPSTEIN. recalled a few of the
females she had recruited for EPSTEIN. LNU was a 17 year-old
with blonde hair and brown eyes.
sister, was not accepted by EPSTEIN because she LNU,
16-18 years old, had freckles and naturally curly light brown hair.
EPSTEIN requested to find young, pretty, white females to bring to
him. EPSTEIN paid her $400 per hour if she brought females to him.
used a cellular telephone provided by EPSTEIN. She believed it was
a New York City number but could not recall the. number. and
were sent to clubs and shops in New York to recruit females for
EPSTEIN. MAXWELL continued to recruit females for EPSTEIN as well.
could only remember faces of the females not their names.
did not procure any females for EPSTEIN in New Mexico, but she did try
unsuccessfully to get females for him in St. Thomas, United States Virgin
Islands (USVI) .
recalled two aircraft owned by EPSTEIN, a 727 and a black
Gulfstream. The Gulfstream had some type of slogan on iti but she could
not recall the wording. One of the pilots of the aircraft was LARRY LNU.
advised that sex acts occurred while traveling on the aircraft.
EPSTEIN also had smaller aircraft and helicopters.
traveled with EPSTEIN to a self-help conference at a hotel in
New Orleans, Louisiana. The hotel was near the Hard Rock Café in New
Orleans. traveled the world with EPSTEIN including the USVI, New
York, Santa Fe, Palm Beach, France, Africa, Spain and the United
Kingdom.
EPSTEIN traveled to Europe for approximately six weeks with an
architect to get construction design ideas. recalled visiting
Alhambra Castle in Spain. The architect left toward the end of the trip.
EPSTEIN, MAXWELL, and eventually traveled to the United Kingdom and
FD-302a (Rev. 05-01-10)
31E—MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of  ,on 03/17/2011 , pai 9 of 12
while there, MAXWELL approached in a very excited manner and told
her they had to go shopping to pick out a dress because S would be
dancing with the Queen's son, referring to PRINCE ANDREW, Duke of York.
and MAXWELL went shopping and purchased makeup, clothing, and a
Burberry bag. The items were purchased with MAXWELL's credit card.
and MAXWELL returned to MAXWELL'S townhome in London, and MAXWELL
instructed to get ready. When came down after getting
ready, she was introduced to PRINCE ANDREW with a traditional English
greeting. and PRINCE ANDREW talked gossip and poked fun
at weight. EPSTEIN and MAXWELL asked PRINCE
ANDREW to u ss age. PRINCE ANDREW responded, "17," which was
correct age. EPSTEIN and MAXWELL's responded, "You're right
there." PRINCE ANDREW had two security guards and a driver with him who
traveled from MAXWELL's residence to CLUB TRAMP in London. EPSTEIN,
MAXWELL, and traveled to CLUB TRAMP in a separate vehicle.
danced with PRINCE ANDREW at CLUB TRAMP and stated he is the worst dancer
in the world. PRINCE ANDREW was grabbing her waist and fondling her on the
dance floor. PRINCE ANDREW's security personnel were outside the club. It
seemed that no one at the club recognized him. They stayed at CLUB TRAMP
for an hour or hour and a half and drank a couple of cocktails before
returning to MAXWELL's residence. had not received any direction
from EPSTEIN or MAXWELL on what to do with PRINCE ANDREW other than be very
pleasant and energetic. After returning to MAXWELL's residence,
requested EPSTEIN to take a photograph of her with PRINCE ANDREW.
advised that she still had the original photograph in her possession and
would provide it to the interviewing agents. S proceeded with PRINCE
ANDREW into a bathroom where they enga ed in fore la advised
that PRINCE ANDREW has a Following the
foreplay in the bathroom, and PRINCE ANDREW entered a bedroom where
they engaged in PRINCE ANDREW and
departed MAXWELL's residence a short time later.
Approximately two months later, met PRINCE ANDREW again at
EPSTEIN's Manhattan residence where she gav tic
massage. The en a ed in foreplay, and she PRINCE
ANDREW until . PRINCE ANDREW did not touch as he did
during their first sexual encounter. recalled one of EPSTEIN's
assistants, LNU, being at the residence. MAXWELL had purchased a
puppet resembling PRINCE ANDREW to give to him as a gift. The group joked
after the puppet's hand was placed on one of the girls' breasts and then
PRINCE ANDREW mimicked the puppet by placing his hand on another female's
breast. recalled MAXWELL joking about trading S in because
she was getting too old.
FD-302a (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E —MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of .00 03/17/2011 ,page 10 of 12
recalled meeting PRINCE ANDREW a third time on EPSTEIN's
private island in the USVI. was using Xanax heavily at the time,
and her recollection was not clear. She remembered there were many models
on the island that did not speak English along with a modeling person who
had an unknown accent.
EPSTEIN's private island had a main house with a television room,
dining room, office, and kitchen. There was also a pool surrounded by four
cottages where females stayed. EPSTEIN's quarters were down a spiral
staircase that lead to a master suite. The island property had numerous
outdoor activities including a trampoline on the water, boats, jet skis,
and quad bikes. observed a desktop computer in the office EPSTEIN
and MAXWELL shared.
EPSTEIN did not have a problem with using prescription drugs.
EPSTEIN did not do drugs or alcohol and was described by as a
health freak. EPSTEIN had a chef, LNU, that prepared meals. LNU
observed females walking around EPSTEIN's residences naked. LNU had
short brown hair, blue eyes, and was soft spoken. LNU had a wife and
EPSTEIN es main driver in New York was "JOJO" (TRUE NAME UNKNOWN), an
Asian male. EPSTEIN also had a ranch employee in New Mexico, but
could not recall his name. She did have a photograph of the ranch
employee.
met numerous famous people while she was with EPSTEIN including
academics, politicians, and celebrities. She met BILL CLINTON and AL GORE
and TIPPER GORE at EPSTEIN's private :sland. did not engage in
sexual activity with CLINTON or GORE.
received many gifts from EPSTEIN including jewelry, watches,
bags, shoes, make up, clothing, and home furnishings. EPSTEIN gave her a
couch from France that had terry cloth upholstery with goose down feathers.
left all of the items behind when she traveled to Thailand to
receive massage training.
In August 2002, traveled by commercial airline to
Thailand and began her massage training at
where she received her massage certification. She stayed at
the Princess Hotel in Thailand and was instructed to p female for
EPSTEIN but never did. met her future husband,
during her visit to Thailand. contacted EPSTEIN telephonically and
told him she had fallen in love with someone. EPSTEIN's response before
abruptly hanging up the phone was, "Have a good life."
FD-302a (Rev. OS-08.10)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of 03/17/2011 jar  11 of 12
had not heard from EPSTEIN until he became concerned about an
investigation into his sexual activity with minors.
telephone call from During that call,
FBI agent. He was trying to determine what she knew about EPSTEIN's
activities. She did not tell anything about her knowledge of
EPSTEIN's activities. She also received another telephone call from a
person that indicated he was an FBI agent. She did not tell that
individual anything either. She also received a call from an attorney that
was trying to determine if she had spoken with anyone or was willing to
speak to anyone about her relationship with EPSTEIN. The attorney advised
that EPSTEIN would take care of her if she did not talk to anyone. She
explained that she was receiving telephone calls from people whom she did
not know and that she was uncomfortable telling them anything over the
telephone.
received a
tated he was an
One or two weeks later, an unknown attorney and EPSTEIN contacted
telephonically. EPSTEIN explained that if she did not say anything
to investigators he would take care of her.
was using a cellular telephone belonging to her husband. She
nor her husband could recall the telephone number but advised that the
carrier was OPTUS telephone company.
IIIIIII reviewed a series of photographs of individuals and identified
the following:
Page 1, number 1, ALAN DERSHOWITZ
Page 1, number 2,
Page 2, number 1,
Page 2, number 6,
Page 3, number 2, AL GORE
Page 4, number 3, LNU
Page 4, number 7,
Page 4, number 8,
Page 5, number 1, JEAN LUC BRUNEL
advised that the following were familiar to her, but she could not recall their names or her association to them:
FD-302a (Rev. O5-08.1O)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-3O2 of L. , On 03/17/2011 page 12 of 12
Page 1, number 4
Page 2, numbers 7 and 8
Page 3, number 8
Page 4, number 1
Page 5,. numbers 5 and 8
The images reviewed by were placed in a lA envelope of the case
file.
When questioned about United States Customs and Border (CBP) Patrol
records of her entries into the United States, advised that her
January 2001 record was the return from her London, England trip where she
had her first sexual encounter with PRINCE ANDREW. The April 2001 CBP
record was her return to the United States just prior to her second sexual
encounter with PRINCE ANDREW. could not recall her travel from
March and May 2001 CPB records. advised that her United States
Passport was turned over to the United States Consulate in Sydney,
Australia.
On March 18, 2011, writer, SA and Sydney ALAT
traveled to residence where she provided 20 photographs and her
massage school certification. ED-597 Receipts for Property were
executed for the items and a copy was provided to It is noted that the receipts were dated based'on the United States 
Eastern Standard Time
Zone date. The photographs, certification and original FD-597s were placed
in a lA envelopes of case file.-
ITEM
WAS NOT
SCANNED
DESCRIPTION

╭─ Page 24, Image 1 ─╮
│ ITEM               │
│ WAS NOT            │
│ SCANNED            │
│                    │
│ DESCRIPTION        │
│                    │
│ CD                 │
╰────────────────────╯

F
EFTA00005707 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2011-03-21)
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 03/14/2011
To: Miami Attn: Squad PB-2/Palm Beach County RA
SA
SSA
To: Canberra Attn: LEGAT
ALATI
From: Criminal Investigative
Crimes Against Children Unit
Contact: SSA
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062 (Pending)
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
GHISLAINE MAXWELL;
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Synopsis: To advise Miami Division of CACU concurrence of the travel
request of two Miami Agents to travel to Sydney, Australia from
03/14/2011 to 03/21/2011 to interview United States Citizen,
Details: CACU concurs with Miami Divisions request for two Miami
Agents to travel to Sydney, Australia from 03/14/2011 to 03/21/2011 to
interview United States Citizen,
In addition, per email dated 03/14/2011, Criminal
Investigative Division, Deputy Assistant Director,
concurs with Miami Division's International travel request.
CACU advises Miami Division to conduct all appropriate
Country Clearance requirements regarding official travel to Foreign
Countries as set forth by the Office of International Operations (0I0)
regarding International Travel requirements for FBI employees.
The following procedures are required to be completed
by travelers prior to official FBI travel overseas:
STEPS 1 AND 2 SHOULD BE DONE SIMULTANEOUSLY AND EARLY
COORDINATION WITH THE RESPECTIVE LEGAT IS STRONGLY ENCOURAGED.

1. An EC to the responsible Legat office indicating intended travel to
its Area of Responsibility(AOR) with personnel information, the
purpose of the proposed travel, and as much detail as possible. One EC
is sufficient for multiple individuals traveling to the same AOR for
the same purpose. In addition to the Legat office, leads should also
be set to the region-specific operational unit in the Office of
International Operations (0I0) for informational purposes (see
Intranet FBI webpages for Legat AORs and OIO operational units),
the Security Division to request passage of the travelers'
clearances to the respective embassies, and to CIRG at SIOC for
the purpose of requesting inclusion on the SIOC Foreign Travel
Report.

2. Completion and submission of an electronic Country
Clearance (eCC) request through the Department of State (DoS)
internet: https://ecc.state.gov. Step by step instructions on
how to complete the eCC can be found on the (MO website:
http://oio.fbinet.fbi/Deployments/. Multiple travelers can be
included in the same eCC request as long they have the same
itineraries. The travelers are responsible for completing and
submitting their eCC requests via the internet.

3. Completion and submission of the Clearance Passage
Worksheet to the Clearance Passage, Contractor, and Law
Enforcement Reinvestigations Unit (CPCLERU). The Clearance
Passage Worksheet can be found at:
http://secd.fbinet.fbi/iss/cpcleru/items_clearance.htm. One
worksheet can be filled out for a maximum of ten people and can
be submitted electronically. This procedure is required to
forward your clearance to the respective embassy.
It should be noted that providing sufficient and
relevant information in the EC will provide the Legat office a
thorough understanding of the proposed travel should any
questions arise from the Embassy. The granting of the Country
Clearance is ultimately the responsibility of the Chief of
Mission at that embassy and the Country Clearance approval will
be coordinated by the Legat office.
When submitting the eCC, all information should be
unclassified. Thus, specific details regarding the specific
purpose of travel, the operational assistance or activity to be
conducted, etc., should be included only in the secure/classified
environment of the FBI EC.
IF THE PURPOSE OF YOUR TRAVEL IS SENSITIVE IN NATURE
AND SUBMITTING ANY INFORMATION VIA THE PUBLIC DOMAIN COULD
COMPROMISE YOUR REASON FOR TRAVEL, CONTACT THE LEGAT OFFICE
IMMEDIATELY TO MAKE THE APPROPRIATE ARRANGEMENTS TO OBTAIN
COUNTRY CLEARANCE.
Both the EC and the eCC are required to ensure all
parties involved in the granting of country clearances and the
coordination/assistance of the travelers' activities in-country
are fully coordinated and approved prior to the travel.
LEAD(s):
Set Lead 1: (Action)
MIAMI
AT MIAMI, FLORIDA
Conduct all appropriate Country Clearance requirements
regarding official travel to Foreign Countries as highlighted in this
communication. CID/CACU concurs with travel.
Set Lead 2: (Information)
CANBERRA
AT CANBERRA, AUSTRALIA
Read and Clear.
* *
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Mt. Gox [crypto] FKA 'Magic the Gathering: Online Exchange', infamous early bitcoin market that was hacked / robbed 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01088079 (Jmail)
 [crypto] someone's thoughts on bitcoin
(inferred date: 2011-03-29)
PART Thoughts on Bitcoin
We propose that the best way to conceptualize Bitcoin is to ignore the notions of "currency" and
"money" and think about a ledger system of debits and credits. You "buy in" to the ledger system with
something that is universally accepted as having value — either with cash or by selling a product or
service in Bitcoins, and then are free to trade within the Bitcoin sandbox.
This is the key and why it doesn't matter whether the Bitcoins themselves have intrinsic value — your
price of admission has intrinsic value and as long as there is one other person in the world who believes
in Bitcoin, you can also "cash out" at any time.
On this view, Bitcoin is "post-currency." Bitcoin allows us to imagine a theoretical steady state where
every human's finances live on the same ledger and the notion that we would use some physical means
of exchange (gold, cigarettes, dollars) to conduct transactions is a vestigial technology like floppy disks.
Most importantly, whether Bitcoin "wins" or not, we believe that the concept of a post-currency ledger
system has taken root. The current price appreciation, capital inflow, popular media coverage, and
accelerating transaction volume all point towards Bitcoin having its "Netscape moment." The ledger
concept is too powerful to ever put the genie back in the bottle, because of the massive amount of value
creation potential it enables:

• Huge reduction of transaction friction. particularly across borders:  When money is as easy and
secure as email, we anticipate reduced border effects (psychology of geographical distance
leads to fewer transactions), lower transaction fees and currency exchange fees, faster
transaction processing times, reduced fraud, and indeed greater trust in the currency of record
as a means of exchange (mostly true for developing markets)

• De-verticalization of banks: From vertically integrated, geographically-specialized institutions to
global, functionally-specialized platforms. It is a historical anomaly that the "warehouse" for
money should also be the "store" for money. In a world of digital money, the intermediary with
the best data and the most liquidity should be the best facilitator of credit, independently of
who owns the largest stores of deposits. There is no possibility that existing banking institutions
will be able to adapt to this disruption, and we anticipate the rise of ledger-based verticals for
the warehousing of money and supplying of credit.
• Net new businesses: We envision ledger systems enabling new business models such as
"insurance" for digital money, new investment products that make savings accounts and CDs
obsolete (P2P lending?), and new "features" such as multiple owners of the same ledger
balance, which could improve corporate governance and family financial planning
Our ledger analogy allows us to better understand the "value" of Bitcoins.
To simplify, suppose there are two means of conducting transactions, one is that you use dollar bills and
someone charges you 2% each time to use them, the other is that you have 100 seats on the ledger
where you can do business with other members on the ledger for free.
Pretty soon more than 100 people at once will want to save 2%, so the ledger seats will get more
valuable as people bid for the right to conduct business for free. We will reach an equilibrium quickly,
since no one will want to pay more than 2% x the number of transactions they expect to be able to do
with the 99 other people on the ledger. The equilibrium is governed by the number of spots available,
the per transaction savings, and the number of transactions that it is possible to conduct with other
people on the ledger.
But let's relax the 100 people constraint and say you can buy a fractional seat at the table, which entitles
you to all the same trading benefits as if you owned a full seat. Now we will have many more people all
willing to pay up to 2% x expected transactions for their fractional seat. And we have also increased the
number of potential transactions that can happen on the ledger because more people are participating.
Once we settle at equilibrium, if we add up how much everyone has paid for their fractional seat, we will
see that the price of a single original seat has appreciated dramatically.
At unlimited divisibility of seats, the supply of seats does not govern the dollar price of a seat — it is
purely a function of the size of the ledger — i.e., the number of potential transactions the network
enables - and the economic savings per transaction inside the ledger vs. outside.
This has a few dramatic implications:
Bitcoin has broken the requirement that money be based on belief
...whether that belief is a collective agreement in the value of gold jewelry, or in the government's ability
to pay its debts into perpetuity. Against the criteria of divisibility, flexibility, transportability, and
(arguably) security, Bitcoin is superior to every other system of money ever invented, and its value
comes from internalizing those superiorities. In fact, the incremental economic value enabled by Bitcoin
is an externality that will be disproportionately captured by the "early adopters" (or, "early believers")
of the system and explains why Bitcoin is not a Ponzi scheme. It makes sense that the early participants
in Bitcoin will "do better" than later participants, since their early contributions towards its viability have
a greater impact on the strength of the network and its ability to create future economic value through
its systemic superiority. The first person to join Facebook contributes more towards its durability and
economic value than the one hundredth millionth.
The debate about the "intrinsic value" of an actual Bitcoin is a red herring.
The Bitcoins themselves are just a conceptual bridge to get people trading within the Bitcoin ledger
system, which appreciates in value in direct proportion to the number of transactions that are
happening within it, which itself is a direct consequence of the number of people on the ledger. Put
differently, if you can buy Bitcoins and conduct transactions in a more seamless or lower cost way, then
whether they have intrinsic value is meaningless to you.
As "post-currency" money, Bitcoin should not be susceptible to a deflationary spiral.
First, seats on the ledger can only appreciate relative to the total incremental value of ledger-facilitated
transactions vs. the higher cost dollar alternative, or it will no longer be worth it to pay higher prices to
get access to the lower friction transaction medium.
Second, hoarding slows down transaction velocity which as we've shown is a direct driver of price
appreciation. There should be a feedback loop here — expected appreciation leads to hoarding, hoarding
2
leads to lower velocity, lower velocity leads to reduced expectations about appreciation, lower
expectations reduces hoarding. Very much like a thermostat at equilibrium — not too hot, not too cold.
Third, even if there is some hoarding effect, as Bitcoin wealth increases through currency appreciation,
the risk of loss increases as well. Bitcoins become too attractive not to trade for other goods, either to
diversify, protect wealth creation, or simply find a better store of value such as stocks, bonds, or real
estate. A company's high stock price doesn't necessarily lead to a collapse in liquidity for that equity.
There is a population distribution of risk tolerance which will lead to profit taking and inject Bitcoins
back into the market.
There should be intense competition for the future of ledger-based money
If it becomes a pain to use Bitcoins due to limited availability, not 100% certain availability, exchange
difficulty, or currency volatility, everyone will see the success of Bitcoin and want to start a competitor.
It is fairly trivial to set up a system to use the internet to trade (going back to our point on "belief no
longer required"). Putting aside Bitcoin's features of anonymity, you can compete with Bitcoin using
something like Western Union, but more electronic. The competing system has to be able to solve the
same problems that Bitcoin, Paypal, and Western Union have—but if they solve those problems, as long
as they have some other low transaction cost way to move money (like banks cutting their fees, who
don't actually have high costs, they just charge high fees), then you can compete with Bitcoin.
Importantly, there are actually strong incentives for governments to move to a post-currency ledger
system. It has been posited by leading economists that electronic money gives central banks the ability
to lower interest rates to below zero' (this is impossible today since you cannot have negative interest
rates on physical currency, which would therefore outcompete negative interest earning bank deposits)
and would provide a powerful tool in enacting fiscal stimulus. Additionally, governments can finally
extract sales tax on ledger transactions that otherwise would have been conducted in cash.
This last point is worth dwelling on. As a competitor to Bitcoin, a central bank electronic ledger system,
backed by the "full faith and credit" of a government, would achieve immediate transactional scale. In
our view, this is probably the greatest threat to Bitcoin in the long-term. If Bitcoin is Netscape, the US
government is Microsoft (A more important question might be — who/what is Google? (i.e. the vertical
application, built on top of the platform, that is a winner-take-all business, with a 10+-year 30%+ annual
growth trajectory and 30%+ margins...).
The strength of a government's monetary system ultimately is a function of the strength of the rule of
law in that country (and in the most deprecated sense, the strength of the rule of law is a function of
military power). So we can say that low quality governments will have low quality monetary systems.
These will be the countries where Bitcoin is most likely to thrive. In the US/EU/Japan, the official
currency is a fairly safe store of value (at least on a day-to-day basis) and the value of an alternative
ledger system is of minimal value. In Argentina, Iraq, Venezuela, et al, this is not true. In those countries
Bitcoins will act like black market dollars (much more useful than the official currency). But unlike black
market dollars they can be used internationally i.e., you can cross a border and email Bitcoins to
yourself, whereas dollars would get confiscated at the border.
3
We foresee a real possibility that all currencies go digital and competition eliminates all currencies from
non-effective governments. The power of friction-free transactions over the Internet will unleash the
typical forces of consolidation and globalization and we will end up with six digital currencies: US Dollar,
Euro, Yen, Pound, Reminbi, and Bitcoin.
The question then becomes, is Bitcoin viable if the government digital ledger systems are just as good?
We think yes, for two reasons:

1. There will always be transactions for which "official money" is less good than Bitcoin
2. If you live outside the US, it is dangerous to have all your money controlled by a state where you
have no rights
PART II: Is Bitcoin a bubble?
To answer the question of whether the current appreciation of Bitcoins relative to dollars is a bubble,
we go back to our fundamental premise that the value of Bitcoin (i.e., a seat on the ledger) is directly
driven by the volume of transactions it facilitates.
Fortunately, the entire transaction history of Bitcoin is available as public record in the blockchain. In
addition, since we know BTC prices and volume on the major exchanges, we can back out the
transactions that are "currency exchanges" to figure out the "real" BTC-BTC trades for goods and
services that make up the Bitcoin economy. To normalize, we take a 365-day trailing total 2:
365 day trailing total of "real" Bitcoin transactions
SM
$
$2,S00
$2/30
S/500
Sae
5500
SO
5200
5160
>110
$00
540
SO
fi I
;;; ;;;;;;;;; WSW 2 S 4. 1 3
Bitcoin price In %AD
o
2 htto://blockchain.info/charts
4
From this, we can make a few observations:

1. There is a clear, steady increase in the "real" transactions happening on Bitcoin over the last two
years. This has corresponded with a reasonably steady appreciation of BTC relative to USD

2. In the May '11-July '11 instance of a price spike/collapse, we saw a significant ramp of
transactions (on a relative basis — after sitting at essentially $0 for its entire history back to 2009,
went to $250M in a month)
3. The current spike in price is not entirely irrational, given real transaction volumes have doubled
over the past six months. However, because of what we observe in #2 and the fact that the
appreciation slope is steeper than the transaction ramp, it is very likely we will experience a
near-term correction
Since we also know the total "market cap" of all BTCs in circulation at any point in time, we can calculate
effectively the "multiple" of Bitcoin:
4
3.5 -
3-
2.5 -
2 -
Bitcoin "market cap" / 365-day trailing total of 'rear Bitcoin transactions
1.5
1 -
.....s",110.5 - Am
0
I
i .t. 2 2 r. 2   2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 a a • .if 4  i  --k• t k  8 i_ i • i 4 1 i k i i it t k...4i in z i /E t a3 a.
< 12011 overarm • 0.89  1 > <  '12 0.15 -> <-I '13.0.42 *
Overall= 0-51
What this shows is that while Bitcoin is indeed getting somewhat more "expensive" relative to where it
has traded in the past, it is not wildly so (note also the 2011 spike was much more dramatic). And since
we know that real transactions are growing, the currency today is not significantly overvalued as it
should be able to grow into the current market cap (spun differently, we see that if the historical
"stable" multiple level of 0.15x can be maintained, there is a $30 floor on $/BTC on the current
transaction volume). More importantly, there is massive upside as long as transactions keep growing,
since the supply of Bitcoins is predictable and fixed over time, even if we see "multiple contraction" back
to historical levels.
Bitcoin upside potential ($ per BTC)
365 day rolling transaction volume
Current ($2.08) $58 $10B $1008
Multiple (@$200/8TC, 1.11 .15
@$70/BTC, 0.4)
0 $27 $68 $136 $1,364
0.25 $45 $114 $227 $2,273
0.40 $73 $182 $364 $3,636
Finally, we don't believe that transaction value growth is a hand wave. We hypothesize that there are a
number of "killer scenarios" where Bitcoin is substantially advantaged as a currency for legitimate
commercial activity:

• Micropayments: the "$0.15/3%, whichever is greater" fee extracted by credit card companies
leads to effectively a 15%+ tax on transactions < $1. In the new digital economy of virtual goods,
content, in-app purchases, etc..., 15% is substantial.

• Online gambling, where deposits & withdrawals are used as the control mechanism for
regulation. Online today represents only 5% of a $400B gambling industry, which has been gated
to a large degree by local governments. Online gambling has always participated in the arms
race between payments innovation and regulation; as Bitcoin is a breakthrough disruption, it
will be rapidly embraced

• Small $ value international transfers, using the same logic as micropayments: International fees
are exorbitant relative to the value of the payments and are sustained only by the existing
payments regimes

• Brute force malware removal: As soon as there is an n > 0 transaction cost on anything, it is
possible to remove a lot of brute force malware on the web (e.g, if it costs .00001 BTC to load
Ticketmaster.com, now bots can't pound the site with bots looking for tickets). We speculate
that it might even be possible to solve email spam with Bitcoin (I opt in to 'BTC mail filtering' and
it costs .00001 BTC to send me a message. Certainly some cold start problems but not
insurmountable)
These killer scenarios will drive the Bitcoin network effect
PART III: Challenges for Bitcoin
Beyond the inherent risk of bootstrapping a new monetary system, we see two primary challenges for
Bitcoin:
1. Government intervention (or, potentially, competition)
Control of the money supply is one of the principal roles of government (along with — fiscal policy,
monopoly of force, taxation, law-making, etc...) Governments use monetary policy as a tool to effect real
economic outcomes, which have a direct impact on the government's ability to maintain power (i.e.,
Depression = Revolution). Indeed, it is not out of the purview of government to enact draconian
measures to control the money supply. Executive Order 6102 signed in 1933 by FDR criminalized the
possession of gold.' So there is some possibility that at a certain scale, Bitcoin represents a significant
threat to the central banks of the world, who have the authority to legally delegitimize it.
And as noted earlier, there are many good reasons for governments not to intervene in Bitcoin, but
compete directly with it.
A few thoughts on this:
3 htto://en.wikinedia.oraiwiki/Executive Order 6102
6

• At $2B "market cap," Bitcoin isn't even big enough to register as a large cap company in the
United States. Even at 2 orders of magnitude of growth, Bitcoin would only represent 1% of
worldwide GDP. So we are probably looking at 3 orders of magnitude of growth before Bitcoin
becomes an issue for central banks, and possibly not even then given its dispersion around the
world

• Despite the network effects at work, it is not necessarily a given that electronic money should
be winner-take-all. Network effects imply dominance at scale but whether that means
monopoly, duopoly, or oligopoly is very different to predict. Just because a market has the
properties of "it is better if everyone in the world does X," doesn't necessarily mean that it will
be so (e.g., systems of weights and measures, competing global wireless standards). And there
are often exogenous, unknowable factors (e.g., web search: search has tended to monopoly in
the rest of the world but in the US has remained 30% non-Google due to Microsoft's persistent
non-market subsidy). So even if governments decide to compete with Bitcoin, we might see a
world where the US-backed ledger is the de facto standard for the developed world, but there
are a cluster of third world economies where Bitcoin still dominates.

• Finally, because of Bitcoin's pseudonymous, distributed structure, government action may not
necessarily lead to its demise. We won't go as far as many Bitcoin bulls who will argue that it is
"untouchable" from government intervention, but it is certainly more protected than any other
currency, ever. The criminalization of something does not necessarily lead to its eradication and
this should especially be true for Bitcoin.
2. Technical risk
As a technical system, Bitcoin has demonstrated remarkable resiliency. Attacks on Bitcoin have come
not on its core technical architecture but on the third party intermediaries such as the Mt. Gox
exchange." While social engineering and "weakest link" hacking will always present some risk for any
technical system, two aspects of Bitcoin are particularly worrisome:

• First, most of the protections are theoretical and not testable. While the current SHA-256 block
hashing algorithm that ensures Bitcoin's security is NSA-grade, it is possible that the
cryptography is hackable; the rebuttal to this is something along the lines of: "by the time that
happens, Bitcoin will have leapfrogged to the next level of cryptographic security and it will be
trivial to migrate the system" or "if you can hack Bitcoin's cryptography, we have bigger
problems" (though, not clear what is a bigger problem than hacking the world's money supply).
Bitcoin also is dependent on the sum total of the world's distributed computing power
dedicated to Bitcoin being larger than what any single actor could muster (with another
handwave of "if you can muscle that much compute power, it's not in your interest to hack
Bitcoin, you're better off participating as a miner or using it somewhere else")

• Second, Bitcoin is not fully autonomous. It requires some management by humans, and all the
weaknesses that entails. Take the "blockchain" fork that occurred on March 111° 2013.5
4
7
"Developers ore currently holding on emergency discussion in itbitcoin-dev to determine a way
forward"
For an open source, distributed, and in many ways deeply subversive/disruptive computing
project that is dependent on mainstream adoption to succeed, even a statement as innocuous
as this is deeply troubling. At $18 market cap, it may not be an issue. At $1008, the competing
agendas, politics, capabilities, and fallibilities of the Bitcoin development community become
magnified and inescapable. Perhaps no worse than central bankers, but the devil you know....

• Third, the unknown unknowns of an experiment like this are massive. We have tried to
articulate what we see but remain humble about what we don't yet know.
a
╔═════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                         Tom Ford [arts] fashion designer 
     Nadia Bjorlin [girls] actress on "Days of Our Lives" 
 Timur Kulibayev [kazakhstan] businessman from Kazakhstan 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01102188 (Jmail)
 [legal] Epstein v. Scott Rothstein, Brad Edwards, & L.M.: Epstein motion to block statements to the press
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Howard Lutnick [crypto] Tether's banker, Cantor Fitzgerald, Trump Secretary of Commerce [cryptadamus] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00434306 (Jmail)
 [crypto] calendar reminder for call with Howard Lutnick
(date: 2011-04-26)
Subject: Howard Lutnick Sun. at 4 or 5:00?
— This to do is stored on an IMAP server.
— It is managed by Mail; do not modify or delete it.
'Howard Lutnick Sun. at 4 or 5:00?' (012785E4-A9F4-4E4E-8C8C-D8A948868839]
Has no due date.
Is incomplete.
Has no priority.
Is stored in the Mail To Do calendar.
Has the following alarms:
Alarm 1
Displays a message.
on April 26, 2011
at 3:24:29 PM EDT
Contains the URL mailitem:012785E4-A9F4-4E4E-8C8C-D8A948868839?
type=todoSaction=showparent Has no note.
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Gino Yu [china] AI researcher/professor in Hong Kong, did PR for Epstein, friend of Masha Drokova? 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01106148 (Jmail)
 [academia] "OpenCog Hong Kong Project Interim Report" by Gino Yu
(date: 2011-05-01)
OpenCog Hong Kong Project
Interim Report, May 2011
Prepared for the Jeffrey Epstein Foundation
Contents
• Background
• Articulation of Specific Goals
• Technical Achievements So Far
• Staffing
• Screenshots of In-Development Game World
Background
The OpenCog Hong Kong project is a collaboration between Hong Kong Polytechnic
University and Novamente LLC, aimed at the use of the OpenCog Al engine to create
a working prototype of simple "artificial general intelligence" in a video game world.
The prototype is supposed to take the form of an open -source software toolkit that
can be utilized and extended, and the principal aim of the project is to provide a
concrete context in which to implement and test various aspects of the OpenCog
system.
The project is funded 90% by the Hong Kong government and 10% by Novamente
LLC. Novamente LLC's portion amounts to roughly US$40K altogether. The initial
$20K of Novamente's portion was funded by a donation from Humanity+, which in
turn was funded by a donation to Humanity+ from the Jeffrey Epstein Foundation.
The funding is earmarked to pay primarily for staff salaries: one Al PhD to lead the
team, plus 3 other Al programmers, one game programmer, and one artist.
The project formally began at the start of October 2010, but in fact staff were
brought on more slowly, due to visa issues (most staff were brought to Hong Kong
from overseas, due to the desire to work with staff having prior OpenCog
experience). A detailed rundown of project staffing is given later in this document
A quick summary is that the current staff have been on board from between 4 and 6
months, at this point (May 2011).
It was originally thought the second $20K of Novamente's contribution would be
due in September 2011, but recently it's been revealed that it's actually due before
the end of May 2011. This is due to Hong Kong government regulations, and is not
negotiable.
Articulation of Specific Goals
One of the things achieved during the first months of the project has been to more
clearly articulate the project goals. (A lot of technical work was also achieved; see
the following section for details.)
We have chosen a specific game world to use for testing and demo-ing, though the
software built will apply in essentially any game world. The game world chosen is
inspired by the game Minecraft, but is implemented in the Unity3D game engine
(which provides a very flexible API for integration of OpenCog or other Al systems).
Some images of Minecraft and our in-progress game world are given at the end of
this document A decision was also made to have the Al control a demo character
taking the appearance of a robot (although the robot artwork is not ready yet, so
that the screenshots at the end of the document show instead the "woman in a red
dress" imported from earlier OpenCog demos).
The basic goals of the OpenCog Hong Kong project, in this context, are for O penCog
to control an artificial agent that can:

• Build structures with blocks so as to achieve its goals in the game world
• Use simple English to describe what it's doing and explain why, and ask
questions relevant to its goals
Simple examples would be:

• Learning to build steps or ladders to get desired objects that are high up
• Learning to build a shelter to protect itself from aggressors

• Learning to build structures resembling structures that it's shown (even if
the available materials are a bit different)

• Learning how to build bridges to cross chasms
Of course, the Al significance of learning tasks like this all depends on what kind of
feedback the system is given, and how complex its environment is. It would be
possible to do things like this in a trivial and highly specialized way, but that is not
the intent of the project - the goal is to have the system learn to carry out tasks like
this using general learning mechanisms and a general cognitive architecture, based
on embodied experience and only scant feedback from human teachers. This will
provide an outstanding platform for ongoing AGI development, as well as a visually
appealing and immediately meaningful demo for OpenCog.
We have identified some specific tasks that like to see the system execute by
August 2011, though we're unsure if this will be realistic (it might take a month or
two more). An earlier version of these tasks are depicted in the document
Bananas_demo.doc. The vision of the demo has changed a bit since then; for
instance, in the new version, instead of seeking bananas, the character will look for
batteries. But the essence remains the same. The core ideas are that the Al
character should be able to, e.g.

• Watch another character build steps to reach a high-up object
• Figure out via imitation of this that, in a different context, building steps to
reach a high up object may be a good idea

• Also figure out that, if it wants a certain high-up object but there are no
materials for building steps available, finding some other way to get elevated
will be a good idea that may help it get the object
With a bit of luck we will be able to demo this at the AGI-11 conference on Google
campus in early August 2011.
Technical Achievements So Far
The OpenCog Hong Kong project has led to a large amount of work on OpenCog
getting done, both system engineering and Al advances. There have been too many
small tasks completed for it to be sensible to list them all here, but here are some of
the major achievements.
A roadmap for the whole OpenCog HK project is attached as a separate document.
Here I just give an informal run-down of what we've done so far. A big-picture
roadmap for the whole OpenCog project is also attached, including the HK project as
a subset.
On the AI side:

• Implementation of the Psi model of emotion and motivation (created by
German psychologist Dietrich Dorner and refined by Joscha Bach in his
MicroPsi AGI system) inside OpenCog, yielding the OpenPsi system. This is a
complete overhaul of OpenCog's motivation and goal system. (Note that
Joscha Bach visited Hong Kong from Germany in April 2011 to help with this
work.)

• Implementation of "frequent subgraph mining" in OpenCog, for identifying
frequently occurring patterns in the game world and in the system's mind -
for instance "when I plug myself in I no longer need electricity", "chairs and
tables are often found near each other", "Bob often hits me", etc. This was
done via integrating the SUBDUE graph mining software with OpenCog

• Implementation of a probabilistic planner based on OpenCog's Probabilistic
Logic Networks reasoning system, enabling simple planning of actions in the
game world

• Implementation of a fairly complete virtual -world perception system that
registers events observed in the game world as logical relationships in
OpenCog's knowledge base. Such a system was present in OpenCog
previously, but only in a very simplified form, not adequate for the current
project
And on the system engineering side:

• Creation of a framework enabling OpenCog MindAgents (cognitive
processes) to be coded in Python as well as C++. As Python is an easier and
faster language to program in, this should speed up OpenCog software
development, as well as make it accessible to a larger pool of programmers.

• Integration of OpenCog with Unity3D, a more powerful and flexible game
engine than the Multiverse engine that OpenCog was integrated with before

• Customization of the MineCraft-like plug-in for Unity3D, to make it
suitable as a world for OpenCog demos
Note also that

• Three OpenCog related papers were accepted for the AGI-11
conference: one on OpenPsi, one on information geometry for attention
allocation, and one on OpenCog/DeSTIN integration for computer vision (the
latter two not directly based on the Hong Kong project's work)

• Two OpenCog related papers were accepted for the AAAI 2011
conference: one on MOSES-PLN integration, and another on lifelong
learning
Staffing

• Dr. Joel Pitt, team leader (from New Zealand), started November 2010
o As well as managing the team, Joel has been doing various Al and
game programming tasks for the project

• Jared Wigmore (also from New Zealand), started toward the end of
December 2010
o Working on probabilistic inference and pattern mining in OpenCog

• Troy Huang and Zhenhua Cai (from Xiamen University in mainland China)
started in January 2011. Note: They are exchange graduate students and will
return to Xiamen in January 2012. Zhenhua will return to Hong Kong in
September 2012 if there is ongoing funding available.
o Zhenhua is working on OpenPsi, an implementation of the Psi model
of emotion and motivation inside OpenCog
o Troy is working on the practicalities of connecting OpenCog to the
game world, and on emotion modeling inside OpenCog

• Cord Krohn started in November 2010, working on the graphic arts aspect
• Lester Lam started in November 2010, working on game programming, and
left the project in April 2011
Cord and Lester's salaries were covered by additional Hong Kong government
funding, separate from the funding mentioned above.
Two additional team members have been made job offers and the paperwork to
bring them on is pending:

• Shujing Ke, an Al PhD student from Xiamen, with 3 years commercial game
programming experience
o Shujing will take charge of applying imitation and reinforcement
learning aspects of OpenCog to the appropriate context, and also help
with game programming

• Dr. Ruiting Lian (PhD to be completed in fall 2011), a computational
linguistics expert from Xiamen
o Ruiting will re-factor the OpenCog language comprehension and
generation system to make it more adaptable based on an agent's
experience in a world, i.e. to enable simple language learning
o She is the original author of OpenCog's language generation system
Potential additional team members are being interviewed.
Screenshots
Minecraft itself, the game that inspired our test/demo game world for the project:
On the next page, some shots of our current, crude Minecraft-like world in Unity3D.
Note that we will soon replace the woman with a robot!
EFTA01733746 (Jmail)
 [crypto] schedule showing "drinks" with Howard Lutnick
(date: 2011-05-01)
May 1st, Sunday

9:30am Breakfast with Terje Roed-Larsen (omlettes) <REDACTED> (<REDACTED>)
10:30am Appt w/Leon Black (<REDACTED>) <REDACTED> Melanie is his assistant: <REDACTED>
12:00am Appt w/<REDACTED>
1:00pm Appt w/Michael Wolff <REDACTED>
3:00pm Appt w/Steve Bastone and Joe (Steve cell: <REDACTED>)
5:00pm Appt w/Howard Lutnick (drinks) (<REDACTED>)
5:30pm Dinner w/Woody Allen, Soon-Yi, Prof. Steve Kosslyn, Katherine
Keating, Alexandra Keating, Korina, Sultan and his Wife (Glenn Dubin may
stop by with <REDACTED>)
8:30pm Buffet Dinner at the Home of Vera Wang After party for L'Amour Fou

May 2, Monday
9:30am TENATIVE breakfast w/Sultan (<REDACTED>)
<REDACTED>
4:30pm Appt w/Dangene and Jennie at Core Club (66 e. 55th street bet
Park and Madison) (Jennie cell: <REDACTED> (Core Club: <REDACTED>)
9:00pm Dinner w/Bill Gates and Larry Summers and Jes Staley (Larry cell:
<REDACTED> Julie is Larry's assistant:
<REDACTED> Jes Staley:
<REDACTED> Rosa is Jes' assistant
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
11:00pm Andre Balasz Vogue After Party at the Boom Boom Room (top of
the Standard Hotel on Washington St. Between West 13th and Little West
12th) JE's name is on the list plus 1

May 3, Tuesday
*Need to hear back from Kevin Law (<REDACTED>) Jenni is his assistant
*Ask JE in the am what he would like for lunch w/Prof. Kosslyn

12:00 Lunch w/Prof. Kosslyn (<REDACTED>)
1:30pm Appt w/Rich Kahn
4:30 m A t w/Mary Erdoes (<REDACTED>)(Tamyka is assistant: <REDACTED>
6:45pm Go for your Typhoid and Malaria booster shot (International Health
Care Services, 450 E. 69th Street between 1st and York.

May 4, Wednesday
1:00 Appt w/Nick Ribis Assistant Lisa <REDACTED>
3:00pm Appt w/George Delson (<REDACTED>)

May 5, Thursday
10:00am Susman Conf. Call Dial: Te Password:
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Second Life [tech] virtual world with early attempt at virtual currency the Linden Dollar [stanford] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01114145 (Jmail)
 [academia] "OpenCog AGI Toddler Project" by Ben Goertzel, Gino Yu
(approximate date: 2011-06-01)
OpenCog
AGI Toddler Project
Open-Source "Human Toddler Level" AGI by 2015
for US $3M Total
Ben Goertzel and Gino Yu, Principal Investigators
Multimedia Innovation Centre, P507 Hong Kong Polytechnic University
Hung Hom, Hong Kong
Rough draft, not yet for distribution
Introduction 2
AGI: The Time is Now 2
Project Strategy 7
Four Year Plan 11
Organizational Structure and Management 15
Preliminary Budget 18
Introduction
The goal of the proposed "OpenCog Toddler" project is to achieve a radical
breakthrough in Artificial General Intelligence, rapidly and at minimal cost. Specifically,
the goal is to use the OpenCog design and codebase to create an AGI system with the
rough general intelligence of a human 3-4 year old child, demonstrated via embodiment
in virtual world characters and humanoid robots, within the scope of a 4 year R&D
project.
The project will involve roughly 15 full time staff, which is achievable within US$750K/
year (including hardware, rent and other costs) -- a bargain price that is possible due to
relatively low costs in the proposed location in Hong Kong Polytechnic University's M-
Lab technology incubator. The proposers are currently leading a smaller, related project
in the M-Lab, the "OpenCog Game Al project", with 6 programmers working on an
OpenCog-based toolkit for the creation of intelligent video game characters. The
OpenCog Toddler project team would be seeded with individuals already on location in
the M-Lab and experienced on the OpenCog Game Al project, in addition to new hires
from within Hong Kong and overseas. All software created would be open-source and
made available to the world at large.
To support this initiative, we require US $3M total, to be spent over 4 years, primarily on
salaries.
While the software created in this effort will have massive commercialization potential,
the proposed work specifically described here focuses on AGI R&D; development of
commercial prototypes or products would require additional staff and funding.
AGI: The Time is Now
What do we mean by AGI, Artificial General Intelligence? And why do we believe the
OpenCog Toddler project will have such a dramatic impact on the overall global
progress of AGI R&D?
The proximal goal of the AGI field is simple, powerful and ambitious: the development
and demonstration of systems that exhibit the broad range of general intelligence
found in humans. In its most ambitious interpretation, "AGI" may be used to refer to
an extreme generality of intelligence potentially going far beyond the human level;
Marcus Hutter has modeled this mathematically with his theory of Universal Al.
However, for the proposed project the focus will be on Human-Level AGI, and unless
otherwise noted, that is what we will take the term "AGI" to mean here. The goal of
developing AGI echoes that of the early years of the Artificial Intelligence movement,
which after many valiant efforts largely settled for research into 'narrow Al' systems that
could demonstrate or surpass human performance in a specific sort of task, but could
not generalize this capability to other types of tasks or other domains.
A classic example of this "narrow Al" approach was IBM's DeepBlue system, which
could beat world chess champion Gary Kasparov but not apply that skill to any other
problem domain (without substantial human re-programming). In 2010, IBM's Watson
question answering system dramatically defeated two all time champions in the quiz
show Jeopardy!, but having never visited Chicago's O'Hare and Midway airports,
fumbled on a question that any human frequent flier would have known. And to apply
the technology underlying Watson to another domain, such as medicine or call center
support, would require not merely education of the Al system, but significant
reprogramming -- the analogue of needing to perform brain surgery on a human each
time they need to confront a new sort of task. As impressive as these and other Al
systems are in their restricted roles, they all lack the basic cognitive capabilities and
common sense of a typical three year old child, let alone a fully educated adult
professional.
Nils Nilsson, one of the early leaders of the Al field, stated the goal of AGI quite crisply
in the 2005 Al Magazine article "Human-Level Artificial Intelligence? Be Serious!" ):
"I claim achieving real Human-Level artificial intelligence would necessarily imply that
most of the tasks that humans perform for pay could be automated. Rather than work
toward this goal of automation by building special-purpose systems, I argue for the
development of general-purpose, educable systems that can learn and be taught to
perform any of the thousands of jobs that humans can perform. Joining others who have
made similar proposals, I advocate beginning with a system that has minimal, although
extensive, built-in capabilities. These would have to include the ability to improve
through learning along with many other abilities."
Or, to get a more detailed feel for the broad scope of AGI, see Table 1, which was
produced by a team of 12 AGI researchers at the AGI Roadmap Workshop organized
by Ben Goertzel and Itamar Arel at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville in 2009. This
table lists a number of the key competencies that an AGI system should be expected to
display if it's going to be considered a proper human-level AGI. By the end of the
proposed 4 year OpenCog Toddler project, the OpenCog AGI system will be able to
handle every one of these capabilities, at least in a simplistic way.
Early Al researchers, though their hearts were often in the right place, lacked sufficiently
powerful computers and software tools and sufficient knowledge of cognition to
practically succeed at their goals. Right now, in 2011, Artificial General Intelligence is
an R&D domain whose time has come -- after a few decades of "AGI winter" it is finally
beginning to flourish, with a host of research ideas, software systems and practical
applications emerging from the minds of AGI researchers worldwide.
Table 1. Some of the Important Competency Areas Associated with Human-Level General Intelligence
Broad
competency
areas
Sub-areas... Sub-areas.. Sub-areas.. Sub-areas.. Sub-areas.. Sub-areas..
Perception Vision Audition Touch Propriocep-
tion
Cross-modal
Actuation Physical
skills
Tool use Navigation Propriocepti
on
Memory Implicit Working Episodic Semantic Procedural
Learning Imitation Reinforce-
ment
Dialogical Via Written
Media
Via
Experimenta
Lion
Reasoning Deduction Induction Abduction Causal Physical Association-
al
Planning Tactical Strategic Physical Social
Attention Visual Social Behavioral
Motivation Subgoal
creation
Affect-
based
Emotion Emotional
expression
Understand
ing
emotions
Perceiving
emotions
Control of
emotions
Modeling
self and
other
Self-
awareness
Theory of
mind
Self-control Other-
awareness
Empathy
Social
interaction
Appropriate
behavior
Social
commun-
ication
Social
inference
Cooperation
, e.g. group
play
Communicat
ion
Gestural Verbal Pictorial Language
acquisition
Cross-modal
Quantitative Counting
observed
entities
Grounded
small
number
arithmetic
Comparison
of
quantitative
properties of
observed
entities
Measure-
ment using
simple tools
Building/
creation
Physical
construction
w/ objects
Formation
of novel
concepts
Verbal
invention
Social
organization
Creating the Sputnik of AGI
The success of the OpenCog Toddler project will have implications far and wide. At this
stage, all that is needed to seed a massive global acceleration in the AGI field is one
truly compelling demonstration of machine intelligence -- one working, vividly
demonstrable software system that both embodies a serious scientific approach to AGI,
and also cries out to the naive viewer "This has the feel of being on the path to human-
level general intelligence!!!" Such a demonstration would serve as a "Sputnik of AGI",
inspiring others to put their energetic and financial resources into pursuing AGI as well.
One of our goals with the proposed project is to create precisely this "Sputnik of
AGI"
Specifically, what aspect of the OpenCog Toddler will have this Sputnik-like impact?
The main point is not to demonstrate any particular functionality, but rather to
demonstrate the capability to robustly learn new behaviors (where this learning
occurs via experimenting with the world and via communicating with human beings, not
via carefully supervised training on human-prepared training sets).
We aim to demonstrate this learning capability in the context of virtual world characters
and humanoid robots. (By a "virtual world" here we mean a 3D video game type world,
but without necessarily having the game-play associated with a video game.) The dual
focus on virtual characters and humanoid robots is necessary because of the limitations
of each of these modalities. Virtual worlds lack the richness of the physical world, yet
current robots lack robust sensors and manipulators. By using the same OpenCog AGI
mind to control both sorts of agents, we can overcome these limitations; the OpenCog
system is capable of integrating what it learns via its robot body with what it learns via
its virtual embodiment, into a single unified "mind-space."
The Big Picture: Beyond the AGI Toddler
While an "AGI toddler" will be a massive R&D achievement, obviously it is not of
particular practical value on its own. The OpenCog project has developed a longer-term
roadmap, in which the proposed 4 years of effort is merely the next phase. We are
focused on this phase currently, both because it's the next natural step in our R&D
work, and because we believe that it can serve as a "Sputnik of AGI" -- so that, once a
robust AGI toddler is demonstrated, large portions of the world will wake up to the
viability of achieving more and more powerful AGI in the near term. We strongly
suspect that, with a robust AGI toddler in hand, a large array of commercial and
government sources will find it in their interest to pursue further AGI development
toward a large variety of practical and research goals.
The next step beyond the AGI Toddler will be to further scale up and educate the
OpenCog AGI system, enabling it to cope with more complex learning such as the
typical elementary school curriculum, and with more complex physical tasks such as
would be required of a household service robot. This next step will enable the
development of a variety of "AGI specialists" carrying out tasks of humanitarian and
commercial value -- for instance, service robots, automated scientists, automated call
center agents, generally intelligent financial trading systems, and so forth (the list is
almost endless). Integration of these specialists within the integrative OpenCog
architecture will ultimately lead to a generally intelligent software system with the
common sense of an ordinary human, but a host of specialized capabilities going
beyond the human level. On the overall OpenCog roadmap, we conjecture that this
stage of "Human Level Plus" AGI may be achievable around 2023. Beyond this level,
further development will also be likely, but becomes even more difficult to chart in
details -- one gets into the territory of what Vernor Vinge, Ray Kurzweil and others have
called "The Singularity."
While this long-term picture is much of our motivation for pursuing the proposed R&D,
nevertheless in the context of the proposed 4 year project, our focus will be squarely on
achieving an AGI Toddler using OpenCog. Even starting from a well-articulated design
and a well-built codebase, as we are, this a very difficult technical challenge. Once we
have met this challenge, we will proceed to the next steps on the broader OpenCog
roadmap, leading toward ever more powerful AGI.
Use of Funds
To ensure that the proposed work is carried out effectively, the resources that we
request will be applied towards the following:
Management and Technical Leadership - The largest portion of the funding will be
used to pay experienced Al researchers and developers to carry out the proposed
R&D program. Technical leadership will be provided by a group of individuals already
experienced with the OpenCog project

• Dr. Ben Goertzel, Executive Director, primary author of the OpenCog Prime AGI
design and chief OpenCog project founder

• Dr. Joel Pitt, Director of AGI Development, OpenCog project co-founder and team
leader of current OpenCog Game Al project in Hong Kong

• Dr. Nil Geisweiller, Chief Scientist, with 4 years of OpenCog experience
• Dr. Zhenhua Cai, Lead AGI Developer, senior Al developer in current OpenCog
Game Al project [to receive PhD in 2012]

• Dr. Ruiting Lian, Lead NLP Developer, lead developer of OpenCog's language
generation and dialogue systems, to join OpenCog Game Al project in Fall 2012 [to
receive PhD in 2012]

• Dan Zwell, Director of Environments & Evaluation, experienced commercial
software developer, previously worked on video game Al using the Novamente
Cognition Engine, a direct predecessor of OpenCog
Technical Staff - The above technical leaders will be assisted in their work with 6 AGI
software developers focused on OpenCog development (two of whom, Jared Wigmore
and Deheng Huang, are current members of the OpenCog Game Al team), and 2
developers focused on the virtual world and robotics aspects.

• Facilities -- We anticipate physically locating the project in the M-Lab, a tech
incubator associated with Hong Kong Polytechnic University, where the OpenCog
Game Al project is currently situated

• Computing Hardware - The OpenCog Toddler project will require a modest amount
of advanced computer hardware, including development machines for staff, a network
of +5 powerful multiprocessor servers, and a GPU supercomputer such as an Nvidia
Kepler. Nevertheless, given the rapidly decreasing cost of advanced computing
hardware, this is a relatively small part of the total budget, estimated at < 10%.

• Robotics Hardware -- In the OpenCog lab at Xiamen University, we have worked with
the Aldebaran Nao robot; but for the OpenCog Toddler project we are more excited
about the new Hanson Robotics Robokind. These are small humanoid robots with
high-quality cameras, relatively capable hands, and humanlike facial expressions,
available for $15K each. We will begin by purchasing two of these for the project (two
so as to enable experimentation with social interaction), and then purchase further
robots for the project in subsequent years as robotics technology advances.
Project Strategy
The foundations of the proposed OpenCog Toddler project are

• the OpenCogPrime design for machine intelligence, spelled out in detail in
the 900-page multi-author manuscript Building Better Minds (which currently
exists as a rough draft available to interested parties, and is being edited and
refined with a view toward publication in 2012).
• the OpenCog codebase, which currently implements roughly 40% of the overall
OpenCog design (see http://openeog.org). It has been under development since
2008, building on code provided by Novamente LLC that was under development
since 2001. Most of the code is C++, but recently a significant percentage of
development being done in Python on top of the C++ core
In the proposed project, the remaining 60% of the OpenCogPrime design will be
implemented in the OpenCog codebase, and used for the control of virtual-world and
robotic agents, with a focus on enabling robust learning via experience and
communication.
OpenCog
OpenCogPrime (OCP) is a comprehensive architecture for cognition, language, and
virtual agent control, created by a team of Al experts led by Dr. Ben Goertzel during the
period since 2001 (and building on their work from the 1990s). Conceptually founded on
the systems theory of intelligence summarized in the 2006 book The Hidden Pattern
(and in more detail in the forthcoming book Building Better Minds), it is currently under
development within the open-source OpenCog Al framework . The architecture
combines multiple Al paradigms such as uncertain logic, computational linguistics,
evolutionary program learning and connectionist attention allocation in a unified
cognitive-science-based architecture. Cognitive processes embodying these different
paradigms interoperate together on a common neural-symbolic knowledge store called
the Atomspace.
OpenCog has been used for numerous commercial applications in the area of natural
language processing and data mining. For instance, in work with the Clinical Center of
the US National Institutes of Health, OpenCog's PLN reasoning and RelEx language
processing were combined to do automated biological hypothesis generation based on
information gathered from PubMed abstracts. Data mining applications have spanned
text classification, bioinformatics and computational finance. OpenCog has also been
used to control virtual agents in videogame type worlds (including current work in the M-
Lab, and earlier work controlling virtual dogs in Second Life and Multiverse) and
humanoid robots (in the BLISS Lab at Xiamen University).
While OpenCog is not closely based on the human brain, it derives its overall
architecture from cognitive science, and as such it shares some general properties with
human intelligence. One of these properties is a fundamental complexity that makes
the design difficult to summarize in one or two sentences. The brain consists of a host
of different regions, operating on similar principles yet with significant differences also,
each carrying out separate but overlapping functions, and interoperating with each other
constantly in subtle ways. Very few neuroscientists believe there is a single, simple
algorithm or structure underlying the brain's intelligence -- rather, there seems to be a
variety of interacting, complexly interrelated mechanisms. Similarly, OpenCog is a
complex design, which contains multiple memory stores corresponding roughly to the
types of human memory identified in cognitive science, and learning algorithms
corresponding to each type of memory.
One of the key principles of the OpenCog design is cognitive synergy, a technical
concept meaning very roughly that the different learning algorithms must interact in
such a way as to help each other scale to large problems. On its own, any one of
OpenCog's learning algorithms would choke on large problems, due to what computer
scientists call "combinatorial explosion" (the existence of far too many combinations of
observations and data items and conjectures, for any algorithm to be able to blindly
search through them all). However, the overall architecture is designed in such a way
that, when one algorithm begins to run into a combinatorial explosion, the others can
help it out. It seems likely that the human brain obeys a similar conceptual principle,
though manifested in different ways. The various memory stores and algorithms in
OpenCog all use a probability-theoretic semantics to represent knowledge (sometimes
among other means), which provides a clean and simple framework within which
cognitive-synergetic dynamics may operate. Tables 2 and 3 below briefly review some
of the key knowledge structures and cognitive algorithms in the system.
Table 2. Key Memory Types and Corresponding OpenCog Knowledge Structures
Memory Type OpenCogPrime Knowledge Structure
Declarative The AtomTable, which is a special form of weighted, labeled hypergraph — i.e. a
table of nodes and links (collectively referred to as Atoms) with different types, and
each weighted with a multi-dimensional truth value (embodying an "indefinite
probability" value that give both probability and confidence information).
Attentional Atoms in the AtomTable are weighted with AttentionValue objects, which contain
both ShortTermlmportance values (governing processor time allocation) and
LongTerm Importance values (governing memory usage).
Procedural This is handled using special "Combo" tree structures embodying LISP-like
programs, in a special program dialed intended to manage behaviors in a virtual
world and actions in the AtomTable
Sensory Handled via a collection of specialized sense-modality-specific data structures
Episodic Handled via an internal simulation world that allows the system to run "mind's eye
movies" of situations it remembers, has heard about, or hypothetically envisions.
Intentional Goals are represented by Atoms stored in the AtomTable; there is a separate table
indicating which Atoms are top-level goals, which is used to guide attention
allocation and goal refinement processes
Table 3. OpenCog's Key Cognitive Algoritms
Cognitive
Process
OpenCogPrime algorithm
Uncertain
inference
Probabilistic Logic Networks (PLN), a logical inference framework capable of
uncertain reasoning about abstract knowledge, everyday commonsense knowledge,
and low-level perceptual and motor knowledge
Supervised
procedure
learning
MOSES, a probabilistic evolutionary teaming algorithm, which learns procedures
(represented as LISP-like program trees) based on specifications
Attention
allocation
Economic Attention Networks (ECAN), a framework for allocating (memory and
processor) attention among items of knowledge and cognitive processes, utilizing a
synthesis of ideas from neural networks and artificial economics. ECAN also
comes with a forgetting agent that either saves to disk or deletes knowledge that is
estimated not sufficiently valuable to keep in memory.
Map formation Use of frequent subgraph mining, MOSES and other algorithms to scan the
knowledge base of the system for patterns and then embodying these patterns
explicitly as new knowledge items
Concept
creation
A collection of heuristics for forming new concepts via combining existing ones,
including conceptual blending, mutation and extensional and intensional logical
operators
Simulation The running of simulations of (remembered or imagined) external-world scenarios in
an internal world-simulation engine
Goal refinement Transformation of given goals into sets of subgoals, using concept creation,
inference and procedure learning
Perception and
Actuation
Sensory and motor processing are handled in OpenCog via the DeSTIN
architecture, a software system originally created by Dr. Itamar Arel (at the
University of Tennessee, Knoxville), which uses hierarchical spatiotemporal memory
networks to enable scalable perception, state inference and reinforcement-learning-
guided action.
Environments and Evaluation for Generally Intelligent Agents
One of the most important issues in any long-term research project is how to gauge
incremental progress. How do we know we're getting closer and closer to our end goal
of advanced AGI?
The commonplace practice of identifying highly specific tasks and then comparing the
performance of various systems on these tasks, doesn't work well for AGI, because for
any highly specific task there is likely to be a reasonably effective "narrow Al" solution.
The crux of AGI is the capability to generalize and perform broadly beyond specific
tasks; but this is a more difficult thing to test.
These issues were discussed in depth at the 2009 AGI Roadmap Workshop, mentioned
above. Among the key conclusions reached there was that, even though it's difficult to
formulate precise tests that are naturally applicable across different AGI paradigms, it's
less problematic to identify environments and tasks that multiple AGI researchers can
agree are appropriate.
With this in mind, our approach in the proposed project is to create environments, with
associated task sets, suitable for evaluating the behavior of various approaches to AGI,
and assessing their progress toward advanced AGI. The goal is not to posit any single
"AGI la test" but rather to create tools suitable for evaluating AGI systems according to
a variety of appropriate criteria. Refining the details of the task sets is something the
Scientific Advisory Board will be very helpful with.
Videogame Agents
Our current OpenCog Game Al project at the M-Lab involves using OpenCog to control
a game character in a game world loosely modeled on the commercial game Minecraft
(in which a wide variety of objects and scenarios may be created via manipulating small
blocks). The game design and engineering aspect of this work will be extended to
create a more general Minecraft-like environment, suitable for testing the full variety of
cognitive capabilities expected of a human-level AGI. Nearly the full spectrum of
intelligence testing tasks used to evaluate the cognitive capabilities of young human
children may be implemented in this context. In addition to its research value, this
evaluation environment possesses obvious value in terms of assessing the readiness of
AGI systems for deployment in a commercial gaming context.
Humanoid Robotics
The OpenCog system is now being used to control a Nao humanoid robot, in the Brain-
Like Intelligent SystemS (BLISS) Lab at Xiamen University, in China. The interface
between OpenCog and the Nao uses the ROS Robot Operating System created by
Willow Garage, which may easily be utilized for other Al systems besides OpenCog,
and for other robots besides the Nao. Via refining and extending the software currently
used to connect OpenCog to the Nao, we can relatively easily create a general
framework for AGI-robot interaction.
Given a general interface of this nature, what remains to create a robust environment
for evaluating AGI systems in a robotics context, is to create a robot lab environment
providing sufficiently rich interactions within the restrictions posed by the sensors and
actuators of affordably available robots (such as the Hanson Robotics Robokind). This
is a relatively simple matter, requiring only some systematic experimentation regarding
the available robots' precise capabilities. Such an environment would have clear utility
for research and also for the evaluation of the readiness of AGI systems to control toy or
household service robots in a commercial setting.
Four Year Plan
A high-level plan for the proposed four-year project is as follows, assuming project
initiation in January 2012.
Year 1: 2012
Key Accomplishments in Year 1
Example internal
OpenCog
achievements

• Simple English dialogue regarding scenes in the virtual world
• Complete integration with DeSTIN for vision processing, enabling basic
object and event recognition in the robot lab

• Complete integration with ROS for flexible robot control in robot lab
environment, allowing execution of complex motor plans

• Tune inference engine for spatiotemporal inference in videogame and robot
lab contexts, allowing commonsense reasoning about simple situations
Environments &
Evaluation

• Completion of video-game world environment for evaluating AGI systems
• Implementation of simple (ROS based) humanoid-robot API enabling AGI
systems to easily interact with robots

• Outfitting of simple humanoid robot lab for AGI experimentation
Example behavioral
milestone
achievements

• Ability to hold simple English conversations about what its virtual agent or
robotic environment sees and does, evincing basic "commonsense
understanding" in the limited contexts of its virtual world and robot lab

• The scope of conversations will include all the major types of speech act
delineated by Speech Act theory

• In the virtual world: ability to build structures from blocks to help it achieve
its goals, e.g. hiding from an attacker, reaching a high-up object, building a
bridge between one place and another
Year 2: 2013
Key Accomplishments in Year 2
Example internal
OpenCog
achievements

• Completion of an integrated, OpenCog-based "proto-AGI mind"
• Ability to improve language understanding and generation capability via
experience

• Robust question answering regarding situations in the virtual world and
robot lab, based on integration of inference with other cognitive functions

• Formation of new concepts in response to new situations and environments
• Integration of knowledge from large databases with experiential knowledge
Environments &
Evaluation

• Implementation of a spectrum of intelligence-testing tasks within the video-
game environment
• Completion of the creation of a robot-lab environment suitable for AGI
experimentation
Example behavioral
milestone
achievements

• When the agent is put in new situations, it is able to form new concepts as
needed for achieving simple goals, and then use simple English to
generate questions or answers about these concepts

• Example: If the agent has never seen a small animal before (only humans,
robots and inanimate objects), then after watching it for a while, it may be
asked to follow, attract or capture the animal, and describe what it's doing.
(Obviously the specifics of this example would be different in the virtual
world and robot lab cases.) If it's then exposed to a second kind of small
animal, it should be able to appropriately generalize what it has learned
from interacting with the first one.

• Ability to build blocks structures in the virtual world that imitate things it has
seen in pictures, or has been shown in the virtual world

• Ability to build simple blocks structures in the robot lab
Year 3: 2014
Key Accomplishments in Year 3
Example internal
OpenCog
achievements

• Increase in the system's learning and reasoning capability, leading to
more useful performance on practical tasks

• Use of abstract inference to draw new conclusions combining knowledge
derived from experience with knowledge derived from databases and text
corpuses

• Scalable implementation on a reasonably large distributed network
• Feedback enabling cognition to guide the details of perception and action

• Generalization of knowledge and intuition back and forth between virtual-
world and robot domain
Environments &
Evaluation

• Systematic intelligence testing of AGI systems in the video-game and data-
analysis environments
• Implementation of a suite of intelligence-testing tasks in the robot lab
environment
Example behavioral
milestone
achievements

• If the agent is shown an object it has never seen but has only been told
about verbally, or read about, it can use this knowledge to figure out what to
do with it.

• If the agent is shown an object in the virtual world and learns what to do
with it, then when it's shown a similar object in the robot lab, it can quickly
understand it ... and vice versa

• In the virtual world: Ability to build complex blocks structures collaboratively
with others, to achieve goals

• Ability to build simple blocks structures in the robot lab
• Ability to describe complex blocks structures and other physical or virtual
entities and situations using complex sentences with multiple phrases and
clauses, and series of linked sentences.

• In the virtual world: Ability to learn new, reasonably complex behaviors via
following instructions, asking questions when needed
Year 4: 2015
Key Accomplishments in Year 4
Example internal
OpenCog
achievements

• Robot control outside the "robot playroom" in a broader indoor office
context
• Creative invention in the virtual world Al context

• Flexible natural language dialogue, involving understanding and production
of complex sentences
Environments &
Evaluation

• Systematic intelligence testing of AGI systems in the video-game and data-
analysis and robot lab environments

• Addition of new intelligence tests to the various environments, in order to
test the more advanced levels of intelligence that the AGI systems have
achieved
Example behavioral
milestone
achievements

• In the robot lab: ability to build moderately complex blocks structures and
describe and answer questions about them (this is basically a matter of
having sufficiently advanced vision and motor control, as the cognitive
aspects would have been achieved in the virtual world long before)

• Ability to construct new entities using blocks and other available materials,
qualitatively different from things it's seen before, and discuss what it has
done and why

• Ability to encounter new entities, ask questions about them, and figure out
how to practically utilize them based on the answers
• Ability to learn from a combination of observation and dialogue, how to
carry out new activities like (e.g.) tag or hide-and seek, or particular sorts of
collective blocks play
In reflecting on the behavioral milestones in the above tables, it's important to recall that
the project goal is not to specifically tune the system for a set of specific milestone tasks
each year. This would produce an interesting virtual world or robot toddler system, but
not a platform for the creation of increasingly powerful AGI. Rather, the goal is to create
a progressively more intelligent proto-AGI system using the OpenCog design and
codebase, and use it to control a virtual agent and humanoid robot, and then test and
demonstrate its capabilities using an assemblage of demonstrable and measurable
tasks, like the ones outlined above. The real point is not the specific tasks but rather
the cognitive capabilities underlying them, which will constitute the same sort of basic
"commonsense understanding" that underlies a human toddler's thinking -- and will then
serve as a platform for further AGI development, in a multitude of scientifically,
pragmatically and commercially valuable directions.
Organizational Structure and Management
Business Structure
The possibilities exist to structure the OpenCog Toddler via either a non-profit or for-
profit enterprise.
On the nonprofit side, it would be straightforward to affiliate the project with a university
(e.g. Hong Kong Polytechnic University, that hosts the current OpenCog Hong Kong
project focused on video game AGI); however, in practical terms this affiliation would
result in extra expenditure due to university overheads. The M-Lab tech incubator,
where the current OpenCog Hong Kong project is focused, hosts both university and
non-university projects. So the most efficient nonprofit route would likely be to host the
proposed project in the M-Lab, but funded via an external nonprofit rather than by a
grant to the university. Two nonprofits that could potentially serve this role would be the
OpenCog Foundation, or Humanity+ (a US nonprofit with 501(c)-3 status, which
operates in close collaboration with the OpenCog Foundation). Project leader Dr. Ben
Goertzel holds Board-level roles in both these organizations. In any case, the
foundation selected would then transfer funds to the M-Lab periodically (e.g. quarterly)
as needed.
On the for-profit side, it would be simple to operate the project via Novamente LLC, an
Al consulting and research company founded and operated by proposer Dr. Ben
Goertzel. The OpenCog codebase is an outgrowth of code initially created by
Novamente LLC during 2001-2008 under the name "Novamente Cognition Engine," and
then open-sourced in 2008; since that time Novamente LLC staff have continued to
contribute to the OpenCog codebase, and Novamente is a co-sponsor of the OpenCog
Hong Kong Game Al project.
Potentially, it would also be viable to create a new firm to operate the OpenCog Toddler
project, with a variety of business models, including game Al, toy robotics, service
robotics, or AGI more broadly. It would also be viable to operate the proposed project
via some other existing commercial entity. We are committed to preserving the open-
source nature of the project, as we strongly feel this is best for promoting AGI progress
overall. However, a variety of different business models and formal structures are
consistent with OSS software development, and we are open to exploring these.
Organizational Structure
The formal organization structure suggested for the proposed project is outlined below.
The upper levels of the org chart may vary slightly depending on the business structure,
but almost everything from the Executive Director down should be independent of
business structure.

• Management Board
• Scientific Advisory Board
• Executive Director: Dr. Ben Goertzel
• Chief Scientist: Dr. Nil Geisweiller

• Director of AGI Development: Dr. Joel Pitt
• Lead AGI Developer: Dr. Zhenhua Cai
• Lead NLP Developer: Dr. Ruiting Lian

• AGI Developer: Jared Wigmore
• AGI Developer: Deheng Huang
• 4 additional AGI Developers: TBD
• Director of Environments and Evaluation: Daniel Zwell

• Virtual-World Software Developer: TBD
• Robotics Software Developer: TBD
• Software Tester: TBD
• Computer System Administrator: TBD

• Administrative Assistant: TBD
Management Board
The management board will meet biannually to monitor the progress of the project, and
will approve all new Director-level staff hired under the initiative's budget. The
management board will initially be composed of Dr. Ben Goertzel, Dr. Gino Yu and one
or more representatives appointed by the project donors.
Scientific Advisory Board
The project's Scientific Advisory Board (SAB) will world's leading AGI researchers,
selected due to the overlap of their research with the specific R&D being pursued at the
in the project. A small amount of funds will be set aside each year to allow SAB
members to visit and collaborate on research
The initial members of the Scientific Advisory Board are:

• Itamar Arel (University of Tennesee, Knoxville)
• Joscha Bach (University of Humboldt)
• Pei Wang (Temple University)
• Paul Rosenbloom (University of Southern California)
with a handful of additions expected.
Executive Director
The project's Executive Director, Dr. Ben Goertzel, will lead the overall project, and also
participate in research and development as appropriate. He will also assist the
Directors of AGI Development and Environments & Evaluation in project management
of their teams.
Chief Scientist
The central role of the Chief Scientist, Dr. Nil Geisweiller, will be to ensure that the AGI
development occurring is done in accordance with the OpenCog plans and
documentation; and to appropriately update the OpenCog plans, theory and
documentation in accordance with what is learned in the course of the project. These
responsibilities will not generally be a full-time occupation and hence Dr. Geisweiller will
also participate in hands-on AGI development.
Director of AGI Development
The Director of AGI Development, Dr. Joel Pitt, will lead the implementation work on the
project, including the allocation of tasks to the other AGI developers and the review of
code and validation of successful task completion. He will also participate in AGI
software design and development as time permits!
AG! Software Developers
The heart of the project team will consist of 8 AGI software developers working together
to implement the OpenCog AGI design for intelligent agent control. Half of these
developers are already experienced with OpenCog development, including Lead AGI
Developer Zhenhua Cai, and Lead NLP Developer Ruiting Lian (both of whom will
complete their PhDs in 2012).
Director of Environments & Evaluation; Virtual Worlds Developer; and Robotics
Developer
Creating environments for AGI agents to live and learn in, and tests to evaluate AGI
agent intelligence, are significant tasks independent of AGI development itself. The
Director of Environments & Evaluation will coordinate this effort, playing a technical lead
and project management role, assisted by two junior software developers, one focusing
on the virtual world environment and one on the robots and robot lab. This role will
initially be played by Daniel Zwell, who in 2007 worked on the predecessor to OpenCog
within Novamente LLC, and has more recently been leading a small commercial
software development team in Shanghai.
Software Testing and System Administration
So that the AGI software developers may focus strictly on AGI, the team will be
supported by a full-time software tester (who will perform a combination of bug testing
and intelligence testing) and a system administrator (who will assist with maintaining the
robots as well as the computer hardware, and also deal with any issues regarding
maintenance of the code and documentation repositories).
Preliminary Budget
A preliminary budget for the proposed project is as follows:
Category Annual Cost in USD
Salary (incl. pension. medical) 5575K
Computing hardware S50K
Travel for Scientific Advisory Board
visits
S15K
Travel for Project Staff S10K
Office (rent. AC. etc.) S70K
Robots S20K
Accounting & Legal 510K
Total S750K
with a detailed breakout of the main expense (salaries) below. Specific salary numbers
for named individuals are withheld below for privacy reasons, but have been estimated
somewhat carefully. Further financial details may be shared with serious potential
donors or investors upon request.
Title Name Estimated annual salary
in USD before overheads
Executive Director Dr. Ben Goertzel
Chief Scientist Dr. Nil Geisweiller —
Director of AGI Development Dr. Joel Pitt "'
Director of Environments &
Evaluation
Daniel Zwell "'
Lead AGI Developer Dr. Zhenhua Cai "'
Lead NLP Developer Dr. Rutting Lian "'
AGI Developer Jared Wigmore "'
Title Name Estimated annual salary
in USD before overheads
AGI Developer Deheng Huang "••
AGI Developer TBD S25K
AGI Developer TBD S25K
AGI Developer TBD S25K
AGI Developer TBD S25K
Virtual World Software
Developer
TBD 525K
Robotics Software Developer TBD S25K
Software Tester TBD S15K
System Administrator TBD S15K
Administrative Assistant TBD 510K
Total Salary Before Overhead -- 5520K
Total Salary Including
Pension & Health Insurance
-- 5575K
Computing hardware needs will be determined as the project unfolds, but are roughly
envisioned to include:

• Development laptops for each developer that needs one (to be replaced in 2014)
• At least 2 multiprocessor servers with generous RAM purchased per year (e.g. a
current OpenCog server has 16 processors and 96BG RAM)

• In 2012, an Nvidia Kepler GPU supercomputer; and potentially updated versions
later as they are released
Regarding robots, in 2012 we will purchase 2 Robokind from Hanson Robotics, at a cost
of roughly $15K each. Further robotics purchases will depend on the technology
available, which is hard to foresee in advance, as robotics is a rapidly developing field.
Possibilities include augmenting the Robokind with additional sensors such as artificial
skin as this becomes available.
EFTA01579877 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2011-07-28 13:55:00)
Jul-28-2011 01:55 PM JPMorgan Chase 302-634-5955 4/4
GHISLAINE MAXWELL
Tel
Mgreotandum
To: Janet, JI' Morgan
From: Mistake Maxwell
Date: 41315bot Gbisbant
Account
Please transfer Sixty Five Thousand Dollars & 00/100 (565,000) from the above account
to:
Bank Nene: Signature Bank
Routing number:
Account number.
Account name: George V. Deleon Associates
ID: 036107281345596 DATE: 07/28/2011 17-..56:00 Page 4 of 4 DID: 8887316607 CSID: 302-634-5955 INDEX1: INDEX2:
Confidential Treatment Requested by JPMorgan Chase JPM-SDNY-00059102
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Debbie Fein [lawyer] Epstein civil attorney in Epstein v. Scott Rothstein, Brad Edwards, & L.M. 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00180294 (Jmail)
 [legal] letter from Jay Lefkowitz to SDFL
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Samuel C. Klagsbrun [medical] psychiatrist, treated women in Epstein's circle 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01118550 (Jmail)
 [academia] bill for psychiatric services by Samuel C. Klagsbrun
(date: 2011-07-31)
Samuel C. Klagsbrun, M.D.
595 Madison Avenue
Suite 2000
New York, NY 10022
BILL TO/PATIENT:
license #0905,5
$00 Cross River Road
Katonah. NY 10536
STATEMENT PERIOD:
July 1, 2011 - July 31, 2011
For professional services:
Date Description Amount
07/01/201-1
07/05/2011
Previous balance
1 N c>.c -1 (...:- , I t $ 400.00
400.00
07/12/2011 >e cm 400.00
07/19/2011 400.00
07/28/2011 400.00
Balance due $ 2000.00
Provider Tax ID 132698221
Diagnosis: 309.24
Provider NPI 1508083437
Please remit your payment within 30 days, payable to DR. KLAGSBRUN. Most major credit cards accepted. If you
have any questions, please call Renee Sibrizzi at ext. 2222. Thank you.
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Tancredi Marchiolo [finance] hedge fund manager, Bremner Capital Management 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02025218 (Jmail)
 [misc] 
(date: 2011-09-09)
To: <REDACTED>
do you want me to try to do her.. or just torture her on fri); Sep 9[@); 2011 at
2:31 PMMI: Tancredi Marchiolo( ; wrote:M)
Subject: Re: From: jeevacation@gmail.com
╔══════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ken Jenne [victim lawyer] Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler attorney 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01616597 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2011-10-07 11:57:55)
Platform: SMS Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739 Jessica
+1 (212) 533-3739 +1 (561) 715-5887
2010/01/20
Jessica
I hope you have a wonderful birthday!!! 000000
Enjoy you day in solitude 0
02:19:26 pm
2010/01/31
Jessica
Your buddy dershowitz is at this event I'm working
11:56:32 pm
1212 5333739
Introduce yourself , what event , not a Jewish one I hope what about bj
11:58:09 pm
2010/02/01
Jessica
Yes some jewish thing. I'm leaving in a sec to go to Collette to work a non-Jewish more
fun job! 0
He's the featured Jew at this one though!
12:00:58 am
2010/02/05
Jessica
Can u give me ok to have investigators keep on LM?
01:15:02 am
2010/04/02
Jessica
Your email is kicking everything back??
11:25:36 pm
1212 5333739
2010/04/05
Jessica
Mediation starting at 10.
01:02:35 pm
2011/05/28
Jessica
Re send tomorrow
11:45:51 pm
1212 5333739
News?
11:00:23 pm
Jojo knows about the move on Tues
11:01:36 pm
No she went to Mexico with her girlfriends so I won't talk to her until she gets back.
She sent me a text early this AM from airport telling me she decided to go.
11:01:40 pm
What move?
11:02:15 pm
1212 5333739
That she left for weekend
11:03:22 pm
•
•
•
Jessica
Why does jojo know?
11:06:39 pm
•
•
•
•
I knew she was thinking about going but tix were too expensive. They apparently
dropped in price
11:09:22 pm
2011/05/29
Jessica
I sent you Im federal. If u don't get tell me file is big
11:15:16 pm
Jessica
Can u talk?
01:52:09 am
Jessica
Jessica Diaz
Elizabeth valar
r
04:50:43 am
2011/05/30
2011/06/03
2011/06/09
1212 5333739
Got
•
12:29:36 am
1212 5333739
I'm in Paris
09:40:57 am
•
1212 5333739
Who are they
06:04:00 am
Jessica
Elizabeth Villar worked w Ken jenne and Cara. Jesika diaz did all the fraudulent
property transfers. They are gfs. Talk to Liz Villar.
04:17:41 pm
•
•
•
Found out last nite that jenne was working with feds. And Cara worked under jenne at
rra,
05:43:36 pm
Jessica
I can't call now. I'm driving my divorce client to airport
06:17:26 pm
Jessica
Ok
09:05:40 pin
2011/06/10
1212 5333739
2127729416
06:13:00 pm
1212 5333739
Now?
08:35:58 pm
1212 5333739
Ask her about how she knows the ken jenne info
06:22:42 pm
2011/06/26
1212 5333739
News?
04:47:40 pm
Jessica
•
•
Nothing of major significance. We haven't had a chance to really talk given her family
issues. But r u in states? If so I'll call u tomorrow
08:24:55 pm
2011/06/28
2011/07/03
Jessica
I'm leaving Delray now and heading up to WPB. You up?
11:58:07 am
Ok im like 30 away
11:59:14 am
1212 5333739
Ny tomorow
09:26:56 pm
1212 5333739
Tom 212-7509895
10:51:39 am
1212 5333739
Waiting for you
11:57:55 am
2011/10/07
Jessica
•
•
•
B found a zip drive with emails not sure what's in it yet
05:06:10 am
1212 5333739
Thanks , I'm still in Europe
07:45:49 am
Will she let you see them , or summarize for you
11:12:29am
Jessica
Probably. Last night was first I heard of it
04:20:31 pm
Jessica
U ever coming back?
04:21:49 pm
???
04:16:48 pm
Thanks
04:19:13 pm
1212 5333739
Mon
04:20:55 pm
2011/10/11
1212 5333739
News?
02:23:05 am
Jessica
No I haven't had a chance to call her back yet. Been too busy here contemplating
suicide or homicide.
01:18:04 pm
2011/10/12
1212 5333739
No , guy was my attny st the time
07:18:49 pm
Jessica
Was villafana employed by guy Lewis in Aug 2008?
07:19:46 pin
1212 5333739
Why?
07:20:24 pm
Sent
Jessica
That's what I thought...
07:21:56 pin
B asked. I'm trying to figure out why. PS... Glad the lost motion to dismiss.
07:22:46 pm
V Read
EFTA00002298 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2011-11-11)
MENNE MO
FOE MOM ASISTIOA
I CILOSSTOII a TOCIMINTO
WIFR DaSOCON,101
RiS
U
111111
IE  U1 0

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002905 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2011-11-11)
Designed by Apple in California Assembled in China Model Number: A1419 100-240V—, 50.60Hz 4A. Apparaten
skall anslutas till jordat nätuttag. CAN ICES-3 (B)/NMB-3(B) Contains FCC ID: QDS-BRCM1070 and IC:4324A-BRCM1070
Ill I I HMI IIII 111111 IIII I IIII IIIIIIII II III Serial No.: CO2NM1MOFY14 EMCNo.: 2806
EFTA00007606 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2011-11-11)
amazon.com.
Billing Address:
Jeffrey Epstein
358 El Brillo Way
Palm Beach, Florida 33480
USA
Amazon.coni
amazon.com. 1850 Mercer Rd.
Lexington, KY 40511
Jeffrey Epstein
358 El Brillo Way
Palm Beach, Honda 33480
USA
Ai rbrd57708/-3-/next/ 2436223 SOR1ExtFastTrae:
Your order of September 4, 2005 (Order ID 103-1737520-450864W
Qty. Wm
IN THIS SHIPMENT
SM 101: A Realistic Introduction
Wiseman, Jay --- Paperback
f" C-2 "I 0963976389
•
Shipping Address:
Jeffrey Epstein
358 El Brill° Way
Palm Beach, Florida 33480
USA
1
SlaveCraft: Roadmaps for Erotic Servitude --Principles, Skills and Tools
Baldwin, Guy --- Paperback
I" C-2 "/ 1881943143
Training With Miss Abernathy: A Workbook for Erotic Slaves and Their
Owners
Abernathy. Christina --- Paperback
l" C-2 01 1890159077
Item Price
Subtotal
Shipping & I kindling
Order Total
Paid via Amex
Balance due
This shipment •ompletes your order.
Total
http://www.enanen.com
Your Account
For detailed information about this and other orders, please visit
Your Account. You can also print invoices, change your e-mail
address and payment settings, alter your communicatioc
preferences, and much more - 24 hours a day - at
http://www.amazon.com/your-accoun.
Returns Ale Easy!
Visit http://www.amaion.com/retums to return any item -
including gifts - in unopened or original condition within 30
days for a full refund (other restrictions apply). Please have
your order ID ready.
$16.47 $16.47
$15.95 $15.95 I Thanks for shopping at Arnazon.corr, and ple,.se
come again!
$11.95 $11.95
$4437
$24.46
$68.83
$68.83
$0.00 I I. amazop.coo'ed m:
rbrdi77Rt; SOR 1 I. x F.t.t 1 ra k/next/2436223/0912-19:30/0911-19,15/mreed Box or Pad: (71.1.B I2X9X2
III III1111111111 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII III
FcdEx l Ship Manager l Label Page 1 of I
From Origin C'
JEFFREY E. EPSIEIN
4111 FLOOR
NEWYORK. NY 10022
Jeffrey,.
358 El Brillo Way
Palm Beach, FL 33480
E
ELL SENDER
Shio Date 1gggpos
Actual WO 2 LB
Syskiinti It I3e640NEy2200
Account', S .........
REF. mal ll
lit [lilt llll II' I Oo fi ery Ad es Ea Coce
Hil 111111
PRIORITY OVERNIGHT
IRO
3348O -FL-US
RES
I 'SW
)20 I
TUE
Deliver By
20SEP05
FLL AA
XH LNAA
Shipping Label: Your shipment Is complete

1. Use the 'Print' feature from your browser to send tnis page to your laser or inkjet printer.
2. Fold the printed page along the horizontal line

3. Place label in shipping pouch and affx it to your shipment so that the tarcode portion of the Inset Can be read and 
scanned.Warning: Use only the printed original label for
shipping. Using a photocopy of this label for shipping purposes is fraudulent and could result in additional billing 
charges, along with the cancellation of your FedEx account number.
Use of this system constitutes yow agreement to the service cc ndrOns in the current FecEx Service Guide available on 
leder corn FedEx will rot be responsible for any claim it excess
of St 00 per package. whether the result of loss, damage, delay. non-delvery.rosdelivery, or misirformabon. unless you 
decare a hgher value. pay ar additional charge. document your
actual loss and Ile a timely claim. Linstaticns turd in Me cuTent Feats Service Gude apply. Your right to reCOve- from 
FedEx for any loss. including intrirsic value or the package.
loss of sates. income .ntarest profit. attorney's fees, costs. and other forms of damage whetter direct. incidental, 
consequential, or special is limited to tie greater of $100 or Me
authorized declared value. Recovery cannot exceed actual documented loss. maximum for Items of extraordinary value is 
550), e g. Jewelry. predous metals, negotable instrumerts and
other items listed in our Service Guide Written claims must be filed within strict time knits. see current redEx Servos 
Guide.
littps://www.fedex.corrilegi-bthishiP_Wunity/31iUv5FiRx0kUq2BcRw0HbQr4AgXt6laUr... 9/19/2005
EFTA00007704 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA02179121 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2011-12-06 20:43:38)
To:
Cc:
Lesley
Groff(
From: ecile de Jongh
Sent: Tue 12/6/2011 8:43:38 PM
Subject: Re: Westin St. John Dock
I spoke with him and go the times. Here is the boat schedule:
Friday, December 9:
7:00 PM JE drop off for dinner with group
9:30 PM JE pick up from dinner
Saturday. December 10:
9:15 AM JE drop off for morning meetings
12:00 PM group pick up for transfer to LSJ for lunch
2:30 PM group drop off
9:30 PM JE pick up after dinner
Sunday. December 11:
9:15 AM JE drop off
3:00 PM JE, Nowak, Minsky and Rudisch pick up and transfer to LSJ
With warm regards,
Cecile
DISCLAIMER: The information contained in this e-mail may be privileged,confidential, and
protected from disclosure. If you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified
that any dissemination, distribution or duplication of this communication is strictly
prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the sender
immediately and delete all copies.
From
To:
Cecile Jonah
es y Groff
en t: I uesaay, uecemoer
Subject: Re: Westin St. John Dock
I asked him today and he said he would know more this evening so let's hope he does
Sent from my iPhone
On 6 Dec 2011, at 15:43, wrote:
Good afternoon All,
The following information is what we have, but will need further information from
JE
Carlos will be JE's boat captain
will be working the boat to pick up the guests for the Sat
Luncheon
Do not have a start/finish time for the luncheon and do not have JE schedule for
his comings and goings, hence would suggest that we get this info  and then
onward all details in one complete E Mail
can you see if you can get times from JE, I also will ask when I see
him
Warmest regards
On Tuc, Dec 6, 2011 at 2:04 PM,
wrote:
Sent from my iPhone
Begin forwarded message:
From: Cecile de Jongh
Date: December 6, 2011 2:42:15 PM AST
To: , Brice Gordon
Cc: Lesley Groff MEMI==
Subject: Fwd: Westin St. John Dock
Can one of you let me know this info. Needed ASAP.
With warm regards,
Cecile
Sent from my iPhone
Begin forwarded message:
From: "Judi Nagelberg"
Date: December 6, 2011 2:00:38 PM GMT -04:00
To: "'Cecile de Jonah"'
Cc:
Subject: FW: Westin St. John Dock
Hi Cecile:
The Director of Security at The Westin has requested
the timing of Jeffrey's boat coming on and off the dock
to attend the meetings/functions for this weekend.
Can you forward this to the appropriate person to
make arrangements? The boat will be unable to
remain on the dock. They will have to drop off and
pick up as needed.
If you can copy me on the response, that would be
helpful.
Many thanks!
Warm regards,
Judi
Judi Nagelberg
President
Island Meetin s & Incentives, Inc.
From: Jarvis, Darcy [mailto:
Sent: Tuesda December 06, 2011 1:45 PM
To
Cc: Shelton, Anissia; Hodge, Kevin
Subject: Westin St. John Dock
Good afternoon Ms. Nagelberg,
We understand that we will be having a guest attend the functions
that will need to drop off and pick-up from the
Westin Dock in Great Cruz Bay. We will be more
than happy to assist them with that. Is it possible
to have the boat captain's contact number, as I
would like to confirm the anticipated times. As you
may already know, the Dock is quite busy between
current in-house vendors, arriving/departing
associates for work, as well as arriving and
departing guests. By confirming the times we can
be sure that there isn't a conflict with another
boat's arrival time, and in addition, we can note
their arrivals and departures in our log book so our
staff can anticipate the boat's arrival and assist if
necessary. Because our Dock does service boats
that go over International waters, we like to
maintain an accurate record of all incoming and
outgoing boats for the Coast Guard.
We look forward to assisting you in any way we can.
Have a wonderful afternoon.
Warm regards,
D'ARCY
JARVIS Director of Security
THE WESTIN ST. JOHN RESORT AND VII I \ti
worm ',non coin on
This electronic message transmission contains information from the Company
that may be proprietary, confidential and/or privileged.
The information is intended only for the use of the
individual(s) or entity named above. If you arc not the
intended recipient, be aware that any disclosure, copying
or distribution or use of the contents of this information
is prohibited. If you have received this electronic
transmission in error, please notify the sender
immediately by replying to the address listed in the
"From:" field.
LSJ,LLC
Island Manager
6I00 Red Hook Quarters Suite B3
St Thomas
USVI 00802
EFTA00005740 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2012-02-01)
Patrick Lawton
General Manager
1'a 1 of I
ti le:///C:(Usets/I AppDatatocal/M ierosoft/W indows/Tem porarr/020Intemet%... 7/2/20 1 9
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Silvio!. Mono liuddIng
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New Yank, New York 10007
July 5, 2019
Re: Grand Jury Subpoena
Please be advised that the accompanying grand jury subpoena has been issued in connection with
an official criminal investigation of a suspected felony being conducted by a federal grand jury. The
Government hereby requests that you voluntarily refrain from disclosing the existence of the subpoena to
any third party. While you are under no obligation to comply with our request, we are requesting you not
to make any disclosure in order to preserve the confidentiality of the investigation and because disclosure
of the existence of this investigation might interfere with and impede the investigation.
Moreover, if you intend to disclose the existence of this subpoena to a third party, please let me
know before making any such disclosure.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
By:
Very truly yours,
GEOFFFEY S. BERMAN
t Mired States Attorney
Assistant United States Attorneys

(212) 637-2415
Advice of Rights
1. You may refuse to answer any question if a truthful answer to the question would tend to incriminate you.

2. Anything that you do say may be used against you by the grand jury or in a subsequent legal proceeding.

3. If you have a lawyer, the grand jury will permit you a reasonable opportunity to step outside the grand jury room to 
consult with your lawyer if you so desire.

4. If you would like a lawyer but do not have funds to retain one, you may make an application to the United States 
Magistrate Judge who will decide whether to appoint a lawyer to
represent you.
Grand Jur) Subrxsena
pititebeStzttezpiztritt court SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
TO:
GREETINGS:
WE COMMAND YOU that all and singular business and excuses being laid aside, you appear and attend before
the GRAND JURY of the people of the United States for the Southern District of New York, at the United States
Courthouse, 40 Foley Square, Room 220, in the Borough of Manhattan, City of New York, New York, in the
Southern District of New York, at the following date, time and place:
Appearance Date: July 24, 2019 Appearance Time: 10:00 a.m.
to testify and give evidence in regard to an alleged violation of :
18 U.S.C. §§ 1591, 2421, 2422, 2423, 371
and not to depart the Grand Jury without leave thereof, or of the United States Attorney, and that you bring
with you and produce at the above time and place the following:
See attached Advice of Rights
Failure to attend and produce any items hereby demanded will constitute contempt of court and will
subject you to civil sanctions and criminal penalties. in addition to other penalties of the Law.
DATED: New York, New York
tidy 5 7019
GEOFFREY S. Et 14-MAN
United States Attorney for the
Cnathern of V011, Velrlf
Assistant United States Attorneys
One St. Andrew's Plaza
New York, New York 10007
Telephone: (212) 637-2415
rev. 02.01.12

╭──── Page 18, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 USCIS [government] United States Citizenship and Immigration Services 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00537633 (Jmail)
 [girls] letter from Mark Zeff to INS about SLK Designs, someone in interior design industry
(date: 2012-03-19)
03/23/2012 05:00 FAX O0001/0002
19 March 2012
USCIS Vermont Service Center
ATTN:1-129 Appeal
75 Lower Welden Street
St. Albans. VT 05478-239
Re: SLK Designs' 1-1-lb Petition on Behalf of Ms.
Dear Sir or Madam:
I am an interior designer with more than 25 years of experience as the owner and
principle designer of MARKZEFF, founded in 1984. Located in New York City, we are an International,
full-service design-consulting firm. I am providing this letter in an effort to help provide insight into the
design business and the types of specialized professionals we utilize.
I know personally. She is an interior designer with amazing talent. To succeed, in our
business, however, company needs more than even sheer artistic talent. Good business
planning and precise marketing are prerequisites of success. In our business, dominated by artistic
minds, the marketing and business planning aspects become more difficult because an "artistic. mind"
and sharp business acumen do not frequently reside in the same person. Therefore, typically in our
business, to ensure our success and growth, we rely on sharp business professionals who understand
our art.
A business person who does not understand our art form would be no use to us. Our artistic projects
require a different insight than other businesses like banking, technology, etc. Therefore, I (and my
peers) seek out professionals with business and marketing education, who have experience in the design
business, to help lead the marketing and business planning aspects of my organization. It is very difficult
to find professionals with such specialized education and experience. Therefore, when we find the right
person, we hold on to them and rely heavily on them for our business and marketing decisions. This is
the lay of the land in the design business.
03/23/2012 05:00 FAX 4/10002/0002
As I mentioned, I know and her work personally. like any other successful
interior designer, needs a very specifically trained business professional for her business development,
planning and marketing. She found such a person in . Ms. has formal education
in business and commerce and has immense experience in the interior design business. in order to
ensure the success and growth of her business, Ms. requires a professional with the specialized
education and experience possessed by Ms.
I hope this letter has helped to address the necessity of retaining specialized talent that is
essential to the prosperity or our firms and the interior design industry at large.
Sincerely yours,
MARKZEFF
55 WUa 20th SI, 4W NtIN Wilk, NY 10011 P 212.624.4004 I. 212.624.4008
moritzeltoom
╔════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Melanie Spinella [finance] representative of Leon Black 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00001911 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2012-03-29)
tt's j--.74dj ) = .9(0 .111
Does  he )a -c( IL—.
11/16 4601 Brautigam Land Surveyor Field House 1,600.00
II/17 4602 Stabenow for US Senate Political Contribution 1,500.00
11/22 4603 Bank of America Visa 2.066.45
11/22 4604 Electronic Environments Bedford 1,234.81
11/22 4605 James Gainfort Field House 20.372.55
11/22 4606 Wells Fargo Kash HO insurance 7,381.00
11/23 4607 Fisher Maramz Field House 587.10
11/30 4608 NJ Gross Income Tax Taxes 2306.34
12/I 4609 Cash LDB 25,000.00
1215 4610 Pawling Mountain Club Thanksgiving shoot 3,427.28
1215 4611 Dom's Landscaping Field House 22.816.06
12/5 4612 MBM Enterprises Alex - Tennis 2305.00
12/5 4613 Hatch Victory committee Political 35,000.00,
12/7 4614 The Four Seasons Lunches 1,064.50
12/7 4615 Sli Acoustics Field House 612.50
12/8 4616 The dinex Group Daniel dinners 1.434.15
12/8 4617 Peter Perez Art conservation 3,400.00
12/8 4618 Glen Arbor Golf Club Golf Club 395.27
12/8 4619 McDermott Will & Emery Legal fees 13,36130
12/8 4620 Madison Cox Associates Field House v...(fx? 12,151.50
12/13 4621 Ushabati LLC Diana 1.043.37
12/14 4622 Dr. Elliott Howard 2012 Concierge Svc. 3,000.00
. 12/14 4623 Brautigam Land Surveyors Field House 1,250.00
12/16 4624 Kellard Sessions Field House 2,890.00
12/19 4625 Melanie Spinella Gill 25,000.00
12/19 4626 Fisher Marantz Field House 9,706.87
12/20 4627 Matthew Hanlon Restor. Art 108.88
12/21 4628 Carper for Senate Political 2,500.00
12/22 4629 Ben Krupinski SI I --- 19,038.19
12/22 4630 Robert J. Hennessey Photo Art photos 834.80
12/22 4631 Dom's Landscaping Field House 33,342.84
12/22 4632 Cash TDB 25,000.00
12/29 4633 Electronic Environments 760 Park 354.12-
12/19 4634 James Gainfort Field House 1,481.5O
1/3/ 4635 PA Department of Revenue Taxes 1,134.0O
1/5 4636 Tibetan Mastiff Rescue Goldner 15.000.00
1/5 4637 Coopers Robertson Field House 8,873.75
1/6 4638 Pawling Mountain Club Ben 20,236.12
EFTA00416586 (Jmail)
 [misc] 
(date: 2012-03-29)
Subject: Steve Hanson & Craig Martin to cross over a day on island?
— This to do is stored on an IMAP server.
— It is managed by Mail; do not modify or delete it.
'Steve Hanson & Craig Martin to cross over a day on island?' [0139B379-6385-4205-A8B4-
D3DFBCE2EF58]
Has no due date.
Is incomplete.
Has no priority.
Is stored in the Mail To Do calendar.
Has the following alarms:
Alarm 1
Displays a message.
on March 29, 2012
at 12:00:00 AM EDT
Contains the URL mailitem: 0139B379-6385-4205-A8S4-D3DFBCE2EF58?
type=todo&action=showparent
Has no note.
╔═══════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Mark Lloyd [lobbyist] real estate broker (???) 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02022626 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2012-04-03 14:45:50)
To: jeevacation©gmaiLcompeevacalion@gmaiLcom]. Jeffrey Epstein
CCfieevacation@gmaitcom
L nn and
Richard
Bamett
From:
Sent
Subject:
Lesley Groff
Tue 4/3/2012 2:45:50 PM
Priveleged & Confidential April 16-18
April 16, Monday
*** Brian Boyd to give talk at 4:00 at Harvard PED***
ni kM  departs today at 6:45pm via Delta #2019***
1:45 Danny Hillis to meet with Jes Stale at Jes' office (270 Park Ave, 48th Floor)
nffice: Danny Cell:
6:00 Tribeca Ball Cocktails (Tickets held at door)
NY Academy of Art
111 Franklin Street
8:30 Tribeca Ball Dinner
April 17, Tuesday
*** Mark Lloyd to be in NY 17-21***
April 18, Wednesday
??? Depart for St. Thomas
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Stephen M. Cutler [bank] JP Morgan general counsel, ex-SEC enforcement director 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01480542 (Jmail)
 [money] JP Morgan Epstein source of wealth filing
(inferred date: 2012-04-12)
Date Issued 01/15/2010    Expiration Date 01/202015

Introduction & Wealth
Introduction Type:
Net worth of client(s):

Source Of Wealth / Financial Information Details
Source Of Wealth -Identify the Clients Source of Wealth from following list of options

Introduction
Non Individual Entity Type                      Corporation - For Profit
For Profit?                                     Yes
Locations Served?                               Domestic
Public or Private                               Private
Are beneficial owners/principal shareholders    Yes
associated with this business?
Who owns this entity?                           Individual
Please Provide ownership details                Jeffrey Epstein is the sole owner of the entity -
.                                               Jeffrey Epstein
.                                               DOB: 0120/1953
.                                               SSN:
.                                               Citizen: USA

.                                               Harry Beller is an authorized signer along with Jeff Epstein on the
.                                               account
.                                               arge:M
.                                               DOB
.                                               SSN:
.                                               Citizen:

Ownership is not equal to 100%?                 No

Are there any authorized signers or any other   Yes
individuals with authority over the entity?

What independent background check, in addition to the
Global Corporate Security ("GCS") background check, has
been carried out? Check all that apply and provide the date
in which the background check was conducted. (at least 1
must be selected)
JPMC Network

JPMC Network Date                               04/12/2012

JPMC Network Comments
This entity is 100% owned by Jeffrey Epstein.
Jeffrey Epstein is an existing client of PB. In years past. Mr.
Epstein was an active brokerage chant, particularly in foreign
exchange and as of this year he is a custody-only client
Formerly. Jeffrey Epstein was a money manager to high net worth
individuals. most notably Leslie Wexner. Wexner was a JPM cient
and then retained Epstein in the late 90s. Mr. Wexner terminated
his relationship with Epstein in 02/2008.

Epstein is well known to several JPM PB employees and to Jos
Staley. Mr. Epstein was convicted of a felony charge in 2008 and
is currently serving an 18-month prison sentence. Jes Staley
conferred with Stephen Cutler and the decision was made to keep

Mr. Epstein as a PH client. Staley and PB then decided that his
PB relationship will be for banking and custody only. We no longer
provide brokerage execution capabilities for Mr. Epstein's
accounts. Bear Stearns will hold the brokerage relationship with

Mr. Epstein.

Politically Exposed Person
Are any of the beneficial owners/authorized signers or other
individuals with authority over this entity a current or former
Senior United States or Non -USA Political Official f also
known as a Politically Exposed Person (PEP) or related to
one?
No

Source of Wealth/Financial Information
Client Category                                     For Profit
Source of Wealth- Identity the clients source of    Other
wealth from the following list of Options

Provide detailed and specific Information.
Jeffrey Epstein is a private investor. Jeff Epstein was a money
manager - made his wealth managing the money of wealthy
individuals.
Confidential Treatment Requested by
JPMorgan Chase
CONFIDENTIAL
JPM-SDNY-00002728
╔══════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
         Arran B McGinnis [employee] engineering at the island 
 Basillia Morales-Mercado [employee] housekeeper at the island 
   Bill Adams [employee] construction supervisor at the island 
      Carlos L. Rodrigue [employee] boat captain at the island 
  Danny Etienne [employee] assistant electrician at the island 
   Ednor Montina [employee] building maintenance at the island 
             Gusneme Dalce [employee] landscaper at the island 
        Hilian J. Bedminister [employee] painter at the island 
              Michael R. Groves [employee] boats at the island 
         Pierressaint Onel [employee] landscaper at the island 
             Reyna Amparo [employee] housekeeper at the island 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02697975 (Jmail)
 [misc] island employee list
(inferred date: 2012-05-31)
Island Employee List
5.5.2012

Employee Name           Date of employment  Position            Release Date  Count

IG To be released at future date
Allangie Clifton                 12/8/2009  Construction        5/31/2012
Benford B. Lewis (Benny)         7/19/2010  Construction        5/31/2012
Michael R. Groves                8/29/2011  Boats               Sale of barge
Phillip Blaize                   6/22/2009  Boats               Sale of barge
Brian K. Bates                    2/2/2007  Mainterance         End of construction TBD
John Werntz                       9/2/2010  Mainterame          End of construction TBD
Josue A. BrIto                  10/27/2010  Engineering         End of construction TBD
Karl Henry                       12/5/2006  Engineering         End of construction TBD
Pierre Jules (Jules)             8/27/2001  Construction        End of construction TBD

LSJ Employees and Lafayette
Thomas J Melnick                 4/27/2008  Constr. Supervisor  End of construction TBD
Bill Adams                      11/16/2009  Constr. Supervisor  End of construction TBD

IG Employed
Anthony Jules (Tony)             5/4/2006   Landscaper
Basillia Morales-Mercado (D     3/29/2002   Housekeeper
Cuthbert Titre (Smiley)         5/3/1999    Pool Maintenance
Danny Etienne (Dereck)          12/30/2010  Assistant Electrician
Danny Vicars                    5/24/2010   Electricains
Dupson Donissaint (Baseah       9/5/2006    Landscaper
Ednor Montina                   6/7/2011    Building Maintenance
Gerry Francis Titre             8/27/2001   Painter
Gusneme Dalce                   7/13/2009   Landscaper
Guy Vicars                      6/16/2010   Building Maint
Hilian J. Bedminister (TJ)      3/2872011   Painter
Justina de la Cruz              10/52009    Housekeeper
Maria Rosario (Keiry)           9/6/2010    Housekeeper
Peter St. Omer                  6/27/2001   Landscaping Foreman
Pierressaint Onel               3/282011    LarKISCaper
Renol Mede                      11/30/2009  Lardscaper
Reyna Amparo (Sandra)           3/28/2011   Housekeeper
Sheridon Emanuel Elizee         10/5/2009   Engineering

LSJ Employees and Lafayette

Employed
Arran B McGinnis                4/20/2000   Engineering
Carlos L. Rodrigue              4/25/2005   Boat Captain
Casey Johnson                   8/25/2007   Boat Captain
William B. Hague                6/2/2008    Engineering
EFTA02731260 (Jmail)
 [misc] notebook full of handwritten love letters with terrible OCR text
(date: 2012-07-16)
notebook full of handwritten love letters with terrible OCR text
EFTA00003098 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2012-08-07)
╭───────────── Page 1, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ DATE 8 7 12 Lowy                          │
│ CASE ID__3\€- ¥¥-307454)                  │
│                                           │
│ FBI                                       │
│                                           │
│ LOCATION __L-rrrce Sr. Janes Tsuamp, USYE │
│                                           │
│ MALUT AREA / oF etce                      │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────╯
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                     Desmond Shum [china] Hong Kong financier, friend of Peter Mandelson 
 Terje Rød-Larsen [europe] Norwegian head of International Peace Institute (IPI), gave jobs to Epstein's eastern European girls [apnews] 
                                                                                                     David Blaine [arts] famous magician 
                                                                   Julie Taymor [arts] film director, creator of "The Lion King" musical 
                                                                           Eileen Alexanderson [finance] Leon Black's Elysium Management 
                                                                                       Tim Zagat [journalist] Zagat restaurant guide CEO 
                                                               Ada Clapp [lawyer] Chief Legal Officer of Leon Black's Elysium Management 
                                                                                        Alan S. Halperin [lawyer] partner at Paul, Weiss 
          Ian Osborne [publicist] PR for Epstein, runs Hedosophia which launched SPACs with Chamath Palihapitiya advised by Epstein [bi] 
                                                           Gerald Barton [real estate] Maryland property developer Landmark Land Company 
                      Bobby Kotick [tech] CEO of video game titan Activision Blizzard (Call of Duty, World of Warcraft, etc.) [gamespot] 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00308123 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(date: 2012-11-08)
November 2012
Thurs. Nov. 8-Island
9:15am oily United Air#1519 from Newark to SIT M
2:09pm o arrive SIT
Fri. Nov. 9-Island
11:00 EST (12:00 STT time Con . Call w lan Osborne, Ivan Schlager, & his group.
Sat. Nov. 10 -Island
Sun. Nov. 11 -Island
3:24pm to depart on United Air#1482 from STT to Newark
6:52pm to arrive Newark (pick up by Citicar)
Mon. Nov. 12 -Island
6:30-9:30 Jes Staley being honored at Evening of Science & Inspiration
Tues. Nov. 13 -Island
12:30 JE to call Tom McGraw
Wed. Nov. 14 -Island
Reminder: Martine from Poland
11:03am (STT time epart Cape Air #808,1:36 depart United Air 1189
from San Juan arriving Newark at 4:52pm
12:30 (577 time) to arrive STT via Cape Air
2:35 (STT time) Darren to arrive STT via Delta 571
3:30 (STT time) Appt w/Erika Kellerhal's to go over Thursday Testimony at FTC
4:45 STT time 3:45 EST)JE is to call Michael Washburn (Per Lawrence Krauss's
request)
Thurs. Nov. 15 -Island to NY
-Jerry Barton & son to stay in Apt ION
1:00 EDC Application Hearing re Tax Exemption Bene its in the VI Port Authority's
Conference Rm, 3rd floor, 8074 Lindbergh Bay
2:30 Wheels up to NY (Darren will be flying with you)
5:30 Arrival at Teterboro
8:00 Dinner w/Desmond Shum
Fri. Nov. 16 -NY
-(4:00 Darren to meet w/Jes Staley re Trusts)
-Meet w/Jerry Barton? (He is due to leave today) Jerry cell:
12:00 Appt w/Carlyn McCa e at 9 West 57Th Street, 48Th Floor
Melanie, Leon's assistant Eileen Alexanderson, Darren and Rich will be
in attendance.
1:00 Tom Turrin to arrive meeting
1-3:00 Wendy Dulman will join meeting from 1-3:00
3:00 John Hannan will join at 3pm via teleconferenece
John Suydam is available until 3pm
Eileen Alexanderson will attend the entire meeting cell)
3:59 to arrive JFK via Virgin America #420  (Citicar will pick her up and
take her to her destination) Jessica cell:
7:30 Dinner w/Woody & Soon Yi (Woody cell:
Sat Nov. 17 -NY
-Julia Sudn today?
-David Blaine today or tomorrow?
TBD Appt wfijke ( j(a)
TBD TENTATIVE Breakfast w/Reid Weingarten (
12:30 Lunch w/Michael Wood (-11
cell
LI
7:00 DINNER w/Bobby Kotick Bobb cell:
Sun. Nov. 18 -NY
-Francis off today for his Engagement Party
-David Blaine today if not yesterday?
12:00 Appt cell: (Svet organized)
6:00 or 6:30 Dinner w/Leon Botstein -WILL NEED TO ORDER DINNER!
REMINDER TO FAST AFTER MIDNIGHT FOR BLOOD WORK TOMORROW
MORNING
Mon. Nov. 19 -NY
-Tim Zagat today or tomorrow if he is in town? cell
8:30 JE to go for Blood Work at Dr. Merrell's Office (44 East 67th Street (between Park
& Madison) Suite 1B,
12:00 Lunch w/Todd Meister & Francisco (Todd:
2:00 Appt w/Dangene & Jennie at Core Club (66 e. 55th street bet Park and Madison)
5:15 Appt w/Eileen Alexanderson & Ada Clapp (Eileen:
6:15 Appt w/Eileen Alexanderson & Alan Halperin (Eileen:
If possible, Eileen should leave promptly after the meeting w/Alan for her tax class on
Long Island.
Tues. Nov. 20 -NY
-Tim Zagat today if he is in town & didn't see yesterday.
-Darren to meet w/Andrew Farkas at 9:30am today re Trusts
cell
1:00 Lunch w Tom McGraw AND Justin Nelson at  Morgan, 270 Park Ave. (Justin
from JP Morgan (Torn
7:30 Dinner w/les Staley( cell) office
10:OOpm Wheels up to PB
Wed. Nov. 21- PB
Thurs. Nov. 22-PB
Thanksgiving Day-Office & FTC Closed
Fri. Nov. 23-PB
Office and FTC Closed
Sat Nov. 24-PB
Sun. Nov. 25- PB to Chicago
Stay at Chicago Park Hyatt Hotel (one suite & one deluxe room organized through
Pritzker's office-No Confirm for Reservation since booked through Pritzker per
Jeannine)
800 N. Michigan Avenue
http://www.parkchicacio.hyatt.com/hyatt/hotels-parkchicago/index.isp?null
Mon. Nov. 26 -Chicago
10-2:00 Pritzker Neuro Consortium, TPO Board Room, Hyatt Center, 47th Floor (M
BRING ID for Building Security
http://www.pritzkerneuropsych.org/
5:00pm Depart Chicago for NY
8:15pm Arrive Teterboro, Atlantic Aviation
Tues. Nov. 27 -NY-PARIS

• rrives via Finnair 873 Valdson to pick upa
7:10PM Depart on Air France Flight ii
Wed. Nov. 28 -Paris
-Reminder: Yoni & Nili to be in NY for the Saban Forum (Barak as well?)
8:25am JE £ to Arrive Paris via Air France Flight #
Thurs. Nov. 29 -Paris to OSIft
-Reminder: Terje back in NY late, due to depart for ME on Dec. 1
-Reminder: Ian Osborne & Simon Nurray in Paris
-Reminder: Doris
Fri. Nov. 30 -Europe
11:00am Meeting at Maitre Guyot's Office, 223 Boulevard Saint Germain in Paris (VII)
(Organized by Marie Experton,
cell) CANCELLING AND DARREN TO RESCHEDULE
People to See While in NY
Paul Barrett & Justin Nelson
Michael Wood
Richard Axel
Kandel
Botstein
toffee
Julie Taymor
Michael Washburn (Lawrence Krauss connection)
David Blaine
Woody Allen
Mort Zuckerman
Harvard
Marvin
Tim Zagat (on Nov. 20th maybe -only day he might be around)
PEOPLE TO SEE IN PARIS
Rassek
Rivkin
Lang
DECEMBER 2012
SATURDAY DEC. 1. 2012 -STOCKHOLM
10:00 Breakfast w/Professor Mathias Uhlen at Hotel An,glais
Humleg0rdsgatan 23
102 44 Stockholm
Phone.
1:00 Brunch w/BBB Girls at Hotel Kung Carl
Birger Jarlsgatan 21
111 45 Stockholm
Tel
Epost:
Barbro's c •
Sana's cell:
╔════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation [jee] Epstein company 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00587235 (Jmail)
 [misc] Epstein's website
(date: 2012-11-14)
Jeffrey Epstein Wordpress Lander FREEMAN 11-14-2012
Jeffrey Epstein
Epstein has years of experience in the financial field. His career found him working with Bear Stearns for
a long period of time as an options trader and products division specialist. In addition to a long and
storied career in finance, Epstein has also made a name for himself in philanthropy. He is the founder of
the Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation and he has supported the endeavors of scientists around the world.
The Foundation
The Foundation began in 2000 with the mission of supporting science and science education worldwide.
Over the course of its history, the Foundation has grown and -is now ablate -provides funding to a variety
of areas, including medical research, the arts and education. This diverse philanthropy division of the-the
Foundation has provided funding to organizations including:

• C.A.H.S. French Club
• Stockholm School of Economics
• Virgin Island Public TV System
• Crohn and Colitis Foundation of America

• The Metropolitan Museum of Art
Program for Evolutionary Dynamics
In 2003, Epstein donated $30 million to Harvard University to start the Program for Evolutionary
Dynamics. The Program takes a unique approach to the study of evolution, focusing on  rStedies4hreugli
the-pregram-exaniiee-mieletiell-from-a-a biochemical and mathematical standpoint. The approach has led
to a-new understandings of evolution as well as in the fields of cancer research, medieineT genetics and the
origin of life on Earth. human-origias,
Scientists
Epstein has also supported the work of a number of well known and established scientists, including
several Nobel Laureates. He has provided financial support to the renowned theoretical physicist,  Stephen
Hawking and was the first to invite Hawking under the ocean in a chartered submarine. r  fer-example.
Other scientists supported by Epstein and the Foundation include:

• Kip Thorne
• Marvin Minksy
• Lee Smolin
• Gerald Edelman
• Lawrence Krauss
A Wider Horizon
Although the Foundation was started to support scientific endeavors, it has evolved over time. It now
provides support to a number of arts organizations as well as educational programs that do not necessarily
have a scientific component.
One way the Foundation helps the arts is by underwriting the Tribeca Film Festival, which has been held
in lower Manhattan al-the-spring-since 2002. A number of arts organizations have received funding in
2012, such as the New York Academy of Art and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Jeffrey Epstein has taken his a-background in science and finance and turned it into a major granting
organization.  One common thread through the diverse entities that he finances is an innovative and
pragmatic approach to helping those in need and furthering excellence wherever he finds it. -Funding-for-
seieftee-is-enteial-feefare-develepaients, Jeffrey Epstein is proud to be able to support such important
works.
EFTA01230639 (Jmail)
[crypto] photo of Epstein and 
Howard Lutnick on Epstein's 
island that was removed from 
DOJ website
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                           Southern Trust [epstein] Epstein financial trust 
 Jeanne Houweling [business] CEO of Adfin, a company Epstein and Howard Lutnick invested in 
                   AdFin Solutions [tech] company invested in by Epstein and Howard Lutnick 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00289560 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Howard Lutnick and Epstein business deal for Adfin Solutions, Inc. (Southern Trust is Epstein)
(date: 2012-12-28)
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
SERIES A PREFERRED STOCK PURCHASE
AGREEMENT
December 28, 2012
This Series A Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement (this "Agreement") is entered into as
of the date set forth above between AdFinSolutions, Inc., a Delaware corporation (the
"Company") and the undersigned purchasers (each a "Purchaser" and collectively, the
"Purchasers") set forth on the Schedule of Purchasers attached hereto as Exhibit A (the
"Schedule of Purchasers"). The parties hereby agree as follows:
SECTION 1
AUTHORIZATION AND SALE OF SECURITIES
1.1 Authorization. The Company has, or before the Closing (as defined in

Section 2.1) will have, duly authorized the sale and issuance pursuant to the terms and conditions
hereof of shares of its Series A Preferred Stock (the "Shares") having the rights, restrictions,
privileges and preferences set forth in the Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation
(the "Restated Certificate") to be filed with the Delaware Secretary of State in substantially the
form attached hereto as Exhibit B.
1.2 Sale of Securities. Subject to the terms and conditions hereof, at the Closing, the
Company will issue and sell to each Purchaser, and each Purchaser agrees, severally and not
jointly, to purchase from the Company, the number of Shares set forth opposite the Purchaser's
name on the Schedule of Purchasers and with regard to David J. Mitchell as set forth opposite his
name on the Payment Schedule attached hereto as Exhibit C and for which the column titled
"Investment Type" indicates "Committed Amount" at a purchase price of $0.4375 per share.
Payment of the purchase price will be made by the Purchaser by (a) check, (b) wire transfer, or
(c) cancellation of indebtedness of the Company to the Purchaser representing the aggregate
purchase price of the Shares that the Purchaser is acquiring.
1.3 Payment Schedule. The Purchasers agree to the terms and conditions set forth in
the Payment Schedule attached hereto as Exhibit C (the "Payment Schedule").
SECTION 2
CLOSING; DELIVERY
2.1 Closing. The initial closing of the purchase by the Purchasers and the sale by the
Company of the Shares (the "Closing") shall be held at the offices of DLA Piper LLP (US),
counsel to the Company, at 2000 University Avenue, East Palo Alto 94303, on December 28,
2012 (the "Closing Date"), or at such other time and place as the Company and the Purchasers
may agree either in writing or orally. Each subsequent closing of a sale of Series A Preferred
Stock to the Purchasers, as contemplated by the Payment Schedule, shall be deemed to be a
WEST1240047077.6
Closing for purposes of this Agreement and Exhibit A shall be amended to so reflect such
Closing.
2.2 Subsequent Sales of Series A Preferred Stock. Subject to the terms and
conditions set forth in this Agreement and through September 30, 2013, the Company may sell
up to the balance of the Shares, other than 5,000,000 of Shares reserved for issuance to the
Purchasers as set forth on the Payment Schedule, not sold at the initial Closing to purchasers
(each a "Subsequent Purchaser") at a per share price not less than the price paid at the Initial
Closing. Any such sale shall be made upon the same terms and conditions as those set forth
herein, and each Subsequent Purchaser shall become a party to this Agreement (and Exhibit A
hereto shall be amended to include such Subsequent Purchaser), the Investors' Rights Agreement
attached hereto as Exhibit 1D (the "Rights Agreement"), the Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale
Agreement attached hereto as Exhibit E (the "Co-Sale Agreement") and the Voting Agreement
attached hereto as Exhibit F (the "Voting Agreement") and shall have the rights and obligations,
and be treated as, a Purchaser hereunder and thereunder. Each closing of a sale of Series A
Preferred Stock to one or more Subsequent Purchasers shall be deemed to be a Closing for
purposes of this Agreement. Each Purchaser hereby agrees to waive any rights of first refusal it
may have in connection with the sale of Shares to Subsequent Purchasers.
2.3 Delivery. At each Closing, the Company will issue to the Purchaser a certificate
in the Purchaser's name representing the Shares purchased by the Purchaser, against payment of
the purchase price therefor. In the event that payment by a Purchaser is made, in whole or in
part, by cancellation of indebtedness, then such Purchaser shall surrender to the Company for
cancellation at the Closing any evidence of indebtedness or shall execute an instrument of
cancellation in form and substance acceptable to the Company.
2.4 Use of Proceeds. In accordance with the directions of the Company's Board of
Directors, the Company will use the proceeds from the sale of the Shares for product
development and general corporate purposes.
SECTION 3
REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES OF THE COMPANY
Except as set forth in the Schedule of Exceptions attached hereto as Bxhibit G (the
"Schedule of Exceptions"), as of the initial Closing (the "Initial Closing") the Company hereby
represents and warrants to each Purchaser as follows:
3.1 Organization and Standing. The Company is a corporation duly organized and
existing under the laws of the State of Delaware and is in good standing under such laws. The
Company has the requisite corporate power to own and operate its properties and assets, and to
carry on its business as presently conducted, and as proposed to be conducted. The Company is
duly qualified to transact business and is in goodstanding in each jurisdiction in which the failure
to so qualify would have a Material Adverse Effect.
WESTN240047077.6 2
3.2 Corporate Power. The Company has all requisite corporate power to enter into
this Agreement, the Rights Agreement, the Voting Agreement and the Co-Sale Agreement to sell
the Shares hereunder and to carry out and perform its other obligations under the terms of this
Agreement, the Rights Agreement, the Voting Agreement and the Co-Sale Agreement.
3.3 Capitalization. Immediately prior to the Initial Closing, the capitalization of the
Company will consist of the following:

(a) Common Stock A total of 22,250,000 authorized shares of Common
Stock, of which 8,000,000 shares will be issued and outstanding. All of the outstanding shares of
Common Stock have been duly authorized, fully paid and are nonassessable and issued in
compliance with all applicable federal and state securities laws.

(b) Preferred Stock A total of 10,250,000 authorized shares of Preferred
Stock, all of which have been designated Series A Preferred Stock (the "Series A Preferred"),
none of which will be issued and outstanding.

(c) Other Securities. The Company has reserved 2,750,000 shares of its
Common Stock for issuance to employees, directors and officers of, and consultants to, the
Company under the 2012 Stock Option Plan (the "2012 Plan"), of which 1,835,875 shares are
subject to options that are currently outstanding and 664,125 shares remain available for
issuance.

(d) Subsection 3.3(c) of the Disclosure Schedule sets forth the capitalization
of the Company immediately following the Initial Closing including the number of granted stock
options, including vesting schedule and exercise price, and warrants or stock purchase rights, if
any. Except for (A) the conversion privileges of the Shares to be issued under this Agreement,

(B) the rights provided in the Investors' Rights Agreement and Co-Sale Agreement, and (C) the
securities and rights described in this Section 3.3 and Subsection 3.3(c) of the Disclosure
Schedule, there are no outstanding options, warrants, rights (including conversion or preemptive
rights and rights of first refusal or similar rights) or agreements, orally or in writing, to purchase
or acquire from the Company any shares of Common Stock or Series A Preferred Stock, or any
securities convertible into or exchangeable for shares of Common Stock or Series A Preferred
Stock. All outstanding shares of the Company's Common Stock and all shares of the Company's
Common Stock underlying outstanding options are subject to a lock-up or market standoff
agreement of not less than 180 days following the Company's initial public offering pursuant to
a registration statement filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission under the Securities
Act.
3.4 Authorization. All corporate action on the part of the Company and its directors
and shareholders necessary for the authorization, execution, delivery and performance of this
Agreement, the Rights Agreement, the Co-Sale Agreement and the Voting Agreement (the
"Transaction Documents") and the authorization, sale, issuance and delivery of the Shares and
the performance of the Company's obligations hereunder has been taken or will be taken prior to
the Closing.
WEST240047077.8 3

(a) This Agreement, when executed and delivered by the Company, will
constitute a valid and binding obligation of the Company enforceable in accordance with its
terms, subject to (i) laws of general application relating to specific performance, injunctive relief
or other equitable remedies, (ii) applicable bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization or other laws
of general application relating to or affecting the enforcement of creditors' rights generally and
(iii) federal or state laws limiting enforceability of the indemnification provisions in the Rights
Agreement.
(b) When issued, sold and delivered in accordance with the terms of this
Agreement for the consideration provided for herein, the Shares shall be duly authorized, validly
issued, fully paid and non-assessable and shall be free of any liens or encumbrances, other than
restrictions on transfer under the Transaction Documents and applicable state and federal
securities laws. The Company has duly and validly reserved sufficient shares of Common Stock
to permit the conversion of the Shares, and such shares of Common Stock (the "Conversion
Shareq"), upon issuance in accordance with the terms of the Restated Certificate, will be duly
authorized, validly issued, fully paid and non-assessable and will be free of any liens or
encumbrances, other than restrictions on transfer under the Transaction Documents and under
applicable state and federal securities laws.
3.5 Subsidiaries. As of the date hereof, the Company does not presently own or
control, directly or indirectly, any equity interest in any other corporation, partnership, trust, joint
venture, association or other entity.
3.6 Governmental Consents. No consent, approval, order or authorization of, or
registration, qualification, designation, declaration or filing with, any federal, state or local
governmental authority by the Company is required in connection with the consummation of the
transactions contemplated by this Agreement except: (i) such other qualifications or filings
under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and the regulations thereunder (the "Securities
Ac_(") and (ii) state securities laws as may be required in connection with the transactions
contemplated by this Agreement. All such qualifications and filings will, in the case of
qualifications, be effective on the Closing and will, in the case of filings, be made within the time
prescribed by law. The Company is not in breach of or default under or, to its knowledge,
alleged to be in breach of or default under, any material lease, license, contract, agreement,
instrument or obligation to which it is a party or its properties are subject, and the Company does
not know of any condition or circumstances that, currently or after notice or the lapse of time, is
likely to result in a breach of, default under or loss of material benefits under any such lease,
license, contract, agreement, instrument or obligation, other than breaches or defaults that could
not reasonably be expected to have a Material Adverse Effect. The execution, delivery and
performance of the Transaction Documents on the part of the Company, and the issuance and
sale of the Shares pursuant hereto, will not result in any such violation or default and will not
accelerate performance under the terms of any agreement or instrument.
3.7 Compliance with Laws and Other Instruments; No Conflicts. To its
knowledge and after reasonable investigation, the Company is not in violation or default of any
provisions of its Restated Certificate or Bylaws, as amended to date or any applicable laws,
regulations, judgments, decrees or orders of the United States of America or any state, foreign
country or other governmental body or agency having jurisdiction over the Company's business
WES11240047077.6 4
or properties, other than violations of laws, regulations, judgments, decrees or orders that could
not reasonably be expected to have a material adverse effect on the business, property, financial
condition or results of operations of the Company (a "Material Adverse Effect"). The execution,
delivery and performance of the transaction agreements described hereunder will not result in
any violation or be in conflict with or constitute, with or without the passage of time and giving
of notice, either (i) a default under any such provision, instrument, judgment, order, writ, decree,
contract or agreement or (ii) an event which results in the creation of any lien, charge or
encumbrance upon any assets of the Company or the suspension, revocation, forfeiture, or
nonrenewal of any material permit or license applicable to the Company.
3.8 Registration Rights. Except as provided in the Rights Agreement, the Company
has not granted or agreed to grant to any person or entity any rights (including piggyback
registration rights) to have any securities of the Company registered with the United States
Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC") or any other governmental authority. To the
Company's knowledge, except as contemplated in the Voting Agreement, no stockholder of the
Company has entered into any agreements with respect to the voting of capital shares of the
Company.
3.9 Litigation. There is no litigation, action, suit or proceeding, or governmental
inquiry or investigation, pending, or, to the best of the Company's knowledge, threatened, orally
or in writing, against the Company which might result in Material Adverse Effect. The
Company is not a party or subject to the provisions of any order, writ, injunction, judgment or
decree of any court or government agency or instrumentality. There is no action, suit,
proceeding or investigation by the Company currently pending or which the Company intends to
initiate.
3.10 Taxes. The Company has timely filed or has obtained presently effective
extensions with respect to all federal, state, county, local and foreign tax returns which are
required to be filed by it. All filed returns are true and correct in all material respects and all
taxes shown thereon to be due have been timely paid with exceptions not material to the
Company. There have been no examinations or audits of any tax returns or reports by any
applicable federal, state, local or foreign governmental agency.
3.1I Intellectual Property. To its knowledge, the Company owns or possesses
sufficient legal rights to all patents, trademarks, service marks, trade names, copyrights, trade
secrets, information and other proprietary rights (collectively "Intellectual Property") necessary
for its business as now conducted, and as presently contemplated to be conducted, without any
known infringement of the rights of others. The Company is not bound by or a party to any
options, licenses or agreements of any kind with respect to the Intellectual Property of the
Company or any other person or entity, other than licenses or agreements relating to the
Company's use rights regarding "off the shelf" or standard products. The Company has received
no notice, oral or in writing, that it is infringing upon, violating or otherwise acting adversely to,
or that by conducting its business as proposed it would infringe upon, violate or otherwise act
adversely to, the right or claimed right of any person or entity under or with respect to any
Intellectual Property or licenses of third parties. The Company is not aware of any violation by a
third party of any of the Company's Intellectual Property. To its knowledge, the Company is not
obligated or under any liability to make payments by way of royalties, fees or otherwise to any
WES T240047077.6 5
owner, licensor of, other claimant to, or party to any option, license or agreement of any kind
with respect to, any Intellectual Property except for commercially available software which the
Company licenses on standard terms. None of the Company's Intellectual Property includes or
incorporates into its source code any open source software that is licensed under the General
Public License or another open source code license having a similar "contaminating" effect on
the Company's Intellectual Property or that would otherwise require the Company or any of its
subsidiaries to release any portion of its source code, or to permit free redistribution, reverse
engineering or modification of any of the Company's Intellectual Property.
3.12 Employees. Each current and former employee, officer and consultant of the
Company has executed and delivered an Assignment of Inventions, Non-Disclosure and Non-
Compete Agreement in substantially the form attached hereto as Exhibit H and all of such
agreements are in full force and effect. To the Company's knowledge, no employee, officer or
consultant of the Company is in violation of such Assignment of Inventions, Non-Disclosure and
Non-Compete Agreement. The Company is not aware of any claims against the Company by
any former Company employees, and the Company has not been threatened with legal action,
orally or in writing, by any former employees.
3.13 Property and Assets. The Company has good and marketable title to all of its
material properties and assets, and good title to its leasehold estates, in each case subject to no
mortgage, pledge, lien, security interest, lease, charge or encumbrance, other than liens resulting
from taxes which have not yet become delinquent and liens and encumbrances which do not in
any case materially detract from the value of the property subject thereto or materially impair the
operations of the Company, and which have not arisen otherwise than in the ordinary course of
business.
3.14 Securities Law Exemptions. Based in part on the accuracy of the
representations and warranties of the Purchasers contained in Section 4 hereof, the offer, sale and
issuance of the Shares and the Conversion Shares are and will be exempt from the registration
requirements of the Securities Act, and the registration, permit or qualification requirements of
any applicable state securities laws. Neither the Company nor any agent on its behalf has
solicited or will solicit any offers to sell or has offered to sell or will offer to sell any pan of the
Shares to any person or persons so as to bring the sale of such Shares by the Company within the
registration provisions of the Securities Act or any state securities law.
3.15 Material Contracts and Obligations. The Schedule of Exceptions lists all
contracts and agreements (a) with expected receipts or expenditures in excess of S30,000, (b)
involving a license or grant of rights to or from the Company involving patents, trademarks,
copyrights or other proprietary information applicable to the business of the Company, (c)
providing for indemnification by the Company with respect to infringements of proprietary
rights, (d) between the Company and any officer, director or 10%-or-greater stockholder other
than agreements entered into in the ordinary course of business, or (e) involving any loans or
advances by the Company to any officer, director or employee which are outstanding as of the
date of the Closing. All such contracts and agreements are legally binding, valid, and in full
force and effect in all material respects.
WES11240047077.6 6
3.16 Permits. The Company has all franchises, permits, licenses, and any similar
authority necessary for the conduct of its business as now being conducted by it, the lack of
which would have a Material Adverse Effect on the Company, and believes it can obtain,
without undue burden or expense, any similar authority for the conduct of its business as
presently planned to be conducted. The Company is not in default in any material respect under
any of such franchises, permits, licenses or other similar authority.
3.17 Disclosure. The Company has made available to the Purchasers all the
information reasonably available to the Company that the Purchasers have requested for deciding
whether to acquire the Shares, including certain of the Company's projections describing its
proposed business plan. No representation or warranty of the Company contained in this
Agreement, as qualified by the Disclosure Schedule, and no certificate furnished or to be
furnished to Purchasers at the Closing contains any untrue statement of a material fact or omits to
state a material fact necessary in order to make the statements contained herein or therein not
misleading in light of the circumstances under which they were made.
SECTION 4
REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES OF PURCHASER
Each Purchaser hereby represents and warrants at each Closing which such Purchaser is a
participant as follows:
4.1 Authorization. This Agreement constitutes the Purchaser's valid and legally
binding obligation, enforceable in accordance with its terms except as may be limited by

(i) applicable bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization or other laws of general application relating
to or affecting the enforcement of creditors' rights generally and (ii) the effect of rules of law
governing the availability of equitable remedies. The Purchaser has full power and authority to
enter into this Agreement.
4.2 Investment. The Purchaser is acquiring the Shares and the Conversion Shares
(collectively, the "Securities")  for investment for the Purchaser's own account and not with the
view to the public resale or distribution thereof within the meaning of the Securities Act, and
such Purchaser has no present intention of selling, granting any participation in, or otherwise
distributing the Securities. No other person has a direct or indirect beneficial interest, in whole
or in part, in such Securities. The Purchaser understands that the Securities have not been
registered under the Securities Act by reason of a specific exemption thereunder, which depends
upon, among other things, the bona fide nature of the Purchaser's investment intent as expressed
herein.
4.3 Relationship to Company; Sophistication; Experience. The Purchaser either
(i) has a preexisting business or personal relationship with the Company and/or any of its
officers, directors or controlling persons or (ii) such Purchaser, either alone or with his or her
purchaser representative(s), has such knowledge and experience in financial and business matters
that he is capable of evaluating the merits and risks of the prospective investment in the Shares.
Each purchaser representative, if any, in connection with the Purchaser's investment in the
Securities, has confirmed in writing the specific details of any and all past, present or future
WES1l240047077.6 7
relationships, actual or contemplated, between the Purchaser or the Purchaser's affiliates and the
Company or any of the Company's affiliates.
4.4 Restrictions on Transfer. The Purchaser acknowledges that the Securities must
be held indefinitely unless subsequently registered under the Securities Act or the Company
receives an opinion of counsel satisfactory to the Company that such registration is not required.
The Purchaser is aware of the provisions of Rule 144 promulgated under the Securities Act
which permit limited resale of stock purchased in a private placement subject to the satisfaction
of certain conditions, including, among other things, the existence of a public market for the
stock, the availability of certain current public information about the Company, the resale
occurring not less than six months after a party has purchased and paid for the stock to be sold,
and, in the case of sales by affiliates of the Company, the sale being made through a "broker's
transaction" or a transaction directly with a "market maker" and the number of shares of the
stock being sold during any three-month period not exceeding specified limitations. The
Purchaser further acknowledges and understands that the Company may not be satisfying the
current public information requirement of Rule 144 at the time the Purchaser wishes to sell the
Securities and, if so, the Purchaser would be precluded from selling the Securities under Rule
144 even if the six-month minimum holding period has been satisfied.
4.5 No Public Market. The Purchaser understands that no public market now exists
for the Securities, that there can be no assurance that a public market will ever exist for the
Securities and that the Company is under no obligation to register the Securities.
4.6 Exemption from Registration. The Purchaser further acknowledges that, in the
event all of the requirements of Rule 144 are not met, compliance with another registration
exemption will be required; and that, although Rule 144 is not exclusive, the staff of the SEC has
expressed its opinion that persons proposing to sell private placement securities other than in a
registered offering and other than pursuant to Rule 144 will have a substantial burden of proof in
establishing that an exemption from registration is available for such offers or sales, that such
persons and the brokers who participate in the transactions do so at their own risk, and that,
therefore, there is no assurance that any exemption from registration under the Securities Act
will be available or, if available, will allow such person to dispose of, or otherwise transfer, all or
any portion of the Securities.
4.7 Access to Information. The Purchaser has had an opportunity to discuss the
Company's business, management and financial affairs with the Company's management and the
opportunity to inspect Company facilities and such books and records and material contracts as
the Purchaser deemed necessary to its determination to purchase the Shares.
4.8 Purchaser's Liquidity. The Purchaser (i) has no need for liquidity in the
Purchaser's investment, (ii) is able to bear the substantial economic risks of an investment in the
Securities for an indefinite period and (iii) at the present time, can afford a complete loss of such
investment. The Purchaser's current commitments to illiquid investments are not
disproportionate to the Purchaser's net worth, and the Purchaser's investment in the Securities
will not cause such commitments to become disproportionate.
WEST1240047077.6 8
4.9 Offer and Sale. The Purchaser understands that the sale of the Securities has not
been registered under the Securities Act in reliance upon an exemption therefrom. The
Purchaser was not offered or sold the Securities, directly or indirectly, by means of any form of
general solicitation or general advertisement, including (i) any advertisement, article, notice or
other communication published in any newspaper, magazine or similar medium or broadcast
over television or radio or (ii) any seminar or other meeting whose attendees had been invited by
general solicitation or general advertising.
4.10 Risks. The Purchaser is aware that the Securities are highly speculative and that
there can be no assurance as to what return, if any, there may be. The Purchaser is aware that the
Company may issue additional securities in the future which could result in the dilution of the
Purchaser's ownership interest in the Company.
4.11 Reliance. The Purchaser has relied only upon the information provided to him or
her in writing by the Company, or information from books and records of the Company. No oral
representations have been made or oral information furnished to Purchaser or his or her
advisor(s) by the Company in connection with the offering of Shares which were not contained
therein or were inconsistent therewith.
4.12 Investment Entity. The Purchaser, if a corporation, partnership, trust or other
entity, is authorized and otherwise duly qualified to purchase and hold the Securities; such entity
has its principal place of business as set forth on the signature page hereof; and such entity has
not been formed for the specific purpose of acquiring the Shares. The Purchaser, if an
individual, is at least 21 years of age.
4.13 Accredited Investor. The Purchaser is an accredited investor as defined in Rule
50I(a) of Regulation D promulgated under the Securities Act.
SECTION 5
CONDITIONS TO PURCHASERS' OBLIGATIONS AT CLOSING
The obligations of each Purchaser under Section 2 of this Agreement are subject to the
fulfillment or waiver, on or before the Initial Closing (and, with respect to Sections 5.1, 5.2 and
5.8, on or before each exercise by a Purchaser of an option to purchase additional Shares as set
forth on Exhibit C of each of the following conditions, the waiver of which shall not be effective
against any Purchaser unless waived by the Purchasers at the Initial Closing (or at a subsequent
Closing pursuant to an exercise of an option as set forth on Exhibit C), which waiver may be
given by written communication to the Company or its counsel:
5.1 Representations and Warranties True. Each of the representations and
warranties of the Company contained in Section 3 shall have been true and correct in all material
respects when made and shall be true and correct in all material respects on and as of the Closing
Date (or at a subsequent Closing pursuant to an exercise of an option as set forth on Exhibit C)
with the same effect as though such representations and warranties had been made on and as of
the Initial Closing Date.
WEST \ 240047077.6 9
5.2 Performance of Obligations; Consents and Waivers. The Company shall have
performed and complied in all material respects with all agreements, obligations and conditions
contained in this Agreement that arc required to be performed or complied with by it on or
before the Closing and shall have obtained all approvals, consents and qualifications necessary to
complete the purchase and sale described herein.
5.3 Restated Certificate Effective. The Restated Certificate shall have been duly
adopted by the Company by all necessary corporate action of its Board of Directors and
stockholders, and shall have been duly filed with and accepted by the Secretary of State of the
State of Delaware.
5.4 Rights Agreement. The Purchasers and the Company shall have entered into the
Rights Agreement in substantially the form attached hereto as Exhibit D.
5.5 Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement. The Co-Sale Agreement in
substantially the form attached hereto as Exhibit E shall have been executed and delivered by the
parties thereto. The stock certificates representing the shares subject to the Co-Sale Agreement
shall have been delivered to the Secretary of the Company and shall have had appropriate
legends placed upon them to reflect the restrictions on transfer set forth in the Co-Sale
Agreement.
5.6 Voting Agreement. The Purchasers and the Company shall have entered into a
Voting Agreement in substantially the form attached hereto as Exhibit F.
5.7 Board of Directors. Effective as of the Initial Closing, the Board of Directors
shall consist of Five (5) authorized directors. As of the Closing, the Board shall consist of
Jonathan Leitersdorf, Gil Mandelzis, Roy Lowrance, Jeanne Houweling and David J. Mitchell.
David J. Mitchell executes standard form indemnification agreement and is granted an option to
purchase 162,143 shares of Common Stock.
5.8 Securities Exemptions. The offer and sale of the Securities to the Purchasers
pursuant to this Agreement shall be exempt from the registration requirements of the Securities
Act, the qualification requirements of the New York Securities Law and the registration and/or
qualification requirements of all other applicable state securities laws.
5.9 Closing Documents. The Company shall have delivered to counsel for the
Purchasers all of the following documents prior to the Initial Closing:

(a) Certified copies of the resolutions duly adopted by the Company's board
of directors (and stockholders, if necessary) authorizing the execution, delivery and performance
of the Transaction Documents, and each of the other agreements contemplated hereby, the filing
of the Restated Certificate, the issuance and sale of the Securities and the consummation of all
other transactions contemplated by this Agreement; and
(b) Certified copies of the Restated Certificate and the Company's bylaws,
each as in effect as of the Closing.
WF-M240047077.6 10
5.10 Assignment of Inventions, Non-Disclosure and Non-Compete Agreement.
The Company and each of its employees shall have entered into the Company's standard form of
Assignment of Inventions, Non-Disclosure and Non-Compete Agreement attached hereto in
Exhibit H.
SECTION 6
CONDITIONS TO COMPANY'S OBLIGATIONS AT CLOSING
The Company's obligation to sell and issue the Shares at each Closing is subject to the
fulfillment of the following conditions, any of which may be waived in writing by the Company:
6.1 Representations and Warranties. The representations and warranties made by
each Purchaser in Section 4 hereof shall have been true and correct when made and shall be true
and correct on the date of the Closing as if made as of such Closing.
6.2 Consents and Waivers. The Company shall have obtained any and all consents
and waivers necessary or appropriate for consummation of the transactions contemplated by this
Agreement.
6.3 Restated Certificate Effective. Prior to the Initial Closing, the Restated
Certificate shall have been duly adopted by the Company by all necessary corporate action of its
Board of Directors and stockholders, and shall have been duly filed with and accepted by the
Secretary of State of the State of Delaware.
6.4 Rights Agreement. The Purchasers and the Company shall have entered into the
Rights Agreement in substantially the form attached hereto as Exhibit D.
6.5 Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement. Prior to the Initial Closing, the
Co-Sale Agreement in substantially the form attached hereto as Exhibit E shall have been
executed by the parties thereto.
6.6 Voting Agreement. The Purchasers and the Company shall have entered into a
Voting Agreement in substantially the form attached hereto as Exhibit F.
6.7 Securities Exemptions. The offer and sale of the Shares to the Purchasers
pursuant to this Agreement shall be exempt from the registration requirements of the Securities
Act, the qualifications requirements of the New York Securities Law and the registration and/or
qualification requirements of all other applicable state securities laws.
SECTION 7
RESTRICTIONS ON TRANSFERABILITY OF SECURITIES
7.1 Restrictions on Transferability. The Securities shall not be transferable except
upon the conditions specified in this Section 7. Each Purchaser will cause any proposed
transferee of the Securities held by such Purchaser to agree to take and hold such Securities
subject to the provisions and upon the conditions specified in this Section 7.
WES11240047077.6 II
7.2 Restrictive Legends. Each certificate representing the Securities, and any other
securities issued in respect of the Securities upon any stock split, stock dividend, recapitalization,
merger, consolidation or similar event (except as otherwise permitted by the provisions of this

Section 7), shall be stamped or otherwise imprinted with legends in substantially the following
form:

(a) "THE SECURITIES EVIDENCED BY THIS CERTIFICATE HAVE
NOT BEEN REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED, AND
MAY NOT BE SOLD, TRANSFERRED, ASSIGNED OR HYPOTHECATED UNLESS
THERE IS AN EFFECTIVE REGISTRATION STATEMENT UNDER SUCH ACT
COVERING SUCH SECURITIES, THE SALE IS MADE IN ACCORDANCE WITH
RULE 144 UNDER THE ACT, OR THE COMPANY RECEIVES AN OPINION OF
COUNSEL FOR THE HOLDER OF THESE SECURITIES REASONABLY SATISFACTORY
TO THE COMPANY STATING THAT SUCH SALE, TRANSFER, ASSIGNMENT OR
HYPOTHECATION IS EXEMPT FROM THE REGISTRATION AND PROSPECTUS
DELIVERY REQUIREMENTS OF SUCH ACT."
(b) Any other legends required by applicable state securities laws.
The Company need not register a transfer of legended Securities and may also instruct its
transfer agent not to register the transfer of the Securities, unless the conditions specified in each
of the foregoing legends are satisfied.
7.3 Removal of Legend and Transfer Restrictions. Any legend endorsed on a
certificate pursuant to subsection 7.2(a) and the stop transfer instructions with respect to such
legended Securities shall be removed, and the Company shall issue a certificate without such
legend to the holder of such Securities, if such Securities are registered under the Securities Act
and a prospectus meeting the requirements of Section 10 of the Securities Act is available or if
such holder satisfies the requirements of Rule I44(b)(1).
SECTION 8
MISCELLANEOUS
8.1 Entire Agreement; Amendment. This Agreement and the exhibits to this
Agreement constitute the MI and entire understanding and agreement between the parties with
regard to the subjects hereof and thereof, and any and all other written or oral agreements
relating to the subject matter hereof existing between the parties hereto are expressly superseded
hereby. Any term of this Agreement may be amended and the observance of any term of this
Agreement may be waived (either generally or in a particular instance and either retroactively or
prospectively) only with the written consent of the party against whom enforcement of any such
amendment or waiver is sought; provided, however, that the beneficial owners of a ninety
percent (90%) majority of the Securities then outstanding may, with the Company's written
consent, execute such amendment or waiver on behalf of all of the Purchasers other than any
Purchaser that the amendment or waiver treats in a materially adverse manner relative to the
other Purchasers. Any amendment or waiver effected in accordance with this Section 8.1 shall
WES71240047077.6 12
be binding upon the Company and the Purchaser and each future holder of the securities
purchased hereunder.
8.2 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed in all respects by the internal
laws of the State of New York, without reference to principles of choice of law.
8.3 Survival. Unless otherwise set forth in this Agreement, the representations,
warranties covenants and agreements made herein shall survive the execution and delivery of
this Agreement and the Closing for a period of one (1) year following the Closing.
8.4 Successors and Assigns. Except as otherwise provided herein, the provisions
hereof shall inure to the benefit of, and be binding upon, the successors, assigns, heirs, executors
and administrators of the parties hereto. Nothing in this Agreement, express or implied, is
intended to confer upon any party other than the parties hereto or their respective successors and
assigns any rights, remedies, obligations or liabilities under or by reason of this Agreement,
except as expressly provided in this Agreement.
8.5 Notices, Etc. All notices and other communications required or permitted
hereunder shall be in writing and shall be deemed effectively given (i) upon actual delivery to the
party to be notified, (ii) 24 hours after confirmed facsimile transmission, or (iii) one business day
after deposit with a recognized overnight courier, addressed (a) if to a Purchaser, at the
Purchaser's address set forth on the Schedule of Purchasers, or at such other address as the
Purchaser shall have furnished to the Company in writing upon 10 days' notice, (b) if to any
other holder of any Securities, at such address as such holder shall have furnished the Company
in writing upon 10 days' notice or, until any such holder so furnishes an address to the Company,
to and at the address of the last holder of such Securities who has so furnished an address to the
Company or (c) if to the Company, at the following address:
AdFin Solutions, Inc.
10 East 53rd Street, 37th Floor
New York NY 10022
Attn: Jeanne Houweling, CEO
with a copy to:
DLA Piper LLP (US)
2000 University Avenue
East Palo Alto, 94303-2215
Fax:
Attn: Matt Oshinsky, Esq.
or at such other address as the Company shall have furnished to the Purchasers upon 10 days'
notice.
WES71240047077.6 13
8.6 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in any number of counterparts,
each of which shall be enforceable against the parties actually executing such counterparts, and
all of which together shall constitute one instrument.
8.7 Titles and Subtitles; References. The titles and subtitles used in this Agreement
are used for convenience only and are not to be considered in construing or interpreting this
Agreement. All references in this Agreement to sections, paragraphs, exhibits and schedules
shall, unless otherwise provided, refer to sections and paragraphs hereof and exhibits and
schedules attached hereto, all of which exhibits and schedules are incorporated herein by this
reference.
8.8 No Finder's Fees. Each party represents that it neither is nor will be obligated
for any finder's or broker's fee or commission in connection with this transaction. Each
Purchaser agrees to indemnify and to hold harmless the Company from any liability for any
commission or compensation in the nature of a finders' or broker's fee (and any asserted
liability) for which such Purchaser or any of its officers, partners, employees, or representatives
is responsible. The Company agrees to indemnify and hold harmless each Purchaser from any
liability for any commission or compensation in the nature of a finder's or broker's fee (and any
asserted liability) for which the Company or any of its officers, employees or representatives is
responsible.
8.9 Severability. If one or more provisions of this Agreement are held to be
unenforceable under applicable law, the parties agree to renegotiate such provision in good faith.
In the event that the parties cannot reach a mutually agreeable and enforceable replacement for
such provision, then such provision(s) shall be excluded from this Agreement and the balance of
the Agreement shall be interpreted as if such provision(s) were so excluded and shall be
enforceable in accordance with its terms.
8.10 Expenses. The Company and the Purchasers shall each bear their respective
expenses and legal fees incurred in connection with the negotiation and consummation of this
Agreement, except that the Company shall pay the reasonable fees and expenses of Katsky
Korins LLP, counsel for David J. Mitchell, up to a maximum of $10,000, incurred with respect
to the negotiation, execution, delivery and performance of this Agreement; provided, however,
(i) that a copy of the invoice is provided to the Company, and (ii) that if Purchaser, David J.
Mitchell, fails to pay all of the Committed Amounts (as set forth on Exhibit C), David J. Mitchell
will reimburse the Company a pro rata amount based on the percentage of the Committed
Amounts that were not paid. For example, if David J. Mitchell receives $10,000 in legal fees
from the Company and then pays 75% of the Committed Amounts, he will be required to
reimburse the Company for $2,500 of the legal fees.
8.11 Delays or Omissions. No delay or omission to exercise any right, power or
remedy accruing to any Purchaser, upon any breach or default of the Company under this
Agreement, shall impair any such right, power, or remedy, nor shall it be construed to be a
waiver of any such breach or default, or any acquiescence therein, or a waiver of or acquiescence
in any similar breach or default thereafter occurring; nor shall any waiver of any single breach or
default be deemed a waiver of any other breach or default theretofore or thereafter occurring. It
is further agreed that any waiver, permit, consent or approval of any kind of character on a
ViESTN240047077.6 14
Purchaser's part of any breach or default under this Agreement, or any waiver on a Purchaser's
part of any provisions or conditions of this Agreement must be in writing and shall be effective
only to the extent specifically set forth in such writing and that all remedies, either under this
Agreement, or by law or otherwise afforded to a Purchaser, shall be cumulative and not
alternative.
8.12 Attorney Fees. Notwithstanding any other provision herein, if any action at law
or in equity is necessary to enforce or interpret the terms of this Agreement or the exhibits
hereto, the prevailing party shall be entitled to reasonable attorneys' fees, costs and
disbursements in addition to any other relief to which such party may be entitled.
8.13 Exculpation Among Purchasers. Each Purchaser acknowledges that it is not
relying upon any person, firm or corporation, other than the Company and its officers and
directors, in making its investment or decision to invest in the Company. Each Purchaser agrees
that no Purchaser nor the respective controlling persons, officers, directors, partners, agents, or
employees of any Purchaser shall be liable to any other Purchaser for any action heretofore or
hereafter taken or omitted to be taken by any of them in connection with the purchase of the
Securities.
8.14 Waiver of Conflicts. Each party to this Agreement acknowledges that DLA
Piper LLP (US) ("DLA"), outside general counsel to the Company, has in the past performed
and is or may now or in the future represent one or more Purchasers or their affiliates in matters
unrelated to the transactions contemplated by this Agreement (the "Financing"), including
representation of such Purchasers or their affiliates in matters of a similar nature to the
Financing. DLA believes that its representation of the Company in the Financing will not
adversely affect its relationship with those of the Purchasers who are clients of DLA, and that its
representation of those Purchasers in matters unrelated to the Financing will not adversely affect
DLA's representation of the Company in the Financing. The applicable rules of professional
conduct require that DLA inform the parties hereunder of this dual representation and obtain
their consent to DLA's representation of the Company, and their waiver of the conflict of interest
which arises from their DLA's representation of the Company adverse to any of the Purchasers
who are clients of DLA, DLA has served as outside general counsel to the Company and has
negotiated the terms of the Financing solely on behalf of the Company. The Company and each
Purchaser hereby (a) acknowledge that they have had an opportunity to ask for and have
obtained information relevant to such representation, including disclosure of the reasonably
foreseeable adverse consequences of such representation; (b) acknowledge that with respect to
the Financing, DLA has represented solely the Company, and not any Purchaser or any
stockholder, director or employee of the Company or any Purchaser; (c) gives its informed
consent to DLA's representation of the Company in the Financing; and (d) represents that it has
had the opportunity to be, or has been, represented by independent counsel in giving the waivers
contained in this Section 8.14.
[REMAINDER OF THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
WEST\ 24004/077.6 15
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Series A Preferred Stock
Purchase Agreement as of the date first set forth above.
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
By:
Jeanne Houweling
President and Chief Executive Officer
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
SERIES A PREFERRED STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
PURCHASER:
Name:
David J. Mitchell
Signature:
Address:
Facsimile:
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
SERIES A PREFERRED STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
PURCHASER:
Name: ‘:47/1-4977 1//94/
Jonathan Lcitersdorf
Signature:
Address: j(.9/5/9,57 — 6 -0 1413 off/,S2  fr5c/e-Npn) yeyo, /OD  La
Facsimile:
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
SERIES A PREFERRED STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
PURfHASER•
WT.51\240047077.7
Signature:
Address:
Facsimile:
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
SERIES A PREFERRED STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
Address:
Facsimile:
WEST24004/077.8
/9 Wesf• /MA S'Ireeij /   Roa..-
/VetN torg, /97 0026
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
SERIES A PREFERRED STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
PURCHASERrn
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
Name: Jeffrey Epstein
Title: FLe
Signature:
Address:  (...otOo P. et) kiooV
RS
Facsimile:
WES-1\240770049.1
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
SERIES A PREFERRED STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
PURCHASER:
CVAFH I LL '
By:
Name: How rd W. Lutnick
Title: President
Address:
Facsimile:
[Si5na4wt Utz 3S-0,Crtro Seise S 14 Tee-ft vv4,4 9i.Dck
90 ( vfilotaS, in (.3
EXHIBITS
Exhibit A — Schedule of Purchasers
Exhibit B — Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation
Exhibit C — Payment Schedule
Exhibit D — Investors' Rights Agreement
Exhibit E — Co-Sale & Right of First Refusal Agreement
Exhibit F — Voting Agreement
Exhibit G — Schedule of Exceptions
Exhibit H — Assignment of Inventions, Non-Disclosure and Non-Compete Agreement
WES11240047077.6
Exhibit A
SCHEDULE OF PURCHASERS
Initial Closing — December 28, 2012
Aggregate
Name No. of Shares Purchase Price
David J. Mitchell
Jonathan Leitersdorf
685,714 $299,999.88
3,428,571 $1,499,999.81
Total 4,114,285 $1,799,999.69
WES1VA 0047077.6
Exhibit A
SCHEDULE OF PURCHASERS
Subsequent Closing — April 10, 2013
Aggregate
Name No. of Shares Purchase Price
David J. Mitchell 457,143 $200,000.06
Richard Kirshenbaum 114,286 $50,000.13
Tom Glocer 228,571 $99,999.81
Southern Trust Company, Inc. 1,142,857 $499,999.94
Total 6,057,142 $2,649,999.63
Exhibit A
SCHEDULE OF PURCHASERS
Subsequent Closing — July 23, 2013
Aggregate
Name No. of Shares Purchase Price
CVAFH I LLC
Dani Ilani
David J. Mitchell
Gil Mandelzis
Jonathan Leitersdorf
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
800,000
169,508
285,714
57,142
285,714
285,714
$350,000
$74,159.75
$124,999.87
$24,999.63
$124,999.87
$124,999.87
Total: 7,940,935 $3,474,158.50
Exhibit B
AMENDED AND RESTATED CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION
WEST \ 2400471)77.6
SCHEDULE I
Exhibit
PAYMENT SCHEDULE
"Subsequent Investment Schedule"
Name of Purchaser Subsequent
Investment Amount
Investment Type Date
Option But Not Obligation to Purchase
Jonathan Leitersdorf $125,000 Option But Not
Obligation to
Purchase
Exercise on or before
July 31, 2013
David J. Mitchell $125,000 Option But Not
Obligation to
Purchase
Exercise on or before
July 31, 2013
Southern Trust
Company, Inc.
$125,000 Option But Not
Obligation to
Purchase
Exercise on or before
July 31, 2013
Gil Mandelzis $25,000 Option But Not
Obligation to
Purchase
Exercise on or before
July 31, 2013
Dani Ilani $74,160 Option But Not
Obligation to
Purchase
Exercise on or before
July 31, 2013
CVAFH LLC $350,000 Option But Not
Obligation to
Purchase
Exercise on or before
July 31, 2013
David J. Mitchell $225,280 Option But Not
Obligation to
Purchase
Exercise on or bcfore
August 31, 2013
Southern Trust
Company, Inc.
$225,280 Option But Not
Obligation to
Purchase
Exercise on or before
August 31, 2013
Jonathan Leitersdorf $225,280 Option But Not
Obligation to
Purchase
Exercise on or before
August 31, 2013
Total $1,500,000
All of the options listed above may be exercised in whole or in part at he sole discretion of the
holder of such options.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in any prior agreement relating to the options
described above, the August 31, 2013 options in favor of David J. Mitchell, Southern Trust
Company, Inc. and Jonathan Leitersdorf shall remain in full force and effect as to each Purchaser
through August 31, 2013, even if such Purchaser fails to exercise all or part of his or its July 31,
2013 option.
Y/ES11241590172.2
Exhibit D
INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
ViEST\240047077.6
Exhibit E
RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL AND CO-SALE AGREEMENT
WES-11240047077.6
Exhibit F
VOTING AGREEMENT
WEST \ 240047077.6
Exhibit G
SCHEDULE OF EXCEPTIONS
WES11240047077.6
Exhibit H
ASSIGNMENT OF INVENTIONS, NON-DISCLOSURE AND NON-COMPETE
AGREEMENT
WEST240047077.6
Delaware The First State
PAGE
I, JEFFREY W. BULLOCK, SECRETARY OF STATE OF THE STATE OF
DELAWARE, DO HEREBY CERTIFY THE ATTACHED IS A TRUE AND CORRECT
COPY OF THE RESTATED CERTIFICATE OF "ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.",
FILED IN THIS OFFICE ON THE TWENTY-EIGHTH DAY OF DECEMBER, A.D.
2012, AT 2:17 O'CLOCK P.M.
A FILED COPY OF THIS CERTIFICATE HAS BEEN FORWARDED TO THE
NEW CASTLE COUNTY RECORDER OF DEEDS.
4973434 8100
121402363
You may verify this certificate online
at corp.delaware.gov/authver.shtml
jeffreywAtaxicsecrewyofstate
AUTHE TION: 0105217
DATE: 12-28-12
State of Delaware
Secretary of State
Division of Corporations
Delivered 02:22 PM 12/28/2012
FILED 02:17 PH 12/28/2012
5121,  121402363 - 4973434 FILE
AMENDED AND RESTATED
CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION
OF AMIN SOLUTIONS, iNC.
AdFin Solutions, Inc , a corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of
Delaware, as originally incorporated as AdFin Services, Inc , hereby ccr titles as follows:
1 The name of the corporation is AdFin Solutions, Inc
2 The corporation was incorporated in Delaware pursuant to a Certificate of
Incorporation filed with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware on April 25, 2011
3 This Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation restates, integrates and
further amends the Certificate of Incorporation of the corporation as het ein set forth in hill:
ARTICLE I
1 he name of the corporation is AdFin Solutions, inc (hereinafter, the "Corporation")
ARTICLE II
The address of the registered office of the Corporation in the State of Delaware is 3411
Silverside Road, Rodney Building #104, City of Wilmington, County of New Castle 19810, and
the name of the registered agent of the Corporation in the State of Delaware at such address is
Corporate Creations Network Inc
ARTICLE III
the purpose of the Corporation is to engage in any lawful act or activity for which a
cotpotation may be organized under the General Corporation law of Delaware
ARTICLE IV
The Corporation is authorized to issue two classes of stock, designated "Common Stock"
and "Preferred Stock," each with a par value of $0 00001 per share. The total number of shares
of Common Stock that the Corporation is authorized to issue is 22,250,000 shares. The total
number of shines of Preferred Stock that the Corporation is authorized to issue is 10.250,000
shares
the Preferred Stock may be issued from time to time in one or more series The first
series of Preferred Stock shall consist of 10,250.000 shares and shall be designated -Series A
Preferred Stock"
The relative rights, preferences, privileges and restrictions granted to or imposed upon the
Preferred Stock are as follows:
WRS1124004706A 6 1

1. Dividends. The holders of the then outstanding Preferred Stock shall be entitled to
receive, when, if and as declared by the Board of Directors, out of assets legally available
therefor. prior and in preference to any declaration or payment of any dividend on the Common
Stock (payable other than in Common Stock or other securities or rights convertible into or
emitting the holder thereof to receive, directly or indirectly, additional shares of Common Stock),
dividends which shall accrue at the annual rate of $0.0352 per share of Series A Preferred Stock
("Accruing Dividends") as adjusted for any stock splits, reverse stock splits, stock dividends and
similar recapitalization events (each a "Recapitalization Event'). Accruing Dividends shall
accrue from day to day, whether or not declared, and shall be cumulative. No dividends shall be
paid on any share of Common Stock unless a dividend (including the amount of any dividends
paid pursuant to the above provisions of this Section 1) is paid with respect to all outstanding
shares of Preferred Stock in an amount for each such share of Preferred Stock equal to or greater
than the aggregate amount of such dividends for all shares of Common Stock into which each
such share of Preferred Stock could then be converted.

2. Liquidation Preference. In the event of a Liquidation Event (as defined below), the
assets and funds of the Corporation available for distribution to stockholders shall be distributed
as follows:

(a) First, the holders of shares of Series A Preferred Stock then outstanding
shall be entitled to receive, out of the assets of the Corporation legally available for distribution
to its stockholders, before any payment or distribution of such assets shall be made in respect of
the Corporation's Common Stock, an amount equal to $0.4375 per share of Series A Preferred
Stock, as adjusted for any Recapitalization Events (the "Original Series A Price") and unpaid
dividends on such shares to the date fixed for such distribution. If, upon the occurrence of such
event, the assets of the Corporation legally available for distribution are insufficient to permit the
payment to the holders of Series A Preferred Stock of the full preferential amounts described in
this Section 2(a), then the entire assets available for distribution to stockholders shall be
distributed to the holders of the Series A Preferred Stock ratably in proportion to the full
preferential amounts which they would be entitled to receive pursuant to the preceding sentence
of this Section 2(a).

(b) After the fi ll preferential amounts due the holders of Preferred Stock
pursuant to Section 2(a) have been paid or set aside, the remaining assets of the Corporation
legally available for distribution to its stockholders, if any, shall be distributed to the holders of
Common Stock ratably in proportion to the number of shares of Common Stock then held by
each holder.
(c) Each of the following events shall be deemed to be a "Liquidation Event'
as that term is used in this Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation unless the holders
of at least 90% of the outstanding shares of the Series A Preferred Stock elect otherwise by
written notice sent to the Corporation at least 30 days prior to the effective date of any such
event: (i) the liquidation, dissolution or winding up of the Corporation, either voluntary or
involuntary, (ii) a merger or consolidation of the Corporation into or with another entity after
which the stockholders of the Corporation immediately prior to such transaction do not own,
immediately following the consummation of the transaction by virtue of their shares in the
Corporation or securities received in exchange for such shares in connection with the transaction,
WEST1240047068 6 2
a majority of the voting power of the surviving entity in proportions substantially similar to those
that existed immediately prior to such transaction, (iii) the sale, transfer or issuance by the
Corporation, or the sale or transfer by the Corporation's stockholders other than a sale or transfer
by the stockholders to existing stockholders of the Corporation or affiliated parties of such
existing stockholders, in either case, of more than 50% of the voting power of the Corporation in
a transaction or series of related transactions, and (iv) the sale, transfer or other disposition (but
not including a transfer or disposition by pledge or mortgage to a bona fide lender) of all or
substantially all of the assets of the Corporation (other than to a wholly-owned subsidiary).
Notwithstanding the foregoing, neither (A) a merger effected exclusively for the purpose of
changing the domicile of the Corporation nor (B) the sale of shares of Preferred Stock of the
Corporation in a transaction or series of related transactions effected primarily for equity
financing purposes shall be deemed a Liquidation Event.

(d) In the event of any Liquidation Event of the Corporation involving the
distribution of assets other than cash to the stockholders of the Corporation, the value of the
assets to be distributed shall be determined as follows:

(i) In the case of securities that are not subject to investment letter or
other similar restrictions on free tradability,
(A)if traded on a national securities exchange or through the
Nasdaq Global Market, the value shall be deemed to be the average of the closing prices of the
securities over the 10 day period ending three days prior to the closing;

(B) if actively traded over-the-counter, the value shall be deemed
to be the average of (i) the average of the last bid and ask prices or (ii) the closing sale prices
(whichever is applicable) over the 30 day period ending three days prior to the closing; and
(C)if there is no active public market, the value shall be the fair
market value thereof, as mutually determined by the Corporation and the holders of at least a
majority of the voting power of all then outstanding shares of Preferred Stock.

(ii) In the case of securities subject to investment letter or other
restrictions on free marketability (other than restrictions arising solely by virtue of a
stockholder's status as an affiliate or former affiliate), the value shall be based on an appropriate
discount from the market value determined as above in Section 2(dXi) to reflect the approximate
fair market value thereof, as determined by the Board of Directors in the good faith exercise of
its reasonable judgment
(iii) In the case of any other property, the value shall be equal to the
property's fair market value, as determined by the Board of Directors in the good faith exercise
of its reasonable judgment.

(iv) The foregoing methods for valuing non-cash consideration to be
distributed in connection with a Liquidation Event may be superseded by any determination of
such value set forth in the definitive agreements governing such Liquidation Event.
WEST12406070686 3

(e) The Corporation does not have the power to effect any transaction
constituting a Liquidation Event pursuant to Section 2(eXii) above unless the agreement or plan
of merger or consolidation provides that the consideration payable to the stockholders of the
Corporation shall be allocated among the holders of capital stock of the Corporation in
accordance with Sections 2(a) and 2(b) above.

(f) Following the occurrence of any Liquidation Event, the Corporation shall,
to the extent that the Corporation has control over, or title to, the proceeds from such Liquidation
Event, use commercially reasonable efforts to distribute such proceeds as promptly as practicable
in accordance with Sections 2(a) and 2(b) above, taking into account the terms and conditions of
the Liquidation Event, including but not limited to, any earn-out or escrow provisions. Prior to
the distribution in accordance with this Section 2(f). the Corporation shall not expend or
dissipate the consideration received for such Liquidation Event, except (i) to discharge expenses
incurred in the ordinary course of business, and (ii) as otherwise required by the agreement
providing for such Liquidation Event, including but not limited to, payment for the fees and
expenses, if any, of bankers, accountants or lawyers for the Corporation.

3. Conversion. The holders of the Preferred Stock shall have conversion rights as
follows:
(a) Right to Convert. Each share of Preferred Stock shall be convertible, at
the option of the holder thereof, at any time after the date of issuance of such share, at the office
of the Corporation or any transfer agent for the Preferred Stock, into Common Stock. The
number of shares of fully paid and nonassessable Common Stock into which each share of
Series A Preferred Stock may be converted shall equal the Original Series A Price divided by the
Series A Conversion Price (as defined below) in effect at the time of conversion (the "Series A
Conversion Rate"). The Conversion Price for the Series A Preferred Stock shall initially be
$0.4375 and shall be subject to adjustment as provided in Section 3(d) below. The Series A
Conversion Price shall be referred to herein as a "Conversion Price" and the Series A
Conversion Rate shall be referred to herein as a "Conversion Rate."

(b) Automatic Conversion. Each share of Preferred Stock shall
automatically be converted into fully paid and nonassessable shares of Common Stock, at the
then effective Conversion Price, upon (i) the vote or written consent of the holders of at least a
ninety percent (90%) majority of the voting power represented by the then outstanding shares of
Preferred Stock (voting together as a single class on an as-convened basis) or (ii) the closing of a
firm commitment underwritten public offering pursuant to an effective registration statement
under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, covering the offer and sale of Common Stock with
aggregate gross proceeds to the Corporation (prior to underwriters' commissions and expenses)
of not less than S15,000,000 (a "Qua! fl ed IPO").
(c) Mechanics of Conversion. Before any holder of Preferred Stock shall be
entitled to convert the same into shares of Common Stock, such holder shall surrender the
certificate or certificates therefore (or a reasonably acceptable affidavit and indemnity
undertaking in the case of a lost, stolen or destroyed certificate), duly endorsed, at the
headquarters of the Corporation or of any transfer agent for the Corporation and shall give
written notice to the Corporation at such office that the holder elects to convert the same and
WEST:M0.O068.6 4
shall state therein the name or names in which the certificate or certificates for shares of
Common Stock are to be issued (except that no such written notice of election to convert shall be
necessary in the event of an automatic conversion upon a Qualified IPO pursuant to Section
3(b)(ii) above). The Corporation shall, as soon as practicable thereafter, issue and deliver at such
office to such holder of Preferred Stock, or to the nominee or nominees of such holder, a
certificate or certificates for the number of shares of Common Stock to which he shall be entitled
as aforesaid. Such conversion shall be deemed to have been made immediately prior to the close
of business on the date of such surrender of the shares of Preferred Stock to be converted (except
that, in the case of an automatic conversion upon a Qualified IPO pursuant to Section 3(b)(ii)
above), such conversion shall be deemed to have been made immediately prior to the closing of
the Qualified IPO) and the person or persons entitled to receive the shares of Common Stock
issuable upon such conversion shall be treated for all purposes as the record holder or holders of
such shares of Common Stock on such date. Upon the occurrence of either of the events
specified in Section 3(b) above, the outstanding shares of Preferred Stock shall be converted
automatically without any further action by the holders of such shares and whether or not the
certificates representing such shares are surrendered to the Corporation or its transfer agent;
provided. however, that the Corporation shall not be obligated to issue certificates evidencing the
shares of Common Stock issuable upon such conversion unless either the certificates evidencing
such shares of Preferred Stock are delivered to the Corporation or its transfer agent as provided
above, or the holder notifies the Corporation or its transfer agent that such certificates have been
lost, stolen or destroyed and executes an agreement satisfactory to the Corporation to indemnify
the Corporation against any loss incurred by it in connection with such certificates.

(d) Adjustments to Conversion Price for Dilutive Issuances.
(i) Special Definitions. For purposes of this Section 3(d), the
following definitions shall apply:

(A) "Original Issue Date" shall mean, with respect to any
series of Preferred Stock, the date on which shares of such series are first issued by the
Corporation.

(B) "Additional Shares of Common Stock" shall mean all
shares of Common Stock issued (or, pursuant to Section 3(dXii) below, deemed to be issued) by
the Corporation after the Original Issue Date, other than:

(1) shares of Common Stock issued upon conversion of
Preferred Stock;
(2) shares of Common Stock issued or issuable to officers,
directors or employees of, or consultants to, the Corporation pursuant to any stock option plan or
agreement or other stock incentive program or agreement approved by the Board of Directors;

(3) shares of Common Stock issued or issuable to financial
institutions, equipment lessors, landlords, business partners or other entities in connection with
commercial credit arrangements, equipment financings, real estate transactions, joint ventures or
other partnering arrangements or similar transactions approved by the Board of Directors;
WES11240047068 6 5

(4) shares issued upon exercise or conversion of any
warrants that arc outstanding as of the date of this Amended and Restated Certificate of
Incorporation;

(5) shares issued in connection with the acquisition by the
Corporation of voting control or all or substantially all of the assets of another business entity in
a transaction approved by the Board of Directors;

(6) shares for which an adjustment is made pursuant to

Section 3(d)(v); or
(7) shares issued in connection with acquisitions of
technology or intellectual property in transactions that are approved by the Board of Directors.

(C) "Options" shall mean rights, options or warrants to
subscribe for, purchase or otherwise acquire either Common Stock or Convertible Securities (as
defined below).

(D) "Convertible Securities" shall mean any evidences of
indebtedness, shares of Preferred Stock or other securities convertible into or exchangeable for
Common Stock.

(ii) Deemed Issue of Additional Shares of Common Stock. In the
event the Corporation at any time or from time to time after the Original Issue Date shall issue
any Options or Convertible Securities or shall fix a record date for the determination of holders
of any class of securities entitled to receive any such Options or Convertible Securities, then the
following provisions shall apply:

(A) The maximum number of shares (as set forth in the
instrument relating thereto without regard to any provisions contained therein for a subsequent
adjustment of such number) of Common Stock issuable upon the exercise of such Options or
upon the conversion or exchange of such Convertible Securities shall be deemed to have been
issued as of the time of the issuance of such Option or Convertible Security or, in case such a
record date shall have been fixed, as of the close of business on such record date.

(B) Except as provided in paragraphs (C) and (D) below, no
further adjustment in the Conversion Price shall be made upon the subsequent issue of
Convertible Securities or shares of Common Stock upon the exercise of such Options or
conversion or exchange of such Convertible Securities.

(C) If such Options or Convertible Securities by their terms
provide, with the passage of time or otherwise, for any change in the consideration payable to the
Corporation or the number of shares of Common Stock issuable upon the exercise, conversion or
exchange thereof (including a change resulting from the antidilution provisions of such Options
or Convertible Securities), the Conversion Price computed upon the original issue thereof (or
upon the occurrence of a record date with respect thereto) and any subsequent adjustments based
thereon shall, upon any such increase or decrease becoming effective, be recomputed to reflect
such increase or decrease insofar as it affects such Options or the rights of conversion or
WES-1%24064706R 6 6
exchange under such Convertible Securities; provided, however, that such recomputed
Conversion Price shall not exceed the Conversion Price that would have been in effect had the
original issuance of Options or Convertible Securities not been deemed to constitute an issuance
of Additional Shares of Common Stock.

(ID) Upon the expiration or termination of any such Options or
unconverted or unexchanged Convertible Securities, the Conversion Price, to the extent in any
way affected by or computed using such Options or Convertible Securities, shall be recomputed
to reflect the issuance of only the number of shares of Common Stock actually issued upon the
exercise of such Options or Convertible Securities.
(iii) Adjustment of Conversion Price for Dilutive Issuances. In the
event the Corporation shall issue Additional Shares of Common Stock (including Additional
Shares of Common Stock deemed to be issued pursuant to Section 3(dXii)) after the Original
Issue Date of any series of Preferred Stock without consideration or for a consideration per share
less than the Conversion Price for such series in effect immediately prior to such issuance, then
and in each such event the Conversion Price for such series shall be reduced to a price (rounded
to the nearest one tenth cent) equal to such Conversion Price multiplied by a fraction:

(x) the numerator of which is equal to the number of shares of
Common Stock outstanding or deemed to be outstanding immediately prior to such issuance plus
the number of shares of Common Stock which the aggregate consideration received by the
Corporation for the total number of Additional Shares of Common Stock so issued would
purchase at the Conversion Price in effect immediately prior to such issuance; and

(y) the denominator of which is equal to the number of shares
of Common Stock outstanding or deemed to be outstanding immediately prior to such issuance
plus the number of Additional Shares of Common Stock so issued.
For the purposes of this Section 3(d)(iii), the number of shares of Common Stock deemed to be
outstanding shall include the Common Stock issuable upon exercise of Options outstanding
immediately prior to such issue or upon conversion or exchange of Convertible Securities
(including the Preferred Stock) outstanding (assuming exercise of any outstanding Options
therefor) immediately prior to such issue.

(iv) Determination of Consideration. For purposes of this

Section 3(d), the consideration received by the Corporation for the issue of any Additional
Shares of Common Stock shall be computed as follows:

(A) Cash sod Property. Such consideration shall:
(1) insofar as it consists of cash, be computed at the
aggregate amount of cash received by the Corporation before deducting any reasonable
discounts, commissions or other expenses allowed, paid or incurred by the Corporation for any
underwriting or otherwise in connection with the issuance and sale thereof;
WEST1240047068 6 7

(2) insofar as it consists of property other than cash, be
computed at the fair value thereof at the time of such issue, as determined by the Board of
Directors in the good faith exercise of its reasonable business judgment; and

(3) in the event Additional Shares of Common Stock
are issued together with other securities or other assets of the Corporation for consideration that
covers both, be the proportion of such consideration so received, computed as provided in
clauses (I) and (2) above, as determined by the Board of Directors in the good faith exercise of
its reasonable business judgment.

(B) Options and Convertible Securities. The consideration
per share received by the Corporation for Additional Shares of Common Stock deemed to have
been issued pursuant to Section 3(d) relating to Options and Convertible Securities shall be equal
to:

(x) the total amount, if any, received or receivable by
the Corporation as consideration for the issuance of such Options or Convertible Securities, plus
the minimum aggregate amount of additional consideration (as set forth in the instruments
relating thereto, without regard to any provision contained therein for a subsequent adjustment of
such consideration) payable to the Corporation upon the exercise of such Options or the
conversion or exchange of such Convertible Securities, or in the case of Options for Convertible
Securities, the exercise of such Options for Convertible Securities and the conversion or
exchange of such Convertible Securities, divided by

(y) the maximum number of shares of Common Stock
(as set forth in the instruments relating thereto, without regard to any provision contained therein
for a subsequent adjustment of such number) issuable upon full exercise and conversion of all
then outstanding Options and Convertible Securities, or in the case of Options for Convertible
Securities, the exercise of such Options for Convertible Securities and the conversion or
exchange of such Convertible Securities.

(v) Other Adjustments to Conversion Price.
(A) Subdivisions, Combinations or Consolidations of
Common Stock. In the event the outstanding shares of Common Stock shall be subdivided,
combined or consolidated, by stock split, reverse stock split or similar event, into a greater or
lesser number of shares of Common Stock after the Original Issue Date of a series of Preferred
Stock, the Conversion Price for such series in effect immediately prior to such subdivision,
combination or consolidation shall, concurrently with the effectiveness of such subdivision,
combination or consolidation, be proportionately adjusted.

(B) Common Stock Dividends and Distributions. If, after
the Original Issue Date of a series of Preferred Stock, the Corporation at any time or from time to
time issues, or fixes a record date for determination of holders of Common Stock entitled to
receive, a dividend or other distribution payable in additional shares of Common Stock, then in
each such event, as of the lime of such issuance or, in the event such record date is fixed, as of
the close of business on such record date, the Conversion Price for such series that is then in
NTS112400.7068 6 8
effect shall be decreased by multiplying the Conversion Price then in effect by a fraction, (x) the
numerator of which is the number of shares of Common Stock issued and outstanding
immediately prior to the time of such issuance or the close of business on such record date, and

(y) the denominator of which is the number of shares of Common Stock issued and outstanding
immediately prior to the time of such issuance or the close of business on such record date plus
the number of shares of Common Stock issuable in payment of such dividend or distribution;
provided, however, that if such record date is fixed and such dividend or distribution is not paid
in full on the date fixed therefor, each Conversion Price shall be recomputed accordingly as of
the close of business on such record date and thereafter each Conversion Price shall be adjusted
pursuant to this Section 3(dXv)(B) to reflect the actual payment of such dividend or distribution.

(C) Other Distributions. In case the Corporation shall
distribute to holders of its Common Stock shares of its capital stock (other than shares of
Common Stock and other than as otherwise subject to adjustment pursuant to this Section 3(d)),
stock or other securities of other persons, evidences of indebtedness issued by the Corporation or
other persons, assets (excluding cash dividends) or options or rights (excluding options to
purchase and rights to subscribe for Common Stock or other securities of the Corporation
convertible into or exchangeable for Common Stock), or shall fix a record date for determination
of holders of Common Stock entitled to receive such a distribution, then, in each such case,
provision shall be made so that the holders of Preferred Stock shall be entitled to receive, upon
conversion thereof, in addition to the number of shares of Common Stock receivable thereupon,
the distribution of securities of the Corporation that they would have received had their Preferred
Stock been convened into Common Stock on the date of such event (or on the record date with
respect thereto, if such record date is fixed) and had they thereafter, during the period from the
date of such event to and including the date of conversion, retained such distribution receivable
by them as aforesaid during such period, subject to all other adjustments called for during such
period under this Section 3 with respect to the rights of the holders of the Preferred Stock.

(II) Recapitalizations and Reorganizations. In the case of
any capital recapitalization or reorganization (other than a subdivision, combination or other
recapitalization provided for elsewhere in this Section 3 or a Liquidation Event provided for in

Section 2), or the fixing of any record date for determination of holders of Common Stock
affected by such recapitalization or reorganization, provision shall be made so that the holders of
Preferred Stock shall be entitled to receive, upon conversion thereof, the type and number of
shares of stock or other securities or property of the Corporation or otherwise that they would
have received had their Preferred Stock been converted into Common Stock on the date of such
event (or on the record date with respect thereto, if such record date is fixed) and had they
thereafter, during the period from the date of such event to and including the date of conversion,
retained such shares of stock or other securities or property receivable by them as aforesaid
during such period, subject to all other adjustments called for during such period under this

Section 3 with respect to the rights of the holders of the Preferred Stock.

(e) Certificate as to Adjustments. Upon the occurrence of each adjustment
or readjustment of the Conversion Prices pursuant to this Section 3, the Corporation at its
expense shall promptly compute such adjustment or readjustment in accordance with the terms
hereof and furnish to each holder of a share of such series of Preferred Stock a certificate setting
forth such adjustment or readjustment and showing in detail the facts upon which such
WEST1240647068 6 9
adjustment or readjustment is based including the consideration received for any Additional
Shares of Common Stock issued. The Corporation shall, upon the written request at any time of
any holder of a Preferred Stock, furnish or cause to be furnished to such holder a like certificate
setting forth (i) such adjustments and readjustments, (ii) the Conversion Price at the time in
effect for the series of Preferred Stock held by such holder and (iii) the number of shares of
Common Stock and the type and amount, if any, of other property which at the time would be
received upon the conversion of a share of such series of Preferred Stock.

(f) Fractional Shares. No fractional shares of Common Stock shall be
issued upon conversion of shares of Preferred Stock. In lieu of any fractional shares to which the
holder of Preferred Stock would otherwise be entitled, the Corporation shall pay cash equal to
such fraction multiplied by the fair market value of one share of Common Stock as reasonably
determined by the Board of Directors. The number of whole shares issuable to each holder of a
series of Preferred Stock upon such conversion shall be determined on the basis of the number of
shares of Common Stock issuable upon conversion of the total number of shares of such series
being converted into Common Stock by such holder at that time.

(g) Notices of Record Date. In the event (i) the Corporation shall take a
record of the holders of its capital stock for the purpose of entitling them to receive a dividend or
other distribution (other than a cash dividend). (ii) of any capital reorganization, reclassification
or recapitalization (other than a subdivision or combination of its outstanding shares of Common
Stock), or (iii) of a Liquidation Event pursuant to Section 2, then, and in any such case, the
Corporation shall cause to be mailed to each holder of record of the Preferred Stock at the
address of record of such stockholder as set forth on the Corporation's books, at least 20 days
prior to the earliest date hereinafter specified, a notice stating the material terms of the proposed
transaction and the date on which (x) a record is to be taken for the purpose of such dividend or
distribution or (y) such reorganization, reclassification, recapitalization or Liquidation Event is to
take place and the date, if any is to be fixed, as of which holders of capital stock of record shall
be entitled to exchange their shares of capital stock for securities or other property deliverable
upon such reorganization, reclassification, recapitalization or Liquidation Event; provided,
however, that such notice period may be shortened upon the written consent of holders of
Preferred Stock that are entitled to such notice rights or similar notice rights and that represent at
least a ninety percent (90%) majority of the voting power of all then outstanding shares of such
Preferred Stock (voting together as a single class on a converted basis). If any material change in
the facts set forth in the written notice shall occur, the Corporation shall promptly give written
notice of such material change to each holder of shares of Preferred Stock.

(h) No Impairment. Without obtaining such consent of the holders of
Preferred Stock as may be required under Section 6 hereof, the Corporation will not, by
amendment of its Certificate of Incorporation or through any reorganization, transfer of assets,
consolidation, merger, dissolution, issue or sale of securities or any other voluntary action, avoid
or seek to avoid the observance or performance of any of the terms to be observed or performed
hereunder by the Corporation, but will at all times in good faith assist in the carrying out of all
the provisions of this Section 3 and in the taking of all such action as may be necessary or
appropriate in order to protect the conversion rights of the holders of Preferred Stock against
impairment.
WEST240647068 6 10

(i) Reservation of Stock Issuable Upon Conversion. The Corporation shall
at all times reserve and keep available out of its authorized but unissued shares of Common
Stock, solely for the purpose of effecting the conversion of the Preferred Stock, such number of
its shares of Common Stock as shall from time to time be sufficient to effect the conversion of all
outstanding shares of Preferred Stock; and if at any time the number of authorized but unissued
shares of Common Stock shall not be sufficient to effect the conversion of all then outstanding
shares of Preferred Stock, the Corporation will take such corporate action as may, in the opinion
of its counsel, be necessary to increase its authorized but unissued shares of Common Stock to
such number of shares as shall be sufficient for such purpose.

4. Redemption.
(a) Redemption Date and Price. At any time after December 31, 2019, but
within ninety (90) days after receipt by the Corporation of a written request from the holders of
not less than 33.33% of the then outstanding shares of the Preferred Stock that all or a specified
percentage of such holders' shares of such Preferred Stock be redeemed, the Corporation shall, to
the extent it may lawfully do so, redeem the shares specified in such request in one (1)
installment in accordance with the procedures set forth in this Section 4 by paying in cash
therefor an amount per share equal to the sum of $0.4375 per share of the Series A Preferred
Stock (as adjusted for any Recapitalization Event) and all declared but unpaid dividends on such
shares (the "Redemption Price" for such series). The date fixed for redemption is referred to
herein as the "Redemption Date." Any redemption of less than all of the outstanding Series A
Preferred Stock pursuant to this Section 4 shall be made pro rata among the holders of the Series
A Preferred Stock in proportion to the number of shares of such Preferred Stock then held by
each holder.

(b) Procedure. At least fifteen (15) but no more than thirty (30) days prior to
the Redemption Date, written notice shall be mailed, first class postage prepaid, to each holder of
record (at the close of business on the business day next preceding the day on which notice is
given) of the Preferred Stock to be redeemed, at the address last shown on the records of the
Corporation for such holder, notifying the holder of the redemption to be effected, specifying the
number of shares to be redeemed from such holder, the Redemption Date, the applicable
Redemption Price and the place at which payment may be obtained and calling upon such holder
to surrender to the Corporation, in the manner and at the place designated, such holder's
certificate or certificates representing the shares to be redeemed (the "Redemption Notice").
Except as provided in Section 4(c), on or after the Redemption Date, each holder of shares of
Preferred Stock to be redeemed shall surrender to the Corporation the certificate or certificates
representing such shares, in the manner and at the place designated in the Redemption Notice,
and thereupon the applicable Redemption Price of such shares shall be payable to the order of the
person whose name appears on such certificate or certificates as the owner thereof and each
surrendered certificate shall be cancelled. In the event less than all the shares represented by any
such certificate are redeemed, a new certificate shall be issued representing the unredeemed
shares.

(c) Effect of Redemption; Insufficient Funds. From and after the
Redemption Date, unless there shall have been a default in payment of the Redemption Price, all
rights of the holders of shares of Preferred Stock designated for redemption in the Redemption
WES11.240047068 6 11
Notice relating to the Redemption Date (except the right to receive the applicable Redemption
Price without interest upon surrender of their certificate or certificates) shall cease with respect to
such shares, and such shares shall not thereafter be transferred on the books of the Corporation or
be deemed to be outstanding for any purpose whatsoever. If the funds of the Corporation legally
available for redemption of Preferred Stock on the Redemption Date are insufficient to redeem
the total number of shares of Preferred Stock to be redeemed on such date, those funds which are
legally available shall be used to redeem the maximum possible number of such shares ratably
among the holders of such shares to be redeemed based upon the total Redemption Price
applicable to their shares of Preferred Stock which are subject to redemption on the Redemption
Date. The shares of Preferred Stock not redeemed shall remain outstanding and entitled to all the
rights and preferences provided herein. At any time thereafter when additional funds of the
Corporation are legally available for the redemption of shares of Preferred Stock, such funds will
immediately be used to redeem the balance of the shares which the Corporation has become
obliged to redeem on the Redemption Date but which it has not redeemed.

5. Voting Rights.
(a) General. Each holder of Preferred Stock shall be entitled to a number of
votes equal to the number of whole shares of Common Stock into which such holder's shares of
Preferred Stock could then be converted and, except as otherwise required by law or as set forth
herein, shall have voting rights and powers equal to the voting rights and powers of the Common
Stock. Each holder of Preferred Stock shall be entitled to notice of any stockholders' meeting in
accordance with the Bylaws of the Corporation and shall be entitled to vote with the holders of
Common Stock with respect to any matter upon which holders of Common Stock have the right
to vote, except as otherwise provided herein or those matters required by law to be submitted to a
class vote.

(b) Election of Directors. At each election of directors of the Corporation, (i)
the holders of Series A Preferred Stock, voting as a separate class, shall be entitled to elect one

(1) director, (ii) the holders of Common Stock, voting as a separate class, shall be entitled to
elect three (3) directors and (iii) the holders of Preferred Stock and Common Stock, voting
together as a single class on an as-convened basis, shall be entitled to elect the remaining
directors of the Corporation. Any director elected as provided in the preceding sentence may be
removed with or without cause by, and only by, the affirmative vote of the holders of the shares
of the class or series of stock entitled to elect such director or directors, given either at a special
meeting of such stockholders duly called for that purpose or pursuant to a written consent of
stockholders.

6. Protective Provisions. So long as any shares of Series A Preferred Stock are
outstanding (as adjusted for any Recapitalization Event), the Corporation shall not, without first
obtaining the affirmative vote or written consent of the holders of at least 90% of the voting
power represented by the then outstanding shares of Series A Preferred Stock, voting together as
a separate class:

(a) amend the Certificate of Incorporation or Bylaws of the Corporation in a
manner that adversely affects the Series A Preferred Stock;
WEST1240047068.6 12

(b) increase or decrease the total number of authorized shares of the
Corporation;
(c) authorize or create any other equity security having a preference over, or
on a parity with, the Series A Preferred Stock;

(d) reclassify any outstanding shares of Series A Preferred Stock;
(e) redeem, purchase or otherwise acquire (or pay into or set aside a sinking
fund for such purpose) any shares of Common Stock or Preferred Stock other than in connection
with (i) the repurchase of Common Stock at the lower of the fair market value and the original
purchase price, from employees, officers, directors, consultants or other service providers
pursuant to agreements providing for such repurchase upon termination of employment, (ii) the
exercise of a contractual right of first refusal entitling the Corporation to purchase such shares
upon substantially the same terms offered by a third party, provided that the purchase is
approved by the Board of Directors, or (iii) the redemption of Preferred Stock pursuant to

Section 4;
(0 declare, set aside for payment or pay any dividend on the Common Stock,
other than a dividend payable solely in shares of Common Stock;

(g) authorize or enter into any transaction or series of related transactions
constituting a Liquidation Event;

(h) authorize the issuance of any debt security (other than trade payables in
the ordinary course of business) if the Corporation's aggregate indebtedness would exceed
$250,000;

(i) guarantee any indebtedness of a third party except for trade accounts of
the Corporation or any subsidiary entered into in the ordinary course of business;

(j) make any loan or advance to any person except advances to employees
and similar expenditures in the ordinary course of business or as approved by the Board;

(k) increase or decrease the authorized number of directors of the
Corporation;
hire, terminate or change the compensation of any executive officer,
change the principal business of the Corporation or enter into new lines of
business;
00 amend, waive or modify any provision relating to the non-competition,
non-solicitation and/or confidentiality or proprietary information contained in any agreement
with any of the Corporation's executive officers or directors; or
(o) enter into any agreement to do any of the foregoing
WESTV40647068 6 13
7. Status of Convened or Redeemed Stock. In the event any shams of Preferred
Stock shall be converted or redeemed pursuant to Section 3 or Section 4 hereof, or otherwise
acquired by the Corporation, the shares so converted or redeemed shall be canceled and shall not
be issuable by the Corporation, and the Certificate of Incorporation of the Corporation shall be
appropriately amended to effect the corresponding reduction in the Corporation's authorized
capital stock.
& Residual Rights. All rights accruing to the outstanding shares of the Corporation not
expressly provided for to the contrary herein shall be vested in the Common Stock.
ARTICLE V
The business and affairs of the Corporation shall be managed by or under the direction of
the Board of Directors. In addition to the powers and authority expressly conferred upon them
by statute or by this Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation or the Bylaws of the
Corporation, the directors are hereby empowered to exercise all such powers and do all such acts
and things as may be exercised or done by the Corporation. Election of directors need not be by
written ballot, unless the Bylaws of the Corporation so provide. Except as otherwise provided in
this Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation, the number of directors of the
Corporation shall be determined in the manner set forth in the Bylaws of the Corporation.
ARTICLE VI
Subject to any requisite stockholder approval pursuant to Article IV, Section 6 of this
Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation, (i) the Board of Directors is authorized to
make, adopt, amend, alter or repeal the Bylaws of the Corporation, and (ii) the stockholders shall
also have power to make, adopt, amend, alter or repeal the Bylaws of the Corporation.
ARTICLE VII
To the fullest extent permitted by the Delaware General Corporation Law, as the same
exists or may hereafter be amended, a director of the Corporation shall not be personally liable to
the Corporation or its stockholders for monetary damages for breach of fiduciary duty as a
director. Any repeal or modification of the foregoing provisions of this Article VII, or the
adoption of any provision of the Certificate of Incorporation inconsistent with this Article VII,
shall not adversely affect any right or protection of a director of the Corporation existing at the
time of, or increase the liability of any director of the Corporation with respect to any acts or
omissions occurring prior to, such repeal or modification.
ARTICLE VIII
To the fullest extent permitted by the Delaware General Corporation Law, as the same
exists or may hereafter be amended, the Corporation is authorized to provide indemnification of
(and advancement of expenses to) agents of the Corporation (and any other persons to which the
Delaware General Corporation Law permits the Corporation to provide indemnification) through
Bylaw provisions, agreements with such agents or other persons, the affirmative vote of
stockholders or disinterested directors or otherwise, in excess of the indemnification and
advancement otherwise permitted by Section 145 of the Delaware General Corporation Law,
WES112400$7066 6 14
subject only to limits created by applicable Delaware General Corporation Law (statutory or
non-statutory), with respect to actions for breach of duty to the Corporation, its stockholders and
others.
Any repeal or modification of the foregoing provisions of this Article VIII, or the
adoption of any provision of the Certificate of Incorporation inconsistent with this Article VIII,
shall not adversely affect any right or protection of a director, officer, agent or other person
existing at the time of, or increase the liability of any director, officer, agent or other person with
respect to any acts or omissions of such director, officer, agent or other person occurring prior to,
such repeal or modification.
ARTICLE IX
The Corporation reserves the right to amend or repeal any of the provisions contained in
this Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation in any manner now or hereafter
permitted by law, and the rights conferred upon the stockholders of the Corporation herein are
granted subject to this reservation."

4. This Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation has been duly adopted by
the board of directors and stockholders of the Corporation in accordance with the provisions of
Sections 228, 242 and 245 of the General Corporation Law of the State of Delaware.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned has executed this Amended and Restated
Certificate of Incorporation on this 28 day of December, 2012.
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
By: /s/ Jeanne Houwelina
Jeanne Houweling
Chief Executive Officer
WESTC:4) OW70611.6 15
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
December 28, 2012
WES11240047083.5
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
This Investors' Rights Agreement (this "Agreement') is made and entered into as of
December 28, 2012 (the "Effective Date") by and among AdFin Solutions, Inc. a Delaware
corporation (the "Company"), Jonathan Leitersdorf (the "Common Holder"), and the holders of
Series A Preferred Stock (the "Series A Stock") as set forth on Exhibit A hereto (the "Holder" or
the "Investors").
RECITALS

A. The Company and the Investors are parties to a Series A Preferred Stock Purchase
Agreement of even date herewith (the "Series A Agreement).

B. In order to induce the Investors to enter into the Series A Agreement and invest
funds in the Company pursuant thereto, the Company and the Common Holder desire to enter
into this Agreement with the Series A Holders.
Therefore, the parties agree as follows:
I. Definitions.
1.1 "Affiliate" means, with respect to any specified individual or entity, any other
individual or entity who or that, directly or indirectly, controls, is controlled by, or is under
common control with such specified individual or entity, including without limitation any
partner, officer, director, manager or employee of such entity and any venture capital fund now
or hereafter existing that is controlled by or under common control with one or more general
partners or managing members of, or shares the same management company with, such
individual or entity.
1.2 "Common Stock" means the common stock of the Company.
1.3 "Equity Securities" means (i) Common Stock, rights, options or warrants to
purchase Common Stock, (ii) any security other than Common Stock having voting rights in the
election of the Board of Directors, other than rights contingent upon a failure to pay dividends, or
(iii) any security convertible into or exchangeable for any of the foregoing.
1.4 "Exchange Act" means the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended.
1.5 "Form 5-3" means such form under the Securities Act as is in effect on the date
hereof or any successor registration form under the Securities Act subsequently adopted by the
SEC (as defined below) which permits inclusion or incorporation of substantial information by
reference to other documents filed by the Company with the SEC (as defined below).
WEST U40047083.5
1.6 "Holder" means any Investor that holds Registrable Securities or securities
convertible into Registrable Securities or any assignee of record of such Registrable Securities to
whom rights under Section 2 have been duly assigned in accordance with Section 2.11 hereof.
1.7 "Preferred Stock" means the Series A Stock.
1.8 "Register," "registered" and "registration" refer to a registration effected by the
preparation and filing of a registration statement in compliance with the Securities Act, and the
declaration or ordering of effectiveness of such registration statement.
1.9 "Registrable Securities" means: (i) any and all shares of Common Stock issued or
issuable upon conversion of the shares of Preferred Stock, and (ii) any shares of Common Stock
issued as (or issuable upon the conversion or exercise of any warrant, right or other security
which is issued as) a dividend or other distribution with respect to, in exchange for, or in
replacement of, such shares of Common Stock described in clause (i); provided, however, that
particular shares of any of the foregoing shall cease to be Registrable Securities once they have
been sold in any public offering or transferred by the Holder in a transaction in which its rights
under this Agreement are not assigned in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement.
1.10 "Registrable Securities then outstanding" means the number of shares of
Common Stock which are Registrable Securities and (i) are then issued and outstanding or

(ii) are then issuable pursuant to the exercise or conversion of options, warrants or convertible
securities.
1.11 "SEC' means the United States Securities and Exchange Commission.
1.12 "Securities Act" means the Securities Act of 1933, as amended.

2. Registration Rights.
2.1 Demand Registration.
(a) Request by Holders. If the Company shall receive at any time after six

(6) months after the effective date of the first registration statement for a public offering of
securities of the Company (other than a registration statement relating to the sale of securities to
employees of the Company pursuant to a stock option, stock purchase or similar benefit plan or
an SEC Rule 145 transaction) a written request from the Holders of at least 50% of the
Registrable Securities then outstanding ("Initiating Holders") that the Company file a
registration statement under the Securities Act covering the registration of fifty percent (50%) of
the Registrable Securities then outstanding or such lesser amount as would have an anticipated
aggregate public offering price of not less than SI 5,000,000, then the Company shall, within ten

(10) business days of the receipt of such written request, give written notice of such request
("Demand Notice") to all Holders and, as soon as practicable, file a registration statement under
the Securities Act covering all Registrable Securities that the Initiating Holders requested to be
registered and any additional Registrable Securities requested to be included in such registration
by any other Holders, as specified by notice given by each such Holder to the Company within
twenty (20) days of the date the Demand Notice is given, and in each case, subject to the
limitations of this Section 2.
2
WEST240047083.$
(b) Underwriting. If the Initiating Holders intend to distribute the
Registrable Securities covered by their request by means of an underwriting, then they shall so
advise the Company as a pan of their request made pursuant to Section 2.1(a) and the Company
shall include such information in the Demand Notice. In such event, the right of any Holder to
include such Holder's Registrable Securities in such registration shall be conditioned upon such
Holder's participation in such underwriting and the inclusion of such Holder's Registrable
Securities in the underwriting (unless otherwise mutually agreed by a majority in interest of the
Initiating Holders and such Holder) to the extent provided herein. The underwriters will be
selected by the Company and shall be reasonably acceptable to a majority in interest of the
Initiating Holders the Company. All Holders proposing to distribute their Registrable Securities
through such underwriting shall enter into an underwriting agreement in customary form with the
managing underwriter or underwriters selected for such underwriting. Notwithstanding any
other provision of this Section 2.1, if the managing underwriters advise the Company in writing
that marketing factors require a limitation of the number of securities to be underwritten, then the
Company shall so advise all Holders of Registrable Securities that would otherwise be registered
and underwritten pursuant hereto, and the number of Registrable Securities that may be included
in the underwriting shall be reduced as required by the underwriters and allocated among the
Holders on a pro rata basis according to the number of Registrable Securities held by each
Holder requesting registration (including the Initiating Holders); provided, however, that the
number of shares of Registrable Securities to be included in such underwriting and registration
shall not be reduced unless all other securities of the Company are first entirely excluded from
the underwriting and registration. Any Registrable Securities excluded and withdrawn from such
underwriting shall be withdrawn from the registration.

(c) Exceptions to Registration Obligations. The Company shall not be
obligated to effect, or to take any action to effect, any registration pursuant to this Section 2.1: (i)
during the period starting with the date sixty (60) days prior to the Company's good faith
estimate of the date of filing of, and ending on the date that is one hundred eighty (180) days
after the effective date of, a Company-initiated registration, provided that the Company is
actively employing in good faith commercially reasonable efforts to cause such registration
statement to become effective; (ii) after the Company has effected two (2) such registrations; or
(iii) if the Initiating Holders propose to dispose of shares of Registrable Securities that may be
immediately registered on Form S-3 pursuant to a request made pursuant to Section 2.3. A
registration shall not be counted as "effected" for purposes of this Section 2.1 until such time as
the applicable registration statement has been declared effective by the SEC, unless the Initiating
Holders withdraw their request for such registration and forfeit their right to one demand
registration pursuant to Section 2.6.

(d) Deferral of Registration. Notwithstanding the foregoing, if the Company
shall furnish to Holders requesting registration pursuant to this Section 2.1 a certificate signed by
the President or Chief Executive Officer of the Company stating that, in the good faith judgment
of the Board of Directors of the Company, it would be materially detrimental to the Company
and its shareholders for such registration statement to be filed and it is therefore essential to defer
the filing of such registration statement, then the Company shall have the right to defer such
filing for a period of not more than 120 days following receipt of the request of the Initiating
Holders under this Section 2.1; provided, however, that the Company may not utilize this right
more than twice in any 12-month period.
3
WEST240047083.5

(c) Other Company Shares. If the managing underwriters have not limited
the Registrable Securities to be underwritten, the Company may include securities for its own
account or for the account of others in such registration if the managing underwriters so agree
and if the number of Registrable Securities which would otherwise have been included in such
registration and underwriting will not thereby be limited.
2.2 Company Registration.

(a) Notice to Holders. If (but without any obligation to do so) the Company
proposes to register (including for this purpose a registration effected by the Company for
shareholders other than the Holders) any of its stock in connection with the public offering of
such stock (other than a registration relating solely to the issuance of securities by the Company
pursuant to a stock option, stock purchase or similar benefit plan or an SEC Rule 145 transaction,
or a registration in which the only stock being registered is stock issuable upon conversion of
debt securities that are also being registered), the Company shall promptly give each Holder
written notice of such registration. Upon the request of each Holder given within twenty (20)
days after such notice is given by the Company, the Company shall, subject to the provisions of

Section 2.2(c), use all reasonable efforts to cause to be registered all of the Registrable Securities
that each such Holder has requested to be included in such registration.

(b) Right to Terminate Registration. The Company shall have the right to
terminate or withdraw any registration initiated by it under this Section 2.2 before the effective
date of such registration, whether or not any Holder has elected to include Registrable Securities
in such registration. The expenses of such withdrawn registration shall be borne by the
Company in accordance with Section 2.6.
(c) Underwriting. If a registration of which the Company gives notice under
this Section 2.2 is for an underwritten offering, then the Company shall so advise the Holders. In
such event, the right of any Holder to include such Holder's Registrable Securities in such
registration shall be conditioned upon such Holder's participation in such underwriting and the
inclusion of such Holder's Registrable Securities in the underwriting to the extent provided
herein. All Holders proposing to distribute their Registrable Securities through such
underwriting shall enter into an underwriting agreement in customary form with the managing
underwriters selected for such underwriting. Notwithstanding any other provision of this
Agreement, if the managing underwriters advise the Company in writing that marketing factors
require a limitation of the number of securities to be underwritten, then the managing
underwriters may exclude shares (including Registrable Securities) from the registration and the
underwriting, and the number of shares that may be included in the registration and the
underwriting shall be allocated, first, to the Company, and second, to each of the Holders
requesting inclusion of their Registrable Securities in such registration statement on a pro rata
basis based on the total number of Registrable Securities then held by each such Holder;
provided, however, that no such reduction shall reduce the amount of securities of the selling
Holders included in the registration below 20% of the total amount of securities included in such
registration, unless such offering is the initial public offering, in which event all Registrable
Securities may be excluded. In no event will shares of any other selling shareholder be included
in such registration which would reduce the number of shares that may be included by selling
Holders without the written consent of not less than a ninety percent (90%) majority in interest of
4
WES71240047083.5
the selling Holders. If any Holder disapproves of the terms of any such underwriting, such
Holder may elect to withdraw therefrom by written notice to the Company and the managing
underwriters. Any Registrable Securities excluded or withdrawn from such underwriting shall
be excluded and withdrawn from the registration. For any Holder that is a partnership, limited
liability company or corporation, the partners or members, retired partners or members or
shareholders of such Holder, the estates and immediate family members of any of the foregoing
persons and any trusts for the benefit of any of the foregoing persons shall be deemed to be a
single Holder, and any pro rata reduction with respect to such Holder shall be based upon the
aggregate amount of shares carrying registration rights owned by all entities and individuals
included in such Holder.
2.3 Form S-3 Registration. In case the Company shall receive from any Holder or
Holders of at least 25% of the Registrable Securities then outstanding a written request or
requests that the Company effect a registration on Form S-3 or a successor form and any related
qualification or compliance with respect to all or a part of the Registrable Securities owned by
such Holder or Holders, then the Company shall:

(a) promptly give written notice of the proposed registration and the Holder's
or Holders' request therefor, and any related qualification or compliance, to all other Holders of
Registrable Securities; and

(b) as soon as practicable, use commercially reasonable efforts to effect such
registration as would permit or facilitate the sale and distribution of all or such portion of such
Holder's or Holders' Registrable Securities as are specified in such request, together with all or
such portion of the Registrable Securities of any other Holders joining in such request as are
specified in a request given ►o the Company within fifteen (15) days after the S-3 Notice is
given; provided, however, that the Company shall not be obligated to effect any such registration
pursuant to this Section 2.3:

(i) if Form S-3 is not then available for such offering by the Holders;
(ii) if the Holders, together with the holders of any other securities of
the Company entitled to and requesting inclusion in such registration, propose to sell Registrable
Securities and such other securities (if any) at an aggregate price to the public of less than
$2,000,000;
(iii) if the Company furnishes to the Holders requesting registration
pursuant to this Section 2.3 a certificate signed by the President or Chief Executive Officer of the
Company stating that, in the good-faith judgment of the Board of Directors of the Company, it
would be materially detrimental to the Company and its shareholders for such registration to be
effected at such time, in which event the Company shall have the right to defer the filing of the
Form S-3 registration statement for a period of not more than 90 days following receipt of the
request of the Initiating Holders under this Section 2.3; provided, however, that the Company
shall not invoke this right more than once in any twelve (12) month period;
5 WES11240047033.5

(iv) if the Company has, within the twelve (12) month period preceding
the date of such request, already effected one registration on Form S-3 for the Holders pursuant
to this Section 2.3; or

(v) during the period ending one hundred eighty (180) days after the
effective date of a registration effected under Section 2.2 hereof.

(c) Registrations effected pursuant to this Section 2.3 shall not be counted as
demands for registration effected pursuant to Section 2.1.

(d) If the registration is for an underwritten offering, the provisions of Section
2.1(b) hereof shall apply to such registration.
2.4 Obligations or the Company. Whenever required under this Section 2 to effect
the registration of any Registrable Securities, the Company shall, as expeditiously as reasonably
possible:

(a) prepare and file with the SEC a registration statement with respect to such
Registrable Securities and use commercially reasonable efforts to cause such registration
statement to become effective, and, upon the request of the Holders of a majority of the
Registrable Securities registered thereunder, keep such registration statement effective for up to
one hundred twenty (120) days.

(b) prepare and file with the SEC such amendments and supplements to such
registration statement and the prospectus used in connection with such registration statement as
may be necessary to comply with the provisions of the Securities Act with respect to the
disposition of all securities covered by such registration statement;

(c) furnish to the selling Holders such number of copies of a prospectus,
including a preliminary prospectus, in conformity with the requirements of the Securities Act,
and such other documents as they may reasonably request in order to facilitate the disposition of
the Registrable Securities owned by them that are covered by such registration statement;

(d) use commercially reasonable efforts to register or qualify the securities
covered by such registration statement under such other securities or blue sky laws of such states
or other jurisdictions as shall be reasonably requested by the selling Holders, provided that the
Company shall not be required in connection therewith or as a condition thereto to qualify to do
business or to file a general consent to service of process in any such states or jurisdictions;

(e) in the event of any underwritten public offering, enter into and perform its
obligations under an underwriting agreement, in usual and customary form, with the managing
underwriters of such offering (it being understood and agreed that, as a condition to the
Company's obligations under this clause (e), each Holder participating in such underwriting shall
also enter into and perform its obligations under such an agreement);
(0 notify each Holder of Registrable Securities covered by such registration
statement at any time when a prospectus relating thereto is required to be delivered under the
Securities Act of the happening of any event as a result of which the prospectus included in such
6 WES11240047053 5
registration statement, as then in effect, includes an untrue statement of a material fact or omits
to state a material fact required to be stated therein or necessary to make the statements therein
not misleading in the light of the circumstances then existing;

(g) use commercially reasonable efforts to cause all such Registrable
Securities registered pursuant hereunder to be listed on a national securities exchange or trading
system and each securities exchange and trading system (if any) on which similar securities
issued by the Company are then listed;

(h) provide a transfer agent and registrar for all Registrable Securities
registered pursuant to such registration statement and a CUSP number for all such Registrable
Securities, in each case not later than the effective date of such registration statement; and
(i) promptly make available for inspection by the selling Holders, any
managing underwriter participating in any disposition pursuant to such registration statement,
and any attorney or accountant or other agent retained by any such underwriter or selected by the
selling Holders, all financial and other records, pertinent corporate documents and properties of
the Company and cause the Company's officers, directors, employees and independent
accountants to supply all information reasonably requested by any such seller, underwriter,
attorney, accountant or agent in connection with any such registration statement.
2.5 Furnish Information. It shall be a condition precedent to the obligations of the
Company to take any action pursuant to Sections 2.1, 2.2 or 2.3 hereof that the selling Holders
shall furnish to the Company such information regarding themselves, the Registrable Securities
held by them and the intended method of disposition of such securities as shall be required to
timely effect the registration of their Registrable Securities.
2.6 Expenses. All expenses (other than underwriting discounts and commissions and
stock transfer taxes and fees) incurred in connection with a registration, including, without
limitation, registration, filing and qualification fees, printers' and accounting fees, fees and
disbursements of counsel for the Company, shall be borne by the Company. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, the Company shall not be required to pay for any expenses of any registration
proceeding begun pursuant to Sections 2.1 if the registration request is subsequently withdrawn
at the request of the Holders of a majority of the Registrable Securities to be registered (in which
case all participating Holders shall bear such expenses on a pro rata basis based on the number of
Registrable Securities that were requested to be included in the withdrawn registration), unless
the Holders of a majority of the Registrable Securities then outstanding agree to forfeit their right
to one demand registration pursuant to Section 2.1; provided, however, that if, at the time of such
withdrawal, the Holders have learned of a material adverse change in the condition, business, or
prospects of the Company from that known to the Holders at the time of their request and have
withdrawn the request with reasonable promptness following disclosure by the Company of such
material adverse change, then the Holders shall not be required to pay any of such expenses and
shall retain their rights pursuant to Section 2.1.
2.7 Delay of Registration. No Holder shall have any right to obtain or seek an
injunction restraining or otherwise delaying any such registration as the result of any controversy
that might arise with respect to the interpretation or implementation of this Section 2.
7
V/ES7\240047083.5
2.8 Indemnification. In the event any Registrable Securities are included in a
registration statement under Sections 2.1, 2.2 or 2.3 hereof:

(a) By the Company. To the extent permitted by law, the Company shall
indemnify and hold harmless each Holder, the partners, members, officers and directors of each
Holder, legal counsel and accountants for each Holder, any underwriter (as defined in the
Securities Act) for such Holder and each person, if any, who controls such Holder or underwriter
within the meaning of the Securities Act or the Exchange Act, against any expenses, losses,
claims, damages or liabilities (joint or several) to which they may become subject under the
Securities Act, the Exchange Act or other federal or state law, insofar as such expenses, losses,
claims, damages or liabilities (or actions in respect thereof) arise out of or are based upon any of
the following statements, omissions or violations (each a "Violation"):

(i) any untrue statement or alleged untrue statement of a material fact
contained in such registration statement, including any preliminary prospectus or final prospectus
contained therein or any amendments or supplements thereto;

(ii) the omission or alleged omission to state therein a material fact
required to be stated therein, or necessary to make the statements therein not misleading; or
(iii) any violation or alleged violation by the Company of the Securities
Act, the Exchange Act, any federal or state securities law or any rule or regulation promulgated
under the Securities Act, the Exchange Act or any federal or state securities law in connection
with the offering covered by such registration statement.
The Company shall reimburse each such Holder, partner, officer or director, underwriter
or controlling person for any legal or other expenses reasonably incurred by them, as incurred, in
connection with investigating or defending any such loss, claim, damage liability or action;
provided, however, that the indemnity agreement contained in this Section 2.8(a) shall not apply
to amounts paid in settlement of any such expense, loss, claim, damage, liability or action if such
settlement is effected without the consent of the Company (which consent shall not be
unreasonably withheld), nor shall the Company be liable in any such case for any such loss,
claim, damage, liability or action to the extent that it arises out of or is based upon actions or
omissions made in reliance upon and in conformity with written information furnished by or on
behalf of any such Holder, partner, officer or director, underwriter or controlling person
expressly for use in connection with such registration by such Holder, partner, officer, director,
underwriter or controlling person.
(b) By Selling Holders. To the extent permitted by law, each selling Holder
shall indemnify and hold harmless the Company, each of its directors, each of its officers who
have signed the registration statement, each person, if any, who controls the Company within the
meaning of the Securities Act, legal counsel and accountants for the Company, any underwriter
and any other Holder selling securities under such registration statement or any of such other
Holder's partners, directors or officers or any person who controls such Holder within the
meaning of the Securities Act or the Exchange Act, against any expenses, losses, claims,
damages or liabilities (joint or several) to which any of the foregoing persons may become
subject under the Securities Act, the Exchange Act or other federal or state law, insofar as such
8 WES11240047083.5
expenses, losses, claims, damages or liabilities (or actions in respect thereto) arise out of or are based upon any 
Violation, in each case to the extent (and
only to the extent) that such Violation arises out of or is based on actions or omissions made in reliance upon and in 
conformity with written information
furnished by such Holder expressly for use in connection with such registration; and each such Holder shall reimburse 
the Company and such other persons for any
legal or other expenses reasonably incurred by them in connection with investigating or defending any such loss, claim, 
damage, liability or action; provided,
however, that the indemnity agreement contained in this Section 2.8(b) shall not apply to amounts paid in settlement of 
any such expense, loss, claim, damage,
liability or action if such settlement is effected without the consent of the Holder, which consent shall not be 
unreasonably withheld; and provided further,
that the total amounts payable in indemnity by a Holder under this Section 2.8(b) in respect of any Violation shall not 
exceed the net proceeds received by such
Holder in the registered offering out of which such Violation arises except in the case of fraud or willful misconduct 
by such Holder.

(c) Notice. Promptly after receipt by an indemnified party under this Section 2.8 of notice of the commencement of any 
action (including any governmental
action) for which a party may be entitled to indemnification hereunder, such indemnified party shall, if a claim in 
respect thereof is to be made against any
indemnifying party under this Section 2.8, deliver to the indemnifying party a written notice of the commencement 
thereof, and the indemnifying party shall have
the right to participate in such action and, to the extent the indemnifying party so desires, jointly with any other 
indemnifying party to which notice has
been given, to assume the defense thereof with counsel mutually satisfactory to the parties;
provided, however, that an indemnified party (together with all other indemnified parties that may be represented 
without conflict by one counsel) shall have
the right to retain its own
counsel, with the fees and expenses to be paid by the indemnifying party, if representation of
such indemnified party by the counsel retained by the indemnifying party would be inappropriate
due to actual or potential differing interests between such indemnified party and any other party
represented by such counsel in such proceeding. The failure to deliver written notice to the indemnifying party within a
reasonable time of the commencement of
any such action, if prejudicial to its ability to defend such action, shall relieve such indemnifying party of any 
liability to the indemnified party under this

Section 2.8, but the omission so to deliver written
notice to the indemnifying party will not relieve it of any liability that it may have to any indemnified party 
otherwise than under this Section 2.8.
(d) Contribution. In order to provide for just and equitable contribution to joint liability under the Securities Act in
any case in which either (i) any party
otherwise entitled
to indemnification hereunder makes a claim for indemnification pursuant to this Section 2.8 but it is judicially 
determined (by the entry of a final judgment or
decree by a court of competent jurisdiction and the expiration of time to appeal or the denial of the last right of 
appeal) that such
indemnification may not be enforced in such case notwithstanding the fact that this Section 2.8 provides for 
indemnification in such case, or (ii) contribution
under the Securities Act may be required on the part of any party hereto for which indemnification is provided under 
this Section 2.8; then, and in each such
case, such parties will contribute to the aggregate expenses,
losses, claims, damages or liabilities to which they may be subject (after contribution from
others) in such proportion as is appropriate to reflect the relative fault of the indemnifying party and the indemnified
party in connection with the Violation
that resulted in such expense, loss,
9 WEST EST 240047083 5
claim, damage or liability as well as other equitable considerations. The relative fault of such
parties shall be determined by reference to, among other things, whether the untrue or allegedly
untrue statement of a material fact or the omission or alleged omission of a material fact relates
to information supplied by the indemnifying party or indemnified party and the parties' relative
intent, knowledge, access to information and opportunity to correct or prevent such statement or
omission; provided, however, that, in any such case, (A) no such Holder will be required to
contribute any amount in excess of the net proceeds from the sale of all such Registrable
Securities offered and sold by such Holder pursuant to such registration statement, and (B) no
individual or entity guilty of fraudulent misrepresentation (within the meaning of Section 11(f)
of the Securities Act) will be entitled to contribution from any individual or entity who was not
guilty of such fraudulent misrepresentation; and provided further, that in no event shall a
Holder's liability pursuant to this Section 2.8(d), when combined with the amounts paid or
payable by such Holder pursuant to Section 2.8(b), exceed the net proceeds from the offering
received by such Holder, except in the case of willful misconduct or fraud by such Holder.

(e) Survival. Unless otherwise superseded by an underwriting agreement
entered into in connection with the offering, the obligations of the Company and Holders under
this Section 2.8 shall survive the completion of any offering of Registrable Securities in a
registration under this Section 2, and otherwise shall survive the termination of this Agreement.
2.9 Rule 144 Reporting. With a view to making available the benefits of certain
rules and regulations of the SEC which may at any time permit the sale of the Registrable
Securities to the public without registration, after such time as a public market exists for the
Common Stock, the Company agrees to:

(a) make and keep public information available, as those terms are understood
and defined in Rule 144 under the Securities Act, at all times after the effective date of the first
registration under the Securities Act filed by the Company for an offering of its securities to the
general public;

(b) use commercially reasonable efforts to file with the SEC in a timely
manner all reports and other documents required of the Company under the Securities Act and
the Exchange Act (at any time after it has become subject to such reporting requirements); and
(c) furnish to any Holder, so long as the Holder owns any Registrable
Securities, forthwith upon request (i) a written statement by the Company as to its compliance
with the reporting requirements of said Rule 144 (at any time after ninety (90) days after the
effective date of the first registration statement filed by the Company for an offering of its
securities to the general public), and of the Securities Act and the Exchange Act (at any time
after it has become subject to the reporting requirements of the Exchange Act), (ii) a copy of the
most recent annual or quarterly report of the Company and (iii) such other reports and documents
of the Company as a Holder may reasonably request in availing itself of any rule or regulation of
the Commission allowing a Holder to sell any such securities without registration (at any time
after the Company has become subject to the reporting requirements of the Exchange Act).
2.10 "Market Stand-Off' Agreement. Each Holder hereby agrees that it will not,
without the prior written consent of the Company or the managing underwriters, as the case may
10 WEST1240047033.5
be, (i) lend, offer, pledge, sell, contract to sell, sell any option or contract to purchase, purchase
any option or contract to sell, grant any option, right, or warrant to purchase, or otherwise
transfer or dispose of, directly or indirectly, any shares of Common Stock or any securities
convertible into or exercisable or exchangeable for Common Stock (whether such shares or any
such securities are then owned by the Holder or are thereafter acquired) or (ii) enter into any
swap or other arrangement that transfers to another, in whole or in part, any of the economic
consequences of ownership of the Common Stock, whether any such transaction described in
clause (i) or (ii) above is to be settled by delivery of Common Stock or other securities, in cash,
or otherwise, for such period of time (not to exceed one hundred eighty (180) days) from the
effective date of such registration as may be requested by the Company or such managing
underwriters and to execute an agreement reflecting the foregoing as may be requested by the
underwriters at the time of the Company's initial public offering; provided. however that, if
during the last 17 days of the restricted period the Company issues an earnings release or
material news or a material event relating to the Company occurs, or prior to the expiration of the
restricted period the Company announces that it will release earnings results during the 16-day
period beginning on the last day of the restricted period, then, upon the request of the managing
underwriters, to the extent required by any FINRA rules, the restrictions imposed by this section
shall continue to apply until the end of the third trading day following the expiration of the 15-
day period beginning on the issuance of the earnings release or the occurrence of the material
news or material event. In no event will the restricted period extend beyond two hundred sixteen

(216) days after the effective date of the registration statement. The underwriters in connection
with the offering are intended third-party beneficiaries of this Section 2.10 and shall have the
right, power, and authority to enforce the provisions hereof as though they were a party hereto.
Each Holder further agrees to execute such agreements as may be reasonably requested by the
managing underwriters in the offering that are consistent with this Section 2.10 or that are
necessary to give further effect thereto.
In order to enforce the foregoing covenant, the Company may impose stop-transfer
instructions with respect to all securities owned by each Holder (and the shares or securities of
every other person subject to the foregoing restriction) until the end of such period.
2.11 Assignment of Registration Rights. The rights to cause the Company to register
Registrable Securities pursuant to this Section 2 may be assigned to a transferee or assignee in
connection with any transfer or assignment of Registrable Securities by the Holder, provided that

(i) such transfer or assignment may otherwise be effected in accordance with applicable
securities laws, (ii) such transferee or assignee acquires at least 1,000,000 shares of Registrable
Securities or, if less, all of the Registrable Securities held by the Holder, (iii) written notice is
promptly given to the Company and (iv) such transferee or assignee agrees to be bound by the
provisions of this Agreement. The foregoing 1,000,000-share limitation shall not apply,
however, to transfers or assignments by a Holder to (a) a partner, member or shareholder of a
Holder that is a partnership, limited liability company or corporation, respectively, (b) a retired
partner or member of such partnership or limited liability company who retires after the date
hereof, (c) the estate of any such partner, member or shareholder (d) an Affiliate of any such
partnership, limited liability company or corporation, or (e) any spouse, parent, child or sibling
of such partner, member or shareholder or of the Holder, including in-laws and persons related
by adoption, or (1) any domestic partner of such partner, member or shareholder or of the Holder
who is covered under an applicable domestic relations statute, provided that all such transferees
11
WEST1240047083.5
or assignees agree in writing to appoint a single representative as their attorney-in-fact for the
purpose of exercising any rights, receiving notices, or taking any action under this Section 2.
2.12 Termination of Registration Rights. The Company's obligations pursuant to
Sections 2.1, 2.2 and 2.3 shall terminate (i) three (3) years after the closing date of the
Company's first firmly underwritten public offering of its Common Stock pursuant to a
Registration Statement filed with, and declared effective by, the SEC under the Securities Act or

(ii) as to any Holder, at such time following such initial public offering, as all Registrable
Securities that such Holder holds or has the right to acquire may immediately be sold in any
three-month period without registration pursuant to Rule 144 under the Securities Act.
2.13 Limitations on Subsequent Registration Rights. From and after the date of this
Agreement, the Company shall not, without the prior written consent of the Holders of a ninety
percent (90%) majority of the Registrable Securities then outstanding, enter into any agreement
with any holder or prospective holder of any securities of the Company that provides such holder
or prospective holder with registration rights with respect to such securities unless (i) such other
registration rights are subordinate to the registration rights granted to the Holders hereunder and
the inclusion of such securities will not reduce the amount of the Registrable Securities of the
Holders that are included in a given registration and (ii) the holders of such rights are subject to
market standoff obligations no more favorable to such persons than those contained herein.
2.I4 Founders' Registration Rights. The Common Holders shall be entitled to
include shares in any registration under Sections 2.1, 2.2 or 2.3 as fully as if they were Holders
and all shares of Common Stock of the Company held by or issuable to them constituted
Registrable Securities, so long as (i) the inclusion of such shares will not diminish the number of
Registrable Securities included by the Holders or the number of securities included by the
Company in such registration, (ii) each of the Common Holders participating in the registration
agrees to be subject to the other provisions of this Section 2 as if he were a Holder.
3. Rights to Purchase Additional Stock.
3.1 Right of First Offer. Subject to the terms of this Section 3 and applicable
securities laws, if the Company proposes to offer or sell any Equity Securities, the Company
shall give each Investor that holds at least 5% of the shares of Registrable Securities (each a
"Major Investor") the right to purchase such Major Investors' pro rata share of such Equity
Securities, on the same terms as the Company is willing to sell such Equity Securities to any
other person. A Major Investor's pro rata share of the Equity Securities shall be equal to that
percentage of the Outstanding Common Equivalents (as defined below) held by such Major
Investor on the date of the company's written notice referred to in Section 3.2 below. For
purposes of this Section 3, the "Outstanding Common Equivalents" shall mean outstanding
shares of Common Stock and all shares of Common Stock issuable, directly or indirectly, upon
exercise or conversion of any outstanding preferred stock, warrants or options or any other right
to acquire any of the foregoing. A Major Investor shall be entitled to apportion this right of first
offer among itself and its Affiliates in such proportions as it deems appropriate.
3.2 Notice; Exercise of Right. Prior to any sale or issuance by the Company of any
Equity Securities, the Company shall give notice to each Major Investor of its intention to sell
12 W657\240047083 5
and issue such Equity Securities, setting forth the terms under which it proposes to make such
sale (the "Offer Notice"). Within twenty (20) days after receipt of the Offer Notice, each Major
Investor shall notify the Company whether such Major Investor desires to purchase its pro rata
share, or any part thereof, of the Equity Securities so offered. If a Major Investor notifies the
Company of its desire to purchase any of the Equity Securities offered by the Company, the
closing of the sale shall occur within sixty (60) days of the date that the Offer Notice is given or,
if later, the closing date for the proposed sale of such Equity Securities to third parties.
3.3 Permitted Sales. With respect to any Equity Securities that are not subscribed
for by Major Investors after the end of the sixty (60) day period specified in Section 3.2, the
Company may, during a period of ninety (90) days following the end of such period, offer and
sell such Equity Securities to other persons upon terms and conditions not less favorable to the
Company than those set forth in the notice to the Investors. In the event the Company has not
entered into a definitive agreement for the sale of the Equity Securities within said 90-day
period, or if such agreement is not consummated within thirty (30) days after the consummation
thereof, the Company shall not thereafter issue or sell any Equity Securities without first offering
such securities to the Major Investors pursuant to this Section 3.
3.4 Exceptions. The right of first offer contained in this Section 3 shall not apply to
issuances by the Company (i) of shares of Common Stock issued or issuable to officers, directors
or employees of, or consultants to, the Company pursuant to any stock option plan or agreement
or other stock incentive program or agreement approved by the Board of Directors (and, if
applicable, any requisite series or class of stock as may be required in the Company's Certificate
of Incorporation), (ii) pursuant to the Company's first firm commitment underwritten public
offering pursuant to an effective registration statement on Form S-1 or Form SB-2 (or a
successor form) under the Securities Act covering the offer and sale of Common Stock at an
offering price of not less than aggregate gross proceeds to the Company (prior to underwriters'
commissions and expenses) of not less than $15,000,000 (a "Qualified Public Offering"), (iii) as
part of an acquisition by the Company of all or substantially all of the assets or shares of another
company or entity through a merger, exchange, reorganization or the like that is approved by the
Board of Directors (and, if applicable, any requisite series or class of stock as may be required in
the Company's Certificate of Incorporation), (iv) in connection with a joint venture, strategic
investment and/or acquisition of technology or intellectual property that is approved by the
Board of Directors (and, if applicable, any requisite series or class of stock as may be required in
the Company's Certificate of Incorporation), (v) to landlords, equipment lessors, lenders or other
financial institutions in commercial transactions or arrangements approved by the Board of
Directors (and, if applicable, any requisite series or class of stock as may be required in the
Company's Certificate of Incorporation), (vi) directly or indirectly upon conversion or exercise
of shares of convertible securities, options or warrants that are outstanding as of the date of this
Agreement, or (vii) in connection with any stock split, stock dividend, reverse stock split or
similar recapitalization event.
3.5 Termination. The right of first offer contained in this Section 3 shall terminate
and be of no further force and effect immediately prior to the closing of (i) the first sale of stock
of the Company pursuant to a Qualified Public Offering or (ii) a transaction that is deemed to be
a liquidation pursuant to the Company's Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation (a
"Deemed Liquidation Event').
13 WES-1\2400470835

4. Information Rights.
4.1
Investor:
Financial Statements and Reports. The Company shall deliver to each Major

(a) as soon as practicable after the end of each fiscal year of the Company,
and in any event within ninety (90) days thereafter, an unaudited balance sheet as of the end of
such year and unaudited statements of income and of cash flows for such year and a statement of
shareholders' equity as of the end of such year, such year-end financial reports to be in
reasonable detail;

(b) as soon as practicable after the end of the first three quarters of each fiscal
year of the Company, and in any event within forty-five (45) days thereafter, an unaudited
balance sheet as of the end of each such quarterly period and unaudited statements of income and
cash flows for such periods, all in reasonable detail; and
(c) within thirty (30) days prior to the end of each fiscal year, a budget and
business plan for the next fiscal year, prepared on a monthly basis, including balance sheets,
income statements and statements of cash flows for such months, and as soon as prepared, any
other budgets or revised budgets prepared by the Company.
Notwithstanding any provision to the contrary, the Company shall not be obligated pursuant to
this Section 4.1 to provide any information (i) that it reasonably considers to be a trade secret or
similar confidential information (unless covered by an enforceable confidentiality agreement, in
form acceptable to the Company) or (ii) to any Investor that the Company reasonably determines
to be a competitor or an officer, employee, director or greater-than-10% shareholder of a
competitor. Each Investor agrees to hold in confidence and trust and not to misuse or disclose
any confidential information provided pursuant to this Section 4.1.
4.2 Inspection Rights. The Company shall permit each Major Investor, at such
Major Investor's expense, to visit and inspect the Company's properties, to examine its books of
account and records and to discuss the Company's affairs, finances and accounts with its
officers, all at such reasonable times as may be requested by the Major Investor; provided,
however, that the Company shall not be obligated pursuant to this Section 4.2 to provide access
to any information (i) that it reasonably considers to be a trade secret or similar confidential
information (unless covered by an enforceable confidentiality agreement, in form acceptable to
the Company), (ii) to any Major Investor that the Company reasonably determines to be a
competitor or an officer, employee, director or greater-than-I0% shareholder of a competitor or
(iii) the disclosure of which would adversely affect the attorney-client privilege between the
Company and its counsel. Each Major Investor agrees to hold in confidence and trust and not to
misuse or disclose any confidential information obtained pursuant to this Section 4.2.
4.3 Confidentiality. Each Investor agrees that such Investor will keep confidential
and will not disclose, divulge or use for any purpose (other than to monitor its investment in the
Company) any confidential information obtained from the Company pursuant to the terms of this
Agreement (including notice of the Company's intention to file a registration statement) unless
such confidential information (a) is known or becomes known to the public in general (other than
14 WES-11240047083.S
as a result of a breach of this Section 4.23 by such Investor), (b) is or has been independently
developed or conceived by the Investor without use of the Company's confidential information,
or (c) is or has been made known or disclosed to the Investor by a third party without a breach of
any obligation of confidentiality such third party may have to the Company; provided, however,
that an Investor may disclose confidential information (i) to its attorneys, accountants,
consultants, and other professionals to the extent necessary to obtain their services in connection
with monitoring its investment in the Company, (ii) to any prospective purchaser of any
Registrable Securities from such Investor, if such prospective purchaser agrees to be bound by
the provisions of this Section 4.23, (iii) to any Affiliate, partner, member, stockholder, or wholly
owned subsidiary of such Investor in the ordinary• course of business, provided that such Investor
informs such Person that such information is confidential and directs such Person to maintain the
confidentiality of such information, or (iv) as may otherwise be required by law, provided that
the Investor promptly notifies the Company of such disclosure and takes reasonable steps to
minimize the extent of any such required disclosure.
4.4 Termination. The rights of any Investor set forth in this Section 4 shall terminate
and be of no further force and effect immediately prior to the earlier of (i) the first sale of stock
of the Company pursuant to a Qualified Public Offering, (ii) such time as the Company first
becomes subject to the periodic reporting requirements of Section 12 or 15(d) of the Exchange
Act or (iii) a Deemed Liquidation Event.
5. Miscellaneous.
5.1 Notices. Any notice, request or other communication required or permitted
hereunder shall be in writing and shall be deemed to have been duly given if delivered
personally, by facsimile when receipt is electronically confirmed, one business day after delivery
to a nationally recognized overnight delivery service, or otherwise upon receipt, addressed (i) if
to Investor, at the address set forth below such Investor's name on Exhibit A, and (ii) if to the
Company, at the address set forth below:
AdFin Solutions, Inc.
10 East 53rd Street, 37th Floor
Attn: Jeanne Houweling, CEO
with a copy to:
DLA Piper LLP (US)
2000 University Avenue
East Palo Alto, 94303-2215
Attn: Matt Oshinsky, Esq.
Any party hereto may, by ten (10) days' prior notice so given, change its address for
future notices hereunder.
15
WES112400470833
5.2 Successors and Assigns. Each Investor agrees that it may not assign any of its rights or obligations hereunder 
unless such rights and obligations are
assigned by such Investor to (i) an individual or entity to which Registrable Securities are transferred by such 
Investor pursuant to Section 2.11 and (ii) with
respect to the right of first offer set forth in Section 3, to another Major Investor or an Affiliate of the Investor, 
and, in each case, such assignee shall be
deemed an "Investor" for purposes of this Agreement, provided, however, that such assignment shall be contingent upon 
the assignee providing a written
instrument to the Company notifying the Company of such assignment and agreeing in writing to be bound by the terms of 
this Agreement. Except as otherwise
provided herein, the provisions of this Agreement shall inure to the benefit of, and shall be binding upon, the 
successors and permitted assigns of the parties
hereto.
5.3 Amendments and Waivers. Any provision of this Agreement may be amended and the observance thereof may be waived, 
either generally or in a particular
instance and either retroactively or prospectively, only with the written consent of the Company and the holders of a 
ninety percent (90%) majority of the
Registrable Securities; provided, however, that this Agreement may not be amended and the observance of any term hereof 
may not be waived with respect to any
Investor without the written consent of such Investor unless such amendment or waiver applies to all Investors in the 
same fashion (it being agreed that a
waiver of the provisions of Section 3 with respect to a particular transaction shall be deemed to apply to all Investors
in the same fashion if such waiver does
so by its terms, notwithstanding the fact that certain Investors may nonetheless, by agreement with the Company, 
purchase securities in such transaction), and
provided further, that if an amendment or waiver adversely affects the Common Holders in a manner that is different from
its effect on the Investors, then such
amendment or waiver shall require the written consent of the holders of a majority of the shares of Common Stock held by
the Common Holders. The Company shall
give prompt notice of any amendment hereof or waiver hereunder to any party hereto that did not consent in writing to 
such amendment or waiver. Any amendment or
waiver effected in accordance with this Section 5.3 shall be binding upon each Investor, the Common Holder, each 
permitted successor or assignee of such
Investor or Common Holder and the Company.
5.4 Entire Agreement. This Agreement, together with all the exhibits hereto, constitutes and contains the entire 
agreement and understanding of the parties with
respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes any and all prior negotiations, correspondence, agreements,
understandings, duties or obligations between the parties with respect to the subject matter
hereof.
5.5 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed exclusively in accordance with the internal laws of
the State of New York as applied to
agreements among New York residents entered into and to be performed entirely within New York.
5.6 Severability. If any provision of this Agreement is held to be unenforceable
under applicable law, then such provision shall be excluded from this Agreement and the balance of this Agreement shall 
be interpreted as if such provision were
so excluded and shall be enforceable in accordance with its terms.
16 WEST1/4140047083.5
5.7 Delays or Omissions. No delay or omission to exercise any right, power or remedy accruing to any party under 
Agreement upon any breach or default of any
other party under this Agreement shall impair any such right, power or remedy of the nonbreaching or nondefaulting 
party, nor shall it be construed to be a
waiver of any such breach or default, or an acquiescence therein, or waiver of or acquiescence in any similar breach or 
default theretofore or thereafter
occurring, nor shall any waiver of any single breach or default be deemed a waiver of any other breach or default 
therefore or thereafter occurring. All
remedies, either under this Agreement or by law or otherwise afforded to any Holder, shall be cumulative and not 
alternative.
5.8 Captions. The captions to sections of this Agreement have been inserted for identification and reference purposes 
only and shall not be used to construe or
interpret this Agreement.
5.9 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original, but all of 
which together shall constitute one and
the same instrument.
5.10 Costs and Attorneys' Fees. In the event that any action, suit or other proceeding is instituted concerning or 
arising out of this Agreement or any
transaction contemplated hereunder, the prevailing party shall recover all of such party's costs and attorneys' fees 
incurred in each such action, suit or other
proceeding, including any and all appeals or petitions therefrom.
5.11 Adjustments for Recapitalization Events. Wherever in this Agreement there is a reference to a specific number of 
shares of Common Stock or Preferred Stock
of the Company or a specific dollar amount per share, then, upon the occurrence of any stock split, stock dividend, 
reverse stock split or similar
recapitalization event affecting such shares, the specific number of shares or dollar amount so referenced in this 
Agreement shall automatically be
proportionally adjusted to reflect the effect on the outstanding shares of such class or series of stock of such 
recapitalization event.
5.12 Aggregation of Stock. All shares held or acquired by Affiliates shall be aggregated together for the purpose of 
determining the availability of any rights
under this Agreement.
5.13 Additional Investors. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained
herein, if the Company issues additional shares of the Series A Stock after the date hereof pursuant to the Series A 
Agreement, any purchaser of such shares of
Series A Stock may become a party to this Agreement by executing and delivering a counterpart signature page to this 
Agreement, and thereafter shall be deemed
an "Investor" and "Holder" for all purposes hereunder, without the need for any consent, approval or signature of any 
Investor.
Remainder of This Page Intentionally Left Blankl
17 WES71240047083.5
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement as of the date
and year first above written.
Company:
AdFin Solutions, Inc.
By:
JEanne Houweling
President & Chief Executive Officer
Common Holder:
Jonathan Leitersdorf
[SIGNATURE PAGE TO INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT)
I
II
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Agreement as of the date and year first above written.
Company:
AdFin Solutions, Inc.
Br
Jeanne Houweling
President & Chief Executive Officer
Common Holder:
JonStfian. ersdo
[SIGNATURE PAGE TO INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT)
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
David J. Mitchell
Name:
Jonathan Leitersdorf
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
Investor: Investor:
Name:  Name:
David J. Mitchell
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO ADEN SOLUTIONS, INC.
INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
Investor:
Name:
David J. Mitchell
wEsT240047693.6
Investor:
Name:
Jonathan Leitersdorf
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
Investor: Investor:
Name:  Name:
David J. Mitchell Jonathan Leitersdorf
Investor: Investor:
Name:  Name:
Richard Kirshenbaum
WEST-7400470Di
Tom Glo
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
PREFERRED HOLDER:.
SOUTHERN TRUST CO ANT:NE.
By:
Name: Jeffrey
Title: President
WES-112407/0165.7
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
Investor:
CVAFI I I I
By:
Name: Howard W. Lutnick
Title: President
bi'snJilfic. Pardo $Ssvicrtiv sev,k( A Freg.rv4 Sioct Tnves+hie,..,4
ftJ SolOYns,
Exhibit A
Investors
Name and Address Investor Series A Preferred Stock
David J Mitchell 685,714
Jonathan Leitersdorf 3,428,571
WEST240047010.5
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL AND CO -SALE AGREEMENT
December 28, 2012
This Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement (this "Agreemen►") is made as of the
date first set forth above, by and among AdFin Solutions, Inc., a Delaware corporation (the
"Company"), Jonathan Leitersdorf (the "Common Holder"), and the purchasers listed on the
Schedule of Purchasers to that certain Series A Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement (the
"Purchase Agreement") who are purchasing more than six hundred thousand (600,0000) shares
of Series A Preferred Stock pursuant to the Purchase Agreement (the "Major Investors").
RECITALS

A. The Common Holder owns shares of the Company's common stock (the
"Common Stock"), as set forth on the Schedule of Common Holders and Major Investors
attached as Exhibit A hereto (the "Schedule of Common Holders and Major Investors").

B. In order to induce the Investors to purchase shares of Series A Preferred Stock
pursuant to the Purchase Agreement, the Company and the Common Holder desire to enter into
this Agreement with the Major Investors.
AGREEMENT
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual promises herein contained, and
other consideration, the receipt and adequacy of which hereby is acknowledged, the parties
hereto agree as follows:

I. Certain Definitions. For purposes of this Agreement, the following terms have
the following meanings:

(a) "Initiating Major Investor" means a Major Investor proposing to Transfer
some or all of his/her/its shares of Series A Preferred Stock.

(b) "IPO" means the first underwritten sale of Company securities to the
public pursuant to a registration statement under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the
"Securities Act").

(c) "Major Investor's Co-Sale Share" means, as to the Right of Co-Sale (as
defined below) with respect to any Major Investor, an amount determined by multiplying (i) the
number of Shares of Offered Stock (as defined below) not purchased by the Company or the
Non-Initiating Major Investors pursuant to Section 3 and remaining available for Transfer by the
Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor by (ii) the ratio determined by dividing (A) the
number of shares of Stock (as defined below) held by the Non-Initiating Major Investor
exercising this right of co-sale by (B) the aggregate number of shares of Stock held by all Major
Investors plus the number of shares of Stock held by the Common Holder or Initiating Major
Investor selling such Offered Stock.
WEST240047063 6

(d) "Non-Initiating Major Investor" means a Major Investor who is not an
Initiating Major Investor.
(e) "Offered Stock" means all Stock held by a Common Holder or an
Initiating Major Investor proposed to be the subject of a Transfer as defined in Section 1(Q)).

(I) "ROFR Share" means, as to the Right of First Refusal (as defined below)
with respect to any Non-Initiating Major Investor, an amount determined by multiplying (i) the
number of Shares of Offered Stock (as defined below) by (ii) the ratio determined by dividing

(A) the number of shares of Stock (as defined below) held by such Non-Initiating Major Investor
by (B) the aggregate number of shares of Stock held by all Major Investors.

(g) "Right of Co-Sale" means the right of co-sale provided to each non-
Initiating Major Investor in Section 4 of this Agreement.

(h) "Right of First Refusal" means the right of first refusal provided to the
Company and each Non-Initiating Major Investor in Section 3 of this Agreement.

(i) "Stock" means all shares of Common Stock and all shares of Series A
Preferred Stock issued and outstanding at the relevant time plus (i) all shares of Common Stock
that may be issued upon exercise or conversion of any options, warrants, convertible securities
and other rights of any kind then outstanding, and (ii) all shares of Common Stock that may be
issued upon conversion of any convertible securities issuable upon exercise of options, warrants
or other rights then outstanding.

(j) "Transfer" means any sale, assignment, encumbrance, hypothecation,
pledge, conveyance in trust, gift, transfer by bequest, devise or descent, or other transfer or
disposition of any kind, including but not limited to transfers to receivers, levying creditors,
trustees or receivers in bankruptcy proceedings or general assignees for the benefit of creditors,
whether voluntary or by operation of law, directly or indirectly, except:

(i) any bona fide pledge if the pledgee executes a counterpart copy of
this Agreement and becomes bound thereby in the same manner as a Common Holder or Major
Investor;

(ii) any transfers of Stock by a Common Holder or a Major Investor:
(A) to a Common Holder's or Major Investor's spouse, lineal descendant or antecedent, father,
mother, brother, sister, adopted child or adopted grandchild; (B) to the spouse of a Common
Holder's or Major Investor's child, adopted child, grandchild or adopted grandchild; (C) to a
trust or trusts for the exclusive benefit of a Common Holder or Major Investor, or a Common
Holder's or Major Investor's family members as described in this Section l(0))((ii)); or (D) by
devise or descent, in all cases if the transferee or other recipient executes a counterpart copy of
this Agreement and becomes bound thereby in the same manner as the Common Holder or Major
Investor;
(iii) any transfer of Stock by a Common Holder or Major Investor
made: (A) pursuant to a merger or consolidation of the Company with or into another
WEST1240047063 6 2
corporation or corporations; (B) pursuant to the winding up and dissolution of the Company;

(C) at, and pursuant to, the IPO; or (D) to each Major Investor pursuant to this Agreement; or
(iv) any bona fide gift to not-for-profit organizations.

2. Notice of Proposed Transfer. Before any Common Holder or Initiating Major
Investor effects any Transfer of any Offered Stock, such Common Holder or Initiating Major
Investor must submit at the same time to the Company and the Non-Initiating Major Investors a
written notice signed by the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor ("Stockholder's
Notice") stating (a) the Common Holder's or Initiating Major Investor's bona fide intention to
transfer such Offered Stock; (b) the number of shares of Offered Stock; (c) the name, address
and relationship, if any, to the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor of each proposed
purchaser or other transferee; and (d) the bona fide cash price or, in reasonable detail, other
consideration, per share for which the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor proposes to
transfer such Offered Stock (the "Offered Price"). Upon the request of the Company or an
Initiating Major Investor, the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor who wishes to effect
a Transfer will promptly furnish such information to the Company and to the Non-Initiating
Major Investors as may be reasonably requested to establish that the offer and proposed
transferee are bona fide.

3. Right of First Refusal.
(a) The Company and Major Investors' Right. With respect to any
Transfer by the Common Holder, or any Transfer by an Initiating Major Investor, the Company
and the Non-Initiating Major Investors shall have a Right of First Refusal to purchase all or any
part of the Offered Stock, exercisable as set forth in subsections (b) and (c) hereof, except that
each Common Holder and each Major Investor shall be permitted to Transfer, and the Right of
First Refusal shall not apply to the Transfer or Transfers of, in the aggregate over the term of this
Agreement, up to five percent (5%) of the Common Holder's Stock or Major Investor's Stock, as
calculated using the Common Stock and Series A Preferred Stock amounts set forth on the
Schedule of Common Holders and Major Investors.

(b) Exercise of the Company's Right of First Refusal. The Company's
Right of First Refusal may be exercised as follows:

(i) Upon receipt of a Stockholder's Notice, the Company shall have
the irrevocable and exclusive right to purchase all or any portion of the Offered Stock.

(ii) If the Company desires to purchase all or any part of the Offered
Stock, the Company must, within the twenty (20) day period (the "Company Refusal Period")
commencing on the date of delivery of the Stockholder's Notice (the "Offer Date"), give written
notice to the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor of the Company's election to purchase
all or any portion of the Offered Stock. If the Company does not elect during the Company
Refusal Period to purchase all of the Offered Stock, the remaining shares of Offered Stock may
be purchased by the Non-Initiating Major Investors as set forth in Section 3(c) below.
(iii) Within ten (10) days after expiration of the Company Refusal
Period, the Company shall give written notice (the "Company's Expiration Notice") to the
WEST \2r0047063.6 3
Common Holder and to the Major Investors stating whether (A) the Company has exercised its
Right of First Refusal with respect to all of the Offered Stock or (B) the Company's Right of
First Refusal has lapsed or been waived as to any portion of the Offered Stock (specifying the
number of shares as to which the Right of First Refusal has lapsed or been waived).
Notwithstanding any failure by the Company to deliver a Company's Expiration Notice, to the
extent that the Company does not exercise its Right of First Refusal during the Company Refusal
Period, it shall be deemed to have waived such right; however, a failure to deliver a Company's
Expiration Notice shall not affect the Non-Initiating Major Investors' Right of First Refusal as
set forth in Section 3(c) below.

(c) Exercise of Major Investors' Right of First Refusal. The Major
Investors' Right of First Refusal may be exercised as follows:

(i) To the extent the Company does not exercise its right to purchase
all of the Offered Stock, each Non-Initiating Major Investor shall have the opportunity to
purchase up to such Major Investor's ROFR Share of the remaining Offered Stock.

(ii) If a Non-Initiating Major Investor or its assignees desires to
purchase any remaining Offered Stock, such Non-Initiating Major Investor must, within a twenty

(20) day period commencing on the earlier of (A) the date of the Company's Expiration Notice
or (B) the thirtieth (30th) day after the Offer Date, give written notice to the Common Holder or
the Initiating Major Investor and to the Company of such Non-Initiating Major Investor's
election to purchase all or a portion of such Major Investor's ROFR Share of the remaining
Offered Stock. To the extent that a Non-Initiating Major Investor does not elect to exercise its
Right of First Refusal during this period, the Non-Initiating Major Investor shall be deemed to
have waived such right.

(d) Purchase Price. The purchase price for the Offered Stock to be
purchased by the Company or a Non-Initiating Major Investor exercising its Right of First
Refusal under this Agreement will be the Offered Price, but will be payable as set forth in

Section 3(e) hereof. If the Offered Price includes consideration other than cash, the cash
equivalent value of the non-cash consideration will be determined by the Board of Directors of
the Company in good faith, which determination will be binding upon the Company, the Major
Investors and the Common Holder absent fraud or error.

(e) Payment. Payment of the purchase price for the Offered Stock purchased
by the Company or by a Non-Initiating Major Investor exercising its Right of First Refusal shall
be made prior to the sixtieth (60th) day following the Offer Date. Payment of the purchase price
will be made by the Company or the Non-Initiating Major Investors (i) by check or by wire
transfer of immediately available funds, (ii) by cancellation of all or a portion of any outstanding
indebtedness of the Common Holder or an Initiating Major Investor to the Company or a Non-
Initiating Major Investor, as applicable, or (iii) by any combination of the foregoing.

(I) Rights as a Shareholder. To the extent that the Company or a Non-
Initiating Major Investor exercises its Right of First Refusal to purchase the Offered Stock, then,
upon consummation of such purchase, the Common Holder or the Initiating Major Investor will
have no further rights as a holder of the Offered Stock except the right to receive payment for the
WEST240047063 6 4
Offered Stock from the Company or the Non-Initiating Major Investors in accordance with the
terms of this Agreement, and the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor will forthwith
cause all certificate(s) evidencing such Offered Stock to be surrendered to the Company for
transfer to the Company or to the Non-Initiating Major Investors.

(g) Common Holder's Right to Transfer. If the Rights of First Refusal of
the Company and the Non-Initiating Major Investors have lapsed or been waived as to any
portion of the Offered Stock, then, subject to the Right of Co-Sale set forth in Section 4 below,
the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor may transfer that portion of the Offered Stock
to any person named as a purchaser or other transferee in the Stockholder's Notice, at the
Offered Price or at a higher price, provided that such transfer (i) is consummated within ninety

(90) days following the Offer Date and (ii) is in accordance with all the terms of this Agreement.
If the Offered Stock is not so transferred during such 90 day period, then the Common Holder or
Initiating Major Investor may not transfer any of such Offered Stock without complying again in
full with the provisions of this Agreement.

4. Right of Co-Sale.
(a) Right of Co-Sale. If the Company and the Major Investors do not
exercise their rights to purchase all of the Offered Stock pursuant to Section 3 above, the
Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor shall deliver to the Company and each (other)
Major Investor a written notice (the "Co-Sale Notice") setting forth the number of shares of
Offered Stock that are not being purchased by the Company or the Non-Initiating Major
Investors. Any Major Investor that has not exercised its Major Investor's Right of First Refusal
shall have a right to participate in the Transfer of such remaining Offered Stock on the same
terms and conditions as the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor by selling up to the
Non-Initiating Major Investor's Co-Sale Share of the remaining Offered Stock specified in the
Co-Sale Notice. To exercise this right, the Non-Initiating Major Investor must, within ten (10)
days following the date when the Co-Sale Notice is given, give written notice to the Common
Holder or Initiating Major Investor, with a copy to the Company, setting forth the number of
shares and type of Stock that the Non-Initiating Major Investor elects to sell under the Right of
Co-Sale. To the extent one or more of the Non-Initiating Major Investors exercise such Right of
Co-Sale, the number of shares of Offered Stock that the Common Holder or Initiating Major
Investor may sell in the transaction shall be correspondingly reduced.

(b) Consummation of Co-Sale. A Non-Initiating Major Investor shall
consummate the exercise of the Right of Co-Sale by delivering to the Common Holder or the
Initiating Major Investor at the closing of the Transfer of Offered Stock to such transferee (the
"Closing") one or more certificates, properly endorsed for transfer, representing the stock to be
transferred by such Non-Initiating Major Investor. At the Closing, such certificates will be
transferred and delivered to the transferee set forth in the Stockholder's Notice in consummation
of the Transfer of the Offered Stock pursuant to the terms and conditions specified in the
Stockholder's Notice, and the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor will remit, or will
cause to be remitted, to such Non-Initiating Major Investor within three (3) business days after
the Closing that portion of the proceeds of the Transfer to which such Non-Initiating Major
Investor is entitled by reason of such Major Investor's participation in such Transfer pursuant to
the Right of Co-Sale.
WEST240047063 6 5

5. Multiple Series, Class or Type of Stock. If the Offered Stock consists of more
than one series or class or type of Stock, the Company and the Non-Initiating Major Investors
shall have the right to purchase or transfer hereunder, as the case may be, each such series, class
or type; provided, however, that if, as to the Right of Co-Sale, a Non-Initiating Major Investor
does not hold any of such series, class, or type, and the proposed transferee is not willing, at the
Closing, to purchase a different series, class or type of Stock from such Non-Initiating Major
Investor, or is unwilling to purchase any Stock from such Non-Initiating Major Investor, then
such Major Investor will have the put right (the "Put Right") set forth in Section 6(b) hereof.

6. Refusal to Transfer; Put Right.
(a) Refusal to Transfer. Any attempt by a Common Holder or Initiating
Major Investor to transfer any Stock in violation of any provision of this Agreement will be void.
The Company will not be required to (i) transfer on its books any Stock that has been sold,
gifted or otherwise transferred in violation of this Agreement, or (ii) treat as owner of such
Stock, or accord the right to vote or pay dividends to any purchaser, donee or other transferee to
whom such Stock may have been so transferred.
(b) Put Right. If a Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor transfers any
Stock in contravention of a Major Investors' Right of Co-Sale under this Agreement (a
"Prohibited Transfer"), or if the proposed transferee of Offered Stock desires to purchase only
the class, series or type of stock offered by a Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor, or is
unwilling to purchase any Stock from a Non-Initiating Major Investor and the provisions of

Section 5 hereof apply, such Non-Initiating Major Investor may, by delivery of written notice to
the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor (a "Put Notice") within ten (10) days after the
later of (i) the Closing as defined in Subsection 4(b) above, or (ii) the date on which the Non-
Initiating Major Investor becomes aware of the Prohibited Transfer or the terms thereof, require
the Common Holder or the Initiating Major Investor to purchase from such Non-Initiating Major
Investor for cash or such other consideration as the Common Holder or Initiating Major Investor
received in the Prohibited Transfer or at the Closing up to a number of shares of Stock (of the
same class, series or type as were transferred in the Prohibited Transfer or at the Closing if such
Non-Initiating Major Investor then owns Stock of such class, series or type; otherwise of
Common Stock) equal to the Non-Initiating Major Investor's Co-Sale Share, at a purchase price
equal to the aggregate purchase price such Non-Initiating Major Investor would have received in
the closing of such Prohibited Transfer if the Non-Initiating Major Investor had exercised its
Right of Co-Sale with respect thereto or in the Closing if the proposed transferee had been
willing to purchase the Stock offered by the Non-Initiating Major Investor. The closing of such
sale to the Common Holder or the Initiating Major Investor will occur within seven (7) days after
the date when the Put Notice is given.
WEST1240047063.6 6

7. Restrictive Legend; Stop-Transfer Orders.
(a) Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Legend. The Common Holders and
Major Investors understand and agree that the Company will cause the legend set forth below, or
a legend substantially equivalent thereto, to be placed upon any certificate(s) or other documents
or instruments evidencing ownership of Stock by the Common Holders and Major Investors:
THE SHARES REPRESENTED BY THIS CERTIFICATE ARE SUBJECT TO
CERTAIN RIGHTS OF FIRST REFUSAL AND RIGHTS OF CO-SALE AS SET
FORTH IN A RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL AND CO-SALE AGREEMENT
ENTERED INTO BY THE HOLDER OF THESE SHARES, THE COMPANY AND
CERTAIN SHAREHOLDERS OF THE COMPANY. A COPY OF SUCH
AGREEMENT IS ON FILE AT THE PRINCIPAL OFFICE OF THE COMPANY.
SUCH RIGHTS OF FIRST REFUSAL AND RIGHTS OF CO-SALE ARE BINDING
ON CERTAIN TRANSFEREES OF THESE SHARES.

(b) Stop Transfer Instructions. The Common Holders and Major Investors
agree, to ensure compliance with the restrictions referred to herein, that the Company may issue
appropriate "stop transfer" certificates or instructions and that, if the Company transfers its own
securities, it may make appropriate notations to the same effect in its records.

8. Termination and Waiver.
(a) Termination. The Right of First Refusal and Right of Co-Sale will
terminate upon the earliest to occur of (i) the closing of the IPO or (ii) the consummation of a
transaction that is deemed to be a liquidation pursuant to the Company's Certificate of
Incorporation.

(b) Waiver. The application of the Right of First Refusal and Right of Co-
Sale as to any proposed Transfer by any Common Holder or Major Investor of any Stock may be
waived (either generally or in a particular instance and either retroactively or prospectively) only
by the written agreement of the Company and Major Investors who beneficially own at least a
ninety percent (90%) majority of the Common Stock issuable or issued upon conversion of the
Series A Preferred Stock issued to all Major Investors; provided, however, that such rights may
not be waived with respect to any Investor without the written consent of such Investor unless
such amendment or waiver applies to all Investors in the same fashion. The Company and the
Major Investors will have the absolute right to exercise or refrain from exercising any right or
rights that such party may have by reason of this Agreement, including, without limitation, the
right to purchase or participate in the sale of Offered Stock, and neither the Company nor the
Major Investors will incur any liability to any other party hereto with respect to exercising or
refraining from exercising any such right or rights. Any waiver by a party of its rights hereunder
will be effective only if evidenced by a written instrument executed by such party or its
authorized representative.
WEST1240047063.6 7

9. Miscellaneous.
(a) Notices, Etc. Any notice, request or other communication required or
permitted hereunder shall be in writing and shall be deemed to have been duly given if delivered
personally, by facsimile when receipt is electronically confirmed, one business day after delivery
to a nationally recognized overnight delivery service, or otherwise upon receipt, addressed (i) if
to an Investor, at the address set forth below such Investor's name on the Schedule of Purchasers
to the Purchase Agreement, (ii) if to a Common Holder or Major Investor, at the address set forth
in the Schedule of Common Holders and Major Investors hereto, and (iii) if to the Company, at
the address set forth below:
AdFin Solutions, Inc.
10 East 53rd Street, 37th Floor
New York, NY 10022
Attn: Jeanne Houweling, CEO
with a copy to:
DLA Piper LLP (US)
2000 University Avenue
East Palo Alto, 94303-2215
Fax:
Attn: Matt Oshinsky, Esq.
Any party hereto may, by ten (10) days' prior notice so given, change its address for
future notices hereunder.

(b) Binding on Successors and Assigns; Inclusion Within Certain
Definitions. This Agreement, and the rights and obligations of the parties hereunder, will inure
to the benefit of, and be binding upon, their respective successors, assigns, heirs, executors,
administrators and legal representatives. Any permitted transferee of the Common Holders who
is required to become a party hereto will be considered a "Common Holder" for purposes of this
Agreement and any permitted transferee of Stock held by a Major Investor will be considered a
"Major Investor" for purposes of this Agreement.

(c) Severability. If any provision of this Agreement is held to be invalid,
illegal or unenforceable in any respect, such provision will be enforced to the maximum extent
possible and such invalidity, illegality or unenforceability will not affect any other provision of
this Agreement, and this Agreement will be construed as if such invalid, illegal or unenforceable
provision had (to the extent not enforceable) never been contained herein.

(d) Amendment. This Agreement may be amended only by a written
instrument executed by the Company, Major Investors who beneficially own at least a ninety
percent (90%) majority of the shares of Common Stock issuable or issued upon conversion of the
Series A Preferred Stock issued to all Major Investors, and Common Holders who beneficially
own at least a majority of the shares of Common Stock owned by all Common Holders.
WE.S1 EST 240047063.6 8

(e) Governing Law. This Agreement will be governed by and construed in
accordance with the laws of the State of New York as such laws are applied to agreements
between New York residents entered into and to be performed entirely within New York without
regard to conflict of law principles.
(0 Obligation of Company; Binding Nature of Exercise. The Company
agrees to use its best efforts to enforce the terms of this Agreement, to inform the Common
Holders and the Major Investors of any breach hereof (to the extent the Company has knowledge
thereof) and to use reasonable efforts to assist the Common Holders and the Major Investors in
the exercise of their rights and the performance of their obligations hereunder. Any exercise of
the Right of First Refusal or Right of Co-Sale will be binding upon the party so exercising, and
may not be withdrawn without the written consent of the Common Holders or Initiating Major
Investor, except that such exercise may be withdrawn unilaterally by the exercising party if there
is any legal prohibition as to a party's consummation of its purchase or sale hereunder.

(g) Aggregation of Stock. For the purposes of determining the availability of
any rights under this Agreement, the holdings of any transferee and assignee of an individual or a
partnership who is a spouse, ancestor, lineal descendant or sibling of such individual or partners
or retired partners of such partnership or affiliates of such partnership (including spouses and
ancestors, lineal descendants and siblings of such partners or spouses who acquire Stock by gift,
will or intestate succession) shall be aggregated together with the individual or partnership, as
the case may be, for the purpose of exercising any rights or taking any action under this
Agreement.

(h) Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in any number of
counterparts, each of which when so executed and delivered will be deemed an original, and all
such counterparts together will constitute one and the same instrument.

(i) Entire Agreement. This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement of
the parties with respect to the specific subject matter hereof and supersedes in their entirety all
other agreements or understandings between or among the parties hereto with respect to such
specific subject matter.

(j) Additional Investors. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary
contained herein, if the Company issues additional shares of the Series A Stock after the date
hereof pursuant to the Series A Agreement, any purchaser of such shares of Series A Stock may
become a party to this Agreement by executing and delivering a counterpart signature page to
this Agreement, and thereafter shall be deemed an "Investor" and "Holder" for all purposes
hereunder, without the need for any consent, approval or signature of any Investor.
WEST 40047063.6 9
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Right of First Refusal
and Co-Sale Agreement as of the date first written above.
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
By:  4A-a-  /tows" - 7 Jeanne Houweling
Chief Executive Officer
COMMON HOLDER:
Jonathan Lcitcrsdorf
10
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Right of First Refusal
and Co-Sale Agreement as of the date first written above.
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
By.
Jeanne Houweling
Chief Executive Officer
COMMON HOLDER:
Jona firuiLcitersdorf
10 WEST \ 240047063_5
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL AND CO-SALE AGREEMENT
INVESTOR:
David J. Mitchell
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL AND CO-SALE AGREEMENT
INVESTOR:
Jonathan citers orf
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL AND CO-SALE AGREEMENT
WESTVA0047063.7
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL AND CO-SALE AGREEMENT
V/TITIVOCNRI 63.7
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, each of the parties hereto has executed this Right of First
Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement as of the date first set forth above.
PREFERRED HOLDER:
S UTHE,LT ST COMPANX, NC-
/
By:  (
Name: Jeffrey Epste --'
Title: President
WESTt2407703611.2
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
RIGHT OF REFUSAL AND CO-SALE AGREEMENT
INVESTOR:
CVAFLI I I
By:
Name: I Iowa
Title: President
. Lutnick
ES(514?tkeft ?oie. +0 535-0,0130 SeivieS prefovveci S+volf- Thveshnt"i -
itelVfn 5,01/4eiVonS ThO
EXHIBIT A
SCHEDULE OF COMMON HOLDERS AND MAJOR INVESTORS
Name Shares Held
Jonathan Leitersdorf 8,000,000 Common Stock
3,714,285 Series A Preferred Stock
David J. Mitchell 1,428,571 Series A Preferred Stock
Richard Kirshenbaum 114,285 Series A Preferred Stock
Tom Glocer 228,571 Series A Preferred Stock
Southern Trust Company, Inc. 1,428,571 Series A Preferred Stock
CVAFH I LLC 800,000 Series A Preferred Stock
Dani Ilani 169,508 Series A Preferred Stock
Gil Mandelzis 57,142 Series A Preferred Stock
WEST 240047063.10
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
VOTING AGREEMENT
This Voting Agreement ("Agreement") is made and entered into as of December 28,
2012 by and among AdFin Solutions, Inc., a Delaware corporation (the "Company"), each of
those persons and entities, severally and not jointly, whose names are set forth on the Schedule
of Investors attached hereto as Exhibit A (individually, an "Investor," and collectively, together
with any subsequent purchasers or transferees who become parties hereto as an Investor pursuant
to Sections 5.1 or 5.2, the "Investors"), and Jonathan Leitersdorf and Jeanne I4ouweling (the
"Key Holders," or collectively, together with any subsequent purchasers or transferees who
become parties hereto as a Key Holder pursuant to Sections 5.1 or 5.2, the "Key Holders," and,
together with the Investors, the "Stockholders").
RECITALS

A. The Company and the Investors are parties to a Series A Preferred Stock Purchase
Agreement of even date herewith (the "Series A Agreement').

B. In order to induce the Investors to enter into the Series A Agreement and invest
funds in the Company pursuant thereto, the Company and the Key Holders desire to enter into
this Agreement with the Investors.

C. The Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation of the Company (the
"Restated Certificate") provides that (i) the holders of Series A Preferred Stock, voting as a
separate class, shall be entitled to elect one director (the "Series A Director"), (ii) the holders of
Common Stock, voting as a separate class, shall be entitled to elect three directors (the
"Common Directors"), and (iii) the holders of Preferred Stock and Common Stock, voting
together as a single class on an as-converted basis, shall be entitled to elect the remaining
directors of the Company ("At-Large Directors").
Therefore, the parties agree as follows:

I. Shares Subject to this Agreement. The Key Holders each agree to hold all
shares of voting capital stock of the Company registered in their respective names or beneficially
owned by them as of the date of this Agreement and any other shares of voting capital stock of
the Company legally or beneficially held or acquired by them after the date hereof (the "Key
Holder Shares") subject to, and to vote the Key Holder Shares in accordance with, the
provisions of this Agreement. The Investors each agree to hold all shares of voting capital stock
of the Company listed in Exhibit A (the "Investor Shares" or, collectively with the Key Holder
Shares, the "Stockholder Shares") subject to, and to vote the Investor Shares in accordance with,
the provisions of this Agreement.
WESTV40082405.10

2. Board of Directors.
2.1 Size of Board. Each of the Stockholders shall vote all of their
Stockholder Shares, and shall take all other necessary actions within their control (whether in
their capacity as a stockholder, director, or officer of the Company or otherwise), including,
without limitation, calling meetings, attending meetings, executing a proxy to vote at any
meeting and executing written consents, in order to ensure that the size of the Board of Directors
(the "Board") shall be set at five (5) directors.
2.2 Board Composition. Each of the Stockholders shall vote all of their
Stockholder Shares, and shall take all other necessary actions within their control (whether in
their capacity as a stockholder, director, or officer of the Company or otherwise), including,
without limitation, calling meetings, attending meetings, executing a proxy to vote at any
meeting and executing written consents, to cause the election to the Board of:

(a) One person designated by David J. Mitchell to serve as the Series
A Director, who shall initially be David J. Mitchell, for so long as such Stockholder and its
Affiliates (as defined below) continue to own beneficially any shares of Series A Preferred
Stock;

(b) Three persons designated by the holders of a majority of the
outstanding shares of Common Stock to serve as the Common Directors who shall initially be
Jonathan Leitersdorf, Gil Mandelzis and Roy Lowrance; and

(c) One person designated by the holders of a majority of the
outstanding shares of Preferred Stock and Common Stock, voting together as a class on an as-
converted basis, to serve as an At-Large Director, who initially shall be Jeanne Houweling.
For purposes of this Agreement, an individual or entity shall be deemed an "Affiliate" of another
individual or entity that, directly or indirectly, controls, is controlled by or is under common
control with such individual or entity, including, without limitation, any general partner,
managing member, officer or director of such entity or any venture capital fund now or hereafter
existing that is controlled by one or more general partners or managing members of, or shares the
same management company with, such entity.
2.3 Removal.

(a) Upon the request of any Investor that is entitled to designate a
director pursuant to Section 2.2, each of the Stockholders shall vote all of their Stockholder
Shares in favor of the removal of the director designated by that Investor. Absent such a request
by an Investor, the Stockholders agree not to vote their Stockholder Shares in favor of the
removal of the director designated by such Investor.
2.4 Vacancies. If any representative designated as provided in Section 2.2
above for any reason ceases to serve as a member of the Board during his or her term of office,
the parties to this Agreement shall cause the resulting vacancy to be filled by a representative
designated as provided above by the respective person or persons entitled to designate such
representative.
2 WEST1240082405.6
2.5 Expenses Incurred by Non-Employee Directors. The Company shall
reimburse all non-employee directors for their actual and reasonable out-of-pocket expenses
incurred in attending meetings of the Board and all committees of the Board and otherwise
incurred in fulfilling their duties as directors.
2.6 Indemnification Agreements. At the date of the closing of the
transactions contemplated by the Series A Agreement and on each later date that a director is
first elected or appointed to the Board, the Company shall enter into its standard form
indemnification agreement with each director of the Company who is elected or appointed to the
Board on such date.

3. Vote to Increase Authorized Common Stock. Each Stockholder agrees to vote
or cause to be voted all Stockholder Shares beneficially owned by such Stockholder in whatever
manner as shall be necessary to increase the number of authorized shares of Common Stock from
time to time to ensure that there will be sufficient shares of Common Stock available for
conversion of all of the shares of Series A Preferred Stock outstanding at any given time.

4. Drag-Along Right. In the event that the Board of Directors and the holders of a
majority of the Key Holder Shares and also the requisite majority of the Series A Preferred Stock
pursuant to Article IV Section 6 of the Certificate of Incorporation (collectively, the "Requisite
Parties"), approve a transaction that is deemed to be a Liquidation Event pursuant to the
Restated Certificate, as amended from time to time (each, a "Sale of the Company"), each of the
Stockholders agrees:

(a) to consent to, vote for and raise no objections to the Sale of the
Company;
(b) if the Sale of the Company is structured as a merger, consolidation
or asset sale, to waive any dissenters rights, appraisal rights or similar rights in connection with
such transaction;

(c) if the Sale of the Company is structured as a Stock Sale, to sell
such Stockholder's Stockholder Shares on the terms and conditions approved by the Requisite
Parties, provided that such terms do not provide that the Stockholder would receive less than the
amount that would be distributed to such Stockholder in the event the proceeds of the Sale of the
Company were distributed in accordance with the Company's Certificate of Incorporation then in
effect; and

(d) to take all necessary and desirable actions approved by the
Requisite Parties in connection with the consummation of the Sale of the Company, including
the execution of such agreements and such instruments and other actions reasonably necessary to
provide the representations, warranties, indemnities, covenants, conditions, non-compete
agreements, escrow agreements and other provisions and agreements relating to the Sale of the
Company;
provided that the liability for indemnification, if any, of each Stockholder in such Sale of the
Company is several and not joint (except to the extent that funds may be paid out of an escrow
established to cover breaches of representations, warranties and covenants of the Company as
WEST240082405.6
3
well as breach by any stockholder of any of identical representations, warranties and covenants
provided by all stockholders), is pro rata based on the consideration payable to each Stockholder
in the Sale of the Company, and will not exceed the consideration payable to such Stockholder in
the Sale of the Company, except, in each case, in the case of liability for fraud or willful
misconduct by such Stockholder.
5. Miscellaneous.
5.1 Application of Agreement to Additional Shares. If, after the date of this
Agreement, any shares or other securities are issued in respect of or in exchange for any of the
Stockholder Shares as a result of any stock splits, stock dividends, recapitalizations,
combinations, or similar transactions, such shares or securities shall be deemed to be Stockholder
Shares for the purposes of this Agreement. If the Company issues additional shares of Series A
Preferred Stock pursuant to the Series A Agreement, as a condition to the issuance of such shares
the Company shall require that any purchaser of such shares become a party to this Agreement
by executing and delivering a counterpart signature page hereto agreeing to be bound by and
subject to the terms of this Agreement as an Investor hereunder and each such person shall
thereafter be deemed an Investor for all purposes hereunder.
5.2 Transfer of Shares. This Agreement shall be binding upon the
successors in interest to any of the Stockholder Shares. The Company shall not register the
transfer of any Stockholder Shares or issue a new certificate representing any Stockholder Shares
unless and until the transferee shall have executed a counterpart signature page to this
Agreement, pursuant to which such person becomes a party to this Agreement and agrees to be
bound by all the provisions of this Agreement as and to the same extent as if he, she or it were an
original stockholder. Any transfer of shares in contravention of the foregoing shall be void ab
initio.
5.3 Legends on Stock Certificates. The certificates representing Stockholder
Shares shall bear the following legend (the "Legend"), together with any other legends required
by separate agreement and applicable law:
THE SHARES REPRESENTED BY THIS CERTIFICATE ARE SUBJECT TO
THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF A VOTING AGREEMENT WHICH
PLACES CERTAIN RESTRICTIONS ON THE VOTING OF THE SHARES
REPRESENTED HEREBY. ANY PERSON ACCEPTING ANY INTEREST IN
SUCH SHARES SHALL BE DEEMED TO AGREE TO AND SHALL
BECOME BOUND BY ALL THE PROVISIONS OF SUCH AGREEMENT. A
COPY OF SUCH VOTING AGREEMENT WILL BE FURNISHED TO THE
RECORD HOLDER OF THIS CERTIFICATE WITHOUT CHARGE UPON
WRITTEN REQUEST TO THE COMPANY AT ITS PRINCIPAL PLACE OF
BUSINESS.
The Company agrees that, during the term of this Agreement, it will maintain (upon registration
of transfer, reissuance, or otherwise), the Legend on any such certificate and will place or cause
to be placed the Legend on any new certificate issued to represent Stockholder Shares. The
failure of the Company to cause the certificates evidencing the Stockholder Shares to bear the
4 WEM21008240$ .6
Legend or the failure of the Company to supply, free of charge, a copy of this Agreement as
provided hereunder shall not affect the validity or enforcement of this Agreement.
5.4 Stockholder Representations. Each Stockholder represents and warrants
that (a) such Stockholder owns its Stockholder Shares free and clear of liens and encumbrances
and has not, prior to or on the date of this Agreement, executed or delivered any proxy or entered
into any other voting agreement or similar arrangement with respect to such shares and (b) such
Stockholder has full power and capacity to execute, deliver, and perform this Agreement, which
has been duly executed and delivered by, and evidences the valid and binding obligation of, such
Stockholder, enforceable in accordance with its terms.
5.5 Irrevocable Proxy. To insure the performance of each Stockholder with
the provisions set forth in this Agreement, each Stockholder hereby appoints the Secretary of the
Company or his designee, as his, her, or its true and lawful proxy and attorney-in-fact, with full
power of substitution and resubstitution, to vote all Stockholder Shares owned or held by such
Stockholder, subject to the provisions of this Agreement, upon any matter presented to the
stockholders of the Company, if (and only it) such Stockholder fails to comply with the
provisions of this Agreement. The proxies and powers granted by each Stockholder pursuant to
the preceding sentence are coupled with an interest and are given to secure the performance of
such Stockholder's commitments under this Agreement. Such proxies shall be irrevocable for
the term of this Agreement and shall survive the death, incompetency, disability, dissolution or
winding up of such Stockholder. Except as provided above, no Stockholder shall grant a proxy
with respect to, transfer any voting control over, or create any right to vote any shares of capital
stock of the Company without the prior written consent of the Company.
5.6 Specific Enforcement. It is agreed and understood that monetary
damages would not adequately compensate an injured Stockholder for the breach of this
Agreement by any party to this Agreement, that this Agreement shall be specifically enforceable,
and that any breach or threatened breach of this Agreement shall be the proper subject of a
temporary or permanent injunction or restraining order. Further, each of the Company and the
Stockholders waives any claim or defense that there is an adequate remedy at law for such
breach or threatened breach.
5.7 Remedies Cumulative. All remedies, either under this Agreement, by
law, or otherwise afforded to any party, shall be cumulative and not alternative.
5.8 Termination. This Agreement shall terminate and be of no further force
or effect upon the earliest to occur of (a) the date of the closing of a firmly underwritten public
offering of the Common Stock pursuant to a registration statement filed with the Securities and
Exchange Commission, and declared effective under the Securities Act, which results in the
outstanding Preferred Stock of the Company being converted into Common Stock, or (b) the
closing of a transaction that is deemed to be a liquidation pursuant to the Restated Certificate.
5.9 Successors and Assigns. Except as otherwise expressly provided herein,
the provisions hereof shall inure to the benefit of, and be binding upon the parties hereto and
their respective successors, assigns, heirs, executors and administrators and shall inure to the
benefit of and be enforceable by each person who shall be a holder of the Stockholder Shares
WEST V40082405.6
5
from time to time; provided, however, that prior to the receipt by the Company of adequate
written notice of the transfer of any Stockholder Shares specifying the full name and address of
the transferee, the Company may deem and treat the person listed as the holder of such
Stockholder Shares in its records as the absolute owner and holder of such Stockholder Shares
for all purposes.
5.10 Third Parties. Nothing in this Agreement, express or implied, is intended
to confer upon any person, other than the parties to this Agreement and their respective
successors and assigns, any rights, remedies, obligations, or liabilities under or by reason of this
Agreement except as expressly provided in this Agreement.
5.11 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed
under the laws of the State of Delaware in all respects as such laws arc applied to agreements
among Delaware residents entered into and performed entirely within Delaware. The parties
agree that any action brought by either party under or in relation to this Agreement, including,
without limitation to interpret or enforce any provision of this Agreement, shall be brought in,
and each party agrees to and does hereby submit to the jurisdiction and venue of, any state or
federal court located in the County of New York, New York.
5.12 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in any number of
counterparts, each of which shall be enforceable against the parties actually executing such
counterparts, and all of which together shall constitute one instrument.
5.13 Headings, Titles and Subtitles; References. The titles and subtitles used
in this Agreement are for convenience only and are not to be considered in construing or
interpreting this Agreement. All references in this Agreement to sections, paragraphs, exhibits
and schedules shall, unless otherwise provided, refer to sections and paragraphs hereof and
exhibits and schedules attached hereto, all of which exhibits and schedules are incorporated
herein by this reference.
5.14 Notices, Etc. Any notice, request or other communication required or
permitted hereunder shall be in writing and shall be deemed to have been duly given if delivered
personally, by facsimile when receipt is electronically confirmed, one business day after delivery
to a nationally recognized overnight delivery service, or otherwise upon receipt, addressed (i) if
to an Investor, at the address set forth below such Investor's name on Exhibit A, (ii) if to a Key
Holder, at the address set forth below such Key Holder's name on Exhibit B, and (iii) if to the
Company, at the following address:
AdFin Solutions, Inc.
10 East 53rd Street, 37th Floor
New York. NY 10022
Attn: Jeanne Houweling, CEO
WEST? 40082405.6
6
with a copy to:
DLA Piper LLP (US)
2000 University Avenue
East Palo Alto, 94303-2215
Attn: Matt Oshinsky, Esq.
Any party hereto may, by ten (10) days' prior notice so given, change its address for
future notices hereunder.
5.15 Costs and Attorneys' Fees. Notwithstanding any other provision herein,
if any action at law or in equity is instituted under or in relation to this Agreement, including
without limitation to enforce any provision in this Agreement, the prevailing party in such
dispute shall be entitled to recover from the losing party all fees, costs and expenses of enforcing
any right of such prevailing party under or with respect to this Agreement, including without
limitation, such reasonable fees and expenses of attorneys and accountants, which shall include,
without limitation, all fees, costs and expenses of appeals.
5.16 Severability. If one or more provisions of this Agreement are held to be
invalid, illegal, or unenforceable under applicable law, then such provision(s) shall be excluded
from this Agreement and the balance of the Agreement shall be interpreted as if such
provision(s) had never been contained herein.
5.17 Entire Agreement; Amendment; Waiver. This Agreement, together
with all the exhibits hereto, constitutes and contains the entire agreement and understanding of
the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes any and all prior negotiations,
correspondence, agreements, understandings, duties or obligations between the parties with
respect to the subject matter hereof. Any term of this Agreement may be amended and the
observance of any term of this Agreement may be waived (either generally or in a particular
instance and either retroactively or prospectively) only with the written consent of (i) the
Company, (ii) the holders of a ninety percent (90%) majority of the Investor Shares, and (iii) the
holders of a majority of the Key Holder Shares; provided, however, that any amendment or
waiver of this Agreement shall also require the written consent of any party that is adversely
affected by such amendment or waiver to a materially greater degree than the other parties
hereto.
5.18 Delays or Omissions. No delay or omission to exercise any right, power
or remedy accruing to any party, upon any breach, default or noncompliance by another party
under this Agreement shall impair any such right, power or remedy, nor shall it be construed to
be a waiver of any such breach, default or noncompliance, or any acquiescence therein, or of or
in any similar breach, default or noncompliance thereafter occurring.
5.19 Further Assurances. From and after the date of this Agreement, upon the
reasonable request of any Stockholder or the Company, the Company and the Stockholders shall
7 WEST2400$2405.6
execute and deliver such instruments, documents, or other writings as may be reasonably
necessary or desirable to confirm and early out and to effectuate fully the intent and purposes of
this Agreement.
5.20 Adjustments for Recapitalization Events. Wherever in this Agreement
there is a reference to a specific number of shares of Common Stock or Preferred Stock of the
Company or a specific dollar amount per share, then, upon the occurrence of any stock split,
stock dividend, reverse stock split or similar recapitalization event affecting such shares, the
specific number of shares or dollar amount so referenced in this Agreement shall automatically
be proportionally adjusted to reflect the effect on the outstanding shares of such class or series of
stock of such recapitalization event.
5.21 Aggregation of Stock. All Stockholder Shares held or acquired by a
Stockholder and its Affiliates shall be aggregated together for the purpose of determining the
availability of any rights of such Stockholder under this Agreement. For purposes of the
foregoing, the shares held by any Stockholder that (a) is a partnership or corporation shall be
deemed to include shares held by affiliated partnerships or the partners, retired partners, and
stockholders of such holder or affiliated partnership, or any spouse, father, mother, brother,
sister, lineal descendant of spouse, or lineal descendant (the "Immediate Family") of any such
partners, retired partners, and stockholders, and any custodian or trustee for the benefit of any of
the foregoing persons and (b) is an individual shall be deemed to include shares held by any
members of the Stockholder's Immediate Family or to any custodian or trustee for the benefit of
any of the foregoing persons.
5.22 No Heightened Duties. Each party hereby acknowledges and agrees that
no fiduciary duty, duty of care, duty of loyalty or other heightened duty shall be created or
imposed upon any party to any other party, the Company or other stockholder of the Company,
by reason of this Agreement and/or any right or obligation hereunder. None of the Stockholders
and no officer, director, stockholder, partner, employee or agent of any Stockholder makes any
representation or warranty as to the fitness or competence of the nominee of any party hereunder
to serve on the Board by virtue of such party's execution of this Agreement or by the act of such
party in voting for such nominee pursuant to this Agreement.
!Signature Page Follows]
WE 11240082405.6
8
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Voting Agreement as of
the date and year first above written.
Company:
ALVIN SOLUTIONS, NC.
S -J anne Houweling
President & Chicf Executive Officer
Key Holders:
Jonathan Lcitcrsdorf
Qnat-ernes cil t , ‘44-,--9---/-.rf •
ne Houweling
9
EN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this Voting Agreement as of
the date and year first above written.
Company:
ADEN SOLUTIONS, INC.
Jeanne Houweling
Chief Executive Officer
Key Holders:
JonatIE -citeg::Iorf
Jeanne Houweling
9
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
VOTING AGREEMENT
Individual Investor: Individual Investor:
David J. Mitchell Jonathan Leitersdoe
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
VOTING AGREEMENT
Individual Investor: Individual Investor:
Cr" David J. Mitchell Jonathaeciteit
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
VOTING AGREEMENT
Individual Investor:
David J. Mitchell
Indi I Investor:
Richar 4 rshenbaum
WEST1/42400814 05.7
Individual Investor:
Jonathan Leitersdorf
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO ADPIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
VOTING AGREEMENT
Individual Investor. Individual Investor:
David J. Mitchell
Individual Investor.
Jonathan Leitersdorf
Richard KIrshenbatun Tom Glocer
WESTt240063405,1
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
VOTING AGREEMENT
Investor:
CVAFI I I LLC
By:
Name: Howatkl W. Lutnick
Title: President
EstrI pme pie 40 fi rb,000 Seivies A 4rt-ferfeA S4ock, Ins4Siwts4+
in Adfrp, So kv+I'atls,
COUNTERPART SIGNATURE PAGE TO
VOTING AGREEMENT
INVESTOR:
souTHonitikrompANy;
By:
Nesne: Jeffrey Epsteid.---
Title: President
WM2407702262
Exhibit A
SCHEDULE OF INVESTORS
Name Number of Shares Held
David J. Mitchell
Jonathan Leitersdorf
Richard Kirshanbaum
Tom Glocer
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
CVAFH I LLC
Dani Mani
Gil Mandelzis
1,428,571
3,714,285
114,285
228,571
1,428,571
800,000
169,508
57,142
VVETA2400VAOill
Exhibit B
SCHEDULE OF KEY HOLDERS
Name and Address Number of Shares Held
Jonathan Leitersdorf 8,000,000
Jeanne Houweling 800,000•
• Stock options as of the date of this
Agreement.
Y/ESTV.40082405 6
SCHEDULE OF EXCEPTIONS
In connection with that certain Series A Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement, dated as of
December 28, 2012 (the "Agreement"),  by and among AdFin Solutions, Inc. (the "Company")
and each of the Purchasers named therein, the Company hereby delivers this Schedule of
Exceptions to the Company's representations and warranties given in the Agreement. This
Schedule of Exceptions and the information and disclosures contained herein are intended only
to qualify and limit the representations, warranties and covenants of the Company contained in
the Agreement, and shall not be deemed to expand in any way the scope or effect of any of such
representations, warranties or covenants. The section numbers in this Schedule of Exceptions
correspond to the section numbers in the Agreement; provided,  however that any information
disclosed herein under any section number shall be deemed to be disclosed and incorporated in
any other section of the Agreement where such disclosure would be appropriate and reasonably
apparent. Where the terms of a contract, agreement or other disclosure item have been
summarized or described in this Schedule of Exceptions, such summary or description does not
purport to be a complete statement of the material terms of such contract, agreement or other
disclosure item and such summary or description is qualified in its entirety by such contract,
agreement or other disclosure item. A disclosure or statement in this Schedule of Exceptions
shall not be construed as indicating that such matter is material, has or could have a material
adverse effect on the Company or is necessarily required to be disclosed by the Company. No
disclosure in this Schedule of Exceptions relating to any possible or alleged breach or alleged
violation of any agreement, law or regulation shall be construed as an admission or indication
that any such alleged breach or alleged violation exists or has actually occurred or that a basis for
any defense to such allegation or claim does not exist or that any basis for any counter-claim or
cross-complaint against the claimant does not exist. Capitalized terms used but not defined
herein shall have the same meanings given them in the Agreement.
WEST,6240I 66418.2
Schedule 3.1
Organization and Standing
The Company has requested a certificate of good standing from the Secretary of State of the state
of New York where it is qualified to do business. Due to excessive orders during the holiday
season, the office of the New York Secretary of State has notified us that the certificate of good
standing will be issued within to 10-15 business days from the date hereof. The Company will
provide the certificate of good standing for the state of New York upon receipt. In the event that
the Company is not in good standing in the state of New York, the Company will use
commercially reasonable efforts to get back into good standing in the state of New York.
WEST,6240I66418.2
Schedule 3.3
Capitalization
Ari Paparo signed an option agreement for an option to purchase 25,000 shares of Common
Stock on December 17, 2012. The Company is currently processing the paperwork and will
update the capitalization table and options ledger accordingly.
The Company will grant David J. Mitchell an option to purchase 246,964 shares of Common
Stock following the Initial Closing.
The Company will gross up Jeanne's Houweling's options and grant her an additional option to
purchase 246,964 shares of Common Stock following the Initial Closing pursuant to the
Houweling Employment Agreement (defined below).
WEST 1240I 66418.2
Schedule 3.11
Intellectual Property
The Company uses open-source components in its software code. The Company believes that
the license will not restrict the Company's abilities to use the Company's software commercially,
although the Company has not conducted an open-source audit on its software code.
WEST,6240I 66418.2
Schedule 3.12
Employees
Jeanne Houweling was recently hired as President and Chief Executive Officer of the Company
and is in the process of signing a form of Assignment of Inventions, Non-Disclosure and Non-
Compete Agreement.
WEST,6240I 66418.2
Schedule 3.15
Material Contracts and Obligations
Executive Employment Agreement, by and between the Company and Jeanne Houweling, dated
November 9, 2012, effective November 5, 2012 (the "Houweling Employment Agreement").
The Company enters into offer letters with its employees in the ordinary course of business.
The Company has received loans totaling approximately $1,500,000 from Jonathan Leitersdorf, a
director and sole stockholder of the Company.
WES1\240I66418.2
Cantor Ventures, L.P.
110 East 59th Street
New York, NY 10022
July 2013
AdFin Solutions, Inc.
10 East 53rd Street
37th Floor
New York, NY 10022
Ladies and Gentlemen:
Reference is made to the Series A Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement, dated as of
December 28, 2012, by and among AdFin Solutions, Inc. (the "Company")  and the Purchasers,
as amended by the Amendment dated as of April 10, 2013 and the Second Amendment dated as
of the date hereof (the "SPA"). Capitalized terms used but not otherwise defined herein shall
have the meanings ascribed to them in the SPA. In connection with the closing of the investment
in the Company by CVAFH I LLC ("Cantor") on the date hereof, the Company and Cantor
hereby agree as follows:

1. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in Sections 4.2 and 4.12 of the SPA,
Cantor has been formed for the specific purpose of acquiring the Shares and the ultimate
holding company of Cantor is Cantor Fitzgerald, L.P., a Delaware limited partnership.
The Company acknowledges and agrees that Cantor is not, and will not be, in breach of
Sections 4.2 and 4.12 of the SPA and waives any right it may have to sue for any such
alleged breach.

2. Except as expressly set forth herein, the SPA remains in full force and effect in
accordance with its terms. All references in the SPA to the SPA shall be deemed to be
references to the SPA after giving effect to this letter agreement. To the extent any
provision of the SPA is inconsistent with this letter agreement, this letter agreement shall
control.

3. This letter agreement and all controversies arising hereunder or relating hereto will be
governed by, and construed and enforced in accordance with, the laws of the State of
New York, without giving effect to conflicts of laws principles thereof. Any suit brought
by any party relating to this letter agreement shall be brought in the state or federal courts
in the Borough of Manhattan in The City of New York.

4. This letter agreement may be executed in any number of counterparts, in each case
including by facsimile or portable document format (pdf), each of which when so
executed and delivered shall be taken to be an original; but such counterparts shall
together constitute but one and the same document.

5. For the purposes of this letter agreement and all agreements executed pursuant hereto, no
course of dealing between or among any of the parties hereto and no delay on the part of
64509 v2
any party hereto in exercising any rights hereunder or thereunder shall operate as a
waiver of the rights hereof and thereof. No provision hereof may be waived otherwise
than by a written instrument signed by the party or parties so waiving such covenant or
other provision. No amendment to this letter agreement may be made without the written
consent of the Company and Cantor.

6. This letter agreement and all its provisions shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit
of the parties and their respective permitted successors and assigns. Nothing in this letter
agreement, whether expressed or implied, will confer on any Person, other than the
parties hereto or their respective permitted successors and assigns, any rights, remedies or
liabilities. No party may assign its rights or obligations under this Agreement without the
prior written consent of the other parties hereto and any purported assignment without
such consent shall be void; provided, however, Cantor may, without the consent of the
Company, assign any or all of its rights or obligations hereunder to any of its Affiliates or
to any successor in interest.
[Signature Page to Follow]
64509 v2
2
The foregoing is acknowledged and agreed as of the date first written above.
CVAFH I I
By:
Accepted and Agreed:
AdFin Solutions, Inc.
By: tAte. eitezceor-S.,
ame: tine Houweidy Title: eco
Name: tiCrwsili •Lv+hiti-
Title: Fee( ;den t-
(Signature Page to the letter agreement dated as of July 2013 by and between AdFin Solutions, Inc. and CVAFH
LLC]
Estro t 000 Sedvits IV Trek yr esj gook. Verhsittiti
64509 v2
ADFIN SOLUTIONS, INC.
COMPLIANCE CERTIFICATE
July 2013
The undersigned, Jeanne Houweling, the duly elected and acting Chief Executive Officer of
AdFin Solutions, Inc., a Delaware corporation (the "Company") does hereby certify as follows:

1. The undersigned is familiar with the terms and conditions of the Series A Preferred
Stock Purchase Agreement, dated December 28, 2012 (the "Agreement'), as amended, by and
among the Company and the investors listed on Exhibit A thereto (the "Purchasers"), and is familiar
with the terms and conditions of the various documents mentioned and described in the Agreement.
Capitalized terms used herein and not otherwise defined herein shall have the meanings ascribed to
them in the Agreement.

2. The representations and warranties made by the Company in Section 3 of the
Agreement, as modified by the Schedule of Exceptions, as amended and restated in the form
attached hereto as Exhibit A (the "Updated Schedule of Exceptions"), are true and correct in all
material respects on and as of the date of this Compliance Certificate with the same effect as though
such representations and warranties had been made on and as of the date of this Compliance
Certificate (except for those representations and warranties which address matters as of a particular
date, which shall have been true and correct in material respects as of such particular date).

3. The Company has performed and complied in all material respects with all
agreements, obligations and conditions contained in the Agreement that are required to be
performed or complied with by it on or before the date of this Compliance Certificate and has
obtained all approvals, consents and qualifications necessary to complete the purchase and sale
described herein.
In witness whereof, the undersigned has signed this Compliance Certificate as of the date
first set forth above.
came Houweling, President & CEO
WEST1241529628.2 1
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                                                                 George Church [harvard] geneticist 
                                                                                   Seth Lloyd [academia] professor of mechanical engineering at MIT 
   Karyna Shuliak aka Korina [russian girl] girlfriend to whom Epstein tried to leave $50 million and the island, alleged sham marriage to Jennifer 
                                                                                                                                    Kalin [lemonde] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00301520 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(date: 2013-01-26)
Harvard Jan. 26 & 27, 2013
Sat. Jan. 26, 2012-NY to Bedford, MA
11:30am Wheels up to Cambridge from Teterboro, Atlantic Aviation, Jet Suite
Reservation #51206
12:11pm ETA at Bedford, ME (BED) Signature Flight Support
Tristar Worldwide Car Service, Sedan requested
Charles Hotel-Confirm #2000252
One Bedroom Boston Suite, Fan has been requested
One Bennett Street
Cambrid e MA 02138
Martin Nowak's Institute
1 Brattle S uare, Suite 6
1:00 Appt w/Mike Hopkins (Martin organized)
1:30 Appt w/Seth Lloyd (1 p)() (CONFIRMED)
3:00 Appt w/Jack Szostak (Martin organized) CONFIRMED
3:30 Appt w/Marvin Minsky & Gloria Rudish (Marvin cell: )(Gloria
cell: j (CONFIRMED)
5:00 Appt w/Henry Rosovsky cell. He
hopes you have a drink for him! (CONFIRMED)
6:00 Appt w/Martin Nowak (CONFIRMED)
6:00 Appt w/Andy Knoll (Martin organized) CONFIRMED
Sun. Jan. 27, 2012 -Bedford, MA to LSJ
10:00am Appt w/George Church
(CONFIRMED)
12:30 Lunch w/Howard Gardner (one on one)
p  (CONFIRMED)
2:00 TENTATIVE Appt w/David Gergen
is at Davos, but back on weekend...DAVID IS REQUESTING A 5pm APPT!
d ) David
5:00 Karyna to depart Boston ...via Delta 5891 Rec. Citicar will
pick her up at 6:26pm Confirm
TBD Depart Bedford Airport for STT
Larry Summers
Larry's Home:
Larry's Cell:
Julie's Cell (Assistant):
Larry Summers home address:
Larry's Assistant is Julie Shample
EFTA00611806 (Jmail)
 [finance] Adam Campbell CEA, LLC High Liquidity Trading Program presentation
(inferred date: 2013-01-29)
Adam Campbell
CEA, LLC
High Liquidity Trading Program
Summary Presentation
January, 2013
WALL-1111ln fl
Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. The performance described herein based upon the 
strategy's performance is for a limited
amount of time and does not reflect performance in different economic cycles. No representation is made that investors 
will experience returns in the future _
that are comparable to those in this document. Please see important notes & disclosures on the last page.
e•-•e's
I
v.. a.7.1.-..a".•
Adam Campbell
CEA, LLC — High Liquidity Trading Program
Introduction
Our trading methodology blends a well conceived systematic approach — using proprietary software
models, lean risk exposure, and continual technological innovation to deliver compelling risk adjusted
returns for investors.
WHAT WE DO - SYSTEMATIC APPROACH:
The strategy is rooted in the technical analysis of markets
We adhere to trading systems utilizing pattern recognition

• All systems have been exhaustively backtested, and subjected to walk-forward analysis — and subsequently have been in 
live
production for over 3 years
Highly disciplined risk management; open position exposures continually monitored with real-time analysis

• All trading algorithms, IP, and all proprietary investment & risk management methodology produced in-house (All IP 
ownership
retained 100%).
OUR OBJECTIVES:
- 1) We seek to consistently outperform the S&P Index within a broad context of market conditions
- 2) Capital preservation is paramount; equity curve smoothness is continually sought
- 3) Since inception we have been characterized by a high Sharpe ratio > 3.00
- 4) Our trading strategies are solely focused on the most highly liquid futures contracts (examples: Crude Oil, S&P's, 
Euro).
- 5) We seek to deliver daily profitability ratios consistently > than 85%, and maintain the highest levels of liquidity
possible for
investors
-404.4.r
A Focus on Consistency
STATISTICALLY-DIRECTED & TECHNOLOGY-DRIVEN

• Non-emotional decision making; trade selection orchestrated via computer systems & proprietary trading algorithms

• Disciplined application of systematic methodology & discretionary overlay; we respond to statistically validated trade
set-ups

• The methodology is capable of (and may occasionally employ) full automation from signal generation thru trade 
execution
MARKET NEUTRAL with respect to macro conditions

• Ability to profit regardless of prevailing market conditions
• Adaptive systematic logic that recognizes & reacts to changing market conditions
ATTENTIVE TO RISK EXPOSURE

• Judgment errors reduced through disciplined application of multiple, well conceived trading systems simultaneously

• Risk management procedures that consider price, position size, volatility, liquidity, and inter-relationships of 
instruments traded

• Trading systems conceived to complement one another; statistical data mining informs our portfolio decisions
SOLID RISK/REWARD
• Annualized targeted range of gross returns: 18% - 24% .
• Live-run Sharpe Ratio: 4.92
• Maximum monthly drawdown in low single digits; max drawdown since inception: -3.61%
$4: 414••••4' ,7;s•
Selected Metrics
3 years of live performance
Metric Result
Sharpe Ratio: 4.92
Average Leverage Usage:
Standard Deviation of Monthly Return:
Win / Loss Ratio Per Position
1.34x
1.68
68.1%
Largest Monthly Drawdown:
Trough-to-Peak Duration/Max-to-Date:
% of Winning Months:
-3.61 %
7 weeks
81%
Daily profitability ratio (methodology goes to all cash position at close > 85%
of each session):
Performance
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec YTD
2012 CEA 3.43 0.09 0.62 0.37 0.88 0.96 0.28 0.13 1.67 -0.73 2.26 0.87 7.71
Live
Production
S&P 4.36 4.06 3.13 -0.75 -6.27 3.96 1.26 1.98 2.42 1.98 0.28 0.71 13.41
2011 CEA 1.41 0.39 0.80 0.28 0.67 0.33 0.48 1.27 1.48 0.89 0.36 6.42 13.82
Live
Production
S&P 2.26 3.20 -0.10 2.85 -1.35 1.83 215 5 68 7 I8 10.77 0.51 0.85 0.00
2010 CEA 1.68 1.95 1.94 1.71 1.06 2.41 3.61 4.22 0.71 0.16 0.03 -0.22 8.85
Live
Production
S&P -3.70 2.85 5.88 1.48 -8.20 .5.39 6.88 4.74 8.76 3.69 0.23 6.53 12.78
2009 CEA 0.43 4.52 -0.85 1.88 0.28 0.69 1.96 0.42 0.21 1.10 1.27 1.40 11.10
Backtest
S&P 8.57 10.99 8.54 9.39 5.31 0.02 7.41 3.36 3.57 98 5.74 1.78 23.45
2008 CEA 1.00 0.71 0.85 0.53 0.19 0.57 0.92 0.65 0.73 4.74 3.54 2.87 18.49
Backtest
S&P 6.12 3.46 0.60 4.75 1.07 8.59 0 99 1.21 9 07 16.94 7.48 0.78 -38.48
2007 CEA -0.39 0.15 1.73 0.29 0.58 0.10 0.44 3.24 0.04 0.51 2.00 0.52 8.67
Backtest
S&P 1.41 2.18 1.00 4.33 3.25 1.78 3 20 1.29 3.58 1.48 3.52
All live returns are audited, and are net of actual fees and expenses of 2120. Go live inception date of 1/2010. Past 
performance is not necessarily indicative
of future
results. No representation is made that investors will experience returns in the future that are comparable to those in 
this document. All returns that reflect
the
backtested period of performance have been subjected to treatment such that they are presented. to the best of our 
ability. a s net of fees and expenses as
would have
been incurred.
Adam Campbell
CEA,LLC
Key Performance Highlights
The trading program has experienced a daily profitability ratio of 85.3% since inception; the program has experienced 
nine (9)
'flawless' months — whereas there are no loss days during entire month — in 25% of live months since inception [11/12, 
5/12,
12/11, 9/11, 8/11, 8/10, 6/10, 5/10, 1/10]
Non-correlation:
In the 2 nd quarter of 2010, our trading program produced 62 of 63 trading days profitable (only one down day in the
quarter) during a -16% peak-to-trough S&P "correction" downturn
During the 3rd and 4'h quarters of 2011, our trading program produced 64 of 65 days profitable (only one down day)
during a -20.6% peak-to-trough S&P "bear market" downturn
The methodology has a demonstrated ability to profit during days of market stress. Since inception, the market has
experienced 60 sessions of DJIA sell-offs (intraday, or by session close) of -200 or more points to the downside; our
program has profitably (95%) traded through 57 of 60 of such sell-off sessions — including a profitable day on the Flash
Crash of May 6, 2010
Since inception, our trading program has notched (8) eight months of 500+ basis point "beats" vs. the S&P 500 [1110,
5/10, 6/10, 8/10, 8/11, 9/11, 12/11, 5/12]. As well, system notched an additional (8) months of 500+ bip outperformances
over 3 year backtest period.
Our approach includes ultra high / daily liquidity. Since inception, our "time-in-market" exposure percentage is 32% (we
maintain 100% cash position during approximately 68% of open market hours)
Out Performing Our Benchmark:
I I- ^ r r. '0 I
$100,000 initial investment, becomes:
CAGR (6 yr. Compound Annual Growth Rate)
$190,898
11.40%
$100,556
0.09%
Adam Campbell
CEA, LLC
Competitive Edge
Our approach is the realization of 15+ years of price pattern recognition — analysis, research & development, 
statistical
analysis of data, and sequential improvements thru our software iterations
18 distinctive systems at software maturity; nearly 3 dozen proprietary software component pieces. All lend themselves 
to
blended combinations; facilitates nearly unlimited upside capacity, and abilities for portfolio diversification
15 + years price data horizon exhaustively analyzed; backtested & forward-tested.

• Decay analysis of "walk-forward" periods indicate certain trading systems have grown stronger
• Analyzed over 500,000 potential trades; stress-tested over 40,000+ fully signaled transactions

• Fully backtested over 3 year period prior to live inception
Over 3 years of live, audited production results from systematic methodology. Over 8,000 fully signaled, executed
transactions in real-time to-date.
High Capacity: Estimated capacity for strategy is > $800M
Attribution Analysis: Trading program at times produces a negative correlation to S&P
Individual trading systems (18 in total to-date) each capable of self sufficiency & delivering profitability; it is the 
combined
output of all systems — a collective 'voting' process - that has proven capable of delivering exceptionally smooth 
performance
curves
Our methodology is built to harvest trade data via relational database mining — we seek to exploit all data elements
surrounding "the trade" akin to a "credit scoring algorithm"
Live example: Methodology's Equity Curve (Performance Graph) during a
strong month.
May. 2010 (vs S&P off -8.2%) Significant Non-correlation
Equity Curve Line
Equity tune Una 40430/10 6P-20 - 00140 16:151
-10000
100 200 330 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100
Trade Humber
Pet/mance Su-nraary Tiede Analysts I bade: Let 1 Pen:Kkei Returns Pedarmance6raphe Nth Graphs] Settings
Legend
Trades

• Peaks
Generated: 6/212010 at 6:24:S3PM
Cleated wlitTiadeStati3n
Live example: Methodology's Performance Curve
During a strong quarter (Q2,2010. Marked by smooth production during a -16% peak/trough S&P
downturn) Significant Non-correlation
Eqier Cove Line
Equity Curve Line 103 31 10 118:02 04 30 11 16:15)
et;
tat 100000
1000 2000
Trade Nine,
Peefarnence Summery Tiede Andyne Trade: Lei Perixical Realms rpelformance Graphs Pride Graphs I Saints I
Generated: 6/30/2010 at 12:24:31 PM
Legend
Trades

• Peeks
Geared web TodeStatiee
More examples - Methodology's live Equity Curve: performance outcomes &
desirable `pattern'
May. 2011 (vs. S&P off -1.35%) — Non-correlation
E y Curve me
Equity Curve Linea, 02.11119:35 - 950111 16:151
•10000
100 200 300 400 500 003 700
Trade Meter
800 900 10W 1100 1200 1300
Lt0CroCI
Trade:
Peal:
PlrelormenGe Summary) T fe05.6.nalysis bade* list Perixlical Roams Pellomance Gtephs I Trade 610/h1 If San,*
Generated: 5/3112011 at 2:56:10 PM
redp51
Another example: the system's live Equity Curve — demonstrating the
curve `smoothness' we seek.
(May. June 2011 no loss days for methodology system vs. S&P -3.18% in May, June)
I Ewa Curve Lire
Ecaray Cleve 1.10e 1 OS 107 II 09:35 • 0600 II 16:15/
20000 O
1003 '
.10CO3
100 200 303 900 SOO KO 700 103 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1403 1500 1103 1700 1800 1900 2000 2100 2200 2300
Trade Kanter
L09rr1
Trade*

• Peaks
I Pelfarriance Summary I Trade Amami' It Trades Litt I Periockal Returns i Performance Graph. J Trade 0taphe I: Settings
I
C4909441:49: 6/30/2011 at 4:35:59 PM
C wawa with Tied Swaim
Price Pattern Recognition; Elements
Fi-865 75 10-820 25 V-1223.729 800808 887824 (Cane.O018.O01420.2.-2.0) 827 49
a
Slocnouic Sbw (141911,Low.C1=4.14.3.3.1 10A0) 93 98
Methods: We propose to trade market "liquidity" wherever we may find it.
Essentially, our methodology is asset class agnostic.
Examples below:
Highly
Liquid
Instruments
SPY
Oil
S&P
Euro
vxx
TRADING ENGINES
TRADE DURATION
TIME IN MARKET EXPOSURE

• Use of Highly Liquid
Markets & Instruments
Characterized by high daily
volume; extreme liquidity;
and price composite
characteristics —IE. not
individual equity "names"

• R/D work completed on
over 50+ highly liquid
instruments
How We Trade It: Employ systematic approach to exploit predictive price
patterns found amidst liquidity. Continually applying multiple sub-systems
(trading engines)
Highly
Liquid
Instruments
TRADING ENGINES
Zen , Apollo I I iggin
od
VXX
\  \
TIME IN MARKET EXPOSURE
TRADE
DURATION
Our portfolio continually
employs 3 or more
trading engines
Each engine a distinct,
systemic software
routine
Each individual engine
capable of functioning
as a fully- automated
expert system
Multiple engines -
simultaneously aimed
at each traded vehicle:
decisioning 'summation'
as a "voting"
mechanism
Resulting Diversification: the "Cube" delivers exceptionally smooth equity
curve; strong Sharpe ratio; and extremely high AUM capacity levels.
Highly Liqui
Instruments
TRADING ENGINES
TIME IN MARKET EXPOSURE
TRADE
DURATION
Featuring as many as
45 engine + instrument
+ timeframe
"combinations"
Extensive blending of
timeframes &
instruments available
Capital allocations per
trade/position closely
monitored
Stop-loss thresholds per
position monitored via
real-time analysis
Extension of cube in all
dimensions: inter-
changeable components
& malleable core trading
engines
A few examples: Our Trading Systems
Algo Description
Zeus
Higgins

• Based on proprietary applications of multiple-price-wave analysis
• Characterized by intermediate time-sensitivity; trade duration

• Responsive to price/momentum shifts over intermediate term; long/or short side
• Based on proprietary applications of trend following systems

• Unique employment of trend lines
• Responsive to trending conditions of market/price behavior: long or short
Apollo • Based on proprietary work with time sensitivity analysis & statistical price arbitrage

• Characterized by strong entry signaling
• Responsive to sideways/trendless conditions; as well as mildly volatile conditions
A
Hedging Strategy
Risk
Classification
Portfolio
Market
Positional
Liquidity
How Does Methodology Consider Risk Management ?

• Multiple trading engines adaptive & responsive to changing market conditions
• Typically 50/50 long/short trade composition

• Net long/short exposure rarely more than 20%
• Balance via time-in-market exposure. system goes to 100% cash at session close

• Blending of short to intermediate term trades; extremely nimble.
• Relative position size allows agility

• Time-in-market ratio: 32% exposure / 68% on sidelines.
• Seek statistically- driven profit opportunities. > 85 daily profitability. At individual
trade level composition; system realizes > 68% win/loss ratio.

• Capital allocation at position level (per trade) closely monitored; max single
positional loss exposure of < 1.5% of total portfolio.

• Overall portfolio loss thresholds monitored at roll-up level; real-time risk
management monitors total single max day portfolio exposure to < 2.25%.

• Employ only most liquid instrument classes
• Nearly all highly liquid instrument classes have proven adaptive to methodology
methodology.

• Methodology represents < than .0005% of liquidity/volume - per instrument traded
• Methodology's 'default' position is to go to 100% cash.
Bio & Contact Info
Adam Campbell
Adam holds a B.A. in Economics from the College of William and Mary and an M.B.A. in Finance & Information
Technology from Jacksonville University. He also received a Certificate in Accounting from the University of Virginia.
Adam has 16 years of experience in systems testing, software engineering, algorithm development, securities
trading, and portfolio management. Adam is a Registered Investment Advisor, and holds Series 3, 30, and 65
licenses.
Most recently, Adam joined with True North Partners, LLC as a CTA, commodities trader, and systematic researcher;
carrying trading responsibility for $150M in notional value. Previously, Adam was the Managing Partner, Founder,
and Portfolio Manager for the Magnum Fund, LLLP, a systematic hedge fund. Adam built the Magnum Fund from a
'Day One' start up, to a successful multi-million [in AUM] Fund that delivered consistent S&P beating returns over his
tenure. Before launching the Magnum Fund, Adam was the Founder of Canal Street Capital, LLC, where he led a
team of software engineers in creating proprietary trading algorithms and also served as the firm's Head Trader.
Earlier, Adam initially created Campbell Equity Advisors, LLC, where he first began to incorporate advanced
computer modeling into his trading methodology. Adam has also held senior-level positions at Oracle and SAP.
Contact Info:
Adam Campbell, Managing Director
Campbell Equity Advisors, LLC
14161 Netherfield Drive
Midlothian, VA 23113
o. 804.594.1924
m.
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Brad Wechsler [finance] IMAX chairman, head of Leon Black's Elysium Management [cnn] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01103509 (Jmail)
 [academia] "Creating Robots with Toddler-Level Intelligence Using the OpenCog AGI Architecture" proposal for Epstein Foundation by Ben Goertzel
(date: 2013-02-01)
Creating Robots with Toddler -Level Intelligence
Using the OpenCog AGI Architecture
Research Proposal for the Epstein Foundation
Ben Goertzel
February, 2013
Introduction
At its inception in the 1950s, the Al field aimed at producing human level general intelligence in computers and
robots. Within a decade or so the difficulty of that goal became evident, and the Al field refocused on producing
systems displaying intelligence within narrow domains. This focus on "narrow Al" has been strikingly successful in
some regards, leading to practical Al applications such as Google's search and ad engines, Deep Blue and other game-
playing Als, IBM's Watson Jeopardy-player, a host of profitable Al financial trading systems, and so forth. Over the
past few years, however, there has been a resurgence of research interest in the original goals of AI, often using
terminology such as Human-Level Al or Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) [1,2,3,4]. The core reason for this
resurgence is a feeling that, due to advances in the Al field and in allied areas such as computer and robotic hardware,
computer science, cognitive psychology and neuroscience, we are in a far better position to approach these goals
today than were the founders of Al in the 1950s.
One may ask why, given all the amazing recent developments in applied Al and allied areas, we have not yet
seen Al software systems with humanlike general intelligence. We believe there is one key ingredient missing—the
effective linkage of subsymbolic Al methods, dealing with raw perceptual and motoric data, with symbolic Al
methods, dealing with abstract reasoning and language, and higher level cognition. The Al field now possesses able
algorithms and architectures on both the symbolic and subsymbolic sides, but without both aspects working together,
human level general intelligence is hard to come by.
Some researchers aim to bridge the gap by making subsymbolic Al systems intelligent enough that they can
learn symbolic reasoning via experience. After all, they figure, symbolic reasoning originally evolved from subsymbolic
thinking — humanity's distant evolutionary ancestors probably didn't do much symbolic reasoning. Others aim to
bypass the need for subsymbolic processing, figuring that one can create a human-level Al well enough by
communicating with it using text chat, and having it gather knowledge from the Web and structured databases — all
sources that are easier to feed directly into a symbolic Al system. Some feel the crux of the Al problem lies on the
symbolic side, and if one wants to make an Al system controlling a robot, one can simply bolt some separate
perception and motor -control modules onto one's symbolic Al system.
The solution we suggest is different, and in a certain sense simpler. We propose to interconnect a highly
functional, primarily symbolic AGI architecture (OpenCog [5], an international open source project), with a highly
functional subsymbolic Al system (DeSTIN [6,7], developed at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville). We propose to
perform this connection, not merely by linking the two systems as separate modules, but by enabling the two systems
to exchange deep information regarding their internal states, and provide guidance to each other's thinking. In order
to do this, we have designed a unique pattern recognition layer intended to live between DeSTIN and OpenCog, and
translate between the languages of the two different systems [B]. The combined OpenCog/DeSTIN system will
powerfully display a core principle of AGI called "cognitive synergy," key to the OpenCog architecture, according to
which different aspects of an intelligent system are engineered to help each other out of cognitive bottlenecks.
To refine and test our approach to OpenCog/DeSTIN integration, we will pose the integrated system the task of
controlling a Hanson Robokind robot in a robot lab environment — a cognitively enabled robot or "CogBot." We will
specifically aim at enabling the Robokind to carry out a variety of preschool-like behaviors, such as playing with 
blocks,
interpreting pictures, drawing with a pencil or marker, answering questions and following instructions.
This forms a natural extension of our current work using OpenCog to control animated characters that build
things with blocks in a 3D video game world; and of prior work using OpenCog to control a Nao robot in a robot lab in
a simpler way, without benefit of hybridization with DeSTIN or any similarly sophisticated perception/action system
[9]. The use of a preschool-like setting enables the application of ideas from developmental psychology to guide and
assess the AGI's progress [10].
httu://ovencotora
1
We don't aim at this stage to create a robot giving a perfect simulation of a human child. Both the body and
mind of our proposed "CogBot" system are very different from those of any human being. Qualitatively, our aim with
the robotics aspect of the project is to create a robot that is recognizably and irrefutably generally intelligent, in 
the
rough manner of a young human child.
In order to rigorously evaluate our progress, we will make use of the WPPSI (Wechler Preschool and Primary
Scale of Intelligence) test, the generally accepted IQ test instrument for children aged 2 through 7. This test may be
carried out via a robot sitting at a table across from a human examiner, answering questions, writing on pieces of
paper, looking at pictures, and manipulating blocks and puzzle pieces. It requires vision and simple physical
manipulation of objects on a tabletop. It does not require carrying of objects, nor navigation (though as it happens
OpenCog is already quite good at navigation). It also does not seek to measure social or emotional intelligence,
though there do exist evaluation instruments for this such as the EQI-YV (Emotional Quotient Index —Youth Version),
which may be interesting to explore in future work.
Due to the complexity of the underlying AI systems (OpenCog and DeSTIN), the proposed project is a
multidisciplinary effort involving component problems in multiple Al areas, including computer vision and audition,
humanoid robot control, computational linguistics, probabilistic reasoning, automatic program learning, assignment of
credit and concept creation. Achieving the project goals will not require breakthroughs in any of these areas; the
focus will rather be on integration and synergetic behavior. However, the results of this research are expected to yield
interesting advances in each of these areas, in addition to the advancement toward human-level artificial general
intelligence implicit in the achievement of childlike intelligence in a humanoid robot.
Existing & Desired Additional Funding
Funding for the work required to complete this project is already partially in place, due to an ITF (Innovation in
Technology Fund) grant obtained via the Hong Kong government, with Dr. Gino Yu as Principal Investigator and Ben
Goertzel's AI consulting firm Novamente LLC as corporate sponsor (providing 10% of the funds to match the ITF's
90%). This ITF grant is titled "Artificial Intelligence Software Enabling Toy Robots to Learn, Communicate, Emotionally
Bond and Display Individual Personalities" (ITS/178/12FP). The ITF grant proposal states that the software produced
with the government funding will be open source, with the Hong Kong government or university not having
intellectual property rights.
The existing government funding amounts to US$342K from the ITF and $38K from Novamente LLC. However,
the government funding is not sufficient to enable the OpenCog controlled robot to be brought to the level required
to perform well on all the WPPSI test tasks, in a genuine way not based on explicitly engineering or teaching "to the
test."
This government funding will pay for a team of 6 PhD students and junior programmers working in a university
lab; the requested additional funding would cover

• A full-time senior software developer
• A full time, experienced Al PhD, to carry out and help supervise Al software development

• A part-time senior systems administrator
• A small, dedicated compute cluster (of Linux machines)
• A dedicated office / robot lab space for the project

• Assistance of Novamente LLC with its corporate contribution (which would be valued due to Novamente's
limited funds and limited commercial activity currently)
In short, the additional funding would transform the project from an underfunded university-research-lab type
initiative, into a professional R&D initiative with experienced hands-on leadership, thus at least doubling productivity
and significantly increasing odds of success.
Background
The background for the project comes from multiple disciplinary directions — computer science, cognitive
science, robotics and systems theory — and the project's conceptual direction is the result of collaboration between
three interdisciplinary researchers and technologists:

• Dr. Ben Goertzel: Principal Investigator; scientific leader of commercial project sponsor Novamente U.C. Dr.
Goertzel is an Al researcher with a mathematics background, the leader of the international Artificial General
Intelligence research community.
2

• Dr. David Hanson: Co-Investigator; scientific leader of commercial project sponsor Hanson Robotics. Dr.
Hanson's whose interdisciplinary background in arts, design and robotics led him to develop a variety of
revolutionary robots including Robot Einstein and Hanson Robokind (the latter to be used in the proposed
project) [see Figure 2I. These robots feature novel robot skin enabling humanlike emotional expression, and
feature a unique combination of hardware and software features focused on rich emotional interaction with
human users.

• Dr. Itamar Arel: Scientific Advisor. Al and engineering professor at the University of Tennessee Knoxville, the
creator of the DeSTIN (Deep SpatioTemporal Inference Network) software to be used in the project for robot
vision and action (to serve as an intermediate layer between OpenCog and the Robokind robot)
The project involves three key components, corresponding to these three researchers:

• The OpenCog artificial general intelligence architecture [S,8], an open-source software project initiated by Dr.
Goertzel and now developed and maintained by a global open-source community led by Goertzel and others

• The DeSTIN framework for machine perception (extensible to action as well), developed by Dr. Itamar Arel
and his students at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville; now an open-source software project bundled with
OpenCogHanson's robotics hardware, the Hanson Robokind, and his open-source software for specifying and
maintaining intelligent characters with individual personalities [15],
-- integrated in a manner that is inspired by the prior research and thinking of Goertzel, Hanson and Arel, but also has
critical novel aspects. The core of the project is a novel approach to bridging the sensation/action domain as
embodied in the Robokind's sensors and actuators and recognized via the (subsymbolic) DeSTIN Al software, and the
domain of symbolic, abstract Al cognition as embodied in the OpenCog cognitive architecture.
OpenCog is the most practically advanced software system explicitly oriented toward Artificial General
Intelligence. Compared to other contemporary AGI-oriented software systems=, OpenCog has a more professionally
designed and implemented codebase, and a wider range of functionalities. Conceptually, the OpenCog architecture is
unique in its integration of a number of powerful learning algorithms within a human-like cognitive architecture.
OpenCog has been used in a variety of commercial projects in areas such as natural language processing,
financial analysis and bioinformatics. The main thrust of current OpenCog development is the use of the system to
control animated characters in a video-game world — which, following a long tradition in the AI field, is a world where
most objects are built from small blocks, whose positions and interactions the AI system can fully understand and
manipulate. OpenCog guides characters in the world as they explore and try to achieve their goals. This is a follow-up
to earlier work using OpenCog to control virtual pets in a simpler virtual world [17I.
OpenCog has also previously been used to control a Nao humanoid robot [18]. However, this was merely a
prototyping activity, which was not expected to yield dramatic embodied intelligence, due to OpenCog's lack of a
serious perception and action module at that time. The core aim of the present proposal is to remedy this lack.
2 Samsonovich [16] has given a good general overview of the various AGI software systems at play in the field
currently, including e.g. classic systems like SOAR and ACT-R, and more modern ones like (to name just a few) Stan
Franklin's LIDA system, Joscha Bach's MicroPsi and Nick Cassimatis's PolyScheme.
3
- a
■
er a L:2z3' •
is a►4 4 V
Achul
FtneravrIntRICUrFc4r1
r i nn.t , • 7••••0
linur hinOtaillso,Sidth
ktarRttr•TIRyfra.e.
I/
• •
Figure 1. Top: Screenshots of virtual dog controlled by OpenCog engine, os it learns soccer skills via imitation and
reinforcement, and builds semantic models of its environment. Bottom: Screenshot of blocks world" being used for
current OpenCog experimentation; the robot is one of multiple OpenCog-controlled characters.
DeSTIN, a machine perception architecture, fills a major gap in OpenCog — the processing of complex, high-
bandwidth perceptual data, as is produced by camera eyes or microphones. It possesses a hierarchical architecture
similar to the human visual and auditory cortices, and an efficient algorithmic implementation that exploits the
massively parallel processing provided by GPU supercomputers. Currently it is being used for recognizing patterns in
images and videos, but the architecture can be straightforwardly extended to audition as well, and also beyond
perception to handle actuation.
To connect DeSTIN and OpenCog in a maximally effective way, we have designed a unique "semantic
perceptual-motor hierarchy", which sits between the two systems, incorporating aspects of each. As depicted in
Figure 3, it has DeSTIN's hierarchical structure, but represents knowledge using OpenCog's symbolic semantic network
representations, rather than DeSTIN's subsymbolic numerical vectors. This semantic hierarchy naturally maps into
both DeSTIN and OpenCog, and enables the two systems to pass information to each other frequently as they
operate, enhancing each other's intelligence synergetically.
4
Figure Z Left: Dr. Hanson's Robot Einstein, probably the most expressive and emotionally evocative robot face ever
constructed. Right: Hanson Robokind — the emotionally expressive humanoid robot to be used in the current project,
based on a donation of two robots from Hanson Robotics.
To refine and evaluate this novel approach to bridging OpenCog's symbolic reasoning and DeSTIN's
subsymbolic pattern recognition activity, one requires a sufficiently sophisticated platform for receiving sensations
and executing actions. The Hanson Robokind robot provides high-quality visual and auditory sensors and servomotor
capability, at a level previously available only in research robots costing hundreds of thousands of US dollars).
Furthermore, the Robokind's capability for facial emotional expressiveness is unparalleled in any previous
commercially available robot regardless of cost. While not useful for the WPPSI evaluation metric, this aspect is
generally valuable in a "childlike AGI" context because it gives the Robokind ability to elicit interesting, informative
behavior from humans, thus help the OpenCog engine to gain the emotional and social knowledge it needs to interact
effectively with the world.. This facial-expression capability is based on special patented flexible robot skin that was
developed in Hanson's prior research robots such as the well-known Robot Einstein, and is brought to the commercial
market for the first time in the Robokind (Figure 2).
Project Aims
The high-level objective of the proposed CogBot project is to create a software system instantiating a solution to
the most fundamental problem holding back progress toward AGI: the bridging of the symbolic and subsymbolic
levels of mental activity. Among the many subproblems to be addressed in this context, the most fundamental
regards intelligent, synergetic interfacing between low-level robotic perception/action data and more abstract Al
cognition — a problem for which we have a novel solution.
Alongside qualitative evaluation and testing of specific technical capabilities, the key measurable aim of the project 
is
to create an OpenCog-powered robot that is able to perform well (above the 90% level) on the WPPSI preschool
intelligence test. The specifics of this test are described in the document "The Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale
of Intelligence (WPPSI): A Brief Overview", provided as a companion to this proposal; and some issues regarding the
application of this test in a robotics context are described in the document "Utilizing Child IQ Tests to Measure Robot
Intelligence", also provided. As noted there, the critical intelligent capabilities required for success on the WPPSI 
test
are:

1. Natural language question answering (regarding information generally known to young children,
and the immediate physical situation of the robot)

2. Object, event and part identification (especially for objects depicted in pictures, and commonly
known to young children)

3. Object manipulation (minimally of objects sitting on, and slid around on, a tabletop)
4. Visual pattem recognkion (of patterns in drawing, and textures on and shapes of physical objects)
5

S. Simple drawing (not necessarily of pictures nor words, but lines and other simple symbols, using
pencil or marker on paper)

6. Instruction following (regarding tasks involved in the intelligence test, but also more broadly)
7. Pragmatic interaction regarding task assignment (because the robot will not be fed the test
questions in an artificial way, but it will rather be posed them as part of a general, everyday robot -
interaction)
On a technical level, the key aims of the project in pursuit of these capabilities are:

1. To create an intermediate "semantic hierarchy" connecting DeSTIN and OpenCog
2. To make various changes identified as necessary to DeSTIN, to enable effective connection with the
semantic hierarchy

3. To adjust OpenCog's internal cognitive algorithms for optimal functionality on the data coming from
the semantic hierarchy (mainly the PIN probabilistic logic engine, the conceptual blending algorithm
for creating new concepts, and the Fishgram pattern recognition algorithm)

4. To integrate the combined OpenCog/DeSTIN software with Hanson's robot control software, and
with open-source text-to speech (Festival) and speech-to-text (Sphinx) engines, to enable the system
to control a Robokind humanoid robot
5. To refine and evaluate this robot's capability to carry out simple "child-like" tasks in a robot lab
furnished with appropriate preschool-like equipment
Items 4 and S will focus mainly but not exclusively on tabletop-interaction based tasks, as those are the ones that
WPPSI focuses on. However, we will not create a robot that can only interact or display intelligence across a
tabletop!
Strategy and Methodology
The fulfillment of the project's aims involvse a significant amount of highly technical software development,
which will be carried out by the two proposed new hires, together with the 6 junior members of the current
OpenCog Hong Kong team. Figure 3 gives a high-level diagram illustrating the integration of DeSTIN and OpenCog,
in the context of humanoid robotics. Figure 4 depicts more of the internals of the OpenCog architecture, as
currently being used for animated agent control. From OpenCog's perspective, the robot and game character are
essentially the same sort of entity — the difference lying in the critical "symbolic/subsymbolic converter"
component that translates between the language of perception/action (DeSTIN states) and the language of
abstract cognition (OpenCog's internal Atom representation). Figure 5 gives a deeper view of OpenCog/DeSTIN
integration.
Note that in this design, the bulk of the robot's "mind" lives on a laptop or PC assumed to be on the same
wifi network as the robot. In a commercial product based on this design, a portion of the robot's mind may also
live in the cloud, allowing sharing of knowledge between different robots. The processor on board the robot
handles real-time action response, low-level sensory processing, and communication with the rest of the robot's
mind via wifi.
6
L Simulator
OPEN. COG
Critic
Hierarchy
Perceptual
Hierarchy
Action
Hierarchy
DeSTIN
Figure 3. High-Level Architecture of proposed system. Key components include the Hanson Robokind robot, the
OpenCog cognition engine, the DeSTIN perception/action engine, and a novel "symbolic/subsymbolic converter
translating between DeSTIN's subsymbolic perception/action language and Open Cog's semantic-network
language.
•
NL
Comprehension Conceptual
blending PLN
r \ •
SCAN
C
M
oL
o
larativ)
rnOrY
Cttontlotta)
MernOrlt
Conn
e
ate)
MrilOrY
C:Z nnnintOry
A
'V  • e e \ e
NL Perception Action
OeneratIOn Selection and
Control
\
CWorld Episodic
alttritery Memory
A
•
Simulation
Eng as
MOSES
Unified
Knowledge
Store
Dialogue
Control
OpenCog Prime
Intelligent character
in game world
Figure 4: Key components of the OpenCog integrated artificial general intelligence architecture, shown in the context
of intelligent game character control. The proposed robotic application is similar, but with the DeSTIN
perception/action component used os an intermediary between OpenCog and the robot, as robot perception/action is
much subtler than its analogue in the virtual world.
7
tessis •
DeSTIN perception
hierarchy
ea a0
Level 2
sensors
feed data
to DeSTIN
Intermediate Semantic Hierarchy
above the semantic hierarchy
level representing faces. is a
level representing entire heath
visual patterns (e.g.
DeSTIN centroids)
corresponding to
the semantic
perception node
linked to "human
eye"
semantic nodes/links
formed by pattern mining
DeSTIN hierarchy
input
concept node
adnce
semantic hierarchy provides
probabilistic biasing to
DeSTIN
OpenCog
AtomSpace
refer erica
link
aligned on axis
perpendicular to
mouth -nose -eyes axis
aligned on axis
perpendicular to below
eyes axis
reference
link
bylaw
Figure S: An in-depth illustration of the "intermediate semantic hierarchy" referenced in Figure 3. In the context of
face recognition, this shows the interfacing between DeSTIN and OpenCog's "cognitive semantic network"
knowledge representation, via means of a symbolic-subsymbolic translation layer that utilizes OpenCog's
knowledge representation atoms but possesses DeSTIN's hierarchical structure. This unique interfacing layer is the
central scientific novelty of the proposed project.
Anticipated Outcomes and Impacts
This project offers the potential to introduce a dramatic advance in artificial general intelligence and cognitive
robotics. It will serve as a platform for further dramatic advances, in the form of ongoing aimed at producing
software enabling humanoid robots to achieve humanlike general intelligence beyond the early childhood level. Its
successful completion is expected to have broad impact on the Al field, inspiring other researchers to pursue
integrated cognitive architectures for intelligent agent control, and in general helping to revive research interest in 
the
original, ambitious goals of the Al field.
Concretely, in order to ensure this influence happens, we intend to publish at least three papers in high-impact
journals summarizing the results of the project, along with making a highly-publicized release of the open-source code
developed, and launching a series of YouTube videos showing the intelligent robot children in action. Presentations at
appropriate conferences will also be done, including academic robotics and Al conferences (AAAI, IEEE) as well as
futurist conferences such as the Singularity Summit, Humanity+, World Future Society, etc.
While the current proposal is focused on pure research, we also intend to encourage the commercialization of
the technology developed in the project, initially via collaboration with Hanson Robotics and Jetta (the Hong Kong firm
that manufactures Hanson's robots) on the creation and marketing of intelligent robot toys. Hanson Robotics has
carefully explored the business and technical aspects of this sort of product offering, but currently lacks the Al
technology to make it work on their own.
Of the $21 billion market for remote-control electronic toys, about $200 million consists of higher-end robotic
8
devices costing $100 or more (including e.g. the Nao, smart drones like the Parrot, and the Kondo robot kits).3 At
lower price points, it's hard to draw the line between robot toys like RoboSapien and "mere" electronic remote
control devices. Clearly the market for - $100 robot toys could be grown dramatically via the entrance of radically
superior technology into the marketplace. One could imagine a commercial toy robot with an initial hardware cost of
—$99, plus a monthly subscription fee of perhaps $4.99, the latter buying online access to OpenCog AGI servers
supplying the robots with advanced intelligence.
Beyond this, there are a number of possibilities for commercialization of the specific cognitive robotics
technology expected to result from this project, including in:

• The robotics industry. The advances in general intelligence developed for robots will make them suitable to take
on more roles in the service industry, among others.

• The toy industry. With toys becoming increasingly sophisticated and electronic, our proposed software can be
applied to drive the behavior of new electronic toys.
• The consumer electronics industry. Consumer electronics such as tablet computers and smart phones could
benefit greatly from being more intelligent, more responsive to users and more predictive of users' needs.
And of course, the follow-on AGI development enabled by success in our project could have much broader
commercial impact.
We are also enthused about the broader social implications of advanced artificial general intelligence making
its initial advent in the guise of friendly, childlike humanoid robots. In the future as AGI advances beyond the 
childlike
level, human attitudes toward AGI may become complex and contentious; we believe the best path to an agreeable
future is one in which people and early-stage AGIs have a relationship of mutual understanding.
Budget
Please see separate budget spreadsheet.
Timeline/Milestones
Please see separate document
References

1. B. Goertzel and C. Pennachin, Artificial General Intelligence. Springer, 2005.
2. [AGI-01] B. G. Stan Franklin and P. W. (Editors), Proceedings of First Conference on Artificial General
Intelligence. IOS Press, 2008.

3. [AGI-02] P. H. Marcus Rutter and B. G. (Editors), Proceedings of Second Conference on Artificial
General Intelligence. Atlantis Press, 2008.

4. N. C. (Editor), Human -Level Intelligence (Special Issue of Artificial Intelligence Magazine). AAAI,
2006.

5. B. Goertzel, "Opencog prime: A cognitive synergy based architecture for embodied artificial general
intelligence," in Proceedings of ICCI-09, Hong Kong, 2009.

6. Arel, D. Rose, and T. Karnowski, "A deep learning architecture comprising homogeneous cortical
circuits for scalable spatiotemporal pattern inference." NIPS 2009 Workshop on Deep Learning for
Speech Recognition and Related Applications, Dec 2009.

7. Thomas P. Karnowski, Itamar Arel, Derek Rose: Deep Spatiotemporal Feature Learning with
Application to Image Classification. ICMLA 2010: 883-888

8. Goertzel, Ben (2011). Integrating a Compositional Spatiotemporal Deep Learning Network with
Symbolic Representation/Reasoning within an Integrative Cognitive Architecture via an
Intermediary Semantic Network. Proceedings of AAAI Symposium on Cognitive Systems, Arlington
3 Figures via personal communication from Mark Tilden, founder & chief scientist of Wowee, maker of RoboSapicn
9
VA

9. Goertzel, Ben and Hugo de Garis. XIA-MAN: An Integrative, Extensible Architecture for Intelligent
Humanoid Robotics. AAAI Symposium on Biologically-Inspired Cognitive Architectures, Washington
DC, November 2008

10. Goertzel, Ben and Stephan Vladimir Bugaj. AGI Preschool: A Framework for Evaluating Early-Stage
Human-like AGIs. Proceedings of the Second Conference on Artificial General Intelligence, Atlantis
Press.

11. Sam Adams, Itmar Arel, Joscha Bach, Robert Coop, Rod Furlan, Ben Goertzel, J. Storrs Hall, Alexei
Samsonovich, Matthias Scheutz, Matthew Schlesinger, Stuart C. Shapiro, John Sowa (2012).
Mapping the Landscape of Human-Level Artificial General Intelligence. Al Magazine, Winter 2012.

12. P. Hayes and K. Ford., "Turing test considered harmful," IJCAI-14, 1995
13. Kurzweil, Ray (2005). The Singularity Is Near. Viking.

14. Breazeal, Cynthia (2002). Designing Sociable Robots. MIT Press.
15. Hanson D. "Bioinspired Robotics", chapter 16 in the book Biomimetics, ed. Yoseph Bar-Cohen, CRC
Press, October 2005.

16. Hanson, David and V. White. (2004). "Converging the Capabilities of ElectroActive Polymer
Artificial Muscles and the Requirements of Bio-inspired Robotics", Proc. SPIE's Electroactive
Polymer Actuators and Devices Conf., San Diego

17. Samsonovich, A. V. (2010). Toward a unified catalog of implemented cognitive architectures
(review). In Samsonovich, A. V., Johannsdottir, K. R., Chella, A., and Goertzel, B. (Eds.). Biologically
Inspired Cognitive Architectures 2010: Proceedings of the First Annual Meeting of the BICA Society.
Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence and Applications, vol. 221, pp. 195-244. Amsterdam, The
Netherlands: IOS Press. ISSN 0922-6389.

18. Goertzel, Ben, Cassio Pennachin, Nil Geissweiller, Moshe Looks, Andre Senna, An Heljakka, Welter
Silva, Carlos Lopes . An Integrative Methodology for Teaching Embodied Non-Linguistic Agents,
Applied to Virtual Animals in Second Life, in Proceedings of the First AGI Conference, Ed. Wang et al,
1O5 Press
10
╔══════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Michael Sitrick [publicist] crisis PR 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00589586 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2013-02-08)
0  American Arbitration Association
Dispute Resolution Services Worldwide
January 30, 2013
VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL
Vincent S. Green, Esq.
Nemecek & Cole
15260 Ventura Boulevard, Suite 920
Sherman Oaks, CA 91403
Stephen G. Rinehart
Troutman Sanders LLP
405 Lexington Ave.
New York, NY 10174
Re: 72 147 00218 12 SIM
Sitrick and Company, a division of Sitrick Brincko
Group, LLC
VS
Jeffrey Epstein
Dear Parties:
Jeffrey Garcia, Vice President
Western Case Management Center
67
internet: httpWwww.adr.org/
We ask the parties to kindly advise us as to the status of the above referenced matter on or before
February 8, 2013.
Please be advised it is the policy of the Association to hold cases in abeyance for one year. The parties
may continue to hold the matter in abeyance beyond that period provided they remit a payment of
$300.00 to the Association to cover the administrative expense of continued tracking of such cases.
You may also view case financial information, as well as make payments with a credit card online via
AAA's WebFile.
The Association will request this fee after this case has been in abeyance for eleven months. Absent
remittance of this fee, we will close our file.
Should you have any questions regarding the above, please do not hesitate to call.
Sincerely,
/s/
Sandra L. Marshall
Mana er of ADR Services
SM/js
EFTA02731556 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2013-04-29)
Sc 'Tarr 4 St ember 30. 2012 Pap 1 of 6
01100W SERVICES
Sc.ember 4 • ember 30.2012 Page 2 of 6
09/0V12 Opening Babnce
09005/12 Incuni Wirt Transfer WIRE FROM LEON D BLACK 60.000.00
St ei• her Se gen tler 30. 20E2 Page to(
Pagr 4 of 6
Pao 5 of 6
nTriSt:^(VP.CT IC.T
A 'NI Pap: I of
CI 1(301.1) SFRVICTS

╭──── Page 6, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

Annl I -:April Q. 201) P3gc 6
' • A ril 2013 Page 3 of 6

╭──── Page 8, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

April 1 • April 2013 Pap: 4 of
. 1 1 Pap! of 10
kin I Ink kl 2013 Page 3 of In
Jul.. I hi ,.

╭──── Page 13, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

.n33 nay 31.2.013 net(4 t0
J I -Ju 31.2013 Pµe 6 of 10
07/25/13 Uremia Wire Transfer WIRE FROM LEON D BLACK 145030.00
Vag of In
futv I • 31.
c+°ikSt4MWM., iff:gia4t Va;sttsti,:ttf-
Jul I -Jul 3 214 Page I of 7
CITIGOLDSERVI U.
July I • Jul) II. :in.: Page 2 oi 7
Ir 1 -fitly 31 2014 Page Soli

╭──────────────── Page 20, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ Coninued                                         │
│                                                  │
│ OIA Incoming Wie Trasfer_WIRE FROM LEON D BLACK, │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
╔══════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Polina Belomlinskaya [russian girl] immigration paralegal 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00313308 (Jmail)
 [resumé] professional resumé of Polina Belomlinskaya
(approximate date: 2013-05-01)
Polina Belomlinskaya
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE:
Greenberg Traurig LLP, New York, New York
Immigration Paralegal, January 2013- April 2013

• Responsibilities included:
-Preparation, review, and filing of various immigration documents
-Interactions with various parties, including clients and government officials
-Translation of promotional materials from and to Russian
-Legal and online research
-various projects for supervising attorneys, as needed
Flemming Zulack Williamson Zauderer LLP, New York, New York
Consulting Paralegal, October 2011- January 2013

• Responsibilities included:
-Discovery review, preparation and translation of foreign documents
-Interactions with various parties, including clients and non-parties to a case
-providing insight into various cultural and political aspects of an international lawsuit
-various projects for attorneys, as needed
Limbus Press Publishing House, Saint Petersburg, Russia
Foreign Rights Director, 2008- 2011

• Managed and supervised foreign rights department
• Responsibilities included:
-Developed and oversaw publishing rights for books and related products domestically as well as abroad
-Coordinated process of sales and purchases of copyrights, from initiating sale of a publication to new contacts,
through to ensuring that particular publication is produced on schedule.
-Liaised with authors, editors, translators and other publishers
-Maintained all records of sales and purchases; produced invoices
-Generated and reviewed copyright agreements
-Represented the company at numerous international book fairs
Cowan Liebowitz & Littman, LLC, New York, New York
Senior Paralegal, 2004 - 2008

• Specialized in intellectual property law. Trademarks and Copyrights.
• Responsibilities included:
-Conducted legal research and on-line use specimen research, drafted and electronically filed oppositions and
prosecutions with the USPTO, conducted general trademark searches for purposes of registration, and filed
registrations and cancellations for MLB as well as various other high-profile clients.
-Managed more than 200 active cases for Recording Industry Association of America as Project Manager
-Prepared, edited and reviewed legal documents
-Maintained case dockets; handled court filings; served process
-Assisted with international arbitrations
-Interacted with clients, opposing counsel, judges and court legal staff
LANGUAGES: Fluent in Russian. Working knowledge of German.
COMPUTER EXPERIENCE:
Research: Internet, Westlaw, LexisNexis, Pacer
Software Proficiency: Word, Word Perfect, Excel, Concordance, CaseMap, MA3000, luris, Adobe Acrobat
Professional, Photoshop, PowerPoint, HTML
EDUCATION:

St. John's University School of Law, Queens, NY
August 2001-December 2007, Degree not attained.
State University College of New York at Oneonta, Oneonta, NY
Degree: Double B.A. in English Literature/Philosophy, Cum Laude, 2002
Honors: • Kai Alpha Epsilon Honor Society • Dean's List • President of the English Club
REFERENCES: AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST
EFTA00191148 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States
EFTA00210958 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Virginia Giuffre, see quote: "1999 began working at Donald Trump's Mar-A-Lago"
(date: 2013-07-05)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 12-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  07/05/2013
maiden name MOININIMMsdate of birth
Social Security Account Number United States Citizen and
Australian Permanent Resident, rest ence 0 Bundeena Road, Glenning Valley,
New South Wales, Australia, 2261 was interviewed at the United States
Consulate in Sydney, Australia. was advised of the identity of the
interviewing agents and purpose of the interview. Present during the
interview was Federal Bureau of Investigation Special Agent
land via telephone, Assistant
United States Attorney'   I provided the
following information:
meta s
currently resides in andl
currently resides
Beach County, Florida with her parents
returned to California at a•e 11.
was placed in a
Florida.
approximately 14
Florida, she met
born in Sacramento, California to parents'
'date of birth' I
date of birth
moved to Palm inl
when she was four years old and
She returned to Florida at age 13 and
in West Palm Beach,
when she was
years old, and while living on the streets in Miami,
was training to be an Ulla
'gave a life off of the streets which made her feel
mwstigstiosim 03/17/2011 at Sydney, Australia (In Person)
Files 31E-MM-108062  Dmectraht4 07/05/2013
by
This document coma mywither recommendations nor conclusions dine FBI. It u liverwort), of the FBI and u loaned to, your 
agency: it and ias ammo are not
to be distributed outside your agency.
136
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
FD-302a (Rev 05-0840)
31E -MM -
Continuation of FD-302  0, 03/17/2011 ju t 2 of 12
like she was locked into the relationship   gave
toward the end of their relationship.
relationship with 'ended while she was at a private
ranch near Ocala, Florida. telephonically contacted a childhood
friend, I from a telephone at the ranch. '
knew' Ifrom elementary school and called him at  the home  telephone
of his parents 'she was
very lonely, an sked her why she did not leave
telephone conversation with
the recreational vehicle  was
did not staying in  at the ranch
strike her,
her belongings and told her she was going to live with another man.
'pack
felt that
specifics
1,6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
she was sent tol  !but did not know the b7c
of the arrangement. engaged in sexual activity with
who was described as a white male stated
approximately one or
her to her parents.
parents ■
Florida.
stayed with ]LNU for
two weeks before the police located her and returned
was interviewed by a male detective.
at the time and lived near
believed there was an FBI investigation related to
She never saw again after
In approximately June 1998 or 1999 began working at Donald
Trump's  Mar-A-Lago  Club in Palm Beach, Florida. father
was able to help her gain
employment as a baby sitter and later as a locker room attendant at the
club. started studying for her GED and wanted to become a massage
therapist. In Au ust, was reading an anatomy/massage book and was
approached by
land help her get her masseuse accreditation.'
consulted her father about the opportunity and at approximately
5:00 p.m. the same day, her father drove her to a residence at
b6
b7C
FD-302a (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of
Florida.
it was a wonderful o
spoke with
ortunity for
also known as
•
0, 03/17/2011 .p 3 of 12
met
father and told him
was led
Once upstairs in
instructed to wash her  hands prior to
beginning the massage The massage begs demonstrated massage
techniques to
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
During the course of the massage,' uestioned b6
about her past, including her time as a runaway. was also b7c
asked if she took birth control.
was given instruction and began kissing'
At the conclusion,'  'instructed to obtain two warm wash
clothes. One wash cloth was used to clean
second was' to help him relax
describe
and then moved to the steam room and shower where
'with soap and a loofah in the shower.
At the conclusion of the shower,
massaged
went downstairs and'
Arrangements were made for to return to the house the following  day
after work. cellular phone number was given to'
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
FD-302a (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of L. O, 03/17/2011 Fa, 4 of 12
The same routine  ern of massages and sexual activity between
alga
land continued for between one and two weeks. At
loffered the option to quit her
job at Mar-A-Lago and travel There
was also discussion of receiving massage training. was to
be paid $200.00 per day for travel and $200.00 per hour for massages.
Early in her relationship with' met'
land was introduced as' 'assistant.
soon  began traveling  For the initial six months,
traveled' around the United States and Caribbean,
including California, New York City, New Mexico, and various business
trips. During those trips,'
Six to nine months after began working for
introduced t4
'Florida.
Iat the timee met the couple
'The condominium was bought)
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
I
was
in b6
b7C
at a condominium next
provided a normal massage t
to the
and was a
'In the condominium,
LNU. Shortly thereafter,' LNU
provided an erotic massage to
and
cleaned  She was
paid cash' lin addition,
paid GIUFFREF was 16
years old at the timer
advised  'introduced her to the
She explained that helped her escape from reality but allowed her to
still function  normally. helped her go forward with what she was
doing with  land others. Her habit went from two pills per day up to
eight pills per day.
second  client was an academic of some sort described as an
older American male 'sent
from Miami International  Airport to
Iby commercial airline. was picked up at the
airport byl land then taken to the island by boat.
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
FD-302a (Rev. 05-0840)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of on 03/17/2011 pate 5 of 12
pointed out that)
client
to ride jet skis and participate in other island activities'
instructed to entertain the
and wanted
spent two days  on
with the client. assumes the client also traveled
commercially.
the island
Durina th following several months, traveled internationally
Prior to her traveling abroad ssisted in
getting her pass ort. got passport photographs of herself and
provided them t he remaining paperwork was taken care of by
I traveled to Paris, France, the
South of France, London, England, Africa, and Spain. While in Paris,
recalled staying  at a hotel overlooking the Champs-Elysees. While
traveling] traveled on
a black •lane. Durin• the international
travel
times, would
At
Rarely a day would pass
ontacted through
land wanted to talk to  rou
offered
and
a contract. agreed to the contract for her story
and was paid $140,000 for the
and another $10,000 to be
contract prevented
period. advised
informatio
story, $10,000 when the article was printed,
wired into account in May 2011. The
from talking to  any other press for a specified
that she provided' 'with detailed
b6
b7c
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
FO4021 (Rev. 05.08.10)
Continuation
31E -MM-108062
of FO.302 of 0, 03/17/2011 pmw 6 of 12
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
16, At age
met
IUFFRE believed she and were
approximately the same age. and)
would dress
, thought explained
provided an
An unknown individual
I described)
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
saw when she arrived at b6
had
said that day was a low stage in her relationshi
because she could not believe)
never
b7C
FD-302a (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of
saw
• Dn 03/17/2011 Page 7 of 12
believed the girls may have been
was not certain of[ 'involvement.
had a picture of herself she wanted to nivel
lb t
described some of the unique interior areas of
which referred to
which was
stayed.
here
While in New York, also stayed at an apartment  on 66th street
was aware ofl additional
apartments in the same building. According tor- 'the
apartment building on 66th street was owned by' Milli'.
advised that she had a photo  raph of the interior of the 66th Street
( apartment among other photos
advised that some of her photographs that were provided to her
civil attorneys by her family were not returned. One of the missing photos
depicted wearing a pink dress while seated on a quad bike.
I ILNU wall (female that formerly lived in 1
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
FD-302a (Rev 05-08-10)
L
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of • o, 03/17/2011 p4, 8 of 12
LNU and went shopping  together and purchased clothing
explained that'
1
used a cellular telephone'
a New York City number but could not recall the number.
did not'
unsuccessfully to get
could only remember faces'
She believed it was
and
not their names.
I but she did try
recalled'
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
but she could
NU.
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
not recall the wording.
advisedt
in
New
at a hotel
d Rock Café in New
'ncluding the USVI,
and the United
traveled' to a self-help conference
New Orleans, Louisiana. The hotel w s near the H
Orleans. traveled the worl
York, Santa Fe, Palm Beach, France, Africa, Spain
Kingdom.
recalled visiting
Alhambra Castle in Spain. I
eventually traveled to the United Kingdom and
/06
b7C
F0.302a(Rev.05-0840)
31E—MM-108062
Commualion of FD-302 of • 0, 03/17/2011 pase 9 of 12
while there' 'approached in a very excited manner and told
her they had to go shopping to pick out a dress because would be
dancing with
and'  went shopping and purchased makeup, clothing,  and a
Burberry ba . The items were purchased withl
an returned'
instructed to get read . When came down after gettin
ready, she was introduced to
traveled to CLUB TRAM
danced at CLUB TRAMP'
Istayed at CLUB TRAMP
for an hour or hour and a half and drank a couple of cocktails before
returnin to
from
requested' Ito take a photograph of her] M W I
I After returning t.
advised that she still had the original photograph in her possession  and
would provide it to the interviewing agents proceeded with'
had not received any direction
Approximately two months later, met' 'at
recalled
ILNU,
recallecj (joking about trading in because
she was getting too old.
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
FD-302a (Rev 05-08-10)
I
31E—MM-1013062
Continuation of FD-302 of la
o, 03/17/2011 Far 10 of 12
recalled meeting,
was heavily at the time,
and her recollection was not clear. She remembered there were many models
on the island that did not speak English along with a modeling person who
had an unknown accent.
I
I
id not have a problem with using
was described by as a
I 1 (TRUE NAME UNKNOWN)
la ranch employee inj Ibut
could not recall his name. She did have a photograph of the ranch
employee.
met numerous famous peopl jancluding
academics, politicians, and celebrities.  She me Iani
IIand f
received many gifts
bags, shoes, make up, clot ina,
I I
left all of the items behind when she traveled to Thailand to
receive massage training.
and
ncludinig jewelry, watches,
home furnishings.
In August 2002, traveled by commercial airline to Bangkok,
Thailand and began her massage training at International Training Massage
School(ITM) where she received thpr tras‘acie certification. She stayed at
the Princess Hotel in Thailand'
but never did. met her future husband,)
contacted' 'telephonically1 and
mnlri him she had fallen in love with someone. L during her visit to Thailand.
I
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
FD-302a (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E -MM -108062
Continuation of FD-302 of
had not heard from
telephone call from[ 'During that call' stated he was an
FBI agent. He was trying to determine  what she knew about
She did not tell 'anything about her knowledge of
She also received another telephone call from a
person that indicated he was an FBI agent. She did not tell that
individual anything either. She also received a call from an attorney that
was trying to determine if she had spoken with anyone or was willing to
speak to anyone'
'She
explained that she was receiving telephone calls from people whom she did
not know and that she was uncomfortable telling them anything over the
telephone.
on 03/17/2011 par 11 of 12
received a
One or two weeks later, an unknown attorney and' contacted
telephonically]r
was using a cellular telephone belonging to her husband. She
nor her husband could recall the telephone number but advised that the
carrier was OPTUS telephone company.
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
reviewed
the following:
a series of photographs of individuals and identified
Page 1, number 1,
LNU, a.k.a b6
b7C
Page 1, number 2,
Page 2, number 1,
Page 2, number 6,
Page 3, number 2,
Page 4, number 3, LNU
Page 4, number 7,
Page 4, number 8,
Page 5, number 1,
advised that the following were familiar to her, but she could not
recall their names or her association to them:
FD-302a (Rev 05.0&10)
31E -MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of o
Page 1, number 4
Page 2, numbers 7 and 8
Page 3, number 8
Page 4, number 1
Page 5, numbers 5 and 8
on 03/17/2011 t h w  12 of 12
The images reviewed by were placed in a lA envelope of the case
file.
When questioned about United States Customs and Border (CBP) Patrol
records of her entries into the United States, advised that her
January 2001 record was the return from her London,  England trip
The April 2001 CBP
record was her return to the United States
could not recall her travel from
March and May 2001 CPB records. advised that her United States
Passport was turned over to the United States Consulate in Sydney,
Australia.
On March 18, 2011, writer, SAI land
traveled to residence where she provided 20 photographs and her
ITM massage school certification. FD-597 Receipts for Property were
executed for the items and a copy was provided to . It is noted that
the receipts were dated based on the United States Eastern Standard Time
Zone date. The photographs, certification and original FD-597s were placed
in a lA envelopes of case file.
b6
b7C
b6
b7C
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 KYC [government] Know Your Customer, anti-money laundering legal framework 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01480623 (Jmail)
 [money] JP Morgan was going to drop Epstein as a client until Jes Staley intervened
(inferred timestamp: 2013-07-13 07:22:00)
Ticket#     105258603       Account#            Initiated Date  07/13/2013 07:22 AM
Client Name HBRK            Account Title       Initiator       JUSTIN D NELSON
.           ASSOCIATES INC
ECI         <REDACTED>      Account Type        Initiating Team PS FRONT OFFICE
LOB         PB

Verify & Confirm for HBRK ASSOCIATES

Final Risk Rating                   High
Initial Risk Rating                 Standard
GCS Report Requested                Full
Presence of Potential High Risk     Yes
Indicators

Reason for Adjustment               Reputational - Convicted Felon
Comments
Summary of Risk Attributes          Jeffrey Epstein was convicted of a felony charge in 2008.
.                                   Jes Staley conferred with Stephen Cutler and the decision
.                                   was made to keep Mr. Epstein as a PB ckent. Mr.
.                                   Epstein completed his sentence and probation in 2010.

Please summarize any material changes which have occurred with the client within the past 12 months:

Jeffrey Epstein is an existing client of PB. He is an active brokerage client across asset
classes currently covered by the Firm's 010 desk. Jeffrey Epstein has been an
investment advisor for numerous high net worth clients and also a personal investor.
Jeffrey is very accessible and well known to the team. We have advised him on
investments as well as estate planning opportunities. Jeffrey has continues to be well
connected across business channels.

Epstein is well known to several JPM PS employees and senior management including
Jes Staley. Also. Mr. Epstein was convicted of a felony charge in 2008. Jes Staley
conferred with Stephen Cutler and the decision was made to keep Mr. Epstein as a PB
client. Mr. Epstein completed his sentence and embalm in 2010. The relationship has
been reviewed with senior management and compliance/legal on a few occasions over
the post year as news stories of Jeffrey's past are picked up. No new claims or stones
have surfaced recently.

Risk Updated History
Creation
Date
Entered by Updated
Risk
Previous
Risk
Comment
GCS Grid
Search Type Security Service Details Further Review Required
Company Information Information confirmed; details included in
the attachment.
No
Corporate Records Information confirmed: details included in
the attachment.
No
Other Database Searches
(RDC/MtS/Factiva)
No records were found. No
Internal Database Search (CSSS/FPS) Internal database search revealed prior
GS8I research for Harry Boiler and nothing
derogatory to report.
No
State Court Searches No records were found. No
Federal Court Searches No records were found. No
Personal Particulars Information confirmed; details included in
the attachment.
No
Publications Publications revealed nothing derogatory. No
Regulatory Sanctions No records were found. No
OFAC/Control List Search A search of OFAC did not reveal any
matches
No
Negative cc Inconsistent Information No
Banker Attestation Details
As the client sponsor, I understand that I am primarily
responsible for protecting the fine's reputation from
inappropriate business relationships, as well as from fraud
and money laundering. By approving this KYC, I am
sponsoring this client as to their character and reputation
and from a I • eta - • ulat• stand• • Int.
Please state your rationale for conducting business with this
client
Comments
We are exiting HBRK and the Epstein relationship.
Confidential Treatment Requested by
JPMorgan Chase
CONFIDENTIAL
JPM-SDNY-00002828
╔══════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 bgC3 [tech] renamed "Bill Gates Ventures" in 2018 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01106135 (Jmail)
 [legal] Bill Gates gives Epstein power to negotiate on behalf of Boris Nikolic
EFTA01107738 (Jmail)
 [misc] creation of Cantor Urramoor Asset Management with Mr. T's (Prince Andrew?) Urramoor and Howard Lutnick's Cantor Fitzgerald
(inferred date: 2013-08-29)
Term Sheet (8/29/13 Preliminary Draft for Discussion Purposes Only)
CONFIDENTIAL
TERM SHEET
This term sheet summarizes certain key concepts regarding a joint venture to create an asset
management business to be known as Cantor Urramoor Asset Management.
Organization: Cantor Urramoor Asset Management (the "Company").
Partners A) Cantor Urramoor Asset Management Holdings, LLC ("Cantor
Holdings"), a wholly owned subsidiary of Cantor Fitzgerald,

B) [Urramoor], an entity owned by a trust created by Mr. T.
("Urramoor" and collectively with Cantor Holdings, the "Partners").
Management. Cantor Holdings would be the manager of the Company.
Purpose of .Joint Venture: The purpose of the joint venture would be to create an asset
management business. The Company would seek to earn management
and incentive fees from managing investments. The Company may
also pursue other business opportunities agreed by the manager.
Regulatory Matters: The Company would seek appropriate licenses and registrations to
conduct its business in the relevant jurisdictions.
Subcontracting to Affiliates: The Company would be permitted to engage affiliates of Cantor as
subcontractor to perform certain services such as brokerage,
investment banking, subadvisory and asset management services.
Loan:
Exclusivity Agreements:
Simultaneous with the formation of the Company and the Exclusivity
Agreements, the Company would advance the sum of £1,000,000 to
Urramoor which would accrue interest at an annual rate of 3.5%,
compounded annually. Any distributions by the Company to
Urramoor would be applied to the repayment of the balance.

Mr. T would refer all business opportunities (including his affiliates'
business opportunities) to the Company, and would not directly or
indirectly engage in any activity that the Company could not. Mr T.
would assign any remuneration, ownership or control rights relating
to any outside business activity to the Company. Any distributions of
income to Urramoor would be conditioned on Urramoor and Mr. T's
compliance with exclusivity obligations.
Capital Commitment: The Partners would not be required to make a capital commitment to
the Company, provided that Cantor would make a capital contribution
to the Company in an amount necessary to fund the Loan.
Distributions: Distributions of operating income would be made if and when
determined by the manager.
Term of the Joint Venture: Ten (10) years, subject to automatic successive [annual] renewals
unless either partner notifies the other of non-renewal prior to the
renewal date.
Support Services:
Confidentiality:
The Company may engage Cantor (or its applicable affiliate) to
provide support services to the Company at 110% of fully allocated
cost, including without limitation, finance, accounting and human
resources.
Neither party hereto shall issue or authorize the issuance of any news
release or other public statement or communication pertaining to this
Preliminary Term Sheet or the contemplated transaction without the
prior written consent of the other parties hereto, except as required by
applicable law or regulation.
Sovereign Immunity Mr T and T Limited etc will execute all appropriate waivers of
immunity.
This term sheet is for discussion purposes only. It is not a commitment to form the Company, either
express or implied, does not impose any obligation or liability on any person, and does not constitute
an offer of securities.
2
EFTA01500597 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2013-08-30)
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC
JPMorgan Classic Business Checking
Checking Account Summary Instances Amount
Beginning Balance 0.00
Deposits & Credits 1 500,000.00
Payments & Transfers 1 (18,580.00)
Ending Balance 2 $481,420.00
Deposits & Credits
Primary Account:
For the Period 8/1/13 to 8/30/13
Date Description
08/27 Internal Transfer of Funds As Requested
Amount
500,000 00
Total Deposits & Credits
Payments & Transfers
$500,000.00
Date Description
08/27 08/27 Fedwire Debit Via: Signature Ban NC: Marks Paneth And Shron Llp Account Ref. Invoice 368394 !mad:
0827B1Qgc08C005288 Tm: 1219700239 s
Amount
18.580.00
Total Payments & Transfers
Daily Ending Balance
($18,580.00)
Date
08/27
Amount

J. P. Morgan Confidential Treatment Requested by JPMorgan
Chase
CONFIDENTIAL
481,420 00
Page 3 of 6
JPM-SDNY-00024684
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                    Fred Haddad [lawyer] co-founder of Heck's in West Virginia 
 Tonja Haddad Coleman [lawyer] civil attorney Epstein v. Scott Rothstein, Brad Edwards, & L.M. 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00598330 (Jmail)
 [legal] Epstein v. Scott Rothstein, Brad Edwards, & L.M.: Motion To Preclude At Trial The Use Of The Following Items
╔══════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ekaterina Norton [russian girl] 27 year old Russian banker at UBS 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01091381 (Jmail)
 [resumé] professional resumé of Ekaterina Norton
(inferred date: 2013-10-29)
Ekaterina Norton
Email address:
Cell:

Work experience:

October 2013-Present - Associate Director in the Leveraged Capital Markets Group at UBS Investment
Banking Department in New York, US
Focus on leveraged loan and high yield bond issuers within the Technology, Media & Telecommunications
industry in the US and globally.
Successfully completed Series 7, 63 and 79 examinations.

July 2013-October 2013 - Associate in the Leveraged Finance & Financial Sponsors Group at UBS Investment
Banking Department in London, UK
Role involved constant interaction with various IBD teams across EMEA and the US, ongoing coverage of both
internal and external clients as well as nurturing strong analytical, technical skills and markets knowledge

July 2010-July 2013 - Analyst in the Leveraged Finance & Financial Sponsors Group at UBS Investment
Banking Department in London, UK
Completed Graduate Training Programme enhancing modelling, valuation and communication skills.
Successfully completed FSA examinations.

Summer 2009 — UBS Investment Banking Summer Internship in the Utilities team in London, UK
September 2008 — Member of the team of four who reached Finals at the Merrill Lynch Challenge (real-time
equities trading game), London, UK

Easter 2008 — Goldman Sachs Operations, Technology & Finance Spring Insight Programme, London, UK

Summer 2005 — Ernst & Young work-shadowing experience in Moscow, Russia

Education:

2007 — 2010 — BSc (Ions) Economics at the University of Warwick, United Kingdom
Bachelor of Science Honours - First Class 1:1

2007/08 — Russia Undergraduate Award Scholarship winner

2005 — 2007 — "A" levels at the Anglo-Russian School, Moscow, Russia.
Awarded "Best in Economics". Economics A2 level - "A" (As level — 297/300 marks)
Government & Politics As - "A" (300/300 marks), Mathematics A2 level - "A", Russian A2
level — "A", English Language As level — "B"

1997 — 2007 — Grammar School 1520, Moscow, Russia: Russian Certificate of Complete Secondary
Education —5/5 and a Gold medal for exceptional academic achievements

1997 — 2007 — Art School Diploma, Krasnopresnenskaya Art School, Moscow, Russia
Other skills and achievements;

2009/10 — Orientation Helper at the Orientation program for international students at the University of Warwick

2008/09 — Member of the University of Warwick's Economics Society Board — Mentor Scheme Coordinator

2008/09 - Co-founder and Secretary of the Warwick Alternative Investments and Private Equity Society

2007/08 — AIESEC Warwick (Association Internationale des Etudiants en Sciences Economiques et
Commerciales) awarded pro-active delegate award at the UK AIESEC 2007 conference

Languages:
Russian (native), English (fluent)
╔════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Mary E. Erdoes [bank] CEO of Wealth Management at JP Morgan 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01480690 (Jmail)
 [money] JP Morgan Know Your Customer information
(approximate date: 2013-11-01)
What is the clients current position? (Include any former
positions, if significant to source of wealth)

Jeffrey Epstein (SSN: 090.44.3348 Dail: 01120/1953 US Citizen)
is an existing client of PB. He is an active brokerage client across
asset classes cunently covered by the Firm'sCIOdesk Jeffrey
Epstein has been an investment advisor for numerous high net
worth clients and abso a personal invested. Jeffrey is very
.iccnssiblo and well known to the team. Wo have advised him on
an estments as well as estate planning opportunities. Jeffrey has
continues to be well connected across business channels. Epstein
began his financial career in 1976 as an options trader at Bear
Steams. He specialized in mathematical models such as the
Black-Scholes oplenpncing model and later worked in the
special products division, advising high not worth dents on tax
strategies. In 1980. Epstein became a 'Danner at Bear Stearns. In

1982. Epstein founded ha own financial management firm. J.
Epstein 8 Co.. managing the assets of clients with more than a
billion in net worth. In 1987. Leslie Wexner. founder and chairman
of the Columbus, Ohio-based Limited chain of womeifselothing
stores became a well-known client. In 1996. Epstein changed the
name of his firm to The Financial Trust Company and based it in
the US Virgin Islands.

Epstein is well known to several JPM PB employees and senior
management ado:ling Jes Staley. Also, Mr. Epstein was
convicted of a felony charge in 2008. Jos Staley conferred with
Stephen Culler and the decision was made to keep Mr. Epstein as
a PB client. Mr. Epstein completed his sentence and probation ii
2010. The relationship has boon reviewed with senior
management and corriphinotulegal on a few occasions over the
post year as news stores of Jeffrey's past are picked up. No new
claims or stories have surfaced recently.

List the number of years in current position. (Include any
former positions, If significant to source of wealth)
. 20

Approximate yearly income/salaryltionusIdistribution and
other compensation history (accumulated earned Income)
. 5000000

Which country(Ies) 1st a reithe Client's primary Source of
Wealth or Income derived?
UNITED STATES

Total Net Worth $ 500000000.00
What was the total net worth based on?
Financial Statements

Business Case

Please specify why you are comfortable with this client given
the Identified risk factor(s). Your answer is your "business
case" and should detail all mitigating factors.

Jeffrey Epstein was asked to exit the firm in August of 2013. The
accounts are in the process of moving to another bank and should
be closed out by yearend.

Provide client historyidetail, including when the relationship
was established, how it came to be in PB/PWM. clients
association with other JPM LOBS, etc.
Jeffrey established his relationship with the bank over 10 years ago.

Client known to whom (JPMorgan employees), how well, and how long:
Known to Mary Erdoes, John Duffy, and others in senior management.

Overall PB/PWM relationship size and type of accounts:
Brokerage and deposit accounts. The ielationshp was around
$200MM but is much reduced as its in the process of leaving the firm.

Is this a shared client, what other LOB has a relationship with
the client? Provide relationship manager name (if known),
o tient of other LOB since (date), and relationship size?
No

When was the last time you met the client? What was the
reason for the meeting?
June 2013

Describe any significant changes in the client's information
or material events that may have occurred over the last year
(Examples: address changes, change In authorized persons
on accounts, change in account type, change in business,
change in net worth. etc.).
Jeffrey Epstein was asked to exit the firm in August of 2013. The
accounts are in the process of moving to another bank and should
be closed out by yearend.

Cash Activity: Summarize client cash activity during the
period reviewed and explain the purpose f use of the funds:
Cash activity is declining as the accounts are leaving for Deutsche
Bank.

Wire Activity: Summarize client wire activity during the
period reviewed and explain the purpose I use of the funds,
Including any International/cross border wires:
Wire activity is declining as the accounts aro leaving for Deutsche Bank.

Before answering the following question please review the
Annual Account History Activity Summary Report that has
been attached in the Summary tab. Did the actual transaction
activity appear reasonable, normal, and expected for the type
of business or industry In which the client engages?
Yes

Was the nature, value, and volume of actual tr a n saction
activity consistent with expected transaction activity?
Yes

Was any unusual or potentially suspicious transaction
activity detected?
No

Additional Comments N/A

Expected Activity
Deposit Account(s)

Transaction Types Expected Activity Levels Anticipated Dollar Amount Totals per Month
Cash Deposits Low (1.10) <$10,000
Cash VVehdrevrals Low (1.10) <$10000
Check Deposits Low (1-10) <$10,000
Checks Paid Low 0401 <$10,000
Incoming Wires (Domestic)

Confidential Treatment Requested by JPMorgan Chase
CONFIDENTIAL
JPM-SDNY-00002904
╔════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 FCPA [government] Foreign Corrupt Practices Act 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01141453 (Jmail)
 [misc] referral agreement between Mr. T's (Prince Andrew?) Urramoor and Howard Lutnick's Cantor Fitzgerald
(inferred date: 2013-11-29)
AGREEMENT FOR REFERRALS
This AGREEMENT FOR REFERRALS (the "Agreement") is made and entered into as of the day of
November, 2013, between: Cantor Opportunities, LLC, a [limited liability company organized under the laws of
] whose office is located at 110 East 59th Street, New York, NY 10022 ("Cantor") and Urramoor Limited'
("UML") a [private limited company organized under the laws of the United Kingdom whose registered office is
located at [ 17 Albermarle Street, London, United Kingdom W IS 4HP ]
WHEREAS, UML has relationships with certain organizations and individuals including asset management firms,
sovereign wealth funds, institutional investors, and high net worth individuals or family offices that may benefit
from services provided by affiliates of Cantor (each, a "Cantor Company") or by third parties introduced by Cantor,
and is willing to arrange for introductions to Cantor for referral by Cantor of such persons to the appropriate third
party or Cantor affiliate, where requested by Cantor for certain asset management opportunities; and
WHEREAS, Cantor is a subsidiary of Cantor Fitzgerald, L.P. which is the holding company for a diverse
organization that includes subsidiaries and affiliates that are involved in various financial services and real estate
activities;
WHEREAS, the parties wish to provide for a framework by which UML may introduce potential clients to Cantor
for referral to the appropriate third party or Cantor affiliate, and receive a portion of Cantor's referral fee as
compensation for such referral, where permitted by applicable law;
NOW THEREFORE, in consideration of the foregoing premises and the mutual covenants herein contained the
parties do hereby agree as follows:

A. Sat
I. During the term hereof, in the event that UML identifies a third party with which it has a preexisting
relationship which it believes may be interested in pursuing an Asset Management Opportunity with a Cantor
Company or a third party referred by Cantor, UML may choose to refer such third party to Cantor. "Asset
Management Opportunities" is defined on Exhibit A hereto, which may be amended in writing by the parties
from time to time.

2. If Cantor in its sole discretion authorizes UML in writing to arrange an introduction to Cantor or a CF Company
and UML arranges such in•petson introduction which takes place, then following such introduction such
potential client shall be considered an "Introduced Client". If such in person meeting leads to Cantor receiving a
referral fee from the third party or such Cantor Company with respect to an Asset Management Opportunity (a
"Client Agreements), such Introduced Client shall be considered an Authorized Client for purposes of this
Agreement. Cantor (or such CF Company, as the case may be) shall have the right, in its sole discretion, to
reject any potential client proposed by UML. If any potential client is accepted by Cantor or such CF
Company as a client of Cantor or such CF Company, such acceptance may be on such terms as Cantor or
such CF Company determines in its sole discretion. Cantor may require UML and such CF Company to enter
into an appropriate agreement in a fonn determined by Cantor or such CF Company including in order to
comply with applicable laws or regulations (e.g. cash solicitation rule pursuant to the Investment Adviser's Act).

3. UML shall act as an independent third party and not as agent of Cantor or any CF Company. Nothing in this
agreement shall be construed or interpreted to create a partnership or joint venture. UML's referral services
hereunder or pursuant to any relationship with a CF Company shall be as a nonexclusive service provider
and UML hereby agrees to act in such capacity. In performing its services hereunder or pursuant to an
agreement with a CF Company, UML and its Representatives will have no authority to bind Cantor or any
Cantor Company in any way and will make no representations to prospective clients or other persons, or
distribute any written materials, relating to Cantor or its affiliates other than as directed by Cantor or such CF
Company from time to time. Cantor may assign third parties to transact and/or to settle any transactions
contemplated by this Agreement.
Page I 1
67891 v

4. UML may perform ongoing client communications and relationship duties with respect to Authorized
Clients as assigned by Cantor. However, UML may not engage in any activity for which a license or
authorization is required in any jurisdiction (including but not limited to broker-dealer activity,
investment advisory services, real estate or mortgage brokerage services) without obtaining the
appropriate license or registration. For the avoidance of doubt, the parties do not intend that UML will
engage in soliciting investments or engaging in broker-dealer, investment adviser, real estate broker or
mortgage broker activity, and shall not be actively promoting investments or asset management
opportunities unless it is appropriate licensed and the parties agree in writing as to the performance by
UML of such activities.

B. Compensation and Expenses.

I. In consideration for the referral activities of UML with respect to Authorized Clients, UML's compensation
for referral fees received by Cantor from each Authorized Client will be as set forth on Exhibit B hereto
("Compensation Structure") or as otherwise set forth in an agreement between the applicable Cantor
Company and UML.

2. Each of UML and Cantor shall be responsible for its own expenses in connection with the operation of
their respective businesses and the negotiation, preparation and consummation of this Agi t.

C. UML's Obligations and Covenants. UML covenants and agrees (on behalf of itself and its affiliates, officers,
directors, investors, equity owners, employees and agents (including but not limited to David Stern and UML's
ultimate beneficial owners) (collectively, "Representatives")) as follows:

I. It will not prepare or distribute any marketing materials or make any representations or disclose information
relating to Cantor or its affiliates without the prior written consent of Cantor. Moreover, it will not use the name of
Cantor or any of Cantor's affiliates or represent its relationship with Cantor other than in the manner
contemplated by this Agreement. Unless the parties mutually agree otherwise, UML's only services shall be to
provide Cantor and any applicable CF Company with introductions to non-US persons, individuals, or entities,
and ongoing client duties assigned to UML.

2. No Introduced Client shall be a "U.S. Person" as defined by the Securities Act of 1933, as amended,
("Securities Act"), the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended (the "Exchange Act"), or any rules and
regulations promulgated under either such act
3. It shall keep confidential any information it may acquire as a result of the activities contemplated by this
Agreement or otherwise regarding the business and affairs of Cantor or its affiliates, including any CF Company
("Confidential Information"), and shall not use such Confidential Information other than in connection
with the services provided hereunder, which obligations shall survive the termination of this ALamment. The
Confidential Information provided may be disclosed only to such Representatives of UML that have
actual need in furtherance of any Services. It shall inform each of its Representatives receiving the
Confidential Information of the confidential nature of the Confidential Information and direct such
Representatives to treat the Confidential Information confidentially in accordance with each of the
terms and conditions of this agreement ("Agreement") and not to use it other than solely in connection
with the Evaluation, and it shall be responsible for any use of the Confidential Information by its
Representatives inconsistent with this Agreement. The Confidential Information provided may be
disclosed only to such Representatives of UML that have actual need in furtherance of any services
provided hereunder. Without the prior written consent of Cantor and subject to the other provisions of
this Agreement, UML will not, and will direct its Representatives not to, disclose to any third person
any Confidential Information that has been made available from Cantor, or that such discussion
concerning a possible Project are taking place or any other facts with respect to such discussion or such
Confidential Information. At the written request of Cantor, it will immediately destroy or return to
Cantor all copies of all written Confidential Information which has been provided to it or its
Representatives including, but not limited to, written summaries of any oral analyses, compilations,
Page I 2
67891 vl
studies or other documents prepared by UML or its Representatives. It will promptly notify Cantor in
writing if any information comes to the attention of it or any of its Representatives working on the
Project, which information may indicate there was or is likely to be a loss of confidentiality of any
portion of Confidential Information. It shall use reasonable efforts to retrieve the lost or wrongfully
disclosed Confidential Information and to prevent further unauthorized disclosure or loss of any
Confidential Information. Notwithstanding the foregoing, it is understood that when known or
available in the trade or otherwise in the public domain, through no act or failure to act by UML or its
Representative(s), or if previously and lawfully known to such party from third parties not under any
obligation of confidentiality or secrecy to Cantor, such information will not be deemed to be
Confidential Information subject hereto.

4. It agrees to perform its obligations under this Agreement diligently and in compliance with all US and foreign laws,
rules, regulations and registrations, including rules and regulations imposed by any U.S. or foreign regulatory or self-
regulatory authority, that are applicable to its activities hereunder, and the laws of the United Kingdom (collectively,
"Laws and Regulations"), and shall ensure that its officers, directors, equity owners, employees and affiliates
comply with Laws and Regulations and the terms of this Agreement UML shall not be entitled to delegate or
subcontract or assign any of its obligations under this Aglwhuit.

5. Except with the prior written consent of Cantor, during the term hereof, none of UML, nor UML's
Representatives, shall directly or indirectly (whether on its own or in conjunction with another person):

(i) solicit or refer potential clients for Asset Management Services to any person other than Cantor or a
Cantor Company, (ii) become engaged in any capacity with atIother entity where the relationship contemplated in
this Agreement with Cantor is in conflict, or (iii) receive compensation from any of the Authorized Clients in
connection with the services provided by Cantor or the applicable third party. During the term hereof and following
the termination of this Agreement, none of UML nor UML's Representatives, shall solicit any clients of Cantor or its
subsidiaries or affiliates with respect to Asset Management Services or induce or encourage such clients to terminate
or reduce their business with Cantor or its subsidiaries or affiliates in any way, or interfere with or damage (or 
attempt
to interfere with or damage) any relationship between Cantor or a Cantor Company and a client UML shall and shall
ensure that its Representatives assign any remuneration, ownership or control rights relating to any such
activity in conflict with the foregoing, to Cantor to the extent necessary to put Cantor in the same
position as if such Representatives and each of their respective related enterprises were subject to this
Agreement.

6. UML shall indemnify and hold Cantor harmless from any direct losses, claims, damages, expenses or other liabilities
(including but not limited to reasonable attorneys' fax and other costs reasonably incurred by Cantor in connection
with any actual or threatened proceeding) in relation to (i) any misstatement or inaccurate or misleading information
provided by UML or its officers, directors, equity owners, employees, agents or affiliates to a piuµttive or actual
client that is not authorized by Cantor, (ii) any violation of Laws and Regulations. (iii) any fraud, willful default,
dishonesty or negligence, and (iv) any breach of this Agreement.

7. UML acknowledges on behalf of itself and its Representatives that the obligations in this section of the Agreement
are reasonable restrictions and are an important factor to the success of the transactions contemplated by this
Agronotot

D. UML's Representations and Warranties. UML represents and warrants to and for the benefit of Cantor and its
affiliates as follows:

1. UML is, and throughout the term hereof will be, a non-"U.S. Person" as defined by the Securities Act, the
Exchange Act and the rules and regulations promulgated pursuant to those as

2. UML is, and throughout the term hereof will remain, in compliance with all rules and regulations imposed or
promulgated by any U.S. or foreign regulatory or self-regulatory authority to which UML is subject. None of
UML nor any of its Representatives are required under U.S. law to register with the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission as a broker/dealer, nor are required under the laws of the United Kingdom or any other
jurisdiction to make any registration or obtain any license in ordcr to conduct the activities contemplated by this
Agreement
Page I3
67891

3. Neither the execution and delivery of this Agreement nor the fidfillment of the terms set forth herein will
constitute a breach of, or default under, any instrument by which UML is bound or, to UML's knowledge,
any order, rule or regulation applicable to UML of any court, or any U.S. or foreign governmental body,
regulatory or self-regulatory authority or administrative agency having jurisdiction over UML. Neither UML nor
its Representatives has been subject to any material administrative, civil or criminal action.

4. UML agrees to notify Cantor promptly if any change occurs which would make the foregoing representations
inaccurate or incomplete.

E. Anti -Bribery /Foreign Corrupt Practices Act
I. UML agrees it shall comply and cause its Representatives to comply with anti-bribery laws and
regulations applicable to it or Cantor which include, but are not limited to, the Foreign Corrupt
Practices Act and the U.K. Bribery Act.

2. UML (nor any Representative) has not and will not pay any compensation, fee or other form of
remuneration of any sort to any third party in connection with the performance of its services
hereunder and no part of its compensation hereunder will be shared with any third party who is not an
employee or executive officer of UML.

3. No payments of money, or anything of value, have been or will be offered, promised or paid, directly
or indirectly, and no officer, employee or agent of the UML has authority to offer, promise or pay, to
any foreign officials (as such term is defined in the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act of 1977, as
amended), political parties, party officials, candidates for public or political party office to influence
the acts of such officials in their official capacity or induce them to use their influence with a
government to obtain or retain business or gain an improper advantage in connection with the services
contemplated hereunder.

4. Cantor reserves the right to cease to deal with the UML and to terminate this Agreement (and any
agreement with a CF Company) immediately including any right to compensation should UML fail to
comply with its obligations under this section.

F. 'Fern' and Termination
I. This term of this agreement shall be five (5) years from the date hereof and shall automatically renew
for successive one-year terms unless either party provides notice of termination at least one (I) year
period prior to the end of such five year or such one-year period. Sections [C, D, E, F and GI shall survive
the termination of this Agreement. Termination by Cantor of this agreement shall result in automatic termination of
all agreements between a CF Company and UML unless otherwise specified by Cantor.

2. Notwithstanding the foregoing, this Agreement (and any agreement between a CF Company and UML) may be
terminated immediately in the event of any material breach of the terms of this Agt Liztent, upon written notice by
the non-breaching party to the other party.

3. Except in the case of termination for material breach or as otherwise set forth in the applicable agreement with the 
CF
Company, UML will be entitled to receive due payment with respect to referral fees received by Cantor from
Authorized Clients within one year following termination.

G. Miscellaneous.

I . This Agreement including Exhibits A and B contains the entire understanding of the parties with
respect to the matters contemplated hereby. This Agreement is for the sole benefit of the parties
hereto and the affiliates of Cantor, and no other person shall have any right, benefit or interest
under or because of this Agreement, except as specifically provided herein.
Page I4
67891 v

2. All notices and other communications hereunder shall be in writing and shall be deemed to have been duly
given if mailed or transmitted by any standard form of telecommunication to the parties at the addresses
set forth at the end of this Agreement or to such other address as may be furnished by any party to the
others in writing. Cantor may provide notices hereunder to the following email address ( ® )
or such other address as maybe furnished by UML.

3. UML shall not disparage in any way Cantor and shall not during the term of this agreement or
thereafter, contact, respond to any request from, or in any way discuss Cantor or its affiliates with
the media (electronic, print, radio, television or otherwise).

4. UML shall not assign this agreement in whole or in part without the prior written consent of
Cantor. Cantor may assign this agreement including but not limited to an affiliate.

5. UML acknowledges that any breach or violation of this Agreement cannot be sufficiently
remedied by money damages alone and, accordingly, Cantor will be entitled, in addition to
damages and any other remedies provided by law, to specific performance, injunctive and other
equitable relief respecting any such violation. In addition, in the event of any violation of this
Agreement, UML shall reimburse Cantor for all costs and expenses, including reasonable
attorneys' fees, incurred in order to enforce the provisions of this Agreement or exercise any
remedies for a violation thereof.

6. If any of the obligations of UML and its Representatives herein are finally held to be invalid,
illegal or unenforceable (whether in whole or in part), such obligation shall be deemed modified
(or the scope thereof reduced) to the extent, but only to the extent, of such invalidity, illegality or
unenforceability and the remaining such obligations shall not be affected thereby

7. This Agreement may be executed by facsimile and .pdf and in counterparts, each of which shall be
deemed an original and all of which when taken together shall constitute but one and the same
instrument.

8. The Section headings in this Agreement have been inserted as a matter of convenience of reference and are
not a part of this Agreement
Page I 5
67891 v

9. THIS AGREEMENT WILL BE GOVERNED BY AND CONSTRUED IN ACCORDANCE
WITH THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, WITHOUT GIVING EFFECT TO THE
PRINCIPLES OF CONFLICT OF LAWS THEREOF. ANY DISPUTE BETWEEN US
ARISING OUT OF OR RELATING TO THIS AGREEMENT SHALL BE HEARD
EXCLUSIVELY IN COURTS LOCATED IN THE CITY AND STATE OF NEW YORK. THIS
AGREEMENT MAY BE EXECUTED IN MULTIPLE COUNTERPARTS, EACH OF WHICH
SHALL CONSTITUTE AN ORIGINAL, BUT ALL OF WHICH SHALL CONSTITUTE ONE
AGREEMENT. THIS AGREEMENT MAY NOT BE MODIFIED EXCEPT BY A WRITING
SIGNED BY BOTH PARTIES. UML HEREBY IRREVOCABLY SUBMITS TO THE
EXCLUSIVE JURISDICTION OF THE COURTS OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK AND/OR
THE COURTS OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA IN THE STATE OF NEW YORK
FOR PURPOSES OF ANY SUIT, ACTION OR PROCEEDING ARISING OUT OF OR
RELATED TO THIS AGREEMENT. UML IRREVOCABLY WAIVES, TO THE FULLEST
EXTENT PERMITTED BY LAW, AN OBJECTION WHICH IT MAY NOW OR HEREAFTER
HAVE TO THE LAYING OF VENUE OF ANY SUIT, ACTION OR PROCEEDING
BROUGHT IN SUCH A COURT AND ANY CLAIM THAT SUCH SUIT ACTION OR
PROCEEDING BROUGHT IN SUCH A COURT HAS BEEN BROUGHT IN AN
INCONVENIENT FORUM.

Please sign in the space provided below and return an executed original of this Agreement to the undersigned to 
acknowledge
your agreement to the terms contained herein.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this agreement on this, the day of November,
2013.
[UML]. Cantor Opportunities, LLC
By:   By:
Name: Name:
Title: Title:
Address: 110 East 59th Street, New York, NY 10022
JOINDER:
The undersigned hereby acknowledges that it has received
and reviewed a complete copy of this Agreement, and
agrees that he shall be fully bound by and subject to all of
the covenants, terms and conditions of the Agreement as a
Representative of UMLAcknowledged and Agreed, as a
Representative of UML
David Stern
Address:
[Signature page to Agreement between UML and Cantor Opportunities, LLC dated as of 2013]
Page I 6
67891 "I
EXHIBIT A
ASSET MANAGEMENT OPPORTUNITIES
"Asset Management Opportunities" shall include the following:

I) Real estate related equity or debt investments (including securities, loans and derivative products) relating to U.S.
real
estate;

2) Mortgage loans related to U.S. real estate;
3) Purchases, sales or equity invi-sh Halts in U.S. real estate projects;

4) Other investment opportunities related to U.S. real estate;
5) Co-investment with Cantor in private equitylventure capital opportunities;

6) Investment in funds or separate account managed by a registered investment advisor such as Cantor Comparative
Advantage, L.P.;

7) Index fund related investment management or managed account relationships.

[Exhibit A to Agreement between UML and Cantor Opportunities. LLC dated as of November [ ], 2013]
Page I 7
67891 "I
EXHIBIT B
COMPENSATION STRUCTURE
UML would receive a share of the referral fee received by Cantor for each Asset Management Opportunity related to an
Authorized Client. In the case where Cantor refers an Authorized Client to an Asset Management Opportunity in which such
Authorized Client makes a commercial mortgage loan to a purchase of real property, a typical referral fee to Cantor 
would be
25% of the lender's fee paid from the borrower/purchaser to the lender, which lender's fee for example may be I% of the
principal amount of the loan. Such referral fee to Cantor would be split 50/50 with UML.
[Exhibit B to Agreement between UML and Cantor Opportunities, LLC, dated as of , 2013]
Page I 8
67891 v
EFTA00008008 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                Austin Hill [crypto] Blockstream co-founder with Adam Back, Brudder Ventures 
 iCog Labs [tech] AI co. in Addis Ababa founded by Ben Goertzel and Getnet Assefa Gesaw (funded by Epstein?) 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01103465 (Jmail)
 [misc] Ben Goertzel funding proposal for AI labs in Africa etc.
(date: 2013-12-02)
Jeffrey Epstein IV Foundation
AGI Initiative
R&D Funding Proposal
Ben Goertzel
December 2, 2013
Executive Summary
This proposal outlines a research initiative aimed at creating human -level, generally-intelligent thinking ma-
chines within an 8 year period.
During the last few decades, the Al field has wandered from its initial focus on human-like general intelligence,
and has devoted nearly all its attention to the creation of highly specialized, task-specific AI. While this focus on
"narrow Al" has borne impressive fruit, the time has come to redirect attention toward the field's original goals. Given
recent advances in computing hardware and algorithms, cognitive science and neuroscience, the goal of building
powerful Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) is far more achievable now than in the 1950s when the AI field was
founded.
In the proposed research, we will create a general-purpose cognitive engine, and demonstrate and test it on tasks
from a number of domains:

• Intelligently controlling animated characters in a 3D video game style world
• Controlling humanoid and wheeled robots in an indoor physical environment

• Engaging in natural language dialogue utilizing information on the Web
• Analyzing genomics datasets relating to the longevity of various organisms
• Automated program learning and theorem proving
From a narrow AI perspective, these endeavors might seem to have little in common — but from an AGI perspective
they are fairly similar, as they all all require general intellectual abilities such as those found in the human brain.
Of course, like all revolutionary scientific advances, once advanced AGI has been achieved it will have a wealth
of practical applications. The five areas mentioned above are only examples, which we have chosen largely due to our
own prior experience applying Al in those domains.
Creating something as complex as a human-level mind requires a comprehensive, coherent design based on sound
science and engineering principles. This is something that did not exist in the early decades of the Al field, when
scientists greatly underestimated the problem. But we have learned that lesson, and we have completed a full design,
which we call the CogPrime AGI Design.
CogPrime is a high level design for a human-level AGI system. It leaves many medium and lower level algo-
rithmic and implementation problems open; but it gives a clear, coherent conceptual and software framework for AGI
engineering, detailed design and experimentation. For a detailed description and an explanation of why we believe
the CogPrime AGI Design has the capability to create true general intelligence, we refer the reader to the overview
available at http : / / wi k i . opencog . ors . / w /CogP ime_Overview. For a more complete and fully technical
description, we refer to the books Engineering General Intelligence Vol. 1 and 2, by Ben Goertzel, Cassio Pennachin
and Nil Geisweiller, to be released in December 2013.
We project that this project can be completed in an eight year period, by a team of 80 scientists and engineers,
with a budget of USS80 million. This cost could be reduced by a factor of 3.4 via offshoring some of the R&D.
In the first five years of the project, we will develop a thinking machine with the general intelligence of a 3 to 5
year old child, and highly powerful, practically useful capabilities in the areas of natural language dialogue, game Al,
toy robotics, computer algorithm design, theorem-proving and genomic data analysis. In the following three years,
we will give the thinking machine the ability to modify its own Al algorithms and to act independently as a research
scientist. It will also be able to control robots moving commonsensically through everyday human environments,
including attending and passing college classes.
Contents
1 Introduction 4
1.1 Why Now?  4
1.2 The CogPrime Design 5
1.3 Application Foci  6
1.4 Modular Design & Development  7
1.5 Open Source Development  8
1.6 Potential for Commercial Spin-offs 8
2 Incremental Development Milestones 9
2.1 Phase 1  9
2.2 Phase 2  14
3 Staffing and Costs 18
3.1 Advisors and Technical Leads  18
3.1.1 Technical Leads  18
3.1.2 Advisors  20
3.2 Estimated Costs  20
3.2.1 Lower-Cost Alternatives  21
4 Scientific and Technical Development 21
4.1 Integrated Cognition  21
4.1.1 Unified Rule Engine  22
4.1.2 Probabilistic Reasoning  22
4.1.3 Motivation and Emotion  22
4.1.4 Procedure Learning  22
4.1.5 Procedure Execution  23
4.1.6 Pattern Mining  23
4.1.7 Planning  23
4.1.8 Language Processing  23
4.1.9 Attention Allocation  23
4.1.10 Concept Formation  24
4.1.11 Perception  24
4.1.12 Action 24
4.2 Distributed and Multicore Processing Infrastructure 24
4.3 Sensation (Vision, Audition & Haptics)  25
4.4 Robot Movement Control  25
4.5 Game World Development  26
4.6 Genomics Data Analysis  26
4.7 Text, Image and Video Mining  27
4.8 Automated Programming  27
4.9 Automated Theorem Proving  28
4.10 Teaching and Intelligence Testing  29
4.11 Software Integration and Testing  29

1 Introduction
A best-selling book a few years ago claimed that "Al11 Really Need to Know I Learned in Kindergarten. - This maxim
has some truth in an AI context. Arguably, what current AI programs are lacking is the kind of commonsense that
every normal human toddler has. If one could create an AI with toddler-like common sense, alongside the specialized
calculating and problem-solving ability that today's intelligent software already displays, one would be well on the
way to creating software systems with general intelligence at the adult human level and beyond.
This is precisely the thrust of the present proposal. Leveraging a new Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) design
called CogPrime and an allied open source software system, OpenCog, we plan to begin by creating an AI software
system that

I. displays the commonsense knowledge and everyday creativity of a young human child, in the context of
controlling an animated character in a game world, and controlling a humanoid robot in an indoor environment
2. displays impressive practical prowess at a variety of intellectual tasks: algorithm design, geometric theorem -
proving, and genomic data analysis
This combination, in itself, will not constitute the "end game" of our AGI work. However, we believe this "Phase 1"
achievement will encapsulate solutions to the hardest problems in AGI design and engineering, and leave us poised
to take the next step — toward a "Phase 2" AGI system that possesses the general intelligence of a human adult,
enhanced by nonhuman calculational and problem -solving capabilities that digital computers bring. The Phase 2
system will be a genuine "AGI Scientist", which can self-modify and improve its own intelligence, alongside other
science and engineering capabilities
We propose that a "Phase 1" early-stage AGI system, displaying the dual capabilities described above as aspects
of its unified cognitive functionality, can be produced within 5 years at a rough cost of US$9 million per year.
Further, we propose that once Phase I has been achieved, Phase 2 can be accomplished within the same design and
software system, and will actually be a smaller leap: 3 further years of effort at the same rate.
1.1 Why Now?
Human -level general intelligence was, of course, the original focus of the founders of the AI field in the 1950s
and 60s. But the hardware, software and conceptual frameworks of that time were not adequate to the task, and in
subsequent decades the Al field shifted focus to narrower problems. Today, however, our hardware, software and
understanding have advanced considerably, so that human-level Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) is an initiative
whose time has finally come.
Today, task-specific narrow Al currently pervades nearly every area of industry, within various forms of back-
end software. It is also achieving an increasing public profile with achievements like self-driving cars, IBM Watson,
online recommendation systems and chatbots like Siri and Google Now (to name just a few). Complementarily,
neuroscience and cognitive science are providing us an ever-deeper understanding of the human brain and mind
each year.
While pursuit of human-level AGI was marginalized within AI academia during the 1980s and 90s, now it is
increasingly becoming accepted as a valuable R&D direction once again. We now have annual conferences on AGI,
Cognitive Systems and Biologically -Inspired Cognitive Architectures (BICA), and also an increasing number of
sessions related to human-level AGI and AI within AAAI, IJCAI, IEEE and other generic AI-oriented conferences.
Al visionary Ray Kurzweil has recently taken a position as a Director of Engineering at Google; and industry
luminaries like Intel CEO Justin Rattner now forecast the arrival of human-level AGI within decades.
The time is ripe for a serious frontal assault on the AGI problem. We have the tools and the knowledge; all that's
needed now is the courage and persistence to confront the problem head-on. AGI is not a trivial problem by any
means, combining as it does multidisciplinary R&D with large-scale software engineering. But given the technology
and science of 2013, human-level AGI is an eminently reasonable near-term development goal.
1.2 The CogPrime Design
To create something as complex as a human-level mind requires a comprehensive, coherent design based on sound
science and engineering principles. The foundation of the proposed research is the CogPrime AGI design, described
in the books Engineering General Intelligence Vol. I and 2, by Ben Goertzel, Cassio Pennachin and Nil Geisweiller,
published in December 2013 [10, 11].
CogPrime provides a high level design for a human-level AGI system. It leaves many medium and lower level
algorithmic and implementation problems open; but it gives a clear, coherent conceptual and software framework
for AGI engineering, detailed design and experimentation. Exposition of CogPrime and why we believe it has the
capability to yield human-level general intelligence would extend this proposal excessively, so we refer the reader to
the online CogPrime overview available at http : //wiki opencog org/w/CogPrime_Overview. There
have also been several academic conference papers published on CogPrime and its potential, most recently [8] pre-
sented at the 2013 IEEE Symposium on Hunan -Level AI, but the online article gives the clearest concise exposition
of the design at this stage.
The conceptual foundation of CogPrime is the "pattemist - theory of mind developed in Ben Goertzel's work
during the 1990s and elaborated at length in [5], which views an intelligent system as concerned with recognizing
patterns in itself and the world, focused substantially toward patterns regarding what actions will achieve its goals in
observed contexts. On a practical level, the high-level architecture of CogPrime involves the use of multiple cognitive
processes associated with multiple types of memory to enable an intelligent agent to execute the procedures that it
believes have the best probability of working toward its goals in its current context. In a robot preschool context,
for example, the top-level goals would be simple things such as pleasing the teacher, learning new information
and skills, and protecting the robot's body. Each of CogPrime's cognitive processes is biased to recognize particular
sorts of patterns, and the particular assemblage of cognitive processes is chosen based on a careful analysis of human
cognition, with input from neuroscience, linguistics, philosophy of mind, computer science and other disciplines as
well.
CogPrime's memory types are the declarative, procedural, sensory, and episodic memory types that are widely
discussed in cognitive neuroscience [18), plus attentional memory for allocating system resources generically, and
intentional memory for allocating system resources in a goal -directed way. Table 1 overviews these memory types,
giving key references and indicating the corresponding cognitive processes, and also crudely indicating which fun-
damental cognitive dynamics each cognitive process corresponds to (pattern creation, association, etc.).
The essence of the CogPrime design lies in the way the structures and processes associated with each type of
memory are designed to work together in a closely coupled way, yielding cooperative intelligence going beyond what
could be achieved by an architecture merely containing the same structures and processes in separate "black boxes:'
All OpenCog memory types are implemented using a common weighted, labeled hypergraph knowledge store called
the Atomspace; and all OpenCog cognitive processes are implemented as software objects called MindAgents, which
interact with the Atomspace.
The inter-cognitive-process interactions in OpenCog are designed so that

• conversion between different types of memory is possible, though sometimes computationally costly (e.g. an
item of declarative knowledge may with some effort be interpreted procedurally or episodically, etc.)
• when a learning process concerned centrally with one type of memory encounters a situation where it learns
very slowly, it can often resolve the issue by convening some of the relevant knowledge into a different type
of memory: i.e. cognitive synergy
Obviously this sort of high-level sketch merely serves to evoke the rough nature of the CogPrime system, and
the curious reader should peruse the above references to get a fuller picture.
The open source OpenCog software project (see opencog . org) provides a foundation designed explicitly for
the implementation of the CogPrime design, and currently contains partial implementations of many of the algo-
rithms constituting CogPrime. OpenCog has been used for commercial applications in the area of natural language
processing and data mining. It has also been used for research involving controlling virtual agents in virtual worlds,
and humanoid robots.
Memory Type Specific Cognitive Processes General Cognitive
Functions
Declarative
Probabilistic Logic Networks
(PLN) [4]; conceptual blending
[3]
pattern creation
Procedural
MOSES (a novel probabilistic
evolutionary program learning
algorithm) [16)
pattern creation
Episodic internal simulation engine [9] association, pattern
creation
Attentional Economic Attention Networks
(ECAN) [14]
association, credit
assignment
Intentional
probabilistic goal hierarchy
refined by PLN and ECAN,
structured according to
MicroPsi [2)
credit assignment,
pattern creation
Sensory Supplied by the DeSTIN
component
association,
attention
allocation, pattern
creation, credit
assignment [1)
Table 1: Memory Types and Cognitive Processes in CogPrime. The third column indicates the general cognitive
function that each specific cognitive process carries out, according to the patternist theory of cognition.
The present proposal is aimed at completing the detailed design and implementation of the CogPrime AGI
architecture within the OpenCog framework.
1.3 Application Foci
It is important that an AGI system must do something even as its development proceeds; intelligence is centrally
about engagement in a variety of complex tasks in complex environments. But choice of any one specific application
runs the risk of overfitting the work to that application and ending up with a more specialized system than intended.
Hence we propose six different application foci, to be pursued concurrently using the same integrated intelligent
system:

I. Control of intelligent animated characters in a 3D "video game" style world
2. Control of (humanoid and wheeled) mobile robots in an indoor environment

3. Natural language dialogue in the context of information available on the Web
4. Analysis of genomics datasets related to longevity in various organisms

5. Automated program learning
6. Automated theorem proving
Each of these applications stresses different aspects of CogPrime and relates preferentially to different aspects
of human intelligence. Pursuing them concurrently with the same developing AGI system guarantees generality of
focus on the application level, alongside the generality of capability existing on the software level due to the nature
of the CogPrime design.
These applications have also been chosen because, with the exception of automated theorem proving, they are
all areas that have already been explored using the OpenCog system, either in commercial or prototype applications;
to wit:

I. Animated character control: In the period 2008-2013, a variety of research prototype systems have been
built using OpenCog to control virtual characters in virtual worlds [9]. Currently this initiative has research
funding from the Hong Kong government, aimed at creating a toolkit enabling OpenCog-controlled non-player
characters to be used in commercial games.

2. Mobile robot control: In 2009, at Xiamen University, a research project was conducted involving the use of
OpenCog to control a humanoid Nao robot [15] [13]. This work was documented in the award-winning film
Singularity or Bust, see http: //singularityorbust.com. Currently the Hong Kong government
is providing research funding aimed at extending this work via using OpenCog to control David Hanson's
Robokind humanoid robots, during 2014 and 2015.

3. Natural language dialogue: OpenCog's language processing tools have been used on the back end of several
practical applications, such as an online language-teaching site, and a US government information system
aimed at intelligence analysts. While these have not focused on dialogue, they have stressed most of the
same NLP components that will be used in dialogue. These language processing tools have also been used
in research together with the NIH on information extraction from PubMed abstracts [12]. A Hong Kong
government grant has been obtained to support extension of this work toward the creation of an OpenCog
dialogue system, in the specific context of a smartphone-based dialogue agent focused on media consumption.

4. Genomics data analysis: OpenCog tools, primarily MOSES but also PLN and clustering tools, have been
extensively used to analyze genomics data for commercial, government and academic customers. This has
led to various successes such as discovering the first genetic basis for Chronic Fatigue Syndrome (7], learning
highly accurate diagnostics for Alzheimers and Parkinson Disease [17], and understanding the means via
which calorie restriction impacts longevity [6].

5. Automated program learning: OpenCog's MOSES component, which performs automated program learn-
ing, has been used for numerous custom commercial data mining jobs (via the consulting firm Novamente
LLC), to learn small programs constituting patterns in data ranging from biology to finance to market research
and power transformer performance
1.4 Modular Design & Development
The CogPrime architecture is structurally modular but dynamically unified. This means that, from an engineering
perspective, it subdivides human-level AGI into a set of discrete modules. However, the intended intelligent oper-
ation of the whole system is dependent on synergetic interactions between the modules. Each module is intended
to display meaningful intelligent behaviors on its own but it's expected that these behaviors will be less scalable
and more narrowly-scoped, than the behaviors the same modules will display in the context of the overall integrated
CogPrime system.
The modular architecture of CogPrime naturally supports development by a distributed team of teams, with
teams focused on particular modules, teams focused on infrastructure tools useful across multiple modules, and
then a central integrative team focused on putting all the pieces together to achieve overall generally intelligent
behavior. While the module-specific teams may be purely research oriented, and the infrastructure teams may be
purely engineering oriented, the central integration team must combine research and engineering capabilities.
We propose that development be broken down according to the following teams, some of which correspond
specifically to application areas as outlined above, and some of which correspond to important support tasks:

I. Integrated Cognition
2. Distributed and Multicore Processing Infrastructure
3. Sensation (Vision, Audition & Haptics)

4. Robot Movement Control
5. Game World Development
6. Genomics Data Analysis
7. Text, Image and Video Mining
8. Automated Programming
9. Automated Theorem Proving
10. Teaching and Intelligence Testing
II. Software Integration and Testing
In Section 4 below we summarize the basic approaches and tasks we propose each team to undertake. While it would
be viable to colocate all the teams, it would also be viable to spread the teams among different locations based on the
existence of relevant expertise. Some of the larger teams could potentially be split among more than one location, in
themselves.
1.5 Open Source Development
The OpenCog system has been developed as an open source software platform since 2008, and we propose to
continue development of the CogPrime design in this vein. The advantage the OSS methodology presents is the
capability of leveraging dramatic additional intellectual and software development, debugging and testing resources,
via leveraging of the academic and OSS software development communities. On the software level, the advantages
of OSS for ensuring software robustness, scalability and stability are well known. On the intellectual level, there
are obviously very considerable benefits to be achieved via open involvement of the academic research world in the
ongoing improvement of various aspects of a human-level AGI system as it matures.
While a traditional business perspective would suggest that open sourcing the proposed software development
is a negative from the perspective of ultimate monetization of the results, this is not necessarily the case. There are
many viable, and potentially highly lucrative business models that the funders and developers of the proposed AGI
software could pursue, that would not be negatively impacted by the open source nature of the underlying software.
1.6 Potential for Commercial Spin-offs
The R&D project described here is proposed primarily for the transformative effect it would have upon science,
technology, society and the evolution of intelligence. However, as a side-effect, numerous possibilities will arise
along the way for leveraging the technology developed in various business domains. As AGI has the potential to
transform every single area of commerce, giving a comprehensive list here would not be viable. However, a few of
the possibilities closest to the specific AI applications to be pursued in the proposed work are:

• AGI non-player characters for video games, or (depending on the game design) AGI for controlling whole
game worlds. This could be provided as game-AGI middleware, or on a custom per-game basis in partnership
with game companies

• AGI toy robots, home service robots or elder care robots
• Combining game characters, robots and other possibilities, it would be viable to develop a cloud-based facility
for serving OpenCog based intelligence to various online software applications — e.g. games, robots, consumer
electronic devices, specialized information systems. The developers of the first generally intelligent OpenCog
system would obviously have a substantial "first-mover advantage" in setting up such a facility. And once
such a facility were operational, the cloud -resident AGI would gain dramatic knowledge from its customers
in the course of its operation, setting up an "increasing returns" dynamic that would make it very difficult
for competitors to catch up (similar to but quite likely more substantial than the increasing -returns based
advantages enjoyed by current firms such as Google and Facebook).

• A host of genomics-related biomedical opportunities, including
— Discovery of targets for pharmaceutical, nutraceutical and gene therapy interventions for age-associated
and other diseases.
— Integration of AGI software with rational drug design software to enable creation of novel molecules
targeting combinations of genes highlighted by AGI genomic/proteomic analysis.
— Predictive toxicology, to identify the human body's reactions to substances prior to their synthesis
— Integration of AGI with systems biology simulation software to enable simulation of organismic response
to therapies

• Conversational personal assistants — like Siri, but with genuine understanding of what they're talking about

• Conversational agents for helpdesk and customer support
By its very nature a general intelligence can be applied in multiple domains, for great benefit and also potentially
substantial financial profit. But first we must meet the challenge of creating a core of generally intelligent software,
which is the focus of the proposed R&D work.
2 Incremental Development Milestones
2.1 Phase 1
Here we list high-level development milestones in each of the identified application areas, year by year for Phase 1
of the proposed project. Much more detailed milestones will be established year by year as the work proceeds.
Year 1 Capability Milestone
Animated Agent Conception and execution of plans to achieve complex movement
and building tasks in blocks-focused game world
Mobile Robot

• Effective recognition of a closed class of objects and events
• Navigation in dynamic indoor environments
Dialogue System Simple dialogue about objects , events and goals in the game
world
Genomic Analysis Construction of an integrated Atomspace-based knowledge base
containing gene expression, SNP and protein-protein interaction
data, pathway and Gene Ontology data, and information extracted
from PubMed abstracts
Automated Pro-
gramming
MOSES -based learning of sorting and searching algorithms
Automated Theo-
rem Proving
Effective importation of Mizar formalized math database into
OpenCog knowledge representation
Year 2 Capability Milestone
Animated Agent

• Linguistic communication about needs and desires in game
world
• Event recognition
• Recognition of never-before -seen objects

• Social reasoning in game world; theory of mind; basics of
empathy, and social manipulation and deception
Mobile Robot

• Recognition of unfamiliar objects and events
• Simple, goal-directed reaching and grasping
Dialogue System Dialogue about objects , events and goals in the game world, in-
volving complex sentences with multiple clauses
Genomic Analysis

• Supervised (MOSES) and unsupervised (MOSES, cluster-
ing, pattern mining) learning based analysis of multiple ge-
nomic datasets utilizing integrated information

• Extrapolation of consequences for drug/nutraceutical target
discovery and diagnostics for age-associated diseases
Automated Pro-
gramming
MOSES -based learning of simple Al heuristics for solving puz-
zles and narrow-AI problems
Automated Theo-
rem Proving
Simple set theory and geometry theorem proving within
OpenCog
Year 3 Capability Milestone
Integrated Cogni-
tion
Ability to pass "3 year old child" variant of AIQ test in the game
world
Animated Agent

• Construction of complex objects
• Group creativity among several AGI agents in game world
• Following and giving of multi -step instructions
Mobile Robot

• Perception-guided object manipulation with robot hands
• World-understanding based on integrating acoustic and vi-
sual data
Dialogue System

• Game-world conversations involving roughly human child
like understanding of context and intention
• Dialogue about objects, events and goals in the physical
world, in the robotics context
Genomic Analysis

• integration of information extracted from research article
bodies
• conception of novel hypotheses regarding relationships be-
tween biological entities and processes, via PLN inference
Automated Pro-
gramming
Learning of modular programs, combining other learned pro-
grams in judicious ways
Automated Theo-
rem Proving
Use of PLN probabilistic reasoning to guide set theory and geom-
etry theorem proving
Year 4 Capability Milestone
Integrated Cogni•
lion
Ability to pass "4 year old child" variant of AIQ test in the game
world
Animated Agent Carrying out of simple "scientific" experimentation in game
world
Mobile Robot

• Building structures from blocks and other simple objects
• Supplementation of third-party speech -to-text with deep
learning based speech -to-text
Dialogue System

• Ability to understand and produce sequences of sentences
embodying a coherent, contextually relevant thought (in the
game world and physical world

• Dialogue about information extracted from texts (not only
about directly experienced events)
Genomic Analysis "Artificial bioinformatic scientist" functionality involving iterated
automated generation of hypotheses and testing of hypotheses
against datasets
Automated Pro-
gramming
Learning of simple programs that involve interaction with the
Atomspace
Automated Theo-
rem Proving
Use of intuitions gained from the game world to guide geometric
theorem proving
Year 5 Capability Milestone
Integrated Cogni-
tion • Ability to pass "5 year old child" variant of AIQ test in the
game world

• Ability to pass "3 year old child" variant of AIQ test in the
robotic embodiment
Animated Agent Solution of complex game-world puzzles based on a combination
of formal and intuitive reasoning
Mobile Robot Creative, child-like play with physical objects
Dialogue System Ability to understand and produce sequences of sentences em-
bodying a coherent, contextually relevant thought, regarding in-
formation extracted from text
Genomic Analysis

• Generation/testing of more complex hypotheses
• Integration of more complex information from research ar-
ticle bodies
Automated Pro-
gramming
Learning of programs involving Al-based heuristics that interact
with the Atomspace
Automated Theo-
rem Proving • Use of intuitions gained from robotics to guide geometric
theorem proving

• Extrapolation from experientially grounded (game-world-
related) to ungrounded theorem -proving via PLN analogi-
cal inference; e.g. from geometry to indirectly geometry -
related set theory algebra
2.2 Phase 2
Phase I development will be focused on implementation and testing of new CogPrime functionalities, and explo-
ration of the implications of these functionalities in the chosen application domains. Phase 2, on the other hand, is
intended to encompass 3 years of teaching the AGI system, and watching it learn and explore, and making modifi-
cations to the system as merited by observing its progress.
It is difficult, at this stage, to project the learning progress of a CogPrime system of this level of sophistication.
However, based on the nature of the CogPrime design, we can conjecture with reasonable solidity as to what kind of
functionality the system may acquire after roughly 3 years of learning from its environment and its human teachers:
Year 6 Capability Milestone
Integrated Cogni-
tion • Ability to pass "8 year old child" variant of
AIQ test in the game world

• Ability to pass "5 year old child" variant of
AIQ test in the robotic embodiment
Animated Agent Ability to robustly take knowledge gained in the
game world and port it to the physical world, and
vice versa
Mobile Robot Leaving the lab and learning to navigate and socially
interact in the city streets (with human assistance at
first
Dialogue System

• Ability to hold intelligent conversations at the
rough level of a 7 year old human child
• Ability to robustly learn new words and lin-
guistic expression patterns from experience

• Ability to read and understand general writ-
ten information aimed at children aged 7 or
younger
• Ability to effectively correlate words with im-
ages and videos, as required for understanding
e.g. children's books or educational videos
Genomic Analysis

• Formalized understanding of experimental de-
signs and how they relate to datasets
• Robust inferential connection between bio-
logical domain knowledge and general knowl-
edge of the everyday world
Automated Pro-
gramming
Ability to automatically create simple MindAgents
to perform aspects of OpenCog reasoning, based on
formal descriptions of MindAgent requirements
Automated Theo-
rem Proving
Ability to prove theorems in more abstract areas of
(still elementary) geometry or set theory, beyond
what the game world provides grounding for
Year 7 Capability Milestone
Integrated Cogni-
tion • Ability to pass adult-level variant of AIQ test in the game
world

• Ability to take ordinary human IQ test and correctly under-
stand and answer a majority of questions
Animated Agent Ability to enter a variety of game worlds, understand the prop-
erties of these worlds, and figure out how to achieve the relevant
goals there
Mobile Robot More robust interaction in a variety of social and physical situa-
tions outside the lab
Dialogue System

• Ability to hold intelligent conversations at the rough level
of a 10 year old child — about science, and also about human
relations and the system's own mind-state

• Ability to read and understand most Web pages, except
those with highly specialized or informal content

• Ability to learn aspects of new languages based on experi-
ence and teaching
Genomic Analysis Creation of hypotheses, analysis of data and design of experi-
ments at the level of a human biology undergraduate student
Automated Pro-
gramming • Ability to write simple scripts to carry out functions in the
Linux operating system

• Ability to create MindAgents performing aspects of
OpenCog reasoning, based on informal description of
MindAgent requirements
Automated Theo-
rem Proving
Ability to prove theorems in more advanced undergraduate ge-
ometry, set theory, topology and calculus
Year 8 Capability Milestone
Integrated Cogni•
Lion
Ability to pass an ordinary human adult IQ test with a strong score
Animated Agent Ability to enter an essentially arbitrary new game world, under-
stand the properties of the world, and figure out how to achieve
the relevant goals in the world
Mobile Robot

• Ability to navigate and manipulate objects in unfamiliar
sorts of environments (e.g. outdoors, in a basement, etc.)

• Ability to automatically adapt to new robotic body parts
Dialogue System
• Ability to hold intelligent, though not necessarily precisely
human-like, adult-level conversations — about science, and
also about human relations and the system's own mind-
state

• Ability to adapt all aspects of language comprehension and
generation based on linguistic experience

• Ability to read and understand most Web pages
• Ability to learn new languages based on experience and
teaching, in the manner of human language learners
Genomic Analysis Creation of hypotheses, analysis of data and design of experi-
ments at the level of a human biology graduate student
Automated Pro-
gramming • Ability to write simple scripts to carry out functions in the
Linux operating system

• Ability to modify its own MindAgents for superior func-
tionality
Automated Theo-
rem Proving
Ability to prove theorems in all areas of undergraduate mathemat-
ics, guided when needed by analogy to its grounded experience
with geometry, set theory and arithmetic
3 Staffing and Costs
3.1 Advisors and Technical Leads
3.1.1 Technical Leads
Key to the success of the proposed work will be the involvement of individuals already expert in OpenCog software
and its application, e.g.
Name Role

Dr. Ben Goertzel founder of the OpenCog project
Dr. Lines Vepstas principal engineer of the OpenCog software system
for the last several years

Dr. Nil Geisweiller

• current main developer of OpenCog's
MOSES subsystem
• prior developer of OpenCog's PLN subsystem
and OpenCog's connection to the Nao robot
• coauthor of Engineering General Intelligence

Dr. Eddie Monroe OpenCog machine learning engineer at Novamente
LLC
Dr. Matthew We' co-developer of the mathematics underlying
OpenCog's attention allocation and probabilistic
logic modules
Dr. Joel Pitt former OpenCog Hong Kong team lead, developer
of OpenCog's attention allocation module
Ruiting Lian lead OpenCog natural language developer
David Hart OpenCog IT/infrastructure guru since the project's
start
Shujing Ke lead OpenCog planning, pattern mining & game-AI
developer
Lake Watkins current developer of the game world used for testing
OpenCog
Scott Jones OpenCog core system developer, current team lead
of OpenCog Hong Kong project
Cosmo Harrigan OpenCog Al developer
Alex van der Peet OpenCog game world and AI developer
Jade O'Neill OpenCog AI developer (principal developer of
OpenCog's current Probabilistic Logic Networks
implementation)
Ted Sanders DeSTIN expert
Michel Drenthe DeSTIN expert
Misgana Bayetta OpenCog (MOSES) developer
Teddy Habtegabriel DeSTIN developer
Rodas Solomon
Amen Belayneh
and OpenCog language processing specialists
Keyvan Sadeghi author of OpenCog temporallspatial reasoning
Mike Duncan Biomind LLC bioinformaticist, currently applying
MOSES to genomics datasets
Angus Griffiths lead developer of Mathics, key tool for automated
theorem proving
The availability of a relatively large team of experienced AI software developers who are "ready to go" on OpenCog
applications is a valuable asset.
3.1.2 Advisors
The proposed work will also benefit substantially from the part-time participation of a set of AI-expert advisors,
including many who have collaborated on OpenCog work in one way or another in the past, and some who have
developed their own related ideas. Most of these individuals were mentioned above in the sections specific to their
expertise areas, but are listed here in summary form, along with their relevant specialty.
Name Affiliation Relevant Specialty
Cassio Pennachin Aidyia Limited original software architect of
OpenCog
Itamar Arel U. Tennessee
Knoxville
vision and audition
Peter Stone U. Texas Austin robotics
Bertram Shi HKUST robotics
Mark Tilden consultant robotics
David Hanson Hanson Robotics robotics
Tom Mitchell Carnegie Mellon information extraction
Dan Miller consultant virtual world infrastructure and
robotics
Michael Rose U.C. Irvine genomics
Joao Pedro de Ma-
galhaes
U. Liverpool bioinformatics, genomics
Predrag Janicic University of Bel-
grade
automated theorem proving
Moshe Looks Google automated program learning
Paul Rosenbloom USC probabilistic reasoning
Noah Goodman Stanford probabilistic reasoning
Joscha Bach MIT/Harvard motivation & emotion
Fray Ozkural Bilkent University automated program learning
Juergen Schmidhu-
ber
IDSIA automated program learning, vi-
sion, robotics
Note: Some but not all of the above -men Toned individuals have been explicitly asked about poten ial involvement in
this specific project, at this stage. All have previously been in discussions regarding collaboratio z and advisement
on OpenCog related AG! projects.
3.2 Estimated Costs
This section presents a crude and preliminary cost estimate for the proposed work. A detailed budget can be produced
upon request, but will depend on specific assumptions such as the particular locations where the different aspects of
the work will be carried out.
Assuming the Integrated Cognition team has 25 staff, and each of the other 11 teams outlined above each have
5 staff, we would then have a total of 80 scientific and technical staff on the project. As some staff will be senior
and some junior, cost per staff member may vary, but if we assume a cost of US$100K per year per staff member on
average (including overheads), the result is a staff cost of US$8 million per year. We will assume a cost of $6M for
the first year as staff will likely be brought on gradually.
We also assume that the team's expert advisors will occasionally be paid consulting fees to give detailed reviews
of system design and performance issues, and paid expenses to visit the project from time to time. Crudely we
assume this amounts to US $200K/year.
Computing hardware will be a significant expense as well. If we assume 1000 cloud-based servers at a cost
of US$25 per month per server, the cost of hardware would be US $300K per year. In the first years the need for
hardware would be less than this, perhaps US $150K. This many machines will also require significant dedicated IT
support, for which we may budget roughly US $300K per year, which adds to the above staff cost. In Phase 2 we
will potentially require a greater amount of hardware, but the details are difficult to foresee in part because the 
costs
of hardware are rapidly declining in complex ways.
Thus, exclusive of administrative costs, we arrive at a rough annual cost estimate as follows (all figures in
millions of USD):
Year Staff (fully
loaded)
Advisors Hardware Total Cost
1 6.3 .2 .15 9.
2 8.3 .2 .3 10.
3 83 .2 .3 11.
4 8.3 .2 .3 11
5 8.3 .2 .3 11.
6 8.3 .2 .5 11.
7 8.3 .2 .5 11.
8 8.3 .2 .5 11.
Total 64.4 3.2 1.35 69
Adding reasonable administrative, travel, legal and miscellaneous costs we obtain a rough cost estimate of $80M
over 8 years.
3.2.1 Lower -Cost Alternatives
The above cost estimate assumes doing all, or nearly all, development in the US or other locations of comparable
cost. An alternative strategy would be to have a team of perhaps 15 expert staff in the US or other high-cost locations,
supplemented by a team in a low-cost location. A number of OpenCog developers are currently working from the
office of iCog Labs, an AI outsourcing and R&D firm in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Extensive use of iCog Labs staff
could bring the total annual cost down to US$2.5-3M from $11M, a substantial reduction. Intermediate scenarios are
also a possibility, with less extreme utilization of offshoring resulting in significant but less extensive cost 
reduction.
4 Scientific and Technical Development
In this section we give rough indications of the work to be done to achieve the above-listed incremental milestones.
4.1 Integrated Cognition
The CogPrime design for advanced Artificial General Intelligence has, at the present time, only been partially im-
plemented within the OpenCog open-source AGI software framework. Considerable work remains to complete the
implementation and testing of the CogPrime design within the OpenCog system. Here we will describe only the
most major points; however, numerous related similar tasks also need doing, many of which are documented on the
OpenCog wild site.
Implementation and testing of the CogPrime design is intended to be completed within the scope of Phase 1 of
this proposal. The achievement of childlike commonsense and domain-specific advanced intelligence can be worked
toward gradually, as more and more of CogPrime is implemented and made workable. During Phase 2, the focus
will be on teaching the system and enabling it to improve its intelligence via spontaneous learning as well as human
instruction. Improvements to the underlying Al code will be made during this phase as seems appropriate based on
observations of the system's learning progress; but these improvements cannot be foreseen in detail at this stage.
4.1.1 Unified Rule Engine
At present the OpenCog system has a number of different "rule engines" implemented within it, which apply differ-
ent sorts of "rewrite rules" to different sorts of data, in the context of different cognitive processes. This is 
workable
but ultimately not the best approach; a design has been created for a unified OpenCog rule engine, but it needs to be
fleshed out and implemented.
4.1.2 Probabilistic Reasoning
OpenCog currently contains an implementation of CogPrime's Probabilistic Logic Networks reasoning system, in-
tegrated with the Economic Attention Allocation module to achieve scalable inference control. However, the current
PLN implementation has a number of limitations in need of remedying, e.g.

• it should be modified to utilize the Unified Rule Engine mentioned above, when the latter is ready
• it currently uses only a simple version of probabilistic truth values, and should be extended to use "indefinite"
and "distributional" truth values

• it has recently been extended to deal efficiently with temporal reasoning. Similar extensions need to be done
for spatial and quantitative reasoning

• inductive inference control needs to be implemented, wherein the choice of next inference step is made based
on analysis of a historical database of prior inferences
While PLN implements its own unique brand of AGI-oriented probabilistic logic, it also has numerous relationships
with other probabilistic logic systems. As PLN work progresses, ongoing feedback from other probabilistic reason-
ing oriented AGI researchers such as Paul Rosenbloom (USC) and Noah Goodman (Stanford) will be valuable.
4.1.3 Motivation and Emotion
OpenCog's OpenPsi module, modeled loosely on Joscha Bach's MicroPsi architecture, currently causes an OpenCog
agent's actions to be chosen based on its goals. This functionality works reasonably but is currently relatively
simplistic. Key improvements needed are:

• Implement the CogPrime system of "Request for Services" based economic goal fulfillment, wherein a goal
offers Atoms "virtual funds" for helping it get achieved, in a way that relies on the Economic Attention
Allocation subsystem

• Implement novelty, amount -of-learning and aesthetics as goals, based on information -theoretic definitions
4.1.4 Procedure Learning
The MOSES automated program learning algorithm is perhaps the most mature portion of the OpenCog codebase,
yet still requires significant augmentation to be fully useful for AGI purposes, i.e.

• Implement effective modeling of multiple interdependent continuous -valued program inputs, to allow effective
MOSES learning of programs depending on multiple continuous values (this is important e.g. for using
MOSES to learn motor control procedures, where the continuous values represent states of a body's motor
control system)

• Extend MOSES's program simplification aspect (Reduct) to handle higher-order functions and local variables,
via using techniques from the functional programming literature such as director strings. This will allow
MOSES to learn more complex programs

• Integrate MOSES with PLN inference to enable each MOSES learning run to benefit from prior MOSES
learning runs via probabilistic analogical reasoning
4.1.5 Procedure Execution
The current OpenCog system lacks the facility to execute multiple procedures at the same time, and mediate potential
conflicts between the procedures. That is, in terms of its interactions with an external world, the system cannot
effectively "multitask:' Refinement and implementation of the CogPrime design for "execution management," which
models and acts on the dependences between concurrently executing procedures, is needed.
4.1.6 Pattern Mining
OpenCog's current pattern mining subsystem, Fishgram (Frequent and Interesting SubHypergraph Mining), is pro-
totype code and not sufficiently scalable. A detailed design has been outlined for reimplementing it in a scalable
manner, but this needs to be executed on. Further, pattern mining needs to be integrated with MOSES so it can guide,
and be guided by, MOSES learning.
4.1.7 Planning
OpenCog currently possesses a planner that integrates hierarchical plan learning with logical inference in a unique
way, customized for learning of plans combining navigating and building in a 3D game world, but extensible much
more generally. This planner needs to be refactored to utilize the Unified Rule Engine, and integrated with PLN so
as to leverage probabilistic inference.
4.1.8 Language Processing
Currently OpenCog has a fairly robust language comprehension component, and a prototype language generation
system, and very little facility for controlling the course of a natural language dialogue. Further, the comprehension
and generation systems rely heavily on hand-coded rules and specialized rule engines. What needs to be done is to
upgrade the current NLP system to be more fully learning-based and Atomspace-centered, i.e.

• Port the specialized hand-coded NLP rules currently used into Atomspace format, so that NLP can be done as
a consequence of generic cognitive processing

• Replace invocation of specialized NLP rule engines with invocation of the Unified Rule Engine
• Transform the existing NL comprehension rules into a reversible format, so that they can be reversed and used
for NL generation

• Deploy clustering and pattern mining to learn new language processing rules from corpus analysis, beginning
with (reversible versions of) the existing NLP rules as initial conditions

• Implement initial dialogue control heuristics as Atoms in the Atomspace, so that speech acts can be chosen by
OpenPsi along with other sorts of acts, based on the system's motivations
4.1.9 Attention Allocation
OpenCog's Economic Attention Allocation (ECAN) module works reasonably effectively on modest-sized Atom-
spaces at the moment, but needs

• extension to handle large Atomspaces efficiently
• fuller integration with PLN, to enable more sophisticated reasoning about what may become important and
deserve attention in the future

• more sophisticated forgetting mechanisms
• mechanisms enabling it to pull knowledge into RAM from disk when merited
4.1.10 Concept Formation
Mechanisms for forming new concepts based on the action of clustering and pattern mining algorithms need to be
implemented. The existing code enabling creation of new concepts via "conceptual blending" of existing concepts,
needs to be extended via integrating information -theoretic measures of what constitutes a high-quality blend.
4.1.11 Perception
Currently the DeSTIN deep perceptual pattern recognition system exports cognitive information into the Atomspace
via mediation of a "frequent pattern mining" component which recognizes patterns in DeSTIN's state and exports
these patterns into the Atomspace. However,

• This specialized pattern mining component is prototype-level and needs to be tuned and completed.
• Concept formation and PLN inference need to be tested on, and customized for, the drawing of inferences
from patterns input to the Atomspace from DeSTIN.

• Information derived from cognitive inferences needs to be fed back into DeSTIN to bias its pattern formation.
This feedback will require significant experimentation and tuning.
4.1.12 Action
The DeSTIN hierarchy needs to be extended to handle actions as well as perceptions. This is somewhat subtle since
instead of the 3D space used for vision or the ID space used for audition, for action DeSTIN must represent the
higher-dimensional "Configuration Space" of a motoric dynamical system. The basic concepts and mechanisms of
DeSTIN will carry over to this case, but numerous implementation changes will be required.
4.2 Distributed and Multicore Processing Infrastructure
To achieve human-level AGI, given current computing technology, will require a significant cloud computing infras-
tructure (a large network of multiprocessor Linux machines), and software customized to make use of said infras-
tructure. A rough estimate is on the order of 500-1000 quad-processor servers, including perhaps 200 with GPU as
well as CPU. The OpenCog framework has been designed with extensibility to networks of this size in mind, but
requires significant enhancement (within its current architecture) to be effective in this kind of deployment, e.g.

• refactoring of the core Atomspace knowledge repository to encompass a single Atomspace spanning a large
number of machines (likely utilizing existing third-party graph DB technology, with specialized extensions)

• design and implementation of subsystems enabling automated management of OpenCog systems running on
large networks

• implementation of code for automatically shifting knowledge among different machines in a large Atomspace,
to optimize intelligence and efficient use of resources
• re-implementation of specific aspects of OpenCog to utilize GPUs effectively (e.g.: the DeSTIN percep-
tion/action hierarchy, truth value estimation in Probabilistic Logic Networks, importance spreading in Eco-
nomic Attention Allocation)
This is engineering rather than Al work, but nevertheless involves many novel aspects and must be done with
care. The OpenCog project currently involves contributors with a combination of OpenCog expertise and decades
of experience in this area, e.g. Dr. Linas Vepstas.
4.3 Sensation (Vision, Audition & Haptics)
"Deep learning" is rapidly becoming the pre-eminent approach to the understanding of visual and auditory data; it is
applicable to haptic (touch) data as well, though this has been less explored. In visual object and event recognition,
deep learning systems are now outperforming narrower systems based on hand-coded feature extractors, for a variety
of tasks. In speech -to-text, deep learning systems are now outperforming the Hidden Markov Model type systems
used by major industry players.
OpenCog has been preliminarily integrated with the DeSTIN deep learning based computer vision system (I],
originally developed by Dr. Itamar Arel at the University of Tennesse, Knoxville and now open sourced as part of
the OpenCog framework. DeSTIN is currently being applied to robot vision utilizing input from stereo cameras and
the Microsoft Kinect.
What is proposed here, during Phase 1, is further development of the DeSTIN system for vision, and extension
to audition and haptics as well. Also, to achieve scalable performance, the current version of DeSTIN should be
ported to CUDA for operation on CPUs (an earlier version of DeSTIN was ported to CUDA and dramatic speedup
was achieved).
4.4 Robot Movement Control
Effective movement control is critical to robotics applications, but also valuable from a broader AGI perspective,
because it provides a paradigm case of coordinated activity and dynamic planning. A great deal of human cognitive,
social and linguistic activity is orchestrated via analogy to physical movement. In the human brain, the cerebellum is
responsible for many additional sorts of planning and sequencing operations alongside motor control, all done using
the same representations and mechanisms.
Standard humanoid or wheeled robotic architectures, with independently controlled motors associated with in-
dividual joints, are not especially well-suited for integration with AGI systems, as they lack the complex internal
dynamics of biological bodies. An alternative is the "biomorphic" architecture, exemplified by the nervous-network
approach pioneered by Mark Tilden, in which the motors in a robot body are controlled by a network of neurons or
other comparable processing elements that pulse signals to each other in coordination with motor movements. In the
biomorphic approach, the body is a complex dynamical system which may be coupled with the complex dynamics
of a cognitive system — resulting in a "deep learning" approach in which the lower layer of learning occurs within
the body via reinforcement learning in the network of pulsing elements; and the upper layers occurs in a cognitive
system coupled with the body (such as OpenCog).
We do not propose novel hardware research, however, only novel research in interfacing cognitive control sys-
tems with biomorphic robotics. This work is best pursued in partnership with experienced robot control researchers.
We are fortunate to have two leaders in this field as consultants and collaborators:

• Mark Tilden, pioneer of biomorphic robotics, former NASA roboticist, and creator of the RoboSapien line of
toy biomorphic robots (more than 23 million sold)

• David Hanson, leader in creation of visually, emotionally and behaviorally human-like humanoid robots
The robot movement control aspect of this project could be carried out via a combination of in-house efforts and
collaboration with appropriate academic robot labs such as (two of many possible examples):

• Peter lab at the University of Texas, Austin
• Bertram Shi's lab at Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, which has special expertise in neuro-
morphic systems (and is located near Mark Tilden)
The overall goal during Phase 1 will be to create a robot capable of robust navigation, object and event recogni-
tion and object manipulation in an indoor environment. Generalization to a broader class of environments (e.g. city
streets rather than the interior of a robot lab) will be carried out during Phase 2, alongside appropriate improvements
to the robot hardware infrastructure (and bearing in mind that robotic hardware for sensing, moving and grasping
improves each year).
4.5 Game World Development
While it is viable and interesting to experiment with early-stage AGI systems in commercial video game worlds,
ultimately, to get the most from 3D simulated worlds for AGI learning, teaching and interaction, one needs to build
customized virtual environments with the requirements of AGIs in mind. The main extensions to current game world
technology needed are:
• More accurate modeling of the physics of non-rigid bodies, such as fabrics, pastes, fluids, etc.
• Integration of robot-simulator functionality with game-world functionality, to enable a "multiplayer robot
simulator" with a complex simulated world
The latter functionality may be achieved by integrating an existing open source robot simulator (e.g. Gazebo is one
option) with an existing open source game engine. The former functionality can be achieved by integrating known
equations from the physics engine research literature with existing open source physics engines such as ODE.
No breakthrough research is required here, but this is a substantial piece of software engineering work that is not
getting done because it doesn't provide an immediate commercial upside. Once available this technology will likely
have a broad impact beyond the domain of of AGI testing/training/teaching.
We have discussed this work extensively with Dan Miller, who integrated the ODE physics engine into the
OpenSim virtual world, and has also done extensive humanoid robotics work with Anybots and Hanson Robotics;
and Ile is interested in leading or participating in this aspect of the proposed work.
The capability of our Phase I AGI system to operate intelligently in a complex 3D game world will have wide
commercial applicability in the gaming industry, in addition to its scientific value. In Phase 2 focus will be laid on
the capability of the system to adapt to novel game worlds and learn spontaneously how the world operates and how
to survive and flourish within it.
4.6 Genomics Data Analysis
One of the most exciting and impactful application areas for AGI technology will be the creation of artificial scien-
tists. Analysis of scientific data and synthesis of novel data-driven scientific hypotheses, is a skill that AGIs can be
expected to eventually master beyond the human level, since the human brain evolved to be specialized for quite dif-
ferent tasks than those involved in science. Furthermore, scientific analysis and hypothesis are somewhat different in
nature from the other applications considered in this proposal, which have more to do with the control of embodied
agents or the manipulation of formal structures like programs and mathematics. Thus it seems important to include
an example of AI -based science as one of the initial applications pursued here.
The value of AI for genomics data analysis is well demonstrated in the literature, and OpenCog's MOSES
component has been used for a number of successful genomics data applications, especially related to the genomics
of longevity. What is proposed here is to take the next step, and push from the narrow AI style use of machine
learning tools to analyze individual genomic datasets or small collections of genomic dataset, to the more general
analysis of large volumes of genomic data en masse. This ultimately should be done across the scope of all genomics
datasets available online, but we propose to begin specifically with aging and longevity related datasets, across
multiple organisms. Specifically this requires:

I. Human effort to standardize and normalize a large set of aging-relevant SNP, gene expression and other ge-
nomic datasets into a common graph-database format. This has already been done for a significant number
of datasets, in the GenAge database. Proteomic, metabolomic and other such data may also be integrated as
appropriate.

2. Integration of OpenCog's natural language comprehension tools with existing open source software for ex-
tracting information from biological texts (e.g. specialized biological entity and relationship extraction code)

3. Human curation of an OpenCog Atomspace combining information from experimental datasets, information
extracted from natural language, and information imported from structured biological knowledge bases such
as the Gene Ontology and pathway databases
4. Tuning of OpenCog cognitive processes for effective pattern recognition, reasoning and learning on this bio-
logical data
Toward this end, we will benefit from advisement by informatics -savvy biologists who have collaborated with
the Biomind LLC team on the application of OpenCog software to genomics data in the past, e.g.:
• Michael Rose, University of California, Irvine
• Joao Pedro de Magalhaes, University of Liverpool
Both of these scientists are recognized leaders in the biology of aging.
The Phase I AGI system will be an extremely powerful "biologist's assistant", with some capability to pose
original hypotheses and test them via analysis of datasets. In Phase 2 the focus will be on teaching the system to
display more autonomy in posing its own research questions and designing its own experiments.
4.7 Text, Image and Video Mining
While a human-level AGI requires its own experience of the world and needs to learn aspects of language via its
own dialogic, social, embodied experience; nevertheless, there is a lot an early-stage AGI can learn from "reading"
and analyzing the copious amount of text available online. This can be approached via the same tools used for
language comprehension in a dialogue context, but requires significantly different "tuning" of the tools, as the usage
of language in spoken conversation or text chat is significantly different from that in most text documents. Also, a
scalable infrastructure for text mining has somewhat different requirements from an infrastructure for control of an
AGI agent.
Alongside text, the Internet contains a massive amount of information in the form of images and videos, of
potential interest to an AGI system. Information regarding what entities and events are depicted in images and
videos can be used to provide knowledge to an AGI system, to aid its understanding of the world.
Carnegie-Mellon University has been conducting very interesting experiments in these directions, called NELL
(Never-Ending Language Learning) and NEIL (Never-Ending Image Learning). These systems conduct information
extraction from texts and images via a combination of machine learning algorithms. A very promising approach
would be to integrate standard machine learning algorithms with OpenCog's proto-AGI algorithms within this sort
of overall information extraction framework.
The NELLINEIL code is not currently open source, but the CMU team is potentially amenable to open-sourcing
it if supplied with resources to "clean up" and professionalize their code (which is currently research-grade rather
than production -grade). Alternately, if this hits a snag, the same functionality could be reimplemented using the
designs described in their research papers.
As Phase I and then Phase 2 progresses, the system's capability to understand text, images and video will
improve, enabling it to extract more information from the Web. And of course, the additional information extracted
will help the system to improve its intelligence yet further, in a virtuous cycle. What begins as relatively simple
"information extraction" will gradually segue into genuine human-level understanding.
4.8 Automated Programming
Expressed in a minimalistic programming language, a typical cognitive control process could be implemented in
a program containing less than 500 terms. This means that if an AGI program could create reasonably complex
programs of this size, it would be able to systematically improve its own cognitive capabilities, and potentially
embark upon a pathway of steadily self-improving intelligence. To get to this point however, we must first create
proto-AGI systems that can learn to create simpler programs. OpenCog contains a powerful automated program
learning subsystem, MOSES, which learns programs via probabilistic evolutionary learning. Currently MOSES
can only learn relatively simple programs; however, the mathematical and software mechanisms needed to extend
MOSES more generally have been clearly articulated.
What is proposed in this regard, technically, is:

I. Extend MOSES's internal representation language to encompass the full set of Mathematica/Mathics struc-
tures (Mathics is an open source analogue of Mathematica, enabling symbolic theorem-proving and numerical
mathematics capabilities within a functional programming framework).

2. Extend MOSES's internal program analysis functionality to encompass higher-order functional programs
(needed for Mathematica/Mathics), as outlined in Engineering General Intelligence

3. Connect MOSES's program reduction (simplification) module to PLN (which in turn will be connected to
Mathics) to enable logic-based simplification of candidate programs during the course of program learning
4. Enable MOSES to observe the execution traces of running programs, so as to include this information in
its modeling of programs (along with the data it currently models: program source code and input/output
behavior)
As this particular application is closely tied to OpenCog's internal cognition processes, it is best carried out
by a team closely integrated with the core OpenCog team. However, this work should also be carried out in close
collaboration with Angus Griffith (current lead developer of Mathics), and the original developer of the MOSES
algorithm, Moshe Looks, currently a Google employee.
The first priority for automated programming will be to get learning of simple algorithms like sorting, searching
and graph traversal to work robustly, without problem-specific engineering as is generally done in the research
literature on such topics. Following this, the next step will be automated learning of simple cognitive algorithms
such as heuristic search and pattern mining.
By the time Phase 2 is reached, the assumption is that a fairly general program learning capability will have
been achieved, and it will be possible to gradually lead the system through learning the programming exercises in a
standard functional programming textbook. Rather than running program -learning experiments, one will be teaching
the system to program.
4.9 Automated Theorem Proving
Automated theorem proving has the potential to play a critical role in the future of AI, because AI systems are
formally describable using mathematics. Hence an AI system capable of robust theorem proving would be able to
formally analyze its own behavior, and derive conclusions regarding its own functionality and how to optimize itself.
Computer scientists use theorem proving to understand aspects of new algorithms they create; and potentially AGIs
can do this as well, combining automated programming with automated theorem proving.
Specialized theorem proving software has already proved invaluable in mathematics, e.g. assisting with the
proof of the characterization of finite simple groups, and resolving unsolved problems in logic. However, existing
theorem -proving software is not yet capable of proving complex theorems on its own, without significant human
guidance, nor of identifying interesting new theorems in need of proof. In order to overcome these weaknesses, two
innovative steps are needed:

I. To enable large-scale analogical reasoning in the context of mathematical proofs. One needs to feed a large
number of mathematical theorems and proofs into an AGI system's knowledge base, so that it can reason
about each new theorem by analogy to others it has studied.
2. To ground a substantial subset of mathematical theorems in domains where an AGI system has direct expe-
rience. A simple example of this would be to ground basic geometric theorem proving in an AGI system's
observations in a video game world — so it could prove theorems about objects and movements in the world,
directly related to objects and movements it had observed itself
Toward the first point, preliminary work has been done regarding loading the Mizar corpus of mathematics
theorems and proof (which covers all mathematics up to the Masters degree level, plus more) into OpenCog's
AtomSpace.
Given these steps, one can then carry out automated theorem proving in OpenCog using an integration of
OpenCog's current PLN (Probabilistic Logic Networks) system with an external theorem proving engine such as
Mathics.
Predrag Janicic, a world authority on automated theorem proving, has worked with OpenCog in the past along
with his graduate students, and has expressed interest in assisting with this aspect of the proposed work.
As Phase 1 segues into Phase 2, the system will be asked to prove more and more complex theorems, generalizing
further and further beyond the game world domain that it uses to ground its knowledge of set-theoretic and geometric
mathematics. By the end of Phase 2, the system should be acting as an innovative mathematician on its own, though
perhaps with different strengths and weaknesses than human mathematicians.
4.10 Teaching and Intelligence Testing
How can one measure incremental progress toward adult human level AGI? IQ assessment instruments as presently
defined are overfit to the specific of the human mind and body and not applicable to AGI systems with slightly
different capabilities. However, it is possible to design "AIQ" tests capturing the essential concepts of human IQ
tests but oriented toward AGI systems that control virtual or robotic agents rather toward humans. Such tests have
been outlined already, but fleshing out the details and implementing them in software will require collaboration
between a psychologist trained in child intelligence assessment and a small group of programmers.
Well-designed, solidly implemented AIQ tests will be valuable beyond the scope of this particular project, and
are likely to play a valuable role in moving the AI and AGI fields forward more broadly.
4.11 Software Integration and Testing
Any project involving multiple teams developing complex software for multiple overlapping purposes, presents
subtle software integration and testing issues. A small dedicated team devoted to integrating, maintaining and testing
the collective codebase of the project will be critical. This team can also mediate the contributions of volunteer open
source developers and participating external academic researchers, which may become substantial as the project
evolves.
References
[I] I. Arel, D. Rose, and T. Karnowski. A deep learning architecture comprising homogeneous cortical circuits
for scalable spatiotemporal pattern inference. NIPS 2009 Workshop on Deep Learning for Speech Recognition
and Related Applications, 2009.
[2] Joscha Bach. Principles of Synthetic Intelligence. Oxford University Press, 2009.
[3] G. Fauconnier and M. Turner. The Way We Think: Conceptual Blending and the Mind's Hidden Complexities.
Basic, 2002.
[4] B. Goenzel, I. Goertzel M. IkM, and A. Heljakka. Probabilistic Logic Networks. Springer, 2008.
[5] Ben Goertzel. The Hidden Pattern. Brown Walker, 2006.
[6] Ben Goertzel, Lucio Coelho, Mauricio Mudado, and Cassio Pennachin. Identifying the genes and genetic
interrelationships underlying the impact of calorie restriction on maximum lifespan: An artificial intelligence
based approach. Rejuvenation Research 11(4): 735-748, 2008.
[7] Ben Goertzel and et al. Combinations of single nucleotide polymorphisms in neuroendocrine effector and
receptor genes predict chronic fatigue syndrome. Phannacogenomics, 2005.
[8] Ben Goertzel and et al. The cogprime architecture for embodied artificial general intelligence. In Proceedings
of IEEE Symposium on Human -Level Al, Singapore, 2013.
[9] Ben Goertzel and Cassio Pennachin Et Al. An integrative methodology for teaching embodied non-linguistic
agents, applied to virtual animals in second life. In Proc.of the First Conf. on AGI. IOS Press, 2008.
[10] Ben Goertzel, Cassio Pennachin, and Nil Geisweiller. Engineering General Intelligence, Part I: A Path to
Advanced AG! via Embodied Learning and Cognitive Synergy. Springer: Atlantis Thinking Machines, 2013.
[11] Ben Goertzel, Cassio Pennachin, and Nil Geisweiller. Engineering General Intelligence, Part 2: The CogPrime
Architecture for Integrative, Embodied AG!. Springer: Atlantis T inking Machines, 2013.
[12] Ben Goertzel, Hugo Pinto, Cassio Pennachin, and Izabela Freire Goertzel. Using dependency parsing and prob-
abilistic inference to extract relationships between genes, proteins and malignancies implicit among multiple
biomedical research abstracts. In Proc. of Bio-NLP 2006,2006.
[13] Ben Goertzel, Joel Pitt, Zhenhua Cai, Jared Wigmore, Deheng Huang, Nil Geisweiller, Ruiting Lian, and Gino

Yu. Integrative general intelligence for controlling game ai in a minecraft-like environment. In Proc. of RICA
2011, 2011.
[14] Ben Goertzel, Joel Pitt, Matthew Ikle, Cassio Pennachin, and Rui Liu. Glocal memory: a design principle for
artificial brains and minds. Neurocomputing, April 2010.
[15] Ben et al Goertzel. Opencogbot: An integrative architecture for embodied agi. Proc. of ICAI-10, Beijing, 2010.
[16] Moshe Looks. Competent Program Evolution. PhD Thesis, Computer Science Department, Washington Uni-
versity, 2006.
[17] Rafal Smigrodzlci, Ben Goertzel, Cassio Pennachin, Lucio Coelho, Francisco Prosdoscimi, and W Davis Parker.
Genetic algorithm for analysis of mutations in parkinsons disease. Artif Intel! Med., 2005.
[18] Endel Tulving and R. Craik. The Oxford Handbook of Memory. Oxford U. Press, 2005.
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Coinbase [crypto] largest American crypto exchange, early investment from Epstein [protos] 
                                                Fred Ehrsam [crypto] co-founder of Coinbase 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01092555 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Coinbase certificate of incorporation
(date: 2013-12-12)
Delaware The First State
PAGE
I, JEFFREY W. BULLOCK, SECRETARY OF STATE OF THE STATE OF
DELAWARE, DO HEREBY CERTIFY THE ATTACHED IS A TRUE AND CORRECT
COPY OF THE RESTATED CERTIFICATE OF "COINBASE GLOBAL, INC.",
FILED IN THIS OFFICE ON THE FIRST DAY OF DECEMBER, A.D. 2014, AT
2:28 O'CLOCK P.M.
A FILED COPY OF THIS CERTIFICATE HAS BEEN FORWARDED TO THE
KENT COUNTY RECORDER OF DEEDS.
5465078 8100
141467945
You may verify this certificate online
at corp.delaware.gov/authver.ahtfal
jeffreywmaxicsecrewyorstate
AUTHE TION: 1908136
DATE: 12-01-14
AMENDED AND RESTATED CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION
OF
COINBASE GLOBAL, INC.
(Pursuant to Sections 242 and 245 of the
General Corporation Law of the State of Delaware)
Coinbase Global, Inc., a corporation organized and existing under and by virtue of the provisions of the General 
Corporation Law of the State of Delaware (the
"General Corporation Law"),
DOES HEREBY CERTIFY:

1. That the name of this corporation is Coinbase Global, Inc., and that this corporation was originally incorporated 
pursuant to the General Corporation Law on
January 27, 2014 under the name Coinbase Global, Inc.

2. That the Board of Directors duly adopted resolutions proposing to amend and restate the Certificate of Incorporation 
of this corporation, declaring said
amendment and restatement to be advisable and in the best interests of this corporation and its stockholders, and 
authorizing the appropriate officers of this
corporation to solicit the consent of the stockholders therefor, which resolution setting forth the proposed amendment 
and restatement is as follows:
RESOLVED, that the Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation of this corporation be amended and restated in its 
entirety to read as follows:
FIRST: The name of this corporation is Coinbase Global, Inc. (the "Corporation").

SECOND: The address of the Corporation's registered office in the State of Delaware is 3500 S. DuPont Hwy, in the City 
of Dover, County of Kent, Zip Code 19901.
The name of its registered agent at such address is Incorporating Services, Ltd.

THIRD: The nature of the business or purposes to be conducted or promoted is to engage in any lawful act or activity for
which corporations may be organized
under the General Corporation Law.

FOURTH: The total number of shares of all classes of stock which the Corporation shall have authority to issue is (i) 
30,000,000 shams of Common Stock, $0.00001
par value per share ("Common Stock'), (ii) 1,377,022 shares of FF Preferred Stock, 0.00001 par value per share ("FF 
Preferred Stock") and (iii) 14,221,712
shares of Preferred Stock, $0.00001 par value per share ("Preferred Stock").

The following is a statement of the designations and the powers, privileges and rights, and the qualifications, 
limitations or restrictions thereof in respect
of each class of capital stock of the Corporation.
OHSUSA:7593(4556.4
State of Delaware
Secretary of State
Division of Corporations
Delivered 02:32 P74 12/01/2014
PILED 02:28 PM 12/01/2014
SW 141467945 - 5465078 FILE

A. COMMON STOCK
I. General. The voting, dividend and liquidation rights of the holders of the
Common Stock are subject to and qualified by the rights, powers and preferences of the holders
of the Preferred Stock set forth herein.

2. Voting. The holders of the Common Stock are entitled to one vote for
each share of Common Stock held at all meetings of stockholders (and written actions in lieu of
meetings). There shall be no cumulative voting. The number of authorized shares of Common
Stock may be increased or decreased (but not below the number of shares thereof then
outstanding) by (in addition to any vote of the holders of one or more series of Preferred Stock
that may be required by the terms of the Certificate of Incorporation) the affirmative vote of the
holders of shares of capital stock of the Corporation representing a majority of the votes
represented by all outstanding shares of capital stock of the Corporation entitled to vote,
irrespective of the provisions of Section 242(bX2) of the General Corporation Law.

B. PREFERRED STOCK
5,163,353 shares of the authorized Preferred Stock of the Corporation are hereby
designated "Series A Preferred Stock", 4,235,963 shares of the authorized Preferred Stock of
the Corporation arc hereby designated "Series B Preferred Stock" and 4,822,3% shares of the
authorized but unissued Preferred Stock of the Corporation are hereby designated "Series C
Preferred Stock", each with the following rights, preferences, powers, privileges and
restrictions, qualifications and limitations. Unless otherwise indicated, references to "sections" or
`subsections" in this Part B of this Article Fourth refer to sections and subsections of Part B of
this Article Fourth.

1. Dividends.
The holders of shares of Preferred Stock shall be entitled to receive dividends, on a pan
passu basis, out of any assets legally available therefor, prior and in preference to any declaration
or payment of any dividend (payable other than in Common Stock or other securities and rights
convertible into or entitling the holder thereof to receive, directly or indirectly, additional shares
of Common Stock of the Corporation) on the Common Stock and FF Preferred Stock of the
Corporation, at the rate of (i) 6% of the Series A Original Issue Price (as adjusted for stock splits,
stock dividends, reclassification and the like) per annum on each outstanding share of Series A
Preferred Stock then held by them, (ii) 6% of the Series B Original Issue Price (as adjusted for
stock splits, stock dividends, reclassification and the like) per annum on each outstanding share
of Series B Preferred Stock then held by them and (iii) 6% of the Series C Original Issue Price
(as adjusted for stock splits, stock dividends, reclassification and the like) per annum on each
outstanding share of Series C Preferred Stock then held by them; in each case payable when, as
and if declared by the Board of Directors of the Corporation (the "Board of Directors"),
calculated on the record date for determination of holders entitled to such dividend. Such
dividends shall not be cumulative. After payment of such dividends, any additional dividends
shall be distributed among the holders of Preferred Stock, Common Stock and FF Preferred
Stock pro rata based on the number of shares of Common Stock then held by each holder
OHSUSA:759168556.4 -2-
(assuming conversion of all such Preferred Stock into Common Stock), calculated on the record
date for determination of holders entitled to such dividend.
2. Liquidation, Dissolution or Winding Up; Certain Mergers. Consolidations
and Asset Sales.
2.1 Preferential Payments to Holders of Preferred Stock. In the event
of any Liquidation Event, the holders of shares of Preferred Stock then outstanding shall be
entitled to be paid out of the assets of the Corporation available for distribution to its
stockholders before any payment shall be made to the holders of Common Stock or FF Preferred
Stock by reason of their ownership thereof, an amount per share equal to the greater of (i) one (1)
times the applicable Original Issue Price for such series, plus any dividends declared but unpaid
thereon, for each share of Preferred Stock then held by them, or (ii) such amount per share as
would have been payable had such share of Preferred Stock been converted into Common Stock
pursuant to Section 4 immediately prior to such Liquidation Event, for each share of Preferred
Stock then held by them (the amount payable pursuant to this sentence is hereinafter referred to
as the "Series A Liquidation Amount" with respect to the Series A Preferred Stock, the "Series
B Liquidation Amount" with respect to the Series B Preferred Stock and the "Series C
Liquidation Amount" with respect to the Series C Preferred Stock); for clarity, the
determination as to which of (i) or (ii) of the foregoing clause is greater shall be made at the time
of the decision to liquidate, dissolve, or wind up, or upon consummation of a Liquidation Event,
assuming any escrowed amounts will be paid out to the stockholders of the Corporation. If
upon any such Liquidation Event, the assets of the Corporation available for distribution to its
stockholders shall be insufficient to pay the holders of shares of Preferred Stock the full amount
to which they shall be entitled under this Subsection 2.1, the holders of shares of Preferred Stock
shall share ratably in any distribution of the assets available for distribution in proportion to the
respective amounts which would otherwise be payable in respect of the shares held by them upon
such distribution if all amounts payable on or with respect to such shares were paid in full.
"Series A Original Issue Price" shall mean $1.18326, subject to appropriate adjustment in the
event of any stock dividend, stock split, combination, or other similar recapitalization with
respect to the Series A Preferred Stock, "Series B Original Issue Price" shall mean $6.04054,
subject to appropriate adjustment in the event of any stock dividend, stock split, combination, or
other similar recapitalization with respect to the Series B Preferred Stock and "Series C Original
Issue Price" shall mean $16.58926, subject to appropriate adjustment in the event of any stock
dividend, stock split, combination, or other similar recapitalization with respect to the Series C
PreLied Stock.
2.2 Payments to Holders of Common Stock and FF Preferred Stock.
In the event of any Liquidation Event, after the payment of all preferential amounts required to
be paid to the holders of shares of Preferred Stock, the remaining assets of the Corporation
available for distribution to its stockholders shall be distributed among the holders of shares of
Common Stock and FF Preferred Stock, pro rata based on the number of shares held by each
such holder.
OHSUSA:759368556.4 -3-
2.3 Liquidation Events.

2.3.1 Definition. Each of the following events shall be considered a "Liquidation Event" unless the holders of at least 
a majority of the outstanding shares of
Series B Preferred Stock (such consent, the "Series B Approval") and the holders of at least a majority of the 
outstanding shares of Series C Preferred Stock
(such consent, the "Series C Approval") elect otherwise by written notice sent to the Corporation prior to the effective
date of any such event:

(a) a merger or consolidation in which
(i)
(ii)
the Corporation is a constituent party or
a direct or indirect subsidiary of the
Corporation is a constituent party and either
the Corporation or any of its subsidiaries,
including but not limited to Coinbase, Inc. a
Delaware corporation or Coinbase UK, Ltd.
a private limited company incorporated
under the laws of the United Kingdom
(each, a "Key Subsidiary"), issues shares of
its capital stock pursuant to such merger or
consolidation,
except any such merger or consolidation involving the Corporation or a subsidiary in which the shares of capital stock 
of the Corporation outstanding
immediately prior to such merger or consolidation continue to represent, or are converted into or exchanged for shares 
of capital stock that represent,
immediately following such merger or consolidation, at least a majority, by voting power, of the capital stock of (1) 
the surviving or resulting corporation or

(2) if the surviving or resulting corporation is a wholly-owned subsidiary of another corporation immediately following
such merger or consolidation, the ultimate parent corporation of such surviving or resulting
corporation;

(b) the sale, lease, transfer, exclusive license or other disposition, in a single transaction or series of related 
transactions, by the Corporation or any
subsidiary of the Corporation of all or substantially all the assets of the Corporation and its subsidiaries taken as a 
whole, or the sale or disposition
(whether by merger or otherwise) of one or more subsidiaries of the Corporation if substantially all of the assets of 
the Corporation and its subsidiaries taken
as a whole are held by such subsidiary or subsidiaries, except where such sale, lease, transfer, exclusive license or 
other disposition is to a wholly-owned
subsidiary of the Corporation;

(c) or winding up of a Key Subsidiary; and
(d)
or winding up of the Corporation.
any voluntary or involuntary liquidation, dissolution
any voluntary or involuntary liquidation, dissolution
OFISUSA:7593611556.4 -4-
2.3.2 Effecting a Liquidation Event.

(a) The Corporation shall not have the power to effect a
Liquidation Event referred to in Subsection 2.3.1(a)(i) unless the agreement or plan of merger or
consolidation for such transaction (the "Merger Agreement") provides that the consideration
payable to the stockholders of the Corporation shall be allocated among the holders of capital
stock of the Corporation in accordance with Subsections 2.1 and 2.2.
(b) In the event of a Liquidation Event referred to in
Subsection 2.3.1(aXii), 2.3.1(6) or 2.3.1(c), if the Corporation does not effect a dissolution of the
Corporation under the General Corporation Law within 90 days after such Liquidation Event,
then (i) the Corporation shall send a written notice to each holder of Preferred Stock no later than
the 90th day after the Liquidation Event advising such holders of their right (and the
requirements to be met to secure such right) pursuant to the terms of the following clause (ii) to
require the redemption of such shares of Preferred Stock, and (ii) if the holders of at least a
majority of the then-outstanding shares of Preferred Stock so request in a written instrument
delivered to the Corporation not later than 120 days after such Liquidation Event, the
Corporation shall use the consideration received by the Corporation for such Liquidation Event
(net of any retained liabilities associated with the assets sold or technology licensed, as
determined in good faith by the Board of Directors of the Corporation), together with any other
assets of the Corporation available for distribution to its stockholders, all to the extent permitted
by Delaware law governing distributions to stockholders (the "Available Proceeds"), on the
150th day after such Liquidation Event, to redeem all outstanding shares of Preferred Stock at a
price per share equal to (i) the Series A Liquidation Amount, with regard to each share of Series
A Preferred Stock then outstanding, (ii) the Series B Liquidation Amount, with regard to each
share of Series B Preferred Stock then outstanding and (iii) the Series C Liquidation Amount,
with regard to each share of Series C Preferred Stock then outstanding. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, in the event of a redemption pursuant to the preceding sentence, if the Available
Proceeds are not sufficient to redeem all outstanding shares of Preferred Stock, the Corporation
shall ratably redeem each holder's shares of Preferred Stock to the fullest extent of such
Available Proceeds, and shall redeem the remaining shares as soon as it may lawfully do so
under Delaware law governing distributions to stockholders. Prior to the distribution or
redemption provided for in this Subsection 2.3.2(6), the Corporation shall not expend or dissipate
the consideration received for such Liquidation Event, except to discharge expenses incurred in
connection with such Liquidation Event or in the ordinary course of business.
2.3.3 Amount Deemed Paid or Distributed. The amount deemed
paid or distributed to the holders of capital stock of the Corporation upon any such merger,
consolidation, sale, transfer, exclusive license, other disposition or redemption shall be the cash
or the value of the property, rights or securities paid or distributed to such holders by the
Corporation or the acquiring person, firm or other entity. The value of such property, rights or
securities shall be determined in good faith by the Board of Directors of the Corporation.
2.3.4 Allocation of Escrow Consideration. In the event of a
Liquidation Event pursuant to Subsection 2.3.1(aXi), if any portion of the consideration payable
to the stockholders of the Corporation is placed into escrow or retained as holdback to be
available for satisfaction of indemnification or similar obligations in connection with such
OFISUSA:759368556.4 -5-
Liquidation Event, and payable only upon certain conditions (the "Escrow Consideration"), the
Merger Agreement shall provide that the Escrow Consideration be included with the
consideration to be allocated among the holders of capital stock of the Corporation in accordance
with Subsections 2.1 and 2.2 in connection with such Liquidation Event

3. Voting.
3.1 General. On any matter presented to the stockholders of the
Corporation for their action or consideration at any meeting of stockholders of the Corporation
(or by written consent of stockholders in lieu of meeting), each holder of outstanding shares of
Preferred Stock shall be entitled to cast the number of votes equal to the number of whole shares
of Common Stock into which the shares of Preferred Stock held by such holder are convertible
as of the record date for determining stockholders entitled to vote on such matter. Except as
provided by law or by the other provisions of the Certificate of Incorporation, holders of
Preferred Stock shall vote together with the holders of Common Stock as a single class, with the
holders of Preferred Stock voting on as-converted to Common Stock basis.
3.2 Board of Directors.
3.2.1 Election of Directors The holders of record of the shares of
Series A Preferred Stock, voting exclusively and as a separate series, shall be entitled to elect one

(1) director of the Corporation (the "Series A Director"). The holders of record of the shares of
Series B Preferred Stock, voting exclusively and as a separate series, shall be entitled to elect one

(1) director of the Corporation (the "Series B Director"). The holders of record of the shares of
Series C Preferred Stock, voting exclusively and as a separate series, shall be entitled to elect one
(1) director of the Corporation (the "Series C Director and, together with the Series A Director
and the Series B Director, the "Preferred Directors"). The holders of record of the shares of
Common Stock, voting exclusively and as a separate class, shall be entitled to elect two (2)
directors of the Corporation (the "Common Directors"). The holders of record of the shares of
Preferred Stock, Common Stock and FF Preferred Stock, voting together as a single class on an
as-converted to Common Stock basis, shall be entitled to elect directors to fill any remaining
vacancies on the Board of Directors of the Corporation (each, an "Additional Director"). Any
director elected as provided in this Subsection 3.2 may be removed without cause by, and only
by, the affirmative vote of the holders of the shares of the class or series of capital stock entitled
to elect such director or directors, given either at a special meeting of such stockholders duly
called for that purpose or pursuant to a written consent of stockholders. If the holders of shares
of Series A Preferred Stock, Series B Preferred Stock or Common Stock, as the case may be, fail
to elect a sufficient number of directors to fill all directorships for which they are entitled to elect
directors, voting exclusively and as a separate class or series, as applicable, pursuant to the first
sentence of this Subsection 3.2, then any directorship not so filled shall remain vacant until such
time as the holders of the A Preferred Stock, Series B Preferred Stock or Common Stock, as the
case may be, elect a person to fill such directorship by vote or written consent in lieu of a
meeting; and no such directorship may be filled by stockholders of the Corporation other than by
the stockholders of the Corporation that are entitled to elect a person to fill such directorship,
voting exclusively and as a separate class or series, as applicable. The holders of record of the
shares of Common Stock and of any other class or series of voting stock (including the Preferred
Stock), exclusively and voting together as a single class on an as-converted to Common Stock
OFISUSA.759368556.4 -6-
basis, shall be entitled to elect the balance of the total number of directors of the Corporation. At any meeting held 
for the purpose of electing a director,
the presence in person or by proxy of the holders of a majority of the outstanding shares of the class or series 
entitled to elect such director shall
constitute a quorum for the purpose of electing such director. Except as otherwise provided in this Subsection 3.2, a 
vacancy in any directorship filled by the
holders of any class or series shall be filled only by vote or written consent in lieu of a meeting of the holders of 
such class or series or by any remaining
director or directors elected by the holders of such class or series pursuant to this Subsection 3.2.
3.2.2 Voting of Directors. At meetings of the Board of Directors, the directors of the Corporation then in office shall 
be entitled to the following votes:

(a) The Common Directors then in office shall be entitled to cast four (4) votes in the aggregate, unless increased to 
an aggregate of five (5) votes pursuant
to Section 3.2.2(e) below (the "Common Director Votes").

(b) Should one (1) Common Director serve on the Board of Directors, such Common Director shall be entitled to cast all 
four (4) or five (5) of the Common
Director Votes, as applicable.

(c) Should two (2) Common Directors serve on the Board of Directors, (i) if the number of Common Director Votes is equal
to four (4), then each of the
then-serving Common Directors shall be entitled to cast two (2) of the Common Director Votes, and (ii) if the number of 
Common Director Votes is equal to five
(5), then (x) if one of such Common Directors is the CEO Director (as defined in the Voting Agreement dated on or about 
December 1, 2014, as the same may be
amended or restated from time to time), the CEO Director shall be entitled to cast three (3) of the Common Director 
Votes and the remaining Common Director
shall be entitled to cast two (2) of the Common Director Votes, and (y) if neither of the then-serving Common Directors 
is the CEO Director, then each of the
then-serving Common Directors shall be entitled to cast two and one half (2.5) of the Common Director Votes.

(d) Each of the Preferred Directors and any Additional
Directors shall be entitled to cast only one (1) vote per director.

(e) Should a seat reserved for an Additional Director be vacant, then the number of Common Director Votes shall be 
increased from four (4) to five (5).
(f) Every reference in this Certificate of Incorporation and the Bylaws of the Corporation, in each case as the same may
be amended or restated from time to
time, to a majority or other proportion of the directors of the Corporation shall refer to a majority or other 
proportion of the votes of the directors. The
voting rules set forth in this Section 3.2.2 shall apply to any vote taken at any meeting of a committee or 
sub-committee of the Board of Directors, such that,
at any meeting of a committee or sub-committee of the Board of Directors, each director shall be entitled to cast the 
number of votes he or she would be
entitled to cast if the vote were being taken at a meeting of the Board of Directors.
OFISUSA:759368556.4 -7-
3.3 Preferred Stock Protective Provisions. At any time when shares
of Preferred Stock are outstanding, the Corporation shall not, either directly or indirectly by
amendment, merger, consolidation or otherwise, do any of the following without (in addition to
any other vote required by law or the Certificate of Incorporation) the written consent or
affirmative vote of the holders of at least a majority of the then outstanding shares of Preferred
Stock (for the avoidance of doubt, not including any shares of FF Preferred Stock) given in
writing or by vote at a meeting, consenting or voting (as the case may be) together as a single
class on an as-converted to Common Stock basis, and any such act or transaction entered into
without such consent or vote shall be null and void ab initio, and of no force or effect:
3.3.1 amend, alter or repeal any provision of the Certificate of
Incorporation or Bylaws of the Corporation or authorize the amendment, alteration or repeal of
any provisions of the certificate of incorporation, bylaws, articles of association or similar
charter documents of any Key Subsidiary;
3.3.2 increase the authorized number of shares of Preferred Stock
or increase the authorized number of shares of any additional class or series of capital stock of
the Corporation or authorize any increase to the authorized shares of common stock or the
creation or issuance of shares of any additional class or series of capital stock of any Key
Subsidiary;
3.3.3 create, or authorize the creation of, or issue or obligate
itself to issue shares of, any additional class or series of capital stock unless the same ranks
junior to each existing series of Preferred Stock with respect to the distribution of assets on a
Liquidation Event, the payment of dividends and rights of redemption and not senior to any
existing series of Preferred Stock with respect to voting;
3.3.4 (i) reclassify, alter or amend any existing security of the
Corporation that is pari passu with an existing series of Preferred Stock in respect of the
distribution of assets on a Liquidation Event, the payment of dividends or rights of redemption, if
such reclassification, alteration or amendment would render such other security senior to an
existing series of Preferred Stock in respect of any such right, preference or privilege, or (ii)
reclassify, alter or amend any existing security of the Corporation that is junior to an existing
series of Preferred Stock in respect of the distribution of assets on a Liquidation Event, the
payment of dividends or rights of redemption, if such reclassification, alteration or amendment
would render such other security senior to or pan passu with an existing series of Preferred Stock
in respect of any such right, preference or privilege, provided that this Subsection 3.3.4 shall not
apply to the conversion of FF Preferred Stock into Subsequent Preferred Stock pursuant to
Subsection 4.7 of Part C of this Article Fourth;
3.3.5 purchase or redeem (or permit any subsidiary to purchase
or redeem) or pay or declare any dividend or make any distribution on, any shares of capital
stock of the Corporation other than (i) redemptions of or dividends or distributions on the
Preferred Stock as expressly authorized herein, (ii) dividends or other distributions payable on
the Common Stock solely in the form of additional shares of Common Stock, (iii) repurchases of
stock from former employees, officers, directors, consultants or other persons who performed
services for the Corporation or any subsidiary in connection with the cessation of such
O11SUSk.759368556A -8-
employment or service at the lower of the original purchase price or the then-current fair market value thereof, (iv) 
repurchases of stock in connection with
the exercise of any fight of first refusal held by the Corporation, or (v) as otherwise approved by the Board of 
Directors including a Preferred Director;
3.3.6 create, or hold capital stock in, any subsidiary that is not wholly owned (either directly or through one or more 
other subsidiaries) by the Corporation,
or sell, transfer or otherwise dispose of any capital stock of any direct or indirect subsidiary of the Corporation, or 
permit any direct or indirect subsidiary
to sell, lease, transfer, exclusively license or otherwise dispose (in a single transaction or series of related 
transactions) of all or substantially all of
the assets of such subsidiary;
3.3.7 liquidate, dissolve or wind-up the business and affairs of the Corporation or authorize the liquidation, 
dissolution and winding up of the business and
affairs of the Key Subsidiary, effect any merger or consolidation or any other Liquidation Event, or consent to any of 
the foregoing;
3.3.8 increase or decrease the authorized number of directors constituting the Board of Directors;
3.3.9 create, or authorize the creation of, or issue, or authorize the issuance of any debt security, or permit any 
subsidiary to take any such action with
respect to any debt security, if the aggregate indebtedness of the Corporation and its subsidiaries for borrowed money 
following such action would exceed
$2,000,000, unless approved by the Board of Directors;
3.3.10 increase the number of shares reserved for issuance under the Corporation's equity compensation plans or 
arrangements; or
3.3.11 enter into a contract or transaction between the Corporation (or any direct or indirect subsidiary of the 
Corporation) and any other corporation,
partnership, association or other organization in which one or more of the officers or directors of the Corporation is 
an officer or director of, or has a
financial interest in, such other corporation, partnership, association or other organization, unless approved by the 
Board of Directors (including a majority
of disinterested directors).

3.4 Series A Preferred Stock Protective Provisions. At any time when at least 1,000,000 shares of Series A Preferred 
Stock are outstanding the Corporation shall
not, either directly or indirectly by amendment, merger, consolidation or otherwise, increase or decrease the authorized
number of shares of Series A Preferred
Stock or amend, alter or repeal any provision of the Certificate of Incorporation or Bylaws of the Corporation in a 
manner that adversely affects the rights and
preferences of the Series A Preferred Stock in a manner different than the other series of Preferred Stock without (in 
addition to any other vote required by
law or the Certificate of Incorporation) the written consent or affirmative vote of the holders of at least a majority 
of the then outstanding shares of Series
A Preferred Stock, voting exclusively and as a separate series, given in writing or by vote at a meeting, and any such 
act or transaction entered into without
such consent or vote shall be null and void ab initio, and of no force or effect.
OHSUSA:75936S556.4 -9-
3.5 Series B Preferred Stock Protective Provisions. At any time when at least 1,000,000 shares of Series B Preferred 
Stock are outstanding the Corporation shall
not, either directly or indirectly by amendment, merger, consolidation or otherwise, do any of the following without (in
addition to any other vote required by
law or the Certificate of Incorporation) the approval of the holders of at least two-thirds of the Series B Preferred 
Stock given in writing or by vote at a
meeting and voting exclusively and as a separate series (the "Series B 2/3rds Approval"), and any such act or 
transaction entered into without such consent or
vote shall be null and void ab batio, and of no force or effect:
3.5.1 increase or decrease the authorized number of shares of Series B Preferred Stock;
3.5.2 amend, alter or repeal any provision of the Certificate of Incorporation or Bylaws of the Corporation or authorize
the amendment, alteration or repeal of
any provisions of the certificate of incorporation, bylaws, articles of association or similar charter documents of any 
Key Subsidiary, in either case, in a
manner that adversely affects the rights and preferences of the Series B Preferred Stock in a manner different than the 
other series of Preferred Stock;
3.5.3 waive the treatment of a Liquidation Event pursuant to Subsection 2.3.1;
3.5.4 waive the price-based antidilution provisions applicable to the Series B Preferred Stock in Section 4.4 hereof;
3.5.5 amend the mandatory conversion provisions in Section 5 hereof;
3.5.6 alter or permit any Key Subsidiary's board of directors (or similar governing body) to alter the composition of 
the board of directors of such Key
Subsidiary; or
3.5.7 permit any Key Subsidiary or Key Subsidiary's board of
directors (or similar governing body) to take any action without the approval of the Corporation's board of directors.
3.6 Series C Preferred Stock Protective Provisions. At any time when at least 1,000,000 shares of Series C Preferred 
Stock are outstanding the Corporation shall
not, either directly or indirectly by amendment, merger, consolidation or otherwise, do any of the following without (in
addition to any other vote required by
law or the Certificate of Incorporation) the approval of the holders of at least a majority of the Series C Preferred 
Stock given in writing or by vote at a
meeting and voting exclusively and as a separate series (the "Series C Majority Approval"), and any such act or 
transaction entered into without such consent or
vote shall be null and void ab Mille, and of no force or effect:
3.6.1 increase or decrease the authorized number of shares of Series C Preferred Stock;
OlISUSA:759368556.4 -10-
3.6.2 amend, alter or repeal any provision of the Certificate of Incorporation or Bylaws of the Corporation or authorize
the amendment, alteration or repeal of
any provisions of the certificate of incorporation, bylaws, articles of association or similar charter documents of any 
Key Subsidiary, in either case, in a
manner that adversely affects the rights and preferences of the Series C Preferred Stock in a manner different than the 
other series of Preferred Stock;
3.6.3 waive the treatment of a Liquidation Event pursuant to Subsection 2.3.1;
3.6.4 waive the price-based antidilution provisions applicable to the Series C Preferred Stock in Section 4.4 hereof;
3.6.5 amend the mandatory conversion provisions in Section 5 hereof;
3.6.6 alter or permit any Key Subsidiary's board of directors (or
similar governing body) to alter the composition of the board of directors (or similar governing
body) of the Key Subsidiary; or
3.6.7 permit any Key Subsidiary or such Key Subsidiary's board
of directors (or similar governing body) to take any action without the approval of the
Corporation's board of directors.
4. Optional Conversion.

The holders of the Preferred Stock shall have conversion rights as follows (the "Conversion Rights"):
4.1 Right to Convert.
4.1.1 Conversion Ratio. Each share of Preferred Stock shall be
convertible, at the option of the holder thereof, at any time and from time to time, and without
the payment of additional consideration by the holder thereof into such number of fully paid and nonacsessable shares of
Common Stock as is determined by
dividing the Series A Original Issue
Price, Series B Original Issue Price or Series C Original Issue Price, as applicable, by the Series
A Conversion Price (as defined below), Series B Conversion Price (as defined below) or Series C Conversion Price (as 
defined below), as applicable, in effect at
the time of conversion. The "Series A Conversion Price" shall initially be equal to the Series A Original Issue Price, 
the "Series B Conversion Price" shall
initially be equal to the Series B Original Issue Price and the "Series C Conversion Price" shall initially be equal to 
the Series C Original Issue Price. Such
initial Conversion Prices, and the rate at which shams of Preferred Stock may be converted into
shares of Common Stock, shall be subject to adjustment as provided below.

4.12 Termination of Conversion Rights. In the event of a Liquidation Event, the Conversion Rights shall terminate at the
close of business on the last full day
preceding the date fixed for the payment of any such amounts distributable on such event to the holders of Preferred 
Stock.
OITSUSA:759368556A -II-
4.2 Fractional Shares. No fractional shares of Common Stock shall be issued upon conversion of the Preferred Stock. In 
lieu of any fractional shares to which
the holder would otherwise be entitled, the Corporation shall pay cash equal to such fraction multiplied by the fair 
market value of a share of Common Stock as
determined in good faith by the Board of Directors of the Corporation. Whether or not fractional shares would be 
issuable upon such conversion shall be
determined on the basis of the total number of shares of Preferred Stock the holder is at the time converting into 
Common Stock and the aggregate number of
shares of Common Stock issuable upon such conversion.
4.3 Mechanics of Conversion.

4.3.1 Notice of Conversion. In order for a holder of Preferred Stock to voluntarily convert shares of Preferred Stock 
into shares of Common Stock, such holder
shall surrender the certificate or certificates for such shares of Preferred Stock (or, if such registered holder 
alleges that such certificate has been lost,
stolen or destroyed, a lost certificate
affidavit and agreement reasonably acceptable to the Corporation to indemnify the Corporation against any claim that may
be made against the Corporation on
account of the alleged loss, theft or destruction of such certificate), at the office of the transfer agent for the 
Preferred Stock (or at the principal office
of the Corporation if the Corporation serves as its own transfer agent), together with written notice that such holder 
elects to convert all or any number of
the shares of the Preferred Stock represented by such certificate or certificates and, if applicable, any event on which
such conversion is contingent. Such
notice shall state such holder's name or the names of the nominees in which such holder wishes the certificate or 
certificates for shares of Common Stock to be
issued. If required by the Corporation, certificates surrendered for conversion shall be endorsed or accompanied by a 
written instrument or instruments of
transfer, in form satisfactory to the Corporation, duly executed by the registered holder or his, her or its attorney 
duly authorized in writing. The close of
business on the date of receipt by the transfer agent (or by the Corporation if the Corporation serves as its own 
transfer agent) of such certificates (or lost
certificate affidavit and agreement) and notice shall be the time of conversion (the "Conversion Time"), and the shares 
of Common Stock issuable upon conversion
of the shares represented by such certificate shall be deemed to be outstanding of record as of such date. The 
Corporation
shall, as soon as practicable after the Conversion Time, (i) issue and deliver to such holder of Preferred Stock, or to 
his, her or its nominees, a certificate
or certificates for the number of MI shares of Common Stock issuable upon such conversion in accordance with the 
provisions hereof and a certificate for the
number (if any) of the shares of Preferred Stock represented by the surrendered certificate that were not converted into
Common Stock, (ii) pay in cash such
amount as provided in Subsection 4.2 in lieu of any fraction of a share of Common Stock otherwise issuable upon such 
conversion and (iii) pay all declared but
unpaid dividends on the shares of Preferred Stock converted.

4.3.2 Reservation of Shares. The Corporation shall at all times when the Preferred Stock shall be outstanding, reserve 
and keep available out of its authorized
but unissued capital stock, for the purpose of effecting the conversion of the Preferred Stock, such number of its duly 
authorized shares of Common Stock as
shall from time to time be sufficient to effect the conversion of all outstanding Preferred Stock; and if at any time 
the number of authorized but unissued
shares of Common Stock shall not be sufficient to effect the conversion of all then outstanding shares of the Preferred 
Stock, the Corporation shall take such
OMUSA:759368556.4 -12-
corporate action as may be necessary to increase its authorized but unissued shares of Common Stock to such number of 
shares as shall be sufficient for such
purposes, including, without limitation, engaging in best efforts to obtain the requisite stockholder approval of any 
necessary amendment to the Certificate of
Incorporation. Before taking any action which would cause an adjustment reducing the Series A. Conversion Price, Series 
B Conversion Price or Series C
Conversion Price below the then par value of the shares of Common Stock issuable upon conversion of the Series A 
Preferred Stock, Series B Preferred Stock or
Series C Preferred Stock, as applicable, the Corporation will take any corporate action which may, in the opinion of its
counsel, be necessary in order that the
Corporation may validly and legally issue fully paid and nonassessable shares of Common Stock at such adjusted Series A 
Conversion Price, Series B Conversion
Price or Series C Conversion Price, as applicable.

4.3.3 Effect of Conversion. All shares of Preferred Stock which shall have been surrendered for conversion as herein 
provided shall no longer be deemed to be
outstanding and all rights with respect to such shares shall immediately cease and terminate at the Conversion Time, 
except only the right of the holders
thereof to receive shares of Common Stock in exchange therefor, to receive payment in lieu of any fraction of a share 
otherwise issuable upon such conversion as
provided in Subsection 4.2 and to receive payment of any dividends declared but unpaid thereon. Any shares of Preferred 
Stock so converted shall be retired and
cancelled and may not be reissued as shares of such series, and the Corporation may thereafter take such appropriate 
action (without the need for stockholder
action) as may be necessary to reduce the authorized number of shares of Preferred Stock accordingly.
4.3.4 No Further Adjustment. Upon any such conversion, no adjustment to the Series A Conversion Price, Series B 
Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price
shall be made for any declared but unpaid dividends on the Series A Preferred Stock, Series B Preferred Stock or Series 
C Preferred Stock surrendered for
conversion or on the Common Stock delivered upon conversion.

4.3.5 Taxes. The Corporation shall pay any and all issue and other similar taxes that may be payable in respect of any 
issuance or delivery of shares of Common
Stock upon conversion of shares of Preferred Stock pursuant to this Section 4. The Corporation shall not, however, be 
required to pay any tax which may be
payable in respect of any transfer involved in the issuance and delivery of shares of Common Stock in a name other than 
that in which the shares of Preferred
Stock so converted were registered, and no such issuance or delivery shall be made unless and until the person or entity
requesting such issuance has paid to
the Corporation the amount of any such tax or has established, to the satisfaction of the Corporation, that such tax has
been paid.
4.4 Adjustments to Conversion Price for Diluting Issues.

4.4.1 Special Definitions. For purposes of this Article Fourth, the following definitions shall apply:

(a) "Option" shall mean rights, options or warrants to subscribe for, purchase or otherwise acquire Common Stock or 
Convertible Securities.
O11SUSA:759368556.4 -13-

(b) "Original Issue Date" shall mean the date on which the first share of Series C Preferred Stock was issued.

(c) "Convertible Securities" shall mean any evidences of indebtedness, shares or other securities directly or indirectly
convertible into or exchangeable for
Common Stock, but excluding Options.

(d) "Additional Shares of Common Stock" shall mean all shares of Common Stock issued (or, pursuant to Subsection 4.4.3 
below, deemed to be issued) by the
Corporation after the Original Issue Date, other than (1) the following shares of Common Stock and (2) shares of Common 
Stock deemed issued pursuant to the
following Options and Convertible Securities (clauses (1) and (2), collectively, "Exempted Securities"):

(i) shares of Common Stock or Options issued
to employees or directors of, or consultants
or advisors to, the Corporation or any of its
subsidiaries pursuant to a plan, agreement or
arrangement approved by the Board of
Directors of the Corporation;

(ii) shares of Common Stock, Options or
Convertible Securities issued to banks,
equipment lessors or other financial
institutions, or to real property lessors,
pursuant to a debt financing, equipment
leasing or real property leasing transaction
approved by the Board of Directors of the
Corporation, including at least one Preferred
Director,
(iii) shares of Common Stock, Options or
Convertible Securities issued pursuant to the
acquisition of another corporation by the
Corporation by merger, purchase of
substantially all of the assets or other
reorganization or to a joint venture
agreement, provided that such issuances are
approved by the Board of Directors of the
Corporation, including at least one Preferred
Director,

(iv) shares of Common Stock, Options or
Convertible Securities issued in connection
with sponsored research, collaboration,
technology liaci ge development, OEM,
marketing or other similar agreements or
strategic partnerships approved by the Board
OHSUSA: 759368556.4 -14-
of Directors of the Corporation, including at
least one Preferred Director,

(v) shares of Common Stock, Options or
Convertible Securities issued by reason of a
dividend, stock split, split-up or other
distribution on shares of Common Stock that
is covered by Subsection 4.5, 4.6, 4.7 or 4.8;

(vi) Common Stock issued or issuable in a
Qualified IPO;
(vii) shares of Common Stock, Options or
Convertible Securities issued upon
conversion of or as a dividend or
distribution on Preferred Stock;
(viii) shares of Common Stock or Convertible
Securities actually issued upon the exercise
of Options or shares of Common Stock
actually issued upon the conversion or
exchange of Convertible Securities, in each
case provided such issuance is pursuant to
the terms of such Option or Convertible
Security; or
securities issued or issuable in any other
transaction for which exemption from these
price-based antidilution provisions is
approved before or after issuance of the
securities by the Board of Directors of the
Corporation, including at least one Preferred
Director and, if the issuance of such
securities would result in an adjustment of
the Series C Conversion Price but not the
Series B Conversion Price or Series A
Conversion Price, the Series C Majority
Approval.

4.4.2 No Adjustment of Conversion Price. No adjustment in the Scries A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or 
Series C Conversion Price shall be made as
the result of the issuance or deemed issuance of Additional Shares of Common Stock if the Corporation receives Series B 
2/3rds Approval and Series C Majority
Approval agreeing that no such adjustment shall be made as the result of the issuance or deemed issuance of such 
Additional Shares of Common Stock.
alSUSA:759363556.4 -15-
4.4.3 Deemed Issue of Additional Shares of Common Stock.

(a) If the Corporation at any time or from time to time after the Original Issue Date shall issue any Options or 
Convertible Securities (excluding Options or
Convertible Securities which are themselves Exempted Securities) or shall fix a record date for the determination of 
holders of any class of securities entitled
to receive any such Options or Convertible Securities, then the maximum number of shares of Common Stock (as set forth 
in the instrument relating thereto,
assuming the satisfaction of any conditions to exercisability, convertibility or exchangeability but without regard to 
any provision contained therein for a
subsequent adjustment of such number) issuable upon the exercise of such Options or, in the case of Convertible 
Securities and Options therefor, the conversion
or exchange of such Convertible Securities, shall be deemed to be Additional Shares of Common Stock issued as of the 
time of such issue or, in case such a
record date shall have been fixed, as of the close of business on such record date.

(b) If the terms of any Option or Convertible Security, the issuance of which resulted in an adjustment to the Series A 
Conversion Price, Series B Conversion
Price or Series C Conversion Price pursuant to the terms of Subsection 4.4.4, are revised as a result of an amendment to
such terms or any other adjustment
pursuant to the provisions of such Option or Convertible Security (but excluding automatic adjustments to such terms 
pursuant to anti-dilution or similar
provisions of such Option or Convertible Security) to provide for either (1) any increase or decrease in the number of 
shares of Common Stock issuable upon the
exercise, conversion and/or exchange of any such Option or Convertible Security or (2) any increase or decrease in the 
consideration payable to the Corporation
upon such exercise, conversion and/or exchange, then, effective upon such increase or decrease becoming effective, the 
Series A Conversion Price, Series B
Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price, as applicable, computed upon the original issue of such Option or 
Convertible Security (or upon the occurrence of
a record date with respect thereto) shall be readjusted to such Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or 
Series C Conversion Price, as
applicable, as would have obtained had such revised terms been in effect upon the original date of issuance of such 
Option or Convertible Security.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, no readjustment pursuant to this clause (b) shall have the effect of increasing the 
Series A Conversion Price, Series B
Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price to an amount which exceeds the lower of (i) the Series A Conversion Price,
Series B Conversion Price or Series C
Conversion Price, as applicable, in effect immediately prior to the original adjustment made as a result of the issuance
of such Option or Convertible Security,
or (ii) the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price, as applicable, that would
have resulted from any issuances of
Additional Shares of Common Stock (other than deemed issuances of Additional Shares of Common Stock as a result of the 
issuance of such Option or Convertible
Security) between the original adjustment date and such readjustment date.

(c) If the terms of any Option or Convertible Security (excluding Options or Convertible Securities which are themselves
Exempted Securities), the issuance of
which did not result in an adjustment to the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C Conversion
Price pursuant to the terms of
Subsection 4.4.4 (either because the consideration per share (determined pursuant to Subsection 4.4.5) of the Additional
Shares of Common Stock subject thereto
was equal to or greater than the Series A Conversion
OHSUSA:75936,1556 4 -16-
Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price, as applicable, then in effect, or because such Option or 
Convertible Security was issued before
the Original Issue Date), are revised after the Original Issue Date as a result of an amendment to such terms or any 
other adjustment pursuant to the provisions
of such Option or Convertible Security (but excluding automatic adjustments to such terms pursuant to anti-dilution or 
similar provisions of such Option or
Convertible Security) to provide for either (1) any increase in the number of shares of Common Stock issuable upon the 
exercise, conversion or exchange of any
such Option or Convertible Security or (2) any decrease in the consideration payable to the Corporation upon such 
exercise, conversion or exchange, then such
Option or Convertible Security, as so amended
or adjusted, and the Additional Shares of Common Stock subject thereto (determined in the manner provided in Subsection 
4.4.3(a) shall be deemed to have been
issued effective upon such increase or decrease becoming effective.

(d) Upon the expiration or termination of any unexercised Option or unconverted or unexchanged Convertible Security (or 
portion thereof) which resulted (either
upon its original issuance or upon a revision of its terms) in an adjustment to the Series A Conversion Price, Series B 
Conversion Price or Series C Conversion
Price, as applicable, pursuant to the terms of Subsection 4.4.4, the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion 
Price and Series C Conversion Price shall
each be readjusted to such Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price and Series C Conversion Price as would 
have obtained had such Option or
Convertible Security (or portion thereof) never been issued.

(e) If the number of shares of Common Stock issuable upon the exercise, conversion and/or exchange of any Option or 
Convertible Security, or the consideration
payable to the Corporation upon such exercise, conversion and/or exchange, is calculable at the time such Option or 
Convertible Security is issued or amended
but is subject to adjustment based upon subsequent events, any adjustment to the Series A Conversion Price, Series B 
Conversion Price or Series C Conversion
Price provided for in this Subsection 4.4.3 shall be effected at the time of such issuance or amendment based on such 
number of shares or amount of
consideration without regard to any provisions for subsequent adjustments (and any subsequent adjustments shall be 
treated as provided in clauses (b) and (c) of
this Subsection 4.4.3). If the number of shares of Common Stock issuable upon the exercise, conversion and/or exchange 
of any Option or Convertible Security, or
the consideration payable to the Corporation upon such exercise, conversion and/or exchange, cannot be calculated at all
at the time such Option or Convertible
Security is issued or amended, any adjustment to the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C 
Conversion Price that would result under
the terms of this Subsection 4.4.3 at the time of such issuance or amendment shall instead be effected at the time such 
number of shares and/or amount of
consideration is first calculable (even if subject to subsequent adjustments), assuming for purposes of calculating such
adjustment to the Series A Conversion
Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price that such issuance or amendment took place at the time 
such calculation can first be made.
4.4.4 Adjustment of Conversion Price Unon Issuance of Additional Shares of Common Stock. In the event the Corporation 
shall at any time after the Original Issue
Date issue Additional Shares of Common Stock (including Additional Shares of Common Stock deemed to be issued pursuant 
to Subsection 4.4.3), without
consideration or for a consideration per share less than the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or
OHSUSA:759368556.4 -17-
Series C Conversion Price, as applicable, in effect immediately prior to such issue, then the Series A Conversion Price,
Series B Conversion Price or Series C
Conversion Price, as applicable, shall be reduced, concurrently with such issue, to a price (calculated to the nearest 
one-hundredth of a cent) determined in
accordance with the following formula:
CP2 =CP I* (A + B) + (A + C).
For purposes of the foregoing formula, the following definitions shall apply:

(a) "CP2" shall mean the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price, as 
applicable, in effect immediately after such
issue of Additional Shares of Common Stock

(b) "CPI" shall mean the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price, as 
applicable, in effect immediately prior to such
issue of Additional Shares of Common Stock;

(c) "A" shall mean the number of shares of Common Stock outstanding immediately prior to such issue of Additional Shares
of Common Stock (treating for this
purpose as outstanding all shares of Common Stock issuable upon exercise of Options outstanding immediately prior to 
such issue or upon conversion or exchange
of Convertible Securities (including the Preferred Stock) outstanding (assuming exercise of any outstanding Options 
therefor) immediately prior to such issue);

(d) "B" shall mean the number of shares of Common Stock that would have been issued if such Additional Shares of Common 
Stock had been issued at a price per
share equal to CPI (determined by dividing the aggregate consideration received by the Corporation in respect of such 
issue by CPO; and

(e) "C" shall mean the number of such Additional Shares of Common Stock issued in such transaction.
4.4.5 Determination of Consideration. For purposes of this Subsection 4.4, the consideration received by the Corporation
for the issue of any Additional Shares
of Common Stock shall be computed as follows:

(a) Cash and Property: Such consideration shall:
(i) insofar as it consists of cash, be computed at
the aggregate amount of cash received by
the Corporation, excluding amounts paid or
payable for accrued interest;

(ii) insofar as it consists of property other than
cash be computed at the fair market value
thereof at the time of such issue, as
determined in good faith by the Board of
Directors of the Corporation; and
MUSA:739368556.4 -18-
(iii) in the event Additional Shares of Common
Stock are issued together with other shares
or securities or other assets of the
Corporation for consideration which covers
both, be the proportion of such consideration
so received, computed as provided in
clauses (i) and (ii) above, as determined in
good faith by the Board of Directors of the
Corporation.

(b) Options and Convertible Securities. The consideration per share received by the Corporation for Additional Shares of
Common Stock deemed to have been issued
pursuant to Subsection 4.4.3, relating to Options and Convertible Securities, shall be determined by dividing
the total amount, if any, received or receivable by the Corporation as consideration for the issue of such Options or 
Convertible Securities, plus the minimum
aggregate amount of additional consideration (as set forth in the instruments relating thereto, without regard to any 
provision contained therein for a
subsequent adjustment of such consideration) payable to the Corporation upon the exercise of such Options or the 
conversion or exchange of such Convertible
Securities, or in the case of Options for Convertible Securities, the exercise of such Options for Convertible 
Securities and the conversion or exchange of such
Convertible Securities, by
(i) the maximum number of shares of Common
Stock (as set forth in the instruments relating
thereto, without regard to any provision
contained therein for a subsequent
adjustment of such number) issuable upon
the exercise of such Options or the
conversion or exchange of such Convertible
Securities, or in the case of Options for
Convertible Securities, the exercise of such
Options for Convertible Securities and the
conversion or exchange of such Convertible
Securities.

4.4.6 Multiple Closing Dates. In the event the Corporation shall issue on more than one date Additional Shares of Common
Stock that are apart of one transaction
or a series of related transactions and that would result in an adjustment to the Series A Conversion Price, Series B 
Conversion Price or Series C Conversion
Price pursuant to the terms of Subsection 4A.4, and such issuance dates occur within a period of no more than 90 days 
from the first such issuance to the final
such issuance, then, upon the final such issuance, the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C 
Conversion Price, as applicable, shall
be readjusted to give effect to all such issuances as if they occurred on the date of the rust such issuance (and 
without giving effect to any additional
adjustments as a result of any such subsequent issuances within such period).
OHSUSA:759368556.4 -19-
4.5 Adjustment for Stock Splits and Combinations. If the Corporation
shall at any time or from time to time after the Original Issue Date effect a subdivision of the outstanding Common 
Stock, the Series A Conversion Price, Series
B Conversion Price and Series C Conversion Price in effect immediately before that subdivision shall be proportionately 
decreased so that the number of shares
of Common Stock issuable on conversion of each share of such series shall be increased in proportion to such increase in
the aggregate number of shares of
Common Stock outstanding. If the Corporation shall at any time or from time to time after the Original Issue Date 
combine the outstanding shares of Common
Stock, the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price and Series C Conversion Price in effect immediately 
before the combination shall be
proportionately increased so that the number of shares of Common Stock issuable on conversion of each share of such 
series shall be decreased in proportion to
such decrease in the aggregate number of shares of Common Stock outstanding. Any adjustment under this subsection shall 
become effective at the close of
business on the date the subdivision or combination becomes effective.

4.6 Adjustment for Certain Dividends and Distributions. In the event the Corporation at any time or from time to time 
after the Original Issue Date shall make
or issue, or fix a record date for the determination of holders of Common Stock entitled to receive, a dividend or other
distribution payable on the Common
Stock in additional shares of Common Stock, then and in each such event the Series A Conversion Price, Series B 
Conversion Price and Series C Conversion Price
in effect immediately before such event shall be decreased as of the time of such issuance or, in the event such a 
record date shall have been fixed, as of the
close of business on such record date, by multiplying the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion
Price or Series C Conversion Price, as applicable, then in effect by a fraction:

(1) the numerator of which shall be the total number of shares of Common Stock issued and outstanding immediately prior 
to the time of such issuance or the
close of business on such record date, and
(2) the denominator of which shall be the total number of shares of Common Stock issued and outstanding immediately 
prior to the time of such issuance or the
close of business on such record date plus the number of shares of Common Stock issuable in payment of such dividend or 
distribution.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, (a) if such record date shall have been fixed and such dividend is not fully paid or if 
such distribution is not fully made on
the date fixed therefor, the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price, as 
applicable, shall be recomputed accordingly
as of the close of business on such record date and thereafter the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price 
and Series C Conversion Price shall be
adjusted pursuant to this subsection as of the time of actual payment of such dividends or distributions; and (b) that 
no such adjustment shall be made to the
Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price, as applicable, if the holders of 
Series A Preferred Stock, Series B Preferred
Stock or Series C Preferred Stock, as applicable, simultaneously receive a dividend or other distribution of shares of 
Common Stock in a number equal to the
number of shares of Common Stock as they would have received if all outstanding shares of Series A Preferred Stock, 
Series B Preferred Stock or Series C
Preferred Stock, as applicable, had been converted into Common Stock on the date of such event.
OHSUSA:759363556.4 -20-
4.7 Adjustments for Other Dividends and Distributions. In the event the Corporation at any time or from time to time 
after the Original Issue Date shall make or
issue, or fix a record date for the determination of holders of Common Stock entitled to receive, a dividend or other 
distribution payable in securities of the
Corporation (other than a distribution of shares of Common Stock in respect of outstanding shares of Common Stock) or in
other property and the provisions of

Section 1 do not apply to such dividend or distribution, then and in each such event the holders of Series A Preferred 
Stock, Series B Preferred Stock and
Series C Preferred Stock, as applicable, shall receive, simultaneously with the distribution to the holders of Common 
Stock, a dividend or other distribution of
such securities or other property in an amount equal to the amount of such securities or other property as they would 
have received if all outstanding shares of
Series A Preferred Stock, Series B Preferred Stock or Series C Preferred Stock, as applicable, had been convened into 
Common Stock on the date of such event
4.8 Adjustment for Merger or Reorganization. etc. Subject to the provisions of Subsection 2.3, if there shall occur any 
reorganization, recapitalization,
reclassification, consolidation or merger involving the Corporation in which the Common Stock (but not the Preferred 
Stock) is converted into or exchanged for
securities, cash or other property (other than a transaction covered by Subsections 4.4, 4.6 or 4.7), then, following 
any such reorganization, recapitalization,
reclassification, consolidation or merger, each share of Preferred Stock shall thereafter be convertible in lieu of the 
Common Stock into which it was
convertible prior to such event into the kind and amount of securities, cash or other property which a holder of the 
number of shares of Common Stock of the
Corporation issuable upon conversion of one share of Preferred Stock immediately prior to such reorganization, 
recapitalization, reclassification, consolidation
or merger would have been entitled to receive pursuant to such transaction; and, in such case, appropriate adjustment 
(as determined in good faith by the Board
of Directors of the Corporation) shall be made in the application of the provisions in this Section 4 with respect to 
the rights and interests thereafter of the
holders of the Preferred Stock, to the end that the provisions set forth in this Section 4 (including provisions with 
respect to changes in and other
adjustments of the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price and Series C Conversion Price) shall thereafter 
be applicable, as nearly as reasonably
may be, in relation to any securities or other property thereafter deliverable upon the conversion of the Series A 
Preferred Stock, Series B Preferred Stock or
Series C Preferred Stock.

4.9 Certificate as to Adjustments. Upon the occurrence of each adjustment or readjustment of the Series A Conversion 
Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series
C Conversion Price pursuant to this Section 4, the Corporation at its expense shall, as promptly as reasonably 
practicable but in any event not later than 10
days thereafter, compute such adjustment or readjustment in accordance with the terms hereof and furnish to each holder 
of Preferred Stock a certificate setting
forth such adjustment or readjustment (including the kind and amount of securities, cash or other property into which 
the Preferred Stock is convertible) and
showing in detail the facts upon which such adjustment or readjustment is based. The Corporation shall, as promptly as 
reasonably practicable after the written
request at any time of any holder of Preferred Stock (but in any event not later than 10 days thereafter), furnish or 
cause to be furnished to such holder a
certificate setting forth (i) the Series A Conversion Price, Series B Conversion Price or Series C Conversion Price, as 
applicable, then in effect, and (ii) the
number of shares of Common Stock and the amount, if any, of other securities, cash or property
OHSIJSA:759368556 4 -21-
which then would be received upon the conversion of Series A Preferred Stock, Series B Preferred Stock or Series C 
Preferred Stock, as applicable.
4.10 Notice of Record Date. In the event:

(a) the Corporation shall take a record of the holders of its Common Stock (or other capital stock or securities at the 
time issuable upon conversion of the
Preferred Stock) for the purpose of entitling or enabling them to receive any dividend or other distribution, or to 
receive any right to subscribe for or
purchase any shares of capital stock of any class or any other securities, or to receive any other security; or

(b) of any capital reorganization of the Corporation, any reclassification of the Common Stock of the Corporation; or

(c) any Liquidation Event,
then, and in each such case, the Corporation will send or cause to be sent to the holders of the Preferred Stock a 
notice specifying, as the case may be, (i)
the record date for such dividend, distribution or right, and the amount and character of such dividend, distribution or
right, or (ii) the effective date on
which such reorganization, reclassification, consolidation, merger, transfer or Liquidation Event is proposed to take 
place, and the time, if any is to be
fixed, as of which the holders of record of Common Stock (or such other capital stock or securities at the time issuable
upon the conversion of the Preferred
Stock) shall be entitled to exchange their shares of Common Stock (or such other capital stock or securities) for 
securities or other property deliverable upon
such reorganization, reclassification, consolidation, merger, transfer or Liquidation Event, and the amount per share 
and character of such exchange applicable
to the Preferred Stock and the Common Stock. Such notice shall be sent at least 10 days prior to the record date or 
effective date for the event specified in
such notice.
5. Mandatory Conversion.

5.1 Trigger Events. Upon either (a) the closing of the sale of shares of Common Stock to the public, in a 
firm-commitment underwritten public offering pursuant
to an effective registration statement under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, resulting in at least $50,000,000 
of proceeds, before deduction of the
underwriting discount and commissions (a "Qualified IPO"), to the Corporation or (b) the date and time, or the 
occurrence of an event, specified by vote or
written consent of the holders of at least a majority of the then outstanding shares of Preferred Stock, voting together
as a single class on an as-converted to
Common Stock basis (the time of such closing or the date and time specified or the time of the event specified in such 
vote or written consent is referred to
herein as the "Mandatory Conversion Time"), (i) all outstanding shares of Preferred Stock shall automatically be 
converted into shares of Common Stock, at the
then effective conversion rate and (ii) such shares may not be reissued by the Corporation; provided, however, that the 
mandatory conversion of the Series B
Preferred Stock pursuant to Section 5.1(b) shall additionally require the Series B Approval and the mandatory conversion
of the Series C Preferred Stock
pursuant to Section 5.1(b) shall additionally require the Series C Approval; provided further, however, that no such 
Series B Approval shall be required in
connection with a Liquidation Event in which the consideration payable to the
OHSUSA:759368556.4 -22-
holders of the Series B Preferred Stock per share of Series B Preferred Stock held by than, and after giving effect to 
the mandatory conversion, is at least
three times (3x) the Series B Original Purchase Price and no such Series C Approval shall be required in connection with
a Liquidation Event in which the
consideration payable to the holders of the Series C Preferred Stock per share of Series C Preferred Stock held by them,
and after giving effect to the
mandatory conversion, is at least three times (3x) the Series C Original Purchase Price.

5.2 Procedural Requirements. All holders of record of shares of Preferred Stock shall be sent written notice of the 
Mandatory Conversion Time and the place
designated for mandatory conversion of all such shares of Preferred Stock pursuant to this Section 5. Such notice need 
not be sent in advance of the occurrence
of the Mandatory Conversion Time. Upon receipt of such notice, each holder of shares of Preferred Stock shall surrender 
his, her or its certificate or
certificates for all such shares (or, if such holder alleges that such certificate has been lost, stolen or destroyed, a
lost certificate affidavit and
agreement reasonably acceptable to the Corporation to indemnify the Corporation against any claim that may be made 
against the Corporation on account of the
alleged loss, theft or destruction of such certificate) to the Corporation at the place designated in such notice. If so
required by the Corporation,
certificates surrendered for conversion shall be endorsed or accompanied by written instrument or instruments of 
transfer, in form satisfactory to the
Corporation, duly executed by the registered holder or by his, her or its attorney duly authorized in writing. All 
rights with respect to the Preferred Stock
converted pursuant to Subsection 5.1, including the rights, if any, to receive notices and vote (other than as a holder 
of Common Stock), will terminate at the
Mandatory Conversion Time (notwithstanding the failure of the holder or holders thereof to surrender the certificates at
or prior to such time), except only the
rights of the holders thereof, upon surrender of their certificate or certificates (or lost certificate affidavit and 
agreement) therefor, to receive the items
provided for in the next sentence of this Subsection 5.2. As soon as practicable after the Mandatory Conversion Time and
the surrender of the certificate or
certificates (or lost certificate affidavit and agreement) for Preferred Stock, the Corporation shall issue and deliver 
to such holder, or to his, her or its
nominees, a certificate or certificates for the number of full shares of Common Stock issuable on such conversion in 
accordance with the provisions hereof,
together with cash as provided in Subsection 4.2 in lieu of any fraction of a share of Common Stock otherwise issuable 
upon such conversion and the payment of
any declared but unpaid dividends on the shares of Preferred Stock converted. Such converted Preferred Stock shall be 
retired and cancelled and may not be
reissued as shares of such series, and the Corporation may thereafter take such appropriate action (without the need for
stockholder action) as may be necessary
to reduce the authorized number of shares of Preferred Stock accordingly.

6. ftedemotion. The Preferred Stock shall not be mandatorily redeemable.

7. Redeemed or Otherwise Acquired Shares. Any shares of Preferred Stock that are redeemed or otherwise acquired by the 
Corporation or any of its subsidiaries
shall be automatically and immediately cancelled and retired and shall not be reissued, sold or transferred. Neither the
Corporation nor any of its subsidiaries
may exercise any voting or other rights granted to the holders of Preferred Stock following redemption.
OHSUSA:759368556.4 -23-

8. Notices. Any notice required or permitted by the provisions of this Article Fourth to be given to a holder of shares 
of Preferred Stock shall be mailed,
postage prepaid, to the post office address last shown on the records of the Corporation, or given by electronic 
communication in compliance with the provisions
of the General Corporation Law, and shall be deemed sent upon such mailing or electronic transmission.

C. FF PREFERRED
The powers, rights, preferences, privileges and restrictions granted to and imposed on the FF Preferred Stock are as set
forth below in this Part C of this
Article Fourth. Unless otherwise
indicated, references to "sections" or "subsections" in this Part C of this Article Fourth refer to sections and 
subsections of Part C of this Article Fourth.

1. Dividend Provisions. The holders of shares of FF Preferred Stock shall be entitled to receive, out of any assets 
legally available therefor, such dividends
(other than payable solely in Common Stock or Common Stock Equivalents, as defined below), when, as and if declared by 
the Board of Directors, on a pro rata
basis with the holders of Common Stock based on the number of shares of Common Stock held by each (assuming conversion 
of all such FF Preferred Stock into
Common Stock).

2. Liquidation Provisions. Upon the liquidation, dissolution or winding up of the Corporation, or the occurrence of a 
Liquidation Event, the assets of the
Corporation shall be distributed as provided in Subsection 2 of Part B of Article Fourth above.
3. Redemption. The FF Preferred Stock is not mandatorily redeemable.

4. Conversion. The holders of shares of FF Preferred Stock shall be entitled to conversion rights as follows:
4.1 Right to Convert to Common Stock. Subject to Subsection 4.3 below, each share of FF Preferred Stock shall be 
convertible, at the option of the holder
thereof, at any time after the date of issuance of such share, at the office of the Corporation or any transfer agent 
for such stock, into such number of fully
paid and nonassessable shares of Common Stock as is determined by dividing $1.00 (as adjusted for any stock splits, 
stock dividends, combinations, subdivisions,
recapitalizations or the like) by the Conversion Price applicable to such shares (the conversion rate for FP Preferred 
Stock into Common Stock is referred to
herein as the "FF Preferred Conversion Rate"), determined as hereafter provided, in effect on (i) the date the 
certificate is surrendered for conversion or (ii)
in the case of uncertificated securities, the date the notice of conversion is received by the Corporation. Any transfer
of shares of FF Preferred Stock that is
neither (A) made in connection with an Equity Financing (as such term is defined in Subsection 4.7 below), nor (B) 
authorized by a majority of the Board of
Directors, shall be deemed an election of an option to convert such shares into Common Stock and each such transferred 
share of FF Preferred Stock shall
automatically convert into such number of fully paid and nonassessable shares of Common Stock as is determined by 
dividing $1.00 (as adjusted for any stock
splits, stock dividends, combinations, subdivisions, recapitalizations or the like) by the Conversion Price applicable 
to such share, determined as hereafter
provided, effective immediately prior to such transfer. The initial
ONSUSA:759368$56.4 -24-
Conversion Price per share of FF Preferred Stock shall be $1.00 (as adjusted for any stock splits,
stock dividends, combinations, subdivisions, recapitalizations or the like). Such initial
Conversion Price shall be subject to adjustment as set forth in Subsection 4.4 below.
4.2 Automatic Conversion. Each share of FF Preferred Stock shall
automatically be converted into shares of Common Stock at the FF Preferred Conversion Rate
then in effect for such share immediately upon the earlier of (i) except as provided in Subsection
4.3 below, a Qualified IPO or (ii) the date specified by vote or written consent of the holders of a
majority of the then outstanding shares of FF Preferred Stock, voting exclusively and as a
separate class.
4.3 Mechanics of Conversion. Before any holder of FF Preferred
Stock shall be entitled to convert such FP Preferred Stock into shares of Common Stock, the
holder shall give written notice to the Corporation at its principal corporate office, of the election
to convert the same and shall state therein the name or names in which the shares of Common
Stock are to be issued and, in the case of FF Preferred Stock represented by a certificate, the
holder shall surrender the certificate or certificates therefor, duly endorsed, at the office of the
Corporation or of any transfer agent for such FF Preferred Stock. The Corporation shall, as
soon as practicable thereafter, issue and deliver at such office to such holder of FF Preferred
Stock, or to the nominee or nominees of such holder, a certificate or certificates or, in the case of
uncertificated securities, a notice of issuance, for the number of shares of Common Stock to
which such holder shall be entitled as aforesaid. Such conversion shall be deemed to have been
made immediately prior to the close of business on the date of such surrender of certificates, or
in the case of uncertificated securities, on the date such notice of conversion is received by the
Corporation, and the person or persons entitled to receive the shares of Common Stock issuable
upon such conversion shall be treated for all purposes as the record holder or holders of such
shares of Common Stock as of such date. If the conversion is in connection with a firm
commitment underwritten public offering of securities, the conversion may, at the option of any
holder tendering such FF Preferred Stock for conversion, be conditioned upon the closing of the
sale of securities pursuant to such offering, in which event any persons entitled to receive
Common Stock upon conversion of such FF Preferred Stock shall not be deemed to have
converted such FF Preferred Stock until immediately prior to the closing of such sale of
securities.
4.4 Conversion Price Adjustments of FE Preferred Stock for Splits and
Combinations. The Conversion Price of the FF Preferred Stock shall be subject to adjustment
from time to time as follows:
4.4.1 Stock Splits and Dividends. In the event the Corporation
should at any time after the filing date of this Certificate fix a record date for the effectuation of a
split or subdivision of the outstanding shares of Common Stock or the determination of holders
of Common Stock entitled to receive a dividend or other distribution payable in additional shares
of Common Stock or other securities or rights convertible into, or entitling the holder thereof to
receive directly or indirectly, additional shares of Common Stock (hereinafter referred to as
"Common Stock Equivalents") without payment of any consideration by such holder for the
additional shares of Common Stock or the Common Stock Equivalents (including the additional
shares of Common Stock issuable upon conversion or exercise thereof), then, as of such record
OHMISA.759361556A -25-
date (or the date of such dividend distribution, split or subdivision if no record date is fixed), the
Conversion Price of the FF Preferred Stock shall be appropriately decreased so that the number
of shares of Common Stock issuable on conversion of each share of such FF Preferred Stock
shall be increased in proportion to such increase of the aggregate number of shares of Common
Stock outstanding and those issuable with respect to such Common Stock Equivalents with the
number of shares issuable with respect to Common Stock Equivalents determined from time to
time in the manner provided for deemed issuances in Subsection 4.4.2 below.
4.4.2 Deemed Issuances of Common Stock. The following
provisions shall apply for purposes of this Subsection 4.4.

(a) The aggregate maximum number of shares of
Common Stock deliverable upon conversion, exchange or exercise (assuming the satisfaction of
any conditions to convertibility, exchangeability or exercisability, including, without limitation,
the passage of time, but without taking into account potential antidilution adjustments) of any
Common Stock Equivalents and subsequent conversion, exchange or exercise thereof shall be
deemed to have been issued at the time such securities were issued or such Common Stock
Equivalents were issued.

(b) In the event of any change in the number of shares
of Common Stock deliverable or in the consideration payable to the Corporation upon
conversion, exchange or exercise of any Common Stock Equivalents, other than a change
resulting from the antidilution provisions thereof, the Conversion Price of the FF Preferred
Stock, to the extent in any way affected by or computed using such Common Stock Equivalents,
shall be recomputed to reflect such change, but no further adjustment shall be made for the actual
issuance of Common Stock or any payment of such consideration upon the conversion, exchange
or exercise of such Common Stock Equivalents.
(c) Upon the termination or expiration of the
convertibility, exchangeability or exercisability of any Common Stock Equivalents, the
Conversion Price of the FF Preferred Stock, to the extent in any way affected by or computed
using such Common Stock Equivalents, shall be recomputed to reflect the icsuance of only the
number of shares of Common Stock (and Common Stock Equivalents that remain convertible,
exchangeable or exercisable) actually issued upon the conversion, exchange or exercise of such
Common Stock Equivalents.
4.4.3 Reverse Stock Splits. If the number of shares of Common
Stock outstanding at any time after the filing date of this Certificate is decreased by a
combination of the outstanding shares of Common Stock, then, following the record date of such
combination, the Conversion Price for the FF Preferred Stock shall be appropriately increased so
that the number of shares of Common Stock issuable on conversion of each share of such FF
Preferred Stock shall be decreased in proportion to such decrease in outstanding shares.
4.5 No Fractional Shares and Notices as to Adjustments.
4.5.1 No fractional shares shall be issued upon the conversion of
any share or shares of FF Preferred Stock, and the number of shares of Common Stock to be
O11SUSA:759368556.4 -26-
issued shall be rounded down to the nearest whole share. The number of shares issuable upon
such conversion shall be determined on the basis of the total number of shares of FF Preferred
Stock the holder is at the time converting into Common Stock and the number of shares of
Common Stock issuable upon such aggregate conversion. If the conversion would result in any
fractional share, the Corporation shall, in lieu of issuing any such fractional share, pay the holder
thereof an amount in cash equal to the fair market value of such fractional share on the date of
conversion, as determined in good faith by the Board of Directors.
4.5.2 Upon the occurrence of each adjustment or readjustment of
the Conversion Price of FF Preferred Stock pursuant to this Subsection 4, the Corporation, at its
expense, shall promptly compute such adjustment or readjustment in accordance with the terms
hereof and prepare and furnish to each holder of such FF Preferred Stock a notice setting forth
such adjustment or readjustment and showing in detail the facts upon which such adjustment or
readjustment is based. The Corporation shall, upon the written request at any time of any holder
of such FF Preferred Stock, furnish or cause to be furnished to such holder a notice setting forth
(A) such adjustment and readjustment, (B) the Conversion Price for the FF Preferred Stock at the
time in effect and (C) the number of shares of Common Stock and the amount, if any, of other
property which at the time would be received upon the conversion of a share of FF Preferred
Stock.
4.6 Reservation of Stock Issuable Upon Conversion. The Corporation
shall at all times reserve and keep available out of its authorized but unissued shares of Common
Stock, solely for the purpose of effecting the conversion of the shares of FF Preferred Stock,
such number of its shares of Common Stock as shall from time to time be sufficient to effect the
conversion of all outstanding shares of FF Preferred Stock; and if at any time the number of
authorized but unissued shares of Common Stock shall not be sufficient to effect the conversion
of all then outstanding shares of FF Preferred Stock, in addition to such other remedies as shall
be available to the holder of such FF Preferred Stock, the Corporation will take such corporate
action as may, in the opinion of its counsel, be necessary to increase its authorized but unissued
shares of Common Stock to such number of shares as shall be sufficient for such purposes,
including, without limitation, engaging in best efforts to obtain the requisite stockholder approval
of any necessary amendment to this Certificate.
4.7 Right to Convert to Preferred Stock. If a share of FP Preferred
Stock is purchased by an investor in connection with an Equity Financing (as defined below),
then immediately upon the closing of such purchase, each such share of FF Preferred Stock
transferred to the investor shall automatically convert, at the Conversion Ratio (as defined
below), into shares of a subsequent series of preferred stock of the Corporation sold by the
Corporation in such Equity Financing ("Subsequent Preferred Stock") (an "FF Preferred
Sale"), provided that the aggregate Liquidation Preference (as defined below) of the Subsequent
Preferred Stock issued upon conversion of (i) the FF Preferred sold in such FF Preferred Sale and

(ii) the FF Preferred sold in any other FF Preferred Sales does not exceed twenty percent (20%)
of the aggregate Liquidation Preference of all shares of Preferred Stock outstanding immediately
following such FF Preferred Sale (including the outstanding shares of Subsequent Preferred
Stock issued upon conversion of the FF Preferred sold in such FF Preferred Sale). As used in
this paragraph, "Liquidation Preference" shall mean the preferential payments to holders of
Preferred Stock in the event of any voluntary or involuntary liquidation, dissolution or winding
Of-MUSA:739368356A -27-
up of the Company or Liquidation Event pursuant to Subsection 2.1 of Part B of Article Fourth. "Conversion Ratio" shall 
mean, for each Equity Financing, one
divided by the number of shares into which a share of Subsequent Preferred Stock issued in such Equity Financing is 
convertible into Common Stock of the
Corporation, and "Equity Financing" shall mean an equity financing of the Corporation in which the Corporation signs a 
purchase agreement and sells and issues
Subsequent Preferred Stock of the Corporation. By way of example only, in the event that one share of Subsequent 
Preferred Stock issued in the Equity Financing
is convertible into two shares of Common Stock, the Conversion Ratio shall be one-half (1/2) and each share of FF 
Preferred Stock would convert into one-half of
a share of such Subsequent Preferred Stock.

4.8 Notices. Any notice required by the provisions of this Subsection 4 to be given to the holders of shares of FF 
Preferred Stock shall be deemed given if
deposited in the U.S. mail, postage prepaid, and addressed to each holder of record at his address appearing
on the books of the Corporation.

5. Voting Rights and Powers. Except as expressly provided by this Certificate or as provided by law, the holders of FF 
Preferred Stock shall be entitled to the
same
voting rights as the holders of the Common Stock and to notice of any stockholders' meeting in accordance with the 
Bylaws of the Corporation, and the holders of
Common Stock and the holders of FF Preferred Stock shall vote together as a single class on all matters. Each holder of 
FF Preferred Stock shall be entitled to
the number of votes equal to the number of shares of Common Stock into which such shares of FF Preferred Stock could be 
converted. Fractional
votes shall not, however, be permitted and any fractional voting rights available on an as-converted basis (after 
aggregating all shares into which shares of FF
Preferred Stock held by each holder could be converted) shall be rounded to the nearest whole number (with one-half
being rounded upward). The number of authorized shares of FF Prefdred Stock may be increased or decreased (but not below
the number of shares thereof then
outstanding) by the affumative vote of the holders of shares of stock of the Corporation representing a majority of the 
votes represented by all outstanding
shares of stock of the Corporation entitled to vote, irrespective of the provisions of Section 242(6)(2) of the Delaware
General Corporation Law.
6. Status of Converted Stock. In the event any shares of FF Preferred Stock shall be converted pursuant to Subsection 4 
above, the shares so converted shall be
cancelled and shall not be issuable by the Corporation. This Certificate shall be appropriately amended to effect the 
corresponding reduction in the
Corporation's authorized capital stock.

FIFTH: Subject to any additional vote required by the Certificate of Incorporation or Bylaws, in furtherance and not in 
limitation of the powers conferred by
statute, the Board of Directors is expressly authorized to make, repeal, alter, amend and rescind any or all of the 
Bylaws of the Corporation.
SIXTH: Subject to any additional vote required by the Certificate of Incorporation, the number of directors of the 
Corporation shall be determined in the manner
set forth in the Bylaws of the Corporation.

SEVENTH: Elections of directors need not be by written ballot unless the Bylaws of the Corporation shall so provide.
ONSUSA:7593611556.4 -28-
EIGHTH: Meetings of stockholders may be held within or without the State of
Delaware, as the Bylaws of the Corporation may provide. The books of the Corporation may be
kept outside the State of Delaware at such place or places as may be designated from time to
time by the Board of Directors or in the Bylaws of the Corporation.
NINTH: To the fullest extent permitted by law, a director of the Corporation
shall not be personally liable to the Corporation or its stockholders for monetary damages for
breach of fiduciary duty as a director. If the General Corporation Law or any other law of the
State of Delaware is amended after approval by the stockholders of this Article Ninth to
authorize corporate action further eliminating or limiting the personal liability of directors, then
the liability of a director of the Corporation shall be eliminated or limited to the fullest extent
permitted by the General Corporation Law as so amended.
Any repeal or modification of the foregoing provisions of this Article Ninth by the
stockholders of the Corporation shall not adversely affect any right or protection of a director of
the Corporation existing at the time of, or increase the liability of any director of the Corporation
with respect to any acts or omissions of such director occurring prior to, such repeal or
modification.
TENTH: To the fullest extent permitted by applicable law, the Corporation is
authorized to provide indemnification of (and advancement of expenses to) directors, officers
and agents of the Corporation (and any other persons to which General Corporation Law permits
the Corporation to provide indemnification) through Bylaw provisions, agreements with such
agents or other persons, vote of stockholders or disinterested directors or otherwise, in excess of
the indemnification and advancement otherwise permitted by Section 145 of the General
Corporation Law.
Any amendment, repeal or modification of the foregoing provisions of this Article Tenth shall
not adversely affect any right or protection of any director, officer or other agent of the
Corporation existing at the time of such amendment, repeal or modification.
ELEVENTH: The Corporation renounces, to the fullest extent permitted by
law, any interest or expectancy of the Corporation in, or in being offered an opportunity to
participate in, any Excluded Opportunity. An "Excluded Opportunity" is any matter,
transaction or interest that is presented to, or acquired, created or developed by, or which
otherwise comes into the possession of, (i) any director of the Corporation who is not an
employee of the Corporation or any of its subsidiaries, or (ii) any holder of Preferred Stock or
any partner, member, director, stockholder, employee or agent of any such holder, other than
someone who is an employee of the Corporation or any of its subsidiaries (collectively,
"Covered Persons"), unless such matter, transaction or interest is presented to, or acquired,
created or developed by, or otherwise comes into the possession of, a Covered Person expressly
and solely in such Covered Person's capacity as a director of the Corporation.
TWELFTH: For purposes of Section 500 of the California Corporations Code
(to the extent applicable), in connection with any repurchase of shares of Common Stock
permitted under this Certificate of Incorporation from employees, officers, directors or
consultants of the Company in connection with a termination of employment or services
pursuant to agreements or arrangements approved by the Board of Directors (in addition to any
OliSUSA:7593685$6.4 -29-
other consent required under this Certificate of Incorporation), such repurchase may be made
without regard to any "preferential dividends arrears amount" or "preferential rights amount" (as
those terms are defined in Section 500 of the California Corporations Code). Accordingly, for
purposes of making any calculation under California Corporations Code Section 500 in
connection with such repurchase, the amount of any "preferential dividends arrears amount" or
"preferential rights amount" (as those terms are defined therein) shall be deemed to be zero.

3. That this Amended and Restated Certificate of Incorporation, which
restates and integrates and further amends the provisions of this Corporation's Certificate of
Incorporation, has been duly adopted in accordance with Sections 141, 228, 242 and 245 of the
General Corporation Law.
O11SUSA:759368556.4 -30-
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, this Amended and Restated Certificate of incorporation
has been executed by a duly authorized officer of this corporation on this 1st day of December,
2014.
By: /s/ Fred Ehrsam
Fred Ehrsarn, President
OFISUSA:75936.1556A -31-
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                    Marc Andreessen [crypto] co-founder of crypto heavy venture fund a16z, Trump convert [cryptadamus/infinitescroll.us] 
                                                                                    Ribbit Capital [crypto] crypto friendly venture fund 
 a16z aka Andreessen Horowitz [crypto] crypto heavy venture fund of Marc Andreessen / Ben Horowitz, invested in many scams [cryptadamus] 
                                                               Dodd-Frank Act [government] financial regulations put in place after 2008 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01120975 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Coinbase Series B stock purchase
(date: 2013-12-12)
COINBASE, INC.
SERIES B PREFERRED STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
THIS SERIES B PREFERRED STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT is made as of the
12ie day of December, 2013 by and among Coinbase, Inc., a Delaware corporation (the
"Company"), and the investors listed on Exhibit A attached to this Agreement (each a
"Purchaser" and together the "Purchasers").
The parties hereby agree as follows:

1. Purchase and Sale of Preferred Stock.
1.1 Sale and Issuance of Series B Preferred Stock.
(a) The Company shall adopt and file with the Secretary of State of the
State of Delaware on or before the Initial Closing (as defined below) the Amended and Restated
Certificate of Incorporation in the form of Exhibit B attached to this Agreement (the "Restated
Certificate").

(b) Subject to the terms and conditions of this Agreement, each
Purchaser agrees to purchase at the Closing and the Company agrees to sell and issue to each
Purchaser at the Closing that number of shares of Series B Preferred Stock, $0.00001 par value
per share (the "Series B Preferred Stock"), set forth opposite each Purchaser's name on Exhibit
A, at a purchase price of $6.04054 per share. The shares of Series B Preferred Stock issued to
the Purchasers pursuant to this Agreement (including any shares issued at the Initial Closing and
any Additional Shares, as defined below) shall be referred to in this Agreement as the "Shares."
1.2 Closing: Delivery.

(a) The initial purchase and sale of the Shares shall take place
remotely via the exchange of documents and signatures, at 10:00 am. on December 12, 2013 or
at such other time and place as the Company and the Purchasers mutually agree upon, orally or in
writing (which time and place are designated as the "Initial Closing"). In the event there is more
than one closing, the term "Closing" shall apply to each such closing unless otherwise specified.

(b) At each Closing, the Company shall deliver to each Purchaser a
certificate representing the Shares being purchased by such Purchaser at such Closing against
payment of the purchase price therefor by check payable to the Company, by wire transfer to a
bank account designated by the Company, by cancellation or conversion of indebtedness of the
Company to Purchaser, including interest, or by any combination of such methods.
1.3 Sale of Additional Shares of Preferred Stock.

(a) If fewer than 4,241,757 shares of Series B Preferred Stock are sold
at the Initial Closing, the Company may sell, on the same terms and conditions as those contained
in this Agreement, such remaining shares of Series B Preferred Stock (subject to appropriate
OHSUSAIS$71$737.3
adjustment in the event of any stock dividend, stock split, combination or similar recapitalization
affecting such shares) of Series B Preferred Stock (the "Additional Shares"), to one or more
purchasers (the "Additional Purchasers") reasonably acceptable to Andreessen Horowitz Fund
III, L.P. ("Andreessen"), provided that (i) such subsequent sale is consummated prior to 180
days after the Initial Closing, (ii) each Additional Purchaser shall become a party to the
Transaction Agreements, (as defined below) (other than the Management Rights Letters), by
executing and delivering a counterpart signature page to each of the Transaction Agreements, and
(iii) Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, counsel for the Company, provides an opinion dated as
of the date of such additional Closing that the offer, issuance, sale and delivery of the Additional
Shares to the Additional Purchasers do not require registration under the Securities Act of 1933,
as amended, or applicable state securities laws. Exhibit A to this Agreement shall be updated to
reflect the number of Additional Shares purchased at each such Closing and the parties
purchasing such Additional Shares.

(b) Notwithstanding Section 1.3(a) above, on April 26, 2014,
Andreessen shall purchase from the Company and the persons listed on Schedule A hereto, the
respective number of shares of FF Preferred Stock and Series B Preferred Stock set forth on
Schedule A hereto, representing an aggregate of 608,526 shares of Series B Preferred Stock
(including Series B Preferred Stock issued upon conversion of the FF Preferred Stock), for a
purchase price of $3,675,825.65 (the "April 2014 Closing").
1.4 Defined Terms Used in this Agreement. In addition to the terms defined
above, the following terms used in this Agreement shall be construed to have the meanings set
forth or referenced below.

(a) "Affiliate" means, with respect to any specified Person, any other
Person who, directly or indirectly, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with
such Person, including, without limitation, any general partner, managing member, officer or
director of such Person or any venture capital fund now or hereafter existing that is controlled by
one or more general partners or managing members of, or shares the same management company
with, such Person.

(b) "Code" means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended.
(c) "Company Intellectual Property" means all patents, patent
applications, trademarks, trademark applications, service marks, service mark applications,
tradenames, copyrights, trade secrets, domain names, mask works, information and proprietary
rights and processes, similar or other intellectual property rights, subject matter of any of the
foregoing, tangible embodiments of any of the foregoing, licenses in to and under any of the
foregoing, and any and all such cases as are necessary to the Company in the conduct of the
Company's business as now conducted and as presently proposed to be conducted.

(d) "Indemnification Agreement" means the agreement between the
Company and the director designated by any Purchaser entitled to designate a member of the
Board of Directors pursuant to the Voting Agreement, dated as of the date of the Initial Closing,
in the form of Exhibit D attached to this Agreement.
OHSUSA:755718737.3 2

(e) "Investors' Rights Agreement" means the Amended and Restated
Investors' Rights Agreement among the Company and the Purchasers dated as of the date of the
Initial Closing, in the form of Exhibit E attached to this Agreement.
(0 "Key Employee" means any executive-level employee (including
division director and vice president-level positions) as well as any employee or consultant who
either alone or in concert with others develops, invents, programs or designs any Company
Intellectual Property.

(g) "Knowledge," including the phrase "to the Company's
knowledge," shall mean the actual knowledge after reasonable investigation of: Brian
Armstrong, Fred Ehrsam and Martine Niejadik.

(h) "Management Rights Letters" means the agreements between the
Company and each of Andreessen, Union Square Ventures 2012 Fund, L.P. and USV Investors
2012 Fund, L.P. (together, "USV") and Ribbit Capital, LP and Fintech Coinbase Holdings, LLC
(together, "Ribbit Capital") dated as of the date of the Initial Closing, in the form of Exhibit F
attached to this Agreement.

(i) "Material Adverse Effect" means a material adverse effect on the
business, assets (including intangible assets), liabilities, financial condition, property, prospects
or results of operations of the Company.

(j) "Person" means any individual, corporation, partnership, trust,
limited liability company, association or other entity.

(k) "Purchaser" means each of the Purchasers who is initially a party
to this Agreement and any Additional Purchaser who becomes a party to this Agreement at a
subsequent Closing under Subsection 1.3.

(1) "Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement" means the
Amended and Restated Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement among the Company, the
Purchasers, and certain other stockholders of the Company, dated as of the date of the Initial
Closing, in the form of Exhibit G attached to this Agreement.

(m) "Securities Act" means the Securities Act of 1933, as amended,
and the rules and regulations promulgated thereunder.

(n) "Shares" means the shares of Series B Preferred Stock issued at
the Initial Closing and any Additional Shares issued at a subsequent Closing under Subsection
1.3.

(o) "Transaction Agreements" means this Agreement, the Investors'
Rights Agreement, the Management Rights Letters, the Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale
Agreement and the Voting Agreement.
OHSUSA:755718737.3 3

(p) "Voting Agreement" means the Amended and Restated Voting
Agreement among the Company, the Purchasers and certain other stockholders of the Company,
dated as of the date of the Initial Closing, in the form of  Exhibit II attached to this Agreement.

2. Representations and Warranties of the Company. The Company hereby represents
and warrants to each Purchaser that, except as set forth on the Disclosure Schedule attached as
Exhibit C to this Agreement, specifically identifying the relevant subsection hereof, which
exceptions shall be deemed to be part of the representations and warranties made hereunder, the
following representations are true and complete as of the date of the Initial Closing, except as
otherwise indicated.
For purposes of these representations and warranties (other than those in
Subsections 2.2 2.3, 2.4, 2.5, and 2.6), the term "the Company" shall include any subsidiaries of
the Company, unless otherwise noted herein.
2.1 Organization, Good Standing, Corporate Power and Oualification. The
Company is a corporation duly organized, validly existing and in good standing under the laws of
the State of Delaware and has all requisite corporate power and authority to carry on its business
as presently conducted and as proposed to be conducted. The Company is duly qualified to
transact business and is in good standing in each jurisdiction in which the failure to so qualify
would have a Material Adverse Effect.
2.2 Capitalization.

(a) The authorized capital stock of the Company consists, immediately
prior to the Initial Closing, of:
32,000,000 shares of common stock, $0.00001 par value
per share (the "Common Stock"), 8,728,833 shares of which are issued and outstanding
immediately prior to the Initial Closing. All of the outstanding shares of Common Stock have
been duly authorized, are fully paid and nonassessable and were issued in compliance with all
applicable federal and state securities laws.

(ii) 1,820,000 shares of FF Preferred Stock, $0.00001 par
value, all of which are issued and outstanding immediately prior to the Initial Closing. All
outstanding shares of FF Preferred Stock have been duly authorized, are fully paid and
nonassessable and were issued in compliance with all applicable federal and state securities laws.
(iii) 9,405,110 shares of Preferred Stock, 5,163,353 of which
have been designated Series A Preferred Stock, all of which are issued and outstanding
immediately prior to the Initial Closing, and 4,241,757 of which have been designated Series B
Preferred Stock, none of which are issued and outstanding immediately prior to the Initial
Closing. The rights, privileges and preferences of the Preferred Stock are as stated in the
Restated Certificate and as provided by the Delaware General Corporation Law.

(b) The Company has reserved 3,221,968 shares of Common Stock for
issuance to officers, directors, employees and consultants of the Company pursuant to its 2013
OHSUSA:755718737.3 4
Stock Plan duly adopted by the Board of Directors and approved by the Company stockholders
(the "Stock Plan"). Of such reserved shares of Common Stock, no shares have been issued
pursuant to restricted stock purchase agreements, 938,286 options to purchase shares have been
granted and are currently outstanding, and 2,283,682 shares of Common Stock remain available
for issuance to officers, directors, employees and consultants pursuant to the Stock Plan. The
Company has furnished to the Purchasers complete and accurate copies of the Stock Plan and
forms of agreements used thereunder.

(c) There are convertible notes (the "Convertible Notes") with an
aggregate conversion amount of $12,512,728.68 that will convert into an aggregate of 2,071,454
shares of Series B Preferred Stock and 103,883 shares of Common Stock at the Initial Closing.

(d) Subsection 2.2(d) of the Disclosure Schedule sets forth the
capitalization of the Company immediately following the Initial Closing including the number of
shares of the following: (i) issued and outstanding Common Stock, including, with respect to
restricted Common Stock, vesting schedule and repurchase price; (ii) granted stock options,
including vesting schedule and exercise price; (iii) shares of Common Stock reserved for future
award grants under the Stock Plan; (iv) each series of Preferred Stock; and (v) warrants or stock
purchase rights, if any. Except for (A) the conversion privileges of the Shares to be issued under
this Agreement, (B) the rights provided in Section 4 of the Investors' Rights Agreement, and (C)
the securities and rights described in Subsection 2.2(62 of this Agreement and Subsection 2.2(d)
of the Disclosure Schedule, there are no outstanding options, warrants, rights (including
conversion or preemptive rights and rights of first refusal or similar rights) or agreements, orally
or in writing, to purchase or acquire from the Company any shares of the Company's capital
stock, or any securities convertible into or exchangeable for shares of the Company's capital
stock. All outstanding shares of the Company's Common Stock and all shares of the Company's
Common Stock underlying outstanding options are subject to (i) a right of first refusal in favor of
the Company upon any proposed transfer (other than transfers for estate planning purposes); and

(ii) a lock-up or market standoff agreement of not less than 180 days following the Company's
initial public offering pursuant to a registration statement filed with the Securities and Exchange
Commission under the Securities Act.

(e) None of the Company's stock purchase agreements or stock option
documents contains a provision for acceleration of vesting (or lapse of a repurchase right) or
other changes in the vesting provisions or other terms of such agreement or understanding upon
the occurrence of any event or combination of events, including without limitation in the case
where the Company's Stock Plan is not assumed in an acquisition. The Company has never
adjusted or amended the exercise price of any stock options previously awarded, whether through
amendment, cancellation, replacement grant, repricing, or any other means. Except as set forth
in the Restated Certificate, the Company has no obligation (contingent or otherwise) to purchase
or redeem any of its capital stock.

(f) 409A. The Company believes in good faith that any "nonqualified
deferred compensation plan" (as such term is defined under Section 409A(dX1) of the Code and
the guidance thereunder) under which the Company makes, is obligated to make or promises to
make, payments (each, a "409A Plan") complies in all material respects, in both form and
OHSUSA:755718737.3 5
operation, with the requirements of Section 409A of the Code and the guidance thereunder. To
the knowledge of the Company, no payment to be made under any 409A Plan is, or will be,
subject to the penalties of Section 409A(aXI) of the Code.

(g) The Company has obtained valid waivers of any rights by other
parties to purchase any of the Shares covered by this Agreement.
2.3 Subsidiaries. The Company does not currently own or control, directly or
indirectly, any interest in any other corporation, partnership, trust, joint venture, limited liability
company, association, or other business entity. The Company is not a participant in any joint
venture, partnership or similar arrangement.
2.4 Authorization. All corporate action required to be taken by the
Company's Board of Directors and stockholders in order to authorize the Company to enter into
the Transaction Agreements, and to issue the Shares at the Closing and the Common Stock
issuable upon conversion of the Shares, has been taken or will be taken prior to the Closing. All
action on the part of the officers of the Company necessary for the execution and delivery of the
Transaction Agreements, the performance of all obligations of the Company under the
Transaction Agreements to be performed as of the Closing, and the issuance and delivery of the
Shares has been taken or will be taken prior to the Closing. The Transaction Agreements, when
executed and delivered by the Company, shall constitute valid and legally binding obligations of
the Company, enforceable against the Company in accordance with their respective terms except
(i) as limited by applicable bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization, moratorium, fraudulent
conveyance, or other laws of general application relating to or affecting the enforcement of
creditors' rights generally, (ii) as limited by laws relating to the availability of specific
performance, injunctive relief, or other equitable remedies, or (iii) to the extent the
indemnification provisions contained in the Investors' Rights Agreement and the Indemnification
Agreement may be limited by applicable federal or state securities laws.
2.5 Valid Issuance of Shares. The Shares, when issued, sold and delivered in
accordance with the terms and for the consideration set forth in this Agreement, will be validly
issued, fully paid and nonassessable and free of restrictions on transfer other than restrictions on
transfer under the Transaction Agreements, applicable state and federal securities laws and liens
or encumbrances created by or imposed by a Purchaser. Assuming the accuracy of the
representations of the Purchasers in Section 3 of this Agreement and subject to the filings
described in Subsection 2.6(ii) below, the Shares will be issued in compliance with all applicable
federal and state securities laws. The Common Stock issuable upon conversion of the Shares has
been duly reserved for issuance, and upon issuance in accordance with the terms of the Restated
Certificate, will be validly issued, frilly paid and nonassessable and free of restrictions on transfer
other than restrictions on transfer under the Transaction Agreements, applicable federal and state
securities laws and liens or encumbrances created by or imposed by a Purchaser. Based in part
upon the representations of the Purchasers in Section 3 of this Agreement, and subject to
Subsection 2.6 below, the Common Stock issuable upon conversion of the Shares will be issued
in compliance with all applicable federal and state securities laws.
OHSUSA:755718737.3 6
2.6 Governmental Consents and Filings. Assuming the accuracy of the
representations made by the Purchasers in Section 3 of this Agreement, no consent, approval,
order or authorization of, or registration, qualification, designation, declaration or filing with, any
federal, state or local governmental authority is required on the part of the Company in
connection with the consummation of the transactions contemplated by this Agreement, except
for (i) the filing of the Restated Certificate, which will have been filed as of the Initial Closing,
and (ii) filings pursuant to Regulation D of the Securities Act, and applicable state securities
laws, which have been made or will be made in a timely manner.
2.7 Litigation. There is no claim, action, suit, proceeding, arbitration,
complaint, subpoena, regulatory inquiry, enforcement action, charge or investigation pending or
to the Company's knowledge, currently threatened in writing (i) against the Company or any
officer, director or Key Employee of the Company arising out of their employment or board
relationship with the Company; or (ii) to the Company's knowledge, that questions the validity of
the Transaction Agreements or the right of the Company to enter into them, or to consummate
the transactions contemplated by the Transaction Agreements. Neither the Company nor, to the
Company's knowledge, any of its officers, directors or Key Employees is a party or is named as
subject to the provisions of any order, writ, injunction, judgment or decree of any court or
government agency or instrumentality (in the case of officers, directors or Key Employees, such
as would affect the Company). There is no action, suit, proceeding or investigation by the
Company pending or which the Company intends to initiate. The foregoing includes, without
limitation, actions, suits, proceedings or investigations pending or threatened in writing (or any
basis therefor known to the Company) involving the prior employment of any of the Company's
employees, their services provided in connection with the Company's business, or any
information or techniques allegedly proprietary to any of their former employers, or their
obligations under any agreements with prior employers.
2.8 Financial Services Laws and Rules. The Company has at all times used its
reasonable best efforts to comply with all Financial Services Laws and Rules. "Financial Services
Laws and Rules" means all (i) United States state and federal laws and regulations and any
applicable foreign laws and regulations related to money services businesses, anti-money
laundering, money transmission, sale of payment instruments (including stored value, checks and
other instruments), currency exchange, electronic funds transfers, banking, commodities and
securities, privacy and data security, and data breach remediation and notification; (ii) United
States state and federal laws and regulations and any applicable foreign laws and regulations
related to customer identity verification and screening (including the Office of Foreign Assets
Control list of Specially Designated Nationals); and (iii) relevant payment association rules.
2.9 Intellectual Property. The Company owns or possesses or believes it can
acquire on commercially reasonable terms sufficient legal rights to all Company Intellectual
Property without known conflict with, or infringement of, the rights of others. To the Company's
knowledge, no product or service marketed or sold (or proposed to be marketed or sold) by the
Company violates or will violate any license or infringes or will infringe any intellectual property
rights of any other party. Other than with respect to commercially available software products
under standard end-user object code license agreements, there are no outstanding options,
licenses, agreements, claims, encumbrances or shared ownership interests of any kind relating to
OHSUSA:755718737.3 7
the Company Intellectual Property, nor is the Company bound by or a party to any options,
licenses or agreements of any kind with respect to the patents, trademarks, service marks, trade
names, copyrights, trade secrets, licenses, information, proprietary rights and processes of any
other Person. The Company has not received any communications alleging that the Company
has violated or, by conducting its business, would violate any of the patents, trademarks, service
marks, tradenames, copyrights, trade secrets, mask works or other proprietary rights or processes
of any other Person. The Company has obtained and possesses valid licenses to use all of the
software programs present on the computers and other software-enabled electronic devices that it
owns or leases or that it has otherwise provided to its employees for their use in connection with
the Company's business. To the Company's knowledge, it will not be necessary to use any
inventions of any of its employees or consultants (or Persons it currently intends to hire) made
prior to their employment by the Company. Each employee and consultant has assigned to the
Company all intellectual property rights he or she owns that are related to the Company's
business as now conducted and as presently proposed to be conducted. Subsection 2.9 of the
Disclosure Schedule lists all Company Intellectual Property. Neither the Company, the
Company's products, nor any software or technology developed by or for the Company is subject
to any obligation or condition that would require that any of the Company's products or any other
software or other technology developed by or for the Company (i) be disclosed, distributed, or
made available in source code form; (ii) be licensed with the permission to create derivative
works; or (iii) be redistributable at no charge. For purposes of this Subsection 2.9, the Company
shall be deemed to have knowledge of a patent right if the Company has actual knowledge of the
patent right or would be found to be on notice of such patent right as determined by reference to
United States patent laws.
2.10 Compliance with Other Instruments. The Company is not in violation or
default (i) of any provisions of its Restated Certificate or Bylaws, (ii) of any instrument,
judgment, order, writ or decree, (iii) under any note, indenture or mortgage, or (iv) under any
lease, agreement, contract or purchase order to which it is a party or by which it is bound that is
required to be listed on the Disclosure Schedule, or, (v) to its knowledge, of any provision of
federal or state statute, rule or regulation applicable to the Company, the violation of which
would have a Material Adverse Effect. The execution, delivery and performance of the
Transaction Agreements and the consummation of the transactions contemplated by the
Transaction Agreements will not result in any such violation or be in conflict with or constitute,
with or without the passage of time and giving of notice, either (i) a default under any such
provision, instrument, judgment, order, writ, decree, contract or agreement or (ii) an event which
results in the creation of any lien, charge or encumbrance upon any assets of the Company or the
suspension, revocation, forfeiture, or nonrenewal of any material permit or license applicable to
the Company.
2.11 Agreements; Actions.

(a) Except for the Transaction Agreements, there are no agreements,
understandings, instruments, contracts or proposed transactions to which the Company is a party
or by which it is bound that involve (i) obligations (contingent or otherwise) of, or payments to,
the Company in excess of $50,000, (ii) the license of any patent, copyright, trademark, trade
secret or other proprietary right to or from the Company, (iii) the grant of rights to manufacture,
OHSUSA:755718737.3 8
produce, assemble, license, market, or sell its products to any other Person that limit the
Company's exclusive right to develop, manufacture, assemble, distribute, market or sell its
products, or (iv) indemnification by the Company with respect to infringements of proprietary
rights.

(b) The Company has not (i) declared or paid any dividends, or
authorized or made any distribution upon or with respect to any class or series of its capital stock,

(ii) incurred any indebtedness for money borrowed or incurred any other liabilities individually in
excess of $50,000 or in excess of $200,000 in the aggregate, (iii) made any loans or advances to
any Person, other than ordinary advances for travel expenses, or (iv) sold, exchanged or
otherwise disposed of any of its assets or rights, other than the sale of its inventory in the
ordinary course of business. For the purposes of subsections (b) and (c) of this Subsection 2.11,
all indebtedness, liabilities, agreements, understandings, instruments, contracts and proposed
transactions involving the same Person (including Persons the Company has reason to believe are
affiliated with each other) shall be aggregated for the purpose of meeting the individual
minimum dollar amounts of such subsection.

(c) of any other Person.
The Company is not a guarantor or indemnitor of any indebtedness
2.12 Certain Transactions.

(a) Other than (i) standard employee benefits generally made available
to all employees, (ii) standard director and officer indemnification agreements approved by the
Board of Directors, and (iii) the purchase of shares of the Company's capital stock and the
issuance of options to purchase shares of the Company's Common Stock, in each instance,
approved in the written minutes of the Board of Directors (previously provided to the Purchasers
or their counsel), there are no agreements, understandings or proposed transactions between the
Company and any of its officers, directors, consultants or Key Employees, or any Affiliate
thereof.
(b) The Company is not indebted, directly or indirectly, to any of its
directors, officers or employees or to their respective spouses or children or to any Affiliate of
any of the foregoing, other than in connection with expenses or advances of expenses incurred in
the ordinary course of business or employee relocation expenses and for other customary
employee benefits made generally available to all employees. None of the Company's directors,
officers or employees, or any members of their immediate families, or any Affiliate of the
foregoing (i) are, directly or indirectly, indebted to the Company or, to the Company's
knowledge, have any financial interest in any material contract with the Company, or (ii) have
any direct or indirect ownership interest in any firm or corporation with which the Company is
affiliated or with which the Company has a business relationship, or any firm or corporation
which competes with the Company.
2.13 Rights of Registration and Voting Rights. Except as provided in the
Investors' Rights Agreement, the Company is not under any obligation to register under the
Securities Act any of its currently outstanding securities or any securities issuable upon exercise
OHSUSA:755718737.3 9
or conversion of its currently outstanding securities. To the Company's knowledge, except as
contemplated in the Voting Agreement, no stockholder of the Company has entered into any
agreements with respect to the voting of capital shares of the Company.
2.14 Property. The property and assets that the Company owns are free and
clear of all mortgages, deeds of trust, liens, loans and encumbrances, except for statutory liens for
the payment of current taxes that are not yet delinquent and encumbrances and liens that arise in
the ordinary course of business and do not materially impair the Company's ownership or use of
such property or assets. With respect to the property and assets it leases, the Company is in
compliance with such leases and, to its knowledge, holds a valid leasehold interest free of any
liens, claims or encumbrances other than those of the lessors of such property or assets. The
Company does not own any real property.
2.15 Financial Statements. The Company has made available to each Purchaser
its unaudited financial statements (including balance sheet, income statement and statement of
cash flows) as of October 31, 2013 and for the fiscal year ended October 31, 2013 (collectively,
the "Financial Statements"). The Financial Statements have been prepared in accordance with
generally accepted accounting principles applied on a consistent basis throughout the periods
indicated, except that the unaudited Financial Statements may not contain all footnotes required
by generally accepted accounting principles. The Financial Statements fairly present in all
material respects the financial condition and operating results of the Company as of the dates,
and for the periods, indicated therein, except that the interim financial statements are subject to
normal year-end audit adjustments. Except as set forth in the Financial Statements, the Company
has no material liabilities or obligations, contingent or otherwise, other than (a) liabilities
incurred in the ordinary course of business subsequent to the date of the most recent balance
sheet included in the Financial Statements and (b) obligations under contracts and commitments
incurred in the ordinary course of business and not required under generally accepted accounting
principles to be reflected in the Financial Statements, which, in both cases, individually or in the
aggregate are not material to the financial condition or operating results of the Company.
2.16 Chances. Since October 31, 2013, there has not been:

(a) any change in the assets, liabilities, financial condition or operating
results of the Company from that reflected in the Financial Statements, except changes in the
ordinary course of business that have not caused, in the aggregate, a Material Adverse Effect;

(b) any damage, destruction or loss, whether or not covered by
insurance, that would have a Material Adverse Effect;

(c) any waiver or compromise by the Company of a valuable right or
of a material debt owed to it;
(d) any satisfaction or discharge of any lien, claim, or encumbrance or
payment of any obligation by the Company, except in the ordinary course of business and the
satisfaction or discharge of which would not have a Material Adverse Effect;
OHSUSA:7557 1 8737.3 10

(e) any material change to a material contract or agreement by which
the Company or any of its assets is bound or subject;

(f) any material change in any compensation arrangement or
agreement with any employee, officer, director or stockholder;

(g) any resignation or termination of employment of any officer or Key
Employee of the Company;
(h) any mortgage, pledge, transfer of a security interest in, or lien,
created by the Company, with respect to any of its material properties or assets, except liens for
taxes not yet due or payable and liens that arise in the ordinary course of business and do not
materially impair the Company's ownership or use of such property or assets;

(i) any loans or guarantees made by the Company to or for the benefit
of its employees, officers or directors, or any members of their immediate families, other than
travel advances and other advances made in the ordinary course of its business;

(j) any declaration, setting aside or payment or other distribution in
respect of any of the Company's capital stock, or any direct or indirect redemption, purchase, or
other acquisition of any of such stock by the Company;

(k) any sale, assignment or transfer of any Company Intellectual
Property that could reasonably be expected to result in a Material Adverse Effect;

(I) receipt of notice that there has been a loss of, or material order
cancellation by, any major customer of the Company;

(m) to the Company's knowledge, any other event or condition of any
character, other than events affecting the economy or the Company's industry generally, that
could reasonably be expected to result in a Material Adverse Effect; or

(n) any arrangement or commitment by the Company to do any of the
things described in this Subsection 2.16.
2.17 Employee Matters.

(a) Subsection 2.16 sets forth a list of all employees, consultants and
independent contractors of the Company as of the date hereof. To the Company's knowledge,
none of its employees is obligated under any contract (including licenses, covenants or
commitments of any nature) or other agreement, or subject to any judgment, decree or order of
any court or administrative agency, that would materially interfere with such employee's ability
to promote the interest of the Company or that would conflict with the Company's business.
Neither the execution or delivery of the Transaction Agreements, nor the carrying on of the
Company's business by the employees of the Company, nor the conduct of the Company's
business as now conducted and as presently proposed to be conducted, will, to the Company's
knowledge, conflict with or result in a breach of the terms, conditions, or provisions of, or
OHSUSA:755718737.3 11
constitute a default under, any contract, covenant or instrument under which any such employee
is now obligated.

(b) The Company is not delinquent in payments to any of its
employees, consultants, or independent contractors for any wages, salaries, commissions,
bonuses, or other direct compensation for any service performed for it to the date hereof or
amounts required to be reimbursed to such employees, consultants, or independent contractors.
The Company has complied in all material respects with all applicable state and federal equal
employment opportunity laws and with other laws related to employment, including those related
to wages, hours, worker classification, and collective bargaining. The Company has withheld
and paid to the appropriate governmental entity or is holding for payment not yet due to such
governmental entity all amounts required to be withheld from employees of the Company and is
not liable for any arrears of wages, taxes, penalties, or other sums for failure to comply with any
of the foregoing.

(c) To the Company's knowledge, no Key Employee intends to
terminate employment with the Company or is otherwise likely to become unavailable to
continue as a Key Employee, nor does the Company have a present intention to terminate the
employment of any of the foregoing. The employment of each employee of the Company is
terminable at the will of the Company. Except as set forth in Subsection 2.17 of the Disclosure
Schedule or as required by law, upon termination of the employment of any such employees, no
severance or other payments will become due. Except as set forth in Subsection 2.17 of the
Disclosure Schedule, the Company has no policy, practice, plan, or program of paying severance
pay or any form of severance compensation in connection with the termination of employment
services.

(d) The Company has not made any representations regarding equity
incentives to any officer, employees, director or consultant that are inconsistent with the share
amounts and terms set forth in the minutes of meetings of the Company's board of directors.

(e) Each former Key Employee whose employment was terminated by
the Company has entered into an agreement with the Company providing for the full release of
any claims against the Company or any related party arising out of such employment.
(f) Subsection 2.17 of the Disclosure Schedule sets forth each
employee benefit plan maintained, established or sponsored by the Company, or which the
Company participates in or contributes to, which is subject to the Employee Retirement Income
Security Act of 1974, as amended ("ERISA"). The Company has made all required
contributions and has no liability to any such employee benefit plan, other than liability for health
plan continuation coverage described in Part 6 of Title I(B) of ERISA, and has complied in all
material respects with all applicable laws for any such employee benefit plan.
2.18 Tax Returns and Payments. There are no federal, state, county, local or
foreign taxes dues and payable by the Company which have not been timely paid. There are no
accrued and unpaid federal, state, country, local or foreign taxes of the Company which are due,
whether or not assessed or disputed. There have been no examinations or audits of any tax
OHSUSA:755718737.3 12
returns or reports by any applicable federal, state, local or foreign governmental agency. The
Company has duly and timely filed all federal, state, county, local and foreign tax returns
required to have been filed by it and there are in effect no waivers of applicable statutes of
limitations with respect to taxes for any year.
2.19 Insurance. The Company has in full force and effect fire and casualty
insurance policies with extended coverage, sufficient in amount (subject to reasonable
deductions) to allow it to replace any of its properties that might be damaged or destroyed.
2.20 Emnlovee Agreements. Each current and former employee, consultant and
officer of the Company has executed an agreement with the Company regarding confidentiality
and proprietary information substantially in the form or forms delivered to the counsel for the
Purchasers (the "Confidential Information Agreements"). Each current and former Key
Employee has executed a non-solicitation agreement substantially in the for► or forms delivered
to counsel for Andreessen. No current or former Key Employee has excluded works or
inventions from his or her assignment of inventions pursuant to such Key Employee's
Confidential Information Agreement. The Company is not aware that any of its Key Employees
is in violation of any agreement covered by this Subsection 2.20.
2.21 Permits. The Company has all franchises, permits, licenses and any
similar authority necessary for the conduct of its business, the lack of which could reasonably be
expected to have a Material Adverse Effect. The Company is not in default in any material
respect under any of such franchises, permits, licenses or other similar authority.
2.22 Corporate Documents. The Restated Certificate and Bylaws of the
Company are in the form provided to the Purchasers. The copy of the minute books of the
Company provided to the Purchasers contains minutes of all meetings of directors and
stockholders and all actions by written consent without a meeting by the directors and
stockholders since the date of incorporation and accurately reflects in all material respects all
actions by the directors (and any committee of directors) and stockholders with respect to all
transactions referred to in such minutes.
2.23 Environmental and Safety Laws. Except as could not reasonably be
expected to have a Material Adverse Effect to the best of its knowledge (a) the Company is and
has been in compliance with all Environmental Laws; (b) there has been no release or to the
Company's knowledge threatened release of any pollutant, contaminant or toxic or hazardous
material, substance or waste, or petroleum or any fraction thereof, (each a "Hazardous
Substance") on, upon, into or from any site currently or heretofore owned, leased or otherwise
used by the Company; (c) there have been no Hazardous Substances generated by the Company
that have been disposed of or come to rest at any site that has been included in any published
U.S. federal, state or local "superfund" site list or any other similar list of hazardous or toxic
waste sites published by any governmental authority in the United States; and (d) there are no
underground storage tanks located on, no polychlorinated biphenyls ("PCBs") or PCB-containing
equipment used or stored on, and no hazardous waste as defined by the Resource Conservation
and Recovery Act, as amended, stored on, any site owned or operated by the Company, except
for the storage of hazardous waste in compliance with Environmental Laws. The Company has
OHSUSA:755718737.3 13
made available to the Purchasers true and complete copies of all material environmental records,
reports, notifications, certificates of need, permits, pending permit applications, correspondence,
engineering studies, and environmental studies or assessments.
For purposes of this Section 2.23 "Environmental Laws" means any law,
regulation, or other applicable requirement relating to (a) releases or threatened release of
Hazardous Substance; (b) pollution or protection of employee health or safety, public health or
the environment; or (c) the manufacture, handling, transport, use, treatment, storage, or disposal
of Hazardous Substances.
2.24 Disclosure. The Company has made available to the Purchasers all the
information reasonably available to the Company that the Purchasers have requested for deciding
whether to acquire the Shares, including certain of the Company's projections describing its
proposed business plan (the "Business Plan"). No representation or warranty of the Company
contained in this Agreement, as qualified by the Disclosure Schedule, and no certificate furnished
or to be furnished to Purchasers at the Closing contains any untrue statement of a material fact or,
to the Company's knowledge, omits to state a material fact necessary in order to make the
statements contained herein or therein not misleading in light of the circumstances under which
they were made. The Business Plan was prepared in good faith; however, the Company does not
warrant that it will achieve any results projected in the Business Plan. It is understood that this
representation is qualified by the fact that the Company has not delivered to the Purchasers, and
has not been requested to deliver, a private placement or similar memorandum or any written
disclosure of the types of information customarily furnished to purchasers of securities.
2.25 Data Privacy and Security. In connection with its collection, storage,
transfer (including without limitation, any transfer across national borders) and/or use of any
personally identifiable information from any individuals, including, without limitation, any
customers, prospective customers, employees and/or other third parties (collectively, "Personal
Information"), the Company is and has been, to the Company's knowledge, in compliance with
all applicable laws in all relevant jurisdictions, the Company's privacy policies, and the
requirements of any contract or codes of conduct to which the Company is a party. The
Company has physical, technical, organizational and administrative security measures and
policies in place to protect all Personal Information and all bitcoin public and/or private key
pairs, wallet addresses and similar data ("Sensitive Data") collected by it or on its behalf from
and against unauthorized access, use and/or disclosure. The Company has not experienced any
actual, probable or reasonably suspected breach of security of the Company Systems and/or of
any actual, probable or reasonably suspected unauthorized access, use, loss, destruction,
compromise or disclosure of any Sensitive Data and/or Personal Information ("Security
Breach"). The Company is and has been, to the Company's knowledge, in compliance in all
material respects with all laws relating to data loss, theft and breach of security notification
obligations. As used herein, "Company Systems" means the computer, information technology
and data processing systems, facilities and services used by or for the Company, including,
without limitation, all software, hardware, networks, communications facilities, platforms and
related systems and services used by the Company to store or otherwise process any Personal
Information or Sensitive Data.
OHSUSA:755718737.3 14
2.26 Disqualification. The Company is not disqualified from relying on Rule
506 of Regulation D ("Rule 506") under the Securities Act for any of the reasons stated in Rule
506(d) in connection with the issuance and sale of the Stock to the Purchasers. The Company
has furnished to each Purchaser, a reasonable time prior to the date hereof, a description in
writing of any matters that would have triggered disqualification under Rule 506(d) but which
occurred before September 23, 2013, in each case, in compliance with the disclosure
requirements of Rule 506(e).
3. Representations and Warranties of the Purchasers. Each Purchaser hereby
represents and warrants to the Company, severally and not jointly, that:
3.1 Authorization. The Purchaser has full power and authority to enter into
the Transaction Agreements. The Transaction Agreements to which the Purchaser is a party,
when executed and delivered by the Purchaser, will constitute valid and legally binding
obligations of the Purchaser, enforceable in accordance with their terms, except (a) as limited by
applicable bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization, moratorium, fraudulent conveyance, and any
other laws of general application affecting enforcement of creditors' rights generally, and as
limited by laws relating to the availability of specific performance, injunctive relief, or other
equitable remedies, or (b) to the extent the indemnification provisions contained in the Investors'
Rights Agreement may be limited by applicable federal or state securities laws.
3.2 Purchase Entirely for Own Account. This Agreement is made with the
Purchaser in reliance upon the Purchaser's representation to the Company, which by the
Purchaser's execution of this Agreement, the Purchaser hereby confirms, that the Shares to be
acquired by the Purchaser will be acquired for investment for the Purchaser's own account, not as
a nominee or agent (except as noted on the signature page hereof) and not with a view to the
resale or distribution of any part thereof, and that the Purchaser has no present intention of
selling, granting any participation in, or otherwise distributing the same. By executing this
Agreement, the Purchaser further represents that the Purchaser does not presently have any
contract, undertaking, agreement or arrangement with any Person to sell, transfer or grant
participations to such Person or to any third Person, with respect to any of the Shares. The
Purchaser has not been formed for the specific purpose of acquiring the Shares.
3.3 Disclosure of Information. The Purchaser has had an opportunity to
discuss the Company's business, management, financial affairs and the terms and conditions of
the offering of the Shares with the Company's management and has had an opportunity to review
the Company's facilities. The foregoing, however, does not limit or modify the representations
and warranties of the Company in Section 2 of this Agreement or the right of the Purchasers to
rely thereon.
3.4 Restricted Securities. The Purchaser understands that the Shares have not
been, and will not be, registered under the Securities Act, by reason of a specific exemption from
the registration provisions of the Securities Act which depends upon, among other things, the
bona fide nature of the investment intent and the accuracy of the Purchaser's representations as
expressed herein. The Purchaser understands that the Shares are "restricted securities" under
applicable U.S. federal and state securities laws and that, pursuant to these laws, the Purchaser
OHSUSA:75571$737.3 15
must hold the Shares indefinitely unless they are registered with the Securities and Exchange
Commission and qualified by state authorities, or an exemption from such registration and
qualification requirements is available. The Purchaser acknowledges that the Company has no
obligation to register or qualify the Shares, or the Common Stock into which it may be converted,
for resale except as set forth in the Investors' Rights Agreement. The Purchaser further
acknowledges that if an exemption from registration or qualification is available, it may be
conditioned on various requirements including, but not limited to, the time and manner of sale,
the holding period for the Shares, and on requirements relating to the Company which are outside
of the Purchaser's control, and which the Company is under no obligation and may not be able to
satisfy.
3.5 No Public Market. The Purchaser understands that no public market now
exists for the Shares, and that the Company has made no assurances that a public market will
ever exist for the Shares.
3.6 Legends. The Purchaser understands that the Shares and any securities
issued in respect of or exchange for the Shares, may bear one or all of the following legends:

(a) "THE SHARES REPRESENTED BY THIS CERTIFICATE
HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AND HAVE
BEEN ACQUIRED FOR INVESTMENT AND NOT WITH A VIEW TO, OR IN
CONNECTION WITH, THE SALE OR DISTRIBUTION THEREOF. NO SUCH TRANSFER
MAY BE EFFECTED WITHOUT AN EFFECTIVE REGISTRATION STATEMENT
RELATED THERETO OR AN OPINION OF COUNSEL IN A FORM SATISFACTORY TO
THE COMPANY THAT SUCH REGISTRATION IS NOT REQUIRED UNDER THE
SECURITIES ACT OF 1933."
(b) Any legend set forth in, or required by, the other Transaction
Agreements.
(c) Any legend required by the securities laws of any state to the extent
such laws are applicable to the Shares represented by the certificate so legended.
3.7 Accredited Investor. The Purchaser is an accredited investor as defined in
Rule 501(a) of Regulation D promulgated under the Securities Act.
3.8 Foreign Investors. If the Purchaser is not a United States person (as
defined by Section 7701(aX30) of the Code), the Purchaser hereby represents that it has satisfied
itself as to the full observance of the laws of its jurisdiction in connection with any invitation to
subscribe for the Shares or any use of this Agreement, including (i) the legal requirements within
its jurisdiction for the purchase of the Shares, (ii) any foreign exchange restrictions applicable to
such purchase, (iii) any governmental or other consents that may need to be obtained, and (iv) the
income tax and other tax consequences, if any, that may be relevant to the purchase, holding,
redemption, sale, or transfer of the Shares. The Purchaser's subscription and payment for and
continued beneficial ownership of the Shares will not violate any applicable securities or other
laws of the Purchaser's jurisdiction.
OHSUSA:755718737.3 16
3.9 No General Solicitation. Neither the Purchaser, nor any of its officers,
directors, employees, agents, stockholders or partners has either directly or indirectly, including
through a broker or finder (a) engaged in any general solicitation, or (b) published any
advertisement in connection with the offer and sale of the Shares.
3.10 Exculpation Among Purchasers. The Purchaser acknowledges that it is
not relying upon any Person, other than the Company and its officers and directors, in making its
investment or decision to invest in the Company.
3.11 Residence. If the Purchaser is an individual, then the Purchaser resides in
the state or province identified in the address of the Purchaser set forth on Exhibit A; if the
Purchaser is a partnership, corporation, limited liability company or other entity, then the office
or offices of the Purchaser in which its principal place of business is identified in the address or
addresses of the Purchaser set forth on Exhibit A.
3.12 Consent to Promissory Note Conversion and Termination. Each
Purchaser, to the extent that such Purchaser, as set forth on the Schedule of Purchasers, is a
holder of any promissory note of the Company being converted and/or cancelled in consideration
of the issuance hereunder of Shares to such Purchaser, hereby agrees that the entire amount owed
to such Purchaser under such note is being tendered to the Company in exchange for the
applicable Shares set forth on the Schedule of Purchasers, and effective upon the Company's and
such Purchaser's execution and delivery of this Agreement, without any further action required
by the Company or such Purchaser, such note and all obligations set forth therein shall be
immediately deemed repaid in full and terminated in their entirety, including, but not limited to,
any security interest effected therein.
3.13 Disqualification. Each Purchaser represents that neither such Purchaser,
nor any person or entity with whom such Purchaser shares beneficial ownership of Company
securities, is subject to any of the "Bad Actor" disqualifications described in Rule 506(dX I Xi) to
(viii) under the Securities Act (attached hereto as Annex D.
4. Conditions to the Purchasers' Obligations at Closing. The obligations of each
Purchaser to purchase Shares at the Initial Closing and each subsequent Closing are subject to the
fulfillment, on or before such Closing, of each of the following conditions, unless otherwise
waived:
4.1 Representations and Warranties. The representations and warranties of the
Company contained in Section 2 shall be true and correct in all material respects on and as of the
Initial Closing with the same effect as though such representations and warranties had been made
on and as of the date of such Initial Closing.
4.2 Performance. The Company shall have performed and complied with all
covenants, agreements, obligations and conditions contained in this Agreement that are required
to be performed or complied with by the Company on or before such Closing.
OHSUSA:7557 I 8737.3 17
4.3 Compliance Certificate. The President of the Company shall deliver to the
Purchasers at such Closing a certificate certifying that the conditions specified in Subsections 4.1
and 4.2 have been fulfilled.
4.4 Qualifications. All authorizations, approvals or permits, if any, of any
governmental authority or regulatory body of the United States or of any state that are required in
connection with the lawful issuance and sale of the Shares pursuant to this Agreement shall be
obtained and effective as of such Closing.
4.5 Opinion of Company Counsel. The Purchasers shall have received from
Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, counsel for the Company, an opinion, dated as of the Initial
Closing, in substantially the form of Exhibit I attached to this Agreement
4.6 Board of Directors. As of the Initial Closing, the authorized size of the
Board shall be 2, and the Board shall be comprised of Brian Armstrong and Fred Ehrsam.
4.7 Indemnification Agreement. The Company shall have executed and
delivered the Indemnification Agreements.
4.8 Investors' Rights Agreement. The Company and each Purchaser (other
than the Purchaser relying upon this condition to excuse such Purchaser's performance
hereunder) shall have executed and delivered the Investors' Rights Agreement.
4.9 Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement. The Company, each
Purchaser (other than the Purchaser relying upon this condition to excuse such Purchaser's
performance hereunder), and the other stockholders of the Company named as parties thereto
shall have executed and delivered the Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement.
4.10 Voting Agreement. The Company, each Purchaser (other than the
Purchaser relying upon this condition to excuse such Purchaser's performance hereunder), and
the other stockholders of the Company named as parties thereto shall have executed and
delivered the Voting Agreement.
4.11 Restated Certificate. The Company shall have filed the Restated
Certificate with the Secretary of State of Delaware on or prior to the Closing, which shall
continue to be in full force and effect as of the Closing.
4.12 Secretary's Certificate. The Secretary of the Company shall have
delivered to the Purchasers at the Closing a certificate certifying (i) the Bylaws of the Company,
(ii) resolutions of the Board of Directors of the Company approving the Transaction Agreements
and the transactions contemplated under the Transaction Agreements, and (iii) resolutions of the
stockholders of the Company approving the Restated Certificate.
4.13 Proceedings and Documents. All corporate and other proceedings in
connection with the transactions contemplated at the Closing and all documents incident thereto
shall be reasonably satisfactory in form and substance to each Purchaser, and each Purchaser (or
OHSUSA:755718737.3 18
its counsel) shall have received all such counterpart original and certified or other copies of such
documents as reasonably requested. Such documents may include good standing certificates.
4.14 Management Rights. Management Rights Letters shall have been
executed by the Company and delivered to each of Andreessen, USV and Ribbit Capital.
4.15 Preemptive Rights. The Company shall have fully satisfied (including
with respect to rights of timely notification) or obtained enforceable waivers in respect of any
preemptive or similar rights directly or indirectly affecting any of its securities.
4.16 indemnification Agreement. The Company's board and stockholders shall
have approved a form of indemnification agreement for use between the Company, its directors
and Purchaser Affiliates, if any, affiliated with any Purchaser that is entitled to designate a
member of the Company's Board of Directors.
4.17 Amendment of Convertible Notes: Satisfaction and Cancelation. The
Company and each Purchaser who holds (either directly or through an affiliate or affiliates) one
or more Convertible Notes issued prior to the Closing, on behalf of itself and all such Purchasers,
hereby (i) agree to amend each such Convertible Note such that the entire principal amount of
each such Convertible Note plus accrued interest to be converted into Series B Preferred Stock
and, if applicable, Common Stock pursuant to such Convertible Note shall be equal to the
amount shown on Exhibit A, (ii) agree that upon the Initial Closing each Convertible Note has
been convened in accordance with the terms into a right of the Purchaser to receive the shares of
Series B Preferred Stock and, if applicable, Common Stock set forth on Exhibit A, (iii) agree that
all amounts owed to such Purchaser by the Company under any borrowings by the Company,
whether evidenced orally or in writing, including without limitation, the Convertible Notes and
any unpaid principal balance, any interest owed and any penalties or additional fees owed to such
Purchaser shall be deemed fully paid and satisfied by the Company and are deemed canceled and

(iv) agree to terminate the Note Purchase Agreements pursuant to which such Convertible Notes
were issued.

5. Conditions of the Company's Obligations at Closing. The obligations of the
Company to sell Shares to the Purchasers at the Initial Closing or any subsequent Closing are
subject to the fulfillment, on or before the Closing, of each of the following conditions, unless
otherwise waived:
5.1 Representations and Warranties. The representations and warranties of
each Purchaser contained in Subsection 4.1 shall be true and correct in all respects as of such
Closing.
5.2 Performance. The Purchasers shall have performed and complied with all
covenants, agreements, obligations and conditions contained in this Agreement that are required
to be performed or complied with by them on or before such Closing.
5.3 Oualifications. All authorizations, approvals or permits, if any, of any
governmental authority or regulatory body of the United States or of any state that are required in
OHSUSA:7557 187373 19
connection with the lawful issuance and sale of the Shares pursuant to this Agreement shall be
obtained and effective as of the Closing.
5.4 Investors' Rights Agreement. Each Purchaser shall have executed and
delivered the Investors' Rights Agreement.
5.5 Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement. Each Purchaser and the
other stockholders of the Company named as parties thereto shall have executed and delivered
the Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale Agreement.
5.6 Voting Agreement. Each Purchaser and the other stockholders of the
Company named as parties thereto shall have executed and delivered the Voting Agreement.
6. Miscellaneous.
6.1 Survival of Warranties. Unless otherwise set forth in this Agreement, the
representations and warranties of the Company and the Purchasers contained in or made pursuant
to this Agreement shall survive the execution and delivery of this Agreement and the Closing for
a period of two (2) years following the Closing and shall in no way be affected by any
investigation or knowledge of the subject matter thereof made by or on behalf of the Purchasers
or the Company.
6.2 Successors and Assigns. The terms and conditions of this Agreement shall
inure to the benefit of and be binding upon the respective successors and assigns of the parties.
Nothing in this Agreement, express or implied, is intended to confer upon any party other than
the parties hereto or their respective successors and assigns any rights, remedies, obligations,
or liabilities under or by reason of this Agreement, except as expressly provided in this
Agreement.
6.3 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by the internal law of
the State of Delaware.
6.4 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in two or more
counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original, but all of which together shall constitute
one and the same instrument. Counterparts may be delivered via facsimile, electronic mail
(including pdf or any electronic signature complying with the U.S. federal ESIGN Act of 2000,
e.g., www.docusign.com) or other transmission method and any counterpart so delivered shall be
deemed to have been duly and validly delivered and be valid and effective for all purposes.
6.5 Titles and Subtitles. The titles and subtitles used in this Agreement are
used for convenience only and are not to be considered in construing or interpreting this
Agreement.
6.6 Notices. All notices and other communications given or made pursuant to
this Agreement shall be in writing and shall be deemed effectively given upon the earlier of
actual receipt or: (a) personal delivery to the party to be notified, (b) when sent, if sent by
electronic mail or facsimile during normal business hours of the recipient, and if not sent during
O11SUSA:755718737.3 20
normal business hours, then on the recipient's next business day, (c) five (5) days after having
been sent by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested, postage prepaid, or (d) one (1)
business day after deposit with a nationally recognized overnight courier, freight prepaid,
specifying next business day delivery, with written verification of receipt. All communications
shall be sent to the respective parties at their address as set forth on the signature page or Exhibit
A, or to such e-mail address, facsimile number or address as subsequently modified by written
notice given in accordance with this Subsection 6.6. If notice is given to the Company, a copy
shall also be sent to Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, 1000 Marsh Road, Menlo Park, CA
94025 Attention: John V. Bautista and if notice is given to the Purchasers, a copy shall also be
given to Perkins Coie LLP, 3150 Porter Drive, Palo Alto, CA 94304 Attention: Lowell Ness.
6.7 No Finder's Fees. Each party represents that it neither is nor will be
obligated for any finder's fee or commission in connection with this transaction. Each Purchaser
agrees to indemnify and to hold harmless the Company from any liability for any commission or
compensation in the nature of a finder's or broker's fee arising out of this transaction (and the
costs and expenses of defending against such liability or asserted liability) for which each
Purchaser or any of its officers, employees, or representatives is responsible. The Company
agrees to indemnify and hold harmless each Purchaser from any liability for any commission or
compensation in the nature of a finder's or broker's fee arising out of this transaction (and the
costs and expenses of defending against such liability or asserted liability) for which the
Company or any of its officers, employees or representatives is responsible.
6.8 Fees and Expenses. At the Closing, the Company shall pay the reasonable
fees and expenses of Perkins Coie LLP, the counsel for Andreessen Horowitz, in an amount not
to exceed, in the aggregate, $35,000.
6.9 Amendments and Waivers. Except as set forth in Subsection 1.3 of this
Agreement, any term of this Agreement may be amended, terminated or waived only with the
written consent of the Company and (i) the holders of at least a majority of the then-outstanding
Shares or (ii) for an amendment, termination or waiver effected prior to the Initial Closing,
Purchasers obligated to purchase a majority of the Shares to be issued at the Initial Closing. Any
amendment or waiver effected in accordance with this Subsection 6.9 shall be binding upon the
Purchasers and each transferee of the Shares (or the Common Stock issuable upon conversion
thereof), each future holder of all such securities, and the Company.
6.10 Severability. The invalidity or unenforceability of any provision hereof
shall in no way affect the validity or enforceability of any other provision.
6.11 Delays or Omissions. No delay or omission to exercise any right, power
or remedy accruing to any party under this Agreement, upon any breach or default of any other
party under this Agreement, shall impair any such right, power or remedy of such non-breaching
or non-defaulting party nor shall it be construed to be a waiver of any such breach or default, or
an acquiescence therein, or of or in any similar breach or default thereafter occurring; nor shall
any waiver of any single breach or default be deemed a waiver of any other breach or default
theretofore or thereafter occurring. Any waiver, permit, consent or approval of any kind or
character on the part of any party of any breach or default under this Agreement, or any waiver on
OHSUSk.755718737.3 21
the part of any party of any provisions or conditions of this Agreement, must be in writing and
shall be effective only to the extent specifically set forth in such writing. All remedies, either
under this Agreement or by law or otherwise afforded to any party, shall be cumulative and not
alternative.
6.12 Entire Agreement. This Agreement (including the Exhibits hereto), the
Restated Certificate and the other Transaction Agreements constitute the full and entire
understanding and agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof, and
any other written or oral agreement relating to the subject matter hereof existing between the
parties are expressly canceled.
6.13 Corporate Securities Law. THE SALE OF THE SECURITIES WHICH
ARE THE SUBJECT OF THIS AGREEMENT HAS NOT BEEN QUALIFIED WITH THE
COMMISSIONER OF CORPORATIONS OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA AND THE
ISSUANCE OF THE SECURITIES OR THE PAYMENT OR RECEIPT OF ANY PART OF
THE CONSIDERATION THEREFOR PRIOR TO THE QUALIFICATION IS UNLAWFUL,
UNLESS THE SALE OF SECURITIES IS EXEMPT FROM THE QUALIFICATION BY
SECTION 25100, 25102 OR 25105 OF THE CALIFORNIA CORPORATIONS CODE. THE
RIGHTS OF ALL PARTIES TO THIS AGREEMENT ARE EXPRESSLY CONDITIONED
UPON THE QUALIFICATION BEING OBTAINED UNLESS THE SALE IS SO EXEMPT.
6.14 Dispute Resolution. Any unresolved controversy or claim arising out of or
relating to this Agreement, except as (i) otherwise provided in this Agreement, or (ii) any such
controversies or claims arising out of either party's intellectual property rights for which a
provisional remedy or equitable relief is sought, shall be submitted to arbitration by one arbitrator
mutually agreed upon by the parties, and if no agreement can be reached within thirty (30) days
after names of potential arbitrators have been proposed by the American Arbitration Association
(the "AAA"), then by one arbitrator having reasonable experience in corporate finance
transactions of the type provided for in this Agreement and who is chosen by the AAA. The
arbitration shall take place in Delaware County, Delaware, in accordance with the AAA rules
then in effect, and judgment upon any award rendered in such arbitration will be binding and may
be entered in any court having jurisdiction thereof. There shall be limited discovery prior to the
arbitration hearing as follows: (a) exchange of witness lists and copies of documentary evidence
and documents relating to or arising out of the issues to be arbitrated, (b) depositions of all party
witnesses and (c) such other depositions as may be allowed by the arbitrators upon a showing of
good cause. Depositions shall be conducted in accordance with the Delaware Code of Civil
Procedure, the arbitrator shall be required to provide in writing to the parties the basis for the
award or order of such arbitrator, and a court reporter shall record all hearings, with such record
constituting the official transcript of such proceedings. The prevailing party shall be entitled to
reasonable attorney's fees, costs, and necessary disbursements in addition to any other relief to
which such party may be entitled. Each of the parties to this Agreement consents to personal
jurisdiction for any equitable action sought in the U.S. District Court for the District of Delaware
or any court of the State of Delaware having subject matter jurisdiction.
WAIVER OF JURY TRIAL: EACH PARTY HEREBY WAIVES ITS RIGHTS TO A JURY
TRIAL OF ANY CLAIM OR CAUSE OF ACTION BASED UPON OR ARISING OUT OF
OHSUSA:755718737.3 22
THIS AGREEMENT, THE OTHER TRANSACTION DOCUMENTS, THE SECURITIES OR
THE SUBJECT MATTER HEREOF OR THEREOF. THE SCOPE OF THIS WAIVER IS
INTENDED TO BE ALL-ENCOMPASSING OF ANY AND ALL DISPUTES THAT MAY BE
FILED IN ANY COURT AND THAT RELATE TO THE SUBJECT MATTER OF THIS
TRANSACTION, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, CONTRACT CLAIMS, TORT
CLAIMS (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE), BREACH OF DUTY CLAIMS, AND ALL OTHER
COMMON LAW AND STATUTORY CLAIMS. THIS SECTION HAS BEEN FULLY
DISCUSSED BY EACH OF THE PARTIES HERETO AND THESE PROVISIONS WILL
NOT BE SUBJECT TO ANY EXCEPTIONS. EACH PARTY HERETO HEREBY FURTHER
WARRANTS AND REPRESENTS THAT SUCH PARTY HAS REVIEWED THIS WAIVER
WITH ITS LEGAL COUNSEL, AND THAT SUCH PARTY KNOWINGLY AND
VOLUNTARILY WAIVES ITS JURY TRIAL RIGHTS FOLLOWING CONSULTATION
WITH LEGAL COUNSEL
6.15 Waiver of Conflicts. Each party to this Agreement acknowledges that
Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP, counsel for the Company, has in the past performed and may
continue to perform legal services for certain of the Purchasers in matters unrelated to the
transactions described in this Agreement, including the representation of such Purchasers in
venture capital financings and other matters. Accordingly, each party to this Agreement hereby
(a) acknowledges that they have had an opportunity to ask for information relevant to this
disclosure; and (b) gives its informed consent to Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP's
representation of certain of the Purchasers in such unrelated matters and to Orrick, Herrington &
Sutcliffe LLP's representation of the Company in connection with this Agreement and the
transactions contemplated hereby.
6.16 Attorney's Fees. If any action at law or in equity (including arbitration) is
necessary to enforce or interpret the terms of any of the Transaction Agreements, the prevailing
party shall be entitled to reasonable attorney's fees, costs and necessary disbursements in
addition to any other relief to which such party may be entitled.
6.17 Sale of FF Preferred Stock. The Purchasers that are purchasing FF
Preferred Stock, listed on Exhibit A attached hereto (the "FF Preferred Stock Purchasers") shall
purchase shares of FF Preferred Stock from certain holders thereof (as set forth on Exhibit A, the
"FF Sellers"), pursuant to an FF Preferred Stock Transfer Agreement at the April 2014 Closing,
which shares shall automatically convert into shares of Series B Preferred Stock as of the date of
purchase. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the FF Preferred Stock Purchasers shall be considered
"Purchasers" for the purposes of this Agreement with respect to the shares of FF Preferred Stock
purchased by such Purchasers and shall sign and be bound by the terms of the Transaction
Agreements with respect to such shares of FF Preferred Stock.
[Signature pages follow]
OHSUSA:755718737.3 23
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Series B Preferred Stock
Purchase Agreement as of the date first written above.
COMPANY:
COINBASE, INC.
By:
Name: Brian Armstrong
Title: Chief Executive Officer
FF SELLERS:
By: C13--- e ——
Name: Brian Armstrong
?red uhrsani By:
Name: Fred Ehrsam
SIGNATURE PAGE TO STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Series B Preferred Stock
Purchase Agreement as of the date first written above.
PURCHASERS:
UNION SQUARE VENTURES 2012 FUND, L.P.
By: Union Square 2012 ., its General
Partner
By
Name: Wtlke\
Title: 420, A.,/
USV INVESTORS 2012 FUND, L.P.
By: Union Square 2012 G .C., its General
Partner
By
Name: fac N\Ascn
Title: ocr w a ,e-
SIGNATURE PAGE TO STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Series B Preferred Stock
Purchase Agreement as of the date first written above.
PURCHASERS:
RIBBIT CAPITAL, L.P.
By: Ribbit Capital GP, L.P., its General Partner
By: Ribbit Capital GP,
Ltd., its general partner
FINTECH COINBASE HOLDINGS, LLC
By:
Meyer M ka, Director
SIGNATURE PAGE TO STOCK PURCIIASE AGREEMENT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Series B Preferred Stock
Purchase Agreement as of the date first written above.
PURCHASERS:
ANDREESSEN HOROWITZ FUND III, L.P.
for itself and as nominee for
Andreessen Horowitz Fund Ill-A, L.P.,
Andreessen Horowitz Fund L.P. and
Andreessen Horowitz Fund III-Q, L.P.
By: AH Equity Partners III, L.L.C.
Its general partner
By:
Name:
Title:  Th ew. har
SIGNATURE PAGE TO STOCK PURCHASE AGREEhIENT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Series B Preferred Stock
Purchase Agreement as of the date first written above.
PURCHASERS:
QUEENSBRIDGE PARTNERS, LLC
By:
Name: Dennis Nguyen
Title: COO/CFO
SIGNATURE PAGE TO STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Series B Preferred Stock
Purchase Agreement as of the date first written above.
PURCHASERS:
KINDLING CAPITAL LLC
By:  *tit
Name: Jenny Haeg
or (print)
Title:  Managing Member
Address:
28 2nd Street, 3rd floor
San Francisco, CA 94105
SIGNATURE PAGE TO STOCK PURCHASE AGREEMENT
EXHIBIT B - FORM OF AMENDED AND RESTATED
CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION
Exhibit C - DISCLOSURE SCHEDULE
Exhibit D - FORM OF INDEMNIFICATION AGREEMENT
Exhibit E - FORM OF AMENDED AND RESTATED INVESTORS'
RIGHTS AGREEMENT
Exhibit F - FORM OF MANAGEMENT RIGHTS LETTER
Exhibit G - FORM OF AMENDED AND RESTATED RIGHT OF FIRST
REFUSAL AND CO -SALE AGREEMENT
Exhibit H - FORM OF AMENDED AND RESTATED VOTING
AGREEMENT
Exhibit I - FORM OF LEGAL OPINION OF ORRICK, HERRINGTON &
SUTCLIFFE LLP
EXHIBIT A
SCHEDULE OF PURCHASERS
SCHEDULE OF PURCHASERS
Initial Closing: December 12, 2013
Purchaser Name Cancelled Debt
Common Stock
Shares for
Cancelled Debt
Series B Shares
for Cancelled
Debt
Cash Series B Shares
for Cash
Total Series B
Shares
Union Square Ventures 2012 Fund, L.P.
$1,403,769.94 58,099 232,390 $2,071,041.43 342,857 575,247
USV Investors 2012 Fund, L.P.
$54,305.90 2,248 8,989 $80,121.73 13,264 22,253
Ribbit Capital, LP
$1,051,913.12 43,536 174,141 51,288,767.34 213,353 387,494
Fintech Coinbase Holdings, LLC
- - $260,069.41 43,054 43,054
Andreessen Horowitz Fund III, L.P., as nominee $10,002,739.73 - 1,655,934 $5,633,975.42 932,694
2,588,628
TOTAL S12,512,728.69 103,883 2,071,454 $9,333,975.33 1,545,222 3,616,676
SCHEDULE OF PURCHASERS
Subsequent Closing: December 27, 2013
Purchaser Name Cash Series B Shares
for Cash
FF Preferred
Shares for Cash
(from Brian
Armstrong)
FF Preferred
Shares for Cash
(from Fred
Ehrsam)
Total Series B Shares
(including FF
Preferred Shares)
Queensbridge Partners, LLC $50,003.59 8,278 0 0 8,278
-4-

╭───────────────────────── Page 33, Image 1 ─────────────────────────╮
│ eure ° 0 suz’s 6s'e00'0ss 77 ‘srouued aBpugsu2and,                 │
│ (wessua Guonsusy                                                   │
│ saaeys po1s9j94,                                                   │
│ (soreys po1s9josd patg moa) wwetigi wos) se 405 we ‘suey s9seqpand │
│ sey 10j soueyg | yse> 10) soueys | sozeys q so119g                 │
│ poxsojrd at | pousajetd dd                                         │
│                                                                    │
│ SUASVHOUNd AO ATAGAHIS                                             │
│                                                                    │
│ £107 ‘LZ 49quia99q :3uys0]9 juanbasqns                             │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

SCHEDULE OF PURCHASERS
Subsequent Closing: February 10, 2014
Purchaser Name Cash Series B Shares
for Cash
FF Preferred
Shares for Cash
(from Brian
Armstrong)
FF Preferred
Shares for Cash
(from Fred
Ehrsam)
Total Series B Shares
(including FF
Preferred Shares)
Kindling Capital LLC S14,998.66 2,483 0 0 2,483
-5-

╭───────────────────────── Page 34, Image 1 ──────────────────────────╮
│ sare o 0 savz__| ovges'nis OTT ede Suypuy                           │
│ (saaet (wesiqg (Guoaysuay                                           │
│ “aor oi so aye wus a se auen soseysang                              │
│ Soret sauisg erog, | SEDAN SOAEUS | HSE. 405 saxEys | souEUS A SHAS │
│ _ pawsajeid Ad pa3jaid Ad                                           │
│                                                                     │
│ SUAISVHOUNd AO TINGS:                                               │
│                                                                     │
│ PIOZ ‘OT Aten.sqay :Sursof) yuanbasqns                              │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

SCHEDULE OF PURCHASERS
Subsequent Closing: April 26, 2014
Purchaser Name Cash Series B Shares
for Cash
FF Preferred
Shares for Cash
(from Brian
Armstrong)
FT Preferred
Shares for Cash
(from Fred
Ehrsam)
Total Series B Shares
(including FE
Preferred Shares)
Andreessen Horowitz Fund III, M., as nominee $3,675,825.65 165,548 342,978 100,000 608,526
-5-

╭─────────────────────────────────── Page 35, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 9zs'809 00°00 sLe‘cre 8pS'S91 S9'STS'SLO'ES souruiou se “I ‘111 puny zmoroy1 uassaaupuy │
│ Gsoawys passayaig (overex .                                                             │
│ aa Surpayou) Pos wou) wo sea urey soseypang                                             │
│ soatte a sass reiog, | WED 40Usez0US | HSE 405 saxeyS | SBAEYS A s9LINS                 │
│ pousyetd dt | peasayesd A                                                               │
│                                                                                         │
│ SUASVHOUNd AO ATAGAIHDS:                                                                │
│                                                                                         │
│ PLOT ‘97 [dy :Buyso[5 yuanbasqng                                                        │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

EXHIBIT B
FORM OF AMENDED AND RESTATED
CERTIFICATE OF INCORPORATION
See Tab 3
EXHIBIT C
DISCLOSURE SCHEDULE
See Tab 5
EXHIBIT D
FORM OF INDEMNIFICATION AGREEMENT
COINBASE, INC.
INDEMNIFICATION AGREEMENT
This Indemnification Agreement (this "Agreement")  is made as of by and
between Coinbase, Inc., a Delaware corporation (the "Company"), and
("Indemnitee").
RECITALS
The Company and Indemnitee recognize the increasing difficulty in obtaining liability
insurance for directors, officers and key employees, the significant increases in the cost of such
insurance and the general reductions in the coverage of such insurance. The Company and
Indemnitee further recognize the substantial increase in corporate litigation in general, subjecting
directors, officers and key employees to expensive litigation risks at the same time as the
availability and coverage of liability insurance has been severely limited. Indemnitee does not
regard the current protection available as adequate under the present circumstances, and
Indemnitee may not be willing to continue to serve in Indemnitee's current capacity with the
Company without additional protection. The Company desires to attract and retain the services
of highly qualified individuals, such as Indemnitee, and to indemnify its directors, officers and
key employees so as to provide them with the maximum protection permitted by law.
AGREEMENT
In consideration of the mutual promises made in this Agreement, and for other good and
valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby acknowledged, the
Company and Indemnitee hereby agree as follows:

1. Indemnification.
(a) Third -Party Proceedings.  To the fullest extent permitted by applicable
law, the Company shall indemnify Indemnitee, if Indemnitee was, is or is threatened to be made,
a party to or a participant (as a witness or otherwise) in any Proceeding (other than a Proceeding
by or in the right of the Company to procure a judgment in the Company's favor), against all
Expenses, judgments, fines and amounts paid in settlement (if such settlement is approved in
advance by the Company, which approval shall not be unreasonably withheld) actually and
reasonably incurred by Indemnitee in connection with such Proceeding if Indemnitee acted in
good faith and in a manner Indemnitee reasonably believed to be in or not opposed to the best
interests of the Company and, in the case of a criminal Proceeding, had no reasonable cause to
believe Indemnitee's conduct was unlawful.

(b) Proceedings By or in the Right of the Company.  To the fullest extent
permitted by applicable law, the Company shall indemnify Indemnitee, if Indemnitee was, is or
is threatened to be made a party to or a participant (as a witness or otherwise) in any Proceeding
by or in the right of the Company to procure a judgment in the Company's favor, against all
Expenses actually and reasonably incurred by Indemnitee in connection with such Proceeding if
Indemnitee acted in good faith and in a manner Indemnitee reasonably believed to be in or not
°MUSA:7533470752
28154-1
opposed to the best interests of the Company, except that no indemnification shall be made in
respect of any claim, issue or matter as to which Indemnitee shall have been finally adjudicated
by court order or judgment to be liable to the Company unless and only to the extent that the
Court of Chancery or the court in which such Proceeding is or was pending shall determine upon
application that, in view of all the circumstances of the case, Indemnitee is fairly and reasonably
entitled to indemnity for such expenses which such court shall deem proper.

(c) Success on the Merits.  To the fullest extent permitted by applicable law
and to the extent that Indemnitee has been successful on the merits or otherwise in defense of
any Proceeding referred to in Section 1(a) or Section 1(b) or the defense of any claim, issue or
matter therein, in whole or in part, the Company shall indemnify Indemnitee against all Expenses
actually and reasonably incurred by Indemnitee in connection therewith. Without limiting the
generality of the foregoing, if Indemnitee is successful on the merits or otherwise as to one or
more but less than all claims, issues or matters in a Proceeding, the Company shall indemnify
Indemnitee against all Expenses actually and reasonably incurred by Indemnitee in connection
with such successfully resolved claims, issues or matters to the fullest extent permitted by
applicable law. If any Proceeding is disposed of on the merits or otherwise (including a
disposition without prejudice), without (i) the disposition being adverse to Indemnitee, (ii) an
adjudication that Indemnitee was liable to the Company, (iii) a plea of guilty by Indemnitee, (iv)
an adjudication that Indemnitee did not act in good faith and in a manner Indemnitee reasonably
believed to be in or not opposed to the best interests of the Company, and (v) with respect to any
criminal Proceeding, an adjudication that Indemnitee had reasonable cause to believe
Indemnitee's conduct was unlawful, Indemnitee shall be considered for the purposes hereof to
have been wholly successful with respect thereto.

(d) Witness Expenses. To the fullest extent permitted by applicable law and
to the extent that Indemnitee is a witness or otherwise asked to participate in any Proceeding to
which Indemnitee is not a party, the Company shall indemnify Indemnitee against all Expenses
actually and reasonably incurred by Indemnitee in connection with such Proceeding.

2. Indemnification Procedure.
(a) Advancement of Expenses. To the fullest extent permitted by applicable
law, the Company shall advance all Expenses actually and reasonably incurred by Indemnitee in
connection with a Proceeding within thirty (30) days after receipt by the Company of a statement
requesting such advances from time to time, whether prior to or after final disposition -of any
Proceeding. Such advances shall be unsecured and interest free and shall be made without
regard to Indemnitee's ability to repay the Expenses and without regard to Indemnitee's ultimate
entitlement to indemnification under the other provisions of this Agreement. Indemnitee shall
be entitled to continue to receive advancement of Expenses pursuant to this Section 2(a) unless
and until the matter of Indemnitee's entitlement to indemnification hereunder has been finally
adjudicated by court order or judgment from which no further right of appeal exists. Indemnitee
hereby undertakes to repay such amounts advanced only if, and to the extent that, it ultimately is
determined that Indemnitee is not entitled to be indemnified by the Company under the other
provisions of this Agreement. Indemnitee shall qualify for advances upon the execution and
delivery of this Agreement, which shall constitute the requisite undertaking with respect to
°MUSA:7533470752
28154-I
-2-
repayment of advances made hereunder and no other form of undertaking shall be required to
qualify for advances made hereunder other than the execution of this Agreement.

(b) Notice and Cooperation by Indemnitee. Indemnitee shall promptly
notify the Company in writing upon being served with any summons, citation, subpoena,
complaint, indictment, information or other document relating to any Proceeding or matter for
which indemnification will or could be sought under this Agreement. Such notice to the
Company shall include a description of the nature of, and facts underlying, the Proceeding, shall
be directed to the Chief Executive Officer of the Company and shall be given in accordance with
the provisions of Section 13(e) below. In addition, Indemnitee shall give the Company such
additional information and cooperation as the Company may reasonably request. Indemnitee's
failure to so notify, provide information and otherwise cooperate with the Company shall not
relieve the Company of any obligation that it may have to Indemnitee under this Agreement,
except to the extent that the Company is adversely affected by such failure.

(c) Determination of Entitlement.
(i) Final Disposition. Notwithstanding any other provision in this
Agreement, no determination as to entitlement to indemnification under this Agreement shall be
required to be made prior to the final disposition of the Proceeding.
(ii) Determination and Payment. Subject to the foregoing, promptly
after receipt of a statement requesting payment with respect to the indemnification rights set
forth in Section 1, to the extent required by applicable law, the Company shall take the steps
necessary to authorize such payment in the manner set forth in Section 145 of the Delaware
General Corporation Law. The Company shall pay any claims made under this Agreement,
under any statute, or under any provision of the Company's Certificate of Incorporation or
Bylaws providing for indemnification or advancement of Expenses, within thirty (30) days after
a written request for payment thereof has first been received by the Company, and if such claim
is not paid in full within such thirty (30) day-period, Indemnitee may, but need not, at any time
thereafter bring an action against the Company in the Delaware Court of Chancery to recover the
unpaid amount of the claim and, subject to Section 12, Indemnitee shall also be entitled to be
paid for all Expenses actually and reasonably incurred by Indemnitee in connection with
bringing such action. It shall be a defense to any such action (other than an action brought to
enforce a claim for advancement of Expenses under Section 2(a)) that Indemnitee has not met
the standards of conduct which make it permissible under applicable law for the Company to
indemnify Indemnitee for the amount claimed. In making a determination with respect to
entitlement to indemnification hereunder, the person or persons or entity making such
determination shall presume that Indemnitee is entitled to indemnification under this Agreement
and the Company shall have the burden of proof to overcome that presumption with clear and
convincing evidence to the contrary. The termination of any Proceeding by judgment, order,
settlement, conviction, or upon a plea of nolo contendere or its equivalent, shall not, of itself,
create a presumption that Indemnitee did not act in good faith and in a manner which Indemnitee
reasonably believed to be in or not opposed to the best interests of the Company, or, in the case
of a criminal Proceeding, that Indemnitee had reasonable cause to believe that Indemnitee's
conduct was unlawful. In addition, it is the parties' intention that if the Company contests
Indemnitee's right to indemnification, the question of Indemnitee's right to indemnification shall
OHSUSA:753347075.2
28154-1
-3-
be for the court to decide, and neither the failure of the Company (including its Board of
Directors, any committee or subgroup of the Board of Directors, independent legal counsel, or its
stockholders) to have made a determination that indemnification of Indemnitee is proper in the
circumstances because Indenmitee has met the applicable standard of conduct required by
applicable law, nor an actual determination by the Company (including its Board of Directors,
any committee or subgroup of the Board of Directors, independent legal counsel, or its
stockholders) that Indemnitee has not met such applicable standard of conduct, shall create a
presumption that Indemnitee has or has not met the applicable standard of conduct. If any
requested determination with respect to entitlement to indemnification hereunder has not been
made within ninety (90) days after the final disposition of the Proceeding, the requisite
determination that Indemnitee is entitled to indemnification shall be deemed to have been made.
(iii) Change of Control. Notwithstanding any other provision in this
Agreement, if a Change of Control has occurred, any person or body appointed by the Board of
Directors in accordance with applicable law to review the Company's obligations hereunder and
under applicable law shall be Independent Counsel selected by Indemnitee and approved by the
Company (which approval shall not be unreasonably withheld). Such counsel, among other
things, will render its written opinion to the Company and Indemnitee as to whether and to what
extent Indemnitee would be entitled to be indemnified hereunder under applicable law and the
Company agrees to abide by such opinion. The Company agrees to pay the reasonable fees of
the Independent Counsel referred to above and to indemnify fully such counsel against any and
all expenses (including attorneys' fees), claims, liabilities and damages arising out of or relating
to this Agreement or its engagement pursuant hereto. Notwithstanding any other provision of
this Agreement, the Company shall not be required to pay Expenses of more than one
Independent Counsel in connection with all matters concerning a single Indemnitee, and such
Independent Counsel shall be the Independent Counsel for any or all other Indemnitees unless (i)
the Company otherwise determines or (ii) any Indemnitee shall provide a written statement
setting forth in detail a reasonable objection to such Independent Counsel representing other
indemnitees under agreements similar to this Agreement.

(d) Payment Directions. To the extent payments are required to be made
hereunder, the Company shall, in accordance with Indemnitee's request (but without
duplication), (i) pay such Expenses on behalf of Indemnitee, (b) advance to Indemnitee funds in
an amount sufficient to pay such Expenses, or (c) reimburse Indemnitee for such Expenses.

(e) Notice to Insurers.  If, at the time of the receipt of a notice of a claim
pursuant to Section 2(b) hereof, the Company has director and officer liability insurance in
effect, the Company shall give prompt notice of the commencement of such Proceeding to the
insurers in accordance with the procedures set forth in the respective policies. The Company
shall thereafter take all necessary or desirable action to cause such insurers to pay, on behalf of
Indemnitee, all amounts payable as a result of such Proceeding in accordance with the terms of
such policies.
(t) Defense of Claim and Selection of Counsel. In the event the Company
shall be obligated under Section 2(a) hereof to advance Expenses with respect to any Proceeding,
the Company, if appropriate, shall be entitled to assume the defense of such Proceeding, with
counsel reasonably acceptable to Indemnitee, upon the delivery to Indemnitee of written notice
OHSUSA:753347075.2
28154-I
-4-
of its election so to do. After delivery of such notice, approval of such counsel by Indemnitee
and the retention of such counsel by the Company, the Company will not be liable to Indemnitee
under this Agreement for any fees of counsel subsequently incurred by Indenmitee with respect
to the same Proceeding, provided that (i) Indemnitee shall have the right to employ counsel in
any such Proceeding at Indemnitee's expense; and (ii) if (A) the employment of counsel by
Indemnitee has been previously authorized by the Company, (B) Indemnitee shall have
reasonably concluded that there may be a conflict of interest between the Company and
Indemnitee in the conduct of any such defense or (C) the Company shall not, in fact, have
employed counsel to assume the defense of such Proceeding, then the fees and expenses of
Indemnitee's counsel shall be at the expense of the Company. In addition, if there exists a
potential, but not an actual conflict of interest between the Company and Indemnitee, the actual
and reasonable legal fees and expenses incurred by Indemnitee for separate counsel retained by
Indemnitee to monitor the Proceeding (so that such counsel may assume Indemnitee's defense if
the conflict of interest between the Company and Indemnitee becomes an actual conflict of
interest) shall be deemed to be Expenses that are subject to indemnification hereunder. The
existence of an actual or potential conflict of interest, and whether such conflict may be waived,
shall be determined pursuant to the rules of attorney professional conduct and applicable law.
The Company shall not be required to obtain the consent of Indemnitee for the settlement of any
Proceeding the Company has undertaken to defend if the Company assumes full and sole
responsibility for each such settlement; provided, however, that the Company shall be required to
obtain Indemnitee's prior written approval, which shall not be unreasonably withheld, before
entering into any settlement which (1) does not grant Indemnitee a complete release of liability,

(2) would impose any penalty or limitation on Indemnitee, or (3) would admit any liability or
misconduct by Indemnitee.

3. Additional Indemnification Rights.
(a) Scope. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, the
Company hereby agrees to indemnify Indemnitee to the fullest extent permitted by law,
notwithstanding that such indemnification is not specifically authorized by the other provisions
of this Agreement, the Company's Certificate of Incorporation, the Company's Bylaws or by
statute. In the event of any change, after the date of this Agreement, in any applicable law,
statute, or rule which expands the right of a Delaware corporation to indemnify a member of its
board of directors or an officer, such changes shall be deemed to be within the purview of
Indemnitee's rights and the Company's obligations under this Agreement. In the event of any
change in any applicable law, statute or rule which narrows the right of a Delaware corporation
to indemnify a member of its board of directors or an officer, such changes, to the extent not
otherwise required by such law, statute or rule to be applied to this Agreement shall have no
effect on this Agreement or the parties' rights and obligations hereunder.

(b) Nonexclusivitv. The indemnification provided by this Agreement shall
not be deemed exclusive of any rights to which Indemnitee may be entitled under the Company's
Certificate of Incorporation, its Bylaws, any agreement, any vote of stockholders or disinterested
members of the Company's Board of Directors, the Delaware General Corporation Law, or
otherwise, both as to action in Indemnitee's official capacity and as to action in another capacity
while holding such office.
OHSUSA:7533470752
28154-I
-5-

(c) Interest on Unpaid Amounts. If any payment to be made by the Company to Indemnitee hereunder is delayed by more than
ninety (90) days from the date the duly
prepared request for such payment is received by the Company, interest shall be paid by the Company to Indemnitee at the
legal rate under Delaware law for
amounts which the Company indemnifies or is obligated to indemnify for the period commencing with the date on which 
Indemnitee actually incurs such Expense or
pays such judgment, fine or amount in settlement and ending with the date on which such payment is made to Indetnnitee 
by the Company.

(d) Information Sharing.  If Indemnitee is the subject of or is implicated in any way during an investigation, whether 
formal or informal, the Company shall
share with Indemnitee any information the Company has furnished to any third parties concerning the investigation 
provided that, at the time such information is
so furnished to such third party, Indemnitee continues to serve in one or more capacities giving rise to the Company's 
indemnification obligations under Section
1.

(e) Third -Party Indemnification.  The Company hereby acknowledges that Indemnitee has or may from time to time obtain 
certain rights to indemnification,
advancement of expenses and/or insurance provided by one or more third parties (collectively, the "Third-Party 
Indemnitors"). The Company hereby agrees that it
is the indemnitor of first resort (i. e., its obligations to Indemnitee are primary and any obligation of the 
Third-Party Indemnitors to advance expenses or to
provide indemnification for the same expenses or liabilities incurred by Indemnitee are secondary), and that the Company
will not assert that the Indemnitee
must seek expense advancement or reimbursement, or indemnification, from any Third-Party Indemnitor before the Company 
must perform its expense advancement and
reimbursement, and indemnification obligations, under this Agreement. No advancement or payment by the Third-Party 
Indemnitors on behalf of Indemnitee with
respect to any claim for which Indemnitee has sought indemnification from the Company shall affect the foregoing. The 
Third-Party Indemnitors shall be
subrogated to the extent of such advancement or payment to all of the rights of recovery which Indemnitee would have had
against the Company if the Third-Party
Indemnitors had not advanced or paid any amount to or on behalf of Indemnitee. If for any reason a court of competent 
jurisdiction determines that the
Third-Party Indemnitors are not entitled to the subrogation rights described in the preceding sentence, the Third-Party 
Indemnitors shall have a right of
contribution by the Company to the Third-Party Indemnitors with respect to any advance or payment by the Third-Party 
Indemnitors to or on behalf of the
Indemnitee.

(f) Indemnification of Control Person. If (i) Indemnitee is or was affiliated with one or more of the Company's current 
or former stockholders that may be
deemed to be or to have been a controlling person of the Company (each a "Control Person"), (ii) a Control Person is, or
is threatened to be made, a party to or
a participant (including as a witness) in any proceeding, and (iii) the Control Person's involvement in the proceeding 
is related to Indemnitee's service to the
Company as a director of the Company, or arises from the Control Person's status or alleged status as a controlling 
person of the Company resulting from such
Control Person's affiliation with Indemnitee, then the Control Person shall be entitled to all of the indemnification 
rights and remedies under this Agreement
to the same extent as Indemnitee.
O14SUSA:7531470752
28154.1 -6-

4. Partial Indemnification.  If Indemnitee is entitled under any provision of this
Agreement to indemnification by the Company for some or a portion of the Expenses,
judgments, fines or amounts paid in settlement, actually and reasonably incurred in connection
with a Proceeding, but not, however, for the total amount thereof, the Company shall
nevertheless indemnify Indemnitee for the portion of such Expenses, judgments, fines and
amounts paid in settlement to which Indemnitee is entitled.

5. Director and Officer Liability Insurance.
(a) D&O Policy. The Company shall, from time to time, make the good
faith determination whether or not it is practicable for the Company to obtain and maintain a
policy or policies of insurance with reputable insurance companies providing the directors and
officers of the Company with coverage for losses from wrongful acts, or to ensure the
Company's performance of its indemnification obligations under this Agreement. Among other
considerations, the Company will weigh the costs of obtaining such insurance coverage against
the protection afforded by such coverage. In all policies of director and officer liability
insurance, Indemnitee shall be named as an insured in such a manner as to provide Indemnitee
the same rights and benefits as are accorded to the most favorably insured of the Company's
directors, if Indemnitee is a director; or of the Company's officers, if Indemnitee is not a director
of the Company but is an officer; or of the Company's key employees, if Indemnitee is not an
officer or director but is a key employee. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Company shall
have no obligation to obtain or maintain such insurance if the Company determines in good faith
that such insurance is not reasonably available, if the premium costs for such insurance are
disproportionate to the amount of coverage provided, if the coverage provided by such insurance
is limited by exclusions so as to provide an insufficient benefit, or if Indemnitee is covered by
similar insurance maintained by a parent or subsidiary of the Company.

(b) Tail Coverage.  In the event of a Change of Control or the Company's
becoming insolvent (including being placed into receivership or entering the federal bankruptcy
process and the like), the Company shall maintain in force any and all insurance policies then
maintained by the Company in providing insurance (directors' and officers' liability, fiduciary,
employment practices or otherwise) in respect of Indemnitee, for a period of six years thereafter.

6. Severability.  Nothing in this Agreement is intended to require or shall be
construed as requiring the Company to do or fail to do any act in violation of applicable law.
The Company's inability, pursuant to court order, to perform its obligations under this
Agreement shall not constitute a breach of this Agreement. If this Agreement or any portion
hereof shall be invalidated on any ground by any court of competent jurisdiction, then the
Company shall nevertheless indemnify Indemnitee to the full extent permitted by any applicable
portion of this Agreement that shall not have been invalidated, and the balance of this Agreement
not so invalidated shall be enforceable in accordance with its terms.

7. Exclusions.  Any other provision herein to the contrary notwithstanding, the
Company shall not be obligated pursuant to the terms of this Agreement:

(a) Claims Initiated by Indemnitee.  To indemnify or advance Expenses to
Indemnitee with respect to Proceedings initiated or brought voluntarily by Indemnitee and not by
OHSUSA:7533470752
28154-1
-7-
way of defense, except with respect to Proceedings brought to establish, enforce or interpret a
right to indemnification under this Agreement or any other statute or law or otherwise as
required under Section 145 of the Delaware General Corporation Law, but such indemnification
or advancement of Expenses may be provided by the Company in specific cases if the Board of
Directors finds it to be appropriate; provided, however, that the exclusion set forth in the first
clause of this subsection shall not be deemed to apply to any investigation initiated or brought by
Indemnitee to the extent reasonably necessary or advisable in support of Indemnitee's defense of
a Proceeding to which Indemnitee was, is or is threatened to be made, a party;

(b) Lack of Good Faith. To indemnify Indemnitee for any Expenses
incurred by Indemnitee with respect to any Proceeding instituted by Indemnitee to establish,
enforce or interpret a right to indemnification under this Agreement or any other statute or law or
otherwise as required under Section 145 of the Delaware General Corporation Law, if a court of
competent jurisdiction determines that each of the material assertions made by Indemnitee in
such proceeding was not made in good faith or was frivolous;

(c) Insured Claims. To indemnify Indemnitee for Expenses to the extent
such Expenses have been paid directly to Indemnitee by an insurance carrier under an insurance
policy maintained by the Company; or

(d) Certain Exchanee Act Claims. To indemnify Indemnitee in connection
with any claim made against Indemnitee for (i) an accounting of profits made from the purchase
and sale (or sale and purchase) by Indemnitee of securities of the Company within the meaning
of Section 16(b) of the Exchange Act or any similar successor statute or any similar provisions of
state statutory law or common law, or (ii) any reimbursement of the Company by Indemnitee of
any bonus or other incentive-based or equity-based compensation or of any profits realized by
Indemnitee from the sale of securities of the Company, as required in each case under the
Exchange Act (including any such reimbursements that arise from an accounting restatement of
the Company pursuant to Section 304 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (the "Sarbanes-Oxlev
Ace") or Section 954 of the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, or the
payment to the Company of profits arising from the purchase and sale by Indemnitee of
securities in violation of Section 306 of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act); provided, however, that to the
fullest extent permitted by applicable law and to the extent Indemnitee is successful on the merits
or otherwise with respect to any such Proceeding, the Expenses actually and reasonably incurred
by Indemnitee in connection with any such Proceeding shall be deemed to be Expenses that are
subject to indemnification hereunder.

8. Contribution Claims.
(a) If the indemnification provided in Section 1 is unavailable in whole or in
part and may not be paid to Indemnitee for any reason other than those set forth in Section 7,
then in respect to any Proceeding in which the Company is jointly liable with Indemnitee (or
would be if joined in such Proceeding), to the fullest extent permitted by applicable law, the
Company, in lieu of indemnifying Indemnitee, shall pay, in the first instance, the entire amount
incurred by Indemnitee, whether for Expenses, judgments, fines or amounts paid in settlement, in
connection with any Proceeding without requiring Indemnitee to contribute to such payment, and
OHSUSA:753347075.2
28154-I
-8-
the Company hereby waives and relinquishes any right of contribution it may have at any time
against Indemnitee.

(b) With respect to a Proceeding brought against directors, officers,
employees or agents of the Company (other than Indemnitee), to the fullest extent permitted by
applicable law, the Company shall indemnify Indemnitee from any claims for contribution that
may be brought by any such directors, officers, employees or agents of the Company (other than
Indemnitee) who may be jointly liable with Indemnitee, to the same extent Indemnitee would
have been entitled to such indemnification under this Agreement if such Proceeding had been
brought against Indemnitee.

9. No Imputation.  The knowledge and/or actions, or failure to act, of any director,
officer, agent or employee of the Company or the Company itself shall not be imputed to
Indemnitee for purposes of determining any rights under this Agreement.

10. Determination of Good Faith. For purposes of any determination of good faith,
Indemnitee shall be deemed to have acted in good faith if Indemnitee's action is based on the
records or books of account of the Enterprise, including financial statements, or on information
supplied to Indemnitee by the officers of the Enterprise in the course of their duties, or on the
advice of legal counsel for the Enterprise or the Board of Directors of the Enterprise or any
counsel selected by any committee of the Board of Directors of the Enterprise or on information
or records given or reports made to the Enterprise by an independent certified public accountant
or by an appraiser, investment banker, compensation consultant, or other expert selected with
reasonable care by the Enterprise or the Board of Directors of the Enterprise or any committee
thereof. The provisions of this Section 10 shall not be deemed to be exclusive or to limit in any
way the other circumstances in which the Indemnitee may be deemed to have met the applicable
standard of conduct. Whether or not the foregoing provisions of this Section are satisfied, it
shall in any event be presumed that Indemnitee has at all times acted in good faith and in a
manner Indemnitee reasonably believed to be in or not opposed to the best interests of the
Company.

11. Defined Terms and Phrases. For purposes of this Agreement, the following
terms shall have the following meanings:

(a) "Beneficial Owner" and "Beneficial Ownership" shall have the meanings
set forth in Rule 13d-3 promulgated under the Exchange Act as in effect on the date hereof.

(b) "Change of Control" shall be deemed to occur upon the earliest of any of
the following events:
(i) Acquisition of Stock by Third Party. Any Person is or becomes
the Beneficial Owner, directly or indirectly, of securities of the Company representing fifteen
percent (15%) or more of the combined voting power of the Company's then outstanding
securities entitled to vote generally in the election of directors, unless (1) the change in the
relative Beneficial Ownership of the Company's securities by any Person results solely from a
reduction in the aggregate number of outstanding shares of securities entitled to vote generally in
the election of directors, or (2) such acquisition was approved in advance by the Continuing
OHSUSA:753347075.2
28154-I
-9-
Directors and such acquisition would not constitute a Change of Control under part (iii) of this
definition.
(ii) Change in Board of Directors. Individuals who, as of the date of
this Agreement, constitute the Company's Board of Directors (the "Board"), and any new
director whose election by the Board or nomination for election by the Company's stockholders
was approved by a vote of at least two thirds of the directors then still in office who were
directors on the date of this Agreement (collectively, the "Continuing Directors"), cease for any
reason to constitute at least a majority of the members of the Board.
(iii) Corporate Transaction. The effective date of a reorganization,
merger, or consolidation of the Company (a "Business Combination"), in each case, unless,
following such Business Combination: (1) all or substantially all of the individuals and entities
who were the Beneficial Owners of securities entitled to vote generally in the election of
directors immediately prior to such Business Combination beneficially own, directly or
indirectly, more than 51% of the combined voting power of the then outstanding securities of the
Company entitled to vote generally in the election of directors resulting from such Business
Combination (including a corporation which as a result of such transaction owns the Company or
all or substantially all of the Company's assets either directly or through one or more
subsidiaries) in substantially the same proportions as their ownership, immediately prior to such
Business Combination, of the securities entitled to vote generally in the election of directors and
with the power to elect at least a majority of the Board or other governing body of the surviving
entity; (2) no Person (excluding any corporation resulting from such Business Combination) is
the Beneficial Owner, directly or indirectly, of 15% or more of the combined voting power of the
then outstanding securities entitled to vote generally in the election of directors of such
corporation except to the extent that such ownership existed prior to the Business Combination;
and (3) at least a majority of the Board of Directors of the corporation resulting from such
Business Combination were Continuing Directors at the time of the execution of the initial
agreement, or of the action of the Board of Directors, providing for such Business Combination.

(iv) Liquidation. The approval by the Company's stockholders of a
complete liquidation of the Company or an agreement or series of agreements for the sale or
disposition by the Company of all or substantially all of the Company's assets, other than
factoring the Company's current receivables or escrows due (or, if such approval is not required,
the decision by the Board to proceed with such a liquidation, sale or disposition in one
transaction or a series of related transactions).

(v) Other Events. There occurs any other event of a nature that would
be required to be reported in response to Item 6(e) of Schedule 14A of Regulation 14A (or a
response to any similar item or any similar schedule or form) promulgated under the Exchange
Act whether or not the Company is then subject to such reporting requirement.

(c) "Company" shall include, in addition to the resulting corporation, any
constituent corporation (including any constituent of a constituent) absorbed in a consolidation or
merger which, if its separate existence had continued, would have had power and authority to
indemnify its directors, officers, and employees or agents, so that if Indemnitee is or was a
director, officer, employee or agent of such constituent corporation, or is or was serving at the
OHSUSA:753347075.2
28151-1
-10-
request of such constituent corporation as a director, officer, trustee, general partner, managing
member, fiduciary, employee or agent of any other enterprise, Indemnitee shall stand in the same
position under the provisions of this Agreement with respect to the resulting or surviving
corporation as Indemnitee would have with respect to such constituent corporation if its separate
existence had continued.

(d) "Enterprise" means the Company and any other enterprise that Indemnitee
was or is serving at the request of the Company as a director, officer, partner (general, limited or
otherwise), member (managing or otherwise), trustee, fiduciary, employee or agent.

(e) "Exchange Act" means the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended.
(f) "Expenses" shall include all direct and indirect costs, fees and expenses of
any type or nature whatsoever, including all attorneys' fees and costs, retainers, court costs,
transcript costs, fees of experts, witness fees, travel expenses, fees of private investigators and
professional advisors, duplicating costs, printing and binding costs, telephone charges, postage,
delivery service fees, any federal, state, local or foreign taxes imposed on Indemnitee as a result
of the actual or deemed receipt of any payment under this Agreement (including taxes that may
be imposed upon the actual or deemed receipt of payments under this Agreement with respect to
the imposition of federal, state, local or foreign taxes), fax transmission charges, secretarial
services and all other disbursements, obligations or expenses in connection with prosecuting,
defending, preparing to prosecute or defend, investigating, being or preparing to be a witness in,
settlement or appeal of, or otherwise participating in a Proceeding. Expenses also shall include
any of the forgoing expenses incurred in connection with any appeal resulting from any
Proceeding, including the principal, premium, security for, and other costs relating to any costs
bond, supersedes bond, or other appeal bond or its equivalent. Expenses also shall include any
interest, assessment or other charges imposed thereon and costs incurred in preparing statements
in support of payment requests hereunder. Expenses, however, shall not include amounts paid
in settlement by Indemnitee or the amount of judgments or fines against Indemnitee.

(g) "Independent Counsel" means an attorney or firm of attorneys, selected in
accordance with the provisions of Section 2(c)(iii), who will not have otherwise performed
services for the Company or Indemnitee within the last three years (other than with respect to
matters concerning the rights of Indemnitee under this Agreement, or of other indemnitees under
similar indemnity agreements).

(h) "Person" shall have the meaning as set forth in Section 13(d) and 14(d) of
the Exchange Act as in effect on the date hereof; provided, however, that "Person" shall exclude:

(i) the Company; (ii) any direct or indirect majority owned subsidiaries of the Company; (iii) any
employee benefit plan of the Company or any direct or indirect majority owned subsidiaries of
the Company or of any corporation owned, directly or indirectly, by the Company's stockholders
in substantially the same proportions as their ownership of stock of the Company (an "Employee
Benefit Plan"); and (iv) any trustee or other fiduciary holding securities under an Employee
Benefit Plan.

(i) "Proceeding" shall include any actual, threatened, pending or completed
action, suit, arbitration, mediation, alternate dispute resolution mechanism, investigation, inquiry,
OUSUSA:753347075.2
28154-1
administrative hearing or any other actual, threatened or completed proceeding, whether brought
by a third party, a government agency, the Company or its Board of Directors or a committee
thereof, whether in the right of the Company or otherwise and whether of a civil (including
intentional or unintentional tort claims), criminal, administrative, legislative or investigative
(formal or informal) nature, including any appeal therefrom, in which Indemnitee was, is, will or
might be involved as a party, potential party, non-party witness or otherwise by reason of the fact
that Indemnitee is or was a director, officer, employee or agent of the Company, by reason of any
action (or failure to act) taken by Indemnitee or of any action (or failure to act) on Indemnitee's
part while acting as a director, officer, employee or agent of the Company, or by reason of the
fact that Indemnitee is or was serving at the request of the Company as a director, officer, partner
(general, limited or otherwise), member (managing or otherwise), trustee, fiduciary, employee or
agent of any other enterprise, in each case whether or not serving in such capacity at the time any
liability or expense is incurred for which indemnification, reimbursement or advancement of
expenses can be provided under this Agreement.

(j) In addition, references to "other enterprise" shall include another
corporation, partnership, limited liability company, joint venture, trust, employee benefit plan or
any other enterprise; references to "fines" shall include any excise taxes assessed on Indemnitee
with respect to an employee benefit plan; references to "serving at the request of the Company"
shall include any service as a director, officer, employee or agent of the Company which imposes
duties on, or involves services by Indemnitee with respect to an employee benefit plan, its
participants, or beneficiaries; and if Indemnitee acted in good faith and in a manner Indemnitee
reasonably believed to be in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries of an employee
benefit plan, Indemnitee shall be deemed to have acted in a manner "not opposed to the best
interests of the Company" as referred to in this Agreement; references to "include" or
"including" shall mean include or including, without limitation; and references to Sections,
paragraphs or clauses are to Sections, paragraphs or clauses in this Agreement unless otherwise
specified.

12. Attorneys' Fees. In the event that any Proceeding is instituted by Indemnitee
under this Agreement to enforce or interpret any of the terms hereof, the Company shall
indemnify Indemnitee against all Expenses actually and reasonably incurred by Indemnitee in
connection with such Proceeding, unless a court of competent jurisdiction determines that each
of the material assertions made by Indemnitee as a basis for such Proceeding were not made in
good faith or were frivolous. In the event of a Proceeding instituted by or in the name of the
Company under this Agreement or to enforce or interpret any of the terms of this Agreement, the
Company shall indemnify Indemnitee against all Expenses actually and reasonably incurred by
Indemnitee in connection with such Proceeding (including with respect to Indemnitee's
counterclaims and cross-claims made in such action), unless a court of competent jurisdiction
determines that each of Indemnitee's material defenses to such action were made in bad faith or
were frivolous.

13. Miscellaneous.
(a) Governing Law. The validity, interpretation, construction and
performance of this Agreement, and all acts and transactions pursuant hereto and the rights and
OHSUSA:753347075.2
28154-1
-12-
obligations of the parties hereto shall be governed, construed and interpreted in accordance with
the laws of the state of Delaware, without giving effect to principles of conflicts of law.

(b) Entire Agreement; Binding Effect. Without limiting any of the rights
of Indemnitee described in Section 3(b), this Agreement sets forth the entire agreement and
understanding of the parties relating to the subject matter herein and merges all prior discussions
and supersedes any and all previous agreements between them covering the subject matter
herein. The indemnification provided under this Agreement applies with respect to events
occurring before or after the effective date of this Agreement, and shall continue to apply even
after Indemnitee has ceased to serve the Company in any and all indemnified capacities.

(c) Amendments and Waivers.  No modification of or amendment to this
Agreement, nor any waiver of any rights under this Agreement, shall be effective unless in
writing signed by the parties to this Agreement. No delay or failure to require performance of
any provision of this Agreement shall constitute a waiver of that provision as to that or any other
instance.

(d) Successors and Assigns. This Agreement shall be binding upon the
Company and its successors (including any direct or indirect successor by purchase, merger,
consolidation or otherwise to all or substantially all of the business and/or assets of the
Company) and assigns, and inure to the benefit of Indemnitee and Indemnitee's heirs, executors,
administrators, legal representatives and assigns. The Company shall require and cause any
successor (whether direct or indirect by purchase, merger, consolidation or otherwise) to all or
substantially all of the business and/or assets of the Company, by written agreement in form and
substance satisfactory to Indemnitee, expressly to assume and agree to perform this Agreement
in the same manner and to the same extent that the Company would be required to perform if no
such succession had taken place.

(e) Notices. Any notice, demand or request required or permitted to be given
under this Agreement shall be in writing and shall be deemed sufficient when delivered
personally or by overnight courier or sent by email, or 48 hours after being deposited in the U.S.
mail as certified or registered mail with postage prepaid, addressed to the party to be notified at
such party's address as set forth on the signature page, as subsequently modified by written
notice, or if no address is specified on the signature page, at the most recent address set forth in
the Company's books and records.

(f) Severabilitv.  If one or more provisions of this Agreement are held to be
unenforceable under applicable law, the parties agree to renegotiate such provision in good faith.
In the event that the parties cannot reach a mutually agreeable and enforceable replacement for
such provision, then (i) such provision shall be excluded from this Agreement, (ii) the balance of
the Agreement shall be interpreted as if such provision were so excluded and (iii) the balance of
the Agreement shall be enforceable in accordance with its terms.

(g) Construction.  This Agreement is the result of negotiations between and
has been reviewed by each of the parties hereto and their respective counsel, if any; accordingly,
this Agreement shall be deemed to be the product of all of the parties hereto, and no ambiguity
shall be construed in favor of or against any one of the parties hereto.
OHSUSA:7533470752
28154-1
-13-

(h) Counterparts.  This Agreement may be executed in any number of
counterparts, each of which when so executed and delivered shall be deemed an original, and all
of which together shall constitute one and the same agreement.

(i) No Employment Rights. Nothing contained in this Agreement is
intended to create in Indemnitee any right to continued employment.

(j) Company Position. The Company shall be precluded from asserting, in
any Proceeding brought for purposes of establishing, enforcing or interpreting any right to
indemnification under this Agreement, that the procedures and presumptions of this Agreement
are not valid, binding and enforceable and shall stipulate in any such court that the Company is
bound by all the provisions of this Agreement and is precluded from making any assertion to the
contrary.

(k) Subrogation.  Subject to Section 3(e), in the event of payment under this
Agreement, the Company shall be subrogated to the extent of such payment to all of the rights of
recovery of Indenmitee, who shall execute all documents required and shall do all acts that may
be necessary to secure such rights and to enable the Company to effectively bring suit to enforce
such rights.
[Signature Page Follows]
O11SUSA.753347O75 2
28154-I
-14-
The parties have executed this Indemnification Agreement as of the date first set forth
above.
THE COMPANY:
COINBASE, INC.
By:
(Signature)
Name:
Title:
Address:
AGREED TO AND ACCEPTED:
INDEMNITEE:
(PRINT NAME)
(Signature)
Address:
Email:
014SUSA:753347075.2
28154.1
-15-
EXHIBIT E
FORM OF AMENDED AND RESTATED INVESTORS' RIGHTS AGREEMENT
See Tab 6
EXHIBIT F
FORM OF MANAGEMENT RIGHTS LETTERS
See Tab 14, 15, and 16
EXHIBIT
FORM OF AMENDED AND RESTATED RIGHT OF FIRST REFUSAL AND CO-SALE
AGREEMENT
See Tab 8
EXHIBIT H
FORM OF AMENDED AND RESTATED VOTING AGREEMENT
See Tab 7
EXHIBIT I
FORM OF LEGAL OPINION OF ORRICK, HERRINGTON & SUTCLIFFE LLP
See Tab 9
ANNEX I
Rule 506(d)(1)(i) to (viii) under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended

(i) Has been convicted, within ten years before such sale (or five years, in the case of issuers, their predecessors and
affiliated issuers), of any felony or misdemeanor:

(A) In connection with the purchase or sale of any security;
(B) Involving the making of any false filing with the Commission; or

(C) Arising out of the conduct of the business of an underwriter, broker, dealer, municipal securities dealer,
investment adviser or paid solicitor of purchasers of securities;

(ii) Is subject to any order, judgment or decree of any court of competent jurisdiction, entered within five years
before such sale, that, at the time of such sale, restrains or enjoins such person from engaging or continuing to
engage in any conduct or practice:

(A) In connection with the purchase or sale of any security;
(B) Involving the making of any false filing with the Commission; or

(C) Arising out of the conduct of the business of an underwriter, broker, dealer, municipal securities dealer,
investment adviser or paid solicitor of purchasers of securities;
(iii) Is subject to a final order of a state securities commission (or an agency or officer of a state performing like
functions); a state authority that supervises or examines banks, savings associations, or credit unions; a state
insurance commission (or an agency or officer of a state performing like functions); an appropriate federal banking
agency; the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission; or the National Credit Union Administration that:

(A) At the time of such sale, bars the person from:
(I) Association with an entity regulated by such commission, authority, agency, or officer;

(2) Engaging in the business of securities, insurance or banking; or
(3) Engaging in savings association or credit union activities; or

(B) Constitutes a final order based on a violation of any law or regulation that prohibits fraudulent,
manipulative, or deceptive conduct entered within ten years before such sale;

(iv) Is subject to an order of the Commission entered pursuant to section 15(b) or 15B(c) of the Securities Exchange
Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 78o(b) or 78o-4(c)) or section 203(e) or (O of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (I5
U.S.C. 80b-3(e) or (O) that, at the time of such sale:

(A) Suspends or revokes such person's registration as a broker, dealer, municipal securities dealer or
investment adviser;

(B) Places limitations on the activities, functions or operations of such person; or
(C)Bars such person from being associated with any entity or from participating in the offering of any penny
stock;

(v) Is subject to any order of the Commission entered within five years before such sale that, at the time of such sale,
orders the person to cease and desist from committing or causing a violation or future violation of:

(A) Any scienter-based anti-fraud provision of the federal securities laws, including without limitation
section 17(a)( I) of the Securities Act of 1933 (15 U.S.C. 77q(a)(1)), section 10(b) of the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 78j(b)) and 17 CFR 240.10b-5, section 15(c)(I ) of the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. 780(O(1)) and section 206(1) of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (15
U.S.C. 80b-6(1)), or any other rule or regulation thereunder; or

(B) Section 5 of the Securities Act of 1933 (15 U.S.C. 77e).
(vi) Is suspended or expelled from membership in, or suspended or barred from association with a member of, a
registered national securities exchange or a registered national or affiliated securities association for any act or
omission to act constituting conduct inconsistent with just and equitable principles of trade;
(vii) Has filed (as a registrant or issuer), or was or was named as an underwriter in, any registration statement or
Regulation A offering statement filed with the Commission that, within five years before such sale, was the subject of
a refusal order, stop order, or order suspending the Regulation A exemption, or is, at the time of such sale, the
subject of an investigation or proceeding to determine whether a stop order or suspension order should be issued; or
(viii) Is subject to a United States Postal Service false representation order entered within five years before such 
sale,
or is, at the time of such sale, subject to a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction with respect to
°MUSA:755718737.2
conduct alleged by the United States Postal Service to constitute a scheme or device for obtaining money or property
through the mail by means of false representations.
LEGAL28662441.2
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Christina Galbraith [publicist] Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation Media/PR, worked with Tyler Shears 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01193705 (Jmail)
 [misc] list of Epstein's known email addresses, internet accounts, cars, boats, airplanes, and telephone numbers
(inferred date: 2013-12-29)
ATTACHMENT TO SEXUAL OFFENDER REGISTRATION FORM
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Automobiles, Boats, Aircraft, Telephone Numbers, Email Addresses, and Internet Related Information
AUTOMOBILES License State
Vin U Plate Registered Color Property
1 2005 Cadillac Escalade 3GYFK66N75G102127 TDJ 142 USVI Black LSJ
2 2010 Cheverolet Suburban .1GNUCKE05AR225550 TED 218 USVI Black LSJ
3 2002 Mercedes Benz 5500 WOBNG75J02A217037 C16 5SP Florida Black Florida
4 2010 Cheverolet Suburban 1GNUKKE30AR251129 MX H78 Florida Black Florida
5 2005 Cadillac Escalade 3GYFK66N45G188335 217 RKF New Mexico Black New Mexico
6 2007 Hummer H2 ' 5GRGN23U57H100289 CPK 643 New Mexico Black New Mexico
7 2000 Chevrolet Suburban .3GNFK16T6YG123568 CHX 920 New Mexico Black New Mexico
8 2006 Bentley Arnage RL SCBLE37G26CX19439 V75 2DS Florida Black New York
9 2012 Cadillac Escalade 1GYS4JEF4CR216976 FTX 3455 New York Black New York
10 2008 Range Rover SALSH23448A128123 MLD 7Ix New Mexico Black New Mexico
11 2013 Dodge Caravan '2C4RDGBG70R597495 TEM 492 USVI Black LSJ
12 2013 Ford Expedition EL '1FMJK2A550EF21918 522 RZZ New Mexico Black New Mexico
Boat
BOATS Names
1 1999 3V Ribtec with Yamaha Engine Nana
2 2011 Yamaha VX1800A-KB .nra
3 2011 Yamaha VX1800A-KB Na
4 2006 31' Cape Horn 'PRO
5 2008 36' Procat Little C
6 Miss Ava - 1968 73' LMC-8 (barge) Big N
7 2012 Bombadier Sea Doo Na
8 2013 34' Sportis 5-10500/K Little S
Registration
Tail Number
AIRCRAFT
1 1968 Boeing 727 .N908JE
2 2001 Bell 430 .N331JE
3 1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE
LANDLINES
JEE lines
JEE lines
JEE lines
JEE lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
staff lines
Registration Hull ID
Number Number
2709-TB 99507 LSJ
4106-TC US-YAMA2823D111 LSJ
4105-TC US-YAMA3205C111 LSJ
0730-TC FAB31056K506 LSJ
2907-TC WJIF10168808 LSJ
2583-TC 740/16763 LSJ
4641-TC YDV19326E212 LSJ
4772-TC PL-SPTZ1969G313 LSJ
Airports for all locations
The Cyril E. King airport in St. Thomas
West Palm Beach International Airport and Boca Raton Airport
Santa Fe Municipal Airport & Albquerque International. New Mexico
John F Kennedy International Airport. Newark International Airport &
Teterboro. NJ plus East 34th Street Heliport - 34th Street & FOR Drive.
Wall Street Heliport - Pier 6 & FDR Drive & VIP Heliport - West 30th
Street & 12th Ave
Long Island MacArthur Airport and Stewart International Airport
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
LSJ
30 start lines LSJ
31 'slatt lines LSJ
32 staty lines LSJ
33 slatt lines LSJ
34 slatt lines LSJ
35 statt lines LSJ
36 slatt lines LSJ
37 statt lines LSJ
38 slatt lines LSJ
39 slatt lines LSJ
40 statt lines LSJ
41 slatt lines LSJ
42 statt lines LSJ
43 slatt lines LSJ
44 slatt lines LSJ
45 statt lines LSJ
46 slatt lines LSJ
47 statt lines LSJ
48 slatt lines LSJ
49 start lines LSJ
50 start lines LSJ
51 JEE line Florida
52 Staff line Florida
53 - fax Staff line Florida
54 Staff line Florida
55 -fax Staff line Florida
56 Staff line Florida
57 -fax Staff line Florida
58 Staff line Florida
59 JEE line New Mexico
60 JEE line New Mexico
61 Staff line New Mexico
62 Staff line New Mexico
63 Staff line New Mexico
64 - fax Staff line New Mexico
65 Staff line New Mexico
66 Staff line New Mexico
67 Staff line New Mexico
68 Staff line New Mexico
69 Staff line New Mexico
70 Staff line New Mexico
71 Staff line New Mexico
72 Staff line New Mexico
73 Staff line New Mexico
74 Staff line New Mexico
75 JEE line New York
76 Staff line New York
77 Staff line New York
78 fax Staff line New York
79 Staff line New York
80 Staff line New York
81 Staff line New York
82 Staff line New York
83 Staff line New York
84 Staff line New York
85 Staff line New York
86 Staff line New York
87 fax Staff line New York
88 fax Staff line New York
89 Staff line New York
CELLPHONE
INTERNET RELATED INFORMATION - SEE NOTE BELOW
EMAIL ADDRESSES
columbiadental1@yahoo.com
jeevacation@me.com
jeevacationl@me.com
jeeproject©yahoo.com
jeevacation@gmail.com
ieffremieffreveDstein..orq
jeffreyepsteinorg@gmail.com
jeffreyepsteinorg@yahoo.com
jeffreyepstein@live.com
WEBSITES
vwfw.jeffreyepsteinfoundation.com
vwfw.jeffreyepsteinscience.com
wwwjeffreyepstein.org
vwswjeffreyepstein.us
vwfwjeffreyepsteinblog.com
vwfwjeffreyepsteinforum.com
vwfw.jeffreyepsteinusvi.com
wwwjeffreyepsteineducation.com
vwfw.jeffreyepsteinintemational.com
wwwjeffreyepsteinnewyork.com
TWITTER
jeffrey_epstein
jeffreyepsteinl
OTHER INTERNET ACCOUNT INFORMATION
Company
8coupons
aboutus.org
AirYell
AllTop
AmericanTowns
Avantar
BestOfTheWeb
bing local business directory
Blogspot (wenv.jeffreyepsteinblog.com) blog host
Blogspot (wvwtjeffreyepsteinforum.com)blog host
Brand Yourself online management
ChamberofCommerce.com business directory
Citysearch business directory
CitySquares business directory
CligSearch business directory
CoPilot business directory
Cricket business directory
Crunchbase scienceriechnology
business directory
Delicious public profile
Digg public profile
Disquis social ntwk directory
eLocal business directory
EZIocal business directory
Facebook public profile
Factual business directory
Flikr social ntwk directory
Flikr social ntwk directory
Gather public profile
GetFave business directory
Go Daddy website
Go Daddy website
Go Daddy website
Go Daddy website
Go Daddy website
Go Daddy website
Go Daddy website
Google + public profile
Google Maps
Grant Watch
HopStop
idealist.org
Indeed
Instagram
Klout
Type
business directory
business directory
public profile
business directory
article directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
Screenname
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
The Jeffrey Epstein Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein Ideas Forum
Jeffrey Epstein
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein
jeffreyepsteinl
The Jeffrey Epstein Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
The Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
www.jeffreyepstein.org
'www.jeffreyepsteinscience.com
www.jeffreyepstein.us
www.jeffreyepsteinusvi.com
www.jeffreyepsteineducation.com
www.jeffreyepsteininternaCional.com
,www.jeffreyepsteinnewyork.com
Jeffrey Epstein
business directory Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
grant directory Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
business directory Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
n-p job srch engine Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
employment directory Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
social ntwk directory Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
social ntwk directory Jeffrey Epstein
Linkedln public profile Jeffrey Epstein
Live public profile Jeffrey Epstein le V D Col
User Name
chrisuna@jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
jeffreyepsteinorg@gmail.com
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
JeffreyEpstein
chrisbna@jeffreyepstein.org
chrisbna@jeffreyepstein.org
chrisbna@jeffreyepsteinagr
jeffreyepstein@hve.com
Jeff reyepsteinorg@gmail.com
Jeff reyepsteinorg@gmail.com
chris tin a©. jeff reyepste in .org
chris tin a @ jeff reyepsteinag
christina@ Jeff reyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
chrisbna@jeffreyepstein.org
chrisbna@jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
jeffreyEpsteinl
Jeff reyepsteinorg@gmail.com
Jeff reyepsteinorg@grna il.com
Jeff reyepsteinorg@gmail.com
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
Christina@jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
jeffreyepsteinorg@yahoo.com
jeffreyepsteinorg@gmail.com
jeffrey_epstein
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
jeffreyespteinfoundation
jeffreyepsteinfoundation
jeffreyepsteinfoundation
jeffreyepsteinfoundation
jeffreyepsteinfoundation
jeffreyepsteinfoundation
jeffreyepsteinfoundation
Jeff reyepsteinorg c gmail.com
jeffreyepsteinorg@grnail.com
Christina Galbraith
chrisbna@jeffreyepstein.org
galbraith_christina@yahoo.com
Jeffrey@jeffreyepstein.org
Jeff rey@teff reyepstein .org
Jeff reyepsteinorg@gmail.com
jeffreyepstein
ffre e stein live.com
Local.com
LocalDatabase
LocalPages
manta
MapQuest
MerchantCircle
MetroPCS
MojoPages
Myspace
Nawrii
Patch
Penny Saver
Philanthropy.Com
PhoneNumber
Photobucket
Pinterest
Pocketly
PR.com
ShowMeLocal
SlideShare
Sodahead
Stumbleupon
Supermedia
Superpages
Switchboard
Technorati
Topix
Tupalo
Twitter
USCity.net
vimeo
Webbs
Where To?
White & Yellow Pages
White Pages
Wikipedia
Wikipedia
Yahoo
Yahoo!
YaSabe
Yellowbook
YellowBot
Ye!Jowls°
YellowMoxie
YellowPageCity
Yellowpages
Yelp
Yext
You Tube
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
public profile
business directory
business directory
business directory
foundation directory
business directory
public profile
public profile
business directory
press releases
business directory
social ntwk directory
public profile
public profile
business directory
business directory
business directory
public profile
business directory
business directory
public profile
business directory
business directory
website
business directory
business directory
business directory
public encyclodpedia
public encyclodpedia
public profile
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
business directory
portal directory
public profile
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey_Epstein
JeffreyEpstein2
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
The Jeffrey Epstein Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein
Jeffrey-epstein
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
jeffreyepstein12
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey_Epstein
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
www.jeffreyepsteinfoundation.com
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein VI Foundation
Jeffrey Epstein1
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
jeffrey©jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
jeffreyepsteinorg@grnail.com
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
JeffreyEpstein
christina©jeffreyepstein.org
jeffreyepsteinom@yahoo.com
jeffrey©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
galbraith_christina@yahoo.com
christina©jeffreyepstein.org
jeffreyepsteinorg@grnail.com
jeffreyepsteinorg@grnail.com
Jeffrey-epstein
jeffrey@jeffreyepstein.org
christina©jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
JeffreyEpstein12
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
jeffreyepsteinorg@gmail.com
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina©jeffreyepstein.org
Jeffreyepsteinfoundation
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
Turville
Tuntille
jeffreyepsteinorg@yahoo.com
christina©jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
jeffrey©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
christina©jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina©.jeffreyepstein.org
christina@jeffreyepstein.org
jeffreyepsteinorg©gmail.com
ADDITIONAL WEBSITES AND BLOG SITES MAINTAINED BY THIRD PARTIES WITH CONTENT RELATING TO
PHILANTHROPIC, SCIENCE OR BUSINESS RELATED ACTIVITIES OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN
www.jeffreyepstein.co
www.jeffreyepsteininfo.com
www.jeffreyepsteinfinance.ccm
vwfw.jeffreyepstein93.wordpress.com
vwswjeffreyepsteins.blogspot.com
vwsw.jeffreyepstein93:jux.com
NOTE: Mr. Epstein has retained third parties to provide reputation management services. These third parties
independently create internet accounts. websites. blog sites. associated email addresses and other web-based
accounts and content concerning Mr. Epstein. but which we neither created nor used by Mr. Epstein.
Out of an abundance of caution. however. Mr. Epstein has been disclosing and will continue to disclose such Internet
related Information. and any changes and additions thereto. as and when such information is disclosed to him by such
third party reputation management service providers. Certain accounts listed above that were established
by such third party reputation management service providers provide links to websites. email addresses and other
accounts (all of which are listed above) associated with Mr. Epstein and/or his business. science or philanthropic 
related activities.
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                            Caroline Lang [europe] daughter of Jack Lang 
 Thorbjørn Jagland [europe] former prime minister of Norway, Nobel Peace Prize Committee, indicted [bbc] 
                                        Steve Kosslyn [harvard] neuroscientist, Active Learning Sciences 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00284890 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(date: 2014-01-01)
2014 APRIL
Tues. April 1, 2014 LSJ
Wed. April 2.2014 LSI
Reminder: Henri could arrange to be in NY April 6th evening & Monday 7th
Thurs. April 3.2014 I Si
Reminder: Prof Kosslyn in NY April 3-8. He will stay in 1011 Kosslyn cell:
Fri April 4. 2014 1-V-PHOENIK
Reminder: Internet Bidding is over today for Woody Allen Photo
6:OOam Depart LS] for Phoenix
TBD Arrive Phoenix
Check in to the Phoenician Scottsdale (one suite, one room) Rec. Loc. #BHZMMV
6000 East Camelback Rd.
Scottsdale, AZ (~)
FAN Requested for Suite
Lawrence Krauss' Origins 5th Anniversary at the Phoenician Resort
Lawrence Krauss cell:
Sat. April S. 2014 PHOENIX-PB
Check out of the Phoenician Scottsdale (we have the rooms until the 6th)
11:OOpm Depart Phoenix for PB
TBD Arrive PB
Sun. April 6.2014 PR-►„4j
Reminder: in NY April 6-9, staying in apartment
Reminder: Henri could arrange to be in NY April 6th evening & Monday 7th
6:OOpm Depart PB for LSJ
TBD Arrive LS]
Mon. April 7, 2014 LSJ
Reminder: Tribeca Ball 6pm Cocktails, 8:30pm Seated Dinner at the NYAA
Tues. Apr►l 8, 2014 LSJ
Wed. April 9.2041 LSJ
Thurs. April 10.2014 LSJ
Reminder: Bella on holiday Apri110-17. Good Friday is 18th, back to work on Mon.
20th
Fri. April 11 2014 LSI
Sat. April 12.2014 LSJ
6:05pm Jagland and family to arrive Miami via Delta#65 (Rec. Loc.#LNUYWE)(Rec.
Loc.#RDPBSM)
Sun. April 13. 2014 LSI
Mon. April 14. 2014 LSJ
Reminder: Les on holiday Apri114-20, Back in office on Mon. Apri121
Tues. April 15.2014 LSI
9:50am Jagland & family to depart Miami for STT via AA#943 (Rec.
Loc.#LNUYWE)(Rec. Loc#RDPBSM)
12:25pm Jagland & family to arrive ST7'
Wed. April 16. 2014 LSJ
Thurs. April17. 2014 ►SI
Fri. Apri118. 2014 IS]
Reminder: Good Friday, Office and STC are closed
Sat. April 19. 2014 LSJ-PB
3:00pm Jagland and family to depart Miami via Delta#408 (Rec. Loc.#LNUYIVE)(Rec.
Loc.#RDPBSM)
Sun. April 20. 2014 PB-NY
Reminder: Easter Sunday
5:25pm Caroline Lang to arrive Miami via AF#0090 from Par ' ' ers
will come with her: Anna 15 and Rebecca 13. Caroline's cell:
Janusz to pick up the family and take them to the PB house.
Mon. April 21. 2014 NY-BOSTON-NY
Reminder: Easter Monday. STC is closed
Reminder: back in the office today
Tues. April 22, 2014 NY
Wed. April 23, 2014 NY
Reminder: when you are at MlTyou want to hire a Chief Science Officer for STC
Thurs. April 24, 2014 NY-PARIS
Fri. April 25, 2014 PARIS
Sat. April 26, 2014 PARIS
Reminder: Jena brother get married today
Reminder:
Jena■ b
Sister and Future Brother in Law in NY Apri127-30
Sun. Apri127. 2014 PARIS
Reminder: JE to call Salar KamangarApril27
TBD Caroline Lang and her daughters to fly back to Paris today
Mon. April 28. 2014 PARIS
Tues. April 29. 2014 PARIS
Wed. April 30, 2014 PARIS
EFTA01361270 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank $60,000 transfer from Southern Trust Company to Ben Goertzel's Novamente
(date: 2014-01-02)
Deutsche Bank
Private Wealth Management
Authorization for Asset Movement
For Non-Retirement Accounts The undersigned hereby authorizes and directs Deutsche Bank Alex Brown ('Deutsche Bank Alex.
Brown" or i'DBAB, to Sallow he below
asset movement instructions.
II you wish to request rye/ thole wires. checks, journals or free deaveries. please use the long form.
MA9 Meant  Name Southern Trust Company Inc.
Amount 44129244
1/Are
El %We federal furors in the amount ol S 60,000.00
10 sus name: Sun Trust Bank
City! State:
ABA a 061000104
Further credit to Intermediary Financial Institution (Optional)
Account t.
Nem
Okras Seneficiary Inkrnotkint
Benelday None  Novamente I-LC
Ammo lie 1000011778460
Acketiond kneuctions
Check
❑ Issue a check in the amount of $
Recipient's Neer
Reopent's hoeing Mtge=
Journal
U Journal Funds in the amount of S
• Journal Raiding,:
Oty/SymboVSecurity:
OWISymboVSetheity:
❑ JOtanal An Holdings
To MAO Account //:
Acossint Name:
Me Delideke
U Please deliver the securities Indicated below to:
DTCCI.
Name of Receiving Finn
Account Paine:
Acoount Nutter  at Recening Fern
OtylSymbeil/Security:
Oty/Symbol/Secudly.
Standing Avesrizaeon
❑ The undersigned hereby requests that this authorization act as a standing authorization. The undersigned understands 
and agrees that des authorization will
remain in effect unt Deutsche Bank Alex. &own requests a new authonoti0rk the undersigned authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex.
Brown to issue the wire.
chock or journal on the day of fora term ol
❑ The urderogned (unfree avinanzae Deutsche Bank Aex. Brown to accept verbal instructions from the undersigned to offs 
funds, Issue checks or journal
funds to/from the above listed e.CO04.-ItS. The undersigned vole provide verbal instructions as to the date and the 
amount of the wire, check or journal. If the
undersigned decides to vary either the date or the amount of the wire, check or jovrnat the undersigned hereby 
authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to
accept the verbal instructions from the undersigned regarding the change or changes. The undersigned further understands
and agrees to comply with the
procedures of Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to verify the authorization and accuracy of verbal Instructions.
The undersigned hereby OCIrfaniedgeS that (i) the information contained in This form is complete and accurate to the 
best knowledge of the widersigned and Id
the
undersigned is responsible for the method ol transmission 0 any instructions issued pursuant to this authorization. 0 
the undersigned elects to transmit any
such
instrucfl0ns kill lax including desktop tad. va email or as an huge attachment to email (e.g.. as a PDF. 11F or other 
image O such instruct:grist. the
undersigned
understands and agrees that the undersigned bears the risk of loss arising from such method of transmission in the event
of transmission errors,
misunderstandings.
Impersonations. transmission by unauthonzed persons, forgery or intim:opts. For trusts or other entities, the 
undersigned further acknowledges dial the
undersigned is
authorized to issue the above asset movement instructions under the terms of the governing doe trams and any applicable 
laws. The undersigned hereby reams end
holds harmless Deutsche Bank Alec Brown from and against loss Iron, any action, claim or demand of any person as  of 
Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown's receipt of
Of COMphaACO vaLh ins euthoruation andrce any instructions that may be given to Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown pursuant to 
this authorization (including any standing
authorization).
The undersigned understands that Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown may but is not required to. Seek verification d the 
undersigned's Ulster-Cons by cell back and that
Courser* Dank Alex. Brown may in its sole discretion refuse to execute such instructions fineiuding standing 
instructions) given pursuant to this authorization,
without
incurung any late rty.. Bank Alex. Crown has reason to believe such instructions For standing instructions) have not 
been provided by the undersigned. The
undersigned further unclogan that f - t Bars Alex. Brown retains the right to refuse to execute any Instructions to 
Gensler funds or SeCurileS teeny acootuds)
pursuant to this &Menfolkq m en instructions beanng original signature(s) of the undersigned.
?ignsture /
nature
Jeffrey Epstein 1.2.2014
Is nt Date
eon, Name Date
III I Ill LIIIII
OA III iii
IPAWM-0I775112/10)
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0050371
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00196555
EFTA00582807 (Jmail)
 [misc] plans for a media empire involved buying Virgin Islands Daily News which had criticized Epstein
(inferred date: 2014-03-29)
NEWGRANGE
CONSULTING SOFTWARE COMMUNICATIONS
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT MEMORANDUM
Extremely Confidential
To: Jeffery Epstein
From: James P. McGee, Newgrange Consulting Group
Date: December 28, 2013
Re: 2014 USVI Media Business Company Model and Development Plan
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
As requested, I have put together a follow up memorandum to summarize our
discussions around the current opportunity to create a full scale media business
entity in US Virgin Islands including the developmental steps that need to be taken
during the coming 2014 year in order to make it happen.
There is currently a very rare and unique opportunity to develop a true media
enterprise in the Virgin Islands at a very reasonable cost which would have the
ability to become a very successful and profitable multimedia business operation in
the Virgin Islands territory and eventually throughout the entire Caribbean region.
I am sure it is no surprise that I am looking for your involvement in this venture to
provide the initial financing component necessary, but I am also looking for you to
have an active participatory role in the overall development of this business entity.
A multimedia business such as the one I am proposing will also require the
identifying of key, trusted individuals who will have important roles in the
operations of the business and will include a community relations component that
will provide for an increased level of community involvement in the territory and
for those reasons I would be looking to have your help, your opinions, and your
expertise in selecting and developing the right operations team that would be best
to accomplish the goals of the business.
Newgrange Consulting Group • N2 Innovations • Newgrange Strategies • The Newgrange Foundation
43 Charles Street Suite 3 • Boston, MA 02114 • Phone: (617) 227.8080 • Fax: (617) 227.8090
•
The sections that follow will outline the approach that we are taking around this
opportunity and the next steps that need to be executed if there is still an interest at
your end to be involved.
If you believe that the areas outlined below are worth pursuing I believe it would
be best to meet and discuss where to go from here. As I mentioned during our call,
I can come to New York if that is a better option for you, or we can find a time
when will both be on island and schedule a meeting in the US Virgin Islands.

Overall Media Entity Creation / Acquisition Steps

The approach to creating the proposed Virgin Islands multimedia business
operation would be the active acquisition of two (2) existing media entities and the
development of a third in cooperation with the US Virgin Islands Government.
The acquisition aspect of the operation includes the pursuit and purchase of the
local newspaper (Virgin Islands Daily News) which is currently up for sale and a
local radio station (Ackley Media) which is available and open to discussions
around purchase.

Virgin Islands Daily News Acquisition
The Virgin Islands Daily News is already underway with a sales process and
looking for a buyer. This is something that has been publicized and is currently
being looked at by a number of interested parties.
The Times -Shamrock Communications family bought the Daily News for $5.25
Million which included the real estate. Times-Shamrock is now looking for
between $6 to $7 Million at this point in time but we have been told that this is
going to be negotiable.
The purchase of the VI Daily News will also require adjustments be made to the
existing operations model in order to make it profitable. There need to be
discussions around a more strategic and flexible multimedia approach for the
future business operations of this newspaper asset.

Radio Station Acquisition
As we have covered briefly, an existing radio station which was previously, and
technically is still, owned by Gordon Ackley is potentially available for purchase.
Gordon Ackley had been looking for a buyer for the station for more than three (3)
years during which time his asking price dropped from the outrageous to the more
realistic but all the while he did not attract any real interest. The most recent
information puts the asking price in the more realistic range of $750.000 to $1
Million.
It is understood that the current owner lacks the ability from both a managerial and
a needed capital investment perspective to make the project work and there may be
an opportunity to move on this potential acquisition in the very near future.
viNGN Broadband ISP / Television Medium Development
In addition to the acquisitions outlined above, the overall media operations
development includes the creation and development of a Local ISP in the Virgin
Islands that will utilize the recently completed territory wide high speed fiber optic
broadband network managed by the Virgin Islands Next Generation Network
(viNGN)
This third component of the potential media business development plan is a bit
more complex but probably also has what could be the greatest potential upside.
The viNGN project provides the opportunity to develop a successful and profitable
Internet Service Provider (ISP) business niche in the territory.
In short, the high speed broadband network was created as the "middle mile" to
provide ultra-high speed internet access via advanced fiber optic networking on all
three (3) islands however, the government does not provide access to the network
for the end user (i.e. the consumer).
In order to provide access to the end user an ISP is needed to purchase the
bandwidth from the viNGN network and then resell to the consumer. The
opportunity in this case is to develop an entity along the lines of the Comcast /
Xfinity Cable TV Model in the mainland US where the business provides bundling
options of Phone, Internet, and Television access over their high speed broadband
network. All of which could be provided through the access of the government
middle mile network at substantially lower costs than the current local competition.
The overall budget to do a full development of an ISP that will be capable of
providing the services described above is in the range of $10 to $12 Million. This
is based on similar ISP developmental plans presently in the territory.
A more detailed budget will need to be developed as well as a timeline of
implementation and marketing strategy which will include a target goal for future
government contractual work. These are details that would be addressed in a
business development meeting if there is a desire to move forward.
There are obviously a number of other more detailed discussions that need to
happen around this topic but even though the opportunity is more complex, as
indicated above the upside for this business venture is tremendous especially given
the increased viewership of local television that has occurred in the territory. This
increase has been polled, measured, and researched over the past seven (7) years
and is clear and definitive.
Business Development and Operational Approach
The current approach will be to create a spin off / subsidiary company from the
already established firm of Westland Strategies which is a public relations and
communications vehicle that has already been established in the US Virgin Islands.
A related but separate entity named the Westland Media Group will be the vehicle
through which we would pursue the entities referenced above. We will look for
initial funding from you to be provided to the Westland Media Group entity and
that will be the representative vehicle through which we will present ourselves to
those prospective sellers as well as the US Virgin Islands government entities with
who we would need to engage.
We will need to meet to discuss the expected rate of return on any investment
dollars you make as well what, if any, ownership interests and levels of
participation you would be interested in for this venture.
Conclusion
The areas that have been briefly outlined in this memorandum should provide a
base level of understanding around the current media business opportunities in the
Virgin Islands at this time.
While the information provided in this memorandum is a good starting point it will
also, no doubt, require a follow up conversation, or meeting if it is your desire to
move forward.
As I had referenced in the beginning of this memorandum, if there is an interest to
proceed on your end, I will be willing to meet in New York, or the US Virgin
Islands, whichever is more convenient for you, to discuss the next steps including
outlining the terms of such a partnership.
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
      BTC-e [crypto] infamous Russian crypto exchange through which Mt. Gox stolen funds were laundered, CEO Vinnik convicted but pardoned by Trump 
                                                                                                                                             [wiki] 
                                                                           Bitfinex [crypto] crypto exchange run by the same people that run Tether 
                                                Silk Road [crypto] online illegal drugs market run by Ross Ulbricht, first real use case for crypto 
                                                                                           FinCEN [government] Financial Crimes Enforcement Network 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01074293 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Jerry Brito, Houman Shadab, & Andrea Castillo discussion draft of "Bitcoin Financial Regulation" paper
(date: 2014-04-10)
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
BITCOIN FINANCIAL REGULATION:
SECURITIES, DERIVATIVES, PREDICTION MARKETS,
& GAMBLING
Jerry Britos• Houman Shadab," & Andrea Castillo"
INTRODUCTION 2

I. BITCOIN AND THE FIRST WAVE OF REGULATION 3
A. Bitcoin in Brief 3
B. The First Wave of Regulation 6
II. REGULATION OF BITCOIN-RELATED FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS 10

A. Bitcoin Derivatives 10
1. Futures 13
2. Forwards 16
3. Swaps 17
4. Options 20
B. Bitcoin Securities 21

1. Bitcoin Funds 22
2. Bitcoin Margin Trading 26
C. Bitcoin-Denominated Instruments & Gambling 29
1. Bitcoin-Denominated Derivatives and Markets 29

2. Bitcoin-Denominated Securities and Exchanges 33
3. Regulating Bitcoin-Denominated Transactions 40
4. Prediction Markets & Gambling 42
III. DECENTRALIZED MARKETS AND EXCHANGES 51
A. Decentralized Applications 55
1. Securities Exchanges 57
2. Predictions Markets 58
3. Gambling 60
B. Law and Decentralization 61
CONCLUSION 65
Senior Research Fellow, Mercatus Center at George Mason University. J.D., George
Mason University School of Law, 2005; B.A., Political Science, Florida International
University, 1999. The authors would like to thank Eli Dourado, Patrick O'Sullivan, and
Jeff Garzik for their thoughtful input and Jacob Hamburger for his research assistance.

• Associate Professor of Law, New York Law School. B.A. 1998, University of
California at Berkeley; J.D. 2002, University of Southern California.
• Research Associate, Mercatus Center at George Mason University. B.S.,
Economics, Florida State University, 2011.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
INTRODUCTION
Bitcoin presents a unique challenge to policymakers. On the one hand,
because it is an open protocol and a decentralized network, there is no
company or central server that can be regulated. On the other hand, there
are a number of emerging new intermediaries operating on the Bitcoin
network that are certainly susceptible to regulation and enforcement. These
include exchanges, merchant processors, and money transmitters that
provide Bitcoin services to consumers. To date, Bitcoin-related regulation
has largely been focused on the application of "know your customer," anti-
money-laundering rules, as well as consumer protection licensing, on these
new intermediaries.
The next major wave of Bitcoin regulation will likely be aimed at
financial instruments, including securities and derivatives, as well as
prediction markets and even gambling. While there are many easily
regulated intermediaries when it comes to traditional securities and
derivatives, emerging bitcoin-denominated instruments rely much less on
traditional intermediaries. Additionally, the block chain technology that
Bitcoin introduced for the first time makes completely decentralized
markets and exchanges possible, thus eliminating the need for
intermediaries in complex financial transactions.
In this article we survey the type of financial instruments and
transactions that will most likely be of interest to regulators, including
traditional securities and derivatives, new bitcoin-denominated instruments,
and completely decentralized markets and exchanges. We find that bitcoin
derivatives would likely not be subject to the full scope of regulation under
the Commodities and Exchange Act because such derivatives would likely
involve physical delivery (as opposed to cash settlement) and would not be
capable of being centrally cleared. We also find that some laws, including
those aimed at online gambling, do not contemplate a payment method like
Bitcoin, thus placing many transactions in a legal gray area.
Following the approach to Bitcoin taken by FinCEN, we conclude that
other financial regulators should consider exempting or excluding certain
financial transactions denominated in Bitcoin from the full scope of the
regulations, much like private securities offerings and forward contracts are
treated. In particular, given that physical settlement of a commodity
derivatives transaction likely means that it is excluded from regulation by
the Commodities Futures Trading Commission, virtual settlement of Bitcoin
transactions should likewise trigger a lighter regulatory framework. We also
suggest that to the extent that regulation and enforcement becomes more
costly than its benefits, policymakers should consider and pursue strategies
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
consistent with that new reality, such as efforts to encourage resilience and
adaption.
This Article is structured as follows. Part I presents a brief sketch of the
Bitcoin technology and describes the first wave of Bitcoin-related
regulation. Part II analyzes the legal treatment of traditional securities and
derivatives that are either bitcoin-backed or which have bitcoins as the
underlying, as well as non-traditional bitcoin-denominated securities,
derivatives, prediction markets, and gambling. Finally, Part III considers the
implications of completely decentralized markets and exchanges made
possible by Bitcoin and other emerging technologies.

I. BITCOIN AND THE FIRST WAVE OF REGULATION
Bitcoin is a new Internet protocol, a peer-to-peer network, and a digital
currency unit. Following the protocol, the network operates to maintain a
global public ledger of bitcoin transactions.' As we will see in later
sections, there are many different applications that this technology enables.
To date, however, it is simple payments and money transfer that has
captured the public's imagination, and it is therefore what has drawn
regulators' attention. In this section we will present a brief overview of
Bitcoin as a payments or money transfer system and the first wave of
regulation that addressed those applications.
A. Bitcoin in Brief
Bitcoin is frequently described as a "digital currency." 2 While that
description is accurate, it can be misleading because it is at once too broad
and too narrow. It is too broad because Bitcoin is a very particular kind of
digital currency called a cryptocurrency (indeed, it is the first of its kind).3 It
is too narrow because although currency is one aspect of the Bitcoin system,
Bitcoin is more broadly an Internet protocol with many applications beyond
payments or money transfer. 4
Virtual or digital currencies are nothing new. From in-game currencies
like World of Warcraft Golds or Linden Dollars, 6 to vendor-specific
I Lowercase vs. uppercase
2 Francois R. Velde, Bitcoin: A Primer, 317 Chicago Fed Letter (2013).
3 Jerry Brito & Andrea Castillo, Bitcoin: A Primer for Policymakers, (I s' ed. 2013).
Jerry Brito, It's More Than Money, Cato Unbound, July 12, 2013, http://www.cato-
unbound.org/2013/07/12/jerry-brito/its-more-just-money; Jerry Brito, Is Bitcoin the Key to
Digital Copyright?, Reason Magazine, February 24, 2014,
http://reason.com/archives/2014/02/24/is-bitcoin-the-key-to-digital-copyright.
5 Laurence H.M. Holland, Making Real Money in Virtual Worlds, Forbes Magazine,
August 7, 2006, http://www.forbes.com/2006/08/07/virtual-world-
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
currencies like Facebook Credits? Microsoft Points,8 or even airline miles,
digital currencies have been around for well over a decade. Even the dollars
in one's PayPal account are essentially digital currency. What makes
Bitcoin unique is that unlike all digital currencies that preceded it, a central
authority, such as a company or government, does not issue Bitcoin and no
central authority is required to verify a transfer from one individual to
another.° Instead, Bitcoin employs cryptography and peer-to-peer
networking to eliminate the need for third parties.  Comparing Bitcoin to
traditional payments and money transfer systems helps explain the
distinction.
Before Bitcoin's invention in 2008, online transactions always required
a trusted third-party intermediary." For example, if Alice wanted to send
$100 to Bob over the Internet, she would have had to rely on a third-party
service like PayPal or MasterCard. Intermediaries like PayPal keep a ledger
of account holders' balances. When Alice sends Bob $100, PayPal deducts
the amount from her account and adds it to Bob's account.
Without such intermediaries, digital money could be spent twice.
Imagine there are no intermediaries with ledgers, and digital cash is simply
a computer file, just as digital documents such as photos or Word
documents are computer files. Alice could send $100 to Bob by attaching a
money file to a message. But just as with email, sending an attachment does
not remove it from one's computer. Alice would retain a perfect copy of the
money file after she had sent it. She could then easily send the same $100 to
Charlie. In computer science, this is known as the "double -spending"
problem," and until Bitcoin it could only be solved by employing a ledger-
keeping trusted third party.
Bitcoin's invention is revolutionary because for the first time the
double-spending problem can be solved without the need for a third party.
jobs cx_de_0807virtualjobs.html.
7  Spencer Reiss, Virtual Economics, MIT Technology Review, December I, 2005,
httriAvww.technologyreview.com/article/404979/virtual-economicst
7 Miguel Helft, Facebook Hopes Credits Make Dollars, New York Times (New York),
September 23,2010 at Bl.
8 Ben Gilbert, Microsoft Points from Xbox 360 transfer to Xbox One as real money,
`equal or greater in Marketplace value,' Engadget, June 12, 2013,
http lAvww.engadget.com/2013/06/12/microsoft-points-conversion-xbox-onet
9 Satoshi Nakamoto, Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System, White Paper,
(2008).
N Id.
II Jerry Brito & Andrea Castillo, Bitcoin: A Primer for Policymakers, (1" ed. 2013). 12 David Chaum, Achieving 
Electronic Privacy, Scientific American Magazine
(New
York), August 1992, at 96-101.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
Bitcoin does this by distributing the necessary ledger among all the users of
the system via a peer-to-peer network. Every transaction that occurs in the
Bitcoin network is registered in a distributed public ledger, which is called
the block chain. New transactions are checked against the block chain to
ensure that the same bitcoins have not been previously spent, thus
eliminating the double-spending problem. The global peer-to-peer network,
composed of thousands of users, takes the place of an intermediary; Alice
and Bob can transact online without PayPal.
Transactions are verified, and double-spending is prevented, through the
clever use of public-key cryptography.' 3 Public-key cryptography requires
that each user be assigned two "keys," one private key that is kept secret
like a password, and one public key that can be shared with the world.
When Alice decides to transfer bitcoins to Bob, she creates a message,
called a "transaction," which contains and Bob's public key and how many
coins she is sending. She then "signs" it with her private key and broadcasts
the message over the network. By looking at Alice's public key, anyone can
verify that the transaction was indeed signed with her private key, that it is
an authentic exchange, and that Bob is the new owner of the funds. The
transaction —and thus the transfer of ownership of the bitcoins-is
recorded, time-stamped, and displayed in one "block" of the block chain.
Public-key cryptography ensures that all computers in the network have a
constantly updated and verified record of all transactions within the Bitcoin
network, which prevents double -spending and fraud.
Out of technical necessity, transactions on the Bitcoin network are not
denominated in dollars or euros or yen as they are on PayPal, but are instead
denominated in bitcoins. This makes it a virtual currency in addition to a
decentralized public ledger. The value of the currency is not derived from
gold or government fiat, but from the value that people assign to it. The
dollar value of a bitcoin is determined on an open market, just as is the
exchange rate between different world currencies. The number of bitcoins
that are issued—that is, the size of the money supply-is not determined by
any person, company, or central bank, but instead grows at a
algorithmically pre-determined rate baked into the protocol."
13 Christof Paar, Jan Pelzl, and Bart Preneel, Introduction to Public -Key Cryptography,
in Understanding Cryptography: A Textbook for Students and Practitioners, ch. 6 (Christof
Paar and Jan Pelzl, eds., New York: Springer 2010). (New York: Springer, 2010), sample
available at http://wiki.crypto.rub.de/Buch/download/Understanding -Cryptography-
Chapter6.pdf.
14 The explanation of Bitcoin's mechanics presented here is a consciously abridged
one. It might therefore be unsatisfying to those encountering Bitcoin for the first time.
Readers looking for a more-detailed explanation of Bitcoin's operation should consult:
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
For these reasons, Bitcoin is unlike any digital currency that preceded it.
Bitcoin is not just a virtual unit of account, but also a decentralized system
for transferring value. It is a nyptocurrency, which means that a central
authority does not issue the currency, nor is a central authority needed to
verify transactions. Transactions are instead recorded in a decentralized and
distributed public ledger and are cryptographically verifiable. Bitcoin was
the world's first cryptocurrency, and since its invention other
cryptocurrencies have emulated its model." As we'll see in Part III, infra,
because Bitcoin is at root a decentralized and distributed public ledger, and
because it is programmable, it has the potential to facilitate completely
decentralized security exchanges, prediction markets, and gambling.
B. The First Wave of Regulation
Payments and money transfers are the most obvious application of the
distributed public ledger technology, so they were the first application of
the technology to be implemented. Merchants from Overstock.com 16 to the
Sacramento Kings17
to WordPress.com 18
have begun accepting payment in
bitcoin, and startups like BitPesa vlan to use the Bitcoin network to
facilitate international remittances. 9  By disintermediating traditional
financial networks like PayPal, Visa, and Western Union, Bitcoin offers
three main advantages: it can be cheaper, faster, and censorship -resistant.
First, Bitcoin transaction costs are much lower than those of traditional
financial networks. While credit card networks charge merchants fees in the
range of 3 to 4 percent of the total amount of a transaction, 26 and the
Brito & Castillo; Velde.
18 Alex Liu, Beyond Bitcoin: A Guide to the Most Promising Cryptocurrencies,
Motherboard, November 29, 2013, http://motherboard.vice.com/blog/beyond-bitcoin-a-
guide-to-the-most-promising-cryptocurrencies.
16 Cade Metz, The Grand Experiment Goes Live: Overstock.com Is Now Accepting
Bitcoins, Wired Magazine, January 9, 2014,
http://www.wired.com/business./2014/01/overstock-bitcoin-livet
17 Cade Metz, Sacramento Kings Crowned First Pro Sports Team to Accept Bitcoin,
Wired Magazine, January 16, 2014, http://virww.wired.com/business/2014/01/sacramento-
kings-bitcoint.
18 Jon Matonis, What's Your Bitcoin Strategy? WordPress Now Accepts Bitcoin
Across the Planet, Forbes Magazine, November 16, 2012,
http://www.forbes.com/sites/jonmatonis/2012/11/16/whats-your-bitcoin-strategy-
wordpress-now-accepts-bitcoin-across-the-planed.
18 Richard Boase, BitPesa Uses Bitcoin to Slash Kenyan Remittance Costs, CoinDesk,
November 28, 2013, http://www.coindesk.com/bitpesa-uses-bitcoin-slash-kenyan-
remittance•costs/.
20 Paul Downs, What You Need to Know About Credit Card Processing, New York
Times, March 25, 2013, http://boss.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/03/25/what-you-need-to-
know-about-credit-carthprocessing/.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
average cost of international remittances is 8.5 percent, 21 a Bitcoin
transaction can cost less than 1 percent. 22 Second, Bitcoin transactions can
be much faster. For example, while international wire transfers can take
days to complete, Bitcoin transactions take roughly ten minutes. 23 Finally,
Bitcoin is censorship -resistant. For example, while PayPal froze the
accounts of WikiLeaks after it released secret State Department cables, and
prevented its customers from making donations to the group,24 such
transactional prior restraint would not be possible on the Bitcoin network
because there is no intermediary.
Bitcoin is in many ways a disruptive technology, 25 and sensing a great
profit opportunity venture capitalists and entrepreneurs are at present
rushing to develop the network's infrastructure. Among the key parts of this
first wave of startups are exchanges that allow consumers to trade fiat
currency, such as dollars or euros, for bitcoins and vice versa; online wallets
that allow consumers who do not want to run the more-complicated desktop
software on their own computers to carry bitcoin balances and spend them;
and merchant services, which easily allow merchants to accept bitcoin
payments and have dollars deposited in their bank accounts, thus
eliminating volatility risk.
Like other disruptive technologies, Bitcoin is first taking hold in spaces
that are underserved by incumbents. This includes innovative areas like
micropayments 26 and crowdfunding, 27 but also payments related to the
online sale of illicit goods, such as drugs and firearms in the U.S. or
subversive actions against oppressive regimes like Iran28 and Russia.29
21 World Bank, Remittance Prices Worldwide, accessed March 26, 2014,
http://remittanceprices.worldbank.org/.
22 Note that the tradeoff for the low transaction costs of a bitcoin transaction is the lack
of insurance and perks that are paid for with traditional payment systems' higher fees.
23 Average transaction times are viewable at: blochain.info, Average Transaction
Confirmation Time, accessed March 26, 2014, http://blockchain.info/charts/avg-
confirmation-time.
24 Kevin Poulsen, PayPal Freezes WikiLeaks Account, Wired Magazine, December 4,
2010, http:/Avww.wired.com/threatleve1/2010/12/paypal-wikileakst
25 Timothy Lee, Bitcoin is a Disruptive Technology, Forbes Magazine, April 9, 2013,
http ://www.forbes.com/s ites/timothylee/2013/04/09/b itco in- is-a-disrupt ive-technologyt
26 Pete Rizzo, Bitcoin Micropayments Get Big Moment as Chicago Sun-Times
Paywall Experiment Goes Live, CoinDesk, February 1, 2014,
http://www.coindesk.comlmicropayments-chicago-sun-times-paywall-livet
27 Eric Blattberg, Crowdtilt launches free, open source crowdfunding solution and it
supports Bitcoin, VentureBeat, February 20, 2014,
http://venturebeat.com/2014/02/20/crowdtilt-launches-free-open-source-crowdfunding-
solution-and-it-supports-bitcoin./.
25 Max Raskin, Dollar -Less Iranians Discover Virtual Currency, BusinessWeek,
November 29, 2012, http://www.businessweek.comlarticles/2012.11-29/dollar-less-
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
Because Bitcoin is censorship-resistant, it can be employed for transactions
that incumbent intermediaries would not process, or are not allowed by law
to process. Indeed, it is possible that Bitcoin's network effects were
bootstrapped by demand for use in facilitating illicit transactions.3°
Given that the first application of the Bitcoin technology has been
simple payments and money transfers, and given that the technology's
censorship-resistance permits transactions that were previously restrained, it
is no surprise that the first wave of regulatory activity related to Bitcoin has
focused on money transmission. At the federal level, the Treasury
Department's Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) issued
guidance in March of 2013 advising that Bitcoin exchangers and other
related enterprises qualified as money transmitters under FinCEN's
regulations implementing the Bank Secrecy Act.31 As a result, such
businesses are obligated to register with FinCEN as money services
businesses (MSBs) and comply with "know your customer" rules, put in
place robust anti-money-laundering programs, and file Suspicious Activity
Reports.32
Money transmitters must be licensed by each state in which they do
business, so at the state level financial regulators have been grappling with
how existing money transmission laws and regulations apply to Bitcoin
businesses.33 New York has taken the lead in making these determinations.
In August 2013, New York's Department of Financial Services subpoenaed
almost two-dozen Bitcoin-related businesses, as well as investors in those
businesses, seeking more information about their activities.34 And in
January of 2014, the Department held two days of hearings looking at how
Bitcoin businesses should be licensed, and considering the possibility of a
iranians-discover-virtual-currency.
" Russian authorities say Bitcoin illegal, Reuters, February 9, 2014,
httplAvww.reuters.comfarticle/2014/02/09/us-russia-bitcoin-idUSBREA1806620140209.
3° Eli Dourado, Can the War on Drugs Bootstrap Bitcoin?, blog post, June 4, 2011,
http://elidourado.com/blog/can-the-war-on•drugs-bootstrawbitcoint.
31 US Department of the Treasury, Financial Crimes and Enforcement Network,
Application of FinCEN's Regulations to Persons Administering, Exchanging, or Using
Virtual Currencies (Regulatory Guidance, FIN -2013-G001, US Department of the
Treasury, Washington, DC, March IS, 2013),
http://fincen.govistatutes_regs/guidance/htrnI/FIN-2013-G001.html.
32 Id.
33 Marco Santori, Bitcoin Law: Money transmission on the state level in the US,
CoinDesk, September 28, 2013, http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-law-money-
transmission-state-level-ust
3° Greg Farrell, N.Y. Subpoenas Bitcoin Firms in Probe on Criminal Risk, Bloomberg,
August 12, 2013, http:l/www.bloomberg.com/news12013-08.12/n-y-regulator-subpoenas-
firms-over-bitcoincrime-risks.html.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
new "BitLicense" tailored specifically for virtual currencies. 35
Law enforcement actions to date have also centered on money
laundering and unlicensed money transmission. In May of 2013, federal
agents seized $5 million from accounts belonging to Mt. Gox, which at the
time was the world's largest bitcoin exchange.' ° According to the seizure
warrant, the company had not registered with FinCEN as a money services
businesses and had stated in its bank application that it was not engaged in
money services. 37 In January of 2014, federal agents arrested Charlie
Shrem, CEO of the now-shuttered exchange Bitlnstant, on charges of
money laundering, operating an unlicensed money transmitter, and willful
failure to file suspicious activity reports with FinCEN. 38 According to the
criminal complaint against Shrem, he knowingly helped a bitcoin reseller
exchange dollars for bitcoins to be used on anonymous online black market
Silk Road.39
In the near term, state regulators will likely continue to develop
guidelines for applying money transmission licensing rules to Bitcoin
businesses. For its part, FinCEN has begun to release administrative rulings
clarifying the applicability of its regulations to specific business cases 40
Other federal regulators are also developing guidance to explain how their
regulations apply to Bitcoin. For example, the Federal Election Commission
39 Cater Dougherty, New York Vying With California to Write Bitcoin Rules,
Bloomberg, January 27, 2014, httplAvvirw.bloomberg.com/news/2014-01-27/new-york-
duels-califomia-to-write-bitcoin-rules.html.
36 Amar Toor, US seizes and freezes funds at biggest Bitcoin exchange, The Verge,
May 15, 2013, http://virww.theverge.com/2013/5/15/4332698/dwolla-payments-mtgox-
halted-by-homeland-security-seizure-warrant.
37 Seizure Warrant — In the Matter of the Seizure of The contents of one Dwolla
account (D. Md. May 14, 2013) (13.1162 SKG), http://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-
content/uploads/2013/05/Mt-Gox-Dwolla-Warrant-5.14-I3.pdf.; Affidavit in Support of
Seizure Warrant (D. Md. May 9, 2013) (B-1085SAG), http://thegenesisblock.com/wp-
content/uploads/2013/08/Gox-Wells-Fargo-Seizure-Warrant.pdf.
35 Sealed Complaint — United States of American v. Robert M. Faiella, a/k/a
"BTCKing," and Charlie Shrem, No. 14-MAG-0164 (S.D.N.Y. January 24, 2014),
http://www.justice.gov/usao/nys/pressreleases/January14/SchremFaiel laChargesPRJFaiel la,
%20Robert%20M.%20and%20Charlie%20Shrem%20Complaint.pdf.
39 Id. eo Department of Treasury Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Application of
FinCEN's Regulations to Virtual Currency Mining Operations, FIN-2014-R001, January
30, 2014, http://www.fincen.govinews_room/rp/rulings/pdf/FIN-2014-R001.pdf;
Department of Treasury Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Application of FinCEN's
Regulations to Virtual Currency Software Development and Certain Investment Activity,
FIN-2014-R002, January 30, 2014, http:/Avww.fincen.goWnews_room/rp/rulings/pdf/FIN-
2014-R002.pdf.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
has been looking at the question of bitcoin campaign contributions,m and
the Internal Revenue Service recently issued guidance on the tax treatment
of bitcoins.42 However, as we will argue in the following Section, the next
major wave of regulatory scrutiny that Bitcoin will face will not be related
to money transmission, but will instead come from financial regulators,
including the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity
Futures Trading Commission, looking at Bitcoin-related financial
instruments and markets.

II. REGULATION OF BITCOIN-RELATED FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS
There is some debate about whether bitcoins qualify as currency,
securities, commodities, or a new asset class altogether.43 Whatever the
answer, the fact is that as the Bitcoin economy develops one should expect
to see demand for Bitcoin-related financial instruments to emerge, and
indeed such demand is already beginning to manifest itself. In this Section
we survey some of these instruments and analyze how existing law and
regulation may apply to them.

A. Bitcoin Derivatives
Over the course of 2013, regulators and central banks around the world
issued warnings to consumers about the risks associated with Bitcoin.44
Chief among these risks is the currency's historical volatility. The dollar-
denominated market price of one bitcoin began 2013 at around $13.41 and
closed the year at around $817.12 in December.45 In that time, the price
reached a high of $1,147.25 on December 4th, and experienced single-day
gains of $198.09,46 and losses of $208.47 This volatility obviously presents a
d1 Benjamin Goad, FEC: No bitcoins in federal campaigns, The Hill, November 21,
2013, http://thehill.com/blogs/regwatchttechnology/191096-fec-no-bitcoins-in-federal-
campaigns.
d2 John D. McKinnon and Ryan Tracy, IRS Says Bitcoin Is Property, Not Currency,
Wall Street Journal, March 25, 2014,
http://online.wsj.cominews/articles/SB10001424052702303949704579461502538024502.
d3 Reuben Grinberg, Bitcoin: An Innovative Alternative Digital Currency, 4 Hasting
Set& Tech. L.J. 160 (2011).
d1 Law Library of Congress, Global Legal Research Center, Regulation of Bitcoin in
Selected Jurisdictions, Report for Congress, LL File No. 2014-010233, January 2014,
httplAvww.hsgac.senate.govidownload/regulation-of-bitcoin-in-selected-jurisdictions.
45 Price data from the CoinDesk Bitcoin Price Index, which aggregates price data from
multiple exchanges that meet certain criteria; in this case, Bitfinex, Bitstamp, and BTC-e.
See: Bitcoin Price Index Chart, CoinDesk, accessed March 27, 2014,
http://www.coindesk.comipricelli2012-12-31,2013-12-30,close,bpi,USD.
46 Gains for trades between the closing prices on November 17 and November I8,
2013. See: Bitcoin Price Index Chart, CoinDesk, accessed March 27, 2014,
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
challenge to anyone looking to transact using Bitcoin.
lb la1 1w Im 3rro p M
Itolflat dint
„ 11
.1,O1.20O to DK.). NT?
Ott 10
OOP COSY
Figure 1— Bitcoin-dollar exchange rate for 2013.
There is nothing inherently volatile about Bitcoin, however.48 Its
volatility is likely attributable to the fact that it is a new currency, still in the
process of discovering its stable price.49 Additionally, as a nascent currency,
it is very thinly traded and as a result a single large-enough trade can affect
the exchange price substantially. Positive news, such as major retailers
announcing they will accept the currency, can make the price jump
dramatically, while negative news, such as unfavorable regulatory
pronouncements, can send the price plummeting. And greater media
coverage of any kind will no doubt introduce more and more persons to
Bitcoin for the first time and thus drive new demand for the currency.
Despite this volatility, tens of thousands of merchants accept bitcoins
for payment.5° The reason is that while Bitcoin's present volatility may
http://www.coindesk.com/pricell/2012-12-31,2013-12-30,close,bpi,USD.
07  Losses for trades between the closing prices on December 5 and December 6, 2013.
See: Bitcoin Price Index Chart, CoinDesk, accessed March 27, 2014,
http://www.coindesk.com/price/#2012-12-31,2013-12-30,close,bpi,USD.
" Indeed, volatility has historically trended down. See: Eli Dourado, Bitcoin Volatility
is Down Over the Last Three Years. Here's the Chart that Proves It, blog, January 20,
2014, http://elidourado.com/blogibitcoin-volatility/.
d9 Timothy B. Lee, These four charts suggest that Bitcoin will stabilize in the future,
Washington Post, February 3, 2014, http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-
switch/wp/2014/02/03/these-four-charts-suggest-that-bitcoin-will-stabilize-in-the-futuret
S0 BitPay Announces Bitcoin Payroll API, BusinessWire, January 13, 2014,
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
make it an unstable store of value, it can nevertheless serve as an excellent
medium of exchange. 5I As Marc Andreessen has put it, "Bitcoin can be
used entirely as a payment system; merchants do not need to hold any
Bitcoin currency or be exposed to Bitcoin volatility at any time.i 52 This
means accepting bitcoins for payment at the current exchange rate and then
immediately converting those bitcoins to dollars or some other stable
currency. This is what Overstock.com, one of the largest retailers to accept
bitcoins, does.53 Overstock CEO Patrick Byrne has explained that the
company will not hold bitcoins saying, "Until we can hedge through some
kind of derivative instrument, we don't want to take that direct exposure." 54
An astute reader will no doubt be thinking: well, someone has to be
holding the bitcoins. Speculators account for a large portion of bitcoin
holdings, 55 but what about bitcoins that are actively being transacted? In the
case of Overstock.com, the retailer is employing merchant services from
Coinbase, a Silicon Valley startup backed by Andreessen Horowitz. 56 When
you make a purchase at Overstock, prices are denominated in dollars, and if
you pay in bitcoins, Coinbase accepts the bitcoins and deposits the dollar
amount into Overstock's bank account. This means that it is Coinbase that
is accepting the exchange volatility risk.57 For its services, Coinbase
charges Overstock a fee of about 1%, which is less than the fees associated
with other electronic payments such as credit cards. 58
However, that 1% fee by itself might not be enough to cover the
exchange rate risk that Coinbase faces. At the moment, Coinbase is hedging
http://www.businesswire.cominews/home/20140113006504/en/BitPay-Announces-Bitcoin-
Payroll-API.; New Coinabase for Android, and Coinbase Merchant App Released for
Android, Coinbase Blog, December 29, 2013,
http://blog.coinbase.com/post/71607045439Inew-coinbase-for-android-and-coinbase-
merchant-app.
51 Marc Andreessen, Why Bitcoin Matters, New York Times, January 21, 2014,
http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2014/01/21/why-bitcoin-matterst 32 Id.
53 Rob Wile, Bitcoin Is Experiencing Its Longest Stretch of Price Stability In a While,
Business Insider, January 29, 2014, http://www.businessinsider.com/bitcoin-volatility-
slows-2014-I.
54 Id.
55 Will Knight, Show Me the Bitcoins, MIT Technology Review, February 2014,
http://www.technologyreview.com/graphiti/524796/show-me-the-bitcoinst
56 Cade Metz, The Grand Experiment Goes Live: Overstock.com Is Now Accepting
Bitcoins, Wired Magazine, January 9, 2014,
http://www.wired.com/business/2014/01/overstock-bitcoin-live/. 57 Id.
SR What fees does Coinbase charge for merchant processing?, Coinbase support,
February 5, 2014, http://support.coinbase.com/customer/portallarticlesil 277919-what-fees-
does-coinbase-charge-for-merchant-processing-.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
using algorithmic trading.59 Other merchant services companies, like
Founders -Fund -backed BitPay, seem to employ a similar approach. °  But
this approach is not as efficient as simply engaging in a swap or futures
contract. It is not surprising, therefore, that bitcoin payment processors and
others are clamoring for bitcoin derivatives. 6I Such instruments could help
calm Bitcoin's volatility and could allow the network's infrastructure to
further develop.
There are several types of derivatives contracts that parties seeking to
reduce their exposure to Bitcoin price volatility can employ. We consider
Bitcoin forwards, futures, swaps, and options. These types of Bitcoin
derivatives come within the orbit of regulation by the Commodity Futures
Trading Commission (CFTC) pursuant to the Commodity and Exchange
Act (CEA). 62 However, because Bitcoin derivatives would likely involve
physical delivery (as opposed to cash settlement) and would not be capable
of being centrally cleared, they would not be subject to the full scope of
CFTC regulation, if any.
1. Futures
In a futures contract, one party agrees to deliver an underlying asset or
its cash-equivalent to another at a later time at a specific price.6  A party
concerned with Bitcoin prices decreasing would take the "short" position in
a futures contract and agree to sell Bitcoin at a specific price. For example,
on January 1st one party may agree to sell 1 bitcoin on February 1st for
$800. This agreement would lock in a bitcoin-to-dollar exchange rate of
0.00125 BTC. A company that owns or expects to be paid in bitcoins, and is
concerned about the value of bitcoins dropping against the dollar, would be
protected against that risk. On the other hand, if bitcoins became more
valuable after January 1st, the forward contract would still require the buyer
to sell at what would be below-market prices. Futures contracts are by
" Cade Metz, The Grand Experiment Goes Live: Overstock.com Is Now Accepting
Bitcoins, Wired Magazine, January 9, 2014,
http://www.wired.com/business/2014/01/overstock-bitcoin-livet
c'e Greg Simon, Exclusive Interview with Bitpay CEO Tony Gallippi, December 28,
2013, http://lmowmadiclife.corniblog/2013/12/28/exclusive-interview-with-b itpay-ceo-
allippi.
°I Cade Metz, The Next Big Thing You Missed: There's a Sure-Fire Way to Control
the Price of Bitcoin, Wired Magazine, January 14, 2014,
http://www.wired.com/business/2014/0 1 ibitcoin-derivatives/.
62 CEA, 7 USC §1 et seq.
63 Futures contract, CFTC Glossary, U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission
Education Center, accessed March 27, 2014,
http://www.cftc.goviconsumerprotectionteducationcenterkfIcglossarya John C. Hull,
Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives 6 (6th ed. 2006)
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
definition highly standardized and trade on exchanges. Accordingly, trading
a futures contract requires parties to open an account with a futures
exchange and abide by its requirements such a posting collateral when
entering the contract (initial margin) and paying more collateral if the
market value of the contract decreases (variation margin). This is often done
through an intermediary known as a futures commission merchant.
The CFTC defines a future as lap) agreement to purchase or sell a
commodity for delivery in the future" in which the price is determined at
the outset of the agreement. 64 With few exceptions, the definition of
commodity is defined broadly to include all agricultural products and "all
services, rights, and interests . . . in which contracts for future delivery are
presently or in the future dealt in."65 The definition of commodity includes
interest rates, foreign exchange rates, indices, and even weather events."
Futures contracts for commodities are subject to the provisions of the CEA
and are regulated by the CFTC and entities that have self-regulatory
responsibilities, including exchanges and the National Futures Association
(NFA). The key regulatory aspect of futures is that they are standardized
with respect to all terms except for price,67 and can only trade on regulated
exchanges. 68
The CEA categorizes regulated futures exchanges as a type of
designated contract market and as such they are required to comply with 23
"core principles.s 69 These principles effectively require them to establish
m Id. See also CFTC v. Erskin (6th Cit. 2008) (defining and distinguishing futures and
forwards contracts), http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-6th-circuit/1106725.htrnl.
65 7 U.S.C. § la(9). Two interests that fall outside of the definition of commodity
include onions and motion picture box office receipts. Id.
b6 See CEA Section la(19), 7 U.S.C. §1a(19) (defining "excluded commodity" to
include a wide range of financial interests); CFTC Glossary, Weather Derivative (definitive
"weather derivative" as "A derivative whose payoff is based on a specified weather event,
for example, the average temperature in Chicago in January"),
httriAvww.cftc.goviconsumerprotectionteducationcenter/cficglossary/glossary_wxyz.
67 Under some circumstances a non-standardized contract may be categorized as a
futures contract. In re Bybee, 945 F.2d 309, 312.13 (9th Cir. 1991).
68 CEA § 6(a).
69 CEA § 5(b-x), 7 USC § 7(d). A DCM is defined as "a board of trade or exchange
designated by the CFTC to trade futures, swaps, and/or options under the CEA. A contract
market can allow both institutional and retail participants and can list for trading contracts
on any commodity, provided that each contract is not readily susceptible to manipulation."
Commodity Market, CFTC Glossary.
http://www.ctic.goviconsumerprotectionieducationcenterkftcglossary/glossary_co; Core
Principles and Other Requirements for Designated Contract Markets 77 Fed. Reg. 36612
(CFTC June 19, 2012),
http://www.cftc.gov/ucm/groups/publici@lrfederalregister/documents/file/2012-
12746a.pdf.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
and enforce rules to protect customers, prevent fraud and manipulation,
maintain and disclose records, and maintain fair and orderly markets by, for
example, enforcing position limits 40 Regulated exchanges are available to
retail investors. A similar regulatory framework applies to derivatives
clearing organizations. 71 In addition, other futures market intermediaries are
required to register with the CFTC and are subject to wide ranging
regulation. These intermediaries include futures commission merchants that
serve the function of brokerages, 72 introducing brokers, 73 commodity pool
operators, 74 and commodity trading advisers. 75 The CEA and CFTC
regulation impose a wide variety of requirements on these intermediaries,
including obligations involving disclosure, reporting, recordkeeping, ethical
requirements, protection of customer funds, and capital requirements. 76
Bitcoins likely fall under the CEA's broad definition of commodity.
Accordingly, any futures contract referencing bitcoins will be subject to the
full scope of regulation under the CEA. This means that Bitcoin futures
must be traded on existing regulated exchanges such as the Chicago
Mercantile Exchange. Otherwise, any platform that offers Bitcoin futures
7° See also 7 U.S.C. 6g(e) (requiring exchanges to publicly disclose daily trading
volume).
71 7 USC § 7a-1(c)(2).
72 CEA la(28); 7 USC la(28) (defining FCM). 73
7 U.S.C. la(31) (defining introducing broker).
74 7 U.S.C. la(11) (defining commodity pool operator); Harmonization of Compliance
Obligations for Registered Investment Companies Required to Register as Commodity
Pool Operators, 78 Fed. Reg. 52308 (CFTC Aug. 22, 2013).
7 U.S.C. la(12) (defining commodity trading advisor); CFTC v. Equity Financial
Group LLP, 572 F.3d 150 (3d Cir. 2009).
76 7 U.S.C. 6d(a)(1) (FCM registration requirements); 7 U.S.C. 6d(a)(2) (FCM
customer funds segregation duties); 78 Fed. Reg. 68506, Enhancing Protections Afforded
Customers and Customer Funds Held by Futures Commission Merchants and Derivatives
Clearing Organizations„ Nov. 14, 2013 http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2013-11-
14/pdf/2013-26665.pdf; 7 U.S.C. 6d(c) (requiring FCMs and introducing brokers to
implement conflicts -of-interest systems); 7 U.S.C. 6g (reporting and recordkeeping
requirements for futures commission merchants, introducing brokers, and floor brokers and
traders); 7 U.S.C. 6f(cX2) (risk assessment recordkeeping requirements for futures
commission merchants); 7 U.S.C. 6d(g) (introducing broker registration requirement);
CFTC, Minimum Net Capital Requirements for Futures Commission Merchants and
Introducing Brokers,
http://www.cfrc.gov/IndustryOversight/Interrnediaries/FCMs/fcmibminimumnetcapital; 7
U.S.C. 6m(1) (registration requirements for CTAs and CFOs); 7 U.S.C. 6o(1) (prohibiting
fraud by commodity trading advisers and commodity pool operators); 77 Fed. Reg. 20127-
20215 (CFTC Apr. 3 2012) (obligations of futures commission merchants); 7 U.S.C.
6n(3)(A) (recordkeeping requirements for commodity trading advisers and commodity pool
operators); 77 Fed. Reg. 11252 (CFTC Feb. 24 2012) (compliance obligations for
commodity pool operators and commodity trading advisers).
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
would have to come into compliance with the wide-ranging and costly
regulation required of futures exchanges by the CEA.
2. Forwards
A forward is a contract whereby parties agree to trade an asset at a later
date at a price specified in the present." In a currency forward, for example,
one party agrees to trade the currency with another at a later date at a pre-
specified exchange rate." Currency forwards are one of the most widely
used and liquid financial instruments.79 Forwards are generally heavily
negotiated to be tailored to the specific risks and other terms that parties are
concerned about. The distinction between a futures and a forward is not
always clear and often depends detailed analysis of the facts and
circumstances of the contract. The general distinction is that, compared to
futures, forwards are non-standardized, do not trade on an exchange, and
are intended for actual delivery of the commodity (as opposed to cash
settlement).8° Other courts have articulated the distinction as being that
futures markets are for the sale of contracts while forward markets are for
the sale of commodities.81
Importantly, forward contracts are not subject to CFTC regulation.82
The court in CFTC v. Erskine explained the underlying policy:
77 Forward Contract, CFTC Glossary, U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission
Education Center, accessed March 27, 2014,
httriAvww.cftc.goviconsumerprotectionieducationcenterkficglossarya Hull, supra note 63,
at 3.4.
71I 7 U.S.C. la(24).
" Swap, CFTC Glossary, U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission Education
Center, accessed March 27, 2014,
http://www.cftc.goviconsumerprotectionieducationcenterkficglossaryt
8° Forward contract, CFTC Glossary, U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission
Education Center, accessed March 27, 2014,
http://www.cftc.goviconsumerprotectionieducationcenterkficglossaryt See also CFTC v.
Erskin (6th Cir. 2008) (defining and distinguishing futures and forwards contracts),
httpficaselaw.findlaw.cornius-6th-circuit/1106725.html; In re National Gas Distributors,
556 F.3d 247 (9th Cir 2009); CFTC v. Hanover Trading Corp., 34 F. Supp. 2d 203
(S.D.N.Y 1999) (contracts where no delivery was contemplated were futures); In re Grain
Land Cooperative, [2003-2004 Transfer Binder] Comm. Fut. L. Rep. (CCH) ¶ 29,636
(CFTC Nov. 25, 2003).
Si CFTC v. Zelener, 373 F.3d 861, 865.66 (7th Cir. 2004); CFTC v. Giovanni Fleury,
et al., No. 10-15041 (11t5 Cir. June 27, 2012).
82 CEA § la(27) (excluding sales "of any cash commodity for deferred shipment or
delivery" from the term "future delivery"); U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Com'n V.
Reed, 481 F. SUPP. 2D 1190 (D. Colo. 2007) ("The CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction does not
extend to transactions involving the sale or physical delivery of the actual commodity,
which are referred to as 'cash forwards' or `spot' transactions").
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
The purpose of Ethel "cash forward" exception [to CFTC regulation) is to
permit those parties who contemplate physical transfer of the commodity to
set up contracts that . . . reduce the risk of price fluctuations, without
subjecting the parties to burdensome regulations. These contracts are not
subject to the CFTC regulations because those regulations are intended to
govern only speculative markets; they arc not meant to cover contracts
wherein the commodity in question has an "inherent value" to the transacting
parties.83
Accordingly, to the extent a contract delivers bitcoins at a date after the sale
(and not their cash equivalent), and is being used by a party to manage price
risk, it would likely be considered a forward and be excluded from the
CEA. Unlike agricultural commodities, bitcoins are easily transferrable
between parties. Indeed, it is easier to transfer bitcoins than their cash-
equivalent. And unlike financial interests such as interest rates or index
prices, bitcoins are not pure intangibles where ownership is not possible. 84
In addition, as a means of payment and other financial services: 6  bitcoins
have inherent value. The digital nature of bitcoins along with their near
costless transferability suggests that most transactions involving future
delivery of bitcoin should be categorized as forwards not futures.
3. Swaps
A third type of potential Bitcoin derivative is a Bitcoin swap. A swap is
a contract in which each counterparty agrees to an exchange of payments
related to the value or return of some underlying asset or event.86 The
structure of Bitcoin swaps may resemble a foreign exchange (FX) swap. In
an FX swap, two parties borrow a foreign currency from each other and
agree to pay each other back at a specified exchange rate.87 Another type of
Bitcoin swap could be cash-settled and not entail the parties actually trading
bitcoins and a legal currency. Tera Group, Inc., is reportedly arranging such
a Bitcoin swap. 58 It would entail the parties to the swap agreeing to
exchange the cash equivalent value of Bitcoin and the dollar at a future
point in time. A merchant accepting Bitcoin would be able to use the swap
to protect itself against a price decrease by being promised to be paid cash if
83 CFTC v. v. Ross Erskine, et al., No. 06-3896., (6111. Cir. Jan. 9, 2008),
http://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-6th-circuitil 106725.html.
81 Bitcoins would likely fall under the "exempt commodity" category under the
CFTC's regulatory framework, as do precious metals.
85 For a discussion of the emerging uses of Bitcoin beyond a means of payment, see
infra Section Ill.
88 Hull, supra note 63, at 149.
88 7 U.S.C. la(25).
83 Katy Bume, New Derivative Guards Against Bitcoin's Price Swings, WSJ.com,
March 24, 2014.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
the value of Bitcoin drops relative to the dollar. Trade a swap that
references an index of virtual currencies would be another way to hedge
Bitcoin price risk.
The SEC has exclusive jurisdiction over swaps based on securities and
narrow-based indices. The CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction over most other
types of swaps, including those based on commodities, currencies, and
interest rates.  Swaps must be cleared by a regulated central counterparty
clearinghouse90 and be traded on either a designated contract market or a
swaps execution facility, unless no designated contract market or swaps
execution facility makes the swap available for trading.'' Swaps contracts
are not available to retail investors; parties to a swaps contract must be an
eligible contract participant.92 In practice, parties to a swaps contract will
enter a trade with an futures commission merchant who will in turn transact
with a clearinghouse. The two major categories of regulated entities are
swaps dealers that make markets in swaps, and major swaps participants, so
defined because their swaps exposures are deemed to pose a systemic risk.93
These entities are required to register with the CFTC and are subject to a
wide range of disclosure, reporting, capital, clearinghouse margin, and
business conduct requirements." Non-financial, commercial end-users of
swaps are not subject to entity-level regulation or the mandatory clearing
and trading requirement so long as they only use swaps to hedge
commercial risk. 93 All users of swaps are prohibited from engaging in fraud
or manipulative behavior.96
89 Further Definition of "Swap," "Security -Based Swap," and "Security -Based Swap
Agreement"; Mixed Swaps; Security -Based Swap Agreement Recordkeeping;, 77 Fed.
Reg. 48,208 (August 13, 2012).
99 CEA Section 2(h)(1XA). The CFTC, either upon application by a clearinghouse or
on its own initiative, may require a category of swaps to be cleared. CEA 2(hX2).
91 CEA Section 2(h)(8). See also Core Principles and Other Requirements for Swap
Execution Facilities, 78 Fed. Reg. 33476 (June 4, 2013),
httr./Avww.cftc.gov/ucm/groups/publici@lrfederalregister/documentsifile/2013-
12242a.pdf. 92 CEA Section 2(e).
" Further Definition of "Swap Dealer," "Security -Based Swap Dealer," "Major Swap
Participant," "Major Security -Based Swap Participant" and "Eligible Contract Participant;"
Final Rules, 77 Fed. Reg. 30,596 May 23, 2012).
91 76 Fed. Reg. 43,851 (July 22, 2011) (large trader reporting).
" CEA Section 2(hX7)(A), CFTC Rule 50.50. See also 77 Fed. Reg. 42,560, 42,590
(July 19, 2012). End-users must comply with certain reporting requirements. Id.
" Melissa Jurgens, Clearing Exemption for Swaps Between Certain Affiliated Entities,
17 CFR Part 50, RIN 3038-AD47 (April I, 2013)
http://www.cftc.gov/ucm/groups/publici@newsroom/documentsffile/federalregister040113.
pdf.
96 CFTC Regulations §180.1-180.2; see also 76 Fed. Reg. 41,398 (July 14, 2011).
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
As of March 2014, the CFTC has applied the clearing requirement to
standard interest rate swaps and certain index credit default swaps.97 This
determination was based on what swaps were actually being cleared by
clearing organizations. 98 In addition, the Treasury Department has
exempted certain physically settled foreign exchange swaps and forwards
from the clearing and trading mandate. This is because the physical
settlement risk associated with the contracts is well managed and they are
short-dated such that compliance with the mandate would not decrease
systemic risk.100 It is not clear what swaps the CFTC will determine qualify
for an exemption or will subject to mandatory clearing requirement in the
future. Uncleared swaps are still subject to mandatory margin requirements.
Not all swaps can be cleared in practical or economic sense. Swaps that are
capable of being cleared must possess a sufficient degree of standardization
and transaction volume.
Given the relatively recent adoption of Bitcoin and the alternatives to
swaps as a volatility reduction device (e.g. forwards), Bitcoin swaps are not
likely to be subject to the mandatory clearing requirement due to lacking
sufficient volume, though they will be uncleared and subject to the margin
requirements of uncleared swaps. The Tera Group swap described above
fits categorization as an uncleared swap. Nonetheless, Tera is reportedly
also seeking regulatory approval for swap that trades on its regulated swaps
execution facility, TeraExchange. 101 In addition, to the extent bitcoin swaps
are structured to resemble exempted foreign exchange swaps (or forwards),
they may likewise be exempted from mandatory clearing and trading.
The use of Bitcoin swaps by merchants is likely to fall under the
commercial end-user exception to mandatory clearing and trading. This is
because merchants would be entering into the swap to hedge the
commercial risk associated with accepting Bitcoin as a method of payment
just as they would be exposed to exchange-rate risk from selling products
overseas. The commercial end-user exemption may also apply to a wide
range of Bitcoin-related business, including those that are built on top of the
block chain.
97 Sauntia S. Warfield, Clearing Requirement Determination Under Section 2(h) of the
CEA, 17 CFR Parts 39 and 50, RIN 3038-AD86 (November 29, 2012)
httplAvww.cftc.gov/ucm/groups/publici@newsroom/documents/file/federalregister112812.
pdf.
99 Id. at 13.
" 77 Fed. Reg. 69,694 (Nov. 20, 2012).
'°° bi.
101 Nermin Hajdarbegovic, Tera Group Hopes to Offer First Bitcoin Swap, Coinbase,
March 25, 2014.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
4. Options
Option contracts are a fourth type of possible bitcoin derivative. A call
option gives the purchaser the right to purchase an asset at pre-specified
price and only has value if that price is below the market price. A put option
works the opposite way.1°2 A call option would enable a merchant selling in
Bitcoin denominated goods to be protected if the price increases. A Bitcoin
put option would protect against Bitcoin price declines by guaranteeing the
option to sell at a pre-specified price.
Options on commodities fall within the definition of "swap" under the
CEA.  Accordingly, options are generally regulated as swaps. K's However,
just as CFTC regulation does not reach forwards based largely on their
physical delivery of commodities, options that entail physical delivery are
likewise exempt from CFTC regulation, but only if they are traded between
entities that include financially sophisticated parties and commercial
users.105 Accordingly, bitcoin options used by qualifying entities would be
exempt from CFTC regulation because they would likely be structured to
involve physical delivery. This means that, as between a merchant and
another sophisticated party, the Bitcoin options being offered on Derivabit
would not be regulated as swaps because they are structured to result in
physical delivery of bitcoins if exercised by the option holder. 1°6 Ordinary
individuals would be prohibited from using Derivabit, however, unless it
registered and complied with the rules of a regulated trading venue open to
103 Hull, supra note 63, at 6.
103 7 U.S.C. a(47)(AXi). Definition of "swap" includes options on physical
commodities (whether or not traded on a DCM). CEA section la(47)(AXi), 7 U.S.C.
la(47)(AXi). The definition of swap excludes options on futures (which must be traded on
a DCM. CEA section la(47XBXi), 7 U.S.C. 1 a(47XBXi). Options on securities are
regulated by the securities laws.
10'1 Commodity Options, 77 Fed. Reg. 25320, 25325 (April 27, 2012), ("commodity
options will be permitted to transact subject to the same rules applicable to any other
swap"), 17 CFR Parts 3, 32, and 33, 77 F.R. 82 (April 27, 2012),
http ://lvww.c fie .gov/ucm/groups/publ id@lrfederalregister/documents/file/2012-9888a.pdf.
See also Commodity Options, Final Rule and Interim Final Rule, 77 Fed. Reg. 25320
(CFTC Apr. 27 2012) (regulating commodity options dealers).
Kis Commodity Options, 77 Fed. Reg. at 25326,
http :thvww.c fie .gov/ucm/groups/publ id@lrfederalregister/documents/fi le/20 I 2-9888a.pdf.
These exempt "trade options" are still subject to CFTC rules regarding recordkeeping,
reporting, anti -fraud, and anti -manipulation. Id. at 25326-25328. Other exempt commodity
options include those embedded in fonvard contracts. See CFTC Division of Market
Oversight Responds to Frequently Asked Questions Regarding Commodity Options,
(September 30, 2012)
https://forms.cfic.gov/ layouts/TradeOptions/DocsaradeOptionsFAQ.pdf.
1°6 Derivabit Guide, (stating that "underlying [Bitcoin] is fully available if the call
option holder chooses to exercise the option"), https://derivabit.com/guide.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
retail investor (e.g., a futures exchange). This is because in the hands of
ordinary investors the Bitcoin options would be viewed as swaps. However,
swaps are not permitted to be offered to such investors because they do not
qualify as eligible contract participants.
Finally, if Bitcoin is categorized as foreign exchange by the CFTC and
offered to retail investors, any foreign exchange futures, options, and
options on futures would require the retail investor's cotmteTarty to
register as a futures commission merchant or a retail forex dealer. l°
B. Bitcoin Securities
At the other end of the spectrum from those looking to hedge against
Bitcoin's volatility are those who want to speculate in the currency. It has
been argued that in some respects buying bitcoins is very much like buying
shares in a financial services startup. 108 If Bitcoin succeeds as an innovative
and low-cost payments system, then there will be much greater demand for
bitcoins, thus driving up the price. Chris Dixon, a partner at Andreessen
Horowitz, has suggested that bitcoins could someday be worth $100,000
each. IN  A research note from Bank of America reached a more conservative
price target of $1,300 by assuming that Bitcoin takes a 10% share of money
transfers and e-commerce transactions.' l° Another prospectus suggests that
if Bitcoin were to reach the scale of PayPal, which has been recently valued
at $22.8 billion, then that implies a valuation per bitcoin of $1,949. 111
To date, investing in Bitcoin has generally meant buying and holding
bitcoins, but for several reasons this is not ideal for investors. First,
acquiring bitcoins in large quantities at this early stage of the currency's
development can be technically daunting. Almost all bitcoin exchanges are
located outside the U.S. and are largely unregulated, which introduces
unnecessary counterparty risk. Second, much like gold, securely storing
1°717 C.F.R. 5.1, 5.3. 17 CFR 5, 76 F.R. 176 (September 12, 2011),
http://www.cftc.gov/LawRegulation/DoddFrankAct/Rulemakings/DF_20_FXSwaps/index.
htm.
In  Joe We isenthal, Why Bitcoin Has Value, Dec. 30, 2013,
http://www.businessinsider.com/why-bitcoin-has-value-2013-12; Stan Larimer, Bitcoin
and the Three Laws of Robotics, Let's Talk Bitcoin!, 2013,
http://letstalkbitcoin.com/bitcoin-and-the-three-laws-oGrobotics..
1°9 Robert McMillan, Silicon Valley VC Thinks a Single Bitcoin Will Be Worth
$100,000, Wired Magazine, January IS, 2014,
http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2014/0 1 /chrisdixon/.
11° David Woo, Ian Gordon, and Vadim laralov, Bitcoin: a first assessment, Bank of
America Merrill Lynch Research Report, December 5, 2013.
III  Bitcoin Investment Trust Investor Presentation, February 2014, Page 6,
http://www.bitcointrust.coNDeck.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
bitcoins can be a laborious affair with little room for error." 2 Standard
practice is to make several backup copies of the private keys that control the
bitcoins and then storing the hard drives containing them in safety deposit
boxes in different jurisdictions around the world. 113 As a result,
entrepreneurs have begun to develop instruments that allow investors to
more easily gain exposure to bitcoins.
1. Bitcoin Funds
SecondMarket, a registered broker-dealer that specializes in the trade of
private Silicon Valley startup shares, has developed the Bitcoin Investment
Trust (BIT), which is describes as "a private, open-ended trust that is
invested exclusively in bitcoin and derives its value solely from the price of
bitcoin." 114 According to its investor presentation, it is modeled on the
SPDR Gold ETF, but is a private fund open only to accredited investors." 8
The fund was seeded with a $2 million investment by SeconciMarket." 8
Meanwhile, Winklevoss Capital is seeking regulatory approval for an
exchange traded fund to invest in bitcoins." Such an ETF would be open
to any investor seeking exposure to bitcoins and would also have
advantages relative to trading bitcoins directly. 118 It could also benefit
111 Quentin Fottrell, To secure your bitcoins, print them out, Wall Street Journal
MarketWatch, February 26, 2014, httpi/www.markehvatch.comfstory/to-secure-your-
bitcoins-print-them-out-2014-02.26.
Ili  Noel Randewich and Julie Gordon, Bitcoin owners find safe place for digital
currency: on paper, Reuters, February 27, 2014,
http://www.reuters.com/article/20 I 4/02/28/us-bitcoin-mattress-
idUSBREAIROOP20140228. 114 Simon Foxman, Once again the Winklevoss twins get beaten launching their big
idea: a bitcoin trust, Quartz, September 26, 2013, http://qz.com/128442/once-again-the-
winklevoss-twins-get-beaten-to-launching-their-big-idea-a-bitcoin-trustt
115 Bitcoin Investment Trust Investor Presentation, February 2014,
http://www.bitcointrust.coNDeck. 116 Emily Spaven, SecondMarket launches Bitcoin Investment Trust, invests $2
million, CoinDesk, September 26, 2013, http://www.coindesk.com/secondmarket-
launches-bitcoin-investment-trust-invests-2-million/.
In  Registration Statement for the Winklevoss Bitcoin Trust, Amendment No. I to
Form S-I Registration Statement, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Registration
No. 333-189752 (October 8, 2013),
http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1579346/000119312513393903/d562329ds I a.htm
; Christopher Condon, Winklevosses' Lawyer in Talks with SEC Over Bitcoin ETF,
Bloomberg, February 2, 2014, http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014.01-30hvinklevosses-
lawyer-in-talks-with-sec-over-bitcoin-etfhtml
lig  Yulia Chernova, Winklevoss Twins Face Competition From SecondMarket's New
Bitcoin Trust, Wall Street Journal Venture Capital Blog, September 25, 2013,
http ://blogs.wsj.com/venturecapita1/2013/09/25/w ink levoss-tw ins-face-competition-from-
secondmarkets-new-bitcoin-trust/.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
Bitcoin by making price discovery much more efficient and transparent. 119
The Winklevoss Bitcoin ETF is structured as a New York common law
trust.120 The trust expects to sell shares to the public in reference to the price
of Bitcoins represented by each share and the market price of the shares. I2I
The trust is passively managed, directly holds bitcoins, and may issue
shares in exchange for a deposit of bitcoins or redeem investors' shares with
bitcoins. 122 The trust's aim is for its shares to achieve a weighted average
price of bitcoins minus fees.123 Its public disclosure document states that the
shares of the trust "are designed for investors seeking a cost-effective and
convenient means to gain exposure to Bitcoins with minimal credit risk." 124
Trusts are governed at the state level primarily by trust statutes and
common law. Because trusts that invest in Bitcoin raise funds by issuing
securities, they are also governed by state and federal securities laws. As an
issuer of securities, a Bitcoin trust is subject to the registration and
disclosure obligations of the Securities Act. If the securities are publicly
issued, the trust must file a publicly available registration statement
containing a prospectus that states basic information about the trust and its
investments and also audited financial statements. I25
An issuer can avoid the registration requirement by issuing the
securities privately. To qualify for a private offering, a trust may satisfy any
one of the private offering exemptions provided by the Securities Act. A
common exemption is provided by Rule 506 of Regulation D, which
requires the issuer to limit their investor base almost exclusively to wealthy,
"accredited" investors. 126 Although an offering pursuant to Rule 506 does
"9 1d
120 Registration Statement for the Winklevoss Bitcoin Trust, Form S-1 Registration
Statement, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Registration No. 333-0 (July
2013), S-1, at 1,
http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1579346/000119312513279830/d562329ds I.htm. 121 S-1, at i. 122 S-1, at 1. 123 S-1
at 1. 124 S-1, at 2. For other
purported benefits of the ETF see pages 37-39. Its 15 U.S.C. § 77e (prohibiting the sale of securities without filing a 
registration
statement); 15 U.S.C. § 77aa (listing schedule of information required in a registration
statement); Regulation C, 17 C.F.R. §§ 230.400 to 230.494 (stating general requirements
regarding preparation and filing of the registration statement); 15 U.S.C. § 77j
(information required in prospectus); Regulation S-K, 17 C.F.R. Part 229 (stating
requirements applicable to the content of the non-financial statement portions of
registration statements). 126 Rule 506 of Regulation D, 17 C.F.R. § 230.506 (2007). Accredited investors
include institutions with at least $5,000,000 in assets and natural persons whose net worth
(or whose joint net worth with a spouse) exceeds $1,000,000 or that have an annual income
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
not require the issuer to file a registration statement, to minimize liability
and satisfy investor demand, a private issuer will nonetheless disclose to
investors information of the type required to be in a registration statement.
Regardless of whether the trust issues its securities to the public or
privately to sophisticated investors, the trust is subject to Section 17(a) of
the Securities Act, which makes it unlawful for any issuer to make an
untrue statement of material fact or to omit any fact so as to make a
statement misleading. 127 Under Section 10(b) and Rule 10b-5 of the
Exchange Act, material omissions in connection with the sale of any
security are likewise prohibited. 128
Exchange -traded funds (ETFs) are typically structured as unit
investment trusts or open-end investment companies with shares that are
listed and traded on exchanges that are open to both retail and institutional
investors. 129 Like public company stock, ETF shares are usually traded
through a broker. I59 ETFs invest in, or track, the performance of a wide
variety of securities, commodities, and indices, and may actively or
passively managed. The potential benefits of ETFs to investors include
gaining access to wide range of investments and sectors through a liquid
instrument with low fees.' 1 ETFs have growth spectacularly in the past
decade and by year-end 2012 managed $1.3 trillion in assets. I32 ETF shares
trade at the market price and not at the fund's net asset value.
ETF shares are securities that must be registered under the Securities
Act and, because their shares are exchange -traded, ETFs must also comply
with the listing requirements of the Securities and Exchange Act of 1940.' 33
ETFs are also typically regulated under the Investment Company Act of
1940 because they invest in securities. To be eligible for offering and
trading, an ETF must obtain relief from several prohibitions of the
for the last two years of at least $200,000 (or $300,000 in joint spousal income). 17 C.F.R.
§ 230.50I(a). 127 15 U.S.C. § 77q(a). 128 15 U.S.C. § 78j; Rule 10b-5, 17 C.F.R. § 240.106-)29 ETFs must also meet 
exchange listing requirements and can
typically do so without
the exchange being required to obtain SEC approval. Exchange Act Rule 1913-4(e)
(permitting shares that meet generic exchange listing requirements to be listed without SEC
approval), Rule 19b-4. Unique ETFs may require an exchange filing a listing rule for SEC
approval. 130 ETFs also sell creation units to authorized participants. 131 Investment Company Institute, Investment 
Company Fact Book (53n' ed., 2013), ch.
3, http://www.icifactbook.org/1b_ch3.html. 132 Id.
133 15 U.S.C. 78a. When it comes to filing a registration statement disclosure, ETFs
registered under the Company Act must comply with Form N-1A and ETFs registered
under the Securities Act must comply with Form S-I.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
Investment Company Act and its regulations. 134 Among other effects,
obtaining relief allows an ETF to trade creation units with authorized
participants, have its shares traded on an exchange at market prices, delay
payment from share redemptions beyond seven days in some circumstances,
and purchase shares in other ETFs. Creating an ETF may take several
months to over a year to obtain the necessary regulatory approval.
Actively managed ETFs are permitted to use derivatives, but such use
must be subject to board review and approval and must be disclosed in a
manner consistent with SEC guidance. An ETF investing in futures must
be registered under the CEA as a commodity pool required to comply with
CFTC disclosure requirements. 136 Shares of the Winklevoss Bitcoin ETF
are registered under the Securities Act. However, because bitcoins are not
regulated as commodity futures or securities, the Winklevoss Bitcoin ETF is
not registered under the Company Act and is not a commodity pool under
the CEA. 137
Investment advisers (managers) to funds that invest in Bitcoin ETFs or
Bitcoin trusts are regulated by the SEC under the Investment Advisers Act
of 1940 (Advisers Act). 138 All U.S.-based managers of funds that invest in
securities must register under the Advisers Act, unless they fall within an
exemption, such as advising funds with less than $150 million in assets
under management or qualifying as a foreign private adviser. 139 Investment
134 Investment Company Act §§ 2(a)(32), 5(aX I) (requiring require shares of an open-
end fund to be redeemable daily); 22(d), 22c-I (requiring issuers to sell redeemable
securities only at the current offering price, and to redeem only at the current NAV); 22(e)
(prohibiting a fund from suspending the right of redemption, or postponing the date of
satisfaction of redemption requests for more than seven days), 17(a)(1), 17(aX2)
(prohibiting affiliated persons, principal underwriters or promoters of a fund (or affiliated
persons of such persons) from selling a security or other property to, or purchasing a
security or other property from, a fund); 12(d)(1) (limiting amount of shares that a
registered investment company may hold of another registered investment company, and
the amount of shares that one investment company may sell to another as an investment).
In  Elizabeth G. Osterman, Moratorium Lift, Securities and Exchange Commission
Office of Investment Company Regulation, December 6, 2012,
http lAvww.sec.govidivisions/investment/noaction/2012/moratorium-lift-120612-etf.pdf. 136 ETFs that invest in commodity 
futures are not required to register
with the CFTC as
a commodity pool operator if they are registered with the SEC as an Investment Company.
CFTC Regulation 4.5(a)(1),
httr./Avww.cftc.gov/IndustryOversight/Intermediaries/CPOsicpoctaexemptionsexclusions.
137 Registration Statement for the Winklevoss Bitcoin Trust, Form S-1 Registration
Statement, U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, Registration No. 333-(J (July I
2013), S-1, at 22-23 and 27,
httriAvww.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1579346/000119312513279830/d562329dsl.htm.
In  15 U.S.C. § 806-1 et seq.
139 Advisers Act §§ 80b-3(b), 80b-3(I), 80b-3(m); Exemptions for Advisers to Venture
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
advisers are subject to the provisions of the Advisers Act prohibiting
advisers from making any material misstatements, misleading omissions,
and other fraudulent statements to investors or prospective investors. 14°
These statements include statements regarding investment strategies,
experience and credentials, risks associated with the fund, or valuation of
the fund's assets. 141
The Advisers Act also requires registered managers to electronically file
and keep current Form ADV with the SEC.142 Part I of Form ADV requires
managers to disclose basic information relating to the firm and its business,
so as to assist regulators with oversight. Part 2 of Form ADV requires a
manager to disclose information relating to potential conflicts of interest
and other issues, including fees and how they are calculated, client referrals,
disciplinary history, and the manager's supervision of personnel. The
Advisers Act also requires hedge fund managers to keep specific business
and accounting records, to protect any client assets over which the fund has
legal custody, and ensure that their own personnel comply with federal
securities law and regulation. 143 Rule 206(4)-7 of the Advisers Act requires
fund managers to establish a compliance program that includes written
policies and procedures and a designated chief compliance officer. 144
2. Bitcoin Margin Trading
Related to securities, there have also been attempts to create platforms
that allow bitcoin margin trading. One of the earliest such platforms was
Bitcoinica, which offered contract-for-difference trading against the
Bitcoin/USD exchange rate starting in September of 2011. 145 Similar to
forex trading, Bitcoinica allowed customers to short sell within a chosen
leverage range. 146 For example, if a trader wanted to bet against Bitcoin, he
could essentially borrow bitcoins from Bitcoinica (in actuality, another
Capital Funds, Private Fund Advisers with Less Than $150 Million in Assets Under
Management, and Foreign Private Advisers, Investment Advisers Act Release No. 3111, 75
Fed. Reg. 77,190 (Nov. 19, 2010).
17 C.F.R. § 275.206(4)-(8)
la  Prohibition of Fraud by Advisers to Certain Pooled Investment Vehicles, 72 Fed.
Reg. 44756, 44759 (Aug. 9, 2007) (to be codified at 17 C.F.R. pt. 275).
142 17 C.F.R. §§ 275.203.1, 275.204-1.
143 SEC, STUDY ON INVESTMENT ADVISERS AND BROKER-DEALERS 32-34 (2011).
144 Compliance Programs of Investment Companies and Investment Advisers, Advisers
Act Release No. 2204, Investment Company Act Release No. 26,299, 68 Fed. Reg. 74714
(Dec. 24, 2003).
In  Jon Matonis, Bitcoinica Registers in New Zealand for Bitcoin Margin Trading,
Forbes, April 21, 2012, httplAvww.forbes.comisites/jonmatonis/2012/04/21/bitcoinica-
registers-in-new-zealand-for-bitcoin-margin-trading/. 146 Id.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
trader who wished to go long, but Bitcoinica was the ultimate counterparty)
and sell them. 14' If Bitcoin's price were to drop, the short-seller could close
out his position by buying back the borrowed bitcoins at a lower exchange
rate and thereby profit by pocketing the difference. Bitcoinica made its
profits by taking the spread between the traders it matched intemally. I45
Although Bitcoinica was registered as a financial services provider in
New Zealand, 149 it was also representative of the ambitious -but-shoestring
operations that dotted the early Bitcoin landscape. Founded by a 17-year-
old computer programmer in Singapore, Zhou Tong, Bitcoinica valued
expediency and experimentation over postponement and risk-aversion. I5°
The response from the Bitcoin community was initially quite enthusiastic.
According to Tong, Bitcoinica facilitated transactions of over 3,724 BTC
within the first 24 hours of operation. I5I Despite persistent security
issues, I52 Bitcoinica hosted an average monthly volume of roughly 1.2
million BTC at its peak. I53 Bitcoinica was not able to overcome the security
and trust issues that plagued it, however, and it went offline in May 2012
after hackers stole a reported 18,000 BTC from the exchange order fund.I54
The company entered into receivership in August 2012 and was liquidated
shortly thereafter. 155 Tong had by this point announced he was leaving the
147 This example was first outlined by a customer on the Bitcointalk forums and
approved by Zhou Tong as an accurate explanation of Bitcoinica operations. Note that this
example uses a 1:1 leverage spread for simplicity. Higher leverage spreads provide
opportunities for broader spreads and higher profits. The explanation also includes a
discussion of how short contracts worked on Bitcoinica. See: Mushoz, Bitcoinica: How It
Works, Bitcointalk.org forum post, December 29, 2011, accessed February 11, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=55970.msg665945ifinsg665945.
In  Jon Matonis, Bitcoinica Registers in New Zealand for Bitcoin Margin Trading,
Forbes, April 21, 2012, http://www.forbes.comisites/jonmatonis/2012/04/21/bitcoinica-
registers-in-new-zealand-for-bitcoin-margin-trading/.
Id.
15° Zhou Tong, Show HN: Bitcoinica - Advanced Bitcoin Trading Platform,
HackerNews forum post, September 8, 2011,
https://news.ycombinator.comatem?id=2973313. isi Zhou Tong, Bitcoinica — Advanced Bitcoin Trading Platform, 
Bitcointalk.org
forum post, September 9, 2011, accessed February II, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=42267.msg517128ifinsg517128.
152 Tim Worstall, Another Theft at Bitcoinica, Forbes Magazine, May 12, 2012,
http://www.forbes.comisitesitimworstall/2012/05/15/another-bitcoin-theft-at-bitconiat
153 Jon Matonis, Bitcoinica Registers in New Zealand for Bitcoin Margin Trading,
Forbes, April 21, 2012, http://www.forbes.comisites/jonmatonis/2012/04/21/bitcoinica-
registers-in-new-zealand-for-bitcoin-margin-trading/.
154 Zhou Tong, [Emergency ANN] Bitcoinica site is taken offline for security
investigation, Bitcointalk.org forum post, May I1, 2012, accessed February 11, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=81045.msg894277ifinsg894277.
155 Justin Porter, Tihan Seale Announces Bitcoinica Liquidation, Bitcoin Magazine,
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
Bitcoin space for good. 156
Today, new entrants are looking to offer similar platforms for margin
trading. The leading contender is probably Coinsetter, a New York City-
based startup that has generated much buzz after a successful $500,000
venture capital funding round in April of 2013.157 The company later filed
with the Securities and Exchange Commission plans to raise another $1.5
million in venture capita1.155 The Coinsetter platform today is only available
to beta testers, and while its full feature set is available to customers outside
the U.S., accounts for U.S. customers only accept Bitcoin deposits and
withdrawals, but not bank transfers.159 While still in limited use and early
development, Coinsetter aims to provide a liquid, trusted, and compliant
forex-like Bitcoin exchange to suit professional short-term traders. Mother
new entrant is Bitfinex, which emerged in late 2012 with a focus on security
and is registered as a Hong Kong limited liability corporation.169
The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Federal
Reserve) regulates the use of margin credit pursuant to its authority under

Section 7(a) of the Securities and Exchange Act.161 The Federal Reserve
promulgated Regulation T under that authority to prevent investors from
taking on too much credit when purchasing or holding securities.167
Regulation T establishes minimum margin requirements,163 but exchanges
August 2, 2012, http://bitcoinmagazine.com/1872/tihan-seale-announces-bitcoinica-
liquidation/.
156 Zhou Tong, I'm Leaving Bitcoin, Bitcointalk.org forum post, May 13, 2012,
accessed February 11, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=81581.msg897948ifinsg897948.
III  Rip Empson, Coinsetter Lands 5500K From SecondMarket Founder & Others to
Help Bring Leverage, Shorting To Trade Bitcoin, TechCrunch, April 9, 2013,
http://techcrunch.com/2013/04/09/coinsetter-lands-500k-from-secondmarket-founder-
others-to-help-bring-leverage-shorting-to-bitcoin-trade/
158 Ari Levy, Bitcoin Trading Exchange Coinsetter Files to Raise $1.5 Million,
Bloomberg, December 27, 2013, http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-12-27/bitcoin-
trading-exchange-coinsetter-files-to-raise-1-5-million.html.
" 9 Learn More, Coinsetter information page, accessed February 12, 2014,
https://www.coinsetter.com/beta
16° Unclescrooge, [OFFICIALIBitfinex.com first Bitcoin P2P lending platform for
leverage trading, Bitcointalk.org forum post, June 8, 2013, accessed February 11, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=229438.0; FAQ, Bitfinex.com, accessed February
II, 2014, https://www.bitfinex.com/pages/support.
161 15 U.S.C. § 78g(a). 161 Regulation T "imposes, among other things, obligations, initial margin
requirements, and payment rules on securities transactions." 12 C.F.R. 220.1(a).
163 12 C.F.R. 220.12(a) (limiting extension of credit to 50 percent of a security's
market value).
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
and other organizations may establish additional requirements. 164 Because
bitcoins are not securities, bitcoin margin trading platforms seem to fall
outside of the scope of the Securities Act and Regulation T. In addition, on
February 27, 2014, Federal Reserve Chairwoman Janet Yellen stated that
the Federal Reserve has no jurisdiction over Bitcoin, 165 implying it is
unlikely that it would assert authority over bitcoin margin trading without a
legislative directive.

C. Bitcoin-Denominated Instruments & Gambling
Separate and apart from derivatives and securities based on bitcoins are
derivatives and securities denominated in bitcoins. It may be hard to
believe, but there are today several unregulated exchanges actively trading
commodity futures contracts and company shares denominated in bitcoins.
These exchanges tend not to be registered with, nor regulated by, any
government agency. There are also unregulated prediction markets
operating today that denominate the price of event contracts in bitcoins.
These exchanges all seem to be operating under the theory that, because
they do not handle government -issued currencies, they are not subject to
regulation. Similarly, there are gambling sites online that denominate bets
in bitcoins and suggest that gambling laws do not apply to them.
In this section we will look at existing derivatives and securities being
offered that are denominated in bitcoins. Similarly, we'll look at event
contracts being offered denominated in bitcoins, as well as bitcoin gambling
sites. We conclude that while their regulation lie in a gray area, they are
generally subject to existing laws and regulation.
1. Bitcoin-Denominated Derivatives and Markets
As we have noted, there is a strong demand for instruments that allow
one to bet against the price of bitcoin. Ideally, such an instrument would be
a dollar/bitcoin currency swap, or a futures contract or option that could be
bought or sold for dollars. Such instruments will likely be available soon,
but not before their platform providers comply with regulatory requirements
as outlined in Part II.A, supra. Impatient with a slow regulatory process,
however, a wide array of startups have begun to offer bitcoin futures
contracts and options that are boned and sold not for dollars or any other
fiat currency, but for bitcoins. I  Indeed, many early experiments in
164 12 C.F.R. 220.1(bX2).
165 Sophie Knight & Takaya Yamaguchi, Japan Says Any Bitcoin Regulation Should
Be International, Feb. 27, 2014.
166 One way to bet against the price of Bitcoin is to borrow bitcoins, sell them, and
then later buy them back at a (hopefully) lower price. Services like Bitfinex offer this kind
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
providing bitcoin-denominated derivatives markets have already launched,
blossomed, and failed.167
One of the most prominent of the bitcoin-denominated futures markets
is ICBIT.se, which launched in January of 2012.168 In April of 2013, the
company reported a customer base of roughly 5,000 registered users and
around $50,000 in revenue per month.169 Users do not purchase options or
futures contracts from ICBIT itself but rather are matched with other buyers
or sellers who have an opposite and corresponding risk profile.170 ICBIT
therefore merely acts as a facilitator, rather than counterparty, of bitcoin-
denominated financial instruments. This business model is at odds with
traditional futures markets in which the exchange also performs the clearing
function. Customers are not given any information about the traders with
whom they are matched and many in the Bitcoin community have
speculated that ICBIT manipulates its central order book for the personal
interest of a small group of insiders.171
MPEx is another longstanding Bitcoin-denominated derivatives market
that has facilitated futures-like trading since 2011. Like ICBIT, MPEx has
of margin trading. Simone Foxman, Now to Short bitcoins 41 you really must), QUARTZ,
April 2, 2013, available at http://qz.com/69630/how-to-short-bitcoins-if-you-really-must.
Shorting the price of bitcoin in bitcoin-denominated contracts, however, is a bit
counterintuitive. Essentially one buys an option to sell an amount of bitcoins at a set dollar
price, but instead of taking dollars as settlement, one takes the bitcoin-equivalent of any
gains. One problem, of course, is that if one believes that the price of a bitcoin will be zero
in the future, then one will not be interested in such bitcoin-settled contracts. Stephen
Gandel, How to bet against the bitcoin megabubble, FORTUNE, Dec. 5, 2013, available at
http Iffinance.fortune.cnn.com/2013/12/05/betting-against-bitcoin-bubble.
167 This summary reviews some of the more successful (or infamous) forays into
Bitcoin futures trading. A considerable amount of over the counter Bitcoin futures trading
has also emerged in IRC chat rooms and TOR-Based connections. See: Bitcoin-otc wiki,
s.v. Beginner's Guide, accessed February 12, 2014, http://wiki.bitcoin-
otc.com/wiki/Beginners_Guide.
I" Fireball, ICBIT — New Exchange, Bitcointalk.org forum post, January 21, 2012,
accessed February 11, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=60548.msg705207iimsg705207
169 Cyrus Farviar, 'Taming the Bubble': investors bet on Bitcoin via derivatives
markets, Ars Technica, April II, 2013, http://arstechnica.com/business/2013/04/taming-
the-bubble-investors-bet-on-bitcoin-via-derivatives-marketst
Im The ICBIT.se website FAQ directs to a Bitcointalk forum post. See: Super T,
•Unofficial• ICBIT (BTC Futures Trading) — Help & FAQ's, Bitcointalk.org forum post,
April 1, 2013, accessed February 11, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=l64255.0.t
In  Greg Mulhauser, Bitcoin Derivatives, Liquidity and Counterparty Risk,
Psychological Investor blog, May 29, 2013, http://psychologicalinvestoncorn/libireal-
markets/bitcoin-derivatives-liquidity-counterparty-risk-134/.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
been dogged by rumors and complaints from disgruntled customers.172
Others, however, raise MPEx for its simple but elegant execution and
long-term vision.1 3 MPEx is considerably less user-friendly than other
existing Bitcoin derivatives markets. Indeed, the creator intentionally
designed the platform to weed out novice investors and foster a higher-
caliber exchange community.174 The website is sparse and users must
interact with the service through an embedded command line terminal.I75
MPEx provides a stripped-down platform for buyers and sellers to discover
each other and trade options. Customers pay a fee to register an MPEx
account that is linked with the public keys of their Bitcoin wallets. Upon
registration, buyers and sellers can then direct the program to withdraw
money from their Bitcoin wallet into the MPEx exchange address from
which they can then issue orders.I76 Similarly, users can deposit their MPEx
earnings back into their personal Bitcoin wallets, send bitcoins to another
MPEx account, execute call and put orders, buy on margin, and execute
batch contracts.I77 MPEx does not appear to be incorporated or registered
with any regulatory body, but it does provide several hypothetical escape
plans in the event of a take down on their website FAQ.17
There is also Singapore-based BTC.sx, which does not offer derivatives
per se, but is rather a bitcoin-denominated margin trading platform. It was
launched in private beta in April of 2013 and full operation in June of
2013.179 Users can deposit bitcoins to a wallet created by BTC.sx and can
then speculate on Bitcoin price movements by opening long or short
positions for varying lengths of time.180 For each open position taken, users
173 The operator responds to these criticisms on his personal blog. See: Mircea
Popescu, Because most people are idiots, in spite of never manning up and admitting to it,
Trilema blog, February 5, 2013, accessed February II, 2014,
http ://tri lema.com/20I3/because-most-people-are- idiots- in-spite -of-never -manning -up-and-
admitting -to-it/ 173 A Review of MPEx, the Bitcoin Stock Exchange, Loper OS blog, February 3, 2013,
accessed February 11, 2014, http://www.loper-os.org/?p=1108. 174 Mircea Popescu, So what's the plan with MPOE/MPEx?, 
Trilema blog, February 3,
2013, accessed February II, 2014, http://trilema.com/2013/so-whats-the-plan-with-
mpoempext
"5  MPEx, English FAQ, accessed February 11, 2014, http://mpex.co/faq.html
"6  a
"7  Id. MPEx also allows stock offerings and dividend payments. This function is
discussed in more depth in the section on stock markets.
"8  a
"9  Seal, [ANN] BTC.sx — Leveraged trading made easy, Bitcointalk.org forum post,
April 27, 2013, accessed March 26, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=188735.msg1955964Nmsg1955964
II° Danny Bradbury, BTC.SX revives bitcoin margin trades, CoinDesk, May 23, 2013,
http://wvirw.coindesk.com/btc-sx-revives-bitcoin-margin-trades/
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
must hold deposits equal to the size of the trade multiplied by the price and
multiplied by a measure of current market volatility.181 This allows the
BTC.sx platform to leverage each position at 100 times the value of the bet,
allowing investors a broader possible return on each investment.182 BTC.sx
has proven popular and relatively successful during its short year of
operation. By November of 2013, BTC.sx surpassed $13.5 million in
margin trading since May of 2013183 and reported 2,000 registered users!"
By January of 2014, BTC.sx reported $35 million in total trading since its
launch and an active user base of 3,300 traders.'"
These Bitcoin derivatives contracts and platforms likely do not fall
under the scope of CFTC regulation. First, their contracts more closely
resemble unregulated, off-exchange forwards and not regulated exchange-
traded futures. This is primarily because the derivatives contracts are
intended to be settled "physically" with bitcoins, and not their cash
equivalent. ICBIT.se states its BTC/USD-4.I4 contract is "Settled in BTC,
quoted in USDs186 and explains that for a party using their platform to short
Bitcoin against the dollar, "if rate goes down he would get as many Bitcoins
as it's needed to buy $6000 on the spot market.s187 Likewise, the settlement
term for MPEx's X.Eur contract contemplates physical delivery of bitcoins
and not cash.188 In addition, the Bitcoin derivatives platforms do not also
in  FAQ, BTC.sx support, accessed March 26, 2014, https://btc.sx/about/faq.
"1  For example, let's say a user wanted to bet 1/100th of a Bitcoin that the price of
Bitcoin will increase over the next day. To take this position, the user must have the proper
deposit amount in their BTC.sx wallet to cover the trade. Let's say this deposit amount is
1.5 BTC in this example. The user communicates to BTC.sx that she wants to bet 0.01
BTC on this position and BTC.sx places I BTC, or 100 times the position, on this bet. If
the user wins the bet, she will make a handsome profit because most of her earnings are
based on BTC.sx's IBTC bet rather than her 0.01 BTC bet. If, the other hand, the user
loses the bet, her losses will be liquidated from her 1.5 BTC deposit. This allows both
BTC.sx and each user to minimize risk with deposit insurance while increasing possible
returns with margin trading. See: Joe Lee, Bitcoin Trading Platform BTC.sx Launches
Private Beta: Offering Long and Short Leveraged Bitcoin Position Trading, PRNewswire,
May 15, 2013, http://www.pmewswire.com/news-releases/bitcoin-tradingplatform-btcsx-
launches-private-beta-offering-long-and-short-leveraged-bitcoin-position-trading-
20755669 I .html.
"3  Daniel Cawrey, Bitcoin Derivatives Platform BTC.sx Surpasses $13.5m in Trades,
CoinDesk, November 25, 2013, http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-derivativesplatform-
btc-sx-trades/.
'" ld
In  George Samman, The World's First Bitcoin Derivatives Platform Surpasses
US$35M in Trades, PRWeb, January 21, 2014,
http://www.pnveb.com/releases/Bitcoinarading/pnveb I 1494016.htm.
IR6 See https://icbit.se/BUJ4. III7 About ICBIT Derivatives Market, https://icbit.se/futures.
INS See http://mpex.co/?mpsic=X.EUR ("intends to market make an Euro based Bitcoin
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
serve as a clearinghouse for their customers' trades, which is an essential
aspect of a futures exchange. On the other hand, there is no bright line
between forwards and futures. The contracts being offered by the platforms
are highly standardized and being offered as "futures," which weigh in
favor of them being treated as regulated futures.
2. Bitcoin-Denominated Securities and Exchanges
In addition to online markets facilitating the trade of bitcoin-
denominated derivatives, there are sites online that essentially serve as
exchanges for shares of stock denominated in bitcoin. Unable or unwilling
to make use of traditional capital markets, a small but growing number of
entrepreneurs turn to these exchanges to raise capital and sell stock in their
companies for bitcoins. The companies and funds listed on these exchanges
tend to be Bitcoin-related concerns, such as mining equipment
manufacturers, but also include Bitcoin-denominated gambling sites like
Satoshi Dice189 and BitBet.190
Bitcoin-denominated stock exchanges have been plagued by frequent
scams in which the underlying company or concern is a hoax, and there has
been seemingly little recourse for investors.191 Nevertheless, they have
proven to be a useful way to fundraise small amounts of capital for
interesting projects. They do not seem, however, to be in compliance with
securities and exchange regulations. As Bitcoin expands in popularity, it is
possible that these stock markets will mature and flourish if supported by an
appropriate legal framework.
The now defunct Global Bitcoin Stock Exchange (GLBSE) is one of the
earliest known Bitcoin-denominated stock markets. Founded in the summer
of 2011, its debut serendipitously coincided with an early burst of interest in
the Bitcoin project.192 The original GLBSE service was quite basic and
future with physical delivery for the foreseeable future ").
I"  In March of 2014, the SEC opened an investigation into SatoshiDice and MPEx for
possible violations of US securities law. See: Jon Southurst, SEC Making Inquiries Into
MPEx, SatoshiDice, CoinDesk, March 20, 2014, http://www.coindesk.com/sec-making-
inquiries-mpex-satoshidicet
19° Mircea Popescu, How does one list on MPEx?, Trilema, October 3, 2012,
http://trilema.com/2012/how-does-one-list•on-mpext 191 Olivia Solon, Founder reflects on the closure of Bitcoin stock 
exchange GLBSE,
Wired UK, October 13, 2013, http://www.wired.co.uldnews/archive/2013-10/24/bitcoin-
exchange-collapseilbse.
191 For frame of reference, GLBSE was founded at around the same time that the
infamous 10,000 BTC pizza was purchased. See: Vitalik Buterin, Interview With GLBSE's
James McCarthy/Nefario, Bitcoin Magazine, October 15, 2012,
http://bitcoinmagazine.com/2578/interview-witlyslbses-nefario/.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
customers used a command line terminal interface to browse listings and
buy or sell shares. 193 Entrepreneurs could list their company on GLBSE for
a registration fee and allow investors to purchase and trade shares. Listed
companies could opt to pay dividends to shareholders or buy back shares at
a later date.
Shareholders had no guarantees that their investments would be honored
and were entirely at the mercy of share issuers. Too often, share issuers did
not honor their commitments. This was the case with GLBSE's first
successfully facilitated IPO. The company behind the IPO, Ubitex, secured
an impressive 1,100 BTC, or roughly $10,000, in investments before its
owner disappeared without a trace a few months later.194 Another major
player in GLBSE, Lambert Investment Funds, I95 also suddenly pulled itself
from the GLBSE directory after several of its investments were revealed to
be illusory. I96
Despite these setbacks, companies and investors continued to trade
shares on GLBSE. An updated version of the GLBSE website introduced
enhanced identification and authentication options to increase user trust and
company accountability. 197 During May of 2012, GLBSE listed 10 major
stocks valued at a sum of over $650,000. 198
The saga of a high-yield investment scheme known as Bitcoin Savings
and Trust (BTCST) foreshadowed GLBSE's demise. It was a high-yield
investment scheme that was traded on the GLBSE exchange platform from
November 2011 to August 2012. BTCST was a popular listing on
193 GLBSE later offered a user-friendly interface and enhanced features to expand
functionality and increase its customer base. Nefario, GLBSE 2.0 open for testing,
Bitcointalk.org forum post, January 21, 2012, accessed February 17, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=60489.0.
194 Vitalik Buterin, Interview With GLBSE's James McCarthy/Nefario, Bitcoin
Magazine, October 15, 2012, http://bitcoinmagazine.com/2578/interview-with-glbses-
nefariot 195 Lambert Investment Funds was not a company, but an investment fund that was
also traded on GLBSE. See: Peter Lambert, GLBSE:LIF, Bitcointalk.org forum thread,
August 5, 2011, accessed February 17, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=34634.
196 The LIF operator, Peter Lambert, did offer to buy back shares at a lower rate, but
many investors felt defrauded by his handling of the affair. See: Peter Lambert, [was on
GLBSE] LIF.x, Bitcointalk.org forum thread, January 17, 2012, accessed February 17,
2014, https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=35775.msg698197Nmsg698197
197 Vitalik Buterin, Global Bitcoin Stock Exchange Shuts Down for Good, Bitcoin
Magazine, October 10, 2012, http://bitcoinmagazine.com/2549/global-bitcoin-stock-
exchange-shuts-down-for-good/.
199 GLBSE Valuations, The Bitcoin Trader Blog, May 13, 2012,
httriAvww.thebitcointrader.com/searchilabel/GLBSE.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
GLBSE, 199 and it promised investors returns of up to 1% per day, or 7% per
week 200 Its manager, a Texas man called Trendon Shavers but known
online as "Pirateat40," explained that he was in the business of "selling
BTC to a group of local people" and that bitcoins deposited with him would
be used in an arbitrage scheme. 201 At its peak, the scheme had attracted
investments of about $7 million, according to Shavers." 2
On July 23, 2013, the SEC filed a complaint against Shavers and
Bitcoin Savings and Trust, alleging that BTCST was a Ponzi scheme, 203
contrary to Shavers' many assurances to his customers that BTCST was a
legitimate operation. 2°4 "In reality," the SEC alleged, "the BTCST offering
was a sham and a Ponzi scheme whereby Shavers used new BTCST
investors' BTC to pay the promised returns on outstanding BTCST
investments and misappropriated BTCST investors' BTC for his personal
use.',zos Shavers moved to dismiss the SEC's complaint, arguing that
BTCST investments did not qualify as securities because "Bitcoin is not
money, and is not party of anything regulated by the United States.s 206
Since no legal tender ever changed hands, Shavers argued, the investments
were not securities and the SEC had no jurisdiction over his investment
scheme.
In denying Shavers's motion to dismiss, the court applied the now-
classic Howey test, which finds that an instrument is an "investment
contract" under the Securities Act if the instrument is (1) the investment of
money; (2) in a common enterprise; (3) with the expectation of profits
derived solely from the efforts of others. 207 Under this test, a wide variety of
investments have found to be securities2 08 Shavers argued that the first
l" Adrianne Jeffries, Suspected Multi-Million Dollar Bitcoin Pyramid Scheme Shuts
Down, Investors Revolt, The Verge, August 27, 2012,
http://lvww.theverge.com/2012/8/27/3271637/bitcoin-savings-trust-pyramid-scheme-shuts-
down
2.0  Securities and Exchange Commission v. Shaven, No. 4:13-CV-416 (E.D. Tex.
Aug. 6, 2013), https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/2013/comp-pr2013.I32.pdf. 201 Id.
2" Vitalik Buterin, The Pirate Saga: And So It Ends, Bitcoin Magazine, August 30,
2012, http:/Ibitcoinmagazine.com/2I 26/the-pirate-saga-and-so-it-ends/.
207 Securities and Exchange Commission v. Shaven, No. 4:13 -CV-416 (E.D. Tex.
Aug. 6, 2013).
Trendon Shaven, If my business is illegal then anyone trading coins for cash and
back to coins is doing something illegal. :), Bitcointalk.org forum post, January 19, 2012,
accessed March 24, 2014, https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=50822.385;wap2.
2°5Securities and Exchange Commission v. Shavers, No. 4:13 -CV-416 (E.D. Tex. Aug.
6, 2013).
2°6 Id.
207 SEC v. W.J. Howey Co., 328 U.S. 293, 298-99 (1946).
2"  For example, the First Circuit held that virtual shares in imaginary companies sold
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
prong of the test failed because Bitcoin was not money 209 The court,
however, disagreed finding that Bitcoin qualified as money:
It is clear that Bitcoin can be used as money. It can be used to purchase
goods or services, and as Shavers stated, used to pay for individual living
expenses. The only limitation of Bitcoin is that it is limited to those places
that accept it as currency. However, it can also be exchanged for
conventional currencies, such as the U.S. dollar, Euro, Yen, and Yuan.
Therefore, Bitcoin is a currency or form of money, and investors wishing to
invest in BTCST provided an investment of money.210
The court also found that BTCST met the other prongs of the Howey
test and therefore "the BTCST investments [met] the definition of
investment contract, and as such, are securities."21I If the Shavers case is
any guide, then issuers and exchanges will not be able to escape SEC
regulation by merely denominating securities in bitcoin.2 I2
Around the same time, GLBSE operator James McCarthy213 sought
legal counsel to ensure compliance with existing regulations as his side
project grew into a going concem.214 After his lawyers convinced him that
GLBSE ran afoul of existing anti-money laundering and know your
customer rules, McCarthy abruptly shut the exchange for good on October
4, 2012.215 McCarthy attempted to ensure the return of investor funds, but
some customers nevertheless likely lost investments.216 Like so many other
in dollars on a virtual exchange as part of a video game were "investment contracts"
subject to securities regulation. SEC v. SG Ltd., 265 F.3d 42, 48 (1st Cir. 2001) (holding
that virtual shares of stock, offered as part of a game by a foreign entity operating a virtual
stock exchange qualified as SEC-regulated investment contracts). For an account of a
virtual stock market, see Robert J. Bloomfield and Young Jun Cho (2011) Unregulated
Stock Markets in Second Life. Southem Economic Journal: July 2011, Vol. 78, No. 1, pp.
6.29.
2"  Securities and Exchange Commission v. Shavers, No. 4:13-CV-416 (E.D. Tex.
Aug. 6, 2013). 210 a
211 Id. 212 Craig K. Ellwell, M. Maureen Murphy, and Michael V. Seitzinger, Bitcoin:
Questions, Answers, and Analysis of Legal Issues, Congressional Research Service Report
No. 7-5700, December 20, 2013, http://www.fas.org/sgp/crsimisc/R43339.pdf 213 James McCarthy did not fully control 
GLBSE. Rather, GLBSE was owned by a
parent company, Bitcoin Global, which is itself a multi -shareholder enterprise. For details,
see: theymos, Nefario, Bitcointalk.org forum post, October 6, 2012, accessed February 17,
2014, https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=115669.0. 214 Vitalik Buterin, Global Bitcoin Stock Exchange Shuts Down 
for Good, Bitcoin
Magazine, October 10, 2012, http://bitcoinmagazine.com/2549/global-bitcoin-stock-
exchange-shuts-down-for-good/.
215 Id. 216 McCarthy estimates that 95% of GLBSE customers were compensated. See Olivia
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
first wave Bitcoin businesses, GLBSE was conceived at a time when
Bitcoin was largely a hobby or seen as a fantasy. McCarthy saw GLBSE as
a fun side project experimenting with what was essentially play money.2t7
By the time McCarthy realized that GLBSE could be a legitimate business,
it was too late to become regulatorily compliant.
A few other Bitcoin stock market exchanges have been launched
and shut down. BitFunder was launched in December of 2012 and allowed
listed assets to be bought and sold using bitcoins. 218 Founded in the wake of
GLBSE's closing, BitFunder aimed to provide easy integration for GLBSE
customers to begin trading on the new platform. A few companies, like the
mining ventures ASICMiner and IceDrill, successfully raised capital by
selling shares on BitFunder. 219 Users could search for shares of companies
and issue bids for buying or selling. Assets were publicly listed by Bitcoin
address so that shareholders and managers could more easily reconnect in
the case of an exchange shutdown. The founder of BitFunder designed the
exchange with the lessons of GLBSE in mind.220 Indeed, BitFunder's
creator was acutely cognizant of the legal challenges his exchange faced
from the day he first announced the project. 22I Fearing SEC investigation
following the BTCST takedown, 222 BitFunder announced that it would no
longer do business with U.S. customers in October of 2013 and encouraged
U.S. customers to move their funds out of the website by December 1 of
that year.223 (It is not clear where BitFunder was based.) By November 4,
2013, BitFunder announced that it was closing for good and announced a
plan for reimbursing shareholders and listed companies. 224
Solon, Founder Reflects on the Closure of Bitcoin Stock Exchange GLBSE, Wired UK,
October 13, 2013, http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/20I3.10/24/bitcoin-exchange-
collapse-glbse
' I' Id.
21° Ulcyo, [BitFunder] Asset Exchange Marketplace + Rewritable Options Trading,
Bitcointalk.org forum post, December 10, 2012, accessed February IS, 2014,
https.://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=130117.0. 219 Kadhim Shubber, Bitcoin stock exchange BitFunder announces 
closure, CoinDesk,
November 12, 2013, http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-stock-exchange-bitftmder-
announces-closure/.
22° Ukyo, Re: [BitFunder] Asset Exchange Marketplace - Official Launch,
Bitcointalk.org forum post, December II 2012, accessed February 18, 2014,
httpsipbitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=130117.msg I 393343Nmsg1393343.
' 1 Id.
222 Investor Alert: Ponzi Schemes Using Virtual Currencies, 7 SEC Pub. 153 (July 23,
20131, http://investor.gov/sites/defaultffiles/ia_virtualcurrencies.pdf.
243 Kadhim Shubber, Bitcoin stock exchange BitFunder announces closure, CoinDesk,
November 12, 2013, http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-stock-exchange-biffimder-
announces-closure/
224 Ukyo, Re: [BitFunder] Asset Exchange Marketplace - Official Launch,
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
Similarly, BTC-TC was another bitcoin-denominated stock market
that rose to popularity after GLBSE's demise. At its peak, BTC-TC listed
39 different assets —including stocks, bonds, futures, and investment
funds—and facilitated roughly $350,000 in daily activity. 225 The
exchange's most popular assets were mining companies like ASICMiner
and LabCoin. At the time of its shutdown, BTC-TC listed assets were
valued at an estimated $15 million. 228 Like BitFunder, BTC-TC prioritized
information transparency and provided asset issuers with complete lists of
shareholder email addresses and share counts to facilitate reconnecting in
the event of an exchange shutdown. 227 BTC-TC prided itself on being
"community operated," asset "approval and scoring" was done by
community moderators that were linked to the founder's Litecoin stock
market exchange, LTC-GLOBAL. 228 BTC-TC also emphasized its legal
registration in Belize as an international company. 229 Still, the website's
own FAQ recognized its questionable legal status, advising customers:
Is it legal for this exchange to operate?
Most countries require real securities exchanges to register and abide by a
very strict set of rules. Obviously we do not have the funding to afford such
registration or the overhead of administering such rules. In addition, no single
country would allow such an exchange to operate globally. As such we have
taken the following approach to the operation of the site:
- No assets on the site are to be considered real.
- Nothing is verified. (Do your research!)
- The use of this site is for educational and entertainment purposes only.
- If an asset issuer on this site defaults, you have ZERO RECOURSE a cnot
like you have any recourse in most international BTC situations anyway.)
This scant legal cover proved inadequate to protect BTC-TC and the
exchange shut down in September of 2013, citing regulatory concems. 23I
Bitcointalk.org forum post, November 4, 2013, accessed February 18, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=130117.msg3482565#msg3482565 225 Jonathan Stacke, Bitcoin Securities Exchange 
BTC-TC Shutters SI 2M Operations,
Cites Regulatory Environment, The Genesis Block, September 23, 2013,
http://thegenesisblock.com/btc-trading-corp-shutters-operations-cites-regulatory-
environment/.
226 a
227 Why BTC-TC Rocks, FAQ, accessed March 26, 2014, https://btct.cot
228 Deprived, Re: [BTCTC] BTC Trading Corp. — All new virtual exchange up at
https://btct.car, Bitcointalk.org forum post, November 19, 2012, accessed February 18,
2014, https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=125629.msg1346121#msg1346121.
229 Why BTC-TC Rocks, FAQ, accessed March 26, 2014, https://btct.cot
23° Why BTC-TC Rocks, FAQ, accessed March 26, 2014, https://btct.co/faq. 231 Jonathan Stacke, Bitcoin Securities 
Exchange BTC-TC Shutters SI 2M Operations,
Cites Regulatory Environment, The Genesis Block, September 23, 2013,
http://thegenesisblock.com/btc-trading-corp-shutters-operations-cites-regulatory-
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
As with BitFunder, BTC-TC outlined a closing plan for issuers and
shareholders to settle or reconcile outstanding balances. 232
A derivatives exchange mentioned earlier, MPEx, also provides Bitcoin-
denominated stock market listings. MPEx extends its strategy of
discouraging novices by employing the same command line method used by
its broader derivatives and options exchange. 233 As with MPEx futures
trading, users must pay an upfront registration fee and a small percent
commission on trades. 234 MPEx currently lists four companies selling
shares, including MPEx itself.235 Each listing has a dedicated page where
prices, trades, and dividend payments are displayed along with a "listing
agreement" drafted by each company operator that serves as an informal
memorandum of understanding between the company and the MPEx
exchange. 236 The operator of MPEx even provides periodic shareholder
reports in the popular Bitcointalk forums237 and his own personal blog.235
The popular gambling site, Satoshi Dice, sold shares of the company on
MPEx from April of 2012 until July of 2013.239 While still small, MPEx
stock trading continues to gamer investment and interest.
In March of 2014, the SEC sent a letter to MPEx's Romanian
proprietor, Mircea Popescu, asking for contracts and other documents
relating to the SatoshiDice.com offering. 240 Popescu, who posted his
environment/.
231Id. 233 A Review of MPEx, the Bitcoin Stock Exchange, Loper OS blog, February 3, 2013,
accessed February 11, 2014, http://v.rww.loper-os.orgfip=1108. 234 As of February 2013, MPEx garnered 2/3 of its profits
from registration fees. Id.
235 http://mpex.co/, accessed March 26, 2014.
236 See, for instance, the listing agreement for BitBet: http://mpex.co/?mpsic=S.BBET,
accessed March 26, 2014.
237 MPOE-PR, Re: Investing in Mircea Popescu's Options Emporium, Bitcointalk.org
forum post, September 29, 2012, accessed February IS, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=64962.msg I 230084#msg1230084; and
238 Mircea Popescu, Six Month MPOE Financial Results, February 20, 2012, accessed
February 18, 2014, http://trilema.com/2012/sa-ne-jucam-de-a-investitiile-n-
bitcoini/ficomment-78745.
239 After being sold to a private third party for $11.5 million, Satoshi Dice de-listed
itself from MPEx and paid S.DICE shareholders 0.0035 BTC per share. See: Eric Vorhees,
[CLOSED] S.DICE - SatoshiDlCE 100% Dividend-Paying Asset on MPEx,
Bitcointalk.org forum post, August 20 2012, accessed February 18, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=101902.0; and Emily Spaven, Bitcoin company
acquisitions begin: Gambling site SatoshiDice sells for $11.5m, CoinDesk, July IS, 2013,
http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-company-acquisitions-begin-gambling-site-satoshidice-
sells-for-11-5m-126315-btct
24° Carter Doughtery, Gambling Website's Bitcoin-Denominated Stock Draws SEC
Inquiry, Bloomberg, March 20, 2014, http:/Avww.bloomberg.com/news/2014-03-
19/gambling-website-s-bitcoin-denominated-stock-draws-sec-inquiry.html.; Daphna A.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
correspondence with the SEC on his blog, responded by questioning the
SEC's jurisdiction over his business and its authority to make any
requests.24I
3. Regulating Bitcoin-Denominated Transactions
Given the broad definition of "commodity" and "security," it seems
likely that regulators will assert jurisdiction over any transaction involving
bitcoins that is structured in a manner that even resembles that of a
regulated financial instrument. Accordingly, a transaction for future
delivery of bitcoins, or that exchanges bitcoin-related payments, would
likely fall under the CFTC's jurisdiction to regulate Bitcoin futures and
Bitcoin swaps, subject to the limitations on regulation for transactions that
are physically settled or not capable of being cleared. 242 Similarly, any
investment in bitcoins that takes place through a contract that satisfies the
broadly defined characteristics of an "investment contract" will fall under
jurisdiction of the SEC. Indeed, as the decision in Shavers strongly
suggests, even if the instrument is Bitcoin-denominated, regulators are
likely to assert jurisdiction just as they would over a transaction
denominated in legal tender. Accordingly, parties that enter into Bitcoin-
denominated transactions, and venues that trade Bitcoin-denominated
instruments, will be regulated by an appropriate regulator.
Nonetheless, financial regulators should consider whether and to what
extent existing financial regulation should apply to certain financial
transactions involving Bitcoin. In particular, regulators should reconsider
bringing the full scope of its regulation to a transaction that involves a
Bitcoin-denominated instrument whose underlying is also Bitcoin-
denominated, which we can call Bitcoin-universe transactions. An example
of a Bitcoin-universe transaction would be a Bitcoin-denominated credit
default swap that references a Bitcoin-denominated loan.
One approach for regulators would be to completely exclude Bitcoin-
universe transactions from regulation, just as forwards and private
investment funds are excluded from the CEA and the Company Act,
respectively. Another approach would be exempt Bitcoin-universe
transactions from most applicable regulation, while still imposing
requirements and prohibitions relating to recordkeeping, reporting, and
fraud. The latter approach would be similar to how private company
Waxman, SEC Letter to Mircea Popescu in Re: SatoshiDICE (NY -8954), March 3, 2014,
http://trilema.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/2014-0303-popescu-mpex.pdf. 24I Mircea Popescu, Interacting with fiat 
institution: a guide, Trilema, March 18,
2014,
http://trilema.com/2014/interacting-with-fiat-institution-a-guidet
241 See supra Section II.A.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
securities and commodity trade options are regulated.
Regulators should reconsider a wide-ranging regime of regulation for
Bitcoin-universe transactions because such transactions do not implicate the
traditional policy goals of financial regulation. The purpose of financial
regulation is to protect the users of financial instruments from fraud,
manipulation, and other types of misconduct that results in real economic
losses. Although Bitcoin universe transactions could lead to economic
losses, the extent to which, if any, may be highly remote and contingent. It
would depend on the value of Bitcoin relative to a fiat currency, the
willingness of merchants and other users to accept Bitcoin as a method of
payment, and the extent to which Bitcoin is used for functions beyond a
payment system. 243 Whether a bitcoin loss leads to real economic loss also
depends on whether a party actually converts their bitcoins to real currency
or property, something that should not be taken for granted. Bitcoin-
universe transactions may leave parties with less bitcoins, but so does an
ordinary direct transfer of bitcoins between wallets or paying a fee to use a
Bitcoin service such as a storage service —neither of which would fall under
the purview of the CFTC or SEC. By treating Bitcoin-universe as no
different from traditional financial instruments that may result in a loss in
real wealth, regulators would implicitly be permitting form to triumph over
substance.
The following chart displays the unique nature of Bitcoin-universe
transactions. It distinguishes a transaction based upon whether the
underlying interest is virtual or real and whether the transaction is
denominated in real or virtual currency:
Real Underlying Virtual Underlying
Denominated
in Real
Currency
Traditional Securities,
Futures, Swaps, Options
Securities investing in
Bitcoin; Futures, Swaps,
and Options on Bitcoin
It citominated
in Virtual
Currency
Bitcoin-denominated
Securities, Futures, Swaps,
Options
Bitcoin-universe
transactions
Figure 2 — "Rea " vs. "Virtual" framework
.1'41
See infra Section III.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
There is already legal precedent for treating Bitcoin-universe
transactions differently. Despite the court's opinion in Shavers, the
approach taken by FinCEN—the federal regulator of money services
business—provides grounds for not regulating or granting an exemption for
Bitcoin-universe transactions. FinCEN defines a virtual currency as a
currency that operates like a currency in some environments, but does not
have all the attributes of real currency.244 It further distinguishes convertible
virtual currency as a virtual currency that either has an equivalent value in
real currency or acts as a substitute for real currency.24 Under FinCEN
regulation of money service businesses, only companies that transmit
convertible virtual currencies or exchange convertible virtual currencies into
real ones are subject to regulation.246 Bitcoin miners and those that trade
convertible virtual currencies for their own investment purposes are not
regulated.247 This approach suggests that transactions that "stay" within the
bitcoin economy—which would include Bitcoin-universe transactions—are
unique and should not be subject to the same level of regulation.
The CFTC in particular should find the argument for excluding or
exempting Bitcoin universe transactions from the CEA to be particularly
compelling. By statute and regulation, most physically-settled transactions
are not subject to the full scope of CFTC regulations, if any. Insofar as the
cash versus physically settled distinction applies to Bitcoin derivatives,
Bitcoin-universe transactions clearly fall within the category of physical
settlement. In a Bitcoin-universe transaction, each party transacts in and
pays (or receives) only bitcoins. Accordingly, for all the reasons the CFTC
places such strong weight on physical settlement as grounds for excluding
contracts from regulation, it should do so for virtual settlement as well.
4. Prediction Markets & Gambling
In the U.S., online gambling and prediction markets have been heavily
regulated, if not outright prohibited. Nevertheless, a number of online
games and prediction markets have emerged that denominate their bets in
244 Department of Treasury Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, Application of
FinCEN's Regulations to Virtual Currency Mining Operations, FIN-2014-R00I, January
30, 2014, http://m.fincen.govinews_roomirplrulings/pdf/FIN-2014-R001.pdf
245 m.
2"  Id.
247 See FinCEN Ruling FIN-2014-R001, Application of FinCEN's Regulations to
Virtual Currency Mining Operations (Jan. 30, 2014),
http://www.fincen.govinews_room/rpfrulings/pdf/FIN-2014-R001.pdf; See FinCEN
Ruling FIN-2014-R002, Application of FinCEN's Regulations to Virtual Currency
Software Development and Certain Investment Activity, (Jan. 30, 2014), accessible at:
http://www.fincen.govinews_room/rp/rulings/pdf/FIN-2014-R002.pdf.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
bitcoins. In this section we will survey the laws and regulations that apply
to online gambling and prediction markets.
Prediction markets are exchanges where individuals trade "event
contracts," which specify some future event with different possible
outcomes, a payment structure based on the outcome, and a contract
expiration date. For example, a contract could specify "Hillary Clinton wins
the U.S. presidential election in 2016" and pay out $10 if the event comes to
pass or $0 if it does not. Obviously, these markets serve to allow betting on
uncertain future events, but more importantly the prices they produce
contain very valuable information. As a result, prediction markets are often
designed for the express purpose of uncovering these prices, and not merely
to facilitate wagering. 248
By aggregating the beliefs of market participants, prediction market
prices reveal the overall market forecast of a particular event's odds of
occurring. In our example, if the contract is trading at a price of $5.50, then
it means the market places the odds of Clinton's election at 55%. As the
election unfolds, the media, political operatives, academics, and citizens can
observe the prices in the market to get a sense of the relative strength of the
candidates.
Beyond elections, prediction markets have been used to predict a wide
variety of events, such as Academy Award and Super Bowl winners,
product sales figures, flu trends, and much more. They also tend to be more
accurate than polls, surveys, and other forecasting methods. Prediction
markets, therefore, could serve many useful social purposes, including
forecasting the probability of man-made or natural disasters; predicting
political events that could affect financial markets, such as whether the
"debt limit" will be raised; better forecasting IPO pricing; and allowing
hedging against failure of a product the market success of which is difficult
to predict, such as entertainment or pharmaceuticals.
Unfortunately, the regulatory atmosphere in the U.S. has been largely
hostile to prediction markets. In 2012, the CFTC sued the prediction market
Intrade for violating the Commission's ban on off-exchange options
trading.249 As David Meister, the Director of the CFTC's Division of
Enforcement, put it in a statement announcing the suit: "It is against the law
248 Adam Ozimek, The Regulation and Value of Prediction Markets, March 12, 2014,
Mercatus Center Working Paper, http://mercatus.org/publicationfregulation-and-value-
prediction-markets 249 CFTC Charges Ireland -Based "Prediction Market" Proprietors Intrade and TEN
with Violating the CFTC's Off-Exchange Options Trading Ban and Filing False Forms
with the CFTC, CFTC Press Release, November 26, 2012,
httpi/www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/pr6423.12.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
to solicit U.S. persons to buy and sell commodity options, even if they are
called `prediction' contracts, unless they are listed for trading and traded on
a CFTC-registered exchange or unless legally exempt. . . . Today's action
should make it clear that we will intervene in the `prediction' markets,
wherever they may be based, when their U.S. activities violate the
Commodity Exchange Act or the CFTC's regulations."25° Intrade suspended
its operations in the U.S., and within months the site had shut down.25I
Exemptions or permission for regulated exchanges to offer such
contracts have not been forthcoming. Shortly after its action against Intrade,
the CFTC rejected a proposal by the regulated exchange Nadex to offer
political "binary options" that would have allowed traders to bet on the
outcomes of that year's presidential and congressional elections.252 In its
order, the CFTC found that "the contracts involve gaming and are contrary
to the public interest, and cannot be listed or made available for clearing or
trading."253
Today, the only legal real-money political prediction market operating
in the U.S. is the Iowa Electronic Market, which is run by the University of
Iowa's Tippie College of Business 254 It operates under the auspices of two
CFTC no-action letters that are contingent on the market's non-profit and
academic status.255 The letters also place a number of restrictions on the
market.256 For example, no individual is allowed to invest more than $500,
and individual markets are limited to a pre-determined range of
250 Id
251 The CFTC continues to target predictions markets. See: Katherine Mangu-Ward,
The Death of Intrade, Reason Magazine, December 2013,
http://reason.com/archives/2013/11/25/the-death-of-intrade.; Jamila Trindle, Regulators
Sue Prediction Site, Allege Illegal Options, Wall Street Journal, June 6, 2013,
http://online.wsj.cominews/articles/SB10001424127887324798904578529241482337164.
251 Jason Abbruzzese, CFTC bans election -based derivatives contracts, Fr, April 3,
2012, http:/lwww.ft.com/Intl/cros/s/0/dcf8b92.2a70.11eI-9bdb-
00144feabdc0.html#axzz2vaSTU2d.
253 CFTC Issues Order Prohibiting North American Derivatives Exchange's Political
Event Derivatives Contracts, CFTC Press Release, April 2, 2012,
http://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/pr6224-12.
251 Paul Gomme, Iowa Electronic Markets, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland Report,
April 15, 2003, https://www.clevelandfed.orgiresearchkommentary/2003/0415.pdf.
253 Andrea M. Corcoran, CFTC Letter to Professor George Neumann, CFTC Letter No.
91.04a, Division of Trading and Markets, February 5, 1992,
http://www.ctic.gov/ucmfgroups/public/@Irlettergeneral/documents/letter/92-04a.pdf;
Andrea M. Corcoran, CFTC Letter to Professor George Neumann, CFTC Letter No. rf05-
003, Division of Trading and Markets, June 18, 1993,
http://www.cftc.govfilles/foia/repfoia/foirf0503b004.pdf
256 m.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
participants. 257 In addition, pursuant to authority granted to it by the Dodd-
Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act,258 the CFTC has
issued rules banning any event contract "that involves, relates to, or
references terrorism, assassination, war, gaming, or an activity that is
unlawful under any State or Federal law."259
The regulatory environment has been similarly hostile to online
gambling. The Wire Act260 prohibits the knowing use of wire
communications for the transmission of bets or wagers or information
assisting bets or wagers on any sporting event or contest, 261 and the Illegal
Gambling Business Act (IGBA)  62  makes it a federal offense to operate
gambling businesses that are illegal under state law. In addition, in 2006
Congress passed the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act
(UIGEA), which prohibits gambling businesses from accepting payments in
connection with unlawful bets or wagers involving the use of the Internet. 263
It also requires payment processors, such as money transmitters and credit
cards providers, to block payments to gambling sites 2°a
Despite this inhospitable regulatory environment, today there are a
number of gambling and prediction market sites operating that offer
wagering, event contracts, and binary options denominated in bitcoins.
They seem to operate under the theory that because they only employ
bitcoin, they are not subject to regulation. For example, Coinbet.cc offers
poker, casino games, and sports betting to U.S. customers and claims that
by using Bitcoin, its offering is legal. The website states:
Because the ever popular cryptocurrency is not legal tender and not
recognized as a legitimate form of currency by the U.S., that also means that
in legal terms- online gambling with Bitcoin is not an illegal event under the
Wire Act or Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act (UIGEA) which is
257 Id.
258 Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, Pub. L. No. 111-
203, 124 Stat. 1376.2223 (codified as amended in scattered sections of U.S.C. titles: 2, 5,
7, 11, 12, 16, 18, 19, 20, 22, 25, 26, 28, 29, 30, 31, 41, 42, 44, 49, 112), s. 275.
258 17 CFR 40.11
268 Is U.S.C. § 1084 261 A 2011 decision from the Department of Justice changed the scope of 18 U.S.C.
§ 1084 to only apply to sports betting. Virginia A. Seitz, Whether Proposals By Illinois and
New York to Use the Internet and Out-Of-State Transaction Processors to Sell Lottery
Tickets to In-State Adults Violate the Wire Act, Memorandum Opinion for the Assistant
Attorney General, Criminal Division, September 20, 2011,
http://www.justice.govioldopiniondocs/state-lotteries-opinion.pdf
262 18 U.S.C. § 1955
263 31 U.S.C. §§ 5361-5367.
264 Id.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
why it is the perfect payment method for online action in the US. 265
Other gambling sites include SatoshiDice.com, SatoshiBet, and dozens
more.266 Bitcoin prediction markets include Predictious.com, BTCOracle,
and Bets of Bitcoin.
It is not likely that courts will see the use of bitcoins for wagering
(instead of legal tender) as a shield from prohibitions on gambling. While
there is no uniform federal standard, state laws generally require that
gambling transactions have three elements: prize, chance, and
consideration. 267 The question, therefore, is whether bitcoins can serve as
consideration, and courts have confronted such "token consideration" cases
before. For example, in United States v. Davis, the defendants operated
intemet cafés in which customers purchased intemet access time. 68 For
each dollar of intemet time purchased, the customer would receive 100
"entries" into a "sweepstakes." Customers could then enter the sweepstakes
through several ways, one of which was playing casino -like games on the
computers. The court found that the defendant's intemet café was an
attempt to legitimize an illegal lottery in violation of IGBA reasoning that,
under Texas gambling law, the sweepstakes participants exchanged some
consideration (the "entry" tokens) in exchange for the privilege to play the
sweepstakes. There are several other cases that are similar to Davis and use
a similar type of analysis. 269 So, it would not be surprising if courts were to
employ an analysis like that in the Bitcoin Savings and Trust Case and find
that bitcoins are indeed money, or tokens representing money, and thus
consideration. 270
As we have seen, the CFTC views event contracts as options, and as
noted in section II.A, supra, options must be traded at regulated exchanges
and are subject to extensive requirements and restrictions. Given the
265 Information for U.S. Bettors, Coinbet.cc customer service, accessed March 26,
2014, http:/Avww.coinbelcc/pages/us-bettorsti.Ux9liOddXze
266 Bitcoin wiki, s.v. Gambling, accessed March 26, 2014,
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Category:Gambling.
267 See, Midwestern Enters. v. Stenehjem, 2001 ND 67, ¶17, 625 N.W.2d 234, 237

(2001) ("The three elements of gambling are generally recognized as consideration, prize,
and chance."). 268 United States v. Davis, 690 F.3d 330 (5th Cir. 2012). 269 See, e.g., Telesweeps of Butler Valley, 
Inc. v. Kelly, 2012 WL 4839010 (M.D. Pa.
2012) (holding that a computerized casino game-style sweepstakes based on credits
purchased from phone cards is considered gambling, in violation of Pennsylvania law);
City of Cleveland v. Thorne, 987 N.E.2d 731 (Ohio Ct. App. 2013) (although not a federal
case, the court held that offering "sweepstakes points" associated with the sale of intemet
time at an intemet cafe violated city gambling ordinances).
27° Securities and Exchange Commission v. Shavers, No. 4:13-CV-416 (E.D. Tex. Aug.
6, 2013).
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
growing consensus that bitcoins can be used as money whether they fit any
particular definition of money or not, it is unlikely the CFTC will find it has
no jurisdiction over event contracts denominated in bitcoins. The CEA talks
in terms of regulated "trading," "agreements," "contracts," and
"transactions" without reference to any limitation based on the kind of
consideration employed. Therefore, the CFTC may give little weight to the
fact that event contract trading is carried out in bitcoins. That said, the
CFTC should consider whether bitcoin-denominated event contracts qualify
as "Bitcoin-universe transactions" as illustrated in Figure 2, and therefore
whether the full scope regulation under the CEA should apply to such
transactions.
The analysis under UIGEA is a bit trickier, however. UIGEA does not
prohibit gambling per se, but instead prohibits accepting certain types of
electronic payments for online gambling. The question is whether bitcoins
transactions qualify. The relevant section of UIGEA reads:
No person engaged in the business of betting or wagering may knowingly
accept, in connection with the participation of another person in unlawful
Internet gambling ... an electronic fund transfer, or funds transmitted by or
through a money transmitting business, or the proceeds of an electronic fund
transfer or money transmitting service, from or on behalf of such other
person[.]271
Assume for the moment that the predicate "unlawful Internet gambling"
violation has been established under state or federal law. The easy case is
one in which "funds [are] transferred by or through a money transmitting
business." Bitcoin exchanges and some online wallet services, such as
Coinbase.com, are money transmitters under federal and state
regulations. 272 Bitcoins are also likely to be considered "funds" under a
similar analysis to that in Bitcoin Savings and Trust.273 Therefore, accepting
bitcoins transmitted by or through one of these Bitcoin intermediaries will
likely violate UIGEA. In addition, this may mean that these intermediaries
may have to comply with UIGEA's requirements to preemptively block
prohibited transactions. 274
The more difficult case is when there is no intermediary involved
271 31 U.S. Code § 5363
272 US Department of the Treasury, Financial Crimes and Enforcement Network,
Application of FinCEN's Regulations to Persons Administering, Exchanging, or Using
Virtual Currencies (Regulatory Guidance, FIN-2013-G001, US Department of the
Treasury, Washington, DC, March IS, 2013),
http://fincen.govistatutes_regs/guidance/html/FIN-2013-G001.html.
273 See supra
274 31 U.S. Code § 5364
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
between the consumer and the gambling business. Some services, like
Coinbase.com, hold bitcoin accounts for consumers in a custodian -like
fashion, and consumers instruct the service to send bitcoins when they want
to make a transaction. 275 Bitcoin's design, however, allows a user to hold
her own bitcoins, just like holding cash. To do so, a user employs software
known as a "wallet," which contains the user's unique keypair that controls
bitcoin holdings. A wallet application can be run on a desktop PC or a
smartphone. There are also web wallets, which provide users online access
to a user's bitcoins. It is important to note that the providers of such web
wallets, such as Blockchain.info, do not hold bitcoins for their users nor do
they have any access whatsoever to any of their users' bitcoins. They also
do not initiate transactions for users. They simply provide the facility for
users to manage their bitcoin holdings. Whether a user employs a wallet on
their desktop, smartphone, or online when they send bitcoins to another
person, there is no intermediary between them.
UIGEA prohibits accepting any "electronic fund transfer" for illegal
Internet gambling, 276 so the question is whether a Bitcoin transaction sent
directly from the consumer to the gambling business, with no intermediary
between them, qualifies as an "electronic fund transfer." Under UIGEA,
electronic fund transfer "means any transfer of funds ... which is initiated
through an electronic terminal, telephonic instrument, or computer or
magnetic tape so as to order, instruct, or authorize a financial institution to
debit or credit an account." 277 In turn, "financial institution" is defined as "a
State or National bank, a State or Federal savings and loan association, a
mutual savings bank, a State or Federal credit union, or any other person
who, directly or indirectly, holds an account belonging to a consumer[.]" 278
Therefore, it would be stretching the plain meaning of the statute to argue
that a bitcoin wallet held on one's own smartphone is equivalent to an
account held at a financial institution. To do so, a court would have to find
that the "other person" that the statute contemplates is the consumer herself;
that the user is both the "consumer" and the "financial institution"
mentioned in the statute. Clearly the statute did not anticipate electronic
cash without the use of intermediaries.
There is another aspect of Bitcoin's use in online gambling and
prediction markets that may pose a challenge to regulators and law
275 For a discussion of the distinction between off-block chain and on-block chain
transactions, see: Ryan Galt, Roger Ver on Blockchain's Past, Present and Future,
CoinDesk, February 15, 2014, http://nw.coindesk.com/roger-ver-blockchain-past-
present-futuret 276 31 U.S. Code § 5363 (2) 277 Emphasis added. 278 Emphasis added.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
enforcement. Quite apart from simply denominating bets and contract prices
in bitcoins, a gambling business or prediction market could employ the
Bitcoin network to serve as the betting or trading infrastructure.
For example, traditional online gambling businesses or prediction
markets require a user to visit a website and create an account and then
deposit funds to be associated with that account via wire transfer or some
other means. Once this is done, the user may gamble or speculate using
their account balance, and they may later withdraw funds, including
earnings, as they see fit. This is also how many bitcoin-denominated sites
operate. One example is Predictious.com, where one can buy or sell
contracts related to political, economic, and sporting events. To do so one
must create an account and then send bitcoins to fund that account. All
users' bitcoin balances are held by Predictious, and one must initiate a
withdrawal to regain control of any outstanding balance. If law enforcement
were to shut down such a site, users would potentially lose access to their
account balances. Indeed, user balances could be subject to seizure as well.
In contrast to this traditional model, there are betting sites and
prediction markets that require no account creation whatsoever, and bets are
placed simply by initiating a Bitcoin transaction. SatoshiDice is probably
the most popular of these block-chain-based gambling sites 279 Playing is as
easy as sending an amount of one's choosing to a static address operated by
the service and immediately getting back either more or less than one's bet.
Different SatoshiDice addresses have different possible payouts and
corresponding odds.28° This design means that no accounts or deposits are
necessary to play. Indeed, no website is needed either. All the SatoshiDice
website does is list the betting addresses, and these are widely known.
Therefore, even if SatoshiDice's .com domain were to be seized, its
operations would not be affected as long as its Dublin-based 28I servers
continued processing Bitcoin transactions. And if its servers were to be shut
down, users would have no account balances to lose. Other sites like
SatoshiDice include BitLotto, 282 and DiceOnCrack. 283
279 Megan Geuss, Firm says online gambling accounts for almost half of all Bitcoin
transactions, ArsTechnica, August 24, 2014, http://arstechnica.comfbusiness/2013/08/firm-
says-online-gambling-accounts-for-almost-half-ohall-bitcoin-transactionst
280 Because all transactions are public, users can verify that the house is paying out
fairly -- unlike traditional casinos.
281 Jon Matonis, Bitcoin Casinos Release 2012 Earnings, CoinDesk, January 22, 2013,
http://www.forbes.com/sites/jonmatonis/2013/01/22/bitcoin-casinos-release-2012-
earnings/.
292 Bitlotto, [B1TLOTTOJ Mar 1 draw over $2000 or 50BTC! Tickets now 0.1 BTC for
Apr 5, Bitcointalk.org forum post, August 3, 2011, accessed April 2, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=34007.0.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
BTCOracle is a similar service that does not require registration or
balances, but instead of gambling, it allows users to attempt to predict the
future price of Bitcoin using binary options. 284 Users can bet on whether the
price of Bitcoin will go up or down within a given period of time simply by
initiating a bitcoin transaction. The BTCOracle website merely serves as a
directory for open options and their corresponding betting addresses. The
front page of the website displays two main tables 85 ("Win in the price is
higher in:" and "Win if the price of lower in:") with five different selections
under each. Each table lists five options: 15 minutes, 3 hours, 1 day, 3 days,
and 1 week. Each option lists a minimum and maximum Bitcoin-
denominated bet along with a price multiplier that will be used to determine
winnings. Finally, each "option" lists a Bitcoin wallet address and
corresponding QR code. Users who wish to bet on any of these options
simply send a bet amount within the predetermined range to the associated
address. If the user wins the bet, the earnings, equal to the amount of the
initial bet times the displayed price multiplier, will be sent back to the
Bitcoin wallet from which the user sent the original bet. If the user loses, he
will receive nothing (or will receive a corresponding repayment according
to the odds) 286 According to the website FAQ, BTCOracle has processed at
least 3,000 options trades since the service launched in April of 2013.282
While bitcoin-denominated prediction markets and gambling sites exist
in a legal gray area, the fact that transactions are bitcoin-denominated is
likely less of a legal shield than some operators imagine. Nevertheless,
Bitcoin will make it more difficult to enforce gambling regulations. After
all, the purpose of UIGEA is to leverage intermediary payment processors
to target illegal online gambling. 288
293 TTBit, DiceOnCrack.com I If you thought dice was addicting..., Bitcointalk.org
forum post, October 24, 2012, accessed April 2, 2014,
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=120239.0.
294 BTCOracle, FAQ, BTCOracle Customer Service, accessed March 26, 2014,
http://btcoracle.comffaq.php.
295 Two other tables are "Win if at any time until the option is closed, the price is 10%
or more higher than the starting price" and "Win if at any time until the option is closed,
the price is 10% or more lower than the starting price" with three different time options: 1
day, 3 days, and 1 week. The remaining tables list running and closed executed options.
296 BTCOracle, FAQ — "How does it work?", BTCOracle Customer Service, accessed
March 26, 2014, http://btcoracle.comffaq.php.
297 BTCOracle, FAQ — "Can you trust us? Who are you?", BTCOracle Customer
Service, accessed March 26, 2014, http:/ibtcoracle.com/faq.php.
293 31 U.S. Code § 5361 - Congressional findings and purpose
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
III. DECENTRALIZED MARKETS AND EXCHANGES
Bitcoin, at root, is a cryptographically verifiable distributed ledger
system. At any moment in time, there is a fixed number of bitcoins and the
block chain allows a user to prove ownership of a particular bitcoin (or
fraction thereof) and to verifiably transfer ownership without the need for a
single trusted third party.
To date, bitcoins have represented money at a floating exchange rate,
and the Bitcoin network has been employed as a fast and inexpensive
payments or money transfer system. But there is no reason why particular
bitcoins (or fractions thereof) could not represent something besides money.
If we conceive of bitcoins simply as tokens, then other applications become
apparent. For example, we could agree that a particular bitcoin (or, indeed,
an infinitesimally small fraction of a bitcoin so as to allow for many tokens)
represents a house, a car, a share of stock, a futures contract, or an ounce of
gold. Conceived of in this way, the Bitcoin block chain then becomes more
than just a payment system. It can be a completely decentralized and
perfectly reconciled property registry.
Additionally, transactions using the Bitcoin protocol are programmable,
which means that they can be automated. 289 For example, Bitcoin allows for
multisignature, or "m-of-n," transactions that require any in number of n
signatures to complete. 299 Compared to a basic two-person transaction
where bitcoins are transferred directly from one person's wallet to another's
with no opportunity for chargebacks, multisignature transactions offer
greater security and more complexity without the need for a trusted third
party through the use of pre-established signature consensus. 29I
Substituting Bitcoin for a trusted third party will likely meet the demand
of a wide range of sellers and merchants. The use of a third party financial
institution to ensure delivery and payment among anonymous parties
currently takes place through the long-standing and widespread practice of
an intermediary issuing an instrument known as a commercial letter of
credit. A letter of credit assures a seller of payment by requiring a buyer to
pay a trusted financial institution to take on the obligation to pay the
289 Gavin Andresen, Pay to Script Hash, Bitcoin Improvement Proposal 0016, March I,
2012, https://github.com/bitcoinibips/blob/masterthip-00 I 6.mediawiki.
"° Gavin Andresen, Bitcoin Faucet Hacked, blog, March 2012,
http://gavintech.blogspot.com/2012/03/bitcoin-faucet-hacked.html.
For an overview of the functions and applications of multisignature transactions,
see: Mike Hearn, The Future of Bitcoin: New Applications and Rebuilding the Banking
System, Presentation at the Bitcoin 2012 Conference in London, YouTube video, uploaded
by QueuePolitely on September 27, 2012, accessed March 21, 2014,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mD4L7xDNCmA.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
seller. 292 At the same time, a letter of credit transaction assures the buyer
that it will not have to pay the seller until the seller ships the goods. The
practice requires the seller to deliver substantial documentation to the
intermediary evidencing proof of shipment before the seller is paid. Letters
of credit are mostly used in international goods transactions, where trust
between contracting parties is relatively low. Letters of credit can be
expensive, and range from 0.5 to 3 percent based upon the structure of the
transaction, whether additional bank intermediaries are used, and the
creditworthiness of the parties. Like credit card payments, using Bitcoin as
a substitute for the third party verification function of letters of credit could
entail a substantial cost savings to merchants.
The simplest application of multisignature transaction is a 2-of-3
transaction. Bitcoins are sent to an address controlled by three parties:293
perhaps the buyer, the seller, and a third party arbitrator. To move the
bitcoins from the jointly controlled address, two out of the three parties
must sign off on the transaction. If the buyer and seller are both happy with
the exchange, they both sign off on the transaction, the bitcoins are
transferred to the seller, and the transaction is reconciled on the block chain.
In the case of a dispute, the seller will sign off on the transfer of the bitcoins
to herself, but the buyer will not. In this case, the third party arbitrator can
render a decision by deciding who should get the coins and signing the
appropriate transaction. 294 The third party's signature provides the second
needed signature to complete the 2-if-3 transaction.
This kind of multisignature transaction can be used to provide escrow -
like services 295 for bitcoin transactions as well as for real world assets.
291 Uniform Commercial Code Section 5.108(b) (requiring an issuer of a letter of
credit to honor by payment); 5.IO2(a)(3) (defining beneficiary as party that issuer of letter
is required to pay upon presentation of documents); 5-102(a)(8) (defining honor as being
satisfied by payment).
293 More technically, three normal bitcoin addresses are gathered or created and their
public keys are noted. A multisignature address is then created from these three public keys
using the "addmultisigaddress" command. Users can then send funds into this
multisignature address using normal Bitcoin commands. See: Gavin Andresen, Re:
[Bounty] How-to Multi signature transactions, Bitcointalk.org forum post, May 18, 2012,
https://bitcointalk.org/indez.php?topic=82213.msg906833iimsg906833.
294 While this third party can technically be any person, early businesses have looked
to provide professionalized mediation services through 2-of-3 transactions. For one
ezam_ple, see: Bitrated, FAQ, accessed March 26, 2013, https://www.bitrated.com/faq.html.
195 Note that multisignature transactions are not like a traditional escrow services
because the third party never actually takes ownership of the collateral or deposit. The
bitcoins are always under the joint control of the multisignature address, so no one party
can simply abscond with the funds as in traditional escrow services.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
Suppose Alice orders an original painting from Bob.2" Instead of using
PayPal to serve as a payment processor and dispute mediator, Alice and
Bob decide to arrange a multisignature bitcoin transaction with a third party
arbitrator, Chuck. A multisignature address is created and Alice sends
enough bitcoins to cover the price to the jointly controlled address. At no
point in time can any one party move these bitcoins from the joint address.
If Alice receives the painting without a dispute, Alice and Bob both sign the
transaction and the bitcoins move to Bob's personal address. If Alice
receives the painting but she cannot get a hold of Bob for some reason, she
can direct Chuck to provide the second signature to the transaction so that
the bitcoins get transferred to Bob's address. If Bob does not send the
painting by the agreed upon date, Chuck and Alice will sign the transaction
to return Alice's bitcoins to her personal address. In the case of a dispute,
Alice and Bob can appeal to Chuck to arbitrate according to the agreed -
upon terms of the contract. Unlike traditional escrow, at no point can Chuck
run away with the money he is holding.
Arbitrators to a multisignature transaction can provide more than simple
dispute mediation. In the case of rare or specialty goods, arbitrators can also
serve as specialists to verify authenticity. Let's say that the painting that
Bob is selling is an original Picasso. Alice and Bob now agree to designate
Dan, a Sotheby's broker, to serve as the third party arbitrator. Bob carefully
ships the painting to the United States, where it is received by Dan and
Alice. With the full weight of Sotheby's reputation behind him, Dan
inspects the work to ensure its authenticity. If he determines the work is a
genuine Picasso, he will provide the second signature to the transaction to
transfer the bitcoins to Bob's private address. This structure allows Bob and
Alice with the expertise of a specialist arbitrator along with the peace of
mind that no one party can move bitcoins from the joint address.
It may one day be possible to even eliminate the need to trust any
individual arbitrator's or organization's professional reputation. Rather than
designating a living person as the third party, users could write a program,
called an oracle,29 to only sign off on the transaction if the program
receives a specified input, like a verified bit of information. An oracle is a
computer server that is programmed to scour data feeds to verify whether a
296 For an overview of the functions and applications of multisignature transactions,
see Mike Hearn, The Future of Bitcoin: New Applications and Rebuilding the Banking
System, Presentation at the Bitcoin 2012 Conference in London, YouTube video, uploaded
by QueuePolitely on September 27, 2012, accessed March 21, 2014,
http://www.youtube.comiwatch?v=mD4L7xDNCmA.
297 For a deeper explanation of oracles, see: Mike Hearn, Contracts - Example 4: Using
external state, Bitcoin wiki, accessed March 21, 2014,
https://en.bitcoinit/wiki/ContractsffExample_4:_Using_external_state.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
user-provided expression is true. Because the oracle is bound by its design
to act only as programmed, there is no risk that the oracle would collude
with any party as there is with a human arbitrator. Oracles can be
programmed to monitor pre-existing data feeds, like official death registries,
stock market tickers, weather reports, or indeed anything that can be
expressed as structured data.2" Conceivably, a custom -designed oracle
could simply monitor news data feeds, such as Google News, looking for
keywords that confirm some arbitrary event. Depending on the information
that the oracle receives, the program will sign its own unique key to the
transaction to send bitcoins to the corresponding address. One early variant
of the oracle concept, Reality Keys, combines a distributed keypair service
with their centrally -managed data feeds that users can combine to create
custom Bitcoin contracts. 99  Eventually, oracles will not require a third-
party facilitator like Reality Keys to provide trustless verification of
conditional outcomes. If oracles are designed carefully enough, they can be
combined with multisignature transactions to virtually eliminate the need to
trust a third party in exchange.
The case of an inheritance is a simple example to illustrate how oracles
and multisignature transactions can be combined. 300 Let's say that Alice
wishes to bequeath an inheritance to her granddaughter Erin. She wants the
inheritance to be dispersed either on Erin's 18th birthday or after Alice dies,
whichever date comes first. It would be easy enough for Alice to create a
conditional transaction that will not complete until a certain agreed -upon
future "lock time." Alice would merely need to specify that the transaction
should be considered pending until Erin's 18ih birthday, after which date
Erin can sign her private key to retrieve the inheritance. In order to also
cover the death condition, Alice can create another transaction, this time a
multisignature transaction, to which herself, Erin, and an oracle are all
parties. The oracle would be programmed to check official death registries
for an official record of Alice's death. If Alice dies before Erin's le
birthday, the oracle will receive an input that Alice's death record has been
registered in the public databases. This input will induce the oracle to sign
the transaction, along with Erin, to transfer the bitcoins to Erin's account. If
Alice does not die before Erin's I e birthday, Erin can simply sign the
transaction that Alice gave her after the date of her birthday. Since the lock
time date has passed, it will be considered valid by the block chain, so the
298 For instance, private companies may opt to create data sources that are specifically
desigued to be used by those companies' oracles.
199 http://www.coindesk.com/reality-keys-bitcoins-third-party-guarantor-contracts/
100 This example is taken from a use case originally developed by Mike Heam. See:
Mike Hearn, Contracts - Example 4: Using external state, Bitcoin wiki, accessed March 21,
2014, https://en.bitcoin.it/wikiitontractsfiExample_4:_Using_extemal_state.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
bitcoins are transferred to Erin.
Eventually, the block chain could even serve as a distributed title
registry for real world assets through the use of "smart property.s301
Physical, non-BTC assets can be represented on the block chain through the
use of "colored coins.s302 Suppose Alice wants to transfer title of her car to
Bob using the block chain. Alice can choose to "color" some fraction of a
bitcoin to represent her car and serve as a "title" on the block chain. Bob
transfers enough bitcoins to Alice to cover the cost of the car and Alice
transfers the colored coin that represents the car to Bob. In this simple
scenario, Bob and Alice would need to rely on an established legal system
to recognize the legitimacy of colored coins in representing property titles.
A more complex variation could make smart property titles self-
enforcing.303 Alice could one day attach a chip to the car that serves both as
a key and a property title.
One way to do this is to attach a small computer or chip to real world
assets that will automatically allow trustless authentication and transfer of
ownership. Once Alice transfers the colored coins that represent the car to
Bob's wallet, the car's chip will then update its ownership information so
that Bob can now open and start the automobile. By adding a programmable
chip that communicates with the block chain to a real world asset, that asset
can be transferred with the same ease as any bitcoin transaction. Eventually,
this concept could be applied to rental concepts, like ZipCar and Car2Go, or
other extensions like hotel booking to allow secure and seamless payments
and access. While still in early development, the possibilities that smart
property creates are innovative and unprecedented.
A. Decentralized Applications
While the Bitcoin block chain could theoretically facilitate these
complex transactions, some in the Bitcoin community have expressed
doubts that the block chain can easily scale to accommodate these services
without slowing or hindering other core functions.304 One solution that has
101 Nick Szabo, The Idea of Smart Contracts, White Paper, 1997,
http://szabo.best.vwh.net/idea.html.
101 For a deeper explanation of colored coins, see the white paper: Yoni Assia and Leor
Hakim, Colored Coins - BitcoinX, White paper, accessed March 21,
2014,https://docs.google.com/document/d/1 AnkP_cVZTCMLIzw4DvsW6M8Q2JC0llzrT
LuoWu2z I BE/edit.
3°3 Mike Hearn, Smart Property, Bitcoin wiki entry, accessed March 26, 2014,
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Smart_Property.
3°4 Chris Odom, Chris Odom on OpenTransactions, presentation at the Miami Bitcoin
Conference 2014, January 25, 2014, accessed March 21, 2014,
https://soundcloud.com/mindtomatter/miami-2014-chris-odom-on-1
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
been proposed is a federated server system and software library known as
Open Transactions." 5 To briefly summarize, the Open Transactions system
uses multisignature transactions, triple entry accounting,306 and Truledger
receipt systems3°' to regulate bitcoin deposits and transfers throughout a
federated system of servers.308 This federated model, along with Open
Transaction's digital software library of complex transactions available for
users to employ, 09 allows Bitcoin users, and indeed the users of any digital
currency or representation of real world assets, to harness complex
transactions without the limits of the Bitcoin block chain or the need to trust
any one third party. It is best thought of as an independent, compatible
extension of the Bitcoin system that uses federated servers to communicate
complex transactions to the block chain.
Like the Bitcoin protocol, the Open Transactions system does not
require a trusted third party to facilitate transactions and does not contain a
single point of control that can be shut down. While the Open Transactions
project was in development before Bitcoin's release, both projects'
functions and philosophies are very compatible. Indeed, Open Transactions
is merely one of several ongoing projects that aim to provide higher
functionality to the Bitcoin protocol. Other "Bitcoin 2.0" experiments that
are in various phases of development include Mastercoin,31°
Counterparty,311 and Ethereum.312 Each project differs in terms of the tools
and specific functions that are prioritized, but they all aim to extend the
Bitcoin protocol's core capabilities of block chain-based peer-to-peer asset
exchange to complex financial instruments and even real world assets.
This is where things get interesting. These three tools-multisignature
3°51d
396 Ian Grigg, Triple Entry Accounting, White Paper, 2005, accessed April 7, 2014,
http://nakamotoinstitute.org/literature/31/htmll.
3°7 Bill St. Clair, Truledger in Plain English, White Paper, 2008, accessed April 7,
2014, http://nakamotoinstitute.orgiliterature/32/htmlt
3°8 Justus Ranvier, Voting Pools: How to Stop the Plague of Bitcoin Heists, Thefts,
Hacks, Scams, and Losses, Bitcoinism blog, December 6, 2013, accessed March II, 2014,
http://bitcoinism.blogspot.com/2013/12/voting-pools-how-to-stopplague-olhtml.
3°9 Open Transactions wiki, s.v. List of Classes, accessed March 26, 2014,
http://opentransactions.org/wiki/index.php?title=List_of Classes.
31° J.R. Willet, Maran Hidskes, David Johnston, Ron Gross, Mary Schneider, and Peter
Todd, The Master Protocol / Mastercoin Complete Specification, White Paper Version
0.4.5.1 Smart Property Fundraisers Edition, accessed March 26, 2014,
https://github.com/mastercoin-MSC/spec. 311 PhantonPhreak, The Counterpart) , Protocol, White Paper, accessed March 26, 
2014,
https://github.com/PhantomPhreak/Counterparty.
312 Vitalik Buterin, et al., A Next Generation Smart Contract and Decentralized
Application Platform, Ethereum White Paper, accessed March 26, 2014,
https://github.com/ethereurn/wiki/wiki/%5BEnglish%5D-White-Paper.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
transactions, real world asset registration on the block chain, and
programmable contracts —can be combined with other cryptographic and
peer-to-peer programs to allow for, inter alia, distributed securities
exchanges, prediction markets, and gambling. Not only does Bitcoin and
Bitcoin-related technologies disintermediate payment processors and money
transfer systems like PayPal, Visa, and Western Union, they also have the
potential to disintermediate the kinds of services provided by the NYSE,
Intrade, or Mega Millions. In the following sections we will briefly survey
each potential application to give the reader an idea of what is possible
without going into too much technical detail.
1. Securities Exchanges
We begin by looking at how Bitcoin and Bitcoin-related technologies
can be used to create a securities exchange that is not controlled or operated
by any central third party, whether registered and regulated or not. Let's say
Alice wants to start a Bitcoin miner company. She has a strong background
in chip design and wants to manufacture and sell dedicated Bitcoin mining
hardware as a business, and she wants to raise capital by selling shares of
Alice's Mining Company. Having observed several instances of fraud or
mismanagement on some of the centralized Bitcoin-denominated stock
market platforms, Alice decides that she would like to bypass these third
party platforms and sell shares of her company using multisignature
transactions and programmable contracts.
First, Alice creates a verified identity for her company through a
distributed naming service like Namecoin m  or Keyhotee. 314 All addresses
and pseudonyms that are associated with Alice's Mining Company are tied
to this one verified identity that only Alice (or anyone with whom she
shares her private key) can control. This provides prospective customers
and investors with a credible identity on which she can build (or destroy)
her company's reputation.
Next, Alice needs to identify and connect with prospective investors.
Since Alice is not using a centralized trading platform, she cannot use the
messaging spaces of such a platform to broadcast offers and discover
investors. Fortunately, a number of alternative, non-centralized messaging
spaces exist. Alice can broadcast shares of her company for sale on the
313 David Gilson, What are Namecoins and .bit domains?, CoinDesk, June 18, 2013,
httr./Avww.coindesk.cornhvhat-are-namecoins-and-bit-domainst. 314 Daniel Larimer, Introduction to Keyhotee, Invictus 
Innovations Presentation, posted
to YouTube on October 24, 2013, accessed March 21, 2014,
httr./Avww.youtube.com/watch?v=3pZaTdEtK-8.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
#bitcoin-otc open order book315 or can create a broadcast on the peer-to-
peer messaging space Bitmessage. 316 These messaging spaces allow buyers
and sellers to connect without the need for a third party platform to oversee
the exchange. Alice can provide details about her business plan, growth
projections, dividend schedule and other relevant information to prospective
buyers.
After drumming up enough investors, Alice can create a custom
algorithmic contract that reflects the terms negotiated with her shareholders
through the Open Transactions software library.317 This may take the form
of colored coins representing shares of the company, a programmable and
algorithmically self-enforcing contract shared among all shareholders, 318 or
even old-fashioned physical documents representing shares. Whatever the
form of the contract, Open Transactions and the Bitcoin block chain provide
Alice with a number of options to publicly and credibly commit the parties
to their agreed -upon financial stakes in Alice's Mining Company.
Shareholders can buy or sell after market shares of Alice's Mining
Company through #bitcoin-otc or Bitmessage. Alice might decide to
broadcast an order book specifically for her company shares to streamline
trading. Alternatively, another individual may list market activity for shares
of Alice's Mining Company among a public broadcast of stock market
indices.
2. Predictions Markets
Similarly, Bitcoin and Open Transactions users can buy or sell
predictions without the need to remain within a centralized third party
platform —that is, users can trade event contracts directly, without the need
for an Intrade-type service. Let's say that Alice wishes to bet on the future
price of Google stock. 319 Alice broadcasts a message to Bitmessage stating
that she thinks the price of Google stock will rise by 20% by six months
from that day and that she is willing to wager 0.5 BTC on her prediction.
315 OTC Order Book, #bitcoin-otc, accessed March 26, 2014, http://bitcoin-
otc.com/vieworderbook.php.
316 Jonathan Warren, Bitmessage: A Peer-to-Peer Authentication and Delivery System,
White Paper, November 12, 2012, https://bitmessage.org/bitmessage.pdf. 317 Open Transactions wiki, s.v. Smart contracts,
accessed March 26, 2014,
http://opentransactions.org/wiki/index.php?title=Smart_contracts. 318 This concept is known as a "decentralized 
autonomous corporation" (DAC) or a
"decentralized autonomous organization" (DAO). [1] Vitalik Buterin's series for Bitcoin
Magazine describes in detail the hypothetical forms and functions that DACs could take.
See: Vitalik Buterin, Bootstrapping A Decentralized Autonomous Corporation: Parts 1-111,
Bitcoin Magazine, September 2013, http://bitcoinmagazine.com/7050/bootstrapping-a-
decentralized-autonomous-corporation-part-it
319 Jerry Brito, Bitcoin: More than Money, Reason Magazine, December 2013.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
Other users can browse public feeds to find potentially lucrative bets. Since
Bitmessage, like Bitcoin, is a pseudonymous system, users can post and
enter into bets without knowing the identity of the party or parties on the
other side. Those who believe that the price of Google stock will behave
differently than the bet that Alice proposes can respond to Alice's message
that they would like to enter the bet.
One easy way to facilitate this bet is to create a smart contract on Open
Transactions that includes an oracle as a party to the exchange. Alice, the
initiator of the bet, creates a smart contract on Open Transactions to codify
and enforce the bet. Each party to the bet enters into the contract along with
the oracle. Bettors send their wagers to a multisignature address and agree
that the bet will close at a certain date. On the closing day, the oracle will
consult a pre-determined price feed, like NASDAQ, to determine which
party is correct about the price of Google stock. The oracle will then
automatically provide the needed signature to the transaction so that the
"pot" goes to winner of the bet.
This basic example involves at least two persons monitoring for bets
and engaging directly in discussions via messaging in order to enter into a
bet, but this process can be automated. 32° Alice, for instance, could write a
program to automatically browse broadcast feeds and enter into prediction
trades that fall within some pre-determined range. If enough bettors prefer
using these autonomous programs to automatically trade certain bets, it is
possible that many or most of the trades made on decentralized prediction
markets will come from these programs acting on their creator's behalf.
Predictions are not just useful for the individuals who believe that they
can profit from their special knowledge, but also from observers who can
use this information to inform their own probabilities of the likelihoods of
certain events. Individuals who wish to view aggregated price information
on prediction market questions could program oracles to scour prediction
broadcasts and display lists of going predictions and prices. These tools
could allow individuals to either trade informational bets to earn potential
profits or simply gauge the probabilities of future events by viewing public
feeds of prediction market prices. In recognition of some of the
informational benefits that publicly-viewable but non-centrally -
administered prediction markets can provide, researchers at Princeton
University are currently developing a theoretical design for such a system.32
320 Nick Szabo, The Idea of Smart Contracts, White Paper, 1997,
http://szabo.best.vwh.nettidea.html.
32i  Ed Felten, Bitcoin Research in Princeton CS, Freedom to Tinker, November 29,
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
These basic tools can allow for a dispersed ecosystem of predictions on
subjects ranging from the weather, expected commodity prices, scientific
discoveries, or even less savory speculations like assassinations or terrorist
attacks. Contracts on heretofore prohibited events, like election outcomes 322
or box office revenues, 323 could proliferate. The outcome of any event that
can be expressed as structured data readable by an oracle could be fair game
for speculation on a distributed prediction market. Like Bitcoin, this
ecosystem would contain no central point of control that authorities could
shut down to end trading. Also like Bitcoin, distributed prediction markets
will challenge the assumptions and methods currently favored by authorities
to regulate these activities.
3. Gambling
Gambling, too, could be more fully decentralized through the use of the
Bitcoin protocol alone. For example, multisignature transactions can
potentially allow for secure multiparty lotteries using the Bitcoin protocol
without relying on a trusted third party.324 A group of researchers from the
University of Warsaw have already theoretically described 3n and
successfully executed 326 this kind of lottery. They explain:
"[W]e construct protocols for secure multiparty lotteries using the Bitcoin
currency, without relying on a trusted authority. By "lottery" we mean a
protocol in which a group of parties initially invests some money, and at the
end one of them, chosen randomly, gets all the invested money (called the
pot). Our protocols can work in purely peer-to-peer environment, and can be
executed between players that are anonymous and do not trust each other. Our
constructions come with a very strong security guarantee: no matter how the
2013, https://freedom-to-tinker.com/blog/felten/bitcoin-research-in-princeton-cs/. 322
324 See, for example: Andrew Chi-Chih Yao, How to Generate and Exchange Secrets,
271h Annual Symposium on the Foundations of Computer Science, IEEE, 1986,
http://www.csee.wvu.edu/—xinIllibrarylpapers/comp/Yao1986.pdf; and Oded Goldreich,
Silvio Micali, and Avi Wigderson, How to Play Any Mental Game: or, A Completeness
Theorem for Protocols with Honest Majority, Proceedings of the nineteenth annual ACM
symposium on Theory of computing, ACM, 1987,
http://www.math.ias.edukavi/PUBLICATIONS/MYPAPERS/GMW87/GMW87.pdf.
325 Marcin Andrychowicz, Stefan Dziembowski, Daniel Malinowski and Lukasz
Mazurek, Secure Multiparty Computations on BitCoin, Cryptology ePrint Archive: Report
2013/784, January 13,2014, http://eprint.iacr.org/2013/784.
S36 Blockchain records of a three-party lottery performed by the University of Warsaw
researchers: PutMoney^: https://blockchain.info/tx-index196946847; PutMoneyri:
https:/iblockchain.info/tx-index/96946887; PutMonet: https://blockchain.info/tx-
index/96947563; Compute: https://blockchain.info/bc-index/96964833; ClaimMoneyc:
https://blockchain.info/bc-index/96966124.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
dishonest parties behave, the honest parties will never get cheated. More
precisely, each honest party can be sure that, once the game starts, it will
always terminate and will be fair." 327
Let's say Alice wishes to initiate a secure multiparty lottery using the
Bitcoin protocol. Alice sends a command to the block chain that opens the
lottery. She specifies a closing date at which the lottery will end and
submits a deposit to the transaction to ensure the lottery. The multiparty
lottery generates some secret value "x" that functions as a "winning
number" for the gamble. If Alice neglects to announce the winning "x" by
the date indicated, Alice's deposit will be distributed among the participants
and their gambles will be returned.
Alice can broadcast an announcement for the lottery in a distributed
message space like Bitmessage to draw entrants. Each entrant contributes
their bets into a common pool that cannot be stolen or transferred by any
one player, along with a secret number "s" for each player, which serves as
each player's individual "lottery ticket number." On the closing date, Alice
sends a command to reveal the winning "x" while the entrants publicly
reveal their "s" values. The entrant whose "s" corresponds to the winning
"x" wins the pot. The winning entrant is automatically broadcast to the
block chain and the winner sends a command to the block chain to claim
her winnings. The lottery closes without any risk of theft or fraud.
This construction provides a successfully tested blueprint for a basic
distributed lottery using only the Bitcoin block chain in a proof-of-concept
test. The authors of this construction indicate that variations on this method
could be used to provide complex forms of distributed gambling, like card
games and board games, through the Bitcoin block chain. It may not be long
before we see the first ever multi -billion dollar global lotteries online.
While they may well be unofficial and illegal, they will be
cryptographically verifiable and therefore completely fraud-proof.
B. Law and Decentralization
In "A History of Online Gatekeeping," Jonathan Zittrain catalogs how
intermediaries serve as the obvious targets of regulation for governments
seeking to control information flows on the Internet.328 These include ISPs,
search engines, payment processors, and DNS registrars. And Jack
Goldsmith & Tim Wu have written that content providers cannot evade
327 Marcin Andrychowicz, Stefan Dziembowski, Daniel Malinowski and Lukasz
Mazurek, Secure Multiparty Computations on BitCoin, Cryptology ePrint Archive: Report
2013/784, January 13, 2014, http://eprint.iacr.org12013/784.
323 Zittrain, J. (2006). A History of Online Gatekeeping. Harvard Journal of Law and
Technology, 19(2), 253.298.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
control by simply avoiding intermediaries because "the elimination of
intermediaries is in many cases the same thing as the elimination of the
underlying conduct." 329 However, growing decentralization can in fact
remove these intermediary points of control, making information even more
costly to regulate.
Consider, for example, attempts to control illegal music sharing.
Napster emerged as the first mainstream peer-to-peer file sharing system. Its
design featured a centralized index, which was the obvious point of control
that could be regulated or shut down.33° That was indeed what happened
after the RIAA successfully sued Napster for contributory copyright
infringement. 33I But of course, that is not where the story ends. Napster's
demise saw the rise of new file-sharing systems that did not use a
centralized index.332 These included FastTrack, Gnutella, and eventually
BitTorrent, which is completely decentralized. 333 As a result, the cost of
policing and controlling illegal file sharing became exponentially higher.
The same may happen to bitcoin-denominated exchanges, prediction
markets, and gambling.
Decentralized peer-to-peer technologies are increasingly removing
layers of intermediation by avoiding centralized servers that can be
regulated or shut down. Despite what Goldsmith and Wu suggest, a peer-to-
peer system can eliminate intermediaries without eliminating the underlying
conduct. As a result, fewer intermediary points of control will further raise
the costs of controlling information while also reducing the costs of sharing
it.
Bitcoin's decentralized nature already makes controlling simple
payments difficult if not impossible. After WikiLeaks released the
Cablegate memos, financial intermediaries including MasterCard and Visa
refused to process donations for the group, and PayPal froze the
organization's account. 334 They did so likely under political pressure.
WikiI PAN began accepting bitcoin donations in 2011,33 and today such a
129 Goldsmith & Wu, Who Controls the Internet, at 69.
33° Annemarie Bridy, Is Online Copyright Enforcement Scalable, 13 Vanderbilt
Journal of Entertainment & Technology Law 695 (2011), 699-701.
331 Id.
331 Id.
333 Id.
334 Greenberg, A. (2010, Dec. 7). Visa, MasterCard Move to Choke WikiLeaks.
Forbes. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/andygreenberg/2010/12/07/visa-
mastercard-move-to-choke-wikileaks/
113Greenberg, A. (2011, June 14). WikiLeaks Asks for Anonymous Bitcoin Donations.
Forbes. Retrieved from
httryJAvww.forbes.com/sitedandygreenberg/2011/06/14/wikileaks-asks-for-anonymous-
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
financial embargo would be much more difficult. In the future, it may well
be more than just simple payments that Bitcoin will make difficult to
control.
This is a new world for policymakers. In the past, to achieve a public
policy goal, they only needed to regulate a handful of intermediaries. The
perceived benefits of the public policy goal very often outweighed the cost
associated with regulating the few intermediaries. If there are no
intermediaries, but only thousands or millions of users interacting peer-to-
peer, then the costs of enforcement may well outweigh any perceived
potential benefits of regulation. In this new world, regulators should take
into consideration the increasingly high cost of information control into
their cost-benefit calculus. Doing so may lead policymakers to conclude
that efforts to control only make sense as a last resort.
If top-down regulation is increasingly not a cost-beneficial option for
achieving public policy goals, policymakers will have to consider realistic
alternatives, such as focusing on resiliency and adaptation. These are
concepts borrowed from biology and ecology. Resilience is the capacity of
an ecosystem to recover quickly from a shock,336 while adaptation is the
change an organism or species undergoes to become better suited to a new
environment. 37 In several works, Adam Thierer has applied these concepts
to information technology as alternatives to precautionary regulation or
prohibition, either of technology of information. 38
Thierer develops a continuum of possible responses to technological
risks, with adaptation at the bottom, followed by resiliency and anticipatory
regulation, and ending with prohibition at the top.339 He argues quite
convincingly that the best approach for policy makers confronted with a
new and potentially risky technology is to take a "bottom-up" approach,
employing first adaptation and then resiliency strategies before considering
anticipatory regulation or prohibition." ) The alternative—a precautionary
principle for information—would be too costly and trade too much potential
innovation for safety, he argues.341
For our purposes, we need not make any normative claims about "top-
bitcoin-donations
336 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resilience_(ecology)
337 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adaptation
338 Adam Thierer, Technopanics, Threat Inflation, and the Danger of an Information
Technology Precautionary Principle, 14 MINNA. L. Sci. & TECH. 309 (2013), available at
http://purLumn.edu/144225
336 Id. at 356-57. Mold
34i It at 361.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
down" responses to unwanted information or behaviors in order to apply
Thierer's model. We need only note that if prohibition and regulation
become too costly, policymaker's next best options will be resilience and
adaptation. The music industry's recent experience with online piracy
presents an example of resiliency and adaptation.
Confronted with a threat to its business from new online technologies,
the music industry at first engaged in a strategy of information control. It
sued prominent file-sharing service Napster out of existence,342 and then
also pursued individual file-sharers.343 These efforts did not succeed in
containing the threat. BitTorrent, a decentralized and difficult-to-control
network protocol, became the new file-sharing standard, and the campaign
of suits against individuals was ended after it resulted in little more than
widespread consumer resentment. Today the industry continues to pursue
new information control regimes, such as the proposed Stop Online Piracy
Act, but it has also begun to adapt to a new environment where such control
is extremely difficult.
Music producers have begun to shift what they monetize away from the
easily copied music, to difficult-to-replicate performances and branded
goods?" As Mark Raustalia and Christopher Sprigman point out, concert
ticket sales tripled in value from $1.5 billion to $4.6 billion between 1999
and 2009, just as the record labels' revenues were plummeting.345 The result
of this changing landscape may be that some species in the music
ecosystem, such as the labels, will not survive. However, those who do
adapt, especially independent artists, may thrive better than ever, and we see
evidence of this.3" More persons make their living as musicians today than
ever before, and thanks in large part to the Internet, there is more music
available today from more artists than ever. The music industry will
therefore likely adapt without having to resort to information control.
One can imagine the same kind of adaptation in other contexts. Larry
Downes notes that concerns about privacy are often the result of how
quickly new information technologies can disrupt traditional patterns of
311 David Kravets, Dec. 7, 1999: RIAA Sues Napster, WIRED, Dec. 7, 2009, at
http://www.wired.com/2009/12/1207riaa-sues-napster/
343 Donald Harris, The New Prohibition: A Look at the Copyright Wars Through the
Lens of Alcohol Prohibition, 80 TENN. L. REv. 101 (2012).
344 Raustalia and Sprigman, Knockoff Economy, p 222(?)
345 Id at 183(?) Also: "Total revenues from live shows grew from $7.3 billion in 2006
to $10.3 billion in 2011."
316 Michael Masnick & Michael Ho, The Sky is Rising: A Detailed Look at the State of
the Entertainment Industry (Jan. 2012), available at
https:/Avww.documentcloud.org/documents/562830-the-sky-is-rising.html
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
information access and use.347 "Still, after the initial panic," he writes, "we
almost always embrace the service that once violated our visceral sense of
privacy." 348 It happened with the introduction of cameras 100 years ago,349
and more recently with the introduction of ad-supported Gmail.35° In the
security context, governments and private firms have been largely unable to
control distributed denial of service attacks, but solutions have emerged that
allow a victim to deflect or more easily absorb attack traffic 35I
The point it not that policymakers should give up once intermediary
control becomes ineffectual; quite the contrary. It's that in the face of a new
technological reality that cuts off certain choices, policymakers should be
prepared not to fight against the new reality, but instead to discover and
pursue strategies consistent with the new reality.
As Bitcoin and related technologies make gambling, prediction markets,
and financial markets decentralized and therefore not easily regulated,
policymakers might find that legalizing and normalizing these activities,
along with promoting education, may yield better public policy outcomes
than trying to wage losing battles. They might also find that some of the
rationales for regulation no longer apply in a decentralized and
disintermediated context. For example, gambling and market regulations are
often aimed at protecting consumers by attempting to eliminate information
asymmetries, but because decentralized peer-to-peer exchanges have no
intermediaries, and because they are inherently public and transparent, there
can be no such asymmetry.
CONCLUSION
Bitcoin presents a unique challenge to policymakers. To date, Bitcoin-
related regulation has largely been focused on the application of "know
your customer," anti-money-laundering rules, as well as consumer
protection licensing, on these new intermediaries. The next major wave of
Bitcoin regulation will likely be aimed at financial instruments, including
securities and derivatives, as well as prediction markets and even gambling.
Following the approach to Bitcoin taken by FinCEN, we conclude that other
financial regulators should consider exempting or excluding certain
financial transactions denominated in Bitcoin from the full scope of the
317 Larry Downes, A Rational Response to the Privacy "Crisis," Cato Institute Policy
Analysis No. 716 (Jan. 7, 2013), available at
http://www.cato.orgisites/cato.orgifiles/pubs/pdf/pa7 I 6.pdf
348 Id.
351 Prolexic -- see Fatal System Error by Menn.
Discussion Draft — April 10, 2014 — Please do not cite.
regulations, much like private securities offerings and forward contracts are
treated. We also suggest that to the extent that regulation and enforcement
becomes more costly than its benefits, policymakers should consider and
pursue strategies consistent with that new reality, such as efforts to
encourage resilience and adaption.
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Kyara Investment [crypto] Epstein crypto fund, all but one created jointly with Joi Ito 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01108775 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Epstein crypto fund Kyara Investment I LLC (Physical Graph Corporation) operating agreement
(inferred date: 2014-05-05)
KYARA INVESTMENTS I LLC
OPERATING AGREEMENT
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT is made as of the 5th day of May, 2014 by and
among Kyara Investments I LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the "Company"),
those persons who execute this Agreement as of the date hereof, and those other
persons, if any, who from time to time become parties to or are otherwise bound by this
Agreement as provided herein.
RECITALS

A. On May 5, 2014, the Company was formed by the Members by the filing of
the Certificate of Formation with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware.

B. The Members now desire to enter into this Agreement in order to set forth
the respective rights and obligations of the Members in regard to the ownership,
management and governance of the Company.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and other valuable
consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the Members and the
Company agree as follows:
ARTICLE 1
DEFINED TERMS
1.1 "Act" means the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act, as amended
from time to time.
1.2 "Adiusted Capital Account Balance" means, with respect to each Member,
such Member's Capital Account balance maintained in accordance with this Agreement,
as of the end of the relevant fiscal year of the Company, after giving effect to the
following adjustments:

(a) Credit to such Capital Account of such Member's share of minimum
gain determined in accordance with Regulations Sections 1.704-2(g)(1) and
1.704-2(i)(5); and

(b) Debit to such Capital Account of the items described in Regulations

Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), (5) and (6).
The foregoing definition of "Adjusted Capital Account Balance" is intended to comply
with the provisions of Regulations Sections 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d) and 1.704-2, and shall
be interpreted consistently therewith.
1.3 "Affiliate" means, with respect to any Person, any other Person that,
directly or indirectly, controls, is under common control with, or is controlled by the
former Person. For purposes of this definition, "control" (including, with correlative
meaning, the terms "controlled by" and "under common control with"), as used with
respect to any Person, shall mean the possession, directly or indirectly, of the power to
direct and cause the direction of the management and policies of such Person, whether
through the ownership of voting securities, by contract or otherwise.
1.4 "Agreement" means this Operating Agreement of the Company, and all
amendments thereto.
1.5 "Approved Sale" has the meaning set forth in Section 9.2(a).
1.6 "Capital Account" means, with respect to each Member, the Capital
Account maintained for such Member in accordance with the following provisions:

(a) To each Member's Capital Account there shall be credited such
Member's Capital Contributions, such Member's distributive share of Profits and
the amount of any Company liabilities assumed by such Member or which are
secured by any property distributed to such Member by the Company.

(b) To each Member's Capital Account there shall be debited the
amount of cash and the Gross Asset Value of any property distributed to such
Member pursuant to any provision of this Agreement, and such Member's
distributive share of Losses.

(c) In the event all or a portion of a Member's Membership Interests
are transferred in accordance with the terms of this Agreement, the transferee
shall succeed to the Capital Account of the transferor to the extent it relates to
the transferred Membership Interests.
(d) In determining the amount of any liability for purposes of the
foregoing subparagraph (a), there shall be taken into account Code

Section 752(c) and any other applicable provisions of the Code and Regulations.
The foregoing provisions and the other provisions of this Agreement relating to
the maintenance of Capital Accounts are intended to comply with Regulations
Sections 1.704-1(b) and 1.704-2, and shall be interpreted and applied in a manner
consistent with such Regulations. In the event the Manager shall reasonably determine
that it is prudent to modify the manner in which the Capital Accounts, or any debits or
credits thereto, are computed in order to comply with such Regulations, the Manager,
with the Consent of the Members, may make such modification; provided that such
modification is not likely to have a material effect on the amount distributed to any
Member pursuant to Article 10 hereof upon the liquidation of the Company.
1.7 "Capital Contributions" means the aggregate amount of cash and Gross
Asset Value of property (less the amount of indebtedness, if any, of such Member which
is assumed by the Company and/or the amount of indebtedness, if any, to which such
property is subject, as of the date of contribution, without regard to the provisions of
Code Section 7701(g)) contributed by a Member to the capital of the Company.
2
1.8 "Cash Flow" means, for any period, the amount by which (a) the gross
cash receipts of the Company from any source for such period (including, but not limited
to, Capital Contributions, loans, distributions received by the Company in respect of any
stock, partnership interest or other equity interest owned by the Company, and
proceeds from the sale, financing, refinancing or other disposition of all or any portion of
the Company property), exceed (b) the sum of (i) the aggregate cash disbursements for
such period (including, but not limited to, Company administrative costs,
reimbursements paid to the Manager in respect of his or her day-to-day management
activities hereunder, principal and interest payable on Company debt and capital
expenditures), and (ii) amounts previously set aside as reserves as determined by the
Manager in his or her discretion.
1.9 "Certificate" means the Certificate of Formation of the Company, as
amended from time to time, as filed in accordance with the Act.
1.10 "Code" means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (or any
corresponding provision of succeeding law).
1.11 "Company" means the limited liability company herein formed and known
as Kyara Investments I LLC, as said Company may from time to time be constituted.
1.12 "Consent" means the prior written consent or approval of a Person or
Persons to do the act or thing for which the consent or approval is solicited, or the act of
granting such consent or approval as the context may require.
1.13 "Depreciation" means, for each fiscal year or other period, an amount
equal to the depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deduction allowable with
respect to an asset for such year or other period, except that if the Gross Asset Value of
an asset differs from its adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes at the beginning
of such year or other period, Depreciation shall be an amount which bears the same
ratio to such beginning Gross Asset Value as the federal income tax depreciation,
amortization or other cost recovery deduction for such year or other period bears to
such beginning adjusted tax basis; provided, however, that if the federal income tax
depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deduction from such year or other
period is zero, Depreciation shall be determined with reference to such beginning Gross
Asset Value using any reasonable method selected by the Manager with the Consent of
the Members.
1.14 "Gross Asset Value" means, with respect to any asset, the asset's
adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes, except as follows:

(a) The initial Gross Asset Value of any asset contributed by a Member
to the Company shall be the gross fair market value of such asset, as determined
by the contributing Member and the Manager;

(b) The Gross Asset Values of all Company assets shall be adjusted to
equal their respective gross fair market values, as reasonably determined by the
Members, as of the following times: (i) the acquisition of additional Membership
3
Interests in the Company by any new or existing Member in exchange for more
than a de minimis capital contribution; (ii) the distribution by the Company to a
Member of more than a de minimis amount of Company assets, including money,
as consideration for an interest in the Company; and (iii) the liquidation of the
Company within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(g);
provided, however, that adjustments pursuant to the preceding clauses (i) and (ii)
shall be made only if the Members reasonably determine that such adjustments
are necessary or appropriate to reflect the relative economic interests of the
Members in the Company;

(c) The Gross Asset Value of any Company asset distributed to any
Member shall be the gross fair market value of such asset on the date of
distribution; and
(d) The Gross Asset Values of Company assets shall be increased (or
decreased) to reflect any adjustments to the adjusted basis of such assets
pursuant to Code Section 734(b) or Code Section 743(b), but only to the extent
that such adjustments are taken into account in determining Capital Accounts
pursuant to Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(m) and the definition of "Capital
Account" herein.
If the Gross Asset Value of an asset has been determined or adjusted pursuant to any
of the foregoing subparagraphs (a), (b) or (d) of this Section, such Gross Asset Value
shall thereafter be adjusted by the Depreciation taken into account with respect to such
asset for purposes of computing Profits and Losses.
1.15 "Investment" has the meaning set forth in Section 2.2.
1.16 "Manager" means the Person designated or appointed as Manager
pursuant to this Agreement, and any other Person who becomes a successor or
additional Manager of the Company pursuant to this Agreement.
1.17 "Member" means any Person who is designated as a Member on Exhibit A
to this Agreement at the time of reference thereto and who is acting in such Person's
capacity as a Member of the Company, and any other Persons who from time to time
become parties to or are otherwise bound by this Agreement as Members.
1.18 "Membership Interest" means an ownership interest of a Member in the
Company at any particular time, including the right of such Member to any and all
benefits to which a Member may be entitled pursuant to this Agreement and under the
Act, together with all obligations of such Member to comply with the terms and
provisions of this Agreement and the Act. Membership Interests are owned by
Members as set forth in Exhibit A to this Agreement, as amended from time to time.
1.19 "Notice" means a writing, containing the information required by this
Agreement to be communicated to any Person, and given or delivered in accordance
with the requirements of this Agreement.
4
1.20 "Person" means any individual, partnership, limited liability company,
corporation, trust, estate or other entity.
1.21 "Profits" and "Losses" means, for each fiscal year or other period, an
amount equal to the Company's taxable income or loss for such year or period,
determined in accordance with Code Section 703(a) (for this purpose, all items of
income, gain, loss or deduction required to be stated separately pursuant to Code

Section 703(a)(1) shall be included in taxable income or loss), with the following
adjustments:

(a) Any income of the Company that is exempt from federal income tax
and not otherwise taken into account in computing Profits or Losses pursuant to
this definition shall be added to such taxable income or loss;

(b) Any expenditures of the Company described in Code

Section 705(a)(2)(B), or treated as Code Section 705(a)(2)(B) expenditures
pursuant to Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(i), and not otherwise taken into
account in computing Profits or Losses pursuant to this definition shall be
subtracted from such taxable income or loss;

(c) In the event the Gross Asset Value of any Company asset is
adjusted pursuant to subparagraph (b) or (d) of Section 1.14 hereof, the amount
of such adjustment shall be taken into account as gain or loss from the
disposition of such asset for purposes of computing Profits or Losses;

(d) Gain or loss resulting from any disposition of property with respect
to which gain or loss is recognized for federal income tax purposes shall be
computed by reference to the Gross Asset Value of the property disposed of
notwithstanding that the adjusted tax basis of such property differs from its Gross
Asset Value; and
(e) Depreciation shall be taken into account for such fiscal year or
other period in computing such taxable income or loss, in lieu of the depreciation,
amortization and other cost recovery deductions that otherwise may be taken into
account in the absence of Section 1.13.
1.22 "Regulations" means the United States Treasury Regulations, as
amended from time to time.
1.23 "Sale of the Company" means the sale of the Company to any party on an
arms-length basis, pursuant to which such party or parties acquire (i) a majority of the
Membership Interests in the Company (whether by sale of Membership Interests or
merger or otherwise), or (ii) all or substantially all of the Company's assets, determined
on a consolidated basis.
1.24 "Transfer" has the meaning set forth in Section 9.1.
1.25 "Unreturned Capital Contributions" means, with respect to any Member,
5
the difference between (a) the Capital Contributions made by such Member, less (b) the
aggregate amount of distributions made to such Member pursuant to Section 4.6(a).
ARTICLE 2
THE COMPANY
2.1 Formation and Name. The Company has been formed as a limited liability
company pursuant to the provisions of the Act. The Company was formed with the
name "Kyara Investments I LLC"; provided that the Company may hereafter adopt such
other name or names as the Manager may from time to time select.
2.2 Purpose. The Company has been organized to engage in the ownership
and management of an equity investment in Physical Graph Corporation, a Delaware
corporation (the "Investment") and, with the Consent of the Members, in any and all
other lawful businesses or activities which a limited liability company may carry on
under the Act and the laws of any other jurisdiction in which the Company is so
engaged.
2.3 Registered Agent. The Company's registered agent shall be the Person
designated by the Manager from time to time to serve in that capacity in accordance
with the terms of the Act.
2.4 Qualification in Additional Jurisdictions. The Manager is authorized, with
the Consent of the Members, to qualify the Company to do business in any jurisdiction
in which such qualification is deemed by the Manager as necessary or desirable in
carrying out the Company's business, and pursuant thereto, to appoint a registered
agent and to establish a registered office in such jurisdiction, and to cause the Company
to operate in such jurisdiction under another name selected by the Manager, in
compliance with the assumed name statute of such jurisdiction, if the Company is not
allowed under the laws of such jurisdiction to operate under its legal name.
ARTICLE 3
MEMBERSHIP INTERESTS; CONTRIBUTIONS BY THE MEMBERS
3.1 Membership Interests. The Company shall issue one type of ownership
interest, with such rights, preferences and obligations as set forth in this Agreement.
Holders of Membership Interests shall be entitled to one vote per Membership Interest
held; provided that such holder is also a Member. Notwithstanding anything to the
contrary contained in this Agreement, no Person shall be entitled to vote with respect to
any Membership Interests unless such person is a Member.
3.2 Initial Capital of the Company. On or prior to the date hereof, each of the
Members (or the Person from whom such Member acquired, directly or indirectly, its, his
or her Membership Interests) has made an initial Capital Contribution to the Company
as provided on Exhibit A attached hereto. In exchange therefor, each Member (or the
Person from whom such Member acquired, directly or indirectly, its, his or her
6
Membership Interests) has received that number of Membership Interests set forth on
such Exhibit A.
3.3 No Additional Capital Contributions. No Member shall be required to
make any additional Capital Contribution to the Company.
3.4 Withdrawal. Except as otherwise provided in Article 9 of this Agreement,
no Member shall be entitled to withdraw or resign from the Company, prior to its
dissolution and winding up, without first obtaining the Consent of the Manager.
3.5 Additional Membership Interests. No additional Membership Interests
shall be issued by the Company without the Consent of the Members.
ARTICLE 4
CAPITAL ACCOUNTS; PROFITS AND LOSSES; DISTRIBUTIONS
4.1 Capital Accounts. The Company shall establish and maintain a Capital
Account for each Member.
4.2 Allocation of Profits and Losses.

(a) Profits of the Company shall be allocated among the Members as
follows:
(i) First, to each Member pro rata and in proportion to the
cumulative Losses, if any, allocated to such Member pursuant to

Section 4.2(b)(ii) hereof until the cumulative Profits allocated to such
Member under this Section 4.2(a)(i) equals the cumulative Losses
allocated to such Member under Section 4.2(b)(i) hereof; and

(ii) Then, the balance, if any, to the Members in accordance
with their respective Membership Interests.
(b) Losses of the Company shall be allocated to the Members as
follows:

(i) First, to the Members in accordance with their respective
Membership Interests; provided, however, that no Member shall be
allocated Losses in excess of its, his or her Adjusted Capital Account
Balance, determined immediately prior to the allocation provided for in this

Section 4.2(b)(i); and
(ii) Then, to the extent any Losses allocated to a Member
pursuant to Section 4.2(b)(i) would, but for the proviso contained therein,
exceed a Member's Adjusted Capital Account Balance, such Losses shall
be allocated first to the other Members in proportion to, and to the extent
of, their respective Adjusted Capital Account Balances, and then to any
7
Member guaranteeing debt of the Company, making loans to the
Company or otherwise having liability for Company debt, in proportion to
the debt guaranteed, the loans made or the amount of such liability.
4.3 Reallocation by Manager. The allocation of Profits and Losses in

Section 4.2 is intended to have substantial economic effect within the meaning of
Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2) or be in accordance with the Members' interests in
the Company within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(4). If subsequent
events (including, but not limited to, nonrecourse borrowing by the Company or a loan
by a Member to the Company) cause, in the reasonable opinion of the Manager, the

Section 4.2 allocations to have neither substantial economic effect nor be in accordance
with the Members' interests in the Company, the Manager may (a) allocate the income,
gain, loss, deduction and credit of the Company so that such allocations are in
accordance with the Members' Membership Interests; or (b) make such other
modifications to this Agreement (including, but not limited to, the addition of minimum
gain chargeback, qualified income offset and other special allocation provisions
specified in Regulations Sections 1.704-2 or 1.704-1(b)) that are necessary in the
reasonable opinion of the Manager to cause such allocations to have substantial
economic effect within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2).
4.4 Tax Allocations. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, all items
of income, gain, loss and deduction shall be allocated, for federal and state income tax
purposes, among the Members in the same manner as the corresponding items of
income, gain, loss and deduction are allocated for purposes of maintaining the Capital
Account of each of the Members.
4.5 Section 704(c) Allocations. In accordance with Code Section 704(c) and
the Regulations thereunder, income, gain, loss and deduction with respect to any
property contributed to the capital of the Company shall, solely for tax purposes, be
allocated among the Members so as to take account of any variation between the
adjusted basis of such property to the Company for federal income tax purposes and its
initial Gross Asset Value, including, but not limited to, special allocations to a
contributing Member that are required under Code Section 704(c) to be made upon
distribution of such property to any of the noncontributing Members. In the event the
Gross Asset Value of any property of the Company is adjusted pursuant to
subparagraph (b) of Section 1.14, subsequent allocations of income, gain, loss and
deduction with respect to such property shall take account of any variation between the
adjusted basis of such property for federal income tax purposes and its Gross Asset
Value in the same manner as under Code Section 704(c) and the Regulations
thereunder. Any elections or other decisions relating to such allocations shall be made
by the Manager in any manner that reasonably reflects the purpose and intention of this
Agreement. Allocations pursuant to this Section 4.5 are solely for purposes of federal,
state and local taxes and shall not affect, or in any way be taken into account in
computing, a Members Capital Account or share of Profits or Losses, other items or
distributions pursuant to any provision of this Agreement.
8
4.6 Distribution of Cash Flow. To the extent there is Cash Flow available for
distribution, as reasonably determined by the Manager, and in any event not later than
45 days after the receipt by the Company of the proceeds from the sale of the
Investment, the Manager shall cause the Company to distribute such available Cash
Flow:

(a) first, to those Members with Unreturned Capital Contributions, pro
rata in proportion to the amount of such Unreturned Capital Contributions, until
the amount of each Member's Unreturned Capital Contributions has been
reduced to zero; and

(b) thereafter, to the Members, pro rata in accordance with their
respective Membership Interests.
ARTICLE 5
MANAGEMENT
5.1 Initial Manager. The management of the Company's business shall be
vested in one Manager unless a greater number of Managers shall be fixed from time to
time by action of the Members. The initial Manager of the Company shall be Joichi Ito.
A Manager shall hold office until his, her or its death, removal, or resignation.
5.2 Management Authority.

(a) Except as otherwise authorized in this Agreement, all management
decisions of the Company (including, without limitation, any actions or votes
taken by or on behalf of the Company in respect of any equity interest held by the
Company in another entity) shall be made by the Manager, who shall be
responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company, subject to the
provisions of this Agreement and the Act. The Manager shall have all of the
rights, powers, duties and obligations of managers as provided in the Act, and as
otherwise provided by law, and any action taken by the Manager, not otherwise
in violation of the Act or this Agreement, shall constitute the act of and serve to
bind the Company.
(b) Only the Manager and agents of the Company authorized by the
Manager shall have the authority to bind the Company. The Manager is an agent
of the Company for the purpose of its business, and the act of the Manager,
including the execution in the Company's name of any instrument for apparently
carrying on in the usual way the business of the Company, binds the Company,
unless such act is in contravention of the Act or this Agreement or any
agreement between the Manager and the Company or unless the Manager so
acting otherwise lacks the authority to act for the Company and the Person with
whom the Manager is dealing has knowledge of the fact that he, she or it has no
such authority. If the Manager acts without the requisite authority, the Manager
shall be liable for any damages or liabilities arising with respect to such action
9
unless the Manager can show that he, she or it reasonably believed after due
inquiry that such action was authorized.
5.3 Limitation on Liability. The Manager shall perform his, her or its duties as
the Manager in good faith, in a manner he, she or it reasonably believes to be in the
best interest of the Company and the Members, and with such care as an ordinarily
prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances. A Person who
so performs his, her or its duties shall not have any liability by reason of being or having
been a Manager of the Company, except where the claim at issue is based on the
fraud, gross negligence or bad faith of the Manager.
5.4 Removal of the Manager. The Manager may be removed with or without
cause upon the Consent of the Members, but such removal shall be without prejudice to
any contract rights the Manager may have under this Agreement. Any removal of the
Manager shall become effective on such date as may be specified by the Members
voting in favor thereof. Should the Manager be removed who is also a Member, such
Member will continue to participate in the Company as a Member and enjoy the burdens
and benefits of his or her Membership Interests.
5.5 Resignation of the Manager. The Manager may resign at any time by
giving Notice to the Members. The resignation of the Manager shall take effect upon
receipt of such Notice or at such later date as specified in such Notice. The acceptance
of the resignation of the Manager shall not be necessary to make such resignation
effective. The resignation of the Manager who is also a Member shall not affect the
Manager's rights as a Member and shall not constitute a withdrawal of the Member.
5.6 Appointment of New Manager. If a vacancy in the office of Manager
occurs, a new Manager shall be designated with the Consent of the Members to fill such
vacancy, provided that in the event of the death, removal, or resignation of Joichi Ito as
the Manager, Darren K. Indyke shall become the succeeding Manager, unless another
Manager is appointed with the Consent of the Members. In the event that any vacancy
in the office of Manager is not filled as provided in the preceding sentence,
management of the Company shall be vested in the Members.
5.7 Indemnification by the Company. The Company shall indemnify the
Manager for all costs, losses, liabilities and damages paid or incurred by the Manager in
connection with the business of the Company to the fullest extent provided or permitted
by the Act and the other laws of the State of Delaware, except where the claim at issue
is based on the fraud, gross negligence or bad faith of the Manager. In connection
therewith, the Company shall advance to the Manager as they are paid or incurred all
expenses arising with respect to the defense of any matter as to which the Company
will be obligated to provide indemnification pursuant to this Section 5.7.
10
ARTICLE 6
MEMBERS
6.1 Powers of Members. Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 5.2, the
Members shall have the right to Consent to the following matters:

(a) removal of the Manager as provided in Section 5.4;
(b) designation of a new Manager upon the resignation, removal, death
or permanent disability of the then-current Manager as provided in Section 5.6

(c) approval either of any Transfer of any Membership Interests or of
any party becoming a Member as provided in Article 9; and
(d) dissolution of the Company as provided in Article 10.
6.2 Partition. While the Company remains in effect or is continued, each
Member waives its rights to have any Company property partitioned, or to file a
complaint or to institute any suit, action or proceeding at law or in equity to have any
Company property partitioned, and each Member, on behalf of itself, its successors and
its assigns hereby waives any such right.
6.3 Authority. Except as expressly authorized in this Agreement, no Member
shall take any action as a Member to bind the Company, and each Member shall
indemnify the Company for any costs or damages incurred by the Company as the
result of the unauthorized action of such Member.
6.4 Vote of the Members. An affirmative vote or consent by or on behalf of all
of the Members shall be required to approve or disapprove any matter on which the
Members are entitled or required to decide or Consent, except as otherwise provided in
this Agreement, the Certificate or the Act.
ARTICLE 7
TRANSACTIONS; AFFILIATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
7.1 Transactions Between a Member or Manager and the Company. Except
as otherwise limited by applicable law, with the Consent of the Members any Member or
Manager may, but shall not be obligated to, lend money to the Company, act as surety
for the Company and transact other business with the Company, and shall have the
same rights and obligations when transacting business with the Company as a person
or entity who is not a Member or Manager.
7.2 Affiliated Party Transactions. The Members acknowledge that the
Company is being formed initially to purchase and then hold an investment in Physical
Graph Corporation, a Delaware corporation, for which the Manager may provide certain
advisory or consulting services or on whose board of directors the Manager may serve.
11
In connection therewith, the Members acknowledge such potential conflict of interest
and waive and consent to any such transaction that may be approved on behalf of the
Company as provided in this Agreement.
ARTICLE 8
FISCAL YEAR; BOOKS AND RECORDS; BANK ACCOUNTS
8.1 Bank Accounts. The funds of the Company shall be deposited in such
federally insured bank account or accounts or other financial intermediary as the
Manager in his or her discretion determine are required, and the Manager shall arrange
for the appropriate conduct of such accounts.
8.2 Books and Records.

(a) There shall be kept and maintained full and accurate books
respecting the business of the Company showing all receipts and expenditures,
assets and liabilities, profits, losses and distributions, and all other records
reasonably necessary or appropriate for recording the Company's business
affairs at the Company's principal place of business or such other location as the
Manager may determine provided that all of the Members are informed of such
other location. Such books and records shall be open to inspection by any
Member (or such Members authorized representative) upon reasonable notice
and during ordinary business hours
(b) The books of the Company shall be kept on the method of
accounting determined by the Members, and shall show at all times each and
every item of income, gain, loss and expense.
8.3 Fiscal Year. The fiscal year of the Company shall be the calendar year.
8.4 Tax Matters Partner. Pursuant to Code Section 6231, the Person
designated by the Manager from time to time shall act as the Tax Matters Partner of the
Company. The Tax Matters Partner shall prepare and provide to each Member all
necessary tax forms and information to enable the Members to meet their tax filing
obligations on a timely basis and shall, within 30 days after receipt thereof, forward to
each Member a photocopy of any notices relating to the Company received from the
Internal Revenue Service or other revenue authority.
8.5 Tax Returns. In addition to the requirements of Section 8.2, tax returns of
the Company shall be prepared by the Person selected by the Manager.
ARTICLE 9
TRANSFERS
9.1 General Provision. No Member shall, directly or indirectly, voluntarily or
involuntarily, sell, assign, transfer, pledge, hypothecate, encumber or otherwise dispose
12
of ("Transfer") the whole or any part of its, his or her Membership Interests in the
Company, except to Affiliates of such Member or with the Consent of the Members.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, if any such Member is an individual, such Person's
Membership Interests may pass to his or her estate upon his or her death subject to the
other provisions of this Agreement. Except in connection with transfers during an
individual Member's lifetime to Affiliates as permitted pursuant to this Section 9.1, which
Affiliates shall become Members when the transfers become effective as hereinafter
provided, no transferee shall become a Member without the Consent of the Members.
Transfers to Affiliates shall be effective upon the Affiliates entering into this Agreement
and notice thereof being provided to the other Members.
9.2 Sale of the Company.

(a) If the Manager approves a Sale of the Company (an "Approved
Sale"), then each Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will
consent to and raise no objection to the Approved Sale, and if the Approved Sale
is structured as a sale of Membership Interests, then each Member and any
other holder of Membership Interests will agree to sell all of their Membership
Interests on the same terms and conditions as approved by the Manager. Each
Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will take all actions which
the Manager deems reasonably necessary in connection with the consummation
of the Approved Sale.

(b) The obligations of the Members and any other holders of
Membership Interests with respect to the Approved Sale are subject to the
condition that upon the consummation of the Approved Sale, all of the holders of
Membership Interests will, subject to Section 4.6, receive substantially the same
form and amount of consideration for their Membership Interests sold, or if any
such Membership Interests are given an option as to the form and amount of
consideration to be received, all such holders will be given the same option.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, nothing contained in this Section 9.2(b) shall
prevent any individual from receiving an offer of employment upon reasonable
terms in connection with services to be provided after the consummation of the
Approved Sale.

(c) Each Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will
bear their pro rata share (based upon the total amount of Membership Interests
sold) of the cost of any sale of Membership Interests pursuant to an Approved
Sale to the extent such costs are incurred for the benefit of all holders of
Membership Interests and are not otherwise paid by the Company. Costs
incurred by Members and the other holders of Membership Interests on their own
behalf, will not be considered costs of the Approved Sale contemplated
hereunder.
13
ARTICLE 10
DISSOLUTION AND TERMINATION
10.1 Dissolution. The Company shall be dissolved upon the Consent of the
Members or as otherwise provided by the Articles or the Act.
10.2 Procedures Upon Dissolution.

(a) Upon dissolution of the Company, the Company shall be terminated
and the Manager, or if there is no Manager, the Members, shall liquidate the
assets of the Company. The proceeds of liquidation shall be applied and
distributed in the following order of priority:

(i) First, to the payment of the debts and liabilities of the
Company (other than any loans or advances made by any of the Members
to the Company) and the expenses of liquidation;

(ii) Second, to the creation of any reserves which the Manager
or liquidating Members deem reasonably necessary for the payment of
any contingent or unforeseen liabilities or obligations of the Company or
Members (to the extent the Company is liable therefor) arising out of or in
connection with the business and operation of the Company;
(iii) Third, to the payment of any loans or advances made by any
of the Members to the Company; and
(iv) Thereafter, to the Members in the manner, and in the
priorities set forth in Section 4.6.
(b) A reasonable time shall be allowed for the orderly liquidation of the
assets of the Company and the discharge of liabilities. During the period
beginning with the dissolution of the Company and ending with its liquidation and
termination of this Agreement pursuant to this Section 10.2, the business affairs
of the Company shall be conducted by the Manager or, if there is no Manager, by
the Members. During such period, the business and affairs of the Company shall
be conducted so as to preserve the assets of the Company and maintain the
status which existed immediately prior to such termination.
ARTICLE 11
MISCELLANEOUS
11.1 Binding Agreement. Subject to the restrictions on transfers and
encumbrances set forth herein, this Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be
binding upon the parties hereto and their respective heirs, executors, legal
14
representatives, successors and permitted assigns. Whenever in this instrument a
reference to any party or Member is made, such reference shall be deemed to include a
reference to the heirs, executors, legal representatives, successors and permitted
assigns of each Member.
11.2 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in several counterparts,
each of which shall be deemed an original, but all of which shall constitute one and the
same instrument. In addition, this Agreement may contain more than one counterpart of
the signature pages and this Agreement may be executed by the affixing of the
signatures of each of the Members to one of such counterpart signature pages; all of
such signature pages shall be read as though, and this Agreement shall have the same
force and effect as though, all of the signers had signed a single signature page.
11.3 Effect of Consent or Waiver. No consent or waiver by any party hereto to
or of any breach or default by any other party hereto in the performance by such other
party hereto of its, his or her obligations hereunder shall be effective unless in writing,
and signed by the party hereto against whom such waiver is sought to be enforced, and
no such consent or waiver shall be deemed or construed to be a consent or waiver to or
of any other breach or default by such other party hereto in the performance by such
other party hereto of the same or any other obligations of such party hereto hereunder.
Failure on the part of any party hereto to object to or complain of any act or failure to act
of any of the other parties hereto or to declare any of the other parties hereto in default,
regardless of how long such failure continues, shall not constitute a waiver by any such
party hereto of its, his or her rights hereunder.
11.4 Enforceability. If any provision of this Agreement or the application thereof
to any Person or circumstances shall be invalid or unenforceable to any extent, the
remainder of this Agreement and the application of such provisions to other Persons or
circumstances shall not be affected thereby and shall be enforced to the greatest extent
permitted by law.
11.5 Entire Agreement. This Agreement contains all of the terms agreed upon
by the parties hereto with respect to the subject matter hereof, and supersedes all prior
agreements, arrangements and communications between the parties dealing with the
Membership Interests, whether oral or written.
11.6 Governing Law; Jurisdiction. In all respects, including all matters of
construction, validity and performance, the Agreement and the obligations arising
hereunder shall be governed by, and construed and enforced in accordance with, the
laws of the State of Delaware, applicable to contracts made and performed in such
state, without regard to the principles thereof regarding conflict of laws. The Company
and each of the parties hereto agree to submit to personal jurisdiction and to waive any
objection as to venue in the courts located in either the county in which the Company's
principal office is located within the State of Delaware or the county in which the
Company's registered office is located within the State of Delaware. Service of process
on the Company and any of the parties hereto in any action arising out of or relating to
this Agreement shall be effective if mailed by certified mail, return receipt requested or
15
delivered by reputable overnight courier to such party at the address set forth on
Exhibit A attached hereto.
11.7 Liability Among Members. No Member shall be liable to any other
Member or to the Manager by reason of its, his or her actions or omissions in
connection with the Company, unless otherwise provided in this Agreement, and except
for acts or omissions or alleged acts or omissions that were performed or omitted
fraudulently or in bad faith or as a result of gross negligence or willful misconduct.
11.8 No Partnership Intended for Nontax Purposes. The Members have
formed the Company under the Act and expressly do not intend hereby to form a
partnership under the laws of any jurisdiction. The Members do not intend to be
partners one to another, or partners as to any third party. To the extent any Member, by
word or action, represents to another Person that any other Member is a partner or that
the Company is a partnership, the Member making such wrongful representation shall
be liable to any other Member who incurs personal liability by reason of such wrongful
representation.
11.9 Amendment. This Agreement may be amended or modified only with the
Consent of the Members.
11.10 Notices. Any Notice to the Manager or Members required under the terms
of this Agreement shall be sent to their respective addresses, as set forth on Exhibit A
attached hereto. All Notices and copies thereof provided for herein shall be hand
delivered with receipt therefor, sent by overnight courier service with receipt therefor, or
sent by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, and first-class postage
prepaid. Changes of address may be given to the Company, the Manager, and the
Members by Notice given in accordance with the terms of this Section. Time periods
shall commence on the date that such Notice is shown as delivered upon any such
receipt or attempted to be delivered if receipt thereof is refused by the recipient. Any
Notice that is required to be given within a stated period of time shall be considered
timely made or given if delivered or postmarked before 11:59 •., local time, on the
last day of such period.
11.11 Business Pursuits of Members and Manager. Except as otherwise
provided in any other written agreement by which any Member or the Manager may be
bound, the Manager and each Member may engage in other business activities. Except
as otherwise provided in this Agreement or in any other written agreement by which any
Member or Manager may be bound, this Agreement shall not preclude or limit in any
respect the right of any Member or the Manager to engage in or invest in any business
activity of any nature or description. Any such permitted activity may be engaged in
independently or with other Members or the Manager. No Member or Manager shall
have the right, by virtue of this the Certificate, this Agreement or the relationship created
hereby, to any interest in such other permitted ventures or activities or to the income or
proceeds derived therefrom. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement or in any
other written agreement by which any Member or Manager may be bound, the pursuit of
such permitted ventures shall not be deemed wrongful or improper and any Member or
16
Manager shall have the right to participate in or to recommend to others any investment
opportunity.
11.12 Expenses. The Company shall recognize $2,000 of the out-of-pocket
expenses actually incurred by Joichi Ito in connection with the organization of the
Company as an initial capital contribution by such Member, and up to $2,000 of the
annual out-of-pocket expenses actually incurred by any Member of the Company in
connection with the operation of the Company each year as an additional capital
contribution by such Member when paid by such Member.
11.13 References. References herein to the singular shall include the plural and
to the plural shall include the singular, and references to one gender shall include the
others, except where the same shall not be appropriate.
11.14 Titles and Captions. Section titles or captions contained in this Agreement
are for convenience only and shall not be deemed a part of the content of this
Agreement.
11.15 Delivery by Facsimile or Electronic Mail. This Agreement, the agreements
referred to herein, and each other agreement or instrument entered into in connection
herewith or therewith or contemplated hereby or thereby, and any amendments hereto
or thereto, to the extent signed and delivered by means of a facsimile machine, pdf
attachment to an email or other electronic means, shall be treated in all manner and
respects as an original agreement or instrument and shall be considered to have the
same binding legal effect as if it were the original signed version thereof delivered in
person. At the request of any party hereto or to any such agreement or instrument,
each other party hereto or thereto shall re-execute original forms thereof and deliver
them to all other parties. No party hereto or to any such agreement or instrument shall
raise the use of such means to deliver a signature or the fact that any signature or
agreement or instrument was transmitted or communicated through the use of such
means as a defense to the formation or enforceability of a contract and each party
hereto forever waives any such defense..
[Signature page follows]
17
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned parties here executed this Agreement
as of the date first set forth above.
Kyara Investments I LLC
By:
Joichi Ito, Manager
Joichi Ito
[Name of JE Entity]
By:
Its:
Joichi Ito, Manager
S-1
EXHIBIT A
The names, addresses and Membership Interests of the Members are set forth
below.
Name and Address
Number of
Membership
Interests
Percentage
Ownershi.
Initial
Capital
Contribution
Joichi Ito
63 Francis Ave.
Cambridge, MA 02138
500 50% $ 2,000
[Name of JE Entity] 500 50% 100,000
TOTAL 1,000 100.00% $ 102,000
Address of Manager and the Company:
Go Joichi Ito
63 Francis Ave.
Cambridge, MA 02138
EFTA00605699 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Epstein crypto fund Kyara Investment II LLC incorporation papers
(inferred timestamp: 2014-05-05 17:04:00)
Delaware The First State
PAGE 1
I, JEFFREY W. BULLOCK, SECRETARY OF STATE OF THE STATE OF
DELAWARE, DO HEREBY CERTIFY THE ATTACHED IS A TRUE AND CORRECT
COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF FORMATION OF "KYARA INVESTMENTS I
LLC", FILED IN THIS OFFICE ON THE FIFTH DAY OF MAY, A.D. 2014,
AT 4:55 O'CLOCK P.M.
AUTHEN
4\ "
Jeffrey W Secretary of Stale
CATION: 1346108
DATE: 05-05-14
You my verify this certificate online
at corp.delavare.goviauthver.shtml
State of Delaware
Secretary of State
Division ofCorporations
Delivered 05:04 PM 05/05/2014
CERTIFICATE OF FORMATION
OF
KYARA INVESTMENTS I LLC
The undersigned, an authorized person, for the purpose of forming a limited liability
company, under the provisions and subject to the requirements of the State of Delaware
(particularly Chapter 18, Title 6 of the Delaware Code and the acts amendatory thereof and
supplemental thereto, and known, identified, and referred to as the "Delaware Limited Liability
Company Ad"), hereby certifies that:
ARTICLE I. The name of the limited liability company is Kyara Investments I
LLC (the "Company").
ARTICLE II. The address of the registered office and the name and the address
of the registered agent of the limited liability company required to be maintained by Section 18-
Limited Liabilit Com an Act are C oration Service Company=
ARTICLE HI. The debts, obligations and liabilities of the Company, whether
arising in contract, tort or otherwise, shall be solely the debts, obligations and liabilities of the
Company, and no member or manager of the Company shall be obligated personally for any such
debt, obligation or liability of the Company solely by reason of being a member or acting as a
manager of the Company.
Dated as of the 5th day of May, 2014
By:  /s/ Dana L. Redburg
Name: Dana L. Redburg
Title: Authorized Person
973899.v1
EFTA01116280 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Epstein crypto fund Kyara Investment I LLC (Physical Graph Corporation) operating agreement with edits
(inferred timestamp: 2014-05-06 10:01:38)
KYARA INVESTMENTS I LLC
OPERATING AGREEMENT
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT is made as of the _5th day of  May, 2014
by and among Kyara Investments I LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the
"Company"), those persons who execute this Agreement as of the date hereof, and
those other persons, if any, who from time to time become parties to or are otherwise
bound by this Agreement as provided herein.
RECITALS

A. On  ,May 5, 2014, the Company was formed by the Members by the
filing of the Certificate of Formation with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware.

B. The Members now desire to enter into this Agreement in order to set forth
the respective rights and obligations of the Members in regard to the ownership,
management and governance of the Company.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and other valuable
consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the Members and the
Company agree as follows:
ARTICLE 1
DEFINED TERMS
1.1 "Act" means the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act, as amended
from time to time.
1.2 "Adiusted Capital Account Balance" means, with respect to each Member,
such Member's Capital Account balance maintained in accordance with this Agreement,
as of the end of the relevant fiscal year of the Company, after giving effect to the
following adjustments:

(a) Credit to such Capital Account of such Members share of minimum
gain determined in accordance with Regulations Sections 1.704-2(g)(1) and
1.704-2(i)(5); and

(b) Debit to such Capital Account of the items described in Regulations

Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), (5) and (6).
The foregoing definition of "Adjusted Capital Account Balance" is intended to comply
with the provisions of Regulations Sections 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d) and 1.704-2, and shall
be interpreted consistently therewith.
1.3 "Affiliate" means, with respect to any Person, any other Person that,
directly or indirectly, controls, is under common control with, or is controlled by the
former Person. For purposes of this definition, "control" (including, with correlative
943493 v5
meaning, the terms "controlled by" and "under common control with"), as used with
respect to any Person, shall mean the possession, directly or indirectly, of the power to
direct and cause the direction of the management and policies of such Person, whether
through the ownership of voting securities, by contract or otherwise.
1.4 "Agreement" means this Operating Agreement of the Company, and all
amendments thereto.
1.5 "Approved Sale" has the meaning set forth in Section 9.2(a).
1.6 "Capital Account" means, with respect to each Member, the Capital
Account maintained for such Member in accordance with the following provisions:

(a) To each Member's Capital Account there shall be credited such
Member's Capital Contributions, such Member's distributive share of Profits and
the amount of any Company liabilities assumed by such Member or which are
secured by any property distributed to such Member by the Company.

(b) To each Member's Capital Account there shall be debited the
amount of cash and the Gross Asset Value of any property distributed to such
Member pursuant to any provision of this Agreement, and such Member's
distributive share of Losses.

(c) In the event all or a portion of a Member's Membership Interests
are transferred in accordance with the terms of this Agreement, the transferee
shall succeed to the Capital Account of the transferor to the extent it relates to
the transferred Membership Interests.
(d) In determining the amount of any liability for purposes of the
foregoing subparagraph (a), there shall be taken into account Code Section
752(c) and any other applicable provisions of the Code and Regulations.
The foregoing provisions and the other provisions of this Agreement relating to
the maintenance of Capital Accounts are intended to comply with Regulations Sections
1.704-1(b) and 1.704-2, and shall be interpreted and applied in a manner consistent
with such Regulations. In the event the Manager shall reasonably determine that it is
prudent to modify the manner in which the Capital Accounts, or any debits or credits
thereto, are computed in order to comply with such Regulations, the Manager, with the
Consent of the Members, may make such modification; provided that such modification
is not likely to have a material effect on the amount distributed to any Member pursuant
to Article 10 hereof upon the liquidation of the Company.
1.7 "Capital Contributions" means the aggregate amount of cash and Gross
Asset Value of property (less the amount of indebtedness, if any, of such Member which
is assumed by the Company and/or the amount of indebtedness, if any, to which such
property is subject, as of the date of contribution, without regard to the provisions of
Code Section 7701(g)) contributed by a Member to the capital of the Company.
2
943193.v5
1.8 "Cash Flow" means, for any period, the amount by which (a) the gross
cash receipts of the Company from any source for such period (including, but not limited
to, Capital Contributions, loans, distributions received by the Company in respect of any
stock, partnership interest or other equity interest owned by the Company, and
proceeds from the sale, financing, refinancing or other disposition of all or any portion of
the Company property), exceed (b) the sum of (i) the aggregate cash disbursements for
such period (including, but not limited to, Company administrative costs,
reimbursements paid to the Manager in respect of his or her day-to-day management
activities hereunder, principal and interest payable on Company debt and capital
expenditures), and (ii) amounts previously set aside as reserves as determined by the
Manager in his or her discretion.
1.9 "Certificate" means the Certificate of Formation of the Company, as
amended from time to time, as filed in accordance with the Act.
1.10 "Code" means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (or any
corresponding provision of succeeding law).
1.11 "Company" means the limited liability company herein formed and known
as Kyara Investments I LLC, as said Company may from time to time be constituted.
1.12 "Consent" means the prior written consent or approval of a Person or
Persons to do the act or thing for which the consent or approval is solicited, or the act of
granting such consent or approval as the context may require.
1.13 "Depreciation" means, for each fiscal year or other period, an amount
equal to the depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deduction allowable with
respect to an asset for such year or other period, except that if the Gross Asset Value of
an asset differs from its adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes at the beginning
of such year or other period, Depreciation shall be an amount which bears the same
ratio to such beginning Gross Asset Value as the federal income tax depreciation,
amortization or other cost recovery deduction for such year or other period bears to
such beginning adjusted tax basis; provided, however, that if the federal income tax
depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deduction from such year or other
period is zero, Depreciation shall be determined with reference to such beginning Gross
Asset Value using any reasonable method selected by the Manager with the Consent of
the Members.
1.14 "Gross Asset Value" means, with respect to any asset, the asset's
adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes, except as follows:

(a) The initial Gross Asset Value of any asset contributed by a Member
to the Company shall be the gross fair market value of such asset, as determined
by the contributing Member and the Manager;

(b) The Gross Asset Values of all Company assets shall be adjusted to
equal their respective gross fair market values, as reasonably determined by the
Members, as of the following times: (i) the acquisition of additional Membership
3
44:40 ,, v5
Interests in the Company by any new or existing Member in exchange for more
than a de minimis capital contribution; (ii) the distribution by the Company to a
Member of more than a de minimis amount of Company assets, including money,
as consideration for an interest in the Company; and (iii) the liquidation of the
Company within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(g);
provided, however, that adjustments pursuant to the preceding clauses (i) and (ii)
shall be made only if the Members reasonably determine that such adjustments
are necessary or appropriate to reflect the relative economic interests of the
Members in the Company;

(c) The Gross Asset Value of any Company asset distributed to any
Member shall be the gross fair market value of such asset on the date of
distribution; and
(d) The Gross Asset Values of Company assets shall be increased (or
decreased) to reflect any adjustments to the adjusted basis of such assets
pursuant to Code Section 734(b) or Code Section 743(b), but only to the extent
that such adjustments are taken into account in determining Capital Accounts
pursuant to Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(m) and the definition of "Capital
Account" herein.
If the Gross Asset Value of an asset has been determined or adjusted pursuant to any
of the foregoing subparagraphs (a), (b) or (d) of this Section, such Gross Asset Value
shall thereafter be adjusted by the Depreciation taken into account with respect to such
asset for purposes of computing Profits and Losses.
1.15 "Investment" has the meaning set forth in Section 2.2.
1.16 "Manager" means the Person designated or appointed as Manager
pursuant to this Agreement, and any other Person who becomes a successor or
additional Manager of the Company pursuant to this Agreement.
1.17 "Member" means any Person who is designated as a Member on Exhibit A
to this Agreement at the time of reference thereto and who is acting in such Person's
capacity as a Member of the Company, and any other Persons who from time to time
become parties to or are otherwise bound by this Agreement as Members.
1.18 "Membership Interest" means an ownership interest of a Member in the
Company at any particular time, including the right of such Member to any and all
benefits to which a Member may be entitled pursuant to this Agreement and under the
Act, together with all obligations of such Member to comply with the terms and
provisions of this Agreement and the Act. Membership Interests are owned by
Members as set forth in Exhibit A to this Agreement, as amended from time to time.
1.19 "Notice" means a writing, containing the information required by this
Agreement to be communicated to any Person, and given or delivered in accordance
with the requirements of this Agreement.
4
943193.v5
1.20 "Person" means any individual, partnership, limited liability company,
corporation, trust, estate or other entity.
1.21 "Profits" and "Losses" means, for each fiscal year or other period, an
amount equal to the Company's taxable income or loss for such year or period,
determined in accordance with Code Section 703(a) (for this purpose, all items of
income, gain, loss or deduction required to be stated separately pursuant to Code

Section 703(a)(1) shall be included in taxable income or loss), with the following
adjustments:

(a) Any income of the Company that is exempt from federal income tax
and not otherwise taken into account in computing Profits or Losses pursuant to
this definition shall be added to such taxable income or loss;

(b) Any expenditures of the Company described in Code Section
705(a)(2)(B), or treated as Code Section 705(a)(2)(B) expenditures pursuant to
Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(i), and not otherwise taken into account in
computing Profits or Losses pursuant to this definition shall be subtracted from
such taxable income or loss;

(c) In the event the Gross Asset Value of any Company asset is
adjusted pursuant to subparagraph (b) or (d) of Section 1.14 hereof, the amount
of such adjustment shall be taken into account as gain or loss from the
disposition of such asset for purposes of computing Profits or Losses;

(d) Gain or loss resulting from any disposition of property with respect
to which gain or loss is recognized for federal income tax purposes shall be
computed by reference to the Gross Asset Value of the property disposed of
notwithstanding that the adjusted tax basis of such property differs from its Gross
Asset Value; and
(e) Depreciation shall be taken into account for such fiscal year or
other period in computing such taxable income or loss, in lieu of the depreciation,
amortization and other cost recovery deductions that otherwise may be taken into
account in the absence of Section 1.13.
1.22 "Regulations" means the United States Treasury Regulations, as
amended from time to time.
1.23 "Sale of the Company" means the sale of the Company to any party on an
arms-length basis, pursuant to which such party or parties acquire (i) a majority of the
Membership Interests in the Company (whether by sale of Membership Interests or
merger or otherwise), or (ii) all or substantially all of the Company's assets, determined
on a consolidated basis.
1.24 "Transfer" has the meaning set forth in Section 9.1.
5
1.25 "Unreturned Capital Contributions" means, with respect to any Member,
the difference between (a) the Capital Contributions made by such Member, less (b) the
aggregate amount of distributions made to such Member pursuant to Section 4.6(a).
ARTICLE 2
THE COMPANY
2.1 Formation and Name. The Company has been formed as a limited liability
company pursuant to the provisions of the Act. The Company was formed with the
name "Kyara Investments I LLC"; provided that the Company may hereafter adopt such
other name or names as the Manager may from time to time select.
2.2 Purpose. The Company has been organized to engage in the ownership
and management of an fequityl—Webli investment in Wlame-ef-lcivestmentIPhysical
C ph C poration a D -I oration (the "Investment") and, with the Consent of
the Members, in any and all other lawful businesses or activities which a limited liability
company may carry on under the Act and the laws of any other jurisdiction in which the
Company is so engaged.
2.3 Registered Agent. The Company's registered agent shall be the Person
designated by the Manager from time to time to serve in that capacity in accordance
with the terms of the Act.
2.4 Qualification in Additional Jurisdictions. The Manager is authorized, with
the Consent of the Members, to qualify the Company to do business in any jurisdiction
in which such qualification is deemed by the Manager as necessary or desirable in
carrying out the Company's business, and pursuant thereto, to appoint a registered
agent and to establish a registered office in such jurisdiction, and to cause the Company
to operate in such jurisdiction under another name selected by the Manager, in
compliance with the assumed name statute of such jurisdiction, if the Company is not
allowed under the laws of such jurisdiction to operate under its legal name.
ARTICLE 3
MEMBERSHIP INTERESTS; CONTRIBUTIONS BY THE MEMBERS
3.1 Membership Interests. The Company shall issue one type of ownership
interest, with such rights, preferences and obligations as set forth in this Agreement.
Holders of Membership Interests shall be entitled to one vote per Membership Interest
held; provided that such holder is also a Member. Notwithstanding anything to the
contrary contained in this Agreement, no Person shall be entitled to vote with respect to
any Membership Interests unless such person is a Member.
3.2 Initial Capital of the Company. On or prior to the date hereof, each of the
Members (or the Person from whom such Member acquired, directly or indirectly, its, his
or her Membership Interests) has made an initial Capital Contribution to the Company
as provided on Exhibit A attached hereto. In exchange therefor, each Member (or the
6
943193.v5
Person from whom such Member acquired, directly or indirectly, its, his or her
Membership Interests) has received that number of Membership Interests set forth on
such Exhibit A.
3.3 No Additional Capital Contributions. No Member shall be required to
make any additional Capital Contribution to the Company.
3.4 Withdrawal. Except as otherwise provided in Article 9 of this Agreement,
no Member shall be entitled to withdraw or resign from the Company, prior to its
dissolution and winding up, without first obtaining the Consent of the Manager.
3.5 Additional Membership Interests. No additional Membership Interests
shall be issued by the Company without the Consent of the Members.
ARTICLE 4
CAPITAL ACCOUNTS; PROFITS AND LOSSES; DISTRIBUTIONS
4.1 Capital Accounts. The Company shall establish and maintain a Capital
Account for each Member.
4.2 Allocation of Profits and Losses.

(a) Profits of the Company shall be allocated among the Members as
follows:
(i) First, to each Member pro rata and in proportion to the
cumulative Losses, if any, allocated to such Member pursuant to Section
4.2(b)(ii) hereof until the cumulative Profits allocated to such Member
under this Section 4.2(a)(i) equals the cumulative Losses allocated to such
Member under Section 4.2(b)(i) hereof; and

(ii) Then, the balance, if any, to the Members in accordance
with their respective Membership Interests.
(b) Losses of the Company shall be allocated to the Members as
follows:

(i) First, to the Members in accordance with their respective
Membership Interests; provided, however, that no Member shall be
allocated Losses in excess of its, his or her Adjusted Capital Account
Balance, determined immediately prior to the allocation provided for in this

Section 4.2(b)(i); and
(ii) Then, to the extent any Losses allocated to a Member
pursuant to Section 4.2(b)(i) would, but for the proviso contained therein,
exceed a Member's Adjusted Capital Account Balance, such Losses shall
be allocated first to the other Members in proportion to, and to the extent
7
943193.v5
of, their respective Adjusted Capital Account Balances, and then to any
Member guaranteeing debt of the Company, making loans to the
Company or otherwise having liability for Company debt, in proportion to
the debt guaranteed, the loans made or the amount of such liability.
4.3 Reallocation by Manager. The allocation of Profits and Losses in Section
4.2 is intended to have substantial economic effect within the meaning of Regulations

Section 1.704-1(b)(2) or be in accordance with the Members' interests in the Company
within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(4). If subsequent events
(including, but not limited to, nonrecourse borrowing by the Company or a loan by a
Member to the Company) cause, in the reasonable opinion of the Manager, the Section
4.2 allocations to have neither substantial economic effect nor be in accordance with the
Members' interests in the Company, the Manager may (a) allocate the income, gain,
loss, deduction and credit of the Company so that such allocations are in accordance
with the Members' Membership Interests; or (b) make such other modifications to this
Agreement (including, but not limited to, the addition of minimum gain chargeback,
qualified income offset and other special allocation provisions specified in Regulations
Sections 1.704-2 or 1.704-1(b)) that are necessary in the reasonable opinion of the
Manager to cause such allocations to have substantial economic effect within the
meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2).
4.4 Tax Allocations. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, all items
of income, gain, loss and deduction shall be allocated, for federal and state income tax
purposes, among the Members in the same manner as the corresponding items of
income, gain, loss and deduction are allocated for purposes of maintaining the Capital
Account of each of the Members.
4.5 Section 704(c) Allocations. In accordance with Code Section 704(c) and
the Regulations thereunder, income, gain, loss and deduction with respect to any
property contributed to the capital of the Company shall, solely for tax purposes, be
allocated among the Members so as to take account of any variation between the
adjusted basis of such property to the Company for federal income tax purposes and its
initial Gross Asset Value, including, but not limited to, special allocations to a
contributing Member that are required under Code Section 704(c) to be made upon
distribution of such property to any of the noncontributing Members. In the event the
Gross Asset Value of any property of the Company is adjusted pursuant to
subparagraph (b) of Section 1.14, subsequent allocations of income, gain, loss and
deduction with respect to such property shall take account of any variation between the
adjusted basis of such property for federal income tax purposes and its Gross Asset
Value in the same manner as under Code Section 704(c) and the Regulations
thereunder. Any elections or other decisions relating to such allocations shall be made
by the Manager in any manner that reasonably reflects the purpose and intention of this
Agreement. Allocations pursuant to this Section 4.5 are solely for purposes of federal,
state and local taxes and shall not affect, or in any way be taken into account in
computing, a Members Capital Account or share of Profits or Losses, other items or
distributions pursuant to any provision of this Agreement.
8
44:40; v5
4.6 Distribution of Cash Flow. To the extent there is Cash Flow available for
distribution, as reasonably determined by the Manager, and in any event not later than
45 days after the receipt by the Company of the proceeds from the sale of the
Investment, the Manager shall cause the Company to distribute such available Cash
Flow:

(a) first, to those Members with Unreturned Capital Contributions, pro
rata in proportion to the amount of such Unreturned Capital Contributions, until
the amount of each Member's Unreturned Capital Contributions has been
reduced to zero; and

(b) thereafter, to the Members, pro rata in accordance with their
respective Membership Interests.
ARTICLE 5
MANAGEMENT
5.1 Initial Manager. The management of the Company's business shall be
vested in one Manager unless a greater number of Managers shall be fixed from time to
time by action of the Members. The initial Manager of the Company shall be Joichi Ito.
A Manager shall hold office until his, her or its death, removal, or resignation.
5.2 Management Authority.

(a) Except as otherwise authorized in this Agreement, all management
decisions of the Company (including, without limitation, any actions or votes
taken by or on behalf of the Company in respect of any equity interest held by the
Company in another entity) shall be made by the Manager, who shall be
responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company, subject to the
provisions of this Agreement and the Act. The Manager shall have all of the
rights, powers, duties and obligations of managers as provided in the Act, and as
otherwise provided by law, and any action taken by the Manager, not otherwise
in violation of the Act or this Agreement, shall constitute the act of and serve to
bind the Company.
(b) Only the Manager and agents of the Company authorized by the
Manager shall have the authority to bind the Company. The Manager is an agent
of the Company for the purpose of its business, and the act of the Manager,
including the execution in the Company's name of any instrument for apparently
carrying on in the usual way the business of the Company, binds the Company,
unless such act is in contravention of the Act or this Agreement or any
agreement between the Manager and the Company or unless the Manager so
acting otherwise lacks the authority to act for the Company and the Person with
whom the Manager is dealing has knowledge of the fact that he, she or it has no
such authority. If the Manager acts without the requisite authority, the Manager
shall be liable for any damages or liabilities arising with respect to such action
9
943193.v5
unless the Manager can show that he, she or it reasonably believed after due
inquiry that such action was authorized.
5.3 Limitation on Liability. The Manager shall perform his, her or its duties as
the Manager in good faith, in a manner he, she or it reasonably believes to be in the
best interest of the Company and the Members, and with such care as an ordinarily
prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances. A Person who
so performs his, her or its duties shall not have any liability by reason of being or having
been a Manager of the Company, except where the claim at issue is based on the
fraud, gross negligence or bad faith of the Manager.
5.4 Removal of the Manager. The Manager may be removed with or without
cause upon the Consent of the Members, but such removal shall be without prejudice to
any contract rights the Manager may have under this Agreement. Any removal of the
Manager shall become effective on such date as may be specified by the Members
voting in favor thereof. Should the Manager be removed who is also a Member, such
Member will continue to participate in the Company as a Member and enjoy the burdens
and benefits of his or her Membership Interests.
5.5 Resignation of the Manager. The Manager may resign at any time by
giving Notice to the Members. The resignation of the Manager shall take effect upon
receipt of such Notice or at such later date as specified in such Notice. The acceptance
of the resignation of the Manager shall not be necessary to make such resignation
effective. The resignation of the Manager who is also a Member shall not affect the
Manager's rights as a Member and shall not constitute a withdrawal of the Member.
5.6 Appointment of New Manager. If a vacancy in the office of Manager
occurs, a new Manager shall be designated with the Consent of the Members to fill such
vacancy, provided that in the event of the death, removal, or resignation of Joichi Ito as
the Manager, Darren K. Indyke shall become the succeeding Manager, unless another
Manager is appointed with the Consent of the Members. In the event that any vacancy
in the office of Manager is not filled as provided in the preceding sentence,
management of the Company shall be vested in the Members.
5.7 Indemnification by the Company. The Company shall indemnify the
Manager for all costs, losses, liabilities and damages paid or incurred by the Manager in
connection with the business of the Company to the fullest extent provided or permitted
by the Act and the other laws of the State of Delaware, except where the claim at issue
is based on the fraud, gross negligence or bad faith of the Manager. In connection
therewith, the Company shall advance to the Manager as they are paid or incurred all
expenses arising with respect to the defense of any matter as to which the Company
will be obligated to provide indemnification pursuant to this Section 5.7.
10
943193.v5
ARTICLE 6
MEMBERS
6.1 Powers of Members. Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 5.2, the
Members shall have the right to Consent to the following matters:

(a) removal of the Manager as provided in Section 5.4;
(b) designation of a new Manager upon the resignation, removal, death
or permanent disability of the then-current Manager as provided in Section 5.6

(c) approval either of any Transfer of any Membership Interests or of
any party becoming a Member as provided in Article 9; and
(d) dissolution of the Company as provided in Article 10.
6.2 Partition. While the Company remains in effect or is continued, each
Member waives its rights to have any Company property partitioned, or to file a
complaint or to institute any suit, action or proceeding at law or in equity to have any
Company property partitioned, and each Member, on behalf of itself, its successors and
its assigns hereby waives any such right.
6.3 Authority. Except as expressly authorized in this Agreement, no Member
shall take any action as a Member to bind the Company, and each Member shall
indemnify the Company for any costs or damages incurred by the Company as the
result of the unauthorized action of such Member.
6.4 Vote of the Members. An affirmative vote or consent by or on behalf of all
of the Members shall be required to approve or disapprove any matter on which the
Members are entitled or required to decide or Consent, except as otherwise provided in
this Agreement, the Certificate or the Act.
ARTICLE 7
TRANSACTIONS; AFFILIATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
7.1 Transactions Between a Member or Manager and the Company. Except
as otherwise limited by applicable law, with the Consent of the Members any Member or
Manager may, but shall not be obligated to, lend money to the Company, act as surety
for the Company and transact other business with the Company, and shall have the
same rights and obligations when transacting business with the Company as a person
or entity who is not a Member or Manager.
7.2 Affiliated Party Transactions. The Members acknowledge that the
Company is being formed initially to purchase and then hold an investment in {Plume-ef
GsampanyThysical Graph Corporation, a Delaware corporation, for which the Manager
may provide certain advisory or consulting services or on whose board of directors the
11
Manager may serve. In connection therewith, the Members acknowledge such potential
conflict of interest and waive and consent to any such transaction that may be approved
on behalf of the Company as provided in this Agreement.
ARTICLE 8
FISCAL YEAR; BOOKS AND RECORDS; BANK ACCOUNTS
8.1 Bank Accounts. The funds of the Company shall be deposited in such
federally insured bank account or accounts or other financial intermediary as the
Manager in his or her discretion determine are required, and the Manager shall arrange
for the appropriate conduct of such accounts.
8.2 Books and Records.

(a) There shall be kept and maintained full and accurate books
respecting the business of the Company showing all receipts and expenditures,
assets and liabilities, profits, losses and distributions, and all other records
reasonably necessary or appropriate for recording the Company's business
affairs at the Company's principal place of business or such other location as the
Manager may determine provided that all of the Members are informed of such
other location. Such books and records shall be open to inspection by any
Member (or such Members authorized representative) upon reasonable notice
and during ordinary business hours
(b) The books of the Company shall be kept on the method of
accounting determined by the Members, and shall show at all times each and
every item of income, gain, loss and expense.
8.3 Fiscal Year. The fiscal year of the Company shall be the calendar year.
8.4 Tax Matters Partner. Pursuant to Code Section 6231, the Person
designated by the Manager from time to time shall act as the Tax Matters Partner of the
Company. The Tax Matters Partner shall prepare and provide to each Member all
necessary tax forms and information to enable the Members to meet their tax filing
obligations on a timely basis and shall, within 30 days after receipt thereof, forward to
each Member a photocopy of any notices relating to the Company received from the
Internal Revenue Service or other revenue authority.
8.5 Tax Returns. In addition to the requirements of Section 8.2, tax returns of
the Company shall be prepared by the Person selected by the Manager.
ARTICLE 9
TRANSFERS
9.1 General Provision. No Member shall, directly or indirectly, voluntarily or
involuntarily, sell, assign, transfer, pledge, hypothecate, encumber or otherwise dispose
12
943193.v5
of ("Transfer") the whole or any part of its, his or her Membership Interests in the
Company, except to Affiliates of such Member or with the Consent of the Members.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, if any such Member is an individual, such Person's
Membership Interests may pass to his or her estate upon his or her death subject to the
other provisions of this Agreement. Except in connection with transfers during an
individual Member's lifetime to Affiliates as permitted pursuant to this Section 9.1, which
Affiliates shall become Members when the transfers become effective as hereinafter
provided, no transferee shall become a Member without the Consent of the Members.
Transfers to Affiliates shall be effective upon the Affiliates entering into this Agreement
and notice thereof being provided to the other Members.
9.2 Sale of the Company.

(a) If the Manager approves a Sale of the Company (an "Approved
Sale"), then each Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will
consent to and raise no objection to the Approved Sale, and if the Approved Sale
is structured as a sale of Membership Interests, then each Member and any
other holder of Membership Interests will agree to sell all of their Membership
Interests on the same terms and conditions as approved by the Manager. Each
Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will take all actions which
the Manager deems reasonably necessary in connection with the consummation
of the Approved Sale.

(b) The obligations of the Members and any other holders of
Membership Interests with respect to the Approved Sale are subject to the
condition that upon the consummation of the Approved Sale, all of the holders of
Membership Interests will, subject to Section 4.6, receive substantially the same
form and amount of consideration for their Membership Interests sold, or if any
such Membership Interests are given an option as to the form and amount of
consideration to be received, all such holders will be given the same option.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, nothing contained in this Section 9.2(b) shall
prevent any individual from receiving an offer of employment upon reasonable
terms in connection with services to be provided after the consummation of the
Approved Sale.

(c) Each Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will
bear their pro rata share (based upon the total amount of Membership Interests
sold) of the cost of any sale of Membership Interests pursuant to an Approved
Sale to the extent such costs are incurred for the benefit of all holders of
Membership Interests and are not otherwise paid by the Company. Costs
incurred by Members and the other holders of Membership Interests on their own
behalf, will not be considered costs of the Approved Sale contemplated
hereunder.
13
943193.v5
ARTICLE 10
DISSOLUTION AND TERMINATION
10.1 Dissolution. The Company shall be dissolved upon the Consent of the
Members or as otherwise provided by the Articles or the Act.
10.2 Procedures Upon Dissolution.

(a) Upon dissolution of the Company, the Company shall be terminated
and the Manager, or if there is no Manager, the Members, shall liquidate the
assets of the Company. The proceeds of liquidation shall be applied and
distributed in the following order of priority:

(i) First, to the payment of the debts and liabilities of the
Company (other than any loans or advances made by any of the Members
to the Company) and the expenses of liquidation;

(ii) Second, to the creation of any reserves which the Manager
or liquidating Members deem reasonably necessary for the payment of
any contingent or unforeseen liabilities or obligations of the Company or
Members (to the extent the Company is liable therefor) arising out of or in
connection with the business and operation of the Company;
(iii) Third, to the payment of any loans or advances made by any
of the Members to the Company; and
(iv) Thereafter, to the Members in the manner, and in the
priorities set forth in Section 4.6.
(b) A reasonable time shall be allowed for the orderly liquidation of the
assets of the Company and the discharge of liabilities. During the period
beginning with the dissolution of the Company and ending with its liquidation and
termination of this Agreement pursuant to this Section 10.2, the business affairs
of the Company shall be conducted by the Manager or, if there is no Manager, by
the Members. During such period, the business and affairs of the Company shall
be conducted so as to preserve the assets of the Company and maintain the
status which existed immediately prior to such termination.
ARTICLE 11
MISCELLANEOUS
11.1 Binding Agreement. Subject to the restrictions on transfers and
encumbrances set forth herein, this Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be
binding upon the parties hereto and their respective heirs, executors, legal
14
943193.v5
representatives, successors and permitted assigns. Whenever in this instrument a
reference to any party or Member is made, such reference shall be deemed to include a
reference to the heirs, executors, legal representatives, successors and permitted
assigns of each Member.
11.2 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in several counterparts,
each of which shall be deemed an original, but all of which shall constitute one and the
same instrument. In addition, this Agreement may contain more than one counterpart of
the signature pages and this Agreement may be executed by the affixing of the
signatures of each of the Members to one of such counterpart signature pages; all of
such signature pages shall be read as though, and this Agreement shall have the same
force and effect as though, all of the signers had signed a single signature page.
11.3 Effect of Consent or Waiver. No consent or waiver by any party hereto to
or of any breach or default by any other party hereto in the performance by such other
party hereto of its, his or her obligations hereunder shall be effective unless in writing,
and signed by the party hereto against whom such waiver is sought to be enforced, and
no such consent or waiver shall be deemed or construed to be a consent or waiver to or
of any other breach or default by such other party hereto in the performance by such
other party hereto of the same or any other obligations of such party hereto hereunder.
Failure on the part of any party hereto to object to or complain of any act or failure to act
of any of the other parties hereto or to declare any of the other parties hereto in default,
regardless of how long such failure continues, shall not constitute a waiver by any such
party hereto of its, his or her rights hereunder.
11.4 Enforceability. If any provision of this Agreement or the application thereof
to any Person or circumstances shall be invalid or unenforceable to any extent, the
remainder of this Agreement and the application of such provisions to other Persons or
circumstances shall not be affected thereby and shall be enforced to the greatest extent
permitted by law.
11.5 Entire Agreement. This Agreement contains all of the terms agreed upon
by the parties hereto with respect to the subject matter hereof, and supersedes all prior
agreements, arrangements and communications between the parties dealing with the
Membership Interests, whether oral or written.
11.6 Governing Law; Jurisdiction. In all respects, including all matters of
construction, validity and performance, the Agreement and the obligations arising
hereunder shall be governed by, and construed and enforced in accordance with, the
laws of the State of Delaware, applicable to contracts made and performed in such
state, without regard to the principles thereof regarding conflict of laws. The Company
and each of the parties hereto agree to submit to personal jurisdiction and to waive any
objection as to venue in the courts located in either the county in which the Company's
principal office is located within the State of Delaware or the county in which the
Company's registered office is located within the State of Delaware. Service of process
on the Company and any of the parties hereto in any action arising out of or relating to
this Agreement shall be effective if mailed by certified mail, return receipt requested or
15
943193.v5
delivered by reputable overnight courier to such party at the address set forth on Exhibit
A attached hereto.
11.7 Liability Among Members. No Member shall be liable to any other
Member or to the Manager by reason of its, his or her actions or omissions in
connection with the Company, unless otherwise provided in this Agreement, and except
for acts or omissions or alleged acts or omissions that were performed or omitted
fraudulently or in bad faith or as a result of gross negligence or willful misconduct.
11.8 No Partnership Intended for Nontax Purposes. The Members have
formed the Company under the Act and expressly do not intend hereby to form a
partnership under the laws of any jurisdiction. The Members do not intend to be
partners one to another, or partners as to any third party. To the extent any Member, by
word or action, represents to another Person that any other Member is a partner or that
the Company is a partnership, the Member making such wrongful representation shall
be liable to any other Member who incurs personal liability by reason of such wrongful
representation.
11.9 Amendment. This Agreement may be amended or modified only with the
Consent of the Members.
11.10 Notices. Any Notice to the Manager or Members required under the terms
of this Agreement shall be sent to their respective addresses, as set forth on Exhibit A
attached hereto. All Notices and copies thereof provided for herein shall be hand
delivered with receipt therefor, sent by overnight courier service with receipt therefor, or
sent by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, and first-class postage
prepaid. Changes of address may be given to the Company, the Manager, and the
Members by Notice given in accordance with the terms of this Section. Time periods
shall commence on the date that such Notice is shown as delivered upon any such
receipt or attempted to be delivered if receipt thereof is refused by the recipient. Any
Notice that is required to be given within a stated period of time shall be considered
timely made or given if delivered or postmarked before 11:59 p.m., local time, on the
last day of such period.
11.11 Business Pursuits of Members and Manager. Except as otherwise
provided in any other written agreement by which any Member or the Manager may be
bound, the Manager and each Member may engage in other business activities. Except
as otherwise provided in this Agreement or in any other written agreement by which any
Member or Manager may be bound, this Agreement shall not preclude or limit in any
respect the right of any Member or the Manager to engage in or invest in any business
activity of any nature or description. Any such permitted activity may be engaged in
independently or with other Members or the Manager. No Member or Manager shall
have the right, by virtue of this the Certificate, this Agreement or the relationship created
hereby, to any interest in such other permitted ventures or activities or to the income or
proceeds derived therefrom. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement or in any
other written agreement by which any Member or Manager may be bound, the pursuit of
such permitted ventures shall not be deemed wrongful or improper and any Member or
16
913193.v5
Manager shall have the right to participate in or to recommend to others any investment
opportunity.
11.12 Expenses. The Company shall recognize $2,000 of the out-of-pocket
expenses actually incurred by Joichi Ito in connection with the organization of the
Company as an initial capital contribution by such Member, and up to $2,000 of the
annual out-of-pocket expenses actually incurred by any Member of the Company in
connection with the operation of the Company each year as an additional capital
contribution by such Member when paid by such Member.
11.13 References. References herein to the singular shall include the plural and
to the plural shall include the singular, and references to one gender shall include the
others, except where the same shall not be appropriate.
11.14 Titles and Captions. Section titles or captions contained in this Agreement
are for convenience only and shall not be deemed a part of the content of this
Agreement.
11.15 Delivery by Facsimile or Electronic Mail. This Agreement, the agreements
referred to herein, and each other agreement or instrument entered into in connection
herewith or therewith or contemplated hereby or thereby, and any amendments hereto
or thereto, to the extent signed and delivered by means of a facsimile machine, pdf
attachment to an email or other electronic means, shall be treated in all manner and
respects as an original agreement or instrument and shall be considered to have the
same binding legal effect as if it were the original signed version thereof delivered in
person. At the request of any party hereto or to any such agreement or instrument,
each other party hereto or thereto shall re-execute original forms thereof and deliver
them to all other parties. No party hereto or to any such agreement or instrument shall
raise the use of such means to deliver a signature or the fact that any signature or
agreement or instrument was transmitted or communicated through the use of such
means as a defense to the formation or enforceability of a contract and each party
hereto forever waives any such defense..
[Signature page follows]
17
943193.v5
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned parties here executed this Agreement
as of the date first set forth above.
Kyara Investments I LLC
By:
Joichi Ito, Manager
Joichi Ito
[Name of JE Entity]
By:
Its:
Joichi Ito, Manager
HA A-Nit -Apt Opemint, *get% . 1 s
EXHIBIT A
The names, addresses and Membership Interests of the Members are set forth
below.
Name and Address
Number of
Membership
Interests
Percentage
Ownershi.
Initial
Capital
Contribution
Joichi Ito
63 Francis Ave.
Cambridge, MA 02138
500 50% $ 2,000
[Name of JE Entity] 500 50% 100,000
TOTAL 1,000 100.00% $ 102,000
Address of Manager and the Company:
Go Joichi Ito
63 Francis Ave.
Cambridge, MA 02138
Document comparison by Workshare Compare on Tuesday, May 06, 2014
10:01:38 AM
Input:
Document 1 ID interwovenSite://IMANAGE/IMAN/943493/5
Description #943493v5<IMAN> - Kyara Investments I LLC Operating
Agreement
Document 2 ID interwovenSite://IMANAGE/IMAN/943493/6
Description #943493v6<IMAN> - Kyara Investments I LLC Operating
Agreement
Rendering set Standard
Legend:
Insertion
Deletion
Moved-from
Moved to
Style change
Format change
Moved deletion
Inserted cell
Deleted cell
Moved cell
Split/Merged cell
Padding cell
Statistics:
Count
Insertions 5
Deletions 11
Moved from 0
Moved to 0
Style change 0
Format changed 0
Total changes 16
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                            Sandy Pentland [academia] MIT Media Lab 
                                         Athena Zelcovich [modeling] actress [imdb] 
 Tyler Shears [publicist] reputation management, worked on with Christina Galbraith 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01217703 (Jmail)
 [reputation] Skype log of conversation with Athena Zelcovich, Joscha Bach, Lawrence Krauss, Tyler Shears
(inferred timestamp: 2014-05-13 22:32:18)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024371.dmg
(Evidence ID: NYC024371.dmg - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case
Data:
Messages
(1901-
2000 of
7780)
Skype
2014-05-03 21:55:08 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Are u there?
Skype
2014-05-03 21:55:08 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Are u there?
Skype
2014-05-04 07:07:08 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Free tomorrow?
Skype
2014-05-04 07:07:08 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Free tomorrow?
Skype
2014-05-04 19:48:33 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Jeffrey ill be in neuilly super late... Can i come tomorrow morning? Or later, im free
tomorrow! I want to tallk to u cause last time we didnt have time
Skype
2014-05-04 19:48:33 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Jeffrey ill be in neuilly super late... Can i come tomorrow morning? Or later, im free
tomorrow! I want to tallk to u cause last time we didnt have time
Skype
2014-05-09 18:12:48 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
I keep missing you.. will try again later today... gotta do some interview now.
Skype
2014-05-09 18:12:48 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
I keep missing you.. will try again later today... gotta do some interview now.
Skype
[2] 2014-05-10 18:13:04 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: (
Skype
[1] 2014-05-10 18:13:04 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: (
Skype
[1] 2014-05-11 10:34:38 (UTC)
), Self (jeevacation )
), Self (jeevacation )
are you there?
are you there?
Sender: Self (i cation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
today?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-11 10:34:38 (UTC)
Sender: Self (i cation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
today?
Skype
2014-05-11 10:52:51 (UTC) [2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Yes
Skype
2014-05-11 10:52:51 C) [I] Sender:
Participants:
Yes
Skype
2014-05-11 10:53:30 (UTC) [2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
). Self ( jeevacation )
Round 2?
Skype
2014-05-11 10:53:30 (UTC) 1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Round 2?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-11 10:53:35 (UTC)
Sender: Self eevacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
15 miutes
Skype
[1] 2014-05-11 10:53:35 (UTC)
Sender: Self eevacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
15 miutes
Skype
2014-05-11 11:07:15 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
I m done with work in 30 min
Skype
2014-05-11 11:07:15 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
I m done with work in 30 min
Skype
[2] 2014-05-11 11:08:55 (UTC)
Sender: Self Ciatacation
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
olk
Skype
[1] 2014-05-11 11:08:55 (UTC)
Sender: Self eevacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
olk
Skype
[2] 2014-05-11 11:19:27 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeva(..I cation )
Participants: (
Skype
[1] 2014-05-11 11:19:27 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeva(..i cation )
Participants: (
), Self ( jeevacation )
), Self ( jeevacation )
today
today
Skype
[2] 2014-05-11 11:19:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
today?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-11 11:19:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
today?
Skype
2014-05-11 12:18:44 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Yes I'll call you when I get home!
Skype
2014-05-11 12:18:44 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Yes I'll call you when I get home!
Skype
2014-05-11 12:50:29 UTC 1
Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
Hi Jeffrey! That would be great. Will be home soon, between 5-6 pm and 9-11 pm today.
NYC time 11-12 and 3 - 5 pm. Best,.
Skype
2014-05-11 12:50:29 (UTC) [2 Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
Hi Jeffrey! That would be great. Will be home soon, between 5-6 pm and 9-11 pm today.
NYC time 11-12 and 3 - 5 pm. Best,.
Skype
[2] 2014-05-11 12:59:22 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Joscha Bach ( joscha.bach ), Self ( jeevacation )
are you around for a Skype?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-11 12:59:22 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self ( jeevacation )
are you around for a Skype?
Skype
2014-05-11 13:50:22 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Joscha Bach ( joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self ( jeevacation )
At 10:15
Skype
2014-05-11 13:50:22 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Joscha Bach ( joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
At 10:15
Skype
2014-05-11 14:15:57 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
Does it work now for you?
Skype
2014-05-11 14:15:57 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Joscha Bach ( joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
Does it work now for you?
Skype
2014-05-11 14:21:54 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Joscha Bach ( joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
martin rohrmeyer - i hope that is the spelling
Skype
2014-05-11 14:21:54 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Joscha Bach ( joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
martin rohrmeyer - i hope that is the spelling
Skype
2014-05-11 14:22:38 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Joscha Bach ( joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Seif ( jeevacation )
Alex Pentland
Skype
2014-05-11 14:22:38 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Joscha Bach ( joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
Alex Pentland
Skype
2014-05-11 14:25:37 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
sony for the noisy enviroment
Skype
2014-05-11 14:25:37 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Joscha Bach ( joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
sony for the noisy enviroment
Skype
2014-05-11 14:26:34 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
we can set up another meeting any time, at the office (good inteinet and no noise)
Skype
2014-05-11 14:26:34 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
we can set up another meeting any time, at the office (good inteinet and no noise)
Skype
[1] 2014-05-11 14:52:47 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self (jeevacation )
no problem
Skype
[2] 2014-05-11 14:52:47 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Joscha Bach (joscha.bach ), Self ( jeevacation )
no problem
Skype
2014-05-11 14:57:09 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
are you there?
Skype
2014-05-11 14:57:09 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
are you there?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-11 19:17:43 (UTC)
Sender: Self "eevacation
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
now?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-11 19:17:43 (UTC)
Sender: Self "eevacation
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
now?
Skype
2014-05-11 19:39:23 UTC 2
Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
Hi just got back home, yes, do you have time?
Skype
2014-05-11 19:39:23 UTC 1
Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
Hi just got back home, yes, do you have time?
Skype
2014-05-11 19:41:16 (MT) [2 Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
Just call when you are available I'm online
Skype
2014-05-11 19:41:16 UTC 1
Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
Just call when you are available I'm online
Skype
2014-05-1120:58:26 UTC 2
Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
Hello Jeffrey, I'm so sorry that I missed you! It took longer time to get home in the rain.
Would love to skype with you tmr after 7, NYC time after 1 pm. Or any other evening
when you have time. Will be home and online all evening tmr. Have a great Sunday!
Skype
2014-05-1I 20:5S:26 (MT) [I Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
Hello Jeffrey, I'm so sorry that I missed you! It took longer time to get home in the rain.
Would love to skype with you tmr after 7, NYC time after 1 pm. Or any other evening
when you have time. Will be home and online all evening tmr. Have a great Sunday!
Skype
2014-05-11 22:05:23 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Hey,are you free now?
Skype
2014-05-11 22:05:23 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Hey,are you free now?
Skype
2014-05-1122:30:55 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
I will visit my family from 8th June to 19 June,I think i can come to New York 22th
June.i'll try call you tomorrow for make sure our schedule!kiss
Skype
2014-05-1122:30:55 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
I will visit my family from 8th June to 19 June,I think i can come to New York 22th
June.i'll try call you tomorrow for make sure our schedule!kiss
Skype
[1] 2014-05-12 01:02:30 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
tomor?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-12 01:02:30 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
tomor?
Skype
2014-05-12 08:40:35 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
How are you?
Skype
2014-05-12 08:40:35 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
How are you?
Skype
2014-05-12 17:13:46 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I wanna stop that modelling shit
Skype
2014-05-12 17:13:46 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I wanna stop that modelling shit
Skype
[1] 2014-05-12 17:15:39 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
you ye , said that five times before
Skype
[2] 2014-05-12 17:15:39 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
you ye , said that five times before
Skype
2014-05-12 17:15:52 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I have nothing else
Skype
2014-05-12 17:15:52 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I have nothing else
Skype
2014-05-12 17:16:15 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I have no family here
Skype
2014-05-12 17:16:15 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I have no family here
Skype
2014-05-12 17:16:21 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
No structure
Skype
2014-05-12 17:16:21 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
No structure
Skype
2014-05-12 18:17:05 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self ( jeevacation )
ping
Skype
2014-05-12 18:17:05 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self ( jeevacation )
ping
Skype
2014-05-12 20:42:02 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: i ), Self (jeevacation )
Skype ?
Skype
2014-05-12 20:42:02 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Skype ?
Skype
2014-05-12 23:14:05 (UTC) 12
Sender:
Participants:
Can we talk?
), Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
2014-05-12 23:14:05 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Can we talk?
Skype
2014-05-12 23:44:00 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
I'm going to bed now,try tomorrow!miss you
Skype
2014-05-12 23:44:00 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
I'm going to bed now,try tomorrow!miss you
Skype
[1] 2014-05-13 02:41:24 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self ( jeevacation )
tomorw
Skype
[2] 2014-05-13 02:41:24 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self ( jeevacation )
tomorw
Skype
[2] 2014-05-13 02:41:30 (UTC)
Sender: Self (i cation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
tomor
Skype
[1] 2014-05-13 02:41:30 (UTC)
Sender: Self Liatacation
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
tomor
Skype
2014-05-13 02:41:55 UTC 2
Sender:
( ), Self ( jeevacation )
<voicemail alt=""><message length="40"›</message></voicemail>
Skype
2014-05-13 02:41:55 UTC 1
Sender:
( ), Self (jeevacation )
<voicemail alt=""><message length="40"›</message></voicemail>
Skype
[2] 2014-05-13 02:42:06 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeva(..i cation )
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
tomor
Skype
[1] 2014-05-13 02:42:06 (UTC)
Sender: Self Cjaacation )
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
2014-05-13 13:13:02 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self (jeevacation )
ok let me know time - i have plan 1130 est to lest but am free after.
Skype
2014-05-13 13:13:02 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self (jeevacation )
ok let me know time - i have plan 1130 est to lest but am free after.
Skype
2014-05-13 16:52:39 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
What Time ?
Skype
2014-05-13 16:52:39 UTC) [1]
Sender:
Participants:
What Time ?
), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2014-05-13 17:51:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self Liatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
tomor
now?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-13 17:51:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self tjatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
now?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-13 19:46:11 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self (jeevacation )
now?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-13 19:46:11 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self ( jeevacation )
now?
Skype
2014-05-13 22:32:18 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self (jeevacation )
was at dinner - late mothers day. is tomorrow at a particular time best for you?
Skype
2014-05-13 22:32:18 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self (jeevacation )
was at dinner - late mothers day. is tomorrow at a particular time best for you?
Notes
[1] Source Device /Macintosh HD
[1] Source File /Users/Jeffrey/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
[2] Source Device NYCO24371.dmg/Macintosh HD
[2] Source File /Users/Jeffrey/Library/Application SupportlSkype/jeevacation/main.db
Case Data: Messages (1801-1900 of 7780) Case Data: Messages (2001-2100 of 7780)
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                            Jimmy Buffet [arts] "Margaritaville" singer, retirement home executive 
                                                     BGC [crypto] Cantor Fitzgerald related firm of Howard Lutnick 
 ATorus aka Red Dot Trade Finance [finance] fund of Michael Fowler / Joshua Levy apparently invested in by Epstein 
                                                   Michael Fowler [finance] ATorus / Red Dot Trade fund co-founder 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01078403 (Jmail)
 [finance] ATorus investment adviser uniform application
(date: 2014-05-14)
FORM ADV
UNIFORM APPLICATION FOR INVESTMENT ADVISER REGISTRATION AND REPORT BY
EXEMPT REPORTING ADVISERS
Primary Business Name: RED DOT TRADE FINANCE, LLC CRD Numbe
Other -Than -Annual Amendment - All Sections Rev. 10/2012
WARNING: Complete this form truthfully. False statements or omissions may result in denial of your
application, revocation of your registration, or criminal prosecution. You must keep this form
updated by filing periodic amendments. See Form ADV General Instruction 4.
Item 1 Identifying Information
Responses to this Item tell us who you are, where you are doing business, and how we can contact you.

A. Your full legal name (if you are a sole proprietor, your last, first, and middle names):
RED DOT TRADE FINANCE, LLC

B. Name under which you primarily conduct your advisory business, if different from Item S.A.:
RED DOT TRADE FINANCE, LLC
List on Section 1.5. of Schedule D any additional names under which you conduct your advisory
business.

C. If this filing is reporting a change in your legal name (Item S.A.) or primary business name (Item
1.B.), enter the new name and specify whether the name change is of
r your legal name or r your primary business name:

D. (1) If you are registered with the SEC as an investment adviser, your SEC file number:
(2) If you report to the SEC as an exempt reporting adviser, your SEC file number:

E. If you have a number ("CRD Number") assigned by the FINRA's CRD system or by the LARD system,
your CRD number
If your firm does not have a CRD number, skip this Item 1.E. Do not provide the CRD number of one of
your officers, employees, or affiliates.

F. Principal Office and Place of Business
(1) Address (do not use a P.O. Box):
Number and Street 1: Number and Street 2:
City: State: Country:
WESTON Massachusetts UNITED STATES
If this address is a private residence, check this box: I7
ZIP +4/Postal Code:
02493
List on Section 1.F. of Schedule D any office, other than your principal office and place of business,
at which you conduct investment advisory business. If you are applying for registration, or are
registered, with one or more state securities authorities, you must list all of your offices in the
state or states to which you are applying for registration or with whom you are registered. If you
are applying for SEC registration, if you are registered only with the SEC, or if you are reporting to
the SEC as an exempt reporting adviser, list the largest five offices in terms of numbers of
employees.

(2) Days of week that you normally conduct business at your principal office and place of business:
Monday - Friday r Other:
Normal business hours at this location:
8 - 5

(3) Tele hone number at this location:
(4) Facsimile number at this location:
G. Mailing address, if different from your principal office and place of business address:
Number and Street 1: Number and Street 2:
City: State: Country:
WESTON Massachusetts UNITED STATES
If this address is a private residence, check this box: F
ZIP+4/Postal Code:
02493

H. If you are a sole proprietor, state your full residence address, if different from your principal office
and place of business address in Item 1.F.:
Number and Street 1: Number and Street 2:
City: State: Country: ZIP+4/Postal Code:

I. Do you have one or more websites?
Yes No
r
If "yes," list all website addresses on Section 1.I. of Schedule D. If a website address serves as a portal
through which to access other information you have published on the web, you may list the portal
without listing addresses for all of the other information. Some advisers may need to list more than one
portal address. Do not provide individual electronic mail (e-mail) addresses in response to this Item.

J. Provide the name and contact information of your Chief Compliance Officer: If you are an exempt
reporting adviser, you must provide the contact information for your Chief Compliance Officer, if you
have one. If not, you must complete Item 1.K. below.
Name:
JOSHUA LEVY
Other titles, if any:
PARTNER
Telephone number:  Facsimile number:
Number and Street 1: Number and Street 2:
86 MYLES STANDISH RD
City: State: Country:
WESTON Massachusetts UNITED STATES
ZIP+4/Postal Code:
02493
Electronic mail (e-mail) address, if Chief Compliance Officer has one:

K. Additional Regulatory Contact Person: If a person other than the Chief Compliance Officer is
authorized to receive information and respond to questions about this Form ADV, you may provide
that information here.
Name:
Telephone number: Facsimile number:
Number and Street 1: Number and Street 2:
City: State: Country: ZIP+4/Postal Code:
Electronic mail (e-mail) address, if contact person has one:

L. Do you maintain some or all of the books and records you are required to keep under

Section 204 of the Advisers Act, or similar state law, somewhere other than your principal
office and place of business?
If "yes," complete Section 1.L. of Schedule D.

M. Are you registered with a foreign financial regulatory authority?
Yes No
r
Yes No
r
Answer "no" if you are not registered with a foreign financial regulatory authority, even if you have an
affiliate that is registered with a foreign financial regulatory authority. If "yes," complete Section 1.M. of
Schedule D.

N. Are you a public reporting company under Sections 12 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange
Act of 1934?
Yes No
r r.
If "yes," provide your CIK number (Central Index Key number that the SEC assigns to each public
reporting company):

O. Did you have $1 billion or more in assets on the last day of your most recent fiscal year?
P. Provide your Legal Entity Identifier if you have one:
Yes No
r
A legal entity identifier is a unique number that companies use to identify each other in the financial
marketplace. In the first half of 2011, the legal entity identifier standard was still in development.
You may not have a legal entity identifier.
SECTION 1.B. Other Business Names
List your other business names and the jurisdictions in which you use them. You must complete a
separate Schedule D Section 1.5. for each business name.
Name: ATORUS
Jurisdictions
❑ AL
❑ AK
r AZ
F AR
CA
1- co
CT

• DE
• DC
• FL
E GA
• GU
✓ HI
❑ ID
OIL
❑ IN
❑ IA
❑ KS
❑ KY
❑ LA
r ME
✓ MD
F MA
✓ MI
E MN
❑ ris
SECTION 1.F. Other Offices
SECTION 1.I. Website Addresses
❑ MO
OMT
ONE
❑ NV
❑ NH
❑ NM
❑ NY
❑ NC
❑ ND
00H
❑ OK
❑ OR
❑ PA
❑ PR
O RI
❑ SO
❑ SD
O-rx
OUT
OVA
❑ WA
O WV
❑WI
❑ Other:
No Information Filed
No Information Filed
SECTION 1.L. Location of Books and Records
No Information Filed
SECTION 1.M. Registration with Foreign Financial Regulatory Authorities
No Information Filed
Item 3 Form of Organization

A. How are you organized?
✓ Corporation
✓ Sole Proprietorship
✓ Limited Liability Partnership (LLP)
r Partnership
• Limited Liability Company (LLC)
✓ Limited Partnership (LP)
✓ Other (specify):
If you are changing your response to this Item, see Part 1A Instruction 4.

B. In what month does your fiscal year end each year?
DECEMBER
C. Under the laws of what state or country are you organized?
State Country
Delaware UNITED STATES
If you are a partnership, provide the name of the state or country under whose laws your partnership
was formed. If you are a sole proprietor, provide the name of the state or country where you reside.
If you are changing your response to this Item, see Part 1A Instruction 4.
Item 4 Successions

A. Are you, at the time of this filing, succeeding to the business of a registered investment
adviser?
If "yes", complete Item 4.8. and Section 4 of Schedule D.

B. Date of Succession: (MM/DD/YYYY)
If you have already reported this succession on a previous Form ADV filing, do not report the succession
again. Instead, check "No." See Part 1A Instruction 4.
SECTION 4 Successions
No Information Filed
Yes No
r r.
Item 5 Information About Your Advisory Business - Employees, Clients, and Compensation
Responses to this Item help us understand your business, assist us in preparing for on -site
examinations, and provide us with data we use when making regulatory policy. Part 1A Instruction 5.a.
provides additional guidance to newly formed advisers for completing this Item 5.
Employees
If you are organized as a sole proprietorship, include yourself as an employee in your responses to Item S.A.
and Items SAW, (2), (3), (4), and (5). If an employee performs more than one function, you should count
that employee in each of your responses to Items 5.8.(1), (2), (3), (4), and (5).

A. Approximately how many employees do you have? Include full- and part-time employees but do not
include any clerical workers.
2

B. (1) Approximately how many of the employees reported in 5.A. perform investment advisory
functions (including research)?
2

(2) Approximately how many of the employees reported in 5.A. are registered representatives of a
broker -dealer?
( 3)
0
Approximately how many of the employees reported in 5.A. are registered with one or more
state securities authorities as investment adviser representatives?
2

(4) Approximately how many of the employees reported in 5.A. are registered with one or more
state securities authorities as investment adviser representatives for an investment adviser
other than you?
0

(5) Approximately how many of the employees reported in 5.A. are licensed agents of an
insurance company or agency?
0

(6) Approximately how many firms or other persons solicit advisory clients on your behalf?
0
In your response to Item 5.6.(6), do not count any of your employees and count a firm only once - do
not count each of the firm's employees that solicit on your behalf.
Clients
In your responses to Items S.C. and S.D. do not include as "clients" the investors in a private fund you
advise, unless you have a separate advisory relationship with those investors.

C. (1) To approximately how many clients did you provide investment advisory services during your
most recently completed fiscal year?
r1-10 r 11-25
r 26-100 r More than 100
If more than 100, how many?
(round to the nearest 100)

(2) Approximately what percentage of your clients are non -United States persons?
0%
D. For purposes of this Item S.D., the category "individuals" includes trusts, estates, and 401(k) plans and
IRAs of individuals and their family members, but does not include businesses organized as sole
proprietorships. The category "business development companies" consists of companies that have made
an election pursuant to section 54 of the Investment Company Act of 1940. Unless you provide advisory
services pursuant to an investment advisory contract to an investment company registered under the
Investment Company Act of 1940, check "None" in response to Item 5.D.(1)(d) and do not check any of
the boxes in response to Item 5.D.(2)(d).

(1) What types of clients do you have? Indicate the approximate percentage that each type of
client comprises of your total number of clients. If a client fits into more than one category,
check all that apply.
Unto  11- 26- 51- 76 -
None 10% 25% 50% 75% 99% 100%

(a) Individuals (other than high net worth
individuals)
(b) High net worth individuals
(c) Banking or thrift institutions

(d) Investment companies
(e) Business development companies
(f) Pooled investment vehicles (other than
investment companies)

(g) Pension and profit sharing plans (but not
the plan participants)
(h) Charitable organizations
(i) Corporations or other businesses not listed
above

(j) State or municipal government entities
(k) Other investment advisers
(I) Insurance companies
(m) Other:
r r e r r r
✓ r r r r r a
r r r r r r

r. r r r r r r
r r r r r r
r r r r r r
r. r e r r r r
r. r e r r r r
r r r r r r
r r r r r r
r r r r r r
r r r r r r
r r r r r r

(2) Indicate the approximate amount of your regulatory assets under management (reported in
Item S.F. below) attributable to each of the following type of client. If a client fits into more
than one category, check all that apply.
UD to UD to UD to None >75 0/0
25% 50% 75%

(a) Individuals (other than high net worth individuals) a r r r r
(b) High net worth individuals r r r r a

(c) Banking or thrift institutions a r r r r
(d) Investment companies a r r r r
(e) Business development companies C.- r r r r

(f) Pooled investment vehicles (other than a r r r r
investment companies)
(g) Pension and profit sharing plans (but not the
plan participants)

(h) Charitable organizations a r r r r
(i) Corporations or other businesses not listed a r r r r
above
(j) State or municipal government entities

(k) Other investment advisers
(I) Insurance companies
(m) Other:
r. r r r r
a r r r r
a r r r r
a r r r r
a r r r r
Compensation Arrangements

E. You are compensated for your investment advisory services by (check all that apply):
Fo (1) A percentage of assets under your management
✓ (2) Hourly charges
✓ (3) Subscription fees (for a newsletter or periodical)
✓ (4) Fixed fees (other than subscription fees)
✓ ( 5) Commissions
P- (6) Performance -based fees
✓ (7) Other (specify):
Item 5 Information About Your Advisory Business - Regulatory Assets Under Management
Regulatory Assets Under Management
Yes No

F. (1) Do you provide continuous and regular supervisory or management services to
securities portfolios?

(2) If yes, what is the amount of your regulatory assets under management and total number of
accounts?
r r.
U.S. Dollar Amount Total Number of Accounts
Discretionary: (a) $ (d)
Non -Discretionary: (b) $ (e)
Total: (c) $
Part 1A Instruction 5.b. explains how to calculate your regulatory assets under management. You
must follow these instructions carefully when completing this Item.
Item 5 Information About Your Advisory Business - Advisory Activities
Advisory Activities

G. What type(s) of advisory services do you provide? Check all that apply.
F (1) Financial planning services
Ft (2) Portfolio management for individuals and/or small businesses
✓ (3) Portfolio management for investment companies (as well as "business development
companies" that have made an election pursuant to section 54 of the Investment
Company Act of 1940)
✓ (4) Portfolio management for pooled investment vehicles (other than investment
companies)
✓ (5) Portfolio management for businesses (other than small businesses) or institutional
clients (other than registered investment companies and other pooled investment
vehicles)

(6) Pension consulting services
(7) Selection of other advisers (including private fund managers)
(8) Publication of periodicals or newsletters

(9) Security ratings or pricing services
(10) Market timing services
(11) Educational seminars/workshops

(12) Other(specify):
1 11 -11 "1-1
Do not check Item 5.G.(3) unless you provide advisory services pursuant to an investment advisory
contract to an investment company registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940, including
as a subadviser. If you check Item 5.G.(3), report the 811 or 814 number of the investment company
or investment companies to which you provide advice in Section 5.G.(3) of Schedule D.

H. If you provide financial planning services, to how many clients did you provide these services during
your last fiscal year?
✓ 1-10
• 11 - 25
✓ 26 - 50
✓ 51 - 100
✓ 101 - 250
✓ 251 - 500
✓ More than 500
If more than 500, how many?
(round to the nearest 500)
In your responses to this Item S.H., do not include as "clients" the investors in a private fund you
advise, unless you have a separate advisory relationship with those investors.

I. If you participate in a wrap fee program, do you (check all that apply):
r (1) sponsor the wrap fee program?
r (2) act as a portfolio manager for the wrap fee program?
If you are a portfolio manager for a wrap fee program, list the names of the programs and their
sponsors in Section 5.I.(2) of Schedule D.
If your involvement in a wrap fee program is limited to recommending wrap fee programs to your
clients, or you advise a mutual fund that is offered through a wrap fee program, do not check either
Item 5.I.(1) or 5.I.(2).
Yes No

3. In response to Item 4.B. of Part 2A of Form ADV, do you indicate that you provide
investment advice only with respect to limited types of investments?
SECTION 5.G.(3) Advisers to Registered Investment Companies and Business Development
Companies
SECTION 5.I.(2) Wrap Fee Programs
No Information Filed
No Information Filed
r
Item 6 Other Business Activities
In this Item, we request information about your firm's other business activities.

A. You are actively engaged in business as a (check all that apply):
✓ (1) broker -dealer (registered or unregistered)
✓ (2) registered representative of a broker -dealer
✓ (3) commodity pool operator or commodity trading advisor (whether registered or exempt
from registration)

(4) futures commission merchant
(5) real estate broker, dealer, or agent
(6) insurance broker or agent
(7) bank (including a separately identifiable department or division of a bank)

(8) trust company
(9) registered municipal advisor
(10) registered security -based swap dealer
(11) major security -based swap participant

(12) accountant or accounting firm
(13) lawyer or law firm
(14) other financial product salesperson (specify):
1 -11 -11 -1 -1 -11 -1 -1
If you engage in other business using a name that is different from the names reported in Items 1.A. or
1.8, complete Section 6.A. of Schedule D.

B. (1) Are you actively engaged in any other business not listed in Item 6.A. (other than
giving investment advice)?

(2) If yes, is this other business your primary business?
Yes No
r
r. r
If "yes," describe this other business on Section 6.8.(2) of Schedule D, and if you engage in this
business under a different name, provide that name.

(3) Do you sell products or provide services other than investment advice to your
advisory clients?
Yes No
r
If "yes," describe this other business on Section 6.8.(3) of Schedule D, and if you engage in this
business under a different name, provide that name.
SECTION 6.A. Names of Your Other Businesses
No Information Filed
SECTION 6.B.(2) Description of Primary Business
Describe your primary business (not your investment advisory business):
WE PROVIDE BUSINESS CONSULTING SERVICES ON AN OPPORTUNISTIC BASIS.
If you engage in that business under a different name, provide that name:
SECTION 6.B.(3) Description of Other Products and Services
Describe other products or services you sell to your dient, You may omit products and services that you
listed in Section 6.B.(2) above.
If you engage in that business under a different name, provide that name.
Item 7 Financial Industry Affiliations and Private Fund Reporting
In this Item, we request information about your financial industry affiliations and activities. This
information identifies areas in which conflicts of interest may occur between you and your clients.

A. This part of Item 7 requires you to provide information about you and your related persons, including
foreign affiliates. Your related persons are all of your advisory affiliates and any person that is under
common control with you.
You have a related person that is a (check all that apply):

(1) broker -dealer, municipal securities dealer, or government securities broker or dealer
(registered or unregistered)

(2) other investment adviser (including financial planners)
(3) registered municipal advisor
(4) registered security -based swap dealer

(5) major security -based swap participant
(6) commodity pool operator or commodity trading advisor (whether registered or exempt
from registration)

(7) futures commission merchant
(8) banking or thrift institution
(9) trust company
(10) accountant or accounting firm

(11) lawyer or law firm
(12) insurance company or agency
(13) pension consultant
(14) real estate broker or dealer

(15) sponsor or syndicator of limited partnerships (or equivalent), excluding pooled
investment vehicles
r (16) sponsor, general partner, managing member (or equivalent) of pooled investment
vehicles
11 -1 - 111 - 111 -11111 1
For each related person, including foreign affiliates that may not be registered or required to be
registered in the United States, complete Section 7.A. of Schedule D.
You do not need to complete Section 7.A. of Schedule D for any related person if: (1) you have no
business dealings with the related person in connection with advisory services you provide to your
clients; (2) you do not conduct shared operations with the related person; (3) you do not refer clients
or business to the related person, and the related person does not refer prospective clients or business
to you; (4) you do not share supervised persons or premises with the related person; and (5) you have
no reason to believe that your relationship with the related person otherwise creates a conflict of
interest with your clients.
You must complete Section 7.A. of Schedule D for each related person acting as qualified custodian in
connection with advisory services you provide to your clients (other than any mutual fund transfer
agent pursuant to rule 206(4)-2(b)(1)), regardless of whether you have determined the related person
to be operationally independent under rule 206(4)-2 of the Advisers Act.

B. Are you an adviser to any private fund?
Yes No
r
If "yes," then for each private fund that you advise, you must complete a Section 7.8.(1) of Schedule D,
except in certain circumstances described in the next sentence and in Instruction 6 of the Instructions
to Part 1A. If another adviser reports this information with respect to any such private fund in Section
7.8.(1) of Schedule D of its Form ADV (e.g., if you are a subadviser), do not complete Section 7.5.(1) of
Schedule D with respect to that private fund. You must, instead, complete Section 7.11(2) of Schedule D.
In either case, if you seek to preserve the anonymity of a private fund client by maintaining its identity
in your books and records in numerical or alphabetical code, or similar designation, pursuant to rule 204-
2(d), you may identify the private fund in Section 7.8.(1 ) or 7.8.(2) of Schedule D using the same code
or designation in place of the fund's name.
SECTION 7.A. Financial Industry Affiliations
No Information Filed
SECTION 7.B.(1) Private Fund Reporting
No Information Filed
SECTION 7.B.(2) Private Fund Reporting
No Information Filed
Item 8 Participation or Interest in Client Transactions
In this Item, we request information about your participation and interest in your clients' transactions.
This information identifies additional areas in which conflicts of interest may occur between you and your
clients.
Like Item 7, Item 8 requires you to provide information about you and your related persons, including
foreign affiliates.
Proprietary Interest in Client Transactions

A. Do you or any related person:
(1) buy securities for yourself from advisory clients, or sell securities you own to advisory
clients (principal transactions)?

(2) buy or sell for yourself securities (other than shares of mutual funds) that you also
recommend to advisory clients?

(3) recommend securities (or other investment products) to advisory clients in which you
or any related person has some other proprietary (ownership) interest (other than
those mentioned in Items 8.A.(1) or (2))?
Yes No
r
r
r
Sales Interest in Client Transactions

B. Do you or any related person: Yes No
(1) as a broker -dealer or registered representative of a broker -dealer, execute securities
trades for brokerage customers in which advisory client securities are sold to or
bought from the brokerage customer (agency cross transactions)?

(2) recommend purchase of securities to advisory clients for which you or any related
person serves as underwriter, general or managing partner, or purchaser
representative?

(3) recommend purchase or sale of securities to advisory clients for which you or any
related person has any other sales interest (other than the receipt of sales
commissions as a broker or registered representative of a broker -dealer)?
Investment or Brokerage Discretion

C. Do you or any related person have discretionary authority to determine the:
(1) securities to be bought or sold for a client's account?

(2) amount of securities to be bought or sold for a client's account?
(3) broker or dealer to be used for a purchase or sale of securities for a client's account?

(4) commission rates to be paid to a broker or dealer for a client's securities
transactions?
D. If you answer "yes" to C.(3) above, are any of the brokers or dealers related persons?

E. Do you or any related person recommend brokers or dealers to clients?
F. If you answer "yes" to E above, are any of the brokers or dealers related persons?

G. (1) Do you or any related person receive research or other products or services other
than execution from a broker -dealer or a third party ("soft dollar benefits") in
✓ r.
✓ r.
✓ r.
Yes No
• r

r. r
• r
• r
✓ r.
✓ r.
r
r. r
connection with client securities transactions?
(2) If "yes" to G.(1) above, are all the "soft dollar benefits" you or any related persons
receive eligible "research or brokerage services" under section 28(e) of the Securities
Exchange Act of 1934?

H. Do you or any related person, directly or indirectly, compensate any person for client
referrals?
I. Do you or any related person, directly or indirectly, receive compensation from any person
for client referrals?
r
r
r
In responding to Items 8.H and 8.L, consider all cash and non -cash compensation that you or a related
person gave to (in answering Item 8.fr) or received from (in answering Item 8.0 any person in exchange
for client referrals, including any bonus that is based, at least in par₹, on the number or amount of client
referrals.
Item 9 Custody
In this Item, we ask you whether you or a related person has custody of client (other than clients that are
investment companies registered under the Investment Company Act of 1940) assets and about your
custodial practices.

A. (1) Do you have custody of any advisory clients':
(a) cash or bank accounts?
(b) securities?
Yes No
r
r r.
If you are registering or registered with the SEC, answer "No" to Item 9.A.(1)(a) and (b) if you have
custody solely because (i) you deduct your advisory fees directly from your clients' accounts, or (ii) a
related person has custody of client assets in connection with advisory services you provide to clients,
but you have overcome the presumption that you are not operationally independent (pursuant to
Advisers Act rule 206(4)-(2)(d)(5)) from the related person.

(2) If you checked "yes" to Item 9.A.(1)(a) or (b), what is the approximate amount of client funds
and securities and total number of clients for which you have custody:
U.S. Dollar Amount Total Number of Clients
(a)$ (b)
If you are registering or registered with the SEC and you have custody solely because you deduct your
advisory fees directly from your clients' accounts, do not include the amount of those assets and the
number of those clients in your response to Item 9.A.(2). If your related person has custody of client
assets in connection with advisory services you provide to clients, do not include the amount of those
assets and number of those clients in your response to 9.A.(2). Instead, include that information in
your response to Item 9.8.(2).

B. (1) In connection with advisory services you provide to clients, do any of your related
persons have custody of any of your advisory clients':

(a) cash or bank accounts?
(b) securities?
You are required to answer this item regardless of how you answered Item 9.A.(1)(a) or (b).

(2) If you checked "yes" to Item 9.B.(1)(a) or (b), what is the approximate amount of client funds
and securities and total number of clients for which your related persons have custody:
U.S. Dollar Amount Total Number of Clients
Yes No
r
r

C. If you or your related persons have custody of client funds or securities in connection with advisory
services you provide to clients, check all the following that apply:

(1) A qualified custodian(s) sends account statements at least quarterly to the investors
in the pooled investment vehicle(s) you manage.

(2) An independent public accountant audits annually the pooled investment vehicle(s)
that you manage and the audited financial statements are distributed to the
investors in the pools.

(3) An independent public accountant conducts an annual surprise examination of client
funds and securities.

(4) An independent public accountant prepares an internal control report with respect to
custodial services when you or your related persons are qualified custodians for client
funds and securities.
r
r
r
If you checked Item 9.C.(2), C.(3) or C.(4), list in Section 9.C. of Schedule D the accountants that are
engaged to perform the audit or examination or prepare an internal control report. (If you checked Item
9.C.(2), you do not have to list auditor information in Section 9.C. of Schedule D if you already provided
this information with respect to the private funds you advise in Section 7.8.(1) of Schedule D).

D. Do you or your related person(s) act as qualified custodians for your clients in connection
with advisory services you provide to clients?

(1) you act as a qualified custodian
(2) your related person(s) act as qualified custodian(s)
Yes No
If you checked "yes" to Item 9.D.(2), all related persons that act as qualified custodians (other than any
mutual fund transfer agent pursuant to rule 206(4)-2(b)(1)) must be identified in Section 7.A. of
Schedule D, regardless of whether you have determined the related person to be operationally
independent under rule 206(4)-2 of the Advisers Act.

E. If you are filing your annual updating amendment and you were subject to a surprise examination by
an independent public accountant during your last fiscal year, provide the date (MM/YYYY) the
examination commenced:

F. If you or your related persons have custody of client funds or securities, how many persons,
including, but not limited to, you and your related persons, act as qualified custodians for your clients
in connection with advisory services you provide to clients?
SECTION 9.C. Independent Public Accountant
No Information Filed
Item 10 Control Persons
In this Item, we ask you to identify every person that, directly or indirectly, controls you.
If you are submitting an initial application or report, you must complete Schedule A and Schedule B.
Schedule A asks for information about your direct owners and executive officers. Schedule B asks for
information about your indirect owners. If this is an amendment and you are updating information you
reported on either Schedule A or Schedule B (or both) that you filed with your initial application or
report, you must complete Schedule C.
Yes No

A. Does any person not named in Item 1.A. or Schedules A, B, or C, directly or indirectly,
control your management or policies?
If yes, complete Section 10.A. of Schedule D.
r
B. If any person named in Schedules A, B, or C or in Section 10.A. of Schedule D is a public reporting
company under Sections 12 or 15(d) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, please complete

Section 10.B. of Schedule D.
SECTION 10.A. Control Persons
No Information Filed
SECTION 10.B. Control Person Public Reporting Companies
No Information Filed
Item 11 Disclosure Information
In this Item, we ask for information about your disciplinary history and the disciplinary history of all your
advisory affiliates. We use this information to determine whether to grant your application for
registration, to decide whether to revoke your registration or to place limitations on your activities as an
investment adviser, and to identify potential problem areas to focus on during our on -site examinations.
One event may result in "yes" answers to more than one of the questions below.
Your advisory affiliates are: (1) all of your current employees (other than employees performing only
clerical, administrative, support or similar functions); (2) all of your officers, partners, or directors (or any
person performing similar functions); and (3) all persons directly or indirectly controlling you or controlled
by you. If you are a "separately identifiable department or division" (SID) of a bank, see the Glossary of
Terms to determine who your advisory affiliates are.
If you are registered or registering with the SEC or if you are an exempt reporting adviser, you may limit your
disclosure of any event listed in Item 11 to ten years following the date of the event. If you are registered or
registering with a state, you must respond to the questions as posed; you may, therefore, limit your
disclosure to ten years following the date of an event only in responding to Items 11.A.(1), 11.A.(2), 11.8.(1),
11.8.(2), 11.D.(4), and 11.1-1.(1)(a). For purposes of calculating this ten-year period, the date of an event is
the date the final order, judgment, or decree was entered, or the date any rights of appeal from preliminary
orders, judgments, or decrees lapsed.
You must complete the appropriate Disclosure Reporting Page ("DRP") for "yes" answers to the
questions in this Item 11.
Do any of the events below involve you or any of your supervised persons?
For "ves" answers to the following questions, comolete a Criminal Action DRP:

A. In the past ten years, have you or any advisory affiliate:
(1) been convicted of or pled guilty or nob contendere ("no contest") in a domestic,
foreign, or military court to any felony?

(2) been charged with any felony?
Yes No
r
Yes No
r
r r.
If you are registered or registering with the SEC, or if you are reporting as an exempt reporting adviser,
you may limit your response to Item 11.A.(2) to charges that are currently pending.

B. In the past ten years, have you or any advisory affiliate:
(1) been convicted of or pled guilty or nob contendere ("no contest") in a domestic,
foreign, or military court to a misdemeanor involving: investments or an investment -
related business, or any fraud, false statements, or omissions, wrongful taking of
property, bribery, perjury, forgery, counterfeiting, extortion, or a conspiracy to commit
any of these offenses?

(2) been charged with a misdemeanor listed in Item 11.B.(1)?
r
r r.
If you are registered or registering with the SEC, or if you are reporting as an exempt reporting adviser,
you may limit your response to Item 11.8.(2) to charges that are currently pending.
For "yes" answers to the following questions, complete a Reaulatory Action DRP:

C. Has the SEC or the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) ever:
(1) found you or any advisory affiliate to have made a false statement or omission?

(2) found you or any advisory affiliate to have been involved in a violation of SEC or CFTC
regulations or statutes?
found you or any advisory affiliate to have been a cause of an investment -related
business having its authorization to do business denied, suspended, revoked, or
restricted?
( 3)

(4) entered an order against you or any advisory affiliate in connection with investment -
related activity?
imposed a civil money penalty on you or any advisory affiliate, or ordered you or any
advisory affiliate to cease and desist from any activity?
( 5)

D. Has any other federal regulatory agency, any state regulatory agency, or any foreign
financial regulatory authority:

(1) ever found you or any advisory affiliate to have made a false statement or omission, or
been dishonest, unfair, or unethical?

(2) ever found you or any advisory affiliate to have been involved in a violation of
investment -related regulations or statutes?
ever found you or any advisory affiliate to have been a cause of an investment -related
business having its authorization to do business denied, suspended, revoked, or
restricted?
( 3)

(4) in the past ten years, entered an order against you or any advisory affiliate in
connection with an investment -related activity?
ever denied, suspended, or revoked your or any advisory affiliate's registration or
license, or otherwise prevented you or any advisory affiliate, by order, from associating
with an investment -related business or restricted your or any advisory affiliate's
activity?
( 5)

E. Has any self -regulatory organization or commodities exchange ever:
(1) found you or any advisory affiliate to have made a false statement or omission?

(2) found you or any advisory affiliate to have been involved in a violation of its rules (other
than a violation designated as a "minor rule violation" under a plan approved by the
SEC)?
found you or any advisory affiliate to have been the cause of an investment -related
business having its authorization to do business denied, suspended, revoked, or
restricted?
( 3)

(4) disciplined you or any advisory affiliate by expelling or suspending you or the advisory
affiliate from membership, barring or suspending you or the advisory affiliate from
association with other members, or otherwise restricting your or the advisory affiliate's
activities?

F. Has an authorization to act as an attorney, accountant, or federal contractor granted to
you or any advisory affiliate ever been revoked or suspended?
Yes No
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r r.
r
r
r
r
r r.

G. Are you or any advisory affiliate now the subject of any regulatory proceeding that could
result in a "yes" answer to any part of Item 11.C., 11.D., or 11.E.?
For "yes" answers to the following questions, complete a Civil Judicial Action DRP:

H. (1) Has any domestic or foreign court:
(a) in the past ten years, enjoined you or any advisory affiliate in connection with any
investment -related activity?

(b) ever found that you or any advisory affiliate were involved in a violation of
investment -related statutes or regulations?

(c) ever dismissed, pursuant to a settlement agreement, an investment -related civil
action brought against you or any advisory affiliate by a state or foreign financial
regulatory authority?

(2) Are you or any advisory affiliate now the subject of any civil proceeding that could
result in a "yes" answer to any part of Item 11.H.(1)?
r r.
Yes No
r
r r.
r
r
Item 12 Small Businesses
The SEC is required by the Regulatory Flexibility Act to consider the effect of its regulations on small
entities. In order to do this, we need to determine whether you meet the definition of "small business"
or "small organization" under rule 0-7.
Answer this Item 12 only if you are registered or registering with the SEC and you indicated in response
to Item 5.F.(2)(c) that you have regulatory assets under management of less than $25 million. You are
not required to answer this Item 12 if you are filing for initial registration as a state adviser, amending a
current state registration, or switching from SEC to state registration.
For purposes of this Item 12 only:

• Total Assets refers to the total assets of a firm, rather than the assets managed on behalf of
clients. In determining your or another person's total assets, you may use the total assets shown
on a current balance sheet (but use total assets reported on a consolidated balance sheet with
subsidiaries included, if that amount is larger).
• Control means the power to direct or cause the direction of the management or policies of a
person, whether through ownership of securities, by contract, or otherwise. Any person that
directly or indirectly has the right to vote 25 percent or more of the voting securities, or is entitled
to 25 percent or more of the profits, of another person is presumed to control the other person.
Yes No

A. Did you have total assets of $5 million or more on the last day of your most recent fiscal
year?
If "yes," you do not need to answer Items 12.8. and 12.C.

B. Do you:
(1) control another investment adviser that had regulatory assets under management
(calculated in response to Item 5.F.(2)(c) of Form ADV) of $25 million or more on the
last day of its most recent fiscal year?

(2) control another person (other than a natural person) that had total assets of $5 million
or more on the last day of its most recent fiscal year?

C. Are you:
(1) controlled by or under common control with another investment adviser that had
regulatory assets under management (calculated in response to Item 5.F.(2)(c) of
Form ADV) of $25 million or more on the last day of its most recent fiscal year?

(2) controlled by or under common control with another person (other than a natural
person) that had total assets of $5 million or more on the last day of its most recent
fiscal year?
✓ r
✓ r
r
✓ r
✓ r
Schedule A
Direct Owners and Executive Officers

1. Complete Schedule A only if you are submitting an initial application or report. Schedule A asks for
information about your direct owners and executive officers. Use Schedule C to amend this
information.

2. Direct Owners and Executive Officers. List below the names of:
(a) each Chief Executive Officer, Chief Financial Officer, Chief Operations Officer, Chief Legal Officer,
Chief Compliance Officer(Chief Compliance Officer is required if you are registered or applying for
registration and cannot be more than one individual), director, and any other individuals with
similar status or functions;

(b) if you are organized as a corporation, each shareholder that is a direct owner of 5% or more of a
class of your voting securities, unless you are a public reporting company (a company subject to

Section 12 or 15(d) of the Exchange Act);
Direct owners include any person that owns, beneficially owns, has the right to vote, or has the
power to sell or direct the sale of, 5% or more of a class of your voting securities. For purposes of
this Schedule, a person beneficially owns any securities: (i) owned by his/her child, stepchild,
grandchild, parent, stepparent, grandparent, spouse, sibling, mother-in-law, father-in-law, son-in-
law, daughter-in-law, brother-in-law, or sister-in-law, sharing the same residence; or (ii) that
he/she has the right to acquire, within 60 days, through the exercise of any option, warrant, or
right to purchase the security.

(c) if you are organized as a partnership, all general partners and those limited and special partners
that have the right to receive upon dissolution, or have contributed, 5% or more of your capital;

(d) in the case of a trust that directly owns 5% or more of a class of your voting securities, or that
has the right to receive upon dissolution, or has contributed, 5% or more of your capital, the trust
and each trustee; and

(e) if you are organized as a limited liability company ("LLC"), (i) those members that have the right to
receive upon dissolution, or have contributed, 5% or more of your capital, and (ii) if managed by
elected managers, all elected managers.

3. Do you have any indirect owners to be reported on Schedule B? r Yes No
4. In the DE/FE/I column below, enter "DE" if the owner is a domestic entity, "FE" if the owner is an
entity incorporated or domiciled in a foreign country, or "I" if the owner or executive officer is an
individual.

5. Complete the Title or Status column by entering board/management titles; status as partner, trustee,
sole proprietor, elected manager, shareholder, or member; and for shareholders or members, the
class of securities owned (if more than one is issued).

6. Ownership codes NA - less than 5%
are:
A - 5% but less than
10%
B - 10% but less than D - 50% but less than
25% 75%
C - 25% but less than E - 75% or more
50 0/0

7. (a) In the Control Person column, enter "Yes" if the person has control as defined in the Glossary of
Terms to Form ADV, and enter "No" if the person does not have control. Note that under this
definition, most executive officers and all 25% owners, general partners, elected managers, and
trustees are control persons.

(b) In the PR column, enter "PR" if the owner is a public reporting company under Sections 12 or 15(d)
of the Exchange Act.

(c) Complete  each column.
FULL LEGAL NAME DE/FE/I Status Date Ownership Control PR CRD No. If None:
(Individuals: Last Name, First Status Code Person S.S. No. and Date
Name, Middle Name) Acquired of Birth, IRS Tax
MM/YYYY No. or Emplc
ID No.
LEW, JOSHUA, LOUIS I PARTNER 12/2009 D Y N
FOWLER, MICHAEL, JAMES I PARTNER 05/2014 C Y
yer
Schedule B
Indirect Owners

1. Complete Schedule B only if you are submitting an initial application. Schedule B asks for information
about your indirect owners; you must first complete Schedule A, which asks for information about
your direct owners. Use Schedule C to amend this information.

2. Indirect Owners. With respect to each owner listed on Schedule A (except individual owners), list
below:

(a) in the case of an owner that is a corporation, each of its shareholders that beneficially owns, has
the right to vote, or has the power to sell or direct the sale of, 25% or more of a class of a voting
security of that corporation;
For purposes of this Schedule, a person beneficially owns any securities: (i) owned by his/her
child, stepchild, grandchild, parent, stepparent, grandparent, spouse, sibling, mother-in-law,
father-in-law, son-in-law, daughter-in-law, brother-in-law, or sister-in-law, sharing the same
residence; or (ii) that he/she has the right to acquire, within 60 days, through the exercise of
any option, warrant, or right to purchase the security.

(b) in the case of an owner that is a partnership, all general partners and those limited and special
partners that have the right to receive upon dissolution, or have contributed, 25% or more of
the partnership's capital;

(c) in the case of an owner that is a trust, the trust and each trustee; and
(d) in the case of an owner that is a limited liability company ("LLC"), (i) those members that have
the right to receive upon dissolution, or have contributed, 25% or more of the LLC's capital, and

(ii) if managed by elected managers, all elected managers.
3. Continue up the chain of ownership listing all 25% owners at each level. Once a public reporting
company (a company subject to Sections 12 or 15(d) of the Exchange Act) is reached, no further
ownership information need be given.

4. In the DE/FE/I column below, enter "DE" if the owner is a domestic entity, "FE" if the owner is an
entity incorporated or domiciled in a foreign country, or "I" if the owner is an individual.

5. Complete the Status column by entering the owner's status as partner, trustee, elected manager,
shareholder, or member; and for shareholders or members, the class of securities owned (if more
than one is issued).

6. Ownership codes C - 25% but less than E - 75% or more
are: 50 0/0
D - 50% but less than F - Other (general partner, trustee, or elected
75 0/0 manager)

7. (a) In the Control Person column, enter "Yes" if the person has control as defined in the Glossary of
Terms to Form ADV, and enter "No" if the person does not have control. Note that under this
definition, most executive officers and all 25% owners, general partners, elected managers, and
trustees are control persons.

(b) In the PR column, enter "PR" if the owner is a public reporting company under Sections 12 or
15(d) of the Exchange Act.

(c) Complete each column.
No Information Filed
Schedule D - Miscellaneous
You may use the space below to explain a response to an Item or to provide any other information.
DRP Pages
CRIMINAL DISCLOSURE REPORTING PAGE (ADV)
No Information Filed
REGULATORY ACTION DISCLOSURE REPORTING PAGE (ADV)
No Information Filed
CIVIL JUDICIAL ACTION DISCLOSURE REPORTING PAGE (ADV)
No Information Filed
Arbitration DRPs
No Information Filed
Bond DRPs
No Information Filed
Judgment/Lien DRPs
No Information Filed
Part 1B Item 1 - State Registration
You must complete this Part 1B only if you are applying for registration, or are registered, as an
investment adviser with any of the state securities authorities.
Complete this Item 1 if you are submitting an initial application for state registration or requesting
additional state registration(s). Check the boxes next to the states to which you are submitting this
application. If you are already registered with at least one state and are applying for registration with
an additional state or states, check the boxes next to the states in which you are applying for
registration. Do not check the boxes next to the states in which you are currently registered or where
you have an application for registration pending.
Jurisdictions
✓ AL
✓ AK
✓ AZ
✓ AR
✓ CA
✓ ID
r IL -
✓ IN
✓ IA
✓ KS
r MO
r MT
r NE
r NV
r NH
✓ pp,
✓ PR
✓ RI
✓ so
✓ SD
✓ CO r KY r N3 r TN
✓ CT r LA r NM r -rx
r- DE r ME r NY r UT
✓ DC r MD I- NC r VT
r- FL F MA r ND r VI
✓ GA r MI rO11 r VA
✓ GU r MN r OK r WA
✓ HI r ms r OR r WV
r WI
Part IB Item 2 - Additional Information
Complete this Item 2A. only if the person responsible for supervision and compliance does not appear in
Item 11 or 1K. of Form ADV Part 1A:

A. Person responsible for supervision and compliance:
Name:
JOSHUA LEVY
Telephone:
Number and Street 1:
Title:
PARTNER
Fax:
9782951765
Number and Street 2:
City: State: Country: ZIP+4/Postal Code:
SUDBURY Massachusetts UNITED STATES 01776
Email address, if available:
If this address is a private residence, check this box: Fl

B. Bond/Capital Information, if required by your home state
(1) Name of Issuing Insurance Company:
(2) Amount of Bond:
$ .00

(3) Bond Policy Number:
(4) If required by your home state, are you in compliance with your home state's
minimum capital requirements?
Part IB - Disclosure Questions
BOND DISCLOSURE
For "yes" answers to the following question, complete a Bond DRP.

C. Has a bonding company ever denied, paid out on, or revoked a bond for you, any
advisory affiliate, or any management person?
Yes No
r r
Yes No
r
JUDGMENT/LIEN DISCLOSURE
For "yes" answers to the following question, complete a Judgment/Lien DRP.

D. Are there any unsatisfied judgments or liens against you, any advisory affiliate, or any
management person?
ARBITRATION DISCLOSURE
For "yes" answers to the following questions, complete an Arbitration DRP.

E. Are you, any advisory affiliate, or any management person currently the subject of, or
have you, any advisory affiliate, or any management person been the subject of, an
arbitration claim alleging damages in excess of $2,500, involving any of the following:

(1) any investment or an investment -related business of activity?
(2) fraud, false statement, or omission?

(3) theft, embezzlement, or other wrongful taking of property?
(4) bribery, forgery, counterfeiting, or extortion?

(5) dishonest, unfair, or unethical practices?
CIVIL JUDICIAL DISCLOSURE
For "yes" answers to the following questions, complete a Civil Judicial Action DRP.

F. Are you, any advisory affiliate, or any management person currently subject to, or have
you, any advisory affiliate, or any management person been found liable in, a civil, self -
regulatory organization, or administrative proceeding involving any of the following:

(1) an investment or investment -related business or activity?
(2) fraud, false statement, or omission?
(3) theft, embezzlement, or other wrongful taking of property?

(4) bribery, forgery, counterfeiting, or extortion?
(5) dishonest, unfair, or unethical practices?
Yes No
✓ r.
Yes No
✓ r.
r
r
r
r
Yes No
✓ r.
r
r
✓ r.
r
Part 18 - Business Information

G. Other Business Activities
(1) Are you, any advisory affiliate, or any management person actively engaged in business as a(n)
(check all that apply):
r Tax Preparer
r Issuer of securities
✓ Sponsor or syndicator of limited partnerships (or equivalent), excluding pooled investment
vehicles
✓ Sponsor, general partner, managing member (or equivalent) of pooled investment vehicles
✓ Real estate adviser

(2) If you, any advisory affiliate, or any management person are actively engaged in any business
other than those listed in Item 6.A of Part 1A or Item 2.G(1) of Part 15, describe the business
and the approximate amount of time spent on that business:

H. If you provide financial planning services, the investments made based on those services at the
end of your last fiscal year totaled:
Securities Investments Non -Securities Investments
Under $100,000
$100,001 to $500,000
$500,001 to $1,000,000
$1,000,001 to $2,500,000
$2,500,001 to $5,000,000
More than $5,000,000
If securities investments are over $5,000,000, how much? (round to the nearest $1,000,000)
If non -securities investments are over $5,000,000, how much? (round to the nearest
$1,000,000)

I. Custody
(1) Advisory Fees
Do you withdraw advisory fees directly from your clients' accounts? If you answered
"yes", respond to the following:

(a) Do you send a copy of your invoice to the custodian or trustee at the same time
that you send a copy to the client?

(b) Does the custodian send quarterly statements to your clients showing all
disbursements for the custodian account, including the amount of the advisory
fees?

(c) Do your clients provide written authorization permitting you to be paid directly for
their accounts held by the custodian or trustee?

(2) Pooled Investment Vehicles and Trusts
(a) (i) Do you or a related person act as a general partner, managing member, or
person serving in a similar capacity, for any pooled investment vehicle for
which you are the adviser to the pooled investment vehicle, or for which you
are the adviser to one or more of the investors in the pooled investment
vehicle? If you answered "yes", respond to the following:

(a) (ii) As the general partner, managing member, or person serving in a similar
capacity, have you or a related person engaged any of the following to
provide authority permitting each direct payment or any transfer of funds or
securities from the account of the pooled investment vehicle?
Yes No
• r
• r

r. r
r
r
Attorney r r
Independent certified public accountant r r
Other independent party r r
Describe the independent party:
For purposes of this Item 21.2(a), "Independent party" means a person that: (A) is
engaged by the investment adviser to act as a gatekeeper for the payment of fees,
expenses and capital withdrawals from the pooled investment; (B) does not control and is
not controlled by and is not under common control with the investment adviser; (C) does
not have, and has not had within the past two years, a material business relationship with
the investment adviser; and (D) shall not negotiate or agree to have material business
relations or commonly controlled relations with an investment adviser for a period of two
years after serving as the person engaged in an independent party agreement.
( 3)

(b) Do you or a related person act as investment adviser and a trustee for any trust,
or act as a trustee for any trust in which your advisory clients are beneficiaries of
the trust?
Do you require the prepayment of fees of more than $500 per client and for six
months or more in advance?
r
r

J. If you are organized as a sole proprietorship, please answer the following: Yes No
( 1) (a) Have you passed, on or after January 1,2000, the Series 65 examination? r r

(b) Have you passed, on or after January 1,2000, the Series 66 examination
and also passed, at any time, the Series 7 examination?
r r

(2) (a) Do you have any investment advisory professional designations? r r
If "non,you do not need to answer Item 2.42)(b).

(b) I have earned and I am in good standing with the organization that issued
the following credential:
✓ Certified Financial Planner ("CFP")
✓ Chartered Financial Analyst ("CFA")
✓ Chartered Financial Consultant ("ChFC")
✓ Chartered Investment Counselor ("CIC")
✓ Personal Financial Specialist ("PFS")
✓ None of the above
( 3) Your Social Security Number:
K. If you are organized other than as a sole proprietorship, please provide the following:
(1) Indicate the date you obtained your legal status. Date of formation: 12/11/2009
( 2) Indicate your IRS Empl. Ident. No.: 271441836
Part 2
Amend, retire or file new brochures:
Brochure ID
88021
Brochure Name Brochure Type(s) Action
RED DOT TRADE FINANCE, LLC ADV 2 High net worth individuals, Other
institutional, Includes material
about supervised persons that
would otherwise be in a
supplement (state -registered
advisers only)
No Change
-1.
Execution Pages
DOMESTIC INVESTMENT ADVISER EXECUTION PAGE
You must complete the following Execution Page to Form ADV. This execution page must be signed and
attached to your initial submission of Form ADV to the SEC and all amendments.
Appointment of Agent for Service of Process
By signing this Form ADV Execution Page, you, the undersigned adviser, irrevocably appoint the
Secretary of State or other legally designated officer, of the state in which you maintain your principal
office and place of business and any other state in which you are submitting a notice filing, as your
agents to receive service, and agree that such persons may accept service on your behalf, of any
notice, subpoena, summons, order instituting proceedings, demand for arbitration, or other process or
papers, and you further agree that such service may be made by registered or certified mail, in any
federal or state action, administrative proceeding or arbitration brought against you in any place
subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, if the action, proceeding, or arbitration (a) arises out of
any activity in connection with your investment advisory business that is subject to the jurisdiction of
the United States, and (b) is founded, directly or indirectly, upon the provisions of: (i) the Securities Act
of 1933, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the Trust Indenture Act of 1939, the Investment
Company Act of 1940, or the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, or any rule or regulation under any of
these acts, or (ii) the laws of the state in which you maintain your principal office and place of business
or of any state in which you are submitting a notice filing.
Signature
I, the undersigned, sign this Form ADV on behalf of, and with the authority of, the investment adviser.
The investment adviser and I both certify, under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States
of America, that the information and statements made in this ADV, including exhibits and any other
information submitted, are true and correct, and that I am signing this Form ADV Execution Page as a
free and voluntary act.
I certify that the adviser's books and records will be preserved and available for inspection as required
by law. Finally, I authorize any person having custody or possession of these books and records to
make them available to federal and state regulatory representatives.
Signature: Date: MM/DD/YYYY
JOSHUA L LEVY 05/14/2014
Printed Name: Title:
JOSHUA L LEVY PARTNER
Adviser CRD Number:
NON-RESIDENT INVESTMENT ADVISER EXECUTION PAGE
You must complete the following Execution Page to Form ADV. This execution page must be signed and
attached to your initial submission of Form ADV to the SEC and all amendments.

1. Appointment of Agent for Service of Process
By signing this Form ADV Execution Page, you, the undersigned adviser, irrevocably appoint each of
the Secretary of the SEC, and the Secretary of State or other legally designated officer, of any other
state in which you are submitting a notice filing, as your agents to receive service, and agree that such
persons may accept service on your behalf, of any notice, subpoena, summons, order instituting
proceedings, demand for arbitration, or other process or papers, and you further agree that such
service may be made by registered or certified mail, in any federal or state action, administrative
proceeding or arbitration brought against you in any place subject to the jurisdiction of the United
States, if the action, proceeding or arbitration (a) arises out of any activity in connection with your
investment advisory business that is subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, and (b) is founded,
directly or indirectly, upon the provisions of: (i) the Securities Act of 1933, the Securities Exchange Act
of 1934, the Trust Indenture Act of 1939, the Investment Company Act of 1940, or the Investment
Advisers Act of 1940, or any rule or regulation under any of these acts, or (ii) the laws of any state in
which you are submitting a notice filing.

2. Appointment and Consent: Effect on Partnerships
If you are organized as a partnership, this irrevocable power of attorney and consent to service of
process will continue in effect if any partner withdraws from or is admitted to the partnership, provided
that the admission or withdrawal does not create a new partnership. If the partnership dissolves, this
irrevocable power of attorney and consent shall be in effect for any action brought against you or any
of your former partners.

3. Non -Resident Investment Adviser Undertaking Regarding Books and Records
By signing this Form ADV, you also agree to provide, at your own expense, to the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission at its principal office in Washington D.C., at any Regional or District Office of the
Commission, or at any one of its offices in the United States, as specified by the Commission, correct,
current, and complete copies of any or all records that you are required to maintain under Rule 204-2
under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. This undertaking shall be binding upon you, your heirs,
successors and assigns, and any person subject to your written irrevocable consents or powers of
attorney or any of your general partners and managing agents.
Signature
I, the undersigned, sign this Form ADV on behalf of, and with the authority of, the non-resident
investment adviser. The investment adviser and I both certify, under penalty of perjury under the laws
of the United States of America, that the information and statements made in this ADV, including
exhibits and any other information submitted, are true and correct, and that I am signing this Form
ADV Execution Page as a free and voluntary act.
I certify that the adviser's books and records will be preserved and available for inspection as required
by law. Finally, I authorize any person having custody or possession of these books and records to
make them available to federal and state regulatory representatives.
Signature: Date: MM/DD/YYYY
Printed Name: Title:
Adviser CRD Number:
166121
STATE -REGISTERED INVESTMENT ADVISER EXECUTION PAGE
You must complete the following Execution Page to Form ADV. This execution page must be signed and
attached to your initial application for state registration and all amendments to registration.

1. Appointment of Agent for Service of Process
By signing this Form ADV Execution Page, you, the undersigned adviser, irrevocably appoint the legally
designated officers and their successors, of the state in which you maintain your principal office and
place of business and any other state in which you are applying for registration or amending your
registration, as your agents to receive service, and agree that such persons may accept service on
your behalf, of any notice, subpoena, summons, order instituting proceedings, demand for arbitration, or
other process or papers, and you further agree that such service may be made by registered or
certified mail, in any federal or state action, administrative proceeding or arbitration brought against
you in any place subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, if the action, proceeding, or arbitration

(a) arises out of any activity in connection with your investment advisory business that is subject to
the jurisdiction of the United States, and (b) is founded, directly or indirectly, upon the provisions of: (i)
the Securities Act of 1933, the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, the Trust Indenture Act of 1939, the
Investment Company Act of 1940, or the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, or any rule or regulation
under any of these acts, or (ii) the laws of the state in which you maintain your principal office and place
of business or of any state in which you are applying for registration or amending your registration.
2. State -Registered Investment Adviser Affidavit
If you are subject to state regulation, by signing this Form ADV, you represent that, you are in
compliance with the registration requirements of the state in which you maintain your principal place of
business and are in compliance with the bonding, capital, and recordkeeping requirements of that
state.
Signature
I, the undersigned, sign this Form ADV on behalf of, and with the authority of, the investment adviser.
The investment adviser and I both certify, under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States
of America, that the information and statements made in this ADV, including exhibits and any other
information submitted, are true and correct, and that I am signing this Form ADV Execution Page as a
free and voluntary act.
I certify that the adviser's books and records will be preserved and available for inspection as required
by law. Finally, I authorize any person having custody or possession of these books and records to
make them available to federal and state regulatory representatives.
Date: MM/DD/YYYY Printed Name:
05/14/2014 JOSHUA L LEVY
CRD Number:
Authorized Signatory:
JOSHUA L LEVY
Title :
PARTNER
Privacy Legal Use of Web CRD®, IARDTM, or PFRDTM is govemed by the Terms & Conditions.
O2014 FINRA. All rights reserved. FINRA is a registered trademark of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, Inc.
Doing Business As:
4ATO R U S
Form ADV Part 2 - Disclosure Brochure
Effective: November 15, 2012
Revised: May 14, 2014
This Brochure provides information about the qualifications and business practices of Red Dot Trade
Finance, LLC doing business as Atoms ("Atoms"). If you have any questions about the contents of this
Brochure, please contact us at (978) 295-1765.
Atoms is a registered investment Advisor registered with the State of Massachusetts. The information
in this Brochure has not been approved or verified by the SEC or by any state securities authority.
Registration of an Investment Advisor does not imply any specific level of skill or training. The oral
and written communications of an Advisor provide you with information about which you determine to
hire or retain an Advisor.
Additional information about Atoms and its advisory persons are available on the SEC's website at
http://advisorinfo.sec.gov.
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
Phone:
Red Dot Trade Finance. LLC
Item 2 - Material Changes
On July 28, 2010, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission voted unanimously to adopt amendments to
Part 2 of Form ADV and related rules under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (the "Advisers Act"). The
amendments are designed to require a registered investment Advisor to provide Clients with a clearly written and
meaningful disclosure, in plain English, about the advisor's business practices, conflicts of interest and advisory
personnel. The new Form ADV 2 is divided into two parts, Part 2A and Part 2B.
Part .244 of the new Form (the "Firm Brochure") provides information about a variety of topics relating to an
Advisor's business practices and conflicts of interest. Part 2B of the new Form (the "Brochure
Supplement") requires an Advisor to provide information about certain advisory personnel.
Atoms believes that communication and transparency are the foundation of our relationship and continually
strive to provide you with the complete and accurate information at all times. We encourage all current and
prospective investors to read this Firm Brochure and discuss any questions you may have with us. And of course,
we always welcome your feedback.
Amendment Filing
This is an amendment filing of the Firm Brochure under the rules.
Future Changes
From time to time, we may amend this Firm Brochure to reflect changes in our business practices, changes in
regulations and routine annual updates as required by the securities regulators. This complete Firm Brochure or
this summary of Material Changes shall be provided to each Client annually or if a material change is made.
At any time, you may view the current Firm Brochure on-line at the SEC's Investment Advisor Public Disclosure
website at http://advisorinfo.sec.gov.
To review the firm information for Atoms,

• Click Investment Advisor Search in the left navigation menu and enter.
• Select the option for Investment Advisor Firm and enter 166121 (our firm's CRD number) in the field
labeled "Finn IARD/CRD Number".

• ADV Part 1 will be displayed.
• This will provide access to Form ADV i and 2A.
• Item 11 of the ADV Part i lists legal and disciplinary questions.

• On the left navigation, Form ADV Part 2A is located near the bottom.
You may also request a copy of this Firm Brochure at any time, by contacting us at (978) 295-
1765.
Red Dot Trade Finance. 1,LC
Item 3 - Table of Contents
Item 2 - Material Changes 2
Item 3 - Table of Contents 3
Item 4 - Advisory Services 4
Item S - Fees and Compensation S
Item 6 - Performance -Based Fees 7
Iten ypF Types of Clients 8
Item 8 - Methods of Analysis. Investment Strate ies and Risk of Loss 8
Item 9 - Disciplinary Information 10
Item 10 - Other Financial Activities and Affiliations 10
Item 11 - Code of Ethics. Participation in Client Transactions and Personal Trading 10
Item 12 - Brokerage Practices 11
Item 13 - Review of Accounts 12
Item 14 - Client Referrals and Other Compensation 13
Item 15 - Custody 13
jtem 16 - Investment Discretion 13
Item 17 - Voting Client Securities 14
Item 18 - Financial Information 14
Item 19 - Requirements for State -Registered Advisors 14
Privacy Policy 14
Red Dot Trade Finance, LW
86 Myles Standish Rd., Weston, MA 02493
Phone: (97 8 ) 295- 1765 0 Fax: (97 8 ) 295-1765
Item 4 - Advisory Services

A. Finn Information
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC ("Atorus") is a registered investment advisor with the State of Massachusetts. Atorus
is a corporation formed under the laws of the State of Delaware in 2009 that conducts business in Massachusetts.
Red Dot Trade Finance LLC is owned and operated by Joshua Levy, Partner and Michael Fowler, Partner.
B. Advisory Services Offered
Investment Advisory Services — Atorus provides continuous, active management of Client investment portfolios.
Atoms has developed a client service model that includes discovery, implementation and monitoring
components.

• Client Discovery — Atorus will only accept Qualified Investors and as such will collect information concerning
the Client's financial status and assets among other things. Upon entering into an advisory agreement with
Atoms, Atoms will begin to implement its proprietary investment strategy

• Investment Plan — Once Atoms confirms that a client's investment objectives, and tolerance, and capacity for
risk are consistent with those of its own investment strategy, Atoms will construct a portfolio for the Client
based on its proprietary security selection and trading process. This portfolio will be designed to maximize
profits by generating short and intermediate term trading gains.

• Investment Selection and Implementation — Upon identification of potential positions, Atoms will begin
constructing the portfolio for the Client. The implementation process may take a considerable period of time
until optimal entry points are reached. Atoms will invest Client assets in variety of instruments, depending
on various factors related to Atoms' investment analysis. Investment securities may include any
class/sector/instrument deemed appropriate by Atoms.

• Investment Monitoring and Maintenance — Atoms will continuously monitor investment portfolios to
ensure that the portfolio meets the objectives of generating speculative gains.
It is the Client's responsibility to notify Atoms promptly of any change to the information provided by the Client,
including any change to any investment objectives, risk tolerance, and any investment policies, guidelines or
reasonable restrictions. Atoms will honor Client restrictions unless those restrictions impair Atoms' ability to
manage Client assets.
Prior to rendering investment management services, Atorus will ascertain, in conjunction with
the Client, that the Client's financial situation, risk tolerance, and investment objective(s) are
appropriate for Atorus' investment process.

C. Client Account Management
Prior to engaging Atoms to provide investment advisory services, the Client is required to enter into an
investment management agreement with Atoms setting forth the terms and conditions of the engagement and
the services to be provided. 'These services will include:

• Security Selection — Atoms will implement its investment recommendations in accordance with its
proprietary strategy. Generally, portfolio management is done on a discretionary basis. Atoms will use the
services of a non-affiliated broker -dealer to provide account custodial services and to affect trades
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
86 Myles Standish Rd., Weston, MA 02493
Phone: (978) 295-1765 ❑ Fax: (97 8 ) 295-1765
• Ongoing Investment Monitoring — Atoms provides ongoing oversight of the Client's investment program. All
investments are monitored for performance on an absolute return basis.
All portfolios are rebalanced as necessary upon Atoms review. More or less frequent rebalancing may be required
depending on macroeconomic, market, or technical factors.

D. Wrap Fee Programs
Atoms does not manage any proprietary wrap fee programs.
E. Assets Under Management
Atoms was registered with the State of Massachusetts in November 2012. Updated asset figures are calculated
annually following the December 31, 2012 fiscal year end of Atoms.
Item 5 - Fees and Compensation
The following paragraphs detail the fee structure and compensation methodology for investment management
services. Each Client shall sign an Investment Advisory Agreement that details the responsibilities of Atoms and
the Client.
A. Fees for Advisory Services
Management Fee — Clients will pay a Management Fee. This Management fee is payable monthly at the start of
the fiscal period. The Management Fee will be 2% annualized. Each month Atoms will be paid 43.1666796, or
1/12th of the annualized fee. The Management Fee will be considered payment for work done to design the
portfolio for the coming month.
Performance Fee  — In addition to the Management Fee, Atoms will charge Clients a Performance Fee. To be
eligible for this fee structure, an individual or institution must place at least $750,000 under management with
Atoms or have a minimum net worth of $1,soo t000. The arrangement must satisfy the requirements of SEC Rule
205-3 and any applicable state requirements dealing with performance fees. The standard Performance Fee is
20% for net realized trading profits above the closing account balance of net realized trading profits of the prior
fiscal period so long as the total NAV is larger than the sum of the initial capital + contributed capital + other
expenses charged + realized gains at the end of the previous fiscal period. The Performance Fee will be calculated
and charged in arrears at the end of each fiscal period starting at the end of the second fiscal period after the
client's initial investment. A fiscal period is one calendar months ending on the last business day of the calendar
month. The Performance Fee is subject to a High Water Mark (see below). A detailed written calculation of the
Performance Fee will be provided to the client after the end of each fiscal period when applicable. The
Performance Fee structure may be negotiated only under special circumstances.
High Water Mark  — Atoms' Performance Fee is subject to a loss carry forward limitation (a "High Water Mark")
such that no Performance Fee will be paid by a Client until prior net realized trading losses, if any, have been
recouped. In addition, no Performance Fee will be paid by the client if NAV at the end of said fiscal period is less
than the sum of the initial capital, contributed capital, expenses charged and realized gains at the end of the
previous fiscal period. A loss carry forward of a Client will be proportionately reduced to take into account any
withdrawals by that Client.
All securities held in a portfolio managed by Atoms will be independently valued by the Custodian. Atoms will
not have the authority or responsibility to value portfolio securities.
Consulting Fees — Atoms' fee for consulting services varies based on the services selected by the client, as well as
the complexity and duration of the engagement. Typically, fees are a fixed dollar amount. This fee includes the
services and costs for contracted services. Retainer fees will be determined in advance of an engagement and
agreed to in writing by the Client and Atoms. Extraordinary costs and expenses may be billed separately, and in
addition to, the contracted retainer fee.
B. Fee Billing
Management Fee — Fees are a fixed percentage of assets under management, based upon the account value on
the last day of the prior month. Fees for investment management services vary depending on the amount of
assets to be managed. Clients are billed monthly for security selection for the coming month. For accounts
opened during the month, fees will be prorated to cover only that period which the account will be managed by
Atoms.
Asset-based management fees will be automatically deducted from the client account by the Custodian. Atoms
shall send a monthly invoice to the Custodian indicating the amount of the fees to be deducted from the Client
Account. The amount due is calculated by applying the annual rate in the table above to the total assets under
management with Atoms at the start of each month. Each billing will be for the security selection applicable to
the coming fiscal period. Atoms does reserve the right to make changes to the portfolio during the month but
will not charge additional management fees for making those changes. Clients will receive independent
statements from the Custodian no less frequently than monthly. It is the responsibility of the client to verify the
accuracy of these fees as listed on the Custodian's brokerage statement as the Custodian does not assume this
responsibility.
Performance Fee — The Performance Fee will be determined monthly at the end of the fiscal period. Atoms will
send to the account Custodian an invoice and the Client an invoice showing the amount to be withdrawn and how
that figure was calculated. The Custodian will debit the Client's account and allocate those funds to Atoms.
Consulting I Retainer Fee — If applicable, once the Retainer Fee for a Client is determined, Atoms may bill up to
so% of the fee in advance of commencing any project work. The balance of the fee is due upon completion of the
work agreed to by contract. Retainer fees will not be debited from the Client's account. Atoms will bill Clients
directly. Atoms will mail to the Client an invoice for the retainer fee. In such cases, no invoice will be sent the
custodian of the Client. Payment is due within to business days of receiving the invoice.

C. Other Fees and Expenses
Clients may incur certain fees or charges imposed by third -parties, other than Atoms, in connection with
investment made on behalf of the Client's account[s]. The Client is responsible for all custodial and securities
execution fees charged by the Custodian and executing broker -dealer. The investment advisory charged by
Atoms is separate and distinct from these Custodian and execution fees. In addition, all fees paid to Atoms for
Investment Advisory Services are separate and distinct from the expenses charged by mutual funds and
exchange -traded funds to their shareholders. These fees and expenses are described in each fund's prospectus.
These fees and expenses will generally be used to pay management fees for the funds, other fund expenses,
account administration (e.g., custody, brokerage and account reporting), and a possible distribution fee. A Client
may be able to invest in certain investments, without the services of Atoms, but would not receive access to
Advisor and Institutional shares classes. The Client also would not receive the services provided by Atoms which
are designed, among other things, to assist the Client in determining which products or services are most
appropriate to each Client's financial condition and objectives. Accordingly, the Client should review both the
fees charged by the fund(s) and the fees charged by Atoms to fully understand the total fees to be paid.
Red Dot Trade Finance. 1.1.0
In the operating of the business Atoms may incur other fees such as fees for market data, data subscription,
information services, accounting, legal or other professional fees. Atoms reserves the right to charge clients for
these services. Charges will be made Pro Rata in proportion to the client's investment relative to the size of other
investors.

D. Advance Payment of Fees and Termination
AdValleP FPfl  — As noted, above, Atoms is compensated for its services in advance of each month for investment
management services to be provided. Clients may request to terminate their Investment Management Agreement
with Atorus, in whole or in part, by providing advance written or oral notification. The Client shall be responsible
for investment advisory fees up to and including the effective date of termination. As fees will be charged at the
start of the fiscal period for security selection, Atorus will not refund any fees billed. In addition clients shall be
responsible for performance fees up to and including the effective date of termination. The Client's Investment
Management Agreement with Atoms is non-transferable without Client's written approval.
Termination - Clients may request to terminate their Investment Advisory Agreement with Atoms, in whole or in
part, by providing advance written notice to Atoms in accordance with investor agreements. The Client shall be
responsible for investment advisory fees up to and including the effective date of termination. The Client's
Investment Management Agreement with Atoms is non-transferable without Client's written approval.
Upon termination, no portion of the Incentive Allocation shall be payable back to the Client as this fee is paid in
arrears.
Clients may terminate the Investment Management Agreement without penalty (full refund or no fees due)
within 5 business days of signing the Agreement if the Atoms Form ADV Part 2 was not delivered at least 48
hours prior to client's execution of the Agreement.
E. Compensation for Sales of Securities
Atoms does not receive commissions or any compensation for transactions in any Client account. As a fee-only
advisor, Atoms is paid only on the advice and investment management provided to Clients based on the assets
under management in the Client's account(s). To the extent any rebates are made available from exchanges or
other third parties they will be for the benefit of the fund.
Item 6 - Performance -Based Fees
Performance -based Fees —Atoms may charge a Performance Fee. The Performance Fee paid by certain eligible
Clients to Atoms may create an incentive for Atoms to make investments that are riskier or more speculative
than would be the case if this fee were not paid. The Performance Fee is calculated on a basis which includes
realized appreciation of the Client's account in order to align the long term goal of investors and Atoms.
Side-by-side Management  — Atoms does not manage any proprietary investment funds or limited partnerships
(for example, a mutual fund or a hedge fund) and has no financial incentive to recommend any particular
investment options for its Clients.
Item 7 - Types of Clients
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
Atorus may provide services to a variety of client types. Clients may include:

• Individuals, Personal Trusts and Estates — Private investors, investing personal assets. Clients are
generally affluent and high net worth persons.
• Other Financial Service Firms — Typically other investment Advisors for whom Atoms provides
investment management services.
The relative percentage each client type currently represents is available on Atoms' Form ADV Part 1. The actual
mix of types of Clients changes over time based upon market conditions, business plans and other factors. Atorus
does not specialize in, or actively seek, any given client type. Atoms is committed to providing services to
qualified investors, regardless of legal or corporate status.
Atoms provides customized services to meet the unique needs of each Client. Additional details are contained in
Item 4 — Advisory Services.
Item 8 - Methods of Analysis, Investment Strategies and Risk of Loss

A. Methods of Analysis
Proprietary Methodology  — The principals of Atorus have proprietary securities research and selection
methodology. Atoms will use this methodology in their analysis of securities for Client portfolios for timing of
entry and exit, leverage points as well as to determine if said securities should be included in the client's portfolio.
Other methods of analysis may be employed by Atoms as deemed appropriate.

B. Investment Strategies
Atoms structures portfolios using the various methodologies described above. The first step in the securities
selection process is to screen the universe of investment options to narrow investment possibilities. Once
securities have been included as a possible investment option, Atoms then undertakes a more rigorous analysis
to determine leverage, exit and entry points. Using this proprietary methodology, Atoms believes that Clients will
benefit from having a portfolio of assets that are not highly correlated. This careful adherence to proprietary
methodology should allow the portfolio to experience investment returns with mitigated risk.
Atoms monitors a broad universe of securities for potential investments. Yet, only a small percentage will fit the
investment criteria employed in the strategy. Atoms' strategy is to generate short and intermediate term trading
profits and is highly speculative in nature.
B. Risk of Loss
General Investment Risks — Investing in securities involves certain investment risks. Securities may fluctuate in
value or lose value. Clients should be prepared to bear the potential risk of loss. There is no guarantee that a
Client will meet their investment goals.
Each Client engagement will entail a review of the Client's investment goals, financial situation, time horizon,
tolerance for risk and other factors to understand if Atorus' strategy is appropriate for each Client. Client
participation in this process, including full and accurate disclosure of requested information, is essential for the
analysis of a Client's account. The Advisor shall rely on the financial and other information provided by the Client
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
86 Myles Standish Rd., Weston, MA 02493
Phone: (978) 295-1765 ❑ Fax: (978) 295-1765
or their designees without the duty or obligation to validate the accuracy and completeness of the provided
information. It is the responsibility of the Client to inform the Advisor of any changes in financial condition, goals
or other factors that may affect this analysis.
Atoms generally employs investment strategies that involve significant risk In choosing Atoms as an investment
advisor the Client is explicitly acknowledging the acceptance of this risk
Options and Futures — Certain investment strategies offered by Atorus may make use of options and/or futures
contracts. These option and futures contracts run the risk of losing value in a relatively short period of time in
amounts in egress of their initial cost or income. Option and futures contracts are leveraged, derivative
instruments that allow the holder of a single contract to control many shares of the underlying issue. This
imbedded leverage may compound gains and losses.
Leverage — Atoms plans to employ leverage on Client portfolios to attempt to enhance gains. Leverage is defined
as borrowing on margin funds in excess of the Client's principal, and as a result could generate losses for the
Client in excess of the principal balance.
Other Risks - Please remember that different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, including the
possible loss of principal and that past performance may not be indicative of future results. Therefore, it should
not be assumed that future performance of any specific investment or investment strategy including the
investments and/or investment strategies undertaken by Atorus will be profitable.
Item 9 - Disciplinary Information
Atoms and its advisory personnel value the trust you place in us. As we advise all Clients, we encourage you to
perform the requisite due diligence on any advisor or service provider in which you partner. Background
information is available on the Investment Advisor Public Disclosure website at http://advisorinfo.sec.gov.
To review the firm information for Atorus, click Investment Advisor Search in the left navigation menu and
enter, select the option for Investment Advisor Firm and enter 166121 (our firm's CRD number) in the field
labeled "Finn IARD/CRD Number:". This will provide access to Form ADV Parts 1 and 2. Item n of the ADV Part
lists legal and disciplinary questions.
There are no legal, regulatory or disciplinary events involving Atoms or any of its employees.
Item 10 - Other Financial Activities and Affiliations
Investment Advisor/Manager Affiliations — Employees of Atorus may also be employees of various investment
advisors or investment managers. Other firm's employing Atoms employees may be registered with a domestic or
foreign governmental agency with jurisdiction over that firm's activity. In this capacity the individual associates
may receive customary remuneration and other related revenues. Some of these may come in the form of
incentives, and most cause the affiliate to have a conflict of interest in rendering professional services to
unrelated firms.
No affiliation is created between Atoms and these other firms by way of common employment by certain
individuals.
Red Dot Trade Finance, LW
86 Myles Standish Rd., Weston, MA 02493
Phone: (978) 295-1765 ❑ Fax: (97 8 ) 295-1765
Item 11 - Code of Ethics, Participation in Client Transactions and Personal
Trading

A. Code of Ethics
Atoms has implemented a Code of Ethics that defines our fiduciary commitment to each Client. This Code of
Ethics applies to all persons associated with Atoms. The Code of Ethics was developed to provide general ethical
guidelines and specific instructions regarding our duties to you, our Client. Atoms and its personnel owe a duty
of loyalty, fairness and good faith towards each Client. It is the obligation of Atoms associates to adhere not only
to the specific provisions of the Code but to the general principles that guide the Code. The Code of Ethics covers
a range of topics that may include; general ethical principles, reporting personal securities trading, exceptions to
reporting securities trading, reportable securities, initial public offerings and private placements, reporting
ethical violations, distribution of the Code of Ethics, review and enforcement processes, amendments to Form
ADV and supervisory procedures.
Atoms has written its Code of Ethics to meet and exceed regulatory standards. To request a copy of our Code of
Ethics, please contact us at (978) 295-1765.

B. Personal Trading and Conflicts of Interest
Atoms allows our employees to purchase or sell the same securities that may be recommended to and purchased
on behalf of Clients. Owning the same securities we recommend (purchase or sell) to you presents a potential
conflict of interest that, as fiduciaries, we must disclose to you and mitigate through policies and procedures. As
noted above, we have adopted, consistent with Section 2o4A of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, a Code of
Ethics, which addresses insider trading (material non-public information controls) and personal securities
reporting procedures.
We have also adopted written policies and procedures to detect the misuse of material, non-public information.
We may have an interest or position in certain securities, which may also be recommended to you.
At no time, will Atorus or any associated person of Atoms, transact in any security to the
detriment of any Client.
Atoms is a pee-Only advisor, who, in all circumstances, is compensated solely by the Client, with neither the
advisor nor any related party receiving compensation that is contingent on the purchase or sale of any financial
product. Atoms does not engage in any transactions where it has a financial interest, including, but not limited to
commissionable securities transactions, buying securities from or selling securities to its Clients.
Item 12 - Brokerage Practices

A. Recommendation of Custodian[s]
Atoms does not have discretionary authority to select the broker-dealer/custodian for custodial and execution
services. The Client will select the broker -dealer or custodian (herein the "Custodian") to safeguard Client assets
and authorize Atoms to direct trades to this Custodian as agreed in the Investment Advisory Agreement. Further,
Red Dot Trade Finance. LLC
Atoms does not have the discretionary authority to negotiate commissions on behalf of our Clients on a trade -by-
trade basis although will work to mitigate transaction costs where possible.
Where Atoms does not exercise discretion over the selection of the Custodian, it may recommend the
custodian(s] to Clients for execution and/or custodial services. Clients are not obligated to use the recommended
Custodian and will not incur any extra fee or cost associated with using a broker not recommended by Atoms.
Atoms may recommend a Custodian based on criteria such as, but not limited to, reasonableness of commissions
charged to the Client, services made available to the Client, and location of the Custodian's offices. Atoms does
not receive research services, other products, or compensation as a result of recommending a particular broker
that may result in the Client paying higher commissions than those obtainable through other brokers.
If requested, Atorus considers a number of factors in selecting and/or recommending brokers and custodians for
its Clients' accounts, including, but not limited to, execution capability, experience and financial stability,
reputation and the quality of services provided. Atoms is not affiliated with, or related to, IS.

1. Soft Dollars - Soft dollars are revenue programs offered by broker -dealers whereby an advisor
enters into an agreement to place security trades with the broker in exchange for research and other
services. Atorus may participate in soft dollar programs sponsored or offered by any
broker -dealer.

2. Brokerage Referrals - Atoms does not receive any compensation from any other entity in
connection with the recommendation for establishing a brokerage account.

3. Directed Brokerage - All Clients are serviced on a "directed brokerage basis", where Atoms will
place trades within the established account[s] at the Custodian designated by the Client. Further, all
Client accounts are traded within their respective brokerage account[s]. Atoms will not engage in any
principal transactions (i.e., trade of any security from or to Atoms' own account) or cross transactions
with other Client accounts (i.e., purchase of a security into one Client account from another Client's
account[s]). In selecting the Custodian, Atoms will not be obligated to select competitive bids on
securities transactions and does not have an obligation to seek the lowest available transaction costs.
These costs are determined by the designated Custodian.

B. Aggregating and Allocating Trades
The primary objective in placing orders for the purchase and sale of securities for Client accounts is to obtain the
most favorable net results taking into account such factors as 1) price, 2) size of order, 3) difficulty of execution,

4) confidentiality and 5) skill required of the broker. Atoms will execute its transactions through an unaffiliated
broker -dealer. Atoms may aggregate orders in a block trade or trades when securities are purchased or sold
through the same broker -dealer for multiple (discretionary) accounts. If a block trade cannot be executed in full
at the same price or time, the securities actually purchased or sold by the close of each business day must be
allocated in a manner that is consistent with the initial pre-allocation or other written statement. This must be
done in a way that does not consistently advantage or disadvantage particular Client accounts.
Item 13 - Review of Accounts

A. Frequency of Reviews
Accounts are monitored on an ongoing basis by Moms for adherence to investment strategy and Client Objective.
Investment management and supervision over the securities contained in the Client's portfolio are performed in
an ongoing basis by Atoms, as applicable.
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
86 Myles Standish Rd., Weston, MA 02493
Phone: (978) 295. 1765 ❑ Fax: (97 8) 295-1765

B. Causes for Reviews
In addition to the investment monitoring noted in Item 13.A., each Client account shall be reviewed at least
quarterly. Reviews may be conducted more or less frequently at the Client's request. Accounts may be reviewed as
a result of major changes in economic conditions, known changes in the Client's financial situation, and/or large
deposits or withdrawals in the Client's account. The Client is encouraged to notify Atoms if changes occur in
his/her personal financial situation that might adversely affect his/her investment plan.
Additional reviews may be triggered by material market, economic or political events.

C. Review Reports
Investment Portfolio Reports  — The Client will receive brokerage statements no less than quarterly from the
Trustee or Custodian. These brokerage statements are sent directly from the Custodian to the Client. The Client
may also establish electronic access to the Custodian's website so that the Client may view these reports and their
account activity. Client brokerage statements will include all positions, transactions and fees relating to the
Client's account[s].
Item t4 - Client Referrals and Other Compensation

A. Compensation Received by Atorus
Atoms is a Fee-Only advisor, who, in all circumstances, is compensated solely by the Client. Atoms does not
receive commissions or other compensation from product sponsors, broker dealers or any un-related third party.
Atoms may refer Clients to various third -parties to provide certain financial services necessary to meet the goals
of its Clients. Likewise, Atorus may receive referrals of new Clients from a third -party.
B. Client Referrals from Solicitors
If a Client is introduced to Atoms by either an unaffiliated party or by a Atoms affiliate, Atoms may pay that
solicitor a referral fee in accordance with the requirements of Rule 206(4)-3 of the Investment Advisers Act of
1940, as amended, and any corresponding state securities law requirements. Any such referral fee shall be paid
solely from the investment management fees earned by Atoms, and shall not result in any additional charge to
the Client. If the Client is introduced to Atoms by an unaffiliated solicitor, the solicitor, at the time of the
solicitation, shall disclose the nature of his/her/its solicitor relationship. If Atoms subsequently contacts or is
contacted by the prospective Client, Atoms shall provide each prospective Client with a copy of Atoms' Form
ADV 2 (the written disclosure statement also known as the "Brochure") and a copy of the solicitor's written
disclosure document and a statement to the Client disclosing the terms of the solicitation arrangement between
Atoms and the solicitor, including the compensation to be received by the solicitor from Atoms.
Item t5 - Custody
Atoms does not accept or maintain custody of any Client accounts. All Clients must place their assets in a
qualified custodian. Clients are required to select their own custodian to retain their funds and securities and
direct Atoms to utilize that custodian for the Client's security transactions. For more information custodians and
brokerage practices, see Item 12 - Brokerage Practices.
laser,- VS et
While Atorus does not have custody of Client funds or securities, payments of fees may be paid by the custodian
from the custodial brokerage account that holds Client assets. In certain jurisdictions this may be deemed
constructive custody. Prior to permitting direct debit of fees each Client provides written authorization
permitting fees be made direct from the custodian. Atoms will send the Client and the custodian a bill showing
the amount of the fee and the way in which it was calculated. The custodian sends every Client an account
statement not less than quarterly showing all account activity, including the amounts disbursed from the account
to Atoms.
Item 16 - Investment Discretion
Discretionary Portfolio Management  — Atorus generally has discretion over the selection and amount of
securities to be bought or sold in Client accounts without obtaining prior consent or approval from the Client..
Discretionary authority will only be authorized upon full disclosure to the Client. The granting of such authority
will be evidenced by the Client's execution of an Investment Management Agreement containing all applicable
limitations to such authority. All discretionary trades made by Atoms will be in accordance with the investment
strategy's objectives and goals.
Item 17 - Voting Client Securities
Atoms does not accept proxy voting responsibility for any Client. Therefore, although Atoms may provide
investment advisory services relative to Client investment assets, Atoms Clients maintain exclusive responsibility
for: (1) directing the manner in which proxies solicited by issuers of securities beneficially owned by the Client
shall be voted, and (2) making all elections relative to any mergers, acquisitions, tender offers, bankruptcy
proceedings or other type events pertaining to the client's investment assets. Atoms and/or the Client shall
correspondingly instruct the Custodian of the assets to forward to the client copies of all proxies and shareholder
communications relating to the client's investment assets.
Item 18 - Financial Information
Neither Atoms, nor its management has any adverse financial situations that would reasonably impair the ability
of Atorus to meet all obligations to its Clients. Neither Atorus, nor any of its advisory persons, has been subject to
a bankruptcy or financial compromise. Atoms is not required to deliver a balance sheet along with this brochure
as the firm does not collect advance fees for services to be performed six months  or more in advance. Atoms
charges fees at the time of providing portfolio selection service at the start of each month. Please see Item 5 - Fees
and Compensation for additional information.
Item is - Requirements for State -Registered Advisors
Atoms has no additional state disclosures to make. Atoms believes itself to be fully compliant with all state laws
and regulations with respect to the business of Atoms.
Red Dot Trade Finance. 1.1.0
Item 19 - Other Requirements for Registered Advisors

A. Educational Background and Business Experience of the Principal Officers
See ADV Part 26 for information on the Principal Officers of Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC.

B. Disciplinary Information
See ADV Part 26 for information on the Principal Officers of Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC.
C. Other Business Activities of the Principal Officers
See ADV Part 2B for information on the Principal Officers of Atoms Trade Fiance, LW.
I V r
Red dot TRADE FINANCE \ /111C
Doing Business As:
ATORUS
Joshua L. Levy
Form ADV Part 2B - Brochure Supplement
Effective: November 15, 2012
Revised: May 15, 2014
This Brochure Supplement provides information about the background and qualifications of Joshua L. Levy
(CRD #5912674) in addition to the information contained in the Red Dot Trade Finance, LW ("Atorus" or the
"Advisor" - CRD #166121) Disclosure Brochure. If you have not received a copy of the Disclosure Brochure or if
you any questions about the contents of the Atoms Disclosure Brochure or this Brochure Supplement, please
contact us at (978) 295-1765.
Additional information about the Principal Officers is available on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public
Disclosure website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov.
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
Item 2 - Educational Background and Business Experience
Joshua Levy is a Partner to Atorus and was born in 1973.
Joshua Levy earned a Bachelor of Arts from Vanderbilt University. Joshua Levy also earned an MBA from the
Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Additional information regarding Joshua Levy's employment history is included below.
Employment History:
Partner, Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC 2009 to Present
Director, Round Hill Capital LLC 2004 to Present
Owner, Graphic Utilities, Inc. 2012 to 2014
Associate, Greenwich Prime Trading Group, LLC 2012 to 2013
Consultant, Red Dot Trading, LLC 2009 to 2012
COO, Sol Inc. 2007 to 2009
Manager - Private Investments, MUUS Asset Management Co. 2005 to 2007
Associate, Alvarez and Marsal 2004 to 2005
Summer Associate, Mckinsey & Co. 2003
Summer Associate, JP Morgan Chase 2003
Founder / COO, Creative Ideas Ltd. 1995 to 2003
Item 3 - Disciplinary Information
There are no legal, civil or disciplinary events to disclose regarding Joshua Levy. Joshua Levy has never been
involved in any regulatory, civil or criminal action. There have been no client complaints, lawsuits, arbitration
claims or administrative proceedings against Joshua Levy.
Securities laws require an advisor to disclose any instances where the advisor or its advisory persons have been
found liable in a legal, regulatory, civil or arbitration matter that alleges violation of securities and other 
statutes;
fraud; false statements or omissions; theft, embezzlement or wrongful taking of property; bribery, forgery,
counterfeiting, or extortion; and/or dishonest, unfair or unethical practices. As previously noted, there are no
legal, civil or disciplinary events to disclose regarding Joshua Levy.
However, we do encourage you to independently view the background of Joshua Levy on the Investment
Adviser Public Disclosure website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov. Select Investment Adviser Search from the left
navigation menu. Then select the option for Investment Adviser Representative and enter 5912674 in the field
labeled "Individual CRD Number".
Item 4 - Other Business Activities
Atoms is not currently affiliated with any other investment advisor or investment manager.

Mr. Levy serves as a board member for Round Hill Capital and related entities. Round Hill Capital LLC is a top
tier real estate investment and management firm for both institutional and private investors. The address is 250
Kings Road, London, SW5 SUE, UK. This is an investment related business and Mr. Levy devotes a few hours
per month + attends occasional board meetings no more than quarterly.
Red Dot Trade Finance. LLC
Mr. Levy is an owner of and advising on the successful turnaround of an ink formulation / manufacturing
company, Graphic Utilities in Limestone, Maine. Mr. Levy devotes no more then 30 hours per month from his
office and attends meetings no more than quarterly.
Item 5 - Additional Compensation
The Principal Officers of Atorus are dedicated to the investment advisory activities of Atorus' Clients. The
Principal Officers of Atorus do not receive any additional forms of compensation for rendering investment
advice via Atorus.
Item 6 - Supervision
Joshua Levy is supervised by Michael Fowler, Partner. Mr. Fowler can be reached at (732) 735-0447.
Atorus has implemented a Code of Ethics and internal compliance that guide each employee in meeting their
fiduciary obligations to Clients of Atorus. Further, Atorus is subject to regulatory oversight by various agencies.
These agencies require registration by Atoms and its employees. As a registered entity, Atoms is subject to
examinations by regulators, which may announced or unannounced. Atoms is required to periodically update
the information provided to these agencies and to provide various reports regarding firm business and assets.
Tn1    V V
Red dot TRADE FINANCE \ !.LC
Doing Business As:
eATORUS Michael J. Fowler
Form ADV Part 2B - Brochure Supplement
Effective: May 15, 2014
This Brochure Supplement provides information about the background and qualifications of Michael J. Fowler
(CRD # 4513451) in addition to the information contained in the Atoms Trading, LLC ("Atorus" or the
"Advisor" - CRD #156822) Disclosure Brochure. If you have not received a copy of the Disclosure Brochure or if
you any questions about the contents of the Atoms Disclosure Brochure or this Brochure Supplement, please
contact us at (212) 503-0410.
Additional information about the Principal Officers is available on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public
Disclosure website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov.
Red Rid Trade Mebane. I IP
Item 2 - Educational Background and Business Experience
Michael Fowler is a Partner to Atorus and was born in 1985.
Mr. Fowler participated in an educational program developed to comply with local high school requirements of
Bound Brook High School, New Jersey. Thereafter, Mr. Fowler chose not to attend college, but instead devoted
his professional life to securities trading and finance.
Additional information regarding Michael Fowler's employment history is included below.
Employment History:
Partner, Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC 2013 to Present
Senior Portfolio Manager, Red Dot Trading, LLC 2009 to 2013
Senior Portfolio Manager and Head of Risk, Eastbridge Group 2009 to 2013
Director Structured Products, The Geneva Group 2006 to 2007
Principal, FSF Capital Partners 2006
Trader, Axxess Capital, LLC 2002 to 2006
Equity Derivative Trader, ETG Trading 2002
Item 3 - Disciplinary Information
There are no legal, civil or disciplinary events to disclose regarding Michael Fowler. No Principal Officer of
Atorus has ever been involved in any regulatory, civil or criminal action. There have been no client complaints,
lawsuits, arbitration claims or administrative proceedings against Michael Fowler.
Securities laws require an advisor to disclose any instances where the advisor or its advisory persons have been
found liable in a legal, regulatory, civil or arbitration matter that alleges violation of securities and other 
statutes;
fraud; false statements or omissions; theft, embezzlement or wrongful taking of property; bribery, forgery,
counterfeiting, or extortion; and/or dishonest, unfair or unethical practices. As previously noted, there are no
legal, civil or disciplinary events to disclose regarding Michael Fowler.
However, we do encourage you to independently view the background Michael Fowler on the Investment
Adviser Public Disclosure website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov.  Select Investment Adviser Search from the left
navigation menu. Then select the option for Investment Adviser Representative and enter 4513451 in the field
labeled "Individual CRD Number".
Item 4 - Other Business Activities
Atorus is not currently affiliated with any other investment advisor or investment manager.
Item 5 - Additional Compensation
The Principal Officers of Atorus are dedicated to the investment advisory activities of Atorus' Clients. The
Principal Officers of Atoms do not receive any additional forms of compensation for rendering investment
advice via Atoms.
Item 6 - Supervision
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
Michael Fowler is supervised by Joshua Levy, Farther. Mr. Levy can be reached at (978) 295-1765.
Atorus has implemented a Code of Ethics and internal compliance that guide each employee in meeting their fiduciary
obligations to Clients of Atoms. Further, Atoms is subject to regulatory oversight by various agencies. These agencies 
require
registration by Atoms and its employees. As a registered entity, Atoms is subject to examinations by regulators, which 
may
announced or unannounced. Atorus is required to periodically update the information provided to these agencies and to
provide various reports regarding firm business and assets.
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
Privacy Policy
Effective: November 15, 2012
Our Commitment to You
Atorus is committed to safeguarding the use of your personal information that we have as your Investment
Advisor. Atorus (referred to as "we", "our" and "us" throughout this notice) protects the security and
confidentiality of the personal information we have and make efforts to ensure that such information is used for
proper business purposes in connection with the management or servicing of your account. Our relationship with
you is our most important asset. We understand that you have entrusted us with your private information, and
we do everything we can to maintain that trust.
We do not sell your non-public personal information to anyone. Nor does Atoms provide such information to
others except for discrete and proper business purposes in connection with the servicing and management of
your account as discussed below.
Details of our approach to privacy and how your personal non-public information is collected and used are set
forth in this privacy policy.
The Information We Collect About You
You typically provide personal information when you complete the paperwork required to become our Client.
This information may include your:

• Name and address • Assets
• E-mail address • Income
• Phone number • Account balance
• Social security or taxpayer identification number • Investment activity

• Accounts at other institutions
In addition, we may collect non-public information about you from the following sources:

• Information we receive on Brokerage Agreements, Managed Account Agreements and other
Subscription and Account Opening Documents;

• Information we receive in the course of establishing a customer relationship including, but not
limited to, applications, forms, and questionnaires;
• Information about your transactions with us or others
Information about You that Atorus Shares
Atoms works to provide products and services that benefit our customers. We may share non-public personal
information with non-affiliated third parties (such as brokers and custodians) as necessary for us to provide
agreed services and products to you consistent with applicable law. We may also disclose non-public personal
information to other financial institutions with whom we have joint business arrangements for proper business
purposes in connection with the management or servicing of your account. In addition, your non-public personal
information may also be disclosed to you, persons we believe to be your authorized agent or representative,
regulators in order to satisfy Atorus' regulatory obligations, and is otherwise required or permitted by law. Lastly,
we may disclose your non-public personal information to companies we hire to help administrate our business.
Companies we hire to provide services of this kind are not allowed to use your personal information for their own
purposes and are contractually obligated to maintain strict confidentiality. We limit their use of your personal
information to the performance of the specific service we have requested.
To repeat, we do not sell your non-public personal information to anyone.
Red Dot Trade Finance. LLC
Information About Former Clients
Atorus does not disclose, and does not intend to disclose, non-public personal information to non-affiliated third
parties with respect to persons who are no longer our clients.
Confidentiality and Security
Our employees are advised about the firm's need to respect the confidentiality of our customers' non-public
personal information. Additionally, we maintain physical, procedural and electronic safeguards in an effort to
protect the information from access by unauthorized parties.
We'll Keep You Informed
We will send you notice of our privacy policy annually for as long as you maintain an ongoing relationship with
us. Periodically we may revise our privacy policy, and will provide you with a revised policy if the changes
materially alter the previous privacy policy. We will not, however, revise our privacy policy to permit the sharing
of non-public personal information other than as described in this notice unless we first notify you and provide
you with an opportunity to prevent the information sharing. You may obtain a copy of our current privacy policy
by contacting us at (978) 295-1765.
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
Michael J. Fowler
Profile Quantitative portfolio manager with entrepreneurial background coupled with
strong foundation in corporate finance and macroeconomic analysis.
Experience
Senior Portfolio Manager 2009 - 2013
Eastbridge Group, New York, NY

• Utilized foundation of previously developed systematic macro model to trade U.S. financials and
real estate listed equity securities in a $50MM managed account (avg. notional risk of
$100MM). Responsible for position sizing, trading, individual position directional bias, and
model development. Collaborated with CIO on security selection and portfolio construction,
with eye toward securities with large vol-adjusted return potential, either long or short.

• Listed equity positions generated win ratio of 40% and profit factor (avg. realized gain to avg.
realized loss) of >2.25:1. Significantly outperformed (generated positive returns) in periods of
large market drawdowns.

• Developed short term futures trading system that was implemented, conditional to large
deviations in the realized volatility surface, to tactically hedge large net exposures. Designed to
operate on a different time scale than core positions in case of a large short term reversal.
Result was higher MTM monetization in high-vol, non-trending periods.
Partner 2007 — 2009
Red Dot Trading, LLC (Registered Investment Advisor), New York, NY

• Founded entity to house development of quantitative systematic global macro trading system.
Sold entity to Eastbridge Group, while personally retaining intellectual property.

• Key areas of research related to how the realized volatility surface coupled with trend
development jointly inform an optimal reference frame. The result was a model that was not
"long volatility" but adaptive to the volatility environment, whether low or high.
Selective Advisory Assignments 2007 — 2009
New York, NY & Aspen, CO

• Retained by €400MM European Infrastructure Private Equity Fund to advise on financing
structure of $150MM acquisition of portfolio of US parking assets in conjunction with Wachovia

• Retained by Deutsche Bank's former Head of High Yield to assist in initial setup up of new special
situations hedge fund (AUM of $140MM). Assisted in trading existing proprietary account
through idea generation, position management, and trade support. Areas of focus were reorg
equities, bank debt, and CDS. Aided in development of marketing materials, track record
reconciliation, and legal structure.
1
Director — Structured Products & Financings 2006- 2007
The Geneva Group, New York, NY

• Advised European Private Equity fund in acquisition of London City Airport. Supported the fund
CEO in structuring of the financing package with various European banks.

• Responsible for developing credit enhancements for bank loans (target markets were project
finance, infrastructure, and energy) to reduce Basel risk weightings. Coordinated process among
transaction participants including accounting firm, lender, borrower, and bond insurer.
Proprietary Trader 2002- 2006
MHG Capital/ETG Trading, New York, NY

• Hired by MHG Capital at age 16 to trade listed equity securities and equity derivatives
Summer Intern
GP Securities (AMEX), New York, NY

• Runner for $2 brokerage firm on American Stock Exchange
2001
Authored Research
• Drivers of Long Volatility Strategies: It's Not the Level of Volatility that Matters

• Attribution Basis Risk os a Determinant of Performance
• Supply & Demand Non-Linearity: Margin Structure of Participants

• Retrocements as a Function of the Changes in the Realized Volatility Surface and Time
• Intro portfolio Correlation and Position Sizing: Analysis of Impact on Returns and Sharpe Ratio
Skills

• Factor models
• Principal Component Analysis
• Relative value investing
• Quantitative system development

• Momentum investing
• Trading: FX, futures, credit, listed equities, derivatives (listed & OTC)
• Structured finance
• Corporate finance & financial analysis
• Portfolio management
• Macroeconomics
• Excel, Bloomberg
Licenses Series 65
2
Search for people. jobs. companies. and more... Advanced n
Home Profile Netwcrk Jobs Interests Business Senices Upgrade
Does Michael have these skills or expertise?
Portfolio Management Leveraged Finance Aftermath.° Imestments
Hedge Finds Equities Type another area of expertise...
Endorse Skip 1
Michael Fowler
CIO, ATorus, LLC
Greater New York City Area I Imestment Management
Current AToms. LLC
Previous Eastbridge GrouptRed Dot Trading. Red Dot Trading. LLC. The Geneva Group
Send a message
Relationship
Background
Endorse
Contact Info
Summary
to
34 comecbons
Connected 7 years *go
Specialties: Portfolio Manager of Ouantitatiw/Systematic Strategies Muti-Asset Classes
Everience
CIO
ATorus, LLC
July 2013 — Present (11 months)
Responsible for quantitative syste
Senior Portfolio Manager
Eastbridge Group/Red Dot Trading
November 2009 — June 2013 (3 yews 8 months)
Responsible for quantitative systems development. Implemented system within $50MM managed
account from institutional investor. Responsible for position sizing. directional bias. and trading execution
of US listed equity securities.
Partner
Red Dot Trading, LLC
2007 — November 2009 (2 years)
Developed quantitative trading strategies applicable across multiple asset classes and markets
Director -Structured Products
The Geneva Group
2006 - 2007 (1 year)
In Common with Michael
O You O Melee!
Responsible for leveraged loan syndications and placements. Manage and oversee syndication and client
relationship managers. Structure and analyze all client transactions. Develop new structured products for
applications in the leveraged loan market.
Skills & Endorsements
Top Skills
1 Structured Products
1 Trading
1 Portfolio Management
Equities
Leveraged Finance
Michael also knows about
Loans Management Syndications Analysis
Hedge Funds Allemathe Investments Asset Management
Fixed Income Investments Principal Component...
Relative Value Tracing Quantitative Investing Statistics
Artificial Neural... Hidden Marko v Models See 5«
Additional hto
Interests
Ultramarathon Running
,a
■
0
Company
Skills & Sponse
O
Group
Connections
All (34) Shared (6)
Next
Groups
oared
Tradiat.4.
r -•
Automated Trading S... Hedge Rind Group (H...
Join Ember
Following
GQg
Red Dot Trading, LLC GOR Global Markets
Investment Finanaal Services
Management Follow
Following
Help Center About I Press Blog Careers Athertising Talent Solutions I Small Business I Mobile Developers Publishers 
Language
Upgrade Your Account
Unkedln Corporabon 2014 user Pgreement PmecyPolicy Community Guidelines Cookie Policy CogyrightPoioc-y Send Feedback
Experience
2009 Red Dot Trade Finance LLC
- Present Founder
Platform for investment activities
Global
2009 - 2012

• RDTF LLC RIA will generate positive absolute returns by monetizing persistent directional
movements investing in a broad portfolio (100+ positions) of high-dispersion, low-correlation
securities/assets (rates, FX, futures, commodities, single stocks) across global markets

• Utilized personally developed systematic model to trade U.S. financials and real estate listed
equity securities in a $50MM managed account (avg. notional risk of $100MM). Responsible
for position selection, trading, and model development. Listed equity positions generated win
ratio of > 37% and profit factor (avg. realized gain to avg. realized loss) of > 2.5:1.
Significantly outperformed (generated positive returns) in periods of large market drawdowns.
2011 - Present

• Led turnaround at Graphic Utilities Inc. a manufacturer of specialty inks focused on banking,
postal and food service ink jet markets after bank threatened to call its loans. 2011 loss of 85
K USD, 2012 net profit 85 K and 2013 expected Net Income of 400 K
Summer 2004 ROUND HILL CAPITAL LLC New York, New York - London, UK
- Present Global Real Estate Investments — Board Member/Managing Director

• Provide board level support with special focus on operational issues both internally and in
company acquisitions of over 5 B USD in assets over 10 years
Summer 2007 SOL INC. Palm City, FL
- 2011 COO
Assigned from private equity firm to complete turnaround from near bankruptcy to acquisition offer

• Simplify, Simplify, Simplify - Led a top to bottom strategy review and reset including
simplification from 8000 to 8 products with 10 common sub assemblies, reduced SKUs in
inventory by 70%, and targeted the sales and marketing pitch replacing entire management
team (CEO, CFO, VP of sales)

• Re-organized entire engineering and production departments, instituted Kaizen and lean
manufacturing techniques, re-organized purchasing to bring about cost reduction and
streamlining, began sourcing materials from overseas to drive down costs.

• Implemented full MRP system for managing customer communications all the way through
to financial controls in one seamless system, standardization of documents,
purchasing/supplier management program and general company controls

• Recruited my replacement and executed handover while focusing on acquisition which
resulted in a firm offer at 3.5x sales nun rate
Autumn 2005 MUUS ASSET MANAGEMENT CO. Westport, CT
- Summer 2007 Director — Private Investments
Qualify, and execute private equity investments in lower middle market companies leading
operational and financial due diligence and then lead continuous improvement at portfolio companies.

• Oversight and management of portfolio companies in a wide range of industries including
High Tech Manufacturing, Commodity Manufacturing, Renewable Energy, Die Casting and
Commodity Product replacement

• Took responsibility for two troubled real estate investments, re-financing and instituting
operational control systems

• Public Oil and Gas Exploration and Production Company ($14 billion MV) - Built an
investment thesis, model and analysis that was validated by Compass Advisers, with a debt
offer from Deutsche Bank for an LBO. Presented thesis to Texas Pacific Group, Warren
Buffet (directly), and Soros as potential partners.
Summer 2004 ALVAREZ & MARSAL EUROPE LTD. London, UK and Stockholm, Sweden
- Autumn 2005 Senior Associate — Restructuring Group
Advised numerous companies across Europe on restructuring

• Created and executed a restructuring and sale plan for a $220 million global moving company
headquartered in London with 62 offices in 44 countries on behalf of shareholders including
JP Morgan London and SVP and led a 4.5 Billion SEK revenue, public and private bus
operator in the restructuring of 190 Million Euros of public debt. Instituted cash forecasting
controls, built and implemented a business plan, and managed stakeholder relations.
Summer 2003 MCKINSEY AND COMPANY
Sununer Associate
JP MORGAN CHASE
Sununer Associate — Special Credits: Restructuring and Work Out Group
Oslo, Norway
London, UK
1995 - 2002 CREATIVE IDEAS INTERNATIONAL Czech Republic, Slovak Republic, and Poland
Founder and COO
Founded a cosmetics distribution and marketing firm, expanded it to 40 distribution points in three
countries and sold it to a US based multinational (NUS on NYSE).
Negotiation and Sale

• Negotiated and managed the sale and post-merger integration including accounting and control
systems to comply with the buyer, GAAP and SEC requirements.
Turnaround

• Took over financial and operational control of the company, implemented a turnaround then
developed and executed a strategic plan which successfully brought about a restructuring
stabilizing the company for a sale
Business Development

• Responsible for operational development including purchasing, logistics and distribution, IT,
infrastructure, and human resources. Developed and maintained a global network of suppliers
into 3 custom's warehouses, 40 distribution / retail points and 24 hour direct shipping to retail
customers.

• Led product development of 150 FMCG product lines from conception to launch, including raw
material and packaging sourcing.
Education
2002 - 2004 MIT SLOAN SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT Cambridge, MA
Master of Business Administration, Focus in Financial Management, 4.8 / 5.0 GPA
1991 - 1995 VANDERBILT UNIVERSITY Nashville, TN
Bachelor of Arts in American History
Other

• Native English, fluent spoken Polish, basic Norwegian, and basic German.
• Passion for extreme skiing — skied Europe's most challenging slopes.

• Active ice hockey goalie - played with the Polish Olympic hockey team members and in
Norwegian league with former professionals
Search for people. jobs. companies. and more...
Home Profile Network Jobs Interests Business Services Upgrade
Background
Everience
Partner
Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
December 2007 - Present (6 years 6 months) I Miami ! New York / Boston
COO
Sol Inc.
July 2007 — August 2008 (1 year 2 months)
Took owr day to day management and operations: restructured. simplified. and created completely new
systems with the company, doubling sales (profitably) in 12 months increasing valuation by arguably
between 7 and 10x.
Manager - Private Investments
MUUS Asset Management
September 2005 - October 2007 (2 yeas 2 months)
• 1 recommendation
Sol
Associate
Alvarez & Mersa!
May 2004 — August 2005 (1 year 4 months)
Summer Associate
JP Morgan
2003 - 2003 (less than a year)
Summer Associate
McKinsey & co.
2003 - 2003 (less than a year)
Founder, COO
Creative Ideas Intl.
AA J. 1?Morgan
June 1996 -Jim 2002 (6 years 1 month)
Founded a FMCG distribution and marketing firm in Poland. which later expanded to 40 distribution
points in three countries working with 50.000 distributors. In 1996 we sold the company to a US based
NYSE listed multinational.
Languages
Polish
Skills & Endorsements
Top Skills
13 Private Equity Illflr MIAS, 10 Venture Capital IAPI
9 Valuation
8 Corporate Dewlopment
I Business Strategy L ~I iii
6 Emerging Markets 714ii.'
6 Mergers & Acquisitions IAT fl
6 Imestments
Due Diligence rtir
5 Corporate Finance riAritA
Joshua also knows about...
Financial Modeling 4 Business Dewlopment 4 Management 3 Mergers
3 Restructuring 3 Strategy 3 Product Development 2 Renewable Energy
2 Financial Analysis 1 Start-ups 1 Alternative Investments
1 Business Valuation Asset Management 1 Business Planning
1 Structured Finance See 13+
Education
Massachusetts Institute of Technology -Sloan School of
Management
MBA
20(.2 - '4031
Vanderbilt University
Bachelor of Arts. Hstory and Business
1991 - 1995 V
Lincoln Sudbury
1987 — 1991
Recommendat
Manager - Private Investments
MUUS Asset Management
Recerved (I) - Given (1)
Connections
lid
Groups
meows Uw & Mann
AI
All Int\ u.•••
Next
(Unofficial) Alvarez &_. Alvarez& Mersa' Co Business Improveme... Camp Cedar Alumnu...
Visible'
tj 4A H
Visible •
Global Business Dev.. Hedge Fund Group (H Hedge Fund Mandate
Hidden' See 14 more
Following
Influencers
UBS
ARC Aviation Renews... Red Dot Trading. LLC IIBS Bank of America
Avation&Aerosr.a:,•: Financial Seraces Banking
Following Following
Schools
V IIIIIIIIII
MIr4'c..,,
Vanderbilt University Massachusetts Instil...
Greater N as hv Ile Nea Greater Boston Nea
Following Following
Help Center About Press Blog Careers Advertising Talent Solutions Small Business Mobile Dewlopers Publishers Language
Upgrade Your Account
Linkedin Corporation ffri 2014 User Agreement Fmecy Policy Community Guidelines Cookie Policy Copyright Polic-y Send 
Feedback
In our previous business, Goldman Sachs, as the platform administrator, required references. In light of
this we provide a list of references.
Credit Suisse (Prime Broker previous business) Contacts for Michael Fowler and Joshua Levy

1. Henry Homes (Director - US Equity Derivatives, Nomura)
2. Rob McClure (Director HOLT/Quant - Credit Suisse)

3. Patrick Moran (Director - US Financials Trading)
Professional References for Michael Fowler
1. Scott Smith (Head of Financial Sector Strategy - Credit Suisse)

2. Corinne Namblard (Former CEO Galaxy Fund, Ltd. & Quantas Board Member)1
3. John Siedem (Head of High Yield - BGC Partners/Cantor Fitzgerald)

4. Dan Singer (Director - Institutional Equity Sales - Deutsche Bank)
Professional Reference for Joshua Levy and Michael Fowler

1. Tim Presutti (Founding Partner - Broadbill Investment Partners, Former Head of Yield Deutsche
Bank
Professional References for Joshua Levy

1. Mickey Greenblatt (Board Member Sol Inc.)
2. Michael Bickford (Founder Round Hill Capital LLC)
3. Chip Fuller (Jones Tradin LLC)
4. Dan Lily (Greenwich Prime)
EFTA01217736 (Jmail)
 [reputation] Skype log of conversation with Athena Zelcovich, Tyler Shears
(inferred timestamp: 2014-05-26 19:52:08)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
• NYC024371.dmg
(Evidence ID: NYC024371.dmg - 001)
o Case Data
• Calendar Items
• Calls
• Contacts
• Messages
• Top Contacts
• User Accounts
Case
Data:
Messages
(2101-
2200 of
7780)
Skype
2014-05-19 11:13:23 C) [1]
Sender:
Participants:
At 8pm?
Skype
2014-05-19 11:13:23 (UTC) [2]
Sender:
Participants: i ), Self (jeevacation )
), Self (jeevacation )
At 8pm?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-19 12:20:19 (UTC)
Sender: Self tjatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[2] 2014-05-19 12:20:19 (UTC)
Sender: Self (I' tacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
my time or yours?
my time or yours?
Skype
2014-05-19 12:28:11 C I]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Mine
Skype
2014-05-19 12:28:11 C) [2]
Sender:
Participants:
Mine
), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2014-05-19 12:32:46 (UTC)
Sender: Self Liatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
earlier or tomorrow I'm on the plane at 2 my tme
Skype
[2] 2014-05-19 12:32:46 (UTC)
Sender: Self Liatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
earlier or tomorrow I'm on the plane at 2 my tme
Skype
2014-05-19 12:47:38 =[1]
Sender: ( )
Participants: 1. Self (jeevacation )
17h45?
Skype
2014-05-19 12:47:38 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
17h45?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-19 12:49:49 (UTC)
Sender: Self (I cation
Participants: ME ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Yes
Skype
[1] 2014-05-19 12:49:49 (UTC)
Sender: Self utacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Yes
Skype
[1] 2014-05-19 15:38:56 (UTC)
Sender: Self (i tacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
we will have to do tomorrow i am in a meeting
Skype
[2] 2014-05-19 15:38:56 (UTC)
Sender: Self Ciatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
we will have to do tomorrow i am in a meeting
Skype
2014-05-19 15:40:30 UTC) 2]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Ok talk to you tomorrow
Skype
2014-05-19 15:40:30 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Ok talk to you tomorrow
Skype
2014-05-19 16:23:06 (UTC) [1]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
Hi are you free now?
Skype
2014-05-19 16:23:06 (UTC) [2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Hi are you free now?
Skype
2014-05-19 20:40:32 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self ( jeevacation )
public interest exception is overruling requests for similar take downs
Skype
2014-05-19 20:40:32 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self (jeevacation )
public interest exception is overruling requests for similar take downs
Skype
2014-05-19 20:40:42 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self ( jeevacation )
i will submit, but anticipate same ruling.
Skype
2014-05-19 20:40:42 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tylershears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self (jeevacation )
i will submit, but anticipate same ruling.
Skype
2014-05-19 20:41:07 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self (jeevacation )
latest articles that came out could have hurt us worse, which is good. any progress on EN
for and I? foundation sites will help i am certain
Skype
2014-05-19 20:41:07 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( tyler.shears ), Self ( jeevacation )
latest articles that came out could have hurt us worse, which is good. any progress on EN
for and I? foundation sites will help i am certain
Skype
2014-05-20 00:58:56 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
in australia.. email me a good time to talk.. just won GRF prize for my paper with wilczek
on quantum gravity and BICEP
Skype
2014-05-20 00:58:56 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
in australia.. email me a good time to talk.. just won GRF prize for my paper with wilczek
on quantum gravity and BICEP
Skype
2014-05-20 12:18:11 C) [2]
Sender:
Participants:
Round 4 ?
), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
2014-05-20 12:18:11 NTC) [ 1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Round 4 ?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-20 12:55:17 (UTC)
Sender: Self tjatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2014-05-20 12:55:17 (UTC)
Sender: Self Liatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
ok
ok
Skype
2014-05-20 13:47:23 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
How arr you?
Skype
2014-05-20 13:47:23 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
How arr you?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-20 16:29:17 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
now?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-20 16:29:17 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
now?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-20 16:31:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Im great, having fun. I tell you to send sexy nude photos and you don't you just tell me
you are confused again, you are smart pretty and ambitious , but you continue to ruin your
own life. by doing nothing that you are asked to do. just doing what you want, even
though that has led to nowhere for years.
Skype
[1] 2014-05-20 16:31:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Im great, having fun. I tell you to send sexy nude photos and you don't you just tell me
you are confused again, you are smart pretty and ambitious , but you continue to ruin your
own life. by doing nothing that you are asked to do. just doing what you want, even
though that has led to nowhere for years.
Skype
2014-05-20 16:32:03 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="77049" index="0" tid="3695056870">4E68F2B2-BEB3-42D1-B061-
605A3C6FE93C.jpg</file></files>
Skype
2014-05-20 16:32:03 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="77049" index="0" tid="3695056870">4E68F2B2-BEB3-42D1-B061-
605A3C6FE93C.jpg</file></files>
Skype
2014-05-20 16:33:23 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
What do u mean by &quot;has led to nowhere for years?&quot;
Skype
2014-05-20 16:33:23 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
What do u mean by &quot;has led to nowhere for years?&quot;
Skype
2014-05-20 16:34:17 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Jeffrey you are completely right on all. BUT i grow a lot thse days... You know that i can
go far
Skype
2014-05-20 16:34:17 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Jeffrey you are completely right on all. BUT i grow a lot thse days... You know that i can
go far
Skype
2014-05-20 16:40:45 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="104413" index="0" tid="2742299979">26EAD21D-413D-47E5-9F23-
OD12F68DE907.jpg<Th le></files>
Skype
2014-05-20 16:40:45 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="104413" index="0" tid="2742299979">26EAD21D-413D-47E5-9F23-
OD12F68DE907.jpg<Th le></files>
Skype
[1] 2014-05-20 17:06:55 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
you can send better,
Skype
[2] 2014-05-20 17:06:55 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
you can send better,
Skype
2014-05-20 17:09:13 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="1198926" index="0" tid="2321197348">3E932368-81B7-4804-998F-
BAC5CF5AB52E.jpg</file></files>
Skype
2014-05-20 17:09:13 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="1198926" index="0" tid="2321197348">3E932368-81B7-4804-998F-
BAC5CF5AB52E.jpg</file></files>
Skype
2014-05-20 17:13:15 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Where are you?
Skype
2014-05-20 17:13:15 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Where are you?
Skype
2014-05-20 17:18:06 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
As faras u are concerned? What i should start to go on?
Skype
2014-05-20 17:18:06 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
As faras u are concerned? What i should start to go on?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-20 18:02:18 (UTC)
Sender: Self eevacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
20 minutes?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-20 18:02:18 (UTC)
Sender: Self uttacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
20 minutes?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-20 21:24:00 (UTC)
Sender: Self ti=acation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
now?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-20 21:24:00 (UTC)
Sender: Self tiatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
now?
Skype
2014-05-20 22:03:26 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
it is now 8 am here... will be in this time zone till june 8
Skype
2014-05-20 22:03:26 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( lawkrauss ), Self ( jeevacation )
it is now 8 am here... will be in this time zone till june 8
Skype
2014-05-21 16:16:48 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Sony i was at work
Skype
2014-05-21 16:16:48 UTC [1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Sony i was at work
Skype
2014-05-21 18:43:06 UTC 1
Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
yuuhuu ? are you here ? triedd to reach you
Skype
2014-05-21 18:43:06 UTC 2
Sender:
), Self ( jeevacation )
yuuhuu ? are you here ? triedd to reach you
Skype
[1] 2014-05-21 19:47:19 (UTC)
Sender: Self Liasacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
now?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-21 19:47:19 (UTC)
Sender: Self Liatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
now?
Skype
2014-05-22 09:16:57 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Can i join u in new york?
Skype
2014-05-22 09:16:57 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Can i join u in new york?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-22 11:55:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I'm not in new york until the 20th of june
Skype
[2] 2014-05-22 11:55:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I'm not in new york until the 20th of june
Skype
[1] 2014-05-22 11:55:46 (UTC)
Sender: Self Ciatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
now?
Skype
[2] 2014-05-22 11:55:46 (UTC)
Sender: Self eevacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
now?
Skype
2014-05-22 16:53:51 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Call tonight
Skype
2014-05-22 16:53:51 (UTC) f
Sender:
Participants:
Call tonight
), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
2014-05-23 07:44:43 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Ah ok...
Skype
2014-05-23 07:44:43 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
Ah ok...
Skype
2014-05-23 07:44:49 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
LA?
Skype
2014-05-23 07:44:49 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
LA?
Skype
2014-05-23 09:31:36 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I think i could work in everything about health, bien etre, i am a good therapiSt i think.
Skype
2014-05-23 09:31:36 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
I think i could work in everything about health, bien etre, i am a good therapiSt i think.
Skype
2014-05-24 20:32:31 UTC [2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Tomorrow?
Skype
2014-05-24 20:32:31 UTC) 1]
Sender:
Participants:
Tomorrow?
), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2014-05-25 20:37:17 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( tacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
ok
Skype
[2] 2014-05-25 20:37:17 (UTC)
Sender: Self Liatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
ok
Skype
2014-05-26 08:57:55 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Call you at the end of the day
Skype
2014-05-26 08:57:55 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Call you at the end of the day
Skype
[2] 2014-05-26 11:28:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self mcation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Yes
Skype
[1] 2014-05-26 11:28:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self Liatacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
yes
Skype
[2] 2014-05-26 12:07:18 (UTC)
Sender: Self Cjaacation )
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
today?
Skype
[1] 2014-05-26 12:07:18 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeva(..I cation )
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
today?
Skype
2014-05-26 12:11:57 UTC I
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Yes call you when I get home
Skype
2014-05-26 12:11:57 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Yes call you when I get home
Skype
2014-05-26 13:08:40 UTC) [2]
Sender:
Participants:
Miss you
Skype
2014-05-26 13:08:40 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: i ), Self (jeevacation )
), Self (jeevacation )
Miss you
Skype
2014-05-26 19:00:32 (UTC) 12]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
Are you free now?
Skype
2014-05-26 19:00:32 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Are you free now?
Skype
2014-05-26 19:46:15 UTC [2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Green card results didnt pass, unfortunately <ss type="sad">:(</ss>
Skype
2014-05-26 19:46:15 (UTC) fli
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
Green card results didnt pass, unfortunately <ss type="sad">:(</ss>
Skype
2014-05-26 19:52:01 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
gal
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="1686956" index="0" tid="2277327712">EE2AD036-2834-4757-B600-
A9B30765306E.jpg</file><Jfiles>
Skype
2014-05-26 19:52:01 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="1686956" index="0" tid="2277327712">EE2AD036-2834-4757-B600-
A9B30765306E.jpg</file><Jfiles>
Skype
2014-05-26 19:52:08 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="697538" index="0" tid="2009998466">91460338-00F9-401-903F-
CDF2FEA7CBC8jpg</file></files>
Skype
2014-05-26 19:52:08 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco )
Participants: Athena Zelcovich ( athezelco ), Self (jeevacation )
<files alt="Fichiers postes">
<file size="697538" index="0" tid="2009998466">91460338-00F9-401-903F-
CDF2FEA7CBC8.jpg</file></files>
Notes
[1] Source Device NYCO24371.dmg/Macintosh HD
[1] Source File /Users/Jeffrey/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
[2] Source Device /Macintosh HD
[2] Source File /Users/Jeffrey/Library/Application SupportlSkype/jeevacation/main.db
Case Data: Messages (2001-2100 of 7780) Case Data: Messages (2201-2300 of 7780)
╔══════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Kathryn Ruemmler [friend] former Obama legal counsel [ft] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00625093 (Jmail)
 [legal] letter from Martin Weinberg to Kathryn Ruemmler
╔═════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Southern Financial Company [epstein] Epstein financial trust 
  Wearality [tech] startup invested in by Epstein and Joi Ito 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01186455 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Epstein crypto fund Kyara Investment II LLC operating agreement
(inferred date: 2014-06-10)
KYARA INVESTMENTS II LLC
OPERATING AGREEMENT
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT is made as of the 10th day of June, 2014 by
and among Kyara Investments II LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the
"Company"), those persons who execute this Agreement as of the date hereof, and
those other persons, if any, who from time to time become parties to or are otherwise
bound by this Agreement as provided herein.
RECITALS

A. On June 10, 2014, the Company was formed by the Members by the filing
of the Certificate of Formation with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware.

B. The Members now desire to enter into this Agreement in order to set forth
the respective rights and obligations of the Members in regard to the ownership,
management and governance of the Company.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and other valuable
consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the Members and the
Company agree as follows:
ARTICLE 1
DEFINED TERMS
1.1 "Act" means the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act, as amended
from time to time.
1.2 "Adjusted Capital Account Balance" means, with respect to each Member,
such Members Capital Account balance maintained in accordance with this Agreement,
as of the end of the relevant fiscal year of the Company, after giving effect to the
following adjustments:

(a) Credit to such Capital Account of such Member's share of minimum
gain determined in accordance with Regulations Sections 1.704-2(g)(1) and
1.704-2(i)(5); and

(b) Debit to such Capital Account of the items described in Regulations

Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), (5) and (6).
The foregoing definition of "Adjusted Capital Account Balance" is intended to comply
with the provisions of Regulations Sections 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d) and 1.704-2, and shall
be interpreted consistently therewith.
1.3 "Affiliate" means, with respect to any Person, any other Person that,
directly or indirectly, controls, is under common control with, or is controlled by the
former Person. For purposes of this definition, "control" (including, with correlative
meaning, the terms "controlled by" and "under common control with"), as used with
respect to any Person, shall mean the possession, directly or indirectly, of the power to
direct and cause the direction of the management and policies of such Person, whether
through the ownership of voting securities, by contract or otherwise.
1.4 "Agreement" means this Operating Agreement of the Company, and all
amendments hereto.
1.5 "Approved Sale" has the meaning set forth in Section 9.2(a).
1.6 "Capital Account" means, with respect to each Member, the Capital
Account maintained for such Member in accordance with the following provisions:

(a) To each Member's Capital Account there shall be credited such
Member's Capital Contributions, such Member's distributive share of Profits and
the amount of any Company liabilities assumed by such Member or which are
secured by any property distributed to such Member by the Company.

(b) To each Member's Capital Account there shall be debited the
amount of cash and the Gross Asset Value of any property distributed to such
Member pursuant to any provision of this Agreement, and such Member's
distributive share of Losses.

(c) In the event all or a portion of a Member's Membership Interests
are transferred in accordance with the terms of this Agreement, the transferee
shall succeed to the Capital Account of the transferor to the extent it relates to
the transferred Membership Interests.
(d) In determining the amount of any liability for purposes of the
foregoing subparagraph (a), there shall be taken into account Code

Section 752(c) and any other applicable provisions of the Code and Regulations.
The foregoing provisions and the other provisions of this Agreement relating to
the maintenance of Capital Accounts are intended to comply with Regulations
Sections 1.704-1(b) and 1.704-2, and shall be interpreted and applied in a manner
consistent with such Regulations. In the event the Manager shall reasonably determine
that it is prudent to modify the manner in which the Capital Accounts, or any debits or
credits thereto, are computed in order to comply with such Regulations, the Manager,
with the Consent of the Members, may make such modification; provided that such
modification is not likely to have a material effect on the amount distributed to any
Member pursuant to Article 10 hereof upon the liquidation of the Company.
1.7 "Capital Contributions" means the aggregate amount of cash and Gross
Asset Value of property (less the amount of indebtedness, if any, of such Member which
is assumed by the Company and/or the amount of indebtedness, if any, to which such
property is subject, as of the date of contribution, without regard to the provisions of
Code Section 7701(g)) contributed by a Member to the capital of the Company.
2
1.8 "Cash Flow" means, for any period, the amount by which (a) the gross
cash receipts of the Company from any source for such period (including, but not limited
to, Capital Contributions, loans, distributions received by the Company in respect of any
stock, partnership interest or other equity interest owned by the Company, and
proceeds from the sale, financing, refinancing or other disposition of all or any portion of
the Company property), exceed (b) the sum of (i) the aggregate cash disbursements for
such period (including, but not limited to, Company administrative costs,
reimbursements paid to the Manager in respect of his or her day-to-day management
activities hereunder, principal and interest payable on Company debt and capital
expenditures), and (ii) amounts previously set aside as reserves as determined by the
Manager in his or her discretion.
1.9 "Certificate" means the Certificate of Formation of the Company, as
amended from time to time, as filed in accordance with the Act.
1.10 "Code" means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (or any
corresponding provision of succeeding law).
1.11 "Company" means the limited liability company herein formed and known
as Kyara Investments II LLC, as said Company may from time to time be constituted.
1.12 "Consent" means the prior written consent or approval of a Person or
Persons to do the act or thing for which the consent or approval is solicited, or the act of
granting such consent or approval as the context may require.
1.13 "Depreciation" means, for each fiscal year or other period, an amount
equal to the depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deduction allowable with
respect to an asset for such year or other period, except that if the Gross Asset Value of
an asset differs from its adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes at the beginning
of such year or other period, Depreciation shall be an amount which bears the same
ratio to such beginning Gross Asset Value as the federal income tax depreciation,
amortization or other cost recovery deduction for such year or other period bears to
such beginning adjusted tax basis; provided, however, that if the federal income tax
depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deduction from such year or other
period is zero, Depreciation shall be determined with reference to such beginning Gross
Asset Value using any reasonable method selected by the Manager with the Consent of
the Members.
1.14 "Gross Asset Value" means, with respect to any asset, the asset's
adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes, except as follows:

(a) The initial Gross Asset Value of any asset contributed by a Member
to the Company shall be the gross fair market value of such asset, as determined
by the contributing Member and the Manager;

(b) The Gross Asset Values of all Company assets shall be adjusted to
equal their respective gross fair market values, as reasonably determined by the
Members, as of the following times: (i) the acquisition of additional Membership
3
Interests in the Company by any new or existing Member in exchange for more
than a de minimis capital contribution; (ii) the distribution by the Company to a
Member of more than a de minimis amount of Company assets, including money,
as consideration for an interest in the Company; and (iii) the liquidation of the
Company within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(g);
provided, however, that adjustments pursuant to the preceding clauses (i) and (ii)
shall be made only if the Members reasonably determine that such adjustments
are necessary or appropriate to reflect the relative economic interests of the
Members in the Company;

(c) The Gross Asset Value of any Company asset distributed to any
Member shall be the gross fair market value of such asset on the date of
distribution; and
(d) The Gross Asset Values of Company assets shall be increased (or
decreased) to reflect any adjustments to the adjusted basis of such assets
pursuant to Code Section 734(b) or Code Section 743(b), but only to the extent
that such adjustments are taken into account in determining Capital Accounts
pursuant to Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(m) and the definition of "Capital
Account" herein.
If the Gross Asset Value of an asset has been determined or adjusted pursuant to any
of the foregoing subparagraphs (a), (b) or (d) of this Section, such Gross Asset Value
shall thereafter be adjusted by the Depreciation taken into account with respect to such
asset for purposes of computing Profits and Losses.
1.15 "Investment" has the meaning set forth in Section 2.2.
1.16 "Manager" means the Person designated or appointed as Manager
pursuant to this Agreement, and any other Person who becomes a successor or
additional Manager of the Company pursuant to this Agreement.
1.17 "Member" means any Person who is designated as a Member on Exhibit A
to this Agreement at the time of reference thereto and who is acting in such Person's
capacity as a Member of the Company, and any other Persons who from time to time
become parties to or are otherwise bound by this Agreement as Members.
1.18 "Membership Interest" means an ownership interest of a Member in the
Company at any particular time, including the right of such Member to any and all
benefits to which a Member may be entitled pursuant to this Agreement and under the
Act, together with all obligations of such Member to comply with the terms and
provisions of this Agreement and the Act. Membership Interests are owned by
Members as set forth in Exhibit A to this Agreement, as amended from time to time.
1.19 "Notice" means a writing, containing the information required by this
Agreement to be communicated to any Person, and given or delivered in accordance
with the requirements of this Agreement.
4
1.20 "Person" means any individual, partnership, limited liability company,
corporation, trust, estate or other entity.
1.21 "Profits" and "Losses" means, for each fiscal year or other period, an
amount equal to the Company's taxable income or loss for such year or period,
determined in accordance with Code Section 703(a) (for this purpose, all items of
income, gain, loss or deduction required to be stated separately pursuant to Code

Section 703(a)(1) shall be included in taxable income or loss), with the following
adjustments:

(a) Any income of the Company that is exempt from federal income tax
and not otherwise taken into account in computing Profits or Losses pursuant to
this definition shall be added to such taxable income or loss;

(b) Any expenditures of the Company described in Code

Section 705(a)(2)(B), or treated as Code Section 705(a)(2)(B) expenditures
pursuant to Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(i), and not otherwise taken into
account in computing Profits or Losses pursuant to this definition shall be
subtracted from such taxable income or loss;

(c) In the event the Gross Asset Value of any Company asset is
adjusted pursuant to subparagraph (b) or (d) of Section 1.14 hereof, the amount
of such adjustment shall be taken into account as gain or loss from the
disposition of such asset for purposes of computing Profits or Losses;

(d) Gain or loss resulting from any disposition of property with respect
to which gain or loss is recognized for federal income tax purposes shall be
computed by reference to the Gross Asset Value of the property disposed of
notwithstanding that the adjusted tax basis of such property differs from its Gross
Asset Value; and
(e) Depreciation shall be taken into account for such fiscal year or
other period in computing such taxable income or loss, in lieu of the depreciation,
amortization and other cost recovery deductions that otherwise may be taken into
account in the absence of Section 1.13.
1.22 "Regulations" means the United States Treasury Regulations, as
amended from time to time.
1.23 "Sale of the Company" means the sale of the Company to any party on an
arms-length basis, pursuant to which such party or parties acquire (i) a majority of the
Membership Interests in the Company (whether by sale of Membership Interests or
merger or otherwise), or (ii) all or substantially all of the Company's assets, determined
on a consolidated basis.
1.24 "Transfer" has the meaning set forth in Section 9.1.
1.25 "Unreturned Capital Contributions" means, with respect to any Member,
5
the difference between (a) the Capital Contributions made by such Member, less (b) the
aggregate amount of distributions made to such Member pursuant to Section 4.6(a).
ARTICLE 2
THE COMPANY
2.1 Formation and Name. The Company has been formed as a limited liability
company pursuant to the provisions of the Act. The Company was formed with the
name "Kyara Investments II LLC"; provided that the Company may hereafter adopt such
other name or names as the Manager may from time to time select.
2.2 Purpose. The Company has been organized to engage in the ownership
and management of a convertible debt investment in Wearality Corporation, a Delaware
corporation (the "Investment") and, with the Consent of the Members, in any and all
other lawful businesses or activities which a limited liability company may carry on
under the Act and the laws of any other jurisdiction in which the Company is so
engaged.
2.3 Registered Agent. The Company's registered agent shall be the Person
designated by the Manager from time to time to serve in that capacity in accordance
with the terms of the Act.
2.4 Qualification in Additional Jurisdictions. The Manager is authorized, with
the Consent of the Members, to qualify the Company to do business in any jurisdiction
in which such qualification is deemed by the Manager as necessary or desirable in
carrying out the Company's business, and pursuant thereto, to appoint a registered
agent and to establish a registered office in such jurisdiction, and to cause the Company
to operate in such jurisdiction under another name selected by the Manager, in
compliance with the assumed name statute of such jurisdiction, if the Company is not
allowed under the laws of such jurisdiction to operate under its legal name.
ARTICLE 3
MEMBERSHIP INTERESTS; CONTRIBUTIONS BY THE MEMBERS
3.1 Membership Interests. The Company shall issue one type of ownership
interest, with such rights, preferences and obligations as set forth in this Agreement.
Holders of Membership Interests shall be entitled to one vote per Membership Interest
held; provided that such holder is also a Member. Notwithstanding anything to the
contrary contained in this Agreement, no Person shall be entitled to vote with respect to
any Membership Interests unless such person is a Member.
3.2 Initial Capital of the Company. On or prior to the date hereof, each of the
Members (or the Person from whom such Member acquired, directly or indirectly, its, his
or her Membership Interests) has made an initial Capital Contribution to the Company
as provided on Exhibit A attached hereto. In exchange therefor, each Member (or the
Person from whom such Member acquired, directly or indirectly, its, his or her
6
Membership Interests) has received that number of Membership Interests set forth on
such Exhibit A.
3.3 No Additional Capital Contributions. No Member shall be required to
make any additional Capital Contribution to the Company.
3.4 Withdrawal. Except as otherwise provided in Article 9 of this Agreement,
no Member shall be entitled to withdraw or resign from the Company, prior to its
dissolution and winding up, without first obtaining the Consent of the Members.
3.5 Additional Membership Interests. No additional Membership Interests
shall be issued by the Company without the Consent of the Members.
ARTICLE 4
CAPITAL ACCOUNTS; PROFITS AND LOSSES; DISTRIBUTIONS
4.1 Capital Accounts. The Company shall establish and maintain a Capital
Account for each Member.
4.2 Allocation of Profits and Losses.

(a) Profits of the Company shall be allocated among the Members as
follows:
(i) First, to each Member pro rata and in proportion to the
cumulative Losses, if any, allocated to such Member pursuant to

Section 4.2(b)(ii) hereof until the cumulative Profits allocated to such
Member under this Section 4.2(a)(i) equals the cumulative Losses
allocated to such Member under Section 4.2(b)(i) hereof; and

(ii) Then, the balance, if any, to the Members in accordance
with their respective Membership Interests.
(b) Losses of the Company shall be allocated to the Members as
follows:

(i) First, to the Members in accordance with their respective
Membership Interests; provided, however, that no Member shall be
allocated Losses in excess of its, his or her Adjusted Capital Account
Balance, determined immediately prior to the allocation provided for in this

Section 4.2(b)(i); and
(ii) Then, to the extent any Losses allocated to a Member
pursuant to Section 4.2(b)(i) would, but for the proviso contained therein,
exceed a Member's Adjusted Capital Account Balance, such Losses shall
be allocated first to the other Members in proportion to, and to the extent
of, their respective Adjusted Capital Account Balances, and then to any
7
Member guaranteeing debt of the Company, making loans to the
Company or otherwise having liability for Company debt, in proportion to
the debt guaranteed, the loans made or the amount of such liability.
4.3 Reallocation by Manager. The allocation of Profits and Losses in

Section 4.2 is intended to have substantial economic effect within the meaning of
Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2) or be in accordance with the Members' interests in
the Company within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(4). If subsequent
events (including, but not limited to, nonrecourse borrowing by the Company or a loan
by a Member to the Company) cause, in the reasonable opinion of the Manager, the

Section 4.2 allocations to have neither substantial economic effect nor be in accordance
with the Members' interests in the Company, the Manager may (a) allocate the income,
gain, loss, deduction and credit of the Company so that such allocations are in
accordance with the Members' Membership Interests; or (b) make such other
modifications to this Agreement (including, but not limited to, the addition of minimum
gain chargeback, qualified income offset and other special allocation provisions
specified in Regulations Sections 1.704-2 or 1.704-1(b)) that are necessary in the
reasonable opinion of the Manager to cause such allocations to have substantial
economic effect within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2).
4.4 Tax Allocations. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, all items
of income, gain, loss and deduction shall be allocated, for federal and state income tax
purposes, among the Members in the same manner as the corresponding items of
income, gain, loss and deduction are allocated for purposes of maintaining the Capital
Account of each of the Members.
4.5 Section 704(c) Allocations. In accordance with Code Section 704(c) and
the Regulations thereunder, income, gain, loss and deduction with respect to any
property contributed to the capital of the Company shall, solely for tax purposes, be
allocated among the Members so as to take account of any variation between the
adjusted basis of such property to the Company for federal income tax purposes and its
initial Gross Asset Value, including, but not limited to, special allocations to a
contributing Member that are required under Code Section 704(c) to be made upon
distribution of such property to any of the noncontributing Members. In the event the
Gross Asset Value of any property of the Company is adjusted pursuant to
subparagraph (b) of Section 1.14, subsequent allocations of income, gain, loss and
deduction with respect to such property shall take account of any variation between the
adjusted basis of such property for federal income tax purposes and its Gross Asset
Value in the same manner as under Code Section 704(c) and the Regulations
thereunder. Any elections or other decisions relating to such allocations shall be made
by the Manager in any manner that reasonably reflects the purpose and intention of this
Agreement. Allocations pursuant to this Section 4.5 are solely for purposes of federal,
state and local taxes and shall not affect, or in any way be taken into account in
computing, a Member's Capital Account or share of Profits or Losses, other items or
distributions pursuant to any provision of this Agreement.
8
4.6 Distribution of Cash Flow. To the extent there is Cash Flow available for
distribution, as reasonably determined by the Manager, and in any event not later than
45 days after the receipt by the Company of the proceeds from the sale of the
Investment, the Manager shall cause the Company to distribute such available Cash
Flow:

(a) first, to those Members with Unreturned Capital Contributions, pro
rata in proportion to the amount of such Unreturned Capital Contributions, until
the amount of each Member's Unreturned Capital Contributions has been
reduced to zero; and

(b) thereafter, to the Members, pro rata in accordance with their
respective Membership Interests.
ARTICLE 5
MANAGEMENT
5.1 Initial Manager. The management of the Company's business shall be
vested in one Manager unless a greater number of Managers shall be fixed from time to
time by action of the Members. The initial Manager of the Company shall be Joichi Ito.
A Manager shall hold office until his, her or its death, removal, or resignation.
5.2 Management Authority.

(a) Except as otherwise authorized in this Agreement, all management
decisions of the Company (including, without limitation, any actions or votes
taken by or on behalf of the Company in respect of any equity interest held by the
Company in another entity) shall be made by the Manager, who shall be
responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company, subject to the
provisions of this Agreement and the Act. The Manager shall have all of the
rights, powers, duties and obligations of managers as provided in the Act, and as
otherwise provided by law, and any action taken by the Manager, not otherwise
in violation of the Act or this Agreement, shall constitute the act of and serve to
bind the Company.
(b) Only the Manager and agents of the Company authorized by the
Manager shall have the authority to bind the Company. The Manager is an agent
of the Company for the purpose of its business, and the act of the Manager,
including the execution in the Company's name of any instrument for apparently
carrying on in the usual way the business of the Company, binds the Company,
unless such act is in contravention of the Act or this Agreement or any
agreement between the Manager and the Company or unless the Manager so
acting otherwise lacks the authority to act for the Company and the Person with
whom the Manager is dealing has knowledge of the fact that he, she or it has no
such authority. If the Manager acts without the requisite authority, the Manager
shall be liable for any damages or liabilities arising with respect to such action
9
unless the Manager can show that he, she or it reasonably believed after due
inquiry that such action was authorized.
5.3 Limitation on Liability. The Manager shall perform his, her or its duties as
the Manager in good faith, in a manner he, she or it reasonably believes to be in the
best interest of the Company and the Members, and with such care as an ordinarily
prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances. A Person who
so performs his, her or its duties shall not have any liability by reason of being or having
been a Manager of the Company, except where the claim at issue is based on the
fraud, gross negligence or bad faith of the Manager.
5.4 Removal of the Manager. The Manager may be removed with or without
cause upon the Consent of the Members, but such removal shall be without prejudice to
any contract rights the Manager may have under this Agreement. Any removal of the
Manager shall become effective on such date as may be specified by the Members
voting in favor thereof. Should the Manager be removed who is also a Member, such
Member will continue to participate in the Company as a Member and enjoy the burdens
and benefits of his or her Membership Interests.
5.5 Resignation of the Manager. The Manager may resign at any time by
giving Notice to the Members. The resignation of the Manager shall take effect upon
receipt of such Notice or at such later date as specified in such Notice. The acceptance
of the resignation of the Manager shall not be necessary to make such resignation
effective. The resignation of the Manager who is also a Member shall not affect the
Managers rights as a Member and shall not constitute a withdrawal of the Member.
5.6 Appointment of New Manager. If a vacancy in the office of Manager
occurs, a new Manager shall be designated with the Consent of the Members to fill such
vacancy, provided that in the event of the death, removal, or resignation of Joichi Ito as
the Manager, Darren K. Indyke shall become the succeeding Manager, unless another
Manager is appointed with the Consent of the Members. In the event that any vacancy
in the office of Manager is not filled as provided in the preceding sentence,
management of the Company shall be vested in the Members.
5.7 Indemnification by the Company. The Company shall indemnify the
Manager for all costs, losses, liabilities and damages paid or incurred by the Manager in
connection with the business of the Company to the fullest extent provided or permitted
by the Act and the other laws of the State of Delaware, except where the claim at issue
is based on the fraud, gross negligence or bad faith of the Manager. In connection
therewith, the Company shall advance to the Manager as they are paid or incurred all
expenses arising with respect to the defense of any matter as to which the Company
will be obligated to provide indemnification pursuant to this Section 5.7.
10
ARTICLE 6
MEMBERS
6.1 Powers of Members. Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 5.2, the
Members shall have the right to Consent to the following matters:

(a) removal of the Manager as provided in Section 5.4;
(b) designation of a new Manager upon the resignation, removal, death
or permanent disability of the then-current Manager as provided in Section 5.6

(c) approval either of any Transfer of any Membership Interests or of
any party becoming a Member as provided in Article 9; and
(d) dissolution of the Company as provided in Article 10.
6.2 Partition. While the Company remains in effect or is continued, each
Member waives its rights to have any Company property partitioned, or to file a
complaint or to institute any suit, action or proceeding at law or in equity to have any
Company property partitioned, and each Member, on behalf of itself, its successors and
its assigns hereby waives any such right.
6.3 Authority. Except as expressly authorized in this Agreement, no Member
shall take any action as a Member to bind the Company, and each Member shall
indemnify the Company for any costs or damages incurred by the Company as the
result of the unauthorized action of such Member.
6.4 Vote of the Members. An affirmative vote or consent by or on behalf of all
of the Members shall be required to approve or disapprove any matter on which the
Members are entitled or required to decide or Consent, except as otherwise provided in
this Agreement, the Certificate or the Act.
ARTICLE 7
TRANSACTIONS; AFFILIATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
7.1 Transactions Between a Member or Manager and the Company. Except
as otherwise limited by applicable law, with the Consent of the Members any Member or
Manager may, but shall not be obligated to, lend money to the Company, act as surety
for the Company and transact other business with the Company, and shall have the
same rights and obligations when transacting business with the Company as a person
or entity who is not a Member or Manager.
7.2 Affiliated Party Transactions. The Members acknowledge that the
Company is being formed initially to purchase and then hold an investment in Wearality
Corporation, a Delaware corporation, for which the Manager may provide certain
advisory or consulting services or on whose board of directors the Manager may serve.
11
In connection therewith, the Members acknowledge such potential conflict of interest
and waive and consent to any such transaction that may be approved on behalf of the
Company as provided in this Agreement.
ARTICLE 8
FISCAL YEAR; BOOKS AND RECORDS; BANK ACCOUNTS
8.1 Bank Accounts. The funds of the Company shall be deposited in such
federally insured bank account or accounts or other financial intermediary as the
Manager in his or her discretion determine are required, and the Manager shall arrange
for the appropriate conduct of such accounts.
8.2 Books and Records.

(a) There shall be kept and maintained full and accurate books
respecting the business of the Company showing all receipts and expenditures,
assets and liabilities, profits, losses and distributions, and all other records
reasonably necessary or appropriate for recording the Company's business
affairs at the Company's principal place of business or such other location as the
Manager may determine provided that all of the Members are informed of such
other location. Such books and records shall be open to inspection by any
Member (or such Member's authorized representative) upon reasonable notice
and during ordinary business hours
(b) The books of the Company shall be kept on the method of
accounting determined by the Members, and shall show at all times each and
every item of income, gain, loss and expense.
8.3 Fiscal Year. The fiscal year of the Company shall be the calendar year.
8.4 Tax Matters Partner. Pursuant to Code Section 6231, the Person
designated by the Manager from time to time shall act as the Tax Matters Partner of the
Company. The Tax Matters Partner shall prepare and provide to each Member all
necessary tax forms and information to enable the Members to meet their tax filing
obligations on a timely basis and shall, within 30 days after receipt thereof, forward to
each Member a photocopy of any notices relating to the Company received from the
Internal Revenue Service or other revenue authority.
8.5 Tax Returns. In addition to the requirements of Section 8.2, tax returns of
the Company shall be prepared by the Person selected by the Manager.
ARTICLE 9
TRANSFERS
9.1 General Provision. No Member shall, directly or indirectly, voluntarily or
involuntarily, sell, assign, transfer, pledge, hypothecate, encumber or otherwise dispose
12
of ("Transfer") the whole or any part of its, his or her Membership Interests in the
Company, except to Affiliates of such Member or with the Consent of the Members.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, if any such Member is an individual, such Person's
Membership Interests may pass to his or her estate upon his or her death subject to the
other provisions of this Agreement. Except in connection with transfers during an
individual Member's lifetime to Affiliates as permitted pursuant to this Section 9.1, which
Affiliates shall become Members when the transfers become effective as hereinafter
provided, no transferee shall become a Member without the Consent of the Members.
Transfers to Affiliates shall be effective upon the Affiliates entering into this Agreement
and notice thereof being provided to the other Members.
9.2 Sale of the Company.

(a) If the Manager approves a Sale of the Company (an "Approved
Sale"), then each Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will
consent to and raise no objection to the Approved Sale, and if the Approved Sale
is structured as a sale of Membership Interests, then each Member and any
other holder of Membership Interests will agree to sell all of their Membership
Interests on the same terms and conditions as approved by the Manager. Each
Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will take all actions which
the Manager deems reasonably necessary in connection with the consummation
of the Approved Sale.

(b) The obligations of the Members and any other holders of
Membership Interests with respect to the Approved Sale are subject to the
condition that upon the consummation of the Approved Sale, all of the holders of
Membership Interests will, subject to Section 4.6, receive substantially the same
form and amount of consideration for their Membership Interests sold, or if any
such Membership Interests are given an option as to the form and amount of
consideration to be received, all such holders will be given the same option.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, nothing contained in this Section 9.2(b) shall
prevent any individual from receiving an offer of employment upon reasonable
terms in connection with services to be provided after the consummation of the
Approved Sale.

(c) Each Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will
bear their pro rata share (based upon the total amount of Membership Interests
sold) of the cost of any sale of Membership Interests pursuant to an Approved
Sale to the extent such costs are incurred for the benefit of all holders of
Membership Interests and are not otherwise paid by the Company. Costs
incurred by Members and the other holders of Membership Interests on their own
behalf, will not be considered costs of the Approved Sale contemplated
hereunder.
13
ARTICLE 10
DISSOLUTION AND TERMINATION
10.1 Dissolution. The Company shall be dissolved upon the Consent of the
Members or as otherwise provided by the Articles or the Act.
10.2 Procedures Upon Dissolution.

(a) Upon dissolution of the Company, the Company shall be terminated
and the Manager, or if there is no Manager, the Members, shall liquidate the
assets of the Company. The proceeds of liquidation shall be applied and
distributed in the following order of priority:
01 First, to the payment of the debts and liabilities of the
Company (other than any loans or advances made by any of the Members
to the Company) and the expenses of liquidation;

(ii) Second, to the creation of any reserves which the Manager
or liquidating Members deem reasonably necessary for the payment of
any contingent or unforeseen liabilities or obligations of the Company or
Members (to the extent the Company is liable therefor) arising out of or in
connection with the business and operation of the Company;
(iii) Third, to the payment of any loans or advances made by any
of the Members to the Company; and
(iv) Thereafter, to the Members in the manner, and in the
priorities set forth in Section 4.6.
(b) A reasonable time shall be allowed for the orderly liquidation of the
assets of the Company and the discharge of liabilities. During the period
beginning with the dissolution of the Company and ending with its liquidation and
termination of this Agreement pursuant to this Section 10.2, the business affairs
of the Company shall be conducted by the Manager or, if there is no Manager, by
the Members. During such period, the business and affairs of the Company shall
be conducted so as to preserve the assets of the Company and maintain the
status which existed immediately prior to such termination.
ARTICLE 11
MISCELLANEOUS
11.1 Binding Agreement. Subject to the restrictions on transfers and
encumbrances set forth herein, this Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be
binding upon the parties hereto and their respective heirs, executors, legal
14
representatives, successors and permitted assigns. Whenever in this instrument a
reference to any party or Member is made, such reference shall be deemed to include a
reference to the heirs, executors, legal representatives, successors and permitted
assigns of each Member.
11.2 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in several counterparts,
each of which shall be deemed an original, but all of which shall constitute one and the
same instrument. In addition, this Agreement may contain more than one counterpart of
the signature pages and this Agreement may be executed by the affixing of the
signatures of each of the Members to one of such counterpart signature pages; all of
such signature pages shall be read as though, and this Agreement shall have the same
force and effect as though, all of the signers had signed a single signature page.
11.3 Effect of Consent or Waiver. No consent or waiver by any party hereto to
or of any breach or default by any other party hereto in the performance by such other
party hereto of its, his or her obligations hereunder shall be effective unless in writing,
and signed by the party hereto against whom such waiver is sought to be enforced, and
no such consent or waiver shall be deemed or construed to be a consent or waiver to or
of any other breach or default by such other party hereto in the performance by such
other party hereto of the same or any other obligations of such party hereto hereunder.
Failure on the part of any party hereto to object to or complain of any act or failure to act
of any of the other parties hereto or to declare any of the other parties hereto in default,
regardless of how long such failure continues, shall not constitute a waiver by any such
party hereto of its, his or her rights hereunder.
11.4 Enforceability. If any provision of this Agreement or the application thereof
to any Person or circumstances shall be invalid or unenforceable to any extent, the
remainder of this Agreement and the application of such provisions to other Persons or
circumstances shall not be affected thereby and shall be enforced to the greatest extent
permitted by law.
11.5 Entire Agreement. This Agreement contains all of the terms agreed upon
by the parties hereto with respect to the subject matter hereof, and supersedes all prior
agreements, arrangements and communications between the parties dealing with the
Membership Interests, whether oral or written.
11.6 Governing Law; Jurisdiction. In all respects, including all matters of
construction, validity and performance, the Agreement and the obligations arising
hereunder shall be governed by, and construed and enforced in accordance with, the
laws of the State of Delaware, applicable to contracts made and performed in such
state, without regard to the principles thereof regarding conflict of laws. The Company
and each of the parties hereto agree to submit to personal jurisdiction and to waive any
objection as to venue in the courts located in either the county in which the Company's
principal office is located within the State of Delaware or the county in which the
Company's registered office is located within the State of Delaware. Service of process
on the Company and any of the parties hereto in any action arising out of or relating to
this Agreement shall be effective if mailed by certified mail, return receipt requested or
15
delivered by reputable overnight courier to such party at the address set forth on
Exhibit A attached hereto.
11.7 Liability Among Members. No Member shall be liable to any other
Member or to the Manager by reason of its, his or her actions or omissions in
connection with the Company, unless otherwise provided in this Agreement, and except
for acts or omissions or alleged acts or omissions that were performed or omitted
fraudulently or in bad faith or as a result of gross negligence or willful misconduct.
11.8 No Partnership Intended for Nontax Purposes. The Members have
formed the Company under the Act and expressly do not intend hereby to form a
partnership under the laws of any jurisdiction. The Members do not intend to be
partners one to another, or partners as to any third party. To the extent any Member, by
word or action, represents to another Person that any other Member is a partner or that
the Company is a partnership, the Member making such wrongful representation shall
be liable to any other Member who incurs personal liability by reason of such wrongful
representation.
11.9 Amendment. This Agreement may be amended or modified only with the
Consent of the Members.
11.10 Notices. Any Notice to the Manager or Members required under the terms
of this Agreement shall be sent to their respective addresses, as set forth on Exhibit A
attached hereto. All Notices and copies thereof provided for herein shall be hand
delivered with receipt therefor, sent by overnight courier service with receipt therefor, or
sent by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, and first-class postage
prepaid. Changes of address may be given to the Company, the Manager, and the
Members by Notice given in accordance with the terms of this Section. Time periods
shall commence on the date that such Notice is shown as delivered upon any such
receipt or attempted to be delivered if receipt thereof is refused by the recipient. Any
Notice that is required to be given within a stated period of time shall be considered
timely made or given if delivered or postmarked before 11:59 local time, on the
last day of such period.
11.11 Business Pursuits of Members and Manager. Except as otherwise
provided in any other written agreement by which any Member or the Manager may be
bound, the Manager and each Member may engage in other business activities. Except
as otherwise provided in this Agreement or in any other written agreement by which any
Member or Manager may be bound, this Agreement shall not preclude or limit in any
respect the right of any Member or the Manager to engage in or invest in any business
activity of any nature or description. Any such permitted activity may be engaged in
independently or with other Members or the Manager. No Member or Manager shall
have the right, by virtue of this the Certificate, this Agreement or the relationship created
hereby, to any interest in such other permitted ventures or activities or to the income or
proceeds derived therefrom. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement or in any
other written agreement by which any Member or Manager may be bound, the pursuit of
such permitted ventures shall not be deemed wrongful or improper and any Member or
16
Manager shall have the right to participate in or to recommend to others any investment
opportunity.
11.12 Expenses. The Company shall recognize $2,000 of the out-of-pocket
expenses actually incurred by Joichi Ito in connection with the organization of the
Company as an initial capital contribution by such Member, and up to $2,000 of the
annual out-of-pocket expenses actually incurred by any Member of the Company in
connection with the operation of the Company each year as an additional capital
contribution by such Member when paid by such Member.
11.13 References. References herein to the singular shall include the plural and
to the plural shall include the singular, and references to one gender shall include the
others, except where the same shall not be appropriate.
11.14 Titles and Captions. Section titles or captions contained in this Agreement
are for convenience only and shall not be deemed a part of the content of this
Agreement.
11.15 Delivery by Facsimile or Electronic Mail. This Agreement, the agreements
referred to herein, and each other agreement or instrument entered into in connection
herewith or therewith or contemplated hereby or thereby, and any amendments hereto
or thereto, to the extent signed and delivered by means of a facsimile machine, pdf
attachment to an email or other electronic means, shall be treated in all manner and
respects as an original agreement or instrument and shall be considered to have the
same binding legal effect as if it were the original signed version thereof delivered in
person. At the request of any party hereto or to any such agreement or instrument,
each other party hereto or thereto shall re-execute original forms thereof and deliver
them to all other parties. No party hereto or to any such agreement or instrument shall
raise the use of such means to deliver a signature or the fact that any signature or
agreement or instrument was transmitted or communicated through the use of such
means as a defense to the formation or enforceability of a contract and each party
hereto forever waives any such defense.
[Signature page follows]
17
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned parties here executed this Agreement
as of the date first set forth above.
Kyara Investments II LLC
By:
Southern Financial, LLC
By:
Jeffrey Epstein, Manager
S-1
EXHIBIT A
The names, addresses and Membership Interests of the Members are set forth
below.
Name and Address
Number of
Membership
Interests
Percentage
Ownership
Initial
Capital
Contribution
Cambridge, MA 02138
500 50% $ 2,000
Southern Financial, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3

St. Thomas, USVI 00802
500 50% 250,000
TOTAL 1,000 100.00% $ 252,000
Address of Manager and the Company:
Cambridge. MA 02138
EFTA00613875 (Jmail)
 [misc] Virgin Islands Legislature
(date: 2014-06-16)
Legislature of tbe Virgin Islands
PRESS RELEASE
Public Affairs, #1 Lagoon St. Complex, Frederiksted, St. Croix VI 001140
- 340-773-2424, Fax: 340.712-2397, E-mail: mediastx@senate.gov.vi
For Immediate Release
Monday, June 16, 2014

Facts placed on record about the UVI RT Park amendment at Friday's hearing

CHARLOTTE AMALIE, ST. THOMAS - Members of the 30th Legislature attempted to
debunk many of the rumors being circulated about the University of the Virgin Islands
Research & Technology Park during Friday's Committee of the Whole meeting on the
island of St. Croix. Several senators also raised concerns about the series of political
attack ads and the propaganda campaign launched for reasons which remain unclear.

"This is the question we now must ask," Senate President Malone said. "Who stands to
gain that they are willing to spend so much money and time to launch these attacks?"

Senate President Shawn-Michael Malone placed all testifiers under oath during the more
than eight hour long hearing. He said the information presented Friday served to reinforce
his opinion that senators acted appropriately in regard to the Tech Park issue, however
further reform was required in regard to the laws governing both the RT Park and
Economic Development Authority programs.

"We need a complete overhaul of our tax system," the Senate President said. "In this case
the Senate had to act quickly to keep the RT Park program viable, but it doesn't mean that
all of our issues are resolved."

Senator-at-Large Craig Barshinger agreed that further review was required, but that the
information imparted during the hearing demonstrated that Senators had done what was
necessary to "fix the horrible problem of pulling out the rug from under these
companies."

Senate President Malone said that certain facts discussed at Friday's meeting warranted
repeating in order to ensure that accurate information was made available to the public.
particularly as it relates to an amendment unanimously supported by Senators on April
24, 2014 and subsequently vetoed by Governor John P. de Jongh.

The amendment did not grant new tax breaks to any company. The UVI RT Park
companies have had tax benefits for years - benefits that were granted by the UVI RT
Park Board, whose members are all directly or indirectly appointed by the Governor. UVI
RT Park Executive Director David Zumwalt testified about the board's composition and
due diligence during the hearing. Further, one of the Internet Service Providers that the
More.. .
Press Release for Monday, June 16, 2014 140616-SIX
Facts placed on record about the UVI RT Park amendment at Friday's hearing
Page 2
June 16, 2014
Governor now says is not eligible for tax incentives - Choice Communications - had
previously been in negotiation for benefits under EDA, but was referred to the Tech Park.

• The amendment lost the territory exactly zero tax dollars as it clarified laws about
companies that already have legal contracts for benefits and senators acted to save the
territory the expense of multiple lawsuits. Senator Malone said Friday that he wanted to
prevent local tax dollars from being used to fight in court when the Virgin Islands had so
many other pressing obligations to teachers, retirees and others.
Senator Neireda Rivera O'Reilly reminded officials that the Governor had recently
insisted that any litigation with HOVENSA would be too costly.
"Now we want to take on not one, but three lawsuits?" she asked.

• There is nothing in the amendment that moves anything from St. Croix to St. Thomas.
Senator Malone said that the bill can be read online and that the public can see that this
claim is patently false.
"In fact, we took SIO million from a St. Thomas project in order to fund the construction
of the Tech Park on St. Croix," the Senate President said.
Several St. Croix district senators were particularly outraged that the public was being
misinformed via the recent propaganda campaign.
Senator Kenneth Gittens said he did not appreciate the attacks and that he did his
homework before voting on every issue.
"I am not about these games -I am about jobs for St. Croix," he said. "When I vote, 1 vote
my conscience."
Senator Sammuel Sanes said that as senators voted unanimously on this issue they could
not be singled out.
"When you attack one member of the body, you attack us all," Sanes said.

• The Administration's actions, particularly the Governor's veto of the recent clarification
amendment and the contentious aftermath, are hurting the territory's global reputation and
have already lost us investors. UVI RT PARK officials testified that three companies
recently decided not to do business in the Virgin Islands.
This was among the issues of concern for Senator Clifford Graham, Chairman of the 30th
Legislature's Committee on Finance.
Press Release for Monday, June 16, 2014 I40616-STX
Facts placed on record about the UVI RT Park amendment at Friday's hearing
Page 3
June 16, 2014
"We will lose people watching from the outside," Graham said.
•The amendment approved by senators was nearly identical to the provisions contained
in a Memorandum of Understanding between the EDA and the RT Park that was
approved and signed off on by Governor de Jongh and EDA Director Percival Clouden,
who confirmed during the hearing that he had been one of the signatories. The
Administration has not indicated what caused the dramatic shift in policy.

• Failure to protect the integrity of the RT Park program will cost jobs and hurt the local
economy both long and short term. Innovative Communications, one of the companies
being targeted by the Administration, is currently the territory's very largest private
employer.

• The attack ads and propaganda have not intimidated senators, however they have
served to raise the question of exactly who stands to gain by discrediting the legislature
and hurting businesses that have complied with the provisions of their contracts with the
RT Park.
"I am a fourth generation public servant and will not allow anyone to sacrifice my
reputation to further their own political ambitions and self-interest," the Senate President
said. "Where are the ads about EDA granting tax breaks to the monopoly at the concrete
plant?"
EDA Director Clouden also testified that the agency had granted benefits to convicted
sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, whose company had been turned away from the Tech Park
program.
"We need to start asking the right questions," Senator Malone said. "We have now had a
hearing which clearly demonstrated why, in this case, swift action was necessary. The
only real mystery remaining is - exactly who stands to gain and by which organizations
and who are funding these attacks? The money and effort spent defending the Governor's
veto is truly without precedent and highly unfortunate given the many actual serious
issues we are contending with as a community. There are some very unholy alliances at
work here and, while some of their motives are quite transparent, others arc much less
so.
Senators requested numerous documents during the hearing to include the Governor's
Action Plan for the Virgin Islands Next Generation Network (viNGN) and the Public
Finance Authority's contract with the Winston & Straum law firm. The viNGN leadership
was asked to be present at Fridays hearing, but stated that they were unable to attend.
Press Release for Monday, June 16, 2014 I40616-STX
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
       Joel Klein [democrat] chancellor of the NYC Dept. of Education 
 Marla Prather [arts] art curator at MoMA, wife of Mortimer Zuckerman 
              Mohammed bin Zayed aka MBZ [mideast] ruler of Abu Dhabi 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01111057 (Jmail)
 [money] Mortimer Zuckerman Mortimer B. Zuckerman Management Trust
(date: 2014-07-10)
MORTIMER B. ZUCKERMAN MANAGEMENT TRUST
Amendment and Restatement
Pursuant to the provisions of Paragraph B of Article I of the Mortimer B. Zuckerman
Management Trust created by Trust Agreement dated November 2, 2010, between Mortimer B.
Zuckerman, as Settlor, and the said Mortimer B. Zuckerman, as Trustee, as most recently amended
and restated on October 31, 2013 (the "Trust"), I, the said MORTIMER B. ZUCKERMAN,
hereby amend the Trust by striking out ARTICLE I through ARTICLE XXV, constituting the
whole of the Trust Agreement, and substituting therefore the following Table of Contents and
Articles I through XXV, which constitute the entire Trust and may be relied on by any person
without reference to any prior document
"Table of Contents
Article I
Article II
Article III
Article IV
Article V
Article VI
Article VII
Article VIII
Article IX
Article X
Article XI
Article XII
Article XIII
Article XIV
Article XV
Disposition of Trust Property and Reservation of Powers During My
Lifetime 2
Payment of Taxes, Debts, Expenses and Bequests under my Will,
Disposition of Art Following My Death 3
Maintenance and Support ProvisiOns for Marla Prather 4
Other Provisions Related to the Separation Agreement 7
Abigail's Inheritance 8
Provisions for Abigail During Minority 8
Provisions for Abigail until her Emancipation 9
Other Provisions for Abigail and Renee 9
Other Gifts at My Death 11
Disposition of Remaining Property 12
Trust for the Benefit of a Descendant of Mine 13
Trust for the Benefit of a Descendant of a Niece or Nephew of Mine 15
Qualified Subchapter S Trusts 16
Further Provisions Regarding the Disposition of the Trust Property 18
Powers of Appointment; Disclaimer; Division and Consolidation of
Trusts 18
MN IAA 4••••• ••••
-1-
Article XVI Survivorship; Manner of Payment; Restrictions
Contingent Termination and Distribution
on Alienation;
19
Article XVII Trustees' Powers 20
Article XVIII Management of Business Interests 23
Article XIX Trustees' Compensation 26
Article XX Other Provisions Relating to the Trustees 28
Article XXI Trustees' Accounts 29
Article XXII Resignation and Appointment of Trustees 30
Article XXIII Liability of Trustees and Others 33
Article XXIV Miscellaneous Matters 33
Article XXV Definitions 34
Article I
Disposition of Trust Property and Reservation
of Powers During My Lifetime

A. During my lifetime my Trustees shall dispose of the net income and principal of the
trust property in such manner as I shall direct from time to time. In the absence of express written
direction from me to the contrary, my Trustees other than myself are at all times authorized in their
discretion to apply all or part of the income or principal for my benefit; to satisfy any of my
obligations, including my obligations under the Separation Agreement; to make distributions to any
one or more of my issue (a) for their support or (Li) to utilize gift tax exclusions and applicable credit
amounts and/or to facilitate any gifts authorized to be made under any power of attorney granted by
me.

B. During my lifetime I shall have the power, acting alone, at any time and from time to
time:
1. To amend or revoke this trust;

2. To appoint a Co-Trustee or Co-Trustees;
3. To remove any Trustee hereof;
4. To appoint a successor Trustee or Trustees;

5. To exercise any rights, options or privileges pertaining to any insurance policy
payable to my Trustees.
-2-
The exercise of any such power shall be by written instrument specifically referring to this trust
signed by me and deposited with my Trustees, either during my lifetime or within a reasonable time
after my death, but any act properly performed by my Trustees before any such instrument has been
deposited with them shall not be affected thereby.
C. While I am serving as a Co-Trustee with another person, until the receipt by any other
Trustee or Trustees then serving hereunder of a statement signed by me or by my duly authorized
attorney-in-fact to the effect that this paragraph is no longer in effect, I, as a Trustee, shall have sole
responsibility for all decisions as to the retention, disposition, investment, reinvestment or other
administration of the assets held by the Trust. Any other Trustee or 'Trustees serving hereunder shall
abide by such decisions and execute all documents which may be requited to effectuate them,
including, without limitation, proxies, subscriptions and documents of sale, acquisition or exchange. If
such other Trustee or Trustees shall fail to receive timely instructions from me as to any action which
must be taken within a specified time period with respect to a particular matter, such other Trustee or
Trustees may, but shall have no duty to take such action as he or they shall deem appropriate.
Article II
Payment of Taxes. Debts. Expenses and Bequests under my Will
Disposition of Art Following My Death
Following my death, my Trustees shall pay or apply such sum or sums from the principal of
the trust property as my executor may request, in writing, for the satisfaction of legacies, my lawful
debts, my legally binding charitable pledges, funeral expenses and expenses of administration of my
estate and any death tax payable by reason of my death with respect to property held under this trust
or with respect to property passing under my Will if such taxes are apportioned to my residuary estate.
If my executor fails to request funds sufficient for the payment of taxes, debts, expenses and legacies, I
direct my Trustees to make such payment or payments as may be necessary to make up such
deficiency directly to the person or organization entitled to the same. To the extent possible, no part
of any payment pursuant to the foregoing shall be made from funds or property which is exempt from
any such taxes if such funds or property would thereby become subject to any such taxes. Except as
otherwise provided in this Agreement or my Will, any such payments by my Trustees shall be made
out of the residue of the trust property that would otherwise be disposed of under Article X hereof
and shall not be made from or charged against any of the other assets passing to any other person
hereunder. I recognize that such payments will reduce the charitable deduction allowable to my estate.
-3-
In addition, my Trustees shall satisfy all specific bequests under Articles FIRST, SECOND
and THIRD of my Will of property that may have been transferred by me to the Trustees during my
lifetime and that is held by my Trustees at the time of my death. Death taxes shall be apportioned to
the persons who receive such specific bequests as provided in my Will.
My Trustees shall sell any works of art and antiques held hereunder at the time of my death
and dispose of the net proceeds as provided in this Agreement My Trustees' good faith determination
as to what constitutes a work of art or antique shall be final and binding on all concerned.
Article III
Maintenance and Support Provisions for Math Prather
Upon my death, if Marla Prather (hereinafter called "Marla") has not violated the terms of our
Separation Agreement and our Separation Agreement is still in effect, my Trustees shall make the
following provisions for Marla and for my daughter Abigail (hereinafter called "Abigail") in
accordance with Sections 5.A and 633 of the Separation Agreement

A. Subject to Paragraph E hereof, if Marla survives me, my Trustees shall set aside an
amount equal to the sum of Five Million ($5,000,000) Dollars and shall hold and dispose of the same
as a separate trust upon the following terms:

I. In each taxable year of such mist, my Trustees shall pay to Marla, during her
lifetime, an annuity amount equal to Two Hundred Fifty Thousand ($250,000) Dollars. The annuity
amount shall be paid in quarterly installments on or about the first day of January, April, July, and
October of each year. Any income of such trust for a taxable year in excess of the annuity amount
shall be added to principal. In determining the annuity amount, my Trustees shall prorate the same on
a daily basis for a short taxable year and for the taxable year ending with Marla's death.

2. Upon Marla's death, my Trustees shall dispose of any remaining principal and
undistributed income in accordance with the provisions of  Article X hereof.

3. This arrangement is intended to satisfy a portion of my obligation under

Section 633.1 of the Separation Agreement to pay Marla the sum of Three Hundred Fifty Thousand
($350,000) Dollars per year for a period ending on the earlier of her death or the 19th anniversary of
the Start Date (as defined in Section 6.13.3 of the Separation Agreement), as well as my obligation
under Section 6.B.2 of the Separation Agreement to continue paying Marla the sum of Two Hundred
Fifty Thousand ($250,000) Dollars per year thereafter for the balance of her life.

B. If my death occurs prior to January 1, 2020, and Marla survives me, my Trustees shall
-4-
IPA AM ,  4.
set aside an amount equal to the sum of One Million ($1,000,000) Dollars and shall hold and dispose
of the same as a separate trust upon the following terms:

1. In each taxable year of such trust, my Trustees shall pay to Marla, during her
lifetime, an annuity amount equal to One Hundred Thousand ($100,000) Dollars. The annuity amount
shall be paid in quarterly installments on or about the first day of January, April, July, and October of
each year. Any income of such trust for a taxable year in excess of the annuity amount shall be added
to principal. In determining the annuity amount, my Trustees shall prorate the same on a daily basis
for a short taxable year and for the taxable year ending with Marla's death or the termination of her
annuity interest

2. Upon the first to occur of January 1, 2020 or Marla's death, my Trustees shall
dispose of any remaining principal and undistributed income in accordance with the provisions of

3. This arrangement is intended to satisfy the balance of my obligation under

Section 6.B.1 of the Separation Agreement to pay Marla the sum of Three Hundred Fifty Thousand
($350,000) Dollars per year for a period ending on the earlier of her death or the 19th anniversary of
the Start Date, as described above.

C. If my daughter Abigail survives me and my death occurs prior to her Emancipation (as
defined in Section 5.E of the Separation Agreement), my Trustees shall set aside the sum of One
Million ($1,000,000) Dollars and shall hold and dispose of the same as a separate trust upon the
following terms:

1. In each taxable year of such trust, my Trustees shall pay to Marla, during her
lifetime, or to Abigail following Marla's death, an annuity amount equal to Eighty Thousand ($80,000)
Dollars. The annuity amount shall be paid in quarterly installments on or about the first day of January,
April, July, and October of each year. Any income of such trust for a taxable year in excess of the
annuity amount shall be added to principal. In determining the annuity amount, my Trustees shall
prorate the same on a daily basis for a short taxable year and for the taxable year ending with the
termination of the annuity interest

2. The annuity interest shall continue for a term ending on August 1, 2022,
except that the annuity interest shall terminate earlier upon the first to occur of either of the following
qualified contingencies (within the meaning of Section 664(0(3) of the Code): Abigail's death; her
marriage; or her completion of four academic years of college education (within the meaning of the
-5-
definition of "Emancipation" in Section 5.E of the Separation Agreement). Upon such termination,
my Trustees shall dispose of any remaining principal and undistributed income in accordance with the
provisions of AtrielLX hereof.

3. This arrangement is intended to satisfy my obligation under Section 5A of the
Separation Agreement to pay Marla the sum of $80,000 per year for Abigail's support and maintenance
for a period ending on Abigail's Emancipation.

D. Subject to Paragraph E hereof, each of the trusts under this Article is intended to
qualify as a charitable remainder annuity trust within the meaning of Section 664(cl)(1) of the Code.
The provisions of this instrument shall be construed and enforced to carry out that intention. Without
limiting the foregoing.

I. No additional contributions shall be made to any such trust after the initial
contribution. The initial contribution, however, shall consist of all property passing to the trust as a
result of my death.

2. My Trustees shall make distributions at such time and in such manner as not
to subject any such trust to tax under Section 4942 of the Code. Except for the payment of the
annuity amounts to the recipients, my Trustees shall not engage in any act of self-dealing, as defined in

Section 4941(d) of the Code, and shall not make any taxable expenditures, as defined in Section
4945(d) of the Code. My Trustees shall not make any investments that jeopardize the charitable
purpose of such trusts, within the meaning of Section 4944 of the Code and the regulations
thereunder, or retain any excess business holdings, within the meaning of Section 4943(c) of the Code.

3. My Trustees are prohibited from exercising any power or discretion granted
under the laws of the State of New York or under other provisions of this instrument that would be
inconsistent with the qualification of such trusts under Section 664(d)(1) of the Code and the
corresponding regulations.

4. My Trustees have the power, acting alone, to amend this instrument in any
manner required for the sole purpose of ensuring that each such trust qualifies and continues to qualify
as a charitable remainder annuity trust within the meaning of Section 664(d)(1) of the Code.

5. Nothing in this instrument shall be construed to restrict my Trustees from
investing the assets of such trusts in a manner that could result in the annual realization of a reasonable
amount of income or gain from the sale or disposition of trust assets.

6. In each case, the obligation to pay the annuity amount shall commence with
-6-
inn awn 0'1
the date of my death, but payment of such amount may be deferred from such date until the end of
the taxable year in which occurs the complete funding of the trust Within a reasonable time after the
end of the taxable year in which occurs the complete funding of the trust, my Trustees shall pay to the
respective recipients of the annuity amounts (in the case of an underpayment) or receive from such
recipients (m the case of an overpayment) the difference between: (a) any annuity amounts actually
paid, plus interest, compounded annually, computed for any period at the rate of interest that the
federal income tax regulations under Section 664 of the Code prescribe for the trust for such period;
and (b) the annuity amounts payable, plus interest, compounded annually, computed for any period at
the rate of interest that the federal income tax regulations under Section 664 of the Code prescribe for
the trust for such period.

E. Notwithstanding the foregoing, if the trust arising under Paragraph A of this Article
fails to satisfy the exhaustion test described in Revenue Ruling 77-374 or the requirements of Section
664(d)(1)(D) of the Code, my Trustees shall, rather than establishing the trust described in Paragraph
A, distribute to a separate trust the amount neercsary to purchase a commercial annuity to satisfy my
obligations under Section 6.B of the Separation Agreement The trust established under this Paragraph
shall administer such annuity to satisfy the payments my estate must pay to Marla pursuant to Section
6.13 of the Separation Agreement. Such annuity shall be purchased within six (6) months of my death.
kick W
Other Provisions Related to the Separation Agreement
The provisions set forth below in this Article W shall take effect only if Marla has not violated
the terms of out Separation Agreement and our Separation Agreement is in effect at the time of my
death.

A. If Math survives me and, at the time of my death, she owns the townhouse at 17 East
75th Street, New York City, New York, my Trustees shall discharge the balance as of the date of my
death of any mortgage on said townhouse that complies with Section 7.B.2 of the Separation
Agreement This provision is intended to satisfy my obligation under Section 7.B.6 of the Separation
Agreement.

B. Upon my death, if Marla survives me and, at the time of my death, she owns the
townhouse at 17 East 75th Street, New York City, New York, my Trustees shall set aside the sum of
Two Million ($2,000,000) Dollars and shall hold and dispose of the same as a separate trust upon the
following terms, which are intended to satisfy my remaining obligations to Marla 'under the Separation
-7-
4.A. •••••1.0
Agreement

1. My Trustees shall, from time to time, make such payments to or on behalf of
Marla as my Trustees shall deem necessary to satisfy the obligations, if any, that I have under Section
7.13 of the Separation Agreement
2. Upon Maria's death or at such earlier time as there shall be no remaining
obligations to satisfy under Section 7.B of the Separation Agreement, my Trustees shall allocate any
remaining principal and undistributed income by right of representation among my then living issue.
My Trustees shall use the property so allocated to any descendant of mine to create or add to a trust
for the benefit of such person under Article XL hereof. If no descendant of mine is then living, my
Trustees shall dispose of said principal and income in accordance with the provisions of Astick_X
hereof.
Article V
Abigail's Inheritance
If my daughter Abigail survives me, my Trustees shall set aside an amount equal to Fifty
Million (150,000,000) Dollars plus, to the extent that I have not during my lifetime fully satisfied the
amount that I am obligated to leave to Abigail under Section 5.F of the Separation Agreement (the
"Section S.F Amount"), an amount necessary to satisfy the Section 5.F Amount. For purposes of the
preceding sentence, the value as of the date of my death of any trust created by me during my lifetime
for the primary benefit of my descendants shall be determined as if the trustees of such trust had no
discretion to distribute income or principal of such trust to any beneficiary from the date of my death
until the funding of separate trusts for my children under such trust To the extent this gift is applied
to satisfy the Section 5.F Amount, it shall take precedence over any other gift hereunder that is not in
satisfaction of an obligation of mine under the Separation Agreement This gift shall be subject to a
proportionate share of any death taxes payable by reason of my death.
My Trustees shall hold and dispose of such amount as a separate trust for Abigail's benefit
pursuant to the provisions of Article XI hereof.
VI
Provisions for Abigail During Minority
If the Separation Agreement is in effect at the time of my death, my daughter Abigail survives
me and I die prior to her eighteenth (18th) birthday, my Trustees shall set aside an amount equal to the
-8-

ft. dIOVI. let
sum of Three Hundred Thousand ($300,000) Dollars multiplied by the number of years between the
date of my death and Abigail's eighteenth (18th) birthday (including the final, fractional year,
computed on a daily basis) and shall add such amount to the trust for Abigail's benefit under Article
XI hereof. This amount is intended to satisfy, and shall be administered and distributed by my
Trustees to satisfy, my obligations to provide for child care and household help while Abigail is under
age eighteen (18) pursuant to the terms and conditions set forth in Section 5.D of the Separation
Agreement
Article VII
Provisions for Abigail until her Emancipation
If the Separation Agreement is in effect at the time of my death, my daughter Abigail survives
me and I die prior to her Emancipation (as defined in Section 5.E of the Separation Agreement), my
Trustees shall set aside an amount equal to the sum of Two Million ($2,000,000) Dollars and shall add
such amount to the trust for Abigail's benefit under Article XI hereof. This amount is intended to
satisfy, and shall be administered and distributed by my Trustees to satisfy, my obligations to pay for
Abigail's educational expenses and medical coverage until Abigail's Emancipation pursuant to the
terms and conditions set forth in Sections 5.B and 5.0 of the Separation Agreement.
Article VIII
Other Provisions for Abigail and Renee
If either or both of my daughter Abigail and my daughter Renee survive me, my Trustees shall
make the following provisions for their benefit

A. If Renee survives me, my Trustees shall set aside for Renee an amount equal to (1) the
amount set aside for Abigail (or, if Abigail does not survive me, the amount that would have been set
aside for Abigail had she survived me) under Article V hereof (calculated net of death taxes
apportioned to the amount set aside for Abigail (or that would have been apportioned to such amount
had Abigail survived me), it being my intent that any death taxes charged against the amount set aside
for Renee shall be paid from the residue); (2) an amount determined in the same manner as provided
in Article VI hereof for Abigail if I die prior to Renee's eighteenth (18th) birthday which shall be set
aside whether or not the Separation Agreement is in effect at the time of my death and whether or not
Abigail survives me; and (3) the amount set aside for Abigail under Article VII hereof. My Trustees
shall add any amount set aside for Renee under clause (1), (2) or (3) of this Paragraph to the trust for
-9-
An •na • PM., le•
the benefit of Renee under Article XI hereof.

B. Paragraph A of Article THIRD of my Will provides for bequests to my Trustees of my
residences located at 950 Fifth Avenue, New York City, New York and on Drew Lane in East
Hampton, New York. Regardless of whether such properties are transferred to my Trustees pursuant
to Paragraph A of Article THIRD of my Will or held hereunder by my Trustees prior to my death,
upon my death, my Trustees shall hold such properties in trust for Abigail's benefit under Article la
hereof; provided that Abigail survives me and the Separation Agreement is in effect at my death.
These bequests or gifts shall be subject to any mortgages, liens or other encumbrances on said
properties at the time of my death and shall also be subject to a proportionate share of any death taxes
payable by reason of my death, based on the ratio between the net value of such properties included in
the measure of any such tax and the net taxable amount on which such tax is imposed.
C. If the bequests or gifts described in Paragraph B of this Article take effect and my
daughter Renee survives me, my Trustees shall set aside an amount equal to the net estate tax value of
the bequests or gifts (taking into account any death taxes charged against the bequests, as well as other
liens and mortgages) and shall add the same to the trust for Renee's benefit under Article XI hereof.
• D. Paragraph B of Article THIRD of my Will provides for a bequest to my Trustees of
my residence in Aspen, Colorado and its contents. Regardless of whether such property and its
contents are transferred to my Trustees pursuant to Paragraph 13 of Article THIRD of my Will or held
hereunder by my Trustees prior to my death, upon my death, my Trustees shall hold and dispose of
said property and its contents or the proceeds from the sale of such property and its contents in equal
shares for the benefit of my children who survive me as part of the respective trusts for their benefit
under Article XI hereof.
If Renee survives me, and if upon my death Renee is younger than twenty-five (25)
years old, my Trustees shall set aside an amount equal to One Million ($1,000,000) Dollars multiplied
by the number of years between the date of my death and Renee's twenty-fifth (256) birthday, and my
Trustees shall pay over and add such amount to the trust arising for Renee's benefit under Article.X1
hereof to be administered as an integral part thereof. My Trustees shall prorate the amount of One
Million ($1,000,000) Dollars on a daily basis for any partial calendar year, such as the year of my death
or the year in which Renee turns twenty-five (25) years old. The amount payable pursuant to this
Paragraph E shall be in addition to any other amount provided for Renee hereunder or under my Will.
-10-
'An Oa., • A
Other Gifts at My Death
Upon my death, my Trustees shall make the following payments, which shall be free and clear
of any death taxes payable by reason of my death except as otherwise provided in this Article:

A. My Trustees shall pay the following amounts to each of the following persons who
survives me.
1. Fifty Thousand ($50,000) Dollars to each child of my friend, M. Gordon
Ehrlich;

2. One Hundred Fifty Thousand ($150,000) Dollars to William Whitworth of
little Rock, Arkansas;
3. One Hundred Fifty Thousand ($150,000) Dollars to Harold Evans of New
York City, New York;

4. Six Hundred Thousand ($600,000) Dollars to Dora Pompey;
5. Six Hundred Thousand ($600,000) Dollars to Clare Probert; and

6. The following amounts to Yesdy Villanueva: (i) One Hundred Thousand
($100,000) Dollars upon my death, (u) Fifty Thousand ($50,000) Dollars at the end of each calendar
year following my death, up to the fifth anniversary of my death, if she is then employed by my
Trustees or by my executors as a childcare provider for any of my children, and (di) One Hundred
Thousand ($100,000) Dollars upon the fifth anniversary of my death if she is then employed by my
Trustees or by my executors as a childcare provider for any of my children.

B. My Trustees shall set aside the sum of Twenty Million ($20,000,000) Dollars for each
of my nephews, Eric Gertler and James Gertler, who survives me or who has issue who survives me.
My Trustees shall distribute the property so allocated to a then living nephew of mine to such nephew,
outright and free of all trusts. My Trustees shall hold, administer and pay over all or any fractional
portion of such amount that a then living nephew of mine disclaims in accordance with the provisions
of Paragraph A of Article XII hereof, and my Trustees shall hold, administer and pay over such
amount that is allocated to the then living issue of a then deceased nephew of mine in accordance with
the provisions of Paragraph B of Article XTj hereof, subject in either case to any generation-skipping
transfer taxes attributable to such amount.

C. My Trustees shall set aside the sum of Two Million ($2,000,000) Dollars for each of
my nieces, Andrea Robinson Talamo and Nancy Robinson, and n:iy nephew, Andrew Gertler, who
-11-
survives me or who has issue who survives me. My Trustees shall distribute the property so allocated
to a then living niece or nephew of mine to such niece or nephew, outright and free of all trusts. My
Trustees shall hold, administer and pay over all or any fractional portion of such amount that a then
living niece or nephew of mine disclaims in accordance with the provisions of Paragraph A of Article
)CII hereof; and my Trustees shall hold, administer and pay over such amount that is allocated to the
then living issue of a then deceased niece or nephew of mine in accordance with the provisions of
Paragraph B of Article XII hereof, subject in either case to any generation-skipping transfer taxes
attributable to such amount.

D. I have created a set of eight charitable remainder unitrusts dated December 11, 2012,
designated as "The Mortimer B. Zuckerman 2015 Charitable Remainder Unitrust" through "The
Mortimer B. Zuckerman 2022 Charitable Remainder Unitrust" (the "CRTs"). I have also entered into
an agreement dated December 13, 2012 (the "Columbia Agreement") relating to the establishment and
funding of The Mortimer B. Zuckerman Mind Brain Behavior Institute (the "MBZ Institute') at
Columbia University ("Columbia'). The Columbia Agreement commits a specified amount of the
funds remaining in each of the CRTs upon the termination of such CRTs for the funding of the M/3Z
Institute. If the assets in any of the CRTs arc insufficient to satisfy any outstanding commitment of
CRT funds to Columbia under the Columbia Agreement, my Trustees shall make a distribution to
Columbia in an amount, determined in the manner specified in such agreement, sufficient to make up
the deficiency.
iAr ifle
Disposition of Remaining Property
From and after my death, my Trustees shall dispose of any trust property that is not otherwise
disposed of as follows:

A. Except as hereinafter provided, my Trustees shall distribute all such property to the
Mortimer B. Zuckerman Foundation, a charitable trust created by me by declaration of trust dated
December 21, 1983, as the same may be amended from time to time, or its successor (hereinafter the
"Foundation"). If the Foundation does not exist or does not qualify as a charitable organization at the
time of my death, my Trustees shall make distributions in satisfaction of this gift to such other
charitable organization or organizations as my Trustees shall determine.

B. It is my intention that the gift under this Article shall, to the maximum extent possible,
qualify for the deduction under Section 2055 of the Code in computing the federal estate tax and any
-12-
state death tax payable with respect to my estate. The provisions of this instrument shall be construed
so as to effectuate this intention.
Article XI
Trust for the Benefit of a Descendant of Ming
My Trustees shall hold and dispose of any property retained or received by them for any
descendant of mine (the "Beneficiary') as a separate trust for the benefit of the Beneficiary and such
Beneficiary's issue upon the following terms:

A. In the case of any separate trust held under this Article of which Abigail is the
Beneficiary, and if the Separation Agreement is in effect at the time of my death, my Trustees shall pay
so much of the net income and principal of the trust for Abigail as is required to be paid to or for the
benefit of Abigail under the Separation Agreement, and no distribution of the income or principal of
such trust shall be made to any beneficiary other than Abigail unless the health, education,
maintenance and support of Abigail have been fully provided for.

B. In the case of any trust held under this Article, my Trustees shall pay to or for the
benefit of such one or more of the Beneficiary (including Abigail or Renee) or, subject to Paragraph A
hereof, the Beneficiary's issue of any generation living from time to time so much of the net income
and principal of the trust as my Trustees deem desirable for the health, education, maintenance and
support of such person or persons, in my Trustees' discretion. In addition, the Disinterested Trustee
of the trust may also make payments from the net income and principal of such trust to or for the
benefit of such one or more of the Beneficiary or, subject to Paragraph A hereof, the Beneficiary's
issue, at such times and in such amounts as the Disinterested Trustee deems desirable. Any
undistributed income shall be added to the principal of the trust

C. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall dispose of the then remaining
principal and undistributed income of the trust for the benefit of such Beneficiary in accordance with
the Beneficiary's exercise of a Special Power of Appointment. To the extent the Beneficiary shall fail to
exercise such power effectively, my Trustees shall allocate said principal and income by right of
representation among the Beneficiary's then living issue or, in default of such issue, by right of
representation among the then living issue of the nearest ancestor of such person who was either
myself or a descendant of mine and who has issue then living. My Trustees shall use the property so
allocated to any descendant of mine to create or add to a trust for the benefit of such person under
this Article. If no descendant of mine is then living, my Trustees shall dispose of said principal and
-13-
income in accordance with the provisions of Article X hereof.

D. Without limiting the discretion my Trustees would otherwise have, my Trustees may
transfer or distribute any portion of the net income and principal of the trust for the primary benefit of
the Beneficiary under this Article to any other trust created by me for the primary benefit of the
Beneficiary, or may merge the trust for the primary benefit of the Beneficiary under this Article with
any other trust created by me during my lifetime or upon my death and determine under which
instrument such continuing trust will be held; provided, however, that such other trust has
substantially similar terms and the same Beneficiary or beneficiaries, provided further that if the
ultimate remainder provisions of such mists are not identical, the trustees of the resulting merged trust
shall keep a record of the initial proportions of the trusts so merged so that if such ultimate remainders
become operative, the remaining principal of the resulting merged trust shall pass proportionately
according to the original governing provisions of the trusts so merged. If the duration of two trusts
that are merged pursuant to this Paragraph is measured or limited by a provision referring to the death
of the survivor of a group of individuals, such provisions shall be considered substantially similar even
if the groups include different individuals, as long all members of one group are included in the other.
If such trusts are merged, the duration of the merged trust shall be measured or limited by the group
that has fewer members.
E. With respect to any trust held under this Article for the benefit of a child of mine who
is a minor at the time of my death, after first satisfying the provisions of Paragraph A hereof with
respect to such trust, my Trustees may distribute to the guardian or guardians of such minor child,
other than Marla Prather if she is then acting as guardian of such minor child, for the guardian's own
use, such sum or sums as my Trustees in their discretion deem appropriate to relieve the financial
burden on such guardian and his or her family resulting from such minor child's presence in the
guardian's household. For example, my Trustees may distribute funds to such guardian to provide
additional domestic help, enlarge such guardian's home or purchase a new home, to the extent
necessary to provide a suitable living arrangement for my minor child and to ensure that such guardian
will not personally bear any additional cost as a result of his or her care for my minor child. In the
exercise of such discretion, my Trustees shall take into account the size of such trust, the needs and
age of such minor child, and the financial resources of the guardian to the extent known to my
Trustees. No Trustee who is simultaneously acting as guardian of such child shall participate in
decisions regarding any distribution pursuant to this Paragraph E to himself or herself or for his or het
-14-
benefit as guardian of such child. In addition, my Trustees may distribute to any nanny or other
person who is determined by my Trustees to serve a quasi-parental role in such minor child's life
(other than Marla) such amounts as my Trustees determine to be appropriate to provide for costs of
care provided to the child so that such person may maintain a close relationship with such child.
Article XII
Trust for the Benefit of a Descendant
of a Niece or Nephew of Mine
My Trustees shall hold and dispose of any property retained or received by them for the
benefit of the issue of a niece or nephew of mine as follows:

A. Whenever any niece or nephew of mine has disclaimed any property passing
hereunder, my Trustees shall hold such disclaimed property in one separate trust for the issue, taken
collectively, of such niece or nephew. Until the death of such niece or nephew of mine who
disclaimed such property, my Trustees shall pay so much of the net income and principal of the trust
to or for the benefit of one or more of the issue of such niece or nephew, of any generation, who is
living at the time such distribution is made, as my Trustees deem desirable for the health, education,
maintenance and support of such person or persons, in my Trustees' discretion. In addition, the
Disinterested Trustee may also make payments from the net income and principal of such trust to or
for the benefit of one or more of such person or persons, at such times and in such amounts as the
Disinterested Trustee deems advisable. Notwithstanding the foregoing, no distribution of income or
principal shall be made from a trust held under this Paragraph that would discharge a legal obligation
of support that my niece or nephew who disclaimed such property owes to any beneficiary of such
trust. Any income not so paid shall be accumulated and added to principal. Upon the death of such
niece or nephew of mine who is the parent of the issue for whom a trust is held under this Paragraph,
or such earlier date as the Disinterested Trustee shall determine, my Trustees shall pay over the
remaining principal of such trust in accordance with Paragraph B hereof.

B. Whenever I have herein directed that property be held, administered or paid over in
accordance with this Paragraph B, my Trustees shall divide the same into shares by right of
representation among the then-living issue of my niece or nephew who would have received such
property if she or he were living at the time of my death and shall hold each such share in a separate
trust for the benefit of such person to be held, administered and paid as follows:

1. My Trustees shall pay to such person, from time to time, so much of the net
-15-
•II
income and principal of the trust as my Trustees deem desirable for the health, education, maintenance
and support of such person, in my Trustees' discretion. In addition, the Disinterested Trustee may
also make payments from the net income and principal of such trust to or for the benefit of such
person at such times and in such amounts as the Disinterested Trustee deems advisable. Any income
not so paid shall be accumulated and added to principal

2. From and after the time such person attains thirty (30) years of age, my
Trustees shall pay to such person from time to time such portion or portions of the principal thereof
as such person shall request in writing.

3. Upon the death of such person, my Trustees shall allocate the then remaining
principal and undistributed income by right of representation among such person's then-living issue
or, in default of such issue, by right of representation among the then living issue of the nearest
ancestor of such person who was a descendant of my grandparents and who has issue then living. My
Trustees shall pay the share so allocated to a niece or nephew of mine to such niece or nephew,
outright and free of all trusts. My Trustees shall retain the share so allocated to any other person for
the benefit of such person upon the trusts set forth in this Article. In default of such issue, my
Trustees shall dispose of the same in accordance with the provisions of  A rtiele g  hereof.
Article XIII
Qualified Subchapter $ Trusts
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary hereinbefore contained, if my Trustees are holding
of acquire stock in a corporation, if my Trustees determine that it would be desirable for such
corporation to make or preserve an election to be treated as an S corporation under Section 1362(a) of
the Code or any successor thereto, and if the Disinterested Trustee shall determine that it would be
desirable for all or a portion of such stock to be held in Qualified Subchapter S Trusts, my Trustees
shall transfer such stock or such portion to one or more Qualified Subchapter S Trusts, each for the
benefit of a person (the "Beneficiary') for whose benefit such stock was theretofore held, as
determined by the Disinterested Trustee, and thereafter shall hold and dispose of the same upon the
following terms:

A. Unless sooner terminated as hereinafter provided or by distribution of all of the
property held therein, each Qualified Subchapter S Trust shall continue during the lifetime of the
Beneficiary thereof. During any year in which stock in an S corporation is held in any such trust, my
Trustees shall pay the net income of such trust to the Beneficiary at least as often as quarterly during
-16-
his or her lifetime. In addition to any payments required by the preceding sentence, my Trustees shall
pay to the Beneficiary from time to time such portion or portions of the net income and principal as
the Disinterested Trustee shall deem advisable for his or her benefit No distributions shall be made
to anyone other than the Beneficiary during such Beneficiary's lifetime.

B. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall dispose of the then remaining
principal and undistributed income in accordance with the exercise by the Beneficiary of a Special
Power of Appointment To the extent the Beneficiary shall fail to exercise said power effectively, my
Trustees shall divide said principal and income into equal shares by right of representation among the
Beneficiary's then living issue or, in default of such issue, by right of representation among the then
living issue of the nearest ancestor of such person who was a descendant of my parents and who has
issue then living. Except to the extent that the property so allocated to any person is used to create a
Qualified Subchapter S Trust for the benefit of such person, my Trustees shall use the property so
allocated to any person to create or add to a trust for the benefit of such person under Article XI or
Article XI[ hereof, as the case may be.

C. As used herein, the term "Qualified Subchapter S Trust" means a trust that satisfies
the requirements of Section 1361(d)(3)(A) of the Code that

1. During the life of the current income beneficiary, there shall only be one
income beneficiary of the trust;

2. Any corpus distributed during the life of the current income beneficiary may
be distributed only to such beneficiary;

3. The income interest of the current income beneficiary in the trust shall
terminate on the earlier of such beneficiary's death or the termination of the trust; and

4. Upon the termination of the trust during the life of the current income
beneficiary, the trust shall distribute all of its assets to such beneficiary.

D. It is my intention that each trust hereunder shall be eligible to be a shareholder in an S
corporation. The provisions of this instrument shall be construed and all actions of my Trustees shall
be taken so as to effectuate this intention. It is my expectation that each beneficiary will make any
elections required for such eligibility under Section 1361(d) of the Code. Nothing herein shall be
construed to prevent my Trustees from joining in the revocation or termination of any corporation's
election to be an S corporation, if my Trustees determine that such revocation or termination would
be advisable.
-17-
Article XIV
Further Provisions Regarding the Disposition of the Trust Property
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein contained, my Trustees may from time to
time following my death make payments to the Foundation from the net income and principal of any
trust hereunder, other than a Qualified Subchapter S Trust under Article XIII hereof, if my Trustees,
in their sole discretion, shall determine that such payments arc advisable; provided, however, that if the
Separation Agreement is then in effect, no such payment may be made from a trust for Abigail's
benefit if such payment would violate my obligations under the Separation Agreement
Article XV
Powers of Appointment Disclaimer•
Division and Consolidation of Trusts

A. Whenever my Trustees are directed to dispose of any property in accordance with the
exercise of a Special Power of Appointment, they shall dispose of such property among such one or
more of the members, living at the death of the holder of the power or thereafter born, of a class
consisting of the issue of my parents and/or such charitable organization or organizations and in such
proportions as the holder of the power shall appoint by will, specifically referring to the power. Such
power shall include the power to appoint outright or in trust and to create new powers exercisable in
favor of a person who was not an object of the original Special Power of Appointment other than the
holder of the original power, his or her creditors, his or her estate or the creditors of his or her estate.
In addition, any person holding such a power may appoint to such person's estate any portion of the
trust property that, in default of appointment, would be subject to a generation-skipping transfer tax
by reason of such person's death; provided, however, that the Disinterested Trustee may at any time
revoke such power to appoint to such person's estate by instrument in writing delivered to such
person. If the Disinterested Trustee revokes the power to appoint to such person's estate, the
Disinterested Trustee subsequently may grant such power to such person by instrument in writing
delivered to such person. The power to grant and revoke powers of appointment may be exercised
multiple times.

B. Any beneficiary hereunder or such beneficiary's executor, administrator, conservator
or guardian may, by instrument in writing delivered to my Trustees, disclaim in whole or in part any
one or more of such beneficiary's rights to receive, appoint or withdraw any portion or all of the trust
property or the income therefrom. If a beneficiary shall disclaim all rights with respect to any portion
-18-
AAAAA •••
of the trust property, my Trustees shall thereafter dispose of such portion for all purposes as if such
beneficiaty had died immediately before such rights became indefeasibly vested in such beneficiary,
unless the provisions hereunder provide otherwise.

C. My Trustees may, in their discretion, for any tax or administrative reason (including the
identification or segregation of property for generation-skipping transfer tax purposes) divide any
property passing into or held in any trust hereunder into two or more separate shares. My Trustees
shall hold and administer each such share as a separate trust upon the same terms and conditions
contained in the original trust. Notwithstanding the foregoing, if any such division is made, the
Disinterested Trustee may, in his discretion, amend the dispositive provisions of any one or more of
such separate trusts from time to time, including provisions regarding beneficiaries' withdrawal rights
or powers of appointment or distributions on termination of such trust, to the extent the Disinterested
Trustee shall deem advisable to take into consideration the tax characteristics of such trusts without, in
the opinion of the Disinterested Trustee, substantially altering the overall interests of the beneficiaries
hereunder. No such amendment shall be made to any trust under Article XIII hereof that would cause
such trust to fail to satisfy the requirements of Paragraph C of said Article.

13. My Trustees may, in their discretion, merge any trust hereunder with any other trust
having substantially identical terms and tax characteristics, whether or not having the same trustees,
and may take such steps as they deem advisable to effect such a merger.
Article XVI
Survivorship: Manner of Payment
Restrictions on Alienation-
contingent Termination and Distribution

A. Except to the extent that the Separation Agreement requires otherwise, if any
beneficiary hereunder shall die within ninety (90) days after my death, it shall be presumed that such
beneficiary predeceased me.

B. Whenever provision is made hereunder for payment of principal or income to a
beneficiary, the same may instead be applied for his or het benefit. If pursuant to any provision
hereunder any property, real or personal, and whether principal or income, becomes payable to a
person who is a minor (defined for the purposes of this Paragraph as a person younger than twenty-
one (21) years old) or other person under a disability, I authorize my Trustees in their sole discretion to
pay over such property in whole or in part at any time and from time to time to a parent or duly
-19-
appointed guardian or committee of such person, to a custodian under a Uniform Gifts or Transfers
to Minors Act (including my Trustees or any one of them) who may act until such person attains age
twenty-one (21) or is no longer under a disability, as the case may be, or to any individual with whom
such person resides, for the use and benefit of such person, or directly to such person by way of an
allowance or otherwise.

C. Neither the income nor the principal of any trust hereunder shall be alienable by any
beneficiary, either by anticipation, assignment or by any other method and the same shall not be
subject to be taken by his or her creditors by any process whatsoever, except that the foregoing shall
not limit any beneficiary's power to disclaim all or a part of such beneficiary's interest or to appoint or
withdraw any part of any trust hereunder to the extent of any such power specifically given herein.

D. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein contained, each trust hereunder shall,
unless sooner terminated in accordance with its terms, terminate in all events twenty-one years after
the death of the survivor of all of the issue of my parents living on the date this trust becomes
irrevocable, by reason of my death or otherwise. The person or persons serving as Disinterested
Trustee of any trust hereunder may amend the preceding sentence with respect to such trust and any
successor trusts by written instrument signed by such person or persons and deposited with the trust
records, to the extent such amendment is consistent with any applicable rule against perpetuities. In
addition, my Trustees may terminate any trust hereunder if, in the opinion of the Disinterested
Trustee, the continuation of such trust is uneconomical or inadvisable for any other reason. Upon any
such termination my Trustees shall pay the then remaining principal and undistributed income of such
trust to the person or persons for whose benefit the same was theretofore held and in such shares as
the Disinterested Trustee shall determine.
If, upon the termination of this trust, there is no person living who is entitled to the
principal or income thereof, my Trustees shall dispose of such principal, together with any then
undistributed income therefrom, in accordance with the provisions of Article X hereof.
Article XVII
Trustees' Powers

A. Subject to the provisions hereinafter set forth in this Article, my Trustees shall have
full power to take any steps and do any acts which they may deem necessary or proper in connection
with the due care, management and disposition of the property and income of any trust hereunder
and, in particular, without limiting the powers given by law or other provisions of this ttust, may, in
-20-
and, ••••••• aft
their discretion, and until actual distribution of the trust property following termination of such trust,
without order or license of court

1. Retain any investments or cash, however the same may be acquired, for such
period of time as they shall deem advisable, and invest and reinvest in any kind of real or personal
property whatsoever (including property of a speculative or unproductive nature, mutual funds and
any common trust fund of which a trustee or its affiliate hereunder may be a trustee) without giving
notice to any beneficiary, notwithstanding the fact that any or all of the same may be of a character or
size which, but for this express authority, would not be considered a proper investment for trustees to
make;

2. Sell real or personal property at public or private sale and exchange, lease, give
options and make contracts concerning any such property for such consideration and upon such terms
as to credit or otherwise as they may determine, which leases, options and contracts may extend
beyond the term of the trust;

3. Borrow money for such periods of time and upon such terms and conditions
as they may deem advisable for any purpose whatsoever and mortgage and pledge such part or all of
the property of the trust as they deem necessary to secure the same;

4. Foreclose by entry or otherwise, extend, assign or give partial releases from
and discharge mortgages or pledges and, as Trustees hereunder, bid for and become the purchaser of
any real or personal property sold at any foreclosure or other sale;

5. Give general or special proxies or powers of attorney for voting or acting in
respect of securities, which may be discretionary and with power of substitution; deposit securities
with, or transfer them to, protective committees, voting trusts or similar bodies; whether or not the
respective terms thereof may extend beyond the term of the trust; join in any reorganization and pay
assessments or subscriptions called for in connection with securities held by my Trustees; register or
qualify for exemption from registration any securities held by my Trustees;

6. Hold securities in bearer form and hold securities and real estate and maintain
bank accounts in the name of a nominee or nominees without indication of any fiduciary capacity;

7. Allocate receipts and charges between principal and income as they shall, in
good faith, determine to be consistent with generally accepted trust accounting principles;

8. Determine whether or not to amortize premiums, to establish sinking funds
for the purpose of amortization of premiums, or reserves for depreciation, depletion, or otherwise and
to abandon and distribute said funds or reserves, allocating the same between principal and income as
they may determine;

9. Allot, in any distribution or division of the trust, any part or parts of the
property held by them in the actual state of investment in or towards satisfaction of any share at
current fair market values (with no requirement to make any adjustment because of differences in cost
bases for income tax purposes), their good faith determination of such market values to be final and
binding on all persons claiming hereunder;

10. Keep any or all of the property of the trust at any place or places in the State of
New York or elsewhere or with a depositary or custodian at such place or places;

11. Employ as investment counsel, custodians, brokers, accountants, appraisers,
-21-
attorneys or other agents such persons, firms or organizations, including any Trustee hereunder and
any firm or organization of which any Trustee hereunder may be a member or employee, as my
Trustees may deem necessary or desirable and pay as an expense of the administration of the trust the
reasonable compensation of such persons, firms or organizations;

12. Settle, compromise or refer to arbitration any matter in any way affecting the
trust and pay, compromise or contest any claim or dispute directly or indirectly affecting the property
thereof;

13. Purchase securities or other property, real or personal, from or make loans to
my executor, which loans may be secured or unsecured and my Trustees shall not be responsible or
liable in any way for any loss occurring by reason of any such purchase or loan made by them in good
faith even though they may be dealing with one or more of themselves as such executor,

14. Mingle the property of the separate trusts hereunder, allotting to each separate
trust an undivided interest in the mingled funds, which interest shall always be equal to such trust's
proportionate contribution thereto as adjusted from time to time to reflect accumulations of income,
payments of principal and additions to principal;

15. Delegate from time to time, by written instrument, to any one or more of the
Trustees hereunder or to a third person or persons (a) the power to lease, have access to or surrender a
safe deposit box of the trust; (b) the power to open, maintain, make deposits in or sign checks or other
orders for the withdrawal of funds from or in connection with any and all bank accounts of the trust;
and (c) the power to make investment changes on a discretionary basis;

16. As principal or in conjunction with others, whether as a partner or otherwise,
manage, improve, exchange, partition, change the character of, or abandon a trust asset or any interest
therein; and

17. Manage any real property as they may deem desirable, including, without
limitation, the authority to contract for the management of any property by other persons or
corporations for compensation and delegate to such other persons or corporations such authority as
they may deem proper; alter or adjust boundaries; grant easements; insure or perfect tide; insure the
premises against loss or liability of any kind; subdivide; equalize shares; and apply other funds of the
trust for any purpose pertaining to such real estate.

B. Any Trustee may delegate to any other Trustee or Trustees from time to time by a
written instrument for such period or periods of time as may be specified therein any one or more of
the powers given in this Article to my Trustees; provided, however that no Disinterested Trustee may
delegate to a Trustee who does not qualify as a Disinterested Trustee any power or responsibility that
is exclusively within the authority of the Disinterested Trustee. Except as otherwise provided herein,
any action to be taken or decision to be made by my Trustees or by the Disinterested Trustee may be
taken or made by a majority of the persons who are serving as Trustees or as a Disinterested Trustee,
as the case may be.

C. The Disinterested Trustee may make guarantees, either unsecured or secured by trust
property, including guarantees for the benefit of a beneficiary on terms and conditions that the
-22-
Disinterested Trustee considers to be fair and reasonable under the circumstances, and my Trustees
shall have a lien on future distributions for repayment of any amount that may be paid on account of
such guarantee (other than guarantees made for investment purposes); provided that any such
guarantee shall be permitted only to the extent it is: (i) made for investment purposes with respect to
an interest in a proprietorship, partnership, limited liability company, statutory trust, business trust,
corporation or other form of business enterprise owned in whole or in part by the trust, (ti) made in
lieu of a distribution that could have been made to or for such beneficiary under the terms of the
governing instrument, or (M) made for the benefit of another trust of which such beneficiary is also a
beneficiary. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Paragraph, (i) during my lifetime, my
Trustees shall make such guarantees, either unsecured or secured by trust property, for my benefit on
such terms and conditions as I direct and (it) any guarantee that is existing at the time of my death will
continue to bind the Trust and any and all successor trusts, and my Trustees and all successor Trustees
of the Trust (and successor trusts) will provide the persons to whom such existing guarantee is made
with written acknowledgement to that effect promptly upon request therefor.
Article XVIII
Management of Business Interests

A. I expect that a substantial portion of my estate will consist of businesses in which I
have a controlling or substantial interest In order to provide for the conservation and management of
the trust property for the benefit of the beneficiaries hereof, if any business in which I own a
controlling or substantial interest, whether such business is a corporation, REIT, partnership or sole
proprietorship (each of said businesses being hereinafter referred to as a "Business"), should hereafter
become trust property, my Trustees may, in their discretion, without order or license of any court,
retain any such Business as trust property and continue to operate such Business for such periods of
time as my Trustees shall deem advisable and, in addition to the powers enumerated in Article XVII
hereof, which powers shall be applicable to any Business, my Trustees shall, with respect to every
Business, have the power to:

1. Control, direct, supervise, manage, operate and participate in a Business to
whatever extent my Trustees in their sole and absolute discretion deem advisable, determine the
manner and degree of their active participation in the operation of a Business and delegate all or any
part of their power to supervise and operate to such person or persons as they may select, including
any associate, partner, officer or employee of the Business or any beneficiary hereunder,

2. Vote the stock of any Business for the election of designated directors and
-23-
officers and elect to serve as director or officer of any Business such individuals as my Trustees shall in
their sole and absolute discretion deem advisable, including any beneficiary hereunder, any director,
officer or employee of any Trustee hereunder or any Trustee hereunder, and instruct such directors
and officers regarding any and all decisions required to be made with respect to the operation of that
Business;

3. Engage and discharge officers and employees, fix their compensation and
define their duties, employ, compensate and discharge agents, attorneys, consultants, accountants and
such other representatives as my Trustees may deem appropriate and employ in any of the foregoing
capacities any beneficiary hereunder, any director, officer or employee of any Trustee hereunder or any
Trustee hereunder;

4. Do all things necessary and proper in the usual course of any Business,
including without limitation, purchasing, processing and selling merchandise and providing services of
every kind and description, and purchasing and selling machinery, equipment, furniture, fixtures and
supplies of all kinds;

5. Take any action necessary to direct a Business to enter into and perform
contracts in connection with the operation of the Business, to purchase, to take options for the
purchase, and to lease property, real or personal, for any period of time whether or not such option or
lease extends beyond the term of the trusts hereunder, to borrow as required for the operation of the
Business or for capital improvements and to execute any guarantees or pledge any assets of the
Business as collateral for such borrowing,, and take any and all such action from time to time on behalf
of the Business and execute and deliver any and all such documents, including without limitation, any
and all notices, certificates, agreements, assignments, bills of sale, leases, powers of attorney, receipts,
declarations, applications, affidavits, deeds, notes and other instruments as may be necessary, advisable
or proper in order to perform the obligations of the Business and to carry on the operation of the
Business;

6. Invest other trust property in a Business, pledge other trust property as
security for loans made to any Business, guarantee the obligations of any Business with other trust
property, loan other trust property to any Business, and borrow from any bank or other lending
institution, including any corporate fiduciary named herein, upon such terms and conditions as are
currently competitive;

7. Take any action neregaary to issue, purchase and/or redeem any stock or
equity interest in a Business and to obtain new equity capital for a Business, whether by means of a
private placement or public offering;

8. Organize a corporation under the laws of this or any other state or country,
transfer thereto all or any part of a Business or other property held in the trusts hereunder, receive in
exchange therefor such stocks, bonds and other securities and forms of indebtedness of such
corporation as my Trustees may deem advisable, and, once incorporated, vote the stock of such
corporation;

9. Take any action required to convert any corporation into a partnership or sole
proprietorship;
10. Make any election under applicable tax laws as my Trustees may deem
advisable to qualify a Business for favorable income tax treatment;
-24-

11. Take any action necessary to amend a Business' articles of organization,
certificate of incorporation, charter, by-laws or partnership agreement;

12. Treat each Business as an entity separate from the trusts hereunder, my
Trustees only being required, in their accountings to any court and to any beneficiaries, to report the
earnings and condition of each Business in accordance with standard corporate accounting practice;

13. Set up and retain such reserves out of income of a Business as my Trustees
deem proper in conformity with sound business practice for working capital, expenses, taxes,
depreciation, repairs, betterments, general maintenance and other needs of the Business;

14. Take any action necessary to merge or consolidate any Business with any other
business and to sell or liquidate all or any part of a Business or its assets or any interest in any
Business or any stock or securities representing any interest in any Business at such time and price and
upon such terms and conditions as my Trustees shall in their sole and absolute discretion deem
advisable, my Trustees being specifically authorized and empowered to make such sale to any partner,
officer or employee of the Business, to any beneficiary hereunder, to any director, officer or employee
of any Trustee hereunder or to any Trustee hereunder;

15. Settle, compromise, refer to arbitration, abandon or otherwise adjust claims of
or against any Business;

16. Diminish, enlarge or change the scope or nature of any Business; and
17. Exercise any of the rights and powers herein confuted in conjunction with
another or others.

B. In enumerating the above-listed powers, it is my intention to grant to my Trustees
every conceivable power to do every conceivable act with respect to the continuance, management,
sale or liquidation of any Business or interest in any Business which I myself could have exercised
during my lifetime. Accordingly, the naming of any power and failure to name any other power shall
not be construed to be the exclusion of any such other power which my Trustees may deem necessary
to exercise in order to carry out to the fullest extent all activities with respect to the continuance,
management, sale or liquidation of any Business.

C. I am aware that certain risks are inherent in the operation of any business and expect
that decisions will be required of a "businessman's risk" nature. Therefore, notwithstanding the fact
that such risks are of a character which, but for this express authority, would not be considered proper
for trustees to take, I direct that my Trustees shall not be liable for any loss resulting from the
retention and operation of any Business unless such loss shall result directly from any Trustee's bad
faith or willful misconduct. In determining any question of liability for losses, it should be considered
that my Trustees arc engaging in a speculative enterprise at my express request.

D. If any Business operated by my Trustees pursuant to the authorization contained in
this Article shall be unincorporated, then I direct that all liabilities arising therefrom shall be satisfied
-25-
&Oa% 4.0•••• if%
first from the Business itself and second out of trust property. It is my intention that in no event shall
any such liability be enforced against my Trustees personally. If my Trustees shall be held personally
liable, they shall be entitled to indemnity as provided in Paragraph C of Article XX hereof, first from
the Business and second from the trusts hereunder.

E. My Will directs my executors to dispose of the Businesses conducted by Daily News
LP., U.S. News & World Report, Inc., and any affiliates of or successors to those entities within two
years after my death, unless my executors determine that that economic considerations make it
advisable to defer or extend the disposition of any portion or portions of those Businesses. If any
interest in any such Business should hereafter become trust property, my Trustees shall cooperate with
my executors in the disposition of such Business or, if the interest in such Business is separate from
the assets of my estate, my Trustees shall dispose of such business or such interest within two years
after my death, unless my Trustees determine that it is advisable to defer or extend the disposition of
any portion or portions of such Business. It is my further wish that my Trustees shall comply with any
memorandum or other written guidance I shall leave regarding the disposition of those Businesses or
the operation of those Businesses until such time as they are disposed of. Pending the disposition of
any such Business, the foregoing provisions of this Article shall apply, but my Trustees shall not take
any action or exercise any powers with respect to any such Business that would jeopardize or reduce
the value of any estate tax charitable deduction for which any portion of my estate would otherwise
qualify.
Article XIX
Trustees' Compensation

A. Unless such fee is waived, any person serving as a Trustee hereunder shall receive
compensation determined in accordance with the following provisions of this Article except as
otherwise may be provided for by me in a writing signed by me and dated after this restatement of the
Trust Agreement fixing another compensation amount and either signed by such Trustee or delivered
to the person designated to serve as Trustee before his or her acceptance of appointment. Acceptance
of appointment after delivery of such writing shall be deemed acceptance of the terms of
compensation provided for in such writing.

13. Until the administration of my estate is complete and my residuary estate is distributed
pursuant to Article X hereof (excluding any reserve for contingencies), each Trustee serving hereunder
shall receive a total fee of Two Hundred Fifty Thousand ($250,000) Dollars per year, or Two Hundred
-26-
aa •••••.•
Thousand ($200,000) Dollars per year if my estate does not include a Business conducted by Daily
News L.P., U.S. News & World Report, Inc., or any affiliate of or successor to those entities, prorated
for any year in which such Trustee served hereunder for less than 12 months, and reduced by the fee
such Trustee receives or received pursuant to Article TENTH of my Will for also serving as executor
thereunder, provided, however, that the aggregate fees received by such person for serving as executor
of my Will (if applicable) and as Trustee hereunder shall not exceed One Million Two Hundred Fifty
Thousand ($1,250,000) Dollars or One Million ($1,000,000) Dollars, as the case may be. This
Paragraph B shall not apply to the compensation a Trustee may receive for his or her services as a
Trustee of any trust arising under Articles III. IV. XL XIj or XIII (hereinafter referred to as the
"subtrusts'), compensation for which shall instead be governed by Paragraphs C and D of this Article.

C. Persons who are serving as Trustees of a subtrust (excluding Marla if she serves as a
Trustee of a subtrust) shall be entitled to reasonable compensation for their services, taking into
account the size of such subtrust and the nature of the services to be performed, but without regard to
any statutory provisions for trustees' commissions.

D. Any Trustee serving hereunder who is an attorney, and such Trustee's law firm, may
receive reasonable compensation for legal services performed with respect to any trust arising
hereunder in addition to any other compensation such Trustee may be entitled to receive under this
Article.

E. I hope, but do not require, that my Trustees will retain the services of persons who
provided investment management, tax advice, secretarial services, financial services, office
management services, domestic services, child care, transportation services and other services to me
and my children during my lifetime, or other persons to provide similar services if the individuals who
provided such services during my lifetime are not available to serve or arc unwilling to serve on the
terms offered to them by my executors or my Trustees, in order to provide continuity in the
management of my affairs and emotional support to my children. I direct that the costs of retaining
such persons shall be treated as an expense of administering my estate and after the administration of
my estate is complete, to the extent the Trustees of any trust hereunder determine that such services
would continue to be desirable, as an expense of administering such trust, and shall not reduce
compensation payable to such Trustees. During the administration of my estate, I expect that such
costs will be allowed as deductions for federal estate tax purposes but, to the extent that such costs are
not allowed as deductions, I do not wish to reduce the amount passing to charity. For example,
-27-
an ISA. ,  • •••
domestic and child care expenses may be allocated to the amounts passing to the trusts for my
children under Article XI hereof, as my executors shall direct (and as my Trustees shall determine after
the administration of my estate is complete), and expenses of maintaining residences shall be charged
to the person or persons or trust or trusts to whom such residence passes.

F. Any person's acceptance of the office of Trustee shall be deemed to be a consent by
him or her to the provisions of this Article and shall be deemed to be a waiver by him or her of any
and all other compensation and commissions to which he or she might otherwise be entitled for acting
in such capacity, whether such other compensation and commissions are computed on principal or
income, whether for receiving or paying out, and whether statutory or otherwise.
&ticle la
Other Provisions Relating to the Trustees

A. If Joel Klein is serving as a Trustee hereunder and he is employed by any person or
entity engaged in activities that are in competition with any activities that are conducted by any
Business in which my Trustees have an interest, the said Joel Klein shall not participate in any
decisions made by my Trustees that affect such Business. If and so long as the said Joel Klein is
employed by any such competitor, any such decisions shall be made by a majority of the persons
serving as Trustees other than the said Joel Klein.

B. I expect that my estate will include certain partnership or REIT interests or closely
held stock in entities of which my Trustees, either individually or in a fiduciary capacity, may also be
partners, shareholders, officers or directors and that there will be such interests that might become
part of the trust property. I have nevertheless appointed the individuals named herein as Trustees,
knowing that each of them will act in our mutual best interests. Except as provided in Paragraph A of
this Article, I specifically direct that any legal principles regarding self-dealing or conflict of interest
shall not apply to any transactions undertaken by my Trustees with respect to any such partnership or
REIT interest or stock. Any such transaction undertaken by my Trustees in good faith shall be binding
on all concerned.

C. I direct that any person serving as Trustee hereunder be indemnified out of the trust
property to the maximum extent permitted by law from any and all actions, suits, proceedings,
penalties, assessments and judgments, and any and all costs and expenses (including, without
limitation, all legal fees and expenses), of any and every kind or character, asserted against or incurred
by such person by reason of, arising out of or in connection with his or her service as Trustee, except
Mann •Petlf IA
to the extent that such claims arise out of such person's fraud, gross negligence or dealings in bad
faith.

D. Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this Article, no provision in this trust
shall be construed as authorizing my Trustees to engage in any act of self-dealing that would be
subject to tax under Section 4941 of the Code or that would jeopardize the allowability of any estate
tax charitable deduction for which any portion of the trust property or of my estate would otherwise
qualify.
F— It is my intention to fulfill all of my obligations under the Separation Agreement to the
extent that the Separation Agreement is in effect at the time of my death. To this end, the
Disinterested Trustee of any subtrust arising hereunder may amend such subtrust to the minimum
extent necessary to comply with the Separation Agreement provided, however, that no such
amendment shall be made that would prevent a trust that would otherwise qualify as a charitable
remainder annuity trust within the meaning of Section 664(d)(1) of the Code from so qualifying.

F. Notwithstanding anything in this Agreement to the contrary, any Trustee who has an
obligation to support a beneficiary of any trust hereunder shall not participate in any decision regarding
a distribution from such trust to or for the benefit of such beneficiary that would discharge such
Trustee's legal obligation to support such beneficiary. This Paragraph shall not apply to decisions
made by a Trustee to distribute amounts for his or her own health, education, maintenance or support.
Article
Trustees' Accounta

A. My Trustees shall render an accounting of their administration of the trusts hereunder:
1. To me upon my request during my lifetime (and my Trustees shall not have
any duty to account to any person other than me during my lifetime); and

2. From and after my death, annually to each legally competent individual who is
a beneficiary of such trust or the legally appointed guardian, conservator, or similar fiduciary, however
denominated in the jurisdiction, of each beneficiary of such trust who is under a legal disability. For
purposes of the immediately preceding sentence, a "beneficiary" of a given trust means (i) a person to
whom current distributions may be made from that trust, or (n) a person to whom a share of such
trust would be payable if such trust were to terminate on the date of such accounting.

B. The written approval of the person or persons entitled to an accounting (hereinafter
called the "accountees") shall bind all persons, whether or not then living or under a legal disability,
-29-
then or thereafter entitled to any property of the trust accounted for, whether principal or income, and
shall completely release and discharge the Trustees for the acts and proceedings so accounted for. The
failure of any accountee to object to such accounting within six (6) months after the receipt thereof
shall be deemed to be the equivalent of such accountee's written approval.
Article XXIi
Resignation and Appoinunent of Trustees

A. Upon my resignation, disability or death, I appoint my nephews, Eric Gutter and
James Gerder, and Joel Klein of New York City, New York, to serve as Co-Trustees hereunder;
provided that I appoint my nephews, Eric Gentler and James Gerder, as Co-Trustees of each subtrust
hereunder and if either of my said nephews shall fail or cease to serve, I appoint Joel Klein to serve as
substitute or successor Co-Trustee of such subttusts. I direct that following my death there shall
always be at least two Trustees serving each trust hereunder. If fewer than two persons shall be
serving as Trustees, I appoint such one of the following persons, in the order of priority listed, to serve
as substitute or successor: Nicole Seligman, Andrea Robinson Talamo, and Jonathan Talamo. If none
of these persons shall be available to serve, the Trustee then serving (other than Marla) shall appoint a
person to serve as Co-Trustee.

B. To the extent required by the Separation Agreement, as amended and as in effect at
the time of my death, and only to the extent that the subtrust of which my daughter Abigail is the
Beneficiary under ArtjcleX[ hereof is funded to satisfy my obligation under Section 5.F of the
Separation Agreement, I appoint Marla Prather to serve as an additional Co-Trustee of such subtrust
provided that at all times when Marla shall be serving as a Co-Trustee, at least one other individual
Trustee of such subtrust shall serve with Marla who qualifies as a Disinterested Trustee. If only a
portion of such subtrust is required to satisfy my obligation under Section 5.F of the Separation
Agreement, my Trustees shall divide such subtrust into separate trusts, and I appoint Marla as an
additional Co-Trustee of only that separate trust that satisfies such obligation. If at any time no
Disinterested Trustee is serving such subtrust, the vacancy shall be filled by such one of the following
persons who is available to serve: Joel Klein, Nicole Seligman, Andrea Robinson Talamo, and
Jonathan Talamo. If none of these persons is available to serve, the other Trustee(s) shall appoint a
person to serve as a Disinterested Trustee. In addition, Marla shall not be entitled to compensation
for serving as a Co-Trustee.

C. A Beneficiary of a subtrust under Article XI or XIII hereof may become an additional
-30-
•
Co-Trustee of such subtrust at any time after attaining the age of twenty-five (25) years and, at any
time after attaining the age of thirty-five (35) years may remove any other Co-Trustee then serving
such subtrust; provided, however, that Q) such power may not be exercised to remove Marla Prather,
Eric Gerder or James Gerder as a Co-Trustee; and (u) either another person is serving as a Co-Trustee
who is not being removed or another Qualified Co-Trustee is appointed by the Beneficiary to serve
with such Beneficiary.

D. If no successor Trustee is appointed pursuant to the preceding provisions of this
Article, then each person serving as Trustee, other than Marla, may appoint one or more Qualified Co-
Trustees to serve as his or her successor or alternate successor. Any appointment made pursuant to
this Paragraph may be subject to conditions to take effect at a future time, may be revoked before it
takes effect and other appointments made instead; provided, however, that after the qualification of a
successor Trustee all appointments of alternate successors shall lapse.
R If at any time no individual who is a Disinterested Trustee (other than Marla) shall be
serving as a Trustee of any trust hereunder, the individual Trustees then serving may appoint an
individual to serve as a Disinterested Trustee, but, except as provided in Paragraph B hereof, shall not
be required to do so. In addition, the individual Trustees at any time may appoint an individual, bank
or trust company to serve as an additional Trustee of any trust hereunder, whether or not such person
qualifies as a Disinterested Trustee. If more than one individual Trustee shall be serving a trust
hereunder, all appointments of additional Trustees shall be made by unanimous vote of the individual
Trustees. Any Disinterested Trustee or additional Trustee appointed by the Trustees may be removed
by the Trustees who made such appointment if such Trustees are then serving or by such appointing
Trustees' successors, if such Trustees are no longer serving as Trustees of such trust.

F. If at any time fewer than two individuals are sewing as Trustees of a trust hereunder
following my death and no appointment of a successor pursuant to the preceding provisions of this
Article is effective, the vacancy shall be filled by appointment made by a majority of the adult and
legally competent beneficiaries of such trust to whom distributions may be made at such time and the
parents or guardians acting collectively in respect of any such beneficiary who is under a disability. If
no such successor is appointed as aforesaid within three (3) months of any vacancy, I authorize the
Firm Chair of the law firm of Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LISP or its successor to appoint such
successor.

G. The individual(s) sewing from time to time as Trustee of any trust hereunder shall
-31-
ens tow, on
have the right to remove any corporate Trustee, with or without cause, and to replace it with another
corporate Trustee or leave such office vacant; provided, however that the corporate Co-Trustee may
not be removed unless Eric Gertler, James Gertler or a Qualified Co-Trustee is serving or is appointed
to serve as its successor.

H. Each appointment, removal and revocation wider this Article shall be made by a duly
acknowledged instrument delivered to each Trustee then serving, removed or appointed. Any
successor or Co-Trustee shall qualify by a duly acknowledge acceptance of such office delivered to the
person making such appointment

I. Any Trustee may resign at any time without approval by any court The Trustee shall
resign by a duly acknowledged instrument delivered to any other Trustee then serving and to the
persons authorized to appoint a successor Trustee. The instrument of resignation shall specify the
date when the resignation shall take effect, which date (except as the successor or remaining Trustee
shall otherwise consent) shall be at least thirty (30) days after delivery of such instrument.

J. Any individual Trustee shall be deemed to have resigned effective upon the earlier of:
(0 receipt of certifications from two physicians (at least one of whom is the Trustee's regularly
attending physician) that the Trustee, in the opinion of such physicians, is unable to handle his or her
personal financial affairs due to mental or physical infirmity; or (ii) the failure to agree to a medical
examination by two physicians selected by such Trustee and to provide a Valid Medical Information
Authorization to the person requesting it within thirty (30) days of a written request from any other
Trustee, or if none is serving, from any beneficiary who is then eligible to receive distributions of
income or principal fcom such trust

K. Any Trustee who ceases to serve for any reason may nonetheless retain property
sufficient to pay expenses or any other proper charges.
L Following a Trustee's resignation, the Trustee shall have no duty other than to deliver
the trust property to the successor Trustee and to render an accounting if requested by a beneficiary or
successor Trustee.

M. Any separate trusts administered hereunder may have different persons serving as
Trustees.
N. Any person may at any time release any power under this Article, in whole or in part,
by delivery of a written instrument so stipulating to my Trustees.
-32-
dam.% •••••••
Article )0CIII
pf Trustees and Others

A. No Trustee hereunder shall be liable for any act or omission or exercise of judgment
done or made in good faith or for the acts or omissions of any agent selected in good faith. Unless
they are otherwise notified by me in writing, my Trustees shall have no responsibility with respect to
the payment of premiums or any other action requited to keep in force any insurance policy payable to
the Trustees hereunder. My Trustees shall not be required to initiate any legal proceedings for the
purpose of collecting life insurance proceeds or other property to which they may become entitled as
Trustees hereunder unless there are sufficient funds in the trust to cover the expenses of such
proceedings or until they have been indemnified to their reasonable satisfaction.

B. No person or organization dealing with my Trustees shall be responsible for the
application of any property delivered to my Trustees hereunder or for carrying out the provisions of
this instrument
Article 3O1W Miscellaneous Matter;

A. An executed counterpart of each alteration or amendment of this instrument and of
any resignation, removal, appointment or revocation or acceptance of an appointment of a Trustee
shall be kept with or attached to the Trustees' original counterpart hereof. Anyone may rely on a copy
of any such document or of this instrument certified by a notary public to be a true copy thereof as
fully as on the original instruments, and anyone may rely fully upon any statements of fact certified by
anyone who appears from the Trustees' original counterpart or a certified copy thereof to be a
Trustee hereunder.
B.
C.
No bond or other security shall be required of any Trustee hereunder.
The validity, construction and effect of the provisions of this instrument in all respects
shall be governed and regulated according to and by the laws of the State of New York; provided,
however, that the Disinterested Trustee may declare that this instrument shall be governed by the laws
of any other jurisdiction if such Disinterested Trustee determines that a change of governing law will
not impair the validity and enforceability of this Agreement, and die Disinterested Trustee may make
such consequential amendments as may be necessary to ensure that the provisions of this instrument
shall be as valid and effective as they were under the law governing this instrument at the time the
power to change the governing law is exercised.
-33-
de•
D. The original situs of the trust created hereunder shall be the State of New York. The
situs of any trust hereunder may be maintained in any jurisdiction Including outside the United States),
as my Trustees, in the exercise of their sole and absolute discretion, may determine, and thereafter
transferred at any time or times to any jurisdiction selected by my Trustees. Upon such transfer of
situs, such trust may thereafter, at the election of the Disinterested Trustee of said trust, be
administered exclusively under the laws of (and subject, as requited, to the exclusive supervision of the
courts of) the jurisdiction to which it has been transferred. Accordingly, if my Trustees hereunder
elect to change the situs of any such trust, my Trustees are hereby relieved of any requirement of
having to qualify in any other jurisdiction and of any requirement of having to account in any court of
such other jurisdiction.
Article XXV
Definitions
As used in this instrument the words "by right of representation" shall mean, with respect to
the issue of any person, the manner in which such issue would inherit property from such person
under the then applicable intestacy law of New York if such person died at the time the determination
is being made; the words "child", "children", "descendant" and "issue" shall include a legally adopted
child and such adopted child's issue if the adoptee is under the age of nineteen (19) years at the time of
adoption; the words "charitable organization" shall mean any organization, gifts to which at the time in
question qualify for charitable deductions for federal income, gift and estate tax purposes; the word
"beneficiary" means a person eligible to receive distributions from a trust hereunder; the words "the
Code" shall mean the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as the same may be amended, and any reference
to a provision of the Code shall include a reference to any corresponding provision of subsequent law;
the words "death tax" shall mean any state, federal or foreign inheritance, legacy, succession, estate or
like tax but shall not include any tax on a generation-skipping transfer other than a direct skip of which
I am the transferor and which does not occur as a result of a disclaimer by another person; the words
"my executor" shall mean the executor of my Will or any administrator of my estate; the words "my
Trustees" shall mean the initial trustee of this Trust and any successor trustee or trustees of this Trust
and of any separate trusts hereunder; the words "Separation Agreement" shall mean the agreement
that Marla and I entered into dated November 30, 2000, as amended by a letter dated October 7, 2008
that was signed by each of us, and as may be amended from time to time; the words "the Disinterested
Trustee" shall mean a trustee who () is not a beneficiary of a trust hereunder, (n) is not legally
-34
obligated to support a beneficiary of a trust hereunder, (rh) has not disclaimed any property that was
then distributed to a trust hereunder due to such disclaimer, and (iv) was not appointed by a
beneficiary of a trust hereunder unless such trustee is not "related or subordinate" to such beneficiary
(as defined for purposes of Section 672(c) of the Code and Revenue Ruling 95-58); the words "Special
Power of Appointment" shall mean a power exercisable by the holder to appoint the property subject
to such power to or in trust for the descendants of my parents (other than the holder of such power),
the spouses of such descendants, and charitable organizations; the words "Valid Medical Information
Authorization" shall mean a written authorization (satisfying the requirements of die Health Insurance
Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 or, if applicable, any more restrictive state law) necessary or
helpful for a physician or other medical provider to disclose patient information concerning such
individual's ability to handle his or her personal financial affairs due to mental or physical infirmity; the
words "Qualified Co-Trustee" shall mean any one or more of Joel Klein, Nicole Seligman, Andrea
Robinson Talamo, and Jonathan Talamo, or a person who is approved by any one of them or by Eric
Gerder or James Gerder, or a person who is a member of the bar and experienced in trusts and estates
law or a certified public accountant with experience in trust income tax law or a bank or trust company
with at least $500 million of assets under management•, the words "trust property" shall include all
property now or hereafter transferred to my Trustees or to which they may otherwise become entided;
and the words "this instrument", "hereunder" and "herein" shall refer to this entire instrument as the
same may be amended from time to time. Any reference herein to any gender or number shall not,
unless die context otherwise requires, affect the construction hereof and the same shall be
interchangeable with any other gender or number, as the case may be."
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I, the said MORTIMER B. ZUCKERMAN, have hereunto set
my hand and seal this Ft) day of 2014.
Mortirfei B. Zj6kerman
-35-
•••
CITY OF NEW YORK
STATE OF NEW YORK
On this /IL day of  12,  2014, before me, the undersigned, a Notary Public in
and Lot the State of New York, personally appeared MORTIMER B. ZUCKERMAN, personally
known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the individual whose name is
subscribed to the within instrument, and acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his
capacity, and that by his signature on the instrument, the individual executed the instrument.
(Sail4.1 ifyien t
Notary Public
My commission expires: 424,1
LAURIE HURST
NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF NEW YORK
Reputation No. 01I1U6032120
Qualified in Richmond County
Communion Expires February 2.2018
-36-
TRUSTEE'S RECEIPT
The undersigned, as Trustee of the Mortimer B. Zuckerman Management Trust, hereby
acknowledges receipt of the foregoing Amendment and Restatement of said Trust as of the  /0  day
of 2014.
-37-
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Jason Calacanis [tech] All-In Podcast with David Sacks and Chamath Palihapitiya, Uber investor 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01063811 (Jmail)
 [misc] 1201-1300 of 4,285 Apple Address Book entries from one of Epstein's accounts
(approximate date: 2014-08-07)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024363.dmg
(Evidence ID: NYC024363.dmg - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Notes
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Case Data: Contacts (1301-1400 of 4285)
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 1686
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 1675
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (VOIP)
Phone Number (Work Phone)
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
Phone Number (Home Phone)
ID
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Jade
HUANG
200
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First .laebland
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (iPhone
Creation Date 2011-11-17 20:12:12 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:19 (UTC)
ID 1134
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jagland
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 534
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jagland
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Creation Date 2011-11-17 20:12:12 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 1134
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First James
Middle P.
Last McGee
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:13 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC) Date
ID 452
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Stoiy/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First James
Last Henderson
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 1544
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Libraiy/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First James
Last Herrera
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID 4383
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First James
Last O'Malley
ID 90
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First James
Last Bennet
ID 751
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Stoiy/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First James
Middle P.
Last McGee
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 406
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First James
Last Bennet
ID 2638
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First James
Last Henderson
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:31 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC) Date
ID 989
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First James
Last Condren
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:10 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC) Date
ID 355
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Stoty/Desktop/contacts /story I 1 -2 I -2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First James
Middle P.
Last McGee
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 406
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First James
Last S. Meiskin
ID 4947
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First james
Last randi
ID 2862
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First James
Last Atlas
ID 3022
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First James
Last Nuquez
ID 2137
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First James
Last Condren
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
ID 1400
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
jamesbdent
3090
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
Jamie
Ireland
2021
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
Jan
Fesnoux
2846
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
Jan
Fesnoux
287
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
Jane
Hickam
1997
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Jane
Last Hickam
ID 363
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Janusz
Last Banasiak
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
ID 1182
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Janusz
Last Banasiak
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC) Date
ID 442
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Janusz
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 127
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Janusz
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:31 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 998
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Janusz
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 127
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jaron
Last Lanier
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:35 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC) Date
ID 1075
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jaron
Last Lanier
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC)
ID 1399
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Jason
Last Kliot
ID 1203
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Jason
Last Kliot
ID 1533
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jason
Last Calacanis
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:39 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:39 (UTC) Date
ID 1200
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jason
Last Calacanis
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:40 (UTC)
ID 1238
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First jasonwishnow
ID 823
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Jatila
Last Van der veen
ID 327
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Jatila
Last Van der veen
ID 2457
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Jatila
Last Van der veen
ID 763
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First jatilavanderveen
ID 1897
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jay
Last Lefkowitz
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Work)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 71
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jay
Last Lefkowitz
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Email (Home)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:31 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 985
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jay
Last Massar
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 576
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jay
Last Leflcowitz
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 71
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jay
Last Massar
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 576
Contact
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jay
Massar
2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
783
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/ContainersMinata/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Jay Lefkowitz
Email (Email)
ID 1649634
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First jbuizer
ID 102
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 568
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:14 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC) Date
ID 507
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 1670
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 568
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2014-08-07 22:04:31 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
1001
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 1677
ft
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2014-08-07 22:03:59 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC)
5
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
2011-11-21 19:13:00 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC)
1633
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
Luc
Brunel
2014-08-07 22:04:03 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
157
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
Luc
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:11 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
ID 382
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:19 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:20 (UTC)
ID 623
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddrtssBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email 0
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 840
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 906
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:34 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC)
ID 1057
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email 0
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:35 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC)
ID 1080
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number 133648519751 (Home)
Email Q
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:36 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC)
ID 1106
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email 0
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:40 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-0722:04:41 (UTC)
ID 1228
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Home)
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 328
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Middle Luc
Last Brunel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
ID 622
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Home)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
ID 1277
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number (Home)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 19:13:00 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 1635
Contact
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
Luc
Phone Number (Home)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Other)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Home)
Email (Other)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Home)
Phone Number (iPhone
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
1665
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
Luc
2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
1685
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
Luc
2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
1687
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number (iPhone
Phone Number (Home) M
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
ID 1704
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:52:44 (UTC)
ID 203
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Last Luc
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:52:44 (UTC)
ID 328
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean
Middle Luc
Last Brunel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 622
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Other)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Other)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Other)
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
Luc
2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
718
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
Luc
2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
2011-11-17 20:51:49 (UTC)
719
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story I1-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
Luc
2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
736
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story I1-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Jean
Luc
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 741
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Jean
Last Luc Brunel
ID 153
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean Luc
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 22:19:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-09-16 20:13:23 (UTC)
ID 4756
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/D0EBC I B4- I 6FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean Luc
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email 0
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:39 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:41 (UTC)
ID 1153
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean Luc
Phone Number (Home)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 93
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean Luc
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Home)
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:51:49 (UTC)
ID 35
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean Luc
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 760
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean Luc
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 22:19:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 4759
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean-Pierre
Middle L.
Last Oriol
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 1232
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Jean-Pierre
Middle L.
Last Oriol
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:03:59 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 20
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First jeanluc
Last brunet
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 391
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First jeanluc
Last brunel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:14 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC) Date
ID 528
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First jeanluc
Last brunel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Nlodification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 391
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/Story/Library/Containersi Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1649634
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:20 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:24 (UTC) Date
ID 653
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 690
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:14 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC) Date
ID 498
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:24 (UTC)
ID 690
Case Data: Contacts (1201-1300 of 4285) Case Data: Contacts (1401-1500 of 4285)
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                        Geir Frantzen [europe] vice president of Norway Seafoods [tv2.no] 
 Amir Taaki [crypto] bitcoin bro, co-founder of Intersango with Donald Norman (and Brock Pierce?) [axios] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01063740 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2014-08-07 22:04:41)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024363.dmg
(Evidence ID: NYC024363.dmg  - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Notes
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Case Data: Contacts (1001-1100 of 4285)
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/SourcesiD0EBC I B4- I 6FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Francis
2014-08-07 22:04:13 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 491
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Francis
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-07-25 21:39:11 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 5218
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Francis
Last jardine-deuss
Phone Number (VOIP) NULL
Phone Number (Work Phone) NULL
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
Phone Number (Home Phone) NULL
ID 1876
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Frank
Last Garrison
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 555
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Frank
Last McKinney
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:04 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:04 (UTC) Date
ID 193
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Frank
Last McKinney
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 295
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Frank
Last Garrison
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 555
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First frank
Last wilczek
ID 3118
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Frank
Last McKinney
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
ID 295
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First frank
Last accetta
ID 2129
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Frank
Last mosier
ID 2097
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Frank
Last Garrison
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:00 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 108
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
frank
accetta
3206
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-02-12 01:53:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 701
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-12 01:53:29 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:19 (UTC)
701
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2014-08-07 22:04:18 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:20 (UTC)
II) 602
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Fraser
Last Cain
ID 3286
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First fred
Last lunau
ID 1873
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Fred
Last Sellers
ID 1297
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Fred
Last Sellers
ID 1845
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 232
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:13 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC) Date
ID 455
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 232
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Friedhelm
Last and sabina Hildebrand
ID 2629
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First frucht
ID 1833
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First FSF
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC)
ID 744
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC I B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First FSF
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:36 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:36 (UTC) Date
ID 1096
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First FSF
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 744
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC I B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last Cipriani
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:13 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 476
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last Cipriani
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 47
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last Cipriani
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 47
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First G
Last Starkman
ID 2165
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First G7 Taxi Paris(english Line)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 1469
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First G7 Taxi Paris(english Line)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 875
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gabrielle
Last Fitzgerald
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 1424
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gabrielle
Last Fitzgerald
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:03:59 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 7
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First gail
Last gross
ID 2181
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Garcia
ID 2085
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Garcia
ID 2317
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First gary
Last hochman
ID 1701
Contact
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
Skype
gaty
hochman
1793
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
gary
wieland
315
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
gary
wieland
1071
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
Gary
S. Chottiner
2658
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gary
Last Kerney
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 314
Source Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC184-16FF-49AC-
848D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First gary
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:40 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:41 (UTC)
Note Gary
ID 1248
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First gary
Last hochman
ID 1957
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application SupportJAddressBook/Sources/DOEBC184-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gary
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
Note Gary
gary
ID 821
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gary
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 96
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Mac AddressBook
Gary
Rosen
2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:40 (UTC)
ID 1382
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First gary
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Home)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Home)
Creation Date
Modification Date
Note
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2010-12-04 01:04:29 (UTC)
2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
113
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
&an'
2010-12-04 01:04:29 (UTC)
2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
Gary
113
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Gary
Kemey
2014-08-07 22:04:14 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
500
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Gary
Kerney
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Nloditication Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 314
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
Gary
Morgenthaler
2565
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First gary
Email (Email)
ID 1649634
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First Gary
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Home)
Creation Date
Modification Date
Note
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
Gary
gary
1669
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First gary
Last hochman
ID 2241
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gary
Last Rosen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:40 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:41 (UTC) Date
ID 1230
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Garykemey
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 137
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Garykemey
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 1445
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gavin
Last Andresen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:30 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:30 (UTC) Date
Website Profile:http://www.google.com/profiles/117494054859918211010:False (Profile)
ID 968
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gavin
Last Andresen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-03-17 01:15:04 (UTC)
Modification Date 2013-01-28 01:09:46 (UTC)
Website (profile) profile:http://www.google.com/profiles/117494054859918211010:False
ID 4994
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gavin
Last Andresen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
Website (profile) profile:http://wwvv.google.com/profiles/117494054859918211010:False
ID 1510
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gavin
Last Andresen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:18 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:18 (UTC) Date
Website Profile:http://www.google.com/profiles/117494054859918211010:False (Profile)
ID 599
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Geir
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 13
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Geir
Frantzen
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Nloditication Date 2014-08-07 22:04:19 (UTC)
ID 348
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Geir
Frantzen
2014-08-07 22:04:19 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:20 (UTC)
622
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
ID 13
Source Device
Path
SourceType
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Geir
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
First Geir
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:11 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
ID 424
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Stoty/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Geir
Last Frantzen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 348
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gene
Last Marcial
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 441
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gene
Last Marcial
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:31 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC) Date
ID 994
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gene
Last Marcial
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 441
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Genesisl
ID 2513
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First geneva
Last address
ID 54
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First genjix
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC) Date
ID 808
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First genjix
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 1515
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
ID 4979
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First george
Last greenfield
ID 3050
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First george
Last greenfield
ID 1269
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First George
Last Reenstra
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
ID 502
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First george
Last greenfield
ID 3354
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First George
Middle M.
Last Whitesides
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 508
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First George
Middle M.
Last Whitesides
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 508
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story I1-21-2011.abbulAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First George
Last Reenstra
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 502
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First george
Last greenfield
ID 1313
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC I B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First George
Last Reenstra
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:05 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC) Date
ID 208
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First George
Last Soros
ID 1513
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First george
Last smoot
ID 1797
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First George
Middle M.
Last Whitesides
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC) Date
ID 822
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First georgi
ID 2437
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gerald
Last Barton
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 131
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Gerald
Last Fallon
ID 1737
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gerald
Last Barton
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 131
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E856I617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gerald
Last Barton
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:13 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC) Date
ID 456
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Gerard
Last Milbum
ID 307
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
gerry
and barbara hines - england
2750
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
Skype
gerry
and barbara hines - england
82
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
1301
Case Data: Contacts (901-1000 of 4285) Case Data: Contacts (1101-1200 of 4285)
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 MIT Media Lab [academia] once great research institute overtaken by get rich quick schemes under Joi Ito 
                   Techonomy [journalist] tech news outlet publishing pieces about Epstein's philanthropy 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01139627 (Jmail)
 [article] Techonomy (???) article about iCog Labs titled "A Harvard Financier, Jeffrey Epstein, Advances Artificial Intelligence in Ethiopia"
(approximate date: 2014-08-15)
A Harvard Financier, Jeffrey Epstein, Advances Artificial Intelligence in Ethiopia
By <REDACTED>

When it comes to Sub-Saharan Africa, the media tends to focus on war, famine and disease. How
can one not, when there are still such devastating crises throughout Africa, including the
horrendous Ebola epidemic in Liberia. But it's not the entirety of Africa's story by a long shot.
Such is the case for Ethiopia, landlocked between Sudan, Eritrea, Djibouti, Somalia and Kenya
and long eclipsed by an appalling famine and war with Eritrea. A little is popularly known
perhaps about Ethiopia's splendid 12'h century rock churches carved into the ground and caves in
Northwest Lalibela, the plateaued Simian Mountains, the ancient city of Gondar, and of course,
Lucy, its oldest hominid ambassador. But practically nothing is known about the technology
emerging from its capital, Addis Ababa, and absolutely zilch about the flourishing of artificial
intelligence. In fact, the computer science growth statistics for Addis Ababa sweep Silicon
Valley, India and China into circuitry dust.

Nothing was certainly known to an inscrutable New York private wealth manager, Jeffrey
Epstein, one of the largest investors of individual scientists around the world including Stephen
Hawkins, Murray-Gell Mann, Gerard t' Hooft and a host of other Nobel Laureates. Epstein was
also the financial founder of the Program for Evolutionary Dynamics at Harvard University, one
of the first graduate departments to study the mathematics of evolution. A former board member
of Harvard's Mind, Brain and Behavior Committee, Epstein's science foundation became
increasingly involved in the marriage between neuroscience and artificial intelligence, working
closely with Harvard's neuroscience branch, MIT Media Lab and MIT AI scientist Marvin
Minsky. It was an impromptu meeting with computer scientist Jaron Lanier, a former graduate
student of Minsky's and a pioneer in virtual reality technology that introduced the Harvard
investor to the OpenCog foundation in Hong Kong and a soon-to-be extraordinary AI lab in
Addis Ababa, called iCog Labs.

The founders of iCog Labs are Ben Goertzel and Getnet Assefa Gesaw. Goertzel is a magnetic
AI tour de force: as Chief Financial Advisor to iCog Labs, he is the founder of the OpenCog
Foundation in Hong Kong, one of the largest open source AI software providers in the world.
Inspired by Linux, the global software mogul which offers cutting edge open source
programming, Goertzel aspires OpenCog, to become the Linux of AI, offering free resources as a

serious alternative to major tech AI firms. On top of this, Goertzel is Chairman of AI software
companies, Novamente LLC, and Biomind LLC, focusing on bioinformatic data analysis,
Chairman of the Al General Intelligence Society and Vice Chairman of the technology ethics
magazine Humanity +. A prolific author on everything AI, Goertzel is also the Scientific
Advisor to Genescient Corporation, Research Professor in the Fujian Key Lab for Brain-Like
Intelligent Systems at Xiamen University, China, general Chair of the Artificial General
Intelligence conference series, an advisor to the Machine Intelligence Research Institute
(formerly the Singularity Institute) and its former Director of Research.

Getnet Assefa Gezaw is an Ethiopian roboticist, a software engineer and the CEO of iCog Labs.
At the impressive young age of X, he is an accomplished programmer at the Machine
Intelligence Research Institute in San Francisco and Addis Ababa University. Gezaw flies
between San Francisco and Addis Ababa, lecturing to hundreds of followers on robotics, AGI,
self-driving cars, nanotechnology, SLAM mapping the brain and other fantastical pursuits.
Similar to Goertzel, Gezaw is a big advocate of open source programming for the public, to
solidify the AI field and advance independent labs, especially across Africa. Gezaw is also an
advocate of DIY Bio (do it yourself biology), also known as bio-hacking or open source
bioengineering, a growing movement midst maverick biotechs everywhere.

Impressed by his work, Goertzel sat down with the young Ethiopian to discuss an open source
software AI lab in Africa. But what ignited this unusual Harvard, Hong Kong, Ethiopian synapse
was an ambitious intellectual drive to use Al to not just emulate human cognition, but to explore
cognition itself: to layout out the process of thought as much as possible, with complex,
weighted, simultaneous, adaptive, machine learning algorithms and to use those models as road
maps to better understand the brain's mechanism and potential. "It's a bit like building a
massive airplane with no instruction manual," Jeffrey Epstein noted, (whose own plane is piloted
by a svelte ex-girlfriend akin to Goldfinger). "One can only go on one's experiential sense of
what an airplane should be and just keep refining it towards something beyond our imagination."
The cerebral investor, Al globalist and Al bio-hacker also share a philanthropic, democratic,
trickle up ethos about providing advanced research to universities and labs in developing
communities. "Developments like OpenCog and iCog spread knowledge and capability widely
across the world," Goertzel remarked, "counteracting the tendency of wealth, knowledge and
influence to concentrate in particular subpopulations. As such, they seem to play a critical role
in the ongoing development of the human ecosystem."
Jeffrey Epstein added, "The value of emerging markets is not just their natural resources, or
relatively inexpensive labor, but the unknown resource of highly educated graduates, striving to
excel. We should be encouraging these bright students to lay a true foundation for growth." In
practice, Epstein's foundation funds many education and empowerment programs in
impoverished communities including the US Virgin Islands, where he recently financed their
largest STEM science fair recognizing hundreds of students for their work. He is also a big
supporter of numerous charter schools and juvenile offender programs. In 2013, he became a
substantial supporter of NeuroTV, the largest online network devoted to sharing academic
discussions and university lectures on neuroscience to the public. But similar to Goertzel and
Getzaw, Epstein is an outsider, in that his path is entirely self-made, unconventional and
propelled by intellectual audacity. And it is very possibly this lone wolf grit that binds the three
pioneers together.

iCog Labs' seed funding came from Sander Olson, a Maryland blogger at Nat Big Future, a tech
angel investor and one of the forces behind the successful 3D printing Kickstarter. Sander saw
the value in low-cost Al outsourcing and was intrigued by bringing AI software development to
an African country of 90 million people. However it was Epstein's ongoing funding and support
of Goertzel's OpenCog Foundation in Hong Kong that helped solidify a long term edifice for the
Ethiopian lab and direct it to where no brain has gone before.

The original plan for iCog Labs, located in the capital's university district of Sidist Kilo, was to
have it do AI development on OpenCog projects and sustain itself with commercial outsourcing
for Al projects around the world. The lab would also develop software for computational
understanding of African languages (a largely uncharted territory) and African causes. Working
closely with Hong Kong, iCog Labs could soon train its growing staff and by early 2014 several
iCog programmers shifted to the OpenCog team in Hong Kong.

While the vast majority of African software programming focuses on everyday issues like Web
development, database administration and systems integration, iCog Labs is the only firm in
Ethiopia focusing on `strong artificial intelligence' including cognitive and mobile robotics,
bioinformatics, machine learning based data analysis, computational linguistics, computer vision
and cognitive architectures. More specifically, their projects include, constructing mobile robots
enabled with SLAM mapping (software that constructs a map of an unknown environment based
on a machine's current experiences in its physical environment), navigation ability and vision
processing, deep learning algorithms for vision processing and object recognition, machine
learning algorithms to predict trends in global consumption of entertainment media and
automated systems to understand the English language.

On the commercial front, iCogs' is already self-supporting, with an impressive clientele spanning
five continents and in such areas as natural language user interfacing for Web apps, humanoid
robotics (for Hanson Robotics, makers of the Robot Einstein and other famously realistic
humanoid robots), genomics of longevity, accounting automation and educational gaming. Who
are some other customers? Despite this growing rolodex however, iCogs Lab continues to
provide open-source programming and collaboration with Ethiopian and African governments,
schools and universities such as the Addis Ababa Institute of Science and Technology.
While iCogs Lab is already looking to expand to a second branch in Hawassa, a smaller city a
few hours from the capital, the road to the Al frontier was far from obvious for the little-lab-that-
could. When Goertzel first met the acutely smart programmers in Addis, none of them knew that
much about AI, nor the modern, agile software development process or use of open source tools
like Github—so a lot of training was required. Day to day issues typical of developing countries,
were also problematic such as poor roads, shoddy electrical, cell tower and wifi systems,
laborious and expensive tariff policies and other tribulations that are often taken for granted. But
none of these hurdles have been insurmountable for the resolute lab.

The climate for Al development in Ethiopia is also ripe. By now, South Africa, Kenya and
Nigeria all have burgeoning software startup ecosystems. IBM recently put Watson
supercomputers in Nairobi, Lagos and Capetown and while Ethiopia's software industry is less
mature, it is rapidly expanding. Ethiopia is now the third fastest growing country in the world,
and the fastest growing African nation. There are currently two dozen small software outsourcing
firms in Addis Ababa, serving a wide array of customers across Africa and the world. Their
software market has doubled in the past three years and the Ministry of Trade and Industry
affirms more than 700 licensed companies in computer technology and 95 software and
computer networking businesses. To back this up, an astounding 95% of its youth graduate from
primary school, 60-70% from high school, and there are almost 100 universities across Ethiopia.
And as the world slowly becomes more developed from the grass roots up, versus haphazardly
from the top down, the Harvard, Hong Kong, Ethiopian synergy offers an inspiring model
especially in the idealistic, deeply intellectual world of artificial intelligence. The effort is
invigorating thousands of African students to participate in an exciting global exploration,
creating communal prosperity and setting the stage for the next frontier: a journey to the center
of the brain.
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Darrell Issa [republican] congressman described as a Russian agent by other Republicans, helped form SpaceX 
                                                                         WEF [lobbyist] World Economic Forum 
                                                                  Hanna Traff [tech] employee (?) of Spotify 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01217787 (Jmail)
 [reputation] Skype log of conversation with Hanna Traff, Tyler Shears
(inferred timestamp: 2014-08-22 20:12:59)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024371.dmg
(Evidence ID: NYC024371.dmg - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case
Data:
Messages
(2401-
2500 of
7780)
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 11:08:15 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears (
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 11:08:15 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears (
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 11:13:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation
Participants:
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 11:13:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation
Participants:
), Self (jeevacation )
), Self (jeevacation )
), Self (jeevacation )
), Self (jeevacation )
today?
today?
will know tomorw
will know tomorw
Skype
2014-08-20 12:53:08 (11TC) (21
Sender:
Participants:
Ok hope soon
), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
2014-08-20 12:53:08 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Ok hope soon
Skype
2014-08-20 13:05:13 (UTC 1
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Yes - couple hours ok?
Skype
2014-08-20 13:05:13 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Yes - couple hours ok?
Skype
2014-08-20 13:35:20 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Let me Know tomorrow
Skype
2014-08-20 13:35:20 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Let me Know tomorrow
Skype
2014-08-20 13:35:26 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
(Miss you)
Skype
2014-08-20 13:35:26 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
(Miss you)
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 13:43:23 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: rob.databanq ( rob.databanq ), martin.gustafssonl ( martin.gustafssonl ), merrittlawoffice (
merrittlawoffice ), dexterbayer ( dexterbayer ), anthonyaires ( anthonyaires ), nathaniel.a.rossique (
nathaniel.a.rossique ), smallbiztrends ( smallbiztrends ), wnstrohl ( wnstrohl ), waseemukhan ( waseemukhan ),
stefanpololopez ( stefanpololopez ), jonnyscottie (jonnyscottie ), ravikumarkamu ( ravikumarkamu ),
marc.hardgrove ( marc.hardgrove ), facebook:livzuk ( facebook:livzuk ), bronwyn_k ( bronwyn_k ), bill.mobley
( bill.mobley ), tonysamios ( tonysamios ), sterlingfx ( sterlingfx ), delebelly ( delebelly ), superdeija (
superdeija ), abrown.at.roughfalls.com ( abrown.at.roughfalls.com ), robjames73 ( robjames73), mcelyea.jason
( mcelyea.jason ), orangemanproductions ( orangemanproductions ), peter.stevanovic ( peter.stevanovic ),
marceladevivo ( marceladevivo ), easyboyweb ( easyboyweb ), mayainverse ( mayainverse ), clayonearth (
clayonearth ), suzzicks ( suzzicks ), jihoyl ( jihoy 1 ), mabbas512 ( mabbas512 ), will.issa 1 ( will.issal ),
tracymbacon ( tracymbacon ), kentuckyfriedmonkey ( kentuckyfriedmonkey ), smsandman ( smsandman ),
karloskar.olsson ( karloskar.olsson ), daniel.sosa9 ( daniel.sosa9 ), andy_r_boyd ( andy_r_boyd ), Self (
jeevacation )
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 13:43:23 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: rob.databanq ( rob.databanq ), martin.gustafssonl ( martin.gustafssonl ), merrittlawoffice (
merrittlawoffice ), dexterbayer ( dexterbayer ), anthonyaires ( anthonyaires ), nathaniel.a.rossique (
nathaniel.a.rossique ), smallbiztrends ( smallbiztrends ), wnstrohl ( wnstrohl ), waseemukhan ( waseemukhan ),
stefanpololopez ( stefanpololopez ), jonnyscottie (jonnyscottie ), ravikumarkamu ( ravikumarkamu ),
marc.hardgrove ( marc.hardgrove ), facebook:livzuk ( facebook:livzuk ), bronwyn_k ( bronwyn_k ), bill.mobley
( bill.mobley ), tonysamios ( tonysamios ), sterlingfx ( sterlingfx ), delebelly ( delebelly ), superdeija (
superdeija ), abrown.at.roughfalls.com ( abrown.at.roughfalls.com ), robjames73 ( robjames73 ), mcelyea.jason
( mcelyea.jason ), orangemanproductions ( orangemanproductions ), peter.stevanovic ( peter.stevanovic ),
marceladevivo ( marceladevivo ), easyboyweb ( easyboyweb ), mayainverse ( mayainverse ), clayonearth (
clayonearth ), suzzicks ( suzzicks ), jihoyl ( jihoy 1 ), mabbas512 ( mabbas512), will.issa 1 ( will.issal ),
tracymbacon ( tracymbacon ), kentuckyfriedmonkey ( kentuckyfriedmonkey ), smsandman ( smsandman ),
karloskar.olsson ( karloskar.olsson ), daniel.sosa9 ( daniel.sosa9 ), andy_r_boyd ( andy_r_boyd ), Self (
jeevacation )
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 13:48:08 (UM)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Hanna Traff ( Self ( jeevacation )
are you still in ny?
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 13:48:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Hanna Taff ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
are you still in ny?
Skype
2014-08-20 13:53:09 UTC 2
Sender: Hanna Traff (
Participants: Hanna Traff ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Back in Stockholm. Started at Spotify last week here.
Skype
2014-08-20 13:53:09 UTC 1
Sender: Hanna Traff (
Participants: Hanna Taff ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Back in Stockholm. Started at Spotify last week here.
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 14:00:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Hanna Traff ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
sounds like fun
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 14:00:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Hanna Taff ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
sounds like fun
Skype
2014-08-20 14:07:52 UTC 1
Sender: Hanna Traff (
Participants: Hanna Taff ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
It is, definitely a very inspiring environment. I am very happy!
Skype
2014-08-20 14:07:52 UTC 2
Sender: Hanna Traff (
Participants: Hanna Traff ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
It is, definitely a very inspiring environment. I am very happy!
Skype
2014-08-20 14:11:09 C 1
Sender: Hanna Traff (
Participants: Hanna Traff ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
I hope you are doing well and that you have found two great additional assistants.
Skype
2014-08-20 14:11:09 C 2
Sender: Hanna Traff (
Participants: Hanna Taff ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
I hope you are doing well and that you have found two great additional assistants.
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 14:43:39 (UTC)
Sender: Self i ij vacatiosi .
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
time?
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 14:43:39 (UTC)
Sender: Self jeev(..l acati. i.
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
time?
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 15:42:00 (UTC)
Sender: Self jeevacation
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
are you there?
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 15:42:00 (UTC)
Sender: Self ij vacatimm il
Participants: ME ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
are you there?
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 15:45:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
one way car rental
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 15:45:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self umacatiosl
Participants: MIE ( ), Self (jeevacation )
one way car rental
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 15:45:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self ijmacatiosi o
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
thrifty
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 15:45:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ME ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
thrifty
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 15:51:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self i'eevacatitmL
Participants: ME ( MEM ), Self ( jeevacation )
hertz
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 15:51:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self i ij vacatiotiL
Participants: ME ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
hertz
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 15:51:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
hertz one way rental.
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 15:51:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self ('eev..l aciti,
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 15:55:06 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 15:55:06 (UTC)
Sender: Self i ij vacatiemil
Participants: ME ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
2014-08-20 16:02:01 UTC) [2]
Sender:
Participants: ( h Self (jeevacation )
hertz one way rental.
Phone: hertz
Phone: hertz
Thank u so so so much for your help u r really amazing <ss type="kiss">:*</ss> God
Bless u <ss type="kiss">:*</ss> I wish u super great day <ss type="heart">(heart)</ss>
Skype
2014-08-20 16:02:01 UTC) [1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Thank u so so so much for your help u r really amazing <ss type="kiss">:*</ss> God
Bless u <ss type="kiss">:*</ss> I wish u super great day <ss type="heart">(heart)</ss>
Skype
2014-08-20 1626:40 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
i will try you 3PM EST
Skype
2014-08-20 16:26:40 (UTC) [1]
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shear9a. ), Self ( jeevacation )
i will try you 3PM EST
Skype
2014-08-20 17:03:11 C) [2]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Hi <55 type="wink">;)</ss> yes I did thank u so so so much <ss type="heart">(heart)
</ss> how r u?
Skype
2014-08-20 17:03:11 C) [1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Hi <ss type="wink">;)</ss> yes I did thank u so so so much css type="heart">(heart)
</ss> how r u?
Skype
2014-08-20 19:10:09 (UTC 1
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
9
Skype
2014-08-20 19:10:09 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
9
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 21:57:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self ij ttacatiosi o
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
did you call , did it work out
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 21:57:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self isi tacati t
Participants: ME ( MEM ), Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
[2] 2014-08-20 21:59:40 (UTC)
Sender: Self ('eev..l aciti.
Participants: ME ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
[1] 2014-08-20 21:59:40 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eev(..l acatioimi ,
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
2014-08-21 00:43:19 UTC 2
Sender: Daniel Siad (
Participants: Daniel Siad ( ), Self (jeevacation )
JEFFREY SHE DOWN WATING
Skype
2014-08-21 00:43:19 UTC 1
Sender: Daniel Siad (
Participants: Daniel Siad ( ), Self (jeevacation )
JEFFREY SHE DOWN WATING
Skype
2014-08-21 00:43:49 UTC 2
Sender: Daniel Siad (
Participants: Daniel Siad ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
NOTBODY TO OPEN FOR HER
Skype
2014-08-21 00:43:49 UTC 1
Sender: Daniel Siad (
Participants: Daniel Siad ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
NOTBODY TO OPEN FOR HER
did you call , did it work out
cute
cute
Skype
2014-08-21 00:44:04 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Daniel Siad (
Participants: Daniel Siac.. ), Self (jeevacation )
YOU NOT ANSWERING THE PHONE
Skype
2014-08-21 00:44:04 UTC 1
Sender: Daniel Siad (
Participants: Daniel Siad ( ), Self (jeevacation )
YOU NOT ANSWERING THE PHONE
Skype
[1] 2014-08-21 02:10:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears (
Skype
[2] 2014-08-21 02:10:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears (
), Self (jeevacation )
), Self (jeevacation )
Skype
2014-08-21 02:10:55 (UTC 1
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
ok
Skype
2014-08-21 02:10:55 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
ok
Skype
[1] 2014-08-21 09:09:22 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( ), Self (jeevacation )
friday. ok
friday. ok
where are you?
Skype
[2] 2014-08-21 09:09:22 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( ), Self (jeevacation )
where are you?
Skype
2014-08-21 14:47:16 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Hey J...
Skype
2014-08-21 14:47:16 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
Hey J
Skype
[2] 2014-08-21 19:18:56 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Here
Skype
[1] 2014-08-21 19:18:56 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Here
Skype
2014-08-21 19:21:21 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Yes
Skype
2014-08-21 19:21:21 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Yes
Skype
2014-08-21 20:36:42 UTC 2]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeevacation )
Good to see you
Skype
2014-08-21 20:36:42 UTC 1]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
Good to see you
Skype
[2] 2014-08-21 20:38:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self Umaciii.
Participants: MIE ( ), Self (jeevacation )
everything ok?
Skype
[1] 2014-08-21 20:38:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self Lima,.
Participants: ME ( ), Self (jeevacation )
everything ok?
Skype
2014-08-22 00:04:48 (UTC 1
Sender: Lawrence Krauss (
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
australia.. back here til sept 8.. then china to world economic forum for 3 days. then back
in the us.
Skype
2014-08-22 00:04:48 (UTC 2
Sender: Lawrence Krauss (
Participants: Lawrence Krauss ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
australia.. back here til sept 8.. then china to world economic forum for 3 days, then back
in the us.
Skype
2014-08-22 14:22:01 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
Hi dear Jeffrey how are you?Do you still plan to come to paris?miss you so much!kiss
Skype
2014-08-22 14:22:01 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
Hi dear Jeffrey how are you?Do you still plan to come to paris?miss you so much!kiss
Skype
[2] 2014-08-22 14:35:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
soon
Skype
[1] 2014-08-22 14:35:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
soon
Skype
[1] 2014-08-22 14:35:17 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
soon miss you
Skype
[2] 2014-08-22 14:35:17 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eevacation
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
soon miss you
Skype
2014-08-22 14:38:38 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
2014-08-22 14:38:38 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeevacation )
Skype
2014-08-22 19:36:32 UTC 1
Sender: Daniel Siad (
Participants: Daniel Siad ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Please try when you have time to watch this video I am writing one my theses In social
anthropology book a bout the evolution technolo ies dan er to human kind the is this
video of YouTube <a href="
v=aJC1ATaiC6w" a>
Skype
2014-08-22 19:36:32 UTC 2
Sender: Daniel Siad (
Participants: Daniel Siad ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Please try when you have time to watch this video I am writing one my theses In social
anthropology book a bout the evolution technolo ies dan er to human kind the is this
video of YouTube <a href="
v=aJC1ATaiC6w" a>
Skype
2014-08-22 20:04:40 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
heading into team meeting
Skype
2014-08-22 20:04:40 (UTC 1
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
heading into team meeting
Skype
[2] 2014-08-22 20:11:26 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
now good
Skype
[1] 2014-08-22 20:11:26 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
now good
Skype
2014-08-22 20:11:37 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
cant meeting starting now
Skype
2014-08-22 20:11:37 (UTC I
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
cant meeting starting now
Skype
2014-08-22 20:11:40 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
1 hour ?
Skype
2014-08-22 20:11:40 (UTC I
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
1 hour ?
Skype
2014-08-22 20:11:44 (UTC I
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
maybe 45 min ?
Skype
2014-08-22 20:11:44 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
maybe 45 min ?
Skype
[1] 2014-08-22 20:12:31 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
try
Skype
[2] 2014-08-22 20:12:31 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeevacation )
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
try
Skype
2014-08-22 20:12:59 (UTC 1
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
k
Skype
2014-08-22 20:12:59 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
k
Skype
2014-08-22 2230:48 (UTC 1
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self (jeevacation )
Ran over. Mother in town having dinner. Free after or all weekend
Skype
2014-08-22 2230:48 (UTC 2
Sender: Tyler Shears (
Participants: Tyler Shears ( ), Self ( jeevacation )
Ran over. Mother in town having dinner. Free after or all weekend
Notes
[1] Source Device NYCO24371.dmg/Macintosh HD
[1] Source File /Users/Jeffrey/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
[2] Source Device /Macintosh HD
[2] Source File /Users/Jeffrey/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Case Data: Messages (2301-2400 of 7780) Case Data: Messages (2501-2600 of 7780)
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Blockstream [crypto] early crypto firm co-founded by Adam Back and Austin Hill 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00584696 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Epstein crypto fund Kyara Investment III LLC operating agreement
(inferred date: 2014-09-04)
KYARA INVESTMENTS III LLC
OPERATING AGREEMENT
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT is made as of the f 1 day of September, 2014
by and among Kyara Investments III LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the
"Company"), those persons who execute this Agreement as of the date hereof, and
those other persons, if any, who from time to time become parties to or are otherwise
bound by this Agreement as provided herein.
RECITALS

A. On September 4, 2014, the Company was formed by the Members by the
filing of the Certificate of Formation with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware.

B. The Members now desire to enter into this Agreement in order to set forth
the respective rights and obligations of the Members in regard to the ownership,
management and governance of the Company.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the premises and other valuable
consideration, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the Members and the
Company agree as follows:
ARTICLE 1
DEFINED TERMS
1.1 "Act" means the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act, as amended
from time to time.
1.2 "Adiusted Capital Account Balance" means, with respect to each Member,
such Member's Capital Account balance maintained in accordance with this Agreement,
as of the end of the relevant fiscal year of the Company, after giving effect to the
following adjustments:

(a) Credit to such Capital Account of such Members share of minimum
gain determined in accordance with Regulations Sections 1.704-2(g)(1) and
1.704-2(i)(5); and

(b) Debit to such Capital Account of the items described in Regulations

Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), (5) and (6).
The foregoing definition of "Adjusted Capital Account Balance" is intended to comply
with the provisions of Regulations Sections 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d) and 1.704-2, and shall
be interpreted consistently therewith.
1.3 "Affiliate" means, with respect to any Person, any other Person that,
directly or indirectly, controls, is under common control with, or is controlled by the
former Person. For purposes of this definition, "control" (including, with correlative
meaning, the terms "controlled by" and "under common control with"), as used with
respect to any Person, shall mean the possession, directly or indirectly, of the power to
direct and cause the direction of the management and policies of such Person, whether
through the ownership of voting securities, by contract or otherwise.
1.4 "Agreement" means this Operating Agreement of the Company, and all
amendments hereto.
1.5 "Approved Sale" has the meaning set forth in Section 9.2(a).
1.6 "Capital Account" means, with respect to each Member, the Capital
Account maintained for such Member in accordance with the following provisions:

(a) To each Member's Capital Account there shall be credited such
Member's Capital Contributions, such Member's distributive share of Profits and
the amount of any Company liabilities assumed by such Member or which are
secured by any property distributed to such Member by the Company.

(b) To each Member's Capital Account there shall be debited the
amount of cash and the Gross Asset Value of any property distributed to such
Member pursuant to any provision of this Agreement, and such Member's
distributive share of Losses.

(c) In the event all or a portion of a Member's Membership Interests
are transferred in accordance with the terms of this Agreement, the transferee
shall succeed to the Capital Account of the transferor to the extent it relates to
the transferred Membership Interests.
(d) In determining the amount of any liability for purposes of the
foregoing subparagraph (a), there shall be taken into account Code

Section 752(c) and any other applicable provisions of the Code and Regulations.
The foregoing provisions and the other provisions of this Agreement relating to
the maintenance of Capital Accounts are intended to comply with Regulations
Sections 1.704-1(b) and 1.704-2, and shall be interpreted and applied in a manner
consistent with such Regulations. In the event the Manager shall reasonably determine
that it is prudent to modify the manner in which the Capital Accounts, or any debits or
credits thereto, are computed in order to comply with such Regulations, the Manager,
with the Consent of the Members, may make such modification; provided that such
modification is not likely to have a material effect on the amount distributed to any
Member pursuant to Article 10 hereof upon the liquidation of the Company.
1.7 "Capital Contributions" means the aggregate amount of cash and Gross
Asset Value of property (less the amount of indebtedness, if any, of such Member which
is assumed by the Company and/or the amount of indebtedness, if any, to which such
property is subject, as of the date of contribution, without regard to the provisions of
Code Section 7701(g)) contributed by a Member to the capital of the Company.
2
1.8 "Cash Flow" means, for any period, the amount by which (a) the gross
cash receipts of the Company from any source for such period (including, but not limited
to, Capital Contributions, loans, distributions received by the Company in respect of any
stock, partnership interest or other equity interest owned by the Company, and
proceeds from the sale, financing, refinancing or other disposition of all or any portion of
the Company property), exceed (b) the sum of (i) the aggregate cash disbursements for
such period (including, but not limited to, Company administrative costs,
reimbursements paid to the Manager in respect of his or her day-to-day management
activities hereunder, principal and interest payable on Company debt and capital
expenditures), and (ii) amounts previously set aside as reserves as determined by the
Manager in his or her discretion.
1.9 "Certificate" means the Certificate of Formation of the Company, as
amended from time to time, as filed in accordance with the Act.
1.10 "Code" means the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (or any
corresponding provision of succeeding law).
1.11 "Company" means the limited liability company herein formed and known
as Kyara Investments III LLC, as said Company may from time to time be constituted.
1.12 "Consent" means the prior written consent or approval of a Person or
Persons to do the act or thing for which the consent or approval is solicited, or the act of
granting such consent or approval as the context may require.
1.13 "Depreciation" means, for each fiscal year or other period, an amount
equal to the depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deduction allowable with
respect to an asset for such year or other period, except that if the Gross Asset Value of
an asset differs from its adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes at the beginning
of such year or other period, Depreciation shall be an amount which bears the same
ratio to such beginning Gross Asset Value as the federal income tax depreciation,
amortization or other cost recovery deduction for such year or other period bears to
such beginning adjusted tax basis; provided, however, that if the federal income tax
depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deduction from such year or other
period is zero, Depreciation shall be determined with reference to such beginning Gross
Asset Value using any reasonable method selected by the Manager with the Consent of
the Members.
1.14 "Gross Asset Value" means, with respect to any asset, the asset's
adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes, except as follows:

(a) The initial Gross Asset Value of any asset contributed by a Member
to the Company shall be the gross fair market value of such asset, as determined
by the contributing Member and the Manager;

(b) The Gross Asset Values of all Company assets shall be adjusted to
equal their respective gross fair market values, as reasonably determined by the
Members, as of the following times: (i) the acquisition of additional Membership
3
Interests in the Company by any new or existing Member in exchange for more
than a de minimis capital contribution; (ii) the distribution by the Company to a
Member of more than a de minimis amount of Company assets, including money,
as consideration for an interest in the Company; and (iii) the liquidation of the
Company within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(g);
provided, however, that adjustments pursuant to the preceding clauses (i) and (ii)
shall be made only if the Members reasonably determine that such adjustments
are necessary or appropriate to reflect the relative economic interests of the
Members in the Company;

(c) The Gross Asset Value of any Company asset distributed to any
Member shall be the gross fair market value of such asset on the date of
distribution; and
(d) The Gross Asset Values of Company assets shall be increased (or
decreased) to reflect any adjustments to the adjusted basis of such assets
pursuant to Code Section 734(b) or Code Section 743(b), but only to the extent
that such adjustments are taken into account in determining Capital Accounts
pursuant to Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(m) and the definition of "Capital
Account" herein.
If the Gross Asset Value of an asset has been determined or adjusted pursuant to any
of the foregoing subparagraphs (a), (b) or (d) of this Section, such Gross Asset Value
shall thereafter be adjusted by the Depreciation taken into account with respect to such
asset for purposes of computing Profits and Losses.
1.15 "Investment" has the meaning set forth in Section 2.2.
1.16 "Manager" means the Person designated or appointed as Manager
pursuant to this Agreement, and any other Person who becomes a successor or
additional Manager of the Company pursuant to this Agreement.
1.17 "Member" means any Person who is designated as a Member on Exhibit A
to this Agreement at the time of reference thereto and who is acting in such Person's
capacity as a Member of the Company, and any other Persons who from time to time
become parties to or are otherwise bound by this Agreement as Members.
1.18 "Membership Interest" means an ownership interest of a Member in the
Company at any particular time, including the right of such Member to any and all
benefits to which a Member may be entitled pursuant to this Agreement and under the
Act, together with all obligations of such Member to comply with the terms and
provisions of this Agreement and the Act. Membership Interests are owned by
Members as set forth in Exhibit A to this Agreement, as amended from time to time.
1.19 "Notice" means a writing, containing the information required by this
Agreement to be communicated to any Person, and given or delivered in accordance
with the requirements of this Agreement.
4
1.20 "Person" means any individual, partnership, limited liability company,
corporation, trust, estate or other entity.
1.21 "Profits" and "Losses" means, for each fiscal year or other period, an
amount equal to the Company's taxable income or loss for such year or period,
determined in accordance with Code Section 703(a) (for this purpose, all items of
income, gain, loss or deduction required to be stated separately pursuant to Code

Section 703(a)(1) shall be included in taxable income or loss), with the following
adjustments:

(a) Any income of the Company that is exempt from federal income tax
and not otherwise taken into account in computing Profits or Losses pursuant to
this definition shall be added to such taxable income or loss;

(b) Any expenditures of the Company described in Code

Section 705(a)(2)(B), or treated as Code Section 705(a)(2)(B) expenditures
pursuant to Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(i), and not otherwise taken into
account in computing Profits or Losses pursuant to this definition shall be
subtracted from such taxable income or loss;

(c) In the event the Gross Asset Value of any Company asset is
adjusted pursuant to subparagraph (b) or (d) of Section 1.14 hereof, the amount
of such adjustment shall be taken into account as gain or loss from the
disposition of such asset for purposes of computing Profits or Losses;

(d) Gain or loss resulting from any disposition of property with respect
to which gain or loss is recognized for federal income tax purposes shall be
computed by reference to the Gross Asset Value of the property disposed of
notwithstanding that the adjusted tax basis of such property differs from its Gross
Asset Value; and
(e) Depreciation shall be taken into account for such fiscal year or
other period in computing such taxable income or loss, in lieu of the depreciation,
amortization and other cost recovery deductions that otherwise may be taken into
account in the absence of Section 1.13.
1.22 "Regulations" means the United States Treasury Regulations, as
amended from time to time.
1.23 "Sale of the Company" means the sale of the Company to any Person or
Persons on an arms-length basis, pursuant to which such Person or Persons acquire (i)
a majority of the Membership Interests in the Company (whether by sale of Membership
Interests or merger or otherwise), or (ii) all or substantially all of the Company's assets,
determined on a consolidated basis.
1.24 "Transfer" has the meaning set forth in Section 9.1.
1.25 "Unreturned Capital Contributions" means, with respect to any Member,
5
the difference between (a) the Capital Contributions made by such Member, less (b) the
aggregate amount of distributions made to such Member pursuant to Section 4.6(a).
ARTICLE 2
THE COMPANY
2.1 Formation and Name. The Company has been formed as a limited liability
company pursuant to the provisions of the Act. The Company was formed with the
name "Kyara Investments III LLC"; provided that the Company may hereafter adopt
such other name or names as the Manager may from time to time select.
2.2 Purpose. The Company has been organized to engage in the ownership
and management of an equity investment in Blockstream Corporation, a corporation
incorporated under the laws of Canada (the "Investment") and, with the Consent of the
Members, in any and all other lawful businesses or activities which a limited liability
company may carry on under the Act and the laws of any other jurisdiction in which the
Company is so engaged.
2.3 Registered Agent. The Company's registered agent shall be the Person
designated by the Manager from time to time to serve in that capacity in accordance
with the terms of the Act.
2.4 Qualification in Additional Jurisdictions. The Manager is authorized, with
the Consent of the Members, to qualify the Company to do business in any jurisdiction
in which such qualification is deemed by the Manager as necessary or desirable in
carrying out the Company's business, and pursuant thereto, to appoint a registered
agent and to establish a registered office in such jurisdiction, and to cause the Company
to operate in such jurisdiction under another name selected by the Manager, in
compliance with the assumed name statute of such jurisdiction, if the Company is not
allowed under the laws of such jurisdiction to operate under its legal name.
ARTICLE 3
MEMBERSHIP INTERESTS; CONTRIBUTIONS BY THE MEMBERS
3.1 Membership Interests. The Company shall issue one type of ownership
interest, with such rights, preferences and obligations as set forth in this Agreement.
Holders of Membership Interests shall be entitled to one vote per Membership Interest
held; provided that such holder is also a Member. Notwithstanding anything to the
contrary contained in this Agreement, no Person shall be entitled to vote with respect to
any Membership Interests unless such person is a Member.
3.2 Initial Capital of the Company. On or prior to the date hereof, each of the
Members (or the Person from whom such Member acquired, directly or indirectly, its, his
or her Membership Interests) has made an initial Capital Contribution to the Company
as provided on Exhibit A attached hereto. In exchange therefor, each Member (or the
Person from whom such Member acquired, directly or indirectly, its, his or her
6
Membership Interests) has received that number of Membership Interests set forth on
such Exhibit A.
3.3 No Additional Capital Contributions. No Member shall be required to
make any additional Capital Contribution to the Company.
3.4 Withdrawal. Except as otherwise provided in Article 9 of this Agreement,
no Member shall be entitled to withdraw or resign from the Company, prior to its
dissolution and winding up, without first obtaining the Consent of the Members.
3.5 Additional Membership Interests. No additional Membership Interests
shall be issued by the Company without the Consent of the Members.
ARTICLE 4
CAPITAL ACCOUNTS; PROFITS AND LOSSES; DISTRIBUTIONS
4.1 Capital Accounts. The Company shall establish and maintain a Capital
Account for each Member.
4.2 Allocation of Profits and Losses.

(a) Profits of the Company shall be allocated among the Members as
follows:
(i) First, to each Member pro rata and in proportion to the
cumulative Losses, if any, allocated to such Member pursuant to

Section 4.2(b)(ii) hereof until the cumulative Profits allocated to such
Member under this Section 4.2(a)(i) equals the cumulative Losses
allocated to such Member under Section 4.2(b)(i) hereof; and

(ii) Then, the balance, if any, to the Members in accordance
with their respective Membership Interests.
(b) Losses of the Company shall be allocated to the Members as
follows:

(i) First, to the Members in accordance with their respective
Membership Interests; provided, however, that no Member shall be
allocated Losses in excess of its, his or her Adjusted Capital Account
Balance, determined immediately prior to the allocation provided for in this

Section 4.2(b)(i); and
(ii) Then, to the extent any Losses allocated to a Member
pursuant to Section 4.2(b)(i) would, but for the proviso contained therein,
exceed a Member's Adjusted Capital Account Balance, such Losses shall
be allocated first to the other Members in proportion to, and to the extent
of, their respective Adjusted Capital Account Balances, and then to any
7
Member guaranteeing debt of the Company, making loans to the
Company or otherwise having liability for Company debt, in proportion to
the debt guaranteed, the loans made or the amount of such liability.
4.3 Reallocation by Manager. The allocation of Profits and Losses in

Section 4.2 is intended to have substantial economic effect within the meaning of
Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2) or be in accordance with the Members' interests in
the Company within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(4). If subsequent
events (including, but not limited to, nonrecourse borrowing by the Company or a loan
by a Member to the Company) cause, in the reasonable opinion of the Manager, the

Section 4.2 allocations to have neither substantial economic effect nor be in accordance
with the Members' interests in the Company, the Manager may (a) allocate the income,
gain, loss, deduction and credit of the Company so that such allocations are in
accordance with the Members' Membership Interests; or (b) make such other
modifications to this Agreement (including, but not limited to, the addition of minimum
gain chargeback, qualified income offset and other special allocation provisions
specified in Regulations Sections 1.704-2 or 1.704-1(b)) that are necessary in the
reasonable opinion of the Manager to cause such allocations to have substantial
economic effect within the meaning of Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2).
4.4 Tax Allocations. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, all items
of income, gain, loss and deduction shall be allocated, for federal and state income tax
purposes, among the Members in the same manner as the corresponding items of
income, gain, loss and deduction are allocated for purposes of maintaining the Capital
Account of each of the Members.
4.5 Section 704(c) Allocations. In accordance with Code Section 704(c) and
the Regulations thereunder, income, gain, loss and deduction with respect to any
property contributed to the capital of the Company shall, solely for tax purposes, be
allocated among the Members so as to take account of any variation between the
adjusted basis of such property to the Company for federal income tax purposes and its
initial Gross Asset Value, including, but not limited to, special allocations to a
contributing Member that are required under Code Section 704(c) to be made upon
distribution of such property to any of the noncontributing Members. In the event the
Gross Asset Value of any property of the Company is adjusted pursuant to
subparagraph (b) of Section 1.14, subsequent allocations of income, gain, loss and
deduction with respect to such property shall take account of any variation between the
adjusted basis of such property for federal income tax purposes and its Gross Asset
Value in the same manner as under Code Section 704(c) and the Regulations
thereunder. Any elections or other decisions relating to such allocations shall be made
by the Manager in any manner that reasonably reflects the purpose and intention of this
Agreement. Allocations pursuant to this Section 4.5 are solely for purposes of federal,
state and local taxes and shall not affect, or in any way be taken into account in
computing, a Members Capital Account or share of Profits or Losses, other items or
distributions pursuant to any provision of this Agreement.
8
4.6 Distribution of Cash Flow. To the extent there is Cash Flow available for
distribution, as reasonably determined by the Manager, and in any event not later than
45 days after the receipt by the Company of the proceeds from the sale of, or other
realization upon, all or any portion of the Investment, the Manager shall cause the
Company to distribute such available Cash Flow:

(a) first, to those Members with Unreturned Capital Contributions, pro
rata in proportion to the amount of such Unreturned Capital Contributions, until
the amount of each Member's Unreturned Capital Contributions has been
reduced to zero; and

(b) thereafter, to the Members, pro rata in accordance with their
respective Membership Interests.
ARTICLE 5
MANAGEMENT
5.1 Initial Manager. The management of the Company's business shall be
vested in one Manager unless a greater number of Managers shall be fixed from time to
time by action of the Members. The initial Manager of the Company shall be Joichi Ito.
A Manager shall hold office until his, her or its death, removal, or resignation.
5.2 Management Authority.

(a) Except as otherwise authorized in this Agreement, all management
decisions of the Company (including, without limitation, any actions or votes
taken by or on behalf of the Company in respect of any equity interest held by the
Company in another entity) shall be made by the Manager, who shall be
responsible for the conduct of the business of the Company, subject to the
provisions of this Agreement and the Act. The Manager shall have all of the
rights, powers, duties and obligations of managers as provided in the Act, and as
otherwise provided by law, and any action taken by the Manager, not otherwise
in violation of the Act or this Agreement, shall constitute the act of and serve to
bind the Company.
(b) Only the Manager and agents of the Company authorized by the
Manager shall have the authority to bind the Company. The Manager is an agent
of the Company for the purpose of its business, and the act of the Manager,
including the execution in the Company's name of any instrument for apparently
carrying on in the usual way the business of the Company, binds the Company,
unless such act is in contravention of the Act or this Agreement or any
agreement between the Manager and the Company or unless the Manager so
acting otherwise lacks the authority to act for the Company and the Person with
whom the Manager is dealing has knowledge of the fact that he, she or it has no
such authority. If the Manager acts without the requisite authority, the Manager
shall be liable for any damages or liabilities arising with respect to such action
9
unless the Manager can show that he, she or it reasonably believed after due
inquiry that such action was authorized.
5.3 Limitation on Liability. The Manager shall perform his, her or its duties as
the Manager in good faith, in a manner he, she or it reasonably believes to be in the
best interest of the Company and the Members, and with such care as an ordinarily
prudent person in a like position would use under similar circumstances. A Person who
so performs his, her or its duties shall not have any liability by reason of being or having
been a Manager of the Company, except where the claim at issue is based on the
fraud, gross negligence or bad faith of the Manager.
5.4 Removal of the Manager. The Manager may be removed with or without
cause upon the Consent of the Members, but such removal shall be without prejudice to
any contract rights the Manager may have under this Agreement. Any removal of the
Manager shall become effective on such date as may be specified by the Members
voting in favor thereof. Should the Manager be removed who is also a Member, such
Member will continue to participate in the Company as a Member and enjoy the burdens
and benefits of his or her Membership Interests.
5.5 Resignation of the Manager. The Manager may resign at any time by
giving Notice to the Members. The resignation of the Manager shall take effect upon
receipt of such Notice or at such later date as specified in such Notice. The acceptance
of the resignation of the Manager shall not be necessary to make such resignation
effective. The resignation of the Manager who is also a Member shall not affect the
Manager's rights as a Member and shall not constitute a withdrawal of the Member.
5.6 Appointment of New Manager. If a vacancy in the office of Manager
occurs, a new Manager shall be designated with the Consent of the Members to fill such
vacancy, provided that in the event of the death, removal, or resignation of Joichi Ito as
the Manager, Darren K. Indyke shall become the succeeding Manager, unless another
Manager is appointed with the Consent of the Members. In the event that any vacancy
in the office of Manager is not filled as provided in the preceding sentence,
management of the Company shall be vested in the Members.
5.7 Indemnification by the Company. The Company shall indemnify the
Manager for all costs, losses, liabilities and damages paid or incurred by the Manager in
connection with the business of the Company to the fullest extent provided or permitted
by the Act and the other laws of the State of Delaware, except where the claim at issue
is based on the fraud, gross negligence or bad faith of the Manager. In connection
therewith, the Company shall advance to the Manager as they are paid or incurred all
expenses arising with respect to the defense of any matter as to which the Company
will be obligated to provide indemnification pursuant to this Section 5.7.
10
ARTICLE 6
MEMBERS
6.1 Powers of Members. Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 5.2, the
Members shall have the right to Consent to the following matters:

(a) removal of the Manager as provided in Section 5.4;
(b) designation of a new Manager upon the resignation, removal, death
or permanent disability of the then-current Manager as provided in Section 5.6

(c) approval either of any Transfer of any Membership Interests or of
any party becoming a Member as provided in Article 9; and
(d) dissolution of the Company as provided in Article 10.
6.2 Partition. While the Company remains in effect or is continued, each
Member waives its rights to have any Company property partitioned, or to file a
complaint or to institute any suit, action or proceeding at law or in equity to have any
Company property partitioned, and each Member, on behalf of itself, its successors and
its assigns hereby waives any such right.
6.3 Authority. Except as expressly authorized in this Agreement, no Member
shall take any action as a Member to bind the Company, and each Member shall
indemnify the Company for any costs or damages incurred by the Company as the
result of the unauthorized action of such Member.
6.4 Vote of the Members. An affirmative vote or consent by or on behalf of all
of the Members shall be required to approve or disapprove any matter on which the
Members are entitled or required to decide or Consent, except as otherwise provided in
this Agreement, the Certificate or the Act.
ARTICLE 7
TRANSACTIONS; AFFILIATED PARTY TRANSACTIONS
7.1 Transactions Between a Member or Manager and the Company. Except
as otherwise limited by applicable law, with the Consent of the Members any Member or
Manager may, but shall not be obligated to, lend money to the Company, act as surety
for the Company and transact other business with the Company, and shall have the
same rights and obligations when transacting business with the Company as a person
or entity who is not a Member or Manager.
7.2 Affiliated Party Transactions. The Members acknowledge that the
Company is being formed initially to purchase and then hold an investment in
Blockstream Corporation, a corporation incorporated under the laws of Canada, for
which the Manager may provide certain advisory or consulting services or on whose
11
board of directors the Manager may serve. In connection therewith, the Members
acknowledge such potential conflict of interest and waive and consent to any such
transaction that may be approved on behalf of the Company as provided in this
Agreement.
ARTICLE 8
FISCAL YEAR; BOOKS AND RECORDS; BANK ACCOUNTS
8.1 Bank Accounts. The funds of the Company shall be deposited in such
federally insured bank account or accounts or other financial intermediary as the
Manager in his or her discretion determine are required, and the Manager shall arrange
for the appropriate conduct of such accounts.
8.2 Books and Records.

(a) There shall be kept and maintained full and accurate books
respecting the business of the Company showing all receipts and expenditures,
assets and liabilities, profits, losses and distributions, and all other records
reasonably necessary or appropriate for recording the Company's business
affairs at the Company's principal place of business or such other location as the
Manager may determine provided that all of the Members are informed of such
other location. Such books and records shall be open to inspection by any
Member (or such Members authorized representative) upon reasonable notice
and during ordinary business hours
(b) The books of the Company shall be kept on the method of
accounting determined by the Members, and shall show at all times each and
every item of income, gain, loss and expense.
8.3 Fiscal Year. The fiscal year of the Company shall be the calendar year.
8.4 Tax Matters Partner. Pursuant to Code Section 6231, the Person
designated by the Manager from time to time shall act as the Tax Matters Partner of the
Company. The Tax Matters Partner shall prepare and provide to each Member all
necessary tax forms and information to enable the Members to meet their tax filing
obligations on a timely basis and shall, within 30 days after receipt thereof, forward to
each Member a photocopy of any notices relating to the Company received from the
Internal Revenue Service or other revenue authority.
8.5 Tax Returns. In addition to the requirements of Section 8.2, tax returns of
the Company shall be prepared by the Person selected by the Manager.
12
ARTICLE 9
TRANSFERS
9.1 General Provision. No Member shall, directly or indirectly, voluntarily or
involuntarily, sell, assign, transfer, pledge, hypothecate, encumber or otherwise dispose
of ("Transfer") the whole or any part of its, his or her Membership Interests in the
Company, except to Affiliates of such Member or with the Consent of the Members.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, if any such Member is an individual, such Person's
Membership Interests may pass to his or her estate upon his or her death subject to the
other provisions of this Agreement. Except in connection with transfers during an
individual Member's lifetime to Affiliates as permitted pursuant to this Section 9.1, which
Affiliates shall become Members when the transfers become effective as hereinafter
provided, no transferee shall become a Member without the Consent of the Members.
Transfers to Affiliates shall be effective upon the Affiliates entering into this Agreement
and notice thereof being provided to the other Members.
9.2 Sale of the Company.

(a) If the Manager approves a Sale of the Company (an "Approved
Sale"), then each Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will
consent to and raise no objection to the Approved Sale, and if the Approved Sale
is structured as a sale of Membership Interests, then each Member and any
other holder of Membership Interests will agree to sell all of their Membership
Interests on the same terms and conditions as approved by the Manager. Each
Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will take all actions which
the Manager deems reasonably necessary in connection with the consummation
of the Approved Sale.

(b) The obligations of the Members and any other holders of
Membership Interests with respect to the Approved Sale are subject to the
condition that upon the consummation of the Approved Sale, all of the holders of
Membership Interests will, subject to Section 4.6, receive substantially the same
form and amount of consideration for their Membership Interests sold, or if any
such Membership Interests are given an option as to the form and amount of
consideration to be received, all such holders will be given the same option.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, nothing contained in this Section 9.2(b) shall
prevent any individual from receiving an offer of employment upon reasonable
terms in connection with services to be provided after the consummation of the
Approved Sale.

(c) Each Member and any other holder of Membership Interests will
bear their pro rata share (based upon the total amount of Membership Interests
sold) of the cost of any sale of Membership Interests pursuant to an Approved
Sale to the extent such costs are incurred for the benefit of all holders of
Membership Interests and are not otherwise paid by the Company. Costs
incurred by Members and the other holders of Membership Interests on their own
13
behalf, will not be considered costs of the Approved Sale contemplated
hereunder.
ARTICLE 10
DISSOLUTION AND TERMINATION
10.1 Dissolution. The Company shall be dissolved upon the Consent of the
Members or as otherwise provided by the Articles or the Act.
10.2 Procedures Upon Dissolution.

(a) Upon dissolution of the Company, the Company shall be terminated
and the Manager, or if there is no Manager, the Members, shall liquidate the
assets of the Company. The proceeds of liquidation shall be applied and
distributed in the following order of priority:

(i) First, to the payment of the debts and liabilities of the
Company (other than any loans or advances made by any of the Members
to the Company) and the expenses of liquidation;

(ii) Second, to the creation of any reserves which the Manager
or liquidating Members deem reasonably necessary for the payment of
any contingent or unforeseen liabilities or obligations of the Company or
Members (to the extent the Company is liable therefor) arising out of or in
connection with the business and operation of the Company;
(iii) Third, to the payment of any loans or advances made by any
of the Members to the Company; and
(iv) Thereafter, to the Members in the manner, and in the
priorities set forth in Section 4.6.
(b) A reasonable time shall be allowed for the orderly liquidation of the
assets of the Company and the discharge of liabilities. During the period
beginning with the dissolution of the Company and ending with its liquidation and
termination of this Agreement pursuant to this Section 10.2, the business affairs
of the Company shall be conducted by the Manager or, if there is no Manager, by
the Members. During such period, the business and affairs of the Company shall
be conducted so as to preserve the assets of the Company and maintain the
status which existed immediately prior to such termination.
14
ARTICLE 11
MISCELLANEOUS
11.1 Binding Agreement. Subject to the restrictions on transfers and
encumbrances set forth herein, this Agreement shall inure to the benefit of and be
binding upon the parties hereto and their respective heirs, executors, legal
representatives, successors and permitted assigns. Whenever in this instrument a
reference to any party or Member is made, such reference shall be deemed to include a
reference to the heirs, executors, legal representatives, successors and permitted
assigns of each Member.
11.2 Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed in several counterparts,
each of which shall be deemed an original, but all of which shall constitute one and the
same instrument. In addition, this Agreement may contain more than one counterpart of
the signature pages and this Agreement may be executed by the affixing of the
signatures of each of the Members to one of such counterpart signature pages; all of
such signature pages shall be read as though, and this Agreement shall have the same
force and effect as though, all of the signers had signed a single signature page.
11.3 Effect of Consent or Waiver. No consent or waiver by any party hereto to
or of any breach or default by any other party hereto in the performance by such other
party hereto of its, his or her obligations hereunder shall be effective unless in writing,
and signed by the party hereto against whom such waiver is sought to be enforced, and
no such consent or waiver shall be deemed or construed to be a consent or waiver to or
of any other breach or default by such other party hereto in the performance by such
other party hereto of the same or any other obligations of such party hereto hereunder.
Failure on the part of any party hereto to object to or complain of any act or failure to act
of any of the other parties hereto or to declare any of the other parties hereto in default,
regardless of how long such failure continues, shall not constitute a waiver by any such
party hereto of its, his or her rights hereunder.
11.4 Enforceability. If any provision of this Agreement or the application thereof
to any Person or circumstances shall be invalid or unenforceable to any extent, the
remainder of this Agreement and the application of such provisions to other Persons or
circumstances shall not be affected thereby and shall be enforced to the greatest extent
permitted by law.
11.5 Entire Agreement. This Agreement contains all of the terms agreed upon
by the parties hereto with respect to the subject matter hereof, and supersedes all prior
agreements, arrangements and communications between the parties dealing with the
Membership Interests, whether oral or written.
11.6 Governing Law; Jurisdiction. In all respects, including all matters of
construction, validity and performance, the Agreement and the obligations arising
hereunder shall be governed by, and construed and enforced in accordance with, the
laws of the State of Delaware, applicable to contracts made and performed in such
15
state, without regard to the principles thereof regarding conflict of laws. The Company
and each of the parties hereto agree to submit to personal jurisdiction and to waive any
objection as to venue in the courts located in either the county in which the Company's
principal office is located within the State of Delaware or the county in which the
Company's registered office is located within the State of Delaware. Service of process
on the Company and any of the parties hereto in any action arising out of or relating to
this Agreement shall be effective if mailed by certified mail, return receipt requested or
delivered by reputable overnight courier to such party at the address set forth on
Exhibit A attached hereto.
11.7 Liability Among Members. No Member shall be liable to any other
Member or to the Manager by reason of its, his or her actions or omissions in
connection with the Company, unless otherwise provided in this Agreement, and except
for acts or omissions or alleged acts or omissions that were performed or omitted
fraudulently or in bad faith or as a result of gross negligence or willful misconduct.
11.8 No Partnership Intended for Nontax Purposes. The Members have
formed the Company under the Act and expressly do not intend hereby to form a
partnership under the laws of any jurisdiction. The Members do not intend to be
partners one to another, or partners as to any third party. To the extent any Member, by
word or action, represents to another Person that any other Member is a partner or that
the Company is a partnership, the Member making such wrongful representation shall
be liable to any other Member who incurs personal liability by reason of such wrongful
representation.
11.9 Amendment. This Agreement may be amended or modified only with the
Consent of the Members.
11.10 Notices. Any Notice to the Manager or Members required under the terms
of this Agreement shall be sent to their respective addresses, as set forth on Exhibit A
attached hereto. All Notices and copies thereof provided for herein shall be hand
delivered with receipt therefor, sent by overnight courier service with receipt therefor, or
sent by certified or registered mail, return receipt requested, and first-class postage
prepaid. Changes of address may be given to the Company, the Manager, and the
Members by Notice given in accordance with the terms of this Section. Time periods
shall commence on the date that such Notice is shown as delivered upon any such
receipt or attempted to be delivered if receipt thereof is refused by the recipient. Any
Notice that is required to be given within a stated period of time shall be considered
timely made or given if delivered or postmarked before 11:59 p.m., local time, on the
last day of such period.
11.11 Business Pursuits of Members and Manager. Except as otherwise
provided in any other written agreement by which any Member or the Manager may be
bound, the Manager and each Member may engage in other business activities. Except
as otherwise provided in this Agreement or in any other written agreement by which any
Member or Manager may be bound, this Agreement shall not preclude or limit in any
respect the right of any Member or the Manager to engage in or invest in any business
16
activity of any nature or description. Any such permitted activity may be engaged in
independently or with other Members or the Manager. No Member or Manager shall
have the right, by virtue of this the Certificate, this Agreement or the relationship created
hereby, to any interest in such other permitted ventures or activities or to the income or
proceeds derived therefrom. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement or in any
other written agreement by which any Member or Manager may be bound, the pursuit of
such permitted ventures shall not be deemed wrongful or improper and any Member or
Manager shall have the right to participate in or to recommend to others any investment
opportunity.
11.12 Expenses. The Company shall recognize $2,000 of the out-of-pocket
expenses actually incurred by Joichi Ito in connection with the organization of the
Company as an initial capital contribution by such Member, and up to $2,000 of the
annual out-of-pocket expenses actually incurred by any Member of the Company in
connection with the operation of the Company each year as an additional capital
contribution by such Member when paid by such Member.
11.13 References. References herein to the singular shall include the plural and
to the plural shall include the singular, and references to one gender shall include the
others, except where the same shall not be appropriate.
11.14 Titles and Captions. Section titles or captions contained in this Agreement
are for convenience only and shall not be deemed a part of the content of this
Agreement.
11.15 Delivery by Facsimile or Electronic Mail. This Agreement, the agreements
referred to herein, and each other agreement or instrument entered into in connection
herewith or therewith or contemplated hereby or thereby, and any amendments hereto
or thereto, to the extent signed and delivered by means of a facsimile machine, pdf
attachment to an email or other electronic means, shall be treated in all manner and
respects as an original agreement or instrument and shall be considered to have the
same binding legal effect as if it were the original signed version thereof delivered in
person. At the request of any party hereto or to any such agreement or instrument,
each other party hereto or thereto shall re-execute original forms thereof and deliver
them to all other parties. No party hereto or to any such agreement or instrument shall
raise the use of such means to deliver a signature or the fact that any signature or
agreement or instrument was transmitted or communicated through the use of such
means as a defense to the formation or enforceability of a contract and each party
hereto forever waives any such defense.
[Signature page follows]
17
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned parties here executed this Agreement
as of the date first set forth above.
Kyara Investments III LLC
By:
Joichi Ito, Manager
Joichi Ito
Southern Financial, LLC
By:
Jeffrey Epstein, Manager
Joichi Ito, Manager
S-1
EXHIBIT A
The names, addresses and Membership Interests of the Members are set forth
below.
Name and Address
Number of
Membership
Interests
Percentage
Ownershi.
Initial
Capital
Contribution
Joichi Ito
63 Francis Ave.
Cambridge, MA 02138
500 50% $ 2,000
Southern Financial, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3

St. Thomas, USVI 00802
500 50% 500,001
TOTAL 1,000 100.00% $ 502,001
Address of Manager and the Company:
Go Joichi Ito
63 Francis Ave.
Cambridge, MA 02138
EFTA01401059 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Deutsche Bank wire transfer receipt for Epstein's investment in Blockstream
(inferred date: 2014-09-09)
Deutsche Bank
Private Wealth Management
Authorization for Asset Movement
For Non-Retirement Accounts
The undersigned hereby authorizes end directs Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown
("Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown" or "DBAB") to follow the below asset movement
instructions
If you wish to request multiple wires, checks, journals or free delivenes,
please use the long (orm.
DBAB Acco • Southem Financial LLC
Account»:
Journal
Q Journal Funds m the amount of S
d Journal Holdings
Oty/Symboi/Security:
Oty/Symbol/Security
❑ Journal All Holdings
To DBAB Account #.
Account Name
Wire
Q Wire federal lunds in the emounl of $ 500,001.00
To Bank Name First Republic Bank
City! State-
ABA*:
San Francisco CA
321061669
Further credit to Inlannadiatv Financial Institution (Optional)
Account #•
Name
Ultimate Beiwlic^ Information:
me: Jolchl ItO
ocom
Additional insiiuctions: subcr to Kvara Investment III. LLC
to fund Blockstream Investment
FiBeOeEvettas
D Please deliver the secunties indicated below to:
DTCCF.
Name of Receiving Firm:
Chech
Q Issue a check m the anxiunl of $
Reopienl's Name.
Rerapiant's Maiing Adckess.
Account Name.
payable to:
Account Number;
at Receiving Firm
Qtv/Svmbo]/Secu;ily
Oty/Symbol/Security;
Standing Authorization
Q The undersigned hereby requests that this aulhoiizetion act as a standing
authonzation. The undersigned understands end agrees that this euthonzation
will
rernain in efiect until Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown requests a new
auihoilzstion. The undersigned authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to issue
the wire,
check or journal on the
(_J The undersigned further authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to accept
verbal instructions from the undersigned to wire funds, issue checks or
journal
funds to/from the above listed accounts, The undersigned will provide verbal
instructions as to the date and the amount of the wire, check or journal. If
the
unders igned decides to vary either the date or the amount of the wire,
check or journal, the undersigned hereby authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex Brown
to
accept me verbal instructions Ifom the undersigned regarding the change or
changes. The undersigned further understands and agrees to comply with the
procedures ol Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to venfy the authorization and
accuracy ol verbal instructions.
day of
for a term ol
The undersigned hereby soknovviedges that (i) the inlormalion contained in
this form is compleie and accurate to the best knowledge ol the undersigned;
and (ii) the
undersigned is responsible for the method of transmission ol any
inslruciions issued pursuant to this authorization. If the undersigned
elects to transmit any such
instructions via fax (including desktop fax), via ameil or as an image
attachment to email le.g., as a PDF. TIF or other image ol such
instructions!, the undersigned
understands and agrees that the undersigned beers the nsk of loss arising
from such method of transmission m the event of transmission errors,
misunderstandings,
impersonations, transmission by unauthorized persons lorgery or intercepts.
For trusts or other entities, the undersigned further acknowledges that the
undersigned is
authonzed to issue the above asset movement instructions under the terms of
the governing documents and any applicable lews The undersigned hereby
releases and
holds harmless Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown from and against loss from any
action, claim or demand ol any person as a result ol Deutsche Bank Alex
Brown's receipt ol
or compliance with this authorization end/or any instructions that may be
given to Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown pursuant to this authorization (including
any standing
authorization).
The undersigned understands that Deutsche Bank Alex, Brown may, but is not
required to. seek verilication of the undersigned's instructions by call
back and that
Deutsche Bank Alex Brown may in its sole discretion refuse to execute such
instructions (including standing instructions) given pursuant to this
authorization, without
incurring any liabllrly. it Deutsche Bank Alex Brown has reason to believe
such instructions [or standing inslnjclJons) have not been provided by the
undersigned. The
undersigned further understands that Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown retains the
right to refuse to execute any insiruclions to transfer funds or secumies to
any accoum(s)
pursuant to this authoriiation without wntten instructions bearing original
signature(s) of the undersigned
Darren Indyke
ib
9-9-2014
V
A JL 0
Print Name
Signal uro
Date
Signature
Print Name
Date
111111111111111111
LOA
10-PWM-0177S 112/10)
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                      Karim Wade [africa] son of the president of Senegal, arrested for corruption [bbc] 
                                                                         Jack Lang [europe] former French Minister of National Education 
                                               Ariane de Rothschild [rothschild] heiress, runs the bank Edmond de Rothschild (Suisse) SA 
                                                                        Vitaly Churkin [russia] Russian ambassador to the United Nations 
                                                                   GSJ [usvi] Great Saint James, larger island also purchased by Epstein 
                                                                                          Kenneth E. Mapp [usvi] Virgin Islands Governor 
                                                                              Misha Gromov [academia] geometer and group theorist [wiki] 
                                                                                          Neri Oxman [academia] MIT, wife of Bill Ackman 
                                                             Nicholas Christakis [academia] Yale professor of Social and Natural Science 
                                                                                 Noam Chomsky [academia] professor of linguistics at MIT 
                                                                                          Robert Trivers [academia] evolutionary biology 
                                                                                         Valeria Chomsky [academia] wife of Noam Chomsky 
                                                                         Whitfield Diffie [academia] MIT cryptographer and mathematician 
                                                                                                 Bobby Slayton [arts] comedian and actor 
                                                                            Richard Merkin [arts] painter, illustrator and arts educator 
                                                                                                      Robert Redford [arts] famous actor 
                                                                                                       Erik Svenson [crypto] Blockstream 
                                                                              Steven Sinofsky [crypto] a16z, ex-Microsoft, loves bitcoin 
                                                                                 Eric Roth [employee] jet decorator at International Jet 
                                                GRAT [finance] Grantor Retained Annuity Trust, tax shelter structure favoured by Epstein 
                                       The Mothers Army [girls] Epstein company rehabilitate Epstein's image with help of powerful women 
                                                                Rupert Murdoch [journalist] owner of Fox News, Wall Street Journal, etc. 
                                                            Harry Fisch [medical] urologist at New York-Presbyterian / Weill Cornell (?) 
                                                                                                Peter Attia [medical] longevity medicine 
                     Hamad bin Jassim al-Thani aka HBJ [mideast] former Qatari prime minister, planned Sharia crypto with Epstein [wiki] 
                  Shaher Abdulhak Besher [mideast] Yemeni billionaire whose son fled London after murdering Martine Vik Magnussen [wiki] 
                                      Ramsey Elkholy [modeling] scouted girls for Epstein in NYC, member of Monotronic [ramseyelkholyny] 
                                                                                           Elon Musk [tech] father of Mecha-Hitler [npr] 
                             Peter Diamandis [tech] XPrize Foundation and Singularity University founder, claimed he met Epstein in 2013 
 Peter Thiel [tech] Paypal mafia, Palantir co-founder, Facebook investor, Epstein invested ~$40 million in his fund Valar Ventures [nyt] 
                                                            Reid Hoffman [tech] PayPal mafia member, founder of LinkedIn, Democrat donor 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01068342 (Jmail)
 [tech] Story Cowles personal address book
(inferred timestamp: 2014-09-20 11:18:22)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024364.dmg
(Evidence ID: NYC024364.dmg - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Notes
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Notes
Note
Source NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/StickiesDatabase
Date 2003-03-05 02:13:27 (UTC) Created
Date 2004-11-16 17:34:02 (UTC) Modifed
Title
Summary Make a note of it!
Make a note of it!
Stickies lets you keep notes (like these) on your desktop. Use a Stickies note to jot down reminder
s, lists, or other information. You can also use notes to store frequently used text or graphics.
Body • To close this note, click the close button.

• To collapse this note, double click the title bar.
Your current notes appear when you open Stickies.
Note
Source NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/StickiesDatabase
Date 2003-03-05 02:14:15 (UTC) Created
Date 2004-11-16 17:29:10 (UTC) Modifed
Title
Summary It's easy to customize your notes.
Body It's easy to customize your notes.
Make your notes stand out and get noticed.

• Format text using different fonts and font sizes
• Add emphasis with bold and italic text styles or color.
• Include graphics classic.tif ,
Stickies has lots of other great features, including a spell checker, import and export features, and o
ther ways to arrange and customize your notes. Plus, you'll find a "Make New Sticky Note" service
in many applications.
Look in Help to find out more about using Stickies.
Note
Source Device NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/StickiesDatabase
Date Created 2010-11-11 12:59:54 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2010-11-11 13:02:04 (UTC)
Title
Summary =1 december, jl iphoto
Body =I, december, jl iphoto
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2010-12-06 00:22:46 (UTC)
2013-04-15 11:18:18 (UTC)
terje ian boris, piney, leon. magnina, boustein,E,
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Gmail Source
Body
<htmlxheadxfheadxbody bgeolor="tiFEF9AC" style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-
mode: space; -webkit-line-break: after-white-space. ">
terje ian boris, piney, leon. magnina, boustein,E,
</body></html>
Note
Source Device NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2010-12-18 00:59:23 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2010-12-18 00:59:23 (UTC)
Title 0603517447
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Body 0603517447
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Libraty/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2010-12-26 14:52:25 (UTC) Created
Date 2011-01-01 20:20:57 (UTC) Modifed
Title
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <htmlxbody bgcolor="#FEF9AC"›
Wildflower thatxtegv curtains storage gym road gym entrance bedroom door Punching nag gym m
ess archer dozerplnt mechanical beacgthree terrace po level garbage can gym weight beltocean equ
ip organize
</body><Iuml>
Note
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/DataiLibrary/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2011-01-08 15:12:44 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2011-01-08 15:12:44 (UTC)
Title Outdoor swivels
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Body Outdoor swivels
Note
Source NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2011-01-11 14:21:22 (UTC)
Date 2011-01-23 13:39:01 (UTC) Modifed
Title Dock lights pneumo mohel Jonathan
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Dock lights pneumo mohel Jonathan
Body Tule full-time Scott cables sultan un gym two jack paul steve gogger Krishna ver Jerry larrypeter
georgeandrews
Note
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2011-01-28 16:07:33 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2011-02-09 15:21:13 (UTC)
Title Dr. Kosslyn ew case3castings one jibbeaxh cleaner algae
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Body Dr. Kosslyn ew case3castings one jibbeaxh cleaner algae
Note
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/StickiesDatabase
Date Created 2012-07-19 12:39:20 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2012-07-19 12:44:47 (UTC)
Title
Summary money as infection , virus colonize markets.
money as infection , virus colonize markets.
dreams awake,
power law , . pareto
deciption
coop and comp , couples
nose experiment
math limiting money„ alternive currency
econophyics econ biology
Body
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
fUsers/Story/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2012-10-28 15:37:55 (UTC)
2013-04-21 00:54:42 (UTC)
joe, jean luc, todd, ari, leah
gallert, acad of art, woody harvard, mette barbro, jabor, summers,
bamaby re do will , woody , gates. ian, terjem, smoklin ghislaine ,
cars lsj, boats„ bLAINE bremmer, lweis blac, IRERRA, Slayton,
sinofsky, mellz, meachnic,IMI, david hanson wsteve,
tom mcimillen , keatin dashca grupman
bill seigal, leon back, g , wexner, S Jorge
liman, david Effen kwok, roman, jylee, rupert murdoch, bob keeryy
pritsker, reid , peggy, thiel, elon, viber, benny, sercuity
conference, music and brain , pwer, signal intelligence ronts.
venquela, fransciso, zagat, kazak, sultan dubai, zuckerman, eric
shcmidt, diffie, norway, mongolia, mr evil, nathan, keith alexander
panetaa, paterus, david stem jack lang, michel, picault, =, bobby
kotik, brockman, ehud, barnaby, maldives, david mitchell, physica
alebraic topology novak nabokov, stafraair maintanin house„
baning license ayh, noadiva, MI= vaiva zwim
corbin, heidi, music bottstein, ion cabana time, set lloyd, mindsly
rosovdky gergen, tax pllan options stat arb equity credit curreency ,
estate, george church, josha back kosslym, eikie, juilsu baer,
m rta anti ua br k michael wood, ben goertzel, redecorate. pinto.
lesle , rich rbk ftc stca jack
brad, 727 , alan heidi,
Summary
Sync
Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <htmlxheadx,thead><body style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-li
ne-break: after-white-space; ">
joe, jean luc, todd, ari, leah
ga ert, aca o art, woo y arvard, mette barbro, jabor, summers,
bamaby re do will , woody , gates. ian, terjem, smoklin ghislaine ,
cars lsj, boats,  bLAINE, bremmer, lweis blac IRERRA, Slayton,
sinofsky, mellz, , Cdr meachnic, , david hanson wsteve,
a bill seil•Pack, g4, wexner, Jorge
tom mcimillen , keatin h grupman
liman, da gvideffen kwok, roman, jylee, rupert murdoch, bob keeryy
pritsker, reid , peggy, thiel, elon, viber, benny, sercuity
conference, music and brain , pwer, signal intelligence ronts.
venquela, fransciso, zagat, kazak, sultan dubai, zuckerman, eric
shcmidt, diffie, norway, mongolia, mr evil, nathan, keith alexander
panetaa, paterus, david stem jack lang, michel, picault,=, bobby
kotik, brockman, ehud, barnaby, maldives, david mitchell, physica
alebraic topology novak, nabokov, staff. repair maintanin house„
baning license ayh, noadiva,IIMMI vaiva zwim
corbin, heidi, music ottstein, ion cabana time, set lloyd, mindsly
rosovdky gergen, tax pllan options stat arb equity credit curreency ,
estate, george church, josha back kosslym, eikie, juilsu baer,
morta e anti ua brock, michael wood, ben goertzel, redecorate. pinto.
lesle , rich rbk ftc stc, , jack
<br clear="all">reidluis lang, joffee , vaiv
svenson, peggy „ boris, geff
aris, plain  we ar
andra, bobkerr
brad, 727 ,flan heidi,
a, leon, ian,jeanluc, danielk, vie,
en, jagband , terje, mette.MIIIIIIk read , david stem,
e you jeanluc Daniel fl e's here, schank, david stem/
y, Joel klein, richard branson grog wyler
shank todd eric, ian Jacob, gates boris.. tanceredi vaiva. </body></html>
Source
Device
Path
Date Created
Date Modifed
Title
Summary
Sync Name
Sync Source
Body
Note
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2013-04-25 15:41:33 (UTC)
2013-04-25 15:53:36 (UTC)
ehud, larry, ? anderw? joel kelin, leon bottsetin? , kerrey. mort.
jeevacation
Gmail
<htm1><Itead></head><body>ehud, larry, anderw? Joel kelin, leon bottsetin? , kerrey. mor
t.
staff, replacement, brice isster. woody , branson. billl, sinofsly, boris
science, bach, hanson signal music,
teachers. weekends. women accomplished, .
lang sultan terje is hossain, =Mvisa status ,
time travel , kayak • kenya ,</body></html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2013-05-03 10:54:20 (UTC) Created
Date 2013-05-15 21:09:02 (UTC) Modifed
Title dsandor, daimandis, chuch, kollsyn, ali reaza, esther dyson, andrewsson, cushion chair,pb phones
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Gmaii
Source
<html>cheadx/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-I
Body the-break: after-white -space; ">dsandor, daimandis, chuch, kollsyn, ali reaza, esther dyson, andrew
sson, cushion chair,pb phones<bodyx/html>
Note
Source NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2013-05-30 12:45:15 (UTC) Created
Date 2013-05-30 12:45:19 (UTC) Modifed
Title This exchange with Alvin Toffler appeared in
Summary
Sync jeevacation Name
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <htmlxheadxfheadxbody>cpre> This exchange with Alvin Toffler appeared in
<i>Playboy<i> for January, 1964. Great trouble was taken on
both sides to achieve the illusion of a spontaneous
conversation. Actually, my contribution as printed conforms
meticulously to the answers, every word of which I had written
in longhand before having them typed for submission to Toffler
when he came to Montreux in mid-March, 1963. The present text
takes into account the order of my interviewer's questions as
well as the fact that a couple of consecutive pages of my
typescript were apparently lost in transit. <i>Egreto perambis
doribus! cti>
<i>With the American publication<i> of Lolita <i>in 1958,
your fame and fortune mushroomed almost overnight from high
repute among the literarycii> cognoscenti-- <i>which you bad
enjoyed for more than 30 years-- to both acclaim and abuse as
the world-renowned author of a sensational bestseller. In the
aftermath of this causecii> celebre, <i>do you ever regret
having written</i> Lolita?
On the contrary, I shudder retrospectively when I recall
that there was a moment, in 1950, and again in 1951, when I was
on the point of burning Humbert Humbert's little black diary.
No, I shall never regret <i>Lolita.</i> She was like the
composition of a beautiful puzzle-- its composition and its
solution at the same time, since one is a mirror view of the
other, depending on the way you look. Of course she completely
eclipsed my other works-- at least those I wrote in English:
<i>The Real Life of Sebastian Knight, Bend Sinister,</i> my
short stories, my book of recollections; but I cannot grudge
her this. There is a queer, tender charm about that mythical
nymphet.
<i>Though many readers and reviewers would disagree that
her charm is tender, few would deny that it is queer-- so much
so that when director Stanley Kubrick proposed his plan to make
a movie ofc/i> Lolita, <>you were quoted as saying, "Of course
they'll have to change the plot. Perhaps they will make Lolita
a dwarfess. Or they will make her 16 and Humbert 26. " Though
you finally wrote the screenplay yourself, several reviewers
took the film to task for watering down the central
relationship. Were you satisfied with the final product? </i>
I thought the movie was absolutely first-rate. The four
main actors deserve the very highest praise. Sue Lyon bringing
that breakfast tray or childishly pulling on her sweater in the
car-- these are moments of unforgettable acting and directing.
The killing of Quilty is a masterpiece, and so is the death of
Mrs. Haze. I must point out, though, that I had nothing to do
with the actual production. If I had, I might have insisted on
stressing certain things that were not stressed-- for example,
the different motels at which they stayed. All I did was write
the screenplay, a preponderating portion of which was used by
Kubrick. The "watering down," if any, did not come from my
aspergillum.
<i>Do you feel thate Lolita's <>twofold success has
affected your life for the better or for the worse? </i>
I gave up teaching-- that's about all in the way of
change. Mind you, I loved teaching, I loved Cornell, I loved
composing and delivering my lectures on Russian writers and
European great books. But around 60, and especially in winter,
one begins to find hard the physical process of teaching, the
getting up at a fixed hour every other morning, the struggle
with the snow in the driveway, the march through long corridors
to the classroom, the effort of drawing on the blackboard a map
of James Joyce's Dublin or the arrangement of the semi-sleeping
car of the St. Petersburg -Moscow express in the early 1870s--
without an understanding of which neither <i>Ulysses</i> nor
<i>Anna Karenin,e respectively, makes sense. For some reason
my most vivid memories concern examinations. Big amphitheater
in Goldwin Smith. Exam from 8 a.m. to 10:30. About 150
students-- unwashed, unshaven young males and reasonably
well-groomed young females. A general sense of tedium and
disaster. Half-past eight. Little coughs, the clearing of
nervous throats, coming in clusters of sound, rustling of
pages. Some of the martyrs plunged in meditation, their aims
locked behind their heads. I meet a dull gaze directed at me,
seeing in me with hope and hate the source of forbidden
knowledge. Girl in glasses comes up to my desk to ask:
"Professor Kafka, do you want us to say that . ? Or do you
want us to answer only the first part of the question?" The
great fraternity of C-minus, backbone of the nation, steadily
scribbling on. A rustle arising simultaneously, the majority
turning a page in their bluebooks, good teamwork. The shaking
of a cramped wrist, the failing ink, the deodorant that breaks
down. When I catch eyes directed at me, they are forthwith
raised to the ceiling in pious meditation. Windowpanes getting
misty. Boys peeling off sweaters. Girls chewing gum in rapid
cadence. Ten minutes, five, three, time's up.
<>Citing in</i> Lolita <i>the same kind of acid-etched
scene you've just described, many critics have called the book
a masterful satiric social commentary on America. Are they
right? </i>
Well, I can only repeat that I have neither the intent nor
the temperament of a moral or social satirist. Whether or not
critics think that in <i>Lolita</i> I am ridiculing human folly
leaves me supremely indifferent. But I am annoyed when the glad
news is spread that I am ridiculing America.
<i>But haven't you written yourself that there is "nothing
more exhilarating than American Philistine vulgarity"? </i>
No, I did not say that. That phrase has been lifted out of
context, and, like a round, deep-sea fish, has burst in the
process. If you look up my little after-piece, "On a Book
Entitled Lolita," which I appended to the novel, you will see
that what I really said was that in regard to Philistine
vulgarity-- which I do feel is most exhilarating-- no
difference exists between American and European manners. I go
on to say that a proletarian from Chicago can be just as
Philistine as an English duke.
<>Many readers have concluded that the Philistinism you
seem to find the most exhilarating is that of America's sexual
mores. </i>
Sex as an institution, sex as a general notion, sex as a
problem, sex as a platitude-- all this is something I find too
tedious for words. Let us skip sex.
<>Have you ever been psychoanalyzed?</>
Have I been <>what?
Subjected to psychoanalytical examination.e
Why, good God?
<i>ln order to see how it is done. Some critics have felt
that your barbed comments about the fashionability of
Freudianism, as practiced by American analysts, suggest a
contempt based upon familiarity. <J>
Bookish familiarity only. The ordeal itself is much too
silly and disgusting to be contemplated even as a joke.
Freudism and all it has tainted with its grotesque implications
and methods appears to me to be one of the vilest deceits
practiced by people on themselves and on others. I reject it
utterly, along with a few other medieval items still adored by
the ignorant, the conventional, or the very sick.
<>Speaking of the very sick, you suggested in<Ji> Lolita
<i>that Humbert Humbert's appetite for nymphets is the result
of an unrequited childhood love affair; in<Ji> Invitation to a
Beheading <i>you wrote about a 12-year-old girl, Emmie, who is
erotically interested in a man twice her age; and in</i> Bend
Sinister <>your protagonist dreams that he is "surreptitiously
enjoying Mariette (his maid) while she sat, wincing a little,
in his lap during the rehearsal of a play in which she was
supposed to be his daughter. " Some critics, in poring over
your works for clues to your personality, have pointed to this
recurrent theme as evidence of an unwholesome preoccupation on
your part with the subject of sexual attraction between
pubescent girls and middle-aged men. Do you feel that there may
be some tnith in this charge? </i>
I think it would be more correct to say that had I not
written <i>tolita,</i> readers would not have started finding
nymphets in my other works and in their own households. I find
it very amusing when a friendly, polite person says to me--
probably just in order to be friendly and polite-- "Mr.
Naborkov," or "Mr. Nabahkov," or "Mr. Nabkov" or "Mr.
Nabohkov," depending on his linguistic abilities, "I have a
little daughter who is a regular Lolita." People tend to
underestimate the power of my imagination and my capacity of
evolving serial selves in my writings. And then, of course,
there is that special type of critic, the ferrety,
human-interest fiend, the jolly vulgarian. Someone, for
instance, discovered telltale affinities between Humbert's
boyhood romance on the Riviera and my own recollections about
little Colette, with whom I built damp sand castles in Biarritz
when I was ten. Somber Humbert was, of course, thirteen and in
the throes of a pretty extravagant sexual excitement, whereas
my own romance with Colette had no trace of erotic desire and
indeed was perfectly common-place and normal. And, of course,
at nine and ten years of age, in that set, in those times, we
knew nothing whatsoever about the false facts of life that are
imparted nowadays to infants by progressive parents.
<>Why false? </i>
Because the imagination of a small child-- especially a
town child-- at once distorts, stylizes, or otherwise alters
the bizarre things he is told about the busy bee, which neither
he nor his parents can distinguish from a bum-blebee, anyway.
<>What one critic has termed your "almost obsessive
attention to the phrasing, rhythm, cadence and connotation of
words" is evident even in the selection of names for your own
celebrated bee and bumblebee-- Lolita and Humbert Humbert. How
did they occur to you? <1i>
For my nymphet I needed a diminutive with a lyrical lilt
to it. One of the most limpid and luminous letters is "L". The
suffix "-ita" has a lot of Latin tenderness, and this I
required too. Hence: Lolita. However, it should not be
pronounced as you and most Americans pronounce it: Low-lee-ta,
with a heavy, clammy "L" and a long "o". No, the first syllable
should be as in "lollipop", the "L" liquid and delicate, the
"lee" not too sharp. Spaniards and Italians pronounce it, of
course, with exactly the necessary note of archness and caress.
Another consideration was the welcome murmur of its source
name, the fountain name: those roses and tears in "Dolores." My
little girl's heartrending fate had to be taken into account
together with the cuteness and limpidity. Dolores also provided
her with another, plainer, more familiar and infantile
diminutive: Dolly, which went nicely with the surname "Haze,"
where Irish mists blend with a German bunny-- 1 mean, a small
German hare.
<>You're making a word-playful reference, of course, to
the German term for rabbit-- <1>Hase. <i>But what inspired you
to dub Lolita's aging inamorato with such engaging redundancy?
<1>
That, too, was easy. The double rumble is, I think, very
nasty, very suggestive. It is a hateful name for a hateful
person. It is also a kingly name, and I did need a royal
vibration for Humbert the Fierce and Humbert the Humble. Lends
itself also to a number of puns. And the execrable diminutive
"Hum" is on a par, socially and emotionally, with "Lo," as her
mother calls her.
<i>Another critic has written of you that "the task of
sifting and selecting just the right succession of words from
that multilingual memory, and of arranging their many-mirrored
nuances into the proper juxtapositions, must be psychically
exhausting work. " Which of all your books, in this sense,
would you say was the most difficult to write? </i>
Oh, <i>Lolita,</i> naturally. I lacked the necessary
information-- that was the initial difficulty. I did not know
any American 12-year-old girls, and I did not know America; I
had to invent America and Lolita. It had taken me some forty
years to invent Russia and Western Europe, and now I was faced
by a similar task, with a lesser amount of time at my disposal.
The obtaining of such local ingredients as would allow me to
inject average "reality" into the brew of individual fancy
proved, at fifty, a much more difficult process than it had
been in the Europe of my youth.
<i>Though born in Russia, you have lived and worked for
many years in America as well as in Europe. Do you feel any
strong sense of national identity? </i>
I am an American writer, born in Russia and educated in
England where I studied French literature, before spending
fifteen years in Germany. I came to America in 1940 and decided
to become an American citizen, and make America my home. It so
happened that I was immediately exposed to the very best in
America, to its rich intellectual life and to its easygoing,
good-natured atmosphere. I immersed myself in its great
libraries and its Grand Canyon. I worked in the laboratories of
its zoological museums. I acquired more friends than I ever had
in Europe, My books-- old books and new ones-- found some
admirable readers. I became as stout as Cortez-- mainly because
I quit smoking and started to munch molasses candy instead,
with the result that my weight went up from my usual 140 to a
monumental and cheerful 200. In consequence, I am one-third
American-- good American flesh keeping me warm and safe.
<i>You spent 20 years in America, and yet you never owned
a home or had a really settled establishment there. Your
friends report that you camped impermanently in motels, cabins,
furnished apartments and the rented homes of professors away on
leave. Did you feel so restless or so alien that the idea of
settling down anywhere disturbed you? </i>
The main reason, the background reason, is, I suppose,
that nothing short of a replica of my childhood surroundings
would have satisfied me. I would never manage to match my
memories correctly-- so why trouble with hopeless
approximations? Then there are some special considerations: for
instance, the question of impetus, the habit of impetus. I
propelled myself out of Russia so vigorously, with such
indignant force, that I have been rolling on and on ever since.
True, I have rolled and lived to become that appetizing thing,
a "full professor," but at heart I have always remained a lean
"visiting lecturer." The few times I said to myself anywhere:
"Now, that's a nice spot for a permanent home," I would
immediately hear in my mind the thunder of an avalanche
carrying away the hundreds of far places which I would destroy
by the very act of settling in one particular nook of the
earth. And finally, I don't much care for furniture, for tables
and chairs and lamps and rugs and things-- perhaps because in
my opulent childhood I was taught to regard with amused
contempt any too-earnest attachment to material wealth, which
is why I felt no regret and no bitterness when the Revolution
abolished that wealth.
<>You lived in Russia for twenty years, in West Europe
for 20 years, and in America for twenty years. But in 1960,
after the success of</i> Lolita, <i>you moved to France and
Switzerland and have not returned to the U. S. since. Does this
mean, despite your self-identification as an American writer,
that you consider your American period over? </i>
I am living in Switzerland for purely private reasons --
family reasons and certain professional ones too, such as some
special research for a special book. I hope to return very soon
to America-- back to its library stacks and mountain passes. An
ideal arrangement would be an absolutely soundproofed flat in
New York, on a top floor-- no feet walking above, no soft music
anywhere-- and a bungalow in the Southwest. Sometimes I think
it might be fun to adorn a university again, residing and
writing there, not teaching, or at least not teaching
regularly.
<i>Meanwhile you remain secluded-- and somewhat sedentary,
from all reports-- in your hotel suite. How do you spend your
time? </i>
I awake around seven in winter: my alarm clock is an
Alpine chough-- big, glossy, black thing with big yellow beak--
which visits the balcony and emits a most melodious chuckle.
For a while I lie in bed mentally revising and planning things.
Around eight: shave, breakfast, enthroned meditation, and
bath-- in that order. Then I work till lunch in my study,
taking time out for a short stroll with my wife along the lake.
Practically all the famous Russian writers of the nineteenth
century have rambled here at one time or another. Zhukovski,
Gogol, Dostoevski, Tolstoy-- who courted the hotel chambermaids
to the detriment of his health-- and many Russian poets. But
then, as much could be said of Nice or Rome. We lunch around
one p.m., and I am back at my desk by half-past one and work
steadily till half-past six. Then a stroll to a newsstand for
the English papers, and dinner at seven. No work after dinner.
And bed around nine. I read till half-past eleven, and then
tussle with insomnia till one a.m. about twice a <i>week<A> I
have a good, long nightmare with unpleasant characters imported
from earlier dreams, appearing in more or less iterative
surroundings-- kaleidoscopic arrangements of broken
impressions, fragments of day thoughts, and irresponsible
mechanical images, utterly lacking any possible Freudian
implication or explication, but singularly akin to the
procession of changing figures that one usually sees on the
inner palpebral screen when closing one's weary eyes.
<i>Funny that witch doctors and their patients have never
hit on that simple and absolutely satisfying explanation of
dreaming. Is it true that you write standing up, and that you
write in longhand rather than on a typewriter? </i>
Yes. I never learned to type. I generally start the day at
a lovely old-fashioned lectern I have in my study. Later on,
when I feel gravity nibbling at my calves, I settle down in a
comfortable armchair alongside an ordinary writing desk; and
finally, when gravity begins climbing up my spine, I lie down
on a couch in a corner of my small study. It is a pleasant
solar routine. But when I was young, in my twenties and early
thirties, I would often stay all day in bed, smoking and
<i>writing.</i> Now things have changed. Horizontal prose,
vertical verse, and sedent scholia keep swapping qualifiers and
spoiling the alliteration.
<i>Can you tell us something more about the actual
creative process involved in the germination of a book--
perhaps by reading a few random notes for or excerpts from a
work in progress? cJi>
Certainly not. No fetus should undergo an exploratory
operation. But I can do something else. This box contains index
cards with some notes I made at various times more or less
recently and discarded when writing <i>Pale Fire.cJi> It's a
little batch of rejects. Help yourself. "Selene, the moon.
Selenginsk, an old town in Siberia: moon-rocket town" ...
"Berry: the black knob on the bill of the mute swan" ...
"Dropworm: a small caterpillar hanging on a thread" ... "In
<i>The New Bon Ton Magazine,<A> volume five, 1820, page 312,
prostitutes are termed 'girls of the town' "... "Youth dreams:
forgot pants; old man dreams: forgot dentures" , . . "Student
explains that when reading a novel he likes to skip passages
'so as to get his own idea about the book and not be influenced
by the author"... "Naprapathy: the ugliest word in the
language."
"And after rain, on beaded wires, one bird, two birds,
three birds, and none. Muddy tires, sun" . . . "Time without
consciousness-- lower animal world; time with consciousness--
man; consciousness without time-- some still higher state" ..
. "We think not in words but in shadows of words. James Joyce's
mistake in those otherwise mar-velous mental soliloquies of his
consists in that he gives too much verbal body to thoughts" ..
. "Parody of politeness: That inimitable 'Please' -- 'Please
send me your beautiful-- ' which firms idiotically address to
themselves in printed forms meant for people ordering their
product." ...
"Naive, nonstop, peep-peep twitter of chicks in dismal
crates late, late at night, on a desolate frost-bedimmed
station platform" ... "The tabloid headline TORSO KILLER MAY
BEAT CHAIR might be translated: <i>'Celui qui tw an buste peat
bien battre une chaise" . . .<,/i> "Newspaper vendor, handing me
a magazine with my story: 1 see you made the slicks.' " "Snow
falling, young father out with tiny child, nose like a pink
cherry. Why does a parent immediately say something to his or
her child if a stranger smiles at the latter? 'Sure,' said the
father to the infant's interrogatory gurgle, which had been
going on for some time, and would have been left to go on in
the quiet falling snow, had I not smiled in passing". . .
"Inter-columniation: dark-blue sky between two white columns."
... "Place-name in the Orkneys: Papilio" . . . "Not 1, too,
lived in Arcadia,' but 'I,' says Death, even am in Arcadia'--
legend on a shepherd's tomb <i>(Notes and Queries,<A> June 13,
1868, p. 561)" "Marat collected butterflies" ... "From
the aesthetic point of view, the tapeworm is certainly an
undesirable boarder. The gravid segments frequently crawl out
of a person's anal canal, sometimes in chains, and have been
reported a source of social embarrassment." <i>(Ann. N. Y.
Acad. Sci.</i> 48:558).
<i>What inspires you to record and collect such
disconnected impressions and quotations? </i>
All I know is that at a very early stage of the novel's
development I get this urge to gamer bits of straw and fluff,
and eat pebbles. Nobody will ever discover how clearly a bird
visualizes, or if it visualizes at all, the future nest and the
eggs in it. When I remember afterwards the force that made me
jot down the correct names of things, or the inches and tints
of things, even before I actually needed the information, I am
inclined to assume that what I call, for want of a better term,
inspiration, had been already at work, mutely pointing at this
or that, having me accumulate the known materials for an
unknown structure. After the first shock of recognition-- a
sudden sense of <i>"this</i> is what I'm going to write"-- the
novel starts to breed by itself; the process goes on solely in
the mind, not on paper; and to be aware of the stage it has
reached at any given moment, I do not have to be conscious of
every exact phrase. I feel a kind of gentle development, an
uncurling inside, and I know that the details are there
already, that in fact I would see them plainly if I looked
closer, if I stopped the machine and opened its inner
compartment; but I prefer to wait until what is loosely called
inspiration has completed the task for me. There comes a moment
when I am informed from within that the entire structure is
finished. All I have to do now is take it down in pencil or
pen. Since this entire structure, dimly illumined in one's
mind, can be compared to a painting, and since you do not have
to work gradually from left to right for its proper perception,
I may direct my flashlight at any part or particle of the
picture when setting it down in writing. I do not begin my
novel at the beginning. I do not reach chapter three before I
reach chapter four, I do not go dutifully from one page to the
next, in consecutive order; no, I pick out a bit here and a bit
there, till I have filled all the gaps on paper. This is why I
like writing my stories and novels on index cards, numbering
them later when the whole set is complete. Every card is
rewritten many times. About three cards make one typewritten
page, and when finally I feel that the conceived picture has
been copied by me as faithfully as physically possible-- a few
vacant lots always remain, alas-- then I dictate the novel to
my wife who types it out in triplicate.
<i>In what sense do you<i> copy <i>"the conceived
picture" of a novel? <i>
A creative writer must study carefully the works of his
rivals, including the Almighty. He must possess the inborn
capacity not only of recombining but of re-creating the given
world. In order to do this adequately, avoiding duplication of
labor, the artist should <i>lcnow<i> the given world.
Imagination without knowledge leads no farther than the back
yard of primitive art, the child's scrawl on the fence, and the
crank's message in the market place. Art is never simple. To
return to my lecturing days: I automatically gave low marks
when a student used the dreadful phrase "sincere and simple" --
"Flaubert writes with a style which is always simple and
sincere"-- under the impression that this was the greatest
compliment payable to prose or poetry. When I struck the phrase
out, which I did with such rage in my pencil that it ripped the
paper, the student complained that this was what teachers had
always taught him: "Art is simple, art is sincere." Someday I
must trace this vulgar absurdity to its source. A schoolmarm in
Ohio? A progressive ass in New York? Because, of course, art at
its greatest is fantastically deceitful and complex.
<i>ln terms of modem art, critical opinion is divided
about the sincerity or deceitfulness, simplicity or complexity,
of contemporary abstract painting. What is your own opinion?
<i>
I do not see any essential difference between abstract and
primitive art. Both are simple and sincere. Naturally, we
should not generalize in these matters: it is the individual
artist that counts. But if we accept for a moment the general
notion of "modem art," then we must admit that the trouble
with it is that it is so commonplace, imitative, and academic.
Blurs and blotches have merely replaced the mass prettiness of
a hundred years ago, pictures of Italian girls, handsome
beggars, romantic ruins, and so forth. But just as among those
corny oils there might occur the work of a true artist with a
richer play of light and shade, with some original streak of
violence or tenderness, so among th" corn of primitive and
abstract art one may come across a flash of great talent. Only
talent interests me in paintings and books. Not general ideas,
but the individual contribution.
<i>A contribution to society? cii>
A work of art has no importance whatever to society. It is
only important to the individual, and only the individual
reader is important to me. I don't give a damn for the group,
the community, the masses, and so forth. Although I do not care
for the slogan "art for art's sake"-- because unfortunately
such promoters of it as, for instance, Oscar Wilde and various
dainty poets, were in reality rank moralists and didacticists--
there can be no question that what makes a work of fiction safe
from larvae and rust is not its social importance but its art,
only its art.
<>What do you want to accomplish or leave behind-- or
should this be of no concern to the writer? </i>
Well, in this matter of accomplishment, of course, I don't
have a 35-year plan or program, but I have a fair inkling of my
literary afterlife. I have sensed certain hints, I have felt
the breeze of certain promises. No doubt there will be ups and
downs, long periods of slump. With the Devil's connivance, I
open a newspaper of 2063 and in some article on the books page
I find: "Nobody reads Nabokov or Fulmerford today." Awful
question: Who is this unfortunate Fulmerford?
<i>While we're on the subject of self-appraisal, what do
you regard as your principal failing as a writer-- apart from
forgetability? </i>
Lack of spontaneity; the nuisance of parallel thoughts,
second thoughts, third thoughts; inability to express myself
properly in any language unless I compose every damned sentence
in my bath, in my mind, at my desk.
<>You're doing rather well at the moment, if we may say
so.</i>
It's an illusion.
<>Your reply might be taken as confirmation of critical
comments that you are "an incorrigible leg puller, " "a
mystificator, " and "a literary<> agent provocateur. " <i>How
do</i> you <i>view yourself? </i>
I think my favorite fact about myself is that I have never
been dismayed by a critic's bilge or bile, and have never once
in my life asked or thanked a reviewer for a review. My second
favorite fact-- or shall I stop at one?
<>No, please go on. </i>
The fact that since my youth-- I was 19 when I left
Russia-- my political creed has remained as bleak and
changeless as an old gray rock. It is classical to the point of
triteness. Freedom of speech, freedom of thought, freedom of
art. The social or economic structure of the ideal state is of
little concern to me. My desires are modest. Portraits of the
head of the government should not exceed a postage stamp in
size. No torture and no executions. No music, except coming
through earphones, or played in theaters.
<>Why no music? </i>
I have no ear for music, a shortcoming I deplore bitterly.
When I attend a concert-- which happens about once in five
years-- I endeavor gamely to follow the sequence and
relationship of sounds but cannot keep it up for more than a
few minutes. Visual impressions, reflections of hands in
lacquered wood, a diligent bald spot over a fiddle, these take
over, and soon I am bored beyond measure by the motions of the
musicians. My knowledge of music is very slight; and I have a
special reason for finding my ignorance and inability so sad,
so unjust: There is a wonderful singer in my family-- my own
son. His great gifts, the rare beauty of his bass, and the
promise of a splendid career-- all this affects me deeply, and
I fee] a fool during a technical conversation among musicians.
I am perfectly aware of the many parallels between the art
forms of music and those of literature, especially in matters
of structure, but what can I do if ear and brain refuse to
cooperate? I have found a queer substitute for music in chess--
more exactly, in the composing of chess problems.
<>Another substitute, surely, has been your own
euphonious prose and poetry. As one of few authors who have
written with. eloquence in more than one language, how would
you characterize the textural differences between Russian and
English, in which you are regarded as equally facile? </i>
In sheer number of words, English is far richer than
Russian. This is especially noticeable in nouns and adjectives.
A very bothersome feature that Russian presents is the dearth,
vagueness, and clumsiness of technical terms.
For example, the simple phrase "to park a car" comes out--
if translated back from the Russian-- as "to leave an
automobile standing for a long time." Russian, at least polite
Russian, is more formal than polite English. Thus, the Russian
word for "sexual"-- <i>polovoy-- </i>is slightly indecent and
not to be bandied around. The same applies to Russian terms
rendering various anatomical and biological notions that are
frequently and familiarly expressed in English conversation. On
the other hand, there are words rendering certain nuances of
motion and gesture and emotion in which Russian excels. Thus by
changing the head of a verb, for which one may have a dozen
different prefixes to choose from, one is able to make Russian
express extremely fine shades of duration and intensity.
English is, syntactically, an extremely flexible medium, but
Russian can be given even more subtle twists and turns.
Translating Russian into English is a little easier than
translating English into Russian, and 10 times easier than
translating English into French.
<i>You have said you will never write another novel in
Russian. Why? </i>
During the great, and still unsung, era of Russian
intellectual expatriation-- roughly between 1920 and 1940--
books written in Russian by emigre Russians and published by
emigre firms abroad <i>werecii> eagerly bought or borrowed by
emigre readers but were absolutely banned in Soviet Russia-- as
they still are (except in the case of a few dead authors such
as Kuprin and Bunin, whose heavily censored works have been
recently reprinted there), no matter the theme of the story or
poem. An emigre novel, published, say, in Paris and sold over
all free Europe, might have, in those years, a total sale of
1,000 or 2,000 copies-- that would be a best seller-- but every
copy would also pass from hand to hand and be read by at least
20 persons, and at least 50 annually if stocked by Russian
lending libraries, of which there were hundreds in West Europe
alone. The era of expatriation can be said to have ended during
World War II. Old writers died, Russian publishers also
vanished, and worst of all, the general atmosphere of exile
culture, with its splendor, and vigor, and purity, and
reverberative force, dwindled to a sprinkle of Russian-language
periodicals, anemic in talent and provincial in tone. Now to
take my own case: It was not the financial side that really
mattered; I don't think my Russian writings ever brought me
more than a few hundred dollars per year, and I am all for the
ivory tower, and for writing to please one reader alone-- one's
own self. But one also needs some reverberation, if not
response, and a moderate multiplication of one's self
throughout a country or countries; and if there be nothing but
a void around one's desk, one would expect it to be at least a
sonorous void, and not circumscribed by the walls of a padded
cell. With the passing of years I grew less and less interested
in Russia and more and more indifferent to the once-harrowing
thought that my books would remain banned there as long as my
contempt for the police state and political oppression
prevented me from entertaining the vaguest thought of return.
No, I will not write another novel in Russian, though I do
allow myself a very few short poems now and then. I wrote my
last Russian novel a quarter of a century ago. But today, in
compensation, in a spirit of justice to my little American
muse, I am doing something else. But perhaps I should not talk
about it at this early stage.
<i>Please do. <it>
Well, it occurred to me one day-- while I was glancing at
the varicolored spines of <i>Lolita<i> translations into
languages I do not read, such as Japanese, Finnish or Arabic--
that the list of unavoidable blunders in these fifteen or
twenty versions would probably make, if collected, a fatter
volume than any of them. I had checked the French translation,
which was basically very good yet would have bristled with
unavoidable errors had I not corrected them. But what could I
do with Portuguese or Hebrew or Danish? Then I imagined
something else. I imagined that in some distant future somebody
might produce a Russian version of <i>Lolita.<i> I trained my
inner telescope upon that particular point in the distant
future and I saw that every paragraph, pock-marked as it is
with pitfalls, could lend itself to hideous mistranslation. In
the hands of a harmful drudge, the Russian version of
<i>Lolita</i> would be entirely degraded and botched by vulgar
paraphrases or blunders. So I decided to translate it myself.
Up to now I have about sixty pages ready.
<i>Are you presently at work on any new project? <A>
Good question, as they say on the lesser screen. I have
just finished correcting the last proofs of my work on
Pushkin's <i>Eugene Onegin-- </i>four fat little volumes which
are to appear this year in the Bollingen Series; the actual
translation of the poem occupies a small section of volume one.
The rest of the volume and volumes two, three and four contain
copious notes on the subject. This opus owes its birth to a
casual remark my wife made in 1950-- in response to my disgust
with rhymed paraphrases of <i>Eugene Onegin,</i> every line of
which I had to revise for my students-- "Why don't you
translate it yourself?" This is the result. It has taken some
ten years of labor. The index alone runs to 5,000 cards in
three long shoe boxes; you see them over there on that shelf.
My translation is, of course, a literal one, a crib, a pony.
And to the fidelity of transposal I have sacrificed everything:
elegance, euphony, clarity, good taste, modern usage, and even
grammar.
<i>In view of these admitted flaws, are you looking
forward to reading the reviews of the book? cti>
I really don't read reviews about myself with any special
eagerness or attention unless they are masterpieces of wit and
acumen-- which does happen now and then. And I never reread
them, though my wife collects the stuff, and though maybe I
shall use a spatter of the more hilarious <i>Lolita</i> items
to write someday a brief history of the nymphet's tribulations.
I remember, however, quite vividly, certain attacks by Russian
emigre critics who wrote about my first novels 30 years ago;
not that I was more vulnerable then, but my memory was
certainly more retentive and enterprising, and I was a reviewer
myself. In the nineteen -twenties I was clawed at by a certain
Mochulski who could never stomach my utter indifference to
organized mysticism, to religion, to the church-- any church.
There were other critics who could not forgive me for keeping
aloof from literary "movements," for not airing the
<i>"angoisse"<i> that they wanted poets to feel, and for not
belonging to any of those groups of poets that held sessions of
common inspiration in the back rooms of Parisian cafes. There
was also the amusing case of Georgiy lvanov, a good poet but a
scurrilous critic. I never met him or his literary wife Irina
Odoevtsev; but one day in the late nineteen -twenties or early
nineteen -thirties, at a time when I regularly reviewed books
for an emigre newspaper in Berlin, she sent me from Paris a
copy of a novel of hers with the wily inscription <i>"Spasibo
za<i> Korolya, <i>damn, valetatc-/i> (thanks for <i>King,
Queen, Knave)— <,/i>which I was free to understand as "Thanks
for writing that book," but which might also provide her with
the alibi: "Thanks for sending me your book," though I never
sent her anything. <i>HercJi> book proved to be pitifully
trite, and I said so in a brief and nasty review, lvanov
retaliated with a grossly personal article about me and my
stuff. The possibility of venting or distilling friendly or
unfriendly feelings through the medium of literary criticism is
what makes that art such a skewy one.
<i>You have been quoted as saying: My pleasures are the
most intense known to man: butterfly hunting and writing. Are
they in any way comparable? <Ji>
No, they belong essentially to quite different types of
enjoyment. Neither is easy to describe to a person who has not
experienced it, and each is so obvious to the one who has that
a description would sound crude and redundant. In the case of
butterfly hunting I think I can distinguish four main elements.
First, the hope of capturing-- or the actual capturing-- of the
first specimen of a species unknown to science: this is the
dream at the back of every lepidopterist's mind, whether he be
climbing a mountain in New Guinea or crossing a bog in Maine.
Secondly, there is the capture of a very rare or very local
butterfly-- things you have gloated over in books, in obscure
scientific reviews, on the splendid plates of famous works, and
that you now see on the wing, in their natural surroundings,
among plants and minerals that acquire a mysterious magic
through the intimate association with the rarities they produce
and support, so that a given landscape lives twice: as a
delightful wilderness in its own right and as the haunt of a
certain butterfly or moth. Thirdly, there is the naturalist's
interest in disentangling the life histories of little-known
insects, in learning about their habits and structure, and in
determining their position in the scheme of classification-- a
scheme which can be sometimes pleasurably exploded in a
dazzling display of polemical fireworks when a new discovery
upsets the old scheme and confounds its obtuse champions. And
fourthly, one should not ignore the element of sport, of luck,
of brisk motion and robust achievement, of an ardent and
arduous quest ending in the silky triangle of a folded
butterfly lying on the palm of one's hand.
<>What about the pleasures of writing? cti>
They correspond exactly to the pleasures of reading, the
bliss, the felicity of a phrase is shared by writer and reader:
by the satisfied writer and the grateful reader, or-- which is
the same thing-- by the artist grateful to the unknown force in
his mind that has suggested a combination of images and by the
artistic reader whom this combination satisfies.
Every good reader has enjoyed a few good books in his life
so why analyze delights that both sides know? I write mainly
for artists, fellow-artists and follow-artists. However, I
could never explain adequately to certain students in my
literature classes, the aspects of good reading-- the fact that
you read an artist's book not with your heart (the heart is a
remarkably stupid reader), and not with your brain alone, but
with your brain and spine. "Ladies and gentlemen, the tingle in
the spine really tells you what the author felt and wished you
to feel." I wonder if I shall ever measure again with happy
hands the breadth of a lectern and plunge into my notes before
the sympathetic abyss of a college audience.
<i>What is your reaction to the mixed feelings vented by
one critic in a review which characterized you as having a fine
and original mind, but "not much trace of a generalizing
intellect, "and as "the typical artist who distrusts ideas"?
</i>
In much the same solemn spirit, certain crusty
lepidopterists have criticized my works on the classification
of butterflies, accusing me of being more interested in the
subspecies and the subgenus than in the genus and the family.
This kind of attitude is a matter of mental temperament, I
suppose. The middlebrow or the upper Philistine cannot get rid
of the furtive feeling that a book, to be great, must deal in
great ideas. Oh, I know the type, the dreary type! He likes a
good yarn spiced with social comment; he likes to recognize his
own thoughts and throes in those of the author; he wants at
least one of the characters to be the author's stooge. If
American, he has a dash of Marxist blood, and if British, he is
acutely and ridiculously class-conscious; he finds it so much
easier to write about ideas than about words; he does not
realize that perhaps the reason he does not find general ideas
in a particular writer is that the particular ideas of that
writer have not yet become general.
<i>Dostoevski, who dealt with themes accepted by most
readers as universal in both scope and significance, is
considered one of the world's great authors. Yet you have
described him as "a cheap sensationalist, clumsy and vulgar. "
Why? <i>
Non-Russian readers do not realize two things: that not
all Russians love Dostoevski as much as Americans do, and that
most of those Russians who do, venerate him as a mystic and not
as an artist. He was a prophet, a claptrap journalist and a
slapdash comedian. I admit that some of his scenes, some of his
tremendous, farcical rows are extraordinarily amusing. But his
sensitive murderers and soulful prostitutes are not to be
endured for one moment-- by this reader anyway.
<i>Is it true that you have called Hemingway and Conrad
"writers of books for boys"? <i>
That's exactly what they are. Hemingway is certainly the
better of the two; he has at least a voice of his own and is
responsible for that delightful, highly artistic short story,
"The Killers." And the description of the iridescent fish and
rhythmic urination in his famous fish story is superb. But I
cannot abide Conrad's souvenir -shop style, bottled ships and
shell necklaces of romanticist cliches. In neither of those two
writers can I find anything that I would care to have written
myself. In mentality and emotion, they are hopelessly juvenile,
and the same can be said of some other beloved authors, the
pets of the common room, the consolation and support of
graduate students, such as-- but some are still alive, and I
hate to hurt living old boys while the dead ones are not yet
buried.
<i>What did you read when</i> you <>were a boy? cJi>
Between the ages of ten and fifteen in St. Petersburg, I
must have read more fiction and poetry-- English, Russian and
French-- than in any other five-year period of my life. I
relished especially the works of Wells, Poe, Browning, Keats,
Flaubert, Verlaine, Rimbaud, Chekhov, Tolstoy, and Alexander
Blok. On another level, my heroes were the Scarlet Pimpernel,
Phileas Fogg, and Sherlock Holmes. In other words, I <i>was</i>
a perfectly normal trilingual child in a family with a large
library. At a later period, in Western Europe, between the ages
of 20 and 40, my favorites were Housman, Rupert Brooke, Norman
Douglas, Bergson, Joyce, Proust, and Pushkin. Of these top
favorites, several-- Poe, Jules Verne, Emmuska Orezy, Conan
Doyle, and Rupert Brooke-- have lost the glamour and thrill
they held for me. The others remain intact and by now are
probably beyond change as far as I am concerned. I was never
exposed in the twenties and thirties, as so many of my coevals
have been, to the poetry of the not quite first-rate Eliot and
of definitely second-rate Pound. I read them late in the
season, around 1945, in the guest room of an American friend's
house, and not only remained completely indifferent to them,
but could not understand why anybody should bother about them.
But I suppose that they preserve some sentimental value for
such readers as discovered them at an earlier age than I did.
<i>What are your reading habits today? </i>
Usually I read several books at a time-- old books, new
books, fiction, nonfiction, verse, anything-- and when the
bedside heap of a dozen volumes or so has dwindled to two or
three, which generally happens by the end of one week, I
accumulate another pile. There are some varieties of fiction
that I never touch-- mystery stories, for instance, which I
abhor, and historical novels. I also detest the so-called
"powerful" novel-- full of commonplace obscenities and torrents
of dialogue-- in fact, when I receive a new novel from a
hopeful publisher-- "hoping that I like the hook as much as he
does"-- 1 check first of all how much dialogue there is, and if
it looks too abundant or too sustained, I shut the book with a
bang and ban it from my bed.
<i>Are there any contemporary authors you do enjoy
reading? <i>
I do have a few favorites-- for example, Robbe-Grillet and
Borges. How freely and gratefully one breathes in their
marvelous labyrinths! I love their lucidity of thought, the
purity and poetry, the mirage in the mirror.
<i>Many critics feel that this description applies no less
aptly to your own prose. To what extent do you feel that prose
and poetry intermingle as art forms? .c-/i>
Except that I started earlier-- that's the answer to the
first part of your question. As to the second: Well, poetry, of
course, includes all creative writing; I have never been able
to see any generic difference between poetry and artistic
prose. As a matter of fact, I would be inclined to define a
good poem of any length as a concentrate of good prose, with or
without the addition of recurrent rhythm and rhyme. The magic
of prosody may improve upon wAhat we call prose by bringing out
the full flavor of meaning, but in plain prose there are also
certain rhythmic patterns, the music of precise phrasing, the
beat of thought rendered by recurrent peculiarities of idiom
and intonation. As in today's scientific classifications, there
is a lot of overlapping in our concept of poetry and prose
today. The bamboo bridge between them is the metaphor.
<i>You have also written that poetry represents "the
mysteries of the irrational perceived through rational words. "
But many feel that the "irrational" has little place in an age
when the exact knowledge of science has begun to plumb the most
profound mysteries of existence. Do you agree? <i>
This appearance is very deceptive. It is a journalistic
illusion. In point of fact, the greater one's science, the
deeper the sense of mystery. Moreover, I don't believe that any
science today has pierced any mystery. We, as newspaper
readers, are inclined to call "science" the cleverness of an
electrician or a psychiatrist's mumbo jumbo. This, at best, is
applied science, and one of the characteristics of applied
science is that yesterday's neutron or today's truth dies
tomorrow. But even in a better sense of "science"-- as the
study of visible and palpable nature, or the poetry of pure
mathematics and pure philosophy-- the situation remains as
hopeless as ever. We shall never know the origin of life, or
the meaning of life, or the nature of space and time, or the
nature of nature, or the nature of thought.
<i>Man's understanding of these mysteries is embodied in
his concept of a Divine Being. As a final question, do you
believe in God? cii>
To be quite candid-- and what I am going to say now is
something I never said before, and I hope it provokes a
salutary little chill-- I know more than I can express in
words, and the little I can express would not have been
expressed, had I not known more.
<prexhr noshade="noshade"><small>Last-modified: Fri, 26 Jul 2002 06:11:39 GMT
</small>e-div align="right"xform action="mailto:hit®library.niisi.ras.ru" method="POST"xa hr
e "http://www.kulichki.cotn/moshkow/HITPARADPixfont color="black">Ottetarre<font></a>
yrar Textr:<ttxfont size="-1">‹,/fontx/ttx/form>
</pre></pre></body>e-/html>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2013-06-28 23:31:15 (UTC)
2013-07-01 00:06:11 (UTC)
eric„ carpet , prices , entertainemt. bori,s emial tede, ianM, diva, lang, fanceli hossain, jo
i„ todd, steve, reid marty jay roy ,tonja, „ mette
Summary
Sync jeevacation Name
Sync
Source Gmail
<htmlxheadx/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-I
ine-break: after-white-space; ">eric,  carpet , prices , entertainemt. bori,s emial tetje, ian I., diva,
lang, fanceli hossain, joi, todd, steve, reid marty jay roy ,tonja, , , mette
Body
faith, ehud, peres birthday?
daniel barbro . neuro science<bodyx/html>
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date 2014-09-20 11:18:22 (UTC) Modifed
Note
NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2013-07-03 02:45:20 (UTC)
Title street smarts , vinny crazy MI sam wall , johnny boy, suz,
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body
<html>cheadx/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-
line-break: after-white-space;">street smarts , vinny crazy MI sam wall , johnny boy, suz,
street gang, one makes good by working for wall st tycoon, denies old friends. gets rich but get put
in a position , that requires him to return to old neighborhood and methods to rectify.
gets to see plans boats houses. girls , but no values, friendship. or loyalty the shallowness of the ric
h walters wife anastasia, russian, knows he cheats. but has a good deal.
contrast with little money but gang mentality, true friends laughs, selflessness. uese the word cunt.
the street outsmarts the wall street
waiter sees himself as a ladies man, though he is old and saggy,
uses crazy
a cat.
to detract walter.. crazy blow job. while ginny threatens . by twisting the head off
and then standing out side the private school.
office , = gifts. girls kill competition.? complicit, friends, family faith. risk reward.
street back to back. fights, </bodyx/html>
Note
Source NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Libraty/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2013-07-03 02:45:20 (UTC) Created
Date 2013-07-03 02:47:24 (UTC) Modifed
Title street smarts , vinny crazy sam wall , johnny boy, suz,
Summary
Sync
Source On My Mac
Body
<html>cheadx/headxbody>street smarts , vinny crazy MI sam wall , johnny boy, suz,
street gang, one makes good by working for wall st tycoon, denies old friends. gets rich but get put
in a position , that requires him to return to old neighborhood an<body></html>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
Summary
Sync
Source
NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2013-07-03 02:45:20 (UTC)
2013-07-16 11:53:42 (UTC)
street smarts , vinny crazy MI sam wall , johnny boy, suz,
On My Mac
<html>cheadx/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-
line-break: after-white-space; ">street smarts , vinny crazy MI sam wall , johnny boy, suz,
street gang, one makes good by working for wall st tycoon, denies old friends. gets rich but get put
in a position , that requires him to return to old neighborhood and methods to rectify.
gets to see plans boats houses. girls , but no values, friendship. or loyalty the shallowness of the ric
h waiters wife anastasia, russian, knows he cheats. but has a good deal.
contrast with little money but gang mentality, true friends laughs, selflessness. uese the word cunt. Body the street 
outsmarts the wall street
waiter sees himself as a ladies man, though he is old and saggy,
uses crazy
a cat.
to detract waiter.. crazy blow job. while ginny threatens . by twisting the head off
and then standing out side the private school.
</body></html>
Source
Device
Path
Date Created
Date Modifed
Title
Note
NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2013-07-16 11:53:46 (UTC)
2013-07-16 11:53:50 (UTC)
had a 45 minute conversation with Larry beginning at 3 Pm pst. Many
questions were raised and Larry kindly said he would get back to me. I
told him that this reminded me of the story where the woman walked in
to find her husband in bed with her best friend, upset she ran quickly
over to the side table, grabbed a gun from the top drawer , pointed
at her own head, and said , after i shoot myself, i will shoot both of
you. Larry didn't find it that funny. I cautioned against
memoriliazing preliminary ideas in writing as a written record is
usually extremely counter productive. Larry said we might be able to
seperate the timing of initial email from the ultimate mechanics. A
good idea for many reasons. The idea of a new investment fund, Lany
understood , and immediatley grasped the difficulty if Bill were not to
be involved. I confirmed that I will come on Aug 8, Larry suggested
skype before. ? We talked about level of help Bill was willing or able
to agree on, and I asked if he could better define the future
restrictionsfor me. Loyalty and friendship here are both paramount and
obvious, though- Lany in response to a direct question,and much to
my surprise and considerable dismay, stated that "Yes, Boris had done
something improper. ".
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<html><head></head><body> had a 45 minute conversation with Larry beginning at 3 Pm pst.
Many
questions were raised and Larry kindly said he would get back to me. I
told him that this reminded me of the story where the woman walked in
to find her husband in bed with her best friend, upset she ran quickly
over to the side table, grabbed a gun from the top drawer , pointed
at her own head, and said , after i shoot myself, i will shoot both of
you. Larry didn't find it that funny. I cautioned against
memoriliazing preliminary ideas in writing as a written record is
usually extremely counter productive. Larry said we might be able to
seperate the timing of initial email from the ultimate mechanics. A
Body good idea for many reasons. The idea of a new investment fund, Larry
understood , and immediatley grasped the difficulty if Bill were not to
be involved. I confirmed that I will come on Aug 8, Larry suggested
skype before. ? We talked about level of help Bill was willing or able
to agree on, and I asked if he could better define the future
restrictionsfor me. Loyalty and friendship here are both paramount and
obvious, though- Larry in response to a direct question,and much to
my surprise and considerable dismay, stated that "Yes, Boris had done
something improper. ". <br clear="all">
</body></html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/DataiLibrary/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2013-07-17 13:40:54 (UTC) Created
Date 2013-07-17 14:21:52 (UTC) Modifed
Title lsj, hangar, shed, road gym mad entry, tile pool, outdoor speakers, polish boat, gates. kawasaki se
ats. mules. new equipment, sell old. dome, plants benches beach chairs
Summary
Sync
Name
Sync
Source
Body
jeevacation
Gmail
<html><head></head><body style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-li
ne-break: after-white-space; ">lsj, hangar, shed, road gym road entry, tile pool, outdoor speakers, p
olish boat, gates. kawasaki seats. mules. new equipment, sell old. dome, plants benches beach chair
<span style="line-height: 22px;">zorro telpphpne s teachers, martin ed,
</span>
BIKES
ny chinese, entry, mechanical. table cloths,
biz, corbin fanveilli, leon, mort, bill, ian , terje, , mongoloisa ehud , sinofsky
calls gergen, brice,= hisaline, joe, john luc paris photo. oliveier benny ( 4th )
za ga  Joffe, ,r iamendment, kotick
veron, diva , blaine, todd. david sieve„ mitchell, Joel,
legal brad, M,
aug 4 list , aug 8 , list. Redford, richardson, wyler, dean ,
MY ESTATE
727 g2 g4 hell school pilots?</body></html>
Note
Source Device NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2013-08-03 12:02:30 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2013-08-03 12:03:35 (UTC)
Title environment , includes communication
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<htm1><head></headxbody>environment , includes communication
we are what we consume not what we eat. we consume signals. chemical visual etc
Body
the signals act at a group level . signals even from the physical. </body></html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Libraty/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
2013-08-07 03:25:06 (UTC)
2013-08-07 03:25:11 (UTC)
At the moment, the best way to
communicate with another person on the information highway is to
exchange electronic mail: to write a message on a computer and send it
through the telephone lines into someone else's computer. In the future,
people will send each other sound and pictures as well as text, and do
it in real time, and improved technology will make it possible to have
rich, human electronic exchanges, but at present E-mail is the closest
thing we have to that. Even now, E-mail allows you to meet and
communicate with people in a way that would be impossible on the phone,
through the regular mail, or face to face, as I discovered while I was
working on this story. Sitting at my computer one day, I realized that I
could try to communicate with Bill Gates, the chairman and co-founder
of the software giant Microsoft, on the information highway. At least, I
could send E-mail to his electronic address, which is widely available,
not tell anyone at Microsoft I was doing it, and see what happened. I
wrote:
Summary
Sync
Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <html>chead>e-Jheadxbodyxtable bgcolot="D6E4BF" border="0" cellpaddinr"0" cellspacing
="0" width="862"xtbodyxtrxtd valign="top"><table border="0" cellpadding="0" cellspacing
="0" width="572"xtbodyxtrxtd valign="top"><p></p>
93>
<b>At the moment,</b> the best way to
communicate with another person on the information highway is to
exchange electronic mail: to write a message on a computer and send it
through the telephone lines into someone else's computer. In the future,
people will send each other sound and pictures as well as text, and do
it in real time, and improved technology will make it possible to have
rich, human electronic exchanges, but at present E-mail is the closest
thing we have to that. Even now, E-mail allows you to meet and
communicate with people in a way that would be impossible on the phone,
through the regular mail, or face to face, as I discovered while I was
working on this story. Sitting at my computer one day, I realized that I
could try to communicate with Bill Gates, the chairman and co-founder
of the software giant Microsoft, on the information highway. At least, I
could send E-mail to his electronic address, which is widely available,
not tell anyone at Microsoft I was doing it, and see what happened. I
wrote: <,/p>
<ul>cp>Dear Bill, <fp>
<p>I am the guy who is writing the article about you for <i>The New Yorkencti>
It occurs to me that we ought to be able to do some of the work through
e-mail. Which raises this fascinating question--What kind of
understanding of another person can e-mail give you? ... </p>
<p>You could begin by telling me what you think is unique about e-mail as a form of communicati
on. </p>
<p>John</p><Jul>
<p> I hit "return," and the computer said, "mail sent."
I walked out to the kitchen to get a drink of water and played with the
cat for a while, then came back and sat at my computer. Thinking that I
was probably wasting money, I nevertheless logged on again and entered
my password. <,/p>
<p> "You have mail," the computer said. </p>
<p> I typed "get mail," and the computer got the following: </p>
<ul>cp>From: Bill Gates <billg@microsoft.com>
Ok, let me know if you get this email.</billg@microsoft.com></p></ul>
<p> According to my computer, eighteen minutes had
passed between the time I E-mailed Bill and he E-mailed me back. His
message said: </p>
<ul><p>E-mail is a unique communication vehicle for a lot of reasons. However email is not a sub
stitute for direct interaction.... <Jp>
<p>There are people who I have corresponded with on
email for months before actually meeting them--people at work and
otherwise. If someone isn't saying something of interest its easier to
not respond to their mail than it is not to answer the phone. In fact I
give out my home phone number to almost no one but my email address is
known very broadly. I am the only person who reads my email so no one
has to worry about embarrassing themselves or going around people when
they send a message. Our email is completely secure.... </p>
<p>Email helps out with other types of communication.
It allows you to exchange a lot of information in advance of a meeting
and make the meeting far far more valuable... </p>
<p>Email is not a good way to get mad at someone since
you can't interact. You can send friendly messages very easily since
those are harder to misinterpret.</p>c/ul>
<p>We began to E-mail each other three or four times a
week. I would have a question about something and say to myself, "I'm
going to E-mail Bill about that," and I'd write him a message and get a
one- or two-page message back within twenty-four hours, sometimes much
sooner. At the beginning of our electronic relationship, I would wake up
in the middle of the night and lie in bed wondering if I had E-mail
from Bill. Generally, he seemed to write messages at night, sleep
(maybe), then send them the next morning. We were intimate in a curious
way, in the sense of being wired into each other's minds, but our
contact was elaborately stylized, like ballroom dancing. </p>
<p>ln some ways, my E-mail relationship with Bill was
like an ongoing, monthlong conversation, except that there was a pause
after each response to think; it was like football players huddling up
after each play. There was no beginning or end to Gates' messages--no
time wasted on stuff like "Dear" and "Yours"--and I quickly corrected
this etiquette breach in my own messages. Nor were there any
fifth-grade-composition-book standards like "It may have come to your
attention that" and "Looking forward to hearing from you." Social
niceties are not what Bill Gates is about. Good spelling is not what
Bill Gates is about, either. He never signed his messages to me, but
sometimes he put an "&" at the end, which, I learned, means "Write
back" in E-mail language. After a while, he stopped putting the "&,"
but I wrote back anyway. He never addressed me by name. Instead of a
letterhead, there was this: </p>
<ul><p>Sender: billg@microsoft.com
Received: from netmail.microsoft.com by dub-img-2.compuserve.com (5.67/5.930129sam) id AA0
3768; Wed, 6 Oct 93 14:00:51 -0400
Received: by netmail.microsoft.com (5.65/25-eef) id AA27745; Fri, 8 Oct 93 10:56:01 -0700
Message-Id: <9310081756.AA27745@
netmail.microsoft.com>
X-Msmail-Message-Id: 15305A55
X-Msmail-Conversation-Id: 15305A55
From: Bill Gates <billg@microsoft.com>
To: 73124.1524@CompuServe.COM<billg@microsoft.comx/p>
<p>For years after the telephone was invented, in 1876,
people thought it was a device that would transmit news, drama, and
music: the idea that the telephone was a way to talk to other people
took about twenty years to sink in here, and about thirty years in
Europe. Similarly, today one hears about shopping, banking, and renting
movies on the information highway. These are all possible ways of making
money, of course, but the point of the information highway, it seems to
me, is that it offers a new way of talking to other people. The trouble
people have understanding this simple point is the same trouble people
in the nineteenth century had understanding the telephone.</pciul>
<p>
<b>Bill Gates, aged<b> thirty-eight, is one of
the richest men in the country--the richest in 1992, and the second
richest, after the investor Warren Buffett, in 1993, with a fortune of
six billion one hundred and sixty million dollars, according to Forbes.
Last March, when he announced his engagement to Melinda French, a
twenty-nine-year-old manager at Microsoft, the news made the front page
of the Wall Street Journal. Gates controls the computer industry to an
extent matched by no other person in any other major industry. The
Justice Department is currently trying to determine whether his control
constitutes a monopoly. </p>
<p>Microsoft now supplies eighty per cent of all the
personal -computer operating -system software in the world--that is, the
layer of software that translates your commands so that the computer can
act on them--and fifty per cent of all the application software, which
is the tools, like Microsoft Word (writing) and Excel (accounting), that
run on top of the operating system. Microsoft uses its leverage in the
operating -system market as a competitive advantage in the applications
market--a practice that is not nice but is not necessarily illegal. "You
could say, as I have said to Bill, that having achieved this much power
you should turn your attention to being magnanimous," a rival software
executive told me. "But Bill believes that now is not the time for
statesmanship. Now is the time to conquer new foes, plunder new lands.
He doesn't like being compared to John D. Rockefeller --he goes, 'Hey,
I'm not a grasping monopolist, am 17--but he doesn't know how to behave
any other way. To hold war councils and to design strategies with the
explicit aim of crushing an opponent --this is very American. You know,
Mother Teresa is not going to build the broadband network of the
future." <fp>
<p>Recently, the wife of a software developer was
listening to her husband describe for me what it was like to be in the
same industry as Bill Gates: he was saying, in a pained but stoical way,
that maybe Gates didn't have to be quite so competitive now that he had
achieved great power, and that it might be better for the computer
industry as a whole if he behaved in a more benevolent way, when his
wife interrupted and said to me, "No. You don't understand. We talk
about Bill Gates every night at home. We think about Bill Gates all the
time. It's like Bill Gates lives with us." This enveloping sense of Bill
Gates is hard for someone outside the computer industry to fathom. To
people who are unfamiliar with computers, Gates is just a nerd, and if
you try to get them to square the negative connotation of the word
"nerd" with Gates' incredible success, and with the fact that, far from
being on the margin of society, Gates is now in a position to determine
what society is like, they're likely to say, "Well, I guess it really is
the revenge of the nerds." Actually, Gates probably represents the end
of the word "nerd" as we know it. </p>
<p>But all Gates' influence and success are small
potatoes compared with the influence he could have and with the
opportunity that now lies before him. The computer, which in twenty-five
years has evolved from a room-size mainframe into a laptop device,
appears to be turning into a new kind of machine. The new machine will
be a communications device that connects people to the information
highway. It will penetrate far beyond the fifteen per cent of American
households that now own a computer, and it will control, or absorb,
other communications machines now in people's homes--the phone, the fax,
the television. It will sit in the living room, not in the study. The
problem of getting people to feel comfortable with such a powerful
machine will be partly solved by putting it inside one of the most
unobtrusive objects in the house--the set-top converter, which is the
featureless black box on top of a cable-connected TV set (the one the
cat likes to sit on if the VCR is occupied). </p>
<p>Gates would like to have his software inside that
box. Microsoft's ambition is to supply the standard operating -system
software for the information -highway machine, just as it now supplies
the standard operating -system software, called Windows, for the personal
computer. Microsoft has two billion dollars in cash, and no debt, and
is spending a hundred million dollars a year developing software for the
new machine, which is a lot more than anyone else is spending. The plan
is first to supply the software that allows people to rent videos over
the TV and makes home shopping more attractive, and then to use money
from the video-rental and home-shopping businesses to pay for the
development of the rest of the software. Therefore, Gates is now meeting
with people like Mike Ovitz and Barry Diller to discuss better ways of
delivering their products into people's homes. "I actually requested a
meeting with him," Ovitz told me last October. "I flew up to Seattle and
we had dinner together and spent three or four hours just talking about
the future." </p>
<p>"Could you say specifically what you talked about?" </p>
<p>"It was just very deep stuff about the future." </p>
<p>"Well, for example, did you talk about information -highway software?" </p>
<p>"It goes much deeper than that." </p>
<p>At Microsoft's main office, in Redmond, a suburb of
Seattle, I saw a demo of an early version of the company's operating
software for the information -highway machine, in which the user points
at the TV screen with a remote control, clicks onto icons, and selects
from menus. I heard a lot about "intelligent agents," which will at
first be animated characters that occasionally appear in the corner of
your TV screen and inform you, for example, that President Aristide is
on "Meet the Press," because they know you're interested in Haitian
politics, but will eventually be out there on the information highway,
filtering the torrent of information roaring along it, picking out books
or articles or movies for you, or receiving messages from individuals.
As the agents become steadily more intelligent, they will begin to
replace more and more of the functions of human intelligent
agents--stockbrokers, postal workers, travel agents, librarians,
editors, reporters. While I was at Microsoft, I sometimes felt like
Prey- <P>
<p>Gates' greatest disadvantage in this new market is
that Microsoft doesn't own any wires into people's homes, nor does it
have the computers installed to handle all the switching and billing
that two-way communication requires. To solve this problem, Microsoft
needs to make an alliance with a cable company or a telephone company,
or both. Microsoft has an alliance with Intel Corporation, the world's
leading manufacturer of microprocessors, and General Instrument, a maker
of set-top converters, but it is not a very powerful alliance compared
with Bell Atlantic's alliance with Tele-Communications, Inc., the
largest cable company in the United States, or with U S West's alliance
with Time Warner, the second-largest cable company. Gates is currently
negotiating an alliance involving Time Warner and Tele-Communications,
Inc.--a kind of granddaddy of all alliances, which would have the power
to set the standard for the information --highway machine. A major issue
in the negotiations will be the extent to which Microsoft would own the
software in the machine. Gates would like to retain the rights to the
software; Gerald Levin, the C.E.O. of Time Warner, and John Malone, the
C.E.O. of T.C.I., will not want to give Gates those rights. <,/p
<p>lf Gates does succeed in providing the operating
system for the new machine, he will have tremendous influence over the
way people communicate with one another: he, more than anyone else, will
determine what it is like to use the information highway. Another
advantage Bill Gates has is that he already lives on the information
highway. </p>
<b>New employees<A> at Microsoft are likely to
encounter Bill Gates electronically long before they meet him in person.
Some get to thinking of him by his E-mail handle, which is "billg,"
rather than by his real name. You'll be chatting with a Microsoft
employee in the employee's office, the computer will make a little belch
or squeak, indicating an incoming piece of electronic mail, and it'll
be E-mail from Bill. It is not unusual to hear a young employee say,
"Hey, that's a good idea, I'm going to E-mail Bill about that." While I
was attending a lunchtime cookout at Microsoft headquarters one day, I
heard several people start conversations by asking about E-mail from
Bill: "Did so it mail from Bill today?" "Did you see Bill's mail?"
Billand were in Africa at the time, touring the valley where
the oldest human skeleton, Lucy, was discovered, but I had the sense
that he was present, in the network, flying around the Microsoft campus
and popping into people's computers. <,/p>
<p>The Microsoft campus looks like a college campus:
there are playing fields, and employees in T-shirts and jeans who aren't
much older than college students. Nowhere on earth do more millionaires
and billionaires go to work every day than do so here--about twenty-two
hundred of the fifteen thousand employees own at least a million
dollars' worth of Microsoft stock--but the campus is in no respect
worldly. Workers spend much of their day staring into large computer
monitors and occasionally exploding into a rapid fingering of keys.
Empty soda cans and cardboard latte cups collect on their desks.
Designing software --or "writing code," as people in the trade say--is a
sort of intellectual handiwork. Operating systems, the most monumental
of all software constructions, are like medieval cathedrals: thousands
of laborers toil for years on small parts of them, each one working by
hand, fashioning zeros and ones into patterns that control switches
inside microprocessors, which constitute the brains of a computer. The
platonic nature of software --it is invisible, weightless, and odorless;
it doesn't exist in the physical world--determines much of the culture
that surrounds it. At Microsoft, workers often describe each other as
"smart" or "supersmart" or "one of the smartest people you'll meet
around here," and it is almost an article of faith that Bill Gates, who
co-founded the company with Paul Allen, a friend from his high-school
days, in 1975, when he was nineteen years old, is the smartest person of
all. </p>
<p>"Bill is just smarter than everyone else," Mike
Maples, an executive vice-president of Microsoft, says. "There are
probably more smart people per square foot right here than anywhere else
in the world, but Bill is just smarter." </p>
<p>Gates' office is exactly twice as large as the
offices of junior employees, and his carpeting is a little richer than
the carpeting in other offices; otherwise, there is nothing fancy about
the place. A large monitor sits on his desk, and on the wall behind the
desk are pictures from important moments in Gates' career, many of which
coincide with important moments in the history of the personal
computer. There are also pictures of Gates' two sisters, and of his
mother and father. (No picture of Melinda French is visible, partly
because Gates wants to keep her job as normal as he can.) As in all the
Microsoft offices, one rarely hears the sound of a ringing phone. The
employees send a total of two hundred million E-mail messages to each
other every month. (Over at McCaw Cellular Communications, another
prominent high-tech company, whose headquarters is a few miles from
Microsoft's, phones ring all the time, and everyone wears a beeper.)
Gates spends at least two hours a day at his desk staring into his
monitor, reading and writing E-mail. E-mail allows Gates to run the
company in his head, in a sense. While he is working, he rocks. Whether
he is in business meetings, on airplanes, or listening to a speech, his
upper body rocks down to an almost forty-five-degree angle, rocks back
up, rocks down again. His elbows are often folded together, resting in
his crotch. He rocks at different levels of intensity according to his
mood. Sometimes people who are in the meetings begin to rock with him.
"I think it's just excess energy," Gates said to me about his rocking.
"I should stop, but I haven't yet. They claim I started at an extremely
young age. I had a rocking horse and they used to put me to sleep on my
rocking horse, and I think that addicted me." </p>
<p>Gates does not have the physical charisma of, say,
Steve Jobs, the co-founder of Apple Computer. Like Lenin, Gates leads by
sheer force of intellect. He looks like a teen-ager, but not because he
actually looks younger than thirty-eight. In some ways, he looks
older--a very old little boy. It is the oddly undeveloped quality in his
pale, freckled face that makes him seem boyish. His hair is brown and
is almost always uncombed. He has heavy lips, which contort into odd
shapes when he talks. His characteristic pose when he is standing is
pelvis pushed forward slightly, one arm wrapped around his body, the
other arm occasionally going up into the air as he talks--kind of flying
up, almost spastically, with the palm outstretched, then settling again
somewhere on his chest. His voice is toneless, with a somewhat weary
note of enthusiasm permanently etched into it, and his vocabulary is
bland: "stuff' is "cool," "neat," "crummy," "super," "supercool." </p>
<p>When Gates was in his twenties, his mother
color-coordinated his clothes--he had green days, beige days, blue
days--and then the job was taken over by girlfriends, and now it will
presumably fall to his wife, but so far no one has really handled the
task successfully. "A lot of his friends have said, 'Bill, come on,
let's go on a shopping spree, we'll buy you some clothes,' but it never
works," Ann Winblad, who is now a highly respected venture capitalist in
Silicon Valley, and was the woman in Bill's life for five years, told

me. "Bill just doesn't think about clothes. And his hygiene is not good.
And his glasses --how can he see out of them? But Bill's attitude is:
I'm in this pure mind state, and clothes and hygiene are last on the
list." Esther Dyson, who edits a computer -industry newletter called
Release 1.0., says, "I'm told that within Microsoft certain people are
allowed to take Bill's glasses off and wipe them, but I've never done
it. You know, it's like--'Don't try this at home.' " </p>
<p>Gates is famously confrontational. If he strongly
disagrees with what you're saying, he is in the habit of blurting out,
"That's the stupidest fucking thing I've ever heard!" People tell
stories of Gates spraying saliva into the face of some hapless employee
as he yells, "This stuff isn't hard! I could do this stuff in a
weekend!" What you're supposed to do in a situation like this, as in
encounters with grizzly bears, is stand your ground: if you flee, the
bear will think you're game and will pursue you, and you can't outrun a
bear. I had a chance to try this approach one day in Gates' office, when
I made a remark to him about Microsoft's antitrust problems, and he got
mad at me. I had mentioned the theory that Anne Bingaman, who is the
head of the Antitrust Division of the Department of Justice, would not
have taken the highly unusual and public action of requesting the
Microsoft file from the Federal Trade Commission, which had pursued a
three-year investigation of Microsoft, if she had not felt she could
make a good case against the company. (In the end, the F.T.C. did not
file any charges.) All the soft planes in Gates' face contorted into an
expression of pure sarcasm. "I think you're a little confused," he said.
"You're saying that before they read even a single piece of paper they
judge what kind of case they have?" He choked slightly on his disgust
for my stupidity. "I think you're confused," he said again. "The Justice
Department chose to get the information to decide what to do. Saying
they have a pretty good case before they've read anything --is that how
these things work?" Going by the book, I answered that someone at the
F.T.C. could have told someone in the Justice Department that the case
against Microsoft was strong. This seemed to make the situation worse.
"Look," Gates said. "The Department of Justice is looking at these
files. You know? It's justice? You're supposed to have facts before you
decide things?" I felt a trickle of sweat run down my back. </p>
<p>AII the executives directly under Gates are male,
and almost all are in their mid-thirties. Nathan Mhyrvold, thirty-four,
who as a graduate student at Cambridge University interpreted for
Stephen Hawking, is in charge of new technology. Steve Ballmer,
thirty-seven, who is Gates' best friend, runs the numbers side of the
business. He and Gates met during freshman year at Harvard, when they
lived down the hall from each other. Cramming together for an
advanced -economics exam was a determining event in their relationship.
Ballmer acted this scene out for me, pacing around the room, waving his
arms, the shirttail of his oxford shirt poking out of his khakis, as he
cried, "'Yes! We're golden! We're going to pass! No! Shit! We're
screwed! We're going to fail! No! Yes! We're golden! We're screwed!'
We'd get real up or real down, and it's still that way. We love to get
up and down." </p>
<p>Ballmer is the reason Gates always flies coach when
he is traveling on business. "If you're going to work for this company,"
Ballmer told me, "you're going to rent a certain kind of car and stay
in a certain kind of hotel and fly coach, because that's business, and
anything else is just aggrandizement." Gates once chartered a plane
because he had to get somewhere in a hurry, but Ballmer gave him so much
grief that Gates is still explaining why he did it. Experienced fliers
into and out of Seattle know to scan the cabin for a man with a blanket
over his head-that's Bill Gates, taking a nap. </p>
<p>
<b>Because Bill Gates<A> was my first E-mail
relationship, I wasn't always sure how to comport myself electronically,
and occasionally I solicited advice from experienced E-mailers. Once,
while I was questioning a media analyst named Mark Stahlman about a
point of E-mail etiquette, he said to me, "Well, hey, you're not a
digital guy!" This line often popped into my head when I was E-mailing
Bill. Was I behaving like a digital guy? Is digital guyhood what nerds
will molt into when the information highway reaches everyone's door? One
evening, I was at home listening to some music, doing this geeky dance I
do and, as usual, wondering whether the Wall Street types across the
street were watching me, when I suddenly thought, Would Bill Gates care
about those guys? I took this as a sign I was becoming a digital guy.
Around the same time, I read an essay in <i>Wired</i> magazine by Paul
Saffo, who is a director of the Institute for the Future, a think tank
in Menlo Park, which argued that the information highway is going to
cause a flowering of personal expression not seen in our society since
the sixties, and that when this happens (maybe in five years) people
whom we now think of as computer nerds will have the same hipness that
in retrospect we now assign to beatniks. </p>
<p>I wrote Gates a message with the title "How does the
future make you feel?" (Putting a title on messages is one of the
different things about E-mail communication. It is a little like writing
a publicity release for what you have to say. However, it does focus
the message.) </p>
<ul><p>How does the rapid change in the power of
microprocessors make you feel? The certainty that microprocessors will
grow twice as fast every eighteen months and that nothing in Nature, no
fire or earthquake or tidal wave, is powerful enough to stop this from
happening. Are you thrilled by this? Do you think that this power is
God, as you understand God? Is it possible this power could be bad? </p></ul>
<p>Gates wrote back: </p>
<ul><p>Feelings are pretty personal. I love coming up
with new ideas or seeing in advance what is going to count and then
making it happen. I love working with smart people.... Our business
is very very competitive -one or two false moves and you can fall behind
in a way that would wipe you out. Market share does not give you the
right to relax. IBM is the best example of this. This is very scary but
also makes it very interesting. </p>
<p>The digital revolution is all about
facilitation --creating tools to make things easy. When I was a kid I was
a lot more curious than I am today--perhaps I have lost less curiosity
than the average adult but if I had had the information tools we are
building today I would know a lot more and not have given up learning
some things. </p>
<p>These tools will be really cool. Say today you want
to meet someone with similar interests to talk or take a trip together
or whatever? Its hard and somewhat random. Say you want to make sure you
pick a good doctor or read a good book? We can make all of these things
work so well--its empowering stuff.
Enough for now.</p></ul><p></p>
<p>I wrote a message titled "TV as the Opium of the People":</p>
<ul>cp>Some people are afraid of interactive TV. TV is a
drug, goes the argument, and the technology that Microsoft and others
are supplying is going to make the drug stronger. People will be inside
more than ever, cut off from their neighbors, watching interactive
monster truck contests. Or porno. They will pile up large cable and
credit card charges. A "T. S. Eliot wasteland ... a nation of
housebound zombies," as Michael Eisner put it recently in a speech. Do
you think this could happen? What difference does it make if you invent
smart boxes to deliver dumb programming?</p</ul>
<p>Gates wrote: </p>
<ul>cp>Interactive TV is probably a really bad name for the in-home device connected to the infor
mation highway. </p>
<p>Lets say I am sitting at home wondering about some
new drug that was prescribed to me. Or wanting to ask a question to my
children's teacher. Or curious about my social security status. Or
wondering about crime in my neighborhood. Or wanting to exchange
information with other people thinking about visiting Tanzania. Or
wondering if the new lawn mower I want to buy works well and if its a
good price. Or I want to ask people who read a book what they thought of
it </p<p>before I take my time reading it. In all of
these cases being able to reach out and communicate by using a messaging
or bulletin board type system lets me do something I could never do
before. Assume that the infrastructure and device to do this is easy to
use and it was funded by the cable or phone company primarily because I
like to watch movies and video-conference with my relatives. </p>
<p>All of the above is about how adults will use the system. Kids will use it in ways we can't even
imagine. </p>
<p>The opportunity for people to reach out and share is
amazing. This doesnt mean you will spend more time inside! It means you
will use your time more effectively and get to do the things you like
more than in the past as well as doing new things. </p>
<p>If you like to get outside you will find out a lot
more about the places that are not crowded and find good companions to
go with. </p>
<p>The bottom line is that 2 way communication is a
very different beast than 1 way communication. In some ways a phone that
has an unbelievable directory, lets you talk or send messages to lots
of people, and works with text and pictures is a better analogy than TV.
The phone did change the world by making it a smaller place. This will
be even more dramatic. There will be some secondary effects that people
will worry about but they won't be the same as TV. We are involved in
creating a new media but it is not up to us to be the censors or
referees of this media--it is up to public policy to make those
decisions. </p>
<p>Because TV had very few channels the value of TV
time was very high so only things of very broad interest could be aired
on those few channels. The information highway will be the opposite of
this--more like the library of congress but with an easy way to find
things.</p>c/ul>
<p>I sometimes felt that this correspondence was a game
I was playing with Gates through the computer, or maybe a game I was
playing against a computer. What is the right move? What question will
get me past the dragon and into the wizard's star chamber, where the
rich information is stored? I had no idea where Gates was when he wrote
to me, except that once he told me he was on a "think week" at his
family's summer place on Hood Canal. I could not tell whether he was
impatient or bored with my questions and was merely answering them
because it served his interest. Because we couldn't talk at the same
time, there was little chance for the conversation to move
spontaneously. On the other hand, his answers meant more, in a certain
way, being written, than answers I would have received on the phone. I
worried that he might think I was being "random" (a big putdown at
Microsoft) because I jumped from topic to topic. I sometimes wondered if
I was actually communicating with Bill Gates. How hard would it be for
an assistant to write these messages? Or for an intelligent agent to do
it? </p>
<p>I wrote a message titled "What motivates you?": </p>
<uI><p>You love to compete, right? Is that where your
energy comes from--love of the game? I wonder how it feels to win on
your level. How much do you fear losing? How about immortality--being
remembered for a thousand years after you're dead--does that excite you?
How strong is your desire to improve people's lives (by providing them
with better tools for thinking and communicating)? Some driven people
are trying to heal a wound or to recover a loss. Is that the case with
you?</p>c/ul>
<p>Gates wrote back: </p>
<ul><p>Its easy to understand why I think I have the
best job around because of day to day enjoyment rather than some grand
long term deep psychological explanation. Its a lot of fun to work with
very smart people in a competitive environment.... We get to hire the
best people coming out of school and give them challenging jobs. We get
to try and figure out how to sell software in every part of the world.
Sometimes our ideas work very well and sometimes they work very poorly.
As long as we stay in the feedback loop and keep tying its a lot of
fun. </p>
<p>It is pretty cool that the products we work on
empower individuals and make their jobs more interesting. It helps a lot
in inventing new software ideas that I will be one of the users of the
software so I can model what's important. . . . </p>
<p>Just thinking of things as winning is a terrible
approach. Success comes from focusing in on what you really like and are
good at--not challenging every random thing. My original vision of a
personal computer on every desk and every home will take more than 15
years to achieve so there will have been more than 30 years since I
first got excited about that goal. My work is not like sports where you
actually win a game and its over after a short period of time. </p>
<p>Besides a lot of luck, a high energy level and
perhaps some IQ I think having an ability to deal with things at a very
detailed level and a very broad level and synthesize between them is
probably the thing that helps me the most. This allows someone to take
deep technical understanding and figure out a business strategy that
fits together with it. </p>
<p>It's ridiculous to consider how things will be
remembered after you are dead. The pioneers of personal computers
including Jobs, Kapor, Lampson, Roberts, Kaye, are all great people but I
don't think any of us will merit an entry in a history book. </p>
1:O1 don't remember being wounded or losing something
big so I don't think that is driving me. I have wonderful parents and
great siblings. I live in the same neighborhood I grew up in (although I
will be moving across the lake when my new house is done). I can't
remember any major disappointments. I did figure out at one point that
if I pursued pure mathematics it would be hard to make a major
contribution and there were a few girls who turned me down when I asked
them out.</p></ul>
<p>At the end of one message, I wrote: </p>
<uI><p>This reporting via e-mail is really fascinating
and I think you are going to come across in an attractive way, in case
you weren't sure of that.</p></ul>
<p>Gates wrote: </p>
<ul>cp>I comb my hair everytime before I send email
hoping to appear attractive. I try and use punctuation in a friendly way
also. I send :) and never :(.</p></ul>
<p>I wrote a message asking Gates whether it was
possible that the alliance with Time Warner and T.C.I. was on shaky
ground because Gerald Levin and John Malone were afraid that Gates was
too smart for them. <4>
<p>Gates wrote: </p>
<ul>cpYour mail is the first time I have ever heard
anyone suggest that John Malone and Jerry Levin deserve sympathy. They
are both great people. They are both smarter about deal making than I
will ever be. John and Jerry and I share a vision of what the
Information Highway can become. Its an incredible opportunity for all 3
companies and we have been spending time to discussing how we might help
each other. We don't have anything concrete at this stage although we
have developed a high level of trust for each other.</p><Jul>
<p>I sent a message asking how much of his money Gates was planning on giving away: </p>
<ul>cp>Will there one day be a Gates Foundation, the
way we have Rockefeller, Ford, Carnegie Foundations? When? How acutely
do you feel a sense of social responsibility? What kinds of philanthropy
would you like your money to perform? How do you feel about leaving a
lot of money to your kids?</p><Jul>
<p>Gates replied: </p>
<ul>cp>I think that giving money away takes a lot of
effort. Not as much effort as making it but still a lot to do it
properly. Therefore when I am old and have time I will put some effort
into that. Assuming I still have a lot of money by the time I retire
which is certainly no certain thing I will give away well over 90% of it
since I dont believe in kids having too much money. I am like my friend
Warren Buffett in this respect. I have already done some giving like to
UW for a biotechnology department [Gate gave the University of
Washington twelve million dollars] and some to Stanford for a computer
science building [six million] and some to United Way which I really
believe in. I do believe in funding great research so some of my
philanthropy will relate to that. Some to humans service activities.
Some to education. Some to population control efforts if it looks like
donations can really help there.</p></ul>
<p>I wrote mail about "The Great Gatsby," which is one
of Gates' favorite books. ("The Catcher in the Rye" and "A Separate
Peace" are other favorites.) Gates dressed as Gatsby for his thirtieth
birthday, and again for an engagement party that friends and colleagues
in Silicon Valley threw for him and Melinda in September. (Melinda
dressed as Daisy Buchanan.) </p>
<p>Gates wrote: </p>
<uI><p>Gatsby had a dream and he pursued it not even
really thinking he might fail or worse that what he dreamed of wasn't
real. The green light is a symbol of his optimism --he had come so far he
could hardly fail to grasp it. At the end Fitz is reinforcing what a
romantic figure Gatsby is. Its also sort of about America but I think of
it more in terms of the people.</p><Jul>
<p>Once, when I was composing E-mail to Gates on an
airplane, I felt physically closer to him than when I was composing from
home. Perhaps I was thinking of all the thousands of people who have
encountered this remarkable person on airplanes, restlessly wandering
the aisles with his shoes off, or sitting in a seat staring into the
screen of his laptop computer, rocking, writing E-mail that will be
fired into the network when the plane lands and send hundreds of people
at Microsoft scurrying into action. </p>
<p>Many executives in the telegraph industry, which had
enjoyed control of the communications field since about 1840, believed
that the telephone did not present a threat to their business, because
no one would want a communications machine that did not leave a written
record of the conversation, as telegrams did. When William Orton, the
president of Western Union, which was the Microsoft of its day, was
offered the opportunity to buy Alexander Graham Bell's patent on the
telephone for a hundred thousand dollars, he is said to have replied,
"What use could this company make of an electric toy?" This remark seems
less dim to me now. </p>
<p>
<b>Technological changee-,/b> is not democratic,
but if we did have a choice would we vote for a man who sometimes
behaves like a ten-year-old boy to be the principal architect of the way
we communicate with each other in the future? Or is it Gates' gift that
he isn't socialized in a way you'd expect a corporate executive to be.
When I was ten, I would sit around with my friends watching it snow, and
someone would say, "I wonder what the deepest snowfall ever was," or
something like that, and someone else would say, "Yeah, it would be cool
to know that." It seemed that there should be this giant, all-knowing
brain, which could answer that kind of question. One of the lessons you
learn in becoming an adult is that it doesn't always pay to be curious.
Some people learn to avoid curiosity altogether. Gates appears to have
completely failed to absorb this lesson. My impression is that he still
has the fantasy of the giant, all-knowing brain, and that this is what
the information highway means to him. It's a place where curiosity is
rewarded. </p>
<p>Not long ago, Paul Saffo, of the Institute for the
Future, said to me, "Bill Gates is an introvert. He is not the kind of
person you want building the social network of the future." Ann Winblad,
Gates' former girlfriend, told me, "People who know Bill know that you
have to bring him into a group--say, 'Hey, Bill, tell us the story of
such-and-such'--because he doesn't have the social skills to do it on
his own. But that doesn't mean he isn't social. Bill is an open,
emotional guy--very. He's actually more open with his feelings than most
men I know. He is not afraid to express fear, or sadness, but hardly
anyone sees that. You can't show that when you're in Bill's position,
when everyone is watching your tiniest gesture. It's not good leadership
to show weakness." An executive with a leading competitor of
Microsoft's says of Gates, "Hey--I think the guy is truly dangerous.
Bill is the most surprisingly conscience -free individual I've ever met,
and that amount of power in the hands of a guy without a conscience is
dangerous. Big Brother did not happen in 1984, but it could happen in
2004. Ask yourself, 'If there was to be a technology -oriented dictator
by the year 2004, who would he be? Bill Gates?' "</p>
<p>Gates argues that Microsoft has to behave
aggressively because of a principle called Moore's Law, which is named
after Gordon Moore, one of the founders of the Intel Corporation.
Moore's Law is the reason the computer industry is fundamentally
different from any other industry in history. It states that
microprocessors get twice as powerful, or twice as cheap, every eighteen
months. This means that in twenty years what now takes a year of
computing will take fifteen minutes. We have no idea what we are going
to do with this power, but it will exist whether we want it to or not. </p>
<p>No natural calamity or political upheaval short of
world-wide anarchy is powerful enough to stop it. Nathan Mhyrvold, of
Microsoft, said to me, "Nature has already signed off on this stuff."
Moore's Law is the primary reason that all the companies that dominated
the computer industry in the nineteen-seventies are now struggling or
gone, and the reason that Microsoft, for all its power, could disappear
in a decade. </p>
<p>Scott McNealy, the head of Sun Microsystems, which
is a leading manufacturer of computer workstations, told me, "I like
Bill. Bill is a smart guy. But I think the problem is that Microsoft has
caught the bunny. You know, when you go to the dog track they have that
mechanical bunny that makes the dogs run? Well, sometimes a dog is so
fast he catches the bunny and then the other dogs don't run anymore.
That's the situation in the software business today: Bill has caught the
bunny. I admire Bill for catching the bunny, but now we can't have a
race. He ought to be loosed from the bunny, to give the other dogs a
chance." </p>
<p>The argument that Microsoft is shaping up to be the
Standard Oil of the Information Age and that the government ought to
loose Bill from the bunny before this happens is now being heard within
the Department of Justice. As the head of the Department's Antitrust
Division, Anne Bingaman is an anti-monopolist, the sort of person who
was common around the Justice Department in the nineteen -thirties and
forties, and was thoroughly weeded out in the eighties, a period during
which the laws on what constitutes a monopoly were relaxed, making it
harder for people like Bingaman to operate. Now Bingaman is expected to
regain some of the ground lost by the anti-monopolists, and she seems to
be using Microsoft as her vehicle. Justice Department lawyers are
currently studying the file that Bingaman requested from the Federal
Trade Commission, and are said to be readying a case against Microsoft,
though whether Bingaman will bring narrow antitrust charges, which would
require the company to pay a fine it could easily afford, or will bring
a broad antitrust case, or will even attempt to break Microsoft up, has
not been decided. </p>
<p>There is substantial political pressure not to
prosecute Microsoft. Microsoft is the principal reason that the United
States is by far the world leader in software production, an industry
that has an unimaginable potential for growth. Also, the government's
huge antitrust case against I.B.M., which was filed in 1969 and ended
with the government's giving up on it in 1982, distracted and weakened
that organization, and helped companies like Microsoft to get the better
of it. Some people argue that the computer industry actually wants and
needs a monopolistic presence like Microsoft, because such a presence
can work to create a standard computer language that other companies can
design products for and that the public can use in common. That is the
role I.B.M. played, and now that I.B.M. has been dethroned, thanks
partly to Microsoft, people expect Microsoft to perform it. </p>
<p>
<b>One big difference<b> between Gates and
other early software entrepreneurs is that, whereas the others were
bright kids from middle-class homes who achieved success beyond their
expectations, Gates was born to rule. His childhood was emphatically not
the stuff of Horatio Alger novels. His father, Bill Gates, Jr., is a
well-known corporate lawyer in Seattle and a former president of the
Washington State Bar Association, and his mother, Mary Gates, is a
former regent at the University of Washington and was on the national
board of the United Way and of U S West. Washington State governors and
senators were guests at the house when Bill was a boy. At dinner, the
parents would lead the children --Bill and his sisters, Kristi and
Libby--in discussions of current affairs. The family also played a lot
of games and horsed around together. "I really like Bill's family, but
it would be nice if you could talk to them once in a while when they
weren't in a human pyramid," Ida Cole, a former Microsoft executive, has
said. Water-skiing was and remains a passion of Gates': several
Seattleites have described for me the experience of coming across the
Evergreen Bridge early on a Sunday morning in the summer and seeing
Gates' big powerboat on Lake Washington, with Gates' white, toneless
body water-skiing behind it and throwing up a big coxcomb of spray.
Young Bill was obsessive about improving aspects of himself he didn't
like. "He was always upset about his little toe curling in, so he'd work
on it. He'd spend time holding it out so he'd have a straight toe," his
sister Kristi told Stephen Manes and Paul Andrews, the co-authors of
"Gates," a recently published biography. Gates used to try to impress
his sisters by jumping out of a trash can, and he still occasionally
jumps over his office chair from a standstill. Sometimes, on his way to a
business meeting, he suddenly jumps up and tries to touch as high as he
can on a wall, or to touch higher than the spot he touched last time,
but he says, in "Gates," "I don't jump spontaneously the way I used to,
in the early years of the company . . . or even in a meeting.... Now
the jumping is not that common." However, he has planned a full-size
trampoline for a house he is building. In Japan, a comic book about the
adventures of a boy modeled on Bill Gates is called "Young Jump." </p>
<p>Gates attended Lakeside School, one of the best
private schools in the Seattle area, and there he met Paul Allen, who
was three years older. The two began spending a lot of time in the
school's computer room. In 1971, when Gates was sixteen, he wrote a
program that made it easier for cities to collect traffic statistics.
That same year, he and Allen started a company called Traf-o-Data. In
the Lakeside yearbook for 1973, Gates' senior year, there is a picture
of Gates in the computer room with a stocking cap pulled over his head
and lying on a table, over the caption "Who is this man?" </p>
<p>Joseph Weizenbaum, a computer scientist at M.I.T.,
perhaps overstating the case a little for effect, wrote, in "Computer
Power and Human Reason," this early portrait of computer hackers:
"Bright young men of disheveled appearance, often with sunken glowing
eyes, [who] can be seen sitting at computer consoles ... on which
their attention seems to be as riveted as a gambler's on the rolling
dice.... They work until they nearly drop, twenty, thirty hours at a
time. Their food, if they arrange it, is brought to them: coffee, Cokes,
sandwiches. . . . Their rumpled clothes, their unwashed and unshaven
faces, and their uncombed hair all testify that they are oblivious to
their bodies and to the world in which they move." This description
matches Gates' outward appearance, but Gates was different from most
hackers in one important respect: Hackers were interested in computers
as a hobby, mostly just for fun, whereas Gates always saw computers as a
way of making money. </p>
<p>Gates and Allen sometimes talked about how cool it
would be to design the software for the first personal computer, which
appeared to be on the horizon, but this was not a serious career goal of
Bill's. His father wanted him to become a lawyer. "When I was in
college, it was really hard to pick a career, because everything seemed
so attractive, and when you had to pick a specific one you had to say no
to all the others," Gates told me. "I'd think, Well, if I went to that
law firm some partner might not like me, and they might assign me to
these crummy cases, and I'd think, Well, God, that could be really
crummy." The question was settled in dramatic fashion in December, 1974,
when Allen, who was working in Boston, passed a newsstand in Harvard
Square and saw on the cover of Popular Electronics a computer called the
Altair 8800. The Altair 8800 was the first computer that ordinary
electronics hobbyists could afford to buy and that people with
reasonable technical knowledge could assemble in their homes. Basically,
it was the first personal computer. Allen bought the magazine, rushed
over to Gates' dorm, and showed it to him. "Look!" Allen said. "It's
going to happen! I told you this was going to happen! And we're going to
miss it!" </p>
<p>They called Ed Roberts, the man who created the
Altair, and told him that they had written a version of a programming
language called basic for his computer. That wasn't true. It was an
early use of a now common strategy in the computer industry, and at
Microsoft in particular: announcing products that don't exist (known in
the industry as "vaporware") in order to discourage possible
competitors. After talking to Roberts, Bill and Paul went on an
eight-week code-writing binge, with Gates writing most of the code,
often falling asleep at the keyboard, dreaming in code, waking up, and
immediately starting to write code again, with no real transition
between dreaming and waking-just code. ("It was the coolest program I
ever wrote," Gates later said.) At the end of the eight weeks, Allen
flew out to Albuquerque, met with Roberts, loaded the software into the
Altair, and typed "print 2 + 2." The Altair spat out "4." The program
worked. </p>
<p>By the end of 1975, Gates and Allen had founded a
company, Micro -soft, to sell their basic. (The hyphen was dropped a few
years later.) Now came what is perhaps the pivotal moment in the early
history of the software industry. Computer hobbyists who had bought the
Altair were dismayed to find that it didn't come with the software to
operate it, and were even more dismayed when they learned that they had
to buy the software for four hundred and fifty dollars from Micro -soft. </p>
<p>At that time, no one thought of software as
something you paid for. Software was just rolls of paper tape with
little holes punched in it. A hacker would write a cool piece of
software for fun, copy it, and give it away to his friends. Altair
owners began to do the same thing with Micro-soft's basic. Then, in
February of 1976, Gates published "An Open Letter to Hobbyists" in the
Altair newsletter, and the letter now stands as a sort of Magna Carta of
the software industry--the underpinning of the intellectual--property
structure. It stated, "As the majority of hobbyists must be aware, most
of you steal your software," and went on to argue that software was just
as much a commodity as hardware, because it represented someone's
intellectual work, and that the creators of the software should be
compensated just as creators of hardware were. </p>
<p>Gates shuttled between Harvard and Albuquerque until
the start of his senior year, when he dropped out for good. The
business expanded, and he and Allen relocated it to Seattle in 1978. In
1980, I.B.M. approached Gates to write an operating system for the
personal computer it was designing, the I.B.M. PC. Gates flew down to
Florida to meet the I.B.M. executives working on the project, realized
on the way that he had forgotten to bring a tie, and drove around
looking for a place to buy one. The I.B.M. executives, who had never
laid eyes on Gates, were stunned to see that their prospective partner
looked exactly like one of the hackers they were beginning to read about
in the press. They told Gates they needed an operating system in three
months--an impossibly short time--and Gates accepted the job. Upon
returning to Seattle, he bought an operating system called qdos, which
was short for Quick and Dirty Operating System, from another software
developer, Seattle Computer, for around seventy-five thousand dollars,
renamed it ms-dos, and, in a three-month code-writing marathon,
converted it to I.B.M.'s specifications. <,/p
<p>Software is sometimes said to be to the age of
information as oil was to the age of the machine. Software is what makes
information systems operate. Software is like a natural resource,
except that its source is not in the earth but in the human mind: people
carry pools of software in their heads. Its lack of physical existence
makes its importance easy to underestimate. I.B.M., which was one of the
great business organizations in history, and which was perfectly placed
to own the personal -computer business, disastrously failed to
appreciate the importance of the software Gates designed for it. Because
I.B.M. thought that the money was going to be in the hardware, in the
computers themselves, it allowed Gates to retain the rights to ms-dos.
During the nineteen -eighties, the PC was cloned by other American
manufacturers and by the Japanese, who could make and sell the machines
more cheaply than I.B.M. could, but no one knew how to clone ms-dos, and
Bill Gates collected a fee for every PC and every PC clone sold in the
world. </p>
<p>Two books about the fall of I.B.M. and Gates' role
in it have recently appeared --"Big Blues," by Paul Carroll, and
"Computer Wars," by Charles H. Ferguson and Charles R. Morris--and an
occasional chill runs up the spine of anyone reading them at the ease
with which Gates eviscerated men much older and more experienced than he
was. "I kept wanting to say to Cannavino, 'We need a shorthand because
these meetings are taking too long,' " Gates says in "Big Blues." James
Cannavino was an I.B.M. executive with whom Gates negotiated about
operating systems. Cannavino would begin meetings by making small talk
about, say, his new car, in a misguided effort to establish some sort of
personal rapport with Gates. Also, like many other American corporate
executives of his generation, Cannavino would spend a lot of time
talking about his company's values. This would drive Gates mad. "Every
time you say 'thirteen,' I'll know that what that means is that all you
want to do is what the customer wants," Gates says he imagined himself
saying to Cannavino. </p>
<p>"And for every one of these other gibberish slogans,
we can also get little numbers. There are a lot of small integers
available. We'll just tighten these meetings up. You know, Cannavino, if
you want to talk about how you're going to save the U.S. educational
system, okay, we've heard that story. That's a good fifteen-minute one.
That can be number eleven." However, Gates managed to swallow these
thoughts and let Cannavino talk. "I'm really very good at this stuff,"
he says. "I know how to be somebody's son. You know, 'Yes, Dad.' " </p>
<p>A prominent software executive told me, "I.B.M.
thought they had Gates by the balls. He's just a hacker, they thought. A
harmless nerd. What they actually had by the balls was an organism
which has been bred for the accumulation of great power and maximum
profit, the child of a lawyer, who knew the language of contracts, and
who just ripped those I.B.M. guys apart." Another leading executive in
the software industry said, "Think of I.B.M. and Microsoft as being a
chess game, where Microsoft plays black. So they're at a disadvantage.
So they have to set up a trap. Microsoft becomes the only supplier of a
commodity that I.B.M. could not produce itself. Having done that, it
proceeds to market that asset to weaken its partner's position. It's
brilliant!" </p>
<p>Now, thirteen years after that contract, Microsoft
is by far the largest software company in the world. It has a market
capitalization of twenty-three billion dollars --more than General
Motors, Xerox, or I.B.M. To what extent Gates is mainly a product of
I.B.M.'s blunder, and therefore a kind of historical accident, and to
what extent he is the first person to imagine software as a
shrink-wrapped commodity, and is therefore a visionary, is a good
question to ask if you are seated next to a computer -industry executive
at a dinner party. Although Microsoft continues to manufacture ms-dos,
it has severed most of its ties with I.B.M. The break came over the
operating system Windows, which Gates introduced in 1985. (Paul Allen,
who had a scary encounter with Hodgkin's disease in 1983, retired,
cashed in some of his Microsoft stock, bought the Portland Trail Blazers
basketball team, and built a house with a basketball court on the
property, where the team could practice. He also provided the funds for a
Jimi Hendrix museum in Seattle. Lately, Allen, whose Microsoft stock is
now worth $2.9 billion, has been in the news for buying nearly
twenty-five per cent of America Online, an information service, and,
most recently, for buying eighty per cent of TicketMaster.) </p>
<p>Windows is a graphical user interface, or gui
(computer people pronounce it "gooey"). Instead of operating the
computer with keyboard commands, as you do in dos, in Windows you use a
pointing device--a mouse--to access little folders and documents on your
electronic desktop. Xerox developed the desktop metaphor in the late
seventies, and in the early eighties Apple Computer commercialized it.
Gates saw that Apple's gui was an easier system to use than dos, and
borrowed it. When Windows first appeared, it was widely viewed as a
kludge (a dog): it was buggy (it had glitches) and was a memory pig (it
used up a lot of space in the computer's hard drive), and it was
generally less elegant than Apple's gui. But Gates stayed with Windows
and kept improving it. Gates understood that it did not matter if the
software used lots of space on the hard drive as long as hard drives
kept getting twice as powerful every eighteen months. Also, whereas
Apple chose to keep its software proprietary --it could run only on
machines that Apple made--Gates licensed Windows to any computer
manufacturer that wanted it, just as he had done with dos. </p>
<p>When Apple realized its mistake--its strategy
limited Apple's share of the operating -system market to the number of
computers Apple could sell--it sued Microsoft for copyright
infringement, but a federal court ruled that "the look and feel" of the
desktop metaphor was not covered under Apple's copyright. </p>
<p>It is often said by Gates' detractors that he has
never invented anything, and this is true in a sense, but you could say
the same thing about Henry Ford. When the Model T appeared, in 1908, it
was by no means the best car on the road, but it worked well enough, and
it was affordable and easy to produce, and Ford stayed with it. Even
today, most users still find Apple's operating system more intuitive
than Windows, but, because the market for Windows is so much larger,
other software manufacturers are more inclined to make applications for
Windows than for Apple's operating system. If there is to be a standard
computer language--which from the point of view of the public is greatly
desirable --it now appears that Windows will be the one. But Gates has
to worry that someone will do to Microsoft what Microsoft did to Apple.
Apple is designing a new operating system with I.B.M.; it's code-named
Pink, and is expected to appear sometime in 1995. </p>
<p>
<b>After a month<A> of E-mail between Gates and
me, my hour in his physical presence arrived. As we shook hands, he
said, "Hello, I'm Bill Gates," and emitted a low, vaguely embarrassed
chuckle. Is this the sound one E-mailer makes to another when they
finally meet in real space? I was aware of a feeling of being
discovered. In the front part of Gates' office, we sat down at right
angles to each other. Gates had on normal-looking clothes--a green shirt
with purple stripes, brown pants, black loafers. He rocked throughout
our time together. He did not look at me very often but either looked
down as he was talking or lifted his eyes above my head to look out the
window in the direction of the campus. The angle of the light caused the
purple stripes in his shirt to reflect in his glasses, which, in turn,
threw an indigo tinge into the dark circles around his eyes. </p>
<p>The emotional boundaries of our encounter seemed to
have been much expanded by the E-mail that preceded it: Gates would be
angry one minute, almost goofily happy the next. I wondered if he was
consciously using our present form of communication to express feelings
that E-mail cannot convey. Maybe this is the way lots of people will
communicate in the future: meet on the information highway, exchange
messages, get to know the lining of each other's mind, then meet face to
face. </p>
<p>In each other's physical presence, they will be able
to eliminate a lot of the polite formalities that clutter people's
encounters now, and say what they really mean. If this happens, it will
be a good thing about the information highway: electronic communication
won't reduce face-to-face communication; instead, it will focus it. </p>
<p>I had been told not to ask Gates about his marriage,
because he didn't want to talk about it, but I was emboldened by the
familiarity that E-mail had established between us and asked anyway.
Gates was silent, rocking gently (I interpreted that as a good sign) and
staring down at his shoes. "Well, ifs a pretty conventional marriage,"
he said after a while. "I'm male, and I'm marrying a female. And
there's just two of us. And we plan to have rings on our fingers. And
there'll be a minister. Or, actually, a priest, I think. Since I'm
marrying a Catholic." He giggled. "Pretty standard stuff. In most
dimensions, including this one, I'm just like everybody else. I found a
girl and fell in love with her. I'm kind of old." As he talked, he began
to make a peculiar ahhh sound--a sort of rapturous vocalized pause,
with a little shyness in it, as if he were confiding in me. </p>
<p>"Some of your competitors are hoping that marriage is going to make you spend less time in th
e office," I said. <fp>
<p>"Yeah, I think ... ahhh ... that's a pretty
strange thing. Being married I don't think is that big a change. It did
take up a lot of energy and time being single. I think in a way it's
more complicated than being married. I mean, marriage has its own
complexities, but they're different . . . ahhh ... and I don't think
timewise they're much different. And I've been going out with this
person off and on for a number of years, so it's not like the day I get
married it will be, like, whoa, wait a minute, she uses curlers to curl
her hair, my God!" </p>
<p>Gates and his bride are constructing a
thirty-five-million-dollar house on the eastern slope of Lake
Washington, just outside Seattle--a series of five pavilions connected
by underground passageways, with display screens scattered throughout
the rooms and linked to a central data base containing hundreds of
thousands of famous works of art in digital form. Gates does not own the
art; he owns the right to reproduce the art digitally, and he and his
assistants continue to throw museum officials around the world into
confusion by offering to buy the digital rights to works in their
collections. </p>
<p>"Do you worry that your wealth is going to corrupt you?" <fp>
<p>"Absolutely." Gates sat upright and raised his arms
in the air. "Absolutely. Hey. Being in the spotlight is a corrupting
thing. Being successful is a corrupting thing. Having lots of money is a
corrupting thing. These are very dangerous things, to be guarded
against carefully. And I think that's very, very hard to do." </p>
<p>"How do you do it?" </p>
<p>"I'm very close to my family. And that's important
to me. It's a very centering thing. I live in the same neighborhood I
grew up in. One of my sisters lives there. We get together as a family a
lot. The woman I'm marrying wants when we have kids to have a normal
environment for them. So we'll mutually brainstorm about how to do the
best we can at that." Gates thought for a while, then said, "I am a
person who is very conscious of, like, why don't I have a TV in my
house? I think TV is great. When I'm in a hotel room, I sit there and
try all these new channels and see what's going on. I probably stay up
too late watching stuff. TV is neat. I don't have a TV at home, because I
would probably watch it, and I prefer to spend that time thinking-or,
mostly, reading. So I'm pretty conscious about not letting myself get
used to certain things." </p>
<p>"So do you consider yourself a puritanical person?" </p>
<p>"Oh, no no no. I'm not a puritan," Gates said. "Hey,
if I was a puritan--" He grinned, apparently mentally flipping through a
sequence of unpuritanical acts he had committed. "O.K., it's a little
bit like this. I go to a baseball game, and I'm having a good time,
watching the game, but then I feel myself getting drawn in. I start
wondering, Who are these guys? Who are the good ones? How much are they
paid? How are the other teams compared to this one? How have the rules
changed? How do these guys compare to the guys twenty years ago? It just
gets so interesting. I know if I let myself go to ten games I'd be
addicted, and I'd want to go more. And there's only so much time in the
day. And, frankly, it's easy for me to get interested in anything. I
think, Gosh, am I going to get good at tennis? Well, we got these kayaks
recently. I think, you know, Are we going to get into that? I was just
in Africa. I think, Should I do my next two or three trips
there--there's just so much there--but I'd sort of like to go to China,
and actually I think I'll end up doing that for my next big trip, in two
or three years. So there's all these choices, but time is this very
scarce resource." </p>
<p>As we were saying goodbye, Gates said, "Well, you're welcome to keep sending me mail." </p>
<p>I walked out to my car, drove off the Microsoft
campus, and headed back over the Evergreen Bridge to Seattle. When I got
to my hotel, I logged on and saw I had E-mail from Bill. It had been
written about two hours after I left his office. There was no reference
to our having just met. He was responding to mail I had sent him several
days earlier, asking what he thought of Henry Ford: </p>
<ul><p>Ford is not that admirable--he did great things
but he was very very narrow minded and was willing to use brute force
power too much. His relationship with his family is tragic. His model of
the world was plain wrong in a lot of ways. He decided he knew
everything he needed to fairly early in his life. </p></ul>
<p>
<p>Copyright (c) John Seabrook 2003. All rights
reserved</p>
<p><a href="http://www.booknoise.net/johnseabrookJstories/technology/emaiUindex.html">Back t
o topc/a></p>
<p>
<p><a href="http://www.booknoise.nejjohnseabrookJindex.html">Home</a> I <a href="http://ww
w.booknoise.net/johnseabrook/boolcs/index.html">Books</a>
<a href="http://www.booknoise.net/johnseabrook/stories/index.html">Stories</a> I <a href"htt
p://www.boolcnoise.net/ohnseabroolcIbio/index.html">Bio</a>
<a href="mailto: 1>Contact</a></p>
</p>
</td>
</tr>
</tbody></table>
</td>
<td valign="top" width="145"><img src="http://www.booknoise.net/johnseabrook/stories/books/sr
c/shim.gif' height=" I " width="145"></td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td colspan="5" valign="top" width="862"><table border="0" cellpadding="0" cellspacing="0" wi
dth="862">
<tbody><tr>
<td valign="top" width="862"><a href="http://www.booknoise.net" target="new"›<object type="a
pplication/x-apple-msg-attachment" data=" cid: 6F66D01F-CE74-4316-8974-BF32B866D3BC"›</
objectx/a></td>
</tr>
</tbody></table>
</td></tr>
</tbody></table>
</p>
<p> </p></body></html>
Note
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2013-08-15 03:43:07 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2013-08-15 03:43:11 (UTC)
Title I understand you are confused,,.. please don't call me
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Body <html><head></head><body>I understand you are confused„.. please don't call me
a liar, when you say you are going to tell me a story
and don't, is that a lie„ you tell me you will
dance„and don't., is that a lie„ you tell me you
will do fun sex things, and don't is that a lie... no
i don't think so... I tried to tell you that the
process the other night (pee included) is a good
metaphor for my frustration... As opposed to you
saying JEffrey , i don't want to dance , but i love
you and will try.. so that there is a real effort,
would have been very much appreciated„ instead it's
no. no. no. i don't care what you want.. I'm not doing
it.... the frustration and the stress that
accompanies these actions is difficult for me to take
at this time,' have told you when you were in eulrope
,with regard working out.. please don't tell me that
see what i have done... my prioirites have been clear
you return from europe as if nothing had happened..
you expect me to ignore all that has gone before...I
have previoulsy asked you to accept there are
consequences for you actions,,,, you choose to ignore
this advice„ YOu talk about doing something special
with dana,,,, did you explain to her why you left
paris, as everyone was clear including her that you
hated her.. you come back, and expect her to be
helpful.... with no explanation,,, THERE ARE
CONSEQUENCES,,,,,,When I send you an e-mail that
illustrates the fact tha after asking you to learn how
to make breakfast for over a year„ you tell me you
spent time wiht lance and Mark... Lance has worked
for me , for four moths,,, you have spent less than an
houi;, with him...THe issue of trust runs both ways
WHY should i trust you, how many times since you know
me that I said i would do something for you , and
didn't.., how many months have you told me something
that is totally under your control and turns out not
to be true... What you will find out , and would have
seen if you were not- so self absorbed , was that I
was very ill.. I almost feinted today„I needed oxygen
Ghislaine came to help, I didn't want to worry you or
involve you , as my testosterone levels, can't handle
the stress, YOu don't ask me how I am„ you ask me why
I didn't call....you should be ashamed of yourself...
G/body></html>
Note
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/DataiLibrary/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2013-08-15 03:46:12 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2013-08-15 03:46:16 (UTC)
Title explained that in the first email...
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<htm1><head>c/head><body>explained that in the first email...
> I've spent a lot of time in the past doing petty
> things I thought were helpful but I learned that
> neither one of us benefits from it. As a result you
> are not any happier and I haven't done anything for
> myself. Since I met you, my life revolves around
> you, there is nothing else I have and it makes me
> feel very uneasy. I feel that I have no security;
> like Jean Luc says , all my eggs are in one basket.
> I don't like taking things from you. I want to be
> able to support myself. You are the expert in that,
> you don't believe in school; so how do I learn and
> what ?
> <body></html>
Body
Note
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/DataiLibrary/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2013-08-20 22:53:44 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2013-08-20 22:54:21 (UTC)
Title corbin, brad fancellik sinofsky,
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<html>chead>elheadxbody>corbin, =, brad fancellik sinofsky,
Body
<,/body><Ilitml>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2013-08-22 01:36:04 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-02-03 23:21:10 (UTC) Modifed
Title
I am often asked to give my views and to rate the distinguished list of todays various financiers. I h
esitate to do so as my area of expertise is now philanthropy and was formerly technology, Money is
a product of my past endeavors and the leverage for my future social goas. That being said, withou
t a doubt , one of the smartest people i have ever met, and I fear this statement will be controversia
I.is New Yorks Jeffrey Epstein, both he and I are very aware of his mistakes that now over a decad
e later still cause concern amongst some very accomplished people, but i am a firm believer that eve
ryone, deserves a second chance and then can be measured on the product of the work after asking f
or forgiveness. that is a great part of what makes this country strong.
Summary
Sync jeevacation Name
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <htmlxhead></headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-li
ne-break: after-white-space;">I am often asked to give my views and to rate the distinguished list of
todays various financiers. I hesitate to do so as my area of expertise is now philanthropy and was for
merly technology, Money is a product of my past endeavors and the leverage for my future social go
as. That being said, without a doubt , one of the smartest people i have ever met, and I fear this state
ment will be controversial.is New Yorks Jeffrey Epstein, both he and I are very aware of his mistake
s that now over a decade later still cause concern amongst some very accomplished people, but i am
a firm believer that everyone, deserves a second chance and then can be measured on the product of
the work after asking for forgiveness. that is a great part of what makes this country strong.
Jeffret is neither fluent in spanish, french or italian however he is highly conversant and
multilingual in the areas of the most advanced sciences and finance.. He can exquisitely conduct a s
eminar in fields as diverse as evolutionary biology, computational neuro science.or even the highly e
soteric mathematics that permeate our future. Mathematicans at Harvard marvel at his breadth that s
pans the divide between the esoteric and the very world..
His interests are far and wide and unlike many gentleman scientists that simply repeat back what the
y have read , he has been an integral part of the creative process in varied fields. , signal intelligence,
power law distributions , and encryption. His facile and hyper speed grasping of complex financial i
ssues remains unique in my experience. He neither qualifies nor does he hold himself out as a great i
nvestor like my friend Warren, or an economist like Larry Summers, but his knowledge of money, it
s uses. its technicalities and its burdens are something he has taught many of my colleagues. 1
Again , as to reiterate my open eyes I am well aware that in his colorful past he has made some awfu
I decisions, Im sure he would have done things differently if he had the opportunity to do them over.
however he has paid his debt to society, asked his friends and family for forgiveness and has continu
ed his charitable work that he began even decades before his travails.
i have had the privilege to meet the worlds greatest minds, and i can easily say that Jeffrey s is amon
gst the best of those.
I have utmost confidence in his integrity. I have dealt with him for a number of years on both sides o
f a negotiation and say with certainty that I;d rather be on his side.
He has been in the Billionaire business for longer than almost anyone else. His insight into the uniqu
e problems of the super wealthy , has been invaluable to many others that i know. He found a niche i
n the early 80s discerning the burdens of hyper wealth and from his time on the board of Rockefeller
or his time at the trilateral commission, the common refrain from those he has come in contact with
Jeffrey has made me think differently about. ..../t<span class="Apple-tab-span" style="white-space:
pre"> </span>
He has an extraordinary ability with numbers , complex concepts. mixed with a sometimes brutal ho
nesty, refreshing, a sense of humor that some find highly cultured others find just outright silly,
His homes are probably the best collection of private real estate in the united states. A private island
, that some describe as a tribute to megalomania. and a ranch in new mexico that is truly beyond ima
gination and my favorite townhouse in NY. HIs attention to detail is remarkable . I find it sad that he
doesn't have children of his own, but makes up for it by maintaining close friendships that have laste
d for decades.
His charitable instincts have been honed over many years and his advice and judgment has been inva
luable in several instances. He has funded bold experiments on the placebo effect. string theory , qua
ntum gravity, music and its insight into the brain etc,
His ability to explain complex financial derivatives or opaque concepts that are on the bleeding edge
of science in layman's terms is I believe a part of his teaching gene and enduring charm.
I have met many people who criticize those who continue to maintain a friendship with Jeffrey, pred
ominately by those whose opinions appear on the surface to be impervious to change , however, in t
he vast majority of cases , it is with those that have not had the opportunity to sit with him watch as
his mind performs an intellectuall ballet. gracefully moving from one difficult topic and transitionin
g to another seemingly unrelated , only at the end to have the thread pulled tightly and ending with a
n elegant coda that recaps the various themes .
I can call him and ask , can you explain this to me, and with an impish respond, and a breath of fresh
air, if he can't , he finds it comfortable and ordinary to simply admit - I Don't know. .
</body></html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Libraty/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
2013-09-04 14:05:25 (UTC)
2013-09-09 00:18:13 (UTC)
micahel wolfe. , anthony , danny-ron, corbin fancelli, . ayh, joe. benny , bach, sheely, gershenfiel b
rockman. koons woody, christakis , dunja,
Summary
Sync jeevacation Name
Sync
Source Gmail
Body
<htm1><head><Jhead>cbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-1
ine-break: after-white-space; ">micahel wolfe. , anthony , danny-ron, corbin fancelli, . ayh, joe. ben
ny , bach, sheely, gershenfiel brockman. koons woody, christakis , dunja,
tolison, ron, mahler, burton. , eric rothpeggy,
dome, roy bye bye. salarys . franscno toedd. jessica. jusitna gave scholoar[ to someone else.
carlotn, celestino,
ehud reid hoffman greg
<span class="Apple-tab-span" style="white-space:pre"> <Jspan></body></html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2013-10-01 15:18:20 (UTC) Created
Date 2013-10-05 02:47:42 (UTC) Modifed
Title a--- gift vic, melan, airplane. votes. staff, against the grain, frames.
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <html><head></head><body style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-I
the-break: after-white-space; ">a--- gift vic, melan, airplane. votes. staff, against the grain, • M
a. frames.
ada and alan think stock might go down.?Mi how are you. . liquidate
two directors.
cloud movies
deaed is the new 80
if they threw dirt on him
his hand came off
hump and walker
crow face. not horrific ,
</body>‹,/html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Libraiy/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2013-10-20 10:56:19 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-03-25 12:56:23 (UTC) Modifed
Title dreams conceice On not dreams,
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <html><head><Jheadxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-
line-break: after-white-space;">dreams conceice On not dreams,
denial
msuci and brain,
symmetyr math biology,
truth, fiction
no straight line in nature, math only
energy games. orthogonal emergent
clock 30 hours biology circadian
algorrithms, mental more than one , may per system.
all cooperation is domain specific and time dependent.
video games international business
</body>e--/html>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
Summary
Sync Name
Sync Source
Body
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
fUsers/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2013-11-23 18:15:09 (UTC)
2013-11-23 20:47:47 (UTC)
art basel.
jeevacation
Gmail
<htm1><head><Jheadxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit
-line-break: after-white-space;">art basel.
gift trust. ada divorce, museum, daf, curators. , tra brh, tax director. . brad, alan,boat. /? early pay .
deductibility
airplane,  art loan, notes. phantom. insurance. cost. sales. gifts. tra. , investments. trees, . loan agr
eements. lerner. ? met? 1031 ,
no real help tax , rich. ? gift. . visa C, ? house? , letaicia. josh successor, </bo
dy></html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path fUsers/Story/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2013-11-23 22:05:28 (UTC) Created
Date 2013-11-23 22:09:31 (UTC) Modifed
Title a book about yourself so you know how it ends— - what are your hopes. - pleasure girl,
why not.- when do you stop.
Summary
Sync
Name
Sync
Source
Body
jeevacation
Gmail
<htmixheadxfheadxbody>wendi— a book about yourself so you know how it ends— what ar
e your hopes. - pleasure girl, why not.- when do you stop.
share , enter, you give me alife . honest - true not important
Jacques, no prioirtes. impedes, creativintu no grades focus on positive, follow nose. takes subway, j
apan food sumo. arab, arabic renew. equivalent degrees europe, . culture army, backbone, language.
. enter by sports, singing , living arts. <,/body>c/html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2013-11-24 00:10:07 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2013-11-24 00:10:59 (UTC)
Title learning,  refined. eat slow. very slow. tea half cup seasonal, . massage
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<htm1><head>e-Theadxbody>leaming„ refined. eat slow. very slow. tea half cup seasonal, . ma
ssage
Body
<,/body>c/html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2013-12-14 14:02:17 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-04-20 12:43:29 (UTC) Modifed
Title xmas presents. tall road block, signature, tennis, masks, move statues, pots , flagpole rug , pictures
grotto. rug grotto. solar . ken email service road arm rest covers
Summary
Sync
Name
Sync
Source
Body <htm1><head>e-/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-li
ne-break: after-white-space;">xmas presents. tall road block, signature, tennis, masks, move statue
jeevacation
Gmail
s, pots , flagpole rug , pictures grotto. rug grotto. solar . ken email service road arm rest covers
G/body></html>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2013-12-29 01:56:30 (UTC)
2014-06-22 21:09:05 (UTC)
woody, she's making sure there is not one molecule of flavor left. . it going to look light recycle
d fabric.
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <htmlxhead>e--/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-1
ine-break: after-white-space;">woody, she's making sure there is not one molecule of flavor left. . i
t going to look light recycled fabric.
on cheating and marriage you can't beat the house
you lay o the couch talking about seeing your parent s in bed trying to break the habit of sleeping w
ith tall blondse makes no sense
upton. a miracle of nature,
an uphill battle .
black girls are all horrible fucks
lactade. soon yi has an opinion about everything. . mon sahl.
i don't want to go to moes hospital and repair shop
taco medical care
forrest lawn
wives ending up looking like something you would see on you plate at a seafood restaurant
cruel waters.
if knighthood comes back into fashion they re in
pigeons stuck to the gook, had to pry them off and flip them on to fifth avenue
the last frankfurter i had was 50 years ago , i still have gas
camege deli to die for. literally, it clogs your arteries, if you don;t die from cholesterol you die from
the guilt<bodreatml>
Note
Source Device NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2014-02-03 23:21:20 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2014-02-03 23:50:39 (UTC)
Title soundproofing, . gaspers larry woodesecurity tv
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<htm1><head>elheadxbody>soundproofing, . gaspers larry wood king security tv
Body
<bodyx/html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2014-02-04 23:59:34 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-06-19 13:18:59 (UTC) Modifed
jagland sultan, shah:,. .rh :), jack lang, jean luc, daviiina o, axel, colon ,
Title farice, , athena, daniel fred girls.hamad blai
ne, fekkai, jagland
Summary
Sync
Name
Sync
Source
Body
jeevacation
Gmail
<html>cheadx/heacixbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-li
ne-break: after-
° axel,
'>jagland, sultan, shaher. aham d, pinto, jack lang, jean luc, navin a, ma
olon , farice, athena, daniel
fred girls. amad blaine, fekkai, jagland
blaine fekkai. reid joi
debbie die first?? gains losses price.fair market. e
clbody></html>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2014-02-09 17:27:06 (UTC)
2014-02-19 14:32:01 (UTC)
financial 64 percent bank, 100 art cars ? , paris, country side. africa properties. non financial
mjaeve, wine, lafite 171. land. foundation boats?
Summary
Sync jeevacation Name
Sync  Source Gmail
Body
<htmlxheadx/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-I
the-break: after-white-space;">financial 64 percent bank, 100 art cars ? , paris, country side. africa
properties. non financial mjaeve, wine, lafite 171. land. foundation boats?
. all to trust =exeunt splite four ways neomei 30 ( drug risk ?) nothing after. . three to take if b
otl.t e, no wills for girls. claude one of three , was already fired. / rene, 75 old but trusted.
6 half inter 16 b shares.. non financial 40 percent.. / reps on board, bertran traitor re majev
e,
guardian mother brother rene , henri.. de guns burg currently.. swiss law , requirements.
cameroon, ?
<ol start="0"><1i> trusts for each girl? will for nomei, names of -lawyer, benj lawyer, </11></
ol></body>c/htrnl>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2014-02-09 17:27:06 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-02-19 14:32:01 (UTC) Modifed
Title financial 64 percent bank, 100 art cars ? , paris, country side. africa properties. non financial
mjaeve, wine, lafite 171. land. foundation boats?
Summary
Sync jeevacation Name
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <html>cheadx/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-I
the-break: after-white-space;">financial 64 percent bank, 100 art cars ? , paris, country side. africa
properties. non financial mjaeve, wine, lafite 171. land. foundation boats?
. all to trust Mexecutr. splite four ways neomei 30 ( drug risk ?) nothing after. . three to take if b
li ne, no wills for girls. claude one of three , was already fired. / rene, 75 old but trusted.
16 half inter 16 b shares.. non financial 40 percent. . / reps on board, bertran traitor re majev
e,
guardian mother brother rene , henri.. de guns burg currently.. swiss law , requirements.
cameroon, ?
<01 start="0"xli> trusts for each girl? will for nomei, names alawyer, benj lawyer, <Rix/
ol></body>c/litml>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2014-02-19 14:32:33 (UTC)
2014-02-19 14:55:34 (UTC)
barry bottstein, woody, . peggy. joe phil michaels. . ian, gates. david mitfchell =IIMIPpug,
Title warren , wolfe,anthony , paul barrett. , chinatownjagland joi, melz. corbin? 727? sultan afric
a,
Summary
Sync jeevacation Name
Sync
Source
Body
Gmail
<htmlxhead>e--/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-li
ne-break: after-white-s ace;">barry bottstein, woody, . peggy. joe phil michaels. . ian, gates. david
mitfchell pug, warren , wolfe,anthony , paul barrett. , chinatownjagland joi,

z. corbin? 727? sultan africa,
ari barnaby, daniel loen trust art phil , barbados ,tra,brh, insurance.? visa, bill.
bard sat. assaya. athena
no kar no leon, free
jacques, more time, gianni 'ean luc, .
wledge ). eduardos friend.
Note
decoratin o ( old ). miachea playboy no kno
mess. , torrible, <,/body></html>
Source Y NCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2014-02-19 14:32:33 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-02-19 14:55:34 (UTC) Modifed
barry bottstein, woody, . peggy. joe phil michaels. . ian, gates. david mitfchell S pug,
Title warren , wolfe,anthony , paul barrett. , chinatownjagland joi, melz. corbin? 727? sultan afric
a,
Summary
Sync
Name
Sync
Source
jeevacation
Gmail
<html>chead>e-/head>cbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-li
ne-break: after-white-space;">bany bottstein, woody, . peggy. joe phil michaels. . ian, gates. david
mitfchell =MI pug, warren , wolfe,anthony , paul barrett. , chinatownjagland joi, nina,
z. corbin? 727? sultan africa
ari barnaby, daniel sue/ loen trust art phil , barbados ,tra,brh, insurance.? visa, bill.
bard sat. assaya. athena
Body
no kar no leon, free
jacques, more time, gianni M. jean luc, . marian.decoratin , into ( old ). miachea playboy no kno
wledge ). eduardos friend.,, mess. orrible, G/body></html>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2014-03-10 12:51:39 (UTC)
2014-03-24 19:08:48 (UTC)
martin, novak, sleeping with your wife is a perversion. , false accounts no penalty„ beauty sym
metry , body adapts to the task, .
Summary
Sync . jeevacation Name
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <htmlxhead>e-/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-1
ine-break: after-white-space;">martin, novak, sleeping with your wife is a perversion. , false accou
nts no penalty,  beauty symmetry , body adapts to the task, .
peter diamandis, singularty finance. austin hill. reid
billl paul, salar, paige. brooks, pigazzi„
tede, kazak azerjagland
rothschild
cahrlie rose
bill leon, josh, joi reid tazia
gordon getty I write so that i can take myself apart cell by cell and put it back together so that it is a
little better.
wooed if my grandmother was an indian, i would be yelling at the rocks for hours tbecuase she was
deaf
not a car for miles :: not a bookstore either
</bodyx/html>
Note
Source Device NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/DataiLibrary/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2014-04-11 23:16:00 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2014-04-11 23:17:05 (UTC)
Title , bitcoin
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<htm1><headx/headxbody>=, bitcoin
Body
model gene bank,
wyler sat ligt
mortgage
boris bill daf
terje , peace. kazak mongolia
‹body></html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title margo nami, atehn daneil S gianni, jean luc jacques oliveier , rams
ey . photos shirts. leah, jaglnand =joe, boris.
Summary
Sync
Name
Sync
Source
Body
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<htmlxheadx/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit
-line-break: after-white-space;"> photos
tetje„ india, kazak, mongolia. norway,
2014-04-20 12:41:40 (UTC)
2014-04-20 13:31:21 (UTC)
jeevacation
Gmail
<htmlxhead>e,Theadxbody:igword-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nlamode: space; -webkit-1
ine-break• after-white margo nami, atehn daneil gianni, jean luc jacqu
es = oliveier , . ramsey ..photos shirts. leah, jaglnand joe, boris.
summers joi.M, marl, reid, page, brockman
tv down;aods for trip fur blanket. plane. </body>‹,/html>
Note
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Libraty/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2014-05-17 13:01:14 (UTC)
2014-06-10 13:05:29 (UTC)
photos
Body bill daf, , satellite. charity.
greg,
</body>‹,/html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2014-06-14 10:51:59 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-06-14 11:03:47 (UTC) Modifed
Title wexner
Summary
Sync jeevacation Name
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <htmlxheadx/headxbody>wexner
necklaace . mother suicide taxes, new albany, bankrupt, never ever, did anything without inf
orming les.. questionable as to unrelated third party, jack kessler, stanley, jerry,  my personal. taken
advantage of, understand scared, i would never put les in harms way. He never called. sale of trust, p
ut call. despont , dick grey ,i followed. . put in fake secretary, . , took an attny, I would never g
ive him up. craig , lursen, everyday 24 hrs a day, security„ jancks house. new albay, aspen, .
ghislane
stood by , father, brothers, wexner, apt, house. forrester, mother, money, rescued
ted, dana,
concord, skiing, hollywood, support before and after,
dersh
don't take deal, probation 5 years with 3 early term. no details of probation transfer
30k per day, millions, brother, ] roy,
lefcourt . stole money, wanted to delay lily, fought with guy
guy lewis, crooked, high five , new biz,
cayne,
fergie , helped lent money, mother argentina, re hab, . mothers army,
</body><Ihtml>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.Notes/DataiLibraty/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2014-06-19 12:57:25 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-06-19 13:02:48 (UTC) Modifed
Title ;chrome glasses binkets. paper towel. salt pepper plates. spit sink, instant coffees.
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
<htmlxheadxfheadxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-1
ine-break: after-white-space;">;chrome glasses blnkets. paper towel. salt pepper plates. spit sink, in
stant coffees.
Body
greg, eric roth, ramsey, barbro , joe , thorborn. mette, haircut, avis rent
a car<,/body>eihtml>
Note
Source Device NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2014-06-25 12:30:19 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2014-06-25 12:30:24 (UTC)
Title 1in1490151429.
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Body <htm1><headx/head><body>lin1490151429.4bodp-e-/html>
Note
Source Device NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2014-07-06 11:34:06 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2014-07-06 11:34:11 (UTC)
Title justify your existence
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Body <html>cheadx/headxbody>justify your existencee-,/bodyx/html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2014-07-11 12:50:06 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2014-07-11 12:50:48 (UTC)
Title coffee„ cups mil, glasses cue. paper towel children meeting, blankets
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<html>cheadx/headxbody>coffee„ cups mil, glasses cue. paper towel children meeting, blan
kets Body
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date 2014-07-13 09:52:58 (UTC) Modifed
Title airplane , blamkets, coffee cups. snacks.
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<html><head></headxbody>airplane , blamkets, coffee cups. snacks.
Body lsj, rugs master, new cabana furniture, vehicles. landscaper. uniforms, mirror , kite house door roa
ds<body></html>
€-/body></html>
Note
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2014-07-13 09:51:33 (UTC)
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2014-07-15 11:43:36 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-09-06 09:32:53 (UTC) Modifed
Title systems breakdown, back 14 15. january, testsoene. weight, apnea.
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <htmlxheadxfheadxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-I
ine-break: after-white-space;">systems breakdown, back 14 15. january, testsoene. weight, apnea.
dash tede bill bums, , mort? boris, daniel mar. mich, peggy, ugo
vet
bill , rummler alma-woody, shaher. dasha, sanna,
re do , ny, pb, lsj , paris. .
leah price harvard english for science editor
</body></html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2014-10-05 09:26:16 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-10-10 19:46:27 (UTC) Modifed
Title why does solitary confinement make you crazy, what is the good that cancer does. ? what is intell . Igence at the 
atomic level?
Summary
Sync . jeevacation Name
Sync
Source Gmail
<htmlxhead>‹,theadxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-1
ine-break: after-white-space;">why does solitary confinement make you crazy, what is the good tha
t cancer does. ? what is intelligence at the atomic level?
lanague is chomasky inherit internal signalling method for thought
Body
conciousness, falling, deception biology mathematics, signal intelligence.
sitting on toilet like slot machine, hoping for a big win, when winning rain into bowl
</body></html>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source
Body
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2014-10-10 19:42:34 (UTC)
2014-10-10 20:08:09 (UTC)
johna, camila alma. melize, daniel ramsey,
Gmail
<htmlxheadx/headxbody st le="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-
line-break: after-white ;">n johna, camila alma. melize,aniel ramsey,
assay , ukriana
gregory apt,
amine, jalang. jabor, kelimbtv. churkin
gates, boris, terje,. leon, mort, sergey thiel, bums, rumeeler eric
leah, gianni, oliver , reid reid joi torn lany
ehud nov
G/bodyx/html>
Note
Source Device NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2014-11-10 02:05:43 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2014-11-10 02:07:24 (UTC)
Title fortune cookies
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Body <htmlxheadx/headxbody>fortune cookies
you will be horribly mangled
you will not have a moments peace
the woman you love is betraying you
you will be bought in a thrashing machine
premature death awaits you
all your friends despise you
the spot in your X-ray is a tumor
‹bodyx/html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2014-11-25 22:45:02 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-11-25 23:11:38 (UTC) Modifed
Title bbj, steve davdi terje, boris joe,. daneil, alma.
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<htmI><head></headxbody>bbj, steve davdi terje, boris, joe, , daneil, alma. e
Body
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
johan MI as wen, M, men
goe;osit, uiersity plants
1
greg time, zorro improv
</bodyx/htznI>
Note
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2014-12-09 15:26:47 (UTC)
2015-07-11 19:11:48 (UTC)
Title Ma faye, goldstein,deena, elaine,
organ dotty celine jill,strassner
paula, lurie metcalf, , m
Summary
Sync
Name
Sync
Source
Body
jeevacation
Gmail
<html>chead>e--/headxbodya="word-wrabreak-word• -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-1
ine-break: after-white-s ace;" MI IM, faye, goldstein,deena, elaine, paula,
lurie metcalf , Morgan dotty celine jill,strassner
inka,  rene, kell ,
agitjill rapproport. francis,
s, graionva
ghislaine luba,= =1, a M
voss glass to cohen
grace an new york haita <body>eihtml>
Note
vicky, fitzbibbons, dara tone
yfIced.
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/DataiLibrary/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2014-12-29 10:31:46 (UTC) Created
Date 2014-12-31 10:35:32 (UTC) Niodifed
Title sell all property? steve gone. 'damn
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <html>chead>c/head>cbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-
line-break: after-white-space;">sell all property? steve gone. 'danen
rich larry
apts trusts /
jean luc, reid peggy, ian peter. peter. mande. gh,
jagland,=. leon, terje,
jean luc, all at customs, mirror. brad pimp, </bodre--/html>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<html>cheadx/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit
-line-break: after-white-space;">sleep. cooperation
power laws
signal intelligence
humamies as translator.
music as lens into brain
deception
beuaty, energy, expended
gravity as a power law , is the pull toward the eman equivalent to grabvity.
blue eyes genius
internal algorihtms and encryption olfaction
first names indivudlat over family
distributions.
gravity as a distribuiton
Body
NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2014-12-29 10:35:31 (UTC)
2015-02-24 10:49:17 (UTC)
sleep. cooperation
<,/body></html>
Note
Source Device NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2015-01-27 10:43:57 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2015-01-27 10:44:51 (UTC)
Title norton.
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<html>cheadx/headxbodya,
biz leon , bill mort..tetje,
social
Body travel
sceince
health
householdc/body></html>
Note
norton.
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2015-03-18 14:39:12 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2015-03-18 14:39:44 (UTC)
Title wall fountain palm, art arianedudley, gardener. wallace.
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<htmlxheadx/headxbody>wall fountain palm, art arianedudley, gardener. wallace.
Body
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
Summary
Sync Name
Sync Source
Body
<,/bodyx/html>
Note
NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2015-04-08 11:46:26 (UTC)
2015-04-08 11:46:31 (UTC)
Date/Time: 2015-04-08 07:43:31 -0400
jeevacation
Gmail
<html>chead>e-/head><body>
Date/Time: 2015-04-08 07:43:31 -0400
OS Version: 10.10.2 (Build 14C109)
Architecture: x86_64h
Report Version: 21
Command: Firefox
Path: /Applications/Firefox.app/Contents/MacOS/firefox
Version: 37.0.1 (3715.4.2)
Parent: launchd [1]
PID: 43032
Event: hang
Duration: 1.70s (process was unresponsive for 29 seconds before sampling)
Steps: 18 (100ms sampling interval)
Hardware model: iMac15,1
Active cpus: 8
Fan speed: 1198 rpm
Timeline format: stacks are sorted chronologically
Use -i and -heavy to re-report with count sorting
Heaviest stack for the main thread of the target process:
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971F1EE096A0> + 2103673) [0x100701979]
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136]
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xfffiff7f80de29 lc]
Process: firefox (Firefox) [43032]
Path: /Applications/Firefox.app/Contents/MacOS/firefox
Architecture: x86_64
Parent: launchd [1]
UID: 501
Task size: 188804 pages
CPU Time: 0.004s
Note: Unresponsive for 29 seconds before sampling
Thread 0x50874d DispatchQueue 1 18 samples (1-18) priority 47
<frontmost, thread QoS user interactive, boosted, received importance donation from WindowSer
ver [105], IO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103673) [0x100701979] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xt11fft7f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x50875d DispatchQueue 2 18 samples (1-18) priority 47
<frontmost, thread QoS user interactive, boosted, received importance donation from WindowSer
ver [105], 1O policy important>
18 _dispatch_mgr thread + 52 (libdispatch.dylib + 19050) [0x7fff94352a6a] 1-18
18 kevent64 + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 94770) [0x7fff8f3b2232] 1-18
*18 ??? (kernel + 5988368) [0xf1111180007b6010] 1-18
Thread 0x508760 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 thread_start + 13 (libsystem_pthread.dylib + 5149) [0x7f1192fe541d] 1-18
18 _pthread_start + 176 (libsystem_pthread.dylib + 12773) [0x7fff92fe71e5] 1-18
18 ??? (<390A2BB0-CAA4-3FFD-B19B-ED I 5A8313953> + 31518289) (Ox10360ee511 1-18
18 mach_msg_trap + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 70878) [Ox7f118f3ac4de] 1-18
*18 ipc_mqueue_receive_continue + 0 (kernel + 1165472) [0xffffff800031c8a0] 1-18
Thread 0x508766 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 kevent + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 94746) [0x7fff8f3b221a] 1-18
*18 ??? (kernel + 5988368) [0xf1111180007b6010] 1-18
Thread 0x50876a 18 samples (1-18) priority 31 cpu time 0.001s
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 _select + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 91130) [0x7fff8f3b13fa] 1-18
*18 ??? (kernel + 6142240) [0xffffff80007db920] 1-18
Thread 0x50876b 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971F1EE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xf111117f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x50876c 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971F1EE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [Ox7f118f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xfffffr f80de29 lc] 1-18
Thread 0x50876d 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971F1EE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xf111117f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x50876e 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971F1EE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [Ox7f118f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xfffffr f80de29 lc] 1-18
Thread 0x50876f 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxftf1t17f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x508770 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxftf1t17f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x508771 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxftf1t17f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x508772 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xft11t17f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x508773 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xft11t17f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x508774 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxftf1t17f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x508775 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [Ox7ftt8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxffffff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread 0x508776 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], fO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxffffff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread Ox508777 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 ??? (<390A2BBO-CAA4-3FFD-B19B-ED15A8313953> + 36899438) [0x103b30a6e] 1-18
18 mach_msg_trap + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 70878) [0x7fff8f3ac4de] 1-18
*18 ipc_mqueue_receive_continue + 0 (kernel + 1165472) [Oxf11111800031c8a0] 1-18
Thread Ox508778 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], fO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103673) [0x100701979] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxffffff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread Ox50877b 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971F1EE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxffffff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread Ox508788 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], fO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxffffff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread Ox508789 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], IO policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971F1EE096A0> + 2103673) [0x100701979] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxffffff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread Ox50878a 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], fO policy important>
18 ??? (<6513B947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2105340) [Ox 100701fit] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxfffiff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread 0x508795 18 samples (1-18) priority 47 cpu time 0.003s
<frontmost, thread QoS user interactive, boosted, received importance donation from WindowSer
ver [105], 1O policy important>
18 thread_start + 13 (libsystem_pthread.dylib + 5149) [0x7fff92fe541d] 1-18
18 _pthread_start + 176 (libsystem_pthread.dylib + 12773) [0x7ffi92fe71e5] 1-18
18 _pthread_body + 131 (libsystem_pthread.dylib + 12904) [Ox7fl192fe7268] 1-18
18 _NSEventThread + 137 (AppKit + 1602363) [0x7fff8fbf83313] 1-18
18 CFRunLoopRunSpecific + 296 (CoreFoundation + 464984) [0x7fff98761858] 1-18
18 _CFRunLoopRun + 1371 (CoreFoundation + 466939) [0x7ffi98761ffb] 1-18
18 _CFRunLoopServiceMachPort + 212 (CoreFoundation + 469812) [0x7fff98762b34] 1-18
18 mach_msg_trap + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 70878) [0x7fff8f3ac4de] 1-18
*18 ipc_mqueue_receive_continue + 0 (kernel + 1165472) [Oxf11111800031c8a0] 1-18
Thread 0x50879a 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<6513B947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2105340) [Ox 100701 ffc] 1-18
18 __psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxfffiff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread 0x50879b 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5],[O policy important>
18 ??? (<6513B947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxffffir f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread 0x50879e 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<390A2BBO-CAA4-3FFD-B19B-ED I 5A8313953> + 36899438) [0x103b30a6e] 1-18
18 mach_msg_trap + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 70878) [0x7fff8f3ac4de] 1-18
*18 ipc_mqueue_receive_continue + 0 (kernel + 1165472) [Oxf11111800031c8a0] 1-18
Thread 0x5087a0 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5],[O policy important>
18 ??? [0x8000000000000000] 1-18
18 ??? (<390A2BBO-CAA4-3FFD-B19B-ED I 5A8313953> + 2935256) [0x101acc9d8] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xfff1117f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x5087a1 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5],[O policy important>
18 ??? [0x8000000000000000] 1-18
18 ??? (<390A2BBO-CAA4-3FFD-B19B-ED15A8313953> + 2935256) [OxlOlacc9d8] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxfffiff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread 0x5087a2 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65138947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2105340) [Ox 100701 ffc] 1-18
18 _psynch_cmait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xfffff17f80de291c] 1-18
Thread Ox5087ab 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5],[O policy important>
18 ??? (<65138947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2105327) [Ox 10070Ifef] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [Ox7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxfffiff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread Ox5087d6 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65138947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2105340) [Ox 100701 ffc] 1-18
18 _psynch_cmait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxffftt17f80de291c] 1-18
Thread Ox5087d7 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5],[O policy important>
18 ??? (<65138947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2105340) [Ox 10070Iffc] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [Ox7f118f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxfffiff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread Ox5087d8 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65138947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2103527) [0x1007018e7] 1-18
18 _psynch_cmait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [Ox7ff18f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxffftt17f80de291c] 1-18
Thread Ox5087d9 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5],[O policy important>
18 ??? (<65138947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2105340) [Ox 10070Iffc] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [Ox7ftt8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [Oxfffiff7f8Ode29 lc] 1-18
Thread 0x5087dc 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2105340) [Ox 100701 ffc] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xffffft7f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x5087de 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-2121-3976-A28C-971FlEE096A0> + 2105340) [Ox 10070Iffc] 1-18
18 _psynch_cvwait + 10 (libsystem_kemel.dylib + 90422) [0x7fff8f3b1136] 1-18
*18 psynch_cvcontinue + 0 (pthread + 26908) [0xffffft7f80de291c] 1-18
Thread 0x5087df 18 samples (1-18) priority 31
<frontmost, thread QoS legacy, boosted, received importance donation from WindowServer [10
5], 1O policy important>
18 ??? (<65DB947D-</body></html>
Note
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2015-04-18 13:02:33 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2015-04-18 13:02:50 (UTC)
Title teeth cleaning. haircut, blood test
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Body <html><head></head><body>teeth cleaning. haircut. blood test<ibod) html>
Note
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2015-05-01 11:37:56 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2015-05-01 11:38:07 (UTC)
Title friendhsip cahnge , realtionship
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<htm1><head></head>cbody>friendhsip cahnge , realtionship
Body
<,/body><Ihtml>
Note
Source Device NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date Created 2015-05-26 17:14:40 (UTC)
Date Modifed 2015-05-26 18:27:55 (UTC)
Title leon, mort, rosvky, ??!!
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
Body <htm1><headx/headxbodye leon, mort, rosvky, ??!!<,/bodreihtml>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2015-07-11 18:39:51 (UTC) Created
Date 2015-08-02 10:14:13 (UTC) Modifed
Title wexner, darren, house. martin, joi, assa aurelia lang. summers. holterbosch
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync
Source Gmail
Body <html>chead>elheadxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-1
ine-break: after-white-space;">wexner, darren, house. martin, joi, Massa aurelia lang. su
mmers. holterbosch
rugs. decorator. pasion g5,  estate erica, soverighn idian
morroco, 40 m. leon plane.
scheudle , nutrition attia, .
live paris, hk, italy,
aniel,
assistant, science writer, krause chomsky, groom
dry hours
leon office
sorry, I'm shocked that you did this
meet.?? best friend did not ask, speak, never ever, gang stuff, jerry merit, mother sister, Inv
estigator,
. suicide, randy , jack kessler, stanley, bankrupt,bankrupt sales tax , ohio, cigars. trusts charity
gifts, aspen, shooting.steve sale.,
mort, heidi , glenn, dershoqit shan'tz, jean luc =, 34 girls wexner , irs,
writer Internet ? book on actuals. poe? rober.
documentary
criteen, jerru If guy lewis, glenn, jarecki hotlerbsoc
four poster bed, coconut cups
FLONASE ASP
umbrealla , tiki fur; four poster, entry rug dressing run. outdoor furniture
airplane seat shock absorbers
art of conversation
young post does. intemet writer scienific american, researchers.
</body></html>
Note
Source NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2015-09-07 13:47:07 (UTC) Created
Date 2015-09-16 23:55:20 (UTC) Modifed
Title character , prince , foucault
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Gmail Source
Body <htmI><head></head><body style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-
line-break: after-white-s ace;">character , prince , foucault
hanson joe david
password music laptop?
hossain, olivier. fabrice. BSI.
weingarten,
zuckerman, holterbosch
kamen kerry jaret. GLENN CALL
AIRCELL coverage?
scarola, sanctions
paul mccartney - leon. grubman motola peggy, boris
BACK APNEA. weak
LASER ISLAND< fountain?
decoraile,r•erson valdson 26th, januz 3rd? chomsky ehud woody
rome,
teeth im lant , dr speaker
sue
sultan,
investment, ari, valor , paul .jpm gs,
tra gift defined value note increase. this year. bank loans
trading account. grat ? tra step -up? NEW GRATS?
kids meeting?
CHARITY FUN ENJOY no moregive togive
estate trusts?
124 . tom me gnaw ?
BITTER RELEAVANT TESTOSTERINE DIET EXCERCISE
Finance , competence.
science hobby , charity, ask glenn, wex. merkin( ito)
broclanan wurman
trivers
BRAD LEON > ALAN. jabor, tetje,
MAPP
naiomi, ?!, gates, ghislaine, ian osbourne, and
brian boyd, slayton
andreeson horowitz, steve sinofsky, putin, karp? wealth
chairman YAO
LIVE MUSIC BOTTSTEIN aganecy
attai [sychiatrist
HOTEL living
trust k predict under stress
mark packer, strip club
woody film , woody birthday. party reason
heart hard eyes back teeth
bbj g4 engines.
</body></html>
Note
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
Date
Modifed
Title
Summary
Sync Name
Sync
Source
Body
Source
Device
Path
Date
Created
NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2015-11-07 15:12:47 (UTC)
2015-11-07 15:16:23 (UTC)
health, lipitor, coq , clomephine. abs
jeevacation
Gmail
<html>cheadx/head><body style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-
line-break: after-white-space;">health, lipitor, coq , clomephine. abs
tooth, apnea. back. </body>e-/html>
Note
NYC024364.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Stoty/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
2015-11-07 15:16:28 (UTC)
Date 2015-11-07 15:16:34 (UTC) Modifed
Title New Note
Summary
Sync Name jeevacation
Sync Source Gmail
<html>chead>c/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit
Body -line-break: after-white-space;">
cibody></html>
Note
Source NYCO24364.dmg/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Story/Library/Containers/com.apple.Notes/Data/Library/Notes/NotesV6.storedata
Date 2015-11-07 15:16:49 (UTC) Created
Date 2015-11-09 04:47:17 (UTC) Modifed
Title health, lipitor, coq , clomephine. abs
Summary
Sync jeevacation Name
Sync °mail
Source
Body <htm1><headx/headxbody style="word-wrap: break-word; -webkit-nbsp-mode: space; -webkit-I
ine-break: after-white-space;">health, lipitor, coq , clomephine. abs
tooth, apnea. back. diet, trainer? most rawlin huger port masco,merrill
terje, jagland, wahled, Karim, outarra, lang, churkin, sergey,ehud, , wilson, 1
isa , brennan ) reid, bottstein ken starr, jay lefkowitz, roy, shaher, antoine fekkai, crowe bill bums,
thiel hoffman, melz sinofsky, boris, bill. brock, austin, joi ,
neri, john brockman , chomsky, karuss, church, martin, yau, gromov. nathan
NERI-
steve, joe, leon, mort, david, anthony
ATTIA
johana , daniel. aureliaa assia, melu marg ai , nstya
I athena, . cortibartarte, ramsey, ands, . kira r
woody, fisch,iima
ghislaine crystal, christina anna, j
'en ren sue jul jul . kar nasti iii
call info, mark packer, benny
ef 1 o er mort, wexner, dersh, guy, wexner glenn
call poi venezeula francisco
jabor, sultan, david stem josh ramo.
washington bard packer woody, saba, st baits.
great st james dersh mediation, ghislane vr, wolff. herman patty glazer , jean luc, APTS
? STaff, janus, island.
transformer , trees, egyipinent GSJ. , zorro roof ,windows, water , garden, ROADS. during back sur
gery, nautical sports, lunch box , SIMON. car kits, shoes redford. gotham award.mark lloyd
meeting with boies and VR, call Kevin and ask about sultan Full money at merchant? chris letter to
sex offender new york air•lepo? letter to judge, never saw list until after in jail. chomsky islan
d.? groom ?hillis mart. tv, nasty dollars.. house head.
Pinto Lang ramo shum, air conditioning,gromov bio. gianii,
rdo . tancredi, olivier , decoratr( lisa cohen) ambulance speak KODESH KORESH
Investment, bonds , jpm. guests in decemebr.? neri, martin, M? <Thodyx.,/html>
ass. edua
╔═════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Gianni Serazzi [modeling] founder of 2morrow 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01078143 (Jmail)
 [girls] Gianni Serazzi 2morrow modeling pitch deck
(approximate date: 2014-09-30)
F morrowmodel
European opportunity
JEE

╭── Page 1, Image 1 ───╮
│ Bmorrowmodel         │
│                      │
│ European opportunity │
│ JEE                  │
╰──────────────────────╯

2morrowmodel group is the fastest growing
group in the Milan market
MS ICCTit
worrt It tot 4445•4n1 citron Ravi "
ro
ORA Foie 106.0 4Psolt
/ Lik4.)  - I 1
kat
L
2100m400 11

• We believe in results
- We measure our success by the numbers of our
clients and their satisfaction
- We do not follow industry rules, we question them
and change them where it's appropriate to make
OUR rules
- We want to create successful companies adequately
structured, what is trendy but does not create
sound business we leave to our competitors
- We operate with a sense of urgency

• We believe in sharing
- Our models, our mother agency partners and our
top employees participate in our success

• We tell it like it is
- We listen hard, but are suspicious of received
industry wisdom
• We aspire to have the most efficient
company in modeling
- We employ our manuals, software and rules to run
our companies as a Swiss clock
- 60% of our employees have university degrees,
20% in management and economics. Our key
managers come from Private Equity, Fashion and
have been educated in the best universities
t recipient; itdo snot ip Ilitw ilis4AR rprsh1aared with any 3rd party without 2morrow's prior written consent.
Exponential growth of 2morrowmodel group
over the last 5 years
Founded in 2001, 2morrowmodel group is
experiencing rapid growth in the last 5 years
since new management arrived...
(INDEXED revenue, 2009 = 100%)
...and is already the largest group for FTEs in
Milan with 48 employees
•••
This information is confidential and was prepared by 2morrmo solely for the direct recipient; t ot ithStalitishwit ryfi 
tipred with any 3rd party without
2morrow's prior written consent.
One group, 3 companies
Bmorrowmodel •

• >2000 models managed
• Paris opening in progress
•
• "500 models managed
•
• "' 300 models managed
4
This information is confidential and was prepared by 2morrow solely for the direct recipient; it eiesnot 
Spilokrr,ghgamil igi shiloared with any 3rd party
without 2morrow's prior written consent.
IL DESIGN DEL COLORE
s DEBORAH
OF LIFE .
A t 7.11
SPORTMAX
Ti sent.

╭──── Page 6, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

Expansion opport
Opportunity
*Leverage the existing business model and the talent already under contract to
open Paris and London
- Provide from Milano the software and the internal procedures bringing efficiency in a dysfunctional
industry. We are the disruptive technology
- Provide from Milano the talent under contract
- Create legally an invoicing platform from Italy to exploit tax advantages
- Bring top quality management from Milano to kick-start the operations
- Include the MC2 network and work together using Jean Luc organization as the American operations
- Collaborate with Jean Luc also on the scouting side, even if the 19 mother agencies where we have equity
participations and special agreements are already a very, very strong platform
Skin in the game

• On this project 2morrow group will bet its
network, brand name and top management
with very high image and opportunity cost. It
MUST be a success, failure would put the rest
of the ventures at risk and is unacceptable

• Existing personnel will be used to support the
venture, that's why we can open these
structures with limited investments
Financial terms
•3M Eur commitment, to be drawn within 3 years
- not all money needed upfront
- 99% as debt, 1% as capital
*Total amount to be repaid before any other
amount paid to shareholders
- Cost of capital of 6% to be calculated for the months
effectively used
- Target: repay debt 3.5 years from when it's drawn
*50-50 split of shares
*Complete transparency and quarterly updates 7
This information is confidential and was prepared by 2morrow solely for the direct recipient; it snot ip l 
bt.Fglig.40,Rw skleared with any 3rd party without
2morrow's prior written consent.
EFTA02701609 (Jmail)
 [girls] Gianni Serazzi 2morrow business plan
(approximate date: 2014-09-30)
Ri, morrow Business plan 1st year presentation
France Only
Invoicing NO VAT Business Plan presentation / 2morrow Paris
Year 2014 - 2015
Invoicing
Monthly FCF
CUM FCF
Jun Jul Aug Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug

• 26'760 it - S0064 C • 104'594
- 26760E - 23104f • 54-530( - 117063E -85'168( -51997f -64193E - 115912E- 128674E 2/3136€ 53392C • 54'988 16061E - 
11'649(

• Company to start working in June 2014 for September launch
• Total invoicing from September 2014 to August 2014 1,55M Eur

• Clear explanation of all expenses in following slides, validate as much as possible
with local experts and Italian internal benchmarks where applicable (e.g., tickets)
• License already applied for and awaiting just incorporation for approval
• Overall financing requested for year 1 until Aug 15 is 668'000 Eur
- From Aug 15, second full year should require a further investment of —65K Eur, however
the details will be presented with next year budget and there will be a higher cash
request for a march cash requirement peak
- Third year the company has to be cash flow positive
morrow
Invoicing NO VAT Business Plan presentation / 2morrow Paris
Year 2014 - 2015
Men
Women
Jun Jul Aug Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
27.680 71660 (37.68 27.680 31.140 27.680 20.760 1920
September 2014:
Assumption 40 models in town
Preparation 40 models in town
I
80 models in town
According to our analysis based on the Italian market and comparing it to the Paris market which usually overachieves a 
+20% of
revenue (conservative assumption) - we assume that a model's monthly average revenue is C 2.000 for the first 3 months 
of stay in
town (conservative 50% utilization rate, i.e., only 50% of models will work at C 4.000/month) , with a gradually 
increase of the +10%-
13% from the 4th month on, due to client's fidelity and model's notoriety.
Men invoicing is based on the direct invoicing that last year 2morrow did from Milano, augmented by 50% because of local
presence in Paris.
F morrow
Fixed costs
Year 2014 - 2015
Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
Office ( 14 000
Cleaning
Cellphones <I.000 (500
Telephones
Electricity 4200
Office supplies
Tax consultant t10.
Pc support + F1W
Work consultant c 2 oco
Zero cost for temporary office for
license, we should be able to
provide it with friends. Then
3500/month and 3 months deposit
in first month. 150 sq mt semi-
central
(3.500 4 1.300 (1500 (1500 <1503 (3.500 (3.500 (3.5W (3.500
<600 t 603 ( 6420 <603 ( 600 ( 600 ( 600 (600 ( 600
C 503 C SOO (500 0500 C 5C0 t 500 c soo (500 t SCO
(603 t 603 ( 600 < 6(0 ( 600 ( 600 ( SOO ( 600 ( 600
< 400 C 400 1400 4 400 t 400 <400 C 400 I(00 1400
Illit (300 (2120 < 200 ( 203 ( 203 ( 200 ( 200 < 200
(15000
( 150 ( 1 500 ( 1 500 < 1 503 ( 1.500 <1.500 ( 1,500
(IOW c SCO ( 503 ( 503 (500 C 500 4 5C0 t 503
LAN + 6 computers x 850
each
Preparation work pre. VOIP installation for 10 internal
opening cellphones usa numbers
Installation of SW
(proprietary + adobe + office)
(3.503
I600
C SCO
(3,50D
(600
t SOO
11500
( 603
C503
(600 (600 (WO
C4C0 C 400 t4,3
( 200 ( 200 ( 203
( 1.503 <1500 ( 1.503
\ C 5C° C 500 C 500
IKEA style furnishing, same
amount spent in Italy for Nologo
and costs are similar in Ikea FR
and IT
Modification of SW
for France after 6
months operations
morrow
Fixed costs
Year 2014 - 2015
Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
Other office costs (2.000 C2000 C2 003 2.000 f. 2003 4 2.033 C2.000 4 x.600 (2000 2030 4 2 COO 2030
Taxes paid C 4 356 (8.711 C
11611 14157 17.137 32.218 $$53 341t59 13.550 21.550 21666 15072
Bank commission +
debt
150 1714 4 400 (1 ,131 13144 11.944 C1167 L642 1435 it 1443 (3.074 (1.351 (3.131 (340
Work consultant 2.000 (1.660. C 500 C SOO SOO t SOO C 5C0 (500 C SO3 C 500 (503 ( 503 1506
Internationl wires 15 x 10 wires/month
+ 6% yearly interest on debt
Second trance license to Setup costs France company. Estimate
operate in France. First
5000 already paid by
2morrow Cost aligned with Italian
expenses and confirmed
preliminarly by French
tax advisor
morrow
Fixed costs
Year 2014 - 2015
Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
Salaries C 1.508 ( 1.500 18.500 ( 18.500 20.350 ( 20 150 ( 20 350 20 150 (10.)50
20.350
( 20 350 (20.350
Social charges t 1 ::0 ( : 110 13 090 ( 13 690 13 690 ( 17/9/ 15 059 15 059 ( 15 G59 15 G59 ( 15 059
15059
15459 15 059
Model social 9 3150 (9.360 C 10.530 (10530 16.193 (42.506 (16.193 C 16.193 18.211 12.145 4048
charges
10 193
One assistant to set up 6 employees
3 Mid level bookers @
4000 each
2 Assistants @ 1500
each
13th month french law 7 employees
1 Traffic and % confirmed by tax advisor
Operations manager @ of total net payment to
3500 models
No scouts included
No CEO included
morrow
Variable costs
Year 2014 - 2015
Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
Apart + Residence C 32.403 t 21.600 C 21,600 161200 C 61200 (25.500 C 20.400 C 35.700 (20.400 t 20400 C 5.100
Driver ”t <LOCO < 2400 t 2 COO 62000 (2.000 ( 2400 C 2030 (2000 C 2 CCO ( 2 003 ( 2 CCO
Taxi (X* ( 300 ( 300 it 100 ( 300 ( MO ( 300 (300 IC 300 (100 ( 200 ( 2C0
Mail t 50 t 50 <50 (50 t 50 t 50 C 50 f SO t SO C SO C SO ( SO
Messanger <250 C2S0 C 250 C 210 t 210 C 250 C 250 C 250 C 210 C 150 C 150 C LSO
Hairdresser < 500 C SCO < 400
Gift to clients 3400
Adapted moth by month based on number of models in town
Only for arrivals at beginning of season
Xmas presents to clients
Kmorrow
Variable costs
Year 2014 - 2015
Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug
Photographers SOO (1.500 (1000 (2.500 t 1 000 t 1 502 (500
Prints ( 000 ( CO) f#Y3 3 500 4.714 3 300 1 000 •
Model
payments
Tickets paid for
models
20 t 7.140 (7.540 19.593 t 11071 (21.071 (11.626 t 12.331 t 12.152 (10.172 t 5113 t 5.613 t 8.711
Mother agency t 1.600 if 1 6t0 t 12C0 t 1800 t 2,768 t 7.266 (2.768 it 2.766 (3.114 (1768 (2.076 (692
Scouting trips (5 000 t 10000 t 5p00 • 10 000 4' 10000 (3 000 10.000 t 10000 t 3.000 t 3 OCO t 14000 15000 t 10.000 
(5000
First prints for Sept arrivals
Strong push for first year to
establish new agency. No
salaries paid to scouters (4
FTEs) that will increase trips
for Paris agency
Aligned with Milano costs
(same cost for CDG and MIL
for flight and other
transprtations)
Assumption payment 24 hours after
work as in Milan (excluding rights)
Conservative estimate assuming 50%
employment rate for first year
la morrow
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                         BitFury [crypto] Dutch bitcoin mining company founded by Valery Vavilov and Mark Dollar 
  Blockchain Capital [crypto] early crypto VC fund co-founded by Bart Stephens and Brock Pierce, invested in by Epstein [protos] 
 Crypto Currency Partners II [crypto] crypto fund set up by Epstein and Brock Pierce as a sidecar to Blockchain Capital [protos] 
                                                 ExpressCoin [crypto] bitcoin market founded by Brock Pierce and William Wheeler 
   Kraken [crypto] 2nd largest American crypto exchange, CEO + employees prone to calling the US dollar "slave money" [bakerlaw] 
                              LedgerX [crypto] crypto derivatives platform acquired by FTX for $298 million in a very shady deal 
                     Noble Bank [crypto] failed crypto friendly bank with ties to Tether and Brock Pierce [news.bitcoinprotocol] 
                                                             Pantera Capital [crypto] silicon valley crypto fund of Dan Morehead 
                                                                                              PayPay [crypto] bitcoin debit card 
                                                       Tim Draper [crypto] partner at Draper Fisher Jurvetson, loves bitcoin [x] 
                                                                  W. Bradford Stephens [crypto] co-founder of Blockchain Capital 
                                                                        Greylock [tech] O.G. silicon valley venture capital firm 
                                                          Lightspeed Venture Partners [tech] silicon valley venture capital firm 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00621239 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Crypto Currency Partners II investor report
(date: 2014-10-01)
Crypto Currency
Partners
INVESTOR UPDATE
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS, L.P.
OCTOBER 2014

╭────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ ©                                           │
│                                             │
│ Crypto Currency                             │
│ Partners                                    │
│                                             │
│ ~ INVESTOR UPDATE ~                         │
│                                             │
│ CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS, L.P.              │
│                                             │
│ OCTOBER 2014                                │
│ Confidential - Proprietary - Do Not Forward │
│ www.Blockchain.capital                      │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯

)Crypto Currency
Partners
Dear CCP Investors,
The Bitcoin ecosystem is one the most exciting investment landscapes that we have seen in
our 20 years as venture capitalists and hedge fund managers. Bitcoin is better, faster, cheaper,
programmable money. Bitcoin is simultaneously a digital currency, a computer protocol, a financial
transaction processing network, a store of value, and a self-protecting global peer-to-peer network.
For the first time in human history, Bitcoin enables the near instantaneous and irreversible
utilization of a payment technology (i.e. cash, Visa or Gold) that doesn't require an incumbent
financial intermediary such as a bank or a sovereign nation. And it is virtually free. We could send
you 1/100 of a penny (1.7 bits) or $10 million dollars (17,670 Bitcoins) using a smart phone, or a
paper-based physical "wallet" containing bitcoins. Hedge fund managers can use crypto currencies
like Bitcoin to store value in a liquid, globally available asset that is negatively correlated to
traditional financial assets. Yet Bitcoin also enables a migrant farm worker in California to send
money back to his family in Mexico and save the 5-10% charged by traditional cash remittance
companies like Western Union. Bitcoin allows for cash to be sent world-wide without the high fixed
costs associated with credit card transactions. We have all seen the hand written-signs at the
checkout register that say "minimum credit card purchase $5." This is because merchants have to
share 2-2.5% of credit card purchases with Visa/MasterCard/American Express. Merchants
accepting Bitcoin get to keep that 2.-2.5%. The fixed costs of the Bitcoin ecosystem are orders of
magnitude cheaper than legacy payment networks. Extrapolating the inherent low costs of the
Bitcoin network on a global basis means that 3 billion of the world's population who are currently
"unbanked" could become consumers of financial products and services.
From a global macro perspective, Bitcoin is interesting because it is experiencing rapid user growth
and is at the same time transnational and super-sovereign. Like the Internet in the mid-1990s. Gold
is also super-sovereign, but it is hard to move physically, and you can't split it and spend it online for
goods and services like you can with Bitcoin. Bitcoin can be thought of as a start-up technology
company that is competing in the world of global financial institutions and governments. The old
adage that "necessity is the mother of invention" applies to Bitcoin. It was invented in the direct
aftermath of the global financial crisis of 2008, which showed the world that financial institutions are
dangerously interconnected, too big to fail, and over-leveraged. These same financial institutions are
still largely unreformed and manage financial assets like stocks, bonds, and currencies. The prices
of these financial assets have been massively supported, in a coordinated fashion, by sovereign
nations and central banks. The debt and liquidity problems of the global banking system were
"solved" with more debt and liquidity by central bankers. History tells us that currency devaluations
and/or inflation will be the result of these policy decisions. A central tenant of our Bitcoin
investment thesis is that Bitcoin is structurally designed to be anti-inflationary. Baked into the
Bitcoin protocol, a "law of Bitcoin" if you will, is that there will only be 21 million bitcoins ever
created by the system (there are approximately 13 million bitcoins in circulation as of August 2014).
The core invention underpinning Bitcoin is a powerful idea and novel technology called The
Blockchain. The Blockchain enables two parties to exchange value without knowing or necessarily
trusting each other. This is similar to physically exchanging cash, except the two parties can be
located anywhere in the world. The Blockchain technology has many applications and Bitcoin is just
the first in the vertical industry of finance. To name a few beyond finance, the Blockchain could be
used as an escrow service, for enabling smart contracts and tides, or to manage elections in emerging
and/or unstable nation states. It could also be used as a decentralized certificate authority for
identification and authorization, or to cheaply manage legal disputes.
We see a massively attractive risk/reward profile for those companies that can leverage Blockchain
technology to disrupt bloated legacy systems like financial services, legal services, and government.
In the Bitcoin ecosystem, we like companies that are creating the financial infrastructure to connect
crypto currencies like Bitcoin to the global capital markets. We see excellent investment
opportunities in sub-sectors of Bitcoin like Blockchain based SaaS for enterprises, mobile apps,
mining/pools, security, global remittance, gaming, and rest-of-world consumer financial products
and services.
Bitcoin is complex, hard to understand, and confusing. As a result, it is often misunderstood and
frequently mis-reported... And therein lies the investment opportunity at this nascent stage in the
development of this organically growing ecosystem.
We created Crypto Currency Partners, LP (CCP) to bring the discipline of professional investors to
the Wild West of crypto currencies, of which Bitcoin is our favorite and primary focus. The limited
partners invited into the investment partnership are Bitcoin thought leaders, Bitcoin entrepreneurs,
professional VC's personal accounts, hedge fund managers, and technology company operating
executives. The start-up companies that receive capital from CCP are companies that are leaders in
their respective Bitcoin sub-sectors. Our mission, as stewards of capital and Bitcoin venture
capitalists, is to help CCP companies grow. We speak at Bitcoin conferences around the world and
are constantly interacting with operating companies, start-ups, regulators, venture capital firms, and
institutional investors. All of whom are learning and getting more exposed to Bitcoin. These are the
early days. Stay tuned and strap in.
Deal Flow
We have seen tremendous deal flow throughout the year originating from our founding partners,
managing partners and limited partners. Through our partners, we believe we have been able to take
a look at nearly every Bitcoin investment opportunity possible, with a few high profile exceptions
that pre-date the fund's inception. As interest in the Bitcoin ecosystem from traditional top tier
venture capitalists grows, it may become more difficult to maintain access to all deals. However, we
are continuing to cultivate relationships with all thought leaders and Bitcoin-interested venture firms.
Our goal is to be viewed as a sector specific venture fund, that generalist venture funds will bring
into their deals for due diligence, industry expertise, sales leads, and domain expertise.
Our Kieretsu
We have been working hard to cultivate the inter-connected relationships of our portfolio
companies. Many of them are utilizing the products or services of other CCP companies. We
encourage our companies to work together and to enact best business practices of the Bitcoin
ecosystem. This network of companies supporting each other, and enabling best-of-breed
specialization, has been very positive for many of our investments. It boosts early revenues and
time-to-market.
Nothing frustrates us more than to see a handful of companies waste time and resources, all trying
to recreate the same service that is not core to their business. We are very early in the rise of crypto
currencies, and speed to market and specialization within targeted markets is paramount to success.
The Bitcoin ecosystem is also evolving in an accelerated fashion, thereby magnifying mistakes by
start-up companies in the sector. We hope to guide our companies and help them grow by
providing capital, assisting them with hiring, bringing customer leads, offering strategic advice, and
access to the CCP network of companies and people.
Capital Calls
The stated goal of this fund was to make roughly 20 investments in the Bitcoin ecosystem in 2014.
We believe that CCP is the only fund in the world that accepts capital calls in either fiat currency or
Bitcoin and that can also fund companies in fiat or Bitcoin.
We have been very active investing in the first nine months of the year, investing the majority of the
capital in 27 Bitcoin start-ups. We will not be making any additional investments from the fund.
How You Can Help
We will continue to leverage the collective network of the general partners, limited partners and
CCP operating company executives to help all of our companies grow and thrive.
A quarter of the portfolio is well capitalized with financing for at least the next year of operations.
Another quarter of the portfolio will be raising capital in early to mid-2015. The remaining 50% of
portfolio companies will be raising capital in Q4 2014. In the near term, much of our focus will be
on assisting these companies with capital needs. As CCP companies seek funding, we may be
reaching out to the limited partners of the fund for specific introductions to venture capital firms if
we don't have existing relationships. We endeavor to keep our limited partners informed of ongoing
capital raises, and if you believe you can be helpful, please speak up. Also, many of our CCP
companies' financings will have opportunities for direct co-investments by CCP limited partners. If
this is something you are interested in, please let us know.
We welcome any comments or feedback,
Brad Stephens
Bart Stephens
Brock Pierce
Portfolio Companies
Authy - Two-factor authentication platform
Co-investors: Y Combinator
Bex.io — White label Bitcoin exchange as a service
Co-investors: Plug and Play, BoostVC
BitAccess— Bitcoin Teller Machine
Co-investors: Y Combinator, Pantera Capital
BitFury - World's largest Bitcoin miner
Co-investors: Binary Financial, Georgian Co-Investment Fund
BitGo - Enterprise focused, multi-signature secure wallet platform
Co-investors: Redpoint, Radar Partners, Founders Fund
BitPesa — Money Remittance to Africa
Co-investors: Pantera
Blade Financial Oka PayPay)— White-label Bitcoin debit card
Co-investors: Angels
BlockCypher — Powering Blockchains in the Cloud
Co-investors: Foundation Capital, Tim Draper
BlockStream — Enabling the creation of Side-chains
Co-investors: Reid Hoffman, Khosla Ventures, Ribbit Capital
BTC China - Leading Chinese Exchange, Mobile Apps and Payments
Co-investors: Lightspeed Venture Partners
Chain.com - Enterprise Bitcoin Infrastructure
Co-investors: Khosla Ventures, RRE Ventures, SV Angel, 500 Startups
ChangeCoin - Platform for receiving and sending online tips
Co-investors: Angellist
Coinsetter — Institutional grade, low latency Bitcoin exchange and ECN
Co-investors: Second Market, Tribeca Venture Fund
Expresscoin — A simple and safe way for consumers to buy Bitcoin
Co-investors: Bitcoin Shop (OTC: NTCS), Angels
FreshPay — Enabling ease of payments for individuals
Co-investors: Future Perfect Ventures, Angels
Gem (fka BitVault) — Bank-grade security for developer apps
Co-investors: Amplify.LA, RRE, First Round Capital
GoCoin - Multi-currency payment gateway for merchants
Co-investors: Bitcoin Shop (OTC: NTCS), Angels
Koinify - Crypto meets crowdfunding
Co-investors: IDG Capital Partners, zPark Venture, Danhua Capital
KrakenEuropean crypto currency exchange
Co-investors: Hummingbird Ventures, SecondMarket
LedgerX - Self-clearing Bitcoin derivatives platform
Co-investors: Lightspeed Venture Partners, SV Angel, Google Ventures
Noble Markets- Financial services focused crypto-exchange
Co-investors: Clearstone Venture Partners, Tally Capital
PeerNova — Crypto infrastructure as a Service and Cloud-hashing
Co-investors: Mosaik Partners, Pierre Lamond, Ashar Aziz
SFOX - Algorithmic Bitcoin exchange
Co-investors: Y Combinator, Khosla Ventures, Tech Accelerator
SnapCard — Spend your Bitcoin on any web site
Co-investors: Boost.VC
Texas Bitcoin Conference — Industry trade show
Co-investors: Angels
Xapo — Bitcoin focused consumer financial services
Co-investors: Pantera, Ribbit, Greylock, Benchmark, Fortress
ZenBox - Bitcoin ATM operator
Co-investors: Angels
ZipZap — global digital currency payment network
Co-investors: 500 Startups, Triple Point Capital, Blumberg Capital
EFTA01089535 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Crypto Currency Partners II investor report
(date: 2014-10-01)
Crypto Currency
Partners
INVESTOR UPDATE
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS, L.P.
OCTOBER 2014

╭────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ ©                                           │
│                                             │
│ Crypto Currency                             │
│ Partners                                    │
│                                             │
│ ~ INVESTOR UPDATE ~                         │
│                                             │
│ CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS, L.P.              │
│                                             │
│ OCTOBER 2014                                │
│ Confidential - Proprietary - Do Not Forward │
│ www.Blockchain.capital                      │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯

)Crypto Currency
Partners
Dear CCP Investors,
The Bitcoin ecosystem is one the most exciting investment landscapes that we have seen in
our 20 years as venture capitalists and hedge fund managers. Bitcoin is better, faster, cheaper,
programmable money. Bitcoin is simultaneously a digital currency, a computer protocol, a financial
transaction processing network, a store of value, and a self-protecting global peer-to-peer network.
For the first time in human history, Bitcoin enables the near instantaneous and irreversible
utilization of a payment technology (i.e. cash, Visa or Gold) that doesn't require an incumbent
financial intermediary such as a bank or a sovereign nation. And it is virtually free. We could send
you 1/100 of a penny (1.7 bits) or $10 million dollars (17,670 Bitcoins) using a smart phone, or a
paper-based physical "wallet" containing bitcoins. Hedge fund managers can use crypto currencies
like Bitcoin to store value in a liquid, globally available asset that is negatively correlated to
traditional financial assets. Yet Bitcoin also enables a migrant farm worker in California to send
money back to his family in Mexico and save the 5-10% charged by traditional cash remittance
companies like Western Union. Bitcoin allows for cash to be sent world-wide without the high fixed
costs associated with credit card transactions. We have all seen the hand written-signs at the
checkout register that say "minimum credit card purchase $5." This is because merchants have to
share 2-2.5% of credit card purchases with Visa/MasterCard/American Express. Merchants
accepting Bitcoin get to keep that 2.-2.5%. The fixed costs of the Bitcoin ecosystem are orders of
magnitude cheaper than legacy payment networks. Extrapolating the inherent low costs of the
Bitcoin network on a global basis means that 3 billion of the world's population who are currently
"unbanked" could become consumers of financial products and services.
From a global macro perspective, Bitcoin is interesting because it is experiencing rapid user growth
and is at the same time transnational and super-sovereign. Like the Internet in the mid-1990s. Gold
is also super-sovereign, but it is hard to move physically, and you can't split it and spend it online for
goods and services like you can with Bitcoin. Bitcoin can be thought of as a start-up technology
company that is competing in the world of global financial institutions and governments. The old
adage that "necessity is the mother of invention" applies to Bitcoin. It was invented in the direct
aftermath of the global financial crisis of 2008, which showed the world that financial institutions are
dangerously interconnected, too big to fail, and over-leveraged. These same financial institutions are
still largely unreformed and manage financial assets like stocks, bonds, and currencies. The prices
of these financial assets have been massively supported, in a coordinated fashion, by sovereign
nations and central banks. The debt and liquidity problems of the global banking system were
"solved" with more debt and liquidity by central bankers. History tells us that currency devaluations
and/or inflation will be the result of these policy decisions. A central tenant of our Bitcoin
investment thesis is that Bitcoin is structurally designed to be anti-inflationary. Baked into the
Bitcoin protocol, a "law of Bitcoin" if you will, is that there will only be 21 million bitcoins ever
created by the system (there are approximately 13 million bitcoins in circulation as of August 2014).
The core invention underpinning Bitcoin is a powerful idea and novel technology called The
Blockchain. The Blockchain enables two parties to exchange value without knowing or necessarily
trusting each other. This is similar to physically exchanging cash, except the two parties can be
located anywhere in the world. The Blockchain technology has many applications and Bitcoin is just
the first in the vertical industry of finance. To name a few beyond finance, the Blockchain could be
used as an escrow service, for enabling smart contracts and tides, or to manage elections in emerging
and/or unstable nation states. It could also be used as a decentralized certificate authority for
identification and authorization, or to cheaply manage legal disputes.
We see a massively attractive risk/reward profile for those companies that can leverage Blockchain
technology to disrupt bloated legacy systems like financial services, legal services, and government.
In the Bitcoin ecosystem, we like companies that are creating the financial infrastructure to connect
crypto currencies like Bitcoin to the global capital markets. We see excellent investment
opportunities in sub-sectors of Bitcoin like Blockchain based SaaS for enterprises, mobile apps,
mining/pools, security, global remittance, gaming, and rest-of-world consumer financial products
and services.
Bitcoin is complex, hard to understand, and confusing. As a result, it is often misunderstood and
frequently mis-reported... And therein lies the investment opportunity at this nascent stage in the
development of this organically growing ecosystem.
We created Crypto Currency Partners, LP (CCP) to bring the discipline of professional investors to
the Wild West of crypto currencies, of which Bitcoin is our favorite and primary focus. The limited
partners invited into the investment partnership are Bitcoin thought leaders, Bitcoin entrepreneurs,
professional VC's personal accounts, hedge fund managers, and technology company operating
executives. The start-up companies that receive capital from CCP are companies that are leaders in
their respective Bitcoin sub-sectors. Our mission, as stewards of capital and Bitcoin venture
capitalists, is to help CCP companies grow. We speak at Bitcoin conferences around the world and
are constantly interacting with operating companies, start-ups, regulators, venture capital firms, and
institutional investors. All of whom are learning and getting more exposed to Bitcoin. These are the
early days. Stay tuned and strap in.
Deal Flow
We have seen tremendous deal flow throughout the year originating from our founding partners,
managing partners and limited partners. Through our partners, we believe we have been able to take
a look at nearly every Bitcoin investment opportunity possible, with a few high profile exceptions
that pre-date the fund's inception. As interest in the Bitcoin ecosystem from traditional top tier
venture capitalists grows, it may become more difficult to maintain access to all deals. However, we
are continuing to cultivate relationships with all thought leaders and Bitcoin-interested venture firms.
Our goal is to be viewed as a sector specific venture fund, that generalist venture funds will bring
into their deals for due diligence, industry expertise, sales leads, and domain expertise.
Our Kieretsu
We have been working hard to cultivate the inter-connected relationships of our portfolio
companies. Many of them are utilizing the products or services of other CCP companies. We
encourage our companies to work together and to enact best business practices of the Bitcoin
ecosystem. This network of companies supporting each other, and enabling best-of-breed
specialization, has been very positive for many of our investments. It boosts early revenues and
time-to-market.
Nothing frustrates us more than to see a handful of companies waste time and resources, all trying
to recreate the same service that is not core to their business. We are very early in the rise of crypto
currencies, and speed to market and specialization within targeted markets is paramount to success.
The Bitcoin ecosystem is also evolving in an accelerated fashion, thereby magnifying mistakes by
start-up companies in the sector. We hope to guide our companies and help them grow by
providing capital, assisting them with hiring, bringing customer leads, offering strategic advice, and
access to the CCP network of companies and people.
Capital Calls
The stated goal of this fund was to make roughly 20 investments in the Bitcoin ecosystem in 2014.
We believe that CCP is the only fund in the world that accepts capital calls in either fiat currency or
Bitcoin and that can also fund companies in fiat or Bitcoin.
We have been very active investing in the first nine months of the year, investing the majority of the
capital in 27 Bitcoin start-ups. We will not be making any additional investments from the fund.
How You Can Help
We will continue to leverage the collective network of the general partners, limited partners and
CCP operating company executives to help all of our companies grow and thrive.
A quarter of the portfolio is well capitalized with financing for at least the next year of operations.
Another quarter of the portfolio will be raising capital in early to mid-2015. The remaining 50% of
portfolio companies will be raising capital in Q4 2014. In the near term, much of our focus will be
on assisting these companies with capital needs. As CCP companies seek funding, we may be
reaching out to the limited partners of the fund for specific introductions to venture capital firms if
we don't have existing relationships. We endeavor to keep our limited partners informed of ongoing
capital raises, and if you believe you can be helpful, please speak up. Also, many of our CCP
companies' financings will have opportunities for direct co-investments by CCP limited partners. If
this is something you are interested in, please let us know.
We welcome any comments or feedback,
Brad Stephens
Bart Stephens
Brock Pierce
Portfolio Companies
Authy - Two-factor authentication platform
Co-investors: Y Combinator
Bex.io — White label Bitcoin exchange as a service
Co-investors: Plug and Play, BoostVC
BitAccess— Bitcoin Teller Machine
Co-investors: Y Combinator, Pantera Capital
BitFury - World's largest Bitcoin miner
Co-investors: Binary Financial, Georgian Co-Investment Fund
BitGo - Enterprise focused, multi-signature secure wallet platform
Co-investors: Redpoint, Radar Partners, Founders Fund
BitPesa — Money Remittance to Africa
Co-investors: Pantera
Blade Financial Oka PayPay)— White-label Bitcoin debit card
Co-investors: Angels
BlockCypher — Powering Blockchains in the Cloud
Co-investors: Foundation Capital, Tim Draper
BlockStream — Enabling the creation of Side-chains
Co-investors: Reid Hoffman, Khosla Ventures, Ribbit Capital
BTC China - Leading Chinese Exchange, Mobile Apps and Payments
Co-investors: Lightspeed Venture Partners
Chain.com - Enterprise Bitcoin Infrastructure
Co-investors: Khosla Ventures, RRE Ventures, SV Angel, 500 Startups
ChangeCoin - Platform for receiving and sending online tips
Co-investors: Angellist
Coinsetter — Institutional grade, low latency Bitcoin exchange and ECN
Co-investors: Second Market, Tribeca Venture Fund
Expresscoin — A simple and safe way for consumers to buy Bitcoin
Co-investors: Bitcoin Shop (OTC: NTCS), Angels
FreshPay — Enabling ease of payments for individuals
Co-investors: Future Perfect Ventures, Angels
Gem (fka BitVault) — Bank-grade security for developer apps
Co-investors: Amplify.LA, RRE, First Round Capital
GoCoin - Multi-currency payment gateway for merchants
Co-investors: Bitcoin Shop (OTC: NTCS), Angels
Koinify - Crypto meets crowdfunding
Co-investors: IDG Capital Partners, zPark Venture, Danhua Capital
KrakenEuropean crypto currency exchange
Co-investors: Hummingbird Ventures, SecondMarket
LedgerX - Self-clearing Bitcoin derivatives platform
Co-investors: Lightspeed Venture Partners, SV Angel, Google Ventures
Noble Markets- Financial services focused crypto-exchange
Co-investors: Clearstone Venture Partners, Tally Capital
PeerNova — Crypto infrastructure as a Service and Cloud-hashing
Co-investors: Mosaik Partners, Pierre Lamond, Ashar Aziz
SFOX - Algorithmic Bitcoin exchange
Co-investors: Y Combinator, Khosla Ventures, Tech Accelerator
SnapCard — Spend your Bitcoin on any web site
Co-investors: Boost.VC
Texas Bitcoin Conference — Industry trade show
Co-investors: Angels
Xapo — Bitcoin focused consumer financial services
Co-investors: Pantera, Ribbit, Greylock, Benchmark, Fortress
ZenBox - Bitcoin ATM operator
Co-investors: Angels
ZipZap — global digital currency payment network
Co-investors: 500 Startups, Triple Point Capital, Blumberg Capital
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Draper Fisher Jurvetson [crypto] fund run by Tim Draper, John Fisher, and Steve Jurvetson, blackmail allegations [psychedelicamericas] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01121035 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Coinbase Series C preferred stock purchase
(date: 2014-10-24)
MEMORANDUM OF TERMS FOR PRIVATE PLACEMENT OF SERIES C PREFERRED STOCK
OF COINBASE GLOBAL INC.
October 24, 2014
This memorandum (the "Term Sheer) summarizes the principal terms of a proposed venture
capital financing for Coinbase Global Inc. (the "Company"). The completion of the transactions
contemplated by this memorandum will be subject to, among other things, satisfactory completion of
financial and legal due diligence by DFJ Growth and its partners and affiliates ("DFJ Growth"), as well
as execution of final transaction documents acceptable to DFJ Growth and the Company.
Offering Terms
Issuer: Coinbase Global Inc. (the Company")
Investor:
Investor Name Amount
DFJ Growth $25.0M
Other Investors $17.0 — 45.0 M
Total Investment Up to $70.0M
'Other Investors" shall include existing investors and new investors
to be determined by the Company in its sole discretion.
Securities to be issued: Series C Preferred Stock (the "Series C Preferred")
Price: [TBD] per share of Series C Preferred, reflecting a fully-diluted
pm-money valuation of $400.0 million. Assuming a total Series
C financing of $50.0 million, the post-money valuation shall be
$450.0 million based on the expected pro forma post-closing
capitalization of the Company. To the extent the pm-money
capitalization differs from that assumed in Exhibit A, the price
per share shall be adjusted accordingly.
Option Pool: Upon closing the Series C Preferred financing, the Company's
stock option pool shall have at least 8.0% of the Company's
fully-diluted equity shares unallocated and available for
issuance of future stock option grants. Any expansion of the
option pool needed to meet this requirement shall be included in
the pre-money valuation.
Expected Closing Date: One or more closings to occur within 90 days after execution of
this Term Sheet (the "Expected Closing Date"), where the
first closing shall include at least $39.6 million of investment
from DFJ Growth and existing investors within 30 days after
execution of this Term Sheet.
Terms of Series C Preferred Stock
Certificate of Incorporation
Liquidation Preference: In the event of a liquidation, dissolution or winding-up, the
proceeds shall be distributed to the stockholders as follows:
OHSUSA:759340828.2 1
First, the Preferred Stock (Series A, B, C) shall be paid one times
(IX) their respective original purchase price (on a pari-passu
basis) plus declared but unpaid dividends. Thereafter, the
Common Stock and FF Preferred Stock shall share any
remaining proceeds on an as-convened basis.
Dividends:
Redemption:
Automatic Conversion:
Price-Based Antidilution:
Other Antidilution Adjustments
Voting Rights:
Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement
Representations and
Warranties:
Conditions to Closing:
Expenses:
Investor Rights Agreement
Registration Rights:
Right of First Offer:
Financial Information:
Same structure as Series B
Same structure as Series B
Series C Preferred shall automatically convert into Common
Stock upon (i) the election of at least a majority of the
outstanding shares of Series C Preferred, or (ii) the
consummation of an underwritten public offering with aggregate
proceeds in excess of $50,000,000 (a "Qualified Public
Offering").
Same structure as Series B
Same structure as Series B
Series C Preferred votes on an as-convened basis, but also has a
series and class vote as provided by law.
Same protective provisions as the Series B investment
documents and requiring majority approval of the Series A, B
and C Preferred Stock (together, the "Preferred Stock").
Same series-based protective provisions as the Series B
Preferred for the Series C Preferred class and requiring majority
approval of the Series C Preferred.
Same structure as Series B
Same structure as Series B
Counsel to the Company will draft the investment documents.
The Company shall pay, at the closing, reasonable legal fees and
due diligence expenses of Investor not to exceed $35,000.
Same structure as Series B
Same structure as Series B
DR! Growth shall be treated as a Major Holder and shall have
information rights consistent with other major Preferred
investors.
OHSUSA:759340828.2
Board Composition: The size and composition of the board of directors (the "Board")
shall be determined by the Company and existing investors. If the
size of the Board is expanded as part of the Series C financing,
then DFJ Growth shall have the right to designate one Board
member and the two directors designated by a majority of the
Common Stock and FF Preferred Stock held by Brian Armstrong
and Fred Ehrsam (the "Founder Directors")  shall be entitled to
two (2) votes each on all matters submitted to the Board (i.e. an
aggregate of four (4) votes). If the size of the Board remains
unchanged at the time of the Series C financing, then DEL Growth
shall have the right to designate one Board member at any time
after the Board composition is expanded from its current size, at
which time each Founder Director shall be entitled to two (2)
votes (i.e. an aggregate of four (4) votes). DFJ Growth shall have
the right to designate a non-voting observer to participate in
Board meetings. In each case, the DFJ Growth Board member or
Board observer, as applicable, shall initially be Barry Schuler,
unless otherwise approved by the company. Approval shall not be
unreasonably withheld.
Other Matters
Right of First Refusal and Co-Sale: Same structure as Series B
Drag Along: Same structure as Series B
Management Rights Letter: At the closing, DFJ Growth shall receive a customary
management rights letter in a form reasonably acceptable to
DFJ Growth, which will include standard inspection rights and
board observation rights for DFJ Growth.
Disproportionate Adverse Changes: The rights of the Series C Preferred in the ancillary financing
documents shall not be adversely affected in a manner different
than the rights of the other series of Preferred Stock without the
consent of the holders of a majority of the Series C Preferred.
Confidentiality: Except as required by law, the Company will not discuss the
terms of this Term Sheet with any person other than key
officers, members of the Board of the Company or the
Company's accountants or attorneys without the written
consent of the Investors.
No Shop: From the signing date hereof until 5:00 P.M. Pacific Time on the
Expected Closing Date, other than in connection with the
allocation of the Series C Preferred financing to other investors
contemplated by this Term Sheet, the Company agrees that it
shall not solicit, encourage others to solicit, or encourage or
accept any offers for another preferred stock equity financing or
sale of the Company, and it shall not negotiate with or enter
into any agreement or understanding with any other person with
respect to any such transaction.
OHSUSA:759340828.2 1
The failure to execute and deliver a definitive agreement shall impose no liability on DFJ Growth, any
Investors or the Company. If not accepted and executed by 5:00 P.M. Pacific Time on October 25, 2014,
this term sheet shall expire.
AGREED AND ACCEPTED:
DFJ GROWTH
C
COINBASE GLOBAL, INC.
torl.S. By:  By:
Name: Barry M. Schuler Name: Fred Ehrsam
Date: 10/24/2014 Date: 10/25/2014 3:36 PM PT
OHSUSA:759340828.2 4
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                         Butterfly Trust [epstein] Epstein financial trust, sole beneficiary Karyna Shuliak 
                                                                     Cypress, Inc [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                       Enhanced Education [epstein] Epstein financial trust 
                                                                   FT Real Estate [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                               Haze Trust [epstein] Epstein financial trust 
                                                    LSJE, LLC [epstein] Epstein company LSJ Emergency (???) 
                                                                     Laurel, Inc. [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                    Maple, Inc. [epstein] Epstein company in Virgin Islands 
                                                   Michelle's Transportation, LLC [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                               Nautilus Education [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                                     Neptune, LLC [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                                           Plan D [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                                 Thomas World Air [epstein] Epstein company 
 Boothbay [finance] fund run by Ari Glass whom Epstein called "a bit sketchy" but invested $50 million with 
                            Jawbone [tech] wireless earpiece company invested in by Epstein and Ian Osborne 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01118143 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2014-10-31)
Valuation Report
10/31/2014
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - OCTOBER 31, 2014
9/30/14 10/31/14 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 144,227,202 233,514,622 89,287,420
Fixed Income 57,864,373 57,800,676 (63,697)
Equities 43,011,160 44,109,757 1,098,597
Equity Options 1,542,000 0 (1,542,000)
Equity ETF's 3,139,200 3,229,200 90,000
FX - Options & Derivatives 262,918 398,286 135,368
Currency 368,632 0 (368,632)
Hedge Funds 105,406,519 41,297,708 (64,108,811)
Investments 18,865,998 18,319,398 (546,600)
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 15,400,000 15,400,000
Loans Receivable 747,446 747,446 -
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 7,500,000 7 500 000 0
Total Assets 398,335,448 422,317,092 23,981,644
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
Highbridge redemption - Haze 38,485,360
redemption - SFL 20,785,189
a ridge
- DB Zwirn payment 4,375,302
Leon Fee 25,000,000
Dividends, interest Income & Other Distributions - per SFL stmt 515,475
Kyara I return of proceeds (100k return of cost basis + 201k profit) 301,100
Sale of ML options I 1,078,463
Euros from brokerage to custody account 368,632
Redemption of JPM Contingent Buffered Equity 1,012,047
Purchase of 49,033 shares of Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% (1,188,315)
Monthly Spending (1,350,000)
Miscellaneous (95,832)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50,000 89,287,420
Deutsche First BNP Paribas Wells
Asset Description Bank Bank UBS & MJ Escrow Fargo Totals
Cash
Southern Trust Company 93,550,306 555,199 94,105.505
Southern Financial LLC 56,774,825 56,774,825
Haze Trust 47,348,340 47,348.340
Jaspers Inc. 24,556,507 372 24.556,879
JEE 2,972,090 491,719 1,979,584 5,443,394
2,332.355 Enhanced Education 2,026,044 308,311
FT Real Estate 1,348,380 1,346,380
NES LLC 278,432 278.432
LSJE LLC 246,736 246.736
JEGE LLC 215,779 215 779
211,942 Zorro Development Corp 71,007 140,935
JEGE Inc. 203,308 203,308
Cypress Inc. 125,206 125,206
Hyperion Air LLC 82,930 82,930
JEE - Paris (US $) 80,934 80,934
Nautilus Inc. 88,670 68,070
Thomas World Air LLC 39,757 39,757
Neptune—LLC 15,773 15,773
Plan D LW 10,400 10,400
Maple Inc. 10,155 10,155
Butterfly Trust 8,055 8,055
Michelles Transportation Co LLC 7,357 7,357
Laurel Inc. 1,304 1,304
The JEE Life Ins Trust #3 206 206
Total Cash 228,114,002 3,199,167 1,979,584 80,934 140,935 233,514,6=
Purchase Quantity 9/30/14 10/31/14 Unrealized
Gain (Loaf Asset Description Date Cost Value Gslue
Haze Trust - Fixed incoliie
Bank of America 8.125% PM 12/29/2049 05/10/11
—iitilbifi
3000,000, 3389,621 3,338,906 3,381396 -2225
inioigeri t-eiriasTA Oki 4/30040 1000200 3237.958 3,346.250 3,25U80 -862-C1-6
Peabody Ennergy Corp Sr Notes 7.375% 11/1/2016 05/10111 1200,000 1.264.664 1,308,629 1,280,250 15,586
-17,195 'payment Inc 10.25% 5/15/2018 10/02/12 500.000 —76 75:62t 460,469 443,632
JPM Tr Fit Rate Income Fund 01/22/13 213.308.357 2,152.009 2,110,078 2118,152 43,857
GS Mortgage Loan 20054FCCL B1 5.739596 3W3M -7,1067600.00 1,185165 1,171,514 1169,061 3,496
Citibank Preferred Set C 5.8% 10/28/14 49,033.00 1,180,739 - 1 188 315 7.576
114.621 Citibank I ftirred Sew K 6.875% — 213/14 79,000.00 1.999.419 j180.860 2, 4.
total Haze Trust -Fixed Income 14,656:66ra3.7 -ff 14.932,096 -18,706
Southern Trust Co. - Find Income
My PinancalTA Pfd erA 6/11113 57,030 1,429,418 1,535,010 1.509,360
Nationwide SoZely 6.875% GBP callable 8120/2019 4/15/14 2,000,000 3,439.193 3,258,138 3,285,143
. 79943
- - -154, 60
Petioles De Venezuela 5% 10/26/15 9/17/13 1,000,000 1189.481. L767.222 M„R e6 -118.925
Total Southern Trust Co.-Fixed Income 6,758.092 6,550,370 6,565,059 -193,033
ampere - Fixed Income
JPM Trust Fr RT Income fund 02/13/13 159.790.724 1,609,119 1,580,673 1,586,722 -22,397
Total .leepers - Fixed income 1.609.119 1,580,673 1,586,722 -22,397
Soutrn ern Mandel LLC • Fred Income
Bank of America 8.125% Pfd Dec 29 2049 1/10111 2,000,000 2,065,000 2,225,938 2, 442, 931 189,931
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 4/3113 300.000 300,000 335229 330.231 30,231
Earlhink Inc 8.875% May 16 2019 10/22/12 400 000 410,444 411 313
61069
405 369
--- ilIMI,Cn
-5 074
Earthtlnk Inc 075% May 15 2019 10/23/12 60000 814.557
General Electric C C 7.125% Dec 15 2049 _13/27rg  2 II0000 0 10p,I32 2,356,563 2 383 833
14,63in
283 202
Headwaters Inc 7. 4/1 19 1- =1/ --- 1 MOD. , Gl'i,W381 1,080.413
JPM Cont Buff SX7P 10/16/2014 85% Cont Barrier 25% Cap Intl
J organirrURsimi - mfmsAwinnel49
9124/13 1,000,000 0 1,061,600 - 0
21,875 6/15/11 2,500.000 2,887.500 2,788.542 22 -0,375
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pid 7.9% April 302049 6/15/11 2500000 2,675,000 2 788.542 2.709375 34 375
LBG Capital 12/29/49 5/21/13 3.000,000 3,247.500 3,285.519 3,316,203 67,703
Lloyds Bank 9.875%12/16/2021 5/10/12 1.500 000 1 617,178 1858,729 1,854,198 237,020
Petroles De Venezuela 5% 10/28/2015 9/16/13 2.500:000 361.851 2.196.528 2,213.194 -148,656
Servicemaster Company 8% Feb 15 2020 1/24/13 440.000 459.327 469,700 477,131 17,804
Servicemaster Company 8% Feb 15 2020 2/25/13 1000,800 T,0487804 1.067,500 1.084.389 3631%
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Osc 31 2049 1/30/12 3.000.000 2,994.167 3,297,000 3,302.490 308,323
330,731 Ally rEln&I Pfd Ser A Callable 9/3/12 46.600 903.218 1.254.938 1,233068
My Finanoal Pfd Ser ACallable 2/9/12 80.000 1,610.000 2 154 400 2,118,400 106,400
GMAC Cap TR I GTD PM Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80.000 1,M1,774 2.128.800 2,138.400 255,626
Royal Bank Scotland Group PLC 7.25% Ser T 10/24/12 40.000 951.600 1,010,000 1,014.000 62 400
1400 Royal Bank Scotland Group PLC 7.2.55‘ Ser r 1/7/13 40,000 995,200 1.010.000 1.014,030
'loyal Bank Scotland Group PLC 7.25% Ser T 1/14/13 40.000 linfififl 1.2122:81 1.014.000 WE
total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income 30,912,732 34,408,721 33,221,896 009,185
Southern Financial LLC • Fixed Income (asset backed securities) fignAbs•
Countrywide Home Loans MOH d 81 5.75% V25/03 4/18/13 978,691 913,887 857,165 846,224 47,643
Washington Mutual Mig 2004-RA2 d CBI var 7/26/2033 11/19/13 739,242 W,
Total Southern Financial LLC • Fixed Income (asset backed securities PM 1 507 902 1,494,903 16 378
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 57,864,373 57,800,676
Note: Accrued Interest has been Included in month end fixed Income values
Purchase Quantity 9/30/14 10/31/14 Unrealized
Asset Dais  on Date Cost 1/abie Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LW - Eireities
,&ple Inc 10128/13 000 1 058 121 1,410400 1,612.000 453 _879
1.357741 Apple Inc 978/14
____,_14
1-50;10 14.842,508 it -n2.500 18,200,a0
Apollo Global Man nt 3131/11 263,157 4.999,1183
11(597
6,273,663 5,986,822 98839
Arlad Pharmaceuticals Inc 2/14/12 7,535 40.689 44,909 -69.688
Mad Pharmaceuticab Inc 1/24/13 9,000 176,400 48,1100 53,640 -122.760
Ascena Retail Group inc. (Formerly Dress Barn 1.3.11) 1/16/01 70,500 1.500030 917A30- 877,725 -622,275
Bank of New York Melon 8raii 4 2.90 000 9 076,406 9 682.500 9 680.000 603,594
422,208 Biogen ldec Inc 2/14/12 2,095 250,455 693.047 672,663
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17,500 665 000 1,383,200 1,312.325 647.325
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49,830 1,265,037 944,777 1,289,600 24,W
Generai-Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3,586,947 3.114,949 3,062,285 -523,662
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 496,109 589.260 593,630 97,521
Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 5,000 396,407 532,250 660,000 163,593
Gilead Sciences Inc 317114 3.100 246,797 329,995 347,200 100403
Waal Net Inc 0/8/14 2500 1.174,506 1.152,750 1,187,750 13,244
JP Morgan Ons & Co. 1114/05 1,453 0 87,529 - 0
Mobileye NV Arnstetveen (3 -ffilartts 91711 800 20,000 42,872 71.104 21,504
Sa_rigamo Biosciences Inc 928/13 50 000 422,214 539,250 607 000 184 786
-40 03 SentatiTT Consumer USA 1/28/14 1.000 24,000 17,610 184,600
Twitter Inc 1117/13 1600 ak
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities 40 353 484 43 011 160 44,109,757 3,756,273
Southern Financial LLC - E. .br Options
Call 100 American Afton.. , 20 Exp Exp 1/17/2015 12/1 /13 1,000 803,315 1 550 000
Put 100 American Airlines - I Exp 1/17/2015 12/12(13 (1,000) -197.702 1.1® Q 4
Total Southern Financial LW - Equity Options 605,613 1,542,000
Southern Financial LLC - Equity Etre
WIsdomIree Japan Hedged Equity 12/18/13 60,000 2,966,099 3,139,200, 3.229 200 263 101
Total Southern Financial LW - Equities 2,986,099 3,139,200 3,229,200 263,101
unrested
Southern Financial LLC - FX Options di Derivatives salotius_
Long Pul USD vs CNN - Strike 6.16 Exp 8/12/2015 8/12/14 75,000,000 273,000 184.139 299A40 26,440
Long Call USD vs JPY - Strike 101.00 Exp 11/20/2014 11/20/13 1,000,000 44,800 79 247 98,852 54,052
Short USD vs JPY - Barrier 90 Exp 11/20/2014 11120/13 (21,0001 -16.500 5227 -4 18,498
Short USD vs JPY • Barrier 98 Exp 11/20/2014 11/20/13 (21,000 -15,000 -147 -2 14,998
Short USD vs JPY - Barrier 97 Exp 4 11/20/13 (21,000 -13,300 45 Q AIN
0 78,779 96,846 9%846
Long 1.345 strike EUR USD Put Exp 9/8/2014 6/6/14 10 boo 000 0 320.000 0 sae en
Short 1.38 strike EUR USD Cal Exp 91812014 er6/14 10,000,000 Q Q 0 remitted gain
0 320.000 0 320A00
total unrealized gain (loss) 125,288
Total Southern Financial LLC - FX Options 44 Derivatives 273,000 262,918 398,286
Southern Financial La - Cuneng
Euros 42 1.2831 (transferred to JEE Custody account) 291,847 0.0000 368,632
Total Southern Financial LLC - Currency 388,832
9/30/14 10131114 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return
Hedge Funds - Southern Financla (SFLLC)
Highbridge 20,785,189 44,549 0.00% 4.70%
Bruce Galloway 3,631,734 3,333,393 -8.21% -16.67%
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 10,051,474 9,991,165 -0.60% -0.09%
Bear Sterns Asset Backed Sec 124,91.0 124.916 (book carryinc value)
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 34,593,313 13,494,023
Hedge Funds - Haze
Highbridge 38,485,360 80,188 0.00% 4.70%
King Street 27 932 544 27,703.497 -0.82% 5.82%
Hedge Funds - Haze 66,417,904 27,783,685
Hedge Funds - Jeepers
DB Zwim - Corbin - est of 5% holdback 20,000 20.000
Cie lessoymtiornik.rnis H a& ss 4.375.302 Q paid 101612014
Hedge Funds - Jeepers 4,395,302 20,000
Total Hedge Funds 105,406,519 41,297,708
SFL
Mort Southern FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust Real Estate Jeepers
investments SFL
Kyara I (at cost) 0
Kyara II (at cost) 250,000
Kyara III (at cost) 500,000
Jawbone Investment (grat at cost) 10,000,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 1,000,000 STC
Adfin Solutions (at cost) 875,000
124 Parc Moceau - Palm Beach (at cost) 4,869,398
21 East 26th Street (repaid 220,500 of 920,500 cost (220.5 & 700) 800,000 proj profit) 800,000
Columbia Holdings (repaid 588,333 + 333,333 profit to date) 25,000
Totals 10,000,000 1,000,000 1,625,000 825,000 4,869,398
Total Investments 18,319,398
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 BeN 430 N331JE 3,000,000 3,000,000
1988 Guifstream G-IV N212JE 8,000,000 8,000,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 3,000,000 3,000,000
Automobiles 700,000 700,000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & 3,000,000 8,000,000 3,000,000 1,400,000 15,400,000
Boats I
Asset Description JEE Totals
Loans Receivable
Adam Bly 300,000 300,000
Larry / Eileen Visosld 225,000 225,000
Johnn O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
200,000 200,000
Total Loans Receivable 747,446 747,446
Enhanced

• Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry
Cello 175,000 175,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - D 3,500,000 3,500,000
Watches. Earring & Other - see attached 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule - see attached 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & 175,000 3,500,000 775,000 3,050,000 7,500,000
Jewelry
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                         Matthew Roszak [crypto] co-founder of Bloq, accusations of insider trading 
               Tether [crypto] $185 billion stablecoin founded by Brock Pierce beloved by drug cartels and Iranians, cash managed by Howard Lutnick 
                                                                                                                                  [cryptadamus/bbg] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01089506 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Crypto Currency Partners II investor report
(date: 2014-11-01)
BLOCKCHAIN CAPITAL, LLC
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS II, LP
NOVEMBER 2014
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA DBILL
EXPERIENCED TEAM IN INVESTING
BART STEPHENS BRAD STEPHENS BROCK PIERCE PAUL STEPHENS

• Stephens Inv. • Stephens Inv. • Bitcoin Foundation • Robertson
Mgmt. Mgmt. Board Member Stephens & Co.

• Ivanhoe Capital • Fidelity Ventures • Founded 15x • RS Investments
EXPERIENCE • E*Trade Group • CSFB Startups • Duke Univ.

• Princeton • Furman Selz • Raised > $200M Endowment
• Duke • Invested in > 25x • UC Berkeley
Startups Endowment
RECOGNITION
#2 U.S. Long/Short Hedge Fund*
2.5x Venture Fund, 11.5% IRR
Leaders in Technology
Investing
lO
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNER
Founded 8 crypto
currency startups
and often
referred to as the
"father of digital
currency"
40 Years in
Silicon Valley
Investment
Management and
Banking
Incubated and Founded
Dozens of Startups
100's of Silicon Valley
Investments
*Absolute Return Magazine 2014
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
ABOUT STEPHENS INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT LLC
STEPHENS INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT
FOUNDED IN 2002 BY THE STEPHENS BROTHERS
INSTITUTIONAL HEDGE FUNDS & VENTURE FUNDS
ASSETS UNDER MANAGEMENT: $150M
Decades of Clicr-Pssful Growth Investing
CRYPTO CURRENCY ANTHERS ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
SUCCESSFUL TRACK RECORD OF HOME RUNS
PRIVATE
o RelatelQ 2014
E 2004
Ova 2008
2008
A 2014 TBD
RUPTURE
PUBLIC
4
25.0x 0! 4
8.1x illumina
6.9x Atim.A.T.
5.0x GILON
ncsoF -r -
2014 77.0x
2009 39.0x
2010 4.6x
2011 5.1x
2007 3.4x
Private and Public Exits through Multiple Market Cycles
CRYPTO CURRENCY
PARTNERS ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 2SS SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
BROCK PIERCE - "FATHER OF DIGITAL CURRENCY"
INDUSTRY LEADER AND SPOKESPERSON
Singularity mil,KFN \ vrITUTE
University
Neuf i o tic Conn) e..3
HIE WALL STREET JOUR \ 11,.
All
TODAY
BITCOIN FOUNDATION BOARD MEMBER
Bitcoin Foundation
• Protocol Roadmap
• Global Regulatory Insight
• Thought leader exposure
PATRICK MURCK GENERAL COUNSEL
I GAVIN ANDRESEN CHIEF SCIENTIST
Repeat Entrepreneur and Digital Currency Visionary
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
BROCK PIERCE - SERIAL ENTREPRENEUR
expresso
FOUNDED CRYPTC
GoCoin (payment processor)
expresscoin (retai l exchange)
FOUNDED NON-CRYPTO
IGE (2001-2007)
Zam (2004-2012)
ry, zenBox ZenBox (ATM / remittance network) RAl IMI Exchange (2004 -Present)
IXAtt Zoomhash (cloud / hardware mining) Xfire 2.0 (2011 -Present)
Obitcoir Blade Financial (Bitcoin debit card) Playsino (2011 -Present) Dtal7C/U:
1>
Noble Markets (institutional exchange) Fl E DELTA Five Delta (2012-2014)
,P,9)N" Coin Congress (conference) fib
GamesTV (2005-2007)
Evertune (2008 -Present) Tether (fiat backed alt coin)
Extensive History of Defining Digital Currencies
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS I, LP
® b bex.io
Change . 1 1 11'
coinsetter
(NI KraKen
[7.11edgerX
* expresscoin
0 BitGo "resBitFury
BTC China
Ihr 4 t„
0 BLADE
mockstream app AlphaPoint IzIpzap
"4
BLOCK
() Gem
WI
BITACCESS
The First Dedicated Bitcoin Venture Fund
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS I, LP
ventures' khosla ventures 'BENCHMARK
Redpoint L  LIGHTSPIED
VENTURE PARTNERS
Ribbit Capital
Q.
SVAngel
RADAR( PARTNERS
FOUNDERS FUND
PLUGAEPpY
Combinator
-
RItEYentut•s
PANTERA
*FORTRESS
AMPLIFY
Sitcom Inc
greylock
partners.
HIGHLAND CAPITAL PARTNERS
500 startups
rst Round CAPITAL
Bitcoin Co-investments with Leading VCs
Ow) CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
USE CASES FOR "BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY"
Financial and Records
I
Bitcoin Private Equities Bonds Public Equities
Shareholder Voting Remittance Crowd-funding
Spending Records Micro-payments Commodities
Trading Records Derivatives Mortgage/loan records
Micro-finance Servicing records Micro-charity
\.
Public Records
C
Land titles Birth certificates Vehicle registries
Business license Business Incorporation/dissolution
Business Ownership records Regulatory records
Criminal records Passports Death certificates
Voter IDs Building permits Health/safety inspections
Non-profit records Court records Gun permits Voting
* CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS
Legal / Health / Education
I
Smart Contracts Signatures/identity Degrees
Wills Genome data Trusts Licensing
Medical Records Escrows Delivery records
Arbitration Grades Patents Copyrights
Certifications Academic Credits
.1
Commercial / Media
HR Records Rental car keys Accounting records
Business transaction records Software licenses
Trademarks Betting records Hotel room keys
Safety deposit box keys Coupons Vouchers
Domain names Betting records Movie Tickets
DRM: Music/movie/book license GPS network identity  ..1
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
INDUSTRY GROWTH OVER THE PAST YEAR
Key Bitcoin Adoption Metrics
Quarterly
Sep-14 Jun-14 CO A
Commerce
Wallets 6.559.978 5.427.688 21%
Merchants 76.000 63.000 21%
Merchants' annual revenue ($bn) 86 29 196%
ATMs 251 103 144%
Unique bitcoin addresses 184.554 136.152 36%
Industry
All-time VC investment ($m) 317.0' 225.3 41%
Number of VC-backed startups 66' 50 32%
Media
Mainstream media mentions 9.398 9.024 4%
Technology
Network Hash Rate (billion/second) 261.900.382 111.194.683 136%
Github no. of updated repositories 18.753 15.109 24%
Valuation
Bitcoin market capitalization ($bn)
Saurces: ConDesit
Last 12 Months
Sep-13
1.353.201
10.0O3
0
0
61.734
30.4
14
1.794
1.213.246
1.573
'ISA.% *cool O4 cloak fM ilkxkcraoll-30Srn I
F cures usea are as of era of quart
6 Slate of Bitcoin O3 2014 S ColnDesk
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
HYPER GROWTH- ONE YEAR
The Mining Arms Race: A More Plausible Total Exchange Trading Volume Sees
Bitcoin Price Drop Theory? Steady Growth
Bacon New.* Hash Rate (Wiens ci bashes second).2010- Present
Cumulative Trading Volume Ibtconsl
104 Sy3 120000 000
.MO WO -
100400000 •
X. a00
INS:MOOD
1410Oopo
00000 OM •
60 COO 000
40 DCO 000
20000 000
To remain cOmpeOtwe miners - who Possess perhaps the largest and ever - 0
growng) supply of btcoins - must sell bacons to finance runnng costs and 1 CP se e 1 sal  4,• it 4, 1 rr  si hardware 
upgrades
Son Crews
t9 C .
Approximately 8 Million Bitcoin Wallets Forecast Cut for Bitcoin-Accepting
Still Forecasted by End of Year Merchants by 10K to 90K by End of Year

• DX COD
13, - 096 ••'. too an 120 000 R, . 0 9777
G.N:C COD 100 000
s• J001, let CM, ••• 60 COO
IWO= 60 COO
saes 40000
MOIR
ISM
20 000
0
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
CASE STUDY: ChangeCoin
ChangeTip enables a "tipping" feature using Bitcoin on other companies' websites. It
has built a Bitcoin micropayment platform that is currently integrated with Twitter,
GitHub, Reddit, Google+, Tumblr, and YouTube.
We believe that ChangeCoin's micro transaction platform is poised to be the financial
equivalent of the "Like" button, and enabling new mechanisms for premium online
constant to be monetized
Social Accounts by Date
a 30k
25k
20k
3 15k
c 10k
3
5k
Ok
Mar 14 Apr 14 May 14 Jun 14 Jul '14 Aug 14 Sep 14
Date
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS
— Sum of Social Accounts — Sum of Users — Sun of Tips
Dabliaro
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
CCP II - INVESTMENT APPROACH
VERTICALS
CONSUMER

• Exchanges
• Remittance
• Digital Wallets
INFRASTRUCTURE
• Side Chains
• Blockchain Apps
• Mining
ENTERPRISE

• Multi-sig
workflow
• Payment
Gateways
• Financial Tools
RIGOROUS
PROCESS
• Deep Global Domain
Knowledge

• Extensive Networks
• Proprietary Deal Flow
• Primary Investigative
Due Diligence
• Exhaustive
Management/
Industry Interaction
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNER
VALUE —ADD
• Recruiting
• Business
Development
• Capital Introduction
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
HISTORIC
VENTURE
RETURNS
CCP II - STRATEGY AND MAKE-UP
FUND POSITION
ALLOCATION
FUND POSITION STRATEGY
$20M
40% New CCP II investments
30% Reserves for CCP II fol low-on rounds
30% Access to CCP fol low-on rounds
Leverage our network and industry expertise to find
investments that uti lize Blockchain technologies and
help these portfol io companies disrupt legacy industries.
Access to CCP's early seed deals as well as future deals
Cod CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
CCP II - CONTRIBUTED INVESTMENTS
BitGo June '14 575,000 Series A preferred
Coinsetter December '13 550,000 Convert to Series A
expresscoin November '13 525,000 Convert to Series A, 52.5m Cap
GoCoin October '13 520,000 Note converted 4.5x at Series A
GoCoin October '13 580,000 Common at 52.5m, 4.5x at Series A
Kraken April '14 570,000 Series A preferred
LedgerX July `14 550,000 Series A preferred
TOTAL $37O,OOO (current value —$73O,OOO)
SIM and Brock contributing Bitcoin Co-Investments at cost to CCP II
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNER S ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
CCP II - INVESTMENTS MADE
PeerNova September '14 550,000 Note Discounted to Series A preferred
BitAccess September '14 525,000 Note Discounted to Series A preferred
BitPesa September '14 $100,000 Note Discounted to Series A preferred
BlockStream October '14 $100,000 Series A preferred
ChangeCoin October '14 $100,000 Series A Preferred
BitNet October '14 $75,000 Series A Preferred
TOTAL $45O,OOO
Actively continuing to invest in the ecosystem
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNER S ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
CCP - PARTNERS AND ADVISORY BOARD
BOBBY LEE
WILL O'BRIEN
VINNY LINGHAM
MALCOLM CASSELLE
STEVE BEAUREGARD
CHARLIE LEE
IFTIKAR AHMED
MATTHEW ROSZAK
SCOTT WALKER
ADAM ETTINGER
BILL LEE
CEO, BTC China
CEO, BitGo
CEO, Gyft (acquired by First Data)
CEO, Timeline Labs
CEO, GoCoin
Coinbase, Founder of Litecoin
Partner, Oak Investment Partners
Partner, Tally Capital
Founder, ZenBox and ZoomHash
leading Bitcoin legal counsel
prolific angel investor
Built a robust team of Advisors and LPs from Bitcoin ecosystem

Co) CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
CCP II - SUMMARY OF TERMS
TERM
FEE/INCENTIVE
GP CONTRIBUTION
INVESTMENTS
STRUCTURE

Ow) CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS
$20M
6-8 Years
2.5% / 25%
+2.5% Fund or + $500k
30 ($100k - $500k per deal)
Called Capital, BTC Accepted
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
CCP II - SERVICE PROVIDERS
ADMINISTRATION / CFO
-=
BTC VAULT
0 CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNER S
Kranz & Associates
Sidley Austin
Crawford Pimintel
Silicon Valley Bank
Merri ll Lynch
Xapo
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
SUMMARY
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS
FIRST DEDICATED BITCOIN VENTURE FUND
UNPARALLELED ACCESS TO DEAL -FLOW
PROVEN TRACK RECORDS
Building the Future Leaders in the Bitcoin Ecosystem
( ) CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNER S ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111
EFTA01082451 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Blockchain Capital / Coinbase nondisclosure agreement possibly regarding Epstein investment
(date: 2014-11-10)
COINBASE, INC.
MUTUAL NONDISCLOSURE AGREEMENT
This Mutual Nondisclosure Agreement (this "Agreement"), effective November 10,
2014 ("Effective Date"), is entered into by and between Coinbase Global, Inc., a Delaware
corporation with an address at San Francisco, CA 94104-5401
("Coinbase") and Blockchain Capital ("Investor") (each herein referred to
individually as a "Party," or collectively as the "Parties"). In consideration of the covenants and
conditions contained herein, the Parties hereby agree to the following:

1. PURPOSE
The Parties wish to explore a business opportunity of mutual interest (the
"Opportunity"), and in connection with the Opportunity, each Party has disclosed, and may
further disclose (such disclosing Party, the "Provider") to the other Party (such receiving Party,
the "Recipient") certain confidential technical and business information that the Provider desires
the Recipient to treat as confidential.

2. CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION
A. Definition. "Confidential Information" means any information disclosed by
Provider to Recipient, including any information disclosed prior to the Effective Date, either
directly or indirectly in writing, orally or by inspection of tangible objects (including, without
limitation, research, product plans, products, services, equipment, customers, markets, software,
inventions, processes, designs, drawings, hardware configuration information, marketing and
finance documents, prototypes, samples and data sets), which derives economic value, actual or
potential, from not being generally known to or readily ascertainable by proper means, by other
persons who can obtain economic value from its disclosure or use, or other information which
should reasonably be expected to be held confidential, in all cases whether or not designated as
"confidential" at the time of disclosure. Confidential Information may also include information
of a third party that is in Provider's possession and is disclosed to Recipient under this
Agreement.

B. Exceptions. Confidential Information shall not, however, include any information that
Recipient can establish (i) was publicly known or made generally available without a duty of
confidentiality prior to the time of disclosure to Recipient by Provider, (ii) becomes publicly
known or made generally available without a duty of confidentiality after disclosure to Recipient
by Provider through no action or inaction of Recipient; (iii) is in the rightful possession of
Recipient without confidentiality obligations at the time of disclosure by Provider to Recipient as
shown by Recipient's then-contemporaneous written files and records kept in the ordinary course
of business; or (iv) is independently developed by the employees or agents of the Recipient
without the use of Confidential Information provided by the Provider as can be demonstrated by
competent evidence.

C. Compelled Disclosure. If Recipient becomes legally compelled to disclose any
Confidential Information, Recipient will provide Provider prompt written notice of such
disclosure and will assist Provider in seeking a protective order or another appropriate remedy. If
Provider waives Recipient's compliance with this Agreement or fails to obtain a protective order
or other appropriate remedy, Recipient will furnish only that portion of the Confidential
information that is legally required to be disclosed, provided that any Confidential Information so
disclosed shall maintain its confidentiality protection for all purposes other than such legally
compelled disclosure.

3. NONUSE AND NONDISCLOSURE
Recipient shall not use any Confidential Information for any purpose except to evaluate
and engage in discussions concerning the Opportunity. Recipient shall not disclose any
Confidential Information or permit any Confidential Information to be disclosed, either directly
or indirectly, to any third party without Provider's prior written consent. Recipient shall not
disclose Confidential Information or permit the disclosure of Confidential Information to its
employees, except that Recipient may disclose Confidential Information to those employees of
Recipient who are required to have the information in order for Recipient to evaluate or engage in
discussions concerning the Opportunity, provided that such employee has signed a nonuse and
nondisclosure agreement in content at least as protective as the provisions hereof, prior to any
disclosure of Confidential Information to such employee. Recipient shall not reverse engineer,
disassemble, or decompile any prototypes, software, samples, or other tangible objects that
embody the Confidential Information.

4. MAINTENANCE OF CONFIDENTIALITY
Recipient shall take reasonable measures to protect the confidentiality of and avoid
disclosure and unauthorized use of the Confidential Information. Without limiting the foregoing,
Recipient shall take at least those measures it employs to protect its own confidential information.
Recipient shall not make any copies of the Confidential Information unless the same arc
previously approved in writing by Provider. Recipient shall reproduce Provider's proprietary
rights notices on any such authorized copies, in the same manner in which such notices were set
forth in or on the original. Recipient shall immediately notify Provider of any unauthorized use
or disclosure, or suspected unauthorized use or disclosure, of Confidential Information.

5. NO OBLIGATION
Nothing in this Agreement shall obligate either Party to proceed with any transaction
between them, and each Party reserves the right, in its sole discretion, to terminate the discussions
contemplated by this Agreement concerning the Opportunity. Nothing in this Agreement shall be
construed to restrict either Party's use or disclosure of its own Confidential Information.

6. NO WARRANTY
ALL CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION IS PROVIDED "AS IS." NEITHER PARTY
MAKES ANY WARRANTIES, EXPRESS, IMPLIED OR OTHERWISE, REGARDING THE
ACCURACY, COMPLETENESS OR PERFORMANCE OF ANY CONFIDENTIAL
INFORMATION, OR WITH RESPECT TO NON-INFRINGEMENT OR OTHER VIOLATION
OF ANY INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS OF A THIRD PARTY OR OF RECIPIENT.

7. RETURN OF MATERIALS
All documents and other tangible objects containing or representing Confidential
Information and all copies or extracts thereof or notes derived therefrom that are in the possession
or control of Recipient shall be and remain the property of Provider and shall be promptly
returned to Provider or destroyed (with proof of such destruction), each upon Provider's request;
provided, however, notwithstanding the foregoing, legal counsel for the Recipient may, in its sole
discretion, retain one (I) copy of Confidential Information in counsel's sole custody to preserve a
record of the same.

8. NO LICENSE
Nothing in this Agreement is intended to grant any rights to Recipient under any
intellectual property right of Provider, nor shall this Agreement grant Recipient any rights in or to
the Confidential Information except as expressly set forth in this Agreement.

9. TERM
This Agreement shall be in force and effect for a period of three (3) years commencing
on the date hereof. The foregoing notwithstanding, the obligations of confidentiality hereunder
with respect to all Confidential Information shall survive and shall be binding upon the Recipient
until such time as all Confidential Information disclosed hereunder qualifies as any of the
exceptions to Confidential Information set forth in Section 2.B through no action or inaction of
Recipient.

10. REMEDIES
The parties agree that any violation or threatened violation of this Agreement by a
Recipient will cause irreparable injury to Provider, entitling Provider to seek injunctive relief in
addition to all legal remedies without showing or proving any actual damage and without any
bond required to be posted.
11. MISCELLANEOUS
This Agreement shall bind and inure to the benefit of the Parties and their respective
successors and permitted assigns; except that neither Party may assign or otherwise transfer this
Agreement, by operation of law or otherwise, without prior written consent of the other Party.
Any assignment or transfer of this Agreement in violation of the foregoing shall be null and void.
This Agreement will be interpreted and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of
California, without regard to conflict of law principles. Any controversy, claim or dispute arising
out of or otherwise relating to this Agreement or any breach thereof, including the scope of this
arbitration clause shall be settled by binding arbitration. The place of arbitration shall be San
Francisco, California. Each Party hereby represents and warrants that the persons executing this
Agreement on its behalf have express authority to do so, and, in so doing, to bind the Party
thereto. This Agreement contains the entire agreement between the Parties with respect to the
Opportunity and supersedes all prior written and oral agreements between the Parties regarding
the Opportunity. If a court or other body of competent jurisdiction finds, or the Parties mutually
believe, any provision of this Agreement, or portion thereof, to be invalid or unenforceable, such
provision will be enforced to the maximum extent permissible so as to effect the intent of the
Parties, and the remainder of this Agreement will continue in full force and effect. No provision
of this Agreement may be waived except by a writing executed by the Party against whom the
waiver is to be effective. A Party's failure to enforce any provision of this Agreement shall
neither be construed as a waiver of the provision nor prevent the Party from enforcing any other
provision of this Agreement. No provision of this Agreement may be amended or otherwise
modified except by a writing signed by the Parties to this Agreement. The Parties may execute
this Agreement in counterparts, each of which is deemed an original, but all of which together
constitute one and the same agreement. This Agreement may be delivered by e-mail or facsimile
transmission, and e-mail or facsimile copies of executed signature pages shall be binding as
originals.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Parties by their duly authorized representatives have
executed this Agreement as of the Effective Date.
COINBASa&BAL, INC.
By:
Name:  r- -
Title:  Co-founder
INV
By:
Name:
Title:  ft ornAte A'S
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Jeffrey E. Epstein 2014 Trust [epstein] Epstein financial trust, trustees: Darren Indyke, David Mitchell, Jes Staley 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00016884 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein last will and testament naming Darren Indyke, David Mitchell, Jes Staley, Larry Summers as executors
(date: 2014-11-18)
LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT
OF
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
I, JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, of Little St. James Island, St. Thomas, United States Virgin Islands, being of
sound mind, do make, publish and declare this to be my Will hereby revoking all prior Wills and Codicils
made by me.
FIRST: A. I direct my Executor to pay from my estate all expenses of my
last illness, my funeral and burial expenses, the administration expenses of my estate and all of my debts
duly proven and allowed against my estate.

B. I direct my Executor to pay from my estate, as
compensation to each Executor for serving as Executor hereunder, the sum of Two Hundred Fifty
Thousand Dollars ($250,000) to each Executor upon the completion of probate of my estate. No
Executor shall receive any other compensation for serving as Executor hereunder; provided, however,
that my Executor shall be reimbursed from my estate for all reasonable costs, expenses, charges, and
liabilities incurred or paid in respect thereto, including fees and expenses of counsel or any other agents
hired by my Executor, and my Executor shall not be liable therefor individually.

C. I direct my Executor to pay from my estate the Federal
and state transfer taxes described in Paragraph B(1) of Article SEVENTH.

D. I direct my Executor to pay from my estate all expenses
of storing, insuring, packing, shipping and delivering my tangible personal property in accordance with
Article SECOND.
SECOND: I give, bequeath and devise all of my property, real and personal,
wherever situated, which I won at my death or of which I have the power to dispose after the payments
and distributions provided in Article FIRST, to the then acting Trustees of The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2014
Trust (the "Trust") created under that certain Trust Agreement (the "Trust Agreement") dated November
2014, as the same may be amended from time to time, to be held in accordance with the provisions
comprising the Trust Agreement at the time of my death.
THIRD: A. I appoint DARREN K. INDYKE, DAVID MITCHELL and
JAMES E. STALEY to be the Executors of this Will. If any one or more of my Executors fails to qualify
or ceases to act, I appoint LAWRENCE H. SUMMERS as successor Executor. I authorize the last acting
Executor to designate his successor as Executor.

B. If my estate must be administered in whole or in part in
any jurisdiction other than the state or territory of my domicile at the date of my death and if my
Executor is unable or unwilling to serve in such jurisdiction, then I appoint the successor Executor of my
estate designated in Paragraph A of Article THIRD provided that he is able and willing to serve in such
jurisdiction. If no Executor or successor Executor is able and willing to serve in such jurisdiction, my
Executor shall designate a successor Executor to serve in such jurisdiction. Such designation shall be
made by written instrument delivered to such successor Executor.
2657367.1
G.I_000159

C. No bond or other security shall be required of any
Executor in any jurisdiction.
D. Any Executor may resign in the manner provided for by
the governing statutes of the state or territory having jurisdiction of the administration of my estate or, in
the absence of such statutory guidance, by filing a written notice of resignation with the Court having
jurisdiction of the administration of my estate. Any Executor who resigns shall not be entitled to any
compensation hereunder for any services rendered as Executor prior to his resignation.

E. My Executor shall not be accountable or responsible to
any person interested in my estate for the manner in which my Executor in good faith exercises or
declines to exercise any discretionary authority or power of my Executor. My Executor shall not be liable
for any loss or depreciation in value occasioned by reason of any negligence, error or mistake of
judgment in entering into any transaction, in making any sale or investment, in continuing to hold any
property or by reason of any action or omission, whether by my Executor or any other fiduciary, unless
my Executor has acted in bad faith. In the absence of proof by affirmative evidence to the contrary and
affirmative evidence of my Executor acting in bad faith, each Executor shall be deemed to have acted
within the scope of my Executor's authority, to have exercised reasonable care, diligence and prudence
and to have acted impartially as to all interested persons. An Executor shall not be liable for the acts or
defaults of another Executor.
FOURTH: The following provisions shall apply to my estate and to my Executor,
except as is otherwise specifically provided in this Will:

A. My Executor has the entire care and custody of all
assets of my estate. My Executor has the power to do everything my Executor in good faith deems
advisable without necessity of any judicial authorization or approval, even though but for this power it
would not be authorized or appropriate for fiduciaries under any statutory or other rule of law. My
Executor shall exercise my Executor's best judgment and discretion for what my Executor believes to be
in the best interests of the beneficiaries hereunder. If more than two Executors are empowered to
participate in the decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Will or by law,
a majority of such Executors shall be empowered to make such decision.

B. Except as otherwise provided herein, my Executor shall
have the power:
(I) to enter upon and take possession of the assets
of my estate and collect the income and profits from such assets, and to invest and reinvest such assets
in real, personal or mixed assets (including the common trust funds of a corporate fiduciary) or in
undivided interests therein without being limited by any present or future investment laws;

(2) to retain all or any part of the assets of my
estate (without regard to the proportion that any one asset or class of assets may bear to the whole) in the
form in which such assets were received or acquired by my Executor;

(3) to sell or dispose of, exchange, transfer, invest
or loan all or any part of the assets of my estate which may, at any time, be held by my Executor for such
sums or upon such terms as to payment, security or otherwise as my Executor determines, either by
public or private transactions;
2
G.1_000160

(4) to buy and sell options, warrants, puts, calls or
other rights to purchase or sell (collectively "options") relating to any security or securities, regardless of
whether such security or securities are then held by my Executor, and whether such options are
purchased or sold on a national securities exchange, and to exercise with respect to such options all
powers which an individual owner thereof could exercise, including, without limitation, the right to allow
the same to expire;
(5) with respect to oil, natural gas, minerals, and all
other natural resources and rights to and interests therein (together with all equipment pertaining
thereto) including, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, oil and gas royalties, leases, or other
oil and gas interests of any character, whether owned in fee, as lessee, lessor, licensee, concessionaire or
otherwise, or alone or jointly with others as partner, joint tenant, or joint venture in any other
noncorporate manner, (a) to make oil, gas and mineral leases or subleases; (b) to pay delay rentals, lease
bonuses, royalties, overriding royalties, taxes, assessments, and all other charges; (c) to sell, lease,
exchange, mortgage, pledge or otherwise hypothecate any or all of such rights and interests; (d) to
surrender or abandon, with or without consideration, any or all of such rights and interests; (e) to make
farm-out, pooling, and unitization agreements; (0 to make reservations or impose conditions on the
transfer of any such rights or interests; (g) to employ the most advantageous business form in which
properly to exploit such rights and interests, whether as corporations, partnerships, limited partnerships,
mining partnerships, joint ventures, co-tenancies, or otherwise exploit any and all such rights and
interests; (h) to produce, process, sell or exchange all products recovered through the exploitation of
such rights and interests, and to enter into contracts and agreements for or in respect of the installation
or operation of absorption, reprocessing or other processing plants; (i) to carry any or all such interests
in the name or names of a nominee or nominees; (j) to delegate, to the extent permitted by law, any or
all of the powers set forth herein to the operator of such property; and (k) to employ personnel, rent
office space, buy or lease office equipment, contract and pay for geological surveys and studies, procure
appraisals, and generally to conduct and engage in any and all activities incident to the foregoing
powers, with full power to borrow and pledge in order to finance such activities; together with the
power to allocate between principal and income any net proceeds received as consideration, whether as
royalties or otherwise, for the permanent severance from lands of oil, natural gas, minerals, and all other
natural resources;

(6) to hold all or any part of the assets of my estate
in cash or in bank accounts without the necessity of investing the same;
(7)
all or any part of the assets of my estate;
to improve, repair, partition, plat or subdivide

(8) to litigate, defend, compromise, settle, abandon
or submit to arbitration on such terms and conditions as my Executor determines; to propose or accept a
compromise with respect to any claims in favor of or against my estate or the assets of my estate;

(9) to loan or borrow money in such amounts and
upon such terms and conditions as my Executor determines, assume such obligations or give such
guarantees as my Executor determines, for the purpose of the acquisition, improvement, protection,
retention or preservation of the assets of my estate, or for the welfare of the beneficiaries of my estate;

(10) to carry on for as long and in such manner as
my Executor determines any business enterprise in which 1 owned any interest at my death, either
individually, or as a partner, joint venture, stockholder or trust beneficiary; to sell such business
3
G.1_000161
enterprise as an ongoing business; to consolidate, merge, encumber, dissolve, liquidate or undertake any
other extraordinary corporate transaction relating to such business enterprise;

(11) to vote in person or by proxy any and all stock
or securities and to become a party to any voting trusts, reorganization, consolidation or other capital or
debt readjustment of any corporation, association, partnership, limited liability partnership, limited
liability company or individual with respect to stocks, securities or debts held by my estate;

(12) except as provided in paragraphs B(19) and
B(20) of this Article FOURTH, to enter into any good faith transactions with my Executor individually
or with any corporation, partnership or other entity in which my Executor has an ownership interest;

(13) to lease, mortgage, pledge, grant a security
interest in or otherwise encumber all or any part of the assets of my estate for any term of years whether
or not beyond the duration of my estate (including, without limitation, any such action for the benefit of
any of the beneficiaries of my estate);

(14) to abandon any property of my estate, real or
personal, which my Executor may deem worthless or not of sufficient value to warrant keeping or
protecting; to abstain from the payment of taxes, water rents or assessments and to forego making
repairs, maintaining or keeping up any such property; and to permit such property to be lost by tax sale or
other proceedings or to convey any such property for a nominal consideration or without consideration so
as to prevent the imposition of any liability by reason of the continued ownership thereof;

(15) to elect the mode of distribution of the proceeds
payable to my estate from any profit-sharing plan, pension plan, employee benefit plan, individual
retirement plan, insurance contract or annuity contract pursuant to the terms of such plan;

(16) to allocate, in my Executors discretion, any
adjustment to basis provided to my estate under the provisions of Federal and state law with respect to
property comprising my estate, without any obligation to make a compensatory adjustment among the
beneficiaries hereunder on account of such allocation;

(17) to conduct any audit, assessment or
investigation with respect to any asset of my estate regarding compliance with any law or regulation
having as its object protection of public health, natural resources or the environment ("Environmental
Laws"); to pay from the assets of my estate to remedy any failure to comply with any Environmental
Law (even to the exhaustion of all of the assets of my estate); and, as may be required in my Executor's
judgment by any Environmental Law, to notify any governmental authority of any past, present or future
non-compliance with any Environmental Law; and

(18) to sell to the Trustee under the Trust Agreement
any stocks, bonds, securities, real or personal property or other assets or borrow from the Trustee under
the Trust Agreement even though the same person or persons occupy the office of the Executor of my
estate and the Trustee under the Trust Agreement.

(19) No executor shall directly or indirectly buy or
sell any property for the estate from or to himself, or from or to his relative, employer, employee,
partner, or other business associate.
4
Gl_000162

(20) No executor shall lend estate funds to himself, or
to his relative, employer, employee, partner, or other business associate.

C. Except as otherwise provided herein, my Executor shall
have the power:
(I) to employ agents, attorneys-at-law, consultants,
investment advisers (to whom my Executor has discretion to delegate my Executor's investment
authority and responsibility), other executors and other fiduciaries in the administration of my Executor's
duties; to delegate to such persons, or to one or more of my Executors, the custody, control or
management of any part of my estate as my Executor determines and to pay for such services from the
assets of my estate, without obtaining judicial authorization or approval;

(2) to delegate, in whole or in part, to any person or
persons the authority and power to (a) sign checks, drafts or orders for the payment or withdrawal of
funds, securities and other assets from any bank, brokerage, custody or other account in which funds,
securities or other assets of my estate shall be deposited, (b) endorse for sale, transfer or delivery, or sell,
transfer or deliver, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any and all property, stocks, stock warrants, stock
rights, options, bonds or other securities whatsoever, (c) gain access to any safe deposit box or boxes in
which my assets or assets of my estate may be located or which may be in the name of my Executor and
remove part or all of the contents of any such safe deposit box or boxes and release and surrender the
same, and (d) take any other action that my Executor may have the power to take with respect to my
estate and the property thereof; no person or corporation acting in reliance on any such delegation shall
be charged with notice of any revocation or change of such delegation unless such person or corporation
receives actual notice thereof;

(3) to pay any property distributable to a
beneficiary under a legal disability, without liability to my Executor, by paying such property (a) to such
beneficiary, (b) for the use of such beneficiary, (c) to a legal representative of such beneficiary appointed
by a court or if none, to a relative for the use of such beneficiary, or (d) to a custodian for such
beneficiary designated by my Executor;

(4) to distribute to any of the beneficiaries of my
estate in kind or in cash, or partly in kind and partly in cash, and to allocate different kinds or
disproportionate shares of assets or undivided interests in assets among all of such beneficiaries;

(5) to have evidence of ownership of any security
maintained in the records of a Federal Reserve Bank under the Federal Reserve Book Entry System; to
deposit funds in any bank or trust company; to carry in the name of my Executor or the nominee or
nominees of my Executor and with or without designation of fiduciary capacity, or to hold in bearer
form, securities or other property requiring or permitting of registration; and to cause any securities to
be held by a depository corporation of which an Executor is a member or by an agent under a
safekeeping contract; provided, however, that the books and records of my Executor shall at all times
show that such investments are part of my estate;

(6) to renounce and disclaim, in whole or in part,
and in accordance with applicable law, any assets, interests, rights or powers (including any power of
appointment) which are payable to (or exercisable by) me or my estate, which are includible in my estate
or Gross Estate or over which I have any right, title, interest or power; and
5
GL000 1 63

(7) to make, execute and deliver any and all such
instruments in writing as shall be necessary or proper to carry out any power, right, duty or obligation of
my Executor or any disposition whatsoever of my estate or any asset of my estate and to exercise any and
all other powers incidental or necessary to carry out or to fulfill the terms, provisions and purposes of my
estate.

D. In connection with any insurance policy or annuity on
the life of an Executor which is included in my estate, such Executor shall not participate in the decision
to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power in connection with any incidents of ownership for such
policy or annuity, including, without limitation, any decision to continue, assign, terminate or convert
such policy or annuity or to name the beneficiary of such policy or annuity.

E. An Executor hereunder may by a written notice
delivered to the other Executor (or Executors) decline to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Will or by law.

F. If an Executor is not empowered (because of a conflict
of interest, declination to act or otherwise) to participate in the decision to exercise or not exercise any
fiduciary power granted by this Will or by law, then the remaining Executor or Executors shall be
empowered to make such decision. If no Executor is empowered to participate in such decision, then the
successor Executor of my estate designated in Paragraph A of Article THIRD and able and willing to act
shall be empowered to make such decision. If no Executor or successor Executor is empowered to
participate in such decision, my Executor may designate a successor Executor to serve as Executor of my
estate who shall be empowered to make such decision but shall have no other power or authority of my
Executor. Such designation shall be by written notice delivered to such successor Executor.

G. (I) Except as otherwise specifically provided
herein and except as provided in Paragraph G(2) of this Article, my Executor shall allocate receipts and
disbursements in accordance with sound trust accounting principles and shall have discretion to allocate
receipts and disbursements when the treatment is uncertain under applicable laws or generally accepted
accounting principles in the judgment of my Executor.

(2) Except as otherwise specifically provided in
this Will, my Executor shall not treat any part of the principal amount of the proceeds of sale of any asset
of my estate as income distributable to or for the benefit of any beneficiary entitled to distributions of
income; provided, however, that my Executor shall treat a portion of any proceeds of sale of any
financial instrument originally issued or acquired at a discount equal to the amount which (a) has
previously been characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes or (b) will be characterized as
ordinary income for income tax purposes in the year of such sale, as income for trust accounting
purposes.
FIFTH: Where a party to any proceeding with respect to my estate has the same
interest as a person under a disability, it shall not be necessary to serve legal process on the person under
a disability.
SIXTH: If any beneficiary under the Trust shall in any way directly or indirectly

(a) contest or object to the probate of my Will or to the validity of any disposition or provision of my
Will or of the Trust or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or indirectly instrumental in
the institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest, objection or claim for the purpose of
setting aside or invalidating my Will or the Trust or any disposition herein or therein or provision hereof
6
G.I_000164
or thereof, then I direct that (a) any and all provisions in the Trust for such beneficiary and his issue in
any degree shall be null and void and (b) my estate, whether passing under my Will or the Trust or
pursuant to the laws of intestacy, shall be disposed of as if such beneficiary and his issue in any degree
had all failed to survive me.
SEVENTH: A. As used herein:

(1) The term "Executor" of a person's estate means
all persons or entities who occupy the office of executor, administrator, personal representative, or
ancillary administrator while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more persons or
entities occupy such office at the same time or times, and includes any successor or successors to that
office. The term "Trustee" means all persons or entities who occupy the office of Trustee under the Trust
Agreement while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more persons or entities
occupy the office of Trustee at the same time or times, and includes any successor Trustee or Trustees. A
reference to a person's estate or probate estate means that person's estate which is subject to probate
administration. A reference to a person's Will means such person's Last Will and Testament and any
Codicil or Codicils thereto.

(2) The term "IRC section" means a section of the
Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, or the corresponding provision of any successor Internal
Revenue law, as in effect as of the date of my death.

(3) A reference to any tax also includes any interest
or penalties thereon. A reference to a person's "Gross Estate" means such person's gross estate as finally
determined for purposes of computing such person's federal estate tax.

(4) Whenever the singular number is used, the
same shall include the plural, and the masculine gender shall include the feminine and neuter genders.

B. (1) The Federal and state transfer taxes which my
Executor shall be obligated to pay pursuant to Paragraph C of Article FIRST shall consist of all Federal
and state estate, inheritance, succession, and similar taxes (including any Federal or state generation-
skipping transfer tax) imposed upon my probate estate or by reason of my death in respect to all assets
which pass under this Will or the Trust Agreement. Subject to Paragraph B(2) of this Article, all Federal
estate taxes with respect to assets not passing under this Will or the Trust Agreement (such assets are
referred to as the "Apportionment Assets") and any applicable state estate taxes with respect to the
Apportionment Assets shall be apportioned among all persons interested in the Apportionment Assets.
My Executor shall make reasonable efforts to collect all Federal estate taxes and state estate, inheritance,
succession and similar taxes allocable to the Apportionment Assets from the recipients of the
Apportionment Assets. Without changing the apportionment of taxes in this Paragraph B(I), my
Executor has discretion, but is not required, to pay all or part of such taxes allocable to the
Apportionment Assets. To the extent my Executor pays such taxes allocable to the Apportionment
Assets, my Executor shall seek reimbursement for such taxes from the recipients of the Apportionment
Assets. My Executor shall not be personally liable for any of such taxes if my Executor is unable, with
reasonable efforts, to collect payment (or reimbursement) from any recipient of any Apportionment
Assets for any or all of such taxes allocable to such assets.

(2) My Executor has discretion to direct the Trustee
of the Trust Agreement to pay all or any portion of the taxes which my Executor is directed or obligated
to pay pursuant to Paragraph B of Article FIRST and this Paragraph B pursuant to a written direction
delivered to the Trustee under the Trust Agreement. Any taxes which my Executor directs the Trustee
7
G1_000165
under the Trust Agreement to pay shall be allocated and paid from the trusts under the Trust Agreement
as provided under the Trust Agreement.

C. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Will, a
bequest or devise to an individual who does not survive me shall lapse notwithstanding any law to the
contrary.

D. To the extent that the distribution to the Trustee under
the Trust Agreement pursuant to Article SECOND shall not be effective, I give all the rest of my
property, real and personal, wherever situated, after the payments and distributions provided in Article
FIRST, to the person or persons named as Trustee or Trustees under the Trust Agreement, be to held in
trust under this Will in accordance with the provisions comprising the Trust Agreement at the time of my
death, which provisions are incorporated in this Will by reference.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have duly executed this Will the IQ) th day of November,
2014.
REY E. EPSTEIN
The foregoing written instrument was on the date thereof, signed, published and
declared by the Testator therein named as the Testator's Will in the presence of us and of each of us,
who, at the Testator's request, in the Testator's presence and in the presence of each other, have
subscsibed,our names as witnesses thereto.
residing at
12..A/  residing at
SA ""-Viora.,1, kit Cato/

Rt. nonlo 3, V/ OO102
We, JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN Gra sa cejcpeti  and Jizar4NiaBize4248.-1 the Testator and the
witnesses, respectively, whose names are signed to the foregoing instrument, having been sworn,
declared to the undersigned officer that the Testator, in the presence of the witnesses, signed the
instrument as his Will, that he signed, and that each of the witnesses, in the presence of the Testator and
in the presence of each other, signed the Will as a witness.
9,„, 6 ,„. l!/„GAaw
8
GJ_000166
TERRITORY OF THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS )
)ss:
DIVISION OF ST. THOMAS AND ST. JOHN )
Subscribed and sworn to before me by JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, the Testator, who is personally known to
me or who has produced  as identification, and by Cent c, rF  is—,. ..1.4 , a
witness who is personally known to me or who has produced   as identification, and
1-4MI,IrP•sia-i,g t...ipt.i Witockitra  witness who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification, on November la, 2014.
Sworn to before me this ‘8 16 day of
November, 20 I 4.
rr----------' 57 c liT Notary Public
Erika A. Kellerhals
Notary Public LNP-11-14
Commission Expires 05129118
St. Thornas1St. John, USVI
9
GL000 1 67
╔════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                       SCI JEP [epstein] Epstein company 
 Ann Rodriguez [employee] property manager at the island 
    Bebe Avdiu [lawyer] legal assistant to Darren Indyke 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01266380 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein death bequests of Jeffrey E. Epstein 2014 Trust naming Darren Indyke, David Mitchell, Jes Staley as trustees
(date: 2014-11-18)
THE JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 2014 TRUST

THIS TRUST AGREEMENT ("Agreement"), dated November 18, 2014, by and among
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, as Grantor ("Grantor"), and DARREN K. INDYKE, JAMES E.
STALEY and DAVID MITCHELL, as Trustees ("Trustees").

The Grantor hereby pays over, assigns, grants, conveys, transfers and delivers to the
Trustees the property described in Schedule A annexed hereto and made a part hereof, to be
administered and disposed of as provided in this Agreement, with any additions, changes, or
amendments to this Agreement.

This Trust shall be known as the "The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2014 Trust."

Article I During My Lifetime
The following provisions shall apply during my lifetime:

Section 1.1.-  Disbursement of Income
All of the income of the trust (the "Trust Estate") shall be paid to me, or accumulated or
paid as I may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.2.  - Disbursement  of Principal
My Trustees may distribute any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate to me as I
may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.3.  - Specific Rights Reserved to  Me

A. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to amend this
Agreement, in whole or in part, by a written instrument executed and acknowledged by me and
my Trustees.

B. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, in my sole and
unfettered discretion, to remove any Trustee by delivering to said removed Trustee and my
remaining Trustees a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

C. I reserve the right, at any time, to revoke this Trust in its entirety or any
provision hereof by delivering to my Trustees a written instrument executed and acknowledged
solely by me.

D. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to withdraw or
appoint any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate by delivering to my Trustees a written
instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.
E. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to transfer to my
Trustees, by gift, by Will or by beneficiary designation, such additional property, including life
insurance policies, as I may desire. Any such additional property shall be held on the same terms
as are then applicable to the original Trust Estate, except that it may be transferred subject to
conditions and provisions of special application to such additional property.
Article II  After My Death
The following provisions shall apply after my death:

Section 2.1.- Payment of My Debts and of Taxes and Exoenseg
My Trustee shall pay from the principal of the Trust Estate (a) my debts, funeral and
burial expenses and the administration expenses of my probate estate which are not paid by the
Executor of my probate estate, and (b) the federal and state estate, inheritance, succession,
generation skipping and similar taxes imposed by reason of my death which are the obligations
of my Trustees (including any of such taxes which the Executor of my probate estate directs my
Trustees to pay by written direction delivered to my Trustees). For purposes of this Section 2.1,
the principal of the Trust Estate shall not include (a) any assets which are not included in my
Gross Estate or (b) any assets which are not subject to, or available to creditors for the payment
of, my debts, my funeral and burial expenses or the administration expenses of my probate
estate.

Section 2.2.  -Specific Bequests or Devises Under My Will and Trust
If my probate estate is insufficient to satisfy all pecuniary bequests (or bequests payable
in cash or in kind in the discretion of the Executor of my probate estate) provided in my Will, my
Trustee shall pay such unpaid bequests from the principal of the Trust Estate. If my Will
provided for a specific bequest or devise of specified assets and such bequest or devise could not
be satisfied from my probate estate because such assets were held by my Trustee at my death, my
Trustee shall distribute such assets to satisfy such bequest or devise.
To the extent the assets of the Trust are insufficient to satisfy all bequests, I direct my
Trustees to pay all specific bequests first, and to the extent assets are insufficient to pay all of the
remaining bequests in Section 2.3.A.1 through 2.3.A.1.22 then the beneficiaries of Section
2.3.A.1 through 2.3.A.1.22 shall share in the remaining estate assets available for distribution
proportionately based upon the ratio of the amount of each general bequest listed in Section
2.3.A.1 through 2.3.A.1.22 to the total amount of all bequests in those same Sections 2.3.A.1
through 2.3.A.1.22. The determination of the Trustees as to the amounts distributable herein shall
be binding on all parties.

Section 2.3.- Bequests

A. I make the following bequests:

1. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED>, if she survives me.

2. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED>, if she survives me.
3. Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000) to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me.

4. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED>, if she survives me.
5. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED>, if she survives me.

6. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to JEAN LUC BRUNEL, if he survives me.
7. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, if he survives me.

8. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED>, if she survives me.
9. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED>, if she survives me.

10. One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) to LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF, if she survives me.
11. One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., if he survives me.

12. Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000) to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR.,
and ROSALYN V. FONTANILLA, to be shared equally if they both survive me, or all to the
survivor, if only one of them survives me.

13. Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000) to RICHARD D. KAHN, if he survives me.
14. Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000) to ANN RODRIGUEZ, if she survives me.

15. Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000) to VALDSON VIERA CONTRIN, if he survives me.
16. Three Hundred Thousand Dollars ($300,000) to <REDACTED>, if she survives me.

17. Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) to BELLA KLEIN, if she survives me.
18. Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) to DAVID ROGERS, if he survives me.

19. Sixty Six Thousand Dollars ($66,000) to STEVE CHAVEZ, if he survives me.
20. Forty Thousand Dollars ($40,000) to if she survives survives me.

21. Thirty Five Thousand Dollars ($35,000) to CYNTHIA CANO, if she survives me.
22. Forty Two Thousand Dollars ($42,000) to CARLOS DELGADO, if he survives me.

23. I forgive any loans which I made to the following individuals:
a) JEAN LUC BRUNEL
b) GADDO CARDINI
c) MARK EPSTEIN

d) LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR.
e) ROSALYN V. FONTANILLA
f) ROBERT GOLD
g) ROBERT GOODMAN
h) EMAD HANNA
i) DARREN KEITH INDYKE

j) DAVID LAMPERT
k) <REDACTED>
l) <REDACTED>
m) <REDACTED>
n) ALBERTO PINTO
o) STEVEN VICTOR
p) <REDACTED>

q) LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR.
r) <REDACTED>
s) KARINA SHULIAK
t) <REDACTED>
u) <REDACTED>
v) <REDACTED>

w) <REDACTED>
x) <REDACTED>
y) SLK DESIGNS, LLC
z) ADAM BLY

24. I give to <REDACTED> if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in all
apartments, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the premises
located in the building known and referred to as , The
interest consists of units 47 with mezzanine, 48 and 81 on the 2nd floor, units 63 and 74 on
the 5th floor and units 5 and 22 (cellars) in the basement. The units are currently all owned by
SCI JEP, a French company of which I ow o 999 of the 1 000 outstanding shares. In addition, I
give to this separate trust for the benefit ofl lif she survives me, the
sum of One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the apartments.
Operating expenses shall include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes,
utilities, general maintenance and repairs and common charges.

25. I give to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in
the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the real
ro located at, and known and referred to as
My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Maple, Inc., a United
States Virgin Islands corporation, which holds legal title to the same. In addition, I give to this
separate trust for the benefit of if she survives me, the sum of Four
Million Dollars ($4,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the property. Operating
expenses shall include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and
general maintenance and repairs.

26. I give to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in
the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to that certain
cay in the United States Virgin Islands known and referred to as Little St. James Island. My
interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Nautilus, Inc., a United States Virgin
Islands corporation, which holds legal title to said cay, the improvements, and fixtures
thereon, and certain permits and rights with respect thereto and which also owns 100% of the
interest of L.S.J., LLC, a Delaware limited liability company that holds certain permits and
rights pertaining to the improvements on said cay. In addition, I give to this separate trust for
the benefit of  if she survives me, the sum of Ten Million Dollars
($10,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the cay. Operating expenses shall include,
but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general maintenance
and repairs.

27. I give to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in
the property, leases, rights, permits, improvements and fixtures comprising and pertaining to
Zorro Ranch, located at 49 Zorro Ranch Road, Stanley, New Mexico 87056. My interest
consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Cypress, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands
corporation, which holds legal title to the same. In addition, I give to this separate trust for the
benefit of  if she survives me, the sum of Five Million Dollars
($5,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the property. Operating expenses shall
include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general
maintenance and repairs.

28. I give to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in
the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the real
property located at, and known and referred to as, 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida.
My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Laurel, Inc., a United States Virgin
Islands corporation,  which holds legal title to the same. In addition, I give to this separate trust
for the benefit of  if she survives me, the sum of One Million
Dollars ($1,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the property. Operating expenses
shall include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general
maintenance and repairs.

Section 2.4.-  Balance  of Trust Estate
The balance of the Trust Estate, after the distributions provided in Sections 2.1, 2.2 and
2.3 of this Article II, shall be distributed as follows:

A. One Hundred percent (100%) thereof to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in separate trust, the provisions of which are 
set forth in Section 3.2 of Article III
below.

B. If <REDACTED><REDACTED> does not survive me, one hundred percent thereof to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she survives me.

C. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN does not survive me, I give a percentage
of the balance of the Trust Estate to each of those persons who survive me named in Sections
2.3.A.1 through and including 2.3.A.22 of this Article II, which percentage shall be determined
for each such person by dividing the amount of the bequest made to such person pursuant to

Section 2.3.A of this Article II by the total amount of all bequests made pursuant to Sections
2.3.A.1 though and including 2.3A. 22 of this Article II to all persons who survive me.
Article III  Trust Provisions

Section 3.1.- Residence Trusts
Any property directed to be held in trust for a Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions of
this Section 3.1 of Article III shall be administered as follows:

A. The Beneficiary shall have the right to occupy the residence or residences
held by the trust and to use the tangible personal property located in the residence for her
lifetime.

B. My Trustees, in my Trustees' sole discretion, may pay any part or all of
the income, and if income is insufficient, the principal of the trust (1) to pay the operating
expenses of the property held by the trust and (2) for any other purpose my Trustees consider
advisable. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal of the trust.

C. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall use my Trustees'
best efforts to sell the trust property and the tangible personal property within two (2) years of
the Beneficiary's death and only in extraordinary circumstances should the property not be sold
within two (2) years of the Beneficiary's death.

D. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall distribute the
remaining principal of the trust (i.e., the proceeds from the sale of the trust assets) to EVA
ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she then survives the Beneficiary. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN
does not survive the Beneficiary, then my Trustees shall distribute the remaining principal to any
one or more persons selected by my Trustees, in my Trustees' discretion, other than my Trustees,
members of the respective families of my Trustees, the respective estates of my Trustees, the
respective creditors of my Trustees or the creditors of the respective estates my Trustees.

Section 3.2.-  Residuary Trusts
Any property directed to be held in trust for a Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions of
this Section 3.2 of Article III shall be distributed as follows:

A. My Trustees may pay any part or all of the income and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of the trust as my Trustees, in my Trustees' discretion, from time
to time and at any time, shall determine for any reason whatsoever to, for the benefit of, or on
behalf of the Beneficiary. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal of the
trust.

B. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall distribute the
remaining principal of the trust to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she then survives the
Beneficiary. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN does not survive the Beneficiary, then my Trustees
shall distribute the remaining principal of the trust to any one or more persons selected by my
Trustees, in my Trustees' discretion, other than my Trustees, members of the respective families
of my Trustees, the respective estates of my Trustees, the respective creditors of my Trustees or
the creditors of the respective estates my Trustees.
7
Article IV Trust Termination
If at any time my Trustees determines that it is uneconomic to continue any trust with
respect to which my Trustees are acting hereunder, my Trustees may terminate such trust and
distribute the trust assets, in such amounts and proportions as my Trustees may determine, to the
person or persons to whom income may be distributed, other than my Trustees, members of the
respective families of my Trustees, the respective estates of my Trustees, the respective creditors
of my Trustees or the creditors of the respective estates of my Trustees.
Article V Trust Administration

Section 5.1. - Exercise of Discretionary Powers
Except as hereinbefore specifically provided, in connection with the exercise of a
discretionary power to distribute income or principal to any person, there shall be no requirement
to take into account such person's other income or capital resources, the interest of such person in
any other fund or the duty of anyone to support such person, although these factors may be taken
into account.

Section 5.2.- Discretionary Distributions
Any discretionary payment from any trust hereunder shall be charged against such trust
as a whole, and shall not be charged against the individual share of any person at any time.

Section 5.3.- Allocation of Assets

A. For each distribution, partial distribution, allocation, or division of assets
into shares or trusts involving a fraction, my Trustees shall apply such fraction to the fair market
value of the relevant assets on the date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever
first occurs. My Trustees shall appropriately adjust such fractions to reflect the effect of any
partial distributions, allocations, or divisions, taking into account the fair market value as of the
date of distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurred, of the assets so distributed,
allocated, or divided.

B. My Trustees shall value any assets distributed, allocated, or divided to
satisfy (in whole or in part) a pecuniary distribution at the fair market value of such assets on the
date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurs.

Section 5.4.- Accounting Allocations

A. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement and except as
provided in Paragraph B of this Section 5.4, my Trustees shall allocate receipts and
disbursements in accordance with sound trust accounting principles and have discretion to
allocate receipts and disbursements when, in the judgment of my Trustees, the treatment is
uncertain under applicable laws or generally accepted accounting principles.
B. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, my Trustees
shall not treat any part of the principal amount of the proceeds of sale of any asset of any trust as
8
income distributable to or for the benefit of any beneficiary entitled to distributions of income;
provided, however, that my Trustees shall treat a portion of any proceeds of sale of any financial
instrument originally issued or acquired at a discount equal to the amount which (I) has
previously been characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes or (2) will be
characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes in the year of such sale, as income for
trust accounting purposes.
Section S.S.  =apendthrift Provision
During the term of any trust hereunder, no money or other assets (either principal or
income) payable or distributable under the provisions of this Agreement shall be pledged,
assigned, transferred, given, conveyed, hypothecated, sold, anticipated, charged, or encumbered
by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder, nor shall the income and principal of any trust, while in
the possession of my Trustees, be liable for any debts, contracts, obligations, or undertakings of
such Beneficiaries, voluntary or involuntary, or for any claims or judgments against any
Beneficiary, including claims for alimony or for the support of any Beneficiary's spouse or
children, or for reimbursement of a federal, state or local government, or any agency of any
federal, state, or local government, for the support of any Beneficiary hereunder, prior to the time
such money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary. Any attempted pledge,
assignment, transfer, gift, conveyance, hypothecation, anticipation, charge, or encumbrance of
any money or assets (either income or principal) payable or distributable under the provisions of
this Agreement by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder prior to the time such money or assets are
actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary shall be null and void and shall not be recognized
by my Trustees. This Section 5.5 of Article V shall not apply to me.

Section 5.6.- Limitation on Distributions
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, no discretionary distribution of
income or principal of any trust hereunder shall be applied to pay for medical care, residential
facilities, or any other care or service that would otherwise be provided for any Beneficiary
hereunder by any federal, state, or other governmental agency; and no such discretionary
distribution of income or principal shall be made for reimbursement for any such care, facilities
or services previously provided. Before making any discretionary payment to or for the benefit
of any such Beneficiary hereunder, my Trustees shall consider the amounts such Beneficiary is
or may be entitled to receive from any governmental agency for such care, facilities, or services.
If such amounts are available, discretionary distributions of income and principal from any trust
hereunder shall be made only to supplement such amounts, and to provide liberally for needs and
comforts over and above the basic maintenance, support, and medical care that may be paid for
by any such agency.

Section 5.7.- Division and Combination of Trusts

A. For any administrative, tax or other purpose determined by my Trustees to
be in the best interests of any Beneficiary (including any remainderman) hereunder, my Trustees
may at any time and from time to time (whether before or after funding), without approval of any
court, divide any trust under this Agreement into two or more separate trusts or combine two or
more trusts with substantially identical terms (whether or not such trusts resulted from division
of a prior trust).

B. If property is directed to be added to any trust hereunder (the "Original
Trust"), whether by the terms of this Agreement any other agreement, or the Will of any person,
my Trustees may hold such property as one or more separate trusts on terms identical to the
terms of the Original Trust. My Trustees may allocate such property among the separate trusts (if
any) into which the Original Trust was divided, whether or not pro-rata, using specific assets or
undivided interests therein (including allocation of all such property to one of such separate
trusts).
C. Any time during the existence of separate trusts created by division of a
trust hereunder, my Trustees may exercise all discretionary powers differently with respect to the
separate trusts and take all other actions consistent with such trusts being separate entities.
Furthermore, the holder of any power of appointment with respect to such separate trusts may
exercise such power differently with respect to each such trust.

Section 5.8.  - Consolidation of Trusts
If at any time after my death there is in existence a trust under my Will or any trust
agreement created by me having identical beneficiaries and substantially the same terms as any
trust under this Agreement, my Trustees may terminate the trust hereunder and transfer the assets
thereof to the Trustees of such other trust, to be administered by the Trustees thereof. Different
termination dates under the applicable Rule Against Perpetuities shall not be deemed a difference
in the terms of such trusts, but the portion of the trust representing the transferred assets shall
retain the same termination date as the original trust.

Section 5.9.  - Termination of Trusts
Notwithstanding anything herein, any trust created hereunder for any person shall (unless
terminated earlier) terminate upon the day preceding the expiration of the maximum period
permitted under the United States Virgin Islands Rule Against Perpetuities, for the vesting of an
interest in a trust and upon such date the assets of such trust shall be distributed to such person.

Section 5.10.  - Equitable Adjustment
If any of my Trustees decides to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by
this Agreement or by law (including, without limitation, any election available to my Trustee)
and the exercise or nonexercise of such power confers a benefit on one Beneficiary or class of
Beneficiaries hereunder and imposes a detriment upon another Beneficiary or class of
Beneficiaries hereunder, my Trustees shall not attempt to restore the interests of the Beneficiaries
or classes of Beneficiaries to the position otherwise contemplated by this Agreement through
adjustment between income and principal or otherwise.

Section 5.11. - Lapsed Distribution
I0
Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, a provision for distribution
to an individual who is not surviving at the date such individual otherwise becomes eligible for
such distribution shall lapse notwithstanding any law to the contrary.

Section 5.12.  - Notice
Any notice required hereunder shall be delivered personally or sent by first class or
certified mail addressed to the last known address of the intended recipient.

Section 5.13.  -Termination of Trust
An instrument in writing completely revoking this Agreement shall, without more, upon
delivery to any of my Trustees, completely terminate all of my Trustees' right, title, and interest
to any life insurance proceeds, death benefits, pension, profit sharing, or other retirement benefits
or any other assets otherwise payable to my Trustees.
Article VI  Powers of Trustees

Section 6.1.- Exercise of Judgment and Powers
The Trustee of a trust hereunder has the entire care and custody of all assets of such trust.
My Trustees have the power to do everything my Trustees in good faith deem advisable without
necessity of any judicial authorization or approval, even though but for this power it would not
be authorized or appropriate for fiduciaries under any statutory or other rule of law. My Trustees
shall exercise my Trustees' best judgment and discretion for what my Trustees believe to be in
the best interests of such trust and the Beneficiaries of such trust. If more than two Trustees are
empowered as my Trustee to participate in the decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power granted by this Agreement or by law, a majority of such Trustees shall be empowered to
make such decision.

Section 6.2.- Compensation of My Trustee
Each Trustee acting hereunder shall be entitled to annual compensation for services
performed hereunder in the amount of Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) per
year, in addition to any bequest to which they may be entitled under this terms of this Trust. No
other compensation shall be payable to my Trustees hereunder; provided, however, that my
Trustees shall be reimbursed for all reasonable costs, expenses, charges, and liabilities incurred
or paid in connection with acting as Trustee or performing services hereunder, including, but not
limited to, fees and expenses of counsel or any other agents hired by my Trustees, and my
Trustees shall not be liable therefor individually. My Trustees have discretion to pay such
compensation and such reimbursements from trust assets, without obtaining judicial
authorization or approval.
II

Section 6.3.- General Investment Powers

A. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, my Trustees have the
power with respect to such trust:

1. To enter upon and take possession of the assets of such trust and collect
the income and profits from such assets, and to invest and reinvest such assets in real,
personal, or mixed assets (including the common trust funds of a corporate fiduciary) or in
undivided interests therein without being limited by any present or future investment laws;

2. To retain all or any part of the assets of such trust (without regard to the
proportion that any one asset or class of assets may bear to the whole) in the form in which
such assets were received or acquired by my Trustees;

3. To sell or dispose of, exchange, transfer, invest, or loan all or any part of
the assets of such trust which my Trustees hold, at any time, for such sums or upon such terms
as to payment, security, or otherwise as my Trustees determine, either by public or private
transactions;

4. To buy and sell options, warrants, puts, calls or other rights to purchase or
sell (collectively called "options") relating to any security or securities, regardless of whether
such security or securities are then held by my Trustees, and whether such options are
purchased or sold on a national securities exchange, and to exercise with respect to such
options all powers which an individual owner thereof could exercise, including, without
limitation, the right to allow the same to expire;
5. With respect to oil, natural gas, minerals, and all other natural resources
and rights to and interests therein (together with all equipment pertaining thereto) including,
without limiting the generality of the foregoing, oil and gas royalties, leases, or other oil and
gas interests of any character, whether owned in fee, as lessee, lessor, licensee, concessionaire
or otherwise, or alone or jointly with others as partner, joint tenant, or joint venturer in any
other noncorporate manner, (a) to make oil, gas and mineral leases or subleases; (b) to pay
delay rentals, lease bonuses, royalties, overriding royalties, taxes, assessments, and all other
charges; (c) to sell, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge or otherwise hypothecate any or all of
such rights and interests; (d) to surrender or abandon, with or without consideration, any or all
of such rights and interests; (e) to make farm-out, pooling, and unitization agreements; (f) to
make reservations or impose conditions on the transfer of any such rights or interests; (g) to
employ the most advantageous business form in which properly to exploit such rights and
interests, whether as corporations, partnerships, limited partnerships, mining partnerships,
joint ventures, co- tenancies, or otherwise exploit any and all such rights and interests; (h) to
produce, process, sell or exchange all products recovered through the exploitation of such
rights and interests, and to enter into contracts and agreements for or in respect of the
installation or operation of absorption, reprocessing or other processing plants; (i) to carry any
or all such interests in the name or names of a nominee or nominees; (j) to delegate, to the
extent permitted by law, any or all of the powers set forth herein to the operator of such
property; and (k) to employ personnel, rent office space, buy or lease office equipment,
contract and pay for geological surveys and studies, procure appraisals, and generally to
12
conduct and engage in any and all activities incident to the foregoing powers, with full power
to borrow and pledge in order to finance such activities; together with the power to allocate
between principal and income any net proceeds received as consideration, whether as royalties
or otherwise, for the permanent severance from lands of oil, natural gas, minerals, and all
other natural resources;

6. To hold all or any part of the assets of such trust in cash or in bank
accounts without the necessity of investing the same; of such trust;

7. To improve, repair, partition, plat, or subdivide all or any part of the assets
of such trust;
8. To litigate, defend, compromise, settle, abandon, or submit to mediation
or arbitration on such terms and conditions as my Trustees determine any claims in favor of or
against such trust or the assets of such trust;

9. To loan or borrow money in such amounts and upon such terms and
conditions as my Trustees determine, assume such obligations or give such guarantees as my
Trustees determine, for the purpose of the acquisition, improvement, protection, retention, or
preservation of the assets of such trust, or for the benefit of any of the Beneficiaries who are
entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust;

10. To create or invest in any entity with all or part of the assets of such trust
and to carry on for as long and in such manner as my Trustees determine any business
enterprise held or created by my Trustees or in which I owned any interest at my death, either
individually or as a partner, joint venturer, stockholder, trust beneficiary, or member; to sell
such business enterprise as an ongoing business; to consolidate, merge, encumber, dissolve,
liquidate or undertake any other extraordinary corporate transaction relating to such business
enterprise;

11. To vote in person or by proxy any and all stock or securities and to
become a party to any voting trusts, reorganization, consolidation, or other capital or debt
readjustment of any corporation, association, partnership, limited liability partnership, limited
liability company, or individual with respect to stocks, securities, or debts held by such trust;

12. Except as provided in Sections 6.3B, C, and D of this Article VI, to enter
into any good faith transactions with my Trustees individually or with any corporation,
partnership, limited liability partnership, limited liability company, or other entity in which
any of my Trustees has an ownership interest;

13. To purchase from my estate any stocks, bonds, securities, real or personal
property, or other assets, or make loans to my estate even though the same person or persons
occupy the office of my Trustees and the office of the Executor of my estate;

14. To lease, mortgage, pledge, grant a security interest in, or otherwise
encumber all or any part of the assets of such trust for any term of years whether or not
beyond the term of such trust (including, without limitation, any such action for the benefit of
any of the beneficiaries of such trust);
13

15. To abandon any property of such trust, real or personal, which my
Trustees may deem worthless or not of sufficient value to warrant keeping or protecting; to
abstain from the payment of taxes, water rents or assessments and to forego making repairs,
maintaining or keeping up any such property; and to permit such property to be lost by tax
sale or other proceedings or to convey any such property for a nominal consideration or
without consideration so as to prevent the imposition of any liability by reason of the
continued ownership thereof;

16. To elect the mode of distribution of the proceeds from any profit-sharing
plan, pension plan, employee benefit plan, individual retirement plan, insurance contract, or
annuity contract pursuant to the terms of such plan or to change to another custodian of such
plan;

17. To conduct any audit, assessment, or investigation with respect to any
asset of such trust regarding compliance with any law or regulation having as its object
protection of public health, natural resources, or the environment (referred to as
"Environmental Laws"); to pay from the assets of such trust to remedy any failure to comply
with any Environmental Law (even to the exhaustion of all of the assets of such trust); and, as
may be required in my Trustee's judgment by any Environmental Law, to notify any
governmental authority of any past, present, or future non-compliance with any
Environmental Law; and

18. To refuse to accept any asset distributable to such trust.
B. No Trustee shall directly or indirectly buy or sell any property for the trust
from or to himself, or from or to his relative, employer, employee, partner or other business
associate.

C. No Trustee shall as trustee of one trust sell property to himself as trustee
of another trust.
D. No Trustee shall lend trust funds to himself, or to his relative, employer,
employee, partner, or other business associate.

Section 6.4. -Administrative Powers
Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, my Trustees have the power with
respect to each trust:

A. To employ agents, attorneys-at-law, consultants, investment advisers (to
whom my Trustees have discretion to delegate my Trustees' investment authority and
responsibility), other trustees and other fiduciaries in the administration of my Trustees' duties, to
delegate to such persons, or to one or more of my Trustees, the custody, control, or management
of any part of the assets of such trust as my Trustees determine and to pay for such services from
the assets of such trust, without obtaining judicial authorization or approval;
14

B. To delegate, in whole or in part, to any person or persons the authority and
power to (1) sign checks, drafts or orders for the payment or withdrawal of funds, securities and
other assets from any bank, brokerage, custody or other account in which funds, securities or
other assets of such trust shall be deposited, (2) endorse for sale, transfer or delivery, or sell,
transfer or deliver, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any and all property, stocks, stock warrants,
stock rights, options, bonds or other securities whatsoever, (3) gain access to any safe deposit
box or boxes in which assets of such trust may be located or which may be in the name of any of
my Trustees and remove part or all of the contents of any such safe deposit box or boxes and
release and surrender the same, and (4) take any other action that my Trustee may have the
power to take with respect to such trust and the property thereof; no person or corporation acting
in reliance on any such delegation shall be charged with notice of any revocation or change of
such delegation unless such person or corporation receives actual notice thereof;

C. To pay any property distributable to a Beneficiary under a legal disability
or who has not attained the age of 21, without liability to my Trustees, by paying such property

(1) to such Beneficiary, (2) for the use of such Beneficiary, (3) to a legal representative of such
Beneficiary appointed by a court or if none, to a relative for the use of such Beneficiary, or (4) to
a custodian for such Beneficiary designated by my Trustees, to hold until age 21 or such earlier
age as shall be the maximum permitted under applicable law;

D. To divide such trust into subsidiary accounts if my Trustees determine that
such division is necessary to maintain fair and accurate records;

E. To permit the Beneficiary of such trust to use, possess, and enjoy real
property, tangible personal property, or club memberships held by such trust;

F. To distribute to such trust or any of the Beneficiaries of such trust in kind
or in cash, or partly in kind and partly in cash, and to allocate different kinds or disproportionate
shares of assets or undivided interests in assets among all of such trusts or all of such
Beneficiaries;

G. In making the division into one or more trusts hereunder (if such trusts
have the same Trustees), to keep the assets of such trusts invested and handled as a single fund
without actual division and to designate such trusts on my Trustees' books as owning a
designated undivided interest in such fund;

H. To have evidence of ownership of any security maintained in the records
of a Federal Reserve Bank under the Federal Reserve Book Entry System; to deposit funds in
any bank or trust company; to carry in the name of any of my Trustees or the nominee or
nominees of the Trustees and with or without designation of fiduciary capacity, or to hold in
bearer form, securities or other property requiring or permitting of registration; and to cause any
securities to be held by a depository corporation of which a Trustee is a member or by an agent
under a safekeeping contract; provided, however, that the books and records of my Trustees shall
at all times show that such investments are part of such trust;
15

I. To register or not register such trust with the probate division of the
Superior Court of the United States Virgin Islands or otherwise and to make all decisions which
relate thereto;

J. To give any Beneficiary of any trust hereunder a general power of
appointment exercisable in such Beneficiary's Will over all or part of such trust, subject to any
terms and conditions as my Trustees determine, by written notice to such Beneficiary; to
eliminate any such power of appointment by written notice to the Beneficiary; and to irrevocably
release the power under this paragraph to give a power of appointment or to eliminate a power of
appointment;

K. To renounce and disclaim, in whole or in part, and in accordance with
applicable law, any assets, interests, rights, or powers (including any power of appointment)
which are payable to (or exercisable by) such trust or over which my Trustees have any right,
title, interest, or power; and

L. To make, execute, and deliver any and all such instruments in writing as
shall be necessary or proper to carry out any power, right, duty, or obligation of my Trustees or
any disposition whatsoever of such trust or any asset of such trust and to exercise any and all
other powers incidental or necessary to carry out or to fulfill the terms, provisions and purposes
of such trust.

Section 6.5.  - Restrictions on Exercise of My Trustee's Powers

A. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, a
Trustee shall not participate in a discretionary decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power to (1) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder to himself or herself; or

(2) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder for the health, support,
maintenance or education of a Beneficiary if such Trustee has a legal obligation to provide for
the health, support, maintenance or education of such Beneficiary from such Trustee's personal
assets. For purposes of this paragraph, a person whose interest in a trust hereunder is limited to a
remote contingent interest (for example, a contingent remainderman whose interest depends
upon another person failing to survive to a specified age or a person designated to receive assets
only in the event a power of appointment is not exercised) shall not be treated as a person who is
or may be a Beneficiary of such trust.

B. A Trustee of any trust hereunder may by a written notice delivered to the
other Trustee (or Trustees) of such trust decline to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law.
C. If a Trustee of any trust hereunder is not empowered (because of a conflict
of interest, declination to act or otherwise) to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, then the remaining Trustee or
Trustees of such trust shall be empowered to make such decision. If no Trustee or successor
Trustee is empowered to participate in such decision, my Trustees may designate a substitute
Trustee to serve as Trustee of such trust who shall be empowered to make such decision but has
16
CONFIDENTIAL al 000367
SONY_GM_00008044
no other power or authority of the Trustees. Such designation shall be by written notice delivered
to such substitute Trustee.
Article VII  Provisions Concerning Trustees

Section 7.1. - Successor Trustees
In the event a Trustee resigns, is removed, becomes incapacitated or is unwilling or is
unable to serve, EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN shall be appointed the successor trustee. In the
event that any additional Trustees are removed, become incapacitated, or are unwilling or unable
to serve, STEVEN HANSON shall first be appointed to fill any vacancy, followed by JOSEPH
PAGANO, such that the total number of Trustees acting on behalf of the Trust at all times shall
be three.

Section 7.2.- Appointment Of Trustee
The appointment of a successor Trustee hereunder shall become effective when such
successor Trustee signs an acceptance of the trust.

Section 7.3.— Resignation of Trustees
Any Trustee may resign at any time, without the approval of any court, by an instrument
in writing filed with the trust records. In addition, if there is filed with the trust records a written
certification from any attending physician of any individual Trustee of a trust that he or she is no
longer able to make decisions with respect to such trust, then from the date of filing of such
certification, such individual Trustee shall be deemed to have resigned for all purposes of this
Agreement.

Section 7.4.- Vacancy in Office
If there is a vacancy in the Trustees and no successor Trustee is designated pursuant to

Section 7.1 who is willing to act, the legally competent adult Beneficiary (or a majority in
beneficial interest of the legally competent adult Beneficiaries if there are multiple Beneficiaries)
then entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust shall designate a successor Trustee
by an instrument in writing delivered to the designated Trustee. If the legally competent adult
Beneficiaries do not designate a successor Trustee within sixty days after receipt of notice of
such vacancy or if there is no legally competent adult Beneficiary of such trust, my Trustees
shall designate a successor Trustee by written notice delivered to the designated Trustee and each
adult beneficiary then entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust. If no successor
Trustee is designated pursuant to this Section 7.4, then a successor Trustee shall be named by
order of a court of competent jurisdiction. All of the fees and expenses of my Trustees (including
attorneys' fees) attributable to the appointment of a successor Trustee of a trust shall be paid
from the assets of such trust.

Section 7.5.- Elimination of Bond
No bond or other security shall be required of any Trustee hereunder in any jurisdiction.
17

Section 7.6.- Exculpation and Indemnification of My Trustee
No one serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be accountable or
responsible to any person interested in any trust hereunder for the manner in which my Trustees
shall in good faith exercise any discretionary authority or any power of my Trustees. No one
serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be liable for any loss or
depreciation in value occasioned by reason of any negligence, error or mistake of judgment in
entering into any transaction, in making any sale or investment, in continuing to hold any
property, or by reason of any action or omission, whether by my Trustees or any other fiduciary,
unless such Trustee has acted in bad faith. In the absence of proof by affirmative evidence to the
contrary, each Trustee shall be deemed to have acted within the scope of my Trustees' authority,
to have exercised reasonable care, diligence, and prudence and to have acted impartially as to all
interested persons. A Trustee shall not be liable for the acts or defaults of another Trustee.
In the event a legal action is brought against any individual serving as the Trustee of any
trust under this Agreement, all legal fees and related expenses incurred in connection with the
defense of such legal action shall be paid by such trust without court authorization; provided,
however, that (a) no such payment shall (or shall continue to) be made if a court enters an order
prohibiting such payment, and (b) such Trustee shall refund to the trust any such payments that
previously had been made if a court enters an order directing that such payments be refunded, or
if a court concludes that such Trustee acted in bad faith.

Section 7.7.- Relief from Virgin Islands Statutory Provisions
Pursuant to Section 1212, Title 15, of the Virgin Islands Code, I hereby relieve my
Trustees and any Successor Trustees of the requirements imposed by Chapter 59, Title 15 of the
Virgin Islands Code, or any similar successor law respecting public filings of inventories and
accountings by Trustees. Furthermore, pursuant to Section 1107, Title 15, of the Virgin Islands
Code, I hereby relieve the my Trustees and any Successor Trustees, to the extent allowable, from
any all duties, restrictions, and liabilities which would otherwise be imposed upon my Trustees
by Chapter 57, Title 15, Virgin Islands Code. This Section 8.7 shall not be deemed a waiver of
any and all other rights, powers, or restrictions otherwise granted to my Trustees in this
Agreement.
Article VIII  Miscellaneous Provisions

Section 8.1.- Representation of Person Under a Disability
To the extent allowed by law, where a party to any proceeding with respect to any trust
hereunder has the same interest as a person under a disability, legal process shall not be required
on the person under a disability.

Section 8.2.  -Simultaneous Deaths
If a Beneficiary under this Agreement and I die simultaneously or under such
circumstances that it is difficult to determine who died first, then for all purposes of this
Agreement such Beneficiary shall be deemed to have predeceased me.
I8

Section 8.3.  - Law Governing
This Agreement and each trust created by it shall in all respects and for all purposes be
governed and regulated by the laws of the Territory of the United States Virgin Islands, as they
now exist and may from time to time be enacted, amended, or repealed. All questions regarding
the validity, construction and administration of this Agreement, or any of its provisions, and of
any trust created by it shall be determined solely by the laws of that Territory. The courts of the
State of Delaware and the U.S. Virgin Islands shall have primary supervision over the
administration of each trust created by this Agreement. It is intended that each such trust shall be
a U.S. domestic trust as defined in Title 26 section 7701(aX30) of the Code by virtue of meeting
the court and control test. As provided in Treas. Reg. section 301.7701-7(cX4XD), if both a
United States court and a foreign court are able to exercise primary supervision over the
administration of the trust, the trust meets the court test.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, my Trustees of each trust
created under this Agreement have discretion at any time or times following my death to transfer
the situs of such trust to such other country, or such other jurisdiction as my Trustees determine,
without obtaining judicial authorization or approval (unless such judicial authorization or
approval is required by applicable law) and without the filing of any bond. My Trustees'
determination to transfer the situs of any trust under this Agreement shall be evidenced by an
instrument in writing signed, witnessed and acknowledged by my Trustees in the same manner
as would be required for a deed. My Trustees are authorized to take whatever actions are
necessary to effect such a transfer of situs. If judicial authorization or approval is required to
effect such a transfer of situs, I intend and desire that the appropriate court accept the
determination of my Trustees concerning the transfer of the situs of such trust even if one or
more Beneficiaries disagree with such determination. From and after my Trustees' transfer of the
situs of a trust pursuant to this Section 8.3 of Article VIII, the administration of such trust shall
be governed by the law of the new situs of such trust.

Section 8.4.  A:lelinition of Terms
Except as otherwise specifically provided herein, as used in this Agreement,

A. The term "Trustee" means all persons or entities who occupy the office of
Trustee of any trust hereunder while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or
more persons or entities occupy the office of Trustee at the same time or times, and includes any
successor Trustee or Trustees. The term "Executor" of a person's estate means all persons or
entities who occupy the office of personal representative, administrator, executor, or ancillary
administrator while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more persons or
entities occupy such office at the same time or times, and includes any successor or successors to
that office. A reference to a person's Will means such person's Last Will and Testament and any
Codicil or Codicils thereto.
19

B. A reference to any tax also includes any interest or penalties thereon. The
term "my Gross Estate" means my gross estate as finally determined for purposes of computing
my federal estate tax.
C. Whenever the singular number is used, the same shall include the plural,
and the masculine gender shall include the feminine and neuter genders.

Section 8.5.- No Contest
If any Beneficiary under this Agreement shall in any way directly or indirectly (a) contest
or object to the probate of my Will or to the validity of any disposition or provision of my Will
or of this Agreement or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or indirectly
instrumental in the institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest, objection or
claim for the purpose of setting aside or invalidating my Will or this Agreement or any
disposition therein or herein or provision thereof or hereof, then I direct that (aa) any and all
provisions in this Agreement for such Beneficiary and his issue in any degree shall be null and
void and (bb) my estate, whether passing under my Will or this Agreement or pursuant to the
laws of intestacy, shall be disposed of as if such Beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all
failed to survive me.

Section 8.6.  - Trustee Notice
My Trustees may have duties and responsibilities in addition to those described in this
Agreement. If my Trustees have questions, my Trustees should obtain legal advice.
CONCLUSION
I have duly executed this Agreement on the date set o y si nature
Date signed:
Date signed:  ►t ato —
Date signed:  ii — t6 -/Y
Date signed:  i 2 3 -
20
CHELL, as a Trustee,
On this IS day of November, 2014, the foregoing instrument was signed, published and
declared to be the Trust Agreement of The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2014 Trust by JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, as Grantor, and was signed and accepted in our presence; and we, at the Grantor's
request, in the Grantor's presence and in the presence of each other, did, on said day, sign our
names nesses thereto.
residing at
id„,„ di/  residing at
TERRITORY OF THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
) ss:
DISTRICT OF ST. THOMAS & ST. JOHN
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and swom to before me this Ieday of
November, 2014 by JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, the Grantor, who is personally known to me or who
has produced as identification.
Sworn to before me this
day of November, 2014.
Erika A. Kellerhals
Notary Public LNP-11-14
Commission Expires 05/29/18 St. Thomas/St. John, USVI
21
STATE OF NEW YORK )
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
t,,The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me thisr4: day of
1‘.1ertr\ne 1".  2014, by DARREN K. 1NDYKE, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has
produced as identification.
Sworn to before me this
AD day of  1\110.46'\'\‘')e`(
2014.
cAlabthe acr6(-o Notary Public
STATE OF gi&13\10((._ )
, )ss:
COUNTY OF wi oto
HABIBE AVDIU
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK

No. 01AV6313116
Qualified in Richmond County
My Commission Expires 0010b01 14, 2071
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me thisAslay of  NiA2m1/2er , 2014,
by !AMES E. STALEY, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this
day of NSNQT00€1(, 2014.
2ACILtaulLa___ Notary Public
HABIBE AVOW
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK

No. 01AV6313116
Qualified In Richmond County
My Commission Expires October 14. 2018
22
SONY_GM_00008050
STATE OF TOY
)ss: COUNTY OF 01
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me thisIty of  kamber2014, by DAVID MJTCHELL, a Trustee, who
is personally known to me or who has
produced
CiA1)44 ktense  as identification.
Swipm to before me this
3Ifi-day of  teartanr- , 2014.
Notary Public
DOUGLAS BENTON ARNAUDIN
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK
No. 0IAR6256222
Qualified In New York County
My Commission }minis February 21, 2010
23
EFTA01089500 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Crypto Currency Partners II investor report
(date: 2015-01-01)
Crypto Currency
Partners
- INVESTOR UPDATE -
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS II,
FEBRUARY 20 1 5 Confidential & Proprietary
www.Blockchain.capital
One Ferry Building, Suite 25S
San Francisco, CA 94111
investor@blockchain.capital (415) 677-5440
Dear CCP II Investors,
The Blockchain economy and the Bitcoin ecosystem are alive and well. Blockchain Capital
LLC (the General Partner) and Crypto Currency Partners II, LP (the fund) are at the forefront of a
confluence of technology trends that we think will reshape financial services and disrupt multiple
legacy industries beyond just financial services. When you hear the term "BitcoM," think
"Blockchain." Bitcoin, the programmable digital currency, is a profound development in the
history of money and finance. It allows for the almost cost free and instantaneous exchange of
value between two parties without a financial intermediary like a bank or sovereign nation. But the
Blockchain, the core invention of Bitcoin, and its technological backbone, is an even bigger idea.
The Blockchain leverages cryptography and a system of decentralized consensus to ensure that two
parties can securely exchange value without knowing or trusting each other. Right now, this is
primarily being used for the exchange of the Blockchain's native currency: Bitcoin. In the near
future, the Blockchain will be utilized to digitally exchange assets of all types including stocks,
bonds, and tides to houses and cars. The Blockchain itself is the harbinger of a new field of
computer science called distributed applications. Distributed applications like the Blockchain
are peer-to-peer based networks that are not owned by anyone, but usable by everyone. These
networks are transparent and they are maintained and improved upon by members of the online
community. It is a fertile platform for "up the stack" development of distributed applications. This
will enable next generation identity management, the low cost resolution of legal disputes, and other
novel applications that will emerge in the coming years. We will be exploring the implications of the
Blockchain in particular, and distributed applications in general, in future newsletters. Stay tuned.
The Blockchain Venture Capital Landscape
Much has been written about similarities between the early days of the Internet and the early
days of Bitcoin. The Internet is enabled by a networking protocol called TCP/IP that allows for the
secure and instantaneous exchange of information. Bitcoin is enabled by the Blockchain, which
allows for the secure and instantaneous exchange of value. Here in Silicon Valley, venture capitalists
are leaning in. We estimate that close to $500M in venture capital financed "Blockchain enabled
technology companies" (a phrase we coined) in 2014. This is especially noteworthy considering
the spot price of Bitcoin was down almost 70% over the same period. Venture capital interest and
investment activity in Bitcoin/Blockchain is outpacing venture investment in the nascent Internet
sector in 1995-6. We were there then; we are here now. Venture capitalists are voting with their
checkbooks. World-class entrepreneurs are voting with their feet. Over the past eighteen months,
we have seen a dramatic increase in the caliber of entrepreneurs and executives that are starting
Blockchain enabled technology companies. It is a pleasure to work with these innovators on a daily
basis.
The Crypto Currency Partners funds have invested in 33 Blockchain enabled technology
companies in the last eighteen months, making us one of the most active Blockchain institutional
investors (based on Crunchbase statistics). What makes the CCP funds unique is not just our
exclusive focus on the sector and our access to nearly every quality investment opportunity. It is our
partners. The CCP funds' co-founders, advisory board members, and limited partners are start-up
Investor@blockchain.capital (415) 677-5440
executives in the Blockchain economy, as well as other venture capitalists, hedge fund managers,
bankers, and Silicon Valley technology executives. This gives us an unparalleled network of
Blockchain expertise to leverage for due diligence, high quality deal referrals, business and corporate
development, and recruiting. CCP was the first venture fund to accept capital calls in Bitcoin or fiat
currency and also fund companies in either Bitcoins or dollars. We have positioned the CCP funds
as specialist funds with domain specific expertise and a leading network of Blockchain operating
executives. The partners have a laser focus on helping our portfolio companies grow and thrive.
We want to co-invest alongside leading venture capitalists, not compete with them. We continue to
see excellent deal flow and have more deal access and investment opportunities than capital.
Portfolio Update
CCP puts its money and time where its mouth is. The general partners of CCP: Bart, Brad
and Brock have contributed capital and stock (at cost) to start CCP2. The Stephens family is the
largest limited partner of CCP2. We did a first dosing in late November and will continue to do
rolling doses until we reach our fund-raising target. Or, more likely, one of the existing 15 CCP2
portfolio companies experiences a material valuation increase or is acquired. We will dose the fund
to new investors if a material valuation event occurs, in order to protect the limited partners of the
fund who invested with us early on.
Coinbase
The newest portfolio company of Crypto Currency Partners is Coinbase. Coinbase is the
flagship company of the Blockchain economy. Period. It is the leader in merchant processing,
helping companies like Dell, Microsoft and accept Bitcoin from customers and
seamlessly delivering dollars. Merchants love accepting Bitcoin because they don't have to share 3-
5% with Visa/MasterCard/Amex/PayPal. Coinbase is also the largest consumer-facing Bitcoin
company that allows retail users to buy and use their Bitcoins in an easy to use wallet available on
iOS/Android. They allow customers to securely store their coins in an online "wallet" that is 100%
insured. The Coinbase management team is incredibly impressive and the company has executed
well on new product development. The most recent $75m financing, in which we participated, is
noteworthy because of the mainstream financial institutions and individuals that also participated:
The New York Stock Exchange, Vikram Pandit (former CEO, Citigroup), USAA (insurance
company), BVAA (Spanish Bank), Andreessen Horowitz, DoCoMo Capital (VC arm of Japan's
largest telecom), Union Square Ventures and Ribbit Capital (founder "Micky" Malka and Partner
Brock Pierce both serve on the elected Board of the Bitcoin Foundation). Coinbase recently
launched the first regulated, US domiciled Bitcoin exchange.
ChangeTip
ChangeTip allows for users of sites like Facebook, YouTube, GitHub, WordPress and
Reddit to tip each other small amounts of Bitcoin. Let's say you are a computer programmer
working on an open source project and another computer scientist finds a bug in your code. With
ChangeTip, you can do more than thank them. You can send them 1/100 of a penny or $999 in
Investor@blockchain.capital (415) 677-5440
Bitcoin as a thank you. Remember, Bitcoin is programmable digital money. If you like a post
on a message board, instead of a Facebook "thumbs up" button, you can tip them any amount of
money using ChangeTip. These types of transactions could never happen using a credit card.
Minimum credit card purchases (we have all seen the handwritten signs at cash registers) are $5-10
due to the high fixed costs associated with legacy financial processing technologies.
Tipping user-to-user is just the "Trojan horse" for ChangeTip. The massive opportunity
that ChangeTip is addressing is reimaging the economics of content ownership and online
publishing. Since the advent of the World Wide Web, content owners and publishers have struggled
to monetize their digital assets. Witness the decimation of the newspaper industry. If you own
content and want to monetize it, your options before ChangeTip were: 1) Put up a "paywall" and
collect a credit card to allow users to read everything you publish. This is similar to paying for
bundled cable where users pay for 547 channels and watch only 10. The other option for content
owners is to give everything away for free and let Google or other ad networks take a 30%
commission and annoy your users with banner ads and pop up videos, etc. ChangeTip will enable
content publishers to have a new monetization channel, allowing customers to pay $.10 per article or
$.50 per 30 min of YouTube content viewed. Analogs for this pricing model have already
happened with enterprise software. SAP/Oracle/PeopleSoft/Siebel used to charge Fortune 500
clients tens of millions of dollars to allow an entire company access to enterprise software after six
months of implementation. Marc Benioff and changed all of that with cloud
computing and selling pizza by the slice in real time, instead of being forced to buy the whole pizza.
ChangeTip will enable large publishers and small bloggers alike to monetize content on
their own terms without sharing their narrow margin with payment processors or ad
networks.
BitPesa
One thing that stinks about living in a developing country is that it is hard to save your way
out of poverty when hyperinflation and currency debasements are commonplace. Moreover, if you
are one of the world's 4 billion who don't have access to financial products like checking accounts
and credit cards, your financial options are severely limited. JP Morgan will never care about you.
However, almost all of these 4 billion people have cell phones, and with Bitcoin, they have a digital
bank in their pocket. We should all care about financial inclusion. An interesting experiment
happened in Kenya about five years ago. The unbanked started using their cell phone minutes as a
digital currency, called M-Pesa, to pay for everyday goods and services. BitPesa is an exchange that
allows users of M-Pesa minutes to convert to Bitcoin that can then be used at the corner market or
be sent anywhere in the world. Globalization is a powerful secular trend that will continue for
the foreseeable future. The Blockchain doesn't just enable financial services to 4 billion of the
"unbanked" in developing countries, it connects them to the Globalized online economy. BitPesa is
a bridge technology platform that connects users of M-Pesa (which is used only in Africa) to the
global financial system via Bitcoin.
investor@blockchain.capital (415) 677-5440
Team Update
We are thrilled to announce that Alison Davis has agreed to become Chairman of our
Advisory Board. Alison is a veteran financial services executive, Board Director and Investor. After
Cambridge, Harvard and Stanford she worked in the financial services practice group at both
McKinsey and AT Kearney. She was CFO of Barclays Global Investors, one of the largest fund
management firms in the world before its acquisition by Blackrock. She has served on numerous
Boards that are highly relevant to our investment focus including: The Royal Bank of Scotland
("RBS"), First Data Corporation, City National Bank, Fiserv, Unisys and XOOIVI. Alison is an
expert in a wide range of banking and regulatory matters, and we are excited to leverage her
experience, investment acumen, and extensive industry contacts.
As always, your comments and questions are appreciated.
Sincerely,
Bart, Brad and Brock
CCP Irs Public Key (you can send your Bitcoin capital calls here)
investor@blockchain.capital (415) 677-5440
Crypto Currency Partners II, LP Portfolio — February 2015
BitAccess — Bitcoin Teller Machine (BTM)
Co-investors: Y Combinator, Pantera Capital
BitGo — Enterprise focused, multi-signature secure wallet platform
Co-investors: Redpoint, Radar Partners, and Founders Fund
BitNet — Payment gateway for merchants
Co-investors: Highland Capital Partners, Rakuten
BitPesa — M-Pesa to Bitcoin exchange in Africa
Co-investors: Pantera, Future/Perfect Ventures
BlockStream — Enabling the creation of Side-chains
Co-investors: Reid Hoffman, Khosla Ventures, and Ribbit Capital
Bonafide — Centralized identity and reputation tied to wallets
Co-investors: 500 Startups
ChangeTip — Platform for receiving and sending online tips
Co-investors: Pantera, 500 Startups and BOLDstart Ventures
Coinbase — Leading U.S.-based Bitcoin wallet and exchange service
Co-investors: Andreessen Horowitz, Union Square Ventures, Ribbit Capital, and DFJ
CoinSetter — Institutional grade, low latency Bitcoin exchange and ECN
Co-investors: Second Market, Tribeca Venture Fund
Expresscoin — A simple and safe way for consumers to buy Bitcoin
Co-investors: Bitcoin Shop, Angels
GoCoin — Multi-currency payment gateway for merchants
Co-investors: Bitcoin Shop, Angels
itBit - NASDAQ -powered Bitcoin exchange
Co-investors: Liberty City Ventures, RRE Ventures, and Canaan Partners
KrakenEuropean crypto currency exchange
Co-investors: Hummingbird Ventures, SecondMarket
LedgerX — Self-clearing Bitcoin derivatives platform
Co-investors: Lightspeed Venture Partners, SV Angel, and Google Ventures
PeerNova — Crypto infrastructure-as-a-service and cloud-hashing
Co-investors: Mosaik Partners, Pierre Lamond, Ashar Aziz
Investor@blockchain.capital (415) 677-5440
EFTA00081180 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Umar Dzhabrailov [russia] Chechen oligarch who called Ghislaine Maxwell his "soulmate", died by "suicide" March 2026 [nyp/jamestown] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01191873 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States
╔══════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Masayoshi Son [tech] CEO of Softbank, often referred to as "Masa" 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00020729 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States: declaration of Virginia Giuffre claiming threats from men impersonating FBI agents, see quote: 
"a call from this supposed FBI Agent made me very scared"
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Roman Polanski [arts] film director, famously fled the US to escape statutory rape charges 
              Stephen R. Alexander [medical] Epstein's sex-addiction therapist (???) [rddt] 
                       Abi Schwinck [modeling] Jean Luc Brunel's MC2 Model Management (???) 
           Ginta Lapina [modeling] Latvian, possibly signed to MC2 Model Management [insta] 
                               Manuela Martinez [modeling] Mega Partners (Brazilian agency) 
                      Michael Sanka [modeling] Jean Luc Brunel's MC2 Model Management (???) 
                              Vladimir Yudashkin [modeling] director of the 1 Mother Agency 
                       lorraine@mc2mm.com [modeling] Jean Luc Brunel's MC2 Model Management 
                           pink@mc2mm.com [modeling] Jean Luc Brunel's MC2 Model Management 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00599855 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jean Luc Brunel v. Jeffrey Epstein and Tyler McDonald d/b/a YI.org: court filing
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Yoni Koren aka Itzhak Koren [israel] assistant to Ehud Barak, ex-Mossad [dropsite] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01401501 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank $10,000 transfer to Yoni Koren
(inferred date: 2015-02-23)
Deutsche Bank
Private Wealth Management
Authorization for Asset Movement
For Non-Retirement Accounts
The undersigned hereby authorizes and directs Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown
("Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown" or "OBAB") to iollow the below asset movement
instructions.
11 you wish to request multipie wires, checks, lournals or free deliveries,
please use the long form
DRAB Accxjunt Name Jeffrey E Epsteln
Account #:
Wire
Journal
d Journal Funds m the amount of S
Q Journal Holdings:
Qiy/SvmholiSecufity
Qty/Symbol/Secuiity:
Q Journal All Holdings
To DBAB Account #:
Account Name'
0 Wire federal funds m the amount of S 10,000.00
To Bank Name- Citibank, NA
City / State:
ABA#
Further credit to Intermediary Financial institution (Qptionaii
Acocum #:
Name:
Ultimate BeneficiaiY Information;
BaneliciavName: Itzhak Koren
Account #-
Free Daliveriee
LI Please deliver die seounues moioated below to:
AddiUonal Instrucuons:
DTCC#:
Name of Receiving Firm.
Account Name:
Check
Q Issue a check in the amount of S
Recipient's Name:
Reapienl's Mailing Address.
payable lo:
Account Number:
at Receiving Firm
Olv/SymboirSecut ity.
OlyASyinbOl/Seairity:
Standing Authorization
Q The undeisigned hereby requesis lhal this authorization act as a standing
authoiizalion. The undersigned understands and agrees that Ihis
authorization will
remain m ellect until Deutsche Bank Aiex Brown requests a new aulhonzalion.
The undersigned authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to issue the wire,
check or journal on the
Q The undersigned further authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to accept
verbal instructions from the undersigned to wire Funds, issue checks or
journal
funds to/from the above listed accounts. The undersigned witi provide verbal
instructions as to the date and the amount of the wire, check or journal. If
the
undersigned decides to vary either the dale or the amount of the wire, check
or journal, the undersigned hereby authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex, Brown to
accept the verbal instructions from the undersigned regarding the change or
changes. The undersigned fuilher understands and agrees to comply with the
procedures of Deutsche Bank Alex Brown to verify the authorization and
accuracy of verbal instructions.
day of
for a tarm of
The undersigned liereby acknowledges that (i) the information contained in
this form is complete and accurate to the best knowledge of the undersigned;
and (II) the
undersigned is lesponsible for the method of transmission of any
insiructions issued pursuant to this authorization. If the undeisigned
elects to transmit any such
instructions via fax (including desktop fax), via email or as an image
attachment to email (e.g , as a PDF, TIF or other image of such
instructions), the undersigned
understands and agrees that the undersigned bears the risk of loss arising
from such meihod of transmission in the event of transmission errors,
misunderstandings,
impersonations, transmission by unauthonzed persons, forgery or intercepts.
For trusts or other entities, the undersigned further acknowledges that the
undersigned rs
authorized to issue the above asset movement iiisiiucuons under the terms of
the govemmg documents and any applicable laws. The undersigned hereby
releases and
holds harmlass Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown from and against loss from any
action, claim or demand of any person as a result of Deutsche Bank Alex.
Brown's receipt of
or compliance with this authorization and/or any instructions that may be
given to Deutsche Bank Alex Brown pursuant to this authorization (including
any standing
authorization!.
The undersigned understands that Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown may, but is not
required to, seek verification of the undersigned's instructions by call
back and that
Daulscha Bank Alex, Brown may in its sola discretion refuse to exscule such
instructions lincluding standing insifuciions) given pursuant to this
authorization, without
incurnng any liability, if Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown has reason to believe
such instructions (or standing instructions) have net been provided by the
undersigned. The
undersigned further understands that Deutsche Baiik /Jex Brown retains the
right lo refuse to execute any instructions to transfer funds or secumies to
any account(s)
"Ntsuani to this authorization without written i^TiurfiSns bearing original
signature(s) of the undersigned.
Darren Indyke
2-23-2015
Prim Name
Signature
Date
Print Name
Date
Signature
LOA
10-PWM-01775 (12/10)
╔════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Reuben Kobulnik [tech] Peter Thiel's Valar Ventures 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01193042 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2015-02-25)
VALAR VLNYUNIU
Valor Global Fund II LP Capital Call
February 11, 2015
Dear Southern Trust Company. Inc..
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund II LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $900.000.00, which represents 6% of your total commitment of
$15,000,000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Wednesday February 25, 2015.
After this capital contribution. you will have contributed 7% of your total commitment with a
remaining 93% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of February 25, 2015:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$15,000,000.00
$1,050.000.00
$13,950,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Wednesday February 25, 2015
$900.000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
121140399
Valor lobal Fund II LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
•
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
C'OO/CFC)
Valor Venlures Management LLC 915 Broadway Suite 1101 New York. New York 10010 www.yolor.com
EFTA01139414 (Jmail)
 [legal] Brad Edwards & Paul G. Cassell v. Alan Dershowitz: interview with minor victim
EFTA01285353 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2015-03-29)
Deutsche Bank El
Deutsche Bank Trust Co. .Americas
- NYC20-0102
New York. NY 10154
Sol I I1ERN TRUST COMPANY. INC.
ST THOMAS
00802
UNITED STATES VI
February 1.2015 to February 28. 2015
Summary of Account Ilalance(s)
Account Account Number Balance
For personal assistance call:
:Mande Kirby
Balance
Elite Money Market Deposit
!lc-Riming Balance at of February I. 2015
S86.419,577.06
587,609,592.10
Deposits and Other Credit 59.984.96
Checks Paid 50.00
AT5.1 and 1)ebit Card Withdrauals 50.00
Service Charges and Other Fees $0.00
Other Debits (51.200,000.00 )
Ending Balance as of February 2& 2015
Transition Detail
Date Description Debit
586.419.577.06
Credit
Beginning Balance at of Febniary I. 2015 587,609,592.10
02.02 x Transfer Of Funds
TRANSFER TO ACCOUNT
(300.000.00 ) 87,309,592.10
02-12 x Outgoing Money Triter
TO SILICON VALLEY BANK A/C
9 VALAR GLOBAL FUND B LE
(900,000.00 ) 86A09.592.10
02-28 :dna-rest Eminent 9.984.96 86.419.577.06
Ending Balance as of Febniap., 28. 2015 (1.200.000.00 ) 59.984.96 586.419.577M
All items arc credited subject to final collection and receipt of pruceedi in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
44129244
I oft SDNY_GM_ 00041588
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.
iN c9r.u(e)F  I DE NTIAL DB-SDNY-0004412
Deutsche Bank
Deposits and Other Credits
Date Description Amount
02-28 Interest Payment 59.984.96
Service Charges and Other Fees
Total NSF return item fees for this statement period $0.00
Total NSF Mum item fees for this calendar sear $0.00
Total Overdraft lea for this statement period $0.00
Thal Chadian real for this calendar sear $0.00
Other Debits
Date Description Amount
02-02 Transfer Of Funds f&100.000.00
02-12 Outgoing klona Tnet (5900.000.00
Interest Calculation
Annual Percentage Yield Earned
Interest Lamed This Period
Interest Paid Year To Dale
0.15%
$9,984.96
$21,179.36
All items are credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceed; in cash or by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Anis-rice&
44129244
2 of 3 SDNY_GM_ 00041589
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.WIN(c) FIDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0004413
Deutsche Bank
In Case of Favors or Questions

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at S or write to us at Deutsche Dank Trust Company Americas. WM Banking Team -
NYC20-0102. New York Na. York 10154 as sour as you can if you think your statement or moript is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MUST hear from you no later than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRSTstatement on which ihe error or problem appeared.

• Tell us wax name and account number
- Describe the erns or transfer you arc unsure about. and explain as clearly as you can %thy you believe it is an error 
or why you
need more information

• Tell us the dollar amount of the suspected error
Please note that if you initially provide the above information to us via telephone. we may 'Nuke that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within 10 business days.
We will investigate your complaint and will correct any error promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 
days for new
acoounts) to do this. we will provisionally credit your account for the amount you think is in error. so that you will 
have the use of the
money during the time it talon us to complete our investigation At the conclusion of our invatigation we will inform you
of our results.

2. Non•Electronic Funds Transfers
Contact the Bank immediately at if your statement is incorrect or if you need more information about any non-electronic
funds transactions (cheeks or deposits) on this natant. If any such error appears. you must notify the Bank in writing 
no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you. Please see sour Terms and Conditions for further infominion on 
the terms
governing your account.

3. Verifying Preauthorized Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once every 60 days from the same person or 
company, you
can telephone us at to find out whether the deposit has been mark
SDNY_GM_ 00041590
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R gdr.o(e) R N D ENTIAL DB-SONY-0004414
I EFTA_00152199
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Raiffeisenbank [russia] Russian bank to which Epstein wired $237,270 for Svetlana Pozhidaeva's family 
                                                        Amanda Kirby [bank] associate at Deutsche Bank 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01366289 (Jmail)
 [girls] Butterfly Trust transfer of $237,270 to Svetlana Pozhidaeva's father Raiffeisenbank from account at Standard Chartered Bank
(date: 2015-03-30)
Butterfly Trust
MEMORANDUM
To Amanda Kirby
From: Richard Kahn
Value Date: March 30, 2015
Debit Account # :
Please wire Two Hundred Thirty Seven Thousand Two Hundred Seventy Dollars
($237,270) from the above account to:
Intermediary Bank:
Standard Ch New York
Swift code:
Chips ABA: 0256
Fedwire #:
Correspondent Account #:
For further credit to:
Beneficiary Bank: AO Raiffeisenbank
Address: 17/1 Troitskaya, Moscow, 129090 Russia
SWIFT:
Account name.
Account #:
Please call Bella Klein with any questions and the US Dollar amount at
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0057814
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00203998
EFTA01285411 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank statement for Epstein's Southern Trust Company showing $82 million balance
(inferred date: 2015-03-31)
Deutsche Bank 0
Deutsche Bank Must Co. Americas
345 Park Avenue - NYC20-0102
New York. NY 10154
Sot I 11ERN TRUSTCOMPANY. INC.
6100 RED 14OOK QUARTER 133
ST THOMAS
00802
UNITED STATES VI
March 1.2015 to March 31. 2015
Summary of 'teemed Balance(s)
Account Account Number Balance
For personal assistance call:
:Manta Kirby
Balance
Elite Money Market Deposit 582.430.475.34
Begiming Balance as of March I. 2015 586.419.577.06
Deposits and Other Credits 510.898.28
Checks Paid 50.00
ATM and Debit Card Withdrauals 50.00
Service Charges and Other Fees 50.00
Other Debits (54.000,000.00 )
Ending Balance as of March 31. 2015
Transa:tion Detail
Dale Des...-ripnon Debit
582,430,475.34
Credit
Beginning Balance as of March I, 2015 586,419,577.06
03-13 a Trawler Of Funds
TR.INSFER TO ACCOUNT
42953707
(300.000.00 ) 86,119,577.06
03-16 Outgoing Money Trrof
TO DEUTSCHE BANK A/C 19200190 ERGO L
TD.
(1.000,000.00 ) 85,119,577.06
03-30 B Outgoing Money Tmsf
R./SILICON VALLEY BANK A/C 330123181
9 VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
(2.700000.00 ) 82.419.577.06
03-31 a IntaestPa‘ment 10.898.28 82,430,475.34
Ending Balance as of March 31.2015 (4030000.00 ) 510.898.28 582.430.475.34
All items are credited subject to final colledico and receipt of proceed< in cash or by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
I of 1 SDNY_GM_0CO41663
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.
IN c9r.u(e)F  IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0004487
Deutsche Bank El
Deposits and Other Credits
Date Description
03-31 Inkiest Payment SI0.139&28
Amount
Service Charges and Other Fees
Total NSF return item fees for this statement period 50.00
Total NSF return item fees for this calendar wear $0.00
Total Overdraft fees for this statement period $0.00
Total th erdraft fee, for this calendar year 50.00
Other Debits
Date Description
03-13 Transfer Of Funds
03-16 Outgoing Money TntS
03-30 Outgoing Money Trnsi
Amount
Interest Cal ulalion
\mud Percentage Yield Earned
Inicre‘i Daniel This Period
kihrest Pald 1 car h• lame
(5300.000.00 )
(S1.000.000.00 )
(S2.700.000.00 )
0.15%
S10.898.213
532,077.61
.II items are cushied subject to final collection and receipt of proceed< in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
America
or SDNY_GM_00041664
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.
c9r.u() iN
DB-SDNY-0004488
I DE NTIAL
Deutsche Bank
In Case of Firer( or Questions

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at or Wilt to us at Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas. 345 Park Avenue. WN1 Banking Team -
NYC20-0102. New York Na. York 10154 as sour as you aurt if you think your statement or receipt is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MCA ST hear from you no later than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRST statement on which ihe error or problem appeared.

• Tell us your name and account number
- Describe the enor or transfer you arc unsure about. and explain as clearly as you can why you believe it is an error 
or why you
need more information

• Tell in the dollar amount of the suspected error
Please note that if you initially provide the above information to us via telephone. we may require that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within 10 business days.
We will investigate yaw complaint and will correct any error promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 days
for new
accounts) to do this. we will provisionally credit your account for the amount you think is in error. so that you will 
have the use of the
money during the time it takes us to complete our investigation. Al the conclusion of our invatigation we sail inform 
you of our results.

2. Non•Eloctronic Funds Transfers
Contact the Bank immediately at-if your statement is incorrect or if you need more information about any non-electronic
funds transactions (checks or deposits) on this statement. If any such error appears. you must notify the Bonk in 
writing no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you. Please see your Tarns and Conditions for limite r 'origination on
the terms
governing your account.

3. Verifying Theauthorked Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once every 60 days from the same person or 
company, you
can telephone us at o find out whether the deposit has been made.
EDNY_GM_ 00041665
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R c9r.o(e) DB -SDNY-0004489
RDENTIAL
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 IPI [europe] International Peace Institute, gave jobs to Epstein's girls [apnews] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00589797 (Jmail)
 [girls] letter from Terje Rød-Larsen to INS recommending "genius" visa for someone
(date: 2015-05-02)
IPI INTERNATIONAL
PEACE
INSTITUTE
May 15, 2015
US DHS CIS
Vermont Service Center
30 Houghton Street

St. Albans, VT 05478
Re: Ms.
Dear Sir or Madam:
O-1 Visa Application
I am writing this letter on behalf of Ms.
a communications and public relations professional of
extraordinary ability.
Since 2005 I have been President of the International Peace
Institute (IPI), an independent, international not-for-profit
think tank dedicated to managing risk and building resilience to
promote peace, security, and sustainable development. To achieve
its purpose, IPI employs a mix of policy research, strategic
analysis, publishing, and convening.
I had the distinct pleasure of working with Ms.
benefitting from her extraordinary abilities. All my staff who
have worked closely with appreciate her skills, command
of languages and her always warm and amicable personality.
I observed Ms. communication and language skills
during a visit to Central Asia in 2014, where she interacted with
foreign officials and professionals. Ms. will also be
providing support to an upcoming international conference on
Global Health and Pandemics.
Sincerely yours,
roA Terje Rod-Larsen
President
777 United Nations Plaza, New York, NY 10017 USA TEL FAX www.lpinst.org
╔════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 OCDETF [government] Organized Crime Drug Enforcement Task Force 
                USMS [government] United States Marshals Service 
       Mariana Idźkowska [modeling] Polish model, island visitor 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00173953 (Jmail)
 [government] OCDETF heavily redacted report on Epstein's potential involvement in Caribbean drug money laundering, Mariana Idźkowska's name is 
unredacted
(date: 2015-05-18)
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15-12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015

MEMORANDUM

Date: May 18, 2015
To: <REDACTED>
.   Assistant Special Agent in Charge
.   Special Operations Division
From: <REDACTED>
.     Director
.     OCDETF Fusion Center
Subject: Target Profile: <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>; Jeffrey EPSTEIN;
.        <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
.        <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

WARNING
This product contains sensitive proprietary law enforcement information which may be either classified or the subject of
stringent caveats. This
product is compiled from multi-agency databases and open sources, and should not be treated as a finished investigative 
product. OCDETF
suggests advising your prosecuting attomey(s) of this intelligence product. The recipient and attomey(s) are advised 
that this product may not be
referenced in affidavits, indictments. extradition documents, other court related documents, press releases. or 
duplicated as a pan of the discovery
process without the express written permission of the OCDETF Fusion Center and the originating agencies. This product is
provided to your
agency for lead purposes only and may not be disseminated to third panics without approval of the originating agencies. 
Further. investigative
action based upon this information should be coordinated with the contributing agencies. This product should be 
destroyed in a manner consistent
with its classification upon determination that retention is no longer necessary to support an investigation, 
prosecution or related activity.

Date of Request: April 28, 2015
Case File Number / Agency: C1-11-0049 GDEP: YNL3B (DEA)
OCDETF Case Number: NY-NYS-0829
OCDETF Operation Name: Chain Reaction
Requestor / Agency / Telephone Number: <REDACTED>
OFC Unit Chief / Telephone Number: <REDACTED>
OFC Desk Officer / Telephone Number: <REDACTED>
OFC Intelligence Analyst / Telephone Number: <REDACTED>
SOD OSF Contact / Telephone Number: <REDACTED>

Agency information contained herein:
ATF SI CBP la DEA O DOC ❑ DOL OIG
114 FBI 61 ICE ❑ IRSCI O USMS ❑ USPIS
FBI Guardian Incident
OAFP ONCA/SOCA OBOP li DSS
❑ USSS ❑NZP lilF1NCEN
SDOS

Table of Contents

ANALYTICAL FINDINGS 1
Background: 1
• Analytical Findings: 1

TARGET 1 — <REDACTED>  4
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 4
ADDRESSES 5
COMMUNICATIONS 5
Telephone Numbers 5
BORDER CROSSINGS 5
Border Crossings - Air S
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 6
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 6
Offline NC1C 6
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 7
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 7
ASSETS 7
Financial Accounts) 7

TARGET 2 — <REDACTED> 8
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 8
ADDRESSES 8
COMMUNICATIONS 8
Telephone Numbers 8
BORDER CROSSINGS 8
Border Crossings - Air 8
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 9
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 9
Offline NC1C 9
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 10
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 10

TARGET 3 - <REDACTED> 11
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 1 I
ADDRESSES II
COMMUNICATIONS I I
Telephone Numbers I
Websites, Email Addresses, IP Addresses II
BORDER CROSSINGS 12
Border Crossings - Air 12
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 12
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 12
Offline NC1C 12
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 13
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 13

TARGET 4 — JEFFREY EPSTEIN 14
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 14
ADDRESSES 14
COMMUNICATIONS 15
Telephone Numbers 15
Websites, Email Addresses, IP Addresses 15
BORDER CROSSINGS 15
Border Crossings - Air 15
CORPORATE/BUSINESS AFFILIATIONS 15
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 16
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 17
Offline NCIC 17
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 19
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 19
UC7'R — Unified Currency Transaction Report(s) 19
CTR — Currency Transaction Report(s) 19
AssErs 20
Financial Accounts) 20
FAMILY MEMBER/ASSOCIATE IDENTIFYING INFORMATION 21
Associates 21

TARGET 5 -  22
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 22
ADDRESSES 22
COMMUNICATIONS 22
Telephone Numbers 22
Websites, Email Addresses, IP Addresses 23
BORDER CROSSINGS 23
Border Crossings - Air 23
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 23
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 24
Off line NCIC 24
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 25
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 25
UC7'R — Unified Currency Transaction Report(s) 25
AssErs 26
Financial Accoum(s) 26

TARGET 6 —  27
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 27
ADDRESSES 28
COMMUNICATIONS 28
Telephone Numbers 28
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

TARGET 7 -
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Websites, Email Addresses, IP Addresses 28
BORDER CROSSINGS 28
Border Crossings - Air 28
CORPORATE/BUSINESS AFFILIATIONS 29
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 29
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 29
Offline NCIC 29
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 30
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 31
CTR - Currency Transaction Report(s) 31
AssErs 31
Financial Account(s) 31
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 32
ADDRESSES 32
COMMUNICATIONS 32
Telephone Numbers 32
Websites, Email Addresses, IP Addresses 32
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 33
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 33
Offline NCIC 33
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 34
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 34
UCTR — Unified Currency Transaction Report(s) 34
CTR - Currency Transaction Report(s) 35

TARGET 8 —  36
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 36
ADDRESSES 36
COMMUNICATIONS 36
Telephone Numbers 36
Websites, Email Addresses, IP Addresses 36
BORDER CROSSINGS 37
Border Crossings - Air 37
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 37
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 37
Offline NCIC 37
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 38
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 38

TARGET 9 -  39
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 39
ADDRESSES 40
COMMUNICATIONS 40
Telephone Numbers 40
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

TARGET 11 -
Websites, Email Addresses, IP Addresses 40
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 40
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 41
Offline NCIC 41
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 41
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 42
AssErs 42
Financial Account(s) 42

TARGET 10 — 43
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 43
ADDRESSES 43
BORDER CROSSINGS 43
Border Crossings - Air 43
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 44
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 44
Offline NCIC 44
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 45
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 45
CTR - Currency Transaction Report(s) 45
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 47
ADDRESSES 47
COMMUNICATIONS 47
Telephone Numbers 47
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 47
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCIC 48
Offline NCIC 48
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 49
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 49
AssErs 49
Financial Account(s) 49

TARGET 12 —  50
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 50
ADDRESSES 50
COMMUNICATIONS 50
Telephone Numbers 50
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 51
CRIMINAL HISTORY/NCiC 51
Offline NCIC 51
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 52
USAR — Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s) 52
AssErs 53
Financial Account(s) 53
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

TARGET 13 -

TARGET 14 -
BIOGRAPHICAL/IDENTIFYING DATA 54
ADDRESSES 54
COMMUNICATIONS 55
Telephone Numbers 55
BORDER CROSSINGS 55
Border Crossings - Air 55
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 55
CRIMINAL HIsToRWNCIC 56
Off line NCIC 56
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 57
BUSINESS IDENTIFYING DATA 58
ADDRESSES 58
COMMUNICATIONS 59
Telephone Numbers 59
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 59
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 59
ASSOCIATE IDENTIFYING INFORMATION 60
Associates 60

TARGET 15 -  61
BUSINESS IDENTIFYING DATA 61
ADDRESSES 61
COMMUNICATIONS 62
Telephone Numbers 62
LINKED INVESTIGATIONS 62
FINANCIAL INFORMATION 62
ASSOCIATE IDENTIFYING INFORMATION 63
Associates 63

Date of Report: May 18, 2015
**CAUTION**
This product may contain active hyperlinks to internet websites and email
addresses. Please use caution when navigating the contents of this publication. Hvperlinks will be
identified in red.

Analytical Findings

Background: A request was submitted by the Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) New
York NY for all information available to the OCDETF Fusion Center OFC for
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>, Jeffrey EPSTEIN, <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>. DEA reporting
indicates the above individuals are involved in illegitimate wire transfers which are tied to illicit
drug and/or prostitution activities occurring in the U.S. Virgin Islands and New York City.

• Analytical Findings: This Target Profile product was prepared from a series of queries
against the available OFC databases. Reporting relative to the subjects was found in Customs
and Border Protection (CBP); DEA; DOS Non-immigrant Visas (DOS NIV); Diplomatic
Security Service (DSS); Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI); Financial Crimes Enforcement
Network (FinCEN) Gateway; and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) databases as
well as the commercial database Accurint.

Through a phone conversation, the requestor indicated recent financial information on the targets
would be beneficial to the investigation.

o Financial Information (Bank Secrecy Act Warnings Apply):

Analyst's Note 1: Many of their financial reports listed below include many/all of the
targets as multiple subjects.

Analyst's Note 2: Only financial reporting from 2010 through 2015 is included in this
report. Older financial information on the targets is available.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of three 2015 USARs totaling $4,193,637.
See attachment I for more information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of three 2015 USARs totaling $4,193,637. See
attachment 1 for more information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of three 2015 USARs totaling $2,754,983. See
attachment 1 for more information.

• Jeffrey EPSTEIN is a subject of seven USARs (4 in 2015, 2 in 2014, and 1 in

2013) totaling $5,672,921. See attachment 1 for more information.

• Jeffrey EPSTEIN and <REDACTED> are subjects together in three Unified
Curren Transaction Reports (UCTR) (1 in 2014 and 2 in 2013) totaling $102,

648. <REDACTED> reportedly conducted transactions on Jeffrey EPSTEIN's behalf.
See Jeffrey EPSTEIN's financial information section for more information.

• Jeffrey EPSTEIN is a subject of eight CTRs (2 in 2011 and 6 in 2010) totaling
$233,397. <REDACTED> is an additional subject of one of these CTRs. See
attachment 2 for more information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of a 2015 USAR for $157,898. See attachment I for
more information.
• <REDACTED> is a subject of a 2014 UCTR for 0 000 in which he conducted
a withdrawal(s) on behalf of See
financial information section for more information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of three USARs (2 in 2015 and 1 in 2014)
totalin 4 236 995. See attachment 1 for more information.

• <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> are subjects of a 2011 CTR in which
<REDACTED> conducted USD and Euro transactions on behalf of <REDACTED>
See <REDACTED> financial information section for more information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of two USARs (1 in 2015 and 1 in 2013) totaling
898. See attachment I for more information.

• <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> are the subjects of three 2013 UCTRs
totaling $157,152. FinCEN indicates cashed negotiable instruments the
businesses' behalf. See <REDACTED> financial information and corporate/business
affiliations sections for more information regarding the UCTRs and <REDACTED>
respectively.

• <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> are the subjects of 22 CTRs (1 in 2013, 9
in 2012, 7 in 2011, and 5 in 2010) totaling $730,000. See attachment 3 for more
information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of three 2015 USARs totaling $2,754,983. See
attachment 1 for more information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of two 2015 USARs totaling $4,079,102.
See attachment I for more information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of three 2015 USARs, totaling $4,193,637. See
attachment 1 for more information.

• <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> are subjects together in two
CTRs (2011 and 2010) in which <REDACTED> conducted deposits on the
company's behalf. See <REDACTED> financial information section for more
information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of two 2015 USARs totaling $4,079,102. See
<REDACTED> financial information section for more information
<REDACTED> is the subject of a 2012 USAR for $45,107. See
<REDACTED> financial information section for more information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of two 2015 USARs totaling $4,079,102.
See IDZKOWSKA's financial information for more information.

• <REDACTED> is a subject of two 2015 USARs
totaling $4,079,101. See attachment 1 for more information
• <REDACTED> is a subject of three 2015 USARs totaling
$4,193,637. See attachment 1 for more information.

o Cases and Contacts: The targets are subjects in the following case:
Agency/Location Case Number Date Opened
ase
Status/DateC
File Title/
Operation
Name
Case
Agent(s)/
Phone No.
DEA/
New York, NY C1-11-0049 12/17/2010 Pending
Judicial
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 3 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 4 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 5 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Offline NCIC repon lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This repon 
does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. Olt 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the rcquestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file, i.c. - Offline
NCIC Results for Target I IMMIDD(fYYY HH:NIM:SS).xls", which provides the dateline and Agency ORI terminal the target 
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discoverine tareet associations based on vehicle stops.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 6 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only for a purpose consistent with a criminal. tax. or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding, or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released. disseminated, disclosed, or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR fling-  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity. filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc utli evidence. but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may nol: 1) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as pert or a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate that  potential 
disclosureixith_FinCENs Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies, along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization, disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation. or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force, provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines Jar Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 7 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May IS, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 8 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May IS, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An GI 'line NCIC report lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This 
report does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OFC 
requests will query• NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the requestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file, i.e. - Offline
NCIC Results for Target I INIM/DDfYYYY HH:fsINI:SS).xls", which provides the datetime and Agency ORI terminal the target
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific infommtion outlined in the attachment to
provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 9 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only for a purpose consistent with a criminal, tax. or regulatory• 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities. including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 53 II.
The information cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed, or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR (Isaac_ This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity. filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that. when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may not: I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part or a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate that potential disclosure with 
FinCEN's Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies, along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization, disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation. or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force. provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines fin. Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 10 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 11 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Offline NCIC rcpon lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This report
does not necessarily
moan the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OIC 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the rcquestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file. i.c. "Offline
NCIC Results for Target I antalirtYYY HH:MNI:SS).xls", which provides the datetimc and Agency ORI terminal the target 
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 12 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information maybe used only for a purpose consistent with a criminal. tax. or regulatory• 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities. including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential infommnt tips. Unauthorized
release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage: This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity. filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs are not evidence. but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as pan of investigative efforts may not: I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part of a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate that potential disclosure with 
FinCEN's Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies. along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization, disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation, or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force. provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines Jar Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 13 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
0FC-TP-15-12392
S0D0FC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
TARGET 4 — Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Biographical/Identifying Data
Information Source
Full Name: Jeffrey Edward
EPSTEIN ICE ROI, PA07QK13PA0002-003
Alias: Jeffrey E. EPSTEIN FinCEN BSA ID 31000062289100
DOB: 01/20/1953 FinCEN BSA ID 31000062289100
SSN: FinCEN BSA ID 31000062289100
Driver's License Number and
State: FinCEN  BSA ID 31000062289100U.S. Vir• in Islands
ICE Subject Record P8529715900CWP
Occupation: Investment Advisor FinCEN BSA ID 31000062289100
Accountant FinCEN BSA ID 20112031315534
Business/Employer: SLK DESIGNS LLC FinCEN BSA ID 31000053179085
HYPERION AIR, INC. FinCEN BSA ID 31000031627861
Agency Identifier(s): ICE P6B38569000CPA ICE Subject Record P6B38569000CPA
ICE P8529715900CWP ICE Subject Record P8529715900CWP
Analyst's Note: See the co orate/business affiliations section for more information regarding SLK
DESIGNS LW and INC.
Addresses
(R) - Residential (B) - Business (U) - Unknown M) -Mailing Company/Post Office (C) - Criminal
Type Address Date of SourceInfo.
R 03/06/2015 FinCEN BSA ID
M 03/0612015 FinCEN BSA ID
R 03/06/20 15 FinCEN BSA ID
B 03/06/20 15 FinCEN BSA ID
B 03/06/2015 FinCEN BSA ID
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 14 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Communications
Telephone Numbers
R — Residential B — Business M — Mobile U — Unknown (P) - Pa er/Bee er V - VOIP
Type Number Address Subscriber/Affiliation
to Target
Date of
Info. Source
M See Analyst's Note Jeffrey E. EPSTEIN 03/06/2015
FinCEN BSA ID
R See Analyst's Note Jeffrey E. EPSTEIN 03/06/2015
B See Analyst's Note See Analyst's Note 03/06/2015
B See Analyst's Note See Analyst's Note 03/06/2015
B See Analyst's Note See Analyst's Note 03/06/2015
B See Analyst's Note See Analyst's Note 03/06/2015
Analyst's Note: Specific subscriber/corresponding businesses names for the above business phone
numbers were not listed.
Websites, Email Addresses, IP Addresses
Website/Email Address/IP
Address Subscriber/Affiliation to Target Source
Jeffrey E. EPSTEIN FinCEN
BSA ID
Border Crossings
Border Crossings - Air
Source: Customs and Border Protection (CBP)
Date/ lime Departure Airport Arrival Airport Flight Number/Airline
05/06/2014 Charles de Gualle Int. JFK Int. 006/Air France
04/29/2014 JFK Int. Charles de Gualle hit. 011/Air France
02/19/2014 Charles de Gualle Int. JFK Int. 022/Air France
02/09/2014 JFK Im. Charles de Gualle Mt. 009/Air France
Corporate/Business Affiliations
Name, Address,
Phone
Corp.
Number/Filing
Type
Status
Affiliation of
Target to
Corp /Business
CorpJBusiness
Off  icers Source
Aim.
Number: Active Signor
‘LLounctint
FinCEN BSA ID
31000031627861;
Accurint
LLC
Qtrs. Ste 133
St Thomas, Virgin
Islands, U.S.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 15 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Nam Ad e,hone dress,P
Corp.
Number/Filing
T
Status
Affiliation of
Target to
Cor /Business
Corp./Business
Officers Source
Details: FinCEN indicates EPSTEIN and are signors
Analyst's Note: FinCEN indicates this company provides aircraft maintenance.
business consists of one 2001 Bell 430 aircraft (S/N: 49078) which
for LLC.
Accur nt indicates this
was registered on 09/06/2013.
SLK DESIGNS
New York, NY
Not Listed Active Association Not Listed FinCEN BSA ID
Details: EPSTEIN and SLK DESIGNS LLC are isted as subjects together in a 2014 USAR. FinCEN
indicates EPSTEIN sent SLK DESIGNS LLC $20,000 from an external bank account in 2014.
Linked Investigations
Agency/Location Case
Number Date Opened Case
Status/Date
File Title/
Operation Name
Case
Agent(s)/
Phone No.
DEA/
New York, NY C1-11-0049 12/17/2010 Pending
Judicial
Details: The R uestor's case
FBI/
Miami, FL
31E-MM-
108062 07/25/2006 Active
EPSTEIN,
JEFFREY
Details: FBI reporting indicates Jeffrey EPSTEIN and Ghislaine MAXWELL are companions (FBI FD-
302, 31E-MM -108062, 07/08/2013).
ICE/
Paris, France
PA07QK13P
A0002 06/07/2013 Closed/
10/03/2013
OPERATION
ANGEL
WATCH/RCSO
PRESENSE/
TRANSITING
INFO SHARING
Details: ICE reporting indicates Jeffrey EPSTEIN was convicted in 2008 of procuring a person under age
18 for prostitution in Florida (ICE ROI, PA07QK 13PA0002-003).
ICE/
Las Vegas, NV
LV15HT09L
V0009 02/02/2009 Pending/
01/27/2010
Details: ICE reporting indicates Jeffrey EPSTEIN pled guilty on 06/30/2008 on charges relating to
solicitation of prostitution and procurement of minors to engage in prostitution (ICE ROI,
LV I 5HT09LV0009-003)
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 16 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Agency/Location Case
Number Date Opened Case
Status/Date
File Title/
Operation Name
Case
Ag
Phone
ent(sY
No.
ICE/
West Palm Beach,
FL
WPIEQI°6WP0011 07/28/2006 Closed/
07/28t2008
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
(El' AL)
Details: ICE reporting indicates Jeffery EPSTEIN pled guilty on 06/30/2008 to state offences relating to
solicitation of prostitution and procurement of minors to engage in prostitution (ICE Subject Record
P8529715900CWP).
Criminal History/NCIC •
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Offline NCIC rcpon lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This report
does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OR: 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the requester.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file, i.e. "Offline
NCIC Results for Target I ININVDDNYYY HII:NINI:SSI.xls", which provides the dateitime and Agency ORI terminal the target
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide funher details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
Agency ORI Count First
Contact
Last
Contact
Agency ORI
Phone
CBP CYRIL E KING AP INTL
ARRIVALS 30 05/22/2013 05/02/2015
US CUST SERV ENFORCEMENT
SYSTEMS NEWINGTON 145 05/11/2013 05/02/2015
FL DEPT OF LAW ENFORCEMENT
COMMAND CENTER 8 05/29/2013 05/01/2015
NY STATE DIV CRIMINAL JUSTICE
SVCS ALBANY 12 06/12/2013 04/28/2015
DRUG ENFOR ADMIN NEW YORK 5 04/24/2015 04/24/2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 17 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
DHS ICE INVEST RAC ST THOMAS
USVI 1 04/13/2015 04/13/2015
CUSTOMS AND BORDER
PROTECTION 13 05/12/2013 04/03/2015
US CUSTOMS SERVICE ENF
SECURITY NEWINGTON 14 06/02/2013 03/01/2015
DHS ICE INVEST SAC MIAMI 2 02/26/2015 02/26/2015
FBI NOPU 1 12/01/2014 12/01/2014
CUSTOMS AND BORDER
PROTECTION BEDFORD L G 4 10/13/2014 11/30/2014
CBP LOGAN INTERNATIONAL
AIRPORT 3 10/13/2014 11/30/2014
US CUSTOMS SERV AIRPORT
BAGGAGE I&C NEWARK 20 03/12/2014 10/23/2014
CUSTOMS AND BORDER
PROTECTION 2 05/16/2014 10/23/2014
CUSTOMS AND BORDER 15 03/11/2014 10/07/2014 PROTECTION
US SECRET SERV UNIFORM DIV
WASHINGTON 1 08/12/2014 08/12/2014
U S SECRET SERVICE WHITE HOUSE
DIVISION 1 08/12/2014 08/12/2014
CUSTOMS AND BORDER
PROTECTION 6 10/15/2013 05/06/2014
US CUSTOMS SERV INSPECTION
CONTROL CLAYTON 5 04/19/2014 04/20/2014
USC MARCH AFB OFFICE OF
ENFORCEMENT RIVERSIDE 4 06/06/2013 03/27/2014
CBP SEATTLE INTL AIRPORT 5 03/19/2014 03/20/2014
USC SEA-TAC AIRPORT PASS PROC
I&C SEATTLE 1 03/19/2014 03/19/2014
CBSA ASFC HQ IBQ 1 03/17/2014 03/17/2014
DOI U S ATTORNEY GENERALS
OFFICE ST THOMAS 1 01/08/2014 01/08/2014
CUSTOMS AND BORDER
PROTECTION 2 11/27/2013 11/2112013
USC OFF INVESTIGATIONS
LEVITTOWN 3 09/10/2013 11/15/2013
HARVARD UNIVERSITY CAMPUS
POLICE 1 11/06/2013 11/06/2013
CBP MK INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT 3 06/03/2013 10/01/2013
CUSTOMS AND BORDER
PROTECTION 1 09/14/2013 09/14/2013
VIRGIN ISLANDS POLICE
DEPARTMENT 1 06/28/2013 06/28/2013
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 18 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
FEU ClIS DIVISION
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
3 05/14/2013 05/28/2013 I
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CPR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal, tax, or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. Sec 31 U.S.C. 531 I.
The information cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed, or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity, akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage: This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity, filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence. but contain information that. when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may not: I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part or a judicial proceeding, law enforcement personnel MS coordinate thapotential digh)Slat 
With_FilICEN's_Qffigialakier
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies. along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization. disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation, or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force. provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines Jar Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
USAR - Unified Suspicious Activity Report(s)
Analyst's Note: EPSTEIN is a subject of seven USARs. See Attachment I for more infonnation.
UCTR — Unified Currency Transaction Reports)
BSA ID Date of
Transaction
Amount Subject(s)/Persons
Involved in
Transaction
Filing Institution/
Location In Out
31000040594074 01/31/2014 $0 $60,775
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Deutsche Bank Trust
an Com Americas/
New York NY 10154
POC:
31000038320027 12/19/2013 $0 $21,150
31000036626342 11/15/2013 $0 $20,723
Details: FinCEN indicates
account 35266976.
conducted transactions on behalf of EPSTEIN which affected
CTR — Currency Transaction Report(s)
Analyst's Note: See attachment .2 jnr more information.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 19 of 63
Assets
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
rFinancial Account(s)

(P) -  Personal (C) -  Casino (B) -  Business (U) -  Unknown (S) - Securities
Account Owner/
Address
Institution
Name/Address
Account Account Number Type Source
Jeffm EPSTEIN/
Qtr. B3

St. Thomas, Virgin
Islands, U.S. 00802
BNP Paribas/
Paris, 75009 France
P FinCEN BSA ID
i 31000049066241
P FinCEN BSA ID
Jeffm EPSTEIN/
Qtr. B3

St. Thomas, Virgin
Islands, U.S. 00802
Deutsche
i
Bank
Trust Company
Americas/
New
York, NY 10154
U
FinCEN BSA ID
Jeffre EPSTEIN/ Fortis Ban ue/
Paris, 75008 France
P FinCEN BSA ID
Qtr. B3

St. Thomas, Virgin
Islands, U.S. 00802
Jeffm EPSTEIN/
Highbridge Capital
Co ration/
Grand Cayman,
Cayman Islands
BWI
S FinCEN BSA ID
i Qtr. B3

St. Thomas, Virgin
Islands, U.S. 00802
Jeffm EPSTEIN/
Qtr. B3
St. Thomas, Virgin
Islands, U.S. 00802
HSBC Private
Bank SA/
Geneva 3 CH121 1
Switzerland
S FinCEN BSA ID
S FinCEN BSA ID
Jeffm EPSTEIN/
Qtr. B3

St. Thomas, Virgin
Islands, U.S. 00802
HSBC Paris/
p FinCEN BSA ID
20101910292960 Paris, 75015 France
PSTEIN/
Suite 10B
New York, NY 10065
JP Morgan Chase
OM.
New York, NY
U FinCEN BSA ID
, effre EP TEIN/
Qtr. B3

St. Thomas, Virgin
Islands, U.S. 00802
JP Morgan Chase
Mill .
New York, NY
B FinCEN BSA ID
B FinCEN BSA ID
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 20 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Account Owner/
Address
Institution
Name/Address Account Number Account Source
Details: FinCEN indicates
account and
and are additional
and
INC.
si nors for
additional signor for acc nt.
is a business account for FinCEN indicates account
Jeffm EPSTEIN/ Valartis Bank AG/
Zurich 8021
Switzerland
S FinCEN BSA ID
i Qtr. B3
St. Thomas, Virgin
Islands, U.S. 00802
Details: FinCEN indicates is an additional signor for this account.
Family Member/Associate Identifying Information'
Associates
Name Relationship to
Target DOB SSN Source
Associate FinCEN
BSA ID
Details: and Jeffrey EPSTEIN are subjects together in a 2014 USAR. FinCEN indicates
was EPSTEIN's personal assistant and would act as a recruiter and facilitator for EPSTEIN's
illicit activities.
Anal st's Note: name was listed on the DOS NIV application as the sponsor of
(Target 6).
Note: Names indicated with an * (asterisk) will be detailed further.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 21 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 22 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 23 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Offline NCIC rcpon lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This report
does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. Olt 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the rcquestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file, i.c. "Offline
NCIC Results for Target I (nsvunrtYYY HH:MM:SS).xls", which provides the datetime and Agency ORI terminal the target was
queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 24 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal. tax. or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Now - SAR Usage.  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity, filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR infomiation as pan of investigative efforts may not: I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAL or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part or a judicial proceeding, law enforcement personnel must coordinac that_polcmial disclosure with 
FineEtsts Office of Chid
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies. along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization, disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation, or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force, provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines Jar Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 25 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 26 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 27 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 28 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
online NCIC
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Offline NCIC report lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This 
report does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OFC 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the requestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed infommtion is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC 
file, i.e. "Offline
NCIC Results for Target I INIMIDDNYYY HH:NSI:SS).xls", which provides the date: time and Agency ORI terminal the target 
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 29 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal. tax. or regulatory 
investigation or pmcceding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities. including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage:  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity. filed by a 
US. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that. when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may Da I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part or a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate that potential disclosure with 
FinCEN's Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies, along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization. disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation. or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force. provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines fi o. Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 30 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 31 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 32 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
Art Offline NCIC rcpon lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This 
report does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OIC 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the rcquestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file. i.e. -Offline
NCIC Results for Target I INIMIDD(YYYY HH:NIM:SS).xls", which provides the datetime and Agency ORI terminal the target 
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 33 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal, tax, or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities. including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released, disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity. filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may not: I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part or a judicial proceeding, law enforcement personnel mustcoordinate thatpotential disclosure with 
FinCEN's_Dffice of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisor>. personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies, along with FinCEN, 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization, disclose a SAR to 
appmpriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation, or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force, provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines Jar Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 34 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 35 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May IS, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 36 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Ott NCIC report lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This report 
does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. MC 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the requester.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file, i.e. - Offline
NCIC Results for Target I INIMMDFYYYY HELNIM:SS).xls", which provides the dateItime and Agency ()RI terminal the target 
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 37 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May IS, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR ChaNer X. The information is sensitive in
nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal. tax, or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage:  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity, filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may not: I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part of a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate that potential disclosure with 
FinCEN's Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies. along with FinCEN, 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization. disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation. or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force, provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines fi ), Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 38 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 39 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 40 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Offline NCIC report lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This 
report does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OFC 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the rcquestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed infomunion is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC 
file, i.e. "Offline
NCIC Results for Target I (MhUDIWYYTY HH:NINI:SSI.xls", which provides the dateltimc and Agency OR1 terminal the target 
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal, tax, or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding, or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval or the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity, akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 41 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage:  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity, filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs am not evidence. but contain information that. when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as pan of investigative efforts may not: I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as pan or a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate that potential disclosure with 
FinCEN's Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank, or the
contents of such SAL with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies. along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization. disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation, or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are pan of the same joint task force. provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines for Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 42 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 43 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
Art Offline NCIC repon lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This repon
does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OFC 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the rcquestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file. i.c. "Offline
NCIC Results for Target I (MM./DDrf YYY HH:NIM:SS).xls", which provides the datetimc and Agency ORI terminal the target 
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide funhcr details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 44 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May IS, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The atdo..N Illi0C11141011 was collie ted and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR ChaNer X. The information is sensitive in
nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal. tax. or regulatory• 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities. including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Na - SAR tImgr .  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity, filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that. when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may not: I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 21
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part of a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel rougspordinate that potential disclosi ire with 
FinCFN's Offire of f'hir(
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies, along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization. disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation, or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force. provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines fl y Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 45 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 46 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 47 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Offline NCIC report lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This 
report does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OFC 
requests will query NCIC
For the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the rcquestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file, i.c. "Offline
NCIC Results for Target I INSIIDDJYYYY HH:MM:SS).xls", which provides the dateitime and Agency ORI terminal the target 
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 48 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal. tax. or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage'  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity, filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may not: 1) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part of a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate 
that_potentialdisclosure_withifinCENis Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR, with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies. along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization. disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation, or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force, provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines Jar Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 49 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 50 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Offline NCIC rcpon lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This report
does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OFC 
requests will query• NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the requestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Offline NCIC
file, i.e. "Offline
NCIC Results for Target I IMM./DINYYYY HH:NINI:SSI.xls", which provides the dateftime and Agency ORI terminal the target
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific information outlined in the attachment 
to provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 51 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal, tax, or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed, or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage.  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity. filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may nol: I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part of a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate that  potential disclosure with 
FinCEN'cOffire of rhiq
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies. along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN, law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization, disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation. or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are pan of the same joint task force. provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines Jar Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 52 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 53 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 54 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May IS, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 55 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Criminal History/NCIC
Offline NCIC
GUIDANCE NOTE
An Offline NCIC rcpon lists other law enforcement agencies that have previously queried the same individual. This report
does not necessarily
mean the agencies listed on the offline NCIC report have additional documents on that individual. By default. OFC 
requests will query NCIC
for the last 2 years of data unless otherwise requested by the rcquestor.
The table below is a summary by Agency. The detailed information is contained in the corresponding attached Online NCIC 
file. i.c. "Offline
NCIC Results for Target I (MM/DDJYYYY HH:MNI:SS).xls", which provides the dateline and Agency ORI terminal the target 
was queried.
When contacting the appropriate LE agency. the LE agency will need the specific infommtion outlined in the attachment to
provide further details
regarding their initial query.
Offline NCIC inquiries are records where individuals were queried by local, state or federal law
enforcement (LE) agencies at a particular point in time. Offline NCIC checks identify the law
enforcement agencies that have previously queried a target. For example, using Offline NCIC checks can
provide the following insight:

• Knowing what other agencies are inquiring about your target can be a primary de-confliction tool
in bringing various agencies together.
• Pinpointing geographical locations where target previously traveled.
• Discovering target associations based on vehicle stops.
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 56 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only for a purpose consistent with a criminal. tax. or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released. disseminated. disclosed, or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports tiled under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage'  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity. filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as pan of investigative efforts may not I ) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as part or a judicial proceeding, law enforcement personnel must coordinate-thatpotentialdisclosure_with_FinCEN's
Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR film
by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies. along with FinCEN. 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization. disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation. or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are pan of the same joint task force, provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines fl y Bank
Secrecy Art Infinmation (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 57 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15.12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 58 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal. tax, or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released. disseminated, disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity, akin to confidential informant tips. 
Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage:  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity, filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as part of investigative efforts may not: 1) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as pan of a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate that potential disclosure with 
FinCEN's Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies. along with FinCEN, 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization. disclose a SAR 
Inappropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation, or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force. provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines Jar Bank
Secrecy Act Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 59 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 60 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 61 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Financial Information
WARNING
The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. 
Department of the
Treasury regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The information is sensitive 
in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only fora purpose consistent with a criminal. tax. or regulatory 
investigation or proceeding. or
in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities, including analysis. to protect against international 
terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311.
The information cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed, or transmitted without prior approval of the 
Director of Financial Crimes
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be treated with 
particular care given that
they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible criminal activity. akin to confidential infomunt tips. Unauthorized
release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
WARNING
Note - SAR Usage:  This report contains a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) of suspected criminal activity, filed by a 
U.S. financial institution.
SARs arc not evidence, but contain information that, when further investigated. may produce evidence of criminal 
activity. Law enforcement
personnel that use SAR information as pan of investigative efforts may not: 1) Confront a customer of a financial 
institution with a SAR. or 2)
Include a SAR as an attachment to an affidavit or other legal document. If it is anticipated that there may be a need to
disclose the actual SAR
filing as pan or a judicial proceeding. law enforcement personnel must coordinate that potential disclosure with 
FinCEN's Office of Chief
Counsel. The prohibition regarding SAR disclosure does not preclude law enforcement personnel from discussing a SAR 
filed by a bank. or the
contents of such SAR. with Federal bank supervisory personnel. Federal bank supervisory agencies, along with FinCEN, 
promulgated the
regulations requiring banks to report suspicious activity by filing SARs. Accordingly. these agencies have access to 
SARs and have the authority
to provide direction with regard to the handling and disclosure of SARs. Notwithstanding the general prohibition on the 
re-dissemination of a
SAR without the prior approval of FinCEN. law enforcement personnel may. without prior authorization. disclose a SAR to 
appropriate domestic
law enforcement personnel and prosecutors working on the same or a related investigation, or to such domestic law 
enforcement personnel that
are part of the same joint task force, provided the disclosing agency satisfies the conditions set forth in the 
Re-dissemination Guidelines Jar Bank
Secrecy Art Information (November 28. 2007).
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 62 of 63
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
OFC-TP-15-12392
SODOFC-15.12392
Date of Report: May 18, 2015
Requestor:
Prepared by:
SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED
Page 63 of 63
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                 Harlequin Dane LLC [epstein] Epstein company 
                                         Michelle Fern Saipher [lawyer] wife of Darren Indyke 
 Coatue Management [tech] VC fund founded by Philippe Laffont possibly invested in by Epstein 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01266403 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein death bequests of Jeffrey E. Epstein 2014 Trust amendment naming Darren Indyke, David Mitchell, Jes Staley as trustees
(date: 2015-05-20)
AMENDMENT AND RESTATEMENT
OF THE
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 2014 TRUST
THIS AMENDMENT AND RESTATEMENT OF THE JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 2014
TRUST dated May 1, 2015 ("Amendment"), by and among JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, as Grantor
("Grantor"), and DARREN K. INDYKE, JAMES E. STALEY and DAVID MITCHELL, as
Trustees ("Trustees").
The Grantor hereby pays over, assigns, grants, conveys, transfers and delivers to the
Trustees the property described in Schedule A annexed hereto and made a part hereof, to be
administered and disposed of as provided in this Agreement, with any additions, changes, or
amendments to this Agreement.
This Trust shall be known as the "The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2014 Trust"
Article  I During  My Lifetime
The following provisions shall apply during my lifetime:
Section  1.1.- Disbursement of Income
All of the income of the trust (the "Trust Estate") shall be paid to me, or accumulated or
paid as I may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.2.  - Disbursement of Principal
My Trustees may distribute any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate to me as I
may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.3.  - Specific Rights Reserved to Me

A. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to amend this
Agreement, in whole or in part, by a written instrument executed and acknowledged by me and
my Trustees.

B. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, in my sole and
unfettered discretion, to remove any Trustee by delivering to said removed Trustee and my
remaining Trustees a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

C. I reserve the right, at any time, to revoke this Trust in its entirety or any
provision hereof by delivering to my Trustees a written instrument executed and acknowledged
solely by me.

D. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to withdraw or
appoint any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate by delivering to my Trustees a written
instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.
E. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to transfer to my
Trustees, by gift, by Will or by beneficiary designation, such additional property, including life
insurance policies, as I may desire. Any such additional property shall be held on the same terms
as are then applicable to the original Trust Estate, except that it may be transferred subject to
conditions and provisions of special application to such additional property.
Article II  After My Death
The following provisions shall apply after my death:

Section 2.1.  - Payment of My Debts and of Taxes and Expenses
My Trustee shall pay from the principal of the Trust Estate (a) my debts, funeral and
burial expenses and the administration expenses of my probate estate which are not paid by the
Executor of my probate estate, and (b) the federal and state estate, inheritance, succession,
generation skipping and similar taxes imposed by reason of my death which are the obligations
of my Trustees (including any of such taxes which the Executor of my probate estate directs my
Trustees to pay by written direction delivered to my Trustees). For purposes of this Section 2.1,
the principal of the Trust Estate shall not include (a) any assets which are not included in my
Gross Estate or (b) any assets which are not subject to, or available to creditors for the payment
of, my debts, my funeral and burial expenses or the administration expenses of my probate
estate.

Section 2.2.- Specific Bequests or Devises Under My Will and Trust
If my probate estate is insufficient to satisfy all pecuniary bequests (or bequests payable
in cash or in kind in the discretion of the Executor of my probate estate) provided in my Will, my
Trustee shall pay such unpaid bequests from the principal of the Trust Estate. If my Will
provided for a specific bequest or devise of specified assets and such bequest or devise could not
be satisfied from my probate estate because such assets were held by my Trustee at my death, my
Trustee shall distribute such assets to satisfy such bequest or devise.
To the extent the assets of the Trust are insufficient to satisfy all bequests, I direct my
Trustees to pay all specific bequests first, and to the extent assets are insufficient to pay all of the
remaining bequests in Section 2.3(A)(1) through 2.3(A)(1X24), then the beneficiaries of Section
2.3(A)(1) through 2.3(A)(1)(24) shall share on a proportionate basis in the remaining estate
assets available for distribution. The determination of the Trustees as to the amounts distributable
herein shall be binding on all parties.

Section 2.3.- Bequest4

A. I make the following bequests:
1. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED> if she survives me.

2. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED> if she survives me.
3. Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000) to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me.

4. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED> if she survives me.
5. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED> if she survives me.

6. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED> if she survives me.
7. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, if he survives me.

8. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED>, if she survives me.
9. Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to <REDACTED>, if she survives me.

10. One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) to LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF, if she survives me.
11. One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., if he survives me.

12. Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000) to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR.,
and ROSALYN V. FONTANILLA, to be shared equally if they both survive me, or all to the
survivor, if only one of them survives me.

13. Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000) to RICHARD D. KAHN, if he survives
14. Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000) to ANN RODRIGUEZ, if she survives me.

15. Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000) to VALDSON VIERA CONTRIN, if he survives me.
16. Three Hundred Thousand Dollars ($300,000) to <REDACTED> if she survives me.

17. Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) to BELLA KLEIN, if she survives me.
18. Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) to DAVID ROGERS, if he survives me.

19. Sixty Six Thousand Dollars ($66,000) to STEVE CHAVEZ, if he survives me.
20. Forty Thousand Dollars ($40,000) to <REDACTED> if she survives me.

21. Thirty Five Thousand Dollars ($35,000) to CYNTHIA CANO, if she survives me.
22. Forty Two Thousand Dollars ($42,000) to CARLOS DELGADO, if he survives me.

23. I forgive any loans which I made to the following individuals or entities:
a) GADDO CARDINI
b) MARK EPSTEIN

c) LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR.
d) ROSALYN V. FONTANILLA
e) ROBERT GOLD
f) ROBERT GOODMAN
g) EMAD HANNA
h) DARREN KEITH INDYKE

i) DAVID LAMPERT
j) <REDACTED>
k) <REDACTED>
l) ALBERTO PINTO
m) STEVEN VICTOR
n) <REDACTED>
o) LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR.

p) <REDACTED>
q) KARYNA SHULIAK
r) <REDACTED>
s) <REDACTED>
t) <REDACTED>
u) <REDACTED>
v) <REDACTED>
w) SLK DESIGNS, LLC

x) ADAM BLY
y) <REDACTED>
z) <REDACTED>

24. Upon my death, the Trustees of this Trust are directed to distribute to
DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns an amount equal to the sum of
all financial obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation,
limited liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to
my death, including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited
liability company, from DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, MICHELLE FERN
SAIPHER, if she is then married to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation,
limited liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity
beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not
limited to, Harlequin Dane, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, or its successor
entities. Said funds shall be distributed to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs,
successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due
obligations and liabilities.

25. Upon my death, the Trustees of this Trust are directed to distribute to
RICHARD KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns an amount equal to the sum of all
financial obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited
liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my
death, including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited
liability company, from RICHARD KAHN, his spouse, LISA KAHN, if she is then married to
RICHARD KAHN, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership,
general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both of them
immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Coatue Enterprises, LLC, a New
York limited liability company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be distributed to
RICHARD KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to
repay all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities.

26. It is my intention that all amounts due and owing to me by the persons
listed in Article H, Section 2.3.A.23 shall be cancelled upon my death. While at the date of
execution, the cancellation of said loans will not result in taxable income to the beneficiaries,
in the event any changes are made to the applicable tax law, my Trustees are directed to take
5
any and all steps necessary to ensure that the cancellation of such indebtedness does not result
in any negative tax consequences to the beneficiaries.

27. I give to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in all
apartments, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the premises
located in the building known and referred to as 22 Avenue Foch, 75016, Paris, France. The
interest consists of units 47 with mezzanine, 48 and 81 on the 2nd floor, units 63 and 74 on
the 5th floor and units 5 and 22 (cellars) in the basement. The units are currently all owned by
SCI JEP, a French company of which I own 999 of the 1,000 outstanding shares. In addition, I
give to this separate trust for the benefit of CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, the
sum of One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the apartments.
Operating expenses shall include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes,
utilities, general maintenance and repairs and common charges.

28. I give to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in
the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the real
property located at, and known and referred to as, 9 East 71st Street, New York, New
York 10021. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Maple, Inc., a United
States Virgin Islands corporation, which holds legal title to the same. In addition, I give to this
separate trust for the benefit of CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, the sum of Four
Million Dollars ($4,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the property. Operating
expenses shall include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and
general maintenance and repairs.

29. I give to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in
the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to that certain
cay in the United States Virgin Islands known and referred to as Little St. James Island. My
interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Nautilus, Inc., a United States Virgin
Islands corporation, which holds legal title to said cay, the improvements, and fixtures
thereon, and certain permits and rights with respect thereto and which also owns 100% of the
interest of L.S.J., LLC, a Delaware limited liability company that holds certain permits and
rights pertaining to the improvements on said cay. In addition, I give to this separate trust for
the benefit of CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, the sum of Ten Million Dollars
($10,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the cay. Operating expenses shall include,
but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general maintenance
and repairs.

30. I give to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in
the property, leases, rights, permits, improvements and fixtures comprising and pertaining to
Zorro Ranch, located at 49 Zorro Ranch Road, Stanley, New Mexico 87056. My interest
consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Cypress, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands
corporation, which holds legal title to the same. In addition, I give to this separate trust for the
benefit of CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, the sum of Five Million Dollars
6
($5,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the property. Operating expenses shall
include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general
maintenance and repairs.

31. I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all of my interest in
the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the real
property located at, and known and referred to as, 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida.
My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Laurel, Inc., a United States Virgin
Islands corporation, which holds legal title to the same. In addition,  my Trustees are directed
to pay the sum of One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) to KARYNA SHULIAK to pay for the
operating expenses for the property. Operating expenses shall include, but not be limited to,
property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general maintenance and repairs.

Section 2.4.- Balance of Trust Estate
The balance of the Trust Estate, after the distributions provided in Sections 2.1, 2.2 and
2.3 of this Article II, shall be distributed as follows:

A. One Hundred percent (100%) thereof to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in separate trust, the provisions of 
which are set forth in Section 3.2 of Article III
below.

B. If CELINA EDITH DUBIN does not survive me, one hundred percent
thereof to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she survives me.

C. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN does not survive me, one hundred percent
(100%) of the balance of the trust estate shall be transferred to THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES
OF TI-IE MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY (hereinafter "the Board"), an
educational institution. The property compromising this gift may, for investment purposes, be
merged with any of the investment assets of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology ("MIT"),
but the gift shall be entered in the books and records of MIT as an endowed fund known as
"THE JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN FUND" (the "Fund"). The Board shall use the endowment payout
from the Fund to provide financial aid for graduate and undergraduate students attending MIT.
In the event MIT is no longer in existence as of the date of any required distribution to it, my
Trustees are hereby directed to choose among them another educational institution to benefit
from my Trust.
Article III  Trust Provisions

Section 3.1.-  Residence Trusts
Any property directed to be held in trust for a Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions of
this Section 3.1 of Article III shall be administered as follows:

A. The Beneficiary shall have the right to occupy the residence or residences
held by the trust and to use the tangible personal property located in the residence for her
lifetime.
7

B. My Trustees, in my Trustees' sole discretion, may pay any part or all of
the income, and if income is insufficient, the principal of the trust (1) to pay the operating
expenses of the property held by the trust and (2) for any other purpose my Trustees consider
advisable. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal of the trust.

C. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall use my Trustees'
best efforts to sell the trust property and the tangible personal property within two (2) years of
the Beneficiary's death and only in extraordinary circumstances should the property not be sold
within two (2) years of the Beneficiary's death.

D. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall distribute the
remaining principal of the trust (i.e., the proceeds from the sale of the trust assets) to EVA
ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she then survives the Beneficiary. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN
does not survive the Beneficiary, then my Trustees shall distribute the remaining principal to the
Board of MIT as provided for in Section 2.4.0 of this Agreement.

Section 3.2.- Residuary Trusts
Any property directed to be held in trust for a Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions of
this Section 3.2 of Article III shall be distributed as follows:

A. My Trustees may pay any part or all of the income and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of the trust as my Trustees, in my Trustees' discretion, from time
to time and at any time, shall determine for any reason whatsoever to, for the benefit of, or on
behalf of the Beneficiary. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal of the
trust.

B. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall distribute the
remaining principal of the trust to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she then survives the
Beneficiary. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN does not survive the Beneficiary, then my Trustees
shall distribute the remaining principal of the trust to the Board of MIT as provided for in

Section 2.4.0 of this Agreement.

C. •
Article IV  Trust Terminatiou
If at any time my Trustees determines that it is uneconomic to continue any trust with
respect to which my Trustees are acting hereunder, my Trustees may terminate such trust and
distribute the trust assets, in such amounts and proportions as my Trustees may determine, to the
person or persons to whom income may be distributed, other than my Trustees, members of the
respective families of my Trustees, the respective estates of my Trustees, the respective creditors
of my Trustees or the creditors of the respective estates of my Trustees.
8
Article V Trust Administration

Section 5.1. - Exercise  of  Discretionary Powers
Except as hereinbefore specifically provided, in connection with the exercise of a
discretionary power to distribute income or principal to any person, there shall be no requirement
to take into account such person's other income or capital resources, the interest of such person in
any other fund or the duty of anyone to support such person, although these factors may be taken
into account.

Section 5.2.- Discretionary Distributions
Any discretionary payment from any trust hereunder shall be charged against such trust
as a whole, and shall not be charged against the individual share of any person at any time.

Section 5.3.  - Allocation of Assets

A. For each distribution, partial distribution, allocation, or division of assets
into shares or trusts involving a fraction, my Trustees shall apply such fraction to the fair market
value of the relevant assets on the date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever
first occurs. My Trustees shall appropriately adjust such fractions to reflect the effect of any
partial distributions, allocations, or divisions, taking into account the fair market value as of the
date of distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurred, of the assets so distributed,
allocated, or divided.

B. My Trustees shall value any assets distributed, allocated, or divided to
satisfy (in whole or in part) a pecuniary distribution at the fair market value of such assets on the
date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurs.

Section 5.4.  -Accounting Allocations

A. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement and except as
provided in Paragraph B of this Section 5.4, my Trustees shall allocate receipts and
disbursements in accordance with sound trust accounting principles and have discretion to
allocate receipts and disbursements when, in the judgment of my Trustees, the treatment is
uncertain under applicable laws or generally accepted accounting principles.
B. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, my Trustees
shall not treat any part of the principal amount of the proceeds of sale of any asset of any trust as
income distributable to or for the benefit of any beneficiary entitled to distributions of income;
provided, however, that my Trustees shall treat a portion of any proceeds of sale of any financial
instrument originally issued or acquired at a discount equal to the amount which (1) has
previously been characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes or (2) will be
characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes in the year of such sale, as income for
trust accounting purposes.
9
CONFIDENTIAL GI 000383
SDNY_GM:0000B060

Section 5.5.  -Spendthrift Provision
During the term of any trust hereunder, no money or other assets (either principal or
income) payable or distributable under the provisions of this Agreement shall be pledged,
assigned, transferred, given, conveyed, hypothecated, sold, anticipated, charged, or encumbered
by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder, nor shall the income and principal of any trust, while in
the poccecsion of my Trustees, be liable for any debts, contracts, obligations, or undertakings of
such Beneficiaries, voluntary or involuntary, or for any claims or judgments against any
Beneficiary, including claims for alimony or for the support of any Beneficiary's spouse or
children, or for reimbursement of a federal, state or local government, or any agency of any
federal, state, or local government, for the support of any Beneficiary hereunder, prior to the time
such money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary. Any attempted pledge,
assignment, transfer, gift, conveyance, hypothecation, anticipation, charge, or encumbrance of
any money or assets (either income or principal) payable or distributable under the provisions of
this Agreement by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder prior to the time such money or assets are
actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary shall be null and void and shall not be recognized
by my Trustees. This Section 5.5 of Article V shall not apply to me.

Section 5.6.- Limitation on Distribution"
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, no discretionary distribution of
income or principal of any trust hereunder shall be applied to pay for medical care, residential
facilities, or any other care or service that would otherwise be provided for any Beneficiary
hereunder by any federal, state, or other governmental agency; and no such discretionary
distribution of income or principal shall be made for reimbursement for any such care, facilities
or services previously provided. Before making any discretionary payment to or for the benefit
of any such Beneficiary hereunder, my Trustees shall consider the amounts such Beneficiary is
or may be entitled to receive from any governmental agency for such care, facilities, or services.
If such amounts are available, discretionary distributions of income and principal from any trust
hereunder shall be made only to supplement such amounts, and to provide liberally for needs and
comforts over and above the basic maintenance, support, and medical care that may be paid for
by any such agency.

Section 5.7.- Division and Combination of Trusts

A. For any administrative, tax or other purpose determined by my Trustees to
be in the best interests of any Beneficiary (including any remainderman) hereunder, my Trustees
may at any time and from time to time (whether before or after funding), without approval of any
court, divide any trust under this Agreement into two or more separate trusts or combine two or
more trusts with substantially identical terms (whether or not such trusts resulted from division
of a prior trust).

B. If property is directed to be added to any trust hereunder (the "Original
Trust"), whether by the terms of this Agreement any other agreement, or the Will of any person,
my Trustees may hold such property as one or more separate trusts on terms identical to the
terms of the Original Trust. My Trustees may allocate such property among the separate trusts (if
any) into which the Original Trust was divided, whether or not pro-rata, using specific assets or
10
CONFIDENTIAL GJ 0003 84
undivided interests therein (including allocation of all such property to one of such separate
trusts).
C. Any time during the existence of separate trusts created by division of a
trust hereunder, my Trustees may exercise all discretionary powers differently with respect to the
separate trusts and take all other actions consistent with such trusts being separate entities.
Furthermore, the holder of any power of appointment with respect to such separate trusts may
exercise such power differently with respect to each such trust.

Section 5.8.- Consolidation of Trusts
If at any time after my death there is in existence a trust under my Will or any trust
agreement created by me having identical beneficiaries and substantially the same terms as any
trust under this Agreement, my Trustees may terminate the trust hereunder and transfer the assets
thereof to the Trustees of such other trust, to be administered by the Trustees thereof. Different
termination dates under the applicable Rule Against Perpetuities shall not be deemed a difference
in the terms of such trusts, but the portion of the trust representing the transferred assets shall
retain the same termination date as the original trust.

Section 5.9.- Termination of Trusts
Notwithstanding anything herein, any trust created hereunder for any person shall (unless
terminated earlier) terminate upon the day preceding the expiration of the maximum period
permitted under the United States Virgin Islands Rule Against Perpetuities, for the vesting of an
interest in a trust and upon such date the assets of such trust shall be distributed to such person.

Section 5.10.  - Equitable Adjustment
If any of my Trustees decides to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by
this Agreement or by law (including, without limitation, any election available to my Trustee)
and the exercise or nonexercise of such power confers a benefit on one Beneficiary or class of
Beneficiaries hereunder and imposes a detriment upon another Beneficiary or class of
Beneficiaries hereunder, my Trustees shall not attempt to restore the interests of the Beneficiaries
or classes of Beneficiaries to the position otherwise contemplated by this Agreement through
adjustment between income and principal or otherwise.

Section 5.11.  - Lapsed Distribution
Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, a provision for distribution
to an individual who is not surviving at the date such individual otherwise becomes eligible for
such distribution shall lapse notwithstanding any law to the contrary.

Section 5.12.  - Notice
Any notice required hereunder shall be delivered personally or sent by first class or
certified mail addressed to the last known address of the intended recipient.
I I
Section  5.13.  - Termination of Trust
An instrument in writing completely revoking this Agreement shall, without more, upon
delivery to any of my Trustees, completely terminate all of my Trustees' right, title, and interest
to any life insurance proceeds, death benefits, pension, profit sharing, or other retirement benefits
or any other assets otherwise payable to my Trustees.
Article VI  Powers of Trustees

Section 6.1.  - Exercise ofJudgment and Powers
The Trustee of a trust hereunder has the entire care and custody of all assets of such trust.
My Trustees have the power to do everything my Trustees in good faith deem advisable without
necessity of any judicial authorization or approval, even though but for this power it would not
be authorized or appropriate for fiduciaries under any statutory or other rule of law. My Trustees
shall exercise my Trustees' best judgment and discretion for what my Trustees believe to be in
the best interests of such trust and the Beneficiaries of such trust. If more than two Trustees are
empowered as my Trustee to participate in the decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power granted by this Agreement or by law, a majority of such Trustees shall be empowered to
make such decision.

Section 6.2.- Compensation of My Trustee
Each Trustee acting hereunder shall be entitled to annual compensation for services
performed hereunder in the amount of Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) per
year, in addition to any bequest to which they may be entitled under this terms of this Trust. No
other compensation shall be payable to my Trustees hereunder; provided, however, that my
Trustees shall be reimbursed for all reasonable costs, expenses, charges, and liabilities incurred
or paid in connection with acting as Trustee or performing services hereunder, including, but not
limited to, fees and expenses of counsel or any other agents hired by my Trustees, and my
Trustees shall not be liable therefor individually. My Trustees have discretion to pay such
compensation and such reimbursements from trust assets, without obtaining judicial
authorization or approval.

Section 6.3.  -C entral Investment Powers

A. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, my Trustees have the
power with respect to such trust:

I. To enter upon and take possession of the assets of such trust and collect
the income and profits from such assets, and to invest and reinvest such assets in real,
personal, or mixed assets (including the common trust funds of a corporate fiduciary) or in
undivided interests therein without being limited by any present or future investment laws;

2. To retain all or any part of the assets of such trust (without regard to the
proportion that any one asset or class of assets may bear to the whole) in the form in which
such assets were received or acquired by my Trustees;
12
CONFIDENTIAL GI 000386

3. To sell or dispose of, exchange, transfer, invest, or loan all or any part of
the assets of such trust which my Trustees hold, at any time, for such sums or upon such terms
as to payment, security, or otherwise as my Trustees determine, either by public or private
transactions;

4. To buy and sell options, warrants, puts, calls or other rights to purchase or
sell (collectively called "options") relating to any security or securities, regardless of whether
such security or securities are then held by my Trustees, and whether such options are
purchased or sold on a national securities exchange, and to exercise with respect to such
options all powers which an individual owner thereof could exercise, including, without
limitation, the right to allow the same to expire;
5. With respect to oil, natural gas, minerals, and all other natural resources
and rights to and interests therein (together with all equipment pertaining thereto) including,
without limiting the generality of the foregoing, oil and gas royalties, leases, or other oil and
gas interests of any character, whether owned in fee, as lessee, lessor, licensee, concessionaire
or otherwise, or alone or jointly with others as partner, joint tenant, or joint venturer in any
other noncorporate manner, (a) to make oil, gas and mineral leases or subleases; (b) to pay
delay rentals, lease bonuses, royalties, overriding royalties, taxes, assessments, and all other
charges; (c) to sell, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge or otherwise hypothecate any or all of
such rights and interests; (d) to surrender or abandon, with or without consideration, any or all
of such rights and interests; (e) to make farm-out, pooling, and unitization agreements; (f) to
make reservations or impose conditions on the transfer of any such rights or interests; (g) to
employ the most advantageous business form in which properly to exploit such rights and
interests, whether as corporations, partnerships, limited partnerships, mining partnerships,
joint ventures, co- tenancies, or otherwise exploit any and all such rights and interests; (h) to
produce, process, sell or exchange all products recovered through the exploitation of such
rights and interests, and to enter into contracts and agreements for or in respect of the
installation or operation of absorption, reprocessing or other processing plants; (i) to carry any
or all such interests in the name or names of a nominee or nominees; (j) to delegate, to the
extent permitted by law, any or all of the powers set forth herein to the operator of such
property; and (k) to employ personnel, rent office space, buy or lease office equipment,
contract and pay for geological surveys and studies, procure appraisals, and generally to
conduct and engage in any and all activities incident to the foregoing powers, with full power
to borrow and pledge in order to finance such activities; together with the power to allocate
between principal and income any net proceeds received as consideration, whether as royalties
or otherwise, for the permanent severance from lands of oil, natural gas, minerals, and all
other natural resources;

6. To hold all or any part of the assets of such trust in cash or in bank
accounts without the necessity of investing the same; of such trust;

7. To improve, repair, partition, plat, or subdivide all or any part of the assets
of such trust;
13
8. To litigate, defend, compromise, settle, abandon, or submit to mediation
or arbitration on such terms and conditions as my Trustees determine any claims in favor of or
against such trust or the assets of such trust;

9. To loan or borrow money in such amounts and upon such terms and
conditions as my Trustees determine, assume such obligations or give such guarantees as my
Trustees determine, for the purpose of the acquisition, improvement, protection, retention, or
preservation of the assets of such trust, or for the benefit of any of the Beneficiaries who are
entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust;

10. To create or invest in any entity with all or part of the assets of such trust
and to carry on for as long and in such manner as my Trustees determine any business
enterprise held or created by my Trustees or in which I owned any interest at my death, either
individually or as a partner, joint venturer, stockholder, trust beneficiary, or member; to sell
such business enterprise as an ongoing business; to consolidate, merge, encumber, dissolve,
liquidate or undertake any other extraordinary corporate transaction relating to such business
enterprise;

11. To vote in person or by proxy any and all stock or securities and to
become a party to any voting trusts, reorganization, consolidation, or other capital or debt
readjustment of any corporation, association, partnership, limited liability partnership, limited
liability company, or individual with respect to stocks, securities, or debts held by such trust;

12. Except as provided in Sections 6.3B, C, and D of this Article VI, to enter
into any good faith transactions with my Trustees individually or with any corporation,
partnership, limited liability partnership, limited liability company, or other entity in which
any of my Trustees has an ownership interest;

13. To purchase from my estate any stocks, bonds, securities, real or personal
property, or other assets, or make loans to my estate even though the same person or persons
occupy the office of my Trustees and the office of the Executor of my estate;

14. To lease, mortgage, pledge, grant a security interest in, or otherwise
encumber all or any part of the assets of such trust for any term of years whether or not
beyond the term of such trust (including, without limitation, any such action for the benefit of
any of the beneficiaries of such trust);

15. To abandon any property of such trust, real or personal, which my
Trustees may deem worthless or not of sufficient value to warrant keeping or protecting; to
abstain from the payment of taxes, water rents or assessments and to forego making repairs,
maintaining or keeping up any such property; and to permit such property to be lost by tax
sale or other proceedings or to convey any such property for a nominal consideration or
without consideration so as to prevent the imposition of any liability by reason of the
continued ownership thereof;

16. To elect the mode of distribution of the proceeds from any profit-sharing
plan, pension plan, employee benefit plan, individual retirement plan, insurance contract, or
14
annuity contract pursuant to the terms of such plan or to change to another custodian of such
plan;

17. To conduct any audit, assessment, or investigation with respect to any
asset of such trust regarding compliance with any law or regulation having as its object
protection of public health, natural resources, or the environment (referred to as
"Environmental Laws"); to pay from the assets of such trust to remedy any failure to comply
with any Environmental Law (even to the exhaustion of all of the assets of such trust); and, as
may be required in my Trustee's judgment by any Environmental Law, to notify any
governmental authority of any past, present, or future non-compliance with any
Environmental Law; and

18. To refuse to accept any asset distributable to such trust.
B. No Trustee shall directly or indirectly buy or sell any property for the trust
from or to himself, or from or to his relative, employer, employee, partner or other business
associate.

C. No Trustee shall as trustee of one trust sell property to himself as trustee
of another trust.
D. No Trustee shall lend trust funds to himself, or to his relative, employer,
employee, partner, or other business associate.

Section 6.4.- Administrative Powers
Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, my Trustees have the power with
respect to each trust:

A. To employ agents, attorneys-at-law, consultants, investment advisers (to
whom my Trustees have discretion to delegate my Trustees' investment authority and
responsibility), other trustees and other fiduciaries in the administration of my Trustees' duties, to
delegate to such persons, or to one or more of my Trustees, the custody, control, or management
of any part of the assets of such trust as my Trustees determine and to pay for such services from
the assets of such trust, without obtaining judicial authorization or approval;

B. To delegate, in whole or in part, to any person or persons the authority and
power to (1) sign checks, drafts or orders for the payment or withdrawal of funds, securities and
other assets from any bank, brokerage, custody or other account in which funds, securities or
other assets of such trust shall be deposited, (2) endorse for sale, transfer or delivery, or sell,
transfer or deliver, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any and all property, stocks, stock warrants,
stock rights, options, bonds or other securities whatsoever, (3) gain access to any safe deposit
box or boxes in which assets of such trust may be located or which may be in the name of any of
my Trustees and remove part or all of the contents of any such safe deposit box or boxes and
release and surrender the same, and (4) take any other action that my Trustee may have the
power to take with respect to such trust and the property thereof; no person or corporation acting
15
in reliance on any such delegation shall be charged with notice of any revocation or change of
such delegation unless such person or corporation receives actual notice thereof;

C. To pay any property distributable to a Beneficiary under a legal disability
or who has not attained the age of 21, without liability to my Trustees, by paying such property

(1) to such Beneficiary, (2) for the use of such Beneficiary, (3) to a legal representative of such
Beneficiary appointed by a court or if none, to a relative for the use of such Beneficiary, or (4) to
a custodian for such Beneficiary designated by my Trustees, to hold until age 21 or such earlier
age as shall be the maximum permitted under applicable law;

D. To divide such trust into subsidiary accounts if my Trustees determine that
such division is necessary to maintain fair and accurate records;

E. To permit the Beneficiary of such trust to use, possess, and enjoy real
property, tangible personal property, or club memberships held by such trust;

F. To distribute to such trust or any of the Beneficiaries of such trust in kind
or in cash, or partly in kind and partly in cash, and to allocate different kinds or disproportionate
shares of assets or undivided interests in assets among all of such trusts or all of such
Beneficiaries;

G. In making the division into one or more trusts hereunder (if such trusts
have the same Trustees), to keep the assets of such trusts invested and handled as a single fund
without actual division and to designate such trusts on my Trustees' books as owning a
designated undivided interest in such fund;

H. To have evidence of ownership of any security maintained in the records
of a Federal Reserve Bank under the Federal Reserve Book Entry System; to deposit funds in
any bank or trust company; to carry in the name of any of my Trustees or the nominee or
nominees of the Trustees and with or without designation of fiduciary capacity, or to hold in
bearer form, securities or other property requiring or permitting of registration; and to cause any
securities to be held by a depository corporation of which a Trustee is a member or by an agent
under a safekeeping contract; provided, however, that the books and records of my Trustees shall
at all times show that such investments are part of such trust;

I. To register or not register such trust with the probate division of the
Superior Court of the United States Virgin Islands or otherwise and to make all decisions which
relate thereto;

J. To give any Beneficiary of any trust hereunder a general power of
appointment exercisable in such Beneficiary's Will over all or part of such trust, subject to any
terms and conditions as my Trustees determine, by written notice to such Beneficiary; to
eliminate any such power of appointment by written notice to the Beneficiary; and to irrevocably
release the power under this paragraph to give a power of appointment or to eliminate a power of
appointment;

K. To renounce and disclaim, in whole or in part, and in accordance with
applicable law, any assets, interests, rights, or powers (including any power of appointment)
16
which are payable to (or exercisable by) such trust or over which my Trustees have any right,
title, interest, or power; and

L. To make, execute, and deliver any and all such instruments in writing as
shall be necessary or proper to carry out any power, right, duty, or obligation of my Trustees or
any disposition whatsoever of such trust or any asset of such trust and to exercise any and all
other powers incidental or necessary to carry out or to fulfill the terms, provisions and purposes
of such trust.

Section 6.5.- Restrictions on Exercise of My Trustee's Powerg

A. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, a
Trustee shall not participate in a discretionary decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power to (1) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder to himself or herself; or

(2) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder for the health, support,
maintenance or education of a Beneficiary if such Trustee has a legal obligation to provide for
the health, support, maintenance or education of such Beneficiary from such Trustee's personal
assets. For purposes of this paragraph, a person whose interest in a trust hereunder is limited to a
remote contingent interest (for example, a contingent remainderman whose interest depends
upon another person failing to survive to a specified age or a person designated to receive assets
only in the event a power of appointment is not exercised) shall not be treated as a person who is
or may be a Beneficiary of such trust.

B. A Trustee of any trust hereunder may by a written notice delivered to the
other Trustee (or Trustees) of such trust decline to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law.
C. If a Trustee of any trust hereunder is not empowered (because of a conflict
of interest, declination to act or otherwise) to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, then the remaining Trustee or
Trustees of such trust shall be empowered to make such decision. If no Trustee or successor
Trustee is empowered to participate in such decision, my Trustees may designate a substitute
Trustee to serve as Trustee of such trust who shall be empowered to make such decision but has
no other power or authority of the Trustees. Such designation shall be by written notice delivered
to such substitute Trustee.
Article VII  Provisions Concerning Trustees

Section 7.1.  -Successor Trustees
In the event a Trustee resigns, is removed, becomes incapacitated or is unwilling or is
unable to serve, EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN shall be appointed the successor trustee. In the
event that any additional Trustees are removed, become incapacitated, or are unwilling or unable
to serve, STEVEN HANSON shall first be appointed to fill any vacancy, followed by JOSEPH
PAGANO, such that the total number of Trustees acting on behalf of the Trust at all times shall
be three.
17
CONFIDENTIAL GJ 00039 1

Section 7.2.  - Appointment of Trustee
The appointment of a successor Trustee hereunder shall become effective when such
successor Trustee signs an acceptance of the trust.

Section 7.3.  — Resignation of Trustees
Any Trustee may resign at any time, without the approval of any court, by an instrument
in writing filed with the trust records. In addition, if there is filed with the trust records a written
certification from any attending physician of any individual Trustee of a trust that he or she is no
longer able to make decisions with respect to such trust, then from the date of filing of such
certification, such individual Trustee shall be deemed to have resigned for all purposes of this
Agreement.

Section 7.4.  - Vacancy in Office
If there is a vacancy in the Trustees and no successor Trustee is designated pursuant to

Section 7.1 who is willing to act, the legally competent adult Beneficiary (or a majority in
beneficial interest of the legally competent adult Beneficiaries if there are multiple Beneficiaries)
then entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust shall designate a successor Trustee
by an instrument in writing delivered to the designated Trustee. If the legally competent adult
Beneficiaries do not designate a successor Trustee within sixty days after receipt of notice of
such vacancy or if there is no legally competent adult Beneficiary of such trust, my Trustees
shall designate a successor Trustee by written notice delivered to the designated Trustee and each
adult beneficiary then entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust. If no successor
Trustee is designated pursuant to this Section 7.4, then a successor Trustee shall be named by
order of a court of competent jurisdiction. All of the fees and expenses of my Trustees (including
attorneys' fees) attributable to the appointment of a successor Trustee of a trust shall be paid
from the assets of such trust.

Section 7.5.  - Elimination of Bond
No bond or other security shall be required of any Trustee hereunder in any jurisdiction.

Section 7.6.  - Exculpation and Indemnification of My Trustee
No one serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be accountable or
responsible to any person interested in any trust hereunder for the manner in which my Trustees
shall in good faith exercise any discretionary authority or any power of my Trustees. No one
serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be liable for any loss or
depreciation in value occasioned by reason of any negligence, error or mistake of judgment in
entering into any transaction, in making any sale or investment, in continuing to hold any
property, or by reason of any action or omission, whether by my Trustees or any other fiduciary,
unless such Trustee has acted in bad faith. In the absence of proof by affirmative evidence to the
contrary, each Trustee shall be deemed to have acted within the scope of my Trustees' authority,
to have exercised reasonable care, diligence, and prudence and to have acted impartially as to all
interested persons. A Trustee shall not be liable for the acts or defaults of another Trustee.
18
In the event a legal action is brought against any individual serving as the Trustee of any
trust under this Agreement, all legal fees and related expenses incurred in connection with the
defense of such legal action shall be paid by such trust without court authorization; provided,
however, that (a) no such payment shall (or shall continue to) be made if a court enters an order
prohibiting such payment, and (b) such Trustee shall refund to the trust any such payments that
previously had been made if a court enters an order directing that such payments be refunded, or
if a court concludes that such Trustee acted in bad faith.

Section 7.7.- Relief from Virein Islands Statutory Provisions
Pursuant to Section 1212, Title 15, of the Virgin Islands Code, I hereby relieve my
Trustees and any Successor Trustees of the requirements imposed by Chapter 59, Title 15 of the
Virgin Islands Code, or any similar successor law respecting public filings of inventories and
accountings by Trustees. Furthermore, pursuant to Section 1107, Title 15, of the Virgin Islands
Code, I hereby relieve the my Trustees and any Successor Trustees, to the extent allowable, from
any all duties, restrictions, and liabilities which would otherwise be imposed upon my Trustees
by Chapter 57, Title 15, Virgin Islands Code. This Section 8.7 shall not be deemed a waiver of
any and all other rights, powers, or restrictions otherwise granted to my Trustees in this
Agreement.
Article VIII  Miscellaneous Provisions

Section 8.1.- Representation of Person Under a Disability
To the extent allowed by law, where a party to any proceeding with respect to any trust
hereunder has the same interest as a person under a disability, legal process shall not be required
on the person under a disability.

Section 8.2.- Simultaneous Deaths
If a Beneficiary under thismAgreement and I die simultaneously or under such
circumstances that it is difficult to determine who died first, then for all purposes of this
Agreement such Beneficiary shall be deemed to have predeceased me.

Section 8.3.- Law Governing
This Agreement and each trust created by it shall in all respects and for all purposes be
governed and regulated by the laws of the Territory of the United States Virgin Islands, as they
now exist and may from time to time be enacted, amended, or repealed. All questions regarding
the validity, construction and administration of this Agreement, or any of its provisions, and of
any trust created by it shall be determined solely by the laws of that Territory. The courts of the
State of Delaware and the U.S. Virgin Islands shall have primary supervision over the
administration of each trust created by this Agreement. It is intended that each such trust shall be
a U.S. domestic trust as defined in Title 26 section 7701(aX30) of the Code by virtue of meeting
the court and control test. As provided in Treas. Reg. section 301.7701-7(c)(4)(D), if both a
United States court and a foreign court are able to exercise primary supervision over the
administration of the trust, the trust meets the court test.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, my Trustees of each trust
created under this Agreement have discretion at any time or times following my death to transfer
the situs of such trust to such other country, or such other jurisdiction as my Trustees determine,
without obtaining judicial authorization or approval (unless such judicial authorization or
approval is required by applicable law) and without the filing of any bond. My Trustees'
determination to transfer the situs of any trust under this Agreement shall be evidenced by an
instrument in writing signed, witnessed and acknowledged by my Trustees in the same manner
as would be required for a deed. My Trustees are authorized to take whatever actions are
necessary to effect such a transfer of situs. If judicial authorization or approval is required to
effect such a transfer of situs, I intend and desire that the appropriate court accept the
determination of my Trustees concerning the transfer of the situs of such trust even if one or
more Beneficiaries disagree with such determination. From and after my Trustees' transfer of the
situs of a trust pursuant to this Section 8.3 of Article VIII, the administration of such trust shall
be governed by the law of the new situs of such trust.

Section 8.4.- Definition of Terms
Except as otherwise specifically provided herein, as used in this Agreement,

A. The term "Trustee" means all persons or entities who occupy the office of
Trustee of any trust hereunder while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or
more persons or entities occupy the office of Trustee at the same time or times, and includes any
successor Trustee or Trustees. The term "Executor" of a person's estate means all persons or
entities who occupy the office of personal representative, administrator, executor, or ancillary
administrator while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more persons or
entities occupy such office at the same time or times, and includes any successor or successors to
that office. A reference to a person's Will means such person's Last Will and Testament and any
Codicil or Codicils thereto.

B. A reference to any tax also includes any interest or penalties thereon. The
term "my Gross Estate" means my gross estate as finally determined for purposes of computing
my federal estate tax.

C. Whenever the singular number is used, the same shall include the plural,
and the masculine gender shall include the feminine and neuter genders.

Section 8.5. -No Contest
If any Beneficiary under this Agreement shall in any way directly or indirectly (a) contest
or object to the probate of my Will or to the validity of any disposition or provision of my Will
or of this Agreement or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or indirectly
instrumental in the institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest, objection or
claim for the purpose of setting aside or invalidating my Will or this Agreement or any
20
disposition therein or herein or provision thereof or hereof, then I direct that (aa) any and all provisions in this 
Agreement for such Beneficiary and his
issue in any degree shall be null and void and (bb) my estate, whether passing under my Will or this Agreement or 
pursuant to the laws of intestacy, shall be
disposed of as if such Beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all failed to survive me.

Section 8.6. - Trustee Notice
My Trustees may have duties and responsibilities in addition to those described in this Agreement. If my Trustees have 
questions, my Trustees should obtain
legal advice.
CONCLUSION
I have duly executed this Amended and Restated Trust Agreement on the date set opposite my signature.
David Mite ell, Trustee
Date
Date
Date
CIS
it/405
Date- I) c 2. 1 7. IS
11
TERRITORY OF THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
) ss:
DISTRICT OF ST. THOMAS & ST. JOHN
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this r e day of NAY , 2015 by JEFFREY E.
EPSTEIN, the Grantor, who is personally known to me or who has produced   as
identification.
Sworn to before me this
day of May, 2015.
Notary Public
Erika A. Kellerhals
Notary Public LNP-11-14
Commission Expires 05/29/18

St. Thomas/St. John, USVI
22
STATE OF NEW YORK )
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me thisl4 lh day of  al°
2015, by DARREN K. INDYKE, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this
VA"' day of  IC(\ (.A
2015.
q4Ctlyk) Nctuct Notary Public
STATE OF )
)ss:
COUNTY OF NaA\1O<'(--)
IMBIBE AVOIU
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE Of NEW YORK

No. 01AV6313116
Qualified in RIChMend Cot"
My Commission Evokes nmnbet
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me thtsl way of  MCI  2015, by
JAMES E. STACEY, a Trustee, who is personally known to me who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this
11;11 day of j20,CkH, 2015.
Notary Public
IMBIBE AVOW
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK

No. 01AV6313116
Qualified in Richmond County
My comminion Expires Oclobat II. 2018
23
SONY_GM_00008074
STATE OF iJeuyty k. )
)ss:
COUNTY OF NIEWID(C. )
4h The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me thi lay of
DAVID MITCHELL, a Trustee, who is personally known to
as identification.
Sworn to before me this
&12 -1 day of  M(11 , 2015.
Notary Public
RABIN AVDIU
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE Of NEW YORK

No. 01AV6313116
Qualified In Richmond County
My Commission Expires October 14, 2018
24
(Yri
me Li  ot
CONFIDENTIAL
, 2015, by
who has produced
GJ 000398
SOW GM:00008075
╔═══════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Skip Rimer [finance] Michael Milken's Milken Institute 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00006055 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2015-05-29)
Vision
Justice for all crime victims.
Mission Statement
With compassion and respect,
we assist victims of sexual
evil- et, domestic violence,
homicide, and other violent
crimes through crisis response,
advocacy, therapy, and
community awareness.
Palm Beach County
Victim Services
is a Certified Rape Crisis Center
that provides therapy services to
all crime victims in Palm Beach
County regardless of the victims'
race, sex, color, religion, national
origin, disability, sexual
orientation, marital status,
familial status or gender identity
or expression.
Start by Believing:
Start by r  A Public Awareness
Believing Campaign to
Change the Way
We Respond to Sexual Violence in Our
Community... one response at a time.
YOUR REACTION
MAKES THE DIFFERENCE.
When someone tells you they've
been raped. there's a simple response.
Start by Believing.
kilo.
it . tr.;
county
Safety .Department
jiiiedin Services Division
wwwpbcgov.com/publitsafety/victimSeeVicett
24/7 SEXUAL ASSAULT
VIOLENT CRIME HELPLINE
HELPLINE: (561 -8$3`7273
TOLL FREE: (866) 891.7273
1:.N Eoi rehouse
-'205 45itil Utile Hwy , Suite 5.1109
West Palm Beach. FL 33401

(561) 355-2418 option 3
TTY: (561) 233-2595
Victim Services SART Center
42113 North Australian Ave.
Vilest Palm Beach. FL 33407
(561)625.2568 option 1 •
TIT (561) 6244520
Noith County Courthouse
3188 PGA Blvd.. Suite 1436
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410:

(561) 355-2418 option 3 '
(561) 624.6643
South County Courthouse
200. West lykraje Ave., Suitt E-301
DenyW4aeh.

(50) 274:1500
ITV: (561) 274-1015
es" West County-Glades Courthouse
2976 $tate n&d 15. 2nd Floor
Belle Glade, FL 33430
(561) 996-4871
ITV; (561)992-1113.._ -.-
--Like Us on przvictimsgrytces Sart-gifts are funded through Palm Beachtounty Board of
County Cornthissioners with grants fronithe OKI& of the -
AttorpeyGeneral and Honda Council Against Sexual Violence;;.,-.
-0, Palm tescItCounly
N
Palm Beach ti • '.
'Public Saki< Denali Intent
iclim Sci viucs Di% is io
Sewing Victims of Violent Crimes
1
Have You Been ,.
A Victim Of A Crime?
Do' Thu Experience
Any Of The Following?
* Inability to fall orstay asleep?
* Feeling anxious or depressed?
* Having outbursts of anger?
* Inability to concentrate?
* reeling emotionally numb?
* Loss of interest in the things you used to enjoy?
* Painful memories of the traumatic event?
* Bad dreams about the traumatic event?
* fl ashbacks or a sense of reliving the events?
* Racing thoughts?
* Physiological stress response to reminders of the
event? (pounding heart, rapid breathing, nausea,
muscle tension, sweating)
Palm Beach County provides equality of services and
care to everyone, regardless of people's age, disability.
gender. gender identity, race, religion or belief or
sexual orientation.
Free services include individual therapy
for children and adults and adult -support
groups.
If you are a crime victim or have been
a victim of crime in the past and are
considering therapy, we welcome your coll.
Therapists are available for appointments
Monday through Friday, excluding legal
holidays.
Therapists Will Help You:
O Identify trauma reactions
O Explore the impact that trauma has on your daily life
O Reduce the intensity of negative emotional
responses and symptoms
O Learn about common trauma reactions and
phases in healing
O Feel hopeful and positive regarding the future
O Develop coping mechanisms to utilize when
thinking or talking about the crime
O Experience a reduction of trauma symptoms
O Return to work or school
O Explore the impact on current and future
relationships
erapy For
Children & Teenagers
O Assessment and treatment for child victims
of crime
O Therapeutic interventions that teach
child safety
•
.0 Play Therapy
.0 Assistance for parents during this
difficult time
Signs Of lPauma In Children
O Sadness: The child may feel despondent or
hopeless The child may cry easily or withdraw/
isolate from others.
O Loss of interest in activities: The child may
complain of feeling "bored" or reject offers to
participate in activities they have previously
enjoyed.
O Anxiety: The child may become anxious and,
tense, and feel panic.
O Turmoil: The child may feel worried and
irritable. The child may lash out in anger
resulting from the distress he/she is feeling.
O Regression: The child may revert to acting
like a baby. bedwetting, clinging and
demanding extra care.
Vision
Justice for all crime victims.
Mission Statement
With compassion and respect, we assist
victims of sexual assault, domestic violence,
homicide, and other violent crimes through
crisis response, advocacy, therapy, and
community awareness.
Florida Statute 960 Provides
Guidelines For Fair lFeatment
& Specific Rights For Victims
In The Criminal Justice System
Some of these include the following:
O Office of Attorney General Crime Victim
Compensation, when applicable;
O lb be informed, present, and heard, when
relevant at all crucial stages of criminal or
juvenile proceedings, to the extent that right
does not interfere with the Constitutional
rights of the accused;
0 lb be provided information concerning
services available including Victim
Compensation, community treatment
pnagrams, crisis intervention services,
counseling and social services;
0 lb a prompt and timely disposition of the case.
to the extent that this right does not interfere
with the Constitutional rights of the accused;
0- lb have your property returned to you as soon
as possible after the investigation and/or
prosecution is completed, unless there is a
compelling reason for its retention;
O Have a Victim Advocate present during
depositions of the victim;
0 Request, for specific crimes, an exemption
prohibiting the disclosure of information to
the public which reveals your identification.
Palm Beach County
Public Safety Department
Victim Services Division
www.pbcgov.comipublicsafety/victimservices
24/7 SEXUAL ASSAULT
VIOLENT CRIME HELPLINE
HELPLINE: (561) 833.7273
TOLL FREE: (866) 891.7273
Main Courthouse
205 North Dixie Hwy., Suite 5.1100
West Palm Beach, FL 33401

(561) 355-2418 option 3
TTY: (561) 233.2595
Victim Services SART Center
4210 North Australian Ave.
West Palm Beach, FL 33407

(561) 625.2568 option 1
TTY: (561) 624.6520
North County Courthouse
3188 PGA Blvd., Suite 1436
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410

(561) 355-2418 option 3
TTY: (561) 624.6643
South County Courthouse
200 West Atlantic Ave., Suite 1E-301
Delray Beach. FL 33444

(561) 274.1500
TTY: (561) 274-1015
West County -Glades Courthouse
2976 State Road 15. 2nd Floor
Belle Glade, FL 33430

(561) 996.4871
TTY: (561) 992-1113
Services are provided to all crime victims in Palm Beach
County regardless of the victims' race, sex. color, religion.
national origin, disability, age, sexual orientation. marital
status, or gender identity or expression.
Services are funded through Palm Beach County Board of
County Commissioners with grants from the Office of the
Attorney General and Florida Council Against Sexual Violence.
Palm Beach County
Board of County Commissioners
N May 2015
like Us on
PISCVIcUrrtServices
Palm Beach County
Public Safety Department
Victim Services Division
Victim Services
& Certified
Rape Crisis Center Serving Victims of Violent Crimes
Sexual Assault Domestic Assault Services Provided
Professional butting and community
presentations are also available.
O. Information about Victims' rights
4. 24-hour crisis response to hospitals, law
enforcement agencies and crime scenes
0 Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner (SANE) and a
Forensic Exam site ti The Butterfly House
4 Sexual Assault Response Team (SART)
to provide Victim -centered assistance
-4 Criminal Justice advocacy and
court accompaniment
4 Assistance with filing State Crime
Victim Compensation applications and
Restraining Orders
O Individual therapy and support groups
0 Information and referral to community
resources, including shelters and Legal Aid
Palm Beach County provides equality of services and
care to everyone, regardless of people's age, disability.
gender, gender identity, race, religion or belief or
sexual orientation.
Sexual Assault is a violent crime including rape,
incest, sexual harassment or any other sexual
contact without consent.
Per Florida Statute 90.5035. a victim of sexual
violence who consults a sexual assault counselor at
a rape crisis center has the right to confidentiality of
information shared with the counselor.
No one except the victim can compel the sexual
assault counselor to reveal information about their
communications. Only the victim can waive the
privilege, and this must be done in writing.
If rape victims are not sure whether to report to law
enforcement, victim advocates will assist them
through their decisionmaking process, respecting
whatever choices are made.
Certified Rape Crisis Victim Advocates
Will Provide:
4 Crisis Intervention and Personal Advocacy
Accompaniment during forensic rape exams at
The Butterfly House and other medical facilities
0 Coordination of follow-up medical care, therapy
and referrals
4 Criminal Justice advocacy and court accompaniment
Start by MS,
Believing
Start by Believing: A Public
Awareness Campaign to Change
the Way We Respond to Sexual
Violence in Our Community...
one response at a time.
YOUR REACTION MAKES THE DIFFERENCE.
When someone tells you they've been raped. there's a
simple response. Start by Believing.
Domestic Assault involves power and control
tactics such as physical violence. emotional abuse,
sexual violence, economic abuse, and isolation.
Victim Advocates Will Provide:
Crisis Intervention
4 Safety Planning
0 Assistance with filing Restraining Orders
0 Safe-Shelter Referrals
4 Personal and legal advocacy during
criminal justice proceedings
Homicide and
Other Violent Crimes
Homicide and other violent crimes shatter the
lives of injured victims and survivors causing
severe emotional trauma and grief.
Victim Advocates Will Provide:
4 Crisis Intervention and emotional support
for victims and surviving family members
0 Assistance with filing crime victim
compensation for medical expenses.
funeral costs and loss of support
4 Court Accompaniment
4 Referrals for individual therapy, support
groups and community assistance
Help is Available
Victims of sexual crimes need
compassion, sensitivity and empathy.
Being the victim of a crime can be
overwhelming. Your reactions are normal.
Local certified rape crisis centers have
advocates who are there to help all
victims, regardless of whether or not
they report to law enforcement.
Services are free and confidential —
certified rape crisis centers are legally
and ethically required to protect your
confidentiality, unless you allow, in
writing, the release of your information.
Advocates are available to:

• Provide crisis intervention
• Speak to you on the 24-hour hotline
• Discuss your options
• Navigate available resources

• Go with you to appointments
• Address safety concerns
• Advocate on your behalf
• Help you apply for victim compensation
Sexual Battery is a Crime!
In Florida, the legal term for rape or
sexual assault is sexual battery (F.S.
794.011). Sexual battery means oral,
anal, or vaginal penetration by, or union
with, the sexual organ of another or the
anal or vaginal penetration of another by
any other object, committed without your
consent.
Consent means Intelligent, knowing,
and voluntary consent and does not
include coerced submission. Failure to
offer physical resistance to the
offender does not imply consent.
A person under 16 years of age
cannot legally consent to sex. Also, a
person 24 years of age or older or a
person in a familial or custodial
position of authority cannot receive
consent from 16 and 17 year old
minors.
Forensic Exam
What is a forensic exam?
The forensic exam is a head-to-toe exam to collect
evidence and check for injuries after a sexual crime.
What are my rights with regard to the
exam?

• Stop the exam at any time
• Have an advocate from a rape crisis center with
you
• Be informed about the status of the kit during
processing
What evidence is collected?
During the exam, the medical professional may collect
blood, urine, saliva, pubic hair combings and/or nail
samples. They may also collect items of your clothing.
They will ask you questions about the crime and your
medical history in order to help them collect evidence.
What happens to the evidence?
If you make a report to law enforcement, your kit will
be sent to the regional or statewide lab within 30
days for testing. The lab is required to process the kit
within 120 days.
If you don't report the crime to law enforcement at
the time you obtain the exam, your kit will be stored
anonymously. Your kit may be stored for only a
limited time, depending on your community's storage
space. The local rape crisis center can advise you
about the storage timelines in your community.
You have the right to:

• Obtain a forensic exam whether or not you report
to law enforcement
• Have an advocate at the forensic exam with you

• Have the forensic exam sent for testing within 30
days, if reported to law enforcement
• Review the law enforcement report prior to final
submission

• Be informed, present, and be heard at all crucial
stages of the criminal or juvenile proceeding
• Have an advocate with you during a discovery
deposition

• Have identifying information about the criminal
investigation kept confidential
• Have the offender, if charged, tested for HIV and
hepatitis

• Attend sentencing or disposition of the offender
• Notification of judicial proceedings and scheduling
changes

• Notification about the release of incarcerated
offender
• Request restitution
• Give a victim impact statement

• Not be subjected to a polygraph
• Take up to 3 days of leave from work (with eligible
employer)
• Apply for an injunction if you fear for your safety or
offender is nearing release
Victim Compensation
You may be eligible for
financial assistance for:
• Medical Care
• Lost Income
• Mental health services
• Relocation
• Other expenses related to injuries as a result
of the crime
Contact your local certified rape
crisis center for more information.
This project was supported by Grant
No. 2015-WL-AX-0037 awarded by
the Office on Violence Against Women,
U.S. Department of Justice. The
opinions, findings, conclusions, and
recommendations expressed in this
publication are those of the author(s)
and do not necessarily reflect the views
of the Department of Justice, Office on
Violence Against Women.
Resources
Florida Council Against Sexual Violence
1-888.956-7273
www.fcasv.org
Victim Compensation
1-800-226-6667
www.myfloridalegal.com
Florida Department of Law Enforcement
Sexual Offender/ Predator Unit
1-888-357-7332; 1-850.410.8572
For TTY Accessibility: 1-877-414-7234
E-mail: sexpred@fdle.state.fl.us
Florida Department of Corrections
Victim Information and Notification Everyday
(VINE)
1-877 -VINE-4-FL
www.dc.state.fLus/othivictasst/index.html
Florida Abuse Hotline
1-800-962-2873
Local Rape Crisis Center
Palm Beach County Victim Services
& Certified Rape Crisis Center
Victim Services SART Center
4210 North Australian Avenue
West Palm Beach, FL 33407
Office: 561-625-2568
Helpline: 866-891-RAPE (7273)
www.pbcgov.com/publicsafety/
victimservices
AWN 2ol . 40:0
Center for Trauma Counseling Where Your Emotional Healing Can Begin
A non-profit Community Counseling Center
Serving Palm Beach County and beyond
Individual, Couples, Family, & Group Therapy
Services for Children (3 y/o) to Adults (99 +)
We offer affordable counseling services to those that are insured and not insured.
Insurance accepted: Cigna, Humana Commercial, Magellan, Beacon (Humana Medicaid,
Coventry)
Sliding Scale: Reduced fees based on income for those who qualify
Languages Spoken: English, Spanish, and Farsi
Evidence Based Models: Play/Sand Tray therapy, EMDR, Trauma Focused Cognitive Behavioral
Therapy
Hours: Monday-Friday, Saturdays and evening appointments available
Referral Process: Call 561-444-3914 (Office) email: info@palmbeachmentalhealth.org
Center for Trauma Counseling, Inc.
6801 Lake Worth Road, Suite 307
Greenacres, FL 33467
Office: 561-444-3914
www.parrnbeachmentalhealth.org
Office of the Attorney General
The Capitol. PL-01 • Tallahassee, FL 3230-1050 . Office: (800)2264687 Fax: (853) 414.6191
Bill Status Inform:tier for Providers 050) 414-3331 • TDD users may call through Florida Relay Service at 1.803.9558771
'Nebsite: myfloridalegalcom • Email address: vointake@myfloridalegal.com
BUREAU OF VICTIM COMPENSATION CLAIM FORM
Instructions
Please read the Eligibility Requirements to see if you qualify for this program. Fill out this form completely (please 
print). attach all required
documentation. and submit to the above address. I' you move or change your address. you are required to notify this 
office.
CHECK THE TYPE Of VICTIM COMPENSATION BENEFITS YOU ARE REQUESTING:
Fl DISABILITY - compensation for the victim who suffered a Donnell cisatilty.
I—I (Attach documentasn as cktined in Section 3.)
EgWAGE LOSS - compensation fa the victm who lost wages due to crime related
ph injuries (Math documentation as outlined in Section 3.)
SS OF SUPPORT - compensation for the dependent(s) of a deceased victim
who was employed at the time of the crime. (Attach Cournentaticn as alined
in Section 4.)
EXPENSES • payment cc retnticrsenent on oehSt of the victim for cnme-retaed
funeral/burial, medical/dente treatment and mental health cornseing expenses:
as well as aesoiptions, eyeglasses, dentures, ons prosthetic &Ake lost
damaged, or required because of cone.
(Attach termed bels and receip treatment/funeral
O FUNERAL/BURIAL EDICALMENTAL NTAL HEALTWGRIEF
TREATMENT COUNSELING
in EMERGENCY ASSISTANCE - relmtursement fu dixturnented wage bee and
out-of-packet a/pauses related b da Came. (Attach receipts.)
CHECK ALL OTHER TYPES OF 8 ENEFFS YOU ARE REOUESTNG: (Separate claim numbes we be assigned.)
In PROPERTY LOSS for an Wuh over the age of 60 or enabled adult ,attach
proof disabity pre( to the dab) of nine from a physician a the Social Security
Administraton) who suflered the loss of tamable serSOna: property, as the restlt
of a criminal or delinquent act. Math a receipt of written estinate train a vendor
or merchant identifying li e comparable replacement value. Compensabie items
mist be identified by the law enforcement report
In SEXUAL BATTERY RELOCATION ASSISTANCE - for the vctm of sexual
Celery seeking assstance b relocate due to reasonable fear A certified rape
crisis center certificatior form must be received with Ine appintion.

Section 1. Victim and Applicant Information
VICTIM'S NAME
(lar. Net mcldle)
SOCIAL
SECURITY NO.
ADORE
TELEPHONE
NUMBER
ALTERNATE
PHONE NUMBER
TITS INFORMATION IS COLLECTED FOR FEDERAL REPORTING PURPOSES AND IS OPTIONAL.
RAMETHINICEY CIMAERICAN 'MAW EIASLAN BLACIVATRICAN rl HISPANIC cr
I--IkLASKA NATIVE I—I AMERICAN L. —I LATINC
(- 1 DOMESTIC VIOLENCE RELOCATION ASSISTANCE - be the victim of
donestc violence seeking assistance to relocate to a sate environment. A
cerifieo domesic violence certif talon form and applcaton nust be receved
with 33 days horn the date of crime.
ri HUMAN TRAFFICKING RELOCATION ASSISTANCE - for the vctiir of sexual
traffickng with an urgent need to relocate. A rape orals or domestic ‘iolence
certer cerbicaton fern and applicator] must be received within 45 days of the
last identifiable threat.
CCCUPATICe
gala wv-ety.r.va,A-
O NATIVE HAWAIIAN or OTTER PACIFIC ISLANDER ❑ OTHER RACE
O eiLLTIRE RACES WHITE NONLKINOCAUCASIAN
GENDER: ti !it
The applicant temp on peep* of a 'kern is required to provide clamant information below. When requestng compensation cn 
behalf of an incompetent adult victim prcol
of legal guardianship must be attached, and the applicant's signature an tie dairr form must oe witnessed by a Notary 
Public.
IS THE VICTIM icheo ore) DECEASED O INJURED MINOR ❑ Al" INJ WITNESS" O INCOMPETENT
NOT URED
APPLICANT NNE
Bed. first middle)
DATE OF
BIRTH / /
SOCIAL ' E-MAIL
SECURITY NO. I ADDRESS
WOULD YOU UKE ALL CORRESPONDENCE
SENT BY EMAIL? YES NO
ADDRESS CITY STATE ZIP
CODE
TEL EPHosE /
TAMER k
ALTERNATE i
PHONE NUMSER k
RELATIONSHIP
TO vICTIM
OCCUPATION
NATIONAL ORIGIN
likS P1
WAS VICTIM DISABLED
BEFORE THE CRIME OCCURRED? D YES
EIVC lee Vt15) The Mee of the Attorney General. Bureau of Victim Compensation is an equal opportunity provider and 
empasyer. Page 1 of it

Section 2. Referral Source Information
Individuals who assisted with or filled out any sections of this application are required to provide referral 
information below. By signing this applicatior, the victim/applicant
affirms that all information provided is true and correct, and thus. al sections should be reviewed before the 
application is signed. (Treatment providers can request
training on the Victim Compensation Program. which is recommended prior to becoming a referral source.)
MME OF PERSON ASSISTING WITH APPLICATION I EMAIL
past first mimic) ADDRESS
hAME OF AGENCY/ORGANIZATION
AGENCY ORGANZATIONS ADDRESS
(address. city, state, zip code)

Section 3. Disability or Lost Wages Information
Men westing ceneersatcrfor bst %vars.tech a copy ofyour ray stub or conics staterrynt atiich 'decrees you eTploinert 
stale WO wages ate tee d the CAM V)0ll ae Semple*
or voider a trtiyrnenter, attach a spay of yet blest barna tax ream aril apckabe MS schedule tarns. If mot than 5 work 
days were meted as a rasa d the crime Malta &dors bear
wtich erased you kr tag abseret When leclAstril dsatilY COMPenSaf011, alath a dactyls letter neon speaks each cite 
related penmen( cisabity rang exoreIng bleanest:an lAeckal
AssoParn Gtitlekes ar Sktifia Imparrre7t Patric Gudekes. and favrad &oat SepolykInwasaatcr award leders
ELEPHQNE
NUMBER
SUPERVISOR'S WE
liAl.E OF COMPANY/BUSINESS
le we ban ere In ernotiyar,pkeie mach looms 'heel
CONPAINY ADDRESS
Iaddress. city state, zip code)
IS WAGE LOSS COVERED BY INSURANCE? LI YES
IS WAGE LOSS COVERED BY WORKER'S COMPENSATION? I-1"° YES
TELENCINIEWEER )NIJ
IS VICTIM DISABLED AS A RESULT OF THE CRIME? n YES I I NO
n NO

Section 4. Loss of Support Information or Grief Counseling Information
'ndicate the narre(s) and date(s) of birth of the deceased viaim's surviving spouse, parent, s bang, or chid. For bss of
support attach a copy of the deceased victim's
3t•eSI income tar rein and individual earnings statement reemploynont assistance benefit statement. tour rimer for 
support. birth mrtficate which idenbfies dependent
viationship, marriage cerhficato, or legal documentation proving principal suapidt.
DEPENDANTAUNCR CLAINAN- NAME(S) DATE OF BIRTH RELATIONSHIP TO MTN

Section 5. Insurance Information
Clements who are determined eligible for the Vctim Compensation and Prcoerty Loss Program may be 'mem( Iran the 
irsurance deductble or co-payment provisions Of
their insurance policyQes).
IS INSURA.NCE OR MEDCAJD AVAILABLE TO ASSIST WITH THESE EXPENSES? O YES NO MEDICAID NUMBER
yes, prende be foaming ix d inwrance paces. including lAerliceid Medicare. Flo hanoonnoq. ailomobit, or moice medal &tad
as related insdarce Expknabcn Of Senses statardends).
i COMPANY NAME
AV-C (AM ilVt WAWA NUMBE 0 - 40 - 115 - 258-5
ADDRESS CITY ZIP
CODE
2. COMPANY NAME POLICY NUMBER TELEPHONE/
NUMBER
ADDRESS CITY STATE Zr
CODE
I TELEPHRONE/

Section 6. Other Compensation, Settlement, and Attorney Information
You must notify this off ce if ye/ have race yea or f yrn antapate receiving compensation or any benefits from any tithe
source as a result of this inadent. You must also
notify this office if you have or are laming to hire an attorney to represert you as a result of the incident
STATE THE SOURCE AND
DATE RECEIVED (IFAPFUCAN1) 0 I ‘S -I  t 41
I ARE YOU REPRESEN-ED_ / I
BY LEGAL COUNSEL? L' S 0 NO
ATTORNEY'S NAME
I
ADDRESS EMAIL
ADDRESS
I TELEPHONE
NUMBER CITY STATE ZIP
CODE
\
BY; 100 tits) The Office of the Attorney General, Bureau of Victim Compensation is an equal oeportoney provider and 
employe, Pogo 2 of 4

Section 7. Crime Information
This section must be completed and proof of Crime (such as a law enforcement report a charging affidavit) must be 
attached. Failure to submit proof of crime wit result in
your application not being processed or your claim being denied.
NAME OF LAW DATE OF
CRIME
I DATE REPORTED TO LAW
ENFORCEMENT AGENCY
ENFORCEMENT AGENCY
WAS THE CRP& j  REPORTED TO LAW ENFORCEMENT WITHIN 72 HOURS? YES ONO
If no. please explain. (II no. failure to provide an acceptable explanation in this section will result in a denial of 
beneib.)
IS THE APPLICATION AND LAW ENFORCEMENT REPORT BEING SUBMITTED WITHIN ONE YEAR FROM THE DATE OF CRIME? ❑ YES 13 NO
If no, please explain. (Please be advised that most benefits apply to treatment losses suffered within one year from the
date of crane. with sane exceptions for minor wan
II no. Mime to Monde an %Made explanation in this seams MI result n a denial of bonen.)
TYPE OF CRIME AS SPECIFIED
ON THE LAW ENFORCEMENT REPORT
NAME OF LAW
ENFORCEMENT OFFICER
NME OF ASSISTANT STATE ATTORNEY
HANDLING THE CASE Of applicatle)
LAW ENFORCEMENT
REPORT NUMBER

Section 8. Eligibility Requirements
NAME OF OFFENDER
Nlmoitin)
STATE ATTORNEY!
CLEW OF COURT CASE NUMBER (if appicable)
Additional qualification criteria. deadlines, and exceptions not listed may apply.
Victim Compensation (VC): The victim must cooperate fuly with law enforcement officials, State Attorneys Office, and the
Attorney General's Office. The clime
must be reported to law enforcement within 72 hours, unless there is good cause for delayed reporting. The claim must be
filed Within one year after the date
of the crime or within two years when there is good reason for not fling within one year. Exceptions for filing time 
requirements apply to victims who are minors.
The victim must not have engaged in an unlawful activity or contributed to the situation that brought about his or her 
own injury or death. The victim must have
suffered a physical, psychiatric, psychological injury, or death as a result of the crime.
Property Loss (PL): The victim must have suffered a substantial diminution in their quality of life from the loss of 
tangible personal property as the result of a
criminal or delinquent act. Property loss reimbursement is available up to $500 on any one claim and a lifetime maximum 
of $1,000 on all claims.
Domestic Violence Relocation Assistance (DV): The victim must need immediate assistance to escape a domestic violence 
environment. The application must
be filed within 30 days after the domestic violence crime. Certification by a certified domestic violence center in the 
State of Florida is required. The victim must
submit estimates, invoices, or receipts for interim lodging, housing, utility deposits, new cellular phone service, 
transportation, moving company expenses, or
emergency food or clothing.
Relocation for Victims of Sexual Battery (RS): The victim must need to relocate due to a reasonable fear for his or her 
safety. Certification by a certified rape
crisis center in the State of Florida is required. The victim must submit estimates, invoices, or receipts for interim 
lodging, housing, utility deposits, new cellular
phone service. transportation, moving company expenses, or emergency food or clothing.
Human Trafficking Relocation Assistance (HT): The victim must have an urgent need to escape from an unsafe environment 
directly related to a sexual human
trafficking offense. Application must be received within 45 days of the last identifiable threat by a human trafficking 
offender. The identifiable threat must have
been communicated with the proper authorities. Certification from a certified rape crisis or domestic violence center in
the State of Florida is required. The victim
must submit estimates, invoices or receipts from interim lodging, housing, utility deposits, new cellular phone service,
transportation, moving company expenses,
or emergency food or clothing.
Criminal History Record Check: In order for compensation to be considered, the victim or applicant must not have been 
confined or in custody in a county
a municipal facility; a state or federal correctional facility; or a juvenile detention commitment. Or assessment 
facility; adjudicated as a habitual felony offender.
habitual violent offender, or violent career criminal; or adjudicated of a forcible felony offense.
Notice of Payment Limitations: The Bureau of Victim Compensation may provide financial assistance for eligible persons, 
but only after all other sources of
. payment have been exhausted. Payments accepted by in-state providers on behalf of victims are considered 
payment-in-full per Florida Statute. Total victim
compensation benefits cannot exceed the maximum award amount determined by the current benefit payment schedule. Limits 
below the maximum may ipty to
specific benefits, which may be reduced without prior notice to the award recipient based on the availability of 
funding.
Acceptable Proof of Crime: The Bureau of Victim Compensation does not make an independent judgment on whether a 
compensable crime occurred, but
instead relies on proof of crime from the proper authorities. Failure to provide acceptable documentation proving that a
compensable crime occurred shall result
in your application not being processed or your claim being denied. Acceptable documentation includes: a law enforcement
report or charging affidavit from
a child protection team, law enforcement agency, state or prosecuting attorney. or the Department of Children and 
Families that affirms a compensable crime
occurred; an indictment by a grand jury; an indictment by a prosecutor from a court of competent jurisdiction; a report 
from the United States Federal Bureau of
Investigation; or a Florida Department of Law Enforcement cybercrime investigator certification of a crime for purposes 
of Section 960.197, F.S.
Complete Application Package: It is your responsibility to provide a complete application package which includes 
acceptable documentation proving that a
come occurred. If the department receives a report which is insufficient for proving that a compensable crime occurred, 
the application will be assigned a claim
number and denied. Claim numbers assigned are not indicative of eligibility or denial. For assistance with collecting 
acceptable documentation. please contact
your local law enforcement agency, the agency where the crime was reported, the referral source, or your local State 
Attomey's Office.
BVC 100 (7/15) The Office of the Attorney General, Bureau of Victim Compensation is an equal opportunity provider and 
employer. Page 3 of 4
PLEASE READ CAREFULLY AND SIGN THE FOLLOWING CERTIFICATIONS

Section 9.
CONFIDENTIALITY: If you are Ire victim of a sexual battery. aggravated chid abuse. aggravated stalking, harassment, 
aggravated battery, or domestic
violence. you have the rignt to have information about your home address and telephore number, employment address and 
telephone number, and your
personal assets, kept confidential for a period of five years. If you are the victim of any of these crimes, please mark
one of the following statements. Your
response will not affe the processing of your claim.
I want the information to be confidential O I do NOT want the information to be confidential
SERIOUS FINANCIAL HARDSHIP: I certify that I have a senous financial hardship because of crime-related expenses that 
cannot be paid by any other
source.
PROPERTY LOSS CERTIFICATION: I eerily that the property in question belonged to the victim: that this loss adversely 
affects the victim's quality of life:
that there is no other source of reimbursement for this loss; and that replacement of the prope-ty would cause the 
claimant a serious financial hardship.
RELEASE OF INFORMATION: I give permission to any hospital, doctor. dentist, mental health counselor, or other treatment 
provider, bankng triStrtution,
social service agency, law enforcement agency. corrections agency, state attorney's office, inssance carrier, attorney 
or employer to give out information that
is requested concerning any treatment rendered, employment Insurance thrd-party payer, or law enforcement nvestigative 
information to the Department
of Legal Affairs for use in processing my dom. I give permission lo the Department to release information about the 
status of my claim to any treatment
provider, law enforcement agency. or state attorney's office.
SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER DISCLOSURE: The Bureau cf Victim Compensation collects and uses Social Security numbers for the 
purpose of performing
mperatve duties and responsiNifieswtoch may include the forowing: searching criminal history records. identity 
management. biting and payments, benefit
processing. and reporting to authorized state and federal government agencies. Failure to provide this optimal 
information may delay lhe processing of your
application or benefits. Federal and State laws fracture the Bureau to protect Social Security numbers from disclosure 
to ulauthoized parties. Absent a waiver
from you or your legal representative Social Security numbers will be redacted. unless the agency receives a court order
to turn over a ron redacted file.
REPAYMENT REQUIREMENT: I understand that payment by the victim compensation program is a payment of last resort and that
I must repay the Crimes
Compensation Trust Fund if I receive a victim compensation award and also receive payment from another source as a 
result of the same crrninal incident
Otter sources include. but are not limited to, any payment from the offender an insurance policy. a settlement, a 
judgment or an award in a third party lawsuit.
I further understard that I must repay any emergency award from the Cnmes Compensation Trust Fund, If my claim is 
determined ineligible. I also understand
that if my eligibility is withdrawn, I must repay any amount received from the Crimes Compensation Trust Fund.
APPLICANT: Applcant signature is required if Mine as the parent. legal guardian. a individual authorized to administer a
vctirts estate.
Pnnted Name:
Signature: Date.
Under Penalty of Perjury or fraud, the information I have provided is true and correct to the best o' my knowledge.
NOTARIZATION REQUIREMENT: Persons submitting an application on behalf of an incompetent adult must sibmit prin.,' or 
legal guarcianship
and have their signalize mtnessed by a Notary Public.
Sworn to and subscribed oefore nit this day of . 20
Personalty known to me. Identification produced.
Votary Pottle Signature: Stamp/Seal:
BVC 10i (-7/15) The Office or the Attorney General, Bureau of Victim Compensation is en equal opportunity provider rid 
employer Page 4 of 4
EFTA00191467 (Jmail)
 [misc] Epstein's little black book with contacts
(approximate date: 2015-06-01)
Epstein's little black book with contacts
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                       Phaidon [arts] titan of art book publishing 
        Ronald Lauder [business] heir to the Estée Lauder fortune, Trump megadonor 
                         BV70, LLC [finance] holding company of Leon Black's yacht 
 Elysium Management [finance] Leon Black family office managing Leon Black's money 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00599517 (Jmail)
 [money] list of Leon Black companies that Eileen Alexanderson can make financial transactions for
(inferred date: 2015-06-29)
FAMILY ENTITIES FOR WHICH EILEEN ALEXANDERSON HAS AUTHORITY TO ACT

ENTITY/OWNERS       PERSONS AUTHORIZED      PERSONS WITH    AUTHORITY GRANTED   CURRENT ACTIVITIES
TO ACT - GOVERNING      DELEGATED                           ON BEHALF OF ENTITY
INSTRUMENTS             AUTHORITY

AS Holdings Ltd.    Director: PASI LLC                      Board of Directors  Eileen signs as needed. She
Member: PASI LLC    Officers:                               manages the company has the authority to transfer
.                   President: Eileen                       Officers have the   funds
.                   Alexanderson                            powers delegated to
.                   Secretary: Codan Services Ltd.          them by the Board

Avioneta Holdings   Manager: unknown                        Note: We have no    John J. Hannon signed a
LLC                 President: John J. Hannan               incorporation       Promissory Note dated
Members: unknown                                            documents and no    8/31/11 as "President and a
.                                                           documents setting   Member."
.                                                           forth the powers of
.                                                           the directors and
.                                                           officers.
.                                                           The structure chart shows the members as Leon D. Black
.                                                           (50.1%) and Debra R. Black (49.9%).

BJAV Marine Ltd.
Shareholder: Arcadia
Nominees Ltd.
(nominee for Leon D.
Black)
Director: Eileen Alexanderson Directors manage the company. Eileen handles the VAT
Declarations (she works with
Moo Stephens and SOS Moore
Yachting on this), charter
contracts, insurance, Pensum
(Cayman Islands Co.) and
banking/payments.
Officers:
Secretary: Arcadia Secretaries
Ltd.
Black Family Partners
LP
General Partner: Black
Family GP LLC
Limited Partners: General Partner manages the property, business and
affairs of the partnership.
Eileen is an "authorized
transactor for the Bank of
America bank account
ending in 0135 in the name
of Black Family Partners,
" (per 1/8/15 letter re:
Sustainable Woodlands Fund
II. LP).
Leon D. Black
LBF Holdings LLC
Judah Investment Trusts K-O
Black Family 1997 Trust
Leon D. Black Investment
Trust A
Trusts for each of the children
u/a/d 11/30/92
Trusts for each of the children
u/a/d 8/1/88
AIF IV Management, Inc.
1
3/23/2015 4:21 PM
L
FAMILY ENTITIES FOR WHICH EILEEN ALEXANDERSON HAS AUTHORITY TO ACT
ENTITY/OWNERS PERSONS AUTHORIZED
TO ACT GOVERNING
INSTRUMENTS
PERSONS WITH
DELEGATED
AUTHORITY
AUTHORITY GRANTED CURRENT ACTIVITIES
ON BEHALF OF ENTITY
BV70 LLC
Member: Leon D.
Black
Manager.  Debra R. Black
Officers:
President: Debra R. Black
Vice President: Leon D. Black
Secretary and Treasurer:
Eileen Alexanderson
Eileen
Alexanderson
Andrew Messinger
Managers manage the company. If more than one
manager is serving, they must act unanimously.
Officers are authorized to perform such actions for and
on behalf of the company as the Managers shall
determine.
Delegations.  Each of Eileen Alexanderson and Andrew
Messinger is an "Authorized Person" pursuant to an
Action of Manager dated 6/25/14 with authority to act in
connection with purchasing or leasing real or personal
property, banking, investment and administrative
transactions, and any transactions necessary to implement
any decision made by the Manager, and to act on the
written or oral instructions of the Manager.
Eileen has banking authority.
(Note: All family vehicles
have recently been registered
in the name of BV70 LLC.)
Donalbane House
LLC
Member: Benjamin
Black 2010 Trust
Manager:  Benjamin E. Black
Officers:
President: Benjamin E. Black
Vice President: Debra R. Black
Secretary and Treasurer:
Eileen Alexanderson
3/23/2015 4:21 PM
Eileen
Alexanderson
Managers manages the company. If more than one
manager is serving, they must act unanimously.
Officers are authorized to perform such actions for and
on behalf of the company as the Managers shall
determine.
Delegation.  Eileen Alexanderson is an "Authorized
Person" pursuant to an Action of Manager dated 8/6/14
"with authority to act in connection with purchasing and
leasing property (including 60 West I 1th Street), banking,
investment, real estate and administrative transactions,
and any transactions necessary to implement any decision
made by the Manager, and to act on the written or oral
instructions of the Manager.
Eileen handles bill paying for
Donalbane House and
contracts for construction
projects.
2
FAMILY ENTITIES FOR WHICH EILEEN ALEXANDERSON HAS AUTHORITY TO ACT
ENTITY/OWNERS PERSONS AUTHORIZED
TO ACT - GOVERNING
INSTRUMENTS
PERSONS WITH
DELEGATED
AUTHORITY
AUTHORITY GRANTED CURRENT ACTIVITIES
ON BEHALF OF ENTITY
Elysium Management
LLC
Member: Leon D.
Black
Managing Directors: Leon D. If majority of the Managing Directors have approved.
each Managing Director may take all actions on behalf of
the company. No prior approval required if actions are
purely ministerial and administrative in nature.
Officers may take any and all actions (including engaging
in banking transactions, executing, delivering and
performing any and all contracts, agreements, certificate.
undertakings or other documents or instruments) and do
any and all things necessary, desirable, convenient or
incidental to carry on the business and purposes of the
Company.
Eileen handles various
contracts and payments. Black. Brad Wechsler
Officers:
President: Leon D. Black
Vice President: Debra R. Black
Secretary and Treasurer:
Eileen Alexanderson
Friends Ventures
LLC
Members: Leon D.
Black and Ronald S.
Lauder
Members: Leon D. Black and Eileen
Alexanderson
Members, acting unanimously, manage the company.
Delegation. Eileen Alexanderson is an "Authorized
Eileen handles funds
transfers. Ronald S. Lauder
Person" pursuant to Resolution by Consent of the
Members 10/16/14 with authority to act in the name and
on behalf of Friends Ventures "in connection with
bankin transactions."
JMWT Ltd.
Wholly owned
subsidiary of JMWT
Midco Ltd.
Directors: Leon D. Black, Directors manage the company.
Debra R. Black and Eileen
Alexanderson
JMWT Midco Ltd.
Wholly owned
subsidiary of JMWT
Topco Ltd.
Directors: Leon D. Black and Note: We have no incorporation documents and no
documents setting forth the powers of the directors.
Directors are listed in the Report and Financial
Statements for the period ended 30i ' June 2013.
Eileen Alexanderson
3
3/23/2015 4:21 PM
FAMILY ENTITIES FOR WHICH EILEEN ALEXANDERSON HAS AUTHORITY TO ACT
ENTITY/OWNERS PERSONS AUTHORIZED
TO ACT - GOVERNING
INSTRUMENTS
PERSONS WITH
DELEGATED
AUTHORITY
AUTHORITY GRANTED CURRENT ACTIVITIES
ON BEHALF OF ENTITY
JMWT Topco Ltd.
Wholly owned
subsidiary of JMWT
Acquisition LLP
Directors: Leon D. Black and Note: We have no incorporation documents and no
documents setting forth the powers of the directors.
Directors are listed in the Report and Financial
Statements for the period ended 30ih June 2013.
Eileen Alexanderson
LDB 2011 LLC
Members: BEB 2011
Trust, .IMB 2011 Trust,
ASB 2011 Trust and
VRB 2011 Trust
Manager: Barry J. Cohen Eileen
Alexanderson
Managers manage the company. If there are two
managers, they must act by unanimous consent. If there
are more than two managers, they must act by majority.
Officers are authorized to perform such actions for and
on behalf of the company as the Managers shall
determine.
Delegation. Eileen Alexanderson is an "Authorized
Eileen handles funds
transfers. Officers:
President: John J. Hannan
Vice President: Richard
Ressler
Treasurer: Barry Cohen
Secretary: Eileen
Alexanderson
Person" pursuant to an Action of Manager dated 6/30/14
with authority to act in connection with banking,
investment and administrative transactions, including any
transactions necessary to implement any decision made
by the Managers and to act on the written or oral
instructions of any one Manager.
LDB 2014 LLC
Member: LDB 2011
LLC
Manager: Barry J. Cohen Eileen
Alexanderson
Managers manage the company.
Officers are authorized to perform such actions for and
on behalf of the company as the Managers shall
determine.
Delegation. Eileen Alexanderson is an "Authorized
Eileen handles funds
transfers. Officers:
President: John J. Hannan
Vice President: Richard
Ressler
Treasurer. Barry J. Cohen
Secretary: Eileen
Alexanderson
Person" pursuant to an Action of Manager dated 6/5/14
with "authority to act in connection with banking,
investment and administrative transactions, including any
transactions necessary to implement any decision made
by the Managers and to act on the written or oral
instructions of any one Manager.
4
3/23/2015 4:21 PM
FAMILY ENTITIES FOR WHICH EILEEN ALEXANDERSON HAS AUTHORITY TO ACT
ENTITY/OWNERS PERSONS AUTHORIZED
TO ACT - GOVERNING
INSTRUMENTS
PERSONS WITH
DELEGATED
AUTHORITY
AUTHORITY GRANTED CURRENT ACTIVITIES
ON BEHALF OF ENTITY
LDB Warren Street,
LLC
Member: APO2
Declaration
(Note: 101 Warren
Street apartment was
sold in June 2015.)
Manager: John J. Hannan Eileen
Alexanderson
Delegation. Eileen Alexanderson is an "Authorized
Person" pursuant to an Action of Manager dated 10/6/14
with authority to act in connection with the purchase, sale
or leasing of real or personal property (including the sale
of Apartment #2350 at 101 Warren Street), banking,
investment, real estate and administrative transactions,
including transactions necessary to implement any
decision made by the Manager and to act on the written
or oral instructions of the Manager.
NY 70th Street CAM
LLC
Members: Leon D.
Black and NY 70th
Street LLC
(Capital Account
Manager for NY 701°
Street LLC)
Manager: John J. Hannan Eileen
Alexanderson
Rich
Managers manage the company. If more than one
manager is serving, they must act unanimously.
Officers are authorized to perform such actions for and
on behalf of the company as the Managers determine.
Delegation. Eileen Alexanderson is an "Authorized
Eileen handles townhouse
contracts and funds transfers. Officers:
President and Vice President:
John J. Hannan
Secretary and Treasurer:
Eileen Alexanderson Person" pursuant to an Action of Manager dated 9/4/14
with authority in connection with purchasing real or
personal property, banking, investment and
administrative transactions, and any transactions
necessary to implement any decision made by the
Manager, and to act on the written or oral instructions of
the Manager.
Delegation. Rich is a an authorized person
pursuant to an Action of Manager dated 9/4/14 with
authority to act in connection with banking and
administrative transactions not to exceed, in each
instance, the sum of Fifty Thousand Dollars ($50,000),
and any transaction necessary to implement any decision
made by the Manager and to act on the written or oral
instructions of the Manager.
5
3123/2015 4:21 PM
FAMILY ENTITIES FOR WHICH EILEEN ALEXANDERSON HAS AUTHORITY TO ACT
ENTITY/OWNERS PERSONS AUTHORIZED
TO ACT - GOVERNING
INSTRUMENTS
PERSONS WITH
DELEGATED
AUTHORITY
AUTHORITY GRANTED
'
CURRENT ACTIVITIES
ON BEHALF OF ENTITY
NY 701° Street LLC Manager: John J. Hannan Eileen Managers manage the company. Eileen handles townhouse Alexanderson 
contracts and funds transfers. Member: APOI
Officers: Officers are authorized to perform such actions for and
Agreement President: John I Hannan on behalf of the company as the Managers shall
determine.
(Nominee for Leon D. Vice President:
Black and NY 70th Eileen Alexanderson Delegation. Eileen Alexanderson is an "Authorized
Street LLC) Person" pursuant to an Action of Manager dated 6/12/14 Secretary: Richard Ressler
Treasurer. Barry J. Cohen
with authority to act in connection with banking,
investment, real estate and administrative transactions,
including execution of purchase and sales agreements and
any transactions necessary to implement any decision
made by the Managers and to act on the written or oral
instructions of any one Manager.
Second Delegation. Eileen Alexanderson is an
"Authorized Person" pursuant to an Action of Manager
dated 6/12/14 with authority to act in connection with
banking, investment, real estate and administrative
transactions, including execution of purchase and sales
agreements (including the purchase of an interest in 19
East 70th Street) with respect to any transactions
necessary to implement any decision made by the
Managers and to act on the written or oral instructions of
any one Manager and with authority to exercise the
powers of the Capital Account Manager with respect to
any Capital Account created pursuant to a split purchase
agreement between the Company and Leon D. Black in
connection with the purchase of 19 East 701".
Nominee Agreement dated 8/28/14: Leon D. Black and
NY 70'h Street LLC authorize NY 70th Street LLC as
Nominee to hold title to 19 East 70th Street property and
Nominee agrees to act solely as agent and on behalf of
Leon D. Black and NY 70'h Street LLC as beneficial
owners.3/23/2015 4:21 PM
6
3/23/2015 4:21 PM
FAMILY ENTITIES FOR WHICH EILEEN ALEXANDERSON HAS AUTHORITY TO ACT
ENTITY/OWNERS
-
PERSONS AUTHORIZED
TO ACT - GOVERNING
INSTRUMENTS
PERSONS WITH
DELEGATED
AUTHORITY
AUTHORITY GRANTED CURRENT ACTIVITIES
ON BEHALF OF ENTITY
PAT70 LLC
Member: Debra R.
Black
Manager. Debra R. Black Eileen
Alexanderson
Managers manage the company.
Officers are authorized to perform such actions for and
on behalf of the company as the Managers shall
determine.
Delegation. Eileen Alexanderson is an "Authorized
Eileen facilitated renewal
lease and related transfer of
funds. Officers:
President: Debra R. Black
Vice President: Debra R. Black
Secretary and Treasurer:
Eileen Alexanderson
Person" pursuant to an Action of Manager dated 6/25/14
with authority to act in connection with leasing property.
banking, investment, real estate and administrative
transactions, and any transactions necessary to implement
any decision made by the Manager, and to act on the
written or oral instructions of the Manager.
Phaidon Press Ltd.
Shareholders: PLB
LLC and JMWT LLC
Directors: Directors manage the company. Directors must act by
majority decision, and a majority decision is defined as a
decision with not more than one director dissenting.
Eileen signs documents as a
director when needed. She
also handles funds transfers. Keith Fox, John Murphy,
Andrew Price Deborah ,
Aaronson, Emilia Terragni,
James Booth-Clibbom, Eileen
Alexanderson
Officers:
CEO and Chairman: Keith Fox
Secretary: Jonathan Whale
7
3/23/2015 4:21 PM
FAMILY ENTITIES FOR WHICH EILEEN ALEXANDERSON HAS AUTHORITY TO ACT
ENTITY/OWNERS PERSONS AUTHORIZED
TO A(-7 - GOVERNING
INSTRUMENTS
PERSONS WITH
DELEGATED
AUTHORITY
AUTHORITY GRANTED
I
CURRENT ACTIVITIES
ON BEHALF OF ENTITY
SH Meadow Lane
LLC
Member: APO2
Declaration
Manager: John J. Hannan Eileen
Alexandersun
Andrew Messinger
Delegation. Eileen Alexanderson is an "Authorized
10/6/14
implement
the
person
with
and
the
Eileen signs contracts and
handles funds transfers. Person" pursuant to an Action of Manager dated
with authority to act in connection with purchasing,
leasing, maintaining and improving real or personal
property, banking, investment and administrative
transactions, and any transactions necessary to
any decision made by the Manager, and to act on
written or oral instructions of the Manager.
Delegation. Andrew Messinger is an authorized
pursuant to an Action of Manager dated 10/6/14
authority in connection with purchasing, leasing,
maintaining and improving real or personal property
administrative transactions in connection with the
forgoing, and any transactions necessary to implement
any decision made by the Manager or to act on
written or oral instructions of the Manager.
8
3/23/2015 4:21 PM
EFTA00605854 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2015-06-30)
VALAR VENTURES
Limited Partner:
Fund:
Unaudited Statement of
Changes in Partner's Capital
As of Jun 30, 2015
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
Valar Global Fund II LP
Commitment: $ 15,000,000
Paid in Capital: $ 3,750,000
Remaining: $ 11,250,000
Current
Quarter
Year to
Date
Inception to
Date
Partner's capital, beginning $ 929,917 $ 0 $ 0
Contributions $ 2,700,000 $ 3,750,000 $ 3,750,000
Net operating income/(loss)
Management fees $ (85,253) $ (173,732) $ (173,732)
Partnership expenses $ (19,140) $ (50,744) $ (50,744)
Interest income $ 460 $ 460 $ 460
Total net operating income/(loss) $ (103,933) $ (224,016) $ (224,016)
Distributions $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
Net realized gain/(loss) on investments $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
Net unrealized gain/(loss) on investments $ 64,950 $ 64,950 $ 64,950
Partner's capital, ending $ 3,590,934 $ 3,590,934 $ 3,590,934
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Wirecard [russia] largest financial fraud in German history, connections to FSB and crypto, CFO Jan Marsalek is a fugitive in Russia [nyer] 
                                     BaFin [government] German financial regulator, tried to arrest journalists who exposed Wirecard's fraud 
                                                                                                  Accel Partners [tech] venture capital firm 
                                                                          Andrew McCormack [tech] co-founder of Peter Thiel's Valar Ventures 
                                                                          James Fitzgerald [tech] co-founder of Peter Thiel's Valar Ventures 
                                                     Kimbal Musk [tech] brother of Elon Musk, dated Epstein's girl Jennifer Kalin [guardian] 
                                                                           Number26 [tech] fintech frontend for Wirecard Bank, renamed "N26" 
                                                                                                                 Transferwise [tech] fintech 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00609489 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(date: 2015-06-30)
Do Not Copy or Distribute Without Written Permission from Valar Ventures LLC
Valar Global Fund III LP
$200,000,000
VALAR
Limited Partner Interests
Confidential Private Placement Memorandum
Valar Ventures LLC
915 Broadway, Suite 1101
New York, New York 10010
Copy #
Issued to:
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
Confidential Private Placement Memorandum
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
$200,000,000
Limited Partner Interests
THIS CONFIDENTIAL PRIVATE PLACEMENT MEMORANDUM (THE "MEMORANDUM")
HAS BEEN PREPARED SOLELY FOR USE BY THE PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS OF VALAR
GLOBAL FUND III LP (THE "FUND" OR THE "PARTNERSHIP") AND SHALL BE
MAINTAINED IN STRICT CONFIDENCE. EACH RECIPIENT HEREOF ACKNOWLEDGES
AND AGREES THAT (I) THE CONTENTS OF THIS MEMORANDUM CONSTITUTE
PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, (II) VALAR VENTURES GP III LLC
(THE "GENERAL PARTNER"), VALAR VENTURES LLC (THE "MANAGEMENT COMPANY')
AND THEIR AFFILIATES, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION THE FUND
(COLLECTIVELY, THE "FIRM") DERIVE INDEPENDENT ECONOMIC VALUE FROM SUCH
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION NOT BEING GENERALLY KNOWN, AND (III) SUCH
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION IS THE SUBJECT OF REASONABLE EFFORTS TO
MAINTAIN ITS SECRECY. THE RECIPIENT FURTHER AGREES THAT THE CONTENTS OF
THIS MEMORANDUM ARE A TRADE SECRET, THE DISCLOSURE OF WHICH IS LIKELY TO
CAUSE SUBSTANTIAL AND IRREPARABLE COMPETITIVE HARM TO THE FIRM. ANY
REPRODUCTION OR DISTRIBUTION OF THIS MEMORANDUM, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, OR
THE DISCLOSURE OF ITS CONTENTS, WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE
MANAGEMENT COMPANY, IS PROHIBITED. EACH PERSON WHO HAS RECEIVED THIS
MEMORANDUM IS DEEMED TO AGREE TO RETURN THIS MEMORANDUM TO THE
MANAGEMENT COMPANY UPON REQUEST. THE EXISTENCE AND NATURE OF ALL
CONVERSATIONS REGARDING THE FUND AND THIS OFFERING MUST BE KEPT
CONFIDENTIAL.
THIS MEMORANDUM HAS BEEN PREPARED IN CONNECTION WITH A PRIVATE
OFFERING TO ACCREDITED INVESTORS OF LIMITED PARTNER INTERESTS IN THE
FUND (THE "INTERESTS"). EACH INVESTOR WILL BE REQUIRED TO EXECUTE A
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (AS AMENDED, RESTATED AND/OR OTHERWISE
MODIFIED FROM TIME TO TIME, THE "PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT) AND
SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE (THE "SUBSCRIPTION
AGREEMENT') TO EFFECT ITS INVESTMENT IN THE FUND. THIS MEMORANDUM
CONTAINS A SUMMARY OF THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT, THE SUBSCRIPTION
AGREEMENT AND CERTAIN OTHER DOCUMENTS REFERRED TO HEREIN. HOWEVER,
THE SUMMARIES IN THIS MEMORANDUM DO NOT PURPORT TO BE COMPLETE AND
ARE SUBJECT TO AND ARE QUALIFIED IN THEIR ENTIRETY BY REFERENCE TO THE
ACTUAL TEXT OF THE RELEVANT DOCUMENT, COPIES OF WHICH WILL BE PROVIDED
TO EACH PROSPECTIVE INVESTOR UPON REQUEST. EACH PROSPECTIVE INVESTOR
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
SHOULD REVIEW THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT, THE SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT
AND SUCH OTHER DOCUMENTS FOR COMPLETE INFORMATION CONCERNING THE
RIGHTS, PRIVILEGES AND OBLIGATIONS OF INVESTORS IN THE FUND. IF ANY OF THE
TERMS, CONDITIONS OR OTHER PROVISIONS OF THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT, THE
SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT OR SUCH OTHER DOCUMENTS ARE INCONSISTENT WITH
OR CONTRARY TO THE DESCRIPTIONS OR TERMS IN THIS MEMORANDUM, THE
PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT, THE SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT OR SUCH OTHER
DOCUMENTS SHALL CONTROL. THE FIRM RESERVES THE RIGHT TO MODIFY THE
TERMS OF THE OFFERING AND THE INTERESTS DESCRIBED IN THIS MEMORANDUM,
AND THE INTERESTS ARE OFFERED SUBJECT TO THE GENERAL PARTNER'S ABILITY TO
REJECT ANY COMMITMENT IN WHOLE OR IN PART.
THE INTERESTS HAVE NOT BEEN AND WILL NOT BE REGISTERED UNDER THE UNITED
STATES SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED (THE "SECURITIES ACT), OR ANY
UNITED STATES STATE SECURITIES LAWS OR THE LAWS OF ANY FOREIGN
JURISDICTION. THE INTERESTS WILL BE OFFERED AND SOLD UNDER THE EXEMPTION
PROVIDED BY SECTION 4(2) OF THE SECURITIES ACT AND REGULATION D
PROMULGATED THEREUNDER AND OTHER EXEMPTIONS OF SIMILAR IMPORT IN THE
LAWS OF THE STATES AND OTHER JURISDICTIONS WHERE THE OFFERING WILL BE
MADE. THE FUND WILL NOT BE REGISTERED AS AN INVESTMENT COMPANY UNDER
THE UNITED STATES INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT OF 1940, AS AMENDED (THE
"INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT). CONSEQUENTLY, INVESTORS WILL NOT BE
AFFORDED THE PROTECTIONS OF THE INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT.
THE INTERESTS DESCRIBED IN THIS MEMORANDUM ARE SUBJECT TO RESTRICTIONS
ON TRANSFERABILITY AND RESALE AND MAY NOT BE TRANSFERRED OR RESOLD
EXCEPT AS PERMITTED UNDER THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT AND THE SECURITIES
ACT AND APPLICABLE STATE SECURITIES LAWS, PURSUANT TO REGISTRATION OR
EXEMPTION THEREFROM. INVESTORS SHOULD BE AWARE THAT THEY WILL BE
REQUIRED TO BEAR THE FINANCIAL RISKS OF THIS INVESTMENT FOR AN INDEFINITE
PERIOD OF TIME.
THE FUND'S INVESTMENTS WILL BE CHARACTERIZED BY A HIGH DEGREE OF RISK,
VOLATILITY AND ILLIQUIDITY. A PROSPECTIVE PURCHASER SHOULD THOROUGHLY
REVIEW THE CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN AND THE TERMS OF
THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT AND SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT, AND CAREFULLY
CONSIDER WHETHER AN INVESTMENT IN THE FUND IS SUITABLE TO THE INVESTOR'S
FINANCIAL SITUATION AND GOALS.
CERTAIN ECONOMIC AND MARKET INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN HAS BEEN
OBTAINED FROM PUBLISHED SOURCES PREPARED BY OTHER PARTIES. WHILE SUCH
SOURCES ARE BELIEVED TO BE RELIABLE, NEITHER THE FUND, THE GENERAL
PARTNER, NOR THEIR RESPECTIVE AFFILIATES ASSUME ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR
THE ACCURACY OR COMPLETENESS OF SUCH INFORMATION. NEITHER DELIVERY OF
THIS MEMORANDUM NOR ANY STATEMENT HEREIN SHOULD BE TAKEN TO IMPLY
THAT ANY INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS CORRECT AS OF ANY TIME
SUBSEQUENT TO THE DATE HEREOF.
NO PERSON HAS BEEN AUTHORIZED TO MAKE ANY STATEMENT CONCERNING THE
FUND OR THE SALE OF THE INTERESTS DISCUSSED HEREIN OTHER THAN AS SET
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
FORTH IN THIS MEMORANDUM, AND ANY SUCH STATEMENTS, IF MADE, MUST NOT BE
RELIED UPON.
PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS ARE CAUTIONED NOT TO RELY ON THE PRIOR RETURN
INFORMATION SET FORTH HEREIN IN MAKING A DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO
PURCHASE THE INTERESTS OFFERED HEREBY. THE RETURN INFORMATION
CONTAINED HEREIN HAS NOT BEEN AUDITED OR VERIFIED BY ANY INDEPENDENT
PARTY AND SHOULD NOT BE CONSIDERED REPRESENTATIVE OF THE RETURNS THAT
MAY BE RECEIVED BY AN INVESTOR IN THE FUND. CERTAIN FACTORS EXIST THAT
MAY AFFECT COMPARABILITY INCLUDING, AMONG OTHERS, THE DEDUCTION OF FEES
AND EXPENSES AND THE PAYMENT OF A CARRIED INTEREST. CERTAIN FACTUAL AND
STATISTICAL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN HAS BEEN OBTAINED FROM
PUBLISHED SOURCES PREPARED BY OTHER PARTIES AND HAS NOT BEEN
INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED BY THE GENERAL PARTNER OR ANY OF ITS AFFILIATES.
OPINIONS AND ESTIMATES MAY BE CHANGED WITHOUT NOTICE. IN CONSIDERING
THE PRIOR PERFORMANCE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN, PROSPECTIVE
INVESTORS SHOULD BEAR IN MIND THAT PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT NECESSARILY
INDICATIVE OF FUTURE RESULTS, AND THERE CAN BE NO ASSURANCE THAT THE
FUND WILL ACHIEVE COMPARABLE RESULTS.
CERTAIN STATEMENTS OF PAST PERFORMANCE OF OTHER INVESTMENT FUNDS
MANAGED BY THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY OR AFFILIATES THEREOF AND CERTAIN
ECONOMIC AND MARKET INFORMATION, CONTAINED HEREIN INCLUDES PROJECTIONS
AND ESTIMATES MADE BY THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY AND OTHER PARTIES. THE
PROJECTED RETURNS CONTAINED HEREIN MAY BE CALCULATED ON A COMPANY BY
COMPANY BASIS, AND ARE BASED ON ESTIMATES OF THE EVENTUAL MAGNITUDE
AND THE TIMING OF THE RETURNS FROM EACH COMPANY MADE BY THE
MANAGEMENT COMPANY. THE PROJECTED RETURNS AND ESTIMATES OF ECONOMIC
AND MARKET INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN INVOLVE RISKS AND
UNCERTAINTIES AND: (I) ARE BASED UPON ASSUMPTIONS CONCERNING
CIRCUMSTANCES AND EVENTS THAT HAVE NOT YET OCCURRED AND (II) MAY BE
SUBJECT TO BEING INFLUENCED BY EVENTS BEYOND THE CONTROL OF THE
MANAGEMENT COMPANY. ACTUAL RESULTS COULD DIFFER SIGNIFICANTLY. NO
REPRESENTATION OR WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, IS MADE BY THE FIRM AS TO
THE REASONABLENESS OR ACCURACY OF THE PROJECTIONS OR ESTIMATES AND, AS
A RESULT, SUCH PROJECTIONS AND ESTIMATES SHOULD BE VIEWED SOLELY AS AN
ORDERLY REPRESENTATION OF ESTIMATED RESULTS IF UNDERLYING ASSUMPTIONS
ARE REALIZED. INVESTORS SHOULD SUBJECT THE PROJECTIONS AND ESTIMATES TO
REVIEW BY THEIR OWN PROFESSIONAL ADVISERS. UPON REQUEST, THE
MANAGEMENT COMPANY WILL PROVIDE INVESTORS WITH THE ASSUMPTIONS AND
METHODOLOGIES USED IN PREPARING THE PROJECTIONS AND ESTIMATES.
THE MEMORANDUM, TOGETHER WITH ANY AMENDMENTS AND SUPPLEMENTS
THERETO, AND ANY OTHER OFFERING MATERIALS DISTRIBUTED TO THE LIMITED
PARTNERS (TOGETHER, THE "OFFERING MATERIALS") CONTAIN CERTAIN
STATEMENTS WITH RESPECT TO, AND DISCLOSE CERTAIN INFORMATION WITH
REGARD, TO THE THIEL PERSONS (AS DEFINED HEREIN). NONE OF THE THIEL PERSONS
MAKES ANY REPRESENTATION OR WARRANTY WITH RESPECT TO THE CONTENTS OF
THE OFFERING MATERIALS. NONE OF THE THIEL PERSONS HAS OR ASSUMES ANY
RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY PART OF THE FORM OR SUBSTANCE OF THE OFFERING
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
iv
MATERIALS, AND THE OFFERING MATERIALS, IN THEIR ENTIRETY, ARE THE
RESPONSIBILITY OF THE GENERAL PARTNER AND THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY. THE
THIEL PERSONS ARE RELYING, WITHOUT INDEPENDENT VERIFICATION, ON THE
ACCURACY AND COMPLETENESS OF OFFERING MATERIALS.
INVESTORS SHOULD MAKE THEIR OWN INVESTIGATIONS AND EVALUATIONS OF THE
FUND, INCLUDING THE MERITS AND RISKS INVOLVED IN AN INVESTMENT THEREIN.
PRIOR TO ANY INVESTMENT, THE GENERAL PARTNER WILL GIVE INVESTORS THE
OPPORTUNITY TO ASK QUESTIONS OF AND RECEIVE ANSWERS AND ADDITIONAL
INFORMATION FROM IT CONCERNING THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS
OFFERING AND OTHER RELEVANT MATTERS TO THE EXTENT THE GENERAL PARTNER
POSSESSES THE SAME OR CAN ACQUIRE IT WITHOUT UNREASONABLE EFFORT OR
EXPENSE. INVESTORS SHOULD INFORM THEMSELVES AS TO THE LEGAL
REQUIREMENTS APPLICABLE TO THEM IN RESPECT OF THE ACQUISITION, HOLDING
AND DISPOSITION OF THE INTERESTS IN THE FUND, AND AS TO THE INCOME AND
OTHER TAX CONSEQUENCES TO THEM OF SUCH ACQUISITION, HOLDING AND
DISPOSITION.
THIS MEMORANDUM DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO SELL, OR A SOLICITATION
OF AN OFFER TO BUY, AN INTEREST IN ANY JURISDICTION IN WHICH IT IS UNLAWFUL
TO MAKE SUCH AN OFFER OR SOLICITATION. NEITHER THE UNITED STATES
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION NOR ANY OTHER FEDERAL, STATE OR
FOREIGN REGULATORY AUTHORITY HAS APPROVED AN INVESTMENT IN THE FUND.
FURTHERMORE, THE FOREGOING AUTHORITIES HAVE NOT CONFIRMED THE
ACCURACY OR DETERMINED THE ADEQUACY OF THIS MEMORANDUM, NOR IS IT
INTENDED THAT THE FOREGOING AUTHORITIES WILL DO SO. ANY REPRESENTATION
TO THE CONTRARY IS A CRIMINAL OFFENSE.
YOUR INVESTMENT WILL BE DENOMINATED IN UNITED STATES DOLLARS ($) AND,
THEREFORE, WILL BE SUBJECT TO ANY FLUCTUATION IN THE RATE OF EXCHANGE
BETWEEN UNITED STATES DOLLARS ($), THE CURRENCY OF YOUR OWN JURISDICTION
AND THE CURRENCY OF THE JURISDICTION IN WHICH ANY FUND PORTFOLIO
COMPANY OPERATES OR GENERATES INVESTMENT PROCEEDS, AS APPLICABLE. SUCH
FLUCTUATIONS MAY HAVE AN ADVERSE EFFECT ON THE VALUE, PRICE OR INCOME
OF YOUR INVESTMENT.
CAUTIONARY STATEMENTS REGARDING FORWARD -LOOKING STATEMENTS
CERTAIN STATEMENTS IN THIS MEMORANDUM CONSTITUTE FORWARD -LOOKING
STATEMENTS. WHEN USED IN THIS MEMORANDUM, THE WORDS "MAY," "WILL,"
"SHOULD," "PROJECT," "ANTICIPATE," "BELIEVE," "ESTIMATE," "INTEND," "EXPECT,"
"CONTINUE," AND SIMILAR EXPRESSIONS OR THE NEGATIVES THEREOF ARE
GENERALLY INTENDED TO IDENTIFY FORWARD -LOOKING STATEMENTS. SUCH
FORWARD -LOOKING STATEMENTS, INCLUDING THE INTENDED ACTIONS AND
PERFORMANCE OBJECTIVES OF THE GENERAL PARTNER, FUND, OR ANY PORTFOLIO
COMPANY REFERENCED HEREIN, INVOLVE KNOWN AND UNKNOWN RISKS,
UNCERTAINTIES, AND OTHER IMPORTANT FACTORS THAT COULD CAUSE THE ACTUAL
RESULTS, PERFORMANCE, OR ACHIEVEMENTS OF THE GENERAL PARTNER, FUND, OR
ANY PORTFOLIO COMPANY TO DIFFER MATERIALLY FROM ANY FUTURE RESULTS,
PERFORMANCE, OR ACHIEVEMENTS EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED BY SUCH FORWARD -
LOOKING STATEMENTS. NO REPRESENTATION OR WARRANTY IS MADE AS TO FUTURE
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR V
Private Placement Memorandum
PERFORMANCE OR SUCH FORWARD -LOOKING STATEMENTS. ALL FORWARD -LOOKING
STATEMENTS IN THIS MEMORANDUM SPEAK ONLY AS OF THE DATE HEREOF. THE
FUND AND THE GENERAL PARTNER EXPRESSLY DISCLAIM ANY OBLIGATION OR
UNDERTAKING TO DISSEMINATE ANY UPDATES OR REVISIONS TO ANY FORWARD -
LOOKING STATEMENT CONTAINED HEREIN TO REFLECT ANY CHANGE IN ITS
EXPECTATION WITH REGARD THERETO OR ANY CHANGE IN EVENTS, CONDITIONS, OR
CIRCUMSTANCES ON WHICH ANY SUCH STATEMENT IS BASED.
PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS ARE NOT TO CONSTRUE THIS MEMORANDUM AS
INVESTMENT, LEGAL, TAX, REGULATORY, FINANCIAL, ACCOUNTING OR OTHER
ADVICE, AND THIS MEMORANDUM IS NOT INTENDED TO PROVIDE THE SOLE BASIS
FOR ANY EVALUATION OF AN INVESTMENT IN AN INTEREST. PRIOR TO ACQUIRING
AN INTEREST, A PROSPECTIVE INVESTOR SHOULD CONSULT WITH ITS OWN LEGAL,
INVESTMENT, TAX, ACCOUNTING, AND OTHER ADVISORS TO DETERMINE THE
POTENTIAL BENEFITS, BURDENS, AND OTHER CONSEQUENCES OF SUCH INVESTMENT.
ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING THIS OFFERING, AND ANY REQUESTS FOR COPIES OF THE
MEMORANDUM, THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT AND THE SUBSCRIPTION
AGREEMENT SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO:
Valar Ventures LLC
915 Broadway, Suite 1101
New York, New York 10010
email:
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
II. KEY PRINCIPAL TERMS 4
III. INVESTMENT STRATEGY S
IV. PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT 11

V. INVESTMENT HISTORY 14
VI. FUND PERFORMANCE AND PORTFOLIO COMPANY PROFILES 15
VII. SUMMARY OF PRINCIPAL TERMS 16
VIII. CERTAIN RISK FACTORS 28

IX. CERTAIN TAX AND REGULATORY MATTERS 38
X. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 49
APPENDIX A: LEGAL NOTICES A-I
APPENDIX B: FUND COMPOSITION AND PERFORMANCE B-I
APPENDIX C: PORTFOLIO COMPANY PROFILES C-I
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Andrew McCormack, James Fitzgerald and Peter Thiel (the "Founding Partners") formed Valar
Ventures (the "Firm" or "Valor") as a venture capital investment firm in 2010, with a mandate to find
and fund high-growth, earlier -stage companies located in markets outside of Northern California where
the top Silicon Valley -based venture firms historically have not focused. The Firm currently manages
$200 million in capital commitments across all its funds and investment vehicles, and is currently
investing out of Valar Global Fund 2, a $100 million fund that is more than 75% invested or reserved
for follow-on investments in existing portfolio companies.
Valar is now raising a larger institutional fund ("Fund 3", the "Fund" or the "Partnership") with
targeted capital commitments of $200 million. The Fund is expected to emphasize Series A and Series
B stage investments in high-growth technology companies based in first-world economies, with a focus
on Europe, Canada, and the US (ex-Northem California), where Valar believes the growth opportunities
are highest relative to the availability of smart capital (the "Strategy').
Since inception, Valar has generated significant returns for its investors, exceeding industry and general
market benchmarks:
Net Multiple Net IRR
Valar Fund I 2.5x 41.0%
Cambridge US Venture Capital Index (Top Quartile) 2.2x 36.1%
Cambridge Global ex US Developed Markets PE/VC Index 1.5x 17.3%
S&P 500 Total Return Index 1.9x 13.5%
• - Numbers presented for Valar am as of 12/31/2015. - Valar Fund l" refers to all funds and investment vehicles
managed by Valar Ventures Management LLC prior to the formation of Velar Global Fund 2, on an aggregate
basis. Valar Fund 1 made its first investment on 10/28/2010. Valar Global Fund 2 made its first investment in
March 2015 and all investments arc still held at cost. Numbers presented for the S&P 500 Total Return Index are
gross results for the period 10/28/2010-1131/2015. The S&P 500 is a stock market index based on the market
capitalizations of large, publicly traded companies, whereas Valar generally invests in earlier stage, privately
held companies. Because final Cambridge data is not made available for several months after the end of a
quarter, Valar has presented the most recent final data available for upper quartile vintage 2010 funds, which is
as of 6/30/2015. Valar Ventures' figures are unaudited estimates incorporating all realized and unrealized
gains/losses and were calculated by reducing gross profits by a flat 25% for hypothetical management fees,
expenses and carry. Past performance may not be an indicator of future performance. Sources: Cambridge
Associates; MarketWatch; Valar.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
Distinguishing Factors

A. Performance
As of December 31, 2015, Valar has deployed $133.9 million in the Strategy, with a gross asset value
of $325.6 million, including realized and unrealized investment gains and losses. Valar Fund 1 (an
aggregation of all funds and investments vehicle managed by Valar prior to the formation of Valar Fund

2) has a current gross multiple of 3.0x since October 2010, which, if treated as a single fund, would
place its performance within the top echelon of all venture funds (as compared to both internationally or
domestically focused funds) and one that has significantly outperformed common public market index
references, such as the S&P 500.' Of the five major portfolio companies in Valar Fund 1, two (Xero and
TransferWise) have already achieved valuations close to or in excess of a billion dollars.
B. Team Dynamic & Experience
The Founding Partners have a long, varied and successful working relationship — Andrew and Peter
have been working together since PayPal in 2001, with James joining them at Clarium in 2008.
Collectively they have structured and managed investments across a range of sectors and geographies
through two major economic cycles. In addition to their investing experience, the Founding Partners
have operational backgrounds — Andrew founded and ran a restaurant group, James served as General
Counsel and COO of Thiel Capital LLC ("Thiel Capital") and Peter co-founded and was CEO of
PayPal and is a co-founder and the chairman of Palantir.
The Partnership will be managed by Andrew and James. All Fund investment decisions will be made
with their unanimous consent, and Andrew and James together will constitute the investment committee
of the Fund (the "Investment Committee"). While Peter is not a member of the Investment Committee
and is not expected to be involved in the day-to-day management of the Firm, he is generally expected
to be available to provide advice and counsel to Valar and its portfolio companies from time-to-time. In
addition, in view of his status as a Founding Partner, Peter owns 20% of the General Partner and the
Management Company and retains veto rights over certain activities of the General Partner, the
Management Company and the Fund.
Andrew and James have traveled the world and taken nearly all meetings together for close to five years
now, looking for investment opportunities that are off the radar of Silicon Valley's top venture firms.
Based on their intensive experience working together with entrepreneurs and portfolio companies on
four continents, they have been able to iterate quickly and continuously refine the Strategy to optimize
for the markets, stage of investment, founder attributes and firm structure with the highest potential for
yielding outsized venture returns.

C. Market/Stage Differentiation
Venture capital as an asset class has performed well since 2010, a fact that has not been lost of the
increasing numbers of investors allocating money to the space. Seed stage investment, on the one end of
the capital stack, and later-stage/pre-IPO investment, on the other end, have been particularly popular,
as smaller investors (including many new entrants to the market) seek to replicate the 1000x returns
Composition of public market indices may not be comparable with composition of Valar's portfolio and past performance 
may
not be an indicator of future performance.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
achieved by early investors in Facebook, Twitter, Uber, etc., and larger investors attempt to eke out
modest returns in the current low interest rate environment by plowing money into later stage
companies that are perceived (correctly or not) as largely de-risked. The space between these two
extremes has not received as much attention, with Series A and Series B financing rounds (sub -$100
million valuations) in particular being less crowded. Moreover, the vast majority of venture investment
continues to be focused on the United States (in particular, Northem California), China and India.
By focusing on Series A and B stage investments outside of Northern California, China and India, Valar
is operating in a segment of the market that remains significantly less crowded, and where valuations
are consequently more attractive. In addition, while limited partners investing primarily through the top
Silicon Valley -based venture firms may find themselves ultimately invested in many of the same
underlying portfolio companies, in most cases Valar is the first US-based investor to invest in its
portfolio companies, providing a segment of diversification to its investors.

D. Reputation
Valar and the Founding Partners enjoy a strong reputation as venture investors across the world and are
particularly prominent in the US, Europe, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, where the Firm has
made approximately 40 investments in 20 portfolio companies since 2010. Moreover, Peter is known
worldwide in technology circles (and otherwise) and has been recognized repeatedly as one of the most
successful venture capital investors in history, building on his first investments in PayPal and the very
first outside investment in Facebook.
The best founders understand the importance of receiving investment from the most reputable venture
firms. As such, Valar's reputation drives extraordinary deal-flow at attractive prices to the Firm, as
entrepreneurs compete to have access to Valar's experience and the imprimatur of its Founding
Partners.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
II. KEY PRINCIPAL TERMS
The following information is presented as a summary of certain of the Fund's key principal terms only
and is qualified in its entirety by the more detailed information contained in "Section VII. Summary of
Principal Terms" herein and by the Partnership Agreement, which will be circulated to investors prior
to closing. To the extent that this summary conflicts with the Partnership Agreement, the Partnership
Agreement will control.
Target Size
General Partner
Commitment
Term
Commitment Period
Management Fee
Management Fee
Reduction
Carried Interest
Clawback
Investment Committee /
Key Persons
No Fault Termination
Organizational Expenses
$200 million
At least I% of fee-bearing capital
10 years, subject to two, one-year extensions at the General Partner's
discretion and thereafter with the consent of a majority in interest of the
Limited Partners
5 years
2.5% of Limited Partners' capital commitments until the end of the
Commitment Period; reduced thereafter by 0.1% annually, but not below
1.5% of the aggregate capital commitments of the Limited Partners
100% of all directors, consulting, management services, transaction,
advisory, break-up or broken deal fees
Carried interest is not payable until 100% of capital contributions have
been returned to the Partners, and thereafter will be 20% of net profits
until the Fund distributes to each Limited Partner an amount equal to
300% of its capital commitment; thereafter 25% of net profits until the
Fund distributes to each Limited Partner an amount equal to 600% of its
capital commitment; thereafter 30% of net profits
Yes, with a guaranty by each managing member of its share on a several,
but not joint, basis
lames Fitzgerald and Andrew McCormack
Yes, at any time by the election of eighty percent (80%) in interest of the
Limited Partners
Capped at $500,000
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
ill. INVESTMENT STRATEGY
A. Core Strategy
The Fund's core strategy is to use its strong brand and execution-oriented structure to invest in high-
growth earlier-stage technology companies located in first world markets outside of Northern
California.
Stage: Valar's typical initial investment is generally sized at $5-$10 million in a company that has an
enterprise (pre-money) value of between $20 and $100 million.
Geography: Valar seeks to identify great companies that are founded in first world, developed
economies outside of Northern California, where Valar believes the opportunity to build a globally
significant technology company is high, while the competition from top-branded venture firms
investing at the Series A and Series B stages is relatively low.
For historical reasons, many of the most prestigious venture firms still remain largely focused on
Silicon Valley and San Francisco. However, as a result of the powerful effects of Moore's Law, the
information sharing culture of the startup ecosystem, and the operating leverage the Internet creates, an
increasing share of the world's most valuable technology companies are being started outside of
Northern California. Startup costs have fallen by orders of magnitude over the past 15 years, business
and engineering talent is easier to find globally, knowledge is shared in real time, distribution channels
are both more open and powerful and deal terms are increasingly standardized to Silicon Valley models.
As long as the Internet remains open for business, Valar believes these tailwinds will continue.
Examples of geographies Valar intends to focus on for investment in the Fund include:

• Western Europe (e.g., UK, Ireland, Germany, France, Netherlands)
• Northern Europe (e.g., Sweden, Finland, Denmark, Estonia)

• North America (e.g., Canada, US (ex-Northern California))
Examples of geographies where Valar is open to inbound deal flow through its networks, but where it
does not plan to travel extensively for the Fund:

• Israel, Japan, South Korea, Singapore, Australia, New Zealand and Northern California
Examples of geographies Valar does not intend to focus on for the Fund:
• China, India, Russia, Brazil, Turkey, Africa, Latin America, the Middle East, Southeast Asia
Investor Value Add: As noted above, the best founders understand the importance of receiving
investment from the most reputable venture firms. Unlike public companies or even later-stage private
firms, information about early-stage startup companies is not readily available. As a result, many of the
key contributors to a startup's ultimate success (e.g., potential employees, prospective customers and
downstream investors) rely heavily on the signaling effect that results from a company receiving
investment from a highly respected investor. Setting this virtuous circle in motion is of paramount
concern to early-stage founders, and is arguably the single most important "value add" a venture
investor can offer. In that regard, the imprimatur of Valar choosing to invest in one company over
others has significant and immediate reputational and branding benefits to the chosen company.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
Beyond that social proof, the Firm adds value initially by aligning the core terms of the company's
governing documents towards growth and removing founder -unfriendly structures that constrain a
startup's flexibility and growth. Post-investment, Valar practices a high-availability, low-touch style of
working with founders; connecting management with the Firm's networks in the US and abroad and
offering strategic advice and mentoring as needed. Valar receives and monitors all board materials and
Andrew and James participate in most board meetings of the Firm's larger investments.

B. Thesis
The technology business worldwide is growing at an exponential rate as even the most offline industries
and business verticals are being disrupted by the rapid adoption and continued evolution of Internet,
cloud -based and mobile technologies. Valar believes that the best technology companies being founded
outside of Northern California are mispriced due to their distance from Sand Hill Road and there is an
opportunity for Valar to establish itself as the funder of first choice for the very best of these companies.
The Firm believes that innovations in technology will fuel a rapidly increasing supply of massive
companies in the geographies Valar is focused on, while the willingness and ability of the best venture
brands in Silicon Valley to travel to access these opportunities is not growing at anywhere close to the
same rate. The venture capital industry's bias toward investing in Silicon Valley - despite steeply rising
US valuations and operating costs - creates compelling opportunities elsewhere, where competition for
markets, employee talent, and funding is much lower. Within that universe of opportunities, Valar
believes that its reputation affords it access to the best companies, access which serves as the primary
driver of returns. These hypotheses rest on three beliefs:

i. Silicon Valley Does Not Have A Monopoly On Entrepreneurial Talent Or Market
Opportunities
VC tends towards regional bias: the US in general and Silicon Valley in particular command
the majority of venture capital funding and the common misconception is that Silicon Valley is
not just the best place to look for start-up opportunities, but in many ways, the only good place
to look.
However, the rest of the world has become a much more fertile place for start-ups as the
success of companies like Skype, Spotify, Zendesk, Atlassian, Shopify, Xero, TransferWise,
Klama, HootSuite and others demonstrate. Moreover, the pool of talent abroad is deep —
interestingly, many of the top founders in Silicon Valley are immigrants or children of
immigrants, including Max Levchin (PayPal), Larry Page, Sergei Brim (Google), and Elon
Musk (Testa, SpaceX). By investing abroad ahead of an entrepreneur's or company's arrival in
the US, Valar believes it can operate in a context where industry bias against ex-Silicon Valley
investment creates significant pricing opportunities.

ii. Silicon Valley-Style Venture Capital Investing Adds Value To Non-Valley Start-Ups
Valar believes that venture firms with Silicon Valley experience can add value to non-US start-
ups in ways that local investors generally cannot:
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum

a. Large pools of capita!:  Silicon Valley remains the single largest non-state source of
start-up funding in the world and even smaller Valley -based funds are significantly
larger than developing market funds (for example, NEA's most recent fund exceeds
the stage-sponsored venture programs of most developed countries combined).
Silicon Valley firms also have established syndication mechanisms in place to
leverage their proprietary capital, including syndication directly to their limited
partners. This dynamic has become especially important as the capital requirements of
many startups have once again begun to rise. Valar's network in Silicon Valley and
the US are valuable to companies looking for downstream capital. Indeed, the Firm's
two largest investments from Fund I, Xero and TransferWise, recently received
significant growth investments from Accel Partners and Andreessen Horowitz, two of
the largest and most respected Silicon Valley venture firms.

b. Patience:  Silicon Valley investors are accustomed to longer liquidity cycles than
regional financiers; Peter Thiel, in particular, has a record of well -rewarded patience:
e.g., Palantir (which grew over ten years from a $35 million valuation to $20 billion);
SpaceX (sub $300 million to over $10 billion in nine years); and Facebook (less than
$10 million to nearly $300 billion in just over a decade). Valar has demonstrated a
willingness to reinvest in its portfolio companies as they grow and the Firm's relative
informational advantages compound: Xero is a notable example, with successive
waves of investment by Valar reaping larger and faster returns. Reinvestment from
the existing syndicate makes subsequent financings more efficient for portfolio
companies, and Valar reaps the rewards of inside access and improved information.

c. Founder -friendliness:  Valar emphasizes founder -investor alignment, believing that it
maximizes value for both parties. The concept of allowing companies a freer hand in
their own development rather than imposing frequently value-destroying "adult
supervision" has gained currency in Silicon Valley since its introduction by Peter
Thiel's Founders Fund, but remains distinctly unorthodox in other tech hubs,
especially outside the US, where investors insist on a variety of "private equity style"
terms that the Silicon Valley investment community has come to realize are of
generally negative utility (e.g., participation rights, highly restrictive spending
oversight, routine vetoes, super pro rata rights, etc.). The Founding Partners' record of
pioneering founder -friendly terms (both at Founders Fund and more recently through
Valar Ventures) is both a competitive advantage in sourcing deals and a value-
creating mechanism post-investment.

d. Experience:  The pool of venture investors with long, significant and successful track
records outside Silicon Valley — especially coupled with prior operational experience
— is not deep. Valar brings Founding Partners who not only have an excellent track
record as investors but who have operational experience in a variety of sectors.
e. Brand:  The US is, and for the foreseeable future is expected to remain, the largest
unitary, sovereign market for new goods and services and is thus important to many
companies founded outside the US. Large corporate partners, investment banks,
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
potential acquirers and other US counterparties tend to be somewhat parochial in their
approach and rely on their impression of the venture capitalist's brand when making
decisions. In addition to credibility based on Valar's own top-tier performance, Peter
Thiel enjoys a reputation as one of the most successful venture capitalists in history.
iii. Only Top Its Produce Excess Returns Because Only Top VCs Have Access To The Best Deals
Industry data suggest that only the top quartile of venture capital firms produce significant
excess returns and that these returns tend to persist over the lifetime of a fum's core
partnership as reputational assets and experience produce self-reinforcing effects. Because top
venture capitalists can arrogate the best opportunities to themselves on the basis of reputation
(as the best deals tend not to be price-competitive, but driven by interpersonal and
philosophical compatibility between venture capitalists and founders), venture capital firms try
to minimize transactional costs when doing deals. In practice, this means that most top tier
venture capitalists invest near Silicon Valley and thus the best venture capital brands — which
create the most value for the companies in which they invest — have less incentive to operate
outside of Silicon Valley. Furthermore, because private equity investing is not a readily
scalable discipline, efforts to extend venture capital culture and brands via country -specific
managers or satellite offices have not been notably successful, providing additional reasons for
most venture capital firms to invest in companies founded closer to their Sand Hill Road
homes. This creates a vacuum that Valar, with a primary emphasis on non-Valley investing,
but with strong Silicon Valley connections, occupies.

C. Deal Flow
Sources of deal flow include:
i. Reputation
Valar and its Founding Partners already enjoy a strong reputation as venture investors in the
geographies they have operated in, particularly in the UK, Germany, New Zealand and
Canada, where the Firm has made significant investments, and increasingly in other parts of
Europe and the US, where Andrew and James have spent significant time but have not yet
invested. In addition, Peter's brand is highly visible and affords the team access to
entrepreneurs globally.
ii. Local connections
Valar seeks to develop deep relationships with local entrepreneurs and investors in the core
cities in which it operates. Most of the major capitals of Europe (e.g., London, Berlin,
Stockholm, Paris, Amsterdam), as well as the largest cities in North America outside of
Northern California (e.g., New York, Toronto, Montreal) have fairly well established
accelerator programs, angel investors and seed-stage investing communities. In particular,
seed -stage venture firms that are not positioned to be lifecycle investors are attractive local
partners for Valar, as those firms tend to be highly incented to share their best deal flow with
deeper pocketed US venture funds that can provide Series A, B and later financing to their
portfolio companies. These relationships serve to channel deals to Valar as the investor of first
choice when companies are looking to raise new financing rounds.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
"It'siii.  a series of tubes"
The Internet, it turns out, is a powerful source of information sharing, and the past few years
have seen an explosion of technology-focused news outlets, blogs and daily email circulars
surfacing even the earliest and geographically most remote of startup financings. Because
Valar is not generally the first money invested in a company, and because the best
entrepreneurs are often highly attuned to building their online presence early, Valar can
identify and monitor startups, even in distant geographies, before they reach an appropriate
stage of investment for the Fund. Valar has recently added two associates to the investment
team, among other things, in order to more systematically track companies identified through
its in-house research. Once a potential portfolio company is identified, Valar can use its local
networks in the relevant market to obtain an introduction, or directly contact the company's
management team, relying on the Firm's global reputation to access to the best companies.

iv. Pre-existing relationships
The Founding Partners already have considerable deal flow from their prior investments and
related networks (including the "PayPal mafia" and their other relationships developed while
working with Peter Thiel over the past decade). These relationships have historically yielded
high quality deal flow (e.g., Max Levchin was an early investor in London-based TransferWise
and helped introduce Valar to TransferWise's founders).

D. Diligence
The Fund expects to undertake its own diligence for most investments. As seasoned investors and
operators, the Founding Partners believe they can conduct most diligence in-house. In certain cases, the
Fund may employ outside experts to assess matters specific to a given investment and legal diligence
may be sourced to the Fund's outside counsels. The Fund's level of diligence is expected to correspond
to the relative importance of a given investment to the portfolio and Valar's previous experience with
the entrepreneur, and may range from brief (in cases where an investment is small or the entrepreneur
or market are well known to the team) to extensive (in the case of larger, more complex investments).
The Fund can also utilize the diverse talents of its advisory board to assist with diligence.

E. Portfolio Construction
On a capital-deployed basis, Valar intends to run a relatively concentrated portfolio, continuing to
support successful companies in subsequent rounds.
Subject to the availability of strong opportunities — which does not, given the Firm's current deal flow,
appear to be a major constraining risk - Valar expects to complete primary capital deployment within
two to three years of the Fund's close. Valar intends to reserve capital for initial follow-on investments
in Fund portfolio companies, although later follow-on investments, including those at significantly
higher valuations, may be made by separate co-investment vehicles or subsequent funds.
Valar also intends to increase invested capital, measured as a percent of the Fund's overall Capital
Commitments, by recycling investment proceeds where available (a practice sometimes referred to as
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
"recycling fees"). Valar believes this strategy will be beneficial for Fund investors by helping converge
net and gross performance of the Fund.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum

IV. PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT
A. Voting Process and Control
I 1
The Partnership will be managed by Andrew and James with Peter providing advice and counsel from
time-to-time as appropriate. Investment decisions will be made with the unanimous consent of James
and Andrew (the "Investment Committee"). If either James or Andrew is affected by a conflict of
interest, the additional consent of the Fund's Advisory Board regarding the proposed transaction will be
sought. The General Partner anticipates appointing an advisory board of three to five members, to be
selected in its discretion following the closing of the Fund.
While Peter Thiel is not a member of the Investment Committee and is not expected to be involved in
the day-to-day management or operations of the General Partner, the Management Company or the
Fund, Peter (directly or through another Thiel Person) will be a member of the General Partner, entitled
to 20% of the carried interest and net management fees paid by the Fund, and as is generally expected
to be available to provide advice and counsel to Valar and its portfolio companies from time-to-time. In
addition, in view of his status as a Founding Partner, Peter will retain veto rights over certain activities
of the General Partner and the Fund, including those relating to the composition of the Investment
Committee, certain investments by the Fund that could create a conflict of interest, actions requiring the
consent of the Advisory Committee and material deadlocks between Andrew and James. These matters
are described in more detail under the heading "Control" in Section VII below. In addition, Andrew and
James are subject to significant non-compete agreements with Peter, and Peter retains the right to
terminate Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald upon the occurrence of certain events constituting
cause.

B. Team Dynamic
Valar believes that the managerial organization of its portfolio companies is an important indicator and
driver of a startup's potential success, and has devoted considerable thought to how to structure its own
team — an area that it believes has posed significant challenges to the ability of other venture capital
firms to access opportunities outside of their home markets.
The core dynamic of Valar's investment process is its "perpetual -partner -meeting" model, meaning that
Andrew and James generally take all calls, meetings and travel together and thus possess nearly
symmetric information and are in constant communication about all opportunities available to Valar.
The ability to make partnership level decisions in real-time, and in particular, the ability to pass on
investment opportunities quickly, are key to the Firm's cross -geography strategy. The Firm does not
plan to make any changes that would affect its ability to maintain the perpetual -partner -meeting model.
Fund sizes (individually and in the aggregate) are expected to be kept at a level that can be effectively
managed by the existing team.
Valar expects to hire additional investment associates and back office personnel as it expands, but all
investment decisions and deal sourcing are expected to be made by the existing Founding Partners for
the foreseeable future. Valar believes that its small team and unanimous voting make it more nimble
than firms with large investment committees, politicized "Monday meetings", struggles over attribution
and economics, and other internal angst caused by large teams operating in an industry where lumpy,
large gains long divorced in time from the investment decision create unhealthy dynamics that erode
returns.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAFI
Private Placement Memorandum

C. Biographies
i. Andrew McCormack
Andrew is a Founding Partner at Valar Ventures. Andrew's career in technology has included
business and corporate development roles at eCount (acquired by Citicorp) and Yahoo! He
joined PayPal in 2001, where he worked closely with Peter in preparing for the company's
IPO. After PayPal's sale to eBay, Andrew helped launch Clarium Capital and later founded a
restaurant group in San Francisco.
In 2008, Andrew rejoined Peter at Thiel Capital, where he led various international initiatives
for Thiel Capital and Peter personally. Andrew received his B.A. in Political Science from the
University of Pennsylvania.
James Fitzgerald
James is a Founding Partner at Valar Ventures. Prior to Valar, he was COO and General
Counsel of Peter Thiel's global parent company, Thiel Capital, where he helped manage
Peter's extensive network of investments and businesses. In that capacity, he worked closely
with Founders Fund, Mithril, and Clarium.
Prior to joining Thiel Capital, James practiced law for seven years in the New York office of
Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP. He received his J.D. from the University of
California, Los Angeles and his undergraduate degree from Brigham Young University.
iii. Peter Thiel
Peter co-founded PayPal and guided it as CEO through its IPO and sale to eBay. He is a co-
founder of Palantir Technologies and the first outside investor in Facebook. Peter is also a New
York Times best-selling author, with his book Zero to One, which details his collected
philosophies on investing in and building technology companies. Through his investing,
writing and speaking career, Peter is mentoring the next generation of transfonnative
entrepreneurs.
Peter earned a B.A. in philosophy from Stanford University and a J.D. from Stanford Law
School, where he occasionally teaches on globalization and technology.

iv. Reuben Kobulnik
Reuben is the Chief Operating Officer and Chief Financial Officer of Valar Ventures,
responsible for all operational, financial reporting and legal matters.
Prior to joining Valar, Reuben was Counsel at Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP,
where he practiced M&A, private equity and general corporate law for nine years. While at
Skadden, Reuben worked closely with James on a number of transactions. Before joining
Skadden, Reuben clerked for Justice Morris J. Fish of the Supreme Court of Canada.
Reuben received his law degree as well as an undergraduate degree in Finance and Strategy
from McGill University.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum

v. Mike Bosserman
Mike is an Investment Associate at Valar Ventures, where he spends his time surfacing great
businesses and entrepreneurs, performing due diligence, and monitoring the Valar
portfolio. Before joining Valar, Mike was an Investment Analyst at Spider Management
Company, the investment manager for the University of Richmond and a number of other
endowments and foundations.
Mike received his B.S. in Business Administration with a Concentration in Finance from the
University of Richmond in 2012. He has also completed all three levels of the CFA Program.

vi. John Tenet
John is an Investment Associate at Valar Ventures and is responsible for sourcing and
evaluating technology -driven companies across a variety of sectors, as well as providing
assistance to the Firm's portfolio companies. John joined Valar from Allen & Company, where
he spent 3 years investing in technology, media, and telecom deals, as well as focusing on third
party manager sourcing and due diligence as part of the Capital Markets and Investment
Management Divisions.
John received his B.A. in Government from Georgetown University in 2010.
vii. Erin Portedield
Erin Porterfield assists with Vales day-to-day operational and financial matters. Prior to
Valar, Erin was an executive assistant at Thiel Capital in San Francisco, where she worked
closely with James and Andrew. She initially joined Clarium in 2011.
Erin received a BS in Mass Communication, with a minor in Psychology from Middle
Tennessee State University.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
V. INVESTMENT HISTORY
Valar began as a new strategy incubated within Thiel Capital that sought to invest in the increasing
number of globally significant technology companies being founded outside of Peter's historical focus
of Northern California. To that end, the team began scouting internationally for opportunities in 2010,
initially making investments through a series of special purpose vehicles that were primarily funded by
Peter, and ultimately spinning out as a stand-alone strategy with significant capital commitments from
outside investors:
2010: Valar Ventures LP, a New Zealand partnership (the "New Zealand Fund"), made
Valar's first investments in New Zealand. Approximately 40% of the capital commitments to
the New Zealand Fund were from Peter Thiel; the rest from the New Zealand government and
other third party investors.
2012: Opportunities in Xero exceeded the New Zealand Fund's concentration limits and Valar
launched VV Xero Holdings LLC (the "Xero Mgr) to harvest those opportunities.
2012-2013:  As Valar broadened its efforts internationally, VV Global LP and VV Global
Principals LP were formed to take advantage of a growing number of opportunities outside of
New Zealand (the "VV Funds"). The VV Funds were 100% funded by Peter Thiel and, with
one exception, made all investments pari passu.
2013: Based on the success of earlier Valar funds, Valar Global Fund I LP and Valar Global
Principals Fund I LP were raised in 2013 with 10% outside capital to invest in technology
companies globally. These funds have made all investments pari passu and are collectively
referred to as "Global Fund I". Among other things, Global Fund I was intended to serve as a
template for Valar's first institutional fund, including by providing the legal framework,
auditable track record and other internal processes necessary to attract institutional capital.
2014: Valar's pro rata rights in the Series C financing of TransferWise, led by Andreessen-
Horowitz, exceeded the remaining capital of the VV Funds and Global Fund 1. Valar raised a
$10M sidecar fund, Valar Co -Invest Fund I LP (the "Transfer Wise SPV"), to participate in
that round.
2014.2015:  Valar Global Fund II LP and Valar Global Principals Fund II LP, which invest
pari passu in all transactions (together, "Fund 2") were raised in late 2014 and closed in
January 2015. Capital commitments to Fund 2 totaled $102 million, with approximately 70%
of the funds coming from outside investors (primarily educational endowments, large multi-
family offices and high net worth individuals) and the remaining capital commitments coming
from Peter Thiel (approximately 30%) and Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald
(approximately 1%). To date, over 75% of capital commitments have been invested or
reserved for follow-ons and expenses.
For ease of reference in this document, "Fund 1" refers to all the funds and investment vehicles listed
above, on an aggregate basis, other than Fund 2.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
VI. FUND PERFORMANCE AND PORTFOLIO COMPANY PROFILES
Performance information and profiles for all Fund 1 and Fund 2 portfolio companies where Valar's
initial cost basis was in excess of $2 million ("Major Investments") appear below in Appendix B and
Appendix C, respectively. Valar's detailed investment track record, including a complete list of all
portfolio company investments, is available in the Firm's electronic data room.2
2 Interested investors should contact Valar for access to the electronic data room.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
VII. SUMMARY OF PRINCIPAL TERMS
The following is a summary of certain of the proposed terms of the Limited Partnership Agreement of
Valar Global Fund III LP (the "Partnership Agreement') and Operating Agreement of the General
Partner. This summary does not purport to be complete and is qualified in its entirety by reference to the
Partnership Agreement.
FUND: Valar Global Fund III LP (the "Fund" or the "Partnership") will be
organized as a Delaware limited partnership.
PURPOSE: To invest, as a general matter, in earlier•stage, high•growth technology
companies with their principal places of business outside of Northem
California through direct, privately negotiated investments in equity or
equity -oriented securities of private and, in certain cases, public companies
with limited liquidity.
GENERAL PARTNER: Valar Ventures GP III LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, will be the
general partner of the Fund (the "General Partner").
LIMITED PARTNERS: Institutions and private individuals (or their estate planning vehicles) that are
"accredited investors" within the meaning of the United States Securities Act
of 1933 or qualified non•U.S. persons (the "Limited Partners", and together
with the General Partner the "Partners").
FUND SIZE: The target size of the Fund is $200 million in committed capital from the
Partners (the "Capital Commitments").
GENERAL PARTNER'S The General Partner will make a Capital Commitment to the Fund of at least
CAPITAL I% of the aggregate fee bearing Capital Commitments of the Partners.
COMMITMENT: In lieu of a contribution to the Fund entirely in cash, the General Partner may
elect to make "deemed" capital contributions for up to 80% of its Capital
Commitment, which would reduce subsequent management fee payments due
to the General Partner by corresponding amounts (each such amount being a
"Fee Adjustment').
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
TIMING OF CAPITAL
CONTRIBUTIONS:
TERM:
Each Limited Partner will contribute capital periodically in installments as
requested by the General Partner upon ten business days' prior written notice;
provided, that certain investors regulated under the Employee Retirement
Income Security Act of 1974, as amended ("ERISA"), may be required to
make their first capital contribution into an escrow account or may not be
required to make a capital contribution prior to the date the Fund makes its
first investment and thereby qualifies as a "venture capital operating
company" under applicable Department of Labor regulations.
No Limited Partner will be required to contribute any capital following the
fifth anniversary of the date the first capital contribution is due except to the
extent necessary for (i) Fund expenses (including payment of management
fees), (ii) completion of investments in new portfolio companies evidenced by
a written term sheet as of such fifth anniversary, (iii) funding follow-on
investments in existing portfolio companies, and (iv) fulfillment of
indemnification and other obligations and liabilities of the Fund. The period
prior to the fifth anniversary of the date the first capital contribution is due is
referred to as the "Commitment Period".
The Fund will be dissolved ten years after the date on which the Partners'
initial capital contribution is due; provided, that the General Partner may
extend the Fund's term (a) for up to two additional one-year periods in its
sole discretion, and (b) for additional one-year periods with the consent of
Limited Partners holding more than 50% of the Capital Commitments (a
"Majority -in-Interest of the Limited Partners").
The Fund may be dissolved prior to the end of its stated term upon the
affirmative vote of Limited Partners holding more than 80% of the Capital
Commitments, or by the affirmative vote of Limited Partners holding more
than two-thirds-in-interest of the Capital Commitments ("Two-Thirds -in-
Interest of the Limited Partners") following certain events constituting
"cause" (as defined in the Partnership Agreement); provided, however, this
shall not apply if, in the case of acts by a Managing Member, the offending
individual is removed as a managing member of the General Partner.
MANAGEMENT The General Partner will cause the Fund to enter into a management
COMPANY: agreement with Valar Ventures LLC, a Delaware limited liability company,
or another entity beneficially owned by Andrew McCormack, James
Fitzgerald and Peter Thiel (or another Thiel Person (as defined below)
designated by Peter) (the "Management Company"), who will be the
manager of the Fund and provide management, administrative, operational
and other services to the Fund from time to time.
CONTROL: Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald are the Managing Members of the
General Partner of the Fund and responsible for the day-to-day operations of
the General Partner, the Management Company and the Fund. Investment
decisions of the Fund are made by the General Partner acting through its
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
IS
Investment Committee (the "Investment Committee"), of which Andrew
McCormack and James Fitzgerald are the sole members.
While Peter Thiel is not a member of the Investment Committee and is not
expected to be involved in the day-to-day management or operations of the
General Partner, the Management Company or the Fund, Peter (directly or
through another Thiel Person) will be a member of the General Partner and
entitled to 20% of the carried interest and net management fees paid by the
Fund. Moreover, in view of his status as a Founding Partner, Peter retains
certain veto rights over the activities of the General Partner and the Fund,
including the following:

• The appointment or removal of any person from the Investment
Committee or Board of Managers of the General Partner of the Fund

• Any investment by the Fund in a portfolio company of another fund
managed by Valar in excess of $5 million

• Any investment by the Fund in a portfolio company in which
Founders Fund, Mithril or Peter are invested

• The creation of any co-investment funds or other special purpose
vehicles
• Any investment by the Fund in a portfolio company in excess of
25% of total capital commitments of the Fund

• Any investment by the Fund in a company listed on a US or UK
stock exchange in excess of 15% of total capital commitments of the
Fund

• The incurrence by the Fund of certain indebtedness in excess of 10%
of total capital commitments
• Any investment by the Fund in other investment funds in excess of
5% of total capital commitments of the Fund

• Any action by the Fund that would subject Peter to additional
burdens or regulatory requirements
• Any investment by the Fund that does not fit within the Fund's
strategy

• Entering into certain side letters or similar agreements with limited
partners of the Fund
• Any decision required to resolve a material deadlock between
Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald relating to the Fund
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
• Any other action that requires the consent of the Advisory
Committee of the Fund.
In addition, Andrew and James are subject to significant non-compete
agreements with Peter, and Peter retains the right to terminate Andrew
McCormack and James Fitzgerald upon the occurrence of certain events
constituting cause.
ADVISORY The Fund will have an Advisory Committee that will serve as such for the
COMMITTEE: Fund and any Parallel Funds, consisting of no less than 3 and no more than 7
representatives of the Limited Partners and constituent limited partners of the
Parallel Funds chosen by the General Partner in its reasonable judgment (the
"Advisory Committee"); provided that the General Partner may not appoint
any Limited Partner that is an affiliate of the General Partner or any of its
respective affiliates. The Advisory Committee will (a) have such duties as are
set forth in the Partnership Agreement, (b) approve or disapprove matters
pertaining to conflicts of interest as requested by the General Partner
(excluding certain matters otherwise expressly addressed pursuant to the
terms of the Partnership Agreement), and (c) render such other advice and
counsel as requested by the General Partner. The Fund will reimburse each
member of the Advisory Committee for his or her reasonable out-of-pocket
expenses in connection with his or her activities on the Advisory Committee.
MANAGEMENT FEE: A management fee will be paid by the Limited Partners of the Fund and the
annual management fee will be equal to the Fund's aggregate Capital
Commitments made by the Limited Partners multiplied by 2.50% (the
"Management Fee Percentage"). Notwithstanding the foregoing, beginning
with the first full fiscal year that begins after the end of the Commitment
Period the Management Fee Percentage will be reduced annually by ten basis
points (i.e., by 0.10% per annum) until it is equal to 1.50%. The installment
of management fee payable for any fiscal quarter will be equal to one-fourth
(114) of the Management Fee Percentage in effect for such fiscal quarter (as
adjusted) multiplied by the aggregate Capital Commitments made by the
Limited Partners.
The management fee payable with respect to a fiscal quarter will be reduced
by the aggregate amount that the General Partner has elected not to contribute
in cash prior to such quarter (i.e., the sum of all Fee Adjustments).
The management fee will also be reduced by 100% of all cash and non-cash
compensation paid as directors, consulting, management services, transaction,
advisory, break-up or broken deal fees or other similar fees received by the
General Partner, the Management Company, or the respective managing
members or managers of such entities in connection with portfolio
investments of the Fund and attributable to the Fund's actual investment in
such entities. The management fee will be further reduced during an
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
KEY PERSON:
ALLOCATIONS OF
PROFIT & LOSS:
extension period.
In the event that either (i) James Fitzgerald or (ii) Andrew McCormack (each
as a "Managing Member" and collectively as "Managing Members") ceases
to be a managing member of the General Partner, otherwise ceases to
participate in the management of the Fund or fails to meet his obligations to
devote his business time to the Fund as set forth below under "Time
Commitment" (a "Suspension Event"), the Commitment Period will
automatically be suspended and shall continue unless Two-Thirds -in-Interest
of the Limited Partners affirmatively vote to terminate the suspension within
one hundred and eighty (180) days of its commencement; provided, that a
Two -Thirds -in-Interest of the Limited Partners may vote to terminate a
suspension period at any time.
Upon the suspension of the Commitment Period, the General Partner will not
request further capital contributions except as required for: (i) Fund expenses
(including payment of management fees), (ii) completion of investments in
new portfolio companies in process at the time of suspension as evidenced by
a written term sheet, (iii) funding follow-on investments in existing portfolio
companies so long as the Advisory Committee consents to each such
investment, and (iv) fulfillment of indemnification and other obligations and
liabilities of the Fund.
Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald are each subject to provisions
under which Peter Thiel may remove them from the Management Company
or the General Partner for certain events constituting "cause" or otherwise by
a vote of one or more of the other members. In the event of such removal, a
Managing Member would cease providing services to the Fund, thereby
triggering a Suspension Event.
At the end of each fiscal year or other accounting period, the net profit and
loss for such period will be allocated as follows:

i. First, until the "First Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is met,
allocations shall be made in a manner necessary to cause cumulative net
profit and loss to be allocated 80% to the Partners, in proportion to their
relative Capital Commitments, and 20% to the General Partner. The "First
Allocation Hurdle" will be deemed to have been met when each Limited
Partner has been allocated net profits equal to 200% of its Capital
Commitment (i.e., an amount sufficient to enable the Fund to distribute to
each Limited Partner an amount equal to 300% of its Capital Commitment).
ii. Second, after the First Allocation Hurdle has been met, and until the
"Second Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is met, (x) 10O% to the
General Partner until the General Partner has been allocated 25% of the
Fund's net profits and (y) thereafter allocations shall be made in a manner
necessary to cause cumulative net profit and loss to be allocated 75% to the
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
DISTRIBUTIONS:
Partners, in proportion to their relative Capital Commitments, and 25% to the
General Partner. The "Second Allocation Hurdle" will be deemed to have
been met when each Limited Partner has been allocated net profits equal to
500% of its Capital Commitment (i.e., an amount sufficient to enable the
Fund to distribute to each Limited Partner an amount equal to 600% of its
Capital Commitment).
iii. Third, after the Second Allocation Hurdle has been met, (x) 100% to the
General Partner until the General Partner has been allocated 30% of the
Fund's net profits and (y) thereafter 70% to the Partners, pro rata in
proportion to their relative Capital Commitments, and 30% to the General
Partner.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, (i) the General Partner will receive priority
allocations of net profits equal to all prior Fee Adjustments and (ii) to the
extent that an allocation of loss would cause the General Partner's capital
account to be reduced to less than the product of the General Partner's
proportionate share of the aggregate Capital Commitments of the Fund and
the sum of the balances of the capital accounts of all Partners (a "Contingent
Loss"), such loss will be reallocated to all Limited Partners in proportion to
their relative Capital Commitments, except as necessary to account for the
General Partner's "clawback" obligation described below.
To the extent Limited Partners have been allocated Contingent Losses,
subsequent profits will be allocated first to the Limited Partners until such
Contingent Losses have been restored and then in accordance with the first
clause of the preceding sentence.
The General Partner may cause the Fund to make distributions of cash or
marketable securities from time to time in its discretion, subject to reasonable
cash reserves for Fund expenses. No more than 120% of the Fund's aggregate
Capital Commitments shall be invested in portfolio companies during the
term of the Fund. Distributions will be made as follows:

i. First, to all Partners in proportion to their relative Capital Commitments
until each Partner has received an amount equal to its aggregate capital
contributions.

ii. Second, until the cumulative amount distributed to each Partner is equal to
300% of such Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of distribution,
such distribution shall be made in the proportions necessary to cause
cumulative distributions (other than distributions made pursuant to (i) above)
to have been made, (x) 20% to the General Partner; and (y) 80% to all
Partners in proportion to their relative Capital Commitments.
iii. Third, after the aggregate amount distributed to each Limited Partner is
equal to 300% of such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date
of such distribution, 100% to the General Partner until it has received
aggregate distributions totaling 25% of (x) the aggregate distributions made
to the Partners pursuant to (ii) above plus (y) the aggregate Tax Distributions
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
TAX DISTRIBUTIONS:
CLAWBACK:
(as defined below) made to the Partners.

iv. Fourth, until the cumulative amount distributed to each Partner is equal to
600% of such Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of distribution,
such distribution shall be made in the proportions necessary to cause
cumulative distributions (other than distributions made pursuant to (i) above)
to have been made, (x) 25% to the General Partner; and (y) 75% to all
Partners in proportion to their relative Capital Commitments.

v. Fifth, after the aggregate amount distributed to each Limited Partner is
equal to 600% of such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date
of distribution, 100% to the General Partner until it has received aggregate
distributions totaling 30% of (x) the aggregate distributions made to the
Partners pursuant to (ii), (iii) and (iv) above plus (y) the aggregate Tax
Distributions made to the Partners.
vi. Sixth, (x) 30% to the General Partner; and (y) 70% to all Partners in
proportion to their relative Capital Commitments.
Following the end of each fiscal year, the General Partner may cause the
Fund to distribute cash to each Partner in an amount equal to the "Applicable
Tax Rate" (as defined below) multiplied by net taxable income (a "Tax
Distribution"), less all prior cash distributions; provided, that the General
Partner will have no obligation to make the foregoing distributions if the total
amount to be distributed to all Partners would be less than $1 million. For
each fiscal year, the amount distributed to any Partner as a Tax Distribution
shall not exceed the amount by which (A) such Partner's cumulative
aggregate annual tax liability with respect to the Fund for such fiscal year and
all prior fiscal years exceeds (B) the cumulative aggregate cash distributions
made to such Partner as Tax Distributions and other regular distributions
through the end of such fiscal year and all prior fiscal years.
The "Applicable Tax Rate" means the highest blended federal, state and local
marginal income, self employment and medicare tax rates then applicable to
an individual residing in any state of the United States, applied by taking into
account the character of the taxable income in question capital gain,
ordinary income, etc.).
The General Partner will be required to pay back to the Fund the amount by
which the cumulative net distributions received by the General Partner over
the life of the Fund (excluding amounts received by the General Partner in
respect of its Capital Commitment) exceeds the product of (A) the applicable
carried interest percentage; and (ii) the aggregate amount of profit
distributions made to all Partners during the whole term of the Fund;
provided, that the General Partner will not be obligated to pay an amount in
excess of the aggregate carried interest and profit distributions it has received
(valued at the time of distribution in the case of securities distributions) less
the gross tax liabilities the General Partner would have incurred on such
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
EXPENSES:
FUND MANAGEMENT
& CERTAIN CONFLICTS
OF INTEREST:
distributions if at all times the General Partner were subject to the Applicable
Tax Rate, all such allocation resulted from fully taxable transactions (plus any
tax benefit actually received by the General Partner in the year in which the
General Partner is required to make a clawback payment as reasonably
determined by the General Partner). Each managing member of the General
Partner will be severally liable for and will personally guaranty his or her pro
rata share of the General Partner's remaining obligation.
In addition to the amount to be contributed by the General Partner pursuant to
the foregoing paragraph, if, upon liquidation of the Partnership, the
cumulative Fee Adjustments applied against Management Fees exceeds the
sum of (i) the cumulative profits of the Fund for all accounting periods less

(ii) the cumulative losses of the Fund for all accounting periods (such amount
the "Deemed Contribution Shortfall"), then the General Partner or its
designated affiliate with a capital contribution obligation shall be required to
pay back to the Fund, the lesser of (x) the Deemed Contribution Shortfall and
(y) the distributions received by the General Partner or its affiliate that are
attributable to the cumulative amount of Profit allocated to the General
Partner with respect to such Fee Adjustments, in each case less the gross tax
liabilities that the General Partner would have incurred on all allocations of
taxable income (net of losses) made with respect to such Fee Adjustments.
From the management fee, the Management Company and the General
Partner will pay all normal operating expenses incurred in connection with
the management of the Fund, the General Partner and the Management
Company, including without limitation salaries, wages, rent, travel and other
expenses of employees, consultants and agents of the Fund, the General
Partner and the Management Company (other than consultants retained in
connection with investments or proposed investments). The Fund will pay all
expenses incurred in the investigation, holding, purchase, sale or exchange of
investments, and certain other related Fund expenses, such as legal, audit and
accounting expenses (including third party bookkeeping services).
The Fund will bear the out-of-pocket expenses incident to the organization of
the Fund and the General Partner up to a maximum of $500,000.
Each opportunity to invest at least $150,000 into a company that is presented
to the Managing Members and that otherwise meets the investment objectives
of the Fund (i.e., the potential investment is within the Fund's stated scope,
the potential investment is sufficiently large, the potential investment is not
expected to require an inordinate portion of the Fund's capital, the company
is at an appropriate stage of development, the Fund has sufficient capital
available at the time the investment is to be made, etc.), shall be offered to the
Fund and each Parallel Fund in proportion to their relative available capital;
provided, however, that the preceding restriction shall only apply from the
due date of the initial capital contribution until the end of the "Time Standard
Period" (as defined below); provided, further, that any opportunities may be
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
allocated in whole or in part to the Partnership's prior funds until the prior
funds are filly invested or reserved; provided, further, that the foregoing shall
not apply to any investment opportunity with respect to which: (i) a
Managing Member's participation in such company has been approved by the
Advisory Committee; (ii) a Managing Member (or an affiliate thereof or any
investment fund managed thereby) has initially invested prior to the date of
the Fund's initial closing; (iii) the General Partner has determined, in good
faith, does not meet the investment objectives of the Fund; or (iv) is to be
held by a Special Purpose Investment Fund (as defined below).
Peter Thiel and the Thiel Persons (as defined below) are not required to
present or offer to the Fund or any Parallel Fund any investment
opportunities.
The General Partner, the Management Company, the Managing Members and
their respective affiliates, members and employees may engage, directly or
indirectly, in other businesses or activities, including but not limited to buying
and selling securities for their own accounts, the accounts of prior investment
funds and other investment vehicles.
The Fund may invest in any portfolio company in which a Successor Fund or
Prior Fund (or any other investment fund managed by any of the General
Partner, the "Affiliated Parties" (as defined below) or their affiliates) holds an
interest; provided, however, that the Fund may not make an investment of
more than $5 million in any such company without the consent of the
Advisory Committee. In addition, without the consent of the Advisory
Committee, the Fund shall not invest in any company in which the Managing
Members, the General Partner, the Management Company or any of their
Affiliates hold a direct interest an interest not held through a Successor
Fund, Prior Fund or other investment fund managed by any of the General
Partner, the Affiliated Parties or their Affiliates).
The Fund may not purchase an interest in a portfolio company from, or sell
securities to, the General Partner, any Affiliated Party, any "Thiel Person" (as
defined below) or any of their respective affiliates, members and employees
(or any investment fund managed by any of the foregoing) without the
consent of the Advisory Committee.
The term "Affiliated Party" means any of the General Partner, the Managing
Members, the Management Company or any member or employee or
Affiliate thereof; provided, however, that Peter Thiel, Peter Thiel's retirement
accounts and Thiel Capital LLC and any wholly owned subsidiary of the
foregoing ("Thiel Persons") shall not be deemed as an Affiliated Party or an
affiliate of any Affiliated Party.
The Fund will not have any right of first refusal with respect to the
investment opportunities or existing portfolio companies of Peter Thiel, nor
any Thiel Persons, nor any other investment funds managed by Peter Thiel or
any Thiel Person.
Without prior approval of the Advisory Committee, (i) no more than 5% of
the Fund's Capital Commitments may be invested in a "blind pool"
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
investment fund that is managed and controlled by an unaffiliated third party
and that pays its manager performance based compensation ; (ii) no more
than 25% of the Fund's Capital Commitments may be invested in any one
portfolio company; (iii) no more than 15% of the Fund's Capital
Commitments may be invested in publicly traded securities; and (iv) the Fund
may not incur indebtedness, or guaranty portfolio company indebtedness, in
excess of the lesser of (A) 10% of the Fund's Capital Commitments, and (B)
the amount of aggregate Capital Commitments of the Partners that have not
been contributed to the Fund as of the date of such debt or guaranty.
TIME COMMITMENT & During the Time Standard Period, and so long as they are managing members
FORMATION OF A of the General Partner, each Managing Member will devote substantially all
SUCCESSOR FUND: of his business time to the affairs of the Management Company, the General
Partner, the Parallel Funds, certain pre-existing investment vehicles, and the
Fund. Following the earlier of (i) such time as at least 75% of the Capital
Commitments of the Fund has been invested, committed or reserved for
investment in portfolio companies, or applied, committed or reserved for
working capital and expenses and (ii) the end of the Commitment Period (the
"Time Standard Period"), the Managing Members will devote such time as
they reasonably deem to be appropriate to the Fund.
The General Partner and the Managing Members may form a "Successor
Fund" to the Fund following the end of the Time Standard Period.
In addition, during the Time Standard Period, the General Partner and the
Managing Members and their respective affiliates may form "Special Purpose
Investment Funds." A Special Purpose Investment Fund is a fund created to
invest in a specified investment opportunity which may or may not meet the
Fund's investment objectives, but which does meet the following criteria: (a)
each Partner is provided the first opportunity (on at least seven (7) days
advance notice) to invest in such special purpose investment fund on a pro
rata basis determined by reference to the total of (x) the Partners' respective
Capital Commitments and (y) the respective capital commitments of the
constituent partners in any Parallel Funds, and (b) such special purpose
investment fund charges a carried interest and/or management fee that are no
higher than those charged to the Fund. A Special Purpose Investment Fund
may not have aggregate capital commitments that exceed 30% of the
aggregate Capital Commitments to the Fund without the Advisory
Committee's approval.
Peter Thiel and the Thiel Persons shall not be required to devote any time to
the affairs of the Management Company, the General Partner, the Parallel
Funds, the pre-existing investment vehicles or the Fund.
REMOVAL OF
GENERAL PARTNER
Within 180 days following the occurrence of certain events constituting
"cause" (as defined in the Partnership Agreement), a Two-Thirds-in-Interest
of the Limited Partners may elect to remove the General Partner. If the
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
UNRELATED BUSINESS
TAXABLE INCOME &
STATUS As A
VENTURE CAPITAL
OPERATING COMPANY:
PARALLEL FUNDS:
Limited Partners vote to remove the General Partner, a replacement general
partner may be appointed on such economic terms and with such subscription
as the replacement general partner and a Two -Thirds -in-Interest of the
Limited Partners may agree. The replacement general partner shall continue
the business of the Partnership until dissolution in normal course, pursuant to
the terms of the Partnership Agreement.
Upon the removal of the General Partner, the former General Partner shall not
be obligated to make any additional capital contributions to the Partnership
and the former General Partner's entire interest in the Partnership shall be
converted to that of a Limited Partner with a capital contribution and capital
account balance equal to those of the former General Partner. The former
General Partner, as a Limited Partner: (i) shall be entitled to receive all
allocations and distributions to which it would otherwise be entitled to receive
had it not been removed when, as and if such allocations and distributions are
made, in respect of all activities of and investments by the Fund that occurred
or were committed to by the Fund prior to the effective date of removal; and
(ii) the removed General Partner shall be entitled to receive one hundred
percent (100%) of all allocations and distributions in respect of its capital
contributions. The removed General Partner shall not be entitled to receive
any payments of management fee with respect to any period of time after the
date of its removal.
The General Partner will use its reasonable best efforts to conduct its affairs
to ensure that no tax-exempt Limited Partner (or any of its equity owners)
will be allocated unrelated business taxable income ("UBTF) within the
meaning of Section 512 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (the "Code"),
as amended.
The General Partner will use its commercially reasonable efforts to (i) avoid
having the Fund treated as being engaged in a trade or business within the
United States under the Code; (ii) avoid the Fund realizing income that is or
is treated as "effectively connected" with the conduct of a trade or business in
the United States under the Code; or (iii) prevent the Fund from acquiring any
interest in real property located in the United States for purposes of Section
897 of the Code or in any company that is a "United States real property
holding corporation" within the meaning of the Code.
The General Partner will use its reasonable best efforts to operate the Fund so
that it will be treated as a "venture capital operating company" under ERISA,
if "equity participation" in the Fund held by "benefit plan investors" is
"significant" within the meaning of ERISA.
The General Partner may form (a) one or more investment partnerships or
similar entities that may not charge management fees or carried interest and
will be comprised of the members of the General Partner or consultants to,
and other persons having strategic or other important relationships with, the
Fund and (b) one or more investment partnerships or similar entities formed
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
to accommodate the tax, regulatory or legal needs of investors (including,
without limitation, non-United States investors) who would otherwise invest
as Limited Partners of the Fund on substantially similar terms, including
economic terms, as the Fund (collectively, the "Parallel Funds"). Each
Parallel Fund will simultaneously invest in the same securities on the same
terms and at the same price as the Fund, except in cases in which the portfolio
company gives written notice that a Parallel Fund will not be permitted to so
invest, or where such investment is not permitted by applicable law or by the
terms of the governing agreement of such Parallel Fund. The Fund and the
Parallel Funds shall make and dispose of an investment, or make a
distribution, on a part passe basis. Investment by each Parallel Fund and the
Fund will be according to available capital.
INDEMNIFICATION: The Fund, out of its assets only, may indemnify the General Partner, the
Management Company, the members of the Advisory Committee, and each
officer, employee or member of the foregoing, against all liabilities incurred
in connection with any action, suit or proceeding arising out of or in
connection with such indemnitee's activities or involvement with the Fund, or
with any other enterprise that such indemnitee is or was serving, as a director,
officer, employee or othenvise, at the request of the Fund; provided, that this
indemnity may not extend to any action, suit or proceeding arising out of or in
connection with (I) conduct not undertaken in good faith, (2) any conduct
which constitutes recklessness, bad faith, gross negligence or intentionally
wrongful conduct, (3) any action, suit or proceeding solely between or among
the General Partner, the Management Company, the Managing Members or
their respective members, employees, affiliates or agents, or (4) any action,
suit or proceeding that arises from any material breach by the General Partner
of the Partnership Agreement or of its fiduciary duties to the Partnership that
has a material adverse effect upon the economic interests of the Limited
Partners of the Fund. In addition, the Fund shall not make any advancement
of expenses for any claim, action or demand brought by a Majority -in-Interest
of the Limited Partners. In the event that an indemnitee is also entitled to
indemnification from a portfolio company, the portfolio company will be the
primary source of indemnification, the Fund will be the secondary source of
indemnification, and the General Partner or the Management Company will
be the tertiary source of indemnification If the Fund's assets are insufficient,
the General Partner may (a) call for any unfunded Capital Commitments and
(b) recall distributions previously made to the Partners, solely for the purpose
of fulfilling an indemnity obligation of the Fund described in the preceding
paragraph. In no event will any Partner be required to return amounts
pursuant to the foregoing clause (13) in an amount in excess of 25% of any
Partner's Capital Commitment. In no event will the General Partner be
permitted to call capital pursuant to the foregoing clauses (a) and (b) more
than two years after dissolution of the Fund, or in connection with a recalled
distribution, more than three years after the date of such distribution.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
VIII. CERTAIN RISK FACTORS
Prospective investors should be aware that an investment in the Partnership involves a high degree of
risk and, therefore, should be undertaken only by investors capable of evaluating the risks of the
Partnership and bearing the risks it represents. There can be no assurance that the Partnership's
investment objectives will be achieved, or that an investor will receive a return of its capital, and
therefore, an investor should only invest in the Partnership if such investor is able to withstand a total
loss of its investment. In addition, there will be occasions when the General Partner, the Management
Company and their affiliates may encounter potential conflicts of interest in connection with the
Partnership. The following considerations, among others, should be carefully evaluated before making
an investment in the Partnership.
RISKS INHERENT IN VENTURE CAPITAL INVESTMENTS. The Partnership will invest substantially all of
its available capital (other than capital the General Partner determines to retain in cash or cash
equivalents or capital applied toward Partnership expenses and liabilities) in securities of portfolio
companies. The types of investments that the Partnership anticipates making involve a high degree of
risk. In general, financial and operating risks confronting portfolio companies can be significant.
While targeted returns should reflect the perceived level of risk in any investment situation, there can be
no assurance that the Partnership will be adequately compensated for risks taken. A loss of an
investor's entire investment is possible. The timing of profit realization is highly uncertain. Losses are
likely to occur early in the Partnership's term, while successes often require a long maturation.
Early-stage and development -stage companies often experience unexpected problems in the areas of
product development, manufacturing, marketing, financing and general management, which, in some
cases, cannot be adequately solved. in addition, such companies may require substantial amounts of
financing which may not be available through institutional private placements or the public markets. In
addition, the markets that such companies target are highly competitive and in many cases the
competition consists of larger companies with access to greater resources. The percentage of
companies that survive and prosper can be small.
Investments in more mature companies in the expansion or profitable stage involve substantial risks.
Such companies typically have obtained capital in the form of debt and/or equity to expand rapidly,
reorganize operations, acquire other businesses, or develop new products and markets. These activities
by definition involve a significant amount of change in a company and could give rise to significant
problems in sales, manufacturing, and general management of these activities.
The Partnership may invest a substantial portion of its assets in companies with modest capitalization.
While the General Partner believes that small and medium-sized companies can provide greater growth
potential than larger, more mature companies, investing in the securities of such companies also
involves greater risk, potential price volatility and cost. Investments in these companies often involve
higher risks because the companies lack the management experience, financial resources, product
diversification, markets, distribution channels and competitive strengths of larger companies. In
addition, in many instances, the frequency and volume of the trading activity in their stock is
substantially less than is typical of larger companies. Therefore, the securities of smaller companies
may be subject to wider price fluctuations. The spreads between the bid and asked prices of the
securities of these companies in the over-the-counter markets typically are larger than the spreads for
more actively traded securities. As a result, the Partnership could incur a loss if it were to sell such a
security a short time after its acquisition. When making a large sale, the Partnership may have to sell a
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
portfolio holding at a discount from quoted prices or may have to make a series of small sales over an
extended period of time because of the limited trading volume of smaller company securities.
INVESTMENT IN COMPANIES DEPENDENT UPON SCIENTIFIC DEVELOPMENTS AND TECHNOLOGIES.
The Partnership plans to focus its investing primarily on technology and technology-related companies.
The value of the Partnership's interests may be susceptible to factors affecting such companies and to a
greater risk and market fluctuation than an investment in a fund that invests in a broader range of
securities. The specific risks faced by such companies include:

• rapidly changing science and technologies;
• new competing products and improvements in existing products which may quickly render
existing products or technologies obsolete;

• exposure, in certain circumstances, to a high degree of government regulation, making these
companies susceptible to changes in government policy and failures to secure, or unanticipated
delays in securing, regulatory approvals;

• scarcity of management, technical, scientific, research and marketing personnel with
appropriate training;
the possibility of lawsuits related to intellectual property rights; and
• rapidly changing investor sentiments and preferences with regard to technology sector
investments (which are generally perceived as risky).
INVESTMENT IN PUBLICLY TRADED SECURITIES. The Partnership may invest in publicly traded
securities. Investments in public securities can entail certain risks. For example, the Partnership, the
General Partner and the Management Company may obtain less information and disclosure about a
company whose securities are publicly traded than from a privately held company. Further, the market
for publicly traded securities is extremely volatile due to economic conditions, political events, and for
many other reasons. Such volatility may adversely affect the ability of the Partnership to dispose of
investments or affect the value of investment securities on the date of sale by the Partnership.
Furthermore, notwithstanding the existence of a public market for the securities of a particular portfolio
company of the Partnership, publicly traded securities held by the Partnership may be thinly traded or
may cease to be traded after the Partnership invests in them. Any securities that the Partnership holds
that are thinly traded may be subject to wider price fluctuations than other companies whose securities
are more actively traded, and the spreads between the bid and ask prices of thinly traded securities of
these companies may be larger than the spreads for more actively traded securities. There can be no
assurance that the Partnership's investments in publicly traded securities will be profitable, and there is
a material risk that the Partnership could incur losses from its investments in publicly traded securities.
INVESTMENTS IN PIPES. The Partnership may be involved in private investments in public equities
("PIPEs") or private financing of public companies. PIPE transactions may involve the sale of equity-
like securities of an already public company. In a PIPE transaction, the Partnership may bear the price
risk from the time of pricing until the time of closing. In addition, the Partnership may have to commit
to purchase a specified number of shares at a fixed price, with the closing conditioned upon, among
other things, the Securities and Exchange Commission's preparedness to declare effective a resale
registration statement covering the resale, from time to time, of the shares sold in the private financing.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
No ASSURANCE OF RETURNS. There can be no assurance that the Limited Partners will receive
distributions from the Partnership in an amount equal to their investment in the Partnership. The timing
of profit realization, if any, is highly uncertain.
LACK OF OPERATING HISTORY. The Partnership and the General Partner are newly formed entities,
and, accordingly have no operating history, historical results or investments upon which investors can
evaluate the potential performance of the Partnership. The prior performance of the Managing
Members or their investments as described in this Memorandum is not necessarily indicative of the
Partnership's future results. There can be no assurance that investments by the Partnership will achieve
returns comparable to the historical performance reflected in this Memorandum, and in any event, the
returns achieved by the Partnership will be subject to the Management Fee and the General Partner's
carried interest. Any given investment made by the Partnership may prove to be worthless, and there is
a risk that investors could lose money.
RELIANCE ON THE GENERAL PARTNER. The General Partner will have sole discretion over the
investment of the funds committed to the Partnership as well as the ultimate realization of any profits.
The Limited Partners will not receive the detailed financial information issued by portfolio companies
that will be available to the Partnership. Accordingly, the Limited Partners will not have the
opportunity to evaluate the relevant economic, financial and other information that will be utilized by
the General Partner in its selection of investments. As such, the pool of funds in the Partnership
represents a blind pool of funds. Investors in the Partnership will be relying on the General Partner to
identify, structure, and implement investments consistent with the Partnership's investment objectives
and policies and to conduct the business of the Partnership as contemplated by this Memorandum. The
Limited Partners will not make decisions with respect to the management, disposition or other
realization of any investment made by the Partnership, or other decisions regarding the Partnership's
business and affairs.
RELIANCE ON THE PRINCIPALS. The loss of one or more of the principals of the General Partner could
have a significant adverse impact on the business of the Partnership. No assurances can be given that
each of the principals will continue to be affiliated with the Partnership throughout its term.
Notwithstanding any prior experience that such principals may have in making investments of the type
expected to be made by the Partnership, any such experience necessarily was obtained under different
market conditions and with different technologies at the forefront of development. There can be no
assurance that the principals of the General Partner will be able to duplicate prior levels of success.
LIMITED PORTFOLIO DIVERSIFICATION. As is typical of venture capital firms, the portfolio holdings
of the Partnership will not be broadly diversified. In addition, if the General Partner is unable to raise
sufficient capital commitments to the Partnership, the diversification of the portfolio holdings of the
Partnership will be further limited. A downturn of the economy or in the business of any one company
could impact the aggregate returns delivered to investors by the Partnership.
DIFFICULTY IN VALUING PORTFOLIO INVESTMENTS. Generally, there will be no readily available
market for a substantial number of the Partnership's investments and hence, most of the Partnership's
investments will be difficult to value. Despite the efforts of the General Partner and the Management
Company to acquire sufficient information to monitor certain of the Partnership's investments and make
well-informed valuation and pricing determinations, the General Partner and the Management Company
may only be able to obtain limited information at certain times. It is possible that the General Partner
and the Management Company may not be aware on a timely basis of material adverse changes that
have occurred with respect to certain of the Partnership's investments. The General Partner and the
Management Company may have to make valuation determinations without the benefit of an adequate
amount of relevant information. Prospective Limited Partners should be aware that as a result of these
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
difficulties, as well as other uncertainties, any valuation made by the General Partner and the
Management Company may not represent the fair market value of the securities acquired by the
Partnership.
COMPETITIVE MARKETPLACE. The marketplace for venture capital investing has become increasingly
competitive. Participation by financial intermediaries has increased, substantial amounts of funds have
been dedicated to making investments in the private sector and the competition for investment
opportunities is at high levels. Some of the Partnership's potential competitors may have greater
financial and personnel resources than the General Partner and the Management Company. There can
be no assurances that the General Partner and the Management Company will locate an adequate
number of attractive investment opportunities and the General Partner and the Management Company
may not be able to identify and successfully close a sufficient number of high quality investments to
utilize all of the Partnership's capital. Such competition may adversely impact the length of time
required to fully invest the Partnership's capital and may adversely impact returns to Limited Partners
in the Partnership.
CHANGING ECONOMIC CONDITIONS. The success of the investment strategy of the General Partner
and the Management Company could be significantly impacted by changing external economic
conditions in the United States and global economies. The stability and sustainability of growth in
global economies may be impacted by terrorism or acts of war. The availability, unavailability, or
hindered operation of external credit markets, equity markets and other economic systems which the
Partnership may depend upon to achieve its objectives may have a significant negative impact on the
Partnership's operations and profitability. There can be no assurance that such markets and economic
systems will be available or will be available as anticipated or needed for the Partnership to operate
successfully. Changing economic conditions could potentially adversely impact the valuation of
portfolio holdings.
MINORITY INVESTMENTS. A significant portion of the Partnership's investments may represent
minority stakes in privately held companies. In addition, during the process of exiting investments, the
Partnership is likely to hold minority equity stakes if portfolio holdings are taken public. As is the case
with minority holdings in general, such minority stakes that the Partnership may hold will have neither
the control characteristics of majority stakes nor the valuation premiums accorded majority or
controlling stakes. The Partnership may also invest in companies for which the Partnership has no right
to appoint a director or othenvise exert significant influence. In such cases, the Partnership will be
reliant on the existing management and board of directors of such companies, which may include
representatives of other financial investors with whom the Partnership is not affiliated and whose
interests may conflict with the interests of the Partnership.
No ASSURANCE OF ADDITIONAL CAPITAL FOR INVESTMENTS. After the Partnership has financed a
company, continued development and marketing of products may require that additional financing be
provided. The Partnership expects to invest in companies that have substantial capital needs that are
typically funded over several stages of investment. No assurance can be given that such additional
financing will be available and no assurance can be made as to the terms upon which such financing
may be obtained. Alternatively, the Partnership, either directly or through one of its portfolio
companies, may elect to sell developed or undeveloped technologies to existing companies. No
assurance can be made that buyers for such technologies can be located or that the terms of any such
sales will be advantageous.
No ASSURANCE OF INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES. Although the Partnership expects to have
significant access to private investment opportunities through the network of relationships of the
Managing Members, there can be no assurance that investment opportunities for the Partnership will
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
materialize and that companies select the Partnership as an investor. Similarly, the Partnership may be
unable to identify or consummate investments in public companies that meet its criteria. There can be
no assurances that the General Partner and the Management Company will locate an adequate number
of attractive investment opportunities that meet the Partnership's investment objectives.
NATURE OF Mawr INVESTMENTS. Many of the Partnership's investments will be highly illiquid. As
such, there will be no public markets for the securities held by the Partnership and there can be no
assurance that the Partnership will be able to realize such investments in a timely manner. In addition,
the realization of value for any investments will not be possible or known with any certainty until the
General Partner and the Management Company elect, in their sole discretion, to sell the Partnership's
investments and subsequently distribute the proceeds to its Limited Partners or to distribute securities to
Limited Partners in lieu of cash. Also, since the Partnership may only make a limited number of
investments and since many of the Partnership's investments may involve a high degree of risk, poor
performance by a few of the investments could severely affect the total returns to the Limited Partners.
Additionally, it should be noted that past performance of the Managing Members and their affiliates is
not a guarantee of future results.
FUTURE AND PAST PERFORMANCE. The performance of the prior funds is not necessarily indicative of
the Partnership's future results. While the General Partner intends for the Partnership to make
investments that have estimated returns commensurate with the risks undertaken, there can be no
assurance that targeted results will be achieved. Loss of principal is possible on any given investment.
BRIDGE FINANCING. The Partnership may lend to portfolio companies on a short-term, unsecured basis
in anticipation of a future issuance of equity or long-term debt. Such bridge loans would typically be
convertible into a more permanent, long-term security; however, for reasons not always in the
Partnership's control, such long-term securities may not issue and such bridge loans may remain
outstanding. In such event, the interest rate on such loans may not adequately reflect the risk associated
with the unsecured position taken by the Partnership.
LEVERAGE. To the extent that any investment is made in a portfolio company with a leveraged capital
structure or any portfolio company borrows or enters into other financing transactions requiring
periodic payments, such investment will be subject to increased exposure to adverse economic factors
such as a significant rise in interest rates, a severe downturn in the economy or deterioration in the
condition of such company or its industry. If such a company is unable to generate sufficient cash flow
to meet principal and interest payments on its indebtedness, the value of any equity investment by the
Partnership in such company could be significantly reduced or even eliminated.
LIMITATIONS ON ABILITY TO EXIT INVESTMENTS. The General Partner expects to exit from its
investments in two principal ways: (i) private sales (including acquisitions of its portfolio companies)
and (ii) initial and secondary public offerings. At any particular time, one or both of these avenues may
not be open to the Partnership, or timing with respect to these exit mechanisms may be inopportune. As
such, the ability to exit from and liquidate portfolio holdings may be constrained at any particular time.
CERTAIN LITIGATION RISKS. The Partnership will be subject to a variety of litigation risks,
particularly if one or more of its portfolio companies face financial or other difficulties during the life of
the Partnership. Legal disputes, involving any or all of the Partnership, the General Partner, the
Management Company, their members or their affiliates, may arise from the Partnership's activities and
investments and could have a significant adverse effect on the Partnership.
POTENTIAL LIABILITIES. In connection with its investments, the Partnership may negotiate the right to
appoint one or more of the Managing Members or other employees or representatives of the
Management Company as a member of the portfolio company's board of directors. Such membership
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
on the board of directors of a company can result in the Partnership or the individual director being
named as a defendant in litigation or other disputes or investigations. The Partnership may also
participate in portfolio company financings at valuations lower than the valuations in preceding rounds
of financing. Disputes arising out of such down -round financings may result in the Partnership, the
General Partner, the Management Company, or their members being named as defendants. Typically,
portfolio companies will have insurance to protect directors and officers, but this insurance may be
inadequate. The Partnership will also indemnify the General Partner, the Managing Members, the
Management Company and their respective affiliates, among others, for liabilities incurred in
connection with operations of the Partnership, including liabilities arising from such disputes. Such
indemnification obligations and other liabilities could be substantial. The Partners may also be required
to return distributions previously made to them to satisfy the Partnership's indemnification obligations.
While the General Partner and the Management Company intend to manage the Partnership in a way
that will minimize exposure to these risks, the possibility of successful claims or lawsuits or adverse
regulatory action cannot be eliminated, and such events could have significant adverse effects on the
Partnership.
CONTINGENT LIABILITIES ON DISPOSITION OF INVESTMENTS. In connection with the disposition of
an investment in a portfolio company, the Partnership may be required to make representations about
the business and financial affairs of such company typical of those made in connection with the sale of
a business. To the extent that any such representations are inaccurate, the Partnership may be required
to indemnify the purchasers of such investment and may be liable to the purchasers for breach of
contract. These arrangements may result in the incurrence of contingent liabilities for which the
General Partner may establish reserves and escrows. In that regard, distributions may be delayed or
withheld until such reserve is no longer needed or the escrow period expires.
RESERVES. As is customary in the industry, the General Partner and the Management Company may
establish reserves for follow-on investments by the Partnership in portfolio companies, operating
expenses (including the Management Fee), Partnership liabilities, and other matters. Estimating the
appropriate amount of such reserves is difficult, especially for follow-on investment opportunities,
which are directly tied to the success and capital needs of portfolio companies. Inadequate or excessive
reserves could impair the investment returns to the Limited Partners. If reserves are inadequate, the
Partnership may be unable to take advantage of attractive follow-on or other investment opportunities
or to protect its existing investments from dilutive or other punitive terms associated with "pay -to-play"
or similar provisions. If reserves are excessive, the Partnership may decline attractive investment
opportunities or hold unnecessary amounts of capital in money market or similar low-yield accounts.
ABSENCE OF LIQUIDITY AND PUBLIC MARKETS. The Partnership's investments will generally be
private, illiquid holdings. As such, there will be no public markets for the securities held by the
Partnership and no readily available liquidity mechanism at any particular time for any of the
investments held by the Partnership. In addition, the realization of value from any investments will not
be possible or known with any certainty until the General Partner and the Management Company elect,
in their sole discretion, to sell the Partnership's investments and subsequently distribute the proceeds to
its investors or to distribute securities to investors in lieu of cash.
No MARKET; ILLIQUIDITY OF LIMITED PARTNER INTERESTS. An investment in the Partnership will
be illiquid and involves a high degree of risk. There is no public market for the limited partner interests
in the Partnership, and it is not expected that a public market will develop. Consequently, Limited
Partners will bear the economic risks of their investment for the term of the Partnership. Prospective
investors will be required to represent and agree that they are purchasing the limited partner interests for
their own account for investment only and not with a view to the resale or distribution thereof.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
CERTAIN LIMITATIONS ON ABILITY OF LIMITED PARTNERS TO TRANSFER THEIR INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIP. The transferability of interests in the Partnership will be restricted by the Partnership
Agreement and by United States federal and state securities laws. In general, Limited Partners will not
be able to sell or transfer their interests in the Partnership to third parties without the consent of the
General Partner.
LEGAL AND REGULATORY RISKS. The Partnership is not and does not expect to be registered as an
"investment company" under the United States Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the
"Investment Company Act"), pursuant to an exemption set forth in Sections 3(c)(I) and/or 3(cX7) of
the Investment Company Act. There is no assurance that such exemptions will continue to be available
to the Partnership. Due to the burdens of compliance with the Investment Company Act, the
performance of the Partnership's investment portfolio could be materially adversely affected, and risks
involved in financing portfolio companies could substantially increase, if the Partnership becomes
subject to registration under the Investment Company Act. Neither the Partnership nor its counsel can
assure investors that, under certain conditions, changed circumstances, or changes in the law, the
Partnership may not become subject to the Investment Company Act or other burdensome regulation.
TAX RISKS. Certain tax risks relating to an investment in the Partnership are discussed in the section
titled "Certain Tax and Regulatory Matters," which prospective investors should read carefully. No
assurances can be given that current tax laws, rulings and regulations will not be changed during the life
of the Partnership. In determining whether or not to make an investment in the Partnership, each
prospective Limited Partner should consider the tax consequences of such an investment. In addition,
each prospective Limited Partner is advised to consult its own tax counsel as to the U.S. federal income
tax consequences of an investment in the Partnership and as to applicable foreign, state and local taxes.
WITHHOLDING AND OTHER TAXES. The General Partner intends to structure the Partnership's
investments in a manner that is intended to achieve the Partnership's investment objectives and,
notwithstanding anything contained herein to the contrary, there can be no assurance that the structure
of any investment will be tax efficient for any particular investor or that any particular tax result will be
achieved. In addition, tax reporting requirements may be imposed on investors under the laws of the
jurisdictions in which investors are liable for taxation or in which the Partnership makes portfolio
investments. Prospective investors should consult their own professional advisors with respect to the
tax consequences to them of an investment in the Partnership under the laws of the jurisdiction in which
they are liable for taxation. Furthermore, the Partnership's returns in respect of its investments may be
reduced by withholding or other taxes imposed by jurisdictions in which the Partnership's portfolio
companies are organized.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST. The following discussion enumerates certain potential conflicts of interest
that should be carefully evaluated before making an investment in the Partnership. The following is not
intended as an exhaustive list of the potential conflicts. Instances may arise where the interest of the
General Partner (or its members), the Management Company and/or their affiliates may potentially or
actually conflict with the interests of the Partnership and the Limited Partners. Among others, investors
should consider the following conflicts of interest:

• The existence of the General Partner's carried interest may create an incentive for the General
Partner to make riskier or more speculative investments on behalf of the Partnership than it
would otherwise make in the absence of such performance -based arrangements.

• Conflicts may arise in the allocation of investment opportunities and the Managing Members'
time among the Partnership and parallel or co-investment entities, on the one hand, and any
prior or future investment funds or vehicles or other entities organized in accordance with the
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
Partnership Agreement or other fund(s) advised by the Management Company, on the other
hand.
• Conflicts may arise where the Partnership and parallel or co•investment entities invest in an
earlier or future round of financing of a portfolio company owned by a prior or future
investment funds or vehicles or other entities organized in accordance with the Partnership
Agreement or other fund(s) advised by the Management Company, or its affiliates. In such a
circumstance, the General Partner may cause the Partnership to invest in such portfolio
company at a higher valuation or lower valuation than such other investment funds, and may
earn lower profit, or realize higher loss, as a result.
The Management Company (and its principals or affiliates) or the General Partner may serve
as investment adviser or investment manager to other client accounts (including separately
managed accounts) and conduct investment activities for its own accounts. Such other entities
or accounts (the "Other Clients") may have investment objectives or may implement
investment strategies similar to those of the Partnership.
While certain assurances are provided in the Partnership Agreement to address these potential conflicts,
certain risks may remain. By acquiring an Interest in the Partnership, each Limited Partner will be
deemed to have acknowledged the existence of any such actual or potential conflicts of interest and to
have waived any claim with respect to any liability arising from the existence of any such conflicts of
interest.
DIVERSE INVESTORS. The Limited Partners may have conflicting investment, tax, and other interests
with respect to their investments in the Partnership. The conflicting interests of individual Limited
Partners may relate to or arise from, among other things, the nature of investments made by the
Partnership, the structuring or the acquisition of investments and the timing of disposition of
investments. As a consequence, conflicts of interest may arise in connection with decisions made by
the General Partner and the Management Company with respect to the nature or structuring of
investments that may be more beneficial for some Limited Partners than for others, particularly with
respect to investors' individual tax situations. In selecting and structuring investments appropriate for
the Partnership, the General Partner and the Management Company will consider the investment and
tax objective of the Partnership and the Partners as a whole, not the investment, tax or other objective of
any Limited Partner individually.
RISK OF DILUTION. Limited Partners subscribing for interests at subsequent closings will participate in
existing investments of the Partnership, diluting the interest of existing Limited Partners therein.
Although such Limited Partners will contribute their pro rata share of prior capital contributions
previously drawn down by the Partnership (plus an additional amount thereon), there can be no
assurance that such payment will reflect the fair value of the Partnership's existing investments at the
time such additional Limited Partners subscribe for such interests.
FAILURE TO MAKE CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS. If a Limited Partner fails to pay when due installments
of its capital commitment to the Partnership, and the contributions made by non•defaulting Limited
Partners and borrowings by the Partnership are inadequate to cover the defaulted capital contribution,
the Partnership may be unable to pay its obligations when due. As a result, the Partnership may be
subjected to significant penalties that could materially and adversely affect the returns to the Limited
Partners (including non•defaulting Limited Partners). If a Limited Partner defaults, it may be subject to
various remedies as provided in the Partnership Agreement.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
FOREIGN INVESTMENTS. The Partnership aims to make majority of its investments in companies that
are based outside of the United States or the operations of which are primarily outside of the United
States. Any investment in a foreign country involves risks not found in the domestic securities market,
including the following: the risk of economic and financial instability in the foreign country, which in
some cases may include a collapse in credit markets, stock prices, currencies and/or consumer
spending; the risk of adverse social and political developments, including nationalization, confiscation
without fair compensation, political and social instability and war; the risk that the foreign country may
impose restrictions on the repatriation of investment income or capital or on the ability of foreign
persons to invest in certain types of companies, assets or securities; risks related to the possible lack of
availability of sufficient financial information as a result of accounting, auditing, and financial
disclosure standards that differ, in some cases significantly, from those in the United States; risks
related to foreign laws and legal systems, which are likely to differ from those of the United States,
including in particular the laws with respect to the rights of investors which may not be as
comprehensive or well developed as those in the United States and the procedures for the judicial or
other enforcement of such rights which may not be as effective as in the United States; risks related to
the fact that some investments or portfolio company operations may be denominated in foreign
currencies and, therefore, will be subject to fluctuations in exchange rates; and risks related to
applicable tax laws and regulations and tax treaties, which are likely to vary from country to country
and may be less well developed than those in the United States, possibly resulting in retroactive taxation
so that the Partnership could become subject to an unanticipated local tax liability. The profits or losses
of the Partnership on any investment, as measured in United States dollars, will be affected by
fluctuations in currency exchange rates and exchange control regulations as well as by the success of
the investment itself. In addition, the Partnership may incur costs in connection with conversions
between various currencies. The Partnership does not presently intend to seek to reduce currency risks
through "hedging" or other methods.
AIFMD. The European Union ("EU') Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive ("AIFMD")
came into force on July 22,2013. AIFMD regulates the activities of private fund managers undertaking
fund management activities or marketing fund interests to investors within the EU. If the Partnership is
marketed to EU-based investors: (i) the Partnership may be subject to certain reporting, disclosure and
other compliance obligations under AIFMD, which may result in the Partnership incurring additional
costs and expenses; and (ii) AIFMD will also restrict certain activities of the Partnership in relation to
EU portfolio companies including, in some circumstances, the Partnership's ability to recapitalize,
refinance or potentially restructure an EU portfolio company within the first two years of ownership.
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION. The Partnership Agreement will contain confidentiality provisions
intended to protect proprietary and other information relating to the Partnership and the Partnership's
portfolio companies. To the extent that such information is publicly disclosed, competitors of the
Partnership and/or competitors of its portfolio companies, and others, may benefit from such
information, thereby adversely affecting the Partnership, its portfolio companies, the General Partner
and the economic interests of Limited Partners.
COUNSEL TO THE PARTNERSHIP DOES NOT REPRESENT THE LIMITED PARTNERS. The General
Partner has retained Cooley LLP in connection with the formation of the Partnership and may retain
Cooley LLP as legal counsel in connection with the management and operation of the Partnership,
including, without limitation, the making and holding of investments. Cooley LLP will not represent
any Limited Partner or prospective limited partner of the Partnership, unless the General Partner and
such Limited Partner or prospective limited partner otherwise agree and such Limited Partner or
prospective limited partner separately engages Cooley LLP, in connection with the formation of the
Partnership, the offering of the Interests, the management and operation of the Partnership or any
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
dispute that may arise between any Limited Partner, on the one hand, and the General Partner, the
Partnership, the Management Company and/or their affiliates on the other hand (the "Partnership Legal
Matters"). Any Limited Partner or prospective limited partner will, if it wishes counsel on any
Partnership Legal Matter, retain its own independent counsel with respect thereto and will pay all fees
and expenses of such independent counsel. Each Limited Partner and prospective limited partner
acknowledges that Cooley LLP may represent the General Partner and/or the Partnership in connection
with any and all Partnership Legal Mailers.
WRITTEN AGREEMENTS. The Partnership, the General Partner and the Management Company will be
authorized, without the approval of any Limited Partner, to enter into side letters or similar written
agreements with Limited Partners that have the effect of establishing rights under, or altering or
supplementing the terms of this Memorandum, the Partnership Agreement, such Limited Partner's
Subscription Agreement or other related agreements. The ability of other Limited Partners to elect to
receive the benefit of such side agreements will be limited.
The foregoing risks do not purport to be a complete enumeration or explanation of all the risks
involved in acquiring an interest in the Partnership. Potential investors are urged to read this
entire Memorandum, the Subscription Agreement and the Partnership Agreement and consult
their own advisers before making a determination whether to invest in the Partnership.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
IX. CERTAIN TAX AND REGULATORY MATTERS
A. Certain United States Federal Income Tax Considerations
Set forth below is a discussion, in summary form, of certain United States federal income tax
consequences relating to an investment in the Partnership. This summary does not attempt to present
all aspects of the United States federal income tax laws or any state, local or foreign laws that may
affect an investment in the Partnership. In particular, foreign investors, financial institutions,
insurance companies, tax-exempt entities and other investors of special status must consult with their
own professional tax advisors. No ruling has been or will be requested from the United States Internal
Revenue Service (the "IRS") and no assurance can be given that the IRS will agree with the tax
consequences described in this summary. Each prospective Limited Partner should consult with its own
tax adviser in order to fully understand the United States federal, state, local and foreign income tax
consequences of an investment in the Partnership.
PARTNERSHIP STATUS. The Partnership will be classified and reported as a partnership for U.S. federal
income tax purposes.
TAXATION OF PARTNERS. Each partner (a "Partner") will report on its federal income tax return its
distributive share of the Partnership's items of income, gain, loss, deduction and credit for the taxable
year. The character of such items, determined at the Partnership level, will pass through to the Partners
(for example, Partners will treat as interest, dividends or capital gain, their distributive shares of such
items recognized by the Partnership).
Each Partner will be required to report on its federal income tax return its distributive share of any
income or gain recognized by the Partnership, whether or not amounts representing such distributive
share have been distributed to it.
Distributions from the Partnership, whether made currently or upon liquidation of the Partnership,
generally may be received by a Partner without further tax. The general rules relating to the tax
treatment of distributions to the Partners may be summarized as follows:

i. Cash distributions will not be taxable to a Partner except to the extent they exceed the Partner's tax
basis for its interest in the Partnership. The excess generally would be taxable as long-term or
short-term capital gain, depending on the Partner's holding period for its Partnership interest;

ii. In-kind distributions of portfolio securities or other assets of the Partnership generally will not be
taxable to the recipient Partner or the Partnership. A partner that receives a distribution of
marketable securities from a partnership generally is required to recognize taxable gain to the extent
that the fair market value of the distributed securities exceeds the partner's tax basis in its
partnership interest. There are a number of exceptions to this rule, including an exception for
distributions by qualified "investment partnerships." It is expected that the Partnership will qualify
as an "investment partnership" and that, accordingly, distributions of marketable securities by the
Partnership generally will not give rise to the current recognition of taxable gain;
iii. For purposes of determining a Partner's gain or loss on a subsequent sale of the Partnership's assets
distributed in-kind (other than in liquidation of the Partner's interest in the Partnership), the
Partner's tax basis for such assets will be equal to the Partnership's adjusted basis for the assets or,
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
if less, the Partner's tax basis for its Partnership interest immediately before the distribution. A
Partner's tax basis for assets distributed in liquidation of its Partnership interest will be equal to its
tax basis in its Partnership interest. A Partner's capital gain holding period for assets distributed
without the recognition of gain will include the period during which the assets were held by the
Partnership; and
iv. No loss will be recognized by a Partner upon the receipt of a distribution from the Partnership
except where the distribution is a liquidating distribution consisting solely of cash, and the amount
of cash is less than the Partner's tax basis in its Partnership interest immediately before the
distribution.
DEDUCTIONS. Subject to certain limitations described below, a Partner will be entitled to deduct on its
federal income tax return its distributive share of Partnership loss, but not in excess of its tax basis in its
Partnership interest. If a Partner's distributive share of Partnership loss exceeds the Partner's tax basis
in its Partnership interest, such excess may not be deducted but will be carried over and become
deductible in any later year if and to the extent the Partner's tax basis exceeds zero and such loss
carryover is otherwise deductible. Each Limited Partner should have a sufficient tax basis in its
Partnership interest to deduct losses up to an amount equal to its cash investment in the Partnership.
The "at risk" provisions of Section 465 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the
"Code"), impose additional ►imitations on the deductibility of partnership losses, but the at risk
provisions are not expected to limit the Partners' ability to deduct Partnership losses.
In the case of a Partner who is an individual, expenses of producing income, including management
fees, are to be aggregated with unreimbursed employee business expenses and other expenses of
producing income and the aggregate amount of such expenses will be deductible only to the extent such
amount exceeds 2% of a taxpayer's adjusted gross income. In addition, total allowable itemized
deductions, other than medical costs, casualty and theft losses, and investment interest expense, are
reduced by a percentage of the taxpayer's adjusted gross income in excess of a threshold amount.
Expenses subject to the limitations in the preceding paragraph do not include expenses incurred in
connection with a trade or business. Whether the Partnership will be engaged in a trade or business for
federal income tax purposes is not certain. The General Partner believes that the Partnership will not be
engaged in a trade or business. Assuming the Partnership is not engaged in a trade or business, an
individual Partner's share of certain expenses of the Partnership will be subject to the two limitations
described in the preceding paragraph.

Section 469 of the Code limits the deductibility of losses from passive activities. These provisions
apply to individuals, estates, trusts, personal service corporations and closely held corporations. In
general, a taxpayer's losses from passive activities may only be offset against income from passive
activities and not against income such as salary or investment income. Any amount of passive activity
loss that is disallowed will be carried over to the following years to offset passive activity gains in such
subsequent years. A passive activity is any activity that involves the conduct of a trade or business and
in which the taxpayer does not materially participate. Although, as noted above, there is uncertainty
whether the activities of the Partnership will constitute a trade or business as that concept has been
interpreted by the IRS and the courts, the General Partner believes that the Partnership's activities will
not be considered a trade or business activity to which the passive activity loss provisions of the Code
would apply.
CAPITAL GAIN, DIVIDEND AND QUALIFIED SMALL BUSINESS STOCK TAX RATES. The Partnership
expects that its gains and losses from its securities transactions typically will be capital gains and capital
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
losses. Property held for more than one year generally will be eligible for long-term capital gain or loss
treatment.
Under current federal income tax law, the maximum federal ordinary income tax rate for individuals is
39.6% and, in general, the maximum individual income tax rate for long-term capital gains is 20%,
although in all cases the effective rates may be higher due to the phase out of certain tax deductions,
exemptions and credits. The excess of capital losses over capital gains may be offset against the
ordinary income of an individual taxpayer, subject to an annual deduction limitation of $3,000; unused
capital losses may be carried forward indefinitely but may not be carried back. For corporate taxpayers,
the maximum federal income tax rate is 35%. Capital losses of a corporate taxpayer may be offset only
against capital gains, but unused capital losses may be carried back three years (subject to certain
limitations) and carried fonvard five years.
A 3.8% Medicare tax is generally imposed on the net investment income of high-income individuals,
estates and trusts. Partnership capital gain and other income will generally be subject to the 3.8%
Medicare tax.
In general, non-corporate investors that, directly or via a pass-through entity such as the Partnership,
hold "qualified small business stock" ("QSBS") for more than 5 years are permitted to exclude from
taxable income a portion of any gain subsequently recognized upon a sale or exchange of such stock.
For each non-corporate investor, the amount of gain eligible for the QSBS exclusion generally is
limited to the greater of: (i) 10 times the investor's basis in the stock or (ii) a total of $10 million with
regard to stock in the issuing corporation. The remaining portion of the gain on such stock, if any, is
subject to tax at a maximum capital gains rate of 28%. For federal alternative minimum tax purposes, a
portion of the QSBS exclusion is generally treated as a preference item.
To be treated as small business stock eligible for the QSBS exclusion, stock must have been acquired at
original issue from a qualified small business corporation after August 10, 1993. In general, a qualified
small business corporation is a domestic "C" corporation that, immediately after issuing the stock in
question, has $50 million or less in gross assets and satisfies certain other requirements. Because
several of these requirements must continue to be satisfied after the issuance of qualified stock, it is
possible that the stock may cease to qualify as small business stock due to events occurring after the
issue date.
Accordingly, there can be no assurance that any stock acquired directly or indirectly by the Partnership
would qualify for the QSBS exclusion, even if such stock qualifies as small business stock at the time of
acquisition. In addition, no assurances can be given that the General Partner will have or provide to
Partners information about any particular stock investment necessary to determine its status as QSBS,
or to satisfy applicable tax reporting requirements related to QSBS treatment.
ROLLOVER FOR QUALIFIED SMALL BUSINESS STOCK. Under Section 1045 of the Code, if an
individual (i) realizes gain on a sale of QSBS that has been held by the individual for more than six
months, and (ii) within 60 days after such sale, purchases new QSBS, the individual generally is
required to recognize (and pay tax on) such gain only to the extent that the net proceeds from the
original stock exceed the cost of the newly purchased stock. Any remaining gain is carried over to the
newly purchased stock and may be recognized (and be taxable) upon a subsequent disposition of such
stock. The benefits of Section 1045 are generally available to individuals who purchase, hold and sell
qualified small business stock indirectly through a pass-through entity such as the Partnership, although
the extent to which a qualifying rollover may be made through a pass-through entity is limited. No
assurances can be given that the General Partner will have or provide to Partners information about any
particular stock investment necessary to determine its eligibility for a Section 1045 rollover, or to
satisfy applicable tax reporting requirements related to a rollover.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
TAX-EXEMPT LIMITED PARTNERS. Income recognized by tax-exempt entities, including qualified
retirement plans (stock, bonus, pension or profit-sharing plans described in Section 40I(a) of the Code)
and individual retirement accounts, is generally exempt from federal income tax. Section 511 of the
Code, however, imposes a tax on such an entity's Unrelated Business Taxable Income ("UBTF").
UBTI is income from a trade or business regularly carried on unrelated to the entity's exempt purpose.
Most types of passive investment income, including dividends, interest, royalties and gains from the
sale of securities are excluded from UBTI. UBTI could also be generated to the extent of the
Partnership's "unrelated debt financed income", if any. Unrelated debt financed income is income
derived from property with respect to which there is outstanding acquisition indebtedness and the use of
such property is unrelated to its exempt purpose. Dividends, interest, annuities, royalties, gains from
the sale of securities and other receipts otherwise excluded in computing unrelated business taxable
income nevertheless may be included to the extent property generating those receipts is debt financed.
In addition, UBTI could be generated by the Partnership if it invests in businesses operated as pass-
through entities such as partnerships and limited liability companies.
FOREIGN PARTNERS. The federal income tax treatment of Partners who are non-resident aliens of the
United States will vary depending on whether the Partnership is treated as being engaged in a trade or
business in the United States. If the Partnership is treated as not engaged in a United States trade or
business, Partners who are non-resident aliens and foreign corporations will be subject to United States
taxation only in limited instances. If a foreign person is not engaged in a United States trade or
business, it is generally subject to a flat tax of 30% of the gross amount received in the form of United
States source investment income. This would include dividends, royalties, certain interest and other
similar income (but not capital gains, except as noted below) that is not related to the active conduct of
a trade or business. The 30% tax is collected by imposing a withholding obligation on the Partnership.
The withholding tax is reduced or eliminated in some circumstances for residents of countries with
which the United States has income tax treaties. A nonresident alien, but not a foreign corporation, is
generally subject to a 30% tax on his United States source capital gains where such person is physically
present in the United States for 183 days or more during the taxable year, although an alien who is
present for such a period will generally be a United States tax resident and therefore subject to United
States taxation on his worldwide income. A nonresident alien who is present in the United States for
183 days or more is required to file a United States tax return and pay a tax of 30% on his net capital
gains. Dispositions of United States real property interests are generally subject to U.S. tax under a
special provision and do not fall within the general capital gains rule.
Interest from certain investments is exempt from the 30% withholding tax. For example, the portfolio
interest exception represents a broad class of interest income, which is exempt from withholding tax,
subject to the significant limitation that it is not applicable to interest paid to a 10% or more
shareholder. In order to constitute portfolio interest, a debt obligation held by the Partnership on which
the interest is paid must generally be issued in registered form and the foreign partner must have
provided the withholding agent with a properly completed IRS Form W-8 BEN. In order to constitute a
registered obligation, the debt must be payable only to the named owner and any transfer of the
obligation must be registered on the books of the issuer or the old note must be surrendered for
cancellation and a new note issued in the name of the transferee.
The portfolio interest exemption does not apply to interest received by a person who owns 10% or more
of the total combined voting power of the payor. In the case of a partnership lender, this 10%
ownership test is applied at the partner level and so is not likely to prevent portfolio interest earned by
the Partnership from qualifying for the portfolio interest exemption.
On the other hand, if the Partnership were engaged in a trade or business (either directly or indirectly
through an investment in a flow-through entity such as a partnership or limited liability company) at
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
any time during the taxable year, each foreign Partner of the Partnership would be treated as being
engaged in a United States trade or business and would be subject to United States income taxation (at
the same net progressive rates applicable to United States citizens, residents and domestic corporations)
on income that is effectively connected with the conduct of that trade or business. For corporate
Partners an additional branch profits tax will generally be imposed on such effectively connected
income. If the Partnership were engaged in a United States trade or business, a withholding tax would
be imposed on its effectively connected income allocable to foreign Partners.
The foregoing discussion relates only to recognized income. The unrealized appreciation in stock or
other securities distributed in-kind by the Partnership is generally not taxable until such stocks or
securities are ultimately sold. The sale of stock by a nonresident alien will generally not be taxed by the
United States so long as the sale is not made through an office or fixed place of business maintained by
the alien in the United States.
Each potential investor that is a non-resident alien of the United States is urged to consult with and
must rely upon the advice of its own professional tax advisors with respect to the United State% and
foreign tar treatment of an investment in the Partnership.
REPORTING. The General Partner will furnish each Partner with an annual statement setting forth
information relating to the operations of the Partnership (including information regarding such Partner's
distributive share of Partnership income and gains, losses, deductions and credits for the taxable year)
as is reasonably required to enable the Partner to properly report to the IRS with respect to such
Partner's participation in the Partnership.
The federal information tax returns filed by the Partnership will be subject to audit by the IRS and the
audit of the Partnership's returns could result in an audit of the Partners' own federal income tax
returns. In connection with such audits, adjustments to Partnership items could result in the assertion of
tax deficiencies (as well as interest and penalties thereon) against the Partners. Any administrative or
judicial proceedings involving the federal income tax treatment of Partnership items will generally be
conducted on a unified basis, with binding effect on all Partners. The General Partner will serve as the
Partnership's "Tax Matters Partner" for purposes of coordinating any such proceedings and providing
any required notices about such proceedings to the Partners.
Treasury regulations impose special reporting rules for "reportable transactions." A reportable
transaction includes, among other things, a transaction in which an advisor limits the disclosure of the
tax treatment or tax structure of the transaction and receives a fee in excess of certain thresholds. The
General Partner intends to take the position that an investment in the Partnership does not constitute a
reportable transaction. If it were determined that an investment in the Partnership does constitute a
reportable transaction, each Partner would be required to complete and file IRS Form 8886 with such
Partner's tax return for the tax year that includes the date that such Partner acquired an interest in the
Partnership. The General Partner reserves the right to disclose certain information about the Partners
and the Partnership to the IRS on Form 8886, including the Partners' capital commitments, tax
identification numbers (if any), and dates of admission to the Partnership, to facilitate compliance with
the reportable transaction rules if necessary. In addition, the Partnership may engage in certain
transactions which themselves constitute reportable transactions and with respect to which both the
Partnership and certain Partners may be required to file Form 8886. A significant penalty is imposed on
taxpayers who participate in a "reportable transaction" and fail to make the required disclosure. Certain
states have similar reporting requirements and may impose penalties for failure to report. Partners
should consult their tax advisors for advice concerning compliance with the reportable transaction
regulations.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
The Code provides for optional, and in certain cases mandatory, adjustments to the basis of partnership
property upon distributions of partnership property to a partner and transfers of partnership interests
(including by reason of death). The General Partner may elect to adjust the basis of Partnership
property in its sole discretion. In addition, the General Partner will be entitled to require that each
Partner provide it with any information necessary to allow the Partnership to comply with its
obligations under the rules relating to tax basis adjustments and disallowance of certain losses under
Sections 734 or 743 of the Code. Partners permitted to transfer interests in the Partnership will also be
required to provide certain information regarding the transfer to the General Partner and any transferee.
FATCA. Pursuant to Code Sections 1471-1474 and treasury regulations issued thereunder
("FATCA"), the Partnership will be required to deduct a 30% withholding tax from payments of certain
U.S. source income, including capital gains, made to its foreign Partners unless the foreign Partners are
individuals or establish an exemption from this new withholding tax. The FATCA withholding tax
cannot be reduced under a tax treaty. Each Partner will be required to provide the Partnership any and
all information required for the Partnership to meet its obligations under FATCA. The purpose of
FATCA is to insure that foreign entities receiving payments from U.S. sources disclose all of their
direct or indirect U.S. owners. The FATCA withholding tax currently applies to payments of interest
and dividends, but should not apply before January 1, 2017 in the case of proceeds from the sales of
stock and securities.
INVESTMENT BY THE PARTNERSHIP IN CONTROLLED FOREIGN CORPORATIONS. A non-
United States corporation in which the Partnership invests may be classified as a controlled foreign
corporation ("CFC) in one or more taxable years while the corporation's stock is held by the
Partnership. In general, a foreign corporation will be classified as a CFC if five or fewer 10% United
States Shareholders (as defined below) own in the aggregate more than 50% of the voting power or
value of the corporation's stock. A "10% United States Shareholder" is generally a U.S. person who
owns, directly or indirectly, and with the application of certain attribution rules, 10% or more of the
voting power of the stock of a foreign corporation. The Partnership will be considered a U.S. person for
these purposes. Each 10% United States Shareholder who owns shares, directly or indirectly, in a CFC
on the last day of the corporation's taxable year will be required to include an amount in gross income,
subject to tax at ordinary income rates, equal to such 10% United States Shareholder's pro rata share of
the corporation's (and each of the corporation's subsidiary CFCs) Subpart F income. In general,
Subpart F income includes passive income and certain related party income. In addition, a 10% United
States Shareholder may recognize ordinary income on all or a portion of the gain from the sale of stock
of a CFC.
INVESTMENT BY THE PARTNERSHIP IN PASSIVE FOREIGN INVESTMENT COMPANIES. A
non-United States corporation in which the Partnership invests may be classified as a passive foreign
investment company ("PF1C) in one or more taxable years while the corporation's stock is held by the
Partnership. In general, a foreign corporation will be classified as a PFIC if (i) at least 75% of its gross
income for the tax year is passive, or (ii) at least 50% of the assets held by the corporation during the
year produce passive income. A direct or indirect United States shareholder of stock in a PFIC may
defer United States tax until the stock is disposed of or until a distribution is received from the
corporation. Gains realized upon disposition of stock in a PFIC and certain excess distributions by the
PFIC will be taxed as ordinary income and will cause a United States shareholder to pay interest on the
tax deferral obtained by reason of holding stock in the PFIC. United States shareholders of a PFIC
other than certain entities exempt from United States federal income tax under Section 501(a) of the
Code may avoid such interest charges by making a qualified electing fund ("QEF) election in the first
taxable year in which the corporation becomes a PFIC. A QEF election would result in an annual
inclusion in gross income of such United States shareholder's pro rata share of the corporation's
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
ordinary earnings and net capital gains irrespective of whether such income is actually distributed. In
order for the Partnership to make a valid QEF election with respect to a portfolio company, the PFIC
must agree to provide detailed information concerning its operating income to the Partnership. There is
no guarantee that any given portfolio company would agree to provide such information. Accordingly,
there can be no assurance that the Partnership will be able to make a valid QEF election for any
portfolio company that is a PFIC.
GENERAL. The foregoing discussion is for general information purposes and intended only as a general
summary of some of the principal federal income tax aspects of participation in the Partnership. The
tax rules applicable with respect to the treatment of the Partners, the Partnership and the transactions
that the Partnership may engage in are highly complex, and their effect, in certain instances, may not be
free from doubt. It also must be emphasized that the tax rules presently applicable with respect to the
transactions described in this offering are subject to change at any time, and any such changes may or
may not be made with retroactive effect.
B. Certain Securities Law And Anti -Money Laundering Considerations
INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT OF 1940. The Partnership will not be subject to the provisions of the
Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the "Investment Company Act'), in reliance upon
either Section 3(cX I ) 1 or Section 3(c)(7) 2 of the Investment Company Act. The Subscription
Agreement and Partnership Agreement will contain representations and restrictions on transfer designed
to ensure that the conditions of one or both of these provisions will be met.
In addition, the General Partner will be entitled to form separate, side•by-side partnerships that would
avoid the application of the Investment Company Act based on application of either Section 3(c)(1) of
the Investment Company Act (if the Partnership is relying on Section 3(c)(7) of the Investment
Company Act) or Section 3(c)(7) of the Investment Company Act (if the Partnership is relying on

Section 3(c)(1) of the Investment Company Act).
INVESTMENT ADVISORS ACT OF 1940. As of the date hereof, there is no requirement that the General
Partner must register under the Advisors Act However, future changes in laws may impose such a
requirement.
SECURITIES ACT OF 1933. The limited partner interests in the Partnership described herein are not
being registered under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the "Securities Act"), in reliance upon
exemptions for transactions not involving a public offering. Each investor will be required to execute
certain agreements in connection with its subscription for a limited partner interest in the Partnership,
and in so doing will make certain representations to the General Partner, including: (i) that it is an
"accredited investor" as defined in Regulation D under the Securities Act; (ii) that it is acquiring its
interest in the Partnership for its own account, for investment purposes only, and not with a view to its

Section 3(c)( I ) excludes from the definition of -investment company' any issuer whose outstanding securities arc 
beneficially
owned by not more than one hundred (100) persons (as defined in this § 3(c)( I)), after giving effect to certain 
attribution rules,
and that does not engage in a public offering of securities.
2 Section 3(cX7) excludes from the definition of "investment company" any issuer whose outstanding securities arc 
beneficially
owned only by "qualified purchasers" or "knowledgeable employees" and that does not engage in a public offering of 
securities.
A "qualified purchaser" includes a natural person who owns not less than 55,000.000 in investments, or a natural person 
or
company, acting for its own account or the accounts of other qualified purchasers. who owns and invests on a 
discretionary basis
not less than 525,000.000 in investments and certain trusts.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
distribution; (iii) that it has received or had access to all information it deems relevant to evaluate the
merits and risks of the prospective investment and that it has reviewed and understood all such
information; (iv) that it has the ability to bear the economic risk of an investment in the Partnership for
an indefinite period of time; and (v) that it has such knowledge and experience of financial and business
matters that it is capable of evaluating the merits of an investment in the Partnership.
Prior to sale, offerees and their advisors are invited to ask questions and obtain additional information
from the General Partner concerning the limited partner interests in the Partnership described herein, the
terms and conditions of the offering, and any other relevant matters (including, but not limited to,
additional information to verify the accuracy of the information set forth herein).
ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING REGULATIONS. All subscriptions for the limited partner interests in the
Partnership described herein are subject to applicable anti-money laundering regulations. Investors will
be required to comply with such anti-money laundering procedures as are required by the Uniting and
Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism
(USA PATRIOT Act) Act of 2001 (Pub. L. No. 107-56).
As part of the Partnership's responsibility to comply with any applicable regulations aimed at the
prevention of money laundering, the Partnership may require verification of identity from all
prospective investors. The Partnership may seek to: verify the identity of a prospective investor; ensure
that the prospective investor is not named on one of the prohibited lists maintained by the U.S. Treasury
Department; verify the source of a prospective investor's funds; once a prospective investor becomes a
limited partner, monitor communications, capital contributions and withdrawals, and other payments
involving the limited partner; and report suspicious activity to appropriate authorities. The Partnership
may be required to exercise special scrutiny when prospective investors employ certain-kinds of
financial institutions or financial institutions from certain countries or when prospective investors are
senior governmental or military officials or senior executives of government-owned businesses. U.S.
anti-money laundering regulations are developing and changing continually and the Partnership may be
required to implement other anti-money laundering measures from time to time. Prospective investors
should be aware that in order to comply with any applicable anti-money laundering regulations, whether
in the United States or any other applicable jurisdiction, certain information regarding prospective
investors and partners may be required to be transmitted to, or held in, the United States or disclosed to
certain regulatory authorities in any applicable jurisdiction. Depending on the circumstances of each
subscription, it may not be necessary to obtain full documentary evidence of identity.
The Partnership reserves the right to request such information as is necessary to verify the identity of a
prospective investor. The Partnership also reserves the right to request such identification evidence in
respect of a transferee of the limited partner interests in the Partnership. In the event of delay or failure
by the prospective investor or transferee to produce any information required for verification purposes,
the Partnership may refuse to accept the application or (as the case may be) to give effect to the relevant
transfer and (in the case of a subscription for the limited partner interests in the Partnership) any funds
received will be returned without interest to the account from which the monies were originally debited.
The Partnership also reserves the right to refuse to make any distribution to a Limited Partner, if the
General Partner suspects or is advised that the payment of any distribution proceeds to such Limited
Partner might result in a breach or violation of any applicable anti-money laundering or other laws or
regulations by any person in any relevant jurisdiction, or such refusal is considered necessary or
appropriate to ensure the compliance by the Partnership, the General Partner or their respective
affiliates with any such laws or regulations in any relevant jurisdiction.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum

C. Certain ERISA Considerations
Each prospective investor that is an employee benefit plan (an "ERISA Plan") within the meaning of
and subject to the provisions of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended
("ERISA ), or a plan within the meaning of and subject to the provisions of Section 4975 of the Code,
such as an individual retirement account (IRA) (a "Code Plan"), should consider the matters described
in this section in determining whether to invest in the Partnership. The provisions of ERISA are
complex and their application to an investment in the Partnership should be reviewed by the
appropriate representatives of any prospective investor that is an ERISA Plan or a Code Plan (each a
"Plan). In particular, each such prospective investor should consult with their own legal counsel
concerning the issues described below. The following is intended to be a summary only and is not a
substitute for careful planning with a professional adviser.
FIDUCIARY MATTERS AND PROHIBITED TRANSACTIONS GENERALLY. In considering an investment
in the Partnership of a portion of the assets of any ERISA Plan, any Code Plan and any entity whose
underlying assets include plan assets by reason of an investment in such entity by an ERISA Plan or a
Code Plan (but not a foreign or governmental benefit plan that is not subject to ERISA or the Code) (a
"benefit plan investor"), a fiduciary should consider, among other factors, (i) whether the investment is
in accordance with the documents and instruments governing the Plan; (ii) whether the investment
satisfies the diversification requirements of Section 404(a)(I)(C) of ERISA, if applicable; (iii) whether
the investment provides sufficient liquidity to permit benefit payments to be made as they become due;

(iv) any requirement that the fiduciary annually value the assets of the Plan; (v) whether the investment
is prudent, since there is a high degree of risk in purchasing interests in the Partnership and it is not
expected that there will be any public market in which the interests may be sold or otherwise disposed
of; and (vi) whether the investment is for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits to participants and
their beneficiaries.
ERISA and the Code prohibit Plan fiduciaries from engaging in various transactions ("Prohibited
Transactions") involving Plan assets with persons who have certain relationships with respect to the
Plan, such as Plan fiduciaries (a "party in interest"). Thus, for example, absent an exemption the
fiduciaries of a Plan should not purchase interests in the Partnership with assets of any Plan if the
General Partner or any of its affiliates (i) has investment discretion with respect to such assets; or

(ii) gives individualized investment advice where there is an understanding that it will serve as the
primary basis for the investment decisions made with respect to such assets.
PLAN ASSETS. If the underlying assets of the Partnership (as opposed to interests in the Partnership
alone) were deemed to be "plan assets" under ERISA, (i) the prudence and other fiduciary
responsibility standards of Title I of ERISA would extend to investments made by the Partnership; and
(ii) certain transactions in which the Partnership might seek to engage could constitute Prohibited
Transactions under ERISA and the Code.
Under a regulation (the "Plan Assets Regulation") issued by the U.S. Department of Labor ("DOL"),
the assets and properties of certain entities in which a Plan makes an equity investment (other than an
investment in a publicly offered security or a security issued by an investment company registered
under the Investment Company Act) would be deemed to be assets of the investing Plan unless (i) the
entity is an "operating company" (including a "venture capital operating company") or (ii) equity
participation by "benefit plan investors" is less than 25% of any class of equity of the entity. Interests
in the Partnership will be neither publicly offered nor securities issued by an investment company
registered under the Investment Company Act, within the meaning of the Plan Assets Regulation, and it
is possible that benefit plan investors may purchase 25% or more of the Limited Partner interests in the
Partnership.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
For the Partnership to be considered a venture capital operating company, as of the date of its initial
long-term investment and on any date of each "annual valuation period," at least 50% of its assets,
valued at cost and exclusive of short-term investments pending long term commitment, must be
investments in operating companies as to which the Partnership has contractual rights directly with the
operating company to substantially participate in, or substantially influence, the conduct of such
companies ("management rights"). In addition, the Partnership must actually exercise its management
rights in at least one of such companies in the ordinary course of its business each year. The
Partnership cannot give any assurances as to whether it will be operated as or considered to be a
venture capital operating company.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, to each investor that is a "benefit plan investor" (as defined in ERISA),
the General Partner acknowledges that it will use commercially reasonable efforts to conduct the affairs
of the Partnership so that the assets of the Partnership will not be deemed to be "plan assets" under
regulations promulgated by the U.S. Department of Labor.
PLAN ASSET CONSEQUENCES-PROHIBITED TRANSACTION EXEMPTIONS. If the Partnership's assets
were deemed to constitute "plan assets" subject to Title I of ERISA or Section 4975 of the Code and a
non-exempt Prohibited Transaction were to occur, then the General Partner, as a fiduciary and "party in
interest," and any other "party in interest" that engaged in the prohibited transaction could be required
(i) to restore to the Plan any profit realized on the transaction and (ii) to reimburse the Plan for any
losses suffered by the Plan, as a result of such investment. In addition, each "party in interest" involved
could be subject to an excise tax equal to 15% of the amount involved in the Prohibited Transaction for
each year such transaction continues and, unless such transaction were corrected within statutorily
required periods, to an additional tax of 100%. Plan fiduciaries who make the decision to invest in an
interest in the Partnership could, under certain circumstances, be liable as co-fiduciaries for actions
taken by the Partnership or the General Partner.
Furthermore, unless appropriate administrative exemptions were available or were obtained, the
Partnership could be restricted from acquiring an otherwise desirable investment or from entering into
an otherwise favorable transaction, if such acquisition or transaction would constitute a Prohibited
Transaction.
FORM 5500— ALTERNATIVE REPORTING OPTION. Most Plans must annually prepare and file with the
Internal Revenue Service a Form 5500, Annual Return/Report of Employee Benefit Plan ("Form
5500"). Schedule C of Form 5500 requires expanded reporting of "indirect compensation" received by
service providers to a Plan. "Indirect compensation" refers to compensation received from sources
other than directly from a Plan or the sponsor of a Plan if received in connection with services rendered
to the Plan. For this purpose, persons providing investment management services to a pooled
investment vehicle in which a Plan invests are treated as indirectly providing investment management
services to the Plan. Reportable "indirect compensation" thus includes fees received by a person from a
pooled investment vehicle in which a Plan invests to the extent that such fees are charged against the
pooled investment vehicle and reflected in the value of the Plan's investment, such as, for example, an
investment adviser asset -based investment management fee. The disclosure and description of the
Partnership's compensation arrangements contained in this Memorandum, the Subscription Agreement
and/or the Partnership Agreement are intended to satisfy the requirements for the alternative reporting
option for "eligible indirect compensation" that are set forth in the instructions to Schedule C of Form
5500 because they disclose and describe (a) the existence of the indirect compensation, (b) the services
provided for the indirect compensation or the purpose for the payment of the indirect compensation, (c)
the amount (or estimate) of the compensation or a description of the formula used to calculate or
determine the compensation, and (d) the identity of the party or parties paying and receiving the
compensation.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
Each Plan fiduciary should consult its legal adviser concerning the potential consequences under
ERISA, Section 4975 of the Code or similar state law before making an investment in the
Partnership.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
X. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Prior to the consummation of the offering, the Partnership will provide to each prospective
investor and such investor's representatives and advisors, if any, the opportunity to ask questions and
receive answers concerning the terms and conditions of the offering and to obtain any additional
information which the Partnership may possess or can obtain without unreasonable effort and expense
that is necessary to verify the accuracy of the information furnished to such prospective investor.
This Memorandum is intended to present a general outline of the policies and structure of the
Partnership and the General Partner. The Partnership Agreement, which specifies the rights and
obligations of the Limited Partners, should be reviewed thoroughly by each prospective investor. The
"Summary of Principal Terms" of the terms and conditions of the Partnership contained herein is
necessarily incomplete and is qualified in its entirety by reference to such agreement and the
subscription agreements relating to the purchase of limited partnership interests therein. In the event
any description of the Partnership's terms and conditions set forth in this Memorandum conflict with
the provisions of such agreements, the terms and conditions set forth in such agreements shall control.
Any questions regarding this offering, and any requests for copies of the Memorandum, the
Partnership Agreement and the Subscription Agreement, should be forwarded to:
Valar Ventures LLC
915 Broadway, Suite 1101
New York, NY 10010
Email:
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-1
APPENDIX A
NOTICES UNDER CERTAIN UNITED STATES AND FOREIGN SECURITIES LAWS
Prospective investors should carefully consider the applicable legends stated below prior to deciding
whether or not to invest in the Partnership.
NOTICE TO FLORIDA RESIDENTS: A PURCHASER (OTHER THAN AN INSTITUTIONAL
INVESTOR DESCRIBED IN SECTION 517.061(7), FLA. STAT.) WHO ACCEPTS AN OFFER TO
PURCHASE SECURITIES EXEMPTED FROM REGISTRATION BY SECTION 517.061(11), FLA.
STAT., MAY VOID SUCH PURCHASE WITHIN A PERIOD OF THREE (3) DAYS AFTER (A)
THE PURCHASER FIRST TENDERS CONSIDERATION TO THE ISSUER, ITS AGENT OR AN
ESCROW AGENT OR (B) THE AVAILABILITY OF THAT PRIVILEGE IS COMMUNICATED TO
THE PURCHASER, WHICHEVER LATER OCCURS, UNLESS SALES ARE MADE TO FEWER
THAN FIVE (5) PURCHASERS IN FLORIDA (NOT COUNTING THOSE INSTITUTIONAL
INVESTORS DESCRIBED IN SECTION 517.061(7)).
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF OTHER STATES: IN MAKING AN INVESTMENT DECISION
INVESTORS MUST RELY ON THEIR OWN EXAMINATION OF THE ISSUER AND THE
TERMS OF THE OFFERING, INCLUDING THE MERITS AND RISKS INVOLVED. THESE
SECURITIES HAVE NOT BEEN RECOMMENDED BY ANY FEDERAL OR STATE SECURITIES
COMMISSION OR REGULATORY AUTHORITY. FURTHERMORE, THE FOREGOING
AUTHORITIES HAVE NOT CONFIRMED THE ACCURACY OR DETERMINED THE
ADEQUACY OF THIS MEMORANDUM. ANY REPRESENTATION TO THE CONTRARY IS A
CRIMINAL OFFENSE.
THESE SECURITIES ARE SUBJECT TO RESTRICTIONS ON TRANSFERABILITY AND
RESALE AND MAY NOT BE TRANSFERRED OR RESOLD EXCEPT AS PERMITTED UNDER
THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED, AND THE APPLICABLE STATE SECURITIES
LAWS, PURSUANT TO REGISTRATION OR EXEMPTION THEREFROM. INVESTORS
SHOULD BE AWARE THAT THEY MAY BE REQUIRED TO BEAR THE FINANCIAL RISKS OF
THIS INVESTMENT FOR AN INDEFINITE PERIOD OF TIME.
NOTICE TO FOREIGN INVESTORS: IT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF ANY PERSON OR
ENTITY WISHING TO PURCHASE AN INTEREST TO SATISFY HIMSELF, HERSELF OR
ITSELF AS TO THE FULL OBSERVANCE OF THE LAWS OF ANY RELEVANT TERRITORY
OUTSIDE OF THE UNITED STATES IN CONNECTION WITH ANY SUCH PURCHASE,
INCLUDING OBTAINING ANY REQUIRED GOVERNMENTAL OR OTHER CONSENTS OR
OBSERVING ANY OTHER APPLICABLE FORMALITIES.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF AUSTRALIA: THE PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REGISTERED AS A
MANAGED INVESTMENT SCHEME IN AUSTRALIA. THE PROVISION OF THIS
MEMORANDUM TO ANY PERSON DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER OF INTERESTS TO
THAT PERSON OR AN INVITATION TO THAT PERSON TO APPLY FOR INTERESTS. ANY
SUCH OFFER OR INVITATION WILL ONLY BE EXTENDED TO A PERSON IF THAT PERSON
HAS FIRST SATISFIED THE GENERAL PARTNER THAT THE PERSON IS A WHOLESALE
CLIENT FOR THE PURPOSE OF SECTION 761G(7) OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT OF
AUSTRALIA. THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT A PROSPECTUS OR PRODUCT DISCLOSURE
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-2
STATEMENT. IT IS NOT REQUIRED TO, AND DOES NOT, CONTAIN ALL THE
INFORMATION WHICH WOULD BE REQUIRED IN A PROSPECTUS OR PRODUCT
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT. IT HAS NOT BEEN LODGED WITH OR BEEN THE SUBJECT OF
NOTIFICATION TO THE AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION. IT
IS A TERM OF ISSUE OF INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP THAT THE INVESTOR MAY
NOT TRANSFER OR OFFER TO TRANSFER THEIR INTERESTS TO ANY PERSON LOCATED
IN, OR RESIDENT OF, AUSTRALIA UNLESS THE PERSON IS A WHOLESALE CLIENT FOR
THE PURPOSES OF SECTION 761G(7) OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT OF AUSTRALIA.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF BAHRAIN: THE MARKETING OF INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIP IN BAHRAIN HAS NOT BEEN APPROVED BY THE CENTRAL BANK OF
BAHRAIN. THE CENTRAL BANK OF BAHRAIN TAKES NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE
ACCURACY OF THE STATEMENTS AND INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS
MEMORANDUM OR FOR THE PERFORMANCE OF THE PARTNERSHIPS, NOR SHALL IT
HAVE ANY LIABILITY TO ANY PERSON, A LIMITED PARTNER OR OTHERWISE. FOR ANY
LOSS OR DAMAGE RESULTING FROM RELIANCE ON ANY STATEMENT OR
INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF BELGIUM: THE PARTNERSHIP HAS NOT BEEN AND WILL
NOT BE REGISTERED WITH THE BELGIAN BANKING, FINANCE AND INSURANCE
COMMISSION (COMMISSIE VOOR HET BANK-, FINANCIE- EN ASSURANTIEWEZEN /
COMMISSION BANCAIRE, FINANCIERE ET DES ASSURANCES) ("CBFA")) AS A FOREIGN
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT INSTITUTION UNDER ARTICLE 127 OF THE BELGIAN LAW OF
20 JULY 2004 ON CERTAIN FORMS OF COLLECTIVE MANAGEMENT OF INVESTMENT
PORTFOLIO. THE OFFERING IN BELGIUM HAS NOT BEEN AND WILL NOT BE NOTIFIED
TO THE CBFA. THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN AND WILL NOT BE APPROVED BY
THE CBFA. THE PUBLIC OFFERING OF INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP IN BELGIUM
WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE BELGIAN ACT OF JULY 20, 2004, AND THE BELGIAN ACT
OF JUNE 16, 2006 ON THE PUBLIC OFFERING OF INVESTMENT INSTRUMENTS AND THE
ADMISSION OF INVESTMENT INSTRUMENTS TO LISTING ON A REGULATED MARKET
HAS NOT BEEN AUTHORIZED BY THE PARTNERSHIP. THE OFFERING MAY NOT BE
ADVERTISED, AND INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP MAY NOT BE OFFERED, SOLD,
TRANSFERRED OR DELIVERED TO, OR SUBSCRIBED TO BY, AND NO MEMORANDUM,
INFORMATION CIRCULAR, BROCHURE OR SIMILAR DOCUMENT MAY BE DISTRIBUTED
TO, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, ANY INDIVIDUAL OR LEGAL ENTITY IN BELGIUM,
EXCEPT (I) TO "QUALIFIED INVESTORS" AS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE 10, § I OF THE
BELGIAN ACT OF JUNE 16, 2006, (II) SUBJECT TO THE RESTRICTION OF A MINIMUM
INVESTMENT OF E50,000 PER INVESTOR OR EQUIVALENT IN RELEVANT FOREIGN
CURRENCY OR (III) IN ANY OTHER CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH THE PRESENT
OFFERING DOES NOT QUALIFY AS A PUBLIC OFFERING IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
AFOREMENTIONED ACT OF JUNE 16, 2006. THIS MEMORANDUM HAS BEEN ISSUED TO
THE INTENDED RECIPIENT FOR PERSONAL USE ONLY AND EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE
PURPOSES OF THE OFFERING. THEREFORE, IT MAY NOT BE USED FOR ANY OTHER
PURPOSE NOR PASSED ON TO ANY OTHER PERSON IN BELGIUM.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF CANADA:
PURCHASERS' REPRESENTATIONS, COVENANTS AND RESALE RESTRICTIONS
CONFIRMATIONS OF THE ACCEPTANCE OF OFFERS TO PURCHASE INTERESTS WILL BE
SENT TO PURCHASERS IN CANADA WHO HAVE NOT WITHDRAWN THEIR OFFERS TO
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-3
PURCHASE PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF SUCH CONFIRMATIONS. EACH PURCHASER OF
INTERESTS IN CANADA WHO RECEIVES A PURCHASE CONFIRMATION, BY THE
PURCHASER'S RECEIPT THEREOF, REPRESENTS TO THE PARTNERSHIP AND ANY
DEALER FROM WHOM SUCH PURCHASE CONFIRMATION IS RECEIVED THAT SUCH
PURCHASER IS A PERSON OR COMPANY TO WHICH INTERESTS MAY BE SOLD WITHOUT
THE BENEFIT OF A PROSPECTUS QUALIFIED UNDER APPLICABLE PROVINCIAL
SECURITIES LAWS. IN PARTICULAR, PURCHASERS RESIDENT IN ONTARIO REPRESENT
TO THE PARTNERSHIP THAT THE PURCHASER IS (A) EITHER AN "ACCREDITED
INVESTOR" AS SUCH TERM IS DEFINED IN SECTION 1.1 OF NATIONAL INSTRUMENT 45-
106 - PROSPECTUS AND REGISTRATION EXEMPTIONS OF THE CANADIAN SECURITIES
ADMINISTRATORS (THE "NI") OR (B) A PURCHASER WHO PURCHASES INTERESTS THAT
HAVE AN ACQUISITION COST TO THE PURCHASER OF NOT LESS THAN C5150,000 PAID
IN CASH AT THE TIME OF THE PURCHASE, AND WHO IS NOT CREATED OR USED
SOLELY TO PURCHASE OR HOLD SECURITIES IN RELIANCE ON THE EXEMPTION IN
SECTION 2.10 OF THE NI. IN EITHER CASE, THE PURCHASER MUST PURCHASE THE
UNITS AS PRINCIPAL. THE DISTRIBUTION OF INTERESTS IN CANADA IS BEING MADE
ON A PRIVATE PLACEMENT BASIS. ACCORDINGLY, ANY RESALE OF THE INTERESTS
MUST BE MADE IN ACCORDANCE WITH AN EXEMPTION FROM THE REGISTRATION AND
PROSPECTUS REQUIREMENTS OF APPLICABLE SECURITIES LAWS, WHICH VARY
DEPENDING ON THE PROVINCE. PURCHASERS OF INTERESTS ARE ADVISED TO SEEK
LEGAL ADVICE PRIOR TO ANY RESALE OF INTERESTS.
IN ONTARIO, THE INTERESTS WILL, AND IN OTHER CANADIAN JURISDICTIONS, THE
INTERESTS MAY, BE DISTRIBUTED THROUGH ONE OR MORE DEALERS REGISTERED
WITH THE RELEVANT SECURITIES REGULATORY AUTHORITY. THE PARTNERSHIP IS
NOT A "CONNECTED ISSUER" OR "RELATED ISSUER", WITHIN THE MEANING OF
NATIONAL INSTRUMENT 33-105 - UNDERWRITING CONFLICTS OF THE CANADIAN
SECURITIES ADMINISTRATORS, OF ANY SUCH DEALER.
ENFORCEMENT OF LEGAL RIGHTS
ALL OF THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, AND THEIR
RESPECTIVE DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS MAY BE LOCATED OUTSIDE OF CANADA AND,
AS A RESULT, IT MAY NOT BE POSSIBLE FOR CANADIAN PURCHASERS TO EFFECT
SERVICE OF PROCESS WITHIN CANADA UPON THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, OR THEIR DIRECTORS OR OFFICERS. ALL OR A
SUBSTANTIAL PORTION OF THE ASSETS OF THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, AND SUCH PERSONS MAY BE LOCATED OUTSIDE OF
CANADA AND, AS A RESULT, IT MAY NOT BE POSSIBLE TO SATISFY A JUDGMENT
AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, AND SUCH
PERSONS IN CANADA OR TO ENFORCE A JUDGMENT OBTAINED IN CANADIAN COURTS
AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, OR SUCH
PERSONS OUTSIDE OF CANADA.
SECURITIES LEGISLATION IN CERTAIN OF THE CANADIAN JURISDICTIONS REQUIRES
PURCHASERS TO BE PROVIDED WITH A REMEDY FOR RESCISSION OR DAMAGES, OR
BOTH, IN ADDITION TO AND NOT IN DEROGATION FROM ANY OTHER RIGHT THEY MAY
HAVE AT LAW, WHERE AN OFFERING MEMORANDUM AND ANY AMENDMENT TO IT
CONTAINS A MISREPRESENTATION. THESE REMEDIES MUST BE EXERCISED BY THE
PURCHASER WITHIN THE TIME LIMITS PRESCRIBED BY THE APPLICABLE SECURITIES
LEGISLATION.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-4
PURCHASERS SHOULD REFER TO THE APPLICABLE PROVISIONS OF THE SECURITIES
LEGISLATION FOR THE COMPLETE TEXT OF THESE RIGHTS OR CONSULT WITH A
LEGAL ADVISOR.
THE APPLICABLE CONTRACTUAL AND/OR STATUTORY RIGHTS ARE SUMMARIZED
BELOW. THE SUMMARY IS SUBJECT TO THE EXPRESS PROVISIONS OF THE APPLICABLE
PROVINCIAL SECURITIES LAWS AND THE REGULATIONS AND RULES THEREUNDER
AND REFERENCE IS MADE THERETO FOR THE COMPLETE TEXT OF SUCH PROVISIONS.
THIS MEMORANDUM CONTAINS, PROXIMATE TO THE FORWARD -LOOKING
INFORMATION, REASONABLE CAUTIONARY LANGUAGE IDENTIFYING THE FORWARD -
LOOKING INFORMATION AS SUCH, AND IDENTIFYING MATERIAL FACTORS THAT
COULD CAUSE ACTUAL RESULTS TO DIFFER MATERIALLY FROM A CONCLUSION,
FORECAST OR PROJECTION IN THE FORWARD -LOOKING INFORMATION, AND A
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTORS OR ASSUMPTIONS THAT WERE APPLIED IN
DRAWING A CONCLUSION OR MAKING A FORECAST OR PROJECTION SET OUT IN THE
FORWARD -LOOKING INFORMATION; AND
THE PARTNERSHIP HAS A REASONABLE BASIS FOR DRAWING THE CONCLUSION OR
MAKING THE FORECASTS AND PROJECTIONS SET OUT IN THE FORWARD LOOKING
INFORMATION.
THE FOREGOING RIGHTS DO NOT APPLY IF THE PURCHASER IS:

(A) A CANADIAN FINANCIAL INSTITUTION (AS DEFINED IN NATIONAL
INSTRUMENT 45.106 - PROSPECTUS AND REGISTRATION EXEMPTIONS OF THE
CANADIAN SECURITIES ADMINISTRATORS) OR A SCHEDULE III BANK;

(B) THE BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT BANK OF CANADA INCORPORATED UNDER THE
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT BANK OF CANADA ACT (CANADA); OR
(C) A SUBSIDIARY OF ANY PERSON REFERRED TO IN PARAGRAPHS (A) AND (B), IF
THE PERSON OWNS ALL OF THE VOTING SECURITIES OF THE SUBSIDIARY, EXCEPT THE
VOTING SECURITIES REQUIRED BY LAW TO BE OWNED BY DIRECTORS OF THAT
SUBSIDIARY.
THE FOREGOING SUMMARY IS SUBJECT TO THE EXPRESS PROVISIONS OF THE
SECURITIES ACT (ONTARIO) AND THE RULES, REGULATIONS AND OTHER
INSTRUMENTS THEREUNDER, AND REFERENCE IS MADE TO THE COMPLETE TEXT OF
SUCH PROVISIONS CONTAINED THEREIN. SUCH PROVISIONS MAY CONTAIN
LIMITATIONS AND STATUTORY DEFENSES ON WHICH THE PARTNERSHIP MAY RELY.
THE RIGHTS OF ACTION DESCRIBED HEREIN ARE IN ADDITION TO AND WITHOUT
DEROGATION FROM ANY OTHER RIGHT OR REMEDY THAT THE PURCHASER MAY
HAVE AT LAW.
CERTAIN CANADIAN INCOME TAX CONSIDERATIONS
PROSPECTIVE PURCHASERS OF INTERESTS SHOULD CONSULT THEIR OWN TAX
ADVISORS WITH RESPECT TO ANY TAXES EXIGIBLE IN CONNECTION WITH THE
ACQUISITION, HOLDING OR DISPOSITION OF INTERESTS. IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT
TAX ADVISORS BE EMPLOYED IN CANADA, AS THERE ARE A NUMBER OF
SUBSTANTIVE CANADIAN TAX COMPLIANCE REQUIREMENTS FOR CANADIAN
INVESTORS.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-5
CONTRACTUAL AND/OR STATUTORY RIGHTS OF ACTION
ONTARIO:
PURCHASERS IN ONTARIO TO WHOM THIS MEMORANDUM IS DELIVERED AND WHO
PURCHASE INTERESTS IN RELIANCE ON THE PROSPECTUS EXEMPTION PROVIDED BY
SECTION 2.3 OF ONTARIO SECURITIES COMMISSION RULE 45.501 ARE HEREBY
GRANTED THE FOLLOWING RIGHTS:
IN THE EVENT THAT THIS MEMORANDUM OR ANY AMENDMENT THERETO DELIVERED
TO A PURCHASER OF INTERESTS IN ONTARIO CONTAINS AN UNTRUE STATEMENT OF A
MATERIAL FACT OR OMITS TO STATE A MATERIAL FACT THAT IS REQUIRED TO BE
STATED OR THAT IS NECESSARY TO MAKE ANY STATEMENT THEREIN NOT
MISLEADING IN THE LIGHT OF THE CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH IT WAS MADE (HEREIN
CALLED A "MISREPRESENTATION") AND IT WAS A MISREPRESENTATION AT THE TIME
OF PURCHASE, THE PURCHASER WILL BE DEEMED TO HAVE RELIED UPON THE
MISREPRESENTATION AND WILL, SUBJECT AS HEREINAFTER PROVIDED, HAVE A
RIGHT OF ACTION AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP FOR DAMAGES, OR, WHILE STILL THE
OWNER OF THE INTERESTS PURCHASED BY THAT PURCHASER FOR RESCISSION, IN
WHICH CASE, IF THE PURCHASER ELECTS TO EXERCISE THE RIGHT OF RESCISSION,
THE PURCHASER WILL HAVE NO RIGHT OF ACTION FOR DAMAGES AGAINST THE
PARTNERSHIP, PROVIDED THAT:

• THE RIGHT OF ACTION FOR RESCISSION WILL BE EXERCISABLE BY A
PURCHASER ONLY IF THE PURCHASER GIVES NOTICE TO THE PARTNERSHIP
NOT LATER THAN 180 DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION THAT
GAVE RISE TO THE CAUSE OF ACTION;

• THE RIGHT OF ACTION FOR DAMAGES OR ANY OTHER ACTION OTHER THAN
THE RIGHT OF ACTION FOR RESCISSION WILL BE EXERCISABLE BY A
PURCHASER ONLY IF THE PURCHASER GIVES NOTICE TO THE PARTNERSHIP
NOT LATER THAN THE EARLIER OF (1) 180 DAYS AFTER THE PURCHASER HAD
KNOWLEDGE OF THE FACTS GIVING RISE TO THE CAUSE OF ACTION OR (II)
THREE YEARS AFTER THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION THAT GAVE RISE TO
THE CAUSE OF ACTION;

• THE PARTNERSHIP WILL NOT BE LIABLE IF IT PROVES THAT THE PURCHASER
PURCHASED THE INTERESTS WITH KNOWLEDGE OF THE MISREPRESENTATION;

• IN THE CASE OF AN ACTION FOR DAMAGES, THE PARTNERSHIP WILL NOT BE
LIABLE FOR ALL OR ANY PORTION OF THE DAMAGES THAT IT PROVES DOES
NOT REPRESENT THE DEPRECIATION IN VALUE OF THE INTERESTS AS A
RESULT OF THE MISREPRESENTATION RELIED UPON; AND

• IN NO CASE WILL THE AMOUNT RECOVERABLE IN ANY ACTION EXCEED THE
PRICE AT WHICH THE INTERESTS WERE SOLD TO PURCHASER.

• THE STATUTORY RIGHTS DISCUSSED ABOVE ARE IN ADDITION TO AND
WITHOUT DEROGATION FROM ANY OTHER RIGHT THE PURCHASER MAY HAVE
AT LAW.
UNLESS THE PARTNERSHIP HAS ENGAGED AN ONTARIO -REGISTERED DEALER TO
PLACE THE INTERESTS IN ONTARIO, EACH PURCHASER OF INTERESTS IN ONTARIO
WILL BE REQUIRED TO DESIGNATE AN ONTARIO -REGISTERED DEALER TO COMPLETE
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-6
THE PURCHASE OF THE INTERESTS ON ITS BEHALF. THE STAFF OF THE ONTARIO
SECURITIES COMMISSION TAKE THE POSITION THAT A PERSON THAT PROVIDES
INVESTMENT ADVICE TO A FUND THAT DISTRIBUTES ITS INTERESTS IN ONTARIO IS
CONSIDERED TO BE ACTING AS AN ADVISER IN ONTARIO, AND IS SUBJECT TO THE
REQUIREMENT TO REGISTER AS AN ADVISER, NOTWITHSTANDING THAT THE ADVICE
MAY BE GIVEN TO AND RECEIVED BY THE PARTNERSHIP OUTSIDE OF ONTARIO.
NEITHER THE GENERAL PARTNER NOR THE RELATED "MANAGEMENT COMPANY" IS
REGISTERED IN ONTARIO. HOWEVER, ONE OR BOTH OF SUCH ENTITIES MAY RELY
UPON AN EXEMPTION FROM THE ADVISER REGISTRATION REQUIREMENT IF THE
INTERESTS ARE DISTRIBUTED THROUGH AN ONTARIO -REGISTERED DEALER.
ACCORDINGLY, UNLESS THE PARTNERSHIP HAS ENGAGED AN ONTARIO -REGISTERED
DEALER TO PLACE THE INTERESTS IN ONTARIO, NO SALE WILL BE MADE TO A
PURCHASER RESIDENT IN ONTARIO UNLESS THE DESIGNATION FORM CONTAINED IN
THE SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT HAS BEEN COMPLETED AND DELIVERED TO THE
PARTNERSHIP.
QUEBEC:
IN QUEBEC, EVERY PERSON WHO HAS SUBSCRIBED FOR SECURITIES PURSUANT TO
THIS MEMORANDUM MAY, IN THE EVENT THAT THIS MEMORANDUM CONTAINS A
MISREPRESENTATION, APPLY TO HAVE THE CONTRACT RESCINDED OR THE PRICE
REVISED, WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO HIS OR HER CLAIM FOR DAMAGES, PROVIDED THAT
NO ACTION MAY BE COMMENCED TO ENFORCE SUCH RIGHT UNLESS THE RIGHT IS
EXERCISED:

• IN THE CASE OF RESCISSION OR REVISION OF THE PRICE, WITHIN ONE YEAR
FROM THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION; AND

• IN THE CASE OF DAMAGES, WITHIN ONE YEAR OF THE DATE ON WHICH THE
PERSON ACQUIRED KNOWLEDGE OF THE FACTS GIVING RISE TO THE ACTION,
EXCEPT UPON PROOF THAT THE PLAINTIFF ACQUIRED SUCH KNOWLEDGE
MORE THAN ONE YEAR AFTER THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION AS A RESULT
OF THE NEGLIGENCE OF THE PLAINTIFF.
AN ACTION FOR RESCISSION OR REVISION OF THE PRICE OR DAMAGES AGAINST THE
ISSUER, THE DEFENDANT MAY DEFEAT THE APPLICATION ONLY IF IT IS PROVED THAT
THE PLAINTIFF KNEW, AT THE TIME OF THE TRANSACTION, OF THE ALLEGED
MISREPRESENTATION.
BRITISH COLUMBIA:
IN THE EVENT THAT THIS MEMORANDUM OR ANY AMENDMENT THERETO DELIVERED
TO A PURCHASER OF INTERESTS IN BRITISH COLUMBIA CONTAINS AN UNTRUE
STATEMENT OF A MATERIAL FACT OR OMITS TO STATE A MATERIAL FACT THAT IS
REQUIRED TO BE STATED OR IS NECESSARY IN ORDER TO PREVENT ANY STATEMENT
THAT IS BEING MADE FROM NOT BEING FALSE OR MISLEADING IN THE
CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH IT WAS MADE (HEREIN CALLED A "MISREPRESENTATION")
AND IT WAS A MISREPRESENTATION AT THE TIME OF PURCHASE, THE PURCHASER
WILL BE DEEMED TO HAVE RELIED UPON THE MISREPRESENTATION AND WILL,
SUBJECT AS HEREINAFTER PROVIDED, HAVE A RIGHT OF ACTION AGAINST THE
PARTNERSHIP FOR DAMAGES, OR, WHILE STILL THE OWNER OF THE INTERESTS
PURCHASED BY THAT PURCHASER, FOR RESCISSION, IN WHICH CASE, IF THE
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-7
PURCHASER ELECTS TO EXERCISE THE RIGHT OF RESCISSION, THE PURCHASER WILL
HAVE NO RIGHT OF ACTION FOR DAMAGES AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP, PROVIDED
THAT:

• THE RIGHT OF ACTION FOR RESCISSION OR DAMAGES IS ENFORCEABLE BY A
PURCHASER ON NOTICE BY THE PURCHASER TO THE PARTNERSHIP ON OR
BEFORE THE 90TH DAY AFTER THE DATE ON WHICH PAYMENT IS MADE FOR
INTERESTS OR ON WHICH THE INITIAL PAYMENT WAS MADE FOR THE
INTERESTS, IF PAYMENTS SUBSEQUENT TO THE INITIAL PAYMENT ARE MADE
UNDER A CONTRACTUAL COMMITMENT ENTERED INTO BEFORE, OR
CONCURRENTLY WITH, THE INITIAL PAYMENT;

• A PURCHASER WILL NOT BE ENTITLED TO COMMENCE AN ACTION TO
ENFORCE A RIGHT: (I) IN THE CASE OF AN ACTION FOR RESCISSION, MORE
THAN ISO DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION THAT GAVE RISE TO
THE CAUSE OF ACTION; OR (II) IN THE CASE OF AN ACTION FOR DAMAGES,
MORE THAN THE EARLIER OF 180 DAYS AFTER THE DATE THE PURCHASER
FIRST HAD KNOWLEDGE OF THE FACTS THAT GAVE RISE TO THE CAUSE OF
ACTION OR THREE YEARS FROM THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION THAT GAVE
RISE TO THE CAUSE OF ACTION;

• THE PARTNERSHIP WILL NOT BE LIABLE IF IT PROVES THAT THE PURCHASER
PURCHASED THE INTERESTS WITH KNOWLEDGE OF THE MISREPRESENTATION;

• IN THE CASE OF AN ACTION FOR DAMAGES, THE PARTNERSHIP WILL NOT BE
LIABLE FOR ALL OR ANY PORTION OF THE DAMAGES THAT IT PROVES DOES
NOT REPRESENT THE DEPRECIATION IN VALUE OF THE INTERESTS AS A
RESULT OF THE MISREPRESENTATION RELIED UPON; AND
• IN NO CASE WILL THE AMOUNT RECOVERABLE IN ANY ACTION EXCEED THE
PRICE AT WHICH THE INTERESTS WERE SOLD TO THE PURCHASER_
THE CONTRACTUAL RIGHTS DISCUSSED ABOVE ARE IN ADDITION TO AND WITHOUT
DEROGATION FROM ANY OTHER RIGHTS OR REMEDIES AVAILABLE AT LAW TO THE
PURCHASER.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF CHINA (THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA): THE
INTERESTS ARE NOT BEING OFFERED OR SOLD AND MAY NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD,
DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, WITHIN THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA (FOR SUCH
PURPOSES, NOT INCLUDING THE HONG KONG AND MACAU SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE
REGIONS OR TAIWAN), EXCEPT AS PERMITTED BY THE SECURITIES AND FUNDS LAWS
OF THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF DENMARK: INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP ARE BEING
OFFERED TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF INSTITUTIONAL AND SOPHISTICATED INVESTORS.
PURSUANT TO SECTION 11 OF THE PROSPECTUS ORDER (MINISTERIAL ORDER NO. 1232
OF OCTOBER 22, 2007 ON THE PROSPECTUS REQUIREMENTS FOR OFFERINGS OF A
VALUE ABOVE €2,500,000) ISSUED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 23(8) OF THE
DANISH SECURITIES TRADING ACT (CONSOLIDATED ACT NO. 214 OF APRIL 2, 2008) THE
FOLLOWING TYPES OF OFFERINGS ARE EXEMPTED FROM PROSPECTUS REGISTRATION
REQUIREMENTS:

(A) OFFERINGS TO ACCREDITED INVESTORS;
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-8

(B) OFFERINGS TO NON -ACCREDITED INVESTORS IF THE OFFER IS DIRECTED AT FEWER
THAN 100 PRIVATE OR LEGAL PERSONS IN DENMARK;
(C) OFFERINGS FOR WHICH THE VALUE OF EACH INTEREST EXCEEDS €50,000; OR
(D) OFFERINGS WHERE PARTICIPATION IS CONDITIONAL UPON PAYMENT OF MORE
THAN €50,000 PER INVESTOR.
THIS MEMORANDUM MAY ONLY BE DISTRIBUTED TO, AND THE OFFERING MAY ONLY
BE SUBSCRIBED BY, INVESTORS THAT SATISFY ONE OR MORE OF THE CONDITIONS SET
OUT ABOVE FROM (A) TO (D). ACCORDINGLY, THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN
AND WILL NOT BE REGISTERED WITH THE DANISH FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY
AUTHORITY OR THE DANISH COMMERCE AND COMPANIES AGENCY UNDER THE
RELEVANT DANISH ACTS AND REGULATIONS ON THE OFFERING IN DENMARK OF
FUND INTERESTS.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF FRANCE: THE OFFER OF INTERESTS IS NOT SUBJECT TO
THE REQUIREMENT OF A PROSPECTUS OR OTHER INFORMATION DOCUMENT FILED
WITH THE COMMISSION DES OPERATIONS DE BOURSE FOR ITS APPROVAL (VISA).
NEITHER THIS MEMORANDUM NOR ANY OFFERING MATERIAL RELATING TO THE
OFFER OF INTERESTS HAVE BEEN OR WILL BE SUBMITTED TO THE CLEARANCE
PROCEDURES OF THE FRENCH AUTHORITIES, INCLUDING THE COMMISSION DES
OPERATIONS DE BOURSE. THE INTERESTS MAY ONLY BE OFFERED TO AND
PURCHASED OR SUBSCRIBED TO BY INVESTORS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE L. 411-2 OF
THE FRENCH MONETARY AND FINANCIAL CODE (CODE MONETAIRE ET FINANCIER)
AND DECRET N° 98.880, DATED OCTOBER 1, 1998, ACTING FOR THEIR OWN ACCOUNT. IN
THE EVENT THAT THE INTERESTS THUS PURCHASED OR SUBSCRIBED TO BY SUCH
INVESTORS ARE OFFERED OR SOLD, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, TO THE PUBLIC IN
FRANCE, THE CONDITIONS SET FORTH IN ARTICLES L. 412-1 AND L. 621.8 OF THE CODE
CITED ABOVE MUST BE COMPLIED WITH. IF THE INTERESTS ARE OFFERED TO A CLOSE
CIRCLE OF INVESTORS OF 100 PERSONS OR MORE, SUCH INVESTORS MUST REPRESENT
THAT THEY KNOW ONE OF THE MEMBERS OF THE PARTNERSHIP'S MANAGEMENT
PERSONALLY AND HAVE EITHER A FAMILY OR PROFESSIONAL RELATIONSHIP WITH
SUCH MEMBER. THIS MEMORANDUM AND OTHER OFFERING MATERIALS RELATING TO
THE OFFER OF INTERESTS ARE STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL AND MAY NOT BE
DISTRIBUTED TO ANY PERSON OR ENTITY OTHER THAN THE RECIPIENTS HEREOF.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF GERMANY: THIS DOCUMENT AND OTHER RELATED
OFFERING MATERIALS HAVE NOT BEEN SUBMITTED TO THE GERMAN FEDERAL
FINANCIAL SERVICES SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY (BUNDESANSTALT FOR
FINANZDIENSTLEISTUNGSAUFSICHT - "BAFIN") AND INTERESTS IN THE FUND
DESCRIBED IN THIS DOCUMENT ARE NOT ADMITTED OR REGISTERED WITH BAFIN FOR
PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION IN GERMANY UNDER THE SECURITIES PROSPECTUS ACT
(WERTPAPIERPROSPEKTGESETZ - "WPPG"), THE CAPITAL INVESTMENTS ACT
(VERMOGENSANLAGENGESETZ - "VERMANLG") AND/OR THE CAPITAL INVESTMENT
CODE (KAPITALANLAGEGESETZBUCH - "KAGB"). CONSEQUENTLY, INTERESTS IN THE
FUND MAY NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD TO THE PUBLIC IN GERMANY AND THIS
DOCUMENT AND ANY OTHER RELATED OFFERING MATERIALS MAY NOT BE
DISTRIBUTED TO THE PUBLIC. FURTHER, NO FILING FOR REGISTRATION OF INTERESTS
IN THE FUND WITH BAFIN UNDER THE KAGB HAS SO FAR BEEN MADE.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-9
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS DOCUMENT AND IN OTHER RELATED
OFFERING MATERIALS IS STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL AND ONLY INTENDED FOR THE
RECIPIENT THEREOF. RECIPIENTS MAY NOT PASS THIS DOCUMENT OR ANY OTHER
RELATED OFFERING MATERIALS ON TO THIRD PERSONS EXCEPT TO THEIR ADVISORS
FOR PURPOSES OF EVALUATING THEIR OWN INVESTMENT. ANY RESALE OF INTERESTS
IN THE FUND IN GERMANY MAY ONLY BE MADE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE
PROVISIONS OF THE WPPG, THE VERMANLG OR THE KAGB, AS APPLICABLE, AND ANY
OTHER LAW APPLICABLE IN GERMANY GOVERNING THE SALE AND OFFERING OF
SECURITIES AND FUND INTERESTS. THE FUND WILL NOT MEET THE REPORTING AND
PUBLICATION REQUIREMENTS UNDER THE GERMAN INVESTMENT TAX ACT
(INVESTMENTSTEUERGESETZ). POTENTIAL INVESTORS IN THE FUND ARE ADVISED TO
CONSULT THEIR OWN TAX ADVISORS AS TO THE TAX CONSEQUENCES OF THE
RELEVANT TRANSACTION INVOLVING THE FUND. TAXATION RATES AND THEIR BASES
MAY CHANGE. AS A RESULT, POTENTIAL INVESTORS SHOULD KEEP ANY TAX ADVICE
OBTAINED UNDER REVIEW.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF GREECE: THIS MEMORANDUM AND INTERSTS TO WHICH
IT RELATES AND ANY OTHER MATERIAL RELATED THERETO MAY NOT BE
ADVERTISED, DISTRIBUTED OR OTHERWISE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC IN
GREECE. THE GREEK CAPITAL MARKET COMMISSION HAS NOT AUTHORIZED ANY
PUBLIC OFFEREING OF THE SUBSCRIPTION OR INTERESTS IN THE FUND;
ACCORDINGLY, INTERESTS MAY NOT BE ADVERTISED, DISTRIBUTED OR IN ANY WAY
OFFERED OR SOLD IN GREECE OR TO RESIDENTS THEREOF EXCEPT AS PERMITETD BY
GREEK LAW. THIS MEMORANDUM AND THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN DO
NOT AND WILL NOT BE DEEMED TO CONSITUTE AN INVITATION TO THE PUBLIC IN
GREECE TO PURCHASE INTERESTS. THE FUND DOES NOT HAVE A GUARANTEED
PERFORMANCE AND PAST RETURNS DO NOT GUARANTEE FUTURE ONES.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF HONG KONG: NO PERSON MAY OFFER OR SELL IN HONG
KONG, BY MEANS OF ANY DOCUMENT, ANY INTERESTS OTHER THAN (A) TO
"PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS" AS DEFINED IN THE SECURITIES AND FUTURES
ORDINANCE (CAP. 571) OF HONG KONG AND ANY RULES MADE UNDER THAT
ORDINANCE; OR (B) IN OTHER CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH DO NOT RESULT IN THE
DOCUMENT BEING A "PROSPECTUS" AS DEFINED IN THE COMPANIES ORDINANCE
(CAP. 32) OF HONG KONG OR WHICH DO NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO THE PUBLIC
WITHIN THE MEANING OF THAT ORDINANCE.
NO PERSON MAY ISSUE, OR HAVE IN ITS POSSESSION FOR THE PURPOSES OF ISSUE,
WHETHER IN HONG KONG OR ELSEWHERE, ANY ADVERTISEMENT, INVITATION OR
DOCUMENT RELATING TO THE INTERESTS, WHICH IS DIRECTED AT, OR THE CONTENTS
OF WHICH ARE LIKELY TO BE ACCESSED OR READ BY, THE PUBLIC IN HONG KONG
(EXCEPT IF PERMITTED TO DO SO UNDER THE SECURITIES LAWS OF HONG KONG)
OTHER THAN WITH RESPECT TO INTERESTS WHICH ARE OR ARE INTENDED TO BE
DISPOSED OF ONLY TO PERSONS OUTSIDE HONG KONG OR ONLY TO "PROFESSIONAL
INVESTORS" AS DEFINED IN THE SECURITIES AND FUTURES ORDINANCE (CAP. 571) OF
HONG KONG AND ANY RULES MADE UNDER THAT ORDINANCE.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF INDIA: THIS SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENT DOES NOT
CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO SELL OR AN OFFER TO BUY INTERESTS FROM ANY PERSON
OTHER THAN THE PERSON TO WHOM THIS SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENT HAS BEEN SENT
BY THE PARTNERSHIP OR ITS AUTHORIZED AGENT. THIS SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENT IS
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-10
NOT AND SHOULD NOT BE CONSTRUED AS A PROSPECTUS. THE INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIP ARE NOT BEING OFFERED TO THE PUBLIC FOR SALE OR SUBSCRIPTION
BUT ARE BEING PRIVATELY PLACED WITH A LIMITED NUMBER OF SOPHISTICATED
INVESTORS. PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS MUST SEEK LEGAL ADVICE AS TO WHETHER
THEY ARE ENTITLED TO SUBSCRIBE FOR THE INTERESTS OF THE PARTNERSHIP AND
MUST COMPLY WITH ALL RELEVANT INDIAN LAWS IN THIS RESPECT.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF IRELAND: THIS DOCUMENT AND THE INFORMATION
CONTAINED HEREIN IS CONFIDENTIAL AND HAS BEEN PREPARED AND IS INTENDED
FOR USE ON A CONFIDENTIAL BASIS SOLELY BY THOSE PERSONS IN IRELAND TO
WHOM IT IS SENT BY. IT MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED, REDISTRIBUTED OR PASSED ON
TO ANY OTHER PERSONS OR PUBLISHED IN WHOLE OR IN ANY PART FOR ANY
PURPOSE. IT DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN INVITATION TO THE PUBLIC IN IRELAND OR
ANY SECTION THEREOF TO SUBSCRIBE FOR OR PURCHASE ANY SHARES OR OTHER
SECURITIES IN ANY COMPANY AND ACCORDINGLY IS NOT A PROSPECTUS WITHIN THE
MEANING OF THE PROSPECTUS DIRECTIVE REGULATIONS.
THE OFFER IS BEING EXTENDED TO A SMALL NUMBER OF PERSONS RESIDENT IN THE
REPUBLIC OF IRELAND BY WAY OF A PRIVATE PLACEMENT. NEITHER THIS DOCUMENT
NOR THE OFFER CONSTITUTE AN INVITATION TO THE PUBLIC IN IRELAND OR ANY
SECTION THEREOF TO SUBSCRIBE FOR OR PURCHASE INTERESTS AND ACCORDINGLY
IS NOT A PROSPECTUS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE PROSPECTUS DIRECTIVE
REGULATIONS.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF ISRAEL: THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN APPROVED
BY THE ISRAELI SECURITIES AUTHORITY. THE INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP ARE
BEING OFFERED TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF SOPHISTICATED INVESTORS, IN ALL CASES
UNDER CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WILL FALL WITHIN THE PRIVATE PLACEMENT OR
OTHER EXEMPTIONS SET FORTH IN THE ISRAELI SECURITIES LAW 1968 OR THE JOINT
INVESTMENT TRUST LAW 1994. THIS MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR
USED FOR ANY OTHER PURPOSE NOR BE FURNISHED TO ANY OTHER PERSON OTHER
THAN THOSE TO WHOM COPIES HAVE BEEN SENT. ANY PROSPECTIVE INVESTOR WHO
PURCHASES AN INTEREST IN THE PARTNERSHIP IS PURCHASING SUCH INTEREST FOR
ITS OWN BENEFIT AND ACCOUNT AND NOT WITH THE AIM OR INTENTION OF
DISTRIBUTING OR OFFERING SUCH INTEREST TO OTHER PARTIES. THIS MEMORANDUM
DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO SELL OR THE SOLICITATION OF AN OFFER TO
BUY, IN ISRAEL, TO ANY PERSON TO WHOM IT IS UNLAWFUL TO MAKE SUCH OFFER OR
SOLICITATION IN ISRAEL. NOTHING IN THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD BE CONSIDERED
AS INVESTMENT ADVICE AS DEFINED IN THE ISRAELI REGULATION OF INVESTMENT
ADVICE, INVESTMENT MARKETING AND INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT LAW
1995.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF JAPAN: NEITHER THE PARTNERSHIP NOR ANY OF ITS
AFFILIATES IS OR WILL BE REGISTERED AS A "FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS FIRM"
PURSUANT TO THE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AND EXCHANGE LAW. NEITHER THE
FINANCIAL SERVICES AGENCY OF JAPAN NOR THE KANTO LOCAL FINANCE BUREAU
HAS PASSED UPON THE ACCURACY OR ADEQUACY OF THIS MEMORANDUM OR
OTHERWISE APPROVED OR AUTHORIZED THE OFFERING OF INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIP TO INVESTORS RESIDENT IN JAPAN. NEITHER THE INTERESTS
DESCRIBED IN THIS MEMORANDUM NOR THE OFFERING THEREOF HAS BEEN
DISCLOSED PURSUANT TO THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE LAW OF JAPAN (LAW NO.25 OF
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-11
1948 AS AMENDED). THE PURCHASER OF AN INTEREST AGREES NOT TO RE-TRANSFER
OR RE-ASSIGN SUCH INTEREST TO ANYONE OTHER THAN NON-RESIDENTS OF JAPAN
EXCEPT PURSUANT TO A PRIVATE PLACEMENT EXEMPTION FROM THE REGISTRATION
REQUIREMENTS OF, AND OTHERWISE IN COMPLIANCE WITH, THE SECURITIES
EXCHANGE LAW AND OTHER RELEVANT LAWS AND REGULATIONS OF JAPAN (EXCEPT
FOR RE-TRANSFER OR RE- ASSIGNMENT TO ONE PERSON BY ONE TRANSACTION OF
ALL SUCH INTEREST PURCHASED BY SUCH PURCHASER). THE INTERESTS ARE BEING
OFFERED TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF QUALIFIED INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS
(TEKIKAKU KIKAN TOSHIKA, AS DEFINED IN THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE LAW OF
JAPAN) AND/OR A SMALL NUMBER OF INVESTORS, IN ALL CASES UNDER
CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WILL FALL WITHIN THE PRIVATE PLACEMENT EXEMPTION
FROM THE REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE LAW AND
OTHER RELEVANT LAWS AND REGULATIONS OF JAPAN. AS SUCH, THE INTERESTS
HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED AND WILL NOT BE REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES
EXCHANGE LAW OF JAPAN. THIS MEMORANDUM IS CONFIDENTIAL AND IS INTENDED
SOLELY FOR THE USE OF ITS RECIPIENT. ANY DUPLICATION OR REDISTRIBUTION OF
THIS MEMORANDUM IS PROHIBITED. THE RECIPIENT OF THIS MEMORANDUM, BY
ACCEPTING DELIVERY THEREOF, AGREES TO RETURN IT AND ALL RELATED
DOCUMENTS TO THE PLACEMENT AGENT IF THE RECIPIENT ELECTS NOT TO
PURCHASE ANY OF THE INTERESTS OFFERED HEREBY OR IF EARLIER REQUESTED BY
THE PLACEMENT AGENT.
THERE IS A RISK THAT THE CUSTOMER MAY LOSE THE PRINCIPAL AMOUNT HE OR SHE
WILL INVEST AS A RESULT OF FLUCTUATIONS IN THE NET ASSET VALUE OF
INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP DUE TO CHANGES IN THE PRICES OF SECURITIES OR
OTHER FINANCIAL PRODUCTS HELD BY THE PARTNERSHIP, CHANGES IN FOREIGN
EXCHANGE RATES AND OTHER FACTORS, IF ANY.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF KOREA (SOUTH KOREA): NEITHER THE PARTNERSHIP
NOR ANY OF ITS AFFILIATES IS MAKING ANY REPRESENTATION WITH RESPECT TO THE
ELIGIBILITY OF ANY RECIPIENTS OF THIS MEMORANDUM TO ACQUIRE INTERESTS IN
THE PARTNERSHIP UNDER THE LAWS OF SOUTH KOREA, INCLUDING, BUT WITHOUT
LIMITATION, THE FOREIGN EXCHANGE TRANSACTION ACT AND REGULATIONS
THEREUNDER. THIS MEMORANDUM IS NOT, AND UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES IS TO BE
CONSTRUED AS, A PUBLIC OFFERING OF SECURITIES IN SOUTH KOREA. NEITHER THE
PARTNERSHIP NOR ANY PLACEMENT AGENT MAKE ANY REPRESENTATION WITH
RESPECT TO THE ELIGIBILITY OF ANY RECIPIENTS OF THIS MEMORANDUM TO
ACQUIRE THE INTEREST UNDER THE LAWS OF SOUTH KOREA, INCLUDING, WITHOUT
LIMITATION, INDIRECT INVESTMENT ASSET MANAGEMENT BUSINESS LAW, THE
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE ACT AND THE FOREIGN EXCHANGE TRANSACTION ACT
AND REGULATIONS THEREUNDER. THE INTERESTS HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED WITH
THE FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY COMMISSION OF KOREA (THE "FSC") FOR A PUBLIC
OFFERING IN SOUTH KOREA UNDER THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE ACT NOR HAVE
THEY BEEN REGISTERED WITH THE FSC FOR DISTRIBUTION TO NON -QUALIFIED
INVESTORS IN SOUTH KOREA UNDER THE INDIRECT INVESTMENTS ASSET
MANAGEMENT BUSINESS ACT OF KOREA AND NONE OF THE INTERESTS MAY BE
OFFERED, SOLD OR DELIVERED, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, OR OFFERED OR SOLD TO
ANY PERSON FOR RE-OFFERING OR RE-SALE, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, IN SOUTH
KOREA OR TO ANY RESIDENT OF SOUTH KOREA, EXCEPT PURSUANT TO THE
APPLICABLE LAWS AND REGULATIONS OF SOUTH KOREA.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-I2
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF KUWAIT: THIS MEMORANDUM AND ANY OTHER
OFFERING MATERIALS, THE PARTNERSHIP AND INTERESTS HAVE NOT BEEN
APPROVED OR LICENSED BY THE MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY OF THE
STATE OF KUWAIT. NOTHING HEREIN CONSTITUTES, NOR SHALL BE DEEMED TO
CONSTITUTE, AN INVITATION OR AN OFFER TO SELL INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP
IN KUWAIT NOR IS INTENDED TO LEAD TO THE CONCLUSION OF ANY CONTRACT OF
WHATSOEVER NATURE WITHIN KUWAIT. INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP MAY ONLY
BE MARKETED OR SOLD BY A KUWAITI SHAREHOLDING COMPANY WHICH IS
PERMITTED TO INVEST MONIES FOR THE ACCOUNT OF ITSELF AND OF THIRD PARTIES
AND WHICH HOLDS A SPECIFIC LICENSE RELATING TO THE MARKETING AND SALE OF
THE INTERESTS ISSUED BY THE MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY UNDER LAW
NO. 31/1990 AND THE VARIOUS MINISTERIAL ORDERS ISSUED PURSUANT THERETO.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF LIECHTENSTEIN: NO ACTION HAS BEEN TAKEN BY THE
PARTNERSHIP TO PERMIT AN OFFERING OF THE PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS TO THE
PUBLIC IN LIECHTENSTEIN. NO PUBLIC OFFER OF THE INTERESTS OR PUBLIC
DISTRIBUTION OF THIS MEMORANDUM MAY BE MADE IN OR OUT OF LIECHTENSTEIN.
THIS PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REGULATED IN LIECHTENSTEIN. IT IS NEITHER SUBJECT TO
THE INVESTMENT UNDERTAKING ACT OR OF ANY OTHER LAW NOR TO ANY
SUPERVISION OF THE LIECHTENSTEIN FINANCIAL SERVICES AUTHORITY. THE
CONTENT OF THIS MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR USED FOR ANY
OTHER PURPOSE, NOR BE FURNISHED TO ANY OTHER PERSON OTHER THAN THOSE TO
WHOM COPIES HAVE BEEN SENT.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF LUXEMBOURG: THE INTERESTS MAY NOT BE OFFERED OR
SOLD IN THE GRAND -DUCHY OF LUXEMBOURG EXCEPT FOR INTERESTS WHICH ARE
OFFERED IN CIRCUMSTANCES THAT DO NOT REQUIRE THE APPROVAL OF A
PROSPECTUS BY THE LUXEMBOURG FINANCIAL REGULATORY AUTHORITY IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE LAW OF JULY 10, 2005 ON PROSPECTUS FOR SECURITIES. THE
PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REGISTERED AS A FOREIGN FUND WITH THE LUXEMBOURG
REGULATORY AUTHORITIES. INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP ARE BEING OFFERED
ONLY IN DENOMINATIONS PER UNIT OF AT LEAST f50,000. THE COMMISSION DE
SURVEILLANCE DU SECTEUR FINANCIER OF LUXEMBOURG HAS NOT PASSED UPON
THE ACCURACY OR ADEQUACY OF THIS MEMORANDUM OR OTHERWISE APPROVED
OR AUTHORISED THE OFFERING OF INTERESTS TO INVESTORS RESIDENT IN
LUXEMBOURG. THIS MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR USED FOR ANY
PURPOSES OTHER THAN THIS PRIVATE PLACEMENT, NOR PROVIDED TO ANY PERSON
OTHER THAN THE RECIPIENT THEREOF.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF MIDDLE EARTH: MALLATH U-THILIAR, RANDIRATH
VISTAR; BRONATH VILL HELEG 1.1-VAB THYND AIND. NAUR O LITH
LACHATHA, GAUL O DAE LABATHA; CRIST RIST PENIATHAR: PEN BEDH-Ri AD ARAN.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF MONACO: THE INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP MAY
NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, TO THE PUBLIC IN MONACO
OTHER THAN BY A MONACO DULY AUTHORISED INTERMEDIARY ACTING AS A
PROFESSIONAL INSTITUTIONAL INVESTOR WHICH HAS SUCH KNOWLEDGE AND
EXPERIENCE IN FINANCIAL AND BUSINESS MATTERS AS TO BE CAPABLE OF
EVALUATING THE RISKS AND MERITS OF AN INVESTMENT IN THE INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIPS. CONSEQUENTLY, THIS MEMORANDUM MAY ONLY BE
COMMUNICATED TO BANKS DULY LICENSED BY THE COMTE DES ETABLISSEMENTS
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-13
DE CREDIT ET DES ENTREPRISES AND FULLY LICENSED
PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT COMPANIES BY VIRTUE OF LAW N° L144 OF 26 JULY 1991
AND LAW 1194 OF 9 JULY 1997 DULY LICENSED BY THE COMMISSION DE CONTROLE
DES ACTIVITES FINANCIERES.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF OMAN: THIS MEMORANDUM AND THE INTERESTS TO
WHICH IT RELATES, MAY NOT BE ADVERTISED, MARKETED, DISTRIBUTED OR
OTHERWISE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC IN OMAN. IN CONNECTION
WITH THE OFFERING OF THE INTERESTS, NO PROSPECTUS HAS BEEN REGISTERED
WITH OR APPROVED BY THE CENTRAL BANK, OF OMAN, THE OMAN MINISTRY OF
COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY, THE OMAN CAPITAL MARKET AUTHORITY OR ANY
OTHER REGULATORY BODY IN THE SULTANATE OF OMAN. THE OFFERING AND SALE
OF INTERESTS DESCRIBED IN THIS MEMORANDUM WILL NOT TAKE PLACE INSIDE
OMAN. INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP ARE BEING OFFERED ON A LIMITED PRIVATE
BASIS, AND DO NOT CONSTITUTE MARKETING, OFFERING OR SALES TO THE GENERAL
PUBLIC OF OMAN.
THIS MEMORANDUM IS BEING SENT AT THE REQUEST OF THE INVESTOR IN OMAN AND
SHOULD NOT BE DISTRIBUTED TO ANY PERSON IN OMAN OTHER THAN ITS INTENDED
RECIPIENT WITHOUT THE PRIOR CONSENT OF THE CONSENT OF THE CAPITAL MARKET
AUTHORITY AND THEN ONLY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ANY TERMS AND CONDITIONS
OF SUCH CONSENT.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS IN QATAR: INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP HAVE NOT BEEN
OFFERED, SOLD OR DELIVERED, AND WILL NOT BE OFFERED, SOLD OR DELIVERED AT
ANY TIME, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, IN THE STATE OF QATAR IN A MANNER THAT
WOULD CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC OFFERING. THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN FILED
WITH, APPROVED, REVIEWED OR REGISTERED WITH THE QATARI CENTRAL BANK OR
ANY OTHER RELEVANT QATARI GOVERNMENT AUTHORITIES OR SECURITIES
EXCHANGE AND DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC OFFER OF SECURITIES IN THE
STATE OF QATAR UNDER QATARI LAW. THEREFORE, THIS MEMORANDUM IS STRICTLY
PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL, AND IS BEING ISSUED TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF
SOPHISTICATED INVESTORS AND MAY NEITHER BE REPRODUCED, USED FOR ANY
OTHER PURPOSES, NOR PROVIDED TO ANY PERSON OTHER THAN THE INTENDED
RECIPIENT HEREOF. ALL APPLICATIONS FOR INVESTMENT SHOULD BE RECEIVED, AND
ANY ALLOTMENT MADE, FROM OUTSIDE QATAR.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS IN RUSSIA: THIS SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENT IS NOT
REGISTERED WITH THE RUSSIAN REGULATOR (FEDERAL SERVICE FOR FINANCIAL
MARKETS) AND INTENDED EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE QUALIFIED INVESTORS (AS
DEFINED IN SECTION 51.2 OF THE FEDERAL LAW NO. 39-FZ OF APRIL 22, 1996 (AS
AMENDED), "ON THE SECURITIES MARKET" AND IN THE ORDER OF THE FEDERAL
SERVICE ON FINANCIAL MARKETS NO. 08-12/PZ-N OF MARCH 18, 2008). ACCORDINGLY,
THE SECURITIES (FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS) CANNOT BE ADVERTISED OR OTHERWISE
PUBLICLY MARKETED AND/OR OFFERED FOR SALE IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF SAUDI ARABIA: NEITHER THIS MEMORANDUM NOR THE
INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP HAVE BEEN APPROVED, REVIEWED OR PASSED ON IN
ANY WAY BY THE CAPITAL MARKET AUTHORITY OR ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL
AUTHORITY IN THE KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA "SAUDI ARABIA", NOR HAS THE
PARTNERSHIP RECEIVED AUTHORIZATION OR LICENSING FROM THE CAPITAL
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A•I4
MARKET AUTHORITY OR ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AUTHORITY IN SAUDI ARABIA
TO MARKET OR SELL INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP WITHIN SAUDI ARABIA. THE
OFFER AND SALE OF THE INTERESTS WILL ONLY TAKE PLACE WITHIN SAUDI ARABIA
IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE CAPITAL MARKET LAW, INCLUDING THE OFFER OF
SECURITIES REGULATIONS ISSUED THEREUNDER. THE INTERESTS WILL BE OFFERED
TO INVESTORS IN SAUDI ARABIA PURSUANT TO AN "EXEMPT OFFER" AS DEFINED IN
THE OFFER OF SECURITIES REGULATIONS. PRIOR TO ANY OFFER OF INTERESTS IN
SAUDI ARABIA, THE CAPITAL MARKET AUTHORITY WILL BE NOTIFIED OF THIS
OFFERING IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE OFFER OF SECURITIES REGULATIONS. THIS
MEMORANDUM DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AND MAY NOT BE USED FOR THE PURPOSE OF
AN OFFER OR INVITATION. NO SERVICES RELATING TO INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIP, INCLUDING THE RECEIPT OF APPLICATIONS AND THE ALLOTMENT OR
REDEMPTION OF SUCH INTERESTS, MAY BE RENDERED BY THE PARTNERSHIP WITHIN
SAUDI ARABIA.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF SINGAPORE: THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN
REGISTERED AS A PROSPECTUS WITH THE MONETARY AUTHORITY OF SINGAPORE
AND THIS OFFERING IS NOT REGULATED BY ANY FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY
AUTHORITY PURSUANT TO ANY LEGISLATION IN SINGAPORE. YOU SHOULD
ACCORDINGLY CONSIDER CAREFULLY WHETHER THE INVESTMENT IS SUITABLE FOR
YOU.
THIS MEMORANDUM AND ANY OTHER DOCUMENT OR MATERIAL IN CONNECTION
WITH THE OFFER OR SALE, OR INVITATION FOR SUBSCRIPTION OR PURCHASE, OF
INTERESTS MAY NOT BE CIRCULATED OR DISTRIBUTED, NOR MAY INTERESTS BE
OFFERED OR SOLD, OR BE MADE THE SUBJECT OF AN INVITATION FOR SUBSCRIPTION
OR PURCHASE, WHETHER DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, TO PERSONS IN SINGAPORE
OTHER THAN INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS (AS DEFINED IN SECTION 4A OF THE
SECURITIES AND FUTURES ACT, CHAPTER 289 OF SINGAPORE (THE "SFA"),
ACCREDITED INVESTORS (AS DEFINED IN SECTION 4A OF THE SFA) OR ANY PERSON
PURSUANT TO AN OFFER THAT IS MADE ON TERMS THAT INTERESTS ARE ACQUIRED
AT A CONSIDERATION OF NOT LESS THAN S$200,000 (OR ITS EQUIVALENT IN A
FOREIGN CURRENCY) FOR EACH TRANSACTION, WHETHER SUCH AMOUNT IS TO BE
PAID FOR IN CASH OR BY EXCHANGE OF SECURITIES OR OTHER ASSETS, UNLESS
OTHERWISE PERMITTED BY LAW.
THIS MEMORANDUM IS CONFIDENTIAL. IT IS ADDRESSED SOLELY TO AND IS FOR THE
EXCLUSIVE USE OF THE PERSON TO WHOM IT WAS GIVEN BY THE PARTNERSHIP OR
ITS AFFILIATES. ANY OFFER OR INVITATION IN RESPECT OF INTERESTS IS CAPABLE OF
ACCEPTANCE ONLY BY SUCH PERSON AND IS NOT TRANSFERABLE. THIS
MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE DISTRIBUTED OR GIVEN TO ANY PERSON OTHER THAN
THE PERSON TO WHOM IT WAS GIVEN BY THE PARTNERSHIP OR ITS AFFILIATES AND
SHOULD BE RETURNED IF SUCH PERSON DECIDES NOT TO PURCHASE ANY INTERESTS.
THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD NOT BE REPRODUCED, IN WHOLE OR IN PART.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF SWEDEN: THE FUND IS NOT AUTHORISED UNDER THE
SWEDISH UCITS FUNDS ACT (LAG (2004:46) OM VARDEPAPPERSFONDER) (THE "UCITS
FUNDS ACT') OR THE SWEDISH ACT ON ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FUND MANAGERS
(LAG (2013:561) OM FORVALTARE AV ALTERNATIVA INVESTERINGSFONDER) (THE
"SAIFM ACT") AND IS NOT SUPERVISED BY THE SWEDISH FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY
AUTHORITY (FINANSINSPEKTIONEN). THIS DOCUMENT HAS NOT BEEN, NOR WILL IT
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-I5
BE, REGISTERED WITH OR APPROVED BY THE SWEDISH FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY
AUTHORITY UNDER THE UCITS FUNDS ACT, THE SAIFM ACT OR THE SWEDISH
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS TRADING ACT (LAG (1991:980) OM HANDEL MED
FINANSIELLA INSTRUMENT) (THE "TRADING ACT,. ACCORDINGLY, THIS DOCUMENT
MAY NOT BE MADE AVAILABLE, NOR MAY INTERESTS IN THE FUND BE MARKETED
AND OFFERED FOR SALE IN SWEDEN, OTHER THAN UNDER CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH
ARE DEEMED NOT TO REQUIRE A PROSPECTUS, UNDER THE TRADING ACT. NO SINGLE
INVESTOR MAY INVEST AN AMOUNT LESS THAN €100,000. PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS
SHOULD NOT CONSTRUE THE CONTENTS OF THIS DOCUMENT AS INVESTMENT, LEGAL
OR TAX ADVICE. THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN PREPARED FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES
ONLY AND DOES NOT CONSTITUTE INVESTMENT ADVICE. A SWEDISH RECIPIENT OF
THE MEMORANDUM MAY NOT IN ANY WAY FORWARD THE MEMORANDUM TO THE
PUBLIC IN SWEDEN.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF SWITZERLAND: THE FUND HAS NOT BEEN APPROVED BY
THE SWISS FINANCIAL MARKET SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY (FINMA) AS A FOREIGN
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEME PURSUANT TO ARTICLE 120 OF THE SWISS
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES ACT OF JUNE 23, 2006 (CISA). CONSEQUENTLY,
INTERESTS IN THE FUND MAY NOT BE DISTRIBUTED IN OR FROM SWITZERLAND TO
NON-QUALIFIED INVESTORS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE CISA OR OTHERWISE IN
ANY MANNER THAT WOULD CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC OFFERING WITHIN THE MEANING
OF THE SWISS CODE OF OBLIGATIONS (CO) AND WILL NOT BE LISTED ON THE SIX
SWISS EXCHANGE (SIX) OR ON ANY OTHER STOCK EXCHANGE OR REGULATED
TRADING FACILITY IN SWITZERLAND.
THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN PREPARED WITHOUT REGARD TO THE DISCLOSURE
STANDARDS FOR PROSPECTUSES UNDER THE CISA, ARTICLE 652A OR 1156 CO OR THE
LISTING RULES OF SIX OR ANY OTHER EXCHANGE OR REGULATED TRADING FACILITY
IN SWITZERLAND AND THEREFORE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A PROSPECTUS WITHIN
THE MEANING OF THE CISA, ARTICLE 652A OR 1156 CO OR THE LISTING RULES OF SIX
OR ANY OTHER EXCHANGE OR REGULATED TRADING FACILITY IN SWITZERLAND. THE
INTERESTS MAY NOT BE PUBLICLY OFFERED (AS SUCH TERM IS DEFINED IN THE CO)
IN SWITZERLAND AND MAY ONLY BE DISTRIBUTED IN OR FROM SWITZERLAND TO
QUALIFIED INVESTORS (AS SUCH TERM IS DEFINED BY THE CISA AND ITS
IMPLEMENTING ORDINANCE). NEITHER THIS DOCUMENT NOR ANY OTHER OFFERING
OR MARKETING MATERIAL RELATING TO THE FUND OR THE INTERESTS MAY BE
DISTRIBUTED TO NON -QUALIFIED INVESTORS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE CISA IN
OR FROM SWITZERLAND OR MADE AVAILABLE IN SWITZERLAND IN ANY MANNER
WHICH WOULD CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC OFFERING WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE CO
AND ALL OTHER APPLICABLE LAWS AND REGULATIONS IN SWITZERLAND. NEITHER
THIS DOCUMENT NOR ANY OTHER OFFERING OR MARKETING MATERIAL RELATING
TO THE FUND OR THE INTERESTS HAVE BEEN OR WILL BE FILED WITH, OR APPROVED
BY, ANY SWISS REGULATORY AUTHORITY. THE INVESTOR PROTECTION AFFORDED TO
INVESTORS OF INTERESTS IN COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES UNDER THE CISA
DOES NOT EXTEND TO ACQUIRERS OF INTERESTS IN THE FUND.

1. REPRESENTATIVE
THE REPRESENTATIVE IN SWITZERLAND IS ARM SWISS REPRESENTATIVES SA,
ROUTE DE CITE-OUEST 2, 1196 GLAND, SWITZERLAND.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A•I6

2. PAYING AGENT
THE PAYING AGENT IN SWITZERLAND IS BANQUE HERITAGE S.A., ROUTE DE
CHENE 61, CASE POSTALE 6600, 1211 GENEVA 6 - SWITZERLAND.

3. LOCATION WHERE THE RELEVANT DOCUMENTATION CAN BE OBTAINED
THE PPM, THE CONSTITUTIONAL DOCUMENTS OF THE FUND, WHEN AVAILABLE,
AND ANNUAL REPORT, IF ANY, CAN BE OBTAINED FREE OF CHARGE FROM THE
REPRESENTATIVE IN SWITZERLAND.

4. PLACE OF PERFORMANCE AND JURISDICTION
THE PLACE OF PERFORMANCE AND JURISDICTION IS THE REGISTERED OFFICE OF
THE REPRESENTATIVE IN SWITZERLAND WITH REGARDS TO THE INTERESTS
DISTRIBUTED IN AND FROM SWITZERLAND.

5. PAYMENT OF RETROCESSIONS
THE FUND/MANAGEMENT COMPANY AND ITS AGENTS MAY PAY RETROCESSIONS
AS REMUNERATION FOR DISTRIBUTION ACTIVITY IN RESPECT OF THE INTERESTS
IN OR FROM SWITZERLAND. THIS REMUNERATION MAY BE DEEMED PAYMENT FOR
THE FOLLOWING SERVICES IN PARTICULAR: DISTRIBUTION OF THE INTERESTS.
RETROCESSIONS ARE NOT DEEMED TO BE REBATES, EVEN IF THEY ARE
ULTIMATELY PASSED ON, IN FULL OR IN PART, TO THE INVESTORS. THE
RECIPIENTS OF SUCH RETROCESSIONS MUST ENSURE TRANSPARENT DISCLOSURE
AND INFORM INVESTORS, UNSOLICITED AND FREE OF CHARGE, ABOUT THE
AMOUNT OF REMUNERATION THEY MAY RECEIVE FOR DISTRIBUTION. ON
REQUEST OF THE INVESTOR, THE RECIPIENTS OF RETROCESSIONS MUST DISCLOSE
THE AMOUNTS THEY ACTUALLY RECEIVE REGARDING THE FUND DISTRIBUTED TO
THIS INVESTOR.
6. PAYMENT OF REBATES
THE FUND/MANAGEMENT COMPANY AND ITS AGENTS, IN RESPECT OF
DISTRIBUTION ACTIVITY IN OR FROM SWITZERLAND DO NOT PAY ANY REBATES
AIMING AT REDUCING FEES AND COSTS INCURRED BY THE INVESTOR AND
CHARGED TO THE FUND.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF TAIWAN, THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA ("TAIWAN"): THE
OFFER OF THE INTERESTS HAS NOT BEEN AND WILL NOT BE REGISTERED WITH THE
FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY COMMISSION OF TAIWAN PURSUANT TO RELEVANT
SECURITIES LAWS AND REGULATIONS OF TAIWAN. NO PERSON OR ENTITY IN TAIWAN
HAS BEEN AUTHORIZED TO OFFER OR SELL THE INTERESTS IN TAIWAN. THE
INTERESTS MAY NOT BE OFFERED, DISTRIBUTED, SOLD OR RESOLD WITHIN TAIWAN
THROUGH A PUBLIC OFFERING OR IN CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH CONSTITUTE AN OFFER
WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE LAW OF TAIWAN
WITHOUT PRIOR APPROVAL OF THE FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY COMMISSION ("FSC") OF
TAIWAN. PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS WITHIN THE TERRITORY OF THE REPUBLIC OF
CHINA ARE REQUIRED TO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH IN THE RULES
GOVERNING OFFSHORE FUNDS AND CONDITIONS PROMULGATED BY THE FSC.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF THE NETHERLANDS: THE INTERESTS MAY NOT BE
SOLICITED, ACQUIRED OR OFFERED IN OR FROM THE NETHERLANDS AND THIS
MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE CIRCULATED IN THE NETHERLANDS TO ANY
INDIVIDUAL OR LEGAL ENTITY AS PART OF THEIR INITIAL DISTRIBUTION OR ANYTIME
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A•I7
THEREAFTER, OTHER THAN TO INDIVIDUALS OR LEGAL ENTITIES WHO OR THAT DEAL
OR INVEST IN SECURITIES OR OTHER INVESTMENT ASSETS IN THE COURSE OF THEIR
OCCUPATION OR BUSINESS, INCLUDING BANKS, BROKERS, DEALERS, AND OTHER
INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS INVESTING IN SECURITIES OR OTHER INVESTMENT
ASSETS (HEREINAFTER REFERRED TO AS "PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS"). IN THE EVENT
OF A SOLICITATION, ACQUISITION OR OFFERING MADE TO OR BY PROFESSIONAL
INVESTORS AND, THEREFORE, EXEMPT FROM THE GENERAL PROHIBITION AS
CONTAINED IN THE ACT ON THE SUPERVISION OF INVESTMENT INSTITUTIONS ("WET
TOEZICHT BELEGGINGSINSTELLINGEN"), NO SUBSEQUENT OFFERING OF THE
INTERESTS IN A "SECONDARY OFFERING" BY SUCH PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS TO
INDIVIDUALS OR ENTITIES OTHER THAN PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS MAY BE MADE.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF THE UNITED ARAB EMIRATES (THE "UAE"): THE
PARTNERSHIP WILL BE SOLD OUTSIDE THE UAE, IS NOT PART OF A PUBLIC OFFERING
AND IS BEING OFFERED TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS AND
MUST NOT BE PROVIDED TO ANY PERSON OTHER THAN THE ORIGINAL RECIPIENT AND
MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR USED FOR ANY OTHER PURPOSE. NEITHER THE
PARTNERSHIP NOR THE INTERESTS HAVE BEEN APPROVED OR LICENSED BY THE UAE
CENTRAL BANK OR ANY OTHER RELEVANT LICENSING AUTHORITIES OR
GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES IN THE UAE. THIS DOCUMENT IS STRICTLY PRIVATE AND
CONFIDENTIAL AND HAS NOT BEEN REVIEWED, DEPOSITED OR REGISTERED WITH
ANY LICENSING AUTHORITY OR GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY IN THE UAE. THIS
DOCUMENT DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AND MAY NOT BE USED FOR THE PURPOSE OF AN
OFFER OR INVITATION. NO SERVICES RELATING TO INTEREST IN THE PARTNERSHIP
MAY BE RENDERED WITHIN THE UAE BY THE PARTNERSHIP. THE PARTNERSHIP MAY
NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY TO THE PUBLIC IN THE UAE. THE
ENTITY CONDUCTING THE PLACEMENT IS NOT A LICENSED BROKER, DEALER OR
INVESTMENT ADVISER UNDER THE LAWS APPLICABLE IN THE UAE, AND IT DOES NOT
ADVISE INDIVIDUALS RESIDENT IN THE UAE AS TO THE APPROPRIATENESS OF
INVESTING IN OR PURCHASING OR SELLING SECURITIES OR OTHER FINANCIAL
PRODUCTS. NOTHING CONTAINED IN THIS MEMORANDUM IS INTENDED TO
CONSTITUTE UAE INVESTMENT, LEGAL, TAX, ACCOUNTING OR OTHER PROFESSIONAL
ADVICE. PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS SHOULD CONSULT WITH AN APPROPRIATE
PROFESSIONAL FOR SPECIFIC ADVICE RENDERED ON THE BASIS OF THEIR SITUATION.
NOTICE TO INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND HIGH NET WORTH COMPANIES OF
THE UNITED KINGDOM: THIS MEMORANDUM IS BEING MADE AVAILABLE ONLY TO
PERSONS WHO ARE DEEMED SUFFICIENTLY EXPERT TO UNDERSTAND THE RISKS
INVOLVED IN MAKING AN INVESTMENT IN THE PARTNERSHIP AND AS SUCH FALL
WITHIN ARTICLES 19(5), 47(2), 48(2), 49(2), 50(1) OR 51 OF THE FINANCIAL SERVICES AND
MARKETS ACT 2000 (FINANCIAL PROMOTION) ORDER 2001 OR OTHER RELEVANT
EXEMPTION UNDER WHICH THIS MEMORANDUM MAY LAWFULLY BE COM
MUNICATED AS A FINANCIAL PROMOTION (TOGETHER "EXEMPTIONS").
THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD ONLY BE CONSIDERED AS AN INVITATION OR
INDUCEMENT TO ENTER INTO AN INVESTMENT ACTIVITY BY SUCH PERSONS TO
WHOM SUCH AN INVITATION OR INDUCEMENT MAY LAWFULLY BE SENT UNDER AN
EXEMPTION AND IT IS NOT INTENDED TO BE DISTRIBUTED OR PASSED FOR SUCH
PURPOSE TO ANY OTHER PERSONS. IN THE CASE OF ANY PERSON NOT SO FALLING
WITHIN THE SCOPE OF AN EXEMPTION, THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD NOT BE
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A- I8
CONSTRUED AS AN INVITATION OR INDUCEMENT TO ENGAGE IN INVESTMENT
ACTIVITIES, AND ANY SUCH PERSON RECEIVING THIS DOCUMENT SHOULD RESPOND
ONLY BY NOTIFYING THE GENERAL PARTNER THAT HE IS NOT WITHIN ANY
EXEMPTION AND/OR BY RETURNING IT TO THE SENDER UNREAD AND, IN ANY EVENT,
SHOULD NOT ENTER INTO AN INVESTMENT ACTIVITY AS A CONSEQUENCE OF IT.
NOTICE TO CERTIFIED HIGH NET WORTH INDIVIDUALS AND CERTIFIED
SOPHISTICATED INVESTORS OF THE UNITED KINGDOM:
IN THIS PART OF THIS DOCUMENT:

(a) WHENEVER A TERM APPEARS IN "ITALICS", IT HAS THE MEANING AND EFFECT
GIVEN TO IT IN AND BY THE UNITED KINGDOM'S FINANCIAL SERVICES AND
MARKETS ACT 2000 (FSMA);

(b) WHENEVER A TERM APPEARS IN "BOLD ITALICS", IT HAS THE MEANING AND
EFFECT GIVEN TO IT IN AND BY THE FSMA 2000 (FINANCIAL PROMOTIONS)
ORDER; AND

(c) WHENEVER A TERM APPEARS IN "BOLD ITALICS WITH UNDERLING", IT HAS
THE MEANING AND EFFECT GIVEN TO IT IN ANY BY THE UNITED KINGDOM'S
ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FUND MANAGERS REGULATIONS (THE
REGULATIONS).
INTRODUCTION
THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY GAVE NOTICE TO THE UNITED KINGDOM'S FINANCIAL
CONDUCT AUTHORITY IN ACCORDANCE WITH REGULATION 58 OF THE REGULATIONS,
ON 23 JULY 2015. THE NOTICE INCLUDED A STATEMENT THAT THE CONDITIONS IN
REGULATION 58(2) OF THE REGULATIONS WERE MET. THE FINANCIAL CONDUCT
AUTHORITY HAS NOT SUSPENDED OR REVOKED THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY'S
ENTITLEMENT TO MARKET INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP TO PROFESSIONAL
INVESTORS THAT ARE DOMICILED OR HAVE A REGISTERED OFFICE IN THE UNITED
KINGDOM.
THIS DOCUMENT IS, OR HAS THE POTENTIAL TO BE, A "FINANCIAL PROMOTION".
OUR INTENTION IS TO COMMUNICATE THIS DOCUMENT IN A WAY THAT ENSURES
THAT IT IS DIRECTED SOLELY AT, AND MADE ONLY TO, THOSE PERSONS THAT WE
BELIEVE:

(a) WILL RECEIVE IT IN THE UNITED KINGDOM; AND
(b) ARE AT LEAST ONE OF THE FOLLOWING:
i. AN "INVESTMENT PROFESSIONAL"; OR

ii. A "HIGH NET WORTH COMPANY, A HIGH NET WORTH UNINCORPORATED
ASSOCIATION, A HIGH NET WORTH PARTNERSHIP, OR THE TRUSTEE OF A
HIGH VALUE TRUST".
ANY OTHER PERSON WHO RECEIVES A COPY OF THIS DOCUMENT SHOULD RETURN OR
DESTROY IT.
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS DOCUMENT IS CONFIDENTIAL AND MUST NOT
BE SHARED, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, WITH ANY OTHER PERSON, EXCEPT FOR THE
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A-19
PURPOSE OF TAKING PROFESSIONAL ADVICE IN CONNECTION WITH THE
INVESTMENTS DESCRIBED IN THIS DOCUMENT.
THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT A "PROSPECTUS'. IT HAS NOT THEREFORE BEEN:

(a) PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF PART VII OF FSMA,
AND THE HANDBOOK OF RULES AND GUIDANCE MAINTAINED BY THE UNITED
KINGDOM'S FINANCIAL CONDUCT AUTHORITY; AND/OR

(b) SUBMITTED TO, OR SHARED OR REGISTERED WITH, ANY FINANCIAL SERVICES
REGULATOR OR SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY OF ANY KIND.
CONSEQUENTLY, THE INTERESTS IN THE FUND DESCRIBED IN THIS DOCUMENT MAY
NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD TO THE PUBLIC IN THE UNITED KINGDOM; AND NO
APPLICATION CAN OR WILL BE MADE FOR INTERESTS IN THE FUND TO BE ADMITTED
TO TRADING ON A REGULATED MARKET SITUATED OR OPERATING IN THE UNITED
KINGDOM, OR ANY OTHER COUNTRY.

I. INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS

• THIS DOCUMENT IS DIRECTED AT PERSONS HAVING PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
IN MATTERS RELATING TO INVESTMENTS; AND ANY INVESTMENT OR
"INVESTMENT ACTIVITY" TO WHICH IT RELATES IS AVAILABLE ONLY TO SUCH
PERSONS, AND WILL BE ENGAGED IN ONLY WITH SUCH PERSONS;

• PERSONS WHO DO NOT HAVE PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE IN MATTERS RELATING
TO INVESTMENTS SHOULD NOT RELY ON THIS DOCUMENT;

• THERE ARE IN PLACE PROPER SYSTEMS AND PROCEDURES TO PREVENT
RECIPIENTS OTHER THAN "INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS' ENGAGING IN THE
"INVESTMENT ACTIVITY" TO WHICH THIS DOCUMENT RELATES WITH THE PERSON
DIRECTING THE COMMUNICATION OF THIS DOCUMENT, A "CLOSE RELATIVE" OF
HIS OR A MEMBER OF THE SAME "GROUP'.
II. HIGH NET WORTH COMPANIES, HIGH NET WORTH UNINCORPORATED
ASSOCIATIONS, HIGH NET WORTH PARTNERSHIPS, AND THE TRUSTEES OF HIGH
VALUE TRUSTS

• THIS DOCUMENT IS DIRECTED AT "HIGH NET WORTH COMPANIES, HIGH NET WORTH
UNINCORPORATED ASSOCIATIONS, HIGH NET WORTH PARTNERSHIPS, AND THE
TRUSTEES OF HIGH VALUE TRUSTS", AND THE "CONTROLLED INVESTMENTS' AND
"CONTROLLED ACTIVITIES.' TO WHICH IT RELATES ARE AVAILABLE ONLY TO SUCH
PERSONS;
• PERSONS OF ANY OTHER DESCRIPTION SHOULD NOT ACT UPON THIS DOCUMENT;
THERE ARE IN PLACE PROPER SYSTEMS AND PROCEDURES TO PREVENT RECIPIENTS
OTHER THAN "HIGH NET WORTH COMPANIES, HIGH NET WORTH UNINCORPORATED
ASSOCIATIONS, HIGH NET WORTH PARTNERSHIPS, AND THE TRUSTEES OF HIGH VALUE
TRUSTS" ENGAGING IN THE "INVESTMENT ACTIVITY' TO WHICH THIS DOCUMENT
RELATES WITH THE PERSON DIRECTING THE COMMUNICATION OF THIS DOCUMENT, A
"CLOSE RELATIVE" OF HIS OR A MEMBER OF THE SAME "GROUP'.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
A•20
THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD ONLY BE CONSIDERED AS AN INVITATION OR
INDUCEMENT TO ENTER INTO AN INVESTMENT ACTIVITY BY SUCH PERSONS TO
WHOM SUCH AN INVITATION OR INDUCEMENT MAY LAWFULLY BE SENT UNDER AN
EXEMPTION AND IT IS NOT INTENDED TO BE DISTRIBUTED OR PASSED FOR SUCH
PURPOSE TO ANY OTHER PERSONS. IN THE CASE OF ANY PERSON NOT SO FALLING
WITHIN THE SCOPE OF AN EXEMPTION AS SET OUT IN THE FORM OF CONFIRMATION,
THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD NOT BE CONSTRUED AS AN INVITATION OR
INDUCEMENT TO ENGAGE IN INVESTMENT ACTIVITIES, AND ANY SUCH PERSON
RECEIVING THIS DOCUMENT SHOULD RESPOND ONLY BY NOTIFYING THE GENERAL
PARTNER THAT HE IS NOT WITHIN ANY EXEMPTION AND/OR BY RETURNING IT TO THE
SENDER UNREAD AND, IN ANY EVENT, SHOULD NOT ENTER INTO AN INVESTMENT
ACTIVITY AS A CONSEQUENCE OF IT.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR.
Private Placement Memorandum
APPENDIX B
FUND COMPOSITION AND PERFORMANCE
B- I
FUND 1•
Geography Date of Initial
Investment
Percent of Capital
Commitments
Privately Hold Stock Publicly Held Stock Totals
Cost Fair Value Cost Fair Value" Cost Fair Value Gross Net
Multiple Mutilate"
Net
'PRA"
Capital Commitments:
598.300000
Xero Ltd. Wellington Oct10 32.0% 531.406,604 S115.804.717 531.408,604 5115,604.717 37
TransferVvise Ltd London Jan-13 21.4% 521.005.721 5138.906580 521.005.721 513005.680 6.8
Oppa, Ltd Sao Paulo Jul-12 18.9% 518883955 511.039.077 518.583.955 511.039.077 0.6
Eden. Ltd (Dincla) Sao Paulo Feb-13 9.0% 58,836.592 54.887.869 $8.838.592 54.887.869 0.8
Vend Lim4ed Auckland Mar-74 8.7% 58.591.046 56.846,000 58.593046 58.846.000 0.8
Other Investments" Venous 5.8% 55.505.178 $7.591598 $5,506,178 57.591.598 1.4
Estimated Foes and Expenses 4.4%
FUND 1 TOTALS 100.0% 562824490 $169.270.123 $31,408,604 5115,604,717 593.933,094 5284,874,840 ao 2.6 41.0%
FUND 2
Caplet Commitments
5102325 000
Breather Products Inc Montreal Sep-15 11.7% 512.000,000 512.000,000 512.000,000 $12,000.000 1.0
EyeEm Limited Berlin Apr-t5 8.3% 58.454.115 58.616.527 58.454.115 58.616.527 1.0
Number26 GrnDll Berlin Apr-15 6.9% 57.063.978 $7,089,262 $7.063.978 57.089262 1.0
Grandy Inc Edmonton Mar-15 5.4% 55.562.004 55.562.005 $5,582.004 55.562.005 1.0
Trading Ticket. Inc. iTradelt) Now York Apr-15 2.1% 52158.499 52,450,278 52.158.499 52,450.278 I.1
Other Investments— Various 4.8% 54.725.806 54.967.736 $4,725,806 54.957.735 I 0
Reserved for Folow-Ons 27.0%
Avalabie for New Ponfola Companies 24.0%
Estimated Fees and Expenses 10.0%
FUND 2 TOTALS 100.0% 539.984.402 540.675,807 539.964,402 540.575.807 I 0 t.O 0.0%
Notes'
Figures presented are unaucked internal estimates in USD and *corpora° all realzed and unrealized gainsAosses as of 
12/31/2015

• As used herein. 'Fund 1" refers to al funds and investment vehicles managed by Valet Ventures Management LLC poor to 
Me formation of Velar Global Fund 2. on
an aggregate bass
- 'Omer Investments' refers to investments where vain Initial cost oasts was less than 52 moon.
A ...Fair Value' of all holdings Is determined by the General Partner In good faith, in accordance wrth US GAP and 
consistent with past practices.
• Not figures aro calculated by reducing gross profits by a flat 25% for hypothetical management foes. expenses and 
cony.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
C-1
APPENDIX C
PORTFOLIO COMPANY PROFILES
Confidential & Trade Secret
PORTFOLIO / XERO
Xero - Cloud Accounting Software for SMBs
Brief Description
Xero provides cloud accounting software and services
for small businesses and their advisors. The company
has over 600,000 paying customers in more than 180
countries. Xero is listed on both the NZX and ASX
under the ticker symbol XRO.
Facts
Founder:
Headquarters:
Notable Investors:
Rod Drury
Wellington. New Zealand
Accel Partners, BlackRock, Fidelity.
Matrix Capital
Returns
Velar Cost Basis: $31.4M
Current FMV: $11S.6M
Gross Multiple: 3.7x
Date of Initial Investment: 10/28/2010
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $99M
Public Market Valuation: $1.96
CDBeautiful accounting software SHALL BUSINESSES ACCOUNTANTS BOOAKEEPERS MORE LOGIN FREE TRIAL
Xero in on your business
)(no is online accounting software that allows Chris from Kafteina to use
real time data when making decisions about growing th eir business. Join
Chris and over $00,000• Subscribers On %aro.
( Try %erg for free
CHEWS NotOtAkO,J.
KAFSEINA ONOuP
a
ti
t
Ei
AT A GLANCE FEATURES ADD-ONS CUSTOMERS PLANS & PRICING
FR:espresentedheron are Livia:Med gross estirnges as of December 31.2015.
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET I C-2
PORTFOLIO / XERO
Investment Thesis
The market for accounting software for SMBs is large. growing and surprisingly
untapped (with many consumers still relying on ad hoc ledgers and spreadsheets
rather than formal software). Incumbent players are based on legacy architecture
and have had difficulties migrating their full feature set successfully to the cloud;
they also view their accounting products as leaders for more profitable ancillary
services and have under-developed their marquee products as a result. In theory,
these factors suggested there may be an opportunity to challenge the legacy
players by building accounting software using the cloud-based technologies and
online distribution channels that have evolved rapidly over the past two decades.
However, the barriers to entry in the sector are also significant: A large feature set is
required to produce a minimally viable accounting product, and the space has
tended to create monopolies, with the largest companies (e.g., Intuit. MYOB and
Sage) dominating in their respective geographies. As a result, historically there have
been very few startups in the United States who could raise the capital required to
challenge the incumbent players.
Xero's origins in New Zealand. a small country with a fairly tight knit accounting
community, allowed it to gain critical mass in a market that was not nearly as
competitive. before taking on legacy players in their home markets. Specifically,
Valar believed that MYOB. the dominant provider of accounting software in Xero's
large neighboring market of Australia. was not well positioned to compete with a
fast-moving startup; MYOB had recently been sold to a private equity firm, and
MYOB's founder had invested a substantial amount of his exit proceeds into Xero.
Valar believed that Xeres technology, product and distribution model would allow it
to gain market share quickly in New Zealand and Australia. and provide it with the
significant capital base required to compete with Sage and Intuit in the much larger
UK and US markets.
History
Based on the Valar team's reputation and Silicon Valley connections. a high profile
New Zealand entrepreneur introduced one of Xeres directors to Valar in 2010. Valar
was convinced that the founder had extraordinary execution abilities, a knack for
sales, a plan for rapid global growth and the energy necessary to convert users away
from entrenched systems. Xero grew significantly in the year following Valar's initial
investment in October 2010. with Valar leading follow-on rounds in the company in
February 2012 and November 2012.
Current Status
With over 600.000 customers, the company is still growing at 70% year-over-year,
taking dominant positions in New Zealand and Australia, and expanding rapidly in the
UK and the US. Xero expects subscription revenue to exceed NZ$200M for the
financial year ending 31 March 2016.
Earlier this year, Xero raised US$100M from Accel Partners, increasing its cash reserves
to $200 million and ensuring it a strong base to ramp up its efforts in the US market.
Since Valar's initial investment in Xero in October 2010. at just under US$100 million
enterprise valuation, the company has raised capital from large US institutions. such
as Fidelity and BlackRock, and has listed on the Australian Stock Exchange. Xero
currently trades on both the ASX and NZX at a valuation north of US $1.5 billion. and
has announced plans to list on a US exchange as early as next year.
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-3
PORTFOLIO / TRANSFERWISE
TransferWise - Low-Cost Currency Transfer Services
Brier Description
TransferWise is a peer-to-peer currency exchange
service that allows its users to send money overseas
easily and inexpensively. By charging less than 1% and
using the mid-market rate. TransferWise is up to 8x
cheaper than traditional banks.
Facts
Founders:
Headquarters:
Notable Investors:
Taavet Hinrikus. Kristo Kaarmann
London. England
Andreessen Horowitz. IA Ventures.
Index Ventures. Richard Branson
Returns
Valar Cost Basis: $21.0M
Current FMV: $138.9M
Gross Multiple: 6.6x
Date of Initial Investment: 1/8/2013
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $20M
Latest Company Valuation: $818M
TransferWise.com
of
te r_
Transfe•W.G
THE CLEVER NEW WAY
TO BEAT BANK FEES
Banks charge hdden fees ..fen you seed minty
abroad. Wds TranthenVne you save up to 9O%.
Prealern soh d. money saved.
A • •
T neswee••
ava• Krt. km,- 1, 14
WELCOME TO MONEY WITHOUT BORDERS
10 TIMES LOWER COST.
saw. mega Mettle.
Neg... feels/IA. erg an
FASTER. SIMPLER.
Tap Aims rnach••••••••
Vekecl In to nagacipe•
eons presented heron are uneuided gross esterotes as of °camber 312O15
034 52
on  Slane
USD •
GBP •
,/ OUTSMART YOURRAW
A mull, ma way a toe n• al spun.
lavelod or 4•-•••••
I
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-4
PORTFOLLL TRANSFERWISE
Investment Thesis
The fee that retail banks charge their customers for currency exchange services is
high for historical rather than technological or business reasons. and is thus ripe for
disruption, especially given the enormity of the market. TransferWise brings
institutional currency exchange pricing to the retail market, through a transparent
approach. TransferWise uses a peer-to-peer model to lower costs. Instead of
transferring the sender's money directly to the recipient it is redirected to the
recipient of an equivalent transfer going in the opposite direction. Likewise, the
recipient of the transfer receives a payment not from the sender initiating the
transfer. but from the sender of the equivalent transfer. This process avoids costly
currency conversion and transfers crossing borders. TransferWise is able to
undercut banks and other legacy competitors, such as Western Union, when
sending money abroad. The fees charged by TransferWise are up to 10x less
expensive than typical transfers executed through a bank - particularly since the
company uses the mid-market rate to determine transfer pricing: the poor
exchange rates commonly used by banks are the major source of revenue in their
currency exchange businesses.
Given the cost savings the company drives for its users. customers love
TransferWise; the company consistently maintains a Net Promoter Score in the 80s,
which is rare for a financial services company. Having such happy customers has the
knock-on effect of making their user base a powerful marketing channel. as many
users recommend the product to friends. Although still early days for the company
- it was only started in 2011 - it's clear that customers trust TransferWise as a
financial intermediary. There is a distinct possibility that the company could parlay
that trust into offering other services in the future; that said, the currency transfer
market is more than large enough for TransferWise to succeed without adding any
new business lines.
TransferWise is a good example of a phenomenon Valar believes to be true - banks
generally do a poor job of servicing retail consumers for a number of services, and
technology forward. user-experience focused companies have an opportunity to
take meaningful market share.
History
Max Levchin. one of PayPal's co-founders and its CTO. referred James and Andrew to
the founders. The teams met several times. and the partners believed that
TransferWise had the ideal combination of a strong technical talent deep knowledge
how large financial groups operate, and a history of successfully building companies -
Taavet Hinrikus was the first employee at Skype and Kristo Kaarmann had a long
career at PwC and Deloitte helping financial institutions modernize their
infrastructure.
Valar led the company's Series A and Series B financings in rounds that closed in early
2013 and 2014. respectively. and participated substantially in its most recent Series C,
led by Andreessen Horowitz, which was announced in early 2015. Today, Valar is the
largest outside shareholder of the company.
Currant Status
Since its most recent financing round. TransferWise has continued to expand both
geographically and in its offering. Historically, TransferWise's main market has been
the Pound/Euro corridor. but as the brand has grown, demand for other currency
options has as well. This year, the company launched for the first time in the United
States, and today offers exchange services for over 30 currencies.
TransferWise continues to grow at a rapid rate. now off of a substantial base, and
today moves over $750 million a month on the platform. TransferWise still only makes
up around 4% of the market for currency exchange in the UK, which is a good
indicator of how large the market is.
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-S
PORTFOLIO / NUMBER26
Number26 - Europe's Modern Bank Account
Brief Description
Number26 is a free checking account born on mobile.
Users who sign up receive a MasterCard and an
intuitive mobile and online banking experience with a
number of innovative features designed with the
customer in mind.
Facts
Founders:
Headquarters:
Notable Investors:
Valentin Stall Maximilian Tayenthal
Berlin. Germany
Earlybird Venture Capital. Axel
Springer Plug and Play Accelerator
Returns
Velar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Date of Initial Investment:
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment
Latest Company Valuation:
€6.SM
€6.SM
1.0x
4/24/2015
€38.4M
€48M
Number26.de
NuMBEP20
Powered by
Ommllark
EUROPE'S MOST MODERN BANK ACCOUNT
Bank n9 but better
35% 42.00 €
<trek presented hem am anat.:Ned gross estimates as ca °member 312015
AVALMA20111. b, GEM ON
AppStore Pr Googk Play
S
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8, TRADE SECRET I C-6
PORTFOLIO / NUMBER26
Investment Thesis
It's no surprise to most, especially younger people, that the basic consumer banking
experience is broken. Valar's experience working with TransferWise has convinced
the team that there is ample room in the market for new and innovative methods of
delivering banking services. Since the financial crisis. the United States has been a
particularly hard place to start a new bank. This is not the case in Europe, which has
a regulatory posture that encourages new financial services: new banking services
that operate across the E.U. can assist in breaking up local monopolies and further
integrating the Eurozone economically. The strong demand, in particular from a
younger generation of users, for Number26's product, reinforces the view that
banks are ripe for disruption. These customers have likely never stepped foot in a
bank branch. having grown up with the Internet, but traditional banks have had a
difficult time bringing their online user experiences up to the same standard that
consumers expect from businesses today. Partly, that comes down to the fact that
the technology underpinning traditional retail banks transactions is dated. and
therefore hard to innovate on top of.
Number26 is entirely in the cloud and on mobile. The product is being built from the
ground up with the customer in mind. Intuitive features like unique numbers for
individual online purchases. instant transaction notifications, and the ability to turn
the card on and off through the app, make the banking experience pleasurable,
particularly in contrast with traditional banks. More importantly. the company can
acquire customers for a fraction of the cost paid by traditional banks, which must
support large retail networks. The lack of overhead that is inherent in Internet-based
companies with no physical retail presence means that Number26 has a
dramatically different cost structure. Purely on word of mouth, Number26 has
racked up over 100,000 new subscribers in the 10 months since their soft launch in
early 2015.
Part of that growth in subscribers is due to Number26's onboarding process. which
is as simple as video chatting with a bank employee through the company's mobile
app. with a customer's VC requirements being fulfilled by registering the
customer's ID or passport on-screen.
VALAR VENTURES
History
Through its experience with Transferwise. Valar became convinced that there was an
interesting opportunity in Europe for startup banks (often referred to as "challenger
banks") to disrupt traditional retail banks as a result of recent changes in European
banking regulations. In contrast with other teams that Valar had met with who were
also looking to enter the space, Number26 had shown strong early traction. with
thousands of customers signing up for an account pre-launch. And the founders
working history (one as a former product manager at a Rocket Internet-backed
company and the other as a former lawyer and strategy consultant) seemed
particularly well suited for the dual challenge faced by all fintech startups: the
marriage of smart technology with an understanding of the legal and regulatory
framework within which financing institutions operate.
Valar also has a close relationship with a New York-based venture firm that had been
an early investor in Simple. a company similar to Number26 that was started in the
United States and ultimately sold to the BBVA group in 2014. Not being able to
acquire a banking license. in addition to some other execution challenges. brought a
pre-mature end to Simple's life as an independent startup, but when they were
ultimately sold, the price received was close to the cost for a brick and mortar bank to
acquire Simple's roster of checking account customers, re-enforcing Valar's
hypothesis about the value of checking account customers to traditional banks. Upon
completion of diligence, Valar led Number26's Series A financing round in April 2015.
Currant Status
Number26 is making good progress towards acquiring its own banking license in
Germany, which can then be passported to other Eurozone countries. In the
meantime. Number26's customer money resides in accounts at the company's
banking partner, Wirecard bank. The company is continuing to build out the feature
set for its core product. and has recently launched in Spain, France, Ireland. Italy,
Greece, and Slovakia.
4CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-7
PORTFOLIO / BREATHER
Breather - Private Office Space on Demand
Brier Description
Breather operates a marketplace for branded, high-
design, private office spaces that fill a need for a short
term. quiet place to work. meet or relax. Breathers can
be booked in hourly increments via mobile or desktop.
Currently. the company operates in 5 cities including
San Francisco and New York, and expects to double
that number by the end of 2016.
Facts
Founder:
Headquarters:
Notable Investors:
Julien Smith
Montreal. Canada
RRE Ventures. Real Ventures.
Slow Ventures, SOS Ventures
Returns
Valar Cost Basis: $12.0M
Current FMV: $12.0M
Gross Multiple: 1.0x
Date of Initial Investment: 9/10/2015
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment $80M
Latest Company Valuation: $98.9M
VALAR VENTURES
©breather How 4 works Submit year space FAO LcSin
A space to work, meet or relax Book pp.r: rrfuL practical spaces whenever you need them
LJ
fgares presented herein are at:arcked gross estimates as of Occember 31. 2O15.
4CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-8
PORTFOLIO / BREATHER
Investment Thoth
Breather operates a marketplace for branded, high-design, private spaces
(referred to as "Breathers") that fill a need for a short term, quiet place to work,
meet or relax. Until now, that space has been filled by a mix of coffee shops, parks,
airport lounges, bars, church basements and similar shared spaces. Through
Breather's mobile app and website, users can book, on an hourly basis, beautiful,
private office spaces that are equipped with fast Wi-Fi and air conditioning.
Although there are numerous desk-sharing startups in the market, the
Breather model is different in important respects - the company offers private
spaces that promote comfortable. productive experiences on demand. Breather is
building a loyal customer base that engages with the service at higher rates over
time. The use cases for Breathers are broad and expanding. Examples include
customers booking the units for meet-ups, overflow conference rooms. temporary
photo studios, therapy sessions, and for short-term use between meetings.
Work culture is undergoing a dramatic shift from traditionally large employers
with rigid office hours to sole proprietorships and more flexible working
arrangements. The Breather marketplace fills a need created by this new work
culture for a consistent, trusted brand in work space.
A confluence of factors make the company's offering possible: smart phone
ubiquity, decentralized workforces. internet-enabled locks. and increased
familiarity and appetite among consumers for on-demand services.
VALAR VENTURES
History
In the course of examining a number of startups in Montreal. Valar's investment team
identified Breather as the most interesting. Andrew and James reached out to Julien
Smith, the CEO, and visited with him in Montreal. Subsequently. the team met with
Julien and other members of Breather's management multiple times. both in Montreal
and New York. Through the firm's due diligence on the product, user experience, and
financial modeling, Valar became convinced of the demand for Breather's product and
the ability for the company to scale its network and marketplaces in a significantly
profitable manner. Valar submitted a term sheet to lead the Company's Series B
financing, with a $I2M investment by Valar and strong participation from existing
investors. including New York-based RRE Ventures and Montreal-based Real Ventures.
Current Status
Breather currently operates in 5 cities: NYC, San Francisco, Boston, Montreal and
Ottawa. The company plans to more than double the number of cities by the end of
2016. In order to maintain control over the initial user experience, Breather has rolled
out into new cities by leasing the Breather spaces directly from landlords. Over time,
Breather expects the majority of the units on the Breather platform to be controlled
by third parties who are looking to boost the return on small office spaces that they
convert into Breathers. This marketplace model requires less capital, with Breather
driving usage of these third party-owned spaces through its app and website and
taking a portion of the revenues in return.
4ifCONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-9
PORTFOLIO EYEEM
EyeEm - The New Source for Stock Photography
Brief Resolution
EyeEm is a marketplace for commercial photography.
The company's highly engaged user base and
machine-curated image library provide a more valuable
sourcing channel for commercial clients than
traditional stock photography databases.
Facts
Founders:
Headquarters:
Notable Investors:
Florian Meissner, Lorenz Aschoff.
Gen Sadakane. Ramzi Rizk
Berlin, Germany
Earlybird Venture Capital.
Wellington Partners, Passion
Capital, Open Ocean
Returns
Valar Cost Basis: €7.9M
Current FMV: €7.9M
Gross Multiple: 1.0x
Date of Initial Investment: 4/14/2015
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment €44M
Latest Company Valuation: €55.8M
VALAR VENTURES
harespresentedharem are unecxlrled gross e;Orn.le; as of December 312015
4itCONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET I C-I0
PORTFOLIO / EYEEM
Investment ThesIs
The demand for commercial images - in particular high quality. authentic
photography that is useable in news outlets, social media posts, online advertising
and publishing in all forms, has increased massively over the past few years. The
continuing migration from text-based to image-based media and from desktop to
mobile is changing the way consumers absorb content. At the same time, with the
proliferation of the smartphone globally, camera technology has also improved
dramatically and today billions of people around the globe carry a high-powered
camera everywhere they go. One would expect both of these trends to continue:
demand for photography increases while the ubiquity of high-quality images grows.
However, sourcing stock photography remains a fairly time consuming, analog and
human-curated process, dominated by a few legacy firms (e.g., Getty Images).
EyeEm hopes to change this by building an automated marketplace for stock
photography contributed by a growing user base of professional, semi-professional
and amateur photographers. With a user base of over 13M people, EyeEm has built
an impressive image library and developed machine learning algorithms to tag and
index photographs, creating an easily searchable database that requires little to no
human curation. In addition, the company is building an all-digital rights sales
process for photographers, seamlessly allowing them to monetize photos they've
uploaded.
Although difficult to start, digital marketplaces, when successful can be extremely
valuable and durable businesses with powerful network effects. Valar believes that
these factors put EyeEm in a strong position to radically increase both the buyers
and sellers of commercial photography. and that the macro trends described above
create powerful tailwinds.
History
Valar was introduced to EyeEm by Passion Capital, a seed-stage fund based in
London that Valar has developed a strong relationship with over the past few years.
Passion Capital had been an early investor in EyeEm. and at their suggestion, Valar
met with the company's founders. Florian and Ramzi. in Berlin in February 2O15.
Andrew and James were particularly impressed by their passion for photography and
for the EyeEm community. as evidenced by their personal and professional
backgrounds. For example, prior to starting EyeEm. Florian quit his high paying job
running sales for a German consumer packaged goods company and relocated to the
US to work for a photography magazine in Brooklyn. Valar takes signal from the
degree of fit between a founding team's experience and natural interests, on the one
hand, and the business that team is trying to build. In the case of EyeEm, Valar
believed that the founders of EyeEm had the critical combination of passion for the
subject matter and the technical expertise required to fulfill the company's mission of
building a fully automated stock photography marketplace. After a number of
meetings in Berlin and New York City. Valar led EyeEm's Series B round, with broad
participation from the company's existing investors.
Current Status
In the few months since Valar's investment, the team has launched its marketplace for
buyers in the US, UK. Ireland. Germany, the Netherlands, and Switzerland, and opened
it for sellers globally. The company also renegotiated its partnership with Getty
Images, as well as made several key hires. including bringing on a new Head of
Product (formerly the Head of Product at Flickr), a new CFO (formerly the CFO of
Wooga). and a new head of Marketing (formerly at Victoria's Secret and
Bertelsmann).
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-II
PORTFOLIO / GRANIFY
Granify - Machine Learning for Maximizing Online Revenue
Brier Description
Granify is a marketing automation company that drives
ecommerce conversion by analyzing the digital body
language of online shoppers and determining what is
likely preventing a customer from completing an online
purchase. before attempting to change their mind.
Facts
Founder: Jeff Lawrence
Headquarters: Edmonton, Canada
Notable Investors: iNovia Capital. BDC
Returns
Valar Cost Basis: $6.8M
Current FMV: $7.9M
Gross Multiple: 1.2x
Date of Initial Investment: 8/14/2012
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $SM
Latest Company Valuation: $32M
Granity.com
rares presented herem we unaudited gross esterrotes as of Oecanber 312015
granifir t Get -sled Wmosces Carer, Prf 1.00,0 Requesi • Den*
Do you know which shoppers aren't going to
buy?
We do. And we can change their minds.
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8, TRADE SECRET I C-I2
PORTFOLIO / GRANIFY
Investment Thesis
Granify uses machine learning and data analytics to improve conversion rates for
online businesses, by analyzing a visitor's online body language through tracking
400 attributes per second, from mouse movements, to hesitations. scrolling and
more. With that data, the algorithm determines what objections the shopper may
have, then seeks to alleviate them with pre-designed stimuli.
Although there are a number of conversion optimization tools available online
today. most require considerable manipulation and regular inputs from the client
themselves. Valar believed Granify stood apart due to its real-time technology. The
software takes little to no development time to setup for a new client, and starts
working straight away. by itself, with very limited further client interaction required.
Results are tracked versus a control group and shown in real-time on an easy to
understand dashboard; Granify earns its revenue as a percentage of the uplift in
conversion it creates, as determined on a real-time basis by comparing a client's
customers at any given time against a control group of a client's customers that
Granify does not engage with.
An early Valar seed investment from Fund 1. by the second half of 2014. Granify
began to achieve product-market fit as it shifted its focus from small online
businesses to much larger ecommerce players with deeper customer data sets. The
larger data sets leverage Granify's capabilities even more effectively. and as a result,
Granify's average uplift has continued to improve over time.
Finally. given the large size of the average client, and the relatively slim costs of
running the business. Granify's unit economics are terrific - even considering the
company's limited operating history likely leads to underestimates of lifetime value
of the customer.
VALAR VENTURES
History
Valar has known Jeff Lawrence, the founder and CEO of Granify, since 2012 when the
firm participated in a seed round. Jeff had previously been involved with an Adtech
business, and saw a great opportunity to optimize online businesses' revenues using
only recently released technology.
In late 2014. after seeing a significant uptick in new business. Valar started to look
more closely at Granify's recent results and their sales pipeline. which contained
multiple well-known ecommerce businesses around the world. One of the critical
pieces of due diligence Valar needed to understand before investing, was where
Granify would find the data science talent required to run such a data-heavy
operation. As it turns out, the University of Alberta is an excellent source of data
science talent, and where previously all the best students left for Silicon Valley or the
oil and gas industry. now Granify had its pick of the bunch.
After visiting Edmonton in the beginning of 2015, Valar offered to lead Granify's Series
A round. allowing Jeff to hire a number of new employees. and start to truly market
his product.
Currant Status
The company now has an impressive pipeline of large customers trialing its software,
and Valar believes the company's revenue can increase by an order of magnitude over
the next 12 months. The machine learning aspect of Granify's product has also
continued to improve. and the average uptick in revenue experienced by customers
has risen as a result. Jeff has also begun significantly expanding his team, adding
personnel to the data science, sales, and customer support sections of his business.
As Granify has proved the value of its product, the focus is squarely on consistently
filling the pipeline. and ensuring a smooth and efficient onboarding process for new
clients.
4CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-I3
PORTFOLIO / VEND
Vend - Point of Sale Software in the Cloud
Brier Description
Retailers with Vend can process and manage
payments. inventory. ecommerce. and loyalty programs
with simple. intuitive software native to the cloud -
even for periods when Internet access is disabled. Over
16,000 businesses now use Vend from locations all
around the globe.
Facts
Founder:
Headquarters:
Notable Investors:
Vaughan Rowsell
Auckland. New Zealand
Point Nine Capital. Square Peg
Capital
Returns
Velar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Date of Initial Investment:
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment:
Latest Company Valuation:
NZ$13M
NZ$13M
1.0x
3/14/2014
NZ$ 90M
NZ$ 138M
VendH0.com
Tour Examples Pricing More y
Crewe, pmented heron are unatrirted gross estimates as of Occulter 312015
Try Vend for free
POS Software
retailers love to use.
Vend is retail POS software, inventory
management, ecommerce & customer loyalty for
Pad, Mac and PC. Easily manage and grow your
business in the cloud.
Try Vend for free
/In 0,41 act No cum. -0
Live walkthiough
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-Id
PORTFOLIO / VEND
Investment Thesis
Traditional retail relies on archaic payment and management systems: while online
stores have achieved various efficiencies. the much larger offline market relies on
idiosyncratic, expensive and antiquated systems of cash registers. disparate
software packages. and non-networked computers. Beyond simply being difficult to
use, bad point-of-sale systems start a host of other problems for businesses around
order tracking. inventory, reporting. and other channels the business may operate in,
like ecommerce.
Much like accounting systems, point-of-sale software is the central nervous system
of a small business, as all transactions originate through it. The information this
creates then needs to feed in to all of the other systems the business uses, and
provides a spring-board for understanding the complexities of day to day
operations. Unlike accounting systems however. point of sale software like Vend is
more easily portable to different countries and cultures, as its uses are largely the
same regardless of geography.
By creating a point-of-sale system that both customers and retailers find easy to
use and is native to the cloud, Vend makes offline retailing more efficient and
reliable (Vend even works when a store temporarily loses connectivity). Retailers no
longer have to bear the high fixed and variable costs of ad hoc payment and retail
management systems, freeing them to spend time on their area of highest
competitive advantage: curating compelling offline shopping spaces.
As Vend has matured as a company, its strategy has evolved. At launch, Vend
targeted mostly smaller retailers with few stores. As the team had seen with Xero,
unless using a clever solution, direct marketing to a disparate group of small
businesses is a large challenge. As a result. Vend found that moving up market in
terms of average store size has become a more valuable client base in many ways.
Larger businesses generally use more of the features Vend provides pay larger fees
to Vend, and churn less. They are also a more efficient use of marketing and sales
dollars in terms of unit economics.
History
Vend was founded in Auckland, New Zealand by Vaughan Rowsell, a programmer
with a long history at emerging companies. Valar's partners met Vaughan shortly after
completing their first investment in Xero in 2010. Over the next three years, Valar
followed Vend as it scaled in its home markets, executed on its business plan. and
expanded its team.
Persuaded that the founder had both the deep technical knowledge to develop a
comprehensive but intuitive retail system from first principles, and complemented by
a dedicated and business-savvy chairman, Valar led an expansion round of financing
in 2014.
Currant Status
Growth has continued to be robust, with more than 15.000 stores globally now relying
on Vend for their point-of-sale needs. With over 200 people. and offices in Auckland,
Toronto. San Francisco, London, and Melbourne, Vend has become a global business,
with customers on every continent.
As its user base has expanded, Vend has also been aggressively adding additional
functionality. Most recently, the company released an ecommerce platform for their
brick and mortar customers. giving traditional retail outlets the opportunity to
become omni-channel retailers, and begin leveraging their existing infrastructure by
selling products online.
Still growing at over 80% year-over-year top line. Vend has gotten traction with small
businesses, yet high customer acquisition costs remain a point of concern. Like many
startups that initially target the SMB market, the company will need to build an
efficient sales organization that can acquire larger business clients at an attractive
cost.
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-IS
PORTFOLIO / OPPA
Oppa - High Design Furniture at Affordable Prices
Brief Description
By thoughtfully curating its product line. emphasizing
online sales channels to consumers. and focusing on
lean inventory management. Oppa delivers fresh and
timely designed furniture to consumers while
maintaining low prices and high margins. Oppa has
been lauded in both the US and Brazil for its designs.
Facts
Founder:
Headquarters:
Notable Investors:
Max Reichel
Sao Paulo, Brazil
Thrive Capital. Monashees Capital.
Kaszek Ventures
Returns
Valar Cost Basis: $19.3M
Current FMV: $11.6M
Gross Multiple: 0.6x
Date of Initial Investment: 8/28/2012
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment $35.0M
Latest Company Valuation: $20.6M
oppo busts nil Om.
WOW'S
q 9 04.00•111 O Ordelatt) ase,..000S0
;sies preserSed heron are srsotted gloss estenSes as of December 312015
LANI cAMENTOS
1/ 00 .40/JULHO 20 1 S
erre tepos•••
Aso, 1Ro
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I c-16
PORTFOLIO / OPPA
Investment Thesis
Brazil's import regime and policies favor domestic manufacturers. providing
significant barriers to entry for foreign competitors, who would generally pay
exorbitant import tax if they were to operate in Brazil. In the furniture business for
instance, Ikea does not operate in Brazil, as there is a 100% import tax on foreign
sourced products. Despite the best intentions by the Brazilian government, this
creates an issue for middle class consumers. as even though they are becoming
wealthier as a group. the cost of household goods (particularly furniture) is often
much higher than in the US or Europe, while also being of much lower quality.
Oppa. started by a former McKinsey consultant. thought to provide another option,
by merging high-end design, low-cost manufacturing. and eliminating traditional
furniture industry middlemen; Oppa seeks to deliver both well-priced goods and
comparatively high gross margins relative to other retailers. By way of direct sales,
both online and offline, plus careful maintenance of lean inventory. Oppa (much like
Warby Parker in the US eyeglass market) can consistently produce contribution
margins that exceed conventional industry norms, without increasing prices.
VALAR VENTURES
History
Oppa's founder, Max Reichel, had followed the Thiel team for some time. Contact was
made, and after several rounds of diligence, Velar invested. along with Monashees, a
well-known Brazilian venture firm, which has been a local partner. and Velar has
syndicated deals with, in the time since.
After Vaiar's first priced investment, Oppa came to the firm for expansion capital.
Valar designed its follow-on investment to give the founder the time and flexibility to
explore additional sales channels to accelerate growth otherwise unavailable with
standard funding mechanisms. Oppa recently closed on a further round of financing,
led by a US-based investment firm, and plans to use this capital to expand its offline
showroom presence more rapidly through a franchise model.
Current Status
Oppa has continued to grow. gaining market share by maintaining high-quality, fresh
designs manufactured quickly and locally, but has had to deal with an increasingly
difficult capital markets and consumer environment, as the Brazilian economy has felt
the effects of a downward re-pricing in commodities. and sources of venture/growth
capital have disappeared.
In an effort to balance against these headwinds. the company has taken a number of
initiatives, including moving to a franchise model (as an alternative to taking equity
financing to fund domestic expansion), streamlining its warehouse operations,
relocating portions of its business to more tax optimal venues and optimizing its
product mix. While the opportunity to build a billion dollar online furniture brand still
exists, the current macro conditions in Brazil require Oppa to maintain growth while
moving towards cash flow breakeven, a challenge most ecommerce businesses are
not forced to face.
4CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-17
PORTFOLIO / DINDA
Dinda - Zulily for Brazil
Brief Description
Given the high cost of consumer goods in Brazil, there
is significant demand for fairly priced. high quality
baby products. Named after Brazil's gift-giving
"dindas" (godmothers). Dinda offers a wide range of
child-oriented products at extraordinary discounts to
Brazil's rapidly growing base of online consumers.
Facts
Founder:
Headquarters:
Notable Investors:
Kimball Thomas
Sao Paulo, Brazil
Accel Partners, Social+Capital.
Thrive Capital. SV Angel. Felicis
Ventures, Monashees Capital
Returns
Valar Cost Basis: $9.6M
Current FMV: $5.9f4
Gross Multiple: 0.6x
Date of Initial Investment: 2/20/2013
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $100M
Latest Company Valuation: $24.9M
Dinda.com.br
Otertas (lianas para babes. cnancas e marnaes
0 Cc0dtos RS 0.00
Conjuntinhos
rAcAlltRICS-A-R
TUDO por ate
RS 29,90
MARALINE
Caluntos choos a charrrol
Termna em 4 dies. 12 5.4 41
;Kit:esmaser-ledheron are ur4Ldrled gem c.ten.le; as of December 31.2015
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL& TRADE SECRET I C.8
PORTFOLIO / DINDA
Investment Thesis
The growing middle class in Brazil is badly underserved by ecommerce. even
though physical and retail infrastructure deficiencies make the case for the
convenience of ecommerce more compelling than in the advanced economies.
One particularly acute need in Brazil are goods and services for new parents. both
for essentials and for discretionary purchases. Price sensitive and fashion conscious,
Brazilian mothers have found Dinda's (which means godmother in Brazilian
Portuguese) offering of a flash sales platform the right mix of brands they trust. at
reasonable prices. Like Zulily in the United States, Dinda has endeared itself with its
customers through a combination of highly targeted product offerings for busy
moms, and the inclusive feel of required membership.
Zulily in this case is a good example of what Dinda is trying to become. The flash
sales model as a whole has been utilized in a number of diverse situations, some to
better effect than others. but Zulily is certainly in the category of successful
versions. One of the reasons for this success is the nature of the products, which are
the types of things that moms buy consistently and often. like clothes, bags. and
household items.
This kind of business model creates a certain kind of repeat customer - shoppers
both know they are getting the best possible price (since everything is discounted),
and are constantly reminded to check for new items, as the inventory changes
almost daily. Also, kids tend to grow out of their clothes constantly. All of these
factors may explain why today a majority of the shoppers at Dinda would
recommend the company to others.
VALAR VENTURES
History
Valar was introduced to the company by Tiger Global in 2012. At the time. the
company operated two websites: Baby.com.br and Dinda.com.br. The "Baby"
business was more of a traditional ecommerce model, along the lines of Diapers.com
in the US.
Over time, it became apparent that a simple ecommerce website selling baby items
wasn't going to generate sufficient gross margins in Brazil, but Dinda had much
stronger appeal with customers. and also better margins. Baby.com.br was sold and
Dinda became the company's sole focus.
Most recently. Dinda closed on a $4.9M Series D downround in October led by Accel
Partners.
Current Status
Dinda has continued to grow in a difficult macroeconomic environment and expand
its product offering towards mobile in a more significant way - the flash sales model
with its time dependency is particularly effective on mobile. Unsurprisingly. in 2015,
the key driver of growth for Dinda has been via its mobile platform, with 58% of web
traffic, and 55% of web orders now coming through the channel.
Like all Brazilian companies in ecommerce/retail, the past two years have been an
extremely challenging environment. Outside funding has dried up and to survive,
ecommerce companies have been forced to operate at break-even. Dinda now turns a
small profit or comes very close to covering costs on a monthly basis, while
maintaining a solid growth rate.
4CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-I9
PORTFOLIO / TRADEIT
Tradelt- Trade Now from Anywhere
Brief Description
Tradelt allows users to quickly and securely buy and
sell stocks with their existing online brokerage
accounts from any website or mobile device using
Tradelt's API. which integrates with major content
providers and apps.
Facts
Founders: Nathan Richardson, Gaspard de
Dreuzy
Headquarters: New York New York
Notable Investors: Citi Ventures
Returns
Valar Cost Basis: $2.2M
Current FMV: $2.5M
Gross Multiple: 11x
Date of Initial Investment: 4/2/2015
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $3.2M
Latest Company Valuation: $16M
Trade.it
TRADEIT
Trade now from anywhere Tr 0 WO" 04 MU 'r ✓M VA/ .»n aRt wth trV1a. 0✓50,0
Foxes preserfed herem are urauf ilia gross e;Orn.le; as of December 31. 2015
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET I C-20
PORTFOLIO / TRADEIT
Investment Thesis
Despite the fact that many online brokerages were built as a disruptive force to
main street banks. the speed with which technology has improved has already
started to put them in the rear window in terms of innovation - particularly with
respect to the migration to mobile. In addition. some large banks with significant
brokerage operations still have not migrated online, even though their target
customer base requires online trading ability. Tradelt and its API solve these pain
points by connecting major brokerage services with the places and times their
customers often make financial decisions - while reading financial content or
viewing their portfolio online and within mobile applications.
Tradelt offers a simple user interface that can plug into any web or mobile content,
allowing users to buy or sell securities through most brokerages. without having to
navigate away from whatever site they are visiting. As consumers increasingly
access their financial information through mobile devices. reducing friction in the
transaction process for buying and selling securities becomes more important.
By driving order flow through the apps and website people already use. content
publishers can be remunerated for routing trade orders without needing to build
their own online trading portal. And at the same time. brokerages get access to
users who may be considering a trade, but don't have the time or willingness to
navigate to a broker's website. log in. and place an order.
History
Andrew and one of the company's founders, Nathan Richardson, worked together at
Yahoo! from 2000-2001 where Nathan ran Yahoo! Finance. Nathan founded Tradelt
with Gaspard de Dreuzy to solve a pain point for internet-based financial content
providers and stock brokerages alike - finding better ways to monetize what should
ultimately be valuable customers. Valar led the company's $4M Series Seed equity
financing round with participation from Citi Ventures.
Current Status
Tradelt has secured agreements with several of the major online stockbrokers in the
US, including Fidelity. TD Ameritrade. Scottrade. Options House. TradeStation, and
more. The team is continuing to look for new partners and to expand their network of
content providers, which already includes TheStreet. MarketWatch. The Motley Fool,
and others. Tradelt has engaged advisors to help it expand outside the US and
expects to begin integrating with overseas brokerages in early 2016.
VALAR VENTURES CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET I C-2I
╔═══════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 FirstBank [bank] Puerto Rican bank used by Epstein 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00614142 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2015-06-30)
Valar Global Fund II LP
Unaudited Financial Statements
June 30, 2015
VALAR VIRNTURILS
Valar Global Fund II LP
Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Partners' Capital
June 30, 2015
Assets
Cash 1,363,955
Investments, at fair value (cost $15,409,617) 15,720,923
Interest receivable 2,204
Total assets $ 17,087,082
Liabilities
Accounts payable 11,398
Partners' Capital
Contributions 17,829,750
Net operating loss (1,065,372)
Net unrealized gain 311,306
Total partners capital 17.075.684
Total liabilities and partners' capital $ 17.087.082
Valar Global Fund II LP
Statement of Operations
January 6, 2015 through June 30, 2015
Income
Interest income 2,204
Expenses
Management fees 824,359
Organizational expenses 141,277
Professional fees 92,288
General and administrative 9,652
Total expenses 1,067,576
Net operating loss 1 065 372)
Net change in unrealized appreciation
in fair value of investments 311,306
Net decrease in partners' capital
resulting from operations $ (754,066)
Valar Global Fund II LP
Schedule of Investments
June 30.2015
Shares Cost Fair Value
Unrealized
Gain/(Loss)
Carmen, Inc.
Series Seed Preferred Shares 220,528 $ 136,000 $ 136,000 $
Eye Em Limited
Series B Preferred Shares 566,666 5,750,510 5,960,764 210,254
Granify Inc.
Series A-3 Preferred Shares 1,215,895 3,782,163 3,782,163 -
IrisVR, Inc.
Series AA Preferred Shares 215,942 170.000 170,000 -
Lystable Industries Ltd
Convertible Note 170.000 170,000 -
Number26 GmbH
Preferred A Shares 5,314 4,802,996 4,904,048 101.052
Oppa, Ltd.
Convertible Note 490,168 490.168
Trading Ticket, Inc.
Common Stock 329.662 107.780 107.780
Total Investments S 15.109.617 S 15.720.923 S 3 11.306
Valar Cobol Fund II LP
Summary of Acquisitions and Dispositions
April 1.2015 through June 30.2015
Company Date of Investment Company Headquarters Investment Type Cost Basis (USD) Current FMV (USD)
Trading Ticket. Inc. 04/02/15 New York Common Stock $107.780 $107.780
Eye Em Limited 04/14/15 Berlin Series B Preferred Shares $5.750,510 $5.960.764
Number26 GmbH 04/24/15 Berlin Preferred A Shares $4.802.996 $4.904,048
Lystable Industries Ltd 05/20/15 London Convertible Note $170.000 $170,000
Carmera. Inc. 06.05/15 Ncw York Series Seed Preferred Shares $136.000 $136.000
Oppa. Ltd. 06/11/15 Sao Paulo Convertible Note $490.168 $490.168
IrisVR. Inc. 06/26/15 Ncw York Series AA Preferred Shares $170.000 $170.000
Company Description
API for trading financial securities from
any partner site or app
Online marketplace for commercial
photography
Mobile-first bank for Europe
SaaS management of independent
contractors for the Enterprise
Generating quality "ground truth" road
and mapping data through roaming
sensors
Self-branded furniture and household
goods
Virtual reality software for architects and
designers
╔══════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Neoteny [crypto] Japanese venture fund of Joi Ito 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01118268 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Joi Ito's Neoteny 3 fund investor update
(date: 2015-06-30)
Neoteny 3, LP - Fund Partnership
Neoteny 3 Management, LLC - General Partner
nicor‘tivq3 Quarterly Report
June 30, 2015
c/o Neoteny 3 Management, LLC
do Prague & Company, P.C.
Fifteen Walnut Street, Suite I50
Phone:
E-mail 2:
www.neoteny.com
le IV ffoi6cnici3
CONTENTS
June 30, 2015 Quarterly Report
LETTER FROM THE GENERAL PARTNER 3
NEOTENY 3, LP INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO 4
Cash and Cash Equivalents Balance 4
Portfolio Companies 4
NEOTENY 3, LP UNAUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 5
Balance Sheet 5
Profit and Loss Statement 6
APPENDIX I - PORTFOLIO COMPANY DESCRIPTIONS 7
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 2
Ncor‘ovq_y June 30. 2015 Quarterly Report
LETTER FROM THE GENERAL PARTNER
August 13, 2015
Dear Partners,
June 30, 2015 marked the first quarter end for Neoteny 3, LP (the "Fund"). After the initial close on
March 31, 2015, the Fund made a capital call on April 2, 2015 equal to 100% of partners' capital
commitments (subject to certain foreign regulatory limitations). During the quarter, the Fund continued to
receive interest from potential investors, and a number of these investors have now been accepted as
partners. As of June 30, 2015, the Fund has received total capital commitments of $7,800,000, of which
$6,250,000 has been called and paid-in. The remaining capital will be called prior to the quarter ended
September 30, 2015 as the Fund has now received the required foreign regulatory approvals. The Fund
will continue to welcome inquiries from potential investors through the earlier of its first distribution to
partners or December 31, 2015 (final closing date), but intends to cap the Fund at $10,000,000.
Upon the initial close, the Fund began acquiring investments in portfolio companies. As of June 30, 2015,
the Fund has invested $1,008,066 in seven portfolio companies. Please see the next section for a summary
of the Fund's investment portfolio as of June 30, 2015. The Fund will continue to seek out additional
investment opportunities in the coming months and work strategically with others to build out its
investment portfolio. To this end, the Fund recognizes that many of its partners are professional investors,
business executives, innovators, industry leaders and the like. The Fund encourages these individuals to
share any potential investment opportunities they may have with the Fund. In turn, to the extent possible,
the Fund will do the same for its partners.
One of the reasons many people have invested in the Fund is to be exposed to the portfolio companies.
Many of the portfolio companies are interested in the Fund's partners as well. In this way, it is quite
different from a traditional find. The Fund would like to make a list of partners available to the portfolio
companies when talking to them. Please let the Fund know if you are interested or willing to be disclosed
in this way, and if so, how you would like to be listed, as many of you are using investment vehicles. In
addition, a number of partners have expressed interest in meeting each other and potentially some of the
portfolio companies. The Fund is considering the feasibility of a meeting, so please also indicate whether
you would be interested in such a gathering. Please e-mail Danielle Prague with your preferences
(Danielle@praguecpalaw.com).
As you know, the Fund maintains an online secure sharing platform through Intralinks
(www.intralinks.com). You may use this platform to view Schedule K-Is, annual and quarterly reports,
and information about the Fund's portfolio companies. Of note, the "Investment information and News"
folder contains an "Investment Tracker" that reflects the Fund's investments to date.
If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to contact the Fund. Thank you for your support.
Sincerely,
72. .0C )
Joichi Ito,
as manager of Neoteny 3 Management, LLC,
the General Partner of Neoteny 3, LP
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 3
nitO1O1)1(f_Y June 30, 2015 Quarterly Report
NEOTENY 3, LP INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO
Cash and Cash Equivalents Balance
(All amounts in United States Dollarsail
Cash and Cash Equivalents Amount (S)
Beginning of the Quarter - April I, 2015 (Inception) so
Funds Raised $6,250,000
Capital Invested S(I 008 066)
Expenses / Organizational Costs 5(116,123)
Other Items $30
End of the Quarter -June 30, 2015 $5,123,841
Portfolio Companies
(All amounts in United States Dollars(S))
Company Name Investment Date Amount (S)r Investment Type Website
Crowd Supply. Inc. Apr. 22. 2015 $101341 492,805 shares of Series Seed II Prefaced Stock www.crowdsupply.00m
Emerald Therapeutics. Inc. I Jun. 19, 2015 S100,064 25.916 shares of Series C Preferred Stock www.emenldeloudlab.com
Kemoko, Inc. (a/k/a Panoply) Feb. 20, 2015 S100.000 128,568 shares of Series Seed Preferred Stock www.itskoko.com
O112 Laboratories, 1.1.0 Apr. 7, 2015 S175,533
575,532
Convenible promissory note
50.000 Funding Units
www.oh2labonitories.com
Top Flight Technologies, Inc. Jun. 8.2015 $250,035 Convertible promissory notc www.thightiech.com
Udu. Inc. Mar. 31,201$ $10/,059
SO
Convertible promissory note
Warrant for 20,000 shares of Common Stock
twitteccomtuduinc
Wearality Comonnion Apr. 27, 2015 $101,502 Convertible promissory note www.wearality.com
TOTAL $1,008,066
Amount means the original purchase price of each investment plus associated capital expenditures.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 4
Ncotffivq3 June 30, 2015 Quarterly Report
NEOTENY 3, LP UNAUDITED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS
Balance Sheet
Unaudited, U.S. Tax Basis
As of June 30, 2015
(All amounts in United States Dollars(S))
YEAR TO DATE JUNE 30,2015
ASSETS
CURRENT ASSETS
Cash and Cash Equivalents $5,125,841
TOTAL CURRENT ASSETS $5,125,841
OTHER ASSETS
Investments in Portfolio Companies $1,008,066
Organizational Costs $86,692
I Accumulated Amortization $(1,445)
;Net Organizational Costs $85,247
TOTAL OTHER ASSETS S1,093,313
TOTAL ASSETS $6,219,154
LIABILITIES AND EQUITY
CURRENT LIABILITIES
Due To Partners $30
TOTAL CURRENT LIABILITIES $30
TOTAL LIABILITIES $30
EQUITY
Partners' Capital Accounts $6,250,000
Net Income/(Loss) $(30,876)
TOTAL EQUITY $6,219,124
TOTAL LIABILITIES AND EQUITY $6,219,154
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION
NE0'6041(13 June 30, 2015 Quarterly Report
Profit and Loss Statement
Unaudited, U.S. Tax Basis
Through Quarter Ended June 30, 2015
(All amounts In United States Dollars (3))
YEAR TO DATE TUNE 30, 2015
EXPENSES
Fund Expenses $29,431
Amortization Expense - Organizational Costs $1,445
TOTAL EXPENSES $30,876
NET INCOME / (LOSS) S(30,876)
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 6
enica6tivq3 June 30, 2015 Quarterly Report
APPENDIX I - PORTFOLIO COMPANY DESCRIPTIONS

• Crowd Supply, Inc. is a crowdfunding platform focused on new product development projects.
The platform supports campaigns, pre-orders (once a campaign has been successfully funded) and
e-commerce sales of completed, fully manufactured products.

• Emerald Therapeutics, Inc. is a venture-backed biotechnology company based in San
Francisco, California. One of the projects it has launched is the Emerald Cloud Lab, a web-based
life sciences lab, developed by scientists for scientists. ECL conducts lab experiments designed
by customers, collects the data and organizes it into a database its customers can access remotely.

• Kemoko, Inc. (a/k/a Panoply) is the company behind the mobile app Koko. Koko was designed
to provide peer-to-peer mental health support through a social network that actually helps you
feel better. Koko has yet to be launched for public use.

• OH2 Laboratories, LLC is a synthetic materials lab. The company mainly focuses on
developing variant water-soluble O-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) that maintain the
functionality of the original. It also provides consulting services to pharma and other research
entities. It continues to seek ways to monetize its technologies in drug and related arenas.

• Top Flight Technologies, Inc. is dedicated to application-specific, cost effective commercial
solutions of unmanned aircraft vehicles (UAVs) using the latest advanced technologies driving
automation and safety. A key innovation is a very small gasoline-based hybrid engine that has
very high energy densities compared to batteries.

• Udu, Inc. is a scheduling and communication platform built on a web services abstraction
framework; chat, exchange media, and share with your favorite social networks, while the udu
app does the work of planning the event.

• Wearality Corporation develops field of view (FOV) head wearable display technology that is
comfortable and gives a natural visual experience. It is the creative force behind Wearality Sky,
lightweight, fold-able, opensource 3D glasses that put a movie theater in your pocket.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 7
EFTA01123862 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(date: 2015-06-30)
VALAR VENTURES
Fall 2015 Update
VALAR VENTURES
Fall 2015 Update
The past two quarters have seen a lot of activity at Valar. Although still
early days, Fund 2's existing portfolio companies are tracking nicely.
Number26 has reached nearly 50,00O users since launching in
February and transaction activity is scaling disproportionally faster.
EyeEm has increased sales of its images through its marketplace
partner, Getty Images, 5x since we made our investment earlier this
year. They have now also launched their own marketplace in six
countries, including the United States. Granify has more than doubled
its team and multiplied its committed pipeline by 9x in the past two
quarters. We've also made two new major investments this quarter,
including the Fund's largest investment to date - a $12 million Series B
investment in Montreal-based Breather - and the Fund's smallest major
investment so far - a $2 million Series Seed investment in New York-
based Trading Ticket. We are excited about the prospects for both of
these companies and teams, and believe they are strong additions to
the Fund, including in terms of stage and sector. Details on each
investment and related press articles are attached.
With the closing of these new investments, roughly $40 million of Fund
2 has now been invested, which is broadly in line with our expectation
of investing around $50 million per year in new investments. As Fund 2
is now over 70% called and reserved for follow-on investments, we are
in the process of raising Fund 3, with a first closing expected prior to
the end of this year and a first capital call after the New Year (i.e., a
2016 vintage fund). Fund 3 will have a target of $200 million in capital
commitments, with a $250 million hard cap. Fund 3 will optimally be as
large as Funds 1 and 2 combined, which, among other things, should
allow for the right amount of portfolio diversification for our core
strategy of leading Series A and Series B financing rounds (i.e..12-14
major investments in the Fund with initial check sizes generally within
the $5 million-$10 million range). We expect that our existing investors
in Fund 2 will participate substantially in Fund 3 and we are looking
forward to adding a select number of new investors with whom we
have been building relationships over the past two years.
Fund 1 Highlights
Inception: October 2010
Total Invested: $93.6M
Total Gross & Net Values: $287.7M / $239.3M
Total Gross & Net Multiples: 31x /2.6x
Gross & Net IRRs: 65.2% / 53.0%
% of Fund Invested/Reserved: 100%
Fund 2 Highlights
Inception:
Total Capital Commitments:
Total Invested:
Current Investment Value:
Gross & Net Multiples:
% of Fund Invested/Reserved:
January 2015
$102M
$38.7M
$39.4M
1.0x/1.0x
71%
VALAR VENTURES - FALL 2015 UPDATE CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET 12
VALAR VENTURES
In terms of team activity, the past few months have been busy with
trips to Canada, Utah and many parts of Europe. As a result of our
active travel schedule, we've been able to build on our existing
relationships with many of the top early-stage investors in our usual
markets of London and Berlin. while also adding new relationships in
places like Amsterdam, Prague. Vienna and Montreal. Our positioning
and growing track record as a Series A/ Series B investor with deep
US and Silicon Valley connections is compelling to local firms and we
continue to see high quality dealflow as a result. In particular, we
believe that the startup ecosystems in our primary markets continue to
mature at a rapid pace. One recent indicator of this is the increasing
amount of seed stage and early Series A capital available across
Europe. We have noted several new funds being formed recently (e.g.,
Mosaic. Blue Yard) and existing firms closing on larger funds (e.g..
Earlybird. Lakestar). We believe this is both evidence of the validity of
our core thesis and deepens the opportunity set by increasing the
breadth and depth of the early-stage funding necessary to
consistently produce the multi-billion dollar businesses required to
generate outsized returns in each vintage year.
Finally, in hiring news, in June we added a second associate to our
investment team. John Tenet, who joined us from Allen & Company,
where he spent three years in that firm's Capital Markets and
Investment Management Divisions. Together with Mike Bosserman
(hired in January). John is focused on sourcing and evaluating
investment opportunities and helping our existing portfolio companies.
John has had an immediate impact, bringing in some interesting
investment opportunities, including one that is now in an advanced
stage of due diligence. We expect that one area of increasing focus for
both John and Mike will be in New York City, where our proximity
should give us an advantage over Silicon Valley-based firms and our
global network differentiates us from other New York-based firms.
Going forward, we expect our funds may include a meaningful amount
of New York-based investments, providing a degree of scalability to
our investment team without sacrificing the core advantages of
remaining lean.
As always, we are deeply grateful for the confidence you've placed in
us. We look forward to connecting in person with many of you this Fall.
This document is confidential, trade secret. and not for further circulation. This document is informational and is not 
an offer or solicitation to buy, sell or
Mid any securities. As used herein, "Fund r refers
to all funds and investment vehicles managed by Valar Ventures Management LLC prior to the formation of Valar Global 
Fund 2, on an aggregate basis. Figures
presented for Fund I are unaudited
estimates in USD as of 6/30/2015. Net figures were calculated by reducing gross profits by a flat 25% for hypothetical 
management fees. expenses. and carry.
Figures presented for Fund 2 are unaudited
estimates in USD as of 9/10/2015, in order to include investments made following the end of the prior quarter.
VALAR VENTURES- FALL 2O15 UPDATE CONFIDENTIAL 8, TRADE SECRET 13
VALAR VENTURES
New Investments
*breather Headquarters: Montreal Company Description
Security Held: Series B-2 Preferred Shares Breather operates a marketplace for branded, high-design, private office 
spaces
(referred to as "Breathers") that fill a need for a short term, quiet place to work,
Investment Date: 9/10/2015 meet or relax.
Round Size: $18,900,000
Pre-Money Valuation: $ 80,000,000
Fund II Investment: $12,000,000
Figures as of 9/10/2015.
Velar Investment Thesis
Until now, the need for a place to work on the go has been filled by a mix of
coffee shops, parks, airport lounges, bars, church basements and similar shared
spaces. Through Breather's mobile app and website, users can book, on an
hourly basis, beautiful, private spaces that are equipped with fast Wi-Fi and air
conditioning. As work culture undergoes a dramatic shift from traditionally large
employers with rigid office hours to sole proprietorships and more flexible
working arrangements, the Breather marketplace fills a growing need for a
consistent, trusted brand in on-demand work space. A confluence of factors
make the company's offering possible: smart phone ubiquity, decentralized
workforces, internet-enabled locks, and increased familiarity and appetite
among consumers for on-demand services.
Financing History
Breather raised a $1.8M Seed round in July 2013, led by Real Ventures. In July
2014, the company raised a $6M Series A, led by RRE Ventures, with
participation from SOS Ventures and Real Ventures. Breather also raised a
supplementary $1M convertible note from Slow Ventures shortly thereafter.
VALAR VENTURES - FALL 2015 UPDATE CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET 14
VALAR VENTURES
TRADE IT Headquarters: New York
Security Held: Series Seed Preferred Shares
Investment Date: 7/10/2015
Round Size: $ 4,000,000
Pre-Money Valuation: $12,000,000
Fund II Investment: $ 2,000,000
Figures as of 9/10/2015.
Company Description
Trading Ticket (dba Tradelt) facilitates quick and secure online stock trading
through any website or app.
Valar Investment Thesis
Despite the fact that many online brokerages were built as a disruptive force to
main street banks, the speed with which technology has improved has already
started to put them in the rear window in terms of innovation - particularly with
respect to the migration to mobile. In addition, some large banks with
significant brokerage operations still have not migrated online, even though
their target customer base requires online trading ability. Trading Ticket and its
API solve these pain points by offering a simple user interface that can plug into
any website or content, allowing users to buy or sell securities through their
preferred broker and connecting major brokerage services with the places and
times their customers often make financial decisions - while reading financial
content or viewing their portfolio online and within mobile applications.
Financing History
Prior to leading Trading Ticket's Series Seed Preferred financing round, Valar
participated in Trading Ticket's $1M pre-seed round in April 2015.
VALAR VENTURES - FALL 2015 UPDATE CONFIDENTIAL 8 TRADE SECRET 15
F9
TIC , t . , Let us know.
News - Video- Events- CrunchBase
„s f Iat P in
Search
DISIMWIF W The Come:Sam Nes Seim • Disrupt Sc San Next week Go Your Tickets Ntror
C2=1 Cal
NersheYs 3D
Printer Prints
Chocolate
Snapchat Starts
Charging $0.99
For 3 Replays.
AddS Face Effect
"tense."
Talking (About
Tech Diversity) Is
Hard
It I 4•Year•Old Boy
Arremed For
Bringing
Homemade Clock
To School
A Case Study Of
Startup Failure
ad Hersheys
Chocolate 3D
Printer whips Up
Any Sweet Design
You want
Facebook is
Building An
Empathy Button.
Not
Here's How It
Could Work
Breather Raises $2oM From Peter Thiel's Valar
Ventures To Expand Its On-Demand Private Room
Business
295  la
InieilliwOlm
fidithE
Today is a good day
Breather, the ondemand private room service has raised 120M led by Peter Thiel's Velar
Ventures. The series B brings Breathers full raise to S27M. This round also had participation
from Real Ventures, RRE Ventures, Slow Ventures and SOS Ventures. Valar will join the board.
The Breather rooms were set up as *secret places-  within cities like New York that allow you
to get work done, have meetings or whatever you'd rather not do at a Starbucks. The best
usecase is when you're traveling, because sometimes you just need to sit down with some
WiFi at a place that's not a coffee shop or a hotel. Its app lets you find a room, pay and unlock
the door.
I chatted with Breathers co-founder and CEO Julien Smith about how far the business has
come and what's on deck next for the company that got through the initial giggles about what
would be going on its rooms. The immediate plan, Smith says is: ^New cities, marketing,
growing existing cities. We really believe there can be a unit like this in every commercial
building in America. Completely serious?
CrunchBase
Peter Thiel
8:0
Pee Thal it •tnrytology awry...on, an, ervivol.
weeit gsneclatterbon lot imcnitirei in ti nny
e,0 sunup inrite Todrypeis .110m, ai pt MtetCe
04 the Pefra, ', MU a enUti,reneun. as wet as lot
waresnp old ceennentrology deka vet,'
store economK CrICKluteCt, rte worts to
accelerate inriOni:Cn to pre .tor non a ons ey
denbtrig and rtangprorn4r. teoinciogi •
RRE Ventures
Starbucks
Valar ventures
Breather
TC NEWSLETTERS
TechCrunch 'IC Week-in-
Daily Review
Our top TOp Vents of
headlines the week
Delivered di* Delivered weekly
CrunchBase
Daily
The 'atesl View More
Neat Stery
Follow • • •
TC News Startups Mobile Gadgets Enterprise Social Europe Trending ,aal Apple Boogie Teethe.*
SOaCeX Tide
Nearly A Full
Uber Funding In
Contracts
oklik The Pod Pro Will
Keep Both Your
Apple Watch And
&hone Charged
!IL Typeform Gets
11SM To Expand
its API For User
interaction
Right now the average Breather is booked for 2« hours, but can go from 30 minutes to an
entire day. Smith also says *thousands' of bookings roll in weekly.
TC: how has the business changed since you started it?
JS: Wow. so much. I had a lot of ideas about what
the company would be before we began, but they
were basically just guesses. We just had a thesis
that pm/ate space would be useful to people (if it
were affordable and nice) and we didn't think with
too much intent about what the audience would
be.
The service basically took off Immediately after we
launched, so we clarified who we are speaking to
really quickly. We know the audience better, we
know how to talk about the product we know
what kind of spaces people want and for what
reason, we know how the operations work. etc. etc. We started with a huge emptiness in
terms of our understanding and just an optimistic idea. lucky for us. we turned out to be
pretty right.
TC: Are there any surprise uses of breathers that you're a fan of?
$5: Multiple people have proposed in breathers - that was a huge surprise. People use them
for meetups all the time, and although that's pretty commonplace, we were surprised to see
it. Women use it to breast-feed. which makes sense. and there are church groups as well.
Music videos and documentaries for Netflix have been shot in them. famous actors have used
them to rehearse for big movies. Press previews and little fashion shows. All kinds of things.
People even use them for training sessions for new employees.
TC: If someone else were to try to get into the space, what difficulty would they have?
JS: The network effects in this business are very, very strong, perhaps even stronger than
Uber, because location, quality, and trust are so important to us getting a booking. A car can
move, but rooms don't, so the same way you always go to the closest, most convenient coffee
shop. and wont go if it's too far away, we have to be very. VERY close to the user for the
service to be effective for them.
A roan el your am
Nola{ pg•apellisin,•••••Vl
4,0 •, ....1. 10 ••• • • •••• •••••• •••••
to Wad.. ilFrO•Se.11,00,...
O
Yraweever you are Wheonever ywa need k
..,•••.• •••• TeM r•.• •-•••
%de. Iry ••••-•••• , me
....••••••••••••"4 OW • •••...
announ<rnentc
Othvered doily
Enter Address SUBSCRIBE
LATEST CRUNCH REPORT
Watch More Episodes
Ned n
News Startups Mobil< Gadgets Enterprise Social Europe Trending Si Apple Google facebook
TC: Are there changes coming to Breathers based on feedback you've gotten? More snacks?
Ws? etc
JS: Yeah. for example I was strongly against technology inside breather locations for a super
long time. I barely even wanted WiFi in the spaces at all. But now it became clear that
traditional things like whiteboards. flatscreen TVs. and other business type amenities are
pretty helpful. There's a line we won't cross - you wont see any fax machines in breather
locations anytime soon for example - but we really started to accommodate the user on
things like this even though we started with a pretty strong stance against it.
San Francisco
Every city in America? Sounds like a grand plan. Right now. Breather is available in New York.
Boston. San Francisco. Montreal and Ottawa.
295
SHARES f She V Tie in share
Story
Let us know.
News Video Events CrunchBase Search
7 F in
DeMUPT SP The Coseeckrorn Wi Beton Dittopt Sr S•.x¢ Vert week Get Tour !Muds Row
Herstleys 3D
MSPrinter Prints
Chocolate
Raspberry PI Now
Makes A
TOuChscreen
Display So You
Can Build Your
Oem PiPad Pro
Mil IS Hidden New
FeatureS Tucked
Away In i05 9
Lulus light Bulbs
Allow Devices TO
Talk To Each
Other YAth
Flashes Of
Brilliance
SnaOthat Starts
Charging $0.99
For 3 Replays. r
Adds Face Effect
-tenses-
t
14-year-Old Boy
Arrested For
Bringing
Homemade Clock
To School
Aced Partners
LOOks TO Map
The Marketing
Technology
Ecosystem
Trading Ticket Gets $4M From Thiel's Valar Ventures,
Citi, Launches Instant Trading Tool Trade It Ingrid Lunden amgr.Munden
7-r ILIUDOMMI2101;11
Finance technology has been one of the more lucrative areas in the world of disruptive
startups, with companies picking up billions of dollars in private investment: and, by Goldman
Sachs estimates. on track to grab $4.7 trillion of revenues away from established financial
players. Now, make way for one more new entrant hoping to make its mark in fintech.
Trading Ticket, a startup based out of New York, wants to develop a suite of products that will
help consumers become more active. and proactive. investors. It has closed a $4 million seed
round as it gears up to officially launch Its first product a mobile frlendly securities trading
tool called Trade It.
While Trade It is just getting off the ground, the funding in Trading Ticket is notable in that it is
coming from two key names in the fintech world: Valar Ventures, the investment fund started
by PayPal co-founder and top VC Peter Thiel; and Oti Ventures, the investment arm of the Citi
banking group. (Prior to this, the company had raised an undisclosed amount in angel
funding from Newfund, and was largely bootstrapped it tells me.)
CrunchBase
Trading Ticket
Train/ Tidal a startup based et Olken Yoh
rants to develops Tr to or prod/cis that Minato
convolve% become mono east and proxive.
ineeslon. Timid is a pan pawned recrinokea Pin
am alpha on a publey Intel putarMaRIPlathaver
Trades Hem used to Die */ 4.4 NV./ pace Onlen
ath cede ttaefe rent Warmest accosts hem
any vadat* Or meal* onica Oweropes
LOCATION
Him ♦o'4 ha am.
CATEGORIES
s.a.e.s Ironer. Pravne
FOUNDERS
Saw Pea. runhan PX%rarril toped tre Dram
wtiniTt
entpliim tux?, tce
put " -•adingicket
Tradelt
Citi Ventures
Valar Ventures
Blake Darcy
♦
♦
♦
TC NEWSLETTERS
Techtrunch TC WwlabH
Daily Review it) Follow • • •
Tc News Startups mobile Gadgets tnterprise Social Europe Trending Gg Apple Gongle notebook
Hyperloop In
Raising 180M
Names EM•04(0
Pres Rob Lloyd AS
CEO And Emay
white As Advtsor
Homeland
Stringy Shuts
Down Ubrarys
TOR Node Citing
'Situational
Awareness'
Tang (About
Tech Diversity) Is
Hard
Trading Tickers three co-founders have equally notable backgrounds. CEO Nathan
Richardson has led a number of finance and content businesses, including WayWire. Yahoo
Finance, AOL and others. Serge Kreiker is formerly of Bloomberg. and Gaspard de Dreuzy is a
co-founder and CEO of doctor house call app Pager. The latter two are also co-founders of
Kapitall.
Trading Ticket has wide ambitions. The idea Is to develop a series of mobile and desktop
products covering all manner of financial transactions: apps to help people open accounts;
access credit place orders for shares and communicate with each other and their financial
service providers.
Trade It the first product, will focus on the third of these areas. It's an API-based service that
lets people place orders for trades instantly and securely directly on third -party sites. apps or
Twitter.
It works by linking up mentions of a company name, ticker symbol or shortened URL with
order tickets that connect with a users brokerage accounts, letting them place orders on the
fly. It also will mark the first time that an ETF (exchange trading fund, or a marketable security
that tracks an index, a bond, a commodity or a basket of assets) can be traded directly
without the need to go through a registered investment adviser.
Trade It will make money in three ways. Richardson says: by way of transaction revenue and
taking a fee per order; marketing sponsorships (essentially ad units that will run in the trading
order ticket); and technology licensing fees.
Early partners for Trade It will include financial mobile apps Stock Tracker. Stocks Live.
Rubicoin, and Invstr: and irs also working with BenzInga. MarketWatch, The Motley Fool,
VETR and ARK Invest for ElTs. Richardson says that the partnerships for the
service will all be launching October 1. While the tech works both on desktop and mobile, to
date. early usage of the service has seen some 80% of all orders placed via mobile devices.
Like ecommerce APIs that let you buy items directly from places where you are talking or
reading about them online, the idea here is to bring the process of trading directly to the
places where you are already going to read and act on business news. In a way, given
Richardson's background across both finance and content, its not really a surprise to see him
working on a product that brings the two together.
'Trade It solves the three most difficult problems in mobile trading,' said Richardson in a
statement. "Speed to trade for users, order volume for brokers, and a direct monetization
opportunity for publishers who don't want the conflict of becoming a broker -dealer.'
While there have been a lot of new services launched that take advantage of online and
mobile innovations to cut down the time for certain financial services — online banking
possibly being one of the most widely used — services focused on consumers and how they
trade has seen relatively little development.
Our top Top stares of
head nes the week
Oetwered say Delivered weekly
CrunchBase
Daily
The Lunt
startup funding
announcements
Other ed daffy
View More
SUBSCRIBE
LATEST CRUNCH REPORT
AgI.e.:1600k
O,
t /L... A Facebook Isn't Building A Dislike
Button I Crunch Report
Watch More Episodes
Nat Day
Trading Ticket is the first financial technology company to integrate mobile trading
seamlessly into online publishing platforms; said Ramneek Gupta. Managing Director and
CO-Head of Investing at Citi Ventures, in a statement. 'We're excited to add them to our
Ts: N. Startups Mobile Gadgets Enterprise Social Europa Trending -71.a- Apple Genie Facebook
portfolio of investments that enable banking to come to the customer, empowering them to
act anytime and anywhere.'
(More specifically, Richardson tells us that after a user registers with the service, Trade It does
not hold credentials for desktop use. 'We hold user name based on publisher preference: he
notes. To make the trade on desktop, users need to enter a password, the amount of the
order and then confirm to place the order. On mobile, he notes that some apps will let users
store their broker credentials on iOS using TouchlD. but users will still need to enter the
order, number of shares and confirm with TouchlD.)
As part of the investment round, Andrew McCormack of Valar and Dlidirect founding CEO
Blake Darcy are joining Trading Tickers board, with Gupta coming on as a board observer.
"Trading Tickers technology position, seasoned leadership team, and strong reception with
both established and new financial services players is impressive: said Valar's Andrew
McCormack in a statement. 'We believe the global opportunity for integrated, mobile trading
Is very promising and Trade It is well positioned to capitalize on Its most valuable areas.'
HAWAII) IMAGE FINNS STIIAUMMAVIS WOO - CC SY 20 1, ,
759 SHARES w heat in Shar
®Dunn
a ("pry
EFTA01205267 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2015-06-30)
VALAR VENTURES
Limited Partner:
Fund:
Unaudited Statement of
Changes in Partner's Capital
As of Jun 30, 2015
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
Valar Global Fund II LP
Commitment: $ 15,000,000
Paid in Capital: $ 3,750,000
Remaining: $ 11,250,000
Current
Quarter
Year to
Date
Inception to
Date
Partner's capital, beginning $ 929,917 $ 0 $ 0
Contributions $ 2,700,000 $ 3,750,000 $ 3,750,000
Net operating income/(loss)
Management fees $ (85,253) $ (173,732) $ (173,732)
Partnership expenses $ (19,140) $ (50,744) $ (50,744)
Interest income $ 460 $ 460 $ 460
Total net operating income/(loss) $ (103,933) $ (224,016) $ (224,016)
Distributions $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
Net realized gain/(loss) on investments $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
Net unrealized gain/(loss) on investments $ 64,950 $ 64,950 $ 64,950
Partner's capital, ending $ 3,590,934 $ 3,590,934 $ 3,590,934
EFTA02710849 (Jmail)
 [money] Pensum BJAV Marine Ltd / Arcadia Group invoice
(inferred date: 2015-06-30)
Invoice Number: 250210
BJAV MARINE LTD

P. O. Box 10300
Grand Cayman KY I -1003
CAYMAN ISLANDS At gust 28. 2014
Professional services rendered tin US$1:
Work performed with respect to mortgage registration (including expenses), updating
company records, request for documents for VAT, and accounting
3.166./5
July 1,2014 to June 30,2015:
Basic Annual Fees 1.830.00
Services provided by Arcadia Group Ltd July 1, 2014 to June 30, 2015
Nominee Shareholder (12/12 months @ US$450) 450.00
Corporate Secretary (12/12 months @ US$450) 450.00
Out of pocket expenses:
Monetary Authority Filing fee 2014 200.00
Communications 109.18
Local and international couriers 126.01 435.19
Sub-total — fees plus out of pocket expenses US$ 6,431.44
Less retainer received for mortgage registration (2.787.50)
Total now due US$ 3443.94
Kindly forward payment within 21 days of receipt. l • npaid invoices will incur additional work
performed charges billed at hourly rates.
WIRING INSTRUCTIONS
To:
ABA Routing No:
For credit of:
Account No:
To further credit:
Bank of New York, 48 Wall St., New York 10286 USA
0210-00018 Swift ID: IRVTUS3N
Butterfield Bank (Cayman) Limited
803-3265-086 Swift ID: BNTBKYKY
Pensum Ltd., Sub-Account No. 01 201 032195
Cayman Business Pa 10024 • Grand Cayman KY I-1001, CAYMAN ISLANDS
T E: Accounts@PensumOffshore.com •
W: PensumOffshore.com
CREDIT CARD AUTHORIZATION (4% Qom ellIC:WC feel
MasterCard/Visa Number: Exp:
NAME OF CARDHOLDER
SIGNATURE OF CARD HOLDER:
PAYMENT BY CHECK
Please note our bank no longer accepts Money Orders or Travelers Checks. There will be a USSI0
bank surcharge to process US$ checks drawn on US banks as of May 1, 2014
Cayman Business Park A7 • P.O. Box 10024 • Grand Cayman KY1-1001, CAYMAN ISLANDS
T: (345) 945-1830 • E: Accounts@PensumOffshore.com •
W: PensumOffshore.com
EFTA01285647 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank statement for Epstein's Southern Trust Company
(inferred date: 2015-07-31)
Deutsche Bank El
Deutsche Bank Must Co. Americas
New To& NY 10154
Sol I I tERN TRUST COMPANY. INC.
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3
ST THONLAS
00802
UNITED STATES VI
July 1.2015 !platy 31. 2015
Summary of Account Ilalanee(s)
Account Account Number Balance
For personal assistance call:
Amanda Kirby
Balance
Elite Money Market Deposit
Beginning Balance as of July I. 2015
571.753.496.27
$73.344,188.56
Deposits and Other Credits 59.307 71
Checks Paid $0.00
AIM and Dcbit Card Withdraoals 50.00
Service Charges and Other Fees $0.00
Other Debits (51.600,000.00 )
Ending Balance as of July 31. 2015
Transaction Detail
Date Description Debit
571.753.496.27
Credit
Beginning Balance as of July 1. 2015 S73.344.1113 56
07.24 a Outgoing Money Tmsf
TO SILICON VALLEY BANK otiC
9 VALAR GLOBAL FUND 11 LP
(600.000.00 ) 72.744.18836
07-28 x Outgoing Money Tins(
TO °MBANK AiC MORGAN STAN
LEY
(1.000,000.00 ) 71,744.18836
07-31 N Interest Payment 9.307.71 71.753.496.27
Ending Balance as of July 31. 2015 (1.600.000.00 ) 59.30771 571.753.496.27
All items ate credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceed< in cash or by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas.
I of SDNY_GM_00041966
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.
iN
GRIM. P.
I DE NTIAL DB-SDNY-0004790
Deutsche Bank
Deposits and Other Credits
Date lkscription
07-31 Interest Payment
Amount
59.307.71
&nice Charges and Other Fees
Thal NSF Mum item fees for this statement period 50.00
Total NSF Mum item lees for this calendar year 50.00
Total Overdrall foes for this statement period SO 00
Total Overdraft fees for this calendar year saw
Other Debits
INte lk-scription Amount
07-24 Outgoing Slone\ Traci (5600.000.00
07-28 Outgoing Money Tntsf 151.000.000.00
Interest Calculation
Annual Percentage Yield Earned
Interest EMU(' This Period
Interest Paid Year To Date
0.15°0
59.307.71
570.098.57
All items an credited subject to final collection and receipt of prtmenh in cash or by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
2 of 3 SDNY_OM_ 00041967
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. ca. N u(e) IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0004791 F EFTA (()152576
Deutsche Bank El
In Case of Furors or Questions

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at 1-866-362-4796. or write to us at Deutsche Bonk Trust Company Americas. 345 Park Avenue. WNI Banking 
learn -
NYC20-0102. New York New York 10154 as sown as you can if you think your statement or receipt is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MUST hear from you no later than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRSTstatement on which ihe error or problem appeared.

• Tell us yam name and account number
- Describe the error or transfer you arc unsure about. and explain as clearly as you can why you believe it is an error 
or why you
need more information

• Tell in the dollar amount of tlw suspected error
Please rare that if you initially provide the above information to us via telephone. we may require that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within 10 business days.
We will investigate your complaint and will correct any error promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 
days for new
accounts) to do this. we will provisionally credit your account fa the amount you think is in error, so that you will 
have the use of the
money during the time it takes us to complete our investigation. Al Ow conclusion of our invatigation we will inform you
of our results.

2. Non-Electronic Funds Transfers
Cann the Bank immediately at 14366•362•4796 if your statement is incorrect or if you need more inlbmiation about any 
non-electronic
funds tr.urastions (cheeks or deposits) on this statement. If any such error appears. you must notify the lkrnk in 
%wiling no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you. Please see yin, -lams and Conditions for further information on 
the terms
governing your account.

3. VerilYing Preau0urved Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once every 60 days from the same prison or  
company, you
can telephone us at 1.866.362.4796 to find out whether the deposit has been made.
SDNY_GM_ 00041968
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R c9r.o(e) N DB-SDNY-0004792
RID ENTIAL
EFTA01359508 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2015-09-28)
Deutsche Bank
Private Wealth Management
Authorization for Asset Movement
For Non-Retirement Accounts The undersigned hereby authorizes and rheas Deutsche Bank Alex Brown (-Deutsche Bank Mr. 
Brown' or 'DRAB} to follow the below asset
movement instructions
You veil , to mount multiple wires. checks. roumals or free dainties. geese we the long Form
DBAB  Account  Nem°  Southern  hilatclIMPA3
Account ir:
Wire
U.1 Vara ledertd funds in the nun, of $ 1.950.000.00
to flank Name Silicon Valley Bank
City I State:
ABA I.
Further credit to th teerniedlary Financial Institution (OPtionel)
Account a
Nerve
Ultenree Partaftlarykdormetkec
Deafly Wm,  Velar Global Fund II LP
account
Addientl Insets:acre Southern trind_Crompa y Ins
CanItal Call 5
Cheek
❑ Issue a check in the amount of S
Rettenre time
fleapwaS Mefrg Mess
Journal
J Journal heat in the amount of S
Journal Holdings.
OhnStrimcvScosity:
Cry ,S moo/Secuitty:
U Journal An Noklings
Iv DRAB Account t
AtO.r...01 Name.
Roe Nevares
Please Mos the monies inacated below to
DICCe
Name of Recarying Firm.
Account Name:
A hoont Number
OterSvinbotrSucurien
Oly4Symbolaacurih -
at Receiving Fern
Sianclarg Asehodzadon -
Uthe °nip, sgrwd hereby requests that this authomation as as a 'tendon euthovueoen. The undersigned unassisted* and 
agrees that the authoneelien kw'
remain in el tact until Deutsche Bank Max Brown etiquette a new euthontaeon The underugned apthootc• Deutsche Bank Aksx 
Brawn to *sue th e we.
check or Jeanne! on the day of lore tempt
0 The undersigned lurch.' authorizes Deutsche Bank Net Brown to accept verbal instructions from th e undersigned to wire
tunas. issue cheeks or }ours
funds io/from the above kited accounts. The undamped will woods verbal instructions as to the date And the amount of the
wire. check a Spume'. II the
uvours.ined decides to very either the date ce the amount of two wire. check or journal. the unlettered hereby 
IbuthOntal Deutsche Sank Max Brown to
accept ore vestal inStrUCWan,  from the Undencfrod regarding the ch ange or changes. The undersigned further understands
and agrees 14 oon'ply with the
procedures of Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to vitrify the authorization and accuracy of verbal untruble0011
The Antler signed iambi ecknoiMedges th at IQ the etfouretion condoned in ths form is complete end troonta to the best 
knowledge of the undersigned: and kg the
unnaisignad it rabronstaa for the method of transmission of any InSinfeliOnS issued pursuant to this autteozatat If the 
uniersurad elects to transmit any such
•flutiudoons vie  fax (askidelg drat top fad. ee emee a at en mega attachment to 'MS es a PDF. Tic or other image at  
s..ch instructions). the Jrxicrt:gnsi
understands and agrees that the Jnal scped been the risk of loss wising horn such methcd of uensmishon in the event of 
transmission errors. in:
VunCessitablings,
'moved xiliOnS. itammission by unauthorized persons. forgery or intercepts. For busts or other entities, the undersigned
fader acknowledges that the ..ndertgnen
is
J.,th,OrireC to issue the above asset movement ,-struttent under the terms of the governing documents and any applcable 
laws. The Undera anaC hereby releases
and
holds harmless Deutsche Bank Mex. Brown from and agattt lo ss from AA? action, Claim a Osmond of any person ass
Wok of DeursOfte Sant Alex. Brown's receipt of
oeinghsooe with this mehoefabon enact any insitucooes that may be ter. tv. to Deutsche Bank Max.Brown pursuant 10 this 
authorization knowing any  hanitang
authorization).
The undersigned understands that Deutsche Bank Mex. Brown may. but is not required to. seek venfic.stion of the 
undersigned's instructions by cell bad( and that
Deutsche Bank Mex. Brom may in its sole deacon refuse to execute such inStrUCtiOnsinciLiiinil standing ifigrosfions) 
green pursuant to this arnhOnfagOni without
inCurning nor "abet% if Deutsche Bank Alen Brown has reason to believe such instructions for Standing instil:dens{ have 
not been provided by to undelebned. The
undersigntd larder undumends that Deutsche Bank Ain. Brown retains the right to refuse to thew* any iftStiliebOrnr to 
transfer funds or securities to any
aCO)untiSt
giant to this OVIIS:WI Alegi V41,10(11 vaiglo erderuCtiOne bearing original sionaturelal of the undersigned
Darren Indyke 9.28.2015
Ftim Name
Signature Print Nene
Date
e
111 l iii
LOA
10-PWIt14:11775 (17/10)
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0047591
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00193775
EFTA01359553 (Jmail)
 [money] transactions by Epstein's Southern Financial LLC
(inferred date: 2015-09-28)
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition Page 9 of 12
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description Transfer fr - SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
Transfer to
01278437
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 9/9/2014
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description subcr to Kyara Investment III, LLC to fund Blockstream Investment
01251916
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 7/2/2014
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description subcr to Kyara Investment II, LLC to fund Wearality Investment
01231158
Case Record Type
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name
Date Opened
Status
Owner
Description
01229686
Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD - Banking
Southern Financial LLC
5/14/2014
Verified
Banking STP Processing
Case Record Type
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name
Date Opened
Status
Owner
Case
Customer Request
Service Issue- Banking
Southern Financial LLC
5/12/2014
Closed
Kathryn Stanfield
Margaux Mcgrath [12:21 PM]:
Hi Kathryn! Is there a way to rush wire transfer case 01229660? Client requested Fedref ASAP and I
want to ensure it goes through
Description Kathryn J Stanfield [12:22 PM]:
let me get them to approve It
Margaux Mcgrath [12:22 PM]:
Thanks so much!
01229660
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
hups://dbforcepb . my . sal esforce.com/00 I 6000000qaNVw/p?retURL=10016000000qaNVw 9/28/2015
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0047638
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00193822
EFTA01359735 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2015-09-28)
Deutsche Bank
Private Wealth Management
Authorization for Asset Movement
For Non-Retirement Accounts The undersigned hereby authorizes and erects Deutsche Bank Alex Brown CC/made Bank Net 
Brown' or TrISAIrl to follow the below asset
movement instructions
If You Mal to teckest multiple woes. checks. rciumals or free dainties. geese we the long Form
DBAB Account Nam° Southern  hilatclIMPA3
Account ir:
Wire
U.1 Vara federal funds in the new% ol $ 1.950.000.00
to flank Name Silicon Valley Bank
City I State:
ABA I.
Further credit to thteernintlery Financial Institution (Optional)
Account a
Nerve
Brataftletykdormetkre
Deafly Wm,  Velar Global Fund II LP
Account IP
Addend Intim:an Southern Malcom's y Ins
CanItal Call 5
Cheek
❑ Issue • check in the amount of S
Retnenre time
fleapwaS Meiling Mmes
Journal
J Jewel heat in the amount of $
J Journal Holdings.
OhnStrimcvScosity:
CryiS moo/Secuitty:
U Journal An Noklings
In DRAB Account t
AtO.r...01 Nene.
Roe Dehmlow
Please Mem the monies inacated below to
DICCa
Name of Recarying Fem.
Amount Name:
A hoont Number
OtyrSvinboliSucirrien
Oly4Symbolaecurth-
at Receiving Fern
Sian:rag Aishodzsdon -
U Ile ordeisgrird hereby requests that this authorization as as a 'feasting summoner% The undersigned manna and agrees 
that the authelTokon Wire
raven in effect until Deutsche Bank Alex Brown etiquette a new euthontaeon The undenagned authsotc• Deutsche Bank Aksx 
Brawn 10 Mfg the wee.
check or Jeanne! on the day of lore tempi
0 The undersigned lucent wine/Mee Deutsche Bank Net Brown to accept verbal instructions from the undersigned to wire 
funds. issue checks or }ours
funds ortrom the atom ksted accounts. The undamped will wood) verbal instructions ea to the date and the amount of the 
wire. Chid a Spume'. II the
v.-lc-t rs:pet! decides to very either the date or the amount of tho wire. check or journal. the um:Soured hereby 
ounlOnnel Deutsche Sank Alex Brown to
accept :he verbal instructs:ins from the Untlengned regefteng the change or changes. The undersigned f tatter 
understands and agrees 14 urn* with the
procedures of Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to vitrify the authorization and accuracy of verbal Mew -bend
the 4,1M, signed heath ecknoiMedges that ii) the frtfeirrefan contested in the form is complete end troonta to the best 
knowledge of the undersigned: and Si)
the
undpisigned it rusuansiNe for the method of transmission of any InelflennOnS issued pursuant to this aUM0021Mal. If the 
uniersired elects to transmit any such
•flutificoons no fax (induaing dru top fag ve sire a all en mega anenhnlent to i es a PDF. Tic or other image at s..ch 
instructions). the Jrxicrs:oncxs
understands and agrees that ths Jnal scped beers the risk of loss wising horn such rnelhecl of unreason in the event of 
uensmission errors. in: hinnecoeulings,
wiiOni9Oluff051. itammisson by unauthorized OCISton. forgery or intercepts. For trusts or other entities, the underagned
further acknowledges that the
.velertgnert is
J.,MOTI/641 to issue the above asset movement :-‘stitetons under the nets of the governing documents and any apploablit 
laws. The undeti rem hereby releases and
holds harmless Deutsche Bank Mex. &Gem from and agattt loss from Any action, Claim a dement/ of any person ass
true of Deuloblite Ben< Alex. Brown's receipt of
ogfogigoog wnh the mAhmtabon and/or any Msoommes that may be yr. tv. to Devise* Bank ANix Brown pursuant to this 
authorization knowing any minding
thrlhorizetion).
The undersigned understands that Deutsche Bank Mex. Brown may. but is not required to. seek verific.stion of the 
undersigned's instructions by cell bad( and
that
Deutsche Bank Mex. Brom may in its WO deacon refuse to execute such instructions f rich Standing inbffunhann) given 
pursuant to this eutMnzabon, meaut
Muffling nor label% if Deutsche Bank Alen Brown has reason to believe such instructions for Standing instructional have 
not been provided by the undeltigned.
The
undersigntd hatter unthamends that Deutsche Bank Ain. Brown retains the right to refuse to mean any untniebOrel to 
transfer funds or securities to any
account's)
giant to this OVIIS:WI Alegi YintlOtilVaiglo enStruCtiOne bearing original sionaturetsl of the undersigned
Darren Indyke 9.28.2015
Fenn Nano
Signature Print Name
Date
e
11i l iii
LOA
tp-liWkini77S (t2ilol
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0047851
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00194035
╔════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 ASU Origins Project [academia] Lawrence Krauss organization 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00584059 (Jmail)
 [academia] donation to Lawrence Krauss by Leon Black
(inferred date: 2015-09-30)
LEON D. BLACK
LEON BLACK FAMILY FOUNDATION, INC.
445 Park Avenue
Suite 1401
New York, New York 10022
January 22. 2015
VIA EMAIL ip
Lawrence M. Krauss, Director THE
ASU ORIGINS PROJECT
Arizona State University
College of Liberal Arts and Sciences School of
Earth and Space Exploration PO Box 87 I 404
Tempe, AZ 85287-1404
Re: $2.000.000 Irrevocable Pledge to the ASU Origins Project (this "Pledge")
DearDr.Krauss:
In consideration of the excellent work now and hereafter conducted under your supervision by the
ASU Origins Project (the "Origins Project"), and with the understanding that the Origins Project will be
relying hereon in projecting its fiscal needs, seeking other support and allocating its limited resources for
continuing such work in the future, I, on behalf of myself individually and as President of Leon Black
Family Foundation, Inc. (the "Donor"), intending to be legally bound, hereby irrevocably pledge and promise
that I and/or Leon Black Family Foundation, Inc. will pay to Arizona State University through the ASU
Foundation for a New American University (the "ASU Foundation"), for the use and benefit of the Origins
Project, the aggregate sum of Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000) as hereinafter provided. The Donor will
fulfill this Pledge with an outright gift in the amount of One Million Dollars ($1,000,000), received from
the Donor by the ASU Foundation on 24 December 2014, and with an outright gift of the remaining balance
of One Million Dollars ($1,000,000), which the Donor shall pay by not later than September 30, 2015 (the
"Final Payment Date").
The Donor may accelerate the payment of any or all of the unpaid funds required under this Pledge at
any time in the Donor's discretion so long as the cumulative total of all such payments hereunder equals
Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000) and is paid in full by the Final Payment Date. All payments under this
Pledge shall be made by wire transfer of immediately available funds to an account of the ASU Foundation,
for the sole use and benefit of the Origins Project, maintained at Wells Fargo Bank in accordance with the
following wire transfer instructions:
Name of Bank:
Bank Address:
ABA No.:
Wells Fargo Acct. Number:
Wells Fargo Acct. Name:
Wire Details
Wells Fargo Bank
100 W. Washington Street
Phoenix, AZ 85003
Arizona State University Foundation, P.O. Box 2260,
Tempe, Arizona
85280.2260
Gift to the ASU Foundation as follows:
Campus/College/Unit: Tempe/CLAS/Origins Project ASU
Account Name: Origins Pro'ect
ASU Account Number:
For Sole Use and Benefit of the Origins Project
The funds from this Pledge shall be for the use and benefit of the Origins Project and may be applied, at the
discretion of the Origins Project's Director, for any purpose consistent with the Origins Project's mission and
purposes in accordance with the ASU Foundation's Gift Administration Terms and Conditions document, which is
attached to this agreement and accessible online at nw.asufoundation.org \giflagreements. The ASU Foundation's
acceptance of any of the funds pledged hereunder shall constitute its agreement to use the amounts received under
this Pledge in accordance with this paragraph.
The Donor understands and acknowledges that the payment of all amounts required under this
Pledge shall constitute the Donor's binding obligation and shall be enforceable at law and equity, including,
without limitation, against Leon Black Family Foundation, Inc., me and my estate, heirs, executors,
administrators and personal representatives, and all of their successors and assigns (the "Bound Parties").
Should full payment of all amounts required to be paid under this Pledge not be completed during my lifetime,
it is understood that this Pledge is binding on the Bound Parties; and that my failure to include a specific
bequest in my Will for such full payment shall not release the Bound Parties from complying with my
payment obligations under this Pledge.
This Pledge shall be interpreted under the laws of the State of New York
With best wishes for your continued success,
Leon D. Black
Individually and as President of Lcon Black Family
Foundation, Inc.
The foregoing irrevocable pledge is gratefully acknowledged and accepted, and its terms are hereby
agreed to on January 2015.
The ASU Foundation on behalf of the Origins Project at ASU
Kathie Cuomo, Vice President and date Virginia E. DeSanto, CPA date
Managing Director of Development Vice President, CFO, Secretary & Treasurer
EFTA00597484 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2015-09-30)
Valar Global Fund II LP
Unaudited Financial Statements
September 30, 2015
VALAR VENTURES
Valar Global Fund H LP
Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Partners' Capital
September 30, 2015
Assets
Cash 6,694,562
Investments, at fair value (cost $26,327,017) 26,809,376
Interest receivable 8,919
Total assets $ 33,512,857
Liabilities
Contributions received in advance 5,629,000
Line of credit 8,160,000
Total liabilities 13,789,000
Partners' Capital
Contributions 20,682,510
Net operating loss (1,441,012)
Net unrealized gain 482,359
Total partners capital 19,723,857
Total liabilities and partners' capital $ 33,512,857
Valar Global Fund II LP
Statement of Operations
January 6, 2015 through September 30, 2015
Income
Interest income 8,919
Expenses
Management fees 1,165,523
Organizational expenses 147,856
Professional fees 121,826
General and administrative 14,726
Total expenses 1,449,931
Net operating loss 1 441 012)
Net change in unrealized appreciation
in fair value of investments 482,359
Net decrease in partners' capital
resulting from operations $ (958,653)
Valar Global Fund II LP
Schedule of Investments
September 30, 2015
Shares Cost Fair Value
Unrealized
Gain/(Loss)
Breather Products Inc.
Series B-2 Preferred Shares 2,947,764 $ 8.160.000 $ 8.160.000 $
Carmen, Inc.
Series Seed Preferred Shares 275,660 170,000 170,000
Eye Em Limited
Series B Preferred Shares 566,666 5,750,510 6,040,270 289,760
Granify, Inc.
Series A-3 Preferred Shares 1,215,895 3,782,163 3,782,163 -
IrisVR, Inc.
Series AA Preferred Shares 215,942 170,000 170,000 -
Lystable Industries Ltd
Convertible Note 170,000 170,000
Number26 GmbH
Preferred A Shares 5.314 4,802,996 4,969,459 166,463
Oppa, Ltd.
Convertible Notes 517,368 389,158 (128,210.00)
Trading Ticket, Inc.
Common Stock 329,662 107,780 306,190 198,410
Series Seed Preferred Stock 1,464,255 1,360,000 1,360,000
Vend Limited
Series D Preferred Shares 503,288 1.336.200 1,292,136 (44,064)
Total Investments S 26.327.017 $ 26.809,376 $ 482.359
Valar Coln! Fund H LP
Summary of Acquisitions and Dispositions
July 1.2015 through September 30. 2015
Company Date of Investment Company Headquarters Investment Type Cost Basis (USD) Current FM V (USD) Company Description
Trading Ticket. Inc. 07/10/15 New York Series Seed Shares $1.360,000 51.360.000 API for trading financial securities 
from
any partner site or app
Oppa. Ltd. 07/15/15 Sao Paulo Convertible Note 527.200 520.460 Self-branded furniture and household
goods
Vend Limited 08/12/15 Auckland Series ID Preference Shares 51.336,200 51.292,136 Cloud-based point-of-sale and inventory
management software
Canners. Inc. 08/27/15 Ncw York Series Seed Preferred Shares 534.000 534.000 Generating quality "ground truth" road
and mapping data through roaming
sensors
Breather Products Inc. 09/10/15 Montreal Series B-2 Preferred Shares $8.160,000 $8.160.000 Marketplace for on-demand 
office space
EFTA00597489 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2015-09-30)
VALAR VENTURES
Limited Partner:
Fund:
Unaudited Statement of
Changes in Partner's Capital
As of Sep 30, 2015
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
Valar Global Fund II LP
Commitment: $ 15,000,000
Paid in Capital: $ 4,350,000
Remaining: $ 10,650,000
Current
Quarter
Year to
Date
Inception to
Date
Partner's capital, beginning $ 3,590,934 $ 0 $ 0
Contributions $ 600,000 $ 4,350,000 $ 4,350,000
Net operating income/(loss)
Management fees $ (71,900) $ (245,632) $ (245,632)
Partnership expenses $ (8,594) $ (59,338) $ (59,338)
Interest income $ 1,401 $ 1,861 $ 1,861
Total net operating income/(loss) $ (79,093) $ (303,109) $ (303,109)
Distributions $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
Net realized gain/(loss) on investments $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
Net unrealized gain/(loss) on investments $ 35,688 $ 100,638 $ 100,638
Partner's capital, ending $ 4,147,529 $ 4,147,529 $ 4,147,529
EFTA00666194 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2015-09-30)
Valar Global Fund II LP
Unaudited Financial Statements
September 30, 2015
VALAR VENTURES
Valar Global Fund H LP
Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Partners' Capital
September 30, 2015
Assets
Cash 6,694,562
Investments, at fair value (cost $26,327,017) 26,809,376
Interest receivable 8,919
Total assets $ 33,512,857
Liabilities
Contributions received in advance 5,629,000
Line of credit 8,160,000
Total liabilities 13,789,000
Partners' Capital
Contributions 20,682,510
Net operating loss (1,441,012)
Net unrealized gain 482,359
Total partners capital 19,723,857
Total liabilities and partners' capital $ 33,512,857
Valar Global Fund II LP
Statement of Operations
January 6, 2015 through September 30, 2015
Income
Interest income 8,919
Expenses
Management fees 1,165,523
Organizational expenses 147,856
Professional fees 121,826
General and administrative 14,726
Total expenses 1,449,931
Net operating loss 1 441 012)
Net change in unrealized appreciation
in fair value of investments 482,359
Net decrease in partners' capital
resulting from operations $ (958,653)
Valar Global Fund II LP
Schedule of Investments
September 30, 2015
Shares Cost Fair Value
Unrealized
Gain/(Loss)
Breather Products Inc.
Series B-2 Preferred Shares 2,947,764 $ 8.160.000 $ 8.160.000 $
Carmen, Inc.
Series Seed Preferred Shares 275,660 170,000 170,000
Eye Em Limited
Series B Preferred Shares 566,666 5,750,510 6,040,270 289,760
Granify, Inc.
Series A-3 Preferred Shares 1,215,895 3,782,163 3,782,163 -
IrisVR, Inc.
Series AA Preferred Shares 215,942 170,000 170,000 -
Lystable Industries Ltd
Convertible Note 170,000 170,000
Number26 GmbH
Preferred A Shares 5.314 4,802,996 4,969,459 166,463
Oppa, Ltd.
Convertible Notes 517,368 389,158 (128,210.00)
Trading Ticket, Inc.
Common Stock 329,662 107,780 306,190 198,410
Series Seed Preferred Stock 1,464,255 1,360,000 1,360,000
Vend Limited
Series D Preferred Shares 503,288 1.336.200 1,292,136 (44,064)
Total Investments S 26.327.017 $ 26.809,376 $ 482.359
Valar Coln! Fund H LP
Summary of Acquisitions and Dispositions
July 1.2015 through September 30. 2015
Company Date of Investment Company Headquarters Investment Type Cost Basis (USD) Current FM V (USD) Company Description
Trading Ticket. Inc. 07/10/15 New York Series Seed Shares $1.360,000 51.360.000 API for trading financial securities 
from
any partner site or app
Oppa. Ltd. 07/15/15 Sao Paulo Convertible Note 527.200 520.460 Self-branded furniture and household
goods
Vend Limited 08/12/15 Auckland Series ID Preference Shares 51.336,200 51.292,136 Cloud-based point-of-sale and inventory
management software
Canners. Inc. 08/27/15 Ncw York Series Seed Preferred Shares 534.000 534.000 Generating quality "ground truth" road
and mapping data through roaming
sensors
Breather Products Inc. 09/10/15 Montreal Series B-2 Preferred Shares $8.160,000 $8.160.000 Marketplace for on-demand 
office space
EFTA00666199 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2015-09-30)
VALAR VENTURES
Limited Partner:
Fund:
Unaudited Statement of
Changes in Partner's Capital
As of Sep 30, 2015
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
Valar Global Fund II LP
Commitment: $ 15,000,000
Paid in Capital: $ 4,350,000
Remaining: $ 10,650,000
Current
Quarter
Year to
Date
Inception to
Date
Partner's capital, beginning $ 3,590,934 $ 0 $ 0
Contributions $ 600,000 $ 4,350,000 $ 4,350,000
Net operating income/(loss)
Management fees $ (71,900) $ (245,632) $ (245,632)
Partnership expenses $ (8,594) $ (59,338) $ (59,338)
Interest income $ 1,401 $ 1,861 $ 1,861
Total net operating income/(loss) $ (79,093) $ (303,109) $ (303,109)
Distributions $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
Net realized gain/(loss) on investments $ 0 $ 0 $ 0
Net unrealized gain/(loss) on investments $ 35,688 $ 100,638 $ 100,638
Partner's capital, ending $ 4,147,529 $ 4,147,529 $ 4,147,529
EFTA01285745 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank statement for Epstein's Southern Trust Company
(inferred date: 2015-09-30)
Deutsche Bank El
Deutsche Bank Must Co. Americas
345 Park Avenue - NYC20-0102
New York. NY 10154
Sol I I tERN TRUSTCOMPANY. INC.
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3
ST THOMAS
00802
UNITED STATES VI
September 1, 2015 to 8g:ember 30. 2015
Summary of Account Balance(%)
Account Account Number Balance
For personal nsistance call:
Amamb Kirby
Balance
Elite Money Market Demon 569.814.428.49
Ilegiming Balance as of September 1, 2015 571,762,637.49
Deposits and Other Credits S8.791.00
Checks Paid 50.00
:VIM and Debit Card Withdraoals 50.00
Service Charges and Other Fees 50.00
Other Debits (51.957,000.00 )
Ending Balance as of September 30. 2015
Transaction Detail
Dale Description Debit
S69.814.428.49
Credit
Beginning Balance m of tic/umber I. 2015 571,762,637.49
09.18 N Outgoing NIonc)
TOCII1BANK. AC MORGAN STAN
LED'
(7,000.00 ) 71,755,637.49
09-24 # Outgoing Money Tnisf
TO SILICON VALLEY BANK A (
9 VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
(1,950,000.00 ) 69,805,637.49
09-30 0 fewest li4 .791.00
Ending Balance as of September 30. 2015 (1.957.000.00 ) 58.791.00
69.814.428.49
569.814.428.49
All items are credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceeds in cash or by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Anicricas
44129244
oft SDNY_GM_ 00042100
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.
IN c9r.u(e)F  IDENTIAL OB-SDNY-0004924
Deutsche Bank
Deposits and Other CnxMs
Dale Description
09-30 Wisest Payment 511.791.00
Amount
Service Charges and Other Fees
Total NSF return item fees for this statement period $0.00
Total NSF mum item fees for this calendar year $0.00
Total Overdraft foes for this Amens:JP period $0.00
Total Overdraft lees fix this calendar sear $0.00
Other Debits
That Description Amount
09-IS Outgoing Nkines. Tmsf ($7.000.00
09-24 Outgoing Money Trust' (51.950.000.00 )
Interest Calculation
Annual Percentage Yield Earned
Interest Earned This Period
Interest Paid Year To Dale
0.15%
*791.00
588.030.79
All items are credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceeds in cash or by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
44129244
2 or 3 SDNY_GM_ 00042101
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. WI F N(c) IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0004925
Deutsche Bank 0
In Case of Futon or Question

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at 1-866.362-4796. or ovine to us at Lkursche Bank Trust Company Americas. 345 Park Avenue. WM Banking 
learn -
NYC20.0102. New York Na. York 10154 as soon as you can. if you think your statement or receipt is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MUST hear from you no lair than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRSTstatement on which the error or problem appeared.

• Tell us .our name and account number
- Describe the error or transfer you arc unsure about. and explain as clearly as you can why you believe it is an error 
or why you
need more information

• Tell is. the dollar amount of the suspected error
Please note that if you initially provide the above information to us via telephone. we may require that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within 10 business days.
We will investigate your complaint and will correct any error promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 
days for new
accounts) to do this. we will provisionally credit your account for the tunount you think is in error, so that you will 
have the use of the
money during the time it takes us to complete ow investigation. At the conclusion of our invatigation we will inform you
of our results.

2. Non•Electronic Funds Transfers
Contact the Bank immediately at 1466-362-4796 if your statement is incorrect or if you need more information about any 
non-electronic
funds trancastions (cheeks or deposits) on this statement. If any such error appears. sou must notify the Bonk in 
%%riling no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you. Please see sow Terms and Conditions for flintier inhumation on 
the terms
governing your account.

3. Verifying Preauthorized Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once every 60 days from the same person or 
company. you
can telephone us at 1.866.362.4796 to find out whether the deposit has been made.
SDNY_GM_ 00042102
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R gdr.o(e)
N DB-SDNY-0004926
RID ENTIAL
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Blythe Masters [crypto] created the weapon of financial destruction known as the Credit Default Swap, now a crypto bro-ette 
                                              Ripple [crypto] token issuing company run by Trump megadonor Brad Garlinghouse 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00604942 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Blockchain Capital Investor Update
(date: 2015-10-01)
BLOCKCHAIN CAPITRL
~ INVESTOR UPDATE ~
OCTOBER 2015

Performance Update
Both funds, CCP I and H, are performing well.
CCP I portfolio companies Chain, ChangeTip, and Gem have executed financings at higher
valuations than the fund's cost. These three financings, along with three others, move CCP l's NAV
to 1.4x. CCP I has 30 companies in the portfolio with no write offs or write-downs. The fund has
had two exits. Authy was acquired for stock by Twilio, which expects to file for an IPO by the end
of the year. Bex.io was acquired by FinTech Enterprises in an acqui-hire transaction.
CCP II is in the sweet spot of the Blockchain ecosystem. Several of the companies in the fund have
products and services that enable financial institutions to leverage Blockchain technology. We
continue to believe that CCP II's focus on the Blockchain's use by financial institutions is timely and
on target. We are also increasingly researching applications of Blockchain technology in industries
outside of financial services. Three of CCP II's portfolio companies will be fundraising in the next
few months, which could lead to valuations significantly above the fund's cost. We are actively
continuing to fundraise for CCP II, but will dose the fund to investors either in December or if
there is a material increase to the NAV of the fund. Since the last investor update, the fund has
made investments into itBit, Chain, Ripple, Gem, Stem and Abra.
Wall Street Discovers Blockchain Technology
In 2008, the global financial system imploded. Governments around the world, led by the US
Federal Reserve, coordinated massive and historic interventions. Numerous financial firms were
bailed out while others went bankrupt. The resulting chaos caused ripple effects on a global scale
that are still being felt to this day. Market participants, financial institutions, and academics will be
debating the causes and lessons learned from the financial crisis for many years to come.
However, to a select group of libertarian minded computer scientists and cryptographers, the lessons
were dear enough. The global financial system was too big, too leveraged, and too interconnected
to fail. The incumbent financial institutions emerged from the crisis even larger, more centralized,
and less transparent than before. They could no longer function as the trusted intermediaries and
central authorities to safeguard wealth, exchange assets, and move money around the world.
Out of the ashes of the global financial meltdown, Bitcoin was born.
The Satoshi Nakamoto (Bitcoin) white paper, published in 2008, describes a digital decentralized,
transparent, peer-to-peer payment system. Bitcoin payments are secured by complex cryptography,
not trust in counterparty's solvency or a central guaranteeing authority. With Bitcoin, the
Blockchain is the counterparty, and payment participants don't necessarily have to know or trust
each other. They also do not have to be in the same place to exchange value via physical currency.
This is a novel invention in the history of financial technology and it led to diverse and often
emotional reactions.
Libertarians rejoiced, technologists marveled, and anti-authority minded individuals applauded the
rise of Bitcoin. Banks and large financial incumbents predictably dismissed Bitcoin as a scam and
potentially dangerous. Jamie Dimon, CEO of JP Morgan, issued a string of negative comments and
dire predictions about Bitcoin's future over the course of 2013-14. US Treasury Secretary Jack Lew
warned of Bitcoin's use by criminals.
Sovereign governments and regulators scratched their heads, wondering if Bitcoin was a digital
currency, a virtual commodity, a payments system, or something new altogether. Was Bitcoin a
threat to the sovereign power's ability to issue fiat currency and enforce the law? Or was Bitcoin an
innovative, though disruptive, financial technology that would create jobs and lower the costs of
financial services to consumers? Could Bitcoin actually protect consumer privacy in an era of
constant cyber identity theft?
As the furor and confusion over Bitcoin died down, and the price of Bitcoin stabilized in 2015,
something unexpected happened: Both Silicon Valley and Wall Street saw opportunity in Bitcoin's
foundational technology, the Blockchain.
Thought leadership by Blockchain Capital and others increasingly focused on Blockchain technology
and its most salient characteristics: a robust security architecture, its transparency, and its ability to
transfer value and assets of all types beyond the Blockchain's native token and first application:
Bitcoin.
We like to say that Bitcoin and the Blockchain are inextricably linked but not limited. The
Blockchain holds the promise to facilitate the secure exchange of assets of all types: stocks, bonds,
currencies, commodities and even the tide to your car or house.
Banks have a central ledger that is opaque and private. The Blockchain is a distributed ledger that is
transparent and open for all to use. Most banks have little interest in Bitcoin, but they are beginning
to realize the power of the Blockchain and distributed ledger technology for the secure exchange of
traditional assets.
Examples of Wall Street's increasing interest in Blockchain technology are abound. Blockchain
Capital portfolio company, Chain, recently announced that it will be working with NASDAQ to
implement Blockchain technology for dynamic capitalization tables and to facilitate trading of shares
in late-stage private companies. Chain also announced a $30M financing with participation from
Blockchain Capital, Visa, Capital One, Orange, NASDAQ and Fiserv.
Another one of our portfolio companies, itBit, became the first Blockchain enabled technology
company to get a Trust charter in New York, essentially becoming a bank. ItBit also announced the
Bankchain- a private Blockchain-leveraging distributed ledger technology to trade traditional assets
like currencies and commodities. ItBit's Board of Directors includes Shelia Baer, the former
Chairman of the FDIC, Senator Bill Bradley, and Robert Herz, the former Chairman of the Federal
Accounting Standards Board.
LedgerX, another Blockchain Capital company, is an institutional trading and clearing platform that
just received temporary regulatory approval from the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission
(CFTC) to trade and dear options. LedgerX has two former Chairmen of the CFTC on their Board
of Directors.
Blythe Masters, the creator of the credit default swap, left a senior executive position at JP Morgan
to become the CEO of Digital Assets Holdings. R3CEV, a Blockchain consultancy, recently
announced that 22 banks and investment banks agreed to work together to study Blockchain
technology and distributed ledgers.
Jamie Dimon in 2015 now says to his shareholders in alarm that "Silicon Valley is coming" and
"Bitcoin is trying to eat our lunch!" JP Morgan is currently investigating Blockchain technology.
Our analysis shows that most of the innovation on Wall Street over the past 30 years has been on
the front end, like trading desks. The back office of investment banks has barely changed over that
same time period. Goldman Sachs, using algorithmic-based high frequency trading strategies, can
trade tens of millions of stock in the time it takes for a human to blink their eye. But each and every
one of those shares still take T+3 days to settle in the back office. Syndicated loans, other credit
products, and derivatives can take 20+ days to settle. The Blockchain can lower costs, speed
settlement, and free up collateral for the $300 Trillion a year of trades in non-cash assets.
Blockchain technology also holds the promise to bring transparency to the remaining opaque nooks
and crannies of Wall Street like securities lending, which enables the naked shorting of securities.
There is, of course, a great irony that banks are embracing the foundational technology that powers
Bitcoin. Bitcoin was created to enable peer-to-peer payments without traditional intermediaries like
banks. Disruptive innovations like the Blockchain can create strange bedfellows. Satoshi might not
like to see Wall Street embracing the Blockchain, but it is happening.
One thing is clear, Blockchain technology holds incredible promise to disrupt legacy industries and
create whole new markets. Wall Street and Silicon Valley have both come to realize that this
technology will not be un-invented and is here to stay. All of us at Blockchain Capital are entirely
focused on discovering tomorrow's large Blockchain-enabled technology companies while they are
small today.
Team Update
We have previously announced the appointment of Alison Davis to chair our Advisory
Board. Alison is a current director of the Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) and Firsen'. She is a
former board member of First Data, Xoom, and City National Bank. Davis was previously CFO of
Barclays Global Investors (now BlackRock), making her one of the most senior female executives
on Wall Street.
With Alison leading the charge, Blockchain Capital has now added a handful of diverse and exciting
new members to our Advisory Board:
Mary Cranston: Director of VISA, ex-CEO and Chairman of Pillsbury Withrop
Simon McNamara: CAO of RBS, ex-CIO of Standard Chartered, BNP and Deutsche Bank
Terry Schwakopf: Former EVP of the Federal Reserve Bank of SF, Banking Supervision
Michael McAdam: CFO of Union Bank (Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group)
Chris Patio= Special Advisor to the MIT Media Lab and Partner at Raptor Capital
We remain incredibly excited about the Blockchain ecosystem, and thank you for investing with us.
As always, your comments and questions are appreciated.
Sincerely,
Bart, Brad and Brock
The General Partners of Blockchain Capital
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                               Jim Pallotta [crypto] MIT Media Lab advisory board 
 Michael Milken [finance] infamous junk bond king who went to prison in the 1980s 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01088644 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Blockchain Capital pitch deck
(date: 2015-10-01)
BLOCKCHAIN CAPITAL, LLC
CCP II, LP
OCTOBER 2015
BLOCKFtl prIIN
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 95111 investor@blockchain.caoital
TECHNOLOGY THOUGHT -LEADERS ARE CONVINCED
Bill Gates:
"Bitcoin is better than currency...a technological tour de force."
Ben Bernanke
"[Virtual Currencies] may hold long-term promise, particularly if the innovations promote a faster,
more secure and more efficient payment system."
Eric Schmidt
"Bitcoin is a remarkable cryptographic achievement and the ability to create something that is
not duplicable in the digital world has enormous value."
Milton Friedman (1999)
"I think the Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing the role of government...
The one thing that's missing, but that will soon be developed, is a reliable e-cash"
Peter Thiel
"I do think Bitcoin is the first encrypted money that has the potential to do something like change
the world."
Al Gore
"I'm a big fan of Bitcoin...Regulation of money supply needs to be depoliticized"
David Marcus (former CEO PayPal)
"I really like Bitcoin. I own Bitcoins. It's a store of value, a distributed ledger. It's a great place to
put assets."
BLOCKCHRIN •-•,•/ CRI=ITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor@blockchain.capital
INCUMBENTS EMBRACING THE BLOCKCHAIN
NASDAQ
6 .6
4161
Santandc
Standard S
Chartered 10•4
RBS Me Roy,,, Rut:: 6-1!:‘,,!!,, ,, t;
111111
NYSE
NASDAQ- partnered with Chain to launch private company exchange
"As blockchain technology continues to redefine not only how the exchange sector operates, but the global
financial economy as a whole, NASDAQ aims to be at the center of this watershed development," - Robert
Greifeld, NASDAQ CEO,
Citi - launched "Citicoin" project
"Blockchain technology not only has an opportunity to transform financial services but also extend far beyond
payments to new use-cases and applications across industries," - Debby Hopkins, Chief Innovation Officer at
Citi
Santander - published: "Fintech 2.0 Paper: Rebooting Financial Services"
"Blockchain technologies could reduce banks' infrastructural costs by $15-20bn a year by 2022"
Standard Chartered
"The banking industry is starting to see the many potential benefits of its underlying technology. For banks,
the blockchain has the potential to become a technology model for a low-cost and transparent transaction
infrastructure." - Anju Patwardhan, Chief Innovation Officer
Royal Bank of Scotland - announced a $3.5 Billion technology revamp over next 3 years
"I don't know what's going to succeed. What I'm certain of is that we are going to see blockchain solutions,
peer-to-peer solutions emerging in our industry and we want to be close to that development." - Simon
McNamara, Chief Administrative Officer at RBS
Bankof America Morgan Stanley BBVA
CREDIT aUISSE *BARCLAYS
BLOCKCHRIN \-,••••:% CRIDITRL
UnionBank JPMorgan
ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255

ti. UBS
STATE STREET
BNY MELLON
\\( •1
RBC
SAN FRANCISCO. CA 94111 investor@blockchainscapital
THREE TECHNOLOGY EVOLUTIONS OF DISRUPTION
1975
The PC PC Era
Semiconductor Technology
ii& 4
:: Microsoft
The Internet Era
TCP/1P Protocol
',...;:i) BLOCK Ep plIIi=TRNLJ_
Goo* amazon
ebay facebook
The Blockchain Era
Bitcoin Protocol
ABA
it coinbase
OD ChangeTip
4 ripple 4
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor@blockchain.caoital
EXPERIENCED TEAM IN INVESTING
EXPERIENCE
RECOGNITION
BART STEPHENS BRAD STEPHENS BROCK PIERCE PAUL STEPHENS
Stephens Inv.
Mgmt.
Ivanhoe Capital

• E*Trade Group
• Princeton
Stephens Inv.
Mgmt.
• Fidelity Ventures
• CSFB
• Furman Selz
• Duke
#2 U.S. Long/Short Hedge Fund"
$500 Million AUM
2.5x Venture Fund, 11.5% IRR
Leaders in Technology
Investing
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITRL
Chairman of the
Bitcoin Foundation Robertson
Board Stephens & Co.
Founded 15x • RS Investments
Startups • Duke Endowment
• Raised > $200M UC Berkeley
• Invested in > 25x Endowment
Startups
Founded 8 crypto
currency startups
and often referred
to as the "father of
digital currency"
40 Years in Silicon
Valley Investment
Management and
Banking
Incubated and Founded
Dozens of Startups
100's of Silicon Valley
Investments
ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255
*Absolute Return Magazine 2004
SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor blockchain.capital
SUCCESSFUL TRACK RECORD OF HOME RUNS
PRIVATE
Q RelatelO
Yalu
at, a
RUPTURE
A ADDEPAR
MM.
2014 25.0x 2014 77.0x
2004 8.1x illumina 2009 39.0x
2008 6.9x 2010 4.6x
2008 5.0x aS1LON 2011 5.1x
2014 TBD  lrCSOFT 2007 3.4x
( 7 IPOs and 13 Acquisitions ) ( 17 Public Acquisitions )
Private and Public Exits through Multiple Market Cycles
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITRL
6
ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor@blockchain.caoital
BROCK PIERCE - CHAIR OF THE BITCOIN FOUNDATION
INDUSTRY LEADER AND SPOKESPERSON SERIAL ENTREPRENEUR
Money 20/20
Singularity
University
INSIDE
-o•todl
I MILKEN INSTITUTE
©IRE
CoinSummit
6The
tSar tgeek410 47
"""'"Cis4AcouAr,i
IMICICcsio
0 BLADE
CO ^co—L—
IGE (2001-2007) - Merged with ItemBay
Zam (2004-2012) - Sold to TenCent
IMI Exchange (2004 -Present)
Xfire 2.0 (2011 -Present)
Playsino (2011 -Present)
GoCoin (payment processor)
Blade Financial (Bitcoin debit card)
Coin Congress (conference)
Repeat Entrepreneur and Digital Currency Visionary
BLOCKCHRIN ••-•••!/ CPIPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor@blockchain.capital
7
PARTNERS AND ADVISORY BOARD
ALISON DAVIS*
MARY CRANSTON
TERRY SCHWAKOPF
MICHAEL MCADAM
SIMON MCNAMARA
VINNY LINGHAM
BOBBY LEE
NICCOLO DE MASI
STEVE BEAUREGARD
CHRIS PALLOTTA
MATT OCKO
WILL O'BRIEN
CHARLIE LEE
Director: Royal Bank of Scotland, XOOM, Fisery and First Data
Director: VISA, ex-CEO and Chair of Pillsbury Winthrop
EVP: Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, banking supervision
CFO: Union Bank (Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group)
CTO: RBS, ex-CIO of Standard Chartered, BNP and Deutsche Bank
CEO: Gyft (acquired by First Data)
CEO: BTC China
CEO: Glu Mobile
CEO: GoCoin
Special Advisor: MIT Media Lab, Partner: Raptor Capital
Partner: Data Collective
Co-founder: BitGo
Coinbase, Founder of Litecoin
* Chairman of the Advisory Board
Built a robust team of Advisors and LPs from the Blockchain ecosystem
1111.--1 / OLOCKCHRIN .----,/ ERPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO. CA 94 i 1 1 
investorablockchain.capital
8
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS I, LP
=I AlphaPoint b bex.io "T?tBitFury Q BitGo
114,
10 BLADE 4 /O Blockstream BTCC chain ChangeTip BLOCK YPHER
1 . 11y l
pS, ESS
*exPress'in
O CIRCLE coinbase ' 11"  Gem Go coinsetter
Alt CLedgerX
Aweem4 ....toy. xapo _Box
Mind
zao
The First Dedicated Bitcoin Venture Fund - 30 Investments, Fully Deployed
EILOCKCHRIN ERPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor.ockchain.caoital
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS II, LP
ABRA BITACCESS 0 BitGo
chcir
OitPesa
Bitnet
-114 idcoinbase 011. *expresscoin
ChangeTip coinsetter
Blockstream
ABA
kor Gern GOCOIN eilLedgerX /: .4 ripple PEERNOVA
Current portfolio - both contributed and new investments
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investorablockchain.caoital
10
PIPELINE & PROCESS
600+
Business Plans
CONSUMER

• Exchanges
• Remittance
• Digital Wallets
INFRASTRUCTURE
• Side Chains
• Blockchain Apps
• Mining
ENTERPRISE

• Multi-sig workflow
• Payment Gateways
• Financial Tools
200+
Meetings
>
• Deep Global Domain
Knowledge

• Extensive Networks
• Proprietary Deal Flow
• Primary Investigative
Due Diligence
• Exhaustive
Management/Industry
Interaction
'i• i BLOCKCHRIN .....-1 -..., CRPITRL
37 Portfolio
Companies
> • Recruiting

• Business Development
• Capital Introduction
. -
ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255
HISTORIC
VENTURE
RETURNS
SAN FRANCISCO. CA 94111 investor al blockchain.capital
ACTIVE BLOCKCHAIN VENTURE INVESTORS
Gook
ventures CC khosla ventures
Redpoint LIGHTSPEED
Nio VENTURE PARTNERS
unionA
Ribbit Capital Ty; ventures
NEA. BENCHMARK
b i g
Foundation
* FORTRESS
RADAR 0 PARTNERS ANDREESSEN
HOROWITZ
ID G b ° °St  PLOWER AY IT-RR E Ventures
• • • ••
• • • ••
FOUNDERS FUND
greylock
FJ partners.
HIGHLAND CAPI IAL PAR I NI RS
PANYERA
Combinator e )firstii.i CAPITAL
Blockchain Capital has co-invested with these leading VCs
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO. CA 94111 investor@blockchainscapital
12
CCP II - 8 CONTRIBUTED INVESTMENTS
BitGo June '14 575.000 Series A preferred
Coinsetter December '13 $50.000 Converted to Series A at 1.5x
expresscoin November '13 $25,000 Convert to Series A, $2.5m Cap
GoCoin October '13 $100.000 Converted to Series A at 4.5x
Kraken April '14 S70.000 Series A preferred
LedgerX July '14 S50.000 Series A preferred
BitAccess September '14 S25.000 Note discounted to Series A preferred
BitNet October '14 $75.000 Series A Preferred
TOTAL $470,000 (current value — $815,000...
General Partners contributed co-investments to CCP II
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor@blockchain.capital
13
CCP II - 12 NEW INVESTMENTS MADE
PeerNova September '14 $50,000 Converted to Series A preferred
BlockStream October'14 $100,000 Series A preferred
ChangeTip November '14 $250,000 Series A preferred
Bonafide November'14 $50,000 Note discounted to Series A preferred
BitPesa December '14 $100,000 Note discounted to Series A preferred
Coinbase December '14 $200,000 Series C preferred
itBit January '15 $250,000 Series B preferred
Ripple March '15 $250,000 Series A preferred
ABRA July '15 $100,000 Series A preferred
Stem August '15 $250,000 Note discounted to Series A preferred
Chain September '15 $250,000 Series C preferred
Gem September '15 $250,000 Series A preferred
$2,100,000
BLOCKCHRIN CRIDITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor(r) blockchain.capital
CCP II - STRATEGY AND MAKE-UP
FUND POSITION
ALLOCATION
INVESTMENT STRATEGY
Diversified Sector-specific
50% New CCP II investments
30% Reserves for CCP II follow-on rounds
20% Option to use CCP l's follow-on rights
Leverage our network and industry expertise to find
investments that utilize Blockchain technologies and help
these portfolio companies disrupt legacy industries.
Access to CCP's early seed deals as well as future deals
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor blockchainscapital
15
CCP II - SUMMARY OF TERMS
FUND TARGET
TERM
FEE/INCENTIVE
GP CONTRIBUTION
INVESTMENTS
STRUCTURE
BLOCKCHRIN •-•••!, CPPITRL
$10-15M
6-8 Years
2.5% / 25%
+5% Fund or +$1m
25 ($100k - $500k per deal)
4 x 25% capital calls, BTC Accepted
ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO. CA 94111 investor@blockchainscanital
16
CCP II SERVICE PROVIDERS
ADMINISTRATION / CFO
LEGAL
TAX / AUDIT
BANK
CUSTODIAN
BTC VAULT
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITRL
Kranz & Associates
Sidley Austin
Crawford Pimintel
Silicon Valley Bank
Merrill Lynch
Xapo & BitGo
ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO. CA 9 4 11 1 investor@blockchai n.capital
USE CASES FOR BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY
Financial and Records
Bitcoin Private Equities Bonds Public Equities
Shareholder Voting Remittance Crowd-funding
Spending Records Micro-payments
Trading Records Derivatives Mortgage/loan records
Digital Coupons Servicing records Micro-charity
Commodities
Public Records
Land titles Birth certificates Vehicle registries
Business license Business Incorporation/dissolution
Business Ownership records Regulatory records
Criminal records Passports Death certificates
Voter IDs Building permits Health/safety inspections
Non-profit records Court records Gun permits Voting
Legal / Health / Education
Smart Contracts Signatures/identity Degrees
Wills Genome data Trusts Licensing
Medical Records Escrows Delivery records
Arbitration Grades Patents Copyrights
Certifications Academic Credits
Commercial / Media
HR Records Supply chain mgmt Accounting records
Business transaction records Software licenses
Trademarks Spam Filters Hotel room keys
Global trade network Loyalty Points Vouchers
Domain names Betting records Movie Tickets
DRM: Music/movie/book license GPS network identity
BLOCKCHRIN ••-•-!/ ERPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor@blockchain.capital
OPPORTUNITES FOR BLOCKCHAIN ADOPTION
E .—Micro -Transactions
All Global Media Companies
Financial Settlement
Stock. Bonds, Derivatives. etc
Early -Adopt Millennials
USA, EU, AU
Remittance Hot Spots
USA. UAE -> India, Mexico, Philip.
Currency Controlled Markets
Korea, S. Africa, China, India
Unstable Markets
Africa, Venezuela, Argentina
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor(e.) blockchain.capital
19
INDUSTRY GROWTH: 2014 to 2015
Key Bitcoin Adoption Metrics
Quarterly Year Ago
June-15 March-15 Q2/Q1A Q1/Q4A June-14
Commerce
Wallets 9.345,510 8.457,207 11% 14% 5,467.263
Merchants 100,000 88,000 14% 7% 65,640
Merchants' annual revenue (Sbn) 187 187 0% 4% 30
ATMs 426 374 14% 9% 126
Unique bitcoin addresses 261,770 203,189 29% 29% 136,152
Industry
All-time VC investment ($m) $832 S687 21% 50% $252
Number of VC-backed startups 113 105 8% 15% 58
Media
Mainstream media mentions 371 458 -19% -10% 1035
Technology
Network hash rate (billion/second) 351.177,610 346.028,956 1% 11% 104,506,281
Valuation
Bitcoin market capitalization ($bn) $3.8 $3.4 11% -22% $8.0
A
-64%
3x
-53%
Data sources and notes CoinDesk, Bleckctlain Info, B tcoirREse. GMAI. Coin ATM Radar Figures are cumulatrve horn start 
of records, except auque
bitcoin adtresses and media mentions. ?Audi aro figures for the quarter ending that month Number of VC-backed startups 
and VC investment
unadjusted for ctosed comparies: Meiotic, Buttercoin. BitInstant. and TradeHit
State of Bitcoin Q2 2015 CoinDesk 7
BLOCKCHRIN ERPITRL ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO. CA 94111 investor blockchain.caGital
CASE STUDY: ChangeTip
ChangeTip enables a "tipping" feature using Bitcoin on other companies' websites. It
has built a Bitcoin micropayment platform that is currently integrated with Twitter,
GitHub, Reddit, Google+, Tumblr, and YouTube.
We believe that ChangeTip's micro transaction platform is poised to be the financial
equivalent of the "Like" button, and enabling new mechanisms for premium online
constant to be monetized.
Social Accounts by Date
ChangeTip
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITRL
NW '14 Apr 14 Adler, '14 ...Ln '14 Ju 14 Aug 14 Sip 10 OA '14 Na: '14
Acco,t,
ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor@blockchain.capital
HYPER -GROWTH- 2013 to 2015
Github repository references Number of daily bitcoin transactions
0 Q. • . • 2
11.011 Mir .10
•
: •
Jan
Forecast for Total Bttcoin Wallets by End of 2015
Maintained at 12 million
• act" , "..iet) AIM 04.$3 JesI41 Fiala Ai.« OSAI ~If .W.IS LAS Oct SS »a- 14
beat Fandt
Dootosotil Wcolba Iowa maim e atrneerre krew Me  low
*MI Soluisi
Nib) BLOCKCHRIN ERPITRL
' L0 000 1.
140 0)0
170.0001.
00.000
eo 000 t•
00.0001.
10 0001.
70.0001.
0
140,000 Bitcoin-Accepting Merchants
Forecast by End of 2015
8,0003
140 000
120.000
00 -
it' TIMMS
80000
60000 • -
40.034:0 . •-•
20000 4-
0
i ts et  .1 +  Oft  1 4. 013  \bit  / 5
Told I ~art. noon. Fool< 0~0 ~Chet
dr°
son. ado no ow oink non Ind ~see :adios MI try 0noo w wean
~es. c•••••••••• • MOW OP Sall. PI MOP Mip •.•
or Nei NY naniaseo ~ABM sow Bra ~MS
ONE FERRY BUILDING. SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO. CA 94 1 1 1 investor@blockchain.capital

╭─────────────────────────────────── Page 22, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────╮
│ HYPER-GROWTH- 2013 to 2015                                                              │
│                                                                                         │
│ Github repository references Number of daily bitcoin transactions                       │
│ 0 ,. ——_ 220000»                                                                        │
│ 200001                                                                                  │
│ = 180,000 tx                                                                            │
│ somo                                                                                    │
│ ~ 140.0000                                                                              │
│ - 70000 j                                                                               │
│ so00%0%                                                                                 │
│ swe + Pw eaan0%                                                                         │
│ tase                                                                                    │
│ 1000 a 09201                                                                            │
│ ——— 900%                                                                                │
│ Ot °                                                                                    │
│ baatead - =e we aon Nort amie std Aug Marne Oe ors                                      │
│                                                                                         │
│ Forecast for Total Bitcoin Wallets by End of 2015                                       │
│                                                                                         │
│ ,000 Bitcoin-Accepting Merchants                                                        │
│ Maintained at 12 million                                                                │
│                                                                                         │
│ Forecast by End of 2015                                                                 │
│                                                                                         │
│ — a -09605                                                                              │
│ 190.000 ~                                                                               │
│                                                                                         │
│ 7 20000                                                                                 │
│                                                                                         │
│ 2 BLOCKCHAIN                                                                            │
│ CAPITAL                                                                                 │
│                                                                                         │
│ Qe                                                                                      │
│ Mins ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 _investor@blockchain.capital │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

SUMMARY
EILOCKCHRIN CRPITRL
FIRST DEDICATED BITCOIN VENTURE FUND
UNPARALLELED ACCESS TO DEAL -FLOW
PROVEN TRACK RECORDS
Building the Future Leaders in the Blockchain Economy
BLOCKCHRIN CRPITEL ONE FERRY BUILDING, SUITE 255 SAN FRANCISCO, CA 94111 investor blockchain.capital
23
╔════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Gratitude America [epstein] Epstein financial trust 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00587879 (Jmail)
 [money] letter from Darren Indyke to BV70 LLC extremely dodgy charitable donation to Epstein associated co. Gratitude
(inferred date: 2015-10-14)
GRATITUDE AMERICA, LTD.
9100 Port of Sale Mall, Suite 15

St. Thomas, USVI 00802
November 24, 2015
BV70 LLC
445 Park Avenue, Suite 1401
New York, NY 10022
Re: Charitable Contribution
Dear Sirs:
Thank you for your charitable contribution on October 14, 2015 in the amount of
$10,000,000 to Gratitude America, Ltd. Gratitude America, Ltd. is a 501(c)(3)
nonprofit organization. A copy of the tax-exempt status recognition letter issued by
the Internal Revenue Service on September 27, 2012 is enclosed for your records.
Your contribution will be tax-deductible to the extent allowed by law. No goods or
services were provided in exchange for your generous contribution. Gratitude
America, Ltd. is sincerely grateful for your support of its charitable activities.
Sincerely,
Darren K Indyke
Secretary
Attachment
EFTA01158019 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2015-10-29)
VALAR VLNYURIU
Valor Global Fund II LP Capital Call
March 27. 2015
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund II LP (the Fund)
capital from you in the amount of $2,700.000.00 which represents 18% of
of $15.000.000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Friday April
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 25% of your total
remaining 75% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of April 10. 2015:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$15,000,000.00
$3,750.000.00
$11,250,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Friday April 10, 2015
$2.700.000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
121140399
Valor Global Fund II LP
. The Fund is calling
your total commitment
10, 2015.
commitment with a
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
•
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
+1 (646) 559-0458
Valor Venlures Management LLC 915 Broadway Suite 1101 New York. New York 10010 www.valar.com
╔════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Mark Wetjen [democrat] CFTC acting chairman under Obama, crypto bro 
                 Jim Newsome [republican] CFTC chairman under Reagan 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01734786 (Jmail)
 [crypto] LedgerX Series B pitch deck
(inferred date: 2015-10-29)
I5ILedgerX
Series B
Confidential

╭─── Page 1, Image 1 ────╮
│ Confidential           │
│                        │
│ © October 2015 LedgerX │
╰────────────────────────╯

Bitcoin's Needs: Regulation and Volatility Management
Bitcoin is a fundamentally new asset class that requires no middlemen or third -party
to process transactions.

• Bitcoin peer-to-peer network: New universal settlement layer and global open-
access financial network

• Bitcoin currency: A more efficient collateral asset
Wall Street banks are scrambling to get into Bitcoin and the blockchain. But they need
regulation and a way to manage volatility.
LedgerX's regulated options exchange will let institutions manage volatility. Our
clearinghouse has built a bridge between Bitcoin and the traditional financial system,
and regulatory approval will activate this bridge.
© October 2015 LedgerX Confidential 2
EFrA_R1_00013227
The Future of Money
Old Money
MO: Cash in circulation
M1-M2-M3: Commercial bank money
lent via traditional ledgers
S
Financial institutions manage cash
volatility risk via CFTC-regulated FX
trading
:CME Group
ice
© October 2015 LedgerX
New Money
MO: Bitcoin blockchain as a
settlement layer
M1-M2-M3: Commercial bank
obligations on top of the blockchain
(via sidechains, smart contracts, etc)
Financial institutions manage bitcoin
volatility risk by trading on LedgerX's
CFTC-regulated options exchange
iffilLedgerX
Confidential
cdi
[sr .'
di.
KS lie
"R3Cev [...] convened the April meeting at
Bank of America, which was attended by
more than 75 people from 15 financial
institutions" — NYT article on blockchain
tech
U.S. COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION
3
Professional Investors and Speculators Want Bitcoin
GOMM
Sachs Morgan'Stanley
OJPMorganChase
TIGER 0 II DOR
SOROS Soros Fund Managemen.
© October 2015 LedgerX
"We see investing and trading bitcoin as one of the first major applications of crypto currency..." — Wedbush Equity 
Research
•
•
•
•
•
Investment
Banks
Bitcoin-specific
Prop Traders
Macro-Funds
Multi -strategy
Hedge Funds
Family Offices
•
•
•
•
•
Buying Ability
Shorting
Ability
Liquidity
Market-
Making
Arbitrage
•
•
•
No Oversight
Unexperienced
Professionals
Complex Banking
Arrangements
•
•
•
•
•
•
U.S. Federal
Regulation
U.S. Banking
Trusted Clearing
Safe Collateral
Storage
Easy API Access
Experienced
Governance
Confidential 4
EF1A_R1_00013229
Hedgers Need Bitcoin Options
Consumers
Merchants
Expedia d:S11 overstock.com
Merchants convert BTC to fiat
© October 2015 LedgerX
Consumer Businesses
CIRCLE coinbase
Payment Processors
Confidential
bitpay Bitnet
LedgerX Approach
Fiat Institutions
tir BNY MELLON
CEMI , K1BRIDGE
Sorot Fund Mortage.mil
October 2015 Ledger%
Federal Regulator
(CFTC)
Confidential
bitpay
Bitcoin Companies
O CIRCLE
Genesis
coinbase
Tei BitFury
Existing "Options"
Mostly inferior products like binary options, cash-settled forwards, or other less-efficient hedges.
Coinut X X X X Singapore
Bitstamp X X X X Slovenia
Bitfinex X X X X Hong Kong
Over-the-
counter
options
X X X New York
CME X Chicago
Tera X X X New York
LedgerX New York
© October 2015 LedgerX Confide , tial 7
EFrA_R1_00013232

╭────────── Page 7, Image 1 ──────────╮
│ © October 2015 LedgerX Confidential │
╰─────────────────────────────────────╯

LedgerX: The Trusted Solution
U.S. Based
U.S. Banked
U.S. Regulated
Experienced Operators
Derivatives Trading
Bitcoin Specialization
© October 2015 LedgerX Co ntidertial
EFrA_R1_00013233
Milestones
Series A
Jan 2014 May 2014
Formal Application Submissions:
Swap Execution Facility" )
Derivatives Clearing Ore
LedgerX Exchange Approved.
CFTC Asserts Jurisdiction
Sep 2014 Sep 2015
— CFTC Enforcement Action against Derivabit, Sep 17, 2015

(1) A Swap Execution Facility ("SEF") is a derivatives trading platform designation under the CFTC. A SEF license 
enables a company to list for trading swaps
and options on currencies and / or commodities.

(2) A Derivatives Clearing Organization ("DCO") is a clearing designation under the CFTC. A DCO license is the only 
regulated way that a company may hold
customer funds and collateral in order to effect
settlement and delivery for derivatives on currencies and / or commodities.
© October 2015 LedgerX Confidential 9
EFrA_R1_00013234
Highly Experienced Team
41
)
Mark Wetjen
DTCC
Fmr. CFTC Acting
Chairman
Jim Newsome
Fmr. CFTC Chairman
NYMEX CEO
CME Board Member
— Tom Lewis
Ameritrade CEO
Green Exchange CEO
© October 2015 LedgerX
Paul Chou, CEO
Juthica Chou, President
& Chief Risk Officer
Zach Dexter, CTO
Shabana Paul, CFO &
COO
Kari Larsen, General
Counsel & Chief
Regulatory Officer
Maria Minguez, Chief
Compliance Officer
Confidential
S
G0ldnlii
s V
Sachs
fioldman buns
Combinator
VL XIA
CREDIT
LOCAL
r.
Series A Lead
L VENTURE PARTNERS
Seed Investors
SVAngel
ventures
10
EFrA_R1_00013235
The Real Margins are in Derivatives Clearing
The biggest clearinghouses in the world are in derivatives
• CM E
Mkt Cap: $31B
2014 Rev: $3.1B
2Q15 Net Revenue Mix
U.S. Cash
Equities
Global
Derivatives
Listings
Data Services
Other
ICE 2Q15 Revenue Mix*
Mkt Cap: $25B
2014 Rev: $3.1B
`ICE acquired NYSE in 2012 for $118, yet NYSE trading revenue (Cash/ Spot Trading) is still only 11% of ICE's total 
transaction revenue. The remaining 89% is
from derivatives.
O October 2015 Ledger)( Confidential 11
EFT=LR1_00C1.3236
Derivatives: Finance's Rocket Fuel
Co-Evolution of Spot and Derivatives Markets: A Case Study
O
To
O O
z
300,000
250,000
200,000
150,000
100,000
50,000
0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Equity Volume Equity Derivatives Volume
Source: World Federation of Exchanges (October 2015)
© October 2015 LedgerX Confidential 2
EFrA_R1_00013237
Bitcoin Volume Projections
Monthly Notional ($ millions)
500
450
400
350
300
250
200
150
100
50
0
© October 2015 LedgerX
Jan-16 Mar -16 Jun-16
Spot Derivatives
Confidential
Dec-16 Dec-17
13
EFrA_R1_00013238
Fundraising
History
Seed: Early 2014
Series A: Mid 2014
Total Raised: —$6M
Current Status Raising Series B. Targeting $5M lead check: $30M pre-money, up to $40M post-
money
Use of Funds
($10M Total)
$4M $2M $2M $2M
Federally-Regulated Liquidity Cash Flow Retail
Clearinghouse Provider Positive License
© October 2015 LedgerX Conticiertial 14
EFrA_R1_00013239
Disclaimers
The information contained herein is confidential and proprietary information of NYBX Inc. ("LedgerX" or the "Company"). 
By
accepting such information, each recipient agrees that it will, and will cause its directors, officers, employees and 
representatives to,
use such information only to evaluate LedgerX's information and not for any other purpose and will not divulge any such 
information
to any other party. Any reproduction of such information, in whole or in part, is prohibited unless permitted in writing
by an
authorized representative of LedgerX. Circulation must be restricted accordingly.
This presentation contains forward -looking statements that are subject to risks and uncertainties, which could cause 
actual results to
differ materially from those anticipated. The results or developments anticipated by management may not be realized or 
even if
realized, may not have the expected consequences to, or effects on, LedgerX or the Company's business prospects, 
financial
condition or results of operations. Readers are cautioned not to place undue reliance on these forward -looking 
statements in making
any investment decision.
The information within this presentation has been compiled by LedgerX for general purposes only. LedgerX assumes no 
responsibility
for any errors or omissions. Additionally, the above information is provided for explanation purposes only, and should 
not be
considered investment advice or the results of actual market experience. This communication is not a recommendation to 
buy, sell or
retain any specific investment.
Derivatives and bitcoin trading  is not suitable for all investors and involves the risk of loss. LedgerX  products and 
platforms are
subject to regulatory oversight and approval. All references to specifications herein are made subject to and are 
superseded by
official LedgerX rules. Current rules should be consulted in all cases concerning contract specifications.
LedgerX"" is a trademark of NYBX Inc. All other trademarks are held by their respective owners.
© October 2015 LedgerX Confidential 15
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                           Freedom Air Petroleum, LLC [epstein] Epstein company 
 Carbyne [israel] FKA "Reporty", Israeli co. invested in by Epstein, Ehud Barak, and Nicole Junkermann [forbes] 
            Paul Morris [bank] Epstein's primary private banker first at JP Morgan then Deutsche Bank [fortune] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01118275 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2015-10-31)
Valuation Report
10/31/2015
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - OCTOBER 31, 2015
9/30/15 10/31/15 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 160,923,083 176,705,130 15,782,047
Fixed Income 70,197,926 66,169,593 (4,028,333)
Equities 44,889,217 48,766,255 3,877,038
Equity ETF's 2,919,600 3,197,400 277,800
FX - Options & Derivatives 514,684 940,579 425,895
Hedge Funds 59,590,821 63,809,984 4,219,163
Investments 35,112,996 36,362,996 1,250,000
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 15,600,000 15,600,000 -
Loans Receivable 3,832,446 3,888,446 56,000
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 9 900 000 9 900 000 0
Total Assets 403,480,773 425,340,383 21,859,610
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
Leon to STC 10,000,000
Leon to Gratitude America 10,000,000
Redemption of Petroles De Venezuela 5% - SFL 2,500,000
Redemption of Petroles De Venezuela 5% - STC 2,000,000
TVVTR settlement - Oct 30 2015 606,081
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per SFL stmt 414,018
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per Haze Trust stmt 201,060
Mark Lloyd loan repayment 60,000
Paul Morris retainer (50,000)
Purchase of 2016 Chevrolet Suburban (74,104)
Miscellaneous (75,008)
Nina Loan (100,000)
Monthly Spending (1,200,000)
Jawbone additional investment (1,250,000)
Kellerhals Escrow - Great St James Deposit (3,000,000)
Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP (4,250,000)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50,000 15,782,047
Deutsche First Wells Morgan TD
aro ls
Cash
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Stanley Amerande
82,547,656 Southern Trust Company Inc. 82,382.271 164,706 679
Haze Trust 47,373.333 47,373,333
Southern Financial LLC 29,251.848 51,584 29,303,232
Gratitude America, Ltd. 10,002,988 346 10,003,334
JEE 2,045,356 568,658 2.614,014
Enhanced Education 1,694.489 36,081 1.730,570
LSJELLC 90.118 382.788 199,985 672.891
Financial Strategy Group LLC 485,846 485,848
NES LLC 410,647 410,647
Jeepers Inc. 297,786 222 298,008
Zorro Development Corp 174.781 92,134 266,915
Laurel Inc. 171,789 171,789
Hyperion Air LLC 164.790 164,790
Neptune LLC 159.270 159,270
JEGE LLC 122,201 122,201
JEGE Inc. 99,120 99,120
Cypress Inc. 90,169 90,169
FT Real Estate 61,797 61,797
Nautilus Inc. 40,347 40,347
JEE - Paris (US $) 39,580 39,580
Thomas World Air LLC 26,925 26,925
Freedom Air Petroleum 23,442 23,442
Ma le Inc. 19,486 19,486
Michelks Transportation Co LLC 14,410 14.410
Plan 0 LLC 10,100 10,100
LSJ LLC 5,150 5,150
IGO Company LLC 990 990
FSF LLC 493 493
The JEE Life Ins Trust #3 206 206
Mort Inn 3 3
Butterfly Trust 0 0
Total Cash 174,279,107 Z093,644 39,580 292,119 679 51,584 176,705,130
Purchase Quantity 9/30115 10431(15 Unrealized
Asset Description Dab Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Trust - Fixed Income
Bank of America 8.125% Pfd 12/29/2049 05/10/11 3.000000 3.389.821 3 226 406 3 236,416
3,111,000
-153,205
JP Morgan CFINTOT.§5115kriara:049 05/10/11 3,00000 — 3. 15.000 -120,M
48,076 (payment Inc 1025% 5/15/2018 10/02/12 500,000 libillil 9.312 494,219 517,382
JPM Tr Flt Rate-IncomeFir( 01/22/13 223,443.678 2.250, 6 JoortFC2100,371 -150,197
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14
10119/14
49,033.00
156,967.00
1,180.739
3,670:435 3,780,588
1,221,412 1,230,233
3,767)47
49,494
917,317 Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8%
Citibank Preferred Sat K 6.875% 2/3S12224) 0.00 1.999A19 2.106.930 3.3Z21§2 il tall
Total Haze Trust- Fixed Income 16,298,048 16,121371 16,164,801 -133,239
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income
fray Financlal 8.6% Pfd Ser A 6/11/13 57.000 1 429,418 1 478 010 1 464 900 35,483
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP callable 6/20/2019 4/15/14 2 000 000 3,439,193 3,034,330 3,190,573 -248,620
Petioles De Venezuela 5% 10/28/15 9/17/13 2.000,000 _2=222 - 9
Total Southern Trust Co. -Mad Income 4,868.611 6,53%582 4,655,473 -213,1341
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income Morgan Stanley)
40,000 1,000.000 toorn,4o6 cremes Schwa 6.0% Prelatical $25 par 7/27/15
Goldman Sachs 5.376% Fixed to 5-10-2020 then 392.2 over 3 mo lbo 6/4/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 5,001,605 5 174693 140,347
Capital One 5.5.5% Fled to 9-1-2020 then 380 over 3 mo Ilbor 5/14/15 3.000,000 1009.81.9 3.0 5 400 3.08 056 77
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income gingen Stanley) 9,044,165 9,033,805 9,298,119 253,9115
Jewers - Fixed income
JPM Trust FIT RT Income ca 02/13/13 107,383.160 1.682.951 1,573,735 1,573,402 -109,549
Total Jeepers - Fixed Income 102,951 1,573,735 1,573,402 -109,549
i'ilhern Financial LLC - Fixed income
Bank of America 8.125% Pfd Dec 29 2049 1/10/11 2,000.000 2,055,000 2,150,938 2,082,680 27,680
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 413/13 300.000 300.000 332,354 327,231
3,031201
27,231
33,285 Citigroup Inc - erincariN 8/6/15 3,000.000 3,000,006 2,982,550
Earthlink Inc 8.875WINFIg 2019 10/22/12 148,000 149.924 155,239 158,720 6798
28,474 Earthlink Inc 8.875% May 15 2019 10/23/12 600.000 615,580 637,969 644,054
Frontier Communkalions 8.5% 4/15/2020 74/15 3,000.000 3.101-.600 3,034.375 3,101,333 -60,287
General Electric Cap Corp 7.125% Dec 15 2049 6/27/12 2.000 000 2090 012 2,351,563 2,403 833 313,821
JP Morgan Chase 6 Co FM 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2, ,00 00 2707 2,679.167 2.597n
JP Morgan Chase & Co PE.9% AO 30 2049 6/15/11
5/21113
2,_500.000 2,675,000 2,679,167 2,597,500 -n 500
LBG Capital 12/29/49 3 Offboo 3,237,600 3,524,362 3,421,684 174,184
Lloyds Bank 9.875% 12/16/2021 5/10/12 1.500,000 1,604,647 1,749,529 1,757,808 153 160
Petroles De Venezuela 5% 10/26/2015 9/16/13 2.500,000 2,53T.-628 - 0
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dee 31 2049 1/30/12 3,000.000 2,994623 3,368,229 3,384,375
1,197,620
369,552
294,40 Pf—TMy Financial -Caiiiiile 2/3/12 46,600 90318 1,208.338
Ally Financial Pfd Set A Callable 2/9/12 W 000 1,610,000 2,074,400 2,056,000 446,000
GMAC Cap TR I GTD Pfd Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80.000 1,882,774 2,042.400 2,066,400 183626
Royal Bank Scotland Group PLC 7.25% Ser T 10/24/12 40,000 951600 1,009,200 1,0197200 67,800
Royal Bank Scotland Group PLC 7.25% Ser I- 1/7/13 40.000 995,200 1,009,200 1,019,200 24,000
Royal Bank Scotland Group PLC 7.25% Seri 1/14/13 40,000 977.5 1 009 200 1 019 20Q 41.600
Total Southern Financial LLC- Fixed Income 31,901,964 36,332,207 33,885,821 1,963,848
Southern Pinang's! LLC - Fixed Moor; (asset backed securities) ("snoops
e AnMja347 asMungtoriritual Mtg 2 el CBI var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 695.959 _ 592.131 51606
TiWut ln-emfiThinneome (asset backed-securities) 532,523 593,247 592,131 59,608
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 64,328,281 70,197,926 66,169,583 1,841,312
Note:
a) Accrued interest has been Included in month end fixed Income values
6) All assets are held at DB with exception of trc account at Morgan Staniar
Purchase Quantity 9130/15 10/31M6 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities
Morn Inc. 6/10/15 5.000 142,525 133,700 -1W516
Alibaba Gros 6/10/16 6,000 444 749 294.850 419,150 -25 599
Allianz SE ADR 5.0430 9 7&73 88,015 -2,041
Apple Inc 14,000 1,058.121 1,544,200 1,973,000 614,880
Apple Inc 21,200 shares were moved to mar in accoun 9/ 150,000 14.842.506 16,545,00}) 17,925,000 3,082,494
&bolo Global na nt 3/31/11 283,157 4,999,983 4,521037 4,807,878 -192,105
Mad Pharmaceu Inc 2/14/12 7,535 114,597 if4r)  4' 51,539 -63.058
Mad Pharmaceuticals Inc 1/24/13 9,000 176,400 52,560 61,560 -114,840
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Bam 1.3.11) 1/16/01 70.500 1,500,000 980,655 939,060 -560,940
Avalanche Biolechnologres 4120116 10.000 398.60d 82,400 84.300 -314.306
BASF ADR 4113/15 5 000 508.056 381.310 411,650 -96 406
Bank of New York Mellon 8/25114' 250.000 9.070.406 9,87,500 10,412,600 1,336,094
Slogan Ides Inc 2/14/12 2.095
5;530
250,455 611,342 608,618 35561163 Dish Network Coop 8110115 364.978 291,700 314,860 -so.128
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17,500 665.000 1,573.250
919.364
1,784,475
1.117,189
1,119,476.
-141,648 Foundation MedicineTac 1/16/14 49,830 1,265.037
General Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3,585,947 2,927 701 3,404,598 -181 350
General Electric Co 4/.13/13 23.000 496.109 maw 665,160 iso.vsi Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 5000 396,407 490,950 540,650 
144,243
Gilead Scenes Inc Trill MOO 246,791 304.389 335,203 88.406
Glaxo Smith Kline PLC 6/10/15 5 000 215,006 192 250 215,300 294
Global Partner AcquisiThr eintorp 7n6 20.000 1480 20,160 160
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/15 700 14.000 17,647 19,238 5,238
Health Net Inc 9/8/14 25,000 1,174.506 1,505,500 1,606.500 431,994
Mol:ii i W Amstelveen OM Share* 8/1/14 800 20,000 36.384 36,416 16 416
Regan* Inc (Morgan Stanley) 9/16/15 2.000 44.060 - 0
Sangarno Biosciences Inc 5/28/13 50.000 422,214 282.000 352,500 -69,714
-5,990 Santander Consumer USA 1/26114 1.000 24.000 20,420 18,010
Terrafonn Global 7/31/15 400 6.000 2.684 3,052 -2,948
Twitter Inc 11/7/13 1,500 39,000 40410 42,690 3,690
Viacom Inc 8/10/15 5,000 338,745 215.76b 246,550 -92,195
Volkswagen AG 4/13/15 5 000 254,306 117 150 139,295 -115,011
Wisdomtree Investments Inc /3/n30 4 1 45 7_09
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities 43,586,350 44,889,217 48,766,255 5,199,905
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ElF's
Wisdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60,000 2,966,099 2,919,600 3,197,400 231,301
Total Southern Financial LW - Equity ETPS 2,966,099 2,919,600 3,197,400 231 M1
unrealized
Southern Financial LLC - FX Options & DanVatIves gain /
725,105 BraW2t3b r eip Y2b20 1/13/15 10,000,000 491,941 1 393.791- 11217,646
Euro Sold call 1.1565 and bought put 1.05 exp1/4/2016 7/2115 25 000 000
—Ritt10 -6
0 -95,509 29,191
49,184
X191
49,184 Euro Sold call 1.114 ty7d ht put 1.04 exp 174/2016 7/2/15 0 -155.325
TWTR Call Sold at Initial Sinks 38.9982 Exp 1/27/2018 1/27/16 3.896,620 100,000 notonal -674,767 -389,983 -389,963
Bought 1200.03%0X JP.' Sold 11.540.400.000 IMO WM 112/2016 10/30/15 'CANN MN no 0 0 0 European Ca on Dsersion Grp 
12/1612015 Mt% 11.15% Mar 2.4% 1/30/15
4,166,000 LOOS_ _46A99 - 35.142 44.656
Total Southern Financial LLC - FX Options & Derivatives 591,941 514,684 940,579 348,638
9/30115 10/31/15 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern Financial (SFLLC) 60:154 ]mm 043
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 32.010.621 36 356 653 0.30% 8.41% **kW 7mm 741
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 32.010,621 36,356,653 ,seed 7.5mm 141
•dSd 546ml/1140
Hedge Funds - Haze selde01.25mon 1041
King Street 27.580.200 27 453 331 -0.48% -1.97%
Hedge Funds - Haze 27.580,200 27,453,331
Total Hedge Funds 59,590,821 63,809,984
SFL
Mort Southern
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Jeepers
Investments SR.
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profit? 0
Kyara II (at cost) 250,000
Kyara III (at cost) -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 16,085
Kyara IV (at cost) 250,000
Neoteny 3 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (grat at cost) 11,250,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 1,000.000 sic
Adfin Solutions (at cost) 875,000
124 Parc Moceau - Palm Beach (at cost + 71,513 re taxes) 4,940,911
Coinbase sTC 3,001,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd 1,000,000
Velar Global Fund II (at cost basis) 6,300.000
FIRE
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston, NJ 3,000,000
Totals 11,250,000 7,480,000 9,691,085 3,001,000 4,940,911
Total Investments 36,362,996
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE (ins value) 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE (insurance value) 6,500,000 6,500,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE (Insurance value) 3,000,000 3,000,000
Deposit on BBJ Serial No. 29273 / YG008 2,000,000 2,000,000
Automobiles 900,000 900,000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & 2,500,000 6,500,000 3,000,000 3,600,000 15,600,000
Boats
Asset Description JEE SFL Totals
Loans Receivable
Larry Delson 100,000 100,000
Nina Keith 100,000 100,000
Mark Lloyd 116,000 116,000
Larry / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
Harlequin Dane, LLC 2,000,000 2,000,000
Coatue Ente ri es LL 1,000,000 1,000,000
325,0QQ 325,000
Total Loans Receivable 888,446 3,000,000 3,888,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques 8 Jewelry
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - Insurance value 5,400,000 5,400;000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 3,050,000 9,900,000
Jewelry
EFTA00285041 (Jmail)
 [misc] birthday book list
(date: 2015-11-15)
2015 Birthday Essay's for Jeffrey

David Gergen - Sent-Asked who else came to the Google Lunch Dec. 10th
Terje Rod Larsen-Sent-Dec. 13th says he will send in a few days
Martin Nowak- Sent-
Woody Allen- Sent to Soon Yi- Woody will think on it and get back very shortly-RECD
Joi Ito- Sent- Sound like fun/ -Said he would work on it in Nov...RECD
Lawrence Krauss-Sent-Replied he will try-RECD
Marvin Minsky- Sent- Gloria will speak to Marvin about this
Ehud- Sent- YES! It will be a best seller- RECD
Leon Black- Sent -Melanie said she will follow up with Leon on Dec. 15th
Mort Zuckerman- Sent-RECD
Arian de Rothschild- Sent- Of Course!
Caroline Lang- Sent-Dec. 11 said she will send soon!
Kathy Ruemmler- Sent- Happy to participate!-Dec. 12th said she will send soon!
Noam Chomsky- Sent to Valeria- They would be delighted!

Hello ...Karyna and I are asking a few ofJeffrey's personal friends if they could help us
out this year with a special gift for Jeffrey's birthday Clan. 20th) We are hoping you
could write a short, one page 'story' on 'Sharing A Meal in Jeffrey's Dining Room...with
Jeffrey and his friends'... We are hoping you may have some fabulous, weird or
enlightening story you could share...
We will then create a booklet of all these 'interesting stories' from all his 'interesting
friends' to present to him!
Might you be able to help in our creation!?? Hoping sot/
Thank you,
Lesley
Assistant to Jeffrey Epstein

Email follow up Sent Nov. 5, 2015:
just circling back in hopes you will be able to help Karyna and me with Jeffrey's birthday
gift of a short, one page story on sharing a meal with him in his dining room...below is
original email...we are hoping to have these stories collected by early December so we
can then bound them in a beautiful book for him....

Emailed follow up on Dec. 11, 2015
Good morning Terje...just following up to see if you might be able to provide me a little
letter to Jeffrey for his birthday ...I am collecting short stories from his good friends on
"sharing a meal with Jeffrey and his friends"....Might you have any special memory you
could share with him? Karyna and I want to create a booklet for Jeffrey of these special
letters and present to him for his birthday Jan.20th...
Would love to receive one from you as we know you are a dear friend!
Thank you,
Lesley
Assistant to Jeffrey Epstein
Emailed another Follow up on Jan. 4th...
╔═════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Anthony Trentacosta [crime] Gambino crime family 
                 Michael Bilotti [crime] murderer 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00129085 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about wiretap linking phone number in John Gotti / Gambino / Michael Bilotti investigation to phone in Epstein investigation
(inferred date: 2015-11-21)
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 05/17/2011
To: Miami
From: Miami
C-9
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafted By: S:css
Case ID #: 281A-MM-114129 (Pending)
Title:STRIP DOWN
Synopsis: To memorialize analysis of a pen register/trap and trace on
telephone number (target number) for the period of April
28, 2011 through May 16, 2011.
Details: A review of a pen register/trap and trace on telephone
number , belonging to Subject , reveals
the following (through ACS and Telephone Applications) :
Target number has been called by telephone number
seventy six (76) times and has called that number seven (7)
times. As of 12/31/2010, this number was verified as belonging to
CARLOS BELZAGUY, 670 Raven Avenue, Miami Springs, Florida, 33166. On
January 5, 2009, telephone number was captured in FBI
case #281D-NK-111938, a case on the Sureno Hispanic gangs in Atlantic
City, however, BELZAGUY was not referenced in that investigation.
Target number has been called by telephone number
sixty two (62) times and has called that number twenty nine (29)
times. The subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
thirty one (31) times and has called that number twenty one (21)
times. As of 12/31/2010, this number was verified as belonging to
ANTHONY F. JACKOWITCH, JUNIOR, 7600 West 18 Lane, Hialeah, Florida,

33014. On July 24, 2009, telephone number was captured in
FBI case #202B-MM-113683, an FCI case involving the Cuban Intelligence
service. JACKOWITCH was not referenced in that investigation.
Target number has been called by telephone number
thirty one (31) times and has called that number twenty one (21)
times. The subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
twenty four (24) times and has called that number two (2) times.
The subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
twenty three (23) times and has called that number six (6) times.
As of 12/04/2010, this number was verified as belonging to LINDA L.
MCNEW and HUGH D. MCNEW, 707 Northeast 195 Street, Miami, Florida,
33179. The subscriber is listed as FM AND SONS INTERNATIONAL
CORPORATION. This number was captured in FBI case #245 NK-63912 on
April 5, 1990.
Target number has been called by telephone number
twenty (20) times and has called that number seven (7) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
nineteen (19) times and has called that number five (5) times.
The subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
eighteen (18) times and has called that number eight (8) times.
The subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
eighteen (18) times and has called that number fourteen (14)
times. The subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
sixteen (16) times and has called that number four (4) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
fifteen (15) times and has called that number five (5) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
thirteen (13) times and has called that number one (1) time. As
of 12/04/2010, this number was verified as belonging to BARRY ROSAYN
with an address of , Fort Lauderdale, Florida,
33311 and a second address of , Boca Raton,
Florida, 33428. Between January 28, 2004 and July 23, 2004, this
number was capture in FBI case #245C-CV-65849, involving Mexican
syndicates who operate a large marijuana distribution network.
Target number has been called by telephone number
eleven (11) times and has called that number two (1) times. As of
12/04/2010, this number was verified as belonging to SEYMOUR (also
known as SY) CHADROFF, and JOYCE CHADROFF, with an address of 3000
Island Boulevard, #401, Aventura, Florida, 33160. In October of 1997,
CHADROFF was referenced in FBI case #281A-MM-87084, involving JOHN
GOTTI, JUNIOR (Acting Gambino Boss) and JOSEPH RUSSO (Colombo soldier)
wanted to purchase an adult entertainment club from an FBI Cooperating
Human Source (CHS), who was, at the time, incarcerated with RUSSO and
his brother ANDREW RUSSO (at that time, Colombo Boss. The CHS
identified the person who obtain the club's (CLUB ONE) liquor license
as LOU TERMINELLO. In July of 1999, CHADROFF approached the FBI
regarding an alleged illegal wire tap on his home telephone. CHADROFF
explained that he is an attorney who specializes in the sale and
acquisition of State of Florida liquor licenses, for license owners.
Twice in 1999, a device was found in the rear of CHADROFF's
residence, near his telephone box. MIAMI DADE POLICE DEPARTMENT was
called and took possession of the device each time. CHADROFF believes
that an individual named LOU TERMINELLO may have had a motive to
intercept CHADROFF's communications. TERMINELLO worked for CHADROFF
for approximately eight years, until CHADROFF fired TERMINELLO because
of bizarre behavior, and for beating his wife in CHADROFF's law
office. CHADROFF is further referenced in FBI case #245A-MM-51443-M1
and #92A-MM-71006-A2. Both cases relate to the Gambino La Cosa Nostra
family. CHADROFF also contacted the target number from telephone
number two (2) times, and the target number called this
number one (1) time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
eleven (11) times and has called that number three (3) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time. This number was
captured in FBI case #245A-MM-84432 on January 31, 1999. This case
involved the investigation of ANTHONY TRENTACOSTA, aka, "TONY PEP",
FREDERICK MASSARO, MICHAEL A. BILOTTI, JOHN PATRICK ROGAN, and WILLIAM
ANTHONY DANTE, all Gambino members or associates.
Target number has been called by telephone number
eleven (11) times and has called that number six (6) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
eleven (11) times and has called that number five (5) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time. Between October
29, 2004 and January 10, 2005 this number was captured in FBI case
#031E-MM-108062, and captured again between July 7, 2005 and September
28, 2005. This investigation involves a child prostitution case in
the West Palm Beach, Florida area. Captioned targets include JEFFREY
EPSTEIN and
Target number has been called by telephone number
eleven (11) times and has called that number two (2) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
nine (9) times and has called that number three (3) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number 954-303-
2310 nine (9) times and has called that number two (2) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has called telephone number eight
(8) times, however, that number has never called the target number.
The subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
eight (8) times and has called that number three (3) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number 954-600-
9880 eight (8) times, however, the target number has never called this
number. The subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number 954-771-
1212 eight (8) times and has called that number one (1) times. As of
12/31/10, this number was verified as belonging to SPERRY VAN NESS
COMMERCIAL REALTY, , Fort Lauderdale, Florida,
33309, as well as NANCY LYNN DKIDWELL, 401 Southeast 6 Terrace,
Pompano Beach, Florida, 33060. This number was captured in FBI case
#329E-MM-108155, involving a mortgage fraud investigation. SPERRY VAN
NESS was not referenced in that case.
Target number has been called by telephone number
seven (7) times, however, the target number has never called this
number. The subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
six (6) times, and has called that number s3even (7) times. As
of 12/31/10, this number was verified as belonging to ROBERT J.
OCONNOR, , Palmetto Bay, Florida, 33157.
This number was also captured on the pen register/trap and trace for
MICHAEL BILOTTI's telephone number on August 18, 2010.
OCONNOR was referenced in FBI case #281A-NY-258727 -BC, involving the
Bonnano LCN family.
Target number has been called by telephone number
seven (7) times, however, the target number has never called this
number. The subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number telephone number six (6) times,
however, this number has never called the target number. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
six (6) times and has called that number one (1) time. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
six (6) times and has called that number five (5) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
six (6) times, however, the target telephone has never called
this number. As of 12/31/2010, this number has been verified as
belonging to JOE R. RODRIGUEZ, , Fort Lauderdale,
Florida, 33312. RODRIGUEZ is the Manager of THE CHEETAH (adult
entertainment club in Pompano beach, and also in Hallandale Beach.
RODRIGUEZ has been surveilled meeting with PHILIP GORI at the
Hallandale Beach location.
Target number has been called by telephone number
five (5) times and has called that number two (2) times. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
five (5) times and has called that number one (1) time. The
subscriber for that number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
five (5)times, however, target number has never called this
number. This number was captured in FBI case #245A-SE-89343,
involving drug trafficking and money laundering in the Seattle area.
This number was also captured in FBI case #194B-SE-88803, involving a
public corruption case in Seattle. Between 07/05/2005 and 06/03/2008,
this number was verified to be a cellular telephone belonging to DAVID
EBERT, from Everett, Washington. The current subscriber has not yet
been verified.
Target number has been called by telephone number
five (5) times, however, the target number has never called this
number. The subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
four (4) times, however, the target number has never called this
number. The subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number four (4) times. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
four (4) times, and has called this number four (4) times. This
number was captured in FBI case #245A-SE-89343, involving drug
trafficking and money laundering in the Seattle area. (See telephone
number .) Between 06/06/2000 and 08/04/2004, this number
was verified as belonging to MICHAEL LAUGHLIN, with an address of
, Fort Lauderdale, Florida. The
current subscriber has not yet been verified.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number four (4) times. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
four (4) times, and has called this number four (4) times. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
four (4) times, and has called this number one (1) time The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
four (4) times, however, the target number has never called this
number. The subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
four (4) times, and has called this number two (2) times. This
number was captured in FBI case #281F-LV-39165, involving a criminal
enterprise on August 9, 2006. This number was also captured in this
case through a pen register/trap and trace on telephone number
which belongs to MICHAEL BILOTTI. These calls were captured
between 08/09/2010 and 11/05/2010. This number belongs to LEONARD E.
ZEDECK, with an address of , Sunrise,
Florida, 33351. ZEDECK, along with BURNSIDE, are listed as the
registered agent on the majority of companies belonging to BILOTTI and
JACK E. GALARDI.
Target number has been called by telephone number
four (4) times, and has called this number two (2) times. This
number was captured in FBI case #281A-MM-94770, involving Italian
organized crime, including DOMINICK IGNAZIO ALOGNA, a Gambino Captain
and JAMES AURIEMMA, an alleged Gambino Soldier. That case was closed
on July 17, 2001. This number was also captured in FBI case #281I-MO-
38239, involving a Carribean criminal enterprise, in 1998. Between
05/30/2002 and 03/31/2009, this number was verified as belonging to
ATTORNEY LAWRENCE BLACKE, with an address of
Fort Lauderdale, Florida, 33308. The current subscriber has not yet
been verified.
Target number has been called by telephone number
four (4) times, and has called this number three (3) times. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
four (4) times, and has called this number two (2) times. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has called telephone number three

(3) times, however, this number has never called the target number.
The subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has called telephone number three

(3) times, however, this number has never called the target number.
The subscriber for this number is unknown at this time. three (3)
times, however, this number has never called the target number. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number three (3) times. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has called telephone number three

(3) times, however, this number has never called the target number.
The subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has called telephone number three

(3) times, however, this number has never called the target number.
This number was captured in FBI case #245H-MM-112115, involving
Armenian organized crime. The number was captured on August 20, 2009.
The subscriber at that time was the CITY OF DANIA BEACH, however,
between 03/31/2010 AND 12/31/2010, the number was verified as
belonging to PATRICIA A. KENNEDY, with an address of
, Fort Lauderdale, Florida, 33312 the current subscriber
has not yet been verified.
Target number has called telephone number three

(3) times, however, this number has never called the target number.
The subscriber for this number appears to be the FLORIDA INSTITUTE FOR
CARDIOVASCULAR CARE located in Miramar, Florida.
Target number has called telephone number three
(3) times, however, this number has never called the target number.
The subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
three (3) times, and has called this number two (2) times. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
three (3) times, and has called this number one (1) time. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
three (3) times, and has called this number one (1) time. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by the following telephone
numbers three (3) times, however, the target number never calls these
numbers:
On August 9, 2004, telephone number
was captured in FBI case #245B-MM-99323, involving the WILLIE
DIAZ drug trafficking organization. The current subscriber has not
yet been verified.
Telephone number has been
captured in multiple FBI cases and is subscribed to by the FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE.
Telephone number has been
captured in multiple FBI cases and is subscribed to by COLDWELL BANKER
RESIDENTIAL REAL ESTATE, located in Cooper City, Florida.
Between 11/11/1995 and 01/10/1996, telephone
number was captured in FBI case #245A-MM-74504, involving
Italian organized crime. The subscriber at that time was verified to
be FORT LAUDERDALE FLORIST, located at
Fort Lauderdale, Florida, 33304. The current subscriber for this
number is unknown at this time.
On February 25, 2003, telephone number
was captured in FBI case #281A-NY-260186, involving the
LUCHESE LCN family. As of 12/04/2010, the subscriber has been
verified to be A NOSE FOR CLOTHES II, located at
Hollywood, Florida, 33021.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number one (1) time. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by the following telephone
numbers two (2) times, however, the target number never calls these
numbers:
. Telephone number has been
captured in multiple 66F files. As of 12/31/2010, the subscriber of
this number has been verified as ROGER FARRELL SENIOR, with an address
of , North Miami Beach, Florida, 33179.
Telephone number has been
captured in FBI case #245I-MM-113568, involving the LAZARO VIDAL drug
trafficking organization. The number was captured between 07/17/2010
and 09/09/2010. As of 12/31/2010, the subscriber was verified as
ROBERT E. EMMRICH JUNIOR, with an address of
, Tampa, Florida, 33647.
Telephone number has been
captured in multiple FBI cases and appears to be subscribed by the
CITY OF MIAMI.
Telephone number has been
captured in two other FBI cases, other than captioned investigation.
Between 09/02/1996 and 09/16/1996, this number was captured in FBI
case #281A-MM-77849 involving two Camorra brothers from Naples Italy
who were in the Miami area trafficking in heroin. Also, between
03/14/2008 and 09/05/2008, this number was captured in FBI case #245D-
MM-111628 involving violent gangs in the Davie area. As of
12/04/2010, this number is verified as belonging to GSE (known to case
agents to stand for GALARDI SOUTH ENTERPRISES), with an address of
, Miami, Florida, 33162.
Telephone number has been
captured in FBI case #087-NH-46813 on 07/11/2010 and between
04/03/2011 and 05/11/2011. This case involves a burglary at ELI LILI
& CO. in Connecticut where individuals stole seventy million dollars
worth of drugs from their warehouse. Two subscribers were previously
identified for this number. Between 06/30/2009 and 09/30/2009 the
subscriber was identified as PAULO MANSOUR, of 400 Alton Road, #1510,
Miami Beach, Florida, 33139. Between 09/30/2010 and 12/31/2010, the
subscriber was identified as DANIEL OLECH, of
, Miami, Florida, 33174. The current subscriber has not
yet been identified.
Telephone number has been
captured in two other FBI cases. FBI case #329A-MM-110179 is a
mortgage fraud investigation of FABIO LAURIA. FBI case #245A-MM-
113233 is an OCDETF case involving Italian organized crime. At the
time this number was captured, the subscriber was identified as HELEN
AXIOTIS.
Telephone number has been
captured in FBI case #281A-NY-296736 involving the Bonnano LCN family.
The current subscriber has not yet been identified.
The subscribers of the other numbers have not yet been
identified.
The target number has called the following numbers two (2)
times, however, these numbers never called the target number:
Telephone number
captured in a 66F case between 01/21/2008 and 03/02/2008. The
subscriber for this number has not yet been identified.
was
Telephone number has
been captured in multiple FBI cases and appears to belong to a COMCAST
CABLE office in Hollywood, Florida.
The subscribers of the other numbers
have not yet been identified.
Target number has called telephone number one
(1) time, and has been called by this number two (2) times. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number one (1) time. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number two (2) times. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time. Telephone number
was captured in FBI case #281E-BS-95229 between
01/05/2011 and 05/16/2011. This case involved Asian prostitution and
human trafficking. This number was verified as belonging to MICHAEL
CROCCO, with an address of , Vernon, New York.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number one (1) time. Between
06/23/2009 and 10/20/2001, this number was captured in FBI case #329A-
MM-110179, involving mortgage fraud. As of 12/31/2010, this number
was verified as belonging to JUSTIN S. DELANEY, with an address of III
, Boca Raton, Florida, 33432.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number one (1) time. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number one (1) time. Between
11/19/2006 and 11/25/2006, this number has been captured in FBI case
#281D-MM-108609 involving the DURRS PARK BOYS, a group of street level
drug distributors. On 07/25/2001, this number was captured in FBI case
#245B-MM-90947 involving the Cali, Columbia drug cartel. As of
12/04/2010, this number was verified as belonging to CANINE CAPERS,
located at , Plantation, Florida, 33324.
Target number has been called by telephone number
two (2) times, and has called this number one (1) time. Between
10/11/2005 and 11/09/2005, this number has been captured in FBI case
#281F-MM-106877 involving the subscriber of this number, DEAN
TRANTALIS. TRANTALIS was a city commissioner in Fort Lauderdale at
the time. It was alleged that TRANTALIS used his position to gain
sensitive information from the FORT LAUDERDALE POLICE DEPARTMENT about
a local drug trafficking organization. Between 07/24/2002 and
08/30/2002, this number has been captured in FBI case #194A-MM-99308
involving a state court judge who was allegedly accepting bribes from
local attorneys for favorable rulings in his court. As of 12/04/2010,
this number was verified as belonging to DEAN TRANTALIS, an attorney,
with an address of , Wilton Manors, Florida, 33305.
Target number has been called by telephone number
one (1) time, and has called this number one (1) time. The
subscriber for this number is unknown at this time.
Target number has been called by telephone number
one (1) time, and has called this number one (1) time. On
09/22/1999, this number was captured in FBI case #245C-SU-49678
involving individuals trafficking in methamphetamines in the Salt Lake
City area. On 02/21/2007, this number was captured in FBI case #318B-
WF-238572 involving securities fraud. As of 12/21/2010, this number
was verified as belonging to SCOTT F. COLLMAN, with an address of
, Cutler Bay, Florida, 33189.
The target number has called the following numbers one (1)
time, however, these numbers have not called the target number:
Telephone number was captured in
FBI case #281A-MM-113156 involving Italian organized crime and pill
mills in South Florida. The subscriber is DYLAN DAVIDSON, with an
address of , Hollywood, Florida, 33020.
Telephone number belongs to
MICHAEL A. BILOTTI, a main Subject of this investigation.
Telephone number belongs to
THOMAS FARESE, a made member of the Colombo LCN family. FARESE has
been a captioned Subject in many Italian organized crime cases, and is
said to be operating an adult entertainment club in Palm Beach County.
EFTA01125109 (Jmail)
 [legal] Brad Edwards & Paul G. Cassell v. Alan Dershowitz: interview with minor victim
EFTA01618339 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2015-12-07 22:39:46)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
•
1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
2015/11/15
Call me tmr pls :)
03:21:22 am
Sneaky sneaky call me back pls:)
05:01:06 pm
I
Check your email
01:09:06
Hi sneaky! Could you call me pls
12:48:01 am
2??
11:50:20 pm
2015/11/19
2015/11/21
2015/11/22
2015/11/23
Ok sneaky xo
03:54:28 pm
7:50pm
11:39:01 pm
2015/11/24
I tried to reach u
12:59:04 am
1212 5333739
Morning
05:24:07 am
1212 5333739
What time is class over
11:21:15pm
V Sell
•
Large wall painting two mirrors,dresser, study table, night table and paper-box grey
table, tall mirrored shelf, shoe shelf ( it's light and small) and about 5-6 boxes of stuff(
kitchen supplies, jewelry, books, shoes and clothes )
02:31:36 am
ine
2015/11/27
Sneaky dog, we are home. Was so dead when arrived took a 30 min nap) thank you so
much for such a nice thanksgiving family gathering <3 sorry we didn't give a good bye
kisses as we had to leave very early. love you! *4
05:25:00 pm
I know it's very hard for you now but don't worry everything will be all right. We all
always there for you and I'll never leave you no matter what happens
05:27:16 pm
2015/11/28
2015/11/29
Hi my Sneaky how r you?
06:07:08 pm
Tried to reach you. Call me xo
06:07:25 pm
2015/12/04
Thank you!!! sis
01:42:48 am

• So what is her name? E .
10:39:46 pm
2015/12/07
So who said it impossible for me to have some curves?
12:24:13 am
5 yrs works:
12:24:32 am
Never received your call back but just wanted to Check on you and say thank you for
everything you're doing for me, your such a rare generosity to all of us and sorry for
bothering you w my apt situation when you've got much more important issue to take
care of. Sorry for my selfishness I should be grateful that I don't sleep in a street and
have YOU<3
12:29:10 am
Read
EFTA00008320 (Jmail)
 [book] "Massage for Dummies (???)"
(inferred date: 2015-12-14)
"Massage for Dummies (???)"
╔════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
               Daphne Wallace [employee] LSJE accountant 
 Una Pascal [employee] Southern Trust Company accountant 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00003149 (Jmail)
 [misc] Little Saint James staff list
(approximate date: 2016-01-01)
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED> Phone / <REDACTED> Fax

Office Manager: Cecile deJongh
Head Accountant: Jeanne Brennan
LSJE Accountant: Daphne Wallace
STC Accountant: Una Pascal
IT Manager: Jennaine Ruan

STC is the Administration office for LSJE which controls Purchasing, Vendor pay-
ments, Expense tracking, Staff payroll and Contractor(s) payments.

HBRK
Attorney: Darren Indyke. Esq.
Project Manager: Richard Kahn
Estate Manager: Mark Tollison
Executive Assistant: <REDACTED>
HBRK is...
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 NYDFS [government] New York Dept. of Financial Services, America's second most important financial regulator 
                                                                        Mandiant [tech] cybersecurity company 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02725909 (Jmail)
 [crypto] memo to NYDFS of NYC Bitcoin Exchange, Balaji Srinivisan & Andrew Farkas on board
(approximate date: 2016-01-01)
NYC Bitcoin Exchange
The First NYDFS Regulated Bitcoin Exchange
EIFTA_R1_03213475
Problem
Bitcoin is innovative but exchanges have had problems

• A brief history of Bitcoin
o Bitcoin: open source technology invented in 2009
o Widely hailed as technological breakthrough
o Like the early Internet, bumpy patches and security problems
o Most prominent: Mt. Gox meltdown and funds loss
o Also potential issues around KYC, AML, compliance

• Where we are today
o Pressing need for a stable, regulated Bitcoin exchange
o NYDFS is leading the way with a regulatory framework
o Regulated exchange should have provisions for auditing of
customer balances, KYC/AML compliance, strong security
Solution
A safe, regulated Bitcoin exchange under NYDFS

• Compliance Goals
o Compliance: Provide full audit trails of every dollar and BTC
that passes through the system, along with identities of large
buyers
o Liquidity: Ensure liquidity for the Bitcoin ecosystem, and have
large enough reserve ratios to prevent Gox-like situation
o Trust: Create trust in Bitcoin ecosystem, allow institutional
investors to establish positions in digital currencies
o Reputation: Build in partnership with established/reputable
investors and venture capital firms

• Technological Goals
o Easy to use front-end comparable to large consumer websites
o Top -to-bottom emphasis on information security
Executive Team
Have built and scaled $1B+ in tech/ finance companies

• Matt Pauker (CEO)
o Founder, Voltage Security (>$40m rev)
o Author of 15+ cryptography patents; commercialized IBE
o BS Computer Science, StanfordAndrew Farkas (Board of Directors)
o CEO of Island Capital
o BA Economics, HarvardBalaji S. Srinivasan (Chairman)
o Newest General Partner at Andreessen Horowitz (1, a)
o Founder/CTO, Counsyl (-5% US births, —$1B+ val)
o BS/MS/PhD EE, MS ChemE Stanford

• Terence Spies (CTO)
o CTO of Voltage Security
o Designed SSL server/client for Microsoft Internet Explorer
o Chairs ANSI X9F1 bank cryptography committee
Technology
What technological considerations are involved?
170,121_02213402
Technical Challenges
Building a Bitcoin exchange is computer science

• Security
o Exchange will be under constant attack by hackers around the globe; both
Denial of Service and active threats (e.g., APTs)
o Bitcoin relies on advanced cryptography; getting it wrong can result in loss
of funds (see Mt. Gox)

• Ecosystem integration
o I \change is one of several core Bitcoin infrastructure services
o Must provide tight API integration with wallets, merchant processors,
miners

• Compliance
o Technology must be designed to support (often conflicting) compliance
goals
o Leverage best practices from PCI, FFIEC, NIST
Technical Challenges
Our number one concern technologically is security

• Threats
o Distributed denial of service (DDoS)
o 0-day exploits in open source software
o Spear-phishing
o Advanced persistent threats (e.g. China)
o Source code compromise
o Social engineering attacks
o Physical compromise of vaulting facility or datacenter

• Mitigation
o FireEye/Mandiant  (malware), Cloudflare (DDoS), Sift Science (fraud),
Voltage (encryption), Skipfish/Ratproxy  (headless)
o Open bids for zero days in any software utilized
o Constant penetration testing, automatic/manual (Detectify)
o Static and dynamic checking of codebase (Coverity)
Technical Challenges
Security expertise must be baked into every layer
Example: Heartbleed: Security issues are subtle
r Meg wants these 500 letters: HAZ. . ..
! ; !  HI . I:4X: .

• ?   :•  .. !•••:r:n r•qa v !! . . •••-! ••••• . . . . . • . rr•i rt. • , : • : • 47 t. •
HAT. [eras requests tho "laiso-A ccero
ctians* pogo. Eve laaninistraUx} war.
to to set server's ouster key to - 148
35038534'. Isabel wants pages about
sashes but not WO Ion' . User Karen
swats to change account Fas..,vord to
Technical Architecture
Increase security via subsystem isolation, cold storage
Accounting
System
00'
Customer
Accounts
User Mgmt Exchange Wallet
System System System
Web UI API Cold Wallet
Enrollment (KYC)
Transaction Validator Warm Wallet
Authentication
Hot Wallet
Funds Transfer Core
Engine Bitcoin Network
Interface

• Services -Oriented Architecture improves security
o Discrete, well-defined subsystems reduce risk of spillover attacks

• Full auditability for all functions
o User activity, funds, trades
• Will work closely with NYSDFS on functionality & user interface
O Ensure regulatory compliance, proper disclosures, transparency
Technical Architecture
Limit amount of "hot" Bitcoin; most in cold wallet
Seller
Wallet
Buyer
Wallet
NYBE
Inbound
Wallet
NYBE
Outbound
Wallet
NYBE
Hot
Wallet
NYBE
Cold
Wallet

• Typical transaction flow:
o Seller sends BTC into NYBE Inbound Wallet, then stored in Hot Wallet
o After trade, BTC is moved to Outbound Wallet, then Buyer Wallet
o Seller & Buyer Wallets reside at 3rd party (Coinbase, Xapo, etc.)

• Occasionally: money moved out of Hot Wallet
o Maintain minimum required amount of BTC online
Technical Architecture
Security principles for wallets, passwords, pentesting

• Bitcoin wallets
o Not a consumer wallet provider: only hold customer funds for trading
o Three -tiered wallet hierarchy
■ Hot: online, available immediately (-25%)
■ Warm: offline, available within 24 hours (-25%)
■ Cold: offline & geo-dispersed, available within 72 hours (-50%)

• Industry -standard best practices
o Least-privilege architecture
o Two-factor user authentication
o n-of-m key sharing
o Bank-level network & data security design (256-bit encryption, anti-DDoS)

• Continuous evaluation
o Regular internal security audits
o External "red teams" to identify potential vulnerabilities
Technical Architecture
We build the exchange for extensibility beyond BTC

• Exchange built to handle more digital currencies over time
o Compliance is kcy in all of this; start with liTC, generalize as we build
confidence
o Technology: simply requires additional wallet subsystems on top of
existing architecture

• Items we may trade over time
o Altcoins: Bitcoin "clones" (Litecoin, Namecoin) which primarily
change some parameters
o Appcoins: new proof-of-work systems with new functionality
(Namecoin, Ethereum, Mastercoin)
o Side-chains: support for side-chains & proof -of-burn
o Smart property: can use the blockchain to exchange software licenses,
stock certificates, digital keys to houses, etc.
o And more: Colored Coins video gives sense of what Bitcoin can enable
Exchange Economics
Two possible models for an exchange

• Model I: Pure facilitation of trades
o In this model, we bucket all buy/sell orders into (say) .1 BTC buckets
o We then match buyers and sellers in the same bucket
o Buyers and sellers exchange directly with each other and the exchange takes
a commission

• Model II: Serve as counterparty
o In this model, we are the buyer and seller of BTC traded on the exchange
o We maintain BTC and USD reserves that are sufficient to handle large
spikes in buy or sell orders
o The exchange monetizes through the size of the bid/ask spread
o Benefit: greater liquidity for exchange customers. Cost: larger reserve ratios.
Next Steps
We'd like to work with NYDFS on this.
EIFTA_R1_02213491
Next Steps
What's the next step from NYDFS's perspective?

• Areas we are seeking input
o What is the optimal corporate structure for this vehicle in NYDFS's view?
o What existing legislation/regulatory framework is NYDFS thinking about
using as a basis for this?
o How does NYDFS think about annual Bitlicense/exchange fees and the
like, if any?
o What type of ongoing supervision does NYDFS envision?
o These are the sorts of questions we'd like to figure out collaboratively;
please tell us how we can help.
EFTA01203276 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred timestamp: 2016-01-05 20:15:00)
VALAR vtrI uoit5
January 16, 2015
Sent Via E-mail
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
uarter, B3
00802
ndyke
Re: Valar Global Fund II LP - Capital Call #1
Dear Limited Partner,
Per Section 4.2(a) of the Limited Partnership Agreement of Valar Global Fund II LP
(the Fund), we are making a capital call for 1% of the Fund's commitments. The Fund has
now called 1% of total commitments:
Amount Due: $150,000
Due Date: January 30, 2015
Please wire the requested amount to the Fund's bank account at:
Bank Name: Silicon Valley Bank
Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any questions or require further
details.
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Valor Ventures Management LLC 915 Broadway Suite 1101 New York. New York 10010 www.volar.com
╔══════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Sigrid McCawley [victim lawyer] Boies Schiller Flener LLP 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00615804 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Alan Dershowitz pages 334-461 (heavily redacted)
(date: 2016-01-12)
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SEVENTEENTH JUDICIAL
CIRCUIT IN AND FOR BROWARD COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO.: CACE 15-000072
BRADLEY J. EDWARDS and PAUL G.
CASSELL,
Plaintiffs,
vs.
ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ,
Defendant.
VIDEOTAPE CONTINUED DEPOSITION OF
ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ
VOLUME 3
Pages 334 through 461
Tuesday, January 12, 2016
9:46 a.m. - 11:59 a.m.
MOM Stenographically Reported By:
Kimberly Fontalvo, RPR, CLR
Realtime Systems Administrator
www.phi sre orting.com
335 337
1 APPEARANCES: 1 I N D EX 2 2
On behalf of Plaintiffs: 3 3
SEARCY. DENNEY. SCAROLA Examination Page
4 4
5 VOLUME 3 (Pages 334 - 461)
5 6
6 7 ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ
7 8 Direct (continued) By Mr. Edwards 341
a On behalf of Defendam: 9 Certificate of Oath 459
9 COLE. SCOTT & KISSANE. P.A. Certificate of Reporter 460
10 Read and Sign Letter to Witness 461 10 Errata Sheet (forwarded upon execution) 462
11 BY: THOMAS EMERSON SCOTT. JR.. kiSQ 11
MIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIMRIIIN= 12 PLAINTIFF EXHIBITS
12 BY: STEVEN SAFRA. FS 4. (Via phcot p • 13
14 No. Page 13 --and-- 15 13 Journal Entries of Alfredo Rodriguez 379 14 SIVEDER & ROSS. UR 16 14 Excerpt -April 1.2015 
Transcript of 394
15 Alan Dershowitz at Chabad Coral
17 _
liallaillit
an _
Springs
15 Excerpt- Transcript dated January 4, 397
2015 Interview of Alan Dershowitz by 18 WILEY. REIN 19 BBC News Breakfast & BBC News
19 20 16 Composite documents 398
F-SC). 21 17 Composite documents 401
it
22 18 Composite Palm Beach Police Department 438 21 Incident Reports 22
25 25
336 338
1 APPEARANCES (Continued): 1 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Let's do some
2 2 preliminaries before we start. I'm Ed
3 On behalf of Jeffrey Epstein: 3 Pozzuoli. I'm the special master appointed by 4
4 Judge Lynch. I wanted to make sure that we
5 5
put
this on the record. The order that I'm
BY: DARREN K. INDYKE. ESQ. ( Via phone) 6 traveling under is Judge Lynch's order of
6 7 114/2016. And originally my partner. Ed
7 On behalf o 8 Curtis. was appointed special master. but
8 ' LP 9 because of health reasons. I've agreed to pitch
9 10 in and take his place with the consent of the
• ID STO. . ESQ. 11 parties. If the parties could just affirm and
10 12 confirm that so that we can proceed.
11 13 MR. EDWARDS: We agree.
12 ALSO PRESENT: 14 MR. SCOTT: We agree.
13 Edward J. Pozzuoli. Special Master 15 MS. McCAWLEY: We agree.
Sean D. Reyes. Utah Attorney General Office
Travis Gallagher. Videographer
SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Okay.
VIDEOGRAPHER: This is the 12th day of
17 18 January. 2016. and the time is approximately
18 19 9:46 a.m. This is the videotaped deposition of
19 20 Alan Dershowitz in the matter of Bradley J.
20 21 Edwards and Paul G. Cassell versus Alan 21
22 22 Dershowitz.
23 23 This deposition is being held at=
24 24
25 25 My nano is
2 (Pages 335 to 338)
www.phi sre orting.com
<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

<WHOLE PAGE REDACTED>

1 <REDACTED>
2 <REDACTED>
3 <REDACTED>
4  <REDACTED>
5  <REDACTED>
6 <REDACTED>
7 <REDACTED>
8 <REDACTED>
9 <REDACTED>
10  <REDACTED>
11 <REDACTED>
12  <REDACTED>
13  <REDACTED>
14  <REDACTED>
15  <REDACTED>
16  <REDACTED>
17  <REDACTED>
18  <REDACTED>
19  <REDACTED>
20  <REDACTED>
21  <REDACTED>
22  <REDACTED>
23  <REDACTED>
24  <REDACTED>
25  <REDACTED>
4 1 3
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. And haven't you also said earlier in your
testimony today that "I believe nothing in the
affidavit lo be true"?

A. No. I believe her name is probably true.
But no substantive statement -- that there is
nothing that she says that should ever be believed.
She's one of these people who lies so consistently.
and so repeatedly. and so transparently. and so
obviously that any lawyer who claims to be believing
her statement is acting unprofessionally.

Q. Okay.
A. And I wish I had the ability to give you
some backup to that. but I've been precluded from
doing that.

Q. µTeen did your representation of Jeffrey
Epstein begin?
MR. SCOTT: Asked and answered in the last
depo. I believe.
MR_ EDWARDS: It was asked. not answered.
A. At the time when he was first alerted to
the fact that he is -- let me amend that. Let me
amend that.
Over the years since I first met Jeffrey
Epstein. he has sought advice front me.
1 MR. INDYKE: Objection. Alan. this is
2 Darren Indyke. If you're going to discuss
3 statements that Jeffrey's made to you in
4 connection with requesting legal advice, then I
5 would instruct you not to answer.
6 MR. EDWARDS: I'm asking for the timing.
7 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: The question is
8 the time. When did your representation of
9 Mr. Epstein start?
10 A. It's not an easy question. My
11 representation in regard to this case suited when
12 he was first accused of improper conduct with one or
13 two women in Palm Beach. But previously. he had
14 sought legal advice from me on a handful of other
15 matters.
16 BY MR. EDWARDS:
17 Q. Is your recollection of the time period
18 when your representation of Mr. Epstein began with
19 respect to the criminal allegations against him in
20 Palm Beach sometime during the year of 2005?
21 A. 2005 to 2006.1just don't have a current
22 recollection. I can check it out. It's easy to
23 find out.
24 Whenever the allegations first surfaced.
25 that's when he called me.
21 (Pages 411 to 414)
www.phi sre orting.com
S
B
S
B
11 Q, ‘VO.oltliyAllvflidcmc pcut
12 for itself.
13 A. This is not evidence — let me be very
14 clear. This is a police report. I've had 50 ran
15 of experience as a criminal lawyer. and I know what
16 credibility and what weight to give police reports.
17 They are often one-sided. and they are regarded as
18 very rough material. not corroborated. And so. I
19 mean, it's obvious that the State Attorney didn't
20 credit all these reports either. based on the —
21 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Mr. Dershowitz.
22 at this point. rm going to ask you to stop.
23 Please ask a specific question about the
24 exhibit or move forward one way or another.
27 (Pages 435 to 438)
www.phi sre orting.com
1 recollection about when they were. Shc remained
2 with him apparently. according to her own account.
3 taking money for prostitution when she was over I8.
when she wasMover IS.
5 MR. SCOTT: Do you want to take a break?
6 Are you okay? We've been going for an hour and
7 a half.
8 THE WITNESS: Whichever you think.
9 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Another ten
10 minutes. I think we'll break for lunch. Are
11 you good with that?
12 MR. EDWARDS: Absolutely. Thank you.
13 BY MR. EDWARDS:
19 Q. In your statement that police reports are
15 often one-sided and you know what kind of weight to
16 give them are you saying that the other minor
17 victims who gave statements in the police report
18 were also lying?
19 MR. SCOTT: Objection. form.
20 argumentative.
21 MR. SIMPSON: Nonprivileged information.
22 BY MR. EDWARDS:
23 Q. Are you claiming privilege or are you
29 saying you really don't know?
25 MR. SIMPSON: Damn?
28 (Pages 439 to 442)
www.phi sre orting.com
443 445
1 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: To the extent — 1 communications.
2 MR. INDYKE: Can you hear me? 2 A. That would be privileged.
3 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Go ahead. make 3 BY MR. EDWARDS:
4 your objection. 4 Q. Your conversation with Ghislaine Maxwell.
5 MR. INDYKE: To the extent that that 5 somebody who you have just told me you did not
6 question requires Alan to disclose privileged 6 represent, would be a privileged communication?
7 information. attorney-client or common 7 A. It would be.
8 interest. Alan. I would instruct you not to 8 Q. In what ■?
9 answer. 9 A. It would be privileged through --
10 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: So qualify that. 10 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Counsel, how
11 BY MR. EDWARDS: 11 would that be privileged?
12 Q. Okay. Haven't you in the past said that 12 THE WITNESS: That would be privileged
13 the girls that accused Jeffrey Epstein of engaging 13 because —
14 in sexual massages with them while they n ere minors 14 MR. SIMPSON: Darren.
15 were also lying? 15 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Darren.
16 A. I don't believe I said that. What I did 16 Darren, are you there?
17 was -- in at least one instance I remember. I was 17 MR. INDYKE: Can you hear me? You guys
18 provided information about one woman. this is early 18 are cutting out. So I'm sorry. I'm trying to
19 on. who had on her web page or whatever it was at 19 listen, but it's cutting in and out. Can you
20 the time. I don't remember what the web situation 20 hear me?
21 was then. she called herself "pimp juice and she 21 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Yes. So the
22 had other terms that would affect her credibility. 22 question is — go back to the question.
23 and I brought that to the attention of the State 23 MR. SCAROLA: Could we first identify
24 Attorney. as any defense lawyer would do. 24 which privileged information is being asserted?
25 And I questioned the credibility of the 25 MR. EDWARDS: I'm going to do that.
444 446
I one or two witnesses. But we never had any 1 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Well. I want to
2 conversation about 40 witnesses. And I have no idea 2 hear the argument first. So let --
3 whether the 40 witness are lying. telling the truth 3 THE REPORTER: "Your conversation with
4 or saying something in between. I just have no 4 Ghislaine Maxwell. somebody who you have just
5 idea. I've never explored that. 5 told me you did not represent, would be a
6 Q. Okay. During the investigation, you 6 privileged communication?
7 represented Jeffrey Epstein, right? 7 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Go back up
8 A. I never represented him alone. I 8 further.
9 represented him always with a local counsel, with 9 THE REPORTER: "When the investigation in
10 Roy Black, with two -- 10 2005 was happening. did you speak with Ghalainc
11 Q. I think we're ntiscommunicating. My 11 Maxwell?"
12 question is were you one of the attorneys that 12 MR. INDYKE: That's the question? Sorry.
13 represented Jeffrey Epstein? 13 I didn't hear the question.
14 A. I was one, yes. 14 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: That is the
15 Q. Did you represent anybody else in 15 question.
16 connection with the investigation Into Jeffrey 16 MR. INDYKE: To the extent that Alan's
17 Epstein? 17 information would invade the attorney-client
18 A. Not that I can think of. 18 privilege and work product. which Jeffrey still
19 Q. It was just Jeffrey Epstein? 19 has a right to object. and common interest. I
20 A. To my knowledge. To my recollection. 20 would object to that — I would object to
21 Q. You know Ghlslaine Maxwell, don't you? 21 Alan's answering that question and instruct
22 A. I do. 22 Alan not to answer. please.
23 Q. When the investigation in 2005 was 23 MR. EDWARDS: There cannot be any
24 happening, did you speak with ( autlaine Maxwell? 24 attomey-client privilege in a communication
25 MR_ SCOTT: Don't reveal any privileged 25 between Alan Dershowitz and Ghalainc Maxwell.
29 (Pages 443 to 446)
www.phi sre orting.com
447 449
1 THE WITNESS: Yes. there can. Would you 1 that Alan knows about only because of his
2 like me to explain why? 2 representation of Jeffrey Epstein. then under
3 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I would like for 3 those circumstances, that is privileged. That
4 your lawyers to explain why. 4 should not be disclosed.
5 THE WITNESS: They may not know this fact. 5 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Let me ask a
6 but my understanding is that there was a joint 6 question. Are you suggesting that the parties
7 defense agreement, and that would therefore 7 to a joint defense agreement. that information
8 allow Jeffrey Epstein to assert the privilege 8 in and of itself is privileged?
9 in relation to Ghislaine Maxwell. That's my 9 MR. INDYKE: Under certain circumstances.
10 understanding. 10 I'm not familiar with the joint defense
11 BY MR. EDWARDS: 11 agreement back then. but it's possible. If
12 Q. (1 hislaine Maxwell was never the target of 12 they're mainly parties who are witnesses.
13 the investigation, was she? 13 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I'm going to
14 A. You're a criminal lawyer. You know that 14 reserve on this and we're going to move forward
15 you don't need to be the target of an investigation 15 because I want to err on the side of protecting
16 to need a lawyer. 16 the privilege and we can review this. Ill
17 Q. Hasn't she just recently publicly said, I 17 resent for further inquiry.
18 was never the target of an investigation? 18 BY MR. EDWARDS:
19 MR. SCOTT: Objection, argumentative -- 19 Q. Was this joint defense agreement in
20 SPECIAL MASTER POrLUOLI: At this point. 20 writing?
21 I'm going to suggest that based upon what 21 A. I have no recollection at this point.
22 Mr. Dershowitz has said. I certainly don't want 22 Q. When was the joint defense agreement
23 him invading the privilege either through a 23 entered into?
24 direct or joint defense agreement. and so at 24 A. I have no recollection. I only remember
25 this point. I will rule that he's not required 25 that there was at a point in time a joint defense
448 450
1 to answer. but I will reserve for further 1 agreement. And I would have to check. And I also
2 information. 2 don't want to -- I want to err on the side of not
3 We can go back and you can revisit this. 3 revealing privileged information. But if it wasn't
4 assuming that, you know. you have documentation 4 part of a joint defense agreement. I would be
5 or there is no such joint defense agreement. S delighted to answer the question. I would be happy
6 BY MR. EDWARDS: 6 to answer the question.
7 Q. Who were the parties to the joint defense 7 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: And we're going
8 agreement? 8 to revisit this because we may have to come
9 A. This is a long time ago. My recollection 9 back to the question.
10 is that very early on. there was a joint defense 10 MR. INDYKE: Your Honor, can I add one
11 agreement between several of the people who were of 31 consideration as well? I heard -- I don't know
12 interest to the District Attorney and to the federal 12 which attorney —
13 government. That's my recollection. And I would 13 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Speak up.
14 always want to resolve doubts in favor of privilege. 19 MR. INDYKE: I'm going to put my -- I
15 We can check further. I would be happy to answer 15 heard — I don't know which attorney made the
16 the question if it's not privileged. 16 statement -- that work product privilege can be
17 Q. Who are the people that you remember being 17 waived by the attorney even though they're the
18 part of the joint defense agreement? 18 objections of the client. I don't believe
19 A. I'm just trying to think of whether -- 19 that's accurate. &al would also object on
20 MR. SCOTT: Don't answer anything 20 those grounds as well.
21 privileged. 21 To the extent that any kind of information
22 A. I just — I would rely on Darren for that. 22 that Alan has that's asked to be disclosed is
23 MR. INDYKE: If you're asking him who are 23 covered under the work product privilege, that
24 the parties to the joint defense agreement. and 24 should also not be disclosed, and I would
25 that would disclose information about witnesses 25 object on that basis and instruct Alan not to
30 (Pages 447 to 450)
www.phi sre orting.com
451 453
1 answer as well. 1 legal issues there. too.
2 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I'm aware of the 2 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Well I would
3 argument between counsel. The question that I 3 count on the parties to make their best
4 have is as follows: Is a — was there, in 4 argument. legal or factual.
5 fact, a joint defense agreement? What form did 5 BY MR. EDWARDS:
6 it take? And is it either subject to direct 6 Q. Do you know a person named
7 privilege or to work product privilege? 7 IIIIIP 8 And so those questions in that order need 8 A. No. I know vaguely 
who she is.
9 to be answered for me. and wed have to come 9 MR. INDYKE: Objection. To the extent.
10 back and revisit those things. So I 10 Alan. that the only way you know the answer to
11 appreciate -- thank you for the distinction. 11 that question is through your representation of
12 but that's where I am on this issue. 12 Jeffrey Epstein. then I would instruct you not
13 MR. EDWARDS: Can I ask, then. just 13 to answer that question. as it violates the
14 specifically. was Ghislaine Maxwell a party to 14 privilege.
15 the joint defense agreement? 15 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: Short of that.
16 MR. SCOTT: Asked and answered. 16 the question was straightforward. But outside
17 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: That goes hack 17 of privileged information.
18 to the question whether or not -- and this is 18 A. The name is familiar. but I don't know —
19 the question I have, is whether or not a 19 I'm sure I've met her. but I don't know her.
20 particular — is it a violation of either the 20 BY MR. EDWARDS:
21 privilege or work product privilege who the 21 Q. Fair to say she was --
22 particular participants arc of a joint defense 22 A. I don't think I've had a conversation with
23 agreement. if one, in fact, existed? 23 her.
24 MR. EDWARDS: But if wee not able to 24 Q. Fair to say, then, she was not a party to
25 answer that question. then the communications 25 the joint defense agreement?
452 454
1 that he had with Ghislaine Maxwell I should be 1 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I'm going to
2 able to get into. 2 stop you. We've talked about this. I'm not
3 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: I -- well. that 3 going to let you backdoor the conversation
4 assumes that the communications — I would say 4 until we flesh that out.
5 it this. For purposes of right now, that 5 MR. EDWARDS: I understand, but if it's
6 assumes the communications somehow fall outside 6 somebody who clearly was not, meaning he
7 the privilege, either work product or 7 doesn't even know her. If she clearly was not.
8 otherwise. and/or had been waived in some ■ 8 then I want to get into those conversations.
9 so that you can make inquiry. And so -- but 9 That would be the easiest thing to do. I can
10 fm not even there yet. 10 eliminate the people that may have been a part
11 But because of the sensitivity around the 11 of that. Okay. we'll leave those alone. But
12 privilege, at this point. fm going to reserve 12 people that he doesn't even know. I want to get
13 and ask the parties to inquire further as to 13 into what that person knows.
14 the four questions that I had around the joint 14 A. Let me shortcut this. To my knowledge. I
15 defense agreement. And I don't want to impact 15 never had a conversation with this person.
16 your rights to inquire until I understand that. 16 BY MR. EDWARDS:
17 THE WITNESS: I will inquire of es-counsel 17 Q. Okay. So that is somebody in these police
18 in the Epstein case, who would probably know 18 reports, if you review them, is listed as -- is
19 the answer to that, to those series of 19 described as Jeffrey Epstein's sex slave at the
20 questions. 20 time. Are you aware of that?
21 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: It's a serious 21 A. No.
22 enough issue that I don't want to — 22 Q. Okay. Do ou ever remember the
23 MR. EDWARDS: I understand and I respect 23 allegations' being a sex slave to
24 it. 24 Jeffrey Epstein?
25 MR. SCOTT: We should also look into the 25 A. Not specifically.
31 (Pages 451 to 454)
www.phi sre orting.com
455 4 5 7
1 Q. Do you ever remember the allegations of 1 A. No. No. I don't think so. My
2 various underage girls that in 2 recollection is there were four names originally.
3 addition to Jeffrey Epstein. engaged in sexual acts 3 and then there was a request by the lawyers of the
4 with minors during the investigation? 4 four named people to eliminate their names.
5 A. I don't have any recollection of that. S MR. INDYKE: Mr. Dershowitz. if you're
6 Q. In trying to ascertain whether the 6 going to go into work product, then I would
7 witnesses who came forward against Jeffrey Epstein 7 rather you —I would instruct you not to
8 then, or coming forward against 8 disclose.
9 Jeffrey Epstein now, arc telling the truth or are 9 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: At this point.
10 lying, have you gone to to ask her 10 it's 12:00. is this a good place for you to
11 questions about the circumstances of this lawsuit? 11 break?
12 A. I don't know her. 12 MR. EDWARDS: This is fine.
13 MR. INDYKE: Objection on the basis of 13 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: 1:00?
14 common interest privilege and on the basis of 14 THE WITNESS: fm happy to do 12:30.
15 attorney-client privilege and on the basis of 15 MR. SCOTT: 1:00 is fine.
16 work product privilege. 16 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: 1:00 start back.
17 SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: He's already 17 We're on break.
18 answered he does not know her. 18 VIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the record. The
19 A. And I have also --I think I can say 19 time is 11:59 a.m.
20 this -- no. I can't. I can't. It's covered by the 20 (A lunch recess was held from 11:59 a.m. until 1:05
21 privilege. 21 p.m.. after which the proceedings continued in
22 BY MR. EDWARDS: 22 Volume 4.)
23 Q. Was considered a 23
24 coconspirator of Jeffrey Epstein's during the 24
25 criminal investigation? 25
456 458

A. There are two criminal —
MR. INDYKE: Same objection.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
CERTIFICATE OF OATH
Q. The federal criminal investigation?

MR. SCOTT: Don't reveal any privileged
materials.
A. No. My recollection is during the federal
investigation, there were four named individuals who
were the subject of the nonprosccution agreement. I
remember two of them -- I remember at least one of
their names. I think I remember a second. but I'm
not sure.
I think she was one of those who was
granted immunity. But the immunity was limited to
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF BROWARD

I. the undersigned authority. certify
that ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ personally appealed duly
sworn on the 12th day of
January. 2016.
Signed this 14th day of January. 2016.
i L
four named individuals. all of whom were women. And
you could easily have found that out, and yet you
accused me of being one of the people who --

MR. EDWARDS: This is not responsive.
SPECIAL MASTER POZZUOLI: It was up
through that point. Let's move forward.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
KIMBERLY FONT CLR
EuilkyleebWjc. State
y Commission No. 8
Expires: 7/12/2019

Q. Didn't the nonprosecution agreement.
though, include as coconspirators -- didn't it say
all coconspirators of Jeffrey Epstein, including,
and then listed four names; that's how it went?
32 (Pages 455 to 458)
www.phi sre orting.com
CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF BROWARD

I. KIMBERLY FONTALVO. Registered
Professional Reporter. do hereby certify that I
was authorized to and did stenographically report
the foregoing videotape continued deposition of
ALAN M. DERSHOWTTZ: pages 334 through 455: that a
review of the transcript was requested: and that
the transcript is a true record of my
stenographic notes.
I FURTHER CERTIFY that I am not a
relative. employee, attorney, or counsel of any
of the parties. nor am I a relative or employee
of any of the panics' attorneys or counsel
connected with the action. nor am I financially
interested in the action.
Dated this 14th day of January. 2016.
ERRATA SHEET
IX/ NOT WRITE. ON IRANSCRIIT - ENTER CHANGES HERE
In Re. BRADLEY EDWARDS. ET AL. V. ALAN M.
DERSHOIMTZ
Cain No.:
ALAN M. DERSHOWITZ
January 12. 2016
PAGE UNE CHANGE REASON
Lida isarahrts of gentry. I declare that I have
read the foregoing document and that the fat
stated Mit are true.
KIMBERLY FONTALVO. RPIt CLR
Date ALAN M. DERSHOWI 1t
January 14. 2016
COLE scar de ICISSANE P.A.
Re: Bradley Edwards. et al.. v. Alan M Ikninninis
Please take notice alit on the 12th day of January.
1116. you gave your deposman in the above cause
As has rune. you did not waive your signanne
Thc abow.addressed attorneyhat ordered a copy of
this transcript and %III make an-angenrnu with you
to read their ropy. Please execute the Errata
SheeL be found back which Can at the of the
transcript and have it returned to us for
distribution to all panics.
If you donor read and sign the deposition within a
reasonable amount a lanc. the comma which has
already been forwarded to the ordering attorney. may
be filed with the Clerk of the Coon.
If you wish to waive your signature now. please sign
sour name in the blank at the bottom of this letter
and return to the address listed below.
Very truly yours.
KIMBERLY FONTALVO. RPR. MR
I do hereby waive my signature
MAN %I insiKiv76-7 --
33 (Pages 459 to 461)
www.phi sre orting.com
acquaintance...
360:17
act (1)
405:18
agreed (3)
338:9 359:3
416:25
agreement (23)
459:10 460:5
460:22 461:3,4
461:25
Alan's (2)
380:17
Andrew (3)
394:2 397:6
427:11
A
a.m (9)
334:15,15
338:19 374:12
375:17,17,19 acting (2) 391:19 415:6 446:16,21 announce (1)
457:19,20 403:18 413:11 429:21 447:7 alerted (1) 339:3
ABC (8) action (2) 447:24 448:5,8 413:21 answer (98)
344:17 373:13 459:18,19 448:11,18,24 Alfredo (4) 340:11 342:17
373:21,22,23 acts (1) 449:7,11,19,22 337:15 378:7,25 353:12,23,25
374:5,7 396:25 455:3 450:1,4 451:5 379:13 354:1,3 360:2
ability (2) add (2) 451:15,23 allegation (10) 360:2,4 361:16
409:14 413:13 423:24 450:10 452:15 453:25 355:2 356:10 361:20,23,25
able (17) added (1) 456:9,22 371:24 372:2 362:15,16,22
348:8 353:2 356:24 agrees (2) 372:15 376:8 362:24 363:1,5
2E :8,9,13 addition (1) 369:22 370:2 376:13 377:3,5 363:6,20
•:2 371:15 455:3 ahead (16) 403:18 376:20,21,24
374:19 376:10 address (1) 377:14 383:13 allegations (22) 377:20,22
376:15 390:23 460:15 393:11 396:2 341:6 342:21 379:8 380:6,20
392:1 404:14 Adler (1) 397:18 400:19 345:20 346:13 380:22,25
411:9 420:6 380:17 402:22 409:4 355:18 361:10 381:22,23
451:24 452:2 Administrator... 421:25 422:17 361:12 362:6 383:12,14
above-address... 334:21 423:3 427:23 365:6 371:18 384:10,12
460:8 advice (4) 434:25 441:2 373:19 385:18 385:12 390:8
Absolutely (4) 413:25 414:4,14 441:14 443:3 407:22 410:6 395:6 398:18
364:15 411:22 415:10 airplane (3) 410:15 414:19 403:4 404:20
425:25 442:12 affect (1) 348:5 365:21 414:24 420:8 408:21,22
accept (1) 443:22 440:20 436:17 440:21 409:4,11,13,17
407:6 affidavit (17) al (17) 454:23 455:1 409:22 414:5
accommodate... 385:6,8,17,19 349:2 351:7,19 alleged (1) 416:16,18
375:14 386:1,3,4,8,11 351:21,21,25 357:11 417:12,21
account (2) 386:23,24,25 352:1,5,8,9,11 alleging (1) 418:12,24
356:21 442:2 399:12 413:4 352:17,20,23 357:3 419:11,23
accounts (1) 420:18 421:11 354:15 460:5 allow (2) 422:1,16,19
341:9 421:12 461:3 432:14 447:8 423:20 424:2
accura te (3) affirm (2) Alan (33) allowed (2) 428:8,11 429:3
417:16 439:21 338:11 339:20 334:7,11 337:7 349:22 350:3 429:4,5,7,8,10
450:19 age (1) 337:16,18 amazing (1) 431:4,16,20
accusation (2) 432:18 338:20,21 433:1 432:15,19
371:23 439:2 ago (5) 359:5 363:20 amend (2) 434:7 435:3,6
accusat ions (2) 341:3 376:5 367:6,7 376:24 413:22,23 435:14,14
409:24 433:8 384:2 437:12 377:16,20 amount (2) 436:10,11,22
accused (7) 448:9 396:17 414:1 355:17 460:12 443:9 446:22
366:14 368:21 agree (9) 416:14,16 and-- (2) 448:1,15,20
375:22 412:4 338:13,14,15 443:6,8 446:22 335:13,17 450:5,6 451:1
414:12 443:13 343:13 353:14 446:25 449:1 and/or (1) 451:25 452:19
456:17 403:13416:10 450:22,25 452:8 453:10,13
416:22 428:8 453:10 458:9 Anderson (1) answered (16)
www.phi s rting.com
357:23 14
363:25 379:3
382:20,22,25
409:10,14
April (4)
337:16 368:3,11
388:7
argue (1)
430:17 434:11
435:4 436:8
437:21 441:10
450:22 451:16
attempted (1)
376:8
attention (1)
443:23
aware (7)
345:9 350:7
352:18 426:18
440:12 451:2
412:23 413:18 418:21 asking (30) attorney (16) 454:20
413:20 441:11 argument (4) 344:17 345:3,4 336:14 349:16
B451:9,16 370:19 446:2 347:7,10 356:19,22
455:18 451:3 453:4 352:15 370:1 361:23 381:10 back (2.8)
answering (2) argumentativ... 372:5 374:24 404:9 438:19 359:10 371:17
373:25 446:21 343:16 346:23 380:24 381:21 443:24 448:12 372:11,13
answers (2) 353:10 359:1 383:1 386:1 450:12,15,17 373:4,10
340:9 435:22 363:10 370:25 393:5 394:10 459:15 460:8 375:18,21
anybody (12) 373:1 380:13 396:25 398:8,9 460:13 386:8 391:21
344:12 348:19 382:15 426:6 398:16 399:4 attorney-dien... 405:16 407:17
354:18,18 440:11442:20 405:11 407:1 359:8,25 360:3 408:14 411:17
364:24 365:7 447:19 412:7 414:6 360:6 361:22 424:3,25
394:11 412:1 arrangements... 415:3,10 417:8 376:23 377:18 430:16 432:12
419:17 430:14 460:9 418:11 427:21 379:7 416:23 437:13 445:22
439:11 444:15 arrest (1) 448:23 417:1,3,10 446:7 448:3
anytime (1) 357:9 assert (2) 429:25 430:1,9 449:11 450:9
365:13 arrested (6) 369:1 447:8 430:11 435:7 451:10,17
apparently (4) 356:12,15,21 asserted (2) 435:15 443:7 457:16 460:10
372:16 373:7 357:2,4 379:13 430:14 445:24 446:17,24 backdoor (1)
405:19 442:2 articles (3) assertion (2) 455:15 454:3
appearances (3) 373:12 374:14 426:19 430:12 attorneys (3) backup (1)
335:1 336:1 375:10 assertions (3) 339:3 444:12 413:14
339:4 ascertain (1) 407:7 430:10,10 459:17 Bar (8)
appeared (1) 455:6 assisted (3) attributed (5) 349:22,25 355:8
458:9 ascertaining (1) 12,21,24 382:4,12 383:22 366:3,10 390:3
appointed (2) 439:25 associated (2) 385:3 387:5 391:12,17
338:3,8 Ashe (2) 344:12 380:11 audience (7) Barack (1)
appreciate (4) 419:24,24 Association (1) 366:18 368:16 371:2
349:13 407:6 aside (1) 366:3 368:17,23 Barak (20)
429:11 451:11 396:9 assume (6) 388:12,14,15 349:3 351:8
appreciated (1) asked (32) 369:8 374:21 August (4) 371:11,14,15
375:14 3i8j 357:22 392:1405:17 405:24406:3,4 372:3,16
appropriate (7) •:11,14 422:9 436:2 406:14 373:17 375:22
350:7 354:5 360:11 361:7 assumed (2) authorities (1) 376:9,13,17
370:6 373:20 363:25 365:13 433:3,5 350:7 377:6,10
394:24 398:11 373:12 374:2 assumes (2) authority (1) 379:21 380:8
431:3 384:18 392:16 452:4,6 458:8 380:12 381:8
appropriately ... 399:23 402:6 assuming (1) authorized (1) 383:17 420:14
354:11 372:19 402:25 403:9 448:4 459:8 Barak's (1)
399:7 405:10 408:1 attach (1) Ave (1) 381:18
approximate!... 408:15 409:6 437:3 336:4 BARNHART ...
338:18 375:19 412:23 413:18 attachment (1) avoided (1) 335:4
433:14 413:20427:6 397:20 348:9 based (14)
www.phi sr orting.com
356:21 360:2
364:10 377:18
417:18 425:5
425:15,21
353:9 354:2,16
362:20 364:1
364:23 367:10
367:12 368:19
big (1)
425:10
Bill (11)
351:6 353:5
442:5,10
457:11,17
Breakfast (2)
337:19 396:22
371:24 373:20
408:18,19
420:20
card (2)
426:14,16 371:3 375:8,9 354:6,8 383:23 bring (5) 349:23,25
436:5,22 382:19 383:2 384:4,5,23 395:10 436:9,20 care (1)
438:20 447:21 386:24 394:20 385:18 386:12 437:21 440:2 431:15
basic (1) 395:11,12,12 386:17 bringing (1) Carlos (1)
433:4 396:20 403:6 bills (2) 389:1 346:25
basically (1) 403:24413:3,5 387:11 391:2 Britain (1) case (16)
401:9 413:19 422:12 bit (1) 371:12 334:2 346:16
basing (1) 423:6,10,13 418:18 broad (6) 350:8 363:17
355:1 425:6,7,12,15 Black (1) 349:4 417:20 364:14 378:5
basis (12) 426:14 433:16 444:10 418:10 419:6 387:10,16
341:1 350:25 434:2,6,16,18 blame (2) 436:21 438:4 391:1 395:21
374:22 379:7 435:12 436:6 348:23 351:11 broader (2) 414:11 430:24
380:24 381:1 436:13 437:23 blank (1) 398:14 420:10 436:16 437:4
396:5 428:21 439:18 441:5 460:15 broken (2) 452:18 461:4
450:25 455:13 443:16 450:18 Blvd (1) 425:13 439:22 cases (3)
455:14,15 believed (11) 336:8 brought (2) 363:5 429:14
BBC (6) 365:6 366:1 Boies (5) 415:21 443:23 430:22
337:19,19 370:20,23 336:8 346:14 BROWARD (3) Cassell (11)
350:11 396:3 412:1 413:7 347:5 389:10 334:1 458:5 334:4 338:21
396:20,22 420:24 439:3 391:17 459:4 339:5 344:17
Beach (12) 439:11,17,18 Boise (3) Building (1) 344:22 346:11
335:4,5 337:22 believes (3) 346:18 347:15 460:19 347:13 350:3
348:6 3 :19 354:18 394:1 351:19 368:20 373:22 C 357:19 :3 397:5 Boise's (1) 374:5
CACE (1) 359:22 414:13 believing (3) 346:24 category (1)
414:20 436:16 348:24 354:20 books (1) 334:2 383:18
460:20 413:10 390:23 call (8) cause (2)
began (4) belong (1) Boston (1) 351:20 352:6 395:22 460:7
340:4 363:5 430:4 335:15 355:20 373:21 caveat (1)
414:18 415:20 belonged (1) bottom (1) 375:23,24 423:1
beginning (10) 379:14 460:15 391:22 409:18 cell (1)
345:15 365:11 belongs (1) Boulevard (3) called (14) 381:18
365:15,18,23 430:6 335:4,10 460:3 348:1 359:22 Centre (2)
411:21,24 Bench (2) bound (2) 371:14 373:11 335:9 460:2
412:20 420:12 366:3,10 363:1,23 373:13,13 certain (1)
434:1 benefit (1) Brad (2) 374:5 408:23 449:9
behalf (10) 341:4 339:5 347:13 414:25 419:24 certainly (4)
335:2,8 336:3,7 best (6) Bradley (4) 419:25 420:2,3 367:12 369:14
339:8,10,12,14 344:6 367:7 334:4 338:20 443:21 386:20 447:22
411:8 430:13 409:14 417:24 460:5 461:3 calling (2) certainty (3)
believe (51) 418:1 453:3 break (8) 347:24 419:18 419:15,16
346:18 348:19 beyond (2) 374:9 393:10 calls (8) 433:20
349:11 351:15 339:2 383:19 41 1 :13 441:3 344:20.22.23 Certificate (4)
www.phi sr orting.com
337:9,9 458:1
459:1
certify (3)
458:8 459:7,14
cetera (2)
407:18
claimed (3)
348:10 372:2
402:6
claiming (2)
381:20
cloth (9)
342:23 345:10
365:2,10
411:19,25
361:19 417:10
429:21 443:7
446:19 455:14
communicatio...
376:6 406:16
426:11
confidentialit...
364:9,10
confirm (1)
338:12
407:4 420:20 356:4 442:23 412:21 420:25 410:24 416:14 conflicting (1)
Chabad (3) claims (5) 433:9 417:8 445:6 407:7
337:16 388:16 365:4 382:5 CLR (4) 446:6,24 conform (2)
390:4 399:16 413:10 334:20 458:15 communicatio... 440:13,15
chairman (1) 425:2 459:22 460:18 406:5 416:2,4 connected (1)
389:15 clarification (1) Club (3) 418:6 445:1 459:18
CHANGE (1) 429:23 421:4 422:7,24 451:25 452:4,6 connection (3)
461:7 clarify (2) CNN (3) complaint (4) 404:11 414:4
CHANGES (1) 342:17 421:18 348:18 349:19 341:7 391:12,17 444:16
461:2 classes (1) 351:17 421:13 consecutive (1)
characterizati... 360:22 co-counsel (1) complaints (3) 400:5
354:7 clean (2) 452:17 390:2,3 391:17 consent (1)
charge (3) 369:8,11 coconspirator ... complete (6) 338:10
350:24 355:10 clear (3) 455:24 340:11,12 352:4 consequence (1)
356:20 384:19 427:14 coconspirator... 365:1 400:2 361:12
charges (4) 438:14 456:23,24 410:1 consider (1)
342:18 399:14 clearly (7) COLE (2) completed (1) 389:3
399:17 415:20 344: 348:23 335:9 460:2 340:6 consideration ...
check (6) M7 368:24 colleague (1) completely (3) 450:11
355:12,21 415:25 454:6,7 339:10 342:22 350:12 considered (1)
375:24 414:22 Clerk (1) collect (1) 385:25 455:23
448:15 450:1 460:13 381:12 composite (9) consistent (3)
checking (1) client (10) Columbia (1) 337:20,21,22 436:18 437:25
357:7 364:8 369:21 389:15 397:23 400:6,8 438:9
chooses (2) 374:20 416:10 combination (1) 400:21 401:3 consistently (1)
363:13 430:8 416:22,25 419:4 406:1 413:8
chosen (1) 417:2 421:19 come (5) compound (5) consulted (1)
405:18 430:13 450:18 346:1 362:9 346:23 354:22 355:6
chronology (3) client's (1) 395:21 450:8 377:13 412:3 contact (8)
344:15 402:4 345:1 451:9 412:24 343:19 345:21
407:12 Clinton (12) comes (2) conclude (2) 352:17 357:19
CIRCUIT (2) 349:2 351:7 387:19,19 364:22 417:16 361:7,9 362:5
334:1,1 353:5 354:6,8 coming (4) conclusion (2) 362:7
circulated (2) 383:23 384:4,5 359:16 373:3 372:18 395:21 contacted (3)
362:11,13 384:23 385:18 421:19455:8 conclusively (3) 361:13,15 362:3
circumstances... 386:12,17 comment (2) 345:12,13 428:1 context (5)
449:3,9 455:11 clock (4) 354:5,11 conduct (5) 390:14 402:15
civil (1) 425:13 439:22 Commission (1) 391:6 407:2,3 403:8 407:21
363:5 439:22,23 458:16 408:9 414:12 430:19
claim (5) close (1) committed (1) confident (1) continuation (2)
343:18 371:14 381:4 395:22 394:17 340:3 405:6
399:24 403:2 closer (1) common (6) confidential (1) continue (4)
mmw.phi sr orting.com
340:7 365:13
369:7 390:23
continued (7)
370:24 379:1
379:18 388:25
397:7,11
credibility (10)
371:3,4,8 436:1
438:16 439:25
417:13 418:15
419:7 427:4
434:22 442:25
334:8 335:8
339:8
defense (22)
334:10 336:1 399:10 405:9 440:8 441:8 445:14,15,16 361:13 363:14
337:8 340:1 405:11407:15 443:22,25 448:22 391:19 443:24
408:25 457:21 412:25 416:4 credible (2) date (3) 447:7,24 448:5
459:9 424:23 440:25 374:8 439:10 397:16 405:23 448:7,10,18,24
contrary (1) correspondin... credit (2) 461:25 449:7,10,19,22
386:15 406:10 428:5 438:20 dated (6) 449:25 450:4
contrived (3) corroborate (1) crime (2) 337:18 396:23 451:5,15,22
344:1 345:16 351:13 355:3 412:5 396:24 405:23 452:15 453:25
346:19 corroborated ... crimes (1) 406:2 459:20 defenses (3)
conversation (8) 438:18 368:20 daughter (1) 397:20 399:4,5
375:25 435:24 counsel (9) criminal (16) 420:3 definitively (1)
444:2 445:4 377:14 383:7 348:19 395:18 David (5) 381:21
446:3 453:22 397:22 430:1 395:20 397:14 346:14,18,24 degree (1)
454:3,15 444:9 445:10 399:14,16 347:14 351:19 377:7
conversations ... 451:3 459:15 407:2,3 408:9 day (10) deliberately (4)
454:8 459:17 414:19 436:16 338:17 384:11 341:17 343:10
cooperate (3) count (2) 438:15 447:14 392:10 396:25 344:24 433:20
404:14 405:15 436:1 453:3 455:25 456:1,4 425:13 439:23 delighted (2)
405:18 counting (1) critical (1) 458:10,12 390:8 450:5
cooperation (6) 391:14 347:23 459:20 460:6 demonstrate (3)
407:10 408:2,16 County (4) cross (1) days (3) 348:8 365:2
408:23,25 334:1 356:19 394:15 344:16 384:2 403:13
409:7 458:5 459:4 current (2) 405:17 denial (1)
copied (1) couple (2) 414:21 415:17 DC (1) 407:7
400:17 400:17 404:4 currently (1) 335:19 denied (1)
copies (2) course (10) 410:20 dealing (1) 399:17
374:17 400:12 341:15 345:8,19 Curtis (1) 438:5 denies (3)
copy (15) 346:10 357:1 338:8 Dear (1) 386:9,12 393:6
367:5 369:8,9 363:9 365:14 cutting (2) 404:8 DENNEY (1)
369:11 374:13 399:11 415:24 445:18,19 debating (1) 335:3
374:24 375:13 417:24 410:21 deny (5)
D 390:19 392:11 court (10) Debbie (1) 367:25 369:13
D (2) 392:22 393:1 334:1 339:18 420:1 369:14 393:7
393:11 437:1 342:11 364:6 336:14 337:1 decide (1) 408:24
460:8,9 391:4 401:3 Dadeland (4) 404:14 denying (1)
Coral (7) 422:18 430:18 335:9,10 460:2 decided (1) 427:13
337:16 368:3,10 437:18 460:13 460:3 389:9 Department (3)
368:11 388:6 covered (4) Daily (1) deciding (1) 337:22 357:20
388:16 390:4 363:13 426:25 341:8 398:10 3
correct (22) 450:23 455:20 damages (2) declare (1) depends (1)
341:12 342:20 crass (1) 394:2 397:7 461:22 343:17
343:11 344:3 350:9 Darren (15) defamatory (1) depo (2)
345:23 346:3 created (1) 336:4,5 339:12 355:18 364:1 413:19
347:25 350:18 355:15 359:7 414:2 Defendant (3) depose (10)
www.phi sr orting.com
399:25 402:6
402:11,13,18
determinable ...
355:14
discovery (5)
375:1,7 378:5
379:23
doubt (1)
343:3,22 347:2
347:7,13,16
402:19 403:3,7 determination... 429:13 430:22 425:18 348:17 349:18
403:10 405:11 374:8 discuss (2) doubts (1) 351:17 352:7
deposed (4) determine (3) 414:2 429:22 448:14 353:16 354:12
402:20 407:24 432:24 439:9 Discussion (1) due (2) 356:1 :1,19
407:25 409:24 441:16 382:2 355:11 373:14 359:9 360:9
deposition (34) determining (1) disease (1) duly (1) 362:4,18 363:3
334:10 338:19 375:23 366:22 458:10 363:16,21
338:23 340:4,6 dialogue (1) disprove (2) 364:3,12,21
E 340:8 341:5 408:25 352:6 355:22 366:8,11 368:9
E (3) 342:7 363:4 dies (1) distinct (2) 368:14 369:11
379:12 386:19 364:8 352:15 357:16 336:8 337:1 369:18,23
392:20,22 difference (2) distinction (1) 460:19 370:1,11 371:9
393:12 403:14 422:11 425:10 451:11 e-mail (3) 373:2 374:15
403:17,22 different (8) distinguish (1) 396:25 397:19 374:17 375:16
404:17 405:10 370:10 372:22 430:9 406:10 375:20 377:2
407:9,19,21 383:2 387:10 distribution (1) e-mailed (1) 377:21 378:4
408:2,12,17 389:3,5 390:25 460:11 392:6 378:23 379:11
409:8 410:14 401:9 District (2) earlier (4) 380:18 381:6
421:9 423:23 difficult (1) 391:4 448:12 359:15,17,18 382:3,18,24
424:3,15 459:9 398:15 divorced (1) 413:2 383:7,21 384:7
460:7,12 diligence (3) 352:3 early (2) 384:21 385:15
derived (2) 355:11,17 document (16) 443:18 448:10 385:23 386:5
418:5,7 373:14 380:10,15 381:2 easier (2) 386:10 387:24
derives (1) dinner (1) 398:4,6,8,10 390:22 401:12 388:5,13,20,21
381:23 361:1 398:14,24,25 easiest (1) 391:9 392:3,9
Dershowitz (30) direct (6) 399:3,3,5,6 454:9 392:15,18
334:7,11 337:7 337:8 340:1 400:4 461:22 easily (7) 393:5,24 394:5
337:16,18 409:22,22 documentary... 355:14 356:25 394:10,18
338:20,22 447:24 451:6 345:25 372:20 373:11 395:3,7 396:17
339:15 340:3 directing (1) documentatio... 408:11 440:13 396:20 397:2,9
347:8 366:9 388:18 448:4 456:16 397:18 398:3
367:6,7 396:18 directly (2) documents (10) easy (4) 398:22,23
417:9,11 430:2 376:11,12 337:20,21 348:8 365:12414:10 399:9,18,22
430:6,7 438:21 disagree (2) 369:9,17,20 414:22 420:16 400:8,20 401:1
446:25 447:22 370:12 403:13 402:4,9 403:12 Ed (3) 401:7,11,22
457:5 458:9 disbarrable (2) 404:1 338:2,7 339:16 402:2,24 404:6
459:10 460:5 343:25 344:5 doing (4) Edward (1) 404:16,21
460:22 461:3,4 disclose (4) 347:23 392:10 336:13 405:3 406:8
461:25 417:9 443:6 392:20 413:15 Edwards (192) 407:16 408:19
described (2) 448:25 457:8 dominant (2) 334:4 337:8 409:12,19
371:6 454:19 disclosed (4) 419:11 420:5 338:13,21 410:2 411:3,11
deserves (1) 375:7 449:4 Don (4) 339:5,5 340:2 411:16 412:6
386:4 450:22,24 343:23 345:25 340:18,19 412:14 413:1
destroy (1) disclosing (1) 348:18 351:17 341:21,24 413:20 414:6
350:8 369:6 Donald (1) 342:5,9.24 414:16 416:9
mmw.phi sr orting.com
416:21 417:15
418:2,19
419:20 420:9
421:8,12 422:1
422:4,20,21
423:8,22 424:7
424:13,17
426:9 427:19
428:9,24 431:1
431:5 432:3
438:4
either (7)
401:16 421:12
438:20 447:23
451:6,20 452:7
electronic (2)
342:7 375:12
elephant (1)
368:25
eliminate (2)
369:16 370:3,7
397:20 399:5
430:1,12
entries (4)
337:15 379:22
379:23 431:9
entry (2)
379:21 380:7
Epstein (80)
336:3 339:13
429:25 431:10
433:13 434:5
454:19 455:24
equivalent (1)
349:20
erotic (2)
434:12 435:5
err (2)
449:15 450:2
Errata (3)
351:19 373:21
Excerpt (2)
337:16,18
excerpts (1)
369:21
exculpatory (1)
370:9
execute (1)
460:9
execution (1)
433:11,22,24 454:10 457:4 351:23,23 337:10 460:9 337:10
434:10,17 embarrassed (2) •:8,21,24 461:1 exhibit (17)
435:2 436:7 369:4,5 359:6,12,23 ESQ (8) 378:13,20
437:2,8,16,19 EMERSON (2) 360:12 361:14 335:5,11,12,15 392:25 393:12
438:10 439:1 335:11 460:4 362:12 364:5 335:19 336:5,9 393:14,23
439:24 440:18 employee (2) 364:11 376:16 460:4 396:12 397:24
440:24 442:12 459:15,16 377:9 378:25 establish (3) 398:7 400:5,7
442:13,22 employer (2) 379:15 380:11 394:15 428:1,1 400:9,25 401:4
443:11 445:3 356:13,16 391:19 403:15 et (4) 406:1 437:7
445:25 446:23 enable (2) 407:2,14 408:9 407:4 420:20 438:24
447:11 448:6 416:11,23 413:17,25 460:5 461:3 exhibits (8)
449:18 451:13 encompass (1) 414:9,18 415:2 ethics (2) 337:12 378:14
451:24 452:23 347:18 415:15,23 350:6 355:5 392:8,23 393:1
453:5,20 454:5 encounters (2) 416:3,15 418:7 evaluated (1) 393:2 400:14
454:16 455:22 357:6 433:19 423:15,25 425:21 401:10
456:3,18,21 ended (1) 424:22 425:1,9 Eve (1) existed (1)
457:12 460:5 409:1 425:17 426:2 380:17 451:23
461:3 engage (1) 426:13,19 event (3) exists (1)
effect (1) 408:9 428:11,18,23 368:2 398:16 378:10
406:25 engaged (1) 429:1,12,24 425:11 experience (2)
effort (2) 455:3 430:5,15,21 evidence (12) 381:9 438:15
344:25 372:7 engagement (1) 431:11,13,22 346:1 426:18,24 experts (1)
Ehud (25) 368:10 432:16 434:12 427:1 428:6,21 355:6
349:2 351:7 engagements (1) 435:5,24 436:9 429:6 432:14 Expires (1)
371:2,11,14,15 387:9 436:15 437:5 433:15 438:11 458:17
372:3,16 engaging (1) 437:21 438:2 438:13 441:9 explain (5)
373:17 375:22 443:13 440:2 443:13 exact (2) 349:9 384:13,15
376:9,13,17 England (1) 444:7,13,17,19 370:17 410:18 447:2,4
377:6,10 372:14 447:8 449:2 exactly (2) explained (1)
379:21 380:8 ENTER (1) 452:18 453:12 349:9 436:10 386:18
380:12 381:8 461:2 454:24 455:3,7 exaggerating (1) explore (1)
382:6 383:4,17 entered (1) 455:9 456:24 353:1 376:10
383:17,20 449:23 Epstein's (15) Examination (2) explored (2)
420:14 entire (3) 351:22 352:12 337:3 340:1 441:11 444:5
eight (1) 341:11 412:21 363:4 367:9 examined (1) exposed (1)
400:23 434:1 378:7 404:9 394:15 356:4
Eighty (1) entitled (7) 421:5 422:8.25 example (2) expression (1)
www.phi sr orting.com
344:4
extent (16)
359:4 361:18
376:22 377:3,4
379:5 416:13
417:7 428:7
429:15 430:23
443:1,5 446:16
450:21 453:9
extraordinaril...
355:2
extraordinary...
355:11,17
387:11 391:1
420:8
falsely (3)
356:21 357:3
403:19
falsity (2)
373:9 422:12
familiar (4)
378:8,9 449:10
453:18
familiarize (1)
341:2
far (4)
354:10 356:16
380:2 437:10
favor (1)
351:21 357:8
373:18 397:25
406:11 410:11
410:11,12
411:9 414:23
432:8
fine (3)
404:6 457:12,15
finish (5)
348:14 404:19
405:1 419:22
422:3
finished (1)
405:4
finishing (1)
440:19 441:4,5
441:9,12,15,17
441:21,23,24
Florida (12)
334:1,18 335:5
335:10 336:9
338:25 355:8
458:4,16 459:3
460:3,20
flown (1)
431:19
fly (1)
348:7
focus (2)
384:17 418:18
371:6,7,7 378:7
383:16
Fort (3)
334:18 336:9
338:25
forth (1)
356:3
Forum (1)
460:19
forward (9)
346:1 392:20,24
426:7 438:24
449:14 455:7,8
456:20
forwarded (2)
F- 448:14 374:1 focusing (1) 337:10 460:13
face (2) February (2) fired (1) 433:7 found (15)
341:10 382:1 366:4,14 356:16 follow (1) 351:24 353:8
fact (13) federal (5) first (10) 402:23 356:18,22
341:11 363:17 391:4,18 448:12 341:5 393:9 follow-up (2) 357:1 372:19
365:8 367:19 456:4,7 396:5 407:17 398:21 409:10 373:21 374:3,4
382:1 399:15 feel (1) 413:21,24 follows (1) 374:4,5 405:19
407:12 413:22 354:10 414:12,24 451:4 431:13 456:16
428:22 441:16 fellow (i) 445:23 446:2 Fontalvo (5) 460:10
447:5 451:5,23 355:10 fit (1) 334:20 458:15 four (13)
facts (2) female (1) 383:17 459:6,22 344:16 381:7
346:16461:22 407:14 five (15) 460:18 391:8,10,11,12
factual (1) FF (1) 352:5 365:3 foot (1) 400:22 452:14
453:4 458:16 381:8 387:10 351:22 456:8,15,25
failing (1) figure (1) 387:13,14,15 foregoing (2) 457:2,4
351:12 426:1 388:24 390:7 459:9 461:22 frame (1)
fair (6) file (1) 390:10,25 form (24) 389:9
349:13 375:9,12 395:14 391:15 399:14 341:1 343:15 fraud (1)
409:1 453:21 filed (4) 400:22 412:24 346:22 354:22 356:5
453:24 355:18 356:19 Fl (1) 372:25 374:22 Frederick (1)
fall (1) 391:13 460:13 336:4 379:2 380:14 380:17
452:6 files (1) flesh (1) 382:14 383:9 friend (4)
false (19) 381:14 454:4 387:18 394:3,8 344:6 345:7
341:11 342:18 filing (1) flew (2) 397:11,13 354:8 381:5
342:22 345:9 394:22 384:4 431:14 410:23 412:24 friends (1)
345:20 346:13 filled (3) FLEXNER (1) 416:5 417:20 415:10
352:12 356:20 385:8,19 386:3 336:8 418:13 436:21 front (4)
356:21 365:5 financial (1) flight (18) 440:10 442:19 366:4 388:10
371:24 374:6 350:10 429:12,16 451:5 391:4 403:12
387:7 390:10 financially (1) 430:21 431:6 formally (3) full (6)
391:23 394:16 459:18 431:14,21 415:2,4,15 346:3,9,10,14
402:16 410:6 find (11) 432:7,24 former (5) 347-9.12
www.phi sr orting.com
fully (2)
345:8 350:7
further (7)
407:4 446:8
448:1,15
449:17 452:13
459:14
424:10 428:4
428:14 434:11
435:4 436:10
438:16 442:16
given (2)
350:22,23
glanced (1)
431:17
go (35)
340:5 349:5,11
371:3 377:14
442:6 445:25
447:21 449:13
449:14 450:7
450:14 452:12
454:1,3 457:6
457:18
good (4)
429:9,10 442:11
457:10
Gorani (3)
349:19 356:2
349:19 356:2
364:22
half (1)
442:7
hand (1)
339:19
handful (1)
414:14
handle (1)
340:14
handwriting (1)
450:11,15
hearing (1)
420:7
heinous (4)
355:3,9 368:20
412:5
held (4)
338:23 364:6
375:17 457:20
helicopter (1)
384:5
G
G (2)
334:4 338:21
gain (1) 383:13 386:8 364:22 374:18 help (5.)_
350:10 389:20 393:10 Gore (15) Hang (7) 341:2 M8
Gallagher (2) 396:2 397:18 349:2 351:7,21 342:2 398:1,2 359:22 387:25
336:15 339:1 402:22 407:17 351:21,25 409:3 412:12 388:22
gatherings (1) 409:3 415:7 352:1,1,5,8,10 426:4 439:12 helpful (1)
361:3 420:23 421:4 352:11,17,20 happened (1) 387:20
Gehrig's (1) 421:25 422:7 352:23 354:15 348:11 hide (1)
366:22 422:17,24 Gore's (1) happening (2) 345:23
general (3) 423:2 424:3 351:19 444:24 446:10 highlighted (6)
336:14 349:17 427:23 430:16 government (1) happy (8) 342:13 378:16
359:20 434:25 435:21 448:13 352:2 361:25 388:7,19 396:3
generated (1) 437:13 441:2 grant (2) 362:25 426:21 441:6
344:22 441:14 443:3 364:19 434:25 438:8 448:15 history (3)
getting (1) 445:22 446:7 granted (1) 450:5 457:14 351:14 356:17
418:20 448:3 457:6 456:14 hard (2) 425:21
Ghalaine (3) goes (3) Great (1) 381:21,24 hold (1)
444:24 446:10 363:11 371:8 371:12 Harvard (1) 419:23
446:25 451:17 grounds (2) 360:19 home (2)
Ghislaine (11) going (54) 363:19 450:20 Hawking (11) 348:6 360:24
421:3 422:6,23 340:5,8,9,14,25 group (1) 366:15,22 367:2 Honor (1)
427:10 444:21 342:14 343:6 390:4 367:2,6,8,21 450:10
445:4 446:4 344:10 347:6 grouping (1) 368:4 370:22 hope (5)
447:9,12 349:5,6 352:14 400:15 420:14,17 349:8 351:9
451:14 452:1 362:1 364:18 Guardian (3) Hawking's (1) 367:18,20,22
girl (1) 374:10,11,16 372:9 376:4,7 367:15 horrible (1)
441:19 375:18,21 guess (1) head (2) 356:13
girls (11) 378:15 387:17 368:6 426:22 hour (3)
384:6 436:9,18 392:1,23 health (1) 350:14 420:7
436:19,20 393:15 396:2,6 338:9 442:6
437:22 438:1.4 396:7 400:4,24 guilty (2) hear (8) hour's (1)
440:3 443:13 402:4,21408:7 368:19 404:10 372:21 374:15 432:23
455:2 408:8 411:17 guys (1) 376:25 443:2 house (3)
give (14) 414:2418:21 445:17 445:17,20 421:5 422:8,25
339:21 340:9 424:25 432:12 446:2,13 housekeepers ...
H341:19 369:15 434:24 437:14 heard (4) 378:7
395:13 413:13 438:11)/ Hala (3) 372:23 408:11 hundreds (1)
www.phi sr orting.com
371:24
hurt (2)
394:1 397:6
352:20 390:6
Incident (1)
337:22
455:13 456:2
457:5
information (...
instructed (1)
364:13
instructing (3)
444:6,16,23
446:9 447:13
447:15,18
include (2) 371:13,15,20 361:23 363:20 455:4,25 456:4
349:2 456:23 372:4,6,22 376:19 456:8
idea (7)_ included (1) 404:12,13 instruction (1) investigators (1)
354:4 M:10 404:2 416:19 417:4 430:3 359:19
385:4 407:8 includes (1) 417:18 418:5 Intellectual (1) invited (1)
440:9 444:2,5 434:19 418:23 419:2,3 361:3 368:23
identified (3) including (5) 419:4 420:6 intend (3) involved (10)
349:4 400:14 357:18 384:1 423:21 427:17 350:21406:4 359:20 387:9,15
401:17 387:4 391:12 427:25,25 409:18 389:1,8,23
identify (4) 456:24 428:3 429:19 intent (2) 390:16,24
387:18 388:4 inclusion (1) 434:15 435:18 349:24 350:2 391:3,7
394:9 445:23 416:5 436:3,4 440:7 interest (7) irrelevant (1)
identifying (1) independent (1) 442:21 443:7 361:19 417:10 353:11
393:3 426:10 443:18 445:24 429:21 443:8 irresponsible (...
ignore (1) indicated (1) 446:17 448:2 446:19 448:12 357:7
399:8 ■15 448:25 449:7 455:14 island (10)
II (2) indication (1) 450:3,21 interested (1) 348:5 351:22
335:9 460:2 381:19 453:17 459:19 352:12 365:20
image (1) indicative (1) initial (2) interrupt (2) 367:9 383:24
368:5 354:15 359:21 432:12 353:18 403:1 384:5,24 420:1
imagine (1) individual (1) initially (4) Interview (1) 420:2
390:5 376:3 408:2,17 409:8 337:18 Islands (1)
immediately (2) individuals (3) 437:20 invade (5) 367:4
348:3 371:21 347:18 456:8,15 innocence (1) 360:5 361:19 issue (11)
immunity (2) Indyke (46) 369:2 417:9 435:6 367:20 368:24
456:14,14 336:4,5 339:12 innocent (1) 446:17 402:13,18,19
impact (1) 339:12 359:4,7 350:9 invades (1) 410:19,19
452:15 359:24 360:4 inquire (5) 361:21 425:16 430:19
implication (2) 361:17 362:14 367:18 406:5 invading (2) 451:12 452:22
354:13 384:3 362:23 363:19 452:13,16,17 359:25 447:23 issued (1)
implied (1) 364:7,16 inquiry (4) invalidate (1) 411:7
386:21 376:18,21 355:5 431:3 420:21 issues (2)
important (1) 377:12,16 449:17 452:9 investigate (1) 435:22 453: I
427:17 379:5 414:1,2 instance (1) 395:21
J impossible (1) 416:13 417:7 443:17 investigated (3)
418:12 418:14,15 instruct (16) 371:13 372:16 J (3)
improper (3) 419:7,8 423:16 360:1 361:19 372:17 334:4 336:13
379:25 391:6 427:6 429:15 364:17 376:24 investigation (... 338:20
414:12 434:22,22 377:19 379:8 346:3,9,10,15 1E (1)
improperly (1) 436:24 443:2,5 384:9 414:5 347:9,17 441:25
403:18 445:17 446:12 416:16 417:11 359:12,17,19 Jack (3)
inability (1) 446:16 448:23 429:21 443:8 359:22 373:14 335:5 339:6
407:6 449:9 450:10 446:21 450:25 419:18 420:6 347:14
inappropriate... 450:14 453:9 453:12 457:7 437:4 438:2 January (24)
www.phi sr orting.com
334:15 337:18
338:18 342:1
342:25 343:23
344:11,16
Jeffrey's (3)
383:24 384:24
414:3
Joanne (1)
KENNETH (1)
335:15
Kimberly (5)
334:20 458:15
432:19 433:4,5
433:17,19
434:8,9 435:22
437:10 438:15
368:16
laughed (1)
366:21
law (3)
345:13 349:19 419:24 459:6,22 440:2,7 441:1 350:4 357:6
350:11 351:18 joint (20) 460:18 441:2 442:15 415:9
360:10 396:24 363:14 391:19 kind (3) 442:24 444:21 Lawrence (1)
397:17,19 447:6,24 448:5 355:4 442:15 447:5,14 448:4 350:19
399:23 410:7 448:7,10,18,24 450:21 450:11,15 lawsuit (12)
458:11,12 449:7,10,19,22 KISSANE (2) 452:18 453:6,8 341:1 374:23
459:20 460:1,6 449:25 450:4 335:9 460:2 453:10,18,19 389:1,2 394:7
461:5 451:5,15,22 knew (17) 454:7,12 394:22 395:10
Jeffrey (78) 452:14 453:25 356:9,10 357:1 455:12,18 395:14 397:8
336:3 339:13 Jonathan (1) 357:2,3,5 knowing (7) 397:10 417:5
351:22 23 23 389:14 367:1 419:15 423:14 425:1,8 455:11
352:12:8 journal (11) 424:21 426:2 428:11,18,25 lawsuits (1)
■:21,24 337:15 378:6,8 426:19 427:12 432:16 403:16
359:6,12 378:10,11,12 427:13 428:23 knowledge (9) lawyer (18)
361:13 362:12 378:15,24 440:14 441:16 377:17 381:24 351:20 355:1,4
363:4 364:5,11 379:14,19,20 441:20 404:10 419:13 355:6,10
367:8 376:16 JR (2) know (95) 424:1 426:11 360:13,14,16
376:23 377:9 335:11 460:4 340:13,17 428:12 444:20 361:5 362:1
377:19 379:7 jsx@searcyla... 341:19 347:3 454:14 363:22 364:13
379:15 380:11 335:6 349:1 351:23 known (3) 413:10 415:8
403:15 404:9 judge (4) 354:9,10 372:24 373:9 438:15 443:24
413:16,24 338:4,6 347:4 355:21 356:17 426:13 447:14,16
415:14,22 391:5 :5,16,20,22 knows (6) lawyer -client (...
418:7 421:4 judges (1) :23 367:14 359:5 363:18 363:2,11,23
422:7,24 366:4 367:17,18 376:22 410:20 lawyers (25)
423:14,25 JUDICIAL (1) 376:2 377:8,9 449:1 454:13 341:16 343:9,17
424:21 425:1,9 334:1 377:10,22 ksweder@swe... 343:25 345:15
425:17 426:2 juice (1) 378:9 379:6 335:16 345:16,16
426:13,19 443:21 380:2,15,16,25 348:23 349:25
I 428:11,18,23 jumped (2) 380:25 381:22 351:11 357:18
Lakes (1) 428:25 429:12 402:20 407:24 381:25 385:3,5 357:24 ■:2,5
429:18 430:20 juror (1) 387:7 388:9,11 335:4 17 359:20
431:10,11,12 425:16 388:14,25 large (1) 363:7 366:4
432:16 433:12 juvenil .2) 393:19 394:13 360:25 394:12 399:24
434:5,12 435:4 357:9 I.: I; 404:8,12 Las (1) 402:6 403:2
436:9 437:5,21 409:17 415:4 336:8 439:3 447:4
K438:2 443:13 415:22 417:23 Lastly (1) 457:3
444:7,13,16,19 K (3) 418:9,24 364:22 laying (1)
446:18 447:8 335:18 336:4,5 422:10 424:20 Lauderdale (3) 340:25
449:2 453:12 keep (2) 424:23 425:2 334:18 336:9 laypeople (1)
454:19,24 368:5 384:16 425:17 426:15 338:25 390:5
455:3,7,9,24 Ken (1) 429:3,4,5,7,8,9 laugh (3) lead (1)
456:24 339:14 430:12 431:23 366:17.18 362:20
www.phi 11 orting.com
leader (2)
371:18,19
leaders (6)
356:12,18,25
411:25 412:5
412:16 420:11
389:21,23
390:3,16 391:1
391:4,7,20
Lou (1)
366:22
love (2)
343:4 344:5
369:13 371:17
383:1 393:6,7
348:21 349:1 425:8,14 429:17 363:6 367:17 394:19 411:18
351:8 371:8 432:21 litigations (1) lunch (3) 419:13 420:12
380:2 420:19 lie (14) 387:14 392:7 442:10 424:4 439:2.5
learned (2) 352:24,25 353:3 little (1) 457:20 441:7
346:21 373:7 385:20 400:1,2 418:18 lying (47) man (1)
leave (2) 400:3 402:7,10 Live (2) 350:17 351:14 350:9
362:1 454:11 403:4 407:18 349:19 364:22 355:16 356:14 manifest (1)
led (1) 407:23 410:1 LLP (2) 356:17 394:25 431:6
432:12 422:10 335:14 336:8 403:6,8 411:21 manifests (6)
legal (9) lied (20) local (1) 419:13,16 429:13,16
349:21 387:11 346:19 348:20 444:9 421:2 422:5,22 430:21 431:14
391:1 414:4,14 349:2 350:20 log (1) 423:9,12,14 431:22 432:18
415:10 429:20 351:6,7,7,8,24 441:24 425:1,8,8,11 Mar-a-Lago (3)
453:1,4 352:24 354:9 logs (10) 425:21 426:12 421:4 422:7 24
Lemon (4) 354:25 365:1 432:7,24 440:19 428:10,17,22
343:23 345:25 365:10,25 441:4,6,9,12 428:25 432:15
348:18 351:18 389:12411:25 441:15,21,24 433:12,21
lend (1) 412:20 420:11 long (10) 434:4,11 435:4
440:8 433:18 351:14,14 435:5,10,11,19
length (1) lies (9) 352:14 356:17 435:20 436:8 mark (9)
379:13 355:13 362:11 363:13 368:6 437:20 440:9 392:25 393:11
Leslie (1) 362:12,17,21 384:11 401:17 441:18,20 396:6,8,9
349:3 385:8 386:3 437:11 448:9 442:18 443:15 397:18 400:5,8
let's (6) 412:18 413:8 longer (1) 444:3 455:10 401:11
338:1 374:9 life (2) 343:14 Lynch (1) marked (10)
384:15 392:20 354:20 433:17 look (12) 338:4 342:12 378:19
432:23 456:20 limitations (9) 341:22 388:13 Lynch's (1) 393:3,22
letter (12) 394:21 395:9,18 401:20,23 338:6 396:11 397:23
337:10 394:23 395:19,24 402:3 404:1,5 398:5 400:6
- 11I- 397:19 398:17 396:14 397:12 406:12 410:11 437:6,17
403:23 405:13 397:15 399:12 426:21 437:9 M (10) marking (1)
405:14,22 limited (1) 452:25 334:7,11 337:7 392:23
406:4,6,12 456:14 looked (3) 458:9 459:10 Marra (2)
460:15 line (4) 431:12 441:15 460:5,22 461:3 391:5,18
letters (2) 424:13,16,18 441:21 461:4,25 Martha's (1)
401:15 415:11 461:7 looking (6) MA (1) 348:7
Lewinsky (1) listed (4) 398:13,13 402:9 335:15 massages (3)
353:7 381:16 454:18 432:5,7,24 main (1) 434:12 435:5
Lexington (1) 456:25 460:15 lose (1) 390:13 443:14
336:4 listen (2) 400:15 maintain (2) master (123)
liar (19) 348:13 445:19 lot (1) 364:9,10 336:13 338:1,3
350:20 351:1,4 litigation (16) 416:6 major (1) 338:8,16
351:5,13,15 387:10,16 389:4 lots (2) 415:19 339:16,17
353:4.9 356:5 389:6.9.19.20 415:9.9 making (15) 341:4 342:2.6
www.phi sr orting.com
342:16 349:14
353:14,20,24
354:2 359:3
360:7 362:2
364:18 369:19
375:8 377:1
379:9 382:22
455:17 456:19
457:9,13,16
material (6)
371:16 408:5,6
415:13 426:16
438:18
materials (4)
345:5
Meredith (5)
339:10 345:12
356:11 399:24
403:2
merely (2)
341:10 344:23
move (12)
353:14 384:8
385:23 392:20
397:2 399:18
399:20 426:7
433:22 438:24
449:14 456:20
411:13 418:24
419:17 430:8
447:15,16
451:8
neither (1)
350:3
never (28)
383:10,13 423:5 435:23 met (6) MSNBC (2) 351:21,22 352:9
384:9,14,17 436:22 456:6 351:22,25 341:25 342:25 353:6 354:9
385:9,13 386:7 matter (4) 352:11 353:2 multiple (3) 356:7,7,8,8
388:3,11,18 338:20 364:4 413:24 453:19 390:16 407:7 365:19,20,21
391:24 392:12 403:16 410:19 Mexico (1) 420:19 367:15 373:6
392:16,19 matters (3) 419:25 385:3,17 387:6
N 393:8,15,18 414:15 415:3,16 Miami (4) 402:18 406:25
N (1) 395:5 396:7,15 Maxwell (14) 335:10 366:3,10 407:13 423:25
396:19,23 421:3 422:6,23 460:3 441:17 444:1,5
397:4,21 398:1 427:10 444:21 mind (3) 444:8 447:12
398:20 399:1 444:24 445:4 355:15 384:20 447:18 454:15
399:19 400:11 446:4,11,25 441:22 New (4)
400:16 401:16 447:9,12 mine (1) name (9) 336:5,5 341:8
402:21 404:19 451:14 452:1 354:8 338:25 342:20 419:25
405:1,21,25 McCAWLEY ... minimal (1) 359:16 367:15 news (9)
409:3,9,21 336:9 338:15 351:12 380:1 413:5 337:19,19 341:9
412:12 414:7 339:9,9 346:14 ministers (3) 432:8 453:18 342:10 350:11
416:17 417:21 346:16,18 371:7 383:16,16 460:15 360:10 396:3
418:16 419:9 347:14 minor (5) named (12) 396:20,22
419:22 421:16 mean (5) 429:2 436:17,19 349:4 367:19,21 newspaper (6)
421:21 422:2 342:18 356:6 436:20 442:16 367:22 371:6 367:4,12 371:12
422:14 423:1 364:25 392:3 minors (3) 380:8 382:6 372:9 386:20
424:10 426:4,7 438:19 440:5 443:14 383:4 453:6 420:17
427:2,22 meaning (3) 455:4 456:8,15 457:4 newspapers (1)
428:19 430:16 386:16 429:1 minutes (5) names (6) 384:1
430:23 431:2 454:6 352:5 374:10 380:2,23 456:11 nine (1)
431:20 433:10 means (2) 401:20 404:5 456:25 457:2,4 400:23
434:24 436:25 407:8 415:5 442:10 nasty (1) non-parties (1)
437:14 438:21 meant (2) miscommunic... 394:23 339:11
439:12 440:23 345:19 346:9 444:1 I national (1) non-privilege...
441:13 442:9 media (11) missing (4) 342:10 377:25 416:7
443:1,3,10 344:19,20,25 404:3 406:13,19 nature (2) 418:8 423:4
445:10,15,21 353:1,3 375:12 406:20 420:15 421:20 non-responsiv...
446:1,7,14 403:20410:4,8 moment (1) nearly (2) 380:5,20
447:3,20 449:5 410:10 412:10 353:19 436:17 437:25 noncredible (1)
449:13 450:7 meeting (1) money (4) necessarily (1) 356:23
450:13 451:2 354:14 353:2 357:4 410:18 nonprivileged ...
451:17 452:3 men (2) 415:7 442:3 need (12) 404:13 416:3
452:21 453:2 356:20 360:25 Monica (1) 368:22,25 369:1 417:19 419:3
453:15 454:1 mental (1) 353:7 401:22 407:8 426:17 428:13
www.phi sr orting.com
432:14 434:9
434:14 435:18
442:21
nonprosecutio...
456:9,22
nonresponsive...
385:24 386:5
395:3 397:2
409:20 433:23
Normally (1)
392:22
Notary (1)
450:19,25
objection (64)
343:15 346:22
353:10,1L
354:22 M: 1 5
359:1,4,24
361:17 362:14
362:14,23
363:10,19
364:7,16,19
370:25 372:25
376:18 377:12
359:10,13
obtained (8)
357:13 359:14
378:6 417:18
418:23 419:2,5
429:19
obtaining (3)
8,12,24
obvious (1)
438:19
obviously (6)
342:19 356:7,8
416:10 419:11
420:16 423:14
425:7 426:17
427:5,8 432:20
433:10 435:9
435:17 436:8
438:11 442:6
443:12 444:6
454:11,17,22
Olas (1)
336:8
old (1)
orgy (5)
367:8 368:4
370:22 383:24
384:24
original (1)
460:12
originally (2)
338:7 457:2
outlines (2)
433:3,4
outrageously (1)
420:7
458:16 377:13,16 362:25 413:10 357:11 outside (12)
notes (4) 379:2,5 380:13 441:23 Oliver (1) 379:10 426:11
375:5 378:14 382:14,20 occasion (1) 335:14 427:2,7,7
393:19 459:13 383:5,8 394:3 369:1 Olmert (4) 428:6 429:8,10
notice (1) 394:8 412:3,23 occasions (4) 382:6 383:4,17 429:16 436:4
460:6 414:1 416:5,13 360:20 385:21 383:20 452:6 453:16
number (14) 417:7,20 411:5,6 one-sided (2) overlap (1)
345:11,14,15 418:10,13,14 offense (1) 438:17 442:15 440:6
360:25 381:16 419:6,7 421:17 395:23 opened (1) overly (5)
389:16,17 423:17 426:6 offered (3) 367:19 417:20 418:10
390:25 398:24 429:15 434:21 346:25 348:7 opening (1) 419:6 436:21
399:1 401:15 434:22,23,25 389:11 395:2 438:4
411:5,6 432:9 436:21,24 office (2) openly (1) overnight (1)
numbers (3) 438:3 440:10 336:14 392:4 355:18 374:14
381:8,13,17 441:10442:19 Oh (1) opinion (3)
-P numerous (3) 443:4 447:19 385:4 344:4 350:5
351:3 386:20 453:9 455:13 okay (58) 354:18 P.A (3)
420:20 456:2 338:16 340:12 opportunity (... 335:4,9 460:2
NW (1) objections (1) 340:23 343:6 350:22,23 351:9 p.m (1)
335:18 450:18 344:10 345:2 367:20,23,25 457:21
objective (8) 345:11 346:6,8 394:14 395:14 page (12)
0 426:24 427:1 347:21 348:12 401:5 402:20 337:3,14 378:12
O'Donnell (1) 428:6,21 429:6 348:15 352:19 407:25 378:15 379:20
350:19 432:13 433:15 353:5 359:10 oppose (1) 393:11 401:15
oath (10) 436:3 364:20 375:16 440:8 423:23 424:5
337:9 368:1 obligation (6) 379:17 381:2,7 option (1) 424:12 443:19
385:7,16 350:6 355:11 386:14 387:8 369:22 461:7
394:14,25 364:9 389:11 389:7 390:18 order (6) pages (5)
395:1 399:17 398:16 399:13 393:17 395:25 338:5,6 353:22 334:13 337:5
439:18 458:1 oblige (1) 400:4 402:25 394:21 400:9 400:21 401:2
object (11) 394:21 403:25 406:18 451:8 459:10
359:21 380:19 obliged (1) 407:17 409:15 ordered (3) paid (2)
383:7 387:17 430:2 409:19 411:12 392:13,15 460:8 415:7,12
416:15 435:21 obtain (41 411:14,15 ordering (1) Palm (12)
446:19.20.20 357:13 -) 413:12415:14 460:13 335:4.5 337:22
www.phi sr orting.com
348:5 356:19
357:19 :3
359:21 414:13
414:20 436:16
460:20
paper (1)
380:24
part (9)
346:15 350:20
355:21 366:15
367:22 369:3
371:2,5 373:8
379:24,24
380:3 381:12
381:14412:18
413:8 415:10
371:15 373:22
persuaded (1)
386:2
perused (1)
441:23
Phipps (1)
460:18
phone (9)
441:25
plea (2)
404:10,11
pleading (1)
347:24
please (15)
339:3,19360:4
392:12 393:14
377:4
positive (1)
372:10
possessor (1)
429:24
possible (6)
427:15,16,18,24
435:25 449:11
341:5 353:3 419:19,21 335:12 336:5 396:8 397:13 possibly (1)
357:1 391:25 420:12,14 351:20 352:6 401:6 422:18 348:11
405:25 407:2 438:6 448:11 371:24 373:20 430:17 438:23 potential (3)
448:18 450:4 448:17 454:10 381:8,13 446:22 460:6,9 389:8,9 391:12
454:10 454:12 456:17 420:20 460:14 power (1)
participants (1) 457:4 photograph (2) plenty (1) 363:12
451:22 percent (3) 427:9,11 426:25 powerful (1)
participated (1) 419:15,16 photographs (1) PLLC (1) 370:19
367:8 433:20 427:5 336:4 Pozzuoli (120)
particular (5) period (6) pixt sically (2) point (24) 336:13 338:1,3
368:16 422:15 359:15 414:17 M6 365:3 344:11 345:7 338:16 339:16
440:1 451:20 416:1 422:13 piece (2) 346:17,24 339:17 342:2,6
451:22 425:17 440:6 434:3 440:7 352:21,23 342:16 349:14
particularly (3) perjurers (1) pieces (6) 353:5 355:13 353:14,20,24
355:8,9 431:12 349:21 387:10,15 389:3 386:15 390:14 354:2 359:3
parties (13) perjuring (2) 389:5,22 391:3 410:9 360:7 362:2
338:11,11 439:22,23 390:25 420:21 426:20 364:18 369:19
360:24 361:1 perjurious (2) pimp (1) 429:9,10 375:8 377:1
430:25 448:7 407:13 440:16 443:21 438:22 447:20 379:9 382:22
448:24 449:6 perjury (1) pitch (1) 447:25 449:21 383:10,13
449:12 452:13 461:22 338:9 449:25 452:12 384:14,17
453:3 459:16 permit (1) place (4) 456:20 457:9 385:9,13 386:7
460:11 417:3 338:10 340:16 police (14) 388:3,11,18
parties' (1) person (16) 457:10 460:19 3 7:22 357:20 391:24 392:12
459:17 345:7 350:24 places (1) :3,24 437:3 392:16,19
partner (2) 354:20,24 365:3 438:1,14,16 393:8,15,18
338:7 346:25 355:3 372:23 Plaintiff (7) 440:4,12,14 395:5 396:7,15
party (2) 375:23 376:7 337:12 378:19 442:14,17 396:19,23
451:14 453:24 381:11 403:5 393:22 396:11 454:17 397:4,21 398:1
passing (1) 438:8,9 440:1 397:23 400:6 Porter (1) 398:20 399:1
431:25 453:6 454:13 437:6 420:1 399:19 400:11
Paul (4) 454:15 Plaintiffs (3) portion (5) 400:16 401:16
334:4 338:21 personal (5) 334:5 335:2 380:4,20 388:19 402:21 404:19
339:5 347:13 381:4,10,13,15 339:6 396:4405:4 405:1,21,25
penalties (1) 381:18 plane (7) portions (1) 409:3,9,21
461:22 personally (3) 431:10,15,23 433:23 412:12 414:7
pending (2) 376:6 377:9 432:1 433:2 posed (1) 416:17 417:21
360:8 410:20 458:9 441:9,20 423:17 418:16 419:9
people (28) persuade (2) planes (1) position (1) 419:22 421:16
www.phi sr orting.com
421:21 422:2
422:14 423:1
424:10 426:4,7
427:2,22
370:19
preserve (2)
354:3 368:22
President (1)
428:7 429:8,10
429:25 430:2,4
430:5,8,9,11
430:13 435:7
338:12 342:16
421:22 427:23
proceedings (1)
457:21
rovided (4)
M:18 370:6
375:1 443:18
public (8)
428:19 430:16 349:2 435:15,23 process (2) 349:10 351:16
430:23 431:2 Presidents (1) 436:4 442:23 342:11 390:1 416:11,24
431:20 433:10 371:7 446:18,24 produce (3) 417:17 418:22
434:24 436:25 press (7) 447:8,23 392:15,17 418:25 458:16
437:14 438:21 385:1 402:13,16 448:14 449:16 393:16 publication (4)
439:12 440:23 409:16 410:24 450:16,23 produced (6) 373:16,18 376:2
441:13 442:9 411:5,9 451:7,7,21,21 392:13 429:13 376:3
443:1,3,10 pressured (1) 452:7,12 430:22,24,25 publicize (2)
445:10,15,21 344:7 453:14 455:14 440:17 344:18,25
446:1,7,14 presumably (1) 455:15,16,21 product (22) publicly (6)
447:3,20 449:5 376:14 privileged (39) 342:5,14 359:8 365:25 372:3,5
449:13 450:7 presumption (1) 359:7 378:3 359:25 360:3,6 372:7,8 447:17
450:13 451:2 355:15 404: I I 406:5 361:22 369:15 publish (5)
451:17 452:3 previous (3) 408:5,6 415:13 374:18 375:4,6 369:20 371:16
452:21 453:2 406:16421:13 416:8,19 430:4,5,10 372:15,19
453:15 454:1 423:18 417:25 418:6 446:18 450:16 373:19
455:17 456:19 previously (6) 418:24 419:4 450:23 451:7 published (6)
457:9,13,16 357:3 414:13 423:21 426:16 451:21 452:7 371:25 373:6,12
practice (1) 416:17 418:17 427:25,25 455:16 457:6 373:16 427:9
350:4 419:10 423:2 428:2 434:19 production (1) 427:11
precise (3) primarily (1) 435:18,22 391:25 publishing (9)
399:2 428:14,16 441:15 436:3,22 443:6 profession (1) 341:19 366:7
precluded (1) prime (3) 444:25 445:2,6 349:22 368:8 369:10
413:14 371:7 383:16,16 445:9,11,12,24 Professional (1) 369:17,23,24
prefer (1) Prince (3) 446:6 448:16 459:7 394:9 421:6
407:9 394:1 397:6 448:21 449:3,8 professor (5) pulled (1)
preliminaries ... 427:10 450:3 453:17 339:15 376:25 343:7
338:2 prior (6) 456:5 415:9 430:6,6 pure (1)
preparing (1) 357:5 364:10 privileges (1) prosecutor (1) 350:9
390:1 415:1,14,23 423:17 395:20 purport (2)
preposterous (... 416:1 privy (2) prostitution (1) 396:16 406:21
341:10 366:23 privately (1) 341:5,6 442:3 purpose (3)
366:24,25 373:8 probable (1) protected (1) 368:15,18
370:23 377:6,7 privilege (58) 395:22 357:12 395:18
387:4 420:13 360:6 361:22 probably (10) protecting (1) purposes (7)
426:3 363:2,11,14,15 381:15 410:7 449:15 353:21,22
presence (1) 363:20,24 411:4 413:5 prove (6) 395:20 396:16
407:14 379:10416:11 416:7428:22 345:11,13 405:21437:22
present (2) 416:23 417:1,3 437:11 440:12 350:21 351:6,6 452:5
336:12 339:16 417:10,11 440:15 452:18 351:9 pursuant (1)
presented (1) 418:17,21 problem (1) provide (3) 429:20
394:20 419:10 426:25 340:15 367:5 409:22 put (7)
presents (1) 427:1.3.7.8 proceed (4) 417:4 338:4 344:15.25
www.phi sr orting.com
394:14 400:13 419:23 420:25 range (4) received (4) referenced (2)
421:14 450:14 421:20,22,25 351:8 366:15 398:7,8 399:3,6 393:21 405:22
putting (2) 422:15,17,18 371:5 379:23 receiving (1) references (1)
347:23 356:2 423:16,18,20 rape (7) 398:10 441:24
424:2,3,25 356:3,4,6,6,20 recess (2) referring (2)
Q 426:8 427:3,6 357:3,11 375:17 457:20 342:20 411:10
qualified (1) 427:20 428:8 raped (1) recollection (38) reflect (2)
412:8 428:10,12,20 356:8 357:16 359:14 409:2 431:22
qualify (3) 430:17,18 read (16 359:16,18 reframe (1)
379:9 411:23 431:16,21 337:10 n6 367:7 376:1 434:25
443:10 432:12,15 378:10 390:21 382:7,10,11,16 refresh (3)
quashed (1) 433:23,25 401:7 404:7,23 383:6,15,18,25 387:25 388:22
373:7 434:8 435:1,3 404:24 405:8 387:13 388:1 393:9
question (142) 435:6,15 408:13 409:5 388:23 390:9 refreshed (1)
340:12,20,22 437:13,20,24 420:16,18 393:10 395:15 395:16
345:3 347:8 438:23 439:13 460:9,12 395:16 399:2 refuse (1)
348:13,14 439:13,14 461:22 409:23 410:13 364:14
352:15 341:17 440:22,25 reading (7) 414:17,22 refused (5)
360:5,8,11 443:6 444:12 342:3 375:10,11 415:17,19 373:19,23 374:7
361:16,20 445:22,22 404:20,22 432:17 442:1 407:23 409:24
362:3,8,22,24 446:12,13,15 405:4 437:11 444:20 448:9 regard (3)
365:14 367:24 446:21 448:16 really (3) 448:13 449:21 414:11 415:12
368:1 372:22 449:6 450:5,6 354:17 391:20 449:24 455:5 436:19
373:15,24 450:9 451:3,18 442:24 456:7 457:2 regarded (1)
376:12 377:18 451:19,25 Realthne (1) record (23) 438:17
377:20,22 453:11,13,16 334:21 338:5 339:4 regarding (4)
379:10 380:6,7 questioned (1) reason (10) 341:20 348:19 345:19 391:20
380:22 381:22 443:25 340:21 425:6 354:3 356:13 398:5 407:21
381:23 382:21 questions (13) 433:16 434:16 374:11 375:18 Registered (1)
382:25 383:2,9 340:9 342:14 434:18 435:12 382:2 390:21 459:6
383:11 384:8 362:1 363:1 436:5,13 393:4 396:16 REIN (1)
384:10,10,18 377:14 402:1 437:23 461:7 404:7,22,25 335:18
384:19 385:10 421:8,23,24 reasonable (4) 405:5,9,22 relate (1)
385:11,14 451:8 452:14 392:17 403:5 409:2 411:5,6 429:17
386:7 395:4,6 452:20 455:11 425:18 460:12 457:18 459:12 related (2)
395:8 396:5 quicker (1) reasons (3) recording (1) 397:14 403:15
398:19,21 417:14 338:9 365:25 366:9 relates (1)
399:20,21 quickly (2) 366:21 records (6) 359:5
402:5,25 403:9 357:8,25 recall (7) 355:22 357:12 relating (4)
404:23 407:18 quote (1) 344:6 394:4 •:6,13 342:19 345:20
407:20 408:13 367:5 403:22 406:24 359:10 440:16 362:17 365:17
408:18,19 410:10 417:6 recruited (3) relation (2)
_R_ 409:4,5,10,13 441:24 421:3 422:6,23 403:18 447:9
409:22 414:7 raise (2) recalled (2) refer (1) relations (2)
414:10 416:20 339:18 430:1 376:4 420:3 424:14 353:6 379:25
417:12,22 ranch (3) receive (4) reference (1) relationship (9)
418:1218.25 348:5 365:19.20 398:4.6.24.25 411:1 360:12 376:23
www.phi 11 orting.com
377:19 379:6
380:16 381:11
rephrase (1)
340:22
368:22
request (3)
344:23 405:13
response (28)
353:22 370:8
396:4 401:6,24
381:15,19,20 report (9) 370:6 398:5 344:19 347:8,12 449:16 454:18
relative (2) 357:10 437:3,11 457:3 361:9 362:10 459:11
459:15,16 438:14 440:4 requested (6) 370:5 377:17 reviewed (1)
release (1) 440:13,14 403:15 404:17 380:5 400:1 441:8
357:20 442:17 459:8 407:19 416:15 404:7,18 405:7 revisit (3)
relevancy (3) reported (2) 417:2 459:11 405:7,11,12,14 448:3 450:8
353:19 438:3,4 334:20 385:1 requesting (1) 405:20 406:1,7 451:10
relevant (1) reporter (14) 414:4 406:13,14,15 Reyes (3)
417:4 337:9 339:18 requests (1) 406:19,21,23 336:14 349:16
rely (1) 342:11 401:3 403:22 419:12 420:5 349:16
448:22 408:15 409:6 require (1) 437:23 RICHARD (1)
relying (1) 422:18 430:18 355:9 responsive (7) 335:19
418:23 430:20 437:18 required (2) 340:10 380:21 Rick (1)
remained (1) 446:3,9 459:1 355:17 447:25 384:7 385:25 339:7
442:1 459:7 requires (2) 399:20 427:20 right (43)
remember (27) Reporting (1) 360:5 443:6 456:18 339:19 345:2,24
343:4 346:4 460:18 reread (1) restrict (2) 346:2 347:20
366:12 368:2 reports 7 430:17 363:12 383:8 348:22,25
368:12 370:17 337:22 :25 research (3) restricting (1) 350:16 352:10
370:17 376:5 386:20 438:16 350:14 420:18 363:7 360:8 362:21
378:21 379:15 438:20 442:14 432:24 result (1) 363:18 364:25
388:24 390:7 454:18 reserve (4) 344:24 366:2,16,19,23
398:10 402:5 represent (8) 448:1 449:14,17 retained (3) 367:18 373:15
424:4 425:4 346:25 359:23 452:12 415:2,4,15 373:25 378:13
432:10 437:10 389:11,13,14 reserved (1) retainer (2) 384:13,15
443:17,20 444:15 445:6 353:21 415:6,11 389:19 391:13
448:17 449:24 446:5 resolve (1) retired (1) 395:11,12
454:22 455:1 representatio... 448:14 390:15 402:17 411:20
456:10,10,11 359:6 364:11 respect (8) retirement (1) 412:8 421:23
remembers (1) 413:16 414:8 405:8 410:15 390:22 425:13 426:3
383:1 414:11,18 414:19 418:16 retracted (2) 430:7 432:6
repeat (7) 415:1,8,20,23 422:14,16 387:2,6 434:15,20
365:12,13 429:18,20 430:3 452:23 retracting (1) 435:16 439:17
384:19 395:6 449:2 453:11 respond (10) 382:13 439:22 444:7
416:20 422:18 represented (8) 348:14 362:5 return (1) 446:19 452:5
435:25 360:14 373:5 394:24 397:4 460:15 rights (1)
repeated (2) 437:5 438:2 398:11,12,17 returned (1) 452:16
351:3 387:1 444:7,8,9,13 405:19 428:15 460:10 road (1)
repeatedly (7)
348:20 354:24
representing (4)
339:2,6 364:4
438:8 reveal (4)
417:24,25
365:9 402:15 436:15
responded (11)
360:13 402:22 444:25 456:5
403:20 413:9 Reprographic... 403:21 406:6 revealing (3)
433:18
repetitious (1)
339:2
reputation (4)
407:5,11 408:4
408:5,7,10,23
362:25 423:21
450:3
359:2 350:9.25 355:4 responding (2) review (8)
www.phi sr orting.com
353:13
run (1)
436:2,18 440:1
scan (1)
362:22 363:10
363:25 364:20
424:11 426:5
435:8 436:3
374:7 392:7 366:6 368:8 439:13 456:11
Scarola (45) 369:8,16,20,24 section (1)
S 335:3,5 339:6 370:3,7,25 378:16
SAFRA (1) 4 340:13 346:13 372:25 374:1 sections (2)
335:12 347:14 353:18 374:13,16,24 340:5 342:13
5 sanctioned (1) 353:23 370:5 375:15 376:19 see (18)
8 391:5 374:9,25 375:5 376:25 377:13 341:22 343:1
sat (3) 392:25 394:20 378:1 379:2 369:16,22
:4 343:24 360:22 394:23 398:6,9 380:13 381:3 370:3,7,8
:2 384:5 398:18 400:3 382:14,20 378:22 381:2,3
:7 satisfactory (1) 401:14 402:12 383:5 384:12 388:14 391:21
I 405:20 403:19,23 385:11 387:17 392:14 404:1
0 Saturday (1) 404:8 405:10 390:19 392:1,6 405:13 406:7
376:11 405:23 406:9 392:13 393:2 406:13 424:20
saw (7) 406:14,15 393:13,17 seeing (4)
352:2 356:7 408:3,13,17,18 394:3,8 396:6 410:10 429:16
:6 408:9 409:2,8,15,17 400:13,18,24 432:17 441:24
432:9,10,10 409:23 410:12 401:5,9,19,24 seek (1)
saying (39) 410:13 411:2,4 404:4,24 404:13
344:7 346:4,20 429:23 434:7 406:24 408:21 seen (22)
354:13 363:6 445:23 411:1,13 412:3 348:10 350:15
Rodriguez (4) 364:23 367:6 Scarola's (2) 412:23 413:18 372:4 378:18
337:15 378:8,25 368:3,12 406:13 411:3 416:5 417:20 378:21 385:6
379:13 370:17 373:4 schedule (1) 418:10 419:6 385:16,19
room (2) 382:10,11 407:8 421:6,10,18 386:11,14
368:24,25 383:18 385:7 Schiller (5) 423:4 424:6,9 407:13 423:25
ROSS (1) 387:13,19,21 336:8 347:6 424:12,14 427:5,9 429:6
335:14 388:24 390:7 389:10,14 426:6 434:21 429:12 430:20
rough (1) 402:15 403:6,6 391:17 435:21 436:21 431:8,9 432:1
438:18 403:23 408:4,5 Schultz (1) 438:3 440:10 432:13 433:15
Roy (1) 408:7,10 412:1 339:10 441:10 442:5 sell (3)
444:10 425:10,11 scientists (1) 442:19 444:25 353:1 374:5
RPR (4) 427:15 432:4 360:25 447:19 448:20 379:14
334:20 458:15 435:17 439:21 Scott (113) 451:16 452:25 selling (1)
441:6 442:16 334:17 335:9,11 456:5 457:15 372:14
442:24 444:4 338:14 339:7,7 460:2,4 sense (1)
says (21) 340:13 341:18 seal (1) 378:9
rule (1) 364:23 381:17 342:4 343:1,15 355:20 sensitivity (1)
447:25 385:5,17,22 346:22 347:4 Sean (2) 452:11
ruled (4) 386:4 396:20 348:13 351:16 336:14 349:16 sent (5)
347:4 416:18 396:22 405:14 353:10,13 SEARCY (1) 357:14 395:8,13
418:17 419:10 406:4 413:7 354:1,22 335:3 396:25 397:11
rules (2) 423:7,11 425:6 357:22 ■:14 second (11) sentence (1)
340:8 355:8 425:12,20 359:1 360:1 342:3 398:2,2 366:17
ruling (1) 433:16 434:4 361:/1 362:15 403:1 412:13 separate (1)
www.phi 11 orting.com
381:25
separately (2)
401:11,18
September (1)
406:16
serial (17)
343:19 345:21
352:17 353:6
365:5 433:17
433:19 437:22
443:14 455:3
share (1)
336:9 339:9
346:14,16,18
347:14
similar (1)
440:5
simple (5)
349:14 354:8
356:3 :3
365:4 373:4
380:8 381:9
382:6 383:4
425:11 445:5
353:14,20,24
354:2 359:3
360:7 362:2
364:18 369:19
375:8 377:1
379:9 382:22
350:20 351:1,4 381:24 347:7 352:6 446:4 454:6,17 383:10,13
351:5,13,15 Shell (1) 424:4 428:17 soon (1) 384:9,14,17
353:4,8 356:12 356:4 428:22 375:13 385:9,13 386:7
356:25 411:25 Sheet (3) simply (1) sorry (3) 388:3,11,18
412:15 420:11 337:10 460:10 363:2 445:18 391:24 392:12
425:7,21 461:1 446:12 392:16,19
432:21 440:9 SHIPLEY (1) sought (2) 393:8,15,18
series (1) 335:4 413:25 414:14 395:5 396:7,15
452:19 short (4) sounds (1) 396:19,23
serious (2) 374:9 384:16 381:10 397:4,21 398:1
355:2 452:21 419:9 453:15 source (7) 398:20 399:1
serving (1) shortcut (1) single (6) 372:5 377:23 399:19 400:11
433:12 454:14 344:18,21 423:6 388:4 418:24 400:16 401:16
set (3) show (20) 423:10,13 421:23,24 402:21 404: I9
351:22 396:8 343:7,12 345:12 425:20 426:11 405:1,21,25
408:11 345:22 356:11 Sires (1) sources 13 409:3,9,21
setting (4) 378:11,15 346:25 357:18 :12 412:12 414:7
385:14 408:2,16 387:23 388:1 sit (2) 417:19,25 416:17 417:21
409:7 395:15 396:2 367:14 431:18 418:8 427:16 418:16 419:9
seven (2) 397:13,21 situation (1) 427:16,18,24 419:22 421:16
381:8 400:23 399:24 400:4 443:20 428:13 434:9 421:21 422:2
SEVENTEEN... 400:20 411:8 six (7) 434:19 435:25 422:14 423:1
334:1 437:1 440:19 365:3,5 380:23 South (2) 424:10 426:4,7
sex (35) 441:4 381:8 385:21 335:10 460:3 427:2,22
352:9,16,25 shown (2) 391:20 400:22 Southeast (2) 428:19 430:16
365:4,18 367:2 354:19 378:14 skeptical (1) 334:17 338:24 430:23 431:2
370:21 371:2,4 sic (2) 355:1 speak (5) 431:20 433:10
371:10,18 388:7 433:23 slave (4) 368:23 438:11 434:24 436:25
372:3 374:6 side (3) 433:13 434:5 444:24 446:10 437:14 438:21
375:22 377:6 344:18 449:15 454:19,23 450:13 439:12 440:23
382:5 383:4,16 450:2 sleazy (1) speaking (10) 441:13 442:9
383:19 385:18 sign (6) 343:25 341:9,16 343:9 443:1,3,10
385:21 386:12 337:10 395:9 smccawley@b... 362:17 366:12 445:10,15,21
386:17 395:1 397:12 399:10 336:10 368:2,10 369:4 446:1,7,14
399:15 402:14 460:12,14 social (1) 387:8 388:9 447:3,20 449:5
403:10 410:15 signature (3) 360:16 special (123) 449:13 450:7
420:19 433:13 460:7,14,21 socialize (1) 336:13 338:1,3 450:13 451:2
434:5 440:3 signed (4) 376:17 338:8,16 451:17 452:3
441:18 454:19 385:7 386:2 socialized (2) 339:16,17 452:21 453:2
454:23 415:6 458:12 377:10 380:12 341:4 342:2,6 453:15 454:1
sexual (10) Sigrid (6) somebody (15) 342:16 349:14 455:17 456:19
www.phi sr orting.com
457:9,13,16
specific (11)
342:21 352:15
375:23 387:20
422:19 425:11
433:8 438:7,8
438:9,23
specifically (4)
344:3,9,19
345:23 347:10
351:16 352:13
355:24 356:24
367:11 368:15
370:2,14,14,16
370:18 372:6
372:24 373:4,6
419:2,12
421:14 439:9
440:13,16
441:7 442:17
states (2)
342:19 364:6
statute (9)
394:21 395:9,17
stories (2)
372:14 420:13
story (31)
344:18 345:1,1
345:17 347:3
350:12 352:4
353:1,3 354:14
365:1,5,10,15
substance (1)
410:17
substantive (1)
413:6
suffers (1)
366:22
suggest (3)
381:20 427:12
372:1 386:16 373:8,9,16 395:19,24 365:17,17,22 447:21
451:14 454:25 375:21 382:4,9 396:13 397:12 373:23,23 suggested (3)
specifics (1) 382:12,17 397:15 399:11 374:6,7 375:24 355:5,6 398:14
365:24 383:1,3,22 stayed (1) 412:21 419:14 suggesting (2)
speculation (1) 384:22,25 419:25 420:23 421:1 379:24 449:6
380:14 385:2,16 Ste (1) 433:1,21 434:1 suing (2)
speech (1) 386:14,19,23 336:8 440:5,8 394:2 397:7
388:7 386:24 387:1 stealing (3) straight (2) suit (3)
spoke (2) 387:12,19,22 356:12,16 357:4 343:6 344:16 391:16,16,18
366:10 411:4 391:23 393:7,7 stemmed (1) straightforwa... Suite (4)
spoken (2) 394:11,19 436:16 439:14 453:16 335:9 338:24
345:6 372:23 396:17 397:16 stenographic (1) Street (4) 460:2,19
Springs (7) 397:25 402:10 459:13 334:17 335:14 summer (3)
337:17 368:3,10 402:16 409:15 stenographica... 335:18 338:24 425:3,4,5
368:11 388:6 410:3 411:3,23 334:20 459:8 strike (6) supervision (1)
388:16 390:5 413:6,11 step (1) 380:4 384:8 359:20
stand (10) 420:11 424:4 400:18 385:23 397:3 support (3)
341:14 343:11 425:14,20 Stephen (11) 399:18 433:22 418:5 419:2
343:19 344:8 428:4,5,14,16 366:15,22 367:2 strongly (1) 426:18
346:6 347:11 432:20 437:24 367:2,6,8,21 427:11 supports (1)
348:25 355:24 437:25 439:4 368:4 370:22 studied (2) 428:7
356:5 368:12 442:14 450:16 420:14,16 431:15,21 supposed (2)
start (4) statements (48) steps (1) study (1) 347:5 361:16
338:2 340:25 341:1,3,23 351:12 431:7 Supreme (1)
414:9 457:16 342:9 343:2,5 sterling (1) studying (1) 364:6
started (2) 343:8 344:10 350:25 431:6 sure (28)
340:14 414:11 344:14 345:4,6 Steven (2) subject (8) 338:4 341:21
state (10) 345:9 349:4,6 335:12 367:15 399:16 403:15 346:21 350:2,6
345:5 356:19,22 349:7,24 stevensafra@... 407:24,25 361:15 362:5
394:25 395:1 369:12,13 335:12 410:19 423:16 378:11,17
438:19 443:23 370:9,13 stickers (2) 451:6 456:9 384:22,22
458:4,16 459:3 374:20,21 378:13 401:13 subjects (1) 387:25 396:9
stated (4) 375:6,15 STONE (1) 399:13 398:22 400:9
362:2 403:20 386:22 387:2,4 336:9 submitted (1) 402:3 407:5
415:24 461:23 393:5 411:7,9 stop (4) 404:9 410:11,12
statement (82) 411:17 412:10 395:5 402:22 submitting (1) 412:9,9,11
341:8,12,13,14 414:3 416:12 438:22 454:2 399:12 417:23 426:10
342:7,8 343:11 416:24 417:17 store (1) Subsequent (1) 435:3 439:2
343:13.20 418:3.5)/./5 357:5 397:11 453:19 456:12
www.phi 11 orting.com
surfaced (1)
414:24
surprise (1)
415:18
surprised (1)
390:7
target (3)
447:12,15,18
teacher (1)
350:5
339:20 354:23
354:23 356:22
379:15 407:13
413:3 440:22
testing (2)
442:8,10
444:11,18
448:19 453:22
455:19 456:11
456:13 457:1
401:24 404:6
410:6 411:23
413:21 414:8
414:17 416:1
420:2,25
352:3 teenager (3) 433:25 434:2 thinking (1) 425:18 429:1
swear (1) 421:4 422:7,24 thank (4) 417:23 431:24 433:13
339:20 teeth (3) 396:10 400:18 Third (1) 433:18 434:3
Sweder (4) 348:20 350:17 442:12 451:11 436:3 437:12 440:6
335:14,15 351:25 thing (13) THOMAS (2) 443:20 448:9
339:14,14 tell (17) 345:14,19,19 335:11 460:4 449:25 454:20
sworn (1) 341:18 343:5 352:8 381:22 thomas.scott... 457:19 460:7
458:10 349:5 362:19 383:5 387:20 335:11 460:4 460:12
systematically... 363:6,18 393:13 401:8 thought (8) timeframe (2)
433:18 371:10 373:3 420:17 425:23 347:4,12 357:12 424:21 425:3
Systems (1) 376:14,21 426:3 454:9 376:4 390:15 times (4)
334:21 388:25 400:21 things (15) 390:15,22 340:16 351:3
410:23 419:17 345:14 347:22 399:7 412:24 432:9
T 422:10 431:17 351:4 366:25 thousand-pou... timing (1)
tabloids (2) 435:19 390:24 393:20 368:25 414:6
372:14 373:12 telling (11) 398:9 411:24 thousands (1) Tipper (1)
take (19) 363:8 389:13 415:7 418:11 380:2 352:1
338:10 340:16 402:12420:13 420:12,15 three (12) today (11)
349:25 351:12 432:25 435:13 421:13 432:4 343:24 377:13 364:4 369:10
352:14 369:21 436:6,13 440:5 451:10 381:7 389:16 370:8 379:18
374:9,10 378:1 444:3 455:9 think (55) 389:17,24 392:2,4,14,19
385:12 390:20 ten (3) 350:6 354:5 400:22 427:16 412:2 413:3
400:11 401:19 400:23 405:17 357:17 367:23 427:18,24 431:18
401:24 404:4 442:9 369:16 370:7 435:25 436:5 told (8)
410:14 442:5 term (1) 370:18 372:9 thrust (1) 348:4 354:19
451:6 460:6 390:5 373:24 374:25 390:13 355:14 362:25
taken (3) terms (2) 375:1,12 tie (1) 372:8 376:7
349:21 352:5 410:18 443:22 376:10 378:1,3 376:15 445:5 446:5
378:25 terrible (1) 382:8 383:12 time (53) Tom (3)
talk (3) 356:13 384:25 386:18 338:18 340:14 339:7 354:3
344:10 390:4 test (1) 387:20 388:2 344:12,13 419:24
428:2 349:6 389:24,25 345:3,5 346:17 tomorrow (1)
talked (3) tested (1) 391:22 393:2 346:24 352:14 393:16
344:12 395:17 439:8 393:10 394:24 353:5 356:9 Tonight (1)
454:2 testified (3) 397:13 403:5 359:15 367:16 351:17
talking (11) 379:12 423:2 406:9,10 374:12 375:19 top (1)
343:18,18 441:12 408:22409:1 378:1381:13 426:22
349:10,11 testify (1) 410:20 416:25 382:13 385:12 total (10)
353:7 360:10 364:14 423:19,20 386:19 387:9 352:4 400:1,2,2
372:1,11,13 testifying (1) 424:7,9 426:22 387:12 390:14 402:7,10 403:4
420:10 421:10 383:8 427:3,22 431:2 390:17,20 407:18,23
tape (1) testimony (8) 431:25 441:13 391:2 392:7.17 409:25
www.phi sr orting.com
totally (7)
342:18,22 345:9
350:12 357:7
379:23
truth (15)
339:21,22,22
U.S (1)
381:18
Uh-huh (1)
United (1)
364:6
University (1)
versus (1)
338:21
victim (6)
385:8 394:16 365:12,13 402:8 389:15 356:3,4,6,6
touched (1) 368:19 421:1 ultimately (2) unprofessiona... 369:5,5
356:7 422:10,11 349:25 418:21 343:25 355:25 victimization (...
transcript (12) 432:25 435:13 Umar (1) 391:6 369:6
337:16,18 366:8 436:6,14 444:3 360:10 unprofessiona... victims (1)
368:9 388:4,6 455:9 unable (1) 413:11 442:17
396:3 459:11 truthful (2) 357:12 unsworn (1) video (1)
459:12 460:9 341:13 386:2 unblemished (1) 407:6 366:9
460:10 461:2 try (3) 355:3 untrue (2) videographer ...
transcripts (2) 378:13 399:25 unclear (1) 402:11 436:2 336:15 338:17
343:6 375:11 403:3 407:11 untruth (1) 339:1 374:11
transparently ... trying (11) underage (13) 354:19 375:18 457:18
413:9 351:13 352:25 384:6 407:14 upset (3) videotape (2)
traveling (3) 374:5 379:14 429:1 433:2 362:10,12,21 334:10459:9
338:6 431:10 384:12 401:12 434:5,13 436:9 use (3) videotaped (1)
433:2 421:18 440:15 437:22 438:1 401:14 410:21 338:19
Travis (2) 445:18 448:19 440:3,4,20 437:15
336:15 339:1 455:6 455:2 Utah (2)
treated (2) Tuesday (1) undersigned (1) 336:14 349:16
399:6,7 334:15 458:8 N itn1 (2)
V trial (1) turn (1) understand (20) 346:5 420:21
v (2) 350:22 439:20 340:10,21 Vineyard (1)
tried (13) turned (1) 346:12 352:8 460:5 461:3 348:8
350:8 372:15 378:5 352:22 353:20 V.R (4) violates (1)
373:22 402:6 turns (2) 377:7,8 378:12 432:9,9,11 453:13
402:11,13,18 425:14 439:21 378:24 383:11 441:25 violation (2)
402:19 403:7,9 twice (3) 389:16,22 vaguely (1) 389:10 451:20
410:14 417:24 382:21 425:13 396:5 398:15 453:8 Virgin (1)
426:1 439:22 422:11 430:18 validate (1)
Tripp (1) two (20) 452:16,23 420:21
334:17 343:24 345:13 454:5 validity (1)
true (23) 345:15 347:18 understandin... 433:5
350:13,21 351:2 356:20 359:20 379:16,18 variety a353:8 356:15 374:10 381:7 380:11 405:9 357:17 :11
360:15,18,21 384:2,6 389:3 407:20 447:6 399:4
360:23 361:2,4 389:5 400:22 447:10 various (11)
361:6,6,11 414:13 424:7 understands (1) 373:11 384:1
366:20 371:1,1 427:15 444:1 421:20 398:9 410:4
386:25 413:4,5 444:10 456:1 Understood (2) 411:17 412:10
425:15 459:12 456:10 340:18 345:2 419:19,21
461:23 type (1) unequivocal (1) 439:9 441:7
truly (1) 342:12 369:2 455:2
460:16 unfair (2) verbal (1)
U Trump (1) 367:24 39I:22 410:25
mmw.phi sr orting.com
waiving (1) 400:5,8 441:2 willfully (5) 342:5,13 350:15
397:12 442:10 454:11 341:17 343:10 359:8,25 360:3
walk (1) we're (22) 343:20 344:24 360:6 361:22
349:15 345:4 347:5 433:21 369:15 374:18
want (43) 349:6 369:16 willing (3) 375:4,5 430:4
340:16,21 370:3,7 372:11 343:7 365:5 430:5,10
342:17 343:1 372:13 374:10 405:16 446:18 450:16
344:8 345:25 384:11 391:7 willingly (1) 450:23 451:7
347:13,17 391:10,11,15 405:15 451:21 452:7
363:17 368:5 396:7 408:8 wish (2) 455:16 457:6
370:4 377:6,8 438:5 444:11 413:13 460:14 worked (1)
389:22 393:19 449:14 450:7 witness (27) 345:16
400:12,20 451:24 457:17 337:10 339:23 working (1)
401:12,17 we've (6) 343:8 348:16 359:11
404:4 418:8 342:12,12 364:1 354:4 384:10 world (9)
N ill118113 ( 1) 420:23 422:19 378:5 442:6 384:16 388:16 348:21 349:1
349:20 424:14427:13 454:2 396:22,24 351:8 371:7,18
volume (4) 428:1,11,15,15 web (2) 405:24 406:3 371:19 380:2
334:13 337:5 429:23 437:1 443:19,20 407:3 409:18 412:5 420:19
424:6 457:22 437:13 442:5 weight (2) 411:15 417:13 wouldn't (6)
voluntary (5) 446:1 447:22 438:16 442:15 423:19 424:16 357:20 390:11
408:1,16,23,24 448:14 449:15 welcome (6) 427:4 431:25 390:12 408:6
409:7 450:2,2 452:15 346:3 347:9 442:8 444:3 415:18 425:15
voracity (1) 452:22 454:8 394:6,13 397:8 445:12 447:1,5 write (2)
439:8 454:12 397:10 452:17 457:14 390:23 461:2
vote (1) wanted (2) went (1) witnessed (1) writing (1)
352:1 338:4 352:1 456:25 407:1 449:20
vs (1) wants (1) weren't (3) witnesses (5) written (4)
334:6 369:13 347:6 375:3 444:1,2 448:25 344:17 410:24
Washington (1) 436:17 449:12 455:7 411:7,8
W 335:19 West (2) woman (9) wrong (1)
wait (2) wasn't (6) 335:5 460:20 344:1 348:19,20 354:20
340:10,12 368:15 372:7 Wexner (1) 351:1 353:7 wrote (3)
waiting (1) 374:8 388:15 349:3 368:6 370:20 394:23 403:22
427:4 428:22 450:3 whatsoever (1) 441:19 443:18 421:8
waive (12) way (13) 352:20 women (3)
X 395:19,24 398:9 340:13 363:12 whereabouts (1) 359:21 414:13
X (1) 399:4 416:11 374:4 390:6 440:17 456:15
416:22 417:1,2 391:3 399:7 Whichever (1) word (8) 337:1
430:7 460:7,14 401:16 438:24 442:8 341:25 342:25
460:21 442:4445:8 wide (3) 351:1,13
ye  (5)waived (4) 452:5,8 453:10 351:8 371:5 364:23 423:6
399:11 418:22 we'll (13) 379:23 423:10,13 348:25 396:13
450:17 452:8 349:11 367:20 wife (1) words (4) 400:13 416:8
waiver (5) 367:22 369:9 420:2 344:21 370:18 440:17
394:20 395:8,14 376:15 378:13 WILEY (1) 399:3 410:21 Year  (5)
397:20 399:5 393:10 397:18 335:18 work (23) 340:4 341:3
www.phi sr orting.com
2 5
362:7 376:5
414:20
years (5)
457:20
110 (2)
334:17 338:23
17769 (1)
335:18
18 (7)
459:20 460:1,7
461:5
2139 (1)
337:22
455 (1)
459:10
350:25 357:11 12 (3) 337:22 429:2 335:4 459 (1)
399:14 413:24 334:15 400:23 432:16 437:7 226848 (1) 337:9
438:14 461:5 437:18 442:3,4 458:16 460 (1)
Yep (1) 12:00 (1) 19 (1) 23 (1) 337:9
424:19 457:10 433:14 406:4 461 (3)
York (3) 12:30 (1) 1998 (2) 248 (4) 334:13 337:5,10
336:5,5 341:8 457:14 425:3,4 423:23 424:5,13 462 (1)
young (2) 1200 (1) 424:16 337:10
2356:20 441:19 336:8 4th (2)
- 3- YouTube (1) 12th (3) 20 (2) 336:4 397:17
388:14 338:17 458:10 366:4,14 3 (2)
5 460:6 200 (1) 334:13 337:5
Z- 5 (5) 13 (3) 460:19 33156 (2)
zero (1) 337:15 378:20 20006 (1) 335:10 460:3 343:23 349:19
436:1 400:23 335:19 33301 (2) 351:18 360:10
131 (1) 2002 (1) 336:9 338:25 397:19
0 335:14 425:5 334 (3) 50 (2)
02110 (1) 14 (7) 2005 (10) 334:13 337:5 350:25 438:14
335:15 337:16 357:11 359:11,17 388:7 459:10 575 (1)
393:23 398:7 414:20,21 33401 (1)
460:20
336:4 1
1 (4)
337:16 368:3,11
401:2433 :19
460:1
415:14,23
416:2 444:23 33402-3626 (1) 6
6th (2)388:7
1,000 (1)
419:16
1/4/2016 (1)
338:7
1:00 (3)
457:13,15,16
1:05 (1)
457:20
10:20 (1)
374:12
10:22 (1)
1400 (2)
335:9 460:2
14A (1)
401:1
14th (2)
458:12 459:20
15 (6)
337:18 396:12
406:3 424:13
424:18 433:13
15-000072 (1)
334:2
446:10
2006 (2)
359:11 414:21
2007 (1)
359:11
2009 (2)
403:14 421:13
2011 (5)
372:11 373:5,10
403:14 405:24
2013 (1)
403:14
335:5
341 (1)
337:8
379 (1)
337:15
394 (1)
337:16
397 (1)
337:18
398 (1)
337:20
334:17 338:24
7/12/2019 (1)
458:17
74 (3)
378:12,15
379:20
8 (3)
342:25 344:16 4
375:17
10:30 (2)
375:17,19
100 (2)
1500 (1)
338:24
1551 (1)
460:19
(12)
337:16,18
342:25 343:23
344:11 360:10
4 (4)
337:18 350:11
396:24 457:22
40 (5)
399:23
87-page (1)
437:3
8th (2)
419:15 433:20
11 (2)
400:23 405:24
16 (5)
337:20 397:24
398:5,24 399:1
366:4,14 368:3
368:11 396:24
410:7
436:17 437:25
440:4 444:2,3
401 (2)
345:13 406:16
9 (1)
425:4
9:46 (2)
11:59 (3)
334:15 457:19
17 (4)
337:21 400:7,21
401:4
2016 (8)
334:15 338:18
458:11.12
336:8 337:21
438 (1)
www.phi sr orting.com
334:15
9150 (2)
338:19
335:10 460:3
99 (1)
425:4
mmw.phi sr orting.com
EFTA00804328 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Natalia Shavkunova aka Naya [russian girl] casting director, recruiter 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00303504 (Jmail)
 [girls] travel arrangements for Natalia Shavkunova
(date: 2016-02-14)
AMERICAN EXPRESS TRAVEL Document generated Sun. 14 February 2016 19:51:01
Any changes made after this time are not reflected below Page 1 of 3
Travel Arrangements for SHAVKUNOVA/NATALIA
American Express Travel Record Locator HZNVGQ
E-Ticket Number(s)
Agent Details
Centurion Travel Service
2401 W. Behrend Dr Ste.55 M/C 08-03-69
Phoenix Arizona 85027
Toll Free 1-877-877-0987
When Overseas Call Collect 602-537-4000
SHAVK/N
SHAVK/N
Ticket AA 0017751459264-11FEB
Ticket AA 0017752469067-14FEB
Travel Details Tuesday 16 Feb 16
Flight Information
Airline Record Locator HZNVGO
Airline American Airlines
Flight AA32
Origin Los Angeles.
Destination New York.
Departing 02:30 PM
Arriving 10:54 PM
Departure Terminal Terminal 4
Arrival Terminal Terminal 8
Class Y Economy Class
Seats Unassigned
Thank You For Choosing American Express Travel Services
Thank You For Choosing American Express Travel Services
Additional Messages
Los Angeles International
John F Kennedy International
Confirmed
Estimated Time 5 Hrs 24 Mins
Equipment Airbus Industrie A321 Sharklets
Meal Food For Purchase
Number of Stops Non-stop
Baggage NIL
ANY CHANGE OR CANCELLATION OF THIS TICKET MAY RESULT
IN AN INCREASE IN FARE OR ANY AIRLINE IMPOSED PENALTY
PLEASE RECONFIRM YOUR FLIGHTS WITH THE AIRLINE DIRECTLY
AS SCHEDULES MAY CHANGE
24 HOURS PRIOR TO DEPARTURE FOR DOMESTIC FUGHTS
72 HOURS PRIOR TO DEPARTURE FOR INTERNATIONAL FLIGHTS
AIRPORT CHECK-IN REQUIREMENTS -
90 MINUTES PRIOR FOR DOMESTIC FLIGHTS
3 HOURS PRIOR FOR INTERNATIONAL FLIGHTS
PLEASE CHECK WITH CARRIER DIRECTLY FOR SPECIFIC
AIRPORT CHECK IN TIMES
ANY CHANGE OR CANCELLATION OF THIS TICKET MAY RESULT IN A
PENALTY UP TO 100 PERCENT AND BE SUBJECT TO AN INCREASE IN
Page 1 of 3 Itinerary HZNVGO itgi mICAN
EXPRESS
Page 2 of 3
FARE.
TICKETS ARE NON-TRANSFERABLE
Hotel Offers
American Express Travel offers FINE HOTELS & RESORTS properties in your travel destination! Take advantage of your 
Centurion benefits by booking your hotel stay
through FINE HOTELS 8 RESORTS and receive access to these complimentary benefits with each reservation:

• Noon check-In. when available
• Roca Upgrade upon arrival. when available'
• Daily breakfast fa two people

• Guaranteed 4pm late checkout
• Additional special amenity unique to each property, such as a 5100 food and beverage credit or a massage for two 
people"
See Program terms and conditions for additional details at wiewamericanexpress.ccm.11—.
To book your stay. visit americanexpress.comlfhr or call your Travel Office.

• Certain room categories are not eligible for upgrade: call Centurion Travel Service for details
•' Benefits vary by property: can Centurion Travel Service for details.
Optional travel insurance can be purchased at www.allianz.con. Please note, if you make any changes in the future to 
your travel plans. please be sure to update
the
insurance provider.
Travel Information
Al services covered by this itinerary are subject to the terms and conditions specified by the suppliers. Customer 
agrees to the terms and conditions set forth
on any
brochures or advertisements describing any tour, cruise, accommodations, transportation or other services. and to any 
and all conditions contained in documents
for any such
services includng, without limitation. as cancellation and change fees. No employee of American Express and its 
affiliates, subsidiary companies or
representatives has
authority to vary the terms and conditions. Please be advised that certain mandatory hotel-imposed charges. including, 
but not limited to, daily resort or
facility fees. may be
applicable to your stay and payable to the hotel operator at check-out from the property. You may cosh to inquire with 
the hotel before your trip regarding the
existence and
amount of such charges.

• Fntry and Frit Infrirmatinn for Travel
American Express strongly recommends that you periadicaly review www Visncenlral cnrnrnmes for the most up to date and 
accurate entry/exit requirements for your
travel
destnabon. Due to frequent changes. American Express cannot guarantee the accuracy of the information provided and 
expressly disclaims any bailey for any
inaccurate
or incomplete information contained on that site.
• Air Transportation Important airline ticket terms and conditions and other important notices apply to air 
transportation.
Please visit https:firnyamextravelcomistabc/conditions for more information.
Please note that U.S. Federal law forbids the carriage of hazardous materials aboard Swart in your luggage or on your 
person. A violation can result in five
years'
imprisonment and penalties of 5250.000 or more (49 U.S.C. 5120). Hazardous materials include explosives. compressed 
gases. flammable liquids and solids.
oxidizers.
poisons. corrosives and radioactrve materials. Examples: Paints, lighter fluid. fireworks. tear gases. oxygen bottles. 
and radio-pharmaceuticals. There are
special
exceptions for small quantities (up to 70 ounces total) of medicinal and toilet articles carried in your luggage and 
certain smoking materials carried on your
person. For
further information contact your airline representative or visit Please note that U.S. Federal law forbids the carriage 
of hazardous materials aboard aircraft
in your luggage or
on your person. A violation can result in five years' imprisonment and penalties of 5250.000 or more (09 U.S.C. 5120). 
Hazardous materials node explosives.
compressed
gases. flammable liquids and scads. oxidizers. poisons. corrosives and radioactive materials. Examples: Pants. lighter 
fluid. fireworks. tear gases. oxygen
bottles. and
radio-pharmaceuticals. There are special exceptions for small quantities (up to 70 ounces total) of medicinal and toilet
articles carried in your luggage and
certain smokeg
materials carried on your person. For further information contact your aide* representative a visit fir w w 'era 
govcabouh)n uativeshavna• safely"
Liability Statement American Express Travel Related Services Company. Inc. and its parent subsidiaries, affiliates and 
representatives (collectively. 'Amex, act
as an
agent for travel suppliers and you understand and agree that Amex shall not be liable for any loss, injury. expense or 
damage to persons or property resulting.
directly or
indirectly. from (1) the acts of omissions of travel suppliers, including but not limited to delays. overbooking's. 
cancellation of services, cessation of
operations, accidents or
falures of equipment, or changes in fares. itineraries or schedules: or (2) acts of God. fres, earthquakes. floods. 
climatic aberrations. acts of governmental
authorities, civi
unrest. strikes. riots, theft. disease, accidents or failures related to the pubtic internet telecommunications lines or
facitities, a third party technology
systems. or any other
cause beyond the control of Amex.
Intermediary Disclosure Amex assists you n finding travel suppliers and makng arrangements that meet your individual 
needs. We consider various factors in
identifying
travel suppliers to you and recommendng specific itineraries. In this role. we are acting as an ridependent third party 
and not as a fiduciary. We want you to
be aware that
certan suppliers pay us commissions as well as ricentives for reaching sales targets or other goals. and from time to 
tine may also provide incentives to our
travel
counselors. Certain suppliers may also provide compensation to us for various marketing and administrative services that
we perform for them. such as granting
them
access to our marketing channels. participating in marketing programs and supportng technology initiatives. In addition.
we receive compensation from suppliers
when
customers use the American Express Card or other American Express products to pay for supplier products and services. 
From time to time we may enter into other
business relationships with suppliers and these arrangements. ncluding levels and types of compensation and incentives 
we receive, are subject to change. In
identifying
suppliers and recommending itineraries. we may consider a number of factors. including supplier availability and your 
preferences. The relationships we have
with suppliers
may also influence the suppliers we identify and the itineraries we recommend.
CAI IFORNIA., This transaction is covered by the California Travel Consumer Restitution Fund (TCRF) if the seller of 
travel was registered and participating in
the TCRF at
the time of sale and the passenger is located in California at the time of payment. Eligible passengers may file a dam 
with TCRF if the passenger is owed a
refund of more
than $50 for transportation or travel services which the seller of travel failed to toward to a proper provider or such 
money was not refunded to you when
required. The
ran:Ours amount which may be paid by the TCRF to any one passenger is the total amount paid on behalf of the passenger 
to the seller of travel. not to exceed
515.000. A
claim must be submitted to the TCRF wkhin 12 months after the scheduled completion date of the travel. A claim must 
include sufficient documentation to prove
your claim
Page 2 of 3 Itinerary HZNVGO
EXPRESS
Page 3 of 3
and a 635 processeig fee. Claimants must agree to waive their right to other civil remedies against a registered 
participating seller of travel for matters
arising out of a sale
for which you file a TCRF claim. You may request a claim form by writing to: Travel Consumer Restitution Corporabon: 
P.O. Box 6001; Larkspur, CA 94977-6001: or
by
visiting TCRC's website at: wiwricrenfo.org.
WASHINGTON' If transportation or other services are canceled by the seller of travel. aM sums paid to the seller of 
travel for services not performed in
accordance vrith the
ccotraa between the seller of travel and the purchaser will be refunded within Slily (30) days of receiving the funds 
from the vendor with whom the services
were arranged.
or if the funds were not sent to the vendor, the funds shall be returned within fourteen (14) days after cancellation by
the seller of travel to the purchaser
uness the
purchaser requests the seller of travel to apply the money to another travel product andior date.
California CSTS1022318, Washington UBIN600-469-694, Iowa TA1/669.
Page 3 of 3 Itinerary HZNVGO
EX R E SS
EFTA01618370 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2016-02-25 18:41:28)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
2016/01/17
Hey that's to mean hang on me! I am serious about your bday I want to be a part of it!
04:57:45 pm
1212 5333739
Aghhhhh
04:58:17 pm
Thank you for the event! Great family pic but our Jew is missing may be we can
photoshop replacing face w however, not sure if it will fit if she
continues our food madness in palm beach .1!it LI541`. - 45,
05:00:20 pm
Haha just accept it, you can't hide from yourself and definitely not from usal
05:01:08 pm
If that's ok if my gf stay at apt Herself and you need me asap I will come down. Lmk
10:24:16 pm
1212 5333739
its ok,
10:55:26 pm
•
•
2016/01/22
10:52:16 pm
Sneaky I want to buy a coat is too cold here. Which one is better?
10:52:17 pin
1212 5333739
Last one
0
11:09:35 pm
11:12:28 pm
Or this one?
11:12:29 pm
???
11:12:54 pm
1212 5333739
No no no. No black collar
11:13:08 pm
But the one you liked Also black
11:13:44 pin
The goose brand
11:13:53 pin
Or that's different for cost and winter jacket
11:14:19 pm
* coat
11:14:27 pm
11:16:19 pm
11:30:44 pm
Sorry last one
11:30:46 pm

• Or this one?
11:30:48 pm
2016/02/08
03:59:22 am
2016/02/09
Sneaky doggy *a.
02:21:53 pm
1212 5333739
do you want to go with
02:53:49 pm
Trying to reAch you since morning. Who you with sneaky!? t I know! You r so sneaky
while inspector is away
04:03:34 pm
2016/02/12
It's ok taxi is coming in a few min
08:26:28 pin
Taking off
09:01:03 pin
2016/02/15
How was your flight sneaky dog? Sorry I missed you this morning U you should have
woken me up t•
06:00:01 pm
1212 5333739
Never
06:00:15 pm
Sorry went to kitchen I am back!
06:02:44 pm
Call me
06:02:49 pm
Thank you sneaky for checking my homework! *4
06:06:15 pm
2016/02/17
What's happened? Are you ok?
01:40:06 am
2016/02/18
Tried to reach you
01:02:15 am
Hi sneaky would you pls check your emails I sent just one to you. Would you be able to
quickly look at my resume before I send it to
05:00:24 pm
2016/02/20
Why you didn't tell me you were leaving this morning I would come by yesterday I was
going to come this morning and said you left already ti
04:00:47 pm
2016/02/22
Morning sneaky dog, are you awake yet? Wanted to ask your help in physics
05:00:36 am
01:50:13 pm
2016/02/23
How is my sneaky dog doing? Being a good boy? 11.
03:00:31 pm
1212 5333739
No of course not
03:03:17 pm
Haha
03:18:17 pm
How many
03:18:32 pm
Ahhhaaa no longer wonder why is / was in Moscow and you rushed to Paris
04:51:51 pm
1212 5333739
Smart
06:41:28 pm
2016/02/25
How are you sneaky? Saw a dream with you this morning. You had some place I never
been at and we were laughing so much talking about something )
04:32:30 pm
Haha you are so bad?! 4
05:16:54 pm
2016/02/27
Sneaky calling you second day no one picks up
03:17:58 pm
Once again :)
03:34:20 pm
1212 5333739
05:06:45 pm
✓ Sem
Sneaky I forgot to ask about internship if you heard anythin.ie still haven't
reached out to me after I sent resume. I'll try to reach out t' on Monday
05:15:57 pm
•,/ Read
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                 Moshe Hoffman [harvard] behavioral and evolutionary economics 
 Jeremy Rubin [crypto] bitcoin developer/researcher, cashed Epstein checks [dlnews/mit/github] 
          Barnaby Marsh [publicist] co-founder of philanthropy services company Saint Partners 
                                                                  James Ce [tech] tech support 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00293621 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(date: 2016-03-01)
2016 March
Tues. March 1, 2016 LSJ
Reminder:
4:09pm Depart L.SI
6:53pm Arrive NY
9:00pm Appt w/Naya Shavkunova & (Maya
Wed. March 2. 2016 Lifi-NY
Reminder: Music for the car in Paris
11:00am James Ce at the house to work on music for Paris car
11:00 Appt Hatch and Darren
12:30pm LUNCH w/Ehud Barak
1:30pm Appt )v/Michael WoW
2:30pm Haircut at Fekkai Salon with Patrick (  have her hair cut too!)
JOJO TO DRIVE YOU
3:40-5:00pm Appt )v/Leon Black iffiP
5-5:15pm Appt w/Nick Gordon Smith (Tancredi's friend
5:15-7:15pm Appt )v/Penny Baird
(6:06pinMo arrive JFK via Aeroflot#102. Rec. Lace (Carsco Confirm
7:15pm Appt w
Thurs. March 3 2016 NY-Salt Lake-Zorro
Reminder: Jo go to Miami today via Delta 1923 (Rec. Loc81923)
Reminder: Ehud and Nili depart NY in the evening, they are back April 8th afternoon
9:03am Depart NY with Woody and family (Teterboro, Meridian Aviation)
11:31am MST Arrive Salt Lake (Main Airport, Atlantic Aviation)
12:05pm MST Depart Salt Lake (Main Airport, Atlantic Aviation)
1:06pm MST Arrive Zorro
Fri. March 4.2016 Zorro-Salt Lake-N
Reminder: Call John Brockman (office:
1:00pm EST Phone Date Iv/Paul Morris
12:31pm MST Depart Zorro
1:46pm MST Arrive Salt Lake (Main Airport, Atlantic Aviation)
2:24pm MST Depart Salt Lake (Main Airport, Atlantic Aviation)
8:19pm EST Arrive NY (Teterboro, Meridian Aviation)
Sat March 5.2016 NY-CAMBRIDGE-NY
8:30am Depart NY
8:55am Arrive Bedford
Tristar Lim
Confirm Pick up gam
10:00am App! w/Martin Nowak
11:00am App! w/Danny Hillis (
11:45am App! w/Jonathan  Friedlander
12:00pm LUNCH w/Vinceiro Lozzo
2:00pm App! Iv/Seth Lloyd
2:45-4:45pm App! w/Joi Ito and Jeremy Rubin (JoiJoi must leave for airport at 4.4)pm
TBD AFTERNOON Noam Chomsky will come see you in the afternoon
Tristar Limo
Confirm 5pm pick up
5:59pm Depart Bedford
6:46pm Arrive NY
Sun. March 6, 2016 NY
8:00am Breakfast w/Baniaby Marshi llBAGLES
12:30pm LUNCH w/Kathy Ruemmler
3:00pm App! Iv/John Brockman
6:00pm App! w/Jemima
Mon. March 7 2016 NY-PB
Reminder: ack to work today
8:15am App! )v/Dr. for
JOJO TO DRIVE YOU
Make sure Jeffrey's cell phone is filly charged and take headphones!
10:00am Depart NY (fly Meridian Air Charter -Larry organized)
1:06pm Arrive PB, Signature Flight Support
(Jeremy
Tues. March 8 2016 P
Reminder: and have their hair cut today (I:30/2pm) w/Patrick.
Iv/Hubert.
4:00pm Appt w/Dr.
Wed. March 9. 2016 PB
to have highlights
Reminder: to see dermatologist Dr. at 2pm
11:15/11:30am Phone Date wa
Thurs. March 10 2016 PB-LSJ
Reminder: Brice and n holiday March 10-14, back to work March 15
8:24am Depart PB (in the B727)
11:28am STT time (10:15am EST) Arrive LSJ
1: 9 m TT time an  arrive 577' via Delatit465 (Rec. Loc )CarsCo Confirm
2:30Pm STT time (1:30pm EST) Mr. Felix Rey to visit GSJ
Fri. March 11, 2016 LSJ
Reminder: 12 tickets to the "That 1770's Show" in NY for Hasty Pudding institute
Sat. March l2 2016 LSJ
Sun. March 13.2016 LSJ
Reminder: Daylight Saving Time Begins
Mon. March 14. 2016 1.3.1
3:00pm Appt Iv/Erika Kellerhath at STC
Tues. March 15.2016 LSJ
Wed. March 16, 2016 1.3.1
Reminder: Kathy Ruemmler to see Dangene today for a facial at 1pm
8:30am Depart LSI
12:21pm Arrive NEWARK, NJ, Signature Flight support
3:00pm Appt Iv/Rich and Darren
5:00pm SKYPE call iv/Arthur Casas Olive iD:
6:00pm Appt w
Thurs. March 17, 2016 NY-Cambridge-NY
8:00-9am BREAKFAST w/Leon Black at 71st
10:30am Depart NY via Jet Suite. Teterboro, Meridian ail #782IS
11:12am Arrive Bedford, Hanscom, Rectrix Aerodrome
11:12am Tristar Pick up upon arrival, SUV Costirm
Passengers:
John Brockmat
Max Brockman
Nicholas Negroponte
12:00pm Appt w/Moshe Hoffman
75 Amherst, Joi 's offic
'Hamburgers and  Deli Sandwiches will be ordered by Heather, Joi's assistan
12:45pm Lunch wiKevin Ewen (a new faculty member ofJors)Joi's office, i=
75 Amherst, Cambridge,
1:30-2:30pm Appt w/Joi Ito and Tenzin Priyadarshi at the Media Lab, Room'
75 Amherst St Cambridge, MA
Joi:
Heather (Joi's assistant): ffice,
3-5:30pm Celebration of Life Gathering for Marvin Minsky at the Media Lab
75 Amherst St., Cambrid e MA (reception following)
Gloria Rudish: ell
6:30pm Tristar Pick Up SUV Cot firm
7:30pm Depart Bedford, Signature Avia
8:22pm Arrive An: Teterboro, Meridian
Tail#N8SSPT
Fri. March 18 2016 NY
Reminder: folly to Houston via United#1973 at 9:39am Rec. LocM(Carsco#
10:00am SKYPE Call w/Arthur Casas (slcype ID:
11:45am apps we=
1:15pm Appt Iv/Rich Kahn
4:00pm Appt )v/Leon Black
Sat March 19. 2016 NY
Sun. March 20.2016 NY
Mon. March 21, 2016 NY
Reminder: HVAC down at main house at Zorro due to Honeywell Control Install for HVAC March 21-
April 1
Reminder: Rich on holiday March 21-25, back in office March 28
Reminder: Peter Attia in NY March 21-25
Reminder:MM .& to LGA via United #1254 arriving 5:29pm (Rec. Loc Carsca
12:00pm Phone Date w/Ariane de Rothschi
1:00pni=
1:30pm Phone Date w/Wendy Adman
2:00pm Phone Date w/Leon Black (f )
5:30pm Appt Iv/Peter Attia
Tues. March 22, 2016 NY-PB
8:00am Depart NY (Newark ,Signature Avaiton, Boeing 727, N908JE)
10:10am Arrive PB, Atlantic Aviation
Wed. March 23.2016 PB
1:30pm Conference Call iv/Joe Carfagna
Diann:
Pass Code:
2:00pm CALL (remind JE)
Thurs. March 24. 2016 PB
Reminder: office to close half day (day before Good Friday)
9:00am Janusz to tick u in South Beach and drive her to PB house
Fri. March 25. 2016 PB
Reminder: Tancredi Is party for Amelie in Paris
Reminder: Good Friday, office and STC are closed
Sat. March 26, 2016 PB-LSJ
Reminder: to depart Miami at 7:34pm arrive JFK 10:45pm (Rec. LocH,
3:00pm Depart PB
5:15pm Arrive LSI
2:22pmMo depart PB via Jet Blue #1254 arriving JFK 5:13pm (Rec. Loce Carscoa
Sun. March 27.2016 L.S.1
Reminder: Easter Sunday
Mon. March 28. 2016 LSJ-NY
Reminder: Easter Monday, STC closed
4:37pm Depart Ls' 8:3/pm Arrive NY
Tues. March 29. 2016 NY
7:00am Breakfast w/Barnaby Marsh
(2:00pm Jojo had dental appointment)
3-4:30pm Screening of Woody's movie at the Film Center-WALK
575 Park Avenue
ss David Karp,Manel=to attend
6:00pm Appt )v/Andrew Farkas
Wed. March 30. 2016 NY
Reminder:Mrom Pinto's office in NY March 31-April 2
9:00am Appt )v/Dr.
10:00am Appt 111:1r.
2:30pm Appt )v/Rich Kahn
5:00pm Haircut w/Patrick at Fekkai Salon
.1OJO TO DRIVE YOU
7:30pm TENTATIVE Dinner w/Woody Allen and Charlie Rose
(Soon Yi (Chelsie is Charlie's assistant:
Thurs. March 31, 2016 NY
Reminder:Mrom Pinto's office wants to come to the house today and April I" to sit in each room and
imagine the solution!
1:00pm LUNCH wiNicholas Negroponte
3:30pm TENTATIVE Appt w' at Core Club
66 e. 55th street, 6th Floor bet Park and Madison,
5:30pm Urban Detox massage at
5 East 57th Street,
JOJO TO DRIVE YOU!
new spa, Sacred Space
EFTA01110414 (Jmail)
 [crypto] LedgerX was later acquired by FTX for $298 million
(inferred date: 2016-03-29)
LedgerX Options Exchange + Bitcion
Clearinghouse: Series B
Confidential
O March 2016 Ledger% LLC
LedgerX: Regulatory Know-How
Board of Directors
Mark Wetjen
DTCC
Fmr. CFTC Acting
Chairman
Jim Newsome
Fmr. CFTC Chairman
NYMEX CEO
CME Board Member
Tom Lewis
Ameritrade CEO
Green Exchange CEO
Management Team
Paul Chou, CEO
Juthica Chou, President
& Chief Risk Officer
Zach Dexter, CTO
Shabana Paul, CFO &
COO
Kari Larsen, General
Counsel & Chief
Regulatory Officer
Goldman
arks
((',ommanSachs
Investors
Q Combinator Series A Lead
tutorspree
Goldman
0004, Green
VENTURE PARTNERS
Seed Investors
SVAngel
Google
ventures
LedgerX Confidential 1
Money: Before and After
Old Money
MO: Cash in circulation
M1-M2-M3: Commercial bank money
lent via traditional ledgers
Financial institutions manage cash
volatility risk via CFTC-regulated FX
trading
UCME Group
How the world advance:
ice
New Money
MO: Bitcoin blockchain as a
settlement layer
M1-M2-M3: Commercial bank
obligations on top of the blockchain
(via sidechains, smart contracts, etc)
Financial institutions manage bitcoin
volatility risk by trading on LedgerX's
CFTC-regulated options exchange
aedgerX
Currencies targeting moderate inflation
rates can be issued on top of the Bitcoin
blockchain using sidechains technology.
ati IISIIC ISIOloncici. 0
(er  *BARCLAYS
)1‘ CREDIT 3uISSE
© LedgerX Confidential 2
CI What is LedgerX?
Reporting
Regulator
(CFTC)
r1LedgerX
Derivatives Exchange
Trade
LedgerX
Matched Trade
Collateral
$ Customer
'7ILedgerX
Derivatives Clearing )
Bank
USD $
Confidential 3
Revenue Opportunities
Derivatives is a good beachhead: There is meaningful demand on both the buy (merchant processors /
consumer-facing bitcoin companies) and short (miner) side. Also, derivatives are big business: ICE acquired
NYSE in 2012 for $11B, yet NYSE trading revenue (Cash / Spot Trading) is still only — 17% of ICE's total trading
revenue. The remaining — 83% is from derivatives.
The long-term value is in the clearinghouse.
Short-Term
Trading fees (per unit of put/call options contract
traded) from our beachhead market, "institutional"
customers (big bitcoin corporates and miners)
Clearing fees
Settlement fees
Bitcoin volatility index (already developed) —
cryptocurrency equivalent of VIX
License our SEF market data feed
Long-Term
Clear for other exchanges (SEFs/DCMs), especially
traditional SEFs/DCMs that want to let participants
post bitcoin as collateral for other assets
Bloomberg Terminal for Bitcoin
Offer bitcoin futures
Market making on LedgerX exchanges
Spot market making
Retail derivatives exchange
Become the next $3B/year clearinghouse for all
commodities asset types, replacing CME
LedgerX Confidential 4
0 Bitcoin as collateral

• Same asset in every jurisdiction
• Less FX risk — collateral posts within 10 minutes (or 1 minute on sidechains)

• Margin in Europe, Asia and US, using the same collateral, any time
• Bitcoin blockchain is the only battle-tested blockchain, operating on public
Internet 24/7 for multiple years
• CFTC has affirmatively asserted jurisdiction over bitcoin derivatives
• It's the most relevant use case
"Importantly, while there has been a great deal of discussion around implementing real-time
settlement using distributed ledger technology, the current U.S. equity market convention of T+3
is based on laws and market structures. Modernizing current practices and laws to enable real-
time settlement are not dependent on the use of blockchain technologies." — "Embracing
Disruption" whitepa per, DTCC, January 2016
© Ledge rX Confidential 5
5 Bitcoin-as-collateral use cases the LedgerX clearinghouse will implement

1. Out-of-bank-hours collateral posting for any asset
- Reduce counterparty risk
2. "Collateral room" for efficient bilateral netting in uncleared trades
- Reduce the total number of payments

3. Vertically integrate OTC derivatives payment processing
- Replace services like CIS with bitcoin, which delivers even better settlement certainty
through cryptography-enforced finality, and is much less costly to operate and integrate
with than e.g. CLS
4. Realtime margining for FCM Direct Clearing Members and client clearing
- Use multisignature bitcoin wallets for big cost savings for FCMs providing fully
segregated, LSOC client clearing
- Replace quad-party clearing — multisignature wallets provide the benefits without the
costs
- Details available upon request
© LedgerX Confidential 6
5 Ask: Series B Lead
LedgerX is raising its Series B to cover the required Derivatives Clearing Organization (DCO) reserve fund, and
enough operating expenses to achieve cash-flow positive.
We are targeting $30MM pre, $40MM post. Our ask is a $4MM lead check.
LedgerX's technology is essentially complete, and has undergone extensive CFTC review. The reserve/operating
fund is the only major item blocking launch.
© LedgerX Confidential 7
Out-of-bank-hours collateral posting for reducing counterparty risk in uncleared trades
If you're a US shop and you only have access to US banks in USD. A market-moving event happens overnight in your favor.=
like collateral pledged to you overnight, as opposed to beginning-of-next-business-day.
Historical collateral posting hours
Bitcoin collateral posting hours
© LedgerX Confidential 8
5 Replacing inefficient bilateral netting with Bitcoin-based escrow
Bitcoin "multisignature wallets" let multiple trading counterparties in uncleared OTC transactions put collateral in a 
secure "room"
— then after a period of trading activity, withdraw any extra. This prevents over-collateralization, freeing up 
collateral for other
uses.
Before, with cash wires After, with bitcoin multisignature wallets
© LedgerX Confidential 9
Facilitating the collateral use cases: Extensions on top of bitcoin
Unlike R3/DAH/Ethereum, Bitcoin extensions technology is built by the same people who have been developing and running 
the
Bitcoin blockchain 24/7 for multiple years. These are the most capable software developers in the ecosystem. Bitcoin 
extensions
are already live, tied to a source of value (bitcoin), and have additional regulatory certainty.
A "sidechain" is a private extension that can be operated by one or more financial institutions or intermediaries. The 
side part
means that value represented on the sidechain as tokens or assets can be freely moved back and forth with the main 
Bitcoin
blockchain, subject to pre-determined rules set by regulated entities participating in the project.
This means regulated entities like clearinghouses, FCMs and brokers can, right now, use bitcoin to implement custom 
collateral and
settlement technology that follows business rules approved by risk and regulatory oversight committees.
LedgerX is the only company with both the in-depth bitcoin technical know-how and regulatory progress to quickly 
implement
sidechains technology for collateral.
LedgerX Confidential 10
Collateral Posting: Before and After
Before sidechains
Before Bitcoin After Bitcoin
X ACH/wire delay
X ACH/wire delay
Clearinghouse
Futures Commission
Merchant
Exchange
participant
Another 10min,
and txn amount
revealed
10min, but txn
amount revealed
Not OK for a
$100MM trade by
a major player
After sidechains + LedgerX (LX) clearinghouse
Clearinghouse
Futures Commission
Merchant
Exchange
participant
No delay because no
additional transfer —
clearinghouse-as-
sidechain-member
maintains running log of
FCM collateral balances
<lmin; Confidential
Transactions protect
amounts
Also, the LX clearinghouse can use issued-assets to completely revolutionize cross-
margining, which involves collateralizing one type of financial contract with
another.
LedgerX Confidential 11
US Financial System: Before and After
Before Bitcoin + sidechains
Time risk everywhere!
Arrows are collateral and asset transfers
Clearinghouse
Going from exchange participant
to swaps or securities
clearinghouse requires 2
intermediaries and risk-creating
delays
Exchange participant
(aka trader)
Value of underlying assets could
change between cash settlement
(from clearinghouse) and delivery
(to exchange participants)
ACH Clearinghouse
After Bitcoin + sidechains + LedgerX clearinghouse
Bitcoin
Main Chain
Bank consortium node(s)

• Participating bank> can let their
customers post collateral to swaps
and securities clearinghouses
within minutes - a huge boon for
deposits
LX Commodities/Swaps
Clearinghouse

• heals clearing requirement -
Dodd-Frank req that certain
swaps transactions in the US are
cleared by a licensed
clearinghouse

• Reports swaps transactions to
Swap Data Repositories, as
required by law, before signing
blocks containing them
Circle of Economic Profit
for Sidechain Members
- Each node can be a
functionary, or run its
own sidechain
- Everyone in the old
system experiences
competitive
disadvantages and is
forced to switch
ACH Clearinghouse
• Relines to ssn b'otks II AMLiKYC
chrci>lail
Securities/Stocks
Clearinghouse
• Fulfills requirement to clear
securities transactions through
SEC-licensed clearinghouse
LedgerX Confidential 12
Are US Financial Institutions Solvent? Before and After
Before Bitcoin + sidechains
????? Unclear
Counterparty
obligations
Government can't
analyze cross-
clearinghouse
financial exposure of
market participants
Clearinghouse
Currently there is no
system to analyze
counterparty
exercise chains,
cross-clearinghouse,
to find the riskiest
default events
Without a top -down
view of the riskiest
default chains,
individual shops
(hedge funds,
traders, banks) have
no idea what their
true exposure is
After Bitcoin + sidechains + LedgerX clearinghouse
Bitcoin
Main Chain
Legally-mandated Swap
Data Repository
LX clearinghouse sidechain
At the clearinghouse level,
regulators rely on the legally-
mandated reports containing
the outstanding obligations for
each market participant.
Issued-assets means
clearinghouses can use these
reports to construct a
comprehensive picture of all
outstanding obligations for any
asset:
Issued-assets for title
transfer of physically-settled
financial contracts
- Issued-assets for cash
settlement of cash-settled
financial contracts
- Bitcoin for btc-settled
contracts (e.g. hashrate
derivatives for miners;
options on bitcoin)
If you can see all obligations,
you know whether the
system is solvent.
LedgerX Confidential 13
0 Disclaimers
The information contained herein is confidential and proprietary information of NYBX Inc. ("LedgerX" or the "Company"). 
By accepting
such information, each recipient agrees that it will, and will cause its directors, officers, employees and 
representatives to, use such
information only to evaluate LedgerX's information and not for any other purpose and will not divulge any such 
information to any other
party. Any reproduction of such information, in whole or in part, is prohibited unless permitted in writing by an 
authorized representative
of LedgerX. Circulation must be restricted accordingly.
This presentation contains forward-looking statements that are subject to risks and uncertainties, which could cause 
actual results to
differ materially from those anticipated. The results or developments anticipated by management may not be realized or 
even if realized,
may not have the expected consequences to, or effects on, LedgerX or the Company's business prospects, financial 
condition or results of
operations. Readers are cautioned not to place undue reliance on these forward-looking statements in making any 
investment decision.
The information within this presentation has been compiled by LedgerX for general purposes only. LedgerX assumes no 
responsibility for
any errors or omissions. Additionally, the above information is provided for explanation purposes only, and should not 
be considered
investment advice or the results of actual market experience. This communication is not a recommendation to buy, sell or
retain any
specific investment.
Derivatives and bitcoin trading is not suitable for all investors and involves the risk of loss. LedgerX products and 
platforms are subject to
regulatory oversight and approval. All references to specifications herein are made subject to and are superseded by 
official LedgerX
rules. Current rules should be consulted in all cases concerning contract specifications.
LedgerXTM is a trademark of NYBX Inc. All other trademarks are held by their respective owners.
© LedgerX Confidential 14
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                         Ronald Eppinger [crime] Virginia Giuffre's first trafficker 
                         Gwendolyn Beck [employee] Epstein fund manager in the 90s, ran for Congress 
                                                                      Rinaldo Rizzo [employee] (???) 
 James Patterson [journalist] pulp fiction author, wrote a book about Epstein with Steven Hoffenberg 
                      Peter Listerman [modeling] Russian model scout and self-described "matchmaker" 
                                                   Ross Gow [publicist] Acuity Reputation Management 
                                  Laura A. Menninger [victim lawyer] Haddon, Morgan and Foreman P.C. 
             Stanley Pottinger [victim lawyer] Virginia Giuffre legal team while working for Epstein 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01182998 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in Virginia Giuffre v. Ghislaine Maxwell
EFTA01299550 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2016-03-31)
RPTXD: MBS010D0
DATE: 04/04/2017
ACCOUNT RR I/O C/W DESCRIPTION
INCOMING/OUTGOING WIRES,CHECKS AND ACH REPORT PAGE: 1
IBD: 610 OFF: N4G
ADDITIONAL INFO BENEFICIARIES
ISSUER/0AM
NET AMOUNT
ENJ 0 W
ENJ 0 W
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERIC
NEW YORK NY
SILICON VALLEY BANK
SANTA CLARA CA
6X
SOUTHERN TRUST
COMPANY INC CAPITAL
CALL 6X
ENJ I w / HSBC BANK USA,
HSBC BANK USA, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION NATIONAL
1800 TYSONS BLVD
MC LEAN VA 22102
000180807
HSBC SECURITIES SERVICES (IRELAND)
DAC
1 GRAND CANAL SQUARE, GRAND CANAL
HARBOUR DUBLIN 2, IRELAND
ASSOCIATION1800
TYSONS BLVD MC LEAN
VA 22102
VOID
/1111F/PERSHINOLLCHBRK
ASSOCIATES30
//1866THSTREET1OFDAS
SEF9001CBVE4L8B
ENJ I W / DEUTSCHE BANK 345
STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMPANY PARK AVENUE NEW YORK
1 LINCOLN ST FL 1 NY 10154
BOSTON MA 02111 VOID
33451370.1 /REC/PERSHING LLC
RANDOLPH BROWN)
1284 BLUE HILL CREEK DRIVE
MARCO ISLAND FL 34145
ENJ 0 W
THE BOSTON PRIVATE BK. i TR CO
BOSTON NA
ENJ 0 W
JSP I W /
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY
AMERICAS
60 WALL STREET
37983653
37983653 - HOWARD G LEPOW
SALLY LEPOW 6 E 79TH ST APT 8 NEW Y
ORK NY 10021
165 SAGO PALM ROAD
VERO BEACH
FL32963-3702 6X
AUTHORIZED DEBIT
1132741729PERSHINO
0210000184932
29 000004
BKTRUS33PWM
VOID
/REC/PERSHING LW
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC
44129244
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
3301520427
impipERsH/QQL/rmnowscsOCIATES30
//1866THSTREET1OFDASREF9001CSVE4L8B
THE HAZE TRUST TN
280009201 RED TD 31MAR16 KS LP C
P-075C KING STREET CAPITAL LP
11313599201
HSBC BANK USA, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
RANDOLPH aware+ 2013 LIVING TRUST
FFC: ACCT
BUY CUST RRN - 0000000108531006
RANDOLPH BROWN 2013 LIVING TRUST
FFC: ACCT -
BUY GUST RAN - 0000000108531006
STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMPANY
JW CH/LDS ASSOCIATES LP
405 4915
HOWARD LEPOW
US
NO ORIGINAL LETTER. THIS IS TO
COVER A FX TRADE IN THE SAME NAME
BROKERAGE ACCOUNT.
BUY CUST RRN - 0/B DBTCO AMERIC
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY
1500000.00
2500000.00
2137874.15
30000.00
100000.00
1000.00
107200.00
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(fc ONFIDENTIAL
SIDNY_GM_00065570
DB-SONY-0028395
RPTID: MBS01000
DATE: 04/04/2017
ACCOUNT RR I/O C/W DESCRIPTION
INCOMING/OUTGOING WIRES,CHECKS AND ACH REPORT PAGE: 2
IBD: 6XE OFF: N4G
ADDITIONAL INFO BENEFICIARIES
ISSUER HAM
NET AMOUNT
L1A 0 W
SYNOVUS BANK
COLUMBUS
L1A I W /
REF: DANIELS
ADDRESS: 12
GA EVERGREEN WAY
PAWLING NY
12564-1328 6X
STATE STREET SANK AND TRUST COMPANY
1 LINCOLN ST FL 1
BOSTON MA 02111
33451922.1
TRUST U/0/0 MARVIN GLICKMAN F/B/O J
27 HOLLY DRIVE
NEW ROCHELLE NY 10801
DEUTSCHE BANK 345
PARK AVENUE NEW YORK
NY 10154
VOID
/REC/PERSHING LLC
THE LAN OFFICE OF PAULA M. KILGORE
LLC
1003335674
TRUST U/W/O MARVIN GLICKMAN JONG
OLFIC: ACCT
BOY COST RRN - 0000000108530730
TRUST U/W/O MARVIN GLICKMAN JOHN
GLFFC: ACCT
BNY CUST RRN - 0000000108530730
163500.00
5.10
STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMPANY
L1A 0 C CHECK IRIMBER - 3616 22500.00
L1A 0 C
40285459000000000000
0006010 04
CHECK NUMBER - 1675 65000.00
L1A 0 C
40285460000000000000
0006010 04
CHECK NUMBER - 0106 500.00
L1A 0 C
40272652000000000000
0006010 04
CHECK NUMBER - 0107 500.00
L1A 0 W
40272651000000000000
0006010 04
AUTHORIZED DEBIT 1100.00
L1A 0 W
0005000008AMEX EPAYM
Err
0910000186836
09 000004
AUTHORIZED DEBIT 3459.05
270283316 Novolpay
1222872556229
40 000004
stn. I N / HSBC BANK USA, /BNF/PERSHINOLLCHARVEYSGETTLESON 1251.51
HSBC BANK USA, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION NATIONAL //9350WILSHIREBLVDSUITE400DASREF903
1800 TYSONS BLVD
MC LEAN VA 22102
000180807
HSBC SECURITIES SERVICES (IRELAND)
DAC
1 DRAW CANAL SQUARE, GRAND CANAL
HARBOUR DUBLIN 2, IRELAND
ASSOCIATION1800
TYSONS BLVD MC LEAN
VA 22102
VOID
/BICF/PERSHINGLICENURV
EYSGETTLESON
//9350WILSHIREBLVDSU
ITE400DASREF903//7CB
V14L8B
//709VE4L813
040000220 LEXINGTON PORTFOLIO I TN
279590401 RED TD 01MAR16 KS LP
ORPHAN P-346 KING STREET CAPITAL LP
N313602801
HSBC BANK USA, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(fc ONFIDENTIAL
DB-SDNY-0028396
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                     JSC Interiors [epstein] Epstein company 
                                     Larry Gagosian [arts] famous art dealer 
 Stewart Oldfield [bank] worked on Epstein related accounts at Deutsche Bank 
        Third Lake [finance] family office managing the Wanek family fortune 
  Hillspire LLC [tech] Eric Schmidt family office of Google CEO Eric Schmidt 
                        Philippe Laffont [tech] founder of Coatue Management 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01478313 (Jmail)
 [money] list of investments (maybe of Leon Black)
(date: 2016-03-31)
> 75% Pipeline
Opportunity Name Relationship Name Customer Name Close Date (%) Product Name
Actual Assets Structure BPS/Flat Fee Actual Revenue Sales Team Member Estimated Mo
nth 8 2015 Est 2016 Rev Est 2017 Rev
Banking ELYSIUM MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Black, Leon D. 3/31/2016 90 Private Wealth Premi
um Checking 25000000 BPS 40 100000 0 IF(H2="BPS",J2*(L2/12),J2)=0 IF(H
2="BPS",J2,0)=100000
Brokerage THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP WANEK TRUST OF 2000 3/31/2016 90 Brok
erage (Commissions) 5000000 BPS 5 2500 Morris 0 IF(H3="BPS",J3*(L3/12),J3)=0
IF(H3="BPS",J3,0)=2500
JTWROS Brokerage THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Wanek, Karen A. 3/31/2016 90 Brok
erage (Commissions) 5000000 BPS 20 10000 Morris 0 IF(H4="BPS",J4*(L4/12),J4)=0
IF(H4="BPS",J4,0)=10000
Real Estate Opportunity 54 MADISON PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 54 Madison Partners 3/31/2016
75 U.S. Structured Lending (Secured) 150000000 BPS 550 12000000 Morr
is 0 0 J5=12000000
KCP ELYSIUM MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Black, Leon D. 3/31/2016 75 Brokerage (Commissio
ns) 50000000 BPS 5 25000 Morris 0 0 J6=25000
Credit Facility GENERAL ATLANTIC FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP General Atlantic Family Office 3/31
/2016 75 U.S. Letter of Credit 150000000 BPS 200 3500000 IF(H22="BPS",J22*(L7
/12),J22)=0 J22=0
Goldrush MEISTER, TODD RELATIONSHIP Meister, Todd 6/30/2016 75 U.S. Structu
red Lending (Secured) 90000000 BPS 1235 13365000 0 0 J8=13365000
Deposits MEISTER, TODD RELATIONSHIP Meister, Todd 3/31/2016 75 Private Weal
th Premium Money Market 10000000 BPS 35 35000 Morris 0 IF(H9="BPS",J9*(L9/1
2),J9)=0 IF(H9="BPS",J9,0)=35000
KCP Private Markets ORIX RELATIONSHIP ORIX Corporation 3/31/2016 75 Priv
ate Equity Funds 10000000 Flat Fee 400000 400000 Morris 0 IF(H10="BPS"
,J10*(L10/12),J10)=400000 J10=400000
Structured Credit PARAMI CAPITAL MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Vaid, Rahul 6/30/2016 75
U.S. Secured Lending (Lombard) 50000000 BPS 300 1500000 Oldfield 0 IF(H
11="BPS",J11*(L11/12),J11)=0 IF(H1l="BPS",J11,0)=1500000
Deposits PARAMI CAPITAL MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Parami Capital Management 3/31/2016
75 Private Wealth Premium Money Market 10000000 BPS 35 35000 Morris 0
0 J12=35000
Airplane Loan SAPIR, TAMIR RELATIONSHIP Sapir, Tamir 3/31/2016 75 U.S. Structu
red Lending (Secured) 10000000 BPS 200 200015 Morris 0 IF(H13="BPS",J13*(L1
3/12),J13)=0 IF(H13="BPS",J13,0)=200015
Falcon Trail Capital, LLC 3/31/2016 75 Deri
200 100000 Morris 0 0 J14=100000
Falcon Trail Capital, LLC 3/31/2016 75 Deri
200 100000 Morris 0 IF(H15="BPS",J15*(L15/12),J1
CLO 2 SK FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP
vatives (Equity - Swap) 5000000 BPS
CLO 5K FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP
vatives (Equity - Swap) 5000000 BPS
5)=0 IF(H15="BPS",J15,0)=100000
Structured Notes SK FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP SK Family Office 3/31/2016
Structured Notes S Deposits (Equity) 3000000 Flat Fee 45000 45000
Loan SK FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP SK Family Office 3/31/2016 75 U.S.
red Lending (Secured) 5000000 BPS 200 100000
Brokerage SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP Gratitude America 3/31/2016 75
erage (Asset -Based Fees) - Advisor Select 10000000 BPS 20 20000
Additional Banking SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP Southern Financial LLC 3/31/2016
Private Wealth Premium Checking w/Interest 50000000 BPS 20 100000
SUM(G2:G19)=6.43E8 SUM(J2:J19)=31637515 SUM(M2:M19)=400000 SUM(N2:N19)=27872515
Structu
Brok
Full Pipeline
Opportunity Name Relationship Name Customer Name
Actual Assets Structure BPS/Flat Fee Actual Revenue
Real Estate Opportunity 54 MADISON PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP
75 U.S. Structured Lending (Secured) 150000000
art Oldfield
Introduction ANNANDALE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Annandale
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction ARDEN ASSET MGMT RELATIONSHIP Arden Asset
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
KCP Private Markets ASPEN GROVE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Aspen Grove Capital, LLC
/2016 25 Brokerage (Commissions) 15000000 BPS 5 7500 Paul Morris
Introduction BAKHSHANDEHPOUR, SAM RELATIONSHIP Bakhshandehpour, Sam 2/29/2016
Private Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Lending BASQUTAT RELATIONSHIP Estate of Gerard Basquiat 3/31/2016
red Lending (Secured) 50000000 BPS 100 500000 Paul Morris
Structured Lending BENEFIT STREET PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP Benefit Street Partners
25 U.S. Structured Lending (Secured) 30000000 BPS 100 300000
KCP Private Markets BLUE MOUNTAIN RELATIONSHIP Greatrex, Peter 3/31/2016
erage (Commissions) 25000000 BPS 5 12500 Paul Morris
Credit Line BLUE MOUNTAIN RELATIONSHIP Blue Mountain Capital Management, LLC
25 U.S. Letter of Credit 50000000
HF Secondaries BLUESTEM LLC RELATIONSHIP
O Stewart Oldfield
KCP Private Markets BOMMER, SCOTT RELATIONSHIP SAB Capital Management, LP
25 Brokerage (Commissions) 35000000 BPS 5 17500 Paul Morris
Deposits BOMMER, SCOTT RELATIONSHIP Bommer, Scott 3/31/2016 10
th Premium Checking 25000000 BPS 40 100000 Paul Morris
Residential Mortgage BOMMER, SCOTT RELATIONSHIP Sommer, Scott 3/31/2016
dard Mortgage - 5/1 Arm 25000000 BPS 100 250000 Paul Morris
Introduction BRACK CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Brack Capital 3/31/2016
th Premium Money Market 0 Paul Morris
Introduction BRIGHT GROUP RELATIONSHIP Bright Group 3/31/2016
th Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Banking BRONFMAN, EDGAR RELATIONSHIP Bronfman, Edgar 3/31/2016 10
um Checking w/Interest 25000000 BPS 40 100000 Paul Morris
Muni Portfolio CAVALRY RELATIONSHIP Cavalry Portfolio Services, LLC 3/31/2016
al Select - Fixed Income 25000000 BPS 50 125000 Paul Morris
Banking Account CAVALRY RELATIONSHIP Cavalry Portfolio Services, LLC 3/31/2016
ate Wealth Premium Checking 50000000 BPS 40 200000 Paul Morris
Brokerage CAVALRY RELATIONSHIP Cavalry Portfolio Services, LLC 3/31/2016
erage (Commissions) 10000000 BPS 5 5000 Paul Morris
Custody CFM RELATIONSHIP Capital Fund Management 3/31/2016 10 Onshore
Stewart Oldfield
Introduction CFM RELATIONSHIP Comprehensive Financial Management 3/31/2016
Private Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
KCP/ Private Markets COLLIS, CHARLES RELATIONSHIP EverWatch Financial 3/31/2016
Private Equity Funds 5000000 Flat Fee 200000 200000 Stewart Oldfield
Brokerage
ommissions)
Share Collars
ommissions)
Introduction
um Money Market
HF Secondaries
Close Date (%) Product Name
Sales Team Member
54 Madison Partners 3/31/2016
BPS 550 12000000 Stew
Capital
Mgmt
3/31/2016 0
3/31/2016 0
10 U.S
Priv
Priv
3/31
Structu
3/31/2016
Paul Morris
50 Brok
3/31/2016
BPS 100 500000 Paul Morris
Bluestem LLC 3/31/2016 25 Hedge Funds
3/31/2016
Private Weal
10 Stan
O Private Weal
O Private Weal
Private
CROSS, LISA RELATIONSHIP Cross, Lisa 3/31/2016 10
75000000 BPS 5 37500 Paul Morris
CUMMINGS, IAN RELATIONSHIP Cummings, Ian 3/31/2016
5000000 Flat Fee 250000 250000 Paul Morris
CV STARR RELATIONSHIP CV Starr 3/31/2016
0 Stewart Oldfield
DELL, MICHAEL RELATIONSHIP Dell, Michael S. 3/31/2016
e Funds 0 Paul Morris
Introduction DOCK STREET CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Dock Street Capital 3/31/2016 0
Private Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Deposits DONALD BRYANT JR. RELATIONSHIP Bryant Jr., Donald 3/31/2016 10 Priv
ate Wealth Premium Checking w/Interest 10000000 BPS 40 40000 Paul Morris
Loan DORRANCE FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Dorrance Family Foundation 3/31/2016 0 U.S.
Structured Lending (Secured) 200000000 BPS 100 2000000 Stewart Oldfield
Cash management DORRANCE FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Dorrance Family Foundation 3/31/2016 0
Private Wealth Premium Money Market 20000000 BPS 30 60000 Stewart Oldfield
Private Equity DORRANCE FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Dorrance Family Foundation 3/31/2016 0
Private Equity Funds 0 Stewart Oldfield
Margin Loan DORRANCE FAMILY RELATIONSHIP DF Enterprises 3/31/2016 0 U.S. Secured
Lending (Lombard) 250000000 BPS 65 1625000 Stewart Oldfield
Land Loan DORRANCE FAMILY RELATIONSHIP DF Enterprises 12/31/2016 0 U.S. Structu
red Lending (Secured) 100000000 BPS 600 6000000 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction DUNCAN INVESTMENTS RELATIONSHIP Duncan Investments 3/31/2016 0 Priv
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Retirement Plan ELLIN, HOWARD RELATIONSHIP Ellin, Howard 9/30/2016 10 U.S. IA - Ba
lanced 1000000 BPS 60 6000 Paul Morris
Banking ELYSIUM MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Black, Leon D. 3/31/2016 90 Private Wealth Premi
um Checking 25000000 BPS 40 100000 Paul Morris
KCP ELYSIUM MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Black, Leon D. 3/31/2016 75 Brokerage (COmmiSSiO
ns) 50000000 BPS 5 25000 Paul Morris
Cash Management ELYSIUM MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Elysium Management 3/31/2016 50 U.S.
Wealth Premi
10 Glob
10 Priv
10 Brok
Custody 0
Brokerage (C
10 Brokerage (C
0 Private Wealth Premi
10 Hedg
IA - RCM 50000000 BPS 25
Art Lending ELYSIUM MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP
red Lending (Secured) 250000000 BPS
Proxy Hedge ELYSIUM MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP
vatives (Equity - Option) 250000000
Introduction ELYSIUM MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP
th Premium Money Market 0
Deposits ERGEN, CHARLES
th Premium Checking w/Interest
Brokerage ERGEN, CHARLES
ommissions) 50000000
Credit Line ERGEN, CHARLES
red Lending (Secured) 300000000 BPS 100 3000000 Paul Morris
Lending FALLLINE RELATIONSHIP FallLine 3/31/2016 25 U.S. Structured
ured) 100000000 100 0 Stewart Oldfield
Custody FALLLINE RELATIONSHIP FallLine 3/31/2016 10
10 1000000 Stewart Oldfield
Lending FITZGIBBONS, JOHN RELATIONSHIP Deerpath Capital Management
Letter of Credit 30000000 BPS 100 300000 Paul Morris
Airplane Loan FITZGIBBONS, JOHN RELATIONSHIP Fitzgibbons, John 3/31/2016
Structured Lending (Secured) 10000000 BPS 100 100000 Paul Morris
Structured Credit FITZGIBBONS, JOHN RELATIONSHIP Fitzgibbons, John 3/31/2016
U.S. Letter of Credit 50000000 BPS 200 1000000 Paul Morris
Residential Mortgage FITZGIBBONS, JOHN RELATIONSHIP Fitzgibbons, John 3/31/2016
Standard Mortgage - Floating Arm 4000000 BPS 100 40000 Paul Morris
Commercial Mortgage FITZGIBBONS, JOHN RELATIONSHIP Fitzgibbons, John 3/31/2016
Commercial Real Estate 5000000 BPS 100 50000 Paul Morris
Introduction FORRESTAL CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Forrestal Capital LLC 3/31/2016
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Deposits GAGOSIAN, LARRY RELATIONSHIP Gagosian, Larry 3/31/2016
th Premium Checking w/Interest 25000000 0 Paul Morris
Brokerage GASLOW, LAWRENCE RELATIONSHIP Gaslow, Peter 3/31/2016
ommissions) 25000000 BPS 5 12500 Paul Morris
Credit Facility GENERAL ATLANTIC FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP General Atlantic Family Office
/2016 75 U.S. Letter of Credit 150000000 BPS 200 3500000 Paul Morris
Secondary CLOs GENERAL ATLANTIC FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP General Atlantic Family Office
/2016 50 Structured Notes & Deposits (Equity) 5000000 Flat Fee 200000 200000
Morris
Rated Infrastructure Notes
ily Office 3/31/2016
90000 90000 Paul Morris
Brokerage GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY RELATIONSHIP
50 Brokerage (Asset -Based Fees) - Advisor Select
Stewart Oldfield
Brokerage GERSCHEL, PATRICK RELATIONSHIP Gerschel, Patrick 3/31/2016
erage (Commissions) 15000000 BPS 5 7500 Paul Morris
Introduction GRANITE GROUP RELATIONSHIP Granite Group Advisors 3/31/2016
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction HIGHLANDER PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP Hirsch, Lawrence
Private Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Referall Fees HUDIBURG RELATIONSHIP Sullivan, Hardin 3/31/2016 0 Referral Fee
O Stewart Oldfield
Brokerage HYMAN, ED RELATIONSHIP Hyman, Ed 3/31/2016 10 Brokerage (Commissio
ns) 20000000 BPS 5
Introduction ILLIG, CLIFF RELATIONS 3/31/2016 0 Priv
Paul Morris
RELATIONSHIP
RELATIONSHIP
BPS 5
RELATIONSHIP
125000 Paul Morris
Black, Leon D. 9/30/2016 50
100 2500000 Paul Morris
Elysium Management 3/31/2016
BPS 100 2500000 Paul Morris
AP Investco LLC 3/31/2016 0
Ergen, Charles 3/31/2016 50
BPS 40 200000 Paul Morris
Ergen, Charles 3/31/2016 25
25000 Paul Morris
Ergen, Charles 3/31/2016 10
Onshore Custody
3/31/2016
U.S. Structu
10 Deri
Private Weal
Private Weal
Brokerage (C
U.S. Structu
Lending (Sec
1.0E9 BPS
10 U.S.
10 U.S.
0 Priv
25 Private Weal
50 Brokerage (C
3/31
3/31
Paul
GENERAL ATLANTIC FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP General Atlantic Fam
50 Structured Notes & Deposits (Equity) 3000000 Flat Fee
Georgetown University Endowment 3/31/2016
25000000 Flat Fee 100 100
25 Brok
0 Priv
3/31/2016 0
10000 Paul Morris
HIP Rock Island Capital
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction ILLIG, CLIFF RELATIONSHIP Sporting KC
th Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Referral Fees ILLIG, CLIFF RELATIONSHIP Illig, Cliff
O Stewart Oldfield
Introduction IRONSIDES ASSET MGMT RELATIONSHIP Ironsides
Private Wealth Premium Money Market 0
Real Estate Financing ITAFIN RELATIONSHIP
eal Estate 25000000 BPS 120
Banking JAIN, NEIL RELATIONSHIP Jain, Sunil
ing w/Interest 25000000 BPS 40 100000 Paul Morris
KCP Private Markets JAIN, NEIL RELATIONSHIP Jain, Neil 3/31/2016
ommissions) 15000000 BPS 5 7500 Paul Morris
HF Secondaries JL SQUARED GROUP RELATIONSHIP JL Squared Group
e Funds 10000000 0 Stewart Oldfield
Structured Credit KIM, STEVEN RELATIONSHIP Kim, Steven
Structured Lending (Secured) 50000000 BPS 100 500000
Deposits LAFFONT, PHILPPE RELATIONSHIP Laf font, Philppe
ate Wealth Premium Checking 25000000 BPS 40 100000 Paul Morris
Mortgage LAFFONT, PHILPPE RELATIONSHIP Laf font, Philppe 3/31/2016 25
dard Mortgage - 5/1 Arm 25000000 BPS 100 250000 Paul Morris
Consumer RE LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Lindemann Jr., George 3/31/2016 50
ercial Real Estate 50000000 BPS 100 500000 Stewart Oldfield
Residential Loan LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Lindemann Jr., George 3/31/2016
3/31/2016 0
3/31/2016 0
Asset Mgmt
Private Weal
Referral Fee
3/31/2016 0
Stewart Oldfield
Chammah, Ezra 3/31/2016 10 Commercial R
300000 Paul Morris
3/31/2016 10 Private Wealth Premium Check
10 Brokerage (C
3/31/2016 50
3/31/2016 25
Stewart Oldfield
3/31/2016 25
Hedg
U.S.
Priv
Stan
Comm
U.S. Structured Lending (Unsecured) 100000000 BPS 200
Art Loan LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Lindemann, Adam M.
Letter of Credit 35000000 BPS 200 700000 Stewart
ETE Loan LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Lindemann Jr., George
Letter of Credit 25000000 BPS 100 250000 Stewart
ETE Loan LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Lindemann, Adam M.
Letter of Credit 37500000 BPS 100 375000 Stewart
Introduction LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Tan Tan Bo Puking LLC
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
ETE- Brokerage Series 1 LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP The George Lindemann Family Limited Partners
hip 3/31/2016 0 Brokerage (Commissions) 30000000 BPS 20 60000 Stew
art Oldfield
ETE loan- Series 2 LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP The George Lindemann Family Limited Partners
hip 3/31/2016 0 U.S. Secured Lending (Lombard) 20000000 BPS 135 2700
00 Stewart Oldfield
Deposits LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP The George Lindemann Family Limited Partnership 3/31
/2016 0 Private Wealth Premium Money Market 1000000 BPS 35 3500 Stewart Oldf
ield
ETE Brokerage- Series 2 LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP The George Lindemann Family Limited Partners
hip 3/31/2016 0 Brokerage (Asset -Based Fees) - Advisor Select 30000000 BPS
20 60000 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction LORBER, HOWARD RELATIONSHIP Lorber, Howard 3/31/2016 0 Private Weal
th Premium Money Market 0 Paul Morris
Introduction M20 INCORPORATED RELATIONSHIP M20 Incorporated
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction MAKENA CAPITAL MANAGMENT, LLC RELATIONSHIP
/2016 0 Private Wealth Premium Money Market 0
Introduction MARINER CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Mariner Capital
th Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Lending MARRON, DONALD B. RELATIONSHIP Marron,
of Credit 25000000 BPS 100
Muhart, Gene- MATEER, CRAIG RELATIONSHIP
art Oldfield
Goldrush MEISTER, TODD RELATIONSHIP
red Lending (Secured) 90000000 BPS
Deposits MEISTER, TODD RELATIONSHIP
th Premium Money Market 10000000 BPS
Structured Credit MEISTER, TODD RELATIONSHIP Meister, Todd 3/31/2016 25 U.S.
Letter of Credit 50000000 BPS 200 1000000 Paul Morris
Residential Mortgage MEISTER, TODD RELATIONSHIP Meister, Todd 3/31/2016 25 Stan
dard Mortgage - Floating Arm 7000000 BPS 100 70000 Paul Morris
Banking MEISTER, TODD RELATIONSHIP Meister, Robert A. 3/31/2016 25 Private Weal
th Premium Checking w/Interest 10000000 BPS 40 40000 Paul Morris
Fixed Income MOODY, ERIK RELATIONSHIP Moody, Erik V 3/31/2016 10 U.S. IA - Fi
87500 Paul Morris
Moody, Erik V 3/31/2016 10
BPS 35 87500 Paul Morris
Murstein, Alvin 3/31/2016 10
100 500000 Paul Morris
Murstein, Andrew 3/31/2016
xed 25000000 BPS 35
Banking MOODY, ERIK RELATIONSHIP
um Checking w/Interest 25000000
Lending MURSTEIN, ALVIN RELATIONSHIP
(Lombard) 50000000 BPS
Banking MURSTEIN, ALVIN RELATIONSHIP
th Premium Checking w/Interest 10000000 BPS 40 40000 Paul Morris
Introduction NAZERIAN, DAVID RELATIONSHIP Nazerian, David 3/31/2016 0 Private Weal
th Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
KCP Private Markets ORIX RELATIONSHIP ORIX Corporation 3/31/2016 75 Priv
ate Equity Funds 10000000 Flat Fee 400000 400000 Stewart Oldfield
Infrastructure ORIX RELATIONSHIP ORIX Americas 3/31/2016 25 U.S. Letter of Credi
t 50000000 BPS 200 1000000 Stewart Oldfield
IX Capital Partners- ORIX RELATIONSHIP IX Capital Partners 5/31/2016 10 0
Stewart Oldfield
Structured Credit PARAMI CAPITAL MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Vaid, Rahul 6/30/2016 75
U.S. Secured Lending (Lombard) 50000000 BPS 300 1500000 Paul Morris
Deposits PARAMI CAPITAL MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Parami Capital Management 3/31/2016
75 Private Wealth Premium Money Market 10000000 BPS 35 35000 Paul Morris
Lending PARAMI CAPITAL MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP Parami Capital Management 3/31/2016 25
U.S. Structured Lending (Secured) 25000000 BPS 100 250000 Paul Morris
Brokerage PATRIOT STRATEGY PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP Patriot Strategy Partners 3/31/2016
0 Brokerage (Commissions) 25000000 Flat Fee 50000 50000 Paul Morris
Introduction PEREGRINE GROUP RELATIONSHIP Peregrine Group, LLC 3/31/2016 0 Priv
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Credit Facility PINE RIVER CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Pine River Capital Management LP 3/31/2016
10 U.S. Letter of Credit 50000000 BPS 100 500000 Paul Morris
Richardson, Julie G.- RICHARDSON, JULIE RELATIONSHIP Richardson, Julie G. 3/31/2016 50
Brokerage (Commissions) 30000000 BPS 5 15000 Paul Morris
Loan ROGER BULLOCH RELATIONSHIP Bulloch, Roger 3/31/2016 10 U.S. Structured Lend
ing (Secured) 20000000 BPS 100 200000 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction ROGER BULLOCH RELATIONSHIP Sher Capital 3/31/2016
th Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction ROGER BULLOCH RELATIONSHIP SPB Partners
th Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
2000000 Stewart Oldfield
3/31/2016 10 U.S.
Oldfield
3/31/2016 10 U.S.
Oldfield
3/31/2016 10 U.S.
Oldfield
3/31/2016 0 Priv
3/31/2016 0 Priv
Makena Capital Mangement, LLC 3/31
Stewart Oldfield
3/31/2016 0 Private Weal
Donald B. 3/31/2016 25 U.S. Letter
250000 Paul Morris
Muhart, Gene 5/31/2016 10 0 Stew
Meister, Todd 6/30/2016 75 U.S. Structu
1235 13365000 Stewart Oldfield
Meister, Todd 3/31/2016 75 Private Weal
35 35000 Paul Morris
Private Wealth Premi
U.S. Secured Lending
10 Private Weal
0 Private Weal
3/31/2016 0 Private Weal
Introduction RUBENSTEIN, KEITH RELATIONSHIP Rubenstein, Keith 3/31/2016 0 Priv
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Paul Morris
Airplane Loan SAPIR, TAMIR RELATIONSHIP Sapir, Tamir 3/31/2016 75 U.S. Structu
red Lending (Secured) 10000000 BPS 200 200015 Stewart Oldfield
KCP SCHMIDT, ERIC RELATIONSHIP Hillspire LLC 3/31/2016 10 Brokerage (Commissio
ns) 0 Stewart Oldfield
Deposits SCHMIDT, ERIC RELATIONSHIP Hillspire LLC 3/31/2016 10 Private Weal
th Premium Checking 50000000 BPS 20 100000 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction SHAMROCK RELATIONSHIP Martin, Greg 3/31/2016 0 Private Wealth Premi
um Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
CIO Strategies SIMON, RICHARD M RELATIONSHIP Simon, Richard M. 3/31/2016 25 Glob
al Select - Equities/Balanced 25000000 BPS 35 87500 Paul Morris
CLO 2 SK FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP Falcon Trail Capital, LLC 3/31/2016 75 Deri
vatives (Equity - Swap) 5000000 BPS 200 100000 Paul Morris
CLO SK FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP Falcon Trail Capital, LLC 3/31/2016 75 Deri
vatives (Equity - Swap) 5000000 BPS 200 100000 Paul Morris
Structured Notes SK FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP SK Family Office 3/31/2016 75
Structured Notes & Deposits (Equity) 3000000 Flat Fee 45000 45000 Paul Morris
Loan SK FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP SK Family Office 3/31/2016 75 U.S. Structu
red Lending (Secured) 5000000 BPS 200 100000 Paul Morris
HELOC SK FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP SK Family Office 3/31/2016 25 Standard Mor
tgage - Floating Arm 15000000 BPS 100 150000 Paul Morris
Introduction SLIFKA, RANDY RELATIONSHIP Slifka, Alfred A. 3/31/2016 0 Priv
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
HF Secondaries SLOME, IAN RELATIONSHIP Slome, Ian 3/31/2016 25
0000 0 Stewart Oldfield
Hedge Funds 2500
Euro Hedge SNYDER, DANIEL RELATIONSHIP Snyder, Daniel 3/31/2016 10 Brokerage (C
ommissions) 100000000 BPS 20 200000 Stewart Oldfield
DPM Mandate SNYDER, DANIEL RELATIONSHIP Snyder, Daniel 3/31/2016 10 U.S. IA - Eq
uity 50000000 BPS 50 250000 Stewart Oldfield
Brokerage SNYDER, DANIEL RELATIONSHIP Snyder, Daniel 3/31/2016 10 Brokerage (C
ommissions) 10000000 BPS 5 5000 Stewart Oldfield
Loan SNYDER, DANIEL RELATIONSHIP Snyder, Daniel 3/31/2016 0 U.S. Letter of Credi
t 50000000 BPS 100 500000 Stewart
Somerset Partners- SOMERSET PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP
Oldfield
Somerset Partners 2/29/2016 10
O Paul Morris
Introduction SONEN CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Sonen Capital 3/31/2016 0 Private Weal
th Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Brokerage SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP Gratitude America 3/31/2016 75 Brok
erage (Asset -Based Fees) - Advisor Select 10000000 BPS 20 20000 Paul Morris
Additional Banking SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP Southern Financial LLC 3/31/2016 75
Private Wealth Premium Checking w/Interest 50000000 BPS 20 100000 Paul Morris
DPM SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP The Haze Trust 3/31/2016 50 U.S. IA - Equity
25000000 BPS 35 87500 Paul Morris
Structured Credit SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP Southern Financial LLC 3/31/2016 10
U.S. Letter of Credit 50000000 BPS 300 1500000 Paul Morris
Brokerage SPRUCE PRIVATE INVESTORS LLC RELATIONSHIP Stock, Robert D. 3/31/2016
25 Brokerage (Commissions) 50000000 BPS 100 500000 Stewart Oldfield
Equity Trading SPRUCE PRIVATE INVESTORS LLC RELATIONSHIP Spruce Investment Advisors, LLC 3/31
/2016 25 Brokerage (Commissions) 50000000 BPS 100 500000 Stewart Oldfield
Real Estate Loan STREAM REALTY RELATIONSHIP Stream Realty Partners 3/31/2016 10
Commercial Real Estate 50000000 BPS 100 500000 Paul Morris
Brokerage THARANI, HARESH RELATIONSHIP Tharani, Haresh 3/31/2016 25 Brokerage (C
ommissions) 30000000 BPS 5 15000 Paul Morris
Airplane Finanching THARANI, HARESH RELATIONSHIP Tharani, Haresh 3/31/2016 10 U.S.
Structured Lending (Secured) 10000000 BPS 100 100000 Paul Morris
Credit Draw THE NATIONAL ORGANIZATION OF THE NEW APOSTOLIC CHURCH OF NORTH AMERICA RELATIONSHIP
The National Organization of the New Apostolic Church of North America 3/31/2016 50 U.S.
Secured Lending (Lombard) 10000000 BPS 180 180000 Paul Morris
Brokerage THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP WANEK TRUST OF 2000 3/31/2016 90 Brok
erage (Commissions) 5000000 BPS 5 2500 Paul Morris
JTWROS Brokerage THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Wanek, Karen A. 3/31/2016 90 Brok
erage (Commissions) 5000000 BPS 20 10000 Paul Morris
CMBS THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Third Lake Capital 3/31/2016 50 Commercial R
eal Estate 20000000 Flat Fee 30000 30000 Paul Morris
Leveraged Loan/Real Estate Lending THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Third Lake Capital 3/31
/2016 50 Commercial Real Estate 50000000 Flat Fee 3000000 3000000 Paul Morris
KCP Private Markets THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Third Lake Capital 3/31/2016 50
Private Equity Funds 15000000 BPS 150 225000 Paul Morris
Banking THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP WANEK TRUST OF 2000 3/31/2016 50 Private Weal
th Premium Checking 10000000 BPS 40 40000 Paul Morris
HF Secondaries THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Third Lake Capital 3/31/2016 25 Hedg
e Funds 25000000 Flat Fee 125000 125000 Paul Morris
Banking Products THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Todd and Karen Wanek Marital Property Trust
3/31/2016 25 Private Wealth Premium Money Market 10000000 BPS 40 4000
O Paul Morris
Cash Management THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Third Lake Capital 3/31/2016 10 U.S.
IA - Fixed 100000000 BPS 25 250000 Paul Morris
Deposits THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP SSW 2007 LLC 3/31/2016 10 Private Weal
th Premium Money Market 50000000 BPS 40 200000 Paul Morris
Fixed Income THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP Third Lake Capital 3/31/2016 10 U.S.
IA - Fixed 100000000 BPS 35 350000 Paul Morris
HF Secondaries TISCH FAMILY RELATIONSHIP TFMG, LLC 3/31/2016 25 Hedge Funds
5000000 Flat Fee 125000 125000 Paul Morris
Deposits TISCH FAMILY RELATIONSHIP TFMG, LLC 3/31/2016 10 Private Weal
th Premium Checking 50000000 BPS 40 200000 Paul Morris
Stock Lending TISCH FAMILY RELATIONSHIP TFMG, LLC 3/31/2016 10 U.S. Structu
red Lending (Secured) 50000000 BPS 100 500000 Paul Morris
HF Secondaries TISCH FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Tisch Financial Management 3/31/2016 0
Hedge Funds 0 Paul Morris
Custody and Trading TISCH FAMILY RELATIONSHIP Tisch Financial Management 3/31/2016
O Onshore Custody 300000000 BPS 20 600000 Paul Morris
Art Financing TOMS CAPITAL LLC RELATIONSHIP TOMS Capital Investment, LLC 3/31/2016 25
U.S. Structured Lending (Secured) 50000000 BPS 100 500000 Paul Morris
Commerical Real Estate TOMS CAPITAL LLC RELATIONSHIP Gottesman, Noam 3/31/2016 10 Comm
ercial Real Estate 50000000 BPS 200 1000000 Paul Morris
Real Estate Financing TOMS CAPITAL LLC RELATIONSHIP TOMS Capital Investment, LLC 3/31/2016
10 U.S. Structured Lending (Secured) 60000000 BPS 100 600000 Paul Morris
Introduction TRUE NORTH ADVISORS RELATIONSHIP True North Advisors, LLC 3/31/2016
O Private Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Introduction UNITED COMPANY RELATIONSHIP United Company 3/31/2016 0 Private Weal
th Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Lending VIOLA, VINCENT RELATIONSHIP Viola, Vincent 3/31/2016 10 U.S. Letter of Credi
t 25000000 BPS 100 250000 Paul Morris
HF Secondaries WILLETT ADVISORS RELATIONSHIP Willett Advisors, LLC 3/16/2016 25 Hedg
e Funds 5000000 Flat Fee 125000 125000 Stewart Oldfield
Structured Credit WILLETT ADVISORS RELATIONSHIP Willett Advisors, LLC 3/31/2016 10
U.S. Letter of Credit 25000000 BPS 100 250000 Stewart Oldfield
CRE Loan WILSON, WELCOME RELATIONSHIP Wilson, Welcome 3/31/2016 10 Commercial R
eal Estate 200000000 BPS 100 2000000 Paul Morris
Introduction WINSTON ADVISORS RELATIONSHIP Winston Advisors 3/31/2016 0 Priv
ate Wealth Premium Money Market 0 Stewart Oldfield
Petrides, George- YORKTOWN PARTNERS, LLC RELATIONSHIP Petrides, George 3/31/2016
25 Brokerage (Commissions) 10000000 BPS 5 5000 Paul Morris
Banking YORKTOWN PARTNERS, LLC RELATIONSHIP Lawrence, Bryan 3/31/2016 25 Private Weal
th Premium Checking 20000000 BPS 40 80000 Paul Morris
IA YORKTOWN PARTNERS, LLC RELATIONSHIP Warren, Glenn 3/31/2016 25 U.S. IA - RC
M 50000000 BPS 35 175000 Paul Morris
Structured Lending YORKTOWN PARTNERS, LLC RELATIONSHIP Yorktown Partners LLC 3/31/2016
25 U.S. Structured Lending (Unsecured) 50000000 BPS 200 1000000 Paul Morris
Brokerage YORKTOWN PARTNERS, LLC RELATIONSHIP Keenan, William Howard 3/31/2016 10
Brokerage (Commissions) 25000000 BPS 5 12500 Paul Morris
Paul 25
Customer Name Last Call Note Customer Number Status Relationship Tier
tionship Investable Assets (Est.) Revenue Potential ($M per annum)
Last Activity Date Date Contacted Category Notes
3 G CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000492967 Active Tier 2 Offflifff
AVISTA RELATIONSHIP 5/16/2013 00000408824 Active Tier 3 $25 - 50 M
f$1$
BLUE MOUNTAIN RELATIONSHIP 00000494553
BOMMER, SCOTT RELATIONSHIP 00000482412
BRONFMAN, EDGAR RELATIONSHIP 00000482491
CAVALRY RELATIONSHIP 00000483810 Active
CUMMINGS, IAN RELATIONSHIP 00000481149
(144$
DELL, MICHAEL RELATIONSHIP 1/6/2015
- 1 M ########
DINAN, JAMIE RELATIONSHIP
ERGEN, CHARLES RELATIONSHIP
- 1 M ########
FELDSTEIN, ANDREW RELATIONSHIP
f$f$
GAGOSIAN, LARRY RELATIONSHIP
GATES FOUNDATION RELATIONSHIP
LAFFONT, PHILPPE RELATIONSHIP
MANDEL, STEPHEN RELATIONSHIP
- 1 M flitifftt
MARRON, DONALD B. RELATIONSHIP
PINE RIVER CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP
SCHAEFER, MARLA RELATIONSHIP
SIRIS CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP
STREAM REALTY RELATIONSHIP
TABLADA, MARO RELATIONSHIP
TOMS CAPITAL LLC RELATIONSHIP
VIOLA, VINCENT RELATIONSHIP
'Mt
WEISS, GEORGE RELATIONSHIP 00000480421
fitf$
YORKTOWN PARTNERS, LLC RELATIONSHIP
7/9/2013
1/12/2015
12/20/2012
6/3/2013
Active
Active
Active
Tier 1
Active
Tier 2 *finite
Tier 3 $##$#$##
Tier 2 $##$$$#$
4441141#1
Tier 1 $100 - 500 M
00000409133 Active Tier 1
Active Tier 3
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 3
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 3
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
00000483947 Active
1111111/
Active Tier 1 $50 - 100 M
H
H
H
Rel. Net Worth Rela
Last Modified Date
<$0.5 M 414.
$250 - 500K ####
$50 - 100 M $0.5
H
$50 - 100 m $50 - 100K
Active Tier 3
1111111/
1111111/
Active Tier 1
#104.410
#104114.0
#104114.11
#104114.11
Active Tier 1
$50 - 100 M
$##$#$$#
H
H
$50 - 100 m
H
H
H
H
H
H
$$#$#$$$
$100 - 250K
$50 - 100 m $100 - 250K
Tier 3 f$$$$#$$
$0.5
Stew 25
Customer Name Last Call Note Customer Number Status Relationship Tier
tionship Investable Assets (Est.) Revenue Potential ($M per annum)
Last Activity Date Date Contacted Category Notes
54 MADISON PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 00000520240 Active
ANNANDALE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000499580 Active Tier 2
BBR PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 11/10/2014 00000480937
H
BLUESTEM LLC RELATIONSHIP
CARUSO, RICHARD RELATIONSHIP
K 9/20/2015
CFM RELATIONSHIP 00000508292 Active
COLLIS, CHARLES RELATIONSHIP 00000499562
DORRANCE FAMILY RELATIONSHIP 8/3/2015
- 500 m $25 - 50K 9/20/2015
DUNCAN INVESTMENTS RELATIONSHIP 00000499619 Active Tier 2
FORRESTAL CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 2/18/2015 00000475431
GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY RELATIONSHIP 00000495959 Active
GETZ FAMILY RELATIONSHIP 8/19/2015 00000421545
$250 - 500K 9/20/2015
HIGHLANDER PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 00000499594 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
KIM, STEVEN RELATIONSHIP 00000499732 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
MAKENA CAPITAL MANAGMENT, LLC RELATIONSHIP 00000499849 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
ORIX RELATIONSHIP 00000497520 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
ROGER BULLOCH RELATIONSHIP 00000514745 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
SCHMIDT, ERIC RELATIONSHIP 12/4/2014 00000409366 Active Tier 2
/2015 H
SHAMROCK RELATIONSHIP 00000508301 Active
SLOME, IAN RELATIONSHIP 00000499573 Active
SNYDER, DANIEL RELATIONSHIP 00000495876
SONEN CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000507994
SPRUCE PRIVATE INVESTORS LLC RELATIONSHIP
- 25 M <$25K 9/20/2015
1/6/2015
Active Tier 3
Rel. Net Worth Rela
Last Modified Date
Tier 1 H
9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 <$25K 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 $10 - 25 M <$25
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
00000409820 Inactive Tier 1 1.5E9 $100
9/20/2015
Active Tier 1 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Inactive Tier 1 $100 - 500 M
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
11/3/2014 00000416313
H
>$500
H
M <$0.5 M 9/20
H
H
Active Tier 3 $10
Clients
Customer Name Last Call Note Customer Number Status Relationship Classification Last
d Date Category
BLANK, ARTHUR M. RELATIONSHIP 8/3/2015 00000409087
BOIES FAMILY RELATIONSHIP 8/3/2015 00000474263
DZIALGA, KIRSTEN S MARK RELATIONSHIP 00000492969 Active
GENERAL ATLANTIC FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP 00000492971
THIRD LAKE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 10/1/2014
TISCH FAMILY RELATIONSHIP 7/22/2013
ELLIN, HOWARD RELATIONSHIP 8/3/2015
ELYSIUM MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP 00000483288
KLEIN, LISA RELATIONSHIP 12/14/2012
LINDEMANN FAMILY RELATIONSHIP 2/6/2015
SK FAMILY OFFICE RELATIONSHIP 00000481998
SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP 00000483290
THE NATIONAL ORGANIZATION OF THE NEW APOSTOLIC
00000499740 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 1
Active Tier 1
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 2 10/19/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 1 9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 10/19/2015
Active Tier 3 10/19/2015
9/20/2015
10/19/2015
Modifie
H
H
H
CHURCH OF NORTH AMERICA RELATIONSHIP 8/3/2015
Prospects
Customer Name Last Call Note Customer Number Status Relationship Classification
d Date Category
3 G CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000492967 Active Tier 2
ANNANDALE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000499580 Active Tier 2
AVISTA RELATIONSHIP 5/16/2013 00000408824 Active
BBR PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 11/10/2014 00000480937
BLUE MOUNTAIN RELATIONSHIP 00000494553
BLUESTEM LLC RELATIONSHIP 00000499584
BONIER, SCOTT RELATIONSHIP 00000482412
BRONFMAN, EDGAR RELATIONSHIP 00000482491
CARUSO, RICHARD RELATIONSHIP 1/6/2015
CAVALRY RELATIONSHIP 00000483810 Active
CFM RELATIONSHIP 00000508292 Active
COLLIS, CHARLES RELATIONSHIP 00000499562
CUMMINGS, IAN RELATIONSHIP
DELL, MICHAEL RELATIONSHIP
DINAN, JAMIE RELATIONSHIP
DORRANCE FAMILY RELATIONSHIP
H
DUNCAN INVESTMENTS RELATIONSHIP
ERGEN, CHARLES RELATIONSHIP
FELDSTEIN, ANDREW RELATIONSHIP
FORRESTAL CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP
GAGOSIAN, LARRY RELATIONSHIP
GATES FOUNDATION RELATIONSHIP 00000487611
GEORGETOWN UNIVERSITY RELATIONSHIP 00000495959 Active
GETZ FAMILY RELATIONSHIP 8/19/2015 00000421545
H
HIGHLANDER PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 00000499594 Active
KIM, STEVEN RELATIONSHIP 00000499732 Active Tier 2
LAFFONT, PHILPPE RELATIONSHIP 00000482519 Active Tier 2
MAKENA CAPITAL MANAGMENT, LLC RELATIONSHIP 00000499849
MANDEL, STEPHEN RELATIONSHIP 12/20/2012
MARRON, DONALD B. RELATIONSHIP 00000487026
ORIX RELATIONSHIP 00000497520 Active
PINE RIVER CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000495627
ROGER BULLOCH RELATIONSHIP 00000514745
SCHAEFER, MARLA RELATIONSHIP 00000482432
SCHMIDT, ERIC RELATIONSHIP 12/4/2014
SHAMROCK RELATIONSHIP 00000508301 Active
SIRIS CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000485211
SLOME, IAN RELATIONSHIP 00000499573 Active
SNYDER, DANIEL RELATIONSHIP 7/3/2015
SONEN CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000507994
SPRUCE PRIVATE INVESTORS LLC RELATIONSHIP
/2015 H
STREAM REALTY RELATIONSHIP
TABLADA, MARO RELATIONSHIP
TOMS CAPITAL LLC RELATIONSHIP
VIOLA, VINCENT RELATIONSHIP 00000481140 Active Tier 2
WEISS, GEORGE RELATIONSHIP 00000480421 Active Tier 2
YORKTOWN PARTNERS, LLC RELATIONSHIP 00000483947 Active
DELUCA, FREDERICK RELATIONSHIP 11/5/2014 00000409192
A
54 MADISON PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 00000520240 Active Tier 1 10/14/2015
ALAGAPPAN, ARUN RELATIONSHIP 00000482385 Active Tier 1 9/20/2015
AMOROUSO, PAUL RELATIONSHIP 00000482396 Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
ARCHSTONE MULTIFAMILY PARTNERS AC, LP RELATIONSHIP 11/5/2014 00000469740
Tier 1 9/20/2015
ARDEN ASSET MGMT RELATIONSHIP 00000499582 Active Tier 2
ARROWPOINT PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 00000493738 Active
ASPEN GROVE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000493757 Active
ASTON, SHERRELL RELATIONSHIP 00000482400 Active Tier 2
ATLAS PIPELINE PARTNERS, LP RELATIONSHIP 00000495788
BARRY, MITCHELL RELATIONSHIP 00000482402 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
BASQUTAT RELATIONSHIP 00000486597 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
BENEFIT STREET PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 00000494492 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
BERTAGNA, ROBERT RELATIONSHIP 00000482406 Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
BHALLA, AJAY RELATIONSHIP
BLACK, LEON D. RELATIONSHIP
BLATT, MITCHELL RELATIONSHIP
BRACK CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP
BRADLEY, THOMAS RELATIONSHIP
BRANDIS, STEVE RELATIONSHIP
BRESLOW, LEN RELATIONSHIP
BRIGHT GROUP RELATIONSHIP
BROWN, BATES RELATIONSHIP
BRUDERMAN, MATTHEW RELATIONSHIP
1/6/2014
8/3/2015
7/9/2013
2/18/2015
1/12/2015
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 3
Active Tier 3
Active Tier 2
00000411476 Active Tier 2
Tier 1 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 1
Active Tier 3
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
00000409366 Active Tier 2
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
00000495876 Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
11/3/2014 00000416313
Last Modifie
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Tier 3 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Active Tier 1
9/20/2015
Inactive
9/20/2015
Active Tier 1
9/20/2015
Active Tier 1
Active Tier 3
9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Inactive Tier 1 9/20/2015
H
H
9/20/2015
H
Tier 1 9/20/2015
H
9/20/2015
H
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
H
H
H
H
Tier 2 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Active Tier 2
H
H
H
9/20/2015
Active Tier 1 9/20/2015
H
00000495565 Active Tier 2
00000482398 Active Tier 2
6/3/2013 00000409286
H
H
H
9/20/2015
H
9/20/2015
H
Active Tier 3 9/20
6/5/2013
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Inactive
Active Tier 3
Inactive
Inactive
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Active Tier 1
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Tier 3 9/20/2015
Inactive Tier 1
H
H
9/20/2015
H
H
H
9/20/2015
H
Inactive
9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Inactive
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 1 9/20/2015
CANDOVER INVESTMENTS RELATIONSHIP 00000483659 Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
CANTER, STEPHEN RELATIONSHIP 00000481394 Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
CHOU, SILAS RELATIONSHIP 00000482437 Active Tier 1 9/20/2015
CLINE, MICHAEL RELATIONSHIP 00000482481 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
COLD SPRING HARBOR LABORATORY RELATIONSHIP 00000481396 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
COOPER, FRED RELATIONSHIP 00000482464 Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
CORRIGAN, PATTON RELATIONSHIP 00000481136 Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
COX, BERRY RELATIONSHIP 00000495990 Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
CROSS, LISA RELATIONSHIP 00000487462 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
CV STARR RELATIONSHIP 00000499589 Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
DANIELS, JOSEPH RELATIONSHIP 00000482485 Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
DENATALE, ROBERT RELATIONSHIP 00000482487 Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
DOCK STREET CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000520273 Active Tier 1 10/16/2015
DODD, RYAN RELATIONSHIP 00000482489 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
DONALD BRYANT JR. RELATIONSHIP 6/1/2013 00000469399 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
ELLMAN, STUART RELATIONSHIP
ENCAP INVESTMENTS RELATIONSHIP
FINE, LONNIE RELATIONSHIP
FITZGIBBONS, JOHN RELATIONSHIP
FORD, GERALD J RELATIONSHIP
GAIL, COLEMAN RELATIONSHIP
SASLOW, LAWRENCE RELATIONSHIP
GEMINI REAL ESTATE RELATIONSHI
GERSCHEL, PATRICK RELATIONSHIP
GLICKMAN, DONALD RELATIONSHIP
GLIMCHER, ARNIE RELATIONSHIP
GOLDMAN, BUDD RELATIONSHIP
GOODWIN, KEIRNAN RELATIONSHIP
GRANDWAY ASSET MANAGEMENT, INC
/2015
GRANITE GROUP RELATIONSHIP
GREENBERG, MAURICE RELATIONSHI
HARBOURTON RELATIONSHIP 000004
HARVEY, BERGER RELATIONSHIP
HATFIELD, JAY RELATIONSHIP
HG CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 000004
HOLTERBOSCH, HEIDI RELATIONSHI
HUDIBURG RELATIONSHIP 000004
HUGHSON, PAUL RELATIONSHIP 00000482515 Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
HUSAIN, FAZLE RELATIONSHIP 00000482529 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
HYMAN, ED RELATIONSHIP 00000481404 Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
ILLIG, CLIFF RELATIONSHIP 00000499604 Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
IRONSIDES ASSET MGMT RELATIONSHIP 00000499596 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
ITAFIN RELATIONSHIP 00000498895 Active
JACK NORRIS RELATIONSHIP 3/7/2013
JAIN, NEIL RELATIONSHIP 00000482496 Active
JESSELSON CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000489088
JL SQUARED GROUP RELATIONSHIP 00000499598
JSC INTERIORS LLC RELATIONSHIP 00000496076
KALIKOW, PETER RELATIONSHIP 00000178401 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
KARGMAN, HARRY RELATIONSHIP 00000482503 Inactive Tier 3 9/20/2015
KATZ, STEVEN RELATIONSHIP 00000482472 Inactive Tier 3 9/20/2015
KEENAN, WILLIAM HOWARD RELATIONSHIP 00000482513 Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
KELLY, JUDY RELATIONSHIP 00000482527 Inactive
KIMMEL, ADAM RELATIONSHIP 00000482533 Active Tier 3
KRISTOFF, MARK RELATIONSHIP 00000482524 Inactive
LANGFORD, DAVID RELATIONSHIP 00000482518 Inactive
LICHTENSTEIN, WARREN RELATIONSHIP 00000482267 Active
LIME ROCK PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 5/16/2013 00000478453
LORBER, HOWARD RELATIONSHIP 00000520256 Active Tier 3
M20 INCORPORATED RELATIONSHIP 00000499600 Active Tier 2
MARINER CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000499577 Active Tier 3
MATEER, CRAIG RELATIONSHIP 8/19/2015 00000495818 Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
MEISTER, TODD RELATIONSHIP 00000482449 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
MEP INVESTORS LLC RELATIONSHIP 12/14/2012 00000410774 Active Tier 1 9/20/2015
MICHELSON, GARY KARLIN RELATIONSHIP 11/6/2014 00000435204 Inactive Tier 2 9/20
/2015
MILCH, NEAL RELATIONSHIP 00000482476 Active
MILTON ACADEMY RELATIONSHIP 00000483494 Active
MIVEN LP RELATIONSHIP 11/4/2014 00000418860
MOODY, ERIK RELATIONSHIP 00000514634 Active
MURSTEIN, ALVIN RELATIONSHIP 00000481145 Active
NAZERIAN, DAVID RELATIONSHIP 00000499575 Active
NIR, DAN RELATIONSHIP 00000482454 Active Tier 3
OVERSTROM, GUNNAR RELATIONSHIP 00000482474 Active
OXFORD LANE CAPITAL RELATIONSHIP 00000493740
PACKER, MARC RELATIONSHIP 00000481318 Active
PARAMI CAPITAL MANAGEMENT RELATIONSHIP 00000498424
PATRIOT STRATEGY PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 00000484400
5/16/2013
2/18/2015
P 00000492404
. RELATIONSHIP
P 11/5/2014
96026 Inactive
00000482512 Active
00000482508 Active
83662 Inactive
P 00000482522 Active
96304 Inactive
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
00000466131 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
00000409212 Active Tier 1 9/20/2015
Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
11/5/2014 00000483929 Active Tier 1 9/20
Active Tier
Tier
Tier
Tier
Tier
Tier
Tier
2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 1 9/20/2015
3 9/20/2015
2 9/20/2015
2 9/20/2015
2 9/20/2015
3 9/20/2015
2 9/20/2015
Tier 3 9/20/2015
00000451105 Inactive
Tier 3 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 3 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Tier 3 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
10/16/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Tier 3 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
Tier 3 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 1 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
Tier 3 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 10/19/2015
PENSLER, SANDY RELATIONSHIP 00000482468
PEREGRINE GROUP RELATIONSHIP 00000499602
POLYMER LOGISTICS RELATIONSHIP 00000508809
RICHARDSON, JULIE RELATIONSHIP 00000481328 Active
ROARK CAPITAL GROUP RELATIONSHIP 11/20/2013
ROSE, SIMON RELATIONSHIP
ROSEMORE, INC RELATIONSHIP
SALZMAN, RICHARD RELATIONSHIP
SCF PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP
SCHOR, FRANCIS RELATIONSHIP
SCHREIBER, KARL RELATIONSHIP
SCS FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP
SHANKEN, MARVIN RELATIONSHIP
SIEGEL, JEROME RELATIONSHIP
SILVESTRI, ANGELO RELATIONSHIP
SIMON, RICHARD M RELATIONSHIP 00000484535 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
SK CAPITAL PARTNERS RELATIONSHIP 3/6/2013 00000435834 Inactive 9/20/2015
SLIFKA, RANDY RELATIONSHIP 8/12/2015 00000451242 Active Tier 1 9/20/2015
STALLER, CARY RELATIONSHIP 00000482410 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
TAXEL, NELSON RELATIONSHIP 00000482391 Inactive Tier 3 9/20/2015
TRUE NORTH ADVISORS RELATIONSHIP 00000508807 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
UNITED COMPANY RELATIONSHIP
WEINDLING, LESTER RELATIONSHIP
WHITE DEER ENERGY RELATIONSHIP
WILLETT ADVISORS RELATIONSHIP
WILSON, WELCOME RELATIONSHIP
WINSTON ADVISORS RELATIONSHIP
Active
Active
Active
11/4/2014
11/10/2014
00000482422 Active Tier 2
00000482418 Active Tier 2
Tier 3 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
Tier 2 9/20/2015
00000459563 Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
00000409735 Inactive 9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
Inactive Tier 2 9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
00000470597 Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
11/17/2014
3/18/2013
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 2
Active Tier 1
Active Tier 2
9/20/2015
Active Tier 3 9/20/2015
Active Tier 2 9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
9/20/2015
EFTA01121678 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2016-04-06)
VALAR VtNTUUtU
Valor Global Fund II LP Capital Call
March 16, 2016
Dear Southern Trust Company. Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valar Global Fund II LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $2,250.000.00 which represents 15% of your total commitment
of $15.000.000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Wednesday April 6, 2016.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 57% of your total commitment with a
remaining 43% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of April 6, 2016:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$15,000,000.00
$8.550.000.00
$6.450.000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Wednesday April 6, 2016
$2.250.000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
121140399
I Fund II LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
•
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Velar Ventures Management LLC 915 Breadway Suite 1101 New York. New York 10010 www.yolar.eam
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Renata Bolotova aka Рената Болотова [russian girl] former model, fund manager at New York State Insurance Fund [x] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01618381 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage from Renata Bolotova (???) screenshot(s), see quote: "how many new girls are there in the island W you now?"
(inferred timestamp: 2016-04-16 19:02:00)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
2016/03/04
04:48:00 pm
My haircut 8 months ago J sneaky can I go next week to
bday be will see
04:49:06 pm
yes, of course
04:53:39 pm
again before
1212 5333739
also going
•
Who is=
04:57:09 pm
Yay. Thank you! .4
04:57:33 pm
•.: But who is=
04:57:53 pm
04:58:04 pm
1212 5333739
04:59:57 pm
I was laughing aloud when I heard that we need a new assistant so don't feel
alone when you and
05:00:33 pm
SNEAKY SNEAKY DOG
05:01:13 pm
are together. Such a bullshit!!! 43,
1212 5333739
if you weren't in school i wouldn't need new
05:01:06 pm
Come on, it's not only that I am sure there is more into it E .
05:02:02 pm
Anyway Just teasing you) miss you
05:02:41 pm
t
And I will graduate very soon! 'n
05:03:06 pm
®Z
05:03:54 pm
You will have a double black months
05:04:59 pm
* dongle black months
05:05:21 pm
Double
05:05:26 pm
1212 5333739
shit
05:03:12 pm
2016/03/12
08:06:30 pm
Hi sneaky! What to wear for bday?
08:06:30 pm
1212 5333739
Great great great
09:00:43 pm
•
Who one ?
09:01:21 pm
Which
09:01:26 pm
1212 5333739
All white
09:01:31 pm
Ok great, thank you 14
09:02:51 pm
2016/03/14
Sneaky, do you sleep yet? Have a question for physics die to tomorrow
12:58:07 am
12:58:26 am
So don't pay attention to calculation only the first trial average time is correct which is
1,15 seconds. So using formulas I tried to calculate initial velocity and maximum
height; using two different formulas I should have gotten the same results, however i
got totally different and having a hard time figuring out what went wrong...
01:01:20 am
Sneaky dog sorry but may ask your help w one calculation for physics lab pls
10:19:32 pm
2016/03/15
1212 5333739
We asylum???
01:41:08 am
How sweet
02:15:21 pm
02:15:27 pm
•
•
•
My professor for genetics wrote that
02:15:59 pm
2016/03/21
Are you staying in the city?
06:31:13 pm
I am here If you need my help
07:02:00 pm
2016/04/16
So how many new girls are there in the island W you now?t 4
06:43:56 pm
1212 5333739
New inspector?
06:48:06 pm
Sent
Well Inspector appointed me to administer while she is " out of office" 0
06:56:55 pm
Read
╔══════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 AfD [europe] right wing German political party [wiki] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00166317 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank statement for Epstein's account 690519
(date: 2016-05-30)
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Contacts As of Mar 31.201E
PRIMARY OFFICER
PAUL MORRIS
CUSTODY OFFICER
ARTHUR TOOTER
rt.
A.ocounl Name JFFFRFY FPSTFIN
Account Number 690519
Base Currency USD
manifest 11n•
L
1
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002091
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
This Pago Intentionally Loft Blank
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002092
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Portfolio Summary As of Way 31.2018
Mai Clan Adwited Cod 1164.6 Merl« V•166 Is of
L1SD Si OW C•tago.ry
Cash an Can Enanarta 32 432 48 53384:  LA
nal 52432 «I 52.398 41 10000%
§111.4144 An.0.01/664166
Total
Note Mann Vann Frcl,A Acnatd ben»
3
Cumin Paned
205
005
Account Nnme JFFFRFY FPSTFIN
Account Number 680519
Elan Currency. USG
16tuket Value 1116066614•66, cr.11,13 Cann, Pond Yar to D466
Ono.% %hag •6 of May 1. 2016 83.057 78 112.041SI
Acklannnhannal
C,:turwts ,0 21 SA 091
14.1 Add4lon/W666rowal 1117379.31 160.351201
Income
ill 281
Nat maws 117.2111 1100911
Pas an Curroncy1:•,6 1.ent 158e 2522 WI
6/10”. unrnated C00•6(2 , Gler"c60 11.7211041 11.2021N
Closing Balance at 8/ May 31, 2018 52,3141.41 52.31141
Ill 66071 2,5
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002093
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Regional Diversification As of May 31.2016
Account Name. JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Account Numbs, 680519
Base Cunene?' USD
Allocation by Region Cash cad CAM Flap acorns Equity Altivnativ• NNW Woe 16 of
Egolvelenta In USD N USD in 1)60 Inyctsinabms M lill0 la USW Cet01144 /
EV00.0 32.38201 000 000 003 52.382 CO 99 97%
United Statto/Canfla 16 41 000 000 00) 16 41 0 031.
Total 52.300 41 000 000 0.00 32.396 41 1000016
• ExclusbbF beer @change Conl•Et$
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002094
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Currency Diversification Ascot War 31 2016
Account Nome JFFFPFY FPSTFIN
Account Number 680519
Base Currency. USD
Allooabon by Currency Caen and Cosh Freed brooms blurry Arterneuvo borer FrtM•le /Arbor Vairre AM
tourvalente in MO Al U90 Al USD Investments in USD in uS0 re 050 Cate/pry
US Caber IU501
two FUN
16 el
52.1112 03
003
000
1,1
•-
Total 52.396.41 0.00 0.00 000 000 52.396 41 100004
EIC010.06 R4990
USD 1. USD 100D0 USD I • USD 1 00003
USD I • CUD 0 OM CUI1 1 . USD 1 11266
5
L
1
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002095
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Detailed Portfolio Information As of Mav 31. 2016
Litt of Holdings • Cosh and Cnh EquIvidonte
Account None JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Account Number 680519
Base Currency USE)
Clumitety fl aunty Eneectipides
Security ID Meetly3R1A• Rand
Cosh
41.0/11 611 fURO
bb
Category
al 9"
teal Unit Cost
CUR 1 WO
Nam In 040
teed Pelee
US01113
fUe1000
MOMS Cast
Ss In USD
62.401 06
~dad Vale had lemma
In USD In USD
62.312C0
Total Cub NB^ 5241605 52,36200
C•16 Meemeidneed
Unitod SIM«
441 DEUTSCHE 0052101 MOO CASH 0.03% US2 1 0)0 1G00 14 II 11141
1NS111U1rONAL SHARES
Tad Umbel Stak» OOfM 10 41 10a1
T0141040 Manapan.ent 003% 16 41 16 41
Total Can *ad Ce50 !~Snob
lone Amara dame
1O0.Ø 02.4246 52.39641
rededahll aaenlel IntOwe
Admned Cost Bests whim, n1Kts Tes Coil tor Mom Mend ome suburb u our us cod »man for al We deals. we rotnel Amu** Cost
Foe Caen Manuemenr menders anal Money MEtei Fundy Armed Yield n mamma en 6* Mesa ier Mammy addan
6
ttO
Estemated Annual Yam to
Incoma In ti lt Mauntyin
6.l011
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0002096
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Transaction Summary May 1 2014 ,n Mry 31 704
Trannction Catsgo.1
Ooornag ffelanco 4* of Moy 1. 4016
AdomonNYfundrannal
4..401
Not A0016014W4141.4yfreal
Invootantwollocomo
00.04 . 41 000 14 06
0,34441 07 211 11310/1
MVMTOM 1400104 07.21I1 Dolt%
Pa./43 f%6.MK1 on Cas4 ISM 232216
Urn**1.44 f x Oeint. on on Ca, 0.7351 11.107
Clap Selasoe as of 1.i44 31.30)6
Ca: M4•43ement 1641 1641
Car• 53.3000 52.31)200
US Dollar (USD)
Amount .4moont Yam to Oat*
164,
6104134
tine,
000
IMMO)
233

• 203923
0/03.351
Th300000
(f0,351.20)
Account Name JFFFRFY FPSTFIN
Account Number 680519
Base Currency USO
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0002097
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Transaction Summary Foreign Currency May 1 2014 12 Mm 31 >S10
Account Name JFFFRFY FPSTFIN
Account Number 6805)9
Base Currency. USD
Transaction COlager,
Eon) ((UPI US DOM. 10501 US Dollar(U50) Giand 7401
BOMICCY11730)
0444mg Balance.. el May 1. 2016 • S11.055 52 03514136 6:146/76
4004.0 4104,146mwal (11.961 y1 511.6/1 091 16219691
invyanmal 1n40450 115401 117 301 11121)
Irmommem Ameary
Capital G... Onuebui
Cuinancy Excfmneo
POMu00 SX Gemitom on Cash 1566 1566
Umpania4 FY Cowles, en Cm/a 0.92021 11 770 04
Clean; Salaam as of May 31. 2016 47.07111 et Stan 00 1041 62.3911
• 0:410410 ve 4104/m tylency 044,011p new 114111541
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0002098
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Transaction Details \431. Nato may 3I 1335
Trade Dots
Samterront Daus
Tranunctron Typo ENNOIMMA
SomatIty 141
Trimuctleno En fury RUM
O8184O14 Awn,
05/180010
NEGATIVE IDLE CASH MOVES!
F8 RATE 0891E
082412016 Caro Doeuruninoun DiSEWFMEME NT OF FUNDS
08242010 FUNDS TRANS TO SOCIETE GENERAL E SSB
KAI SCMS1405219411046
IBM FR70303430371500000140 72133 SWAT
PEto 14373219AN7
Fit PATE 0 SITS
05082010 Caort CALtursenstun DISBURSEMENT OF FUNDS
0&7V2010 FUNDS TAINS TOM CAP LITHUANIA IRAN
LNI040100610(COTHI9U no Rico
SCM41193S24:188642 SWIFT REFS 16052411.4.80
FS RATE 08983
057240010 Coot 480mAutmem DISIMONIEME NT OF FUNDS
0504/2010 FUNDS TRANS TO CRGOIT LYGNIMOS SS8
RE Fa SCMS18052493440) SORT CODE 300)2
RI B COOK 03091 17 CODE OUCHET 01469 KEY
CODE 7O
TX RATE O8933
093142014 CAM CritturmomM DISPOSE M(NT OF FUNDS
05/302016 FUNDS TRANS TO SOCIETE GENERALE SSB
RE Fe SCMS161577588O94.8AN
11068.130303:218)00A06403.902 SWIFT REFS
M3%1034149
tx RAI( 0 IOU
Account Warne JFFFRFY FPSTFIN
Account Number 680519
Base Currency. USO
OullAtTly
0546
0.000000
0.000031
a.iel SD
0.500000
♦mount w Lots CCV Com A Loom Oar ITanzsti Cava**.
Amount In USD
OS 4O1
O7211
aorpoom
0.12930
(303) 001
(LI In 30I
0.441 Ml
0,354141
asoom 0.781031
=MSS
Cost on USEI A USD
3'3 rx
x
Ix
1341 ft(
114A IX
L
1
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002099
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Disclaimer As of  bay 31 2016
Disclosure Notice
Account Neme JFFFIRF1( FPSTFIN
Account Number 690519
Base Cunene.? USO
IMPOPTANi NOTICES", account is ntainumnd a Denee ban Tall Campalty AMNION Manna ~YE
ASS"( StabenSeat Intianeteen iit'e tii • ' hatmertee psetani »In behsten Wens Pin and Cenneta Bent The nereestel e 
inebiblasa ate Of Eno cetera? Ma« SSW TO etch
apse. nt rem "or to re, act tap tie Mesit folds Wear dulcet Bank nor rta attain or subsclusio anent frisponsinly fa any 
Olsen ore Iran IN named it coal nos< tor
inns: ic" coma/1e rn Its accoani
Sfalestel DSOS. Bent and aJana aro sutinearet msee M reces0 ea,on. tafrainyereatantee. atone ear sewn. m eerineetten lbe
asOrmalten prOv440 n MON.:am Ea:mere
new mee te l in °Peron
statemoni maw wear trweilinenti Ornate wary ey la amount nalea act atan Mal are rot SO s Oebieene Sant
Valuallin Of Mee*: IC Nees PC anneal «Maas presentee n Ms Pens sameal may te brad upon Me mew <yam MONO* pea oroodeo by 
to :Net play porap Yenta an lee ~Is Snit
a: he Ise SS
Marren, sae peeled one pram or Woes or nett sea aeon mey not whet Me plat papa PS nolti 00 0010^00 Coen la Ornabeen el 
try te ch  met one oo nor °memo' term a
000 retar to unwind W.V
sass, or Swaths ape storm soul only be an as • swept pod* lo portiere Sir ire peps of piton saunas may inset 
approsonatons ban upon sen wormas' rettansnon lo
Other Isaac mot
Quetta Hoe brOttscilarell OtaMo.n sent p 6maar noose% 0'  CPC^ nub!~ leem/al Male ran MSC fetal le 'Sees Ematenf Sae le 
°Men' intanaben IN Mete amen am lop scum
sand oi le r assets :Men
oh:perm nol publicly need may nste teen obtained Worn IS account Saw nentsol tol accents Polar. R Ws nieces nal mayor 
may not be retest
enemaw enetnrenna hue ,  al roes trors ce sale aptly tune» ray tan in minty Sete women OM may be PIICPt fa nut In ants, 
et canons petanita a Ms noon be efenclar
neesimenn ;Sea Me
w1uMM trys Mn ante* SI Iht Pre el besets, Me ritpon one ray be feettleoner elebstr Ins tic most sited Stets Se enalsod 
al Sutton crt atisrano tartness we So
nose rts in wet" my seal at
dOlirmen ter re inxiniment manna used SP suppled q IN aderlytere land ranbers SSW almetarabes 01 VW 414eNsfas 
entesYnents 04ifte• rnable any ~Want Clicsfos web
mow. to yent atboatla sinesInann.
Plea crawl yaw . ennory01ficte »awn ene mom oast se4sion of MO aernalive vnellrtnl
tee ebtai of ens V onto or mee arms new rbC410 Silt." • 'NM ann." Tee *se rot nesseanh mean nut IN fan ate worm woe. Sal
tilt Mall eh .n neat mean IS DCweene
Elba Serena uneelt
0152,14b 4 rope lor Mete IMPS bet ,. SCOW Of th.3 aeleeral "pearl It OS Oa te' nor attecit , we s ^Munn et 'HS' M Its 
vod. Men Peat leiro PeishemleCe CDS/se
toel Pa late, IttasOM ""Yeaten n  nerben.
tech knell. NMI not ban (ban as IN Maebet San Inlowatan. Soiernanty cle IN easel Otiobsbon elourahon at IN trtgennine 01
Mrs stalemate
0.01 Wessel Stites mat bet sem Or mew cannon Stites may Os ropeenei m Vit,Cat ot a pin relent pasty tops oixycrerce, mi 
ry aMect te  yin postern rosy not; mat
yettuaorwty s ~e t*, in me
*beset clactlt MN $17•03, O. sotto shirr. or Sid Sal The attal fin or le meabsciato fauna mei wry coarse to she rule el 
WilISO, IN taditey.re pawns or mar
freest mates a* peon Inloontion
coperning renenpien 1001,00 I'd MO **GIP, rat ofte<! yea wit be Isernne0 CPn ladle telMt 0/ me apenni beep
me "(incg  or Nis dtge pis raw soave iht is [lame peck art awn a to past be rte ohm gram
Sono non ins álinaugn money saw keels rat IS prifalln• Ill video el no savant at blear Coro ti pestle ra ION misty by 
min ne ern
Dut lo in• money" cowtmons aPrin sumenry stmooda ad sate ter tors en aasmm ant prowingen my al no^ nS rum et" IN  
'flOrnala' smoans Ob ey ed
AM,* an ti* St tinas Seenbed amnia ~Owe: These nets te  MI cancan wish Nunes Bap PAU! Sea eerhere' en IS resent est sr 
account suer inermame P.O.Aded on nn
oatemem en correcoon
van such Awns (inducing actuators) vas net PIOVIdd or 's ol ed  by OtratiChe Ewa
Feehaeba Ras: (Shape rates ta SOP«, eit a 151(0 petty MSC. &Minted 10 batten* BOM am me eased on .morture eamws rant Mme
IMO Of re Cahal P Ina attecnt SharritC1
Callen* Bent den ro t tielaáre.
eel P sane IWO Rea MO Dealt ,. Ss re not relensate In eNcvely. ncomptele. or  stone inlorennon web spa »so ewe
Owairrent 'eau. say r antra iny Crain 0 .010.CY nOeliA 50"
Mposiled CM sew. smust..4. One Mang Peeled Infonaino.: The tannabon pvda m Iht scat slanmenl with spat to alttors cost 
no ranee se/Oss. one Came pent may  ro t
anal MI storasen
mammary let na went,. pumas In scalp. Mt entrecion of Lena ad enaterapi Cassia Arena Epos Sea real natal pant slat. 
local. or lose, lain Mai ensti *poly CUTIPTA
'Mould only of ritormatam .n
th e Metal sielemem astil Mer Own WPM "Mtn Careerase e rerOcatte ~Or CIS WSW:ea Iron  a SW. reCketten. 0' smart te an 
baser De.:sche DEli e no: worse., toe me
accuracy of woe moreueon »mown
mays ripens to noon to tacknal stn. or Ph« VS or snit) S bone actions bone* Bene mats no warrants.; wee -aspect to. end 
spactIr-bet Osborn say teeny amine out
of a pplosms vet of. or any tit setup
fats in wawa opon, IN Soera on COnlati44 ...Macaroni sans,
Deane BY* dancer weed* is rape The Malaria sepal ro l ba and lot tau reportne patois
10
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002100
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Disclaimer As M Wao 31. 2310
Account Name JFFFRFY F PSTFIN
Account Numbei 690519
Base CUII0e1Cy USD
0~sche Unit. a *oom ornintlo too:łnea Naai b amia aow: ás boent n rb rantomtri claráttaki m Pis accoam Wammen TW limbi 
ol boen ol Tiet* maksom on i. wc co
',migma wan ranonim•lro
okt:n wittn ‚boeg ot PP Plcoeti bob« Citatg 04tex ot ns arti Mim *by ~IM Moeren t*WinebiOn ItOnk OMA »nes n cOnabtiOn 
wet liabblens 0eick040 n Ms aoCOunt
stegralni Deutsche BWik yeit turnen IM
bar* ab woon: Ot Wf *Ah Woonettalifin opOn worm IpOM101 OP aCtOr POW.
Ambonie fee ~ich ~sela Bal Y aeting n Trusia
1 Odgoni, Somt*. Caklom. Intobene Con Socho,  IS0». M wg . ~nero oolincohon lo Ino occant ~M d un Ic4~~ ION ~on of iwo 
WOW, nb peldnIn COJI pultant IO COMOta•
MOCAte COOP StAbOn
I7200 lei Olgan !SOWI Moty Ol Wf &WWW aro o I Me un of no :nom MOWCO trein. ~ OO don» osainfo ino Mało ia tesben of von 
mus: ł* mo:» *Min 3~n oe :ha ara e*
terenowy W 4ref4 T!0(0!11 ol
• MOOI °OCMW.; loch pana b* IO Ine Olim
2. Morga Trusts An beivan tor owen ot Ina ba~ ut:a.i.-nomen &BOM m von socountag or wiem noon M W• inalt• Mb be PAWI »a 
0 manii waluto M ~won. trom ~Naw M ino
ruw accouning or Oiner
nbien Fyeu art Ogen ons. p...4 omegi! WW anynev
Comonon Tont Fund ~unu os kocono: ta a Bonc»ont .5 a Deutsche Bant'. Common Teun Funda. a lonowe OI O» mil want ...dood 
minut fopte! u Lnelabb toon ~bi eibtOtil
~ce
Non-US Morwom nokio, Win tm. oci ie yeit alsen c itablikl wu Ciligarnie pent eiCitiMil Ind 001•19Mrili r 0-Ignitgionit 
*Mn yOot OCOMani miry pl MACIOM Win /WW
Witzliagn PAMP Obiegli beier IM lionigir III
/mmmc oto W Owinie!): of siwi trátablorts
Cing ~Mion oe Tor MO COMIMMOI 014MOOMBIbilltbil InOlvichsols Tbr ~con? bober °Wem, PW k rw reaContieitty miry optoggione
eno Ww repotammy ‚bomb dalai appicacie
lo nim in any ‚Wan
whatOcinons Met TV, wite n con...ween wlk beng. imion, of ttirnweima in hit acconnibb ano hm Manen talicimitbnith lb 
Bonk
Confirmatie>, of Tos on0 Compliono• A•000nolOOMeo lor Orsponozaelonst Ind  AfitCam ncie/or connrrna Mat 4 M ns 
mtpirbalty to AMII WW Mc Otaplitin MO We 00101
itiOgaire tfecinn3 dato bOocaCle Abb ,  WW PAW:
‚MAMCIOM fi t my ab0 in <Onnet:Cm nitn abn. intOme W itOnan: IWO in +Z b«Cantgl To 15 Noren nlKIXano »IM IM UM r 
uttnternMe. IM Mcouni War con,,,~ me100 nce~ary
tmotivolion I W Mc bosi oe of
woonecoe ab <bonbon‚ n made antab no tent Man annaty te re rwennt efeehoo OW nMltl. wnottist twennietliell pettneng. etc
lo wenie CirritheMinein lo tritli Sny
tempen* tot otimblimn Inkt my tną
ninytwrinorn rn <Onnet:4n agonem twbukt nObor's OtninOts Miatontnip rw (kant
Fot I wmunent «kitowy aceouni nadert. II ~a MM Soos ony ~epos in voos 1~nekal snuabort or Iwonom.» obloccivon. oralno 
wals to mot on ~a~tektoserbecion• oo Oto
mon•oon.~ d not
inrownsenr menory ~oom ot toosenztay ~My *kisten reeittetion bene **Maa yeem Piienery Oefaket
!COC Uritimc nentaxl to the contrarie m a ponoblar Cna mie betintien and financial marymont* pnesoneed nnm we not ns., 
red by gm Podwoi Gronik i bomem ,
Coberlinon 0 10 101. mit rmt Ocetantelel kW. Mm etai
ottbatieno of. Croulciene Abs AG et ony el li t Mln:nee r subeedimme and twe subject lo inyoalmont enk ircading pominie 
ion M IM p~pol "Gont tnvonao
Dowticno Bank ~nol gowontoo ~fugom pwlonin~o oe voor account promom Ony ~do Meo, oe pede marce oe prom*. In/l Deutecine 
Bonn envettinont tocommonomion. er winu»
o• fot bm account wili
be succomfel
1~ DOOof~100 wilii Deutsche Bonk AG.
AelaNiono M Witkentvels OspOsti
ik ká ltbáts it blm /gubiona); nb‚ bit mi.034 w b ID Any LOMP withrltawal wil wol! in dbam M tt4
EW* re*MetIon4
Ceuncti• Bakt nt pbs pens‚ on aty wmotani Bon a TO prot bite neck.nry Trio amount O» omar» wil u <Wegebt on Me Oom of 
%teamy nitebrbwo in 'oliwy
A 'Ben.sBy Rwe wa oe coeolgeo „ne 'Penny Paw' N Ine onerence ‚erwten me intrnd 0tagone Sets interes: rat tm IM remairing
pw,» oe Be owe ce ~ramion ano IM inweeg
ram on bim 10 Ine »tal
Vn: MY «Abb of ‚IW TO On laie date Of tfmnbtiOn WP be ewtobet1 bl ino Bonotiv eb» wid Ben tl~e0 otrw 300 ot 30B a ‚woed 
Oo KPY, Wiltrishop ~PW th0 mowno monter
wn ~4~0 rw n odner ol twa miniowy bolo rp ong~ NaNrcy 0~ ‚o acne w tee ',ogum oe oe gnoe
eXamp. Ol M eany walmaat Maait spoNgno lus men000rogy amor wie oo w~~ le yeti opon musa s,  Mlllon, In babi» 01 Ine opną
svOndrawal perony prof eo toememon wam
relMCl le yoar 10 M11 N veem
'cynu opon mmmii
SKINI M annin Mitil4MOO K<OpMp010 Na!~ Bonk n ns SOM OWP" nO pralny AMIN <MIMO Me Pany witridnowg ~n toe debr less or 
vaaal conooromy oe am Bccedual sto M OP
LWOWI IWOM Of tb 1D
EoupWomoukuu cumowi wil regime MO smout Or ~erm wood on o» TO
111111111111111111111 11111111
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0002101
Deutsche Asset
& Wealth Management
Disclaimer As of Lia 31. dette
MICOrdErM,
Criant M to se,tondry ~nel »na lor na TO brei no mamma e aanlaad Inas me wil area, n re ivesre
Accouni Neme' JFFFRFY FPSTFIN
Account Numbei 690519
Base Currency. USO
Meter ad bega la Nasa On lat air 0. (»Mal trer all oe 0,094 fa yo,F tecosal on I» Wim» Dale onne TO loe !De Alla er 
nataal,. pi 12 morilbs or aa Fa TO, ala f
marde pm». am, It Kaam Kamt me be
pee annalry »cl al rel be baad » precoal Inleent »II N Uitsneed Naad upon mar III • »J en «Alt Or Ma 305 My ma in Neb 
oase lor Or mimer of aa» Mam» ban IN day
of Opaal »Ine Kraag and es
»Mee» N MI retalanicap FrOnarc Na nerre wil *area on me 10 er« ra Maan» are IF de MISOOSOCI prof to re Man« Oslo innaai 
na «h ta <MMO, » vat rea.tni 10 tN treni
mY. n sats me tent
mindrJMl penaby Mare« ent tem De cearamsdNI Tte Meter »Inni 904 Omga aerg :he wood ol IN TO
~Ma
Ine lpmi na ocian•imay rolawr boon natraY
faraMEW
Om» mie trac muf TO .9 ro< MMO N Ia 'Die
Tredende». ad Copyright. Mony's Ininfoo Sen«. IN na Standera & Po«, Consalson SI•nditd S Pont raden] • a «neon of »e 
M<dfw fall Cceennnin.lrn Arovoducton of ny
enfornaton prerand Dy SAP en any
etno n ~non *Ene van Mannin pennoen sa. even aa Manna» Me >Mary. adebalre COMpleane» avOcanila lay anneen end.nrel 
response«. be >N anOls 04 "Wn. ala tb nasla
obainal
noen IN ne oe loa nbernalon n none« ni SAP be etle lol any nama. eienai a connoverated Nese en orrociron sen ne of any 
SAP enlontseion
Int rauw 04 MOodes ~las Sera». K takidalrii") aØ Mie abri.» in m9 staienril redenen Woof aØ Sts" ~OM Ia b re *wiey el IN
innen ING MI Aanwen n «Nina and
eve•Cleve ard M NI
ascese ittendwas omedy Credo: party of envons don not renos miebi st Am »er Marron war mort » »maan Oei Fellscied 'Na 
bral t or • Faang Nol Aniateln pee n Cent
Paling molm« ihs
nlacroni n4k40 upa ,  vernam roomt of Ine %CON! holden
At Vademon en0 mam Kif» on Ine stremt» belang »Oorwas erm AG r ia raai oe eAtnoinage. ene« Kawa traciemets or amice maa 
anen ve re peoperlyan Mee mora» nam
le« Ganst IndanyCesediorion bands» MOFCS'l ras anneoped end is Ine ~urn woon» afd • ~ooi mark ot Mao» SliaharCaser 
Inlionratel Inc MMO', and SAP. »o play innend
n "NON. oe ~noem° Po AKS
OIaM'eKSCptpnGtMimenrorOWnlarm0ledrVnaMMRa4DresnelW0mer0aNt » lab 
in0.V0atlnprrGealØnry0.1610NMtYnsNIMuslna((/.%9sNepYletMrNnpre4MarWimot
warinlos or crooner'. rooms. coraleareire. ererchainlataty and Innen ase • dertiger papa* aan mimi IQ ra el men lam» or 
~Malen Warme 'mama any ol n lort/mam in
no ~nl Mal Mbo. S&O. any of
nto innam« ene Tro Mae inveKed a Mabad a COnalling OIO GCS a any 0/CS CaMMSIOnfOOM In/ Stil« 1« *nv «Va. Mank Mroil 
Maart CON0airatil «ma or« aow« ',notedop ion
«conti even n notiree
OF re Parallel OF aval 00, 49es
Please review your account statement. II you lind or suspect any inaccuracies or discrepancies in your account 
statement, ya.must
write to us to inham us ot the suspecter' inaccuracy discrepancy within 30 days to Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas,
Box

318. Church Street Station. MS NYC20-0004. New York. NY 10008.0318 otherwise any claims you have may be barred. Please 
tall your
Primary Officer il you have any questions.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002102
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
   Maria Prusakova aka Masha Prusso aka Mary Prusakova [russian girl] former Olympic snowboarder, Crypto PR Lab co-founder, long time recruiter for 
                                                                                        Epstein, WEF, Story VC [scamurai/rddt/rddt/olympedia/archv] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01114895 (Jmail)
 [girls] Maria Prusakova application letter to UC Berkeley
(approximate date: 2016-06-01)
Personal statement
Based on my leadership potential and commitment to contribute to improving the world, I was
nominated to be a Global Shaper, a program for young leaders run by the World Economic Forum
("WEF"). Why me? Maybe because I adopt an entrepreneurial approach to creating change. My
instinct is not to wait for decisions from authority, but to propose solutions, to reach out to my
network and to start movements, to build things.

In January 2015, I represented the voices of the Youth in Davos WEF discussions on gender parity,
economic growth strategies and banking and financial regulations.

This year at World Economic Forum only 17% of the 2,500 attendees were women. I was fortunate to
debate on the equality of women's and men's salaries with brilliant barrister Cherie Blair. She is the
wife of former Prime Minister of the UKTony Blair. Also, I listened to the speech of Christine
Lagarde, managing director of the International Monetary Fund. Then, we shared the dinner table with
her where she told me about her legal career which I have already known by heart. Mrs Lagarde
admired that as a native Russian speaker and a professional athlete, I graduated at the top of the class
with Highest Honors (900 students) in French Corporate Law at Sorbonne Law School. Then, she told
me that there is a shortage of knowledgeable specialists in French, Russian and American laws. This
legendary woman encouraged me to fulfill my dream to sit for American Bar exam.

To interact with the world's smartest French lawyer and to learn from her made me confident that one
day I will do just as good as she did starting her career at Baker&McKenzie in 1981. It was probably
even a more significant and life changing experience for me than my participation in 2006 Winter
Olympic Games in Turin as the youngest member of the Russian National Team. In fact, at the age of
14, I had to negotiate my first sponsorship contract with O'Neil clothes brand. Since then, reading and
understanding legal contracts became my second nature. Driven for legal success, I worked at top
world law firms, Clifford Chance in Paris, Allen & Gledhill in Singapore, then in the legal department
of HSBC Private Bank and other international companies. It sharpened my legal reasoning and
prepared me for the success at your LL.M. course. Moreover, a California based hedge fund agreed to
grant me a sponsorship to cover the fees of my LL.M. if I am accepted to Berkeley Law.

In my legal career so far, I have developed unique experiences in corporate and banking laws and got
insights in litigation. The most exciting mission was my work at Subordinate court in Singapore in
2013. An American scientist Shane Todd was found dead in his apartment on the day he resigned
from Singaporean Science Agency. His next-of-kin accused the former employer of murdering him
because of the secret information he held. There was a risk that he would reveal it to American
military authorities. On this mission, I led the team of 12 trainee lawyers from the top Singaporean
law firm, Allen & Gledhill. Our task was to report daily the cross-examination of the witnesses and
the allegations of the next-of-kin advocates to our clients. Our clients were the alleged murderers of
Shane Todd. At court from 9 am until 6 pm, I was typing up after the judges and banisters who spoke
Singlish (a dialect of English). Every evening, I worked very hard, sometimes until the next morning,
on the compelling arguments for our lawyers. My passion for law and public speaking grew.

If I dare opening the envelope of my future, I can see myself being an international attorney, qualified
in France and in the United States of America. I wish to defend the best I can my clients at court,
attempting to improve their lives. I conceive that debating in court is a form of competition. I grew up
competing in World Cups defending the honor of the Russian Federation in the half-pipe (figure in
acrobatic snowboarding). In law, the competition of ideas and the search for compelling arguments
require both skill and practice not unlike sports training. At trials, small changes make big differences,
just as in sports tiny errors may lead to a tragic injury. The legal system and the world of sport look
backward to precedent, though in sports we talk about breaking one's own records as well as the
world's best. I visualize doing both. Being prepared for the unknown, ready to prove the cause of my
client, I will follow the rules of the legal game and push to the edge of my intellectual limits - this
time in the legal world. Law enables me to do intellectually what professional sports has allowed me
to do physically.
I have excellent common law knowledge thanks to my kris Doctor course at University of New
South Wales in Sydney. After having intensively studied for LSAT, I have successfully passed it in
2011 with the ambition to study at Berkeley one day. As such, my deep interest to study American
law in one of the top Law Schools of your country was born 4 years ago and kept on growing. The
opportunity to earn an LL.M. from Berkeley in the frames of the Paris Bar School program is my
desired next step on becoming a successful attorney. It is also a challenge which I strive to undertake.
Sincerely,
EFTA00623147 (Jmail)
 [flight] flight log
(approximate date: 2016-06-30)
flight log
EFTA01286240 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank statement for Epstein's Southern Trust Company
(inferred date: 2016-06-30)
Deutsche Bat*
Deutsche Bank Trust Co. Americas
345 Park Avenue - NYC20-0102
New York. NY 10154
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY. INC. 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3
ST THOMAS
00802
UNITED STATES VI
June 1. 2016 to hate 30. 2016
Summary of Account Balance(s)
Account Account Number Balance
For personal assistance call:
Paul Nlorris
Balance
Elite Money Market lenosit
Ilcgiming Balance as of lime I, 2016
S56.542 688 38
560.885.489.33
Demerits and Other Credit. 57,199.05
Checks Paid 93.00
ATM and Debit Card Withdrauals 50.00
Service Charges and Other Fees $0.00
Other Debits (54.350,000.00 )
Ending Balance as of June 30. 2016
Transaction 1)etail
Date Description Debit
556.542.688.38
Credit
Beginning Balance as offline I. 2016 560.885,489.33
06-03 a Cash Mgmt Trsfr Dr
REF 15511151 RINDS TRANSFER TO
DEP 35269691 FROM
(2,000,000.00 ) 58,885.489.33
06-23 a Outgoing Money Tmsf
TO SILICON VALLEY BANK NC 330152042
7 VALAR GLOBAAL FUND 11112
(250,000.00 ) 58.635.489.33
06-23 N Outgoing Money Trust
TO SILICON VALLEY BANK NC 330123181
9 SO1 111LRN DOS r CON1P \NV INC
(2,1013.006.00 ) 56.535.489.33
05-30 Interest l'a‘incnt 7.199.05 56.541,68838
Ending Balance as of lune 30. 2016 (4.350.000.00 ) $7.199.05 556.542.688.38
All items an credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceeds in cash or by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
I of 3 SDNY_GM_00042702
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. ca. N v(e) IDENTIAL OB-SDNY-0005526 F EFTA_001533I I
Deutsche Bank
Deposits and Other Credits
Date Description
06-30 Inkiest Payment 57.199.05
Amount
Service Charges and Other Fees
Taal NSF mum item fees for this statement period 50.00
Total NSF mum item fees for this calendar year SOMO
Taal Overdraft fees for this statement period $0.00
Taal Overdraft fees for this calendar scar 50.00
Other Debits
Date Description
06-03 Cash Munn Trsfr Ilr
06-23 Outgoing Money Ten/
06-23 Outgoing Money Intl
Minna
(52.000.000.00 )
($250.000.00 )
(52.100.000.00 )
Interest Calculation
Annual Pementatte Yield Earned 0.15%
Interest Earned Tins Period $7,199.05
Interest Paid Year To Rue 550,197.77
All items are credited subject to final collection and receipt of pruceeth in cash or by unconditional .edit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas.
of SDNY_DM_00042703
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. cg i
r.o() INF IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0005527
Deutsche Bank El
In Case of F.nort ur Qumions

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at 1-866-362-4796. or write to us at Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas. 345 Park Avenue. WNI Banking 
Team -
NYC20-0102. New York Na. York 10154 as soon as you can. if you think your statement or receipt is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MUST hear from you no later than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRSTstatement on which the error or problem appeared.

• Tell us your name and account number
- Describe the emu or transfer you are unsure about. and explain rat clearly as you can why you believe it is an error 
or why you
need more information

• Tell us the dollar amount of the stemmed error
Please note that if you initially provide the above information to us via telephone. we may require that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within 10 business days.
We will investigate your complaint and will correct any error promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 
days for new
accounts) to do this. we will provisionally credit your account for the amount you think is in error, so that you will 
have the use of the
money during the time it takes us to complete our investigation. At the conclusion of our invotigation we will inform 
you of our results.

2. Non-Electronic Funds Transfers
Contact the Bank immediately at I-866•362-4796 if your statement is incorrect or ii)041 need more information about any 
non-electronic
funds tnumaions (checks or deposits) on this statement. If any such error appears. you must notify the Bonk in writing 
no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you. Please see your -ferrnN and Conditions for further information on
the terms
governing your account.

3. VeriBing ['reauthorized Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once every 60 days from the same person or 
company. you
can telephone us at 1.866462.4796 to find out whether the deposit has been mark
SDNY_GM_ 00042704
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R gdr.o(e)
RDENTIALN DB-SDNY-0005528
EFTA00593789 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2016-07-01)
VALAR Vt.N ulf
Valor Global Fund III LP Capital Call
June 20, 2016
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund III LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $250,000.00, which represents 1% of your total commitment of
$25,000,000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Friday July 1, 2016.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 1% of your total commitment with a
remaining 99% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of July 1, 2016:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$25,000,000.00
$250,000.00
$24,750,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Friday July I. 2016
$250,000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
121140399
Valor Global Fund Ill LP
3301520427
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
+1 (646) 559-0458
Valor Ventures LLC 915 Broadway Stile 1101 New York. New York 10010 WWW.VOIOLCOM
EFTA01622387 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage from Renata Bolotova (???) screenshot(s)
(inferred timestamp: 2016-07-10 16:05:29)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• jeeitunes@gmail.com
2016/01/17
Hey that's to mean hang on me! I am serious about your bday I want to be a part of it!
04:57:45 pm
jeeitunes@gmail.com
Aghhhhh
04:58:17 pm
Thank you for the event! Great family pic but our Jew is missing may be we can
photoshop replacing face w however, not sure if it will fit if she
continues our food madness in palm beach .4 .7...05•Q • ;40,
05:00:20 pm
Haha just accept it, you can't hide from yourself and definitely not from us.,
05:01:08 pm
If that's ok if my gf stay at apt Herself and you need me asap I will come down. Lmk
10:24:16 pm
jeeitunes@gmail.com
its ok,
10:55:26 pm
2016/01/22
10:52:16 pm
Sneaky I want to buy a coat is too cold here. Which one is better ?
10:52:17 pm
jeeitunes@gmail.com
Last one
11:09:35 pm11:12:28 pm
Or this one?
11:12:29 pm
???
11:12:54 pm
jeeitunes@gmail.com
No no no. No black collar
11:13:07 pm
But the one you liked Also black
11:13:44 pin
The goose brand
11:13:53 pin
Or that's different for cost and winter jacket
11:14:19 pm
* coat
11:14:27 pm
11:16:19 pm11:30:44 pm
Sorry last one
11:30:46 pm
Or this one?
11:30:47 pm
2016/02/08
•
•
•
•
•
03:59:23 am
2016/04/16
So how many new girls are there in the island W you now?&C)
06:43:56 pm
jeeitunes@gmail.com
New inspector?
06:48:06 pm
Well Inspector appointed me to administer while she is " out of office"
06:56:56 pm
2016/04/30
Sneaky, if you need me today or any time this weekend I am here *4
06:30:00 pm
2016/05/01
Hi sneaky, here is a something to make your day even more awesome
"Your butt is s000 flat that when you sit down it spreads into two zip codesC. "
05:34:31 pm
2016/06/05
••  AT&T LIE
< Messages
11351 AM * 93%IM
Details
ace - • - a •may
check out other bars, wan to
pin?
Any chance you guys would
come out in Miami?
I offered to my friend but it's
unlikely as its late already and
we wouldn't want to drive back
to PB that late and after having
drinks ...
I came to NY today will be back
on Sunday late. If i get out of
work early on Monday I could try
and come see you. What airport
are you flying out of on
Tuesday?
03:51:51 pm
This is from the guy I wanted to come to see. So he didn't know I was coming to PB and
instead got a ticket to NY, I guess he could have canceled if he really wanted to see me
03:53:06 pm
So I am not sure what is the best fly tonight or stay and see if he comes to see me?
03:54:56 pm
jeeitunes@gmail.com
Stay
04:11:25 pm
Yes but my friend's parents are coming today so I will have to move out today from his
apt
04:34:42 pm
be ok to ask Janusz to drive me and stay at your house for two nights?
04:43:58 pm
2016/06/23
Called you earlier this morning. Finally reached and you hang up on me as usualQ111
Just wanted to check how do you feel and how your eye? Still swollen?
04:48:00 pm
jeeitunes@gmail.com
In meeting
04:48:25 pm
OK t?
04:48:53 pm
Sneaky, let me know if you stay here tonight!
09:43:06 pm
And a reminder about IPI internship, I am ready any time they want me to come. Thank
you . 4 44 . 4
09:44:11 pin
2016/06/24
Hi sneaky! Did you leave?
04:19:22 pm
2016/07/01
•
•
•
Hang on me againtjust wanted to say have a great weekend to you and -
Love two of you! Wand thank you .4 but keep me posted if you change your mind
and need me, you know I can arrive any time without forgetting at this time my
documents ze
03:59:18 pm
Sneaky, I am on my way! Still home?
09:15:33 pm
2016/07/06
2016/07/09
Can I bring anything for you? Medicine?
12:05:32 am
Food?
12:05:45 am
jeeitunes@gmail.com
Yes
09:15:48 pm
Sent
2016/07/10
04:05:29 pm
My dad 43.t.S
04:05:30 pm
✓ Read
╔═════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Audrey Strauss [government] USA Attorney 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00008874 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2016-07-22)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
Defendant.
x
x
SEALED
INDICTMENT
20 Cr.
COUNT ONE
(Conspiracy to Entice Minors to Travel to Engage in
Illegal Sex Acts)
The Grand Jury charges:
OVERVIEW

1. The charges set forth herein stem from the role
of GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, in the sexual exploitation
and abuse of multiple minor girls by Jeffrey Epstein. In
particular, from at least in or about 1994, up to and including
at least in or about 1997, MAXWELL assisted, facilitated, and
contributed to Jeffrey Epstein's abuse of minor girls by, among
other things, helping Epstein to recruit, groom, and ultimately
abuse victims known to MAXWELL and Epstein to be under the age
of 18. The victims were as young as 14 years old when they were
groomed and abused by MAXWELL and Epstein, both of whom knew
that certain victims were in fact under the age of 18.

2. As a part and in furtherance of their scheme to
abuse minor victims, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, and
Jeffrey Epstein enticed and caused minor victims to travel to
GM_GLSDN Y_00000346
2
Epstein's residences in different states, which MAXWELL knew and
intended would result in their grooming for and subjection to
sexual abuse. Moreover, in an effort to conceal her crimes,
MAXWELL repeatedly lied when questioned about her conduct,
including in relation to some of the minor victims described
herein, when providing testimony under oath in 2016.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND

3. During the time periods charged in this
Indictment, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, had a personal and
professional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein and was among his
closest associates. In particular, between in or about 1994 and
in or about 1997, MAXWELL was in an intimate relationship with
Epstein and also was paid by Epstein to manage his various
properties. Over the course of their relationship, MAXWELL and
Epstein were photographed together on multiple occasions,
including in the below image:
GM_GLSDNY_00000347

4. Beginning in at least 1994, GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
the defendant, enticed and groomed multiple minor girls to
engage in sex acts with Jeffrey Epstein, through a variety of
means and methods, including but not limited to the following:

a. MAXWELL first attempted to befriend some of
Epstein's minor victims prior to their abuse, including by
asking the victims about their lives, their schools, and their
families. MAXWELL and Epstein would spend time building
friendships with minor victims by, for example, taking minor
victims to the movies or shopping. Some of these outings would
involve MAXWELL and Epstein spending time together with a minor
victim, while some would involve MAXWELL or Epstein spending
time alone with a minor victim.

b. Having developed a rapport with a victim,
MAXWELL would try to normalize sexual abuse for a minor victim
by, among other things, discussing sexual topics, undressing in
front of the victim, being present when a minor victim was
undressed, and/or being present for sex acts involving the minor
victim and Epstein.

c. MAXWELL'S presence during minor victims'
interactions with Epstein, including interactions where the
minor victim was undressed or that involved sex acts with
Epstein, helped put the victims at ease because an adult woman
was present. For example, in some instances, MAXWELL would
3
GM_GLSDNY_00000348
massage Epstein in front of a minor victim. In other instances,
MAXWELL encouraged minor victims to provide massages to Epstein,
including sexualized massages during which a minor victim would
be fully or partially nude. Many of those massages resulted in
Epstein sexually abusing the minor victims.

d. In addition, Epstein offered to help some
minor victims by paying for travel and/or educational
opportunities, and MAXWELL encouraged certain victims to accept
Epstein's assistance. As a result, victims were made to feel
indebted and believed that MAXWELL and Epstein were trying to
help them.

e. Through this process, MAXWELL and Epstein
enticed victims to engage in sexual activity with Epstein. In
some instances, MAXWELL was present for and participated in the
sexual abuse of minor victims. Some such incidents occurred in
the context of massages, which developed into sexual encounters.

5. GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, facilitated
Jeffrey Epstein's access to minor victims knowing that he had a
sexual preference for underage girls and that he intended to
engage in sexual activity with those victims. Epstein's
resulting abuse of minor victims included, among other things,
touching a victim's breast, touching a victim's genitals,
placing a sex toy such as a vibrator on a victim's genitals,
4
GM_GLSDNY_00000349
directing a victim to touch Epstein while he masturbated, and
directing a victim to touch Epstein's genitals.
MAXWELL AND EPSTEIN'S VICTIMS

6. Between approximately in or about 1994 and in or
about 1997, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, facilitated
Jeffrey Epstein's access to minor victims by, among other
things, inducing and enticing, and aiding and abetting the
inducement and enticement of, multiple minor victims. Victims
were groomed and/or abused at multiple locations, including the
following:

a. A a multi -story private residence on the
Upper East Side of Manhattan, New York owned by Epstein (the
"New York Residence"), which is depicted in the following
photograph:
GM_GLSDNY_00000350
6

b. An estate in Palm Beach, Florida owned by
Epstein (the "Palm Beach Residence") , which is depicted in the
following photograph:

c. A ranch in Santa Fe, New Mexico owned by
Epstein (the "New Mexico Residence"), which is depicted in the
following photograph:
GNI_GLSDNYJMNB51

d. MAXWELL's personal residence in London,
England.
7. Among the victims induced or enticed by GHISLAINE
MAXWELL, the defendant, were minor victims identified herein as
Minor Victim -1, Minor Victim -2, and Minor Victim -3. In
particular, and during time periods relevant to this Indictment,
MAXWELL engaged in the following acts, among others, with
respect to minor victims:

a. MAXWELL met Minor Victim -1 when Minor
Victim -1 was approximately 14 years old. MAXWELL subsequently
interacted with Minor Victim -1 on multiple occasions at
Epstein's residences, knowing that Minor Victim -1 was under the
age of 18 at the time. During these interactions, which took
place between approximately 1994 and 1997, MAXWELL groomed Minor
Victim -1 to engage in sexual acts with Epstein through multiple
means. First, MAXWELL and Epstein attempted to befriend Minor
Victim -1, taking her to the movies and on shopping trips.
MAXWELL also asked Minor Victim -1 about school, her classes, her
family, and other aspects of her life. MAXWELL then sought to
normalize inappropriate and abusive conduct by, among other
things, undressing in front of Minor Victim -1 and being present
when Minor Victim -1 undressed in front of Epstein. Within the
first year after MAXWELL and Epstein met Minor Victim -1, Epstein
began sexually abusing Minor Victim -1. MAXWELL was present for
7
GM_GLSDNY_00000352
and involved in some of this abuse. In particular, MAXWELL
involved Minor Victim -1 in group sexualized massages of Epstein.
During those group sexualized massages, MAXWELL and/or Minor
Victim -1 would engage in sex acts with Epstein. Epstein and
MAXWELL both encouraged Minor Victim -1 to travel to Epstein's
residences in both New York and Florida. As a result, Minor
Victim -1 was sexually abused by Epstein in both New York and
Florida. Minor Victim -1 was enticed to travel across state
lines for the purpose of sexual encounters with Epstein, and
MAXWELL was aware that Epstein engaged in sexual activity with
Minor Victim -1 after Minor -Victim -1 traveled to Epstein's
properties, including in the context of a sexualized massage.

b. MAXWELL interacted with Minor Victim -2 on at
least one occasion in or about 1996 at Epstein's residence in
New Mexico when Minor Victim -2 was under the age of 18. Minor
Victim -2 had flown into New Mexico from out of state at
Epstein's invitation for the purpose of being groomed for and/or
subjected to acts of sexual abuse. MAXWELL knew that Minor
Victim -2 was under the age of 18 at the time. While in New
Mexico, MAXWELL and Epstein took Minor Victim -2 to a movie and
MAXWELL took Minor Victim -2 shopping. MAXWELL also discussed
Minor Victim -2's school, classes, and family with Minor Victim -

2. In New Mexico, MAXWELL began her efforts to groom Minor
Victim -2 for abuse by Epstein by, among other things, providing
8
GM_GLSDNY_00000353
an unsolicited massage to Minor Victim -2, during which Minor
Victim -2 was topless. MAXWELL also encouraged Minor Victim -2 to
massage Epstein.

c. MAXWELL groomed and befriended Minor
Victim -3 in London, England between approximately 1994 and 1995,
including during a period of time in which MAXWELL knew that
Minor Victim -3 was under the age of 18. Among other things,
MAXWELL discussed Minor Victim -3's life and family with Minor
Victim -3. MAXWELL introduced Minor Victim -3 to Epstein and
arranged for multiple interactions between Minor Victim -3 and
Epstein. During those interactions, MAXWELL encouraged Minor
Victim -3 to massage Epstein, knowing that Epstein would engage
in sex acts with Minor Victim -3 during those massages. Minor
Victim -3 provided Epstein with the requested massages, and
during those massages, Epstein sexually abused Minor Victim -3.
MAXWELL was aware that Epstein engaged in sexual activity with
Minor Victim -3 on multiple occasions, including at times when
Minor Victim -3 was under the age of 18, including in the context
of a sexualized massage.
MAXWELL'S EFFORTS TO CONCEAL HER CONDUCT

8. In or around 2016, in the context of a deposition
as part of civil litigation, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant,
repeatedly provided false and perjurious statements, under oath,
regarding, among other subjects, her role in facilitating the
9
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000354
abuse of minor victims by Jeffrey Epstein, including some of the
specific events and acts of abuse detailed above.
STATUTORY ALLEGATIONS

9. From at least in or about 1994, up to and
including in or about 1997, in the Southern District of New York
and elsewhere, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, Jeffrey
Epstein, and others known and unknown, willfully and knowingly
did combine, conspire, confederate, and agree together and with
each other to commit an offense against the United States, to
wit, enticement, in violation of Title 18, United States Code,

Section 2422.

10. It was a part and object of the conspiracy that
GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, and others
known and unknown, would and did knowingly persuade, induce,
entice, and coerce one and more individuals to travel in
interstate and foreign commerce, to engage in sexual activity
for which a person can be charged with a criminal offense, in
violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section 2422.
Overt Acts

11. In furtherance of the conspiracy and to effect
the illegal object thereof, the following overt acts, among
others, were committed in the Southern District of New York and
elsewhere:
10
GM_GLSDN Y_00000355

a. Between in or about 1994 and in or about
1997, when Minor Victim -1 was under the age of 18, MAXWELL
participated in multiple group sexual encounters with Epstein
and Minor Victim -1 in New York and Florida.

b. In or about 1996, when Minor Victim -1 was
under the age of 18, Minor Victim -1 was enticed to travel from
Florida to New York for purposes of sexually abusing her at the
New York Residence, in violation of New York Penal Law, Section
130.55.

c. In or about 1996, when Minor Victim -2 was
under the age of 18, MAXWELL provided Minor Victim -2 with an
unsolicited massage in New Mexico, during which Minor Victim -2
•
was topless.

d. Between in or about 1994 and in or about
1995, when Minor Victim -3 was under the age of 18, MAXWELL
encouraged Minor Victim -3 to provide massages to Epstein in
London, England, knowing that Epstein intended to sexually abuse
Minor Victim -3 during those massages.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.)
COUNT TWO
(Enticement of a Minor to Travel to Engage in Illegal Sex Acts)
The Grand Jury further charges:

12. The allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 8 of this Indictment are repeated and realleged as if
fully set forth within.
11
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000356

13. From at least in or about 1994, up to and
including in or about 1997, in the Southern District of New York
and elsewhere, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, knowingly did
persuade, induce, entice, and coerce an individual to travel in
interstate and foreign commerce to engage in sexual activity for
which a person can be charged with a criminal offense, and
attempted to do the same, and aided and abetted the same, to
wit, MAXWELL persuaded, induced, enticed, and coerced Minor
Victim -1 to travel from Florida to New York, New York on
multiple occasions with the intention that Minor Victim -1 would
engage in one or more sex acts with Jeffrey Epstein, in
violation of New York Penal Law, Section 130.55.
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 2422 and 2.)
COUNT THREE
(Conspiracy to Transport Minors with Intent to
Engage in Criminal Sexual Activity)
The Grand Jury further charges:

14. The allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 8 of this Indictment are repeated and realleged as if
fully set forth within.

15. From at least in or about 1994, up to and
including in or about 1997, in the Southern District of New York
and elsewhere, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, Jeffrey
Epstein, and others known and unknown, willfully and knowingly
did combine, conspire, confederate, and agree together and with
each other to commit an offense against the United States, to
12
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000357
wit, transportation of minors, in violation of Title 18, United
States Code, Section 2423(a) .

16. It was a part and object of the conspiracy that
GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, and others
known and unknown, would and did, knowingly transport an
individual who had not attained the age of 18 in interstate and
foreign commerce, with intent that the individual engage in
sexual activity for which a person can be charged with a
criminal offense, in violation of Title 18, United States Code,

Section 2423(a) .
Overt Acts

17. In furtherance of the conspiracy and to effect
the illegal object thereof, the following overt acts, among
others, were committed in the Southern District of New York and
elsewhere:

a. Between in or about 1994 and in or about
1997, when Minor Victim -1 was under the age of 18, MAXWELL
participated in multiple group sexual encounters with EPSTEIN
and Minor Victim -1 in New York and Florida.

b. In or about 1996, when Minor Victim -1 was
under the age of 18, Minor Victim -1 was enticed to travel from
Florida to New York for purposes of sexually abusing her at the
13
GM_GLSDNY_00000358
New York Residence, in violation of New York Penal Law, Section
130.55.

c. In or about 1996, when Minor Victim -2 was
under the age of 18, MAXWELL provided Minor Victim -2 with an
unsolicited massage in New Mexico, during which Minor Victim -2
was topless.

d. Between in or about 1994 and in or about
1995, when Minor Victim -3 was under the age of 18, MAXWELL
encouraged Minor Victim -3 to provide massages to Epstein in
London, England, knowing that Epstein intended to sexually abuse
Minor Victim -3 during those massages.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.)
COUNT FOUR
(Transportation of a Minor with Intent to
Engage in Criminal Sexual Activity)
The Grand Jury further charges:

18. The allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 8 of this Indictment are repeated and realleged as if
fully set forth within.

19. From at least in or about 1994, up to and
including in or about 1997, in the Southern District of New York
and elsewhere, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, knowingly did
transport an individual who had not attained the age of 18 in
interstate and foreign commerce, with the intent that the
individual engage in sexual activity for which a person can be
charged with a criminal offense, and attempted to do so, and
14
GM_GLSDN Y_00000359
aided and abetted the same, to wit, MAXWELL arranged for Minor
victim-1 to be transported from Florida to New York, New York on
multiple occasions with the intention that Minor Victim-1 would
engage in one or more sex acts with Jeffrey Epstein, in
violation of New York Penal Law, Section 130.55.
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 2423(a) and 2.)
COUNT FIVE
(Perjury)
The Grand Jury further charges:

20. The allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 8 of this Indictment are repeated and realleged as if
fully set forth within.

21. On or about April 22, 2016, in the Southern
District of New York, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, having
taken an oath to testify truthfully in a deposition in
connection with a case then pending before the United States
District Court for the Southern District of New York under
docket number 15 Civ. 7344, knowingly made false material
declarations, to wit, MAXWELL gave the following underlined
false testimony:

Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein have a scheme to recruit
underage girls for sexual massages? If you know.
A. I don't know what you're talking about.

• • •
15
GM_GLSDN Y_00000360
Q• List all the people under the age of 18 that you
interacted with at any of Jeffrey's properties?

A. I'm not aware of anybody that I interacted with,
other than obviously [the plaintiff] who was 17
at this point.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 1623.)
COUNT SIX
(Perjury)
The Grand Jury further charges:

22. The allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 8 of this Indictment are repeated and realleged as if
fully set forth within.

23. On or about July 22, 2016, in the Southern
District of New York, GHISLAINE MAXWELL, the defendant, having
taken an oath to testify truthfully in a deposition in
connection with a case then pending before the United States
District Court for the Southern District of New York under
docket number 15 Civ. 7344, knowingly made false material
declarations, to wit, MAXWELL gave the following underlined
false testimony:
Q: Were you aware of the presence of sex toys or
devices used in sexual activities in Mr.
Epstein's Palm Beach house?
A: No, not that I recall. . .
Q• Do you know whether Mr. Epstein possessed sex
toys or devices used in sexual activities?

A. No.
16
ONLGLSDNY2WENBM
Q. Other than yourself and the blond and brunette
that you have identified as having been involved
in three-way sexual activities, with whom did Mr.
Epstein have sexual activities?

A. I wasn't aware that he was having sexual
activities with anyone when I was with him other
than myself.
Q• I want to be sure that I'm clear. Is it your
testimony that in the 1990s and 2000s, you were
not aware that Mr. Epstein was having sexual
activities with anyone other than yourself and
the blond and brunette on those few occasions
when they were involved with you?

A. That is my testimony, that is correct.

• • •
Q. Is it your testimony that you've never given
anybody a massage?

A. I have not given anyone a massage.
Q. You never gave Mr. Epstein a massage, is that
your testimony?
A. That is my testimony.
Q• You never gave [Minor Victim -2] a massage is your
testimony?

A. I never gave [Minor Victim -2] a massage.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 1623.)
FOREPERSON
17
AUDREY S RAUSS
Acting nited States Attorney
GM_GLSDNY_00000362
Form No. USA -33s-274 (Ed. 9-25-58)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
v.
GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
Defendant.
INDICTMENT
(18 U.S.C. §§ 371, 1623, 2422, 2423(e),
and 2)
AUDREY STRAUSS
Acting United States Attorney
Foreperson
18
GM_GLSDNY_00000363
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Alberto Pinto Cabinet [employee] interior design favoured by Epstein 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00616025 (Jmail)
 [property] Alberto Pinto Cabinet furniture inventory
(inferred date: 2016-07-29)
Alberto Pinto
LITTLE ST JAMES ISLAND
The 29th of July 2016
ATTENTION :
GENERAL COST ESTIMATE EXCLUDING :
20% OF FEES
TRANSPORT OF ITEMS
ELECTRICIAN AND STONE INSTALLATION
HOTELS AND FLIGHTS
MAIOR ANTICS AND ART PIECES
PRICES IN THIS COST ESTIMATE HAVE BEEN STUDIED TO THE CLOSEST BUT
MIGHT VARIATE AROUND 10% AS A LOT OF ITEMS ARE CUSTOM MADE
Little St James Island
OFFICE / POOL HOUSE +
KITCHEN
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting & ceiling 52 764,00
1 rug 16 000,00
2 doors & 1 bay windows layout 44 706,00
1 pair of curtains upholstery
+ curtains rod 8 175,00
+ fabric
1 sofa upholstery with cushions
+ fabric 16 600,00
+ leather
1 coffee table 15 000,00
1 armchair
+ fabric 6 100,00
1 console 3 000,00
1 desk/ client
1 desk chair / client
upholstery for desk stool 5 000,00 + leather
2 side tables 1 700,00
3 sets of art 81 000,00
KITCHEN: layout, proposal in progress 0,00
KITCHEN: wall painting 15 386,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN C 265 431,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 1 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
KITCHEN
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
1 sofa/bench
+ fabric
+ leather
38 500,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 38 500,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 2 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CHILLAX/AFRICAN OFFICE
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting & ceiling 62 732,00
woodwork 135 400,00
1 rug 8 010,00
1 desk 25 000,00
1 desk armchair 6 000,00
1 bench 10 000,00
2 lamps / client
2 lampshades 1 800,00
1 chandelier 6 000,00
1 light 6 000,00
2 paintings / client
1 Calder / client
2 mask / client
3 vases / client
1 head / client
TOTAL TAX FREE IN C 260 942,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 3 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CHILLAX POWDER ROOM
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting + vanity + cornice + mirror
frame 31 064,00
1 rug 2 000,00
1 vanity / client
6 knobs for vanity 1 242,00
1 mirror 2 500,00
2 vases 2 000,00
2 wall light 4 500,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 43 306,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 4 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
LIBRARY
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
leather pannels painting 20 000,00
ceilling decorative painting 48 000,00
1 rug 25 000,00
1 sofa upholstery
+ fabric 14 650,00 + 6 cushions upholstery
+ leather
3 armchairs
+ fabric 27 450,00 + 3 cushions upholstery
+ leather
1 armchair upholstery
+ fabric 5 510,00 + 1 cushions upholstery
+ leather
1 optional bench upholstery
cushions / client
3 000,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 143 610,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 5 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CABANA 1
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting & ceiling 27 000,00
1 rug 15 000,00
1 bed canopy 13 800,00
8 curtains bed upholstery
+ fabric 17 000,00
1 headboard 1 725,00
1 headboard upholstery
+ 1 bed skirt upholstery
+ 2 cushions upholstery 11 690,00 + fabric for bed skirt + headboard +
cushions
+ embroidery
1 plaid upholstery 2 000,00 + fabric
1 bench 7 500,00
1 chest 0,00
1 lamp with lampshade 0,00
2 bedside table 10 000,00
2 reading light 500,00
2 bedside lamp / client
2 lampshade 1 500,00
1 cabinet 25 000,00
1 desk 25 000,00
1 desk armchair / client
1 lamp with lampshade 5 000,00
1 armchair 6 500,00
1 side table / client
2 Boor lamp 7 000,00
1 reading lamp 2 500,00
1 mirror 1 800,00
1 stool 7 200,00
2 ceiling fan with light 6 000,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 193 715,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 6 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CABANA BATHROOM 1
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting & ceiling 9 700,00
2 mirrors 3 600,00
1 vanity / client
accessories 2 000,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 15 300,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 7 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CABANA 2
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting & ceiling 32 000,00
1 rug 10 000,00
1 bed structure & headboard 21 400,00
1 plaid upholstery
+ fabric 2 500,00
+ trimming
2 bedside table 22 500,00
2 reading light 500,00
2 lamp with lampshade 7 400,00
embroidery for 2 lampshade 2 000,00
1 desk 4 000,00
1 stool 5 800,00
1 lamp 3 000,00
1 lampshade 700,00
1 cabinet / client
painting for cabinet 8 000,00
2 knobs for cabinet 700,00
1 armchair 6 500,00
objects 2 000,00
2 cushions floor knooty 800,00
2 wall lights 5 000,00
1 lamp floor 3 000,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 137 800,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 8 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CABANA BATHROOM 2
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting & ceiling 11 073,00
2 mirrors 4 000,00
1 vanity / client
painting for vanity 8 000,00
10 knobs for vanity 3 000,00
2 wall lights 0,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 26 073,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 9 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CABANA 3
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting & ceiling 47 962,00
1 rug 7 000,00
1 headboard upholstery
+ bed skirt upholstery
+ 2 cushions upholstery 7 360,00 + fabric for bed valance + headboard +
cushions
+ embroidery for headboard + cushions
1 plaid upholstery 2 500,00 + fabric
1 chest with painting 10 000,00
2 bedside table 6 500,00
2 reading light 500,00
2 bedside lamp / client
electrification 1 400,00
2 lampshade 1 200,00
Embroidery for lampshade 1 900,00
1 cabinet with painting 23 000,00
1 desk 3 600,00
garniture on desk 1 000,00
1 stool 765,00
1 lamp 3 000,00
1 lampshade 500,00
Embroidery for lampshade 950,00
1 armchair 4 500,00
fabric for armchair 1 200,00
2 cushions 800,00
embroidery for cushions 500,00
objects 2 000,00
2 wall lights 5 000,00
1 floor lamp / client
1 lampshade 700,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 133 837,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 10 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CABANA BATHROOM 3
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting & ceiling 11 655,00
2 mirrors 4 000,00
1 vanity / client
10 knobs for vanity 3 000,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 18 655,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 11 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CABANA 4
ITEMS ESTIMATE HTC
wall painting & ceiling 49 706,00
1 rug 6 500,00
4 pairs of curtains upholstery
+ curtains box 28 200,00 + fabric for curtains & headboard
+ fabric for inner curtains
1 headboard upholstery
+ bed skirt upholstery
+ 2 cushions upholstery S 300,00
+ fabrics for bed
+ leather for headboard + bed skirt
1 plaid upholstery 2 500,00 + fabric
1 cabinet / client
1 chest / client
painting for cabinet + chest 3 000,00
2 lamps 6 000,00
2 lampshade 500,00
2 bedside table 2 600,00
2 reading light 500,00
2 bedside lamp 6 500,00
2 lampshade 1 400,00
1 armchair 6 000,00
1 stool / client
1 desk 4 100,00
1 desk armchair 3 100,00
2 wall light 4 000,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN C 129 906,00
PRICES ARE IN C AND TAX FREE 12 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
CABANA BATHROOM 4
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
wall painting & ceiling
2 mirrors
1 vanity / client
10 knobs for vanity
objects
115 486,00
4 000,00
3 000,00
2 000,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 124 486,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 13 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
MAUSOLEUM
ITEMS ESTIMATE HT€
1 sofa
+ fabric 13 600,00
TOTAL TAX FREE IN € 13 600,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 14 29/07/2016
Little St James Island
ESTIMATE HT€
OFFICE POOL HOUSE+KITCHEN 265 431,00
KITCHEN 38 500,00
CHILAX/AFRICAN OFFICE 260 942,00
CHILAX POWDER ROOM 43 306,00
LIBRARY 143 610,00
CABANA 1 193 715,00
CABANA BATHROOM 1 26 073,00
CABANA 2 137 800,00
CABANA BATHROOM 2 26 073,00
CABANA 3 133 837,00
CABANA BATHROOM 3 18 655,00
CABANA 4 129 906,00
CABANA BATHROOM 4 124 486,00
MAUSOLEUM 13 600,00
TOTAL Little St James island HT€ 1555 934,00
PRICES ARE IN € AND TAX FREE 15 29/07/2016
EFTA01612888 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Kevin Peterson, Bammohan Deeduvanu, Pradip Kanjamala, and Kelly Boles A Blockchain-Based Approach to Health Information Exchange Networks
(inferred date: 2016-08-06)
A Blockchain-Based Approach to Health Information Exchange
Networks
Kevin Peterson, Bammohan Deeduvanu, Pradip Kanjamala, and Kelly Boles
Mayo Clinic
Abstract
Sharing healthcare data between institutions is challenging. Heterogeneous data structures may
preclude compatibility, while disparate use of healthcare terminology limits data comprehension. Even
if structure and semantics could be agreed upon, both security and data consistency concerns abound.
Centralized data stores and authority providers are attractive targets for cyber attack, and establishing a
consistent view of the patient record across a data sharing network is problematic. In this work we present
a Blockchain-based approach to sharing patient data. This approach trades a single centralized source
of trust in favor of network consensus, and predicates consensus on proof of structural and semantic
interoperability.
1 Problem Statement
Cross-institutional sharing of healthcare data is a complex undertaking with the potential to significantly
increase research and clinical effectivenessin. First and foremost, institutions often are reluctant to share
data because of privacy concerms[2], and may fear that sending information will give others a competitive
advantageN. Next, even if privacy concerns could be addressed, there is no broad consensus around the
specific technical infrastructure needed to support such a task[4). Finally, healthcare data itself is complex,
and sending information across institutional boundaries requires a shared understanding of both data struc-
tures and meaning. Even assuming data can be shared efficiently and securely, these interoperability issues
left unchecked will limit the utility of the data. Despite evidence that the value of healthcare data exchange
is large[5], these issues, described below, remain significant barriers.
1.1 Security
Failing to secure the patient record has financial and legal consequences, as well as the potential to impact
patient care. Securing the electronic medical record is a challenging task[6], and the ramifications of a breach
are a strong disincentive to sharing data. For this work, we focus on both privacy and anonymity and how
they apply to data sharing.
Data privacy involves ensuring only authorized parties may access the medical record. This impacts any
healthcare system, as patient privacy is not only an ethical responsibility, but a legal mandato[7]. Patient
data is also an asset to the institution, and unauthorized access could compromise competitive advantages
or reveal proprietary practices.
Data anonymity may also be used to secure the record. In this way, identifiable information is left out,
and only summary/partial data is shared. This can be acceptable, but is challenging, as it requires a large
number of attributes with potential resource or patient care value to be removed from the record in order
for it to be considered de-identifled[8].
1.2 Infrastructure
A significant hurdle to sharing data is the agreement of the supporting technical architecture and infrastruc-
ture. Many attempts at data sharing require either (I) a centralized data source, or (2) the transmission
1
of bulk data to other institutions. Both options introduce unique problems. Centralization increases the
security risk footprint, and requires centralized trust in a single authority, while bulk data transmission forces
institutions to yield operational control of their data.
1.3 Interoperability
Interoperability of healthcare records is the extent to which the clinical intent can be conveyed across
institutional boundaries. Given the complexities of data in the healthcare domain, this is inherently difficult
to achieve[9]. We examine interoperability within the context of two facets: Structure and Semantics, each
necessary for the successful exchange of healthcare data[10].
Data structure, or the attributes and data elements use to convey information, is an important part of
interoperability. Healthcare data is complex, and heterogeneous structures decrease the effectiveness of anal-
ysis and reduce understandability. To combat this, several industry -wide standards have been advanced[11].
While effective, there is no one authoritative standard, and aligning data encoded with disparate standards
is a non-trivial task.
Semantics refers to the use of terminologies and vocabularies to describe data meaning, or to codify the
data. This codification of healthcare data is important to its interpretation, but is only effective if all parties
agree upon the same codification schemes, or controlled terminologiesilq. Often, subsets of vocabularies are
used to scope a particular domain of interest. These subsets, called Value Sets, may be used in conjunction
with structural models to constrain the allowable codifications for attributes or attribute types.
2 Goals
The main goal of this work is to describe an approach to effectively and securely share healthcare information
within a data sharing network. We believe that a patient's record should be consistent and available across
institutional boundaries, and the terms of its access strictly dictated by the patient. As a secondary goal,
this data should not only be shared, but shared in such a way that all interested parties can understand the
structure and meaning, ultimately leading to improved data utility and patient care.
3 Proposal
3.1 Assumptions
Below are general assumptions about healthcare stakeholders (or nodes) participating in a data sharing
network. These assumptions exclude any regulation/incentives that the network itself defines.

1. There is value in receiving external data from other nodes, but only if you can understand the data
structure and semantics.
2. Without guarantees of security and auditability, nodes will neither share nor receive data.
3. The patient ultimately controls their record, and authorizes who may access it and when.
3.2 Background
3.2.1 Blockchain
A blockchain is a distributed transaction ledger[13]. The blockchain itself is composed of blocks, with each
block representing a set of transactions. As a data structure, a blockchain has several interesting properties.
First, blocks are provably immutable. This is possible because each block contains a hash, or numeric digest
of its content, that can be used to verify the integrity of the containing transactions. Next, the hash of a
block is dependent on the hash of the block before it. This effectively makes the entire blockchain history
immutable, as changing the hash of any block a — i would also change the hash of block n.
The blockchain itself does not depend on a central, trusted authority. Rather, it is distributed to all nodes
participating in the network. Because no centralized authority may verify the validity of the blockchain,
2
a mechanism for reaching network consensus mast be employed. In Bitcoin, a Proof of Work function is
used to ensure network consensus[13]. This strategy requires that any node wishing to add a block to the
blockchain must complete a computationally expensive (but easily verifiable) puzzle first. At a high level,
this ensures consensus of the network because there is an opportunity cost (the computation time) to building
a block. There are several other techniques used, such Proof of Stake[14] and Proof of Activity[15], but all
are designed to drive the network to consensus on blockchain validity.
Miners are nodes that assemble the blocks and add them to the blockchain. It is through the miners that
the consensus strategy is enacted, usually via seine incentivisation protocol. In Bitcoin, for example, miners
are incentivized by collecting transaction fees and also by a reward for adding the block to the blockchain.
In general, however, there should exist an incentive for them to only build on top of valid blocks, which in
turn drives the entire network to consensus.
3.2.2 Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources
Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources (FHIR)[16, 17, 18, 19] is an emerging standard that depicts data
formats and elements, along with providing publicly accessible Application Programming Interfaces (APIs)
for the purpose of exchanging Electronic Health Records. The standard was created and is managed by
the Health Level Seven International (HL7) healthcare standards organization. FHIR is licensed without
restriction or royalty requirements, which should serve to further facilitate its broader adoption. FHIR offers
the potential for increased utilization of mobile and cloud-based applications, medical device integration, and
flexible/customized healthcare workflows. FHIR enables the separation of EHR data elements into defined
structured data types known as resources. Two of the resource types pertain to identification (providers and
patients) and common clinical activities. The segmented resource constructs of FHIR facilitate the transfer of
portions of EHR data where appropriate or desired. FHIR resources follow Representational State Transfer
(ReST)(20] principles, and can be validated for structural conformance to the standard as well as further
refined by additional conformance statements called Profiles.
3.3 A Healthcare Blockchain
Because a blockchain is a general-purpose data structure, it is possible to apply it to domains other than
digital currency. Healthcare, we believe, is one such domain. The challenges of a patient record are not
unlike those of a distributed ledger. For example, a patient may receive care at multiple institutions. From
the patient's point of view, their record is a single series of sequential care events, regardless of where these
events were performed. This notion of shared state across entities, inherent to the blockchain model, is
congruent with patient expectations. Also, it is reasonable to assume that each patient care event was
influenced by one or more events before it. For example, a prescription may be issued only after a positive
lab test was received. The notion of historical care influencing present decisions fits well into the blockchain
model, where the identity of a present event is dependent on all past events.
Figure 1 describes the structure of a block of healthcare data. Much like the Bitcoin approach, our block
is a Merkle Tree-based structure[21]. The leaf nodes of this tree represent patient record transactions, and
describe the addition of a resource to the official patient record. Transactions, however, do not include the
actual record document. Instead, they reference FHIR Resources via Uniform Resource Locators (URLs).
This allows institutions to retain operational control of their data, but more importantly, keeps sensitive
patient data out of the blockchain. FHIR was chosen as a exchange format not only because it is an emerging
standard, but also because it contains inherent support for provenance and audit trails, making it a suitable
symbiotic foundation for blockchain ledger entries. FHIR in conjunction with the blockchain can serve to
preserve the integrity and associated context of data transactions.
A transaction has the following characteristics:
- Hash: The SHA256 hash of the resource payload. Although the actual resource itself is not entered
into the blockchain, its content can be verified using the transaction hash upon retrieval.
- Contributor Signature: The digital signature of the originating node.
- FHIR URL: A reference to the actual FHIR resource location.
3
- FHIR Profile: The URI of the FHIR Profile to which this resource conforms.
- Secure Index: An encrypted index allowing for data discovery without leaking information about
the record. See Section 3.6 for more information.
The hashes of all transactions in a block contribute to the hash of the Merkle Root, or Block Header. The
Block Header contains the following metadata used to validate the new block:
- Hash: The SHA256 hash of the block. Assume the NIerkle Root has two children co and c1, with a
previous block b„_ i. Let the hash of b„ equal the hash of the hashed concatenation of the of the bn_i,
co, and c1 hashes.
- Previous Block Hash: The hash of the previous block, for validation purposes.
- Contributor Signatures: For each node that contributed to the block, a digital signature is required.
This is to ensure that the block remains valid after it was assembled by the miner.
- Miner Elections: Each node that contributed to the block is required to provide a random number
encrypted with the node's private key. This will be used to seed the election of the next miner, which
is discussed in section 3.5.
Block Meader
Hash
Plovious Block Hash
Contnbulor Signatures
Miner Elections
Hash •— Hash(Taltlash • Tx2.Huh)
TfellSOCt10111
Rash
COntrobulOg Signature
FHIR URL
FHIR Probe
Secure Index
Nash Hash(Tx3.Hash • Mail***
Figure 1: A healthcare blockchain block containing entries into the patient record.
3.4 Adding Data to the Blockchain
Figure 2 outlines the basic activities involved in adding data to the blockchain. In our system, much
like Bitcoin, a block is added to the blockchain at regular intervals of time. For Bitcoin, this interval is
determined by the difficulty of the Proof of Work function. For our network, we specify a constant interval
of time for creating a block, or a block period. Within this block period, the network undergoes four phases
of activity. First, during the Transaction Distribution phase starting at time T0, transactions are sent to the
coordinating, or miner node. This phase continues until T6, when the miner node may stop accepting new
transactions for the block. The miner then assembles the new block and sends it to the nodes for review in
the Block Verification Request phase. This allows all nodes that have contributed at least one transaction
to digitally sign the block, indicating that they endorse its correctness. The block is then returned to the
miner in the Signed Block Return phase. The miner node then adds the block to its local blockchain, and
finally distributes the new blockchain in the last phase, New Blockchain Distribution.
Algorithm 1 describes this process in more detail. Transactions are collected starting at line 3. Note that
the miner cannot mine its own transactions, as shown in line 4 where it is excluded from the set of nodes
N. When signing the block, only nodes with at least one transaction in the block are required to sign. This
computation is shown in line 7. At the end of this algorithm, the blockchain is distributed to all nodes.
4
Time
T,
Transaction
Distribution
Block Verification
Request
Signed Stock
Return
New Biockchain
Distribution
To
Figure 2: The four phases of adding a block to the healthcare blockchain.
Algorithm 1: Creating a new block and adding it to the blockchain.
input : A set N of Nodes participating in the network.
input : A blockchain, B representing a sequence of {60...64 where b„ is the current (last) block
on the chain.
input : T6, the end of the Message Distribution phase.
1 a 4- ElectMinerNode(b n,N);
2 P 4— {}; //Begin with an empty set of pending transactions.
s while CurrentTime() < T6 do
4
[
foreach n E N— {a} do
5 LP<- PUCetTransactionsFromNode(n);

• AssembleBlock(P);
7 N' E Arl(Bort E P A IsOriginator(n,t)1}; //N I. is an nodes with >= 1 transaction.
• foreach n E N' do
e L SignBlock(bp,n);
ro B' AddBlock(B, bp)
rr foreach n E N do
12 L Dist ribut eliaockchain(fr, n) ;
3.5 Mining
We use the term Mining to refer to adding blocks to the blockchain. The general intent is similar to that of
Bitcoin, but our use case demands a substantially different approach. An overarching goal of the network is to
avoid a Proof of Work model, where network computational power is expended without providing something
intrinsically valuable. Rather, we aim to arrive at network consensus by forcing nodes to provide proof that
the data a transaction references can be meaningfully interpreted, while at the same time requiring nodes to
verify these validity proofs. This mechanism, described below, not only ensures blockchain consistency, but
incentivizes interoperability among the nodes.
3.5.1 Proof of Interoperability
Proof of Interoperability is an alternative method for network consensus that avoids some of the of disadvan-
tages of Proof of Work. Specifically, it is designed to leverage the effort required to reach network consensus
to do something intrinsically valuable: to verify that incoming messages are interoperable with regard to a
known set of structural and semantic constraints. For our use case, the mechanism for designating these
interoperability constraints is the FHIR Profile. Profiles in FHIR are a mechanism to further constrain a
5
FHIR resource by introducing a model for computable conformance statements. This conformance is both
structural and semantic, allowing not only structural constraints on attributes such as cardinality and type,
but semantic constraints using value sets.
Algorithm 2 describes the process in greater detail. Given a transaction, the specified FHIR Profile
is compared to the known set of allowable Profiles. If the Profile is recognized, conformance to the Profile
is checked via the CheckProfileConformance function. This operation will ase the FHIR URL to make a
validate' request to the FHIR server. The result of this request is a FHIR OperationOutcome response,
which can then be inspected for conformance by the Conforms function.
Algorithm 2: Proof of Interoperability.
input : A set P of pending transactions.
input : A set F of network agreed -upon FHIR Profile URIs.
input : b0, the current block being assembled.
output : A set V of valid transactions.
1 V 4- 0; //Begin with an empty set of valid transactions.
2 foreach t E P do
s u <— CetFhirURL(t);
4 p F CetFhirProfile(t);
5 if p E F then
cs result <- CheckProfileConformance(u,p); //Using the FHIR `validate' operation.
7 if Conforms(resuit) then
v<_vv{t};
Proof of Interoperability does require the network to reach consensus on the set of allowed FHIR Profiles,
including the content of the attendant value sets. This consensus cannot, however, be reached programtnat-
ically. Network agreement is most likely a human -based process, where network participants negotiate and
collaborate with the help of both terminology specialists and clinicians. This type of collaboration necessi-
tates a centralized, well known repository. For the value sets, we propose the use of the Value Set Authority
Center (VSAC)[22J as a value set repository.
3.5.2 Miner Election
In a Proof of Work scenario, miners compete for the right to add a block to the blockchain. We instead
employ a system of guaranteed mining share, similar to the system employed by MultiaminI23). This
system has several advantages. First, nodes know at the start of the block period who the next miner will
be, so transactions may he sent directly instead of distributed to the entire network. Next, it ensures that
the mining work required to keep the network consistent is distributed evenly. Finally, by eliminating the
competition of Proof of Work, we eliminate wasted computational effort.2
The Miner Election process is described in Algorithm 3. Recall that the last step of adding a block to
the blockchain is for the participating nodes to sign it (see Algorithm 1). During this signing process, each
node is required to submit a random number to be used for miner election. This set of random numbers is
collected on line 1, and is hashed together with the block hash to produce a new number. The next miner
then becomes the node whose Public Key is closest to this value. This process serves two purposes: (1) The
probability of becoming a miner for any node in the network N should be 1/INS, and (2) the random number
used for election is seeded by all participating nodes in the network. This prevents a node from generating
a non-random number and electing itself or a chosen collaborator.
I helps: //www .h17.org/fhir/resource-operations.html#validate
2We do not assert that Proof of Work effort is strictly wasted. The work expended by nodes in a Proof of Work system
certainly has value, as it is the mechanism by which the network stays consistent.
6
Algorithm 3: Miner Election.
input : A set N of Nodes participating in the network.
input : The current (last) block on the blockchain, block bn.
output : A randomly elected miner node a.
S SetRandomSeed(b.);
2 h GetSlockliash(b.);
s foreach s E S do
4 L h Hash(h+s);
s a 4— where iGetPublicKey(n) — hi is minimized for node it;
3.6 Data Discovery and Access
Even though the block itself does not contain the actual record data, searchability and discoverability
remain requirements, as well as a mechanism to access data once the appropriate transactions are found.
External entities, with the appropriate permissions, may query the blockchain using keywords in the Secure
Index held of the transaction. These keywords may be encrypted to prevent data leakage while still being
searehable[24, 2]. Once the transactions of interest are located, the FHIR URL can be used to retrieve the
actual resource.
3.7 Security
As stated above, data security (both privacy and anonymity) are fundamental priorities for the system. A
multi -faceted approach to security for our proposed network includes:
Blockchain Encryption. Nothing in the blockchain should be stored in plain text. Public information,
or information intended for all nodes in the network, is expected to be encrypted by a network -shared key,
while sensitive information should he encrypted by the originating node.
Privacy Preserving Keyword Searches. To facilitate data searchability and discoverability, Privacy
Preserving Keyword Searches[24] are used. In this way, an external entity may request a set of transactions
from the blockchain matching some criteria, with both the query and the transactions remaining encrypted.
Smart Contracts. In reality, the security landscape around the patient record is much more nuanced than
simply encrypting data. Patients may authorize access to their record only under certain conditions or for
a specific reason. This notion of the codification of usage agreements is called smart contracts[25]. There is
precedent for their use on a blockchain (e.g., the Ethereum project[26]), and given the complexities involved
with our healthcare use case, smart contracts will play an important role. The intent is to ensure that
patient authorization is codified and executable - for example. a patient may want their data shared only
for research of a certain type, or for a given time range. These smart contracts can be placed directly on the
blockchain as transactions[27], providing not only assurances of validity but an audit mechanism as well.
3.8 Patient Identification
Consistently identifying a patient between institutions is a non-trivial problem. Many approaches involve
some variation of a centralized Master Patient Index (MP0[23], or a single trusted identifier source. This
approach has many of the same disadvantages as centralizing patient data - mainly, it requires centralized
trust and consolidates valuable information in a single, known place. While a robust MPI discussion is
beyond the scope of this work, we can apply some of the design approaches used here. Borrowing from the
Bitcoin model, we can think of data on the blockchain assigned to addresses, not patients, with patients
controlling the keys to these addresses. The advantage to this approach is that consensus on a single identifier
does not need to be reached - a patient may hold multiple blockchain addresses for different institutions.
This notion requires the patient to manage and maintain keys to these addresses via an electronic wallet,
and is a significant deviation from current practices where institutions assign and own patient identifiers.
7
4 Business Value
Both the patient and the provider are positioned to benefit from a robust data exchange platform. Viewed
from both perspectives, one may see that the quantifiable benefits gained by providers and organizations[5]
are paralleled by greater convenience and better care outcomes for the patient.
Patient Perspective:
- Patients no longer need to coordinate the tedious and frustrating task of gathering records from various
providers to send to their specialist. Instead, they would provide the specialist access to the blockchain,
enabling them access to the data as they see fit.
- Patients retain control of their data without having to be data stewards - meaning, they no longer
have to spend time and energy keeping their data managed and up to date. They also no longer need
to manually reconcile the data when they visit multiple providers, which can be a non-trivial task.
- Ultimately, better and more available data leads to better care for the patient.
Provider and Organization Perspective:
- The true collaborative nature of creating and sharing data would eliminate many of the challenges of
existing Health Information Exchange approaches.
- Healthcare organizations do not have to fight for a data -driven competitive advantage, because they
all have access to the same information. This approach will enable organizations to collaborate on care
coordination and outcomes -based care.
- Through existing trust/contracts with patients and partner hospitals/organizations, nodes can broad-
cast alerts or potential threats.
- Data can be shared for research activities including clinical trials, enabling larger and more diverse
patient populations.
5 Summary
The challenges of data sharing within the healthcare domain are significant. Simply sharing data is not
enough - we've shown that effective data sharing networks require consensus on data syntax, meaning, and
security. We've proposed that a blockchain can play a fundamental role in enabling data sharing within a
network, and have defined the high level structures and protocols necessary to apply this new technology to
healthcare. Building on techniques used successfully by other blockchain applications, we've introduced a
new consensus algorithm designed to facilitate data interoperability. Finally, we have applied extra measures
of security on the blockchain such as network -wide keys and smart contracts, keeping security a top priority.
Ultimately, we believe that a blockchain-based data sharing network is a tenable solution for the complex
problem of sharing healthcare data.
6 Future Directions
6.1 Aggregate Blockchains
In this work, we've explored how nodes in a data sharing network may interact. Intuitively, we can con-
ceptualize these nodes as individual institutions or providers. This mental model aligns to current Heath
Information Exchanges. which tend to be (at least in the United States) groupings of regional providers[29].
But what if we reconsider our definition of a node in the network? Envision a node not as a single institution,
but as an entire blockebain-based data sharing network. We can now imagine not only cross-institutional
sharing, but cross-network sharing as well. This would enable the institution/provider-based networks to
grow and evolve, at the same time allowing them to connect to similar networks. This notion of aggregation,
or nested blockchains, may be an approach to extending the reach of collaborations and sharing beyond local
networks.
8
6.2 Machine Learning
With the rapid improvement in computational power and machine learning algorithms, blockchain technol-
ogy can help facilitate a mechanism to compensate an Artificial Intelligence (AI) service provider for the
development and execution of novel machine learning algorithms. For example, developing machine learning
algorithms that can look at a radiology image or CT scan and make diagnosis predictions are time con-
sinning to develop, but once developed are easy to execute. By leveraging blockchain technology, one can
envision a world in which a service provider publishes FHIR DiagnosticReports of radiology images to the
blockchain. An AI service provider that specializes in developing novel machine learning algorithms with
which the hospital has partnerships would be allowed to rim their algorithm over the images and publish
the Al diagnosis output back to the blockchain.
The radiologist at the hospital could then use this result as an independent reference to compare his or
her own diagnosis. The AI providers get compensated when their diagnosis matches that of the radiologist,
so there is an incentive for the AI providers to refine and keep improving the accuracy of their algorithms.
The blockchain also provides an irrefutable trail of what the AI provider diagnosed and the final official
diagnosis.
References
[1] Yaorong Ge, David K Ahn, Bhagyashree Unde, H Donald Gage, and J Jeffrey Carr. Patient -controlled
sharing of medical imaging data across unaffiliated healthcare organizations. Journal of the American
Medical Informatics Association, 20(1):157-163, 2013.
[2] Chris Clifton, Murat Kantarcioglu, AnHai Doan, Gunther Schadow, Jaideep Vaidya, Ahmed Elma-
garmid, and Dan Stiehl. Privacy -preserving data integration and sharing. In Proceedings of the 9th
ACM SIGMOD Workshop on Research Issues in Data Mining and Knowledge Discovery, pages 19-26.
ACM, 2004.
[3] Joshua R Vest and Larry D Gamin. Health Information Exchange: persistent challenges and new
strategies. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 17(3):288-294, 2010.
[4] Paul C Tang, Joan S Ash, David \V Bates, J Marc Overhage, and Daniel Z Sands. Personal health
records: definitions, benefits, and strategies for overcoming barriers to adoption. Journal of the American
Medical Informatics Association, 13(2):121-126, 2006.
[5] Jan Walker, Eric Pan, Douglas Johnston, Julia Adler-Milstein, et al. The value of health care information
exchange and interoperability. Health Affairs, 24:W5, 2005.
[6] Randolph C Barrows and Paul D Clayton. Privacy, confidentiality, and electronic medical records.
Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 3(2):139-148, 1996.
Centers for Disease Control, Prevention, et al. HIPAA privacy rule and public health. Guidance from
CDC and the US Department of Health and Human Services. AI AIIVR: Morbidity and Mortality Weekly
Report, 52(Suppl. 1):1-17, 2003.
[8] US GPO. CFR§ 164 security and privacy. 2008. http://www.access.gpo.gov/
nara/cfr/waisklx_08/45cfr164_08.html. Accessed: 2016-08-06.
[9] Charles N Mead et al. Data interchange standards in healthcare it-computable semantic interoperability:
Now possible but still difficult. do we really need a better mousetrap? Journal of Healthcare Information
Management, 20(1):71, 2006.
[10] Amit P Sheth. Changing focus on interoperability in information systems: from system, syntax, struc-
ture to semantics. In Interoperating Geographic Information Systems, pages 5-29. Springer, 1999.
[11] A Begoyan. An overview of interoperability standards for electronic health records. USA: Society for
Design and Process Science, 2007.
[71
9
[121 James J Cimino et al. Desiderata for controlled medical vocabularies in the twenty-first century. Methods
of Information in Medicine-Methodik der Information in der Medisin, 37(4):394-403, 1998.
[131 Satoshi Nakarnoto. Bitcoin: A peer-to -peer electronic cash system, 2008.
[141 Sunny King and Scott Nadal. PPCoin: Peer-to-peer crypto-currency with proof-of-stake. Self-Published
Paper, August, 19, 2012.
[15J hide Bentov, Charles Lee, Alex Mizrahi, and Meth Rosenfeld. Proof of activity: Extending bitcoin's
proof of work via proof of stake. ACM SIG METRICS Performance Evaluation Review, 42(3):34-37,
2014.
[16J HL7. HL7 Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources (FHIR). https://www.h17.org/fhir/. Accessed:
2016-08-01.
[11 Russell Leftwich. The path to deriving clinical value from FHIR - InterSystems.
http://www.intersystems.com/library/library-item/path-deriving-clinical-value-fhir/. Accessed:
2016-08-06.
[18] iNTERFACEWARE Inc. What is 'FHIR' and why you should care?
http://wvnv.interfaceware.com/blog/what-is-fhir-and-why-should-you-care/. Accessed: 2016-08-06.
[19] Tim Benson. Principles of health interoperability HL7 and SNOMED. Springer Science & Business
Media, 2012.
[20] Roy Thomas Fielding. Architectural styles and the design of network -based software architectures. PhD
thesis, University of California, Irvine, 2000.
[21J Leslie Lamport. Constructing digital signatures from a one-way function. Technical report, Technical
Report CSL-98, SRI International Palo Alto, 1979.
[22J Olivier Bodenreider, Duc Nguyen, Fishing Chiang, Philip Chuang, Maureen Madden, Rainer Winnen-
burg, Rob McClure, Steve Emrick, and Ivor DSouza. The NLM Value Set Authority Center. Studies
in Health Technology and Informatics, 192:1224, 2013.
[23] Steffan D Norberhuis. MultiChain: A cybercurrency for cooperation. PhD thesis, TU Delft, Delft
University of Technology, 2015.
[24] Yan-Cheng Chang and Michael Mitzenmacher. Privacy preserving keyword searches on remote encrypted
data. In International Conference on. Applied Cryptography and Network Security, pages 442-455.
Springer, 2005.
[251 Nick Szabo. Formalizing and securing relationships on public networks. First Monday, 2(9), 1997.
[261 Vitalik Buterin. A next -generation smart contract and decentralized application platform. White Paper,
2014.
[27] Loi Luu, Jason Teutsch, Raghav Kulkarni, and Prateek Saxena. Demystifying incentives in the consensus
computer. In Proceedings of the 22nd ACM SIOSAC Conference on Computer and Communications
Security, pages 706-719. ACM, 2015.
[28J Peter Littlejohns, Jeremy C Wyatt, and Linda Garvican. Evaluating computerised health information
systems: hard lessons still to be learnt. BhfJ, 326(7394):860-863, 2003.
[29J Ashish K Jha, David Doolan, Daniel Grandt, Tim Scott, and David \V Bates. The use of health
information technology in seven nations. International Journal of Medical Informatics, 77(12):848-854,
2008.
10
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Benjamin Wegg-Prosser [europe] CEO of Peter Mandelson's failed lobbying firm Global Counsel 
                              Bechet Allen [arts] daughter of Woody Allen and Soon-Yi Previn 
                                     Boris Collardi [bank] CEO of the Swiss bank Julius Baer 
                                                               Julius Baer [bank] Swiss bank 
                              Brad Karp [lawyer] head of the law firm Paul, Weiss [guardian] 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00507197 (Jmail)
 [tech] Sarah Kellen personal address book
(approximate date: 2016-09-16)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024328.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024328.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Case Data: Contacts (401-500 of 3037)
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Bamaby
Marsh
2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
2017-11-09 15:31:26 (UTC)
6633
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Bamaby
Last Marsh
ID 12986
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Bamaby Marsh
Email (Email)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Barrack
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-14 20:41:48 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 81
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Barrack
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
ID 950
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Barry
Last Josephson
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 604
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Barry
Last Josephson
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-02-04 17:57:57 (UTC)
ID 495
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Barry
Last Zelin
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC) Date
ID 6328
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Barry
Last Loudermilk
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Work)
Email ()
Creation Date 2018-09-22 22:51:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-09-22 22:51:55 (UTC)
ID 6890
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Barry
Last Zelin
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
ID 400
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Barry
Last Josephson
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-02-04 17:57:57 (UTC)
ID 601
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First Bany J. Cohen
Email (Email)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Bechet
Last Allen
ID 68871
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bechet
Last Allen
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Address (Home)
Address (Other)
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
Modification Date 2019-03-18 01:12:27 (UTC)
ID 6191
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First behnbom
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 297
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First behnbom
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC) Date
ID 6644
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First bella
Last klein
ID 29
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bella
Last Klein
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 62
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bella
Last Klein
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 667
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First bellaklein
Email (Email)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Belova
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
ID 681
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Belova
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 1542
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ben
Last Laurie
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 595
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ben
Last Goertzel
Email (Home)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
ID 516
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ben
Last Laurie
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC) Date
ID 6645
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ben
Last Goertzel
Email (Home)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
Nlodification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 155
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ben
Last Bram
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5230
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Ben
Last Goertzel
ID 3912
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ben
Last Bram
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
ID 221
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Benjamin
Last Wegg-Prosser
Email (Home)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:45 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-0902:38:45 (UTC) Date
ID 6399
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Benjamin
Last Wegg-Prosser
Email (Home)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 308
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bennet
Middle J.
Last Moskowitz
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC) Date
ID 6461
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bennet
Middle J.
Last Moskowitz
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 395
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First benny
Last shabtai
ID 89026
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-05-21/Benny on 2019-04-30 at 10.31.3
1.ichat
SourceType iChat
First Benny
Instant Message (iChat 19179725080 ID)
ID 1395573
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Benny
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
ID 1591
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Benny
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:13 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
ID 5514
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application SupportlSkype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Benny
Last Shabtai
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID 89022
Source Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Rece
nts/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Benny
Phone Number (Phone
Number)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
1139
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bernard
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:09 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
ID 4868
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bernard
Last Kruger
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Work)
Phone Number 0
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-06-06 10:09:19 (UTC)
ID 808
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bernard
Last Kruger
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 513
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bernard
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 1608
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Rece
nts/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Bernard Kruger
Phone Number (Phone
Number)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First bertill
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC) Date
ID 6537
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First bertill
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
ID 1530
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Bertille
Last Saulnier
ID 42
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Beth
Last Flansbaum-Talabisco
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 588
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Beth
Last Flansbaum-Talabisco
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:45 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC) Date
ID 6372
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First beynbeynbeyn
ID 12894
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First bgC3
ID 7588
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2016-09-21 07:01:09 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
4781
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2012-02-01 16:53:54 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-02-01 16:53:56 (UTC)
ID 1355
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-02-01 16:53:56 (UTC)
ID 1587
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bill
Last Siegel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC) Date
ID 6655
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bill
Last Conover
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 391
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First bill
Last riley
Email (Home) "William Riley" -MIMIMI=>
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
Nlodification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 813
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bill
Last Dunseth
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 1506
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Work)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Bill
Bums
2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
6233
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Bill
Dunseth
2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC)
2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC)
5125
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Bill
Elkus
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 590
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Home)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
bill
riley
"William Riley" <MIMINI=>
2010-12-14 20:41:48 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 100
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bill
Last Elkus
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC) Date
ID 6207
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bill
Last Conover
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 7?
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bill
Last Siegel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
ID 1578
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First bmarsh.templeton.org
ID 10388
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bob
Last Anderson
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC) Date
ID 6313
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bob
Last Anderson
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
1D 501
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Bob
Last Keny
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
ID 6620
Contact
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(WorkFAX)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Work)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B
022-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Bobby
Slayton Bobby
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
6300
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 169
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Bojana
ID 20737
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
ID 1603
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Boreh
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Boreh
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
ID 6682
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Rece
nts/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Boreh
Phone Number (Phone 447552550550 Number)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Boris
Last Nikolic
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-02-04 17:57:57 (UTC)
ID 706
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/916B364D-8EB5-48B8-90
D2-9403585F56B9/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Boris
Last Collardi
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2017-11-13 02:42:43 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-13 02:42:45 (UTC)
Organization Julius Baer
ID I
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Boris
Nikolic
90899
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Boris
Nikolic
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-02-04 17:57:57 (UTC)
ID 355
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Boris
Nikolic
2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
175
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Work)
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Home)
Creation Date
Modification Date
Note
ID
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Boris
2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
boris
boris
474
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Phone
Number)
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Home)
Creation Date
Modification Date
Note
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Rece
nts/Recents
Recents
Boris
1428976
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Boris
2010-12-14 20:41:48 (UTC)
2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
boris
boris
ID 74
Source Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email 0
Creation Date
Mac AddressBook
Boris
Collardi
2017-11-10 20:56:18 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-13 15:46:04 (UTC)
Julius Baer
6754
Organization
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraiy/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Boris Colatdi
2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
ID 6174
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Phone Number Q
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraiy/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Brad
S
Karp
2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
2018-10-30 23:39:36 (UTC)
5500
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraiy/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Brad
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
ID 6609
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Brad
Middle S
Last Karp
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 299
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Brad
Last Harris
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
ID 541
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B0
22-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Brad
Last Edwards
Phone Number
(Work)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Address (Work)
Email CI
Creation Date
Modification Date
Job Title
Organization
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
2018-03-26 15:31:27 (UTC)
2019-03-18 01:12:27 (UTC)
Attorney
EDWARDS POTTINGER LLC
6823
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Brad
Harris
2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
5331
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Brian
Webster
2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
6628
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Brian
Webster
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 638
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Brian
Last Webster
ID 90742
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Brian
Last Boyd
ID 2314
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Brian
Last Greene
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:45 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)

11) 6417
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Brice
Last Gordon
Phone Number (Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 578
Source Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Rece
nts/Recents
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Phone
Number)
ID
Recents
Brice
1428976
Case Data: Contacts (301-400 of 3037) Case Data: Contacts (501-600 of 3037)
EFTA01286368 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank bank statements showing receipt of $2 million from Jeepers, Inc.
(inferred date: 2016-09-30)
Deutsche Bank El
Deutsche Bank Must Co. Americas
345 Park Avenue - NYC20-0102
New York. NY 10154
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QTR. B3
SAINT THOMAS
00802
UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
For personal assistance call:
Steuart Oldfield
212-454-2881
September 1. 2016 lo September 30. 2016
8 Enclosures
Summary of Account Etalamx(s)
Account Aecotua Number Balance
Elite Checking With Interco SI.765 042.26
Beginning Balance as or scptennwr 1. 2016 52.064.949.66
I kilos its and Other Credits $2.0,30,775.63
Checks Paid (5832.365.15 )
ATM and Debit Card Withdrawals 50.00
&nice Charges and Other Fees 50.00
Other Debits ISI.468.317 88 )
Ending Balance as of September 30. 2016 SI.765.042.26
Transaction Detail
Dale Description Debit Credit Balance
Be¢iming Balance as of September 1. 2016 52 064949.66
09-01 to Outgoing Money Tmsf 00.(00.00 ) 2,054,949.66
TO VALLEY NATIONAL BANK •
AlTERBURY. GOLDBERGER AND WEISS P
.A
09-01 # Outgoing Money Tmsf
TO BANK OF AMERICA, N.A. NY
(3.003.00 ) 2.051.946.66
09-06 to Cash Mgmt Tnfr Dr
REF 2501551 L FUNDS TRANSFER TO
DEP 42953467 FROM
(1.000.000.00 ) 1.051.946.66
All items are credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceedi in cash a by unconditional credit to anti 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Ante-rico
35269691
I of 5 SDNY_GM_00042858
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0005682
Deutsche Bank
Date Description Debit Credit Balance
09-06 g Outgoing Money Tnts1 (529.99 ) 1.051.416.67
1'0 TD BANK, NA. -
09-06 g Reauthorized Debit (21.174.78 ) 1030.241.89
102091000014932751
AC II PNET AMEX EPAYMENT
0946 Preauthorized Debit (7.600.00 ) 1.022.641.89
102091000015099689
ACII PMT AMEX EPavinent
09-07 ft Reauthorized Debit (25.004.03 ) 997.607.86
101091000015708790
ACII PMT AMEX EPAYMENT
09-07 4 Preauthorized Debit (1,976.80 ) 995,631.06
101091000015708808
CCPY3ff WELLS FARGO CARD
0948 Check 1067 (7.500.00 ) 988.131.06
09-08 ft Outgoing Money Tntsf (760.50 ) 987370.56
TO FIRSTMERIT BANK. N.A.
■ MCDONALD HOPKINS LW 1OLTA ACCGLI
NT
09-08 ft Outgoing Money Trust'
TO SANTANDER BANK. N.A.M
MARTIN G. WEINBERG, PC
09-09 ft Incoming Money Tmsf
ORO-N40-024935• I JEEPERS INC 6100 R
ED HOOK QUARTER B 3 ST THOMAS VI 00
090913108154C003948
0949 ft Outgoing Money Trust
TO BANK OF AMERICA, NA, NY
(7.267.00 ) 980.103.56
2.000.0(th.00 2.980.103.56
(5,000.00 ) 2,975,103.56
09-09 "Outgoing Money Inn:
TO TD WANK. NA •
(639.00 ) 2.974.464.56
09-13 ft Preauthonza Debit (87.519.13 ) 2.886.945.43
1010910000! 8745489
ACH PMT AMEX EPAYMENT
09-14 0 Outgoing Money Trust (477.00 ) 2.886.468.43
TO BANK OF AMERICA. N.A. NY
09.14 ft Preauthorized Debit (113,794.80 ) 2,772,673.63
102091000019507971
ACII PMT AMEX EPAYMENT
09-15 Cheek 1069 (7,500.00 ) 2.765.173.63
09-16 a Preauthorized Debit (7,195.15 ) 2,757,978.48
101091000010888451
ACID PN1T AMEN EPAYMENT
09-16 0 Reauthorized Debit (113.17 ) 2.757,865.31
101091000010888638
CCPYMT WELLS FARGO CARD
09-19 Check 1068 (750.000.00 ) 2.007.865.31
09-20 k Reauthorized Debit (119.986.69 ) 1187.878.62
MI0910000'1855747
ACII PMT AMEX EPayment
MI items at credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceeds in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
35269691
2of5 SDNY_GM_00042859
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0005683
Deutsche Bank
lute   Description Debit Credit Balance
09-21 Check 1057 (5.400.00 ) 1.882.478.62
09-22 fr Outgoing Money Tmsf (25,000.00 ) 1.857.478.62
TO BANK OF AMERICA. N.A. NI' MEI
09-22 # Outgoing Money Tmsf (1.950.00 ) 1.855.528.62
TO PNC BANK. NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
BALLARD SPAI1R LLP
09-22 ft Preauthorized Debit
101091000013808200
CCPYNff WELLS FARO* CARD
09-23 # Deposit
0150010140
09-23 # Outgoing Money Tmsf
TO DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO AMERICAS,
NIKOLAY ALEK
SANDROVICH GYROV
09-27 # Preauthorized Debit
101091000015241644
ACID PMT AMEX EPAYMENT
09-28 Check 1071 (13.065.00 )
09-29 Cheek 1074 (7.500.00 )
09-30 Check 1072 (32.525.15 )
09-30 Check 1073 (8,875.00 )
09-30 ft Interest Payment
Ending Balance as of September 30. 2016 (2.300.683.03 )
(1.419.00 ) 1854.109.62
600.00 1,854,709.62
(1,700.00 ) 1,853,009.62
(26.177.84 ) 1.826.831.78
175.63
42.000.77543
1.813.766.78
1.806.266.78
1.773.741.63
1,764,866.63
1,765,042.26
81.765.042.26
Checks Paid
Number Date Amount Number Date Amount Number Date Amount
1057 09-21 5.400.00 1069 09.15 7,500.00 1071 09-30 8275.00
1067 • 09-08 7.50000 1071 • 09-28 13.065.03 1074 09-29 7.500.00
1068 09-19 750.000.00 1072 09-30 32.525.15 • Skip in check sequence
Deposits and Other Credits
Dale Description Amount
09-09 Incoming Money Tmsf 32030,000.00
09-23 Deposit $600.00
09-30 Interest Pa%ment $175.63
Service Charges and Other Ess
Total NSF return item fees for this thacmcnt priori 50.00
TOW NSF mum item fees for this calendar %car 30.00
Total Overdraft fees for this statement period $0.00
Total Overdraft fits for this calendar year 50.00
Other Ikbits
Date 0.ceription Amount
09-01 Outgoing Money Tmsf (810.000.00 )
09-01 Outgoing Money Tmsf (53,003.00 )
09-06 Cash Mgni Trsfr Dr (51.000.000.00 )
All items are credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceeth in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
35269691
3 of 5 SDNY_GM_00042860
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0005684
Deutsche Bank
Date Description .Amount
09-06 Outgoing Money Tung (S529.99_)
09.06 Preautiorized Debit (321.174.78 )
09-06 Preauthorized Debit (S7.6C0.00 )
09-07 Reauthorized Debit (325.034.03 )
09-07 Reauthorized Debit (31.976.80 )
09-08 Outgoing Money Tmsf (3760.50 )
09-08 Outgoing Money 'Bast (57.26700 )
09-09 Outgoing Money Tmid' (35.000.00 )
09-09 Outgoing Money Trust (5639.00 )
0943 Reauthorized Debit ($87,519.13 )
09-14 Outgoing Money Tmsf ($477.00 )
09-14 Preauthorized Debit ($113,794.80 )
09.16 Preauthorized Debit (57,195.15 )
09-16 Reauthorized Debit (S113.17 )
09-20 Preauthorized Debit (5119.986.69 )
09-22 Outgoing Money Inn! (525.000.00 )
09-22 Outgoing Money Inuit (31.950.00 )
09-22 Reauthorized Debit 419.00
09-23 Outgoing Moncs Tnuf (51.700.00 )
09-27 Preauthorized Debit (326.177.84 )
Interest Calculation
Annual Percentage Yield Limed 0.10%
Interest Earned This Period $175.63
Interest Paid Year To Dale $953.59
Alt items are credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceeds in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
*anted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
35269691
4 of5 SDNY_GM_00042861
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0005685
Deutsche Bank
In Case of Enron or Questions

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at 1-866-362-4796. or write to us at Deutsche Dank Trust Company Americas. 345 Park Avenue. WNI Banking 
Team -
NYC20-0102. New York New York 10154 as soon as you can. if you think your gateman or receipt is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MUST hear from you no later than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRST statement on which the error or problem appeared.

• Tell us your name and account number
- Describe the error or transfer you are unsure about. and explain as clearly as you can why you believe it is an error 
or %shy you
need more infoimation

• Tell in the dollar amount of the suspected error
Please note that if you initially provide the above information to If% via telephone. we may squire that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within 10 business days.
We will investigate your complaint and will correct any error promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 
days for new
accounts) to do this, we will provisionally credit your account for the amount you think is in error, so that you will 
have the use of the
money during the time it takes us to complete ow investigation At the conclusion of our involigation we will inform you 
of our results.

2. Non-Electronic Funds Transfers
Contact the Bank immediately at 1-866-362-4796 if vow statement is incorrect or if y041 need more information about any 
non-electronic
funds transactions (checks or deposits) on this statement. If any such error appears. you must notify the Belk in 
writing no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you. Please see vow Terms and Conditions for flintie r infonnmion on 
the terms
governing your account.

3. Verifying Preauthorized Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once every 60 days from the same person or 
company. you
can telephone us at 1.866-362.47% to find out whether the deposit has been made.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0005686
EFTA01616545 (Jmail)
 [academia] iMessage from Deepak Chopra screenshot(s)
(timestamp: 2016-10-09 22:01:25)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
Deepak

I not a predator
Just a lover
O 10:01:25 pm

Read
Deepak
2016/10/09
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
               Ike Groff [employee] maybe brother or husband of Lesley Groff? 
 Mangrove Partners [finance] Nathaniel August shockingly high performing fund 
                 Nathaniel August [finance] fund manager of Mangrove Partners 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00286949 (Jmail)
 [finance] Nathaniel August Mangrove Partners valuation report
(date: 2016-11-03)
Mangrove Fund& HFRX GL2 5(102
Prior Month (October 201611•+ +1 1.7" t).6' -1.8%
Year to Date (2016)4 +49.1% +0.8% +5.9%
Trailing Twelve Months 4 +49.2% -1.3% +4.5%
Since Inception (April 2010)4 +439.4% +0.6% +108.9%
Dear Partners:
The Funds had a gain in the month of October 2016 of 11.7%. At month -end, the portfolio's gross exposure
was 196% and its net exposure was +1%.s Our performance in October was due to substantial gains from both
long and short investments. The rate-of-return oriented portfolio also had small gains from stressed credit and
capital structure arbitrage investments which were partially offset by small losses from arbitrage and liquidation
investments. We are clearly very pleased by our recent performance, but it is obviously unsustainable.
Rather than include our normal discussion of an observation or perspective on the economy or market, we think
it would be helpful to reflect upon our performance over the past eight months. In order to keep this letter
subway-ride length, we will defer market and economic commentary until next month after the election. There
should then be plenty to discuss. Regarding our recent performance, we believe it is important to emphasize to
our partners that our portfolio construction is likely to result in some highly volatile months. When we construct
our portfolio, we try to select both long and short investments that will be profitable on an individual investment
level and we use our aggregate short exposure to reduce market risk. Importantly, we do not construct our short
portfolio to reduce the idiosyncratic or industry risk of our long investments. Because each of our investments is
chosen to produce its own profits, it is possible for both sides of our portfolio to make gains or losses in a given
period. While this can be spectacular, as was the case last month, it can also result in substantial losses if we get
the investments on both sides of our portfolio wrong. Even though we carefully choose each investment, we still
make many mistakes. We will also have periods when the market simply doesn't agree with us, as was the case in
2013 and 2015. As a result, the same portfolio that generates a greater than 10% return in a month could also
generate losses of more than 10% in another month. There's no free lunch in investing and we don't want to
mislead anyone just because it's been a while since we've had a setback.

In October, we finished exiting our long position in shares of Apollo Residential Mortgage, Inc. (Prior: AMTG),
although most of the position was exited in August. AMTG was a hybrid mortgage REIT which invested in a
leveraged mix of agency and non-agency debt. We have written in the past about our view that mortgage REITs
deserve to trade at or above book value when properly managed. We believe that well-managed non-agency
mortgage REITs represent sustainable, difficult to replicate, high-yielding fixed income portfolios that have the
ability to preserve book value and generate attractive ROEs in a wide range of interest rate environments. Based
on this view, we initiated our AMTG position in May 2013 at an approximate 5% discount to book value per
share after the company had, on average, traded at a premium to book value over the prior 12 month period.
Mangrove Partners I 645 Madison Avenue, I4 6 Floor, New York, NY 10022
ike ciroff - 2016-11-03 12:47:55
AMTG shares proceeded to promptly trade down more than 30% during the 2013 taper tantrum and traded
down even more after the company mismanaged its interest rate hedging, failed to execute on several credit
investment initiatives, and management refused to acknowledge its shortcomings. Largely as a result of the
interest rate hedging mismanagement, AMTG's book value per share declined by approximately 27% during our
ownership period, which was bottom quartile performance in its hybrid mortgage REIT group.

Throughout this period, we continued purchasing shares, including at prices more than 50% below our initial
investment, as we judged the combination of a double-digit dividend yield and at times greater than 30%
discount to book value an attractive risk to undertake. Ultimately, AMTG sold itself to a related party at a
discounted multiple of a depressed spot book value. To add insult to injury, we believe that the company
understated its book value on which the merger consideration was based, because it showed almost no rebound
in the value of its non-agency mortgages between the time of the merger announcement in February 2016 and
the time of the final determination of book value in July. Despite all of these circumstances, our investment in
AMTG was modestly profitable for the partnership due to our willingness to average down combined with the
company's high dividend yield and an active trading strategy that sought to profit from market volatility. In many
ways, we believe our small profit in light of all of the headwinds we faced supports our view that mortgage
REITs often make attractive investments.
We are grateful for your trust in us and welcome any comments or questions you have.
Sincerely,
v'e Nathanici August
Results reflect the performance of The Mangrove Partners Fund, L.P. ('U.S. Fund') and. beginning January 2013. the 
ocathined performance of the U.S. Fund and
The Mangrove Partners Fund (Cayman), Ltd. ('Cayman Fund' and. collectively with U.S. Fund. the -Funds* or 'Mangrove 
Funds'). An investor's actual performance
will vary based on a number of factors, including whether the investment was made n the U.S. Fund a the Cayman Fund, the
timing of the initial nvestrnent
editions and withdrawals. and participation in 'New Issues and 'Designated Investments.' Historical performance is not 
indicative of future results and such
differences may be material. Performance is reflected net of fees and expenses and assumes the reinvestment of al 
proceeds from the disposition of investments
and
dividends. The Funds are audited amually. Wenn periods are unaudited. This calculation estimates monthly management fees
at 0.167% and an ante'
performance alocation at 20%. Original letters for months prior to November 2012 reflect results based on a sample 
partner who invested only al Mention."
2 HFFtX Global Hedge Fund Index. produced by Hedge Fund Research. Inc.. is an index designed to be representative of the
overall hedge fund universe and is
comprised of funds representing at main hedge fund strategies. As a result. this index may include hedge fund strategies
that the Funds do not employ and the
hedge
funds underlying this index may make nvestments in asset classes and companies with market capitalizations and liquidity
ladies that differ from the Funds'
investments. The SW 500, produced by Standard & Poor's, Inc., is an index designed to be representative of the large cap
V.S. equities market. The S&P 500 is
adjusted to reflect the reinvestment of dividends. The Funds portfolio contains short investments as wet as securities 
issued by companies with varying
capitalization,
securities of non.U.S. companies. and derivatives. none of which are represented in this index. While Mangrove believes 
neither of these indices represents a
benchmark for the Funds, each is a broad index and is presented for informational purposes.

The estimated returns of the Funds fa October 2016 are +11.7% and +11.9% for the U.S. Fund and Cayman Fund, 
respectively.
Results include an estimate for the month immediately preceding the date of this letter, represent Mangrove Partners 
best estimate, and do not benefit from the
MI
accounting process Mat produces the final results for other months in the period. Actual performance may vary materially
from the estimate. Returns including
prior
periods include the prior month's estimate and the actual final returns for an other periods. The final return for 
September 2016 was +1.9% (+1.9% and +1.9% foe
the
U.S. Fund and Cayman Fund, respectively), versus the estimate of +2.0%.

s Net exposure is measured on a beta. and detta.adjusted basis in the long/short book only: gross exposure on a 
detta.adjusted basis.
This letter is confidential and not intended for public use or distribution. This letter does not constitute an offer to
sell or the solicitation of an offer to
buy any security which may only be made pursuant to the terms of the constituent documents of the relevant Fund, 
incising their respective,
current offering memoranda. The securities of the Funds may not be offered for sale or sold in any jurisdiction in which
such an offer or sale would be
unlawful. Specific investments ore described if, in Mangrove's view, they are interesting and lead to a better 
understanding of what Mangrove
invests in, the process by which Mangrove invests and the path such investments take. They are not intended to and do 
not represent the
performance of all investments or the Funds, It should not be assumed that investments mode in the future will be 
profitable or will equal the
performance of the securities discussed in this letter. Please see our quarterly letters for a schedule of the top five 
winners and bottom fi ve losers.
Mangrove Partners I 645 Madison Avenue, t46 Floor, New York, NY 10022 I
ike Groff - 2016-11-03 12:47:55
EFTA00039190 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons Special Housing Units
(date: 2016-11-23)
. U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
PROGRAM STATEMENT
OPI: CPD/CSB
NUMBER: 5270.11
DATE: November 23, 2016
Special Housing Units
Is,
Approved: Thomas R. Kane
Acting Director, Federal Bureau of Prisons

1. PURPOSE AND SCOPE
§ 541.20 Purpose.
This subpart describes the Federal Bureau of Prisons' (Bureau) operation of
special housing units (SHU) at Bureau institutions. The Bureau's operation of
SHUs is authorized by 18 U.S.C. 4042(a)(2) and (3).

a. Program Objectives. The expected results of this program are:
■ Special Housing Unit placement should always serve a specific penological purpose.
■ Inmates are housed in the least restrictive setting necessary to ensure their own safety, as well
as the safety of staff, other inmates, and the public.
■ A safe and orderly environment will be provided for staff and inmates.
■ Living conditions for inmates in disciplinary segregation and administrative detention will
meet or exceed applicable standards.
■ Accurate and complete records will be maintained on conditions and events in special
housing units.
Federal Regulations from 28 CFR are shown in this type.
Implementing instructions are shown in this type.

b. Summary of Changes
Policy Rescinded
P5270.10 Special Housing Units (7/29/11)
Memorandum from Assistant Director Scott Dodrill, Secure Housing Unit Operations, dated
3/2/10
Memorandum from Assistant Director Frank Strada, Special Housing Unit Training, dated
4/17/2015
The following changes have been incorporated into the policy:
■ Several changes have been implemented to adhere to Department of Justice recommendations
regarding guiding principles.
■ Training standards have been updated.
■ Alternate Clothing guidance is provided.
■ Objectives were defined.
■ Forms have been updated.
■ Circumstances under which pregnant inmates can be placed in SHU have been defined.
■ Psychological concerns regarding SHU placements have been addressed.

c. Institution Supplement. None required. Should local facilities make any changes outside
the required changes in the national policy or establish any additional local procedures to
implement the national policy, the local Union may invoke to negotiate procedures or
appropriate arrangements.
2. SPECIAL HOUSING UNITS (SHUS)
§ 541.21 Special Housing Units (SHUs).
Special Housing Units (SHUs) are housing units in Bureau institutions where
inmates are securely separated from the general inmate population, and may be
housed either alone or with other inmates. Special housing units help ensure the
safety, security, and orderly operation of correctional facilities, and protect the
public, by providing alternative housing assignments for inmates removed from
the general population.
For inmates with suspected or confirmed contagious diseases, refer to the Program Statements
Intake Screening, Infectious Disease Management, and Patient Care, and, when applicable,
the Pandemic Influenza Plan.
P5270.11 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown In this type. Implementing instructions: this type.
Alternative segregation housing arrangements outside the Special Housing Unit itself must be
proposed by the Warden to the Regional Director, and ultimately approved by the Assistant
Director, Correctional Programs Division, before activation. Alternative segregation housing of
this type will only be approved as SHU overflow for inmates in administrative detention or
disciplinary segregation status. Operation of such alternative segregation housing requires
compliance with all Bureau rules, policies, staffing, and post orders for operating Special
Housing Units.
General population inmates are not permitted to enter a secure housing unit to interact with
inmates for dispute resolutions, intelligence gathering, or security threat group/disruptive group
meetings. This also applies to removing inmates from a secure housing unit to meet with inmates
in general population. Institution staff must rely on trained investigative techniques, link
analysis, and other means of gathering information without allowing inmates into a secure
housing setting to conduct face-to-face meetings with one another.
Inmates who are pregnant, who are post-partum (up to 8 weeks), who recently had a
miscarriage (up to 4 weeks), or who recently had a terminated pregnancy (up to 4 weeks)
should not be placed in restrictive housing. In rare situations, these inmates may be placed in
restrictive housing as a temporary response to behavior that poses a serious and immediate risk
of physical harm or to ensure the safety, security, and orderly running of a BOP facility.

3. STATUS WHEN PLACED IN THE SHU
§ 541.22 Status when placed in the SHU.
When placed in the SHU, you are either in administrative detention status or
disciplinary segregation status.

(a) Administrative detention status. Administrative detention status is an
administrative status which removes you from the general population when
necessary to ensure the safety, security, and orderly operation of correctional
facilities, or protect the public. Administrative detention status is non -punitive,
and can occur for a variety of reasons.
The Warden may impose temporarily more restrictive conditions on an inmate (which may be in
an area ordinarily set aside for disciplinary segregation and therefore requires the withdrawal of
privileges ordinarily afforded in administrative detention status, until a hearing before the DHO
can be held) who:
P5270.11 11/23f2016 Federal Regulations are shown In this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 3
■ Is causing a serious disruption (threatening life, serious bodily harm, or property) in
administrative detention.
■ Cannot be controlled within the physical confines of administrative detention.
■ Upon advice of qualified health personnel. does not require confinement in the institution
hospital if the institution has one for mental or physical treatment, or who would ordinarily
be housed in the institution hospital for mental or physical treatment, but who cannot safely
be housed there because the hospital does not have a room or cell with adequate security
provisions.
Inmate confined under these more restrictive conditions must have their status reviewed and
fully documented on a new BP-A0321 every 5 days.
The Warden may delegate this authority no further than to the official in charge of the institution
when the move is necessary.
A fully documented report Special Housing Unit — Temporary Restrictive Housing Order (BP-
A032I) is maintained in the Inmate Central File.

(b) Disciplinary segregation status. Disciplinary segregation status is a punitive
status imposed only by a Discipline Hearing Officer (DHO) as a sanction for
committing a prohibited act(s).

4. ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION STATUS
§ 541.23 Administrative detention status.
You may be placed in administrative detention status for the following reasons:

(a) Pending Classification or Reclassification. You are a new commitment
pending classification or under review for Reclassification.
This includes newly arrived inmates from the Bus. Airlift, and U.S. Marshals Service.

(b) Holdover Status. You are in holdover status during transfer to a designated
institution or other destination.

(c) Removal from general population. Your presence in the general population
poses a threat to life, property, self, staff, other inmates, the public, or to the
security or orderly running of the institution and:
P5270.1 I 1123/20 16 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. implementing instructions: this type. 4

(1) Investigation. You are under investigation or awaiting a hearing for
possibly violating a Bureau regulation or criminal law;

(2) Transfer. You are pending transfer to another institution or location;
(3) Protection cases. You requested, or staff determined you need,
administrative detention status for your own protection; or
(4) Post -disciplinary detention. You are ending confinement in disciplinary
segregation status, and your return to the general population would threaten
the safety, security, and orderly operation of a correctional facility, or public
safety.
Staff must obtain approval from a Lieutenant or the Captain before placing an inmate in
Administrative Detention status pending investigation of a disciplinary violation. When
considering approval for Administrative Detention, the seriousness of the violation should be
reviewed.
In making Special Housing determination, officials should consider the seriousness of the
alleged offense, including whether the offense involved violence, involved escape, or posed a
threat to institutional safety or the orderly running of the institution.
If an inmate is terminating confinement in disciplinary segregation and staff determine
placement in the general population is not prudent, the inmate may be placed in administrative
detention status if warranted by the conditions established above. The decision for post-
disciplinary detention must be based on a separate review, not solely on the initial hearing before
the DHO that resulted in the inmate's placement in disciplinary segregation.
The Segregation Review Official (SRO) advises the inmate of this determination and the reason
for the action via an Administrative Detention Order (ADO; BP-A0308). The Warden or shift
supervisor can order immediate segregation. Ordinarily, within 24 hours of an inmate's
placement in Administrative Detention, a supervisory official not involved in the initial
placement will review and approve the placement decision.
Except for pretrial inmates or inmates in a control unit program, staff ordinarily, within 90 days
of an inmate's placement in post-disciplinary detention, must either return the inmate to the
general inmate population or request a transfer of the inmate to a more suitable institution using
Form EMS-A409, Request for Transfer/Application of Management Variable. The Regional
Correctional Programs Administrator will be copied on the completed form.
P5270.11 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown In this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 5
The institution must generate a regional referral for each inmate in post-disciplinary detention in
excess of 90 days that includes case-specific information stating why the inmate is not appropriate
for return to general population or immediate transfer. The Regional Director must submit a
recommendation for post-disciplinary detention in excess of 90 days and every additional 60 days
thereafter to the Assistant Director, Correctional Programs Division (CPD) for concurrence.
Distribution includes a copy to the GroupWise mailbox BOP-CPD/DHO—.
The institution generates an ADO that cites the same case-specific information and includes
documentation indicating that the SRO has advised the inmate of the basis for the extended stay.

5. DISCIPLINARY SEGREGATION STATUS
§ 541.24 Disciplinary segregation status.
You may be placed in disciplinary segregation status only by the DHO as a
disciplinary sanction.

6. NOTICE RECEIVED WHEN PLACED IN THE SHU
§ 541.25 Notice received when placed in the SHU.
You will be notified of the reason(s) you are placed in the SHU as follows:
The Lieutenant or other correctional supervisor prepares an Administrative Detention Order
(ADO; BP-A0308). The specific reason for placement in SHU must be supported by objective
evidence and clearly articulated in the narrative section of the ADO. A new ADO is required if
an inmate's status in administrative detention changes. Inmates will remain in SHU for no longer
than necessary to address the specific reason for placement. Distribution of copies is indicated on
the ADO.

(a) Administrative detention status. When placed in administrative detention
status, you will receive a copy of the administrative detention order, ordinarily
within 24 hours, detailing the reason(s) for your placement. However, when
placed in administrative detention status pending classification or while in
holdover status, you will not receive an administrative detention order.
Pending classification refers to newly arrived inmates.

(b) Disciplinary segregation status. When you are to be placed in disciplinary
segregation status as a sanction for violating Bureau regulations, you will be
informed by the DHO at the end of your discipline hearing.
P5270.) I 11232016 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 6

7. REVIEW OF PLACEMENT IN THE SHU
§ 541.26 Review of placement in the SHU.
Your placement in the SHU will be reviewed by the Segregation Review Official
(SRO) as follows:

(a) Three day review. Within three work days of your placement in administrative
detention status, not counting the day you were admitted, weekends, and
holidays, the SRO will review the supporting records. If you are in disciplinary
segregation status, this review will not occur.
For reviews of Protection Cases see section 9.

(b) Seven day reviews. Within seven continuous calendar days of your
placement in either administrative detention or disciplinary segregation status,
the SRO will formally review your status at a hearing you can attend. Subsequent
reviews of your records will be performed in your absence by the SRO every
seven continuous calendar days thereafter.

(c) Thirty day reviews. After every 30 calendar days of continuous placement in
either administrative detention or disciplinary segregation status, the SRO will
formally review your status at a hearing you can attend.

(d) Administrative remedy program. You can submit a formal grievance
challenging your placement in the SHU through the Administrative Remedy
Program, 28 CFR part 542, subpart B.
28 CFR Part 542. Subpart B. refers to the Program Statement Administrative Remedy
Program.
The SRO refers to the individual at each Bureau institution assigned to review the status of each
inmate housed in disciplinary segregation and administrative detention. The SRO must conduct
the required reviews. The SRO does not have to be a DHO. Ordinarily, the SRO is the Captain
(may be delegated to a Lieutenant responsible for supervision of the SHU). This review must
include:
■ A review of the inmate's records while in the SHU (Special Housing Unit Record. BP-
A0292).
■ All available memoranda from staff (including psychology staff).
P5270.11 I I/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 7
■ All available investigatory memoranda.
■ The SRO completes a Special Housing Review (SP-A0295) after review of the Special
Housing Unit Record and other relevant documentation. Maintain permanent logs.
A multidisciplinary team that includes, at a minimum, institution executive staff. Correctional
Services, unit staff, Health Services, and psychology staff reviews the inmate's initial and
ongoing placement in SHU. This committee meets on a regular basis. ordinarily weekly.

8. PROTECTION CASE — PLACEMENT IN ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION
STATUS
§ 541.27 Protection case - placement in Administrative Detention status.
You may be placed in administrative detention status as a protection case in the
following circumstances.

(a) Victim of inmate assault or threats. You were the victim of an inmate
assault, or are being threatened by other inmates, including threats of harm if
you do not act in a certain way, for example, threats of harm unless you engage
in sexual activity.

(b) Inmate informant. Your safety is threatened because you provided, or are
perceived as having provided, information to staff or law enforcement authorities
regarding other inmates or persons in the community.

(c) Inmate refusal to enter general population. You refuse to enter the general
population because of alleged pressures or threats from unidentified inmates, or
for no expressed reason.

(d) Staff concern. Based on evidence, staff believe your safety may be
seriously jeopardized by placement in the general population.
When an inmate is placed in Administrative Detention for an investigative period and the threat
is verified. correctional officials should seek alternative housing, by transferring the threatened
inmate either to the general population of another institution or to a special-purpose housing unit
for inmates who face similar threats, with conditions comparable to those of the general
population.
When the inmate poses such security risk that even a special-purpose housing unit is insufficient
to ensure the inmate's safety and the safety of staff, other inmates, and the public, the inmate
P5270.11 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. Implementing instruetion.s: this type.
may be housed in more restrictive conditions. The inmate's placement should be regularly
reviewed to monitor any medical or mental health deterioration and to determine whether the
security risks have subsided.

9. PROTECTION CASE — REVIEW OF PLACEMENT IN THE SHU
§ 541.28 Protection case - review of placement in the SHU.

(a) Staff investigation. Whenever you are placed in the SHU as a protection case,
whether requested by you or staff, an investigation will occur to verify the
reasons for your placement.

(b) Hearing. You will receive a hearing according to the procedural requirements
of § 541.26(b) within seven calendar days of your placement. Additionally, if you
feel at any time your placement in the SHU as a protection case is unnecessary,
you may request a hearing under this section.

(c) Periodic review. If you remain in administrative detention status following
such a hearing, you will be periodically reviewed as an ordinary administrative
detention case under § 541.26.
When an inmate is placed in administrative detention for protection, the Warden or designee
(ordinarily the Captain). must review the placement within two work days of the placement to
determine if continued protective custody is necessary. This review includes documents that led
to the inmate being placed in protective custody status and any other documents pertinent to the
inmate's protection.

10. STAFF VERIFICATION OF NEED FOR PROTECTION
§ 541.29 Staff verification of need for protection.
If a staff investigation verifies your need for placement in the SHU as a protection
case, you may remain in the SHU or be transferred to another institution where
your status as a protection case may not be necessary, at the Warden's
discretion.
P5270.1 I 112320 16 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 9

11. LACK OF VERIFICATION OF NEED FOR PROTECTION
§ 541.30 Lack of verification of need for protection.
If a staff investigation fails to verify your need for placement in the SHU as a
protection case, you will be instructed to return to the general population. If you
refuse to return to the general population under these circumstances, you may be
subject to disciplinary action.
Inmates refusing placement in general population should be maintained in Administrative
Detention status and, if appropriate, initiate disciplinary action.

12. CONDITIONS OF CONFINEMENT IN THE SHU
§ 541.31 Conditions of confinement in the SHU.
Your living conditions in the SHU will meet or exceed standards for healthy and
humane treatment, including, but not limited to, the following specific conditions:

(a) Environment. Your living quarters will be well -ventilated, adequately
lighted, appropriately heated, and maintained in a sanitary condition.

(b) Cell Occupancy. Your living quarters will ordinarily house only the amount
of occupants for which it is designed. The Warden, however, may authorize more
occupants so long as adequate standards can be maintained.

(c) Clothing. You will receive adequate institution clothing, including
footwear, while housed in the SHU. You will be provided necessary
opportunities to exchange clothing and/or have it washed.
The Warden's written approval is required prior to placing an inmate on alternate clothing/linen
status. The Warden or Acting Warden may not delegate the authority to place an inmate in
alternate clothing/linen (e.g., paper). The memorandum must include, at a minimum, the
signature of the Warden. Health Services Administrator. and a psychologist. A written
explanation of the reason(s) for alternate clothing/linen status must be included in the Warden's
authorization. This status will be reviewed every 3 days. Inmates will not be authorized to
remain in alternate clothing/linen for more than 6 days. After 6 days, the inmate is removed from
the alternate clothing/linen status, or, if necessary, a new authorization is generated. Inmates
must be offered a change of clothing daily and the clothing must be adequate to the temperature
in the SHU.
P.5270.1) 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. implementing instructions: this type. 10
Alternate clothing/linen is authorized when an inmate alters, destroys, or uses a clothing/linen
issued article in a manner that poses a threat to safety, security, or good order of the SHU or to
herself/himself, other inmates, or staff.
Alternate clothing/linen will not be used as punishment or during external transportation (i.e.,
outside the secure perimeter). Inmates that originate from BOP facilities will not be transported
in alternate clothing for any reason. Ordinarily, inmates with serious mental illness and those
with identified chronic or acute suicide risk are not placed in paper clothing. Paper clothing is
not used on suicide watch.

(d) Bedding. You will receive a mattress, blankets, a pillow, and linens
for sleeping. You will receive necessary opportunities to exchange
linens.
If the institution issues the combination mattress with a pillow incorporated, a separate pillow
will not be issued. Staff may remove an inmate's mattress during non-sleeping daytime hours as
a "loss of privilege" sanction imposed by the Unit Discipline Committee (UDC)/DHO. Removal
of an inmate's mattress is otherwise prohibited, absent life or safety concerns as specifically
documented and authorized by the Warden, or his/her designee.

(e) Food. You will receive nutritionally adequate meals.
Refer to the Program Statement Food Service Manual for standards and guidelines for feeding
inmates in Special Housing Units. When an inmate uses food products, Food Service items, or
the feeding process itself in a manner that poses a threat to the safety, security, or good order of
the institution, or to the inmate him-/herself, other inmates, or staff, a written explanation of the
reason(s) for alternate meal status must be included in the CEO's authorization and approved by
Health Services. The Warden's written approval is required prior to placing an inmate on
alternative meal status. After 7 days, the inmate is removed from the alternative meal service or,
if necessary, a new authorization is generated.

(f) Personal hygiene. You will have access to a wash basin and toilet. You will
receive personal items necessary to maintain an acceptable level of personal
hygiene, for example, toilet tissue, soap, toothbrush and cleanser, shaving
utensils, etc. You will ordinarily have an opportunity to shower and shave at least
three times per week. You will have access to hair care services as necessary.
(g) Exercise. You will receive the opportunity to exercise outside your
individual quarters at least five hours per week, ordinarily on different days in
P5270.11 1123/2016 Federal Regulations are shown In this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 11
one -hour periods. You can be denied these exercise periods for a week at a
time by order of the Warden if it is determined that your use of exercise
privileges threatens safety, security, and orderly operation of a correctional
facility, or public safety.
If weather, resources, and staffing permit, the inmate shall receive outdoor exercise periods.
"Week" means one calendar week.
Plans for increasing recreation time are developed locally for each institution in an effort to
provide additional out of cell time. These plans will be developed considering the views and
input from the local union.
The following factors must be considered when developing plans to increase out of cell time for
recreation:
■ Inmate to correctional services staff ratio in SHU.
■ Total number of inmates in SHU.
■ Limitations of the physical plant and infrastructure, especially regarding spaces used for
recreation.
When an institution possesses the resources identified within the three factors listed above to
implement these plans, it should do so.
A memorandum for the plan will be generated. The Warden will review the plan at least
annually and make adjustments as necessary.
Restriction or denial of exercise is not used as punishment. The Warden or Acting Warden may
not delegate the authority to restrict or deny exercise. Exercise periods are only restricted or
denied when the inmate's activities pose a threat to the safety, security, and orderly operation of
a correctional facility, or health conditions of the unit.
The appropriate staff member recommends recreation restrictions to a supervisor who then
makes the recommendation to the Warden in writing. The recommending staff member
describes briefly the reason for recommending a restriction and its proposed extent. The Warden
reviews the recommendation and approves, modifies, or denies the restriction. If the Warden
approves a restriction, it must be based on the conclusion that the inmate's actions pose a threat
to the safety, security, and orderly operation of a correctional facility or health conditions of the
unit.
P5270.11 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown In this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 12

(h) Personal property. In either status, your amount of personal property may
be limited for reasons of fire safety or sanitation.

(1) In administrative detention status you are ordinarily allowed a reasonable
amount of personal property and reasonable access to the commissary.

(2) In disciplinary segregation status your personal property will be impounded,
with the exception of limited readingiwriting materials, and religious articles.
Also, your commissary privileges may be limited.

(3) Personal property ordinarily allowed in administrative detention (if not otherwise a threat to
institution security) includes:
■ Bible, Koran, or other scriptures (1).
■ Books, paperback (5).
■ Eyeglasses, prescription (2).
■ Legal material (see the Program Statement Inmate Legal Activities).
■ Magazine (3).
■ Mail (10).
■ Newspaper (I).
■ Personal hygiene items (1 of each type) (no dental floss or razors*).
■ Photographs (25).
■ Authorized religious medals/headgear (e.g., kufi).
■ Shoes, shower (1).
■ Shoes, other (1).
■ Snack foods without aluminum foil wrappers (5 individual packs).
■ Soft drinks, powdered (1 container).
■ Stationery/stamps (20 each).
■ Wedding band (I).
■ Radio with ear plugs (1).
■ Watch (must not have metal backing) (1).
*Razors are controlled by SHU staff. Only disposable razors are used.
The Warden may modify the quantity and type of personal property allowed. Personal property
may be limited or withheld for reasons of security, fire safety, or housekeeping.
Unauthorized use of any authorized item may result in the restriction of the item. If there are
numerous misuses of an authorized item, the Warden may determine that the item will not be
issued in the SHU.
P5270.11 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 13
Reading Material. The inmate will receive a reasonable amount of non-legal reading material,
not to exceed five books per inmate at any one time, on a circulating basis. Staff shall provide
the inmate the opportunity to possess religious scriptures of the inmate's faith.

(i) Correspondence. You will receive correspondence privileges according to
part 540, subpart B.
Part 540. Subpart B. refers to the Program Statement Correspondence.

(j) Telephone. You will receive telephone privileges according to part 540,
subpart I.
Part 540, Subpart I, refers to the Program Statement Inmate Telephone Regulations.
If the inmate has not been restricted from telephone use as the result of a specific disciplinary
sanction, he/she is allowed to make one telephone call per month. Meaning, the inmate should
receive a phone call within the first 30 calendar days of placement in the Special Housing Unit
and within every 30 calendar days thereafter.

(k) Visiting. You will receive visiting privileges according to part 540, subpart D.
Part 540, Subpart D, refers to the Program Statement Visiting Regulations.

(I) Legal activities. You will receive an opportunity to perform personal legal
activities according to part 543, subpart B.
Part 543, Subpart B, refers to the Program Statement Inmate Legal Activities.

(m) Staff monitoring. You will be monitored by staff assigned to the SHU,
including program and unit team staff.
Program staff, including unit staff, arrange to visit inmates in a SHU within a reasonable time
after receiving the inmate's request.
In addition to direct supervision by the unit officer, qualified health personnel and one or more
responsible officers the Warden designates (ordinarily the Institution Duty Officer) visit each
segregated inmate daily, including weekends and holidays. A Lieutenant must visit the SHU
during each shift to ensure all procedures are followed.
P5270.11 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 14
Duress buttons, if present. will be utilized only for emergency and/or life-threatening situations, to
include health-related issues. The use of the duress button for anything other than an emergency
and/or life-threatening situation is subject to disciplinary action.

(n) Programming activities. In administrative detention status, you will have
access to programming activities to the extent safety, security, orderly operation
of a correctional facility, or public safety are not jeopardized. In disciplinary
segregation status, your participation in programming activities, e.g., educational
programs, may be suspended.
All out of cell time will be recorded in BP-A0292, Special Housing Unit Record.

(o) Administrative Remedy Program. You can submit a formal grievance
challenging any aspect of your confinement in the SHU through the
Administrative Remedy Program, 28 CFR part 542, subpart B.
28 CFR Part 542. Subpart B. refers to the Program Statement Administrative Remedy Program.

13. MEDICAL AND MENTAL HEALTH CARE IN THE SHU
§ 541.32 Medical and mental health care in the SHU.
(a) Medical care. A health services staff member will visit you daily to provide
necessary medical care. Emergency medical care is always available.
While in a SHU, inmates may continue taking their prescribed medications.

(b) Mental health care. After every 30 calendar days of continuous placement in
either administrative detention or disciplinary segregation status, mental health
staff will examine you, including a personal interview. Emergency mental health
care is always available.
Generally, an inmate who has been identified by Psychology/Health Services as a Care-3 (MH).
Care-4 (MH). psychology alert in SENTRY, or identified on the monthly SHU advisory
should not be placed in Special Housing unless he/she presents an immediate and/or serious
danger to self, staff, or the orderly running of a facility.
If an inmate who has been identified by Psychology/Health Services as a Care-3 (MH), Care-4
(MH), psychology alert in SENTRY, or identified on the monthly SHU advisory (Hot List). is
placed in Special Housing. psychology services should be notified and conduct a mental health
P5270.11 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 15
evaluation within 24 hours of placement. Staff should conduct a psychiatric or psychological
assessment, including a personal interview, when administrative detention continues beyond 30
days. The assessment, submitted to the SRO in a written report with a copy to the inmate's
central file, addresses:
■ The inmate's adjustment to surroundings.
■ The threat the inmate poses to self, staff, and other inmates.
Staff conduct a similar psychiatric or psychological assessment and report at 30-day intervals
should detention continue for an extended period.

14. RELEASE FROM THE SHU
§ 541.33 Release from the SHU.
(a) Administrative detention status. You will be released from administrative
detention status when the reasons for your placement no longer exist.

(b) Disciplinary segregation status. You will be released from disciplinary
segregation status after satisfying the sanction imposed by the DHO. The SRO
may release you earlier if it is determined you no longer require disciplinary
segregation status.
Ordinarily, inmates nearing the end of their term of incarceration will not be placed in SHU,
except when their presence in General Population threatens the safety, security, or the orderly
running of a BOP facility.
Every effort should be made to avoid releasing an inmate directly from SHU to the community.
If the inmate remains in SHU within 180 days of release, options to release the inmate to less
restrictive settings should be considered. If a less restrictive setting is not possible, the inmate
will receive targeted reentry programming to prepare for return to the community.
A clear plan for returning the inmate to less restrictive conditions will be developed and is
ordinarily shared with the inmate.
The SRO may not increase any previously imposed sanction(s). When considering release from
disciplinary segregation, the SRO first consults with the Captain and must notify the Discipline
Hearing Officer (DHO) of the inmate's release from disciplinary segregation before satisfying
the imposed sanction.
P5270.11 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 16

15. TRAINING
Completion of quarterly training will be required for staff assigned to SHU prior to the start of
each new quarter, regardless of how many times a staff member has completed the training. When
assignment to a SHU post is known sufficiently in advance, each staff member should be afforded
a reasonable amount of duty time to complete the training. For instances when last-minute
assignments to the SHU occur, the employer must advise the staff of the general requirements of a
SHU post and answer any questions.
This training session may include, but is not limited to, search procedures, escort procedures,
application of restraints, use of force, orderly supervision, cell/unit sanitation, emergency
response, suicide prevention, and dealing with mentally ill inmates, as well as other security
procedures related to the unit. If this in-person training is completed, a training sheet will be
completed documenting the training, and will be routed to the Captain and Human Resources
Department for retention.

16. AGENCY'S ACA ACCREDITATION PROVISIONS
■ 4'h Edition Standards for Adult Correctional Institutions: 4-4133, 4-4235, 4-4249, 4-4250, 4-
4251, 4-4252, 4-4253, 4-4254, 4-4255, 4-4256, 4-4258, 4-4260, 4-4261, 4-4262, 4-4263, 4-
4264, 4-4265, 4-4266, 4-4267, 4-4268, 4-4269, 4-4270, 4-4271, 4-4272, and 4-4273.
■ 4'h Edition Performance-Based Standards for Adult Local Detention Facilities: 4-ALDF-2A-
44, 4-ALDF-2A-45, 4-ALDF-2A-46, 4-ALDF-2A-47, 4-ALDF-2A-48, 4-ALDF-2A-49, 4-
ALDF-2A-50, 4-ALDF-2A-51, 4-ALDF-2A-53, 4-ALDF-2A-55, 4-ALDF-2A-56, 4-ALDF-
2A-57, 4-ALDF-2A-58, 4-ALDF-2A-59, 4-ALDF-2A-60, 4-ALDF-2A-61, 4-ALDF-2A-62,
4-ALDF-2A-63, 4-ALDF-2A-64, 4-ALDF-2A-65, and 4-ALDF-2A [66.
REFERENCES
Program Statements
P1315.07 Inmate Legal Activities (11/5/99)
P1330.18 Administrative Remedy Program (1/6/14)
P4700.06 Food Service Manual (9/3/11)
P5100.08 Inmate Security Designation and Custody Classification (9/12/06)
P5212.07 Control Unit Programs (2/20/01)
P5264.08 Inmate Telephone Regulations (1/24/08)
P5265.14 Correspondence (4/5/11)
P5267.09 Visiting Regulations (12/10/15)
P5270.09 Inmate Discipline Program (7/8/11)
P6031.04 Patient Care (6/3/14)
P5270.11 11/23/7016 Federal Regulations are shown in this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 17
P6340.04
P6360.01
BOP Fonns
BP-A0292
BP-A0295
BP-A0308
BP-A0321
Psychiatric Services (1/15/05)
Pharmacy Services (1/15/05)
Special Housing Unit Record
Special Housing Review
Administrative Detention Order
Special Housing Unit — Temporary Restrictive Housing Order
Records Retention Requirements
Requirements and retention guidance for records and information applicable to this program are
available in the Records and Information Disposition Schedule (RIDS) on Sallyport.
P5270.11 11/23/2016 Federal Regulations are shown In this type. Implementing instructions: this type. 18
╔═════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Thomas Magnani [medical] dentist 
╚══════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00298194 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2016-12-14)
December 12, Monday
8:30 Breakfast w/Bill Conover
10:30 Appt w/Nina Keita
11:30 Appt w/
1:00 Lunch w/Austin Hearst
2:30 Appt w/Darren, Rich and Harry
3:30 Appt w/Sultan
4:00 Appt w/Elen
7:00 Cocktails at Eva's Gala at the Mandarin Oriental) 80 Columbus
Circle at 60th Street, Festive Attire
8:00 Dinner at Eva's Gala
December 13. Tuesday
8:30 Appt w/David Mitchell ( (p)
10:30 David the Piano Tuner coming to the house ( organized)
) ( )
10:30 Appt w/ (
12:00
12:30 Lunch w/Andrew Farkas
1:30 Appt w/Darren & Rich
1:45 OR 2:30 CALL Erika Kellerhals,
2:45
)
to come over for a walk
5:00 Appt wa
4-4:15 Joe Pagano said he can meet you (he also needs
application to NYU)
4:30 Appt w/
5:30 Dinner w Matt Menchel office)
7:30 Screening of "the Iron Lady" at the Ziegfeld, 141 West 54th between
6th & 7th Ave
9:30 After Party at the Royalton, 44 West 44th between 6t1 & 7th Ave.
December 14. Wednesday
on Holiday Dec. 14-16
Call with Erika Kellerhals either between 11-2 or after 3:30?
11:00 Appt w/Merwin (Lyn has his number if you need it)
11:30 Appt WA= I I
4:00 Appt w/Steve Cutler at his office. (270 Park Ave., 48th Floor)
5:30 Cleaning w/lvy at Dr. Magnani's office (7 W. 51st Street, 7th Floor
December 15, Thursday
Interview with Adam Bly's Candidate? a
11:00 Conf. Call w oe Ackerman, Lilly Sanchez, Chris Knight, Darren
Dial In: Conference code: 9167070757#, Leader Pin:
*3741# (star 3741 pound) Darren is leader
1:00 Appt w/Hind Alowais I
4:30 Appt w/Dangene & Jennie at the Core Club (66 e. 55th street bet
Park and Madison,
Possibly Depart for Oslo
Oslo
December 16, Friday
Lunch w/Sultan and Zagat?
Tentative Schedule:
Oslo to Paris Dec. 17
Paris to Casablanca Dec. 19
Casablanca to Ivory Coast Dec. 20
Ivory Coast to Senegal Dec. 22
WAITING FOR RESPONSE FROM:
-lunch with Tim Zagat, Sultan and Jeffrey for Friday. Still waiting to hear
from Tim's office. Tim:
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Andrey Vavilov [russia] former Russian finance minister accused of stealing $230 million and other frauds 
                                                                            Sberbank [russia] Russian bank 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01413294 (Jmail)
 [money] compliance report on payment from Epstein to Sberbank account of Nikolay Aleksandrovich Gyrov
(approximate date: 2016-12-16)
C168333-40-cAUaN000005
101.0 SYSTEM MT
1,100.000 USD CPS AUTO HOLD 01 DEC 16 15:26:15 100.0 79.0
C168333-40-cAUaN000005 - User Actions and Comments:
User Location Disposition Date/Time
Comments
CHHAJUH
MT MANUAL PASS 01 DEC 16 15:41:48
KUMAPUN MT MANUAL PASS 01 DEC 16 15:46:23
C168333-40-cAUaN000005 - Transaction Details:
Format type
Request type
Criteria Set
Transaction Location
Rule Based Scanning
Message Priority
2016)
Resubmitted
: U
: S
: 230
: MT
: Not Applied
: Medium(LOC=MT; Cur=-NA-; Amt66N-NA-; Srv=ALL; Recv@15:26 01-12:
No
Free
Form:
:01: AC
- JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QTR, B3 SAINT THOMAS
00802 UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
:S: SW BKTRUS33PWM
BKTRUS33PWM
For internal use only
LEGAL WORKSTATION
BTCO
PRIVATE BANK-DOMESTIC SALES
BTCO USA
:R1: AC BKTRUS33PWM 99955009
99955009
LEGAL WORKSTATION
BTCO
PRIVATE BANK-DOMESTIC SALES
BTCO USA
:D: AC BKTRUS33PWM
99955009
99955009
LEGAL WORKSTATION
BTCO
PRIVATE BANK-DOMESTIC SALES
BTCO USA
:C: CB IRVTUS3NXXX
0001
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON
NEW YORK
NEW YORK, NY USA
1* :B1: CH SABRRUMMXXX
321233
2* 3* 4* 5*
VAVILOV STREET 19
MOSCOW 117997 RUSSIA
:B2: AC
For internal use only
RU
:20:
:70: REE
/OUROUR/
/LTR/
/LTR/
C168333-40-cAUaN000005 - Match 1 [Field Based Scanning Associated Item Match]
*
Name
Address
City/state
Country
Origin
: SECTOR
Risk Entity Comments
Title
Remarks
Risk Entity Info
: PROHIBITED TO ENGAGE IN NEW LONG-TERM DEBT (>30D),
: OFAC / EU SECTORAL SANCTION
: -
Additional information 1 :
Additional information 2 : DIRECT OFAC SSI; MAIN RISK ENTIY / A.K.A.
(SBERBANK)
Additional information 3 : NON-USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO RESP. AMLO OR
DEPT.
Additional information 4 : USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO
SANCTIONS.COMPLIANCE@DB.COM
Additional information 5 :
Additional information 6 : ESCALATE FOR ALL CURRENCY
Additional information 7 :
Additional information 8 :
Additional information 9 :
For internal use only
Additional information 10 :
Free Form Match Text
: SABRRU
C168333-40-cAUaN000005
- Match 2 [Field Based Scanning Risk Entity Match]
*
Name
•
Address
City/state
Country
Origin
: SECTOR
Risk Entity Comments
Title
Remarks
Risk Entity Info
: PROHIBITED TO ENGAGE IN NEW LONG-TERM DEBT (>30D),
: OFAC / EU SECTORAL SANCTION
: -
Additional information 1 :
Additional information 2 : DIRECT OFAC SSI; MAIN RISK ENTIY / A.K.A.
(SBERBANK)
Additional information 3 : NON-USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO RESP. AMLO OR
DEPT.
Additional information 4 : USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO
SANCTIONS.COMPLIANCE@DB.COM
Additional information 5 :
Additional information 6 : ESCALATE FOR ALL CURRENCY
Additional information 7 :
Additional information 8 :
Additional information 9 :
Additional information 10 :
Free Form Match Text
For
internal use only
C168333-40-cAUaN000005 - Match 3 [Field Based Scanning Risk Entity Match]
*
Name
: SBERBANK
Address
City/state
Country
Origin
: SECTOR
Risk Entity Comments
Title
Remarks
Risk Entity Info
: PROHIBITED TO ENGAGE IN NEW LONG-TERM DEBT (>30D),
: OFAC / EU SECTORAL SANCTION
: -
Additional information 1 :
Additional information 2 : MAIN RISK ENTIY / A.K.A. (MAIN ENTITY / A.K.A.)
Additional information 3 : NON-USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO RESP. AMLO OR
DEPT.
Additional information 4 : USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO
SANCTIONS.COMPLIANCE@DB.COM
Additional information 5 :
Additional information 6 : ESCALATE FOR ALL CURRENCY
Additional information 7 :
Additional information 8 :
Additional information 9 :
Additional information 10 :
Free Form Match Text
: SBERBANK
C168333-40-cAUaN000005
- Match 4 [Field Based Scanning Risk Entity Match]
* Name
: SBERBANK MOSCOW
For internal use only
Address
City/state
Country
Origin
: SECTOR
Risk Entity Comments
Title
Remarks
Risk Entity Info
: PROHIBITED TO ENGAGE IN NEW LONG-TERM DEBT (>30D),
: OFAC / EU SECTORAL SANCTION
: -
Additional information 1 :
Additional information 2 : SUBSIDIARY (>= 50%) OF SBERBANK
Additional information 3 : NON-USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO RESP. AMLO OR
DEPT.
Additional information 4 : USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO
SANCTIONS.COMPLIANCE@DB.COM
Additional information 5 :
Additional information 6 : ESCALATE FOR ALL CURRENCY
Additional information 7 :
Additional information 8 :
Additional information 9 :
Additional information 10 :
Free Form Match Text
VAVILOV STREET 19
MOSCOW
C168333-40-cAUaN000005
- Match 5 [Field Based Scanning Risk Entity Match]
*
Name
: JSC
Address
City/state
For internal use only
Country
Origin
: SECTOR
Risk Entity Comments
Title
Remarks
Risk Entity Info
: PROHIBITED TO ENGAGE IN NEW LONG-TERM DEBT (>30D),
: OFAC / EU SECTORAL SANCTION
: -
Additional information 1 :
Additional information 2 : SUBSIDIARY (>= 50%) OF SBERBANK
Additional information 3 : NON-USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO RESP. AMLO OR
DEPT.
Additional information 4 : USA: ESCALATE ALL TRUE HITS TO
SANCTIONS
Additional information 5 :
Additional information 6 : ESCALATE FOR ALL CURRENCY
Additional information 7 :
Additional information 8 :
Additional information 9 :
Additional information 10 :
Free Form Match Text
: SBERBANK OF RUSSIA
For internal use only
EFTA00606411 (Jmail)
 [money] proposed jet ownership structure flowchart
(approximate date: 2017-01-01)
proposed jet ownership structure flowchart
╔═══════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Anna Kasatkina [russian girl] Russian girl 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01623342 (Jmail)
 [girls] Skype log of conversation with Anna Kasatkina (???) recruiting russian girls [rddt]
(inferred timestamp: 2017-01-15 22:59:27)
Platform: Skype: jeevacation Timezone: UTC+0000
•
•
•
•
jeevacation
2017/01/13
jeevacation
do you also have exams 23 -25?
04:04:51 pm
Hello, Jeffrey!!!! Sorryyyy, but yes, I have 23 and 25 days practice lessons and 24 -
exams!
04:10:10 pin
jeevacation
no problem
04:10:40 pin
Today I met with M, she told that you like, when you have two assistant in a trip, I
would like to ask you, do you want that I found a girl, which will come with me or not?
04:13:10 pin
jeevacation
often when i travel i have to go to meetings for many hours and prefer if the assistant
is not left alone in foreign countries. it also gives me more peace of mind when going
out shopping in strange places. so only if you find someone you trust
04:14:57 pin
You are incredible person) nobody cares about me like you, just my family!!! Thank you
so much! I will try to ask one girl, if it will give you more peace!
04:22:38 pin
jeevacation
yes, its important to me that you do well in life
05:00:28 pm
•
•
please send me your bank account details . i will send you the money for your life in
moscow
05:44:02 pm
Thank you so much, I just could dream about person like you in my life! I really
appreciate all what you do for me, and I really want that you feel the same good
feelings from me, from my work. I do want that you feel yourself very well, and I really
want to help as I can! And I have to say I don't want that you worry about me when I m
alone, because I feel myself very good already, and i like read, study smth or do smth
like that. But, sure, I try to find a girl to you will give more peace! Just please don't
worrym
05:57:13 pin
Thank you!!! Do you need the details of my plastic card or?
05:58:29 pin
jeevacation
Bank detail for transfer money for next few months as agreed
06:00:53 pin
Send you here?
06:19:52 pm
jeevacation
Yes
06:20:13 pm
06:20:30 pm
•
•
•
Sorryyy, I forget that here just English letters, but not word! Are you understand?)
06:24:12 pm
jeevacation
It's ok. Did you buy your sex toy??;)
06:27:16 pm
Unfortunately not  when I was in omsk, my little brother was everywhere with me!) in
Moscow I haven't time) I decide to give opportunity my girls make me present for some
day) I like surprise
06:37:33 pm
How are youu?)))
06:38:14 pm
jeevacation
Great
06:51:56 pm
2017/01/14
jeevacation
friend CANNOT do massage. only you
03:58:09 pin
Thank youuuu!!! How do you understand that I already worried about it))))
04:05:47 pin
jeevacation
•
•
•
i know you
04:15:26 pm
Yeeeesjik thank you so much!
04:20:03 pm
jeevacation
between me and you is VERY PRIVATE
05:32:49 pm
Yes, I understand!)
05:37:39 pm
jeevacation
remind me what day are you finished and free to travel
10:59:27 pm
2017/01/15
The first of February is the last exam and I will free)!
05:36:28 am
jeevacation
how many days after that can you travel
09:54:50 am
•
•
•
I will free anytime, I will have a new exams in summer. I can take massage Lessons
when I am at Moscow. And my English course was finished in December, because we
take just for 3 month. And I would like to ask you, maybe better if I will take private
class with teacher and we can use Skype sometimes. Because I think it's better, when I
will speak with a teacher all time and she will correct my mistakes. When I was in a
course I always speak with a students and I seems I need more control. And, of course,
I use a book, which you gave me! I asked about this one, she also think that it's
better for my English. But I would like to know, what do you think about it?
10:08:52 am
jeevacation
its similar to my answer to jeffrey do you prefer blondes or brunettes. I say no need
to choose i will take both. . same here you should do all three skype private and
class. . each has its benefits
10:21:29 am
I agree with you) especially about blondes and brunettes= well, i can take privet class
on Sundays in this month still I have exams, and after I can take course one more time
as in addition. Is it okay?
11:46:25 am
jeevacation
don't worry about class until all exams passed
12:17:52 pm
Yes, you are right, it will be more productive. Thank youuuu
01:48:50 pm
jeevacation
happy today i hope
12:21:46 pm
2017/01/16
Today is so serious)))) too much study) what about you?
12:25:13 pm
•
•
Dasha sad that you spoke with her) what impressions of her?
12:29:13 pm
jeevacation
Nice but confused
12:30:29 pm
Maybe she confused because you was unknown person) she also sad me that she
worried. But I sad her that she didn't need it)
12:44:50 pm
Have a good day
01:11:33 pm
EFTA00313650 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in case 1:17-cv-00616
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust [epstein] Epstein financial trust, trustees: Darren Indyke, Eva Dubin, Richard Kahn 
                                                                           Merwin Dela Cruz [employee] housekeeper 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00099424 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein death bequests of Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust naming Darren Indyke, Eva Dubin, Richard Kahn as trustees
(date: 2017-01-30)
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 2017 TRUST

THIS TRUST AGREEMENT, dated January 2017 ("Agreement"), by and among
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, as Grantor ("Grantor"), and EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, DARREN K.
INDYKE, and RICHARD D. KAHN, as Trustees ("Trustees").

The Grantor hereby pays over, assignsi grants, conveys, transfers and delivers to the
Trustees the property described in Schedule I annexed hereto and made I part hereof, to be
administered and disposed of as provided in this Agreement, with any additions, changes, or
amendments to this Agreement.

This Trust shall be known as the "Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust".

Article': During My Lifetime
The following provisions shall apply during my lifetime:

Section 1.1. - Disbursement of Income
All of the income of the trust (the "Trust Estate") shall be paid to me, or accumulated or
paid as I may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.2. - Disbursement of Principal
My Trustees may distribute any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate to me as I
may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.3. - Specific Rights Reserved to Me

A. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to amend this
Agreement, in whole or in part, by' written instrument executed and acknowledged by me and
delivered to no less than one Trustee of this Trust.

B. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, in my sole and
unfettered discretion, to remove any Trustee by delivering to said removed Trustee and my
remaining Trustees I written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

C. I reserve the right, at anL time, to revoke this Trust in its entirety or any
provision hereof by delivering to my Trustees I written instrument executed and acknowledged
solely by me.

D. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to withdraw or
appoint any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate by delivering to my Trustees' written
instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.
GJ 000406
Jeffrey a Epstein 2011 'crust
Page 2 of 23
E. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to transfer to my
Trustees, by gift, by Will or by beneficiary designation, such additional property, including life
insurance policies, as I may desire. Any such additional property shall be held on the same
terms as are then applicable to the original Trust Estate, except that it may be transferred
subject to conditions and provisions of special application to such additional property.

Article II : After My Death
The following provisions shall apply after my death:

Section 2.1. - Payment of My Debts and of Taxes and Expenses
My Trustee shall pay from the principal of the Trust Estate (I) my debts, funeral and
burial expenses and the administration expenses of my probate estate which are not paid by the
Executor of my probate estate, and (b) the federal and state estate, inheritance, succession,
generation skipping and similar taxes imposed by reason of my death which are the obligations
of my Trustees (including any of such taxes which the Executor of my probate estate directs
my Trustees to pay by written direction delivered to my Trustees). For purposes of this Section
2.1, the principal of the Trust Estate shall not include (I) any assets which are not included in
my Gross Estate or (b) any assets which are not subject to, or available to creditors for the
payment of, my debts, my funeral and burial expenses or the administration expenses of my
probate estate.

Section 2.2. — Specific Bequests and Devises under My Will and Trust
If my probate estate is insufficient to satisfy all pecuniary bequests (or bequests payable
in cash or in kind in the discretion of the Executor of my probate estate) provided in my Will, if
any, my Trustee shall pay such unpaid bequests from the principal of the Trust Estate. If my
Will provided fort specific bequest or devise of specified assets and such bequest or devise
could not be satisfied from my probate estate because such assets were held by my Trustee at
my death, my Trustee shall distribute such assets to satisfy such bequest or devise.
To the extent the assets of the Trust are insufficient to satisfy all bequests, I direct my
Trustees to pay all specific bequests first., and to the extent assets are insufficient to pay all of
the remainirs bequests in Section 2.31)(1) through 2.3(1)(1)(28), then the beneficiaries of

Section 2.31)(1) through 2.31)(1X28) shall share on t  proportionate basis in the remaining
estate assets available for distribution. The determination of the Trustees as to the amounts
distributable herein shall be binding on all parties.

Section 2.3. - Bequests
Imake the following bequests:

1. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars
($2,000,000), plus an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of
from t  reputable financial institution in the amount of Five Million Dollars
($5,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of with
lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of <REDACTED>
upon her death.

2. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars
$2,000,000 plus an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of
from I reputable financial institution in the amount of Five Million Dollars
($5,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life o with
lum sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of
upon her death.

3. to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, Ten Million Dollars
($10,000,000), plus an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of KARYNA
SHULIAK from I reputable financial institution in the amount of Ten Million Dollars
($10,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of KARYNA SHULIAK
with I lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of
KARYNA SHULIAK upon her death.

4. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, One
1101,0 plus al annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of
from I reputable financial institution in the amount of Five Million Dollars
($5,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of •
with lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of
upon her death.

5. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, One Million Dollars
($1,000,000) plus an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of <REDACTED>
from I reputable financial institution in the amount of Five Million Dollars
($5,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life oa with
lum sum in th amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of
upon her death.

6. to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, if he survives me, Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).
7. to MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if she is then married to DARREN
KEITH INDYKE, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000), which funds shall be distributed and used
for the sole purpose of repaying FT Real Estate, Inc. the funds it previously paid to KCAC, LLC
in connection with I real estate purchase contract between FT Real Estate, Inc., as purchaser,
and KCAC, LLC, as seller, for the purchase of the real property known as and located at 2 Kean
Court in Livingston, New Jersey, and terminating said real estate purchase contract. It is my
express desire, intent and direction, as the sole shareholder of FT Real Estate, Inc., that upon my
death, FT Real Estate, Inc. be directed to cancel and terminate said real estate purchase contract
as contemplated herein; provided, however, that such distribution to MICHELLE F. SAIPHER
shall not be made and such termination shall not occur if the transfer of such real property to FT
Real Estate, Inc. pursuant to such real estate purchase contract has been completed prior to the
my death.

8. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, One Million Dollars
$1,000,000 plus an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of
from I reputable financial institution in the amount of Two
$2,000,000 which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of
with lum sum in the am unt of the then remaining principal balance payable
to the estate of upon her death.

9. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, One Million Dollars
$1,000,000 plus an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of
from I reputable financial institution in the amount of Four Million Doll
($4,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of
with lum sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of
upon her death.

10. to LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).
11. to LARWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., if he survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

12. to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA JR., if he survives me, an anguity to be
purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of LUCIANO 0. FONTANILLA, JR. from I reputable
financial institution in the amount of Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000), which annuity shall be
payable monthly for the life of LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR. with I lump sum in the
amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the then surviving children of
LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR. and ROSALYN V. FONTANILLA.

13. to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR., or his heirs, successors and assigns,
whether or not LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR. survives me, all of my interest in the
property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the real property
located at, and known and referred to as, 18 Teneyck Avenue, Valley Stream, New York. My
interest consists of 100% of the issued and outstanding Membership Interests in Lyn & Jojo,
LLC, a New York limited liability company which holds legal title to said real property,
improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights, which Mejnbership Interests are held in the
name of Darren K. Indyke, as nominee for me, and which I direct my Trustees to transfer to
LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns.

14. to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, if he survives me, Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).
15. to ANN RODRIGUEZ, if she survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000).

16. to VALDSON VIERA CONTRIN, if he survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000).
17. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Hundred
Thousand Dollars ($250,001 an to addition t eto and whether or not
survives me, to , or her heirs, successors or assigns, an
amount a ual to otal outstanding debt, including accrued and unpaid interest thereon, due
from to FT Real Estate, Inc., which amount shall be distributed to
, or her heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used
to repay all u h outstanding debt and accrued but unpaid interest.

18. ti if she survives me, Forty Thousand Dollars ($40,000).
19. to MERWIN DELA CRUZ, if he survives me, One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100,000).

20. to JANUSZ BANASIAK, if he survives me, Twenty-Five Thousand Dollars ($25,000).
21. to BRICE GORDON, if he survives me, Two Hundred Thousand Dollars
($200,000), but only if BRICE GORDON, whether in his own name or on behalf of I separate
entity, continues for' period of two years following my death to provide such services as the
Trustees deem necessary or appropriate in respect of one or more of the real properties
beneficially owned by me prior to my death. This bequest shall not be distributed to BRICE
GORDON prior to the expiration of two years following the date of my death. This bequest
shall not be subject to the provisions of Article II, Section 2.5.

22. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Hundred Thousand Dollars
($200,000), but only if I , whether in her own name or on behalf of I separate
entity, continues for' period of two years following my death to provide such services as the
Trustees deem necessary or appropriate in respect of one or more of the real poi
owned by me prior to my death. This bequest shall not be distributed to
rior to the expiration of two years following the date of my death. This bequest
shall not be subject to the provisions of Article II, Section 2.5.

23. to BELLA KLEIN, if she survives me, Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000).
24. to DAVID ROGERS, if he survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000).

25. to STEVE CHAVEZ, if he survives me, Sixty-Six Thousand Dollars ($66,000).
26. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Forty Thousand Dollars ($40,000).

27. to CYNTHIA CANO, if she survives me, Thirty-Five Thousand Dollars ($35,000).
28. to CARLOS DELGADO, if he survives me, Forty-Two Thousand Dollars ($42,000).

29. I forgive any loans which' made to the following individuals or
entities:

a) LUCIANO I. FONTANILLA, JR.

b) <REDACTED>
c) <REDACTED>
d) <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
.  <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

e) LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF
f) LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR.
g) KARYNA SHULIAK
h) <REDACTED>
i) <REDACTED>
j) <REDACTED>

k) <REDACTED>
l) <REDACTED>
m) SLK DESIGNS, LLC

30. Upon my death, my Trustees are directed to distribute to DARREN KEITH
INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns an amount equal to the sum of all financial
obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, I U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability
company, from DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if she
is then married to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation, limited liability
company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by
one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Harlequin
Dane, LLC,' Florida limited liability company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be
distributed to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole
purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities.

31. Upon my death, my Trustees are directed to distribute to RICHARD
DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns an amount equal to the sum of all financial
obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, I U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability
company, from RICHARD KAHN, his spouse, LISA KAHN, if she is then married to
RICHARD KAHN, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership,
general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both oc them
immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Coatue Enterprises, LLC, I New
York limited liability company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be distributed to
RICHARD KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to
repay all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities.

32. It is my intention that all amounts due and owing to me by the persons
listed in Article II, Section 2.31.29 shall be cancelled upon my death. While at the date of
execution, the cancellation of said loans will not result in taxable income to the beneficiaries, in
the event any changes are made to the applicable tax law, my Trustees are directed to take any
and all steps necessary to ensure that the cancellation of such indebtedness does not result in
any negative tax consequences to the Beneficiaries.

33. give to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in. separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Section 3.1 of Article III below, all of my interest in all
apartments, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the premises
located in the building known and referred to as 22 Avenue Foch, 75016, Paris, France. The
interest consists of units 47 with mezzanine, 48 and 81 on the 2nd floor, units 63 and 74 on the
5th floor and units 5 and 22 (cellass) in the basement. The units are currently all owned by SCI
JEP, I French company of which I own 999 of the 1 000 outstanding shares. In addition, I give
to this separate trust for the benefit of if she survives me, the sum of
One Million Dollars ($1,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses for the apartments.
Operating expenses shall include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes,
utilities, general maintenance and repairs and common charges.

Section 2.4. - Balance of Trust Estate
The balance of the Trust Estate, after the distributions provided in Sections 2.1, 2.2 and
2.3 of this Article II, shall be distributed as follows:

1. One Hundred percent (100%) thereof to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in separate trust, the provisions of which are 
set forth in Section 3.2 of Article
III below.
B. I does not survive me, one hundred percent
thereof to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she survives me.
C. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN does not survive me, one hundred
percent (100%) of the balance of the trust estate shall be transferred to THE BOARD OF
TRUSTEES OF THE MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY (hereinafter "the
Board"), an educational institution. The property compromising this gift may, for investment
purposes, be merged with any of the investment assets of the Massachusetts Institute of
Technology ("MIT"), but the gift shall be entered in the books and records of MIT as an
endowed fund known as "THE JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN FUND" (the "Fund"). The Board shall
7 GJ 000412
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 8 of 23
use the endowment payout from the Fund to provide financial aid for graduate and
undergraduate students attending MIT. In the event MIT is no longer in existence as of the
date of any required distribution to it, my Trustees are hereby directed to choose among them
another educational institution to benefit from my Trust.

Section 2.5. — Condition Applicable to Certain Bequests
Except as expressly provided herein, no bequest to any Beneficiary of this Agreement
who, during my lifetime, was employed by or provided services to me or any entity that was
owned directly or indirectly by me during my lifetime shall be distributed to said Beneficiary
prior to the expiration of one year following the date of my death. Any Beneficiary of this
Agreement who, during my lifetime, was employed by me or any entity that was owned directly
or indirectly by me during my lifetime, and who, after my death, shall voluntarily discontinue,
or as' result of said Beneficiary's misconduct, cause to be terminated, said Beneficiary's
employment with or provision of services to my estate or any entity or parcel of real property
directly or indirectly owned by me during my lifetime, prior to the expiration of one year
following the date of my death, shall be ineligible to receive any bequest hereunder; provided,
however that in the event that prior to the expiration of one year following the date of my death,
there is I cessation in the specific operations of my estate or said real property or entity in
respect of which said Beneficiary is employed or provides services, and prior to that cessation,
said Beneficiary had not voluntarily discontinued, or as' result of said Beneficiary's
misconduct, caused to be terminated, said Beneficiary's employment with or provision of
services to my estate or said real property or entity, then my Trustees shall distribute the bequest
hereunder to said Beneficiary within sixty days following the date of such cessation or as soon
as is reasonably practicable thereafter.
Article : Trust Provisions

Section 3.1. - Residence Trust
Any property directed to be held in trust for' Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions of
this Section 3.1 of Article III shall be administered as follows:
The Beneficiary shall have the right to occupy the residence held by the
trust and to use the tangible personal property located in the residence for her lifetime.

B. My Trustees, in my Trustees' sole discretion, may pay any part or all of
the income, and if income is insufficient, the principal of the trust (1) to pay the operating
expenses of the property held by the trust and (2) for any other purpose my Trustees consider
advisable. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal of the trust.

C. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall use my Trustees'
best efforts to sell the trust property and the tangible personal property within two (2) years of
the Beneficiary's death and only in extraordinary circumstances should the property not be sold
within two (2) years of the Beneficiary's death.
8 GJ 000413
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 9 of 23

D. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall distribute the
remaining principal of the trust M., the proceeds from the sale of the trust assets) to EVA
ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she then survives the Beneficiary. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN
does not survive the Beneficiary, then my Trustees shall distribute the remaining principal to
the Board of MIT as provided for in Section 2.4.0 of this Agreement.

Section 3.2. - Residuary Trusts
Any property directed to be held in trust for' Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions of
this Section 3.2 of Article III shall be administered as follows:

I. Any trust property that is real property, including, but not limited to,
improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to such real property, held
directly by me, or indirectly through ovvnershi of shares of capital stock of I corporation or
membership interests of I company, of which I  was the sole beneficial owner prior to my
death, shall be sold by my Trustees and the proceeds thereof held in said trust as soon as is
reasonably practicable following my death. In marketing and effectuating the sale of said real
property, my Trustees shall be guided as nearly as my Trustees determine in their discretion is
possible or appropriate under the then prevailing circumstances by my last express wishes with
respect to the sale of said real property, as shall be contained in the last writing signed by me
and notarized and delivered to at least one of my Trustees prior to my death.

B. My Trustees may pay any part or all of the income and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of the trust as my Trustees, in my Trustees' discretion, from time
to time and at any time, shall determine for any reason whatsoever to, for the benefit of, or on
behalf of the Beneficiary. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal of
the trust.
C. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall distribute the
remaining principal of the trust to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she then survives the
Beneficiary. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN does not survive the Beneficiary, then my
Trustees shall distribute the remaining principal of the trust to the Board of MIT as provided
for in Section 2.4.0 of this Agreement.
ArficlelBL:Thastlerminafinn
If at any time my Trustees determine that it is uneconomic to continue any trust with
respect to which my Trustees are acting hereunder, my Trustees may terminate such trust and
distribute the trust assets, in such amounts and proportions as my Trustees may determine, to
the person or persons to whom income may be distributed, other than my Trustees, members of
the respective families of my Trustees, the respective estates of my Trustees, the respective
creditors of my Trustees or the creditors of the respective estates of my Trustees.
Article V: Trust Administration

Section 5.1. - Exercise of Discretionary Powers
9 GJ 000414
Jeffrey b. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 10 of 23
Except as hereinbefore specifically provided, in connection with the exercise of I
discretionary power to distribute income or principal to any person, there shall be no
requirement to take into account such person's other income or capital resources, the interest of
such person in any other fund or the duty of anyone to support such person, although these
factors may be taken into account.

Section 5.2. - Discretionary Distributions
Any discretionary payment from any trust hereunder shall be charged against such trust
as' whole, and shall not be charged against the individual share of any person at any time.

Section 5.3. - Allocation of Assets
For each distribution, partial distribution, allocation, or division of assets
into shares or trusts involving I fraction, my Trustees shall apply such fraction to the fair
market value of the relevant assets on the date of such distribution, allocation, or division,
whichever first occurs. My Trustees shall appropriately adjust such fractions to reflect the
effect of any partial distributions, allocations, or divisions, taking into account the fair market
value as of the date of distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurred, of the
assets so distributed, allocated, or divided.

B. My Trustees shall value any assets distributed, allocated, or divided to
satisfy (in whole or in part) I pecuniary distribution at the fair market value of such assets on
the date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurs.

Section 5.4. - Accounting Allocations

I. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement and except
as provided in Paragraph B of this Section 5.4, my Trustees shall allocate receipts and
disbursements in accordance with sound trust accounting principles and have discretion to
allocate receipts and disbursements when, in the judgment of my Trustees, the treatment is
uncertain under applicable laws or generally accepted accounting principles.

B. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, my
Trustees shall not treat any part of the principal amount of the proceeds of sale of any asset of
any trust as income distributable to or for the benefit of any beneficiary entitled to distributions
of income; provided, however, that my Trustees shall treat' portion of any proceeds of sale of
any financial instrument originally issued or acquired at' discount equal to the amount which

(1) has previously been characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes or (2) will be
characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes in the year of such sale, as income
for trust accounting purposes.

Section 5.5. - Spendthrift Provision
During the term of any trust hereunder, no money or other assets (either principal or
income) payable or distributable under the provisions of this Agreement shall be pledged,
assigned, transferred, given, conveyed, hypothecated, sold, anticipated, charged, or
encumbered by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder, nor shall the income and principal of any
to GJ 000415
iettrey E. Epstein 2017 trust
Page 11 of 23
trust, while in the possession of my Trustees, be liable for any debts, contracts, obligations, or
undertakings of such Beneficiaries, voluntary or involuntary, or for any claims or judgments
against any Beneficiary. including claims for alimony or for the support of any Beneficiary's
spouse or children, or for reimbursement of I federal, state or local government, or any agency
of any federal, state, or local government, for the support of any Beneficiary hereunder, prior to
the time such money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary. Any
attempted pledge, assignment, transfer, gift, conveyance, hypothecation, anticipation, charge,
or encumbrance of any money or assets (either income or principal) payable or distributable
under the provisions of this Agreement by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder prior to the time
such money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary shall be null and void
and shall not be recognized by my Trustees. This Section 5.5 of Article V shall not apply to
me.

Section 5.6. - Limitation on Distributions
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, no discretionary distribution of
income or principal of any trust hereunder shall be applied to pay for medical care, residential
facilities, or any other care or service that would otherwise be provided for any Beneficiary
hereunder by any federal, state, or other governmental agency; and no such discretionary
distribution of income or principal shall be made for reimbursement for any such care, facilities
or services previously provided. Before making any discretionary payment to or for the benefit
of any such Beneficiary hereunder, my Trustees shall consider the amounts such Beneficiary is
or may be entitled to receive from any governmental agency for such care, facilities, or
services. If such amounts are available, discretionary distributions of income and principal
from any trust hereunder shall be made only to supplement such amounts, and to provide
liberally for needs and comforts over and above the basic maintenance, support, and medical
care that may be paid for by any such agency.

Section 5.7. - Division and Combination of Trusts

I. For any administrative, tax or other purpose determined by my Trustees
to be in the best interests of any Beneficiary (including any remainderman) hereunder, my
Trustees may at any time and from time to time (whether before or after finding), without
approval of any court, divide any trust under this Agreement into two or more separate trusts or
combine two or more trusts with substantially identical terms (whether or not such trusts
resulted from division of I prior trust).

B. If property is directed to be added to any trust hereunder (the "Original
Trust"), whether by the terms of this Agreement any other agreement, or the Will of any
person, my Trustees may hold such property as one or more separate trusts on terms identical
to the terms of the Original Trust. My Trustees may allocate such property among the separate
trusts (if any) into which the Original Trust was divided, whether or not pro-rata, using
specific assets or undivided interests therein (including allocation of all such property to one of
such separate trusts).
C. Any time during the existence of separate trusts created by division of I
trust hereunder, my Trustees may exercise all discretionary powers differently with respect to
the separate trusts and take all other actions consistent with such trusts being separate entities.
11 GJ 000416
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 12 of 23
Furthermore, the holder of any power of appointment with respect to such separate trusts may
exercise such power differently with respect to each such trust.

Section 5.8. - Consolidation of Trusts
If at any time after my death there is in existence' trust under my Will or any trust
agreement created by me having identical beneficiaries and substantially the same terms as any
trust under this Agreement, my Trustees may terminate the trust hereunder and transfer the
assets thereof to the Trustees of such other trust, to be administered by the Trustees thereof.
Different termination dates under the applicable Rule Against Perpetuities shall not be deemed
Idifference in the terms of such trusts, but the portion of the trust representing the transferred
assets shall retain the same termination date as the original trust.

Section 5.9. -Termination of Trusts
Notwithstanding anything herein, any trust created hereunder for any person shall
(unless terminated earlier) terminate upon the day preceding the expiration of the maximum
period permitted under the United States Virgin Islands Rule Against Perpetuities, for the
vesting of an interest in' trust and upon such date the assets of such trust shall be distributed to
such person.

Section 5.10.  — Equitable Adjustment
If any of my Trustees decides to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted
by this Agreement or by law (including, without limitation, any election available to my
Trustee) and the exercise or non-exercise of such power confers' benefit on one Beneficiary or
class of Beneficiaries hereunder and imposes' detriment upon another Beneficiary or class of
Beneficiaries hereunder, my Trustees shall not attempt to restore the interests of the
Beneficiaries or classes of Beneficiaries to the position otherwise contemplated by this
Agreement through adjustment between income and principal or otherwise.

Section 5.11. - Lapsed Distribution
Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, I provision for
distribution to an individual who is not surviving at the date such individual otherwise becomes
eligible for such distribution shall lapse notwithstanding any law to the contrary.

Section 5.12. - Notice
Any notice required hereunder shall be delivered personally or sent by first class or
certified mail addressed to the last known address of the intended recipient.

Section 5.13. - Termination of Trust
An instrument in writing completely revoking this Agreement shall, without more,
upon delivery to any of my Trustees, completely terminate all of my Trustees' right, title,
and interest to any life insurance proceeds, death benefits, pension, profit sharing, or other
retirement benefits or any other assets otherwise payable to my Trustees.
12 GJ 000417
Jettrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 13 of 23
Article VI: Powers of Trustees

Section 6.1. - Exercise of Judgment and Powers
The Trustee oft trust hereunder has the entire care and custody of all assets of such
trust. My Trustees have the power to do everything my Trustees in good faith deem
advisable without necessity of any judicial authorization or approval, even though but for
this power it would not be authorized or appropriate for fiduciaries under any statutory or
other rule of law. My Trustees shall exercise my Trustees' best judgment and discretion for
what my Trustees believe to be in the best interests of such trust and the Beneficiaries of
such trust. If more than two Trustees are empowered as my Trustee to participate in the
decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by
law,' majority of such Trustees shall be empowered to make such decision.

Section 6.2. - Compensation of My Trustee
Each Trustee acting hereunder shall be entitled to annual compensation for services
performed hereunder in the amount of Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000)
per year, in addition to any bequest to which they may be entitled under this terms of this
Trust. No other compensation shall be payable to my Trustees hereunder; provided,
however, that my Trustees shall be reimbursed for all reasonable costs, expenses, charges,
and liabilities incurred or paid in connection with acting as Trustee or performing services
hereunder, including, but not limited to, fees and expenses of counsel or any other agents
hired by my Trustees, and my Trustees shall not be liable therefor individually. My
Trustees have discretion to pay such compensation and such reimbursements from trust
assets, without obtaining judicial authorization or approval.

Section 6.3. - General Investment Powers
I . Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, my Trustees have
the power with respect to each and ever trust created hereunder:

1. To enter upon and take possession of the assets of such trust and
collect the income and profits from such assets, and to invest and reinvest Rich assets in
real, personal, or mixed assets (including the common trust funds of I corporate
fiduciary) or in undivided interests therein without being limited by any present or
future investment laws;

2. To retain all or any part of the assets of such trust (without regard to
the proportion that any one asset or class of assets may bear to the whole) in the form in
which such assets were received or acquired by my Trustees;

3. To sell or dispose of, exchange, transfer, invest, or loan all or any part of
the assets of such trust which my Trustees hold, at any time, for such sums or upon such
terms as to payment, security, or otherwise as my Trustees determine, either by public or
private transactions;
13 GJ 000418
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 14 of 23

4. To buy and sell options, warrants, puts, calls or other rights to purchase or
sell (collectively called "options") relating to any security or securities, regardless of
whether such security or securities are then held by my Trustees, and whether such options
are purchased or sold on I national securities exchange, and to exercise with respect to such
options all powers which an individual owner thereof could exercise, including, without
limitation, the right to allow the same to expire;
5. With respect to oil, natural gas, minerals, and all other natural resources
and rights to and interests therein (together with all equipment pertaining thereto) including,
without limiting the generality of the foregoing, oil and gas royalties, leases, or other oil and
gas interests of any character, whether owned in fee, as lessee, lessor, licensee,
concessionaire or otherwise, or alone or jointly with others as partner, joint tenant, or joint
venturer in any other noncorporate manner, I) to make oil, gas and mineral leases or
subleases; (b) to pay delay rentals, lease bonuses, royalties, overriding royalties, taxes,
assessments, and all other charges; (c) to sell, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge or
otherwise hypothecate any or all of such rights and interests; (d) to surrender or abandon,
with or without consideration, any or all of such rights and interests; (e) to make farm-out,
pooling, and unitization agreements; (f) to make reservations or impose conditions on the
transfer of any such rights or interests; (g) to employ the most advantageous business form
in which properly to exploit such rights and interests, whether as corporations, partnerships,
limited partnerships, mining partnerships, limited liability companies, joint ventures, co-
tenancies, or otherwise exploit any and all such rights and interests; (h) to produce, process,
sell or exchange all products recovered through the exploitation of such rights and interests,
and to enter into contracts and agreements for or in t of the installation or operation of
absorption, reprocessin or other processing pianist co carry any or all such interests in
the name or names ofl nominee or nominees; (j) to delegate, to the extent permitted by law,
any or all of the powers set forth herein to the operator of such property; and (k) to employ
personnel, rent office space, buy or lease office equipment, contract and pay for geological
surveys and studies, procure appraisals, and generally to conduct and engage in any and all
activities incident to the foregoing powers, with full power to borrow and pledge in order to
finance such activities; together with the power to allocate between principal and income
any net proceeds received as consideration, whether as royalties or otherwise, for the
permanent severance from lands of oil, natural gas, minerals, and all other natural
resources;

6. To hold all or any part of the assets of such trust in cash or in bank
accounts without the necessity of investing the same; of such trust;

7. To improve, repair, partition, plat, or subdivide all or any part of the assets
of such trust;
8. To litigate, defend, compromise, settle, abandon, or submit to mediation
or arbitration on such terms and conditions as my Trustees determine any claims in favor of
or against such trust or the assets of such trust;

9. To loan or borrow money in such amounts and upon such terms and
conditions as my Trustees determine, assume such obligations or give such guarantees as my
14 GJ 000419
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 15 of 23
Trustees determine, for the purpose of the acquisition, improvement, protection, retention, or
preservation of the assets of such trust, or for the benefit of any of the Beneficiaries who are
entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust;

10. To create or invest in any entity with all or part of the assets of such trust
and to carry on for as long and in such manner as m Trustees determine any business
enterprise held or created by my Trustees or in which I owned any interest at my death,
either individually or as' partner, member joint venturer, stockholder, trust beneficiary, or
member; to sell such business enterprise as an ongoing business; to consolidate, merge,
encumber, dissolve, liquidate or undertake any other extraordinary corporate transaction
relating to such business enterprise;

11. To vote in person or by proxy any and all stock or securities and to
become' party to any voting trusts, reorganization, consolidation, or other capital or debt
readjustment of any corporation, association, partnership, limited liability partnership,
limited liability company, or individual with respect to stocks, securities, or debts held by
such trust;

12. Except as provided in Sections 6.3B, C, and D of this Article VI, to enter
into any good faith transactions with my Trustees individually or with any corporation,
partnership, limited liability partnership, limited liability company, or other entity in which
any of my Trustees has an ownership interest;

13. To purchase from my estate any stocks, bonds, securities, real or
personal property, or other assets, or make loans to my estate even though the same person
or persons occupy the office of my Trustee and the office of the Executor of my estate;

14. To lease, mortgage, pledge, grant' security interest in, or otherwise
encumber all or any part of the assets of such trust for any term of years whether or not
beyond the term of such trust (including, without limitation, any such action for the benefit
of any of the Beneficiaries of such trust);

15. To abandon any property of such trust, real or personal, which my
Trustees may deem worthless or not of sufficient value to warrant keeping or protecting; to
abstain from the payment of taxes, water rents or assessments and to forego making repairs,
maintaining or keeping up any such property; and to permit such property to be lost by tax
sale or other proceedings or to convey any such property for' nominal consideration or
without consideration so as to prevent the imposition of any liability by reason of the
continued ownership thereof;

16. To elect the mode of distribution of the proceeds from any profit-sharing
plan, pension plan, employee benefit plan, individual retirement plan, insurance contract, or
annuity contract pursuant to the terms of such plan or to change to another custodian of
such plan;

17. To conduct any audit, assessment, or investigation with respect to any
asset of such trust regarding compliance with any law or regulation having as its object
protection of public health, natural resources, or the environment (referred to as
15 GJ 000420
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 16 of 23
"Environmental Laws"); to pay from the assets of such trust to remedy any failure to
comply with any Environmental Law (even to the exhaustion of all of the assets of such
trust); and, as may be required in my Trustee's judgment by any Environmental Law, to
notify any governmental authority of any past, present, or future non-compliance with
any Environmental Law; and

18. To refuse to accept any asset distributable to suchtrust.
B. No Trustee shall directly or indirectly buy or sell any property for the
trust from or to himself, or from or to his relative, employer, employee, partner or other
business associate.

C. No Trustee shall as trustee of one trust sell property to himself as
trustee of another trust.
D. No Trustee shall lend trust funds to himself, or to his relative,
employer, employee, partner, or other business associate.

Section 6.4. - Administrative Powers
Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, my Trustees have the power with
respect to each trust:

I. To employ agents, attorneys-at-law, consultants, investment advisers
(to whom my Trustees have discretion to delegate my Trustees' investment authority and
responsibility), other trustees and other fiduciaries in the administration of my Trustees'
duties, to delegate to such persons, or to one or more of my Trustees, the custody, control,
or management of any part of the assets of such trust as my Trustees determine and to pay
for such services from the assets of such trust, without obtaining judicial authorization or
approval;

B. To delegate, in whole or in part, to any person or persons the
authority and power to (1) sign checks, drafts or orders for the payment or withdrawal of
funds, securities and other assets from any bank, brokerage, custody or other account in
which funds, securities or other assets of such trust shall be deposited, (2) endorse for sale,
transfer or delivery, or sell, transfer or deliver, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any and
all property, stocks, stock warrants, stock rights, options, bonds or other securities
whatsoever, (3) gain access to any safe deposit box or boxes in which assets of such trust
may be located or which may be in the name of any of my Trustees and remove part or all
of the contents of any such safe deposit box or boxes and release and surrender the same,
and (4) take any other action that my Trustee may have the power to take with respect to
such trust and the property thereof; no person or corporation acting in reliance on any such
delegation shall be charged with notice of any revocation or change of such delegation
unless such person or corporation receives actual notice thereof;

C. To pay any property distributable to' Beneficiary under' legal
16 GJ_000421
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 17 of 23
disability or who has not attained the age of 21, without liability to my Trustees, by paying
such property (1) to such Beneficiary, (2) for the use of such Beneficiary, (3) to I legal
representative of such Beneficiary appointed by' court or if none, to' relative for the use
of such Beneficiary, or (4) to, custodian for such Beneficiary designated by my Trustees,
to hold until age 21 or such earlier age as shall be the maximum permitted under
applicable law;

D. To divide such trust into subsidiary accounts if my Trustees
determine that such division is necessary to maintain fair and accurate records;

E. To permit the Beneficiary of such trust to use, possess, and enjoy real
property, tangible personal property, or club memberships held by such trust;

F. To distribute to such trust or any of the Beneficiaries of such trust in
kind or in cash, or partly in kind and partly in cash, and to allocate different kinds or
disproportionate shares of assets or undivided interests in assets among all of such trusts or
all of such Beneficiaries;

G. In making the division into one or more trusts hereunder (if such
trusts have the same Trustees), to keep the assets of such trusts invested and handled as'
single fund without actual division and to designate such trusts on my Trustees' books as
owning' designated undivided interest in such fund;

H. To have evidence of ownership of any security maintained in the
records of I Federal Reserve Bank under the Federal Reserve Book Entry System; to
deposit funds in any bank or trust company; to carry in the name of any of my Trustees or
the nominee or nominees of the Trustees and with or without designation of fiduciary
capacity, or to hold in bearer form, securities or other roperty requiring or permitting of
registration; and to cause any securities to be held by I depository corporation of which'
Trustee is I member or by an agent under' safekeeping contract; provided, however, that
the books and records of my Trustees shall at all times show that such investments are part
of such trust;
To register or not register such trust with the probate division of the
Superior Court of the United States Virgin Islands or otherwise and to make all decisions
which relate thereto;

J. To give any Beneficiary of any trust hereunder' general power of
appointment exercisable in such Beneficiary's Will over all or part of such trust, subject to
any terms and conditions as my Trustees determine, by written notice to such Beneficiary;
to eliminate any such power of appointment by written notice to the Beneficiary; and to
irrevocabl release the power under this paragraph to give' power of appointment or to
I eliminate  power of appointment;

K. To renounce and disclaim, in whole or in part, and in accordance
with applicable law, any assets, interests, rights, or powers (including any power of
17 GJ 000422
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 18 of 23
appointment) which are payable to (or exercisable by) such trust or over which my
Trustees have any right, title, interest, or power; and

L. To make, execute, and deliver any and all such instruments in
writing as shall be necessary or proper to carry out any power, right, duty, or obligation of
my Trustees or any disposition whatsoever of such trust or any asset of such trust and to
exercise any and all other powers incidental or necessary to carry out or to fulfill the
terms, provisions and purposes of such trust.

Section 6.5. _Restrictions on Exercise of My Trustee's Powers

A. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, a
Trustee shall not participate in a discretionary decision to exercise or not exercise any
fiduciary power to (1) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder to
himself or herself; or (2) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder for the
health, support, maintenance or education of a Beneficiary if such Trustee has a legal
obligation to provide for the health, support, maintenance or education of such
Beneficiary from such Trustee's personal assets. For purposes of this paragraph, a person
whose interest in a trust hereunder is limited to a remote contingent interest (for example,
a contingent remainderman whose interest depends upon another person failing to survive
to a specified age or a person designated to receive assets only in the event a power of
appointment is not exercised) shall not be treated as a person who is or may be a
Beneficiary of such trust.

B. A Trustee of any trust hereunder may by a written notice delivered to
the other Trustee (or Trustees) of such trust decline to participate in the decision to
exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law.
C. If a Trustee of any trust hereunder is not empowered (because of a
conflict of interest, declination to act or otherwise) to participate in the decision to exercise
or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, then the
remaining Trustee or Trustees of such trust shall be empowered to make such decision. If
no Trustee or successor Trustee is empowered to participate in such decision, my Trustees
may designate a substitute Trustee to serve as Trustee of such trust who shall be
empowered to make such decision but has no other power or authority of the Trustees.
Such designation shall be by written notice delivered to such substitute Trustee.
Article VII: Provisions Concerning Trustees

Section 7.1. - Successor Trustees
In the event a Trustee resigns, is removed, becomes incapacitated or is unwilling or
is unable to serve, KATHRYN RUEMMLER shall be appointed the successor trustee. In
the event that any additional Trustees are removed, become incapacitated, or are unwilling
or unable to serve, STEPHEN HANSON shall first be appointed to fill any vacancy, such
18 GJ 000423
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 19 of 23
that the total number of Trustees acting on behalf of the Trust at all times shall be three.

Section 7.2. - Appointment of Trustee
The appointment of I successor Trustee hereunder shall become effective when such
successor Trustee signs an acceptance of the trust.

Section 7.3. - Resignation of Trustees
Any Trustee may resign at any time, without the approval of any court, by an
instrument in writing filed with the trust records. In addition, if there is filed with the trust
records' written certification from any attending physician of any individual Trustee of I trust
that he or she is no longer able to make decisions with respect to such trust, then from the date
of filing of such certification, such individual Trustee shall be deemed to have resigned for all
purposes of this Agreement.

Section 7.4. - Vacancy in Office
If there is one or more than one vacancy in the Trustees and no successor Trustee is
designated pursuant to Section 7.1 who is willing or able to act, my Trustees then serving shall
designate one or more successor Trustees as is necessary to fill such vacancy or vacancies by
written notice delivered to the designated Trustee or Trustees. If there are no Trustees then
serving to fill ply of the three vacancies in the Trustees, the legally competent adult
Beneficiary (or I majority in beneficial interest of the legally competent adult Beneficiaries if
there are multiple Beneficiaries) then entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust
shall designate the successor Trustees to fill such vacancies by an instrument in writing
delivered to the designated Trustees. If the legally competent adult Beneficiaries do not
designate the successor Trustees to fill such vacancies within sixty days after receipt of notice
of such vacancies or if there is no legally competent adult Beneficiary of such trust, then'
successor Trustee shall be named by order of I court of competent jurisdiction, and said
appointed successor Trustee shall designate the remaining Trustees necessary to fill such
vacancies by an instrument in writing delivered to the designated Trustees. All of the fees and
expenses of my Trustees (including attorneys' fees) attributable to the appointment of one or
more successor Trustees of I trust shall be paid from the assets of such trust.

Section 7.5. - Elimination of Bond
No bond or other security shall be required of any Trustee hereunder in any jurisdiction.

Section 7.6. - Exculpation and Indemnification of My Trustee
No one serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be accountable or
responsible to any person interested in any trust hereunder for the manner in which my
Trustees shall in good faith exercise any discretionary authority or any power of my Trustees.
No one serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be liable for any loss or
depreciation in value occasioned by reason of any negligence, error or mistake of judgment in
entering into any transaction, in making any sale or investment, in continuing to hold any
property, or by reason of any action or omission, whether by my Trustees or any other
19 GJ 000424
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 20 of 23
fiduciary, unless such Trustee has acted in bad faith. In the absence of proof by affirmative
evidence to the contrary, each Trustee shall be deemed to have acted within the scope of my
Trustees' authority, to have exercised reasonable care, diligence, and prudence and to have
acted impartially as to all interested persons. I Trustee shall not be liable for the acts or
defaults of another Trustee.
In the event' legal action is brought against any individual serving as the Trustee of
any trust under this Agreement, all legal fees and related expenses incurred in connection with
the defense of such lewd action shall be paid by such trust without court authorization;
provided, however, that (ID no such payment shall (or shall continue to) be made if' court
enters an order prohibiting such payment, and (b) such Trustee shall refund to the trust any
such payments that previously had been made if' court enters an order directing that such
payments be refunded, or if' court concludes that such Trustee acted in bad faith.

Section 7.7. - Relief from Virgin Islands Statutory Provisions
Pursuant to Section 1212, Title 15, of the Virgin Islands Code, I hereby relieve my
Trustees and any Successor Trustees of the requirements imposed by Chapter 59, Tide 15 of
the Virgin Islands Code, or any similar successor law respecting public filings of inventories
and accounting by Trustees. Furthermore, pursuant to Section 1107, Title 15, of the Virgin
Islands Code, I hereby relieve the my Trustees and any Successor Trustees, to the extent
allowable, from any all duties, restrictions, and liabilities which would otherwise be imposed
upon my Trustees by Chapter 57, Tide 15, Virgin Islands Code. This Section 7.7 shall not be
deemed' waiver of any and all other rights, powers, or restrictions otherwise granted to my
Trustees in this Agreement.
Article VIII: Miscellaneous Provisions

Section 8.1. - Representation of Person Under Disability
To the extent allowed by law, where' party to any proceeding with respect to any trust
hereunder has the same interest as' person under' disability, legal process shall not be
required on the person under' disability.

Section 8.2. - Simultaneous Deaths
If' Beneficiary under this Agreement and I die simultaneously or under such
circumstances that it is difficult to determine who died first, then for all purposes of this
Agreement such Beneficiary shall be deemed to have predeceased me.

Section 8.3. - Law Governing
This Agreement and each trust created by it shall in all respects and for all purposes be
governed and regulated by the laws of the Territory of the United States Virgin Islands, as they
now exist and may from time to time be enacted, amended, or repealed. All questions regarding
the validity, construction and administration of this Agreement, or any of its provisions, and of
any trust created by it shall be determined solely by the laws of that Territory. The courts of the
State of Delaware and the U.S. Virgin Islands shall have primary supervision over the
administration of each trust created by this Agreement. It is intended that each such trust shall
20 GJ 000425
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 21 of 23
be' U.S. domestic trust as defined in Title 26 section 7701(1)(30) of the Code by virtue of
meeting the court and control test. As provided in Treas. Reg. section 301.7701-7(cX4)(D),
if both United States court and' foreign court are able to exercise primary supervision over the
administration of the trust, the trust meets the court test.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, my Trustees of each trust
created under this Agreement have discretion at any time or times following my death to
transfer the situs of such trust to such other country, or such other jurisdiction as my Trustees
determine, without obtaining judicial authorization or approval (unless such judicial
authorization or approval is required by applicable law) and without the filing of any bond. My
Trustees' determination to transfer the situs of any trust under this Agreement shall be
evidenced by an instrument in writing signed, witnessed and acknowledged by my Trustees in
the same manner as would be required for' deed. My Trustees are authorized to take whatever
actions are necessary to affect such' transfer of situs. If judicial authorization or approval is
required to effect such' transfer of silos,' intend and desire that the appropriate court accept
the determination of my Trustees concerning the transfer of the situs of such trust even if one
or more Beneficiaries disagree with such determination. From and after my Trustees' transfer
of the situs of I trust pursuant to this Section 8.3 of Article VIII, the administration of such
trust shall be governed by the law of the new situs of such trust.

Section 8.4. - Definition of Terms
Except as otherwise specifically provided herein, as used in this Agreement,

II. The term "Trustee" means all persons or entities who occupy the office
of Trustee of any trust hereunder while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether
one or more persons or entities occupy the office of Trustee at the same time or times, and
includes any successor Trustee or Trustees. The term "Executor" of I person's estate means all
persons or entities who occupy the office of personal representative, administrator, executor, or
ancillary administrator while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more
persons or entities occupy such office at the same time or times, and includes any successor or
successors to that office., reference to' person's Will means such person's Last Will and
Testament and any Codicil or Codicils thereto.

B. 'reference to any tax also includes any interest or penalties thereon.
The term "my Gross Estate" means my gross estate as finally determined for purposes of
computing my federal estate tax.

C. Whenever the singular number is used, the same shall include the plural,
and the masculine gender shall include the feminine and neuter genders.

Section 8.5. - No Contest
If any Beneficiary under this Agreement shall in any way directly or indirectly (I) contest or
object to the probate of my Will or to the validity of any disposition or provision of my Will or
of this Agreement or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or indirectly instrumental
in the institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest, objection or claim for the
21 GJ 000426
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 22 of 23
purpose of setting aside or invalidating my Will or this Agreement or any disposition therein or
herein or provision thereof or hereof, then I direct that (aa) any and all provisions in this
Agreement for such Beneficiary and his issue in any degree shall be null and void and (bb) my
estate whether passing under my Will or this Agreement or pursuant to the laws of intestacy shall
be disposed of as if such Beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all failed to survive me.

Section 8.6. -Trustee Notice
My Trustees may have duties and responsibilities in addition to those described in
this Agreement. If my Trustees have questions, my Trustees should obtain legal advice.
CONCLUSION
Ihave duly executed this Amended and Restated Trust Agreement on the date set opposite
my signature.
Jeffrey-E. Epstein, Grantor
Eva Andersson Dubin, Trustee
Richard D. Kahn, Trustee

K. Indyke, Trustee
STATE OF NEW YORK )
) ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
Date  1 V31-3\ \ -1
Date
Date  1 \ '\1
Date ll3a,1/q
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this Wtlay of January, 2017
by JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, the Grantor, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn t. before me this 3O -itt day of January, 2017.
Not Public
LESLEY K GROFF
Notary Public • State of New York

NO. 01GR6285700
Oualitled in New York CoJnis
My Commission Expires Jul 9. 4ot?
22 GJ_000427
Jeffrey E. Epstein 2017 Trust
Page 23 of 23
STATE OF NEW YORK )
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this day of January, 2017,
by EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, I Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this day of January, 2017.
Notary Public
STATE OF NEW YORK )
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this 30 -uiday of January, 2017,
by DARREN K. INDYKE, I Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this r day of January, 2017.
ry Public LESLEY K GROFF
Notary Public - State of New York

NO. 01GR6285700
Qualified in New York County
My Commission Expires Jul 8, 2011
STATE OF NEW YORK )
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this 3E/Thday of January, 2017,
by RICI-IARD D. KAHN, I Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworj to before me this 3O11'day of January, 2017.
- ll
Public LESLEY K GROFF
Notary Public • State of New York
NO. 016R6285700
(MIMS in New York County
My Commission Expires Jul 8. 2017
23 GJ 000428
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                    Electric Coin Company [crypto] FKA 'Zerocoin', Madars Virza and untraceable cryptocurrency ZCash 
 Zerocoin [crypto] early name for Epstein funded untraceable cryptocurrency ZCash developed by Madars Virza [z.cash] 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00615489 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2017-03-01)
The Zerocoin Electric Coin Company
Tax Returns Update
2017-03-01
Due to the technical nature of the tax issues faced by the company we are working with our tax
advisors to ensure we adopt the best possible overall tax situation. This will require that the
partnership file an extension of time to file its tax return and as a result we do not expect final
Schedule K-1's to be available until sometime later this summer. We will be working with our
CPA to get everyone estimated numbers so that the partner's can properly estimate their tax
liability for their taxes and file an extension.
EFTA00593085 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2017-03-03)
VALAR Vt.NTURtU
Valor Global Fund II LP Capital Call
February 10, 2017
Dear Southern Trust Company. Inc..
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund II LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $1,500.000.00, which represents 10% of your total commitment
of $15.000.000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Friday March 3, 2017.
After this capitol contribution, you will have contributed 91% of your total commitment with a
remaining 9% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of March 3, 2017:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$15,000,000.00
$13,650,000.00
$1,350.000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Friday March 3, 2017
$1,500,000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
Valor Global Fund II LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
+1
VOiO1 Ventures LLC New York, New York 10010 www.valar.com
EFTA01616775 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage from Bechet Allen grooming Bechet Allen
(date: 2017-03-29)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
•
Bechet Allen
0  Bechet Allen
Sure, what time works for you?
03:46:00 pm
Bechet Allen
Can we do 2:40?
03:52:25 pin
2017/03/29
Bechet , can we Skype ?? Jeffrey epstein
03:43:50 pm
2? Is that ok?
03:52:10 pm
Of course
03:52:34 pm
Jeevacation is my Skype
03:52:48 pm
http://www.bard.edu/bardabroad/bard/exchanges/
05:39:00 pm
•
•
Bechet Allen
06:35:48 pm
lots to talk about what is your Skype name?
05:39:00 pm
2017/03/30
if you could have job drawing is that something you would enjoy, . drawing for
? . or learning biz. . or what would be your ideal job, ? traveling.? building
homes for the poor ( homes for habitat ). . fashion? etc
02:55:36 am
Bechet Allen
I think I'd want to build schools around the world for girls in areas where they lack
proper education.
11:24:54 am
Go to "homes for habitat ". I'm on plane to Paris can Skype after 5 your time
11:26:16 am
I'd appreciate a drawing of your choice
11:26:50 am
Bechet Allen
I don't think I have anything good enough for you...
11:27:47 am
Ok
11:28:11 am
•
•
•
Taking off now
11:28:55 am
Skype ?
07:24:18 pm
Bechet Allen
I can't. I have practice right now until 5
07:25:53 pin
anytime you like tomorrow ok. if over the weekend if you prefer.
07:28:00 pm
2017/03/31
https://www.habitat.org/housing-help
2017/04/0105:10:52 pm
Interested?
04:57:41 pm
Builds schools
04:57:57 pm
Time for Skype? If you prefer not it's ok
05:01:19 pm
•
•
•
•
Bechet Allen
Sorry I just got out of school
08:21:38 pm
Bechet Allen
Right now works
08:26:16 pm
Bechet Allen
Yup it's done :)
02:00:59 pm
would you like to Skype now or tomorrow? your call Im easy
08:23:44 pm
2017/04/07
did you fill out application. do you need help , guidance etc
01:02:51 pm
great
02:17:24 pm
you were going to send me some drawings
02:17:38 pm
2017/04/09
777
05:59:32 pm
•
•
•
•
Bechet Allen
06:00:52 pm
Applications filled out?
06:02:11 pm
Money sent?
06:02:20 pm
I pay if you prefer
06:02:38 pm
Bechet Allen
Yes they're all filled out thank you :)
06:20:04 pm
great
06:50:07 pm
2017/04/18
http://camp.interlochen.org/program/visual-arts/hs/advanced-drawing
1 1
please look at this I know this well.
06:54:34 pm
it is terrific. if you agree, i can try, it is really great fun \
07:00:18 pm
Bechet Allen
I won't have the time unfortunately...l'Il be in Kenya with habitat
09:18:44 pm
yes, i know. but if we can get you into the camp. we could switch kenya for later. . its
an amazing place with great teachers and unique art classes. . its also the last year
you could go as you get to old next year.
09:35:10 pm
come see me thurs in new york, bring my drawing ur
09:35:45 pm
Bechet Allen
When would I go to Kenya?
09:45:28 pm
2017/04/19
Bechet Allen
It would also interfere with my trip to Australia...
12:56:28 am
2017/10/21
Bechet Allen
Hi Jeffrey, it's Bechet. I heard you were going to the concert tonight at Bard
06:08:13 pm
✓ Read
2017/10/23
helicopter couldn't land. . i don't like cars
10:45:53 am
✓ Sent
EFTA02731529 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2017-03-29)
. A t Paselal
onaxosumas

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ CITIGOLD SERVICES │
╰───────────────────╯

%In I • \In III. 2,715 lag
Pig; 3o; 7
Mart I ,A I 'fit Par 4 of 7
Page 5 47

╭─────────────── Page 5, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ Tucomig Wire Taner WIRE FROM THE) BLACK TRUST │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Ni3N : • Slav 31. 201) Page 0 d7
Chttking Continued
November 2 November 30.2015 Page 1 of 7
November 2 - No..rmitr 30. 2015 Nee 2 of 7
Nin •. iP `n S Page 3 of
MOS Page 4 of
Miteigrena:;:i,
IMO Pars of 7
II/20/15 I ncomi Wire Tanta WIRE FROM E 7RUST 1CO.000.00
r 2 No.en Page6o(7
' I - Ma 1.3016
0405/16 Incoming Wire Transfer WIRE FROM E TRUST 100.000.00
Page 20(7
. v 2 1 Rag; 3°17
0.-'70-1007.-0: Jf
A rill -Ma 1.2016 Page 4 0(7
it I %Lay I, 7016 Pagc 5 of?
Se cnbe 2017 Page I of 10
CITIGOLD SERVICES
ember I -Se comber 30.2017 Page 2 off 10
tcmhcr I .tie al c: .10 :011 l'a,;.e 3a to
M1 -Se ember 30. 2017 Page 4d 10
er1-SRmberJ 2017 Pap 5 of 10

╭──── Page 21, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

ember 1. Se member 30 2017 Page 6 of 10
09/20117 brcomi. Wire Transfer WIRE FROM EIRUST 100.0:10.00
' ' .a', • 7," l'a 7 ono
EFTA00009952 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2017-03-31)
STATEMENT IN SUPPORT OF REGISTRATION OF A UNITED STATES
CIVIL AIRCRAFT IN THE NAME OF A
LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY.
PLAN D, LLC -, a limited liability company of a United States Citizen and is eligible to register aircraft
in its name. In this regard, we make to following representations:

1. The full name of the Applicant LLC is: PLAN D, LLC
II. The state in which this LLC is lawfully organized is: U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS
The effective date of the LLC is: OCTOBER 19,2012

IV. The name of each of the members of the LLC and the type of entity of each member
(i.e.: individual, corporation, partnership, etc.)
Name Type of Entity  U.S. Citizenship Verification
Jeffrey E. Epstein  Individual  Y  X
Additional Members listed on additional pages:
Y N
Y  N

V. This LLC is managed by Managers or Members (Circle One)
VI. The manager(s) or member(s) of this LLC may act independently: Y  X  N
VII. The name of the Manager of this LLC LAWRENCE VISOSKI
The Manager is a(n)_X individual corporation partnership  other
The undersigned certifies that he/she/it understands that an LLC is eligible to register aircraft in its name provided
that:

(I) at least 2/3rds of the managers or managing members are "U.S. Citizens" within the meaning of 49 U.S.C.

Section 40102(2)(15)(C) and:

(2) at least 75% of the voting interest or units is owned or controlled by persons who are "U.S.citizens" or
citizens of one of its possessions; and specifically that AN LLC CANNOT REGISTER AS A NON -CITIZENS
CORPORATION.
If any member of this LLC is not a United States Citizen as defined in 40102(a)(15)(C) an explanation appears below
to support the certification that this LLC is a "U.S. Citizen" as required by 49 U.S.C. Section 40102(2)(15)(C).
The undersigned hereby also certifies that the information given herein is true and correct and meets all citizenship
specifications as required by the Federal Aviation AdminiStlation.
PLAIN D, LLC
L
e
By:
wrence Visoski
Its: Manager
Accepted CF Mar/31/2017
FILED WITH FAA AIRCRAFT REGISTRATION DR
2011 MAR 29 A 9 09
8:TAW:IA CITY OKLAHOMA
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                         Mort, Inc. [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                                      Prytanee, LLC [epstein] Epstein company 
                                                     Southern Country International [epstein] Epstein company 
                                    Nicholas Ribis [trump] Hilton CEO, former president of Trump Organization 
 Honeycomb Asset Management [tech] venture fund invested in Tencent, Epstein invested in Spotify through them 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00811479 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2017-03-31)
Valuation Report
3/31/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - MARCH 31, 2017
2/28/17 3/31/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 89,672,522 110,396,021 20,723,499
Fixed Income 75,939,447 75,106,683 (832,764)
Equities 94,128,808 83,337,233 (10,791,575)
Equity ETF's 3,042,600 3,037,200 (5,400)
Options 288,875 574,280 285,405
Hedge Funds 71,554,949 72,697,525 1,142,576
Investments 47,006,000 47,006,000 -
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 11,850,000 26,600,000 14,750,000
Loans Receivable 9,482,446 9,632,446 150,000
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 39 900 000 17.400,000 -22,500,000
Total Assets 442,865,647 445,787,388 2,921,741
Cash Activity - Items over 50.000
Leon loan 22,500,000
Apple - sold 100,000 shares @ 143 55 - ML 14,351,000
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 721,036
Earthlink Inc 8.875% bond redemption 358,789
Larry Visoski Loan (50,000)
Enhanced - Hasty Pudding 50k /ASU 25k (75,000)
Gratitude - Pe 25k / Noam 20k / Krasner 5k / Crohn Colitis 10k / Cuba 25k / MS Walk (90,000)
loan (100,000)
Miscellaneous (323,963)
Apple - Bought 2,500 May 150 calls ML (502,500)
Monthly Spending (1,300,000)
G 550 closing (14,765,863)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50,000 20,723,499
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan TO
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Stanley Merrill Panorniscle Totals
Cash
Southern Financial LLC 2%200,046 51,682 29,251,728
Haze Trust 23,102,730 23,102.730
Plan D LLC 22,819,561 22.819,561
Southern Trust Company Inc. 6,205,167 118 053 300,000 701,044 14,351,900 21.674,164
Gratitude America, Ltd. 1,242,337 76,966 2,843,528 4.162.831
JEE 2.809,938 701,062 456,765 3.967.765
jaspers Inc. 1,481,642 72 1,481,714
LSJE LLC 362.067 354,036 294,634 1.010,737
JEGE Inc. 963.188 963,188
Southern Country International LTD 455,512 455,512
Sono Development Corp/Management LLC 324,025 324.025
JEGE LLC 308,895 308.895
NES LLC 297,909 297,909
Hyperion Air LLC 101.625 101,625
Enhanced Education 9.013 81,780 90.793
Neptune LLC 82,697 82,697
Thomas World Air Ile 80.826 80,826
JEE - Paris (US S) 69,145 69,145
Nautilus Inc. 42,859 42,859
FT Real Estate 42,299 42,299
Freedom Air Petroleum 23,112 23.112
Michelins Transponation Co LLC 13,573 13.573
Great St Jim LLC 8,877 8,877
LSJ LLC 5,150 5,150
Maple Inc. 4 440 4,440
Laurel Inc. ‘2?) 4,220
Cypress Inc. 3.807 3 807
ISM FSF LLC 937
IGO Company LLC 690 690
The JEE Life Ins Trust a3 206 206
Mort Inc 3 3
Butterfly Trust 3 3
Total Cash 89,311,052 2,016,271 825,910 294,634 3,544,572 14,351,900 51,682 110,396,021
1
Purchase Quantity 2128117 3/31/17 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Trust- Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/30/2049 05/10/11 3,000,000 3,337,958 3.197,683 3,207.500 -130,458
Ipaymem Inc 10.25% 5/15/2018 10/02/12 500,000 485986 441,483 454,361 -31,205
JPM Tr Fit Rate Income Fund 01/22/13 238,034.829 2,385,730 2,250,009 2,249,429 -136,301
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 4%033.00 1,180,739 1.253.283 1,289.955 89,218
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/29/14 150,967.00 3670430, 3,858 717 3,910.045 239 615
238..651
269,517
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 70,000.00 1.999.419 2.267:302 . 2.238 070
Total Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB) 13,059,843 13,268,476 13,329,380
Jeepers - Fixed Income (DB)
JPM Trust FLT RT Income fund 02/13/13 178,313.490 1.784.202 1 685,497  1 RAS 062 9914Q
Total Jeepers - Fixed Income (DB) 1,784,202 1,685,497 1,685,062 -99,140
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Western Digital Corp 7.375% Matures 41-2023 06/09/16 2,000,000 2 084.067 2 255 229 2.2(*25() B 2sa2.
Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 2,084,067 2,266,229 2,286,260 182,183
Southern Trust Ca - Fixed Income (DB)
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP callable 6/20/2019 4/15/14 2,000,000 mama 9 592.21Q 2 573.558 Mal
-865,6343 Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (DB) 3,439,193 2,592,219 2,673,658
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill)
Mogan mandatory convertible proffered 5.5%3/1/2018 08/15/16 1,000,000 881,500 871,530 848.430 -33,070
LSCCOM 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 26,250.000 2,859,332 2,859,884 2,839.457 -19,875
Frontier Communications 10.5% 9/15/2022 11/9/16 4,000,000 4,180000 4,158,720 4,050000 -110,000
Kindred Healthcare 7.25% 1/15/2020 STC ML 10/13/16 3,000,000 3,125,750 3.060,667 3,099.417 -26,333
Teva mandatory convertible proffered 7.0% 12/15/2018 08/15/16 1,000,000 901.750 649 875 577.000 -324.7w
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill) 11,928,332 11,600,676 11,414,303 -514,028
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred $25 par 7/27/15 40,000 1,000,000 1,051,600 1,067,200 67,200
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $25 par 08/04/16 8.000 200,000 160,560 170500 -29,200
Wells Fargo 5.7% Preferred $25 par 1/19/16 120000 3.000,000 3,009,600 3,020,400 20 400
115,300 Ebay 6% Preferred $25 par matures 2.1.2056 2/2216 80.000 2,000,000 2,064,000 2,115,200
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 8/16/16 500,000 500,000 533,264 516,833 16,833
Etrade Fnancial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 2,500,000 2,623,122 2,638,350 2,581.000 -42,122
Royal Bars Second 7.64% Fixed to 9-29-2017 then 3M Wm •232163 11/10/15 5,000,000 5,298,817 4,907,044 4,672,500 -628,317
Goldman Sachs 5.375% Flied to 5-162020 then 392.2 over 3 mo Tibor 6/4/15 5.000,000 5,034,346 5,243,125 . 5,217.760 
183,414
Capital One 5.55% Fixed to 9.1.2020 then 380 over 3 ma libor 5/14/15 3,000,000 3.00991t 3145.238 3.168600 158.18?
Total Southern Trust Co. -Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 22,666,104 22,752,781 22,529,693 -136,411
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB)
Bank of America 8.125% Pfd Dec 29 2049 1/10/11 2,000,000 2,055,000 2,141,493 Z146,389 91,389
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 4/3/13 300,000 300,000 330,750 325,819 25,819
Cifigroup Inc - Series 0 5.95% 8/8/15 3,000 000 3,000,006 3,141,416 3,150,309 150,303
Earthlink Inc 8.875% Ntay 15 2019 10/23/12 351..000 361,349 redeemed
General Electric Co GTD Fixed to Fleet 4.0% Dee 15 2065 12/3/15 2,469,000 2,175,016 2,478,681 2,454.872 279,856
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500,000 2,687,500 2,664,736 2.672,917 -14,583
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500,000 2,675,000 2.664,736 2,672.917 -2,083
LBG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49 5121/13 1,903,000 1,948,500 2,043.857 2,014,199 65,699
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,000.000 2,995,764 3,329,813 3,331,250 335,486
GMAC Cap TR I GTD Pfd Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80.000 1882.774 2.057 600 2.034 400 151,621 Total Southern Financial LLC • 
Fixed Income (DB) 19,719,560 21,212,430
2%803,072 1 083 612
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) (ace value
Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 ci CBI var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 595,372 455 57Q 572.14Q SOS "iftS,_ 49.815
Total Southern Financial LLC • Fixed Income (DE) 455,570 672.140 605,385 49,815
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 75,136,870 75,939,447 75,106,683 -30,187
Note - Accrued interest has been included in month end fixed income values
Purchase Quantity 2/28/17 3131117 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss) ,
Southern Financial LW - Equities (DB)
Akom Inc. 6/10/15 5.000 234,206 104glir 120,400 -113,806
Alibaba Group 6/10/15 5 000 444,749 514 500 539150 94 401
Allianz SE ADR 4/13/15 -Ow 90,056 87,050 92.650 1:594 Apple Inc 10/28/13 14,000 1,917860 *slow 0
Apple Inc 915114 86,000 11,781,140 sits. a 0
Apple Inc 9/5/14 64,000 6,332,800 8,767,360 9,194,240 2,861,440
Apple Inc 1/11/16 250,000 24,750,006 34,247,500 35,915.000 11,164,994
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 263,157 4,999,983 5,984,190 6,399,978 1,399,995
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Barn 1.3.11) 1/16/01 70 500 1,500,000 324,300 300.330 -1,199,670
Avalanche Blotechnologles now called Adverum 6lotechnologies 4/20/15 1(000 398,606 28,500 27.000 -371,806
BASF ADR 4/13/15 000 508,056 465950 495,875 -12,181
Bank of New York Mellon 6/25/14
__,__5
2t6,000 9,076,406 11,785;000 11,807.500 2,731,094
Biogen Idec Inc 2/14/12 2,095 250,455 604,617 572.815 322,360
Bioverativ Inc 2/1/17 1,047 20,254 54,528 57020 36,766
Centene Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1,096,275 1,108,093 121596
47,528 Dish Network Corp 6/10/15 5.000 364,978 310,000 317.450
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17,500 665,000 2,371,950 2,485,875 1,820,875
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49,830 1,265,037 1,235,784 1,607,018 341,981
General Motors Co 12/9110 97,525 3,585,947 3,592,821 3,448,484 -137,463
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 496,109 685,630 685,400 189,291
Gilead Sciences Inc 215/14 5,000 396,407 352,400 339.800 -56,807
Gilead Sciences Inc 3/7/14 3,100 246,797 218,488 210,552
210,600
-36,245
-4,206 Glaxo Smith Kline PLC 6/10/15 5,000 215,006 207,400
Global Partner Acquisition Corp 7/30/15 2,000 20,000 20,400 19,600 400
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/15 700 14,000 25,795 26.530 12,530
Match 11/19/15 200 2,400 3,232 3266 866
Mobileye NVAmstelveen OW Shares ' 8/1/14 800 20,000 36,416 49,120 29,120
Square 11/19/15 200 1,800 3 464 3,456 1,658
Sangamo Biosciences Inc 5128113 50,000 422,214 227:500 260,000 -162,214
Santander Consumer USA 1/28/14 1,000 24,000 14,780 13,320 -10,680
Terraform Global 7/31/15 400 6,000 1740 1,920 4,080
Twitter Inc 11/7/13 1,500 39,000 23,855 22,425 -16,575
Viacom Inc 6/10/15 5,000 338,745 217,250 233100 -105,645
Volkswagen AG 4/13/15 8000 254,306 151,750 149.950 -104,356
Wisdon*ee investments Inc 3/31/15 15000 atam salst u§.2232Ilaila• 58,293,977 87,597,925 18,560,140 Total Southern 
Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 76,854,117
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
Barclays PLC ADR 7/18/16 100000 805,098 1,119,000 1,124,000 318,904
Credit Suisse Group 7/18/16 10O00 1,137,626 1,509,000 1,484.000 346,374
270 Express 1W27/16 3,500 fano 45.11§ 45115 -22,435
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,010,972 2,673,116 2,663,816 642,843
Gratitude America, LTD • Equities Morgan Sterile
Colony Capital->Colony NatWest' Ina 9/28/16 73,315 928,837 1.076,264 946.497 17,860
Sequential Brands 9/23/16 50,000 402,134 196,500 194,500 -207,634
ITO Express
Bank of America
10/27/18 1,150 22,425 14824 15.054 -7,372
3/2/16 7 500 100,825 185,100 176,295 75,470
Editas Medicine 3/2/16 i ,,2oo 102,199 79,776 71,424 -30,775
Tenant li& I gal iaa J,W8/1 50,000
2,720,182 2,880,464 126,687 Total Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,846,769
J Epstein W Foundation - Equities (DB)
Bristol Myers Squfifis 10/30/15 5,000 334,712 283,550 271,900 42,812
Disney 10/30/15 5,000 570,073 550.450 566.950 4,123
Pfizer Inc 10/30/15 4.200 145,028 143.304 143682 -1 34
Total J Epstein Ill Foundation - Equities (DB) 1,049,812 977,304 982,532 47,280
TOTAL EQUITIES 64,074,944 94,128,808 83,337,233 19,262,289
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETFs (DB)
Wisdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60.000 2,966.099 3044600 =ion am
71,101 Total Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF'S (DB) 2,966,099 3,042,600 3,037,200
Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill Lynch)
AAPL May 19 2017 150 Cans 3/29/17 2.500 502,500 0 432,576 -69,924
TLF•mommiall smell My usenta ltenSISOI•Itillewaliew Sawmills 12/9/18 604,174 2N,SOR 288 874 141 704 11911,2,%
-178,220 Total Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill Lynch) notional 762,600 288,875 574,280
2/28/17 3/31/17 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern Financial fSFLLC) added 10mm WM 6
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund ill 44 395 269 44.981.287 1.32%- 2.45% added Starn 3/31216
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 44,395,269 44,981.287 *thane Ulaim 1110117
total Invettmawd 40mat
2016 return 3.77%
Hedge Funds - Haze
King Street 5153.57Q 5.753.576 0.00% 0.00% 2016/17 paid to data
Hedge Funds - Haze 5,753,576 5,753,576 tame 0267.054 PIM
7127/16 6,102,1124 paid
10/27116 1.186.1101 pak
1/27t17 3694,644 paid
2016 ream 4.611%
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 21.408,104 21 962 663 2.60% 9.30% added 20mm III31/16
Total Hedge Funds - STC 1,4106,104 21,962,663 2016 ..em 044%
Total Hedge Funds 71,554,949 72,697,525
SFI.
Mort Southern FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profi ) 0
Kyara II (investment amount) II 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0 Kyara IV (Investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (grat at cost) 11,250,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,000 sit
Adfin Solutions (investment amount 875,000 buttidly oust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Uvingston, NJ 3.000,000
Coinbase I STC 3.001,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Velar Global Fund II (investment amount) 13,650,000
Velar Global Fund III (investment amount) 5,250,000
Totals 11,250,000 3,000,000 23,275,000 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total Investments 47,006,000
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfsheam G-IV N212JE 6,500,000 6,500,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 also 0 LLC 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 900,000 900,000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 2,500,000 6,500,000 250,000 17,350,000 26,600,000
•
Asset Description JEE SFL SIC FIRE Totals
Loans Receivable
100,000 100,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Karyna 350,000 350,000
Nick Ribis 75,000 75,000
Larry / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225.000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
David Mitchell 1,500,000 1,500,000
302,000 302,000
Harlequin Dane, LLC 3,750,000 3,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 1,000,000 1,000,000
Lesley 200,000 200,000
Cecile 50,000 50,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
LV Home & Other 1,300,000 1,300,000
525.000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,697,446 4,950,000 50,000 1,935,000 9,632,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry Nast bust
Giacometti 25,000,000 25,000,000
Braque 5,000,000 5,000,000
Leon Loan Payable -22,500,000 -22,500,000
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 . 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - Insurance value 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques 8 Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 10,550,000 17,400,000
╔═════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Charles Pickett [employee] pilot 
╚══════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01286706 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank Plan D, LLC bank statement showing $22,500,000 incoming and $15,000,000 outgoing
(inferred date: 2017-03-31)
Deutsche Bank El
Deutsche Bank Must Co. Americas
345 Park Avenue - NYC20-0102
New York. NY 10154
PLAN D. LIE
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
6100 RED 14OOK QUARTER. B3
SE THOMAS
00802
UNITED STATES VI
Mach 1.2017 to March 31. 2017
Summar). of Account Balance(s)
Account N bet Balance
For personal assistance call:
Stewart Oldfield
Balance
Business Checking S22-819.560.81
592.699.94 Beginning Balance as of March I. 2017
IN:posits and Other Credits 537.500.000.00
Checks Paid 50.00
ATM and D.:bit Card Withdrmals 50.00
&Ake Charges and Other Fees 50.00
Other Debits (514.773 139 13 )
Ending Balance as of March 31.201'
Trenwtion Detail
Date Description Debit
522.819.560.81
Credit
Beginning Balance as of March I, 2017 592,699.94
03.10 0 Outgoing NIonc) Trn4
TO ZB NA DBA VECTRA BANK A C 4107119
374 CHARLES PICKETT
(7,276.46 ) 85,423.48
03-27 a Cash Mgmi Tnfr Cr
REF 08615141. FUNDS TRANSFER FRM
DEP 77000949 FROM
15.000.000.00 15.085.423.48
03-28 k Outgoing Money Tmsf
TO BANK OF AMERICA. N.A. NY A/C 002
863585210 INSURED AIRCRAFT TITLE SER
VICE. INC
(15.862.67 ) 15.069.560.81
03-28 MOulgoing Maley Tmsf
TO BANK OF AMERICA NC 002863585210
INSURED AIRCRAFT TITLE SERVICE
(14.750.000.00 ) 319.56081
All items an credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceed( in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Compsiy
Antericas.
I of 3 SDNY_GM_0CO43288
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0006112
Deutsche Bank
Dale Description
03-31 Incoming Money Turf
ORG=483056444952 BV70 LI.0 445 PARK
AVE STE 1401 NEW YORK NY 10022-8626
Ending Balance as of March 31. 2017
Debit Credit
22.500.000.00
Balance
22.819.560.81
Deposits and Other Credits
Date Description
03-27 Cash Mgmi Tr& Cr
0341 Incoming Money Tmsf
(14,771139.13 ) 537.500.000.00 S22.819.560.81
Amount
515,000,000.00
S22,500,000.60
Service Charges and Other Fees
Total NSF mum item fees fee this statement period 50.00
Total NSF return item fees for this calendar Year $0.00
Total Overdraft fas for this statement period $0.00
Total Overdraft leas for this calendar year $0.00
Other Debits
Date Description
03-10 Outgoing Monty Tms1 (57.276.46 )
03-28 Outgoing Money Ina ($15,862.67 )
03.28 Outgoing Month. Tmsf (514,750.000.00  )
Amormt
Ul items are credited NlIbitNi to final collection and receipt of proceeds in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Antericas
2 of 3 SDNY_GM_00043289
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0006113
Deutsche Bank
In Case of Furors or Questions

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at 1-866-362-4796. or write to us at Deutsche Rank Trust Company Americas. 345 Park Avenue. WNI Banking 
Team -
NYC20-0102. New York Na. York 10154 as soon as you can. if you think your statement or receipt is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MUST hear front you no later than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRSTstatement on which the error or problem appeared.

• Tell us your name and account number
- Describe the error or transfer you arc unsure about. and explain as clearly as you can why you believe it is an error 
or why you
need more information
- Tell in the dollar amount of the suspected error
Please note that if you initially provide the above information to If% via telephone. we may require that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within ID business days.
We will investigate your complaint and will correct any enor promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 
business days for
new accounts) to do this, we will provisionally credit your account for the amount you think is in error. so that you 
will have the use of
the money during the time it takes us to complete our investigation. At the conclusion of our investigation. we will 
info= you of our
results.
1 Non-Electronic Funds Transfers
Contact the Bank immediately at 1-866-362-4796 if your statement is incorrect or if you need mole information about any 
non-electronic
funds Introadions (checks or deposits) on this statement. If any such error appears. you must notify the Bank in writing
no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you. Please see your Tennis and Conditions for further information on 
the tens
governing your account.

3. Verifying Preauthorized Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once every 60 days from the same person or 
compass> you
can telephone us at 1.866.362.4SM to find out whether the deposit has been made.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0006114
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
         Robert Lawrence Kuhn [business] investment banker, China expert 
             Matthew Hiltzik [publicist] crisis PR at Hiltzik Strategies 
 Vincenzo Iozzo [tech] CEO of the identity-security company SlashID [tc] 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00285309 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(date: 2017-04-01)
2017 April
Sat. April 1, 2017 Paris
Sun. April 2.2017 Paris
Reminder: Vincenzo in London April 2-6
Mon. April 3 2017Paris
Reminder: Jojo off today
Hasty Pudding Event
1. Karyna Shuliak
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8. ()ley tu
9. Maxim Churkin
Tues. April 4. 2017 Paris
Reminder: Jojo off today
2:00pm Paris tin tato depart Paris CDG via Aeroflot#2455 (Rec Loa
10:00am EST 4:00 in Paris time) PHONE DATE w/Commissioner Henry. YOU are
to call her at
Wed. April 5, 2017 Paris
Reminder: Jojo to take off today (he will now be up to date with days owed off)
Reminder: ConEd to do steam repair on street which will affect the hot water in the
house starting at 11pm tonight and will last 6-7 hours
Reminder: Ehud/Nili to depart this evening
Reminder  court today
Reminder to see Lion King tonight
Thurs. April 6, 2017 Paris -Marrakech -NY
Reminder: Darren departs for holiday at 1pm today, back Apri117
11:03am Depart Paris (with Jacques & Monique Lang, Assaiya)
12:40pm Arrive Marrakech
TBD Depart Marrakech
8:20pm Arrive NY (Long Island MacArthur)
Fri April 7.2017 NY
TBD Go Fabric shopping for plane with Katyna
2:00pm Appt aand.
SatiAprilikalINELSI
10:30/11am Appt w/Boris Nikolic (M I)
2:00pm Depart NY
TM Arrive LS]
Sun. April 9.2017 ISI
Mon. April 10. 2017 LSJ
Reminder: Bella on holiday April 10-18
10:00am James Ce at the house to work on1stfloor wilt
10:00am SKYPE Interview with Vince Fauci (Eva's recommendation)
Skype ID: or you can use his cell
Cell: Email:
2:04pmno depart St. Thomas via Delta #676 (Rec. Loc
her up
4:05pm to arrive STT via Jetblue#1036 (Rec. Loc.#
Tues. 4pril 1L 2017 IQ
Wed. April 12.2017 LSJ-NY
9:26am Depart LSJ
12:39pm Arrive NY (Islip)
Thurs. April 13.2017 NY
11:00am Robert Kuhn
2:00/2:30pm Leon Black
Fri. Apr1114. 2017 NY
Good Friday: Office and STC Closed
Reminder.al for doctor appointments today
11:00am Appt w/Peter Attia
Sat. Apri115, 2017 NY-Bedford-LSJ
Carosa to pick
8:30am Drive to Islip to meet Eric Roth
11:03am Depart Islip, NY
11:42am Arrive Bedford
6:12pm Depart Bedford
9:20pm Arrive LSJ
Sun. April 16. 2017 LSJ-PB
3:13pm Depart LSJ
6:00pm Arrive PB
Mon. April 17.2017 PB
Reminder: Rich out today, back in office tomorrow
Reminder Darren back in the office today
2:00pma arrive NY via Lufthansa #7603 (Rec. Loc
Tues. April 18. 2017 PB
Wed.Mla PB-NY
Reminder: Jack Goldberger inlijApril 19-24
Reminder Kathy Ruemmlal
8:32am Depart PB
10:54am Arrive NY
11:30aaat the house
12:30pm-ish Commissioner Hemy to call during her afternoon break from her
conference
TBD Appt w/Bobby Slayton ( )
2:30pm Appt w/Nathan Myhrvold (M=)
4:00pm Appt w
5:30pm Haircut w/Patrick at salon
JOJO TO DRIVE YOU!
6:30pm or anytime after: Phone Date w
Thurs. April 20.2017 NY
10:15am Appt w/Boris Nikolic (MM)
2:00pm o have her hair cut with• iMit
2:30pm to have her hair cut wit a
4:00pm Appt w/Michael Wog (=M)
5:30pm Appt w/Paul Barrett (M=) Rich to join in
Fit April 7 NY
Reminder: to Wizz Air #2564 Barcelona to Riga (Confirm=
Reminde o see Lion King tonight at 8pm
8:45am BREAKFAST w/Leon Black (MM)
11:00am Appt w
3:00pm Karyna to have hair cut w/Patrick at Fekkai
4:30pm Appt w/Rich and Darren
5:30pm Appt w/Paul Barrett (MM) Rich to join in
Sat April 22.2017 NY
12:5 l and Kimberly Ross to arrive S7T via United #1443 (Rec.
Loci
6:05pm depart Newark via Lufthansa #403 (Rec. Loc
Citicar
Sun. April 23. 2017 NY-15f
4:00pm Michael and Kimberly Ross to depart S7T via United #1289 (Red.
Loc.#FKGGTH)
4:27pm Depart NY
7:37pm Arrive LSJ
Mon. April 24. 2017 LSI
Reminder: Vincenzo Lozzo in Vancouver April 24-27
Retninde to fly Vilnius to Florence (Rec. Loc l
Retninde to go visit her family in FL (depart via Delta #898 at 10:40am Rec.
Loc#
1:00pm Appt w/Mapp
i lOpm PHONE DATE w Matthew Hiltzik, friend of Michael Wolff (cell:
)(office:
Tues. Apri125. 2017 LSJ
Reminder: Jojo off today and tomorrow for days off owed
Wed. April 26. 20171 Ssf
Thurs. Apri127. 2017 LSJ
12:00pm Appt w/John Woods at STC
12:00pm Appt w/Erika Kellerhals (MM)
1:14pato arrive STT via AA#936 (Rec Loa) Carosa to pick her up at
7:10am
2:15pmM to depart S7T via AA#936 (Rec. Loa
2:15pm Conference Call w/Amy Dempsey, Hugo Hodge and Rich
Dial in Required
Fri. April 28, 2017 LSJ
Reminder: Children's Carnival Parade today
5:40pm to departJFK via Finnair#6 (Rec. Loa (pp to take her to the
airport at 1:45pm)
Sat. April 29. 2017 LSJ
Sun. April 30.2017 LSJ-NY
4:34pm Depart LSJ
7:53pm Arrive NY
Meet w/Eric Roth to discuss interior material selection
EFTA01435885 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2017-04-04)
Deutsche Bank
Private Wealth Management
Authorization for Asset Movement
For Non-Retirement Accounts
The undersigned hereby authorizes and directs Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown
("Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown" or "DBAB") to follow the below asset movement
instructions.
If you wish to request multiple wires, checks, journals or free deliveries,
please use the long Form.
DBAB Account Name: Southern Trust Company Inc.
Account #; N4G.Q23812
Journal
Q Journal Funds in the amount of S
Q Journal Holdings:
Qty/Symbol/Securily:
Oly/Symbol/Security:
Q Journal All Holdings
To DBAB Account #:
Account Name:
Wire
Q Wire federal funds in the amount of $ 2,500.000
To Bank Name: Silicon Valley Bank
City / State:
ABA#:
121140399
Further credit to Intermediary Rnancial Institution (Optional]
Account #:
Name:
UhimBte Benefidary Information:
Beneficiafy Name: Valar Global Fund III LP
3301520427
Additional Instructions: Southem TrUSt ComP3nV InC.
Capital Call
Account#:
Free Deliveries
Q Please deliver the securities indicated below to:
DTCC#:
Name of Receiving Rrm:
Check
Q Issue a check in the amount of S
Redpent's Name:
Redpieni's Mailing Address:
Account Name:
payable to:
at Receiving Firm
Account Number:
Oty/Symbol/Security:
Qly/Symboi/Securety:
Sfonding Autftorization
0 The undersigned hereby requests that this authorization act as a standing
authorization. The undersigned understands and agrees that this
authorization will
remain in effect until Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown requests a new
authorization. The undersigned authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to issue
the wire.
check or journal on the
Q The undersigned further authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to accept
verbal instructions from the undersigned to wire funds, issue checks or
journal
funds to/from the above listed accounts. The undersigned will provide verbal
instructions as to the date and the amount of the wire, check or journal. If
the
undersigned decides to vary either the date or the amount of the wire, check
or journal, the undersigned hereby authorizes Deutsche Bank Alex, Brown to
accept the verbal instructions from the undersigned regarding the change or
changes. The undersigned further understands and agrees to comply with the
procedures of Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown to verify the authorization and
accuracy of verbal instructions.
day of
for a term of
The undersigned hereby acknowledges that (i) the information contained in
this form is complete and accurate to the best knowledge of the undersigned:
and (ii) the
undersigned is responsible for the method of transmission of any
instructions issued pursuant to this authorization. If the undersigned
elects to transmit any such
instructions via fax (including desktop fax), via email or as an image
attachment to email (e.g., as a PDF, TIF or other image of such
instructions), the undersigned
understands and agrees that the undersigned bears the risk of loss arising
from such method of transmission in the event of transmission errors,
misundersiandings,
impersonations, transmission by unauthorized persons, forgery or intercepts.
For trusts or other entities, the undersigned further acknowledges that the
undersigned is
authorized to issue the above asset movement instructions under the terms of
the governing documents and any applicable laws. The undersigned hereby
releases and
holds harmless Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown from and against loss from any
action, claim or demand of any person as a result of Deutsche Bank Alex.
Brown's receipt of
or compliance with this authorization and/or any instructions that may be
given to Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown pursuant to this authorization (including
any standing
authorization).
The undersigned understands that Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown may, but is not
required to, seek verification of the undersigned's instructions by call
back and that
Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown may in its sole discretion refuse to execute such
instructions (including standing instructions) given pursuant to this
authorization, without
Incurring any liability, if Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown has reason to believe
such instructions (or standing instructions) have not been provided by the
undersigned. The
undersigned further understands that Deutsctje B^k Alex. Brown retains the
right to refuse to execute any instructions to transfer funds or securities
to any accountfs)
pvreuant to this authorization w/ffiSut writttfniKsm :tions bearing original
signature(s) of the undersigned.
10 . AJ Darren Indyke
04-04-2017
Print Name
Date
iignature
Print Name
Signature
Date
1111111111111111111
LOA
10-PWM-01775 (12/10)
EFTA01621978 (Jmail)
 [girls] Skype log of conversation with Daniel Siad
(date: 2017-04-04)
Platform: Skype: jeevacation Timezone: UTC+0000
•
Daniel Siad
•
•
•
Daniel Siad
06:17:05 pm
jeevacation
2017/04/04
I just try to organise something with to come to see you with them
06:17:50 pm
jeevacation
just dark hair
06:19:06 pm
Daniel Siad
Ok
06:45:43 pm
Daniel Siad
Hello Jeffrey I just arrived in Paris
04:20:14 pm
2017/04/13
jeevacation
•
•
i m on new york
04:34:44 pm
Daniel Siad
I will be here for a week then I will go to Cuba untill the 15th of May . Warmest
regards from Paris
04:41:19 pm
2017/04/14
jeevacation
hope you find something new
10:27:51 am
Daniel Siad
I did Paris is unique I wish I had more time in Paris , I will keep you updated warmest
regards Jeffrey thank You Happy Easter Happy Holidays
10:58:54 am
2017/04/24
Daniel Siad
Hello from Barcelona!
06:24:56 pin
Receiving file... IMG_20170424_144347.jpg
06:26:16 pm
I meet great model from Poland today
06:27:02 pm
Warmest regards
06:27:21 pin
Sending video of her but the internet is slow
06:30:05 pm
Receiving file... VID_20170424_144320.mp4
06:32:44 pm
I arrived yesterday from Dubai I will staying here I just signed contract for a studio here
I am waiting to move in this week I really love it more then anywhere !
06:33:25 pin
A lot action here then anywhere in Europe
06:34:12 pm
•
•
08:50:27 pm
2017/04/25
jeevacation
if i can help let me know. I will be in paris 10-17
10:43:17 am
Daniel Siad
Hello Jeffrey are going to be 10-17 ?
Warmest regards
02:09:36 am
jeevacation
yes hope to see you
05:47:50 am
2017/05/04
2017/05/09
Daniel Siad
•
•
•
I am in Paris arrived tonight
11:49:18 pm
jeevacation
see you thurs or fri
02:10:29 am
Daniel Siad
Ok welcome warmest regards
07:36:22 am
jeevacation
tomorw?‘
09:56:25 pm
Daniel Siad
Yes I am in Paris
10:34:55 pm
What is the best time
10:35:13 pm
jeevacation
6
01:44:34 am
2017/05/10
2017/05/11
2017/05/12
•
•
Daniel Siad
Ok
05:31:23 am
jeevacation
let me know if you are bringing anyone? see you then
11:35:02 am
Daniel Siad
I will of cause
08:07:25 pm
It was great pleasure to see you thank you very much for your help
08:08:27 pm
Here is my French numbe]
08:12:00 pm
jeevacation
tried to call
10:46:26 am
callme
10:46:34 am
Maybe takecassaya with you ?)
03:32:20 pm
2017/05/14
EFTA00622816 (Jmail)
 [money] Plan D note promising $8,000,000 to Leon Black's BV70 LLC
(date: 2017-04-17)
DEMAND PROMISSORY NOTE
$8,000,000.00 April 17, 2017
FOR VALUE RECEIVED, the undersigned, Plan D, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands
limited liability company (the "Maker"), hereby unconditionally promises to pay to the
order of BV70 LLC, a New York limited liability company with an address at do
Elysium Management LLC, 445 Park Avenue, Suite 1401, New York, NY 10022 (the
"Holder"), the principal amount of Eight Million Dollars ($8,000,000.00), together with
interest on the unpaid principal balance at an initial rate per annum equal to the Federal
short-term rate, as published by the Internal Revenue Service pursuant to Section 1275(d)
of the Internal Revenue Code, compounded semiannually (the "Short -Term Rate") in
effect for the month first above written. The interest rate on the unpaid principal amount
of this Note shall be adjusted as of January 1 and July I of each year to the Short-Term
Rate in effect for such January and July, as the case may be.
The unpaid principal balance of this Note, and all accrued interest thereon, shall
be due and payable within two (2) business days of written demand therefor given by the
Holder to the Maker.
The unpaid principal balance of this Note and all accrued interest thereon may be
prepaid, in full or in part, at any time or from time to time without premium or penalty.
All payments of principal and interest hereunder shall be made in lawful money
of the United States, in immediately available funds at do Elysium Management LLC,
445 Park Avenue, Suite 1401, New York, NY 10022 (or at such other place as the
Holder may designate in writing to the Maker).

1. Events of Default.
(a) If any of the following events shall occur during the term hereof, such
events shall be deemed a default by the Maker hereunder (each an "Event of Default"):

(i) The Maker shall have defaulted in the payment of principal or
interest under this Note as and when the same shall have become due and payable in
accordance with the terms hereof; or

(ii) There shall have been entered any order, judgment or decree by a
court of competent jurisdiction for relief in respect of the Maker under any applicable
Federal or state bankruptcy law or similar law, or appointing a receiver, assignee or
trustee of all or a substantial part of the Maker's property, assets or revenues; or
(iii) The filing by the Maker of a petition or consent to a petition
seeking relief under Title 11 of the United States Code, as now or hereafter constituted,
or any other applicable federal or state bankruptcy, insolvency or other similar law, or the
consent by the Maker to the institution of proceedings thereunder or to the filing of any
such petition or to the appointment or taking of possession by a receiver, liquidator,
assignee, trustee or custodian, of any substantial part of the property, assets or revenues
of the Maker, or the making by the Maker of an assignment for the benefit of creditors, or
the inability of the Maker to pay its debts as they become due and payable; or

(iv) The earliest to occur of the cessation of activities in the ordinary
course, the winding down and dissolution of the Maker.

(b) In the case of an Event of Default, without any demand, presentment,
protest or other notice whatsoever to the Maker, or other statutory or other rights of
redemption, or any other action by the Holder, all of which are hereby expressly waived
by the Maker, the unpaid principal amount hereof and all accrued interest shall become
due and payable in full upon the occurrence of any such event and the Holder may
exercise simultaneously or seriatim any or all of such other rights and remedies as may be
lawfully permitted under Federal law or state law and any and all of the remedies of the
Holder set forth herein.

(c) All payments made hereunder shall first be applied to accrued interest and
then to principal.
2. Loss. Etc. of Note.
Upon receipt of evidence reasonably satisfactory to the Maker of the loss, theft,
destruction or mutilation of this Note, and of indemnity reasonably satisfactory to the
Maker, if lost, stolen, destroyed or mutilated, the Maker shall execute and deliver to the
Holder a new note identical in all respects to this Note.

3. Collection Costs.
In the event that it becomes necessary to enforce the provisions of this Note
against the Maker in order to collect any amounts due hereunder, all costs, fees and
expenses of such enforcement, including, without limitation, all attorneys fees and
disbursements and all fees and disbursements of other professionals relating to the
enforcement of any obligations under this Note, when incurred shall be deemed to be
additions to principal and shall become immediately due and payable hereunder.

4. Non-Waiver.
The Maker hereby expressly waives presentment for payment, demand for
payment, notice of dishonor, protest, notice of protest, notice of non-payment, and all
lack of diligence or delays in collection or enforcement of this Note. The Holder may
extend the time of payment of this Note, postpone the enforcement hereof, release any
collateral securing this Note, or grant any other indulgences whatsoever without affecting
or diminishing the Holder's rights under this Note, which rights are hereby expressly
reserved. Any waiver of any provision hereof must be in writing. No failure on the part
of the Holder to exercise, and no delay in exercising, any right, power or privilege under
this Note shall operate as a waiver thereof, nor shall any single or partial exercise of any
right, power or privilege under this Note preclude any other or further exercise thereof or
2
the exercise of any other right, power or privilege. The remedies herein provided are
cumulative and not exclusive of any and all other remedies provided by law.

5. Successors and Assigns.
This Note is binding upon the Maker and its successors and assigns; provided,
however, that the Maker shall not be entitled to assign or delegate any rights or
obligations under this Note without the prior written consent of the Holder. The Maker
hereby consents to the Holder's sale, assignment, transfer or other disposition at any time
or times hereafter, of this Note, or any right or interest herein contained to any "affiliate"
of the Holder. For purposes hereof, the term "affiliate" shall mean any person
beneficially owning a majority of the ownership interests of the Holder or any entity
beneficially owned by such person. Upon such permitted assignment, the permitted
assignee shall have all of the rights of the Holder to enforce any of the provisions of this
Note. The Maker agrees not to assert as against any such permitted assignee any claims,
offsets, deductions or defenses it may have against the Holder for breach of this Note or
otherwise.

6. Amendment and Modification.
This Note may be amended, modified or supplemented only by written agreement
signed by the Holder and the Maker.

7. No Right of Offset.
The Maker agrees that it shall have no right to assert against the Holder any offset
or deduction from any amount due and payable under this Note by reason of any right or
claim against the Holder arising from any cause or circumstance whatsoever, whether
previously existing or hereafter arising.

8. The Maker's Due Authorization.
The Maker hereby represents and warrants to the Holder that (a) the Maker has
full power and authority to borrow the sum of Eight Million Dollars ($8,000,000.00)
from BV70 LLC on the terms and conditions provided in the Note (the "Borrowing"),
and to execute and deliver the Note to the Holder, (b) the Borrowing, and the execution
and delivery of the Note by the Maker have been duly authorized by all necessary limited
liability company action of the Maker, and (c) the Note has been duly executed and
delivered by the Maker, and constitutes a valid, legal and binding obligation of the
Maker, enforceable in accordance with its terms, except as such enforceability may be
limited by bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization or similar laws affecting the rights of
creditors generally and subject to general principles of equity.

9. Notices
All notices, requests, demands and other communications required or permitted
hereunder shall be in writing and shall be deemed to have been duly given if delivered by
3
personal delivery, reputable overnight courier service, certified mail (postage pre paid,
return receipt requested), by email or by telecopy, as follows:
If to the Maker:
BV70 LLC
do Elysium Management LLC
445 Park Avenue, Suite 1401
New York, NY 10022
Fax:
Email:
If to the Holder:
Plan D, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3

St. Thomas, USVI 00802
Fax:
Email:
Any party hereto may change the address to which notices, requests, demands and
other communications to such party shall be given hereunder by giving notice thereof to
the other party hereto in the manner herein provided. Notices shall be deemed given at
the time they are delivered personally; if by overnight courier, the next business day
following the delivery thereof to such courier (or such later date as is demonstrated by a
bona fide receipt therefor); if given by certified mail (postage pre-paid, return receipt
requested), three days after deposit in the mail; or if given by email or facsimile prior to 6
p.m. on a business day, on the business day on which the email or facsimile transmission
is transmitted (receipt confirmed).

10. Governint Law.
THIS NOTE SHALL BE GOVERNED BY, AND CONSTRUED IN
ACCORDANCE WITH, THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK APPLICABLE
TO CONTRACTS TO BE PERFORMED ENTIRELY THEREIN, WITHOUT GIVING
EFFECT TO THE PRINCIPLES OF CONFLICT OF LAWS APPLICABLE THEREIN.

11. Waiver of Jury Trial.
TO THE EXTENT PERMITTED BY LAW, THE MAKERS AND THE
HOLDER HEREBY WAIVE ANY RIGHT TO A TRIAL BY JURY.
4

12. Faxed and Scanned Signatures.
Signatures of this Note transmitted by fax, or scanned and then transmitted by
email transmission shall have the same effect as original signatures.
PLAN D, LLC, Maker
Jeffrey Epstein, Sole Member
STATE OF
) ss.:
COUNTY OF
On April 17, 2017, before me, the undersigned, personally appeared Jeffrey Epstein,
personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory evidence to be the
individual whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and acknowledged to me that
he executed the same in his capacity as Sole Member of Plan 13, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands
limited liability company, and that by his signature on the instrument, Plan D, LLC executed
the instrument.
Notary Public
5
EFTA01286816 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank statement for Epstein's Southern Trust Company
(inferred date: 2017-04-30)
Deutsche Bank
Deutsche Bank Trust Co. Americas
345 Park Avenue - NYC20-0102
New York. NY 10154
St» I I CERN TRUST COMPANY. INC.
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3
ST THOMAS
00802
UNITED STATES VI
April I. 201710 April 30. 2017
Summary of Accourn Balance(s)
Account Accoing Number Balance
For personal assistance call:
Stewart Oldfield
Balance
Elite Money Market Deposit 44.129444 516.802,138.59
Beginning Balance as of April I. 11)1' 5500.764.97
Deposits and taller Credits 540.001373.62
Checks Paid 50.00
ATN1 and Ikbit Card WithtIrmali. 50.00
Senke Charges and Other Fees 50.00
Other Debits (523,700.000.00 )
Ending Balance as of April 30. 2017
Transaction Detail
Dale Description Debit
516.802.138.59
Credit
Beginning Balance as of April I, 2017 5500,764.97
04.04 k Incoming Money Tust
ORO-N40-023812-I SOUTHERN TRUST COM
PANY INC 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER 83 5
1,500,000.00 2.000,64.97
04-04 # Outgoing Money Tmsf
113 F1RSTB.ANK PUERTO RICO AC
521 SOUTHERN TRUSTCOMPANY. INC.
(300,000.00 ) 1,700,764.97
04-04 # Outgoing Money Trid'
TO BELLA KLEIN A/C SOUTHE
RN TRUST COMPANY. INC.
(400.000.00 ) 1.300.764.97
04-20 k Cash Mgml Trsfr Cr
REF 11009401 FUNDS TRANSFER FRNI
DEP ~FROM
30.500.000.00 31.800.764.97
/Minolta an credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceed< in cash or by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
44129244
of 3 SDNY_GM_00043416
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0006240
Deutsche Bank
Date Description Debit Credit Balance
04-20 # Cash Mgml Trsfr Dr
REF 11009401 FUNDS TRANSFER TO
DEP Mi. FROM
(3.000.000.00 ) 28.800.764.97
04-20 N Cash Mgmt Trsfr Dr
REF I100942L FUNDS TRANSFER TO
DEP FROM
(17000.000.00 ) 11.800.764.97
04-20 # Outgoing Money Trnsf
TO SILICON VALLEY BANK NC
7 VALAR GLOBAAL FUND III LP
(3.000.000.00 ) 8.800.764.97
04-25 0 Incoming Money ?met
ORO LEON D BLACK DEBRA
R BLACK CO APOLLO MANAGEMENT 9 W $
8.000.000.00 16.800.764.97
04-30 .1 Interest Payment 1373.62 16.802.13839
Ending Balance as of April 30. 2017
Deposits and Other Credits
(23,700,000.00 ) $40,001,373.62 $16,802,138.59
Date Description Amount
04-04 Incoming Mono Tmsf 51.500.000.00
04-20 Cash Mgmt Trsfr Cr 530.500.000.00
04-25 Incoming Money Trnsf S8.000.030.00
04-30 Interest Payment $1.373.62
Service Charges and Other Fees
Total NSF return item fees foe this statement period $0.00
Total NSF return item fees for this calendar year $0.00
Total Overdraft fen for this statement period $0.00
Total Overdraft lees for this calendar year $0.00
Other Debits
Date Description
04-04 Outgoing Money Trust
04-04 Outgoing Money Tmsf
04-20 Cash NIgni Trsfr Dv
04-20 Cash SIgmi Trsfr Dr
04-20 Outgoing Money Trani
.1.mount
(5300.000.00
(5400.000.00 )
(33.000.000.0V
(317,000.000.00 )
(33.000,000.00 )
Interest Calculation
Annual Percentage Yield Earned 0.30%
Interest Earned This Period 51.373.62
Want Paid Year To Date 5.4.933.13
All items are credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceedi in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
44129244
2 of 3 SDNY_GM_00043417
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0006241
Deutsche Bank
In Case of Furors or Questions

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at I  Of %Witt tO us at Deutsche Rank Trust Company Americas. 345 Park Avenue. WNI Banking learn -
NYC20•0102. New York Na' York 10154 as soca as you can. if you think your statement or receipt is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MUST hear front you no later than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRST statement on which the error or problem appeared.

• Tell us your name and account number
- Describe the error or transfer you arc unsure about. and explain as clearly as you can why you believe it is an error 
or why you
need more information

• Tell in the dollar amount of the suspected error
Please mite that if you initially provide the above information to us via telephone. we may squire that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within ID business days.
We will investigate your complaint and will correct any enor promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 
business days for
new accounts) to do this, we will provisionally credit your amount for the amount you think is in error• so that you 
will have the use of
the money during the time it takes us to complete our investigation. At the conclusion of our investigation. we will 
info= you of our
results.
1 Non-Electronic Funds Transfers
Contact the Bank immediately at your statement is incorrect or if you need more information about any non-electronic
funds trarnactions (checks or deposits) on this statement. If any such error appears. you must notify the Bank in 
writing no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you Please see your m  Conditions for further information on the 
tenni;
sampling your account.

3. Verifying Proauthorized Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once even, 60 days from the same person or 
compansyou
can telephone us al •to find out whether the deposit has been made.
1I 1.7.‘•2 1 I SDNY_GM_00043418
;
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0006242
EFTA00608737 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2017-05-05)
VALAR VLNYURIU
Valor Global Fund III LP Capital Call
April 18, 2017
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund III LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $3,000.000.00, which represents 12% of your total commitment
of $25,000,000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Friday May 5, 2017.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 43% of your total commitment with a
remaining 57% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of May 5, 2017:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$25,000,000.00
$10,750,000.00
$14,250,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Friday May 5, 2017
$3,000,000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
121140399
Valor Global Fund III LP
3301520427
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
•
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
+1 (646) 559-0458
Valor Ventures LLC 915 Bloodwoy SUNG 1101 New York, New York 10010 www.volor.eom
EFTA00810357 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2017-05-05)
VALAR Vt.NTulttU
Valor Global Fund III LP Capital Call
April 18, 2017
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund III LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $3,000,000.00, which represents 12% of your total commitment
of $25,000,000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Friday May 5, 2017.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 43% of your total commitment with a
remaining 57% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of May 5, 2017:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$25,000,000.00
$10,750,000.00
$14,250,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Friday May 5, 2017
$3,000,000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
Valor Global Fund III LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Valor Ventures LLC 919 Broadway SUiiS 1101 New York, New York 10010 www.volor.com
EFTA00615490 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2017-05-31)
(i) The Zerocoin Electric Coin Company
5655 W. 8th Avenue, Lakewood, CO 80214
To: Founders' Reward Recipients (ZECC Founders, Investors, Employees & Advisors)
From: Zooko Wilcox
Date: 1st June 2017
Subject: Update on Tax Matters
Dear Zcash Founders,
In the memo dated 13th December 2016, the Company indicated that the Founders Reward
would be treated as income when received for U.S. federal income tax purposes. However,
after extensive consultation with our tax advisors, the Company intends to take the position that,
for U.S. federal income tax purposes, the Company will not recognize income upon the
successful mining of the Founders Reward. While this position is not free from doubt and may
be subject to challenge by the Internal Revenue Service, the Company believes there is a
reasonable basis for such position.
Accordingly, the Company does not intend to report any income with respect to any portion of
the Founders Reward unless it disposes of such portion in a taxable transaction.
In order to assist the investors with calculating their 2017 estimated taxes, the Company is
providing the following information.
The distribution of Founders Reward in the form of ZEC will be treated as a property distribution.
We expect that partners will be subject to U.S. federal income tax when they dispose of such
ZEC in a taxable transaction. To the extent the ZEC is a capital asset held for more than one
year, any gain may be eligible for preferred rates applicable to long-term capital gains. However,
partners are urged to seek their own tax advice on this matter, as well as with respect to the tax
consequences of owning an interest in the Company generally.
The Company has disposed of some of the Founders Reward in taxable sales to fund ongoing
operations (i.e. salaries, legal costs, etc.) and to generate USD for distribution to certain
partners. These dispositions have generated taxable income for the Company.
We plan to make a special allocation of such income to the partners who received the
corresponding USD distributions.
As of May 31, 2017 the Company is projecting little to no taxable income for 2017 other than the
income that will be specially allocated as described above. As a result, we expect there to be
little or no allocation of income to partners who have not received as USD distribution from the
Company.
Should this projection change materially (for instance due to a large sale of coins), the Company
will provide an update to the income projection at that time. Regardless, the Company intends
to also provide a taxable income projection prior to the end of the year.
With respect to the Company's taxable income projections, the investors should be able to use
the annualized income method to determine their estimated tax obligations.
EFTA00621739 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2017-05-31)
Valuation Report
5/31/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - MAY 31, 2017
4/30/17 5/31/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 121,833,887 122,551,549 717,662
Fixed Income 75,508,486 71,036,555 (4,471,931)
Equities 84,663,760 88,944,962 4,281,202
Equity ETF's 3,064,200 3,059,400 (4,800)
Options 226,206 506 (225,700)
Hedge Funds 71,555,101 70,946,742 (608,359)
Investments 52,506,000 52,506,000 -
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 26,600,000 26,875,000 275,000
Loans Receivable 9,632,446 11,132,446 1,500,000
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 9,400,000 12;125,000 2,725,000
Total Assets 454,990,086 459,178,160 4,188,074
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
Frontier bond - sold 4mm @ 96.5 3,981,167
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 1,205,000
Apple Calls - sold 2500 @ 2.40 vs 2.00 cost 600,000
I-Payment Bond redemption Haze Trust 500,000
Legal - Steptoe & Johnson (55,895)
JSC Interiors funding (100,000)
International Jet - G550 Interior (175,000)
Gratitude - IPI 150k, Met Orch 50k, Int Police & Fire Chaplain 50k & 25k Film Inst (275,000)
Bentley final payment (275,338)
Miscellaneous (438,143)
Coatue - Loan (500,000)
Harlequin - Loan (1,000,000)
Monthly Spending (1,300,000)
NTES- bought 5000 shares - STC ML (1,449,129)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50,000 717,662
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan to
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Stanley Merrill AmerWade Totals
Cash
Southern Trust Company Inc. 32.527,104 586,297 300,000 953.560 17,199,40' 51,566,370
Southern Financial LLC 28,534,701 51,690 28,586,391
Haze Trust 26.189.380 26,189.380
JEE 3.720.060 720,836 456.832 4,897.728
Gratitude America. Ltd. 865,020 71,918 2,935,967 3,872,904
Jeepers Inc. 1.473.299 8,876 1,482,175
LSJE LLC 256.080 780,776 229.798 1.266,654
JEGE Inc. 963.188 963,188
Zorro Dev•lopment Cap/ Managemeril LLC 687,923 687,923
Plan D LLC 646.794 646,794
NES LLC 499,655 499,655
Southern Country International LTD 455,022 455,022
Maple Inc. 354.415 354.415
JEGE LLC 295,660 295.660
Neptune LLC 215.743 215,743
Enhanced Education 25.039 108,793 133,832
Hyperion Air LLC 100.592 100,592
Thomas VVorld Air LLC 71,440 71,440
JEE - Paris (US 5) 60,273- 60.273
Cypress Inc. 48.036 48,036
42,859 Nautilus Inc. 42,859
FT Real Estate 42,300 42,300
Freedom Air Petroleum 23,112 23,112
Michelins Transportation Co LLC 23,036 23,036
Great St Jim lie 8.857 8.857
LSJ LLC 6.150 6.150
Mort Inc 5,003 5,003
Laurel Inc. 4.220 4220
FSF LLC 937 937
1GO Company LLC 690 690
The JEE Life Ins Trust #3 206 206
Butterfly Trust 3 3
Total Cash 97,005,450 3,358,570 817,105 229,798 3,889,527 17,199,409 51,690 122,551,549
Purchase Quantity 4130117 6131117 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Trust- Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/30/2049 05(10(11 3,000,000 3,337,958 3,135,000 3,133,150 -204,808
!payment Inc 10.25% 5/15/2018 10/02/12 500,000 523,490 0
JPM Tr Flt Rate Income Fund 01/22/13 239,625.000 2,400,749 2,256,551 2,262,060 -138,689
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 49,033.00 1,180.739 1,260,638 1,261,129 80,390
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/29/14 150.967:00 3.670.430 3,881,361 3,882,871 212,441
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000.00 1.999.419 2 326 550 2.309-4.30 al1
12,843 640 25ir Total Haze Trust • Fixed Income (DB) 12,689,296 13,383,590
Avers - Fixed income (DB)
JPM Trust FLT RT Income fund 02/13/13 179,505.000 1295.452 1.690 398 1,694.524 -100 928
Total Jeepers - Fixed Income (DB) 1,795,452 1,690,398 1,694,524 -100,928
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Western Digital Cog) 7.375% Matures 4-1-2023 06/09/16 2,000,000 2.0813116 2 201 RR2 2.213.583 127.577
127,577 Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 2,086,006 2,201,882 2,213,583
Southern Trust Ca - Fixed Income (DB)
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP callable 6/20/2019 4/15/14 2.000.000 3.439193 2.736,380 2 761.059 &ADA
478,134 Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB) 3,439,193 2,736,380 2,761,059
Southern Trust Co. - Fried income (Mania)
Allergen mandatory convertible preffered 5.5% 3/1/2018 08/15/16 1.000.000 881.500 885,780 800.770 -80.730
LSCCOM 8.75% 1015/2023 01/13/17 26,250,000 2,859,332 2,746,431 2,772,378 -86,954
Frontier Communications 10.5% 9/15/2022 11/9/16 4,000,000 4.020.000 0
Kindred Healthcare 7.25%1/15/2020 STC ML 10/13/16 3,000.000 3,125,750 3,168,167 3,231,306 105 556
-401'75Q Teva mandatory convertible preffered 7.0%12/15/2018 08/15/16 1,000.000 01.750 571.000 500.000
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (Merrill) 7,768,332 11,371,378 7,304,454 463,878
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Charles Schwab 8.0% Preferred 525 par 7/27/15 40,000 1,000,000 1,096,000 1,091,600 91.600
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred 525 par 08/04/16 8.000 200,000 172.640 165.120 -34.880
Welts Fargo 5.7% Preferred 525 par 1/19/16 120,000 3,000,000 3,052.800 3,058,800 58,800
Ebay 6% Preferred 525 par matures 2-1-2056 2/22/16 80,000 2,000,000 2,120,800 2,143,200 143.200
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2028 then floats 8/16/16 500,000 500,000 522,750 532,628 32.628
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9.15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 2,500,000 2,623,122 2,610,781 2,662,150 39.028
Rept Bans Saabs 794% heed to 9-29-2017 then 3M Libor +232bp 11/10115 5600,000 5298.817 4.700.083 4.804.417 494.400
Goldman Sachs 5.375% Fixed to 5-10.2020 then 302.2 over 3 mo Rye 614/15 5,000,000 5,034.346 5,310,660 5,190,677 156 331
182'182
174,487
Capital One 5.55% Fixed to 9.1.2020 then 380 over 3 motor 5/14/15 3,000,000 3.009.819 3.188.913 3.19200
Total Southern Trust Co. • Rxed income (Morgan Stanley) 22,666,104 22,776,427 22,840,591
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed income (DB)
Bank of America 8.125% PM Dec 29 2049 1/10/11 2.000,000 2,055.000 2,189,479 2,090,982 35,982
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 4/3/13 300,000 300.000 315,974 316,794 16,794
Citigroup Inc - Series O 5.95% 8/8/15 3.000.000 3,000.006 3,191,988 3,215,698 215.892
General Electric Co GTO Faed to Float 4.0% Dec 15 2065 12/3/15 2,469,000 2,175.016 2,478,259 2,489,849 314,833
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500.000 2,887.500 2,612,500 2810.958 -76.542
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500.000 2,675,000 2,612,500 2,610„958 -64,042
LTG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49 5121/13 1.903,000 1.948.500 2.00.566 £118,673 170.173
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,000,000 2,995.764 3387,604 3,392,500 396,736
GMAC Cap TR I GTD Pfd Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80,000 1.882774 2.036.800 2.041,690 158.828
Tote/ Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 19,719,560 20,868,669 20,888,013 1,168,453
Southern  Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) hat YAM
Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 el CB1 var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 567,081 411922 480163 490.691 56.769
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 433,922 480,763 490,691 66,769
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 70,497,884 76,608,486 71,038,556 538,691
Note - Accrued interest has been included in month end t&ed income values
Purchase Quantity 4/30/17 5/31117 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
Akom Inc. 6/10/15 5,000 234.206 167,250 166,350 -67.856
Alibabe Group 6/10/15 5,000 444,749 577,500 612,300 167.551
Allianz SE ADR 4/13/15 5,000 90.056 95,045 96,250 6,194
Apple Inc 9/5/14 64.000 6,332.800 9,193,600 9,776,640 3,443,840
Apple Inc 1/11/16 250,000 24,750,006 35,912500 38,190,000 13.439.994
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 263,157 4.999.983 7;044;713 7,113,134 2.113,151
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Barn 1.3.11) 1/16/01 70,500 1 500.000 275,655 124,785 -1.375.215
Avalanche Ellotedinoisgles now called Adverum Biotechnologles 4/20/15 10,000 298.806 28,500 25,500 -373,106
BASF ADR 4/13/15 5000 508,056 486,430 472,250 -35.806
Bank of New York Mellon 6/25/14 250,000 9.076,406 11,765,000 11,780.000 2,703.594
Biogen Idec Inc 2/14/12 2,095 250,455 568,185 519,078 268,623
Bioverativ Inc 2/1/17 1.047 20,254 61,574 57,679 37,425
Centime Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1,156,920 1,129,397 142,900
-46.128 Dish Network Corp 6/10/15 5,000 364,978 322,200 318,850
Facebook Inc 5117112 17,500 665.000 2,629,375 2,650,550 1,985,550
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49.830 1,265,037 1,798,965 1,893,540 628.503
General Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3,585.947 3,378,266 3,309,023 -276,924
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 496,109 666,777 629,740 133.631
Gilead Sciences Inc 215/14 5,000 396.407 342,760 324,450 -71.957
Gilead Sciences Inc 3/7/14 3,100 246,797 212,505 201,159 -45,638
Glaxo Smith Me PLC 6/10/15 5,000 215,006 204,500 221,150 6.144
Global Partner Acquisition Corp 7/30/15 2,000 20,000 19 700 20,000 0
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/16 700 14,000 27:244 28,798 14.798
Match 11/19/15 200 2400 3,726 3,896 1,496
Mobileye NV Amsteiveen Ord Shares 8/1/14 800 20.000 49,536 49,520 29.520
Square 11/19/15 200 1.800 3,648 3,896 2,096
Sangamo Biosciences Inc 5/28/13 50.000 422.214 240,000 340,000 -82214
Santander Consumer USA 1/28/14 1.000 24,000 12,740 11,170 -12,830
Terraform Global 7/31/15 400 6.000 1,900 1,980 -4.040
Twitter Inc 1117113 1,500 39,000 24,720 27,480 -11.520
Viacom Inc 6/10/15 5,000 338,745 212,800 173,950 -164,795
Volkswagen AG 4/13/15 5,000 254,306 160.800 157,100 -97.206
Wisdomtree Investments Inc 3/31/15 15000 324.158 125.250 142.650 J.81.503
22,278,268 Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 58,293,977 77,770,274 80,672,245
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
Barclays PLC ADR 7/18/16 100,000 805,096 1,081,000 1,077,000 271.904
Credit Suisse Group 7/18/16 100,000 1.137.626 1,526,000 1,414,000 276,374
ZTO Express 10/27/16 3,500 ELM 48251 50 01,1 -18,235
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,010,972 2,655,755 2,541,015 530,043
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill)
Netease 5/16/17 5000 1,449,329 - 1,423 900 -25,429
INC 4/4/17 2000 48,500
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill) 1,822,829 407,000 1,846,900 23,071
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Mo an Stanie
Colony Capital->eolony Northstar Inc. 9/26/16 73.315 928,837 958227 1,035,941 107,105
Sequential Brands 9/23/16 50,000 402.134 168,500 160,500 -241,634
ZTO Express 10/27/16 1,150 22.425 16,020 16,434 -5.991
Bank of America 312/16 7,500 100,825 175,050 168,075 67,250
Editas Medicine 312/16 3,200 102,199 60.320 43,712 -58.487
Tenant Holdings 7/18/16 50 000 .1 163 762 10607.3.00 1 772 094 058.738
Total Gratitude America, LW - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,720,182 2,945,617 3,147,162 426,980
J Epstein Vi Foundation - Equities (DB)
Bristol Myers Squibb 10/30/15 5,000 334.712 280,250 269,750 -64.962
Disney 10/30/15 4,000 456.040 462,400 431.760 -24,280
Pfizer Inc 10/30/15 4,200 145.028 142.464 137.130 IA91
-97,140 Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 935,780 885,114 838,640
TOTAL EQUITIES 66,783,740 84,663,760 88,944,962 23,161,222
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF's (DB)
Wisdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 80,000 2_966_099 3.064,20 3.059.400 2,3401
93,301 Total Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETFS (DB) 2,966,099 3,064,200 3,069,400
Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill Lynch)
AAR_ May 19 2017 150 Calls 3/29/17 2,500 184,686 0
AFIINOMNII•••••• MO ••••• um, emornstato....u....m...h 1219/16 604,174 219.3292 41,519 St :24.94a
-249,494 Total Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill Lynch) notional 250,000 226,206 506
4/30/17 5/31/17 MTD YTO
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern FinanclaifSFLLC) added tOortm atm 6
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 45.283.309 45.002.552 -0.62% 2.49% added Sans 341/16
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 45,283,309 45,002,552 wthdnv ternm 1110117
total Invecrnem 40mm
2016 return 3.7714
Hedge Funds - Haze
king Street 3,444.251 3.444.251 0.00% 0.00% 2016n7 Mild CO datO:
Hedge Funds - Haze 3,444,251 3,444,251 647n6 14967,954 paid
7127116 6,102,924 paid
2017 - apri return 1047116 6,146.941 pair
of capitol of 1127417 2.914.644 PM
2.102.401 2016 return 4.68%
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 22,827.541 22.499.939 -1.40% 12.00% added 20mm emns
Total Hedge Funds - STC 22,827,541 22,499,939 2016 return 0.44%
Total Hedge Funds 71,555,101 70,946,742
SFL
Mort Southern FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profit) 0
Kyara II (investment amount) II 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0
Kyara IV (investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (grat at cost) 11,250,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,066 sTc
Aden Solutions (investment amount) 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston. NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase sic 3,001,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Valar Global Fund II (investment amount - 15mm oommittment) 13,650,000
Valar Global Fund III (investment amount - 25mm committment) 10,750,000
Totals 11,250,000 3,000,000 28,775,000 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total Investments 52,506,000
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 6,500,000 6,500,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 Plan D LLC 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 1,175,000 1,175,000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile A Boats 2,500,000 6,500,000 250,000 17,625,000 26,875,000
Asset Description JEE SFL STC FTRE Totals
Loans Receivable
Nina Keita 100,000 100,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Karyna 350,000 350.000
Nick Ribis 75,000 75,000
Lam/ / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
David Mitchell 1,500,000 1,500,000
302,000 302,000
Harlequin Dane, LLC 4,750,000 4,750,000
eEnterprises LLC 1,500,000 1,500,000
200,000 200,000
50,000 50.000
Home 133,000 133,000
il allii m 1,300,000 1,300,000
525,000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,697,446 6,450,000 50,000 1,935,000 11,132,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry haze
Giacometti 25,000,000 25.000,000
Braque 7,725,000 7,725,000
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) -30,500,000 -30,500,000
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - Insurance value 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 35,775,000 12,125,000
EFTA00811508 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2017-05-31)
Valuation Report
5/31/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - MAY 31, 2017
4/30/17 5/31/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 121,833,887 122,551,549 717,662
Fixed Income 75,508,486 71,036,555 (4,471,931)
Equities 84,663,760 88,944,962 4,281,202
Equity ETF's 3,064,200 3,059,400 (4,800)
Options 226,206 506 (225,700)
Hedge Funds 71,555,101 70,946,742 (608,359)
Investments 52,506,000 52,506,000 -
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 26,600,000 26,875,000 275,000
Loans Receivable 9,632,446 11,132,446 1,500,000
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 9,400,000 12;125,000 2,725,000
Total Assets 454,990,086 459,178,160 4,188,074
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
Frontier bond - sold 4mm @ 96.5 3,981,167
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 1,205,000
Apple Calls - sold 2500 @ 2.40 vs 2.00 cost 600,000
I-Payment Bond redemption Haze Trust 500,000
Legal - Steptoe & Johnson (55,895)
JSC Interiors funding (100,000)
International Jet - G550 Interior (175,000)
Gratitude - IPI 150k, Met Orch 50k, Int Police & Fire Chaplain 50k & 25k Film Inst (275,000)
Bentley final payment (275,338)
Miscellaneous (438,143)
Coatue - Loan (500,000)
Harlequin - Loan (1,000,000)
Monthly Spending (1,300,000)
NTES- bought 5000 shares - STC ML (1,449,129)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50,000 717,662
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan to
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Stanley Merrill AmerWade Totals
Cash
Southern Trust Company Inc. 32.527,104 586,297 300,000 953.560 17,199,40' 51,566,370
Southern Financial LLC 28,534,701 51,690 28,586,391
Haze Trust 26.189.380 26,189.380
JEE 3.720.060 720,836 456.832 4,897.728
Gratitude America. Ltd. 865,020 71,918 2,935,967 3,872,904
Jeepers Inc. 1.473.299 8,876 1,482,175
LSJE LLC 256.080 780,776 229.798 1.266,654
JEGE Inc. 963.188 963,188
Zorro Dev•lopment Cap/ Managemeril LLC 687,923 687,923
Plan D LLC 646.794 646,794
NES LLC 499,655 499,655
Southern Country International LTD 455,022 455,022
Maple Inc. 354.415 354.415
JEGE LLC 295,660 295.660
Neptune LLC 215.743 215,743
Enhanced Education 25.039 108,793 133,832
Hyperion Air LLC 100.592 100,592
Thomas VVorld Air LLC 71,440 71,440
JEE - Paris (US 5) 60,273- 60.273
Cypress Inc. 48.036 48,036
42,859 Nautilus Inc. 42,859
FT Real Estate 42,300 42,300
Freedom Air Petroleum 23,112 23,112
Michelins Transportation Co LLC 23,036 23,036
Great St Jim lie 8.857 8.857
LSJ LLC 6.150 6.150
Mort Inc 5,003 5,003
Laurel Inc. 4.220 4220
FSF LLC 937 937
1GO Company LLC 690 690
The JEE Life Ins Trust #3 206 206
Butterfly Trust 3 3
Total Cash 97,005,450 3,358,570 817,105 229,798 3,889,527 17,199,409 51,690 122,551,549
Purchase Quantity 4130117 6131117 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Trust- Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/30/2049 05(10(11 3,000,000 3,337,958 3,135,000 3,133,150 -204,808
!payment Inc 10.25% 5/15/2018 10/02/12 500,000 523,490 0
JPM Tr Flt Rate Income Fund 01/22/13 239,625.000 2,400,749 2,256,551 2,262,060 -138,689
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 49,033.00 1,180.739 1,260,638 1,261,129 80,390
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/29/14 150.967:00 3.670.430 3,881,361 3,882,871 212,441
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000.00 1.999.419 2 326 550 2.309-4.30 al1
12,843 640 25ir Total Haze Trust • Fixed Income (DB) 12,689,296 13,383,590
Avers - Fixed income (DB)
JPM Trust FLT RT Income fund 02/13/13 179,505.000 1295.452 1.690 398 1,694.524 -100 928
Total Jeepers - Fixed Income (DB) 1,795,452 1,690,398 1,694,524 -100,928
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Western Digital Cog) 7.375% Matures 4-1-2023 06/09/16 2,000,000 2.0813116 2 201 RR2 2.213.583 127.577
127,577 Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 2,086,006 2,201,882 2,213,583
Southern Trust Ca - Fixed Income (DB)
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP callable 6/20/2019 4/15/14 2.000.000 3.439193 2.736,380 2 761.059 &ADA
478,134 Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB) 3,439,193 2,736,380 2,761,059
Southern Trust Co. - Fried income (Mania)
Allergen mandatory convertible preffered 5.5% 3/1/2018 08/15/16 1.000.000 881.500 885,780 800.770 -80.730
LSCCOM 8.75% 1015/2023 01/13/17 26,250,000 2,859,332 2,746,431 2,772,378 -86,954
Frontier Communications 10.5% 9/15/2022 11/9/16 4,000,000 4.020.000 0
Kindred Healthcare 7.25%1/15/2020 STC ML 10/13/16 3,000.000 3,125,750 3,168,167 3,231,306 105 556
-401'75Q Teva mandatory convertible preffered 7.0%12/15/2018 08/15/16 1,000.000 01.750 571.000 500.000
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (Merrill) 7,768,332 11,371,378 7,304,454 463,878
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Charles Schwab 8.0% Preferred 525 par 7/27/15 40,000 1,000,000 1,096,000 1,091,600 91.600
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred 525 par 08/04/16 8.000 200,000 172.640 165.120 -34.880
Welts Fargo 5.7% Preferred 525 par 1/19/16 120,000 3,000,000 3,052.800 3,058,800 58,800
Ebay 6% Preferred 525 par matures 2-1-2056 2/22/16 80,000 2,000,000 2,120,800 2,143,200 143.200
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2028 then floats 8/16/16 500,000 500,000 522,750 532,628 32.628
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9.15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 2,500,000 2,623,122 2,610,781 2,662,150 39.028
Rept Bans Saabs 794% heed to 9-29-2017 then 3M Libor +232bp 11/10115 5600,000 5298.817 4.700.083 4.804.417 494.400
Goldman Sachs 5.375% Fixed to 5-10.2020 then 302.2 over 3 mo Rye 614/15 5,000,000 5,034.346 5,310,660 5,190,677 156 331
182'182
174,487
Capital One 5.55% Fixed to 9.1.2020 then 380 over 3 motor 5/14/15 3,000,000 3.009.819 3.188.913 3.19200
Total Southern Trust Co. • Rxed income (Morgan Stanley) 22,666,104 22,776,427 22,840,591
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed income (DB)
Bank of America 8.125% PM Dec 29 2049 1/10/11 2.000,000 2,055.000 2,189,479 2,090,982 35,982
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 4/3/13 300,000 300.000 315,974 316,794 16,794
Citigroup Inc - Series O 5.95% 8/8/15 3.000.000 3,000.006 3,191,988 3,215,698 215.892
General Electric Co GTO Faed to Float 4.0% Dec 15 2065 12/3/15 2,469,000 2,175.016 2,478,259 2,489,849 314,833
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500.000 2,887.500 2,612,500 2810.958 -76.542
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500.000 2,675,000 2,612,500 2,610„958 -64,042
LTG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49 5121/13 1.903,000 1.948.500 2.00.566 £118,673 170.173
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,000,000 2,995.764 3387,604 3,392,500 396,736
GMAC Cap TR I GTD Pfd Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80,000 1.882774 2.036.800 2.041,690 158.828
Tote/ Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 19,719,560 20,868,669 20,888,013 1,168,453
Southern  Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) hat YAM
Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 el CB1 var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 567,081 411922 480163 490.691 56.769
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 433,922 480,763 490,691 66,769
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 70,497,884 76,608,486 71,038,556 538,691
Note - Accrued interest has been included in month end t&ed income values
Purchase Quantity 4/30/17 5/31117 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
Akom Inc. 6/10/15 5,000 234.206 167,250 166,350 -67.856
Alibabe Group 6/10/15 5,000 444,749 577,500 612,300 167.551
Allianz SE ADR 4/13/15 5,000 90.056 95,045 96,250 6,194
Apple Inc 9/5/14 64.000 6,332.800 9,193,600 9,776,640 3,443,840
Apple Inc 1/11/16 250,000 24,750,006 35,912500 38,190,000 13.439.994
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 263,157 4.999.983 7;044;713 7,113,134 2.113,151
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Barn 1.3.11) 1/16/01 70,500 1 500.000 275,655 124,785 -1.375.215
Avalanche Ellotedinoisgles now called Adverum Biotechnologles 4/20/15 10,000 298.806 28,500 25,500 -373,106
BASF ADR 4/13/15 5000 508,056 486,430 472,250 -35.806
Bank of New York Mellon 6/25/14 250,000 9.076,406 11,765,000 11,780.000 2,703.594
Biogen Idec Inc 2/14/12 2,095 250,455 568,185 519,078 268,623
Bioverativ Inc 2/1/17 1.047 20,254 61,574 57,679 37,425
Centime Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1,156,920 1,129,397 142,900
-46.128 Dish Network Corp 6/10/15 5,000 364,978 322,200 318,850
Facebook Inc 5117112 17,500 665.000 2,629,375 2,650,550 1,985,550
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49.830 1,265,037 1,798,965 1,893,540 628.503
General Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3,585.947 3,378,266 3,309,023 -276,924
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 496,109 666,777 629,740 133.631
Gilead Sciences Inc 215/14 5,000 396.407 342,760 324,450 -71.957
Gilead Sciences Inc 3/7/14 3,100 246,797 212,505 201,159 -45,638
Glaxo Smith Me PLC 6/10/15 5,000 215,006 204,500 221,150 6.144
Global Partner Acquisition Corp 7/30/15 2,000 20,000 19 700 20,000 0
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/16 700 14,000 27:244 28,798 14.798
Match 11/19/15 200 2400 3,726 3,896 1,496
Mobileye NV Amsteiveen Ord Shares 8/1/14 800 20.000 49,536 49,520 29.520
Square 11/19/15 200 1.800 3,648 3,896 2,096
Sangamo Biosciences Inc 5/28/13 50.000 422.214 240,000 340,000 -82214
Santander Consumer USA 1/28/14 1.000 24,000 12,740 11,170 -12,830
Terraform Global 7/31/15 400 6.000 1,900 1,980 -4.040
Twitter Inc 1117113 1,500 39,000 24,720 27,480 -11.520
Viacom Inc 6/10/15 5,000 338,745 212,800 173,950 -164,795
Volkswagen AG 4/13/15 5,000 254,306 160.800 157,100 -97.206
Wisdomtree Investments Inc 3/31/15 15000 324.158 125.250 142.650 J.81.503
22,278,268 Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 58,293,977 77,770,274 80,672,245
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
Barclays PLC ADR 7/18/16 100,000 805,096 1,081,000 1,077,000 271.904
Credit Suisse Group 7/18/16 100,000 1.137.626 1,526,000 1,414,000 276,374
ZTO Express 10/27/16 3,500 ELM 48251 50 01,1 -18,235
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,010,972 2,655,755 2,541,015 530,043
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill)
Netease 5/16/17 5000 1,449,329 - 1,423 900 -25,429
INC 4/4/17 2000 48,500
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill) 1,822,829 407,000 1,846,900 23,071
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Mo an Stanie
Colony Capital->eolony Northstar Inc. 9/26/16 73.315 928,837 958227 1,035,941 107,105
Sequential Brands 9/23/16 50,000 402.134 168,500 160,500 -241,634
ZTO Express 10/27/16 1,150 22.425 16,020 16,434 -5.991
Bank of America 312/16 7,500 100,825 175,050 168,075 67,250
Editas Medicine 312/16 3,200 102,199 60.320 43,712 -58.487
Tenant Holdings 7/18/16 50 000 .1 163 762 10607.3.00 1 772 094 058.738
Total Gratitude America, LW - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,720,182 2,945,617 3,147,162 426,980
J Epstein Vi Foundation - Equities (DB)
Bristol Myers Squibb 10/30/15 5,000 334.712 280,250 269,750 -64.962
Disney 10/30/15 4,000 456.040 462,400 431.760 -24,280
Pfizer Inc 10/30/15 4,200 145.028 142.464 137.130 IA91
-97,140 Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 935,780 885,114 838,640
TOTAL EQUITIES 66,783,740 84,663,760 88,944,962 23,161,222
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF's (DB)
Wisdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 80,000 2_966_099 3.064,20 3.059.400 2,3401
93,301 Total Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETFS (DB) 2,966,099 3,064,200 3,069,400
Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill Lynch)
AAR_ May 19 2017 150 Calls 3/29/17 2,500 184,686 0
AFIINOMNII•••••• MO ••••• um, emornstato....u....m...h 1219/16 604,174 219.3292 41,519 St :24.94a
-249,494 Total Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill Lynch) notional 250,000 226,206 506
4/30/17 5/31/17 MTD YTO
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern FinanclaifSFLLC) added tOortm atm 6
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 45.283.309 45.002.552 -0.62% 2.49% added Sans 341/16
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 45,283,309 45,002,552 wthdnv ternm 1110117
total Invecrnem 40mm
2016 return 3.7714
Hedge Funds - Haze
king Street 3,444.251 3.444.251 0.00% 0.00% 2016n7 Mild CO datO:
Hedge Funds - Haze 3,444,251 3,444,251 647n6 14967,954 paid
7127116 6,102,924 paid
2017 - apri return 1047116 6,146.941 pair
of capitol of 1127417 2.914.644 PM
2.102.401 2016 return 4.68%
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 22,827.541 22.499.939 -1.40% 12.00% added 20mm emns
Total Hedge Funds - STC 22,827,541 22,499,939 2016 return 0.44%
Total Hedge Funds 71,555,101 70,946,742
SFL
Mort Southern FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profit) 0
Kyara II (investment amount) II 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0
Kyara IV (investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (grat at cost) 11,250,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,066 sTc
Aden Solutions (investment amount) 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston. NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase sic 3,001,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Valar Global Fund II (investment amount - 15mm oommittment) 13,650,000
Valar Global Fund III (investment amount - 25mm committment) 10,750,000
Totals 11,250,000 3,000,000 28,775,000 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total Investments 52,506,000
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 6,500,000 6,500,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 Plan D LLC 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 1,175,000 1,175,000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile A Boats 2,500,000 6,500,000 250,000 17,625,000 26,875,000
Asset Description JEE SFL STC FTRE Totals
imaceivable
100,000 100,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Karyna 350,000 350,000
Nick Ribis 75,000 75,000
Lam/ / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
David Mitchell 1,500,000 1,500,000
302,000 302,000
Harlequin Dane, LLC 4,750,000 4,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 1,500,000 1,500,000
Lesley 200,000 200,000
Cecile 50,000 50.000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
LVHi 1,300,000 1,300,000
525,000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,697,446 6,450,000 50,000 1,935,000 11,132,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry ha  _.. t
Giacometti 25,000,000 25.000,000
Braque 7,725,000 7,725,000
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) -30,500,000 -30,500.000
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - Insurance value 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 35,775,000 12,125,000
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                          Education Advance [russia] nonprofit set up by Svetlana Pozhidaeva with $55,000 from Epstein [dailybeast] 
    Masha Drokova aka Masha Bucher [russian girl] silicon valley venture capitalist (Day One Ventures), former Putin Youth member, star of "Putin's 
                                                                                                                               Kiss" [davidzmorris] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00308104 (Jmail)
 [girls] letter from Martin Nowak to INS possibly about Masha Drokova visa
(date: 2017-06-06)
[Please insert on your letterhead]
[Please insert the date here]
US DHS CIS
Vermont Service Center
30 Houghton Street

St. Albans, VT 05478
Re: Ms.
Dear Sir or Madam:
O-1 Visa Application
My name is Martin Nowak and I am a professor of Mathematics and of Biology at
Harvard University, and the director of Harvard's Program for Evolutionary dynamics.
"Evolutionary dynamics" is the study of the fundamental mathematical principles that guide
evolution. The Program for Evolutionary Dynamics (PED) at Harvard University was
established in 2003 and is dedicated to research and teaching.
Our current research topics include: evolution of cooperation, cancer, viruses,
evolutionary game/graph/set theory, prelife, protocells, eusociality, evolution of construction,
population structure, evolution of language, experimental games, and evolutionary
economics. Our ambitious goals include curing the world of cancer, infectious disease,
selfishness, and inclusive fitness theory.
First of all, I would like to take this opportunity to thank Enhanced Education
Foundation for its generous and timely charitable contributions to the Program for
Evolutionary Dynamics (PED). These contributions enabled me and those I work with at
PED to further our research goals, which include curing the world of cancer and infectious
diseases and expanding our research in fundamental questions of biology. For this, we cannot
thank Ms.1[ enough. She was the lead for Enhanced Education in raising
funds for ED, and, she is a fund-raising wizard.
Ms. is also an organizational and public relations wizard. There are many
event organizers an public relations professionals. What sets Ms. apart is her
intelligence and her understanding of very abstract issues and science: A highly educated
and intelligent person fluent in several languages, Ms. quickly understood the
fundamentals of PED during her fundraising efforts. This is no small feat—what we work on
is very, very complex, and oftentimes abstract science. But, Ms. quickly grasped
the fundamentals of our work and its importance, and, put her organizational and public
relations skills to use, fostering and promoting our work.
Our work is multidisciplinary —all basic sciences, mathematics, linguistics, sociology,
engineering, medicine and everything in between is involved. Because she understood what
we were doing, and because she gained the respect of many leading scientists and institutions
of the United States through her work with Enhanced Education, she worked hard for
establishing a bridge between our neighbor MIT and the PED.
Through her assistance, coordination, and organization, we brought in Joi Ito, the
Director of the MIT Media Labs and a board member of Sony Corporation, The New York
Times Company, the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation, the John D. and Catherine T.
MacArthur Foundation; Noam Chomsky, the legendary MIT linguistics professor described
as "the father of modem linguistics", and a major figure in analytic philosophy and one of the
founders of the field of cognitive science; Danny Hillis, the American inventor, engineer,
mathematician, entrepreneur, and author, who co-founded Thinking Machines Corporation, a
company that developed the Connection Machine, a parallel supercomputer designed by
Hillis at MIT; and Seth Lloyd, principal investigator at the MIT Research Laboratory of
Electronics, and the director of MIT's Center for Extreme Quantum Information Theory, to
our dialogue at the PED. Ms. was the lead, and a true force of nature, in
organizing and setting up meetings, and fostering these relationships.
I am sincerely looking forward to our continued work with Ms. and
Enhanced Education. I am also aware that Ms. is now focusing on the the
Education Advance Foundation, dedicated to promoting and fostering STEM education in the
United States and assisting disadvantaged students interested in STEM fields with
standardized test preparation. Promoting and increasing STEM education in the US is a
crucial mission and a drastic necessity. Therefore, I am looking forward to Ms.
work with Education Advance. Knowing her capabilities and extraordinary skills, I believe
she will continue contributing to the US education and academia.
Sincerely,
Martin A. Nowak,
Professor of Mathematics and of Biology
Harvard University
EFTA00314931 (Jmail)
 [girls] letter from Terje Rød-Larsen to INS speaking for the International Peace Institute recommending "genius" visa for Masha Drokova
(date: 2017-06-08)
IPI MWMMMPIAL
MAM
mmwn
June 8, 2017
US DHS CIS
Vermont Service Center
30 Houghton Street
St. Albans, VT 05478
Re: Ms. O-1 Visa Application
Dear Sir or Madam:
I am writing this letter on behalf of Ms.
a communications and public relations professional of
extraordinary ability, who has contributed immensely to our
organization, International Peace Institute.
Since 2005 I have been President of the International Peace
Institute (IPI), an independent, international not-for-profit
think tank dedicated to managing risk and building resilience to
promote peace, security, and sustainable development. To achieve
its purpose, IPI employs a mix of policy research, strategic
analysis, publishing, and convening.
IPI is an independent non-profit research and policy
development institution based in New York (beside the headquarters
of the United Nations, with which IPI works closely). Additionally,
the Institute has regional offices in Europe (Vienna, Austria),
and in the Middle East. We specialize in multilateral approaches
to peace and security issues, working closely with the Secretariat
and membership of the United Nations. Our primary objective is to
promote effective international responses to new and emerging
issues and crises through research, analysis, and policy
development.
Before joining the IPI, I was principal architect of the 1990s
Oslo Peace Accords (between the PLO and the Government of Israel)
and am a Norwegian sociologist and diplomat who has served the UN
as Norway's senior envoy in the Middle East.
I had the distinct pleasure of working with
benefitting from her extraordinary abilities. All my staff who
777 United Nations Plaza, New York, NY 10017 USA TEL +1-212-6874300 FAX +1-212-983-8246 www.lpinst.org
have worked closely with appreciate her skills, command
of languages and her always warm and amicable personality.
I first observed communication and language
skills during a visit to Central Asia in 2014, where she interacted
with foreign officials and professionals.
Impressed with her extraordinary skills, we asked
and the Enhanced Education Foundation, to provide support for our
international conference on Global Health and Pandemics. III
met and exceeded all our expectations. On September
12 the IPI hosted a high-level international conference on
"Preparing for Pandemics: Lessons Learned for More Effective
Responses" at Palais des Nations, Geneva, Switzerland.
Prominent leaders of international organizations such as the
United Nations, the World Health Organization, the Red Cross, the
Institut Pasteur, Medecins Sans Frontieres and the Open Society
Foundation, as well as senior officials and leading health experts
from around the world participated in this event.
The conference offered an ideal platform to discuss
challenges and lessons learned from the Ebola crisis, as well as
actionable solutions and their implementation. The meeting builds
on IPI's work on peace and health, particularly its cooperation
with the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, to overcome the final
barriers to the global eradication of polio.
and the Enhanced Education Foundation has been
an extraordinary asset for us the last few years, especially in
the organizing and fundraising of the Epidemic Conference. III
through Enhanced Education, helped allocate and raise
funds for the Conference. Without her extraordinary efforts, the
fundraising would not have reached the levels it reached.
Furthermore, participated in the Conference on
behalf of Enhanced Education, taking an active and lead role,
coordinating the follow-up meetings. In major international
conferences like our Epidemic Conference, the sessions and the
program is very strict and rigid, given the world leaders
participating. Policy, general mission and vision statements are
made at the regular sessions. After the structured sessions,
sometimes impromptu, sometimes formal, follow-up meetings need to
be organized to effectively initiate the dialogue and the working
relations for the goals and policies set forth at the conference
sessions. And, this is where shined: Using her
extraordinary understanding of international relations, knowing
who is who, and, how they would interact with each other, and,
777 United Nations Plaza. New York. NY 10017 USA zu +1-212.687-4300 FAX +1-212-983-8246 www.ipinst.org
understanding precisely the goals and the mission of the
Conference, she organized some of the follow-up meetings. The
follow-up meetings, repeating myself, are as important as the
Conference itself —the working groups and the stakeholders get
together in the follow-up meetings more efficiently, and, the real
work begins in these meetings. Given competing and sometimes
conflicting interests, it is extremely difficult to put the right
people on the right table. And this is where
excelled —she understands the inner workings of international
organizations and governments, and, she was able to, with her
singular communications skills, was able to put the right people
in the right room, furthering the success of our Conference.
We are currently discussing with future
fundraising opportunities for the IPI. is an amazing
public relations and fundraising expert. She told me about her new
endeavor, : She is undertaking a
crucial task- promoting, subsidizing, and fostering STEM Education
and standardized test taking preparations. As IPI, we firmly
believe that education  is the key to  solving the world's problems.
Therefore, we applaud in this endeavor.
With best regards,
roA Terje Rod-Larsen
President
777 United Nations Plaza. New York, NY 10017 USA ru +1-212-687-4300 FAX +1-212-983-8246 www.ipinst.Org
EFTA01112265 (Jmail)
 [legal] Brad Edwards & Paul G. Cassell v. Alan Dershowitz: interview with minor victim
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Melanie Walker [medical] neurosurgeon, Gates Foundation, Epstein science advisor [uw] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01613143 (Jmail)
 [misc] Skype log of conversation with Melanie Walker
(date: 2017-06-24)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 2017/06/24
Larry meeting?
09:45:28 am
Benign
Basically a reminder that I have 4 months left
And so far only a bunch of "errands" to show for my time
07:55:51 pm
Would like to walk away w everyone smiling ... need a happy ending but need to get
out
FYI
Got introd to Dubai And Kuwaiti SWF by Klaus Schwab from WEF.
08:30:10 pin
next time we talk can discuss
08:30:16 pm
Boris is not going to have a happy ending w BG
08:30:29 pm
Larry told BG a bunch of stuff that isn't really accurate or fair
08:31:02 pm
about? boris ? you /?
10:48:31 pm
•
•
About boris
10:48:55 pm
So that he wouldn't reinvest in his fund
10:49:20 pm
Larry has been telling BG stuff about me for years. That's not new.
10:49:41 pm
In 2006 he told him he should let me work on a project at the fndn
10:50:13 pm
10:50:17 pm
2017/06/25
Want to talk next week?
07:45:04 pm
ok
08:21:35 pm
2017/06/26
http://www.alexstjohn.com/WP/2017/06/16/fooling-ourselves-with-ai/?
fdx_switcher=true
02:09:25 am
Interesting
02:09:25 am
2017/06/27
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/23627837/
Pub qed
07:33:02 am
Nutrigenetics?
07:33:02 am
you need a plan
02:11:23 pm
V Sent
Someone sent me that crazy thing had never heard of it
04:04:40 pm
Would love a plan but maybe I just be s doc here in seattle -
04:05:56 pm
Had an idea to propose to BG that might link and improve all the things he's trying to
address as it relates to Alzheimer.
Might be a way to bring pieces together in a different and potentially impactful way.
We can talk Thursday or Friday but for now my plan is to do endovascular
neurosurgery and take over the clinical service sometime next year and just be a
clinician. Can apply for grants or try to build stuff from the UW,
Or just be a practitioner.
Seems I can't really depend on others to build a career and maybe sticking to my core
strengths is just fine. Being a doc isn't gonna change the universe or make a billion
jillion dollars but it is legit and something I can control and do ...
08:20:05 pm
I will do my best to bring some of BG dreams to life as best I can in the time I've got.
08:20:33 pm
And if something t works out w plants and sciences great.
08:20:57 pm
Mangrove photo
Neat
2017/06/29
http://m.gulfnews.com/news/uae/government/bill-gates-thanks-mohammad-bin-
zayed-for-supporting-drive-to-eradicate-global-polio-1.2050838
06:18:41 pm
V Read
╔════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Leo Loking [employee] witness to Epstein's last weill and testament 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01266268 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein last will and testament witnessed by Leo Loking and Karyna Shuliak naming Darren Indyke, Eva Dubin, Kathryn Ruemmler, Richard Kahn, 
Terje Rød-Larsen as executors
(date: 2017-06-29)
LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT
OF
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN

I, JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, a resident and domiciliary of St. Thomas, United Sta
Islands, do make, publish and declare this to be my Will hereby revoking all prior
Codicils made by me.

FIRST: A. I direct my Executor to pay from my estate all expenses of
my last illness, my funeral and burial expenses, the administration expenses of my estate and all
of my debts duly proven and allowed against my estate.

B. I direct my Executor to pay from my estate, as
compensation to each Executor for serving as Executor hereunder, the sum of Two Hundred
Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) to each Executor, upon the completion of probate of my
estate. No Executor shall receive any other compensation for serving as Executor hereunder;
provided, however, that my Executor shall be reimbursed from my estate for all reasonable
costs, expenses, charges, and liabilitie incu
expenses of counsel or any other agen hire
liable therefor individually.
state transfer taxes desert
pensation reimbursed fr d or paid in resp by my Executor,

C. I direc my Executor to pay from my estate the federal and
state transfer taxes described in Paragraph B(1) of Article SEVENTH

D. I direct my Executor to pay from my estate all expenses of
storing insuring packing shipping and delivering my tangible personal property in accordance
with the provisions of Article SECOND.
or to p Virgin s and state all expenses o es of my estate and all pay fror, the sum
ompletion of ving as Executo of Arne e NTH. estate, Two Hu obat red f myveunder; easonable
ereto, including fees and Executor shall not be from my estate the federal and

SECOND: ive all of my property, real and personal, wherever situated,
d di i.utions provided in Article FIRST, to the then acting Trustees of
017 Trust (" st") created under that certain Amendment and
ey E. Epste 017 Trust (the "Trust Agreement") dated June ,
same may from time to time, to be held in accordance with the
mprising the Trust Agreement at the time of my death.
THIRD: I appoint DARREN K. INDYKE, RICHARD D. KAHN
and TERJE R' P-LARSEN to serve as the Executors of this Will. If any one or more of my
Executors fails qualify, is unable or unwilling to serve or ceases to act, I appoint EVA
ANDERSSON D BIN, as successor Executor, followed by KATHRYN RUEMMLER, as
successor Executor, followed by STEPHEN HANSON, as successor Executor. If one or more of
such successor Executors fails to qualify, is unable or unwilling to serve or ceases to act, I
authorize the last acting Executor to designate his or her successor. Such designation shall be
made by written instrument delivered to such designated successor Executor.
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007845
Last Will & Testament of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Page 2 of 10

B. If my estate must be administered in whole or in part in
any jurisdiction other than the state or territory of my domicile at the date of my death and if my
Executor is unable or unwilling to serve in such jurisdiction, then I appoint the successor
Executor of my estate designated in Paragraph A of Article THIRD provided that he or she is
able and willing to serve in such jurisdiction. If no Executor or successor Executor is able and
willing to serve in such jurisdiction, my Executor shall designate a successor Executor to serve
in such jurisdiction. Such designation shall be made by written instrument delivered to such
successor Executor.

C. No bond or other security shall be required of any
Executor in any jurisdiction.
D. Any Executor may resign in the manner provided for by
the governing statutes of the state or territory having jurisdiction of the administration of my
estate or in the absence of such statutory guidance, by filing a written notice of resignation with
the Court having jurisdiction of the administration of my estate. Any Executor who resigns shall
not be entitled to any compensation hereunder for any services rendered as Executor prior to his
or her resignation.

E. My Executor shall not be accountable or responsible to any
person interested in my estate for the manner in which my Executor in good faith exercises or
declines to exercise any discretionary authority or power of my Executor. My Executor shall not
be liable for any loss or depreciation in value occasioned by reason of any negligence, error or
mistake of judgment in entering into any transaction, in making any sale or investment, in
continuing to hold any property or by reason of any action or omission, whether by my Executor
or any other fiduciary, unless my Executor has acted in bad faith. In the absence of proof by
affirmative evidence to the contrary, each Executor shall be deemed to have acted within the
scope of my Executor's authority, to have exercised reasonable care, diligence and prudence and
to have acted impartially as to all interested persons. An Executor shall not be liable for the acts
or defaults of another Executor.
FOURTH: The following provisions shall apply to my estate and to my
Executor, except as is otherwise specifically provided in this Will:

A. My Executor has the entire care and custody of all assets
of my estate. My Executor has the power to do everything my Executor in good faith deems
advisable without necessity of any judicial authorization or approval, even though but for this
power it would not be authorized or appropriate for fiduciaries under any statutory or other rule
of law. My Executor shall exercise my Executor's best judgment and discretion for what my
Executor believes to be in the best interests of the beneficiaries hereunder. If more than two
Executors are empowered to participate in the decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power granted by this Will or by law, a majority of such Executors shall be empowered to make
such decision.

B. Except as otherwise provided herein, my Executor shall
have the power:
2
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007846
Last Will & Testament of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Page 3 of 10

(1) to enter upon and take possession of the
assets of my estate and collect the income and profits from such assets, and to invest and
reinvest such assets in real, personal or mixed assets (including the common trust funds of a
corporate fiduciary) or in undivided interests therein without being limited by any present or
future investment laws;

(2) to retain all or any part of the assets of my
estate (without regard to the proportion that any one asset or class of assets may bear to the
whole) in the form in which such assets were received or acquired by my Executor;

(3) to sell or dispose of, exchange, transfer,
invest or loan all or any part of the assets of my estate which may, at any time, be held by my
Executor for such sums or upon such terms as to payment, security or otherwise as my Executor
determines, either by public or private transactions;

(4) to buy and sell options, warrants, puts, calls
or other rights to purchase or sell (collectively "options") relating to any security or securities,
regardless of whether such security or securities are then held by my Executor, and whether
such options are purchased or sold on a national securities exchange, and to exercise with
respect to such options all powers which an individual owner thereof could exercise, including,
without limitation, the right to allow the same to expire;
(5) with respect to oil, natural gas, minerals,
and all other natural resources and rights to and interests therein (together with all equipment
pertaining thereto) including, without limiting the generality of the foregoing, oil and gas
royalties, leases, or other oil and gas interests of any character, whether owned in fee, as lessee,
lessor, licensee, concessionaire or otherwise, or alone or jointly with others as partner, joint
tenant, or joint venture in any other noncorporate manner, (a) to make oil, gas and mineral leases
or subleases; (b) to pay delay rentals, lease bonuses, royalties, overriding royalties, taxes,
agqnsments, and all other charges; (c) to sell, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge or otherwise
hypothecate any or all of such rights and interests; (d) to surrender or abandon, with or without
consideration, any or all of such rights and interests; (e) to make farm-out, pooling, and
unitization agreements; (0 to make reservations or impose conditions on the transfer of any such
rights or interests; (g) to employ the most advantageous business form in which properly to
exploit such rights and interests, whether as corporations, partnerships, limited partnerships,
mining partnerships, limited liability companies, joint ventures, co-tenancies, or otherwise
exploit any and all such rights and interests; (h) to produce, process, sell or exchange all
products recovered through the exploitation of such rights and interests, and to enter into
contracts and agreements for or in respect of the installation or operation of absorption,
reprocessing or other processing plants; (i) to carry any or all such interests in the name or
names of a nominee or nominees; (j) to delegate, to the extent permitted by law, any or all of the
powers set forth herein to the operator of such property; and (k) to employ personnel, rent office
space, buy or lease office equipment, contract and pay for geological surveys and studies,
procure appraisals, and generally to conduct and engage in any and all activities incident to the
foregoing powers, with full power to borrow and pledge in order to finance such activities;
together with the power to allocate between principal and income any net proceeds received as
3
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007847
Last Will & Testament of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Page 4 of 10
consideration, whether as royalties or otherwise, for the permanent severance from lands of oil,
natural gas, minerals, and all other natural resources;

(6) to hold all or any part of the assets of my
estate in cash or in bank accounts without the necessity of investing the same;

(7) to improve, repair, partition, plat or
subdivide all or any part of the assets of my estate;
(8) to litigate, defend, compromise, settle,
abandon or submit to arbitration on such terms and conditions as my Executor determines any
claims in favor of or against my estate or the assets of my estate;

(9) to loan or borrow money in such amounts
and upon such terms and conditions as my Executor determines, assume such obligations or give
such guarantees as my Executor determines, for the purpose of the acquisition, improvement,
protection, retention or preservation of the assets of my estate, or for the welfare of the
beneficiaries of my estate;

(10) to carry on for as long and in such manner
as my Executor determines any business enterprise in which I owned any interest at my death,
either individually, or as a partner, member, joint venture, stockholder or trust beneficiary; to
sell such business enterprise as an ongoing business; to consolidate, merge, encumber, dissolve,
liquidate or undertake any other extraordinary corporate transaction relating to such business
enterprise;

(11) to vote in person or by proxy any and all
stock or securities and to become a party to any voting trusts, reorganization, consolidation or
other capital or debt readjustment of any corporation, association, partnership, limited liability
partnership, limited liability company or individual with respect to stocks, securities or debts
held by my estate;

(12) except as provided for in Sections (20) and
(21) of this Article Fourth, to enter into any good faith transactions with any Executor
individually or with any corporation, partnership or other entity in which any Executor has an
ownership interest;

(13) To purchase from my estate any stocks,
bonds, securities, real or personal property, or other assets, or make loans to my estate even
though the same person or persons occupy the office of my Trustee and the office of the
Executor of my estate;

(14) to lease, mortgage, pledge, grant a security
interest in or otherwise encumber all or any part of the assets of my estate for any term of years
whether or not beyond the duration of my estate (including, without limitation, any such action
for the benefit of any of the beneficiaries of my estate);
4
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007848
Last Will & Testament of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Page 5 of 10

(15) to abandon any property of my estate, real
or personal, which my Executor may deem worthless or not of sufficient value to warrant
keeping or protecting; to abstain from the payment of taxes, water rents or assessments and to
forego making repairs, maintaining or keeping up any such property; and to permit such
property to be lost by tax sale or other proceedings or to convey any such property for a nominal
consideration or without consideration so as to prevent the imposition of any liability by reason
of the continued ownership thereof;

(16) to elect the mode of distribution of the
proceeds payable to my estate from any profit-sharing plan, pension plan, employee benefit
plan, individual retirement plan, insurance contract or annuity contract pursuant to the terms of
such plan;

(17) to allocate, in my Executors discretion, any
adjustment to basis provided to my estate under the provisions of Federal and State law with
respect to property comprising my estate, without any obligation to make a compensatory
adjustment among the beneficiaries hereunder on account of such allocation;

(18) to conduct any audit, assessment or
investigation with respect to any asset of my estate regarding compliance with any law or
regulation having as its object protection of public health, natural resources or the environment
("Environmental Laws"); to pay from the assets of my estate to remedy any failure to comply
with any Environmental Law (even to the exhaustion of all of the assets of my estate); and, as
may be required in my Executor's judgment by any Environmental Law, to notify any
governmental authority of any past, present or future non-compliance with any Environmental
Law; and

(19) to sell to the Trustee under the Trust
Agreement any stocks, bonds, securities, real or personal property or other assets or borrow
from the Trustee under the Trust Agreement even though the same person or persons occupy the
office of the Executor of my estate and the Trustee under the Trust Agreement.

(20) No executor shall directly or indirectly buy
or sell any property for the estate from or to himself, or from or to his relative, employer,
employee, partner, or other business associate.

(21) No executor shall lend estate funds to
himself, or to his relative, employer, employee, partner, or other business associate.

C. Except as otherwise provided herein, my Executor shall
have the power:
(1) to employ agents, attorneys-at-law,
consultants, investment advisers (to whom my Executor has discretion to delegate my
Executor's investment authority and responsibility), other executors and other fiduciaries in the
administration of my Executor's duties; to delegate to such persons, or to one or more of my
Executors, the custody, control or management of any part of my estate as my Executor
5
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007849
Last Will & Testament of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Page 6 of 10
determines and to pay for such services from the assets of my estate, without obtaining judicial
authorization or approval;

(2) to delegate, in whole or in part, to any
person or persons the authority and power to (a) sign checks, drafts or orders for the payment or
withdrawal of funds, securities and other assets from any bank, brokerage, custody or other
account in which funds, securities or other assets of my estate shall be deposited, (b) endorse for
sale, transfer or delivery, or sell, transfer or deliver, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any and
all property, stocks, stock warrants, stock rights, options, bonds or other securities whatsoever,

(c) gain access to any safe deposit box or boxes in which my assets or assets of my estate may
be located or which may be in the name of my Executor and remove part or all of the contents of
any such safe deposit box or boxes and release and surrender the same, and (d) take any other
action that my Executor may have the power to take with respect to my estate and the property
thereof; no person or corporation acting in reliance on any such delegation shall be charged with
notice of any revocation or change of such delegation unless such person or corporation receives
actual notice thereof;

(3) to pay any property distributable to a
beneficiary under a legal disability or who has not attained the age of 21, without liability to my
Executor, by paying such property (a) to such beneficiary, (b) for the use of such beneficiary, (c)
to a legal representative of such beneficiary appointed by a court or if none, to a relative for the
use of such beneficiary, or (d) to a custodian for such beneficiary designated by my Executor, to
hold until age 21 or such earlier age as shall be the maximum permitted under applicable law;

(4) to distribute to any of the beneficiaries of
my estate in kind or in cash, or partly in kind and partly in cash, and to allocate different kinds
or disproportionate shares of assets or undivided interests in assets among all of such
beneficiaries;

(5) to have evidence of ownership of any
security maintained in the records of a Federal Reserve Bank under the Federal Reserve Book
Entry System; to deposit funds in any bank or trust company; to carry in the name of my
Executor or the nominee or nominees of my Executor and with or without designation of
fiduciary capacity, or to hold in bearer form, securities or other property requiring or permitting
of registration; and to cause any securities to be held by a depository corporation of which an
Executor is a member or by an agent under a safekeeping contract; provided, however, that the
books and records of my Executor shall at all times show that such investments are part of my
estate;

(6) to renounce and disclaim, in whole or in
part, and in accordance with applicable law, any assets, interests, rights or powers (including
any power of appointment) which are payable to (or exercisable by) me or my estate, which are
includible in my estate or Gross Estate or over which I have any right, title, interest or power;
and

(7) to make, execute and deliver any and all
such instruments in writing as shall be necessary or proper to carry out any power, right, duty or
6
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007850
Last Will & Testament of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Page 7 of 10
obligation of my Executor or any disposition whatsoever of my estate or any asset of my estate
and to exercise any and all other powers incidental or necessary to carry out or to fulfill the
terms, provisions and purposes of my estate.

D. In connection with any insurance policy or annuity on the
life of an Executor which is included in my estate, such Executor shall not participate in the
decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power in connection with any incidents of
ownership for such policy or annuity, including, without limitation, any decision to continue,
assign, terminate or convert such policy or annuity or to name the beneficiary of such policy or
annuity.

E. An Executor hereunder may by a written notice delivered
to the other Executor (or Executors) decline to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Will or by law.

F. If an Executor is not empowered (because of a conflict of
interest, declination to act or otherwise) to participate in the decision to exercise or not exercise
any fiduciary power granted by this Will or by law, then the remaining Executor or Executors
shall be empowered to make such decision. If no Executor is empowered to participate in such
decision, then the successor Executor of my estate designated in Paragraph A of Article THIRD
and able and willing to act shall be empowered to make such decision. If no Executor or
successor Executor is empowered to participate in such decision, my Executor may designate a
successor Executor to serve as Executor of my estate who shall be empowered to make such
decision but shall have no other power or authority of my Executor. Such designation shall be
by written notice delivered to such successor Executor.

G. (1) Except as otherwise specifically provided herein
and except as provided in Paragraph G(2) of this Article, my Executor shall allocate receipts and
disbursements in accordance with sound trust accounting principles and shall have discretion to
allocate receipts and disbursements when the treatment is uncertain under applicable laws or
generally accepted accounting principles in the judgment of my Executor.

(2) Except as otherwise specifically provided in this
Will, my Executor shall not treat any part of the principal amount of the proceeds of sale of any
asset of my estate as income distributable to or for the benefit of any beneficiary entitled to
distributions of income; provided, however, that my Executor shall treat a portion of any
proceeds of sale of any financial instrument originally issued or acquired at a discount equal to
the amount which (a) has previously been characterized as ordinary income for income tax
purposes or (b) will be characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes in the year of
such sale, as income for trust accounting purposes.
FIFTH: Where a party to any proceeding with respect to my estate has the
same interest as a person under a disability, it shall not be necessary to serve legal process on the
person under a disability.
SIXTH: If any beneficiary under the Trust shall in any way directly or
indirectly (a) contest or object to the probate of my Will or to the validity of any disposition or
7
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007851
Last Will & Testament of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Page 8 of 10
provision of my Will or of the Trust or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or
indirectly instrumental in the institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest,
objection or claim for the purpose of setting aside or invalidating my Will or the Trust or any
disposition therein or provision thereof, then I direct that (a) any and all provisions in the Trust
for such beneficiary and his issue in any degree shall be null and void and (b) my estate, whether
passing under my Will or the Trust or pursuant to the laws of intestacy, shall be disposed of as if
such beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all failed to survive me.
SEVENTH: A. As used herein:

(1) The term "Executor" of a person's estate
means all persons or entities who occupy the office of executor, administrator, personal
representative, or ancillary administrator while such persons or entities occupy such office,
whether one or more persons or entities occupy such office at the same time or times, and
includes any successor or successors to that office. The term "Trustee" means all persons or
entities who occupy the office of Trustee under the Trust Agreement while such persons or
entities occupy such office, whether one or more persons or entities occupy the office of Trustee
at the same time or times, and includes any successor Trustee or Trustees. A reference to a
person's estate or probate estate means that person's estate which is subject to probate
administration. A reference to a person's Will means such person's Last Will and Testament and
any Codicil or Codicils thereto.

(2) The term "IRC section" means a section of
the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, or the corresponding provision of any
successor Internal Revenue law, as in effect as of the date of my death.

(3) A reference to any tax also includes any
interest or penalties thereon. A reference to a person's "Gross Estate" means such person's gross
estate as finally determined for purposes of computing such person's federal estate tax.

(4) Whenever the singular number is used, the
same shall include the plural, and the masculine gender shall include the feminine and neuter
genders.

B. (1) The federal and state transfer taxes which my
Executor shall be obligated to pay pursuant to Paragraph B of Article FIRST shall consist of all
federal and state estate, inheritance, succession, and similar taxes (including any federal or state
generation-skipping transfer tax) imposed upon my probate estate or by reason of my death in
respect to all assets which pass under this Will or the Trust Agreement. Subject to Paragraph
B(2) of this Article, all federal estate taxes with respect to assets not passing under this Will or
the Trust Agreement (such assets are referred to as the "Apportionment Assets") and any
applicable state estate taxes with respect to the Apportionment Assets shall be apportioned
among all persons interested in the Apportionment Assets. My Executor shall make reasonable
efforts to collect all federal estate taxes and state estate, inheritance, succession and similar taxes
allocable to the Apportionment Assets from the recipients of the Apportionment Assets. Without
changing the apportionment of taxes in this Paragraph B(1), my Executor has discretion, but is
not required, to pay all or part of such taxes allocable to the Apportionment Assets. To the
8
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007852
Last Will & Testament of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Page 9 of 10
extent my Executor pays such taxes allocable to the Apportionment Assets, my Executor shall
seek reimbursement for such taxes from the recipients of the Apportionment Assets. My
Executor shall not be personally liable for any of such taxes if my Executor is unable, with
reasonable efforts, to collect payment (or reimbursement) from any recipient of any
Apportionment Assets for any or all of such taxes allocable to such assets.

(2) My Executor has discretion to direct the
Trustee of the Trust Agreement to pay all or any portion of the taxes which my Executor is
directed or obligated to pay pursuant to Paragraph B of Article FIRST and this Paragraph B
pursuant to a written direction delivered to the Trustee under the Trust Agreement. Any taxes
which my Executor directs the Trustee under the Trust Agreement to pay shall be allocated and
paid from the trusts under the Trust Agreement as provided under the Trust Agreement.

C. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Will, a
bequest or devise to an individual who does not survive me shall lapse notwithstanding any law
to the contrary.

D. To the extent that the distribution to the Trustee under the
Trust Agreement pursuant to Article SECOND shall not be effective, I give all the rest of my
property, real and personal, wherever situated, after the payments and distributions provided in
Article FIRST, to the person or persons named as Trustee or Trustees under the Trust
Agreement, be to held in trust under this Will in accordance with the provisions comprising the
Trust Agreement at the time of my death, which provisions are incorporated in this Will by
reference.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I have duly executed this Will thisQl 4hday of June,
2017.
JEFFREY E. EPS
The foregoing written instrument was, on the date thereof, igned, published
and declared by the Testator therein named as the Testator's Will in the presence of us and of
each of us, who, at the Testator's request, in the Testator's presence, and in the presence of
each other have subscribed our names as witnesses thereto.
__,.„--:---c-
LEO Loking
residing at
/e.--- --2-- ------ residing at
Karyna Shuliak I
9
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007853
Last Will & Testament of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Page 10 of 10
AFFIDAVIT
We, JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, leO LOY-A 0,C)
and the witnesses, respectively, whose names are
been sworn, declared to the undersigned officer
witnesses, signed the instrument as his Will, that he
presence of the Testator and in the presence of each
STATE OF NEW YORK
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
, and ioaryna inuIt0K. the Testator
signed to the foregoing instrument, having
that the Testator, in the presence of the
signed, and that each of the witnesses, in the
other, signed the Will as a witness.
Subscribed and sworn to before me by JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, the Testator, who is personally
known to me or who has produced   as identification, and by
Leo 1—OKvEn , a witness who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification, and daNna , a witness who is personally known to me or
who has produced as identification, on June .2q  2017.
Sworn to before me this (Pr  day of June, 2017.
a/0AM daith Notary Public
HABIBE AVOIU
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK

No. 01AV6313116
Qualified in Richmond County
My Commission Expires October 14. 2018
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_000071354
EFTA00811530 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2017-06-30)
Valuation Report
6/30/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - JUNE 30, 2017
5/31/17 6/30/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 122,551,549 127,228,936 4,677,387
Fixed Income 71,036,555 72,806,515 1,769,960
Equities 88,944,962 87,293,777 (1,651,186)
E uity ETF's 3,059,400 3,120,000 60,600
Options 506 0 (506)
Hedge Funds 70,976,054 71,309,742 333,688
Investments 52,506,000 52,506,000
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 26,875,000 26,875,000 -
Loans Receivable 11,132,446 11,207,446 75,000
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 12,125,000 1 583 200 -10,541,800
Total Assets 459,207,472 453,930,616 -5,276,856
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
Haze Trust - Braque Payment 7,725,000
STC ML - Sold 5000 NTES 305.7206 1,528,603
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 508,380
Enhanced - Sold 4,200 PFE 137,815
Cecile loan repaid 50,000
Miscellaneous (44,097)
Legal / PR - Hiltzik 25k & Goldberger 25k (50,000)
NES - Sothebys via Pinto (50,889)
LSJE - Ford 250 & Lift Gate (54,472)
Solano Constuction - Zorro Deposit Windows and Staff Cottage (65,000)
GIV Rolls Royce Engine Program (6 months) (91,960)
Enhanced - Humanity + (115,000)
NLR Resorts / Nick Loan (125,000)
STC MS - Bought 10,000 Altice 30.00 then Sold 5,000 (150,000)
G550 - Flight Saftety - LV, DR, WH & Chip (199,224)
STC ML - Bought 12,000 shares ON 16.63 (200,038)
G550 Rolls Royce Engine Program (9 months) (215,755)
STC ML - Bought 8,000 shares MU 30.85 (246,798)
Gratitude America - 125k IPI & 125k MIT & 2 others (265,000)
NES - NYC RE Taxes (327,498)
NES - Pinto NYC renovations (372,780)
STC ML - Bought 20,000 shares XLF 24.34 (486,800)
Monthly Spending (1,050,000)
STC MS - Bought 46,484 shares NGL preferred 25.00 (1,162,100)
i I
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50,000 4,677,387
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan TD
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Stanley Merrill Amnitrads Totals
Cash
Southern Trust Company Inc 29,759,824 462,985 300.000 2,752.615 17,826,766 51.102.190
Haze Trust 33.928,618 33.928.616
Southern Financial LLC 28,733,556 51,690 28,785.246
4,250.922 JEE 3,060,307 733,742 456,873
Gratitude America, Ltd. 440,146 71,822 2,940,238 3,452,206
1,482,999 Jeepers Inc. 1.474.273 8,726
JEGE Inc 963 188 963,188
LSJE LLC 12t541 532,015 202,156 857,711
Zorro Management LW 500,193 500,193
Southern Country International LTD 454,272 454,272
NES LLC 339,489 339,489
Plan D LLC 220,654 220,654
JEGE LLC 173,343 173,343
Neptune LLC 154,993 154,993
Enhanced Education 38,962 100,460 139,422
Hyperion Air LLC 100,292 100.292
(homes World Alr LLC 65,656 65.656
JEE - Paris (US Si 54,621 54.621
Cypress Inc. 47,857 47,857
FT Real Estate 42,149 42,149
Maple Inc. 26,768 26,768
Freedom Air Petroleum 22,812 22,812
Michelles Transportation Co LW 22,736 22,736
Nautilus Inc. 15,137 15,137
Great St Jim LLC 8,857 8,857
LSJ ISO 6,150 6,150
Mort Inc 4,853 4853
4,070 Laurel Inc 4,070
FSF LLC 937 937
IGO Company LLC 390 390
The JEE Life Ins Trust P3 206 206
Butterfly Trust 3 3
Total Cash 100,016,437 2,627,540 811,494 202,156 5,692,853 17,826,766 51,690 127,228,936
Purchase Quantity 5/31/17 6130117 Unrealized Asset Description Dab Cost Value Value Gain (Lose)
Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% PM 4/30/2049 05/10/11 3,000300 3,337,958 3,133,150 3 -179,958 JPM Tr Fit Rate Income Fund 01/22/13 
240.303397 2,407,128 2.262,080
_158300
2261,257 -145.871 Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 49,033.00 1,180,739 1261,129 1,276,819 96,080 Citibank 
Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/29114 150,967.00
3.670,430 U62,871 3331.181 280.751 Citibank Preferred Ser I< 6.875% 2/3/14 79 000.00
12,964,867 389,19 Total Haze Trust - F name (DB) 'F6 5,874 „
Japers - Fixed Income DB)
JPM Trust FLT RT Income fund 02/13/13 180013.000 2 1 1.694 524 X3.923 - Total Japers - Fixed Income (DB) ,800,231 
1,694,624 1,693,923 -106,308
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Sternal Western Digital Corp 7.375% Matures 4-1-2023 06/09/18 2,000,000 
2.088.0A _1.213.583 2.233.965 147.959 Total
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 2,086,008 2,213,683 2,233 965 147,959
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB)
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP callable 6/20/2019 4/15/14 2.000 000 3,439.193 _2.761.05.2 __1868.513 -770,681 Total 
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (DB)
3,439,193 2,761,059 2,668,513 -770,681
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income Merril°
Allegan mandatory convertibleproffered 5.5%3/1!2018 08/15/16 1,000,000 881,500 800,770 867,410 -14,090 LSCCOM 8.75% 
10/15/2023 01/13/17 21,250,000 2789125
2,772,378 2,814,889 25,764 Kindred Healthcare 7.25%1/15/2020 Sit ML 10/13/16 3.000,000 3,060.528 3,231,306 3,260,667 
200,138 Teas mandatory convertible
proffered 7.0% 12/15/2018 08/15/18 1,000,000 01.750 500.0® 594.500 307.250 Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (MEMO
7,832,903 7,304,454 7,537,468 415,436
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred $25 par 7/27/15 40.000 1,000.000 1,091,600 1,0t0,400 86,400 NGL Energy Partners 9%525 par 
6/6/17 46484 1,162,100 - 1,151,874
-10,226 Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $25 par 08/04/16 400 200.000 185,120 168320 -33,680 Wells Fargo 5.7% Preferred $25 par 
1/19/16 120000
80.000
3,000,000
2.000.000
3,058,800
2143,200
3,108,000
2.189,600
108.000
189,600 Ebay 6% Preferred $25 par matures 2.1.2058 2/22/16 Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 
8/16/16 500,000 500,000 532,628 530,000
2,650,000
30 MO
26'378 Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 2,500.000 2,623.122 2,862,150 Royal Bank Sco5and 
7.64% Fixed M 9-29-2017 then 3M Leor
+nap 11/10/15 5,000,000 5,298,817 4,804,417 4,895.000 -403,817 Goldman Sachs 5.375% Fixed to 5-104020 then 3922 over 3 
mo bar 6/4/15 5,000.000 5.034346
5,190,677— 5,291,326 256,980 Capital One 5.55% Fired to 9.1.2020 then 380 over 3 mo libor 5/14115 3,000,000 3,022.819 
3.19232() 3.10,413 153,594 Total Southern
Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 23,828,204 22,840,591 24,231,933 403,729
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB)
Bank of America 8.125% PM Dec 29 2049 1/10111 2.000.000 2,055,000 2090,982 2100,013 45 013 Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 
4/1072023 4/3113 300,000 300.000 316,794
317,187 17,187 Citigroup Inc - Series Q 5.95% 8/6/15 3,000,000 3,000,006 3,215,698 3,223,598 223,592 General Electric Co
GTD Fixed to Float 4.0% Dee 16 2065
12/3/15 2.489.000 2.175.016 2,489,849 2,485.460 310,444 JP Morgan Chase Si Co Pfd 7.9% Apri 30 2049 6115/11 2500 000 
2,687,500 2,610,958 2331 667 -55,833 JP
Morgan Chase & Co PM 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2.500300 2,675.000 - 2,810,958 2331367 -43,333 LBG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49
5/21/13 1903000 1,948,500 2,118,673
2,100,446 151.946 Southern Cal Edison 8.25% Dec31 2049 1/30/12 3300.000 2.996.011 3.392.500 3.400.104 404,093 GMAC Cap 
TR I GTD Pfd Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80,000
1882174 2,041.600 2.096.000
20,986,120
211226
1,266,314 Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 19 719,807 20,888,013
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) tact zallet Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-"RA2 cl 081 var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 
567.081 4 .270 490391 489,779 §7. 59 Total
Southern Financial LLC - Fired income (DB) 432.270 490,691 489,729 57,469
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 71,534,289 71,036,655 72,806,615 1,272,227
Note - Accrued interest has been Included In month ells tired income YAWS
1
Purchase Quantity 6131117 6/30117 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DO)
Akorn Inc 6/10/15 5 000 234.206 166,350 167,700 -66,506
Alibaba Group 6110/15 5:000 444.749 612,300 704,500 259.751
Allianz SE ADR 4/13/15 6,000 90.056 96,250 98,875 8.819
Apple Inc 9/5/14 64,000 6.332.800 9,776,640 9,217,280 2,884,480
Apple Inc 1111/18 250,000 24.750.006 38,190.000 36,005.000 11,254,994
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 263,157 4,999,983 7,113,134 6,960.503 1,960,520
-1,348,425 Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Barn 1.3.11) 1/16101 70.500 1.500.000 124,785 151,575
Avalanche Biotechnologies now called Adverum Biotechnologies 4/20/15 10 000 398,606 25500 25,000 -373 606
-41,606 BASF ADR 4/13/15 5000 508,056 472,250 486,450
Bank of New York Mellon 6/25/14 2517,000 9,076,406 11,780,000 12,755,000 3,678594
318.044 Blogen Idec Inc 2/14/12 2,095 250.455 519.078 568,499
Bioverativ Inc 2/1/17 1,047 20,254 57,679 62,998 42,744
Cenlene Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1,129,397 1,242,134 255,637
Dish Network Corp 6/10/15 5,000 364,978 318.850 313,800 -51,178
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17,500 665,000 2,650,550 2,642,150 1,977,150
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49,830 1,265,037 1,893.540 1,980,743 715,706
General Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3,585,947 3,309,023 3,406,548 -179,399
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 496,109 629,740 621.230 125.121
Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 5,000 396,407 324,450 353,900 -42,507
Gilead Sciences Inc 3/7/14 3,100 246,797 201,159 219,418 -27,379
Glaxo Smith Kline PLC 6/10/15 5000 215OO6 221 150 215,600 594
Global Partner Acquisition Corp 7/30/15 x,000 20.000 20:000 19,700 -300
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/15 700 14,000 28798 29,694 15,694
Match 11/19/15 200 2.400 3.896 3,476 1,076
Mobileye NV Amstelveen Ord Shares 8/1/14 800 20.000 49,520 50,240 30,240
Square 11/19/15 200 1,800 3,896 3,476 1,676
Sangamo Biosciences Inc 5/28/13 50,000 422.214 340,000 440,000 17.786
Santander Consumer USA 1/28/14 1,000 24,000 11.170 12,760 -11,240
Terraform Global 7/31/15 400 6.000 1,960 2,020 4,980
Twitter Inc 11/7/13 1,500 39,000 27,480 26,805 -12,195
-170.895 Viacom Inc 6/10/15 5,000 338.745 173,950 167,850
Volkswagen AG 4/13/15 5000 254,306 157,100 155,625 -98,681
1Afisdomtree Investments Inc 3/31/15 15000 a24.118 142.650 152.550 0 71.608
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 68,293,977 80,572,245 79,243,099 20,949,121
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
Barclays PLC ADR 7/18/16 100,000 805.096 1.077,000 1,059,000 253.904
Altice 6/22/17 5,000 150,000 - 161,500
1,460.000
11,500
322.374 Credit Suisse Group 7/18/16 100,000 1,137,626 1,414,000
ZTO Express 10/27/16 3,500 68250 50.015 48.860 -1929Q
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,160,972 2,541,015 2,729,360 568,388
Southern Trust Ca • Equities (Merril°
Netease 5/16/17 5 000 1,423,900 -
238.880
0
4.238 Micron Technology 6/20/17 d,000 247,118 -
XLF Financial Sector 6/20/17 20 000 487,600 - 493,400 5,800
ON Semiconductor 6/8/17 12;000 200,038 - 168,480 -31,558
ING 4/4/17 26,000 373.509 422.0(X) 4_34.750 61,250
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill) 1,308,255 1,845,900 1,335,510 27,255
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morga
Colony Capital->Colony Northstar Inc. 9/26/16 73 315 928,837 1,035,941 1,033,008 104,172
Sequential Brands 9/23/16 50:000 402.134 160,500 199,500 -202,634
ZTO Express 10/27/16 1 150 22,425 16.434 16,054 4,371
Bank of America 3/2/16 71400 100,825 168,075 181,950 81,125
Editas Medicine 3/2/16 3,200 102,199 43.712 53.696 -48,503
Tencent Holdings 7/18/16 50,000 1.163 762 1_722.500 1.798.000 634,238
Total Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,720,182 3,147,162 3,282,208 562,026
J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB)
Bristol Myers Squibb ! 10/30/15 5.000 334,712 269.750 278.600 -56.112
Disney 10/30/15 4,000 456,040 431.760 425.000 41,040
'Pfizer Inc 10/30/15 4,200 3.—.312 - 2
Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 790,752 838,640 703,600 -87,162
TOTAL EQUITIES 65,274,139 88,944,962 87,293,777 22,019,638
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETPs (DB)
Wlsdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60,000 2.966 099 3.059.4% 3_1.22.2gQ 153.901
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETPS (DB) 2,966,099 3,059,400 3,120,000 153,901
Southern Trust Ca - Options (Merrill Lynch)
NJ II &OM. MO soma My 24 14a MS l*Ol• ittesasUniss bra le 12/9/16 604.174 250.000 5017 taitleisl WORMOH 0
Total Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill Lynch) notional 250,000 506 0 0
5/31/17 6/30/17 MTD YTD Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern Financial ISFLLC) • . • lOmm 3/1/16
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 45 031 864 45 247 764 0.48% 3.05% • • ed 5ram 3/31216
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 45,031,864 45,247,764 9.1hdiw 10mm 1/10/17
total Investment 40mm
2016 /Mum 327%
Hedge Funds -Haze
King Street
i s,441,5 1111
3.516.505 0.55% 2.99% 2014/17 paid to date:
Hedge Funds - Haze 3,516,505 4127116 5,967.954 pal
7127116 6,102,924 pad
2017• awl Mum 10127114 $,1114,N1 Fps
01 capital o/ 1/27/17 3,994,644 • •
2,307,103 2016 return 4.16%
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 22 499 939 22.545.473 0.20% 12.23% adanomm mit
Total Hedge Funds - STC 22,499,939 22,545,473 2018 Mom 0.44%
Total Hedge Funds 70,976,054 71,309,742
SFL
Mort Southern FT Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments I
SFL Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k prop ) 0 Kyara II (investment amount) 250,000 Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0
Kyara IV (Investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000 Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000 Jawbone Investment (grat at cost) 
11,250,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,000 src Adfin Solutions (investment amount) 875,000 butterfly trust Park Partners LLC -
320 East 82nd Street (investment
amount) 3,480.000 Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston, NJ 3.000,000 Coinbase I STC 3,001,000 Reporty via 
Ergo Ltd (Investment amount) 1,000,000
Valar Global Fund II (investment amount - 16mrn cornmMment) 13,650,000
Valar Global Fund III (investment amount - 25mm committment) 10,750,000
Totals 11,250,000 3,000,000 28,775,000 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total investments 52,506,000
Hyperion JEGE JEGE Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500.000 1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 6,500,000 6,500,000 1968 Boeing 727 N90&IE 250,000 
Plitn g LLC 250,000
15,750.000 2008 G550 15,750,000 Automobiles 1,175,000 1,175, et s Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 2,500,000 6,500,000 250,000 17,625,000 26,875,000
Asset Description JEE SFL STC FIRE Totals
Loans Receivable
100,000 100,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Karyna 350,000 350,000
Nick RibIs 200,000 200,000
Larry / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
David Mitchell 1,500,000 1,500,000
302,000 302,000
Harlequin Dane, LLC 4,750,000 4,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 1,500,000 1,500,000
Lesley 200,000 200,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
LVIciii 1,300,000 1,300,000
525.000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,822,446 6,450,000 0 1,935,000 11,207,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Ads, Antiques & Jewelry,' haze That
Giacometti (17.064.000 Pounds a tag 22,183,200 22,183,200
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) -30,500,000 -30,500,000
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - insurance value 5,400,000 5,400.000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3.050.000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 25,233,200 1,583,200
EFTA01612665 (Jmail)
 [girls] Epstein gives advice on how to recruit girls, see quote: "stressed about finding girls. It's hard"
(inferred timestamp: 2017-07-02 22:31:49)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
2017/06/29
How are u Dear How have u been
03:26:27 pm
/ <REDACTED>
03:26:29 pm
This is My New Italian number
03:26:35 pm
If you have time Please call me so we can catch up
03:27:29 pm
What happen
O 05:26:20 pm
sorry you are stressed. i believe in you. don't worry. , that being said , its time to
grow up and deal with the future. . modeling cant last more than a year at
most. there is little biz . you have not found anyone for me. either. time to get
your asss in gear. you have great potential
05:58:07 pm
Thank you for your message. Thanks for believing in me. Yes I really wanna deal with
the future now and be a big girl. Modeling should be a side thing to do sometimes for
fun. I'm sorry I haven't found you anyone yet. It's been hard. I dunno how to find
someone. I need advice on how to do it. Should I talk to maybe?
06:01:50 pm
What do you think I should do?
06:01:56 pm
I really wanna get my ass in gear and feel successful. Would you like me to work more
for you and even travel with you etc? I would like to. I wanna show you how hard I can work
06:08:48 pm
U called by mistake?
O 07:48:00 pm
Yes, I am concerned however that you need to have a plan. I will help , but you
need to get serious.
08:49:30 pm
I agree fully. After our call I reached out to a man I met in New York. Him and another
guy are the founders of "Wunderbrow" huge make up brand, most sold make up item
on Amazon. They have office in London and Miami but soon maybe New York.
When I met him he asked what I am studying and bunch of things and I told him I am
studying marketing and I like online/digital marketing how brands should behave
successfully on social media, how to create content on social media etc especially for
cosmetics or fashion. And after our conversation he told me to contact him when I was
done with studying. He seemed interested and serious. So I contacted him now and he
said he is gonna get back to me soon.
08:58:26 pm
Could maybe lead to something interesting and a way for me to get hired. Also
thinking about other opportunities and searching. And also trying to find
nice/interesting girls in Milan
09:00:52 pm
But right now in this moment I really just wish I was with you. You always make me feel
great. You are an amazing person Jeff, I hope u know that. Very lucky I am to have
someone like you in my life
O 09:02:24 pm
2017/07/01
Feeling better?
01:18:57 pm
???
09:59:05 pm
Yes feeling a little better. But still stressed about finding girls. It's hard. Can we please
talk about it soon
10:02:04 pm
How are u
O 10:02:12 pm
Very busy
10:03:46 pm
Just become friends with them, gym. castings. Shoots restaurants etc. if you have
to fly back to the states for a job interview. No problem. III pay. If you don't get any
work in sept however. We will have to make some very big deceisions
10:05:10 pin
Okay. Yes will try. Problem in Milan is that there are very little nice girls. From what I've
seen so far. Very young and nothing special. But will look for them as much as I can.
Thank you thank you very much for all. Let me Know if you find some spare time
tomorrow or Monday to FaceTime. Would like to see u and talk on the phone for a
little. But if you busy of course no problems
10:21:04 pin
can i call you now??
10:31:20 pm
<bikini photo>
Yes sure
O 10:31:49 pm
2017/07/02
Take photos of your shoot
06:26:22 pm
V Sent
Do you mean the bikini fitting tomorrow? If the bikini fits and the client like it on me I
will book the show so let's hope for the best„
06:30:03 pin
Will send you pits
06:30:03 pm
Also I had an editorial here I can show u
06:30:12 pm
<bikini photo>
06:30:52 pm
<bikini photo>
06:43:03 pm
../ Read
EFTA00006036 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2017-07-04 20:20:00)
fi
ts)O5/eyo

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

_Pat' ill y,  & Xsiesta
Reed tuna  dge. Wmci 1111,9
MID -ISLAND NY 117
AB XI 21.$2D Phi 5 L
-United-States-Atterney's-office -
The  Silvio J Mollo Building
New York, New York 10007
Attn:
Acting United States Attorney
10007 —i70i0i
oendiagferazz, & eigiedow
Sr
111S, Ie W it ° e
saffnehor reintia,fiat#, 4. tava. emetedow, 4.
July 17, 2020
United States Attorney's Office
The Silvio J. Mollo Buildin
New York, New York 10007
Attn:
Acting United States Attorney
Re: Richard Taus
91A1040
Dear Ms.
Please be advised that I have represented Richard Taus who is currently an
inmate at Clinton Correctional Facility. By way of background Richard Taus is a
former Special Agent with the FBI and a former decorated Lt. Colonel and
helicopter pilot who served our country with honor and distinction during the
Vietnam War. Richard Taus has informed me he believes he possesses important
information relative to the death of Jeffrey Epstein along with information
regarding Ghislaine Maxwell and he possesses relevant information to an
individual named J. Doe who visited him while an inmate in prison.
I am respectfully requesting as a former Assistant United States Attorney
and a present practicing attorney that you utilize your good office to interview
Richard Taus who seeks to lend you assistance in this investigation. It is my
respectful opinion that Robert possesses important and vital information that can
assist in the interest of justice.
Thank you for your consideration in this matter.
Respectfully submitted,
V oirnvvo --7 -elz44-
ANTHONY V. LOMBARDINO
EFTA00599617 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2017-07-31)
Valuation Report
7/31/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - JULY 31, 2017
6130117 7/31/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash '127,228,936 135,985,107 8,756,171
Fixed Income 72,806,515 73,841,829 1,035,314
Equities 87,293,777 73,617,040 (13,676,737)
Equity ETF's 3,120,000 3,138,000 18,000
Options 0 91,350 91,350
Hedge Funds 71,455,541 73,055,554 1,600,012
Investments 52,506,000 57,756,000 5,250,000
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 26,875,000 26,875,000 -
Loans Receivable 11,207,446 11,207,446 -
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 123.200 1.583.200 Q
Total Assets 454,076,415 457,150,525 3,074,110
Cash Activity - Items over 50.000
STC ML - Sold 250,000 shares BK 51.84 12,955,276
STC ML - Sold 97,525 shares GM 35.592 3,471,110
STC ML - Sold 23,000 shares GE 25.4032 584,274
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 304,386
STC ML - Sold 8,000 shares MU 31.64 253,120
SFL DB - Sale of AKRX, GPACU, MTCH, SQ, GLBL 199,453
STC MS - Sold 6,484 NGL Energy Partners 24.81 160,858
Enhanced - Sold 1,500 Disney 159,804
STC MS - Sold 5,000 Mice 31.5484 157,532
Enhanced - BBB (25,000)
Legal - Erika Mapp Invoice (50,717)
Miscellaneous (76,715)
Enhanced - DPNR (160,000)
NES - Pinto 400k Euro (456,128)
SIC MS - Bought 2,000 NTES 308.5245 (617,049)
STC ML - Bought 20,000 shares TER 35.2016 (704,032)
STC MS - Bought 40,000 NLY 25.00 (1,000,000)
Spotify Investment via Honeycomb (1,000,000)
Monthly Spending (1,150,000)
Velar III Capital Call (4.250,000)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50 000 8,756,171
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan 10
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Stanley I Merrill Amentrs. Totals
. .._
58.184.007
Cash
Southern Must Company Inc. 21,524297 343.180 299,452 1.478.105 34.538.973
Haze Trust 34,019,367 34,019,367
Southern Financial LLC 28,971,578 51.891 29,023.267
JEE 4,539,461 743.738 456.950 5,740.149
Gratitude America, Ltd. 825,259 71606 — 2.060,885 3,657,750
Jeepers Inc, 1,475,399 7,853 1.483.252
963.188JEGE Inc. 963,188
LSJE LW 393,800 327.261
453.880
157.161 878221
Southern Country International LTG 40410
Zorro Management LLC 380,501 380 501
Plan D LLC 220,654 220,654
NES LLC 211,421 211,421
JEGE LLC 141,777 141,777
Enhanced Education 88,512 22.121 108.639
Hyperion Air LLC 100,292
--- 0,171
100,292
JEE - Paris (US 5) 89.177
Neptune LLC 69,063 69,063
Thomas World Air LLC 57.579 57.579
Cypress Inc
FT Real Estate
47.857
42.149
26.768
22.812
22.736
47,857
42,149
Maple Inc 26.768
Freedom Air Petroleum
Mrchelles Transportation Co LLC
22.812
22.736
Nautilus Inc
Great St Jim LLC
LSJ LLC
15.137
8.857
15,137
8,857
6.150 6,150
Mort Inc 4.853 4,853
Laurel Inc _____.
FSF LLC
4.070 4.070
9-3r 937
IGO Company LLC 390 390
The JEE Lite Ins Trust #3 206
3
20‘
Butterfly Trust 3
Total Cash 93,727,827 2,226,285 845,579 157,181 4,438,790 34,538,973 51,891 135,985,107
Purchase I Quantity 6130117 7131/17 Unrealized
Asset Description Date i Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Weer - Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7 9% Pfd 4/30/2049
JPM Tr Fit Rate Income Fund
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8%
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8%
05/10/11
01/22/13
3.000.000
240,973.957
-225.458
-133.856
83,332
3937,958
2.413.469
3058,000 _ 3 112 500
2,279,614 2,261,257
10/28/14 49,033.00 1,180 739 1,276,819 1,264.071
10/29/14 150,967.00 3,670,430 3,931,181 3,891,929 221,499
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000.00 1199419 2.337.610 2073/...630 368.211
Total Haze Trust- Fixed Income (DB) 12,602,016 12,964,867 12,915,744 313,728
Jeepers - Fixed incomr
JPM Trust FLT FIT Income fund 07/13/13 180,515.211 1 693a
1 693 923
1 707174
1,707,674
-97 307
Total Jeepers - Axed income (DB) 1,804,981 -97,307
r i e . - 4x • mom* ". • . n Stange
Western Digital Corp 7.375% Matures 4-1-2023 06/09/16 2 000 000 2 086 0 i ; 4.9 t;.- _ :I 158.161
Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 2,086,006 2,233,966 2,244,167 158,161
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB)
3.439,193 2.668.513 $60 lig
-660,107
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP cable 6/20/2019 4/15/14 2,000.000 _3,779.013
2,779,086 Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB) I 3,439,193 2 668 513
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merril)
Agergan mandatory convertible proffered 5.5%3/1/2016 08/15/16 1,000,000 881.500 867,410 894,010 12,510
LSCCOM 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 26,250,000 2,789,125 2,814889 2.850,774 61.649
Kindred Heston 7.25% 1/15/2020 STC ML 10/13/18 3,000.000 3,060,528 3,260,667 3,025667 44,862
Teva inarillatoryccevertible proffered 7.0% 12/15/2018
faitISOtithent  Trust Co. - Fixed income (Merrill) 08715/16.t. ...1,000.000_
L.
901,750
7,632,903
594.500
7,537,466
584.000 -317.750
7,354,451, -278,462
Southern Trutt CO. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred 525 pat 7/27/15 40,000 1 000 000 1.086.400 1.106.000 106,000
Annaly Cap Management 7/25/17 40 000 994 000 4,000 1 000 000
NGL Energy Partners 9%525 par 61/17 4 000 1.151.874 996800 3,200
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $2kpar 08/04/16 8,000 200,000 166,320 174,080 -25.920
Wells Fargo 5.7% Preferred $25 par 1/19/16 120.000 3,000,000 3,108.000 3,115,200 115,200
Ebay 6% Preferred $25 par matures 2-1.2056 2/22/16 80,000 2 000 000 2 189 600 2,166,400 166,400
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 8716/16 50D,000 500,000 530,000 548,300 48,300
Etrade Financial 5.875% faed to 9-15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 2,500.000 262, 3 122 2650.000 2,730,083 106,961
Royal Bank Scotland 7.64% Fixed to 9-294017 Fran 3M Libor +232Im 11/10/15 5.000.000 5,298,817 4,895,000 4,931,082 
467,735
Goldman Saths 6.375% FOAM to 6404030 then 392.2 one 3 motor 6f4/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 5 291 326 5,285.469 251,122
Capital One 5.55% Fixed to 9-1-2020 then 380 over 3 mo libor 5/14/15 3.000 000 1 413
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) f4,231,933 25 236 4141 670,310
I
I
Southern Rnancial LLC - Fixed Income (DB)
Bank olAmerica 8.125% PM Dec 29 204 1/10/11 2.000,000 2,055.000 2.100.013 ' 2,123.626 68,626
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10.2023
Citigroup Inc - Series Cl 5.95%
4/3/13 300,000
8/6/15 3,000000
i2/3/15 2.469,000
6/15/11 2.500,000
30.000
3,030,006
_ 2 175 016
2 687,500
317.167
3,223.598
2,485.460
2.631.667
316.919
3,238,968
. .
2.643.125
16919
238,
General Electric Co GTO Fixed to Float 4.0% Dee 152065_
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7-W -A-pril 30 2049
281,913
44,375
JP Morgan Chase 6 Co Pfd 7.916 /Vat .30 2049_____
LBG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49
6/15/11
5/21/13
2.500,000
1.903.000
3.000,000
2,675,000
1,948,500
2,996.074
2.631.667
2,100.446
3.400.104
2.643,125 31,875
2130,567 182,067
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,438 760 442,676
GMAC Cap TR I GTD PM Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80 000 1,862.774 2,096.00 2.12400 241.22e
Total Southern Financial LLC • Fixed income (09) 19 719 870 20,986,1$ 21,116,000 1,396,139
Southern Financial LLC .. Fixed Income (DB) [tangos
Washington Mutual hltg 2004-RA2 cl CBI var 7/25/2033 11119/13 562.781 939—.§19, _489.729 188.293 57.845
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 430,640 489,729 488,285 57,645
TOTAL AXED INCOME 72,381,714 72,806,515 73,841,829 1,480,116
Note • Accrued Interest mras boon inckided in month en MUNI income auras
Purchase Quantity I 6/30117 7131117 I Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value I Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
Akorn Inc.
Akbaba Group
Allianz SE ADR
6/10/15. "--
6/10/15
4/13/15
5.000 234.205
5.000 444.749
5.000 90.056
fa:VW -
704.500
98.875
_
' .:_1
774.750 I
106.750 .
434.?06
330,001
Apple Inc
Apple Inc
9/5/14 64.000
250.000
6.332.800 9,217,280 9,518,720 3,185,920
1/11/16 24,750.008 38,005000 37,182.500 12,432 494
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11. 263.157 4 999 983 6.960.503 7,394,712 2 394 729
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Barn 1.3.11) 1/16101i 70.500 151.575 164,970 -1,335.030 1,50000
Avalanche Biotechnologies now called Advorum Btotochnolowes 4/20/16 10,000 398,606 25,000 25,500 373,106
BASF ADR 4/13/15 5,000 508.056 466,450 476,350 -31,706
Bank of New York Mellon 6/25/14 250.000 9.076.406 12,755,000 -9,076,406
356.236 Biogen Idec Inc 2114/12 2,095 250,455 568,499 606.691
Bioverativ Inc OM 1,047 20,254 62,996 84,863 44.629
248,484 Centene Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1 242,134 1,234,981
Dish Network Corp 6/10/15 5,000 384,978 313,800 320,150 -44.828
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17500 665000 2642150 2961,875 2,296,875
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49830 1.265.037 1,980,743 1,781,491 496,454
General Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3.585,947 3406548 -3,565,947
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 496,109 621,230 -496,109
Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 5,000 396,407 353 900 380 450 -15,957
Gilead Sciences Inc 3/7/14 3,100 246,797 219,418 235,879
202,600
-10.918
-12,406 'Cie xo Smith Kline PLC 6/10/15 6,000 215,008 215 600
Global Partner Acquisition Corp 7/30/15 2.000 20,000 19,700 -20 000
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/15 700 14,000 29,694 30,086 16,086
Match 11/19/15 200 2,400 3,476 - -2,400
Mobileye NVAmstelveen Ord Shares 811/14 800 20,000 50,240 50,640 30,640
Square 11/19/15 200 1,800 3,476 -1,800
Sangamo Biosciences Inc 6/28/13 50 ,000 422,214 440,000 430,000 7,786
Santander Consumer USA 1/28/14 1 000 24 000 12 760 12 810 -11 190
larraform Global 7/31/15 400 6 2 20 -(000
Twitter Inc 11/7/13 1,500 39 000 26805 1 24,135 -14,865
Viacom Inc 8/10/15 5.000 338,745 167501 174.600 -164,145
Volkswagen AG
Wildocn1ree Investments Inc
4/13/15
3/31/15
5,000 254,306
15000 324,158
155,625
152 550
157,250 . ..._. ____
156.600
__ -97,056
z.16Z,556
Total eouthern Financial LLC • Equities (DB) 68,293,977 79,243,099 64,449,372 6,166,395
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
7/18/16
6/22/17
7/11/17
7/18/16
10/27/16
Barclays PLC ADR 100.000 805,096
5.000
2.000 617,135
100,000 1,137.626
3.500 69 250
2,628,107
1.059.000
161.500
-
1.460.000
48,860
1.073.000
622.560
. 1.535.000
52 430
267,904
_ 0
5,425
Alice
Natease.com Inc
Credit Suisse Group
ZTO Expiate 397156
374
654,883 Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,729,360 3,282,990
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill)_
Teradyhe Inc 7/20/17._- '
6120117
6/20/17
6/8/17
4/4/17
— 2800
8,000
i 704.832
487.600
. .0 -_ _ 691.800 -13,0g
0
14,200
-20.638
____
Moron technology 238 880
XLF Finanacial Sector 20,000 493,400 501,800
ON Semiconductor  12,000
25.000
200.038 1 80
-_873.5co —
68 4
434.750._
179,400
465.25 ING
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (titeryllti 1,765,970' 1,335,510 1,841,250 75,280
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (illsuge
ColtinycapislaCo_kmy NorthstarInct. ____
Sequential Brenda
270 Express
Bank of America
9/26/16
9/23/16
10/27/16
3/7/161
. . 73.315
50.000
1.150
7.500
928.837
402.134
22425
100,825
1.033.006
199.500
16,054
-- I:073,332  I
160,500
17,227
1:14:496
__241,634
-5,198
80.075 181.950 180,900
Eclitas Medicine 3/2/16 3,200 102,199 53.696 54,144 -48.055
',anoint Holdings 50.000 1.163.762 _.1.798.00Q .. 1.996.000 634,236
Total Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
J Epateln VI Foundation - Eqult es (DB)
2,720,182 3,282,208 3,484,103 763,920
-50.212
j0289
Bristol Myers Squibb 334,712 278.600
425000
284.500
' 274.825 Disney 0/30/ 285.025
Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 1  619,737 . _793,600 _ 659 325 .__ -60412
TOTAL EQUITIES 66,027,973 87,293,777 73,617 040 7,689,067
Southern Financial LLC - Equity EIT's (DB) I
Wlsdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60,000 2 968 099 3 120 000 3.1388001 121.901
Total Southern Financial LW - Equity ETF'S (DB) I 2,966,099 3 120 000 3 138 000i 171,901
Southern Financial Financial LLC - Options (DB)
Long FXE 113 Calls - exp Sep 15 2017 7119117i 450 36.006 0 98,550I 62,544
Short FXE 110 Puts - exp Sep 15 2017 7/19/171 (450) 41043 0 77.2QQ_ 460
Total Southern Financial LW - Options (08) 4,963 0 91,3501 86,387
6/30/17 7/31/17 MID YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern FinancialfSFLLQ added 10mm 3iii16
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 45.393.564 45.746.548 0.78% 4.19% *dried fenm 3trine
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 45,393,564 45,746,548 winanvlOmm WOW
weal immetment 40mm
2015 Mum 3.77%
Hedge Funds - Haze
King Street 3.516.505 3.648.710 20M117 mkt be dale:
Hedge Funds - Haze 3,516,505 3,648,710 3017 •aprp alum 4172111 5,47,954 paid
of capital of 7/27/10 6.102,124 paid
2.307403 10/27116 6,186,141 pale
4tle111.414 112787 3,99044 US
diarib000011 201$ return 4.ee%
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 22.545.473 23.660.296 4.94% 17.78% added 2Orrun 041/10
Total Hedge Funds - STC 22,545,473 23,660,296 2011 return 0.44%
Total Hedge Funds 71,455,541 73,055,554
. - . SFL
Mort Southern FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profit 0
Kyara II (investment amount) 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0 Kyara IV (Investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment rat at cost) 11,250,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,000 SIC
Adfin Solutions (investment amount) 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investmen amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston, NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase SIC 3,001,000
Spotify via Honeycomb 11 1,000,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Valar Global Fund II (amount funded vs 15mm committmen ) 13,650,000 000/24717 Is fl aws 5.8rown ommelued pis)
Valar Global Fund III (amount funded vs 25mm committment) 15,000,000 (80312017 le Sm. altrommteelimei 061)
Totals I 11 260 000 3,000,000 34,026,000 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total Investments 57,756,000
I Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description I Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 6,500,000 6,500,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 Plan D LLC 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 1,175,000 1,175.000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 2,500.000 6,500,000 250,000 17,625,000 26,875,000
hlto://www.espn.corninin/M0ryi jun20421 . .J•kvrin.wvintt-hoSIOn•Cellics-deal.unClvding•luaiali-Thomas 8/2207, 10:27 PM
Page 10 of 9
Asset Description JEE SFL STC FTRE Totals
Loans Receivable
Nina Keita 100,000 100,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100.000
Karyna 350,000 350,000
Nick Ribis 200,000 200,000
Larry / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22.446 22,446
David Mitchell 1,500,000 1,500,000
Anna 302,000 302,000
Harlequin Dane, LLC 4,750,000 4,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 1,500,000 1,500,000
Lesley 200,000 200,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
LV Home & Other 1,300,000 1 300 000
525.000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,822,446 6,450,000 0 1,935,000 11,207,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry haze trust
Giacometti (17,064,000 pounds @ 1.30) 22,183,200 22,183,200
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) -30,500,000 -30,500,000
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond • Insurance value 5,400,000 5,400.000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775.000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 -29,725,000 25,233,200 1,583,200
EFTA00811539 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2017-07-31)
Valuation Report
7/31/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - JULY 31, 2017
6130117 7/31/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash '127,228,936 135,985,107 8,756,171
Fixed Income 72,806,515 73,841,829 1,035,314
Equities 87,293,777 73,617,040 (13,676,737)
Equity ETF's 3,120,000 3,138,000 18,000
Options 0 91,350 91,350
Hedge Funds 71,455,541 73,055,554 1,600,012
Investments 52,506,000 57,756,000 5,250,000
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 26,875,000 26,875,000 -
Loans Receivable 11,207,446 11,207,446 -
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 123.200 1.583.200 Q
Total Assets 454,076,415 457,150,525 3,074,110
Cash Activity - Items over 50.000
STC ML - Sold 250,000 shares BK 51.84 12,955,276
STC ML - Sold 97,525 shares GM 35.592 3,471,110
STC ML - Sold 23,000 shares GE 25.4032 584,274
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 304,386
STC ML - Sold 8,000 shares MU 31.64 253,120
SFL DB - Sale of AKRX, GPACU, MTCH, SQ, GLBL 199,453
STC MS - Sold 6,484 NGL Energy Partners 24.81 160,858
Enhanced - Sold 1,500 Disney 159,804
STC MS - Sold 5,000 Mice 31.5484 157,532
Enhanced - BBB (25,000)
Legal - Erika Mapp Invoice (50,717)
Miscellaneous (76,715)
Enhanced - DPNR (160,000)
NES - Pinto 400k Euro (456,128)
SIC MS - Bought 2,000 NTES 308.5245 (617,049)
STC ML - Bought 20,000 shares TER 35.2016 (704,032)
STC MS - Bought 40,000 NLY 25.00 (1,000,000)
Spotify Investment via Honeycomb (1,000,000)
Monthly Spending (1,150,000)
Velar III Capital Call (4.250,000)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50 000 8,756,171
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan 10
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Stanley I Merrill Amentrs. Totals
. .._
58.184.007
Cash
Southern Must Company Inc. 21,524297 343.180 299,452 1.478.105 34.538.973
Haze Trust 34,019,367 34,019,367
Southern Financial LLC 28,971,578 51.891 29,023.267
JEE 4,539,461 743.738 456.950 5,740.149
Gratitude America, Ltd. 825,259 71606 — 2.060,885 3,657,750
Jeepers Inc, 1,475,399 7,853 1.483.252
963.188JEGE Inc. 963,188
LSJE LW 393,800 327.261
453.880
157.161 878221
Southern Country International LTG 40410
Zorro Management LLC 380,501 380 501
Plan D LLC 220,654 220,654
NES LLC 211,421 211,421
JEGE LLC 141,777 141,777
Enhanced Education 88,512 22.121 108.639
Hyperion Air LLC 100,292
--- 0,171
100,292
JEE - Paris (US 5) 89.177
Neptune LLC 69,063 69,063
Thomas World Air LLC 57.579 57.579
Cypress Inc
FT Real Estate
47.857
42.149
26.768
22.812
22.736
47,857
42,149
Maple Inc 26.768
Freedom Air Petroleum
Mrchelles Transportation Co LLC
22.812
22.736
Nautilus Inc
Great St Jim LLC
LSJ LLC
15.137
8.857
15,137
8,857
6.150 6,150
Mort Inc 4.853 4,853
Laurel Inc _____.
FSF LLC
4.070 4.070
9-3r 937
IGO Company LLC 390 390
The JEE Lite Ins Trust #3 206
3
20‘
Butterfly Trust 3
Total Cash 93,727,827 2,226,285 845,579 157,181 4,438,790 34,538,973 51,891 135,985,107
Purchase I Quantity 6130117 7131/17 Unrealized
Asset Description Date i Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Weer - Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7 9% Pfd 4/30/2049
JPM Tr Fit Rate Income Fund
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8%
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8%
05/10/11
01/22/13
3.000.000
240,973.957
-225.458
-133.856
83,332
3937,958
2.413.469
3058,000 _ 3 112 500
2,279,614 2,261,257
10/28/14 49,033.00 1,180 739 1,276,819 1,264.071
10/29/14 150,967.00 3,670,430 3,931,181 3,891,929 221,499
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000.00 1199419 2.337.610 2073/...630 368.211
Total Haze Trust- Fixed Income (DB) 12,602,016 12,964,867 12,915,744 313,728
Jeepers - Fixed incomr
JPM Trust FLT FIT Income fund 07/13/13 180,515.211 1 693a
1 693 923
1 707174
1,707,674
-97 307
Total Jeepers - Axed income (DB) 1,804,981 -97,307
r i e . - 4x • mom* ". • . n Stange
Western Digital Corp 7.375% Matures 4-1-2023 06/09/16 2 000 000 2 086 0 i ; 4.9 t;.- _ :I 158.161
Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 2,086,006 2,233,966 2,244,167 158,161
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB)
3.439,193 2.668.513 $60 lig
-660,107
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP cable 6/20/2019 4/15/14 2,000.000 _3,779.013
2,779,086 Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB) I 3,439,193 2 668 513
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merril)
Agergan mandatory convertible proffered 5.5%3/1/2016 08/15/16 1,000,000 881.500 867,410 894,010 12,510
LSCCOM 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 26,250,000 2,789,125 2,814889 2.850,774 61.649
Kindred Heston 7.25% 1/15/2020 STC ML 10/13/18 3,000.000 3,060,528 3,260,667 3,025667 44,862
Teva inarillatoryccevertible proffered 7.0% 12/15/2018
faitISOtithent  Trust Co. - Fixed income (Merrill) 08715/16.t. ...1,000.000_
L.
901,750
7,632,903
594.500
7,537,466
584.000 -317.750
7,354,451, -278,462
Southern Trutt CO. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred 525 pat 7/27/15 40,000 1 000 000 1.086.400 1.106.000 106,000
Annaly Cap Management 7/25/17 40 000 994 000 4,000 1 000 000
NGL Energy Partners 9%525 par 61/17 4 000 1.151.874 996800 3,200
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $2kpar 08/04/16 8,000 200,000 166,320 174,080 -25.920
Wells Fargo 5.7% Preferred $25 par 1/19/16 120.000 3,000,000 3,108.000 3,115,200 115,200
Ebay 6% Preferred $25 par matures 2-1.2056 2/22/16 80,000 2 000 000 2 189 600 2,166,400 166,400
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 8716/16 50D,000 500,000 530,000 548,300 48,300
Etrade Financial 5.875% faed to 9-15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 2,500.000 262, 3 122 2650.000 2,730,083 106,961
Royal Bank Scotland 7.64% Fixed to 9-294017 Fran 3M Libor +232Im 11/10/15 5.000.000 5,298,817 4,895,000 4,931,082 
467,735
Goldman Saths 6.375% FOAM to 6404030 then 392.2 one 3 motor 6f4/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 5 291 326 5,285.469 251,122
Capital One 5.55% Fixed to 9-1-2020 then 380 over 3 mo libor 5/14/15 3.000 000 1 413
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) f4,231,933 25 236 4141 670,310
I
I
Southern Rnancial LLC - Fixed Income (DB)
Bank olAmerica 8.125% PM Dec 29 204 1/10/11 2.000,000 2,055.000 2.100.013 ' 2,123.626 68,626
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10.2023
Citigroup Inc - Series Cl 5.95%
4/3/13 300,000
8/6/15 3,000000
i2/3/15 2.469,000
6/15/11 2.500,000
30.000
3,030,006
_ 2 175 016
2 687,500
317.167
3,223.598
2,485.460
2.631.667
316.919
3,238,968
. .
2.643.125
16919
238,
General Electric Co GTO Fixed to Float 4.0% Dee 152065_
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7-W -A-pril 30 2049
281,913
44,375
JP Morgan Chase 6 Co Pfd 7.916 /Vat .30 2049_____
LBG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49
6/15/11
5/21/13
2.500,000
1.903.000
3.000,000
2,675,000
1,948,500
2,996.074
2.631.667
2,100.446
3.400.104
2.643,125 31,875
2130,567 182,067
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,438 760 442,676
GMAC Cap TR I GTD PM Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80 000 1,862.774 2,096.00 2.12400 241.22e
Total Southern Financial LLC • Fixed income (09) 19 719 870 20,986,1$ 21,116,000 1,396,139
Southern Financial LLC .. Fixed Income (DB) [tangos
Washington Mutual hltg 2004-RA2 cl CBI var 7/25/2033 11119/13 562.781 939—.§19, _489.729 188.293 57.845
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 430,640 489,729 488,285 57,645
TOTAL AXED INCOME 72,381,714 72,806,515 73,841,829 1,480,116
Note • Accrued Interest mras boon inckided in month en MUNI income auras
Purchase Quantity I 6/30117 7131117 I Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value I Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
Akorn Inc.
Akbaba Group
Allianz SE ADR
6/10/15. "--
6/10/15
4/13/15
5.000 234.205
5.000 444.749
5.000 90.056
fa:VW -
704.500
98.875
_
' .:_1
774.750 I
106.750 .
434.?06
330,001
Apple Inc
Apple Inc
9/5/14 64.000
250.000
6.332.800 9,217,280 9,518,720 3,185,920
1/11/16 24,750.008 38,005000 37,182.500 12,432 494
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11. 263.157 4 999 983 6.960.503 7,394,712 2 394 729
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Barn 1.3.11) 1/16101i 70.500 151.575 164,970 -1,335.030 1,50000
Avalanche Biotechnologies now called Advorum Btotochnolowes 4/20/16 10,000 398,606 25,000 25,500 373,106
BASF ADR 4/13/15 5,000 508.056 466,450 476,350 -31,706
Bank of New York Mellon 6/25/14 250.000 9.076.406 12,755,000 -9,076,406
356.236 Biogen Idec Inc 2114/12 2,095 250,455 568,499 606.691
Bioverativ Inc OM 1,047 20,254 62,996 84,863 44.629
248,484 Centene Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1 242,134 1,234,981
Dish Network Corp 6/10/15 5,000 384,978 313,800 320,150 -44.828
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17500 665000 2642150 2961,875 2,296,875
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49830 1.265.037 1,980,743 1,781,491 496,454
General Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3.585,947 3406548 -3,565,947
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 496,109 621,230 -496,109
Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 5,000 396,407 353 900 380 450 -15,957
Gilead Sciences Inc 3/7/14 3,100 246,797 219,418 235,879
202,600
-10.918
-12,406 'Cie xo Smith Kline PLC 6/10/15 6,000 215,008 215 600
Global Partner Acquisition Corp 7/30/15 2.000 20,000 19,700 -20 000
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/15 700 14,000 29,694 30,086 16,086
Match 11/19/15 200 2,400 3,476 - -2,400
Mobileye NVAmstelveen Ord Shares 811/14 800 20,000 50,240 50,640 30,640
Square 11/19/15 200 1,800 3,476 -1,800
Sangamo Biosciences Inc 6/28/13 50 ,000 422,214 440,000 430,000 7,786
Santander Consumer USA 1/28/14 1 000 24 000 12 760 12 810 -11 190
larraform Global 7/31/15 400 6 2 20 -(000
Twitter Inc 11/7/13 1,500 39 000 26805 1 24,135 -14,865
Viacom Inc 8/10/15 5.000 338,745 167501 174.600 -164,145
Volkswagen AG
Wildocn1ree Investments Inc
4/13/15
3/31/15
5,000 254,306
15000 324,158
155,625
152 550
157,250 . ..._. ____
156.600
__ -97,056
z.16Z,556
Total eouthern Financial LLC • Equities (DB) 68,293,977 79,243,099 64,449,372 6,166,395
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
7/18/16
6/22/17
7/11/17
7/18/16
10/27/16
Barclays PLC ADR 100.000 805,096
5.000
2.000 617,135
100,000 1,137.626
3.500 69 250
2,628,107
1.059.000
161.500
-
1.460.000
48,860
1.073.000
622.560
. 1.535.000
52 430
267,904
_ 0
5,425
Alice
Natease.com Inc
Credit Suisse Group
ZTO Expiate 397156
374
654,883 Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,729,360 3,282,990
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill)_
Teradyhe Inc 7/20/17._- '
6120117
6/20/17
6/8/17
4/4/17
— 2800
8,000
i 704.832
487.600
. .0 -_ _ 691.800 -13,0g
0
14,200
-20.638
____
Moron technology 238 880
XLF Finanacial Sector 20,000 493,400 501,800
ON Semiconductor  12,000
25.000
200.038 1 80
-_873.5co —
68 4
434.750._
179,400
465.25 ING
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (titeryllti 1,765,970' 1,335,510 1,841,250 75,280
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (illsuge
ColtinycapislaCo_kmy NorthstarInct. ____
Sequential Brenda
270 Express
Bank of America
9/26/16
9/23/16
10/27/16
3/7/161
. . 73.315
50.000
1.150
7.500
928.837
402.134
22425
100,825
1.033.006
199.500
16,054
-- I:073,332  I
160,500
17,227
1:14:496
__241,634
-5,198
80.075 181.950 180,900
Eclitas Medicine 3/2/16 3,200 102,199 53.696 54,144 -48.055
',anoint Holdings 50.000 1.163.762 _.1.798.00Q .. 1.996.000 634,236
Total Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
J Epateln VI Foundation - Eqult es (DB)
2,720,182 3,282,208 3,484,103 763,920
-50.212
j0289
Bristol Myers Squibb 334,712 278.600
425000
284.500
' 274.825 Disney 0/30/ 285.025
Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 1  619,737 . _793,600 _ 659 325 .__ -60412
TOTAL EQUITIES 66,027,973 87,293,777 73,617 040 7,689,067
Southern Financial LLC - Equity EIT's (DB) I
Wlsdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60,000 2 968 099 3 120 000 3.1388001 121.901
Total Southern Financial LW - Equity ETF'S (DB) I 2,966,099 3 120 000 3 138 000i 171,901
Southern Financial Financial LLC - Options (DB)
Long FXE 113 Calls - exp Sep 15 2017 7119117i 450 36.006 0 98,550I 62,544
Short FXE 110 Puts - exp Sep 15 2017 7/19/171 (450) 41043 0 77.2QQ_ 460
Total Southern Financial LW - Options (08) 4,963 0 91,3501 86,387
6/30/17 7/31/17 MID YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern FinancialfSFLLQ added 10mm 3iii16
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 45.393.564 45.746.548 0.78% 4.19% *dried fenm 3trine
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 45,393,564 45,746,548 winanvlOmm WOW
weal immetment 40mm
2015 Mum 3.77%
Hedge Funds - Haze
King Street 3.516.505 3.648.710 20M117 mkt be dale:
Hedge Funds - Haze 3,516,505 3,648,710 3017 •aprp alum 4172111 5,47,954 paid
of capital of 7/27/10 6.102,124 paid
2.307403 10/27116 6,186,141 pale
4tle111.414 112787 3,99044 US
diarib000011 201$ return 4.ee%
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 22.545.473 23.660.296 4.94% 17.78% added 2Orrun 041/10
Total Hedge Funds - STC 22,545,473 23,660,296 2011 return 0.44%
Total Hedge Funds 71,455,541 73,055,554
. - . SFL
Mort Southern FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profit 0
Kyara II (investment amount) 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0 Kyara IV (Investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment rat at cost) 11,250,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,000 SIC
Adfin Solutions (investment amount) 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investmen amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston, NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase SIC 3,001,000
Spotify via Honeycomb 11 1,000,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Valar Global Fund II (amount funded vs 15mm committmen ) 13,650,000 000/24717 Is fl aws 5.8rown ommelued pis)
Valar Global Fund III (amount funded vs 25mm committment) 15,000,000 (80312017 le Sm. altrommteelimei 061)
Totals I 11 260 000 3,000,000 34,026,000 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total Investments 57,756,000
I Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description I Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 6,500,000 6,500,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 Plan D LLC 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 1,175,000 1,175.000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 2,500.000 6,500,000 250,000 17,625,000 26,875,000
hlto://www.espn.corninin/M0ryi jun20421 . .J•kvrin.wvintt-hoSIOn•Cellics-deal.unClvding•luaiali-Thomas 8/2207, 10:27 PM
Page 10 of 9
Asset Description  JEE SFL STC FTRE Totals
Loans icervable
100,000 100,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100.000
Karyna 350,000 350,000
Nick Ribis 200,000 200,000
Larry / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
David Mitchell 1,500,000 1,500,000
302,000 302,000
Harlequin Dane, LLC 4,750,000 4,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 1,500,000 1,500,000
Lesley 200,000 200,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
LV Home & Other 1,300,000 1,300.000
525.000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,822,446 6,450,000 0 1,935,000 11,207,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry haze bus
Giacometti (17,064,000 pounds @ 1.30) 22,183,200 22,183,200
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LW) -30,500,000 -30,500,000
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - Insurance value 5,400,000 5,400.000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775.000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 -29,725,000 25,233,200 1,583,200
EFTA01286953 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2017-07-31)
Deutsche Bank El
Deutsche Bank Must Co. Americas
345 Park Avenue - NYC20-0102
New York. NY 10154
St/1 I I tERN TRUSTCOMPANY. INC.
6100 RED 1100E QUARTER B3
ST THOMAS
00802
UNITED STATES VI
July 1.2017 to July 31. 2017
Summary of Accourt1 Balance(s)
Account
Elite Money Market Deposit
Beginning Balance a of July I. 2017
Deposits and Other Credit,
Checks Paid
A.13.1 and Debit Card Withdrawals
Service Charges and Other Fees
Other Debits
Ending Balance as of July 31. 2017
Balance
S2.66 I. 352.64
510.909.210.55
52.122.09
50.00
50.00
50.00
(S&250,000.00 )
S2.661.352.64
For personal assistance call:
i s m
Transaction Detail
Dale Description Debit Credit Balance
Beginning Balance a of ink 1. 2017 510,909,230.55
07.10 0 Outgoing Money (1,000,000.00 ) 9,909,230.55
To JPMORGAN 11.‘NK, NA AC 70112
6687 IIONLY0011.111 \ 'EN ORES I LP
07-24 N Cash Mani Trai Dr (1000,000.00 ) 6,909,230.55
REF 20514471. FUNDS TRANSFER TO
DEP 35269691 FROM
07-24 N Outgoing Money Tmsf (4,250.000.00 ) 2459.230.55
TO SILICON VALLEY BANK AC 330152042
7 VALAR OLOB.AAL FUND III LP
07-31 # Interest Payment 2.122.09 2.661.352.64
Ending Balance a of July 31. 2017 (8.250.000.00 ) $2.122.09 S2.661.352.64
All items are credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceeds in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
44129244
I of 3 SONY_GM_00043583
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0006407
Deutsche Bank
Deposits and Oilier Cnxtits
bate lkscription
07-31 Interest Pasment
Amount
52.122.09
Service Charges and Other Fees
Total NSF mum item fees for this statement period 5000
Total NSF mum item toes for this calendar sear $0.00
Total (kerdrall foes for this statement period 50 .00
Total (hertfrall fees for this calendar year S0.00
Other Debits
Date Description Amount
07-10 Outgoing Stoney Tmsf 61.0000)0.00 )
07-24 Cash klym Trsfr l)r (S3.000.000.00 )
07-24 Outgoing Monet Tritsi 154.250.000.00 )
Interest Cakulation
Annual Percentage Yield Earned 0.30°
[merest Earned 'Ibis Period $2.122.09
interest Paid Year TO Rile S14.14718
All items an credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceeds in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
44129244
2 ofd SDNY_GM_00043584
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0006408
Deutsche Bank
In Case of Furors or Questions

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at 1-866-362-4796. or write to us at Deutsche Rank Trust Company Americas. 345 Park Avenue. WNI Banking 
Team -
NYC20-0102. New York Na. York 10154 as soon as you can. if you think your statement or receipt is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MUST hear front you no later than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRSTstatement on which the error or problem appeared.

• Tell us your name and account number
- Describe the error or transfer you arc unsure about. and explain as clearly as you can why you believe it is an error 
or why you
need more information
- Tell in the dollar amount of the suspected error
Please note that if you initially provide the above information to If% via telephone. we may require that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within ID business days.
We will investigate your complaint and will correct any enor promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 
business days for
new accounts) to do this, we will provisionally credit your account for the amount you think is in error. so that you 
will have the use of
the money during the time it takes us to complete our investigation. At the conclusion of our investigation. we will 
info= you of our
results.
1 Non-Electronic Funds Transfers
Contact the Bank immediately at 1-866-362-4796 if your statement is incorrect or if you need mole information about any 
non-electronic
funds Introadions (checks or deposits) on this statement. If any such error appears. you must notify the Bank in writing
no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you. Please see your Tennis and Conditions for further information on 
the tens
governing your account.

3. Verifying Preauthorized Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once every 60 days from the same person or 
compass> you
can telephone us at 1.866.362.4796 to find out whether the deposit has been made.
I I I .7.‘•2 I SDNY_GM_00043585
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) CS -SONY -0006409
EFTA00591792 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2017-08-03)
VALAR VLNYURLU
Valor Global Fund III LP Capital Call
July 20, 2017
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund III LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $4,250,000.00, which represents 17% of your total commitment
of $25,000,000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Thursday August 3, 2017.
After this capital contribution, you will hove contributed 60% of your total commitment with a
remaining 40% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of August 3, 2017:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$25,000,000.00
$15,000,000.00
$10,000,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Thursday August 3, 2017
$4,250,000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
121140399
Valor Global Fund III LP
3301520427
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
reuben@valar.com.
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Valor Ventures LLC 915 Broadway Suite 1101 New York, New York 10010 www.volor.eom
EFTA00810358 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2017-08-03)
VALAR VLNYUNLU
Valor Global Fund III LP Capital Call
July 20, 2017
Dear Southern Trust Company. Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund III LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $4,250.000.00, which represents 17% of your total commitment
of $25,000.000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Thursday August 3, 2017.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 60% of your total commitment with a
remaining 40% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of August 3, 2017:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$25,000,000.00
$15,000,000.00
$10,000,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Thursday August 3, 2017
$4.250.000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
Valor Global Fund III LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Valor Ventures LLC 915 Bloodwoy SUNS 1101 New York, New York 10010 www.volor.com
EFTA01618446 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2017-08-24 17:18:45)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
2017/07/21
Sneaky dog!!!
10:57:05 pin
Yay!!!
10:57:13 pm
We just talked about it today and I checked my mail came today
10:57:37 pm
1212 5333739
Yay
10:58:22 pm2017/07/28
Or :26:58 am
Not sure what to respond but I am not interested working in his firm but the
government...
01:27:50 am
2017/08/01
11:39:41 pm
Came back from
11:39:59 pm
thank you sneaky! *4
1212 5333739
if you're happy it looks great
11:40:10 pm
I am, thank you! The final result will be after I wash my hair. it will have some volume
and won't be so straight but leave a shine and reduce fuzziness
11:42:44 pm
They just straightened them by a flat iron
11:43:14 pin
2017/08/03
•
•
Are you very busy bye 1:30-4pm?
03:46:52 pin
1212 5333739
Free
03:47:11 pm
I actually can come now on my lunch break and leave earlier. Is ok?
03:57:05 pin
1212 5333739
Ok
03:57:25 pm
Will pass by grand central would you like your favorite bread?
03:57:56 pm
Where did you leave to
06:40:38 pin
Sneaky could I ask bella to transfer money today for this month and a little extra for
the Hamptons (Friday-Monday)? I mean if you could email her be she asks for your
confirmation. I am not sure if you want just add money to a transfer or used Amex
card for food and taxi there? I promise not to use it for anything else if it is a subject of
possible concern
07:45:09 pin
Just checked his office. His secretary said he is out at the meeting and should be back
around 4:30 pm I will check again when he comes back and let him know
07:56:06 pin
is not at the office either... might be with him
07:56:37 pin
Just spoke a he said you said to come at 5 pm not 6:30 so he is shortly on his
way
08:35:01 pm
t
Thank you for V!! `4
08:39:46 pm
What time do you leave today?
01:19:12 pm
Ok
01:40:17 pin
2017/08/04
1212 5333739
Ok
08:37:29 pm
1212 5333739
11
01:21:45 pm
2017/08/06
•
•
We missed you! Thank you
11:54:12 pm
12:24:55 am
I lost you
09:26:25 pm
2017/08/07
2017/08/08
1212 5333739
nice
11:54:12 pm
Sneaky forgot to say that when I call, you are unreachable. It sends me right away to
your voice mail. Just in case if you didn't do it on purpose and expecting someone's call
(TA,
09:33:49 pm
2017/08/23

• Sneaky dog, I miss you so much! %%when am I seeing you again? vi
03:56:34 pm
One more week it
04:07:19 pm
1212 5333739
wednesday
04:01:27 pm
1212 5333739
Yup
04:19:52 pm
Sneaky, I filling out employee enrollment form for health care. Should I list my wife as a
dependent?
06:45:54 pm
Ok
1212 5333739
no
06:46:09 pm
06:46:13 pm
Will be dr Merell and Dr. Magnani listed as my primary care and dental care doctors?
06:48:08 pm
Ok, thank you!
06:48:38 pm
2017/08/24
05:18:45 pm
✓ Read
1212 5333739
Yes
06:48:25 pm
1212 5333739
77
05:42:55 pm
✓ Sent
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                              BVI [usvi] British Virgin Islands, infamous offshore tax haven 
 Bin Ennakhill [real estate] palace in Morocco that Epstein was in the process of purchasing 
            Kensington Luxury Properties [real estate] broker handling sale of Bin Ennakhill 
                Marc Leon [real estate] Epstein's realtor in Morocco, Luxury Properties Sari 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00585171 (Jmail)
 [money] purchase of Bin Ennakhill palace in Marrakech
(inferred date: 2017-08-30)
SALE AND SHARE TRANSFER AGREEMENT
between
RILTON INVESTMENTS LTD., BVI, ARCANA TREUHAND ANSTALT Lawenastrasse 57, FL 9495 Triesen,
Principality of Liechtenstein
represented by:
Dr hirgen RIEGEL
(the 'SELLER')
and
represented by:
.... (Power of Attorney, dated ..., Exhibit 2)
(the 'BUYER')
as follows:

1. Preamble
The PAMUR Anstalt with its registered address c/o Arcana Treuhand Anstalt, Lawenastrasse 57, FL 9495 Triesen,
Principality of Liechtenstein, (which founder rights are the object of the purchase) is an establishment under the
laws of Liechtenstein and registered in the Liechtenstein Commercial Register under number FL-0001.115.138-1
(hereinafter also referred to as the 'COMPANY').
The SELLER holds 100% of the founder rights (the 'shares') in the COMPANY.
The BUYER intends to purchase from the SELLER all shares in the COMPANY, and the SELLER intends to sell to
the BUYER all shares in the COMPANY.
Now therefore, in consideration of the above, the Parties agree as follows:

2. Obiect of Purchase
Subject-matter of the Sale and Share Transfer Agreement (hereinafter referred to as the 'AGREEMENT') are all
shares which the SELLER holds in the COMPANY, hence the shares which represent a fully paid-up initial
contribution in the nominal value of CHF 30'000.00 (say: Swiss Francs thirtythousand) and thus representing
100% of the COMPANY's share capital (hereinafter also referred to as the 'SHARE').

3. Purchase and Transfer
Subject to the terms and conditions hereof, the SELLER sells and assigns to BUYER and BUYER purchases and
accepts from the SELLER the SHARE along with all rights and obligations.

4. Effective Date
The BUYER will legally transfer the SHARE to the BUYER concurrently with the payment of the purchase price
irrevocably accredited to the SELLER's account on Closing Date (this is 30 August 2017; see para. 12 of this
AGREEMENT; hereinafter referred to as the 'Closing Date').
On Closing Date, any risk and benefit relating to the SHARE shall transfer to the BUYER, unless the AGREEMENT
provides otherwise.

5. Purchase Price
The purchase price for the Share is € 25'000'000.00 (say: Euro twentyfivemillion).
6. Payment of Purchase Price
The purchase price shall be paid until latest 30 August 2017 in such a way that the SELLER will be able to dispose
of the purchase price unconditionally. The purchase price will be irrevocably and free of any expense accredited
to the following SELLER's account

7. SELLER's Representations and Warranties
In connection with the sale and transfer of the SHARE, the SELLER warrants to the BUYER exclusively that the
following declarations, statements and covenants are true on the date of signing hereof and on the Closing Date:

(1) The COMPANY is an establishment duly organized and existing under the laws of Liechtenstein.
(2) The COMPANY's share capital is fully paid up in cash. No contributions are payable by or were called from
shareholders.

(3) No contributions were repaid or otherwise refunded to the SELLER.
(4) The SELLER is the sole legal and beneficial owner of the SHARE.

(5) The SHARE passes to the BUYER on Closing Date free and clear of any encumbrances or of any rights of
third parties, in particular the Share is not subject to any lien or any other security rights.

(6) All shares of all subsidiaries are free and clear of any encumbrances or of any rights of third parties, in
particular the shares are not subject to any lien or any other security rights.
(7)
(B)
(9)
The SELLER is not subject to any restrictions in connection with disposing of the SHARE, and the transfer
thereof is not subject to any consent of a third party.
The SHARE is not subject to any options, shareholder agreements or similar restrictions.
Except for the SELLER, no third party holds any rights in the COMPANY, and there are no silent
participations, sub-participations or similar rights in the COMPANY.

(10) The COMPANY is not in liquidation. The COMPANY is neither insolvent nor over indebted nor was a petition
for bankruptcy or composition filed or relevant proceedings initiated. The SELLER is not aware of any
proceedings initiated by authorities to dissolve the COMPANY.

(11) The COMPANY and its subsidiaries hold all respective necessary public-law authorizations, permits,
concessions, licenses or similar.
$. BUYER's Representations and Warranties
The BUYER has authority to execute and perform this AGREEMENT, and after the signing hereof, this
AGREEMENT shall constitute a valid obligation on the part of the BUYER.
9. Liability and Limitation of Liability
The BUYER has received from the broker Marc Leon, Kensington Luxury Properties (the 'BROKER'), all necessary
information regarding all factual and legal qualities of the COMPANY and its assets.
The BUYER has further inspected all the assets of the COMPANY, in the main the real estate property known as
Bin Ennakhil in Marrakech / Morocco. By signing this AGREEMENT, the BUYER confirms that he explicitly
restrains from receiving further information or documentation regarding the COMPANY or its assets.
As a result of the review and evaluation of the DOCUMENTATION-information provided by the BROKER  and
inspection to the assets of the COMPANY and its subsidiaries (MABARA ESTABLISHMENT  PAMUR ANSTALT}
the BUYER hereby confirms to have best knowledge of the factual and legal qualities and of the value of the
COMPANY, its subsidiaries and their assets.
The SELLER shall be liable to the BUYER hereunder only for a breach of the representations and warranties
issued hereunder and only subject to the following provisions and limitations. Any further claims of the BUYER
related to the factual or legal qualities of the SHARE or the COMPANY shall be expressly excluded.
The Parties waive the right to rescind this AGREEMENT on the grounds of, or to assert by way of defense, error,
laesio enormis or frustration of contract or to assert any price reduction or an adjustment of this AGREEMENT
for any of these reasons.
In case of a breach of any of the representations and warranties issued hereunder (hereinafter also referred to
as 'DEFECT'), the BUYER shall be required to give a maximum of 7 day? notice to the SELLER, stating the DEFECT
and requesting the SELLER to remedy the DEFECT and establishing the warranted status (restitution in kind —
Noturalrestitution).
The burden to prove any DEFECT shall lie with the BUYER.
Liability for any breach of warranties as set forth herein shall be excluded, provided that the facts which are
asserted within the scope of the BUYER's warranty claims are or were public domain or were disclosed in writing
to the BUYER or its advisors in-the-course-of-the-clue-cliligence-review r in-the-DOCUME-NTAT4ON-or-by the
BROKER or by the  officers or:representatives or advisors of the COMPANY or the SELLER.
The BUYER may not assert warranty claims against the SELLER, unless such warranty claims are asserted within
30 days after the CLOSING in court proceedings.

10. Conduct of Business between Signing and Closing
The SELLER undertakes to procure that the COMPANY's operations are conducted within the scope of its
ordinary course of business consistent with previous practice, dividends are not distributed and corporate
restructuring measures not implemented between the signing of the AGREEMENT (also referred to as 'Signing')
and the Closing Date. To the extent the COMPANY intends to conduct any business between the Signing date
and the Closing Date which is not part of the COMPANY's ordinary course of business or which exceeds a total
value of EUR 100'000.00, the SELLER will promptly give notice to the BUYER.

11. Removal of Antiques, Works of Art, Paintings, Personal Items
The BUYER takes notice and accepts that all antiques, works of art, paintings and any other personal items on
the real estate properties in or on Bin Ennakhil in Marrakech / Morocco are personal property of Gunter and/or
Barbel Kiss and that these items are not sold respectively do not form part of the object of purchase (as defined
in para. 4 of the AGREEMENT). Hence, the BUYER takes notice and accepts that Gunter and/or Barbel Kiss (or
their representatives) will remove all antiques, works of art, paintings and any other personal items from the
real estate properties Bin Ennakhil in Marrakech / Morocco, within 4 (four) weeks after the Closing Date.
For this purpose the BUYER any time will grant Gunter and/or Barbel Kiss or their representatives access to the
said real estate properties.

12. Closing
The transfer of the SHARE described herein will take place in Vaduz/Principality of Liechtenstein on 30 August
2017 provided that the purchase price has been accredited on the accounts of the SELLER (see para. 4 'Effective
Date') (hereinafter also the 'Closing').
On the Closing Date, the SELLER will deliver to the BUYER the following:

(1) A current confirmation that all representation and warranties issued by the SELLER are effective and
correct also on the Closing Date (see draft - Exhibit 3);

(2) The signed letters of resignation of the COMPANY's officers (see draft - Exhibit 4);
(3) A Deed of Assignment regarding all shares in the COMPANY (Exhibit 5).
All benefits and obligations relating to the AGREEMENT become void, unless the SELLER can freely dispose of the
purchase price latest on CLOSING DATE i.e. 30 August 2017 according to para. 6 of the AGREEMENT.

13. Confidentiality
The PARTIES undertake not to discuss with or to disclose to or otherwise inform third parties of any trade secrets
or other confidential information of the COMPANY, the products and services, financial information, Employees,
customers and suppliers of the COMPANY.
The Parties agree not to disclose the contents of this AGREEMENT to third parties and keep confidential any
information disclosed in this context, unless disclosure is required by mandatory laws or necessary to prove the
existence or non-existence of a right in legal proceedings. The Parties will procure that the COMPANY, its
management, its employees and its consultants will comply with this confidentiality obligation.

14. Expenses
Either Party shall bear its own costs arising in connection with the preparation, negotiation, execution, and
performance of this AGREEMENT, including but not limited to all legal fees, auditor's fees and other professional
fees.
Costs for all of the BUYER'S investigations and examinations of the COMPANY, including expenses of the
commercial, legal, tax, and technical due diligence review, shall exclusively be borne by the BUYER.
The BUYER undertakes to fully bear all taxes, duties, and levies arising out of or in connection with the
transactions described herein.
15. General Provisions
All Exhibits to this AGREEMENT shall form integral parts hereof as if fully set forth herein. This AGREEMENT and
all Exhibits thereof shall comprise the entire understanding between the Parties regarding the transaction
contemplated therein, and there are no other agreements, representations and warranties or obligations
between the Parties except for those expressly provided for herein.
Any amendment of this AGREEMENT shall be made by an instrument in writing bearing the legal signatures of
the Parties or their respective successors. This applies also to any waiver of the written form requirement.
Headings of sections and paragraphs in this AGREEMENT and its Exhibits are for convenience only and do not
affect the interpretation of its provisions.
The AGREEMENT was concluded for the benefit of the respective Parties and their permitted successors, but not
for the benefit of third parties.
Should one or several provisions hereof be or become invalid or ineffective, these provisions shall not be
applied. This shall not affect the validity and effectiveness of the remaining provisions hereof. The non-
applicable provisions shall be replaced by provisions that best reflect the contents and meaning of the valid
provisions hereof and the intention of the parties. The same applies, by analogy, to any gap in this AGREEMENT.
All notices and declarations of either Party shall be given in writing and be addressed as follows:
if to SELLER: RILTON INVESTMENTS LTD., BVI, c/o ARCANA TREUHAND ANSTALT Lawenastrasse 57, FL
9495 Triesen, Principality of Liechtenstein
with a copy to: DR. THOMAS STRUTH, Kieber Nuener Struth - Attorneys at Law, Austrasse 56, FL 9490 Vaduz,
Principality of Liechtenstein
if to BUYER:
with a copy to: Marc Leon, Kensington Luxury Properties, Avenue Yacoub El Mansour Marrakech, Morocco
This AGREEMENT is drawn up in two counterparts, one counterpart intended for either Party. Each counterpart
shall be deemed an original.

16. Applicable Law and Jurisdiction
This AGREEMENT and all its Exhibits shall be governed by and construed in accordance with Liechtenstein law, to
the exclusion of the conflict of law rules of Liechtenstein international private law.
All disputes, disagreements or any claim arising from this AGREEMENT or its Exhibits or relating to this
AGREEMENT or its Exhibits, its conclusion, violation, dissolution or invalidity shall be exclusively referred to the
Princely District Court of Vaduz/Principality of Liechtenstein.
Vaduz, .. August 2017
SELLER: RILTON INVESTMENTS LTD., By!
BUYER:
Exhibits:
Exhibit 1: Power of Attorney, dated
Exhibit 2: Power of Attorney, dated Exhibit 3: Draft confirmation that all
representation and warranties issued by the SELLER are effective and
correct also on the Closing Date
Exhibit 4: Draft letters of resignation of the COMPANY's officers
Exhibit S: Copy draft Deed of Assignment regarding all shares in the COMPANY
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Miroslav Lajčák [europe] Russia-friendly Slovakian national security advisor, friend of Steve Bannon [bbc] 
                                                                        Arline M. Toylo [employee] employee 
                                                                        Carluz N. Toylo [employee] employee 
  Dylan Love [journalist] Business Insider / The Next Web, financial support from Epstein via Masha Drokova 
                                    Jordan Josephson [medical] Epstein's doctor, brother of Barry Josephson 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00285408 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(date: 2017-10-01)
2017 October
Sun. Oct 1.2017 NY-PB
10:00am Appt w, friend) (M=)
1:51pm Carluz & Arline Toylo to arrive JFK via jetblue#154 (Rec. Loc#KYDQAA)
5:00pm to be picked up and taken to Teterboro (Carosa Confirm)
7:44pm Depart NY
9:56pm Arrive PB
Mon. Oct 2.2017 PB
9:00am Carluz and Arline Toylo at 71st for training (Carluz:
2:00pm Coq: Call w/Darren, Jack, Tonja and Chet
Toll-free dial-in number (U.S. and Canada):
Conference code.
8:50pa to arrive NY! (she will stay in
Tues. Oct 3, 2017 PB
Reminder: Nathan Myhrvold in NY Oct 3-11
Reminder: Jojo off today and tomorrow for days owed
Reminder off today for day owed
7:30am to depart PB via Delta #2281 (Rec. Loc#HCXBDW) Carosa for
pick up
1:30pato arrive PB via Delta #898 (Rec. Loc#USZULT)
3:30pm PHONE DATE w/Dylan Love (M=)
6:30pm Appt w/Dr. Moskowitz at HMF Restaurant (MM)
Wed. Oct 4, 2017 PB
Reminder: Exterminator for the apartments
10:00am SKYPE w/Barnaby and Gerd (Barnaby
1:30pm Appt w/Dr. Bard ( 1)
6:00pm SKYPE w/Joi Ito (MM) Skype NameM
Thurs. Oct. 5. 2017 PB-LSJ-NY
Reminder: Merwin out today (H.. at )
8:09am Depart PB (G550 N415LM)
10:28am Arrive LSJ
5:49pm Depart LSJ
9:12pm Arrive NY (Islip)
Fri. Oct. 6. 2017 NY
Reminder: Ehud and Nili return to NY early afternoon
Reminder: Jack Goldberger in NY Oct. 6-9, staying in apt 3M
Reminder: Merwin's birthday!
12:30pm Phone Date w/Paul Morris (a)
1:00pm Appt w/Jack Goldberger & Darren (Jack
2:00pm Appt w
4:00pm Appt w/Barry Josephson (MM)
4:00pm Appt w/M(aI)
4:30pm Appt w/Boris Nikolic (MM)
5:00pm ZOOM Interview w/Bryan Johnson and possibly Masha
9:00pm Carosa to pick up from 71st and take her to JFK
11:55pn to depart JFK via XL Airways 51 (Rec. Loc#DXYVIX)
,Sat. Oct 7. 2017 NY
9:00am BREAKFAST w/Ehud
1:00pm LUNCH w/Miroslav Lajcak (M=)
2:00pm Appt w/Nathan Myhrvold
Sun. Oct. 8. 2017 NY
Mon. Oct 9, 2017 NY-Paris
Reminder: COLUMBUS DAY-Office and STC are closed
Reminder: Ehud and Nili depart to Boston flight at noon
7:38am Depart NY
7:51pm Arrive Paris (new G550 plane,
Tues. Oct 10.2017 Paris
10:45am Paris Time to arrive Paris CDG via AeroflotI/4427 (Rec.
Loc#ZEXCHJ)
Wed. Oct 11.2017 Paris
Reminder: Birthday
Reminder: 5:29pm to depart JFK via AA#177 to San Fran (Rec. Loc#SHJOTW)
Reminder: TBLao depart today
5:30pm Paris Time SKYPE w/Jeff Tolle son Nature Correspondent) and Masha.
Masha will initiate (Masha Skype ID: 11:30am EST
Thurs. Oct. 12, 2017 Pads
Reminder: 8am to fly to PB via Delta #2358 (Rec Loc#DLRCMI) She will take
Thurs and Fri off for days owed.
Reminder: Jojo off today and tomorrow for days owed
Reminder: Carluz & Arline to fly to PB, return Monday morning
Reminder: Misha Gromov to go watch Woody Aliens shoot to escort him)
CANCELLED 9:30am
(Rec. Loc#RUREWK)
to arrive Paris CDG via Ural Airlines #709
9:35am to depart Paris CDG via AirFrance#1044 (Rec. Loc#ZEXCHJ)
Fri. Oct. 13. 2017 Paris
Reminder: at Loro Piana's birthday-roses to be sent w/Thanks & Happy Bday
(From Jerome Florist
Reminder: Call Dr. Robert Friedman(optometrist) ( 1
2017 Part
Reminder:
Reminder: to fly to Tampa at 1:58pm via AA#943 to Miami, then M#2444 to
Tampa (Rec. Loc#YPVXKF)
CANCELLED 3:11pm to take the train to Geneva then car service on to Glion
6:10pm to arrive Paris CDG via Finnair#873 (Rec. Loc#JLVOLE)
Sun. Oct 15.2017 Paris
Reminder: Charlie Albright playing in Boston
12:55p to depart Paris CDG via AF#1744 (Rec. Loc#JZAZBF)
Mon. Oct 16. 2017 Paris
Reminder: to work w . today at the PB house
Reminder. to fly Ekaterinburg to Moscow via Aeroflot#1413, stay
at Park Inn Hotel (Rec Loc.#BQIYMO)
2:00pm to depart Paris CDG via Aeroflot#2455 (Rec. Loc#JLVOLE)
2:40pm to arrive Paris CDG via Aeroflot#2462 (Rec. Loc#COBMWG)
Tues. Oct 17. 2017 Paris
Reminder: 7a,:  to arrive JFK via Delta #1908 from LA (QQOZLS)
Reminder: to fly back to STT via Delta 2137 at 7:20am through Atlanta arriving
STT 1:25pm Delta#571 Rec. Loc#YPVXJF)
Reminder: to fly Moscow to Lisbon via Aeroflot #2606 (Rec
Loc#PXWYZa
Reminder. to fly Moscow to Geneva via SU#2382 depart 6:10pm arrive 9:50pm
(Rec. Loc then take car service to Glion (Blacklane Limo,
Confirm
9:15pm Ion Nicola to arrive JFK via AF#8 (Rec. Loc#BOJMEC)
Wed. Oct 18, 2017 Paris
9:35a in to depart Paris CDG via Aeroflot #3001 (Rec. Loc#COBMWG)
Thurs. Oct 19. 2017 Paris
Reminder: Bobby Slayton in NY Oct 19-27
Reminder: Yoni to depart NY today (we will have apt 10B back)
Fri. Oct. 20, 2017 Paris -NY
Reminder: Leon Botstein's dress rehearsal today at Bard 1:30-5pm
8:00am Depart Paris
9:27am Arrive NY, Teterboro
11:30am Appt w/Dr. Friedman for contacts (IM=)
1001 Park Ave, between 80 and Park
1010 TO DRIVE YOU!
3:00pm Haircut w/Patrick at Fekkai Salon (MM)
1010 to drive you unless otherwise instructed
7:00pm DINNER w Woody Allen and Dick Cavett (maybe Ron Lauder?)
Soon Yi: Dick:
Sat. Oct. 21.2017 NY
Reminder: Leon Botstein's concert 8pm @ The Richard B. Fisher Center for the
Performing Arts (Sosnoff Theater), Bard College
Reminder: Ito depart today (we will have apt 7] back) she departs 4am
1:3Opm Appt w/Misha Gromov (Me
3:OOpm Appt w/Bobby Slayton (l
3:3Opm Appt w/Reid Weingarten (MM)
Sun. Oct. 22.2017 NY
Reminder: Charlie Albright to play in Mamaroneck
Reminder: Leon Botstein's concert 2pm @ The Richard B. Fisher Center for the
Performing Arts (Sosnoff Theater), Bard College
6:00 pm Appt w/Richard Axel and Misha Gromov (Misha (Richard
Mon. Oct 23.2017 NY
Reminder: Invite Dr. Josephson to breakfast this week
9:3O-11:3Oam Treadmill Test Dr. Moskowitz prescribed
Vascular Lab, Department of Surgery
520 East 70th Street, Starr Pavilion, 8th Floor
When entering the building, turn left and take the Starr elevators to the 8th floor
Wear comfortable clothes/shoes!
Take ID and Insurance Card!
11:3Oam Meet w/Dr. Darren Schneider immediately after your vascular study to
review the results and offer any recommendations
CALL DR SHIMONY ON HIS CELL W/DR. SCHNEIDER:
12:15-1:15pm Appt wire* (MM)
2:O0pm Appt w/Dr. Rami Said (Columbia) Dr. Chen recommended Dr. Said
710 West 168th Street, 5th Floor,
4:3Opm Interview w/Yana Novoselova (=M)
5:OOpm Appt w/Lydia Laurenson (Gino Yu's friend) (=M)
Tues. Oct 24. 2017 NY-Bedford-NY
Reminder: Pritzker dates for the Middle East are Oct 24-28
7:15am Apptw/Dr. Cahill ( 1
850 5th Ave. btwn 66th and 67th
9:22am Depart NY (Tail#N120JE)
9:56am Arrive Bedford, Rectrix FB0
TriStar will ick u u on arrival and drop you at Martin's office. Confirn
(Tristan (Martin's office:
10:30/11am Appt w/Martin Nowak at his office (MM)
11:30am Appt w/Misha Lukin
12:30pm Appt w/Joscha Bach (MM) waiting for confirm of time
3:30pm Appt w/Danny Hillis ( j)
5:00pm Appt w/Joi Ito at Martin's office (MM)
6:30pm Tristar pick up from Martin's office (Confirm Car will arrive 6pm
just in case
8:15pm Depart Bedford
9:02pm Arrive NY
10:15pm Appt w= and her friend (M=)
Wed. Oct. 25 2017 NY
Reminder at MRI apps. 10am (must leave at 9am) will come to house directly
after.
Reminder 1:08pm Ion Nicola to arrive STT via AA#943 (Rec. Loc#DQPMSQ)
6:30am Jojo to pick u Dr. Jose hson from

Dr. Josephson cell:
6:45am BREAKFAST w/Dr. Jordan Josephson (M=)
7:45am Jojo to drive Dr. Josephson to his office when done with breakfast (he sees
patients at 8am)
10:00am A t w Leon Botstein and Terje
(Leon (Terje
12:00pm Appt wS)
1:00pm Call Peggy Siegal (MM)
2:00pm Appt w/Lydia Laurenson (Gino Yu's friend) t==)
3:30pm Appt/Ariane de Rothschild
4:00pm Tour House w/David Mitchell & Tristan Harper
(David Tristan
Address:
Ariane de Rothschild and Karyna to o with ou
(Arian (Karyna
8:30pm Appt w/Sergey Beliakov and Yulia, his wife lw lands at
5:20pm)
Thurs. Oct 26.2017 NY-PB
9:55am Depart NY
12:10pm Arrive PB
Fri. Oct 27, 2017 PB
Reminder: Jojo and Merwin off today for days owed.
10:40an= to arrive JFK via AF#22 (Rec. Loc#WIPXVA)
4:00pm to depart PB via Delta#1902 (Rec. Loc#NHXUTW)
6:06pm Karyna to arrive PB via Delta#2852 (Rec Loc#OCUTLH)
Sat Oct 28, 2017 PB
Reminder: Jojo off to celebrate Lynn's passing Oct 28 and 29
TBD Skype w/Austin Hall
Sun. Oct 29.2017 PB
Ilion. Oct. 30. 2017 PB
Reminder: Jojo's birthday
Reminder: to go see Ludovico Einaudi
Tues. Oct 31. 2017 PB
Reminder: Halloween!
Reminder: Ehud and Nili back in NY Oct 31 at 9pm. They depart Nov. 1 at 9pm
EFTA00810311 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2017-10-20)
VALAR
Valor Global Fund II LP Capital Call
October 10. 2017
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund II LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $600,000.00, which represents 4% of your total commitment of
$15,000,000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Friday, October 20, 2017.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 95% of your total commitment with a
remaining 5% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of October 20, 2017:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$15,000,000.00
$14,250,000.00
$750.000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Friday, October 20. 2017
$600.000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
Valor Global Fund II LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Valor Venlutes LLC 915 Bloodway Suite 1101 New York, New York 10010 www.volor.com
EFTA00810359 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2017-10-20)
VALAR
Valor Global Fund III LP Capital Call
October 10. 2017
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund III LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $2,250,000.00, which represents 9% of your total commitment
of $25,000,000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Friday, October 20. 2017.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 69% of your total commitment with a
remaining 31% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of October 20, 2017:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$25,000,000.00
$17,250,000.00
$7,750,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Friday, October 20, 2017
$2.250.000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
Valor Global Fund III LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Valor Ventures LLC 915 Broadway SUNS 1101 New York, New York 10010 www.volor.eom
EFTA01618454 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2017-10-26 20:38:45)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
2017/09/14
Sneaky, I am here in case you forgot
10:16:49 pin
2017/09/15
Sneaky went home, is ok?
01:09:51 am
I mean going home
01:10:14 am
When do I see you
01:11:00 am
1212 5333739
Ok
01:10:38 am
I am aware of peace and quite you want but If you need any help at the house I am
free on the weekend
01:13:00 am
1212 5333739
Thx
01:32:21 am
•
•
2017/09/16
Is all good sneaky? Enjoying peace and quite ti
03:20:19 pm
1212 5333739
free
03:23:50 pm
Free from what? 4.1.
03:24:39 pm
Or whom?
03:24:45 pm
1212 5333739
to visit now?]
03:25:05 pm
Yay! Ok will quickly shower and come by! S
03:26:19 pm
2017/09/17
1212 5333739
send me a copy of tonites invite the
04:17:32 pm
Sent to your email
05:44:27 pm
•
Surprise
05:58:31 pm
Are you coming too?
05:58:38 pm
Why not?I
06:09:16 pm
was invited for reception :)
didn't invite you?
2017/10/01
1212 5333739
No
05:58:43 pm
Sneaky just to confirm did you say after 1:30 pm or at 1:30pm? I hardly could hear
from the loud street
03:58:06 pm
Ah ok
03:58:56 pm
See you then!
03:59:05 pin
1212 5333739
3
03:58:15 pm
2017/10/02
Yay! Many many thanks Sneaky for my ticket!!! el
Ans thank you so much for cosmetic products. This was very kind of you to do for us!
*31.
08:14:53 pm
*It was
08:151 5 pm
Going to meet this guy.after work. I met him througl  and he has a several
businesses in Vietnam. I told him about my thesis and research concerning the
Mekong River so maybe can get involved in something :)
08:18:24 pm
*Has several businesses
08:18:41 pm
•
I mentioned you him before that he knownell
08:19:19 pm
2017/10/06
Hi sneaky! Welcome back! :.:. how is a ginger drink
04:38:17 pm
1212 5333739
This. Haven't tried yet. . busy. Feel free to come at 4
04:38:40 pm
Sneaky i work until 7 pm today :( we have to finish something for the report... after that
I have a date •• I can cancel it if you want me to help with something just let me know
04:40:07 pm
Ok if you change your mind sneaky please let me know
07:43:19 pm
Can I help tomorrow or this weekend?
07:44:06 pm
2017/10/08
Sneaky would be ok to come at 5pm instead of 4:30pm?
06:12:07 pm
1212 5333739
No its ok
04:40:46 pm
•
•
2
0/:18:24 pm
Ah thank you!
01:18:50 pm
2017/10/09
1212 5333739
Great sleep
06:22:16 pm
Awww me too! How was your flight?
05:4-5:08 pm
2017/10/16
Thank you so much sneaky for the trip! So much fun and my last day here flying back
tonight.
08:09:53 pm
How are you? When are you back?
08:09:53 pin
2017/10/22
Is ok to come now to the house?
08:42:27 pin
2017/10/25
•
•
08:38:45 pm
2017/10/26
Sneaky thank you so so much for all your support witf
02:31:54 am
Just saw
07:40:05 pm
✓ Read
walking in to se'M
1212 5333739
;)
01:35:21 am
✓ Sent
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                                 Andres Serrano [arts] "Piss Christ" artist 
 Al Seckel [publicist] Isabel Maxwell's husband, Mindshift Conference organizer, mysterious death (possibly faked) [tablet] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00507111 (Jmail)
 [tech] personal address book
(approximate date: 2017-11-02)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024328.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024328.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Case Data: Contacts (201-300 of 3037)
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Adam
Bly
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
6704
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Adel
E.
Ghazzawi
2016-09-21 07:01:09 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
4837
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Adel
Middle E.
Last Ghazzawi
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 290
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Adriaan
Last Tuiten
ID 47707
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Advice
Last NY
ID 8166
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First afri
Last xp
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
ID 1607
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First afri
Last xp
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC) Date
ID 6339
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First afri
Last xp
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID 30831
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ahmed
Last Protocal
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
ID 6160
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ahmed
Last Protocal
Phone Number (Mobile
Creation Date 2010-12-14 20:41:48 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
ID 29
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Akan Haloerin
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
ID 6678
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Al
Last seckel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
ID 435
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Al
Last seckel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5325
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First alain
Last forget
ID 43364
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alan
Middle M.
Last Dershowitz
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 566
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alan
Middle M.
Last Dershowitz
Phone Number
(Home)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-09-20 17:55:55 (UTC)
ID 6255
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alana
Last Righi
ID 90911
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alana
Last Righi
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 171
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alana
Last Righi
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 1047
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alberto
Last Pinto
Phone Number (Work Phone)
ID 34704
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Aleksander
Last Sichkar
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 539
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Aleksander
Last Sichkar
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:13 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5592
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Aleksandra
Last Eriksson
ID 171
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 540
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Path
2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
5390
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Alexa
Staley
2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
ID 6130
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Alexa
N.
Staley
2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5226
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alexa
Middle N.
Last Staley
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 238
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alexa
Last Staley
ID 90895
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First alexa930
ID 13366
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/916B364D-8EB5-48B
8-90D2-9403585F56B9/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alexandre
Middle Allard
Phone Number (Office
Paris)
Phone Number (Office
Sao Paulo)
Phone Number (French
Cell)
Phone Number (Brazil
Cell)
Address (Work)
Email 0
Email 0
Creation Date
Modification Date
Organization
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Phone Number (Office
Paris)
Phone Number (French
Cell)
Phone Number (Brazil
Cell)
Phone Number (Office
Sao Paulo)
Address (Work)
Email 0
Email 0
Creation Date
Modification Date
Organization
ID
2017-11-13 02:42:43 (UTC)
2017-11-13 02:42:45 (UTC)
Groupe Allard
15
Contact
NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47E
C-B022-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Alexandre
Allard
2017-11-10 20:56:18 (UTC)
2019-03-18 01:12:27 (UTC)
Groupe Allard
6751
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
alexandre
allard
92922
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType
First
Last
ID 90782
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
ook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 413
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 612
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
13344
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Path
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC) Date
ID 6203
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
52
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Work)
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Ali
2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
ID 6618
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
ID 369
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alice
Last Hargrove
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
!Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 786
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alice
Last Hargrove
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 690
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 144
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jeefLibraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First Alice de Rothschild
Email (Email)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Sk
First
Last
ID 90947
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:54 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 1371
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType essBook
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
Modification Date 2019-02-14 18:46:39 (UTC)
ID 946
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType ook
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 1594
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Sk
First
Last
ID 90931
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
ID 1572
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
177
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Allan
J
Arffa
2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
5412
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
/Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Allan
J
Arffa
2012-02-01 16:53:54 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 1404
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last Aha
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 1540
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Allesandro
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Allesandro
Ahag
2016-09-21 07:01:08 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
4729
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 579
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 358
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alya
ID 7774
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Amanda
Middle Gefter (New
Last Scientist)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:08 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
Note Gefter
Suffix (New Scientist)
ID 4663
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Amanda
Middle Getter (New
Last Scientist)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-02-01 16:53:56 (UTC)
Note Geier
Suffix (New Scientist)
ID 473
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Amanda
Last Gefter
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:54 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-02-01 16:53:56 (UTC)
Suffix (New Scientist)
ID 1374
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Amanda
Last Gefter
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
Suffix (New Scientist)
ID 585
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Amanda
Last Hutton
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID 50753
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Amanda
Middle Gefter (New
Last Scientist)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-02-04 17:57:57 (UTC)
ID 532
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Amanda
Last Getter
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-02-01 16:53:56 (UTC)
Suffix (New Scientist)
ID 1539
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First amc628
ID 13645
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ami
Last Sheth
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
!Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 1222
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ami
Last Sheth
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
ID 591
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Amy
Last Gray
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
ID 499
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Amy
Last Gray
Phone Number (Work Phone)
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID 90734
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Amy
Last Gray
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC) Date
ID 6302
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First Amy Dempsey
Email (Email)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Note
ID 6216
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
ID 730
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2016-09-21 07:01:13 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
5595
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Anas
2012-02-01 16:53:54 (UTC)
2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
ID 1433
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Anas
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
ID 1151
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jeelLibrary/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Anastasia
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
ID 6469
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Anastasia
ID 28607
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1428976
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Anastasiya
Last Kopets
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 1500
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Anastasiya
Last Siroochenko
Email 0
Email
(Obsolete)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 1072
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Anastasiya
Last Siroochenko
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 214
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Anastasiya
Last Siro
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID 44
Contact
Source Device NYC024328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Anastasiya
Last Siro
Entail (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 16:41:24 (LUC) Date

II) 6523
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Anastasiya
Last Kopets
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:09 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 4853
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Anat
Last Barak
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
II) 5353
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Anat
Last Barak
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:16 (UTC)
ID 1504
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Andersen
Last Bernard
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC) Date
ID 6448
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Andersen
Last Bernard
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 1473
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType dressBook
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
ID 694
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:18 (UTC)
Modification
Date
ID
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
1195
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
2436
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:43 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
6196
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
598
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
ID 554
Contact
Source Device NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Andreas
Last Ioannides
Phone Number (Work Phone)
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID 78629
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Andres
Serrano
2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
6488
Case Data: Contacts (101-200 of 3037) Case Data: Contacts (301-400 of 3037)
EFTA00511333 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2017-11-09 02:38:48)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024329.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024329.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Notes
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case Data: Contacts (11201-11300 of 19830)
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/6/9/Messages/96028.emlx
Mac Mail
Liudmila Pronovich (DHL BY)
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Live Nation
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Libraiy/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Live Nation Concerts
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/9/Messages/94601.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Live Nation Concerts
Email
(Email)
ID 1401643
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First live
ID 56409
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First live
ID 56409
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First live
ID 56409
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First live
ID 90979
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First live
ID 90979
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
ID
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
Skype
live:a
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
Skype
liv
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
Skype
liv.
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
Skype
liv. 81067
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
Skype
liv~
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
Skype
liv~
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First liv.
ID 90650
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path filsers/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First liv.
ID 90955
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path filsers/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First live-
ID 90955
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fllsers/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First liv.
ID 90955
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path filsers/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First live
ID 90666
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First live-
ID 90666
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fllsers/jee/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First live-
ID 90666
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac Deleted Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-0
98A-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/4/6/1/Messages/164259.emlx
Mac Mail
LiveAuctioneers
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxi4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/3/1/Messages/137505.emlx
Mac Mail
LiveAuctioneers
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users (Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/MacaNBOX.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-
977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/4/2/1/Messages/124741.emlx
Mac Mail
LiveAuctioneers Newsletter
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Liz
Whalen
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 375
Source Device
Path
SourceType
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
First Liz
Last Whalen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 375
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Liz
Last Whalen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 6
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Liz
Last Whalen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 375
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Liz
Last Whalen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 6
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Liz
Last Whalen
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 6
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
fUsers/karyna/Libraiy/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/0/1/Messages/109391.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Liz Carvalho
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Contact
fUsers/karyna/Libraiy/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B194848234372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/2/1/Messages/127743.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Liz Farren
Email
(Email)
ID 1364215
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Liz Whalen
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
fUsers/karyna/Libraiy/MaiUV6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B194848234372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/0/1/Messages/108245.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Lizette Chen
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/1/1/Messages/114761.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1501976
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Icatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/8/Messages/87712.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First LLC
Email
(Email)
ID 1340237
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/1/1/Messages/112587.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
LLP via Talksoft
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/9/Messages/95024.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/9/Messages/95024.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/9/Messages/96301.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
LN Curtis and sons
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/9/Messages/97625.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email (Email)
ID
Loan Manager
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/lcatyna/Libraty/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/9/Messages/92635.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Local YokelA®
Email
(Email)
ID 1435977
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/3/1/Messages/137570.emlx
Mac Mail
Loco Coco
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/4/1/Messages/147559.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Loco2
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B194848234372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/4/1/Messages/147558.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Loco2
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac Deleted Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-0
98A-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/4/6/1/Messages/164066.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/Mailboxes/Junk (iCloud).mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810
-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/6/1/1/Messages/116232.embt
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lojek
Email Lojek (Email)
ID 1081125
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/8/Messages/82759.emix
Mac Mail
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/3/1/Messages/135766.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B19484823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/4/1/Messages/146723.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users, (Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/Mailboxes/Junk (iCloud).mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810
-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/0/2/1/Messages/120711.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lola Chay
Email
(Email)
ID 1081072
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/_ (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac Deleted Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-0
98A-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/4/6/1/Messages/164123.emlx
Mac Mail
Lola Davenport
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mailboxes/Junk (iCloud).mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810
-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/6/1/1/Messages/116339.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lola Sako
Email
(Email)
ID 1081350
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/Mailboxes/Junk (iCloud).mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810
-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/3/1/Messages/139305.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lolita Morren
Email
(Email)
ID 1081056
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/lcatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/1/1/Messages/114422.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Email
(Email)
ID 1501628
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Userilkaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13C1A/Deleted Messag
es.mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/4/1/Messages/148698.emlx
Mac Mail
Longchamp
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/1/3/1/Messages/131354.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/2/1/1/Messages/112003.emlx
Mac Mail
lookfantastic.com
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/2/1/1/Messages/112074.emlx
Mac Mail
lookfantastic.com
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/0/1/Messages/100536.emlx
Mac Mail
Lookout Plan B
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1AfiNBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/2/9/Messages/92631.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Lorenz Ehrsam
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Lori
Downey
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Lori
Downey
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Lori
Downey
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/9/Messages/97796.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Lori Gerber
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lori Hargrave
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Lori Wilson
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac- Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/2/3/1/Messages/132537.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MacaDeleted Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-0
98A-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/3/6/1/Messages/163963.emlx
Mac Mail
Loma Leblanc
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Macaunk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-97
7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/3/6/1/Messages/163853.emlx
Mac Mail
Loma Small
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/8/Messages/88353.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Datal/4/1/Messages/147583.emlx
Mac Mail
Loro Piana
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Contact
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Macaeleted Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-0
98A-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/4/6/1/Messages/164210.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lorraine Lindsay
Email
(Email)
ID 1044187
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/karyna/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First LORTHOLARY Bertrand
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/Mailboxes/Junk (iCloud).mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810
-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/6/1/1/Messages/116080.emlx
Mac Mail
Los
Los
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Deleted Messag
es.mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/4/1/Messages/148533.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Los Angeles Times
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users, (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac-_'Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/2/7/Messages/72379.emlx
Mac Mail
Los Maria
Contact
Source
lks ice
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usersikatyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/8/Messages/82046.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/3/1/Messages/137473.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Lotte VanDrooge
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 636
Contact
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 636
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 636
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac Junk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-97
7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/3/6/1/Messages/163954.emlx
Mac Mail
Lottie Fletcher
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jeelLibrary/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
ID 6280
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usersilcaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/1/1/Messages/114798.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Source Device
Path
Bella
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
ID 6280
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
losers, (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac- Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/6/0/1/Messages/106177.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/9/Messages/99170.emlx
Mac Mail
> Janusz
Case Data: Contacts (11101-11200 of 19830) Case Data: Contacts (11301-11400 of 19830)
EFTA01620764 (Jmail)
 [crypto] iMessage from Melanie Walker (???) to Jeffrey Epstein about crypto philanthropy and Bill Gates being drunk all the time
(inferred timestamp: 2017-11-19 02:45:36)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
•
O
0
2017/11/12
As BG requested I put together plan and slides. Got senior leadership at McKinsey (the
ones he likes) to help me put slides together.
Basically
1800s blood transplant for cellular oxygenation
1900s bone marrow transplant for cellular immunity
2000s motochondrial transplant for cellular bioenergetics
09:07:19 pm
https://www.gatesnotes.com/
gn
2017/11/13
O n
04:27:17 pm
Yay / Paul Allen's CEO on Nov 22
07:57:53 pm
2017/11/14
Other stuff:

1. Did sultan Sulayman get in touch w Shai Efrati?
2. Any thoughts on ideas for Paul Allen? I know hes not hiring now but he does love
good ideas. His CEO is really good too. Paul wants science ideas / I've got a lot - but he
also wants to know about ways to turn science into money.
3. Not sure he'd be interested in a DAF be he doesn't usually do partnerships or rally
other donors (he's super shy!) but maybe?
Anyway - he's very smart and looking to do very good things.
O 03:58:15 pm
plant biology. - words as pharmaceuticals.
04:24:00 pm
•
Ok am making my list
Yes on plants but words as pharma is cool. Isn't that just religion?
Any thoughts on money stuff? He's worried his philanthropy is growing out of check.
Too much staff etc. he sees BilIG and the Foundation now at 1500+ employees. I was
emplpyee 28. Crazy growth.
O 04:43:26 pin
yes, philanthropic impact and crypto . currency to track payments
04:44:20 pm
What the heck is that
O 04:47:22 pm
im in a meeting can do later
04:47:43 pm
Paul has been hearing that EPIC needs help (medical records) and that he could do
I jist think that's a swamp
04:47:51 pin
It's now a private equity company - not an interesting operating system play
Medical records seems like a painful trap in my view (having to deal w then every day!)
04:48:29 pin
Ok later
O 04:48:38 pin
•
2017/11/15
0
philanthropy, not useful, distinction between charity , and venture investing for the
public good
12:50:33 am
plants mushrooms . data base
12:51:01 am
with human health.
12:51:10 am
why can we control our breath but not our immune system or digestive system. seems
odd
12:52:32 am
Autonomic nervous system
12:54:31 am
And you can't really control your breath
It is impossible to stop breathing
12:54:45 am
You can control raw
12:54:53 am
Rate
12:54:56 am
you can modulate more than other systems
12:55:18 am
•
•
Sorta
01:16:50 am
You have more control
Of inputs
Like eating sugar messes w EVERYTHing
01:17:09 am
Haven't heard back but I do know BG is in Dubai getting and award and then goes to
india
Supposedly an intense few days and not back till weekend
So he may not read anything from me till then
03:02:39 pm
Q: why don't elephants get cancer?
A: 42 copies of p53 per cell
O 08:33:31 pm
ok
09:31:44 pm
2017/11/17
Nothing from BG
I sent an email saying did you get my note and no response
01:54:20 am
Steve was with some reporters this past week and they were telling him BG has
become a strange behavior guy and is always drunk.
Sad
O 01:54:57 am
O en
You have done tough decision s to make
02:12:23 am
Not sure what they are and how to even think about it
He may never reply
I know we have discussed how you believe and have seen him respect people more
when they fight back
Worried about his wife and also larry
Not sure what to do
Statute of limitations in state of Washington - don't know
02:38:03 am
Let's talk weekend
I feel like I'm in a good and safe and credible place
I don't want him to ruin the future I have worked very hard for - mostly on his behalf
02:44:48 am
I'm very scared and hesitant to do anything to upset him
He seems bigger than police and justice systems etc
02:45:36 am
2017/11/19
Ok
02:49:03 am
Sounds like bogey man
08:42:12 am
•
•
•
Sounds like but mostly just vindictive
Wife worse
Larry horrible
O e-N 06:40:17 pin
I assume you have your own reasons . steve? reputation .? but after world bank,
and being fired from foundation. your future reputation is in your hands. I will help
all I can, but if you prefer to just slink off its your life
06:44:04 pin
Lord knows what is holding me back other than fear. Just having lived through years
with them. World Bank re-election of Jim had nothing to do with me. Did nothing
wrong and wasn't accused of wrong. Gossip surrounding politics isn't new and I'm not
first person or last caught in cross fire. I understand the nature of politics. The
foundation was a 16 year run. I left before I left work at Bank and they were very kind
and generous. I was not fired. We looked at roles I could do and none of them seemed
like useful or fun. Philanthropy just not for me, at least in the way it grew. My record
there is strong.
06:48:23 pin
I have always maintained my medical skills to allow me to have a place to be and
participate. I dont think it is slinking away and actually I enjoy it quite a lot. I would like
to do more in science and feel like i sort of got bait and switched by joining
philanthropy. The initial idea was to grow and scale new ideas and yes i did ru that
team but the new ideas weren't science (health isn't medicine...or tech) as I was
promised but more broadly about other things in development. But that's ok I learned
a lot and had a great time. It just wasn't what I thought or hoped. But I dont want to fall
into that trap again. My skills and interests aren't in poverty or development. And I
dont enjoy politics. They never have happy endings for anyone.
06:51:48 pm
If I go on the offensive for being attacked and mistreated by b then my life goes off
track again. For zero upside other revenge.
The legal system may provide justice for me but the exposure will be gross. Can't do
anonymously and it just feels gross to me.
O e-N 06:53:05 pm
yes to all, but you must find next quickly,
, otherwise planted on th beach
06:53:25 pm
its like surfing. wave to wave
Can't really do behind closed doors because it seems illegal. Like textbook extortion to
say I was wronged please make it right. Temporarily he might give me like 50,000 or
some small contract or something silly but behind closed doors larry and his wife will
then start bashing me from every direction. That doesn't feel like a win at all. So yes i
feel stuck.
06:54:34 pm
There is no upside other than knowing i was right. Yes. I have a "blue dress" emails and
a few other embarrassing things and yes the stories are so eerily similar to all in media
that he sounds weinsteinlike. I cant be the only one.
But next for me is more important than last. It is difficult to conceptualize where I
would fit. Not politics. Not corporate. Yes science.
I feel like I have two years of runway. First as an endovascular doc but second as a
rockefeller fellow.
06:57:24 pm
I feel like there are some really good ideas to change the way we live. I want to think
about those and make those happen. They start with a solid base in science. So, that
direction is where I'd like to be.
I meet w Paul Allen's CEO Wednesday. Then his science team in 2 weeks. That might be
a step in the right direction.
But as you know I'm just hesitant to kick the hornets nest w b. If there were a quiet and
non vengeful way to proceed with making his meanness right then I would consider. I
guess I could always auction his body fluids on eBay.
07:00:44 pm
The one thing i would like to try to ensure is that Larry doesn't spend all of his time
trashing me like he does Boris.
07:08:04 pm
Am open to suggestions and ideas for "next" even if they are conceptual. Am also to
open ideas about to have a happy ending or at least a real and fair ending w b.
0
1'1 07:09:26 pin
its up to you. he won't help unless you ask in a strong way, larry will trash you either
way, boris never does to my knowledge
11:07:56 pin
✓ Sent
I would like to ask in a strong way. One where I am in a position of strength and not as
victim.
Boris is a true friend to me and always helpful - just like you are and have been. I'm
grateful for you both. Meant that Larry trashes Boris. And me. And everyone.
11:10:55 pm
Email feels like the wrong way. He hasn't responded and Larry hasn't either.
11:11:21 pm
Haven't heard from him since mid October but in years past sometimes he goes a few
months without being touch. I've never really asked him for anything so I'm not sure
what to expect in terms of response time - but when we last met and larry was there
he asked me to put together the Story and plan and price etc and I did. I know he's
busy and traveling right now but also coming up on thanksgiving.
O en
If you have advice please let me know. Otherwise I feel like I have been playing by the
rules and doing what he asked and also what is agreed w Larry.
11:15:08 pm
✓ Read
╔═══════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Robert Mugabe [africa] Zimbabwean dictator 
   CrowdStrike [tech] cybersecurity company 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01683874 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from Confidential Human Source about "Epstein's personal hacker"
(date: 2017-11-27)
SECRET//NOFORN
FD-1023 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
CHS REPORTING DOCUMENT

HEADER
Source ID: <REDACTED>
Date: 12/13/2017
Case Agent Name: <REDACTED>
Field Office/Division: New York
Squad: ID 25
Classified By: J<REDACTED>
Derived From: FBI NSIC dated 20120629
Declassify On: 20421231

SOURCE REPORTING
Date of Contact: 11/27/2017

List all present including yourself (do not include the CHS):
Special Agent <REDACTED> Special Agent <REDACTED>

Type of Contact: In Person
Country: UNITED STATES
City: New York
State: New York
Date of Report: 11/27/2017

Substantive Case File Number
8<REDACTED>
Substantive Case File Number
813B -NY-2928278
FD-1023 Page 1 of 2 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
SECRET//NOFORN
SECRET//NOFORN
FD-1023 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
CHS REPORTING DOCUMENT
OFFICIAL RECORD

Check here if additional reporting is in Echo
No

Source Reporting:
S NF On November 27, 2017, Special Agen nd Special Agen met with <REDACTED>
a Confidential Human Source with whom the FBI has recently established a relationship. The CHS
reported the following:

(S//NF) Jeffrey Epstein ("Epstein") had a compound in New Mexico where he lured and video recorded underage
women. He also had a private island. Epstein was President Vladimir Putin's wealth mans er and provided the
same service for Zimbabwean President Robert Mugabe. Epstein had some connection to om MIT Media
Lab but CHS was unsure of the details. Epstein had dirt on other people. The logs from his ig is were made
public at some point. Epstein had a mansion on the Upper West Side. Epstein made his money from charging his
clients fees to hide their money offshore. Epstein knew former President Bill Clinton, and was very close to current
President Donald Trump. In the spring of 2015, President Trump had just been to Epstein's property for lunch.

(S//NF) (UM) <REDACTED> (<REDACTED>) was Epstein's personal hacker. <REDACTED> was an Italian citizen born in Calabria 
who
developed zero-day exploits and offensive cyber tools and sold the tools to government <REDACTED> established the
Saudi government's cyber surveillance program. <REDACTED> sold a zero-day to Hezbollah. <REDACTED> was known as the 
first
person to hack and find vulnerabilities in Blackberries and iOS. He was also known for finding Firefox
vulnerabilities. <REDACTED> surrounded himself with powerful friends like Epstein; he leveraged his connections with his
billionaire friends. <REDACTED> former company, was acquired by CrowdStrike in fall 2017, and <REDACTED> was
currently a Vice President there. <REDACTED> had three billionaire backers: <REDACTED>, Jeffrey Epstein and <REDACTED>
provided the company's see money; <REDACTED> had a Japanese company called <REDACTED>.

(S//NF) <REDACTED> was very good at finding vulnerabilities <REDACTED> was friends with "old school" European hackers. 
One
"friend" was a hacker named <REDACTED> (phonetic, "PH"). Another friend was <REDACTED> (PH). <REDACTED>eceived a
trunk of cash from Hezbollah when <REDACTED> was in Italy; drove the money to Switzerland and deposited it in
another ba<REDACTED> owned a theater company in California and he used the theater company to launder his zero -
day money <REDACTED>ade six figures from the sale of his zero -days. He sold his tools to United Kingdom GCHQ and
provided training to the organization. He also sold his zero-days to a Central African overnment, as well as
Hezbollah for political reasons. The Italian Government asked <REDACTED> for help, but <REDACTED>eclined because he felt
the Government was incompetent. Calabria was mob-controlled an<REDACTED> did nothave much loyalty for his birth
country. <REDACTED> sold his exploits to the United States and United Kingdom, but he would not sell to Asian countries
because he was racist. He was also anti-Semitic. <REDACTED> was terrified of Russia, however, and would never travel
there. He lived in Dubai at one time, and was acquainted with the <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>lived in Oman
as well. He may have an Iranian and Israeli passport, in addition to his Vatican City passport.

Synopsis:
11/27/1, Jeffrey Epstein
SIGNATURE
Submitted By —
First Level Approved By
FD-1023 Page 2 of 2 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
EFTA00797937 (Jmail)
 [crypto] John Pfeffer An (Institutional) Investor's Take on Cryptoassets
(date: 2017-12-24)
An (Institutional) Investor's Take on Cryptoassets
December 24, 2017 • version 6'
John Pfeffer
Medium  • • Linkedln
John Pfeffer is an entrepreneur and investor. In the 2000s, he was a London -based
partner at private equity firm Kohlberg Kravis Roberts, and in the 1990s, he was
Chairman of the Executive Board of leading French IT company Groupe Allium S.A.
Before that, he advised on turnarounds while with McKinsey in Europe and Latin
America.
IMPORTANT NOTICE: This document is intended for informational purposes
only. The views expressed in this document are not, and should not be construed as,
investment advice or recommendations. Recipients of this document should do their
own due diligence, taking into account their specific financial circumstances,
investment objectives and risk tolerance (which are not considered in this document)
before investing. This document is not an offer, nor the solicitation of an offer, to
buy or sell any of the assets mentioned herein.

Amidst the indiscriminate speculation, sensationalist and mostly misguided media coverage
and roller-coaster price volatility, this paper sets out to consider cryptoassets from the
perspective of a rational, long-term investor. As investors, we look for things that generate
sustainable, ideally growing economic rent—an economic surplus that will accrete to us. This
paper evaluates the extent to which cryptoassets offer the foregoing. It aims to assess the
potential future value of cryptoassets at mature equilibrium, 2 on the assumption that they
develop successfully and achieve widescale adoption. By design, it does not dwell on the
significant risks that a given cryptoasset could fail, for technical, regulatory, political, or
other reasons. These risks are very real, and are well documented elsewhere. Temporarily
setting them aside allows for an objective analysis of the potential value of different kinds of
cryptoassets and their use cases.

I write not from the perspective of a trader, but from that of an investor who believes the long
term is easier to predict than the short term. The paper thus focuses entirely on long-term
equilibrium outcomes and investment strategy rather than short-term price movements. It
also assumes the reader has some familiarity with the topic.

Blockchain technology has the potential to disrupt a number of industries and to create
significant economic surplus. The open-source nature of public blockchain protocols,
Earlier versions of this paper were drafted beginning in June 2017.

2 The notion of mature equilibrium as I use it here is admittedly imprecise. Conceptually I mean once the
speculative phase has passed and (i) in the case of monetary store of value, once there is a mainstream,
institutional view that crypto is a core monetary store of value like gold is today and (ii) in the context of
infrastructure and applications, once markets are valuing cryptoassets based on significant realised user
penetration. The obvious analogy is the intemet. Internet penetration and internet-enabled businesses are
still growing today but growth is slowing. Today, large internet•enabled businesses are valued based on
financial ratios such as PEG and EBITDA multiples rather than clicks or eyeballs as was the case in the late
1990s. That's the end point I'm thinking about. For shorthand, let's assume 10 years from now.
combined with intrinsic mechanisms to break down monopoly effects, mean that the vast
majority of this economic surplus will accrue to users. While tens or perhaps hundreds of
billions of dollars of value will also likely accrue to the cryptoassets underlying these
protocols and therefore to investors in them, this potential value will be fragmented across
many different protocols and is generally insufficient in relation to current valuations to offer
a long-term investor attractive returns relative to the inherent risks. The one key exception is
the potential for a cryptoasset to emerge as a dominant, non-sovereign monetary store of
value, which could be worth many trillions of dollars. While also risky, this potential value
and the probability that it might develop for the current leading candidate for this use case
(Bitcoin) would appear to be sufficiently high to make it rational for many investors to
allocate a small portion of their assets to Bitcoin with a long-term investment horizon.
We can break cryptographic token use cases into three broad categories:

I. Network backbone / Virtual Machine (e.g., Ethereum)
2. Distributed applications (Dapps)
3. Money, and in particular:
a. Payments
b. Monetary store of value.

I will start by looking at the first two use cases from a general perspective and then dive
deeper in analysing the largest current example of the first one, Ethereum. I'll then turn to a
discussion of the different functions of money, the potential for cryptoassets to perform them
and the implications for the value of such cryptoassets, including Bitcoin.
The economics and valuation of utility protocols
Use cases I and 2 can be grouped into what I call utility protocols. I will start with some
general observations on utility protocols and the implications for their network valuation at
equilibrium and then specifically consider the network value of Ethereum at mature
equilibrium.
General observations
A blockchain protocol is a database maintained by a decentralised consensus mechanism
operated by its nodes. Utility protocol tokens serve to provision scarce network resources:
the processing power, memory, and bandwidth necessary for maintaining the blockchain in
question. These resources have a real-world cost in terms of energy and the equipment
employed, and these costs are borne by the miners who maintain the blockchain by providing
computational services. The miners may be remunerated for their service with block
rewards, paid in protocol tokens, and/or transaction fees, paid in protocol tokens or some
other means of exchange. While protocol developers may claim that tokens are the basis for
other kinds of exchange among users and not just a means of allocating and paying for
computing resources, it is my argument that, at mature equilibrium, tokens will do no more
than allocate computing resource, with the exception of the special case of a cryptoasset that
serves as a monetary store of value.

A given protocol is analogous to a simplified economy. The GDP of such an economy would
be the aggregate cost of the computing resources necessary to maintain the blockchain, based
on the quantity of processing power, memory and bandwidth consumed, multiplied by the
unit cost of each. The token is typically the currency used to pay for those resources. The
total network value is analogous to the money supply M (i.e., all tokens in issuance), where
M = PQ/V; PQ (Price x Quantity) is the total cost of the computing resources consumed, V is
a measure of how frequently a token is used and reused in the system (its velocity, V). The
value of a single token is therefore M/T, where T is the total number of tokens.
If a given utility protocol does not have a built-in mechanism, such as Ethereum's
GASPRICE, to ensure that the cost of using the network does not arbitrarily and sustainably
diverge from the underlying cost of the computational resources it consumes, one of three
things happens: (a) the token's price trades to a level such that there is no premium cost to
using the network (i.e., there is no economic rent); (b) the chain forks into a functionally
identical but less rent-seeking chains until any premium usage cost and economic rent on the
network declines to a level at which it is no longer worthwhile to arbitrage; (c) the protocol's
adoption is temporarily limited to the highest-value use cases until (a) or (b) occurs. In all
cases, the equilibrium result must be at or near marginal revenue = marginal cost for the
mining industry maintaining the blockchain in question, so that the token's value cannot
materially decouple from the underlying computing resource cost.

PQ, the cost of computing resources required to maintain a blockchain, is not only low
relative to the current network values being attributed to cryptoassets; it is also inflated by the
prevalence of proof-of-work consensus mechanisms, which mean that the vast majority of
computing resource consumed is make-work. To the extent that new scaling technologies
such as proof-of-stake, sharding, Segregated Witness, Lightning, Raiden and Plasma become
prevalent, the amount of computing resource consumed may become quite small. Note also
that in the context of cryptoassets, V could go very high at equilibrium. Even if a significant
portion of a given cryptoasset has a low velocity because it is being hodl'd by speculators or
because it is staked by miners under a proof-of-stake consensus mechanism, the circulating
portion of the tokens can circulate at the speed of computer processing and bandwidth—i.e.,
fast and accelerating. The implication is that average velocities can and are likely to be high,
regardless of how many tokens are actually actively circulating for utility purposes to allocate
network resources.' The combined effect of low and falling PQ and potentially very high V
is that the utility value of utility cryptoassets at equilibrium should in fact be relatively low.
Clearly, scaling solutions such as proof-of-stake, etc. are bullish for adoption/users but
bearish for token value/investors. Even without those technology shifts, the cost of using
decentralised protocols is deflationary, since the cost of processing power, storage and
bandwidth are deflationary. This is also bullish for adoption and users and bearish for token
value and investors?'
Whatever scaling solutions are developed, the inherent redundancy of the consensus
mechanism means that there may be fewer use cases than many decentralised revolutionaries
think in which a decentralised solution displaces a centralised solution. Use cases will be
limited to dematerialised networks where the value of decentralisation, censorship -resistance
and trustlessness is high enough to justify the inherent inefficiency and redundancy of the
consensus mechanism. Is it worth the cost for payments? Yes for some, but not for all.
Consider Twitter -- what is the added value to the user of a massively redundant, trustless,
3 Chris Burniske's recent blog post "Cryptoasset Valuations" (https://medium.comftacburniske/cryptoasset-
valuations-ac83479ffca7) estimates an average V of 7, after adjusting for hodlers, stakers, etc. This assumption
may be optimistic (meaning, it is probably a low value of V to assume at equilibrium and therefore an
optimistic number to be using to estimate the potential equilibrium value of a given cryptoasset), but his
framework is useful for thinking about the different drivers of V for a given cryptoasset.
I have yet to come across any examples of a protocol where I have been persuaded that when all is said and
done the underlying scarce resource being provisioned is something other than computing resources, or at
least where that is what it will boil down to at competitive equilibrium after competition in mining, forks, etc.
Please alert me to any counter examples you have seen or can think of.

decentralised Twitter? Is that added value enough to offset its inefficiency compared to the
incumbent centralised Twitter? Would Token Twitter offer compellingly higher utility
compared to centralised Twitter, including enough surplus utility to offset the cost of
operating the consensus mechanism? I'm not so sure.

People often make the mistake of conflating the monopoly network effects of, say, Facebook
to blockchain protocols. This notion is fallacious on several levels:

• Blockchain protocols can be forked to a functionally identical blockchain with the
same history and users up to that moment if a parent chain persists in being arbitrarily
expensive to use (i.e., rent-seeking). Like TCP/IP but unlike Facebook, blockchain
protocols are open-source software that anyone can copy or fork freely. A protocol
fork is analogous to a team of Facebook developers who decide one Tuesday morning
that Zuck is not paying them enough; they could simply flip a switch and use the
servers and software that run Facebook to run a new Facebook that is functionally
identical, with all the same users and data up to that point. That can, does, and will
happen all the time in protocol-land, but would be theft in the context of private
companies that own their code, data, intellectual property, etc. Those property rights
are why Zuck is rich, and their absence in the protocol economy has profound
implications. The ability to fork protocols maximises utility for users but suppresses
economic rent for token holders.

• When people talk about the potential value of cryptoassets, they often refer to
Metcalfe's Law. Metcalfe's Law asserts that network value = - n(n-I), where A is a
constant that captures the differences in the economics built into the business model
of each network and where n is the number of nodes in the network. It's not enough
to focus on n(n-1). You must also consider what 0 is. Wikipedia has a lot of
contributors and users but not a lot of monetary value because it doesn't charge users
or have advertisers or attract any other sources of revenue apart from donations.
Facebook's 0 is higher than Twitter's because its advertising business model is
stronger. TCP/IP lacks financial value not only because no one owns it but also
because it doesn't have a revenue model. The problem for utility protocols is that the
in question is driven by the cost of the computing resources to maintain the
network, which is relatively low and deflationary and which must remain low for their
adoption to be successful vs. non-distributed technologies.

• When thinking about whether a protocol's token can capture and sustain economic
rent, what is relevant is whether the mining industry maintaining the protocol's
blockchain is competitive, not the stickiness of users. The mining industry supporting
any decentralised protocol must be a competitive market; otherwise the protocol isn't
decentralised. It is the economic competition amongst miners that will ultimately
drive the cost of using the protocol and therefore the value of the token. No
mechanisms for monopoly rents there.

• Not only must protocols compete against their own potential forks; competition
amongst protocols is also fierce. Witness, for example, recent press reports that Kik
is considering migrating its token network from the Ethereum backbone to another
blockchain because the Ethereum network is becoming too expensive to use.'
S https://www.coindesk.com/kik-might-move-its-ico-tokens-to-a-new-blockchain/
• The network value of a tokenised version of a dematerialised network business (a
social network, Uber, AirBnB, a betting exchange, etc.) will by construction be a
small fraction of the enterprise value of its centralised, joint-stock-company
equivalent. Holding the number of users constant, you basically take the fully-loaded
IT budget (including energy and a capital charge) of those companies (representing
PQ) and divide by some (likely high) velocity V. The disruption of traditional
networked businesses by decentralised protocol challengers will represent an
enormous transfer of utility to users and an enormous destruction of market value.
Great for users, the economy and society; bad for investors.

The next topic to address is the impact of a move to proof-of-stake mining and of staking
models in general on the network values of Ethereum and other protocols. The idea is that
miners are compensated for maintaining the network either in a native cryptoasset or another
cryptoasset (such as ETH or BTC), in proportion to the amount of the native network
cryptoasset that they stake (i.e., effectively put into escrow and at risk of loss if they attempt
to validate false transactions and the like). The promoters of this idea hope that it will
reduce the actual computing costs of maintaining the network, by eliminating the costly
proof-of-work mechanism, while at the same time creating an alchemic virtuous cycle
wherein miners buy and lock up significant amounts of the native cryptoasset as an
investment conveying them a right to a mining revenue stream, thereby reducing the velocity
of the native cryptoasset and causing its value to rise to a level representing some multiple of
their mining profits, much as taxi medallions or shares in a company are valued based on the
net present value of future cash flows.
Let's think through how this plays out.

First, before staking is introduced into the equation, we've established that forks and
competition in mining and among protocols lead us to an equilibrium outcome where PQ
equals the aggregate cost of the computational resources (capital charge on or usage cost of
processing and storage hardware, cost of bandwidth and energy) of maintaining the network.
Second, recall that the impetus for moving from proof-of-work to proof-of-stake is to reduce
the amount of computational resource and energy required to maintain the network by a
couple orders of magnitude. That's good for scalability and potential adoption, but also
means a commensurate reduction in the PQ of the network.

Third, let's layer on the idea that in order to participate in mining and the associated
revenues, on top of paying for processing power, storage, bandwidth and energy, you must
now bear an additional cost in the form of a capital charge from acquiring and immobilising
an amount of the native cryptoasset. This capital charge on immobilised cryptoasset is added
to PQ, making the protocol in question more expensive to use than an equivalent utility
protocol that doesn't require staking (or where staking is less expensive because the native
cryptoasset is cheaper).

This system operates a bit like a taxi medallion system: an authority issues a finite number of
licenses, and you must buy one from another medallion holder if you want to operate a taxi.
The value of the license captures the discounted value of any economic profits that are
expected to accrue from operation. Whoever owned the license first is the primary
beneficiary of this monopoly, and he receives that value when he sells the license to
someone. The buyer of the license does not enjoy any economic rent because he paid the
discounted present value of it to the previous license holder, and so on as the license changes
hands. Passengers pay higher fares because the taxi driver's capital cost of buying the license
must be compensated for, all for the benefit of the first owner of the license.

Imagine there are several different taxi companies operating that have acquired a number of
licenses. Now imagine that a new entrant decides it would like to take market share. In the
world of a taxi medallion monopoly created by an issuing public authority, they would have
no option other than to buy medallions from other medallion owners. But here is where
protocol-land is different from real-world taxi medallion schemes. Protocols are open source
software and can be freely forked.

In protocol-land, all the upstart taxi company needs to do is to fork the protocol, effectively
issuing an identical number of new taxi medallions and reallocating medallions owned by
existing large taxi companies to itself and perhaps a few other friends. Because the upstart
taxi company didn't have to pay for its taxi medallions, it and the other recipients of the new
medallions can charge its passengers lower fares. Passengers thus flock to the upstart
company, and the monopoly value embedded in the original taxi medallions vanishes.

Everyone in the system except for the large taxi company wins. If necessary, this process can
be repeated indefinitely. The result is that the medallions have low values (as would the
analogous native cryptoasset). 6
Another mechanism for utility protocols is mine and burn. In this system, new coins are
minted and allocated to miners based on the network services they provide, and users must
buy these coins and burn them to pay for transaction processing. This is a perfectly fine
mechanism, but it simply ensures that the network value equals PQ/V, where PQ is the actual
fiat cost of maintaining the network and V is the average time from minting to burning. That
gets you to the same low equilibrium network value more simply and quickly.
Other general observations:
• Analysts often use a working capital analogy in order to assess how much of a given
cryptoasset a user will stock to facilitate actual use of a given blockchain's utility
function. Fair enough, but digging further into that line of thinking, the way optimal
inventories of a good are set is based on the relationship of the volume and volatility
of demand, optimal order sizes, communication and delivery latency and production
times. Since cryptoassets are generally highly divisible and may circulate very fast
(as fast as processor speed and bandwidth allow), it would seem to me that a user
would, by the same maths as those used to determine optimal inventory quantities,
conclude that he needs to hold very little inventory of a given cryptoasset. Friction
moving among cryptoassets is already low and will quickly disappear entirely with
technologies like atomic swaps. Consequently, one would expect velocity to be very
high at equilibrium. It would make no more sense for users to hoard utility
cryptoassets beyond the minimum they need to carry out their desired operations than
it would be for individuals to hoard petrol or for companies to hoard giant warehouses
full of whatever goods they sell. Companies need inventories of goods to run a
business and those inventories have a value on their balance sheet, but they try to
minimise such holdings, as they are unproductive assets that are costly to finance and
carry. They certainly don't try to accumulate more inventory than necessary as a way
to store their retained earnings. Similarly, individuals have petrol in the tanks of their
cars, but they don't stockpile petrol in their basements as a form of savings.'
6 The competitive forces to eliminate economic rent would function in largely the same way whether the
staking system involves payment for services in cryptoassets that are native or external to the protocol at
hand.

7 See also Vitalik Buterin's recent blog post: "On Medium of Exchange Token Valuations"
(http://vitalik.ca/general/2017/10/17/moe.htmil

• For every successful utility protocol (certainly for every successful Dapp), there will
ben failed versions. In fact, one of the advantages of the protocol economy is that it
facilitates open and inexpensive experimentation, which will mean that there will be
many more attempts and many more failures, and that each success will be
individually smaller in its value and reach. The open-source, forkable nature of this
kind of software will likely drive toward a fragmentation of use cases and protocol
functionality; businesses built on top of the protocols will be protocol agnostic and
capable of using and combining modularly a changing array of protocols to deliver
whatever service or value chain they are trying to deliver. These dynamics are great
for users and generate lots of positive economic and social externalities, but they are
bad dynamics for investors.8 The problem of making money by investing in utility
protocols is aggravated by: (a) the fact that this is a fragmented space with very high
failure rates, so selecting winners a priori will be very difficult; and (b) the fact that
most of the long-term winning protocols probably haven't even been launched yet
(witness the fact that the most valuable internet businesses were founded after 2001).
• Developer incentives over time are a fundamental issue in crypto. For most protocols,
such incentives are heavily front-ended around launch and insufficiently provided for
over time. The more ambitious and long-term a protocol's development roadmap is,
the more problematic this failure of incentives becomes. The incentives to improve
an existing protocol by forking it may be strong if some tokens are reallocated at the
fork to the developers making the improvements. For example, where tokens have
been retained by a foundation linked to the original protocol developers, an aggressive
group of forking developers could reallocate the foundation's tokens to their own new
entity in their fork, leaving all other users in the same position and letting the market
decide which fork to support. The incentives for a developer to create a new,
competing protocol are also strong, but network effects do make it harder to displace
an existing protocol than to improve or fork it. Miners and perhaps large users have a
strong economic incentive to invest in development of the protocol they are mining
either through changes to the protocol or by forking it. The foregoing suggests that
we're likely to see (a) more success with protocols focused on simple use-cases that
require less ambitious future development; (b) future protocols launched with better
long-term developer incentive schemes (easier said than done)9; (c) aggressive forks
that transfer value from incumbent to challenger developers1); and (d) large
miners/users or groups of miners/users acting together employing or paying
developers to improve legacy protocols either directly or via forks.

The implication of this section is not that utility protocols won't have any network value.
PQN does represent positive value. The implication is that network value of a utility
See also Teemu Paivenen's blog post "Thin Protocols" (httos://blotzeppelin.solutions/thin-protocols-
cc872258379f).

g Tezos proposes an interesting potential solution to the developer incentive problem. Tezos combines a PoS
consensus mechanism with a system whereby token-holders can vote on improvements to the protocol
proposed by developers and reward the developers for their contribution. We'll see if it works, but the
problem for Tezos remains that the mature equilibrium value of the Tezos token will be Trews = PQ/VM where
PQ is the cost of the computing resource maintaining the Tezos blockchain, i.e., Tiezos probably won't have a
high value when the dust settles.
1D See also Fred Ersham's blogpost "Accelerating Evolution through Forking"
(https://medium.com/OFEhrsam/accelerating-evolution-through-forking-6b0bba8Sa2ba)
protocol will converge on or near an equilibrium, where it is a fraction (denominator V) of
the actual cost of the computing resources consumed to maintain the networks.

For a fork to succeed, there needs to be enough value available to arbitrage to incentivise
users, some miners and a sufficiently credible developer group to support the fork. It should
therefore be acknowledged that, to the extent the equilibrium outcome is arrived by way of
one or more forks, there could be a sustainable level of network value economic rent
premium above computing cost that is too small to provide adequate incentives for a fork to
succeed. I would not, however, consider it to be a very compelling investment thesis when
the best I can hope for is to keep an amount of value corresponding to an economic rent that's
too small for anyone to bother arbitraging it away from me despite relatively low barriers to
doing so. While a protocol's core development team may be bound by various soft ties, in
protocol-land (unlike in a traditional software business), the work product is all open-source;
intellectual property isn't generally owned or protected; and developers have little or nothing
in the way of contractual ties or limitations (e.g., no non-compete, no non-disclosure, no non-
solicit). That means developers can defect or take the work of others. At a minimum, these
factors place a low ceiling on how much economic rent can be created and sustained."
As illustrated in the ETH valuation example to follow, it is likely that the combined network
values of all utility protocol cryptoassets together will total between tens of billions and
hundreds of billions of dollars. That is significant value, but not when compared to the
current -$250 billion combined network value of protocols other than Bitcoin. Investing in
utility protocol cryptoassets could make sense if their current network values were one or two
orders of magnitude lower than they currently are, but at current valuations, the risk/return to
investors is not attractive.
The Network Value of ETH
ETH, the Ethereum token, is an interesting case to explore because of its significant current
network value and Ethereum's potential as the ultimate utility protocol. Ethereum could
serve as the backbone for processing smart contract operations for (hopefully) untold
numbers of decentralised applications, DAOs, etc., and perhaps one day maybe even
something like the fabled Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM).

Ethereum's developers understood that for Ethereum to fulfil its potential, the cost of using it
as a smart -contract -executing utility must be as low as possible and must not depart at
equilibrium from the actual cost of the computational resources consumed. To ensure this
will be the case, they built the GAS mechanism into Ethereum to decouple the use of the
network (and the cost thereof) from the value of the ETH token.

Each possible type of computing operation has a pre-defined GASCOST, measured in units
of GAS. GAS may then be paid for using ETH (or another token or currency) based on the
GASPRICE `exchange rate', which is freely set among users and miners. 12
11 An interesting business idea that someone could logically pursue at some point would be to raise capital to
fund a crack team of mercenary blockchain developers and systematically target technically-mature or
maturing protocols where there is still a significant economic rent premium and arbitrage that value via hostile
forks of those protocols in a way that reduces cost and/or improves functionality to users and reassigns
network tokens held by the incumbent developer team and backers to the insurgent team and backers.
12 Note that because GASPRICE is fully-flexible, GASCOST might only need to be updated in the system from
time to time if and to the extent the relative cost of certain sub-components of computing costs changes, for
example the cost of processing power vs storage.
The Ethereum Homestead Documentation makes this all clear:
"Gas Price is how much Gas costs in terms of another currency or token like Ether.

To stabilise the value of gas, the Gas Price is a floating value such that if the cost of
tokens or currency fluctuates, the Gas Price changes to keep the same real value. The
Gas Price is set by the equilibrium price of how much users are willing to spend, and
how much processing nodes are willing to accept '3." (Ethereum Homestead
Documentation Release 0.1, p49)
"Gas and ether are decoupled deliberately since units of gas align with computation
units having a natural cost, while the price of ether generally fluctuates as a result of
market forces. The two are mediated by a free market: the price of gas is actually
decided by the miners, who can refuse to process a transaction with a lower gas price
than their minimum limit." (Ethereum Homestead Documentation Release 0.1, p68)
This is all logical in the sense that GAS, and by extension the ETH token itself, is a metering
device meant to ensure correct economic allocation and remuneration of the network's
resources. In the long term, the GASPRICE (and through it the value of ETH) should
therefore tend toward the actual marginal cost of computing resource on the network. It
could not possibly be otherwise, since if the cost of running operations on the Ethereum
blockchain became materially more expensive than the actual underlying cost of computing
resources consumed by it, people would simply use another blockchain where that premium
doesn't exist (or fork to create a cheaper Ethereum network that has identical functionality
and users at that moment)? Also, if the GASPRICE were to decouple sustainably from the
actual computing cost of operations, then mining would be the only perfectly competitive
industry in history to earn sustainably positive economic rent. There is no reason for this to
be the case in an industry where capacity can be freely added and withdrawn and the market
price freely set.
Since the value of ETH is decoupled from GAS and therefore from the volume of
transactions on the Ethereum protocol, an ETH bull could argue that ETH tokens could have
an arbitrarily high value without compromising the cost-efficiency of operations on the chain.
But let's first agree that because of the GASPRICE mechanism 14 the volume of transactions
on the ETH blockchain and the scale of its adoption are not transitive to a high ETH token
value. This point is important as observers often erroneously assume that a high volume of
network transaction volume driven by all of the different potential uses of the Ethereum
protocol will necessarily give the ETH token high value.

Let's work through some numbers to see what in fact the utility value of ETH might be.
Ethereum GDP (i.e., PQ) is the total `revenue' of the computing network performing the
13 Today in practice it seems that the vast majority of transactions use the default 0.02 microETH price, but
that most likely reflects the incipient nature of activity on the network. GASPRICE can be expected to become
more market-driven as use of the Ethereum network grows. From a basic microeconomic perspective, if the
GASPRICE (in fiat terms converted via the GASPRICE to ETH exchange rate and the fiat value of ETH) exceeds
from time to time the actual fiat cost of providing the requisite computing resources, you would expect users
to reduce GASPRICE offered or miners to add competing computing resources to the network until the
marginal cost again equals the marginal revenue, driving a decline in the GASPRICE. This relationship should
hold no matter what the scale of the operations being performed on the blockchain. The market will just keep
allocating more computing and storage resources to the network as long as it is profitable to do so.
14 Note that the GASPRICE mechanism helps to reduce the incentives to fork the chain because economic rent
can be eliminated quickly through it without necessitating a fork. Protocols without a GAS mechanism can be
expected to end up at a similar economic equilibrium through forks as Ethereum will reach through the GAS
mechanism. Ethereum may still fork for other reasons.
underlying operations, which can be directly measured as GAS used multiplied by the
average GASPRICE. On 23 December 2017, the total amount of ETH used to fuel (pay
miners for) transactions on the Ethereum network was ETH 1,388 (derived from the total
GAS used' s multiplied by the average GASPRICE that day16)17. ETH 1,388 is worth about
$1 million at $700 per ETH. Annualised (simplistically multiplying by 365), this is about
$355m per year.

We can then play with different assumptions for how fast the Ethereum network will grow vs
the declining computing and energy costs. For example, let's assume Ethereum network
traffic grows from here at the same rate internet traffic grew from 1995 to 2005 (roughly
150% growth per year)' 8 and that the combined offsetting impact of declining computing
costs is -20% per year (optimistic as this approximates only the effects of the average rate of
decline in computing costs without a change in the consensus mechanism; implementation of
proof-of-stake or other scaling solutions could represent a step change down in the computing
costs of the network by orders of magnitude). The combined net effect would imply
`Ethereum GDP' (PQ) doubles each year. At this rate, Ethereum GDP would grow from
$355 million to $363 billion in ten years, an over thousand -fold increase. If we assume an
ETH velocity of 7, the network value of ETH would be $52 billion in 10 years, about 24%
less than its current network value of approximately $68 billion. Of course, in order to
provide an attractive return to investors buying ETH today, its current network value would
have to be significantly lower than $52 billion (assuming investors would expect to make a
30 - 40% annual rate of return over that period, the current network value would need to be
in the range of $1.8 - 3.8 billion).

The foregoing calculation implicitly assumes that GASPRICE is already set at the level
where miners are making zero economic rent and that Ethereum does not change its proof-of-
work system, for example to proof-of-stake. As it's early days for Ethereum and mining
computing resources are still catching up with demand, miners are probably still temporarily
making positive economic rent, which means this back-of-the-envelope calculation in fact
overstates PQ even if proof-of-work is maintained. More significantly, if Ethereum
successfully moves to a proof-of-stake mining system and thereby substantially reduces the
computational inefficiency inherent in proof-of-work where 99% of the computing power
goes to proof-of-work and only a very small portion to actually maintaining the ledger, the
PQ of the blockchain would fall massively and along with it the Ethereum network value.
Recall also the analysis in the previous section explaining why staking of tokens for mining
under proof-of-stake won't allow Ethereum to sustain a network monopoly premium.

Another way to look at this is to relate the Ethereum GDP to the total revenue of Amazon
Web Services. AWS total revenue in 2017 is estimated to be $16.8b, growing to $40b in
2021 (according to JP Morgan), an order of magnitude smaller than our 10-year estimation
for ETH GDP in the previous paragraph. If the velocity of ETH is 7, the Ethereum GDP (PQ
of computational resources running the network) would need to reach approximately $476
billion or 28 times AWS' current revenue to justify its current network value and excluding
any return on investment during the years while Ethereum grows to reach that scale. Now, of
course, AWS is just one provider of cloud services, but Ethereum is just one blockchain.
Even if we assume that Ethereum will have some greater market share of blockchain than
https://etherscan.io/chart/gasused
https://etherscan.io/chart/gasorice
17 On 23 December 2017: GAS Used 41,686.74 million x Average GASPRICE 0.000000033285710975 ETH =
1,388 ETH.
https://blogs.cisco.com/so/the-historv-and-future-of-internet-traffic
AWS has of cloud, it is still hard to see how the current Ethereum network value can be
remotely justified on this basis.

Note that in my reasoning about the future value of ETH at equilibrium, I have so far not
taken into account the mined tokens that miners receive for performing computational
services for the network as that value does not accrue to token holders. Rather the opposite.
There are in fact two negative impacts of mining rewards on the value per token:

• Issuance of new tokens doesn't increase the total network value, just as
printing fiat money doesn't make people collectively richer in real terms. The
new issuance goes to the miners at a one-for-one cost of dilution spread across
the value of all pre-existing tokens. This must also be true for the interest rate
(BIR) paid on ETH tokens deposited in a proof-of-stake system. The new
tokens generated to pay the interest dilute all existing tokens such that the
effect on the overall total value of ETH tokens is neutral. Those engaged in
mining will benefit from the interest earned while those not engaged in mining
will suffer from the corresponding dilution. But the existence of this system
does not drive growth in the network value of ETH and in fact drives
devaluation of each ETH token at the rate of total interest paid in ETH divided
by the total issuance of ETH. 19
• There is a second, subtler negative effect of this new token issuance. It
subsidises the cost of operating the network, which at competitive equilibrium
puts downward pressure on GASPRICE, which in turn puts downward
pressure on the value of ETH at a constant GAS <> ETH exchange rate.

The paradoxical combined effect is that the cost of new token issuance through mining
rewards is effectively borne twice by non-miner token holders.

The implication of all of the foregoing is that, even if Ethereum is hugely successful, the
value implied by its use as a backbone utility protocol is likely a small fraction of its current
value. All of this raises a question for ETH bulls: why would ETH be arbitrarily valuable if
it's not some scarcity in relation to the volume of transactions and operations on the chain?
One proposed reason has been that people will hoard ETH as a currency with which to make
financial investments, for example in ERC20 token ICOs or DAOs built on the Ethereum
protocol. In his blog post "Platform Currencies May Soon Be Obsolete" 20, Aleksandr
Bulkin articulates why it is unlikely that a single blockchain will host a large number of
Dapps and at the same time function as a major monetary store of value. Also, if utility
protocols turn out to be poor financial investments as the foregoing analysis suggests, how
much investment demand will there be? Finally, in a frictionless, multi-protocol future, why
stockpile a particular token specifically to make a particular type of investment rather than
store your value in the best pure store of value protocol (or in productive investment assets)
and acquire the amount of ETH or any other currency for a particular purpose (including a
subset of investment purposes) at the time of need?
So that leaves the possibility that ETH replaces Bitcoin and becomes the dominant non-
sovereign monetary store of value simply on pure store-of-value merits. We'll go deeper into
the topic of monetary store of value below, but from where we are today, an objective
observer would give Bitcoin significantly higher odds than ETH of becoming such a store of
value. And as for those who argue that you can recreate Bitcoin on top of Ethereum, the
19  Vitalik Buterin Incentives in Casper the Friendly Finality Gadget (v 27 August 20171, p6.
Aleksandr Bulkin https://blog.coinfund.io/platform-currencies-may-soon-be-obsolete-78d9b263d902.
question is, why would you? Why substitute a new sub -token on top of a more complex
protocol with a larger attack surface, shorter track record, less decentralised governance and
propensity to make backwards incompatible protocol changes, for a hugely robust, stable,
proven, and widely accepted protocol that already performs that narrow function very well?
Cryptoassets as Money
Money is a debt ledger with three sub-functions:
I. Store of value
2. Means of payment
3. Unit of account.

Cryptocurrency's performance advantage over incumbent forms of money is (a) strongest and
most obvious as a monetary store of value; (b) stronger for some, but far from all, payments;
and (c) differentiated as a unit of account for a few select purposes.

Cryptocurrency is overwhelmingly better as a monetary store of value than, say, gold. (I
won't enumerate the reasons why, as it's pretty intuitive and has been written about widely.)
As a means of payment, it can perform better than incumbent technologies in specific
instances (think international payments), but Visa, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal and fiat
currency work well and better than cryptocurrency for most day-to-day payments. As a unit
of account, a non-sovereign cryptocurrency could be most useful in international trade, global
commodity markets, foreign reserves, and jurisdictions with unstable domestic currencies.
Before addressing the question of how to think about valuing the payment and the monetary
store of value functions of a cryptocurrency, I'll first examine the link between payments and
monetary store of value. Many observers presume this link to be very strong, but the reality
is more nuanced.

First, let me draw a distinction between a monetary store of value and a run-of-the-mill asset.
A monetary store of value is characterised by having a value that is decoupled from its utility
for other purposes and from the cost of making/extracting and storing it. A warehouse full of
goods, a stockpile of copper and a tankful of petrol are all assets and have value (determined
by the market at the equilibrium point where their marginal utility meets their marginal cost
of manufacture/extraction, i.e., MR = MC). Inventories of assets such as these appear on a
company's balance sheet, but companies seek to minimise how much they have to hold to
carry out their business, given the capital carrying cost. They don't try to accumulate these
inventories to store their retained earnings. Gold, by contrast, is a monetary store of value.
Its value is decoupled at equilibrium from the cost of extracting and storing it. While we may
also use it for jewellery (an ancient way of signalling our wealth to other members of
society), and we use a bit of it for manufacturing electronic goods and other industrial uses,
we also store tonnes of it at great expense in giant inert lumps as a form of savings -a store
of value—with no intent of ever using those lumps for any other purpose. Gold is therefore
arbitrarily expensive relative to its extraction and storage cost. Its value is subjective.
Consider some examples of the things we use as means of payment versus those we use as
monetary stores of value today21:
31 Note that I exclude here things like pre-paid debit cards, gift cards, pre-paid telephone plans and air miles as
they are relatively immaterial to the financial system. As it happens, these can all be used for payments and
are assets but people treat them as working capital (immobilised balance sheet assets with a carrying cost)
rather than a form of savings, so if anything, they are more payment rails than monetary stores of value.

• Means of payment: Visa (credit and debit), SWIFT, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay,
Western Union, physical cash
• Monetary stores of value: Gold, fixed and demand bank deposits, physical cash.

What's interesting is that the only thing that appears as both a means of payment and a
monetary store of value is physical cash. Yet even though physical cash is clearly both a
means of payment and a monetary store of value, individuals typically hold only what's in
their pockets and extract more from a deposit account as they need it. Companies that aren't
retailers typically hold zero or close to zero actual physical cash (instead keeping their
treasury in bank deposits, commercial paper, treasuries, etc.). For a retailer, cash in tills is not
even treated as money but rather as working capital. Bank deposits are a monetary store of
value but are neither a payment rail nor cash; rather they are contractual obligations of a
financial institution operating on a fractional reserve model. When you make a payment, you
can convert the deposit (store of value) into physical cash (payment rail) and pay with the
cash or you use your Visa (payment rail), which is then paid by way of your local interbank
payment network (payment rail) through a change in ledger entries of bank deposits held by
you, Visa and the merchant. Credit cards clearly aren't a store of value. SWIFT is a payment
rail but stores no value. On the other hand, gold is just a monetary store of value but not a
payment rail. No companies keep their accounts and no retailers price their goods in ounces
of gold. No one pays for coffee with gold. But that doesn't dissuade people from using gold
as a store of value.

The reality is that means of payment and monetary stores of value are more generally
separated than combined. The point of all of this is to illustrate that there are lots of means of
payment which don't represent stores of value. It is thus overly simplistic to assume that
people will hoard that which they use to make payments as opposed to converting their store
of value via the payment rail at the time of payment in the exact amount needed and for as
little time as possible.

There is substantial evidence that economic actors choose what to use as a means of payment
and what to use as a monetary store of value somewhat independently of one another, based
on the inherent functional merits and demerits of the `thing' in question as a payment rail or
monetary store of value. Cryptoassets are an interesting special case where, since the
technology is potentially advantageous compared to incumbent forms of money as a
monetary store of value and also for some payments, it is possible that a single cryptoasset
might successfully compete as both. (The counterargument is that, because it is likely to be
effectively frictionless to convert between two cryptocurrencies, it will be even easier to
disaggregate the payment and store of value functions than it is with incumbent forms of
money.)
A useful thought experiment in this regard is to imagine there are competing cryptocurrencies
that have the following hypothetical relative utility scores across the five key characteristics
of money:
Utility (10 high -1
low) Coin A Coin B Coin C
Scarcity 10 2 7
Durability 10 3 7
Portability 6 10 7
Divisibility 6 10 7
Acceptability 3 10 7
Total 35 35 35
When the dust settles, what will be the outcome? Which hypothetical coin will be the
dominant payment rail and which one the dominant monetary store of value? Will Coin C
be the one coin to rule them all?22 Or will Coin A emerge as the dominant monetary store of
value and Coin B the dominant payment rail with users converting as required between the
two? Much will depend on the technical and political trade-offs in creating cryptoassets that
score relatively higher or lower on each of the five dimensions, but I lean towards the view
that specialisation combined with protocol interoperability is a more likely equilibrium than
one coin to rule them all.

It would be rash to go so far as to dismiss payments functionality as a necessary feature of a
dominant monetary store of value (despite gold having none). A cryptoasset aspiring to be
the dominant monetary store of value should prudently strive to have reasonably good
payment functionality (divisibility, fungibility, acceptability); the more the better, provided
that its monetary store of value functionality (scarcity and durability) isn't compromised.
Poor or no payment functionality could impair a cryptoasset's ability to be adopted as a
monetary store of value, so it's an important feature. But the point of all of this is to observe
that a cryptoasset with the strongest monetary store of value functionality and with good but
perhaps not the strongest payment functionality has a strong chance of winning out as the
dominant store of value. Payments functionality in a monetary store of value cryptoasset is a
satisficing, rather than a maximising, condition.

By corollary, just because a cryptoasset has an edge in payments doesn't mean it will
automatically become a store of value. To wit, the only means of payment listed above that
is also a store of value is physical cash. If a cryptoasset like Ripple is better for payments
(cheaper transactions and more bank support) but weaker as a store of value than Bitcoin (due
to centralisation of governance and supply uncertainty), it's unlikely that Ripple will win out
as a store of value. And just because users employ some utility cryptoasset (such as ETH) for
practical purposes, it doesn't mean that they will see it as a monetary store of value and hoard
it as a form of savings rather than treat it as working capital to be minimised on their balance
sheets by buying just as much ETH as needed when needed.

22 A crypto-spork? The crypto equivalent of that hybrid spoon and fork that no one uses because it's not as
good as a fork in piercing solids nor as good as a spoon in transporting liquids. Insightful humour credit:
https://medium.comi@hamptonfischeribitcoin-cash-a-spork-7f9f6230a57.  Or rather, a crypto-fpoon? But I
digress.

What does all of this mean for assessing the potential value of cryptoassets as money? First,
you should look at payment functionality valuation and monetary store-of-value valuation as
two separate and additive things. You should then consider the relative functional strength of
the cryptoasset you are valuing on payment and store -of-value dimensions compared to
competing cryptoassets, to check that extreme weakness on one dimension doesn't result in
weakness on the other dimension; you shouldn't just assume that payments and monetary
store of value are inseparable. The network value of a hypothetical cryptoasset that ends up
serving as both a monetary store of value and a payment rail can be thought of on a sum -of-
the-parts basis, where (total network value) = (monetary store-of-value valuation) + (means
of payment valuation).

What do I think could be the equilibrium outcome? A very credible scenario is that you end
up with a mix of non-sovereign cryptocurrencies, sovereign digital currencies, off-
chain/layer-two payment solutions and evolved versions of centralised payment systems such
as Visa, PayPal and Apple/Google Pay, competing in payments (with each having different
strengths and weaknesses for specific types of payments), along with a single dominant non-
sovereign monetary store of value, playing a role much like that of gold today. That monetary
store of value could also replace a significant portion of foreign reserves and perhaps become
a unit of account for international trade and commodities.

It seems likely that payments will remain a fragmented market and that sovereign digital
currencies, off-chain (censorship -resistant or not) payment solutions and centralised payment
systems will successfully compete for the vast majority of global payment volumes, most of
which are small, domestic and mundane, and where speed and cost matter more than strong
censorship -resistance. In this scenario, non-sovereign, censorship -resistant, decentralised
payment protocols could end up being a niche product for international payments, markets
with a failed domestic sovereign currency or payments where censorship -resistance is
important (capital controls, sanctions, political repression, illicit activity). I can imagine
sovereign states creating regulations that favour use of sovereign digital currencies rather
than non-sovereign cryptocurrencies for domestic payments to help them retain control over
domestic monetary policy and taxation. It's worth highlighting that, while sovereign digital
currencies will probably successfully compete with non-sovereign payment-focused
cryptocurrencies for payment volumes, they will likely facilitate the emergence of a non-
sovereign monetary store of value, since their existence will help to eliminate the on- and off-
ramp banking issues and friction currently involved in exchanging fiat for crypto.

To preview what follows, monetary store-of-value functionality is potentially far more
valuable than payments functionality. Thus, if a monetary store -of-value cryptocurrency also
works well as a means of payment, that's just a little additional value upside. What matters
far more to us as investors is store of value.
Payments
Proceeding from the general observations at the beginning of this paper, a means of payment,
examined in isolation from the monetary store -of-value function, is just another utility
protocol where the value of the token cannot decouple from M = PQN of the computing
resource maintaining the payment blockchain. Payments on a large scale must be cost
efficient. To the extent a cryptoasset is both a store of value and major payment rail, in order
to be cost-efficient and competitive as a means of payment, the payment part will have to be
economically disassociated from the store-of-value function, such that the incremental M for
payments still equals PQN for the computing resources facilitating the payment function and
where V can go very high. This dissociation can be achieved by way of an explicit
mechanism like Ethereum's GAS; by way of various scaling solutions like off-chain
transaction processing; and/or by emphasising transaction fees rather than block rewards in
rewarding the mining network. The effect of something like Layer 2 transaction processing
is to massively increase V (and reduce M) for the payment component of the sum-of-parts
valuation of a cryptoasset.

Blockchain payments will in fact be worth (to token-holders) much less than their centralised
counterparts like Visa, Apple/Google Pay and PayPal are worth today. It is incorrect to think
that because a cryptoasset serves as a payment rail, owners of the token in the system would
own something comparable to the enterprise value of, say, Visa divided by the number of
tokens issued. Rather, at mature equilibrium, the network value of such a token would be M
= PQN where PQ is just the aggregate cost of the computing resources to run the chain
(which may be thought of as the annual IT budget of an equivalent -volume incumbent
payment system multiplied by some coefficient to adjust for the relative computing
inefficiency of decentralised vs. centralised architectures) and V is of course some (probably
high) velocity. The value implied by the correct valuation framework of M = PQN is much,
much lower than the enterprise value of the incumbents. Blockchain payments may disrupt
and displace the incumbents to the enormous benefit of users, but the value of these protocols
as expressed through their tokens will be much less than the value of the disrupted
enterprises.

An additional factor to consider is the extent to which companies and individuals choose to
keep an inventory of payment tokens as working capital on their balance sheets. The
question is how strong this working capital driver will actually be. Companies and
individuals hold very little physical cash. To the extent they hold cash-equivalents as a buffer
against uncertainty, they hold it in the same currency in which they incur expenses, which
will play to the advantage of sovereign digital currencies and incumbent payment systems
unless retailers and suppliers begin to reprice directly in cryptocurrency units on a large scale.
Except for users who make lots of international payments, who are primarily engaged in
international or commodity -based trade or who operate in economies with weak domestic
currencies, it may not make a lot of sense to maintain a significant stock of a non-sovereign -
denominated payment rail cryptocurrency. In a crypto-native world, moving from one
cryptoasset to another (for example from a store-of-value cryptoasset to a means-of-payment
cryptoasset or converting between alternative payment cryptoassets) will be trivial,
immediate and frictionless. What would the rationale be for holding an inventory of a given
means-of-payment cryptoasset?
It's also worth reflecting on the difference between cash equivalents, such as deposits at a
fractional reserve bank, and physical cash, and how that distinction reads over to a
cryptoasset. If there is no fractional reserve banking system available for the cryptoasset,
users may opt to store their value in yielding fiat-denominated deposits while keeping a low
inventory of the payment rail cryptoasset rather than have a large holding of a cryptoasset
that doesn't yield anything, or they may lend their cryptoassets out by buying yielding
cryptoasset-denominated bonds and commercial paper. 23
Finally, in thinking about the potential value of the payments function of a single non-
sovereign cryptocurrency, it's noteworthy that, while there clearly are network effects in
payments (Visa is more useful and worth more as a business than Diners Club because it's
accepted by more merchants and used by more consumers), payments today do appear to be a
23 Note that both of these things increase the money multiplier and effectively decrease the scarcity of the
cryptoasset in question.

structurally somewhat fragmented space. How many non-sovereign monetary stores of value
are held in portfolios? Gold is pretty much it. Now think about how many different payment
rails you've used over the past month: physical cash (perhaps in multiple currencies), Visa,
Amex, PayPal, direct debit, SWIFT, etc. They were all good and reasonably fit for purpose
in slightly different ways and with slightly different features for a specific payment: cash to
tip the porter, Visa to pay on Amazon, Amex to buy a plane ticket and get the points, PayPal
to pay on that dodgy website you don't trust with your card number, direct debit to pay your
utilities bill, SWIFT for an international transfer. We should always be careful not to assume
the new paradigm will function like the old paradigm (in the 90s, for example, we imagined
old media online rather than social media). But we can arrive at the expectation that payments
will be a fragmented space by applying first principles rather than extrapolating from the
present. Moving among cryptoassets will be frictionless, and there are lots of nuanced
differences across payment instances. It's thus more likely that we'll use lots of different
payment rails based on how their respective features mesh with the circumstances. Time will
tell what those will be, but it's not hard to come up with an initial list of possibilities: fully-
autonomous smart contract payments that require a Turing -complete language overlay,
payments where speed is of the essence or where cost is of the essence, payments where
security or anonymity dominate, cases where one merchant simply accepts Litecoin while
another takes Dash and many, many others.

In sum, I can imagine constant innovation and an ever-changing, fragmented, increasingly
competitive payments landscape. This stands in contrast to monetary store of value, where
leadership tends to strengthen over time. Path dependency is likely to be much stronger in
store of value than means of payment. While there is some value in a payment rail exclusive
of monetary store-of-value value, it is relatively low. Absence of payment functionality may
hinder a cryptoasset's monetary store of value utility, but there are many examples where that
isn't the case and where payment functionality doesn't translate into store of value, so any
causality is weak.
Monetary Store of Value
I would argue that one cryptocurrency will likely become the dominant non-sovereign
monetary store of value, because it's not clear what utility having two or more of them would
add. Gold is the one dominant monetary store of value that isn't a fiat currency or tied to
one. Yes, there's silver, but the value of all silver is a tiny fraction of the value of all gold,
only about 20% of annual silver demand (worth about USD 3.3 billion in 2016) is for
monetary uses24, and it's trivial from a financial markets perspective. Why would we need
multiple cryptocurrencies serving as non-fiat monetary stores of value? What utility would
that add?
That brings us to the matter of quantifying the potential future value of the dominant store -of-
value cryptoasset—and therefore the upside relative to today's value. If a cryptoasset
becomes a dominant non-fiat monetary store of value, a logical place to start in estimating its
potential network value is as a fraction or a multiple of the value of the total stock of the
current technology filling that role, i.e., gold, which has a total value of USD 7.8 trillion.'-5
The question of what fraction or multiple to apply is more subjective. You may feel it will be
hard or take a very long time for a cryptoasset to fully replace gold, which has been around
for millennia, in which case you think it will be a fraction. Or you may argue that the
3' https://www.silverinstitute.org/silver-supply-demand/
25 USD 7.8 trillion = total estimated gold above ground of 187,200 metric tonnes x 32,150.7 troy ounces per
metric tonne x USD 1,292 per troy ounce on 21 August 2017, the date this section was written.
technical advantages in terms of divisibility and portability in particular will mean that more
of the world's population will hold this cryptoasset than they do gold (anyone with a
smartphone, a memory stick or a paper wallet can hold any quantity of a cryptoasset, but
carrying and storing investment gold is more difficult). That cryptoasset, moreover, will
likely play some role in payments while gold does not.

To try to bring some objectivity to this last question, let's look at the breakdown of where
gold is today. Of total above ground stocks of gold of 187,200 metric tonnes, 38% is in the
form of bullion holdings, of which a little less than half was held by the official sector (i.e.,
national treasuries) and the remainder by the private sector. The remainder of above -ground
gold is almost all in the form of fabricated products, which breaks down roughly into 80%
jewellery and 20% industrial products. 26
With those building blocks you can play with your own different scenarios of what success
looks like. I'll develop a strawman scenario for consideration below.

While some jewellery may be notionally held for investment purposes, and there may be
some collectible coins in the fabricated products number that holders think of as
`investments', I broadly exclude fabricated products, as a cryptoasset isn't a substitute for the
vast majority if not all of those uses. Instead I focus on the bullion holdings. Because of
cryptoassets' superior features over gold and its additional utility advantage for some
payments, we might assume that a successfully dominant cryptoasset store of value being
worth at maturity 1 — 3x private bullion holdings. Because national treasuries may be slower
and reluctant to adapt, I'll suggest an assumption at a ten-year horizon of 0.25 — lx official
bullion holdings. Breaking the 38% of gold represented by bullion into 20% private and 18%
official holdings and using the foregoing assumptions, we would estimate that the dominant
store-of-value crypto could be worth 25 — 78%22 of total gold stocks at maturity, i.e., USD
1.9 — 6.1 trillion.

Displacing gold bullion could, however, just be the tip of the iceberg. Gold represents a little
less than 11% of the USD 12.7 trillion of total international reserves, with fiat currencies
making up 86% and IMF Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) and IMF-related assets the
remaining 3%.n  The fiat currency portion is made up of 63% USD, 20% EUR and the
remainder other currencies (most significantly GBP, JPY and CHF).

We need to separate fiat currencies' use for domestic payments from their use as international
reserves. As stated above, there are good reasons to be sceptical about how significant a
portion of domestic payments a non-sovereign cryptoasset will replace outside of countries
with unstable sovereign currencies, namely: the existence of incumbent low cost and efficient
centralised payment rails, the unwillingness of states to give up control over domestic
monetary policy and the inevitability of sovereign digital currencies. But think how
uncomfortable a situation it is for countries to hold the bulk of their international reserves in
other countries' fiat currencies. We know that China and Russia in particular chafe at this
situation. They would love to have an alternative to the USD and EUR and have even talked
about creating an alternative (which didn't go very far, since creating such an alternative
would require their trusting each other). Think about how difficult it must be for the Chinese
to have exports often priced in USD and for commodity -producing nations that commodities
are priced globally in USD. Furthermore, any USD-based transactions must pass through
26 GFMS Gold Survey 2017 p.36
27 Low end: ((20%" 1) + (18% " 0.25)) = 25%; High end: ((20% • 3) + (18%* 1.0)) = 78%.
28 As of 28 April2017. International Monetary Fund 2017 Annual Report. Note that on 28 April2017 an IMF
Special Drawing Right = 1.371020 USD.

SWIFT, which is controlled by the US, and exclusion from SWIFT would be tantamount to
near-complete isolation from the international financial system (witness Iran). This is an
increasingly untenable situation for many sovereigns, particularly as the global power and
influence of the US wanes. A non-sovereign, non-fiat, trustless, censorship -resistant
cryptoasset would be a far better alternative for most foreign currency international reserves.
IMF SDRs are already a synthetic store of value, so could also be easily and sensibly
replaced by such a cryptoasset.

Building on our gold bullion analysis above to put some numbers around the potential
implications for the network value of our monetary store-of-value cryptoasset, we might
assume that it replaces somewhere between 0.25x and 0.75x of non-gold international
reserves. My low-end assumption is fairly arbitrary but my high-end assumption reflects the
likelihood that states will want to diversify their foreign reserves to some extent as they
already do in holding fiat currencies other than the USD. These assumptions would add a
further USD 2.8 - 8.5 trillion in value to our dominant monetary store -of-value cryptoasset.
Adding these amounts to our gold bullion-based numbers above gives a total potential value
range for our dominant monetary store-of-value cryptoasset of USD 4.7 — 14.6 trillion."
I'll stop there for now, but there are two further upsides that I haven't explicitly taken into
account. First, it could make sense for such a cryptoasset to replace the USD as the standard
unit of account for global trade and commodity prices. Trade- and commodity -centric firms
may therefore choose to capitalise themselves in such a cryptoasset, creating further demand
for its limited supply, mitigated by the inevitable emergence of fractional reserve banking and
bond markets denominated in the cryptoasset which would increase its money multiplier.
Second, such a cryptoasset will likely be used for some payments, such as international
payments or domestic payments in countries without stable sovereign currencies (where this
is already happening). This latter potential is at least somewhat, if not fully, captured in the
high end of the range above in the sense that, when we start thinking about this cryptoasset
store of value representing a multiple of private gold bullion holdings, we are implicitly
already accounting for some displacement of physical cash holdings. 30 As explained in the
previous section, the incremental sum-of-parts value contribution from the payments
functionality arguably won't be that significant compared to the store -of-value component, so
ignoring it here probably doesn't very materially impact the potential value target.
The next question is, which cryptocurrency has the highest probability today of becoming the
dominant store of value? It seems to me that the probable answer based on the information in
our possession today is Bitcoin (BTC). It has more users; has decentralised (to the point of
dysfunctional) governance; has more hashing power than any other crypto; is highly stable
and robust; has been around longest; and has never been hacked. Other cryptoassets may
have features that Bitcoin doesn't have that are useful in sundry use cases other than store of
value, but store of value is a simple functionality (perhaps the simplest of all the cryptoasset
use cases), and Bitcoin has been and continues to acquit that functionality flawlessly. Critics
point to the conflictual politics that complicate changes to Bitcoin's code, but seen purely
through a monetary -store-of-value lens, that can be seen as more of a feature than a bug. It
seems to me that it is far more likely that Bitcoin becomes the dominant store -of-value crypto
than some other existing or future contender that isn't Bitcoin. If Bitcoin were to become the
dominant monetary store of value cryptoasset, based on my total mature network value
2° Total international reserves of USD 12.6 trillion, of which 89% non-gold reserves = USD 11.3 trillion. Low
end: USD 11.3 trillion x 25% = USD 2.8 trillion; high end: USD 11.3 trillion x 75% = USD 8.5 trillion.
3° To give some bounded idea of the potential value of displacement of some domestic fiat currency holdings,
global MO is about USD 5 trillion, so we'd be talking about a relatively small fraction of that.
estimate of USD 4.7 — 14.6 trillion, it would be worth approximately USD 260,000 - 800,000
per BTC at maturity.

We should pause here to think about how long the emergence of a cryptoasset as a dominant
monetary store of value might take. On the one hand, gold has been around for millennia, so
the mental paradigm shift required might take longer than 10 years and never occur fully. On
the other hand, we rode horses for transportation for millennia and moved on from that pretty
quickly and categorically with the advent of the superior technology of the motorcar. That
transition required a major build-out of physical infrastructure while the one that interests us
here requires little more than a shift in mindset. Also, financial markets tend to discount the
future as soon as there is consensus about it, so the value per Bitcoin could anticipate the
levels of adoption I'm holding up for consideration. (For a more extensive discussion of this
topic, see below for Addendum on Pace of BTC Price Rise)
Regarding risk, an investment with a 20x - 60x upside32 only requires a probability of
success of between 2% to 5% to be a positive net expected value investment. Each of us can
reflect on his own view of what that the probability is of the foregoing scenario materialising.
I'm personally pretty comfortable that, given where we are today in Bitcoin's development
and adoption, that the probability is higher than 2 — 5%, likely much higher. While there are
many technical, political, regulatory and psychological hurdles ahead, the store -of-value use
case is by far the simplest one, and already closest to reality. I would argue therefore that
here you have an investment with a downside:upside skew of -lx : 60x and a positive net
expected value. Investments with both those characteristics are extremely rare.

While this paper isn't focused on analysing the risks ahead, it's interesting to observe that, of
all the potential use cases for cryptoassets, monetary store of value is the one with the least
technological risk. While Bitcoin will continue to evolve and improve over time (hopefully
becoming more scalable, more fungible, etc.) and those improvements represent upsides, it
doesn't in fact need to improve (or at least not materially) in order to replace gold and most
foreign reserves. The existing state of the software and the existing network infrastructure is
basically in place for this basic gold 2.0 / foreign reserves 2.0 function. Pretty much all that
is required for that to happen is adoption and a change in popular and institutional perception
and attitudes. In contrast, the more significant EVM-type ambitions of decentralised utility
protocols require a number of technical advances and significant investments in infrastructure
beyond what we have today. It is reasonable to believe those advances will occur in time,
and we should all hope that they do, as they have the potential to make the world a better
place, but it is obviously a longer, riskier path.

It is often proposed that Bitcoin's lead as the emergent dominant crypto monetary store of
value could be usurped by another existing or future cryptoasset. This is true, but as
Bayesians, we arrive at our views using probabilities based on the information at our disposal
and update them as new information emerges. Based on the current information available to
us, Bitcoin has the highest probability of becoming the dominant crypto monetary store of
value, and that probability would appear to be high enough (greater than 5%) to make it a
rational investment. As new information emerges regarding existing and new contenders for
31 To arrive at this target price, I have used a fully-diluted number of BTC of 21 million2.8 million = 18.2
million. While the total number of BTC that will ever be issued is fixed at 21 million, blockchain analytics firm
Chainalysis estimates that 2.8 - 3.8 million BTC have probably already been permanently lost and are
unrecoverable. Even if some of these BTC are later recovered, it is reasonable to expect that more BTC will be
lost over time, so using the low-end estimate of 2.8 million for our purposes here seems reasonable.
32 At the time of this update in late December 2017, BTC was trading at around USD 13,000.
the monetary store of value crown, we can and should update our assessment. So far, as
Bitcoin's price has risen, so have its odds of success. For now, Bitcoin appears to remain a
rational bet.

The question of forks often comes up and whether forks of Bitcoin undermine its scarcity.
Because they share same hash power, Bitcoin forks will either need to demonstrate some
differentiated and valuable niche functionality compared to BTC, or they will wither and die
in time. As long as BTC continues to perform well as a non-sovereign, monetary store of
value, any such differentiated functionality will likely need to focus on less valuable use
cases. It's possible that a Bitcoin fork finds such a non-store-of-value use case and survives
with some relatively low, sustainable value reflecting the niche functionality it has addressed.
It's also possible that the market assigns some fractional value for some period of time to an
alternative store-of-value fork either irrationally (an ideological schism occurs and self-
sustains for a little while) or as a kind of ace-in-the-hole back-up against some corruption of
the main blockchain. In the end, the equilibrium outcome is more likely to be a single,
dominant, monetary store of value, and it currently appears more likely that that will be BTC.
For an investor who already owns BTC, the prudent investment strategy is simply to hold
onto any forked versions that credibly appear to have a sustainable use case and value as they
are received. For a new investor, it probably doesn't make sense allocating capital to prior
forks due to their lower probability of success and their relatively niche potential value.
BTC v BCH
This is a good juncture to touch on the recent Bitcoin Cash (BCH) fork from Bitcoin (BTC)
in August and the subsequent community ideological split behind them following the
abandonment of the 2x fork in November. BTC appears to be focusing first on being a
censorship -resistant store of value and improving its scalability over the long term, foremost
through second -layer solutions; BCH is focused on immediate payments competitiveness
through on-chain scaling. At the time of writing, BCH is cheaper for payments than BTC,
acceptance of BCH for payments appears to be growing, and there are doubts in some
quarters about both the timing and degree of success of BTC's second -layer scaling efforts.
On the other hand, BCH is seen as weaker as a store of value and to have a weaker
development team. BCH would just be another alt-coin as far as BTC is concerned but for
(a) potential user confusion due to the similarity of the names and the ownership of the
domain bitcoin.com by one of BCH's promoters, who actively claims that BCH is the `true
Bitcoin'; (b) the fact that BCH and BTC share and compete for the same hash power; and (c)
the fact that BCH is being promoted by individuals with significant BTC holdings, who run
large exchanges and wallet companies and hold sway over a significant amount (maybe more
than 50% collectively) of hash power. Factor (b) raises the concern that, because BTC's
difficulty adjustment is fortnightly while BCH's is daily, a significant increase in the price of
BCH relative to BTC would cause hash power to swing away from BTC to BCH, slowing or
halting BTC block times until the next BTC difficulty adjustment. 33 Factor (c) means that
BCH's main backers may try to attack BTC by various means with a non-zero probability of
success.

This blog post and this blog post go into scenarios in which the price of BCH could increase
in the short run relative to the price of BTC. In a nutshell, if such price swings are temporary,
so should be the disruption caused by them, and as a store of value BTC is less sensitive
(store-of-value use implies generally larger, less time-sensitive transactions) to this kind of
short term disruption than BCH is as a means of payment (generally smaller, time-sensitive
33 You can follow the swings in hashrate between BIC and BCH here.

transactions). Furthermore, this disruption in block times assumes transaction fees are held
constant, but in reality transaction fees can adjust upwards to defend against short term
attacks to keep hash power allocated to BTC and keep blocks moving, especially again
because BTC functions more as a store of value than as a means of payment and as such is
less sensitive to fluctuations in transaction fees.

The easiest and most prudent way to hedge against this risk is simply to own the same
number of both tokens.' But if forced to get off the fence, the implications of the investment
thesis laid out in this paper are that we should bet on store-of-value strength over means-of-
payment strength, as we expect the former to be worth more than the latter over time. By
focusing on the competitive and commoditised payments space, BCH is fighting for a place
in a structurally fragmented use case where it doesn't really seem to do anything new or
better compared to existing payment rail cryptocurrencies such as Dash and Litecoin, 35 not to
mention the sovereign digital currencies that will soon appear; BTC is currently out ahead on
its own as the leading crypto monetary store of value, a use case that is less prone to
fragmentation and more likely to be dominated by a single cryptoasset. If BTC is the
stronger store of value, it should remain more valuable than BCH and profit-driven miners
should continue to allocate more hash power to it over the long run. Tortoise and hare-style,
there's also a good chance that BTC's various second -layer development efforts will make it
more relevant for payments, smart contracts and the like over time, providing potential
upsides beyond the core store-of-value case.
Conclusion
Due to protocols being open-source, the ability to fork, the competitiveness of mining and the
importance of relative cost to adoption levels, the value of utility protocol tokens will at
equilibrium not decouple from an M = PQN valuation, where PQ is the total cost of the
computing resources required to maintain the blockchains. This value will likely be
relatively low due to the very high potential values of V (velocity) and will be deflationary in
line with deflation in the cost of processing power, storage and bandwidth and due to
scalability-enhancing innovation.

Public blockchain technology is an incredibly powerful engine for creating significant user
surplus, but that surplus will go to users, not to token holders or miners. Investing in utility
tokens is in the end tantamount to investing to own a bit of the currency used to operate a big,
commoditised, perfectly competitive SaaS business that itself earns no sustainable economic
rent. There will be some value there, but perhaps not much. It is possible, and in fact quite
reasonable, to construct very bullish protocol adoption scenarios where the equilibrium
network values are very low and lower than the current network values of utility protocols
such as Ethereum.

While the scale of use of utility protocols may be very large (caveated by the fact that the
inherent redundancy of trustless, censorship -resistant consensus mechanisms compared to
centralised ones makes them more expensive to operate and therefore only economically
relevant for a subset of potential use cases), the potentially very high velocity suggests that
this future mature equilibrium value may be thought of as something in the tens or hundreds
of billions of USD in aggregate. A sizeable amount, no doubt, but perhaps not sufficiently
3° The BCH:BTC price is currently hovering around 20% and even if BCH fails to win dominance it is likely to
persist and retain value for some time, so the cost of the hedge isn't huge.

Bitcoin Cash's main selling points relative to other payment rail cryptocurrencies seems to be that its name
includes the word 'Bitcoin' and that holders of BTC on 1 August 2017 received BCH for free in the fork.
attractive compared to the current -$250 billion of network value of all alt coins combined to
provide an attractive risk/retum for investors from where we are today.

In the context of evaluating cryptoassets as money and in a world where value can be moved
among protocols with little or no friction, a cryptoasset can be a monetary store of value
without being most efficient for payments or a great means of payment without being a store
of value. We can therefore look at the potential value of a cryptoasset's monetary store of
value function separately from its payments functionality. Monetary store of value
functionality will likely be one or two orders of magnitude more valuable than means of
payment functionality.

Payments are likely to be fragmented and transaction volumes shared across a range of
sovereign digital currencies, off-chain payment systems, centralised payment systems and
multiple non-sovereign cryptocurrencies, each with their respective strengths and weaknesses
for specific payment instances. This, combined with the fact that payment functionality is
analogous to utility protocols and will therefore be valued on a M = PQN basis, means that
the means of payment value of any given cryptocurrency will be relatively low.

In contrast, the potential value of a winning monetary store of value protocol can be
measured in relation to the total value of gold bullion and foreign reserves, suggesting a
potential value in the USD 4.7 — 14.6 trillion range. If Bitcoin were to become that monetary
store of value (and it currently appears to be the strongest contender by some margin), it
could be worth USD 260,000 - 800,000 per BTC, i.e., 20 — 60x its current value. If one
places a higher than -5% chance of Bitcoin succeeding in this way, it is a rational and
attractive investment for a long-term investor before considering other potential upsides
stemming from payments and unit of account utility. Investing in other cryptoassets based on
use cases other than monetary store of value appears less compelling.

Let's be clear. This could all go substantially to zero for various reasons. Being `right' in an
investment with a high risk of failure but a highly positively -skewed distribution of potential
outcomes is about getting the a priori probabilities right (as adjusted for new information as
it arises) and getting position sizing right. Provided you accept that Bitcoin's net expected
value is positive, even marginally so, the right answer on position sizing isn't zero. Nor of
course is it 100% of assets. For those stuck at the step of whether or not to invest, the logical
thing to do is to move past that point and focus on position sizing. If you're more sceptical,
invest less. If more confident, invest more. But even for the most sceptical, you might
constructively ask yourself, why wouldn't you invest USD 1? Well, rationally, you probably
would. Now how about USD 2? Repeat until you get to your Bayesian optimal position size.
Given the significant risk of loss, in most circumstances the correct answer is probably a
long-term, buy-and-hold, unlevered investment of a low single-digit percentage of assets (at
cost).
Addendum: Thoughts on pace of BTC price rise
9 December 2017
How alarmed should we be about the recent rapid run-up in the price of Bitcoin? We read
every day now that the speed of the increase itself is a tell-tale sign of a bubble.
Let's think further about how long it could or should take Bitcoin to reach its long-term
equilibrium value and the shape of the path it might follow. When considering the potential
or appropriate pace of price discovery for different kinds of cryptoassets, we again need to
distinguish between utility protocols (including means-of-payment protocols) and a monetary
store of value protocol.

When we value the shares of a growing company, we discount our expectations of future cash
flows based on the expected growth path of the business in acquiring customers, building its
team, building out its infrastructure for delivering value to customers, developing its
technology or products, etc. at some discount rate that reflects our assessment of how much
risk there is around the realisation of those expectations. This means that a company's
shares can be overvalued at price x at time to but undervalued at the same price x at time tn.
To frame this with an example, it is not necessarily inconsistent to say that Amazon was
overvalued at $107 per share in 1999 even though it trades at $1,162 per share in 2017.
Amazon has grown exponentially and navigated tremendous risks while competitors have
progressively ceded market share and while the economy and the markets Amazon serves
grew over those 18 years. If you had bought shares when they first peaked around $107 in
December 1999 and held them until December 2017 at $1,162 per share, you would have
made a 14% annual rate of return. In hindsight that would have been a very good investment,
but there are a lot of other companies you could have invested in at 1999 prices that would
have been bad investments and it was very difficult to know a priori that Amazon would be
an exception. A 14% return arguably wasn't all that great, or certainly not excessive, based
on a reasonable assessment of the risks in 1999. If you had sat down at the time to do a DCF
valuation of Amazon in 2000 and were discounting a set of financial projections reflecting
what actually happened, you would have reasonably applied a higher discount rate than 14%.
You could have earned a similar return investing for example in a fairly pedestrian diversified
leveraged buyout fund with arguably much less risk of loss of capital.

What does all this have to do with how long it could or should take a cryptoasset to
appreciate in price? Similar to the shares in a company' 6, the growth of the value of a utility
protocol (including a payments protocol) should accompany the growth in the number of
users, volume of use/transactions, buildout of the network (for example, merchants accepting
a particular payment protocol or the installed base of IoT devices running a kind of smart
contract), progress in following any development roadmap, etc. So, when we say ETH
should be worth $52 billion 10 years, we aren't saying it should be worth $52 billion today.
Lots has to happen to make it worth $52 billion in 10 years. Accordingly, you should
discount the $52 billion back to the present using some discount rate reflecting the perceived
risk of that actually happening, versus something better or worse.

A monetary store of value protocol works completely differently in terms of the potential (or
even appropriate) timing and pace of price appreciation. Provided a monetary store of value
protocol and the network running it is technically capable of acquitting its function as a
monetary store of value (as arguably is already the case of BTC), the pace of it reaching its
mature equilibrium value is as fast or slow as the pace of collective mindsets seeing it as
such. This could take centuries or only as long as it takes synapses to fire. The value of a bar
of gold or of a Picasso at a point in time is simply the value we collectively assign to it. Of
course, that value might still evolve over time along with the accumulated wealth of our
society and the size of our economy, but it is decoupled from some path of growing cash
flows or expected cash flows.

If we relate this back to the potential equilibrium value of a dominant non-sovereign
monetary store of value, there are two distinct steps, each of which could take a very long
time or only days/weeks/months and with a long or short hiatus between the two. Of the
overall potential value estimate of USD 4.7 — 14.6 trillion, USD 1.5 — 4.7 trillion is based on
private sector holdings and USD 3.2 — 9.9 trillion on public sector holdings. The first step is
36 The analogy to equity is used narrowly here in the context of price appreciation. As discussed above, utility
protocols are akin to money supply, not equity, in other respects.

for private investors to reach a consensus that it is a strong monetary store of value. It could
take a very long time for private investors to reach this consensus, or the network value could
simply gap up to that level in a matter of weeks or months as adoption moves from just retail
investors to institutional and retail investors. This is the stage we're in the middle of today
with BTC. Until 2017, BTC ownership was predominantly a retail investor phenomenon,
dominated by techie early adopters and some UHNWIs and family offices with connections
to tech.' Then, over the course of 2017, we saw a proliferation of crypto-focused funds (still
collectively only representing an estimated USD 2 — 3 billion across 119 funds38). While
both those groups continue to grow, we are now seeing the much larger collective firepower
of mainstream hedge funds, family offices and (U)HNWIs starting to come in. This could
very easily turn into a stampede for the entrance and value could very credibly gap up to at
least the low-end private-sector target of USD 1.5 trillion in a matter of months, with
subsequent growth to the high-end private-sector target of USD 4.7 trillion happening more
slowly over the course of two or three years. The potentially rapid move to USD 1.5 trillion
would imply a BTC price of USD 112,000 based on the current number of BTC39 (potentially
relevant given the short time frame being considered) or USD 86,000 fully-diluted'.
The speed with which this move, especially the first leg of it, could happen is accentuated by
the fact that Bitcoin ownership is concentrated; that most Bitcoin haven't changed hands
since the price was in the double digits; 01 and that these owners have high conviction and
high long-term BTC price expectations and have already weathered tremendous volatility for
years without blinking. Fewer than perhaps I million BTC effectively circulate at all, and
any new money will be forced to compete mostly for those, so the propensity for price to gap
up as new institutional money flows in is high.

The second step is adoption by public institutions as a store of value and as a replacement of
gold and foreign fiat in countries' international reserves. Of course, this could take a very
long time, even after the private sector has embraced and accepted it. Governments move
slowly. Decision processes are political. On the other hand, as soon as one government is
known to have bought its first Bitcoin into its reserves, we could see a second stampede for
the entrance as national treasuries around the world realise they need to diversify at least
some of their reserves into Bitcoin before all their rivals do or be left at a strategic
disadvantage. So here again, we could see a rapid addition to total network value of the low-
end public-sector network value estimate of another USD 3.2 trillion, with that subsequently
growing to the high-end target of USD 9.9 trillion (in addition to the private sector value
above) over a few years.

The above scenario suggests that the price of BTC could increase by a very steep slope in the
very near term as network value moves quickly to USD 1.5 trillion, then a flatter slope as
private sector adoption matures towards USD 4.7 trillion and before the first adoption by
countries as a component of international reserves. Then we could see another steep slope
addition of USD 3.2 trillion to BTC's network value as countries stampede to the entrance,
followed by a slower slope appreciation to USD 9.9 trillion of public sector adoption.
An interesting aside is that, with the shares of a company or the price of a utility cryptoasset,
the higher the price from time to time, the higher the risk. For Bitcoin, paradoxically, the
37 And people lucky enough to count Wences Casares as a friend.
aa hitS://WWW.hfalen.COM/SearCh.DRARTICLE=175427
3916.7 million BTC in existence less estimated 2.8 million lost BTC = 13.9 million BTC.
c' 21 million BTC maximum less estimated 2.8 million lost BTC = 18.2 million BTC.
https://bitinfocharts.com/too-100-richest-bitcoin-addresses.html
opposite may be true up to a point and for certain periods. Right now, Bitcoin is still an
insignificant curiosity to the financial markets, with a network value of just USD 218 billion.
If and when it breaks through the USD 1 trillion level, it will likely be seen and accepted as a
fully-fledged asset class and the financial world will go about building out complete financial
markets infrastructure (full suite of derivatives, more robust and liquid exchanges and trading
platforms, more custody options). That, combined with broadening private and public
institutional ownership over time, will serve to consolidate Bitcoin's position as a monetary
store of value and reduce risk. Of course, if at some point price starts to overshoot the
potential value estimates for the relevant stage of adoption we're in, we could reasonably
begin to worry. But let's cross that bridge if and when we come to it.

Consistent with the overall approach of this paper, the point of the foregoing isn't to say that
the above necessarily will happen but rather to look at what reasonably could happen.
Depending on what stage of the adoption path we are on and where we are relative to long-
term potential network value and the interim milestone value points along the way, it may be
entirely reasonable for the price to move up by a lot in a very short period. Such moves don't
necessarily reflect irrational, bubble behaviour.
EFTA00811649 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2017-12-31)
Valuation Report
12/31/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - DECEMBER 31, 2017
11/30/17 12/31/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 121,090,909 119,111,263 (1,979,646)
Fixed Income 84,962,692 81,548,416 (3,414,276)
Equities 91,329,982 94,570,326 3,240,344
Equity ETF's 6,427,720 6,444,920 17,200
Options 5,395,568 5,280,333 (115,235)
Hedge Funds 76,886,666 78,522,866 1,636,200
Investments 50,702,680 50,702,680 -
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 23,375,000 23,375,000 -
Loans Receivable 12,740,708 12,790,708 50,000
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 21,149,417 21,149,417 -
Loan Payable - BJAV (30,500.000) (30,500,000) -
Total Assets 463,561,342 462,995,928 -565,414
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
DB - Sold 314,000 Apple @ 169 5469 53,231,447
DB - Sold 2,000,000 Nationwide Society 6.875% 2,799,247
TD - Sold 20,000 Brunswick Corp @ 56.10 1,122,000
AYH Distribution 1,000,000
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 575,348
TD - Sold 3,300 Cavco Industries Inc @ 147.75 487,575
ML - Sold 1,000 Teva Preferred @ 330.087 330,080
IB - Sold 10,000 XLF @ 27.86 278,600
TD - Sold 50,500 Ascena Retail Group Inc. @ 2.36 119,180
Nick Ribis Loan Repayment 50,000
LSJ - Jimmy prepayment (60,000)
LSJ - Lull (65,250)
Gratitude America - MIT Neri Oxman 25k Moskowitz 50K (75,000)
JEGE LLC - 6 months Rolls Royce Engine Corporate Care (93,404)
SFL LLC Loan - Lesley Groff (100,000)
DB - Bought 150,200 Dongfang Electric Corp (127,069)
Plan D LLC - 6 months Rolls Royce Engine Corporate Care (145,020)
DB - Bought 24,800 HSBC Holdings PLC (246,105)
DB - Bought 228,000 Weichai Power Co (246,611)
DB - Bought 6,300 Nabtesco Corp (247,324)
DB - Bought 144,000 Nine Dragons Paper Ho (248,025)
DB - Bought 224,000 China Communications (248,728)
DB - Bought 512,000 Bank of China Ltd (248,967)
DB - Bought 52,500 Anhui Conch Cement (249,073)
DB - Bought 70,600 ZTE Corp (249,835)
DB - Bought 710,000 Lonking Holdings Ltd (253,693)
DB - Bought 43,400 Zhuzhou CRRC Times (253,976)
Legal - Link (257,198)
DB - Bought 900 SPY 270 Calls @ 2.89 (262,806)
Legal - Gunster Yoakley and Stewart (275,000)
Miscellaneous (323,630)
DB - Bought 30,000 AMD @ 13.00 (390,000)
DB - Bought 2,000 Naspers Ltd (515,466)
ML - Bought 10,000 Tencent Holdings @ 52.05 (520,900)
ML - Bought 1,000 Allergen @ 634.40 (634,400)
Monthly Spending (1,300,000)
Haze - Bought 1,000 Google @ 1,014.015 (1,014,015)
DB - Bought 314,000 Apple @ 169.7941 (53,321,627)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50,000 (1,979,646)
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan Interactive TD
Asset Description Bank Bank EttiP Paribas Fargo Stanley Merrill Braun i Amerltrid• Totals
Cash
Haze Trust 56,338,148 56,338,148
Southern Trust Company Inc. 16,694,496 503,210 299.452 6 21.645.286 1,260,8031 40,403,047
Southern Financial LLC 9,893,685 2,363,572 12,257,257
Gratitude AMMO. Ltd. 2,596.030 221,430 594.625 3.412.085
JEE 2.402,089 59,906 143,647 2,605.642
Jeepers Inc. 1,522,838 7.737 1,530.575
LSJE LLC 200,443 315,636 45,146 561.225
Southern Country International LTD 438,684 435.684
JEGE LLC 415.319 415,319
Zom, Management LLC 245.850 245.850
Plan D LW 239,246 239,246
Thomas World Air LLC 132,274 132,274
Neptune LLC 104.949 104,949
NES LLC 95.738 95.738
Hyperion Air LLC 51,300 51,300
FT Real Estate 42.149 42,149
Laurel Inc 37 129 37,129
35,422 Enhanced Education 24,960 16,462'
Cypress Inc. 29,736 29736
26,427 JEE - Pans (US 6) 28,421
Freedom Air Petroleum 22 812 22612
22.736 Mk:hellos Transportation Co LW 22:736
Maple Inc 18281 1881
Nautilus Inc. 14,367 14.387
JEGE Inc. 9,790 9,790
Great St Am LLC ow 8,817
LSJ LLC 6,150 6,150
Mon Inc 4,853 4.853
FSF LLC 637 637
no Company LLC 390 390
The JEE Life Ins Tnssl 13 206 206
Butterfly Trust 3 3
Total Cash 90,839,943 1,892,562 469,526 45,146 594,825 21,645,286 1,260,603 2,363,572 119,111,263
Purchase Quantity 11/30/17 12131/17 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Wile Gain (Loss)
Haze Trust- Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% PM 4/30/2049 05/10/11 3,000,000 3,337,950 3,057,010 3,077,000 -260,958
JPM Floating Rate Income fund 01/22/13 244,929 2,450,844 2,289,377 2.297.436 -153,208
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 49,033 1,180,739 1,260,148 1,248,380 67,641
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/29/14 150,967 3,670,430 3.879.852 3,843,620 173,190
Cibbank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000 1 999 419 _2.268O90 2.253.870 254451
Total Haze Trust - Fixed income (DB) 12,639,191 12,754,477 12,720,306 81,115
Japers - Fixed income (DB)
JPM Floating Rate Income fund 02/13/13 1,834.787 1 832 829 1 714 987 1.721.025 -111.804
Total Jaspers - Fixed Income (DB) 1,832,829 1,714,987 1,721,025 -111,804
Gratitude America • Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
General Motors 5.75% fixed to 9/30/2027 09/20/17 1,450,000 1,493,756 1,505,855 1,516645
980,979
22,t389
-16,343 Citizens Communications 7.125% Matures 3/1512019 10102/17 1,000,000 997,322 981,094
Plains All America 6.125% 10/10/17 500,000 501,381 495,651 503.163 1,782
Teekay LNG Partners 8.5% 10/17/17 10,000 250 000 246.200 245.40Q -AM
Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 3,242,459 3,228,800 3,248,187 3,728
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB)
Royal Sank &Oland 7.64% Fixed to 9-20-2017 then 3M Libor +2320p 11/10/15 5,000,000 5,298,817 4,951,700 4,962,500 436,317
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP callable 6f20/2019 4/15/14 2,000.000 2020957 - Q
Total Southern Trust Co. • Fixed Income (DB) 6,298,817 7,872,667 4,962,600 -336,317
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill)
Allergen mandatory convertible predated 5.5% 08/15/16 1,000 881,500 636.060 586,250 495,250
Allergen mandatory convertible pawed 5.5% 11/29/17 1,000 834,400 836.060 586.250 -48,150
Plains All America Pipefine 10/04/17 1,000 1000,000 989,279 1,000,022 22
LSCCOM 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 2,650,000 2,89.125 2,752,503 2,771.826 -17,299
Kindred Healthcare 8% 1/152020 10/13/16 3,000,000 3,060,528 3,113,167 3 361,017 300,488
Teva mandatory convertible preffered 7.0% 12/15/2018 08/15/16 1,000,000 302.4%) - 0
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merril° 8,366,663 8,429,069 8,306,385 40,189
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (Interactive Brokers)
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred 525 par 7/27/15 40,000 1,000,000 1,080,800 1,075,200 75,200
NGL Energy Partners 9% 525 par 616/17 40,000 1,000,000 972.800 976.000 -24,000
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $25 par 08/04/16 8,000 200,000 190.000 189,200 -10,800
Wells Fargo 5.7% Preferred $25 par 1/19/16 120,000 3,000,000 3,132,000 3,118,800
2,158200
118 800
155:200 Ebay 6% Preferred $25 par matures 2-1-2056 2122116 80,000 2,000,000 2,148,000
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 3,000,000 3,123,122 3,264,600 3,10&750
5,159000
-14 372
11454 Goldman Sachs 5.375% Fined to 5-102020 then 392.2 over 3 mo tor 614/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 5,187,500
Ca !One 5.55% Fixed to 9-1-2020 then 380 over 3 mo lftsor 5/14/15 3 000 000
Total So ern rust o. - Fixed income interactive Brokers) 8,367,287 19,193,950 1 „ 50 597,
Southern Financial LW - Fixed Income (DB)
Bank of America 8.125% Pfd Dec 29 2049 1/10/11 2,000,000 2,055,000 2,061,911 2,060,764 5,764
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 4/3/13 300,000 300,000 308,929 309,731 9,731
Citigroup Inc - Series O 5.95% 8/8/15 3,000,000 3,000.006 3,198.703 3,202,433 202,427
General Electric Co GTD Fixed to Float 4.0% Dec 15 2065 12/3/15 2469000 2,175,016 2,486,489 2,404,504 229,488
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500,000 2O87,500 2.547.508 2,564,167 -123,333
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7.9% Apri 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500,000 2675,000 2,547508 2,564,167 -110,833
LBG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49 5/21/13 1,903,000 1948,500 2.180.125 2,159,112 210,612
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,000,000 2,996,137 3,422,909 3,355.925 359,788
Service Master 7.25% Mar 1 2038 10/20/174 1,500,000 1,559,765 1,564,385 1,570,000 10,235
Citizens Communications 7.125% Mar 15 2019 10/3/17 1,000,000 1,000,849 981,094 980.979 -19,870
Exelainter LLC 10% July 15 2023 10/24/17 2,000,000 1,940,506 1,954,167 2 038,889 98,383
Frontier Communications 8.5% April 15 2020 10/11/17 1,000,000 987,506 925,005 847,944 •13 62
JBS Investments 7.25% April 3 2024 10/31/17 2,000,000 1,981,300 2,012,958 2,000,042 18,742
JPM Floating Rate income fund 9/28/17 322,062 3,030.543 3,010,641 3,620,938 -9,605
GMAC Cap TR I GTD Pict Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80,000 1 882 77.4_ 2 089 60e 2.076.000 19322Q
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed income (DB) 30,220,402 31,291,932 31,155,595 935,194
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) face value
Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 cl CBI var 72512033 11119/13 514,038 393.335 475 87Q 472.21Q 78.953
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed income (DB) 393,335 476,820 472,288 78,953
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 80,359,872 84,962,692 81,548,416 1,188,543
Purchase Quantity 11/30/17 12/31/17 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
Advanced Micro Devices (received 0.70 from selling puts) 9/15/17 20,000 246,012 217,800 205,600 -40,412
Advanced Micro Devices (received 0.77 from selling puts) 12/15/17 30,000 366.913 308.400 -55.513
Alibaba Group 6/10/15 5,000 444,749 885.400 862,150 417,401
Apple Inc 915/14 64,000 10,998.400 0
Apple Inc 1111/16 250,000 42,962.500 - 0 Apple Inc 12/7/17 314,000 53,321,627 - 53,138,220 -183,407
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 283,157 4,999,983 8,239,448 8,807,865 3.807.882
Broadcom Ltd 10/13/17 4 000 985,931 1,111,760 1,027,600 41,669
BASF ACM 4/13/15 5,000 508,058 560,000 549,400 41,344
Biogen Idec Inc 2/14/12 2,095 250,455 674,946 667,404 416,949
Centene Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1,587,500 1,568,684 582,187
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17,500 665,000 3,100,650 1,-*,050 2,423,050
Gilead Sciences Inc 10/24/17 4,400 352,396 329,032 315 216 -37,180
Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 8,100 643,204 605,718 seom -62.920
HSBC Holdings PLC 12/4/17 24.800 246 105 - 257234 11,129
Lotting Holdings Ltd 12/4/17 710,000 253,693 - 311$38 57,845
Nine Dragons Paper Ho 12/4/17 144,000 248,025 - 230,635 -17,390
ZTE Corp 12/4/17 70,600 249,835 - 265,077 15,242
Anhui Conch Cement 12/4/17 52,500 249,073 - 246,817 -2,258
Bank of China Ltd 12/4117 512,000 248,967 - 251,512 2545
China Communications 1214/17 224,000 248,728 - 254,460 5.732
Dongfang Electric Corp 12/4/17 150,200 127069 - 123,165 -3,904
VVeichai Power Co 1214/17 228,000 246,611 - 249,870 3.059
Zhuzhou CRRC Times 12/4/17 43,400 253,976 - 282,319 28,343
Nabtesco Corp 12/4/17 6,300 247,324 - 241,624 -5,700
Wavers Ltd 12/4/17 2,000 515,468 - 557,689 42,223
Volkswagen AG 4/13/15 5,000 254,306 207,600 202,175 -52,131
Volkswagen AG 9/21/17 24,000 820.503 996 480 970 440 149.937
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 67,980,504 72,477,232 75,563,227 7,582,722
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (TD)
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Bam 1.3.11) 1/16/01 50,500 118,170 - 0
Brunswick Corp 9/18/17 15.000 830,250 - 0 Brunswidc Corp 10/27/17 5,000 276,750 - 0
Cavco Industries Inc 9/27/17 3,300 505.395 - 0 Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 25000 857,115 1,330,000 1,705,000 847,885
General Electric 10/20/17 75,000 1.127.899 1,371,750 1,308,750 180,851
Sangamo Therapeutics Inc 5/28/13 40,000 337.771 848.000 856.(1® 318.229
Total Southern Financial LLC-Equities (TD) 2,322,785 5,080,315 3,669,750 1,346,965
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Interactive Brokers)
Bardays PLC ADR 7/18/16 100,000 805,096 1,035.000 1,090,000 284,904
Advanced Micro Devices 8/11/17 12,000 144,486 130,680 123,360 -21,126
16,300 XLF Finanacial Sector 11/16/17 10,000 262,800 525.683 279.100
Credit Suisse Group 7118116 100,000 1 137 Pfl 1.690.000 1.785.000 647.374
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Interactive Brokers) 2,350,008 3,381,363 3,277,460 927,452
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill)
Teradyne Inc 7/20/17 20,000 704,832 809,400 837,400 132,558
XLF Finanacial Sector 6/20/17 20,000 487,600 550.400 558,200 70,600
XLF Finanacial Sector 8/2/17 80,000 2,023,688 2,201,600 2,232,800 209,112
JD Corn Inc 8/23/17 10,000 419,839 374.500 414,200 -5.439 JD Corn Inc 1013/17 20,000 759,982 749,000 828,400 68,418
Caesars Entertainment 10/4/17 30,000 391,185 397.500 379,500 -11,685
First Republic 10/24/17 1,000 97,300 95,540 86,640 -10,660 Qualcom Inc 10/11/17 10,000 542,890 663.400 640,200 97,310 ON
Semiconductor 6/8/17 12,000 200,038
240.980 251,280 51,242 Tencent Holdings 11/2/17 20,000 986280 511750 1,038720 52,440 KBW Regional Bank ETF 11/16/17 
9.000 50167 533.970 520,650- 26,483 ING
414/17 25,000 37 %)3/4 452_50Q
7,580,520
461.500
8,258,490
$11-002
768,390 Total Southern Trust Co. • Equities (Merrill) 7,490.  ,100
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities Morgan Stanley)
Colony Capital->Colony Northstar Inc. 9/26/16 73,315 928.837
402,134
893.710
85,500
836,524
89,000
-92,313
-313,134 Sequential Brands 9/23/16 50,000
General Electric 10/23/17 22,000 491,068 402,380 383,900 -107,168
Bank of America 32/16 7,500 100,825 211,275 221,400 120,575
Tencent Holdings 7/18/16 12,500 298.878 639.688 649 0°° 350.122
Total Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,221,742 2,232,552 2,179,824 41,918
Haze That • Equities (DB)
Google 12/5/17 1,000 - tQ46 40Q 32.385
Haze Trust- Total Equities (DB) 1, 117AM 0 1,046,400 32,385
J Epstein Vi Foundation - Equities (DB)
Bristol Myers Squibb 10/30/15 5,000 334,712 315,950 306,400 -28,312
Disney 10/30/15 2,500 285.025 262.050 268.775 -16.250
Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 619,737 578,000 575,176 _ -44,562
TOTAL EQUITIES 83,998,892 91,329,982 94,570,328 10,571,434
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF's (DB)
'shares South Korea ETF 11/3/17 13,000 985,997 976.950 974.090 -11,907
'shares China ETF 11/3/17 21 000 973 747 969 570 969 570 4 177
s ores man ,
Wisdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60,000 2951099 3.51.6.649 1559-8012 593.701
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF'S 'DB) 5,913,048 6,427,720 6,444,920 531,872
Southern Financial LLC - Options (DB)
Forward LongARS 59.020.000 us USD Shed 3.000.000 Exp 6/15/2018 11/9/17 19.94 0 86,687 42.975 42,975
Forward LongARS 64870,000 vs USD Shod 3.000.000 Exp 315/2018 12/5/17 18.29 0 0 -135,808 -135,808
Font-aid LongARS 58.341.500 vs USD Short 3.000.000 Exp 6/15.2018 12/15/17 19.46 0 0 -119,841 -119,841
Long EUR 10.003.000 vs CHF Short 11.703.000 Exp 3/12/2010 11/20/17 1.1703 0 0 4,350 4,350
Long USD 10.000.000 vs EUR Shot 4583,691 Exp 2/20/2018 11/20/17 1.1650 78,000 50,000 10,727 -67,273
Long TWX 100 Calls - exp Jan 19 2018 10/13/17 10 4,536 400 60 4,476
Short GE 18 Puts - exp Jan 19 2018 12/5/17 (250) -21,493 0 -17,000 4,493
Short AVGO 260 Calls - exp Jan 19 2018 12/15/17 (2O) -21,127 0 -9,340 11,787
Shod GILD 75 Puts - exp Jan 19 2018 12/15/17 (125) -20,994 0 44,500 -23,507
Short AVGO 250 Calls - exp Feb 16 2018 12/15/17 (20) -36.803 0 -29,000 7,803
Long SPY 270 Calls - exp March 16 2018 12/11/17 900 262,806 0 265,500 2,694
Short GILD 85 Calls - exp Dec 15 2017 10/24/17 (60) -240 0 0
Short GILD 75 Puts - exp Dec 15 2017 10/24/17 (125) -22,250 0 0
Short GILD 82.5 Calls - exp Dec 15 2017 10/24/17 (65) -325 0 0
Short AVGO 250 Calls - exp Dec 15 2017 10/13/17 (90) -59,120 0 0
Short AVG° 260 Calls - exp Dec 15 2017 10/13/17 (20) -4Z600 0 0
ShodAVG° 240 Puts • exp Dec 15 2017 10/13/17 (40) 4,400 0 0
Shod AMC 13 Puts - exp Dec 15 2017 10/25/17 (300) :Q2.12QQ. Q 0
Total Southern Financial LW - Options (DB) 244,926 -55,748 -128,627 -373,452
Southern Financial LW - Options (TD)
Long 280 JD 40 Celts - exp 1/19/2018 10116/17 280 75.122 20.328 56,645 -18,477
Shod 280 JD 44 Coifs - exp 1192018 10116/17 (280) -5,449 0 0
Shod 280 JD 37 Puts - exp1/19/2018 10/18/17 (280) -37.498 Q 0
Total Southern Financial LLC - Options (TO) 75,122 -22,618 56,545 -18,477
Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill)
Euro Wu 50 Index Si oio7igoio steep sue 3508 (amnia threshold 73.5% 9/25/17 ref price 3555 2,500,000 2,520,126 2,473,556
-26e144
-121,341 SX7E Market Plus Note Exp 4/26/2019 10/24/17 3.000,000 2,916,385 2,878,659
TWx 100 Calls Exp 1/19/2018 10/13/17 50,000 19,845 0 0
EEM > IWN Exp 12/29/2017 10/13/17 10mm notional 17 579 Q O
Southern Trust Co. • Options (Merrill) 6,500,000 5,473,935 5,352,215 (147,755)
TOTAL OPTIONS 5,820,047 5,396,568 5,280,333 (539,714)
11/30/17 12/31/17 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern Financia (SFLLC)
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 49 335 627 50 • • 2 204 2.69% 15.38% wluwmw,amm WIWI?
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 49,335,627 50,662,204 widWrew,3mm +111110
2016 return 3.77%
Hedge Funds - Haze
King Street 3.555.125
Hedge Funds -Haze 3,555,125 3,552,188 416 270,7103 4n11e 6.667,eaawie
&16113,684 7127116 6,102,824 paid
6113 2,776 10127116 4,166,601 paid
1011216,»0 1127717 3,664,444 p.16
1119 4.060 2016 return 4.66%
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 23.995.914 24.308.474 1.30% 21.01% odded20rm6/31/16
Total Hedge Funds - STC 23,995,914 24,308,474 2016 mute 0.44%
Total Hedge Funds 76,886,666 78,522,866
SFL
Mort Southern Grat FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profit) 0
Kyara II (investment amount) ll 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0
Kyara IV (investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1.000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000.000
Jawbone Investment (grat) 1,000,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3.000,000 sic
Seaford Avenue Capital - PB Investment -Auto Debt (total comm 2.6mm) 346,680
Adfln Solutions (investment amount 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston. NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase via Grat sic 3,001,000
Spotify via Honeycomb ll 1,000,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Velar Global Fund II (amount funded vs 15mm committment) 14,250,000 (N012017 stmt sham 3,665,396 nallzitl 94e
Velar Global Fund Ill (amount funded vs 25mm committment) 17,250,000 (40012017 am( shows 027,24? wirealla0 944
Totals 1,000,000 3,000,000 37,221,680 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total Investments 50,702,680
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 3,000,000 3,000,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 plan D LLC 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 1,175,000 1,175,000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 2,500,000 3,000,000 250,000 17,625,000 23,375,000
Asset Description JEE SFL JEGE Inc. FTRE Totals
Loans Receivable
pods am moons woo 150,000 150,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Nick Ribis 150,000 150,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
Osboume Lane Capital (Paul B) 1,000,000 1,000,000
David Mitchell 100,000 1,500,000 1,600,000
MI 303,262 303,262
Harlequin Dane, LLC 4,750,000 4,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 1,500,000 1,500,000
Lesley 300,000 300,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
Darren Indyke 475,000 475.000
Richard Kahn 475,000 475,000
LV Home & Ot er 1,307,000 1,307,000
525,000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,354,446 6,550,000 950,000 2,936,262 12,790,708
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques .4 Jewelry Lasers
Giacornetti (8,532,000 pounds © tat 11,249.417 11,249,417
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Enteral Cut Diamond - Insurance value 5,400,000 5.400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
3,050,006 Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 14,299,417 21,149,417
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) (30,500,000) (30,500,000)
EFTA00003070 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2018-01-11)
'NO
a
Today's Date:
Employee Name:
Physical Address,
Mailing Address:
Cell Phone:
E-mail:
LSJE, LLC
6I ok uarters. Suite 13-3, St. Thomas, VI 00802-1348
Phi E-mail: thesaintjamcs.group(a)gmail.com
I mergency Contact Form
01/11/18
Sylvester Gaillard
fide/Position: Kupenesor
Allergies or Health Concerns: None
riabetic Medications Current Medications:
Doctors Name:
Doctor's Name:

Dr. Alah
In case of emergency, please contact:
Name:
Name:
St Thomas, V1
Relationship:
Relationship:
Stan Date:
Date of Birth:
StThomas, VI
IMOther
Phone (other):
Marital Status:
Driver's License No:
Doctor's Phone:
Doctor's Phone:
Single
Phone:
Phone:
This information is for your safety and the safety of others
0 Unknown
11
EFTA01618464 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2018-01-11)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
•
•
2017/11/30
Sneaky, thank you!
Are you in New York?
08:35:23 pm
Whenr2"
08:36:04 pm
It
08:36:49 pm
1212 5333739
leaving
08:35:40 pm
1212 5333739
now
08:36:10 pm
Why you didn't tell me 1.i
I tried to call you after work on Tuesday see if I could come to see you but you didn't
pick up...
08:37:58 pm
When are you coming back?
08:41:36 pm
1212 5333739
Ok `31,
11:58:42 pin
2017/12/06
Hi sneaky, how are you?
Spoke to our Vice President about my future at IPI and possibilities
04:03:07 pm
Am I seeing you on Thursday?
04:06:50 pm
Here but take your time :)
01:47:11 pm
2017/12/14
2017/12/24
Sneaky
We are quickly biking to a store, back shortly! `31,
03:44:28 pm
Thurs
08:42:46 pm
1212 5333739
Yes ok
03:49:20 pm
•
•
2017/12/27
Thank you sneaky!! III te
09:27:52 pm
I missed you already!
09:28:06 pm
1212 5333739
Portofino
09:28:27 pm
Sarah lives there
09:28:35 pm
Oh wow great. Thank you! Looked it up. Looks beautiful
09:36:54 pm
2017/12/31
My parents already celebrating NYE and were so mean to send this pic of home-made
traditional food a
05:14:07 pm
*Are already celebrating
05:15:10 pm
1212 5333739
Yum my
05:15:50 pm
You don't even liked buuzy ( traditional dumplings) when I made it a J
05:40:54 pm
* didn't like
05:41:20 pm
Next time I will ask my mom to make it for you t:
05:41:49 pm
How are you? Tried to phone you? Miss you!
05:42:11 pm
1212 5333739
Ok will leave you in peace
07:41:04 pin
Happy New Year!
07:41:10 pm
And please read my email until the end, I promise it worth
07:42:01 pm
2018/01/01
You?
05:08:55 pin
peaeful
05:45:46 pm
1212 5333739
Kind
11:44:00 am
1212 5333739
sleep
05:11:25 pm
•
•
•
•
•
Sneaky I gave up guessing what the meaning of these words %t3,
07:31:19 pm
2018/01/04
getting only worse, I am glad you are safe and warm *4
06:21:19 pm
2018/01/10
09:05:01 pm
Yay!
09:05:01 pm
•
How are you sneaky? So quiet and unreachable
09:05:22 pm
When? Tonight?
09:54:40 pm
When are you leaving?
09:54:53 pm
1212 5333739
Come visit
09:17:30 pm
Sent
2018/01/11
Just left the office, could I come now?
12:42:53 am
Hi sneaky!
To come tonight after work is ok?
07:27:30 pin
✓ Read
EFTA00810360 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2018-01-17)
VALAR
Valor Global Fund III LP Capital Call
January 3, 2018
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund III LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $1,500,000.00, which represents 6% of your total commitment
of $25.000.000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Wednesday, January 17. 2018.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 75% of your total commitment with a
remaining 25% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of January 17, 2018:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$25,000,000.00
$18,750,000.00
$6,250,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Wednesday, January 17. 2018
$1.500.000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
Valor Global Fund III LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Valor Ventures LLC 915 Broadway Suite 1101 New York, New York 10010 www.volor.com
EFTA00810239 (Jmail)
 [tech] Valar Ventures pitch deck
(inferred date: 2018-01-29)
Valar Ventures
Formed in 2010
Spun out of Thiel Capital in 2013
Based in New York City
Raising Fund 4, targeting $100M -$150M
Anticipated closing December 2017
We invest in high margin, fast
growing technology companies
that are pursuing huge market
opportunities.
VALAR
Stage
We lead Series A and Series B
investments (valuations between
$20M - $100M).
We keep significant reserves to
follow-on in our best companies.
Sector
We focus on high-margin businesses
operating in massive addressable
markets.
Examples: Fintech, Software,
Marketplaces
Geography
The majority of our companies are
based in the United States and Europe.
Q 0 Q Cost basis by stage:

• Series A
• Series B
• Seed
• Later follow-ons
Cost basis by sector:
• Fintech
• Software
• Marketplaces
• Other
Cost basis by geography:
• US & CanadaEuropeAustralia/New Zealand
• Other
VALAR
Results
Fund Inception
Capital
Commitments
Current
FMV
Gross/Net
Multiples
Gross/Net
IRRs DPI
% of Fund
Invested/
Reserved
Fund 1 Oct 2010 $100.0M $411.8M 4.3x/ 3.4x 43.7% / 36.3% 1.2x 100%
Fund 2 Jan 2015 $102.3M $139.5M 1.6x / 1.3x 36.2% / 27.9% N/A 100%
Fund 3 Jul 2016 $103.9M $94.8M 1.4x / 1.3x 208.5% / 146.8% N/A 90%
As used throughout this presentation, "Fund I" refers to all funds and investment vehicles managed by Valar Ventures 
Management LLC prior to the formation of
Valar Global Fund 2, on an aggregate
basis. "Fund 2" refers to Valar Global Fund 2 LP and Valar Global Principals Fund 2 LP, on an aggregate basis, and "Fund
3" refers to Valar Global Fund 3 LP and
Valar Global Principals Fund 3 LP, on
an aggregate basis. All figures presented are unaudited estimates in USD as of 6/30/2017, including signed deals that 
are expected to close in Q3. Gross figures
do not include the impact of fees, expenses
and carry, and net figures are calculated by reducing gross investment profits by a flat 25% for hypothetical management
fees, expenses, and carry.
VALAR
Why is
our strategy
working?
VALAR I
Portfolio
Construction
We've kept
our funds small.
The first funds raised by Union Square
Ventures, Founders Fund, FirstMark, IA
Ventures and Foundry Group had average
capital commitments of $129M. These
funds were among the best performing
early-stage funds of the last decade.
$250,000,000
$187,500,000
$125,000,000
$62,500,000
$o
$ 100M
Fund 1
(October 2010)
$102M
Fund 2
(January 2015)
$104M
Fund 3
(July 2016)
VALAR I
We believe in
concentration.
Only 6-8 core investments in each fund,
with 50%+ of each fund invested in the
best 2-3 companies.
$125,000,000
$93,750,000
$62,500,000
$31,250,000
The 2 best performing
companies in Fund 1
received 54% of the
Fund's capital.
The 3 best performing
companies in Fund 2
received 52% of the
Fund's capital.
3 major investments in
Fund 3 have received
42% of the Fund's
capital commitments,
with 25% still reserved
for follow-ons.
STASH
1gOctane
Fund 1 Fund 2 Fund 3
VALAR 9
We follow-on heavily in our winners.
$500,000,000
$375,000,000
$250,000,000
$125,000,000
$o
Fund 1
I
(7 separate investments into
2 companies account for
99% of Fund l's current
profits.

• Transferwise
• Xero
O Other Investments
Cost Basis Current FMV • Fees/Expenses
$160,000,000
$120,000,000
$80,000,000
$40,000,000
Fund 2
$O
Cost Basis Current FMV
110 separate investments into
3 companies account for 92%
of Fund 2's current profits.

• Breather
• N26
O Kalo
O Other Investments
• Fees/Expenses
VALAR I 10
High Concentration + Aggressive Follow-Ons + Small Funds =
Any single company can return a fund multiple times over.
Fund 1
0
7TransferWise
Fund 2
©breather
N 2 6
kalo
Fund 3
STASH
Octane
x qonto
Fund
Ownership
Required Exit
Valuation to
Return the Fund
Current
Valuation
Current Contribution
to Fund Multiple
6.7% $1.5B $2.0B 1.3x
15.2% $651M $1.7B 2.6x
16.8% $609M $252M 0.4x
13.5% $758M $302M 0.4x
23.5% $435M $70M 0.2x
18.4% $565M $253M 0.4x
16.2% $642M $83M 0.1x
22.2% $468M $48M 0.1x
VALAR I

╭──── Page 12, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

Sources of Deal Flow:
VALAR / THIEL NETWORK
"TransferWise
STASH
kalo
Octane
CO :'A
Pre -
Investment: LOCAL FUNDS
x qonto
granify
EyeEm
Our network and brand generate
high quality Deal Flow and Access.
IN-HOUSE RESEARCH
to
® breather
N26
Jetty
VALAR
VALAR
Post -
Investment:
Our network and brand help provide
a Bridge to Growth Capital.
Sources of Deal Flow:
\ \EAR NETWORK
"TransferWise
STASH
kalo
Octane
CO'fik
LOCAL FUNDS
qonto
granify
EyeEm
IN-11OLSE RESEARC11
®breather
N26
Jetty
VALAR
Follow -On Investors:
qTransferWise
•
N26
al6z
IVP
Accel
Matrix Capital
(f)breather
STASH
Horizons
Battery
Menlo
Google Ventures
kalo
Coatue
Jim Breyer
SciFi VC
(Max Levchin)
VALAR I 14
Investment
Discipline
VL AP
Strict Investment Discipline
All investments must pass 3 key tests:
TEST 1
Team
TEST 2
Total
Addressable
Market
(TAM)
TEST 3
Traction
Most investment opportunities fail the TAM test
VALAR
"IVIAVERICK"

╭─ Page 17, Image 1 ─╮
│ VALAR | 7          │
╰────────────────────╯

Great tech companies are
being started in lots of lUir-'114ft
places.
Our New York base allows us to:

• Avoid Silicon Valley bias
• Identify and work with companies anywhere —
from SF to Berlin — at a much earlier stage
than Bay Area firms.
• Compare opportunities across geographies.
We are only looking for global winners but we
don't presume they will all be in California.
18
,
VALAR

╭─ Page 19, Image 1 ─╮
│ é ~ VALAR | 19     │
╰────────────────────╯

We operate like a
highly -focused
"Special Ops" team,
purpose-built to
outflank other VCs
Our team is deliberately small: Andrew and
James are the Investment Committee and meet
the companies together. There are no "Monday
morning meetings" or partner politics. We can
make decisions in real time. We also sit on the
boards together, eliminating horse trading over
remaining reserves in follow-on rounds.
RESULT: We are solely returns focused and can
move faster than anyone else in the business.
Founding
Partners
James Fitzgerald
Skadden, Clarium, Thiel Capital
Andrew McCormack
Yahoo!, PayPal, Clarium, Thiel Capital
Fund 4 Terms
Raising: $100M-$150M
Management Fee: 2.5%/year (subject to step-down)
Carry: 20% scaling to 25%/30% at 3x/6x net to investors
Fund Life: 10 years
Investment Period: 5 years
Minimum Investor Commitment: $5M
Due Date for Executed Sub Docs: Dec. 2017 (Jan. 2018 vintage fund)
VALAR I 22
Appendix
o o 10 ompanies
Xero is a leading cloud-based
accounting software provider
with over 1 million SMB
customers across the globe.
Xero is listed on both the NZX
and ASX under the ticker
symbol XRO.
Headquarters: Auckland
Valar Cost Basis: $31.4M
Current FMV: $124.3
Gross Multiple: 4.0x
Date of Initial Investment: October 2010
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $98.8M
Company Valuation at Time of Exit: $2.0B
Other Key Investors: Accel, Matrix Capital, Fidelity, Blackstone, TCV
VALAR I
/7TransferWise
TransferWise is a peer-to-peer
currency exchange service that
brings institutional pricing to
retail customers by coordinating
transfer needs within countries.
Headquarters: London
Valar Cost Basis: $22.2M
Current FMV: $252.7M
Gross Multiple: 11.4x
Date of Initial Investment: January 2013
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $20M
Current Company Valuation: $1.7B
Other Key Investors: IA Ventures, Andreessen-Horowitz, IVP
VALAR I
*breather
Breather operates a network of
private, professional meeting
rooms designed for work,
meetings and to focus.
Headquarters: New York City & Montreal
Valar Cost Basis: $25.5M
Current FMV: $42.3M
Gross Multiple: 1.7x
Date of Initial Investment: September 2015
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $80.0M
Current Company Valuation: $252.1M
Other Key Investors: RRE, Menlo Ventures, Google Ventures
VALAR I 26
N26
N26 is a new European bank
focused on building an
innovative mobile-first banking
experience.
Headquarters: Berlin
Valar Cost Basis: $14.9M
Current FMV: $40.6M
Gross Multiple: 2.7x
Date of Initial Investment: April 2015
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: €38M
Current Company Valuation: €265M
Other Key Investors Earlybird, Horizons Ventures, Battery Ventures
VALAR I
kalo
Businesses increasingly rely on
external workforces of
freelancers and contractors,
often without an effective way
to keep track of them. Kalo
(formerly Lystable) provides an
elegant platform to simplify
every step of these workers —
from onboarding to internal
reviews to payment.
Headquarters: London & San Francisco
Valar Cost Basis: $12.4M
Current FMV: $16.5
Gross Multiple: 1.3x
Date of Initial Investment: May 2015
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $7.5M
Current Company Valuation: $70M
Other Key Investors: Kindred, Goldcrest, SciFi VC (Max Levchin)
VALAR 28
EyeEm
EyeEm is a marketplace for
commercial photography. The
company's highly engaged user
base and machine-curated
image library provide a more
valuable sourcing channel for
commercial clients than
traditional stock photography
databases.
Headquarters: Berlin
Valar Cost Basis: $10.4M
Current FMV: $11.1M (change due to FX)
Gross Multiple: 1.1x
Date of Initial Investment: April 2015
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: €44.0M
Current Company Valuation: €55.8M
Other Key Investors: Earlybird Capital, Wellington Partners
VALAR I 29
Even
Even is a financial app that
ensures hourly workers always
get at least their average pay.
By offering consistency, Even
helps its customers save more
and avoid expensive payday
lenders.
Headquarters: Oakland
Valar Cost Basis: $4.5M
Current FMV: $4.5M
Gross Multiple: 1.0x
Date of Initial Investment: March 2016
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $28M
Current Company Valuation: $37M
Other Key Investors: Khosla Ventures, BoxGroup, Allen & Company
VALAR I
granify
Granify maximizes revenue for
online retailers by identifying
shoppers that aren't going to
buy and changing their mind
while they're still on the site
by harnessing the power of real-
time data analytics and machine
learning.
Headquarters: Edmonton & Austin
Valar Cost Basis: $7.5M
Current FMV: $8.7M
Gross Multiple: 1.2x
Date of Initial Investment: May 2015
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $5M
Current Company Valuation: $32M
Other Key Investors: iNovia Capital, BDC
VALAR I 31
TRADE IT TM
Tradelt facilitates quick and
secure online stock trading
through any website or app. Headquarters: New York City
Valar Cost Basis: $3.7M
Current FMV: $4.6M
Gross Multiple: 1.2x
Date of Initial Investment: April 2015
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $3.2M
Current Company Valuation: $23M
Other Key Investors: Citi Ventures, Sandy Robertson, Point72
VALAR I 32
homie
Homie is a peer-to-peer
marketplace that is
disintermediating the real estate
brokerage commission model.
By leveraging technology and
taking the transaction process
online, Homie makes FSBO a
real option for sellers and saves
home buyers thousands of
dollars.
Headquarters: Salt Lake City
Valar Cost Basis: $2.8M
Current FMV: $2.8M
Gross Multiple: 1.0x
Date of Initial Investment: March 2016
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $15.9M
Current Company Valuation: $18.5M
Other Key Investors: Peak Ventures, Kleiner Perkins
VALAR 33
STASH
Stash is a community for people
who want to start investing and
who don't want to rely on a
black box service to do it for
them. Starting with as little as
$5, Stash investors build a
portfolio of investments that
aligns with their interests,
beliefs and goals.
Headquarters: New York City
Valar Cost Basis: $22.1M
Current FMV: $48.3M
Gross Multiple: 2.2x
Date of Initial Investment: January 2016
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $12.0M
Current Company Valuation: $252.6M
Other Key Investors: Coatue Management, Goodwater, Jim Breyer
Octane
Octane Lending is a technology-
enabled lender focused on
secured consumer lending
markets starting with
powersports.
Headquarters: New York City
Valar Cost Basis: $13.2M
Current FMV: $13.5M
Gross Multiple: 1.0x
Date of Initial Investment: April 2017
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $68.0M
Current Company Valuation: $83.1M
Other Key Investors: IA Ventures, Contour Ventures, Third Prime Capital
VALAR I
x qonto
Qonto is a next generation bank
for entrepreneurs, SMEs and
startups, providing an online
service that allows businesses to
create an account in less than
five minutes.
Headquarters: Paris
Valar Cost Basis: $8.4M
Current FMV: $10.6M
Gross Multiple: 1.3x
Date of Initial Investment: September 2016
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: €5.3M
Current Company Valuation: €41.7M
Other Key Investors: Alven Capital
VALAR I 36
Jetty
Jetty is a new kind of insurance
company designed to help
people in cities reach their goals
faster by removing obstacles
and risks. Its mission is to
protect its customers against
setbacks of all kinds, from fire
and theft to wasted time and
money.
Headquarters: New York City
Valar Cost Basis: $8.1M
Current FMV: $8.1M
Gross Multiple: 1.0x
Dat of Initial Investment July 2017
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: $3 1 .0M
Current Company Valuation: $42.5M
Other Key Investors: Ribbit Capital, BoxGroup, SV Angel
VALAR I 37
CO%:°A
Coya is a full-stack European
insurance challenger that will
offer scalable protection at the
point of need, with personalized
predictive risk management and
simple, transparent insurance
designed to manage life's risks.
Headquarters: Berlin
Valar Cost Basis: $6.3M
Current FMV: $6.3M
Gross Multiple: 1.0x
Dat of Initial Investment: July 2017
Pre-Money Valuation at Initial Investment: €19.8M
Current Company Valuation: €27M
Other Key Investors: E.ventures
VALAR 38
sIsiCpuy up-rnollod
t s e
Over 60% of Fund l's profits
from Xero were attributable to
Valar's follow-on investments.
75,000,000
60,000,000
45,000,000
30,000,000
15,000,000
0 Xero ($99 pre-) Xero ($212M pre-) Xero ($529M pre-) Xero ($1.8B pre-)
■ Valar Cost Basis ■ Valar Current FMV
VALAR I
(f)breather
Over 40% of Valar's profits
from Breather are expected to
come from our follow-on
investments in the Company.
30,000,000
24,000,000
18,000,000
12,000,000
6,000,000
0 Breather (Series B)
,ft  d Breather (Series B-2) Breather (Series C)
■ Valar Cost Basis ■ Valar Current FMV
VALAR I 41
N26
And nearly 40% of Valar's
profits on N26 will also be
attributable to follow-on
investments.
37,500,000
30,000,000
22,500,000
15,000,000
7,500,000
0 N26 (Series A) N26 (Series B) N26 (Series B-2)
■ Valar Cost Basis ■ Valar Current FMV
VALAR I
STASH
37% of Valar's profits from
Stash are attributable to our
second investment in the
company and 57% from Valar's
third investment.
37,500,000
30,000,000
22,500,000
15,000,000
7,500,000
0 = Stash (Seed)
■ Stash (Series A) Stash (Series B) Stash (Series C)
■ Valar Cost Basis ■ Valar Current FMV
VALAR I
kalo
90% of our profits from Kalo
will be attributable to our third
and fourth investments into the
company.
12,500,000
10,000,000
7,500,000
5,000,000
2,500,000
0 Kalo (Seed) Kalo (Seed Extension) Kalo (Series A) Kalo (A-2)
■ Valar Cost Basis ■ Valar Current FMV
VALAR I
'7 TransferWise
Finally, while only 24% of our
current Transferwise profits are
attributable to follow-on
investments in the company,
those additional investments are
expected to add at least a full lx
to Fund l's returns.
225,000,000
180,000,000
135,000,000
90,000,000
45,000,000
0
■
p
Transferwise (Series A)
AmE_J Transferwise (Series B) Transferwise (Series C)
■ Valar Cost Basis ■ Valar Current FMV
VALAR I 45
Disclaimers
THIS DOCUMENT IS CONFIDENTIAL. The information in this
presentation may not be copied, reproduced, or redistributed without the
express written permission of Valar Ventures LLC (the "Sponsor"). This
presentation is not intended for distribution to, or use by, any person or
entity in any jurisdiction or country where such distribution or use is
contrary to local law or regulation. Nothing in this presentation should
be construed as an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any
securities and may not be relied upon in connection with the purchase or
sale of any security. This presentation is not intended to provide, and
should not be relied upon for, legal, tax, regulatory, investment financial,
or accounting advice or investment recommendation.
Statements contained herein are made as of June 30, 2017 unless
otherwise noted, and are subject to change without notice. The
valuations forecasts, estimates, opinions, and projections contained
herein involve elements of subjective judgment and analysis. There can
be no assurance that assumption made in connection with such
valuations, forecasts, estimates, opinions, and projections will prove
accurate. These materials may contain forward-looking statements that
are subject to certain risks and uncertainties. The Sponsor undertakes no
obligation to update these forward-looking statements for events or
circumstances that occur subsequent to such dates or to update or keep
current any of the information contained herein. Certain information and
data contained herein are based on sources the Sponsor believes to be
reliable, but such information has not been independently verified.
PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT INDICATIVE OF FUTURE
RESULTS AND SHOULD NOT BE RELIED UPON FOR MAKING
AN INVESTMENT DECISION. ANY INVESTMENT IN A
PROGRAM OFFERED BY THE SPONSOR OR ITS AFFILIATES
WILL BE HIGHLY SPECULATIVE AND THERE CAN BE NO
ASSURANCE THAT SUCH PROGRAM'S INVESTMENT
OBJECTIVE WILL BE ACHIEVED. INVESTORS MUST BE
PREPARED TO BEAR THE RISK OF A TOTAL LOSS OF THEIR
INVESTMENT.
ADDITIONAL DISCLAIMER FOR THOSE WHO WILL RECEIVE
OR ACCESS THIS DOCUMENT IN THE UNITED KINGDOM: This
document is directed solely at, and made only to, persons that we believe
are: (a) "investment professionals" (as that term is used in and by article
19(5) of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (Financial
Promotions) Order 2005 (the "Order"); and (b) "high orth
companies"; "high net worth unincorporated associations igh net
worth partnerships" or the "trustees of high value trusts" (toge "high
net worth companies etc.") (as each of these terms is us and by
article 49(2) the Order). There are in place proper ms and
procedures to prevent any other recipient from enga in the
investment activities to which this document relates wi
directing the communication of this document, a close relativ
member of the same group. This document is not a prospectus.
It has not therefore been: (a) prepared in accordance with the
requirements of Part VII of the Financial Services and Markets Act
2000, and the Handbook of rules and guidance maintained by the
Financial Conduct Authority (the "FCA"); and/or (b) submitted to, or
shared or registered with, the FCA. Consequently, interests in the funds
described in this document may not be ordered or sold to the public in
the United Kingdom; and no application can or will be made for interests
in the fund to be admitted to trading on a regulated market situated or
operating in the United Kingdom, or any other country.
For investment professionals: ument is directed at persons
having professional expert nee in matters relating to investments; and
any investment or investment activity to which it relates is available only
to such persons, and will be engaged in only with such persons. Persons
who do not have professional experience in matters relating to
investments should not rely on this document.
For high net worth companies: This document is directed at high net
worth companies, and the controlled investments and controlled
activities to which it r tes are available only to such persons. 4a
VALAR -16
EFTA00811666 (Jmail)
 [crypto] asset valuations of Epstein's holdings, includes "Coinbase via grat"
(date: 2018-01-31)
Valuation Report
1/31/2018
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - JANUARY 31, 2018
12/31/17 1/31/18 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 119,111,263 107,909,055 (11,202,208)
Fixed Income 81,548,416 81,642,786 94,370
Equities 94,570,326 103,157,212 8,586,886
Equity ETF's 6,444,920 3,127,830 (3,317,090)
Options 5,280,333 8,841,609 3,561,276
Hedge Funds 78,776,310 82,272,841 3,496,531
Investments 50,702,680 52,202,680 1,500,000
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 23,375,000 23,375,000
Loans Receivable 12,790,708 14,440,708 1,650,000
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 9,900,000 9,900,000
Loan Payable - BJAV (30.500.000) (30,500,000) -
Total Assets 451,999,956 456,369,722 4,369,766
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
DB - Sold 60,000 Wisdomtree Japan Hedged Equity @ 61.30 3,678,231
DB - Sold 900 SPY 270 Calls Exp 3-16-2018 @ 14.5011 1,302,363
DB - Sold 1,000,000 Frontier Communications 8.5% April 15 2020 986,130
MS - Sold 73,315 Colony Capital @ 9.3518 680,473
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 622,286
TD - Sold Short 9,900 XLU @ 50.561 499,546
MS - Sold Teekay LNG Partners 8.5% 246,440
Enhanced - Sold 1,600 BMY @ 61.66 98,651
Enhanced - Sold 815 DIS © 110.49 90,051
Nick - Loan repayments 25,000 x 2 50,000
DB - Bought Sy10y USD Rates Curve Cap 100,000,000 Notional (41,000)
Brice Karen bonus (50,000)
Paul Barrett fees Q1 2018 (54,165)
LSJ - Prosolar (58,100)
Dave Rodgers - 2017 hours (85,000)
Legal Fees - Steptoe and Johnson (100,000)
Cash withdrawal at bank (100,000)
DB - Bought Long USD 10,455,000 vs EUR Short 8,500,000 (100,000)
IB - Bought 525 XLI 80 Calls @ 1.929 (101,269)
IB - Bought 1,000 EWY 79 Calls @ 1.0213 (102,130)
IB - Bought 2,400 EEM 55 Calls @ 0.44 (105,606)
Enhanced - Joscha Boch (125,000)
IB - Bought 675 SPY 295 Calls @ 1.87 (126,313)
Larry Visoski Loan (150,000)
TD - Bought 1,000 SPY 300 Calls @ 1.8055 (180,576)
Legal Fees - Link (260,807)
MS - Bought 5,930 Starbucks @ 58.0283 (344,464)
Miscellaneous (361,959)
MS - Bought 3,500 Anheuser busch @ 112.2844 (393,352)
IB - Bought 1,850 GS @ 269.03 (499,868)
HBRK Funding (500,000)
Coatue Enterprises LLC Loan (500,000)
TD - Bought 43,000 AMLO @ 11.65 (500,956)
DB - Bought 95,400 China PAC Insurance Group @ 5.31 (506,380)
DB - Bought 151,000 China Life Insurance Co @ 3.36 (507,285)
DB - Bought 59,000 AIA Group Hong Kong @ 8.62 (508,816)
DB - Bought 40,500 PING An Insurance @ 12.64 (511,931)
ML - Bought 40,000 NY Community Bank @ 13.63 (545,212)
IB - Bought 10,000 SBUX @ 58.04 (580,378)
DKI Funding (600,000)
ML - Bought 4,000 Cummins Inc @ 188.90 (755,600)
TD - Bought 50,000 GE @ 19.25 (962,506)
Harlequin Dane, LLC Loan (1,000,000)
DB - Bought Buckeye Partners Fixed to Float 6.37 (1,019,996)
IB - Bought 100,000 AMLP @ 11.43 (1,142,710)
Monthly Spending (1,475,000)
Valar III funding (1,500,000)
ML - Bought Japan Banks Capped Note Exp Feb 1 2019 (3,000,000)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50,000 (11,202,207)
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan intoracriv• To
Asset Description Bank Bank SNP Paribas Fargo Merrill Stanley Brokers Amortrade Totals
Cash
Haze Trust 54423,200 54,423200
Southern Trust Company Inc. 10,328,286 555,442 299.452 12.525,985 0 3.836.376 27.545.544
Southern Financial LLC 13,784362 1.339.834 15.124.196
Gratitude America, Ltd. 61092 221,430 2.000.000 838,435 3.876,857
JEE 1,996,201 59,906 7,025 2,063,132
1,532,188 Jaspers Inc. 1,524,431 7,737
LSJE LLC 231,806 728,155 325,222 1285,183
463.079 JEGE LLC 463,079
Southern Country International LTD 434,889 434.889
Plan 0 US 239,248 239246
Neptune LW 207661 207.661
143,188 NES LLC 143.188
Thomas World Ai LW 127,973 127,973
121.954 2orro Management LLC 121.954
JEE - Paris (US 8) 108,465 108,465
Enhanced €ducation -6-.320 86.827 92,947
Nautilus Inc. 64,387 64,387
Hyperion Air LW 51,300 51.300
FT Real Estate 42,149 42.149
Laurel Inc. 37,129 37,129
Cypress Inc. 29,736 29.736
Freedom Air Petroleum 22,812 22,812
Michellos Transportation Co LLC 22,736 22,736
Maple Inc. 18,281 18281
JEGE Inc. 9,790 9.790
Great St Jim LLC 8 817 8,817
LSJ LW 6150 6,150
Mod Inc 4,853 4.853
FSF LW 837 837
IGO Company LLC 390 390
iThe JFFi fe Ins Trust #3 206 206
Butledly Trust 3 a
Total Cash 84,152,877 2,475,382 414,942 326,222 14,625,986 838,435 3,836.378 1,336.634 107,909,055
Purchase Quantity 12/31/17 1131/18 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/30/2049 05/10/11 3000000, , 3337958 3,077,000 3,100,500 -237,458
JPM Floating Rate Income fund 01/22113 24089 2458,427 27297743-8 2,325,163 -133,264
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 49,033 1,180,739 1,248,380 1,228,277 47,537
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 1029/14 150,957 3,670,430 3,843,620 3,781,723 111,293
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000 1 999 419 2253 87Q 2.227.50Q 228.381
Total Haze Trust- Fixed income (DB) 12,646,973 12,720,306 12,663,463 16,489
Jeepers - Fixed Income (DB)
JPM Floating Rate Income fund 02/13/13 184,122 1 838 659 1.721 025 1.741.795 -96 854
Total Joiners - Fbred Income (DB) 1,838,669 1,721,026 1,741,795 -96,864
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
General Motors 5.75% fixed to 9/30/2027 09/20/17 1,450,000 1,493,756 1,516645 1,527464 33,708
Citizens Communications 7.125% Matures 3/15/2019 1O132/17 1,000,000 997,322 980,979 1.,036,667 38,345
Plains Al America 6.125% 10/10/17 500,000 501,381 503.163 509,590 8,209
Teekay LNG Partners 8.5% 10/17/17 10,000 245.400 - 0
Total Gratitude America - Fixed income (Morgan Stanley) 2,992,469 3,246,187 3,072,721 80,262
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB)
Buckeye Partners Fixed to Float 6.375% Ciliate 1/22/23 1/25/18 1,000 000 1019,996 - 1,020.544 548
Royal Bank Scotland 7.64% Fixed to 9-29-2017 then 3M Ubor +232% 11/10/15 5,000,000 5.298 817 4.962 500 .-8.083  280 
-215.537
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB) 6,318,813 4,962,500 6,103,824 -214,989
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill)
Allergan mandatory convertible preffered 5.5% 08/15/16 1,000 881,500 586,250 647,700 -233,800
Allergen mandatory convertible proffered 5.5% 11/29/17 1,000 834.400 586,250 847,700 13,300
Plains All America Pipeline 10/04/17 1000 1,000,000 1,000,022 1,906,764 8,764
LSCCOM 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 2,650,000 2,789,125 2,771.826 2,824,274 35,149
Kindred Healthcare 8%1/1512020 10/13/16 3,000 000 150.778
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill) 8,365,553 8,305,365 , , -25,809
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Interactive Brokers)
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred $25 par 7/27/15 40,000 1.000,000 1,075,200 1,049.200 49,200
NGL Energy Partners 9%525 par 6/6/17 40,000 1,000,000 976,000 980,004 -19,996
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $25 par 0&134/16 8,000 200.000 189,200 187.920 -12,080
Wells Fargo 5.7% Preferred $25 par 1/19/16 120,000 3,000,000 3,118,800 3,024,000 24,000
Ebay 6% Preferred $25 par matures 2-1-2056 2/22/16 80,000 2.000,000 2,155,200 2,072.800 72,800
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9.15-2026 then floats 10/11/18 3,000,000 3,123,122 3,108,750 3,217,073 93.951
Goldman Sachs 5.375% Fixed to 540.2020 then 392.2 over 3 mo Ibor 6/4/15 5,000,000 5,034346 5,150,000 5,223.715 189.369
Centel One 5.55% Fixed to 9.1.2020 then 380 over 3 mo libor 5/14/15 3,000,000 3.009.81f 3.:192100 3.118.213 108.394
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (Interactive Brokers) 18,367,287 18,965,150 18,872,925 505,638
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed income (DB)
Bank of America 8.125% Pfd Dec 29 2049 1/10/11 2,000,000 2,055,000 2,060,764 2,072,348 17,346
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/1012023 4/3/13 300,000 300,000 309,731 309,119 9,119
Citigroup Inc - Series Q 5.95% 8/6/15 3000000 3.000,006 3,202,433 3 213,558 213,552
General Electric Co GTD Fixed to Float 4.0% Dec 15 2085 12/3/15 2.469,000 2.175.018 2,404,504 2,$58,169 183,153
JP Morgan Chase & Co Phi 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500 000 2,687,500 2,564,167 2,583,750 -103,750
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2.500.000 2.675.000 2,564,187 2,583,750 -91.250
LBG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49 5/21/13 1903,000 1,948,500 2,159.112 2,161,491 212,991
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec31 2049 1/30/12 3.000,000 2.996.137 3,355,925 3,315,000 318.863
Service Master 7.25% Mar 1 2038 10/20/17 1,500,000 1.559.785 1,570,000 1,582,813 23,048
Citizens Communications 7.125% Mar 15 2019 10/3/17 1,000,000 1,000,793 980,979 1,035,667 34,874
Exelainter LLC 10% July 15 2023 10/24/17 2,000.000 1.940.506 2.038.889 1,983,889 43 383
Frontier Communications 8.5% April 15 2020 10111/17 1,000000 847944 - 0
JBS Investments 7.25% April 3 2024 1041717 7.000.000 1.981.300 2.000.042 2.052.125- 70.825
JPM Floating Rate Income kind 9/28/17 323192 3.041.226 3.020.938 3,057,397 16 171
19625 GMAC Cap TR I GT0 Pfd Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80,000 1 Ap. 774 2.076_000 2.081 600
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 29,243,622 31,155,595 30,390,673 1,147,150
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) intlibli_ Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 d CBI var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 485,210
371.276 472.288 457642 86.366
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 371,276 472,288 457,642 86,366
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 80,144,543 81,548,416 81,642,786 1,498,244
Purchase Quantity 12/31117 1131/18 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
Advanced Micro Devices (received 0.70 from selling puts) 9115117 20,000 246,012 205,600 274,800 28,788
Advanced Micro Devices (received 0.77 from selling Puts) 12/15/17 30,000 366,913 308,400 412,200 45,287
Alibaba Group 6/10/15 5,000 444,749 862,150 1,021,450 576,701
Apple Inc 12/7/17 314,000 53,321,627 53,138,220 52,573,020 -748,607
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 263,157 4,999,983 8,807,865 9,407,863 4,407,880
Broadcom Ltd 10/13/17 4,000 985,931 1,027,600 992,120 6,189
BASF ADR 4/13/15 5,000 508,056 549,400 586,000 77,944
Blogen Idec Inc 2/14/12 2,095 250.455 667,404 728.662 478,207
Centene Corp W8/14 15,550 986,497 1,568,684 1,667,582 681,085
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17,500 665,000 3,088,050 3,270,575 2,605,575
Gilead Sciences Inc 10/24/17 4,400 352,396 315,218 368,720 16,324
Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 8,100 643,204 580,284 678,780 35,576
Volkswagen AG 4/13/15 5,000 254.308 202,175 222.200 -32,106
Volkswagen AG 9/21/17 24,000 820,503 970,440 1,066,560 246 057
20,881 HSBC Holdings PLC 12/4/17 24,800 246,105 257,234 265.986
Lonking Holdings Ltd 12/4/17 710,000 253,693 311,538 317,724 64.031
Nine Dragons Paper Ho 12/4/17 144,000 248,025 230,635 224,251 -23.774
ZTE Cow 12/4/17 70,600 249,835 265,077 257,261 7,426
Anhui Conch Cement 12/4/17 52,500 249073 246,817 289.308 40,235
Bank of China Ltd 12/4/17 512;000 248,967 251,512 308.329 59,362
China Communications 12/4/17 224,000 248728 254.460 267,497 18,769
1C194 Dongfang Electric Corp 12/4/17 150,200 127,069 123,165 143,263
Weichai Power Co 12/4/17 228,000 248,611 249,670 285,101 38,490
-13,705 Zhuzhou CRRC Times 12/4/17 43,400 253,976 282.319 240,271
Nabtesco Cow 12/4/17 6,300 247,324 241,824 297,261 49,937
NaspersLti 12)4/17 laMO200 569.914 54.448
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 67,980,504 75,563,227 76,737,698 8,757,193
Southern Financial LW - Equities (TO)
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 25,000 857,115 1.705.000 1,735,000 877,885
General Electric 10/20/17 75,000 1,127,899 1,308,750 1,212„750
806500
84,851
-154,006 General Electric 1/11/18 50,000 962.506
ALPS ETF Alerian MLP 1/12/18 40 000 500 956 - 490,200 -10756
-6,750 Utility Sector Spider XLU 1/12/18 (400) 49448 - (505,296)
Sangamo Therapeutics Inc 5/28/13 40,000 337 771. 656.000  834.000  496.229
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (TD) 3,286,701 3,669,750 4,575,154 1,288,453
Southern Twat Co. - Equities (Interactive Brokers)
331,904 Barclays PLC ADR 7/18716 100,000 805,096 1,090,000 1,137.000
Advanced Micro Devices 8/11/17 12,000 144,486 123,360 164,880 20,394
ALPS ETF Alerian MLP 1/8/18 100,000 1.142,710 1,140,000 -2,710
Goldman Sachs 1/25/18 1,850 499,873 - 495,597 -4,276
Starbux 1/26/18 10,000 580,378 - 568,100 -12,278
XLF Finanacial Sector 11/18/17 10,000 262,800 279,100 297,400 34,600
Credit Suisse Group 7/18/16 100,000 1.137.62k 1.785.000 1.934.000 796.374
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Interactive Brokers) 4,572,969 3,277,460 5,736,977 1,164,008
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill)
Teradyne Inc 7120117 20,000 704,832 837,400 918,800 211,968
XLF Finanacial Sector 6/20/17
8/2711 907600
20,_000 487,600 558,200
2,232,800
594,800
2,375200
107,200
355512 XLF Finanacial Sector 2.023.8/1
JD Corn Inc 8/23/17 10,000 419,639 414,200 492,300 72,661
224.618 JO Corn Inc 10/3/17 20,000 759,982 828,400 984,600
Caesars Entertainment 10/4/17 30,000 391,185 379.500 418,500 27,315
-7,750 First Republic 10/24/17 1,000 97,300 86,640 es 550
Qualcom Inc 10/11/17 10,000 542,890 640.200 682.500 139.610
ON Semiconductor 6/8/17 12,000 200,038 251,280 299,880 96,842
Tencent Holdings 11/2/17 20,000 986,280 1,038.720 1,183.400 197.120
New York Community Bancorp 1/10/18 40,000 545,212 - 565,400 21,188
Cummins Inc 1/19/18 4,000 755.600 - 752,000 3.600
KBW Regional Bank ETF 11/18/17 9,000 503,167 529.650 560.700 57,533
ING 4/4/17 25,000 373.500 461 500 492 500 119.000
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill) 8,790,912 8,258,490 10,410,130 1,619,218
Gratitude America, LTD . Equities (Morg
Colony Capital->Colony Northstar Inc. 9/26/16 73.315 836,524 - 0
Sequential Brands 923/16 50,000 402,134 89,000 81,000 -321.134
Anheuser Busch 1129/18 3,500 393,352 397,180 3.628
Starbucks 1/30/18 5,930 344,464 - 335.883 -7,581
General Electric 10/23/17 22,000 491,068 383,900 355,740 -135,328
Bai t of America 3/2/18 7,500 100,825 221,400 240,000 139,175
Tencent Holdings 7/18/16 12,500 298.878 649.000 739.625 940.747
Total Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 1 2,030,722 2,179,824 2,150,428 119,706
Haze Trust- Equities (DB)
AIA Group Hong Kong 1/23/18 59,000 508.816 - 506,279 -2.537
China Life Insurance Co 1/23/18 151,000 507,285 - 510,654 3,369
PING An Insurance 1/23/18 40.500 511,931 - 484,243 -27,688
China PAC Insurance Group 1/23/18 95,400 506,380 - 479,761 -26.619
Google 12/5/17 1,000 1 014 015 1.046.406 1169 940 155.825
Haze Trust • Total Equities (DB) 3,048,427 1,046,400 3,150,877 102,450
J Epstein VI Foundation • Equities (DB)
Bristol Myers Squibb 10/30/15 3,400 227,604 306,400 212,840 -14,764
Disney 10/30/15 1,685 192.114 268.775 1814109 AZ&
Total J Epstein VI Foundation • Equities (DB) 419,718 575,175 395,949 -23,769
TOTAL EQUITIES 90,129,953 94,570,326 103,157,212 13,027,260
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF's (DB)
'shares South Korea ETF 11/3/17 13,000 985,997 974,090 1,017,120 31,123
Ishares China ETF 11/3/17 21,000 973,747 959 570 1 105 070 132,323
Ishares Taiwan ETF 11/3/17 26,000 987,205 941).460 1tickf.64o 17,435
Vifisdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60,000 &Mak Q 0
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETPSIDS) 2,946,949 6,444,920 3,127,830 180,881
Southern Financial LLC - Options (DB)
Poniard Long ARS 59.820.000 vs USD Short 3,000.000 Exp W1372016 11/9/17 19.94 0 42,975 -154,647 -154,647
Forward LaXIARS 54,870.000 vs USD Short 3,000.000 Exp 315/201$ 12/5/17 18.29 0 -135,808 0 0 Bomar(' Long ARS 58.381.500 
vs USD Short 3.000.000 Exp 6/15/2018
12/15/17 19.46 0 -119,841 -228,748 -228,748
Long EUR 10,000.000 vs CHF Shod 11.703.000 Exp 3/1212018 11/20/17 1.1703 0 -6,350 -139,405 -139,405
Long USD 10.000,000 vs EUR Shod 8.583,591 Exp 2/20/2018 11/20/17 1.1650 78,000 10,727 84 -77,916
Long USD 10.455.000 vs EUR Short 8.500.000 Exp 4/30/2018 1/25/18 1.2300 100.000 0 80,688 -19,312
Sy100.130 Rates Curve Cap 100,C00,000 Notional 1/12/18 Strike 0.14% 41,000 0 34,994
22,721
-6,806
22.721 USD 2 yew swap 12.800,000 Notional we pay 2.215% ti received 3 month lbw 2.215% 0 0 Forward Shod ARS 29.910.000 
vs USD Shod 1,422.931 Exp W1372010
1/24/18 21.02 0 0 709 709
Short GILD 75 Puts - exp Feb 16 2018 1/9/18 (125) (19,554) - (3.375) 16.179
Short GILD 82.5 Puts - exp Feb 16 2018 1/9/18 (125) (15,341) - (42,500) -27,159
Long Ishares South Korea ETF 79 Calls - exp Feb 16 2018 1/23/18 2 132 - 186 54
Short GE 18 Puts - exp March 16 2018 1/19/18 (250) (45,543) - (49.750) 4207
Long EEM 55 Calls @ 0.44 1/17/18 2,400 105,606 0 220800  115194
Long XU 80 Calls a 1.929 1/9/18 525 101,289 0 144,375 4106
Long TIM( 100 Calls - exp Jan 19 2018 10/13/17 10 0 60 0 0
Short GE 18 Puts - exp Jan 19 2018 12/5/17 (250) 0 -17,000 0 0 Short AVGO 260 Calls - exp Jan 19 2018 12/15/17 (20) 0 
-9,340 0 0
Short GILD 75 Puts - exp Jan 19 2018 12/15/17 (125) 0 -44,500 0 0 Shod AVGO 250 Calls - exp Feb 16 2018 12/15/17 (20) 0 
-29,000 0 0
Long SPY 270 Calls - exp March 16 2018 12/11/17 900 20.12I 4 0
Total Southern Financial LLC - Options (DB) 346,689 -128,527 -113,868 -469,438
Southern Financial LLC - Options (TO)
Long 280 JD 40 Cans - exp 1/19/2018 10116/17 280 56,645 0 0
Long 1,000 SPY 300 Cab - exp 8/15/2018 1/30/18 1,000 180.576 Q 155 000 -25.576
Total Southern Financial LLC - Options (TD) 180,576 56,645 155,000 -25,576
Southern Trust Ca - Options BB)
Long 1,000 EIVY 79 Calls - exp 2/16/2018 1/24/18 1,000 102,130 0 82,03-5 -20,100
long 675 SPY 295 Calls-exp 5/18/2018 1/23/18 675 126.313 Q lam Lagi
Southern Trust Co. - Options (18) 228,443 - 216,693 (11,750)
Southern Trust Co. • Options (Merrill) -
ewe swot so index due 3127/2019 stomp Si. 3538 (034,41$** Meld 73.6% 9/25/17 ref price 3555 2.500.000 2,473.556 
2,547,912 47,912
Japan Banks Capped Note Exp Feb 1 2010 (75% barrier) 1/25/18 3,000,000 0 2,928651
3.107.222
-71,349
107.222 S)(7E Market Plus Note Exp 4/26/2019 (72%1:order) 10/24/17 3,000,000 9,878 659
Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill) 8,500,000 5,352,216 8,683,785 83,785
TOTAL OPTIONS 9,254,588 5,280,333 8,841,609 (412,979)
12/31/17 1/31/18 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern FlnanciatfSFLLC)
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 50 848 101 52 643 039 3.53% 3.53% withdraw/10mm 1110117
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 50,848,101 52,643,039 withdraw Haim 1131/14
basis 40mm - s 26mm
2016 return 3.77%
2017 return 15.8%
Hedge Funds - Haze
King Street 3.619.735 3.619.735 2017 return of capital 2016117 gold to date:
Hedge Funds - Haze 3,619,735 3,619,735 Old 230,7103 4/9/16 6967,954 paid
0/16 113,664 MISIO 6.10024 Pal
sna 2,710 loam 5.196,941 pal
1011218.370 1127/17 3,994,644 paid
110 4,050 2016 return 4.50%
Scott Shelton - IPO / Secondary Trading
Gratitude America 0 0 Feb 1 2018 start added 2ffen 1131114
Total Scott Shelton - !PO / Secondary Tradl2 0 0
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 24 308 474 26 010 067 7.00% 7.00% added 20mm 6/31/16
Total Hedge Funds - STC 24,308,474 26,010,067 2016 return 0.44%
Total Hedge Funds 78,776,310 82,272,841 12017 return 21.0%
SFL
Mod Southern Grat FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments
A
SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profit 0
Ryara II (investment amount) r 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0
Kyara IV (investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (grat) 1,000,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,000 STC
Seaford Avenue Capital - PB Investment -Auto Debt (total comm 2.6mm) 346,680
Adfin Solutions (investment amount) 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Uvingston, NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase via Grat SIC 3,001,000
Spotify via Honeycomb 1,000,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Velar Global Fund II (amount funded vs 15mm commIttment) 14,250,000 (9/30/2017 suet shows 3.6111,393 unread:ad gal
Velar Global Fund III (amount funded vs 25mm committment) 18,750,000 (9/30/2017 Witt shorn 4.327.247 unrealized gel
Totals 1,00%000 3,000,000 38,721,680 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total investments 52,202,680
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 3,000,000 3,000,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 plan 0 isc 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 1,175,000 1,175,000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 2,500,000 3,000,000 250,000 17,625,000 23,375,000
Asset Description JEE SFL JEGE Inc. FTRE Totals
Loans Receivable
(boon Now 100k yal tee veld 150K) 150,000 150,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Nick Ribis 150,000 150,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
Osboume Lane Capital (Paul B) 1,000,000 1,000,000
David Mitchell 100,000 1,500,000 1,600,000
303,262 303,262
Harlequin Dane, LLC 5,750,000 5,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 2,000,000 2,000,000
Lesley 300,000 300,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
Darren Indyke 475,000 475,000
Richard Kahn 475,000 475,000
LV Home & Other 1,457,000 1,457,000
525.000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,504,446 8,050,000 950,000 2,936,262 14,440,708
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32/3 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - insurance value 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 3,050,000 9,900,000
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) (30,500,000) (30,500,000)
EFTA00810361 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2018-03-01)
VALAR
Valor Global Fund III LP Capital Call
February 14, 2018
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund III LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $500,000.00, which represents 2% of your total commitment of
$25,000,000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Thursday. March 1, 2018.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 77% of your total commitment with a
remaining 23% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of March 1, 2018:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$25,000,000.00
$19,250,000.00
$5,750,000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Thursday, March 1 2018
$500.000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
Valor Global Fund III LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Valor Ventures LLC 915 Broadway Suite 1101 New York, New York 10010 www.volor.eom
EFTA01618472 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2018-03-05)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
2018/01/21
Sneaky!!! Why can't reach you all day? Happy happy Birthday!!!
02:24:20 am
02:24:42 am
Sent you email
02:24:50 am
After my last try
02:25:05 am
")") 5333/39
What? When? Today?
02:27:00 am
02:26:01 am
I've called you over and over
02:26:13 am
1212 5333739
now
02:27:10 am
•
•
I don't have
02:27:31 am
•
•
Is anyone was at the house today? Was I the only who didn't see you?®
02:31:44 am
Haha ok! --
02:47:48 am
no one came
02:33:26 am
1212 5333739
PEACEFUL
2018/01/28
•
Don't know what to reply. She keeps talking about unrelated nonsense, I am running
out of my vocabulary
10:24:20 pm
Sneaky? Are you feeling ok?
07:56:25 pm
2018/01/31
2018/02/14
rxiValeni-ines q• (jet ur 6F:27. OFF
Brina liP 14111C)1491F
4  gif
Bring both al "the
sam iimG FREE
*terms Ito:nulls:ft .113 apt
06:31:18 pm
Happy Valentines my sneaky! V
06:31:38 pm
2018/02/15
Sneaky are you home? Can I come?
11:47:46 pin
1212 5333139
No later than 8 as 30
11:52:11 pm
•
M aid come or earlier tha n8:30?
11:52:52 pm
Come not earlier
11:53:04 pm
1212 5333739
I have dinner with woody at 7. Then TV YAYYY
11:54:33 pm
2018/02/17
sneaky come back safely! There is snowstorm coming around 5 pm
06:59:53 pin
2018/02/18
Sorry sneaky went down to laundry room could you call me back pls ••
06:07:17 pin
Thank you again for the car!
Sneaky, trying to find a navy suit for work at IPI. Which one looks better sneaky?

• 08:38:53 pm
So?
03:33:38 am
Fever? e
03:33:48 am
2018/02/23
2018/02/24
Sneaky pls help? How does color and length?
04:33:29 pm
1212 5333739
Larger size dark grey shorter
04:39:40 pm2018/03/05
Should I write to the girl first? Or just wait until she writes
04:00:17 pm
1212 5333739
??
04:04:20 pm
The girl al was upset with over the weekend :)
04:19:25 pm
1212 5333739
Write
04:20:19 pm
OK,Thank you
04:42:18 pm
You never called back but I wanted to check if you will be ok today without me? I could
have asked for a personal day
04:43:04 pin
2018/03/06
1212 5333739
Call me
01:44:56 pm
✓ Sent
04:13:16 pm
This what I sent
04:13:26 pm
He probably about to leave to the retreat so does
meet me today
04:14:23 pm
2018/03/07
I think he won't be able to
Hi sneaky,
Just calling checking if you are not dying anywhere and safe home?
06:10:39 pm
*nor flying anywhere I meant
06:11:00 pm
Sorry typo
06:11:16 pm
Read
EFTA00003060 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
(date: 2018-03-19)
•
11
4 0
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red !look Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel:
Emergency Contact Form
Date: 03/19/18
Employee Name: Leiria fliornitt
Address:
Phone Coll-
Title / Position: H
emergency Information:
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood Type:
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name: Coorbin
Doctor's Name: Coorbin
Fax::
Start Date:
Date of Birth:
E-Mail:
Marital Status: Married License:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact:
Relationship Marned
Relationship Son
Phone:
Phone:
Phone
Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00811130 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Perkins Coie tax opinion on ZCash tokens
(inferred date: 2018-03-22)
PeRKINSCOle
March 22, 2018
TO: The Zerocoin Electric Coin Company
FROM: Bryan Smith
RE: Certain Federal Income Tax Consequences Applicable to Retention and
Distribution of Zcash
This memorandum discusses certain federal income tax consequences applicable to The
Zerocoin Electric Coin Company ("ZECC") and its members with respect to the retention and
distribution of Zcash, as defined below.
1. Background
We understand the facts to be as follows. ZECC was formed on November 13, 2014,
with the purpose of developing an open-source, decentralized software protocol that produces
and defines the rights to a virtual currency referred to as Zcash. The platform created by ZECC
allows owners of Zcash to engage in transactions with Zcash such that the details of the
transaction (monetary amounts, transaction metadata, and counterparty identifiers) are not
disclosed to all parties via the Zcash blockchain, but can still be disclosed to selected third
parties. Zcash is also more fungible than other virtual currencies, as Zcash coins may be
unlinked from their history on the Zcash blockchain. ZECC developed a working Zcash
prototype during 2015, deployed and announced the prototype on January 20, 2016, and
launched the Zcash protocol and blockchain on October 28, 2016 (the "Launch Date"). Since the
Launch Date, ZECC has monitored the Zcash blockchain, and it regularly releases protocol
upgrades, security fixes, and usability improvements. However, ZECC does not engage in any
activities related to verifying transactions or maintaining the blockchain, nor does it devote any
computing or other resources to "mining" activities.' Moreover, following the Launch Date,
ZECC does not exercise control over the Zcash protocol or blockchain. Rather, similar to
Bitcoin, any changes to the protocol must be adopted by the Zcash users.
ZECC's protocol established 21 million Zcash virtual currency units, which are "mined"
or "unlocked" over time, similar to the manner in which Bitcoin is mined. Of those total units,
10% ultimately will be retained by ZECC as the "Founders Reward." Half of all Zcash will be
mined in the first four years following the Launch Date (the "First Halving"), and the entire
Founders Reward will be retained by ZECC during this time. Accordingly, whenever a new
valid block is mined between the Launch Date and the First Halving, the block is split between
the "Miners Reward" (80%), which is received by the miner, and the Founders Reward (20%),
which is retained by ZECC. While each miner choses his or her own address for receipt of
mined Zcash, the Founders Reward is automatically assigned to a ZECC address pursuant to the
I Accordingly, ZECC is not engaged in any "mining" activities, as that term is generally understood in the context of
virtual currencies. See Notice 2014-21, 2014-16 1.R.B. 938, Q/A-8 (April 14, 2014).
Ptfkris Coe LLP
139063133.3
Zcash protocol in the source code. ZECC is not required to perform any services or take any
other action in order to retain the Founders Reward. After the First Halving, 100% of any mined
Zcash will go to the miner.
ZECC is treated as a partnership for U.S. federal income tax purposes. The rights and
responsibilities of ZECC's members (the "Members") are governed by ZECC's Fifth Amended
Limited Liability Company Agreement (the "Operating Agreement"). The Members own either
common units, which are held by ZECC's founders, employees, and advisors, or preferred units,
which were issued to investors through two rounds of funding in 2016.
The Operating Agreement describes the Founders Reward, providing that, of the twenty-
one (21) million units of Zcash to be created by ZECC, ten percent (10%), or 2.1 million Zcash
units, shall be "retained" for the benefit of ZECC for distribution to ZECC's Members. Under
the Operating Agreement, a portion of the Founders Reward will be distributed to the Members
in proportion to the number of units held by each Member. Prior to the Launch Date, ZECC
issued a report identifying the number of Zcash units of the Founders Reward to be distributed to
each Member based on that Member's ownership percentage in ZECC. Of the total Founders
Reward of 10%, ZECC's common Members will collectively receive 5.72%, the preferred
Members will receive 1.65%, ZECC will retain 1.19% for use in its operations, and the Zcash
Foundation (a nonprofit created to further the interests of Zcash) will receive 1.44%. While the
Founders Reward will be unlocked to ZECC over the four-year period following the Launch
Date, in accordance with the terms of the Operating Agreement, the Members holding preferred
units were distributed their entire share of the Founders Reward during the first year following
the Launch Date.
Similar to Bitcoin and other virtual currencies, Zcash may be purchased and sold on
various virtual currency exchanges (e.g., Bitfinex). However, Zcash is not traded on any
regulated securities or commodities exchange.

2. Issues
This memorandum addresses two federal income tax issues that are relevant to ZECC and
its Members:

(a) Whether ZECC realizes gross income with respect to its retention of the Founders
Reward?
(b) Whether distributions by ZECC of Zcash result in recognition of gain by recipient
members of ZECC by reason of Zcash being a "marketable security" as defined in

Section 731(c) of the Internal Revenue Code (the "Code")?
Perkm Coe LLP
-2-
139063133.3
3. Discussion
(a) ZECC's Retention of the Founders Reward
As an initial matter, ZECC, as a partnership for income tax purposes, is not subject to
federal income tax. Rather, its income, loss and other tax items pass through to its Members,
who are required to report their proportionate share of such income, loss and other items on their
respective tax returns, without regard to whether any amounts are distributed to them by ZECC.
Accordingly, the treatment of ZECC's retention of the Founders Reward has a direct impact on
ZECC's Members.
With respect to ZECC's retention of the Founders Reward, as with many issues relating
to the treatment of virtual currency transactions for tax purposes, there is no clear authority on
point? In particular, no authorities specifically address whether a creator of virtual currency may
recognize income with respect to the retention or receipt of the virtual currency as it is mined by
others pursuant to an automatic protocol established by the creator (a structure that is unique to
the virtual currency world). Nevertheless, general tax principles relating to realization of
income, as well as authorities involving analogous circumstances, provide substantial support for
the position that ZECC should not realize gross income with respect to its retention of the
Founders Reward.
Under general federal tax principles, gross income is only realized to the extent the
taxpayer has an accession to wealth. It is well established that the mere creation of valuable
property does not result in the realization of gross income until the property has been disposed or
otherwise exchanged for money or other property. 3 Similarly, where an owner of property
disposes of only part of the owner's interest in the property, the retention of a portion of the
property generally does not constitute an accession to wealth!' Under the commonly used
analogy of property constituting a "bundle of sticks," 5 neither the creation of the bundle nor
retention of a portion of the bundle generally constitutes an accession to wealth.
The foregoing analysis is consistent with authorities arising under analogous
circumstances. First, in the context of natural resource mining, a taxpayer with an economic
interest in un-mined resources does not realize income until the resources are sold or exchanged
for consideration that sufficiently differs from the underlying investment. 6 The mere extraction,
production, refinement, or storage of minerals does not cause a taxpayer to realize income,
because such actions do not sufficiently alter the taxpayer's interest in the underlying minerals.'
2 The only authority regarding the treatment of virtual currency for federal tax purposes is set forth in IRS Notice
2014-21, which does not address any of the issues set forth herein.
3 Eisner v. Macomber, 252 U.S. 189 (1920).
See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 77413, 1977.2 C.B. 298.
s See Frank Lyon Co. v. United States, 536 F2d 746 (8th Cir. 1976), 435 US 561 (1978).
6Rev. Rul. 76.533, 1976-2 C.B. 189; see also Palmer v. Bender, 287 U.S. 551 (1933); Lynch v. Aiworib-Stephens,
267 U.S. 364 (1925).
7 Priv. Ltr. Rul. 88-12-055 (December 24, 1987).
rtwkrsCoeLLP
-3-
139063133.3
The foregoing principles continue to apply where a property owner assigns an interest in mineral
property, but retains an interest in the underlying minerals.
A second analogy may be drawn from authorities involving the sale and simultaneous
retention of a leasehold or other possessory interest in real property. In such situations, the seller
of real property has generally been treated as having reserved certain rights in the property it
already held (resulting in no increase in the seller's amount realized upon sale), provided that the
seller retains the benefits and burdens of ownership with respect to the retained interest.9 Other
analogous situations involve (1) a donor's retention of an interest in donated property, where the
amount of the donation is reduced by the value of the retained rights, and the donor does not
realize gross income with respect to the retained interest; 1° (2) the retention of an interest in a
business in connection with its sale, where the retention of the interest itself (as distinguished
from the receipt of cash payments with respect to such interest) is not included in the seller's
gross income; I and (3) the partition of jointly-held property into separate assets, where the
receipt by each owner of their share of the partitioned property is not included in gross income. 12
The foregoing authorities support the position that ZECC's retention of the Founders
Reward is a mere retention of Zcash to which ZECC was already entitled to as the creator of the
Zcash units. The Operating Agreement supports this characterization by referring to the
"creation" and "retention" of Zcash by ZECC. ZECC's interest in the Zcash protocol (prior to
the Launch Date) is analogous to an economic interest in natural resources, and ZECC's right to
retain, via the Founders Reward, a portion of the Zcash it created may be viewed as similar to an
interest in minerals retained by an economic owner. In context of virtual currency, the protocol's
automatic issuance of Zcash to a ZECC address does not change ZECC's retained interest in the
underlying property; the mining process merely changes the form of ZECC's ownership interest
in its Zcash units (from an interest in "locked" units to "unlocked" units). If anything, ZECC has
a much stronger claim that it does not realize gross income than a resource owner, because
ZECC created the "resource" itself and willingly subjected it to being initially locked and
unlocked over time. Similarly, ZECC's situation is comparable to other dispositions of property
where the owner retains an interest in the property, whether pursuant to a sale/leaseback,
donation of a partial interest, retention of an interest upon the sale of a business, or partition of
jointly-owned property. Characterizing ZECC's retention of Zcash as the retention of an interest
in an asset (as distinguished from the disposition of the entire asset and subsequent receipt of
payments of income) is more consistent with both the form and substance of the arrangement.
8 See Priv. Ltr. Rul. 90-23.017 (March 7, 1990).
9 Kruesel v. United States, 63-2 USTC ¶ 9714 (D. Minn. 1963); Rev. Rul. 77-413. 1977-2 C.B. 298; Rev. Rul. 71-
567, 1971-2 C.B. 309; Priv. Ltr. Rul. 80-25-116 (Mar. 28, 1980). In some situations, courts have held taxpayers to
the form of their transactions and treated the reserved rights as additional proceeds for the property. See &stores
Realty Corp. v. Commissioner, 46 T.C. 363 (1966); Steinway & Sons v. Commissioner, 46 T.C. 375 (1966); Eller v.
Commissioner, 77 T.C. 934 (1981); Giberson v. Commissioner, 44 . 154 (CCH) 1982.
m See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 2003-28, 2003.11 I.R.B. 194; Rev. Rul. 57.293, 1957-2 C.B. 153.
"See, e.g., Nassau Suffolk Lumber & Supply Corp. v. Commissioner, 53 TC 280 (1969).
12 See, e.g., Rev. Rul. 56-437, 1956.2 C.B. 537.
FtrIcrisCoe LIP
-4-
139063133.3
While the foregoing authorities support the position that ZECC does not realize gross
income with respect to its retention of the Founders Reward, the IRS or a court could disagree.
The authorities cited above, while generally supportive of the desired position, are in contexts
factually distinct from virtual currency (and, in particular, the establishment of a virtual currency
protocol), and it is possible that the IRS would not apply such authorities to ZECC on the view
that the nature of virtual currencies are distinguishable. To the extent the IRS successfully
maintained such a position, the result could be the inclusion in gross income by ZECC of Zcash
units derived (or deemed to have been derived) by ZECC. The lack of guidance with respect to
the treatment of virtual currency transactions results in any position taken by ZECC with respect
to its retention of Zcash units being somewhat uncertain.
(b) Treatment of Distributions of Zcash
As described in more detail above, the Members are entitled under the Operating
Agreement to be distributed a portion of the Founders Reward. Generally, distributions of
property by a partnership do not result in gain recognition by the partner receiving the
distribution, except to the extent that the partner receives money in excess of the partner's basis
in the partner's interest in the partnership. 13 In certain circumstances, marketable securities, as
that term is defined in Section 731(c) of the Code, are treated as if they were money for this
purpose. 14 For this purpose, the term "marketable securities" generally means financial
instruments and foreign currencies which are actively traded, )  and "financial instruments"
include stocks and other equity interests, evidences of indebtedness, options, forward or futures
contracts, notional principal contracts, and derivatives. 16 The issue with respect to distributions
by ZECC of Zcash to its Members is whether such distributions could be treated as distributions
of "marketable securities," which could result in gain recognition on the part of the recipient
Members.
Zcash should not constitute a marketable security within the meaning of Section 731(c)
of the Code and, even if it were a marketable security for that purpose, its distribution to the
Members should not result in gain recognition by them. Virtual currency does not fit within the
list of traditional securities used to define "financial instruments," insofar is does not vest a
holder with, for instance, an interest in a legal entity (equity), an unconditional right to be paid a
fixed sum or the right to interest (indebtedness), or the right to buy or sell an asset in the future
(forward or futures contracts). Rather, for U.S. federal tax purposes, Zcash and other virtual
currencies are more likely to constitute commodities," rather than securities. 18 Moreover, Zcash
13 I.R.C. § 731(a)(1).
14 I.R.C. § 731(cX1XA).
16 I.R.C. § 731(cX2XA). Notably, the IRS has determined that virtual currencies are not considered to be foreign
currencies for purposes of the Code. Notice 2014-21, Q/A-2.
16 I.R.C. § 731(c)(2XC).
14 Bitcoin constitutes a commodity for purposes of the broker reporting rules under Treasury Regulations Section
1.6045-1(a)(5) (defining commodity to include any personal property the trading of regulated futures contracts in
which has been approved by the CFTC, which occurred with respect to Bitcoin in December, 2017). Additionally,
the IRS has stated that the term "commodity," for federal income tax purposes, is used "in its ordinary financial
Peckns Coe LLP
-5-
139063133.3
should not be treated as "actively traded" within the meaning of the foregoing rules, which
requires that there be an "established financial market" for the purported security.19 Applicable
Treasury Regulations provide a non-exhaustive list of established financial markets, none of
which should include the virtual currency exchanges on which Zcash is traded.20
In the unlikely event that Zcash constitutes a marketable security under the definition set
forth above, that determination should nevertheless be of no consequence in this situation.
Under an exception to the foregoing rules, the value of distributed marketable securities treated
as money is reduced (but not below zero) to the extent the recipient partner receives their
proportionate share of the partnership's appreciation with respect to securities of the type
distributed.21 Thus, because the distributions of Zcash to the Members have been in accordance
with their respective shares of the Founders Reward, as outlined in the Operating Agreement, the
recipient Members should not recognize gain on these distributions even if Zcash were to be
treated as a marketable security.22
4. Conclusions and Limitations
While not free from doubt due to the inherently uncertain nature of applicable law as
applied to virtual currency, we believe that, for U.S. federal income tax purposes, (a) substantial
authority supports the position that ZECC does not realize gross income with respect to its
retention of the Founders Reward, and (b) Members of ZECC should not recognize any gain
upon receipt of distributions of Zcash by reason of Zcash constituting a "marketable security"
within the meaning of Section 731(c) of the Code.
This memorandum is based upon current law and the facts and assumptions set forth
above. Changes in the law or the facts may adversely affect the conclusions reached in this
memorandum. This memorandum is limited to the specific federal income tax matters discussed
herein, and does not address the potential application of any other laws. This memorandum is
solely for the use of ZECC and its Members. However, this memorandum does not address the
individual circumstances of any particular Member, and each Member should seek advice from
sense and includes all products that are traded in and listed on commodity exchanges located in the United States."
Rev. Rul. 73.158, 1973.1 C.B. 337.
12 For federal income tax purposes, to the extent that virtual currency is a commodity, it should not also constitute a
"marketable security." See House Report No. 103.826, PL 103.465 r[c]commodities (other than precious metals)
are not treated as marketable securities under the provision.").
ig  See Treas. Reg. § I.731-2(cX2) (adopting the definition of § 1092(d)(1) and Treas. Reg. § 1.1092(d)-1(a)).
2° Treas. Reg. §1.1092(d)-1(b)(I) (including markets such as a registered national securities exchange, interdealer
markets under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, certain boards of trade designated by the CFTC, etc.).
21 I.R.C. § 731(c)(3); Treas. Reg. § 1.731-2(bX2).
n  It seems likely that Zcash also would qualify for a different exception applicable to "securities" that are held for 
at
least six months by the partnership before becoming marketable. Treas. Reg. § 1.73 1-2(d)(1Xiii). Zcash and the
related protocol should be analogous to a patentable invention, where the holding period for the invention begins
upon the creation of a working prototype (which in this case was more than 6 months prior to the Launch Date). See
Allied Chemical Corp. v. United States, 17 AFTR 2d 316, 1966).
Rirkns Coe UY
-6-
139063133.3
their own tax advisor. We undertake no obligation to update this memorandum after the date
hereof.
RthnsCoe LIP
-7-
139063133.3
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 David Fiszel [tech] CIO Honeycomb Asset Management, Epstein invested in Spotify through him 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00803405 (Jmail)
 [money] Honeycomb Asset Management fund brochure
(inferred date: 2018-03-29)
ITEM 1
Cover Page
PART 2A OF FORM ADV: FIRM BROCHURE
HONEYCOMB ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
March 2018
Honeycomb Asset Management LP
645 Madison Avenue, 16'h Floor
New York, NY 10022
Tel: 646.883-1105
This brochure provides information about the qualifications and business practices of
Honeycomb Asset Management LP. If you have any questions about the contents of this brochure,
please contact us at 646-883-1105 or compliance@honeycombaacom. The information in this
brochure (the "Brochure") has not been approved or verified by the United States Securities and
Exchange Commission (the "SEC") or by any state securities authority.

Additional information about Honeycomb Asset Management LP also is available on the SEC's
website at www.adviserinfo.sec.gov.
Registration with the SEC does not imply a certain level of skill or training.
ITEM 2
Material Changes
Honeycomb Asset Management LP ("Honeycomb") is filing this annual amendment as of the date
on this Brochure. No material changes have occurred since Honeycomb submitted its last annual
amendment filing on March 30, 2017.

In September 2017, Honeycomb filed an "other -than -annual" amendment to make certain non-
material clarifying updates.
ii March 2018
ITEM 3
Table of Contents
Item 1 Cover Page
Item 2 Material Changes ii
Item 3 Table of Contents iii
Item 4 Advisory Business 4
Item 5 Fees and Compensation  7
Item 6 Performance -Based Fees and Side-By-Side Management 9
Item 7 Types of Clients  10
Item 8 Methods of Analysis, Investment Strategies and Risk of Loss  11
Item 9 Disciplinary Information 28
Item 10 Other Financial Industry Activities and Affiliations 29
Item 11 Code of Ethics, Participation or Interest in Client Transactions and Personal Trading 30
Item 12 Brokerage Practices 35
Item 13 Review of Accounts 38
Item 14 Client Referrals and Other Compensation 39
Item 15 Custody 40
Item 16 Investment Discretion 41
Item 17 Voting Client Securities 42
Item 18 Financial Information 43
iii March 2018
ITEM 4
Advisory Business
Advisory Firm
Honeycomb Asset Management LP ("Honeycomb" or "Investment Manager") commenced
investment management activities on June 1, 2016. Mr. David Fiszel, the Founder and Chief
Investment Officer of Honeycomb, is the principal owner of Honeycomb.
Investment Strategies and Types of Investments
The investment objective of Honeycomb is to seek superior risk-adjusted returns with a focus on
long and short positions in publicly traded equity and equity-related securities (including options,
futures, swaps and other derivatives). Honeycomb invests globally across various industries and
sectors, including, without limitation, in technology, media, telecommunications and consumer -
related investments. While Honeycomb focuses the investment program on equity securities, it
may take long or short positions in other assets and financial instruments (including, without
limitation, corporate debt, loans, commodities and convertible and preferred securities) based on
its assessment of the highest and best use of capital for investors and the availability of market
opportunities across the public and private spectrum.

Honeycomb has a one-team collaborative approach to conducting research and analysis for both
public and private investments. This approach typically includes developing an investment thesis
for potential investment opportunities, refining and challenging the underlying assumptions behind
the thesis, and initiating and sizing investments in an effort to maximize risk-adjusted returns.
As a primary avenue for idea generation, Honeycomb utilizes the investment experience of Mr.
David Fiszel and the firm's team of analysts in seeking to identify market and company -specific
trends. Honeycomb believes that many companies have a few key discrete drivers that could
significantly impact future value. For long ideas, Honeycomb may seek to identify companies
benefitting from value drivers such as, among other things, secular growth trends, best-in-class
management teams, misunderstood earnings trajectories, strong industry positioning, recovering
margin expansion, or accelerating growth profiles. For short ideas, Honeycomb may seek to
identify companies that are hindered by, among other things, secularly declining cash flows, new
technologies or products in the marketplace that threaten their businesses, little or no barriers to
entry despite significant embedded growth, and inflated multiples due to excessive M&A or other
corporate activity.

For private investments, Honeycomb focuses on companies it believes offer value creation not
generally available in the public markets. Honeycomb endeavors to evaluate the highest and best
use of investor capital and to implement a disciplined, patient approach to private company
investing. Honeycomb believes its rigorous analytical approach to evaluating public companies is
critical in helping it assess the projected trajectory of potential private company investments.
Similarly, Honeycomb believes knowledge about private companies and the technologies,
products and services they produce better positions itself with respect to public market investing.
4 March 2018
From time to time, Honeycomb may acquire certain assets or securities which it believes either
may not have a readily assessable market value or should be held until the resolution or occurrence
of an event or circumstance and which it designates as a special investment in its sole discretion
(each, a "Special Investment"). Upon admission to the Funds (as defined below), each investor
may elect not to participate in Special Investments.

Honeycomb reserves the right to alter or modify the investment strategies of the Funds in light of
available investment opportunities or to take advantage of changing market conditions when it
concludes that alterations or modifications are consistent with the Funds' investment objectives.
Honeycomb has broad investment discretion and is not subject to limitations with respect to the
level of leverage it uses or the portion of the Funds' portfolio that may be invested in any particular
asset, financial instrument, investment, region, industry or sector (including various industries and
sectors in addition to technology, media, telecom and consumer). All investments risk the loss of
capital.
Advisory Services
Honeycomb provides discretionary investment advisory services to the following pooled
investment vehicles (the "Funds"): Honeycomb Partners LP, a Delaware limited partnership (the
"Onshore Feeder") that invests all or substantially all of its assets in Honeycomb Master Fund LP,
an exempted limited partnership organized under the laws of the Cayman Islands (the "Master
Fund"); and Honeycomb Offshore Fund Ltd., an exempted company incorporated under the laws
of the Cayman Islands (the "Offshore Feeder") which invests its assets in Honeycomb Intermediate
Fund LP (the "Intermediate Fund"), an exempted limited partnership organized under the laws of
the Cayman Islands, which, in turn, also invests all or substantially all of its assets in the Master
Fund. As used herein, the term "client" or "clients" refers to one or more of the Funds referenced
above as well as associated co-investment vehicles. Honeycomb intends to manage each client
based on the investment objectives and restrictions as set out in the relevant client's offering
materials. In addition, for investment structuring, legal, tax, regulatory or other reasons,
Honeycomb has created one or more special purpose vehicles through which it makes Fund
investments and may create additional such vehicles in the future.

Honeycomb Advisors, LLC (the "General Partner"), a limited liability company organized under
the laws of the state of Delaware and controlled by Mr. David Fiszel, serves as the general partner
of the Onshore Feeder and the co-investment vehicles, and Mr. David Fiszel serves as one of three
directors for the Offshore Feeder.

It should be noted that Honeycomb may in the future provide trading advisory or investment
management services to separately managed accounts, investment funds, or other investment
vehicles for investors interested in investment programs that differ from the ones used by the Funds
or for investors that do not wish to invest in the pooled investment vehicles referenced above. The
investment terms for each such other client would be negotiated by Honeycomb and the relevant
parties and may differ from the terms of an investment in the Funds, including with respect to fees,
liquidity, information rights, and other terms. As referenced above, Honeycomb managed two
separate co-investment vehicles as of December 31, 2017 in addition to the Funds. The co-
5 March 2018
investment vehicles do not engage in a continuous offering of interests and are not accepting
subscriptions as this time.

Lastly, it should be noted that the Funds may issue classes of interests or enter into separate written
agreements with certain investors ("Side Letters"), which grant rights that are more favorable or
may otherwise differ from the rights attributable to other investors in terms of, among other things,
incentive allocation, management fee, withdrawal rights (including different withdrawal dates and
notice periods), minimum and additional subscription amounts, information rights, and other
rights. The terms and the scope of the offering of such rights (including an offering limited to
strategic or other specific categories of investors) will be determined by Honeycomb in its sole
discretion. In addition to the foregoing, Honeycomb may also enter into Side Letters to address
legal, regulatory, tax or policy issues impacting particular investors and their investment activities.
Honeycomb has granted one or more of the rights referenced above (whether through Side Letters
or otherwise) to a limited number of early investors in the Fund and may do so in the future without
disclosure to or receiving consent from existing investors.
Regulatory Assets Under Management
At the time of this Brochure, Honeycomb has discretionary authority (i.e., the authority to decide
which securities to purchase and sell) for all of its clients and has regulatory assets under
management of $918,759,770.
6 March 2018
ITEM 5
Fees and Compensation
The fee schedules for the Funds are described in detail in each of the respective Fund's offering
memorandum. As a general matter, with respect to each Fund and for each investor therein,
Honeycomb or its affiliate deducts an asset-based fee (i.e., Management Fee) of up to 2% in
advance on a quarterly basis, including the fair value, as determined by Honeycomb, of any Special
Investments in which such investor has an interest. In addition, Honeycomb or its affiliates will
be entitled to performance-based compensation (i.e., Incentive Allocation) at the end of each fiscal
year in an amount up to 20% of the net capital appreciation of each investment in the Fund made
by an investor (taking into account, as applicable, gains and losses realized or deemed realized
with respect to Special Investments allocated during such fiscal year, and after reducing such
amount by the amount of the Management Fee debited to such investor during such fiscal year).
Any unrealized net capital appreciation upon which the calculation of the Incentive Allocation is
based will be reduced to the extent of any unrecovered balance remaining in any loss recovery
account maintained for each such investment (i.e., Incentive Allocation will be taken subject to a
"high water mark", if any). If an investor in a Fund withdraws its interest in the Onshore Feeder
or redeems its shares in the Offshore Feeder prior to the end of a calendar year, such investor's
performance-based compensation, with respect to the portion withdrawn or redeemed, will be
deducted at the time of such withdrawal or redemption. Co-investment vehicles managed by
Honeycomb are subject to performance-based compensation of up to 20% solely on a realized
rather than unrealized basis.

The Management Fee will be prorated for any period that is less than a full quarter and will be
adjusted for contributions and withdrawals/redemptions made during the quarter.

Honeycomb reserves the right to elect to reduce, waive or calculate differently the Management
Fee and/or Incentive Allocation with respect to any investor, including employees or partners of
Honeycomb, the General Partner or their affiliates, or their respective family members or trusts or
estate planning vehicles of such persons. Please refer to the disclosure regarding Side Letters in
Item 4 for more details.

Honeycomb deducts applicable fees from each investor's account. Investors do not have the ability
to choose to be billed directly for fees incurred.

Each Fund bears its own operating and other expenses and its pro raw share of the Master Fund's
expenses, including, but not limited to, investment-related expenses (e.g., brokerage commissions
and transaction costs, clearing and settlement charges, custodial fees, interest expense, and third
party trading-related software (including trade order management software)); research-related
expenses (e.g., third-party research, advisers and consultants, news and quotation equipment and
services, and fees for providers of market and portfolio data and software); legal and compliance
expenses (e.g., investment-related legal expenses (including document negotiation and review and
legal advice), formal and informal inquiries, indemnification expenses, and expenses associated
with regulatory filings relating to the Fund and/or the Master Fund and to their respective
portfolios, including without limitation Schedules 13D, 13G, 13H, Form PF and all other
investment or investor related filings,); insurance costs incurred in connection with each Fund's
7 March 2018
business (e.g., acquiring and maintaining D&O and/or E&O insurance for the Funds, Honeycomb,
the General Partner and their respective employees and affiliates); third party valuation,
accounting, audit and tax preparation and consulting expenses; legal and other expenses relating
to the offer and sale of interests in the Funds (including, without limitation, negotiating terms with,
reporting to, and developing offering and related materials for, investors or prospective investors);
entity-level taxes; fees and expenses of the directors of the Offshore Feeder, advisory committee
of the Master Fund, auditor and administrator; and expenses related to the maintenance of the
Funds' registered office, corporate licensing, extraordinary expenses and other similar expenses.
Expenses of the Funds, other than the Management Fee, certain investor -related taxes and any
expenses which Honeycomb determines in its sole discretion should be allocated to a particular
investor, generally will be shared by all investors pro rata provided, however, that any expense
relating specifically to a Special Investment will be charged against the investors participating in
such Special Investment in proportion to their respective participating percentage interests therein.
Additionally, if any of the above expenses are incurred jointly for the account of a Fund (and/or
the Master Fund) and any other investment funds (including any co-investment vehicle), client
accounts and proprietary accounts sponsored by Honeycomb, such expenses will be allocated
among the Fund (and/or the Master Fund) and such other accounts based on relative assets under
management, pro raw based on participation in a particular transaction or in such other manner as
Honeycomb considers fair and reasonable.

The Funds and co-investment vehicles may also pay for research with "soft" or commission dollars
if Honeycomb has determined such research is within the safe harbor of Section 28(e) of the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended. Refer to Item 12 — Brokerage Practices for further
information.

It is critical that investors refer to the relevant confidential private offering memorandum
and other governing documents for a complete understanding of how Honeycomb is
compensated, a complete understanding of the Funds' expenses and their
withdrawal/redemption rights. The information contained herein is a summary only and is
qualified in its entirety by such documents.
8 March 2018
ITEM 6
Performance -Based Fees and Side -By-Side Management
All clients are charged performance -based compensation in addition to asset-based fees.
Honeycomb may face a conflict of interest to the extent that it receives different levels of
performance -based compensation from different clients. In such cases, Honeycomb may have an
incentive to favor a client, or take increased investment risk on behalf of a client, for which it
receives greater performance -based compensation. Honeycomb is committed to allocating
investment opportunities on a fair and equitable basis, and in a manner that is consistent with its
fiduciary duties to its clients. In that connection, Honeycomb has adopted policies and procedures
to address conflicts associated with contemporaneous trading among client accounts.
Additionally, it should be noted that because performance -based compensation for the Funds is
calculated on a basis that includes unrealized appreciation of the Funds' assets, the performance -
based compensation may be greater than if it were based solely on realized gains. Investors are
provided with additional disclosure in applicable Fund documents as to how the performance -
based compensation is charged.
March 2018
ITEM 7
Types of Clients
Honeycomb provides discretionary investment advisory services to clients that consist of Funds
and their associated co-investment vehicles offered to investors on a private placement basis. In
order to invest in the Funds, a prospective investor is required to make certain representations as
to suitability and legal requirements of the respective Fund. Investors in the co-investment
vehicles, Onshore Feeder and U.S. investors in the Offshore Feeder must be "accredited investors"
as that term is defined in Rule 501 of Regulation D of the Securities Act of 1933 and "qualified
purchasers" within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51) and Rule 2a51-1 under the Investment
Company Act of 1940.

The minimum initial capital contribution for the Onshore Feeder and Offshore Feeder is
$5,000,000. Thereafter, the minimum additional capital contribution is $500,000. The minimum
investment amounts are subject to waiver in the sole discretion of Honeycomb or its affiliates, but
in the case of the Offshore Feeder, the minimum initial investment amount will not be reduced
below $100,000.

In addition, as noted in Item 4, Honeycomb may in the future provide trading advisory or
investment management services to separately managed accounts, investment funds, or other
investment vehicles for investors interested in investment programs that differ from the ones used
by the Funds or for investors that do not wish to invest in the pooled investment vehicles referenced
above.
March 2018
ITEM 8
Methods of Analysis, Investment Strategies and Risk of Loss
Honeycomb's investment objective is to seek superior risk-adjusted returns with a focus on long
and short positions in publicly traded equity and equity -related securities (including options,
futures, swaps and other derivatives). Honeycomb invests globally across industries and sectors,
including, without limitation, in technology, media, telecommunications and consumer -related
investments. While Honeycomb focuses the investment program on equity securities, it may take
long or short positions in other assets and financial instruments (including, without limitation,
corporate debt, loans, commodities and convertible and preferred securities) based on its
assessment of the highest and best use of capital for investors and the availability of market
opportunities across the public and private spectrum. Honeycomb will employ leverage as part of
its investment strategy, in accordance with the investment guidelines and restrictions, if any,
applicable with respect to a particular client.

Honeycomb's investment process is data-driven and process-oriented. It generally includes in-
depth research and due diligence on potential investment opportunities along with ongoing
monitoring of investments.

Honeycomb's initial due diligence process generally includes gathering and assessing publicly
available information on potential investment opportunities, including industry and company -
specific data. This data may include regulatory filings, research reports, earnings information,
discussions with management, and analyst commentary. After evaluating such information,
Honeycomb will generally develop financial models to determine its estimate of the company's
intrinsic value and key potential drivers that could impact future value. For core investment ideas,
Honeycomb may also require a more formal research write-up. In addition to the analyses set forth
above, Honeycomb also seeks to meet and maintain relationships with company management in
order to develop a more informed investment perspective.

Prior to initiating an investment, Honeycomb may establish investment targets for the investment,
including price targets, investment horizon, and potential catalysts for generating positive
performance. These targets will be reviewed and may be updated on a periodic basis.
A core part of Honeycomb's investment process is ongoing monitoring of portfolio investments.
This ongoing analysis may include, without limitation, the following:

• an assessment of the extent to which a particular investment is correlated to other
investments in the portfolio;
• measuring the risk/reward potential of a particular investment;
• a reassessment of the investment targets discussed above and potential entry/exit
points;
II
March 2018
➢ an evaluation of position sizing based on Honeycomb's conviction regarding the
investment thesis and to avoid potential "thesis drift";
➢ any potential changes to hedging strategies; and
➢ a review of potential catalysts to drive value.

The descriptions set forth in this Brochure of specific advisory services that Honeycomb offers or
may offer to clients, and investment strategies pursued and investments made by Honeycomb on
behalf of its clients, should not be understood to limit in any way Honeycomb's investment
activities. Honeycomb may offer any advisory services, engage in any investment strategy and
make any investment, including any not described in this Brochure, that Honeycomb considers
appropriate, subject to each client's investment objectives and guidelines.

The investment strategies Honeycomb pursues are speculative and entail substantial risks.
Clients should be prepared to bear a substantial loss of capital. There can be no assurance
that the investment objectives of any client will be achieved or that hedging strategies (if any)
will be successful.
Risk Factors Related to Investment Strategies and Particular Types of Securities
The following risk factors do not purport to be a complete list or explanation of the risks involved
in investments made by clients advised by Honeycomb. These risk factors include only those risks
Honeycomb believes to be material, significant or unusual and relate to particular significant
investment strategies or methods of analysis employed by or expected to be employed by
Honeycomb on behalf of its clients.

Risks of Investments Generally. An investment in any client involves significant risks, including
the risk that the entire amount invested may be lost. Clients invest in and actively trade securities
and other financial instruments using investment techniques with significant risk characteristics,
including, without limitation, risks arising from the volatility of the equity markets and the
potential illiquidity of securities and other financial instruments and the risk of loss from
counterparty defaults. No guarantee or representation is made that a client's investment objective
will be achieved.

Risks of Illiquid Investments; Special Investments. Client investments will also include privately-
held securities or other financial instruments which are generally less liquid than publicly-traded
securities, including Special Investments for those investors who do not opt-out of such
investments. Such investments may require a significant amount of time from the date of initial
investment before disposition and any investments in such privately-held securities are not subject
to redemption. To the extent valuations are obtained for privately-held securities, there can be no
assurance that the valuations assigned to such securities will ever be realized. In addition, such
privately-held securities may be of early stage companies with little or no profit or significant
losses which create substantial uncertainties with regards to the performance of such securities.
March 2018
General Economic and Market Conditions. The success of a client's activities will be affected by
general economic and market conditions, such as interest rates, availability of credit, credit
defaults, inflation rates, economic uncertainty, changes in laws (including laws relating to taxation
of investments), trade bathers, currency exchange controls, and national and international political
circumstances (including wars, terrorist acts or security operations). These factors may affect the
level and volatility of the prices and the liquidity of client investments. Volatility or illiquidity
could impair profitability or result in losses. Clients may maintain substantial trading positions
that can be adversely affected by the level of volatility in the financial markets.
Investment and Due Diligence Process. Before making investments, Honeycomb will conduct
due diligence that it deems reasonable and appropriate based on the facts and circumstances
applicable to each investment. When conducting due diligence, Honeycomb may be required to
evaluate important and complex business, financial, tax, accounting, environmental and legal
issues. When conducting due diligence and making an assessment regarding an investment,
Honeycomb will rely on the resources reasonably available to it, which in some circumstances
whether or not known to Honeycomb at the time, may not be sufficient, accurate, complete or
reliable. Due diligence may not reveal or highlight matters that could have a material adverse
effect on the value of an investment. Honeycomb may make investment decisions based on
incomplete or limited information and based on assumptions that may not be accurate.
Long/Short. The success of Honeycomb's long/short investment strategy depends upon
Honeycomb's ability to identify and purchase securities that are undervalued and identify and sell
short securities that are overvalued. The identification of investment opportunities in the
implementation of a client's long/short investment strategies is a difficult task, and there are no
assurances that such opportunities will be successfully recognized or acquired. In the event that
the perceived opportunities underlying client positions were to fail to converge toward, or were to
diverge further from values expected by Honeycomb, a client may incur a loss. In the event of
market disruptions, significant losses can be incurred which may force a client to close out one or
more positions. Furthermore, the financial and valuation models and assumptions used to
determine whether a position presents an attractive opportunity consistent with Honeycomb's
long/short strategies may become outdated and inaccurate as market conditions change.
Diversification and Concentration. Honeycomb is not subject to any diversification or
concentration limits with respect to its management of clients. As a result, Honeycomb may select
investments that are highly concentrated in a very limited number or type of securities. In addition,
a client's portfolio may become highly concentrated in securities related to a single or a limited
number of issuers, industries, sectors, strategies, countries or geographic regions. This limited
diversification may result in the concentration of risk, which, in turn, could expose a client to losses
disproportionate to market movements in general if there are disproportionately greater adverse
price movements in such securities.

Investing in Emerging Growth Companies. Companies in rapidly changing fields face special
risks. Neither Honeycomb nor the companies in which the clients invest have any significant
March 2018
control over the pace of developments. Among other things, a company may fail to acquire or
develop necessary technology or products, it may acquire the rights to or develop a technology or
product that is rendered obsolete by other developments or its product or service may not prove to
be commercially successful. Some industries may be subject to greater governmental regulation
than other areas and changes in governmental policies and the need for regulatory approvals may
materially and adversely affect these industries.

Investing in Technology Companies. Investing in securities and other instruments of technology
companies involves substantial risks. These risks include: the fact that certain companies in a
client's portfolio may have limited operating histories; rapidly changing technologies and products
which may quickly become obsolete; cyclical patterns in information technology spending which
may result in inventory write-offs, cancellation of orders and operating losses; scarcity of
management, engineering and marketing personnel with appropriate technological training; the
possibility of lawsuits related to technological patents; changing investors' sentiments and
preferences with regard to technology sector investments (which are generally perceived as risky)
with their resultant effect on the price of underlying securities; and volatility in the U.S. stock
markets affecting the prices of technology company securities, which may cause the performance
of clients to experience substantial volatility.

Initial Public Offerings. Honeycomb will invest in initial public offerings as part of its investment
strategy. Investments in initial public offerings (or shortly thereafter) may involve higher risks
than investments issued in secondary public offerings or purchases on a secondary market due to
a variety of factors, including, without limitation, the limited number of shares available for
trading, unseasoned trading, lack of investor knowledge of the issuer and limited operating history
of the issuer. In addition, some companies in initial public offerings are involved in relatively new
industries or lines of business, which may not be widely understood by investors. Some of these
companies may be undercapitalized or regarded as developmental stage companies, without
revenues or operating income, or the near-term prospects of achieving them. These factors may
contribute to substantial price volatility for such securities and, thus, for the value of client
interests.

Investing in Other Investment Vehicles. Honeycomb has invested, and may in the future invest, in
other pooled investment vehicles, including to access Special Investments. A client will typically
have limited rights pursuant to which it may withdraw, transfer or otherwise liquidate its
investments in such investment vehicles including, but not limited to, other hedge funds.
Investments in other investment vehicles are not themselves marketable and, therefore, clients may
not be able to readily dispose of their interests in other investment vehicles. Under the terms of
the governing documents of the other investment vehicles, the ability of a client to withdraw any
amount invested therein may be subject to certain restrictions and conditions, including restrictions
on the withdrawal of interests for an initial period, restrictions on the amount of withdrawals and
the frequency with which withdrawals can be made (including permitting withdrawals only upon
realization of investments), and investment minimums which must be maintained. Other
March 2018
investment vehicles typically charge management fees and/or incentive fees or allocations. As a
result, an investor will indirectly bear multiple management fees, incentive fees or allocations and
other expenses imposed by other investment vehicles, as well as directly bear the Management
Fee, Incentive Allocation and expenses of the clients.

Short Selling. Clients engage in short selling. Short selling involves selling securities which are
not owned and borrowing them for delivery to the purchaser, with an obligation to replace the
borrowed securities at a later date. Short selling allows the investor to profit from declines in
market prices to the extent such decline exceeds the transaction costs and the costs of borrowing
the securities. The extent to which a client may engage in short sales will depend upon
Honeycomb's ability to identify and sell short securities that are overvalued. A short sale creates
the risk of a theoretically unlimited loss, in that the price of the underlying security could
theoretically increase without limit, thus increasing the cost to the client of buying those securities
to cover the short position. There can be no assurance that a client will be able to maintain the
ability to borrow securities sold short and the cost of borrowing securities sold short may be
significant. In such cases, the client can be "bought in" (Le., forced to repurchase securities in the
open market to return to the lender). There also can be no assurance that the securities necessary
to cover a short position will be available for purchase at or near prices quoted in the market.
Purchasing securities to close out a short position can itself cause the price of the securities to rise
further, thereby exacerbating the loss. Short strategies can also be implemented synthetically
through various instruments and be used with respect to indices or in the over-the-counter market
and with respect to futures and other instruments. In some cases of synthetic short sales, there is
no floating supply of an underlying instrument with which to cover or close out a short position
and the client may be entirely dependent on the willingness of over-the-counter market makers to
quote prices at which the synthetic short position may be unwound. There can be no assurance
that such market makers will be willing to make such quotes. Short strategies can also be
implemented on a leveraged basis. Lastly, even though a client secures a "good borrow" of the
securities sold short at the time of execution, the lending institution may recall the lent security at
any time, thereby forcing the client to purchase the security at the then-prevailing market price,
which may be higher than the price at which such security was originally sold short by the client.
Leverage; Margin. The use of leverage has attendant risks and can substantially increase the
adverse impact to which a client's investment portfolio may be subject. Honeycomb will use
leverage as part of its investment strategy and the level of leverage could be substantial. The use
of leverage will allow clients to make additional investments, thereby increasing exposure to
assets, such that total assets may be greater than capital. However, leverage will also magnify the
volatility of changes in the value of a client's portfolio. The effect of the use of leverage by a
client in a market that moves adversely to its investments could result in substantial losses to the
client, which would be greater than if the client were not leveraged. In addition, any leverage used
by a client is subject to the risk that changes in the general level of interest rates may adversely
affect expenses and operating results.
March 2018
In general, any use by a client of short-term margin borrowings results in certain additional risks.
For example, should the securities pledged to brokers to secure the portfolio's margin accounts
decline in value, the portfolio could be subject to a "margin call", pursuant to which the portfolio
must either deposit additional funds with the broker, or suffer mandatory liquidation of the pledged
securities to compensate for the decline in value. In the event of a sudden precipitous drop in the
value of the portfolio's assets, the portfolio might not be able to liquidate assets quickly enough to
pay off its margin debt.

In the futures and forward markets, margin deposits are typically low relative to the value of the
futures contracts purchased or sold. Such low margin deposits are indicative of the fact that any
futures or forward contract trading is typically accompanied by a high degree of leverage. Low
margin deposits mean that a relatively small price movement in a contract may result in immediate
and substantial losses to the investor.

To the extent a client purchases an option in the U.S., there is no margin requirement because the
option premium is paid for in full. The premiums for certain options traded on non-U.S. exchanges
may be paid for on margin. Whether any margin deposit will be required for over-the-counter
options and other over-the-counter instruments, will depend on the credit determinations and
specific agreements of the parties to the transaction, which are individually negotiated.
Lending of Portfolio Securities. Clients may lend securities on a collateralized and an
uncollateralized basis from their portfolios to creditworthy securities firms and financial
institutions. While a securities loan is outstanding, a client will continue to receive the equivalent
of the interest or dividends paid by the issuer on the securities, as well as interest on the investment
of the collateral or a fee from the borrower. The risks in lending securities, as with other extensions
of secured credit, if any, consist of possible delay in receiving additional collateral, if any, or in
recovery of the securities or possible loss of rights in the collateral, if any, should the borrower fail
financially.

Lack of Control of Portfolio Companies. Clients invest in securities of companies that they do not
control, which clients may acquire through market transactions or through purchases of securities
directly from the issuer. Such securities will be subject to the risk that the issuer may make business,
financial or management decisions with which clients do not agree or that the majority stakeholders
or the management of the issuer may take risks or otherwise act in a manner that does not serve client
interests.

Hedging Transactions. Honeycomb is not required to, and may not attempt to, hedge market risks
or other risks inherent in client positions, and is not expected to hedge risks associated with Special
Investments. In addition, Honeycomb may not anticipate a particular risk so as to hedge against it
or successfully hedge against it even if such risk is anticipated.

Clients, however, may utilize a variety of financial instruments (including options and derivatives),
both for investment purposes and (to the extent desired) for risk management purposes in order to,
March 2018
among other things: (i) protect against possible changes in the market value of the investment
portfolio resulting from fluctuations in the securities markets and changes in interest rates; (ii)
protect the unrealized gains in the value of the investment portfolio; (iii) facilitate the sale of any
such investments; (iv) enhance or preserve returns, spreads or gains on any investment in the
portfolio; (v) hedge the interest rate or currency exchange rate on any of the liabilities or assets;
(vi) protect against any increase in the price of any securities they anticipate purchasing at a later
date; or (vii) for any other reason that Honeycomb deems appropriate.

The success of Honeycomb's hedging is subject to its ability to correctly assess the degree of
correlation between the performance of the instruments used to hedge and the performance of the
investments in the portfolios being hedged. Since the characteristics of many securities change as
markets change or time passes, the success of the instances when Honeycomb hedges portfolio
positions is also subject to Honeycomb's ability to continually recalculate, readjust and execute
hedges in an efficient and timely manner. While Honeycomb may enter into certain hedging
transactions to seek to reduce risk, such transactions may result in a poorer overall performance
than if they had not engaged in any such hedging transactions. For a variety of reasons,
Honeycomb may not seek to establish a perfect correlation between such hedging instruments and
the portfolio holdings being hedged. Such imperfect correlation may prevent clients from
achieving the intended hedge or expose clients to risk of loss. Hedging and risk management
transactions requires skills complementary to those needed in the selection of portfolio holdings
and there can be no guarantee that Honeycomb's hedging transactions, if any, will be successful.
Fundamental Analysis. Honeycomb's investment process is based on, among other things,
fundamental analysis. Data on which fundamental analysis relies may be inaccurate or may be
generally available to other market participants. To the extent that any such data are inaccurate or
that other market participants have developed, based on such data, trading strategies similar to the
clients' trading strategies, Honeycomb may not be able to realize its investment goals. In addition,
fundamental market information and other data used by Honeycomb as part of its investment
process is subject to interpretation. To the extent that Honeycomb misinterprets the meaning of
data, a client may incur losses.

Analytical and Financial Model Risks. Honeycomb employs certain strategies which depend upon
the reliability, accuracy and analysis of its analytical models. To the extent such models (or the
assumptions underlying them) do not prove to be correct substantial losses could result. All
models ultimately depend upon the judgment of Honeycomb and the assumptions embedded in
them. To the extent that with respect to any investment, the judgment or assumptions are incorrect,
clients can suffer losses.

Necessity for Counterparty Trading Relationships; Counterpart) , Risk. Honeycomb expects to
establish relationships to obtain financing, derivative intermediation and prime brokerage services
that permit clients to trade in any variety of markets or asset classes over time; however, there can
be no assurance that Honeycomb will be able to maintain such relationships or establish such
relationships. An inability to establish or maintain such relationships would limit client trading
March 2018
activities, and could create losses, preclude clients from engaging in certain transactions,
financing, derivative intermediation and prime brokerage services and prevent clients from trading
at optimal rates and terms. Moreover, a disruption in the financing, derivative intermediation and
prime brokerage services provided by any such relationships before Honeycomb establishes
additional relationships could have a significant impact on client business due to such client's
reliance on such counterparties.

Some of the markets in which clients may effect transactions are not "exchanged -based", including
"over-the-counter" or "interdealer" markets. The participants in such markets are typically not
subject to the credit evaluation and regulatory oversight to which members of "exchange -based"
markets are subject. The lack of evaluation and oversight of over-the-counter markets exposes
clients to the risk that a counterparty will not settle a transaction in accordance with its terms and
conditions because of a dispute over the terms of the contract (whether or not bona fide) or because
of a credit or liquidity problem, thus causing clients to suffer a loss. Such "counterparty risk" is
accentuated for contracts with longer maturities where events may intervene to prevent settlement,
or where a client has concentrated its transactions with a single or small group of counterparties.
Generally, clients are not restricted from dealing with any particular counterparties. Honeycomb's
evaluation of the creditworthiness of counterparties may not prove sufficient. The lack of a
complete and "foolproof' evaluation of the financial capabilities of client counterparties and the
absence of a regulated market to facilitate settlement may increase the potential for losses.
Execution of Orders. Honeycomb's investment strategies and trading strategies depend on its
ability to establish and maintain an overall market position in a combination of financial
instruments selected by Honeycomb. Trading orders may not be executed in a timely and efficient
manner due to various circumstances, including, without limitation, trading volume surges or
systems failures attributable to a client, Honeycomb, client counterparties, brokers, dealers, agents
or other service providers. In such event, clients might only be able to acquire or dispose of some,
but not all, of the components of such position, or if the overall position were to need adjustment,
clients might not be able to make such adjustment. As a result, such client would not be able to
achieve the market position selected by Honeycomb, which may result in a loss. In addition,
clients rely heavily on electronic execution systems (and may rely on new systems and technology
in the future), and such systems may be subject to certain systemic limitations or mistakes, causing
the interruption of trading orders made by clients.

Litigation. With regard to certain investments, it is a possibility that Honeycomb and/or one of its
clients may be plaintiffs or defendants in civil proceedings. The expense of prosecuting claims,
for which there is no guarantee of success, and/or the expense of defending against claims by third
parties and paying any amounts pursuant to settlements or judgments would be borne by clients
and would reduce net assets or may, pursuant to applicable law, require investors to return
distributed capital and earnings.

Counterparty Fraud. Of paramount concern in investments is the possibility of material
misrepresentation or omission on the part of a counterparty. Such inaccuracy or incompleteness
March 2018
may adversely affect the valuation of the collateral underlying an investment. Honeycomb relies
upon the accuracy and completeness of representations made by counterparties to the extent
reasonable, but cannot guarantee such accuracy or completeness. Under certain circumstances,
payments to a client may be reclaimed if any such payment or distribution is later determined to
have been a fraudulent conveyance or a preferential payment.

Counterpart) , Insolvency. Client assets may be held in one or more accounts maintained for the
client by counterparties, including its prime brokers. There is a risk that any of such counterparties
could become insolvent. The insolvency of counterparties is likely to impair the operational
capabilities or the assets of clients. Although Honeycomb regularly monitors the financial
condition of the counterparties it uses, if one or more of the counterparties were to become
insolvent or the subject of liquidation proceedings in the U.S. (either under the Securities Investor
Protection Act or the U.S. Bankruptcy Code), there exists the risk that the recovery of the client
securities and other assets from such prime broker or broker-dealer will be delayed or be of a value
less than the value of the securities or assets originally entrusted to such prime broker or broker-
dealer.

In addition, clients may use counterparties located in various jurisdictions outside the U.S. Such
local counterparties are subject to various laws and regulations in various jurisdictions that are
designed to protect their customers in the event of their insolvency. However, the practical effect
of these laws and their application to client assets are subject to substantial limitations and
uncertainties. Because of the large number of entities and jurisdictions involved and the range of
possible factual scenarios involving the insolvency of a counterparty, it is impossible to generalize
about the effect of their insolvency on clients and their assets. Investors should assume that the
insolvency of any client counterparty would result in a loss, which could be material.
Competition; Availability of Investments. Certain markets in which clients may invest are
extremely competitive for attractive investment opportunities. As a result, there can be no
assurance that Honeycomb will be able to identify or successfully pursue attractive investment
opportunities in such environments.

Significant Positions in Securities; Regulatory Requirements. In the event a client acquires a
significant stake in certain issuers of securities and such stake exceeds certain percentage or value
limits, such client may be subject to regulation and regulatory oversight that may impose
notification and filing requirements or other administrative burdens on the client and Honeycomb.
Any such requirements may impose additional costs on the client and may delay the acquisition or
disposition of the securities or the client's ability to respond in a timely manner to changes in the
markets with respect to such securities.

In addition, "position limits" may be imposed by various regulators that may limit Honeycomb's
ability to effect desired trades. Position limits are the maximum amounts of gross, net long or net
short positions that any one person or entity may own or control in a particular issuer's securities.
All positions owned or controlled by the same person or entity, even if in different accounts, may
March 2018
be aggregated for purposes of determining whether the applicable position limits have been
exceeded. To the extent that the client position limits were aggregated with an affiliate's position
limits, the effect on such client and resulting restriction on its investment activities may be
significant. If at any time positions managed by Honeycomb were to exceed applicable position
limits, Honeycomb would be required to liquidate positions, to the extent necessary to come within
those limits. Further, to avoid exceeding any position limits, a client might have to forego or
modify certain of its contemplated trades.

In addition, if a client, acting alone or as part of a group, acquires beneficial ownership of more
than 10% of a certain class of securities of a public company or places a director on the board of
directors of such a company, under Section 16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended,
such client may be subject to certain additional reporting requirements and may be required to
disgorge certain short-swing profits arising from purchases and sales of such securities.
Furthermore, in such circumstances the client will be prohibited from entering into a short position
in such issuer's securities, and therefore limited in its ability to hedge such investments. Similar
restrictions and requirements may apply in non-U.S. jurisdictions.

Exposure to Material Non-Public Information. From time to time, Honeycomb may receive
material non-public information with respect to an issuer of publicly traded securities. In such
circumstances, clients may be prohibited, by law, policy or contract, for a period of time from (i)
unwinding a position in such issuer, (ii) establishing an initial position or taking any greater
position in such issuer, and (iii) pursuing other investment opportunities related to such issuer.
These restrictions will limit Honeycomb's flexibility to manage client investments and could result
in significant losses.

Information Sources. Honeycomb selects positions for clients in part based on information filed
by the issuers of securities with the SEC and other regulatory authorities, or made available to
Honeycomb by the issuers or by others. Honeycomb cannot confirm the completeness,
genuineness or accuracy of such information, and, in some cases, complete and accurate
information is not readily available.

Currency Exchange Exposure. Clients may invest in securities denominated in non-U.S.
currencies, the prices of which are determined with reference to currencies other than the U.S.
dollar. Clients, however, value their securities in U.S. dollars. Honeycomb may or may not seek
to hedge non-U.S. currency exposure by entering into currency hedging transactions, such as
treasury locks, forward contracts, futures contracts and cross-currency swaps. There can be no
guarantee that securities suitable for hedging currency or market shifts will be available at the time
when a client wishes to use them, or that hedging techniques employed by a client will be effective.
Furthermore, certain currency market risks may not be fully hedged or hedged at all. To the extent
unhedged, the value of client positions in non-U.S. investments will fluctuate with U.S. dollar
exchange rates as well as with the price changes of the investments in the various local markets
and currencies. Such fluctuations may result in a loss.
March 2018
Furthermore, clients may incur costs in connection with conversions between various currencies.
Non-U.S. currency exchange dealers realize a profit based on the difference between the prices at
which they are buying and selling various currencies. Thus, a dealer normally will offer to sell
currency to a client at one rate, while offering a lesser rate of exchange should the client desire
immediately to resell that currency to the dealer. Honeycomb will conduct currency exchange
transactions either on a spot (Le., cash) basis at the spot rate prevailing in the currency exchange
market, or through entering into forward or options contracts to purchase or sell non-U.S.
currencies. Most of the clients' currency exchange transactions occur at the time non-U.S.
investments are purchased and are executed through the local broker or custodian acting for a
client.

Restricted Investments. Clients may invest in securities which are subject to legal or other
restrictions on transfer. The market prices, if any, for such securities tend to be volatile and may
not be readily ascertainable, and a client may not be able to sell them when it desires to do so or
to realize what it perceives to be their fair value in the event of a sale. Restricted securities may
sell at a price lower than similar securities that are not subject to restrictions on resale.
Non-U.S. Investments. Clients may invest in companies outside the United States. Investing in the
financial instruments of companies in non-U.S. countries involves certain considerations not
usually associated with investing in financial instruments of U.S. companies or U.S. markets,
including: political and economic considerations, such as greater risks of expropriation and
nationalization, confiscatory taxation, the potential difficulty of repatriating funds, general social,
political and economic instability and adverse diplomatic developments; the possibility of
imposition of withholding or other taxes on dividends, interest, capital gain, gross sale or
disposition proceeds or other income; the small size of the securities markets in such countries and
the low volume of trading, resulting in potential lack of liquidity and in price volatility; fluctuations
in the rate of exchange between currencies and costs associated with currency conversion; and
certain government policies that may restrict client investment opportunities. In addition,
accounting and financial reporting standards that prevail in such countries generally are not
equivalent to U.S. standards and, consequently, less information is available to investors in
companies located in such countries than is available to investors in companies located in the U.S.
There is also less regulation, generally, of the securities markets in such countries than there is in
the U.S. As a result, clients may be unable to structure transactions to achieve the intended results or
to mitigate all risks associated with such markets. It may also be difficult to enforce client rights in
such markets. For example, securities traded on non-U.S. exchanges and the non-U.S. persons that
trade these instruments are not subject to the jurisdiction of the SEC or the Commodity Futures
Trading Commission, the securities and commodities laws and regulations of the U.S. Accordingly,
the protections accorded to the clients under such laws and regulations are unavailable for transactions
on non-U.S. exchanges and with non-U.S. counterparties.

Discretion to Employ New Strategies and Techniques. Honeycomb has considerable discretion in
the types of financial instruments which clients may trade and has the right to modify the trading
March 2018
strategies or techniques of a Fund without the consent of investors. Any of these new trading
strategies or techniques may not be thoroughly tested in the market before being employed and
may have operational or theoretical shortcomings which could result in unsuccessful trades and,
ultimately, losses. In addition, any new trading strategy or technique developed by Honeycomb
may be more speculative than earlier techniques and may increase the risk of an investment.
Risks Related to Specific Investments
Equity Securities. Client investment portfolios include equity and equity-related securities of U.S.
and non-U.S. companies. The value of equity securities of public companies and equity derivatives
generally varies with the performance of the issuer and movements in the equity markets. As a
result, clients may suffer losses if they invest in equity instruments of issuers whose performance
diverges from Honeycomb's expectations or if equity markets generally move in a single direction
and a client has not hedged against such a general move.

Derivative Instruments Generally. Clients will enter into derivative transactions. Certain swaps,
options and other derivative instruments may be subject to various types of risks, including market
risk, liquidity risk, the risk of non-performance by the counterparty, including risks relating to the
financial soundness and creditworthiness of the counterparty, legal risk and operations risk.
Derivatives traded over-the-counter may not have an authoritative source of valuation and the
models used to value such derivatives is subject to change. Special risks may apply in the future
that cannot be determined at this time with respect to certain other derivative instruments that are
not presently contemplated for use or that are currently not available. The regulatory and tax
environment for derivative instruments in which clients may participate is evolving, and changes
in the regulation or taxation of such securities may have a material adverse effect on clients.
Call Options. There are risks associated with the sale and purchase of call options. The seller
(writer) of a call option which is covered (e.g., the writer holds the underlying security) assumes
the risk of a decline in the market price of the underlying security below the purchase price of the
underlying security offset by the gain of the premium received if the option expires out of the
money, and gives up the opportunity for gain on the underlying security above the exercise price
of the option. The seller of an uncovered call option assumes the risk of a theoretically unlimited
increase in the market price of the underlying security above the exercise price of the option. The
buyer of a call option assumes the risk of losing the premium if the option expires out of the money.
Put Options. There are risks associated with the sale and purchase of put options. The seller
(writer) of a put option which is covered (e.g., the writer has a short position in the underlying
security) assumes the risk of an increase in the market price of the underlying security above the
sale price of the short position of the underlying security offset by the premium if the option expires
out of the money, and thus the gain in the premium, and the option seller gives up the opportunity
for gain on the underlying security below the exercise price of the option. The seller of an
uncovered put option assumes the risk of a decline in the market price of the underlying security
March 2018
to zero. The buyer of a put option assumes the risk of losing the premium if the option expires out
of the money.

Index or Index Options. The value of an index or index option fluctuates with changes in the
market values of the securities included in the index. Because the value of an index or index option
depends upon movements in the level of the index rather than the price of a particular security,
whether a client will realize appreciation or depreciation from the purchase or writing of options
on indices depends upon movements in the level of instrument prices in the security market
generally or, in the case of certain indices, in an industry or market segment, rather than
movements in the price of particular securities.

Index Futures. The price of index futures contracts may not correlate perfectly with the movement
in the underlying index because of certain market distortions. First, all participants in the futures
market are subject to margin deposit and maintenance requirements. Rather than meeting
additional margin deposit requirements, shareholders may close futures contracts through
offsetting transactions that would distort the normal relationship between the index and futures
markets. Second, from the point of view of speculators, the deposit requirements in the futures
market are less onerous than margin requirements in the securities market. Therefore, increased
participation by speculators in the futures market also may cause price distortions. Successful use
of index futures contracts by clients also is subject to Honeycomb's ability to correctly predict
movements in the direction of the market.

Futures Contracts. Clients may invest in futures contracts or options thereon. Futures positions
may be illiquid because, for example, many commodity exchanges limit fluctuations in certain
futures contract prices during a single day by regulations referred to as "daily price fluctuation
limits" or "daily limits." Under such daily limits, during a single trading day no trades may be
executed at prices beyond the daily limits. Once the price of a contract for a particular future has
increased or decreased by an amount equal to the daily limit, positions in the future can neither be
taken nor liquidated unless traders are willing to effect trades at or within the limit. Futures
contract prices on various commodities or financial instruments occasionally have moved the daily
limit for several consecutive days with little or no trading. Similar occurrences could prevent
clients from promptly liquidating unfavorable positions and subject clients to substantial losses.
In addition, a client may not be able to execute futures contract trades at favorable prices if trading
volume in such contracts is low. It is also possible that an exchange or a regulator may suspend
trading in a particular contract, order immediate liquidation and settlement of a particular contract
or order that trading in a particular contract be conducted for liquidation only.

Fonvard Trading. Forward contracts and options thereon, unlike futures contracts, are generally
not traded on exchanges and are not standardized; rather, banks and dealers act as principals in these
markets, negotiating each transaction on an individual basis. Forward and "cash" trading is
substantially unregulated; there is no limitation on daily price movements and speculative position
limits are not applicable. The principals who deal in the forward markets are not required to continue
to make markets in the currencies or commodities they trade and these markets can experience
March 2018
periods of illiquidity, sometimes of significant duration. There have been periods during which
certain participants in these markets have refused to quote prices for certain currencies or
commodities or have quoted prices with an unusually wide spread between the price at which they
were prepared to buy and that at which they were prepared to sell. Disruptions can occur in any
market traded by a client due to unusually high trading volume, political intervention or other factors.
The imposition of controls by governmental authorities might also limit such forward (and futures)
trading to less than that which Honeycomb would otherwise recommend, to the possible detriment
of clients. Market illiquidity or disruption could result in major losses to clients.
Swap Agreements. Clients will enter into swap agreements. These agreements are individually
negotiated and can be structured to include exposure to a variety of different types of investments,
asset classes or market factors. Depending on their structure, swap agreements may increase or
decrease a client's exposure to, for example, equity securities. Swap agreements can take many
different forms and are known by a variety of names. A client is not limited to any particular form
of swap agreement if consistent with the client's investment objective. Whether a client's use of
swap agreements will be successful depends on Honeycomb's ability to select appropriate
transactions for the client. Swap transactions may be highly illiquid and may increase or decrease
the volatility of a client's portfolio. Moreover, a client bears the risk of loss of the amount expected
to be received under a swap agreement in the event of the default or insolvency of its counterparty.
Clients also bear the risk of loss related to swap agreements, for example, for breaches of such
agreements or the failure of Honeycomb to post or maintain required collateral. Many swap
markets are relatively new and still developing. It is possible that developments in the swap
markets, including potential government regulation, could adversely affect a client's ability to
terminate existing swap transactions or to realize amounts to be received under such transactions.
Exchange Traded Funds. ETFs are publicly traded unit investment trusts, open-end funds or
depository receipts that seek to track the performance and dividend yield of specific indexes or
companies in related industries. These indexes may be either broad-based, sector, or international.
However, ETF shareholders are generally subject to the same risk as holders of the underlying
securities they are designed to track. ETFs are also subject to certain additional risks, including,
without limitation, the risk that their prices may not correlate perfectly with changes in the prices
of the underlying securities they are designed to track, and the risk of trading in an ETF halting
due to market conditions or other reasons, based on the policies of the exchange upon which the
ETF trades. Generally, each shareholder of an ETF bears a pro rata portion of the ETF's expenses,
including management fees. Accordingly, in addition to bearing their proportionate share of client
expenses (e.g., Management Fees and operating expenses), investors will also indirectly bear
similar expenses of an ETF.

Other Derivative Instruments. Clients will enter into swaps and/or other derivative instruments.
They may take advantage of opportunities with respect to certain other derivative instruments that
are not currently contemplated for use or that are currently not available, but that may be
developed, to the extent such opportunities are both consistent with the investment objective of a
March 2018
client and believed by Honeycomb to be legally permissible. Special risks may apply to
instruments that are invested in by a client in the future that cannot be determined at this time or
until such instruments are developed or invested in by the client. Certain swaps, options and other
derivative instruments may be subject to various types of risks, including market risk, liquidity
risk, the risk of non-performance by the counterparty, including risks relating to the financial
soundness and creditworthiness of the counterparty, legal risk and operations risk.
High Volatility. The prices of derivative instruments, including currencies, futures and option
prices, can be highly volatile. Price movements of derivative contracts in which a client's
portfolio's assets may be invested are influenced by, among other things, interest rates, changing
supply and demand relationships, trade, fiscal, monetary and exchange control programs and
policies of governments, and national and international political and economic events and policies.
In addition, governments from time to time intervene, directly and by regulation, in certain
markets, particularly those in currencies, financial instruments, futures and options. Such
intervention often is intended directly to influence prices and may, together with other factors,
cause all of such markets to move rapidly in the same direction because of, among other things,
interest rate fluctuations. Client portfolios are also subject to the risk of the failure of any
exchanges on which their positions trade or of their clearinghouses.

Currencies. Clients will enter into spot and forward currency contracts or invest in currency futures
contracts and options on currencies and futures to hedge currency risk by shifting exposure to foreign
currency fluctuations from one currency to another with respect to a client. Currency transactions
made on a spot (i.e., cash) basis are at the spot rate prevailing in the currency exchange market. A
forward currency contract, which involves an obligation to purchase or sell a specific currency at a
future date at a price set at the time of the contract, reduces client exposure with respect to its
investment to changes in the value of the currency it will deliver and increases client exposure to
changes in the value of the currency it will receive for the duration of the contract.
Currency trading is subject to risks different from those of other securities transactions. Because
exchange rate control is of great importance to the issuing governments and influences economic
planning and policy, purchases and sales of currency and related instruments can be negatively
affected by government exchange controls, blockages, and manipulations or exchange restrictions
imposed by governments. These government actions can result in losses if it is unable to deliver or
receive currency or funds in settlement of obligations. Buyers and sellers of currency futures are
subject to the same risks that apply to the use of futures generally. Furthermore, settlement of a
currency forward contract for the purchase of most currencies must occur at a bank based in the
issuing nation. The ability to establish and close out options on currency futures is subject to the
maintenance of a liquid market, which may not always be available. Currency exchange rates may
fluctuate based on factors extrinsic to that country's economy.

At or before the maturity of a forward currency contract, a client may either make delivery of the
currency, or terminate its contractual obligation to deliver the currency by buying an "offsetting"
contract obligating it to buy, on the same maturity date, the same amount of the currency.
March 2018
If a client engages in an offsetting transaction, it may later enter into a new forward currency contract
to sell the currency. If a client engages in an offsetting transaction, it will incur a gain or loss to the
extent that there has been movement in forward currency contract prices. If forward prices go down
during the period between the date the client enters into a forward currency contract for the sale of a
currency and the date it enters into an offsetting contract for the purchase of the currency, the client
will realize a gain to the extent that the price of the currency it has agreed to sell exceeds the price
of the currency it has agreed to buy. If forward prices go up, the client will suffer a loss to the extent
the price of the currency it has agreed to buy exceeds the price of the currency it has agreed to sell.
Commodities. The values of commodities that underlie commodity futures contracts and other
types of financial instruments in which clients may invest generally are affected by, among other
factors, the cost of producing commodities, changes in consumer demand for commodities, the
hedging and trading strategies of producers and consumers of commodities, speculative trading in
commodities by commodity pools and other market participants, disruptions in commodity supply,
weather and climate conditions, changes in interest rates, rates of inflation, currency devaluations
and revaluations, embargoes, tariffs, regulatory developments, governmental, agricultural, trade,
fiscal, monetary and exchange control programs and policies, political and other global events and
global economic factors. In addition, governments from time to time intervene, directly and by
regulation, in certain markets, often with the intent to influence prices directly. The effects of
governmental intervention may be particularly significant at certain times in certain markets and
this intervention may cause these markets to move rapidly. Honeycomb has no control over the
factors that affect the price of commodities. Accordingly, the value of client investments could
change substantially and in a rapid and unpredictable manner.

Preferred Stock. Investments in preferred stock involve risks related to priority in the event of
bankruptcy, insolvency or liquidation of the issuing company and how dividends are declared.
Preferred stock ranks junior to debt securities in an issuer's capital structure and, accordingly, is
subordinate to all debt in bankruptcy. Preferred stock generally has a preference as to dividends.
Such dividends are generally paid in cash (or additional shares of preferred stock) at a defined rate,
but unlike interest payments on debt securities, preferred stock dividends are payable only if
declared by the issuer's board of directors. Dividends on preferred stock may be cumulative,
meaning that, in the event the issuer fails to make one or more dividend payments on the preferred
stock, no dividends may be paid on the issuer's common stock until all unpaid preferred stock
dividends have been paid. Preferred stock may also be subject to optional or mandatory
redemption provisions.

Fixed Income Instruments. Clients may invest in fixed income instruments (including debt, bonds,
notes and credit-related derivatives). The value of fixed income instruments in which clients may
invest will change in response to fluctuations in interest rates. Increases in interest rates may cause
the value of a client's debt investments to decline. Clients may experience increased interest rate
risk to the extent they invest in lower-rated instruments, debt instruments with longer maturities,
debt instruments paying no interest (such as zero-coupon debt instruments) or debt instruments
March 2018
paying non-cash interest in the form of other debt instruments. Except to the extent that values are
independently affected by currency exchange rate fluctuations, when interest rates decline, the
value of fixed income instruments generally can be expected to rise. Conversely, when interest
rates rise, the value of fixed income instruments generally can be expected to decline. In addition,
the value of certain fixed income instruments can fluctuate in response to perceptions of credit
worthiness, political stability or soundness of economic policies. Valuations of other fixed income
instruments may fluctuate in response to changes in the economic environment that may affect
future cash flows.

Convertible Securities. Convertible securities are bonds, debentures, notes, preferred stocks or
other securities that may be converted into or exchanged for a specified amount of common stock
of the same or different issuer within a particular period of time at a specified price or formula. A
convertible security entitles its holder to receive interest that is generally paid or accrued on debt
or a dividend that is paid or accrued on preferred stock until the convertible security matures or is
redeemed, converted or exchanged. Convertible securities have unique investment characteristics
in that they generally (i) have higher yields than common stocks, but lower yields than comparable
non-convertible securities, (ii) are less subject to fluctuation in value than the underlying common
stock due to their fixed-income characteristics and (iii) provide the potential for capital
appreciation if the market price of the underlying common stock increases.

The value of a convertible security is a function of its "investment value" (determined by its yield
in comparison with the yields of other securities of comparable maturity and quality that do not
have a conversion privilege) and its "conversion value" (the security's worth, at market value, if
converted into the underlying common stock). The investment value of a convertible security is
influenced by changes in interest rates, with investment value declining as interest rates increase
and increasing as interest rates decline. The credit standing of the issuer and other factors may
also have an effect on the convertible security's investment value. The conversion value of a
convertible security is determined by the market price of the underlying common stock. If the
conversion value is low relative to the investment value, the price of the convertible security is
governed principally by its investment value. To the extent the market price of the underlying
common stock approaches or exceeds the conversion price, the price of the convertible security
will be increasingly influenced by its conversion value. A convertible security generally will sell
at a premium over its conversion value by the extent to which investors place value on the right to
acquire the underlying common stock while holding a fixed-income security. Generally, the
amount of the premium decreases as the convertible security approaches maturity.

A convertible security may be subject to redemption at the option of the issuer at a price established
in the convertible security's governing instrument. If a convertible security held by a client is
called for redemption, the client will be required to permit the issuer to redeem the security, convert
it into the underlying common stock or sell it to a third-party. Any of these actions could have an
adverse effect on a client's ability to achieve its investment objective.
March 2018
ITEM 9
Disciplinary Information
Neither Honeycomb nor its management persons are subject to legal or disciplinary events that are
material to a client's or prospective client's evaluation of Honeycomb's advisory business or the
integrity of Honeycomb's management.
March 2018
ITEM 10
Other Financial Industry Activities and Affiliations
Honeycomb and its management persons have material relationships with each of the Funds and
co-investment vehicles to which Honeycomb provides investment management services. As
described in Item 4, an affiliate of Honeycomb serves as the general partner to the Onshore Feeder
and each co-investment vehicle, and David Fiszel serves as one of three directors for the Offshore
Feeder.

While the Funds and the Master Fund may trade commodity interests, Honeycomb (and its
affiliates) are exempt from registration with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (the
"CFTC") as a commodity pool operator pursuant to CFTC Rule 4.13(a)(3).
March 2018
ITEM II
Code of Ethics, Participation or Interest in Client Transactions and Personal Trading
Code of Ethics
As a registered investment adviser, Honeycomb has adopted a code of ethics (the "Ethics Code")
under Advisers Act Rule 204A-1 which sets forth standards of business conduct for its partners
and employees (together, the "Employees"). The Ethics Code may also apply to other persons that
are designated by the Chief Compliance Officer ("CCO"). The Ethics Code is based on the
fundamental principle that Honeycomb stands in a position of trust and confidence with respect to
its clients and has a fiduciary duty to place the interests of its clients before its own interests or
those of its Employees.
The major areas that are covered in the Ethics Code are summarized below.

Personal Trading. Personal accounts that hold or have the ability to hold "reportable securities"
in which an Employee has beneficial ownership must be reported at the start of employment and
annually to the CCO. Trading in reportable securities is generally prohibited, except for limited
instruments or in limited circumstances, each with pre-approval of the CCO.

Outside Interests. Outside interests of an Employee and members of his or her household and
immediate family must be reported at the start of employment and annually. In addition,
Employees must obtain permission before engaging in certain activities, including but not limited
to, receiving compensation, taking a management or executive position, or providing advice about
investments and/or trading.

Gifts and Entertainment. Gifts and entertainment that are received or given and that have a certain
fair market value must be reported to the CCO. Gifts of cash and cash equivalents are strictly
prohibited. Gifts and entertainment to any government officials (including foreign government
officials) or their families, any political party or official or candidate for political office (including
any foreign political party or official or candidate for political office) are prohibited without prior
approval of the CCO.

Compliance with Federal Securities Laws. Employees are required to comply with applicable
federal securities laws.

General; Administration of the Ethics Code. The Ethics Code will be administered by the CCO.
Employees are required to report any violation of the Ethics Code to the CCO. Exceptions to the
Ethics Code may be granted by the CCO under limited circumstances provided that certain
conditions are met. Violations of the Ethics Code may result in disciplinary action and any
sanctions will be determined by the CCO in consultation with the Chief Investment Officer. The
CCO maintains records of violations of the Ethics Code and any action taken as a result.
March 2018
Clients and prospective clients may request to review the Ethics Code in its entirety by contacting
compliance@honeycombam.com.
Investing in Securities that Honeycomb Recommends to Clients
As explained above, Honeycomb serves as investment manager to the Funds, an affiliate of
Honeycomb serves as the general partner to the Onshore Feeder and the co-investment vehicles,
and David Fiszel serves as one of three directors for the Offshore Feeder and managing member
and majority owner of the general partner entities. As of the date of this Brochure, Honeycomb's
clients include the Funds and their associated co-investment vehicles.

Honeycomb, its Employees or their related persons have invested directly or indirectly in the Funds
and co-investment vehicles. The fact that Honeycomb, its affiliates, its Employees or their related
persons have a financial ownership interest in the Funds and co-investment vehicles creates a
potential conflict in that it could cause Honeycomb to make different investment decisions than if
they did not have such a financial ownership interest.

Complete fee disclosures are provided to investors in the governing fund documents of the Funds
and co-investment vehicles and should be carefully reviewed by prospective investors. Further,
Honeycomb's Ethics Code sets forth a standard of business conduct that takes into account
Honeycomb's status as a fiduciary and requires Employees to place the interests of the Funds, co-
investment vehicles, and their investors above their own interests. Honeycomb further addresses
these potential conflicts through, among other things, disclosure of potential conflicts of interests
and risks in offering documents provided to prospective investors and required suitability criteria
for investors.
Conflicts Caused by Contemporaneous Trading
As noted above, as of the date of this Brochure, Honeycomb's clients include the Funds and their
associated co-investment vehicles. Honeycomb is committed to allocating investment
opportunities on a fair and equitable basis, and in a manner that is consistent with its fiduciary
duties to its clients. In that connection, Honeycomb has adopted policies and procedures to address
conflicts associated with contemporaneous trading among client accounts.

Honeycomb and its related persons may from time to time, purchase, sell, or otherwise enter into
transactions for themselves in securities. Prior to, simultaneously with or subsequent to such
transactions, Honeycomb may, for the account of a client, purchase, sell, or otherwise enter into
transactions involving any of these same securities or other related securities. Such trading could
create potential conflicts of interest because Honeycomb's decision to buy or sell a security for a
client can affect the value of that security or a related security held by Honeycomb and its related
persons, and Honeycomb and its related persons' decision to buy or sell a security for themselves
can affect the value of that security or related security held by a client. In addition, Honeycomb
and its related persons may hold positions that increase in value due to market, company specific
March 2018
or other events that at the same time cause client securities to decrease in value and vice versa.
Therefore, any securities transaction for the accounts of Honeycomb and its related persons will
be entered into only if the transaction is consistent with Honeycomb's fiduciary duties to its clients
and its applicable internal procedures then in effect. In certain circumstances (e.g., when
Honeycomb determines that a particular investment opportunity is too large for a client or not
appropriate for allocation to a client for the other reasons discussed below), Honeycomb or its
affiliates may co-invest in an opportunity with a client.
Other Activities
Honeycomb and its respective members, partners, officers, employees and affiliates will devote as
much of their time to the activities of clients as they deem necessary and appropriate. Honeycomb
and its respective affiliates are not restricted from forming additional investment funds, from
entering into other investment advisory relationships (including, without limitation, managed
accounts or other vehicles held by single investors) or from engaging in other business activities,
even though such activities may be in competition with clients and/or may involve substantial time
and resources. Honeycomb and its affiliates and employees will also source and elect to participate
in Special Investments while other investors in the Fund may elect not to participate in such
investments. These activities could be viewed as creating a conflict of interest in that the time and
effort of Honeycomb their affiliates and their officers and employees will not be devoted
exclusively to the business of a particular client or to investments for a Fund in which all investors
will participate, but will be allocated between the business of multiple clients and other potential
businesses of Honeycomb.
Allocation of Investment Opportunities
As of the date of this Brochure, Honeycomb's clients include the Funds and co-investment
vehicles. The Onshore Feeder and the Offshore Feeder invest all or substantially all of their assets
in the Master Fund and Honeycomb maintains trading accounts for the Master Fund, to which it
allocates a majority of its investment opportunities. Each of the co-investment vehicles also
maintain prime brokerage and custodial relationships. It should be noted that Honeycomb
currently acts as (and may in the future act as) investment adviser for clients that have a variety of
investment objectives and strategies. A particular investment may be deemed suitable for one
client but not another, irrespective of whether the clients' investment objectives and strategies are
similar. In all instances, Honeycomb will allocate investment opportunities in a manner which it
determines over time is fair and equitable under the circumstances to all clients.

While certain investments may be purchased or sold for clients on a pro rata basis, many
investments may not be allocated to a particular client at all or may be allocated differently among
clients (e.g., not on a pro rata basis). The decision whether and to what extent to include a
particular client in the purchase or sale of an investment will be based on various factors, including
but not limited to: the investment objectives, strategies and policies of clients, which may include
distinguishing what Honeycomb deems to be the primary investment objective or strategy for one
March 2018
client and not the primary investment objective or strategy for another client; the amount of capital
available for a particular investment or type of investment; exposure targets for a particular
investment, sector or industry; the availability of (or potential availability of) investments with
better risk/reward profiles for a particular client; the need to ramp up or rebalance a client portfolio;
risk management considerations, including risk tolerance of a particular client; administrative
complexity associated with an allocation, which may include avoiding a de minimis allocation to
one or more clients, and timing constraints for completing required legal or compliance
documentation or checks; liquidity considerations, including the impact of the investment on the
liquidity of the client's portfolio as a whole and the need for cash to satisfy redemption requests
or other obligations; legal or regulatory considerations and restrictions; tax considerations
(including, without limitation, the holding period for the investment); availability of, and terms
related to, financing or leverage; counterparty relationships of different clients; and the maturity
of the investment (e.g., expected proximity to a liquidity event), including in the context of private
investment allocations to a hedge fund client outside of any side pocket.

All such factors, as set forth in Honeycomb's allocation policy, regardless of whether they are
enumerated herein or not are referred to as the "Allocation Factors". Allocation Factors may be
weighted differently as determined by Honeycomb depending on the relevant facts and
circumstances. As a result of the Allocation Factors, not all clients, even clients that have the same
or similar investment objectives and strategies, may participate in the allocation of investment
opportunities of other clients. To the extent more than one client participates in the allocation of
the same investment opportunity, the amount allocated to one client may differ substantially from
the allocation granted to another client. In addition to primary portfolio positions, clients may also
engage in different hedging activities (or no hedging at all) depending on the Allocation Factors
listed above, including in situations where clients hold the same primary portfolio positions.
Co-Investment Opportunities
Honeycomb and its affiliates may, from time to time, offer one or more clients, investors in such
clients and/or other third-party investors the opportunity to co-invest in particular investments.
Honeycomb is not obligated to arrange co-investment opportunities, no investor will be obligated
to participate in such an opportunity, and Honeycomb may offer co-investment opportunities only
to certain of the persons referenced above in its sole discretion. Honeycomb and its affiliates have
sole discretion as to the amount (if any) of a co-investment opportunity that will be allocated to a
particular investor and may allocate co-investment opportunities only to certain investors, certain
clients or to third parties. If Honeycomb determines that an investment opportunity is too large for
a client, it or its affiliates may, but will not be obligated to, make proprietary investments therein.
Honeycomb and its affiliates may receive fees and/or allocations from co-investors, which may
differ as among co-investors and also may differ from the fees and/or allocations borne by other
clients. Other terms and rights applicable to such co-investors (including without limitation,
withdrawal rights, information rights and the terms related to the particular structure of any co-
March 2018
investment vehicle) may also differ from the terms and rights applicable to clients as well as among
co-investors.
March 2018
ITEM 12
Brokerage Practices
Brokerage Practices
Honeycomb will seek to obtain best execution for clients. Subject to best execution, in selecting
brokers and dealers (including prime brokers) to execute transactions Honeycomb may consider,
among other factors that are deemed appropriate to consider under the circumstances, the
following: price quotes; the size of the transaction; the nature of the market for the security; the
timing of the transaction; the difficulty of execution; the broker or dealer's expertise in the relevant
market or sector; the extent to which the broker or dealer makes a market in the security or has
access to such market; the broker or dealer's skill in positioning the relevant market; the broker or
dealer's facilities, reliability, promptness and financial stability; the broker or dealer's reputation
for diligence and integrity (including in correcting errors); confidentiality considerations; the
quality and usefulness of research products and services and investment ideas presented by the
broker or dealer, including access to company management and deal flow; consulting and advice
with respect to technology, operations, and equipment; the provision by brokers of capital
introduction, talent introduction and marketing assistance; and other factors deemed appropriate
by Honeycomb. Accordingly, the prices, commission rates (or dealer mark-ups and mark-downs
arising in connection with riskless principal transactions) or spreads charged to clients by brokers
or dealers in the foregoing circumstances may be higher than those charged by other brokers and
dealers not offering the same level of such services. Honeycomb need not solicit competitive bids
and does not have an obligation to seek the lowest available commission cost or spread.
Honeycomb will enact policies and procedures to review the quality of executions, including
periodic reviews by one or more of its investment professionals and other personnel to evaluate
the qualitative execution performance of brokers executing Honeycomb's trade orders.
Soft Dollar Usage
It is Honeycomb's policy to use client brokerage commission dollars ("soft dollars") to pay only
for products and services that qualify as eligible "research and brokerage services" and that fall
within the safe harbor provided by Section 28(e) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as
amended (the "Exchange Act"). Also, consistent with Section 28(e), research and brokerage
services obtained with soft dollars generated by one or more clients may be used by Honeycomb
to service one or more other clients, including clients that may not have paid for the soft dollar
benefits. Honeycomb does not seek to allocate soft dollar benefits to clients in proportion to the
soft dollar credits such clients generate.

In the last year, Honeycomb has acquired the following types of products and services with soft
dollars:
March 2018

• Research reports, including market, company or industry specific reports;
• Investment related data services, including services providing market, company financial or
economic data, data on trends related to a specific company or industry, and other data
providing assistance in investment and trading decision -making; and
• Investment -related research services from sell-side analysts and other third party research
firms, including written and oral research and assistance used in investment decision -making
and order execution, access to corporate executives, and attendance at seminars, conferences,
roundtables and other discussions.

Although soft dollars are expressly permitted under the Exchange Act, their use gives rise to a
number of potential conflicts of interest. For example, investment advisers using soft dollars may
not have the same interest in controlling the expense of research or brokerage services as they
would if they were paying for such services directly. When an investment adviser uses
commissions arising from client portfolio transactions to obtain research or other products or
services, it receives a benefit because it does not have to produce or pay for the research, products
or service, and these benefits provide an incentive for the adviser to select a broker-dealer based
on its interest in receiving such products or services, rather than on clients' interest in receiving
best execution. Investment advisers using soft dollars may also have an incentive to trade more
frequently than reasonably necessary in order to generate soft dollars to pay for research or
brokerage services. Finally, investment advisers using soft dollars may have an incentive to route
a particular trade order to a participating soft dollar broker over a venue that may offer better trade
execution for that particular order. Although Honeycomb will make a good faith determination
that the amount of commissions paid is reasonable in light of the products or services provided by
a broker, commission rates are generally negotiable and thus, selecting brokers on the basis of
considerations that are not limited to the applicable commission rates may result in higher
transaction costs than would otherwise be obtainable.

In order to mitigate these potential conflicts of interest, professionals of Honeycomb meet
periodically to evaluate the qualitative execution performance of brokers executing Honeycomb's
trade orders including the use and allocation of brokerage commissions and the firm's spending
on research and brokerage services.
Client and Investor Referrals
One or more brokers for the Funds may provide Honeycomb with capital introduction services
whereby Honeycomb may be afforded the opportunity to make a presentation regarding its services
to clients of the broker. While the brokers generally provide such services at no additional cost,
Honeycomb (and not the Funds) may be the principal or sole beneficiary of those services, which
could present a potential conflict of interest between the Funds and Honeycomb, because
Honeycomb is responsible for selecting brokers and negotiating brokerage, margin and other fees
that are paid by the Funds. Since these arrangements will include brokers Honeycomb selects to
March 2018
execute trades on behalf of the Funds, Honeycomb may consider this potential conflict of interest
as part of its periodic reviews to evaluate best execution.
Directed Brokerage
Honeycomb does not currently have any directed brokerage arrangements in place.
Order Aggregation
If Honeycomb determines that the purchase or sale of a financial instrument is appropriate with
regard to multiple client accounts, Honeycomb may, but is not obligated to, purchase or sell such
a financial instrument on behalf of such accounts with an aggregated order to the extent permitted
by applicable law, consistent with its duty to obtain best execution, and any relevant Allocation
Factors. When an aggregated order is filled through multiple trades at different prices on the same
day, each participating account will receive the average price, with transaction costs generally
allocated pro rata based on the size of each account's participation in the order as determined by
Honeycomb. In the event of a partial fill, allocations will generally be allocated pro rata in
proportion to the size of the orders placed for each client to the extent practicable but may be
modified on a basis that Honeycomb deems to be appropriate, including, for example, in order to
avoid odd lots or de minimis allocations. In some circumstances, Honeycomb may reach
investment decisions for different clients at different times during a day and such orders may not
be aggregated. When orders are not aggregated, trades generally will be processed in the order that
they are placed with the broker or counterparty selected by Honeycomb. As a result, certain trades
in the same financial instrument for one client may receive more or less favorable prices or terms
than another client, and orders placed later may not be filled entirely or at all, based upon the
prevailing market prices and/or volume of trading at the time of the order or trade. In addition,
some opportunities for reduced transaction costs and economies of scale may not be achieved.
March 2018
ITEM 13
Review of Accounts
Client accounts will be reviewed on a daily basis by the Chief Investment Officer, Head Trader
and other members of Honeycomb's staff. These reviews include an assessment to determine
whether securities positions should be maintained in view of current market conditions. Matters
reviewed include specific securities held and the performance of clients. Further, the Chief
Compliance Officer, periodically reviews trading to ensure consistency with applicable laws and
regulations.

Investors receive periodic performance reports and an annual financial report audited by the Funds'
independent auditors. Additional information is available to all investors in the Funds upon request.
March 2018
ITEM 14
Client Referrals and Other Compensation
As described in Item 12, one or more of the brokers for the Funds may provide Honeycomb with
capital introduction services whereby Honeycomb may be afforded the opportunity to make a
presentation regarding its services to clients of the broker. While the brokers generally provide
such services at no additional cost, Honeycomb (and not the Funds) may be the principal or sole
beneficiary of those services, which could present a potential conflict of interest between the Funds
and Honeycomb, because Honeycomb is responsible for selecting brokers and negotiating
brokerage, margin and other fees that are paid by the Funds. Since these arrangements will include
brokers Honeycomb selects to execute trades on behalf of the Funds, Honeycomb may consider
this potential conflict of interest as part of its periodic reviews to evaluate best execution
March 2018
ITEM 15
Custody
Honeycomb is deemed to have custody of the assets of the Funds and associated co-investment
vehicles because it has the authority to obtain client funds or securities, for example, by deducting
performance -based compensation from a client's account or otherwise withdrawing funds from a
client's account.

Honeycomb is subject to Rule 206(4)-2 under the Advisers Act (the "Custody Rule"). However,
it is not required to comply (or is deemed to have complied) with certain requirements of the
Custody Rule with respect to each Fund because it complies with the provisions of the so-called
"Pooled Vehicle Annual Audit Exception", which, among other things, requires that each Fund be
subject to audit at least annually by an independent public accountant that is registered with, and
subject to regular inspection by, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board, and requires
that each Fund distribute its audited financial statements to all investors within 120 days of the end
of its fiscal year.
March 2018
ITEM 16
Investment Discretion
Honeycomb has discretionary authority to manage investments of its clients.

Any limitation on Honeycomb's discretionary authority is contained in the relevant documents for
the particular Fund or co-investment vehicle (e.g., offering materials, subscription documents,
limited partnership agreement for the Onshore Feeder and co-investment vehicles or memorandum
of association and articles of association for the Offshore Feeder).
March 2018
ITEM 17
Voting Client Securities
Honeycomb has discretionary authority to vote proxies for its clients. Honeycomb has retained
the proxy research and voting services of Institutional Shareholder Services Inc. ("ISS") to assist
Honeycomb in voting proxies in the best interests of its clients. ISS is an independent proxy voting
firm that specializes in analyzing shareholder voting matters, issuing research reports on such
matters, and making voting recommendations intended to maximize shareholder value. ISS
provides Honeycomb with analytical summaries and final vote recommendations for domestic and
foreign proxy matters.

As a general matter, Honeycomb believes that ISS is in the best position to make proxy vote
recommendations that are in the best interests of clients in light of the dedicated resources and
expertise of ISS. Honeycomb also believes that ISS is a more cost effective alternative to handle
proxy voting (e.g., conducting research and analysis on proxy matters as well as the mechanics of
voting proxies and retaining records) and is the best way to protect clients against potential
conflicts of interest between Honeycomb and its clients. Notwithstanding the foregoing, however,
Honeycomb does retain the right to override ISS vote recommendations where Honeycomb
believes it is important to do so (e.g., when an ISS vote recommendation is at odds with a client's
investment objectives).

Records of proxy materials and proxy votes are maintained in Honeycomb's offices and/or by ISS.
Clients may request to review Honeycomb's proxy voting policies and procedures in its entirety
as well as Honeycomb's proxy voting history by contacting compliance@honevcombam.com.
March 2018
PfEM 18
Financial Information
Honeycomb is not required to include a balance sheet for its most recent fiscal year, is not aware
of any financial condition reasonably likely to impair its ability to meet contractual commitments
to clients, and has not been the subject of a bankruptcy petition at any time during the past ten
years.
March 2018
EFTA00810306 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2018-03-31)
Valar Global Fund II LP
Unaudited Financial Statements
March 31, 2018
VALAR
Valar Global Fund II LP
Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Partners' Capital
March 31.2018
Assets
Cash 1,537,573
Investments, at fair value (cost $59,507,899) [06,578,582
Interest receivable 75,177
Total assets $ 108.191.332
Partners' Capital
Contributions 69,179,430
Syndication costs (315,000)
Net operating loss (5,826,623)
Net realized loss (1,917,158)
Net unrealized gain 47,070,683
Total partners capital $ 108,191,332
Valar Global Fund II LP
Statement of Operations
January I, 2018 through March 31, 2018
Income
Interest income 19,389
Expenses
Net management fees 421,804
Professional fees 71,456
General and administrative 9,782
Total expenses 503,042
Net operating loss
Net realized loss
Net change in unrealized appreciation
in fair value of investments
Net increase in partners' capital
resulting from operations
(483,653)
(1,917,158)
20,058,658
17.657.847
Valar Global Fund II LP
Schedule of Investments
March 31, 2018
Shares Cost Fair Value
Unrealized
Gain/(Loss)
1426 GmbH
Series A Preferred Shares 5.314 $ 4,802,996 $ 33,540,547 $28,737,551
Series B Preferred Shares 2,127 5,562,347 13,425,055 7,862,708
Breather Products Inc.
Series B-2 Preferred Shares 4,175,999 11,560,000 22,966,324 11,406,324
Series C Preferred Shares 1,050,985 5,779,997 5,779,997
Kalo Industries Inc. (Ma Lystable Inc.)
Series A5 Preferred Shares 1,542,649 3,399,998 3,399,998
Series A4 Preferred Shares 3,028,446 4,705,599 6,674,695 1,969,096
Series A3 Preferred Shares 194,578 174,634 428,850 254,216
Series A2 Preferred Shares 319,095 179,012 703,285 524,273
Granify, Inc.
Series A-3 Preferred Shares 1,215,895 3,782,163 3,782,163
Convertible Note 489,600 489,600
Trade It. Inc. (f/1c/a Trading Ticket. Inc.)
Series Seed-2 Preferred Shares 896,484 1,040,818 1,040,818 -
Series Seed Preferred Shares 1,464,255 1,360,000 1,700,000 340,000
Common Shares 329,662 107,780 382,738 274,958
Even Responsible Finance, Inc.
Series A Preferred Shares 1,627,564 3,093,999 3,093,999
Deposit Solutions GmbH
Series B Preferred Shares 668 1,153,583 2,251,932 1,098,349
Homie. Inc.
Series Seed-2 Preferred Shares 1,569,713 1,699,999 1,699,999
Convertibe Note 170,000 170,000
Common Shares 212,894 170,002 230,564 60,562
Vend Limited
Series D Preferred Shares 503,288 1,336,200 1.477.776 141,576
Stash Financial, Inc (Vida Collective Returns. Inc.)
Series Seed-2 Preferred Shares 92,270 169,998 1.360.925 1,190,927
Valar Global Fund II LP
Schedule of Investments
March 31, 2018
Shares Cost Fair Value
Unrealized
Gainnoss)
Eden, Ltd.
Series I) Preference Shares 738,246 $ 509,980 $ 704,361 $ 194,381
Convertible Note 195,103 195,103
IrisVR. Inc.
Series AA Preferred Shares 215,942 170,000 258,612 88,612
Series A Preferred Shares 129,308 154,859 154,859
Carmen. Inc.
Series Seed Preferred Shares 275,660 170,000 265,618 95,618
Jopwell, Inc.
Series A-1 Preferred Stock 170,622 226,382 226,382
Eye Em Limited
Common Shares 562,453,356 7,342,850 174,382 (7.168,468)
Total Investments S 59.507.899 S 106.578.582 547.070.6S3
EFTA00810352 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2018-03-31)
Valar Global Fund III LP
Unaudited Financial Statements
March 31, 2018
VALAR
Valar Global Fund HI LP
Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Partners' Capital
March 31, 2018
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents 879,320
Investments, at fair value (cost $52,001,076) 84,152,228
Interest receivable 8,896
Total assets $ 85,040,444
Partners' Capital
Contributions $ 56,362,460
Syndication costs (139,155)
Net operating loss (3,334,013)
Net unrealized gain 32,151,152
Total partners capital 85,040,444
Total liabilities and partners' capital $ 85.040.444
Valar Global Fund III LP
Statement of Operations
January I, 2018 through March 31, 2018
Income
Interest income 2,096
Expenses
Gross management fee 403,283
Management fee reduction for syndication costs (31,500)
Net management fee 371,783
Professional fees 75,285
General and administrative 24,207
Total expenses 471,275
Net operating loss (469,179)
Net change in unrealized appreciation
in fair value of investments 6,910,798
Net increase in partners' capital
resulting from operations $ 6,441.619
Vida,- Global Fund III LP
Schedule of Investments
Match 31. 2018
Company Shares Cost Fair Value
Unrealized
Gaminess)
Stash Financial. Inc.
SenesB Named Shares 1.647219 S 10.200.000 S 24.304.309 S 14.104.309
Series A Preferred Shams 693329 1.937.997 10.229,123 8.291,126
Series C Preferred Shares 217.494 2.692.576 3.207,902 515.326
Series D Pretested Shares 46.103 679,991 679,991
Octane Lending. Inc.
Series A-Ill Convertible Preferred Stock 1262226 8.473.658 8.473.658
Common Stock 129.127 516308 700.397 183.889
Coss AG
Series A Preferred Shares 11.914 4.422.963 8.514./// 4.113,259
Olinda S.A.S Okra Qonto/
Series A ()alma!). Shares 26.165 5.378.771 6.255.352 876.581
Series Seed Ordinary Shares 6.351 344346 1318.354 1.173,808
N26 GmbH
Preferred B Shams 1.098 4.114.464 6.930.282 2.595,818
Petal Card. Inc.
Series A Preferred Shares 4.485.326 5.405.889 5.647.025 241.136
Common Stock 18.100 70332 98.328 27.796
Jetty National. Inc.
Series A Preferred Shares 2.315.145 5.505351 5.505251
Spaceship Financial Services Pty Ltd
Convertible Notes 521.876 521.376 500
Brolly UK Technology Limited
Series Seed Preferred Shares 592.449 210.580 238,184 27,604
Convertible Notes 237375 237.575
Seed Platform. Inc.
Simple Agreement fa Hawse Equity 340.000 340.400
Simple. Inc.
Simple Agreement fa Fbuite Equity 217.600 217.600
Peak Ventures Fund IL..
Limited Partnership Intetests 204.000 204.000
Minor Al Inc.
Convertible Notes 170.0O) 170.000
Andutil Industries. Inc.
Series Seed Preferred Stock 123.143 68.000 68.0:0
Brat Inc.
Series Seed Preferred Stock 83.563 67.999 67,999
Taal Investments S 52.001.076 S 84.152.228 S 32.151.152
EFTA00007763 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Digital Currency Group aka DCG [crypto] formerly the most import crypto VC fund in the US, rekt in FTXplosion [cnbc] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00603348 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Electric Coin Company created the untraceable crypto ZCash funded by Larry Summers's DCG
(inferred date: 2018-04-18)
The Zerocoin Electric Coin Company
From: Jack Gavigan
Subject: December 2016 Auction of ZEC
Date: 21st December 2016

1. The Zerocoin Electric Coin Company LLC ("ZECC") intends to conduct an auction in order to
sell an amount of ZEC for US Dollars (USD).

2. Interested parties should register their interest by emailing and
supplying the following information:

a. The name, address and state of registration of the company taking part in the auction
(the "Participant"),

b. The name, email address and phone number of the person who will participate in the
auction on behalf of the Participant (the "Trader"),

c. The name, email address and phone number of the person who is authorised to sign
the bill of sale on behalf of the Participant (the "Signatory"),

d. The transparent Zcash payment address ("t-address") to which ZEC should be
transferred in the event that the Participant submits a winning bid.

3. ZECC will draft a simple, non-binding Letter of Intent, indicating:
a. ZECC's intent to conduct an auction,

b. the Participant's intent to participate in the auction,
c. the participating company's intent, in the event that it submits a winning bid, to pay
the appropriate amount of USD (the "Funds"), by wire transfer directly to ZECC's
bank account, by the end of the first business day following the conclusion of the
auction, and

d. ZECC's intent to remit the corresponding amount of ZEC to the Participant's
t-address within 24 hours of confirming receipt of the Funds.
The details listed in paragraph 2 above, ZECC's bank wire transfer details, and a copy of
this memorandum will be attached to the Letter of Intent (see example below).
Both Zooko (acting in his capacity as CEO of ZECC) and the Signatory will digitally sign the
Letter of Intent using the DocuSign service.

4. The Participants' t-addresses will be tested by transferring a small amount of ZEC.
Participants should verify that they can access and move the transferred ZEC, and confirm
that the test was successful by emailing

5. The auction will be conducted on behalf of ZECC by Jack Gavigan ("Jack"). In the event that
Jack believes that the auction cannot be completed in an orderly fashion, he may delay,
suspend, reschedule or cancel it.

6. On the day of the auction, Jack will email the Participants' Traders individually (from the
email address), to inform them of the amount of ZEC to be auctioned,
and the deadline for submitting bids (to be no less than two hours after the email is sent).

7. The Trader should acknowledge receipt of Jack's email by replying to it. If Jack does not
receive an acknowledgement within a reasonable amount of time, he will attempt to contact
the Trader by telephone. If there is no answer or response, the auction will continue.

8. We are aware that some bidders may prefer to purchase the full amount being auctioned, so
we will run a hybrid auction, to allow bidders to bid different prices for purchasing the full
amount versus purchasing a portion of the full amount (in a clearing auction).

9. Participants may submit the following types of bid:
a. a Single Bid for the full amount of the ZEC being auctioned, and

b. one or more Clearing Bids, indicating both the amount of ZEC desired, and the price
the Participant is willing to pay per ZEC in a clearing auction.
Participants may submit either or both types of bid. Participants should submit no more than
20 Clearing Bids.

10. Bids must be submitted by email to in the following format:
Bid type: USD X per ZEC for Q ZEC
where Bid type is one of "Single bid" or "Clearing bid", Xis the bid price in USD, and Q is the
quantity. There must be only one bid to a line. Bid prices must have no greater than six
decimal places.
For example, if the auction amount was 10,000 ZEC, and a Participant wished to submit a
Single Bid of $40 per ZEC, and two Clearing Bids of $42 per ZEC for 4,000 ZEC, and $41
per ZEC for 5,650 ZEC, their submission should read as follows:
Single bid: USD 40 per ZEC for 10000 ZEC
Clearing bid: USD 41 per ZEC for 5650 ZEC
Clearing bid: USD 42 per ZEC for 4000 ZEC
All bids are binding. Bids will remain confidential.

11. Jack will acknowledge receipt of bids by replying to the email submission.
12. Following receipt of all Participants' bids (or at the deadline), Jack will collate the bids and
calculate the results of the auction as follows:

a. As a preliminary step, he will first calculate a Clearing Price based on the submitted
Clearing Bids, as follows:

i. He will serve the highest clearing bid first, allocating to it the number of ZEC
requested, then the second-highest clearing bid and so forth until the supply
of ZEC is exhausted.

V. The Clearing Price will be equal to the lowest winning clearing bid (i.e. the lowest
bid which received an allocation of ZEC).

b. Jack will then compare the Clearing Price to the highest Single Bid.
i. if the highest Single Bid is higher than the Clearing Price, the Participant who
submitted the highest Single Bid will win the auction.

U. If the Clearing Price is higher than the highest Single Bid, the auction will be
won by the Participants who submitted Clearing Bids equal to or above the
Clearing Price. Any Participant who submits a Clearing Bid that is equal to
Clearing Price might not receive the full amount of ZEC they bid for.
iii. If there are two or more highest Single Bids that exceed the Clearing Price,
the winning bid shall be the bid that was received first.

13. Jack will then email the successful Participant(s) to inform them of the result of the auction
(i.e. the auction-winning price, and the amount of ZEC they have been allocated).

14. Jack will then email the unsuccessful Participants to inform them of the result of the auction
(i.e. the winning price, and whether the result was a Clearing Price or the highest Single
Bid).

15. Shortly after the auction, Jack will email to the successful Participant(s) an invoice (in PDF
format) issued by ZECC, setting out the amount of ZEC the Participant is purchasing, the
price per ZEC to be paid, and the amount of Funds the Participant should transfer to ZECC's
bank account.

16. The successful Participant(s) will transfer the necessary Funds to complete the purchase of
ZEC by the end of the business day following the completion of the auction.

17. ZECC will transfer the appropriate amount of ZEC to each winning Participant's t-address
within 24 hours of confirming receipt of all Funds.

18. When the exchange of Funds and ZEC is complete, ZECC will draft a simple Bill of Sale, for
each successful Participant, with the details of the sale (see example below).
Contingencies

19. In the event that a successful Participant fails to transfer the required Funds, ZECC will
either:
a. recalculate the result of the auction with that Participant's bids excluded, or

b. re-run the auction.
20. If the result of the auction is recalculated, all Participants will be notified of the new result. In
the event that:

a. the original auction was won by multiple Participants who submitted Clearing Bids
equal to or above the Clearing Price, and

b. the recalculated auction result is a lower Clearing Price,
any Participants who have already transferred Funds to ZECC will be reimbursed
accordingly.

21. In the event that ZECC is unable to transfer the relevant amount of ZEC to the Participant's
t-address, ZECC will return the Funds within a reasonable amount of time, not exceeding
five business days after the Participant transferred the Funds to ZECC.
Clarifications to the Memo
The following clarifications were sent to the Participants via email in response to questions they
raised regarding the content of the memo above.

1. As indicated by paragraph 12(b)(ii) of the Memo, if the Clearing Price is higher than the
highest Single Bid, the auction will be won by the Participants who submitted Clearing Bids
equal to or above the Clearing Price. For the avoidance of doubt, in this eventuality, all
winning Participants will pay the same price per ZEC (i.e. the Clearing Price). See Examples
4 and 6.

2. To clarify paragraph 12(b)(iii) of the Memo: If there are two or more highest Single Bids (i.e.
if two or more bidders submitted identical Single Bids that are tied for the position of highest
Single Bid) that exceed the Clearing Price, the winning bid shall be the bid that was received
first. See Example 2.

3. If two or more bidders submit Clearing Bids at the Clearing Price, precedence for the
allocation of ZEC shall be granted in the order that the bids were received. See Examples 4,
5 and 6.
4. Clearing bids are accumulative. This means that if a bidder submits multiple Clearing Bids,
they might be allocated ZEC equal to the sum total of the quantities of their Clearing Bids.
See Example 6.
Below are some examples of different auction scenarios and the corresponding outcomes. All
examples are based on an hypothetical auction amount of 10,000 ZEC.
Example].
Participant A's bit frectivedfirst)
Single bid: USD 40 per ZEC for 10900 ZEC
Clearing bad: USD 42 per ZEC for 4000 ZEC
Clearing bid: ISSO al per ZEC for 5650 ZEC
Participant D'sblds frectired second) Participant Cs bids iterated third/
Single bid: USD 42 per ZEC for 14000 ZEC Clearing Old: USD 41 per ZEC for 501)(1 ZEC
Clearing 050 40 per ZEC for 10800 ZEC
Cleadog~ $41
Highest Shape Bid: $42
Result $42 Per EEC limbed Single Bid)
Participant 8 rotapes 10.000 ZEC
me ~err grvik Rd is Note, than the Chor.no Price.
Otadraduatikod:
Participant A: IND 42 perEECfor400(12EG
Participant A: USD 41 per ZEC for 5650 ZEC
Participant C: USD 41 per ZEC for 5088 ZEC
Participant II: USD 40 per ZEC for 10900 ZEC
Clearing
allacalian
.WA
WA
WA
WA
Example 2
Pargdparit A's bit freaked first)
Single bid: USD 42 per ZEC for 10004 ZEC
Clearing bid: IND 42 per ZEC for ago ZEC
Clearing Old: USD 41 per ZEC for 5650 ZEC
Participant We bids frectired second) Participant Cs blds freaked third/
Single Old: USO 41 per EEC for 10908 ZEC Clearing Old: USD 41 per EEC for 5000 ZEC
Clearing bid: USD 90 per ZEC far 10000 ZEC
ClitatingPrirm $41
Highest Single Bid: $42
Rends $42 per ZEC peened Sing» Bid)
ParticipantrtroccconsIDOCOZEC
CbtatlAtMatikrA030A;
Pa rt icipant A: IND 42 per ZEC for 4010 ZEC
Pa rticipant A: USD 41 par ZEC for 5658 ZEC
Participant C: IND 41 per ZEC for 5000 ZEC WA
Participant II: IND 4(1 per EEC for 113800 ZEC WA
Porticipant A's Smite Bid takes precedence owe Pink/pant a's because Pattletpent Rs bids were reraed before ParthrJpont 
Erg
Clearing
~gin
WA
WA
Example 3
ranizant41/2alds (retbred first)
Single bid: USD 90 per ZEC for 10000 ZEC
Clearing Old: IND 42 per ZEC for 4000 ZEC
Clearing Old: IND 41 per ZEC for 5650 ZEC
Participant e's bids (manta:nod) Participant Cs bids freaked third/
Single bid: USD 41 par ZEC for 180418 ZEC Clearing bid: USD 42 per ZEC for 5088 ZEC
Clearing bid: USD 40 per ZEC for 10000 EEC
(StarkePrice:  $41
IffightstIlfl $41
Rut $41 per MC liaghest Single Bid)
Participant B receives 10.000 ZEC
°canna Olds ranked:
Participant A: USD 42 par ZEC for 4088 ZEC
Participant C: USD 42 per ZEC for 5046 ZEC
Participant A: USD 41 per ZEC for 565B ZEC
Participant B: USD 48 par ZEC for 10880 ZEC
The foohest Sigh &V end the among Price are ay& the Highest Stook MI totes precedence over th e Clear/no Pike.
Cleagnit
allocation
WA
WA
WA
WA
Example 4
Participant A's bleistrectiredikst)
Single Old: IND 40 per ZEC for 10000 ZEC
Clearing bid: IND 42 per ZEC for 4000 ZEC
Clearing bid: IND 41 per ZEC for 5858 ZEC
Participant Be' bids tracerred second) Participant Cs blds irereiVed Wm"
Single Old: USD 40 per 2EC for 10000 ZEC Clearing bid: USD 43 per ZEC for Salle ZEC
Clearing bid: USD 40 per ZEC for 10000 EEC
øfficlogliks $41
Highest Single Bid: $40
$41 pa ZEC Kleanng Price/
Pancipant C receives 5,030 ZEC
Pancipant A romves 5.000ZEC
Cleating
naldn8. 11" ,  nails* Magadan
Participant C: USD 43 per ZEC for 5900 ZEC 5000
Participant A: US() 42 per ZEC for 4480 ZEC 4000
Participant A: ND El per ZEC for 5658 ZEC 1000
Participant B: USD 40 per ZEC for 10000 ZEC
me Charing Price H lather dim the >West Single Bid. Both winning Portingorws pay the ~le pike ($41 Per 22 ).
Note that both Pottirlpool A's ~flog Bids «cent ZEC ~Warw.
Example 5
Participant At alt freaked fast)
Single bid: USD 40 per ZEC for 10000 ZEC
Clearing Old: IND 41 per ZEC for 4000 ZEC
Clearing bid: USD 48 per ZEC for 5650 ZEC
Participant We bids irconVed second)
Single bid: USD 41 per ZEC for 10000 /EC
Clearing bid: USD 42 per ZEC for 8889 ZEC
Pardolpant Cs bids (nailed third?
Clearing bid: USD 42 per ZEC for 5900 ZEC
crtannc Peke:  $42
tlithtw5lottlellid; $41
Rena $42 per ZEC 'Clean% Price/
Participant B receives 8.000 Zit
Participant C receives 2000 ZEC
Clearing Bids ranked:
Participant 0: USD 42 par ZEC for 80110 ZEC
Participant C: IND 42 per ZEC for 51300 ZEC
Participant A: USD 41 par ZEC for 40110 ZEC 0
Participant A: USD 40 per ZEC for 5658 ZEC 0
Both sywnng PorboOonts 18 .4 QM the some price ($42 per Ha Participant B's cleodoo &el I soh« pnalev for ouocotwo of ZEC
because Pottle-4,mM B's bids were tacked before Participant Cs
Undo&
allocation
8000
2000
Example 6
Participant AY alt freaked Prig
Single bid: USD 40 per ZEC for 10000 ZEC
Clearing bid: USD Al per ZEC for 4000 IEC
Clearing Old: USD 40 per EEC for 5650 ZEC
Panldpant. bids (rreeired fourthi
Clearing bid: USD 45 per ZEC for 2000 ZEC
Clearing bid: IND 44 per ZEC for 2898 ZEC
Clearing bid: IND 43 per 2EC for 2040 2EC
Participant lEs bids Peaked secood)
Single 010: USO 41 per 2EC for 10004 EEC
Clearing bid: 050 42 per ZEC for 8000 ZEC
Pastelpant bis (received fifth ,/
Clearing bid: USD 43 per ZEC for 1000 Zee
Clearing USD 42 per ZEC for 1080 EEC
Clearing bid: USD 41 per ZEC for 1000 2C
Clearing bid: USD 90 per ZEC for 1080 EEC
Partipal Cs bids (recited third)
Clearing Old: IND 42 per ZEC for 5088 ZEC
Participant Ps Olds pectWedstitn)
Single Old: USD 41 per ZEC for 10001 ZEC
Clearing bid: USD 41 per ZEC for 10888 ZEC
ClfaciDpittlge.: $42
tIlabsst.SIaalsAisL $41
Result: $42 per ZEC 'Cleating Price/
Participant D roteins 6,000 MC
Participant E receives 1.003ZEC
Participant B receives 3.000 ZEC
mhwoniooportwieooNpoydwsomepncef$420aZW.
PortinOzot B's ckonOg bid of USO 42 per ZEC Is ran
pnontylor olfaction ofZEC !mediae Participant z' bids
writ received before Portfripont Cs and PartIcipani
Note that oil of Participant leaeorlAg Bids rem* EEC
&Nations, totoffing &POO ZEC.
Clearing.
allocation
Participant D: USD 45 per EEC for MG ZEC 2000
Participant D: USD 44 per ZEC for 2880 ZEC 2000
Participant D: USD 43 per ZEC for 2000 ZEC 2000
Participant E: USD 43 per ZEC for 1908 ZEC 1000
Participant 8: USD 42 per ZEC for BOBO ZEC 3000
Participant C: USD 42 per ZEC for 501)(1 ZEC 0
Participant E: USD 42 par ZEC for 1080 EEC 0
Participant A: USD 41 per ZEC for 4019 ZEC
Pa rticipant E: USD 41 par ZEC for 1080 EEC 0
Participant F: USD 41 per ZEC for 10090 ZEC
Participant A: USD 40 per ZEC for 5658 ZEC
Participant E: USD 40 per ZEC for 1008 ZEC 0
Letter of Intent (Template)
THIS LETTER OF INTENT (the "Letter") made as of this 25th day of December, 2016 (the
"Execution Date"),
BETWEEN:
Signatory's Name of Participant Company Name of Participant Company's Address, (the
"Participant")
- AND -
Zooko Wilcox of The Zerocoin Electric Coin Company LLC of ZECC's address (the "Seller").
BACKGROUND

A. The Seller is the owner of certain assets that it intends to sell in an auction (the
"Auction").
B. The Participant intends to participate in the Auction.
This Letter will establish the basic terms to be used in the Auction. The terms contained in this
Letter are not comprehensive and it is expected that additional terms may be added, and
existing terms may be changed or deleted. The basic terms are as follows:
Non-Binding

1. This Letter does not create a binding agreement between the Participant and the Seller
and will not be enforceable. Only the future Bill of Sale, duly executed by the Seller and
the Participant, will be enforceable. The terms and conditions of any future Bill of Sale
will supersede all terms and conditions contained in this Letter.
Transaction Description

2. The following is a complete description of the assets (the "Assets") to be sold in the
Auction:
an amount (to be specified at the time of the Auction) of Zcash virtual currency
units ("ZEC")
Representations

3. The Seller represents and warrants that the Assets are free and clear of any liens,
charges, encumbrances or rights of other which will not be satisfied out of the sales
proceeds.
Conduct of the Auction

4. The Seller represents that it intends to conduct the Auction in the manner described in
the attached memorandum ("the Memo").

5. The Participant represents that it intends to participate in the Auction.
6. The Participant represents that if it submits a winning bid it will pay to the Seller the
relevant amount of USD (the "Funds") by wire transfer directly to ZECC's Bank Account
by the end of the first business day following the conclusion of the Auction.

7. The Seller represents that it will transfer to the Participant's t-address, the relevant
amount of ZEC within 24 hours of confirming receipt of the Funds.

8. The following is the name, email address and phone number of the person who will
conduct the Auction on behalf of the Seller ("Jack"):
Name:
Email address:
Phone Number:
Jack Gavigan

9. The following is the name, email address and phone number of the person who will
participate in the auction on behalf of the Participant (the "Trader"):
Name:
Email address:
Phone Number:

10. The following is the name, email address and phone number of the person who is
authorised to sign the Bill of Sale on behalf of the Participant (the "Signatory"):
Name:
Email address:
Phone Number:

11. The following is the bank account ("ZECC's Bank Account") to which the relevant
amount of USD (the "Funds") will be paid by the Participant if it submits a winning bid
ABA Routing Number:
Account Number:
Bank information:
Destination account information:
12. The following is the Participant's transparent Zcash payment address (the "t-address") to
which the relevant amount of ZEC will be transferred by the Seller in the event that the
Participant submits a winning bid.
Participant's t-address:
This letter accurately reflects the understanding between the Seller and the Participant, signed
on this 25th day of December, 2016.
Signatory's Name of Participant Company Name (Participant)
Zooko Wilcox of The Zerocoin Electric Coin Company LLC (Seller)
Invoice (Template)
Bill to: Participant Company Name
Participant Company's Address
Participant Company's Address
Participant Company's Address
Invoice #:
Date:
Due Date:
ZECC-001
25th December 2016
26th December 2016
Item
Zcash Currency Units (ZEC)
From: The Zerocoin Electric Coin Company LLC
ZECC's address
ZECC's address
ZECC's address
Quantity
xxxxx
Price
xx
Amount
xxx,xxx
Balance Due: $xxx,xxx
Payment Terms
Payment due by close of business on 26th December 2016 to the following account:
ABA Routing Number:
Account Number:
Bank information:
Destination account information:
Bill of Sale (Template)
This Bill of Sale is made this 26th day of December, 2016 by The Zerocoin Electric Coin
Company LLC of ZECC's address ("the Seller") and Participant Company Name of Participant
Company's Address ("the Buyer").
For and in consideration of one hundred and twenty three thousand and four hundred and fifty
six Dollars ($123,456), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the Seller does hereby sell
and convey to the Buyer the following property ("the Property"):
XX,000 Zcash virtual currency units (ZEC)
The Property was transferred to the Buyer by Zcash transaction transaction id.
The Seller affirms that the Property is free and clear of any liens, charges, encumbrances or
rights of other which will not be satisfied out of the sales proceeds.
The Property is being sold on an "AS IS" basis and the Seller expressly disclaims all warranties,
whether expressed or implied, including but not limited to, any implied warranty of
merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. The Seller does not assume, or authorize any
other person to assume on the behalf of the Seller, any liability in connection with the sale of the
Property.
The Buyer acknowledges receipt of the Property and of this Bill of Sale.
The Buyer agrees to indemnify the Seller for legal costs and expenses related to any legal
action or dispute that arises out of this Sale. Further, the Buyer shall indemnify Seller for all
Losses arising out of any actions (or omissions to act) of Seller or any of its Affiliates taken at
the direction of the Buyer or any of its Affiliates.
Zooko Wilcox of The Zerocoin Electric Coin Company LLC (Seller) Date
Signatory's Name of Participant Company Name (Buyer) Date
EFTA01616222 (Jmail)
 [academia] iMessage from Harry Fisch screenshot(s)
(timestamp: 2018-04-23 14:25:30)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
•
Harry Fish
How many
02:25:30 pm
Harry Fish
Harry Fish
2018/04/11
I'm back can you call in Stendra 100 at zitimer
02:18:48 pm
You have refills available. Call them back.
04:55:18 pm
10
02:25:52 pm
They didn't have your call yet?
04:48:54 pm
Thx
05101:41 pm
They want you to call
08:04:14 pm
•
•
•
Ha—y Fun
I just did. You can pick them up now
08:11:18 pm
After you use them, wash your hands and lets go get pizza and grape soda.
08:11:50 pm
Call me
HF 08:40:43 pm
2018/04/"./
Harry Pun

• Just watched "The Zen Diaries of Garry Shandling". HBO documentary. You should
watch it,'"
03:21:40 am
Harry Fish
You should have joined us.
2018/04/18
05:14:17 pin
Cannot believe Bruno died. It's a very sad day.
05:14:40 pin
•
•
When Gorilla Monsoon died I got depressed. Well, more than usual.
05:15:22 pin
2018/04/21
Terje fainted . Fractured patrols and some stitches in head
02:50:55 am
Harry Fish
Nicola's Restauraunt 146 east 84th st
01:31:23 pm
02:18:29 pm
Awake?
11:58:44 am iea)
2018/04/23
Harry Fish

Ok. Got the answer to your spinal stenosis.
01:50:17 pin
Celebrex daily.
01:50:35 pin
Just spoke with a Pfizer expert.
01:50:50 pin
Did you get the chicken pharm?
04:59:00 pin
They only had veal
07:14:09 pm
Harry Fish
Did u have it?
07:18:19 pm
No I'm a chicken
07:18:38 pm
✓ Sent
Harry Fish
Understood
07:19:09 pm
✓ Read
EFTA01616232 (Jmail)
 [academia] iMessage from Harry Fisch screenshot(s)
(timestamp: 2018-04-23 14:25:30)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• goHarry Fish
2018/06/02
Hey can you bring Howard stern to dinner
10:19:36 am
Harry Fish
I don't know him well enough.
12:39:49 pm
2018/06/04
Harry Fish
Lunch today?
02:08:21 pm
Harry Fish
Calif cryobank
03:39:17 pm
Repros lab
03:39:38 pm
Ok
12:43:23 pm
Can't
03:32:45 pm
•
•
•
Repro lab
03:39:51 pm
I am disappointed
06:07:29 pm
You are off my show
06:07:40 pm
2018/06/05
do you want a woody dinner tonite
10:53:42 am
Harry Fish
Cannot. Investor conference and meetings today.
11:15:01 am
I am with Mitch all day. Can he come to dinner?
05:12:13 pin
He is very interesting.
05:12:34 pm
He was a prostate cancer surgeon
05:12:47 pin
2018/06/06
Harry Fish
Epstein, the best!
02:54:59 am
Thanks for a great dinner
02:55:07 am
The fish heads was what I needed
02:55:22 am
Chicken pharm would have been good too
02:55:41 am
You are back on my show.
02:56:03 am
Oh, one more thing. CHUNKYs!!!!
02:56:37 am
2018/06/14
Harry Fish
Cherry pop tart from Greenberg
04:15:55 pm
2018/06/17
Sultan wants to replace bionic dick with new swiss version. Wants different surgeon
03:01:04 pmHarry Fish
You're joking I hope.
03:37:40 pm
Nope
03:45:00 pm
goyim
03:45:04 pm
Harry Fish
Pizza and grape soda tomorrow for lunch? We can also buy tefillin for Woody.
03:56:02 pm
Harry Fish
Ok
03:57:03 pm
You're back on the show
03:57:14 pm
Bernstein
03:57:20 pm
Ask barry
03:56:18 pm
Time?
09:48:32 pm
•
•
•
Harry Fish
•
•
•
1:00
10:44:12 pm
Harry Fish
10:53:25 pm
2018/06/18
Harry Fish
They sell tefillin on Lex and 84th street
08:05:38 pm
Just ate 2 devil dogs. 360 of the best calories I could eat.
08:42:2/ pm
Thx
08:42:29 pm
Harry Fish
Lets get the tefillin
07:22:44 pm
2018/06/19
Ok
10:44:54 pm
Here
04:45:52 pm
✓ Unsent
✓ Read
EFTA00810509 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2018-04-29)
STASH
Velar Fund 3 /
Put your money where it matters
Stash Updates
✓ Continued rapid user growth, reaching 2.5M users
and I .5M funded accounts in September. CAC
remains stable at < $20 per new user.
1 Revenue has grown 5x YoY, exceeding forecasts
with $3.8M in Q3. Revenue expected to hit $100M
annualized by the end of next year.
1 Gross margins (negative last year) are now positive
and nearing 50%.
1 Accelerated pace of new product launches.
Retirement and custodial accounts, as well as
insurance referrals, all growing exponentially. Stash
debit card, cash back and gifting launching in Q4.
1 Over $2.5M has been pre-funded for the Stash Debit
product, with 50k sign ups during a 3 week period.
1 Series D financing expected in Q4 2018.
✓ Valar is the second largest investor in Stash, with a
19% ownership stake in the company.

0. neat n • rem Of egsO eV WOW cat" cuian b
tan *noose maw new. WS al
el p goollisa
feaP.MgetgillEtt
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$29.6M
$65.6M
2.2x
$347.5M
USV. Coatue. Goodwater. Jim Breyer
VALAR /
╔════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Lockheed Martin [business] American military contractor 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00811705 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2018-04-30)
Valuation Report
4/30/2018
SUMMARY OF ASSETS -APRIL 30, 2018
3/31/18 4/30/18 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 108,529,600 93,225,893 (15,303,707)
Fixed Income 73,511,947 80,123,947 6,612,000
Equities 120,961,675 126,464,427 5,502,752
Equity ETF's 980,850 982,800 1,950
Options -485,652 -116,621 369,031
Hedge Funds 83,368,270 84,468,702 1,100,432
Investments 51,598,855 51,568,855 (30,000)
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 22,875,000 22,875,000 -
Loans Receivable 14,684,408 14,784,408 100,000
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 9,900,000 9,900,000 -
Loan Payable - BJAV (30,500,000) (30,500,000) -
Total Assets 455,424,953 453,777,410 -1,647,543
Cash Activity - Items over 45.000
DB - Sold 6500 FB @ 160.882 1,045,443
Butterfly Trust - sale of Celmins 732,995
King Street Distributions (2) 37,263 & 374,259 411,522
DB - Sold Barclays 7.75% - redeemed early by bank 300,000
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 235,000
DB - Enhanced Sold 1,000 DIS @ 100.47 100,472
LSJE - NGS Power - 2 generators (46,325)
LSJE - Ford 450 Truck (67,165)
JEGE - GIV - 24 month inspection (70,218)
ML - Bought SPX Index Call with 2950 KO - Strike 2800 exp 9/21/2018 (95,999)
Plan D - G550 International Jet (eric roth) - interior work (100,000)
SFL Loan - Bella Klein (100,000)
Legal Fees - Steptoe & Johnson (100,000)
ABC Nursery Plants (123,304)
301 East 66th Street - 2017 annual charges (202,840)
Miscellaneous (206,053)
Legal Fees - Link Feb 2018 (226,688)
Legal Fees - Link March 2018 (250,000)
MS - Gratitude Bought 1200 Equinox Inc @ 410.65 (492,775)
MS - Gratitude Bought 5200 Microsoft @ 95.58 (497,008)
DB - Bought 10,000 QCOM @ 60 (600,412)
IB - Bought 4000 Broadcom @ 250.52 (1,002,093)
DB - Bought 1000 GOOG @ 1005 (1,004,634)
IB - Bought 10,000 NXP Semi @ 102.9 (1,028,951)
Monthly Spending (1,110,000)
DB - Bought 31,348 CD Projeckt @ 35.53 (1,113,904)
DB - Bought 2,000,000 Republic of Argentina @ 0.63 (1,259,388)
DB - Bought 1000 AMZN @ 1,395 (1,395,441)
DB - Bought 2,000,000 Assurant Inc Fixed to Float 7% exp 3/27/2048 (2,042,339)
ML - Bought 5,000,000 Treasury bill (4.993,603)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 45,000 (15,303,707)
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan Interactive TO
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Merrill Stanley Broken *mu* 4e Totals
Cash
Haze Trust 52,954,353 52,954,353
The 2017 Colsonlir Trust 13,471,910 13,471.910
Southern Trust Company Inc. 5,119,381 430,348 299.452 621,746 2.701.329 9,172.256
JEE 4,659,712 128,113 7,027 4,794,852
Southern Financial LLC 3,479,656 1,258,115 4,737,771
Gratitude America, Ltd. 474,093 221,406 1.616.722 2,214221
Jeepers Inc. 1,529,822 7,309 1,537.131
LSJE LLC 242.993 753,125 240,178 1.226.296
Butterfly Trust 733,265 733,265
Plan 0 LLC 485,885 485.885
363.758 Southern Country International LTD 363,758
JEGE LLC 346,590 346.590
Zona Management LLC 276 481 276,481
NES LLC 1991.947 199.947
Enhanced Education 8,830 121,014 129.844
Thomas World Air LLC 111,516 111,516
Neptune LLC 88,881 88,881
JEE - Paris (US 3) 72,214 72214
Nautilus Inc. 54,887 54,887
Hyperion Mr LLC 51,300 51,300
FT Real Estate 42,785 42,785
Laurel Inc. 37,129 37.129
Cypress Inc. 29,686 29.686
Freedom Air Petroleum 22,812 22,812
Michelins Transportation Co LLC 22,736 22,736
Maple Inc. 18,256 18,256
JEGE Inc. 9,078 9.078
Great St Jim LLC 8 817 8,817
LSJ LLC t?.1-50 5,150
Mort Inc 4,853 4,853
FSF LLC 637 837
IGO Company LLC 390 390
The JEE life ins Trust 83 206 206
Total Cash 84,127,236 2,379,874 378,693 240,178 621,746 1,518,722 2,701,329 1,258,115 93,225,893
Purchase Quantity 3131/18 4130118 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB)
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 49 033 1 180 739 1 246 419 1 237,103 56 364
'Wank Preferred Ser 5.8 10129/14 150,987 3.870.430 3,837,581 3,908. 97
Citibank Preferred Sec K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000 1,999,419 2,214,370 2,173290 173871
-316458 JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/302049 05110/11 3,000,000 3,337,958 3,114,050 3,0a500
JP Morgan Floating Rate Income fund 01/22/13 248,355 2.482.548 2.326.698 2.337,cgo
12,578,81.0
-145.54
-92,285 Total Haze Trust - Fixed income (DB) 12,671,095 12,739,118
Jeepers - Fixed income (DB)
JPM Floating Rate Income fund 02/13/13 186,044 1 85B 728 1.742.946 1 750 678 -106 050
Total Jeepers - Fixed Income (DB) 1,856,728 1,742,945 1,750,678 -106,050
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Citizens Communications 7.125% Matures 3/15/2019 10/02/17 1,000,000 997,322 1,001,917 1,003,906 6.584
Plains All America 6.125% 10/10/17 500,000 501.3111 494.069 NOM -1.095
Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 1,498,703 1,495,986 1,504,192 6,489
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB)
Buckeye Partners Fixed to Float 6.375% Caiabee 1/22123 1/25/18 1,000,000 1,018,753 1,001,969 992,774 -25,979
Royal eank Scothend 7.64% Fixed to 9-29.2017 then 3M Libor *23299 11/10/15 5,000,000 5.2.93,194 5.037.500 5,054.222 
-244.142,
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB) 6,317,157 6,039,469 6,046,996 -270,161
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill)
Bank of America 5.88% Pfd Dec 2051 03/08/18 1,000,000 1,000,000 1,006,310 1,00t670 7,670
Kindred Healthcare 8% 1/1512020 10/13/16 3,000,000 3,041.990 3,226,917 3,284,417 242,427
LSCCOM 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 2,850,000 2,773,650 2,833,273 2,733,181 -40,469
US Treasury Bill Due 5/3/2018 04/04/18 5,000,000 4,993,603 4,999,550 5.947
Plains All America Pipekne 10/04/17 1,000 1.000 000 969.499 977.992 :2290
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill) 12,809,243 8,035,998 13,002,810 193,567
Southern Trust Ca - Fixed Income (Interactive Brokers)
Capkal One 5.55% Fixed to 9.1.2020 then 380 over 3 mo libor 5/14/15 3,000,000 3,009,819 3,105,000 3,142,500 132,682
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred 325 par 7/27/15 40,000 1,000.000 1,041,600 1,039,600 39,600
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 3,000,000 3.123.122 3,127,500 3,135.750 12,628
Goldman Sachs 5.375% Fixed to 5-10-2020 then 392.2 over 3 mo itor 6/4/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 5,154,050 5,243,750 209,404
NGL Energy Partners 9% 525 par 6/6/17 40,000 1.000.000 930.208 953.200 -46,800
Se an 7.875% Preferred $25 par 08/04/16 4,995 124875 115.634 117.033 7-842
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Interactive Brokers) 13,292,162 13,473,992 13,631,833 339,671
Southern Financial LW - Fixed Income (DB)
Bank of America 8.125% PM Dec 29 2049 1/10/11 2,000,000 2,079,598 2,069,389 2,078,479 -1,117
Assurant Fixed to Float 7% March 2048 3/29/18 2,000,000 2.039,973 - 2,096,713 56,740
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 4/3/13 300,000 - 311,104 -
CM- ou - Inc - Series 0 5.95% 8/6/15 3 000,003 3.001),006 3,131,588 3,138,438 138,432
itizens•ommunications 7.125 Mar 15 2019 10/3/17 1.000.737 1,001,917 1,003,906 3.169 1,000,000
Exelainter LLC 0% J 15 2023 10/24/17 2,000,000 1,940,506 2,064,722 2,080,833 120,327
12/3/15 2469,000 2.175.016 2,275.869 2259,135 84,119
GMAC Cap TR I GTD PM Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80,000 1.882,774 2,078,000 2,127,200 244,428
JBS Investments 7.25% April 3 2024 10/31/17 2,000,000 1,981,300 2,058,292 1,982,775 1,475
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500,000 2.887,500 2,595,042 2,518,750 -168.750
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500,000 2,675,000 2,595,042 2,518,750 -156,250
JPM Floating Rate Income fund 9/28/17 326,566 3.072.943 3,059,416 3,072,989 48
LBG Capital 7.5% 1229/49 5/21/13 1,903,000 1,948,500 2,063,962 2,066,420 117,920
Service Master 7.25% Mar 1 2038 10/20/17 1,000,000 1.039.620 1.010,792 1,009,382 -30,238
Southern Cat Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,000,000 2.996137 3210.250 3,226.354 230.217
Total Southern Financial LW - Fixed Income (DB) 30,519,608 29,533,884 31,160,124 640,516
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) OtaxMa_ Washin on Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 ci CBI var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 483,267 
366,648 450.555 448.504 81.856
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 366,648 450,555 448,504 81,866
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 79,331,343 73,511,947 80,123,947 792,604
Purchase Quantity 3/31/18 4/30/18 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
Advanced Micro Devices 12/15/17 50,000 612,925 502,500 544,000 -68,925
Amazon 4/2/18 1,000 1.395,441 1,568,130 170,689
Alibaba Group 6/10/15 5,000 444,749 917,700 1,017,330 572,581
Alphabet Inc 4/2/18 1,000 1,004.634 1.017,330 12,696
Apple Inc 1217/17 314,000 53,321,627 52,682,920 51,891,640 -1,429.987
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 263.157 4.999.983 7.794.710 7.589,448 2.589.465
BASF ADR 4/13/15 5,000 508,056 507,800 521,000 12,944
Berkshire Hathaway 2/5/18 6 1,852.362 1,794,600 1,743,900 -108,482
Berkshire Hathaway 3127/18 9 2,707,938 2,691,900 2,615.850 -92,088
Biogen Idec Inc 2/14/12 2,095 250,455 573,653 573,192 322737
701,922 Centene Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1,661,829 1,688.419
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 6,500 1,038,635 0
General Electric (exercise of puts sold at 18) 2/24/18 25,000 405,493 337,000 351,750 -53,743
Gilead Sciences Inc 10/24/17 12,500 995,600 942,375 902,875 -92,725
Nintendo 2/5/18 10,000 517,906 555,100 524,800 6,894
-71,718 Qualoomm Inc 4118/18 10,000 581,718 510.000
Ubisoft Entertainment 3/29/18 11,200 974,199 943,701 1,072445 98,246
CO Projekt - Poland 3/29/18 41,348 1,445.508 319,462 1,413.oes 27,578
Republic of Argentina 4/13/18 1,000,000 1,259,388 - 1,177,293 -82,095
IISBC Holdings PLC 12/4/17 24,800 246,105 233,839 248,693 2,588
Lonking Holdings Ltd 12/4/17 710,000 253.693 302,161 325.686 71,993
Nine Dragons Paper Ho 12/4/17 144,000 248.025 215,409 217,246 -30,779
ZTE Corp 12/4/17 70,600 249.835 229,842 230.294 -19,541
Anhui Conch Cement 12/4/17 52,500 249,073 285,976 330,464 81,391
Bank of China Ltd 12/4/17 512,000 248.987 275,307 280,528 31,561
China Communications 1214117 224,000 248,728 230,047 259,733 11,005
tonglang Electric Corp 12/4/17 150,200 127.069 116,935 117.893 -9,176
Weichai Power Co 12/4/17 228,000 246,611 255,653 266,114 19,503
Zhuzhou CRRC Times 1214/17 43,400 253,976 210,139 231,432 -22,544
Nabtesco Cal) 12/4/17 6,300 247,324 241,424 227,712 -19,612
Naspers Ltd 12/4/17 2,000 515.466 ....gi2§2 490.281 -25.185
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 77,399,351 76,348,886 80,008,584 2,807,213
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (TO)
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/18/14 25,000 857,115 1,968,750 1,908,750 1,051,635
General Electric 10/20/17 75,000 1127,899 1011,000 1,055,250 -72649
-259,008 General Electric 1/11/18 50,000 '962,506 674,000 703,500
ALPS ETF Aktrien MLP 1/12/18 40,000 500,956 402,910 434,300 -66,656
Utility Sector Spider XLU 1/12/18 (9,900) (499,546) (500,247) (510,444) -10,898
Sangamo Therapeutics Inc 5/28/13 40,000 337 771 760.400 QUM ULM
936,655 Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (1V) 3,286,701 4,316,413 4,223,356
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Interactive Brokers)
Advanced Micro Devices (exercise of puts sold at 12) 3116(18 40,000 462716 402,000 435,200 -27,516
ALPS ETF Aledan MLP 1/8/18 100,000 1,14710 1,102,520 1,010,000 -132,710
ALPS ETF Alerian MLP 3/9/18 50,000 511,069 551,260 505,000 -6,069
Broadcom 4/17/18 4,000 1,002,093 917,680 -84,413
JD Corn Inc 3/6/18 10.000 431,100 404,900 365,100 -66,000
Goldman Sachs 1/25/18 1,850 499,873 465,941 440,911 -58,962
General Dynamics 2/7/18 2,300 501,381 508,070 463,013 38,388
General Dynamics 3/27/08 3,450 773,056 76%105 694520 -78,536
Lockheed artin 2/7/18 1,400 489,300 473,102 44176 40.124
Lockheed Martin 3/20/18 2,100 707,676 70%653 673,764 -33,912
Northtrop Grumman 2/7/18 1,470 493,920 513,206 473,399 -20,521
Northtrop Gunmen 3/28/18 2,195 760,159 766,318 706,878 -53,281
NXP Semiconductor 4/24/18 10,000 1,028,951 1,049,000 20,049
Raytheon 2/7/18 2,400 498,840 517,968 491,856 -6,984
Raytheon 3/20/18 3,600 763,284 776,952 737,784 -25,500
KBW Regional Bank ETF (KRE) 3/26/18 20,000 1.210.847 1,182,755 1,232,800 21,953
XLF Financial Sector 11/16/17 10,000 262,800 275,700 274,500 11,700
XLF Financial Sector 3/26/18 22,000 603,789 806,540 803,900 111
Credit Suisse Group 7/18/16 100,000 t137.626 1.679.000 1.677,000 539.374
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Interactive Brokers) 13,281,190 11,697,990 13,201,481 -79,709
Purchase Quantity 3131118 4/30/18 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Lon)
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Mendlo
Allergen (mandatory convert from preferred) 311/18 7,01E 1,515.900 1,189,137 1,085,691 -430.209
Cummins Inc 1/19/18 4000 755600 648,360 639,440 -116,160
ING 4/4/17 26000 373,500 423,250 419,750 46,250
JD Corn Inc 8/23/17 10,000 419.639 404,900 385,100 -54,539
JD Corn Inc 10/3/17 20,000 759.982 809,800 730,200 -29 782
KBW Regional Bank ETF (KRE) 11/16/17 9,000 503,167 643,610 554.760 51,593
ON Semiconductor 6/8/17 12,000 200,038 293,520 264,960 64.922
Qualcom Inc 10(11/17 10,000 542,890 654,100 510,100 -32,790
Tencent Holdings 112/17 20,000 986,260 1,043,800 982,600 -3,680
Tenant Holdings 3/22/17 20.000 1.046.140 1.043,800 962.600 -63,540
Teradyne Inc 7/20/17 20900 704,832 914,200 651,000 -53932
233)12 XLF Financial Sector 8/2/17 100,000 2,511,288 2.757,000 2,745.000
Euro Sion so mon due 3/77/2019 Stang SO 3538 (Ckmiiitle elf Ofh014 73.515 9/25/17 ref price 3555 2,500,000 2,372,989 
2,496,541 -3,459
Japan Banks Capped Note Exp Feb 1 2019 (75% barrier) 1/2918 3.000.000 2,617,110 2,738,867 -261,133
vortex Linked Nous (slang S&P put spreads and buying utx coos) 3/8/18 3.000.000 2,955,340 2,988,673 -11,327
5X7E Market Plus Note Exp 4/26/2019 (72% barrier) 10/24/17 3.000.000 2.772.981 2,ffilega -130166
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill) 21,819,255 21,343,797 21,025,116 -794,139
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Mon”
Anheuser Busch 1129/18 3,500 393,352 384,790 350,280 -43,072
Sequential Brands 9/23/16 50,000 402,134 104,250 96,500 405934
Starbucks 1/30/18 5,930 344.464 343,288 341,390 4) 74
Microsoft 4/17/18 5,200 497,008 486,304 -10,704
12,173 Equinox Inc 4/17/18 1,200 492.775 - 504,948
Bank of America 3/2/16 7,500 100,825 224,925 224,400 123,575
-181,528 General Electric 10/23/17 22,000 491,068 296,560 309,540
Tencent Holdings 7/18/16 12 500 298.878 666.186 614.125 315.247
Total Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 3,020,505 2,019,938 2,927,487 -93,018
Haze Trust- Equities (DB)
15.8a AIA Group Hong Kong 1/23/18 59,000 508,816 500,320 524,510
China Life Insurance Co 1/23/18 151,000 507,285 415,590 432,909 74,376
China PAC Insurance Group 1/23/18 95,400 506,380 427,275 424,848 -81,532
Google 2/2/18 2,000 2,222,173 2,063.580 2,034,660 -187,513
Google 12/5/17 1,000 1,014,015 1,031,790 1,017,330 3,315
PING An Insurance 1/23/18 40,500 511 931 411,805 400,198 -111.73
Haze Trust- Total Equities (DB) 5,270,599 4,850,360 4,834,455 -436,144
J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB)
Bristol Myers Squib 10/30/15 3,400 227,604 215,050 177,242 -50 382
Disney 10/30/15 685 BUDD 169 241 68. a -9.374
Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 305,704 384,291 245,968 -59,736
TOTAL EQUITIES 124,383,304 120,961,675 126,464,427 2,081,122
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF's (DB)
'shares South Korea ETF 11/3/17 13,000 985.997 91/9,1,6V 982.800 .,M .
Total Southern Financial LW - Equity ETF'S !DB) 985,997 980,850 982,800 4,197
Southern Financial LLC - Options (DB)
Forward Long ARS 59.820.000 vs USD Short 3,000,000 Exp 6/2312018 11/9/17 19.94 - -150,299 - -
Forward Long ARS 56.361.500 vs USD Short 3.000.000 Exp onsnous 12/15/17 19.46 - -222,019 -
Shod QCOM 60 Aprl 20 2018 Puts 3/7/18 (100) - (52,000) -
long S&P 500 277.50 April 20 2018 Cat 3119/18 (200) - 7,800 -
Short S&P 500 255 April 20 2018 Puts 3/19/18 (200) - (42,000) - -
Shod GILD 82.5 Aprii 20 2018 Calls 3/16/18 (125) - (3,125) - •
Short GILD 77.5 Apnl 20 2018 Pula 3/16/18 (125) - (37,500) - -
Shod GILD 77.5 May 18 2018 Puts 4/20/18 (125) (62.118) - (68,750) -6,632
Long EEM 55 Calls @ 0.44 Exp 6/15/2018 1/17/18 2,400 105.606 26 400 2 4(10 -103.206
Total Southern Financial LLC - Options (DB) 43,488 -472,743 46,350 408,838
Southern Financial LLC - Options (TD)
Long 1,000 SPY 300 Calls • exp 6/15/2018 1/30/18 1,000 180.570 13.099 2,1394 -178.0Zei
Total Southern Financial LLC - Options (TD) 180,576 13,000 2,600 -178,076
Purchase Quantity 3/31118 4130118 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss),
Southern Trust Co. - Options (ML)
SPX Index Cal with 2950 KO - Snits 2800 exp 9/21/2018 4110/18 7524 95.999 Q 99.186 3187
Total Southern Trust Co. - Options (ML) 95,999 0 99,186 3,187
Southern Trust Co. - Options PM
Long XLV 88 Calls @ 1.75 exp 8/15/2018 2/Stig 210 20,993 4,489 937 -20.056
Shod XLV 80 Puts O 2.24 exp 6/15/2018 2/5/18 -26
4
884 -25.956 -10,949 15,937
Sh Shat JD 38 Puts 0.75 exp 5g /18/2018 4/20118
Re
=7,8-7 6 -21,710 -14.223
Short JD 40 Calls @ 3.32 exp 5/18/2018 4/20/18 (100) -33,233 0 -37,340 -4.107
Long AVGO 40 Puts @ 6.86 Exp 5/18/18 4/17/18 100 -27,450 0 42,929 -55,479
Short JD 40 Puts a 0.85 exp 4/20/2018 3/6/18 (40) -11,034 0 0
Short JD 46 Calls @ 0.99 exp 420/2018 3/6/18 (48) -921 0 0
Long 675 SPY 295 Cells • exp 5/18/2018 1/23/18 675 128.313 7.533 all -126.279
Total Southern Trust Co. - Options (IS) 52,250 (25,909) (151,957) (204,207)
TOTAL OPTIONS 372,313 (485,652) (116,621) (488,934)
3/31/18 4/30/18 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern Financial ISFLIC)
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 45,538,044 45,994,860 0.93% 5.43% withdrew 10mm 1710/17
Boothbay Enhanced Fund 7.557.965 7.672.630 1.37% 2.15% withd,,,wiemm lawn
Total Hedge Funds - SF LW 53,096,009 53,667,490 ra le ra ren - > 25mm
2016 retum 3.77%
2017 return 16.6%
Hedge Funds -Haze 2018 return of caora 2017 return cit capital 2016417 redeMCOMIS pe
King Street - Illiquid Special Investments 3 612 150 3.272.578 2/13/2018 67,388 4/16 230,7103 4/27/16 5.167,954 paid
Hedge Funds - Haze 3,612,150 3,272,578 311412011 12.077 6711 113.614 7727116 6,102)24 pald
4/3/2018 37,263 9/13 2,730 10/27/16 6.186,911 pekl
411182018 374,239 10712 18,370 1171117 3.994,344 PSI
11/1 4,050 2018 tram 448%
Scott Shelton - WO /Secondary Trading
Gratitude America 1 869 591 1.895.236 1.37% -5.24% semi 2ran Witte
Total Scott Shelton - IPO 1 Secondary Trodh 1,869,591 1,895,236 "0120111art
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 24.790.520 25.633.398 3.40% 5.50% added 20ra 8/31116
Total Hedge Funds - STC 24,790,520 25,633,398 12016 ret OM% (6 mo.)
Total Hedge Funds 83,368,270 84,468,702 2017 return 21.0%
SFL
Mort Southern Grat FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara II (investment amount) 250,000
Kyara IV (investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount less 30k distribution 4/20/18) 970,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (grat) 1,000,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,000 STC
Seaford Avenue Capital - PB Investment - Auto Debt (total comm 2.6mm) 743,355
Adfin Solutions (Investment amount 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston, NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase via Grat (50% sold for $15mm Feb 2018) sic 1,500,500
Spotify via Honeycomb 1 1,000,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Valar Global Fund II (amount funded vs 15mm committment) 14,250,000 cumulative IRR thru 1241-2016 23.20%
cumuletive IRR thru 1241.2017 12.32%
Vaiar Global Fund III (amount funded vs 25mm committment) 19,250,000 curate** IRR thru 12414016 67.3015
cumulative IRR thru 12.31.2017 52.02%
Totals 1,000,000 3,000,000 39,588,355 1,600,600 6,480,000
Total Investments 51,568,855
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 3,000,000 3,000,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 Plan D LIS 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 875,000 875,000
Boats 500,000 500,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 2,500,000 3,000,000 250,000 17,125,000 22,875,000 ,
Asset Description JEE SFL JEGE Inc. FTRE Totals
Loans Receivable
(boob:non 10% yel *saki 150I0 150,000 150,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Nick Ribis 150,000 150.000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
Osboume Lane Capital (Paul B) 1,000,000 1,000,000
David Mitchell 243,700 1,500,000 1.743,700
303,262 303,262
Harlequin Dane, LLC 5,750,000 5,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 2,000,000 2,000,000
Bella Klein 100,000 100,000
Lesley 300,000 300,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
Darren Indyke 475,000 475,000
Richard Kahn 475,000 475,000
LV Home & Other 1,457,000 1,457,000
625.000 625,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,748,146 8,150,000 950,000 2,936,262 14,784,408
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - insurance value 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050.000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 3,050,000 9,900,000
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LW) (30,600,000) (30,500,000)
EFTA00511309 (Jmail)
 [tech] Karyna Shuliak personal address book
(inferred timestamp: 2018-05-01 10:49:03)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYCO24329.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024329.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Notes
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case Data: Contacts (11001-11100 of 19830)
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/8/Messages/86460.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3 EB-C 561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C 1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/1/1/Messages/114258.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/8/Messages/84697.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/8/Messages/84791.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email sal
(Email)
ID 1403957
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/8/Messages/85106.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email Annie (Email)
ID 1446262
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/8/Messages/84365.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
(Email)
ID 1404219
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/8/Messages/84115.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
Ma>
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/8/Messages/83165.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
(Email)
ID 1411376
Source
Device
Path
Merwin Dela
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/lcatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/8/Messages/83236.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
(Email)
ID 1411219
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/lcatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/8/Messages/83080.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
=Min Sonam
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/2/1/Messages/121983.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
(Email)
ID 1374624
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/2/1/Messages/123751.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
(Email)
ID 1416790
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/6/2/1/Messages/126949.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
=Min
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/3/1/Messages/130171.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
=Ma> Renato
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Phone
Number)
Email (Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Containers/comspple.corerecentssecentscl/Data/Library/R
ecents/Recents
Recents
Lesley Groff
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3 EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/1/3/1/Messages/131811.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
MIMIII > Renato
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/3/1/Messages/132103.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
a> Carlos (Email)
ID 1442376
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
Path /Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/3/1/Messages/135299.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
a >(Email)
ID 1448165
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
Path /Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/3/1/Messages/135604.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
a> LSJ (Email)
ID 1448240
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
Path /Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Datal/3/1/Messages/137437.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
Mike (Email)
ID 1342375
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/0/4/1/Messages/140103.emlx
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
MIMIn Dave
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/3/4/1/Messages/143843.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
a> Larry Visoski (Email)
ID 1412406
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/4/1/Messages/144896.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email Daphne (Email)
ID 1405097
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/Mail/V6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/2/1/Messages/120014.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
Jennaine
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/Mail/V6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/1/2/1/Messages/121028.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Groff
MIMIa> Bella
ID 1482618
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/1/1/Messages/114793.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
(Email)
ID 1501667
Source
Device
Path
=Min Stephanie MIMIMMIEle
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/42381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/1/1/Messages/116393.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
Ma Bella (Email)
ID 1479848
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/8/Messages/81554.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1481252
Source
Device
Path
Lesley Groff
=Mlle
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/42381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/81 1Messages/78807.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email
=Min (Email)
ID 1483823
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/42381948-4823-4372-8F I 3-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/3/1/Messages/133743.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lesley Groff
Email  MINIa> (Email)
ID 1502960
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First lesley taylor
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948 -4823-4372-8F I 3-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/0/1/Messages/101712.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1371130
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-056 I -4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/9/Messages/98968.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1375237
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/9/Messages/92397.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Email
(Email)
ID 1435881
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MaiUV6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/0/1/Messages/107215.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/3/9/Messages/93559.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1408178
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /11sersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
(Users, (Deleted)/LibrarylMailN2/Mac-_'Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/2/7/Messages/72150.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/3/1/Messages/137129.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Leslie Groff
Email
(Email)
ID 1342034
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/8/Messages/89599.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Leslie Henderson
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/3/4/1/Messages/143839.emlx
Mac Mail
Leslie L Flores-Wilson
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/3/4/1/Messages/143772.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Maceeleted Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-0
98A-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/4/6/1/Messages/164140.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Letha York
Email
(Email)
ID 1043890
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/3/1/Messages/139181.emlx
Mac Mail
leticia urgilez
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Leticia Urgilez
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/2/8/Messages/82884.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Macaunk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-97
7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/1/6/1/Messages/161140.emlx
Mac Mail
Letitia Edwards
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Usersficaryna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/B7D700EF-A587-412
1-AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Letty
Last Moss-Salentijn
Phone Number
(WorkFAX)
Phone Number
(Work)
Address (Home)
Columbia University College of Dental Medicine
622 W. 168th Street,
PH 7E-122
New York
NY
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2018-02-22 23:50:50 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-02-22 23:50:50 (UTC)
ID 272
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/BD0AllAA-097E-4F
AC-AA25-FC01E963AC0C/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lefty
Last Moss-Salentijn
Phone Number
(WorkFAX)
Phone Number
(Work)
Address (Home)
Columbia University College of Dental Medicine
622 W. 168th Street,
PH 7E-122
New York
NY
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2016-03-24 16:28:45 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-03-24 16:28:45 (UTC)
ID 383
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Letty Moss-Salentijn
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C I A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/3/1/1/Messages/113927.emlx
Mac Mail
Levi's
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/BD0AI1AA-097E-4FA
C-AA25-FC01E963AC0C/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Lewis
Chen
2016-03-24 16:28:45 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-03-24 16:28:45 (UTC)
ID 184
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-
AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Lewis
Chen
2018-02-22 23:50:49 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-02-22 23:50:50 (UTC)
ID 57
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac Junk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-97
7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/5/1/Messages/159067.emlx
Mac Mail
Email
(Email)
ID 1019831
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/1/1/Messages/110863.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First E. Robert Wardius
Email
(Email)
ID 1335392
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lhasa OMS
Email (Email) Lhasa OMS
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First LHS
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First LHS1
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5402
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First LHS1
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5402
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First LHS1
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:54 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 1360
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First LHS1
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5402
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First LHS1
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:54 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 1360
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First LHS1
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:54 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 1360
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usersficaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/5/9/Messages/95094.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Li
Email Li (Email)
ID 1443311
Contact
Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /U/Users,(Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/Mailboxes/Junk (iCloud).mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810
-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/9/3/1/Messages/139210.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lianna Mirjah
Email
(Email)
ID 1081057
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Userilkaryna/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Lichtenthal, Richard M.
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/BD0AllAA-097E-4FA
C-AA25-FC01E963AC0C/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Lidia
2016-03-24 16:28:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-03-24 16:28:44 (UTC)
Organization Pt
ID 40
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
Organization
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-
AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Lidia
2018-02-22 23:50:49 (UTC)
2018-02-22 23:50:50 (UTC)
Pt
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lifestyle Lift
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Light Technology Publishing
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/Mailboxes/Junk (iCloud).mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810
-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/6/1/1/Messages/116048.embc
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lighting Universe
Email
(Email)
ID 1081123
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac-Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613 A4F7EC65/Data/31/Messages/73479.emlx
Mac Mail
Lighting&Locks.com (through Yahoo! Store Order System)
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/8/Messages/86520.emlx
Mac Mail
LightStim Professional
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/3/1/Messages/131354.emlx
Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1373758
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/1/3/1/Messages/131354.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1373758
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Liliya
Last Levaya
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
ID 29765
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Liliya
Last Levaya
Phone Number (Mobile Phone-
ID 29765
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Liliya
Last Levaya
Phone Number (Mobile Phone-
ID 29765
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Last Sanchez
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2010-12-14 20:41:48 (UTC)
Modification Date 2010-12-14 20:41:46 (UTC)
ID 55
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Last Sanchez
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC)
Modification 2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC) Date
ID 5209
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Middle Ann
Last Sanchez
Email (Home)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:09 (UTC)
Modification 2016-09-21 07:01:10 (UTC) Date
ID 4915
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Middle Ann
Last Sanchez
Email (Home)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:09 (UTC)
Modification 2016-09-21 07:01:10 (UTC) Date
ID 4915
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Last Sanchez
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2010-12-14 20:41:48 (UTC)
Modification Date 2010-12-14 20:41:46 (UTC)
ID 55
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Last Sanchez
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2010-12-14 20:41:48 (UTC)
Modification Date 2010-12-14 20:41:46 (UTC)
ID 55
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Last Sanchez
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC)
Modification 2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC) Date
ID 5209
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Middle Ann
Last Sanchez
Email (Work)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-02-04 17:57:57 (UTC)
ID 206
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Last Sanchez
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC)
Modification 2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC) Date
ID 5209
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Middle Ann
Last Sanchez
Email (Home)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:09 (UTC)
Modification 2016-09-21 07:01:10 (UTC) Date
ID 4915
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Middle Ann
Last Sanchez
Email (Work)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-02-04 17:57:57 (UTC)
ID 206
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lilly
Middle Ann
Last Sanchez
Email (Work)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-02-04 17:57:57 (UTC)
ID 206
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lilly Ann Sanchez
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lilly Pulitzer
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Lilly Pulitzer
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-
AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Lily (curved Statue)
Phone Number
(Home)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2018-05-01 08:42:54 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-05-01 10:49:03 (UTC)
Organization Bali Sculpture Curved Wash
ID 478
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/lcaryna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/BD0AI1AA-097E-4FA
C-AA25-FC01E963AC0C/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Lin
2016-03-24 16:28:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-03-24 16:28:44 (UTC)
Organization Uber Driver
ID 93
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-
AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Lin
2018-02-22 23:50:50 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-02-22 23:50:50 (UTC)
Organization Uber Driver
ID 119
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/0/1/Messages/109573.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Case Data: Contacts (10901-11000 of 19830)  Case Data: Contacts (11101-11200 of 19830)
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Jeffrey E. Epstein 2018 Trust [epstein] Epstein financial trust, trustees: Darren Indyke, Eva Dubin, Kathryn Ruemmler 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01266457 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein death bequests of Jeffrey E. Epstein 2018 Trust naming Darren Indyke, Kathryn Ruemmler, Richard Kahn as trustees
(date: 2018-05-08)
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 2018 TRUST

THIS TRUST AGREEMENT dated May 8, 2018 ("Agreement"), by and among JEFFREY

E. EPSTEIN, as Grantor (the "Grantor"), and DARREN K. INDYKE, RICHARD D. KAHN, and
KATHERYN H. RUEMMLER, as Trustees (the "Trustees").

The Grantor hereby pays over, assigns, grants, conveys, transfers and delivers to the
Trustees the property described in Schedule A annexed hereto and made a part hereof, to be
administered and disposed of as provided in this Agreement, with any additions, changes, or
amendments to this Agreement.

The trust created by this Agreement ("Trust") shall be known as the "The Jeffrey E.
Epstein 2018 Trust".

Article I During My Lifetime
The following provisions shall apply during my lifetime:

Section 1.1. - Disbursement of Income
All of the income derived from the property held in this Trust (the "Trust Estate") shall
be paid to me, or accumulated or paid as I may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.2. - Disbursement of Principal
My Trustees may distribute any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate to me as I
may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.3. - Specific Rights Reserved to Me

A. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to amend this
Agreement, in whole or in part, by a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by
me and delivered to no less than one Trustee of this Trust.

B. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, in my sole and
unfettered discretion, to remove any Trustee by delivering to no less than one Trustee of this
Trust a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

C. I reserve the right, at any time, to revoke this Trust in its entirety or, at
any time and from time to time, to revoke any provision hereof by delivering to no less than one
Trustee of this Trust a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

D. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to withdraw or
appoint any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate by delivering to no less than one
Trustee of this Trust a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.
E. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to transfer to my
Trustees, by gift, by Will or by beneficiary designation, such additional property, including life
insurance policies, as I may desire. Any such additional property shall be held on the same terms
as are then applicable to the original Trust Estate, except that it may be transferred subject to
conditions and provisions of special application to such additional property.
Article II After My Death
The following provisions shall apply after my death:

Section 2.1. - Payment of My Debts and of Taxes and Expenses
My Trustee shall pay from the principal of the Trust Estate (a) my debts, funeral and
burial expenses and the administration expenses of my probate estate which are not paid by the
Executors of my probate estate, and (b) the federal and state estate, inheritance, succession,
generation skipping and similar taxes imposed by reason of my death which are the obligations
of my Trustees (including any of such taxes which the Executors of my probate estate direct my
Trustees to pay by written direction delivered to my Trustees). For purposes of this Section 2.1,
the principal of the Trust Estate shall not include (a) any assets which are not included in my
Gross Estate or (b) any assets which are not subject to, or available to creditors for the payment
of, my debts, my funeral and burial expenses or the administration expenses of my probate
estate.

Section 2.2. — Specific Bequests and Devises under My Will and Trust
If my probate estate is insufficient to satisfy all pecuniary bequests (or bequests payable
in cash or in kind in the discretion of the Executors of my probate estate) provided in my Will,
my Trustees shall pay such unpaid bequests from the principal of the Trust Estate. If my Will
provided for a specific bequest or devise of specified assets and such bequest or devise could
not be satisfied from my probate estate because such assets were held by my Trustees at my
death, my Trustees shall distribute such assets to satisfy such bequest or devise.
To the extent the assets of the Trust are insufficient to satisfy all bequests, I direct my
Trustees to first pay all specific bequests in Article II, Sections 2.3(A)(12), (30), (31), and (32),
and the bequest in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(33), then next comply with the provisions of Article
II, Sections 2.3(A)(6), (17), (23), (24), (25), (26), (27), (28) and (29), and to the extent assets are
insufficient to pay all of the remaining bequests in Article II, Section 2.3(A), then the
beneficiaries of all such remaining bequests in Article II, Section 2.3(A) shall share on a
proportionate basis in the remaining estate assets available for distribution. The determination
of the Trustees as to the amounts distributable herein shall be binding on all parties.

Section 2.3. - Bequests

A. I make the following bequests:
1. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Four Million Dollars
($4,000,000), plus an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of
from a reputable financial institution in the amount of Ten Million Dollars
($10,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of ith a
lum sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate
upon her death.

2. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Four Million Dollars ($4.000,000), plus an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees
for the benefit of from a reputable financial institution in the amount of
Ten Million llars ($10,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of
e amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to
upon her death.

3. to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, Twenty Million Dollars
($20,000,000), plus an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of KARYNA
SHULIAK from a reputable financial institution in the amount of Twenty Million Dollars
($20,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of KARYNA SHULIAK with
a lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of
KARYNA SHULIAK upon her death.

4. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000)
plus an annuity to be purcnased by my Trustees for the benefit of <REDACTED> if she survives me, from a reputable 
financial institution in the amount of Ten Million Dollars
($10,000,000) which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of
a lump sum in e amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of
upon her death.

5. to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, if he survives me, Twenty Million Dollars ($20,000,000).
6. to MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if she is then married to DARREN
KEITH INDYKE, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000), which funds shall be distributed and used
for the sole purpose of repaying FT Real Estate, Inc. the funds it previously paid to KCAC, LLC
in connection with a real estate purchase contract between FT Real Estate, Inc., as purchaser, and
KCAC, LLC, as seller, for the purchase of the real property known as and located at 2 Kean Court
in Livingston, New Jersey, and terminating said real estate purchase contract. It is my express
desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate,
the Trustees shall treat said $3,000,000 as having been distributed by the Trust to MICHELLE
FERN SAIPHER, as the sole member of KCAC, LLC, as then having been repaid by MICHELLE
FERN SAIPHER on behalf of KCAC, LLC to FT Real Estate, Inc. and as then having been
distributed by FT Real Estate, Inc. to the Trust, as the sole shareholder of FT Real Estate, Inc. It
is further my express desire and intention, as the sole shareholder of FT Real Estate, Inc., that
upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, FT Real Estate, Inc. be
directed to cancel and terminate said real estate purchase contract as contemplated herein;
provided, however, that such distribution shall not be made or deemed to have been made and
such termination shall not occur if the transfer of such real property to FT Real Estate, Inc.
pursuant to such real estate purchase contract has been completed prior to my death or if prior to
my death said real estate purchase contract has been terminated or is otherwise no longer in effect.

7. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000)
plus an annuity to be purcnased by my Trustees for the benefit of <REDACTED>
from a reputable financial institution in the amount of Four Million Dollars
($4,000,000) which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of
nt of the then remaining principal balance payable upon her death.

8. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars
($2,000,000) which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life o with
from a reputable financial institution in the amount of Eight MilliolicWs
($2,000,000), plus an my Trustees for the benefit of
a lum sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance pays e to 1 ie estate of
pon her death.

9. to LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).
10. to LARWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., if he survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

11. to <REDACTED>, if he survives me, an annuity to be purchased by my Trustees for the benefit of
<REDACTED> from a reputable financial institution in the amount of Two Million Dollars
($2,000,000), payable monthly for the life of <REDACTED> of the then remainin rinci

12. to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR., or his heirs, successors and assigns,
whether or not LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR. surivives me, all of my interest in the property,
improvements, fixtures, permits located at <REDACTED>
and known and referred to as, y interest
consists of 100% of the issued an ou s an ing em ers 1p n eres rn yn c ojo, LC, a New
York limited liability company which holds legal title to said real property, improvements,
fixtures, permits and other rights, which Membership Interests are held in the name of Darren K.
Indyke, as nominee for me, and which I direct my Trustees to transfer to LUCIANO A.
FONTANILLA, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns.

13. to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, if he survives me, Twenty Million Dollars ($20,000,000).
14. to ANN RODRIQUEZ, if she survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000).

15. to VALDSON VIERA CONTRIN, if he survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000).
16. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000).

17. whether or not <REDACTED> survives me, to <REDACTED>
or her heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the total outstanding e t,
g ithout limitation, all principal and all accrued and unpaid interest thereon, due from
It is my express desire and intention that, upon
my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the full
amount of said outstanding debt, including, without limitation, all principal and accrued and
unpaid interest thereon, as having been distributed by the Trust to or
her heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used
debt and accrued but unpaid interest, as then having been repaid by
and then as having been distributed to the T as es o e s o

18. to MERWIN DELA CRUZ, if he survives me, One Hundred Thousand Dollars ($100,000).
19. to BRICE GORDON, if he survives me, Two Hundred Thousand Dollars
($200,000), but only if BRICE GORDON, whether in his own name or on behalf of a separate
entity, continues for a period of two years following my death to provide such services as the
Trustees deem necessary or appropriate in respect of one or more of the real properties
beneficially owned by me prior to my death. This bequest shall not be distributed to BRICE
GORDON prior to the expiration of two years following the date of my death. This bequest shall
not be subject to the provisions of Article II, Section 2.5.

21. to BELLA KLEIN, if she survives me, Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000).
22. to DAVID ROGERS, if he survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000).

23. I forgive any loans which I made to the following individuals or entities:

a) LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR.

b) <REDACTED>
c) <REDACTED>
d) <REDACTED>
e) LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF
f) KARYNA SHULIAK
g) <REDACTED>
h) <REDACTED>
i) <REDACTED>
j) <REDACTED>
k) SLK DESIGNS, LLC
l) JSC INTERIORS, LLC

24. Upon my death, my Trustees are directed to distribute to DARREN KEITH
INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial
obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability
company, from DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if she
is then married to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation, limited liability
company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by
one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Harlequin
Dane, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be
distributed to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole
purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my
express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from
my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial obligations and liabilities as
having been distributed by the Trust to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or
assigns, and as then having been repaid by DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors
or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due to me, or any
corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me
immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from
DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if she is then married
to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited
partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both of them
immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Harlequin Dane, LLC, or its
successor entities.
25. Upon my death, my Trustees are directed to distribute to RICHARD DAVID
KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations
and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company,
trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not
limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company, from
RICHARD DAVID KAHN, his spouse, LISA KAHN, if she is then married to RICHARD
DAVID KAHN, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general
partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior
to my death, including, but not limited to, Coatue Enterprises, LLC, a New York limited liability
company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be distributed to RICHARD DAVID KAHN,
or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such
outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon
my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the
total sum of all such financial obligations and liabilities as having been distributed by the Trust
to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid
by RICHARD DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of
all such liabilities and obligations due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust,
or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not
limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from RICHARD DAVID KAHN, his spouse, LISA
KAHN, if she is then married to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, and/or any corporation, limited
liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially
owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to,
Coatue Enterprises, LLC, or its successor entities.

26. Upon my death, my Trustees are directed to distribute to PAUL BARRETT,
or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations and
liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust,
or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, from PAUL
BARRETT, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general
partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by him immediately prior to my death,
including, without limitation, Osborne Lane Capital, LLC, a New York limited liability
company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be distributed to PAUL BARRETT, or his
heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and
due obligations and liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and the
receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such
financial obligations and liabilities as having been distributed by the Trust to PAUL BARRETT,
or his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid by PAUL BARRETT, or his
heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due
to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, rust, or other entity beneficially owned by
me immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from
PAUL BARRETT, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership,
general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by him immediately prior to my
death, including, but not limited to, Osborne Lane Capital, LLC, or its successor entities.
27. Upon my death, my Trustees are directed to distribute to LAWRENCE
PAUL VISOSKI, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all
financial obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited
SDNY_GM-_00008112
liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability
company, from LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., his spouse, EILEEN VISOSKI, if she is
then married to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., and/or both of them jointly, and/or any
corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other
entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death. Said funds
shall be distributed to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns,
for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and
liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust
of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial obligations
and liabilities as having been distributed by the Trust to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., or
his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid by LAWRENCE PAUL
VISOSKI, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such liabilities
and obligations due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity
beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Southern
Financial, LLC, from LAWRENCE P. VISOSKI, JR., his spouse, EILEEN VISOSKI, and/or
both of them jointly, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership,
general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately
prior to my death.

28. U  n my death my Trustees  are directed to distribute to each of LESLEY
!CATHERINE GROFF , BELLA KLEIN and ANN RODRIQUEZ, or
her heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations and
liabilities then outstanding and due from her to me, or any corporation, limited liability company,
trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not
limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company, and FT
Real Estate, Inc., a U.S. Virgin Isl  sCArnrwsitinn gala fi lmic than be distributed to each of
LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF, ELLA KLEIN and ANN
RODRIQUEZ, or her heirs, succe rs or assigns, ror me sole p se of being used to repay
all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my express desire and intention
that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall
treat the total sum of all such financial obligationsF] ' ' ,n distributed by
the Trust to each of LESLEY KATHERINE GROF  BELLA KLEIN
and ANN RODRIQUEZ, or her heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid by
each of LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF, BELLA KLEIN and ANN
RODRIQUEZ, or her heirs, successors or Issigns, to me rust in repayment of all such liabilities
and obligations due from her to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other
entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to,
Southern Financial, LLC and FT Real Estate, Inc.

29. It is my express desire and intention that all amounts due and owing to me
by the persons listed in Article II, Section 2.3(AX23) shall be cancelled upon my death. While
at the date of execution of this Amendment, the cancellation of said loans will not result in
taxable income to any such persons, in the event any changes are made to the applicable tax law,
my Trustees are directed to take any and all steps necessary to ensure that the cancellation of
such indebtedness does not result in any negative tax consequences to such persons. In that
regard, as necessary, all such amounts due and owing to me by the persons enumerated in Article
CONFICiENTIAL GJ 000436
II, Section 2.3(AX23) may be be deemed to have been distributed by the Trust to such persons
and repaid by such persons to the Trust. It is also my express desire and intention that all
financial obligations and liabilities enumerated in Article II, Sections 2.3(A)(6), (17), (24), (25),
(26), (27) and (28) shall be deemed to be terminated upon my death, and that such termination
shall not result in taxable income to any of the Beneficiaries enumerated in such Sections, and
my Trustees are directed to take any and all steps necessary to ensure that the termination of
such obligations and liabilities does not result in any negative tax consequences to such
Beneficiaries.

30. I give to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.1, all of my interest in all
apartments, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the premises
located in the building known and referred to as 22 Avenue Foch, 75016, Paris, France. The
interest consists of units 47 with mezzanine, 48 and 81 on the 2nd floor, units 63 and 74 on the
5th floor and units 5 and 22 (cellars) in the basement. The units are currently all owned by SCI
JEP, a French company of which I own 999 of the 1,000 outstanding shares. Such interest is
hereinafter referred to as the "Paris Property". In addition, I give to this separate trust for the
benefit of f she survives me, the sum of One Million Dollars
(51,000,06) w pay vor me upet dung expenses for the said premises. Operating expenses shall
include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities, general maintenance
and repairs and common charges.

31. I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all of my interest in the
property, leases, ri hts ermits improvements and fixtures com rising and pertaining to Zorro
Ranch, located al My interest consists of 10,000
shares of common stock of Cypress, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which
holds legal title to the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "New Mexico
Property".

32. I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all of my interest in the
property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the real property
located at, and known and referred to as, 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida. My interest
consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Laurel, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands
corporation, which holds legal title to the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the
"Florida Property".

33. I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, in a separate trust, the
provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.2, the sum of Ten Million Dollars
($10,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses of the New Mexico Property and the Florida
Property. Operating expenses shall include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate
taxes, utilities and general maintenance and repairs.

Section 2.4. - Balance of Trust Estate
The balance of the Trust Estate, after the distributions provided in Sections 2.1, 2.2 and
2.3 of this Article II, shall be distributed as follows:
CONFIbENTIAL GJ 000437
SDNY_GM:0000B114

A. One Hundred percent (100%) thereof tot f she
survives me, in separate trust, the provisions of which are set forth In Article Itt, Section 3.3.

B. If does not survive me, one hundred percent
thereof to EVA ANDE SON DUI31N, it she survives me.
C. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN does not survive me, one hundred percent
(100%) of the balance of the trust estate shall be transferred to THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES
OF THE MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY (hereinafter "the Board"), an
educational institution. The property compromising this gift may, for investment purposes, be
merged with any of the investment assets of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology ("MIT"),
but the gift shall be entered in the books and records of MIT as an endowed fluid known as
"THE JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN FUND" (the "Fund"). The Board shall use the endowment payout
from the Fund to provide financial aid for graduate and undergraduate students attending MIT.
In the event MIT is no longer in existence as of the date of any required distribution to it, my
Trustees are hereby directed to choose among them another educational institution to benefit
from my Trust.

Section 2.5. - Condition Applicable to Certain Bequests
A. Except as expressly provided herein, no bequest to any Beneficiary of this
Agreement who, during my lifetime, was employed by or provided services to me or any entity
that was owned directly or indirectly by me during my lifetime or HBRK Associates, Inc. or
Darren K. Indyke, PLLC, shall be distributed to said Beneficiary prior to the expiration of two
years following the date of my death. Any Beneficiary of this Agreement who, during my
lifetime, was employed by or provided services to me or any entity that was owned directly or
indirectly by me during my lifetime or HBRK Associates, Inc. or Darren K. Indyke, PLLC, and
who, after my death, shall voluntarily discontinue, or as a result of said Beneficiary's misconduct,
cause to be terminated, said Beneficiary's employment with or provision of services to my estate
or any entity or parcel of real property directly or indirectly owned by me during my lifetime or
HBRK Assoicates, Inc. or Darren K. Indyke, PLLC, prior to the expiration of two years following
the date of my death, shall be ineligible to receive any bequest hereunder; provided, however,
that in the event that prior to the expiration of two years following the date of my death, there is
a cessation in the specific operations of my estate or said real property or entity or HBRK
Associates, Inc. or Darren K. Indyke, PLLC in respect of which said Beneficiary is employed or
provides services, and prior to that cessation, said Beneficiary had not voluntarily discontinued,
or as a result of said Beneficiary's misconduct, caused to be terminated, said Beneficiary's
employment with or provision of services to my estate or said real property or entity or HBRK
Associates, Inc. or Darren K. Indyke, PLLC, then my Trustees shall distribute the bequest
hereunder to said Beneficiary within sixty days following the date of such cessation or as soon as
is reasonably practicable thereafter.

B. In order to provide for the continued and uninterrupted maintenance and
operation of the assets in my Trust Estate following my death, my Trustees shall ensure that all
persons who were employed by, or provided services to, me or any entity directly or indirectly
owned by me or HBRK Associates, Inc. or Darren K. Indyke, PLLC, shall continue to be so
employed or to so provide such services for a period of two (2) years following the date of my
CONFII5ENTIAL GJ 000438
death; provided, however, that my Trustees shall have the right terminate the employment or the
engagement of any such employees or service providers if and at such times as my Trustees
determine in their discretion that there is cause for such termination. For purposes of this Section
2.5 of this Article II, cause for such termination shall include, without limitation, physical or
mental incapacity, intentional misconduct, insubordination, breach of duty, disloyalty,
dishonesty, fraud, embezzlement, theft, abusive or inappropriate workplace behavior, substance
abuse, criminal misconduct (whether or not pertaining to the assets in the Trust Estate), decrease
or cessation of the need for employment or services, or any other circumstances causing my
Trustees to determine in their discretion that there is cause for such termination. The obligation
of my Trustees to ensure such continued employment or provision of services shall include,
without limitation, payment for the costs and expenses of all items of compensation, remuneration
and benefits as shall then be in effect at the then current rates and in the then current amounts
immediately prior to my death.

C. The provisions of this Section 2.5 of this Article II shall not apply to my
Trustees so long as they continue to serve as my Trustees hereunder.

D. The provisions of this Section 2.5 of this Article II shall not apply to the
provisions of Sections 2.3(AX6), (12), (17), (23), (24), (25), (26), (27), (28), (29), (30), (31),

(32) and (33) of this Article II.

Section 2.6. - Trust Property that Is Real Property
Except for property directed to be held in trust for a Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions
of Article III, Section 3.1, any trust property, including, without limitation, trust property directed
to be held in trust for a Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions of Article III, Section 3.3, that is
real property, including, but not limited to, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of
and pertaining to such real property, held directly by me, or indirectly through ownership of
shares of capital stock of a corporation of which I was the sole beneficial owner prior to my death,
shall be sold by my Trustees and the proceeds thereof held in said trust as soon as is reasonably
practicable following my death. In marketing and effectuating the sale of said real property, my
Trustees shall be guided as nearly as my Trustees determine in their discretion is possible or
appropriate under the then prevailing circumstances by my last express wishes with respect to the
sale of said real property, as shall be contained in the last writing signed by me and notarized and
delivered to at least one of my Trustees prior to my death.
Article III Iwasaki=

Section 3.1. - Residence Trust
Any property directed to be held in trust for a Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions of
this Section 3.1 of Article III shall be administered as follows:

A. The Beneficiary shall have the right to occupy the residence held by the
trust and to use the tangible personal property located in the residence for her lifetime.
CONFIbENTIAL GJ 000439

B. My Trustees, in my Trustees' sole discretion, may pay any part or all of
the income, and if income is insufficient, the principal of the trust (1) to pay the operating
expenses of the property held by the trust and (2) for any other purpose my Trustees consider
advisable. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal of the trust.

C. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall use my Trustees'
best efforts to sell the trust property and all tangible personal property associated therewith that
is part of the Trust Estate within two (2) years of the Beneficiary's death, and only in
extraordinary circumstances should the property not be sold within two (2) years of the
Beneficiary's death.

D. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall distribute the
remaining principal of the trust (i.e., the proceeds from the sale of the trust assets) to EVA
ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she then survives the Beneficiary. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN
does not survive the Beneficiary, then my Trustees shall distribute the remaining principal to
the Board of MIT as provided for in Section 2.4(C) of Article II.

Section 3.2. — Trust for Operating Expenses of the New Mexico Property and the Florida Property
All sums directed to be held in trust for KARYNA SHULIAK pursuant to the
provisions of this Section 3.2 of this Article III shall be administered as follows:

A. DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees
of the trust created pursuant to the provisions of Article II, Section 2.3(A)(33) and this Section
3.2 of this Article III.

B. Unless and until such trust terminates as provided in Section 3.2(E) of
this Article III, the Trustees may, in their discretion, apply at any time and from time to time
any part or all of the income of such trust and such sums from any part or all of the principal of
such trust to the payment of any and all operating expenses for either or both of the New Mexico
Property and the Florida Property, provided that such property is then solely beneficially owned
by KARYNA SHULIAK.

C. For purposes of this Section 3.2 of Article III, "Operating expenses" shall
include, but not be limited to, all expenses that the Trustees, in their discretion, determine are
required or appropriate in order to pay property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general
maintenance and repairs for the said properties.
D. For the sake of clarity, the Trustees shall not at any time pay from the
income or principal of such trust any operating expenses for any property that is not then solely
beneficially owned by KARYNA SHULIAK, including, without limitation, for this purpose,
any property that is not then solely beneficially owned by KARYNA SHULIAK as a result of
the acquisition by any third party, whether by sale, transfer, assignment, other disposition,
merger, condemnation, abandonment, adverse possession or other operation of law, of any
interest in said property, including, without limitation, a security interest, mortgage or lien on
said property, or the acquisition by any third party of any such interest in any entity (including,
CONFICYENTIAL GJ 000440
without limitation, any such interest in any shares of stock, membership interests or other
ownership interests of such entity) that is the record tide holder of said property, and the Trustees
shall not pay from the income or principal of this trust any expenses incurred in connection with
creating, servicing or extinguishing any debt that is incurred on either of said properties or that
is incurred by any record title holder of either of said properties, or any expenses in connection
with the sale, transfer, assignment, or other disposition of any direct or indirect interest in either
of said properties or in any record tide holder of either of said properties (including, without
limitation, a security interest, mortgage and/or lien). For purposes hereof, a "third party" means
any person (including a spouse or other relative of KARYNA SHULIAK) who is not KARYNA
SHULIAK, or any entity, including, without limitation, a corporation, partnership, limited
partnership, limited liability company, trust or other entity, that is not wholly beneficially owned
by KARYNA SHULIAK and over which KARYNA SHULIAK does not exercise exclusive
decision making authority. For purposes of this Section 3.2(D) of this Article III, the grant by
KARYNA SHULIAK, whether by proxy, power of attorney, or otherwise, of decision making
authority with respect to the New Mexico Property or the Florida Property, or the record title
holder thereof, may be deemed by the Trustees in their discretion as the loss by KARYNA
SHULIAK of exclusive beneficial ownership of such property or record title holder for so long
as the Trustees in their discretion shall continue to deem that loss to be so.

E. Immediately upon the occurrence of any of the following events, the trust
under the provisions of this Section 3.2 of this Article III shall terminate, no further payments
shall be made from the income or principal of such trust other than for operating expenses that
accrued prior to the date of such event, and the Trustees shall distribute all principal and income
then remaining in such trust pursuant to the provisions of Section 3.2(F) of this Article Ill:

1. The death of KARYNA SHULIAK;
2. The permanent mental incapacity of KARYNA SHULIAK as determined
by the Trustees in their discretion;

3. KARYNA SHULIAK shall cease to be the exclusive beneficial owner of
at least one of the New Mexico Property and the Palm Beach Property, as
determined by the Trustees in their discretion accordance with the
provisions of Section 3.2(D) of this Article III;

4. Other than by reason of her temporary mental incapacity, KARYNA
SHULIAK shall cease to exercise exclusive decision making authority
over at least one the New Mexico Property and the Palm Beach Property,
as determined by the Trustees in their discretion

F. Upon the termination of the trust as provided in Section 3.2(E) of this
Apcle_111.Aheanas_sii 'all distribute 100% the remaining principal and income of such trust
to  if she is then surviving. I   is not then
surviving, then the Trustees shall distribute 100% the remaining principal and income of such
trust to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she is then surviving. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN
is not then surviving, then the Trustees shall distribute 100% of the remaining principal and
income of such trust to the Board of MIT as provided for in Article II, Section 2.4(C) of this
Agreement.

Section 3.3. - Residuary Trusts
Any property directed to be held in trust for a Beneficiary pursuant to the provisions of
this Section 3.3 of Article III shall be administered as follows:

G. My Trustees may pay any part or all of the income and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of the trust as my Trustees, in my Trustees' discretion, from time
to time and at any time, shall determine for any reason whatsoever to, for the benefit of, or on
behalf of the Beneficiary. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal of
the trust.

H. Upon the death of the Beneficiary, my Trustees shall distribute the
remaining principal of the trust to EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN, if she then survives the
Beneficiary. If EVA ANDERSSON DUBIN does not survive the Beneficiary, then my Trustees
shall distribute the remaining principal of the trust to the Board of MIT as provided for in Article
II, Section 2.4(C) of this Agreement.
Article IV  Trust Terminating
If at any time my Trustees determine that it is uneconomic to continue any trust with
respect to which my Trustees are acting hereunder, my Trustees may terminate such trust and
distribute the trust assets, in such amounts and proportions as my Trustees may determine, to
the person or persons to whom income may be distributed, other than my Trustees, members of
the respective families of my Trustees, the respective estates of my Trustees, the respective
creditors of my Trustees or the creditors of the respective estates of my Trustees.
Article V  Trust Administration

Section 5.1. - Exercise of Discretionary Powers
Except as hereinbefore specifically provided, in connection with the exercise of a
discretionary power to distribute income or principal to any person, there shall be no
requirement to take into account such person's other income or capital resources, the interest of
such person in any other fund or the duty of anyone to support such person, although these
factors may be taken into account.

Section 5.2. - Discretionary Distributions
Any discretionary payment from any trust hereunder shall be charged against such trust
as a whole, and shall not be charged against the individual share of any person at any time.

Section 5.3. - Allocation of Assets

A. For each distribution, partial distribution, allocation, or division of assets
into shares or trusts involving a fraction, my Trustees shall apply such fraction to the fair market
CONFIdENTIAL GJ 000442
value of the relevant assets on the date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever
first occurs. My Trustees shall appropriately adjust such fractions to reflect the effect of any
partial distributions, allocations, or divisions, taking into account the fair market value as of the
date of distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurred, of the assets so distributed,
allocated, or divided.

B. My Trustees shall value any assets distributed, allocated, or divided to
satisfy (in whole or in part) a pecuniary distribution at the fair market value of such assets on
the date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurs.

Section 5.4. - Accounting Allocations

A. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement and except
as provided in Paragraph B of this Section 5.4, my Trustees shall allocate receipts and
disbursements in accordance with sound trust accounting principles and have discretion to
allocate receipts and disbursements when, in the judgment of my Trustees, the treatment is
uncertain under applicable laws or generally accepted accounting principles.
B. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, my Trustees
shall not treat any part of the principal amount of the proceeds of sale of any asset of any trust
as income distributable to or for the benefit of any beneficiary entitled to distributions of income;
provided, however, that my Trustees shall treat a portion of any proceeds of sale of any financial
instrument originally issued or acquired at a discount equal to the amount which (1) has
previously been characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes or (2) will be
characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes in the year of such sale, as income for
trust accounting purposes.

Section 5.5. - Spendthrift Provision
During the term of any trust hereunder, no money or other assets (either principal or
income) payable or distributable under the provisions of this Agreement shall be pledged,
assigned, transferred, given, conveyed, hypothecated, sold, anticipated, charged, or encumbered
by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder, nor shall the income and principal of any trust, while in
the possession of my Trustees, be liable for any debts, contracts, obligations, or undertakings of
such Beneficiaries, voluntary or involuntary, or for any claims or judgments against any
Beneficiary, including claims for alimony or for the support of any Beneficiary's spouse or
children, or for reimbursement of a federal, state or local government, or any agency of any
federal, state, or local government, for the support of any Beneficiary hereunder, prior to the
time such money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary. Any attempted
pledge, assignment, transfer, gift, conveyance, hypothecation, anticipation, charge, or
encumbrance of any money or assets (either income or principal) payable or distributable under
the provisions of this Agreement by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder prior to the time such
money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary shall be null and void and
shall not be recognized by my Trustees. This Section 5.5 of Article V shall not apply to me.

Section 5.6. - Limitation on Distributions
CONFIEYENTIAL GJ 000443
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, no discretionary distribution of
income or principal of any trust hereunder shall be applied to pay for medical care, residential
facilities, or any other care or service that would otherwise be provided for any Beneficiary
hereunder by any federal, state, or other governmental agency; and no such discretionary
distribution of income or principal shall be made for reimbursement for any such care, facilities
or services previously provided. Before making any discretionary payment to or for the benefit
of any such Beneficiary hereunder, my Trustees shall consider the amounts such Beneficiary is
or may be entitled to receive from any governmental agency for such care, facilities, or services.
If such amounts are available, discretionary distributions of income and principal from any trust
hereunder shall be made only to supplement such amounts, and to provide liberally for needs
and comforts over and above the basic maintenance, support, and medical care that may be paid
for by any such agency.

Section 5.7. - Division and Combination of Trusts

A. For any administrative, tax or other purpose determined by my Trustees
to be in the best interests of any Beneficiary (including any remainderman) hereunder, my
Trustees may at any time and from time to time (whether before or after funding), without
approval of any court, divide any trust under this Agreement into two or more separate trusts or
combine two or more trusts with substantially identical terms (whether or not such trusts resulted
from division of a prior trust).

B. If property is directed to be added to any trust hereunder (the "Original
Trust"), whether by the terms of this Agreement any other agreement, or the Will of any person,
my Trustees may hold such property as one or more separate trusts on terms identical to the
terms of the Original Trust. My Trustees may allocate such property among the separate trusts
(if any) into which the Original Trust was divided, whether or not pro-rata, using specific
assets or undivided interests therein (including allocation of all such property to one of such separate
trusts).
C. Any time during the existence of separate trusts created by division of a
trust hereunder, my Trustees may exercise all discretionary powers differently with respect to
the separate trusts and take all other actions consistent with such trusts being separate entities.
Furthermore, the holder of any power of appointment with respect to such separate trusts may
exercise such power differently with respect to each such trust.

Section 5.8. - Consolidation of Trusts
If at any time after my death there is in existence a trust under my Will or any trust
agreement created by me having identical beneficiaries and substantially the same terms as any
trust under this Agreement, my Trustees may terminate the trust hereunder and transfer the
assets thereof to the Trustees of such other trust, to be administered by the Trustees thereof.
Different termination dates under the applicable Rule Against Perpetuities shall not be deemed
a difference in the terms of such trusts, but the portion of the trust representing the transferred
assets shall retain the same termination date as the original trust.

Section 5.9. -Termination of Trusts
CONFIdENTIAL GJ 000444
Notwithstanding anything herein, any trust created hereunder for any person shall
(unless terminated earlier) terminate upon the day preceding the expiration of the maximum
period permitted under the United States Virgin Islands Rule Against Perpetuities, for the
vesting of an interest in a trust and upon such date the assets of such trust shall be distributed to
such person.

Section 5.10.  — EquitableAdjustment
If any of my Trustees decides to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by
this Agreement or by law (including, without limitation, any election available to my Trustee)
and the exercise or nonexercise of such power confers a benefit on one Beneficiary or class of
Beneficiaries hereunder and imposes a detriment upon another Beneficiary or class of
Beneficiaries hereunder, my Trustees shall not attempt to restore the interests of the
Beneficiaries or classes of Beneficiaries to the position otherwise contemplated by this
Agreement through adjustment between income and principal or otherwise.

Section 5.11. - Lapsed Distribution
Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, a provision for distribution
to an individual who is not surviving at the date such individual otherwise becomes eligible for
such distribution shall lapse notwithstanding any law to the contrary.

Section 5.12. - Notice
Any notice required hereunder shall be delivered personally or sent by first class or
certified mail addressed to the last known address of the intended recipient.

Section 5.13. - Termination of Trust
An instrument in writing completely revoking this Agreement shall, without more, upon
delivery to any of my Trustees, completely terminate all of my Trustees' right, title, and interest
to any life insurance proceeds, death benefits, pension, profit sharing, or other retirement
benefits or any other assets otherwise payable to my Trustees.
Article VI  Powers of Trustees

Section 6.1. - Exercise of Judgment and Powers
The Trustee of a trust hereunder has the entire care and custody of all assets of such
trust. My Trustees have the power to do everything my Trustees in good faith deem advisable
without necessity of any judicial authorization or approval, even though but for this power it
would not be authorized or appropriate for fiduciaries under any statutory or other rule of law.
My Trustees shall exercise my Trustees' best judgment and discretion for what my Trustees
believe to be in the best interests of such trust and the Beneficiaries of such trust. If more than
two Trustees are empowered as my Trustee to participate in the decision to exercise or not
CONFIdENTIAL GJ 000445
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, a majority of such Trustees
shall be empowered to make such decision.

Section 6.2. - Compensation of My Trustee
Each Trustee acting hereunder shall be entitled to annual compensation for services
performed hereunder in the amount of Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) per
year, in addition to any bequest to which they may be entitled under this terms of this Trust. No
other compensation shall be payable to my Trustees hereunder; provided, however, that my
Trustees shall be reimbursed for all reasonable costs, expenses, charges, and liabilities incurred
or paid in connection with acting as Trustee or performing services hereunder, including, but
not limited to, fees and expenses of counsel or any other agents hired by my Trustees, and my
Trustees shall not be liable therefor individually. My Trustees have discretion to pay such
compensation and such reimbursements from trust assets, without obtaining judicial
authorization or approval.

Section 6.3. - General Investment Powers

A. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, my Trustees have the
power with respect to each and every trust created hereunder:

I. To enter upon and take possession of the assets of such trust and collect
the income and profits from such assets, and to invest and reinvest such assets in real,
personal, or mixed assets (including the common trust funds of a corporate fiduciary) or in
undivided interests therein without being limited by any present or future investment laws;

2. To retain all or any part of the assets of such trust (without regard to the
proportion that any one asset or class of assets may bear to the whole) in the form in which
such assets were received or acquired by my Trustees;

3. To sell or dispose of, exchange, transfer, invest, or loan all or any part of
the assets of such trust which my Trustees hold, at any time, for such sums or upon such terms
as to payment, security, or otherwise as my Trustees determine, either by public or private
transactions;

4. To buy and sell options, warrants, puts, calls or other rights to purchase or
sell (collectively called "options") relating to any security or securities, regardless of whether
such security or securities are then held by my Trustees, and whether such options are
purchased or sold on a national securities exchange, and to exercise with respect to such
options all powers which an individual owner thereof could exercise, including, without
limitation, the right to allow the same to expire;
5. With respect to oil, natural gas, minerals, and all other natural resources
and rights to and interests therein (together with all equipment pertaining thereto) including,
without limiting the generality of the foregoing, oil and gas royalties, leases, or other oil and
gas interests of any character, whether owned in fee, as lessee, lessor, licensee, concessionaire
or otherwise, or alone or jointly with others as partner, joint tenant, or joint venturer in any
other noncorporate marner, (a) to make oil, gas and mineral leases or subleases; (b) to pay
CONFICYENTIAL GJ 000446
delay rentals, lease bonuses, royalties, overriding royalties, taxes, assessments, and all other
charges; (c) to sell, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge or otherwise hypothecate any or all of
such rights and interests; (d) to surrender or abandon, with or without consideration, any or
all of such rights and interests; (e) to make farm-out, pooling, and unitization agreements; (0
to make reservations or impose conditions on the transfer of any such rights or interests; (g)
to employ the most advantageous business form in which properly to exploit such rights and
interests, whether as corporations, partnerships, limited partnerships, mining partnerships,
joint ventures, co- tenancies, or otherwise exploit any and all such rights and interests; (h) to
produce, process, sell or exchange all products recovered through the exploitation of such
rights and interests, and to enter into contracts and agreements for or in respect of the
installation or operation of absorption, reprocessing or other processing plants; (i) to carry
any or all such interests in the name or names of a nominee or nominees; G) to delegate, to
the extent permitted by law, any or all of the powers set forth herein to the operator of such
property; and (k) to employ personnel, rent office space, buy or lease office equipment,
contract and pay for geological surveys and studies, procure appraisals, and generally to
conduct and engage in any and all activities incident to the foregoing powers, with full power
to borrow and pledge in order to finance such activities; together with the power to allocate
between principal and income any net proceeds received as consideration, whether as
royalties or otherwise, for the permanent severance from lands of oil, natural gas, minerals,
and all other natural resources;

6. To hold all or any part of the assets of such trust in cash or in bank accounts
without the necessity of investing the same;

7. To improve, repair, partition, plat, or subdivide all or any part of the assets
of such trust;
8. To litigate, defend, compromise, settle, abandon, or submit to mediation
or arbitration on such terms and conditions as my Trustees determine any claims in favor of
or against such trust or the assets of such trust;

9. To loan or borrow money in such amounts and upon such terms and
conditions as my Trustees determine, assume such obligations or give such guarantees as my
Trustees determine, for the purpose of the acquisition, improvement, protection, retention, or
preservation of the assets of such trust, or for the benefit of any of the Beneficiaries who are
entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust;

10. To create or invest in any entity with all or part of the assets of such trust
and to carry on for as long and in such manner as my Trustees determine any business
enterprise held or created by my Trustees or in which I owned any interest at my death, either
individually or as a partner, joint venturer, stockholder, trust beneficiary, or member; to sell
such business enterprise as an ongoing business; to consolidate, merge, encumber, dissolve,
liquidate or undertake any other extraordinary corporate transaction relating to such business
enterprise;

11. To vote in person or by proxy any and all stock or securities and to
become a party to any voting trusts, reorganization, consolidation, or other capital or debt
readjustment of any corporation, association, partnership, limited liability partnership, limited
CONFIEYENTIAL GJ 000447
liability company, or individual with respect to stocks, securities, or debts held by such trust;

12. Except as provided in Sections 6.3(B), (C), and (D) of this Article VI, to
enter into any good faith transactions with my Trustees individually or with any corporation,
partnership, limited liability partnership, limited liability company, or other entity in which
any of my Trustees has an ownership interest;

13. To purchase from my estate any stocks, bonds, securities, real or personal
property, or other assets, or make loans to my estate even though the same person or persons
occupy the office of my Trustee and the office of the Executor of my estate;

14. To lease, mortgage, pledge, grant a security interest in, or otherwise
encumber all or any part of the assets of such trust for any term of years whether or not beyond
the term of such trust (including, without limitation, any such action for the benefit of any of
the Beneficiaries of such trust);

15. To abandon any property of such trust, real or personal, which my
Trustees may deem worthless or not of sufficient value to warrant keeping or protecting; to
abstain from the payment of taxes, water rents or assessments and to forego making repairs,
maintaining or keeping up any such property; and to permit such property to be lost by tax
sale or other proceedings or to convey any such property for a nominal consideration or
without consideration so as to prevent the imposition of any liability by reason of the
continued ownership thereof;

16. To elect the mode of distribution of the proceeds from any profit-sharing
plan, pension plan, employee benefit plan, individual retirement plan, insurance contract, or
annuity contract pursuant to the terms of such plan or to change to another custodian of such
plan;

17. To conduct any audit, assessment, or investigation with respect to any
asset of such trust regarding compliance with any law or regulation having as its object
protection of public health, natural resources, or the environment (referred to as
"Environmental Laws"); to pay from the assets of such trust to remedy any failure to comply
with any Environmental Law (even to the exhaustion of all of the assets of such trust); and,
as may be required in my Trustee's judgment by any Environmental Law, to notify any
governmental authority of any past, present, or future non-compliance with any
Environmental Law; and

IS. To refuse to accept any asset distributable to such trust.
B. No Trustee shall directly or indirectly buy or sell any property for the
trust from or to himself, or from or to his relative, employer, employee, partner or other business
associate.

C. No Trustee shall as trustee of one trust sell property to himself as trustee
of another trust.
D. No Trustee shall lend trust funds to himself, or to his relative, employer,
CONFIdENTIAL GJ 000448
employee, partner, or other business associate.

Section 6.4. - Administrative Powers
Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, my Trustees have the power with
respect to each trust:

A. To employ agents, attorneys-at-law, consultants, investment advisers (to
whom my Trustees have discretion to delegate my Trustees' investment authority and
responsibility), other trustees and other fiduciaries in the administration of my Trustees' duties,
to delegate to such persons, or to one or more of my Trustees, the custody, control, or
management of any part of the assets of such trust as my Trustees determine and to pay for such
services from the assets of such trust, without obtaining judicial authorization orapproval;

B. To delegate, in whole or in part, to any person or persons the authority
and power to (I) sign checks, drafts or orders for the payment or withdrawal of funds, securities
and other assets from any bank, brokerage, custody or other account in which funds, securities
or other assets of such trust shall be deposited, (2) endorse for sale, transfer or delivery, or sell,
transfer or deliver, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any and all property, stocks, stock
warrants, stock rights, options, bonds or other securities whatsoever, (3) gain access to any safe
deposit box or boxes in which assets of such trust may be located or which may be in the name
of any of my Trustees and remove part or all of the contents of any such safe deposit box or
boxes and release and surrender the same, and (4) take any other action that my Trustee may
have the power to take with respect to such trust and the property thereof; no person or
corporation acting in reliance on any such delegation shall be charged with notice of any
revocation or change of such delegation unless such person or corporation receives actual notice
thereof;

C. To pay any property distributable to a Beneficiary under a legal disability
or who has not attained the age of 21, without liability to my Trustees, by paying such property

(I) to such Beneficiary, (2) for the use of such Beneficiary, (3) to a legal representative of such
Beneficiary appointed by a court or if none, to a relative for the use of such Beneficiary, or (4)
to a custodian for such Beneficiary designated by my Trustees, to hold until age 21 or such
earlier age as shall be the maximum permitted under applicable law;

D. To divide such trust into subsidiary accounts if my Trustees determine
that such division is necessary to maintain fair and accurate records;

E. To permit the Beneficiary of such trust to use, possess, and enjoy real
property, tangible personal property, or club memberships held by such trust;

F. To distribute to such trust or any of the Beneficiaries of such trust in kind
or in cash, or partly in kind and partly in cash, and to allocate different kinds or disproportionate
shares of assets or undivided interests in assets among all of such trusts or all of such
Beneficiaries;

G. In making the division into one or more trusts hereunder (if such trusts
CONFIEIENTIAL GJ 000449
have the same Trustees), to keep the assets of such trusts invested and handled as a single fund
without actual division and to designate such trusts on my Trustees' books as owning a
designated undivided interest in such fund;

13. To have evidence of ownership of any security maintained in the records
of a Federal Reserve Bank under the Federal Reserve Book Entry System; to deposit funds in
any bank or trust company; to carry in the name of any of my Trustees or the nominee or
nominees of the Trustees and with or without designation of fiduciary capacity, or to hold in
bearer form, securities or other property requiring or permitting of registration; and to cause
any securities to be held by a depository corporation of which a Trustee is a member or by an
agent under a safekeeping contract; provided, however, that the books and records of my
Trustees shall at all times show that such investments are part of such trust;

I. To register or not register such trust with the probate division of the
Superior Court of the United States Virgin Islands or otherwise and to make all decisions which
relate thereto;

J. To give any Beneficiary of any trust hereunder a general power of
appointment exercisable in such Beneficiary's Will over all or part of such trust, subject to any
terms and conditions as my Trustees determine, by written notice to such Beneficiary; to
eliminate any such power of appointment by written notice to the Beneficiary; and to
irrevocably release the power under this paragraph to give a power of appointment or to
eliminate a power of appointment;

K. To renounce and disclaim, in whole or in part, and in accordance with
applicable law, any assets, interests, rights, or powers (including any power of appointment)
which are payable to (or exercisable by) such trust or over which my Trustees have any right,
title, interest, or power; and

L. To make, execute, and deliver any and all such instruments in writing as
shall be necessary or proper to carry out any power, right, duty, or obligation of my Trustees or
any disposition whatsoever of such trust or any asset of such trust and to exercise any and all
other powers incidental or necessary to carry out or to fulfill the terms, provisions and purposes
of such trust.

Section 6.5. - Restrictions on Exercise of 111v Trustee's Powers

A. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, a
Trustee shall not participate in a discretionary decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power to (1) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder to himself or herself; or

(2) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder for the health, support,
maintenance or education of a Beneficiary if such Trustee has a legal obligation to provide for
the health, support, maintenance or education of such Beneficiary from such Trustee's personal
assets. For purposes of this paragraph, a person whose interest in a trust hereunder is limited to
a remote contingent interest (for example, a contingent remainderman whose interest depends
upon another person failing to survive to a specified age or a person designated to receive assets
CONFIdENTIAL GJ 000450
only in the event a power of appointment is not exercised) shall not be treated as a person who
is or may be a Beneficiary of such trust.

B. A Trustee of any trust hereunder may by a written notice delivered to the
other Trustee (or Trustees) of such trust decline to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or bylaw.

C. If a Trustee of any trust hereunder is not empowered (because of a
conflict of interest, declination to act or otherwise) to participate in the decision to exercise or
not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, then the remaining
Trustee or Trustees of such trust shall be empowered to make such decision. If no Trustee or
successor Trustee is empowered to participate in such decision, my Trustees may designate a
substitute Trustee to serve as Trustee of such trust who shall be empowered to make such
decision but has no other power or authority of the Trustees. Such designation shall be by
written notice delivered to such substitute Trustee.
Article VII  Provisions Concerning Trustees

Section 7.1. - Successor Trustees

A. In the event a Trustee of any trust created pursuant to the provisions of

Section 2.3(A)(33) of Article II and Section 3.2 of Article III, or any successor Trustee thereof,
resigns, is removed, becomes incapacitated or is unwilling or is unable to serve, a successor
Trustee shall be appointed to fill the vacancy thereby created, such that the total number of
Trustees acting on behalf of such trust at all times shall be two. Said successor Trustee may be
appointed at any time by the Trustees then acting, or, if, as a result of said vacancy, only one
Trustee is then acting, by the sole remaining Trustee then acting.
B. Except as specifically provided in Section 7.1(A) of this Article VII, in
the event a Trustee of the Trust resigns, is removed, becomes incapacitated or is unwilling or
is unable to serve, a successor Trustee shall be appointed to fill the vacancy thereby created,
such that the total number of Trustees acting on behalf of the Trust at all times shall be three.
BARNABY MARSH shall first be appointed to fill any such vacancy, and thereafter the
successor Trustee appointed to fill any such vacancy shall be appointed by the Trustees then
acting, including, but not limited to, if there are fewer than three Trustees then acting.

Section 7.2. - Appointment of Trustee
The appointment of a successor Trustee hereunder shall become effective when such
successor Trustee signs an acceptance of the trust.

Section 7.3. - Resignation of Trustees
Any Trustee may resign at any time, without the approval of any court, by an instrument
in writing filed with the trust records. In addition, if there is filed with the trust records a written
CONFIdENTIAL GJ 000451
certification from any attending physician of any individual Trustee of a trust that he or she is
no longer able to make decisions with respect to such trust, then from the date of filing of such
certification, such individual Trustee shall be deemed to have resigned for all purposes of this
Agreement.

Section 7.4. - Vacancy in Office
If there is a vacancy in the Trustees and no successor Trustee is designated pursuant to

Section 7.1 who is willing to act, the legally competent adult Beneficiary (or a majority in
beneficial interest of the legally competent adult Beneficiaries if there are multiple
Beneficiaries) then entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust shall designate a
successor Trustee by an instrument in writing delivered to the designated Trustee. If the legally
competent adult Beneficiaries do not designate a successor Trustee within sixty days after
receipt of notice of such vacancy or if there is no legally competent adult Beneficiary of such
trust, then a successor Trustee shall be named by order of a court of competent jurisdiction. All
of the fees and expenses of my Trustees (including attorneys' fees) attributable to the
appointment of a successor Trustee of a trust shall be paid from the assets of such trust.

Section 7.5. - Elimination of Bond
No bond or other security shall be required of any Trustee hereunder in any jurisdiction.

Section 7.6. - Exculpation and Indemnification of My Trustee
No one serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be accountable or
responsible to any person interested in any trust hereunder for the manner in which my Trustees
shall in good faith exercise any discretionary authority or any power of my Trustees. No one
serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be liable for any loss or
depreciation in value occasioned by reason of any negligence, error or mistake of judgment in
entering into any transaction, in making any sale or investment, in continuing to hold any
property, or by reason of any action or omission, whether by my Trustees or any other fiduciary,
unless such Trustee has acted in bad faith. In the absence of proof by affirmative evidence to the
contrary, each Trustee shall be deemed to have acted within the scope of my Trustees' authority,
to have exercised reasonable care, diligence, and prudence and to have acted impartially as to
all interested persons. A Trustee shall not be liable for the acts or defaults of another Trustee.
In the event a legal action is brought against any individual serving as the Trustee of any
trust under this Agreement, all legal fees and related expenses incurred in connection with the
defense of such legal action shall be paid by such trust without court authorization; provided,
however, that (a) no such payment shall (or shall continue to) be made if a court enters an order
prohibiting such payment, and (b) such Trustee shall refund to the trust any such payments that
previously had been made if a court enters an order directing that such payments be refunded,
or if a court concludes that such Trustee acted in bad faith.

Section 7.7. - Relief from Virgin Islands Statutory Provisions
Pursuant to Section 1212, Title IS, of the Virgin Islands Code, I hereby relieve my
Trustees and any successor Trustees of the requirements imposed by Chapter 59, Title 15 of the
Virgin Islands Code, or any similar successor law respecting public filings of inventories and
CONFIdENTIAL GJ 000452
accountings by Trustees. Furthermore, pursuant to Section 1107, Title 15, of the Virgin Islands
Code, I hereby relieve my Trustees and any successor Trustees, to the extent allowable, from
any and all duties, restrictions, and liabilities which would otherwise be imposed upon my
Trustees by Chapter 57, Title 15, Virgin Islands Code. This Section 7.7 of this Article VII shall
not be deemed a waiver of any and all other rights, powers, or restrictions otherwise granted to
my Trustees in this Agreement.
Article VIII  Miscellaneous Provisions

Section 8.1. - Representation of Person Under a Disability
To the extent allowed by law, where a party to any proceeding with respect to any trust
hereunder has the same interest as a person under a disability, legal process shall not be required
on the person under a disability.

Section 8.2. - Simultaneous Deaths
If a Beneficiary under this Agreement and I die simultaneously or under such
circumstances that it is difficult to determine who died first, then for all purposes of this
Agreement such Beneficiary shall be deemed to have predeceased me.

Section 8.3. - Law Governing
This Agreement and each trust created by it shall in all respects and for all purposes be
governed and regulated by the laws of the Territory of the United States Virgin Islands, as they
now exist and may from time to time be enacted, amended, or repealed. All questions regarding
the validity, construction and administration of this Agreement, or any of its provisions, and of
any trust created by it shall be determined solely by the laws of that Territory. The courts of the
State of Delaware and the U.S. Virgin Islands shall have primary supervision over the
administration of each trust created by this Agreement. It is intended that each such trust shall
be a U.S. domestic trust as defined in Title 26 section 7701(a)(30) of the Code by virtue of
meeting the court and control test. As provided in Treas Reg. section 301.770 I -7(c)(4)(D),
if both a United States court and a foreign court are able to exercise primary supervision over
the administration of the trust, the trust meets the court test.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, my Trustees of each trust
created under this Agreement have discretion at any time or times following my death to transfer
the situs of such trust to such other country, or such other jurisdiction as my Trustees determine,
without obtaining judicial authorization or approval (unless such judicial authorization or
approval is required by applicable law) and without the filing of any bond. My Trustees'
determination to transfer the situs of any trust under this Agreement shall be evidenced by an
instrument in writing signed, witnessed and acknowledged by my Trustees in the same manner
as would be required for a deed. My Trustees are authorized to take whatever actions are
necessary to effect such a transfer of situs. If judicial authorization or approval is required to
effect such a transfer of situs, I intend and desire that the appropriate court accept the
determination of my Trustees concerning the transfer of the situs of such trust even if one or
CONFI dENTIAL GJ 000453
SDW_GM:00008130
more Beneficiaries disagree with such determination. From and after my Trustees' transfer of
the situs of a trust pursuant to this Section 8.3 of this Article VIII, the administration of such
trust shall be governed by the law of the new situs of such trust.

Section 8.4. - Definition of Terms
Except as otherwise specifically provided herein, as used in this Agreement,

A. The term "Trustee" means all persons or entities who occupy the office
of Trustee of any trust hereunder while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one
or more persons or entities occupy the office of Trustee at the same time or times, and includes
any successor Trustee or Trustees. The term "Executor" of a person's estate means all persons
or entities who occupy the office of personal representative, administrator, executor, or ancillary
administrator while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more persons or
entities occupy such office at the same time or times, and includes any successor or successors
to that office. A reference to a person's Will means such person's Last Will and Testament and
any Codicil or Codicils thereto.

B. A reference to any tax also includes any interest or penalties thereon. The
term "my Gross Estate" means my gross estate as finally determined for purposes of computing
my federal estate tax.

C. Whenever the singular number is used, the same shall include the plural,
and the masculine gender shall include the feminine and neuter genders.

Section 8.5. - No Contest
If any Beneficiary under this Agreement shall in any way directly or indirectly (a) contest
or object to the probate of my Will or to the validity of any disposition or provision of my Will
or of this Agreement or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or indirectly
instrumental in the institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest, objection or
claim for the purpose of setting aside or invalidating my Will or this Agreement or any
disposition therein or herein or provision thereof or hereof, then I direct that (aa) any and all
provisions in this Agreement for such Beneficiary and his issue in any degree shall be null and
void and (bb) my estate whether passing under my Will or this Agreement or pursuant to the
laws of intestacy shall be disposed of as if such Beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all
failed to survive me.

Section 8.6. -Trustee Notice
My Trustees may have duties and responsibilities in addition to those described in this
Agreement. If my Trustees have questions, my Trustees should obtain legal advice.
CONCLUSION
I have duly executed this Agreement on the date set opposite my signature.
CONFIdENTIAL GJ 000454
Richard D. Kahn, Trustee
itA /I, pf..4
Kathryn H. Ruemmler, Trustee
STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
Date  \
Date S
Date Sl obe
Date  Sidi //  r
) ss:
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me thi&Iday of May, 2018 by JEFFREY

E. EPSTEIN, the Grantor, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this
r Ih day of May, 2018.
chialiht (toitli Notary Public
IMBIBE AVOW
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK

No. 01AV6313116
Qualified in Richmond County
My Commission Expires October 10. 2011
STATE OF NEW YORK
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this day of May, 2018, by DARREN

K. INDYKE, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced as
identification.
Sworn to before me this
SLY) day of May, 2018.
OutewNotary Public
IMBIBE AVOW
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK

No. 01AV6313116
Qualified in Richmond County
My Commission Expires October 14, 2016
27 CONFIDENTIAL GJ 000455
STATE OF NEW YORK )
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this day of May, 2018, by
RICHARD D. KAHN, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this
day of May, 2018.
CThfrib (WI LI Notary Public
STATE OF
)ss:
COUNTY OF
HABIBE AVOIU
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK

No. 01AV6313116
Qualified In Richmond County
My Commission Expires Octanes Id. 2010
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn t  b day of May, 2018, by
KATHRYN H. RUEMMLER, a Trustee, who is personally known to me r who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this
of  day of May, 2018.
Notary Public
28 CONFIDENTIAL
• „ '
GJ 000456
SCHEDULE A
Demist... of Trust PronerD,
8100.00
CONFIDENTIAL EFT,00120806
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Sergey Belyakov [russia] graduate of Russia's FSB academy (AKA "a spy"), head of the St. Petersburg Economic Forum [dossier] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00306033 (Jmail)
 [girls] Sergey Belyakov Epstein Russian visa
(inferred date: 2018-05-31)
To Russian Consulate General in NYC
Association of Nongovernmental Pension Funds
PRESIDENT
2 Tsvetnoi boulevard,
Phone number
127051 Moscow
Date: April 28, 2018
The Self-regulated organization Association of Nongovernmental Pension Funds "Alliance of
Pension Funds" (legal address: 2 Tsvetnoy boulevard, Phone numbe
Moscow; Tax Identification I would like to ask you to grant a 3 year mu tip e
entrance visa for the United States citizen Jeffrey Edward Epstein.

Mr. Epstein is the Chairman of Southern Trust Company. The purpose of his visit is collaboration
in helping American companies participate in Russian investment projects.

Mr. Epstein is planning to visit Moscow on May 28th will May 31st, 2018. After that, he is
planning to come to Russia multiple times to participate in international seminars and forums.
Passport info:
The Association of Nongovernmental Pension Funds "Alliance of Pension Funds" guarantees to
cover Mr. Epstein's expenses in the territory of Russian Federation.
In case of the deportation of Mr. Epstein, we agree to cover all the related expenses.
All the best,
Sergey Belyakov
EFTA00810356 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2018-06-14)
VALAR
Valor Global Fund III LP Capital Call
May 31, 2018
Dear Southern Trust Company, Inc.,
Thank you again for your partnership in Valor Global Fund III LP (the Fund). The Fund is calling
capital from you in the amount of $1,750,000.00, which represents 7% of your total commitment
of $25.000.000.00. This capital contribution is due on or before Thursday, June 14, 2018.
After this capital contribution, you will have contributed 84% of your total commitment with a
remaining 16% of total unfunded commitment, which is detailed below.
Total Commitment:
Total Contributions as of June 14, 2018:
Total Unfunded Commitment:
$25,000,000.00
$21,000,000.00
$4,000.000.00
Please wire your funds in accordance with the following instructions:
Due Date:
Amount Due:
Bank Name:
ABA#:
Beneficiary Name:
Beneficiary Account:
Thursday, June 14. 2018
$1,750.000.00
Silicon Valley Bank
Valor Global Fund III LP
If you should have any questions regarding this information, please feel free to contact me at
Sincerely,
Reuben Kobulnik
COO/CFO
Valor Ventures LLC 91 S Bloodwoy Suite 1101 New York, New York 10010 www.volor.com
EFTA01227877 (Jmail)
 [russia] multi entry visa for the Russian Federation
(date: 2018-06-25)
ВИЗА Visa                23 7643906
P0CCHNCKAR OETIEPAIDIR
RUSSIAN FEDERATION
МНОГОКРАТНАЯ "М" ОД

25.06.18/24.06.21
НА СРОК/DURATION         183
>                        НИК512858
ЭПШТЕЙН ДЖЕФФРИ ЭДВАРД
EPSTEIN JEFFREY EDWARD
545368864   20.01.1953   МУЖ
ДЕЛОВАЯ, 003

НЕПРЕРЫВНОЕ ПРЕБЫВАНИЕ 6 МЕСЯЦЕВ

V6P4TEQN<<DJEFFRI<6DVARD<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<6
545368864<<<7USA2001539M<<<<<<<<<ONYC5128584
EFTA00811791 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2018-06-30)
Valar Global Fund II LP
Unaudited Financial Statements
June 30, 2018
VALAR
Valar Global Fund 11 LP
Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Partners' Capital
June 30, 2018
Assets
Cash $ 404.138
Investments, at fair value (cost $52,964,083) 107.942.704
Interest receivable 94.782
Total assets $ 108.441,624
Partners' Capital
Contributions $ 69,179.430
Syndication costs (315,000)
Net operating loss (6.315238)
Net realized loss (9,086.189)
Net unrealized gain 54.978.621
Total partners capital $ 108,441,624
Valar Global Fund II LP
Statement of Operations
January 1, 2018 through June 30. 2018
Income
Interest income S 38,994
Expenses
Net management fees 855,128
Professional fees 133,324
General and administrative 22,810
Total expenses 1.011.262
Net operating loss
Net realized loss
(972,268)
(9.086.189)
Net change in unrealized appreciation
in fair value of investments 27,966.596
Net increase in partners' capital
resulting from operations S 17.908,139
Valar Global Fund II LP
Schedule of Investments
June 30. 2018
Shares Cost Fair Value
Unrealized
Gain/(Loss)
N26 GmbH
Series A Preferred Shares 5.314 $ 4,802,996 S 31.798.746 S 26.995.750
Series B Preferred Shares 2,127 5.562,347 12.727.876 7.165329
Breather Products Inc.
Series B-2 Preferred Shares 4,175.999 11.560.000 22.966.324 11.406.324
Series C Preferred Shares 1.050.985 5.779.997 5.779.997
Kalo Industries Inc. (0k/a Lystable Inc.)
Series A5 Preferred Shares 1.542.649 3,399.998 3,399,998
Series A4 Preferred Shares 3,028,446 4,705,599 6,674.695 1.969.096
Series A3 Preferred Shares 194,578 174.634 428.850 254.216
Series A2 Preferred Shares 319.095 179.012 703.285 524.273
Even Responsible Finance. Inc.
Series A Preferred Shares 1.627,564 3,093,999 6.484,866 3.390.867
Series B Preferred Shares 140,808 561,035 561.035
Granify, Inc.
Series A-3 Preferred Shares 1.215.895 3,782.163 3.782.163
Convertible Note 489,600 489,600
Trade It. Inc. (f/k/a Trading Ticket, Inc.)
Series Seed Preferred Shares 1.464255 1.160.000 1.700,000 340.000
Series Seed-2 Preferred Shares 1.101.479 1,278,817 1,278.817
Common Shares 329,662 107.780 382.738 274.958
Deposit Solutions GmbH
Series B Preferred Shares 668 1,153.583 2,134.987 981,404
Homie, Inc.
Series Seed-2 Preferred Shares 1,569,713 1,699,999 1,699,999
Convertibe Note 170.000 170.000
Common Shares 212,894 170,002 230.564 60.562
Vend Limited
Series D Preferred Shares 503,288 1,336,200 1,382.304 46.104
Stash Financial, Inc. (f7k/a Collective Returns, Inc.)
Series Seed-2 Preferred Shares 92,270 169,998 1,360,925 1,190,927
Valar Global Fund II LP
Schedule of Investments
June 30, 2018
Shares Cost Fair Value
Unrealized
Gain/(LossI
Eden, Ltd.
Series 1) Preference Shares 738.246 S 509,980 S 704.361 S 194.381
Convertible Note 195,103 195.103
IrisVR. Inc.
Series AA Preferred Shares 215,942 170.000 258.612 88.612
Series A Preferred Shares 129,308 154,859 154.859
Camera, Inc.
Series Seed Preferred Shares 275,660 170,000 265.618 95.618
Jopwell. Inc.
Series A-I Preferred Stock 170,622 226.382 226.382
Total Investments $ 52,964.083 $107.942.704 S 54.978.621
VALAR
Limited Partner:
Fund:
Commitment:
Paid in Capital:
Remaining:
Unaudited Statement of
Changes in Partner's Capital
As of 06-30-2018
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
Velar Global Fund II LP
$15,000,000
$14,550,000
$450,000
Current
Quarter
Year to
Date
Inception to
Date
Partner's capital, beginning $20,961,349 $17,718,634 $0
Contributions $0 $300,000 $14,550,000
Net operating income/(loss)
Management fees ($91,322) ($180,217) ($1,123,095)
Partnership expenses ($15,626) ($32,575) ($298,468)
Interest income $4,090 $8,136 $26,334
Total net operating income/(loss) ($102,858) ($204,656) ($1,395,229)
Distributions $0 $0 $0
Transfer $0 $0 $0
Net realized gain/(loss) on investments ($1,495,729) ($1,895,721) ($1,895,721)
Net unrealized gain/(loss) on investments $1,637,709 $5,082,214 $9,741,421
Partner's capital, ending $21,000,471 $21,000,471 $21,000,471
EFTA00811797 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2018-06-30)
Valar Global Fund III LP
Unaudited Financial Statements
June 30, 2018
VALAR
Valar Global Fund III LP
Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Partners' Capital
June 30.2018
Assets
Cash and cash equivalents $ 3.360.542
Investments, at fair value (cost $54.143.077) 104.150.863
Interest receivable 11.01$
Total assets $ 107.522.420
Partners' Capital
Contributions $ 61.486.320
Syndication costs (139,155)
Net operating loss (3,832,531)
Net unrealized gain 50,007.786
Total partners capital 107,522,420
Total liabilities and partners' capital $ 107.522,420
Vain Global Fund III LP
Statement of Operations
January 1.2018 through June 30.2018
Income
Interest income S 4.215
Expenses
Gross management fee 812,485
Management fee reduction for syndication costs (31,500)
Net management fee 780,985 Professional fees 126.629
General and administrative 64,298
Total expenses 971,912
Net operating loss (967,697)
Net change in unrealized appreciation
in fair value of investments 24,767,432
Net increase in partners' capital
resulting from operations S 23.799.735
else Glottal Fund III 1.P
Schedule of Interments
lone ;U. 24'8
Comport Shams Coil I'm Value
Utirealifed
Gaisalmm)
Stash Financial, Inc
Sena D Preferred Sham 1.647319 S 10200.000 S 24304,309 S 14,104309
Saki A Preferred Shares 693.529 1.937997 10229.123 8.291.126
Sams C Preferred Shares 217.494 2.692576 3307,902 515.326
Series I)  Preferred Shares 46,103 679991 679.991
Clint S.A.S (r119a Guido)
Saws A Ordinary Shines 26.165 3378.771 19239.059 13.860388
Senn Seed Ordinary Shams 6351 344346 4.669.874 4,325228
Octane Lending. Inc
Sena A411Consemble Professed Sleek 1.562226 8,473.658 10.815,443 2361,785
Sena II Convenkle Preferred Sleek 294.122 2.040.001 2,040.001
Common Stock 129.127 516.508 895.612 379,101
Co),  AG
Sena A Preferred Simms 11,914 4.422.963 8.092.926 3.669,963
N26 Gmbll
Mefened II Shares LOU 4334.464 6.570.383 2.233921
Pelat Can!. Inc
Sena A Preened Shares 4485126 5.405289 5.647.025 241.136
Canteen Mock
lefty Mammal. Inc
Series A Prefened Share.
78.100
2.375.245
70.332
5.505351
98328
5305.551
27.796
Spaceship Financial Scniom Pty Ltd
Comestible Nola 521276 303,676 418200)
Molly IlK Technology Lined
Series Seed Preferred Sures 592.449 210380 .124.484 13.101
Cnnsenihle Nola. 237375 237.575
Seed 17Mkwn. hie
Simple Aeœlllell for future liquily 340.000 340000
Peak Verdun:. Fund WM
I smiled l'Ininership lateens 306.000 306.000
Sylmar. Inc
Simple Ageoneic for Future [quay 217.600 217.600
Mirror Al Inc
Conn-ruble Noies 170400 170100
Andusil 'wineries. Inc
Series Seed Pedaled Slack 123.143 68.000 65100
Ike Inc.
Series Seed 'Inferred Slot* 83,563 67.999 67.999
fetal Imminent. $ 54.I43.077 5 104.150.863 S 50.007.786
VALAR
Limited Partner:
Fund:
Unaudited Statement of
Changes in Partner's Capital
As of 06-30-2018
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
Velar Global Fund Ill LP
Commitment: $25.000,000
Paid in Capital:
Remaining: $21,000,000
$4,000.000
Current
Quarter
Year to
Date
Inception to
Date
Partner's capital, beginning $26,904,496 $23,182,649 $0
Contributions $1,750,000 $3,750,000 $21,000,000
Net operating income/(loss)
Management fees ($140,042) ($267,278) ($1,061,658)
Partnership expenses ($30,978) ($75,466) ($299,472)
Interest income $718 $1,428 $4,552
Total net operating income/(loss) ($170,302) ($341,316) ($1,356,577)
Distributions $0 $0 $0
Transfer $0 $0 $0
Net realized gain/(loss) on investments $0 $0 $0
Net unrealized gain/(loss) on investments $4,861,076 $6,753,936 $13,701,846
Partner's capital, ending $33,345,270 $33,345,270 $33,345,270
EFTA00803464 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Honeycomb Asset Management July 2018 report
(date: 2018-07-17)
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
July 17, 2018
Dear Rich:
Below please find Honeycomb's O2 2018, Year To Date, and Inception To Date Fund performance since
our institutional launch.
Performance — Gross and Net'
O2 2018 Year To Date Inception To Date
(July'16-Jun*18)
Honeycomb Class A (gross) 8.6% 11.3% 46.2%
Honeycomb Class A (net) 6.9% 9.0% 36.2%
Honeycomb Class B (gross) 8.7% 11.5% 47.5%
Honeycomb Class B (net) 7.0% 9.2% 37.2%
Internal capital anchored our June 2016 soft launch which also ricluded select friends and family capital. The Fund's 
June 2016 net performance was
-3.4% and -3.3% for classes A and B. respectively. Past performance es not riclicabve or a guarantee of future results.
Q2 2018 Performance Review
April was a strong start to the quarter. Names across the growth intemet, media, and payments space
drove our long performance while our shorts held predominantly flat.
May was a positive month led by various positions across Chinese and US intemet-related companies as
well as exposure to video gaming and software names. Single name shorts used as hedges against our
growth exposure detracted from performance.
June was also a month where we delivered positive returns to our partners. We began to take profits in
names where our risk/reward became less favorable and we reduced exposure to the information
technology sector as our price targets were achieved. However, some of our structural shorts such as
positions in advertising agencies were performance detractors.
Our largest position and biggest performance contributor in Q2 was our Spotify long, which represents a
more than year-long effort in developing exposure to the streaming music space. Honeycomb invested in
Spotify as a private company (with our initial investment in July of 2017 via the side pocket and Honeycomb
Ventures I) and has been tracking its progress since before that time. Our high conviction in the secular
growth of streaming music, and in Spotify's position as the category leader, led us to make it our largest
investment for Q2 as the company came public via a non-traditional direct listing. We were able to benefit
from early investors seeking immediate liquidity in the public market and some market skepticism around
the business model. It has done well since it went public in April but it's early and we believe it will continue
to deliver strong performance by growing its subscriber base and improving its profitability as the business
gains even greater scale.
Exposures for O2 averaged approximately 166% gross and 62% net, which compares to 170% gross and
62% net averages in O1. We have taken a more conservative approach thus far in 2018, operating at the
lower end of our gross historical exposure range but are still on track to deliver our targeted returns.
645 Madsen Avenue. 1 Floor. New York. NY 10022
Con - Not for Disinbuton
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
Gross Long and Short Security Selection Contribution — Q2 2018•
rlo
-3%
11.5%
-2.6%
8.9%
Long Short Total
'The secunly elf/at-ton above defers from we 2018 performame table as it does not consider management fee. incentwe 
atocabon. forwards or run! expenses. Past
performance is not indicative of a guarantee of More results.
New Investment Idea — The Stars Group (Ticker: "TSG". $37)
As a firm, our investment style is to find growth at a reasonable price. Sometimes this leads us to
technology ideas and other times it leads us to broader investment opportunities. Honeycomb is focused
on investing in the future and shorting the past, so we spend a great deal of time researching secular trends.
One irreversible trend taking shape is the change in social behaviors as we transform from an offline to
digital world. Last summer, we noticed this trend being expressed through impressive growth in streaming
music, which led to our successful investment in Spotify. This summer we see online gaming as another
market rapidly gaining acceptance. More and more, consumers are turning to their computers and mobile
devices when they want to play poker or bet on sporting events. With the backdrop of "gamification" in
customized betting, plus a secular shift to mobile, we believe that online gaming is poised to accelerate
meaningfully.
At Honeycomb, we believe in the power of leading online platforms, and we believe regulatory change can
unlock market opportunities. Under this framework, we acquired a meaningful position in The Stars Group
("TSG" or "Stars") during the second quarter. It is a $9B market cap company with limited research
coverage, which we believe is helping create this great investment opportunity.
Stars is a fast growing online gaming company best known for operating Pokerstars, the leading online
poker platform with over 8x the poker revenue of the next largest competitor. We think the network effects
generated from the scale of TSG's business, coupled with a leading gaming technology platform, have
created a sustainable competitive moat around the core Pokerstars asset, building a strong foundation for
the overall TSG business.
In our view, one sign of a great company is the ability to leverage an existing competitive moat into new
areas. Stars has done just that building upon its Poker base, launching an online casino in 2014 and an
online sports betting product in 2015. By 2017, casino and sports gaming combined for -30% of TSG
revenue, with +46% 2017 revenue growth versus +4% in poker.
2
Confidential - Not Ice OisIntuton
TSG's Pokerstars has
over 8x the poker
revenue of the next
largest competitor.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
$1,000
$800
$600
$400
$200
Poker Revenue (2017, $mn)
• Pokerstars partypoker 888 Poker (888
(MG) (GVC LN) LN)
Source: Company filings
partypoker reflects Honeycomb estimates based on GVC disclosures.
TSG today reflects a marked transformation from Stars' history as the B2B gaming supply company Amaya,
which acquired Pokerstars in 2014. TSG was renamed The Stars Group (from Amaya) in August 2017, with
a new management team in place and a focus on pushing beyond poker and into new markets. In today's
Stars Group, we see a powerful flywheel where TSG can acquire customers in a low-cost manner through
poker, cross-sell into sports and casino gaming, and feed the top of the funnel through free-to-play offerings
(as illustrated below).
Rouen; tp flrivers TSG Revenue by Product (Smn)
Poker growth at a +LSD rate Ss.000
2 Casino step-up from M&A in $4.000
2018/2019, with low-teens growth 53.000
thereafter 52.000
Sportsbook step-up from M&A in st000
2018/2019, with approximately S- 2015 2016 2017 2018E 2019E 2020E 2021E
+20% growth thereafter ■Poker Revenue • Casino Revenue Sportsbook Revenue
Source: Company filings. Honeycomb estimates
TSG becomes even more compelling in our view as we add in the next spoke of the flywheel: Sky Betting.
TSG just closed its $4.7bn acquisition of Sky Betting ("Sky"), a leading sports betting operator in the UK.
Sky grew 2014-2017 revenue at a +50% CAGR, doubling market share from 6% to 12% while the overall
UK Online Gaming market grew at a +19% CAGR. Sky Betting benefits from its general affiliation with Sky
Plc, the 6th most valuable brand across the UK (per WPP research). Additionally, Sky Betting has direct
tie-ins with the Sky Sports network, including in-game advertisements; we think this partnership is a unique
3
Ca-Manua/ - Not Ian Chsintvon
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
competitive advantage. We are positive on the Sky Betting asset because of its mobile-first strategy, best
in class technology investments, and culture of innovation. As an example of their in-game innovation, Sky
pioneered the 'RequestABet' product, where customers can make up their own custom bets and Sky will
provide odds. We believe continued software product innovation is a great way to keep customers engaged
with Sky Betting. An epitome of an offline traditional business benefiting from technology and expanding
the total addressable market.
IheISCLElywhol
I Cross-sell Poker customers into Sports Betting
Up-sell Poker and Sports customers into the
higher-margin Casino business
Leverage the growing Sports business to drive
more Poker customers
4 Feed the top of the funnel with free-to -play
offerings
4 Pees
0
Casino
O
0
Sporn
SUPERc,
Source Company flings
Both Stars and Sky have track records of building leading platforms, and we believe TSG can leverage
Sky's technology software for expanding its sports betting offering in new markets. In addition to Sky,
TSG recently completed two acquisitions in Australia (CrownBet and William Hill Australia), providing a
top 3 sportsbook in one of the largest regulated online gaming markets. In our view, the combination of
core Stars, Sky Betting, and the Australian assets creates online gaming's premier growth company.
We now have an online gaming powerhouse with poker, casino, and sports betting; a missing piece is the
ability to operate across the United States, potentially the world's largest online gaming market. Which
brings us back to the theme of regulatory change. On May 14th, the US Supreme Court declared the
Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act ("PASPA") unconstitutional, overturning a regulation which
prevented states from legalizing sports betting. We have been tracking this case since earlier in the year,
and in Honeycomb fashion, we had our analysis honed and our buy program ready to activate.
The consensus view on PASPA beneficiaries has centered around regional casinos and gaming suppliers.
We take a differentiated view and believe the best way to play this theme is through TSG. We see the future
of sports betting as people placing bets on mobile phones while socially watching games, not while sitting
in physical sportsbook bars in states outside of Nevada. Global online gaming is a $40bn market, growing
at a +8% CAGR, benefitting from a secular shift to digital and mobile consumption. Sports betting represents
over 50% of the online gaming market. We believe the online sports betting segment is well-positioned for
the continued shift from offline to online gaming.
4
Ccedidonbai Not for ['muttton
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
660
$50
$40
$30
$20
5-
Total Online Gross Gambling Revenue (Sbn)
2015.2020E
CAGR = 8%
Sts
I
$19
7015 7016 ➢01/ 201E* 201-n 2020E
• Sports Betting • Casino
San: Conon Filings. IQ Carding Capita
As a pure-play online operator, TSG is well-suited for this vision of the future. TSG has brand recognition
with Pokerstars and has a toehold in the US, already operating in the regulated online poker gaming market
in New Jersey. When PokerStars entered the NJ market in 1Q16 in partnership with Resorts Casino, they
quickly ramped from 0% to a consistent 40% market share, displacing incumbents including Caesars and
Borgata. PokerStars is well-known in the US, as customers played on the platform until Pokerstars exited
the US market in 2011 (for regulatory reasons). The very rapid ramp up in market share shows that
consumers who used PokerStars in the US pre-2011 had a desire to return to the platform. The NJ case
study increases our confidence in TSG's ability to capitalize on the emerging US opportunity. If states
legalize additional forms of online gaming along with sports betting, this would create even greater upside
potential for TSG. We do not assume any meaningful uplift in our model from US sports betting. continuing
to view this as a call option and a potential 2020+ growth driver.
Pokerstars entered
the NJ Online Poker
market in 1016.
By 2O16 they obtained
leading market share,
and have since
maintained steady
40% share.
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
55% 53%
NJ Online Poker Market Share
66% 50%
21% 30% 29% 31% 32% 32% 31%
1015 2015 3015 40E 1016 2016 3016 4016 1017 2017 3017 4017 1018
■ TSG PokerStars/ Resorts World ■ 888 / Caesars PartyPoker / Borgata
Source: Now Jersey Gaming COMITd$SIOn
6
Ccnfidonlial - Not For Distnbuban
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
We see TSG generating over $3bn of revenue and over $1bn of EBITDA in 2019. Post-2019, we forecast
a +13% 3-year revenue CAGR, a +21% EBITDA CAGR, and +36% FCF/share CAGR. By 2022, we forecast
TSG with revenue of nearly $5bn and EBITDA of over $2bn. In addition to secular top line growth and share
gains, TSG benefits from high incremental margins and free cash flow conversion as an online-only
operator.
16.000
16000
$000
$3,000
$2.000
11000
TSG Revenue (Sinn)
2017 20
181ill
Source: Com03nY fangs. Honeycomb estimates
TSG EBITDA ($mn) TSG FCF per Share
12.500 $7.00
$6.00
$2.000
21% CAGR $5.00 +36%CAGR
$1.500 $4.00
"DOG Woo
1600
2017 206E 2019E 2020E
$2.00
$100
2017 10181 20/9E 2020) 20111 10121
TSG trades at 10x Honey estimated 2020 EBITDA and 12x 2020 FCF/share despite higher than 30% FCF
growth. Compared to its peers, it has much higher growth and an undemanding valuation. On a discounted
cash flow basis, we see over 100% upside from the current share price.
While TSGs forward FFITDA multi
14.0x
12 Ox
10 0<
8 Ox
GO<
4.0x
20x
00c
Price to 2020 FCF/Share EV to 2020 EBITDA
p I p Source Bloomberg. COmOany Filings. Honeycomb EstimateS
240x
210x
18 Cu
120x
901
601
30x
0.0c
2 J 0
6 ffi
We see a positive event path unfolding, including further US state announcements and upside to Sky
synergy estimates. We are excited to be invested in The Stars Group and have expressed this view by
making TSG a substantial Top 5 holding for Honeycomb.
6
Confidential - Not for Clistntuton
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
Private Investment Update
We are pleased to share that Spotify's direct listing was completed in O2. Publicly listed shares commenced
trading on the New York Stock Exchange April 3id under the ticker symbol SPOT. This marked
Honeycomb's first successful realization of a crossover opportunity (i.e., late stage private-to-public
investments).
Thank you to our partners who participated in our first private vehicle, Honeycomb Ventures I, which has
been realized after delivering a +75% net fund return in 10 months. We expect Spotify to continue being
an important position in our Flagship fund.
For those Flagship fund investors who opted-in to our private investment strategy, side pocket activity in
O2 included an investment in Ant Financial, a leading payments platform in China. Side pocket investors
also benefitted from the Spotify crossover opportunity and subsequent realization.
Over the course of our team's investing career, we have learned to be entrepreneurial and create our own
opportunities. We believe we have developed the framework, network and skill set to continue to identify
winning crossover opportunities. You should know and expect that the bar is very high before we call on
you for capital. We see several exciting opportunities and will be in touch shortly as we finalize our plans.
Business Update
In O2 we hired a Controller to join our team, which grows our firm to 10 employees. We remain committed
to recruiting top talent as we continue to grow.
This month we celebrate our second anniversary. We reflect on the journey that has brought us closer to
the longer-term goals we established at the outset while delivering strong performance.
The collaborative Honeycomb team has accomplished our initial goals of launching the Flagship fund, hiring
key talent, deploying capital into private growth equity opportunities, and building a creative culture that
rewards integrity and entrepreneurship. According to industry prime brokerage data, we launched in the
worst period for hedge fund asset raising since 2008 but started with initial capital of -$200m following our
institutional launch. Our firm AUM is now $700m+. The Flagship fund (ex-privates) has delivered +36%
net returns inception to date to our institutional launch partners. Along the way we also launched three
separate co-investment vehicles to invest in Spotify: Honeycomb Ventures I, II and III, which have delivered
net fund returns of 75% (realized), 40% (unrealized as of June 30), and 27% (unrealized as of June 30),
since their respective inception dates.
It has been fun and full of challenges such as Brexit at our launch, or more recently the February 10% stock
market correction, which like many drawdowns are to be expected and should be viewed as opportunities.
The best part is that we are extremely excited for the future. The world is changing very rapidly; we believe
the long and short opportunities we are identifying today are even better than two years ago when we
started Honeycomb.
Closing Remarks
We want Honeycomb to be known for our repeatable and scalable investment process, common-sense
approach to ideation, flexible mindset, and for delivering consistent organic growth. We believe all of this
can only continue to be developed by being aligned with our capital partners. We have been careful to
7
Ccedidonbai Not foe Omintvon
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
construct our partnership with terrific day one investors, and have strategically turned away capital that may
not have been a good fit longer-term.
We thank you for your partnership and look forward to continuing to build something special together.
Best regards,
The Honeycomb Team
CONTACT INFORMATION:
Dominique Ahumada
Head of Capital Partnerships & Talent
(646) 883-1128
8
Ccedidonbai Not Io( Oisinvon
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
Endnotes & Important Legal Disclosure
'I-loner-Omb Master Fund LP (tie 'Master Fund') includes all or substantially as inveslible assets from its feeder Mids.
Honeycomb Partners LP ('Domestic
Fund').
Honeycomb intermediate Fund LP and Honeycomb Onshore Fund Ltd. (collectively. the 'Funds'). However. investors are 
expected to invest at the feeder kind not
at the Master Fund level. The reflected returns assume a representative investor invested in the Domestic Fund in each 
of (I) the Class A interests that are
subject
to a management fee of 2% and incentive allocation ol 20% and 00 the Class B interests that are subject to a management 
fee of 1.5% and an incentive atocation
ot 20%. 'Net reflects the performance of the Domestic Feld net of management lee. expenses and incentive allocation. 
'Gross' reflects the performance of the
Domestic Fund net of management fee and expenses. but gross of incentive allocation. Returns assume the reinvestment of 
all dividends. interest. income and
profits. The management fee and expense figwes used for performance calculations are pro-rated foe the performance 
period. and incentive allocation calcLiabons
reflect an investment since the Domestic Fund's July 1.2016 institutional launch date. The reflected rains assume 
participation by the Glass A and B
representative
investor in 'new issue' investments and no participation in side pockets. Individual results will vary (potentially 
considerably) depending on. among other
things.
investing al the offshore feeder fund rather than the Domestic Fund level. new issue eligibility. side pocket 
participation. the liming of
contributions/subscriptions and
wandrawalsfredemptions. different fee arrangements and any accanulated loss carry-forwards. This performance infatuation
is estimated and Honeycomb Asset
Management LP (the -Investment Manager') makes no representations as to the accuracy or completeness thereof. and such 
information should not be relied upon
for investment related or other purposes. The performance information is based on unaudited information as of the date 
hereof and S subject to change as actual
performance for the relevant period is finalized. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
Pus investor letter is confidential. is intended only for the person to whom it has been provided and under no 
circumstances may a city be shown. copied.
transmitted. or otherwise given to any person other than the authorized recipient without the prior written aonsent of 
the Investment Manager. Except as
otherwise
specifically set forth Main. the information in this letter is as 01 the date hereof. Notwithstanding anything to the 
contrary heron. each recipient to this
document
rand each employee. representative. or recipient) may disclose to any and all persons. without limitation of any kind 
the lax treatment and tax structure of the
Funds
any of thee transeC0CIIS. and all materials of any kind (Including opinions or other lax analyses) relating to such tax 
treatment and tax structure. it being
understood
that lax treatment' and 'tax structure' do not include the name a klenblying information of a Fund a a Vansacbon.
The distribution of the information contained herein may be restricted in certain jurisdictions, accordingly. it is the 
responsibility of any prospective
kweslor to satisfy
itself as to compliance with relevant laws and regulation. The reopieni and Its professional advisors. by aaoepting 
delivery of this docenent. agree to keep
confidential all matters herein and to return this document promptly upon the request of the Investment Manager.
The information contained herein is preliminary and is provided for discussion peposes dilly. This infatuations oily a 
summary of key information. it is not
compete
and does not contain certain material Information about the Funds. including important conflict of interests disclosures
and risk lectors associated Mb an
Investment
in the Funds and is subject to change without notice.
TM document has been suppled for discussion purposes only, and therefore no representation or warranty is made. whether 
expressed or steed, by the fl uids
or the Investment Manager or any of their partners. employees, members. or agents as to the accuracy or completeness of 
the information provided herein. This
document may be amended at any time. There is no express or implied obligation to update you of any changes to the 
information set forth herekt The information
contained herein should not be relied upon as the basis of any investment decision or for any other purpose.
TM document is not mended to be. nor should it be construed or used as an offer to sell, or a solicitation of any offer 
to buy. interests or shares in the
Funds. No
offer or solicitation may be made prior to the deavery of a deMtive offering memorandum (the WiernorandLin") which will 
contain additional information about the
Fulda. including disclosures relating to risk factors and conflicts of interest. The information contained hers, does 
not consider the particular investment
objectives
or financial circumstances 01 any specific person who may receive it and is Qualified in its entirety by the 
Atemorandion. In the event of any disaepancies
between
the information contained herein and the Memorandum. the Memorandum will control. The information herein is not Intended
to provide. and should not be relied
upon for, accounting. and legal or tax advice or investment recommendations. Each recipient of this document should make
an independent investigation as to at
matters concerning an investment in the Fettle or otherwise described herein, including consulting with its own tax, 
legal, accounting or other advisors about
the
matters concerning an investment in the Funds or otherwise discussed herein. In making an investment decision. kweslors 
must rely upon their own exanvnab0n 01
the Funds and the terms of the offering. including the merits and risks involved.
An investment in the Funds may not be matelots for al investors. An investment in the Funds will be suitable only for 
certain financially
sophisticated investors who meet certain eligibilty requirements. have no need for immediate 'quickly in their 
investment. and can bear the flee of an
investment in
the Funds for an extended period of time.
Investing in financial markets involves a substantial degree of risk. There can be no assurance that the investment 
objectives described herein will be
achieved.
Investment tosses may otter. and investors could lose some or all thew investment. No guarantee or representation is 
made that the Fulda investment program.
Including. without Mutation. its investment objeaktes. diversification strategies. or risk monitoring goals. will be 
successful, and investment results may vary
substantially over lone. Nothing herein is intended to imply that the Funds' investment methodology may be considered 
"conservative". 'safe'. 'risk tree' or
'risk
averse. Economic, market and other conditions could also cause the Funds to alter thee investment objectives, guidelines
and restrictions.
Getters information contained in this document (including, in particular. the discussion of investment themes contained 
herein) constitutes lavaud.looking
statements'. which can be identified using forward-looking terminology such as 'may'. NAP. 'should". 'expect'. 
'anticipate". larger. "prOject'. 'estimate".
Intend'.
'continue' or 'believe' or the negatives ihereol or other variations thereon or comparable terminology. Due to various 
risks and uncertainties and assumptions
made
by the kwestment Manager. actual events or results or the actual performance of the Funds may Offer materially from 
those retlectod or contemplated in such
fonvard-looking statements.
The estimates. investment strategies. investment themes. and views expressed in this document are based upon past or 
current market conditions and/or data and
infatuation provided by unaffiliated third pasties (which has not been independently verified) and is subject to change 
without notice. In addition. many ol the
views
expressed herein are sikpctIve andf or reflect the Investment Manager's estimates or keecasts on future performance and 
market events. Such statements should
not be underst0od to be predictions or guarantees of any particular outcome, or of the Investment Manager's commitment 
to invest in any particular industry,
sector.
region, or cottony. In particular. you should be snare that any new technologies or products discussed herein are 
unproven, may never develop as the kwesitnent
Manager anticipates. could be superseded by other technologies, and are subject to signeicant investment risks.
Past performance is not indicative nor a guarantee of future returns. Each issuer discussed as a bnigishon contributor 
or detractor from performance was one of
the
top 10 lionsfshort contributors or detractors from performance for the quarter and was selected based on being a 
representative driver of performance for the
quarter.
Honeycomb Offshore Fund Ltd. the 'Offshore Fund') has not been approved for distribution in or from Switzerland by the 
Swiss Financial Market Supervisory
Authority. Asa result. the Offshore Fund's shares may only be offered or distributed to qualfied investors within the 
meaning of Swiss law. The Representatwe of
the Offshore Fund in Svatzeriand is Bastions Partners Office SA with registered office at Route de GMne 61A. 1208 
Geneva. Switzerland. The Paying Agent in
Switzerland is Banque Heritage SA. with registered office al Route de Cher* 61. 1208 Geneva. Switzerland. The place of 
performance and jurisdiction tor shares
of
the Offshore Fund distributed in or from Switzerland are at the registered office of the Representative.
9
Confoential - Not for Distribution
EFTA00810734 (Jmail)
 [property] Alberto Pinto Cabinet Plant work order for master bathroom
(date: 2018-07-31)
PLANT

WORK ORDER Number: 2 R1
Date: 2018.07.31
Contract Date: N/A
Location: 9 East 71st Street, New York, NY
Project: Master Bathroom 3-18 at 3rd Floor General Plant Construction LLC
9 East 71st Street Contractor: 181 Broadway, 5th Floor
New York. NY New York, NY 10007
Owner: The Private Residence Designer: Cabinet Alberto Pinto
9 East 71st Street
New York. NY 75002 Paris (France)
The Work Order as follows:
Preliminary Budget for Bath Tub Alcove and Dome ceiling in Master
Bathroom 3-18 at 3rd floor:
Protection: $5,255
F/I Furnish and install Temporary protection on floors and stair steps
(heavy protection) at 1st floor, 2nd floor, 3rd floor, Master Bathroom 3-18,
and the elevator: reinstallation of protection, removals and discard
all protection materials after completion of work;
Demolition: $4,600
RIO Removals of the existing bathtub with stone slab tub deck.
(3) aprons, and (3) stone saddles in Bath Tub Alcove
including of carting
"' Existing stone wall tiles above bathtub deck and stone tile jambs
to remain per the walk through notes dated 07.12.2018.
Plumbing: $5,900
F/I Disconnection & cap the exiting bathtub, new plumbing rough-in
cold, hot water, waste, vent lines for new specified bathtub. new
shot off valves for hot and cold water riser, fiberglass insulation
in Bath Tub Alcove
I/O Installation only of new bathtub. drain, (2) overflow, thermostatic
control, hand shower in Bath Tub Alcove
NIC New booster pumps and associated works or upgrade
the existing booster pumps
Plumbing Fixture (Furnish Only), Allowance:
F/O (1) Bath tub ref B10-8550 glossy white finish by THG (to be $10,282
installed under the stone top)
F/O (2) Cover plates to be used as a water spout ref 816-K103 / incl.
K104, glossy nickel finish by THG
F/O (1) Waste cap and over-flow drain / waste knob. glossy incl.
nickel finish by THG
*A' F/O (1) Aero Thermostatic control valve trim with metal cross $2,000
lever handle (ref M12-15EN16EM ?) glossy nickel finish
F/O (2) Aero control volume trim cross handles (ref AEVC57) $1,243
glossy nickel finish (for stop handle and 2 ways
handle, hand shower or bath tub recessed cover plates spouts)
F/O F/O (1) Aero recessed hand shower (ref AEHS25), $2,226
glossy nickel finish
"' PENDING of Waterworks / Aero hard quote for plumbing
fixture that indicated 'A'
"' PENDING of final approved specifications for Plumbing fixtures
1 / 4
WO #2 R1 continued ...
Carpentry::
'A' Allowance for patching of the existing floor and walls to get $4.420
new stone tub deck for new bathtub in Bath Tub Alcove
F/I Wood blocking for new tub deck $650
I/0 Reinstallation of the existing framed mirror on stone tile wall $570
F/I Miscellaneous work between trades in Master Bathroom 3-18 $1.000
Stone slab work (nn stone work on walls above bathtub deck & jambs): $50.621
F/I Floor preparation, new soundproofing on floor, & new waterproofing
on floor extend 6" up perimeter walls & overlap existing
F/I Furnish, fabrication and Installation of new Travertine stone slabs:
2" thick tub deck with cut out for an undermount tub with custom
edges, (3) 3/4" thick aprons, & (3) 3/4" thick saddles; and 1-7/8"
height splash with ogee edge above stone tub deck
F/I Replacement of vertical stone and the stone shelf to match existing
to install new wall mounted thermostatic control for new bathtub
Allowance for patching of the existing wall tiles above new
bathtub deck in Bath Tub Alcove, TBD after removals
Alternate is Not Included in Base Price:
ALT 1 ADD: Allowance for Furnish and Installation of new Stone tile
walls (above new bathtub) and jambs (Full height) to match
existing including of removals of stone wall tiles & jambs,
cement boards on walls, patching of walls and jambs, new
waterproofing on walls, new cement boards on walls, and
re-painting of the existing ceiling in Bath Tub Alcove,
Allowance for Stone tile materials $40 psf
"' Existing metal studs on walls and existing ceiling to remain
Note to ALT: The duration for construction will be extended by 2 - 3 weeks
for Stone tile work noted in ALT 1
Painting of Dome ceiling:
F/I Primer coat on the existing Dome ceiling from the cornice to the edge
of the surrounding frieze of the opening in Master Bathroom 3-18
including of scaffolding
F/I Two (2) painters during 2 weeks as assistants of the Artist:
$650 per day x 2 men x 10 work days including of scaffolding
in Master Bathroom 3-18
NIC New Decorative painting for the ceiling with a Dome shape by Others
NIC Re-paint the existing walls, trim, and woodwork in Master Bathroom 3-18
$70,644
Estimated General Requirements for a 6-weeks period:
- Project Manager: 20 hours
- Project Supervision / daily cleaning: 200 hours
- Driver: 8 hours
- Estimating / purchasing: 20 hours
- Reimbursement of Direct Expenses for 6 weeks including of
(1) Negative Air pressure and HEPA filter during work and Caning
- Final professional cleaning in Master Bathroom 3-18 and Elevator only
Constniction Sc - ila
The Order of THG's bathtub, tub spout / filler is 10 - 12 weeks
The Order of Waterworks / Aero Thermostatic Control valves is 14 - 16 weeks
The Order of Stone materials is 8 weeks
The estimated duration for on-site construction is appr. 6 weeks
including of Protection, Demolition, Plumbing & Fixture, Carpentry,
Stone work, Painting (prime coat & assistants), and Final cleaning
in work areas only.
$1,500
$8.840
$13.000
$38.100
214
WO #2 R1 continued ...
Exclusion;
Daily dismantle and re-install temporary protection.
Miscellaneous Touchups.
Electrical work and Lighting fixtures.
Correction of existing violations or site conditions (i.e. existing plumbing, etc.).
Job phasing.
Mock-ups.
Overtime for Contractor's labor and its subcontractors.
Union labor will not be provided on this job.
Department of Buildings plan filing, applications, building permits, fees.
Controlled Inspections.
Integrated drawings.
Engineering services (MEP).
Removing and replacing building utilities.
Chopping and/or channeling structural floors or ceilings.
Performance or payment bonds.
Environmental / hazardous materials testing and monitoring.
Removals of asbestos on floor, walls, ceilings, ductwork, pipe insulations.
Notpc / flualifiratinnc
- WO #2 RI is based on regular work hours.
- Deposit is 50%.
- Moving Arts and furniture will be provided by Owner.
- Temporary toilet and sink during construction is assuming to use
the existing bathroom in Basement.
- Certificate of Capital Improvement supposed to be signed by the Owner.
- Plant's General liability insurance minimum limits are $1 million per
occurrence, $2 million aggregate per year, with a $5 million umbrella.
Any higher limits, umbrella policy, OCP or other policies requested will
need to be quoted individually and will provided if requested at additional
cost to Owner.
- Plant's Automobile Insurance policy limits are $1 million per occurrence,
$1 million aggregate per yew and $1 million property damage. Any higher
limits or any additional coverage requested will be provided if requested
at additional cost to Owner.
- The scope of work is limited to the items described above.
- This WO is valid for 60 days from date on page one.
Documents:
- The rendering with the new bath tub that has been approved by the Client
by e-mail at 01.29.2018.
- Pictures of the existing by e-mail at 01.29.2018.
- Location plan by e-mail at 01.29.2018.
- Pictures of the ceiling shape and existing state (blue painting) by e-mail at 01.29.2018.
- Two (2) e-mails dated 01.29.2018 from the Designer.
- The Designer's e-mails dated 06.26.2018, 06.27.2018 (with pictures), 06.28.2018
(with cut sheets for new bathtub & dimensions), 06.29.2018 (with CAD plan, pictures,
cut sheets for new bathtub).
- The walk through notes dated 07.12.2018.
- The Designers e-mails dated 06.26.2018, 06.27.2018, 07.17.2018, 07.20.2018,
07.25.2018, 07.26.2018, and 07.27.2018 (with cut sheet).
- Revised plan for Master Bathroom 3-18 dated 07.25.2018.
3 / 4
WO #2 R1 continued ...
KEY:
F/I Furnish and Install
I/O Install Only
RIO Remove Only
F/O Furnish Only
NIC Not In Contract
TBD To Be Determined (NIC)
"' Note
*A' Allowance
ALT Alternate (NIC)
Subtotal $150,208
Overhead & Profit $22,531
Insurance $4,318
Total $177,056
Contingency 5% (NOT included in above "Total") $8,853
NOT VALID UNTIL SIGNED
Owner's Representative
Designer
General Contractor
414
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Steve Bannon [republican] Epstein bestie, Trump campaign manager, Brock Pierce biz partner (IGN), memecoin grifter [cryptadamus] 
                                                                             Eduardo Teodorani [business] Italian, CNH Industrial 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01617527 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage from Eduardo Teodorani screenshot(s), see quote: "interesting pussy than Fl in Milano interesting pussy as well"
(inferred timestamp: 2018-08-05 16:08:29)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
TEODORANI Eduardo
TE
TEODORANI Eduardo
2018/06/24
Sorry Davina she got food poison and I still here I call you tomorrow.
TE 04:40:28 pm
2018/06/25
TEODORANI Eduardo
1212 5333739
777
03:14:04 pm
1212 5333739
Do you need anything
09:36:40 am
Davina got so sick that I had to hire a plane to go to London to his doc
TE 09:52:33 am
1212 5333739
Sorry to hear. . hope she feels better
09:53:41 am
Maybe 8
09:53:55 am
TEODORANI Eduardo
Thankyou
09:58:10 am
So sorry not being able to see you next time I will come alone
10:13:12 am
You are really a good friend Thankyou for asking
TE 10:34:36 am
2018/07/02
1212 5333739
TEODORANI Eduardo
Yes Thankyou
TE 06:43:35 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Very sad she was a good friend
TE 10:17:48 am
2018/07/18
2018/07/21
Better?
06:29:58 pm
1212 5333739
Sorry yo hear about Annabelle
12:42:42 am
To
12:42:44 am
1212 5333739
Im in Paris for the week
09:06:27 pm
•
•
•
2018/07/22
TEODORANI Eduardo
In Italy I will try to come to see you
TE 05:59:42 am
2018/07/26
TEODORANI Eduardo
Sorry I think I can't come I will see you in September.
04:05:26 pm
We are facing some big changes and I am in torino in family meetings
TE 04:06:30 pm
1212 5333739
Understood
04:08:29 pm
2018/08/05
TEODORANI Eduardo
http://www.ow6.rassegnestampa.it/Exor/PDF/2018/2018-08-
05/2018080539731618.pdf
02:56:15 pm
Have somebody translate it for you.
Very interesting
Sent an attachment
Filename: 2018080539731618.pdf
Path: 2018080539731618.pdf
Size: 971 KB
Type: application/pdf
TE 02:56:16 pin
1212 5333739
Steve Bannon's Big Plan For Europe Has Some Big Flaws
There's little evidence for the bombastic former Trump adviser's claim that he can
dominate next year's European Parliament elections.
headshot
By Akbar Shahid Ahmed. Can this really be his name? t:
03:08:47 pm
Sounds like SNL
03:09:09 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Yes
03:09:19 pm
I am in Gstaad then Tuscany which I hope you can once interesting pussy than Fl in
Milano interesting pussy as well
TE 03:10:49 pm
✓ Read
1212 5333739
Nice
03:16:24 pm
2018/09/10
1212 5333739
Im in Paris
09:56:19 am
✓ Sent
╔═══════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 James Stewart [journalist] New York Times reporter 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01614950 (Jmail)
 [tech] SMS log of conversation with James Stewart see quote: "Musk - fun"
(date: 2018-08-17)
Platform: SMS Timezone: UTC+0000
James Stewart O Unknown
n
2018/08/17
Unknovm
•
Good work- interview, jeffrey
05:25:27 am
When Beethoven was having a rough period I wonder whether his audience thought
about bringing in a ceo to help:)
10:15:49 am
Fyi - I personally like this - as it becomes apparent that he is unable to form intent :)
03:50:51 pm
2018/08/19
Unknown
How was the opera
12:57:14 pm
Not sure it was money for art or art of money;)
12:59:56 pm
Recall - happiness cant buy money
01:01:10 pm
James Stewart
Loved it. Beautiful, intimate setting. Presentation was a big success.
04:09:07 pm
O n
O
Unknown
James Stewart
Fascinating.
08:35:46 pm
2018/08/20
Great. Does Thursday work Woody
11:34:34 pm
Unknown
7
03:40:24 pm
Woody changed dinner to Friday if that works
O 05:44:56 pm en
O n
2018/09/07
2018/09/09
2018/09/24
Unknown
Musk - fun
05:15:24 pm
Unknown
Sorry to have been right on moonves
08:27:57 pm O
0
Unknovm
Want to come by for coffee this week?
08:17:54 pm O en
2018/09/26
James Stewart
Sure. Tomorrow or Friday afternoon?
03:31:39 pm
Unknown
James Stewart
I'll be in your vicinity Friday about 2:30.
03:33:15 pm
James Stewart
SEC just sued Musk.
08:30:59 pm
2018/09/27
2018/09/28
Your choice
03:32:08 pm
Unknown
Ok great
03:37:03 pm
Unknown
Yup
08:31:20 pm
Unknown
most people believe the middle easterners. . bluster . bloviating bragging. . its their
language. . elon just wasnt fluent in it.
10:02:08 am
O
O
O in
James Stewart
On my way...
07:14:16 pm
Confirming 230 t
01:59:23 pm
Unknown
https://int.nyt.com/data/documenthelper/178-kavanaugh-clinton-monica-
lewin/9b9a46ab055ee2458fd5/optimized/full.pdf#page=1
09:29:40 pin
2018/09/29
Unknoym
Cedric villani -macrons cabinet . Compare to ours
12:59:29 am
Bannon will sit with you snd discuss the subject
10:23:16 pin
2018/09/30
2019/04/08
You wanted
10:23:22 pin
Unknown
You will hear an interesting twist
10:42:24 am
Unknoym
James- any interest in doing a piece on me warts and all?
O 08:17:58 pm
O n
n
n
James Stewart
I'm on book leave....am hibernating until I finish. Should emerge around June 1.
11:57:03 pm
✓ Read
2019/04/09
Unknown
Ok great
12:08:02 am
✓ Sent
0
EFTA01619579 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage from Deepak Chopra screenshot(s)
(inferred date: 2018-08-21)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
•
Deepak
Deepak
D
2018/07/15
My family is here almost all summer
Just FYI
My son in law 49 years old is a venture capitalist
Mike Milken and son put on 100 million $ into his fund
You might enjoy meeting him ( can't talk about girls )
Maybe we can visit tomorrow?
D 01:20:41 pm
Deepak
I'm traveling to Atlanta onTuesday
D 01:50:20 pm
Deepak
How about 730 PM ?
D 01:55:04 pm
Tues
01:45:38 pm
Late Monday I arrive at 5 pm
01:50:45 pm
I will fly in early. If 4 works
01:57:08 pm
•
•
•
Deepak
4 PM at your place ?
We can do it
D 02:03:56 pin
Deepak
Thank you!
It will be interesting
Ok to bring my son in law ?
D 02:05:46 pm
Deepak
Let
02:16:31 pm
See you 4 PM
02:16:42 pm
Tomorrow
O 02:16:49 pm
2018/07/16
Deepak
10 min
In traffic
D 08:07:17 pin
done
02:04:03 pm
Bring as many as you Ike
02:05:59 pm
•
•
2018/07/17
Deepak
Thanks for yesterday
Sumant loved how you think A
O 01:31:08 pm
2018/08/12
Deepak
How are you ?
Judging by his tweets Krauss seems ok
I'm going to a retreat in England
When are you in NYC ?
D 06:05:58 pin
Deepak
I should be back by then
D 06:15:37 pin
2018/08/20
Deepak
Speak now ?
D 12:38:14 pm
Ok
08:10:41 pm
23?
06:14:50 pm
you?
06:14:59 pm
•
•
2018/08/21
Can you do early Thursday instead! I want to see u
05:45:20 pm
06:54:46 pm
Deepak
I'm doing a podcast v early with Michio Kaku and then flying to California
Let's plan leisurely in NYCSept onwards - I'm in and out
A
0 06:55:09 pm
Ok
06:55:23 pm
Deepak
Will stay in close touch
Much to discuss
D 08:13:43 pm
Yes. Look forward to it
08:14:15 pm
V Sent
Deepak
D 08:15:23 pm
V Read
EFTA01618483 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2018-08-21 00:28:06)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
I am here :)
09:19:33 pm
2018/03/29
2018/03/31
Sneaky happy Good Friday and Passover!
I always forget that you are jew tt
12:38:11 am
What time are you leaving to Paris tomorrow?
12:44:04 am
12:44:30 am
1212 5333739
tyhx'
12:42:26 am
1212 5333739
6 am
12:44:17 am

• For a long? Will i see you soon?
12:4S:03 air
12:45:35 am
I hope it's not like you left to PB
12:45:4/ am
1212 5333739
10 days'
12:45:17 am
1212 5333739
paris
09:16:33 am
•
•
2018/04/13
Went to dr wearing new shoes
08:00:04 pm

• Are you here this weekend?
08:05:37 pm
2018/04/14
•
•
07:30:24 pm
2018/04/17
Hi sneaky,
Do you know what happening with Is he in the country?
All week trying to call him both personal and office number doesn't pick up only a
voice mail. I sent email also a silence...
08:21:44 pm
1212 5333739
I will send message
08:22:27 pm
He actually never answered to any of my calls and emails previously only when you
connected us via a conference call so might be just ignoring me
08:22:44 pm
Ok, thank you!!!
08:22:59 pm
2018/04/23
•
•
Sneaky, did you have fun with
01:35:35 am
2018/04/26
:)
Sneaky,
Do you need anything else? Is ok if I go home now?
I have a policy workshop event tomorrow and I have to be at 8 am in office ••
02:11:44 am
09:13:27 pm
2018/04/30
2018/07/08
•
•
•
So you asked me to phone you back so that you have enough time to block my calls a
07:40:20 pm
2018/07/09
07:15:31 pm
2018/07/19
Hi sneaky,
I will come around 7:45-8pm is that's ok?
08:57:33 pm
Great, thank you!
09:01:05 pm
1212 5333739
ok
09:00:13 pm
2018/07/31
Sent an attachment
Filename: IMG_6313.mov
Path: IMG_6313.mov
Size: 4 MB
Type: video/quicktime
03:26:41 am
1212 5333739
come see me
10:37:14 am
Good morning sneaky!
How are you feeling?
Around 9:15-9:30 is ok?
11:18:13 am
1212 5333739
ok
11:18:50 am
Sneaky sorry 7 min late. Went to a bakery and its a line here!
01:29:25 pm
1212 5333739
no worry
01:29:36 pm
✓ Sent
Thank yo!IP
01:37:53 pm
•
•
Sneaky could you call me if you have a chance
08:02:55 pm
2018/08/07
Sent an attachment
Filename: IMG_6431.mov
Path: IMG_6431.mov
Size: 684 KB
Type: video/quicktime
11:23:21 am
My morning cup of coffee —
11:25:12 am
2018/08/18
Can't wait to see you sneaky!!! :•
12:28:06 am
2018/08/21
Russians have some propaganda on you! IP et:
e 07:47:36 pm
V Read
╔════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Irina Pozhidaeva [russia] mother of Svetlana Pozhidaeva 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01297974 (Jmail)
 [girls] DOJ queries OffshoreLeaks database for Svetlana Pozhidaeva's mother
(inferred date: 2018-08-22)
Search results for ""Irina I ICIJ Offshore Leaks Database Page I of 3
OFFSHORE LEAKS DATABASE
by The International Consortium of Investigative Journalists
ABOUT DOWNLOAD SUPPORT US
We believe this data should be publicly-available, and we need your x
support to keep it that way.
Make a donation and help us keep it free, online and accessible.
"Irina Pozhidaeva"
Search results for ""
SEARCH
Offshore Entities (0) Officers (0) Intermediaries (0) Addresses (0) Others (0)
No results found
ALTER BY DATA SOURCE
r
All sources gir
FILTER BY COUNTRY
I All countries
ALTER BY JURISDICTION

• Antieua and Barbuda
n.th
A1_00061729
littps://offshoreleaks.icij.org/sea rectlfift42F L .. 8/22/2018
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.  ) DB-SDNY-0024554
Search results for Offshore Leaks Database Page 2 of 3
The ICU Offshore Leaks Database is licensed under the Omen. CiiitobAisp Licc,nae and contents under
creotim...c.piimpos Mtribi.itigp.:Stlar.gAli ',A I icense. Always cite the International Consortium of
Investigative Journalists when using this data. You can download a raw copy of the database !ig.r?..
SUPPORT US
Help ICIJ investigate
ABOUT US
The International Consortium of Investigative Journalists is a global network of
more than 190 investigative journalists in more than 65 countries who collaborate on
in-depth investigative stories.
Learn more
SUPPORT US
Independent, fearless investigative journalism is expensive and ICIJ relies on your
support.
Help protect global societies from unprecedented threats by supporting independent
investigative journalism.
Become a sponsor
INTERNATIONAL CONSORTIUM
OF INVESTIGATIVE JOURNALISTS
Imps://offshoreleaks.icij.org/searc orDENT2R
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.tithels.a(b)
Y_GM_00061730
ke... 8/22/2018
DB-SDNY-0024555
Search results for =CU Offshore Leaks Database Page 3 of 3
910 17th Street NW Suite 410
Washington DC 20006 USA
contact@icij.org
Download
Partners
Support us
The Panama Papers
Secrecy For Sale
Evicted and Abandoned
Fatal Extraction
LinkedIn
Twitter
© 2018 - The International Consortium of Investigative Journalists. All rights reserved.
https://offshoreleaks.icij.org/searcrtbitneFI.B  orDENTFA
CONFIDENTIAL—PURSUANT TO FED. R.
NY_GM_00061731
&e... 8/22/2018
DB-SDNY-0024556
EFTA00811866 (Jmail)
 [money] valuations of Epstein's investments
(date: 2018-08-31)
Valuation Report
8/31/2018
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - AUGUST 31, 2018
7/31/18 8/31/18 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 92,429,110 101,512,764 9,083,654
Fixed Income 69,199,199 61,437,427 (7,761,772)
Equities 131,074,081 141,426,424 10,352,343
Equity ETF's 874,380 875,160 780
Options 122,392 168,553 46,161
Hedge Funds 99,608,897 100,343,432 734,535
Investments 52,318,855 52,492,187 173,332
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 22,525,000 22,525,000 -
Loans Receivable 16,039,472 16,039,472 -
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 9,900,000 9,900,000 -
Loan Payable - BJAV 30 500 000 30 500 000 -
Total Assets 463,591,386 476,220,419 12,629,033
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
Sold 4,000,000 Royal Bank of Scotland Preferred at 95.85 at DB 4,759,908
Sold 100,000 AMLP @ 11.24 at IB 1,119,515
Sold CD Projekt - Poland 1,084,774
Sold 1,000,000 Service Master Bonds @ 98.375 at DB 1,004,884
Sold 1,000,000 Plains All American Pipeline 6.125% preferred @ 98.5 ML 985,000
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions 838,000
Sold 50,000 AMLP @ 11.23 @ IB 559,713
Sold 40,000 SGMO @ 13.83 at TD 552,614
Sold 500,000 Plains All American 6 125% preferred @ 98.5 MS 499,725
Sold 43,000 AMLP @ 11.30 at TD I 485,916
Sold 1,200,000 Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 @ 87 at DB 412,499
Sold 5,000 TSG @ 31.92 MS 159,417
Sold 4,995 Seaspan Preferred @ 25.04 a IB 122,717
Sold 50,000 SQBG @ 2.12 MS 103,886
Humanity Plus-Gratitude (50,000)
Edge Foundation - Enhanced 25k & Gratitude 35k (60,000)
LSJ - Cherrington 5500 (121,800)
Miscellaneous (169,100)
STC - Seaford Avenue Capital Draw (173,332)
LSJ - Cat 303 & 307 equipment (192,884)
Birch Tree LLC funding (200,000)
Zorro - Paving Deposit of 40% (272,098)
MS - Gratitude bought 10,000 shares of World Acceptance @ 111.07 (1,110,700)
Monthly Spending (1,255,000)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50,000 9,083,654
September Cash Spending
CVNA - 125,000 shares @ 66.006 8,250,750
MSFT - 10,000 shares @ 111.33 1,113,298
CTL - 10,000 shares @ 21.18 211,827
Euro bond via Paul 2,915,396
Total Cash Spent September 12,491,271
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan Interactive TO
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Merrill Stanley Braun AmerItrado Totals
Cash
Haze Trust 41.681,487 41,661.487
Southern Trust Company Inc. 7.245,194 685.680 299.452 4.314.329 4.885.951 17,430.606
Southern Financial LLC 8,729,146 100,366 5.280.333 14,109,845
The 2017 CatepIllar Trust 13.548.085 13548.085
Gratitude America, Ltd. 2,347,269 156,406 2039351 5,543,026
JEE 3.057.524 182.445 7.027 3.246,996
Jaspers Inc. 1.497.593 7.009 1.504,602
LSJE LLC 178.628 511.687 341.721 1.032,036
Butterfly Trust 705.281 705,281
Zono Management LUX 416.616 416,616
FT Real Estate 382,485 382,485
Southern Country International LTD 361,873 361,873
Plan D LLC I 312.178 312,178
JEGE LLC I 284,983 284,983
NES LLC 231.503 231.503
Neptune LLC 179.689 179,689
Hyperion Air LLC 147.203 147,203
Thomas World Air LLC 92,425 92,425
Enhanced Education 12.189 62.682 74,871
Nautlus Inc. I 54.587 54.587
JEEParis (US 5) I 42,743 42,743
Laurel Inc. I 36.829 36,829
Maple Inc. I 31,484 31,484
Cypress Inc. I 29.386 29,386
Freedom Air Petroleum I 22.512 22,512
JEGE Inc. I 8.366 8.386
Groat St Jim LLC I 6.000 6,000
LSJ LLC 5.150 5.150
Mechelles Transportation Co LLC I 4.733 4.733
Mort Inc I 4,553 4,553
FSF LLC I 337 337
The JEE Life Ins Trust N3 206 206
IGO Company LLC 90 90
Total Cash 80,567,692 2,638799 349,222 341.721 4,314,329 3.039,351 4,986.317 5,280,333 101,512,764
Purchase Quantity 7/31/18 8131/18 Unrealized
Asset Description Symbo Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB)
Citbank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000 1,999419 2,194,620 2,188.300 188,881
JBS Investments 7.75% October 28 2020 5/18/18 2,000,000 2,046,231 2,089,911 2,084.548 38,317
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/30/2049 05/10/11 3,000,000 3,337,958 3,013,686 3,036,541 -301,417
JP Morgan Floating Rate Income fund 01/22/13 251,591 2,512.832 2.349.054 2.357.402 -155,430
Total Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB) 9,896,440 9,647,271 9,666,791 -229,649
Jeepers - Fixed Income (08)
JPM Floating Rate Income fund 02/13/13 188,468 1.879.415 1.759.692 1.765.946 -113.469
Total Jeepers- Fixed income (DB) 1,879,415 1,759,692 1,765,946 -113.469
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Frontier Communications 7.125% Matures 3/15/2019 10102/17 1.000000 997.322 1.031.917 1,036.604 39,282
Plains Al America 6.125% 10/10/17 500,000 492.715 • 0
Total Gratitude America- Fixed income (Morgan Stanley) 997,322 1,524,632 1,036,604 39.282
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB)
Buckeye Partners Fixed to Real 6.375% Caltalsle 1(22/23 1/25/18 1,000,000 1,018.741 925,284 958.286 -60,455
Ftoyal Bank Scotland 7.64% Reed to 9'29.2017 Mon 3M Le or •232b0 11/10./15 5.000.000 4.789,780 • 0
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB) 1,018,741 5,715,064 958,286 -60,455
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (Merrill)
Bank of America 5.88% Pfd 12-31-2049 03/08/18 1,000,000 1.000,000 990.000 1.000.000 0
LSC Communications Inc. 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 2850000 2,773,650 2,661,962 2,704.472 -69.178
Rails Al America Fixaine 10/04/17 1,000 985.431 - 0
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill) 3,773,650 4,637,393 3,704,472 -69,178
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Interactive Brokers)
Capital One 5.55% Fixed to 9-1-2020 then 380 over 3 mo fiber 5/14/15 3,000,000 3,009,819 3,086,250 3,093,030 83,181
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred 625 par 7/27/15 40,000 1,000,000 1,062,800 1,044,400 44,400
Etrade Fhancial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then bats 10/11/16 3,000,&30 3,123,122 3.076.500 3,093.750 -29,372
Goldman Sachs 5.375% Fixed to 5-104020 then 392.2 over 3 no fiber 6/4/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 5,096,500 5,162,500 128,154
NGL Energy Partners 9% $25 par 6/6/17 40.000 1.000.000 974000 993.560 -6,440
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $25 Par 08/04/16 4,995 124.775 - 0
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Interactive Brokers 13,167,287 13,420,825 13,387,210 219,923
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB)
Assurant Fixed to Float 7% March 2048 3/29/18 2,000.000 2,039,868 2,088,222 2,099,889 60.021
Citloroup Inc - Series 0 5.95% 8/6/15 3,000,000 3,000,006 3,188,808 3,111,073 111,067
Citizens Communications 7.125% Mar 15 2019 10/3/17 1,000,000 1,000,392 1,031,917 1,036,604 36,212
Deutsche Bank AG 4.875% exp 12/1/2032 6/1(18 1.000,000 868,256 891,995 879,998 11,742
Deutsche Bank AG 4.296% exp 5124/2028 6/1/18 1,000,000 917,776 918,235 925,595 7,819
Exetainter LLC 10% July 15 2023 10/24/17 2.000,000 1,940,506 2,071,389 2,120.556 180.050
Exelainter LLC 10% JUN 15 2023 7/9/18 1.000,000 1,028,517 1,035,694 1,060,278 31,761
General Electric Co GTO Fixed to Float 4.0% Dec 15 2065 12/3/15 2,469,000 2,175,016 2,234,719 2,193.569 18,553
GMAC Cap TR I GTD Pfd Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80,000 1,882,774 2.125,600 2,144,000 261,226
JBS Investments 7.25% Apri 3 2024 10/31/17 2,000,000 1,981,300 2,052,125 1,987,740 6,440
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2.500,000 2,687,500 2,511,405 2,530.451 -157.049
JP Morgan Chase 8 Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500,000 2.675.000 2,511,405 2,530,451 -144,549
JPM Floating Rate Income fund 9/28/17 330,821 3,112,765 3,088,811 3,099.789 -12,976
Lloyds Banking Group Capital 7.5% 12/29/49 5/21/13 1,903,000 1,948,500 1.978.328 2,002,171 53,671
Service Master 7.25% Mar 1 2038 10/20/17 1.000.000 1,030.208 0
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30112 3.000,000 2 996.137 3.292.500 3.195.955 199 818
Total Southern Financial LW - Fixed Income (DB) 30,254,313 32,051,361 30,918,118 663,805
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) face value
Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 cl CBI var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 475,159 442.961 - 0
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 0 442,961 0 0
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 60,987,167 69,199,199 61,437,427 450,260
Southern Financial LLC- Equities (DB)
Amazon AWN 4/2/18 1.000 1,395,441 1,777,440 2,012 710 617,269
Albaba Group BABA 6/10/15 5.000 444,749 936.150 875.050 430.301
Apple Inc AAPL 12/7/17 314,000 53,321,627 59,751,060 71,475.820 18,154,193
Apple Inc AAPL 6/20/18 50,000 9,339,691 9514,500 11.381,500 2,041,809
Apollo Global Management APO 3731/11 263,157 4,999,983 9,342,074 9,086,811 4,086,828
Biogen Idec Inc Bite 2/14/12 2.095 250,455 700,505 740.562 490,107
Centeno Coro CNC 918/14 15.550 986,497 2,026,632 2,277,764 1,291,267
General Electric (exercise of puts sold at 18) GE 2/24/18 25.000 405.493 340,750 323.500 -81,993
Karyopharm Therapeutics Inc KPTI 7/12/16 25.000 467.106 426.700 526250 59,144
Nintendo NTDOY 2/5/18 10,000 517,906 426,700 449.500 -68,406
Ubisoft Entertainment U8SFF 3/29/18 11,200 974.199 1,237,436 1,207.367 233.168
CD Projekt - Poland OTGLF 3/29/18 20,000 1.080.562 - 0
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 73,103,147 87,560,509 100,356,834 27253.687
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (TO)
General Electric GE mullple 125,000 2,593,861 1,703,750 1,617.500 -976,361
ALPS ETF Alerian MLP AM..P 1/12/18 43,000 470,420 - 0
Sangamo Therapeutics Inc SGMO 5/28/13 40.000 546,000 - 0
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (TO) 2,5 9 3,8 61 2,7 2 0,1 7 0 1,61 7,500 -976,381
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merril°
Allergen (mandatory convert from preferred) AGN 3/1/18 7,066 1,515,900 1,300,780 1,354,623 -161,277
KBW Regional Bank ETF KRE 11/16/17 9,000 503,167 553,590 568.350 65,183
Facebook FB 7/26/18 20.000 3.559,596 3,451.600 3,514,600 -44,996
0111 Oi Services ETF OIH 5/16/18 17,000 490.376 441,830 420.070 -70,306
XLF Financial Sector XLF 8/2/17 82,000 2,072,448 2,291,900 2,323,060 250,612
Groat= antic( am 3/2a20MaaringraulieaMaaraiderresnla73.5%) 9/25/17 ref price 3555 2,500,000 2,505,025 2,453,400 -46.600
Japan Banks Capped Nolo Exp Feb i 2019 (75% Waif) 1/25118 3.000,000 2,972.100 2,972.100 -27,900
Vertex Linked Note (ceding SW pi spreads and buying VIX cals) 3/8/18 3,000.000 3,049,632 3,074,430 74,430
SX7E Market Plus Note Exp 4/26/2019 (72% binied 10/24/17 3.000.000 2.742.060 2.49078Q -509.220
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merril° 1 9,6 4 1,4 8 7 19,3 0 8,51 7 19,1 71,41 3 -470,074
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Interactive Brokers)
ALPS ETF Medan MLP AMP 1/8/18 100,000 1,094,000 - 0
ALPS ETF Alerian MLP AMLP 3/9/18 50,000 547.000 • 0
Broadcom AVGO 4/17/18 4,000 1,002,093 887,080 876,120 -125,973
Broadcom AVGO 5/17/18 4,000 1,000,000 887.080 876.120 -123.880
Goldman Sachs GS 1/25/18 1,850 499,873 439.246 439.949 -59,924
General Dynamics GD 2/7/18 2,300 501,381 459,448 444.820 -56,561
General Dynamics GD 3/27/08 3,450 773,056 689,172 667.230 -105,826
General Dynamics GD 5/7/08 2,500 491,250 499,400 483,500 -7,750
Lockheed Martin LMT 2/7/18 1.400 489,300 456.540 448.574 -40.726
Lockheed Martin LMT 3/20/18 2,100 707,676 684,810 672,861 -34,815
Lockheed Martin LMT 5/7/18 1,500 472,500 489,150 480.615 8,115
Nkilendo NTDOY 5/22/18 20,000 853.400 0
Northtrop Grumman 1400 2(7/18 1,470 493,920 441,720 438,780 -55,140
Northtrop Grumman NOC 3/28/18 2,195 760,159 659.576 655.188 -104.973
Northtrop Grumman NOC 5/7/18 1,500 475,800 450,735 447,735 -28,065
OIH Oil Services ETF 0114 5/17/08 17,000 504.839 441.830 420.070 -84,769
Raytheon RTN 2/7/18 2,400 498,840 475.920 478,560 -20,280
Raytheon RTN 3/20/18 3,600 763.284 713,880 717,840 -45,444
Raytheon RTN 57/18 2,400 491,880 475,920 478,580 -13,320
KBW Regional Bank ETF KRE 326/18 20,000 1,210847 1.230,200 1,263,000 52,153
XLF Financial Sector XLF 11/16/17 10,000 262.800 279.500 283.300 20.500
XLF Financial Sector XLF 3/26/18 22,000 603.789 614.900 623.260 19 471
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Interactive Brokers, 1 2,0 0 3,287 13,7 7 0,5 07 11,19 6,080 -807,207
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Mo _ an Stanle
Sequential Brands SOBG 9/23/16 50,000 108,500 0
General Electric GE 10/23/17 22,000 491,068 299,860 284,680 -206,388
Work] Acceptance Group VVRLD 10,000 1.111.107 - 1,186.100 74,993
Stars Group TSG 7/19/18 5,000 171,500 - 0
Total Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 1,602,175 579,860 1,470,780 -131,395
Haze Trust - Equities (DB)
Bombardier Inc Class B proem 6/21/18 25,000 97,249 94.100 82.643 -14.606
Carvana CVNA 6/21/18 25.000 1,086,102 1,075,000 1,618,500 532,398
Google GOOG 2/2/18 2,000 2,222,173 2,434,520 2,436.380 214,207
Google GOOG 12/5/17 1,000 1,014,015 1,217,260 1,218,190 204.175
United Techncbgies Urn 6/21/18 15,000 1,882.944 2,036.100 1.975,500 92.556
Haze Trust- Total Equities (DB) 6,302,483 6,856,980 7,331,213 1,028,730
J Epstein W Foundation - Equities (DB)
Bristol Myers Squibb BMY 10/30/15 3,400 227,604 199,750 205,870 -21,734
Disney DIS 10/30/15 685 78.100 77.789 76.734 -1.366
Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 305,704 277,539 282,604 -23,100
TOTAL EQUITIES 115,552,143 131,074,082 141,426,424 25,874,280
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF's (DB)
Ishares South Korea ETF 11/3/17 13.000 985.997 874380 875.160 -110)337
Total Southern Financial LW - Equity ETFS (DB) 985,997 874,380 875,160 -110,837
Southern Financial LLC - Options (DB)
US curve cap between 2yr and 10yr swap exp 5.22.2020 5/22/18 ONILLO) •••• a al 103500 85,435 88.528 -16,972
US curve cap between 2yr and wap exp 6-1-2020 6/1/18 asato.....s 96,7N
f 416, a
sto25.166,553
-14.725
.31,697 Total Southern Financial11C  (DB) Options 200,250
Southern Trust Co. - Options (IB)
Long OM 30 Calls CO 0.88 Exp 8/17/18 5/31118 370 63 0 0
Short O1H 25 Puts a 0.12 Exp 8/17/18 5/31118 (370) -7,289 0 0
Short OtH 26 Puts a? 0.64 Exp 8/17/18 6/7/18 (500) -28,485 0 0
Long DIN 29 Calls til 0.73 al? 8117/18 6/7/18 500 550 0 0
Long NXPI 110 Cats a 7.50 Exp 1/18/2019 5/7/18 100 26,600 0 0
Short NXPI 125 Cats a 2.30 Exp 1/18/2019 5/7118 (100) -7,508 0 0
Short NXPI 85 Puts (...a 5.50 Ex 1/182019 517118 100) -29.663 0 0
Total Southern Trust Co. - Options (IB) - (43,732) -
TOTAL OPTIONS 200,250 122,392 168,553 (31,697)
7131/18 8/31/18 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern Financia (SFLLC) 0ana 50mm - a 4Ornm
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 46,659,587 46,841,952 0.39% 7.37% withdrew lfnan 1/1017
Boothbay Enhanced Fund 7 835 726 7 879 421 0.56% 5.06% Enti Fie 12018:fart
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 54,495,313 54,721,373 2016 /Num ITT%
2017 mom 156%
Hedge Funds - Haze 2011Iretorn of mitt 7017 nal I/0 of moll* W417 ladeenotions o4
King Street - Illiquid Special Investment 3 102 745 3 102 745 ws3riots 57.303 415 230.7103 4/27116 5467.954 paid
Hedge Funds -Haze 3,102,745 3,102,745 0142015 12,077 815 113,584 7127/16416;924 pain
4/3/2018 37.263 413 2.738 10/27/16 6.118.641 pint
416/2018 37093 10/12 18.370 1/77/17 3534,644 paid
617720113 67,976 11/9 4.060 2016 Mum 068%
7116/2015 435
Hedge Funds - STC Initial Inv 20min 5131/16
Honeycomb 42.010.839 42.519,314 1.21% 11.69% added 15rrm 6/27/16
Total Hedge Funds-STC 42,010,839 42,519,314 2016 int 244% (6 504
Total Hedge Funds 99,608,897 100,343,432 2017 return 21.0%
SFL
Mort Southern Grat FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments
,
SFL
Kyara II (investment amount) marked to $0 in Sep 2018 250,000
Kyara IV (investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount les 30k distribution 4/20/18) 970,000
Prylanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (prat) 1,000,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3.000,000 STC
Seaford Avenue Capital - PB Investment - Auto Debt (total comrn 2.6mm) 916,687
Adfin Solutions (investment amoun ) 875,000 butterflytrust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3.480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston. NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase via Grat (50% sold for $15mm Feb 2018) sit 1,500,500
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Velar Global Fund II (amount funded vs 15mm comrnittment) 14,250,000 comulativ6 IRR !lira 12-31.2016 2220%
[v alue as of 6-30-2018 21.000,470 cumulafavo IRA Dm 12414017 1232%
Velar Global Fund III (amount funded vs 25mm committment) 21,000,000 cumulative IRR Um 1 414016 6t$%
value as of 6-30 2018 33,345,270 cumulative IRA Ihru 12414017 WA%
Totals 1,000,000 3,000,000 40,511,687 1,500,500 6,480,000
Total Investments 52,492,187 ,
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description  Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 2,900,000 2,900,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 0 plan D LLC 0
2008 G550 15150,000 15,750.000
Automobiles 875,000 875.000
Boats 500,000 500,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 2,500,000 2,900,000 0 17,125,000 22,525,000
Asset Description JEE SFL JEGE Inc. FIRE Totals
Loans Receivable
(tccs sham iON yet lee :Ss 1SCK) 150,000 150,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Nick Ribis 150,000 150,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
David Mitchell 243,700 1,160,000 1,403,700
Osboume Lane Capital (Paul B) 1.000,000 1,000,000
20,000 303,262 323,262
Harlequin Dane, LLC 6,750,000 6,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 2,500,000 2,500,000
Bella Klein 100,000 100.000
Lesley 300,000 300.000
David Rodgers 50,000 50,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
Darren Indyke 475,000 475,000
Richard Kahn 475,000 475,000
LV Home & Other 1,457,000 1,457,000
650,064 650,064
Total Loans Receivable 2,793,210 9,700,000 950,000 2,596,262 16,039,472
Enhanced
Asset Description  Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry_
Cello 175,000 175.000
Pagano Diamonds 500.000 500,000
3273 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - I nsuranos yaw 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Arts Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fi ne Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 3,050,000 9,900,000
Loan Payable to BJAV LW (PLAN D LW) (30,500,000) (30,500,000)
II
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                        Albert Bryan [usvi] Virgin Islands governor 
                                                Stacey Plaskett [usvi] Virgin Islands non-voting member of Congress 
               Daniel Schmachtenberger [academia] founder of Civilization Research Institute [civilizationemerging] 
                                                                              Sasha Baron Cohen [arts] Borat, Ali G 
 Anthony Scaramucci aka The Mooch [crypto] Skybridge Capital, FTX investor, Trump spokesman for two weeks [fortune] 
                                                                        Michael Miller [lawyer] Steptoe LLP partner 
            Darius Paduch [medical] Epstein's urologist, convicted of sexual abuse of patients, life sentence [doj] 
                                         Neal Kassell [medical] professor of neurosurgery at University of Virginia 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00285597 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(date: 2018-09-01)
2018 September
Sat Sept 1, 2018 PB
4:30pin to arrive PB via Jet Blue#1161 (Rec. Loa)
Sun. Sept 2, 2018 PB
5:40pin i to depart JFK via Finnair#6 to Helsinki (Rec. Loc.
Mon. Sept 3. 2018 PB-NY
Reminder: LABOR DAY Office and STC are closed
8 :44am Depart PB
11 :07am Arrive NY
3:00pm Appt w/Deepak Chopra
6:30pm Appt w/Miro
Tues. Sept. 4, 2018 NY
Reminder: Dave at G550 training Sept 16-23
Reminder: Larry at G550 training in Dallas Sept 4-8
6:45am Appt wM and
10:30am PHONE DATE w/Steptoe, Michael Miller
Dial In Passcode
12:00pm Haircut w/Patrick at Fekkai Salo
JOJO TO DRIVE YOU!
1:00pm to see Dr. Magnani
2:30 in CONSULTATION A t w Dr. Bilezikian
4:30pm Appt w/The Mooch
Wed. Sept 5, 2018 NY
Reminder Yoni in apeept. S-Oct 8
Reminder Merwin to checlaAC before coming to house today
11:OOam Appt w/Nellie Bowle (Masha's friend)
11:30am Appt w/Steve Hanson
1:30pm LUNCH w/Leon Black
3:00pm Appt w/Rich and Darren (reminder to talk to Vincent)
4:30pm CALL MAX
5:00pm Appt w/Jaylideliov (Masha's friegd)
5:30pm Appt w
Thurs. Sept. 6, 2018 NY-Paris
Reminder: Terje in town on Thurs. Sept. 6
7:29am Depart NY
8:24pm Arrive Paris
2:4Spm o ARRIVE Paris CDG via Aeroflot#2462 (Rec. Loc~
Fri. Sept 7, 2018 Paris
Reminder: Darren in Washington DC for niece's wedding Sept 7-9
Reminder: John Brockman's 2nd Brockman Conference at Eastover Farm Sept 7-9
Reminder: James to apa work on Apple TV
2:00pm Appt w/3B's Architect at their office
4:00pm Appt w/Xavier the Architect at the Paris apartment
SatSW.LL2=21:1S
Sun. Sept 9. 2018 Paris
Mon. Sept 10.2018 Paris
Re • • pri to arrive JFK via Finnair#5 from Helsinki (Rec
Loc
Reminder: Michael Wolff and Sasha Baron Cohen
Reminder: Karl Sigmund in NY Sept 10-16 for the opening night of his latest movie "Einstein's
Vienna"
Reminder: Rosh Hashanah
11:40or to ARRIVE Paris CDG via Aeroflot#6635 (Rec. Loc,
Tues. Sept 11, 2018 Paris
12:05p1 to ARRIVE Paris £DG via AF#1149 (Rec Loc.
Wed. Sept. 12, 2018 Paris
Reminder: Rachel Roth to vacate apt today (it has been 4 weeks since she moved in)
9:34EM to DEPART Paris CDG via Aeroflot (operated by AF) #3001 (Rec.
Loc
12:35p to DEPART Paris CDG via Aeroflot#6636(operated by FV)
(Rec.Locial
3:50pmli to DEPART Paris CDG via Aeroflot #2463 (Rec. Lot
TBD DINNDER w/Ariane De Rothschild
7 Sept.'  13, 2018 Paris -NY
3:00pm Depart Paris
6:00pm Arrive NY
Fri. Sept 14.2018 NY
Reminder: STC Closed today so Gabriel and crew can continue sanding and working
12:00 m A t w Dr. Wood Merrell lood work
JOJO TO DRIVE YOU
1:30pm Appt w/Rich and Darren
5:00pm Appt
5:30pm Appt w/Miro
6:30pm Appt w/Bannon
7:30pm Appt w/Terje
8:30pm Appt WI=
SCILUPLIST:82
Reminder to travel from Dalian to Paris, arrive Sept 16 (Rec. Loc.
••  LUNCH w/Karl Sigmund and Misha Gromov (Karl (Misha
1:30pm Appt w/Kathy Ruemmler (Ruemmle
2:O0pm TENAT1VE Appt w/Bannon
3:30pm Appt w/Miro (Miro:
7:34pm Depart NY
9:59pm Arrive PB
7:25pm to depart FK via Swiss Intl Air#23 (Rec. Loc#
Transfer Sedan by Blacklane to
Sun. Sept. 16.2018 PB
Reminder: Dave at G550 training Sept 16-23
5:45pm Appt w/Dr. Bard
Mon. Sept 17.2018 PB
Tues. Sept 18, 2018 PB
Reminder: Yom Kippur
Reminder: Ehud and Nili return to NY early Sept 18
Reminder: Daniel Schmachtenberger (Masha's friend) in NY Sept 18-25
11:OOam PHONE DATE w/Leon Black
3:30pmi to have haircut w/Patrick at
Wed. Sept 19, 2018 PB
Reminder. arrive back to PB Sept 19 at 7:08pm (Rec. Loc
Reminder telly from Newark to Paris via La Compagnie#101 at 7:05pm arriving
8:50am Septl:. LocA
Reminder: taying at Paris apt Sept 20
Thurs. Sept 20.20  -
Reminder: 11:00pm to depart JFK via British Air#182 for London (Rec.
Loca
9:31am Depart PB
11:53am Arrive LSJ
Fri. Sept 21. 2018 LSJ
1:30pm Appt w/Albert Bryan at STC (Albert: (Erika Kellerhals organized)
Sat Sept 22. 2018 LSJ-NY
Reminder: Jagland to be in Apt.and.Sept 22-29
1:20pm ant. to arrive JFK via AA#45 (Rec. Locii
1:51pm Depart LSJ
5:44pm Arrive NY
8:30pm Appt waand
Sun. Sept 23.2018 NY
Mon. Sept 24, 2108 NY
Reminder David Stern will be in NY for the day and use apt as 'home base'
8:00am BREAKFAST w/Ehud
11:00am Appt w/David Stern
12:00pm Appt w/Thorbjon Jagland (SNACKS)
1:00pm Appt w/Stacey Plaskett
3:30pm PHONE DATE w/Erika Kellerhals
3:30pm Appt w/David Stern
6:30pin Appt w/Daniel Schinachtenberger (Masha's friend)
Tues. Sept 25, 2018 NY
11:00am Appt w/Larry Delsoi
3:00pm Appt w/Rich and Darren
5:00pm Appt w/Neal Kassel!
8:00 Appt w/Borge Brende, Terje Rod Larsen and Michael Wolff (Michaels
al(Terjel l
Wed. Sept 26.2018 NY-?
Reminder Darren at Oxford, OH then Tuscaloosa, AL Sept 26-Oct 1
Reminder Martin Nowak in apt.Sept 26-28
8:00am Appt w/Dr. Paduch (Dr. Merrell recommended)
--Once through that entrance, he should take elevators immediately to his left to the 9th Floor
--Once off the elevator; he will make a left and walk straight down the hall to the last office on
his left
--Our room number is
Lisa is our contact:
Weill Cornell Medicine
Department of Urolo
1010 to DRIVE YOU
11:45am Eye Exam w/Dr. Friedman
1010 TO DRIVE YOU!
4:00pm Meet Karyna at the Design Building
5:45pm Appt w/Benny Shabtaz
6:00pm Apptw/Leon Botste"
7:00pm DINNER w/Woody and Soon Yi.
Thurs. Sept. 27 2018 NY
7:30am BREAKFAST w/Barnaby Marsh9:00am Appt w
10:17anal to arrive LGA via Delta#1428(Rec. Loc
He will stay in
3:00pm Appt tv/Rich (Darren out of town)
3:00pm amino JFK via Uber
6:00pm Appt w/Benny Shabtai
6:55pm and to depart JFK via AF#7 (Rec. Loa
Fri. Sept 28. 2018 NY
Reminder:
(Rec. Loc
and her mom traveling via Siberia Air#43from Moscow to St Petersburg
Stay at the -Hotel (Rec. Loc
9:00am BREAKFAST w/Martin Nowak
1:00pm Haircut w/Patrick at Fekkai
1 :30 mato have her hair cut with
2:30pm Appt w/PeterAttia
3:30pm Appt w/James Stewar
6:00pm Appt w/Miro
Sat Sept 29. 2018 NY
Reminder: Quizzy
7:15am BREAKFAST w/ Tom Prather
10:00am BREAKFAST w/Misha GromovM.
1:00pm Appt w/1 Guest
TBD labor
Sun. Sept. 70 201R NY-PB
Reminder: and her mom to travel from St Petersburg to Moscow via Siberia Air#44
(Rec. Lo
11:4Sam to ARRIVE Paris CDG via Aeroflot#2462 (Rec. Loa)
2:30pm Appt wMand
7:02pm Depart NY
9:13pm Arrive PB
EFTA01618494 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage from Renata Bolotova (???) screenshot(s)
(inferred date: 2018-09-03)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-37392018/09/03
Thank you sneaky! I want to see you before you leave?! *41.have fun tonight and hi to
Miro:) I hope to see him before he departs to his country
09:31:38 pm
Sneaky sorry I will be 5-7 mom late
04:59:48 pm
2018/09/15
2018/09/28
1212 5333739
Ok
09:47:22 pm
Sneaky, I am coming from school. When do you leave? Should i come now or better
tomorrow?
12:35:34 am
Ok
12:36:17 am
1212 5333739
Tomorrow
12:36:11 am
1212 5333739
Hi sneaky? Are you busy now? Could I come?
05:59:17 pm
7
07:26:34 pm
What should I buy as a gift for Miro?
09:16:24 pm
2018/09/30
Time
05:01:22 pm
7
05:01:24 pm
Good morning Sneaky, have a safe trip!
I left gifts With other stuff that were supposed to go in the car/ plane,
They should be in small "lady M" bag and there are stickers on each chocolate bag with
different sign which one is for Miro and which one is for his former employee. Please
give it all to Miro, he will figure it out.
Thank you!
11:38:25 am
*Different signs
11:38:55 am
1212 5333739
we delayed the trip till tomorw
11:39:18 am
•
•
Oh ok •• ',L
11:49:14 am
Is everything ok? Or Just delayed
12:13:10 pm
1212 5333739
karyna not feeling well
12:17:26 pm
Ah what? She was ok last night. Can I help with anything?
12:18:45 pin
1212 5333739
maybe
12:18:59 pm
Ok Imk
12:19:30 pin
02:12:09 pin
1212 5333739
terje said he would talk to adam re you doing research all ok
06:15:11 pm
Aww sneaky I love you!! Thank you very much!!! 4,141
07:57:25 pin
Sorry I was procrastinating earlier from my studying/ writing and put my phone away
in a different room
07:58:41 pm
•
Are you ok there? How is
07:59:12 pm
Tonight?
07:59:53 pm
What about Paris?
08:00:04 pm
And my presents? '•
08:11:21 pm
11,1111
08:20:04 pm
Hi sneaky, how I are you?
04:37:07 pm
2018/10/02
1212 5333739
pop going to floria
07:59:31 pm
1212 5333739
i will fed ex them
08:11:33 pm
Could you tell me what was the title of the video with the court hearing of the guy who
killed millions of Jewish? Or the guy's name sentenced to life in prison?
04:38:30 pm
1212 5333739
Adolph eichman
04:39:14 pm
Also check you status on the uscis
06:55:12 pm
Nuremberg trials
06:55:24 pm
07:04:55 pm
Nothing changed
07:04:55 pm
I check it almost daily Thank you
07:05:32 pm
07:06:02 pm
It was for this silly blog post for one of my classes where we have to reflect weekly on
our readings
07:06:51 pm
07:08:35 pm
Ops missed a page
07:08:42 pm
Did you hear from right?
07:14:05 pm
1212 5333739
Yes. All taken care of
07:14:19 pm
Thank you "I‘
07:14:41 pm

• How are you doing? In Pb now?
0/:15:10 pm
Loved "Great"
0/:16:22 pm
✓ Redd
1212 5333739
Great
07:1S:21 pm
✓ Sent
EFTA00513929 (Jmail)
 [tech] personal address book
(approximate date: 2018-09-08)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024329.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024329.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Notes
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Instant Message (iChat
ID)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Case Data: Contacts (9701-9800 of 19830)
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2018-09-28/Karina on 2018-09-28 at 17.05.3
2.ichat
iChat
Karina
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/6/9/Messages/96932.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karina
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number (Phone
Number)
ID 9241400
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Rece
nts/Recents
Recents
Karina
Source Device
Path
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Karina
Last Shuliak
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
ID 1593
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Rece
nts/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Karina
Phone Number (Phone
Number)
ID 3892502
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2018-09-28/Karina on 2018-09-28 at 17.05.3
2.ichat
SourceType iChat
First Karina
Instant Message (iChat
ID)
ID 3866706
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Karina
Last Shuliak
Email 0
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5290
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Karina
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:13 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-09-21 07:36:47 (UTC)
ID 5580
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Karina
Last Shuliak
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:13 (UTC)
ID 1593
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Karina
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 1551
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/8/Messages/89952.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina
Email
(Email)
ID 1329759
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Karina
Last Shuliak
Email 0
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:11 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5290
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/1/1/Messages/112153.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina
Email
(Email)
ID 1437442
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
Path /Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/9/Messages/95346.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina
Email jeffrey E.jeevacation®gmail.com (Email)
ID 1444223
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-802
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Karina
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:13 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-09-21 07:36:47 (UTC)
ID 5580
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Santos
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usersficaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1AfiNBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/9/Messages/99453.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karina Shuliak
Brice
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/0/1/Messages/107596.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karina Shuliak
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usersficatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/9/Messages/99754.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
Darren Ma (Email)
ID 1327648
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B19484823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/0/1/Messages/106399.emlx
Mac Mail
Karina Shuliak
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/9/Messages/97152.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
a> (Email)
ID 1337904
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/0/1/Messages/100801.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Karina Shuliak
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Karina Shuliak
Email (Email)
ID 3892502
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac- Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/5/2/1/Messages/125467.emlx
Mac Mail
Karina Shuliak
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/9/Messages/99814.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
a> (Email)
ID 1327600
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-056 I -4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3CIA/INBOX.mboxi4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/0/1/Messages/107065.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
(Email)
ID 1338532
Source
Device
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraiy/Mai IN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C I A/INBOX.mboxi4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/8/Messages/8 I 868.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
(Email)
ID 1372745
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jeefLibrary/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Karina Shuliak
Email (Email)
ID 9241400
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/9/Messages/98458.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
Eva (Email)
ID 1375246
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3CIA/INBOX.mboxi4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/0/0/1/Messages/100944.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
(Email) Ia >  Ea Darren
ID 1334155
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path fUsers/jeefLibraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First Karina Shuliak
Email (Email)
ID 9324727
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path fUsers/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/0/1/Messages/104442.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
(Email)
ID 1402691
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Contact
Path fUsers/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/6/0/1/Messages/106278.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
> a (Email)
ID 1365672
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Contact
Path fUsers/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/2/0/1/Messages/102733.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karina Shuliak
Email
(Email)
ID 1437003
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C I A/1NBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/9/Messages/98512.emlx
Mac Mail
Karina Shuliak
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C I A/1NBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/9/Messages/94893.emlx
Mac Mail
Karina Shuliak
Daphne
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3 EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/0/1/Messages/106066.emlx
Mac Mail
Karina Shuliak
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3 EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B19484823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/0/1/Messages/106630.emlx
Mac Mail
hoo.co.uk
hoo.co.uk
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
kara_durrant@ya
kara_durrant@ya
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/5/0/1/Messages/105910.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/9/Messages/98348.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
karisia
karisia
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3 EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/9/Messages/99979.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/9/Messages/97947.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karla J Perez
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MacffilN BO X . mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-
977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/8/4/1/Messages/148786.emlx
Mac Mail
First Karla Shaw
Email
(Email)
ID 1025990
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/karyna/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Karluz
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 707
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
Last
ID 32
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 707
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Work)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
/Users/M (Deleted)/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/458842CC-A34
740CB-9BB1-4AF33B39134B/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-07-22 18:31:15 (UTC)
2011-08-16 16:38:56 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:12 (UTC)
ID 707
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
Last
ID 32
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /U/Users,(Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/Mailboxes/Junk (iCloud).mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810
-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/6/1/1/Messages/116232.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First !Carolina
Email
(Email)
ID 1081125
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:44 (UTC)
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
Last
ID 32
Source Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/M (Deleted)/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/458842CC-A
34740CB-9B814AF33B39134B/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First ICarosa
Phone Number
(WorkFAX)
Phone Number
(Main)
Phone Number
(Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-07-22 18:31:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-08-16 16:38:56 (UTC)
Note
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Vinny
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/0/1/Messages/109293.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karpinska
Karpinska
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/1/1/Messages/111799.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna
Email(Email) Richard
ID 1371408
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/9/Messages/96290.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna
Email
(Email)
ID 1364412
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/4/1/Messages/143834.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna
Richard
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/katyna/Library/Messages/Archive/2018-07-13/Chat with
al on 2018-07-13 at 09.55.56.ichat
SourceType iChat
First Karyna
Instant Message
(iChat ID)
ID 1309197
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First Karyna
iChat ID:e
Creation Date 2016-03-03 13:18:18 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-03-03 13:18:18 (UTC)
ID 1
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
False
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Contact
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/8/Messages/83003.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna
Merwin Dela
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/8/Messages/82465.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Karyna
jeevacation@gmail.co
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-AC
4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Karyna
Shuliak
2018-12-09 16:20:30 (UTC)
2018-12-09 16:20:30 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/9/Messages/97995.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shulia
Darren
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3 EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/0/1/Messages/105317.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shulia
=Min Dave
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/9/Messages/99519.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
I la >(Email)
ID 1327519
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MaiUV6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/0/1/Messages/103739.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
a> Bella (Email)
ID 1409261
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/9/Messages/98084.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
la >  INE=Ia >(Email)
ID 1375238
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/8/Messages/88545.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
Jabor (Email)
ID 1377400
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/8/Messages/81848.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/3/0/1/Messages/103791.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
a> Larry (Email)
ID 1408435
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1376841
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usersficaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1AfiNBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/8/Messages/88906.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
Karyna Shuliak
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/3/0/1/Messages/103914.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
(Email)
ID 1408754
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1402527
Darren
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/0/1/Messages/104132.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
Contact
Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/8/Messages/82077.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
Ma Leo (Email)
ID 1438584
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/8/Messages/82099.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1438419
Source
Device
Path
Karyna Shuliak
Ma Ramon
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/0/1/Messages/104666.partial.emix
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
> Larry (Email)
ID 1402292
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/0/1/Messages/103388.partial.emix
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/7/Messages/75430.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
MOM (Email)
ID 1445562
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/thers/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-056 I -4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/8/Messages/8866 I .emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
MO Dave
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/8/Messages/89629.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
(Email)
ID 1329715
Source
Device
Path
MO> Dave
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/0/1/Messages/101906.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email Huang Ma (Email)
ID 1370989
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-056 I -4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/0/1/Messages/105891.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/3/0/1/Messages/103459.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
Ma Larry (Email)
ID 1409206
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1402404
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/0/1/Messages/104843.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1330254
Karyna Shuliak
Ille
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usersficaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1AfiNBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/8/Messages/89374.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
Karyna Shuliak
Ma
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usersficaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1AfiNBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/8/Messages/89339.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
(Email)
ID 1330209
E le Brice
Contact
Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3CIA/INBOX.mboxi4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/2/1/Messages/121903.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
Ma (Email)
ID 1374651
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/0/9/Messages/90018.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
Ma (Email) Mizuka
ID 1332776
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
fUsers/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B194848234372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/0/1/Messages/103559.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxi4
23B194848234372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/2/1/Messages/122931.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Karyna Shuliak
Ma
Contact
Source NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD Device
Path fUsers/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/0/0/1/Messages/100485.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Karyna Shuliak
Email
(Email)
ID 1334627
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergitaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/8/Messages/89879.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/2/1/Messages/123132.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1416892
Source
Device
Path
Karyna Shuliak
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MaiUV6/1B90A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948 -4823-4372-8F I 3-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/ I/O/I/Messages/I 01191.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1371373
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Karyna Shuliak
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MaiUV6/1B90A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948 -4823-4372-8F I 3-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/0/1/Messages/106415.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Userelcaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/2/1/Messages/124871.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/8/Messages/89758.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Karyna Shuliak
Case Data: Contacts (9601-9700 of 19830) Case Data: Contacts (9801-9900 of 19830)
EFTA00314072 (Jmail)
 [misc] Darius Paduch confirms he was Epstein's doctor
(date: 2018-09-26)
__ Beneficiary or his/her legal representative understands that Medi-Gap plans do
nk, and that other supplemental plans may elect not to, make payments for items and
services not paid for by Medicare.
__ Beneficiary or his/her legal representative acknowledges that the beneficiary is not
cukently in an emergency or urgent health care situation.
__ Beneficiary or his/her legal representative acknowledges that a copy of this
contract has been made available to him.

Executed on:
Date: Sept. 26, 2018

By: _____________

And:
Darius Paduch, M.D.

11111111111111 2935318
EPSTEIN,JEFFREY
01/20/1953
Initial:___ Date:
EFTA01255549 (Jmail)
 [money] due diligence on Jeepers, Inc. amusement park owned by Epstein
(date: 2018-09-27)
NAME SEARCHED: Jeepers, Inc

PWM BIS-RESEARCH performed due diligence research in accordance with the standards set by AML Compliance for your 
business. We completed thorough searches
on your subject name(s) in the required databases and have attached the search results under the correct heading below.
Significant negative media results may require escalation to senior business. Legal and Compliance management. Also. all
accounts involving PEPs must be
escalated.

Search:     Result:     Click here for results:     Reviewer Comments (as Necessary):

RDC         [x] No hit  RDC Results     I. RDC Results  No RIX . Alert (Please See Attached)

FIRCOSOFT   No lilt E Not Required    ii. FIRCOSOFT Results No FIRCOSOFT Alert (Please See Attached) 0 nit

BIS         [x] Yes     III. Negative Media         No Information Found
.                       IV. Non-Negative Media      Information Found (Please See Attached)
.                       V. Other Language Media     Not Required

D&B         Results? [x] Yes    VI. D&B Information Found (Please See Attached)

SMARTLINX   Results? [x] Yes    Information Found (Please See Attached) Results? _t Yes M No

COURT CASES [x] No results                  No Information Found

Prepared by: Krishna Dadhich    Date: 09/27/2018 Research Analyst
Instructions:

I. Review and confirm that all results arc returned for your client.
2. Please note that you are still required to perform any Martindale -Hubbell search (if applicable) on each starch 
subject. We have attached the web link
below for your convenience:Martindale-Hubbellhttp://www.mariindale.comhp/Martindale/home.sml

3. As needed, provide comment for any negative results.
4. If applicable, please obtain clearance from Compliance for all alerts.
5. Save any changes you make to this document and attach file to your KYC.
Please note: Submission of a signed KYC is your confirmation that you have fully reviewed the research documents.

For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) CONFIDENTIAL
DB-SDNY-0025963

Page 2
OFAC RESULTS

RDC:
Inquiry Id Response Type Tracking Id Name Address Date of Birth/Age
11640994 No Match Found KYC 01977705 Jeepers, Inc  VIRGIN ISLANDS, U.S.

FIRCOSOFT:
Request ID Record ID Type Name Details  Alert(s)
.                                       ADM INT PEP SAE
29778521 WR_297785212182 Company iJnecepe rs, No Alert No Alert No Alert No Alert

BIS RESULTS:

Negative Media:
No Information Found

Non-Negative Media:
News Bites - People in Business

May 9. 2018 Wednesday
Carpenter Technology director Karol Steven E sells 08 May 2018
Carpenter Technology (NYSE:CRS) Independent Director <REDACTED>> sold 10,000 shares worth $555,000 on
May 04. The selling price was SUS55.50.

HTTP link to original article
https://www.sce.gov/Archivesiedgaddala/I7843/00000178431t1000011/AF345X03/cdgar.xml

Karol Steven E (Reported Selling: trailing 12 months)
Month No. of Skims Price, USD Value, USD
May 08, 2018 10.000 55.5 555,000
September 08, 2017 2,645 40.5 107,122
August 09, 2017 3,877 40.18 155.760
Total 16,522 49.5 817,882
Download Table
Original news release
Source: SEC

SECTION 1 BIOGRAPHY <REDACTED> INDEPENDENT DIRECTOR
SECTION 2 CARPENTER TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION PRICE PERFORMANCE SCORECARD
(NYSE:CRS):
2.1 Carpenter Technology Corporation is placed 189/2,704 in the BSS News Bites ranking of price performance of
NYSE stocks in the past year. a percentile ranking of 93.
2.2 The Past Two Years
Carpenter Technology rises for a second consecutive year, a two-year rise of 73%
Carpenter Technology Corporation (NYSE:CRS), extended its gains in the past year. rising an additional SUS19.29
(52.4%) to close at SUS56.09. In the previous year the shares rose SUS4.44 (13.7%). The shares have lifted SUS23.73
(73.3%) over the past two years, compared with the S&P 500 Index which rose 615.5 points (29.9%) in the two years
for a relative price increase of 43.4%.
2.3 MCap History:
In the past 5 years Marko Capitalization has increased by SUS280.7 million from SUS2.4 billion to SUS2.6 billion.
Based on a dynamic start date of 5 years ago, there have been declines in MCap in 2 out of 5 years.
Price MCap (USS M)
Last SUS56.09 2.631.5
1 Year ago SUS36.80 1,739.9
2 Years ago SUS32.39 1.562.8
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025965
Page 3
3 Years ago SUS42.44 2,345.9
4 Years ago SUS60.27 3,374.8
5 Years ago SUS41.85 2,350.9
Download Table
2.4 Moving Annual Return (Trailing 12 months):
Based on a dynamic start date of 5 years ago, the Moving Annual Return has been positive in 3 of the last 5 years. An
investment in CRS a year ago would have produced a return of 55.7%
CRS Close Dividends Capital Gain / (Loss) % %Yield Annual Return %
Last Traded May 08 SUS56.04 72.Oc 53.7 2 55.7
I Year ago SUS36.46 72.0c 12.7 2.2 14.9
2 Years ago SUS32.36 90.0c (22.3) 2.2 -20.1
3 Years ago SUS4I.63 90.0c (31.1) 1.5 -29.6
4 Years ago SUS60.44 90.0e 39.6 2.1 41.7
Download Table
Close 5 years ago SUS43.29.
2.5 Present Value of SUS1000 invested in the past
The present value of SUS1000 invested a year ago is SUS1.548
PVS1000 1-week 1-month 1-year
CRS.NYSE 1.057 1.239 1.548
S&P 500 Index 1,010 998 1,114
Download Table
2.6 Trailing Price Change %
1-Year price change of 53.7% for Carpenter Technology outperformed the change of 11.1% in the S&P 500 Index for a
relative price change of 42.6%.
Price Change % 1-Month 3-Month 1-Year
CRS 21.9 21.0 53.7
Iron & steel sector 7.5 6.5 -22.0
S&P 500 Index 2.3 3.3 11.1
Download Table
SECTION 3 CARPENTER TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION FINANCIALS AND GROWTH PERFORMANCE
SCORECARD (NYSE:CRS):
3.1 Key Financials (All figures percent)
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED R.QQNE I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025966
Page 4
EPS Growth has improved from -9.2% in 2014 to 330.4% in 2017 and Revenue Growth has improved from 4.5% in
2014 to -0.8% in 2017.
CRS Revenue Growth EPS Growth Operating Margin ROE
2017 -0.8 330.4 5.6 3.9
2016 -18.5 -79.3 2.7 1
2015 2.4 -55.1 5.2 4.4
2014 4.5 -9.2 9.8 8.8
Download Table
3.2 Reverie and Net Profit
In the last 3 years Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) avenged -6.1% for Total Revenue and -29.3% for Net
Profit.
Description Annual (SUS M) 3-year Avg (SUS M) 3-year CAGR %
Total Revenue 1.800.4 1,947.5 .6.1
EBITDA 100 129.5 -32.5
Operating Profit 100 88.8 -22.3
Net Profit 47 39 -29.3
Download Table
CAGR ^t Compound Annual Growth Rate
3.3 Performance (All figures in %)
Net Profit Margin 3-year average is 2.0% and Return on Equity 3-year average is 3.1%.
Description Annual 3-year Avg
EBITDA Margin 5.6 6.3
Operating Profit Margin 5.6 4.5
Net Profit Margin 2.6 2.0
Return on Equity 3.9 3.1
Return on Assets 1.6 1.4
Return on Capital Employed 4.0 3.5
Download Table
3.4 High Performance Indicators:
Description Value Rank In NYSE Market
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R.CONE I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025967
Page 5
Price/MAP50 I.14 In Top 5%
% Prem to I-mo Vol Wtd Price 11.1 In Top 6%
Relative Price Change (.14(1 Year) 41.0 In Top 8%
3-mo Price Change % 22.26 In Top 8%
PriceMAP200 1.18 In Top Quartile
Price Change % 1.9 In Top Quartile
Download Table
SECTION 4 CARPENTER TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION GLOBAL RANK (NYSE:CRS):
4.1 Global Rank
Global Rank [out of 47,702 stocks]
Description Value Rank Quartile
MCap (USS) 2.6B 4.520 Top
Total Assets (USS) 2.9B 5.673 Top
Revenue (US$) I.8B 4,732 Top
Net Profit (USS) 47M 8.045 Top
Return on Equity % 3.9 23,114 Second
Net Profit Margin % 2.6 22,769 Second
Price to Book 2.4 21.907 Second
Price Earnings 44.6 16.000 Second
Yield % 1.6 14.055 Second
PV$1000 (1Year) USS 1.548 5,742 Top
USS Change (1Year)% 21.7 13.070 Second
Rcl Strength 6 Mo (USS) 52 22,742 Second
Download Table
SECTION 5 OTHER DIRECTORS OF CARPENTER TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION
William A. Wulfsohn. President
Gregory• A. Pratt. Chairman & Director
Damon Audio. Chief Financial Officer & Senior Vice President
Peter N. Stephan. Director
Philip M. Anderson, Director
Stephen M. Ward. Director
Jeffrey Wadsworth, Director
Robert R. McMaster. Director
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025968
Page 6
Katheryn C. Turner, Director
I. Martin Inglis, Director
Carl G. Anderson, Director
Karol Steven E, Independent Director
Joe Haniford. Chief Operating Officer
SECTION 6 CARPENTER TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION ACTIVITIES
Carpenter is a leader in the development, manufacture and distribution of cast/wrought and powder metal stainless steels
and specialty alloys including high temperature (iron-nickel-cobalt base), stainless, superior corrosion resistant.
controlled expansion alloys, ultra high-strength and implantable alloys, tool and die steels, and other specialty metals
as
well as cast/wrought titanium alloys.
SECTION 7 RECENT NEWS ON DIRECTORS
7.1 CHANGES IN BOARD OF DIRECTORS AND SENIOR MANAGEMENT
22 February 2018
Carpenter Technology appoints Joe Haniford as COO
C.•upenter Technology has appointed Joe Haniford as COO. The appointment takes effect from Feb 22, 2018.
7.2 RECENT REPORTED SELLING
03 May 2018
Carpenter Technology director Kathery•n C. Turner sells
Carpenter Technology (NYSE:CRS) Director Kathery•n C. Turner sold 2,358 shares worth 5135124.974 on May 01. The
selling price was SUS53.0. The shares hit a five-day low on the day.
03 May 2018
Carpenter Technology director I. Martin Inglis sells
Carpenter Technology (NYSE:CRS) Director 1. Martin Inglis sold 2.358 shares worth SUS125,811 on May 02. The
selling price was SUS53.35.
Source: www.BuyScllSignals.com
DOCUMENT-TYPE: Regulatory• issues
Other Language Media:
Not Required
D&B:
Copyright 2018 Dun & Bradstreet. Inc.
D&B Federal Employer Identification Numbers
September 21, 2018
JEEPERS INC
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED R.QQN(F I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025969
Page 2
Search:
Terms:
t 63 SOUTH AVENUE
BURLINGTON. MA 01803
UNITED STATES
****** • * • COMPANY IDENTIFIERS
FEIN: 71-2596237
SOURCE REFERENCE NAME: KANSAS UCC FILINGS
Public Record:
No Documents Found
No docunerts were Poor< fcr the search terms entered.
You can etit your search and try again, or save e. To are t. you may want tom one et mere of the
fa/owing:
• Cheek for sprang errors,
• Remove some search towns.
• Check the 'fed arrnlar-soundne last names' chedrbox.
Smarr:brag Comprehensive Elusmess Report a en(60-0629193) radFus(13)
1 OF 2 RECORD(S)
New SerinCIH
SmartLinx ® Comprehensive Business Report
Report Created:9.27.2018 2:40 PM EST I FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY I Copyright 2018 LexisNexis,
All rights reserved.
Search Terms - company(Jeepers. Inc) radius(15)
Executives - Current (0) Incceporalion/SOS (5) Operations/Sites (6) Sales (0)
Licenses (0) URLs (2) Real Property - Current (0) Real Property • Prior (0)
MVRts • Current (0) MVRe - Prior (0) Watercraft • Current (0) Watercraft • Prior (0)
Aircraft - Current (0) Aircraft - Prior (0) Bankruptcy Filings (0) Judgments & Liens Filings (21)
UCC Filings (148) Executives - Pnor (9) Registered Agents (5) Name Variations (21)
Possible Employees (7) Person Associates (2) Business Associates (62) TI Ns (6)
Possible Connected Parent Company (0) Industry Information (1)
Business (188)
View NI Sources (196)
Business Summa
Name Address
JEEPERS INC 700 Hungerford Dr
Rockville, MD 20850.1724 (Phone De-Listed in Electronic
Montgomery County Directory Assistance)
LexID Established TIN
0000-7570-5693 1986
(32 Years in Business)
At a Glance
Real Property 0 UCC Debtor 98
Personal Property 0 Bankruptcy 0
Secured Assets 0 Judgments/Liens 21
Executives 0 Foreclosure/Notice of Default 0
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025970
Page 3
Name Variations - 21 name variations found

NO. NAME
1. JEEPERS INC
2. JEEBERS INC
3. JEEPARSI INC
4. JEEPERAL, INC
5. JEEPERS
6. JEEPERS OF KANSAS INC

7. JEEPERS OF MARYLAND, INC
8. JEEPERS OF MISSOURI. INC
9. JEEPERS! INC
10. JEEPERS! OF KANSAS. INC
11. JEEPERS! OF MARYLAND. INC

12. JEEPERS! OF MICHIGAN, INC
13. JEEPERS! OF VIRGINIA. INC
14. JEEPERS: OF MASSACHUSETTS, INC
15. JEEPERSI. INC

16. JEEPERSL. INC
17. JEEPERSU OF KANSAS, INC
18. JEEPERS] INC
19. JEEPERS] OF MARYLAND, INC
20. JEEPERS] OF MICHIGAN. INC

21. JUNGLE JIMS PLAYLANDS OF MARYLAND. INC
TINs - 6 TINs found
NO. TIN NAME
1. 74-259XXXX JEEPERAL INC
JEEPERS INC
JEEPERS OF MD INC
JEEPERS! INC

2. 00-0626561 JEEPERS OF MD INC
JEEPERS OF MISSOURI INC
JEEPERS: OF MA INC
3. 00.0639586 JEEPERS OF MD INC
JEEPERS OF MISSOURI INC
JEEPERS: OF MA INC

4. 04-3331674 JEEPERS
5. 04.3351751 JEEPERS OF KANSAS INC
JEEPERS! OF KANSAS INC
JEEPERSU OF KANSAS INC

6. 04-3351851 JEEPERS OF OLATHE INC
Business Profile
Executives: Current - 0 executive(s) found
Incorporation/SOS (0 active, 5 other)

NO. NAME FILING TYPE STATUS FILING
DATE
FILING NO. STATE
1. JEEPERS: INC. FOREIGN
CORPORATION
INACTIVE 03/23/2000 000696836 MA
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QPN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025971
Page 4
Additional Details
Business Type: FOREIGN CORPORATION
Business Status: INACTIVE
For Profit: Unknown
Foreign/Domestic: Foreign
Foreign Incorporation Location: DELAWARE
Origin: State of MA
Filing History (most recent two years)
Filing Date Description
05/18/2007 CERTIFICATE OF WITHDRAWAL

2. JEEPERS: OF
MASSACHUSETTS,
INC.
FOREIGN
CORPORATION
INACTIVE 08/11/1998 000626561 MA
Additional Details
Business Type: FOREIGN CORPORATION
Business Status: INACTIVE
For Profit: Unknown
Foreign/Domestic: Foreign
Foreign Incorporation Location: DELAWARE
Origin: State of MA
Filing History (most recent two years)
Filing Date Description
05/18/2007 CERTIFICATE OF WITHDRAWAL

3. JEEPERS! OF KANSAS,
INC.
FOREIGN
CORPORATION
FORFEITED 02/21/1997 2455202 KS
Additional Details
Business Type: FOREIGN CORPORATION
Business Status: FORFEITED
Expiration: PERPETUAL
For Profit: Yes
Foreign/Domestic: Foreign
Foreign Incorporation Location: DELAWARE
Origin: State of KS

4. JEEPERS OF
MISSOURI, INC.
GEN. BUSINESS -FOR
PROFIT
DISSOLVED 10/11/1996 F00432274 MO
Additional Details
Business Type: GEN. BUSINESS - FOR PROFIT
Business Status. DISSOLVED
Expiration: PERPETUAL
For Profit: Yes
Foreign/Domestic: Foreign
Foreign Incorporation Location: DELAWARE
Origin: State of MO
Filing History (most recent two years)
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025972
Page 5
Filing Date Description
08/31/1998 APPLICATION OF WITHDRAWAL
10/11/1996 CREATION - GEN. BUSINESS FOREIGN

5. JEEPERS! OF
MARYLAND, INC.
FOREIGN
CORPORATION
FORFEITED 07/15/1996 F04454914 MD
Additional Details
Business Type: FOREIGN CORPORATION
Business Status: FORFEITED
For Profit: Unknown
Foreign/Domestic: Foreign
Foreign Incorporation Location: DELAWARE
Origin: State of MD
Filing History (most recent two years)
Filing Date Description
03/03/2008 RESIGNATION OF RESIDENT AGENT
11/16/2006 DEPT. ACTION - FORFEITURE
0 stabil Locations - Showing 6 locations

NO. ADDRESS METRO AREA PHONE
1. 91 E North Ave
Glendale Heights. IL 60139-3496
Du•a•e Coun
Chicago, IL
2. 700 Hungerford Dr
Rockville, MD 20850-1724
Montgomery County
Washington. DC-MD-
VA-WV

3. 63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Middlesex County
Boston, MA-NI-3
4. 60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Middlesex Coun
Boston, MA-NH

5. 800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Middlesex County
Boston, MA-NH
6. PO Box 8238
Corpus Christi, TX 78468-8238
Nueces Count
Corpus Christ TX
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.cONE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025973
Page 6
Sales - 0 record(s) found
Parent Company - 0 record(s) found
Industry Information
SIC NAIC
7993 Coin-operated Amusement Devices No NAIC information available
7996 Amusement Parks
9999 Nonclassifiable Establishments
Industry Description: AMUSEMENT PLACES
Business Description:
Licenses - 0 licenses found
URLs - 2 URLs found
CENTREPARTNERS.COM
JEEPERS.NET
Bankruptcy (0 active, 0 closed)
Judgments/Liens (21 filings)

NO. FILING TYPE AMOUNT FILE DATE FILE NUMBER JURISDICTION
1. STATE TM LIEN $15.425.00 05/08/2008 24L08003730 MD
Debtor 1
JEEPERS
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Debtor 2
JEEPERS OF MD INC
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Creditor 1
STATE OF MARYLAND
Filing Information
Filing Date. 05/08/2008
Original Filing Number: 24L08003730
Jurisdiction: MD
Amount: $15,425.00
Filing 1
Filing Number 24L08003730
Filing Type: STATE TAX LIEN
Agency: BALTIMORE CITY CIRCUIT COURT
Agency State: MD
Agency County: BALTIMORE CITY)

2. SMALL CLAIMS $5,882.00 05/02/2007 060100243662006 MD
JUDGMENT
For internal use on y
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025974
Page 7
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF MARYLAND INC
700 Hungerford Dr
Rockville, MD 20850-1724
Creditor 1
UNIFIRST CORPORATION
Filing Information
Filing Date: 05/02/2007
Original Filing Number: 060100243662006
Jurisdiction: MD
Amount: $5,882.00
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number. 060100243662006
Filing Type: SMALL CLAIMS JUDGMENT
Agency: MONTGOMERY DISTRICT COURT
Agency State: MD
Agency County: MONTGOMERY

3. I CIVIL NEW FILING I $6,832.00 101/17/2007 1060200014502007 I MD
Debtor 1
Pesnell, Sean
700 Hungerford Dr
Rockville. MD 20850-1724
Debtor 2
JEEPERS INC
700 Hungerford Dr
Rockville, MD 20850-1724
Creditor 1
CINTAS CORPORATION
Filing Information
Filing Date 01/17/2007
Original Filing Number: 060200014502007
Jurisdiction: MD
Amount: $6,832.00
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number: 060200014502007
Filing Type: CIVIL NEW FILING
Agency: MONTGOMERY DISTRICT COURT #2
Agency State: MD
Agency County: MONTGOMERY

4. I CIVIL NEW FILING $6.833.00 101117/2007 100014502007 I MD
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.WANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025975
Page 8
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
700 Hungerford Dr
Rockville, MD 20850-1724
Creditor 1
CINTAS CORP
Filing Information
Filing Date: 01/17/2007
Original Filing Number: 00014502007
Jurisdiction: MD
Amount: $6,833.00
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number 00014502007
Filing Type: CIVIL NEW FILING
Agency: MONTGOMERY DISTRICT COURT
Agency State: MD
Agency County: MONTGOMERY

5. !CIVIL SUIT 185,842.32 112/06/2006 10601-024366-2006 1MD
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF MARYLAND. INC.
700 Hungerford Dr
Rockville, MD 20850-1724
Creditor 1
UNIFIRST CORPORATION
Filing Information
Filing Date. 12/06/2006
Original Filing Number: 0601-024366-2006
Jurisdiction: MD
Filing Status: Updates May Be Present Elsewhere In This Report: Check The Court For The Current Status
Amount: $5.842.32
Filing 1
Filing Number: 0601-024366-2006
Filing Type: CIVIL SUIT
Filing Status: UPDATES MAY BE PRESENT ELSEWHERE IN THIS REPORT: CHECK THE COURT FOR THE
CURRENT STATUS
Agency: MARYLAND DISTRICT COURT
Agency State: MD
Agency County: MONTGOMERY

6. SMALL CLAIMS $17,947.00 12/14/2005 050200276982005 MD
JUDGMENT
RELEASE
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF INC
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025976
Page 9
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Debtor 2
JUNGLE JIMS PLAYLANDS SVCORP TRU
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Creditor 1
PR GEORGES CO MD
Filing Information
Filing Date: 12/14/2005
Original Filing Number: 050200276982005
Jurisdiction: MD
Amount: $17,947.00
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number. 050200276982005
Filing Type: SMALL CLAIMS JUDGMENT RELEASE
Agency: PRINCE GEORGES DISTRICT COURT
Agency State: MD
Agency County: PRINCE GEORGES
Release Date: 11/14/2011

7. 1CIVIL NEW FILING 1616.265.00 109/07/2005 1050200276982005 1MD
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF INC
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Creditor 1
PR GEORGES CO MD
Filing Information
Filing Date: 09/07/2005
Original Filing Number: 050200276982005
Jurisdiction: MD
Amount: $16,265.00
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number. 050200276982005
Filing Type: CIVIL NEW FILING
Agency: PRINCE GEORGES DISTRICT COURT
Agency State: MD
Agency County: PRINCE GEORGES

8. (CIVIL JUDGMENT 1$250,000.00 110/17/2003 ICV03501132 1OH
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.ctON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025977
Page 10
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Creditor 1
CDC RANDALL PARK MALL TRUST
Filing Information
Filing Date: 10/17/2003
Original Filing Number: CV03501132
Jurisdiction: OH
Amount: $250,000.00
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number CV03501132
Filing Type: CIVIL JUDGMENT
Agency: CUYAHOGA COUNTY COMMON PLEAS
Agency State: OH
Agency County: CUYAHOGA

9. I CIVIL JUDGMENT I $7.249.00 102/20/2003 I CCO035273 I FL
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Creditor 1
PLAY TIME TOYS INC
Filing Information
Filing Date: 02/20/2003
Original Filing Number: CCO035273
Jurisdiction: FL
Amount: $7.249.00
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number: CCO035273
Filing Type: CIVIL JUDGMENT
Agency: ORANGE COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT
Agency State: FL
Agency County: ORANGE

10. 1CIVIL NEW FILING I 101/03/2003 148CC2003000052 I FL
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Creditor 1
PLAY TIME TOYS INC
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025978
Page II
Filing Information
Filing Date: 01/03/2003
Original Filing Number: 48CC2003000052
Jurisdiction: FL
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number: 48CC2003000052
Filing Type: CIVIL NEW FILING
Agency: ORANGE COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT
Agency State: FL
Agency County: ORANGE

11. ILLINOIS TAX $208,826.79 05/02/2002 2002R23728 SANGAMON
RELEASE COUNTY. ILLINOIS
Debtor 1
JEEPERS
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Debtor 2
JEEPERS OF ILLINOIS INC
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Filing Information
Filing Date. 05/02/2002
Original Filing Number: 2002R23728
Jurisdiction: SANGAMON COUNTY, ILLINOIS
Amount: $208,826.79
Filing 1
Filing Number: 2002R23728
Filing Type: ILLINOIS TAX RELEASE
Agency State: IL
Filing Date: 03/22/2004

12. I STATE TAX LIEN I$208.826.00 105/022002 I 2002R23728 I IL
Debtor 1
JEEPERS
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Debtor 2
JEEPERS OF ILLINOIS INC
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Tax Id: 04-3331674
Creditor 1
STATE OF ILLINOIS
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025979
Page 12
Filing Information
Filing Date 05/02/2002
Original Filing Number: 2002R23728
Jurisdiction: IL
Amount: $206826.00
Filing 1
Filing Number: 2002R23728
Filing Type: STATE TAX LIEN
Agency: SANGAMON RECORDER OF DEEDS
Agency State: IL
Agency County: SANGAMON

13. STATE TAX $84,079.00 03/27/2002 020000917 KS
WARRANT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF OLATHE INC
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Tax Id: 04-3351851
Creditor 1
STATE OF KANSAS
Filing Information
Filing Date: 03/27/2002
Original Filing Number: 02U000917
Jurisdiction: KS
Amount: $84.079.00
Filing 1
Filing Number. 02U000917
Filing Type: STATE TAX WARRANT
Agency: SHAWNEE COUNTY DISTRICT COURT
Agency State: KS
Agency County: SHAWNEE

14. I JUDGMENT x$1,213.00 103/06/2002 102-004300 OVA
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF VA
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Creditor 1
THE VIRGINIA PILOT
Filing Information
Filing Date: 03/06/2002
Original Filing Number: 02-004300
Jurisdiction: VA
Filing Status: Updates May Be Present Elsewhere In This Report; Check The Court For The Current Status
Amount $1,213.00
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.Q1;;;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025980
Page 13
Filing 1
Filing Number 02-004300
Filing Type: JUDGMENT
Filing Status: UPDATES MAY BE PRESENT ELSEWHERE IN THIS REPORT: CHECK THE COURT FOR THE
CURRENT STATUS
Agency. VIRGINIA CIRCUIT COURT
Agency State: VA

15. I JUDGMENT X31.250.00 X011302002 I
Debtor 1
JEEPERS
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Tax Id: 74-2596237
Debtor 2
JEEPERS OF NYACK INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Creditor 1
WORKERS COMPENSATION BOARD OF NYS
Filing Information
Filing Date: 01/30/2002
Amount: $1,250.00
Filing 1
Filing Type: JUDGMENT
Agency State: NY

16. I CIVIL SUIT l$23.989.54 X03272001 101 50702 IPA
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Tax Id: 74-2596237
Creditor 1
KANE BUILDERS. INC.
Filing Information
Filing Date: 03/27/2001
Original Filing Number: 01 50702
Jurisdiction: PA
Filing Status: Updates May Be Present Elsewhere In This Report; Check The Court For The Current Status
Amount: $23,989.54
Filing 1
Filing Number 01 50702
Filing Type: CIVIL SUIT
Filing Status: UPDATES MAY BE PRESENT ELSEWHERE IN THIS REPORT: CHECK THE COURT FOR THE
CURRENT STATUS
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025981
Page 14
Agency: COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Agency State: PA
Agency County: DELAWARE

17. I CIVIL JUDGMENT I$88,194.00 110/2O2000 1253065 I TX
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Tax Id: 74-2596237
Creditor 1
DELL MARKETING L P
Filing Information
Filing Date. 10/24/2000
Original Filing Number: 253065
Jurisdiction: TX
Amount: $88,194.00
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number 253065
Filing Type: CIVIL JUDGMENT
Agency: TRAVIS COUNTY COURT-AUSTIN
Agency State: TX
Agency County: TRAVIS

18. !JUDGMENT 1$2,019.00 108/14/2000 1 I
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Tax Id: 74-2596237
Creditor 1
Piltz, Troy
Filing Information
Filing Date 08/14/2000
Amount: $2,019.00
Filing 1
Filing Type: JUDGMENT
Agency State: MA

19. !CIVIL SUIT I 102/28/2000 100.01203 IPA
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Tax Id: 74-2596237
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025982
Page IS
Creditor 1
DELTRONIC LABS INC
Filing Information
Filing Date: 02/28/2000
Original Filing Number: 00-01203
Jurisdiction: PA
Filing Status: Updates May Be Present Elsewhere In This Report; Check The Court For The Current Status
Filing 1
Filing Number. 00-01203
Filing Type: CIVIL SUIT
Filing Status: UPDATES MAY BE PRESENT ELSEWHERE IN THIS REPORT; CHECK THE COURT FOR THE
CURRENT STATUS
Agency: COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
Agency State: PA
Agency County: BUCKS

20. I CIVIL SUIT I $1.105.000.00 101/13/2000 IL 000201 00 I NJ
Debtor 1
Doe, John
Debtor 2
Elhage, Nabil
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Debtor 3
Roe, Richard
Debtor 4
Sanginario, Kenneth J
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Tax Id: 017-50-XXXX
Debtor 5
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Tax Id: 74-2596237
Debtor 6
JEEPERS OF JERSEY GARDENS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Debtor 7
JEEPERS OF NJ INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025983
Page 16
Debtor 8
NJ METROMALL URBAN RENEWAL INC
20 S 3rd St
Columbus. OH 43215-4206
Creditor 1
C RAIMONDO & SONS CONSTRUCTION
Filing Information
Filing Date: 01/13/2000
Original Filing Number: L 000201 00
Jurisdiction: NJ
Filing Status: Updates May Be Present Elsewhere In This Report: Check The Court For The Current Status
Amount: $1.105,000.00
Filing 1
Filing Number: L 000201 00
Filing Type: CIVIL SUIT
Filing Status: UPDATES MAY BE PRESENT ELSEWHERE IN THIS REPORT; CHECK THE COURT FOR THE
CURRENT STATUS
Agency: NEW JERSEY SUPERIOR COURT LAW DIVISION
Agency State: NJ
Agency County: UNION
21 JUDGMENT 57.99390 09/14/1999
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Tax Id: 74-2596237
Creditor 1
DETROIT NEWSPAPER
Filing Information
Filing Date: 09/14/1999
Amount: $7,993.00
Filing 1
Filing Type: JUDGMENT
Agency State: MA
UCC Filings (100 debtor, 0 creditor)
100 UCC filings showing out of 148 &

NO. ROLE STATUS ORIG.
FILING
DATE
ORIG. FILE
NUMBER
JURISDICTI
ON
FILE TYPE
1. Debtor Active 11/09/2006 6391725 9 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
For internal use only
For internal use only
SONY_GM_00063159
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.ctONE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025984
EFrA_00173667
Page 17
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 6391725 9
Filing Date. 11/09/2006
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF MARYLAND, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
BELTWAY PLAZA SHOPPING CENTER
The Quantum Building 4912DEL
Bethesda. MD 20814
Collateral
EQUIPMENT;INVENTORY;FIXTURES;MACHINERY

2. !Debtor 'Active 112/23/2004 [4363612 5 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 4363612 5
Filing Date: 12/23/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF MICHIGAN, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
MACOMB MALL ASSOCIATES LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, A MICHIGAN
LIMIT
25800 Northwestern Hwy Ste 750
Southfield. MI 48075-8403
Collateral
ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:MACHINERY INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;EQUIPMENT INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;FIXTURES INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;COMPUTER EQUIPMENT INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;COMMUNICATIONS EQUIPMENT INCLUDING PROCEEDS
AND PRODUCTS:CHATTEL PAPER INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS
3. 1Debtor 1Active 110/15/2004 14296398 3 DE Assignment
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CCANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SONY-0025985
Page 18
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal 8 Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 4
Filing Number: 6323725 2
Filing Date: 09/19/2006
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEERERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES, LLC
153 N Main
Weston, MA 02493
Filing 3
Filing Number 6317973 6
Filing Date: 09/14/2006
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897.4007
Collateral
VauCLES.EOUiPMENT
Filing 2
Filing Number 6317068 5
Filing Date: 09/13/2006
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025986
Page 19
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
VEHICLES.EQUIPMENT
Filing 1
Filing Number: 4296398 3
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT
4 I Debtor I Active 110/15/2004 14296308 2 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 4296308 2
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

5. I Debtor I Active 110/15/2004 14296307 4 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SONY-0025987
Page 20
Filing 1
Filing Number 4296307 4
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

6. (Debtor (Active 110/15/2004 '4296304 1 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number. 4296304 1
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED
7 (Debtor (Active 110/15/2004 14296295 1 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number: 4296295 1
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.ctit;nf IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025988
Page 21
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

8. 1Debtor !Active 110/15/2004 '42962902 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 4296290 2
Filing Date 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

9. I Debtor 1 Active '10/15/2004 '42962852 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number: 4296285 2
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCIANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025989
Page 22
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897.4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

10. I Debtor Active 110/15/2004 142962803 DE Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 2
Filing Number 5014385 0
Filing Date: 01/11/2005
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.,
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT
Filing 1
Filing Number 4296280 3
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

11. I Debtor (Active 110/15/2004 142962787 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCIANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025990
Page 23
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number: 4296278 7
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

12. I Debtor Active 110/15/2004 14296274 6 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 4296274 6
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED:COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED;FIXTURES
LEASED

13. I Debtor I Active 110/15/2004 14296270 4 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number. 4296270 4
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025991
Page 24
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

14. 1Debtor 1Active 110/15/2004 14296266 2 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 4296266 2
Filing Date. 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED;EQUIPMENT LEASED

15. 1Debtor 1Active 110/1512004 14296262 1 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATENCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 4296262 1
Filing Date: 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCIANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025992
Page 25
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
FIXTURES LEASED:COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED:EQUIPMENT
LEASED

16. 1Debtor 1Active 110/1572004 14295798 5 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 4295798 5
Filing Date. 10/15/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897.4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED:COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED

17. 1Debtor lActive 111/202003 13306610 0 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 3306610 0
Filing Date: 1120/2003
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK, AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025993
Page 26
Collateral
UNSPECIFIED

18. I Debtor I Active 11112012003 13306605 0 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number: 3306605 0
Filing Date. 11/20/2003
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal Street Mc Maofd07a
Boston. MA 02211-0001
Collateral
UNSPECIFIED

19. I Debtor !Active 111120/2003 13306601 9 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 3306601 9
Filing Date: 11/20/2003
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
UNSPECIFIED

20. I Debtor I Active 112/12/2001 111683064 DE Continuation
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025994
Page 27
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 3
Filing Number 6423126 2
Filing Date: 12/05/2006
Filing Type: CONTINUATION
Debtor 1
JEEPERS' OF KANSAS. INC.
Secured Party Info 1
GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES. LLC
Filing 2
Filing Number 6159191 6
Filing Date: 05/05/2006
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF KANSAS. INC.
Secured Party Info 1
GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES. LLC
Filing 1
Filing Number 1168306 4
Filing Date: 12/12/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF KANSAS. INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004
Assignees 1
GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES, LLC
153 North Ave
Weston, MA 02493-2032
Collateral
ALL ASSETS

21. I Debtor Active 12/12/2001 111682876 L DE Continuation
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025995
Page 28
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 2
Filing Number 6423089 2
Filing Date. 12/05/2006
Filing Type: CONTINUATION
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC
Secured Party Info 1
GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES, LLC
Filing 1
Filing Number 1168287 6
Filing Date: 12/12/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004
Assignees 1
GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES, LLC
153 North Ave
Weston, MA 02493-2032
Collateral
ALL ASSETS

22. I Debtor Active 111/13/2001 11166348 8 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1166348 8
Filing Date: 11/13/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025996
Page 29
MOSS DISTRIBUTING. INC.
1801 Guthrie Ave
Des Moines. IA 50316-2735
Collateral
EQUIPMENT

23. I Debtor I Active 111/05/2001 11159138 2 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number: 1159138 2
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED;EQUIPMENT LEASED

24. Debtor Active 11/05/2001 1159131 7 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159131 7
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED;COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025997
Page 30

25. !Debtor (Active 111/05/2001 I1159125 9 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159125 9
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897.4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED;EQUIPMENT LEASED
26 I Debtor I Active 111/05/2001 11159116 8 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number: 1159116 8
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED:EQUIPMENT LEASED

27. !Debtor (Active 111/05/2001 11159113 5 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025998
Page 31
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159113 5
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERSI INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

28. 1Debtor !Active 111/052001 11159108 5 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159108 5
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

29. 1Debtor Active 111/052001 11159102 8 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number: 1159102 8
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0025999
Page 32
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED;EQUIPMENT LEASED

30. Debtor Active 11/052001 1159099 6 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159099 6
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED;FIXTURES LEASED;EQUIPMENT
LEASED

31. IDebtor (Active 111/052001 11159095 4 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159095 4
Filing Date: 11/052001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026000
Page 33
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

32. 1Debtor I Active 111/05/2001 11159091 3 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159091 3
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT LEASED;EQUIPMENT LEASED

33. !Debtor (Active 111/052001 11159083 0 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number. 1159083 0
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
For internal use only
For internal use only
SONY_GM_00063176
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCIANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026001
Page 34
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

34. 'Debtor 'Active 111/05/2001 11159082 2 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159082 2
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

35. 1Debtor I Active 111/052001 11159080 6 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover. DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159080 6
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

36. 1Debtor (Active 111/05/2001 11159079 8 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026002
Page 35
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159079 8
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED
3T I Debtor lActive 111/05/2001 11159074 9 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159074 9
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453.1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

38. I Debtor 'Active 111/05/2001 11159069 9 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159069 9
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026003
Page 36
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

39. 1Debtor (Active 111/05/2001 11159067 3 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159067 3
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

40. 1Debtor (Active 111/05/2001 11159066 5 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1159066 5
Filing Date: 11/05/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026004
Page 37
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

41. IDebtor 'Active 110/1072001 11136495 4 DE Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
Federal & Duke Of York Sts
Dover, DE 19901
Filing 1
Filing Number 1136495 4
Filing Date. 10/10/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Secured Party Info 1
BANKERS TRUST CO., N.A.
PO Box 897
Des Moines, IA 50306.0897
Collateral
EQUIPMENT

42. 1Debtor (Active 104/06/2001 14604690 KS Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
301 Sw 10th Ave
Topeka, KS 66612
Filing 1
Filing Number: 4604690
Filing Date: 04/0672001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
INNOVATIVE CONCEPTS IN ENTERTAINMENT. INC.
10123 Main St
Clarence, NY 14031-2164
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026005
Page 38
Collateral
EQUIPMENT

43. I Debtor 'Active 101/04/2001 139100000038112 MD Amendment
Filing Office Information
UCC DIVISION
301 W Preston St
Baltimore. MD 21201
Filing 1
Filing Number: 39100000038112
Filing Date. 09/06/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Expiration: 12/04/2010
Debtor 1
JEEPERSI INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02110-2012

44. I Debtor 'Active 101/04/2001 139100000032933 MD Amendment
Filing Office Information
UCC DIVISION
301 W Preston St
Baltimore, MD 21201
Filing 1
Filing Number 39100000032933
Filing Date: 09/06/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Expiration: 10/29/2010
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026006
Page 39
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK, AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519

45. (Debtor !Active 108/22/2000 120000085482 NC Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
300 N Salisbury St. Legis Off Bldg
Raleigh, NC 27603
Filing 1
Filing Number: 20000085482
Filing Date: 08/2212000
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERSI, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT

46. 'Debtor jActive 105/2412000 IAP0242826 OH Assignment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
30 E Broad St
Columbus. OH 43215
Filing 2
Filing Number 20011720640
Filing Date. 06/18/2001
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Expiration: 05/24/2005
Debtor 1
JEEPERS' INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Assignees 1
GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES, LLC
153 North Ave
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026007
Page 40
Weston. MA 02493-2032
Filing 1
Filing Number: AP0242826
Filing Date: 05/24/2000
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Expiration: 05/24/2005
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004

47. 1 Debtor 'Active 105/24/2000 100000181046689 MD Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/DEPARTMENT OF ASSESSMENT AND
TAXATION/UCC DIVISION
301 W Preston St
Baltimore, MD 21201
Filing 1
Filing Number: 00000181046689
Filing Date: 0512412000
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Expiration: 05/24/2012
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF MARYLAND, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Collateral
FIXTURES INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS:PARTNERSHIP
INTERESTINCLUDINGPROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS;NEGOTIABLE
INSTRUMENTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS:CONTRACT
RIGHTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS:ACCOUNTS
RECEIVABLE INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS:INVENTORY
INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND P

48. 'Debtor I Active 105123/2000 '3647385 KS Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
301 Sw 10th Ave
Topeka, KS 66612
For internal use only
For internal use only
SONY_GM_00063183
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026008
Page 41
Filing 1
Filing Number: 3647385
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF KANSAS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Collateral
INVENTORY INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS:CONTRACT
RIGHTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS:PARTNERSHIP
INTERESTINCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS:NEGOTIABLE
INSTRUMENTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS:FIXTURES
INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS;ACCOUNT(S) INCLUDING
PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS;C

49. Debtor Active 01/25/2000 004147617 IL Amendment To A
Secured Party
Filing 1
Filing Number: 004279352
Filing Date: 10/06/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT TO A SECURED PARTY
Expiration: 01/25/2005
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL INC
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT

50. 1Debtor 1 Active 101/06/2000 '000106 7187 VA Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF THE COMMONWEALTHAJCC DIVISION
Old Finance Bldg Capitol Square
Richmond. VA 23219
Filing 2
Filing Number 000822 7167
Filing Date: 08/22/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SONY-0026009
Page 42
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
Filing 1
Filing Number 000106 7187
Filing Date: 01/06/2000
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT
51. !Debtor I Active 101/06/2000 100004125 NY Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
162 Washington Ave
Albany. NY 12210
Filing 2
Filing Number 00164047
Filing Date: 08/22/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERSI, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Filing 1
Filing Number 00004125
Filing Date: 01/06/2000
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026010
Page 43
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897.4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT
52 'Debtor 'Active '03/18/1999 139100000054103 MD Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/DEPARTMENT OF ASSESSMENT AND
TAXATION/UCC DIVISION
301 W Preston St
Baltimore, MD 21201
Filing 2
Filing Number. 39100000054103
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Expiration: 03/18/2011
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF MARYLAND, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number. 39100000054103
Filing Date: 03/18/1999
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF GLEN BURNIE. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004
Collateral
NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;GENERAL INTANGIBLE(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS
ANDPRODUCTS,EQUIPMENT INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:INVENTORY INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026011
Page 44
PRODUCTS:ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:CONTRACT RIGHTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:CHATTELPAPER INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:PARTNERSHIP INTEREST:FIXTURES INCLUDING
PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS;ACCOUNT(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS
AND PRODUCTS

53. 'Debtor 'Active 103/15/1999 101835C MI Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
430 W Allegan
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 2
Filing Number 14006C
Filing Date 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF MICHIGAN, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number 01835C
Filing Date: 03/15/1999
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF AUBURN HILLS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Collateral
ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:EQUIPMENT INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:CONTRACT RIGHTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:GENERAL INTANGIBLE(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:CHATTEL PAPER INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;ACCOUNT(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:FIXTURES INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:INVENTORY INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:PARTNERSHIP INTEREST;NEGOTIABLEINSTRUMENTS
INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS

54. I Debtor 1 Active '01/29/1999 ID472927 MI Amendment
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026012
Page 45
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATEJUCC DIVISION
430 W Allegan
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 2
Filing Number: D792430
Filing Date: 06/29/2001
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Filing 1
Filing Number. D472927
Filing Date: 0129/1999
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERSI INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT
55 Debtor [Active j01/29/1999 1051282 AZ Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE UCC DIVISION
1700W Washington Ave
Phoenix, AZ 85007
Filing 3
Filing Number 1051282
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Expiration: 01/292005
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
For Internal use only
For internal use only
S0NY_GM_00063188
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QQN(F I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026013
Page 46
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 2
Filing Number: 1051282
Filing Date: 06/01/1999
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St Mc Maofd07a
Boston. MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number: 1051282
Filing Date: 01/29/1999
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT

56. [Debtor [Active 101/29/1999 11051281 AZ Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE UCC DIVISION
1700 W Washington Ave
Phoenix, AZ 85007
Filing 3
Filing Number 1051281
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026014
Page 47
Expiration: 01/29/2005
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 2
Filing Number 1051281
Filing Data 06/01/1999
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St Mc Maofd07a
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number 1051281
Filing Date: 01/29/1999
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT

57. (Debtor (Active 112/18/1998 198265949 NY Assignment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
162 Washington Ave
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.ctailf IDENTIAL DB-SONY-0026015
Page 48
Albany, NY 12210
Filing 2
Filing Number: 00034822
Filing Date: 02222000
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
NAMCO CYBERTAINMENT INC.
872 Supreme Dr
Bensenville. IL 60106-1107
Assignees 1
CENTRE CAPITAL INVESTORS IL L.O.
30 Rockefeller Plz Ste 5050
New York, NY 10112-0015
Filing 1
Filing Number: 98265949
Filing Date: 12/18/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
NAMCO CYBERTAINMENT INC
877 Supreme Dr
Bensenville. IL 60106-1106
Collateral
EQUIPMENT ALL AND PRODUCTS

58. I Debtor I Active 112/10/1998 I AP0106680 OH Assignment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
30 E Broad St
Columbus, OH 43215
Filing 2
Filing Number. 20000540163
Filing Date: 02/22/2000
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Expiration: 12/10/2003
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCIANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026016
Page 49
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
NAMCO CYBERTAINMENT INC
877 Supreme Dr
Bensenville. IL 60106-1106
Assignees 1
CENTRE CAPITAL INVESTORS II LP
30 Rockefeller Piz Ste 5050
New York, NY 10112-0015
Filing 1
Filing Number: AP0106680
Filing Date: 12/10/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Expiration: 12/10/2003
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
NAMCO CYBERTAINMENT INC
877 Supreme Dr
Bensenville, IL 60106-1106

59. 'Debtor 'Active 112/1011998 139100000039057 MD Assignment
Filing Office Information
UCC DIVISION
301 W Preston St
Baltimore, MD 21201
Filing 2
Filing Number: 39100000039057
Filing Date: 02/22/2000
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Expiration: 06/30)2006
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
CENTRE CAPITAL INVESTORS IL L.P.
30 Rockefeller Plz Ste 5050
New York, NY 10112-0015
Assignees 1
CENTRE PARALLEL MANAGEMENT PARTNERS, L.P.
30 Rockefeller Plz Ste 5050
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026017
Page 50
New York, NY 10112-0015
Filing 1
Filing Number: 39100000039057
Filing Date: 12/10/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
NAMCO CYBERTAINMENT INC
877 Supreme Dr
Bensenville. IL 60106-1106
Collateral
EQUIPMENT AND PROCEEDS

60. I Debtor Active 112/04/1998 139100000038635 MD Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/DEPARTMENT OF ASSESSMENT AND
TAXATION/UCC DIVISION
301 W Preston St
Baltimore, MD 21201
Filing 2
Filing Number 39100000038635
Filing Date: 10/06/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Expiration: 12/04/2010
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
Onefederal Street Mc Maofdo7
Boston. MA
Filing 1
Filing Number 39100000038635
Filing Date: 12/04/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(f IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026018
Page 51
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897.4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT:FIXTURES

61. !Debtor 1 Active 111130/1998 IAP0101092 OH Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
30 E Broad St
Columbus, OH 43215
Filing 2
Filing Number: 20002520019
Filing Date. 09/0512000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Expiration: 11/30/2003
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number AP0101092
Filing Date: 11/30/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Expiration: 11/30/2003
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026019
Page 52
62 I Debtor Active 111/30/1998 1992398 MI Continuation
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
430W Allegan
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 2
Filing Number: D692295
Filing Date: 09/07/2000
Filing Type: CONTINUATION
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number 99239B
Filing Date: 11/30/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston. MA 02211-0001
Collateral
EQUIPMENT

63. (Debtor 'Active 111/30/1998 198252226 NY Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
162 Washington Ave
Albany, NY 12210
Filing 2
Filing Number. 00171794
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.crt;IINI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026020
Page 53
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number: 98252226
Filing Date: 11/30/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERSI. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHONOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston. MA 02211-0001
Collateral
EQUIPMENT ALL

64. !Debtor Active 110/29/1998 198229697 NY Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
162 Washington Ave
Albany. NY 12210
Filing 3
Filing Number 00171802
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK. AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519
Filing 2
Filing Number: 99058348
Filing Date: 03/24/1999
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCIANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026021
Page 54
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
Filing 1
Filing Number: 98229697
Filing Date: 10/29/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT:EQUIPMENT

65. IDebtor 'Active 110/29/1998 198229695 NY Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
162 Washington Ave
Albany, NY 12210
Filing 3
Filing Number. 00171799
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERSL. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK. AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.ckftAl(f IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026022
Page 55
Filing 2
Filing Number 99058349
Filing Date: 03/24/1999
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPARSI INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519
Filing 1
Filing Number 98229695
Filing Date: 10/29/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT,COMPUTER EQUIPMENT

66. 'Debtor (Active '09/09/1998 (D418831 MI Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
430 W Allegan
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 3
Filing Number 0691284
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.O2N(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026023
Page 56
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK, AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
Filing 2
Filing Number: D549899
Filing Date: 08/03/1999
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK. AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT:EQUIPMENT
Filing 1
Filing Number D418831
Filing Date: 09/09/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS ! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT:EQUIPMENT

67. (Debtor (Active 109/09/1998 1D418830 MI Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
430 W Allegan
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 3
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026024
Page 57
Filing Number: D691285
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERSI, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK, AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519
Filing 2
Filing Number D551043
Filing Date: 08/05/1999
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK, AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519
Collateral
EQUIPMENT:COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
Filing 1
Filing Number D418830
Filing Date: 09/09/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897.4007
Collateral
COMPUTER EQUIPMENT:EQUIPMENT
For internal use only
For internal use only
SONY_GM_00063200
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCIANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026025
Page 58

68. Debtor Active 09/09/1998 D148831 MI Continuation
Filing Office Information
UNIFORM COMMERCIAL CODE SECTION
7064 Crowner Dr
Lansing, MI 48909
Filing 3
Filing Number: 2016068490-2
Filing Date: 05/17/2016
Filing Type: CONTINUATION
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
COMERICA BANK
Filing 2
Filing Number: 2011076402-7
Filing Date. 05126/2011
Filing Type: CONTINUATION
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
COMERICA BANK
Filing 1
Filing Number 2008147829-0
Filing Date: 09/23/2008
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
COMERICA BANK
Assignees 1
GOOD CONSULTING LLC
O-21 Fennessey St SW
Grand Rapids, MI 49534-6707

69. I Debtor [Active 109/09/1998 12488565 KS Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026026
Page 59
301 Sw 10th Ave
Topeka. KS 66612
Filing 3
Filing Number 3962230
Filing Date. 09/07/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK, AS AGENT
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519
Filing 2
Filing Number 2578421
Filing Date: 08/03/1999
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Expiration: 09/09/2003
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
Collateral
EQUIPMENT
Filing 1
Filing Number 2488565
Filing Date: 09/09/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Expiration: 09/09/2003
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECH INTL INC
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT.COMPUTER EQUIPMENT
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.ctit;)N(F IDENTIAL DB-SONY-0026027
Page 60

70. I Debtor 'Active 106/23/1998 1953208 MI Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
430 W Allegan
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 2
Filing Number: 14005C
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF MICHIGAN, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number 95320B
Filing Date: 06/23/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF MACOMB, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Collateral
ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:PARTNERSHIP INTERESTINCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;ACCOUNT(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;GENERAL INTANGIBLE(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:FIXTURES INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS INCLUDING PROCEED

71. 'Debtor 'Active 106/23/1998 1953198 MI Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
430 W Allegan
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 2
Filing Number. 14004C
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026028
Page 61
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF MICHIGAN, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number 953198
Filing Date: 06/23/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF WONDERLAND, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004
Collateral
ACCOUNT(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUCTS;NEGOTIABLE
INSTRUMENTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:PARTNERSHIP INTERESTINCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:CONTRACT RIGHTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;INVENTORY INCLUDINGPROCEEDS AND

72. Debtor Active 06/23/1998 2466609 KS Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
301 Sw 10th Ave
Topeka. KS 66612
Filing 2
Filing Number: 3647070
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF KANSAS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026029
Page 62
Filing 1
Filing Number 2466609
Filing Date: 0612311998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Expiration: 06/23/2003
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF OLATHE INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Collateral
PARTNERSHIP INTERESTSINCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:EQUIPMENT INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:INVENTORY INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:GENERAL INTANGIBLE(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:ACCOUNT(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND PRODUC

73. (Debtor 'Active 106/23/1998 12466608 KS Amendment
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
301 Sw 10th Ave
Topeka. KS 66612
Filing 2
Filing Number 3647104
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! OF KANSAS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number: 2466608
Filing Date: 06/23/1998
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Expiration: 06/23/2003
Debtor 1
JJP OF KANSAS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCIANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026030
Page 63
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Collateral
PARTNERSHIP INTERESTSINCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;ACCOUNT(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;GENERAL INTANGIBLE(S) INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;INVENTORY INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS:ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND
PRODUCTS;CONTRACT RIGHTS INCLUDING PROCEEDS AND;

74. Debtor Active 06/23/1998 1003869897 IL Partial Release
Filing 2
Filing Number. 004384981
Filing Date: 05/14/2001
Filing Type: PARTIAL RELEASE
Expiration: 06/23/2003
Collateral
ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE. INVENTORY. CONTRACT RIGHTS CHATTEL
PAPER. GENERAL INTANGIBLE,WITH PROCEEDS.WITH PRODUCTS
Filing 1
Filing Number: 004384980
Filing Date: 05/14/2001
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT TO A SECURED PARTY
Expiration: 06/23/2003
Debtor 1
JEEPERS INC
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES LLC
153 North Ave
Weston, MA 02493-2032
Collateral
ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE. INVENTORY. CONTRACT RIGHTS CHATTEL
PAPER, GENERAL INTANGIBLE,WITH PROCEEDS.WITH PRODUCTS

75. (Debtor (Active I '99606780 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741587
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026031
Page 64
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number 99606780
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007

76. I Debtor 1 Active I 199606779 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741588
Filing Date: 09/052000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number 99606779
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007

77. )Debtor 1Active 1 199606778 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741586
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026032
Page 65
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number: 99606778
Debtor 1
JEEPERS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007

78. !Debtor 1 Active 1 198593027 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number. 00741585
Filing Date. 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number. 98593027
Debtor 1
JEEPERS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026033
Page 66
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
79 I Debtor Active I 198593026 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741584
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number 98593026
Debtor 1
JEEPERS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston. MA 02211-00O1

80. 'Debtor 1 Active I 198593025 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number. 00741583
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QCIANI(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026034
Page 67
1 Federal St
Boston. MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number: 98593025
Debtor 1
JEEPERS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001

81. I Debtor 'Active I 198593024 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741582
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston. MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number: 98593024
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston. MA 02211-0001
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026035
Page 68

82. !Debtor (Active I 198593023 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number: 00741581
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEERERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston. MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number 98593023
Debtor 1
JEERERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001

83. I Debtor (Active I 198593022 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741590
Filing Date 09/052000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEERERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number 98593022
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.Q11;)N(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026036
Page 69
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston. MA 02211-00O1

84. I Debtor (Active I 198593021 MA Amendment
Filing 3
Filing Number. 00741599
Filing Date: 09/052000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
166 Lafayette Rd
Salisbury. MA 01952-1507
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741591
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston, MA 02211-0001
Filing 1
Filing Number: 98593021
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.ckft;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SONY-0026037
Page 70
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FLEET NATIONAL BANK
1 Federal St
Boston. MA 02211-00O1

85. 'Debtor 'Active I 198587342 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741597
Filing Date! 09/0512000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519
Filing 1
Filing Number 98587342
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519

86. [Debtor I Active 1 198587341 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number. 00741598
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026038
Page 71
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
Filing 1
Filing Number 98587341
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519

87. (Debtor (Active I '98587340 MA Amendment
Filing 3
Filing Number 00741596
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
8321 Concord Mills Blvd
Concord. NC 28027-6460
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut Hill St
Philadelphia, PA 19107
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741592
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026039
Page 72
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
Filing 1
Filing Number 98587340
Debtor 1
JEEPERS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519

88. IDebtor !Active I 198576568 MA Amendment
Filing 3
Filing Number 00741594
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
Filing 2
Filing Number 99651031
Filing Date: 08/03/1999
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026040
Page 73
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
Filing 1
Filing Number: 98576568
Debtor 1
JEEPERS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007

89. (Debtor (Active I 198576567 MA Amendment
Filing 3
Filing Number 00741595
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia, PA 19107-3519
Filing 2
Filing Number 99651022
Filing Date: 08/03/1999
Filing Type: ASSIGNMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Assignees 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
Filing 1
Filing Number: 98576567
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026041
Page 74
Debtor 1
JEEPERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007

90. 'Debtor 'Active I 198559100 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00718865
Filing Date 05/2312000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF MASSACHUSETTS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number 98559100
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF METHUEN, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004

91. 'Debtor (Active I '98559096 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number. 00718857
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF AUBURN HILLS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SONY-0026042
Page 75
226 Airport Retry
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number: 985590%
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF AUBURN HILLS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Hwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004

92. 'Debtor 'Active I 198559092 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number: 00718874
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1

J. J. P. OF KANSAS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number 98559092
Debtor 1

J. .1. P. OF KANSAS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004

93. 'Debtor 'Active I '98559091 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00718868
Filing Date. 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF MACOMB, INC.
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026043
Page 76
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number. 98559091
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF MACOMB, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
Imperial, Bnak
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004

94. (Debtor 'Active I '98559089 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00718860
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type. AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF MICHIGAN. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number. 98559089
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF WONDERLAND. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004

95. 'Debtor "Active 1 198559086 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number: 00718873
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.c2C;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026044
Page 77
Filing Date: 05123/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF GLEN BURNIE. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number: 98559086
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF GLEN BURNIE, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004

96. 'Debtor 'Active I 198559083 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00718862
Filing Date: 05/23/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF KANSAS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number, 98559083
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF OLATHE, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026045
Page 78

97. !Debtor (Active I '98559080 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00721039
Filing Date: 06/02/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1

J. J. P. OF MARYLAND. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose. CA 95110-1004
Filing 1
Filing Number 98559080
Debtor 1

J. J. P. OF MARYLAND, INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
IMPERIAL BANK
226 Airport Pkwy
San Jose, CA 95110-1004

98. (Debtor (Active I 100686727 MA Amendment
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741589
Filing Date: 09/05/2000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington. MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Filing 1
Filing Number 00686727
Debtor 1
JEEPERS. INC.
60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026046
Page 79
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007

99. I Debtor I Closed l 10/22/1997 197-582650 UT Termination
Filing Office Information
UCC DIV
160 East 300 South
Salt Lake City, UT 84111
Filing 1
Filing Number 97-582650
Filing Date. 06/15/2000
Filing Type: TERMINATION
Debtor 1
JEERERS, INC.
60 Hickory Dr Fl 5
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Secured Party Info 1
MOUNTAIN COIN MACHINE DIST
3753 S State St
Salt Lake City. UT 841154812

100. Debtor Closed 98531780 MA UCC-3
Termination
Filing 4
Filing Number 200216780680
Filing Date: 12/09/2002
Filing Type: UCC-3 TERMINATION
Debtor 1
JEERERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
CITIZENS BANK OF MASSACHUSETTS
28 State St
Boston. MA 02109-1775
Filing 3
Filing Number: 200215400200
Filing Date. 10/08/2002
Filing Type: CONTINUATION
Debtor 1
JEERERS!, INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.cON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026047
Page 80
Secured Party Info 1
CITIZENS BANK OF MASSACHUSETTS
28 State St
Boston, MA 02109-1775
Filing 2
Filing Number 00741593
Filing Date: 09/052000
Filing Type: AMENDMENT
Debtor 1
JEEPERS!. INC.
63 South Ave
Burlington, MA 01803-4903
Secured Party Info 1
FIRST UNION NATIONAL BANK
1339 Chestnut St
Philadelphia. PA 19107-3519
Filing 1
Filing Number 98531780
Debtor 1
WEBSTER ENGINEERING CO.. INC.
50 Ceylon St
Boston, MA 02121-2004
Secured Party Info 1
CITIZENS BANK OF MASSACHUSETTS
28 State St
Boston, MA 02109-1775
Real Property (0 current, 0 prior)
Personal Property (0 current, 0 prior)
Associates
Executives. Prior - 9 rior executive s found
For internal use on y
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026048
Page 81
Registered Agents - 5 registered agent(s) found

NO. NAME ADDRESS STATE DATE(S)
1. C T CORPORATION SYSTEM 155 Federal St Ste 700
Boston, MA 02110-1727
Massachuset
is
08/11/1998 -
09/18/2018

2. THE CORPORATION COMPANY 120 S Central Ave
Saint Louis, MO 63105-1705
Missouri 10/11/1996 -
09/19/2018

3. THE CORPORATION COMPANY,
INC.
515 S Kansas Ave
Topeka. KS 66603-3405
Kansas 07/15/2006 -
09/20/2018
4. THE CORPORATION TRUST
INCORPORATED
300 E Lombard St
Baltimore. MD 21202-3219
Maryland 07/15/1996 -
09/05/2018

5. Connolly, Mary-Elise 800 South St Ste 355
Waltham. MA 02453-1457
Massachuset
is
03/23/2000 -
09/18/2018
Possible  Employees  - 0 current, 7 prior employees found

NO. NAME ADDRESS STATUS DATE(S)
1. Bardury, Nadine
BRANCH MANAGER
91 E North Ave
Glendale Heights, IL 60139-
3496
Prior

2. Bebear, Guilaume 60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Prior
3. Bebear, Guillaume 60 Hickory Dr
Waltham. MA 02451-1013
Prior

4. Geatches, Todd
MANAGER
700 Hungerford Dr
Rockville, MD 20850-1724
Prior
04/1997
5. Pesnell, Sean
MANAGER
700 Hungerford Dr
Rockville. MD 20850.1724
Prior

6. Pollack, Lester 60 Hickory Dr
Waltham MA 02451-1013
Prior
7. Tomai, William M 60 Hickory Dr
Waltham, MA 02451-1013
Prior
Person Associates - 2 other • erson associates found
Possible Connected Business - 100 Possible Connected Businesses showing out of
188
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.cf;;?N(F IDENTIAL DB-SONY-0026049
Page 82
A::
Ta:14L4

8. PENES DC 1059 Berea RJ
Richmond, KY 4 -3401
Madison County
. BR ASSOCIATES, INC. 700 N Green River Rd
Evansville, IN 47715-2416

10. BRADLEY ; 3
40-2650
11. C 4 P Pi ‘I' COMPANY, .. centre Dr S
10-2079
12. C D'S SEAFOOD OF MONROEVILLE LLC 1591 S Alabama Ave
Monroeville, AL 36460-3019
Monroe County

13. CAPTAIN D S PO Box 229
Leitchfield, KY 42755-0229
Grayson County
14. CAPTAIN D 5 PO Box 40
West Plains, MO 65775-0040
Nowell County

15. CAPTAIN D S 112 N Highway 52
Mancha Corner, SC 29461-3910
Berkeley County
16. CAPTAIN D S 1200 1st Ave SE
Moultrie, GA 31768-5008
Colguitt County

17. CAPTAIN D 5 123 Footway Dr
Charlotte, NC 28213-7101
Mecklenburg County
18. CAPTAIN D S 176 Country Club Dr
Waynesville, NC 28786-4722
Haywood County

19. CAPTAIN D S 2328 N Interstate Dr
Norman, OK 73072-2991
Cleveland County
20. CAPTAIN D S 521 Naccorkle Ave SW
Saint Albans, WV 2517]-1638
Kanawha County

21. CAPTAIN D S SEAFOOD 12406 Ashford Hollow Dr
Sugar Land, TX 77470-6166
Fort Bend County
22. CAPTAIN D 5 SEAFOOD 2614 Harry Nichols
Madison, IN 47250-4646
Jefferson County

23. CAPTAIN I ..5 H Broadway St
,:--it Memphis, AR 72301-3903
•I London County
24. CAPTAIN D 5 .;:- - .rt Ave
, TN 38111-5621
, county

25. CAPTAIN D S SEAr.....g k AURANT 10711 K 7 Milo Rd
Detroit, MI 48221-1919
Wayne County
26. CAPTAIN D S SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 3218 Victory Dr
Columbus. GA 31903-1013
Moscone County

27. CAPTAIN D S SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 6380 Brandt Pike
Dayton, OH 45424-4041
Montgomery County
28. CAPTAIN D S SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 6554 Forest Hill Dr
Forest Hill, T7( 76140-2206
Tarrant County

29. CAPTAIN D S SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 800 N Davis Ave
Cleveland, MS 38712-2104
Bolivar Carat:
10. CAPTAIN D'S 13016 Ut , ,
Dade C:'

31. CAPTAIN D'S OF SOMERSET GENERAL PARTNERSHIP 356 Hells :-table Pa
Science 11111, KY 42553-9317
Pulaski County

32. CAPTAIN DS Bessemer Super Hwy
Fairfield, AL 35064
Jefferson County
33. CAPTAIN DS PO Box 1537
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CONE I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026050
Page 83
us*
'WAIN DS FO Box 594
Wynne, AR 72196-0594
Cross County
3). CAPTAIN DS 10414 E Colonial Dr
Orlando, It 32817-4425
Orange betty

36. CAPTAIN DS 1066 NA, r T. Rd
Thomann, '24-7513
N2d .ff
37. CAPTAIN DS
42% • - 44
Gad
38. CAPTAIN DS 1592 State Highway 34 S
Terrell, TX 75160-4864
Kaufman County

39. CAPTAIN DS 1906 Arcadia St
Hattiesburg, KS 39401-6364
Forrest County
40. CAPTAIN DS 2530 Balyeat Dr
Lima, OH 45805-4019
Allen County

41. CAPTAIN DS 312A Wilson Pike Car
Brentwood, TN 31027-2741
Williamson County
42. CAPTAIN DS 350 Stanley K Tanger Blvd
Locust Grove, GA 30248-3650
Henry County

43. CAPTAIN DS 402 Governor, Dr SW
Huntsville, AL 35801-5124
Madison County
44. CAPTAIN DS 4120 W Cypress St
Tampa, FL 33607-384e
Hillsborough County

45. CAPTAIN DS 5792 Coventry Ln
Fort Wayne, IN 46004-7141
Allen County
46. CAPTAIN DS LLC 1133 3rd Ave N
Birmingham, AL 35204-4509
Jefferson County

47. CAPTAIN DS LLC 115 W Grand Ave
Rainbow City, AL 35906-3275
Etowah County
48. CAPTAIN DS LLC 2411 Stringtown Rd
Evansville, IN 47711-3307
Vanderburg!) County

49. CAPTAIN DS LLC 54 E May St
Winder, GA 30680-1914
Barrow County
50. CAPTAIN DS LLC 5694 Fairborn Rd
Douglasvllle, GA 30134-2562
Douglas County

51. CAPTAIN DS LW 624 Grossman; Part Ste 30
Nashville, TN 31211-3611
Davidson County
52. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD PO Box 1143
Americus, GA 31709-1143
Sumter County

53. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD 1012 Highway 62 E
Mountain Hose, AR 72653-3216
Baxter County
54. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD 10703 Jones Rd
Houston, TX 77065-4215
Harris County

55. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD 11314 Windy Creek Dr
Pearland, TX 77584-0212
8[Ar^t:A r441,44.,.
CAPTAIN LS SEAF.XL. 19:,%. S Sp44%ItleAd Ave
Bolivar, I40 65613-9684
Polk County

58. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD 2020 Harding Hwy
Lima, OH 45804-3420
Allen County
59. CAPTAIN DS SIMI 2307 E No Highway 54
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QQN(F I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026051
EFrA_00I 73734
Page 84
Durham, NC 21713-2210
Durham County

60. ‘PTAIN DS SEAFOOD 27704 State Highway 249
Tomball, TX 77315-6472
Harris County
61. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD 4340 Elvis Presley Blvd
Memphis, TN 38116-6406

67. CAPTAIN :.: - ' 4 Rd
' A-8110
63. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD KITCHEN • i44.1
'095-1418
64. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 150 N Reynolds Ave
Canon City, CO 81212-4014
Fremont County

65. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 2427 Boundary St
Beaufort, SC 29906-3770
Beaufort County
66. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 2495 S Academy Blvd
Colorado Springs, CO 80916-2407
El Paso County

67. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 300 Brookes Dr Ste 106
Hazelwood, HO 63042-2731
St. Louis County
68. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 4245 Pouncey Tract Rd
Glen Allen, VA 23060-5829
Henrico County

69. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 4337 woodbriar Dr
Toledo, ON 43623-1539
Lucas County
70. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 5514 N Jim Hiller Rd
Dallas, TX 75228-7011
Dallas County

71. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANT 607 2nd Ave E
Oneonta, AL 35121-1509
Blount County
72. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD r," ANT 6751 Johnson c•-
Mission, KS i- - -LO

73. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD i, A:,
IL:-
Ca:
74. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD , ' ',ANT 44
7:,'
Di,
75. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD AL:Tr:RANTS 10013 Hull Stied. 4 :
North Chesterfield, . .
Chesterfield County

76. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 1108 Parts Rd
Hayfield, KY 42066-I4
Graves County
77. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 1110 Old W Liberty SI
Sumter, SC 29150-4713
Sumter County

78. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 15760 East Noy
Channelview, TX 77530-412 7
Harris County
79. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 1626 Us 31W Byp
Bowling Green, la 42101-3029
Warren County

80. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 4324 Barringer Dr Ste IC:
Charlotte, MC 28217-150C
Mecklenburg Cc.u4ty

81. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 50 Turner Rd
North Chester: . . %A 21225-6434
rhA, , t 41.' 1 c-: .:
Si. CAPTAIN L:f. C.E.Arcti° 7 7 'ANTS /11'4 :i:a4e RU
Memphis, TN 38133-3927
Shelby County

84. CAPTAIN DS SEAFOOD RESTAURANTS 6090 N Davis Hwy
Pensacola, Pt 32514-7570
Eseambia County
85. CAPTAIN I.7 :71i, • ' 7 7. RANTS 8342 Us Highway 51 N
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CONE I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026052
Page 85
M:.
She . : .:.t.,

80. CENTRE MANAGEMENT CO 10848 70th Rd
Forest Hills, NY 11375 -35-
Queens County
87. CENTRE PARTNERS MANAGEMENT LLC 11766 Wilshire Blvd Ste 890
Los Anaeles, CA 90025-6571

88. CHESAPEAK EYE CENTER :'0 3
-'199
89. COURTYARD HEALTH CARE CENTER, INC.
90. COVENANT CARE 405 N Johnston Ave
Hemet, CA 92543-701
Riverside County

91. COVENANT CARE CALIFORNIA INC 410 N Winchester Blvd
Santa Clara, CA 95050-6325
Santa Clara County
92. COVENANT CARE CALIFORNIA INC 6821 24th St
Sacramento, CA 95822-4037
Sacramento County

93. CARE CLINTON NOUSE, LLC 809 it Freeman St
Frankfort, IN 46041-2944
Clinton County
94. [RISES 200 31st AVe N Ste 200
Nashville, TN 37203-1205
Davidson County

95. TuRPRISES 3010 Poston Ave Ste 150
Nashville, TN 37203-6305
Davidson County
96. 04....J.0 BARD LLC 5900 Nil 39th St
Warr Acres, OK 73122-2009
Oklahoma County

97. D'S OP KENTUCKY INC 2530 Balyeat Dr
Lima, ON 45805-4019
Allen County
98. D'S OF C4410 INC 2530 Balyeat Di
Lima, ON 45805-4019
Allen County

99. DE:.-' .KGS, LLC :e1/ W Central Ave
' epee, CA 93436-2 701
*a P le:ra County
10D. :- Dr Ste 101
:8217-1500
Business Associates - 62 business associates found '.0DRESS ROLE
,, Box 897
:es Moines, IA 50306-0897
sulk County
UCC
BELTWAY PLAZA SHOPPING CENTER .he Quantum Building 4912DEL
Pothesda, MD 20814
eontgomery County
UCC

3. BELTWAY PLAZA SHOPPING CENTER :335 University Blvd E
Hyattsville, MD 20783-4600
iance George's County
UCC

4. BETS0t4 ENTERPRISES :03 Paterson Plank Rd
Carlstadt, NJ 07072-2307
Bergen County
UCC
5. CENTRE CAPITA: INVESTORS II, L.P. 30 Rockefeller Plz Ste 5050
New York, NY 10112-0015
New York County
VC:

6. :YEMPT INVESTORS II 877 Supreme Dr
Bensenville, IL 60106-1106
DUpage County
7. JOINVU7 - LTD PARTNERSHIP 877 Supreme Dr
Bensenville, IL 60106-1106
Donat. County
UCC

8. CENTRE PARALLEL MANAGEMENT PARTNERS LTD
PARTNERSHIP
877 Supreme Dr
Bensenville, IL 60106-1106
Dupage County
UCC

9. CENTRE PARALLEL MANAGEMENT PARTNERS, L.P. 30 Rockefeller P32 Ste 5050
New York, NY 10112-0015
UCC
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED R.QQN(F I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026053
EFrA_00I 73736
Page 86
ditY

10. CENTRE PARALLEL MANAGEMENT PARTNERS, L.P.
C/0 CENTRE PARALLE
3: i -,-,-Iler Piz ::..-
New :ink, NY 10112-051:
Na, York County
UCC

11. CENTRE PARTNERS COINVESTMENT, L.P. 30 Rocknollor Plz Sto 505D
New York, NY 10112-0015
New Yort County
UCC
' -T-fl:r ,N.: : ...,,,,, - - '•

14. DELTRONIC LABS INC .-cnt/Lion
15. EKLECOD. 4 Clinton S,
Syracuse, NY
*or:doge Co';
UCC
16. FIRST UNION NATICtUa. BANK :339 Cheskni/
hLladelphti, --,',19
,hlladelphio ...
UCC

17. FLEET NATIONAL BANK , Federal St
3-tston, MA 02211-0001
UCc
18. FLEET NATIONAL BANK rdo7 UCC
19. FLEET NATIONAL BANK
::7ston, 751 02211-0001
::uffolk County
ODC

20. GB MALL LIMITED PARTNERSHIP :335 University Blvd E
Hyattsville, HD 20701-4600
:zinc. Georce so County
UCC

21. GB MALL LIMITED PARTNERSHIP The Quantum Building 49121t1
Bethesda, MD 20614
Montgomery County
UCC
22. GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES, LW 153 North Ave
Huston, MA 02491-2032
mIddlesex County
UCC

23. GLOBAL ENTERTAINMENT VENTURES, LW .34 N Main
Weston, MA 02493
likddlesex County
UCC
24. GOOD CONSULTING 1LG _ -21 Penn.'s:set: St sw
,-rand Rapier, --
ttawa Count.,
UC7

25. IMPERIAL BANK :26 Ai:,
santa
26. IMPERIAL RANK
27. IMPERIAL BANK
28. INNOVATIVE COW -Fr.'s :,, ,-.
INC.

29. J. J. P. OF LQ.k.3 , :. .
, HA 02451-1013
-Jox County
30. J. J. P. OF MARYLAND, INC.
,,41tharn, MA 02451-1013
Middlesex County
UCC

31. JEEPERS OF AUBURN HILLS, In -. L0 Hickory Dr
Waltham, na 02451-1013
V.iddlesex County
UCC
32. JEEPERS OF GLEN BURNIE, INC. :0 Hickory Dr
walthorn, MA 02451-1013
Kiddiesex Count
UCC

33. JEEPERS OF ILLINOIS INC 300 South St Ste 355
Waltham, MA 02453-1457
Yiddlenex County
Judgment/Lien
34. JEEPERS OF JERSEY GARDENS pr .' tHctory Dr
_ --k 3o, MA 02451-1013
..,tex County
Judgeontiiinn

35. JEEPERS OF MACOMB, INC. :.:kory Dr
.,Itham, MA 02451-1013
4tildleaex County
UO2
36. JEEPERS OF MD INC -'0 South St Ste 355
, ,..‘ 02453-1457
Judgment/Lien
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R.QoAlF I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026054
Pace 87

37. JEERERS OF NE:hoEN, ::::. ... , 1.!
F.1 them, MA 02451-1013
Elddlesex County
UOC
38. JEEPERS OF NJ INC ,..0 Hickory Dr
Waltham, 981 02451-1013
Middlesex County
Judgment/Lien

39. JEEPERS OF OLATHE, INs%
40. JEEPERS OF WoNN-3.7',. ,
41. JEE'iTs.-. ,,- ..;..ANT CEN'7 7
92.
43. JEL. . ":, .,4 '. ..., ; -:
i..7,1tham, Mat 02451-:
,-:Iddlesex County
uil

41. JEEPERSI OF WA1Uz::, ::.:. •JO Hickory Dr
hAlthamr MA 02451- 1
middlosirx County
UCC
45. JUNGLE JIM FLATLAND OF UTAH 60 Hickory Dr Fl 5
Waltham, MA 02401-1013
Middlesex County
UCC

46. JUNGLE JIMS FLATLANDS 60 Hickory Dr FL 5
Waltham, MA 02451-1023
Middlesex County
UCC
47. JUNGLE JIMS FLATLANDS SVCORP TRU 800 South St Ste 355
Waltham, NA 02453-1457
Middlesex County
Judgment/Lion

48. LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL, INC. 221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Fairfield County
UCC
49. MACOMB MALL ASSOCIATES LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP, A MICHIGAN LIMIT
25800 Northwestern Hwy Ste 750
Southfield, MI 48075-8403
Oakland County
UOC

50. MOSS DISTRIBUTING, INC. 1801 Guthrie Ave
Los Moines, IA 501l6-1735
loik County
UCC
51. MOUNTAIN COIN MACHINE DIST •53 S State St
salt Lake City, UT 09115-481T
Salt Lake County
UCC

52. HMCO CYBERTAINMENT 877 Supreme Dr
Bensenville, IL 60106-1106
Dupont County
UCC
53. NAKCO CYBERTAINMENT INC. 872 Suprylw D:
Peasenv • ,
Oipant.
tv-,'

54. NO METROMALL URBAN RENEWA: .
' - %ft UH 4 215-4:0C
in County
55. PR GEORGES CO ND JUdglient/tAr.-
56. PYRAMID COMPANY OF BUFFALO ; Ainton Sq
Syracuse, NY 13202
onondaga County
UCC

57. R1E. . v:LL ARONSON 3 Bethesda Metro Ctr Ste 650
Bethesda, ND 20824-6336
Montgomery County
Judgment/Lion

68. STATE BOARD OF ADMIN OF FLORIDA %CENTRE
PARALLEL PIGNUT PRTN
30 Rockefeller PIT Ste 5050
NOW York, NY 10112-0015
New York County
UCC

59. STATE BOARD OF AMINISTRATICN OF FLORIDA,
C/O CENTRE PARALLE
30 Rockefeller Plz Ste 5050
New York, NY 10112-0015
New York County
UCC

60. UNIFIRST CORPORATION 6201 Sheriff Rd
Hyattsville, HD 20705-4802
Pilnco George's County
61. WEBSTER ENGINEERING CO., INC. 50 Ceylon St
Dorchester, HA 02121-2004
Suffolk County
UCC

62. WESTERN FINANCE 4 LEASE, INC. PO Box 640
Devils Lake, ND 58301-0640
Ramsey County
UCC
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QQNE I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026055
Page 88
Sources
Key:
AHigh Risk Indicator. These symbols may prompt you to investigate further.
Moderate Risk Indicator. These symbols may prompt you to investigate further.
.r " General Information Indicator. These symbols inform you that additional information is provided.
ti# The most recent telephone listing as reported by Electronic Directory Assistance.
Wireless Phone Indicator. These symbols indicate a cell phone number.
Residential Phone Indicator. These symbols indicate a residential phone number.
Business Phone Indicator. These symbols indicate a business phone number.

ke) Shared Phone Indicator. These symbols indicate the phone number may be shared between wireless and landline
service.
QD FAX Indicator. These symbols indicate a FAX number.
(4)  Govemment Phone Indicator. Th ese symbols indicate a government phone number.
Important: The Public Records and commercially available data sources used on reports have errors. Data is sometimes 
ordered poorly. processed
inconectly and is generally not free horn defect This system should not be relied upon as definitively accurate. Before 
relying on any data this system
supplies. it should be independently verified. For Secretary of Slate documents. the b aning data is for information 
purposes only and is not an official
record. Certified copies may be obtained horn that bdividual stales Department of Slate.
Your DPPA Permissible Use is: Debt Recovery/Fraud
Your GLBA Permissible Use is: Legal Compliance
Copyright O 2018 LexisNexis. a division of Rood Elsevier Inc. Al Rights Reserved.
2 OF 2 RECORD(S)
SmartLinx ® Comprehensive Business Report
Report Created:9-27-2018 2.40 PM EST I FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY l Copyright Cr 2018 LexisNexis.
All rights reserved.
Search Terms - company(Jeepers. Inc) radius(15)
Executives - Current (0) Incorporation/SOS (1) Operations/Sites (1) Sales (0)
Licenses (1) URLs (1) Real Property - Current (0) Real Property • Prior (1)
MVRs - Current (0) MVRs - Prior (0) Watercraft - Current (0) Watercraft - Prior (0)
Aircraft - Current (0) Aircraft - Prior (0) Bankruptcy Fibngs (0) Judgments & Liens Filings (4)
UCC Filings (3) Executives - Prior (1) Registered Agents (0) Name Variations (4)
Possible Employees (0) Person Asseriates (0) Business Associates (12) TI Ns (1)
Possible Connected Parent Company (0) Industry Information (1)
Business (13)
View All Sources (29)
Business Summary
Name Address Phone
JEEPER'S OF SOUTHFIELD INC 21500 Northwestern Hwy
Southfield. MI 48075-5018
Oakland County 410 (Most Recent Liston)
07/01/201509/25/2018
® (Business)
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026056
Page 89
LexID Established TIN
0000-7580-8734 2001
(17 Years in Business)
20.083XXXX
At a Glance
Real Property 0 UCC Debtor 3
Personal Property 0 Bankruptcy 0
Secured Assets 0 Judgments/Liens 4
Executives 0 Foreclosure/Notice of Default 0
Name Variations - 4 name variations found

NO. NAME
1. JEEPER'S OF SOUTHFIELD INC
2. JEEPERS
3. JEEPERS OF SOUTHFIELD
4. JEEPERS! INC
TINs -1 TINs found

NO. TIN NAME
1. 20.083XXXX JEEPER'S OF SOUTHFIELD INC
JEEPERS
Business Profile
Executives: Current - 0 executive(s) found
Incorporation/SOS (0 active, 1 other)

NO. NAME FILING TYPE STATUS FILING
DATE
FILING NO. STATE
1. JEEPER'S OF
SOUTHFIELD INC
N/A 02/17/2004 15601D
Additional Details
Business Status: N/A
Filing Type: SOS Filing
Expiration: 05/15/2005
For Profit Unknown
Origin: Other Business Filing
OperatingLocations - Showing 1 location(s)

NO. ADDRESS METRO AREA PHONE
1. 21500 Northwestern Hwy Ste 2103
Southfield, MI 48075-5037
Oakland County
Detroit. MI

as) eceni Listing)
07101/2015 - 09/25t2018
8
(Fax)
Sales - 0 record(s) found
Parent Company - 0 record(s) found
Industry Information
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.WANI(E IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026057
Page 90
SIC NAIC
5812 Eating Places 71311 Amusement and Theme Parks
7993 Coin-operated Amusement Devices 713110 Amusement and Theme Parks
7996 Amusement Parks 713120 Amusement Arcades
713990 All Other Amusement and
Recreation Industries
Industry Description: PARTY SUPPLIES
Business Description.
Licenses -1 licenses found

NO. LICENSE NO. DESCRIPTION ISSUER ISSUED/EXPIRED
1. 2001000394 COMPANY MI CARNIVAUAMUSEMENT Issued: 01/07/2005
URLs -1 URLs found
MWEEPERs.coM
Bankruptcy (0 active, 0 closed)
Judgments/Liens (4 filings

NO. FILING TYPE AMOUNT ALE DATE FILE NUMBER JURISDICTION
1. CIVIL NEW FILING 01/27/2012 120492LT MI
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF SOUTHFIELD
21500 Northwestern Hwy # 900
Southfield. MI 48075-5018
Debtor 2
MOM DAD AND ME INC
21500 Northwestern Hwy # 900
Southfield, MI 48075-5018
Tax Id: 20-4594639
Creditor 1
NORTHLAND CENTER MICHIGAN LLC
Filing Information
Filing Date 01/27/2012
Original Filing Number. 120492LT
Jurisdiction: MI
Eviction: YES
Filing 1
Filing Number. 120492LT
Filing Type: CIVIL NEW FILING
Agency: OAKLAND COUNTY 46TH DISTRICT COURT
Agency State: MI
Agency County: OAKLAND

2. STATE TAX LIEN $420.00 04/21/2008 8K40232PG716 MI
RELEASE
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QC;IN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026058
Page 91
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF SOUTHFIELD
21500 Northwestern Hwy
Southfield, MI 48075-5018
Debtor 2
MOM DAD AND ME INC
21500 Northwestern Hwy
Southfield, MI 48075-5018
Tax Id: 20-4594639
Creditor 1
STATE OF MICHIGAN
Filing Information
Filing Date: 04/21/2008
Original Filing Number. BK40232PG716
Jurisdiction: MI
Amount: $420.00
Filing 1
Filing Number. BK41389PG685
Filing Type: STATE TAX LIEN RELEASE
Agency. OAKLAND COUNTY REGISTER OF DEEDS
Agency State: MI
Agency County: OAKLAND
Release Date: 08/06/2009

3. STATE TAX LIEN I S420.00 04/21/2008 MI
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF SOUTHFIELD
21500 Northwestern Hwy
Southfield. MI 48075-5018
Creditor 1
STATE OF MICHIGAN
Filing Information
Filing Date: 04/21/2008
Jurisdiction: MI
Amount: $420.00
Filing 1
Filing Type: STATE TAX LIEN
Agency: OAKLAND COUNTY REGISTER OF DEEDS
Agency State: MI
A en Coun :OAKLAND

4. CIVIL JUDGMENT $11.741.00 08/09/2007 0732137GC MI
Debtor 1
JEEPERS OF AUBURN INC
4240 Baldwin Rd
For Internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QQN(F I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026059
Page 92
Auburn Hills, MI 48326-1267
Tax Id: 20.0833106
Debtor 2
JEEPERS OF GRATIOT INC
46531 Hawkins St
Shelby Twp. MI 48315-5726
Tax Id: 20-8059329
Debtor 3
JEEPERS OF ROSEVILLE INC
32241 Gratiot Ave
Roseville, MI 48066.1100
Debtor 4
JEEPERS OF SOUTHFIELD INC
21500 Northwestern Hwy
Southfield. MI 48075-5018
Creditor 1
SCHAFER AND WEINER LLC
Filing Information
Filing Date 08/09/2007
Original Filing Number. 0732137GC
Jurisdiction: MI
Amount: $11,741.00
Eviction: NO
Filing 1
Filing Number 0732137GC
Filing Type: CIVIL JUDGMENT
Agency: OAKLAND COUNTY 48TH DISTRICT COURT
Agency State: MI
Agency County: OAKLAND
UCC Filings (3 debtor, 0 cred tor)

NO. ROLE STATUS ORIG.
FILING
DATE
ORIG. FILE
NUMBER
JURISDICTI
ON
FILE TYPE
1. Debtor Active 11/21/2005 2005201142-5 MI Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
430 W Allegan St 1st Fl
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 1
Filing Number: 2005201142-5
Filing Date: 11/21/2005
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPER'S OF SOUTHFIELD. INC
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026060
Page 93
21500 Northwestern Hwy
Southfield, MI 48075-5018
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton. CT 06897-4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT LEASED

2. 'Debtor 'Active 111/01/2004 12004213241.7 MI Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
430 W Allegan St 1st Fl
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 1
Filing Number 2004213241-7
Filing Date: 11/01/2004
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPER'S OF SOUTHFIELD, INC.
21500 Northwestern Hwy
Southfield, MI 48075-5018
Secured Party Info 1
LEASING TECHNOLOGIES INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897.4007
Collateral
EQUIPMENT

3. (Debtor (Active '04/06/2001 I D760676 MI Initial Filing
Filing Office Information
SECRETARY OF STATE/UCC DIVISION
430 W Allegan
Lansing, MI 48918
Filing 1
Filing Number: D760676
Filing Date: 04/06/2001
Filing Type: INITIAL FILING
Debtor 1
JEEPERS! INC.
29859 Plymouth Rd
Livonia, MI 48150-2114
Secured Party Info 1
INNOVATIVE CONCEPTS IN ENTERTAINMENT, INC
10123 Main St
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QPN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026061
Page 94
Clarence. NY 14031-2164
Collateral
EQUIPMENT
Real Property (0 current, 1 prior

NO. ADDRESS STATUS PURCHASE PRICE SALE PRICE STATE
1. 21500 Northwestern Hwy
Southfield. MI 48075.5018
Oakland County
Source: B
Prior MI
Owner 1 Information
JEEPERS OF MICHIGAN INCORPORATED
800 South St Ste 35
Waltham, MA 02453-1478
Middlesex County
Legal Information
Parcel Number 99-62-076-490
Assessment Year: 2003
Document Type: ASSESSOR
Assessed Value: 5576.700.00
Type of Address: MISCELLANEOUS (GENERAL)
Personal Property (0 current, 0 prior)
Associates
Executives. Prior -1 prior executive(s) found

NO. NAME TITLE
1. Yazite. Nebal EXECUTIVE - FINANCE
(09P2003)
Registered Agents - 0 registered agent(s) found
Possible Employees - 0 current, 0 prior employees found
Person Associates - 0 other person associates found
Possible Connected Business - 13 businesses found

NO. NAME ADDRESS
1. ARB REPAIR SERVICES 145 Silver Fox Rd
Marshall, TX 75670-2451
Harrison County
2. JEEPER'S OF SOUTHFIELD, INC. 13918 Basilisco Chase Dr
Shelby Township, MI 48315-4248
Macomb County

3. JEEPERS 14600 Lakeside Cir
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CCIN(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026062
Page 95
Sterling Heights, MI 48313-1356
Macomb County

4. JEEPERS 29877 Plymouth Rd
Livonia. MI 48150-2114
Wayne County
5. JEEPERS 32233 Gratiot Ave
Roseville. MI 48066-1147
Macomb County

6. JEEPERS 37212 Alper Dr
Sterling Heights. MI 48312-2202
Macomb County
7. JEEPERS 37292 Charter Oaks Blvd
Clinton Township, MI 48036.2419
Macomb County

8. JEEPERS 4240 Baldwin Rd
Auburn Hills. MI 48326-1267
Oakland County
9. JEEPERS INC Roseville. MI
10. JEEPERS LLC Wixom, MI

11. JEEPERS OF MICHIGAN 21500 Northwestern Northland Hwy
Southfield. MI 48075
Oakland County
12. JEEPERS OF SOUTHFIELD INC 37212 Alper Dr
Sterling Heights, MI 48312-2202
Macomb County

13. JEEPERS! INC. 29859 Plymouth Rd
Livonia, MI 48150-2114
Wayne County
Business Associates - 12 business associates found

NO. NAME ADDRESS ROLE
1. INNOVATIVE CONCEPTS IN
ENTERTAINMENT, INC
10123 Main St
Clarence, NY 14031-2164
Erie County
UCC

2. JEEPERS INCORPORATED 800 South St Ste 35
Waltham, MA 02453-1478
Middlesex County
Real Property
3. JEEPERS OF AUBURN INC 4240 Baldwin Rd
Auburn Hills, MI 48326-1267
Oakland County
Judgment/Lien

4. JEEPERS OF GRATIOT INC 46531 Hawkins St
Shelby Township, MI 48315-5726
Macomb County
Judgment/Lien
5. JEEPERS OF MICHIGAN
INCORPORATED
800 South St Ste 35
Waltham, MA 02453-1478
Middlesex County
Real Property

6. JEEPERS OF ROSEVILLE INC 32241 Gratiot Ave
Roseville, MI 48066-1100
Macomb County
Judgment/Lien
7. JEEPERS! INC. 4240 Baldwin Rd
Auburn Hills. MI 48326-1267
Oakland County
UCC

8. JEEPERS! INC. 32241 Gratiot Ave
Roseville. MI 48066-1100
Macomb County
UCC
9. JEEPERS! INC. 29859 Plymouth Rd
Livonia, MI 48150-2114
Wayne County
UCC
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL DB-SONY-0026063
Page 96

10. LEASING TECHNOLOGIES
INTERNATIONAL. INC.
221 Danbury Rd
Wilton, CT 06897-4007
Fairfield County
UCC
11. MOM DAD AND ME INC 21500 Northwestern Hwy # 900
Southfield. MI 48075.5018
Oakland County
Judgment/Lien
12. NORTHLAND CENTER MICHIGAN LLC Judgment/Lien
Sources
All Sources 29 Source Documents
Real Property 3 Source Documents
Judgment & Uens 4 Source Documents
UCC 3 Source Documents
Government Agency 3 Source Documents
Other Directories 6 Source Documents
Telco 8 Source Documents
Experian FEIN 1 Source Documents
Experian 1 Source Documents
Key:
AHigh Risk Indicator. These symbols may prompt you to investigate further.
I Moderate Risk Indicator. These symbols may prompt you to investigate further.
General Information Indicator. These symbols inform you that additional information is provided.
V The most recent telephone listing as reported by Electronic Directory Assistance.
Wireless Phone Indicator. These symbols indicate a cell phone number.
8 Residential Phone Indicator. These symbols indicate a residential phone number.
8 Business Phone Indicator. These symbols indicate a business phone number.
0 Shared Phone Indicator. These symbols indicate the phone number may be shared between wireless and landline
service.
FAX Indicator. These symbols indicate a FAX number.
© Government Phone Indicator. These symbols indicate a government phone number.
Important: The Public Records and commercially available dale sources used on reports have error. Data is sometimes 
entered poorly, processed
incorrectly and is generally not free from defect This system should not be relied upon as definitively accurate. Before
relying on any dela this system
supplies: it should be independently verified. For Secretary of Slate documents, the laming data Is for information 
purposes only and is not an official
record. cenifis4 copies may be obtained from that individual state's Department of Stale.
Your DPPA Permissible Use is: Debt Recovery/Fraud
Your GLBA Permissible Use is: Legal Compliance
Copyright O 2018 LexisNous. a division of Rood Elsevier Inc. Al Rights Reserved.
LEGAL RESULTS:
Court Cases:
No Information Found
For internal use only
For internal use only
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0026064
EFTA00003059 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
(inferred date: 2018-10-01)
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters,
Suite
13-3,
St.
Thomas.
VI
00802-1348
Phone:
E-mail:
thesaintjames.group(0,gmail.com
Today's
Date:
Employee
Name:
Physical
Address:
Mailing
Address:
Cell
Phone:
E-mail: Title/Position:
I5ngineer
Emergency
Contact
Form
Keshaun
Moms
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
type:
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:
10/01/18
Phone
(other):
Marital
Status:
Drivers
License
No:
Current
Medications:
Doctor's
Name:
Doctors
Phone:
Doctors
Name:
Doctors
Phone:
In
case
of
emergency,
please
contact:
Name: Name:
NM
-
7
Relationship: Relationship:
This
information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others

╭─── Page 1, Image 1 ────╮
│ Emergency Contact Form │
│                        │
│ sanone foorre          │
╰────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003045 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
(inferred date: 2018-10-15)
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters.
Suite
B-3.
St.
Thomas.
VI
00802-1348
Phone:
E-mail:
thesaintjames.group@gmail.com
Emergency
Contact
Form
Today's
Date:
Employee
Name:
Physical
Address'
10/15/18 }Carlos
L
Rodriguez
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:
Thomas.
VI
06802

ro. Red
Hook
a
Mailing
Address.
Cell
Phone:
E-mail:
U
Title/Position:
Faotain
Phone
(other):
Marital
Status:
Driver's
License
No:
I.=
lamed
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
L
Blood
type:
El
A-
D
A+
D
AB-
C
AB+
El
g-
EJ
8+
o-
D
o+
QX
Unknown
Current
Medications:
rime
Doctors
Name:
Doctors
Name:
Livingston
Doctors
Phone:
Doctor's
Phone:
In
case
of
emergency,
please
contact:
Name: Name:
Relationship: Relationship:
Phone: Phone:
This
information
is for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others.
╔═════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Scott J. Link [lawyer] criminal defense attorney 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00806751 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Igor Zinoviev notice of subpoena
(inferred date: 2018-10-15)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

<REDCTED>
Plaintiff,

v.                   No. 17 Civ. 00616 (JGK)

JEFFREY EPSTEIN, GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
<REDACTED>, LESLEY GROFF and <REDACTED>
Defendants.

PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RULE 45 SUBPOENA AND NOTICE OF
TAKING VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF IGOR ZINOVIEV

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT, pursuant to Rules 30 and 45 of the Federal Rules of
Civil Procedure, counsel for Plaintiff, <REDACTED> will take a videotaped deposition as set
forth below:

NAME: Igor Zinoviev

DATE AND TIME: November 15, 2018 at 10:00 a.m.

LOCATION: Boies Schiller Flexner, LLP
575 Lexington Avenue, 7th Floor
New York, NY 10022

The videotaped deposition will be taken upon oral examination before Magna Legal
Services, or any other notary public authorized by law to take depositions. The oral examination
will continue from day to day until completed.

The video operator shall be provided by Magna Legal Services. This deposition is being
taken for the purpose of discovery, for use at trial, or for such other purposes as are permitted
under the rules of this Court.

Plaintiff, <REDACTED> also hereby provides Notice of Service of Subpoena upon Igor
Zinoviev. A copy of the Subpoena is attached to this Notice.

Dated: October 15, 2018.
BOIES SCHILLER FLEXNER LLP
By: /s/ Sigrid McCawley
Sigrid McCawley (Pro Hac Vice)
Meredith Schultz (Pro Hac Vice)
Boies Schiller Flexner LLP
Bradley J. Edwards, Esq. (Pro Hac Vice)
Stanley Pottinger, Esq.
EDWARDS POTTINGER LLC
Paul G. Cassell (Pro Hac Vice)
S.J. Quinney College of Law

------------------
¹ This daytime business address is provided for identification and correspondence purposes only
and is not intended to imply institutional endorsement by the University of Utah for this private
representation.

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY that on the 15th day of October, 2018, I served the attached
PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RULE 45 SUBPOENA AND NOTICE OF TAKING
VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF IGOR ZINOVIEV via Email to the following counsel of
record.

Michael Miller
Justin Y.K Chu
Michael A. Keough
STEPTOE & JOHNSON LLP

Scott J. Link
LINK & ROCKENBACH, PA
Counsel for Jeffrey Epstein, <REDACTED>, and Lesley Groff

Laura A. Menninger, Esq.
Jeffrey Pagliuca, Esq.
LAO: Lk 9: kA L
Counsel for Ghislaine Maxwell

3
By: /s/ Sigrid McCawlev
Sigrid McCawley
EFTA00003050 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
(inferred date: 2018-10-18)
Today's
Date:
Employee
Name
Physical
Address:
Isia:Eng
Address:
L
Cell
Phone
E-mail: Title/Position:
LSJE,
LLC
(
et's.
Suite
B-3.
St.
Thomas.
VI
00802-1348
Pilot
E-mail:
thesaintjames.group@,gmaiI.com
Emergency
Contact
Form
10/18/18 Donald
Po4lon
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:
r
Phone
(other):
Marital
Status:
Driver's
License
No:
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
tyoe:
7
A-
D
A+
7
AB-
D
AB+
E
Current
Medications:
Doctors
Name:
Doctor's
Name:
B-
E
8+
0
O-
c
o+
E
Unknown
in
case
of
emergency,
please
contact:
Name: Name:
Relationship: Relationship:
Doctor's
Phone:
Doctor's
Phone:
Phone: Phone:
This
information
is for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others.
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Crypto PR Lab [crypto] PR firm founded by Maria Prusakova and Aleksandra Karpova, advised by Epstein [x] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00295126 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Crypto PR Lab accounting statement
(inferred timestamp: 2018-11-27 19:30:00)
7:30 PM
11/27/18
Cash Basis As of October 31, 2018
ASSETS
Current Assets
Checking/Savings
Oct 31, 18
Chase Total Business Checking 27'54.28
Total Cheeking/Sayings 27,754 28
Total Current Assets 27,754.28
TOTAL ASSETS 27,754.28
LIABILITIES 8, EQUITY
Equity
Member 1 Draws 7,000.00
Net Income 20,754.28
Total Equity 27,754.28
TOTAL LIABILITIES & EQUITY 27,754.28
Crypto PR Lab
Balance Sheet
Page 1
EFTA00309271 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Crypto PR Lab financial statement
(inferred timestamp: 2018-11-27 19:31:00)
7:31 PM
11/27/18
Accrual Basis
Crypto PR Lab
Profit & Loss Detail
August through October 2018
Type Date Hum Adj Name Marne Clr SPM Debit Credit Balance
Ordinary Income:Expense
Income
Sales
Cloposit 08/1712018
Deposit 03121/2018
OCOOPt 002712018
Deposit 09121,2018
OCOOPt 0024 ,2018
Deposit 0028 ,2018
OCOOSit 10032018
Deposit 10:03,2018
OCOOSO 10.112018
Total Sales
Total Incorre
Gross Profit
Espana*
Advertiskm and Promotion
Cheek 09202018
Check 09/272018
Total Artestising and Promotion
Bank Sande* Charge*
Check 01/10/2018
OCOOSt 03/29/2018
Depose cermout
Cheek 66/29/2018
Cheek 09/0512018
Check CO/10/2018
Cheek 09/1712018
Check 03118/2018
Cheek 092812018
Check 1011882018
Cheek 10/1712018
Check 1011602018
Check 1011212018
Cheek 10/19/2018
Check 10/19/2018
Cheek 10/19/2018
Check 1011912018
Cheek 10/19/2018
Check 10/24/2018
Check 10/2412018
Total Bank Service Charges
Client GPM
Check 03/29/2018
Check 101292018
Total Client Gilts
Computer/ad Internet Expellee*
Check 08106,7018
Check 09.96/2018
Check 10/1912018
Check 10129/2018
Check 10.292018
Total Computer and Internet Cleanses
Guaranteed Payments
Cheek 09117/2018
Check oanancrie Check 09/24/2018
Check 00/25/2018
Check 10222018
Total GaraMeed Payments
Marketing Espana*
Check 03/27J2018
Cheek 03/28/2018
Check 03/2W2018
Cheek 03/28/2018
Check 09/04/2018
Cheek 09.0412018
Total Marketing Expense
Constant Innovations
Dragonchain. Inc.
UAB Desks
UAB Desk*
Arocmcn lhadta En
Crypto Finance Con...
Constant ImeedlienS
Marsha Cuttan (Acua)
UAB Desks
Card Replacerrant...
Paypal
Paypal
Paypal
International Wire F...
Foreign Exchange...
Foreign Exchange...
Foreign Exchange...
Dernestic Wire Fee
Foreign Exchange...
International Wire F...
Foreign Exchange...
Foreign Exchange...
Foreign ExChange...
Foreign Exchange...
Withdrawal
Foreign Exchange...
Non-Chase ATM Fee
Foreign Exchange...
Foreign Exchange...
Vislapnni
From You Fevers
Sean Mail
The Lir* Molders
Cybectryle
Cy0erbyl'
Cybectryle
Marba
Mardla
Vislaprnt
Vislaprint
Vislaprint
Vislaprint
Vislaprint
Vislaprint
Bock Transit..
Bock Transit,-
Deposat
Depose
Book Tran0e...
Chips Craft
Book
Paypal
Deposit
Veneto
Veneto
Verlfyberit
Verlfybank
V011ytenk
Online US 00...
Ace Bus Mr Ibiza
Ryan kr
Oorneerm Inc...
Atlantis Bah ._
Ochre US 00...
Orrma Ho Ba...
Kubal Villa &...
°Dreamt, Bar...
°Dreams Bar...
Nen-Chase A...
FAD
Mass Transit ..
Paypal
Paypal
Paypal
Paypal
Paypal
OulekPaY
Ouickpay
OulekPaY
Ouickpay with..
OulekPaY
Chase Tots B...
Chase Tots B...
Chan Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chat. Total 8...
Chase Tots B...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Total B._
Chew Total B...
Chase TOtal B
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B-.
Chafe Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B. .
Chase Total B
Chase TOIal B
Chase Tots B.
Chase 10lal B.
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Claw iota B...
Chase Tots B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B-.
Chase Tots B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B._
Chase Total B._
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B._
Chose Tc4al B...
Chase Total B..
Chase Teal B...
Chase Total El-.
Chen Total B...
5.000.00
1.200.00
10.000.00
7.500.00
1.00000
3.745.00
5.000.00
2.900.00
22.500.03
5.000.00
8200.03
15280.03
23.703.03
24.703.03
28.445.00
33.445.00
38345.00
58.845 00
0.00 58845.00 58.845.00
0.00 58.845.00 58.84500
0.00
47.50
40.00
58845.00 58045.00
47.50
87.50
87.50
0.24
40.00
0.57
0.08
1.99
15.00
3.00
40.00
0.98
1.79
20.63
20.83
4.14
&12
5.00
0.93
0.44
0.0)
0.18
0.06
87.50
5.03
4.82
4.78
5.03
45.00
45.57
45.63
47.84
62.64
85.84
105.64
108.80
103.39
129.02
149.65
153.79
159.91
164.91
185.84
166.28
166.52
21.27
77.03
0.24 166.28
21.27
98.27
98.27
2.03000
300.00
111.00
1,000.00
150.80
0.03 98.27
2.060.00
2.360.03
2.411.00
3,411.03
3.581.00
3.581.00
2200.00
5.000.00
1235.00
2.000.00
5000.07
0.03 3.581.00
2260.00
8436.03
15.43500
15.436.80
54.59
99.25
47.73
317.89
58.58
6.51
0.00 15436.00
54.59
153.84
201.57
519.46
578.04
584.55
584.55 0.03 584.55
Page 1
7:31 PM
11/27118
Accrual Basis
Crypto PR Lab
Profit & Loss Detail
August through October 2018
Type Date Num Adj Name Marne Clr Split Debit Credit Balance
Meals and EntirtsInmera
Cheek
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
Check
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
Total Meals and Erdertainment
Office Expenses
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Total °MOO Expenses
Oneida Bovine
Cheek
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
De0a611
Ocoost
Danced
Ocoost
Deposit
Total Outside Services
PlacerimM Cede
Deposit
Cheek
Check
Check
Cheek
Check
Total Placement
Postage and Delivery
Cheek
Check
Total Postage and
Press Pass Espana
Check
Cheek
Total Press Ran
Rent Expense
Check
Total Rent Expense
Storage Expenses
Check
Total Storage Expenses
Travel Expense
Airfare
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Cheek
Check
Cheek
Check
Total Airfare
66/23/2018
08/27/2018
01127/2018
08/27/2018
0128/2018
98129/2018
09/2112018
99/27/2018
0/01/2018
0/01/2018
0101/2018
0/01/2018
0101/2018
0/01/2018
0/173/2018
0/173/2018
0/012018
0/15/2018
0/18/2018
0328/2018
0328/2018
1024/2018
06/27/2018
00,0512018
09/1712018
09118/2018
09118/2018
09/25/2018
00/25/2018
0/09/2018
0117/2018
0122/2018 0/22/2018
0127/2018 0/22/2018
09/17/2018
09121/2018
09127/2018
10/04/2018
10/2312018
10123/2018
Costs
09,06/2018
10/24/2018
Delivery
09/24/2018
09.25/2018
EV00/30
10/09/2018
09/17/2018
09/18/2018
09/24/2018
10/19/2018
10/19/2018
10122,2018
10/25/2018
Slarbudd
Leal Kitehen and ...
Starbudd
Slarbucks
Hubbard lm
Five 8 Diemen
Lcchwced Market
Caumo
Whde Foods
Great White
Greet White
Whole Foods
Boardwalk PIRA
Boardwalk Paza
Ceene Grocery
Anted Coffee
Spa Patace APO Palace Panda Express
Atlantis Ball Dive
Kubal Vila 8. Resta
Inset Tech
Vistapint
Vistapint
Maid Almunrek
Casco Coisultsecy
kland Almubarak
kind Alenubarak
Sarah Austin
Sarah Aviilln
klahte Nmubarak
MVO. Alfrobarak
Casco Ccrisuitancy
Mend. Alcrubarak
Mend. Alcrubarak
Mind Ahrubarak
Mend. Alcrubarak
Mahe/ Ahrubarak
aS ir GuinOnn
Tzurel Tech
TZuf lel Tech
Torusco Ou
The UPS Slone
USPS
ID Creator
ID Creator
152 East 22 Rentals
Tiburon Lockers Inc
Ryan Air
Ryan An
Amencan Fur
eDreerre Elattaltila
*Dreams Barcelona
Den AM
Dena Ak
LAX Airport
Quicken Mk,.
InteMnOnel ...
Ouickpay wdh...
QUICkpay WM..,
Cuickpay with...
allICkPaY nth-
Ouickpay with..
QUICkpay vain..
Ochre Intern...
ReverfAl -Cu...
ROVOISal - Cu...
Reversal • Cu...
Reversal - Cu...
Paypal
Paypel
Oulckpey wen...
Paypal
Paypal
Paypal
Ouickpay wit...
Chen TOW B...
Chant TOM18...
Chase Total B...
Chen TWA B...
Chase Teal B...
Chase TOW 8...
Chase Teal B...
Chen TOM B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chen TOM B...
Chase Total B...
Chen TOM B...
Chase Total B...
Chase TOW 8...
Chase Taal B.-
Chen Total B...
Chen Total B...
Chase Told B...
Chen TOM B...
Chase Total B...
Chen TOM B...
Chase Total B...
Chen TOM B...
Chen Total 8...
Chen TOO B...
Chase Total 8...
Chain. 'Fetal B...
Chase Total B.
Ginn Total B.
Chase Total B.
Chase Total B.
Chase Told B...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Total 8...
ChaseTotal B...
Chen TOW 8...
Chen T0MS...
Chase Total B...
Chen TOO B...
Chase Total B...
Chase TOW B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Total B...
Chase Told B...
Chase Total B...
Chen Tow B...
Chant Told B...
Chase Told B...
Chen 70031 B...
Chase Total B...
6.50
4.25
9.39
7.72
54.74
176.99
30.62
16.62
26.99
15.17
23.87
10.13
160.00
39.00
10.84
100.18
59.99
8.50
96.50
100.75
110.14
117.63
226.07
280.61
457.80
488.42
507.04
535.51
564.60
579.67
603.34
634.55
644.78
804.78
843.78
854.62
954.80
1.014.79
1.014.79
323.98
31.13
0.00 1.014.79
323.98
397.76
428.89
428.69
1500.00
1.500.00
1.500.00
500.00
1.000.00
1,000.00
1.500.00
1500.00
3.375.00
0.00
1.500130
1.500130
1.50000
1500.00
500.00
428.89
1380.843
3.000.00
4660.60
5.000.03
8,000.00
7080.03
8.560.60
10.000.86
13.376.60
11575.03
10375.00
8876.60
7375.03
6.875.00
13.376.60
304.99
200.00
137.30
150.00
297.65
6.600.60
300.00
6.875.00
-300.00
4.99
204.99
342.29
492.29
789.94
1.089.94
41.33
6.70
300.00 769.94
41.33
48.03
48.03
12.87
22.99
0.00 48.03
12.87
35.86
3.000.60
0.00 35.86
3.000.00
3.000.00
7.00
0.00 3000.00
7.00
7.00
263.66
66.56
51.20
687.81
687.81
51.20
30.00
0.00 7.00
263.66
330.21
381.41
1.06922
1.757.03
1.808,23
1.838.23 0.00 1938 23
Page 2
7:31 PM
1927/18
Accrual Bade
Crypto PR Lab
Profit & Loss Detail
August through October 2018
Type Date Num Adj Name Memo Cs SPIN Debit Creek Balance
Lodging
Check
Check
Check
Tow: Lodging
Travel Expense
Check
Chace
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Check
Total Travel E
Total Travel Expense
Writer Expense
Chock
Check
Total Wnter Expense
Total Expense
Net xdnszy Income
Net Income
CW27/2018
19O3/2O1e

• Oilier
C6/27,2O18
09/1012018
09/13/2018
CO/131201e
09/17/2018
0/01,2018
0/01/2018
0/01,2018
0/01/2018
0/01/2018
0/01/2018
0/01/2018
0/02,2018
0,03/2018
03,2018
0..04,2018
00 4,2018
0)0420180106.2018
0/09/2018
0.,09,2018
0/09/2018
0/09,2018
0/18/2018
0119/2018
0,24/2018
0,2412018
Dense - Other
OCx2g,20113
Hotel TongN
Ace Hotel
Ace Hold
Playabike Transport
Ace Bus
Taxi 50 vue Taxi 50 Vila
Mr Mica
Lyle
Lyle
Lyle
Lyle
Lyle
Lyle
Lyle
Lye
Lyft
Ise
Lyft
Lyft
Orma Ho Badung
Withdrawal
Mt« Trans.! Railway
ueer
Cenral Fee
Cenral Fee
Cenral Fee
Non-Chase A...
VenMO
Venrno
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Teed EL..
Chase Teed B._
Chess Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Toad B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Teed EL..
Chess Total B...
Chase Teed B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Taal B...
Chase Teed EL..
Chase Total B...
Chase Teed EL..
Chess Tilel B...
Chase Teed EL..
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Taal B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Taal B...
Chase Total 8...
Chase Total B_.
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
Chase Total B...
117.00
82.62
303.51
117.00
199.62
503.16
603.18
1.800.00
12.02
24.23
2.87
14.50
14.50
22.71
23.42
15.20
26.71
30.80
15.43
59.18
22.21
6.57
4.76
5.00
5.00
4.25
5.00
4.18
4.04
4.06
32.32
200.00
14.67
24.28
0.00 503.16
1.003.00
1,019.22
1.031.24
1.05647
1,068.34
1.072.84
1,087.34
1.110.05
1,133.47
1.148.67
1.175.38
1256.18
1221.61
1280.79
1.303.00
1.308.67
1.313.43
1,318.43
1,323.43
1.327.68
1232.58
1.336.88
1,340.90
1.344.95
1.377.27
1.577.27
1.591.94
1.616 22
961622 0.00 1.616.22
3.957.61
1.000.00
1.000.00
0.00 3257.61
1,093.00
2.000.00
2.000.00 0.00 2.000.00
44.890.96 6020.24 38.090.72
44.890.96 65.646.24 29764.28
44.890.96 89648.24 20.75428
Page 3
╔════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Maria Macaraeg [employee] applied for housekeeper/nanny job 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00522933 (Jmail)
 [resumé] professional resumé of Maria Macaraeg applied to be housekeeper for Epstein
(inferred date: 2018-11-29)
Maria C. Macaraeg
Job Objective: Seeking a Nanny/Housekeeper position in which my organizational skills can be
fully utilized.
Highlights of Qualifications:

• Exceptional experience in providing nanny services in private homes
• Passion for painting, sketching, arts & crafts

• Adept at writing poems (creative writing)
• Ability to prepare meals
• Highly organized (both office and home settings) and maintain meticulous housekeeping
services
Professional Experience:
Housekeeper
Libbie Mugrabi, UES, Manhattan
August 2018 — November 2018
Responsibilities:

• Render deep-cleaning routine at NYC and Hampton residences (bedrooms, bathrooms,
living rooms, kitchen, hallways)

• Prepare and ensure optimal organized, sanitary cleaning schedule for various categories
such as: vents, pantry, outside oven/fridge, closets, garage, gates, windows/window sills,
curtains, baseboards, walls

• Manage trash for the residences and disposed them off appropriately
• Maintain household inventory and replenish as required

• Assist with kids' needs (school drop-off/pick-up, meals, groceries, etc.) as needed
• Provide logistics for family & household staff on travels (between two residences, and
locally) as needed

• Sort through and organized office files in her Hamptons home
• Perform other duties as may be required
Nanny/Housekeeper/Administrative Assistant
Diane Rosky, Union NJ
2012 — Present
Responsibilities:

• Take care of kids' drop-off & pick-up at school and activities
• Prepare kids and family meals
• Do housekeeping and laundry

• Database management
• Office organization (design filing systems and ensure they are maintained and are up-to-
date including supplies procurement)

• Documents and memos preparation
• Perform other duties as may be required
Other Jobs:
Administrative Assistant
Essex County College (College — Yes)
Newark, NJ
November 2007 — February 2012
Adjunct Instructor
Essex County College (Adult Learning Center)
Newark, NJ
2007 - 2008
Marketing Manager
ADI Telecoms
Manila, Philippines
2002 - 2006
Project Manager
Swiftel Datacom Limited
Manila, Hong Kong and Macau offices
1996 — 2002
Executive Assistant
Barrington Carpets Inc.
Manila, Philippines
1995 —1996
Education:
Bachelor's Degree in Fine Arts major in Advertising
College of the Holy Spirit, Manila, Philippines
EFTA00000019 (Jmail)
 [misc] Merwin Dela Cruz cooling tower maintenance
(date: 2018-12-10)
lob Code Client Name
)c Type SetVOReacjattel
Spec& frogrottbett
Sertaatt
00Ap02018
5135 Mew/500a Crux -1.t tem Water treatment Cogent 7 own , Mee000 Marten. me perform 94 re I treatment on Coohne *Anne
ImMde MA mth water *eels and fea0rm
5136 Mews, Oct. Out -1 Epstein Tower Clearer* Clearing 6 Oninfecticei • COON laoAta
25 Aper2016
$1351 Mento Deb Ow • I f pite0 Water Treatment Coding Tower. Moodily Maintenance 100Men aaaaa treenagan On (wind tower
Include of troth tole, Weis and reedits
OI•May-Z018
4869.1 Merton Dela Olsi -1 (Osten tegioneila lea Coding Tower • leigtonella
Completer, Nowt
did the 93 day tower onseettonard legionero tnt
23-May.20111
5135 2 Merton Deb Out • I Epstein Water treatment Cooing Tater - Month Maintenance perform whet treatment Co Cwt.ton?
Include P51, with water Mveh and reading;
Into -2018
5135.3 Mnwwr Deb Ow i / (putt Water Treatment Ceding Tower- Montt Mareensecie potent wirer treatment DI Cooing tow
Include P33 with water tire's and readings
0910-2018
5135.4 Matwin Data Cruz • 1 Epstein Watt Treatment Cook* Town-Moritly Manwnancttoucan
ro ate. treatment on Cody tont
trade F51 wet i watt can and leid4h11
138.8.2018
4849.2 Metwin Deb OW - I t Wen tetioneTa Test
a--
?crane lost r titres's&
90day totes inspection and kennel. tett 21434.2018
5135.8 Merewineieta Ow • /Totten Wan treatment COON lower. /Mae* Ma newt (*rhino went -chewed on Cooing tower
Indy* P54 Mei water ktett and readings
!Oleg-201g
5135.6 MeinenDeh Chat • ;.Epttein Wow Tteatinent Coding Tower- Mo0NN Manlenana perform water treatment on Cooing lower
Include PSIlvalh wan 'nth and teadings
osoci.zots
5136.1 Meant Oth Ow - 1 Ertntet tower Cleans* (fearing 6 Oputettion - Cooley ?taw
IS-00.2018
513? Memo Ode ow -I [fasten Inspection mow) Caring Tower. Inspector
2250W-201g
5135 7 Menet Oda Cm • Litho, Water ritalMent Cook* Iowa • Monthly MaralteavbCt pedarm wave treatment on Cooing tower 
12.1.0.-2016
white nitwit waterier/eh and reedits
1849 I Merin Dela Cow i I I mien leemnella Test Cooing Tower , legionelta
90 day tower inspector, and /month& test. 19-tiov•2018
S135-11 &lentil Doh Cecil. al Rata% Water Treatment tooting tower. Monthly 1.1489894e9t pedom watt, treatment on tooting
tower 10
Include P53 Will Wahl teeth ant teeth.
Ileci2018

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA01299820 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Crypto PR Lab bank transfer
(date: 2018-12-18)
RPTID: MBS01000
DATE: 12/18/2018
ACCOUNT RR I/O C/W DESCRIPTION
INCOMING/OUTGOING WIRES,CHECKS AND ACH REPORT
IBD: EXE OFF: N4G
ADDITIONAL INFO BENEFICIARIES
ISSUER IONE
PAGE: 1
NET AMOUNT
AB2 I W /PW011000028 00041178 DEUTSCHE
STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMPANY BANK 345 PARK AVENUE
1 LINCOLN STREET FLOOR 1 NEW YORK NY 10154
BOSTON MA 02111 VOID
33451025.2 /REC/PERSHING
GB REVOCABLE TRUST
2020 ROCKWOOD
SACRAMENTO CA 95864
AXZ I N /FW021001033
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY
AMERICAS
60 WALL STREET
44130229
44130229 - WEST INVESTMENT HOLDINGS
1603 ORPINGTON AVE SUITE 810 EVANST
ON IL 60201
JSP 0 W 021001033
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. MIMIC
NEW YORK NY
JSP O W 026013576
SIGNATURE BANK
NEW YORK NY
JSP I W /FM021001033
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY
AMERICAS
60 WALL STREET
35257287
35257287 - ELI UNGAR AND/OR HARLEY
207 CHESTNUT ST ENGLEWOOD NJ 07631
L1A 0 C
L1A I C RCD CASH
L1A I C RCD CASH
L1A 0 W 021001033
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERIC
NEW YORK NY
BKTRUS33PWM
VOID
/REC/PERSHING LLC
//US
485 LEXINGTON AVENUE
15TH FLOOR NEW YORK
NY 10017-2630 6%
510 MADISON AVE 8TH
FLOORS NEW YORKIST
10022-5730 6X
BKTRUS33PWM
VOID
/REC/PERSHING LLC
//US
04023745326
CHECK RECEIVED RESNI
CK CHECKI : 4715
CHECK RECEIVED RESNI
CK CHECKI : 4716
RMS: PRHO ADDRESS:
BEATRIZ H CABAL
STREET PROCONSA II
BUILDING8TH FLOOR
GB REVOCABLE
N40030502
BUY CUST ?RN
GB REVOCABLE
1140030502
BEY CUST RRN
TRUST FFC: ACCT
- 0000000117211149
TRUST FFC. ACCT
- 0000000117211149
STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMPANY
FFC WEST INVESTMENT HOLDINGS LLC
FFC ACCT N4G 024414
BUY GUST RRN - 0/B DBTCO AMERIC
FFC WEST INVESTMENT HOLDINGS LLC
FFC ACCT N4G 024414
BUY COST RRN - 0/B DBTCO MIMIC
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY
GOLDENTREE ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
42927306
GEH CAPITAL
1501289341
FFC ACCT IAMB ELI
N40031559
BUY CUST RRN - 0/B DBTCO AMERIC
FFC ACC? NAME ELI UNGAR ACCT NO
N40031559
BEY GUST RRN - 0/B DBTCO AMERIC
UNGAR ACCT NO
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY
LYNWOOD W LESIKAR
POB 121788
FORT WORTH TX 76121-1788
DEUTSCHE BANK AG LONDON
50000.00
300000.00
220000.00
100000.00
30000.00
50000.00
30000.00
30000.00
4970000.00
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(fc ONFIDENTIAL
DB-SDNY-0028769
RPTID: MBS01000
DATE: 12/18/2018
ACCOUNT RR I/O C/W DESCRIPTION
INCOMING/OUTGOING WIRES,CHECKS AND ACH REPORT
IBD: 610 OFF: N40
ADDITIONAL INFO BENEFICIARIES
ISSUER HAMM
PAGE: 2
NET AMOUNT
L1A 0 C
Y89 I W /FW044000024
THE HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK
41 S HIGH ST HC0910
COLUMBUS OH 43215
03668602070
DONNA KRASNEY
MARK FF0314ONT
2600 FAIRWOOD DR
PEPPER PIKE OR 44124-4543
2814 0 W 322271627
JPMORGAN CHASE 'Jam, NA
SEATTLE WA
PANAMA CITY 6%
CHECK NUMBER - 0507
21585617000000000000
0006010 04
THE mArrImorrom
NATIONAL BANK 41 S
HIGH ST HC0910
COLUMBUS OH 43215
VOID
/REC/PERSHING LLC
04411739
INVESTMENT FFC DONNA B KRASNEY,
ACCOUNT NO. N40028902
BNY COST RRN - 0/B HUNT COL
INVESTMENT FFC DONNA B KRASNEY,
ACCOUNT NO. N40028902
BUY COST RAN - 0/8 HUNT COL
THE HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK
82 SOCIAL MEDIU LLC
DBA CRYPTO PR LAB
312326728
5000.00
7601.00
6821.40
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(P ONFIDENTIAL
SIDNY_GM_00065945
DB-SDNY-0028770
EFTA00810400 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2019-01-01)
Do Not Copy or Distribute Without Written Permission from Valar Ventures LLC
Valar Global Fund IV LP
$150,000,000
VALAR
Limited Partner Interests
Confidential Private Placement Memorandum
Valar Ventures LLC
915 Broadway, Suite 1101
New York, New York 10010
Copy #
Issued to:
148264373 vl
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum
Confidential Private Placement Memorandum
VALAR GLOBAL FUND IV LP
$150,000,000
Limited Partner Interests
THIS CONFIDENTIAL PRIVATE PLACEMENT MEMORANDUM (THE "MEMORANDUM") HAS
BEEN PREPARED SOLELY FOR USE BY THE PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS OF VALAR GLOBAL
FUND IV LP (THE "FUND" OR THE "PARTNERSHIP") AND SHALL BE MAINTAINED IN
STRICT CONFIDENCE. EACH RECIPIENT HEREOF ACKNOWLEDGES AND AGREES THAT
(I) THE CONTENTS OF THIS MEMORANDUM CONSTITUTE PROPRIETARY AND
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, (II) VALAR VENTURES GP IV LLC (THE "GENERAL
PARTNER"), VALAR VENTURES LLC (THE "MANAGEMENT COMPANY') AND THEIR
AFFILIATES, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION THE FUND (COLLECTIVELY, THE
"FIRM") DERIVE INDEPENDENT ECONOMIC VALUE FROM SUCH CONFIDENTIAL
INFORMATION NOT BEING GENERALLY KNOWN, AND (III) SUCH CONFIDENTIAL
INFORMATION IS THE SUBJECT OF REASONABLE EFFORTS TO MAINTAIN ITS SECRECY.
THE RECIPIENT FURTHER AGREES THAT THE CONTENTS OF THIS MEMORANDUM ARE A
TRADE SECRET, THE DISCLOSURE OF WHICH IS LIKELY TO CAUSE SUBSTANTIAL AND
IRREPARABLE COMPETITIVE HARM TO THE FIRM. ANY REPRODUCTION OR
DISTRIBUTION OF THIS MEMORANDUM, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, OR THE DISCLOSURE OF
ITS CONTENTS, WITHOUT THE PRIOR WRITTEN CONSENT OF THE MANAGEMENT
COMPANY, IS PROHIBITED. EACH PERSON WHO HAS RECEIVED THIS MEMORANDUM IS
DEEMED TO AGREE TO RETURN THIS MEMORANDUM TO THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY
UPON REQUEST. THE EXISTENCE AND NATURE OF ALL CONVERSATIONS REGARDING
THE FUND AND THIS OFFERING MUST BE KEPT CONFIDENTIAL.
THIS MEMORANDUM HAS BEEN PREPARED IN CONNECTION WITH A PRIVATE OFFERING
TO ACCREDITED INVESTORS OF LIMITED PARTNER INTERESTS IN THE FUND (THE
"INTERESTS"). EACH INVESTOR WILL BE REQUIRED TO EXECUTE A LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (AS AMENDED, RESTATED AND/OR OTHERWISE MODIFIED
FROM TIME TO TIME, THE "PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT') AND SUBSCRIPTION
AGREEMENT AND INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE (THE "SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT') TO
EFFECT ITS INVESTMENT IN THE FUND. THIS MEMORANDUM CONTAINS A SUMMARY
OF THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT, THE SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND CERTAIN
OTHER DOCUMENTS REFERRED TO HEREIN. HOWEVER, THE SUMMARIES IN THIS
MEMORANDUM DO NOT PURPORT TO BE COMPLETE AND ARE SUBJECT TO AND ARE
QUALIFIED IN THEIR ENTIRETY BY REFERENCE TO THE ACTUAL TEXT OF THE
RELEVANT DOCUMENT, COPIES OF WHICH WILL BE PROVIDED TO EACH PROSPECTIVE
INVESTOR UPON REQUEST. EACH PROSPECTIVE INVESTOR SHOULD REVIEW THE
PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT, THE SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND SUCH OTHER
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
ii
DOCUMENTS FOR COMPLETE INFORMATION CONCERNING THE RIGHTS, PRIVILEGES
AND OBLIGATIONS OF INVESTORS IN THE FUND. IF ANY OF THE TERMS, CONDITIONS
OR OTHER PROVISIONS OF THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT, THE SUBSCRIPTION
AGREEMENT OR SUCH OTHER DOCUMENTS ARE INCONSISTENT WITH OR CONTRARY TO
THE DESCRIPTIONS OR TERMS IN THIS MEMORANDUM, THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT,
THE SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT OR SUCH OTHER DOCUMENTS SHALL CONTROL. THE
FIRM RESERVES THE RIGHT TO MODIFY THE TERMS OF THE OFFERING AND THE
INTERESTS DESCRIBED IN THIS MEMORANDUM, AND THE INTERESTS ARE OFFERED
SUBJECT TO THE GENERAL PARTNER'S ABILITY TO REJECT ANY COMMITMENT IN
WHOLE OR IN PART.
THE INTERESTS HAVE NOT BEEN AND WILL NOT BE REGISTERED UNDER THE UNITED
STATES SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED (THE "SECURITIES ACT), OR ANY
UNITED STATES STATE SECURITIES LAWS OR THE LAWS OF ANY FOREIGN
JURISDICTION. THE INTERESTS WILL BE OFFERED AND SOLD UNDER THE EXEMPTION
PROVIDED BY SECTION 4(2) OF THE SECURITIES ACT AND REGULATION D
PROMULGATED THEREUNDER AND OTHER EXEMPTIONS OF SIMILAR IMPORT IN THE
LAWS OF THE STATES AND OTHER JURISDICTIONS WHERE THE OFFERING WILL BE
MADE. THE FUND WILL NOT BE REGISTERED AS AN INVESTMENT COMPANY UNDER
THE UNITED STATES INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT OF 1940, AS AMENDED (THE
"INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT). CONSEQUENTLY, INVESTORS WILL NOT BE AFFORDED
THE PROTECTIONS OF THE INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT.
THE INTERESTS DESCRIBED IN THIS MEMORANDUM ARE SUBJECT TO RESTRICTIONS ON
TRANSFERABILITY AND RESALE AND MAY NOT BE TRANSFERRED OR RESOLD EXCEPT
AS PERMITTED UNDER THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT AND THE SECURITIES ACT AND
APPLICABLE STATE SECURITIES LAWS, PURSUANT TO REGISTRATION OR EXEMPTION
THEREFROM. INVESTORS SHOULD BE AWARE THAT THEY WILL BE REQUIRED TO BEAR
THE FINANCIAL RISKS OF THIS INVESTMENT FOR AN INDEFINITE PERIOD OF TIME.
THE FUND'S INVESTMENTS WILL BE CHARACTERIZED BY A HIGH DEGREE OF RISK,
VOLATILITY AND ILLIQUIDITY. A PROSPECTIVE PURCHASER SHOULD THOROUGHLY
REVIEW THE CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN AND THE TERMS OF
THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT AND SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT, AND CAREFULLY
CONSIDER WHETHER AN INVESTMENT IN THE FUND IS SUITABLE TO THE INVESTOR'S
FINANCIAL SITUATION AND GOALS.
CERTAIN ECONOMIC AND MARKET INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN HAS BEEN
OBTAINED FROM PUBLISHED SOURCES PREPARED BY OTHER PARTIES. WHILE SUCH
SOURCES ARE BELIEVED TO BE RELIABLE, NEITHER THE FUND, THE GENERAL PARTNER,
NOR THEIR RESPECTIVE AFFILIATES ASSUME ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE
ACCURACY OR COMPLETENESS OF SUCH INFORMATION. NEITHER DELIVERY OF THIS
MEMORANDUM NOR ANY STATEMENT HEREIN SHOULD BE TAKEN TO IMPLY THAT ANY
INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN IS CORRECT AS OF ANY TIME SUBSEQUENT TO THE
DATE HEREOF.
NO PERSON HAS BEEN AUTHORIZED TO MAKE ANY STATEMENT CONCERNING THE
FUND OR THE SALE OF THE INTERESTS DISCUSSED HEREIN OTHER THAN AS SET FORTH
IN THIS MEMORANDUM, AND ANY SUCH STATEMENTS, IF MADE, MUST NOT BE RELIED
UPON.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
iii
PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS ARE CAUTIONED NOT TO RELY ON THE PRIOR RETURN
INFORMATION SET FORTH HEREIN IN MAKING A DECISION WHETHER OR NOT TO
PURCHASE THE INTERESTS OFFERED HEREBY. THE RETURN INFORMATION CONTAINED
HEREIN HAS NOT BEEN AUDITED OR VERIFIED BY ANY INDEPENDENT PARTY AND
SHOULD NOT BE CONSIDERED REPRESENTATIVE OF THE RETURNS THAT MAY BE
RECEIVED BY AN INVESTOR IN THE FUND. CERTAIN FACTORS EXIST THAT MAY AFFECT
COMPARABILITY INCLUDING, AMONG OTHERS, THE DEDUCTION OF FEES AND
EXPENSES AND THE PAYMENT OF A CARRIED INTEREST. CERTAIN FACTUAL AND
STATISTICAL INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN HAS BEEN OBTAINED FROM
PUBLISHED SOURCES PREPARED BY OTHER PARTIES AND HAS NOT BEEN
INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED BY THE GENERAL PARTNER OR ANY OF ITS AFFILIATES.
OPINIONS AND ESTIMATES MAY BE CHANGED WITHOUT NOTICE. IN CONSIDERING THE
PRIOR PERFORMANCE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN, PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS
SHOULD BEAR IN MIND THAT PAST PERFORMANCE IS NOT NECESSARILY INDICATIVE
OF FUTURE RESULTS, AND THERE CAN BE NO ASSURANCE THAT THE FUND WILL
ACHIEVE COMPARABLE RESULTS.
CERTAIN STATEMENTS OF PAST PERFORMANCE OF OTHER INVESTMENT FUNDS
MANAGED BY THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY OR AFFILIATES THEREOF AND CERTAIN
ECONOMIC AND MARKET INFORMATION, CONTAINED HEREIN INCLUDES PROJECTIONS
AND ESTIMATES MADE BY THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY AND OTHER PARTIES. THE
PROJECTED RETURNS CONTAINED HEREIN MAY BE CALCULATED ON A COMPANY BY
COMPANY BASIS, AND ARE BASED ON ESTIMATES OF THE EVENTUAL MAGNITUDE AND
THE TIMING OF THE RETURNS FROM EACH COMPANY MADE BY THE MANAGEMENT
COMPANY. THE PROJECTED RETURNS AND ESTIMATES OF ECONOMIC AND MARKET
INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN INVOLVE RISKS AND UNCERTAINTIES AND: (I) ARE
BASED UPON ASSUMPTIONS CONCERNING CIRCUMSTANCES AND EVENTS THAT HAVE
NOT YET OCCURRED AND (II) MAY BE SUBJECT TO BEING INFLUENCED BY EVENTS
BEYOND THE CONTROL OF THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY. ACTUAL RESULTS COULD
DIFFER SIGNIFICANTLY. NO REPRESENTATION OR WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED,
IS MADE BY THE FIRM AS TO THE REASONABLENESS OR ACCURACY OF THE
PROJECTIONS OR ESTIMATES AND, AS A RESULT, SUCH PROJECTIONS AND ESTIMATES
SHOULD BE VIEWED SOLELY AS AN ORDERLY REPRESENTATION OF ESTIMATED
RESULTS IF UNDERLYING ASSUMPTIONS ARE REALIZED. INVESTORS SHOULD SUBJECT
THE PROJECTIONS AND ESTIMATES TO REVIEW BY THEIR OWN PROFESSIONAL
ADVISERS. UPON REQUEST, THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY WILL PROVIDE INVESTORS
WITH THE ASSUMPTIONS AND METHODOLOGIES USED IN PREPARING THE PROJECTIONS
AND ESTIMATES.
THE MEMORANDUM, TOGETHER WITH ANY AMENDMENTS AND SUPPLEMENTS
THERETO, AND ANY OTHER OFFERING MATERIALS DISTRIBUTED TO THE LIMITED
PARTNERS (TOGETHER, THE "OFFERING MATERIALS") CONTAIN CERTAIN STATEMENTS
WITH RESPECT TO, AND DISCLOSE CERTAIN INFORMATION WITH REGARD, TO THE
THIEL PERSONS (AS DEFINED HEREIN). NONE OF THE THIEL PERSONS MAKES ANY
REPRESENTATION OR WARRANTY WITH RESPECT TO THE CONTENTS OF THE OFFERING
MATERIALS. NONE OF THE THIEL PERSONS HAS OR ASSUMES ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR
ANY PART OF THE FORM OR SUBSTANCE OF THE OFFERING MATERIALS, AND THE
OFFERING MATERIALS, IN THEIR ENTIRETY, ARE THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE GENERAL
PARTNER AND THE MANAGEMENT COMPANY. THE THIEL PERSONS ARE RELYING,
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
iv
WITHOUT INDEPENDENT VERIFICATION, ON THE ACCURACY AND COMPLETENESS OF
OFFERING MATERIALS.
INVESTORS SHOULD MAKE THEIR OWN INVESTIGATIONS AND EVALUATIONS OF THE
FUND, INCLUDING THE MERITS AND RISKS INVOLVED IN AN INVESTMENT THEREIN.
PRIOR TO ANY INVESTMENT, THE GENERAL PARTNER WILL GIVE INVESTORS THE
OPPORTUNITY TO ASK QUESTIONS OF AND RECEIVE ANSWERS AND ADDITIONAL
INFORMATION FROM IT CONCERNING THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS OFFERING
AND OTHER RELEVANT MATTERS TO THE EXTENT THE GENERAL PARTNER POSSESSES
THE SAME OR CAN ACQUIRE IT WITHOUT UNREASONABLE EFFORT OR EXPENSE.
INVESTORS SHOULD INFORM THEMSELVES AS TO THE LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
APPLICABLE TO THEM IN RESPECT OF THE ACQUISITION, HOLDING AND DISPOSITION
OF THE INTERESTS IN THE FUND, AND AS TO THE INCOME AND OTHER TAX
CONSEQUENCES TO THEM OF SUCH ACQUISITION, HOLDING AND DISPOSITION.
THIS MEMORANDUM DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO SELL, OR A SOLICITATION
OF AN OFFER TO BUY, AN INTEREST IN ANY JURISDICTION IN WHICH IT IS UNLAWFUL
TO MAKE SUCH AN OFFER OR SOLICITATION. NEITHER THE UNITED STATES SECURITIES
AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION NOR ANY OTHER FEDERAL, STATE OR FOREIGN
REGULATORY AUTHORITY HAS APPROVED AN INVESTMENT IN THE FUND.
FURTHERMORE, THE FOREGOING AUTHORITIES HAVE NOT CONFIRMED THE ACCURACY
OR DETERMINED THE ADEQUACY OF THIS MEMORANDUM, NOR IS IT INTENDED THAT
THE FOREGOING AUTHORITIES WILL DO SO. ANY REPRESENTATION TO THE CONTRARY
IS A CRIMINAL OFFENSE.
YOUR INVESTMENT WILL BE DENOMINATED IN UNITED STATES DOLLARS ($) AND,
THEREFORE, WILL BE SUBJECT TO ANY FLUCTUATION IN THE RATE OF EXCHANGE
BETWEEN UNITED STATES DOLLARS ($), THE CURRENCY OF YOUR OWN JURISDICTION
AND THE CURRENCY OF THE JURISDICTION IN WHICH ANY FUND PORTFOLIO COMPANY
OPERATES OR GENERATES INVESTMENT PROCEEDS, AS APPLICABLE. SUCH
FLUCTUATIONS MAY HAVE AN ADVERSE EFFECT ON THE VALUE, PRICE OR INCOME OF
YOUR INVESTMENT.
CAUTIONARY STATEMENTS REGARDING FORWARD -LOOKING STATEMENTS
CERTAIN STATEMENTS IN THIS MEMORANDUM CONSTITUTE FORWARD -LOOKING
STATEMENTS. WHEN USED IN THIS MEMORANDUM, THE WORDS "MAY, -  "WILL,"
"SHOULD," "PROJECT," "ANTICIPATE," "BELIEVE," "ESTIMATE," "INTEND," "EXPECT,"
"CONTINUE," AND SIMILAR EXPRESSIONS OR THE NEGATIVES THEREOF ARE
GENERALLY INTENDED TO IDENTIFY FORWARD -LOOKING STATEMENTS. SUCH
FORWARD -LOOKING STATEMENTS, INCLUDING THE INTENDED ACTIONS AND
PERFORMANCE OBJECTIVES OF THE GENERAL PARTNER, FUND, OR ANY PORTFOLIO
COMPANY REFERENCED HEREIN, INVOLVE KNOWN AND UNKNOWN RISKS,
UNCERTAINTIES, AND OTHER IMPORTANT FACTORS THAT COULD CAUSE THE ACTUAL
RESULTS, PERFORMANCE, OR ACHIEVEMENTS OF THE GENERAL PARTNER, FUND, OR
ANY PORTFOLIO COMPANY TO DIFFER MATERIALLY FROM ANY FUTURE RESULTS,
PERFORMANCE, OR ACHIEVEMENTS EXPRESSED OR IMPLIED BY SUCH FORWARD -
LOOKING STATEMENTS. NO REPRESENTATION OR WARRANTY IS MADE AS TO FUTURE
PERFORMANCE OR SUCH FORWARD -LOOKING STATEMENTS. ALL FORWARD -LOOKING
STATEMENTS IN THIS MEMORANDUM SPEAK ONLY AS OF THE DATE HEREOF. THE FUND
AND THE GENERAL PARTNER EXPRESSLY DISCLAIM ANY OBLIGATION OR
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
V
UNDERTAKING TO DISSEMINATE ANY UPDATES OR REVISIONS TO ANY FORWARD -
LOOKING STATEMENT CONTAINED HEREIN TO REFLECT ANY CHANGE IN ITS
EXPECTATION WITH REGARD THERETO OR ANY CHANGE IN EVENTS, CONDITIONS, OR
CIRCUMSTANCES ON WHICH ANY SUCH STATEMENT IS BASED.
PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS ARE NOT TO CONSTRUE THIS MEMORANDUM AS
INVESTMENT, LEGAL, TAX, REGULATORY, FINANCIAL, ACCOUNTING OR OTHER
ADVICE, AND THIS MEMORANDUM IS NOT INTENDED TO PROVIDE THE SOLE BASIS FOR
ANY EVALUATION OF AN INVESTMENT IN AN INTEREST. PRIOR TO ACQUIRING AN
INTEREST, A PROSPECTIVE INVESTOR SHOULD CONSULT WITH ITS OWN LEGAL,
INVESTMENT, TAX, ACCOUNTING, AND OTHER ADVISORS TO DETERMINE THE
POTENTIAL BENEFITS, BURDENS, AND OTHER CONSEQUENCES OF SUCH INVESTMENT.
+++
ANY QUESTIONS REGARDING THIS OFFERING, AND ANY REQUESTS FOR COPIES OF THE
MEMORANDUM, THE PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT AND THE SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT
SHOULD BE FORWARDED TO:
Valar Ventures LLC
915 Broadway, Suite 1101
New York, New York 10010
email:
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum
vi
TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
II. KEY PRINCIPAL TERMS 3
III. INVESTMENT STRATEGY 4
IV. COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES 7
V. PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT 10

VI. INVESTMENT HISTORY 12
VII. FUND PERFORMANCE AND PORTFOLIO COMPANY PROFILES 14
VIII. SUMMARY OF PRINCIPAL TERMS 15

IX. CERTAIN RISK FACTORS 27
X. CERTAIN TAX AND REGULATORY MATTERS 37
XI. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 47
APPENDIX A: LEGAL NOTICES A-I
APPENDIX B: FUND COMPOSITION AND PERFORMANCE B-I
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Valar Ventures is a venture capital firm focused on identifying and investing in high-growth, early -stage
technology companies with the potential to become multi -billion dollar enterprises within 5.7 years of
initial investment. Based in New York City, and with one of the strongest brands and networks in the
industry, Valar is uniquely positioned to identify and access exceptional early -stage investment
opportunities across geographies — from the Bay Area to New York to Europe.
Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald (the "Managing Partners") formed Valar Ventures in 2010
while working at Thiel Capital, Peter Thiel's family office. Peter was Valar's initial sponsor and
represented over S0% of the firm's capital commitments, on an aggregate basis, in the firm's initial
investment vehicles (collectively referred to herein as "Fund I"). Valar Ventures spun -out of Thiel
Capital in 2013 and is now backed by a broad range of endowments, foundations, institutional wealth
managers, family offices and high net worth individuals. Andrew and James are the sole members of the
firm's Investment Committee and are responsible for all of the firm's day-to-day operations.
The Firm currently manages over $300 million in capital commitments across all its funds and investment
vehicles, and is currently investing out of Valar Global Fund 3, a $100 million fund that is more than 90%
invested or reserved for follow-on investments in existing portfolio companies.
Valar is now raising a further fund ("Fund 4", the "Fund" or the "Partnership") with targeted capital
commitments of $100.150 million. The Fund is expected to emphasize Series A and Series B stage
investments in high-growth technology companies based in first-world economies, with a focus on the
US, Europe and Canada, where Valar believes the opportunity to build a massive, globally dominant
technology company is the highest (the "Strategy").
Since inception, Valar has consistently generated significant returns for its investors, across all of its
funds. Fund I has significantly outperformed industry benchmarks. And while Funds 2 and 3 are still too
early for industry comps, the net IRRs are evidence of early traction in the firm's major investments in
those funds.
As of June 30, 2017, Valar has deployed $254.7 million in the Strategy, with a gross asset value of $649.4
million, including realized and unrealized investment gains and losses. Valar Fund I (an aggregation of
all funds and investments vehicle managed by Valar prior to the formation of Valar Fund 2) has a current
gross multiple of 4.3x since October 2010, which, if treated as a single fund, would place its performance
within the top echelon of all venture funds and one that has significantly outperformed common public
market index references, such as the S&P 500.1 Out of a total 15 portfolio companies where Valar has
invested at least $5 million since inception, two (Xero and TransferWise) have already achieved
valuations in excess of a billion dollars and three (Breather, N26 and Stash) have already achieved
valuations in excess of a quarter of a billion dollars.
Composition of public market indices may not be comparable with composition of Valar's portfolio and past performance 
may
not be an indicator of future performance.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum
RESULTS
Inception Capital
Commitments
Current
FMV
Gross/Net
Multiple
Gross/Net IRR DPI % of Fun
Invested/
Reserved
Fund 1 Oct 2010 $100.0M $411.8M 4.3x / 3.4x 43.7% / 36.3% 1.2x 100%
Fund 2 Jan 2015 $102.3M $139.5M 1.6x / I.3x 36.2% / 27.9% N/A 100%
Fund 3 July 2016 $103.9M $94.8M 1.4x / I.3x 207.4% / 146.0% N/A 90%
- All figure presented are unaudited estimates 'n USD as of 6/30/2017, including signed deals that are expec ed to
lose in Q3. Gross figures do not include the impact of fees, expenses and carry, and net figures are calculated by
reducing gross investment profits by a flat 25/. for hypothetical management fees, expenses. and carry. Past
performance may not be an indicator of future performance.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 3
Private Placement Memorandum
II. KEY PRINCIPAL TERMS
The following information is presented as a summary of certain of the Fund's key principal terms only
and is qualified in its entirety by the more detailed information contained in "Section VII. Summary of
Principal Terms" herein and by the Partnership Agreement, which will be circulated to investors prior to
closing. To the extent that this summary conflicts with the Partnership Agreement, the Partnership
Agreement will control.
Target Size $100 million - 150 million
General Partner
Commitment
At least 1% of fee-bearing capital
Term 10 years, subject to two, one-year extensions at the General Partner's
discretion and thereafter with the consent of a majority in interest of
the Limited Partners
Commitment Period 5 years
Management Fee 2.5% of Limited Partners' capital commitments until the end of the
Commitment Period; reduced thereafter by 0.1% annually, but not
below 1.5% of the aggregate capital commitments of the Limited
Partners
Management Fee
Reduction
100% of all directors, consulting, management services, transaction,
advisory, break-up or broken deal fees
Carried Interest Carried interest is not payable until 100% of capital contributions have
been returned to the Partners, and thereafter will be 20% of net profits
until the Fund distributes to each Limited Partner an amount equal to
300% of its capital commitment; thereafter 25% of net profits until the
Fund distributes to each Limited Partner an amount equal to 600% of
its capital commitment; thereafter 30% of net profits (in each case, with
full catch-up for the General Partner)
Clawback Yes, with a guaranty by each managing member of its share on a
several, but not joint, basis
Investment Committee /
Key Persons
James Fitzgerald and Andrew McCormack
No Fault Termination Yes, at any time by the election of eighty percent (80%) in interest of
the Limited Partners
Organizational Expenses Capped at $500,000
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 4
Private Placement Memorandum
III. INVESTMENT STRATEGY

A. CORE STRATEGY
Valar's core strategy is to use its strong brand and its execution-oriented team structure to invest in high-
growth, early stage technology companies located in North America and Europe.
Stage: Valar's typical initial investment is generally sized at $3-$12 million into a company that has an
enterprise (pre-money) valuation of between $20 and $100 million (in general, Series A and Series B
stage investments). A small amount of each fund (up to 10% of capital commitments) may be invested
into earlier, seed stage companies, which are considered non-core to the fund's strategy, but some of
which may develop into major investments for a fund. In Funds 2 and 3, the average initial check size for
major investments has been approximately $7 million. Before making an initial investment, Valar looks
for a company to have achieved some initial product/market fit. This can be evidenced by significant
customer engagement, early revenue growth, executed partnership agreements (especially in an enterprise
sales distribution model) or other market validation of the company's vision and execution. The amount
of traction required prior to the Fund investing may vary depending on the market a company is focused
on. For example, fintech companies that are digitizing previously analog or inefficient business processes
require less proof points, whereas marketplace businesses or companies that are unlocking previously
hidden demand require more evidence of traction prior to Valar investing. The Managing Partners also
look to the strength of a company's team (including "founder/market fit") as evidence that it is at an
appropriate stage to warrant an investment. Valar is comfortable making sizeable investments at even
very early stages where the above dynamics are in place.
Sector: Valar is focused on backing companies with the potential to become multi -billion dollar
enterprises during the life of the Fund. Valar believes these companies tend to be high-margin businesses
focused on massive markets, such as currency transfer (Transferwise), banking (N26, Qonto), commercial
real estate (Breather), insurance (Jetty, Coya), investing/retirement savings (Stash), accounting software
(Xero), and human resources/compliance software (Kato). Given that the statistical likelihood of success
for any individual startup is low, Valar believes that constructing a portfolio of companies that are
operating in trillion dollar industries provides the highest potential to produce at least one significant
success. In sourcing and filtering investment opportunities, Valar's investment process eliminates
companies that do not have a massive Total Addressable Market ("TAM"). Most often, when the firm
passes on an investment, it's because it failed this TAM test.
Geography: Valar backs companies that are founded in, and focused on, the United States and Europe.
Valar believes that these first-world geographies have the highest potential to consistently produce the
sort of multi -billion dollar technology companies that Valar seeks to invest in. Valar's headquarters in
New York City affords it a key advantage in accessing opportunities on the East Coast and in Europe
while still being within reasonable distance (in terms of time zones and flight times) to work with its
companies that are based in, or ultimately relocate to, the Bay Area.
Within North American and Europe, Valar believes that certain cities have a significant advantage in
terms of affording a startup the best chance of success. While in theory, an internet-based business can
be started from anywhere in the world, scaling a technology company into a global champion requires
access to a deep network of capital, business partners and available talent at all stages of the company's
lifecycle. Valar believes that, in the Western World, these dynamics are most prevalent in Silicon Valley,
New York, London, Berlin and Paris, and to a lesser extent, in the smaller cities that feed into the larger
tech hubs (e.g., Provo, Boulder, Portland, Seattle, Los Angeles, all of which feed into Silicon Valley;
Conlidcanal & Trade Secret
VALAR 5
Private Placement Memorandum
Toronto, Montreal, and Boston, which feed into New York; or Amsterdam, Stockholm, Helsinki, and
Tallinn, which feed into London).
In Fund 4, Valar intends to continue focusing on companies being built in the geographies in North
America and Europe where Valar has previously invested and where its brand value, networks and
experience give it a significant competitive advantage in terms of accessing the best opportunities.
B. TARGET RETURNS & PORTFOLIO CONSTRUCTION
Valar intends for each of its flagship funds to realize a 4-6x gross return over the life of the fund. In order
to achieve this, Valar places significant importance on the following portfolio construction practices that
maximize the potential for outsized returns:
High Concentration: Valar believes strongly in the "power law" theory of venture finance, where the
single best performing investment tends to generate a greater return than all of the other investments in a
fund combined (and where the second-best performing investment contributes more to the fund's
performance than all other investment thereafter combined, and so on). Accordingly, Valar expects that
a limited number of major investments — companies meriting at least $3M in capital from the fund - will
receive 90% of the fund's invested capital on a cost basis (e.g., 6-8 major investments in a $100M fund),
and that the top performing two (or sometimes three) best investments will receive more than 50% of a
fund's invested capital.
For example, in Fund I, two companies, Xero and Transferwise, which make up nearly 100% of Fund
l's profits, received approximately 54% of Fund I (based on committed capital). Similarly,
approximately 52% of Fund 2 committed capital has been invested in three companies (Breather, N26
and Kalo), with Breather reaching the fund's concentration limit of 25%. And in Fund 3, three companies
(Stash, Octane and Qonto) account for 42% of Fund 3's capital commitments, with significant reserves
remaining for additional follow-on investment, if warranted.
Significant Follow -On Capital into the Best Performers: Valar believes ensuring that the best performing
company or companies have received the lion's share of the fund's investment is key to managing a
successful, highly concentrated venture fund. Valar works to achieve this by legging into its investments
over time, affording the Managing Partners the opportunity to monitor the performance of each company
and determine where the fund's incremental dollars are best allocated. For example, in Fund I, Valar
made four separate investments into Xero over the span of 3+ years (with the third investment being by
far its largest) and three investments into Transferwise, writing larger checks in each subsequent round.
Moreover, Valar led Transferwise's Series A and Series B, taking advantage of Valar's position as an
insider to identify a business that had extreme traction and velocity and significantly increase Fund l's
ownership in the company at the right time. To this day, Valar remains the largest investor in
Transferwise, a company now valued at $1.7B. The lessons from Fund I have been applied to Funds 2
and 3, with Valar making three investments into each of Breather and N26 from Fund 2 (with the majority
of Valar's investment into each company coming after Fund 2's first investment into each company) and
three investments into Stash Invest from Fund 3 (where Valar co-led the Series A with a $3M investment,
and then led the Series B with a $15M investment). Rather than simply taking additional "shots on goal"
— a strategy that Valar believes is a common mistake among other venture firms — Valar intends to
continue allocating the remaining reserves from both Funds 2 and 3 into its existing portfolio companies
that demonstrate the highest expected returns for its investors.
In some cases, later follow-on investments, including those at significantly higher valuations, may be
made by separate co-investment vehicles or subsequent funds. In addition, Valar may raise a later stage
"opportunity fund" in order to take advantage of access to growth stage rounds of companies that have
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 6
Private Placement Memorandum
exceeded the fund's early stage mandate (e.g., companies raising follow-on financing at valuations in
excess of $250 million).
Small Funds: Valar believes that smaller funds are more suited for investors looking to achieve annual
returns in excess of a 20% IRR. Accordingly, all of Valar's funds have been relatively small, with Funds
2 and 3 having capital commitments of just over $100M each. The firm is targeting $100M-$150M for
Fund 4. Given the firm's investment pace, these smaller funds are expected to be fully deployed in
approximately three years, with a new fund being raised every 18.24 months.
Venture Math: As a result of Valar's portfolio construction principles (small funds with high
concentration and significant follow-on in the best performing companies), any single portfolio company
may return a fund multiple times. For example, in Fund 1, Transfenvise (which received 22% of the
fund's capital commitments), currently accounts for over 2.5x the fund's capital commitments, a figure
which the firm expects could end up being two or even three times higher. Valar expects that this dynamic
may be even more manifest in Funds 2 and 3, where Valar has emphasized buying larger stakes of each
company in its initial investment, increasing the firm's average ownership percentage in its major
investments from 12% in Fund 1 to 16% in Fund 2 and nearly 20% in Fund 3. As a result, the average
exit valuation required in order for a single company to return 100% of each fund's respective capital
commitments was close to $1 billion for Fund 1, but only $650 million for Fund 2 and closer to $500
million for Fund 3.
Valar intends to employ the portfolio concentration principles outlined above in the operation of Fund 4.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 7
Private Placement Memorandum

IV. COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGES
A. SUPERIOR DEAL FLOW & ACCESS
Early-stage venture capital is fundamentally a people business. Valar's network and reputation are critical
to identifying the most promising opportunities, convincing the best entrepreneurs to accept Valar's
investment and then helping its companies access smart, down-stream capital. The Managing Partners
have spent years building their network and cultivating relationships with key players in each of the
venture eco-systems in which they operate.
Deal Flow: Valar's superior deal flow comes from three sources:

I. Valar/Thiel Proprietary Network: Prior to forming Valar, Andrew and James had already
developed strong networks on both Coasts: Andrew in California, as part of the "PayPal
Mafia", and James as a lawyer at a top Wall Street law firm in New York. Then, in 2008,
the Managing Partners joined Peter Thiel at Clarium (later Thiel Capital), where they
worked closely with many of the rising generation of start-ups and investors, including the
founders and senior leadership of Palantir, Facebook, Eventbrite, Founders Fund, Tiger
Global, Formation8 (now 8VC), 137 Ventures, and Goldcrest Capital, to name just a few.
These relationships, together with Peter Thiel's initial support, accelerated the Managing
Partners entry into venture capital and directly yielded some of the firm's best investments
to date, including Transferwise (an introduction from Max Levchin), Stash Invest (an
introduction through Andrew's San Francisco network) and Octane Lending (an
introduction from James' former colleagues at Skadden).

2. Local Connections: Similar to Silicon Valley, each of the major cities in which Valar
operates has a known circle of top entrepreneurs and investors. The Managing Partners have
added to their pre-existing relationships in the Bay Area by spending significant time over
the past 5 years developing deep relationships with the major players in each of the other
core cities in which it operates (e.g., New York, London, Berlin, Paris). Each of the tech
hubs has fairly well established accelerator programs, angel investors and seed-stage
investing communities. In particular, seed-stage venture firms that are not positioned to be
lifecycle investors are attractive local partners for Valar, as those firms tend to be highly
incented to share their best deal flow with deeper pocketed venture funds that can provide
Series A, B and later financing to their portfolio companies. These relationships serve to
channel deals to Valar as the investor of first choice when companies are looking to raise
new financing rounds, particularly in New York (where working with a local investor is
preferable to Bay Area money) and in Europe (where partnership with a US firm is viewed
as a strong validation of a startups prospects).
3. In -House Research: The Internet, it turns out, is a powerful source of information sharing,
and the past few years have seen an explosion of technology-focused news outlets, blogs
and daily email circulars that surface even the earliest and geographically most remote of
startup financings. Because Valar is not generally the first money invested in a company,
and because the best entrepreneurs are often highly attuned to building their online presence
early, Valar can identify and monitor startups, even in distant geographies, before they reach
an appropriate stage of investment for the Fund. Once a potential portfolio company is
identified, Valar can use its local networks in the relevant market to obtain an introduction,
or directly contact the company's management team, relying on the Firm's global reputation
to access to the best companies.
Conlidcnliat & Trade Secret
VALAR 8
Private Placement Memorandum
Access: The best entrepreneurs understand the importance of receiving investment from the most
reputable venture firms. Unlike public companies or even later-stage private firms, information about
early -stage startup companies is not readily available. As a result, many of the key contributors to a
startup's ultimate success (e.g., potential employees, prospective customers and downstream investors)
rely heavily on the signaling effect that results from a company receiving investment from a highly
respected investor. Setting this virtuous circle in motion is of paramount concern to early -stage founders,
and is arguably the single most important "value add" a venture investor can offer. In that regard, the
imprimatur of Valar choosing to invest in one company over others has significant and immediate
reputational and branding benefits to the chosen company. As a result of Valar's prior successes investing
in leading fintech startups (Xero, Transfenvise, N26, Stash), Valar's reputation as a top fintech investor
has grown significantly in the past two years. Moreover, Valar has demonstrated its ability to help attract
future downstream financing from top funds, with several of the fum's portfolio companies taking
subsequent capital from a number of the most respected VCs, including Accel (Xero), Andreesen-
Horowitz and IVP (Transfenvise), Coatue Management (Stash Invest), Menlo Ventures and Google
Ventures (Breather), and Horizon Ventures (N26).
Beyond the social proof the Valar brand provides, the Managing Partners have also cultivated a reputation
for adding value by aligning the core terms of the company's governing documents towards growth and
removing founder -unfriendly structures that constrain a startup's flexibility and growth. The Firm is
known for practicing a high-availability, low-touch style of working with founders; connecting
management with the Firm's networks and offering strategic advice and mentoring as needed. The strong
referrals provided by Valar's portfolio company CEOs have become an important part of the Finn's
ability to get into the best deals. Examples include Breather's Series B and Jetty's Series A, both of which
were highly competitive rounds, and where the founders placed significant weight on the input provided
by Valar's other portfolio companies. Valar expects that the continued success of its portfolio companies,
and the increasing respect earned by the Managing Partners in the startup eco-system, will keep in motion
the virtuous circle that helps drive persistence in venture capital returns for the best performing managers.

B. WILLINGNESS TO TRAVEL
For most Silicon Valley -based funds, making a small, early -stage investment (seed, Series A or even
Series B) into an East Coast or European -based startup is simply not practical. The travel required to
attend board meetings and work closely with companies at that stage is outside of the historical practice
of most Bay Area VCs, a tradition that has been reinforced by both (a) the intense competition among
VCs in the Bay Area (there is an important opportunity cost of spending time in other places), (b) the
sheer difficulty in traveling from San Francisco to many of the emerging tech hubs (for example, there
are no daily non-stop flights from San Francisco to Berlin, and there are no flights under 10 hours from
San Francisco to anywhere in Europe), and (c) the simple realities of time zones (Continental Europe is
+9.10 hours ahead of California, making scheduling board calls and informal check -ins very difficult).
As a result, many of the most prestigious venture firms still remain largely focused on the West Coast at
the seed, Series A and Series B stages. This dynamic creates a large and growing opportunity, which
Valar has been capitalizing on by identifying and working with promising startups on the East Coast and
in Europe before they are even on the radar or within the investment mandate of most West Coast venture
capital funds.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 9
Private Placement Memorandum
C. EXECUTION-ORIENTED TEAM
Valar's small size and execution -oriented team has been optimized to allow the Firm to move faster and
outflank every firm it has competed against to date. The Managing Partners have devoted considerable
thought to how to structure its team — an area that it believes has posed significant challenges to the ability
of other venture capital firms to access opportunities outside of their home markets.
The core dynamic of Valar's investment process is its "perpetual -partner -meeting" model, meaning that
Andrew and James generally travel and take all calls and meetings together and thus possess nearly
symmetric information and are in constant communication about all opportunities available to Valar. The
ability to make partnership level decisions in real-time has been key to Valar's success in securing the
best opportunities, even in the face of competition from older, more established venture firms with much
larger funds and partnerships. Moreover, the Managing Partners attend board meetings and work on all
major investments together, avoiding deal attribution or the political horse-trading that goes along with
that (there is no "you support my deal and I will support your deal"). This dynamic is particularly
important when determining how to allocate remaining dollars in a fund that are reserved for a limited
number of follow-on opportunities. As noted above, Valar has been highly successfully preempting
successive financing rounds (e.g., Transferwise, Breather, Stash); the Managing Partners' tight alignment
and shared data set was key to those decisions.
Valar expects to hire additional investment associates and back office personnel as it expands, but all
investment decisions and deal sourcing are expected to be made by the existing Managing Partners for
the foreseeable future. Valar believes that its small team and unanimous voting make it more nimble than
firms with large investment committees, politicized "Monday meetings", struggles over attribution and
economics, and other internal angst caused by large teams operating in an industry where lumpy, large
gains, long divorced in time from the investment decision create unhealthy dynamics that erode returns.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 10
Private Placement Memorandum

V. PARTNERSHIP MANAGEMENT
A. VOTING PROCESS AND CONTROL
The Partnership will be managed by Andrew and James. Investment decisions will be made with the
unanimous consent of James and Andrew (the "Investment Committee"). If either James or Andrew is
affected by a conflict of interest, the additional consent of the Fund's Advisory Board regarding the
proposed transaction will be sought. The General Partner anticipates appointing an advisory board of
three to five members, to be selected in its discretion following the closing of the Fund. While Peter Thiel
is not a member of the Investment Committee and is not expected to be involved in the day-to-day
management of the Firm, he owns 20% of the General Partner and the Management Company and may
retain veto rights over certain activities of the General Partner, the Management Company and the Fund.

B. STRATEGIC DIRECTION
Andrew and James have traveled the world and taken nearly all meetings together for the past seven years.
Based on their intensive experience working together with entrepreneurs and portfolio companies on four
continents, they have been able to iterate quickly and continuously refine the Strategy to optimize for the
markets, stage of investment, founder attributes and firm structure with the highest potential for yielding
outsized venture returns.
C. TEAM BIOGRAPHIES
Andrew McCormack
Andrew is a founder and Managing Partner at Valar Ventures. Andrew's career in technology
has included business and corporate development roles at eCount (acquired by Citicorp) and
Yahoo! He joined PayPal in 2001, where he worked closely with Peter in preparing for the
company's IPO. After PayPal's sale to eBay, Andrew helped launch Clarium Capital and later
founded a restaurant group in San Francisco.
In 2008, Andrew rejoined Peter at Thiel Capital, where he led various international initiatives
for Thiel Capital and Peter personally. Andrew received his B.A. in Political Science from the
University of Pennsylvania.
James Fitzgerald
James is a founder and Managing Partner at Valar Ventura. Prior to Valar, he was COO and
General Counsel of Peter Thiel's global parent company, Thiel Capital, where he helped manage
Peter's extensive network of investments and businesses. In that capacity, he worked closely
with Founders Fund, Mithril, and Clarium.
Prior to joining Thiel Capital, James practiced law for seven years in the New York office of
Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP. He received his J.D. from the University of
California, Los Angeles and his undergraduate degree from Brigham Young University.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR II
Private Placement Memorandum
Reuben Kobuinik
Reuben is the Chief Operating Officer and Chief Financial Officer of Valar Ventures,
responsible for all operational, financial reporting and legal matters.
Prior to joining Valar, Reuben was Counsel at Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP,
where he practiced M&A, private equity and general corporate law for nine years. While at
Skadden, Reuben worked closely with James on a number of transactions. Before joining
Skadden, Reuben clerked for Justice Morris J. Fish of the Supreme Court of Canada.
Reuben received his law degree as well as an undergraduate degree in Finance and Strategy from
McGill University.
John Tenet
John is an Investment Principal at Valar Ventures and is responsible for sourcing and evaluating
technology-driven companies across a variety of sectors, as well as providing assistance to the
Firm's portfolio companies. John joined Valar from Allen & Company, where he spent 3 years
investing in technology, media, and telecom deals, as well as focusing on third party manager
sourcing and due diligence as part of the Capital Markets and Investment Management
Divisions.
John received his B.A. in Government from Georgetown University in 2010.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 12
Private Placement Memorandum
VI. INVESTMENT HISTORY
Valar began as a new strategy incubated within Thiel Capital that sought to invest in the increasing
number of globally significant technology companies being founded outside of Peter's historical focus of
Northern Califomia. To that end, the team began scouting internationally for opportunities in 2010,
initially making investments through a series of special purpose vehicles that were primarily funded by
Peter, and ultimately spinning out as a stand-alone strategy with significant capital commitments from
outside investors:
2010: Valar Ventures LP, a New Zealand partnership (the "New Zealand Fund), made Valar's
ifrst investments in New Zealand. Approximately 40% of the capital commitments to the New
Zealand Fund were from Peter Thiel; the rest from the New Zealand government and other third
party investors.
2012: Opportunities in Xero exceeded the New Zealand Fund's concentration limits and Valar
launched VV Xero Holdings LLC (the "Xero SPV) to harvest those opportunities.
2012.2013:  As Valar broadened its efforts internationally, VV Global LP and VV Global
Principals LP were formed to take advantage of a growing number of opportunities outside of
New Zealand (the "VV Funds"). The VV Funds were 100% funded by Peter Thiel and, with one
exception, made all investments pari passu.
2013: Based on the success of earlier Valar funds, Velar Global Fund I LP and Valar Global
Principals Fund I LP were raised in 2013 with 10% outside capital to invest in technology
companies globally. These funds have made all investments par! passu and are collectively
referred to as "Global Fund I". Among other things, Global Fund 1 was intended to serve as a
template for Valar's first institutional fund, including by providing the legal framework,
auditable track record and other internal processes necessary to attract institutional capital.
2014: Valar's pro rata rights in the Series C financing of TransferWise, led by Andreessen-
Horowitz, exceeded the remaining capital of the VV Funds and Global Fund 1. Valar raised a
sidecar fund, Valar Co-Invest I LP (the "TransferWise SPV), to participate in that round.
2014.2015:  Valar Global Fund II LP and Valar Global Principals Fund II LP, which invest pari
passu in all transactions (together, "Fund 2") were raised in late 2014 and closed in January
2015. Capital commitments to Fund 2 totaled $102 million, with approximately 70% of the funds
coming from outside investors (primarily educational endowments, large multi -family offices
and high net worth individuals) and the remaining capital commitments coming from Peter Thiel
(approximately 30%) and Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald (approximately 1%). 100%
of capital commitments have been invested or reserved for follow-ons and expenses.
2016-2017:  Valar Global Fund III LP and Valar Global Principals Fund III LP, which invest
part passu in all transactions (together, "Fund 3") closed in July 2016. Capital commitments to
Fund 3 totaled $104 million, with approximately 70% of the funds coming from outside investors
(primarily educational endowments, large multi -family offices and high net worth individuals)
and the remaining capital commitments coming from Peter Thiel (approximately 30%) and
Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald (approximately 1%). To date, 90% of capital
commitments have been invested or reserved for follow-ons and expenses.
Confidential & Tradc Scat'
VALAR 13
Private Placement Memorandum
2017: Valar's pro rata rights in the Series C financing of Stash Invest, led by Coatue
Management, exceeded Fund 3's reserves for the company. Valar raised a sidecar fund, Valar
Co-Invest 2 LP (the "Stash SPV"), to participate in that round.
For ease of reference in this document, "Fund 1" refers to all the funds and investment vehicles listed
above that were formed prior to Fund 2, on an aggregate basis.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 14
Private Placement Memorandum
VII. FUND PERFORMANCE AND PORTFOLIO COMPANY PROFILES
Performance information for all Fund 1, Fund 2 and Fund 3 portfolio companies where Valar's initial
cost basis was in excess of $2.5 million ("Major Investments") appear below in Appendix B. Valar's
detailed investment track record, including a complete list of all portfolio company investments, is
available in the Finn's electronic data room.2
Interested investors should contact Valar for access to the electronic data room.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 15
Private Placement Memorandum
VIII. SUMMARY OF PRINCIPAL TERMS
The following is a summary of certain of the proposed terms of the Limited Partnership Agreement of
Valar Global Fund IV LP (the "Partnership Agreement') and Operating Agreement of the General
Partner. This summary does not purport to be complete and is qualified in its entirety by reference to the
Partnership Agreement.
FUND: Valar Global Fund IV LP (the "Fund" or the "Partnership") will be
organized as a Delaware limited partnership.
PURPOSE: To invest, as a general matter, in earlier-stage, high-growth technology
companies through direct, privately negotiated investments in equity or
equity-oriented securities of private and, in certain cases, public companies
with limited liquidity.
GENERAL PARTNER: Valar Ventures GP IV LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, will be
the general partner of the Fund (the "General Partner").
LIMITED PARTNERS: Institutions and private individuals (or their estate planning vehicles) that
are "accredited investors" within the meaning of the United States
Securities Act of 1933 or qualified non-U.S. persons (the "Limited
Partners", and together with the General Partner the "Partners").
FUND SIZE: The target size of the Fund is $100 -$150 million in committed capital from
the Partners (the "Capital Commitments").
GENERAL PARTNER'S
CAPITAL
COMMITMENT:
The General Partner will make a Capital Commitment to the Fund of at
least 1% of the aggregate fee bearing Capital Commitments of the Partners.
In lieu of a contribution to the Fund entirely in cash, the General Partner
may elect to make "deemed" capital contributions for up to 80% of its
Capital Commitment, which would reduce subsequent management fee
payments due to the General Partner by corresponding amounts (each such
amount being a "Fee Adjustment").
TIMING OF CAPITAL Each Limited Partner will contribute capital periodically in installments as
Con ltd.:float & Trade Secret
VALAR 16
Private Placement Memorandum
CONTRIBUTIONS: requested by the General Partner upon ten business days' prior written
notice; provided, that certain investors regulated under the Employee
Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended ("ERISA"), may be
required to make their first capital contribution into an escrow account or
may not be required to make a capital contribution prior to the date the Fund
makes its first investment and thereby qualifies as a "venture capital
operating company" under applicable Department of Labor regulations.
No Limited Partner will be required to contribute any capital following the
fifth anniversary of the date of the first investment in a portfolio company
except to the extent necessary for (i) Fund expenses (including payment of
management fees), (ii) completion of investments in new portfolio
companies evidenced by a written term sheet as of such fi fth anniversary.
(iii) funding follow-on investments in existing portfolio companies, and
(iv) fulfillment of indemnification and other obligations and liabilities of
the Fund. The period prior to the fifth anniversary of the date of the first
investment in a portfolio company is referred to as the "Commitment
Period".
TERM: The Fund will be dissolved ten years after the date of the Fund's first
investment in a portfolio company; provided, that the General Partner may
extend the Fund's term (a) for up to two additional one-year periods in its
sole discretion, and (b) for additional one-year periods with the consent of
Limited Partners holding more than 50% of the Capital Commitments (a
"Majority -in-Interest of the Limited Partners").
The Fund may be dissolved prior to the end of its stated term upon the
affirmative vote of Limited Partners holding more than 80% of the Capital
Commitments, or by the affirmative vote of Limited Partners holding more
than two-thirds-in-interest of the Capital Commitments ("Two-Thirds -in-
Interest of the Limited Partners") following certain events constituting
"cause" (as defined in the Partnership Agreement); provided, however, this
shall not apply if, in the case of acts by a Managing Member, the offending
individual is removed as a managing member of the General Partner.
MANAGEMENT
COMPANY:
The General Partner will cause the Fund to enter into a management
agreement with Valar Ventures LLC, a Delaware limited liability company.
or another entity beneficially owned by Andrew McCormack, James
Fitzgerald and Peter Thiel (or another Thiel Person (as defined below)
designated by Peter) (the "Management Company"), who will be the
manager of the Fund and provide management, administrative, operational
and other services to the Fund from time to time.
CONTROL: Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald are the Managing Members of
the General Partner of the Fund and responsible for the day-to-day
operations of the General Partner, the Management Company and the Fund.
Investment decisions of the Fund are made by the General Partner acting
Coo lidcanal & Trade Secret
VALAR 17
Private Placement Memorandum
through its Investment Committee (the "Investment Committee"), of which
Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald are the sole members.
While Peter Thiel is not a member of the Investment Committee and is not
expected to be involved in the day-to-day management or operations of the
General Partner, the Management Company or the Fund, Peter (directly or
through another Thiel Person) is expected to be a member of the General
Partner and entitled to 20% of the carried interest and net management fees
paid by the Fund. Moreover, in view of his status as the firm's
initial sponsor, Peter may retain veto rights over certain activities of the
General Partner, the Management Company and the Fund, as well as the
right to terminate Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald upon the
occurrence of certain events constituting cause.
ADVISORY
COMMITTEE:
The Fund will have an Advisory Committee that will serve as such for the
Fund and any Parallel Funds, consisting of no less than 3 and no more than
7 representatives of the Limited Partners and constituent limited partners of
the Parallel Funds chosen (and subject to removal at any time) by the General
Partner in its reasonable judgment (the "Advisory Committee"); provided
that the General Partner may not appoint any Limited Partner that is an
affiliate of the General Partner or any of its respective affiliates. The
Advisory Committee will (a) have such duties as are set forth in the
Partnership Agreement, (b) approve or disapprove matters pertaining to
conflicts of interest as requested by the General Partner (excluding certain
matters otherwise expressly addressed pursuant to the terms of the
Partnership Agreement), and (c) render such other advice and counsel as
requested by the General Partner. The Fund will reimburse each member of
the Advisory Committee for his or her reasonable out-of-pocket expenses in
connection with his or her activities on the Advisory Committee.
MANAGEMENT FEE: A management fee will be paid by the Limited Partners of the Fund and the
annual management fee will be equal to the Fund's aggregate Capital
Commitments made by the Limited Partners multiplied by 2.50% (the
"Management Fee Percentage"). Notwithstanding the foregoing.
beginning with the first full fiscal year that begins after the end of the
Commitment Period the Management Fee Percentage will be reduced
annually by ten basis points (La, by 0.10% per annum) until it is equal to
1.50%. The installment of management fee payable for any fiscal quarter
will be equal to one-fourth (114) of the Management Fee Percentage in
effect for such fiscal quarter (as adjusted) multiplied by the aggregate
Capital Commitments made by the Limited Partners.
The management fee payable with respect to a fiscal quarter will be reduced
by the aggregate amount that the General Partner has elected not to
contribute in cash prior to such quarter (i.e., the sum of all Fee
Adjustments).
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR I8
Private Placement Memorandum
The management fee will also be reduced by 100% of (i) all cash and non-
cash compensation paid as directors, consulting, management services,
transaction, advisory, break-up or broken deal fees or other similar fees
received by the General Partner, the Management Company, or the
respective managing members or managers of such entities in connection
with portfolio investments of the Fund and attributable to the Fund's actual
investment in such entities and (ii) any placement fees paid by the Fund
with respect to the sale of limited partnership interest in the Fund. The
management fee will be further reduced during an extension period.
KEY PERSON: In the event that either (i) James Fitzgerald or (ii) Andrew McCormack
(each as a "Managing Member" and collectively as "Managing
Members") ceases to be a managing member of the General Partner.
otherwise ceases to participate in the management of the Fund or fails to
meet his obligations to devote his business time to the Fund as set forth
below under "Time Commitment" (a "Suspension Event"), the
Commitment Period will automatically be suspended and shall terminate
unless Two-Thirds-in-Interest of the Limited Partners affirmatively vote to
terminate the suspension within one hundred and eighty (180) days of its
commencement; provided, that a Two-Thirds-in-Interest of the Limited
Partners may vote to terminate a suspension period at any time.
Upon the suspension of the Commitment Period, the General Partner will
not request further capital contributions except as required for: (i) Fund
expenses (including payment of management fees), (ii) completion of
investments in new portfolio companies in process at the time of suspension
as evidenced by a written term sheet, (iii) funding follow-on investments in
existing portfolio companies so long as the Advisory Committee consents
to each such investment, and (iv) fulfillment of indemnification and other
obligations and liabilities of the Fund.
Andrew McCormack and James Fitzgerald are each subject to provisions
under which Peter Thiel may remove them from the Management
Company or the General Partner for certain events constituting "cause" or
otherwise by a vote of one or more of the other members. In the event of
such removal, a Managing Member would cease providing services to the
Fund, thereby triggering a Suspension Event
ALLOCATIONS OF At the end of each fiscal year or other accounting period, the net profit and
PROFIT & Loss: loss for such period will be allocated as follows:

i. First, until the "First Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is met.
allocations shall be made in a manner necessary to cause cumulative net
profit and loss to be allocated 80% to the Partners, in proportion to their
relative Capital Commitments, and 20% to the General Partner. The "First
Allocation Hurdle" will be deemed to have been met when each Limited
Partner has been allocated net profits equal to 200% of its Capital
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 19
Private Placement Memorandum
Commitment (i.e., an amount sufficient to enable the Fund to distribute to
each Limited Partner an amount equal to 300% of its Capital Commitment).

ii. Second, after the First Allocation Hurdle has been met, and until the
"Second Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is met, (x) 100% to the
General Partner until the General Partner has been allocated 25% of the
Fund's net profits and (y) thereafter allocations shall be made in a manner
necessary to cause cumulative net profit and loss to be allocated 75% to the
Partners, in proportion to their relative Capital Commitments, and 25% to
the General Partner. The "Second Allocation Hurdle" will be deemed to
have been met when each Limited Partner has been allocated net profits
equal to 500% of its Capital Commitment (i.e., an amount sufficient to
enable the Fund to distribute to each Limited Partner an amount equal to
600% of its Capital Commitment).
iii. Third, after the Second Allocation Hurdle has been met, (x) 100% to the
General Partner until the General Partner has been allocated 30% of the
Fund's net profits and (y) thereafter 70% to the Partners, pro rata in
proportion to their relative Capital Commitments, and 30% to the General
Partner.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the General Partner will receive priority
allocations of net profits equal to all prior Fee Adjustments.
DISTRIBUTIONS: The General Partner may cause the Fund to make distributions of cash or
marketable securities from time to time in its discretion, subject to
reasonable cash reserves for Fund expenses. No more than 120% of the
Fund's aggregate Capital Commitments shall be invested in portfolio
companies during the term of the Fund. Distributions will be made as
follows:

i. First, to all Partners in proportion to their relative Capital Commitments
until each Partner has received an amount equal to its aggregate capital
contributions.

ii. Second, until the cumulative amount distributed to each Partner is equal
to 300% of such Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of
distribution, such distribution shall be made in the proportions necessary to
cause cumulative distributions (other than distributions made pursuant to

(i) above) to have been made, (x) 20% to the General Partner; and (y) 80%
to all Partners in proportion to their relative Capital Commitments.
iii. Third, after the aggregate amount distributed to each Limited Partner is
equal to 300% of such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date
of such distribution, 100% to the General Partner until it has received
aggregate distributions totaling 25% of (x) the aggregate distributions made
to the Partners pursuant to (ii) above plus (y) the aggregate Tax
Distributions (as defined below) made to the Partners.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 20
Private Placement Memorandum

iv. Fourth, until the cumulative amount distributed to each Partner is equal
to 600% of such Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of
distribution, such distribution shall be made in the proportions necessary to
cause cumulative distributions (other than distributions made pursuant to

(i) above) to have been made, (x) 25% to the General Partner; and (y) 75%
to all Partners in proportion to their relative Capital Commitments.

v. Fifth, after the aggregate amount distributed to each Limited Partner is
equal to 600% of such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date
of distribution, 100% to the General Partner until it has received aggregate
distributions totaling 30% of (x) the aggregate distributions made to the
Partners pursuant to (ii), (iii) and (iv) above plus (y) the aggregate Tax
Distributions made to the Partners.
vi. Sixth, (x) 30% to the General Partner; and (y) 70% to all Partners in
proportion to their relative Capital Commitments.
TAX DISTRIBUTIONS: Following the end of each fiscal year, the General Partner may cause the
Fund to distribute cash to each Partner in an amount equal to the
"Applicable Tax Rate" (as defined below) multiplied by net taxable income
(a "Tax Distribution"), less all prior cash distributions; provided, that the
General Partner will have no obligation to make the foregoing distributions
if the total amount to be distributed to all Partners would be less than S I
million. For each fiscal year, the amount distributed to any Partner as a Tax
Distribution shall not exceed the amount by which (A) such Partner's
cumulative aggregate annual tax liability with respect to the Fund for such
fiscal year and all prior fiscal years exceeds (B) the cumulative aggregate
cash distributions made to such Partner as Tax Distributions and other
regular distributions through the end of such fiscal year and all prior fiscal
years.
The "Applicable Tax Rate" means the highest blended federal, state and
local marginal income, self employment and medicare tax rates then
applicable to an individual residing in any state of the United States, applied
by taking into account the character of the taxable income in question (i.e..
capital gain, ordinary income, etc.).
CLAWBACK: The General Partner will be required to pay back to the Fund the amount
by which the cumulative net distributions received by the General Partner
over the life of the Fund (excluding amounts received by the General
Partner in respect of its Capital Commitment) exceeds the product of (A)
the applicable carried interest percentage; and (ii) the aggregate amount of
profit distributions made to all Partners during the whole term of the Fund;
provided, that the General Partner will not be obligated to pay an amount
in excess of the aggregate carried interest and profit distributions it has
received (valued at the time of distribution in the case of securities
distributions) less the gross tax liabilities the General Partner would have
Coo lidcanal & Trade Secret
VALAR 21
Private Placement Memorandum
incurred on such distributions if at all times the General Partner were
subject to the Applicable Tax Rate, all such allocation resulted from fully
taxable transactions (plus any tax benefit actually received by the General
Partner in the year in which the General Partner is required to make a
clawback payment as reasonably determined by the General Partner). Each
managing member of the General Partner will be severally liable for and
will personally guaranty his or her pro rata share of the General Partner's
remaining obligation.
In addition to the amount to be contributed by the General Partner pursuant
to the foregoing paragraph, if, upon liquidation of the Partnership, the
cumulative Fee Adjustments applied against Management Fees exceeds the
sum of (i) the cumulative profits of the Fund for all accounting periods less
(ii) the cumulative losses of the Fund for all accounting periods (such
amount the "Deemed Contribution Shortfall), then the General Partner or
its designated affiliate with a capital contribution obligation shall be
required to pay back to the Fund, the lesser of (x) the Deemed Contribution
Shortfall and (y) the distributions received by the General Partner or its
affiliate that are attributable to the cumulative amount of Profit allocated to
the General Partner with respect to such Fee Adjustments, in each case less
the gross tax liabilities that the General Partner would have incurred on all
allocations of taxable income (net of losses) made with respect to such Fee
Adjustments.
EXPENSES: From the management fee, the Management Company and the General
Partner will pay all normal operating expenses incurred in connection with
the management of the Fund, the General Partner and the Management
Company, including without limitation salaries, wages, rent, travel and
other expenses of employees, consultants and agents of the Fund, the
General Partner and the Management Company (other than consultants
retained in connection with investments or proposed investments). The
Fund will pay all expenses incurred in the investigation, holding, purchase.
sale or exchange of investments, and certain other related Fund expenses.
such as legal, audit and accounting expenses (including third party
bookkeeping services).
The Fund will bear the out•of-pocket expenses incident to the organization
of the Fund and the General Partner up to a maximum of $500,000.
FUND MANAGEMENT Each opportunity to invest at least $►50,000 into a company that is
& CERTAIN presented to the Managing Members and that otherwise meets the
CONFLICTS OF investment objectives of the Fund (i.e., the potential investment is within
INTEREST: the Fund's stated scope, the potential investment is sufficiently large, the
potential investment is not expected to require an inordinate portion of the
Fund's capital, the company is at an appropriate stage of development, the
Fund has sufficient capital available at the time the investment is to be
made, etc.), shall be offered to the Fund and each Parallel Fund in
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 22
Private Placement Memorandum
proportion to their relative available capital; provided, however, that the
preceding restriction shall only apply from the due date of the initial capital
contribution until the end of the "Time Standard Period" (as defined
below); provided, further, that any opportunities may be allocated in whole
or in part to the Partnership's prior funds or the Opportunity Fund (as
defined below) until the prior funds or the Opportunity Fund are fully
invested or reserved; and provided, further, that the foregoing shall not
apply to any investment opportunity with respect to which: (i) the
participation of an Affiliated Party (as defined below) in such company has
been approved by the Advisory Committee; (ii) an Affiliated Party (or an
affiliate thereof) has initially invested prior to the date of the Fund's initial
closing; (iii) the General Partner has determined, in good faith, does not
meet the investment objectives of the Fund; (iv) is to be held by a Special
Purpose Investment Fund (as defined below); (v) any investment
opportunity in a portfolio company of a Prior Fund, Successor Fund or
Opportunity Fund; or (vi) any investment opportunity offered to a Prior
Fund, Successor Fund or Opportunity Fund.
Peter Thiel and the Thiel Persons (as defined below) are not required to
present or offer to the Fund or any Parallel Fund any investment
opportunities.
The General Partner, the Management Company, the Managing Members
and their respective affiliates, members and employees may engage.
directly or indirectly, in other businesses or activities, including but not
limited to buying and selling securities for their own accounts, the accounts
of prior investment funds and other investment vehicles.
The Fund may invest in any portfolio company in which a Successor Fund.
Prior Fund or Opportunity Fund (or any other investment fund managed by
any of the General Partner, the Affiliated Parties or their affiliates) holds
an interest. In addition, without the consent of the Advisory Committee, the
Fund shall not invest in any company in which the Managing Members, the
General Partner, the Management Company or any of their Affiliates hold
a direct interest (Le., an interest not held through a Successor Fund, Prior
Fund or other investment fund managed by any of the General Partner, the
Affiliated Parties or their Affiliates).
The Fund may not purchase an interest in a portfolio company from, or sell
securities to, the General Partner, any Affiliated Party, any Thiel Person or
any of their respective affiliates, members and employees (or any
investment fund managed by any of the foregoing) without the consent of
the Advisory Committee.
The term "Affiliated Party" means any of the General Partner, the
Managing Members, the Management Company or any member or
employee or Affiliate thereof; provided, however, that Peter Thiel, Peter
Thiel's retirement accounts and Thiel Capital LLC and any wholly owned
subsidiary of the foregoing ("Thiel Persons") shall not be deemed as an
Affiliated Party or an affiliate of any Affiliated Party.
The Fund will not have any right of first refusal with respect to the
onlidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 23
Private Placement Memorandum
investment opportunities or existing portfolio companies of Peter Thiel, nor
any Thiel Persons, nor any other investment funds managed by Peter Thiel
or any Thiel Person.
Without prior approval of the Advisory Committee, (i) no more than 5% of
"Combined Capital Commitments" (i.e., aggregate capital commitments
made to the Fund and the Parallel Funds) may be invested in a "blind pool"
investment fund that is managed and controlled by an unaffiliated third
party and that pays its manager performance based compensation; (ii) no
more than 25% of Combined Capital Commitments may be invested in any
one portfolio company by the Fund and the Parallel Funds; (iii) no more
than 15% of Combined Capital Commitments may be invested in publicly
traded securities by the Fund and the Parallel Funds; and (iv) the Fund may
not incur indebtedness, or guaranty portfolio company indebtedness, in
excess of the lesser of (A) 10% of the Fund's Capital Commitments, and
(B) the amount of aggregate Capital Commitments of the Partners that have
not been contributed to the Fund as of the date of such debt or guaranty.
TIME COMMITMENT & During the Time Standard Period, and so long as they are managing
FORMATION OF A members of the General Partner, each Managing Member will devote
SUCCESSOR FUND: substantially all of his business time to the affairs of the Management
Company, the General Partner, the Parallel Funds, certain pre-existing
investment vehicles, and the Fund. Following the earlier of (i) such time as
at least 75% of the Capital Commitments of the Fund has been invested.
committed or reserved for investment in portfolio companies, or applied.
committed or reserved for working capital and expenses and (ii) the end of
the Commitment Period (the "Time Standard Period"), the Managing
Members will devote such time as they reasonably deem to be appropriate
to the Fund.
The General Partner and the Managing Members may form a "Successor
Fund" to the Fund following the end of the Time Standard Period.
In addition, during the Time Standard Period, the General Partner and the
Managing Members and their respective affiliates may form an
"Opportunity Funds" and/or "Special Purpose Investment Funds." An
Opportunity Fund is a fund created to invest in portfolio companies whose
"pre-money" valuation exceeds the valuation at which the Fund typically
would invest A Special Purpose Investment Fund is a fund created to
invest in a specified investment opportunity which meets the Fund's
investment objectives and the following criteria: (a) each Partner is
provided the first opportunity (on at least five (5) days advance notice) to
invest in such special purpose investment fund on a pro rata basis
determined by reference to the total of (x) the Partners' respective Capital
Commitments and (y) the respective capital commitments of the constituent
partners in any Parallel Funds, and (b) such special purpose investment
fund charges a carried interest and/or management fee that are no higher
than those charged to the Fund. A Special Purpose Investment Fund may
not have aggregate capital commitments that exceed 30% of the Combined
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 24
Private Placement Memorandum
Capital Commitments without the Advisory Committee's approval.
For the avoidance of doubt, neither Peter Thiel nor any Thiel Persons shall
be required to devote any time to the affairs of the Management Company.
the General Partner, the Fund, any Parallel Funds, any Special Purpose
Investment Fund or Opportunity Fund or any pre-existing investment
vehicles.
REMOVAL OF
GENERAL PARTNER
Within 180 days following the occurrence of certain events constituting
"trigger events" (as defined in the Partnership Agreement), a Two-Thirds-
in-Interest of the Limited Partners may elect to remove the General Partner.
If the Limited Partners vote to remove the General Partner, a replacement
general partner may be appointed on such economic terms and with such
subscription as the replacement general partner and a Two-Thirds-in-
Interest of the Limited Partners may agree. The replacement general partner
shall continue the business of the Partnership until dissolution in normal
course, pursuant to the terms of the Partnership Agreement.
Upon the removal of the General Partner, the former General Partner shall
not be obligated to make any additional capital contributions to the
Partnership and the former General Partner's entire interest in the
Partnership shall be converted to that of a Limited Partner with a capital
contribution and capital account balance equal to those of the former
General Partner. The former General Partner, as a Limited Partner (i) shall
be entitled to receive all allocations and distributions to which it would
otherwise be entitled to receive had it not been removed when, as and if
such allocations and distributions are made, in respect of all activities of
and investments by the Fund that occurred or were committed to by the
Fund prior to the effective date of removal; and (ii) the removed General
Partner shall be entitled to receive one hundred percent (100%) of all
allocations and distributions in respect of its capital contributions. The
removed General Partner shall not be entitled to receive any payments of
management fee with respect to any period of time after the date of its
removal.
UNRELATED BUSINESS
TAXABLE INCOME &
STATUS AS A
VENTURE CAPITAL
OPERATING
COMPANY:
The General Partner will use its reasonable best efforts to operate the Fund
to ensure that no tax-exempt Limited Partner (or any of its equity owners)
will be allocated unrelated business taxable income ("UBTI') within the
meaning of Section 512 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (the "Code").
as amended.
The General Partner will use its commercially reasonable efforts to (i)
avoid having the Fund treated as being engaged in a trade or business within
the United States under the Code; (ii) avoid the Fund realizing income that
is or is treated as "effectively connected" with the conduct of a trade or
business in the United States under the Code; or (iii) prevent the Fund from
acquiring any interest in real property located in the United States for
purposes of Section 897 of the Code or in any company that is a "United
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 25
Private Placement Memorandum
States real property holding corporation" within the meaning of the Code.
The General Partner will use its reasonable best efforts to operate the Fund
so that it will be treated as a "venture capital operating company" under
ERISA, if "equity participation" in the Fund held by "benefit plan
investors" is "significant" within the meaning of ERISA.
PARALLEL FUNDS: The General Partner may form (a) one or more investment partnerships or
similar entities that may waive (or charge a lower) management fees or
carried interest and will be comprised of the members of the General
Partner or consultants to, and other persons having strategic or other
important relationships with, the Fund and (b) one or more investment
partnerships or similar entities formed to accommodate the tax, regulatory
or legal needs of investors (including, without limitation, non•United States
investors) who would othenvise invest as Limited Partners of the Fund on
substantially similar terms, including economic terms, as the Fund
(collectively, the "Parallel Funds"). Each Parallel Fund will
simultaneously invest in the same securities on the same terms and at the
same price as the Fund, except in cases in which the portfolio company
gives written notice that a Parallel Fund will not be permitted to so invest.
or where such investment is not permitted by applicable law or by the terms
of the governing agreement of such Parallel Fund. The Fund and the
Parallel Funds shall make and dispose of an investment, or make a
distribution, on a pan passu basis. Investment by each Parallel Fund and
the Fund will be according to available capital.
INDEMNIFICATION: The Fund, out of its assets only, may indemnify the General Partner, the
Management Company, the members of the Advisory Committee, and each
officer, employee or member of the foregoing, against all liabilities
incurred in connection with any action, suit or proceeding arising out of or
in connection with such indemnitee's activities or involvement with the
Fund, or with any other enterprise that such indemnitee is or was serving.
as a director, officer, employee or othenvise, at the request of the Fund:
provided, that this indemnity may not extend to (I) any action, suit or
proceeding solely between or among the General Partner, the Management
Company, the Managing Members or their respective members.
employees, affiliates or agents, (2) conduct which constitutes bad faith on
the part of any Advisory Committee member or Thiel Person, or any
conduct which constitutes recklessness, bad faith, gross negligence or
intentionally wrongful conduct on the part of any other indemnified party.
or (3) any action, suit or proceeding that arises from any material breach by
the General Partner of the Partnership Agreement or of its fiduciary duties
to the Partnership that has a material adverse effect upon the economic
interests of the Limited Partners of the Fund. In addition, the Fund shall not
make any advancement of expenses for any claim, action or demand
brought by a Majority -in-Interest of the Limited Partners. In the event that
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 26
Private Placement Memorandum
an indemnitee is also entitled to indemnification from a portfolio company,
the portfolio company will be the primary source of indemnification, the
Fund will be the secondary source of indemnification, and the General
Partner or the Management Company will be the tertiary source of
indemnification. If the Fund's assets are insufficient, the General Partner
may (a) call for any unfunded Capital Commitments and (b) recall
distributions previously made to the Partners, solely for the purpose of
fulfilling an indemnity obligation of the Fund described in the preceding
paragraph. In no event will any Partner be required to return amounts
pursuant to the foregoing clause (b) in an amount in excess of the lesser of

(i) all distributions previously received by such Partner from the Fund and
(ii) 25% of such Partner's Capital Commitment. In no event will the
General Partner be permitted to call capital pursuant to the foregoing
clauses (a) and (b) more than two years after dissolution of the Fund, or in
connection with a recalled distribution, more than three years after the date
of such distribution.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 27
Private Placement Memorandum
IX. CERTAIN RISK FACTORS
Prospective investors should be aware that an investment in the Partnership involves a high degree of
risk and, therefore, should be undertaken only by investors capable of evaluating the risks of the
Partnership and bearing the risks it represents. There can be no assurance that the Partnership's
investment objectives will be achieved, or that an investor will receive a return of its capital, and
therefore, an investor should only invest in the Partnership if such investor is able to withstand a total
loss of its investment. In addition, there will be occasions when the General Partner, the Management
Company and their affiliates may encounter potential conflicts of interest in connection with the
Partnership. The following considerations, among others, should be carefully evaluated before making
an investment in the Partnership.
RISKS INHERENT IN VENTURE CAPITAL INVESTMENTS. The Partnership will invest substantially all of
its available capital (other than capital the General Partner determines to retain in cash or cash equivalents
or capital applied toward Partnership expenses and liabilities) in securities of portfolio companies. The
types of investments that the Partnership anticipates making involve a high degree of risk. In general,
financial and operating risks confronting portfolio companies can be significant. While targeted returns
should reflect the perceived level of risk in any investment situation, there can be no assurance that the
Partnership will be adequately compensated for risks taken. A loss of an investor's entire investment is
possible. The timing of profit realization is highly uncertain. Losses are likely to occur early in the
Partnership's term, while successes often require a long maturation.
Early-stage and development-stage companies often experience unexpected problems in the areas of
product development, manufacturing, marketing, financing and general management, which, in some
cases, cannot be adequately solved. in addition, such companies may require substantial amounts of
financing which may not be available through institutional private placements or the public markets. In
addition, the markets that such companies target are highly competitive and in many cases the competition
consists of larger companies with access to greater resources. The percentage of companies that survive
and prosper can be small.
Investments in more mature companies in the expansion or profitable stage involve substantial risks.
Such companies typically have obtained capital in the form of debt and/or equity to expand rapidly,
reorganize operations, acquire other businesses, or develop new products and markets. These activities
by definition involve a significant amount of change in a company and could give rise to significant
problems in sales, manufacturing, and general management of these activities.
The Partnership may invest a substantial portion of its assets in companies with modest capitalization.
While the General Partner believes that small and medium-sized companies can provide greater growth
potential than larger, more mature companies, investing in the securities of such companies also involves
greater risk, potential price volatility and cost. Investments in these companies often involve higher risks
because the companies lack the management experience, financial resources, product diversification,
markets, distribution channels and competitive strengths of larger companies. In addition, in many
instances, the frequency and volume of the trading activity in their stock is substantially less than what is
typical of larger companies. Therefore, the securities of smaller companies may be subject to wider price
fluctuations. The spreads between the bid and asked prices of the securities of these companies in the
over-the-counter markets typically are larger than the spreads for more actively traded securities. As a
result, the Partnership could incur a loss if it were to sell such a security a short time after its acquisition.
When making a large sale, the Partnership may have to sell a portfolio holding at a discount from quoted
Confidential & Tradc Secret
VALAR 28
Private Placement Memorandum
prices or may have to make a series of small sales over an extended period of time because of the limited
trading volume of smaller company securities.
INVESTMENT IN COMPANIES DEPENDENT UPON SCIENTIFIC DEVELOPMENTS AND TECHNOLOGIES.
The Partnership plans to focus its investing primarily on technology and technology-related companies.
The value of the Partnership's interests may be susceptible to factors affecting such companies and to a
greater risk and market fluctuation than an investment in a fund that invests in a broader range of
securities. The specific risks faced by such companies include:

• rapidly changing science and technologies;
• new competing products and improvements in existing products which may quickly render
existing products or technologies obsolete;

• exposure, in certain circumstances, to a high degree of government regulation, making these
companies susceptible to changes in government policy and failures to secure, or unanticipated
delays in securing, regulatory approvals;

• scarcity of management, technical, scientific, research and marketing personnel with appropriate
training;
the possibility of lawsuits related to intellectual property rights; and
• rapidly changing investor sentiments and preferences with regard to technology sector
investments (which are generally perceived as risky).
INVESTMENT IN PUBLICLY TRADED SECURITIES. The Partnership may invest in publicly traded
securities. Investments in public securities can entail certain risks. For example, the Partnership, the
General Partner and the Management Company may obtain less information and disclosure about a
company whose securities are publicly traded than from a privately held company. Further, the market
for publicly traded securities is extremely volatile due to economic conditions, political events, and for
many other reasons. Such volatility may adversely affect the ability of the Partnership to dispose of
investments or affect the value of investment securities on the date of sale by the Partnership.
Furthermore, notwithstanding the existence of a public market for the securities of a particular portfolio
company of the Partnership, publicly traded securities held by the Partnership may be thinly traded or
may cease to be traded after the Partnership invests in them. Any securities that the Partnership holds
that are thinly traded may be subject to wider price fluctuations than other companies whose securities
are more actively traded, and the spreads between the bid and ask prices of thinly traded securities of
these companies may be larger than the spreads for more actively traded securities. There can be no
assurance that the Partnership's investments in publicly traded securities will be profitable, and there is a
material risk that the Partnership could incur losses from its investments in publicly traded securities.
INVESTMENTS IN PIPES. The Partnership may be involved in private investments in public equities
("PIPEs") or private financing of public companies. PIPE transactions may involve the sale of equity-
like securities of an already public company. In a PIPE transaction, the Partnership may bear the price
risk from the time of pricing until the time of closing. In addition, the Partnership may have to commit
to purchase a specified number of shares at a fixed price, with the closing conditioned upon, among other
things, the Securities and Exchange Commission's preparedness to declare effective a resale registration
statement covering the resale, from time to time, of the shares sold in the private financing.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 29
Private Placement Memorandum
No ASSURANCE OF RETURNS. There can be no assurance that the Limited Partners will receive
distributions from the Partnership in an amount equal to their investment in the Partnership. The timing
of profit realization, if any, is highly uncertain.
LACK OF OPERATING HISTORY. The Partnership and the General Partner are newly formed entities,
and, accordingly have no operating history, historical results or investments upon which investors can
evaluate the potential performance of the Partnership. The prior performance of the Managing Members
or their investments as described in this Memorandum is not necessarily indicative of the Partnership's
future results. There can be no assurance that investments by the Partnership will achieve returns
comparable to the historical performance reflected in this Memorandum, and in any event, the returns
achieved by the Partnership will be subject to the Management Fee and the General Partner's carried
interest. Any given investment made by the Partnership may prove to be worthless, and there is a risk
that investors could lose money.
RELIANCE ON THE GENERAL PARTNER. The General Partner will have sole discretion over the
investment of the funds committed to the Partnership as well as the ultimate realization of any profits.
The Limited Partners will not receive the detailed financial information issued by portfolio companies
that will be available to the Partnership. Accordingly, the Limited Partners will not have the opportunity
to evaluate the relevant economic, financial and other information that will be utilized by the General
Partner in its selection of investments. As such, the pool of funds in the Partnership represents a blind
pool of funds. Investors in the Partnership will be relying on the General Partner to identify, structure,
and implement investments consistent with the Partnership's investment objectives and policies and to
conduct the business of the Partnership as contemplated by this Memorandum. The Limited Partners will
not make decisions with respect to the management, disposition or other realization of any investment
made by the Partnership, or other decisions regarding the Partnership's business and affairs.
RELIANCE ON THE PRINCIPALS. The loss of one or more of the principals of the General Partner could
have a significant adverse impact on the business of the Partnership. No assurances can be given that
each of the principals will continue to be affiliated with the Partnership throughout its term.
Notwithstanding any prior experience that such principals may have in making investments of the type
expected to be made by the Partnership, any such experience necessarily was obtained under different
market conditions and with different technologies at the forefront of development. There can be no
assurance that the principals of the General Partner will be able to duplicate prior levels of success.
LIMITED PORTFOLIO DIVERSIFICATION. As is typical of venture capital firms, the portfolio holdings of
the Partnership will not be broadly diversified. In addition, if the General Partner is unable to raise
sufficient capital commitments to the Partnership, the diversification of the portfolio holdings of the
Partnership will be further limited. A downturn of the economy or in the business of any one company
could impact the aggregate returns delivered to investors by the Partnership.
DIFFICULTY IN VALUING PORTFOLIO INVESTMENTS. Generally, there will be no readily available
market for a substantial number of the Partnership's investments and hence, most of the Partnership's
investments will be difficult to value. Despite the efforts of the General Partner and the Management
Company to acquire sufficient information to monitor certain of the Partnership's investments and make
well-informed valuation and pricing determinations, the General Partner and the Management Company
may only be able to obtain limited information at certain times. It is possible that the General Partner and
the Management Company may not be aware on a timely basis of material adverse changes that have
occurred with respect to certain of the Partnership's investments. The General Partner and the
Management Company may have to make valuation determinations without the benefit of an adequate
amount of relevant information. Prospective Limited Partners should be aware that as a result of these
difficulties, as well as other uncertainties, any valuation made by the General Partner and the Management
Company may not represent the fair market value of the securities acquired by the Partnership.
confidential & Tradc Sccrri
VALAR 30
Private Placement Memorandum
COMPETITIVE MARKETPLACE. The marketplace for venture capital investing has become increasingly
competitive. Participation by financial intermediaries has increased, substantial amounts of funds have
been dedicated to making investments in the private sector and the competition for investment
opportunities is at high levels. Some of the Partnership's potential competitors may have greater financial
and personnel resources than the General Partner and the Management Company. There can be no
assurances that the General Partner and the Management Company will locate an adequate number of
attractive investment opportunities and the General Partner and the Management Company may not be
able to identify and successfully close a sufficient number of high quality investments to utilize all of the
Partnership's capital. Such competition may adversely impact the length of time required to fully invest
the Partnership's capital and may adversely impact returns to Limited Partners in the Partnership.
CHANGING ECONOMIC CONDITIONS. The success of the investment strategy of the General Partner and
the Management Company could be significantly impacted by changing external economic conditions in
the United States and global economies. The stability and sustainability of growth in global economies
may be impacted by terrorism or acts of war. The availability, unavailability, or hindered operation of
external credit markets, equity markets and other economic systems which the Partnership may depend
upon to achieve its objectives may have a significant negative impact on the Partnership's operations and
profitability. There can be no assurance that such markets and economic systems will be available or will
be available as anticipated or needed for the Partnership to operate successfully. Changing economic
conditions could potentially adversely impact the valuation of portfolio holdings.
MINORITY INVESTMENTS. A significant portion of the Partnership's investments may represent minority
stakes in privately held companies. In addition, during the process of exiting investments, the Partnership
is likely to hold minority equity stakes if portfolio holdings are taken public. As is the case with minority
holdings in general, such minority stakes that the Partnership may hold will have neither the control
characteristics of majority stakes nor the valuation premiums accorded majority or controlling stakes.
The Partnership may also invest in companies for which the Partnership has no right to appoint a director
or otherwise exert significant influence. In such cases, the Partnership will be reliant on the existing
management and board of directors of such companies, which may include representatives of other
financial investors with whom the Partnership is not affiliated and whose interests may conflict with the
interests of the Partnership.
No ASSURANCE OF ADDITIONAL CAPITAL FOR INVESTMENTS. After the Partnership has financed a
company, continued development and marketing of products may require that additional financing be
provided. The Partnership expects to invest in companies that have substantial capital needs that are
typically funded over several stages of investment. No assurance can be given that such additional
financing will be available and no assurance can be made as to the terms upon which such financing may
be obtained. Alternatively, the Partnership, either directly or through one of its portfolio companies, may
elect to sell developed or undeveloped technologies to existing companies. No assurance can be made
that buyers for such technologies can be located or that the terms of any such sales will be advantageous.
No ASSURANCE OF INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES. Although the Partnership expects to have significant
access to private investment opportunities through the network of relationships of the Managing
Members, there can be no assurance that investment opportunities for the Partnership will materialize and
that companies select the Partnership as an investor. Similarly, the Partnership may be unable to identify
or consummate investments in public companies that meet its criteria. There can be no assurances that
the General Partner and the Management Company will locate an adequate number of attractive
investment opportunities that meet the Partnership's investment objectives.
NATURE OF DIRECT INVESTMENTS. Many of the Partnership's investments will be highly illiquid. As
such, there will be no public markets for the securities held by the Partnership and there can be no
assurance that the Partnership will be able to realize such investments in a timely manner. In addition.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 3I
Private Placement Memorandum
the realization of value for any investments will not be possible or known with any certainty until the
General Partner and the Management Company elect, in their sole discretion, to sell the Partnership's
investments and subsequently distribute the proceeds to its Limited Partners or to distribute securities to
Limited Partners in lieu of cash. Also, since the Partnership may only make a limited number of
investments and since many of the Partnership's investments may involve a high degree of risk, poor
performance by a few of the investments could severely affect the total returns to the Limited Partners.
Additionally, it should be noted that past performance of the Managing Members and their affiliates is
not a guarantee of future results.
FUTURE AND PAST PERFORMANCE. The performance of the prior funds is not necessarily indicative of
the Partnership's future results. While the General Partner intends for the Partnership to make
investments that have estimated returns commensurate with the risks undertaken, there can be no
assurance that targeted results will be achieved. Loss of principal is possible on any given investment.
BRIDGE FINANCING. The Partnership may lend to portfolio companies on a short-term, unsecured basis
in anticipation of a future issuance of equity or long-term debt. Such bridge loans would typically be
convertible into a more permanent, long-term security; however, for reasons not always in the
Partnership's control, such long-term securities may not issue and such bridge loans may remain
outstanding. In such event, the interest rate on such loans may not adequately reflect the risk associated
with the unsecured position taken by the Partnership.
LEVERAGE. To the extent that any investment is made in a portfolio company with a leveraged capital
structure or any portfolio company borrows or enters into other financing transactions requiring periodic
payments, such investment will be subject to increased exposure to adverse economic factors such as a
significant rise in interest rates, a severe downturn in the economy or deterioration in the condition of
such company or its industry. If such a company is unable to generate sufficient cash flow to meet
principal and interest payments on its indebtedness, the value of any equity investment by the Partnership
in such company could be significantly reduced or even eliminated.
LIMITATIONS ON ABILITY TO EXIT INVESTMENTS. The General Partner expects to exit from its
investments in two principal ways: (i) private sales (including acquisitions of its portfolio companies) and
(ii) initial and secondary public offerings. At any particular time, one or both of these avenues may not
be open to the Partnership, or timing with respect to these exit mechanisms may be inopportune. As such,
the ability to exit from and liquidate portfolio holdings may be constrained at any particular time.
CERTAIN LITIGATION RISKS. The Partnership will be subject to a variety of litigation risks, particularly
if one or more of its portfolio companies face financial or other difficulties during the life of the
Partnership. Legal disputes, involving any or all of the Partnership, the General Partner, the Management
Company, their members or their affiliates, may arise from the Partnership's activities and investments
and could have a significant adverse effect on the Partnership.
POTENTIAL LIABILITIES. In connection with its investments, the Partnership may negotiate the right to
appoint one or more of the Managing Members or other employees or representatives of the Management
Company as a member of the portfolio company's board of directors. Such membership on the board of
directors of a company can result in the Partnership or the individual director being named as a defendant
in litigation or other disputes or investigations. The Partnership may also participate in portfolio company
financings at valuations lower than the valuations in preceding rounds of financing. Disputes arising out
of such down-round financings may result in the Partnership, the General Partner, the Management
Company, or their members being named as defendants. Typically, portfolio companies will have
insurance to protect directors and officers, but this insurance may be inadequate. The Partnership will
also indemnify the General Partner, the Managing Members, the Management Company and their
respective affiliates, among others, for liabilities incurred in connection with operations of the
Con ltd.:float & Trade Secret
VALAR 32
Private Placement Memorandum
Partnership, including liabilities arising from such disputes. Such indemnification obligations and other
liabilities could be substantial. The Partners may also be required to return distributions previously made
to them to satisfy the Partnership's indemnification obligations. While the General Partner and the
Management Company intend to manage the Partnership in a way that will minimize exposure to these
risks, the possibility of successful claims or lawsuits or adverse regulatory action cannot be eliminated,
and such events could have significant adverse effects on the Partnership.
CONTINGENT LIABILITIES ON DISPOSITION OF INVESTMENTS. In connection with the disposition of an
investment in a portfolio company, the Partnership may be required to make representations about the
business and financial affairs of such company typical of those made in connection with the sale of a
business. To the extent that any such representations are inaccurate, the Partnership may be required to
indemnify the purchasers of such investment and may be liable to the purchasers for breach of contract.
These arrangements may result in the incurrence of contingent liabilities for which the General Partner
may establish reserves and escrows. In that regard, distributions may be delayed or withheld until such
reserve is no longer needed or the escrow period expires.
RESERVES. As is customary in the industry, the General Partner and the Management Company may
establish reserves for follow-on investments by the Partnership in portfolio companies, operating
expenses (including the Management Fee), Partnership liabilities, and other matters. Estimating the
appropriate amount of such reserves is difficult, especially for follow-on investment opportunities, which
are directly tied to the success and capital needs of portfolio companies. Inadequate or excessive reserves
could impair the investment returns to the Limited Partners. If reserves are inadequate, the Partnership
may be unable to take advantage of attractive follow-on or other investment opportunities or to protect
its existing investments from dilutive or other punitive terms associated with "pay -to-play" or similar
provisions. If reserves are excessive, the Partnership may decline attractive investment opportunities or
hold unnecessary amounts of capital in money market or similar low-yield accounts.
ABSENCE OF LIQUIDITY AND PUBLIC MARKETS. The Partnerships investments will generally be
private, illiquid holdings. As such, there will be no public markets for the securities held by the
Partnership and no readily available liquidity mechanism at any particular time for any of the investments
held by the Partnership. In addition, the realization of value from any investments will not be possible or
known with any certainty until the General Partner and the Management Company elect, in their sole
discretion, to sell the Partnership's investments and subsequently distribute the proceeds to its investors
or to distribute securities to investors in lieu of cash.
No MARKET; ILLIQUIDITY OF LIMITED PARTNER INTERESTS. An investment in the Partnership will
be illiquid and involves a high degree of risk. There is no public market for the limited partner interests
in the Partnership, and it is not expected that a public market will develop. Consequently, Limited
Partners will bear the economic risks of their investment for the term of the Partnership. Prospective
investors will be required to represent and agree that they are purchasing the limited partner interests for
their own account for investment only and not with a view to the resale or distribution thereof.
CERTAIN LIMITATIONS ON ABILITY OF LIMITED PARTNERS TO TRANSFER THEIR INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIP. The transferability of interests in the Partnership will be restricted by the Partnership
Agreement and by United States federal and state securities laws. In general, Limited Partners will not
be able to sell or transfer their interests in the Partnership to third parties without the consent of the
General Partner.
LEGAL AND REGULATORY RISKS. The Partnership is not and does not expect to be registered as an
"investment company" under the United States Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the
"investment Company Act'), pursuant to an exemption set forth in Sections 3(c)(I) and/or 3(cX7) of the
Investment Company Act. There is no assurance that such exemptions will continue to be available to
C4)11110:float & Trade Scott
VALAR 33
Private Placement Memorandum
the Partnership. Due to the burdens of compliance with the Investment Company Act, the performance
of the Partnership's investment portfolio could be materially adversely affected, and risks involved in
financing portfolio companies could substantially increase, if the Partnership becomes subject to
registration under the Investment Company Act. Neither the Partnership nor its counsel can assure
investors that, under certain conditions, changed circumstances, or changes in the law, the Partnership
may not become subject to the Investment Company Act or other burdensome regulation.
TAX RISKS. Certain tax risks relating to an investment in the Partnership are discussed in the section
titled "Certain Tax and Regulatory Matters," which prospective investors should read carefully. No
assurances can be given that current tax laws, rulings and regulations will not be changed during the life
of the Partnership. In determining whether or not to make an investment in the Partnership, each
prospective Limited Partner should consider the tax consequences of such an investment. In addition,
each prospective Limited Partner is advised to consult its own tax counsel as to the U.S. federal income
tax consequences of an investment in the Partnership and as to applicable foreign, state and local taxes.
WITHHOLDING AND OTHER TAXES. The General Partner intends to structure the Partnership's
investments in a manner that is intended to achieve the Partnership's investment objectives and,
notwithstanding anything contained herein to the contrary, there can be no assurance that the structure of
any investment will be tax efficient for any particular investor or that any particular tax result will be
achieved. In addition, tax reporting requirements may be imposed on investors under the laws of the
jurisdictions in which investors are liable for taxation or in which the Partnership makes portfolio
investments. Prospective investors should consult their own professional advisors with respect to the tax
consequences to them of an investment in the Partnership under the laws of the jurisdiction in which they
are liable for taxation. Furthermore, the Partnership's returns in respect of its investments may be reduced
by withholding or other taxes imposed by jurisdictions in which the Partnership's portfolio companies
are organized.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST. The following discussion enumerates certain potential conflicts of interest
that should be carefully evaluated before making an investment in the Partnership. The following is not
intended as an exhaustive list of the potential conflicts. Instances may arise where the interest of the
General Partner (or its members), the Management Company and/or their affiliates may potentially or
actually conflict with the interests of the Partnership and the Limited Partners. Among others, investors
should consider the following conflicts of interest:

• The existence of the General Partner's carried interest may create an incentive for the General
Partner to make riskier or more speculative investments on behalf of the Partnership than it
would otherwise make in the absence of such performance•based arrangements.

• Conflicts may arise in the allocation of investment opportunities and the Managing Members'
time among the Partnership and parallel or co•investment entities, on the one hand, and any prior
or future investment funds or vehicles or other entities organized in accordance with the
Partnership Agreement or other fund(s) advised by the Management Company, on the other
hand.
• Conflicts may arise where the Partnership and parallel or co•investment entities invest in an
earlier or future round of financing of a portfolio company owned by a prior or future investment
funds or vehicles or other entities organized in accordance with the Partnership Agreement or
other fund(s) advised by the Management Company, or its affiliates. In such a circumstance,
the General Partner may cause the Partnership to invest in such portfolio company at a higher
valuation or lower valuation than such other investment funds, and may earn lower profit, or
realize higher loss, as a result.
Conlidenital & Trade Scat'
VALAR 34
Private Placement Memorandum
The Management Company (and its principals or affiliates) or the General Partner may serve as
investment adviser or investment manager to other client accounts (including separately
managed accounts) and conduct investment activities for its own accounts. Such other entities
or accounts (the "Other Clients") may have investment objectives or may implement investment
strategies similar to those of the Partnership.
While certain assurances are provided in the Partnership Agreement to address these potential conflicts,
certain risks may remain. By acquiring an Interest in the Partnership, each Limited Partner will be deemed
to have acknowledged the existence of any such actual or potential conflicts of interest and to have waived
any claim with respect to any liability arising from the existence of any such conflicts of interest.
DIVERSE INVESTORS. The Limited Partners may have conflicting investment, tax, and other interests
with respect to their investments in the Partnership. The conflicting interests of individual Limited
Partners may relate to or arise from, among other things, the nature of investments made by the
Partnership, the structuring or the acquisition of investments and the timing of disposition of investments.
As a consequence, conflicts of interest may arise in connection with decisions made by the General
Partner and the Management Company with respect to the nature or structuring of investments that may
be more beneficial for some Limited Partners than for others, particularly with respect to investors'
individual tax situations. In selecting and structuring investments appropriate for the Partnership, the
General Partner and the Management Company will consider the investment and tax objective of the
Partnership and the Partners as a whole, not the investment, tax or other objective of any Limited Partner
individually.
RISK OF DILUTION. Limited Partners subscribing for interests at subsequent closings will participate in
existing investments of the Partnership, diluting the interest of existing Limited Partners therein.
Although such Limited Partners will contribute their pro rata share of prior capital contributions
previously drawn down by the Partnership (plus an additional amount thereon), there can be no assurance
that such payment will reflect the fair value of the Partnership's existing investments at the time such
additional Limited Partners subscribe for such interests.
FAILURE TO MAKE CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS. If a Limited Partner fails to pay when due installments
of its capital commitment to the Partnership, and the contributions made by non-defaulting Limited
Partners and borrowings by the Partnership are inadequate to cover the defaulted capital contribution, the
Partnership may be unable to pay its obligations when due. As a result, the Partnership may be subjected
to significant penalties that could materially and adversely affect the returns to the Limited Partners
(including non-defaulting Limited Partners). If a Limited Partner defaults, it may be subject to various
remedies as provided in the Partnership Agreement.
FOREIGN INVESTMENTS. The Partnership expects to make a number of investments in companies that
are based outside of the United States or the operations of which are primarily outside of the United
States. Any investment in a foreign country involves risks not found in the domestic securities market,
including the following: the risk of economic and financial instability in the foreign country, which in
some cases may include a collapse in credit markets, stock prices, currencies and/or consumer spending;
the risk of adverse social and political developments, including nationalization, confiscation without fair
compensation, political and social instability and war; the risk that the foreign country may impose
restrictions on the repatriation of investment income or capital or on the ability of foreign persons to
invest in certain types of companies, assets or securities; risks related to the possible lack of availability
of sufficient financial information as a result of accounting, auditing, and financial disclosure standards
that differ, in some cases significantly, from those in the United States; risks related to foreign laws and
legal systems, which are likely to differ from those of the United States, including in particular the laws
with respect to the rights of investors which may not be as comprehensive or well developed as those in
Conlidanlal & Trade Secret
VALAR 35
Private Placement Memorandum
the United States and the procedures for the judicial or other enforcement of such rights which may not
be as effective as in the United States; risks related to the fact that some investments or portfolio company
operations may be denominated in foreign currencies and, therefore, will be subject to fluctuations in
exchange rates; and risks related to applicable tax laws and regulations and tax treaties, which are likely
to vary from country to country and may be less well developed than those in the United States, possibly
resulting in retroactive taxation so that the Partnership could become subject to an unanticipated local tax
liability. The profits or losses of the Partnership on any investment, as measured in United States dollars,
will be affected by fluctuations in currency exchange rates and exchange control regulations as well as
by the success of the investment itself. In addition, the Partnership may incur costs in connection with
conversions between various currencies. The Partnership does not presently intend to seek to reduce
currency risks through "hedging" or other methods.
AIFMD. The Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive ("AIFMD") came into force on 21 July
2011, and certain fund managers have been obliged to comply with the European Economic Area
("EEA") Member States' respective AIFMD implementing laws since July 22, 2013. AIFMD regulates
the activities of private fund managers undertaking fund management activities or marketing fund
interests to investors domiciled or with a registered office in the EEA. If the Partnership is marketed to
these investors: (i) the Partnership may be subject to certain reporting, disclosure and other compliance
obligations under AIFMD, which may result in the Partnership incurring additional costs and expenses;
and (ii) AIFMD will also restrict certain activities of the Partnership in relation to EEA portfolio
companies including, in some circumstances, the Partnership's ability to recapitalize, refinance or
potentially restructure an EEA portfolio company within the first two years of ownership.
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION. The Partnership Agreement will contain confidentiality provisions
intended to protect proprietary and other information relating to the Partnership and the Partnership's
portfolio companies. To the extent that such information is publicly disclosed, competitors of the
Partnership and/or competitors of its portfolio companies, and others, may benefit from such information,
thereby adversely affecting the Partnership, its portfolio companies, the General Partner and the economic
interests of Limited Partners.
COUNSEL TO THE PARTNERSHIP DOES NOT REPRESENT THE LIMITED PARTNERS. The General Partner
has retained Cooley LLP in connection with the formation of the Partnership and may retain Cooley LLP
as legal counsel in connection with the management and operation of the Partnership, including, without
limitation, the making and holding of investments. Cooley LLP will not represent any Limited Partner
or prospective limited partner of the Partnership, unless the General Partner and such Limited Partner or
prospective limited partner otherwise agree and such Limited Partner or prospective limited partner
separately engages Cooley LLP, in connection with the formation of the Partnership, the offering of the
Interests, the management and operation of the Partnership or any dispute that may arise between any
Limited Partner, on the one hand, and the General Partner, the Partnership, the Management Company
and/or their affiliates on the other hand (the "Partnership Legal Matters"). Any Limited Partner or
prospective limited partner will, if it wishes counsel on any Partnership Legal Matter, retain its own
independent counsel with respect thereto and will pay all fees and expenses of such independent counsel.
Each Limited Partner and prospective limited partner acknowledges that Cooley LLP may represent the
General Partner and/or the Partnership in connection with any and all Partnership Legal Matters.
WRITTEN AGREEMENTS. The Partnership, the General Partner and the Management Company will be
authorized, without the approval of any Limited Partner, to enter into side letters or similar written
agreements with Limited Partners that have the effect of establishing rights under, or altering or
supplementing the terms of this Memorandum, the Partnership Agreement, such Limited Partner's
Subscription Agreement or other related agreements. The ability of other Limited Partners to elect to
receive the benefit of such side agreements will be limited.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR 36
Private Placement Memorandum
The foregoing risks do not purport to be a complete enumeration or explanation of all the risks
involved in acquiring an interest in the Partnership. Potential investors are urged to read this
entire Memorandum, the Subscription Agreement and the Partnership Agreement and consult
their own advisers before making a determination whether to invest in the Partnership.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 37
X. CERTAIN TAX AND REGULATORY MATTERS
Certain United States Federal Income Tax Considerations
Set forth below is a discussion, in summary form, of certain United States federal income tax
consequences relating to an investment in the Partnership. This summary does not attempt to present all
aspects of the United States federal income tax laws or any state, local or foreign laws that may affect an
investment in the Partnership. In particular, foreign investors, financial institutions, insurance
companies, tax-exempt entities and other investors of special status must consult with their own
professional tax advisors. No ruling has been or will be requested from the United States Internal
Revenue Service (the "IRS") and no assurance can be given that the IRS will agree with the tax
consequences described in this summary. Each prospective Limited Partner should consult with its own
tax adviser in order to fi lly understand the United States federal, state, local and foreign income tax
consequences of an investment in the Partnership.
PARTNERSHIP STATUS. The Partnership will be classified and reported as a partnership for U.S. federal
income tax purposes.
TAnTION OF PARTNERS. Each partner (a "Partner") will report on its federal income tax return its
distributive share of the Partnership's items of income, gain, loss, deduction and credit for the taxable
year. The character of such items, determined at the Partnership level, will pass through to the Partners
(for example, Partners will treat as interest, dividends or capital gain, their distributive shares of such
items recognized by the Partnership).
Each Partner will be required to report on its federal income tax return its distributive share of any income
or gain recognized by the Partnership, whether or not amounts representing such distributive share have
been distributed to it.
Distributions from the Partnership, whether made currently or upon liquidation of the Partnership,
generally may be received by a Partner without further tax. The general rules relating to the tax treatment
of distributions to the Partners may be summarized as follows:
Cash distributions will not be taxable to a Partner except to the extent they exceed the Partner's tax basis
for its interest in the Partnership. The excess generally would be taxable as long-term or short-term capital
gain, depending on the Partner's holding period for its Partnership interest;
In-kind distributions of portfolio securities or other assets of the Partnership generally will not be taxable
to the recipient Partner or the Partnership. A partner that receives a distribution of marketable securities
from a partnership generally is required to recognize taxable gain to the extent that the fair market value
of the distributed securities exceeds the partner's tax basis in its partnership interest. There are a number
of exceptions to this rule, including an exception for distributions by qualified "investment partnerships."
It is expected that the Partnership will qualify as an "investment partnership" and that, accordingly,
distributions of marketable securities by the Partnership generally will not give rise to the current
recognition of taxable gain;
For purposes of determining a Partner's gain or loss on a subsequent sale of the Partnership's assets
distributed in-kind (other than in liquidation of the Partner's interest in the Partnership), the Partner's tax
basis for such assets will be equal to the Partnership's adjusted basis for the assets or, if less, the Partner's
tax basis for its Partnership interest immediately before the distribution. A Partner's tax basis for assets
distributed in liquidation of its Partnership interest will be equal to its tax basis in its Partnership interest.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 38
A Partner's capital gain holding period for assets distributed without the recognition of gain will include
the period during which the assets were held by the Partnership; and
No loss will be recognized by a Partner upon the receipt of a distribution from the Partnership except where
the distribution is a liquidating distribution consisting solely of cash, and the amount of cash is less than the
Partner's tax basis in its Partnership interest immediately before the distribution.
DEDUCTIONS. Subject to certain limitations described below, a Partner will be entitled to deduct on its
federal income tax return its distributive share of Partnership loss, but not in excess of its tax basis in its
Partnership interest. If a Partner's distributive share of Partnership loss exceeds the Partner's tax basis in
its Partnership interest, such excess may not be deducted but will be carried over and become deductible
in any later year if and to the extent the Partner's tax basis exceeds zero and such loss carryover is
otherwise deductible. Each Limited Partner should have a sufficient tax basis in its Partnership interest
to deduct losses up to an amount equal to its cash investment in the Partnership.
The "at risk" provisions of Section 465 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the "Code"),
impose additional limitations on the deductibility of partnership losses, but the at risk provisions are not
expected to limit the Partners' ability to deduct Partnership losses.
In the case of a Partner who is an individual, expenses of producing income, including management fees,
are to be aggregated with unreimbursed employee business expenses and other expenses of producing
income and the aggregate amount of such expenses will be deductible only to the extent such amount
exceeds 2% of a taxpayer's adjusted gross income. In addition, total allowable itemized deductions, other
than medical costs, casualty and theft losses, and investment interest expense, are generally reduced by a
percentage of the amount of the taxpayer's adjusted gross income in excess of a threshold amount, which
is adjusted for inflation each year. Thus, there is the possibility that certain taxpayers may not be able to
enjoy the full tax benefit of their expenses of producing income.
Expenses subject to the limitations above do not include expenses incurred in connection with a trade or
business. The issue of whether the Partnership will be engaged in a trade or business for federal income
tax purposes is unclear and will depend in part on the form or organization of the companies in which the
Partnership invests. The Partnership may be treated as engaged in a trade or business for federal income
tax purposes if a company in which the fund invests is classified as a partnership for federal income tax
purposes, and that company operates a trade or business. Assuming the Partnership is not engaged in a
trade or business, an individual Partner's share of certain expenses of the Partnership will be subject to
the two limitations described in the preceding paragraph.

Section 469 of the Code limits the deductibility of losses from passive activities. These provisions apply
to individuals, estates, trusts, personal service corporations and closely held corporations. In general, a
taxpayer's losses from passive activities may only be offset against income from passive activities and
not against income such as salary or investment income. Any amount of passive activity loss that is
disallowed will be carried over to the following years to offset passive activity gains in such subsequent
years. A passive activity is any activity that involves the conduct of a trade or business and in which the
taxpayer does not materially participate. Although, as noted above, there is uncertainty whether the
activities of the Partnership will constitute a trade or business as that concept has been interpreted by the
IRS and the courts, the General Partner believes that the Partnership's activities will not be considered a
trade or business activity to which the passive activity loss provisions of the Code would apply.
CAPITAL GAIN, DIVIDEND AND QUALIFIED SMALL BUSINESS STOCK TAX RATES. The Partnership
expects that its gains and losses from its securities transactions typically will be capital gains and capital
losses. Property held for more than one year generally will be eligible for long-term capital gain or loss
treatment.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 39
Under current federal income tax law, the maximum federal ordinary income tax rate for individuals is
39.6% and, in general, the maximum individual income tax rate for long-term capital gains and certain
dividend income is 20%. The excess of capital losses over capital gains may be offset against the ordinary
income of an individual taxpayer, subject to an annual deduction limitation of $3,000; unused capital
losses may be carried forward indefinitely but may not be carried back. For corporate taxpayers, the
maximum federal income tax rate is 35%. Capital losses of a corporate taxpayer may be offset only
against capital gains, but unused capital losses may be carried back three years (subject to certain
limitations) and carried fonvard five years.
A 3.8% Medicare tax is generally imposed on the net investment income of high-income individuals,
estates and trusts. Net investment income generally includes interest, dividends and capital gain income.
Partnership capital gain and other income will generally be subject to the 3.8% Medicare tax.
In general, non-corporate investors that, directly or via a pass-through entity such as the Partnership, hold
"qualified small business stock" ("QSBS") for more than 5 years are permitted to exclude from taxable
income all or a portion of any gain subsequently recognized upon a sale or exchange of such stock. Under
current U.S. federal income tax law, the QSBS exclusion percentage is generally 100% of QSBS
purchased on or after September 28, 2010. For each non-corporate investor, the amount of gain eligible
for the QSBS exclusion generally is limited to the greater of: (i) 10 times the investor's basis in the stock
or (ii) a total of $10 million with regard to stock in the issuing corporation. The remaining portion of the
gain on such stock, if any, is subject to tax at long term capital gains rates.
To be treated as small business stock eligible for the QSBS exclusion, stock must have been acquired at
original issue from a qualified small business corporation after August 10, 1993. In general, a qualified
small business corporation is a domestic "C" corporation that, immediately after issuing the stock in
question, has $50 million or less in gross assets and satisfies certain other requirements. Because several
of these requirements must continue to be satisfied after the issuance of qualified stock, it is possible that
the stock may cease to qualify as small business stock due to events occurring after the issue date.
Accordingly, there can be no assurance that any stock acquired directly or indirectly by the Partnership
would qualify for the QSBS exclusion, even if such stock qualifies as small business stock at the time of
acquisition. In addition, no assurances can be given that the General Partner will have or provide to
Partners information about any particular stock investment necessary to determine its status as QSBS, or
to satisfy applicable tax reporting requirements related to QSBS treatment.
ROLLOVER FOR QUALIFIED SMALL BUSINESS STOCK. Under Section 1045 of the Code, if an individual
(i) realizes gain on a sale of QSBS that has been held by the individual for more than six months, and (ii)
within 60 days after such sale, purchases new QSBS, the individual generally is required to recognize
(and pay tax on) such gain only to the extent that the net proceeds from the original stock exceed the cost
of the newly purchased stock. Any remaining gain is carried over to the newly purchased stock and may
be recognized (and be taxable) upon a subsequent disposition of such stock. The benefits of Section 1045
are generally available to individuals who purchase, hold and sell qualified small business stock indirectly
through a pass-through entity such as the Partnership, although the extent to which a qualifying rollover
may be made through a pass-through entity is limited. No assurances can be given that the General
Partner will have or provide to Partners information about any particular stock investment necessary to
determine its eligibility for a Section 1045 rollover, or to satisfy applicable tax reporting requirements
related to a rollover.
TAX-EXEMPT LIMITED PARTNERS. Income recognized by tax-exempt entities, including qualified
retirement plans (stock, bonus, pension or profit-sharing plans described in Section 401(a) of the Code)
and individual retirement accounts, is generally exempt from federal income tax. Section 511 of the
Code, however, imposes a tax on such an entity's Unrelated Business Taxable Income ("UBTF). UBTI
Conlidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 40
is income from a trade or business regularly carried on unrelated to the entity's exempt purpose. Most
types of passive investment income, including dividends, interest, royalties and gains from the sale of
securities are excluded from UBTI. UBTI could also be generated to the extent of the Partnership's
"unrelated debt financed income", if any. Unrelated debt financed income is income derived from
property with respect to which there is outstanding acquisition indebtedness and the use of such property
is unrelated to its exempt purpose. Dividends, interest, annuities, royalties, gains from the sale of
securities and other receipts otherwise excluded in computing unrelated business taxable income
nevertheless may be included to the extent property generating those receipts is debt financed. In
addition, UBTI could be generated by the Partnership if it invests in businesses operated as pass-through
entities such as partnerships and limited liability companies.
FOREIGN PARTNERS. The federal income tax treatment of Partners who are non-resident aliens of the
United States will vary depending on whether the Partnership is treated as being engaged in a trade or
business in the United States. If the Partnership is treated as not engaged in a United States trade or
business, Partners who are non-resident aliens and foreign corporations will be subject to United States
taxation only in limited instances. If a foreign person is not engaged in a United States trade or business,
it is generally subject to a flat tax of 30% of the gross amount received in the form of United States source
investment income. This would include dividends, royalties, certain interest and other similar income
(but not capital gains, except as noted below) that is not related to the active conduct of a trade or business.
The 30% tax is collected by imposing a withholding obligation on the Partnership. The withholding tax
is reduced or eliminated in some circumstances for residents of countries with which the United States
has income tax treaties. A nonresident alien, but not a foreign corporation, is generally subject to a 30%
tax on his United States source capital gains where such person is physically present in the United States
for 183 days or more during the taxable year, although an alien who is present for such a period will
generally be a United States tax resident and therefore subject to United States taxation on his worldwide
income. A nonresident alien who is present in the United States for 183 days or more is required to file
a United States tax return and pay a tax of 30% on his net capital gains. Dispositions of United States
real property interests are generally subject to U.S. tax under a special provision and do not fall within
the general capital gains rule.
Interest from certain investments is exempt from the 30% withholding tax. For example, the portfolio
interest exception covers a broad class of interest income, which is exempt from withholding tax. In order
to constitute portfolio interest, the underlying debt obligation on which the interest is paid must generally
be issued in registered form and the foreign partner must have provided the withholding agent with a
properly completed IRS Form W-8 BEN or W-8BEN-E or the obligation must be issued in bearer form
and sold only overseas to foreign buyers (in which case a domestic partnership would generally not be an
eligible holder). In order to constitute a registered obligation, the debt must be payable only to the named
owner and any transfer of the obligation must be registered on the books of the issuer or the old note must
be surrendered for cancellation and a new note issued in the name of the transferee.
The portfolio interest exemption does not apply to interest received by a person who owns 10% or more
of the total combined voting power of the payor. In the case of a partnership lender (such as the
Partnership), this I 0% ownership test is applied at the partner level and so is not likely to prevent portfolio
interest earned by the Partnership from qualifying for the portfolio interest exemption.
On the other hand, if the Partnership were engaged in a trade or business (either directly or indirectly
through an investment in a flow-through entity such as a partnership or limited liability company) at any
time during the taxable year, each foreign Partner of the Partnership would be treated as being engaged
in a United States trade or business and would be subject to United States income taxation (at the same
net progressive rates applicable to United States citizens, residents and domestic corporations) on income
that is effectively connected with the conduct of that trade or business. For corporate Partners an
Coo lidcatial & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 41
additional branch profits tax will generally be imposed on such effectively connected income. If the
Partnership were engaged in a United States trade or business, a withholding tax would be imposed on its
effectively connected income allocable to foreign Partners.
The foregoing discussion relates only to recognized income. The unrealized appreciation in stock or other
securities distributed in-kind by the Partnership is generally not taxable until such stocks or securities are
ultimately sold. The sale of stock by a nonresident alien will generally not be taxed by the United States
so long as the sale is not made through an office or fi xed place of business maintained by the alien in the
United States.
Each potential investor that is a non-resident alien of the United States is urged to consult with and
must rely upon the advice of its own professional tax advisors with respect to the United States and
foreign tar treatment of an investment in the Partnership.
REPORTING. The General Partner will furnish each Partner with an annual statement setting forth
information relating to the operations of the Partnership (including information regarding such Partner's
distributive share of Partnership income and gains, losses, deductions and credits for the taxable year) as
is reasonably required to enable the Partner to properly report to the IRS with respect to such Partner's
participation in the Partnership.
The federal information tax returns filed by the Partnership will be subject to audit by the IRS and the
audit of the Partnership's returns could result in an audit of the Partners' own federal income tax returns.
In connection with such audits, adjustments to Partnership items could result in the assertion of tax
deficiencies (as well as interest and penalties thereon) against the Partners. Any administrative or judicial
proceedings involving the federal income tax treatment of Partnership items will generally be conducted
on a unified basis, with binding effect on all Partners. The General Partner will serve as the Partnership's
"Tax Matters Partner" for purposes of coordinating any such proceedings and providing any required
notices about such proceedings to the Partners.
Treasury regulations impose special reporting rules for "reportable transactions." A reportable transaction
includes, among other things, a transaction in which an advisor limits the disclosure of the tax treatment
or tax structure of the transaction and receives a fee in excess of certain thresholds. The General Partner
intends to take the position that an investment in the Partnership does not constitute a reportable
transaction. If it were determined that an investment in the Partnership does constitute a reportable
transaction, each Partner would be required to complete and file IRS Form 8886 with such Partner's tax
return for the tax year that includes the date that such Partner acquired an interest in the Partnership. The
General Partner reserves the right to disclose certain information about the Partners and the Partnership
to the IRS on Form 8886, including the Partners' capital commitments, tax identification numbers (if
any), and dates of admission to the Partnership, to facilitate compliance with the reportable transaction
rules if necessary. In addition, the Partnership may engage in certain transactions which themselves
constitute reportable transactions and with respect to which both the Partnership and certain Partners may
be required to file Form 8886. A significant penalty is imposed on taxpayers who participate in a
"reportable transaction" and fail to make the required disclosure. Certain states have similar reporting
requirements and may impose penalties for failure to report. Partners should consult their tax advisors
for advice concerning compliance with the reportable transaction regulations.
The Code provides for optional, and in certain cases mandatory, adjustments to the basis of partnership
property upon distributions of partnership property to a partner and transfers of partnership interests
(including by reason of death). The General Partner may elect to adjust the basis of Partnership property
in its sole discretion. In addition, the General Partner will be entitled to require that each Partner provide
it with any information necessary to allow the Partnership to comply with its obligations under the rules
relating to tax basis adjustments and disallowance of certain losses under Sections 734 or 743 of the Code.
Conlidcanal & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 42
Partners permitted to transfer interests in the Partnership will also be required to provide certain
information regarding the transfer to the General Partner and any transferee.
FATCA. Pursuant to Code Sections 1471-1474 and treasury regulations issued thereunder ("FATCA"),
the Partnership will be required to deduct a 30% withholding tax from payments of certain U.S. source
income, including capital gains, made to its foreign Partners unless the foreign Partners are individuals
or establish an exemption from this new withholding tax. The FATCA withholding tax cannot be reduced
under a tax treaty. Each Partner will be required to provide the Partnership any and all information
required for the Partnership to meet its obligations under FATCA. The purpose of FATCA is to insure
that foreign entities receiving payments from U.S. sources disclose all of their direct or indirect U.S.
owners. The FATCA withholding tax currently applies to payments of interest and dividends, but should
not apply before January 1, 2019 in the case of proceeds from the sales of stock and securities.
INVESTMENT BY THE PARTNERSHIP IN CONTROLLED FOREIGN CORPORATIONS. A non-United States
corporation in which the Partnership invests may be classified as a controlled foreign corporation
("CFC') in one or more taxable years while the corporation's stock is held by the Partnership. In general,
a foreign corporation will be classified as a CFC if five or fewer 10% United States Shareholders (as
defined below) own in the aggregate more than 50% of the voting power or value of the corporation's
stock. A "10% United States Shareholder" is generally a U.S. person who owns, directly or indirectly,
and with the application of certain attribution rules, 10% or more of the voting power of the stock of a
foreign corporation. The Partnership will be considered a U.S. person for these purposes. Each 10%
United States Shareholder who owns shares, directly or indirectly, in a CFC on the last day of the
corporation's taxable year will be required to include an amount in gross income, subject to tax at ordinary
income rates, equal to such 10% United States Shareholder's pro rata share of the corporation's (and each
of the corporation's subsidiary CFCs) Subpart F income. In general, Subpart F income includes passive
income and certain related party income. In addition, a 10% United States Shareholder may recognize
ordinary income on all or a portion of the gain from the sale of stock of a CFC.
INVESTMENT BY THE PARTNERSHIP IN PASSIVE FOREIGN INVESTMENT COMPANIES. A non-United
States corporation in which the Partnership invests may be classified as a passive foreign investment
company ("PFJC') in one or more taxable years while the corporation's stock is held by the Partnership.
In general, a foreign corporation will be classified as a PFIC if (i) at least 75% of its gross income for the
tax year is passive, or (ii) at least 50% of the assets held by the corporation during the year produce
passive income. A direct or indirect United States shareholder of stock in a PFIC may defer United States
tax until the stock is disposed of or until a distribution is received from the corporation. Gains realized
upon disposition of stock in a PFIC and certain excess distributions by the PFIC will be taxed as ordinary
income and will cause a United States shareholder to pay interest on the tax deferral obtained by reason
of holding stock in the PFIC. United States shareholders of a PFIC other than certain entities exempt
from United States federal income tax under Section 501(a) of the Code may avoid such interest charges
by making a qualified electing fund ("QEF') election in the first taxable year in which the corporation
becomes a PFIC. A QEF election would result in an annual inclusion in gross income of such United
States shareholder's pro rata share of the corporation's ordinary earnings and net capital gains irrespective
of whether such income is actually distributed. In order for the Partnership to make a valid QEF election
with respect to a portfolio company, the PFIC must agree to provide detailed information concerning its
operating income to the Partnership. There is no guarantee that any given portfolio company would agree
to provide such information. Accordingly, there can be no assurance that the Partnership will be able to
make a valid QEF election for any portfolio company that is a PFIC.
GENERAL. The foregoing discussion is for general information purposes and intended only as a general
summary of some of the principal federal income tax aspects of participation in the Partnership. The tax
Con ltd.:float & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 43
rules applicable with respect to the treatment of the Partners, the Partnership and the transactions that the
Partnership may engage in are highly complex, and their effect, in certain instances, may not be free from
doubt. It also must be emphasized that the tax rules presently applicable with respect to the transactions
described in this offering are subject to change at any time, and any such changes may or may not be
made with retroactive effect.
Certain Securities Law And Anti -Money Laundering Considerations
INVESTMENT COMPANY ACT OF 1940. The Partnership will not be subject to the provisions of the
Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the "Investment Company Act"), in reliance upon either

Section 3(cX1)i or Section 3(cX7)2 of the Investment Company Act. The Subscription Agreement and
Partnership Agreement will contain representations and restrictions on transfer designed to ensure that
the conditions of one or both of these provisions will be met.
In addition, the General Partner will be entitled to form separate, side-by-side partnerships that would
avoid the application of the Investment Company Act based on application of either Section 3(c)(1) of
the Investment Company Act (if the Partnership is relying on Section 3(c)(7) of the Investment Company
Act) or Section 3(cX7) of the Investment Company Act (if the Partnership is relying on Section 3(cX I )
of the Investment Company Act).
INVESTMENT ADVISORS ACT OF 1940. As of the date hereof, there is no requirement that the General
Partner must register under the Advisors Act However, future changes in laws may impose such a
requirement.
SECURITIES ACT OF 1933. The limited partner interests in the Partnership described herein are not being
registered under the Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the "Securities Ace'), in reliance upon
exemptions for transactions not involving a public offering. Each investor will be required to execute
certain agreements in connection with its subscription for a limited partner interest in the Partnership, and
in so doing will make certain representations to the General Partner, including: (i) that it is an "accredited
investor" as defined in Regulation D under the Securities Act; (ii) that it is acquiring its interest in the
Partnership for its own account, for investment purposes only, and not with a view to its distribution; (iii)
that it has received or had access to all information it deems relevant to evaluate the merits and risks of
the prospective investment and that it has reviewed and understood all such information; (iv) that it has
the ability to bear the economic risk of an investment in the Partnership for an indefinite period of time;
and (v) that it has such knowledge and experience of financial and business matters that it is capable of
evaluating the merits of an investment in the Partnership.
Prior to sale, offerees and their advisors are invited to ask questions and obtain additional information
from the General Partner concerning the limited partner interests in the Partnership described herein, the
terms and conditions of the offering, and any other relevant matters (including, but not limited to,
additional information to verify the accuracy of the information set forth herein).

Section 3(cX I ) excludes from the definition of "investment company" any issuer whose outstanding securities arc 
beneficially
owned by not more than one hundred (100) persons (as defined in this § 3(c)( I)), after giving effect to certain 
attribution rules,
and that does not engage in a public offering of securities.
2 Section 3(eX7) excludes from the definition of "investment company" any issuer whose outstanding securities are 
beneficially
owned only by "qualified purchasers" or "knowledgeable employees" and that does not engage in a public offering of 
securities.
A "qualified purchaser" includes a natural person who owns not less than $5,000,000 in investments, or a natural person 
or
company, acting for its own account or the accounts of other qualified purchasers, who owns and invests on a 
discretionary basis
not less than 525,000.000 in investments and certain trusts.
confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 44
ANTI-MONEY LAUNDERING REGULATIONS. All subscriptions for the limited partner interests in the
Partnership described herein are subject to applicable anti-money laundering regulations. Investors will
be required to comply with such anti-money laundering procedures as are required by Fulfilling Rights
and Ending Eavesdropping Dragnet-collection and Online Monitoring Act of 2015 (USA FREEDOM
Act).
As part of the Partnership's responsibility to comply with any applicable regulations aimed at the
prevention of money laundering, the Partnership may require verification of identity from all prospective
investors. The Partnership may seek to: verify the identity of a prospective investor; ensure that the
prospective investor is not named on one of the prohibited lists maintained by the U.S. Treasury
Department; verify the source of a prospective investor's funds; once a prospective investor becomes a
limited partner, monitor communications, capital contributions and withdrawals, and other payments
involving the limited partner; and report suspicious activity to appropriate authorities. The Partnership
may be required to exercise special scrutiny when prospective investors employ certain-kinds of financial
institutions or financial institutions from certain countries or when prospective investors are senior
governmental or military officials or senior executives of government-owned businesses. U.S. anti-
money laundering regulations are developing and changing continually and the Partnership may be
required to implement other anti-money laundering measures from time to time. Prospective investors
should be aware that in order to comply with any applicable anti-money laundering regulations, whether
in the United States or any other applicable jurisdiction, certain information regarding prospective
investors and partners may be required to be transmitted to, or held in, the United States or disclosed to
certain regulatory authorities in any applicable jurisdiction. Depending on the circumstances of each
subscription, it may not be necessary to obtain full documentary evidence of identity.
The Partnership reserves the right to request such information as is necessary to verify the identity of a
prospective investor. The Partnership also reserves the right to request such identification evidence in
respect of a transferee of the limited partner interests in the Partnership. In the event of delay or failure
by the prospective investor or transferee to produce any information required for verification purposes,
the Partnership may refuse to accept the application or (as the case may be) to give effect to the relevant
transfer and (in the case of a subscription for the limited partner interests in the Partnership) any funds
received will be returned without interest to the account from which the monies were originally debited.
The Partnership also reserves the right to refuse to make any distribution to a Limited Partner, if the
General Partner suspects or is advised that the payment of any distribution proceeds to such Limited
Partner might result in a breach or violation of any applicable anti-money laundering or other laws or
regulations by any person in any relevant jurisdiction, or such refusal is considered necessary or
appropriate to ensure the compliance by the Partnership, the General Partner or their respective affiliates
with any such laws or regulations in any relevant jurisdiction.
Certain ERISA Considerations
Each prospective investor that is an employee benefit plan or trust (an "ERISA Plan') within the
meaning of and subject to the provisions of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as
amended ("ERISA '7, or a plan within the meaning of and subject to the provisions of Section 4975 of
the Code, such as an individual retirement account (IRA) (a "Code Plan'), should consider the matters
described in this section in determining whether to invest in the Partnership. The provisions of ERISA
are complex and their application to an investment in the Partnership should be reviewed by the
appropriate representatives of any prospective investor that is an ERISA Plan or a Code Plan (each a
"Plan"). In particular, each such prospective investor should consult with their own legal counsel
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 45
concerning the issues described below. The following is intended to be a summary only and is not a
substitute for careful planning with a professional adviser.
FIDUCIARY MATTERS AND PROHIBITED TRANSACTIONS GENERALLY. In considering an investment in
the Partnership of a portion of the assets of any ERISA Plan, any Code Plan and any entity whose
underlying assets include plan assets by reason of an investment in such entity by an ERISA Plan or a
Code Plan (but not a foreign or governmental benefit plan that is not subject to ERISA or the Code) (a
"benefit plan investor"), a fiduciary should consider, among other factors, (i) whether the investment is
in accordance with the documents and instruments governing the Plan; (ii) whether the investment
satisfies the diversification requirements of Section 404(a)(I)(C) of ERISA, if applicable; (iii) whether
the investment provides sufficient liquidity to permit benefit payments to be made as they become due;
(iv) any requirement that the fiduciary annually value the assets of the Plan; (v) whether the investment
is prudent, since there is a high degree of risk in purchasing interests in the Partnership and it is not
expected that there will be any public market in which the interests may be sold or otherwise disposed of;
and (vi) whether the investment is for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits to participants and their
beneficiaries.
ERISA and the Code prohibit Plan fiduciaries from engaging in various transactions ("Prohibited
Transactions") involving Plan assets with persons who have certain relationships with respect to the Plan,
such as Plan fiduciaries (a "party in interest"). Thus, for example, absent an exemption the fiduciaries of
a Plan should not purchase interests in the Partnership with assets of any Plan if the General Partner or
any of its affiliates (i) has investment discretion with respect to such assets; or (ii) gives individualized
investment advice where there is an understanding that it will serve as the primary basis for the investment
decisions made with respect to such assets.
PLAN ASSETS. If the underlying assets of the Partnership (as opposed to interests in the Partnership alone)
were deemed to be "plan assets" under ERISA, (i) the prudence and other fiduciary responsibility
standards of Title I of ERISA would extend to investments made by the Partnership; and (ii) certain
transactions in which the Partnership might seek to engage could constitute Prohibited Transactions under
ERISA and the Code.
Under a regulation (the "Plan Assets Regulation") issued by the U.S. Department of Labor ("DOL"), the
assets and properties of certain entities in which a Plan makes an equity investment (other than an
investment in a publicly offered security or a security issued by an investment company registered under
the Investment Company Act) would be deemed to be assets of the investing Plan unless (i) the entity is
an "operating company" (including a "venture capital operating company') or (ii) equity participation by
"benefit plan investors" is less than 25% of any class of equity of the entity. Interests in the Partnership
will be neither publicly offered nor securities issued by an investment company registered under the
Investment Company Act, within the meaning of the Plan Assets Regulation, and it is possible that benefit
plan investors may purchase 25% or more of the Limited Partner interests in the Partnership.
For the Partnership to be considered a venture capital operating company, as of the date of its initial long-
term investment and on any date of each "annual valuation period," at least 50% of its assets, valued at
cost and exclusive of short-term investments pending long term commitment, must be investments in
operating companies as to which the Partnership has contractual rights directly with the operating
company to substantially participate in, or substantially influence, the conduct of such companies
("management rights"). In addition, the Partnership must actually exercise its management rights in at
least one of such companies in the ordinary course of its business each year. The Partnership cannot
give any assurances as to whether it will be operated as or considered to be a venture capital
operating company.
Coalidential & Tradc Sorrel
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 46
Notwithstanding the foregoing, to each investor that is a "benefit plan investor" (as defined in ERISA),
the General Partner acknowledges that it will use commercially reasonable efforts to conduct the affairs
of the Partnership so that the assets of the Partnership will not be deemed to be "plan assets" under
regulations promulgated by the U.S. Department of Labor.
PLAN ASSET CONSEQUENCES-PROHIBITED TRANSACTION EXEMPTIONS. If the Partnership's assets
were deemed to constitute "plan assets" subject to Title I of ERISA or Section 4975 of the Code and a
non-exempt Prohibited Transaction were to occur, then the General Partner, as a fiduciary and "party in
interest," and any other "party in interest" that engaged in the prohibited transaction could be required (i)
to restore to the Plan any profit realized on the transaction and (ii) to reimburse the Plan for any losses
suffered by the Plan, as a result of such investment. In addition, each "party in interest" involved could
be subject to an excise tax equal to 15% of the amount involved in the Prohibited Transaction for each
year such transaction continues and, unless such transaction were corrected within statutorily required
periods, to an additional tax of 100%. Plan fiduciaries who make the decision to invest in an interest in
the Partnership could, under certain circumstances, be liable as co-fiduciaries for actions taken by the
Partnership or the General Partner.
Furthermore, unless appropriate administrative exemptions were available or were obtained, the
Partnership could be restricted from acquiring an otherwise desirable investment or from entering into an
otherwise favorable transaction, if such acquisition or transaction would constitute a Prohibited
Transaction.
FORM 5500—ALTERNATIVE REPORTING OPTION. Most Plans must annually prepare and file with the
Internal Revenue Service a Form 5500, Annual Return/Report of Employee Benefit Plan ("Form 5500").
Schedule C of Form 5500 requires expanded reporting of "indirect compensation" received by service
providers to a Plan. "Indirect compensation" refers to compensation received from sources other than
directly from a Plan or the sponsor of a Plan if received in connection with services rendered to the Plan.
For this purpose, persons providing investment management services to a pooled investment vehicle in
which a Plan invests are treated as indirectly providing investment management services to the Plan.
Reportable "indirect compensation" thus includes fees received by a person from a pooled investment
vehicle in which a Plan invests to the extent that such fees are charged against the pooled investment
vehicle and reflected in the value of the Plan's investment, such as, for example, an investment adviser
asset-based investment management fee. The disclosure and description of the Partnership's
compensation arrangements contained in this Memorandum, the Subscription Agreement and/or the
Partnership Agreement are intended to satisfy the requirements for the alternative reporting option for
"eligible indirect compensation" that are set forth in the instructions to Schedule C of Form 5500 because
they disclose and describe (a) the existence of the indirect compensation, (b) the services provided for the
indirect compensation or the purpose for the payment of the indirect compensation, (c) the amount (or
estimate) of the compensation or a description of the formula used to calculate or determine the
compensation, and (d) the identity of the party or parties paying and receiving the compensation.
Each Plan fiduciary should consult its legal adviser concerning the potential consequences under
ERISA, Section 4975 of the Code or similar state law before making an investment in the
Partnership.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum 47
XI. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Prior to the consummation of the offering, the Partnership will provide to each prospective
investor and such investor's representatives and advisors, if any, the opportunity to ask questions and
receive answers concerning the terms and conditions of the offering and to obtain any additional
information which the Partnership may possess or can obtain without unreasonable effort and expense
that is necessary to verify the accuracy of the information furnished to such prospective investor.
This Memorandum is intended to present a general outline of the policies and structure of the
Partnership and the General Partner. The Partnership Agreement, which specifies the rights and
obligations of the Limited Partners, should be reviewed thoroughly by each prospective investor. The
"Summary of Principal Terms" of the terms and conditions of the Partnership contained herein is
necessarily incomplete and is qualified in its entirety by reference to such agreement and the subscription
agreements relating to the purchase of limited partnership interests therein. In the event any description
of the Partnership's terms and conditions set forth in this Memorandum conflict with the provisions of
such agreements, the terms and conditions set forth in such agreements shall control.
Any questions regarding this offering, and any requests for copies of the Memorandum, the
Partnership Agreement and the Subscription Agreement, should be forwarded to:
Valar Ventures LLC
915 Broadway, Suite 1101
New York, NY 10010
Email:
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-1
APPENDIX A
NOTICES UNDER CERTAIN UNITED STATES AND FOREIGN SECURITIES LAWS
Prospective investors should carefully consider the applicable legends stated below prior to deciding
whether or not to invest in the Partnership.
NOTICE TO FLORIDA RESIDENTS: A PURCHASER (OTHER THAN AN INSTITUTIONAL
INVESTOR DESCRIBED IN SECTION 517.061(7), FLA. STAT.) WHO ACCEPTS AN OFFER TO
PURCHASE SECURITIES EXEMPTED FROM REGISTRATION BY SECTION 517.061(11), FLA.
STAT., MAY VOID SUCH PURCHASE WITHIN A PERIOD OF THREE (3) DAYS AFTER (A) THE
PURCHASER FIRST TENDERS CONSIDERATION TO THE ISSUER, ITS AGENT OR AN
ESCROW AGENT OR (B) THE AVAILABILITY OF THAT PRIVILEGE IS COMMUNICATED TO
THE PURCHASER, WHICHEVER LATER OCCURS, UNLESS SALES ARE MADE TO FEWER
THAN FIVE (5) PURCHASERS IN FLORIDA (NOT COUNTING THOSE INSTITUTIONAL
INVESTORS DESCRIBED IN SECTION 517.061(7)).
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF OTHER STATES: IN MAKING AN INVESTMENT DECISION
INVESTORS MUST RELY ON THEIR OWN EXAMINATION OF THE ISSUER AND THE TERMS
OF THE OFFERING, INCLUDING THE MERITS AND RISKS INVOLVED. THESE SECURITIES
HAVE NOT BEEN RECOMMENDED BY ANY FEDERAL OR STATE SECURITIES
COMMISSION OR REGULATORY AUTHORITY. FURTHERMORE, THE FOREGOING
AUTHORITIES HAVE NOT CONFIRMED THE ACCURACY OR DETERMINED THE
ADEQUACY OF THIS MEMORANDUM. ANY REPRESENTATION TO THE CONTRARY IS A
CRIMINAL OFFENSE.
THESE SECURITIES ARE SUBJECT TO RESTRICTIONS ON TRANSFERABILITY AND RESALE
AND MAY NOT BE TRANSFERRED OR RESOLD EXCEPT AS PERMITTED UNDER THE
SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED, AND THE APPLICABLE STATE SECURITIES
LAWS, PURSUANT TO REGISTRATION OR EXEMPTION THEREFROM. INVESTORS SHOULD
BE AWARE THAT THEY MAY BE REQUIRED TO BEAR THE FINANCIAL RISKS OF THIS
INVESTMENT FOR AN INDEFINITE PERIOD OF TIME.
NOTICE TO FOREIGN INVESTORS: IT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF ANY PERSON OR
ENTITY WISHING TO PURCHASE AN INTEREST TO SATISFY HIMSELF, HERSELF OR ITSELF
AS TO THE FULL OBSERVANCE OF THE LAWS OF ANY RELEVANT TERRITORY OUTSIDE
OF THE UNITED STATES IN CONNECTION WITH ANY SUCH PURCHASE, INCLUDING
OBTAINING ANY REQUIRED GOVERNMENTAL OR OTHER CONSENTS OR OBSERVING
ANY OTHER APPLICABLE FORMALITIES.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF AUSTRALIA: THE PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REGISTERED AS A
MANAGED INVESTMENT SCHEME IN AUSTRALIA. THE PROVISION OF THIS
MEMORANDUM TO ANY PERSON DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER OF INTERESTS TO
THAT PERSON OR AN INVITATION TO THAT PERSON TO APPLY FOR INTERESTS. ANY
SUCH OFFER OR INVITATION WILL ONLY BE EXTENDED TO A PERSON IF THAT PERSON
HAS FIRST SATISFIED THE GENERAL PARTNER THAT THE PERSON IS A WHOLESALE
CLIENT FOR THE PURPOSE OF SECTION 76 I G(7) OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT OF
AUSTRALIA. THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT A PROSPECTUS OR PRODUCT DISCLOSURE
Con lidentual & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-2
STATEMENT. IT IS NOT REQUIRED TO, AND DOES NOT, CONTAIN ALL THE INFORMATION
WHICH WOULD BE REQUIRED IN A PROSPECTUS OR PRODUCT DISCLOSURE STATEMENT.
IT HAS NOT BEEN LODGED WITH OR BEEN THE SUBJECT OF NOTIFICATION TO THE
AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION. IT IS A TERM OF ISSUE OF
INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP THAT THE INVESTOR MAY NOT TRANSFER OR OFFER
TO TRANSFER THEIR INTERESTS TO ANY PERSON LOCATED IN, OR RESIDENT OF,
AUSTRALIA UNLESS THE PERSON IS A WHOLESALE CLIENT FOR THE PURPOSES OF
SECTION 761G(7) OF THE CORPORATIONS ACT OF AUSTRALIA.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF BAHRAIN: THE MARKETING OF INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIP IN BAHRAIN HAS NOT BEEN APPROVED BY THE CENTRAL BANK OF
BAHRAIN. THE CENTRAL BANK OF BAHRAIN TAKES NO RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE
ACCURACY OF THE STATEMENTS AND INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS
MEMORANDUM OR FOR THE PERFORMANCE OF THE PARTNERSHIPS, NOR SHALL IT
HAVE ANY LIABILITY TO ANY PERSON, A LIMITED PARTNER OR OTHERWISE, FOR ANY
LOSS OR DAMAGE RESULTING FROM RELIANCE ON ANY STATEMENT OR INFORMATION
CONTAINED HEREIN.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF BELGIUM: THE PARTNERSHIP HAS NOT BEEN AND WILL
NOT BE REGISTERED WITH THE BELGIAN BANKING, FINANCE AND INSURANCE
COMMISSION (COMMISSIE VOOR HET BANK-, FINANCIE- EN ASSURANTIEWEZEN /
COMMISSION BANCAIRE, FINANCIERE ET DES ASSURANCES) ("CBFA")) AS A FOREIGN
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT INSTITUTION UNDER ARTICLE 127 OF THE BELGIAN LAW OF
20 JULY 2004 ON CERTAIN FORMS OF COLLECTIVE MANAGEMENT OF INVESTMENT
PORTFOLIO. THE OFFERING IN BELGIUM HAS NOT BEEN AND WILL NOT BE NOTIFIED TO
THE CBFA. THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN AND WILL NOT BE APPROVED BY THE
CBFA. THE PUBLIC OFFERING OF INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP IN BELGIUM WITHIN
THE MEANING OF THE BELGIAN ACT OF JULY 20, 2004, AND THE BELGIAN ACT OF JUNE
16, 2006 ON THE PUBLIC OFFERING OF INVESTMENT INSTRUMENTS AND THE ADMISSION
OF INVESTMENT INSTRUMENTS TO LISTING ON A REGULATED MARKET HAS NOT BEEN
AUTHORIZED BY THE PARTNERSHIP. THE OFFERING MAY NOT BE ADVERTISED, AND
INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP MAY NOT BE OFFERED, SOLD, TRANSFERRED OR
DELIVERED TO, OR SUBSCRIBED TO BY, AND NO MEMORANDUM, INFORMATION
CIRCULAR, BROCHURE OR SIMILAR DOCUMENT MAY BE DISTRIBUTED TO, DIRECTLY
OR INDIRECTLY, ANY INDIVIDUAL OR LEGAL ENTITY IN BELGIUM, EXCEPT (I) TO
"QUALIFIED INVESTORS" AS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE 10, § 1 OF THE BELGIAN ACT OF
JUNE 16, 2006, (II) SUBJECT TO THE RESTRICTION OF A MINIMUM INVESTMENT OF E50,000
PER INVESTOR OR EQUIVALENT IN RELEVANT FOREIGN CURRENCY OR (III) IN ANY
OTHER CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH THE PRESENT OFFERING DOES NOT QUALIFY AS A
PUBLIC OFFERING IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE AFOREMENTIONED ACT OF JUNE 16, 2006.
THIS MEMORANDUM HAS BEEN ISSUED TO THE INTENDED RECIPIENT FOR PERSONAL
USE ONLY AND EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE PURPOSES OF THE OFFERING. THEREFORE, IT
MAY NOT BE USED FOR ANY OTHER PURPOSE NOR PASSED ON TO ANY OTHER PERSON
IN BELGIUM.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF CANADA:
PURCHASERS' REPRESENTATIONS, COVENANTS AND RESALE RESTRICTIONS
CONFIRMATIONS OF THE ACCEPTANCE OF OFFERS TO PURCHASE INTERESTS WILL BE
SENT TO PURCHASERS IN CANADA WHO HAVE NOT WITHDRAWN THEIR OFFERS TO
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-3
PURCHASE PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF SUCH CONFIRMATIONS. EACH PURCHASER OF
INTERESTS IN CANADA WHO RECEIVES A PURCHASE CONFIRMATION, BY THE
PURCHASER'S RECEIPT THEREOF, REPRESENTS TO THE PARTNERSHIP AND ANY DEALER
FROM WHOM SUCH PURCHASE CONFIRMATION IS RECEIVED THAT SUCH PURCHASER IS
A PERSON OR COMPANY TO WHICH INTERESTS MAY BE SOLD WITHOUT THE BENEFIT
OF A PROSPECTUS QUALIFIED UNDER APPLICABLE PROVINCIAL SECURITIES LAWS. IN
PARTICULAR, PURCHASERS RESIDENT IN ONTARIO REPRESENT TO THE PARTNERSHIP
THAT THE PURCHASER IS (A) EITHER AN "ACCREDITED INVESTOR" AS SUCH TERM IS
DEFINED IN SECTION 1.1 OF NATIONAL INSTRUMENT 45-106 - PROSPECTUS AND
REGISTRATION EXEMPTIONS OF THE CANADIAN SECURITIES ADMINISTRATORS (THE
"NI") OR (B) A PURCHASER WHO PURCHASES INTERESTS THAT HAVE AN ACQUISITION
COST TO THE PURCHASER OF NOT LESS THAN CS 150,000 PAID IN CASH AT THE TIME OF
THE PURCHASE, AND WHO IS NOT CREATED OR USED SOLELY TO PURCHASE OR HOLD
SECURITIES IN RELIANCE ON THE EXEMPTION IN SECTION 2.10 OF THE NI. IN EITHER
CASE, THE PURCHASER MUST PURCHASE THE UNITS AS PRINCIPAL. THE DISTRIBUTION
OF INTERESTS IN CANADA IS BEING MADE ON A PRIVATE PLACEMENT BASIS.
ACCORDINGLY, ANY RESALE OF THE INTERESTS MUST BE MADE IN ACCORDANCE WITH
AN EXEMPTION FROM THE REGISTRATION AND PROSPECTUS REQUIREMENTS OF
APPLICABLE SECURITIES LAWS, WHICH VARY DEPENDING ON THE PROVINCE.
PURCHASERS OF INTERESTS ARE ADVISED TO SEEK LEGAL ADVICE PRIOR TO ANY
RESALE OF INTERESTS.
IN ONTARIO, THE INTERESTS WILL, AND IN OTHER CANADIAN JURISDICTIONS, THE
INTERESTS MAY, BE DISTRIBUTED THROUGH ONE OR MORE DEALERS REGISTERED
WITH THE RELEVANT SECURITIES REGULATORY AUTHORITY. THE PARTNERSHIP IS NOT
A "CONNECTED ISSUER" OR "RELATED ISSUER", WITHIN THE MEANING OF NATIONAL
INSTRUMENT 33-105 - UNDERWRITING CONFLICTS OF THE CANADIAN SECURITIES
ADMINISTRATORS, OF ANY SUCH DEALER.
ENFORCEMENT OF LEGAL RIGHTS
ALL OF THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, AND THEIR
RESPECTIVE DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS MAY BE LOCATED OUTSIDE OF CANADA AND,
AS A RESULT, IT MAY NOT BE POSSIBLE FOR CANADIAN PURCHASERS TO EFFECT
SERVICE OF PROCESS WITHIN CANADA UPON THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, OR THEIR DIRECTORS OR OFFICERS. ALL OR A
SUBSTANTIAL PORTION OF THE ASSETS OF THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL
REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, AND SUCH PERSONS MAY BE LOCATED OUTSIDE OF
CANADA AND, AS A RESULT, IT MAY NOT BE POSSIBLE TO SATISFY A JUDGMENT
AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, AND SUCH
PERSONS IN CANADA OR TO ENFORCE A JUDGMENT OBTAINED IN CANADIAN COURTS
AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP, ITS LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES, THE ADVISER, OR SUCH
PERSONS OUTSIDE OF CANADA.
SECURITIES LEGISLATION IN CERTAIN OF THE CANADIAN JURISDICTIONS REQUIRES
PURCHASERS TO BE PROVIDED WITH A REMEDY FOR RESCISSION OR DAMAGES, OR
BOTH, IN ADDITION TO AND NOT IN DEROGATION FROM ANY OTHER RIGHT THEY MAY
HAVE AT LAW, WHERE AN OFFERING MEMORANDUM AND ANY AMENDMENT TO IT
CONTAINS A MISREPRESENTATION. THESE REMEDIES MUST BE EXERCISED BY THE
PURCHASER WITHIN THE TIME LIMITS PRESCRIBED BY THE APPLICABLE SECURITIES
LEGISLATION.
Con & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-4
PURCHASERS SHOULD REFER TO THE APPLICABLE PROVISIONS OF THE SECURITIES
LEGISLATION FOR THE COMPLETE TEXT OF THESE RIGHTS OR CONSULT WITH A LEGAL
ADVISOR.
THE APPLICABLE CONTRACTUAL AND/OR STATUTORY RIGHTS ARE SUMMARIZED
BELOW. THE SUMMARY IS SUBJECT TO THE EXPRESS PROVISIONS OF THE APPLICABLE
PROVINCIAL SECURITIES LAWS AND THE REGULATIONS AND RULES THEREUNDER AND
REFERENCE IS MADE THERETO FOR THE COMPLETE TEXT OF SUCH PROVISIONS.
THIS MEMORANDUM CONTAINS, PROXIMATE TO THE FORWARD -LOOKING
INFORMATION, REASONABLE CAUTIONARY LANGUAGE IDENTIFYING THE FORWARD -
LOOKING INFORMATION AS SUCH, AND IDENTIFYING MATERIAL FACTORS THAT
COULD CAUSE ACTUAL RESULTS TO DIFFER MATERIALLY FROM A CONCLUSION,
FORECAST OR PROJECTION IN THE FORWARD -LOOKING INFORMATION, AND A
STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTORS OR ASSUMPTIONS THAT WERE APPLIED IN
DRAWING A CONCLUSION OR MAKING A FORECAST OR PROJECTION SET OUT IN THE
FORWARD -LOOKING INFORMATION; AND
THE PARTNERSHIP HAS A REASONABLE BASIS FOR DRAWING THE CONCLUSION OR
MAKING THE FORECASTS AND PROJECTIONS SET OUT IN THE FORWARD LOOKING
INFORMATION.
THE FOREGOING RIGHTS DO NOT APPLY IF THE PURCHASER IS:

(A) A CANADIAN FINANCIAL INSTITUTION (AS DEFINED IN NATIONAL INSTRUMENT
45-106 - PROSPECTUS AND REGISTRATION EXEMPTIONS OF THE CANADIAN SECURITIES
ADMINISTRATORS) OR A SCHEDULE III BANK;

(B) THE BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT BANK OF CANADA INCORPORATED UNDER THE
BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT BANK OF CANADA ACT (CANADA); OR
(C) A SUBSIDIARY OF ANY PERSON REFERRED TO IN PARAGRAPHS (A) AND (B), IF
THE PERSON OWNS ALL OF THE VOTING SECURITIES OF THE SUBSIDIARY, EXCEPT THE
VOTING SECURITIES REQUIRED BY LAW TO BE OWNED BY DIRECTORS OF THAT
SUBSIDIARY.
THE FOREGOING SUMMARY IS SUBJECT TO THE EXPRESS PROVISIONS OF THE
SECURITIES ACT (ONTARIO) AND THE RULES, REGULATIONS AND OTHER INSTRUMENTS
THEREUNDER, AND REFERENCE IS MADE TO THE COMPLETE TEXT OF SUCH PROVISIONS
CONTAINED THEREIN. SUCH PROVISIONS MAY CONTAIN LIMITATIONS AND
STATUTORY DEFENSES ON WHICH THE PARTNERSHIP MAY RELY. THE RIGHTS OF
ACTION DESCRIBED HEREIN ARE IN ADDITION TO AND WITHOUT DEROGATION FROM
ANY OTHER RIGHT OR REMEDY THAT THE PURCHASER MAY HAVE AT LAW.
CERTAIN CANADIAN INCOME TAX CONSIDERATIONS
PROSPECTIVE PURCHASERS OF INTERESTS SHOULD CONSULT THEIR OWN TAX
ADVISORS WITH RESPECT TO ANY TAXES EXIGIBLE IN CONNECTION WITH THE
ACQUISITION, HOLDING OR DISPOSITION OF INTERESTS. IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT
TAX ADVISORS BE EMPLOYED IN CANADA, AS THERE ARE A NUMBER OF SUBSTANTIVE
CANADIAN TAX COMPLIANCE REQUIREMENTS FOR CANADIAN INVESTORS.
CONTRACTUAL AND/OR STATUTORY RIGHTS OF ACTION
ONTARIO:
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-5
PURCHASERS IN ONTARIO TO WHOM THIS MEMORANDUM IS DELIVERED AND WHO
PURCHASE INTERESTS IN RELIANCE ON THE PROSPECTUS EXEMPTION PROVIDED BY
SECTION 2.3 OF ONTARIO SECURITIES COMMISSION RULE 45.501 ARE HEREBY GRANTED
THE FOLLOWING RIGHTS:
IN THE EVENT THAT THIS MEMORANDUM OR ANY AMENDMENT THERETO DELIVERED
TO A PURCHASER OF INTERESTS IN ONTARIO CONTAINS AN UNTRUE STATEMENT OF A
MATERIAL FACT OR OMITS TO STATE A MATERIAL FACT THAT IS REQUIRED TO BE
STATED OR THAT IS NECESSARY TO MAKE ANY STATEMENT THEREIN NOT MISLEADING
IN THE LIGHT OF THE CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH IT WAS MADE (HEREIN CALLED A
"MISREPRESENTATION") AND IT WAS A MISREPRESENTATION AT THE TIME OF
PURCHASE, THE PURCHASER WILL BE DEEMED TO HAVE RELIED UPON THE
MISREPRESENTATION AND WILL, SUBJECT AS HEREINAFTER PROVIDED, HAVE A RIGHT
OF ACTION AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP FOR DAMAGES, OR, WHILE STILL THE OWNER
OF THE INTERESTS PURCHASED BY THAT PURCHASER FOR RESCISSION, IN WHICH CASE,
IF THE PURCHASER ELECTS TO EXERCISE THE RIGHT OF RESCISSION, THE PURCHASER
WILL HAVE NO RIGHT OF ACTION FOR DAMAGES AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP,
PROVIDED THAT:

• THE RIGHT OF ACTION FOR RESCISSION WILL BE EXERCISABLE BY A
PURCHASER ONLY IF THE PURCHASER GIVES NOTICE TO THE PARTNERSHIP NOT
LATER THAN 180 DAYS AFTER THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION THAT GAVE RISE
TO THE CAUSE OF ACTION;

• THE RIGHT OF ACTION FOR DAMAGES OR ANY OTHER ACTION OTHER THAN THE
RIGHT OF ACTION FOR RESCISSION WILL BE EXERCISABLE BY A PURCHASER
ONLY IF THE PURCHASER GIVES NOTICE TO THE PARTNERSHIP NOT LATER
THAN THE EARLIER OF (I) 180 DAYS AFTER THE PURCHASER HAD KNOWLEDGE
OF THE FACTS GIVING RISE TO THE CAUSE OF ACTION OR (II) THREE YEARS
AFTER THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION THAT GAVE RISE TO THE CAUSE OF
ACTION;

• THE PARTNERSHIP WILL NOT BE LIABLE IF IT PROVES THAT THE PURCHASER
PURCHASED THE INTERESTS WITH KNOWLEDGE OF THE MISREPRESENTATION;

• IN THE CASE OF AN ACTION FOR DAMAGES, THE PARTNERSHIP WILL NOT BE
LIABLE FOR ALL OR ANY PORTION OF THE DAMAGES THAT IT PROVES DOES NOT
REPRESENT THE DEPRECIATION IN VALUE OF THE INTERESTS AS A RESULT OF
THE MISREPRESENTATION RELIED UPON; AND

• IN NO CASE WILL THE AMOUNT RECOVERABLE IN ANY ACTION EXCEED THE
PRICE AT WHICH THE INTERESTS WERE SOLD TO PURCHASER.

• THE STATUTORY RIGHTS DISCUSSED ABOVE ARE IN ADDITION TO AND
WITHOUT DEROGATION FROM ANY OTHER RIGHT THE PURCHASER MAY HAVE
AT LAW.
UNLESS THE PARTNERSHIP HAS ENGAGED AN ONTARIO -REGISTERED DEALER TO
PLACE THE INTERESTS IN ONTARIO, EACH PURCHASER OF INTERESTS IN ONTARIO WILL
BE REQUIRED TO DESIGNATE AN ONTARIO -REGISTERED DEALER TO COMPLETE THE
PURCHASE OF THE INTERESTS ON ITS BEHALF. THE STAFF OF THE ONTARIO SECURITIES
COMMISSION TAKE THE POSITION THAT A PERSON THAT PROVIDES INVESTMENT
ADVICE TO A FUND THAT DISTRIBUTES ITS INTERESTS IN ONTARIO IS CONSIDERED TO
Con lidcanal & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-6
BE ACTING AS AN ADVISER IN ONTARIO, AND IS SUBJECT TO THE REQUIREMENT TO
REGISTER AS AN ADVISER, NOTWITHSTANDING THAT THE ADVICE MAY BE GIVEN TO
AND RECEIVED BY THE PARTNERSHIP OUTSIDE OF ONTARIO. NEITHER THE GENERAL
PARTNER NOR THE RELATED "MANAGEMENT COMPANY" IS REGISTERED IN ONTARIO.
HOWEVER, ONE OR BOTH OF SUCH ENTITIES MAY RELY UPON AN EXEMPTION FROM
THE ADVISER REGISTRATION REQUIREMENT IF THE INTERESTS ARE DISTRIBUTED
THROUGH AN ONTARIO -REGISTERED DEALER. ACCORDINGLY, UNLESS THE
PARTNERSHIP HAS ENGAGED AN ONTARIO -REGISTERED DEALER TO PLACE THE
INTERESTS IN ONTARIO, NO SALE WILL BE MADE TO A PURCHASER RESIDENT IN
ONTARIO UNLESS THE DESIGNATION FORM CONTAINED IN THE SUBSCRIPTION
AGREEMENT HAS BEEN COMPLETED AND DELIVERED TO THE PARTNERSHIP.
QUEBEC:
IN QUEBEC, EVERY PERSON WHO HAS SUBSCRIBED FOR SECURITIES PURSUANT TO THIS
MEMORANDUM MAY, IN THE EVENT THAT THIS MEMORANDUM CONTAINS A
MISREPRESENTATION, APPLY TO HAVE THE CONTRACT RESCINDED OR THE PRICE
REVISED, WITHOUT PREJUDICE TO HIS OR HER CLAIM FOR DAMAGES, PROVIDED THAT
NO ACTION MAY BE COMMENCED TO ENFORCE SUCH RIGHT UNLESS THE RIGHT IS
EXERCISED:
IN THE CASE OF RESCISSION OR REVISION OF THE PRICE, WITHIN ONE YEAR
FROM THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION; AND

• IN THE CASE OF DAMAGES, WITHIN ONE YEAR OF THE DATE ON WHICH THE
PERSON ACQUIRED KNOWLEDGE OF THE FACTS GIVING RISE TO THE ACTION,
EXCEPT UPON PROOF THAT THE PLAINTIFF ACQUIRED SUCH KNOWLEDGE MORE
THAN ONE YEAR AFTER THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION AS A RESULT OF THE
NEGLIGENCE OF THE PLAINTIFF.
AN ACTION FOR RESCISSION OR REVISION OF THE PRICE OR DAMAGES AGAINST THE
ISSUER, THE DEFENDANT MAY DEFEAT THE APPLICATION ONLY IF IT IS PROVED THAT
THE PLAINTIFF KNEW, AT THE TIME OF THE TRANSACTION, OF THE ALLEGED
MISREPRESENTATION.
BRITISH COLUMBIA:
IN THE EVENT THAT THIS MEMORANDUM OR ANY AMENDMENT THERETO DELIVERED
TO A PURCHASER OF INTERESTS IN BRITISH COLUMBIA CONTAINS AN UNTRUE
STATEMENT OF A MATERIAL FACT OR OMITS TO STATE A MATERIAL FACT THAT IS
REQUIRED TO BE STATED OR IS NECESSARY IN ORDER TO PREVENT ANY STATEMENT
THAT IS BEING MADE FROM NOT BEING FALSE OR MISLEADING IN THE
CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH IT WAS MADE (HEREIN CALLED A "MISREPRESENTATION")
AND IT WAS A MISREPRESENTATION AT THE TIME OF PURCHASE, THE PURCHASER WILL
BE DEEMED TO HAVE RELIED UPON THE MISREPRESENTATION AND WILL, SUBJECT AS
HEREINAFTER PROVIDED, HAVE A RIGHT OF ACTION AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP FOR
DAMAGES, OR, WHILE STILL THE OWNER OF THE INTERESTS PURCHASED BY THAT
PURCHASER, FOR RESCISSION, IN WHICH CASE, IF THE PURCHASER ELECTS TO
EXERCISE THE RIGHT OF RESCISSION, THE PURCHASER WILL HAVE NO RIGHT OF
ACTION FOR DAMAGES AGAINST THE PARTNERSHIP, PROVIDED THAT:

• THE RIGHT OF ACTION FOR RESCISSION OR DAMAGES IS ENFORCEABLE BY A
PURCHASER ON NOTICE BY THE PURCHASER TO THE PARTNERSHIP ON OR
Con lidcattal & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-7
BEFORE THE 90TH DAY AFTER THE DATE ON WHICH PAYMENT IS MADE FOR
INTERESTS OR ON WHICH THE INITIAL PAYMENT WAS MADE FOR THE
INTERESTS, IF PAYMENTS SUBSEQUENT TO THE INITIAL PAYMENT ARE MADE
UNDER A CONTRACTUAL COMMITMENT ENTERED INTO BEFORE, OR
CONCURRENTLY WITH, THE INITIAL PAYMENT;

• A PURCHASER WILL NOT BE ENTITLED TO COMMENCE AN ACTION TO ENFORCE
A RIGHT: (1) IN THE CASE OF AN ACTION FOR RESCISSION, MORE THAN 180 DAYS
AFTER THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION THAT GAVE RISE TO THE CAUSE OF
ACTION; OR (II) IN THE CASE OF AN ACTION FOR DAMAGES, MORE THAN THE
EARLIER OF 180 DAYS AFTER THE DATE THE PURCHASER FIRST HAD
KNOWLEDGE OF THE FACTS THAT GAVE RISE TO THE CAUSE OF ACTION OR
THREE YEARS FROM THE DATE OF THE TRANSACTION THAT GAVE RISE TO THE
CAUSE OF ACTION;

• THE PARTNERSHIP WILL NOT BE LIABLE IF IT PROVES THAT THE PURCHASER
PURCHASED THE INTERESTS WITH KNOWLEDGE OF THE MISREPRESENTATION;

• IN THE CASE OF AN ACTION FOR DAMAGES, THE PARTNERSHIP WILL NOT BE
LIABLE FOR ALL OR ANY PORTION OF THE DAMAGES THAT IT PROVES DOES NOT
REPRESENT THE DEPRECIATION IN VALUE OF THE INTERESTS AS A RESULT OF
THE MISREPRESENTATION RELIED UPON; AND
• IN NO CASE WILL THE AMOUNT RECOVERABLE IN ANY ACTION EXCEED THE
PRICE AT WHICH THE INTERESTS WERE SOLD TO THE PURCHASER_
THE CONTRACTUAL RIGHTS DISCUSSED ABOVE ARE IN ADDITION TO AND WITHOUT
DEROGATION FROM ANY OTHER RIGHTS OR REMEDIES AVAILABLE AT LAW TO THE
PURCHASER.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF CHINA (THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA): THE
INTERESTS ARE NOT BEING OFFERED OR SOLD AND MAY NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD,
DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, WITHIN THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA (FOR SUCH
PURPOSES, NOT INCLUDING THE HONG KONG AND MACAU SPECIAL ADMINISTRATIVE
REGIONS OR TAIWAN), EXCEPT AS PERMITTED BY THE SECURITIES AND FUNDS LAWS
OF THE PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF DENMARK: INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP ARE BEING
OFFERED TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF INSTITUTIONAL AND SOPHISTICATED INVESTORS.
PURSUANT TO SECTION 11 OF THE PROSPECTUS ORDER (MINISTERIAL ORDER NO. 1232
OF OCTOBER 22, 2007 ON THE PROSPECTUS REQUIREMENTS FOR OFFERINGS OF A VALUE
ABOVE 62,500,000) ISSUED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 23(8) OF THE DANISH
SECURITIES TRADING ACT (CONSOLIDATED ACT NO. 214 OF APRIL 2, 2008) THE
FOLLOWING TYPES OF OFFERINGS ARE EXEMPTED FROM PROSPECTUS REGISTRATION
REQUIREMENTS:

(A) OFFERINGS TO ACCREDITED INVESTORS;
(B) OFFERINGS TO NON -ACCREDITED INVESTORS IF THE OFFER IS DIRECTED AT FEWER
THAN 100 PRIVATE OR LEGAL PERSONS IN DENMARK;

(C) OFFERINGS FOR WHICH THE VALUE OF EACH INTEREST EXCEEDS €50,000; OR
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-8
(D) OFFERINGS WHERE PARTICIPATION IS CONDITIONAL UPON PAYMENT OF MORE
THAN €50,000 PER INVESTOR.
THIS MEMORANDUM MAY ONLY BE DISTRIBUTED TO, AND THE OFFERING MAY ONLY
BE SUBSCRIBED BY, INVESTORS THAT SATISFY ONE OR MORE OF THE CONDITIONS SET
OUT ABOVE FROM (A) TO (D). ACCORDINGLY, THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN AND
WILL NOT BE REGISTERED WITH THE DANISH FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY OR
THE DANISH COMMERCE AND COMPANIES AGENCY UNDER THE RELEVANT DANISH
ACTS AND REGULATIONS ON THE OFFERING IN DENMARK OF FUND INTERESTS.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF FRANCE: THE OFFER OF INTERESTS IS NOT SUBJECT TO THE
REQUIREMENT OF A PROSPECTUS OR OTHER INFORMATION DOCUMENT FILED WITH
THE COMMISSION DES OPERATIONS DE BOURSE FOR ITS APPROVAL (VISA). NEITHER
THIS MEMORANDUM NOR ANY OFFERING MATERIAL RELATING TO THE OFFER OF
INTERESTS HAVE BEEN OR WILL BE SUBMITTED TO THE CLEARANCE PROCEDURES OF
THE FRENCH AUTHORITIES, INCLUDING THE COMMISSION DES OPERATIONS DE
BOURSE. THE INTERESTS MAY ONLY BE OFFERED TO AND PURCHASED OR SUBSCRIBED
TO BY INVESTORS REFERRED TO IN ARTICLE L. 411-2 OF THE FRENCH MONETARY AND
FINANCIAL CODE (CODE MONETAIRE ET FINANCIER) AND DECRET N° 98.880, DATED
OCTOBER 1, 1998, ACTING FOR THEIR OWN ACCOUNT. IN THE EVENT THAT THE
INTERESTS THUS PURCHASED OR SUBSCRIBED TO BY SUCH INVESTORS ARE OFFERED
OR SOLD, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, TO THE PUBLIC IN FRANCE, THE CONDITIONS SET
FORTH IN ARTICLES L. 412-I AND L. 621-8 OF THE CODE CITED ABOVE MUST BE
COMPLIED WITH. IF THE INTERESTS ARE OFFERED TO A CLOSE CIRCLE OF INVESTORS
OF 100 PERSONS OR MORE, SUCH INVESTORS MUST REPRESENT THAT THEY KNOW ONE
OF THE MEMBERS OF THE PARTNERSHIP'S MANAGEMENT PERSONALLY AND HAVE
EITHER A FAMILY OR PROFESSIONAL RELATIONSHIP WITH SUCH MEMBER. THIS
MEMORANDUM AND OTHER OFFERING MATERIALS RELATING TO THE OFFER OF
INTERESTS ARE STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL AND MAY NOT BE DISTRIBUTED TO ANY
PERSON OR ENTITY OTHER THAN THE RECIPIENTS HEREOF.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF GERMANY: THIS DOCUMENT AND OTHER RELATED
OFFERING MATERIALS HAVE NOT BEEN SUBMITTED TO THE GERMAN FEDERAL
FINANCIAL SERVICES SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY (BUNDESANSTALT FOR
FINANZDIENSTLEISTUNGSAUFSICHT - "BAFIN") AND INTERESTS IN THE FUND
DESCRIBED IN THIS DOCUMENT ARE NOT ADMITTED OR REGISTERED WITH BAFIN FOR
PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION IN GERMANY UNDER THE SECURITIES PROSPECTUS ACT
(WERTPAPIERPROSPEKTGESETZ - "WPPG"), THE CAPITAL INVESTMENTS ACT
(VERMOGENSANLAGENGESETZ - "VERMANLG") AND/OR THE CAPITAL INVESTMENT
CODE (KAPITALANLAGEGESETZBUCH - "KAGB"). CONSEQUENTLY, INTERESTS IN THE
FUND MAY NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD TO THE PUBLIC IN GERMANY AND THIS
DOCUMENT AND ANY OTHER RELATED OFFERING MATERIALS MAY NOT BE
DISTRIBUTED TO THE PUBLIC. FURTHER, NO FILING FOR REGISTRATION OF INTERESTS
IN THE FUND WITH BAFIN UNDER THE KAGB HAS SO FAR BEEN MADE.
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS DOCUMENT AND IN OTHER RELATED OFFERING
MATERIALS IS STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL AND ONLY INTENDED FOR THE RECIPIENT
THEREOF. RECIPIENTS MAY NOT PASS THIS DOCUMENT OR ANY OTHER RELATED
OFFERING MATERIALS ON TO THIRD PERSONS EXCEPT TO THEIR ADVISORS FOR
PURPOSES OF EVALUATING THEIR OWN INVESTMENT. ANY RESALE OF INTERESTS IN
THE FUND IN GERMANY MAY ONLY BE MADE IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PROVISIONS
Conlidentual & Trade Scat'
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-9
OF THE WPPG, THE VERMANLG OR THE KAGB, AS APPLICABLE, AND ANY OTHER LAW
APPLICABLE IN GERMANY GOVERNING THE SALE AND OFFERING OF SECURITIES AND
FUND INTERESTS. THE FUND WILL NOT MEET THE REPORTING AND PUBLICATION
REQUIREMENTS UNDER THE GERMAN INVESTMENT TAX ACT
(INVESTMENTSTEUERGESETZ). POTENTIAL INVESTORS IN THE FUND ARE ADVISED TO
CONSULT THEIR OWN TAX ADVISORS AS TO THE TAX CONSEQUENCES OF THE
RELEVANT TRANSACTION INVOLVING THE FUND. TAXATION RATES AND THEIR BASES
MAY CHANGE. AS A RESULT, POTENTIAL INVESTORS SHOULD KEEP ANY TAX ADVICE
OBTAINED UNDER REVIEW.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF GREECE: THIS MEMORANDUM AND INTERSTS TO WHICH IT
RELATES AND ANY OTHER MATERIAL RELATED THERETO MAY NOT BE ADVERTISED,
DISTRIBUTED OR OTHERWISE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE PUBLIC IN GREECE. THE GREEK
CAPITAL MARKET COMMISSION HAS NOT AUTHORIZED ANY PUBLIC OFFEREING OF THE
SUBSCRIPTION OR INTERESTS IN THE FUND; ACCORDINGLY, INTERESTS MAY NOT BE
ADVERTISED, DISTRIBUTED OR IN ANY WAY OFFERED OR SOLD IN GREECE OR TO
RESIDENTS THEREOF EXCEPT AS PERMITETD BY GREEK LAW. THIS MEMORANDUM AND
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN DO NOT AND WILL NOT BE DEEMED TO
CONSITUTE AN INVITATION TO THE PUBLIC IN GREECE TO PURCHASE INTERESTS. THE
FUND DOES NOT HAVE A GUARANTEED PERFORMANCE AND PAST RETURNS DO NOT
GUARANTEE FUTURE ONES.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF HONG KONG: NO PERSON MAY OFFER OR SELL IN HONG
KONG, BY MEANS OF ANY DOCUMENT, ANY INTERESTS OTHER THAN (A) TO
"PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS" AS DEFINED IN THE SECURITIES AND FUTURES
ORDINANCE (CAP. 571) OF HONG KONG AND ANY RULES MADE UNDER THAT
ORDINANCE; OR (B) IN OTHER CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH DO NOT RESULT IN THE
DOCUMENT BEING A "PROSPECTUS" AS DEFINED IN THE COMPANIES ORDINANCE (CAP.
32) OF HONG KONG OR WHICH DO NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO THE PUBLIC WITHIN
THE MEANING OF THAT ORDINANCE.
NO PERSON MAY ISSUE, OR HAVE IN ITS POSSESSION FOR THE PURPOSES OF ISSUE,
WHETHER IN HONG KONG OR ELSEWHERE, ANY ADVERTISEMENT, INVITATION OR
DOCUMENT RELATING TO THE INTERESTS, WHICH IS DIRECTED AT, OR THE CONTENTS
OF WHICH ARE LIKELY TO BE ACCESSED OR READ BY, THE PUBLIC IN HONG KONG
(EXCEPT IF PERMITTED TO DO SO UNDER THE SECURITIES LAWS OF HONG KONG) OTHER
THAN WITH RESPECT TO INTERESTS WHICH ARE OR ARE INTENDED TO BE DISPOSED OF
ONLY TO PERSONS OUTSIDE HONG KONG OR ONLY TO "PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS" AS
DEFINED IN THE SECURITIES AND FUTURES ORDINANCE (CAP. 571) OF HONG KONG AND
ANY RULES MADE UNDER THAT ORDINANCE.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF INDIA: THIS SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENT DOES NOT
CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO SELL OR AN OFFER TO BUY INTERESTS FROM ANY PERSON
OTHER THAN THE PERSON TO WHOM THIS SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENT HAS BEEN SENT
BY THE PARTNERSHIP OR ITS AUTHORIZED AGENT. THIS SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENT IS
NOT AND SHOULD NOT BE CONSTRUED AS A PROSPECTUS. THE INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIP ARE NOT BEING OFFERED TO THE PUBLIC FOR SALE OR SUBSCRIPTION
BUT ARE BEING PRIVATELY PLACED WITH A LIMITED NUMBER OF SOPHISTICATED
INVESTORS. PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS MUST SEEK LEGAL ADVICE AS TO WHETHER
THEY ARE ENTITLED TO SUBSCRIBE FOR THE INTERESTS OF THE PARTNERSHIP AND
MUST COMPLY WITH ALL RELEVANT INDIAN LAWS IN THIS RESPECT.
Conlidennal & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-10
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF IRELAND: THIS DOCUMENT AND THE INFORMATION
CONTAINED HEREIN IS CONFIDENTIAL AND HAS BEEN PREPARED AND IS INTENDED FOR
USE ON A CONFIDENTIAL BASIS SOLELY BY THOSE PERSONS IN IRELAND TO WHOM IT
IS SENT BY. IT MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED, REDISTRIBUTED OR PASSED ON TO ANY
OTHER PERSONS OR PUBLISHED IN WHOLE OR IN ANY PART FOR ANY PURPOSE. IT DOES
NOT CONSTITUTE AN INVITATION TO THE PUBLIC IN IRELAND OR ANY SECTION
THEREOF TO SUBSCRIBE FOR OR PURCHASE ANY SHARES OR OTHER SECURITIES IN ANY
COMPANY AND ACCORDINGLY IS NOT A PROSPECTUS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE
PROSPECTUS DIRECTIVE REGULATIONS.
THE OFFER IS BEING EXTENDED TO A SMALL NUMBER OF PERSONS RESIDENT IN THE
REPUBLIC OF IRELAND BY WAY OF A PRIVATE PLACEMENT. NEITHER THIS DOCUMENT
NOR THE OFFER CONSTITUTE AN INVITATION TO THE PUBLIC IN IRELAND OR ANY
SECTION THEREOF TO SUBSCRIBE FOR OR PURCHASE INTERESTS AND ACCORDINGLY
IS NOT A PROSPECTUS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE PROSPECTUS DIRECTIVE
REGULATIONS.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF ISRAEL: THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN APPROVED
BY THE ISRAELI SECURITIES AUTHORITY. THE INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP ARE
BEING OFFERED TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF SOPHISTICATED INVESTORS, IN ALL CASES
UNDER CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WILL FALL WITHIN THE PRIVATE PLACEMENT OR
OTHER EXEMPTIONS SET FORTH IN THE ISRAELI SECURITIES LAW 1968 OR THE JOINT
INVESTMENT TRUST LAW 1994. THIS MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR
USED FOR ANY OTHER PURPOSE NOR BE FURNISHED TO ANY OTHER PERSON OTHER
THAN THOSE TO WHOM COPIES HAVE BEEN SENT. ANY PROSPECTIVE INVESTOR WHO
PURCHASES AN INTEREST IN THE PARTNERSHIP IS PURCHASING SUCH INTEREST FOR
ITS OWN BENEFIT AND ACCOUNT AND NOT WITH THE AIM OR INTENTION OF
DISTRIBUTING OR OFFERING SUCH INTEREST TO OTHER PARTIES. THIS MEMORANDUM
DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN OFFER TO SELL OR THE SOLICITATION OF AN OFFER TO BUY,
IN ISRAEL, TO ANY PERSON TO WHOM IT IS UNLAWFUL TO MAKE SUCH OFFER OR
SOLICITATION IN ISRAEL. NOTHING IN THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD BE CONSIDERED
AS INVESTMENT ADVICE AS DEFINED IN THE ISRAELI REGULATION OF INVESTMENT
ADVICE, INVESTMENT MARKETING AND INVESTMENT PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT LAW
1995.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF JAPAN: NEITHER THE PARTNERSHIP NOR ANY OF ITS
AFFILIATES IS OR WILL BE REGISTERED AS A "FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS FIRM"
PURSUANT TO THE FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS AND EXCHANGE LAW. NEITHER THE
FINANCIAL SERVICES AGENCY OF JAPAN NOR THE KANTO LOCAL FINANCE BUREAU
HAS PASSED UPON THE ACCURACY OR ADEQUACY OF THIS MEMORANDUM OR
OTHERWISE APPROVED OR AUTHORIZED THE OFFERING OF INTERESTS IN THE
PARTNERSHIP TO INVESTORS RESIDENT IN JAPAN. NEITHER THE INTERESTS DESCRIBED
IN THIS MEMORANDUM NOR THE OFFERING THEREOF HAS BEEN DISCLOSED PURSUANT
TO THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE LAW OF JAPAN (LAW NO.25 OF 1948 AS AMENDED). THE
PURCHASER OF AN INTEREST AGREES NOT TO RE-TRANSFER OR RE-ASSIGN SUCH
INTEREST TO ANYONE OTHER THAN NON-RESIDENTS OF JAPAN EXCEPT PURSUANT TO
A PRIVATE PLACEMENT EXEMPTION FROM THE REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS OF,
AND OTHERWISE IN COMPLIANCE WITH, THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE LAW AND OTHER
RELEVANT LAWS AND REGULATIONS OF JAPAN (EXCEPT FOR RE-TRANSFER OR
RE- ASSIGNMENT TO ONE PERSON BY ONE TRANSACTION OF ALL SUCH INTEREST
Coalidcanal & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-1 I
PURCHASED BY SUCH PURCHASER). THE INTERESTS ARE BEING OFFERED TO A LIMITED
NUMBER OF QUALIFIED INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS (TEKIKAKU KIKAN TOSHIKA, AS
DEFINED IN THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE LAW OF JAPAN) AND/OR A SMALL NUMBER OF
INVESTORS, IN ALL CASES UNDER CIRCUMSTANCES THAT WILL FALL WITHIN THE
PRIVATE PLACEMENT EXEMPTION FROM THE REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS OF THE
SECURITIES EXCHANGE LAW AND OTHER RELEVANT LAWS AND REGULATIONS OF
JAPAN. AS SUCH, THE INTERESTS HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED AND WILL NOT BE
REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE LAW OF JAPAN. THIS MEMORANDUM
IS CONFIDENTIAL AND IS INTENDED SOLELY FOR THE USE OF ITS RECIPIENT. ANY
DUPLICATION OR REDISTRIBUTION OF THIS MEMORANDUM IS PROHIBITED. THE
RECIPIENT OF THIS MEMORANDUM, BY ACCEPTING DELIVERY THEREOF, AGREES TO
RETURN IT AND ALL RELATED DOCUMENTS TO THE PLACEMENT AGENT IF THE
RECIPIENT ELECTS NOT TO PURCHASE ANY OF THE INTERESTS OFFERED HEREBY OR IF
EARLIER REQUESTED BY THE PLACEMENT AGENT.
THERE IS A RISK THAT THE CUSTOMER MAY LOSE THE PRINCIPAL AMOUNT HE OR SHE
WILL INVEST AS A RESULT OF FLUCTUATIONS IN THE NET ASSET VALUE OF INTERESTS
IN THE PARTNERSHIP DUE TO CHANGES IN THE PRICES OF SECURITIES OR OTHER
FINANCIAL PRODUCTS HELD BY THE PARTNERSHIP, CHANGES IN FOREIGN EXCHANGE
RATES AND OTHER FACTORS, IF ANY.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF KOREA (SOUTH KOREA): NEITHER THE PARTNERSHIP NOR
ANY OF ITS AFFILIATES IS MAKING ANY REPRESENTATION WITH RESPECT TO THE
ELIGIBILITY OF ANY RECIPIENTS OF THIS MEMORANDUM TO ACQUIRE INTERESTS IN
THE PARTNERSHIP UNDER THE LAWS OF SOUTH KOREA, INCLUDING, BUT WITHOUT
LIMITATION, THE FOREIGN EXCHANGE TRANSACTION ACT AND REGULATIONS
THEREUNDER. THIS MEMORANDUM IS NOT, AND UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES IS TO BE
CONSTRUED AS, A PUBLIC OFFERING OF SECURITIES IN SOUTH KOREA. NEITHER THE
PARTNERSHIP NOR ANY PLACEMENT AGENT MAKE ANY REPRESENTATION WITH
RESPECT TO THE ELIGIBILITY OF ANY RECIPIENTS OF THIS MEMORANDUM TO ACQUIRE
THE INTEREST UNDER THE LAWS OF SOUTH KOREA, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION,
INDIRECT INVESTMENT ASSET MANAGEMENT BUSINESS LAW, THE SECURITIES AND
EXCHANGE ACT AND THE FOREIGN EXCHANGE TRANSACTION ACT AND REGULATIONS
THEREUNDER. THE INTERESTS HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED WITH THE FINANCIAL
SUPERVISORY COMMISSION OF KOREA (THE "FSC") FOR A PUBLIC OFFERING IN SOUTH
KOREA UNDER THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE ACT NOR HAVE THEY BEEN
REGISTERED WITH THE FSC FOR DISTRIBUTION TO NON-QUALIFIED INVESTORS IN
SOUTH KOREA UNDER THE INDIRECT INVESTMENTS ASSET MANAGEMENT BUSINESS
ACT OF KOREA AND NONE OF THE INTERESTS MAY BE OFFERED, SOLD OR DELIVERED,
DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, OR OFFERED OR SOLD TO ANY PERSON FOR RE-OFFERING
OR RE-SALE, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, IN SOUTH KOREA OR TO ANY RESIDENT OF
SOUTH KOREA, EXCEPT PURSUANT TO THE APPLICABLE LAWS AND REGULATIONS OF
SOUTH KOREA.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF KUWAIT: THIS MEMORANDUM AND ANY OTHER OFFERING
MATERIALS, THE PARTNERSHIP AND INTERESTS HAVE NOT BEEN APPROVED OR
LICENSED BY THE MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY OF THE STATE OF KUWAIT.
NOTHING HEREIN CONSTITUTES, NOR SHALL BE DEEMED TO CONSTITUTE, AN
INVITATION OR AN OFFER TO SELL INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP IN KUWAIT NOR IS
INTENDED TO LEAD TO THE CONCLUSION OF ANY CONTRACT OF WHATSOEVER
oalidentual & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-12
NATURE WITHIN KUWAIT. INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP MAY ONLY BE MARKETED
OR SOLD BY A KUWAITI SHAREHOLDING COMPANY WHICH IS PERMITTED TO INVEST
MONIES FOR THE ACCOUNT OF ITSELF AND OF THIRD PARTIES AND WHICH HOLDS A
SPECIFIC LICENSE RELATING TO THE MARKETING AND SALE OF THE INTERESTS ISSUED
BY THE MINISTRY OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRY UNDER LAW NO. 3111990 AND THE
VARIOUS MINISTERIAL ORDERS ISSUED PURSUANT THERETO.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF LIECHTENSTEIN: NO ACTION HAS BEEN TAKEN BY THE
PARTNERSHIP TO PERMIT AN OFFERING OF THE PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS TO THE
PUBLIC IN LIECHTENSTEIN. NO PUBLIC OFFER OF THE INTERESTS OR PUBLIC
DISTRIBUTION OF THIS MEMORANDUM MAY BE MADE IN OR OUT OF LIECHTENSTEIN.
THIS PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REGULATED IN LIECHTENSTEIN. IT IS NEITHER SUBJECT TO
THE INVESTMENT UNDERTAKING ACT OR OF ANY OTHER LAW NOR TO ANY
SUPERVISION OF THE LIECHTENSTEIN FINANCIAL SERVICES AUTHORITY. THE CONTENT
OF THIS MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR USED FOR ANY OTHER PURPOSE,
NOR BE FURNISHED TO ANY OTHER PERSON OTHER THAN THOSE TO WHOM COPIES
HAVE BEEN SENT.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF LUXEMBOURG: THE INTERESTS MAY NOT BE OFFERED OR
SOLD IN THE GRAND -DUCHY OF LUXEMBOURG EXCEPT FOR INTERESTS WHICH ARE
OFFERED IN CIRCUMSTANCES THAT DO NOT REQUIRE THE APPROVAL OF A
PROSPECTUS BY THE LUXEMBOURG FINANCIAL REGULATORY AUTHORITY IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE LAW OF JULY 10, 2005 ON PROSPECTUS FOR SECURITIES. THE
PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REGISTERED AS A FOREIGN FUND WITH THE LUXEMBOURG
REGULATORY AUTHORITIES. INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP ARE BEING OFFERED
ONLY IN DENOMINATIONS PER UNIT OF AT LEAST f50,000. THE COMMISSION DE
SURVEILLANCE DU SECTEUR FINANCIER OF LUXEMBOURG HAS NOT PASSED UPON THE
ACCURACY OR ADEQUACY OF THIS MEMORANDUM OR OTHERWISE APPROVED OR
AUTHORISED THE OFFERING OF INTERESTS TO INVESTORS RESIDENT IN LUXEMBOURG.
THIS MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR USED FOR ANY PURPOSES OTHER
THAN THIS PRIVATE PLACEMENT, NOR PROVIDED TO ANY PERSON OTHER THAN THE
RECIPIENT THEREOF.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF MIDDLE EARTH: MALLATH U-THILIAR, RANDIRATH U-
VISTAR; BRUNATH VILL CJ-FIRIR, HELEG 0-VAB THYND AIND. NAUR O LITH LACHATHA,
GAUL O DAE LABATHA; CRIST RIST PENIATHAR: PEN BEDH-Rt AD ARAN.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF MONACO: THE INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP MAY NOT
BE OFFERED OR SOLD, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, TO THE PUBLIC IN MONACO OTHER
THAN BY A MONACO DULY AUTHORISED INTERMEDIARY ACTING AS A PROFESSIONAL
INSTITUTIONAL INVESTOR WHICH HAS SUCH KNOWLEDGE AND EXPERIENCE IN
FINANCIAL AND BUSINESS MATTERS AS TO BE CAPABLE OF EVALUATING THE RISKS
AND MERITS OF AN INVESTMENT IN THE INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIPS.
CONSEQUENTLY, THIS MEMORANDUM MAY ONLY BE COMMUNICATED TO BANKS
DULY LICENSED BY THE COMTE DES ETABLISSEMENTS DE CREDIT ET DES
ENTREPRISES D'INVESTISSEMENT AND FULLY LICENSED PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT
COMPANIES BY VIRTUE OF LAW N° 1.144 OF 26 JULY 1991 AND LAW 1.194 OF 9 JULY 1997
DULY LICENSED BY THE COMMISSION DE CONTROLE DES ACTIVITES FINANCIERES.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF OMAN: THIS MEMORANDUM AND THE INTERESTS TO
WHICH IT RELATES, MAY NOT BE ADVERTISED, MARKETED, DISTRIBUTED OR
(onlidcntial & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-I3
OTHERWISE MADE AVAILABLE TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC IN OMAN. IN CONNECTION
WITH THE OFFERING OF THE INTERESTS, NO PROSPECTUS HAS BEEN REGISTERED WITH
OR APPROVED BY THE CENTRAL BANK, OF OMAN, THE OMAN MINISTRY OF COMMERCE
AND INDUSTRY, THE OMAN CAPITAL MARKET AUTHORITY OR ANY OTHER
REGULATORY BODY IN THE SULTANATE OF OMAN. THE OFFERING AND SALE OF
INTERESTS DESCRIBED IN THIS MEMORANDUM WILL NOT TAKE PLACE INSIDE OMAN.
INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP ARE BEING OFFERED ON A LIMITED PRIVATE BASIS,
AND DO NOT CONSTITUTE MARKETING, OFFERING OR SALES TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC
OF OMAN.
THIS MEMORANDUM IS BEING SENT AT THE REQUEST OF THE INVESTOR IN OMAN AND
SHOULD NOT BE DISTRIBUTED TO ANY PERSON IN OMAN OTHER THAN ITS INTENDED
RECIPIENT WITHOUT THE PRIOR CONSENT OF THE CONSENT OF THE CAPITAL MARKET
AUTHORITY AND THEN ONLY IN ACCORDANCE WITH ANY TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF
SUCH CONSENT.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF QATAR: INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP HAVE NOT BEEN
OFFERED, SOLD OR DELIVERED, AND WILL NOT BE OFFERED, SOLD OR DELIVERED AT
ANY TIME, DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, IN THE STATE OF QATAR IN A MANNER THAT
WOULD CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC OFFERING. THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN FILED
WITH, APPROVED, REVIEWED OR REGISTERED WITH THE QATARI CENTRAL BANK OR
ANY OTHER RELEVANT QATARI GOVERNMENT AUTHORITIES OR SECURITIES
EXCHANGE AND DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC OFFER OF SECURITIES IN THE STATE
OF QATAR UNDER QATARI LAW. THEREFORE, THIS MEMORANDUM IS STRICTLY
PRIVATE AND CONFIDENTIAL, AND IS BEING ISSUED TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF
SOPHISTICATED INVESTORS AND MAY NEITHER BE REPRODUCED, USED FOR ANY
OTHER PURPOSES, NOR PROVIDED TO ANY PERSON OTHER THAN THE INTENDED
RECIPIENT HEREOF. ALL APPLICATIONS FOR INVESTMENT SHOULD BE RECEIVED, AND
ANY ALLOTMENT MADE, FROM OUTSIDE QATAR.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF RUSSIA: THIS SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENT IS NOT
REGISTERED WITH THE RUSSIAN REGULATOR (FEDERAL SERVICE FOR FINANCIAL
MARKETS) AND INTENDED EXCLUSIVELY FOR THE QUALIFIED INVESTORS (AS DEFINED
IN SECTION 51.2 OF THE FEDERAL LAW NO. 39-FZ OF APRIL 22, 1996 (AS AMENDED), "ON
THE SECURITIES MARKET" AND IN THE ORDER OF THE FEDERAL SERVICE ON
FINANCIAL MARKETS NO. 08-I2/PZ-N OF MARCH 18, 2008). ACCORDINGLY, THE
SECURITIES (FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS) CANNOT BE ADVERTISED OR OTHERWISE
PUBLICLY MARKETED AND/OR OFFERED FOR SALE IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF SAUDI ARABIA: NEITHER THIS MEMORANDUM NOR THE
INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP HAVE BEEN APPROVED, REVIEWED OR PASSED ON IN
ANY WAY BY THE CAPITAL MARKET AUTHORITY OR ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL
AUTHORITY IN THE KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA "SAUDI ARABIA", NOR HAS THE
PARTNERSHIP RECEIVED AUTHORIZATION OR LICENSING FROM THE CAPITAL MARKET
AUTHORITY OR ANY OTHER GOVERNMENTAL AUTHORITY IN SAUDI ARABIA TO
MARKET OR SELL INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP WITHIN SAUDI ARABIA. THE OFFER
AND SALE OF THE INTERESTS WILL ONLY TAKE PLACE WITHIN SAUDI ARABIA IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE CAPITAL MARKET LAW, INCLUDING THE OFFER OF
SECURITIES REGULATIONS ISSUED THEREUNDER. THE INTERESTS WILL BE OFFERED TO
INVESTORS IN SAUDI ARABIA PURSUANT TO AN "EXEMPT OFFER" AS DEFINED IN THE
OFFER OF SECURITIES REGULATIONS. PRIOR TO ANY OFFER OF INTERESTS IN SAUDI
Con lab:float & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A•I4
ARABIA, THE CAPITAL MARKET AUTHORITY WILL BE NOTIFIED OF THIS OFFERING IN
ACCORDANCE WITH THE OFFER OF SECURITIES REGULATIONS. THIS MEMORANDUM
DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AND MAY NOT BE USED FOR THE PURPOSE OF AN OFFER OR
INVITATION. NO SERVICES RELATING TO INTERESTS IN THE PARTNERSHIP, INCLUDING
THE RECEIPT OF APPLICATIONS AND THE ALLOTMENT OR REDEMPTION OF SUCH
INTERESTS, MAY BE RENDERED BY THE PARTNERSHIP WITHIN SAUDI ARABIA.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF SINGAPORE: THIS MEMORANDUM HAS NOT BEEN
REGISTERED AS A PROSPECTUS WITH THE MONETARY AUTHORITY OF SINGAPORE AND
THIS OFFERING IS NOT REGULATED BY ANY FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY
PURSUANT TO ANY LEGISLATION IN SINGAPORE. YOU SHOULD ACCORDINGLY
CONSIDER CAREFULLY WHETHER THE INVESTMENT IS SUITABLE FOR YOU.
THIS MEMORANDUM AND ANY OTHER DOCUMENT OR MATERIAL IN CONNECTION WITH
THE OFFER OR SALE, OR INVITATION FOR SUBSCRIPTION OR PURCHASE, OF INTERESTS
MAY NOT BE CIRCULATED OR DISTRIBUTED, NOR MAY INTERESTS BE OFFERED OR
SOLD, OR BE MADE THE SUBJECT OF AN INVITATION FOR SUBSCRIPTION OR PURCHASE,
WHETHER DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY, TO PERSONS IN SINGAPORE OTHER THAN
INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS (AS DEFINED IN SECTION 4A OF THE SECURITIES AND
FUTURES ACT, CHAPTER 289 OF SINGAPORE (THE "SFA"), ACCREDITED INVESTORS (AS
DEFINED IN SECTION 4A OF THE SFA) OR ANY PERSON PURSUANT TO AN OFFER THAT IS
MADE ON TERMS THAT INTERESTS ARE ACQUIRED AT A CONSIDERATION OF NOT LESS
THAN S$200,000 (OR ITS EQUIVALENT IN A FOREIGN CURRENCY) FOR EACH
TRANSACTION, WHETHER SUCH AMOUNT IS TO BE PAID FOR IN CASH OR BY EXCHANGE
OF SECURITIES OR OTHER ASSETS, UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED BY LAW.
THIS MEMORANDUM IS CONFIDENTIAL. IT IS ADDRESSED SOLELY TO AND IS FOR THE
EXCLUSIVE USE OF THE PERSON TO WHOM IT WAS GIVEN BY THE PARTNERSHIP OR ITS
AFFILIATES. ANY OFFER OR INVITATION IN RESPECT OF INTERESTS IS CAPABLE OF
ACCEPTANCE ONLY BY SUCH PERSON AND IS NOT TRANSFERABLE. THIS
MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE DISTRIBUTED OR GIVEN TO ANY PERSON OTHER THAN
THE PERSON TO WHOM IT WAS GIVEN BY THE PARTNERSHIP OR ITS AFFILIATES AND
SHOULD BE RETURNED IF SUCH PERSON DECIDES NOT TO PURCHASE ANY INTERESTS.
THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD NOT BE REPRODUCED, IN WHOLE OR IN PART.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF SWEDEN: THE FUND IS NOT AUTHORISED UNDER THE
SWEDISH UCITS FUNDS ACT (LAG (2004:46) OM VARDEPAPPERSFONDER) (THE "UCITS
FUNDS ACT") OR THE SWEDISH ACT ON ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FUND MANAGERS
(LAG (2013:561) OM FORVALTARE AV ALTERNATIVA INVESTERINGSFONDER) (THE
"SAIFM ACT") AND IS NOT SUPERVISED BY THE SWEDISH FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY
AUTHORITY (FINANSINSPEKTIONEN). THIS DOCUMENT HAS NOT BEEN, NOR WILL IT BE,
REGISTERED WITH OR APPROVED BY THE SWEDISH FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY
AUTHORITY UNDER THE UCITS FUNDS ACT, THE SAIFM ACT OR THE SWEDISH
FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS TRADING ACT (LAG (1991:980) OM HANDEL MED
FINANSIELLA INSTRUMENT) (THE "TRADING ACT'). ACCORDINGLY, THIS DOCUMENT
MAY NOT BE MADE AVAILABLE, NOR MAY INTERESTS IN THE FUND BE MARKETED AND
OFFERED FOR SALE IN SWEDEN, OTHER THAN UNDER CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH ARE
DEEMED NOT TO REQUIRE A PROSPECTUS, UNDER THE TRADING ACT. NO SINGLE
INVESTOR MAY INVEST AN AMOUNT LESS THAN €100,000. PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS
SHOULD NOT CONSTRUE THE CONTENTS OF THIS DOCUMENT AS INVESTMENT, LEGAL
OR TAX ADVICE. THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN PREPARED FOR INFORMATION PURPOSES
Conlidcntial & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-15
ONLY AND DOES NOT CONSTITUTE INVESTMENT ADVICE. A SWEDISH RECIPIENT OF THE
MEMORANDUM MAY NOT IN ANY WAY FORWARD THE MEMORANDUM TO THE PUBLIC
IN SWEDEN.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF SWITZERLAND: THE FUND HAS NOT BEEN APPROVED BY
THE SWISS FINANCIAL MARKET SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY (FINMA) AS A FOREIGN
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEME PURSUANT TO ARTICLE 120 OF THE SWISS
COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES ACT OF JUNE 23, 2006 (CISA). CONSEQUENTLY,
INTERESTS IN THE FUND MAY NOT BE DISTRIBUTED IN OR FROM SWITZERLAND TO
NON -QUALIFIED INVESTORS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE CISA OR OTHERWISE IN ANY
MANNER THAT WOULD CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC OFFERING WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE
SWISS CODE OF OBLIGATIONS (CO) AND WILL NOT BE LISTED ON THE SIX SWISS
EXCHANGE (SIX) OR ON ANY OTHER STOCK EXCHANGE OR REGULATED TRADING
FACILITY IN SWITZERLAND.
THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN PREPARED WITHOUT REGARD TO THE DISCLOSURE
STANDARDS FOR PROSPECTUSES UNDER THE CISA, ARTICLE 652A OR 1156 CO OR THE
LISTING RULES OF SIX OR ANY OTHER EXCHANGE OR REGULATED TRADING FACILITY
IN SWITZERLAND AND THEREFORE DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A PROSPECTUS WITHIN THE
MEANING OF THE CISA, ARTICLE 652A OR 1156 CO OR THE LISTING RULES OF SIX OR ANY
OTHER EXCHANGE OR REGULATED TRADING FACILITY IN SWITZERLAND. THE
INTERESTS MAY NOT BE PUBLICLY OFFERED (AS SUCH TERM IS DEFINED IN THE CO) IN
SWITZERLAND AND MAY ONLY BE DISTRIBUTED IN OR FROM SWITZERLAND TO
QUALIFIED INVESTORS (AS SUCH TERM IS DEFINED BY THE CISA AND ITS
IMPLEMENTING ORDINANCE). NEITHER THIS DOCUMENT NOR ANY OTHER OFFERING
OR MARKETING MATERIAL RELATING TO THE FUND OR THE INTERESTS MAY BE
DISTRIBUTED TO NON -QUALIFIED INVESTORS WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE CISA IN OR
FROM SWITZERLAND OR MADE AVAILABLE IN SWITZERLAND IN ANY MANNER WHICH
WOULD CONSTITUTE A PUBLIC OFFERING WITHIN THE MEANING OF THE CO AND ALL
OTHER APPLICABLE LAWS AND REGULATIONS IN SWITZERLAND. NEITHER THIS
DOCUMENT NOR ANY OTHER OFFERING OR MARKETING MATERIAL RELATING TO THE
FUND OR THE INTERESTS HAVE BEEN OR WILL BE FILED WITH, OR APPROVED BY, ANY
SWISS REGULATORY AUTHORITY. THE INVESTOR PROTECTION AFFORDED TO
INVESTORS OF INTERESTS IN COLLECTIVE INVESTMENT SCHEMES UNDER THE CISA
DOES NOT EXTEND TO ACQUIRERS OF INTERESTS IN THE FUND.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF TAIWAN, THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA ("TAIWAN"): THE
OFFER OF THE INTERESTS HAS NOT BEEN AND WILL NOT BE REGISTERED WITH THE
FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY COMMISSION OF TAIWAN PURSUANT TO RELEVANT
SECURITIES LAWS AND REGULATIONS OF TAIWAN. NO PERSON OR ENTITY IN TAIWAN
HAS BEEN AUTHORIZED TO OFFER OR SELL THE INTERESTS IN TAIWAN. THE INTERESTS
MAY NOT BE OFFERED, DISTRIBUTED, SOLD OR RESOLD WITHIN TAIWAN THROUGH A
PUBLIC OFFERING OR IN CIRCUMSTANCES WHICH CONSTITUTE AN OFFER WITHIN THE
MEANING OF THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE LAW OF TAIWAN WITHOUT PRIOR
APPROVAL OF THE FINANCIAL SUPERVISORY COMMISSION ("FSC") OF TAIWAN.
PROSPECTIVE INVESTORS WITHIN THE TERRITORY OF THE REPUBLIC OF CHINA ARE
REQUIRED TO MEET CERTAIN REQUIREMENTS SET FORTH IN THE RULES GOVERNING
OFFSHORE FUNDS AND CONDITIONS PROMULGATED BY THE FSC.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF THE NETHERLANDS: THE INTERESTS MAY NOT BE
SOLICITED, ACQUIRED OR OFFERED IN OR FROM THE NETHERLANDS AND THIS
(onlidanlal & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A•I6
MEMORANDUM MAY NOT BE CIRCULATED IN THE NETHERLANDS TO ANY INDIVIDUAL
OR LEGAL ENTITY AS PART OF THEIR INITIAL DISTRIBUTION OR ANYTIME THEREAFTER,
OTHER THAN TO INDIVIDUALS OR LEGAL ENTITIES WHO OR THAT DEAL OR INVEST IN
SECURITIES OR OTHER INVESTMENT ASSETS IN THE COURSE OF THEIR OCCUPATION OR
BUSINESS, INCLUDING BANKS, BROKERS, DEALERS, AND OTHER INSTITUTIONAL
INVESTORS INVESTING IN SECURITIES OR OTHER INVESTMENT ASSETS (HEREINAFTER
REFERRED TO AS "PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS"). IN THE EVENT OF A SOLICITATION,
ACQUISITION OR OFFERING MADE TO OR BY PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS AND,
THEREFORE, EXEMPT FROM THE GENERAL PROHIBITION AS CONTAINED IN THE ACT ON
THE SUPERVISION OF INVESTMENT INSTITUTIONS ("WET TOEZICHT
BELEGGINGSINSTELLINGEN"), NO SUBSEQUENT OFFERING OF THE INTERESTS IN A
"SECONDARY OFFERING" BY SUCH PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS TO INDIVIDUALS OR
ENTITIES OTHER THAN PROFESSIONAL INVESTORS MAY BE MADE.
NOTICE TO RESIDENTS OF THE UNITED ARAB EMIRATES (THE "UAE"): THE
PARTNERSHIP WILL BE SOLD OUTSIDE THE UAE, IS NOT PART OF A PUBLIC OFFERING
AND IS BEING OFFERED TO A LIMITED NUMBER OF INSTITUTIONAL INVESTORS AND
MUST NOT BE PROVIDED TO ANY PERSON OTHER THAN THE ORIGINAL RECIPIENT AND
MAY NOT BE REPRODUCED OR USED FOR ANY OTHER PURPOSE. NEITHER THE
PARTNERSHIP NOR THE INTERESTS HAVE BEEN APPROVED OR LICENSED BY THE UAE
CENTRAL BANK OR ANY OTHER RELEVANT LICENSING AUTHORITIES OR
GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES IN THE UAE. THIS DOCUMENT IS STRICTLY PRIVATE AND
CONFIDENTIAL AND HAS NOT BEEN REVIEWED, DEPOSITED OR REGISTERED WITH ANY
LICENSING AUTHORITY OR GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY IN THE UAE. THIS DOCUMENT
DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AND MAY NOT BE USED FOR THE PURPOSE OF AN OFFER OR
INVITATION. NO SERVICES RELATING TO INTEREST IN THE PARTNERSHIP MAY BE
RENDERED WITHIN THE UAE BY THE PARTNERSHIP. THE PARTNERSHIP MAY NOT BE
OFFERED OR SOLD DIRECTLY OR INDIRECTLY TO THE PUBLIC IN THE UAE. THE ENTITY
CONDUCTING THE PLACEMENT IS NOT A LICENSED BROKER, DEALER OR INVESTMENT
ADVISER UNDER THE LAWS APPLICABLE IN THE UAE, AND IT DOES NOT ADVISE
INDIVIDUALS RESIDENT IN THE UAE AS TO THE APPROPRIATENESS OF INVESTING IN OR
PURCHASING OR SELLING SECURITIES OR OTHER FINANCIAL PRODUCTS. NOTHING
CONTAINED IN THIS MEMORANDUM IS INTENDED TO CONSTITUTE UAE INVESTMENT,
LEGAL, TAX, ACCOUNTING OR OTHER PROFESSIONAL ADVICE. PROSPECTIVE
INVESTORS SHOULD CONSULT WITH AN APPROPRIATE PROFESSIONAL FOR SPECIFIC
ADVICE RENDERED ON THE BASIS OF THEIR SITUATION.
NOTICE TO INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS AND HIGH NET WORTH COMPANIES OF
THE UNITED KINGDOM: THIS MEMORANDUM IS BEING MADE AVAILABLE ONLY TO
PERSONS WHO ARE DEEMED SUFFICIENTLY EXPERT TO UNDERSTAND THE RISKS
INVOLVED IN MAKING AN INVESTMENT IN THE PARTNERSHIP AND AS SUCH FALL
WITHIN ARTICLES 19(5), 47(2), 48(2), 49(2), 50(1) OR 51 OF THE FINANCIAL SERVICES AND
MARKETS ACT 2000 (FINANCIAL PROMOTION) ORDER 2001 OR OTHER RELEVANT
EXEMPTION UNDER WHICH THIS MEMORANDUM MAY LAWFULLY BE COM MUNICATED
AS A FINANCIAL PROMOTION (TOGETHER "EXEMPTIONS").
THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD ONLY BE CONSIDERED AS AN INVITATION OR
INDUCEMENT TO ENTER INTO AN INVESTMENT ACTIVITY BY SUCH PERSONS TO WHOM
SUCH AN INVITATION OR INDUCEMENT MAY LAWFULLY BE SENT UNDER AN
EXEMPTION AND IT IS NOT INTENDED TO BE DISTRIBUTED OR PASSED FOR SUCH
(onlidanlal & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A•I7
PURPOSE TO ANY OTHER PERSONS. IN THE CASE OF ANY PERSON NOT SO FALLING
WITHIN THE SCOPE OF AN EXEMPTION, THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD NOT BE
CONSTRUED AS AN INVITATION OR INDUCEMENT TO ENGAGE IN INVESTMENT
ACTIVITIES, AND ANY SUCH PERSON RECEIVING THIS DOCUMENT SHOULD RESPOND
ONLY BY NOTIFYING THE GENERAL PARTNER THAT HE IS NOT WITHIN ANY EXEMPTION
AND/OR BY RETURNING IT TO THE SENDER UNREAD AND, IN ANY EVENT, SHOULD NOT
ENTER INTO AN INVESTMENT ACTIVITY AS A CONSEQUENCE OF IT.
NOTICE TO CERTIFIED HIGH NET WORTH INDIVIDUALS AND CERTIFIED
SOPHISTICATED INVESTORS OF THE UNITED KINGDOM:
IN THIS PART OF THIS DOCUMENT:

(a) WHENEVER A TERM APPEARS IN "ITALICS", IT HAS THE MEANING AND EFFECT
GIVEN TO IT IN AND BY THE UNITED KINGDOM'S FINANCIAL SERVICES AND
MARKETS ACT 2000 (FSMA);

(b) WHENEVER A TERM APPEARS IN "BOLD ITALICS", IT HAS THE MEANING AND
EFFECT GIVEN TO IT IN AND BY THE FSMA 2000 (FINANCIAL PROMOTIONS)
ORDER; AND

(c) WHENEVER A TERM APPEARS IN "BOLD ITALICS WITH UNDERLING", IT HAS
THE MEANING AND EFFECT GIVEN TO IT IN ANY BY THE UNITED KINGDOM'S
ALTERNATIVE INVESTMENT FUND MANAGERS REGULATIONS (THE
REGULATIONS).
THIS DOCUMENT IS, OR HAS THE POTENTIAL TO BE, A "FINANCIAL PROMOTION".
OUR INTENTION IS TO COMMUNICATE THIS DOCUMENT IN A WAY THAT ENSURES THAT
IT IS DIRECTED SOLELY AT, AND MADE ONLY TO, THOSE PERSONS THAT WE BELIEVE:

(a) WILL RECEIVE IT IN THE UNITED KINGDOM; AND
(b) ARE AT LEAST ONE OF THE FOLLOWING:
i. AN "INVESTMENT PROFESSIONAL"; OR

ii. A "HIGH NET WORTH COMPANY, A HIGH NET WORTH UNINCORPORATED
ASSOCIATION, A HIGH NET WORTH PARTNERSHIP, OR THE TRUSTEE OF A
HIGH VALUE TRUST".
ANY OTHER PERSON WHO RECEIVES A COPY OF THIS DOCUMENT SHOULD RETURN OR
DESTROY IT.
THE INFORMATION CONTAINED IN THIS DOCUMENT IS CONFIDENTIAL AND MUST NOT
BE SHARED, IN WHOLE OR IN PART, WITH ANY OTHER PERSON, EXCEPT FOR THE
PURPOSE OF TAKING PROFESSIONAL ADVICE IN CONNECTION WITH THE INVESTMENTS
DESCRIBED IN THIS DOCUMENT.
THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT A "PROSPECTUS". IT HAS NOT THEREFORE BEEN:

(a) PREPARED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF PART VII OF FSMA,
AND THE HANDBOOK OF RULES AND GUIDANCE MAINTAINED BY THE UNITED
KINGDOM'S FINANCIAL CONDUCT AUTHORITY; AND/OR
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A•IS

(b) SUBMITTED TO, OR SHARED OR REGISTERED WITH, ANY FINANCIAL SERVICES
REGULATOR OR SUPERVISORY AUTHORITY OF ANY KIND.
CONSEQUENTLY, THE INTERESTS IN THE FUND DESCRIBED IN THIS DOCUMENT MAY
NOT BE OFFERED OR SOLD TO THE PUBLIC IN THE UNITED KINGDOM; AND NO
APPLICATION CAN OR WILL BE MADE FOR INTERESTS IN THE FUND TO BE ADMITTED
TO TRADING ON A REGULATED MARKET SITUATED OR OPERATING IN THE UNITED
KINGDOM, OR ANY OTHER COUNTRY.

I. INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS

• THIS DOCUMENT IS DIRECTED AT PERSONS HAVING PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE IN
MATTERS RELATING TO INVESTMENTS; AND ANY INVESTMENT OR "INVESTMENT
ACTIVITY' TO WHICH IT RELATES IS AVAILABLE ONLY TO SUCH PERSONS, AND WILL
BE ENGAGED IN ONLY WITH SUCH PERSONS;

• PERSONS WHO DO NOT HAVE PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE IN MATTERS RELATING
TO INVESTMENTS SHOULD NOT RELY ON THIS DOCUMENT;

• THERE ARE IN PLACE PROPER SYSTEMS AND PROCEDURES TO PREVENT RECIPIENTS
OTHER THAN 'INVESTMENT PROFESSIONALS' ENGAGING IN THE "INVESTMENT
ACTIVITY" TO WHICH THIS DOCUMENT RELATES WITH THE PERSON DIRECTING THE
COMMUNICATION OF THIS DOCUMENT, A "CLOSE RELATIVE" OF HIS OR A MEMBER
OF THE SAME "GROUP'.
II. HIGH NET WORTH COMPANIES, HIGH NET WORTH UNINCORPORATED ASSOCIATIONS,
HIGH NET WORTH PARTNERSHIPS, AND THE TRUSTEES OF HIGH VALUE TRUSTS

• THIS DOCUMENT IS DIRECTED AT "HIGH NET WORTH COMPANIES, HIGH NET WORTH
UNINCORPORATED ASSOCIATIONS, HIGH NET WORTH PARTNERSHIPS, AND THE
TRUSTEES OF HIGH VALUE TRUSTS", AND THE "CONTROLLED INVESTMENTS' AND
"CONTROLLED ACTIVITIES" TO WHICH IT RELATES ARE AVAILABLE ONLY TO SUCH
PERSONS;
• PERSONS OF ANY OTHER DESCRIPTION SHOULD NOT ACT UPON THIS DOCUMENT;
THERE ARE IN PLACE PROPER SYSTEMS AND PROCEDURES TO PREVENT RECIPIENTS
OTHER THAN "HIGH NET WORTH COMPANIES, HIGH NET WORTH UNINCORPORATED
ASSOCIATIONS, HIGH NET WORTH PARTNERSHIPS, AND THE TRUSTEES OF HIGH VALUE
TRUSTS' ENGAGING IN THE "INVESTMENT ACTIVITY' TO WHICH THIS DOCUMENT
RELATES WITH THE PERSON DIRECTING THE COMMUNICATION OF THIS DOCUMENT, A
"CLOSE RELATIVE" OF HIS OR A MEMBER OF THE SAME "GROUP'.
THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD ONLY BE CONSIDERED AS AN INVITATION OR
INDUCEMENT TO ENTER INTO AN INVESTMENT ACTIVITY BY SUCH PERSONS TO WHOM
SUCH AN INVITATION OR INDUCEMENT MAY LAWFULLY BE SENT UNDER AN
EXEMPTION AND IT IS NOT INTENDED TO BE DISTRIBUTED OR PASSED FOR SUCH
Con dentual & Trade Secret
VALAR Private Placement Memorandum A-19
PURPOSE TO ANY OTHER PERSONS. IN THE CASE OF ANY PERSON NOT SO FALLING
WITHIN THE SCOPE OF AN EXEMPTION AS SET OUT IN THE FORM OF CONFIRMATION,
THIS MEMORANDUM SHOULD NOT BE CONSTRUED AS AN INVITATION OR INDUCEMENT
TO ENGAGE IN INVESTMENT ACTIVITIES, AND ANY SUCH PERSON RECEIVING THIS
DOCUMENT SHOULD RESPOND ONLY BY NOTIFYING THE GENERAL PARTNER THAT HE
IS NOT WITHIN ANY EXEMPTION AND/OR BY RETURNING IT TO THE SENDER UNREAD
AND, IN ANY EVENT, SHOULD NOT ENTER INTO AN INVESTMENT ACTIVITY AS A
CONSEQUENCE OF IT.
Confidential & Trade Secret
VALAR
Private Placement Memorandum B-1
APPENDIX B
FUND COMPOSITION AND PERFORMANCE
«intrap,»
Date a4 1001
lil. ~Or
Perom el (096
Curiumwrs Cmi Fair tereuer••
Gras
Matige
Net
Menige'
Gr
110/`
Capita Cmuniamaris 199.951.519
%ne Lid Wel logkei 06.10 314% 1.11.101501 1121262323 1A
TrarederWrie lid Imide6 bei-13 2:22% n1.139195 5252.71608 11.1
appra.L k St» hola Juld 2 116% 513.513.915 511=6.067 0.7
Vod I. »wied Aaldrad Mar- PI t6% 039306 5/.32000 0.9
Item. Lid 116616 St» hola Feb-13 111% 11.1.36392 510709 Ok
Olb« lentommts•• Vrom 5.5% 55305176 590200 I./
Esiarkil Fte. red Enen» .1.9%
FIND I TOTALS 1060% 995.106.667 5111417.518 4.3 34 563%
Dal
(031 <gammelere. S102.21.070
lIrrean Predens Ik' Morriretrk NVV 5015 419% 525490.995 542.21101 1.7
126 (Mei I Bed» Apr.15 11.6% 511.929.971 519616.10E 2.7
K 0o Indam» lek Oh 1)91001 1/07.16 12.1% 511.119.996 516.40.628 IJ
I y rem Luwe! Bed» Apt.15 101% 510396300 511.137.762 IJ
Gemok Ire EaricatoM Aar» 412615 6.1% 560200 56.712.163 1.0
I no Rolomble Ferm_ lere 0.1.4641 1.0-I6 .1.1% 51551000 5155000 IA
I ra» ry; 1 kimt Ia (TraMll I Nor Yort Arm% 3.6% 5309111 51.01163 II
1 »rem 1•9 Sak Late Ok Mm-16 17% 12.719.998 52.753468 IA
eliber 1 ninarnetits•• Viltig", 12% 5809346 510.021254 IJ
Reten el ern Polln. AM- 11%
E 5001 nos and Experms 10.0%
FUND 21107.115 610.0% 9180112/ 5139.511.141 14 IJ 27.9%
Luw
CarMil G:tombak/4 110102500
Ceder iive Rekent. lae. 1560 New York Aup-I6 21.0% =1.109.661 06.535.977 2.1
OcheieLerdeginc. Nor Yort 014 7 12.7% 511120413 513.491152 1.0
OlInear SA5.100» Pars Sep-l6 SA% 11115470 510.596,219 IJ
kik Noirnol. Ia New Vod liiI-17 /II% 5803100 0403900 1.0
126 embh Bet lin Sep-l7 7.1% 17351430 17371376 1.0
Con AG 6ttlin 64.17 6.0% 56.0.425 56.251.125 1.0
nam tensorannt• • 'Geram 13% 52347111 12361.073 Ik
Ren» o1 tor lentsumertn P ollotv-Om 250%
(311111001 Pttrs end Crigme0 100%
FUND 3 TOTALS 14:04114 557.515307 594.716.220 14 1.3 1460%
D11741.
Pikker metenieJ ere unauleieJ mom, »twee- a USO ra «6102017. istlading rIped desk Pui me emeAM »Min in OS.

• • As risd kreek lArtJ ritkin »all luMs and intmirmer varder trunsgAd by Iďalar Vrom» Maeormitati L I. C Dim le kt 6~0 
61 Vater Cd0111 had 2 LP. Air ktSrepre
tesas.
•• • 'Oker lon»temaii tere» te e» minaor mime Vshe's. initiál rag tm» 163 ilun 52.5 »dimt
•• • ••IYfValere <4 all bedingt n emennakd by Gmeral Pon« arxredmx US 6.1.A P ar» remrszere rib pak karexs. Es ried 
posnurris iturted el keu V3I1X.

• raf t•S 21MPda mi welde Pre »04 er km »punter ml kek. ad mi 6040 ne ral:Jake by snlmen6 pm. asesimeFaCabyu Om 25% Gr 
19»óeul nurupeet0
otpitisa and C0 r4
e01T1DENTIAL ANP 1RADE SWRET. NOT POR illt7REIIIORCALA1106.
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Michael Thomas [government] MCC 'guard of interest' at time of Epstein's death, fired 
      Tova Noel [government] MCC 'guard of interest' at time of Epstein's death, fired 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00039153 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons List of Exhibits, Chapter 2
(date: 2019-01-06)
LIST OF EXHIBITS - CHAPTER 2

1. Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) Psychological Reconstruction dated September 17, 2019,
regarding inmate Jeffrey Epstein (previously exhibited in Introduction).

2. Indictment filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York against
Jefferey Epstein, dated July 2, 2019 (previously exhibited in Introduction).

3. Decision and Order Remanding Defendant filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern
District of New York against Jeffrey Epstein, dated July 18, 2019 (previously exhibited in
Introduction).

4. Attorney's Guide to The Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York (MCC New
York), dated April 2008.

5. MCC New York, Daily Assignment Rosters, dated July 22, 2019.
6. Indictment filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York against Tova
Noel and Michael Thomas, dated November 19, 2019.

7. MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute Check Sheet, L-Tier, dated August 9, 2019.
8. MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute Check Sheet, ZA, Tier-G, dated August 10,
2019.

9. Deferred Prosecution Agreement filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of
New York against Tova Noel, dated May 25, 2021.

10. Deferred Prosecution Agreement filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of
New York against Michael Thomas, dated May 25, 2021.

11. Nolle Prosequi filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York against
Tova Noel and Michael Thomas, dated January 3, 2022.

12. 5 C.F.R. Section 2635.101, Basic Obligation of Public Service.
13. 5 C.F.R. Section 2635.705, Use of Official Time.

14. 5 C.F.R. Section 2635.704, Use of Government Property.
15. BOP Program Statement Number 3420.11, Standards of Employee Conduct, dated
December 6, 2013.
U.S. Department of Justice
Office of the Inspector General DATE:
CASE NUMBER: 2019.010614

16. 18 U.S.C.A. Section 1001, Statements or Entries Generally.
17. Bryan v. United States, 524 U.S. 184 (1998).

18. 28 C.F.R. Section 541.21, Special Housing Units (SHUs).
19. BOP Program Statement Number 5270.11, Special Housing Units, dated November 23, 2016.

20. 28 C.F.R. Section 541.22, Status When Placed in the SHU.
21. 28 C.F.R. Section 541.23, Administrative Detention Status.

22. 28 C.F.R. Section 541.27, Protection Case - Placement in Administrative Detention Status.
23. 28 C.F.R. Section 541.32, Medical and Mental Health Care in the SHU.

24. BOP Program Statement Number 5500.14, CN-1, Correctional Service Procedures Manual,
dated August 1, 2016.

25. MCC New York, Specific Post Orders, SHU Number 1, dated December 7, 2018.
26. MCC New York, Specific Post Orders, SHU Number 2, dated December 7, 2018.

27. MCC New York, Special Post Orders, Special Housing Unit, dated December 7, 2018.
28. BOP Program Statement Number 5521.06, Searches of Housing Units, Inmates, and Inmate
Work Areas, dated June 4, 2015.

29. BOP Program Statement Number 7331.04, Pretrial Inmates, dated January 31, 2003.
30. 28 C.F.R. Section 552.40, Purpose and Scope.

31. BOP Program Statement Number P5324.08, Suicide Prevention Program, dated April 5,
2007.
32. MCC New York, Institution Supplement, Suicide Prevention Program, dated May 21, 2013.

33. BOP Program Statement Number 5270.09, Inmate Discipline Program, dated July 8, 2011.
34. BOP Elements of Prohibited Acts, dated November 18, 2020.

35. 28 C.F.R. Section 540.102, Monitoring of Inmate Telephone Calls.
U.S. Department of Justice
Office of the Inspector General DATE:
CASE NUMBER: 2019.010614

36. BOP Program Statement Number P5264.08, Inmate Telephone Regulations, dated January
24, 2008.
37. 28 C.F.R. Section 541.31, Conditions of Confinement in the SHU.

38. BOP Program Statement Number P6360.01, Pharmacy Services, dated January 15, 2005.
39. 28 C.F.R. Section 549.30, Purpose and Scope.

40. BOP Program Statement Number P6541.02, Over-the-Counter Medications, dated
November 17, 2004.
41. MCC New York, Special Post Orders, General Housing Units, dated December 7, 2018.
U.S. Department of Justice
Office of the Inspector General DATE:
CASE NUMBER: 2019.010614
EFTA00270345 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about investigation of Epstein possibly connection to murder of Arthur Shapiro
(inferred date: 2019-01-10)
FD-1057 (Rev. 5-8-10)
(Overall Document Classification Required)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Electronic Communication
Title: (U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF
RE:ARTHUR SHAPIRO
Drafted By: Missing
Case ID #: 72-MM -NEW
Date: 01/10/2019
(U) RODRIGUEZ, ALFREDO - SEE SUB
Details: 72-MM -113327 CJP:c' • The following investigation was
conducted b S•ecial A•ent
Detective Columbus Ohio Police Department,120
Marconi Boulevard, Columbus, Ohio, phone, , was
interviewed telephonically regarding the homicide investigation of
Arthur Shapiro. advised that Shapiro w olumbus attorney
who was killed in the mid-1980's in Columbus. was not one of
the original detectives assigned to the case but came on board in the
mid-1990'S after a city commission was formed to investigate
allegations of misconduct by the city's then police chief. As a result
of the commission's investigation, documents relatin to the Shapiro
homicide were seized from a commander's office. became
involved in the homicide investigation at that time. It was determined
that Shapiro was involved in misconduct and fraudulent business
activity with the firm where he was employed. Specifically, it was
believed Shapiro was helping businessmen purchase coat were
facing bankruptcy and creating illegal tax shelters. believed
Shapiro had been subpoenaed to testify before a federal grand jury
regarding those business activities and was to appear before the grand
jury the day after he was killed. Regarding the circumstances of his
death, Shapiro was seen meeting with an unknown man believed to be the
killer in his vehicle first in a shopping center and then in a
Columbus cemetery. In the cemetery, Shapiro fled from the vehicle to a
nearby condominium complex where he was shot multiple times. Shapiro's
car was later found in the shopping center parking lot. Investigation
revealed that Barry Kessler, a business associate of Shapiro'S, was
seen meeting with a man at Kessler's office fitting the description of
the man seen with Shapiro before he was killed. A secretary of Kessler
saw Kessler meeting with the man in his office with a suitcase or
briefcase of money. Kessler was subsequently convicted of murder for
pecuniary gain in federal court in Florida relating to a life
insurance policy of a business associate. Though no sufficient
evidence to charge Kessler was uncovered, III'''. believed Kessler
was complicit or responsible for Shapiro's death. In the mid-1990'S,
prominent Columbus business man Leslie Wexner's name was published in
on October 26, 2010.
(Overall Document Classification Required)
(Overall Document Classification Required)
Title: (U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF DET JAMES MCCOSKEY RE:ARTHUR SHAPIRO
Re: 72-MM -NEW, 01/10/2019
the local newspaper, alleging some connection to the Shapiro's death.
found no evidence connecting Wexner to the homicide case. In
addition, investigation has revealed no connection between
the homicide of Shapiro and Jeffrey Esptein to date.
.•
(Overall Document Classification Required)
2
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Poplar, Inc. [epstein] Epstein company ownership in Great Saint James Island 
                           Edward Rod Larsen [europe] son of Terje Rød-Larsen 
                       Emma Rød Larsesn [europe] relation of Terje Rød-Larsen 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00098341 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein last will and testament naming Darren Indyke, Richard Kahn as executors
(date: 2019-01-18)
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 2019 TRUST

THIS TRUST AGREEMENT dated January 18, 2019 ("Agreement"), by and among
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, as Grantor (the "Grantor"), and DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD

D. KAHN, as Trustees (the "Trustees").

The Grantor hereby pays over, assigns, grants, conveys, transfers and delivers to the
Trustees the property described in Schedule A annexed hereto and made a part hereof, to be
administered and disposed of as provided in this Agreement, with any additions, changes, or
amendments to this Agreement.

The trust created by this Agreement ("Trust") shall be known as the "The Jeffrey E.
Epstein 2019 Trust". The Grantor hereby expressly revokes The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2018 Trust
previously created by him, and as of the date of execution of this Agreement, The Jeffrey E.
Epstein 2018 Trust shall have no force and effect.

Article I During My Lifetime

The following provisions shall apply during my lifetime:

Section 1.1. - Disbursement of Income
All of the income derived from the property held in this Trust (the "Trust Estate") shall
be paid to me, or accumulated or paid as I may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.2. - Disbursement of Principal
The Trustees may distribute any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate to me as I
may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.3. - Specific Rights Reserved to Me

A. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to amend this
Agreement, in whole or in part, by a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by
me and delivered to no less than one Trustee of this Trust.

B. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, in my sole and
unfettered discretion, to remove any Trustee by delivering to no less than one Trustee of this
Trust a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

C. I reserve the right, at any time, to revoke this Trust in its entirety or, at
any time and from time to time, to revoke any provision hereof by delivering to no less than one
Trustee of this Trust a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

D. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to withdraw or
appoint any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate by delivering to no less than one
Trustee of this Trust a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.
1 GJ 00069
E. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to transfer to the
Trustees, by gift, by Will or by beneficiary designation, such additional property, including life
insurance policies, as I may desire. Any such additional property shall be held on the same terms
as are then applicable to the original Trust Estate, except that it may be transferred subject to
conditions and provisions of special application to such additional property.
Article II  After My Death
The following provisions shall apply after my death:

Section 2.1. - Payment of My Debts and of Taxes and Expenses
The Trustees shall pay from the principal of the Trust Estate (a) my debts, funeral and
burial expenses and the administration expenses of my probate estate which are not paid by the
Executors of my probate estate, and (b) the federal and state estate, inheritance, succession,
generation skipping and similar taxes imposed by reason of my death which are the obligations
of the Trustees (including any of such taxes which the Executors of my probate estate direct the
Trustees to pay by written direction delivered to the Trustees). For purposes of this Section 2.1,
the principal of the Trust Estate shall not include (a) any assets which are not included in my
Gross Estate or (b) any assets which are not subject to, or available to creditors for the payment
of, my debts, my funeral and burial expenses or the administration expenses of my probate
estate.

Section 2.2. — Specific Bequests and Devises under My Will and Trust
If my probate estate is insufficient to satisfy all pecuniary bequests (or bequests payable
in cash or in kind in the discretion of the Executors of my probate estate) provided in my Will,
the Trustees shall pay such unpaid bequests from the principal of the Trust Estate. If my Will
provided for a specific bequest or devise of specified assets and such bequest or devise could
not be satisfied from my probate estate because such assets were held by the Trustees at my
death, the Trustees shall distribute such assets to satisfy such bequest or devise.
To the extent the assets of the Trust are insufficient to satisfy all bequests provided for
in this Agreement, I direct the Trustees to first pay all specific bequests in Article II, Sections
2.3(A)(17), (40), (42), and (45) of this Agreement, and the bequests in Article II, Sections
2.3(A)(41) and (43) of this Agreement, then next to comply with the provisions of Article II,
Sections 2.3(A)(7), (23), (33), (34), (35), (36), (37), and (38) of this Agreement, and to the extent
assets are insufficient to pay all of the remaining bequests in Article II, Section 2.3(A) of this
Agreement, then the beneficiaries of all such remaining bequests in Article II, Section 2.3(A) of
this Agreement shall share on a proportionate basis in the remaining estate assets available for
distribution. The determination of the Trustees as to the amounts distributable herein shall be
binding on all parties.

Section 2.3. - Bequests

A. I make the following bequests:

1. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, an annuity to be purchased by
the Trustees for the benefit of from a reputable financial institution in the
amount of Four Million Dollars ($4,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life
of with a lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance
payable to the estate of upon her death.

2. to <REDACTED> (A/K/A <REDACTED> MARCINKOVA) if she survives me, an annuity to be purchased
by the Trustees for the benefit of <REDACTED>
from a reputable financial institution in the amount of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000), which
annuity shall be payable monthly for the life <REDACTED> of with a lump sum in the
amount of the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of <REDACTED>
upon her death.

3. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, an annuity to be purchased by
the Trustees for the benefit of <REDACTED> from a reputable financial institution in the
amount of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the
life of <REDACTED> with a lump sum the amount of the then remaining principal balance
payable to the estate of <REDACTED> upon her death.

4. to <REDACTED> if she survives to a date one year from the date of
my death, One Hundred Million Dollars ($100,000,000). In addition to said bequest, as soon as
practicable after m death, the Trustees are directed to purchase an annuity for the benefit of
<REDACTED> from a reputable financial institution in the amount of Twenty Million
Dollars ($20,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of
with a lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance payable upon
her death to her arents, if they survive <REDACTED>, and if her parents do not survive
<REDACTED> said lump sum shall payable to the estate of <REDACTED>
upon her death.

5. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, an annuity to be purchased
by the Trustees for the benefit of YULIA <REDACTED> from a reputable financial institution in
the amount of Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the
life of <REDACTED> with a lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal
balance payable to the estate of upon her death.

6. to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, if he survives me, Twenty Million Dollars ($20,000,000).
7. to <REDACTED> FERN SAIPHER, if she is then married to DARREN
KEITH INDYKE, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000), which funds shall be distributed and used
for the sole purpose of repaying FT Real Estate, Inc. the funds it previously paid to KCAC, LLC
in connection with a real estate purchase contract between FT Real Estate, Inc., as purchaser, and
KCAC, LLC, as seller, for the purchase of the real property known as and located at 2 Kean Court
in Livingston, New Jersey, and terminating said real estate purchase contract. It is my express
desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from m estate
the Trustees shall treat said $3,000,000 as having been distributed by the Trust to
3 GJ 00071
IM as the sole member of KCAC, LLC, as then having been repaid by
on behalf of KCAC, LLC to FT Real Estate, Inc. and as then having been
distributed by FT Real Estate, Inc. to the Trust, as the sole shareholder of FT Real Estate, Inc. It
is further my express desire and intention, as the sole shareholder of FT Real Estate, Inc., that
upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, FT Real Estate, Inc. be
directed to cancel and terminate said real estate purchase contract as contemplated herein;
provided, however, that such distribution shall not be made or deemed to have been made and
such termination shall not occur if the transfer of such real property to FT Real Estate, Inc.
pursuant to such real estate purchase contract has been completed prior to my death or if prior to
my death said real estate purchase contract has been terminated or is otherwise no longer in effect.

8. to <REDACTED> <REDACTED> if she survives me an annuity to be
purchased by the Trustees for the benefit of <REDACTED> from a reputable
financial institution in the amount of Two Million Dollars $2,000,000), which annuity shall be
payable monthly for the life of <REDACTED> with a lump sum in the amount of
the then remaining principal balance payable to the estate of upon
her death.

9. to <REDACTED> <REDACTED> if she survives me, an annuity to be purchased
by the Trustees for the benefit of from a reputable financial institution
in the amount of Four Million Dollars ($4,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for
the life of <REDACTED> with a lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal
balance payable to the estate of <REDACTED> upon her death.

10. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, an annuity to be purchased by the
Trustees for the benefit of from a reputable financial institution in the amount
of Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of
with a lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance
payable to the estate of upon her death.

11. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, an annuity to be purchased
by the Trustees for the benefit of <REDACTED> from a reputable financial institution in
the amount of Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the
life of with a lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal
balance payable to the estate of upon her death.

12. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, an annuity to be purchased by the
Trustees for the benefit of from a reputable financial institution in the amount
of Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life of
to the estate of <REDACTED> with a th um in the amount of the then remaining principal balance
payable upon her death.

13. to ANN RODRIQUEZ, if she survives me, an annuity to be purchased by
the Trustees for the benefit of ANN RODRIQUEZ from a reputable financial institution in the
amount of Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000), which annuity shall be payable monthly for the life
of ANN RODRIQUEZ with a lump sum in the amount of the then remaining principal balance
($2,000,000) payable to the estate of ANN RODRIQUEZ upon her death.

14. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).
15. to <REDACTED> <REDACTED> JR., if he survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

16. to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR., if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
17. to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR., or his heirs, successors and assigns,
whether or not LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR. surivives me, all of my interest in the property,
improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and ertainin • to the real .ro.erty located at,
and known and referred to as, . My interest
consists of 100% of the issued and outstanding Membership Interests in Lyn & Jojo, LLC, a New
York limited liability company which holds legal title to said real property, improvements,
fixtures, permits and other rights, which Membership Interests are held in the name of Darren K.
Indyke, as nominee for me, and which I direct the Trustees to transfer to LUCIANO A.
FONTANILLA, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns.

18. to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, if he survives me, Twenty Million Dollars ($20,000,000).
19. to VALDSON VIERA CONTRIN, if he survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

20. to CARLUZ N. TOYLO, if he survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars $(500,000)
21. to ARLINE M. TOYLO, if she survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000).

22. to LOUELLA E. RABUYO, if she survives me, Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000).
23. whether or not LOUELLA E. RABUYO survives me, to LOUELLA E.
RABUYO, or her heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the total outstanding debt,
including, without limitation, all principal and all accrued and unpaid interest thereon, due from
LOUELLA E. RABUYO to FT Real Estate, Inc. to be used sole for the purpose of repaying said
principal and interest in full. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and the
receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the full amount of said
outstanding debt, including, without limitation, all principal and accrued and unpaid interest
thereon, as having been distributed by the Trust to LOUELLA E. RABUYO, or her heirs,
successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding debt and
accrued but unpaid interest, as then having been repaid by LOUELLA E. RABUYO to FT Real
Estate, Inc., and then as having been distributed to the Trust as the sole shareholder of FT Real
Estate, Inc.

24. to MERWIN DELA CRUZ, if he survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000).
25. to BELLA KLEIN, if she survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000).

26. to <REDACTED>, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
27. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

28. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).
29. to EDWARD ROED LARSEN, if he survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

30. to EMMA ROED LARSEN, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).
31. to MARTIN NOWACK, if he survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

32. to LEO LOKING, if he survives me, Five Hundred Thousand Dollars ($500,000.00).

33. I forgive any loans which I made to the following individuals or entities:

a) LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR.
b) <REDACTED>
c) <REDACTED> (A/K/A <REDACTED>)
d) <REDACTED> (A/K/A <REDACTED> A/K/A <REDACTED>)

e) <REDACTED><REDACTED>
g) <REDACTED>
h) <REDACTED>
i) <REDACTED>
k) <REDACTED>
l) <REDACTED>
m) <REDACTED> KEITA

n) PAUL CRASSNER
o) DAVID MITCHELL
p) LAWRENCE BRUCE DELSON and <REDACTED>, jointly and severally
q) MARK LLOYD

r) <REDACTED>
s) <REDACTED>
t) <REDACTED>
u) <REDACTED>
v) <REDACTED>
y) <REDACTED>
z) <REDACTED>
aa) <REDACTED>
bb) <REDACTED>
cc) <REDACTED>
dd) NLR VENTURES, LLC
ee) SLK DESIGNS, LLC
ff) JSC INTERIORS, LW

34 Upon my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to DARREN KEITH
INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial
obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Vir in Islands limited liability
company, from DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, EIMI, if she
is then married to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation, limited liability
company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by
one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Harlequin
Dane, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be
distributed to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole
purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my
express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from
my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial obligations and liabilities as
having been distributed by the Trust to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or
assigns, and as then having been repaid by DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors
or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due to me, or any
corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me
immediately prior to my death, includin but not limited to Southern Financial, LLC, from
DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, a, if she is then married
to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited
partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both of them
immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Harlequin Dane, LLC, or its
successor entities.
35 Upon my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to RICHARD DAVID
KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations
and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company,
trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not
limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company, from
RICHARD DAVID KAHN, his spouse, LISA KAHN, if she is then married to RICHARD
DAVID KAHN, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general
partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior
to my death, including, but not limited to, Coatue Enterprises, LLC, a New York limited liability
company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be distributed to RICHARD DAVID KAHN,
or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such
outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon
my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the
total sum of all such financial obligations and liabilities as having been distributed by the Trust
to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid
by RICHARD DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of
all such liabilities and obligations due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust,
or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not
limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from RICHARD DAVID KAHN, his spouse, LISA
8 GJ 00076
KAHN, if she is then married to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, and/or any corporation, limited
liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially
owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to,
Coatue Enterprises, LLC, or its successor entities.
36 Upon my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to PAUL BARRETT,
or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations and
liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust,
or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not
limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company, from PAUL
BARRETT, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general
partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by him immediately prior to my death,
including, without limitation, Osborne Lane Capital, LLC, a New York limited liability
company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be distributed to PAUL BARRETT, or his
heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and
due obligations and liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and the
receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such
financial obligations and liabilities as having been distributed by the Trust to PAUL BARRETT,
or his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid by PAUL BARRETT, or his
heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due
to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by
me immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from
PAUL BARRETT, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership,
general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by him immediately prior to my
death, including, but not limited to, Osborne Lane Capital, LLC, or its successor entities.
37 Upon my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to
, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all
financial obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited
liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to Southern Financial, LLCa U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability
company, from MEM JR., EILEEN VISOSKI, if she is
then married to , JR., and/or both of them jointly, and/or any
corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other
entity beneficially owned b one or both of them immediately prior to my death. Said funds
shall be distributed to , JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns,
for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and
liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust
of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial obligations
and liabilities as having been distributed by the Trust to JR.
his heirs successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid by
, JR, or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such liabilities
and obligations due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity
beneficially owned by me immediate! prior tom death includin but not limited to Southern
Financial, LLC, from , JR., EILEEN , and/or
both of them jointly, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership,
9 GJ 00077
general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately
prior to my death.
38 U n my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to each of
, LOUELLA E. RABUYO, BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ,
, and MERWIN DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or assigns, an
amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due from
her or him to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially
owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Southern Financial,
LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company, and FT Real Estate
Islands corporation. Said funds shall be distributed to each of IMMI Inc. a
U.S.
LOUELLA E. RABUYO, BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ, DAVID ROGERS, and
MERWIN DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being
used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my express desire
and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the
Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial obli ations and liabilities as having been
distributed by the Trust to each of , LOUELLA E. RABUYO,
BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ, DAVID ROGERS, and MERWIN DELA CRUZor her
or his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid by each of
, LOUELLA E. RABUYO, BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ,
, and MERWIN DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or assigns, to
the Trust in repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due from her or him to me, or any
corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me
immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC and FT
Real Estate, Inc.
39 It is my express desire and intention that all amounts due and owing to me
by the persons listed in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(33) of this Agreement shall be cancelled upon
my death. While at the date of execution of this Amendment, the cancellation of said loans will
not result in taxable income to any such persons, in the event any changes are made to the
applicable tax law, the Trustees are directed to take any and all steps necessary to ensure that the
cancellation of such indebtedness does not result in any negative tax consequences to such
persons. In that regard, as necessary, all such amounts due and owing to me by the persons
enumerated in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(33) of this Agreement may be deemed to have been
distributed by the Trust to such persons and repaid by such persons to the Trust. It is also my
express desire and intention that all financial obligations and liabilities enumerated in Article II,
Sections 2.3(A)(7), (23), (33), (34), (35), (36), (37) and (38) of this Agreement shall be deemed
to be terminated upon my death, and that such termination shall not result in taxable income to
any of the Beneficiaries enumerated in such Sections, and the Trustees are directed to take any
and all steps necessary to ensure that the termination of such obligations and liabilities does not
result in any negative tax consequences to such Beneficiaries.
40 I give to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement, all of my
interest in the property, leases, rights • ermits im • rovements and fixtures comprising and
pertaining to Zorro Ranch, located at . My interest
consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Cypress, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands
10 GJ 00078
corporation, which holds legal title to the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the
"New Mexico Property". In addition, I give to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in
a separate trust, the provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement,
all of my interest in the property, rights, permits, improvements and fixtures comprising and
pertaining to the island known as Little St. James, located in the U.S. Virgin Islands. My interest
consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Nautilus, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands
corporation, which holds legal title to the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the
"LSJ Property". In addition, I give to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in a separate
trust, the provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement, all of my
interest in the property, rights, permits, improvements and fixtures comprising and pertaining to
the island known as Great St. James, located in the U.S. Virgin Islands. My interest consists of
10,000 shares of common stock of Poplar, Inc. a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which
holds all of the membership interests of Great St. Jim, LLC, a United States Virgin Islands
limited liability company, which holds legal title to said property, rights, permits, improvements
and fixtures comprising and pertaining to the said island known as Great St. James. Such interest
is hereinafter referred to as the "GSJ Property".
41 I give to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.2 of this Agreement, the sum of Ten
Million Dollars ($10,000,000) to pay for the operating expenses of the New Mexico Property,
the LSJ Property and the GSJ Property. Operating expenses shall include, but not be limited to,
property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities, general maintenance and repairs and common
charges.
42 I give to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in a separate trust, the
provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement, all of my interest
in all apartments, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and ertaining to the
remises located in the building known and referred to aris. France.
. The units are currently all owned by
SCI JEP, a French company of which I own 999 of the 1,000 outstanclii,ares. Such interest
is hereinafter referred to as the "Paris Property". In addition, I give to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in a separate
trust, the provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section
3.1 of this Agreement, all of my interest in the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and
other rights of and pertaining to the real property located at, and known and referred to asall
My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of
Laurel, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which holds le al title to the same. Such
interest is hereinafter referred to as the "Florida Property". If does not
survive me, I give to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in a separate trust, the
provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement, all of my interest
in the Paris Property and all of my interest in the Florida Property.
43 I give to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, in a separate trust, the
provisions of which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.2 of this Agreement, the sum of Ten
Million Dollars ($10 000  for the operating expenses of the Paris Property and the
Florida Property. If does not survive me, I give to CELINA EDITH
11 GJ 00079
DUBIN, if she survives me, in a separate trust, the provisions of which are set forth in Article
III, Section 3.2 of this Agreement, the sum of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000) to pay for the
operating expenses of the Paris Property and the Florida Property. Operating expenses shall
include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general
maintenance and repairs.
44 If and at such time or times as the Trustees shall determine in their sole and
absolute discretion that it would be beneficial for theprotection of the exclusive and unimpeded
right to the use and enjoyment by of the outright distribution which
pursuant to the rovisions of Section 2.3(A)(4) of this Article II is to be made directly to
, then notwithstanding the rovision of this Agreement directing the
Trustees to make such distribution directly to the Trustees shall be
authorized to make such distribution in Trust for the benefit of . With
respect to any such distribution placed in trust pursuant to the provisions of this Section
2.3(A)(44) of this Article II, said trust shall be administered in accordance with the provisions
of Article III, Section 3.4 of this Agreement.
45 I give if she survives me, all of my interest
in the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other ri hts of andpertaining to the real
property located at, and known and referred to as . My
interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of Maple, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands
corporation, which holds legal title to the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the
"New York Property".

Section 2.4. - Balance of Trust Estate
The balance of the Trust Estate, after the distributions provided in Article II, Sections 2.1, 2.2 and
2.3 of this Agreement, shall be distributed as follows:

A. One Hundred percent (100%) thereof to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives me, in separate trust, the provisions of 
which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.3 of
this Agreement.

B. If CELINA EDITH DUBIN does not survive me, one hundred percent
thereof tcl , if she survives me.
C. I does not survive me, one hundred percent
(100%) of the balance of the trust estate shall be transferred to the persons listed on Schedule B
to this Agreement in accordance with directions provided in Schedule B to this Agreement,
which Schedule B may be amended by me at any time and from time to time during my lifetime.

Section 2.5. — Condition Applicable to Certain Bequests
A. Except as expressly provided herein, no bequest to any Beneficiary of this
Agreement who, during my lifetime, was employed by or provided services to me or any entity
12 GJ 00080
that was owned directly or indirectly by me during my lifetime or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any
entity owned by Darren K. Indyke, shall be distributed to said Beneficiary prior to the expiration
of two years following the date of my death. Any Beneficiary of this Agreement who, during my
lifetime, was employed by or provided services to me or any entity that was owned directly or
indirectly by me during my lifetime or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K.
Indyke, and who, after my death, shall voluntarily discontinue, or as a result of said Beneficiary's
misconduct, cause to be terminated, said Beneficiary's employment with or provision of services
to my estate or any entity or parcel of real property directly or indirectly owned by me during my
lifetime or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K. Indyke, prior to the
expiration of two years following the date of my death, shall be ineligible to receive any bequest
hereunder; provided, however, that in the event that prior to the expiration of two years following
the date of my death, there is a cessation in the specific operations of my estate or said real
property or entity or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K. Indyke, in respect
of which said Beneficiary is employed or provides services, and prior to that cessation, said
Beneficiary had not voluntarily discontinued, or as a result of said Beneficiary's misconduct,
caused to be terminated, said Beneficiary's employment with or provision of services to my estate
or said real property or entity or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K. Indyke,
then the Trustees shall distribute the bequest hereunder to said Beneficiary within sixty days
following the date of such cessation or as soon as is reasonably practicable thereafter.

B. In order to provide for the continued and uninterrupted maintenance and
operation of the assets in my Trust Estate following my death, the Trustees shall ensure that all
persons who were employed by, or provided services to, me or any entity directly or indirectly
owned by me or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K. Indyke, shall continue
to be so employed or to so provide such services for a period of two (2) years following the date
of my death; provided, however, that the Trustees shall have the right terminate the employment
or the engagement of any such employees or service providers if and at such times as the Trustees
determine in their discretion that there is cause for such termination. For purposes of this Section
2.5 of this Article II, cause for such termination shall include, without limitation, physical or
mental incapacity, intentional misconduct, insubordination, breach of duty, disloyalty,
dishonesty, fraud, embezzlement, theft, abusive or inappropriate workplace behavior, substance
abuse, criminal misconduct (whether or not pertaining to the assets in the Trust Estate), decrease
or cessation of the need for employment or services, or any other circumstances causing the
Trustees to determine in their discretion that there is cause for such termination. The obligation
of the Trustees to ensure such continued employment or provision of services shall include,
without limitation, payment out of the assets of the Trust Estate for the costs and expenses of all
items of compensation, remuneration and benefits as shall then be in effect at the then current
rates and in the then current amounts immediately prior to my death.

C. The provisions of this Section 2.5 of this Article II shall not apply to the
Trustees so long as they continue to serve as the Trustees hereunder.

D. The provisions of this Section 2.5 of this Article II shall not apply to the
provisions of Article II, Sections 2.3(A)(7), (17), (23), (33), (34), (35), (36), (37), (38) and (39)
of this Agreement.
$ection 2.6. - Trust Provertv that Is Real ProDerW
13 GJ 00081
Except for property held in trust for or CELINA EDITH DUBIN in
accordance with the provisions of Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement, any trust property
that is real property, including, but not limited to, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights
of and pertaining to such real property, held directly by me, or indirectly through ownership of
shares of capital stock of a corporation or membership interests in a limited liability company of
which I was the sole beneficial owner prior to my death, shall be sold by the Trustees and the
proceeds thereof held in said trust as soon as is reasonably practicable following my death. In
marketing and effectuating the sale of said real property, the Trustees shall be guided as nearly
as the Trustees determine in their discretion is possible or appropriate under the then prevailing
circumstances by my last express wishes with respect to the sale of said real property, as shall be
contained in the last writing signed by me and notarized and delivered to at least one of the
Trustees prior to my death.
Article III irust Provisioas

Section 3.1. - Residence Trust
Any property directed to be held in trust for a Beneficiary in accordance with the provisions of
this Section 3.1 of this Article III shall be administered as follows:

A. DARREN IC. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees
of the trust administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.1 of this Article Ill.

B. The Beneficiary shall have the right to personally use and occupy the
residence held by the trust and to personally use the tangible personal property located in the
residence for her lifetime. The Beneficiary may not sell, assign, transfer, lease, encumber or
otherwise dispose of all or any of such rights, and the Trustees may take any and all action in
their sole discretion as they deem appropriate to ensure that no such sale, assignment, transfer,
lease, encumbrance or other disposition shall occur.

C. The Trustees, in the Trustees' sole discretion, may pay any part or all of
the income, and if income is insufficient, the principal of the trust (1) to pay the operating
expenses of the property held by the trust and (2) for any other purpose the Trustees consider
advisable. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal of the trust.

D. U n the death of KARYNA
to the rovisions of this Section 3.1 to
the Trustees shall distribute the
property held in trust for pursuant
CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she survives , in a separate trust, to be
administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.1 of this Article III.

E. Upon the death of CELINA EDITH DUBIN, and, in the event that
CELINA EDITH DUBIN does not survive , upon the death of
the Trustees shall use their best efforts to sell any and all property that is real
property, including, but not limited to, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and
pertaining to such real property, held in trust, directly or indirectly through ownership of shares
of capital stock of a corporation or membership interests in a limited liability company, for the
14 GJ 00082
benefit of said decedent pursuant to the provisions of this Section 3.1 of this Article HI, and all
tangible personal property associated with said real property, within two (2) years following
said decedent's death, and only in extraordinary circumstances should the property not be sold
within two (2) years following said decedent's death.
Promptly following the sale of said real property and tangible personal
property as provided in Article III Section 3.1E of this A reement, the Trustees shall
distribute the roceeds of such sale t , if she is then surviving. If
is not then surviving, then the Trustees shall distribute the
remaining principal and income to the persons listed on Schedule B to this Agreement in
accordance with directions provided in Schedule B to this Agreement, which Schedule B may
be amended by me at any time and from time to time during my lifetime.

G. Neither nor CELINA EDITH DUBIN may sell,
assign, transfer, lease, encumber or otherwise dispose of all or any part of her interests as a
beneficiary of any trust created pursuant to this Agreement, and the Trustees may take any and
all action in their sole discretion as they deem appropriate to ensure that no such sale,
assignment, transfer, encumbrance or other disposition shall occur.

Section 3.2. — Trust for Operating Expenses of the Real Properties

A. All sums directed to be held in mist for in
accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.2 of this Article III shall be administered as
follows:

1. DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees
of the trust administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.2(A)
of this Article III.

2. Unless and until such trust terminates as provided in Article III, Section
3.2(A)(5) of this Agreement, the Trustees may, in their discretion, apply at any
time and from time to time any part or all of the income of such trust and such
sums from any part or all of the principal of such trust to the payment of any and
all operating expenses for either or both of the Paris Property and the Florida
Property.

3. For purposes of this Section 3.2(A) of this Article DI, "operating
expenses" shall include, but not be limited to, all expenses that the Trustees, in
their discretion, determine are required or appropriate in order to pay property
insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general maintenance and repairs for the
said properties.

4. For the sake of clarity, the Trustees shall not be required to pay from the
income or principal of such trust any o ratio ex enses for any property that,
although held in trust for the benefit of in accordance with
the provisions of Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement, is not personally used
15 GJ 00083
and occupied by

5. Promptly following the sale of the property held in trust in accordance
with the  of Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement after the death
of the trust for her benefit under the provisions of this

Section 3.2(A) of this Article III shall terminate, no further payments shall be
made from the income or principal of such trust other than for operating expenses
that accrued prior to the date of such event, and the Trustees shall distribute all
principal and income then remaining in such trust pursuant to the provisions of
Article III, Section 3.2(AX6) of this Agreement.

6. Upon the termination of the trust as provided in Article Ill, Section
3.2(A)(5) of this Agreement, the Trustees shall distribute 100% the remaining
principal and income of such trust to CELINA EDITH DUBIN, if she is then
surviving, in a separate trust administered in accordance with the provisions of
Article III, Section 3.2(B) of this Agreement to be used to pay for the operating
expenses of the Paris Property and the Florida Property. If CELINA EDITH
DUBIN is not then surviving, then the Trustees shall distribute 100% the
remaining principal and income of such trust to , if
she is then surviving. I is not then surviving, then
the Trustees shall distribute 100% of the remaining principal and income of such
trust to the persons listed on Schedule B to this Agreement in accordance with
directions provided in Schedule B to this Agreement, which Schedule B may be
amended by me at any time and from time to time during my lifetime.

B. All sums directed to be held in trust for CELINA EDITH DUBIN in
accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.2 of this Article III shall be administered as
follows:

1. DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees
of the trust administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.2(B)
of this Article III.

2. With respect to the trust, if any, created for the benefit of CELINA
EDITH DUBIN pursuant to the provisions of Article II, Section 2.3(A)(41) of
this Agreement, unless and until such trust terminates as provided in Section
Article III, 3.2(B)(5) of this Agreement, the Trustees may, in their discretion,
apply at any time and from time to time any part or all of the income of such trust
and such sums from any part or all of the principal of such trust to the payment
of any and all operating expenses for any or all of the New Mexico Property, the
LSJ Property and the GSJ Property. With respect to the trust, if any, created for
the benefit of CELINA EDITH DUBIN pursuant to the provisions of Article II,

Section 2.3(A)(43) of this Agreement, unless and until such trust terminates as
provided in Article III, Section 3.2(B)(5) of this Agreement, the Trustees may,
in their discretion, apply at any time and from time to time any part or all of the
income of such trust and such sums from any part or all of the principal of such
trust to the payment of any and all operating expenses for any or all of the Paris
16 GJ 00084
Pro err and the Florida Property. In the event of the death of
and the transfer, pursuant to Article HI, Section 3.2(A)(6) of this
Agreement, to CELINA EDITH DUBIN in trust of all principal and income of
the trust held for the benefit of in accordance with the
provisions of Article III, Section 3.2(A) of this Agreement, unless and until such
trust terminates as provided in Article III, Section 3.2(B)(5) of this Agreement,
the Trustees may, in their discretion, apply at any time and from time to time any
part or all of such income of such trust so transferred and such sums from any
part or all of such principal of such trust so transferred to the payment of any and
all operating expenses for either or both of the Paris Property and the Florida
Property.

3. For purposes of this Section 3.2(B) of this Article III, "operating
expenses" shall include, but not be limited to, all expenses that the Trustees, in
their discretion, determine are required or appropriate in order to pay property
insurance, real estate taxes, utilities and general maintenance and repairs for the
said properties.

4. For the sake of clarity, the Trustees shall not be required to pay from the
income or principal of such trust any operating expenses for any property that,
although held in trust for the benefit of CELINA EDITH DUBIN in accordance
with the provisions of Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement, is not personally
used and occupied by CELINA EDITH DUBIN.

5. Promptly following the sale of the property held in trust in accordance
with the provisions of Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement after the death
of CELINA EDITH DUBIN, the trust for her benefit under the provisions of this

Section 3.2(B) of this Article III shall terminate, no further payments shall be
made from the income or principal of such trust other than for operating expenses
that accrued prior to the date of such event, and the Trustees shall distribute all
principal and income then remaining in such trust pursuant to the provisions of
Article III, Section 3.2(BX6) of this Agreement.

6. Upon the termination of the trust as provided in Article III, Section
3.2(B)(5) of this Agreement, the Trustees shall distribute 100% the remaining
principal and income of such trust to , if she is then
surviving. If is not then surviving, then the
Trustees shall distribute 100% of the remaining principal and income of such
trust to the persons listed on Schedule B to this Agreement in accordance with
directions provided in Schedule B to this Agreement, which Schedule B may be
amended by me at any time and from time to time during my lifetime.

Section 3.3. - Residuary Trust
Any property directed to be held in trust for CELINA EDITH DUBIN in accordance
17 GJ 00085
with the provisions of this Section 3.3 of this Article III shall be administered as follows:

A. DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees of
the trust administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.3 of this Article III.

B. The Trustees may pay any part or all of the income and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of the trust as the Trustees, in the Trustees' discretion, from time
to time and at any time, shall determine for any reason whatsoever to, for the benefit of, or on
behalf of CELINA EDITH DUBIN. Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the
principal of the trust.

C. Upon the death of the CELINA EDITH DUBIN the Trustees shall
distribute the remaining principal and income of the trust to , if she
then survives CELINA EDITH DUBIN. If does not survive the
CELINA EDITH DUBIN, then the Trustees shall distribute the remaining principal and income
of the trust to the persons listed on Schedule B to this Agreement in accordance with directions
provided in Schedule B to this Agreement, which Schedule B may be amended by me at any
time and from time to time during my lifetime.

Section 3.4. — Trust for the Benefit of.
Any property directed to be held in trust for in accordance with
the provisions of this Section 3.4 of this Article Ill shall be administered as follows:

A. DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees of
the trust administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.4 of this Article III.

B. The Trustees may pay any part or all of the income and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of the trust as the Trustees, in the Trustees' discretion, from time
to time and at any time shall determine for any reason whatsoever to, for the benefit of, or on
behalf of KARYNA . Any income not so paid shall annually be added to the principal
of the trust.
C. Upon the death of the , the Trustees shall distribute
the remaininprincipal and income of the trust to CELINA EDITH DUBIN if she survives,
. If CELINA EDITH DUBIN does not survive
then the Trustees shall distribute the remainin rinci al and income of the trust to
if she survives . If
does not survive , then the Trustees shall distribute the remaining
principal and income of the trust to the persons listed on Schedule B to this Agreement in
accordance with directions provided in Schedule B to this Agreement, which Schedule 13 may
be amended by me at any time and from time to time during my lifetime.
Article IV Trust Terminatiou
If at any time the Trustees determine that it is uneconomic to continue any trust with
respect to which the Trustees are acting hereunder, the Trustees may terminate such trust and
18 GJ_00086
distribute the trust assets, in such amounts and proportions as the Trustees may determine, to
the person or persons to whom income may be distributed, other than the Trustees, members of
the respective families of the Trustees, the respective estates of the Trustees, the respective
creditors of the Trustees or the creditors of the respective estates of the Trustees.
Article V  Trust Administration

Section 5.1. - Exercise of Discretionary Powers
Except as hereinbefore specifically provided, in connection with the exercise of a
discretionary power to distribute income or principal to any person, there shall be no
requirement to take into account such person's other income or capital resources, the interest of
such person in any other fund or the duty of anyone to support such person, although these
factors may be taken into account.

Section 5.2. - Discretionary Distributions
Any discretionary payment from any trust hereunder shall be charged against such trust
as a whole, and shall not be charged against the individual share of any person at any time.

Section 5.3. - Allocation of Assets

A. For each distribution, partial distribution, allocation, or division of assets
into shares or trusts involving a fraction, the Trustees shall apply such fraction to the fair market
value of the relevant assets on the date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever
first occurs. The Trustees shall appropriately adjust such fractions to reflect the effect of any
partial distributions, allocations, or divisions, taking into account the fair market value as of the
date of distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurred, of the assets so distributed,
allocated, or divided.

B. The Trustees shall value any assets distributed, allocated, or divided to
satisfy (in whole or in part) a pecuniary distribution at the fair market value of such assets on
the date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurs.

Section 5.4. - Accounting Allocations

A. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement and except
as provided in Paragraph B of this Section 5.4, the Trustees shall allocate receipts and
disbursements in accordance with sound trust accounting principles and have discretion to
allocate receipts and disbursements when, in the judgment of the Trustees, the treatment is
uncertain under applicable laws or generally accepted accounting principles.
B. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, the Trustees
shall not treat any part of the principal amount of the proceeds of sale of any asset of any trust
as income distributable to or for the benefit of any beneficiary entitled to distributions of income;
provided, however, that the Trustees shall treat a portion of any proceeds of sale of any financial
instrument originally issued or acquired at a discount equal to the amount which (1) has
19 GJ 00087
previously been characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes or (2) will be
characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes in the year of such sale, as income for
trust accounting purposes.

Section 5.5. - Spendthrift Provision
During the term of any trust hereunder, no money or other assets (either principal or
income) payable or distributable under the provisions of this Agreement shall be pledged,
assigned, transferred, given, conveyed, hypothecated, sold, anticipated, charged, or encumbered
by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder, nor shall the income and principal of any trust, while in
the possession of the Trustees, be liable for any debts, contracts, obligations, or undertakings of
such Beneficiaries, voluntary or involuntary, or for any claims or judgments against any
Beneficiary, including claims for alimony or for the support of any Beneficiary's spouse or
children, or for reimbursement of a federal, state or local government, or any agency of any
federal, state, or local government, for the support of any Beneficiary hereunder, prior to the
time such money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary. Any attempted
pledge, assignment, transfer, gift, conveyance, hypothecation, anticipation, charge, or
encumbrance of any money or assets (either income or principal) payable or distributable under
the provisions of this Agreement by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder prior to the time such
money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary shall be null and void and
shall not be recognized by the Trustees. This Section 5.5 of this Article V shall not apply to me.

Section 5.6. - Limitation on Distributions
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, no discretionary distribution of
income or principal of any trust hereunder shall be applied to pay for medical care, residential
facilities, or any other care or service that would otherwise be provided for any Beneficiary
hereunder by any federal, state, or other governmental agency; and no such discretionary
distribution of income or principal shall be made for reimbursement for any such care, facilities
or services previously provided. Before making any discretionary payment to or for the benefit
of any such Beneficiary hereunder, the Trustees shall consider the amounts such Beneficiary is
or may be entitled to receive from any governmental agency for such care, facilities, or services.
If such amounts are available, discretionary distributions of income and principal from any trust
hereunder shall be made only to supplement such amounts, and to provide liberally for needs
and comforts over and above the basic maintenance, support, and medical care that may be paid
for by any such agency.

Section 5.7. - Division and Combination of Trusts

A. For any administrative, tax or other purpose determined by the Trustees
to be in the best interests of any Beneficiary (including any remainderman) hereunder, the
Trustees may at any time and from time to time (whether before or after funding), without
approval of any court, divide any trust under this Agreement into two or more separate trusts or
combine two or more trusts with substantially identical terms (whether or not such trusts resulted
from division of a prior trust).

B. If property is directed to be added to any trust hereunder (the "Original
20 GJ 00088
Trust"), whether by the terms of this Agreement any other agreement, or the Will of any person,
the Trustees may hold such property as one or more separate trusts on terms identical to the
terms of the Original Trust. The Trustees may allocate such property among the separate trusts
(if any) into which the Original Trust was divided, whether or not pro-rata, using specific
assets or undivided interests therein (including allocation of all such property to one of such separate
trusts).
C. Any time during the existence of separate trusts created by division of a
trust hereunder, the Trustees may exercise all discretionary powers differently with respect to
the separate trusts and take all other actions consistent with such trusts being separate entities.
Furthermore, the holder of any power of appointment with respect to such separate trusts may
exercise such power differently with respect to each such trust.

Section 5.8. - Consolidation of Trusts
If at any time after my death there is in existence a trust under my Will or any trust
agreement created by me having identical beneficiaries and substantially the same terms as any
trust under this Agreement, the Trustees may terminate the trust hereunder and transfer the
assets thereof to the Trustees of such other trust, to be administered by the Trustees thereof.
Different termination dates under the applicable Rule Against Perpetuities shall not be deemed
a difference in the terms of such trusts, but the portion of the trust representing the transferred
assets shall retain the same termination date as the original trust.

Section 5.9. -Termination of Trusts
Notwithstanding anything herein, any trust created hereunder for any person shall
(unless terminated earlier) terminate upon the day preceding the expiration of the maximum
period permitted under the United States Virgin Islands Rule Against Perpetuities, for the
vesting of an interest in a trust and upon such date the assets of such trust shall be distributed to
such person.

Section 5.10.  — Equitable Adjustment
If any of the Trustees decides to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by
this Agreement or by law (including, without limitation, any election available to any Trustee)
and the exercise or nonexercise of such power confers a benefit on one Beneficiary or class of
Beneficiaries hereunder and imposes a detriment upon another Beneficiary or class of
Beneficiaries hereunder, the Trustees shall not attempt to restore the interests of the
Beneficiaries or classes of Beneficiaries to the position otherwise contemplated by this
Agreement through adjustment between income and principal or otherwise.

Section 5.1 1. - Lapsed Distribution
Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, a provision for distribution
to an individual who is not surviving at the date such individual otherwise becomes eligible for
such distribution shall lapse notwithstanding any law to the contrary.

Section 5.12. - Notice
21 GJ 00089
Any notice required hereunder shall be delivered personally or sent by first class or
certified mail addressed to the last known address of the intended recipient.

Section 5.13. - Termination of Trust
An instrument in writing completely revoking this Agreement shall, without more, upon
delivery to any of the Trustees, completely terminate all of the Trustees' right, title, and interest
to any life insurance proceeds, death benefits, pension, profit sharing, or other retirement
benefits or any other assets otherwise payable to the Trustees.
Article VI  Powers of Trustees

Section 6.1. - Exercise of Judgment and Powers
The Trustees of each trust hereunder have the entire care and custody of all assets of
such trust. The Trustees have the power to do everything the Trustees in good faith deem
advisable without necessity of any judicial authorization or approval, even though but for this
power it would not be authorized or appropriate for fiduciaries under any statutory or other rule
of law. The Trustees shall exercise the Trustees' best judgment and discretion for what the
Trustees believe to be in the best interests of such trust and the Beneficiaries of such trust. If
two Trustees are empowered to participate in a decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power granted by this Agreement or by law, such decision must be made unanimously by the
Trustees. If more than two Trustees are empowered as the Trustee to participate in the decision
to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, a majority
of such Trustees shall be empowered to make such decision.

Section 6.2. - Compensation of the Trustees
Each Trustee acting hereunder (without regard to the number of separate trusts for which
such Trustee is so acting) shall be entitled to annual compensation for services performed
hereunder in the amount of Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) per year, in
addition to any bequest to which they may be entitled under this terms of this Agreement. No
other compensation shall be payable to the Trustees hereunder; provided, however, that the
Trustees shall be reimbursed for all reasonable costs, expenses, charges, and liabilities incurred
or paid in connection with acting as Trustee or performing services hereunder, including, but
not limited to, fees and expenses of counsel or any other agents hired by the Trustees, and the
Trustees shall not be liable therefor individually. The Trustees have discretion to pay such
compensation and such reimbursements from trust assets, without obtaining judicial
authorization or approval.

Section 6.3. - General Investment Powers

A. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, the Trustees have the
power with respect to each and every trust created hereunder:

1. To enter upon and take possession of the assets of such trust and collect
22 CI 00090
the income and profits from such assets, and to invest and reinvest such assets in real,
personal, or mixed assets (including the common trust funds of a corporate fiduciary) or in
undivided interests therein without being limited by any present or future investment laws;

2. To retain all or any part of the assets of such trust (without regard to the
proportion that any one asset or class of assets may bear to the whole) in the form in which
such assets were received or acquired by the Trustees;

3. To sell or dispose of, exchange, transfer, invest, or loan all or any part of
the assets of such trust which the Trustees hold, at any time, for such sums or upon such terms
as to payment, security, or otherwise as the Trustees determine, either by public or private
transactions;

4. To buy and sell options, warrants, puts, calls or other rights to purchase or
sell (collectively called "options") relating to any security or securities, regardless of whether
such security or securities are then held by the Trustees, and whether such options are
purchased or sold on a national securities exchange, and to exercise with respect to such
options all powers which an individual owner thereof could exercise, including, without
limitation, the right to allow the same to expire;
5. With respect to oil, natural gas, minerals, and all other natural resources
and rights to and interests therein (together with all equipment pertaining thereto) including,
without limiting the generality of the foregoing, oil and gas royalties, leases, or other oil and
gas interests of any character, whether owned in fee, as lessee, lessor, licensee, concessionaire
or otherwise, or alone or jointly with others as partner, joint tenant, or joint venturer in any
other noncorporate manner, (a) to make oil, gas and mineral leases or subleases; (b) to pay
delay rentals, lease bonuses, royalties, overriding royalties, taxes, assessments, and all other
charges; (c) to sell, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge or otherwise hypothecate any or all of
such rights and interests; (d) to surrender or abandon, with or without consideration, any or
all of such rights and interests; (e) to make farm-out, pooling, and unitization agreements; si)
to make reservations or impose conditions on the transfer of any such rights or interests; (g)
to employ the most advantageous business form in which properly to exploit such rights and
interests, whether as corporations, partnerships, limited partnerships, mining partnerships,
joint ventures, co- tenancies, or otherwise exploit any and all such rights and interests; (h) to
produce, process, sell or exchange all products recovered through the exploitation of such
rights and interests, and to enter into contacts and agreements for or in respect of the
installation or operation of absorption, reprocessing or other processing plants; (i) to carry
any or all such interests in the name or names of a nominee or nominees; G) to delegate, to
the extent permitted by law, any or all of the powers set forth herein to the operator of such
property; and (k) to employ personnel, rent office space, buy or lease office equipment,
contract and pay for geological surveys and studies, procure appraisals, and generally to
conduct and engage in any and all activities incident to the foregoing powers, with full power
to borrow and pledge in order to finance such activities; together with the power to allocate
between principal and income any net proceeds received as consideration, whether as
royalties or otherwise, for the permanent severance from lands of oil, natural gas, minerals,
and all other natural resources;
23 GJ 00091

6. To hold all or any part of the assets of such trust in cash or in bank accounts
without the necessity of investing the same;

7. To improve, repair, partition, plat, or subdivide all or any part of the assets
of such trust;
8. To litigate, defend, compromise, settle, abandon, or submit to mediation
or arbitration on such terms and conditions as the Trustees determine any claims in favor of
or against such trust or the assets of such trust;

9. To loan or borrow money in such amounts and upon such terms and
conditions as the Trustees determine, assume such obligations or give such guarantees as the
Trustees determine, for the purpose of the acquisition, improvement, protection, retention, or
preservation of the assets of such trust, or for the benefit of any of the Beneficiaries who are
entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust;

10. To create or invest in any entity with all or part of the assets of such trust
and to carry on for as long and in such manner as the Trustees determine any business
enterprise held or created by the Trustees or in which I owned any interest at my death, either
individually or as a partner, joint venturer, stockholder, trust beneficiary, or member; to sell
such business enterprise as an ongoing business; to consolidate, merge, encumber, dissolve,
liquidate or undertake any other extraordinary corporate transaction relating to such business
enterprise;

II. To vote in person or by proxy any and all stock or securities and to
become a party to any voting trusts, reorganization, consolidation, or other capital or debt
readjustment of any corporation, association, partnership, limited liability partnership, limited
liability company, or individual with respect to stocks, securities, or debts held by such trust;

12. Except as provided in Sections 6.3(B), (C), and (D) of this Article VI, to
enter into any good faith transactions with the Trustees individually or with any corporation,
partnership, limited liability partnership, limited liability company, or other entity in which
any of the Trustees has an ownership interest;

13. To purchase from my estate any stocks, bonds, securities, real or personal
property, or other assets, or make loans to my estate even though the same person or persons
occupy the office of the Trustee and the office of the Executor of my estate;

14. To lease, mortgage, pledge, grant a security interest in, or otherwise
encumber all or any part of the assets of such trust for any term of years whether or not beyond
the term of such trust (including, without limitation, any such action for the benefit of any of
the Beneficiaries of such trust);

15. To abandon any property of such trust, real or personal, which the
Trustees may deem worthless or not of sufficient value to warrant keeping or protecting; to
abstain from the payment of taxes, water rents or assessments and to forego making repairs,
maintaining or keeping up any such property; and to permit such property to be lost by tax
sale or other proceedings or to convey any such property for a nominal consideration or
24 GJ 00092
without consideration so as to prevent the imposition of any liability by reason of the
continued ownership thereof;

16. To elect the mode of distribution of the proceeds from any profit-sharing
plan, pension plan, employee benefit plan, individual retirement plan, insurance contract, or
annuity contract pursuant to the terms of such plan or to change to another custodian of such
plan;

17. To conduct any audit, assessment, or investigation with respect to any
asset of such trust regarding compliance with any law or regulation having as its object
protection of public health, natural resources, or the environment (referred to as
"Environmental Laws"); to pay from the assets of such trust to remedy any failure to comply
with any Environmental Law (even to the exhaustion of all of the assets of such trust); and,
as may be required in the Trustees' judgment by any Environmental Law, to notify any
governmental authority of any past, present, or future non-compliance with any
Environmental Law; and

18. To refuse to accept any asset distributable to such trust.
B. No Trustee shall directly or indirectly buy or sell any property for the
trust from or to himself, or from or to his relative, employer, employee, partner or other business
associate.

C. No Trustee shall as trustee of one trust sell property to himself as trustee
of another trust.
D. No Trustee shall lend trust funds to himself, or to his relative, employer,
employee, partner, or other business associate.

Section 6.4. - Administrative Powers
Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, the Trustees have the power with
respect to each trust:

A. To employ agents, attorneys-at-law, consultants, investment advisers (to
whom the Trustees have discretion to delegate the Trustees' investment authority and
responsibility), other trustees and other fiduciaries in the administration of the Trustees' duties,
to delegate to such persons, or to one or more of the Trustees, the custody, control, or
management of any part of the assets of such trust as the Trustees determine and to pay for such
services from the assets of such trust, without obtaining judicial authorization or approval;

B. To delegate, in whole or in part, to any person or persons the authority
and power to (1) sign checks, drafts or orders for the payment or withdrawal of funds, securities
and other assets from any bank, brokerage, custody or other account in which funds, securities
or other assets of such trust shall be deposited, (2) endorse for sale, transfer or delivery, or sell,
transfer or deliver, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any and all property, stocks, stock
warrants, stock rights, options, bonds or other securities whatsoever, (3) gain access to any safe
deposit box or boxes in which assets of such trust may be located or which may be in the name
25 GJ 00093
of any of the Trustees and remove part or all of the contents of any such safe deposit box or
boxes and release and surrender the same, and (4) take any other action that the Trustees may
have the power to take with respect to such trust and the property thereof; no person or
corporation acting in reliance on any such delegation shall be charged with notice of any
revocation or change of such delegation unless such person or corporation receives actual notice
thereof;

C. To pay any property distributable to a Beneficiary under a legal disability
or who has not attained the age of 21, without liability to the Trustees, by paying such property

(1) to such Beneficiary, (2) for the use of such Beneficiary, (3) to a legal representative of such
Beneficiary appointed by a court or if none, to a relative for the use of such Beneficiary, or (4)
to a custodian for such Beneficiary designated by the Trustees, to hold until age 21 or such
earlier age as shall be the maximum permitted under applicable law;

D. To divide such trust into subsidiary accounts if the Trustees determine
that such division is necessary to maintain fair and accurate records;

E. To permit the Beneficiary of such trust to use, possess, and enjoy real
property, tangible personal property, or club memberships held by such trust;

F. To distribute to such trust or any of the Beneficiaries of such trust in kind
or in cash, or partly in kind and partly in cash, and to allocate different kinds or disproportionate
shares of assets or undivided interests in assets among all of such trusts or all of such
Beneficiaries;

G. In making the division into one or more trusts hereunder (if such trusts
have the same Trustees), to keep the assets of such trusts invested and handled as a single fund
without actual division and to designate such trusts on the Trustees' books as owning a
designated undivided interest in such fluid;

H. To have evidence of ownership of any security maintained in the records
of a Federal Reserve Bank under the Federal Reserve Book Entry System; to deposit funds in
any bank or trust company; to carry in the name of any of the Trustees or the nominee or
nominees of the Trustees and with or without designation of fiduciary capacity, or to hold in
bearer form, securities or other property requiring or permitting of registration; and to cause
any securities to be held by a depository corporation of which a Trustee is a member or by an
agent under a safekeeping contract; provided, however, that the books and records of the
Trustees shall at all times show that such investments are part of such trust;

I. To register or not register such trust with the probate division of the
Superior Court of the United States Virgin Islands or otherwise and to make all decisions which
relate thereto;

J. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, to give any
Beneficiary of any trust hereunder a general power of appointment exercisable in such
Beneficiary's Will over all or part of such trust, subject to any terms and conditions as the
Trustees determine, by written notice to such Beneficiary; to eliminate any such power of
appointment by written notice to the Beneficiary; and to irrevocably release the power under
26 GJ 00094
this paragraph to give a power of appointment or to eliminate a power of appointment;

K. To renounce and disclaim, in whole or in part, and in accordance with
applicable law, any assets, interests, rights, or powers (including any power of appointment)
which are payable to (or exercisable by) such trust or over which the Trustees have any right,
title, interest, or power; and

L. To make, execute, and deliver any and all such instruments in writing as
shall be necessary or proper to carry out any power, right, duty, or obligation of the Trustees or
any disposition whatsoever of such trust or any asset of such trust and to exercise any and all
other powers incidental or necessary to carry out or to fulfill the terms, provisions and purposes
of such trust.

Section 6.5. - Restrictions on Exercise of The Trustee's Powers

A. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, a
Trustee shall not participate in a discretionary decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power to (1) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder to himself or herself; or

(2) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder for the health, support,
maintenance or education of a Beneficiary if such Trustee has a legal obligation to provide for
the health, support, maintenance or education of such Beneficiary from such Trustee's personal
assets. For purposes of this paragraph, a person whose interest in a trust hereunder is limited to
a remote contingent interest (for example, a contingent remainderman whose interest depends
upon another person failing to survive to a specified age or a person designated to receive assets
only in the event a power of appointment is not exercised) shall not be treated as a person who
is or may be a Beneficiary of such trust.

B. A Trustee of any trust hereunder may by a written notice delivered to the
other Trustee (or Trustees) of such trust decline to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or bylaw.

C. If a Trustee of any trust hereunder is not empowered (because of a
conflict of interest, declination to act or otherwise) to participate in the decision to exercise or
not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, then the remaining
Trustee or Trustees of such trust shall be empowered to make such decision. If no Trustee or
successor Trustee is empowered to participate in such decision, the Trustees may designate a
substitute Trustee to serve as Trustee of such trust who shall be empowered to make such
decision but has no other power or authority of the Trustees. Such designation shall be by
written notice delivered to such substitute Trustee.
Article VII  Provisions Concerning Trustees

Section 7.1. - Successor Trustees

A. In the event a Trustee of any trust created for the benefit of CELINA
EDITH DUBIN pursuant to the provisions of Article II, Section 2.3(A) or Section 2.4 of this
27 GJ 00095
Agreement and administered in accordance with the provisions of Article III, Section 3.1, 3.2
or 3.3 of this Agreement, or any successor Trustee thereof, resigns, is removed, becomes
incapacitated or is unwilling or is unable to serve, a successor Trustee shall be appointed to fill
the vacancy thereby created, such that the total number of Trustees acting on behalf of such
trust at all times shall be two. shall first be appointed to fill any
such vacancy, and thereafter said successor Trustee may be appointed at any time by the
Trustees then acting, or, if, as a result of said vacancy, only one Trustee is then acting, by the
sole remaining Trustee then acting.
B. Except as specifically provided in Article VII, Section 7.1(A) of this
Agreement, in the event a Trustee of the Trust resigns, is removed, becomes incapacitated or is
unwilling or is unable to serve, a successor Trustee shall be appointed to fill the vacancy thereby
created, such that the total number of Trustees acting on behalf of the Trust at all times shall be
two. KATHERYN RUEMMLER shall first be a ointed to fill any such vacancy, and if she
is unwilling or unable to serve, shall be appointed to fill any such
vacancy, and thereafter the successor Trustee appointed to fill any such vacancy shall be
appointed by the Trustees then acting, or, if as a result of said vacancy, only one Trustee is then
acting, by the sole remaining Trustee then acting.

Section 7.2. - Appointment of Trustee
The appointment of a successor Trustee hereunder shall become effective when such
successor Trustee signs an acceptance of the trust.

Section 7.3. - Resignation of Trustees
Any Trustee may resign at any time, without the approval of any court, by an instrument
in writing filed with the trust records. In addition, if there is filed with the trust records a written
certification from any attending physician of any individual Trustee of a trust that he or she is
no longer able to make decisions with respect to such trust, then from the date of filing of such
certification, such individual Trustee shall be deemed to have resigned for all purposes of this
Agreement.

Section 7.4. - Vacancy in Office
If there is a vacancy in the Trustees and no successor Trustee is designated pursuant to

Section 7.1 who is willing to act, the legally competent adult Beneficiary (or a majority in
beneficial interest of the legally competent adult Beneficiaries if there are multiple
Beneficiaries) then entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust shall designate a
successor Trustee by an instrument in writing delivered to the designated Trustee. If the legally
competent adult Beneficiaries do not designate a successor Trustee within sixty days after
receipt of notice of such vacancy or if there is no legally competent adult Beneficiary of such
trust, then a successor Trustee shall be named by order of a court of competent jurisdiction. All
of the fees and expenses of the Trustees (including attorneys' fees) attributable to the
appointment of a successor Trustee of a trust shall be paid from the assets of such trust.

Section 7.5. - Elimination of Bond
28 CI 00096
No bond or other security shall be required of any Trustee hereunder in any jurisdiction.

Section 7.6. - Exculpation and Indemnification of the Trustees
No one serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be accountable or
responsible to any person interested in any trust hereunder for the manner in which the Trustees
shall in good faith exercise any discretionary authority or any power of the Trustees. No one
serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be liable for any loss or
depreciation in value occasioned by reason of any negligence, error or mistake of judgment in
entering into any transaction, in making any sale or investment, in continuing to hold any
property, or by reason of any action or omission, whether by the Trustees or any other fiduciary,
unless such Trustee has acted in bad faith. In the absence of proof by affirmative evidence to the
contrary, each Trustee shall be deemed to have acted within the scope of the Trustees' authority,
to have exercised reasonable care, diligence, and prudence and to have acted impartially as to
all interested persons. A Trustee shall not be liable for the acts or defaults of another Trustee.
In the event a legal action is brought against any individual serving as the Trustee of any
trust under this Agreement, all legal fees and related expenses incurred in connection with the
defense of such legal action shall be paid by such trust without court authorization; provided,
however, that (a) no such payment shall (or shall continue to) be made if a court enters an order
prohibiting such payment, and (b) such Trustee shall refund to the trust any such payments that
previously had been made if a court enters an order directing that such payments be refunded,
or if a court concludes that such Trustee acted in bad faith.

Section 7.7. - Relief from Virgin Islands Statutory Provisions
Pursuant to Section 1212, Title 15, of the Virgin Islands Code, I hereby relieve the
Trustees and any successor Trustees of the requirements imposed by Chapter 59, Title 15 of the
Virgin Islands Code, or any similar successor law respecting public filings of inventories and
accountings by Trustees. Furthermore, pursuant to Section 1107, Title 15, of the Virgin Islands
Code, I hereby relieve the Trustees and any successor Trustees, to the extent allowable, from
any and all duties, restrictions, and liabilities which would otherwise be imposed upon the
Trustees by Chapter 57, Title 15, Virgin Islands Code. This Section 7.7 of this Article VII shall
not be deemed a waiver of any and all other rights, powers, or restrictions otherwise granted to
the Trustees in this Agreement.
Article VIII  Miscellaneous Provisions

Section 8.1. - Representation of Person Under a Disability
To the extent allowed by law, where a party to any proceeding with respect to any trust
hereunder has the same interest as a person under a disability, legal process shall not be required
on the person under a disability.

Section 8.2. - Simultaneous Deaths
If a Beneficiary under this Agreement and I die simultaneously or under such
circumstances that it is difficult to determine who died first, then for all purposes of this
29 CI 00097
Agreement such Beneficiary shall be deemed to have predeceased me.

Section 8.3. - Law Governing
This Agreement and each trust created by it shall in all respects and for all purposes be
governed and regulated by the laws of the Territory of the United States Virgin Islands, as they
now exist and may from time to time be enacted, amended, or repealed. All questions regarding
the validity, construction and administration of this Agreement, or any of its provisions, and of
any trust created by it shall be determined solely by the laws of that Territory. The courts of the
State of Delaware and the U.S. Virgin Islands shall have primary supervision over the
administration of each trust created by this Agreement. It is intended that each such trust shall
be a U.S. domestic trust as defined in Title 26 section 7701(a)(30) of the Code by virtue of
meeting the court and control test. As provided in Treas. Reg. section 301.770 I-7(c)(4)(D),
if both a United States court and a foreign court are able to exercise primary supervision over
the administration of the trust, the trust meets the court test.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, the Trustees of each trust
created under this Agreement have discretion at any time or times following my death to transfer
the situs of such trust to such other country, or such other jurisdiction as the Trustees determine,
without obtaining judicial authorization or approval (unless such judicial authorization or
approval is required by applicable law) and without the filing of any bond. The Trustees'
determination to transfer the situs of any trust under this Agreement shall be evidenced by an
instrument in writing signed, witnessed and acknowledged by the Trustees in the same manner
as would be required for a deed. The Trustees are authorized to take whatever actions are
necessary to effect such a transfer of situs. If judicial authorization or approval is required to
effect such a transfer of situs, I intend and desire that the appropriate court accept the
determination of the Trustees concerning the transfer of the situs of such trust even if one or
more Beneficiaries disagree with such determination. From and after the Trustees' transfer of
the situs of a trust pursuant to this Section 8.3 of this Article VIII, the administration of such
trust shall be governed by the law of the new situs of such trust.

Section 8.4. - Definition of Terms
Except as otherwise specifically provided herein, as used in this Agreement,

A. The term "Trustee" means all persons or entities who occupy the office
of Trustee of any trust hereunder while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one
or more persons or entities occupy the office of Trustee at the same time or times, and includes
any successor Trustee or Trustees. The term "Executor" of a person's estate means all persons
or entities who occupy the office of personal representative, administrator, executor, or ancillary
administrator while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more persons or
entities occupy such office at the same time or times, and includes any successor or successors
to that office. A reference to a person's Will means such person's Last Will and Testament and
any Codicil or Codicils thereto.

B. A reference to any tax also includes any interest or penalties thereon. The
term "my Gross Estate" means my gross estate as finally determined for purposes of computing
30 GJ 00098
Richard D. Kahn, Trustee
my federal estate tax.
C. Whenever the singular number is used, the same shall include the plural,
and the masculine gender shall include the feminine and neuter genders.

Section 8.5. - No Contest
If any Beneficiary under this Agreement shall in any way directly or indirectly (a) contest
or object to the probate of my Will or to the validity of any disposition or provision of my Will
or of this Agreement or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or indirectly
instrumental in the institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest, objection or
claim for the purpose of setting aside or invalidating my Will or this Agreement or any
disposition therein or herein or provision thereof or hereof, then I direct that (aa) any and all
provisions in this Agreement for such Beneficiary and his issue in any degree shall be null and
void and (bb) my estate whether passing under my Will or this Agreement or pursuant to the
laws of intestacy shall be disposed of as if such Beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all
failed to survive me.

Section 8.6. -Trustee Notice
The Trustees may have duties and responsibilities in addition to those described in this
Agreement. If the Trustees have questions, the Trustees should obtain legal advice.
CONCLUSION
this Agreement on the date set opposite my signature.
Date  C I (t
Date  t I It I 19
Date  dick
31 GJ 00099
STATE OF FLORIDA
) ss:
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this 18th day of January, 2019 by
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, the Grantor, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this
18th day of January, 2019.
alra VJZAti/h-ta•
Notary Public
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
) )ss:
)
1
AMANDA Driest Ars 041.-,
(1 4" 0 .s.1Tfi Notary Pthlk - State or Fionoa
..A.„. At Commission F GG 268365
\CO.."5.1. My Comm. Expires Oct 16. 2022
Bonded through Natweal holey ASV.
— — — —
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this I8th day of January, 2019, by
DARREN K. INDYICE, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this
18th day of January, 2019.
1/ 1/4.70%-9_,
Notary Public
STATE OF NEW YORK
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
1 , tic; NAANO4 DEVINE
'; Notary eilalic • State or Florida
I Commission 0 GG 263365
\\,F,as et,My Comm. Expires Oct 16. 2022
Bonded through National Notary Assn.
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this day of January, 2019, by
RICHARD D. KAHN, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
NOTARY PUBLIC-STATE OF NEW YORK

No. 01086285700
Qualified in New York County
My Commission F.koires 07.08-2021
32 GJ_00100
SCHEDULE A
Description of Trust Property
$100.00
33 GJ_00101
SCHEDULE B
ADDITIONAL DISTRIBUTIONS
Any and all distributions to be made pursuant to the provisions of this Agreement to the persons listed
on Schedule B to this Agreement in accordance with directions provided in Schedule B to this
Agreement shall be made to each the persons listed below in the percentage set forth opposite
such person's name below, but only if such person shall be then surviving at the time of the event
which gives rise to such distribution. In the event that any of the persons listed below shall not
be then surviving, such distribution shall be made to those of the persons listed below who shall
then be surviving, pro rata in accordance with their relative distribution percentages provided
below:
50%
10%
10%
LISA KAHN 5%
MAX G. KAHN 5%
LYLA B. KAHN 5%
5%
SAMANTHA M. INDYKE 5%
HANNAH E. INDYKE 5%
The Grantor shall have the right to amend this Schedule B at any time and from time to time during his
lifetime by executing and acknowledging a written Amended Schedule B and delivering the same to no
less than one Trustee.
34 GJ 00102
╔═════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Valdas Petreikis [europe] Lithuanian businessman [aa.com.tr] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01616004 (Jmail)
 [misc] Skype log of conversation with Valdas Petreikis
(inferred timestamp: 2019-01-25 22:43:25)
Platform: Skype: jeevacation Name: CS:waldorado Timezone: UTC+0000
OValdas Petreikis A jeevacation
201910100
1.0.14JS Pene.kis
or I could drive from Gene✓a on weekend if you would meet me?
104216 pm
v.r./..rhut
of course i would , please coordieante with -
10:42.33 pm
V,Edas Peter.kis
thank you so much!
10.43.13 pm
•
•
•
I will write Lesley
10:43:25 pm
2019/01/25
valdas tomorrow there are yellow vest protests planned. sunday easier, or we should do later after 4pm on sat. or.. 
whatever ewasiet for you
07:17:38 pm
valdas Petrokis
(Deleted) Dear Jeffrey, I will be in Paris 11 am saturday, 4pm would be great?
0748.56 pm
(Deleted) Dear Jeffrey?! will be in Paris 11 am saturday, 4pm would be better, if it good for you?
07.48.57 pm
Dear Jeffrey, l will be in Paris 11 am saturday, 4pm would be better, if it is good for you?
07.48.58 pm
valdas Peunkis
great. thanks
07 54 16 pm
have a nice evening!
07 54.19 pm
Shull
4 pm fine
07:50 49 pm
we need to check if you can get near my house i live at the arc de triompjhe.
<a href="https://wwwprelecturedepolice.interieur.gouvir/content/download/340.81/258333ffile/CP9620PP%2025012019%20-
%2ORestrictions9620de%20circulation%20mises%20en1620place%2Ole%20samedi9620269620janvier%202019.pdr>https://www.prefectu
redepolice.interieur.gouvir/content/down
loadad081/258333/file/CP%2OPP9620250120199620-
%20Restrictions%20de9620circulation%20mises%20en9620place%2Ole%20samedi9620269620janvier%202019.pdf<k>
07 55.25 pm
VaSaas Pane las
sure, I will do that!
07:58:53 pm
IU
Valdas Pettelas
it was the same last time we went to Paris, taxi works
08.02.06 pm
it was the same last time we went to Paris, taxi works
08.02.06 pm
9a Was Peter kis
thank you, I will come tomorrow
03 03 06 pm
Vaklas Peve.los
Jeffrey it was amazing to meet you, I appreciate your time very much! Thank you!
05.45.04 pm
2019/01/26
2019/01/27
sunday seems much easier. I have no idea about tomrow streets. subways etc.
07.59:30 pm
paris CRAZY
07 59 36 pm
nun
ok with me
08.02.07 pm
im happy to see you anytime
03.02.26 pm
always
05:58.23 pm
einstein book great , thnx1
08:17:50 pm
O
O
O
O
vaklas Petreikis
•
•
I am very happy you like it!
08.35.08 pm
vaklas Pent-Ms
Dear Jeffrey, how are you?
06.10.11 pm
I ha✓e one ballet dancer, she would use some support
06.10.45 pm
Sent an attachment
06.10.53 pm
do you think I could use previously transferred funds?
06:13:44 pm
valdas Peunkis
great. thanks!
0621:27 pm
2019/0344
jenwation
yes
06:17:06 pm
EFTA01612695 (Jmail)
 [girls] Skype log of conversation with Daniel Siad see quote: "my friend the Thai actrice is new York if you have time to invite her"
(date: 2019-02-05)
Platform: Skype: jeevacation Name: C
0  Daniel Siad 0 jeevacation
2019/02/05
Daniel Siad
Hello Jeffrey tell when you have time to speak
09:21:22 pm
Daniel Siad
I hope you get well warmest regards
09:36:37 pm
2019/02/10
Daniel Siad
Timezone: UTC+0000
jeevacau on
Flu. Sic
09:24:04 pm
I forgot meeting
09:32:17 pm
I forgot meeting
09:32:18 pm
Hello Jeffrey my friend the Thai actrice is new York if you have time to invite her
01:43:00 pin
I just give her your number
01:43:12 pm
•
•
•
777
01:45:07 pm
Daniel Siad
Ok
01:50:10 pm
She is staying at Hotel standard highline
02:04:41 pm
Daniel Siad
Perfect I told her
02:47:23 pin
Are you free to chat
09:16:49 pm
??
10:47:45 pm
2019/02/11
jeevacation
ill be there wednesday
01:47:00 pm
jeevacation
ok, i can see her wednesday
02:12:32 pm
jeevacation
now?
:4758  am
s
0
Daniel Siad
Hello Jeffrey
03:00:35 pm
I am free if you have time
03:05:28 pm
jeevacation
Call type: Outgoing
Siad
From: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:03:51.4420000
03:27:38 pm
Call t e: Out oing
To Daniel Siad
From: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:03:51.4420000
03:27:38 pm
2019/02/14
jeevacation
i invited your friend pookluck to my house. she wants to meet in a restaurant.
dont do that in new york .
12:34:29 pm
Daniel Siad
I agree with you.
12:41:34 pm
jeevacation
she did not even respond ? not nice
11:02:50 pm
0
0
0
2019/02/22
Daniel Siad
•
•
•
•
How are you
04:45:19 pin
2019/02/26
Daniel Siad
I hope you are well
01:00:58 pm
Sending warmest regards
01:01:14 pm
2019/02/27
Daniel Siad
Are you in Paris
01:20:11 pm
Daniel Siad
I hope You are well sending you warmest regards
01:21:35 pm
jeevacation
no
01:20:37 pm
2019/03/05
Daniel Siad
Call ty e: Missed
From aniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:00:00
01:22:58 pin
Call type: Missed
From Daniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:00:00
0/:22:58 pin
Tell me when you are free if I can call you
07:23:31 pm
jeevacation
now
08:14:20 pm
Daniel Siad
Yes
08:19:14 pm
Call type: Incoming
From Daniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:02:53.7000000
08:19:23 pm
Call ty e: Incomin
From )aniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:02:53.7000000
08:19:23 pm
2019/03/21
Daniel Siad
Call type: Missed
From Daniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:00:00
11:55:03 pin
Call type: Missed
From aniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:00:00
11:55:03 pin
2019/03/25
Daniel Siad
Call ty e: Missed
From: Daniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:00:00
04:46:19 pm
Call type: Missed
From: I lkaniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:00:00
04:46:19 pm
l&apos;m hope you are well sending you warmest regards
05:05:55 pm
Call ty e: Missed
From: Daniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:00:00
09:27:23 pm
Call type: Missed
From Daniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
•
•
Duration: 00:00:00
09:27:23 pm
Daniel Siad
Call type: Missed
Froma)aniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:00:00
04:28:43 pm
Call type: Missed
From Daniel Siad
To: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:00:00
04:28:43 pm
VoicemailPlay
Sent an attachment
Filename: Voicemail
Path: Voicemail
04:28:54 pm
2019/03/26
EFTA00003042 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
(date: 2019-02-06)
If'"6" leler
/F
erg
wow
ad/
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters, Suite B-3, St. Thomas. V100802-1348
Phone E-mail: thesaintjames.gyouP@email.com
Emergency Contact Form
Today's Date:
Employee Name:
Start Date:
Date of Birth:
z/o/79 1
OA tarrerrebn E./ast
Physical Address:
Mailing Address:
Cell Phone:
E-mail:
Title/Position:
Phone (other):
Marital Status:
Driver's License No:
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood type:
❑ A- ❑ A-t- ❑ AB- 17 AB+
Current Medications:
❑ 0- ❑ Unknown
Doctor's Name: I Doctor's Phone: i
Doctor's Name: Doctor's Phone:
rnent
In case of emergency, please contact:
ado
Name: Relationship:) Phone:
0RO
Name:Relationship: Phone:
ca l
ame
This information is for your safety and the safety of others.
male ovo-oov

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ gic               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00783660 (Jmail)
 [politics] iMessage to Steve Bannon screenshot(s)
(date: 2019-02-06)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024362.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024362.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case
Data:
Messages
(20901-
21000 of
32198)
iMessage
2019-02-06 15:22:28 UTC) [11
Sender:
Participants:
is coming , I am staying in NYC.
iMessage
2019-02-0615:23:57 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: (
I will give Lesley details when
free, later today. And Lesley will get the
), Self (jeeitunes®ginail.com )
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
she gets the approval from the agency that she s
ticket
iMessage
2019-02-0615:23:57 lift
Sender:
Participants:
I will give Lesley details when
free, later today. And Lesley will get the
iMessage
[2] 2019-02-06 15:29:52 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: (
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
she gets the approval from the agency that she s
ticket
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Ok I misunderstood
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 15:29:52 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Ok I misunderstood
iMessage
[3] 2019-02-06 16:14:42 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Im in until Friday at 4 . We are scheduled tomorrow but feel free to change ir to anyplace
anytime
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 16:14:42 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Im in until Friday at 4 . We are scheduled tomorrow but feel free to change ir to anyplace
anytime
iMessage
2019-02-06 17:09:07 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Lesley is taking care of her ticket now.
iMessage
2019-02-06 17:09:07 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Lesley is taking care of her ticket now.
iMessage
[2] 2019-02-06 17:17:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Thx
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 17:17:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Thx
iMessage
2019-02-06 19:05:22 UTC) [3
Sender: (
Participants: 1 ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Ok
iMessage
2019-02-06 19:05:22 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Ok
iMessage
2019-02-0619:05:30 UTC 3
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I like schedules
iMessage
2019-02-0619:05:30 UTC I]
Sender:
Participants: 1 ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I like schedules
iMessage
[3] 2019-02-06 19:06:55 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Ok see you at erikas at 2?
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 19:06:55 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Ok see you at erikas at 2?
iMessage
[4] 2019-02-06 19:40:36 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 19:40:36 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Im back in ny 13th
), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Im back in ny 13th
iMessage
2019-02-06 20:56:35 (UTC) {51
Sender:
Participants: ii (a ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Hope you're well. Let me know if you have time to talk next week or so. Thanks
iMessage
2019-02-06 20:56:35 UTC) [1
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Hope you're well. Let me know if you have time to talk next week or so. Thanks
iMessage
2019-02-06 22:57:41 UTC 6
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
https://www.axios.com/jeffrey-epstein-justice-department-investigation-ben-sasse-
e66366da-162f-4aca-9189-002bfe328fae.html
iMessage
2019-02-06 22:57:41 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-02-06 22:57:41 (UTC) [1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-02-06 22:57:41 (UTC) 1
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
https://www.axios.com/jeffrey-epstein-justice-department-investigation-ben-sasse-
e66366da-162f-4aca-9189-c02bfe328fae.html
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:00:12 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:00:12 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:00:29 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:00:29 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Yes, I've seen
Yes, I've seen
Nobody would like the true facts out more than me
), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Nobody would like the true facts out more than me
iMessage
2019-02-06 23:00:55 UTC 6
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
You keep saying that-- you should just want this to go away
iMessage
2019-02-06 23:00:55 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
You keep saying that-- you should just want this to go away
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:01:21 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
yes of course. thats the first choice always
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:01:21 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
yes of course. thats the first choice always
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:02:35 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
The question arises. As I am too juicy a story, so do I just say nothing. ? or ..
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:02:35 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
The question arises. As I am too juicy a story, so do I just say nothing. ? or ..
iMessage
2019-02-06 23:03:31 UTC) 161
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Have you lost your fucking mind--- the moment you say ANYTHING this is global story
iMessage
2019-02-06 23:03:31 (UTC) [1]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Have you lost your fucking mind--- the moment you say ANYTHING this is global story
#111111
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:05:05 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
yes , not me, I only serve food and beverage. Question is the reporters are asking Kathy
for comment . Not sure if she should respond. lye been called many things. Retarded is not
one of them
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:05:05 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
yes , not me, I only serve food and beverage. Question is the reporters are asking Kathy
for comment . Not sure if she should respond. lye been called many things. Retarded is not
one of them
iMessage
2019-02-06 23:05:49 UTC) [6
Sender: (
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
NFW
iMessage
2019-02-06 23:05:49 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
NFW
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:06:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
The Agreement entered into between Jeffrey Epstein and the United States Attorneys
Office was fairly negotiated by experienced teams of attorneys representing each party. It
was anything but a sweetheart deal. And it was carefully and fully reviewed not only by
senior prosecutors within the Southern District of Florida Office but also at multiple levels
of the Department of Justice in D.C. At each level, the decision-making of the US
Attorney was approved. As a result, the Government avoided litigation risks including the
risks of an acquittal and Mr Epstein went to jail, served a period of probation, lived up to
each and every obligation under the Agreement, and has fully conformed his conduct to
the law for well over 10 years. ??
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:06:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
The Agreement entered into between Jeffrey Epstein and the United States Attorneys
Office was fairly negotiated by experienced teams of attorneys representing each party. It
was anything but a sweetheart deal. And it was carefully and fully reviewed not only by
senior prosecutors within the Southern District of Florida Office but also at multiple levels
of the Department of Justice in D.C. At each level, the decision -making of the US
Attorney was approved. As a result, the Government avoided litigation risks including the
risks of an acquittal and Mr Epstein went to jail, served a period of probation, lived up to
each and every obligation under the Agreement, and has fully conformed his conduct to
the law for well over 10 years. ??
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:06:56 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Or off the record.?
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:06:56 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Or off the record.?
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:07:01 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Conversation?
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:07:01 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Conversation?
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:08:01 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
thoughts?
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:08:01 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
thoughts?
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-06 23:12:14 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
Only a few minutes to decide
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:12:14 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitunes ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Only a few minutes to decide
iMessage
[7] 2019-02-06 23:12:33 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I sent you a question
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-06 23:12:33 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I sent you a question
iMessage
2019-02-07 00:27:19 UTC 6
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
You should not say anything OR have your attorney say anything
iMessage
2019-02-07 00:27:19 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
You should not say anything OR have your attorney say anything
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-07 00:29:53 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I m of course saying nothing, I told her I didn't hear back from you , Kathy wrote the
paragraph, and spoke off the record as she know these , and the opr. people.
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 00:29:53 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I m of course saying nothing, I told her I didn't hear back from you , Kathy wrote the
paragraph, and spoke off the record as she know these , and the opr. people.
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-07 00:31:24 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Ive spent my time keeping dersh in check, what a dick
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 00:31:24 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Ive spent my time keeping dersh in check, what a dick
iMessage
2019-02-07 01:01:41 UTC) 6
Sender: (
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
What a cluster fuck
iMessage
2019-02-07 01:01:41 UTC) [11
Sender:
Participants:
What a cluster fuck
iMessage
[6] 2019-02-07 01:02:12 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 01:02:12 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitunes ail.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 01:02:12 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
), Self ( jeenunes®gmail.com )
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-02-07 02:07:12 UTC 8
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
How are you?
iMessage
2019-02-07 02:07:12 (UTC)111
Sender:
Participants:
How are you?
Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-02-07 02:07:33 UTC) 8
Sender: (
Participants: 1 ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Nothing from reporter
iMessage
2019-02-07 02:07:33 UTC) [1] Sender:
Participants:
Nothing from reporter
), Self ( jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-02-07 05:35:10 UTC 9
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
https://www.zerohedge.cotn/news/2019-02-06/senate-investigating-mueller-fbis-
prosecution-orgy-island-billionaire-jeffrey
iMessage
2019-02-07 05:35:10 UTC 1
Sender: (
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
g:(
iMessage
2019-02-07 05:35:10 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-02-07 05:35:10 (11TC) 1 I
Sender: IMM .Mai .
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
https://www.zerohedge.com/news/2019-02-06/senate-investigating-mueller-fbis-
prosecution-orgy-island-billionaire-jeffrey
iMessage
[9] 2019-02-07 06:52:58 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 06:52:58 (UTC)
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Yes/ wild
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
[9] 2019-02-07 06:53:22 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Yes/ wild
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/doj-opens-probe-into-plea-bargain-awarded-by-trump-
official-to-alleged-pedophile-predator-jeffrey-epstein
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 06:53:22 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 06:53:22 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 06:53:22 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/doj-opens-probe-into-plea-bargain-awarded-by-trump-
official-to-alleged-pedophile-predator-jeffrey-epstein
iMessage
[9] 2019-02-07 10:08:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Continue to ignore? Ann Coulter on hannityl. Attack? Op ed , ? Not my skill set
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 10:08:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Continue to ignore? Ann Coulter on hannity/. Attack? Op ed , ? Not my skill set
iMessage
[9] 2019-02-07 10:30:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
What about the attunes penning something that suggests indignation and lays out some of
the facts..
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 10:30:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
What about the attunes penning something that suggests indignation and lays out some of
the facts. .
iMessage
2019-02-07 11:04:47 C 9
Sender: (
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
That drives it a week
iMessage
2019-02-07 11:04:47 UTC I
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
That drives it a week
iMessage
[9] 2019-02-07 11:06:57 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
sasse calling me a child rapist , is nuts!!! Sorry do. You mean ignore. , or responding
makes it worse. ?
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 11:06:58 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
sasse calling me a child rapist , is nuts!!! Sony do. You mean ignore. , or responding
makes it worse. ?
iMessage
2019-02-07 11:31:47 UTC 9
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I think makes it way worse
iMessage
2019-02-07 11:31:47 C) [I
Sender: (
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I think makes it way worse
iMessage
[9] 2019-02-07 11:32:48 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
K, what about Ken talking directly to sasse
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 11:32:48 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
K, what about Ken talking directly to sasse
iMessage
[10] 2019-02-07 11:46:12 (UTC)
Sender: Self ii,tfir timail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Lets see , he's either waiting for more. Or he has lost the edge. Doesn't seem timely. Now
that is gone. Silly
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 11:46:12 (UTC)
Sender: Self i•unegiail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Lets see , he's either waiting for more. Or he has lost the edge. Doesn't seem timely. Now
that is gone. Silly
iMessage
2019-02-07 11:57:10 (UTC) [9]
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Won't help but yes
iMessage
2019-02-07 11:57:10 C 1
Sender: (
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Won"t help but yes
iMessage
[9] 2019-02-07 12:07:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
K
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 12:07:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
K
iMessage
[11] 2019-02-07 19:35:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Now where
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 19:35:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Now where
iMessage
[12] 2019-02-07 19:51:31 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes® il.com
Participants: Woody Allen ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Lawsuit well done. John Quinn good guy
iMessage
[1] 2019-02-07 19:51:31 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeeitunes@gmail.com
Participants: Woody Allen ( ), Self ( jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Lawsuit well done. John Quinn good guy
Notes
[1] Source
Device
[1] Source File
[2] Source
Device
[2] Source File
[3] Source
Device
[3] Source File
[4] Source
Device
[4] Source File
[5] Source
Device
[5] Source File
[6] Source
Device
[6] Source File
[7] Source
Device
[7] Source File
[8] Source
Device
[8] Source File
[9] Source
Device
[9] Source File
[10] Source
Device
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsersijeefLibrary/Messagesichat.db
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsersijeefLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-02-06
08.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-02-06
30.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/jeefLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-02-06
36.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-02-06
31.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/jeefLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-02-06
41.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-02-06
33.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/jeefLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-02-06
06 at 10.52.40.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/jeefLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-02-07
10.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
[10] Source File fUsers/jeefLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-02-07
07 at 07.46.12.ichat
on 2019-02-06 at 13.17.
on 2019-02-06 at 15.05.
on 2019-02-06 at 15.40.
on 2019-01-08 at 16.50.
on 2019-02-06 at 18.57.
on 2019-02-06 at 19.12.
on 2019-02-
on 2019-02-07 at 01.35.
on 2019-02-
[11] Source NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
[11] Source File fUsersijeefLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-02-13/1
42.ichat
[12] Source
Device
[12] Source File fU
t
sersijeefLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-02-19/Woody Allen on 2019-02-19 at 10.55.46.ich
on 2019-02-07 at 20.33.
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
Case Data: Messages (20801-20900 of 32198) Case Data: Messages (21001-21100 of 32198)
EFTA01222951 (Jmail)
 [money] credit card expenses for Carlos L Rodriguez using Plum Card
(date: 2019-02-12)
'UV

• „. I SS
Date
02/08/20 t9
02/08/2019
0248/2019
02/08/2019
02/07/2019
02/07/2019
02/07/2019
02/06/2019
02/06/2019
02/00/2019
02/06/2019
02/06/2019
02105/2019
02/05/2019
02/05/2019
02/05/2019
02/04/2019
02/04/2019
02/04/2010
02104/2019
02/04/2019
02/04/2019
02/04/2019
0244/2019
02/02/2019
Transaction Details
Prepared for
Carlos L Rodriguez
Account Number
Receipt Description
IAMZN MKTP USINMAT2VV62 - AM2N.COINBILL. WA
AMZN MKTP USIAI407t261 AMZN COMIBILL. WA
!THE HOME DEPOT #8201 • ST THOMAS. VI
WESTERN AUTO 5047 5047 - ST THOMAS, VI
}FOOD CENTER SUPERMARKET FOOD CENTER SU - ST. THOMAS. VI
MOES FRESH MARKET - ST THOMAS. VI
r.. HOME DEPOT 68201 - ST THOMAS, VI
1ST STOP GAS STATION E - ST THOMAS. VI
INCH MKTP US•MB1M48K72 -AMZN.COMIBILL. WA
AM2N MKTP USIA4B62J t 702 - AMZN COM/SILL, WA
?AWN MKTP US'IAB76SIVVM2 - AMZN COM/BILL. WA
WESTERN AUTO 5047 5047 - ST THOMAS. VI
1ST STOP GAS STATION E - ST THOMAS. VI
THE HOME DEPOT #8201 - ST THOMAS, VI
ITHE HOME DEPOT #8201 - ST THOMAS. VI
THE HOME DEPOT 8201 - SANT THOMAS, VI
'FOOD CENTER SUPERMARKET FOOD CENTER SU - ST. THOMAS. VI
FOOD CENTER SUPERMARKET FOOD CENTER SU - ST. THOMAS. VI
IKMART • ST THOMAS, VI
M.M. ELECTRIC CO., INC. • ST THOMAS. VI
PRICESMART - ST THOMAS. VI
THE HOME DEPOT .3201 - ST THOMAS, VI
THE HOME DEPOT18201 - ST THOMAS. VI
WALGREENS #13846 003013846 - ST THOMAS, VI
!SHERVVIN WILLIAMS 702872 2872 - ST THOMAS, \l
The Plum Card& /January 18, 2019 to February 12, 2019
Amount Racelpt tNl
179.130
130.153I
,•••
b,•
_
/1.-Q •
;7)21/4 LC5
•5 /404
o .1 t-
et.'
23.99C /-7,:<//,/7/ • .<-;
I"'411De.• 5.08 • /
•d. /F.
mei 1„
148.78
x g cics Yoz-, N1QC‘01 •
130.37 Cr ) 4:2'7* k isd t 334.49
b v"t CkZc d-At
21.48
93.41
71: -
79;
t /2,
44.07
/
190 OB.
S'itcf kc n e cc. ,
95.66
i -
H'
S -4 St,
lei
•
Pc<
L., .Apr:;
y,-..PL
4 &
98 96
2'00 /A
165.00
4/( 7, a 369.891
56.92
2Y.• 17;lie* cc, 124.59'
74,,,dcyp 44.50'
01 ye: 499 oo,

╭────────────────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────────────────────╮
│ “Transaction Details ~The Plum Card / January 18, 2018 to February 12, 2019 │
│ “cicyy] Prepared for                                                        │
│ [rcs Carlos L Rodriguez                                                     │
│ e ‘Account Number                                                           │
│ i                                                                           │
│                                                                             │
│ Doe Recolpt Desesiption                                                     │
│ mo TREN HRT US HBAATAWGE - AMZN GOMTBILL, WA                                │
│ c2rer2019 Aan Mc Ue M718 -ANZHOOM WA                                        │
│ ozerz010 [Tie voweperor ann -sr ouna                                        │
│ lozeraore WESTERN AUTO S047 5047 -ST THOMAS, V                              │
│ loaorr2019 | | FOOD CENTER SUPERMARKET FOOD CENTER SU -ST. THOMAS,          │
│ loaorreo10 ' 'MOES FRESH MARKET -ST THOMAS, VI                              │
│ Jozorr20r9 | freescuonrer am er reo                                         │
│ Joaver2010 {1ST STOP GAS STATION E -ST THOMAS,                              │
│ comsr20r9 JAMzN NTP US"MB:IM48K72 -AZN.COMIEIL, WA                          │
│ Jo2cer2010 ‘AMZN RKTP USMD621702- AMZN COMPIL, WA                           │
│ carsr2010 |Awzn mire us'MB70S:WIN2 - AMZN COMPAL, WA                        │
│ c2r6r2010 |WESTERN AUTO So47 $047 -ST THOMAS, VL                            │
│ oaosi20%0 {ST STOP GAS STATION E- ST THOMAS, VI                             │
│ earsr20%0 | eve eroremi- er Tours                                           │
│ oonsraor9 [He vowe neror stan -or moans.                                    │
│ consraor9 “THE HOME DEPOT 8201. SAINT THOMAS,                               │
│ oamaraor0 |FoOD CENTER SUPERMARKET FOOD CENTER SU - ST. THOMAS, VI          │
│ Joaoarz010 "FOOD CENTER SUPERMARKET FOOD CENTER SU- ST. THOMAS, Vi          │
│ Jo2oar2019 | [rar ST THOMAS,                                                │
│ Joaoarz010 : 'MM, ELECTRIC 60, INC ST. THOMAS, V                            │
│ lozoavzors [recess rious                                                    │
│ Jozoaraors “TE HOME DEPOT #8201 - ST THOMAS, V                              │
│ oanarz0r9 [Revonc ocroraton sr icuns                                        │
│ Jo2oaraor9 WALGREENS #13846 000019846 - ST THOMAS. VI                       │
│ Joaozract9 | |SHERWAN WILLIAMS 7026722872 ST THOMAS, Vi                     │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

02/01/2019 01/3112019 01/312019
PLAZA
EXTRA
TUTU
PARK
- ST
THOMAS,
VI
AMZN
MKTP
USWBACO9UPI
- AMZN.COWBILL.
WA
THE
HOME
DEPOT
- ST
THOMAS,
VI
43.44
V
ttS

O
E'S Vit
S
VI=
\WI
t
•no
s
ilia
728.10
Ji
N
Iti
cS
01/312019
THE
HOME
DEPOT
- SAINT
THOMAS.
VI
206.22'
—
•
-
;C
:—.
/. 1. • I ,
/
•
(e//
,
4/.6
.
01/30/2019
OFFICEMAXIDEPOT

• SAINT
THOMAS,
VI
73.43
71/c
01/30/2019
1THE
HOME
DEPOT
• ST
THOMAS,
VI
67.571
/It
.• • 4
,/,.
„.,
f•-•
01/3012019
THE
HOME
DEPOT
- SAINT
THOMAS,
VI
-90.34
;13,./c•
01/2912019
;FOOD
CENTER
SUPERMARKET
FOOD
CENTER
SU
- ST.
THOMAS.
VI
34.91
<17
0129/2019
GAS
WORKS
WC-
ST
THOMAS.
VI
96.13
2c
IC
01/29/2019
SEA
CHEST
ACE
HARDWARE
- ST
THOMAS,
VI
24.991
/

• •
01/29/2019
THE
HOME
DEPOT
N8201
• ST
THOMAS,
VI
C.)
864.12
/
ref>.
T
1 4ri
(
0129/2019
THE
HOME
DEPOT

• SAINT
THOMAS.
VI
973.80i
I
<
A,.
01/28/2019
MART
- ST
THOMAS.
VI
(#1,4,
/
/
01/28/2019 01/28/2019
;THE
HOME
DEPOT
#8201
- ST
THOMAS.
VI
THE
HOME
DEPOT
#8201

• ST
THOMAS.
VI
1.068.49
A
s 1;,,
• e-/,'•
/
/1761
/
50.28
iv
-1
C
it
0/S
0124/2019
1ST
STOP
EAST
• ST
THOMAS.
VI
89.96;
/ A6
01/24/2019
KMART
- ST
THOMAS.
VI
87.98
C.-1
.
C/:
-•:‘
•
01/24/2019
;THE
HOME
DEPOT
#8291

• ST
THOMAS.
VI
148.35!
)
• \
0123/2019
SEA
CHEST
ACE
HARDWARE
- ST
THOMAS,
VI
29.99
9,
;
,
birei
/4.
//
/
-1Acc
0123/2010 01/22/2019
1THE
HOME
DEPOT
#8201

• ST
THOMAS.
VI
AWN
MKTP
UW102017810
AMIN.COMMILL,
WA
128.68;
'
1 r
71/5r.;
f
1.1
Xi
/2
24.70
n--11
-1)9
O
01/2212019
1OFFICEMAXEDEPOT

• SAINT
THOMAS.
VI
113.761
Sic
01/22/2019
WESTERN
AUTO
- ST
THOMAS,
VI
1cAk...
C
tt••::
2,,iv
C1/46
01/18/2019
/
•
1.
BOLONGO
BAY
BEACH
CLUB
? ST.
THOMAS.
VI
/e
S1zr
8"
1lZt
7b
/-PS"
01/18/2019
FRANKS
LOCKS
KEY
FRANKS
LOCKS
KE
- ST
THOMAS.
PR

jPe
CS.~.-S.•.-/7t;
.
Mey
/- new
/7«'
j1( L.
01/18/2019
THE
HOME
DEPOT
- SAINT
THOMAS,
VI

kylc
`1ST
cec.c
c•-‘0
•1S
-12.3-
S
it 90-
01/18/2019
THE
HOME
DEPOT
8201-
SAINT
THOMAS,
VI
,,
•
494.12
y
c
lic.,
6,
sit

ce,
As 0 7,/,‘
M-
,
-
hth
j4
/to
;THE
HOME
DEPOT
#8201
- ST
THOMAS,
VI
19A41
x
8,956.10:
amazon.com
Final Details for Order #114-6556819-5033821
Print this page for your records.
Order Placed: February 8, 2019
Amazon.com order number: 114-6556819-5033821
Order Total: $27.31
Shipped on February 11, 2019
Items Ordered
21 of: 2 1/4 die., 3/8-16 thds., Five Prong Plastic Knob w/Black Polypropylene
Thru Hole Zinc Plated Steel Hex Nut (1 Each)
Sold by: Essentra Components (formerly Reid Supply Co.) (seller profile)
Condition: New
Shipping Address:
Carlos odri uez
United States
Shipping Speed:
Standard Shipping
Price
$0.81
Item(s) Subtotal: $17.01
Shipping & Handling: $10.30
Total before tax: $27.31
Sales Tax: $0.00
Total for This Shipment:$27.31
Payment information
Payment Method:
American Express I Last digits:
Billing address
United States
Credit Card
transactions
Item(s) Subtotal: $17.01
Shipping & Handling: $10.30
Total before tax: $27.31
Estimated tax to be collected: $0.00
Grand Total:$27.31
AmericanExpress ending in February 11, 2019: $27.31
To view the status of your order, return to Order Summary.
Conditions of thy: I Privacy NvPce  0 1996.2019, Amazon.com, Inc. or Its affiliates
amaon.com
Final Details for Order #114-0401636-8900228
Print this page for your records.
Order Placed: February 8, 2019
Amazon.com order number: 114-0401636-8900228
Order Total: $179.60
Shipped on February 9, 2019
0200e ceoetotAD
O A- covtite
Items Ordered Price
1 of: SHD Commercial Ozone Generator 3500mg •••• 7000mg O3 Air Purifier $159.50
Industrial Ozone Machine Car Deodorizer Sterilizer for Home Hotel Farm
Sold by: SHD TECH (seller profile)  I Product question? Ask Seller
Condition: New
Shipping Address: Item(s) Subtotal: $159.50
arlos odri uez Shipping & Handling: $20.10
United States
Shipping Speed:
Two-Day Shipping
Total before tax: $179.60
Sales Tax: $0.00
Total for This Shipment:$179.60
Payment information
Payment Method:
American Express I Last digits:
Billin address
United States
Credit Card
transactions
Item(s) Subtotal: $159.50
Shipping & Handling: $20.10
Total before tax: $179.60
Estimated tax to be collected: $0.00
Grand Total:$179.60
AmericanExpress ending in February 9, 2019:$179.60
To view the status of your order, return to Order Summary.
Conditions of (i ce I Privacy Notice e 1996-2019, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00057 19182 02/08/19 08:30 AN'
SELF CHECK OUT
783110231969 BLKWIRE <A> 4.75
16GA BLK ALAMBRE REBAR TIE WIRE 3.1
4715409150572 CABLE TIES <A> 4.35
CE 14" NATURAL CABLE TIE 20PK
099713048744 3'X50'GRNWIR <A> 51.7?
3')(50' 16GA GRN PVC COAT WELDED WIRE
SUBTOTAL 60.83
SALES TAX 0.00
TOTAL 560.83
XXXXXXXXXXX2050 AMEX
USDS 60.83
AUTH CODE 803236/4573545 TA
AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
8211011115117111 1111121!!!!!0/6
RETURN POLICY DEFINITIONS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON
A 1 90 05/09/2019
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN
A $5,000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espahol
www.homedepot.com/survey
User ID: 2PX3 46854 38710
PASSWORD: 19108 38653
Entries must be completed within 14 days
of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or
older to enter. See complete rules on
website. No purchase necessary.
Page 1 of l
Advance N
Auto Partshv g Service is our best part.
Store 4 05047
4603 TUTU PARK
ST THOMAS VI 00802 (340) 775-4400
02/03/19 l3:00 REG 02 TRN4 S940 Kishanel
DIEM. EXHAUST FLUID 2. 10082203
OEF002 I $15.99 $15.99
BUN 1 Get 1 at 50% off
DIESEL EXHAUST FLUID 2. 10082203
DEF002 1 58 00 28 00
Buy I Get 1 at 50x off
You saved $7.99
Sub Total $23.99
Total $23.99
623.19 PURCHASE 0 1:01 PR
AREA  2IIIIENIF REA
AUDI $69765 Approved REF 5047023910ot
OW CARD I HERON 129301 TERN 60000002
Issuer IC FF7CICSETESCHISI
AID
Hpi
Standard Revokee s con:toter 84600 purchase
Standard Revolvtna
Standard 29.99% APR wilt. reaular poNmenTA
Cusloner Signature
AA
V,"
ti? ,
2e_d .Le‘ii_ft
I
FOOD CENTER
STA-LOMAS, USVI
(340) 7770806
Cashier: JOSETTE W.
TRANSACTION 99990731816 RESUMED
GROCERY '.
GROCERY 7.99 FA
GROCERY 35.00 FA
FIJI WATER (CASE) 31.99 F
SWEET N LON SWEETNER 3.49 FA
SWEET N LOW SWEETNER 3.49 FA
SWEET N LOW SWEETNER 3.49 FA
GATORADE STRAWBERRY 6 PK 5.99 FA GATORADE STRAWBERRY 6 PK 5.99 FA GATORADE STRAWBERRY 6 PK 5.99 FA GATORADE STRAWBERRY 6
PK 5.99 FA ST JOHN BREWERS ROO1BEER
40.56 FA ST JOHN BREWERS ROOTBEER -40.56 VD
SUBTOTAL 117.40
TOTAL 117.40 CREDIT CARD 117.40 CREDIT ACCT 0.00
Item Count 11
All Returns Must Be Within 24 Hours Receipt is Required
THANK YOU!
Date Time Lane Clerk Trans e 02/07/19 08:52 AM 3 121 81
I
Welcome To
Moe's Fresh Market
18A-2 Estate Smith Bay St.Thomas USVI
340-693-0254
Cashier: SHENAE J.
GATORADE FRUIT PUNCH
2 P 2.19
GATORADE LEMON LIME
1 8 .62
4.38 FA
0.62 FA
SUBTOTAL 5.00
TOTAL 5.00
CREDIT ACCT 1..°n00 ,_ CREDIT CARO
You Saved $1.57 Item Count 3
Thank You for Shopping y!!
RETURNS
1 Day on Perishables
7 Days On Dry or Nonfood Goods
Must Have Original Purchase Receipt
Date Time Lane Clerk Trans S
02/07/19 09:42 AM 2 21 50
CUSTOMER COPY
Moe's Fresh Market
Red Hook St. Thomas UM
Tnursday, February.W, 2019 9:42:47 AM
MID 365083 TID 00000002
Sequsnce U 020207134242
AMERICAN E4 8
Chip Read
Total USD: $5.00 APPROVED 824334
Mode:
AID:
TVR: IAD: 06480103A02002
TSI: E800
ARC: 3030
Lane b 2 Checker U 21 Trans I 50
The Issuer of this Card is authorized
to pay the amount shown as 'Total'
upon proper, presentation.
I promise to pay this total
subject to and in accordance
with the agr2ement governing
the use of this Card.
PURCHASE
X Cardholder Signature
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00038 33134 02/07/19 03:35 PM
CASHIER SiENOVIA
1002-147-510 12X12 FILE =As 17.22
12X12 POLARIS BLANCA-CA-'12.39 SF
0000-745-075 18X18 TILE 4A>
18X18 PLANETA-21.52 SOFT-CA
2020.90 41.80
SUBTOTAL 59 2
SALES TAX 0..000
TOTAL $59.02
XOXXXXXXXX2C60 AMEX
USDS 59.02
AU1 El 0 .147 25 TA
AID NEIMAN EXPRESS
820 3o "3134 02,0.' 0 2024
RETURN POLICY OEFINI OHS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON
A
DRAYS
S IC 08/2019
.. . xxXXXAAFAXAIAXAKFA.FAA• AltAAXIkkin
Ula) WE NAIL IT'?
Take a shirt survey for a chance TO WIN
A $5,000 HOME DEPOT G1Ff CARD
Opine en espahol
www.homedepot.com/surveY
User ID: M89 7475.5 66595
PASSWORD: 19107 65557 .
Entries must he completed within 14 ddyt
of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or
older to miter. See complete rules on
website. No purchase necessary.
WELCOME TO
FIRST STOP EAST
VP130074 11001
VeriFone Gold Disk
V3c•I'FL
Description 0ty Amount
PREMIUM CA 1108 21.0596 80.00
SELF 3.798/ G
Subtotal 80.00
Tax 0.00
TOTAL 80_00
CASH $ 80.00
THANKS
: 9 \MX 12Ax i TRANI' 1013258
02/06/19 09:15:11
amazon.coni
Final Details for Order #114-7758457-0853006
Print this Dage for your records.
Order Placed: February 6, 2019
Amazon.com order number: 114-7758457-0853006
Order Total: ;146.76
Shipped on February 6, 2019
ft. pi /"1
Items Ordered Price
2 of: 48 Pack - Crest Travel -Sized Pro-Health Mouthwash, 1.22 oz.
Sold by: Travel Toiletry Kits (seller orofile)
Condition: New
Shipping Address:
Carlos odri uez
United States
$50.38
Item(s) Subtotal: $100.76
Shipping & Handling: $46.00
Total before tax: $146.76
Sales Tax: $0.00
Shipping Speed: Total for This Shipment:6146.76
Standard Shipping
Payment information
Payment Method:
American Express I Last digits:
Billin address
United States
Credit Card
transactions
Item(s) Subtotal: $100.76
Shipping & Handling: $46.00
Total before tax: $146.76
Estimated tax to be collected: $0.00
Grand Total:$146.76
AmericanExpress ending in February 6, 2019: $146.76
To view the status of your order, return to Order Summary.
Conditions of Use I privacy Notice 0 1996-2019, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates
amazon.com
Final Details for Order #114-6018750-8926643
Print this Page for your records.
Order Placed: February 6, 2019
Amazon.com order number: 114-6018750-8926643
Order Total: $130.37
Shipped on February 7, 2019
Items Ordered Price
1 of: OFF! Family Care, Insect Repellent II Clean Feel, 6 oz ( Pack of 24 )
Sold by: Pharrnapacks (seller work)
Condition: New
Brand New
Shipping Address:
Carlos odri uez
United States
$121.84
Item(s) Subtotal: $121.84
Shipping & Handling: $0.00
Total before tax: $121.84
Sales Tax: $8.53
Shipping Speed: Total for This Shipment:$130.37
Standard Shipping
Payment information
Payment Method:
American Express I Last digits:
Blinn address
United States
Credit Card
transactions
Item(s) Subtotal: $121.84
Shipping & Handling: $0.00
Total before tax: $121.84
Estimated tax to be collected: $8.53
Grand Total:$130.37
AmericanExpress ending in : February 7, 2019:$130.37
To view the status of your order, return to Order Summary.
Conditions of Use I Privacy Noticq  1996-2019, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates
anuttrn.com.
.11L3Final Details for Order #114-3592417-1816261
) 9Albr
Print this page for your records.
Order Placed: February 6, 2019 914P(5  rAmazon.com order number: 114-3592417-1816261
Order Total: $334.49
Shipped on February 11, 2019
Items Ordered Price
5 of: Oral-B FlossAction Electric Toothbrush Replacement Brush Head Refill (3 $37.99
count)
Sold by: Amazon.com Services, Inc
Condition: New
3 of: Gillette Fusion5 ProGlide Men's Razor Blades, 12 Blade Refills
Sold by: Amazon.com Services, Inc
Condition: New
2 of: Crest Ph 3d Wht Tp Arctc Size 4.8z Crest Pro Health 3d White
Toothpaste Arctic Fresh 4.8z
Sold by: Common Cents Distributors beller orotile)
Condition: New
Shipping Address:
Carlos odri uez
United States
Shipping Speed:
FREE Shipping
$28.49
$19.90
Item(s) Subtotal: $315.22
Shipping & Handling: $8.26
Free Shipping: -$8.26
Total before tax: $315.22
Sales Tax: $19.27
Total for This Shipment:$334.49
Payment information
Payment Method:
American Express I Last digits:
Billin address
United States
Credit Card
transactions
Item(s) Subtotal: $315.22
Shipping & Handling: $8.26
Free Shipping: -$8.26
Total before tax: $315.22
Estimated tax to be collected: $19.27
Grand Total:$334.49
AmericanExpress ending in February 11, 2019:$334.49
To view the status of your order, return to Order Summary.
Advance>: AutoPartskeir Service is our best part.
Store 11 05047
4603 TUTU PARK ST THOMAS VI 00802 (340) 775-4400 02/06/19 8.44 REG 01 TM 9906 SANDRA R.
Troller Hitch Behing 1 10721504 45405 I 514 99 $14.99 ND Hitch Pin/City 1 EA 11873194 21506 1 56.49 56.49 I YR 
REPLACEMENT IF DEFECTIVE
Sub Total 521.48 Total 521.48 $21.48 PURCHASE 41 8:48 OR 8th F441 CHIP REO RUIN 880405 Approved REF 504701000801 DV CARD
I REACH 128383 IRO 00000001 Issuer IC
83112458838EMEE
22NV2184R1INMO
Standard Revolving [snowier 84600 Purchase Standard Revolving Standard 29.995 APR with resulor payments
Customer Signature
0/u J~bwc&yL WELCOME TO
FIRST STOP EAST
1/N30074,1001
VeriFone Gold Disk
FL
Description Qty Amount
PREMIUM CA 008 24.610G 93.49
SELF 3.799/ G
Subtotal 93.49
Tax 0.00
TOTAL 93.49
CASH $ 93.49
THANKS
STS ABI23 TILL XXXX DRS 1 TRAM0 1012915 CSH: 9 02/05/19 08:59:04
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077 USYI
8201 00037 39729 02/05/19 01:35 PM CASHIER RITA
887480073003 GALVWAHSER <A> 17.47 WASHER CUT 1/2 GALV BOX-50PK CXG 1/2X1OLGSCRO <A> LAG
.32
SCREW GALV 1/2%10 945 26.60
SUBTOTAL 44.07 SALE 0 S .TAX .0007TOTAL $44XXXXXXXXXXx2050 AMEX
Lig* 44.07
AID 243A
MERICAII EXPRESS
JUN RETURN POLICY GIFFIN! IQ% POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON A 1 90 05/06/2019
RitAX2****IMSNAJIANARMAAllaklEt*IANAX
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN A $5,000 NOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en esnallol
www.homederat.com/su'vey
User ID: W53 87948 79784 PASSWORD: 19105 79747
Entries must be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
rebsite. No purchase necessary.
e "7 • -2
tpi -/Q /y", --k
S/rr
More saving.
More doing."
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00059 32439 02/05/19 12:15 PM
SELF CHECK OUT
074523503034 3 IN SWIVEL 4A>
3' NON-MARKING SWIVEL RUBBER CASTER 10.10.56 190.08
SUBTOTAL 190.08
SALES TAX 0.00
TOTAL $190.08 XXXXXXXXXXX2050 AMEX
USES 190.08
TA
AAUTIDt 2CSABWRICAN EXPRESS
I III 8201 59 32439 02/05/2019 5350
RETURN POLICY DEFINITIONS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON A 1 90 05/06/2019
ssysstssssassssrassssimmsssxxsxsIssssw
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN A $5.000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espatol
wiew.homedepot.com/survey
User ID: 2PX3 73368 65226
PASSWORD: 19105 65167
Entries must be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
website. No purchase necessary.
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00039 75935 02/05/19 08:40 AM
CASHIER KARIMAN A'
000346397 31.61 000 NKLT12 <A>
Viii IC \‘ e•-• --
BOSCH DAREDEVIL 3/4 X 17- NIGER ‘
000346397185 NAST12 alp. 17.98.--#.a.
BOSCH DAREDEVIL AUGER 3/4-X7-1/2" TO
037103136657 7200 GUN cA> 22.97'
v-WELLER 75W SOLDERING GAIN
KIT
ACID SOLDER <t 11.27 >ig.
BERN200ArIC 302 LF ACID CORE SOLDER
070042196337 LEAOEIJ5OLOER <A> 11.83
BEPN20MATIC 60/40 LEADED WIRE SOLDER
SUBTOTAL 95.66
SALES TAX 0.00
TOT
XXXXXXXXX1X2050 AMEX $95.66
USD$ 95.66
AID
AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
TA
jull-121511ni RE URN POLICY DEFIN IONS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON
A 1 90 05/06/2019
&A* XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN
A $5,030 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espahol
www.hon‘Depot.com/strvey
User ID: HXY 160360 152198
PASSWORD: 19105 152159
Entries must be condoted within 14 days
of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or
ulder to enter. See complete rules on
website. No percharse necessary.
FOOD CENTER
ST.THOKAS, USVI

(340) 777-8806
Cashier: JOSETTE N.
ACOUA PANNA SPRING WATER
ADOUA PANNA SPRING WATER
VOSS WATER@ 1.5$4.99 PINT 4
3.29 FA >j
3.29 FA 19.96 FA
SUBTOTAL 26.54 TOTAL 26.54
CREDIT CARD 26.54
CREDIT ACCT 0.00
Item Count 6
All Returns Must Be Within 24 Hours
Recelgoiratired
Date The Lane Clerk Trans (I
02/04/19 08:54 AM 3 121 84
04TH
FOOD wool
26 ESTATE MAIM
SI NUM
IMF Tilt IDiT
Fab 04.19 $16:94:26 ADS
MIDI TIMM. ID IERCIMI ID
DOSS S'9081 9300041641
SALE
ACCT.
maborns.2050
CODE: 861616 INCE: EfIVEC
D*1
Tom, * 26.54
SIGNARIRE:
AMNION DMUS
rarrinsv..cas",rcre: CADDO.DER FOOOLECISES RECEIPT CF GOSS
NAM SERVICE IN III PIMA OF DE TOIL
SHOW HEWN MEI AMES TO PERFORM TM
03LICATIONS SET FORM IN TIE CMINCLLADES
KISSES KITH TIE ISSUER
CISIOMR COPY
Gracia Ace m manorial
RE
- OATH FOOD CENTER
ST.THOMAS, USVI
(340) 777->:06
Cashier: MIGSELANGE P. FOOD CENTER
ESTATE FFFNENII0J
ST MOMS
MN I NE AZT
Feb MIS IL4F:38 ADC
BATCH !EVANS ID mRamia ID
WAS XEFAII080 SIONFilal
SALT
PRODUCE 10.99 FA tr_52>:lid///
SOFT SCRUB CLEASER OXI 5.19
SOFT SCRUB CLEASER OXI 5.19 A
SOFT SCRUB CLEASER OXI 5.19 A
Fluvlial0Veli
.1
USER: Nell
ACCT.
NEM AannumARFICR
SOH SCRUB CLEASER OXI 5,19 A
SOFT SCRUB CLEASER OXI 5.19 A
SOFT SCRUB CLEASER OXI 5.19 A
••• IW1  ENIRY u. SOFT SCRUB CLEASER OXI 5.19 A
HERSHEYS CARAMEL 11 02 5.99 FA
Ant elf: 121560 MEE: 612425 HERSHEY'S KISSES ALMOND 6.29 FA
ME *143 HERSHEY MINI BIG SAG 19.7501 7.99 FA
HERSHEY MINI BIG BAG 19.7502 7.99 FA ST---
TOTS : • 03. S?
HERSHEY MINI BIG BAG 19.7501 7.99 FA
I SUBTOTAL 83.51
SIGNAILS: 83.57
CREDIT CAROTOTAL 83.57
CRADNOLDER ADOCUILGES SCRIPT OF 5016 CREDIT ACCT 0.00
FRIAR SERVICE IN THE MUFF IN THE TOTAL
SKEIN KNEW NID AGREES TO PERES" DIE Item Count 13
03LICATICIC SET MTh IN TEE CORCHOWER'S
KAFKA' WIN DE ISSFR All Returns Wist Be Within 24 Hours
ClalaiR CCEY Receipt Is Required
GriN IM P µ Petra Late THANK YOU!
Date Time Lane Clerk Trans I
02/04/19 11:47 AM 1 126 88
It mart.
BIG RIORI STOP( 3829
CHAFI.OTIE ARAL IE
ST MINOS. VI 00802
t HOMY -3853
**et Mark 45 ,J For *NIA
Nell shove b o ai !four kwarf *ea
\ 6) S 6ENERAiHERCHANK5E
CASHIER: RAYANt BA °° JJJ
30041666630 IR.SAR SOFT
7 @ 1:9 49 66.43
30041668066 1 I. CROSS TB
5 8 1:6 49 32.45
01200073(48 1. 1 1" BAG FEE .10
**a* FAX  00 BAL 98 98
kkXxXXXXXXX205(
AR APPROVAL 5,1.668
ENTRY METHOD: I
IF AX
'RANGE
98.98
a
.0
TO TA UMBER 01 EMS = 13
I agree that thus sale is subject to
the cardholder mireeneril issued bw
0, 4 cord ars:it/id. .
RECEIRTI 038;9 020419 008 51630
02/04/19 8:24 AN 3829 08 5163 0125
Receipt dated t I thin 30 days required
• For most re furl i. 1'4'e:changes. See
Service Desk of gnarl .con for comele. e
eel & except! Ions
)4141009110004NICIANNK44101*1001M******)•N
WE E0811011
if***)****301**1000E3OEMIOEMM*W301300.*
Lei is -ow Ina we did by
taking .• r(ttbeck s'rves at

LW. i a- .Feeigacq con
You mild °En $600 in Slia
Points. &Ignition rids at end
of amp) dantt.. Void shore
prohibit ed. eider without waking
a Rrchene ail dilinn arPlete details.
see Ofitcial Rules at
M.M.ELECTRIC CO INC.
9154 Estate Thomas
P.O.Box 302640
St THOMAS VI 00803
774-7793 779-7980 FAX
Sold To:
Invoice Date: 02/04/2019 Time: 11:03 0002
Number: 397064 Page 02
Reference:
Account:
Salesperson: 0002
Ship Via:
Ship To Telephone:
r item Number Item Description Quantity Unit
Price Extended
Price
12-4S
50 Item(s)
12-4 SJEOOW CORDS 50 3.30 165.00
Sub Total 165.00
Total 165.00
Credit Card 165.00
Credit Card Agreement
I agree to pay the total amount above
according to the card issuer(s)
agreement(s),
X --
MS SS S Z, fed
IMP
.111 lit. IL. In DC
bin
ST. 11101V1. VI OGROI
I I. taot In. uoutmutu.iotreo
. ID OF.F..431gl
S.Iit lic% Ivo •
Sale
479t7(4031
kILUCKAAIATAr.:.: OYWCNI Orkt SS
rovafis /111His All I .314.t.'..
Alt.:
.14A . tot
To :0300002.472
dal. k Dr:
Total: Uxi
JO:IA.11(n'
11:10:”
halt 11:101541
16.01
20% TO RESTOCK, NO RETURN AFTER 30 DAYS
RETURNED CHECKS CHARGE $50.00 DOLLARS
.•.
PRIcEskAar Members,.*Shopping
PriceSnart St Thomas
26-2A Estate Charlotte Estate
St Thomas. USVI 00802
. .
Tel: 340-777-3430
Terminal # 8
Mon - Sat 9:00am 8:00pa f‘c
Sunday 9:00am - 6:00k191".
000000585561 C ' • 45i. Y CCSale
6 183812 Tide0riwina
5 25835 Spray Starch
4 673254 Raid Elk 3p
337555 Sponge 21pic
3029 Clorox 2
suarratd.
AMCANT DUE
35.18 E
63.96 E
200.94 E
26.45 E
43.16 E
369.69
369.69
Amex 369.69
CHANGE O - OO
Total Items: 21
C• • Total Rewards you would have earned it you
were a Pla nun Member:
7.39
Member 4 810 0622540001
Thank You for shopping at PriceSmart
We are always happy to serve you
Retunds within 30 days with receipt
02/04/2019 10:17 8101 008 0037 81013435 004
More saving.
More doing:
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00059 31472 02/04/19 11:27 AM
SELF CHECK CUT
049000009774 20 02. WATER <A> 1.98
2002 DASANI WATER
785007855173 TL PLUG <A> 23.94
30A 125/250V BLK8WHT GROUNDING PLUG
785007857696 TL OUTLET <A> 31.00
30A BLK NYLON LOCKING SINGLE OUTLET
SUBTOTAL 56.92
SALES TAX 0.00
TOTAL $56.92
W000000000(2050 AMEX
USC$ 56.92
AUTH CODE 808728/8592071 TA
AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
1 1111111111111111111111111 I 8201 59 31472 02/04/2019 2795
RETURN POLICY DEFINI IONS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON
A 1 90 05/05/2019
VIOCIIIIWWWOMIX* ****** ******21fItiltukiiiiit
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN
A $5,000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espatol
www.homedepot.com/su"veY
User ID: 2PX3 71434 63292
PASSWORD: 19104 63233
Entries must be completed within 14 days
of pi/these. Entrants must be 18 or
older to enter. See complete rules on
website. No purchase necessary.
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HONE DEPOT (340)777-1077
USYI
8201 00004 85888 02/04/19 10:42 AN CASHIER MARIMAH
731161007248 24 SHELF <A> 59.77 KIX PLASTIC 5 SHELF STORAGE UNIT 24" 757037212837 ORANGE GLO <A> ORANGE7.48 44.88
GLO W/SPRAYER 320Z 1.1et a K ee60 086364541472 CUSHION MAT <A> 21(3' SOFT FOOT CUSHION MAT - GRAY 299.97 19.94 - fl,k; 
/14 SUBTOTAL 124.59 TALESS  TAX
$124.59
0.00
XXX/0000000(2050 AMEX
USO$ 124.59 AUTHS0 1154 TA AID IIMINIMMI AMERICAN EXPRESS
e .
8201 04 85 2/042019 7705 it RE URN POLICY CEFINI IONS POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON A 1 90 05/05/2019
OntAxXIKKA*IAAStallxVIA*****XIMMAzdt*ERR
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short strvey for a chance TO WIN A 85,000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARO
Opine en espanol
www.homedepot.com/survey
User ID: H89 180266 172069 PASSWORD: 19104 172065
Entries must be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
(eel:site. No purchase necessary.
413846 4030 ARRAS RETREAT ST THOMAS, VI 00 9255 802 340-7/7-
222 2464 0071 02/04/2019 8:32 AM
ORAL 8 PRO HLTH CRPCT CLN T8 30041010376 OTC 6.58 SALE 2 0 3.29 REGULAR PRICE 5.99 SAVINGS 5.40 RETURN VALUE 3.29 ea 
ORAL B HEALTHY CLEAN SOFT Hi 30041010317
OTC 1.49 RETURN VALUE 1.49 ORAL B PRO HLTH VII ADV TB SOFT 30041010502 OTC 14.97 3 4 4.99 RETURN VALUE 4.99 as ORAL B 30
WHT VIVO HEO TB 30041664766 OTC 14.97 3
0 4.99 RETURN VALUE 4.99 ea ORAL 8 PRO HLTH ALL IN 1 MED T8 30041668066 OTC 6.49 RETURN VALUE 6.49
TOTAL 44.50 AMEX ACCT 44.50 CHANGE .00
STORE ADVERTISED SAVINGS 5.40
THANK YOU FOR SHOPPING Al WALGREENS
YOU MOLD HAVE EARNED AN ADDITIONAL 8000 POINTS BY USING YOUR BALANCE REWARDS CARD TODAY. RESTRICTIONS APPLY. FOR TERMS 
AND CONDITIONS, VISIT
WALGREENS.COH/BALANCE.
NOT A HERBER? JOIN NOW AT ANY REGISTER, OR GO TO OALEREENS.COM/BALANCE. ENROLLING IS CAJICXEASY AND FREE! REDEEM POINTS 
FOR DuLLARS OFF FUTURE PURCHASES.
RHO 1384-6712-4645-1902-0403
1110111111M111111111111111M1111111111111111
• TOTAL SAVINGS SAVINGS VALUE
ewarcl 15.40
IIX
How are we do i nw? Enter our eonthly sweepstakes for $3 .000 cash
Visit WWW.WALGREENSLISTENS.COH
or call toll free 1-800-219-7451 within 72 hours to take a short survey about this Nalgreens visit
SLPVEYt 1384-6712-464
PASSWOPO
ASHERININ-WILLIAMS. 5) note 5toce 2t72
7e) ESTAIT BOVUMi BUIG
ST >MAS II 00802
(340)774-6912
f-ax (340) 714-2989
wiem.sherwin-willta2s.c.u.
SAO::
'à-au 1 12.28-0 ;47:1211,3
Ii23114.302
KelAS
LITILE el JAVIS
Account XXXX-5670-!,
Joh LITTlf St JAPES 1,:Q
!:I ::i• Sr .iidEs
i :Z!
'Mg, a pote
en9-414/(iffritiralii -------
shenum %el? SlAtib
1.0e: (4 torentr Serai' Fe lialAiN41105:7!
aie:fat 8EittUi TAX
Sri MX: ij.krailtrleu
WOU.
C .
efflue ,:e9ESS
&tri xxxxmAxe2ce; f4e Re,&j.
4Q:frateNhrhiebOl
Matit:413
eapikineefra
Sien MUS Elee 10:00 Fil • .5:40 hll
»aie Loo - 5:00'r0
iteink You
recuisit requ%recltor refond
LSJE, LLC 6100 • s. Suite B-3. St. Thomas. VI 00802-1348
Phone: E-mail: thesaintjames.groupAgmail.com
Missing Invoice Form
Invoices to substantiate credit card transactions are required. This form is to be used when a required original invoice
is not available. Purchaser should make
every attempt to obtain an invoice before using this form. Repeated use of this form as substitute documentation could 
result in revocation of your LSJE, LLC
Credit Card.
Vendor:
Vendor Address:
Date of Purchase:
Items Purchased:
(0(2-9 X+ r q
`)605 - etki.1-3 MC-1I suite and ST 11-O,Am li t 008321
Purchase Amount: $ 2 - 4/
S mg \lnss "0-1-1ie3
Business Purpose:
Reason receipt is
not available:
Explain the action
steps taken to
obtain a duplicate
receipt:
Taz .."" cook-t-A- N3.0Aic.k.k.0
Lns4
As the Purchaser, by signing my name below I certify the following:

1. This purchase was made for official LSJE, LLC business.
2. I am aware that LSJE, LLC requires an original invoice for this purchase, and by completing this form, I acknowledge 
that I am in violation of LSJE. LLC
policy.
3. I understand that my LSJE, LLC Credit Card may be revoked for not providing an original invoice. 4. No reimbursement 
of this expense has been or will be
sought or accepted from any other source.
Print Purchaser Name:
Purchaser Signature:
LI G e $ ::s• 2.
_co Date: 2,/3./Y
amazon.coni
Final Details for Order #114-8887972-1965812
Print this oacie for your records,
Order Placed: January 31, 2019
Amazon.com order number: 114-8887972-1965812
Order Total: $30.00
Shipped on January 31, 2019
Items Ordered Price
1 of: Idec RR2P-U Relay 12 VAC 50/60Hz 8Pin Sold by: wegotpkl (seller profile)
Condition: Used - Very Good
Shipping Address:
Carlos odri uez
United States
q4-7 - /CI? te_
$30.00
e l f  c cs c l SyCkti
Item(s) Subtotal: $30.00
Shipping & Handling: $0.00
Total before tax: $30.00
Sales Tax: $0.00
Shipping Speed: Total for This Shipment:$30.00
Economy Shipping
Payment information
Payment Method: Item(s) Subtotal: $30.00 American Express I Last digits:
Billin addre s
United States
Credit Card
transactions
Shipping & Handling: $0.00
Total before tax: $30.00
Estimated tax to be collected: $0.00
Grand Total:$30.00
AmericanExpress ending in January 31, 2019:$30.00
To view the status of your order, return to Order Summary.
Conditions of Use I PnvaCif Notice C 1996-2019, Amazon.com, Inc. or Its affiliates
More saving.
More d • ing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340 777-1077
USVI
8201 00097 76188 0 1 11:43 AM
ORDER ID: H8201-50705
RECALL AMOUNT V 809.00
10% off Applianc
809.00 10% off Appliances $ -80.90
MUST RETURN ALL ITEMS FOR FULL REFUND
SUBTOTAL 728.10
SALES TAX 0.00
TOTAL $728.10
XXXXXXXXXXX2050 AMEX
USD$ 728.10
AUTH CODE 848595/2974347 TA
AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN
A $5,000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espanol
www.homedepot.com/survey
User ID: GVM3 160866 152762
PASSWORD: 19081 152665
Entries must be completed within 14 days
of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on
website. No purchase necessary.
Page 1 of I
SPECIAL
SERVICES
CUSTOMER
INVOICE
Store
ST
THOMAS,VI
1-2
DONOE
ROAD
SAINT
THOMAS,
VI
Phone:
(340)
777.1077
Salesperson:
TLW0893
Reviewer:
This
is
only
a
QUOTE
for
the
merchandise
and
services
printed
below.
This
becomes
an
Agreement
upon
payment
and
an
endorsement
by
a
Home
Depot
register
validation.
o
N:vro RODRIGUEZ
Phi:A*1
i
CARLOS
__.---
(
•
E— 0 iti
nair
PM"
(340)
474-4931
Company
Nan'
co
Ct!y
Jobo—ia—
carry
out
s.•
co"''
SAINT
THOMAS
Page
of
No.
H8201-50705
VALIDATION
AREA
QUOTE
is
Va
date:
01/31/2019
CARRY
OUT
MERCHANDISE
STOCK
MERCHANDISE
CARRIED
OUT:
MERCHANDISE
AND
SERVICE
SUMMARY
We
reserve
the
right
to
limit
the
quantities
of
merchandise
sold
to
customers
REF
a W02
SKU
s 0000-515-644
The
items
listed
In
this
section
will
be
carried
out
of
the
store
by
the
customer
at
time
of
sale.
REF
SKU
I
()TY
UM
DESCRIPTION
PI
TAX
PRICE
EACH
EXTENSION
RO1
1001.228.993
1.00
EA
WRT138F2DM
18'
ESTAR,
WIRE
TM,
SS
A
N
$809.00
$809.00
MERCHANDISE
TOTAL:
$809.00
END
OF
CARRY
OUT
MERCHANDISE
- REF
#W02
TOTAL
CHARGES
OF
ALL
MERCHANDISE
&
SERVICES
Policy
Id
(P1):
A:
DAYS
DEFAULT
POLICY;
'The
Home
Depot
reserves
the
right
to
limit
/ deny
returns.
Please
see
the
return
policy
sign
in
stores
for
details.'
END
OF
ORDER
No.
H8201-90705
ORDER
TOTAL
$809.00
SALES
TAX
$0.00
TOTAL
$809.00
BALANCE
DUE
$809.00
Check
your
current
order
status
online
at
www.homedepot.comlorderstatus
(980
) 0100240682
Page
of
No.
H8201-50705
Customer
Copy
MAYTAG/ WHIRLPOOL APPLIANCES WARRANTY
Thank you for choosing to purchase your appliance at The Home Depot. Your appliance comes with a ONE (1) year "FIXABLE 
WARRANTY", which means a technician has
to be first called and provide service to your appliance at your home. For ALL service requests / repairs please contact
the manufacturer DIRECTLY via phone.
They will be more than happy to assist you with processing your request. The turn around time for the call center to 
process and assign a technician to your
service request is 24-48 hrs. The technician will then contact you the customer within 24-48 hrs to schedule an 
appointment for service.
CONTACT INFORMATION
1-787-999-7400
Option 1 for new service
Option 2 for existing service/claims
Available Monday thru Friday 8AM-SPM
THANK YOU FOR SHOPPING AT THE HOME DEPOT
1 Same business day shipping
appliances l Lawn Equipment I Heating &Cooling I Vacuums
More saving.
More doing:
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00059 27355 01/31/19 12:11 PM SELF CHECK OUT
037103269980 17PCMINI HEX <A> 10.76 17PC SAE 8 MM MINI FOLD HEX KEY SET 079055259169 9/16 STAPLES <A> ARROW 9/16" CAT5 
T25 STAPLES 1000P1( 403.92 15.68
731161006401 18" 5-SHELF <A,S>
HIM PLASTIC 5 SHELF STORAGE UNIT 18" 2038.98  037000748526 BOUNTY 8 ROL <A>
77.96
BOUNTY 8 HUGE ROLL WHITE
6016.97 101.82
SUBTOTAL 206.22 SALES TAX 0.00

206. XXLXXXXXXXX2050 TOTAL AMEX $ 22
USD$ 206.22 AUTH 1676 2591939 TA AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
•
(III 8201 59 27355 01/31/2019 62 0
RETURN POLICY DEFINITIONS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON A 1 90 05/01/2019
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN A $5,000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espatol
wischomedepot.com/survey
User ID: 2PX3 63200 55058
PASSWORD: 19081 54999
Entries must be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
website. No purchase necessary.
••••-- OC.AS
Co. LEAs Els
— Ht4-6Q-Ael C
s4P1C'SQ__
Office DEPOT
OfficeMax Si THOMAS - (340) 716-36(6
01/30/2019 11:53 RH
"MI IE 11'' 1111  .11119.111
2PYT5QAP55YX88XFH
SALE 6538-3-9849-892161 18 12.2
659339 CHARGER,AC,DUA
6 8 9.99 59.94
You Paw 69.94E
257438 LEGALPA0,5X8,C 10.69E
Instant Savings -2.69
You Paw 8.00E
725844 NTBK.PLY,8.5X5 5.49 E
Subtotal: 73.43
Total: 73.43
Amex 050: 73.43
RUTH CODE 826606
TDS Chip Read
AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
TVR 0000008000
CVS No SI nature Required
Total Sav;n9s
$2.69
XXXIINIAMIK AAAAAA XIAWIXXRIAXXIXIINIKICICRIR
WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YDUI
Visit survew.officedepot.com
and enter the survey code below:
T602 MRSJ AH9R
ximszKixxxixxximnimuunixggmeeexxxxxxlmxx
GeM GSA
More saving.
More doing.
SI TH0HAE HOVE DEPOT t340)777-2077 USVI
8201 00038 11460 01/30/19 SELF CHECK OUT 11:35 AK
887460039900 1/2X6L0SCRWG <A> 67.57 LAG SCREW GALY 1/2 X 6-25PV
SUBTOTAL 67.57 SALES TAX 0.00 TOTAL $67.57 XXXXXXXXXXX2050 AIREX
USOS 67.577
IAID M*kICAH
EXPPCSS
I I1111111111! III1IIIlhIIIN CII RETURI POLICY DEFIN TIONS POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON A 1 90 04/30/2019 
AXAXAAXAAXAA)14,42AVAXXXXMAtRAKXAXAnan
DID WE NAIL IT? Take a short survey fur a chance TO WIN A 16,000 HOVE DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espafiol
User ID: H89 31410 23247 PASSWORD: 19080 23209 Entries oust be convicted wtthIr. I4 drays of pitches*. Entreats must be 
1$ or older to enter. See couplet& rules
on sebsite. No purchase necessary.
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00012 35027 01/29/19 09:05 AM CASHIER TYMIKA
if ORIG REC: 8201 037 U3196 01.28/19 TA v
008925095323 3" CUP BRSH -6.20 008925095330 3' WIREWFEEL
051411615079 BOX 64-13.25 -79.50
SUBTOTAL -90.34
SALE TAX 0. TOTAL - $90.
34 XXXXXXXXXXXX2050 ALEX -90.34 INVOICE 4122141 TA
REFUND -CUSTOMER COPY
BUY ONLINE PICK-UP IN STORE AVAILABLE NOW ON HOMEDEPOI.COM.
CONVENIENT. EASY AND MOST ORDERS READY IN LESS THAN 2 HOURS! VIttkI1CAAK*Il*Wil .)0(WfinAltAtSkt2K*XMalA*21
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance 10 WIN
A $5,000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espanel
www.homedepot.com/survey
User ID: XKH 78544 70355 PASSWORD: 19079 70343
Entries must he completed within 14 days of perchase. Entrants must be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules Of:
No pirchase necessary.
1-12,o Gs-j FOOD CENTER ST.THDMAS, USVI (340) 717-B806 Cashier: GERALOA H.
NATUR5ALIS$01e9i WATER. (CAS 34.95 F 6.
e •
SUBTOTAL. 34.95 TOTAL 34.95 CREDIT CARD 34.95 CREDIT ACCT 0.00
Item Count 5 All Returns Must Be Within 24 Hours Receipt is Required THANK YOU: Date Time Lane Clerk Trans N 01/29/19 
03:02 PH 3 129 24
so lot sob C itS W IMSINC rr r.:41 4B0 S." WC d 1S. VI 00802 :'w 01552
ae
.'ti •Isat.:ha ' .: :65 •
$96.13
:REDO' %RIP $9633 AA EX 20 a
Jan-',:( 19 • :;:52A ;9:33 islet:co BAY kls, ERIC .;
:X4XX/".% XXX) 1 ;080
:ARLa :Ofik : to I: 91; 900! ; ?0
whit: ;l4'':
Al :,:**'•""'"' ' .1123 .01v. AO: :0011; !C 10801 WATMIE t'• ' 11
3n1Ini:
•.41 `'1 t.fGMYJ6
ti

╭── Page 38, Image 1 ──╮
│ £010 Sub             │
│                      │
│ ONS WorKS INC        │
│                      │
│ STE yr 480           │
│ S$" The 48. vi oggo2 │
│ mu 54552             │
│ athier: ae           │
│ fe Y8QC hon". 265    │
│ oa $96.13            │
│ PREDIT AR $96.13     │
│                      │
│ Dlaneel 19 i594      │
│ 192.13 Metts Hay     │
│ MERIC A.V Ex         │
│ SKOKIIKN             │
│                      │
│ "ARLOS Gl            │
│ #9; 900:             │
│ Wh aoa               │
│ Act eto 9g           │
│ We:AO!20CaC | 510801 │
│ JONAT JRE FD         │
│                      │
│ Salve: ht            │
│                      │
│ 1402" GMYIB          │
│                      │
│ eee                  │
╰──────────────────────╯

tic:Dol -
Service Makei: rile Difference!
3806 Crown Bay ''el ;74-: %SS Fox 776.2547
Mos-Frk :3t : al 8.1
01/29/19 it
13:15:32 eitchtly
Ord: 41665922 :741: k87413
GFI ST RECPT TR;•3A 411;3532967)
I EA 11 2z..990 24.99
SUE. IOIAL 24.99
-A) 0.00
24.99
ANEPICA E xxxx -24.99
NO cash returns-Story Credit ONLY.NO
returns after 1E. days. Restock fee 15%.
Thank You for Your Patronage ft
MP
grotknce
6.79c rocep Arde
T---r
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00097 74209
ORDER ID: H8201-50507
01/29/19 09:31 AM
RECALL AMOUNT 864.12
SUBTOTAL 864.12
SALES TAX 0.00
TOTAL $864.12
XXXXXXXXXXX2050 AMEX
USDS 864.12
AUTH CODE 829219/4974217 TA
AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO MIN
A $5,000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espahol
www.homedepot.com/survey
User ID: GV143 156908 148804
PASSWORD: 19079 148707
Entries must be completed within 14 days
of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or
older to enter. See complete rules on
website. No purchase necessary.
P
SPECIAL SERVICES CUSTOMER INVOICE
Store 8201 ST THOMAS,VI
1.2 DONOE ROAD 4000
SAINT THOMAS. VI 00802
Phone: (340) 777-1077
Salesperson: KXE0KLB
Reviewer: sv995
Name
RODRIGUEZ
H:r o PhDr o
CARLOS
I— AtrOis War% Phone
_J
O
(I)
Corpany Alert0
et/
AS3 DeUtan Carry Out
i/ ccp1'`'" SAINT THOMAS
Page 1 of 1 No. H8201-50507
REPRINT
2019.01-29 08:35
CARRY OUT
MERCHANDISE MERCHANDISE AND SERVICE SUMMARY We
ld z
reserve the right to km t the quantities of merchandise
soo customers
REF # W03 SKU # 0000.515664 The items listed in this section will be carded out of the store by the customer at time of 
sale.
STOCK MERCHANDISE CARRIED OUT:
REF # SKU QTY UM DESCRIPTION PI TAX PRICE EACH EXTENSION
R01 1002-625-760 2.00 EA HMDR1000BE MC10.1 CU.FT.TOP MOUNT BL / A N $399.00 $798.00
R02 0000-239-840 57.00 EA RIGID 1-HOLE STRAP 3/4" PK4 / A Y $1.16 566.12
MERCHANDISE
END OF CARRY OUT
TOTAL: $864.12
MERCHANDISE - REF #W03
TOTAL CHARGES OF ALL MERCHANDISE & SERVICES
Policy Id (PI):
A: 90 DAYS DEFAULT POLICY;
'The Home Depot reserves the right to limit / deny returns. Please see the return policy sign in stores for details.'
ORDER TOTAL
SALES TAX
$864.12
50.00
TOTAL $864.12
BALANCE DUE $0.00
END OF ORDER No. H8201-50507
Check your current order status online at
www.homedepot.comforderstatue
Page 1 of 1 No. H8201-50507 Customer Copy
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00004 69312 01/29/19 09:56 AM CASHIER KISHTO.
0000-524-845 DOOR SWEEP <As E/0 MO 36" TRIPLE FIN VVL DR SWP-WH 2099.98 199.50 0000-625-221 DOOR SWEEP 4A> MD 26" CLX 
VVL DR SWP-WH 9e/14.38 129.42 093994183507
MORTAR WHITE <A> ULTRAFLEX 1 TILE MORTAR WHITE 904.8 3918.47 55.41 045242224760 13PC KIT <A> 90.37 MILWAUKEE BI-METAL 
HOLE SAW 13PC KIT 1000.004-596 8' TILE SAN
<As 499.00 8" RIDGE) TILE 8 PAVER SAW W/ STAND
SUBTOTAL 973.80
SALES TAX 0.00 TOTAL $973.80 XXXXXXXXXXX2C40 AMEX
USD$ 973.80 AUTH 4061E TA AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
8201 04 693 2 01/29/0 9 8479
RUM POCIC DEF NI TOTS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON A 1 90 04/29/2019
S Ives
IASA‘XXIARAXIMX**XXXAIAXXX*XXVIratig*IS
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN A $5.000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espaAol
www hcweedepot.com:survey
User ID: H89 147114 138917
PASSWORD: 19079 138913
Entries must be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
website. Kb purchase necessary.
openers
kmart.BIG KNART STORE 3829
CHARLOTTE AMALIE
51 THOMAS. VI 00802
(340)777-3853
*at* thank you For 4***
NIFIX slumping at uovr knart mug
CASHIER: AVARUA POT
glygRAL HEPCHANRISE
07t16007735 STORAGE 50.99
71981207281 CAN OPENER • 25.99 Slerhc? 5051126851E'i2 CAN OPENER 11.99 88'71900887 BATH ROLLOUT L S3 2 @ 1/5.99 A 11.98
*Js: TA) .00 BAL 101.95 XXXXXXXXXXN2050
RX APPROVEL 805240
EN"RY MEMO: C RUTH MODE. E RID:R00000CO25010801
APPI PREF MIME:AMERICAN EXPRESS CVM: VERIFIED BY SIG
VF AX 101.95
CHFMGE .00
(  TOTAL SAVED: 4.60
TO7AL NUMBER OF ITEMS , 5
I agree that fhls sale is subject to the cardholder agreement Issued b4 ms card ercvider.
two D9W OSL 01'
')3829 A.
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00037 03196 01/28/19 02:20 PM
CASHIER KARIMAH
047242061796 30" PEDESTAL CA>
COMMERCIAL ELECTRIC 30 INCH YOKE PE • 1-13-14 S
46169.00 676.00
851414002469 BUBBLE CUSHN vA>
3/16"X12"X2501 BUBBLE CUSHION WRAP
30.7 2.61
42 8 9979 BUBBLE <A> 16.97
3/16 X 24 X 50 BUBBLE CUSHION
817423017337 H3 STRETCH <A>
20 X 1000 WAVY DUTY STRETCH WRAP
38435.97 107.91
084305355546 HOMER BUCKET CA> 3.74
5GAL HOMER BUCKET
051411615079 BOX <A>
EMT 1-HOLE STRAP 3/4" PK100 CD' 6013.25 79.50 — 1M'
826341040082 BLGHT C8L6FT <A> - 1,-‘che
18G BRAIDED CABLE LIGHTNING. 6FT 1 cc.Ntis
3016.97 50.91 ---
008925095323 3" CUP BRSH vA> 6.20 . I_Si
AVANTI PRO 3"WIRE CUP BRUSH GP
008925095330 3" WIREWHEEL <A> 4.64
AVANTI PRO 3"CRIMP WIRE WHEEL GP
826341040099 LGHT CBL3PK vA> 29.97
I8G CABLE 3-PACK FOR LIGHTNING, 3FT
KXXXXXXXXYX2050
AUTH
AID
SUBTOTAL
SALES TAX
TOTAL
AMEX USD$ 1,068.45
335 TA
AMERICAN EXPRESS
1,068.45
0.00
$1,068.45
11 10111$
8201 37103 96 01 28/2019 77
RETURN POLICY DEFINITIONS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON
A 1 90 04/28/2019
XXX2Xxl(XtX/010.XX2XXXXXxl/lx*x2Atilycicx*Xt
DID WE NAIL. IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN
A $5,000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Wine en °spew'
www.homedepot.com/survev
User ID: W53 14882 6718
PASSWORD: 19078 6681
Entries must be completed within 14 days
of perchase. Entrants must be 18 or
older to enter. See complete rules on
website. No purchase necessary.
K,ko
More saving.
More doing:"
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00057 00430 01/26/19 09:24 AM SELF CHECK CUT
037103264435 10PC3/8SAE <A> 22.76 10PC 3/8" DRIVE SAE DEEP SOCKET SET 037103254214 H38RHRAT <A, 15.56 RATCHET 3/8' 
ROUNDHEAD
037103245632 HAOPTR3PC <A> 11.96
3PC 1/4" AND 3/8' ADAPTER SET
SUBTOTAL 50.28
SALES TAX 0.00
TOTAL $50.28 )0(X)00(XXXX2050 AMEX
USD$ 50.28
72935 TA
AMERICAN EXPRESS
dllllla MOON 8201 57 00430 01/26/2019 8686
RETURN POLICY DEFINITIONS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON A 1 90 04/26/2019
XXIMIVICSI2V*1**ItItEtAltAWIt*XXSX,22*Wt222
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN A $5.000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARO
Opine en espatol
mew.homedepot.com/scrvey
User ID: 2PX3 9350 1206 PASSWORD: 19076 1149
Entries must be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
website. No purchase necessary.
WELCOME TO
FIRST STOP EAST
VP13007411001
st3Ve one Gold Disk
T2 FL
Description Qty Amount
PREMIUM CA 008 23.6816 89.96 SELF 8 3.799/ G
Subtotal 89.96
Tax 0.00 TOTAL 89 _96
CASH $ 89.96
THANKS
ST0 A8123 TILL XXXX ORS I TRAMP 1019109 CSH: 9 01/24/19 12:50:01
K
kmart.
BIG KMART STORE 3829 CHARLOTTE AMALIE ST THOMAS, VI 00802 (390/777-3853
**** thank 4QU For **4* **** shopains at flour knari ***
CASHIER: JUDITH TOO GENERAL mugHANDIsE
83632100286 OVEN A 69 99 GROCERY
01780015131 ONE SATSUMA 17.99
**** TAX .00 SAL XXXXXXXXXXX20S0
AX APPROVAL $27161 ENTRY METHOD: C AUTH MODE' E AID.
APPL PREF NAm EXPRESS CVM: VERIFIED
VF AX
CHAN
87.98
87.98
TOTAL SAVED: 20.00
,

╭────── Page 47, Image 1 ───────╮
│ kmart                         │
│ BIG KMART STORE 3825          │
│ CHARLOTTE aNaLie              │
│ ST THoWAS. vI gogo            │
│ (3409777-3853                 │
│                               │
│ #38 thank You For sees        │
│ "HA shopping ot sour knart sn │
│                               │
│ SW Oe                         │
│ GENERAL MERCHANDISE Oven      │
│ 83652100286 gveN A 69.99      │
│ GRocERy S 4                   │
│ 1780015131 ONE sHrBLHtH 47.96 │
│ ZOOOKRAKKK2060 dover.         │
│ 8X “APPROVAL B27161           │
│                               │
│ ArREMETHOD: AUTH none         │
│ 1D                            │
╰───────────────────────────────╯

More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00037 84204 01/24/19 CASHIER KISHHA
049074023522 SS FILE <A> SENTRY FHW40100 FILE 020066172473 UNV GL WHT udo UNIVERSAL GLOSS WHITE 11$5.67
SUBTOTAL
SALES TAX
TOTAL xxxuxxxxxx2oso AMEX
10:29 AM
Sh-83.9r
SIC pkin
62.37__
146.35
$146.00
.35
USD$ 146.35 AUTHISM/0733
AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
TA
C •
8201 37 84204 0 /24/2019 1329
RETURN POLICY DEFINITIONS
A 1 90
POLICY ID DAYS POlICY
04/24/20
EXPIRES ON
tier*,,wxxemeetteeteteermmeeeege ******** DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN A $5,000 HONE DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espanol
wew.homedepot.comJsurvey
User ID: W53 176898 168734 • PASSWORD: 19074 168697
Entries must be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants Mist be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
mebsite. No purchase necessary.
SeacC4
Service Makes i ne Difference! 10• 4  INF • I
3106 Gown Bay 41 7744:195 Fax 776-2547
Morfd: 7;30-41:3 oi-Sua: 8-1
r -a nip° /, '"t S
SIR lltS1 SEE 3806 IRMA SI INNS. I/1 340-774-0.
(11,123/•2019
Mel (it:lilt 111:
Dry ire II):
'Fermi nal I I):
l • l '4 i
erianN.n-i inn If:
01/23/19 A( Card Type:
12:12:15 AC11111111: l;
Ordt: 41663515 :14: 14..55006 Knit :
TARP POLY BLUE/ERNI I2:t 6(73196) Ainni ti I I
1 EA E ,I.990 29.99
STAN:
LOCAL 29.99
0.00
29.99
Response: TRANS
Mode:
AHD ICA14 Ir. xxxx -29.99 AID: TYR:
Alt
NO cash returns-3tcre credit ONLY.NO
returns after E &it.. Restock fee 15%. LUSIOI1ER
Thank You for lqiur Patronage II

╭─────────── Page 49, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ Seatihesr                               │
│                                         │
│ "I;                                     │
│ he Difference!                          │
│                                         │
│ Service Maices                          │
│ 3806 Crown Boy ‘el 774-195 Fox 776-2547 │
│ Mon-Fri: 7:30-4:30 4                    │
│                                         │
│ Transport GAS                           │
│                                         │
│ 01/23/19 c                              │
│ 12:12:15 entehel                        │
│ Orde: 41663515 “avi: 1655005            │
│                                         │
│ TARP POLY BLUE/EV 12:\°6(73196)         │
│                                         │
│ 1 EA & 990 (29.99                       │
│ Sub (OTAL = 29,99                       │
│ ». 0.00                                 │
│ ‘OTL 23.99                              │
│                                         │
│ AMERICAN Ey soo -29.99                  │
│                                         │
│ NO cash returns-Store credit ONLY.NO    │
│ returns after If days, Restock fee 15%. │
│                                         │
│ Tu 6.                                   │
│                                         │
│ Thank You for Your Patronage #!         │
│                                         │
│ Sew Ces aCe i                           │
│ SB,                                     │
│                                         │
│ sv Tha. Vi                              │
│ MO-Ti4-e                                │
│ 1/28/2019                               │
│ Merchant ID:                            │
│ PEPE                                    │
│ Device ID:                              │
│ Terminal 1D:                            │
│ Credit                                  │
│                                         │
│ Transaction He                          │
│ Card Type:                              │
│ Account: bb t+                          │
│ Fatry                                   │
│                                         │
│ Amount:                                 │
│                                         │
│ STAN,                                   │
│ Auth. Code                              │
│ ir                                      │
│ fe                                      │
│ t                                       │
│ cCUSTONER                               │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────╯

More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS HOSE DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00037 79279 01/23/19 11:18 AM CASHIER LINAI
851414002636 MOVING BLNKT <A> 72"X80" MOVING BLANKET 4120.67 82.68 6940376000867 1IN X 15FT <A> 1IN X 15ET RATCHET 
TIE-DOWN M S HOOK 414.64 18.56 030699731244
POLY ROPE <A> 9.58 1/4"X100.ALL PURPOSE. POLY ROPE 6940376000881 1-1/4 IN. X cA> 1-1/4 IN. X 16 FT. E-LOOP RATCHET AIR_ 
218.93 17.86
SUBTOTAL 128.68 SALES TAX TOT 0.00
)0(X)00(XXXXX2050 AMEX $128.68
AUT 53
T
USC$ 128.86
AAID AMERICAN EXPRESS
tooLoolitio  RETURN POLICY DEFIN TIONS POLICY ID DAYS POLICYEXPIRESON A 1 90 04/23/2019
iti22222XWXZXXXXX,
DID WE Kifk]El_ IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO YIN A $5.000 MOMS DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espanol
ere.homedepot.coesurveY
User ID: W53 167048 158884 PASWORD: 19073 158847
Entries Rust be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants mist be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
website. No purchase necessary.
11,
amazon.com.
Final Details for Order #114-6860722-1902661
Print this cage for your records.
Order Placed: January 22, 2019
Amazon.com order number: 114-6860722-1902661
Order Total: $24.70
Shipped on January 22, 2019
Items Ordered Price
(I of: 3/4 dia., 1/4-20 thds., Black Phenolic Knurled Plastic Knobs w/Inch Brass $0.76
nsert - Black ABS (1 Each)
Sold by: Essentra Components (formerly Reld Supply Co.) (teller profile)
)Condition: New
9 of: 3/4 dia., 1/4-20 thds., Black Phenolic Knurled Plastic Knobs w/Inch Brass $0.76
Insert - Black ABS (1 Each)
Sold by: Essentra Components (formerly Reid Supply Co.) (seller Drofulv)
Condition: New
9 of: 3/4 dia., 1/4-20 thds., Black Phenolic Knurled Plastic Knobs w/Inch Brass $0.76
Insert - Black ABS (1 Each)
Sold by: Essentra Components (formerly Reid Supply Co.) (celler moftlq)
Condition: New
Shipping Address:
Carlos odri uez
United tates
Shipping Speed:
Standard Shipping
Item(s) Subtotal: $15.20
Shipping & Handling: $9.50
Total before tax: $24.70
Sales Tax: $0.00
Total for This Shipment:$24.70
Payment information
Payment Method:
American Express I Last digits:
Billin address
United Cates
Credit Card
transactions
Item(s) Subtotal: $15.20
Shipping & Handling: $9.50
Total before tax: $24.70
Estimated tax to be collected: $0.00
Grand Total:$24.70
AmericanExpress ending in January 22, 2019: $24.70
To view the status of your order, return to Order Summary.
Office DEPOT
OfficeMax ST THOMAS - (340) 715-3546
01/22/2019 12:51 PM
Ecumpui SALE 6538-2-531-909195-18.12.2
656096 FLE 8X.ORGAILU 20.19 E
te482002 CBL,USB,MICRO,
3 0 31.19 93.57
You Paw 93.67E
Subtotal: 113.76
Total: 113.76
Amex 050: 113.76
RUTH CODE 845282
TOS Chip Read
RIO  AMERICAN EXPRESS
TVR 0000008000
CVS No Signature Required
Shop online at
OE VONT TO HEAR FROM YOU!
Visit
and enter the survey code below:
V500 MICK FHKO
Advancel'iN;` Auto Partsia"N Service is our best part.
Store II 05047
4603 TUTU PARK
ST THOMAS VI 00802 (340) 775-4400
01/22/19 13:00 REG 01 TRAP 6441ABOUL S.
4 WAY LUG WRENCH-SAE 1 9050019
AC9584492 1 $22.99 $22.99
1 YR REPLACEMENT IF DEFECTIVE
Sub Total $22.99
Total $22.99
122.911 PURCHASE 0 1:00 PN
We nssssssat CHIP REA
RUTH 841881 Approved REF 504701844101
EIN,CARD I MITCH 129383 TERN 00000001
Issuer IC 4018900BE783AE33
AID 80000030 10801
Z2NVKIBJNY1RMO
IMINIENNIN NIIIIIk It
Standard Revolviny coisumer 84600 purchase
Standard Revolving
Standard 29.995 APR with regular payments
Customer Signature
.PO/ 0 Ssiltur-L:n
WELCOME TO
FIRST STOP EAST
VP 13007411001
VeriFone 6o1d Disk 7) 9_,)
• el:c:7FL
Description Oty Amount
PREMIUM CA 408 21.0596 80.00
SELF II 3.799/ 6
Sti4total 80.00
Tax 0.00
TOTAL 80 .00
CASH $ 80.00
API, THANKS
9 \AXX 0RA I TRANA 1013258
02/06/19 09:15:11
FRANK'S I OCK & KEY
IAII
11.19
MICR
NIX cot
111M :
IlhiryKS I om≥ hEY 561 KROICIIDS06 SHIP SI Moms
111E tOST 12:st:J/ HISS IEVIDIRLID IERCIANT /D XISSOITE 9396S6Ar
SALE
ACCI.
114 . 1.••••2106
NONCE:
16'e.
TkiT
St
Ni CAIN
SI IIKMAS. VI WW2
01/18/2019 11:42AH 02
00000046422 HEAL
1 @ $55.00
TPX KEY ii$55.00
XPONDER/REHOIES fis69.95 7Pi3 4 @ $3.25
Nt1111,VI 1M55
010:glaleeNerjeneel AC: CAC 99x rac Isceono IvR VuOVOOSOESITSI. Rea
r ER AOCNOltutes Kum pSERVICE IN DE TER ASUNI Cr Of
TOTAL HUNHUN M, MO *ASS TO PtCOEMAIIONS ST FORZIIIII,I.H;1,
PI
R,$ Ai76E/[HY RI 0555
U1Sink UPY Fm so" AY MI ovIsac late
SS OUP 11$13.00
ITEMS 60
CHARGE $1 57.95
SAVE YOUR RECIEPT
RECIEPT REQUIRED
FOR ALL CLAIMS
X-÷4
—
X_ 1-° 1
fa/ 0 k -e/
1-6'04.0k
C.op/ e_f s T-C
More saving.
More doing:"
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00057 84715 01/18/19 08:31 AM SELF CHECK OUT
783110231969 BLKWIRE <A> 4.75 16GA BLK ALAMBRE REBAR TIE WIRE 3.1 764177430939 PP 220V-9KW <A, 204.00 MAREY POWER PAK 
XE5 - 220V -9 KW
SUBTOTAL 208.75 SALES TAX 0.00
XXXXXXX)00(X2050 AMEX $208.75
tursami2329.ZE:si
8201 57 84715 0 /18/2019 8921
RETURN POLICY OEFINI IONS POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON A 1 90 04/18/2019
XIStrittiXXSTWX; ****** W22,SXVIC*ItttlIttlr
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN A $5,000 NOM DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en esparol
wew.homedePot.com/surveY
User ICI: 2PX3 177920 169776 PASSWORD: 19068 169719
Entries must be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants must be 18 ce older to enter. See complete rules on 
website. No purchase necessary.
More saving.
More doing:
ST THOMAS HOME DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00056 90664 01/18/19 10:17 All SELF CHECK OUT
020066199357 PTCHSGLSWHOT 4A>
PAINTERS TOUCH SEMI-GLS WHITE OT
7568470 249.9700047 121CUBETAP4H 411,
19.94
16/2 12' WHITE CU3E TAP EXT CORD 243.82 7.64 756847000443 16/3 25'WF 'A> 12.97 16/3 25' HDX EXTENSION CORD
020066187170 2X S-GLBLK <A> PAINTERS TOUCH 2X SEMI-GLOSS BLACK 2404.37  020066172473 UNV GL WHT 4A* 104.88
UNIVERSAL GLOSS WHITE
15415.67  020066187859 UNIVERSAL <A>
85.05
UNIVERSAL METALLIC OIL RUBBED BRONZE 3946.76 263.64
SUBTOTAL 494.12
SALES TAX 0.00
TOTAL $494.12 XXXXXXXXXXX2050 AMEX
USD$ 494.12 AUTH CODE 828411/5560721 TA AID AMERICAN EXPRESS
Immo IIIIIIIIIIng 8201 56 90664 01/18/2019 296
RETURN POLICY DEFINITIONS
POLICY ID DAYS POLICY EXPIRES ON A 1 90 04/18/2019
XXXXIXtrarrliXtxXXXXXX222X*xxXXXIMint
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN A $5,000 HOME DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espatol
www.homedepot.com/sLrvey
User ID: 2PX3 189818 181673
PASSWORD: 19068 181617
Entries must be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants must be 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
website. No purchase necessary.
More saving.
More doing.
ST THOMAS MOTE DEPOT (340)777-1077
USVI
8201 00001 34585 01/17/19 09:54 AM CASHIER VERONICA
020066208189 PRIMER SPRAY <A> STOPS RUST AUTO LIGHT GRAY PRIMER 294.98 9.96 076308724535 3TICHN220G2P8 <A> 9.48 311 PGP 
CHANNELS SPONGE BIM 220G 29K
SUBTOTAL 19.44
TOTA
SALEL
$19
S TAX 0
.44.00
XXXXXXXXXXX2050 AMEX
USD$ 19.44 AUD
A
Tt1562 TA AI MERICAN EXPRESS
RETURN POLICY DEF NITIONS A
1 04/
POLICY 90 ID DAYS POLICY
EXPI/20RES19 ON
WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW MAIMPOISIMWS2ARXItiltillt*
DID WE NAIL IT?
Take a short survey for a chance TO WIN A $5,000 HONE DEPOT GIFT CARD
Opine en espariol
www.homedepot.com/sirvey
User ID: WTS 77660 69460 PASSWORD: 19067 69459
Entries most be completed within 14 days of purchase. Entrants must he 18 or older to enter. See complete rules on 
mebsite. No purchase necessary.
EFTA00010507 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States
╔════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Lori Goler [tech] Facebook Vice President of People 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00285783 (Jmail)
 [misc] daily schedule [Jcal]
(date: 2019-03-01)
2019 March
Fri. March 1, 2019 NY
Reminder: and to go to London and stay at the Intercontinental Hotel Rec.
Loc#YJMSUM via Eurostar and via air Rec.
10:00am Conf. Call w/Stpehanie Remington, Mike Glidden and Rich
11:00am appt w/Kathy Ruemmler
1:00pm Appt w/James Peyer (Masha's friend)
Sat. March 2, 2019 NY-PB
1:14pm Depart NY
3:35pm Arrive PB
Sun. March 3, 2019 PB
11:29pm to depart Vegas via DL#1694 to JFK (Rec Lot
Mon. March 4, 2019 PB
Reminder: Sun. March 10 Day Light Savings Time Begins (Spring Ahead one hour)
Tues. March S. 2019 PB
RE-REGISTER ON THE VI-ASK FOR A NEW PHOTO BE SENT TO THE NYS SEX OFF. REG
11:23am John Pinette to arrive PB via DL1953 (Rec. Loc#KFCWXB) (IMME)
(John to depart Lafayette via DL1580 at 6am to Atlanta)
1:18pm Jojo to depart PB via DL2852 to JFK arrive 4:16pm (Rec. Loc#HEVYIN)
7:58pm John Pinette to depart Miami via AA305 (Rec. Loc#HEGHJI)
Wed. March 6, 2019 PB
11:10am MI to depart PB via Jet Blue#154 (Rec. Loc#RIFHSO)
Thurs. March 7.2019 PB
Reminder Dave iicniSnoscopy March 7/8
Reminder: to fly to Tokyo (Rec. Lo'
Fri. March 8.2019 PB-NY
Reminder Moshe in NY and staying in Apt's 2G and 71 March 8-10
6:30am Heli to Miami
7:30am Arrive Miami Regional Passport Agency
8:00am Appt for New Passport (Confirm#7.5577322)
1501 Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 210
Miami, FL (877 487 2778)
8 :45am Hell to PB Airport
2:24pm Depart PB
4:58pm Arrive NY
6:30pm Patrick to the house for a cut
7:4Spm to depart LGA via Delta# (Rec. Loc#RIFHSO)
10:56pm Arrive PB
Sat. March 9, 2019 NY
4:00pm Appt
Sun. March 10, 2019 NY
Reminder: Day Light Savings Time Begins (Spring Ahead One Hour)
11:00am Conf. Call w/NicoleJunkermann and Robert Kuhn
2:00pm Appt wa
fifon. March 11.2019 NY-PB
8:52am Depart NY
11:41atn Arrive PB
S:07pina to depart PB via Jet Blue 1944 (Rec. Loc#NYQEAZ)
8:10pm to depart JFK for Moscow via SU103 (Rec.
Tues. March 12, 2019 PB
2:30pm Phone Date w/Andrew Farkas aa)
Wed. March 13, 2019 PB
Thurs. March 14, 2019 PB-LSJ
Reminder: birthday
8:05am Depart PB
10:10am Arrive LSJ
RE REGISTER IN THE VI-ASK FOR NEW PHOTO TO BE SENT TO THE NYS SEX OFFENDER
REG.
Fri. March 15, 2019 LSJ-PB
Reminder: Leo out today to register his daughter for school
1:10pm Stephanie Remington to depart ST7' for Kansas City to visit her ailing father (Rec.
Loc#OKMPYV)
2:58pm Depart LSJ
5:26pm Arrive PB
Sat March 16, 2019 PB
Sun. March 17, 2019 PB-NY
Reminder: St. Patrick's Day
5:29pm Depart PB
8:08pm Arrive NY
Mon. March 18.2019 W
Reminder: Rich Kahn on holiday March 18-22 (back in office March 25)
Reminder: Stephanie Remington to return to STT today 1:10pm from Kansas City (Rec.
Loc#OKMPYV)
Reminder: Deliver Gift Cards to
5:30pm Appt
Tues. March 19. 2019 NY-Paris
Reminder: to travel to San Francisco today via DL1353 (Rec.
9:20ain DEPART NY
8:39pin Arrive Paris
3:00pm to ARRIVE Paris via 5U2462 (Rec.
Wed. March 20, 2019 Paris
12:30pm to ARRIVE Paris via 5112454 (Rec
Thurs. March 21, 2019 Paris
Fri. March 22, 2019 Paris -Vienna -Paris
2:34pm Depart Paris
4:07pm Arrive Vienna
9:06pm Depart Vienna
10:33pm Arrive Paris
Sat March 23. 2019 Paris
12:10pm to ARRIVE Paris via P5127 (Rec.
12:10pm Sofia Girich to ARRIVE Paris via PS127 (Rec. Loc#MLOGAJ)
1:30pm
1:30pm
7:30pm
to DEPART via SI160 (Rec.
to DEPART Paris via SII60
to ARRIVE Paris via EK75 (Rec.Loc )
Sun. March 24, 2019 Paris
3:20pm to DEPART Paris via AF7706 (Rec. Loch
Mon. March 25.2019 Paris
Reminder: Rich back in the office today
Reminder: Daphne on holiday March 25-29, back in office Mon. April 1
10:00am EST (3pm Paris time) Phone Date w/Andrew Farkas gE to call Andrew's cell:
12:45pm to ARRIVE Paris via TK1823 (Rec.
1:20pm to DEPART Paris via PS127 (Rec.
1:20pm Sofia Girich to DEPART Paris via PS127 (Rec. Loc#MLOGAJ)
1:30pm PHONE DATE w/Lori Goler (RICH KAHN) (MM)
Tues. March 26.2019 Paris
Reminder: to see Dangene at 8am for consultation on and for a facial treatment
Wed. March 27, 2019 Paris -Nice-Paris
12:26pm Depart Paris
1:35pm Arrive Nice
5:43pm Depart Nice
7:00pm Arrive Paris
Thurs. March 28. 2019 Paris
Reminder: Yoni in NY and staying in apt March 28-April 30
Reminder: Palm Beach Boat Show March 28-31
(https://www.pbboatshow.com/en/home.html)
Fri. March 29, 2019 Paris
Reminder: Darren to spend the day with Hannah
Reminder= on holiday April 14-21
7:40pm to ARRIVE Paris via AF5063 ( )
7:45pm to DEPART Paris via Lot#336 (Rec.
Sat. March 30, 2019 Paris
Sun. March 31.2019 Paris
Reminder Nathan Myhrvold in NY March 31 -April 1
11:50amm to ARRIVE Paris via AF1145(Rec. Loc
2:25pm to DEPART Paris ORLY via Transavia Air
Booking
(purchased on line)
EFTA01620249 (Jmail)
 [politics] iMessage to Steve Bannon screenshot(s)
(date: 2019-03-04)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
2019/03/04
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/04/opinion/letters/jeffrey-epstein.html
2019/03/05
Hes here with me now. He thinks stick to legal legal legal . A deal is a deal etc. and
then a few months from now. Decide how to deal with the pervert hermit image and
fill the box with another narrative .
08:34:05 pm
Articles by legal people . Professors. Lawyers etc. now I'm focused
09:16:22 pm
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/05/sports/robert-kraft-massage-defense.html
Maybe one of them should write a piece- a deal is a deal.
11:11:02 pm
2019/03/07
12:38:16 pm
At least trump had some supporters fighting back
12:38:37 pm
ruemmler proposal
12:39:22 pm
"The criticism is wrong and reflects a fundamental misunderstanding of both the facts
underlying Mr. Epstein's case and how it was prosecuted by both local and federal
authorities. Far from a receiving a sweetheart deal, Mr. Epstein was subjected to a
lengthy, aggressive, and highly unusual federal investigation for what were, in essence,
local offenses of sexual solicitation. He accepted responsibility, served time and
prison, and paid significant monetary settlements to the victims involved.
12:39:23 pm
This is what Kathy suggests we tell Waco
12:42:31 pm
Wapo
12:42:39 pm
2019/03/09
how is it there? wanted your advice on how much the lawyers should go on
background with weapon
11:16:32 am
wapo
1116:35 am
no 14 year olds . here's the charging document. one girl 1 month shy of her 18th
birthday. that's the truth. the story is blown wayyyy out as we have never countered
facts. some are counseling that in this environment , doing so just leads to more
digging whining etc.
11:42:16 am
i know. that s my point. each time the number grows, no pushback ie here are the
documents.
11:43:45 am
the numbers get larger and the ages get younger. no one at all either investigates or
is told whoa
11:44:15 am
weinberg. . for starters. as it seems ken starr, drives the dems in apoplectic fits
11:44:54 am
your talk there was perfect
11:49:47 am
good work
11:49:51 am
2019/04/02
Ok
11:23:04 am
2019/04/03
02:56:43 pm
The hearing is at 2 pm?
02:57:55 pm
Ok
09:04:05 pm
2019/04/04
Yes I watched
09:45:32 am
yees, adding documents
11:26:40 am
of course , can you bring proof from george? lots of skepticism
12:12:23 pm
proof for kathy
12:13:47 pm
today with spiro and tomrw with kathry
12:16:39 pm
correct
12:16:46 pm
Yes
02:02:02 pm
Are you and spiro on time for 4 today
07:30:50 pm
??
08:09:18 pm
Spiro 4 pm on Thursday --- no brewkfast meeting will have michael join us right
before???
08:31:09 pm
Yes
08:54:07 pm
No worry, no surprise
08:55:20 pm2019/04/05

Ok. Thx appreciate it . As numbers go i guess my 38 is still worse than your 1.7
09:46:21 am
in any bar where drinking age is 18 i guess that 10 percent of patrons are under

18. . they sneak in, they have fake id. their friends bring them in. . and that is
with guards at the door, the owner gets a fine. . every bar in florida. there is no
intercourse
10:02:44 am
the reports that said they lied when asked re their ages undercuts the argument that i
Isought young girls. think of the bar
10:24:36 am
they told the police that they were told by the friend of theirs that brought them if
asked make sure you say you are 18. .
10:30:00 am
exactly the opposite of sting results were guys are looking for underage girls. . they
alway always want UNDER and are explicit
10:33:25 am
but I get it ,
10:33:40 am
and each girl knew why she was coming to the house massage with extra , hardly
coercion
10:34:56 am
reminder , I am not delusional , no ego , not my skill set
12:52:48 pm
re kathy documents paramount . . re kazans same
12:56:52 pm2019/04/06
Im thinking id let the Miami Herald writer do a live interview no editing. Or an act of
contrition coupled with setting the facts straight . Discuss later
09:51:58 am
Or let the victims interview me
10:04:58 am
And I them
10:05:41 am
2019/04/21
Thoughts on Netflix counter strategy
05:42:04 pm
2019/05/19
Miami Herald never asked for anything
02:37:48 pm
./ Sent
EFTA00001884 (Jmail)
 [government] photo of letter from Virgin Islands DOJ to Epstein
(date: 2019-03-14)
ci 4
Tn V I'NITro •tt.te• Vtotitt. Ito att..
/rife, Immo
61-201.2.1l2.2. 22.222.112
Ilco Mr I heat
orro r re. ATI. , N,ri
Jon 22.222 %IC , : ;C.
:22.2.02 V.V.V• o'22. VC 4c CIC
1 ,,  u11,1,.` Mee. 2arc-...-  at I M. IDE u,2 Immo. ow fe.,Mbr 211, 2
C1.110 ACV VIVM1VJ MVO Vt Mc imoi %Mon
onl n or rest 22,
eva.2.2.2. tlw :1 4.2.2 ne.f.anot o Nutted 222+v mug wale. =roVrillVal 222
vammt of Mc room. for ammo.] et Joarieet of I SVIDIM
reef -2 2.2-22.22 2.2femn ens vv.. lame m eirmi num memor u.
Mewt• e
I 22.022 22 co. ,
Mie, 2.22 .2.mmlara fmo-ort
lencram Joe 2•
2.4freo or tr elmimm.
I22.7 , 2.22 of ern 21
An, ‘..ther 2Mv--.22.23.2
them rmurancre ,  Sc NNW/I:MI( form Ia . Sotem 2'1:12 mog toe Nom. C
N II P 5 I 5 . Inimetomil
M• p.m.< on.krum..ItMe the feroom promwea °ryas; Iraqi noallotIon re I orm .22orto! On I M2 ID.11 an.1 im mai Coemlf 
oramnhaltly web tte endear road 3hMC C
tteet to ttot cateneen n3  out the toot eta awe to ones
(Awl TImenam/wele, tea
.‘[tae Agent, Ocoee

╭─────────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ 2 sce ain pring 0) eo ind             │
│                                       │
│ 4 Haein te hy meetin na a             │
│ Spence falictyonna ates               │
│                                       │
│ ae ULI ne ce mee a rt                 │
│                                       │
│ {Asters gon ott iomson                │
│ 1 heafme                              │
│ 1 Refcccropindteman                   │
│ ‘ee eum ama Cg Sen 724 elie Vigne abe │
│ ni Sec pen oe                         │
│                                       │
│ Sp par at i vo psn ore il             │
│ a ree er lene plein                   │
╰───────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00105454 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of minor victim
(date: 2019-03-22)
ED-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 3-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Oanta
Date of entry 04/17/2019
, date of birth (DOB) , was interviewed at the
Law offices of Boies Schiller Flexner at 401 E Las Olas Blvd, Fort
Lauderdale, Florida. Present for the interview were AUSA
AUSA , Task Force Officer , and Special Agent
. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents and
the nature of the interview, provided the following information:
is from West Palm Beach, Florida. attended Lake Worth High
School and John I. Leonard High School, but dropped out before graduating.
lived with her friend from the approximate ages of 14 to
16. has worked in different jobs, including Miami Subs, being a
hostess in restaurants, and worked as a dancer.
waitress at Duffy's Sports Bar.
currently works as a
When was 14 years old she was introduced to JEFFREY EPSTEIN.
described herself as having braces at the time. and were at a
high school party when they were approached by a girl around their age.
They were told they could make $200 if they gave a massage naked or with
their bra and panties on. At first, went by herself then brought
with her. estimated that she had gone to EPSTEIN's residence
approximately sixty times over a three to four year period.
The first time met EPSTEIN, she told him that she was 16 because
her friends told her to not tell him her actual age. thought that
EPSTEIN was a brain surgeon or doctor but does not recall why she thought
that.
thought
"very nice."
to set everything up. would call
would tell when they would land
girls. would ask questions about the
like, etc. would have to express to EPSTEIN and
had things going on and activities that they were involved in.
recalled receiving a call from New York.
met and gave
was "like a live in assistant."
would sometimes take
her phone number.
described
upstairs and show
as
how
before they got on a plane.
and ask if she had any
girls, asking what they looked
that the girls
stated that EPSTEIN was "pushy and had control of the situation."
EPSTEIN would have a robe on or come in the room wearing slacks and a
Investigation on
File #
03/22/2019
31E-NY-3027571
at Fort Lauderdale, Florida, United States (In Person)
Datednfted 03/26/2019
by

FD-302a (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E-NY-3027571
ContimMionaFD-302of (U) Interview of Mn 03/22/2019 , page 2 of 3
shirt.
." EPSTEIN gave off
the vibe that they were not doing anything wrong. EPSTEIN was "super
casual" about it all. did not go further into the details about the
sexual contact at this time. was always paid in cash in 100 dollar
bills, sometimes by and sometimes by EPSTEIN, who would place the
money on the counter or take it out of the pocket of his robe.
The first time massaged EPSTEIN, he asked her if she had friends
that she could bring with her. would get paid $200 for each girl that
she brought to EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN made her feel like his sidekick. EPSTEIN
would call and "hound" for girls that were underage. EPSTEIN did not
say specifically that he wanted "underage girls" but told her "you know
what I like." knew that meant he wanted younger girls. learned
this through "trial and error." EPSTEIN would tell her which girls he
liked. was bringing girls that were from a trailer park environment.
brought girls who were young. initially told the girls that she
brought that they would just be giving a massage. Later, she told the
girls that he's "gonna jack off and look at you." told this to the
girls so that they "wouldn't freak out" because EPSTEIN had asked her why
she had not told the girls what to expect. EPSTEIN was very open with what
girls he liked and did not like. EPSTEIN did not like black or mixed
girls. told that when she took black and/or mixed girls,
EPSTEIN "flipped out." would relay messages about girls that
EPSTEIN liked.
believed that there were certain girls that EPSTEIN "took to a
different level." recalled taking a girl, , who
looked very
of them.
and EPSTEIN really liked her. EPSTEIN gave $300 to both
was shaken up and never wanted to go back.
described that when she brought girls that they would have a
routine where both and the other girl would go in together to massage
EPSTEIN for approximately 30 minutes. Each girl would massage a side of
EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN would then flip over and ask to go downstairs.
EPSTEIN would tell that she could have whatever food she wanted while
she waited. recalled taking III , who would have been 16 or 17
years old at the time. stormed out and told "Let's go."
When was an adult and working at a club she brought a woman, who
was an adult, and the woman took off her clothes, but EPSTEIN said that he
had to go. EPSTEIN gave the woman money and left before any massage took
place. stated the adult woman that she took to EPSTEIN did not care
to go back.
FD-302a (Rev. 05-08-10)
31E -NY -3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of on 03/22/2019 page 3 of 3
remembered that there was an apartment at EPSTEIN's residence
where those who worked for EPSTEIN stayed. recalled seeing a chef who
worked there. stated that it was "pretty obvious" what was going on
in the residence. recalled seeing quite a bit at EPSTEIN's
residence over a two year period. "seemed like his sex toy."
received lotions and Victoria's Secret items from EPSTEIN.
knew that when was pregnant, EPSTEIN bought her a golden rattle and
all the remaining items off of her registry.
EPSTEIN called one time, saying that he had a friend that he
wanted her to meet. did not go to meet him that time. had less
contact with EPSTEIN when she turned 18.
of.
his
she
saw EPSTEIN's mug shot on TV. called his phone number and
answered and told her not to worry and
told her that Bob Critton would be
information. told that if she
would be taken care of. met with the
that she would be taken care
her attorney and gave
did not say anything then
attorney but there was a
personality clash and did not understand why
attorney. contacted a different attorney and
was contacted by the FBI. gave
criminal and civil proceedings.
she would have needed an
eventually met
depositions for both
had heard that EPSTEIN's investigators were harassing
by shining lights in her window.
in a different location because of it.
had to be placed in a hotel
met a woman, when she was in prison.
told her that she had gone to EPSTEIN's residence.
and friend also went to EPSTEIN's residence.
recalled that was another girl that went to EPSTEIN's
residence and may have been the one who took
had
also knew that
was contacted by the media, including the Miami Herald.
an interview to the Miami Herald. After she gave the interview,
constantly called by journalists and had to change her phone number.
gave
was
stated that she was open and willing to speak further in depth at
another date.
EFTA00000535 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-03-29)
30
%CIO hint I
IS I? /v :on.?
1n0444/ sem' ember wirer11

• it r it I I •
June ,
2019
Dec ember January Febnaary Match Apia
• ".•.f. r• 9". tr if  • .. .. TVS • •MiwI ll • SMISSI I. S. SninVic 1 .
I 3 1. • • I l e ,•

• ., , zi T.. it • IA 4. if ti la I, Hom Mato/4 12111 44 % lll MB
it la • 2* r 4 JS .17 In n 11 12 212124 VI Its 27 r• 20112312 2421
%/.. nu, 2, yr ro 29 201% 1427 HI% 30

╭── Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ AT-A-GLANC          │
│ CT                  │
│ 17 18 19 {20        │
│ 24 25 26 27 28 2 =a │
│ 30                  │
│ 1, , Mn fe June     │
│                     │
│ 2019                │
╰─────────────────────╯
EFTA00000837 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-03-29)
FD-674a (7-24-2017)
PHOTOGRAPHER
LOCATION  q East 1M Sit2tet, New s(o14, 1002.1

╭────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ FD-674a (7-24-2017)                          │
│                                              │
│ DANE Oe fe iy = f_ 2019                      │
│                                              │
│ CASE ID _3\E-N\- 302757!                     │
│                                              │
│ PHOTOGRAPHER                                 │
│                                              │
│ LOCATION _2£as\ 71" Sweet, New Yor, NY 10021 │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002178 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-03-29)
LSJ & GSJ
BOAT LOG 2019
PM/M.1AX ISA p#..
Crerlifrna.
Lteturrea3 51/4  g , If•-••••••
figit....T1 / *OA 4 .ed.5..
ern,,e • afWac- niww. 1.
it•nc l Une•tre n ttar 4 eir
te“" 4" -‘ 1>
.Nata.c.vvr.
Au rem.... mrlevo_ ^trc“
R4a) "nr"o o* 6t 41 - 44.
VGA. tt etteo.ITC .
cearte ( " 4- i'01%•••% LO•I3, I
can., Tr/
<honka wadi.%
Ra 41rna
C.44
trw %V."( Pe. -.f
ta-• 41/4  C-4^ .(vr
''"•••
EFTA01615703 (Jmail)
 [politics] iMessage to Steve Bannon screenshot(s)
(date: 2019-04-01)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
•
SB
SB
SB
Steve Bannon
Heading back
04:21:19 pm
730
04:21:21 pm
Steve Bannon
SB
Steve Bannon
2019/04/01
2019/04/02
Ok
04:21:43 pm
Friday afternoon media training @ your place -- 2 camera shoot ; my crew so totally
confidential
10:54:09 am
Steve Bannon
3 pm to 6 pm???
11:37:59 am
Ok
11:23:04 am
Ok, trial by fire
11:3851 am
Steve Bannon
On trial that matters
11:44:14 am
Spiro 4 pm on Thursday --- no brewkfast meeting will have michael join us right before
SB 11:58:23 am
Ok
12:45:28 pm
Is there s settlement number for jsta
01:07:25 pm
Steve Bannon
Standby
SB 01:07:55 pm
Kathy coming to house to see you on Friday
11:2/:33 pm
Steve Bannon
Perfect
SB 11:28:45 pm
•
/
0ri
2019/04/03
Steve Bannon
Crew needs to set up around 1 pm or 2 on Friday
SB 12:27:23 am
K
02:33:36 am
Larry summers is at the hyatt in san paolo giving a speech today. If you like he'd be
Willing to meet any of your peeps there
11:19:19 am
Steve Bannon
Standby
11:33:27 am
https://www.thedailybeast.com/alan-dershowitz-says-hes-advising-trump-and-jared-kushner-on-middle-east-peace
11:3/:52
This is why New Yorker coming after him --- we need to focus on this
SB :37:52 am
Spoke to New Yorker last night, no publication imminent for a few weeks. My guys
followed your script
11:40:00 am
Steve Bannon
Perfect :: did u talk with the British comms guy yesterday???
SB 11:40:35 am
They have not set a call yet
11:42:03 am
Did you speak with jsta guys
11:42:29 am
Steve Bannon
Here @ 1030 from Philadelphia
SB 11:43:10 am
I gave summers talking points- only economic stay away from social policy
11:43:27 am
Steve Bannon
I've already talked to them-- they want to meet and are working on it
SB 11:43:52 am
I told him to - like the N word . The C word is - corrupt . And never utter it
11:44:47 am
Steve Bannon
LMAO !!!-- Bolsanoro the anti corruption guy though
SB 11:45:25 am
You can structure the message- me the massage
11:47:22 am
Steve Bannon
See where that got us
SB 12:09:23 pm
Lol. Woody coming to dinner tonight if you like
12:28:55 pm
V Sent
Steve Bannon
In dc
SB 12:38:54 pm
Read
•
•
╔═════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Melania [trump] ...Trump? [politico] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01615720 (Jmail)
 [politics] iMessage to Steve Bannon screenshot(s)
(date: 2019-04-05)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• SB
Steve Bannon
2019/04/05
Steve Bannon
Need the list from the attorney today
09:41:24 am
Let me know how oliver goes
SB 09:41:45 am

Ok. Thx appreciate it . As numbers go i guess my 38 is still worse than your 1.7
09:46:21 am
Steve Bannon
We need to work around your 38--first we need to push back on the lies ; then crush
the pedo/trafficking narrative ; then rebuild your image as philanthropist
SB 09:49:39 am
in any bar where drinking age is 18 i guess that 10 percent of patrons are under
18. . they sneak in, they have fake id. their friends bring them in. . and that is
with guards at the door, the owner gets a fine. . every bar in florida. there is no
intercourse
10:02:44 am
the reports that said they lied when asked re their ages undercuts the argument that i
sought young girls. think of the bar
10:24:36 am
•
•
Steve Bannon
Who did they lie too?
SB 10:28:05 am
they told the police that they were told by the friend of theirs that brought them if
asked make sure you say you are 18. .
10:30:00 am
exactly the opposite of sting results were guys are looking for underage girls. . they
alway always want UNDER and are explicit
10:33:25 am
but I get it ,
10:33:40 am
and each girl knew why she was coming to the house massage with extra , hardly
coercion
10:34:56 am
reminder , I am not delusional , no ego , not my skill set
12:52:48 pm
re kathy documents paramount . . re kazans same
12:56:52 pm
Steve Bannon
Kirscher blows this case out of the water-- why have u never had him come forward
now that he is retired
SB 03:44:50 pm
Face to face
03:48:44 pm
s
Thank you very much for your time and your guys., I am happy to pick up any cost
from today. Pay your guys. etc
10:32:11 pm
Steve Bannon
Yes dan will get to you
10:35:20 pm
Great session
10:35:26 pm
Guys were blown away---mesmerized because they have been sold you are a 'monster'
SB 10:36:15 pm
2019/04/06
If klayman wanted to make you look bad she failed miserably. Good for you- very
12:54:47 am
Steve Bannon
Seriously?
SB 12:55:08 am
Yup karyna said she would vote for you- breakfast?
01:14:46 am
there is a new matthemtician coming from argentina at 12, if you like
01:28:23 am
Steve Bannon
7am breakfast???
SB 09:39:21 am
Steve Bannon
Yes
SB 09:49:44 am
Can you do 8
09:49:32 am
K
09:49:47 am
Im thinking id let the Miami Herald writer do a live interview no editing. Or an act of
contrition coupled with setting the facts straight . Discuss later
09:51:58 am
Steve Bannon
Something there
SB 09:52:34 am
Or let the victims interview me
10:04:58 am
And I them
10:05:41 am
Steve Bannon
Wow
10:06:51 am
Are your guys @ the front door???
SB 11:54:41 am
•
•
•
Yes
11:57:57 am
Steve Bannon
Coming up
11:58:09 am
What's your sked
SB 06:31:10 pm
Free till 6
06:31:34 pm
Steve Bannon
Should be there @ 4
SB 06:33:07 pm
Perfect
06:34:41 pm
Steve Bannon
R ur guys @ front door ???
SB 08:05:12 pin
https://www.salon.com/2019/04/04/house-intelligence-committee-probing-melania-
friend-who-made-1-6m-off-inauguration/
•
•
•
•
Sent
2019/04/07
Steve Bannon
'reportedly cooperating'--- yikes!!!
SB 12:15:07 am
Read
╔══════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ekaterina Gusarova aka Katya [russian girl] Instagram model (???) 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01613468 (Jmail)
 [girls] Skype log of conversation with Ekaterina Gusarova (???)
(inferred timestamp: 2019-04-05 09:44:25)
Platform: Skype: jeevacation Name: C8:live
DB
•
•
Ok
07:44:14 pm
0  jeevacation
What does it mean ?
11:05:02 am
Means she comes to London ?
11:06:25 am
If yes I'm so happy
11:06:34 am
I II help her with everything here
11:07:13 am
2019/03/31
2019/04/01
Timezone: UTC+0000
jeevacation
, not interesting .
07:39:23 pm
jeevacation
Ok forts
11:04:40 am
0
0
leevcLatEor
DB
DB
yes, ok with me i II pay
11:17:34 am
Oh so kind of you
11:25:31 am
Thank you
11:25:34 am
jeevacation
Call type: Outgoing
To: live:
From: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:01:35.8349999
" 1:28:4 / arn
Call type: Outgoing
To: live
From: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:01:35.8349999
11:28:4/ arn
We need to pay for=chool to get invitation for student visa
11:35:54 am
jeevacation
ok
11:36:57 am
0
0
s
•
•
•
•
We can book and pay it online
11:37:12 am
2019/04/02
Hi Jeffrey how are you ?
I want to go to English school and buy a furniture for apartment.
Could you please help with it ?
Thank you so much 'V'
07:27:31 pm
Thank you so much Jeffrey .4 *4 'Is
08:28:42 pm
2019/04/03
2019/04/04
jeevacation
ok
11:25:48 am
jeevacation
i am sending you money for you and katya and school and Turn . use it carefully
01:25:34 am
Thank you so much Jeffrey .4 I will pay for the school as soon as I receive the money
and we can work on her visa
09:44:25 am
2019/04/05
•
•
•
Hi Jeffrey <55 type="smile">:)</ss>
Sorry for asking you again , did u send by PayPal? Because I don't receive anything,
usually it's fast
is asking me about school and I can't book anything yet <ss type="sad">:(</ss>
08:26:53 am
jeevacation
I think paypal rejected as too large an amount. Will check
09:38:34 am
Oh I see . Thank you Jeffrey
10:19:26 am
Jeffrey is Morning on 14.04 to London ?
02:23:02 pin
I thought-comes
02:23:11 pm
We have 2 bedrooms only
02:33:46 pm
Landlord gave me only 2 keys , 1 they keep
02:35:28 pm
jeevacation
both
02:33:04 pm
jeevacation
no worry i dont hinlMvill stay . you can make extra keys , im in meeeting and
we can talk later
02:36:46 pm
Sure sorry for disturbing
02:37:07 pm
Here is a bit problem to make another key, coz I need permission from landlord and
they said they don't want me to do a third key . It's strange here
02:38:23 pm
Here is a bit problem to make another key, coz I need permission from landlord and
they said they don't want me to do a third key . It's strange here
02:38:27 pm
Ok I II go and double check
02:41:16 pin
jeevacation
ok, you can make keys its not in the lease
02:39:06 pm
jeevacation
Just make them
02:51:58 pm
Just make them
02:51:59 pm
0
0
0

• I checked with the keys with this locker they are doing in only one place which is closed
already . I will make them tomorrow
04:22:40 pm
EFTA00811973 (Jmail)
 [money] Darren Indyke $250,000 check to open Charles Schwab account from Southern Trust Company account at FirstBank
(date: 2019-04-08)
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.                FIRSTBANK ST. THOMAS, VI 00002 101726611216
6100 RED HOOK QUARTERS 83
ST. THOMAS, VI 00602

Check# 1997
4/8/2019

PAY TO THE ORDER OF Charles Schwab & Co., Inc.
Two Hundred Fifty Thousand and 00/100""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
Charles Schwab & Co., Inc.
$250,000.00 DOLLARS

MEMO
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
Charles Schwab & Co., Inc.
DB JEE ckg 3526969
4/8/2019
1997
250,000.00
250,000 00
Charles SCHWAB Instructions for the Schwab One Account
Application for Incorporated Organizations
1-800435-4000 (inside the U.S.) I .1415-667-8400 (outside the U.S.) 11-888-686.6916 (multilingual services)
Instructions for How to Open a Schwab One Incorporated Organization Account

• You must meet a $250.000 relationship minimum across all Schwab accounts and complete this application to open a new 
Schwab Incorporated
Organization Account.

• if you are submitting a handwritten form, please print in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS.
• This application is only for use by organizations incorporated and domiciled in the United States. If your 
Organization is a non-incorporated
organization (sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability company, unincorporated association, etc.) or a 
non-U.S. organization, please contact
us for the correct account application.

• If the Organization wishes to request option, margin, and short trading, please complete and submit a separate Add 
Options Trading and Margin to
Your Account form.

• If the Organization wishes to have the ability to write checks In the account, please complete and submit a 
Checkwriting and Visa• Debit Card
Application for Organization Accounts.

• If the Organization wishes to fund this account by transferring assets from another brokerage firm, please also submit
a Transfer Your Account to
Schwab form.

• A minimum of two signatures of corporate officers are required to open an account. One signature must be from the 
Chairman of the Board, the
President. or any Vice President: the second signature must be from the Secretary, any Assistant Secretary. the Chief 
Financial Officer, the Treasurer.
or any Assistant Treasurer.
Schwab, like all U.S. financial institutions, Is required to follow federal regulations to assist the government in its 
efforts to fight money laundering and
other financial crimes. Schwab therefore requests specific information and documentation in order to verify the identity
of an entity applying for a
Schwab account, as well as the identities of that entity's Control Persons, Authorized Individuals, and Beneficial 
Owners. Schwab may require additional
documentary evidence demonstrating identity and legal status. Schwab also captures personal information on all customers
and related authorized
parties who have the ability to transact, control, or manage an account. Schwab has the discretion to not accept an 
account, to close an account, or to
terminate any and all services rendered under the Schwab One Account Agreement at any time.
Return Instructions

• Upload online with secure messaging (if you are an existing client and have online access to your account).

1. Go to and log in to your account.
2. Click Message Center (under Service), and then click Upload Document.
• Fax to 1-888-526-7252.
• Bring to your nearest Schwab branch (visit for locations).
• Mall to any of the following addresses:
Regular Mail (West) Regular Mail (East)
Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. aeries Schwab & Co., Inc.
Box 982600 ■. Box 628291
El Paso. TX 79998-2600 Orlando, FL 328624291
Overnight Mall (West)
Charles Schwab & Co., Inc.
1945 Northwestern Dr.
El Paso, TX 79912
Overnight Mall (East)
Charles Schwab & Co., Inc.
1958 Summit Park Or., Ste. 200
Orlando, FL 32810
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. Ail rights reserved. Member Sin.
CC2344861(1118.8AK) APP63584-12 (12/18)
Please retain this page for your files.
You do not need to send it back to Schwab.
charles SCHWAB Schwab One® Account Application
for Incorporated Organizations
EMIMII 1-800435-4000  (inside the U.S.) 1+1416436743400 (outside the U.S.) 0.488-6866916 (multilingual services)
Page 1 of 13

1. Required Information About the Corporation
Schwab will use the information you provl 0 en ands ur account, communicate with you, and provide information about 
products and services.
Read about Schwab's privacy policy a . As required by law. Schwab will use the information provided to verify the 
identity of
the corporation and its Authorized Individuals, Control Persons, and Beneficial Owners. As provided In the Schwab One 
Application Agreement for
Incorporated OrpnizatIons. Schwab is also authorized to inquire as to the creditworthiness of the corporation or any 
person associated with your account.
TYPO of OrgenkatIon/Fedeial Tee CfassAcation Meatered—sefect only Om)
0 C Corp: cation RiSCOMMatlim
Name of ConsatIon Ms Penn on the charter or other legal document mating the carporadm) illereinatter referred to as the 
-Corporallann
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
Corporedan Tax '0 Member
66-0779861
II COreoredOn Is Imam by weds name. enter name. telephone Number

(340) 775-2525
Corporation Street Address Oda OM'S
6100 Red Hook Quarter B3
City
St. Thomas
State
USVI
Zip 040 '
00802
..iatling Address Of Onion from abovea. sates may be used) City State Zip Code
Country of Incorporation

U. S. Virgin Islands
State of Incorpotemon
USVI
Detect Inceepottidin IroriVrIctehtt,
11/18/2011
Corporation's URL Wren
Are you a Mecum 10% einivehletlet or Wrenn...king (racer a a swiftly ass Certain('
g m,  Ayes (II 'ors: enter coupons some end traded Wheel /
2. Required Information About the Corporation's Primary Business or Professional Activity
2a.To property categorize and serve your Corporation, we need to know the type of activity in which it is engaged.
Please provide the siiockiPt North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) code that best describes
our business (If you don't know your NAICS code. you can look it up at vnyw.census.govieos/wwwinalcs).
2b. Select only one option that most closely reflects the Corporation's primary business and provide the additional 
requested information (as applicable):
5 4 1 6 0 0
0 flumetel IratitiMon
EraMpleS of antihero, institutions include:

• investment Mick (eated/oSSsite investment vehicles) • Termite Mita , mmicles
• Private equity ',chide, • Investment Advisor,
grokendealerS . Baum

• tnsui once cannon** • Trust companies
Please describe the Cceeoratim's Peeedry SuilaOseiS) end Seld(S) Or detests.
Please also prOvde the name el the sSerominent agents VW semis as phiprimary rt-Mator.
ID if the Orienitatron .5 *Chin a U.S. registered brokendealot or a norrU.S. Mumma'
institution and II the asses in tra Account are not euStOrnee Mat. please Cheek this bOx.
peer( Operating Why
The COrpelallOn geol.:WS cornmeicrat orodicts of tented.
Please (laser*, the eOnuneroal products or services Mot oh/ital./W*0On provides.
Business Consulting Services
0 Non-Operating EMILY
Emmoits of nOnr0OlooOnd made* Wilier

• Holding companies • Estate reaming vehicles
• Asset pretty:On vehrcleS • Shea <WIWI,.
• Personal investment CConparotS
Please Onalhe me Cciporalrorie ornery PuroOfe(sl and ee40(5) of stainer.
0 Charitable annuli llon Please detente the CeeparilliOn'S chaeltaye purpose.
0  Cleverninental Ormazatim
ThiS Indoles Wry MU or poetical subdivision or e state. Including:

• Any agency. authOnty. Of InStrufneMallty of the state or political sybdniltion
• A ow of assets so:named or established by date state or poetical subdivision or any erlitnCy. trolerecth or 
redtromentalltY thereerf. intloden. but not
smith:I to. a 'dealer  tenon plan' as
demea in section 414(I)Of gm merino' Ramis Code 120 U.S.C. 41em) or • sole gene's fund
- A plan or protein ola gOvementrot entity
• 04a em. agents. or employees of the stew or malice' subonsion or am money. authmity. or instrumentality thereof. 
acting in their of Ica' capacity
0 TAUS Organization
A tribe-governed organization that is created by the um or tribal chambers on reservation land and under trim Lives 
(Contact Schwab 0 eactitiorel 00CAsnent
reClUiretents.)
ST
O2018 Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC.
CC2344861 (11.18-8ANE) APP63584.12 (12/18) ipiiVrtp4diiiipnii.i 1
Schwab One• Account Application for Incorporated Organizations Page 2 of 13

3. Required Information About the Organization's Investment Profile
Annual Income of Corporation
❑ Under $15,000$15,000-$24,999 L.] $25.000-$49,999 ❑ 550.000-599.999 [El $100,000 or more
Liquid Net Worth of Corporation
❑ Under $25,000$25.000-$49,999$50.000-$99.999$100.000-5249.999 15 $250,000 or more (please specify): $  
t00.000.00Qa.
Overall Investment Objective of Account
❑ Capital preservation ❑ Income g Growth ❑ Speculation
Source of Funds in Account (Check all that apply.)
Please provide the source of assets that will be deposited or held in the account. If the source is a transfer from 
another firm, please indicate the
source of funds that were used to purchase the assets.
❑ Salary, wages, savings ❑ Working capital [!J Investment capital gains
g Corporate income ❑ Family, relatives. inheritance
Purpose of Account (Check all that apply.)
❑ Business operating revenue and expense processing
❑ Investing for estate planning purposes
❑ Investing of pooled assets
(Er General investing
❑ Other (please specify):
❑ Sales of property ❑ Other (please specify):
❑ Investing of retirement funds ❑ Investing of college funds
❑ Business payroll processing ❑ Business funding
❑ Investing of business revenue ❑ Business cash management and treasury
❑ investing for tax benefits
4. Required Information About Authorized Individuals, Control Persons and 210% Beneficial Owners
Please complete this section for the following:

• Each Authorized Individual
• At least one Control Person of the Organization
• All 210% Beneficial Owners
❑ Check here if no single individual or Legal Entity/Trust owns 210% of this Organization. You agree to notify Schwab if
or when someone owns ≥10%
of the Organization in the future. If checked, complete the following for Authorized Individuals and at least one 
Control Person (e.g., principals.
directors, officers, and managing members).
Authorized Individuals • Any individual or representative of an owner, partner, member, officer, employee, or agent of 
the Organization that is
authorized by the Organization to:

• Buy and sell securities;
• Withdraw and transfer cash and securities;
• Sign contracts, waivers, and releases; and

• Otherwise conduct business with Schwab on behalf of the Organization.
• Complete Individual 1 below for the PrimaryAuthorized Individual who will receive all email correspondence from 
Schwab.

• Schwab will have no obligation of inquiry with respect to the validity of. or authority with respect to. any 
transaction or
instruction provided by an Authorized Individual.

• An individual with significant responsibility for managing the Organization (e.g.. a Chief Executive Officer, Chief
Financial Officer, Chief Operating Officer, Managing Member, General Partner. President. Vice President. or Treasurer).

• Please complete Section 4b for a Legal Entity or Trust that is a Control Person of the Organization.

• At least one Control Person is required.
• Each individual, if any, who owns, directly or Indirectly. 210% of the equity interests of the Organization (e.g.. 
each
natural person that owns 210% of the shares of a corporation).

• In the instance where a Trust is an equity owner of the Organization, the Trustees are considered Beneficial Owners
per Industry regulations. Please complete Section 4c with Trust and Trustee Information.
• Please note that the Beneficial Ownership information provided in this application wi I be applied to all other 
similarly
registered Organization accounts with the same Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN maintained at Schwab.
Control Persons
21.0% Beneficial Owners
FOR CHARLES SCHWAB USE ONLY:
Stanch Office and ACCOunt NUfillyer
sr
C2018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC.
CC2344861 (1118-8ANE) APP6358442 (12/18) A
II 1111311 Pill2
RI II
Schwab One °  Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 3 of 13
4a. Required Information About Individuals Who Are Authorized Individuals, Control Persons and/or zits; Beneficial 
Owners
If there are more than four individuals who are Authorized Individuals, Control Persons and/or ≥10% Beneficial Owners. 
please make, complete. and
attach additional copies of this section.
Individual 1
Rote of indniOual On Account (Secret ise Mat apply.)
Z Primary ketnorued lndhldubi I:l Control Parton O 210% Bondage) Owner
Title ecCepeOty of InSlylOual (Setter as that apPlY1
O CIO DCF0 O COO O eribmian of the Board Ele Met Donner
SeerelefY iFf Pamir Elailletint waster El Other (soecityl: . President EIViCe President OSeCretery O AseeStant
Name (First) (Middle) (Last)
Richard Kahn
Home Street eddreSS (no . beced)
130 East 75th Street Apt 7E
ow
New York
State
NY
Zip Cade
10021
Mailing Address Ill deferral Iran above: IM. bases may be used)
5 Lexington Ave 4 Fl
Cary
New York
Stale
NY
DP Code
10022
;veers Tmeolsone Number(lading Nee code)
014extro Efeuswass CIA400ile (212) 971-1306
ANernille Telephone Humber (Ineludnil area code)
O °nine= ErMOtrit (9 7) 414.7584 • mow
Social Security Honer
108-50-9833
Date of girth Ina 1/0441)11
12/06/1972
Email Adding
CeonVy(ieS) Of CitibenSfllPPAUSt est all.)
gine Dower Doreen
Country Of Leta ReeddenCe
gum I:i Other:
TO Number and Type
ErPasspon O Dbeer'S Ucense Demmelessuedi0 477516497
CountryOr State of Issuance Evade°
USA
Keene
Me beci/ddinyal
03/16/2021
eiviemeni sews (Select Only one.)
O Student O Not Employed
Employer Name/Sus/1M
HBRK ASSOCIATES INC gEnviOyed O SeITEmplOyed x Flared alernemaker
Occupation (If yOti selectee implored' or 'Seittnuerairad: select one aerial that best desciteS Ireml cucleTelfm)
Professions Om Mary O eanSultant
Pe:45 w°' Dclucator O Omer Ispeelfy)1
O CleficabAdminsostive Services
Employee liederst/State/Local) arade/Senica aliter/Manulacbcelng/Production)
Employee defamb.S.i OSaWs/Marsetinc
II Business OwnefiMil.Ereplommo D financial Seruces/Clanking
EExecutive/SenkxManagtenem D informilion TechnOletlY
O Malcal Professimal DOtlwr Professional
II Legal Probsbortal O U.S. Government
El Recounting Profirse/Onal O PlielHie Gonuitirnont
Business Street Address
575 Lexington Ave 4 Fl
Oty
NEW YORK
State
NY
Zip Cede
10022
Are you al and ran or employed bye fl ack ecnang or member km of an eteronge or FINRA. Ore municipal Securities 
OroltectleaSer?
Elko Des (If yes: yet; must attach a letter from your emplOyer Or maws Proem -dealer approving the establishment of your
account %nen Suballtfing
List the company name: )
this application.
Are you a director. 10% Shatehaider or DOliCprimillin• officer of • Needy Told company?
Miro Oyes or Its: Wirer compaew name and trading symbol .1
rot Benelcial Owners OW
what IS your percentage of venal:M 0a %
O uneaten, wan) O orlefsbeng O sot,* Security benefits
O Lottery O Sale of moped), Or busintas OGIlts
whet is your source of peastrt?(Caeck al that 'COM
Mselary. wens. taints D Family. relatives. nitedUnC•
O Invtstment capital Calms O Invention/patent
ST
G)2018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. Alt rights reserved. Member SI PC
CC2344862 II.118-flANE) APP63584.12 (12/18) I'll] Hill II 1 2
Schwab 0ne° Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 4 of 13
4a. Required Information About Individuals Who Are Authorized Individuals, Control Persons and/or ≥.1.0% Beneficial 
Owners (Continued)
Individual 2
pole or inismsoal on Account (Select all that aetsly.i
OMethod/eel IncliMuerk O Control Person ig≥ 10% Beneficial Owner
Toe or Capacny or inamduad (Select VI Mat *W .}
0CE0 0CF0 Ocoo O Chalons.. of Me Beard O Manager DN.*/
SeCrett",  O Treats/et O ASSietant Treasurer O Onset (SPeolli): MPresidemt E Vice President O SeatterY O Assistant
Name (First) (Middle) oast)
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Home Street Mina (ne al boon)
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER 83
City
ST THOMAS
State
VI
Zip owe
00802
Mailing Address Of Orferent from above: it tares may be used) City State be Cede
Pretend TeittetiOne Number (inducting wee code)
OHente igetnisess O Mobile (340) 775-2525
stomas Telephone Member (included area coat)
O Home O Business OMobilit
Social Security Nunn.,
090-44-3348
Olite ot Sinn franVelehrni
01/20/1953
Email Address
richardkahn12@gmail.com
COun(rytieS)Olatisenship (Must Int till.)
EfUSA 00then ClOther:
COUntryrat Legal Residence
&rum Dump: US VIRGIN ISLANDS
0 eons Nu Type
Er Passport O Divers License puove.ssuba 0 566672615
Countryor State of issuance
USA
Esolnyikle Date trInVeltUrifY)
0=7/2029
Email:Meant Statue (Select Only one.)
gEmoloyed OSellerployed °Retired O Homemaker O Stotirmt O Not Emptorld
SWIM. NarneMuSineSS Name
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
Occupation(,  you selectee • Employed' et • SelleImployed: select
O Bunnell Owner/Seiginployee Drsiancral Secnceifftenkng
ElEsecutive/Senict management OInf effusion Technology
O Medical raoressicem 00ther ProresVonar
one *Won that beet cieltlantt your OccvetillOrs)
Professional O PA Lary OConsultant
Professional DEducatOr 00ther (WOW:
OCierieW/Administrative Services
Employee geOveaState/tocoll O Trade/Service Itersor/Manulacturinuproductiony
Ern:Ovine [POMMY OSeles/Marlysting
in LOU' Protinsional 0 U.S. Government
O AccOunting Professions O Rain Government
Cosiness Street Address
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER 83
City
ST THOMAS
State
VI
Zip Code
00802
me you affiliated with Of ern040110 by a stock eschenge or member arm of an exchange or FINRA. or a muncipal securities 
Of0Sentleseet?
IgNO Dyes of yes: yOU must attach a letter from your employer of affiliated OrOkeridealer approving 010 establiShment of
your account Pawn submitting
List the company in 1
tan application.
Aro you a orator, lox shareholder Or colkyaeldng officer of a Publicly AM CernOaPP
[Ero O l'eS Or yes: enter oxbow name and &acme symbol .)
Far Broefictel Owners emir-
what is your percentage of ownersNp? 100 %
O litigation award Detail:sling OSociel Searatybeneita
O Lottery Oasis of property or business O GUIs
Mel is your source of wealth? (Check all that 5000
O Geralls wages. savings O Freely. relatives. onenunce
EfInvntmer4 Caput gain O Inventioh/patent
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC.
CC2344861 (1118 -SANE) 'v136358442 (12/18) nii 11IIIIIIIII
Schwab one• Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 5 of 13
4a. Required Information About Individuals Who Are Authorized Individuals, Control Persons and/or 210% Beneficial Owners
(Continued)
Individual 3
Role of mammal on Accoom (Select at that MOM
0Authorized Inc/Nichol 0 Censor Person 0210% Elenersisi Miner
Tale Of Caps:ayor rovidual 'Select all that apply.)
O CEOCFO ❑coo
❑President ❑ Vice Mash:fent ❑Secretary
Name mrso
❑ Chairman el the board
❑ Assistant Secretary
Deanna
0 Treasurer
❑ Nom
❑ Assistant %Snorer ❑ Other (specilyr
Middle)
Home Street AddreSS Nos Soros) City Stele Zip Code
mailing Address (if afferent horn aeon; s boon may he used) City State Zip Code
Preferred Telephone bombes(inchona area code)
El Have ❑ BuSOOSS ❑ MOM
Social Security Hunter
Memel Telephone Number fineltramit sees MOO
0/tern. ❑ Business ❑ M0000
DOW of Dinh OrinVddiryyyyl (mall Address
Country(NS) of Otizensalp (Must tat all?
0 LISA 0 Other:  0 Other:
ID Hunter and Type
❑ PM4Con ❑ others License Obalakssued ID
Employment Status (Select only One.)
0 Employed ❑ Self-Employed 0 Retired ❑ Homemaker 0 Student ❑ Not Employed
OCCUp0000 (it you $440C100 '0110totte of 'S.$-mployed: school on. option Met bast descrilNs yoo ocCv00110o)
❑ Busmen Owner/501 ElorPrzfod
❑ Execultue/Sonlor Management
❑Medea' Preessknal
❑ Lep Proltssiona
0Accounting Professional
Business Street Address
Country &Legal nascence
El OSA ❑Other.
Ga)ntrya State of  istranoe Expiration Date anmSdertYffff
Employer Name/bus/neat Name
❑ Nankai Seraces/Banking Professional
❑ information ?tonne/eV NI:011 MM'
0 Other PrOansonai
❑0.s. Othamment employee (Federal/Sul./hall
Oniveignemoemmom Employee (Non-U.00
Off Mtn
❑Educator
❑ Clencal/Adrraniatrothe Services
❑ Iteder/Servic• (Lebef/hilalitletuting/PrOduCVOn)
❑ Sales/Menurong
City
0 Consultant
❑ °the:Welly):
Stale Zip Cede
Are you 01111100/0 with a 0000000 by a stock echange of fnembor farm of an exthange a ForRa. or a munieffal securities 
broker -dealer?
❑ NO 0 MS (If Yes: you must attach 8 letter from your employer or affiliated broker -dealer approving the establishment 
of your account when SubMittIng this
appliCaliOn.
MOO COMMAS Miarlei
Me you a director. 10% shareholder or path- trashing officer of a pubicly Mid company?
0 No 0 Ma (If yes: enter company name  and trading symbol
For Beneath Owners Only:
What Incur ptnetttlite of onfolhoO?
Minot la your SOWN Of wealth? (Chock all that apply.)
❑ Salary. wages. sating, ❑ ramps relatives. trVitrillnet
O investment capital gains ❑ invermon/pacent
❑ Miamian avraro ❑Ganeang ❑ Social Security benefits
0 Lottery ❑ Sale of property or business OWN&
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. AB rights reserved. Member 08C.
CC2344861 u118-amozi acm6358412 01/181 ftl11411111II11111 2
Schwab One* Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 6 of 13
4a. Required Information About Individuals Who Are Authorized Individuals, Control Persons and/or ≥10% Beneficial Owners
(Continued)
Individual 4
Role of inclivicual on Account Omen all mat asely.)
O Autroodzed Individual OControl Person MI 310% Benders, Owner
nue or Capacity of InclivIdeal (Select al mat axis)
OCE0 OCII0 0000 O Cheers/mot the board O manager O Owner
OPresident O vice OfeSidelt O SeCretaff O *SSW afil Sauna'' ,  a hemmer PASSietrint Treasurer O Other (specify):
Name OHM Paddle) Met)
Home Street Address (no Il. boxes) Guy State Zip Coie
mailing Address Of *Velem from above:. bores Maybe used) Oty Stale Zip Code
Preferred Telephone Number (Oohs:ling area code)
O Home O &mass O Motile
Memel Telephone Number Inclutang area COPP)
O Hom OBusiness O Mobile
Social Security Number Data of girth immiclooryy) Email Address
Country( *M M Citizenship (Must Mt all.)
O USA O Other: Dome
Counvy 01 Segal Malden,*
MI USA 00ther:
0 Number and Type Country or Stine of !nuance Expiration bate (mmid4O/YYY)
• Passport O Covers ucense OGoestssued lb
Employment Status (Select Only One)
O EMMA.] O SeltEnefle0 O Reared O Homemelor OStment O Not Employed
EmPlOrefilarne/eusiness Name
Occupetion (limy selected 'Ernolorocr or • saw(mployed. select one moan that best describes your occupation.)
O business Owner/SeitEmoloyecl P roamer SenncesAllankim Professions O Khios 00:extuitent
OEyesight/Senior Management O information Technoiegy processional O Educate( O 0tnef ISINCifyk
O Memel R/OltSSIMIII 00ther Prolosucoai OClencar/Admnistraio Services
Oleg., Professional (0 u.s. Gmernment Enwoyee (PedefaliSteteAccall O padeiService (Labof/Mamfactoung/Productionl
O Accounting Proltolcoar ofore;r0ovemmem Employee (Nal.U.S 1 OSatosiMarlieting
Business Street Acktfess City State Zip Code
Ate you affiliated with or employed by a sack Ma:flange or member fan of an exmango or FINRA. or a municipst securities 
brokesclealer?
Olio fp yes (II yes: you must attach a better from your employee Or (mated brokendealer apfxoying the establishment of 
your account when Submitting this
application.
Ust the company name: I
Are you a dimmer. 10% shareholder or poky.making ofacef of a 0 SAO held comeanY?
ONO pros Ill *Ww. enter compere name and tracing symbol .)
rot Benachtl Owners Only
That Is your percentage Of amortise? %
OILrogation award O Gambling O Social Security benefits
O Lottery O Sale of property of bosoms Delfts
What Is )0W source N wealth? (OWN NI Mat mealy.)
O Stew. wages. sayings O FSMilf. mothers. Weientance
O inwestmere capital gains O swention/patent
Sr
8,2018 Charles Scrwrab & CO.. Inc. All rights reserved. member SIPC.
CC2344861 (1118 -SANE) APPt33584-12 (12/ 18) A 8
Schwab One *  Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 7 of 13
4b. Control Person That Is a Legal Entity
If the Control Person is a Legal Entity or a Trust. provide the information requested below —all Information is 
required. In addition, please complete the
information requested for at least one of the underlying Control Persons/Trustees of the Legal Entity/Trust.
Name of Legal Entity Legal Entity Tax IC Number
■ apt Entity le known by soothe. name. ear name. Telephone Member
Legal Emily Swat Mellen (no. boa.) City State !Made
Mailing Address (if afferent from Name boos ray be used) City State Zif) Code
Country of InuorporstiordEStabliament state of IncorpOratierV
Establisreant
Date or Incuporabon/Establishment
lmiliVOWM111
6-0Igit NAICS Cale
Provide the following information for at least one Control Person/Trustee for the above Legal Entity/Trust. If 
information was provided for the Control
Person/Trustee in Section 4a, list only his/her name below.
Control Person/Trustee
Name (First) (Middle 0.030
Nome Street Address OM boxes) Oty Slate Zip Cede
Preferted Telephone Number lincordIng aces code)
0 ❑ &Gass 0 Mobile
Afternele To/No.1one
0 lire
Number (including area cede)

• BusineSS 0 Mobile Nicene
Social Security Monter Bale of Birth imenad/n7N
CountiMieS)cit C(diasnlp (Must Ni all.) Country el legal Residence
0 USA 0 Other 0 USA ❑owe.: IMI Other
Cr Number and Type
0 Passport ❑ Drivers license 00alossued IO
COunUyOr Sate Of issuance Corium One boor/dd./WW)
Employment Wild clad only one.) Employe Nerne/Busteess Name
0 EnclOyed ❑settEmotged ■ Retired 011:memaker 0 Student 0 Not Employed
Occupation Of you selected 'imps:Ise et •SeaMmoloted: select ere option that best delabes pydr occupatica.)
❑ Business Owner/Selamployed ❑rman:ai Strikes/Banked Professional OM Amy
❑ Ficeanlve/Senia Management Osamu:Mon TechnOicela PrcasMonal 0 Educator
❑ Medial Professcnal 0 Other Professional 0ClesiceMAdministratia
❑ Legal Prolessionai 0 U.S. Government Employee tarletaliState/loral) ❑ Trade/Serva (laitsx/Manuf
0Accounting Proltsolcoal ❑ Foreign Goyemmern Employee OroniU.S.1 OSMes/Matating
• Conata
Ili Other (specify):
Sen%es
sawing/Production)
Business Street ArlOress City State Zip Code
ate you affiliated eat or ernolOad bye stock Mange or member Arm of an etettage or FIMTA, or  securities brokenderier?
EjNO OleS (If "yeS: YOU must attach a letter from your employer or Militated bream:Male, approving the establishrnem of 
your account even suomitting
test ti e company name: • )
this application.
Are you e Orman 10% shirehower or ookresaltieg officer ten a giubliclY held company?
0 No 0 MS Ill yes: Matra. company name and trading symbol a
ST
022018 Charles Schwab & CO.. Inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC.
CC2344861 (1118.8ANE) APP63584.12 (12/18)
A
I II I III III, i
Schwab One *  ACCount Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 8 of 13
4c, Information About Trusts That Are 210% Beneficial Owners
in the instance where a Trust is a 210% equity owner of the Organization, the Trustees are considered Beneficial Owners 
per industry regulations.
Information for at least one current Trustee is required. If there is more than ono Trust that is a 210% Beneficial 
Owner of the Organization, please
make, complete, and attach additional copies of this Section 4c.
Name of Trust
Country CA Eatebtiervnent State of Establishment
Met is the Trust's percentage 01 ownership in the OrganizatalT
Please complete Part 1 for a current Trustee(s) that is an Individual and Part 2 for a current Trustee that is an Entity
Trustee.
Part 1.• Trustee That Is an Individual
Provide the following information for at least one current Trustee of the aforementioned Trust. If information was 
provided for a current Trustee in

Section 4a or 4b, list only his/her name below.
Trustee
li arne (First) (Middle) (Lob
Home StreetMolten (n0■ born) City State Zip COO
Prelernicl Telephone Number (incMding lirea 0000)
Li Home ❑ Busness O Mobile
Alternate Teletertne
O Heine O
Number Mauling fired code)
Susktees O Mobile
Social SeatebY Sumba ( Date of Birth (mmiddiyyyy)
Coontryllee) Of Cittranship pant am aio
❑ us. ❑Other. Dome..
Country or Legal Residence
❑ usa ❑ouwr.
0 Number end Type
❑ PeopOrt O Driver's License OtimebiSsuery ID
COMP, or State of Invent& ExplraUcn Date  (mmMIAITO
Employment SUMS (Select Only Mt)
O Employed ❑sernEmgo)ed O Retired akeriernaker O Student ❑ Not Employed
Employer kame/BuSinind Name
Occupation (1l you selected 'Employed* or •Sai'Emplomd: select one onion that best descries purr occupation.)
❑ Business Onner/Sellexployed ❑ FinaMal Secnces/Sertking ProlessiOnal
ODetuthe/Senor Management ❑ information Technology Pordessimai
ElMosical Professional ❑ Other Professional
pail Proleselonio O U.S. Goverment DitOlOyet woo•raVStatenouill
❑ Amounting Professicoel ❑ Foreign Government Employee Illorsti.SY
O MOUSY
O Edtrostor
OCierical/Acsmisuative
O OrnSultant
ClOmer feeecifyli
Services
Itabee/marlofeetvringraretietiont I. weee/Service
❑ Sales/Mannting
Business Street Morels City State Zip Code
me you affiliated with or employed by a stock exchange or member irm of an exchange or MCA, or  securities
O No O yes (II "05. - you must attach a letter from your employer Or aftlialea brokeodeMer approving
List the company name: )
brokerclealer?
the establishment of your account when Submitting this application.
Me you a director. 10% sharaholcier ot poky -making *Meer Of a publicly held MOW
❑Iii O Yes Of 'yes: also cote' «moony nano  and Ulidilt symbol .)
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC.
CC234486111118.8ANE) API:03584-12 (12/18) I j II IR iw I 8
Schwab One° Accowtt Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 9 of 13
4c. Information About Trusts That Are 210% Beneficial Owners (Continued)
Part 2: Entity Trustee
Complete this section if the Trustee is an entity (corporate trustee or other entity).
Name of Legal Entity (as charm se the charter or other legal document cresting the legal entity: hereinafter referred to
as the Nagai Entity") Legal Entity Tea
IC (*Amber
II Loot Entityla moon by another name. enter name. Telephone Ninnyor
Legal Entity Street Address (no MI bores) City State Zip Code
Country of InOXPOratIOEVEStablishment State or hcoroaration/
Establishment
Date of IneerporaoarVastahaslonont
(mmidcVnyt)
6.Exot MACS COOe
Required Information About Entity Trustee Control Person
Complete this section for one Control Person of the aforementioned Entity Trustee.
Entity Trustee Control Person
/omens') (Middle) (Last)
Nome Street ...Wren (non bons) City Stag be Code
Preened Ultra?, Number (Including area coda)
p E❑I euelnelS O Mcbas
mounme Tele:none Number (Including Yea MOM
O Home O Business 0 Mobile Mee
Social Security Number Otte of Own UnnVelliyyyy)
COuntryllIS) OE Citizenship (Must int ad.)
O USA DOthea CI Other:
Country of Legs Residence
O USA DettieR
D Number and Type
O Passport O Divers License ❑60VI issued ID
Country or State of Issuance Expiration Date (mrrizadimiYA
Employment Status (Select only one.)
ElEmployed O SettEmpoyed O Retired ONomerneker I:Student O Not Employed
Emulator None/Business Name
Occupation Of you sainted 'Cmporrop' or • Self-Employed; Weer one ormon inn ton descraes your occupation.)
O Business Ownet/Seil.EmOloved O Anomie Sonricos/Bankino Proltselonal OMOrlery ElCormultant
0 Execotmermnox Management O information TecnnolOgY FOOMSMoIM DEducster Does (specify),
OMedical Orden:pod O Other Professiami Ociericammaxinistrative Services
O Legal Professions O U.S. 0Cmyrnment Employee II ecletal/Stete/locall El Toote/Sorylca tlatior/Marolocwring/Productmnl
OAecounting Professional O foreign Government Employee (NonD.S) OSoles/Maasting
Business Street Address City State Zip Cod
Ate you MAIMS with Of employed bye Mock exchange or member1ml of en exchange or FINIAL or a municipal securities 
OrckentloMerl
Elmo ID Ye If Ids: also enter company name .
(You must attach a letter tO this application Mat is from your employer, approving the establishment of Ws account.)
Are you a director. 10% shareholder or polictmaking officer of a publicly held company?
O No Oyes (If 'yes.' also enter conspany name  and trading symbol
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & CO.. Inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC.
CC2344861 (111813ANE) APP83584.12 (12/18) A
1111 11 111111
Schwab One* Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 10 at 13

5. Your Consent to Enroll In Schwab's Cash Features Program
The Cash Features Program is a service that we provide that permits the uninvested cash or 'free credit balance' In your
Account to earn income while
those funds remain uninvested. Additional information about the Cash Features Program and each Cash Feature is available
in the Cash Features
Disclosure Statement.
The designated Cash Feature for this Account is the Schwab One Interest feature. By signing this Application, you 
consent to participate in Schwab's
Cash Features Program• as described in the Cash Features Disclosure Statement, and you also consent to having the Schwab
One Interest feature as.
your designated cash feature.
You understand and agree that Schwab may (1) make changes to the terms and conditions of the Cash Features Program; (2) 
make changes to the
terms and conditions of any Cash Feature; (3) change, add, or discontinue any Cash Feature: (4) change your investment 
from one Cash Feature to
another if you become ineligible for your current Cash Feature or your current Cash Feature Is discontinued; and (5) 
make any other changes to the Cash
Features Program or Cash Feature as allowed by law. Schwab will notify you in writing of changes to the terms of the 
Cash Features, changes to the Cash
Features we make available, or changes to the Cash Features Program prior to the effective date of the proposed changes.

6. Fund Account
g Check or money order made payable to Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. enclosed for S  250.°° 0 -0°
❑ Transfer from another financial institution (complete the Transfer Your Account to Schwab form).
❑ Electronic transfer using Schwab MoneyLink• (complete the Set Up Schwab MoneyLink Electronic Funds Transfer form).
7. Paperless Document Enrollment
Here's how paperless works: The Primary Authorized Individual will receive account statements, trade confirmations, 
shareholder materials, account
agreements and related disclosures, and other regulatory documents, if available in paperless form, by email. For 
certain documents, including account
Statements. you will receive an email notification with a link to log on to our secure website to access your documents.
For complete information, please
see Important Information About Your informed Consent to Receive Paperless Documents In the Appendix to this 
application.
To opt for Paperless Documents, simply provide the Primary Authorized Individual's email address in Section 4a. The 
enrollment completion will depend
on one of the following scenarios.
Scenario 1
If you are the Primary Authorized Individual, and already have an account enrolled in Papedess Documents using the email
address provided in Section
4a, have logged on to in the past six months, and agree to the following, your paperless enrollment will be complete 
once your account is
opened.

• I have read and understood the Important Information About Your Informed Consent to Receive Paperless Documents In the
Appendix to this applica-
tion and consent to enrolling this account In Paperless Documents.
• i understand that I will receive an email with my new account agreement and related disclosures.
Or
Scenario 2:
If you ere the Primary Authorized Individual, and do not have an existing account enrolled In Papedess Documents, are 
using a different email address, or
have not logged on to in the past six months. we will send you an email after the account is opened. To complete 
enrollment, you will need to
cick the Consent" button in that email and/or follow the instructions to access If you do not click the 'I Consent' 
button, this account will
not be enrolled in Paperless Documents and we will send your account agreement an re ate disclosures, as well as future 
regulatory documents, by
postal mall.
If you are the Primary Authorized Individual and do not want to participate in Paperless Documents, please check the box
below.
(PS No. do net enroll my account in Paperless Documents. Please send my regulatory documents via postal mail.
ST
O2018 Charles Schwab & Co.. inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC.
CC2344862 (1118-BANE) APP63584.12 (12/18) A p
Schwab Ones Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 11 of 13

8. Offer/Referral Code (Optional, up to three offer/referral code entries)
env/Werra: Code
Orferinsfarrei Code
Orrer/Rererna Code
Terms and conditions may apply. Any taxes related to an offer are your responsibility You should consult with your tax 
or legal advisor regarding any tax
implications and the appropriate tax treatment of an offer. For more information regarding an offer, please call 
1.866-469-7017.
9. Required Account Opening Authorizations
Required Signatures for Section 9
At least two signatures are required to open a Schwab One Organization Account for a Corporation. There must be at least
one signature in each of
the following categories:
Category 1: The Chairman of the Board, the President. or any Vice President of the Corporation
Category 2: The Secretary, any Assistant Secretary, the Chief Financial Officer, the Treasurer, or any Assistant 
Treasurer of the Corporation

• If you ars the only corporate officer, please sign in boas Category 1 and Category 2, indicating your respective 
corporate roles under each category.
• All other Authorized Individuals listed in Section 4a who have the authority to conduct business with Schwab and who 
have not already signed
under Category 1 or 2 must sign in the Additional required signatures and W-9 certifications section.
Please complete all four Signature fields: (1) sign name, (2) print name. (3) specify title, and (4) enter date. Schwab 
cannot complete these fields on
your behalf—failure to complete all four fields will delay the processing of your application.
By signing this application, each individual in his or her representative and individual capacity ('you') certifies, 
represents and warrants that all of the
information supplied in this application Is complete, true and correct. You also agree that you have received and read a
copy of the attached Schwab One
Account Application Agreement for Incorporated Organizations (-Application Agreement"). which contains a predispute 
arbitration clause. You acknowl-
edge and agree that this arbitration clause Is a binding obligation of both the Corporation and you with respect to your
capacity as an authorized individual
on the account(s).
You represent and warrant that you have all the requisite power and authority to (1) provide the tax certifications and 
(2) establish, maintain and operate an
account(s) with Schwab on behalf of the Corporation and to bind the Corporation to the Application Agreement and all 
incorporated agreements and
disclosures, including, but not limited to. the Schwab One Account Agreement and the Charles Schwab Pricing Guide for 
Individual Investors, each as
amended from time to time (the -Agreement and Disclosures"). You represent and warrant that the Corporation documents, 
resolutions, agreements and
laws governing the Corporation permit the establishment and maintenance of the account(s) in accordance with the 
Agreement and Disclosures. You
represent and warrant that you will not take any action or provide any instruction to Schwab that exceeds your authority
under Corporation documents,
resolutions, agreements and laws governing the Corporation.
You represent and warrant that each Authorized Individual listed on this application or subsequently provided to Schwab 
is authorized by the Corporation
to act individually, independently and without the consent of the board or any director, officer or other person of the 
Corporation. You represent and
warrant that any notice sent to any Authorized Individual will constitute notice to the Corporation. You represent and 
warrant that nothing in the Corpora-
tion documents, agreements and laws governing the Corporation imposes any obligation upon Schwab for determining the 
purpose or propriety 0) of any
instructions received from any Authorized Individual or (II) of payments or deliveries to or among Authorized 
Individuals.
You authorize Schwab to apply the Beneficial Ownership information provided in this application to all other similarly 
registered Organization accounts with
the same Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN) maintained at Schwab.
You authorize Schwab to inquire from any source. including a consumer reporting agency, as to the identity of you and 
any Corporation you represent (as
required by federal law), creditworthiness and ongoing eligibility for the account(s) at account opening, at any time 
throughout the life of the account(s), and
thereafter for debt collection or investigative purposes.
You agree to notify Schwab immediately in writing of any change that would cause these representations and warranties to
become incorrect or incom-
plete. You hereby, jointly and severally, in both personal and representative capacities, agree to indemnify Schwab and 
its affiliates, officers, directors,
employees and agents from• and to hold such persons harmless against, any claims, judgments, surcharges. settlements or 
other liabilities or costs of
defense or settlement (including investigative and attorneys' fees) arising out of or related to any act or omission to 
act by any Authorized Individual with
respect to the account(s), the breach of any agreement with Schwab or any dispute involving you and the Corporation.
The representations and obligations stated in this certification will survive the termination of the account(s).
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. All rIPts reserved. Member SIPC.
CC2344861 (11184BANM APP63584.12 (12/18) I( 11 1111111
Schwab One° Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 12 Of 13
9. Required Account Opening Authorizations (Continued)
By signing below, you represent and warrant that this application and the incorporated Agreement and Disclosures 
constitute a legal, valid, and binding
obligation enforceable against the Corporation. You also agree, In your personal capacity. that your relationship with 
Schwab with respect to the
account(s) will be governed by the Agreement and Disclosures.
All Authorized Individuals listed in Section its must sign. Please complete all four steps: (1) sign, (2) print name, 
(3) specify title, and (4) enter date.
Schwab cannot complete these fields on your behalf—failure to complete all four steps will delay the processing of your 
application.
I certify, under penalty of perjury, that (1) the number shown on this application is the correct Taxpayer 
Identification Number; (2) 1/Organization am not
subject to backup withholding because (a) I/Organization am exempt from backup withholding, or (b) I/Organization am not
subject to backup
withholding due to a failure to report interest and dividend Income; (3) l am (a) a U.S. person, or (b) a partnership. 
corporation, company, or association
created or organized in the United States or under the laws of the United States, or (C) an estate (other than a foreign
estate), or (d) a domestic trust as
defined in federal tax regulations; and (4)I/Organizatlon am exempt from Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) 
reporting. I/Organization
understand that if VOrganization have been notified by the IRS that i/Organization am subject to backup withholding as a
result of dividend or interest
underreporting and I have not received a notice from the IRS advising me/Organization that backup withholding is 
terminated, VOrgenuation must
cross out item 2 above.
Tho internal Revenue Service does not require your consent to any
provision of this nt other than the certifications required to avoid
backup with ding.
Required s
The Agreement with Schwab Includes a predispute arbitration clause.
You acknowledge receipt of the predispute arbitration ciause contained
in Section 12, page 2, of the attached Schwab One Account Application
Agreement for Incorporated Organizations.
d W-9 certification(s) for Category 1: Chairman of the Board, President. or any Vice President
110' Jeffrey  Epstein
SignilitUre Plot Name
Title: DChartm of the rd (President ❑ Vice President
1/4120/q
Date (iviVieWnwl
Signature Print Nome
Title: EChairman of the Board ID President El Vice President
Date Imm/.51/Dyr)
Require nature(s) and W-9 c rtincation(s) for Category 2: Secretary, any Assistant Secretary. Chief Financial Officer, 
Treasurer, or any
Assist s er
Richard Kahn
Pmt Name Date (alm/da/M2)
Title: O Secretary DAssistant Secretary [pier Financial Officer [Treasurer DAssistant Treasurer
10'
Strain Print Name Data (nunrcid/WW)
Title: O Secretary DAssistant Secretary ['Chief Financial Officer DIreasurer ['Assistant Treasurer
10"
Y/5-40/9
PintStature nt Name
Title: Secretary DAssistant Secretary OChief Financial Officer ['Treasurer ['Assistant hemmer
Date (rilm/m/ww)
Additional required signatures and W-9 certifications: All remaining Authorized Individuals fisted in Section 4a who 
have not already signed and
certified under Categories 1. or 2.
Signaling Print Homo
Title
►
Stratum
title
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC.
CC2344861 (111.8•8ANE) APP63584.12 (12/18)
Date arim/c0/m71
Ant Name
11 A
1,11,1 I 113 I.
Date onfaidd/rvir)
ni 1 1
Schwab One' Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 13 of 13

10. Required Certificate of Authority and Corporate Resolution: President or Secretary
The Corporation adopts the following Certificate of Authority and Corporate Resolution.
The undersigned certifies that:

1. Each individual whose signature appears in Section 9 (each, an Authorized Individual) is authorized to (1) provide 
tax certifications; (2) establish.
maintain, and operate an account(s) with Schwab on behalf of the Corporation and to bind the Corporation to the 
Application Agreement and all
incorporated agreements and disclosures, including, but not limited to. the Schwab One Account Agreement and the Charles
Schwab Pacing Guide for
Individual Investors, each as amended from time to time (the 'Agreement and Disclosures"); and (3) designate persons to 
operate such account(s).

2. Each Authorized Individual is authorized to act Individually, independently, and without the consent of the board or 
any director, officer, or other
person of the Corporation. Notice sent to any Authorized Individual will constitute notice to the Corporation. Nothing 
in the organizational documents,
agreements, and laws governing the Corporation Imposes any obligation upon Schwab for determining the purpose or 
propriety (1) of any Instructions
received from any Authorized Individual or (2) of payments or deliveries to or among Authorized Individuals.

3. The authority thereby conferred Is not inconsistent or in conflict with the Certificate of incorporation. charter, 
bylaws, resolution, or other
applicable constituent documents of the Corporation and is within the Corporation's corporate power and authority and 
agreements and laws
governing the Corporation.
4. The signatures that Section 9 are true and genuine original signatures.
The information set
Certificate of A
Schwab at an a
ertiflcate of Authority and Corporate Resolution is true and correct, and Schwab may conclusively rely upon this
rate Resolution until the Corporation delivers a written replacement Certificate of Authority and Corporate Resolution 
to
by Schwab.
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. MI rights reserved. Member SIPC.
CC2344881 (1118 8ANE) APP83584-12 0.2/18) A
9/5'40/f Date (mmiddintyl
IN IIII I11J 11 1111112
charles SCHWAB Schwab Ones Account Application Agreement
for Incorporated Organizations
These terms relate to your Account and are part of the Account Agreement between each Account Holder and Schwab,
Please retain for your files.
Account Opening Authorizations
By signing this application, each individual in
his or her representative and individual capacity
("you") represents and warrants that all of the
information supplied in this application is true
and correct. You also agree that you have
received and read a copy of the attached Schwab
One Account APPlitation Agreement for Incorpo-
rated Organizations (*Annotation Agreement").
which contains a predispute arbitration clause.
You acknowledge and agree that this arbitration
clause is a binding obligation of both the Corpo-
ration and you with respect to your capacity as
an Authorized Individual on the Account(s).
You represent and warrant that you have all the
requisite power and authority to (1) provide the
tax certifications and (2) establish, maintain and
ooerate an account(s) with Schwab on behalf of
the Corporation and to bind the Corporation to
the Application Agreement and all incorporated
agreements and disclosures, including, but not
limited to, the Schwab One Account Agreement
and the Charles Schwab Pricing Guide for
Individual Investors, each as amended from time
to time (the 'Agreement and Disclosures").
You represent and warrant that the Corporation
documents, resolutions, agreements and laws
governing the Corporation permit the establish-
ment and maintenance of the Account(s) in
accordance with the Agreement and Disclosures.
You represent and warrant that you will not take
any action or provide any instruction to Schwab
that exceeds your authority under Corporation
documents, resolutions, agreements and laws
governing the Corporation.
You represent and warrant that each Authorized
Individual listed on this application or subse-
quently provided to Schwab is authorized by the
Corporation to act individually, independently
and without the consent of the board or any
director, officer or other person of the Corpora-
tion. You represent and warrant that any notice
sent to any Authorized Individual will constitute
notice to the Corporation. You represent and war-
rant that nothing in the Corporation documents.
agreements and laws governing the Corporation
imposes any obligation upon Schwab for
determining the purpose or propriety (I) of any
instructions received from any Authorized
individual or Oh of payments or deliveries to or
among Authorized Individuals.
You authorize Schwab to apply the Beneficial
Ownership information provided in this Update
Form to all other similarly registered Organization
accounts with the same Taxpayer identification
Number (TIN) maintained at Schwab.
You authorize Schwab to inquire from any source.
including a consumer reporting agency, as to the
identity of you and any Corporation you represent
(as required by federal law), creditworthiness and
ongoing eligibility for the Account(s) at account
opening, at any time throughout the life of the
AccounUS), and thereafter for debt collection or
Investigative purposes.
You agree to notify Schwab immediately in
writing of any change that would cause these
representations and warranties to become
incorrect or incomplete. You hereby. Jointly and
severally, in both personal and representative
capacities, agree to Indemnify Schwab and its
affiliates, officers, directors, employees and
agents from, and to hold such persons harmless
against, any claims, judgments, surcharges,
settlements or other liabilities or costs of
defense or settlement (including investigative
and attorneys' fees) arising out of or related to
any act or omission to act by any Authorized
Indhidual with respect to the Account(s), the
breach of any agreement with Schwab or any
dispute involving you and the Corporation.
The representations and obligations stated in
this certification will survive the termination of
the Account(s).
By signing this application, you represent and
warrant that this application and the incorpo-
rated Agreement and Disclosures constitute a
legal, valid and binding obligation enforceable
against the Corporation. You also agree, in your
personal capacity, that your relationship with
Schwab with respect to the Account(s) will be
governed by the Agreement and Disclosures.
Certificate of Authority and Corporate Resolution: President or Secretary
The Corporation adopts the following Certificate
of Authority and Corporate Resolution:

1. Each individual whose signature appears in

Section 9 (each, an Authorized Individual) is
authorized to (1) provide tax certifications;

(2) establish, maintain and operate an
account(s) with Schwab on behalf of the
Corporation and to bind the Corporation to the
Application Agreement and all incorporated
agreements and disclosures, including, but
not limited to, the Schwab One Account Agree-
ment and the Charles Schwab Pricing Guide for
Individual Investors, each as amended from
time to time (the "Agreement and Disclo-
sures"); and (3) designate persons to operate
such account(s).

2. Each Authorized individual is authorized to act
individually, independently and without the
consent of the board or any director, officer or
other person of the Corporation. Notice sent
to any Authorized Individual will constitute
notice to the Corporation. Nothing in the
organizational documents, agreements and
laws governing the Corporation imposes any
obligation upon Schwab for determining the
purpose or propriety (i) of any instructions
received from any Authorized Individual or
(i) of payments or deliveries to or among
Authorized Individuals.
3. The authority thereby conferred is not incon-
sistent or in conflict with the Certificate of
Incorporation, charter, bylaws, resolution or
other applicable constituent documents of
the Corporation and is within the Corporation's
corporate power and authority and agree-
ments and laws governing the Corporation.
4, The signatures that appear in Section 9 are
true and genuine original signatures.
The information set forth in this Certificate of
Authority and Corporate Resottion Is true and
correct, and Schwab may conclusively rely upon
this Certificate of Authority and Corporate
Resolution until the Corporation delivers a
written replacement Certificate of Authority and
Corporate Resolution to Schwab at an address
specified by Schwab.
Schwab One Account Application Agreement for Incorporated Corporations

Section 1: Scope of Agreement. Your agree-
ment with Schwab consists of the terms set
forth in this Application Agreement and the
terms set forth in the Schwab One Account
Agreement, which incorporates the Charles
Schwab Pricing Guide for InalWdual Investors and
a number of other important disclosures. The
Schwab One Account Agreement is provided
with this application or at the opening of your
Account. You agree to contact Schwab if you do
not receive the Schwab One Account Agreement.
In addition. you may in the future receive from
Schwab supplemental terms or disclosures that
pertain to certain account types, service
features and benefit packages. These supple-
mental terms and disclosures, this Application
Agreement and the Schwab One Account
Agreement are collectively referred to as the
"Agreement and Disclosures: You agree to read
the Agreement and Disclosures carefully and
retain copies for your records.
ST
02018 Charles Schwab 6 Co.. Inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC. CC2344881 (1118.8ANC) APP83584.12 (12/18)
Schwab One• Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 2 of 3

Section 2: Acceptance of Agreement and
Disclosures. You agree that the Agreement and
Disclosures govern all aspects of your relation.
ship with Schwab. Including all transactions
between Schwab and you and all products and
services now or in the future offered through
Schwab. Schwab may rely on your use of
Schwab's products and services as evidence of
your continued acceptance of the Agreement
and Disclosures.

Section 3: Your Representations and Warran-
ties. You represent and warrant that: (a) you are
of legal age in the state in which you live and you
are authorized to enter into this Agreement:

(b) you have suppiied accurate information in
your Account Application; (c) no one except the
Account Holders listed on the Account Applica-
tion (and if community property is held, the
Account Holders' spouses) has an interest in the
Account; (d) no additional authorizations from
third parties are required for you to open the
Account and effect transactions therein;
(e) except as you have otherwise indicated on
your Account Application or in writing to us.
(i) you are not an employee of or affiliated with
any securities exchange or member firm of any
exchange, the Financial Industry Regulatory
Authority (FINRA), or any securities firm, bank,
fast company, or insurance company; and
(I0 you are not a director, 10% beneficial
shareholder. policy-making officer, or otherwise
an 'affiliate (as defined in Rule 144 under the
Securities Act of 1933) of a publicly traded
company: and (1) this Application Agreement, as
amended from time to time, is a legal, valid and
binding obligation, enforceable against you in
accordance with its terms.

Section 4: Account Handling. Schwab will
automatically hold all of your securities
purchased, sales proceeds. dividends and
interest. Schwab will also release your name,
address and securities positions to companies
in which we hold securities for your Account
upon request, unless you notify us otherwise In
Writing. If you maintain more than one account
at Schwab, you authorize Schwab to transfer
assets between your accounts when no written
authorization Is requested.

Section 5: Responsibility for Investment
Decisions. You agree that you and any agent
under a power of attorney or Investment Advisor
(if you have one) are solely responsible for
investment decisions in your Account, including
whether to buy or sell or hold a particular secu-
rity. Unless required by law, or unless Schwab
provides advice to you that is clearly identified
as an individualized recommendation for you,
you understand that Schwab has no obligation
to determine whether a particular transaction,
strategy, or purchase or sale of a security is
suitable for you. Your obligation includes an affir-
mative duty to monitor and stay informed about
Your Account and your investments and respond
lb Changes as you deem appropriate.
Unless Schwab otherwise agrees with you in
writing. Schwab does not have any discretionary
authority or obligation to review or make recom-
mendations for the investment of securities or
cash in your Account.
You acknowledge that Schwab does not provide
tax or legal advice.

Section 6: Payment of Indebtedness. You agree
to make payment of any indebtedness related to
your Account, including. but not limited to, any
such Indebtedness that results from instructions
provided to Schwab by you, your agent or any
attorney-in-fact under a power of attorney or
Investment Advisor authorized to make transac-
tions in your Account. We may elect anytime, with
or without notice, to make any debit balance or
other obligation related to your Account imrnedi.
ately due and payable. We may report any
pastdue account to a consumer and/or
securities credit reporting agency. We may also
refer your Account to a collection agency.

Section 7: Security for Indebtedness. Note:
This section does not apply to any tax-qualified
accounts subject to the prohibited transaction
rules of the Internal Revenue Code or ERISA, or
any indebtedness arising therefrom.
As security for the repayment of all present or
future indebtedness owed to us by any Account
Holder under the Schwab One Account Agree-
ment or otherwise, each Account Hokier grants
to us a continuing security interest in and lien
on, and a right of setoff with respect to. all
Securities and Other Property that are, now or in
the future, held, carried or maintained for any
purpose In or through the Schwab One Account.
and, to the extent of such Account Holder's
interest in or through. any present or future
account with us in which the Account Holder has
an interest.
If you owe money to Schwab as the result of
activity in your Account and there are assets
available in any account that you hold at Schwab
which could fully or partially satisfy the debt, you
agree that upon Schwab's written demand, you
will execute all documents necessary t0 effect a
distribution from your account and agree to pay
or cause such funds to be paid immediately to
Schwab in order to satisfy your indebtedness
to Schwab.

Section 8: Liquidations. Whenever it is neces-
sary for our protection or to satisfy a margin
deficiency, debit or other obligation owed us, we
may (but are not required to) sell, assign and
deliver all or any part of the property securing
your obligations, or close any or all transactions
in your Account. We may choose which property
to buy or sell, which transactions to close and
the sequence and timing of liquidation. We may
take such actions on whatever exchange or
market and in whatever manner (including pubic
auction or private sale) that we choose in the ex-
ercise of our business Judgment. You agree not
to hold us liable for the choke of which property
to buy or sell or of which transactions to close
or for timing or manner of liquidation.
In certain circumstances we may. at our sole
discretion, liquidate your entire margin loan
balance to satisfy a margin call. You agree not
to hold us liable for taking such action.
We may transfer property from any non-retirement
brokerage account in which you have an interest
to any other brokerage accounts in which you
have an interest regardless of whether there
are other Account Holders on either account,
if we determine that your obligations are not
adequately secured or to satisfy a margin defi-
ciency or other obligation. You agree to pay on
demand any account deficiencies after liquida-
tion. whether liquidation is complete or partial.
All of the above may be done without demand
for margin or notice of purchase, sale, transfer
or cancellation to you. No demand for margin or
notice shah impose on Schwab any obligation to
make such demand or provide such notice to
you in the future. Any such notice or demand is
hereby expressly waived, and no specific
demand or notice shall invalidate this waiver.

Section 9: Interest on Debit Balances. We will
charge and compound interest on your debit
balances according to our Disclosure of Credit
Terms and Policies.

Section 10: Using the Check Feature. If you
have requested the check feature through
your Account, you authorize checks to be issued
as indicated in your Account Application. You
agree that each Account Holder Is authorized to
write checks.

Section 11: Verification. You authorize Schwab to
Inquire from any source, including a consumer
reporting agency, as to the identity (as required by
law). creditworthiness and ongoing ekgrbrity for
the Account of the Account Holders, any other
person referred to on this appacaticn, or any
person who Schwab is later notified is associated
with or has an interest in the Account at account
opening, at anytime throughout the fife of the
Account, and thereafter for debt collection or
investigative purposes.

Section 12: Required Arbitration Disclosures.
Regulatory authorities require that any
brokerage agreement containing a predispute
arbitration agreement must disclose that this
agreement contains a predispute arbitration
clause. This Agreement contains a predispute
arbitration clause. By signing an arbitration
agreement, the parties agree as follows:

• All parties to this Agreement are giving up the
right to sue each other in court, including the
right to a trial by jury, except as provided by
the rules of the arbitration forum in which a
claim is filed.

• Arbitration awards are generally final and
binding: a party's ability to have a court
reverse or modify an arbitration award IS
very limited.

• The ability of the parties to obtain docu-
ments, witness statements and other
discovery Is generally more limited in
arbitration than in court proceedings.

• The arbitrators do not have to explain the
reason(s) for their award unless, in an eligible
case, a joint request for an explained decision
has been submitted by all parties to the panel
at least 20 days prior to the first scheduled
hearing date.

• The panel of arbitrators will typically Include
a minority of arbitrators who were or are
affiliated with the securities industry.

• The rules of some arbitration forums may
impose time limits for bringing a claim in
arbitration. In some cases, a claim that is
ineligible for arbitration may be brought
in court.
• The rules of the arbitration forum in which the
claim is filed, and any amendments thereto,
shall be incorporated into this Agreement.
No person shall bring a putative or certified
class action to arbitration, nor seek to enforce
any predispute arbitration agreement against
any person who has initiated in court a putative
class action; or who is a member of a putative
class who has not opted out of the class with
respect to any claims encompassed by the
putative class action until:

1. the class certification Is denied;
2. the class is decertified; or
3. the customer is excluded from the class
by the court.
ST
02018 Charles SClitiab & Co., inc. At rights reserved. Member SIPC. CC2344861 (1118.8ANE) APP63584-12 (12/18)
Schwab Onee Account Application for Incorporated Organizations I Page 3 of 3
Such forbearance to enforce an agreement to
arbitrate shall not constitute a waiver of any
rights under this Agreement except to the
extent stated herein.

Section 13: Arbitration Agreement. Any
controversy or claim arising out of or relating
to (I) this Agreement, any other agreement
with Schwab, an Instruction or authorization
provided to Schwab or the breach of any such
agreements, instructions, or authorizations;
(ii) the Account, any other Schwab account or
Services; (Ili) transactions In the Account or
any other Schwab account (iv) or In any way
arising from the relationship with Schwab, its
parent, subsidiaries, affiliates, officers,
directors, employees, agents or service
providers ("Related Third Parties"), including
any controversy over the arbitrabllity of a
dispute, will be settled by arbitration.
This arbitration agreement will be binding upon
and inure to the benefit of the parties hereto
and their respective representatives, attorneys -
in-fact, heirs, successors, assigns and any other
persons having or claiming to have a legal or
beneficial interest In the Account, including
court-appointed trustees and receivers. This
arbitration agreement will also Inure to the
benefit of third-party service providers that
assist Schwab in providing Services ("Third -
Party Service Providers") and such Third-Party
Service Providers are deemed to be third -party
beneficiaries of this arbitration agreement.
The parties agree that this arbitration agree-
ment will apply even if the application to open
the Account is denied and will survive the
closure of your Account and/or the termination
of services rendered under this Agreement.
Such arbitration will be conducted by, and
according to tho securities arbitration rules
and regulations then in effect of, the Financial
Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) or any
national securities exchange that provides a
forum for the arbitration of disputes, provided
that Schwab is a member of such national
'angles exchange at the time the arbitration
,wrs initiated. Any party may initiate arbitration by
filing a written claim with FINRA or such eligible
national securities exchange. If arbitration
before FINRA or an eligible national securities
exchange is unavailable or impossible for any
reason, than such arbitration will be conducted
by, and according to the rules and regulations
then in effect of, the American Arbitration
Association (AAA). If arbitration before the AAA
is unavailable or impossible for any reason, the
parties agree to have a court of competent
jurisdiction appoint three (3) arbitrators to
resolve any and all disputes or controversies
between or among the parties. Each party shall
bear its own Initial arbitration costs, which ore
determined by the rules and regulations of the
arbitration forum. In the event of financial
hardship, the arbitration forum may waive
certain costs in accordance with such rules. At
the conclusion of the hearing, the arbitrators will
decide how to assess the costs of the arbitra-
tion among the parties.
Any award the arbitrator makes shall bo final and
binding, and judgment on it may be entered in
any court having jurisdiction. This arbitration
agreement shall be enforced and interpreted
exclusively in accordance with applicable federal
taws of the United States, including the Federal
Arbitration Act. Any costs, fees or taxes involved
in enforcing the award shall be fully assessed
against and paid by the party resisting enforce-
ment of said award.
For FINRA arbitrations, FINRA will appoint a
single public arbitrator in customer cases
decided by one arbitrator. In customer cases
decided by three arbitrators, investors have the
option of choosing an arbitration panel with two
public arbitrators and one non-public arbitrator
(Majority -Public Panel Rule) or a panel of all
public arbitrators (Optional All•Public Panel
Rule). If the customer declines to elect a panel
selection method in writing by the applicable
deadline, the Majority -Public Panel Rule for
selecting arbitrators will apply.
All notices from one party to the other
involving arbitration shall be considered to
have been fully given when so served, mailed
by first-class, certified or registered mail, or
otherwise given by other commercially
accepted medium of written notification.
In addition to the above provisions, if a party
to this Agreement is or becomes a non4J.S.
resident at the time of any controversy subject
to this arbitration agreement, such party
acknowledges and agrees to the following
additional provisions:

(1) The rules of the organization administering
the arbitration specifically provide for the
formal designation of the place at which the
arbitration is to be held.

(2) Entering into this Agreement constitutes
consent to submit to the personal jurisdic-
tion of the courts of the state of California,
U.S.A., to interpret or enforce any or all of
these arbitration provisions. Judgment on
any arbitration award may be entered in any
court having jurisdiction, or application may
be made to such court for judicial accep-
tance of the award and an order of enforce-
ment, as the case may be.

(3) The exclusive language to be used by the
parties and the arbitrators in the arbitration
proceedings shall be English. Any party
wishing an interpreter shall make all
arrangements directly with the interpreter
and shall assume all costs of the service.
(4) If a party is a foreign government or state,
state-owned or state -operated enterprise or
other instrumentality of a foreign govern-
ment or state, such party waives all rights
of sovereign immunity and neither the
Federal Act of State doctrine nor the
doctrine of sovereign immunity shall apply
insofar as any enforcement in courts located
in the U.S.A. is concerned.

Section 14: Electronic Copies. The electronically
stored copy of your (or your agent's) signature.
any written Instructions or authorizations, the
Account Application and the Agreement and
Disclosures are considered to be the true,
complete, valid, authentic and enforceable
record, admissible in judicial, administrative or
arbitration proceedings to the same extent as if
the documents and records were originally
generated and maintained in printed form.
You agree to not contest the admissibility or •
enforceability of Schwab's electronically stored
copy of such documents in any proceeding
between you and Schwab.

Section 15: Unclaimed Property. If no 'activity
occurs in the Account within the time period
specified by applicable state law, the Account
may be transferred to the appropriate state.

Section 16: Information About SIPC. To obtain
information about the Securities Investor
Protection Corporation (SIPC). including an
explanatory SIPC brochure, please contact SIPC
at www.sipc.org or 1-202-371-8300.

Section 17: Impartial Lottery for Securities
Subject to Partial Call or Partial Redemption.
If Schwab holds securities for you in street name.
in Schwab's name. or In bearer form that are
subject to partial call or partial redemption, then
in the case of a partial call or partial redemption
Schwab will use an impartial lottery system to
select the Securities to be called or redeemed
from among accounts holding those securities.
For a descrl allir
please visit If
you would like a printed description of Schwab's
lottery system mailed to you, please contact 8
Schwab representative at 1-800-435-4000.
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. MI rlgbts reserved. Member SIPC. CC2344861 (1118'BANE) APP63584.12 (12/18)
charles SCHWAB Cash Features Program
General Terms and Conditions Page 1 of 2
The automatic investment of your free credit balance, including the frequency and the amount of each sweep,
is governed by the terms and conditions set forth In the Cash Features Disclosure Statement and in the Account
Agreement applicable to your account. The material in this document is intended for informational purposes only.
If there is any conflict between the descriptions in this document and the terms of the Cash Features Disclosure
Statement, the Cash Features Disclosure Statement will control.
How the Cash
Features Program
Works
Schwab's Cash Features Program is the service (described in the Cash Features Disclosure
Statement) that we provide to automatically invest, or "sweep," the free credit balance in your
account into a liquid investment to earn interest. The program permits you to earn income
white you decide how those funds should be invested longer term.
Available Cash
Feature
The available cash features currently consist of:

• The free credit balance in your eligible account (the "Schwab One Interest feature"), on
which Schwab pays interest;

• Interest-bearing deposit accounts at one or more of our affiliated banks (the "Bank Sweep
feature" for most accounts and the "Bank Sweep for Benefit Plans feature" for retirement
plan accounts); and

• For some accounts, one or more affiliated money market mutual funds (the "Money Fund
Sweep feature").
Eligibility Eligibility for each cash feature is based on the registered ownership and the type of account.
Not all account registrations and account types will be eligible for all cash features. Some
account registrations and account types will be eligible for only one cash feature. Please see
your Account Application and the Cash Features Disclosure Statement for more complete
eligibility details.
Duty to Monitor
Eligibility for Cash
Features
It is your responsibility to monitor your eligibility for the cash features and determine the best
cash feature available to you. Schwab is not responsible for contacting you if you are, or later
become, eligible for other higher-yielding cash features.
Interest Rates and
Yields
The interest rates and yields for the different cash features vary over time. There is no
guarantee that the interest rate and yield on any particular cash feature will be or will remain
higher than the interest rate and yield on any other cash features over any period. Current
interest rates and yields can be obtained by contacting your independent investment advisor
or your Financial Consultant, or by callin us at 1- -4 5-4000. If you already have an
account, you can visit our website at If r ccount is an Advisor
Services account, please contact your advisor, visit , or call
Schwab Alliance at 1-800-515-2157.

• The interest rate on the Schwab One Interest feature is set by Schwab. We may seek to pay
as low a rate as possible consistent with our views of competitive necessities. With certain
exceptions, the rate will be tiered based upon the overall free credit balance within your
account.

• The interest rate on the Bank Sweep feature is set by our affiliated bank(s), which may
seek to pay as low a rate as possible consistent with their views of competitive necessities.
Retirement accounts will be paid a reasonable rate consistent with applicable legal and
regulatory requirements. With certain exceptions, the rate will be tiered based upon your
account type and the combined amount of your account's Bank Sweep deposits at our
affiliated bank(s).
Brokerage Products: Not FDIC-Insured • No Bank Guarantee • May Lose Value
ST
02017 Owles Schwab.; Co. Inc. Al rights resemd. member SIPC. SC1297321101184104 MS91285-01 WITT)
Cash Features Program General Terms and Conditions I Page 2 of 2
Interest Rates and
Yields
(Continued)

• The interest rate on the Bank Sweep for Benefit Plans feature is set by our affiliated bank(s),
which intend to pay interest consistent with reasonable rate provisions of applicable legal
and regulatory requirements. This may be lower than some competitors' rates. Interest rates
do not vary by tiers and do not vary based on your cash balances.

• Money market mutual funds offered through the Money Fund Sweep feature seek to achieve
the highest yield (less fees and expenses) consistent with prudence and their investment
objectives.
Cash features are not intended to be long-term investments, and yields on any of our cash
features may be lower than those of similar investments or deposit accounts offered outside
the Cash Features Program. If you desire to maintain cash balances for other than a short-term
period and/or are seeking the highest ields l v i ble in the market, please contact
your Schwab representative or visit for investment options that may
be available outside of the Cash Features Program to help maximize your return potential
consistent with your investment objectives and risk an Advisor
Services account, please contact your advisor, visit , or call
Schwab Alliance at 1-800-515-2157.
Benefits to Schwab We may charge fees and receive certain benefits under the different cash features. A portion
of these fees and benefits may be shared with your investment professional. Because of these
fees and benefits, we have a financial incentive to select the particular cash features included
in the Cash Features Program.
Differing Risks and
Account Protection
The different cash features are subject to different risks and account protection:

• The Schwab One° Interest feature is not subject to market risk and value loss but is subject
to the risk of Schwab's failure. In the unlikely event that Schwab fails, cash is eligible for
SIPC coverage up to a limit of $250,000 (including principal and interest) per client in each
insurable capacity (e.g., individual or joint). Free credit balances held at Schwab are not
insured or guaranteed by the FDIC.

• The Bank Sweep and Bank Sweep for Benefit Plans features are not subject to market risk
and value loss but are subject to the risk of the failure of one or more of our affiliated banks.
In the unlikely event that one or more of our affiliated banks fails, deposits at each bank
are eligible for FDIC insurance protection up to a limit of $250,000 (including principal and
interest) per depositor in each insurable capacity (e.g., individual, joint, and plan participant).
This limit includes any other deposits you may have at that bank outside of the Bank Sweep
and Bank Sweep for Benefit Plans features. You are responsible for monitoring your bank
balances in the Bank Sweep and Bank Sweep for Benefit Plans features and the balances
in any of your other bank accounts at each affiliated bank to determine if these, in total,
exceed FDIC insurance limits. Monies held in both features are not covered by SIPC.
• Money market mutual funds in the Money Fund Sweep feature invest in high-quality, short-
term securities and seek to maintain a stable value, but are subject to market risks and
potential value loss. They are not bank accounts and are not subject to FDIC insurance
protection. They are instead covered by SIPC, which protects against the custodial risk (and
not a decline in market value) when a brokerage firm fails by replacing missing securities
and cash up to a limit of $500,000, of which $250,000 may be cash. Shares held through the
Money Fund Sweep feature are not considered cash, but are treated as securities for SIPC
coverage.
Brokerage Products: Not FDIC-Insured • No Bank Guarantee • May Lose Value
Sr
02017 Charles Schwab& Ca.Inc. Al right' resew!. Member SPC. CC1292321 10118-7768) REG9122601107/17)
charles SCHWAB Important Information About Your Informed
Consent to Receive Paperless Documents
The Purpose and Effect of Your Consent
This disclosure and informed consent applies to all communications for
ices offered in person or available via
, or via a Schwab mobile website or
mobile application used to access those accounts, products or services,
to the extent they are not otherwise governed by the terms of a separate
disclosure and informed consent.
We are required to provide to you "in writing" certain records and
disclosures about our relationship and transactions in your account. You
are entitled to receive those documents on paper. With your affirmative
consent, we can provide the documents to you electronically instead via
the Schwab Paperless Documents program ("Paperless Documents").
The information below will help you understand the conditions and
requirements relating to Paperless Documents. You can
most up-to-date version of this important information a
papertess_consent
Papedess Documents categories include: tax forms, trade confirmations,
shareholder materials, statements and account documents (e.g., account
statements and other account-related documents associated with
the account, including account agreement amendments and program
disclosures, fund prospectuses, and investment advisory service
disclosures). Each of these document categories is described in detail
below. If you are opening an account, the account agreements and account
and program disclosures delivered to you as part of the account opening
process are also included in Paperless Documents. Electronic documents
specific to your transactions and account will be available online for up to
1O years from the date of initial delivery. Your consent to receive documents
electronically is not limited in duration and does not expire.
Depending on where you reside, the initial scope of your Paperless
Documents enrollment, and whether you have made modifications to
your enrollment, not all document categories may apply to you. Certain
documents that are not currently included in Paperless Documents may
continue to be delivered to you via postal mail. In the future, some or all
of these documents may be added to Paperless Documents and made
available to you electronically in accordance with your informed consent
to this disclosure. If you are uncertain which documents are covered by
your Papertess Documents enrollment, please check online at schwab.
Corn/papertess_services or call or email Schwab or Schwab Bank using the
contact information below.
For additional information about Schwab Bank account statements, see
the "Addendum• on the following page.
You indicate your consent to Paperless Documents by providing an email
address and signing an account agreement, or by clicking or touching
an "I consent" or other button indicating assent to or acceptance of the
conditions and requirements relating to Paperless Documents, and we
record your consent. The method of consent may depend on whether you
are opening an account or separately enrolling in Paperless Documents
for an existing account. If you do not provide consent. Schwab or Schwab
Bank will send you paper copies. Your consent will be effective until you
cancel your enrollment in Papertess Documents or Schwab or Schwab
Bank notifies you that the program is discontinued. If you are a joint
account holder, your consent binds the other account holder.
By providing consent, you confirm that you have the ability to access
Schwab on the web, and the ability to open, view, save, retain, and print
PDF documents as described below. These abilities demonstrate that you
can receive the documents we will deliver to you. You also confirm that
you have provided a valid email address as part of the account opening or
PaperieSS Documents enrollment process.
We may, if necessary and at our discretion, end your participation in
Paperless Documents, or change the terms and conditions relating
to Paperless Documents and electronic communications. It is your
responsibility to review any updates in a timely manner. We will provide you
with notice of any discontinuation or update as required by law.
Page 1 of 2
Our Contact Information to Request Paper or Ask Questions
To access the document and print a copy, log in to your Schwab or Schwab
Bank account, select the "Accounts" tab, then select "Statements." To
request paper, ask questions about, or report problems concerning
Paperless Documents, you may contact us as follows:
To contact us by email, log in toe, click "Contact Us," and then
••
" Message." Advisor Services clients, please log in to
To contact us by phone:

• Investor Services clients: 1-800-435-4000.
• Schwab Bank High Yield Investor Checking' (or other Schwab Bank)
clients: 1-888-603-9000.

• Clients in the U.K.:OO 800 0826-5001.
• Clients in other countries: *1-415-667-84OO.
Advisor Services clients: Contact your independent advisor or call
1-8OO-515-2157.
• Schwab Intelligent Portfolios• clients: 1-855-694-52O8.
• Institutional Intelligent Portfolios® clients: 1-877-805-3399.
To Withdraw Your Consent
When you change your preference back to postal mail delivery, this cancels
your enrollment in Paperless Documents and withdraws your consent
for tha ru,,, ,n'ant rsti.nnns. .i indicate. You can do this by logging in
to , Or by calling or emailing Schwab
or Schwab Bank using the contact information above. Allow 48 hours
for processing. Your consent will remain effective for other document
categories for which you maintain a paperless delivery preference.
Important note forSchwab Advisor Services clients: Canceling or
modifying your enrollment may make your account(s) ineligible for lower
commission rates, and the commissions you pay may increase.
Important note for Schwab Intelligent Portfolios and Institutional Intelligent
Portfolios clients: Intelligent Portfolios is an all-electronic service. If in the
future you request paper documents, withdraw your consent or are unable
to receive Paperless Documents, Schwab may terminate your account.
Electronic Notification When a Paperless Document Is Ready
We send you an email to let you know a document is available. For some
documents, the email itself will be the paperless document. For other
documents, the email wil contain a link that will allow you to access or
download the document, and your login may be required prior to such
access.
Keeping Your Email Address Current and Actions Schwab or
Schwab Bank Wilt Take If There Is a Problem
Please note that after three consecutive months of unsuccessful electronic
delivery attempts of your tax forms, trade confirmations, or statements and
account documents, your accounts) will revert backto postal mail delivery.
This will cancel your enrollment in Paperless Documents and withdraw
your consent to receive Papertess Documents.
It is your responsibility to notify Schwab or Schwab Bank of any change in
your email address by logging in to the Schwab site and going to Service >
My Profile > Email Addresses or using the contact information above. In
addition to the unenrollment process outlined above, if we receive any
indication either that the email notification did not reach you successfully
or that there is a problem with your email address or service, we will take
the following actions:

• Tax Forms—Send a letter by postal mail within two business days to
inform you that we were unable to deliver your tax form electronically.
In certain circumstances, as may be required by law or regulation or
for other reasons, we may send you the tax form itself by postal mail
within the time period prescribed by the relevant legal or regulatory
requirements.

• Trade Confirmation—Send a paper copy of trade confirmation by postal
mail within 24 hours. Also send a letter by postal mail to inform you that
we were unable to detiveryour Trade Confirmation to you electronically.
Sr
O2018 Chadic Schwab 8 Co. Inc. All rights reserved. M SIPC. CCi597816 (0188-M1N REG86030.00 (ome)
Informed Consent to Receive Paperless Documents I Page 2 of 2
Statements and Account Documents—Send a letter by postal mail
informing you that we were unable to deliver your statement or account
document electronically.
Shareholder Materials—Send a paper copy of the shareholder materials
via postal mail within 24 hours. We will send you a letter informing you
that we were unable to deliver your shareholder materials electronically.
The account will be unenrolled from Paperless Documents, and we will
begin to send you paper shareholder materials.
Hardware and Software Requirements
Paned/ass Documents requires you to have access to a device (computer
or smartphone) with Internet service and an active email account and
address, along with the following.

• A current version of a common Internet browser, with JavaScript
enabled.
• A current version of a program, such as Adobe° Reader? that accurately
reads and displays PDF documents. If you do not have Adobe Acrobat
' n your device, you can download the free software at

• An operating system on your device that supports the above.
• A printer that connects to your device, if you wish to print documents.
• Electronic storage connected to your device, if you wish to retain records
in electronic form. (If you are using your computer, just save documents
to your local hard drive.)
If you use your smartphone, you must access the full Schwab website to
view and print your documents. If you have questions relating to hardware
and software requirements, please call or email Schwab using the contact
information on the previous page.
Security and Privacy Information
Unless expressly stated, email notifications for Papertess Documents are
not encrypted. For security and confidentiality, unencrypted emails will not
include your name, full account number, or any other personal identifier.
Be aware, however, that some email addresses may use part of your name
or your entire name. If you use a work email address, your employer or
other employees may have access to your email. To help you identify your
account, we may include some portion, but not all, of your account number.
Schwab or Schwab Bank may use a vendor to deliver Papertess Documents.
Whether Schwab, Schwab Bank, or a vendor delivers the documents,
Schwab's privacy policy applies.
Records and Disclosures Included In Schwab and Schwab Bank's
Paperless Documents Program
Tax Forms relax Documents")
A tax document provides important information you need to complete
your tax returns. Much of the information we provide in tax documents
is also reported to the IRS. This includes any corrected tax documents
and accompanying notices. When a tax document is ready, we will send
an email notification with the subject line "IMPORTANT TAX RETURN
DOCUMENTAVAILABLE" and containing a web link to the document
available after you log in.
Trade Confirmations reconfirms")
A trade confirmation is an official record of your securities transaction.
It includes the price, number of shares, and the commission we charge
you, as well as disclosures required under federal law. If you choose to
receive paperless trade confirmations, the terms and conditions of your
transaction will appear in the email and on a web page you can link to
from the email. Your consent to receive paperless trade confirmations
also includes paperless delivery of prospectuses or other regulatory
information we provide to you at the time of your trade. Your consent to
receive paperless trade confirmations also covers paperless delivery of
Trade Confirmation Reports (TCRs) if you elect this alternative as part of
your Managed Account enrollment.
Statements and Account Documents ("eStatements")
An account statement provides important information about your account,
including the price and quantity of securities you hold, the transactions
conducted, other activity in your account, and terms and conditions
governing your account. Account statements are sent at the end of each
month in which you conducted activity in your account or at the end of
each calendar quarter, regardless of any account activity. With your
account statements, we often include accompanying account-related
notices and other regulatory information, including, but not limited to,
Schwab's Statement of Financial Condition, pricing changes, changes to
payment features, privacy policy, annual notices, amendments to your
account agreements, and any other documents, notices, and disclosures
required by law or regulatory rules W be provided to you. At account
opening and from time to time thereafter, we also send you notifications
about your account. Collectively, we call these documents, notices, and
disclosures "account documents." When you consent to papedess account
statements, you also consent to papertess account documents.
Investment Advisory Service Disclosures
(A Sub-Category of Account Documents)
Your consent to paperless Statements and Account Documents includes
investment advisory program disclosures, brochure supplements with
information about individual Schwab representatives, and related
materials such as periodic updates or annual summaries of any changes
to those documents ("Form ADV Disclosures") as Schwab makes these
available in the future. The investment advisory programs may include
Schwab Private Client; Schwab Managed Portfolios' Schwab Managed
Account Services', the Schwab Advisor Networks Schwab Intelligent
Portfolios': and other similar advisory services, and fee-based Financial
Planning Services. In addition to Schwab's and its affiliates' own Form ADV
Disclosures, your consent also covers ADV Disclosures from third-party
investment advisors whose services you select through Schwab. Paperless
Form ADV Disclosures may accompany your account statements or be sent
independently. If the third party does not make its Form ADV Disclosures
available electronically, you will instead receive the standard printed
materials by postal mail.
Shareholder Materials ("Electronic Delivery)
Shareholder materials include regulatory information such as
prospectuses; prospectus supplements; quarterly, semi-annual, and
annual reports; and proxy materials. You will receive an email notification
with a web link to shareholder materials if you have a position in an
equity or mutual fund as of the record date for a particular shareholder
distribution and the materials are made available electronically by the
issuer or third party. If the issuer or third party does not make shareholder
materials available electronically, you will instead receive the standard
printed materials by postal mail. By providing your consent to receive
electronic delivery of shareholder material, you also consent to electronic
householding. This means that if you and someone else enroll in this
paperless service using the same email address, we may send one email
announcement to this email address if each account holds securities of the
same issuer. This avoids duplicate mailings of shareholder documents. If
you no longer want electronic householding of your shareholder materials,
you must modify your Paperless Documents enrollment as described
above. Your shareholder materials ma include electronic proxies. You may
elect to vote your proxy online at by entering the control
number included in your email an d the last four digits of
your Social Security number or Taxpayer Identification Number as your PIN.
Addendum for Schwab Bank Papertess Statements
("eStatements")
Schwab Bank Paperless Documents categories include statements and
account documents and tax forms. The above information regarding
the purpose and effect of your consent, including how to request paper
delivery, how to ask questions, how to withdraw consent for papertess
delivery, electronic notification of ready statements, keeping a current
email address, hardware and software requirements, and security
and privacy information, are all applicable to Schwab Bank accounts.
Paperless Documents include account statements and tax forms. In
addition, account statements for your Investor Checking account(s),
Investor Savings account(s), and Pledged Asset Line' account(s) provide
important information about your accounts, including the account balance;
the transactions conducted; other activity in your accounts; and other
information, terms. and conditions governing your accounts.
Brokerage Products: Hot FDIC-Insured • No Bank Guarantee • May Lose Value
Chides Scenvab Link and Chats Schwab & Co., Inc us mutate but aniatod tampion anti subsitUries of The Cartes Schwab 
Corporation. Brokerage prcoxlsolleced by
tholes Schen', g Co.lnc
are not inured by the FDIC, are not &Mils et obligations ce Chain Schwab Bark, and a e Saject to investment rig. axtudin
the cossble loss ce oienpal if-Nested.
Depost and or lenling ceoducts
rd services are oil wed by Drain Schwab tank, liembe FDIC Ed an FpatHasing Lender. Charles Schwab Bank es not actin or 
registered as a secunties broker. dealer
or ',vestment adesce.
SF
02018 Charles Sclverab & Co.. Inc. All rigta reserved. Member SIPC. CC1597876 (0188-7A1V) REG8E030-03 (01/18)
',Anted on reepled paper.
ST
02018 Charles Schwab & Co.. Inc. All rights reserved. Member SIPC. CC2344861 (1118 BANE) APP63584 12 (12/18)
00219912
EFTA01616933 (Jmail)
 [girls] Skype log "no one can beat your pussy network", see quote: "now im finding pussy for you"
(date: 2019-04-08)
Platform: Sk e: jeevacation Name Timezone: UTC+0000
0  jeevacation
2019/04/08
2019/04/09
jeevacation
call her now
11:26:39 pm
Sir, I'm trying to reach her since Saturday. She doesn't answer me now, Ill call her again when it
will be morning in MSC and I leave work. 11.
12:34:44 am
how are you?
09:48:38 pm
2019/04/10
2019/04/11
jeevacation
Forget
12:49:51 am
jeevacation
have you spoken to
hawaii
10:04:39 am
she has not really had contact , she went to calif then going to
Yes, Im in touch with her, talked to her today after she landed in California, but before the
custom. Just texted her right now. Waiting.
10:07:35 am
jeevacation
did you tell her i was annoyed . ? or did she get it on her own
10:09:11 am
I asked her about girls in Moscow and Tokyo for me, also does she have any good girls in LA,
but I didn't mention you
10:12:44 am
■
•
Just told that it would be nice of her and very helpful for me ( Tokyo/ MSC)
10:13:37 am
jeevacation
1 friend of mine is there from cveta <a href="https://instagram.com/narman_polina?
utm_source=ig_profile_share&amp;igshid=5qqllgjudt6r">https:Mnstagram.com/narman_polina?
utm_source=ig_profile_share&amp;igshid=5qql1gjudt6r</a>
10:35:10 am
Oh! Thank you! Just added her, I'll tell her that I'm from right?
10:38:45 am
jeevacation
w ill connect
10:39:14 am
I also connected with promoter fromaoing to join them tomorrow
10:39:26 am
jeevacation
now im finding pussy for you . something wrong with that
10:39:30 am
Ok, I'll be in touch withMabout it.
10:41:29 am
jeevacation
•
•
now im finding pussy for you . something wrong with that
10:41:35 am
:)) no one can beat your pussy network))
Thank you! I understand.
Im focusing on it.
10:42:30 am
jeevacation
now im finding pussy for you . something wrong with that
10:47:22 am
2019/04/12
2019/04/13
2019/04/14
Will you be available to Skype on Sunday morning( NY time)?
01:18:44 am
jeevacation
Contact rich
04:32:16 pm
jeevacaflon
Contact rich
03:48:32 am
Contact rich
10:01:04 am
skype?
10:01:07 am
jeevacation
You
07:41:35 am
Ill be at home in 20 min, ak?)
09:01:47 am
My mornings are like:
D2C1573m
09:0355 am

• here
39:: kr::: am
jeevacation
Call type: Outgoing
From: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:22:43.9369999
09:19:11 am
Call hma• f1i ttanino
From. jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:22:43.9369999
09:19:11 am
Call type: Outgoing
From: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:23:48.8119999
09:49:44 am
Call type: Outgoing
From: jeevacation jeevacation (owner)
Duration: 00:23:48.8119999
09:49:44 am
So happy to see you!!!! Thank you so much for tour time!!!<ss type="hearteyes">(hearteyes)
</ss><ss type="hearteyes">(hearteyes)</ss><ss type="hearteyes">(hearteyes)</ss>
10:14:11 am
wrote to Lesley, that she need ticket either from LA to NYC, or from Hawaii to Tokyo, or
from LA to Russia. it was few days ago.
12:17:48 pm
Deleted I will ask Lesley to cancel ticket from la to Moscow in any case there are no need.
should write you now.
12:19:14 pm
I will ask Lesley to cancel ticket from MSC to LA in any case there are no need. Monster should
write you now.
12:33:43 pm
Sir, as Lesley  is &quot; out of office&quot; should I write to
href="mailto:
ticket?
12:58:14 pm
done
01:12:50 pm
at <a
</a> to cancel
jeevacation
write to lesley
01:12:38 pm
jeevacation
write to lesley
01:13:11 pm
write to lesley
01:13:16 pm
0
0
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Christian Everdell [epstein] Ghislaine Maxwell's lawyer ca. 2021, Cohen & Gresser 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00016124 (Jmail)
 [government] letter from SDNY to Bobbi C. Sternheim, Christian Everdell, Laura A. Menninger re: unsearched Epstein computer backups that are no 
inaccessible, see quote: "the Government cannot permit you to review the contents of the Discs"
(date: 2019-04-09)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Silvio J. Mollo Building
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York, New York 10007
April 9, 2021
BY ELECTRONIC MAIL
Christian Everdell, Esq.
Mark Cohen, Esq.
Cohen & Gresser LLP
800 Third Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Laura Menninger, Esq.
Jeffrey Pagliuca, Esq.
Haddon, Morgan and Foreman, P.C.
150 East Tenth Avenue
Denver, CO 80203
Bobbi Stemheim, Esq.
Law Offices of Bobbi C. Stemheim
33 West 19th Street-4th Fl.
New York, NY 10007
Re: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (MN)
Dear Counsel:
The Government writes regarding your request to review sixteen (16) discs in the
possession of the Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI") as part of the file previously maintained
by the FBI's Palm Beach Resident Agency (the "FBI Florida Office") during its investigation of
Jeffrey Epstein under evidence number 1B8, Subitem 8 (the "Discs"). As noted in the evidence
log previously provided to you, the Discs are described in the FBI's evidence system as follows:

(16) DVD-R discs with printed labels reading, "Palm Beach County
Sheriffs Office Case # 05-250067 Epstein Encase Files Palm Beach
PD DVD-R for General VERBATIM DVD Computer Crimes
Unit." Each disc is also respectively labeled, "Disk 1 of 16," "Disk
2 of 16," etc.
When the FBI's New York Office first received the FBI Florida Office's file regarding its
investigation of Jeffrey Epstein, the agents working on this case attempted to review all electronic
media contained in that file, including the Discs. During that review, the case agents were unable
to open any files contained on the Discs and believed that the files were inoperable.
Page 2
In preparing for defense counsel in this case to review all physical evidence in the FBI
Florida Office's file, the Government tried to access the content of these Discs and was similarly
unable to open those files. However, the Government recognized that the file extensions and sizes
of those files appeared to be consistent with those of a forensic image of an electronic device.
With the help of an FBI computer specialist, the Government has learned that the Discs appear to
contain a forensic image of a computer seized from Jeffrey Epstein's residence in Palm Beach,
Florida by the Palm Beach Police Department during the execution of a search warrant in or about
2005 (the "Epstein Computer").
The Government has reviewed the 2005 search warrant obtained by the Palm Beach Police
Department, which was previously produced to you in a discovery production dated October 20,

2020. While that warrant appears to have authorized the seizure of electronic devices, it does not
appear to have authorized a search of the content of such devices. Moreover, the Government is
not aware of any further warrant obtained by local or federal authorities as part of the prior Florida
Investigation that would authorize a review of the contents of the Epstein Computer. Nor has this
Office obtained a warrant for the Epstein Computer. Accordingly, the Government does not
believe it has a lawful basis to review the forensic image of the Epstein Computer contained on
the Discs. Moreover, and given, among other things, the passage of time since the Epstein
Computer was seized in 2005, the Government does not intend to obtain a warrant to search the
Epstein Computer or otherwise review or make use of its contents. As such, because the
Government lacks authority to review their contents, the Discs are not discoverable in this case,
and the Government cannot permit you to review the contents of the Discs.'
Very truly yours,
AUDREY STRAUSS
United States Attorney
Assistant United States Attorneys
In this respect, the Government is also mindful of the fact that Epstein's estate has repeatedly
informed the Government that it is unwilling to waive any attorney-client privileges in connection
devices seized from Epstein during this investigation. As a result, even assuming the Government
had the authority to review the contents of the Discs, the Government would have to first conduct
a privilege review before producing any non-privileged material to you. However, because the
Government has no lawful authority to search the contents, it cannot conduct such a review.
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Women Empowerment aka WE Talks [russia] organization started by Epstein's assistant Svetlana Pozhidaeva [dailybeast] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02445716 (Jmail)
 [girls] Svetlana Pozhidaeva Women Empowerment (WE) conference pilot event
(date: 2019-04-12)
WE TALKS PILOT
Date: April 12th
Time: 6pm - 8pm
Venue: Maiyet Store Soho (16 Crosby St, New York, NY 10013)
Curator/Host: Lana Pozhidaeva
Moderator: TBD
Speakers:

Dr. Raj / @ Tula (Skincare Company) CONFIRMED
Nadia Masri, Founder & CEO @ Perksy (Marketing) CONFIRMED
Rebecca Huy @ Roots Studio (Arts) TBC
Kathleen Griffith @ Grayce @ Co (Marketing agency for women) TBC
Brand Partners: TBD
Topic: Women Founders, Fundraising challenges
Guest Count: 40 max, preferably 30
Format: 20 mins mixer + panel for 30 mins + 15 mins Q&A + 20 min
post mixer
EFTA01615808 (Jmail)
 [politics] iMessage to Steve Bannon screenshot(s)
(inferred date: 2019-04-30)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• SB
Steve Bannon
2019/04/30
Steve Bannon
Similar as in 'nobody knows nothing'
SB 11:35:13 am
case weak not well done can keep them for years
11:36:02 am
Steve Bannon
Oh on that yes
SB 11:36:22 am
on another note if you like you can go to yemen and meet with heads . you have an
invitation.
11:37:44 am
Steve Bannon
Would love it
SB 11:38:06 am
have fun
11:38:12 am
you should if you decide of course coordinate with pompeo
11:38:28 am
•
•
but you will have access unlike others
11:38:51 am
Steve Bannon
Of course -- I'm sure it will be a resounding NO
SB 11:38:53 am
I'm only F and B
11:39:19 am
Steve Bannon
KSA wants everybody to stay away-- closer inspection only leads to more doubts / head
scratching
11:39:46 am
Have you followed nick bostrom?
11:59:14 am
Oxford prof-- bill gates guy
SB 11:59:25 am
chicken little
12:00:45 pm
Steve Bannon
I'm watching our second hour now-- guys were blown away and I didn't think it was as
strong at the time but I was wrong
12:01:47 pin
Need huge part on threat of Al versus reality / threat of climate change
SB 12:02:22 pm
•
•
•
i was a little all over the place
12:02:27 pm
go back to the industrial revolution same argument.
12:02:47 pm
the computer doesn't have soul so no worry
12:03:14 pm
Steve Bannon
I thought so but most of my team just saw it on film , were not there and loved it ,
wanted more
SB 12:03:27 pm
the christians i met with feel , the media portraying me as beyond redemption is
deeply troubling and offensive
12:03:46 pin
Steve Bannon
Yes yes yes of course -- but we must counter 'rapist who traffics in female children to
be raped by worlds most powerful , richest men'--- that can't be redeemed -- that why
we let them blow up the argument while showing the 12 you redeemed
12:06:05 pm
Can't redeem unredeemable -- you are a lot of things-which we will show-- but you are
NOT that
12:07:06 pm
Did u get the film we shot ??
SB 07:42:43 pm
•
•
Steve Bannon
Money
08:37:56 pm
Just landed
08:35:18 pm
Unfortunately probably not going to be allowed to be in the film
SB 08:48:08 pm
Ill show you the private photos
09:06:07 pm
Steve Bannon
Bad
SB 09:06:54 pm
0
•
I watched the interview. Well done again , thx. . here is what I think will work
legally,
09:07:40 pm
I pay direct costs of filming.
09:08:13 pm
As Darren is the contractor for legal service prep . It gets paid by Darren. He has final
control as it is his work product. I have no interest whatsoever in making money
here. Zero . You deserve whatever it brings . As it is our cost , no return on it. .
09:10:23 pin
Steve Bannon
Are you far enough along on your assignment -- could we film this weekend ??
09:11:39 pm
K
SB 09:12:10 pm
lye listed out the scientists. Sending to darren. But there are no scientists on the
island. ?
09:13:29 pm
Lets talk later. , tonight.
09:13:40 pm
V Sent
Steve Bannon
The team actually thought second was even more compelling than first and the LOVED
the first
09:17:25 pin
Standby
09:17:49 pm
Don't need scientist now need you walking thru the entire vertical -- get them in weeks
/ months to come
SB 09:38:10 pm
v Read
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                     Lorenzo de Medici [crypto] Medici Bank, possibly Medici heir? 
 Medici Bank [crypto] crypto friendly bank set up by Lorenzo de Medici with investment from Maria Prusakova and maybe Brock Pierce 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01612733 (Jmail)
 [girls] WhatsApp log of conversation with Maria Prusakova (???) saying being Epstein's lawyer would be preferable to recruiting, discusses Medici 
Bank, see quote: "way better than supplying you ladies"
(date: 2019-05-08)
Platform: WhatsApp Name: Timezone: UTC+0000

• 0  System Message
•
2019/05/08
Jeffrey I took Roaccutane for a week, french nurses and US doctors told me it has too
many side effects and will damage my liver. My US facial lady has brown spots for life
because of 12 months of Roaccutane , her hair fell over and got dry.
That's why I asked you contacts of French girls who took it to ask their feeling about it
and how much they took
Sent an attachment
02:22:28 pm
they took 20 mg for 5 months and then 10
Sent an attachment
02:24:08 pm
nonsense
Sent an attachment
02:24:17 pm
•
I take one pill a day. Skin got super sensitive. Can't have sun even when covered with
sunblock. The skin gets super broWn and weird
Sent an attachment
02:27:13 pm
what type m you need blood test. something not right
Sent an attachment
02:27:51 pm
I took blood test ! Results are ok
Sent an attachment
02:37:03 pm
02:37:27 pm
Bi sun lots of water
02:38:54 pm
2019/05/09
Ok
Sent an attachment
02:47:01 pm
2019/05/16
Login again
Sent an attachment
06:10:31 pm
To the link.
Check microphone settings
Sent an attachment
06:10:46 pm
2019/05/29
Jeffrey greetings from davos
Sent an attachment
07:08:28 pm
Nosun
02:38:58 pm
•
Did u answer Lorenzo ? Please. So he is not pissed.
I spent weekend with Brock. Brilliant young man. I want to be like him but female
version
Sent an attachment
07:09:01 pm
07:10:15 pm
Sent an attachment
Filename: 475b91b3-b0b8-473a-b53e-ee0bd8c26295.thumb
URL: https://mmg-
fna.whatsapp.net/d/f/AsbHHylEfAGQ48g1BWAc7hMU2EnycWlmwcXhX2KZn3e4.enc
Path: 475b91b3-b0b8-473a-b53e-ee0bd8c26295.thumb
Size: 2 KB
Type: video/mp4
07:10:21 pm
Sent an attachment
Filename: bf3f9ea4-0752-413c-a4eb-09568e85e1d6.thumb
URL: https://mmg-fna.whatsapp.net/d/f/Arpoh9bYxkUgFJMVcrWB_Io-J-
f1B6LfqnWK2yYD2yTG.enc
Path: bf3f9ea4-0752-413c-a4eb-09568e85e1d6.thumb
Size: 2 KB
Type: video/mp4
07:10:27 pm
•
•
07:10:52 pm
Sent an attachment
Filename: 570af821-4cbf-48a6-99e2-b8ed634ec692.thumb
URL: https://mmg-fna.whatsapp.net/d/f/Ai-
CWuOR1RQfDhitsHiNmmyHRxwxAAeCkg_TxmdVSOON.enc
Path: 570af821-4cbf-48a6-99e2-b8ed634ec692.thumb
Size: 2 KB
Type: video/mp4
07:10:52 pm
thanks a lot ! greetings from davos
Sent an attachment
12:23:45 pm
2019/05/30
ive been in contact with lorenzo all good
Sent an attachment
12:18:12 pm
2019/07/06
How are you Jeffrey ?
09:13:18 am
I had whom you met stop talking to me since 6 months. He
said, after I finally got him on the phone asking 20 times what is wrong between us,
the reason being that I advertised PA positions for you and it was « willingly and
knowingly, indirectly, putting girls in danger ».
It made me think that I was very stupid and you didn't tell me about my stupidity here.
Also I have the most horrible reputation in Zurich, UBS and other Swiss circles,
because I asked some people for connections to PAs. When returned from ZH
last summer , she was shocked how badly people speak of me given my side gig A
recruiting for a NY businessman.
Anyway...it was a price to pay for Berkeley I guess. And I don't judge or complain. Hire
me as a lawyer/paralegal at some point - way better than supplying you ladies.
Are u in NY 25-30 July? I'm coming for Nexus conference at the UN&want to see you.
We invested in Medici bank. Small amount.
Currently in Europe, Lufthansa flight attendants wanted to downgrade me to economy
from business because I was wearing training pants....they have a dress code. Weird.
How do u pass this dress code dressed up casual in business/1 class ?
09:13:19 am
Nonsense
02:09:37 pm
V Sent
2019/07/07
Jeffrey are you fine ?
12:19:17 pm
Just read news, someone shared. Are you home ? You were not taken anywhere ? What
they mean by arrest?
12:19:18 pm
Interesting... i didnt know abt NJ arrest (did it happen at all?) and just thought of you
and how you were doing.
Jeffrey, do ayhuasca and it will strengthen you intuition even more. I just came from a 5
days Aya retreat where sent me... it's better than Sex, success or anything else I
experienced before. Comparable to Olympics
Sent an attachment
12:23:17 pm
2019/07/10
Jeffrey Im worried how are you ' )
03:44:41 pm
Unread
╔══════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ed Boyle [crypto] Medici Bank 
╚═══════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01613714 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2019-05-16 23:35:50)
Platform: WhatsApp Name: Timezone: UTC+0000

• O en
•
• System Message
2018/05/10
System Message
created the group
09:11:57 pm
Messages to this group are now secured with end-to-end encryption. Tap for more
info.
09:11:57 pm
09:11:57 pm
joined
2019/05/08
O n 06:58:01 am
He taught you all about crypto didn't he ?
Sent an attachment
O 02:18:49 pm
Great
09:54:21 am
yes
Sent an attachment
02:19:03 pm
•
•
He set up a new crypto currency bank with Medici heir at its head
Convertible note 10 mln cap.
Ed Boyel CEO of the bank.
Prince Lorenzo Medici is the face of the company.
1 mln friends and family round. Possible to put 100l<
Sent an attachment
02:28:42 pm
We think to invest with 25k each. He will get us into the deal
What do you think? Would you invest?
Sent an attachment
O 02:29:12 pm
more details?
Sent an attachment
02:29:31 pm
2019/05/13
We get them tmrw at 11 am
Brock Pierce and Medici heir are behind the bank.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/bitcoinexchangeguide.com/medici-bank-which-is-5-
centuries-old-intends-to-use-blockchain-in-historical-turning-point-notion/amp/
O en
Sent an attachment
Title: Medici Bank, Which is 5 Centuries Old, Intends to Use Blockchain in Historical
Turning Point Notion
URL: https://www.google.com/amp/s/bitcoinexchangeguide.com/medici-bank-which-is-
5-centuries-old-intends-to-use-blockchain-in-historical-turning-point-notion/amp/
06:20:42 am
Great
09:14:22 am
Hi Jeffrey - how are you? Hope to see you this week while is in town :)
Sent an attachment
05:03:40 pm
They asked us to prep some questions on their materials. We're going thru them
however would love to show you some of their offerings to so perhaps we can ask
some of your questions as well?
Sent an attachment
05:04:26 pm
Please let us know
Sent an attachment
05:04:29 pm
Send
05:06:05 pm
•
•
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/d6ogg31byfzsrnq/AAAYU-H9OgHmxbrg-AcnA0u6a?dl=0
Sent an attachment
05:06:55 pm
sent email to Jeffrey
Sent an attachment
05:14:26 pm
I am dubious about investing in a bank. it is so long and card to build to have serious
revenues. unless the team is top. lets research the team and meet them all in
person
Sent an attachment
O 05:28:25 pm
2019/05/15
Hi Jeffrey
We have a meeting at 2 pm EST with Medici bank founders and team tmrw. What is the
best way to video call you then ?
Sent an attachment
O 10:10:30 pm
facetime , i need to know who will be on the call
Sent an attachment
10:13:02 pmEd Boyle, Newton Gomez, Steve Williams
Sent an attachment
O 11:35:50 pm
2019/05/16
send their resumes first
Sent an attachment
09:50:39 am

Ok. I will check on Linkedln . It should be full
Sent an attachment
02:19:32 pm
Newton Gomez : https://www.linkedin.com/in/newton-gomez-09203a57/
Sent an attachment
04:17:16 pm
Steve Williams: https://www.linkedin.com/in/misterwilliams/
Sent an attachment
04:19:45 pm
Ed Boyle: https://www.linkedin.com/in/edwardjboyle/
Sent an attachment
O 04:20:15 pm
https://casetext.com/case/us-v-gomez-37
Sent an attachment
Title: U.S. v. Gomez, 05 Cr. 698 (GBD) I Casetext
URL: https://casetext.com/case/us-v-gomez-37
04:20:52 pm
this is clef him?
Sent an attachment
04:22:17 pm
dontknow.
Sent an attachment
04:22:35 pm
not too many people with that name in new jersey
Sent an attachment
04:22:54 pm
Sent

ok. will check
•
•
Sent an attachment
04:32:44 pm
file with some questions, feel free to add to it
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Tm_lh3-Km2dIp0gyTQ-
hsnPkmWHSjeD7fn3kGeH03do/edit
4AM Ow won. NM 0mA Pamemovi Am.
Man ans penr AVM meem ••• mole 444

• • 4••• 4014
OMRO •••••••••• tA ••••••••••••MerelM•0 44
wen Alma. 04•010 04Y
4.44 AIM Opp., ••• an v7. Mu 44•••••4 ••••
04:33:18 pm
Medici Bank License from OCIF PR.pdf
Sent an attachment
Filename: d9309c05-8f54-4981-9785-9b03461289c8.pdf
URL: https://mmg-
fna.whatsapp.net/d/f/AmO7d5Rx4wCieJhfnNxNoVjNLzPHjNuUfOGRhjUFSwEV.enc
Path: d9309c05-8f54-4981-9785-9b03461289c8.pdf
Size: 480 KB
Type: application/pdf
04:43:24 pin
check the licence @12125333739 it seems they need additional permissions to
operate internationally
Sent an attachment
O 04:43:45 pm
Read
EFTA01613731 (Jmail)
 [crypto] WhatsApp log Medici Bank conversation on Whatsapp
(inferred timestamp: 2019-05-17 19:12:12)
Platform: WhatsApp Name: <REDACTED> Timezone: UTC+0000
╭───────────────────────╮  ╭───────────────────────╮
│ <REDACTED>            │  │ <REDACTED>            │
│ <REDACTED>            │  │ <REDACTED>            │
│ <REDACTED> <REDACTED> │  │ <REDACTED> <REDACTED> │
╰───────────────────────╯  ╰───────────────────────╯
╭────────────────────────────────╮  ╭────────────────╮
│ <REDACTED><REDACTED>           │  │ System Message │
│ <REDACTED><REDACTED>           │  │ <REDACTED>     │
│ <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> │  │ <REDACTED>     │
╰────────────────────────────────╯  ╰────────────────╯
2019/05/16
We're a few min late to Ed's office, call might be slightly delayed
Sent an attachment
05:53:30 pm
5 min
Sent an attachment
06:00:44 pm
we're just setting up the call
time?
Sent an attachment
06:00:35 pm
Sent an attachment
06:05:32 pm
does zoom work for you ?
Sent an attachment
06:05:37 pm
we will share the link
Sent an attachment
06:05:42 pm
ok
Sent an attachment
06:06:58 pm
https://zoom.us/j/6309 173420
ZOOM
06:08:08 pm
Jeffrey can you come to the video link ?
Sent an attachment
O en 06:08:21 pm
Alloy $5k setup plus $1500 x 4 = $11 k
Finxact $150k setup plus $8500/month x 3 months = $175k
NY team/office plus 1 Dev and 1 Compliance x S months = $300k
Si team/office plus 1 Compliance x 5 months = $150k
Comply Advantage = $25k
Reserve CD = $300k
Deal Payoff = $175k
T&E/Conferences = $30k
Wachsman PR = $100k
Rent = $20k (new office move-in)
TOTAL: $1,185,000
Sent an attachment
06:24:13 pm
ed talked aml vendor kyc vendor. dont see it.
Sent an attachment
06:33:06 pm
hang on
Sent an attachment
06:34:09 pm
kyc is alloy, aml is comly advantage
Sent an attachment
06:34:51 pm
•

• 06:34:58 pu
is medici putting in money or only his name
just the name
Sent an attachment
06:37:50 pm
medici only brought 200k of equity investments tho
Sent an attachment
06:36:08 pm
•
•
O en
•
Sent an attachment
07:12:12 pm
2019/05/17
Thank you for the call Jeffrey. I put together the summary of notes and will send you
too.
Do you want to have a call/meet Lorenzo Medici?
Sent an attachment
04:08:20 am
What do you think of Medici bank ?
Sent an attachment
04:17:02 am
Yes
08:37:49 am
Ed suggested we speak to the lead investor of Medici - Greg Gilbert of Agilic Capital, he
is a former VC/startup lawyer and investor. His cell is
Sent an attachment
01:36:41 pm
No - first medici
01:40:04 pm
•
•
ok
Sent an attachment
01:40:25 pm
we asked
Sent an attachment
01:40:28 pm
waiting
•
•
Sent an attachment
01:40:33 pm
if not, not what
Sent an attachment
01:40:56 pm
not interested at all?
Sent an attachment
01:41:04 pm
if not. - not
Sent an attachment
01:40:41 pm
correct
Sent an attachment
01:41:09 pm
ok makes sense
Sent an attachment
01:41:31 pm
XBP deck redacted
Sent an attachment
Filename: 86ab0c9b-d761-42ee-a4ee-adb3f00c1894.pdf
URL: https://mmg-fna.whatsapp.net/d/f/AiV6QoTXNjVPqdlavF0QI5S8niSe64_H-
JuhCkbkou3O.enc
Path: 86ab0c9b-d761-42ee-a4ee-adb3f00c1894.pdf
Size: 2 MB
Type: application/pdf
06:16:38 pm

2:16 PM
3 Messages
group
╭───────────────────────────────────────╮
│ Ed Boyle                    2:03 PM   │
│ introduction                Details   │
│ To: <REDACTED>                        │
│                                       │
│ <REDACTED>                            │
│ By way of cc, I introduce you to      │
│ Prince Lorenzo de' Medici, my         │
│ business partner/co-founder. I am     │
│ using both personal and work          │
│ emails as we have just setup the      │
│ work email and, since Lorenzo is      │
│ traveling, IDK if he has that working │
│ fully yet. Please make the            │
│ introduction to Jeffrey.              │
│ Also, you may recall Jeffrey and I    │
│ arguing over FX rates on cross-       │
│ border payments...where big-          │
│ money movements would be low          │
│ cost but typical small business       │
╰───────────────────────────────────────╯
06:17:09 pm

╭───────────────────────────────────────╮
│ movements (our clients' clients might │
│ normally wire $10k or $20k) are       │
│ subject to expensive retail rates.    │
│ See attached excerpted pages          │
│ (somewhat redacted for confidentiality│
│ purposes) done by Glenbrook           │
│ Partners for a couple of banks        │
│ recently (12 months ago). Perhaps     │
│ useful to Jeffrey to understand       │
│ why we consider cross-border          │
│ payments an opportunity.              │
╰───────────────────────────────────────╯

06:17:10 pm
We want to co-invest with you, Jeffrey. They want 100k minimum check.
Kingsley Advani, Alex and myself, can put 40-50K together so if you can put the rest
they will allow us to enter the round.
Sent an attachment
O 06:18:38 pm
Read

<REDACTED> (probably Epstein)
If I decide yes ill put all and give you 50perce
06:23:18 pm
V Sent
EFTA01612721 (Jmail)
 [crypto] WhatsApp log of conversation with Maria Prusakova about Crypto PR Lab
(date: 2019-05-21)
Platform: WhatsApp Name: Timezone: UTC+0000
coSystem Message
•
•
•
•
how are you
Sent an attachment
04:01:02 am
System Message
2019/04/12
Messages to this chat and calls are now secured with end-to-end encryption. Tap for
more info.
04:01:02 am
where in the world are you ? im watching christine lagarde speak live every day. she is
so mighty
Sent an attachment
04:01:34 am
2019/04/23
09:55:31 am
Greetings from Paris. Got my 01 alien with special abilities visa...walking around
Sent an attachment
09:56:00 am
where?
Sent an attachment
09:56:01 am
You ?
Sent an attachment
09:56:10 am
paris
Sent an attachment
09:56:14 am
•
•
Wau
Sent an attachment
09:56:20 am
Want to meet !?
Sent an attachment
09:56:24 am
My train to davos is at 2.20 pm though
•
•
Sent an attachment
09:56:38 am
when are you back?
Sent an attachment
09:57:19 am
or do you want to come now? 22 ave foch
Sent an attachment
09:58:05 am
Let me see. Have former client appointment - they owe us 49.500$
Sent an attachment
10:06:59 am
System Message
Missed Voice Call
10:08:01 am
I can come at 12.30 pm till 1.15 pm
Sent an attachment
10:08:25 am
Let me know and I take uber
Flying back to US next week, not back to paris unless visa issues
Sent an attachment
10:09:10 am
2DD
Sent an attachment
10:13:45 am
ok
Sent an attachment
10:14:03 am
code 2512
Sent an attachment
10:14:07 am10:21:45 am
We work with his company now on due diligence. They want to acquire our entity
Sent an attachment
10:22:05 am
'great
Sent an attachment
10:22:30 am
https://transformgroup.com
Is looking into M&A with crypto Pr lab. Second company that is interested to invest /
acquire
E 10:24:05 am
Coming in 3 mins
•
Sent an attachment
10:24:14 am
Merci cheri de Paris .
Anything I forgot?
Old thinking is for babushka, new thinking is

1) freeze eggs, get kids any time. All his friends froze eggs.
2) have several boyfriends but don't get desease, only blowjobs.

3) find a strong man to control , manhandle, be stronger than me. For now, all my bfs
were weaker. I'm smarter than them and need bf who can win me in argument.

4) break up maybe by Christmas
5) let men help you and don't by shy getting things, money from them. Future thinking.

6) don't invest next 2 years. Markets are uncertain. Keep money. Maybe invest a little.
Trade currencies, stocks; don't manage people (hard) when you can make money by
managing money.

7) to invest in property is old thinking
8) men's makeup is the future big trend
9) marriage is for money. No need to get married otherwise.

10) in past men marry secretaries, pretty women with no assets other than body,
beauty. Future- successful women that combine beauty and brain.
- the more feminine You are the less brainy. To understand men you need to think as a
man - look manly and think like a man.
- the more symetrie you have on your face the more symmetrical is your brain
symmetrical brains are not necessary smart. When more neurons are being wired the
brain and cnsqtly face gets changed. No symetrie left-less pretty. Why do we like how
kids look ? Pretty, symmetrical faces.
Smarter the person the more asymmetrical is face and brain.

11) it is ok to break rules to survive. You don't know if it comes badly back to you or
not. It is a lottery. Like throughing a coin.

12) break up when you get your acne fixed (rocutane) and took care of hair, looks.
13) if you are not looking perfect it means you can't take care of yourself, clients think
that you won't be able to take care of them.
Sent an attachment
01:12:59 pm
...remember for girls under 24.
Maybe my amygdala is damaged because I can't recall the Ritz towels secret room
scene :1

• Sent an attachment
02:21:19 pm
in fact there was an exercise ball in the room
Sent an attachment
02:22:02 pm
blue
Sent an attachment
02:22:29 pm
Sent an attachment
Filename: 59dfb966-acdd-4112-a661-14aeca525b1b.opus
URL: https://mmg.whatsapp.net/d/f/AusYaUjGSoaQGnmG-
2MdRQp1IrEODRILG_o9mrtx5IQY.enc
Path: 59dfb966-acdd-4112-a66f-14aeca525b1b.opus
Size: 108 KB
Type: audio/ogg
03:37:23 pm
•
IMMIIIMMIN
WM.
03:43:48 pm
Jeffrey i bought roccuntane with no prescriptions and no pregnancy test. Broke all
French doctors rules. Lol. Will talk to American GP before taking it
Thank you for advice !
Sent an attachment
03:54:51 pm
Can you plz give me contact of a French lady who is currently taking this anti acne pill ?
Sent an attachment
04:11:43 pm
ill ask
Sent an attachment
04:13:46 pm
Merci
Sent an attachment
10:14:14 pm
New company, MadeMan, male cosmetics of Jeremy Gardner (friend). Raising 600k
https://docsend.com/view/ubymvew
10:16:18 pm
1
•
Sent an attachment
Filename: b9c08a35-00a4-4667-932a-e456a9a5f807.thumb
URL: https://mmg-
fna.whatsapp.net/d/f/Ao3D7bFmJBmxwADxwluPferxlisbmom7HrbQm3xFM6E-.enc
Path: b9c08a35-00a4-4667-932a-e456a9a5f807.thumb
Size: 9 KB
Type: application/pdf
10:17:48 pm
Green Booster by David Mikhaylovich Yakobashvili and his son. Have you met them?
I saw son, Misha, in Monaco a they sold the technology to few governments and look
for more African and South American counties to buy it.
Sent an attachment
10:21:46 pm
10:23:52 pin
2019/04/24
no, no interest
Sent an attachment
10:22:08 pm
explain why. these are serious business people with whom you can make money. the
under 24 year old muses will come too...
•
Sent an attachment
08:15:48 am
This is about Jeremy Gardner (on my column t.•) whom I want you to meet in NY, 9-16
May. He is founder of MadeMan among many other ventures. 25 years old.
Sent an attachment
09:52:07 am
https://thriveglobal.com/stories/an-unscientific-perspective-on-human-energy/
Sent an attachment
09:52:11 am
please only use my email i dont check this very often
Sent an attachment
09:52:43 am
Sent
Ok!
Sent an attachment
08:05:03 pm
Read
•
EFTA01613762 (Jmail)
 [crypto] WhatsApp log of conversation with Maria Prusakova about Crypto PR Lab
(date: 2019-05-21)
Platform: WhatsApp Name: Timezone: UTC+0000

• O en
O n
•
0  System Message
2019/05/21
sent you by email our financials from beginning of business
Sent an attachment
11:17:34am
difficult to see billings from receipts . how much new biz , new revenue billed in the
first 4 months
you need a breakdown ?
Sent an attachment
11:20:25 am
of this year
Sent an attachment
11:20:28 am
•
Sent an attachment
11:25:07 am
my bday tomorrow btw
Sent an attachment
ii:25:14 am
301,0
Sent an attachment
11:25:19 am
how old ?
Sent an attachment
11:25:24 am
30
Sent an attachment
11:25:32 am
big date
Sent an attachment
11:25:58 am
ha ha
•
•
•
Sent an attachment
11:25:59 am
time to get serious
Sent an attachment
11:26:11 am
Sent an attachment
11:26:22 am
right
Sent an attachment
11:26:24 am
Why tax cnsq are silly?
Sent an attachment
02:54:36 pm
Thanks Jeffrey for your care. At our age girls sold companies for billions... we just didn't
grow up or became smart quick enough unfortunately
Sent an attachment
02:56:55 pm
What do u mean "the tell call was RE the parties"?
Sent an attachment
0 02:57:14 pm
•
someone I know in Italy on family office space told me this
Sent an attachment
08:20:59 pm
thoughts?
Sent an attachment
08:21:16 pm
First, the Medici family from Florence
is EXTINCT since 1737 or so! Second,
he was born in Catanzaro the worst
city of Italy for quality of life and
in the deep South of Italy. Third his
name is not listed in the Almanach de
Gotha books which is the only official
list of European nobility!
The only Lorenzo de' Medici lives
centuries ago
And the real Medici bank of Florence
was dissolved in the 15th century
He is fake
100%
+4 You can believe me or not but I am
sure. And when he will do something
strange you will remember my words
and advice ea)
O
08:24:14 pm
2019/05/22
Hi Jeffrey
It's clear you don't want to invest in the bank it it's sad. I want to invest and ask them
to decrease minimum check size. It is a strategic investment(network and PR) and I
also think they can build business and we can exit on series B for instance.
Calling Lorenzo today.
Different topic:
Would you be interested to give me and a loan of 100k for our davos
business ? We need to get properties and events space for the Davos WEF part of the
business to rent and pay 20-50% deposits before the wet This spring-summer.
brought over 20 clients to the WEF 2019.
I was in davos 3 weeks in April and am in davos next week with Alex to secure all
venues and properties.
(Got serious. Working hard. Failed the CA bar)
My previous clients for apartments were Ellie Goulding (famous singer). She rented for
50K eur a place that we paid about 6k for.
Other clients - UK Parliament members . We rented for 7K CHf and subrented for 23K
eur.
www.davos-apartments.com
www.davos2020.com
Let me know which % you would ask.
can you explain again why Bank Chase doesn't give a loan to Our company?
O en
Sent an attachment
10:30:42 am
banks require a 2 year history of the biz to be aligible for a traditional loan. we're only
1 yr...
Sent an attachment
10:35:02 am
eligible*
Sent an attachment
10:35:13 am
I cant have anything to do with WEE biz wise. I am very invovied
Sent an attachment
10:36:19 am
Are u involved with WEF ?
We do Side events in Davos, not WEF at all.
O n
Sent an attachment
10:37:20 am
yes, when are you going to take the bar again?
Sent an attachment
10:39:00 am
think about what you can do for me , rather than get from me , it woud be in your
interest
I am paying you interest on the loan so You make money.
Sent an attachment
10:39:55 am
O en
O
Sent an attachment
10:40:33 am
LOL
Sent an attachment
10:40:53 am
I only got now SSN in this country , no credit card yet. No way a bank will give me a
loan. I don't even try anymore.
Sent you a pretty talent. PhD neuroscience. Email.
Sent an attachment
10:41:37 am
try to do better
Sent an attachment
10:42:07 am
After my O1 visa is expired (2021, November). I am bound to Crypto PR Lab and our
ventures with Alex.
In 2022 July I rather take NY bar cause it's easier.
Will be tech / blockchain attorney (unless you want to hire me for other purposes
attorney), after I gained network who will be my legal clients and made money in PR
and davos WEF events.
That's the plan.
Sent an attachment
10:44:51 am
What is your 3 years plan ?
O
O en
Sent an attachment
10:45:06 am
That opportunistic ?
Sent an attachment
10:54:55 am
i dont even have 3 day plan
Sent an attachment
10:45:25 am
https://www.youtu be.com/watc h?v=zfhgvl WlvJQ&feature=youtu. be
01:57:24 pm
lol
Sent an attachment
02:42:50 pm
I guess not so fake after all
Sent an attachment
02:43:42 pm
or is he?
•
•
Sent an attachment
02:44:46 pm
but this video cant be a proof of real prince
Sent an attachment
02:48:05 pm
it's just some show ...
Sent an attachment
02:48:09 pm
not a banker
Sent an attachment
02:47:10 pm
•
Jeffrey have you ever did this
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchant_cash_advance
Sent an attachment
Title: Merchant cash advance - Wikipedia
URL: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchant_cash_advance
O en 06:15:06 pm
No
06:15:47 pm
✓ Sent
Mezzanine structure or bond issuance ,
Thinking of how to finance our davos project
Sent an attachment
O 06:15:58 pm
✓ Read
EFTA01613759 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Crypto PR Lab letter of intent of acquisition from Transform Group
(inferred date: 2019-05-24)
DocuSign Envelope ID: F3B1AFBEBED2-4F28.9754-EB928526BF0E
STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL
0T TransforrnOROUP
LETTER OF INTENT
May 20, 2019
EZ Social Media LLC. d/b/a/ Crypto PR Lab
& Millennium Communications
Dear
Transform Group International, LLC (the "Firm"), a Puerto Rico limited liability company ("Transform",
"The Group" or "Buyer") is the leading public relations and advisory firm in the blockchain industry.
Transform believes as the blockchain industry evolves and matures, the need for agency-of-record conflict
companies will be required to continue a leadership position in the blockchain space. Management is
confident that Crypto PR Lab and Millennium Communications has delivered an impressive reputation in
the blockchain industry. We are also confident that by combining our resources and talented people, we
can continue to dominate this burgeoning industry.
Therefore, we are pleased to confirm the interest of Transform Group to acquire 100% of the issued and
outstanding equity interest in EZ Social Media LLC. d/b/a/ Crypto PR Lab, Millennium Communications
collectively ("CryptoPR").

I. Acquisition of Interest/Consideration.  Subject to satisfaction of the conditions described in
paragraph 5 below, at the closing of the acquisition (the "Closing"), the Buyer would purchase from
the Seller 100% of the issued and outstanding shares of capital stock of CryptoPR, free and clear of
any liens, charges or encumbrances (other than permitted encumbrances to be mutually agreed upon).
The target consideration for the purchase of the Company is $400,000 USD on a debt-free basis to
be paid in the form of a combination of cash and stock options. In addition, we are offering a share
in profitability to be formed into a bonus pool. The acquisition consideration is based on an
estimated $280,000 in Revenue and $195,000 in Net Profit for the trailing 12 months of operation.
The recommended consideration is as follows;

i. $200,000 in cash. Cash will be generated from collection of Revenue from first day
after Closing Date until the $200,000 is reached;

ii. $200,000 in options to vest over 3 years from Closing Date plus;
iii. Earn out of 50% of the Net Profit as a dividend from the CryptoPR P&L over the next
two years.
P.O. Box 13950. Santurce Station. San Juan. PR 009081 Yet 939-775-9575.www.iranstormgroup.com
San Juan I Las Vegas I Los Angeles I NewYorkl San Francisco I Toronto I Seoul
Page I of 3
DocuSign Envelope ID: F3BIAFBE•BED2.4F28.9754-E8928526BFOE
STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL
At the Closing, the Company is to be free of all interest -bearing debt, capital leases, taxes payable,
and any amounts due to the Seller or related parties, or the Buyer may at its option reduce the
purchase price to reflect such assumed liabilities.

2. Non-Competition Agreement:  At the Closing, the Seller will enter into a non-competition agreement
for three years (the "Non -Competition Agreement") pursuant to which the Seller will agree that
neither they nor any affiliates will directly or indirectly engage in, consult, manage or otherwise
participate in the operation of a business that directly competes with the Company or the Group, the
Seller will agree that for a period of three years neither they nor any affiliates will solicit or employ
any members of senior management of the Company or the Group.

3. Due Diligence.  Following the signing of this letter, the Seller agrees to provide information on the
Company, as well as reasonable access to its facilities, records, and customers, to Buyer (including its
agents and lenders) for the purpose of completing its due diligence. It is expected that the Company
will show performance similar to that which is stated in the materials provided thus far to the Buyer.

4. Covenants and Representations of the Seller. During the period from the signing of this letter to the
Closing, the Seller will: (i) conduct the business of the Company in the ordinary course in a manner
consistent with past custom and practice, and (ii) use their reasonable best efforts to maintain the
business and employees, customers, assets and operations of CryptoPR.

5. Definitive Documentation.  Subject to the mutual agreement of the parties, the terms and conditions of
the proposed transaction will be set forth fully in a definitive purchase and sale agreement (the
"Purchase Agreement") and other documents required to give effect to this Letter of Intent.
In general, the Buyer will expect to be indemnified for liabilities incurred outside the ordinary course
of business or substantially in excess of those reflected in the Company's financial statements prior to
the Closing, subject to a cap to be mutually agreed upon by the parties and set forth in the Purchase
Agreement; The completion of the transaction shall be contingent upon the Buyer's completion of due
diligence to its satisfaction and to receipt of financing sufficient to complete the transaction on terms
which Buyer deems acceptable.
The Buyer's obligation to close will be subject to customary conditions, including:

• receipt of all necessary governmental and third-party approvals;
• satisfactory completion of the Buyer's financial, accounting, business and legal due diligence
review of the Company;

• the execution of definitive agreements mutually satisfactory to the parties;
• the absence of any material adverse change with respect to the Company; and,
• Seller's and the Company's compliance with pre-closing covenants.

6. Confidentiality.  Neither party shall disclose (except to its representatives, key managers, agents,
lenders and investors) the existence of this Letter of Intent nor any of the terms and conditions
contained herein without the prior written consent of the other party. Buyer and Seller will prepare all
press releases and other pre-closing public announcements relating to the transaction described herein
jointly.
7. Exclusivity.  The Seller agrees that unless negotiations between the Buyer and the Seller are earlier
terminated by mutual agreement, the Seller with regard to the Company will not until 90 days from the
date of the execution of this letter by both parties: (a) solicit, initiate or encourage the submission of
any proposal or offer from any person or entity relating to a (i) liquidation, dissolution, sale of assets
P.O. Box 13980. Santurce Station. San Juan. PR 00908[ Tel 939-775-9575. www.transtormgroup.com
San Juan I Las Vegas I Los Angeles I New York [ San Francisco 'Toronto I Seoul
Page 2 of 3
DocuSign Envelope ID: F3B1AFBE•BED24F28•9754-EB928526BFOE
STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL
or stock, or recapitalization, (ii) merger or consolidation, (iii) acquisition or purchase of assets or any
equity interest, or (iv) similar transaction or business combination, or (b) institute, pursue, or engage
in any discussions, negotiations, or agreements with any person or entity concerning any of the
foregoing, or furnish any information with respect to any effort or attempt by any other person or
entity to do any of the foregoing. During the exclusivity period, the Seller agrees to immediately
notify the Buyer of the substance of any transaction inquiry, proposal or offer concerning the
Company that either the Company or the Seller may receive.
The Seller hereby acknowledges that neither they nor the Company is subject to any agreement which
conflicts with the subject matter of this letter. The Seller represent and warrant that neither they nor
the Company, nor any of their agents or representatives, as the case may be, has entered into any
agreement or had any discussions with any third party regarding a transaction which could result in the
Buyer having any liability to such third party as a result of entering into this letter or pursuing the
transactions contemplated hereby. The Seller and Buyer agree to indemnify, defend and save and hold
the other party harmless from any claims or liabilities resulting from any breach of the foregoing
representation and warranty, including any legal or other expenses incurred in connection with the
defense of any such claims or liabilities against the Buyer or Seller.

8. Conduct of Business. The Seller hereby represents that between the prior fiscal year end and the date
of the signing of this letter the Company has conducted its business in the ordinary course.

9. Binding Effect/Termination; Governing Law. This letter is not intended to and does not create a
legally binding obligation on the part of any party with respect to this proposal, except with regard to
Paragraphs 6, 7, 9, and 10, which shall be legally binding on Buyer and Seller. This letter agreement
shall be construed in accordance with the laws of the State of Nevada.

10. Miscellaneous. The Buyer and the Seller will each pay their own respective transaction expenses,
including fees and expenses of investment bankers and other advisers, incurred in connection with the
transactions contemplated. This Agreement shall not be assignable by any party without the consent of
the other parties hereto. The laws of Nevada will govern this letter agreement.
If the foregoing is acceptable, please so indicate by executing and returning a counterpart of this letter.
This offer will be deemed to have expired unless signed and returned to Enzo Villani no later than 12:00
am (Pacific Standard Time) on May 24, 2019.
Sincerely,
Michael Terpin
Chairman and CEO
Transform Group, LLC
CryptoPR CryptoPR
Co-Founder and Chief Executive Officer Co-Founder
P.O. Box 13980. Santurce Station. San Juan. PR 00908[ Tel. www.transtormgroup.com
San Juan I Las Vegas I Los Angeles I New York [ San Francisco [Toronto I Seoul
Page 3 of 3
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                   Bo Collins aka James Robert Collins [crypto] Mercantile Global Holdings, testified in trial of Miles Guo/Miles Kwok 
 Mercantile Global Holdings [crypto] company of Bo Collins who ended up testifying in trial of chinese criminal Miles Guo / Miles Kwok 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00805569 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Mercantile Global Holdings, San Juan Mercantile Bank & Trust, Noble Bank + Signature Bank + BitGo
(inferred date: 2019-05-29)
DRAFT—
Work in Progress
Mercantile Global Holdings, Inc.
Investor Presentation Alp
February 2019
MERCANTILE
GLOBAL HOLDINGS
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION
Disclosures
Confirm Disclosure
— any revisions?
This disclaimer applies to this document and the verbal or written comments of any person presenting it. This document,
taken together with any such verbal or written comments, is referred to herein as "this presentation." This presentation
is
for informational and discussion purposes only. Information contained in this presentation is provided in summary form 
and
is confidential and proprietary to Mercantile Global Holdings, Inc. ("MGH") and its affiliates. This presentation may 
not be
disclosed to any party without a written disclosure agreement, and any sharing of this confidential information to
unauthorized parties may have a material adverse effect on MGH and its affiliates.

• Nothing in this presentation constitutes, or is intended to be construed as, an offer to issue, allot, sell, or 
otherwise transfer,
or an invitation, advertisement, solicitation, recommendation, advice, or inducement to invest in or make a commitment 
to
invest in, any securities, options, other financial instruments or other assets, whatsoever.

• This presentation contains forward looking statements including statements regarding our intent, belief or 
expectations.
Forward looking statements are subject to risks and uncertainties, which could cause actual results to differ materially
from
those anticipated. Words such as "may," "will? "potential" "should;' "expect" "anticipate "target;' "project," 
"estimate;'
"intend," "continue," or "believe," or the negatives thereof or similar expressions or terminology are intended to 
identify
forward-looking statements. Statements in this presentation are made as of the date hereof unless otherwise stated 
herein.

• MGH and its affiliates may or may not pursue the strategy as specifically outlined in this presentation and may change
strategy depending on changing market conditions, opportunities, resources, regulations or other factors. Neither MGH 
nor
any of its affiliates undertake any obligation to furnish additional information or to update, revise or correct any of 
the
information contained herein. By accepting this presentation, each recipient on their own accord, and on behalf of their
respective business entities, agrees to the foregoing.
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 2
Speaker Introductions • • Team / Speakers to be
discussed
Our team has over 60 years of exchange, banking, and other related experience and has deep knowledge in the
sector from running and operating large predecessor institutions
Bo Collins
Chairman & CEO of
MGH and SJMBT

• Former President of the New York Mercantile
Exchange
• Led NYMEX through transition to electronic
trading and increased market cap from
$600M to $2.7B within 3 years

• Created ClearPort, the first successful OTC
Clearing platform
• In partnership with NASDAQ, launched
International Derivatives Clearing Group in
2008, which was sold to LCH.Clearnet Group

• Serial entrepreneur and well regarded
FinTech executive
Rick Beaman
CEO of SJMX
• Recent CEO of NASDAQ Futures Exchange
(NFX)

• Grew NFX volumes from start-up to the 2n°
largest exchange in Natural Gas Options;
named the 'Fastest Growing exchange in 2017

• Successfully launched TradeSpark Exchange
with Cantor Fitzgerald, which was an early
competitor to ICE

• Served 10 years in the U.S. Navy, and last
served on the Personal Staff for Admiral
William J. Flanagan, Jr. (four star),
Commander in Chief of the U.S. Atlantic Fleet
Nick Varelakis
President & COO of SJMBT and
CFO of MGH

• Previous COO and Interim CFO of Noble Bank
International, an IFE dedicated to facilitating
growth of the digital asset market

• Head of large operational and business
development teams at JP Morgan across
various asset classes
• Director at LCH.Clearnet, Head of Global
Operations for SwapClear, a CFTC registered
DCO
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 3
Compelling Investment Highlights To Be Refined
1.) Seasoned and Cohesive
Management Team
2.) Integrated Institutional -
Focused Exchange and
Regulated Bank Entity
3.) Network of Over
150,000+ Global Prop
Traders
4.) Enterprise-Grade
Trading Technology
5.) High Free Cash Flow
Business Model
6.) Growth Opportunities to
Build Operating Scale

• Current management team has over 60 years of exchange, banking and related experience, and key members of
management have worked together or known each other for years

• CEO Bo Collins was previously the President of New York Mercantile Exchange from 2001-2004; launched the International
Derivatives Clearing Group in partnership with NASDAQ in 2008 (later sold to LCH Clearnet Group)

• Rick Beaman was formerly the CEO of the Nasdaq Futures Exchange and Vice President of NASDAQ; has been involved in the
exchange, clearing, product development and brokering of energy markets for over 20 years

• Nicholas Varelakis was formerly the interim CFO and Chief Operations Officer for Noble Bank International; before 
Noble
Bank, Nicholas was an Executive Director and ran the North American Business Architecture and Transformation Group
Clear focus on providing a comprehensive suite of integrated products geared toward institutional traders as a leading
market differentiator in the exchange space
High importance placed on quality products & services, including low latency connectivity, post-trade settlement
services, variety of custody solutions, and risk analytics and management
Operates regulated bank entity, offering full services in-house and fiat custody while partnering with third-party 
crypto
custodial solutions
Existing relationship with COG grants access to over 40+ global exchanges, including the CME, CBOT, NYSE, NYMEX, LSE,
LME, Euronext, Tokyo Stock Exchange and others
All existing customers of CQG today will have access to SJMX upon launch and after onboarding process; CQG will also
offer free customer access to CQG's Desktop, Mobile, and FX products
CQG to allow MAX to co-locate in their data centers, allowing for industry-low latency (less than 3 milliseconds a 100
micro-seconds by end of 2019)
Trading technology is programmed to facilitate trades in digital currencies and is already integrated with CQG's 
existing
institutional trading infrastructure, which has been operating globally for —40 years

• Matching engine can process over 1.5mm transactions per second and has the capacity to support 1,600 listed products 
for
trading

• Software will be developed so that it can be integrated into existing institutional infrastructure and trading 
platforms and
will be available as a computer and smartphone application

• Traditional and cryptocurrency trading exchanges have proven to be highly cash generative and a high margin business,
offering flexibility for capital deployment and working capital security

• Strong run-rate profitability may provide investors with multiple exit opportunities at higher valuations in the 
future

• Larger publicly-traded global exchange businesses have historically been highly acquisitive to fuel growth

• Numerous acquisition opportunities exist for SJMX to acquire and build operating scale, with a potential to leverage 
SJMX's
platform for a roll-up strategy
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 4
Table of Contents DRAFT

1. Company Overview [XI
2. Integrated Exchange & Banking Platform [XI
3. Deep Network and Relationships In-Place [XI
4. Technology Systems [XI
5. Financial Overview [XI
6. Key Milestones & Growth Opportunities [XI
7. Appendices [XI
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 5
MERCANTILE
GLOBAL HOLDINGS
Company Overview
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 6
Company Overview DRAFT
Mercantile Global Holdings, Inc. ("MGH") is developing an institutional -grade electronic trading platform and 
integrated banking
platform for digital assets
MERCANTILE
Li GLOBAL HOLDINGS
San Juan Mercantile Exchange, Inc. ("SJMX")
(Based in Chicago)
Institutional -Grade Exchange Technology
Connected to LIT market, dark pool, and OTC trading
Enterprise-grade matching engine with FIX APIs
Capacity for 1.5 million transactions per second with 3 milliseconds of
latency
Professional Trading Infrastructure

• Connectivity with leading software vendor currently servicing global
financial markets
• Immediate on-ramp for traders
Other Exchanges
San Juan Mercantile Bank & Trust International Corp. ("SJMBT")
(Based in Puerto Rico)
Fully Regulated Bank Entity

• Regulated by the Puerto Rico Office of the Commissioner of Financial
Institutions
• Correspondent banking partners will be in-place for launch

• Fully integrated FinTech layer for connectivity to exchange
• Real time settlement and cash / margin efficiency and availability
Custodial Services
Working to integrate with leading digital asset custodians
Client directed with ability to diversify holdings across multiple custodians
Mercantile Global Holdings
Exchange
(Del. Corp)
41- Order Routing
Technology
Clients
L Jrp
Completed Trade Data
Bank
(PR Corp)
I Correspondent
Banks Federal
Reserve Broker
Institutional Digital
Custody Services
Trust Accounts
Custody Settlement
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 7
Cohesive Management Team with Deep History • SJMX to confirm # of
Employees _ mi l
Key members of MGH's management team have worked together and known each other for years
Executive Management Team & History Organizational Chart
Key Industry Prior Working
Executives Experience Firms Together
S Bo Collins
Chairman &
CEO of MGH
and SJBT
31+ years
New York
Mercantile
Exchange
120+ years.

• Rick Beaman
CEO of SJMX 23+ years NASDAQ
• Nick Varelakis
President &
COO of SJMBT
and CRO of
MGH
Bob Cavnar
President &
COO of MGH
19+ years
Noble Bank
JP Morgan
SwapClear
44+ years enegX LLC
0 Rene Canon
Head of Global
Legal &
Compliance
15+ years Sidley
Austin
Bo Collins
Chairman & CEO of NIGH
Bob Cavnar
President & COO of MGH
Joined
recently
from
NASDAQ Rick
Beaman
CEO of
SJMX
Nick
Varelakis
Interim
CFO &
COO of
SJMBT
John
Wyman
Chief
Tech
Officer
Rene
Carson
Chief
Lego! &
Govern
Officer
Carrie
Gill
Head of
HR
Bank team
together for
7+ years (3l Team (9) Team (1/ Team
Members Members Member
(3l Team PI Team
Members Member
With Bo
since 1997,
El Paso
Corporation
(22+ years)
Infrastructure In-Place with (24) Team Members
Ready for Operational Ramp-Up
Legal team
together for
- 8+ years
Actively Seeking to Build Out Platform and Hiring
Additional Key Employees
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 8
Full Product Suite for All Institutional Trader Needs I • Confirm — S.INIXport?
Settlement services?
Comprehensive suite of products & services all offered in-house to build customer flexibility and ease of use
Overview of Products & Services 2020E Revenue by Product ($mm)
Central Limit Order Book:

• Match engine designed to process more than 1.5 million transactions per
second with an expected latency of 3 milliseconds
Fix APIs or access through CQG front-end
OTC Execution Desk:

• Facilitate large buy or sell orders through OTC facilitation desks
• Execute orders through proprietary execution algorithms or with other
counter-parties
Integrated bank platform intended to enhance security and efficiency of
transactions
Dark Pool:
Handles large OTC or Institutional orders by efficiently connecting
customers to superior liquidity, promote best execution, and decrease
market impact
Ability to stream quotes into the OTC Book / Dark Pool
Ability to place large orders across both dark and lit markets
$44.2
34%
$22.8
18%
$4.6
4%
$29.8
23%
2020E
i
fRevenue:
$128mm
$26.7
21%

• CL0B • OTC Dark Pool • Settlement Fees • Custody Revenue
[Exchange Support Products] Projected Exchange ADTV ($mm) and Fee Structure
SJMXport:

• Settle OTC trades bi-laterally with registered participants through
proprietary systems
• Standardized on-boarding procedures, developed to comply with
customary KYC / AML practices

• Access a flexible suite of settlement services to provide secure and
efficient transactions
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION
$530.5
FeeStructure
$91.4
CLOB Execution Fee 0.025%
$80.3
OTC Execution Fee 0.100%
Dark Pool Execution Fee 0.075%
S114.9 $358.8
Settlement Fee 0.025%
$19.8
517.4
577.7 Custody 0.400%
2019E 2020E

• CLOB • OTC Dark Pool 9
Fully Integrated Operational Infrastructure • Confirm Next Custodian
and power checks
MGH's fully integrated platform provide customers additional liquidity, integrated onboarding, and expedited
transfers between crypto and fiat currencies
NSW A
°onto, )
xapo
fl e et "
It
e
BitGo owe,.
DIGITAL
ASSF1 DACC concur
COMPANY

• ETAINA Omani
(Next] -S
Eat
Custodian Banks
Overnight
Investments
Instant trade
settlement and ability
to trade. Once a day
rebalance across
custodians and Fiat
Banks
MGH
Ledger
Elysium
Fintech Layer
t
Buying power
checks

• Trade submission
• Trade confirmation
• Limits management
• Reporting
Lit Market
•
Dark Pool
Orders
RFQs
Reports
The operational structure on the
left hand side illustrates:

• Clients onboarded onto MGH
are simultaneously
onboarded with each
exchange integrated with the
ETP / Elysium, allowing for
fast access to liquidity

• Elysium provides buying
power checks, trade
submissions, trade
confirmations, limit
management, and reporting

• When onboarded, clients
have access to two pools of
liquidity: lit market and dark
market. Clients have the
ability to seek liquidity within
the dark pool while
maintaining price matching
functionality with Lit Market

• MGH connects to digital
currency custodians and
banks, allowing clients to
switch between digital and
fiat currencies allowing for
instantaneous trading

• Daily rebalancing between
custodians and fiat banks
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 10
co, MERCANTILE
GLOBAL HOLDINGS
Integrated Exchange & Bank Platform
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 11
MGH's Value Proposition
MGH is able to offer traders an institutional approach towards digital asset trading
DRAFT
The Issue: Retail Infrastructure The Solution: MGH's Institutional- Grade Infrastructure
Existing digital asset exchanges are not designed to meet
institutional requirements

• Access via a web browser and often too slow
• Outsourced infrastructure (i.e., AWS)
• Vulnerable to cyberattacks and unreliable during peak times

• Unable to trade on other exchanges
Most institutions are not able to trade on their existing
infrastructure platforms

• Incompatible with web-based connectivity and protocols
• Inconsistent connectivity
• Not able to service existing customers

• Subject to fraud, manipulation, and deceptive trading
practices
Unable to connect with middle and back office workflows
Material limitations on security, withdrawals, and support
At risk of cyberattacks; funds sit with the exchange
Tiered account security creates vulnerabilities and unfair
advantages
Limitations on dollar and / or digital asset withdrawal
amounts
Delayed and unpredictable trade processing
The Exchange will have technical infrastructure modeled after
top commodity exchanges

• Access via proprietary trading application
• High speed private network
• Owned and controlled infrastructure

• Enterprise grade security infrastructure
• High performance and fault tolerant
Integrated into global exchange ecosystem
Institutions will be able to trade on their existing infrastructure
platforms

• Industry accepted connectivity and protocol standards
• Reliable connectivity and customary exchange controls

• Fair and efficient markets
• Maintain and enhance your existing customer relationships
• Intuitive workflow integrations
More secure infrastructure, no limits on withdrawals and
dedicated support

• Separation between the Exchange and the Bank along with
3rd party custody options creates significant security
benefits

• No planned limits on dollar or digital asset withdrawal
amounts
• Dedicated account management and customer service
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 12
Integrated Platform Tailored Towards Institutional Trade rs DRAFT
MGH's integrated exchange and banking platform provides instantaneous execution between traders and their
counterparties with complete flexibility between fiat and digital asset currencies
SAN JUAN
CA\ MERCANTILE
\W EXCHANGE

• Enterprise-grade matching engine
• Connectivity with major ISVs currently servicing the global
financial markets

• Real time limit management based on intraday Bank
balances
• Increased stability and security compared to web-based
exchanges
Electronic
Trading Platform

• Matching engine
processes more than 1.5
million transactions per
second with a 3
millisecond latency

• State of the art trading
application and analytics
with strong risk
management tools
Liquidity
• Substantial number of
traders able to connect
through existing trading
infrastructure, creating
and increasing liquidity

• Integration between
Exchange and Bank will
facilitate seamless
settlement of OTC
transactions
1,JAN
re MERCANTILE
c if BANK & TRUST

• Single user interface to manage fiat and digital asset
balances
• Real-time settlement and availability of asset balances
based on intraday exchange activity

• Connectivity with reputable fiat and digital custodians
• Customers will be subject to AML and KYC requirements
Clearing &
Settlement

• Real-time limit
management that is based
upon holdings at the bank
• Ability to view and
manage fiat and digital
asset custody in one entity
Fiat & Digital
Custody
S

• Fiat assets to be held in
accounts with correspondent
bank partners
• Digital assets to be held with
custody partners; wide
network of custodial
partners allow for active
management of
concentration risk across
multiple platforms
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 13
Fully Regulated & Robust Compliance Systems DRAFT
Active dialogue with regulators and compliance teams in-place allow for seamless and speedy client onboarding and
KYC/AML procedures
Foundation of a rigorous and
trusted regulatory framework
Fully regulated with industry best practices
SJMBT is treated as a regulated bank by FINCEN for purposes
of BSA / AML/ OFAC compliance

• Strict oversight and audit by the OCFI, using the same FFIEC
audit standards that are applied to FDIC-guaranteed banks

• Strong compliance culture created and reinforced by MGH's
Board of Directors, ensuring compliance amongst leadership,
senior management, and employees
Rigorous on-boarding using customary KYC/ AML
procedures

• Robust KYC / AML procedures for client onboarding process
• Once customer is onboarded, customer is onboarded among
all users and exchanges integrated onto the ETP

• KYC / AML procedures consist of a 4 step process:
Customer Identification Program
• Due Diligence
• Risk Rating Assessment

• Enhanced Due Diligence
Active transaction monitoring in-place and market
surveillance technology
Transaction monitoring compares customer activity with
broader market activity to assist in assessing client behavior
Provides information to the compliance staff and officers to
identify specific transactions that may require additional
review, documentation and reporting
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION
Gilberto Figueroa
Chief Compliance Officer
Active dialogue and great relationship with
Puerto Rican and other regulators
, ociF  • Organized as an International Financial Entity
(IFE) in Puerto Rico; subject to regulatory
oversight and BSA & OFAC requirements

• Bo Collins and the Commissioner of OCIF, George Joiner, both serve on
the BlockChain Advisory Council

• Both Bo Collins and George Joiner have a positive relationship and active
dialogue
On February 12, 2019, MGH submitted their second stage application in
their request for a Permit to Operate

• Expected to take 2-4 weeks and on-site inspection by OCIF
[Also ongoing and recent dialogue with FINCEN, CFTC and the SEC,
informing regulators of entry to market and business plan]
Strong and Experienced Compliance
Team In-Place
Run by a seasoned Chief Compliance Officer and a compliance department
staffed with 4-6 experienced professionals
2 dedicated attorneys with outside legal support by DLA Piper
Chief Compliance Officer Biography

• Former U.S. Department of Homeland Security
Special Agent with 10+ years of experience
• Worked as the BSA / AML / OFAC Compliance
Officer for Banco Popular in New York and in
Puerto Rico

• Currently is a Certified Anti-Money Laundering
Specialist and Certified Internal Controls Auditor
• Received his B.A. at the University of Puerto
Rico and from Interamerican University 14
Clear Market Differentiator and Competitive Advantag DRAFT
MGH will offer professional trading front-end that is connected through CQG in order to promote faster execution
and greater reliability
This structure provides efficiency and unique benefits, including building upon customer flexibility for their demands /
needs, institutional-grade custody for digital assets, and connectivity to major liquidity pools
Professional trading platform and integrated into traditional capital markets infrastructure

• Designed to increase security, efficiency and flexibility for professional traders
Features an API that uses Financial Interface Exchange ("FIX") protocol relied upon by banks and broker dealers globally

• Clients are able to co-late their servers with CQG for even greater speed and security
Owns and will operate a proprietary matching engine designed to manage millions of traders per second

• Other exchanges lack this technology and struggle to balance functionality and security
Structural advantages over incumbent digital asset exchanges by having an integrated bank entity

• Fully regulated and operational bank entity will settle transactions and manage fiat currency balances
Only exchange that offers a customer-centric custody solution

• Allows customers to choose MGH's proprietary custody solution or to hold assets at other custodians instead
With the Exchange and the Bank, MGH will be able to provide customers the ability to hold both fiat and digital assets

• Provides clients the ability to trade on the exchange based on these balances
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 15
Competitive Landscape • Note — Names to be removed in final version

• TBU — Add in ErisX and Bakkt
MGH offers a comprehensive product suite with full functional and 24/7 support that is not offered or often limited at
other cryptocurrency exchanges
Key Features r  SIMI( Colnbase Pro Gemini Kraken Bristamp Mitre( halt Circle l Polonlex bitflyer USA
Exchange (CLOBI Fee's
OTC Fee's
Oark Pool Fee's
Security
Digital Asset Custody
Primary Customer Base
Web/ Cloud-based Option
0.025%
0.10%
0.25%
High
Multi
Institutional
•
0.O3096 to 0.30% 0.00% to 1.00% 0.0096 to 1.00% 0.10% - 025% 0.25%
Medium
Self.custody
Retail
✓
Medium
Self.custody
Retail
✓
010%436%
Low
Self. custody
Retail
Mediwn
Bitgo
Retail
✓
Medium
Self-custody
Retail
✓
ODM-025% 0.00%-010% 0D2%-0.12%
0.10% n/a
low
Self-custody
Retail
✓
Medium
Sett custody
Retail
Low
Self custody
Retail
Full FIX Protocol Implementation
Proprietary desktop Software
Bank Subsidiary
Escrow Services
OTC Facilitation desk
Instant OTC Settlement
BI-Lateral Trading
Dark Pool Liquidity
Block Trading
Connectivity to Other Digital Asset mattorrns
Connectivity to Global Exchange Network
Co-location Services
Match Engine Sub 1 Millisecond
Advanced Order Types
Algo Budder
Access to Traditional Exchanges
Sub-Account Structure
Diversified Custody Options
Trade Surveillance
Agency Trading Model
Exchange Membership Model
Experienced Exchange Management
Connected to leading ISV
Subject to Banking Regulations
Integrated Risk Management Tools
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
✓
K
K
✓
K
K
K
K
✓
K
✓
K
K
K
✓
K
✓
K
K
K
✓
✓
K
K
K
K
✓
✓
K
K
N
N
N
K
✓
✓ ✓ K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
K
NOTE: The summary above compares features of San Juan Mercantile Exchange (SIM%) with those of other digital asset 
trading platforms. The comparison represents
the conclusions of SIMCs management based on currently available information reviewed by them, as of February 2019.
•••••••••
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. ) CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 16
(.6, MERCANTILE
GLOBAL HOLDINGS
Deep Network and Relationships In-Place
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 17
Exchange Ecosystem & Execution Avenues i • Confirm SIMXport — Bank product for settlement?

• Confirm what is defined as a fiduciary customer?
Potential access to multiple exchanges and other financial institutions through an integrated electronic trading
platform, allowing accessibility to all of MGH's product offerings and instantaneous market liquidity
Value Chain
Full functionality and
accessibility for
customers to use MGH
products as well as act
as a platform for MGH
distribution
fa\ MERCANTILE
GLOBAL HOLDINGS
EA\ MERCANTILE
EXCHANGE
Products & Services
Accessibility to LIT &
Dark Pool Markets
MGH Exchange Ecosystem
Futures Commission
Merchant ("FCM")
Solicits or accepts orders
to buy or sell future
contracts and options
Active dialogue with 2-3
FCMs
ai Elysium Technology Group
Digital Currency
Trading Firms
Digital currency trading
firms are ideal customers
to target and onboard to
utilize MGH's platform
Active dialogue with 30-40
trading firms
Fiduciaries

• [T8U)
• Active dialogue with 1
fiduciary
Other Exchanges
• Other exchanges are able
to utilize MGH's ETP to
access products and
additional liquidity

• MGH may also onboard
customers from other
exchanges
Active dialogue with 5-7
exchanges
MGH's fully integrated ETP platform with Elysium partnership
Central Limit
Order Book
Provides access to liquidity
and trading LIT markets
Matching engine that can
process 1.5 million
transactions per second
with latency of 3
milliseconds
FIX APIs and access
through CQG front-end
Dark Pool

• Execution of large trades
through a dark pool
execution facility
• Accessibility to greater
liquidity opportunities

• Orders can be placed
across both the LIT
markets as well as the
dark pool markets
simultaneously
OTC Execution

• Facilitate large buy or sell
orders through an OTC
facilitation desk
• Execute orders through a
proprietary execution
algorithm or with other
counter-parties bi-laterally
[SJMXport]
Settles OTC trades bi-
laterally with registered
participants through
proprietary settlement
system
Accessibility with a flexible
suite of settlement
services to provide secure
and efficient transactions
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 18
Complementary Relationship with CQG DRAFT
An existing agreement with CQG provides MGH with back-end exchange support with the potential for MGH to reap
additional rewards
CQG:::
Company Overview

• CQG provides data, decision making, and order
execution software for the financial trading
industry worldwide

• Also offers market data, news, analytics, and
other electronic trading services & solutions
• The company was incorporated in 1976 and is
based in Denver, CO
Access to CQG's Products & Services

• Integrated Client: access to global market data
and trading interfaces for electronic trading and
order management

• Trader: provides market data and electronic
trading platform ("ETP") including real-time
quotes, trading, and order management

• FX: provides FX solutions for foreign exchange
trading and execution
• Desktop: offers trading, market data, charting,
and analytics in a one integrated product

• Mobile: mobile application for remote access to
quotes, analytics, and trading
MERCANTILE
+ GLOBAL HOLDINGS  CQGE:•/1 •
Background of Relationship
Relationship Background

• MGH entered into an agreement with CQG LLC on [January X], 2019
• Integrated MGH's electronic trading platform ("ETP") with CQG's existing
network, with CQG providing order-routing and independent software
vendor ("ISV") services

• CQG's analytic tools and order-rerouting ISV services are industry leading
and among the industry's best performing

• Worldwide network and global reach
• 24/7 monitoring fully backed by a customer support staff located in
11 locations across the globe
Complementary Relationship to MGH

• MGH customers will have the ability to access over 40+ global exchanges,
including the CME, CBOE, NYSE, NYMEX, LSE, and several others

• MGH and CQG customers will be able to utilize the integrated ETP to
purchase and sell digital currencies and other digital assets

• Access to CQG's full suite of professional trading technologies, including:
• Integrated Client, CQG Desktop, Mobile, and FX products

• Real-time and historical data, technical analysis tools, decision-
making tools, and order execution software
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 19
Full Fiat Currency & Digital Asset Custody in One Entity DRAFT
MGH is continuously expanding their correspondent banking partners and digital asset custodians to provide
customers full accessibility and flexibility under one entity
Currently
Engaged /
Agreement
In-Place
Correspondent Banking Partners

• Publicly traded (NASDAQ:
SBNY) $47 billion asset-sized
bank based in New York
• Recently approved
correspondent bank partner

• Fully onboarded onto
Signature's systems
Digital Asset Custodians
BitGo
.4
KINGDOM
TRUST.
• [Executed custody agreement
and completed KYC / AML
process]; expected to go live
on March 1g, 2019

• [Executed agreement in-place
and KYC / AML process
completed]; expected to go
live on [X]
Ongoing
Dialogue
Fidelity A
BU RLI NG BANK
NORTH ERN
TRUST
BM()© I lams Bank
Metropolitan
Commercial Bank
FIFTH THIRD BANK
UBS
BNY MELLON

• Ongoing dialogue with Fidelity
and have submitted initial
Fidelity A documentation
DIGITAL ASSETS- • Digital asset custodian
business not yet publicly
launched; expected April 2019
Targeted
Potential
Partners
RBS BANK FRICK NOAMJRA
Standard S Y Royal Bank MUFG
pi e 7t of Scotland Chartered
IIIDBS @MIAS taitatJtAN I k
xa po DACC
DIGITAL
ASSET
CUSTODY
COMPANY
Primesiust
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 20
• From company - picture
of the user interface?
Technology Systems
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 21
Technology Development DRAFT
Mercantile Global Holdings and its subsidiaries are currently developing and/or integrating the following systems
and technologies:
Banking Systems
The banking system will provide S1MX operation staff with the ability to manage customer accounts and transactions such 
as deposits and withdrawals. For S1MX
customers, the banking system will serve as an online portal providing account and transaction details. Banking system 
is being developed by Elysium Technology
Group ("ETG")
Status: Banking system will be ready for demonstration to bank regulators by [2/15/20191. The system will be fully 
operation by [3/15/20191.
Dark Pool and OTC Trading
2 The dark pool and OTC trading will enable customers to transact large block volume in complete anonymity. Dark pool is
being integrated with the Block,
Execution,
Access, Control, Onboarding, Network ("BECAON") to facilitate OTC and dark pool trading. BEACON is a deal management 
system that enables a network of brokers,
market makers and other market participants to source dark liquidity at better prices. Dark pool is being developed by 
Mercury Digital Assets ("MDA") and will
be
operated as S1MX dark pool. MDA is also developing a white label S1MX branded version of the BEACON tool.
Status: Dark Pool and OTC trading will be fully operational by 13/31/20191and launch with the bank.
LIT Exchange
3 LIT Exchange is being developed by the MGH tech team. LIT exchange has specific hardware and infrastructure 
requirements. The proposed hardware has a 3 month
lead time from order placement to production availability. Prior to Launch, LIT Exchange will be integrated with CGQ. 
Prior to integration, CQG will be upgraded
to
support crypto currency decriminalized volume.
Status: CQG's upgrade to support crypto volume is expected to be complete with [May 20191. LIT Exchange is scheduled to 
launch [May 2019).
APIs
4 The banking system, dark pool, OTC trading and LIT Exchange will all need to be integrated through APIs.
Status: APIs required to launch the banking system, dark pool and OTC trading systems will be operational by 
(3/15/2019). APIs required to launch our LIT
Exchange
will be operational by [May 2019).
CQG Trading Tools
5 Partnered with CQG to deliver customers with an innovative set of trading tools, global data and advanced analytic 
capabilities. Our customers will have
access to
several COG trading tools including their flagship CQG Integrated Client, COG Desktop, and native iOS mobile trading.
Status: Partnership established and customers are being onboarded.
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 22
Operational Infrastructure DRAFT
The bank and exchange work closely together to create a high performing and efficiency operation for MGH
customers
San Juan Mercantile Exchange
San Juan Mercantile Bank &
Trust International
Highlights
SAN JUAN MERCANTILE BANK & TRUST INTERNATIONAL
&JIMA T
D.001_4 .1 4$ Are/
Weasels
R
ard
Rowing

• Security built into the infrastructure
rather than bolted-on
• High-performance InfiniBand
backbone ensures high-speed,
UIC4
On* GalavegS
low- latency order routing and
execution Direct vats
Access
FIX 0S
Gamy,

• High-availability, fault-tolerant roux
architecture to provide
customers an always-on
neanj cwct WebSothets
experience in* c eon
Sri's* IMAM Da

• Financial Services security WROPYI
NI Wags
Data Rooms standards and compliance with
Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act WAR( ORLI
Krebs
(GBLA), Dodd-Frank Reform, Web Socials
wAM Del•
Feeder. Consumer Protection Act and
Payment Card Industry Data
Security
a it
Cusiodv
Ona.eIr, • A
CusIZO/
Parader • 5
Aeceufil
Maple&
Vale
lira%
5a d
ftlesene
Ore Trade
,---• maneq
[MK*
OK*
managensent
ROACTIree Darn
ItgA Antwas
Cakaor Ault Lcgs
SAN JUAN MERCANTILE EXCHANGE
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 23

• To Discuss — financial model &
burn rate with Nick
Financial Overview
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 24
• From Pat - collective
view on growth
opportunities
Key Milestones & Growth Opportunities
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 29
H12019 Company Milestones • To Be Updated — Pat with key milestones & collective view on growth strategies
Mercantile Global Holdings has established a clear execution plan for the upcoming fiscal year
January February March April May
SJMX
Integrate Bank
and Exchange
Launch Dark
Pool and OTC
Trading
Deploy Exchange
Trade Surveillance
Technology and CQG
Integration
O Buildout 350 Launch
Cermak Exchange, 3/31
Production
Facility in
Chicago, IL
Onboard API
Client
SJMB&T
Obtain IFE
Banking License
Launch Bank
(Dark Pools and
Fit / Digital
Custodian
Support)
IMe  Complete • In Progress • Ongoing
Launch
onboarding,
KYC /AML tech
Launch Bank
Escrow Services
Fully integrate
KYC / AML tech
Onboard
Corresponding
Banking Partners
(e.g., Signature Bank
onboarded 2/19)
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 30
MERCANTILE
GLOBAL HOLDINGS
Appendices
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 31
DRAFT
Management Team

J. Robert "Bo" Collins Jr.
CEO of MGH and SJMX
Mr. Collins served as the President of New York Mercantile Exchange ("NYMEX") from 2001 to 2004, which was the largest
commodities exchange in the world during such time. Under his leadership, NYMEX launched Clearport Clearing, the first
commercially successful OTC clearing platform. Mr. Collins also initiated and led the development of the Dubai 
Mercantile
Exchange.
During his time at NYMEX, Mr. Collins brought the exchange
into a new era of electronic trading and increased the market
cap from $600 million to $2.7 billion within 3 years (amidst
the 9/11 attacks, Enron bankruptcy and largest power outage
in U.S. history). Additionally, he led the exchange to an initial
credit rating of A++ and its recognition by Energy Risk
magazine as the 2004 "Exchange of the Year." In 2008, in
partnership with NASDAQ Mr. Collins launched a new
clearinghouse, the International Derivatives Clearing Group,
which was later sold to LCH.Clearnet Group.

Mr. Collins is an active entrepreneur and respected FinTech
professional currently involved in successful ventures such
as Matrix Global, the first crude oil storage auction platform.
He has also launched an incubator initiative to utilize
innovative solutions such as digital assets and blockchain
technology to improve infrastructure development, physical
logistics, financial trading and exchange clearing.
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 32
Management Team (
DRAFT
Robert Cavnar
President & Chief Operating Officer of MGH
Robert L. Cavnar is president and chief operating officer of MGH. Mr. Cavnar
is a 40-plus year veteran of the oil and gas industry. He served as chairman,
president and chief executive officer of Mission Resources Corporation where
he led the restoration of the company to profitability. Prior to Mission
Resources, he was a senior vice president of El Paso Corporation where he
served as chief operating officer of its midstream business unit and as chief
financial officer of its upstream business unit.
He has spent a large portion of his career performing startups, turnarounds,
and reorganizations, including realigning governance structures. Mr. Cavnar is
also author of Disaster on the Horizon: High Stokes, High Risks, and the Story
Behind the Deepwoter Well Blowout, a behind-the-scenes investigative look at
the worst oil well accident in US history.
Rick Beaman
CEO of SJMX
Rick Beaman is the CEO of SJMX. Mr. Beaman was formerly a Vice President of
NASDAQ and CEO, Nasdaq Futures Exchange (NFX).

Mr. Beaman has been involved in the Exchange, Clearing, Product Development
and Brokering of Energy Markets for 20 years.
Before joining NASDAQ OMX, Mr. Beaman worked S years at VMAC, LLC, as VP
of Client relations and Marketing developing a Clearing solution for Physical and
Financial derivatives. Prior to VMAC he was employed by TradeSpark, LLC as
the General Manager where he managed a sizeable Broker and Sales team of
72, that was a competitive hybrid model in the energy industry- a combination
of electronic trading and commodities brokering. Prior to TradeSpark, he was
employed by Cantor Fitzgerald and supervised a team of 46 brokers in Natural
Gas, Power, Emissions, and Coal. Rick is also a veteran of ten years in the U.S.
Navy.
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 33
Management Team (
DRAFT

R. Rene Carson
General Counsel of MGH and SJMX
Ms. Carson is an experienced legal and compliance professional, with more
than fifteen years in the financial service, technology and energy sectors.
Prior to joining Lone Star Capital and Renovatio PR, Ms. Carson was General
Counsel and Global Head of Compliance for INTL FCStone Inc. (NASDAQ: INTL),
a Fortune S00 company that provides customers across the globe with
execution, clearing, and advisory services in commodities, capital markets,
and other related sectors. As Global Head of Compliance, Rene supervised over
40 compliance professionals and helped build a new compliance infrastructure
for the company's derivatives business post Dodd-Frank.
Prior to INTL, Ms. Carson spent more than a decade in private practice,
including as a partner at Sidley & Austin.

Ms. Carson received her Juris Doctor degree with honors from NYU School of
Law, and her B.A. with honors in Political Science from University of Wyoming.
Nicholas Varelakis
COO of SJMBT and CFO of MGH

Mr. Varelakis is President and COO of SJMBT and the CFO of MGH. He formerly
served as Chief Operations Officer and interim CFO for Noble Bank
International. Mr. Varelakis joined Noble from JPMorgan Chase & Co., Inc.
where he served his second non-consecutive term as an Executive Director,
responsible for leadership of the North American Business Architecture and
Transformation group.
Prior to joining JP Morgan, Mr. Varelakis was a Director at LCH. Clearnet LLC,
responsible for oversight of global operations for the SwapClear division, a
derivatives clearing organization registered with the Commodity Futures
Trading Commission. Prior to joining LCH in April 2011, Mr. Varelakis spent
seven years at JP Morgan and served as North American Head of Middle Office
Operations for the firm's credit default swap clearing and prime brokerage
businesses.

Mr. Varelakis graduated magna cum laude from Pace University, where he
earned his undergraduate degree in Business Administration.
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 34
Management Team (
DRAFT
John Wyman
Chief Technology Officer of MGH & SJMX

Mr. Wyman brings 2O+ years of trading technology development. He most
recently served as CTO at NEO Markets, overseeing the design and
development of a state-of-the-art exchange-matching engine and front-end
trading solution. This innovative platform brought together OTC physical,
OTC financial and listed futures for the first time onto one screen. He spent
12 years as CTO of Houston Street Exchange, an innovative electronic exchange
offering trading in physical crude oil, refined products, biofuels, natural gas
liquids and grain. As a founding partner with DirecTrade, an online equities
brokerage and trading firm, he led the design, architecture and development
of the company's proprietary trading solution. He also founded Engineered
Information Systems, a management consulting firm, and has held
management and technical positions at MCI Communications, Softbridge
Microsystems and Coordination Technology.

Mr. Wyman studied computer science at lona College and the University
of New Haven.
MERCANTILE GLOBAL HOLDINGS, INC. I CONFIDENTIAL I NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 35
EFTA00785160 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2019-05-29 23:12:55)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024362.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024362.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case
Data:
Messages
(29301-
29400 of
32198)
iMessage
[1] 2019-05.22:41:. (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I spoke to her and told her you are my new assistant and to take special care.
iMessage
2019-05 22:42:47 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I read about her - she is amazing !
Thank u .
How is Florida ?
iMessage
2019-05 22:42:47 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I read about her - she is amazing !
Thank u .
How is Florida ?
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-. 22:49:38 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Super sunny and calm
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-22:49:38 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Super sunny and calm
iMessage
[2] 2019-05. 22:49:57 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
What time do you finish work on Monday ? Do you know
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-22:49:57 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
What time do you finish work on Monday ? Do you know
iMessage
[2] 2019-05. 22:50:29 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
She s obviously Jewish
iMessage
[1] 2019-05. 22:50:29 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
She s obviously jewish
iMessage
[2] 2019-05. 22:52:M (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Her clients are the wealthiest families in New York and she is very kind
iMessage
[1] 2019-052 22:522 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Her clients are the wealthiest families in New York and she is very kind
iMessage
2019-05 23:12:55 UTC) [2
Sender: (
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Working till 2:00 on Monday
iMessage
2019-05 23:12:55 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Working till 2:00 on Monday
iMessage
2019-05-18 23:32:59 (UTC) 3
Sender: I 18j
Participants: MI I 18 ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Hey Jeffrey! Thank you so much for everything!! I'm finally settled. It was so helpful to
have Jojo and Leo with me and Lesley who was texting me also!
iMessage
2019-05-18 23:32:59 TiU
Sender: +21 18j .
Participants: 18 ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Hey Jeffrey! Thank you so much for everything!! I'm finally settled. It was so helpful to
have Jojo and Leo with me and Lesley who was texting me also!
iMessage
[3] 2019-05-19 01:46:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( gleeitunes&pail.com
Participants: 12 2.18 ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Great
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 01:46:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeituneoail.com
Participants: -FEMME 18 ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Great
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-19 02:00:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Don't forget to do your gratitude exercise before going to sleep
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 02:00:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Don't forget to do your gratitude exercise before going to sleep
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 10:11:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Did you go to church
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 10:11:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Did you go to church
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-19 11:00:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitune±..cor
Participants: Eduardo ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Lorenzo e medici is trying to start a crypto bank . Weird - want s to talk
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 11:00:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeeitunes&mail.cor±L
Participants: Eduardo ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Lorenzo e medici is trying to start a crypto bank . Weird - want s to talk
iMessage
2019-05-19 11:35:06 UTC 4
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Of course
iMessage
2019-05-19 11:35:06 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Of course
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:16: UTC 6
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin (
I'm going to Europe tomorrow
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:16: UTC
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin (
I'm going to Europe tomorrow
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:16:52 UTC 6
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Mathematics is ordered thought
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:16:52 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Mathematics is ordered thought
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-19 12:39:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
facetime?
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:39:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
facetime?
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 12:39:30 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Do you know when you are back?
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:39:30 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Do you know when you are back?
iMessage
[6] 2019-05-19 12:41:38 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes il.com )
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Illusion
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:41:38 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeeitune ail.com
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Illusion
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:47:40 UTC 4
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
31 May
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:47:40 (UTC) rii Sender: IlMn
Participants:
31 May
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 12:48:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
K
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:48:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
K
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 12:49:34 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I m on island 3-10 , 13 in New York with Davos pres. And then Paris
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:49:34 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I m on island 3-10 , 13 in New York with Davos pres. And then Paris
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:52:47 UTC 4
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Where r u now ??
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:52:47 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Where r u now ??
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 12:56:34 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Palm
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:56:34 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Palm
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 12:57:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Dc tues. wed ny thurs Santa Fe
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:57:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Dc tues. wed ny thurs Santa Fe
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-19 13:40:27 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
9
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 13:40:27 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
9
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:47:09 (UTC) [2]
Sender:
Participants:
Good morning
( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:47:09 UTC 1
Sender: (
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Good morning
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:47:30 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Just woke up - can we do it in 10-15 min ?
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:47:30 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Just woke up - can we do it in 10-15 min ?
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-19 13:47:49 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Of courses
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 13:47:49 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Of courses
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:47:55 UTC 6
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:47:55 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:47:55 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:48:06 (UTC) [61
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:48:06 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( jeeitunes@gma il.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 13:48:06 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:02:OR (111-C)1.41
Sender: ( =a m
Participants:
When are we making this film???
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:02:08 UTC) f1
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
When are we making this film???
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 14:02:53 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
when you make some time !
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 14:02:53 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
when you make some time !
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:04:32 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I'm on this 24/7---we already have the film preliminarily blocked out --- just need your
attorney to respond to dan
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:04:32 (11TC) ril Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I"m on this 24/7---we already have the film preliminarily blocked out --- just need your
attorney to respond to dan
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 14:05:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I have blocked out new area.s. beards. Genotypes phenotypes. Ties as bacteria
transmitters. . currencies and debt
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 14:05:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I have blocked out new area.s. beards. Genotypes phenotypes. Ties as bacteria
transmitters. . currencies and debt
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:06:39 (UTC') 141
Sender:
Participants:
We have massive amount of :
research to do; footage to pull ;
sme's too book;
participants to film; recreations to develop
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:06:39 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
We have massive amount of :
research to do; footage to pull ;
sme"s too book;
participants to film; recreations to develop
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 14:07:11 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I have some really great new documents that I found. , you won't believe it
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 14:07:11 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I have some really great new documents that I found. , you won't believe it
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:07:29 (UTC) r41
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Love all that-- film is getting deeper , better by the day ; everybody excited
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:07:29 UTC 1
Sender: (
Participants: ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Love all that-- film is getting deeper , better by the day ; everybody excited
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 14:14:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Woman lawyer. Saying prosecution not warranted. At all. She is former doj head of sex
crimes and no w judge on the fourth circuit court of appeals
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 14:14:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Woman lawyer. Saying prosecution not warranted. At all. She is former doj head of sex
crimes and no w judge on the fourth circuit court of appeals
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 14:14:31 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Not bad Jeffrey
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 14:14:31 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Not bad Jeffrey
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-19 14:14:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
now?
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 14:14:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
now?
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:15:02 (UT(') 121
Sender: (
Participants:
Perfect
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:15:02 UTC)11
Sender: (
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Perfect
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:15:20 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
But gonna be without make up - didn't have a time for that
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:15:20 (11TC) pi Sender:
Participants: ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
But gonna be without make up - didn't have a time for that
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:15:27 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants:
iMessage
2019-05-19
(
14:15:27 UTC 1
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:16:58 UTC 4
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Wat-- has that been decided nowt mil
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:16:58 UTC 1
Sender: )
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Wat-- has that been decided now w!
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 14:17:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
No it was an opinion that I found in the files. Fucking lawyers
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 14:17:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
No it was an opinion that I found in the files. Fucking lawyers
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:17:48 (UTC 7
Sender: Larry Summers (
Participants: Larry Summers ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Good. Will try to call today.
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:17:48 (UTC 1
Sender: Larry Summers (
Participants: Larry Summers ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Good. Will try to call today.
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:18:23 (IJTC) 4
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Why hasn't that been out EVERYWHERE!!!
iMessage
2019-05-19 14:18:23 (11TC)(11
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Why hasn"t that been out EVERYWHERE!!!
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 14:24:39 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I have two things to show you when you return
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 14:24:39 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I have two things to show you when you return
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 14:26:54 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I just emailed them
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 14:26:54 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I just emailed them
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-19 14:27:36 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Promise you will say. ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING
Notes
[1] Source
Device
[1] Source File /Users/jee/Library/Messages/chat.db
NYC024362.aff4/Macintosh HD
[2] Source
Device
[2] Source File
[3] Source
Device
[3] Source File
[4] Source
Device
[4] Source File
[5] Source
Device
[5] Source File
[6] Source
Device
[6] Source File
[I] Source
Device
I] Source File
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-05-201 on 2019-05-. at 10.50.
50.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-05-18/+. I MEM 18 on 2019-03-28 at 11.03.1
8.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-05-204 on 2019-05-18 at 10.37.
34.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-05-19/Eduardo on 2019-04-30 at 05.51.01.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-05-19/Martin on 2019-05-15 at 20.29.54.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-05-19/Larry Summers on 2019-05-16 at 19.20.48.i
chat
Case Data: Messages (29201-29300 of 32198) Case Data: Messages (29401-29500 of 32198)
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Julie K. Brown [journalist] blew the lid on the 2006 Epstein sweetheart deal 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00261990 (Jmail)
 [reputation] screenshots of Esptein's wikipedia
(date: 2019-06-01)
CH it- r> p RoST Tat() Ni 5/19/22, 3:52 PM
WIKIPEDIA
Jeffrey Epskin-WIldpedia
Jeffrey Epstein
Jeffrey Edward Epstein (I' apstiti  172-Steen; l January
20, 1953 — August io, 2019) was an American fi nancier and
convicted sex offender.(31/41 Epstein, who was born and raised
in Brooklyn, New  York Cif, began his professional life by teaching at the Dalton School in Manhattan, despite lacking a
college degree. After his dismissal from the school, he entered
the banking and finance sector, working at Bear Stearns in
various roles; he eventually started his own firm. Epstein
developed an elite social circle and procured many women and children; he and some of his associates then sexually 
abused them.1,5,11.46271
In 2005, police in Palm Beach, Florida, began investigating
Epstein after a parent complained that he had sexually abused
her 14-year-old daughter.ai Epstein pleaded guilty and was
convicted in 2008 by a Florida state court of procuring a child
for prostitution  and of soliciting a vrostitute.(51(21 He served
almost 13 months in custody, but with extensive work release.
He was convicted of only these two crimes as part of a
controversial plea deal; federal officials had identified 36 girls, some as young as 14 years old, whom Epstein had 
allegedly
sexually abused [Quo)
Epstein was arrested again on July 6, 2019, on federal charges
for the sex trafficking of minors in Florida and New
York-M(14J He died in his jail cell on August r.o, 2,319.M The
medical examiner ruled the death a suicide.M Epstein's
lawyers have disputed the ruling, and there has been
significant public skepticism about the true cause of his death,
resulting in numerous conspiracy theories 1'5)[161 Since
Epstein's death precluded the possibility of pursuing criminal
charges against him, a judge dismissed all criminal charges on
August 29, 2019.M( 181  Epstein had a decades-long association
with the British socialite  Ghi.slaine Maxwell,  leading to her
2021 convictionon U.S. federal charges of  sex trafficking and
conspiracy for helping him procure girls, including a 14 year -
old, for child sexual abuse and prostitution.i9X?_•0/ 21][22/
Epstein also maintained long-term relationships with various
high-profile individuals, including Donald Trump, Leslie
Wexner, Bill Clinton, Alan Dershowitz, and Prince Andrew,
Duke of Yortrag
Contents
Early llfe
Career
Jeffrey Epstein
Epstein's final mugshot, 2019
Born Jeffrey Edward
Epstein
January 20, 1953
New York City New
York, U.S.
Died August 10, 2019
(aged 66)
New York City, New
York, U.S.
Cause of Suicide by hanging
death (disputed)
I. J. Morris Star of
David Cemetery,
Palm Beach, Florida
Occupation Financier • broker •
educator • socialite
Title Owner of Jeffrey
Epsteig VI
Foundation
Procuring an
underage girl  for
prostitution; sex
trafficking
13 months with work
release (2008)
Pa rtner(s) Eva Andersson
(early 1980s)
Resting
place
I Criminal
Icharge
Penalty
5/19/22.3:52 PM ( 1/40 tjaZ 1C1 tdtekri - i Pet tCC 44Ci p(21, ay edfktiE ANZE; 199 3 - 02022
of the failed Bear Stearns hedge fund. Alan Dershowitz, one of Epstein's Florida attorneys on the case, told Fox 
Business Network "We would have been touting
that if he had [cooperated]. The idea that Epstein helped in any prosecution is news to me."[1][64][75]
Israeli startup
In 2015, the Israeli newspaper Haaretz reported that Epstein invested in the startup Reporty Homeland Security 
(rebranded as Carbyne in 2o18).[Zqn7-117?3 The
startup is connected with Israel's defense industry. It is headed by former Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak, who was 
also at one time the defense minister,
and chief of staff of the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF). The CEO of the company is Amir Elihai who was a special forces 
officer, and Pinchas Bukhris, who is a
director of the company, was at one time the defense ministry director general and commander of the IDF cyber unit 
8200.17.91 Epstein and Barak, the head of
Carbyne, were close, and Epstein often offered him lodging at one of his apartment units at 301 Fast 66th Street in 
Manhattan: 8°H" Epstein had past experience
with Israel's research and military sector.M In April zoo8, he went to Israel and met with a number of research 
scientists and visited different Israeli
military bases.($?] During this trip, he thought about staying in Israel in order to avoid trial, and possible jail, for
charges he was facing for sex crimes;
however, he opted to return to the United States.113-31
Video recordings
Epstein installed concealed cameras in numerous places on his properties to allegedly record sexual activity with 
underage girls by prominent people for
criminal purposes such as blackmail.(M Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein's close companion, told a friend that Epstein's 
private island in the Virgin Islands was
completely wired for video and the friend believed that Maxwell and Epstein were videotaping everyone on the island as 
an insurance policlz.(85.1 When police
raided his Palm Beach residence in 2006, two bidden pinhole cameras were discovered in his home.18&J It was also 
reported that Epstein's mansion in New York was
wired extensively with a video surveillance system.W-1
an artist who worked for Epstein in 1996, noted that Epstein showed her a media room in the New York mansion where there
were individuals monitoring the
pinhole cameras throughout the house. The media room was accessed through a hidden door. She stated that in the media 
mom "there were men sitting here. And I
looked on the cameras, and I saw toilet, toilet, bed, bed, toilet, bed." She added that "It was very obvious that they 
were, like, monitoring private moments."M
Epstein allegedly "lent" girls to powerful people to ingratiate himself  with them and also to gain possible blackmail 
information.1§9i According to the
Department of Justice, he kept compact discs locked in his safe in his New York mansion with handwritten labels that 
included the description:
"young [name] + [name]".[9c4 Epstein implied that he had blackmail material when he told a New York Times reporter in 
2018, off the record, that he had dirt on
powerful people, including
information about their sexual proclivities and recreational drug use.19A
Legal proceedings
First criminal case
Initial developments (2005-2006)
/
'ten
ing.66 -161) or- ocre  Mope- (.4_ 'skit; KF)Dir•115 5/19/22, 352 PM Jeffrey EPstein - Wikipedla
In March 2005, a woman contacted Florida's Palm Beach Police
Department and alleged that her 14-year-old stepdaughter had been
taken to Epstein's mansion by an older girl. While there, she was
allegedly paid $300 (equivalent to $42o in 2021) to strip and massage
Epstein.I] She had allegedly undressed, but left the encounter
wearing her underwear.1,931
Palm Beach Police began a 13-month undercover investigation of
Epstein, including a search of his home. x-41 During the
investigation, Palm Beach Police Chief Michael Reiter publicly
accused the Palm Beach County state prosecutor, Thaw Krischer, of
being too lenient and called for help from the FBI.(2?1
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) then became involved.
Subsequently, the police alleged that Epstein had paid several girls to
perform sexual-acts with him.I891 Interviews with five alleged victims and 17 witnesses under oath,
a high-school transcript and other items found in Epstein's trash and home allegedly showed that
some of the girls involved were under 18, the youngest being 14, with many under 16.L951[961 The
police search of Epstein's home found two hidden cameras and large numbers of photos of girls
throughout the house, some  of whom the police had interviewed in the course of their
investigation. (9-31 , a former model from Poland who became an Epstein assistant,
reportedly removed computer drives and other electronic equipment from the financier's Florida
mansion before Palm Beach Police searched the home as part of their investigationi271 The court
documents record that a search of Epstein's residence by Palm Beach Police detective Joseph
Recarey in 2005 uncovered an incriminating Amazon receipt containing books on S&M. The books
he ordered are titled: SM ioi: A Realistic Introduction, SlaveCraft: Roadmaps for Erotic
Servitude — Principles, Skills and Tools and Training with Miss Abernathy: A Workbook for
Erotic Slaves and Their Owners.[1
A former employee told the police that Epstein would receive massages three times a day.(93]
Eventually the FBI compiled reports on "34 confirmed minors" eligible for restitution (increased to
40 in the NPA) whose allegations of sexual abuse by Epstein included corroborating details.1291
Julie Brown's 2018 exposes in the Miami Herald  identified about 8o victims and located about 6o
of t1- 1W- nrri. 1 Th][1221 She quotes the then police chief Reiter as saying "This was 50-something 'shes'
and one 'he'—and the 'shes' all basically told the same story."W Details from the investigation
included allegations that 12-year-old triplets were flown in from France for Epstein's birthday, and
flown back the following day after being sexually abused by the financier. It was alleged that young
girls were recruited from Brazil and other South American countries, former Soviet countries, and
Europe, and that Jean-Luc Brunel's "MC2" modeling agency was also supplying girls to Enstein.i9slimillio21 4 jilvits CCC
- 0 peRce ctiez In1 14.1‘) >Nr- 1/4 fl
lt DO Ho N.JC
Ts)QGETED VI critst •
In May 2006, Palm Beach police filed a probable cause affidavit saying that Epstein should be
charged with four counts of unlawful sex with minors and one count of sexual abuse.f937f1osl pn
July 27, 2006, Epstein was arrested by the Palm Beach Police Department on state felony charges
of procuring a minor for prostitution  and solicitation of a prostitute. He was booked at the Palm
Beach County jail and Later released on a $3,000   State prosecutor Krischer
later convened a Palm Beach County grand jury, which was usually only done in capital cases.
Presented evidence from only two victims, the grand jury returned a single *iv of felony
solicitation of prostitution,1io61 to which Epstein pleaded not guilty in August 2oo6.0 71
Epstein's defense lawyers included Roy Black, Gerald Lefcourt, Harvard Law School professor
Alan Dershowitz, and former U.S. Solicitor General Ken Starr.192111°8] Linguist Steven Pinker also
assistedim 91
Epstein's 2006 mugshot
https://en.wikipedia.orgAviki/Jeffrey_EpMeln 8160
GOVERNMENT AND POLICE TARGETING CONNECTED TO EPSTEIN AND MAXWELL
JOHN OLSEN - KADINA - AUSTRALIAN GOVERNMENT
EPSTEIN AND MAXWELL RECRUITING MODELS FOR "SEX RING" INVOLVING PROMINENT
POSITIONS INCLUDING UNDER AGE GIRLS
MODELLING PROPOSAL - 14 YEARS OLD - KADINA - UNDER AGE MINOR - 1987
Targeted victim was approached b a ' a clothing store located in the Kadina district
while shopping with her mother, and asked if she would be interested in doing
modelling as a Kmart catalogue model in ma catalogues.
The targeted victim replied "I will have to ask my mother" , and proceeded to walk towards her
mother while the unknown woman waited for her to return.
The targeted victim approached her mother and informed her mother of what the woman had
proposed regarding becoming a model for Kmart catalogues.
The targeted victims mother informed her daughter, (targeted victim) that she
could not allow her daughter to do modelling due to nancia reasons and that she was raising a
family of four children and could not support her daughter by accompanying her to modelling
shoots, which would be necessary as she was a minor of 14 years of age.
The targeted victim returned to the woman who stood waiting for her and informed her that she
would have to decline the offer of doing modelling.
The woman smiled at the targeted victim before leaving the clothing store.
The woman was unknown to the targeted victim and was not sighted in the Kadina district again
following this incident by the targeted victim.
Witness :
Connection to targeted victim :  11 OThi e C
Signed :
Date :
5/1 , 3:52 PM P ULt  Ir /aCCTINC` kif"°1-)Eirils‘;W:111;lkipedla CAC le)
Bloom asserted that the woman had received threats. The suit was dropped on November 4, 2016.
Trump attorney Alan Garten denied the allegations, while Epstein declined to
comment. [156] [1-573[158][1593[16°]

v. Epstein and Maxwell (2017)
In  2017,   filed a suit against Epstein and Maxwell,
alleging t at Maxwell had hired her to give massages to Epstein and
later  threatened to physically harm her or destroy her career
prospects  if she did not comply with their sexual demands  at his
mansion in New York City and on his private Caribbean island, Little
Saint James. The suit was settled in 2018 under undisclosed terms.[161][20[162]
Bradley Edwards' defamation v. Epstein (2018)
A state civil lawsuit in Florida filed by attorney Bradley Edwards
against Epstein was scheduled for trial in December 2018. The trial
was expected to provide victims with their first opportunity to make
their accusations in public. However, the case was settled on the first
day of the trial, with Epstein publicly apologizing to Edwards; other
terms of the settlement were confidential.“.3t63]
Epstein was accused of sex
trafficking of minors at his
mansion at 9 East 71st
Street.

v. Epstein and Maxwell (2019)
-riwzre-0 Jtcs t-\ - FIRST  sausfac leoceiii.4 - 1ThcacC cnkeC  It ‘/R-5° W V44131&
On April 16, 2019, went public and filed a sworn affidavit in federal court in New
York, alleging that she and her 15-year-old sister, had been sexually assaulted by Epstein
and Maxwell in separate locations in 1996. met Epstein and Maxwell at her graduate art
gallery reception at the New York Academy of Art in 1995. The following year, in the summer of
1996, they hired her to work on an art project in Leslie Wexner's Ohio mansion, where she was
then sexually assaulted.Ei6q) Farmer reported the incident to the New York City Police Department
and the FBI.['65]
affidavit also stated that during the same summer, Epstein flew her then-15-year-old
sister to his New Mexico property where he and Maxwell sexually abused her on a massage
table J1661
v. Epstein and Maxwell (2019)
On July 22, 2019, while in jail awaiting trial, Epstein was served with a petition regarding a
pending state civil lawsuit filed by 1147-1 She stated that an associate for Epstein had
recruited her outside at age 14 and she was gradually groomed for
over a year  before Epstein raped her  in his New York City mansion when  she was 15.D68)IIM
filed her suit on August 14, 2019, when New York State law was updated to allow one year for adult
survivors of child sexual abuse to sue for previous offenses, regardless of how long ago the abuse
took placeP-491 In October 2019, amended her complaint to include over 20 corporate
entities associated with Epstein and named the additional individuals Lesley Groff and
as enablersJIM
Katlyn Doe, et at v. Epstein's estate (2019)
https://en.wilapedia.orgAviki/Jeffrey_Epsteln 13/60
.)7k- rot ce: c..,,,coe5L -re R,c, et) Nice - R3 or -  /'GE - H (n)GR 4---
oNDEA\ "66 se,Kon L sec ic- i ti c-7/9  Or A Pa tai - G &Fe
PRIMAL SOURCE - COMMENCEMENT OF GOVERNMENT TARGETING 1988 KADINA - 27 YEARS DOCUMENTED EVIDENCE - 1988 FIRST RECALLED 
EVENT OF DISTURBANCES IN THE HOME AND
UNUSUAL BEHAVIOUR IN THE TOWNSHIP
GOVERNMENT AND POLICE TARGETING OF AN INDIVIDUAL
1988 - Targeted victim 15 years of age, Kadina John Olsen, MP Kadina 1st event of disturbances in the home Connected to 
Australian EMF & RF Transmissions -
Parents family home Government and American Bedroom / night hours Government Exact location at the exact moment the 
targeted victim is in that location
(Government and Police Illegal Suryeillance of the targeted victim recorded since first incident of Intellectual 
Property Theft in 1993, from the Privacy of the
targeted victims own home, Willamulka SA)
4  % 1989 - Targeted victim 16 years of age, Kadina - Police - VVallaroo location 1st event of Police Sexual Targeting
Police sexual advances towards a 16 year old teenager
Exact location at the exact moment the targeted victim is in that location (Government and Police Illegal Surveillance 
of the targeted victim recorded since
first incident of Intellectual Property Theft in 1993, from the Privacy of the targeted victims own home, Willamulka SA)
1991 - Targeted victim 19 years of age, Moonta - Police - Moonta location PTSD as a result of Severe Extreme Domestic
Domestic violence and entrapment of the victim
Police officer as a witness of targeted victim
Entrapped and at knife point while entrapped
Perpetrator was not charged by the police officer who
• Witnessed the attack of the victim and pulled her out
of a front window of the domestic home
Perpetrator of Prominent local family - Home roofing business, Moonta and House boats
at Renmark - McGinley
1993 - Targeted victim 22 years of age, Willamulka SA - American Government
Targeted victim engaged to be married, given birth American Academy
To twin sons
First recorded event of Intellectual Property Theft
In the Privacy of her own home and in the American
Governments possession - Infant sleep Positioner
Exact location at the exact moment the targeted victim is in that location (Government and Police Illegal Surveillance 
of the targeted victim recorded since
first incident of Intellectual Property Theft in 1993, from the Privacy of the targeted victims own home. Willamulka
5/19/22.3:52 pm 1943 fl kST EUEni TNICti-691121 : h pedIVERTy TH
girlfriend" who also handled the hiring, supervising, and firing of staff starting around-1/2992, In
1995, Epstein renamed one of his companies the Ghislaine Corporation in Palm Beach, Florida;
the company was dissolved in 1998.[1651 In 2OOO, Maxwell moved into a 7,000-square-foot
townhouse, less than to blocks from Epstein's New York mansion. This townhome was purchased
for $4.95 million by an anonymous limited liability company, with an address that matches the
office of J. Epstein & Co. Representing the buyer was Darren Indyke, Epstein's longtime
lawyer. Ki In a 2003 Vanity Fair expose,  Epstein refers to Maxwell as "my best friend"  Dia
Epstein was a longtime acquaintance of Prince Andrew and Tom Barrack, 2101 and attended
parties with many prominent people, including BM Clinton, George Stephanopoulos, Donald
Trump, al Katie Couric, Woody Allen, 212 and Harvey Weinstein.1 - His contacts included
Rupert  Murdoch, Michael Bloomberg, Richard Branson, Michael Jackson, Alec Baldwin and the
Kennedys.l2141 His contacts also included Israeli prime minister Ehud Barak, British prime
minister.Tony Blair, and Saudi Arabian crown prince Mohammed bin Salman.r2-15][216][211 Both
Clintoni2181 and Trump 21  claimed that they never visited Epstein's island.
Epstein owned a private Boeing 72/ jet and traveled in it frequently, logging "600 flying hours a
year ... usually with guests on board". 22°  The jet was nicknamed the Loli.ta Express by the locals
in the Virgin Islands, because of its frequent arrivals at Little Saint James with apparently
underage girls. 1 In 2003, Epstein flew to Cuba aboard his plane with Colombian president
Andres Pastrana Arango at the invitation of Cuban president Fidel Castro. According to Fabiola
Santiago of the Miami Herald,  Epstein was likely considering relocating to Cuba in order to escape
U.S. law enforcement; Epstein was under investigation from U.S. law enforcement at the time. 222
In 2009, Epstein's brother Mark claimed Trump had flown on Epstein's plane at least once. He
later told The Washington Post that Trump flew "numerous times" on Epstein's airplane, although
Mark was present on only one of the flights.f22312241 According to Michael Corcoran, Trump flew
Epstein on his own airplane at least once.1225) In September 2002, Epstein flew Clinton, Kevin
Spacey, and Chris Tucker to Africa in this jet.132X226X2271 Flight records obtained in 2016 show Bill
Clinton flew 27 times to at least a dozen international locationsPS Flight logs did not list any
Secret Service detail for at least five flights, on an Asia trip, 228 and Secret Service stated that
there is no evidence of the former president making a trip to Epstein's private island. 2281 In 2019,
a Clinton spokesperson stated that, in 2002 and 2003, Clinton took four trips on Epstein's
airplane, making stops on three continents, all with his staff and Secret Service detail.l~~91 At the
time of Epstein's 2019 arrest, Clinton's spokeswoman Angel Ureiia stated that Clinton had "not
spoken to Epstein in well over a decade, and has never been to Little St. James Island, Epstein's
ranch in New Mexico, or his residence in Florida.423°1
In a profile of Epstein in New York magazine in 2002, former
Democratic Senate leader George J. Mitchell said of Epstein, "I
would certainly call him a friend and a supporter". In the same
article, Donald Trump remarked, "I've known Jeff for fifteen
years. Terrific guy. He's a lot of fun to be with. It is even said
that he likes beautiful women as much as I do, and many of
them are on the younger side. No doubt about it — Jeffrey
enjoys his social life "(2311 In July 2019, Trump said "I knew
him like everybody in Palm Beach knew him," stating four
times he had not been "a fan" of Epstein and that he had not
spoken to him in about fifteen years. A video shot in 1992
surfaced showing the two men partying together at Mar-a-
I ago (232)(233](2341(235] By 2007, Trump reportedly banned
Epstein from his Mar-a-Lago dub for unseemly pursuit of young females.1236][23711238][2391 The
ban allegation was included in court documents filed by attorney Bradley Edwards,1-421 although
Edwards later said it was a rumor he tried to, but could not, confirm [2411(2421
President Trump states "I knew him
like everybody in Palm Beach knew
him." July 2019 video from the
White House.
htlps://en.wIcipedia.org/wIld/Jeffrey_Epstein 17160
-1- 614 c.- coNiceKS .s1315IRCIC*
*TFIRCe..TE7 VICTi M TAKCCTED cry Li N1E, - MAk 2CCL .PC) 13 4:
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ruslana Korshunova [russian girl] Russian model who visited Epstein's island before falling to her death in 2008 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00785575 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2019-06-04 16:51:39)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024362.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024362.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case
Data:
Messages
(31501-
31600 of
32198)
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-03 22:33:07 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-03 22:36:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitunes ail.com
Participants: (
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Mandatory minimum 15
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Do you take contraception pills . If not you should, it will get rid of the cysts
iMessage
2019-06-03 22:37:41 (UTC) 121
Sender:
Participants:
MBZ must have coughed him up
iMessage
2019-06-03 22:37:41 UTC)111
Sender:
Participants:
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
MBZ must have coughed him up
iMessage
[2] 2019-06-03 22:38:24 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Nope
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-03 22:38:24 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Nope
iMessage
2019-06-03 23:47:21 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I am not using any of the pills for the last 3 years . Cause I was so worry about my red
spot on my face ( the same as yours ) and I was sure that it's cause I am allergic to
something - so I decided not to take any of them + I didn't have a regular sexual life and
non- of gynecologist recommend it
iMessage
2019-06-03 23:49:52 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
And if I decide to take them - I feel like it shouldn't be random pills ! Doctor should see
my blood test - and chose right one for me ( cause if it's not right now girl might have
problems with her skin, over weight, emotional unstable - and obviously I don't want that
iMessage
[3] 2019-06-04 00:14:07 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Agreed- 1 . You are already emotional! 2 the newer pills have much less side effects. My
doctor that reviewed your cyst report said she would try . No surgery!! We can FaceTime
tomorrow or whenever convenient. I also will explain insurance
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 00:14:07 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Agreed- 1 . You are already emotional! 2 the newer pills have much less side effects. My
doctor that reviewed your cyst report said she would try . No surgery!! We can FaceTime
tomorrow or whenever convenient. I also will explain insurance
iMessage
2019-06-04 00:58:10 (I IT(')1•41
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I could do FaceTime tmr in the evening :what time is more comfortable for u ?
U gave me a big HOPE about my surgery situation !
Thank u .
iMessage
2019-06-04 00:58:10 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I could do FaceTime tmr in the evening :what time is more comfortable for u ?
U gave me a big HOPE about my surgery situation !
Thank u .
iMessage
[4] 2019-06-04 02:21:28 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
It is not hope. It is fact. And you can rest easy . Trying to make decisions re pills , surgery ,
health when you know so little is not smart.. sorry . You are going to drive yourself crazy
. Tomorrow might work. Or wed. Your call. Sleep well you deserve it . No worry promise
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 02:21:28 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
It is not hope. It is fact. And you can rest easy . Trying to make decisions re pills , surgery ,
health when you know so little is not smart.. sorry . You are going to drive yourself crazy
. Tomorrow might work. Or wed. Your call. Sleep well you deserve it . No worry promise
iMessage
2019-06-04 06:38:38 UTC 5
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
I'm it Florence at Peter's meeting. Back in the US on Friday.
iMessage
2019-06-04 06:38:38 (I1TC) (11
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I'm it Florence at Peter's meeting. Back in the US on Friday.
iMessage
2019-06-04 06:39:36 UTC 5
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
Gloria is visiting me in Concord over the weekend. She is leaving on Monday 10 June.
iMessage
2019-06-04 06:39:36 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Gloria is visiting me in Concord over the weekend. She is leaving on Monday 10 June.
iMessage
[5] 2019-06-04 10:18:47 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes il.com )
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
If Peter is there you can tell him we are friends
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 10:18:47 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( jeeittme ail.com
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
If Peter is there you can tell him we are friends
iMessage
2019-06-04 10:20:21 UTC 5
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
Yes. Sure. I also talked to Berlinsky this morning. He visited you in Paris.
iMessage
2019-06-04 10:20:21 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Yes. Sure. I also talked to Berlinsky this morning. He visited you in Paris.
iMessage
2019-06-04 10:21:08 UTC 5
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( cieeitunes@gmail.com )
Amazing morning session
iMessage
2019-06-04 10:21:08 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Amazing morning session
iMessage
2019-06-04 10:21:37 (UTC) [51
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self ( cieeitunes@gmail.com )
Newton, Galileo, Einstein, Lemaitre, God
iMessage
2019-06-04 10:21:37 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Newton, Galileo, Einstein, Lemaitre, God
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 10:40:43 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Please research , if you don't know already. Rusalana. K...
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 10:40:43 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Please research , if you don't know already. Rusalana. K...
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 10:40:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self eeeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 10:40:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 10:40:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 10:40:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: (
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 10:44:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: (
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruslana_Korshunova
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ruslana_Korshunova
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Korshunova's most telling message came in March 2008: "I'm so lost. Will I ever find
myself?".[12]
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 10:44:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Korshunova"s most telling message came in March 2008: "I"m so lost. Will I ever find
myself?".[12]
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 10:44:58 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes mail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Then she jumped from a windoq
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 10:44:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Then she jumped from a windoq
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 10:45:06 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Window and committed suicide
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 10:45:06 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Window and committed suicide
iMessage
2019-06-04 12:03:27 (UTC) m
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
How did he get extradited ?-- could have stayed in UAE forever
iMessage
2019-06-04 12:03:27 UTC 1
Sender: (
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
How did he get extradited ?-- could have stayed in UAE forever
iMessage
2019-06-04 12:23:12 UTC 6
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I heard about her : it was a lot of tv program about her by the time it's happened .
Why did u decide to send it to me ?
iMessage
2019-06-04 12:23:12 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I heard about her : it was a lot of tv program about her by the time it's happened .
Why did u decide to send it to me ?
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 12:28:18 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I knew her very well. She drove herself crazy . Worrying and took her own advice and of
her boyfriend. That knew little as well. She went to doctor after doctor. Anxiety and bad
answers. Had a very bad ending. She was great. Smart but so lost and confused and
worried . It was easy to have been another ending. But she didn't have a father and no one
was strong with her .
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 12:28:18 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I knew her very well. She drove herself crazy . Worrying and took her own advice and of
her boyfriend. That knew little as well. She went to doctor after doctor. Anxiety and bad
answers. Had a very bad ending. She was great. Smart but so lost and confused and
worried . It was easy to have been another ending. But she didn't have a father and no one
was strong with her .
iMessage
[7] 2019-06-04 12:28:51 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
He was not extradited .
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 12:28:51 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
He was not extradited .
iMessage
[7] 2019-06-04 12:29:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
He was duped
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 12:29:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
He was duped
iMessage
2019-06-04 12:41:45 UTC) [7
Sender: (
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
WTF
iMessage
2019-06-04 12:41:45 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
WTF
iMessage
[7] 2019-06-04 12:45:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
There is his bail hearing today. Doesn't look good. Pre trial detention . Currently in
Brooklyn
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 12:45:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
There is his bail hearing today. Doesn't look good. Pre trial detention . Currently in
Brooklyn
iMessage
[7] 2019-06-04 12:46:27 (UTC)
Sender: Self mates
Participants: (
Can you imagine. He actually , literally
true---!!!
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
, had pictures of some kid fucking a goat. .
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 12:46:27 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Can you imagine. He actually , literally , had pictures of some kid fucking a goat. .
true—!!!
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 13:29:00 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Each time she went to a doctor they told her something a little different.. her boyfriend
was afraid she would gain weight and not be able to earn money. It was horrible. Her mind
drove her to throw herself out of the window.
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 13:29:00 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Each time she went to a doctor they told her something a little different.. her boyfriend
was afraid she would gain weight and not be able to earn money. It was horrible. Her mind
drove her to throw herself out of the window.
iMessage
2019-06-04 13:46:04 UTC) 7
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
He just came into the country!!
iMessage
2019-06-04 13:46:04 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
He just came into the country!!
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 14:00:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
So when I hear from you. I might not want to take medicine to fix my cysts. Because it
might make my skin bad . I get worried
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 14:00:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
So when I hear from you. I might not want to take medicine to fix my cysts. Because it
might make my skin bad . I get worried
iMessage
2019-06-04 14:21:10 UTC 6
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
No, Jeffrey - i didn't mean that I will not take medicine to fix my cyst ! I would love to
have a medicine which can fix my cyst - no one told me that it is a medicine which can fix
it , we talk about contraceptive pills - and the reason why I didn't take them it's cause I
don't have a regular partner , so why should I ?
iMessage
2019-06-04 14:21:10 UTC 1
Sender: (
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
No, Jeffrey - i didn't mean that I will not take medicine to fix my cyst ! I would love to
have a medicine which can fix my cyst - no one told me that it is a medicine which can fix
it , we talk about contraceptive pills - and the reason why I didn't take them it's cause I
don't have a regular partner , so why should I ?
iMessage
2019-06-04 14:21:34 UTC 7
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Any update on our cast???
iMessage
2019-06-04 14:21:34 UTC) 1
Sender: (
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Any update on our cast???
iMessage
[7] 2019-06-04 14:50:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Government wants to consider timing and how to control press
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 14:50:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Government wants to consider timing and how to control press
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 14:51:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Health
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 14:51:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Health
iMessage
2019-06-04 15:11:43 (UTC) [71 Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Fine : but we have a cast we can film sometime late summer / sept???
iMessage
2019-06-04 15:11:43 (UTC) 1
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Fine : but we have a cast we can film sometime late summer / sept???
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 16:09:23 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Contraceptive pills chosen correctly will most likely fix everything. Going to doctors for
okder women is not what you need. I spoke to three gyno. And each suggest contraception
hormone etc
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 16:09:23 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Contraceptive pills chosen correctly will mo
okder women is not what you need. I spoke
hormone etc
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:09:26 UTC 6
Sender:
Participants: ( ),
Jeffrey, also if u are have a time during next
tmr - what will work for u
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:09:26 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ),
Jeffrey, also if u are have a time during next
tmr - what will work for u
st likely fix everything. Going to doctors for
to three gyno. And each suggest contraception
Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
few hours i could talk or at the evening , or
Self ( jeeitunes@gmail.com )
few hours i could talk or at the evening , or
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:10:05 UTC 6
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Non one of the doctors I saw suggest it to me ( even Dr.Shifrin )
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:10:05 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Non one of the doctors I saw suggest it to me ( even Dr.Shifrin )
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 16:12:26 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
Simple answer but they don't make money:).
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 16:12:26 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Simple answer but they don't make money:).
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 16:12:53 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Ill by in 40 minutes to FaceTime
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 16:12:53 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Ill try in 40 minutes to FaceTime
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:13:06 UTC 6
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Ok
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:13:06 UTC I]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Ok
iMessage
[7] 2019-06-04 16:15:54 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:'eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Government sensitive to exploitation
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 16:15:54 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Government sensitive to exploitation
iMessage
[7] 2019-06-04 16:16:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
But probably yes
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 16:16:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
But probably yes
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:17:09 (I ITC) 171
Sender:
Participants:
Exploitation!!!!
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:17:09 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Exploitation!!!!
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:25:11 UTC 8
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I never heard from Kathy Rummler.
SMS
2019-06-04 16:25:11 (UTC) [11 =lSender: I aParticipants:
I never heard from Kathy Rummler.
), Self
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:26:03 (UTC) [9]
Sender: Eva (
Participants: Eva ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
On my flight !
Thank you s00000000 much for my IPad and headphones
iMessage
2019-06-04 16:26:03 UTC 1]
Sender: Eva (
Participants: Eva ( ), Self (jeeitunes®gmail.com )
On my flight !
Thank you s00000000 much for my I Pad and headphones
iMessage
[8] 2019-06-04 16:30:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
In couy
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 16:30:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
In couy
iMessage
[8] 2019-06-04 16:30:46 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Courts
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 16:30:46 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self (jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Courts
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 16:50:54 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Medical treatments for ovarian cysts include:
Hormonal birth control pills to regulate the hormones and reduce the risk of developing
more cysts.
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 16:50:54 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Medical treatments for ovarian cysts include:
Hormonal birth control pills to regulate the hormones and reduce the risk of developing
more cysts.
iMessage
[6] 2019-06-04 16:51:39 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes il.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
The vaccination series can be started at age 9 years. Teen boys and girls who did not get
vaccinated when they were younger should get it now. HPV vaccine is recommended for
young women through age 26, and young men through age 21.
iMessage
[1] 2019-06-04 16:51:39 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
The vaccination series can be started at age 9 years. Teen boys and girls who did not get
vaccinated when they were younger should get it now. HPV vaccine is recommended for
young women through age 26, and young men through age 21.
Notes
[1] Source
Device
[1] Source File
[2] Source
Device
[2] Source File
[3] Source
Device
[3] Source File
[4] Source
Device
[4] Source File
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/chat.db
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-06-03
13.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-06-03
42.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-06-03
10.ichat
on 2019-06-03 at 18.13.
on 2019-05-29 at 06.28.
on 2019-06-03 at 20.58.
[5] Source
Device
[5] Source File
[6] Source
Device
[6] Source File
[7] Source
Device
[7] Source File
[8] Source
Device
[8] Source File
[9] Source
Device
[9] Source File
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-06-04/Martin on 2019-05-22 at 05.17.09.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-06-04 on 2019-06-04 at 06.40.
43.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-06-04 on 2019-06-03 at 18.38.
24.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-06-04 on 2019-06-02 at 11.03.
07.ichat
NYCO24362.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/20 I 9-06-04/Eva on 2019-05-31 at 23.13.13.ichat
Case Data: Messages (31401-31500 of 32198) Case Data: Messages (31601-31700 of 32198)
EFTA00005818 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-06-06)
(MA nAml-h?LQ n wex-e
r a k -v.
+I 'col

╭───── Page 1, Image 1 ──────╮
│ _                          │
│ (ned multe le eS Nore were │
│ “yee Pv hiv                │
│                            │
│ #1501 4                    │
╰────────────────────────────╯

CAM a
l()s
wN avik
IBC, eh~c/c 7Z O A -a,c 07 41cet
".\,),92 t/Th " 7-74111/41 -* 449`,./ dc/c/Ce.r.retif
-0 1}1(12
Reitfk) crratti.9 47 //1/20k

╭──── Page 2, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

eJusticeN Y Integrated Justice Portal Page I et
eJusticeNY. INTEGRATED JUSTICE PORTAL
people • DMV Photo System • DMV Photo Reouest 1+: Feedback
liDMV Photo Request eol
DMV Photo
Subject
lientiD:
ase Number:
Information
1182350 MV - ransaction Number:
MV Transaction Date/Time:
Back
About Site Map s.t,,
31ENY3027175
2019-06-06 15:08:20:577
June 6, 2019 3:08 PM EDT
https://www.ejustice.ny.gov/svps/myponalAut/p/a1/111bd6IwFIV_Sx98,pelGB7BC4M3H... 6/6/2019
eJusticeNY Integrated Justice Portal Page 1 of I
eJusticeNVOiliLIWID . lists( F-orrt
it] ewe • DrieImo itereete• Licassathea Fee l/Ma
'Drivers License
Inquiry
Results
Sarin CrIterN Mint ID (COD
laLl-Drixen Rabe: VALID (Non-CDI4
Alsem an men 'cis radon: 07/21/2025
Mese: Client ID:
Nile Deis
Addrees:
- '31
ie MP. dye CottlIKIROVIts License Otte!
County: QUEENS
OttlA New York 11106
Donn fxdfdanniCal
NYS Parole NO he
NYS Probation NO hit
NYS Order of No hit Protection
NYS / NCI('
Perterk (NAM1 NYS Person Response
No hit
NCIC Person Response
No hit
Transaction ID: 3ocW763.88te•11e94MBD-202020202511
Abort Sa Mee Sra noncan
DMV Drivers License
Larch Criteria: Client ID (OW:
Submitted: 06/0612019 03:06 PM
Statue: VALID (non-coL;
License Cleric 'ration: 07/71/202S
Mans: Client ID:
Birth Date: Female NSF. Lye Color: EaCe,
Address; County: QUOINS
ASTDRIA •
Motorist ID:
New ark 111
Image Captured: 13/11/2012 (KEPT)
Activity Informatbn
School Sue Driver Siam (118A)4 NOT APMSCASLII
T'ensaction IDI 3000363-SiMie-11•1.460-2020202on::
hups://www.ejustice.ny.gov/wps/myportalflut/p/a1/17-11315owFIV_yrAmhylYngELzRvUH... 6/6/2019
EFTA02731039 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ memo about prosecution memo naming Lesley Groff
(inferred date: 2019-06-11)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
Prosecution Memorandum
Privileged and Confidential — Attorney Work Product
Do Not Disseminate Outside of the SDNY USAO
USAO #: United States v. Epstein, 19 Cr. ( ) June 11, 2019
This memorandum seeks authorization to charge JEFFREY EPSTEIN with one count
of sex trafficking of children and one count of conspiracy to commit sex trafficking of children.
These charges arise from a years-long scheme to recruit and entice minor girls into engaging in
commercial sex acts, specifically sexualized massages and related sexual activity in exchange for
money, in locations including Manhattan and Palm Beach, Florida. The proposed indictment is
attached hereto, and this memorandum is submitted to provide additional factual background and
relevant legal analysis.
1. Overview
The Scheme
For a period of years, from at least 2002 through approximately 2005, Epstein engaged
in a pattern of enticing minor girls to engage in paid sex acts.' This conduct was in part revealed
through a previous federal investigation into Epstein by the U.S. Attorney's Office and FBI in the
Southern District of Florida ("SDFL"), which resulted in a 2007 non-prosecution agreement,2 and
was further investigated and revealed thorough our investigation, which began in late 2018.
As detailed below, the SDNY is not bound by the SDFL non-prosecution agreement; moreover,
while our investigation and charges cover some conduct and victims initially identified by the
SDFL investigation, our charges also include conduct and victims who were not interviewed
during that prior investigation, including individuals who were victimized solely in New York.
Based on our review of interview reports from the historical case file and from victim interviews
in media, we have reason to believe that Epstein's conduct traces back at least to the 1990s.
However, because the victims we have interviewed were not abused during that time
we have not focused on that pen
2 Epstein's conduct became the subject of an investigation by the Palm Beach Police Department,
and then the FBI, in approximately 2005, after the parents of a victim reported to law enforcement
that Epstein had abused their daughter. Those investigations spanned approximately two years
and included, among other things, interviews with approximately 35 victims; a search warrant
executed on Epstein's Florida residence; and detailed analysis of various phone and flight records.
As detailed below, the terms of the 2007 non-prosecution agreement required Epstein to plead
guilty in Florida state court to soliciting prostitution, which he did in 2008. He was sentenced to
18 months in jail, was permitted to serve his sentence in a facility where he was released during
the day to work, and was released from his sentence after serving approximately 13 months.
Page 2
In both Florida and New York, the scheme operated in a nearly identical fashion:
Epstein essentially operated a pyramid scheme of sexual exploitation, victimizing minor girls who
were brought to his homes to give Epstein erotic "massages," in exchange for hundreds of dollars,
and then paying those individuals to recruit additional minor victims. Once the victims were alone
with Epstein, the "massages" became increasingly sexual. The identified victims ranged from
approximately 14 to 17 years old when their abuse began, with the majority having been
approximately 15 or 16 when they were recruited to perform sex acts with Epstein. Epstein's
conduct included masturbating in front of victims; fondling their breasts; placing a vibrator on
their genitals; and/or directly touching their genitals. Some victims also continued to engage in
such acts with Epstein after they were no longer minors. Victims and recruiters in New York and
Florida generally were paid $300 and $200 per visit, respectively. The victims were typically paid
by Epstein or his employees in cash, in hundred dollar bills.
After their first visit to Epstein's residences, victims in New York and Florida usually
were contacted via telephone by individuals who worked for Epstein to arrange additional
massages. In New York, one of those individuals was Leslie Groff, one of Epstein's assistants; in
Florida, the primary contact for the girls was who was Epstein's employee and often
accompanied him on travel, including to ew or everal victims reported that when they
arrived at the Florida residence for massage appointments, was present at the house and
escorted them to the massage room to meet Epstein.
In order to maintain a steady stream of underage girls to perform sexual acts, Epstein
also directed others, including some of his victims, to recruit other minor girls to engage in
sexualized massages. Some victims brought just one or two friends, while others become prolific
recruiters, bringing Epstein dozens of other girls. Epstein and his employees, including
typically paid the recruiters hundreds of dollars for each girl they brought to Epstein's resi ences.
The SDNY investigation has focused principally on conduct occurring in New York or
with connections to New York, although, as detailed herein, through our review of information
gathered through the prior investigation we have also developed considerable familiarity with—
and plan to charge—conduct that occurred in Florida.
Epstein Background
Epstein has had significant connections to New York City for many years. According
to press reporting over the past approximately 20 years, he owns what is reportedly the largest
private residence in Manhattan, on East 71st street, and his professional career was initially
centered in New York. He was raised in Coney Island, and he taught calculus and physics at the
Dalton School after dropping out of Cooper Union. From Dalton, he was hired at Bear Stems,
where he worked from approximately 1976 to 1981 before reportedly starting his own wealth
management business. The source of his reportedly-vast wealth is opaque; most concretely, he
has worked closely with multi-billionaire Leslie Wexner, founder of the Limited chain of women's
clothing stores, who also either gave or sold Epstein the Manhattan mansion. In the 1990s and
2000s, Epstein apparently managed money, engaged in various philanthropy, and was briefly more
publicly known for providing use of his aircraft to—and accompanying—Bill Clinton, Kevin
Spacey, and Chris Tucker for a philanthropic trip to Africa. Since the Florida investigations, he
has maintained a lower profile, residing primarily on his private island in the U.S. Virgin Islands.
Page 3
II. Victim Interviews and Corroborating Evidence
New York and Victim-I
Epstein spent significant time in Manhattan during the relevant period. As described
by at least one individual who was victimized in—and, as discussed further below, recruited other
minor victims in—New York City ("Victim-1"), Epstein victimized at least dozens of girls in New
York, in addition to the dozens of girls he victimized in Florida.
In particular, we have met with Victim-1, who has been cooperative with the
investigation and is represented by counsel. In several proffers, Victim-1 has described how she
was recruited to engage in sexual contact with Epstein in approximately 2002, at the age of
approximately 14. While at a New York City club, Victim-1 met another teenager who described
having worked for a rich man, giving topless massages—and recruiting other girls to do the same—
and invited Victim-1 to make money this way. At the time, Victim-1 was living by herself and
supporting herself financially, having moved away from a difficult home life. As further detailed
below, Victim-1 ultimately visited Epstein's Manhattan mansion to engage in sexual massages and
other sex acts at least dozens of times between approximately 2002 and 2005.
During her visits to the mansion, Victim-1 performed erotic massages on Epstein,
including being partially or fully nude while she massaged him. Most or all of the massages
performed by Victim-1 would end with Epstein masturbating and ejaculating; during some of the
massages, Epstein touched the genitals of Victim-1 with his hand or with a vibrator or sex toy. He
also commonly asked Victim-1 to pinch or twist his nipples. Epstein ordinarily paid Victim-1
$300 in cash after a massage was completed. All of these interactions with Epstein occurred while
Victim-1 was a minor, including times when Epstein touched her genitals.
After Victim-I's initial meetings with Epstein, he asked her, in sum and substance, to
recruit other girls for the same activity. Over approximately two years, Victim-1 estimates that
she brought dozens of girls to Epstein to provide massages, starting with girls she knew from her
community and eventually strangers whom Victim-1 met at bars, clubs, or other locations.
Victim-1 would describe to the girls what was expected, i.e., that they would provide erotic
massages to Epstein, while nude, and that Epstein might touch them or ask them to touch him.
Victim-1 would schedule appointments for the girls by phone with Epstein's assistant, "Leslie."
Based on the investigation, we have identified "Leslie" as Leslie Groff.
Each time Victim-1 brought a girl to Epstein, Victim-1 was paid $300, and the other
girl also would receive $300, always in cash. Victim-1 states that Epstein knew that she was under
the age of 18, and that he knew other girls she brought were under 18. In particular, Victim-1
recalls Epstein having asked her how old she was and her truthfully telling Epstein that she was
14 years old. After Victim-1 brought a girl to Epstein, he would sometimes either tell Victim-1 to
bring the girl again, if he liked her, or tell Victim-1 not to bring the girl again. Victim-1 noticed
that the girls Epstein liked were generally younger and more petite. Epstein would tell Victim-1:
"you know what I like," which she took to mean underage, petite girls. Epstein would occasionally
indicate his displeasure with Victim-1 for bringing a particular girl, including expressing to
Victim-1 that he did not like dark-skinned girls. Later on, as Victim-1 grew older and knew fewer
young girls to bring, she brought older girls, which Epstein expressed displeasure about. Victim-1
recalls at least one occasion when she saw a girl show Epstein an ID to prove she was under 18.
Page 4
Corroboration of Victim-1
Corroboration of Victim-I's account exists through contemporaneous records, as well
as through other victims we have already approached. We also expect to develop additional
corroboration through interviews of victims we plan as well as likely through additional victims
we expect to approach immediately after the investigation is overt, i.e., after charging.
In our review of the evidence from the initial investigation, we have identified a written
phone message that was obtained from a trash pull from Epstein's Florida residence. The message
is from a 646 area code, and the person listed is Victim-I's first name, Victim-1
does not recognize the phone number, and has told us she cycled throug manydifferent phones
when she was a teenager, but contemporaneous phone records of an associate of Victim-1 reflect
tolls with the 646 number, which strongly suggests the 646 number was being used by Victim-1.
With respect to corroborating witnesses, two individuals who were introduced to
Epstein by Victim-1 and were paid by Epstein to perform erotic massages ("Individual-1" and
"Individual-2," respectively) were interviewed in connection with the prior Florida investigations.
In those interviews, Individual-1 stated that when she was approximately 18, she met Victim-1
(known to her only by first name) through a mutual friend. Victim-1 told Individual-1 she knew
a man named Jeffrey who would pay girls $300 for massages. Victim-1 made an appointment for
Individual-1 to go to Epstein's house, which she did. After Individual-1 was brought to Epstein's
massage room, he asked her to strip down to her underwear and massage him; Individual-1 agreed
only to strip down to a shirt and underwear. Individual-1 massaged Epstein's back for
approximately 20 minutes before Epstein got off the table, handed her $300, and told her he did
not want her to massage him again, because she reminded him of his niece, and that he wanted her
to bring him other girls instead. Individual-1 recalls that later she and Victim-1 brought
Individual-2 to Epstein's house to perform a massage. Individual-1 recalled bringing Individual-2
approximately two additional times, and recalled receiving calls from "Leslie" regarding
scheduling. Individual-2 generally confirmed this account, telling FBI agents that during massages
with Epstein she removed her clothes and he masturbated in front of her. She said Epstein
attempted to use a vibrator on her, but she refused. Individual-2 confirmed that Victim-1 (known
to her only by first name) and Individual-1 had recruited her to give massages to Epstein.
The case agents in our investigation have approached Individual-1 and Individual-2,
both of whom preferred not to speak to law enforcement at this time and emphasized that they
believed they were 18 years old during the relevant time period. However, while they would not
be considered statutory victims given their age at the time, if called to testify they could corroborate
that Victim-1 worked as a recruiter for Epstein as a minor. To our knowledge, Victim-1 has not
spoken to Individual-1 or Individual-2 in the many years since they each interacted with Epstein.
Victim-I also has described Epstein's Upper East Side residence in great detail,
including describing the artwork in the massage room, a stuffed dog in the living room, and a
library that she compared to the one in "Beauty and the Beast." It would be extraordinarily unlikely
that Victim-1 could describe these aspects of the residence in such detail if she had not spent
significant time there. Finally, the account from Victim-1 is nearly identical to that of another
victim who became a recruiter for Epstein in Florida ("Victim-2"), with whom Victim-1 has had
no contact or communications. Victim-2 is further described below.
Page 5
Finally. Victim-1 also has identified several other girls she recruited, including at least
one who was a victim and recruiter. We intend to approach additional such victims when the case
is overt, after charging. One of those victims has agreed to speak with us, but we are unlikely to
be able to meet with her for several weeks because she is about to give birth.
he has met with us for live lengthy interviews, during wlnc
s e as provided detai e m ormation
Florida Victims
We have also met with and interviewed two primary Florida-based victims, each of
whom has described a generally similar course of abuse. In speaking with them we have focused
on individuals who we believe, based on their own accounts and/or phone records, were contacted
by co-conspirators located in New York in connection with their abuse, i.e., to schedule massages.
Victim-2
Victim-2 was recruited to be a victim when she was approximately 14 years old: she
currently recalls having been 14 when she met Epstein. though she stated in a 2007 FBI interview
that she believed her interactions with him began when she was 15. Victim-2 estimates that she
herself performed more than ten sexualized massages and that she also recruited approximately
20-30 additional girls who were similarly abused by Epstein in Florida.
When Victim-2 first encountered Epstein, she was a high school dropout, living away
from home and supporting herself financially. She recalls being recruited by a young girl at a
party who told her she could make $200 by giving a massage to an older man. Victim-2 agreed to
go to Epstein's residence in Palm Beach, and she ultimately participated in at least ten massages,
which became increasingly sexual over time. She recalled that Epstein would instruct her to pinch
his nipples while he masturbated, and that she was often instructed to take her clothes off and
perform the massage while nude. During the massages, Epstein would use a vibrating massager
on her vagina, and during at least one incident he put his hand on her genitals. She recounted that
Epstein would frequently push things further to see how far he could go.
I
Page 6
Epstein asked Victim-2 to bring other girls for massages, which she did. Initially,
Epstein simply asked her to "bring a friend" and told her he would pay her to bring other girls.
Later, after a few experiences of Victim-2 bringing victims who balked at the sexual nature of the
massages, Epstein told her not to bring girls unless they knew what to expect. Victim-2 understood
this to mean she should warn girls to expect they would need to take off their clothes, and that
Epstein would touch them and masturbate. She then conveyed as much in recruiting victims.
Victim-2 estimates she recruited approximately 20 to 30 girls for Epstein, all of whom
were approximately 15 to 20 years old. Victim-2 believes that most of the girls she brought were
minors. This continued for approximately two to three years. Although Epstein did not expressly
tell Victim-2 to bring minors, the girls she knew—and thus the girls she could recruit—were all
minors at the time. Epstein would occasionally indicate to Victim-2 which girls he liked and which
girls he disliked, and she noticed he preferred the younger minors she brought, and that he preferred
petite blonde girls. Victim-2 usually coordinated these appointments with Victim-2
specifically recalls that would occasionally call Victim-2 and say that she was in New York,
that Epstein would be arriving in Florida soon, and that she wanted to know if Victim-2 could
"work" when he arrived.
When Victim-2 first met Epstein, she told him she was 18 because her friend had told
her to lie about her age. In truth, she was approximately 14 or 15 at the time, and was wearing
braces, and recalls that it would have been obvious that she was very young. Initially, Victim-2
similarly told other girls she brought to Epstein to say they were older because her friend had given
her that instruction. Over time, however, based on her observations of the girls that Epstein seemed
to prefer—and the sheer number of minors she brought to the house without issue—Victim-2 came
to believe that Epstein wanted younger girls, and did not care if the girls told him their true ages.
For this reason, Victim-2 stopped telling the girls she recruited to lie about their ages. She stated
that the girls she recruited looked very young, and she believes it would have been obvious to
anyone that they were underage.
When the Florida investigations became public, after Victim-2 had stopped visiting
Epstein, she recalls having a phone conversation with in which stated, in sum and
substance, that Victim-2 would be taken care of if she didn't say anything.
Corroboration of Victim-2
The full name and phone number of Victim-2 appear on message pads recovered from
Epstein's house during a search conducted as part of the prior investigations. The messages appear
to refer to scheduling appointments and recruiting other girls, e.g.: "She has a female friend for
you, please call back as soon as possible." These messages strongly corroborate that Victim-2
worked as a recruiter for Epstein. Additionally, the message pads appear to include messages with
names of individuals Victim-2 has identified as other victims, and who were interviewed during
the previous investigation (and who confirmed at the time that they were victimized in a matter
consistent with the pattern of conduct victims have described in our investigation). Although we
have not yet been able to interview those victims, we intend to approach them after charging.
Contemporaneous phone records also reflect numerous phone calls between Victim-2
and corroborating Victim-2's account that was her primary contact for scheduling
massagesor Epstein.
Page 7
Victim-3
Victim-3 recalls that between in or around 2003 and 2005. she went to Epstein's Florida
residence approximately 20 times to participate in sexualized massages, receiving payments of
$200 for each visit. Victim-3 recalls that she told Epstein her true age. and that she was 17.
However, we believe it is possible that Victim-3 may be mistaken as to her age at the time, and
indeed may have begun engaging with Epstein at the age of 16. Specifically, Victim-3 explained
that she would typically deposit cash from Epstein in her bank account right away. Victim-3
provided a notebook in which she noted deposits she made; based on her dates of deposits, it
appears the abuse began in approximately June 2003, weeks past her sixteenth birthday. The
records also appear to show that cash payments from Epstein continued through January 2005,
several months before her eighteenth birthday.
Similar to other victims, Victim-3 was recruited by a high school friend, who told her
she could make money by giving a massage. She recalls Epstein telling her that they could travel
together after she turned 18, and that once she turned 18 he would be able to help her with a
modeling career. She ultimately stopped going to Epstein's residence because she felt disgusted
by her interactions with him.
Victim-3 generally scheduled the massages through

Victim-3 recalled that
scwould sometimes call from New York to schedule massagesMance of E stein's arrival
uilrida. and Victim-3 specifically recalls il mentioning on calls that was in New
York at the time. She also reported that Epstein asked her to bring girls that loo e her, which
she took to mean blonde girls her age. Victim-3 brought two seventeen-year-old girls to Epstein's
house for massages, for which Victim-3 was also paid. Victim-3 has reported that the massages
became increasingly sexual over time, and included Epstein touching her genitals and using a
vibrator on her genital area, including under her underwear. Victim-3 also recalled that Epstein
asked her for intercourse, but she refused.
Page 8
Corroboration of Victim-3
A review of tolls for cell phone reflect several calls with Victim-3, when
Victim-3 was a minor, corroborating er recollection that would call her to schedule
massages with Epstein. A comparison of call records a ainst logs o Epstein's flights on his private
jet reflects several sets of calls during times when a ars to have been in New York City
with Epstein. For example. on September 16, 2004, and Victim-3 had three calls spread
throughout the afternoon; later that night, flight recor re ect that and E stein flew from
JFK Airport to West Palm Beach. This corroborates Victim-3's recollection that said that
she was in New York during some of their phone conversations to set up massages.
Investigative Leads from Florida Investigation
During the Florida investigation, the FBI interviewed dozens of victims who described
a pattern of abuse virtually identical to the experiences that victims have described to us. During
our investigation, we approached a small, targeted group of these individuals; in some instances,
victims declined to speak with us until charges were brought, given the history of this case.4 We
intend to approach additional victims identified during the Florida investigation after charging, but
have not approached them at this stage for fear of leak concerns. Given the benefits of charging
from a covert posture, we plan to hold off on approaching these individuals until after charging.
4 One additional individual who did speak to us, Victim-4, stated that when she was approximately
17 years old, a friend brought her to Epstein's house to perform a massage for S200. During the
massage, Epstein attempted to touch Victim-4's buttocks. She told him not to touch her; he tried
to again; and she pushed his hands away. Epstein said, in sum and substance. "you're done" and
took money from a drawer and put it on the table. Victim-4 was upset and left the house, and
subsequently had no additional contact with Epstein. However, she does not recall discussing her
age with Epstein. and in an interview in the Florida state investigation she recalled having been 18
years old during this incident. Notably. Victim-4 later became aware that some high school friends
had gone to Epstein's house, including a friend named told Victim-4 that
Epstein would get angry if brought girls who not want to do more than just give a
massage, and that Epstein want young girls.
Page 9
Proposed ( haraes, Elements of the Offenses. and Venue
A draft indictment is attached as an exhibit. We propose to charge Epstein with one
count of sex trafficking, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 1591 and 2, and one count of conspiracy to
commit the same, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 371. The first count covers Epstein's abuse of
victims in New York. The second count covers all three victims along with dozens of others in
both New York and Florida. By having a freestanding New York count, the indictment will make
clear that this case goes beyond the Florida investigation, and that New York is a significant
stakeholder in the equities of this case. It also provides a freestanding count we believe will be
immune to arguments that the NPA bars prosecution. At the same time, we think it is important
to charge a conspiracy count that covers all of the conduct, so that Epstein can be held accountable
for the harm he caused to all of his victims.
Count One,5 18 U.S.C. §§ 1591 (Sex Trafficking of Children) and 2
Charged period: 2002 to 2005
STATUTE ELEMENTS PROOF AS TO EACH ELEMENT
18 U.S.C. § 1591(a)
& (bX2)

1) Knowingly recruited, enticed,
harbored, transported,
provided, or obtained by any
means a person;
•
2) In or affecting interstate or
foreign commerce;
•

3) Knowing the fact that the
victim had not yet attained the
age of 18 years old; and
•
Page 10
4) Knowing the victim will be
caused to engage in a
commercial sex act.
•
Venue •
We discuss the elements as follows:
i
a separable offense, may be charged in a single count if those acts can be characterized as part of
I
Page 11
Page 12
naturally, the word 'any' has an expansive meaning, that is, 'one or some
Page 13Page 14
Count Two. 18 U.S.C. § 371 (Conspiracy, with the object to commit 18 U.S.C. § 1591)
Charged period: 2002 to 2005
STATUTE ELEMENTS PROOF AS TO EACH' ELEMENT
18 U.S.C. § 371 I) Two or more persons
unlawfully agreed to violate
section 1591:
•

2) Defendant knowingly and
willfully became a member
of the conspiracy: and
3) An overt act in furtherance
of the conspiracy.
•

IV. Cooper:UWE Defendants
None currently. Following the filing of the initial indictment charging Epstein, we
hope to approach other suspected and alleged co-conspirators. and to further develop evidence
against such individuals through the overt investigation, with the possibility of utilizing certain
such individuals as cooperating defendants.
Page 16

V. I .eflal Context
Separate from anticipated defenses, which are addressed further below, we expect there
are two legal issues that might be raised in connection with a prosecution of Epstein in SDNY.
A. The Florida Non-Prosecution Agreement
Prior to opening our investigation, we examined the question whether Epstein's prior
non-prosecution agreement with the SDFL would bar prosecution against Epstein or his
co-conspirators in the SDNY, including for conduct that occurred in part in SDFL. For the reasons
set forth below, we believe that it would not. In particular, we believe that the Agreement—which
was signed only by representatives of SDFL and spoke, in relevant part, only to binding that
Office—would not preclude another federal district from bringing properly-venued charges based
on the same conduct.
Background
Following the SDFL and state investigations into Epstein's conduct from
approximately 2005 through 2007, Epstein entered into a non-prosecution agreement (the "NPA,"
a copy of which is attached) with the SDFL in September 2007. II As discussed further below, the
terms of the NPA required, among other things, that Epstein plead guilty to state charges of
soliciting prostitution from a single victim. In exchange, the SDFL agreed not to prosecute Epstein
for "any offenses that arose" from the SDFL investigation, including trafficking and enticement
offenses. The NPA further purported to commit the SDFL to not bringing c es a ainst "an
potential co-co irators of Epstein. including but not limited tono n
Lesley Groff, or none of whom were signatories to e NPA.
Groff are believ to ve wo or Epstein to schedule massages, and and
are believed to have recruited Epstein's victims. As noted, only Epsteinhimself an t SDFL
were parties to the NPA.
Substance and Language of the NPA
The language of the NPA overwhelmingly refers to the SDFL, and the core terms and
text of the agreement appear to be limited to the SDFL. The prefatory language states:
"THEREFORE, on the authority of R. Alexander Acosta, United States Attorney for the Southern
District of Florida, prosecution in this District for these ofJenses 13 shall be deferred in favor of
II On February 21, 2019, following litigation initiated in 2008 by certain of the Victims, a court in
the Southern District of Florida found that the SDFL violated the Crime Victims' Rights Act in
connection with its entrance into, and notification regarding. the NPA. A decision on the
appropriate remedy currently is pending.
12 As discussed above,1. and Groff worked for Epstein and scheduled appointments for
victims. nu also wo as an assistant to Epstein during the relevant period, but appears to
have had minimal contact with victims. lived with Epstein during the relevant period
and appears to have had some kind of sexua re ationship with him.
13 All emphases relating to the NPA are added unless otherwise specified.
Page 17
prosecution by the State of Florida." The final paragraph of the prefatory language also states,
among other things, that after fulfilling the terms of the agreement, "no prosecution for the [sex
abuse] offenses set out on pages 1 and 2 of this Agreement, nor any other offenses that have been
the subject of the joint investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the United States
Attorney's Office, nor any offenses that arose from the Federal Grand July investigation will be
instituted in this District."
In its terms section, the NPA further states that Epstein's signature "is not to be
construed as an admission of civil or criminal liability or a waiver of any jurisdictional or other
defense" as to any victim whose identity was not disclosed by SDFL to Epstein, as provided for in
the NPA, and additionally states that neither Epstein's signature nor any resulting waivers or civil
settlements "are to be construed as admissions or evidence of civil or criminal liability or a waiver
of any jurisdictional or other defense as to any person." These provisions strongly suggest that the
parties contemplated possible criminal prosecutions in other jurisdictions and/or based on victims
not initially identified in the Florida investigations (whether in Florida or elsewhere). The final
substantive paragraph of the NPA states that "Epstein hereby requests that the United States
Attorney for the Southern District of Florida defer [. . .] prosecution."
Applicability of NPA Immunity Provisions to Other Jurisdictions
Page 18
Page 19
Page 20
The Independent Interests of the Southern District of New York
Page 21
Accordingly, we believe this SDNY prosecution is in the interests of justice.

B. Statute of Limitations
The conduct we ex t to char e s ed from a roximatel 2002 throw
approximately 2005.
Evolving Statutes of Limitations for Sex Crimes Involving Children
Although a federal criminal case ordinarily is subject to a five-year statute of
limitations, since at least 1994 there have been expanded statutes of limitations for sexual offenses
against children.
In 1994, the statute of limitations in effect for sexual offenses against children ran until
—the child reaches the age of 25 years." 18 U.S.C. § 3509(k) (1990), amended 18 U.S.C. § 3283

(1994) ("No statute of limitations that would otherwise preclude prosecution for an offense
involving the sexual or physical abuse of a child under the age of 18 years shall preclude such
prosecution before the child reaches the age of 25.").
In April 2003. Section 3283 was revised to permit the prosecution of sex offenses
against minors at any time during the lifetime of the minor victim. 18 U.S.C. § 3283 (2003)
(-No statute of limitations that would otherwise preclude prosecution for an offense involving the
sexual or physical abuse, or kidnaping, of a  child under the age of 18 years shall preclude such
prosecution during the life of the child."). 18
18 Section 3283 was further revised in January 2006 to permit the prosecution of such offenses
during the lifetime of the victim or ten years after the offense, whichever is longer. Additionally.
in July 2006. a separate but partially overlapping provision. 18 U.S.C. § 3299, was enacted.

Section 3299 eliminated the statute of limitation for certain specified sex crimes and/or crimes
against children, including 18 U.S.C. § 1591.
Page 22
Application of Statute of Limitations
19 The term "sexual abuse" is defined as including "the employment, use, persuasion, inducement,
or coercion of a child to engage in, or assist or another person to engage in, sexually explicit
conduct or the rape, molestation, prostitution, or other form of sexual exploitation of children, or
incest with children." 18 U.S.C. § 3509(8). The term "sexually explicit conduct" means "actual
or simulated (A) sexual intercourse [. . .] (C) masturbation: [or] (D) lascivious exhibition of the
genitals or pubic area of a person[.]"
Page 23
Page 24
VI. Anticipated Defenses
J
00022579

╭──── Page 24, Image 1 ────╮
│ Page 24                  │
│                          │
│ VI. Anticipated Defenses │
│                          │
│ LJ                       │
│ — r                      │
│                          │
│ HM 00022579              │
╰──────────────────────────╯

Page 25
_1
Page 26
I=
I I I I
M
Page 27
Page 28
_I
VII. Discover Issues
We have reviewed the SDNY Discovery and Disclosure Policy and believe we will be
able to provide all necessary discovery materials to the defense on a timely basis. We nevertheless
note that discovery in this case will be significant, due to the prior investigations.
Page 29
We are aware of two substantial and historical sets of materials (in addition to materials
we have obtained as part of our current investigation) that will require discovery and disclosure
processes: files maintained by the Department of Justice FOIA office, and files maintained by the
FBI in Florida in connection with the initial investigations. In addition, we are in the process of
obtaining the physical evidence obtained in connection with the Florida investigation so we can
log and store it in evidence in New York. The evidence currently remains in FBI custody in
Florida.
Separate from those two sources of materials, although we believe that the FBI file
contains all materials from the initial state investigation, to the extent that is not correct, we may
need to obtain certain materials from local police. We have held off on contacting local police but
will do so once the investigation is overt. Additionally, while unlikely, at an appropriate time we
will need to ascertain whether SDFL has any materials separate and in addition to the FBI case
files, and, if so, to obtain copies of any such materials.
We also expect to need to determine what protections should cover discovery materials,
potentially including the need for significant redactions, including of victim identifying
information.
VIII. Forfeiture / Restitution
We expect to seek both forfeiture and restitution in this case.
Restitution is mandatory under the Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act
of 2000 (the "TVPA"), and includes "the full amount of the victim's losses" including "any costs
incurred by the victim for—(A) medical services relating to physical, psychiatric, or psychological
care; (B) physical and occupational therapy or rehabilitation; (C) neePqRaty transportation,
temporary housing, and child care expenses: (D) lost income; (E) attorney's fees, as well as other
costs incurred: and (F) any other losses suffered by the victim as a proximate result of the
offense." 18 U.S.C. § 1593(bX3) (incorporating by reference 18 U.S.C. § 2259(bX3)). The
statutory language is circumscribed by a requirement of a causal connection between the offense
of conviction and victim's harm, but "mathematical precision" is not required.
Forfeiture is also specifically provided for under the TVPA. 18 U.S.C. § 1594 provides,
in relevant part: "The court, in imposing sentence on any person convicted of [an involuntary
servitude offense, including 18 U.S.C. § 1591] shall order . . . that such person's interest in any
property, real or personal, that was used or intended to be used to commit or to facilitate the
commission of such violation." 18 U.S.C. • 159• 1 . This includes residential
which such crimes are committed.
Page 30

IX. Coordinated Proceedinos
Does the offense conduct involve fraud/faLse claims on a federally funded program, or
fraud on or committed by a federally insured financial institution? No.

X. Victim Issues
Does the case involve victims? Yes. The case involves at least dozens of potential
victim-witnesses, many of whom have been identified and likely many more who have not yet
been identified.
We will y attuned to victims' rights and associated processes, and we wi
coordinate with the SDNY victims and witness coordinators as well as with the FBI victims
liaisons.

XI. Speedy Trial Act Calculations & Deadline
The defendant has not yet been indicted.
XII. Statute of Limitations
See above analysis of statute of limitations.

MI. Plans for Arrest
We ex , ect to arrest e en t followm • the film. of the Duo I • sed indictment.
By:
Assistant United States Attorneys
EFTA01617727 (Jmail)
 [misc] Skype log
(inferred date: 2019-06-30)
Platform: Skype: jeevacation Name: C8:live
•
Timezone: UTC+0000
ii• jeevacation
2019/06/30
jeevacation
bring me a picture of the sofa that you want to buy, when I see you tonight at 7. do
you know which school in canada. do some research. .
05:49:28 am
Yes! Ef or Caplan school! I'm wanna compare programs and choose what a better!
Already write them and waiting program, info , price, accommodation options!
05:51:35 am
jeevacation
kaplan not interesting you want a universtiy that has esl program.
05:52:41 am
Sofa from ikea can be my choice C. I'm not looking sofa of my dream on this moment
!!
05:53:07 am
jeevacation
in your mercantile manor. I m not sure what you are offering. it is also clear what you
want for yourself
05:53:35 am
always
05:53:49 am
e
0
0
I indicated that I want to prepare for testing for to be study university
05:54:24 am
I'm want this really! It's just opportunity is unreal for me! therefore very attractive
05:56:45 am
jeevacation
yes i understood. what you WANT . what are you offfering
05:57:14 am
if anything. . either way ok.
05:57:28 am
i try to explain that you need to focus on what you give. everyone wants. !! wants
and wants!
05:57:56 am
I try to make step
05:58:26 am
jeevacation
the step is about wanting or givign
05:58:48 am
What do u mean
05:59:04 am
Giving?
05:59:47 am
•
•
To we're ?
05:59:56 am
jeevacation
mercantile what do you give in exchange for what you receive? :)0
06:00:36 am
i am going to a meeting already . will talk about it tonight.
06:01:11 am
U talking about what I can give? If u help me with school?) haha?)
06:01:36 am
Or what do u mean
06:01:50 am
U too
06:01:58 am
Hahah)) I didn't think it would be so difficult
06:03:57 am
have fun today
06:01:21 am
jeevacation
again, you need to focus on what you do for others. stop thinking about what you
can get for yourself . the nicest thing you told me was that you took your mom on
vacation. i liked that. bags sofa kitchen no so
06:05:23 am
0
0
Lim6bi npocmorperb 3ry 06i.uyio (kororpacimio, nepeilAwre K:
https://login.skype.com/login/sso?go=xmmfallback?pic=0-neu-d7-
84954aad5c1Ocbc2e88230fdb4136c9d
Sent an attachment
Filename: 256DFCF4-AEBD-40DE-8458-967CFCCF848E.jpg
Path: 256DFCF4-AEBD-40DE-8458-967CFCCF848E.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
06:12:25 am
Liro6bi npocmorperb 3ry ci6gyio ctiororpa4mio, nepeilAwre K:
httpS://lOgirl.Skype.COMMOgirl/SSO?g0=XMMialibaCk?piC=0-neU-dll -
39917208db4f65d443be 1 d5b3a225073
Sent an attachment
Filename: IMG_1430.PNG
Path: IMG_1430.PNG
Type: image/png
06:12:32 am
if you talk about my family !! I always think, I just do not like to brag about it! the
money that I give my family! big for my little town
06:14:01 am
If u tallk about other people!! I&apos;m not trying to use anyone else more than
someone uses me
06:14:47 am
jeevacation
ouch
06:15:25 am
My next big purchase will be a change apartment for my family
06:15:47 am
Ouch)) hahah for example people in work always use u)
06:16:12 am
The don't care about nothing u problem and plab
06:16:36 am
Plan
•
•
•
06:16:40 am
Yes
06:17:27 am
Just be work like this
06:17:39 am
jeevacation
why should they?
06:16:48 am
you are meat to them
06:16:53 am
meat that gets repalced every few years
06:17:08 am
jeevacation
so you should budget , how are you going to make the money you need for an apt. ?
plan it out. be precise with numbers talk later
06:18:11 am
An apt?
06:19:03 am
0
•
jeevacation
apartment .
061930 am
you should read karl marx re work . using . . captilism is exchange. using others is
an issue of intnet and lack of caring. does a doctor use his patients? to make money.
. dont think so , but there is a give and take
06:21:21 am
you just need to learn the &quot; give &quot; part.
06:21:50 am
I'm know numbers) about my work! I'm will start do already what I can make best for
this! I'm be make skin better, try to be more fat, and when I'm back to Russ im need
change a bit my portfolio! Im need organize myself some shot with nice photography,
more comers! What I'm better can do in this bizness ? Nothing!
06:23:19 am
I'm know numbers) about my work! I'm will start do already what I can make best for
this! I'm be make skin better, try to be more fat, and when I'm back to Russ im need
change a bit my portfolio! Im need organize myself some shot with nice photography,
more corners! What I'm better can do in this bizness ? Nothing!
06:23:20 am
I know the Marxist theory! part of giving away sometimes find themselves in other
things! if you are a pawn at your job, you can give something to another (from outside
) not in work only!! u can not always offer something to your boss! but for their merits
everyone has karma
06:26:22 am
Doctor just work , but Does the patient give something to the doctor? Thankful, that all
06:27:41 am
if you think that I forgot about my family with new bag, it is not at all so!
06:29:10 am
• My mom have some nice bag too)) ttooneinsi
06:29:30 am
EFTA00009809 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ sealed indictment of Jeffrey Epstein
(date: 2019-07-02)
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 1 of 14
ORIGINAL UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
x.
SEALED
INDICTMENT
19 Cr.
19CRIM 490
COUNT ONE
(Sex Trafficking Conspiracy
The Grand Jury charges:
OVERVIEW

1. As set forth herein, over the course of many
years, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, sexually exploited and
abused dozens of minor girls at his homes in Manhattan, New .
York, and Palm Beach, Florida, among other locations.

2. In particular, from at least in or about 2002, up
to and including at least in or about 2005, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, enticed and recruited, and caused to be enticed and
recruited, minor girls to visit his mansion in Manhattan, New
York (the "New York Residence") and his estate in Palm Beach,
Florida (the "Palm Beach Residence") to engage in sex acts with
him, after which he would give the victims hundreds of dollars
in cash. Moreover, and in order to maintain and increase his
supply of victims, EPSTEIN also paid certain of his victims to
recruit additional girls to be similarly abused by EPSTEIN. In
base 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 2 of 14
this way, EPSTEIN created a vast network of underage victims for
him to sexually exploit in locations including New York and
Palm Beach.

3. The victims described herein were as young as 14
years old at the time they were abused by JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, and were, for various reasons, often particularly
vulnerable to exploitation. EPSTEIN intentionally sought out
minors and knew that many of his victims were in fact under the
age of 18, including because, in some instances, minor victims
expressly told him their age.

4. in creating and maintaining this network of minor
victims in multiple states to sexually abuse and exploit,
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, worked and conspired with
others, including employees and associates who facilitated his
conduct by, among other things, contacting victims and
scheduling their sexual encounters with EPSTEIN at the New York
Residence and at the Palm Beach Residence.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND

5. During all time periods charged in this
Indictment, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, was a financier with
multiple residences in the continental United States, including
the New York Residence and the Palm Beach Residence.

6. Beginning in at least 2002, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, enticed and recruited, and caused to be enticed and
t Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 3 of 14
recruited, dozens of minor girls to engage in sex acts with him,
after which EPSTEIN paid the victims hundreds of dollars in
cash, at the New York Residence and the Palm Beach Residence.

7. In both New York and Florida, JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
the defendant, perpetuated this abuse in similar ways. Victims
were initially recruited to provide "massages" to EPSTEIN, which
would be performed nude or partially nude, would become
increasingly sexual in nature, and would typically include one
or more sex acts. EPSTEIN paid his victims hundreds of dollars
in cash for each encounter. Moreover, EPSTEIN actively
encouraged certain of his victims to recruit additional girls to
be similarly sexually abused. EPSTEIN incentivized his victims
to become recruiters by paying these victim -recruiters hundreds
of dollars for each girl that they brought to EPSTEIN. In so
doing, EPSTEIN maintained a steady supply of new victims to
exploit.
The New York Residence

8. At all times relevant to this Indictment, JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, the defendant, possessed and controlled a multi-story
private residence on the Upper East Side of Manhattan, New York,
i.e., the New York Residence. Between at least in or about 2002
and in or about 2005, EPSTEIN abused numerous minor victims at
the New York Residence by causing these victims to be recruited
to engage in paid sex acts with him.
T Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 4 of 14

9. When a victim arrived at the New York Residence,
she typically would be escorted to a room with a massage table,
where she would perform a massage on JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant. The victims, who were as young as 14 years of age,
were told by EPSTEIN or other individuals to partially or fully
undress before beginning the "massage." During the encounter,
EPSTEIN would escalate the nature and scope of physical contact
with his victim to include, among other things, sex acts such as
groping and direct and indirect contact with the victim's
genitals. EPSTEIN typically would also masturbate during these
sexualized encounters, ask victims to touch him while he
masturbated, and touch victims' genitals with his hands or with
sex toys.

10. In connection with each sexual encounter, JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, the defendant, or one of his employees or associates,
paid the victim in cash. Victims typically were paid hundreds
of dollars in cash for each encounter.

11. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, knew that many of
his New York victims were underage, including because certain
victims told him their age. Further, once these minor victims
were recruited, many were abused by EPSTEIN on multiple
subsequent occasions at the New York Residence. EPSTEIN
sometimes personally contacted victims to schedule appointments
at the New York Residence. In other instances, EPSTEIN directed
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 5 of 14
employees and associates, including a New York-based employee
("Employee -I"), to communicate with victims via phone to arrange
for these victims to return to the New York Residence for
additional sexual encounters with EPSTEIN.

12. Additionally, and to further facilitate his
ability to abuse minor girls in New York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, asked and enticed certain of his victims to recruit
additional girls to perform "massages" and similarly engage in
sex acts with EPSTEIN. When a victim would recruit another girl
for EPSTEIN, he paid both the victim-recruiter and the new
victim hundreds of dollars in cash. Through these victim-
recruiters, EPSTEIN gained access to and was able to abuse
dozens of additional minor girls.

13. In particular, certain recruiters brought dozens
of additional minor girls to the New York Residence to give
massages to and engage in sex acts with JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant. EPSTEIN encouraged victims to recruit additional
girls by offering to pay these victim-recruiters for every
additional girl they brought to EPSTEIN. When a victim-
recruiter accompanied a new minor victim to the New York
Residence, both the victim-recruiter and the new minor victim
were paid hundreds of dollars by EPSTEIN for each encounter. In
addition, certain victim -recruiters routinely scheduled these
5
•• Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 6 of 14
encounters through Employee -1, who sometimes asked the
recruiters to bring a specific minor girl for EPSTEIN.
The Palm Beach Residence

14. In addition to recruiting and abusing minor girls
in New York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, created a similar
network of minor girls to victimize in Palm Beach, Florida,
where EPSTEIN owned, possessed and controlled another large
residence, i.e., the Palm Beach Residence. EPSTEIN frequently
traveled from New York to Palm Beach by private jet, before
which an employee or associate would ensure that minor victims
were available for encounters upon his arrival in Florida.

15. At the Palm Beach Residence, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, engaged in a similar course of abusive conduct.
When a victim initially arrived at the Palm Beach Residence, she
would be escorted to a room, sometimes by an employee of
EPSTE1N's, including, at times, two assistants ("Employee -2" and
"Employee -3") who, as described herein, were also responsible
for scheduling sexual encounters with minor victims. Once
inside, the victim would provide a nude or semi-nude massage for
EPSTEIN, who would himself typically be naked. During these
encounters, EPSTEIN would escalate the nature and scope of the
physical contact to include sex acts such as groping and direct
and indirect contact with the victim's genitals. EPSTEIN would
also typically masturbate during these encounters, ask victims
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 7 of 14
to touch him while he masturbated, and touch victims' genitals
with his hands or with sex toys.

16. In connection with each sexual encounter, JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, the defendant, or one of his employees or associates,
paid the victim in cash. Victims typically were paid hundreds
of dollars for each encounter.

17. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, knew that certain
of his victims were underage, including because certain victims
told him their age. In addition, as with New York-based
victims, many Florida victims, once recruited, were abused by
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, on multiple additional
occasions.

18. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, who during the
relevant time period was frequently in New York, would arrange
for Employee -2 or other employees to contact victims by phone in
advance of EPSTEIN's travel to Florida to ensure appointments
were scheduled for when he arrived. In particular, in certain
instances, Employee -2 placed phone calls to minor victims in
Florida to schedule encounters at the Palm Beach Residence. At
the time of certain of those phone calls, EPSTEIN and Employee -2
were in New York, New York. Additionally, certain of the
individuals victimized at the Palm Beach Residence were
contacted by phone by Employee -3 to schedule these encounters.
7
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 8 of 14

19. Moreover, as in New York, to ensure a steady
stream of minor victims, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, asked
and enticed certain victims in Florida to recruit other girls to
engage in sex acts. EPSTEIN paid hundreds of dollars to victim-
recruiters for each additional girl they brought to the Palm
Beach Residence.
STATUTORY ALLEGATIONS

20. From at least in or about 2002, up to and
including in or about 2005, in the Southern District of New York
and elsewhere, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, and others known
and unknown, willfully and knowingly did combine, conspire,
confederate, and agree together and with each other to commit an
offense against the United States, to wit, sex trafficking of
minors, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section
1591(a) and (b).

21. It was a part and object of the conspiracy that
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, and others known and unknown,
would and did, in and affecting interstate and foreign commerce,
recruit, entice, harbor, transport, provide, and obtain, by any
means a person, and to benefit, financially and by receiving
anything of value, from participation in a venture which has
engaged in any such act, knowing that the person had not
attained the age of 18 years and would be caused to engage in a
z
8
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 9 of 14
commercial sex act, in violation of Title 18, United States
Code, Sections 1591(a) and (b)(2).
Overt Acts

22. In furtherance of the conspiracy and to effect
the illegal object thereof, the following overt acts, among
others, were committed in the Southern District of New York and
elsewhere:

a. In or about 2004, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, enticed and recruited multiple minor victims,
including minor victims identified herein as Minor Victim-1,
Minor Victim-2, and Minor Victim-3, to engage in sex acts with
EPSTEIN at his residences in Manhattan, New York, and Palm
Beach, Florida, after which he provided them with hundreds of
dollars in cash for each encounter.

b. In or about 2002, Minor Victim-1 was
recruited to engage in sex acts with EPSTEIN and was repeatedly
sexually abused by EPSTEIN at the New York Residence over a
period of years and was paid hundreds of dollars for each
encounter. EPSTEIN also encouraged and enticed Minor Victim-1
to recruit other girls to engage in paid sex acts, which she
did. EPSTEIN asked Minor Victim -1 how old she was, and Minor
Victim-1 answered truthfully.

c. In or about 2004, Employee -1, located in the
Southern District of New York, and on behalf of EPSTEIN, placed
9
e Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 10 of 14
a telephone call to Minor Victim-1 in order to schedule an
appointment for Minor Victim-1 to engage in paid sex acts with
EPSTEIN.

d. In or about 2004, Minor Victim-2 was
recruited to engage in sex acts with EPSTEIN and was repeatedly
sexually abused by EPSTEIN at the Palm Beach Residence over a
period of years and was paid hundreds of dollars after each
encounter. EPSTEIN also encouraged and enticed Minor Victim-2
to recruit other girls to engage in paid sex acts, which she
did.

e. In or about 2005, Employee -2, located in the
Southern District of New York, and on behalf of EPSTEIN, placed
a telephone call to Minor Victim -2 in order to schedule an
appointment for Minor Victim -2 to engage in paid sex acts with
EPSTEIN.

f. In or about 2005, Minor Victim-3 was
recruited to engage in sex acts with EPSTEIN and was repeatedly
sexually abused by EPSTEIN at the Palm Beach Residence over a
period of years and was paid hundreds of dollars for each
encounter. EPSTEIN also encouraged and enticed Minor Victim-3
to recruit other girls to engage in paid sex acts, which she
did. EPSTEIN asked Minor Victim -3 how old she was, and Minor
Victim-3 answered truthfully.
10
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 11 of 14

g. In or about 2005, Employee -2, located in the
Southern District of New York, and on behalf of EPSTEIN, placed
a telephone call to Minor Victim-3 in Florida in order to
schedule an appointment for Minor Victim-3 to engage in paid sex
acts with EPSTEIN.

h. In or about 2004, Employee -3 placed a
telephone call to Minor Victim-3 in order to schedule an
appointment for Minor Victim-3 to engage in paid sex acts with
EPSTEIN.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.)
COUNT TWO
(Sex Trafficking)
The Grand Jury further charges:

23. The allegations contained in paragraphs 1
through 19 and 22 of this Indictment are repeated and realleged
as if fully set forth within.

24. From at least in or about 2002, up to and
including in or about 2005, in the Southern District of New
York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, willfully and knowingly,
in and affecting interstate and foreign commerce, did recruit,
entice, harbor, transport, provide, and obtain by any means a
person, knowing that the person had not attained the age of 18
years and would be caused to engage in a commercial sex act, and
did aid and abet the same, to wit, EPSTEIN recruited, enticed,
harbored, transported, provided, and obtained numerous
11
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Rade 12 of 14
individuals•who were less than 18 years old, including but not
limited to Minor Victim-1, as described above, and who were then
caused to engage in at least one commercial sex act in
Manhattan, New York.
(Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591(a).

(b) (2), and 2.)
FORFEITURE ALLEGATIONS
25. As a result of committing the offense alleged in
Count Two of this Indictment, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant,
shall forfeit to the United States, pursuant to Title 18, United
States Code, Section 1594(c) (1), any property, real and
personal, that was used or intended to be used to commit or to
facilitate the commission of the offense alleged in Count Two,
and any property, real or personal, constituting or derived from
any proceeds obtained, directly or indirectly, as a result of
the offense alleged in Count Two, or any property traceable to
such property, and the following specific property:

a. The lot or parcel of land, together with its
buildings, appurtenances, improvements, fixtures, attachments
and easements, located at 9 East 71st Street, New York, New
York, with block number 1386 and lot number 10, owned by
Maple, Inc.
12
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 13 of 14
Substitute Asset Provision

26. If any of the above-described forfeitable
property, as a result of any act or omission of the defendant:

(a) cannot be located upon the exercise of due diligence;
(b) has been transferred or sold to, or deposited with, a
third person;

(c) has been placed beyond the jurisdiction of the Court;
(d) has been substantially diminished in value; or

(e) has been commingled with other property which cannot
be subdivided without difficulty;
it is the intent of the United States, pursuant to 21 U.S.C.
853(p) and 28 U.S.C. S 2461(c), to seek forfeiture of any
other property of the defendant up to the value of the above
forfeitable property.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 1594; Title 21,
United States Code, Section 853(p); and
Title 28, United States Code, Section 2461.)
GEOFFREY . BERMAN
United States Attorney
13
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 2 Filed 07/02/19 Page 14 of 14
Form No. USA-33s-274 (Ed. 9-25-58)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
v.
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
INDICTMENT
(18 U.S.C. §§ 371, 1591(a), (b)(2),
and 2)
14
EFTA00513467 (Jmail)
 [tech] personal address book
(approximate date: 2019-07-02)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
• NYC024329.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024329.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
• Calendar Items
• Calls
• Contacts
• Messages
• Notes
• Top Contacts
• User Accounts
Case Data: Contacts (7001-7100 of 19830)
Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/9/Messages/97658.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Google+
Email
(Email)
ID 1337557
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/0/1/Messages/100382.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Google+ team
Contact
Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/9/Messages/98043.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Google+ team
Email
(Email)
ID 1375388
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/0/9/Messages/90331.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-056 I -4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C 1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/3/1/Messages/138956.emlx
Mac Mail
goop
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac- Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613 A4F7EC65/Data/3/6/1/Messages/163791.emlx
Mac Mail
Gordon Erik
EMEIMM> Ryan
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/1/1/Messages/111273.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
GoTek - Amazon Marketplace
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/0/1/Messages/107441.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Gourmet Cooking & Living
Email
(Email)
ID 1339433
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First GourmetFoodMall
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First GourmetFoodMall.com
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First GOV
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Use/Users(Deleted)/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/458842CC-A3
4740CB-9BB14AF33B39134B/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gov
Last Richardson
Phone Number
(Main)
Phone Number
(Work)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Home)
Email (Home)
Email (Work)
Email (MobileMe) Bill Richardson <a
Creation Date 2011-07-22 18:31:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-08-16 16:38:57 (UTC)
Jackie
Janice cell
Chris cell
Note
Annette
ID 93
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/2/1/1/Messages/112647.emlx
Mac Mail
Gov Richardson
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Usera (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac- Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/6/4/1/Messages/146252.emlx
Mac Mail
Gov Richardson
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/1/1/Messages/110827.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
/Users/karyna/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-
AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Grace
IVP
2019-07-02 16:36:02 (UTC)
Modification Date 2019-07-02 16:36:02 (UTC)
ID 540
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/MacaNBOX.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-
977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/5/3/1/Messages/135682.emlx
Mac Mail
Grace Vele
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/9/Messages/94932.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Gracious Home
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3 EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/0/1/Messages/108292.emlx
Mac Mail
Gracious Home
Contact
Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Path /Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/0/1/Messages/108563.emlx
Mac Mail
Gracious Home
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/9/Messages/92880.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Gracious Home
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/8/Messages/82727.emlx
Mac Mail
Gracious Home NY (via Clover)
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/9/Messages/94230.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Gracious Home Ratings from Bizrate
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/9/Messages/94828.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Graham
Email Graham (Email)
ID 1401449
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/BD0AllAA-097E-4FA
C-AA25-FC01E963AC0C/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Grand Hyatt Tokyo
Concierge
2017-02-23 18:44:33 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-02-23 18:44:33 (UTC)
ID 472
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/2/1/Messages/127087.emlx
Mac Mail
Grand Hyatt Tokyo
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/lcaryna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-
AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Grand Hyatt Tokyo
Concierge
2018-02-22 23:50:51 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-02-22 23:50:51 (UTC)
ID 337
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-
AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Grand Prix Driving School
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2018-02-22 23:50:51 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-02-22 23:50:52 (UTC)
ID 467
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/BD0AI1AA-097E-4FA
C-AA25-FC01E963AC0C/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Grand Prix Driving School
2016-03-24 16:28:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-03-24 16:28:44 (UTC)
ID 98
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/2/2/1/Messages/122920.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Grasso
Grasso
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users, (Deleted)/Library/Mail/V2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/3/1/Messages/139111.emlx
Mac Mail
Gray Malin
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Use/Users,(Deleted)/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/458842CC-A3
47-40CB-9B81-4AF33B39134B/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Graydon
Last Carter
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Work)
Creation Date 2011-07-22 18:31:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-08-16 16:38:56 (UTC)
ID 273
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/BD0AllAA-097E4FA
C-AA25-FC01E963ACOC/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Greg
Last Tietje
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date 2016-03-24 16:28:45 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-03-24 16:28:45 (UTC)
Organization •
ID 234
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Greg
Last Wyler
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
ID 6652
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Use/Users(Deleted)/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/458842CC-A34
740CB-9BB1-4AF33B39134B/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Greg
Last Nespol
Phone Number
(Work)
Creation Date 2011-07-22 18:31:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-08-16 16:38:52 (UTC)
ID 65
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Greg
Email (Email)
ID 9241400
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Greg
Last Wyler
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
ID 6652
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First Greg
Email (Email)
ID 9324727
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First Greg
Email (Email)
ID 3892502
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Greg
Last Wyler
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:47 (UTC)
ID 6652
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-
AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Greg
Last Tietje
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date 2018-02-22 23:50:50 (UTC)
Modification Date 2018-02-22 23:50:50 (UTC)
Organization
ID 218
Contact
Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users (Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/MacaNBOX.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-
977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/2/3/1/Messages/132757.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Greg Abel
Email
(Email)
ID 1028194
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Libraty/MailN2/Mac- INBOX.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-
977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/2/3/1/Messages/132723.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Greg Abel
Email
(Email)
ID 1028389
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Libraiy/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gregory
Last Nespole
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 279
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gregory
Last Nespole
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC) Date
ID 6513
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gregory
Last Nespole
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC) Date
ID 6513
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Gregory
Nespole
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 279
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Gregory
Nespole
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 279
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Gregory
Nespole
2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/9/Messages/95116.emlx
Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Gregory Quental
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/1/1/Messages/110086.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Gregory Riches
Email
(Email)
ID 1334799
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/9/Messages/94549.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Gregory Riches
Email  Carolina (Email)
ID 1401022
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Phone Number
(Home)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Other)
Creation Date
Modification Date
Organization
ID
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/B7D700EF-A587-4121-
AC4E-96461B74EEF5/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Gregory Riches
2018-02-22 23:50:51 (UTC)
2018-02-22 23:50:51 (UTC)
Designer
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/0/1/1/Messages/110058.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Gregory Riches
Email
(Email)
ID 1335714
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUserstkaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/0/1/Messages/109917.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Gregory Riches
Email
(Email)
ID 1329315
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Gregory Riches
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/BD0AllAA-097E-4FA
C-AA25-FC01E963ACOC/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gregory Riches
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Home)
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2016-03-24 16:28:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2016-03-24 16:28:45 (UTC)
Organization Designer
ID 136
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/42381948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/1/1/Messages/117436.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Gregory Riches
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/9/Messages/94449.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Gregory Riches
Email
IMMa Rich (Email)
ID 1400919
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/0/1/Messages/109901.emlx
Mac Mail
Gregory Riches
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Gregory VanNatter
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/1/1/1/Messages/111593.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Greta Moss
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/6/9/Messages/96006.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Gretchen
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
gretchen
carroll
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Gretchen
SIK
Carroll
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 298
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
gretchen
carroll
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Librmy/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gretchen
Middle SIK
Last Carroll
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5404
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gretchen
Middle SIK
Last Carroll
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 298
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gretchen
Middle SIK
Last Carroll
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 5404
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Gretchen
Middle SIK
Last Carroll
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:14 (UTC)
ID 298
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/458842CC-A3
4740CB-9BB14AF33B39134B/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-07-22 18:31:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-08-16 16:39:02 (UTC)
ID 211
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
gretchen
carroll
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Gretchen
SIK
Carroll
2016-09-21 07:01:12 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Path /Users,  (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac /Junk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-97
7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/3/6/1/Messages/163913.emlx
Mac Mail
Gretchen Parker
Contact
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/4/1/Messages/148588.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Grinnage
Grinnage
Contact
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/5/0/1/Messages/105129.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Groupon
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C 1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/6/0/1/Messages/106960.emlx
Mac Mail
Groupon
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /U/User,,_(Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac Deleted Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-0
98A-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/4/6/1/Messages/164234.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Groupon Goods
Email
(Email)
ID 1043991
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path Alsers/Icatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxa
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/0/9/Messages/90514.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Grubhub
Email
(Email)
ID 1332931
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Libraty/MaiUV6/1B90A3EB-05614DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/0/1/Messages/103443.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First GrubHub
Email
(Email)
ID 1409218
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First GrubHub
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First GrubHub
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
2381948-48234372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/4/1/Messages/144984.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First GRUBHUB
Email
(Email)
ID 1405093
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
/Users/itaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/8/Messages/88246.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Grubhub
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First GrubHub.com
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/0/1/Messages/103445.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/1/2/1/Messages/121115.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/3/1/Messages/137025.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/lcatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Sent Messages.
mbox/423B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/5/1/1/Messages/115479.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Gucci
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Gucci
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/0/1/Messages/107588.emlx
Mac Mail
Guesso
ID 1338632
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/6/0/1/Messages/106827.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
guesso.com
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/3/1/Messages/137788.emlx
Mac Mail
Guest Relation
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users,_ (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Guest Relations at The Ritz-Carlton
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/lcaryna/Library/Mai IN6/1B90A3 EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/8/Messages/84577.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mailboxes/Junk (iCloud).mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810
-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/6/1/1/Messages/116244.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1081161
Case Data: Contacts (6901-7000 of 19830) Case Data: Contacts (7101-7200 of 19830)
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Steven Pfeiffer [arts] Associate Director at Independent Filmmaker Project (IFP) 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01064310 (Jmail)
 [tech] personal address book
(approximate date: 2019-07-02)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024363.dmg
(Evidence ID: NYC024363.dmg - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Notes
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case Data: Contacts (3101-3200 of 4285)
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Terry
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 79
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Terry
Kafka
2014-08-07 22:04:11 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
375
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Terry
Kafka
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 339
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First terry
Last liming
ID 951
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Terry
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:24 (UTC)
ID 79
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tharangsee
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:30 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC) Date
ID 953
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tharangsee
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Nloditication Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 615
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tharangsee
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 615
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First The
Last Duke
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 22:19:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-03-17 01:15:05 (UTC)
ID 4788
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First The
Last Duke
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:21 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:24 (UTC) Date
ID 688
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First The
Last Duke
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 722
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First The
Last Duke
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:24 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:24 (UTC) Date
ID 744
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First The
Last Duke
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 722
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:03:59 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 25
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:00 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 91
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 650
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 723
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
1D 1708
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 1644
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2014-08-07 22:04:28 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC) Date
ID 858
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
ID 2625
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
ID 3338
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Thomas
Last L.* Jenkins
ID 2601
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Thomas
Middle J.
Last Barrack
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
Suffix Jr.
ID 405
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Thomas
Middle J.
Last Barrack
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:08 (UTC)
Suffix Jr.
ID 405
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Thomas
Last G. Eck
ID 3230
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Thomas
Last Pfeiffer
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:05 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC) Date
ID 223
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Thomas
Last Pfeiffer
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 155
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Thomas
Last Pfeiffer
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
ID 155
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Thomas
Middle J.
Last Barrack
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
Suffix Jr.
ID 263
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:09 (UTC)
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 300
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 300
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC I B4- I 6FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2014-08-07 22:04:32 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC) Date
ID 1037
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tim
Last Zagat
Phone Number (Work)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Address (Work)
Email (Home)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Work)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
4 Columbus Circle 3rd Floor
Address (Work) New York
NY
10019
4 Columbus Circle 3rd Floor
New York
NY
10019
2011-12-16 00:16:30 (UTC)
2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
1762
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Tim
Zagat
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:05 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:05 (UTC)
ID 202
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Tim
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Work)
Address (Work)
Email (Home)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Zagat
4 Columbus Circle 3rd Floor
New York
NY
10019
2014-08-07 22:04:40 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:40 (UTC)
1246
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
Tim
Doerr
1265
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Work)
Address (Work)
Email (Home)
Creation Date
Modification Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application SupportiAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Tim
Zagat
4 Columbus Circle 3rd Floor
New York
NY
10019
2011-12-16 00:16:30 (UTC)
2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
1761
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First toby
Last harshaw
ID 1597
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Todd
Last Yuba
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
ID 600
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Todd
Last Yuba
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 600
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Todd
Last Yuba
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:11 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC) Date
ID 414
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
ID 2533
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First TOM
Last MELNICK
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-03-17 01:19:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-03-17 01:34:15 (UTC)
ID 5136
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last Sze
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:03:59 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 43
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Tom
Last Shutt
ID 1195
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 936
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/D0EBC I B4- I 6FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:35 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC)
ID 1078
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Tom
Last Shutt
ID 267
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
ID 363
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 352
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last Sze
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 223
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First TOM
Last MELNICK
Email (Other)
Creation Date 2012-03-17 01:31:37 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-03-17 01:31:37 (UTC)
ID 5137
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Middle Barrack
Last Private
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:11 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC) Date
ID 417
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last Pritzker
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 245
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last P
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
ID 1643
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last Sze
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 223
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Middle Barrack
Last Private
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:12 (UTC)
ID 453
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 1485
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email 0
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
/Users/Stoty/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
TOM
MELNICK
2014-08-07 22:04:04 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
185
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
Last
ID
Tom
Appelquist
2762
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 19:13:01 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:55 (UTC)
ID 1667
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Tom
P
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
Last
ID
Tom
Appelquist
2742
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
tom
kwei
2301
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Tom
Last Weiler
ID 58
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Tom
Last Weiler
ID 391
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 726
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:00 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC)
ID 60
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last Pritzker
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Nloditication Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 245
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 726
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First TOM
Last MELNICK
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:20 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:24 (UTC) Date
ID 654
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 732
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Last Pritzker
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:32 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC) Date
ID 1036
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Tom
Last Appelquist
ID 1245
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom
Middle Barrack
Last Private
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 453
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom P
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 1043
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom P
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 51
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tom P
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 22:19:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 4769
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tommy
Last Gendru
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:00 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 122
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First TOMMY
Last MOTTOLA
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:19 (UTC)
ID 667
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tommy
Phone Number (Home)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 101
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tommy
Phone Number (Home)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC)
ID 101
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First TOMMY
Last MOTTOLA
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:19 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:20 (UTC) Date
ID 631
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/D0EBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tommy
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Phone Number
(Home)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:35 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:38 (UTC)
ID 1067
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Tommy
Gendru
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 248
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story I 1 -2 I -2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tommy
Last Gendru
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 248
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First TOMMY
Last MOTTOLA
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 667
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First tomsommai
ID 2950
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tony
Last Knight
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:08 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:09 (UTC) Date
ID 330
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First tony
Last scartelli
ID 299
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tony
Last Knight
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:08 (UTC)
ID 1581
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tony Cuomo
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-11-17 20:12:12 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:19 (UTC)
ID 1137
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tony Cuomo
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 876
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tony Cuomo
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-11-17 20:12:12 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 1137
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tony Haddard
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Creation Date 2011-11-17 20:12:12 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:08 (UTC)
ID 1136
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tony Haddard
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (iPhone)
Creation Date 2011-11-17 20:12:12 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:19 (UTC)
ID 1136
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC I B4- I 6FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Tony Haddard
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:07 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:09 (UTC)
ID 275
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Tracy
Last Day
ID 671
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Tracy
Last Day
ID 1489
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
trivers
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
1 D 379
Case Data: Contacts (3001-3100 of 4285) Case Data: Contacts (3201-3300 of 4285)
EFTA00005848 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2019-07-02 21:55:00)
00;3
LAJLLZU 1 EttlIN I rage I of 2
COLLECT
PERSON QUERY RESULTS Department of Emergency Services aid Public Protection
1111 Country C ILO RAKE MiddIctowr, C 00457
Search Criteria:
DATE -2019-07-02
TIME -21:55
USER -PSC01332
OR I - crcs P0051
(Production Server C) IE edge
Expenied DOB Search.
Agencies mended to be searched: (Please ncte: Actual agencies searched may differ)
COLLECT. DMV. NOC, PRAWN. WEAPONS
Search Results:
Linens< radasonent RcsInch Sow flak ans Sup Status Susp Items Effected (DD-MMM-YY)
Exp Dale
mhaver) giver License Number State i Class ReICIV Status nn -
02.
CT 14-0eE20 D VALID
14
splayed is the most recent image from DMV
cords. which may differ from credential
resented.
MV image is restricted to law enforcement
urposes, and shall not be saved, disclosed or used
n photo array or photo lint -up.
Commercial Lic Stator PK? States Cancel Status Cancel Date Cancel State
NONE ISSUED NONE ISSUED
Medical Certification Certification P.m:initial Federal Variance Skill Performance Evaluation Self Certification
I
Pips Donor Code Pendirg Act %Any pop Issued?
ORGAN DNR 00
Operator Full Name Sex Height Frieder
https://collect.cjis.ct.gov/collect/jsp/commonlprintContext.jsp 7/2/2019
t-utaint, t rruss 1 rage L. oI
Mates AtSteese•
Steed
DOB
(IfYYY4044X)
City
ResidentsAddress
CANAAN
Sheet Ci Caney Sate
F O3 IGLU
Stele VP Zip Bet
$ 1684° II- -- -
ZIP Sxt
_JI
hnps://colleetcjis.ct.govicolleet/jsp/common/printContext.jsp 7/2/2019

╭────────────────────────── Page 3, Image 1 ──────────────────────────╮
│ WULLrul rnunt rage zor                                              │
│                                                                     │
│ Ct)                                                                 │
│                                                                     │
│ aang sco                                                            │
│                                                                     │
│ Suet Sue tet                                                        │
│ 7 pow                                                               │
│ Rese Ar                                                             │
│                                                                     │
│ =i |                                                                │
│                                                                     │
│ hitps://collect.¢jis.ct.gov/collect/jsp/common/printContext.jsp TNO │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA01620912 (Jmail)
 [politics] iMessage to Steve Bannon screenshot(s), see quote: "first we need to push back on the lies ; then crush the pedo/trafficking narrative ; 
then rebuild your image as philanthropist"
(inferred date: 2019-07-04)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
Steve Bannon
SB
2019/04/02
Steve Bannon
Friday afternoon media training @ your place -- 2 camera shoot ; my crew so totally
confidential
SB 10:54:09 am
2019/04/03
Steve Bannon
What's National Security Advisor name
02:12:39 pm
Name???
02:28:57 pm
Can u talk asap
02:33:50 pm
Watch Acosta hearing @ appropriattions
02:34:33 pm
They are trying to bring witnesses
02:39:02 pm
https://video.snapstream.net/Play/5mINa9t3p6FB7UVWlqOmCH?accessToken=deqsyxuxeqrj0
02:45:30 pm
This guy prepped Acosta
02:45:30 pm
Yes
02:59:47 pm
What's the advisors names
02:59:59 pm
Name
03:00:03 pm
This is strong -- need to drive it all
07:55:59 pm
My guy today your very best defender
07:56:18 pm
https://www.mediaite.com/online/alan-dershowitz-lashes-out-at-miami-herald-epstein-reporting-and-calls-on-pulitzer-commi
ttee-to-ignore-it/
M
08:00:44 pm
NetFlix is making the film --
Find out details
09:00:39 pm
Brilliant
10:06:21 pm
Brilliant
SB 10:06:28 pm
2019/04/04
Steve Bannon
Sheriff:: 1. JE never trafficked in women-- ever.This case was based upon 1 (?) woman.

2. JE never knowingly solicited sex from 'underaged' women--every woman legitimately
presented themselves as 18 or older . 3. JE sentence given the actual facts are
extraordinary-- he did over a year in jail, paid restitution directly to the women, and
registered as a class sex offender-- anyone of which would be extraordinary, but
taken together is incredible given the facts .
03:58:16 am
First cut-- need michael to see
03:58:32 am
https://www.mediaite.com/print/miami-herald-hits-back-at-dershowitzs-fake-news-attack-on-epstein-sex-abuse-expose-we-sta
nd-by-our-story/
M
4••,(r41:7 -$4.7---71"1""!
01:29:29 pm
You have an opening
01:29:29 pm
Can u talk???
02:01:43 pm
We need a punch list of ALL the lies and misrepresentations in the MH piece--- this is
massive opening
02:05:38 pm
Spiro out
08:50:00 pm
Firm killed it just now
08:50:12 pm
You @ your place ?
SB 08:50:30 pm
2019/04/05
Steve Bannon
Need the list from the attorney today
09:41:24 am
Let me know how oliver goes
09:41:45 am
We need to work around your 38--first we need to push back on the lies ; then crush
the pedo/trafficking narrative ; then rebuild your image as philanthropist
09:49:39 am
Who did they lie too?
SB 10:28:05 am
2019/04/06
Steve Bannon
Something there
09:52:34 am
Wow
SB 10:06:51 am
2019/04/08
Steve Bannon
The Netflix film -- did they interview the sheriff yet
SB 03:40:33 pm
2019/06/25
Steve Bannon
Dude"
02:52:50 pm
Is this real
02:52:57 pm
Tell me this is real
02:57:53 pm
Is that out anywhere yet
SB 03:55:47 pm
2019/07/03
Steve Bannon
Done
03:33:02 pm
https://www.thedailybeast.comfjeffrey-epstein-court-orders-release-of-sealed-docs-about-alleged-sex-ring
SB 07:39:02 pm
Steve Bannon
2019/07/04
My guy is in Israel-- can we connect him to erhud ???
SB 03:29:21 am
Read
EFTA00299850 (Jmail)
 [money] inventory of the contents of FILE CABINET ONE
(approximate date: 2019-07-06)
FILE CABINET ONE
DRAWER ONE:
The Florida Science Foundation. Inc.

I. Correspondence
2. Articles of Incorporation
3. Office Space
4. Lease Agreement
5. Annual Report
6. Mark Dedick- Draft Corporate Documents

7. Accounting Invoices
8. Disputed Mark Dedick Invoices
COUQ Foundation, Inc. Organizational ( d/b/a Florida Science Foundation

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Certificate of Incorporation
6. By-Laws

7. Minutes and Consents
8. Notification/Release of Information Form
9. IRS Determination Letter
10. NY Application for Authority to do Business

11. SS-4
12. 1023 Application for Recognition as Exemption
13. Annual Franchise Tax Report
14. Annual Invoice for Statutory Representation

15. Charities Registration Request 9-9-99
16. NY Charities Registration Statement
17. Determination of Exempt Status

18. Balance Sheets
19. Tax Returns 2006
20. COUQ Tax Preparation February 2008
21. Filed 2007 Form 990-PF

22. Qualification to conduct Business in Florida
23. Fictitious Name Registration as Florida Science Foundation

24. Distribution Carryover
25. Florida Science Foundation Wachovia Bank Account
26. FSF Phone Lines
27. FSF Liability Insurance

28. FSF Office Lease @ One Clearlake and Amendment
29. FSF Application for Consumer Certificate of Exemption

30. FSF Security
31. FSF Expenses
32. FSF Invoices from Comiter, Singer, Baseman and Braun
33. FSF Correspondence

34. FSF Office Lease Second Amendment (April 1, 09- July 31, 09)
35. Grant Agreement Oct. 1, 2008 (btwn J Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation aka
Enhanced Education & the COUQ Foundation

36. Info Regarding Replacement of Florida Accountant
COUQ Foundation Transactions
1. Bear Stearns Asset Backed Securities Partners, LP Subscription Documents

2. Second City Capital Partners I ( SEE BINDER IN COMMUNITY INTEREST FILE)
3. Bear Stearns Asset Backed Securities Overseas, Ltd.

4. COUQ Goldman Sachs Account
5. JP Morgan account documents
6. JPMorgan POA sent 6/26/08
COUQ Foundation Charitable Contributions/Consulting Agreements

1. Confidentiality Agreement William Daniel Hillis
2. Edge Foundation Inc.
3. Website for COUQ
4. Offer Letter to

5. Consulting Agreement
6. Mark Lloyd Consulting Agreement
7. Rwandan Student Scholarships — City College

8. Kyle Godfrey Consulting Agreement
9. Marvin Minsky Consulting Agreement
10. David Grosof Consulting Agreement

11. Dr. Marc Hauser
1. Articles of Organization
J. Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation
1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes

3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Minutes
6. Article of Incorporation
7. By-Laws
FSF LLC
8. EIN
9. 2007 Form 990-PF

10. Chase Account Documents
11. Bear Stearns Account Documents
12. Goldman Sachs Account Documents
13. 501(c)(3) Application

14. Form 8718 Determination Letter Request
15. Determination Letter
16. 2007 990-PF
Enhanced Education
1. Trade Name Registration

2. Goldman Sachs
3. Morgan Stanley/Dean Witter
4. Bear Stearns
5. Acceptance of Conditions of Gift-Antilles School

6. Invoices
7. Certificate of Good Standing
8. Perry Partners and "hot issues"
9. Schedule K-1 2003
10. Thank you Letters

11. GS Capital II Consent to Extend the Fund Term Until 4/15/09
12. Consulting Agreement Enhanced Education & Ben Goertzel

13. Edge Foundation/John Brockman
14. Marvin Minsky
15. Distribution Carryover
16. Form 990
17. First Bank of the VI online banking authorization

18. Grant Agreement Oct. 1, 2008 (btwn J Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation aka
Enhanced Education & the COUQ Foundation)

19. Expenditure Responsibility —Grant to COUQ
Epstein Interests aka J. Epstein Foundation
1. Correspondence

2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memoranda
5. Trust Agreements and Amendments
6. EIN
7. Worker's Compensation

8. Contribution to American Agenda/Ezra Reese
9. Application for Recognition of Exemption
10. Charities Registration Form

11. Distribution Carryover
12. JP Morgan POA
13. Form 990PF Incomplete Filing Notice
Max Foundation
1. Correspondence

2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Contributions
6. Trust Agreement
7. Consents of Trustees

8. Appointments of Trustees
9. Determination of Exempt Status
10. Resignation of Trustees
11. Trust Account Agreement

12. Donations 1997
13. Check for Annual Report-Charities Estates and Trusts Bureau
14. Distribution Carryover

15. 2007 990-PF
Max Hotel Services Corp.
1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Certificate of Formation

6. SS-4
7. Application for Registration as a Sales Tax Vendor
8. Resale Certificate
9. Certificate of Authority

10. Business Tax Account Update
11. NY State ID #, File #, Filing Period
12. Biennial Statement
13. Miscellaneous Purchases
Darren K. Indyke PLLC

I. Articles of Organization
2. EIN
3. Form TR-570 Information Request
4. JP Morgan Chase Account
5. Agreement with
HBRK Associates Inc.

1. Certificate of Incorporation
2. EIN
DRAWER TWO:
407 Helicopter Operating File
1. Potential Sale
2. Aviation Insurance Review

3. Charter Possibility
4. Private/Public Partnership Agreement
5.
JEGE, Inc. Organizational File
1. Correspondence

2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memoranda
5. JEGE, Inc. Certificate of Incorporation
6. S-Election
7. SS-4

8. Entity Services Sublease Agreement
9. New Maintenance Program JEGE Inc.
10. Franchise Tax
JEGE, Inc. Operational File

I. Quiet Wing Purchase Agreement
2. Boeing Fuel Tank Repair
JEGE, Inc. Purchase of Boeing 727-31 Aircraft

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memoranda
5. Memorandum of Understanding
6. Acknowledgement of Receipt of Deposit

7. Aircraft Purchase Agreement
8. Acknowledgement of Receipt and Acceptance of Aircraft
9. Evidence of Toija Beutler's Authority to Sign Documents on Behalf of Real Estate
Exchange, Inc.
10.Closing Agenda
11.Conveyance Recordation Notice
12.Title Service Invoice
13.Wiring Instructions
14.Aircraft Registration Application
15.O00 Lien Filing
16.Aircraft Bill of Sale

17. Certificate of Insurance
18.Declaration of International Operations
19.Termination Letter to Paramount Logistics
20.Refurbishment Specification by International Jet Interiors
21.Refurbishment Invoice
22.Interior Refurbishments Status
23.Contact Information
24.Completion Specification
25.TIMCO
26.Drafts
Hyperion Air Miscellaneous

I. Hyperion Air Inc. Delaware Office
2. Hyperion Air - Insurance
3. Universal Weather and Aviation, Inc.

4. Dallas Airmotive, Inc.- 10 Year Core Inspection
5. Noise Abatement at Teterboro
6. Interior refurbishment proposals for the Gulfstream

7. Gulfstream Service January 2007
8. Hyperion Air Inc. Like Kind Exchange Binder
Purchase of Bell 407 Helicopter

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
S. Bill of Lading
6. Bill of Sale
7. Insurance

8. Purchase Agreement
9. Delivery Receipt
10. EA Quotation
11.Cancellation Certificate
12.Aircraft Bill of Sale
13.Wire Transfers
14.Offer
15.Shipment
16.Customs Power of Attorney
17.Vibration Test Results

18. Mortgage Details
19.Acceptance Letter
20.Tariff Duty and Entry Requirements
21.Lien and Title Search
22.Pre-Purchase Inventory
23.Mann Aviation

24. Certificate of Registration
25.Export Certificate of Airworthiness
26. Conditions for Inspections Report

27. Discrepancies and Due Items
28.Aircraft Documents includes in Sale
29.Robard Bank Details
30.Additional Items Pricing
31.Escrow Account
32.Airworthiness Directives
33.Invoices
Plan D, LLC/ Plan D Inc.

1. Certificate of Incorporation
2. EIN
3. Entity Services
4. Invoices
5. Plan D, LLC
S-76C++ 760667 Sale

I. Letter of Intent to Purchase by Five Star Holding Company LLC (Must Organize)
2. Helicopter Brokerage Agreement b/w Air Ghislaine and Aircraft Servicesh

3. Like Kind Exchange Account Statement for the 576C++
Sale of Boeing 727
Purchase of S-76C S7TD6167A
1. Turbomeca Warranty
Puchase of Bell 609 (Bell 417 not being made)
Purchase of S-76D
Lufthansa/Bar ( Boeing Business Jet) Specs
The Hyperion Trust Organizational File
The Hyperion Trust Purchase of Gulfstream G650

1. Correspondence
4. Research
5. Attorney Notes
6. Memoranda
7. Letter of Intent
Acquisition of Execujet

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Contacts
6. Purchase Agreement
7. Assets

8. Wire Instructions
9. Corporate Documents of Hairoun
10. Lease agreement and Amendment b/w VI Port Authority and Hairoun

11. Assignment of Lease between Port Authority and Hairoun
12. Terms of Leasehold with VIPA and Hairoun
13. Spill Prevention Plan and Addendum

14. Small Business Administration Loan Eric Williams
15. Due Diligence ( ALSO SEE BINDER)
16. Hairoun Complaint
Four Star Aviation. Inc.

1. Lease Agreement VI Port Authority and Four Star Aviation, Inc. Cyril E. King Airport
2. Lease Agreement VI Port Authority and Four Star Aviation, Inc.
Thomas World Air LLC Lease of Space at Cyril E. King Airport

8. Letter of Intent to Lease
2. VIPA Application for Space/Tenant Information
EAL Enterprises LLC
1. Correspondence

2. Research
3. Attorney Notes
4. Memorandum
5. Certificate of Formation
Thomas World Enterprises LLC
1. Correspondence

2. Research
3. Attorney Notes
4. Memorandum
5. Certificate of Formation
Acquisition of Execuiet Flight Services

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Purchase Agreement
6. Purchase Order Agreement/Assets

7. Corporate Documents of Hairoun Aviation Services
8. Assignment of Lease b/w Port Authority and Hairoun

9. Terms of Leasehold between Hairoun and the Port Authority
10.Spill Prevention Plan and Addendum Hairoun

11. Lease Agreement and Amendment Hairoun and VI Port Authority
12. Lease Agreement between VI Port Authority and Four Star Aviation, Inc. Cyril E. King
Airport St. Thomas

13. Lease Agreement between VI Port Authority and Four Star Aviation, Inc. Henry H.
Rohlsen Airport St. Croix
14.Small Business Administration Loan with David Eric Williams

15. Wire Instructions
Air Ghislaine, Inc. Organizational File
1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research

4. Memoranda
5. Certificate of Incorporation
6. SS-4
7. Form 2553
8. GMAIR, LLC
9. Corporate filings
Flight Options
-Exchange Agreement March 2009
-Comparative Specifications of Exchanged Aircraft
FIFTH DRAWER
Wexner Miscellaneous

I. YLK Charitable Fund
2. Annual Inv for Statutory Representation for Buckeye, LLC
3. 1099-DIV for the RHREI Trust
Extra Molvneux Binders and St. James Binder
╔══════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
       Caterpillar Trust [epstein] Epstein financial trust 
       Financial Ballistics, LLC [epstein] Epstein company 
     Liquid Funding [epstein] Epstein company [craigunger] 
 Cathy Alexander [employee] property manager at the island 
                                Scott Denett [employee] IT 
                 Laurie Cameron [finance] currency trading 
    Alan Dlugash [lawyer] tax partner at Paneth and Shrone 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00299927 (Jmail)
 [money] inventory of the contents of FILE CABINET TWO, includes James Cayne estate plan
(approximate date: 2019-07-06)
FILE CABINET TWO
DRAWER ONE:
Financial Trust Company, Inc. Organizational File (FTC)

0. Correspondence
I. Attorney Notes
2. Research
3. Memoranda
4. Articles of Incorporation
5. By-Laws
6. Minutes

7. EIN
8. S-Election
9. Certificate of Good Standing
10. Tax Documents
II. FTC Resignations Acceptances

12. Business Licenses
13. Report of Stockholders on Tax Exempted Entities
14. Miscellaneous
15. Corporate Resolutions (NOT IN FOLDER as of July 30, 2010)

16. FTC Application for Tax Filing and Payment Status Report Licensing
17. FTC Chase Business Account
18. FTC letterhead

19. JP Morgan Account Docs (March 2010)
20. 2010 ISDA Agreement (Collateral Agreement FTC & JPM)
21. Bernard Andersen/ Bank Account Docs SIGNED

22. Valartis Bank BLANK Docs from Bernard Andersen
23. Valartis Bank Confirmation of Corporate Resolution

24. Valartis Correspondence
25. Valartis W9 Taxpayer ID Number & Certification
26. Waste Hauling Citation (Steve Rampino)

27. Liquid Funding Sale of Class A Voting Units
28. Annual Report, June 30, 2012
29. Report of Stockkholders on Tax Exempted Entities
30. Withdrawal from MLHertz
31. EDC Renewal Application 2011
FINANCIAL TRUST (FTC) TRANSACTION FILE
-JPM NEW DODD-FRANK ACCOUNT DOCS
STC OPERATING FILE (SOUTHERN TRUST CO)
CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT W/ALAN DLUGASH & MARKS PANETH
Purchase of $1N1 NI 9% convertible Debentures of Environmental Solutions Worldwide, Inc
(ESW)
-Correspondence
-Subscription Agreement
-Form of Debenture
-Cap Table
-Escrow Agreement
-Registration Rights Agreement
-Previously Aquired Shares of Common Stock
-Wire Transfer, March 19, 2010
-Revised Capitalization Table, March 5, 2010
-Stock Certificate for 2,002,959 shares, March 29, 2010
-Notice of Mandatory Conversion
-Environmental Solution Securities Filing
-Exchange Act Filings
-Share Certificate for 175,883 Shares of Common Stock, Nov. 30, 2010
-MFN Acknowledgment
-Prospectus RTS Offering June 30, 2011
-Stock Cert July 14, 2011 for 6,333,333 shares and 2,333,595 shares
-Form 8-K
-13G and Information re Basis for Percentages Used
-Stock Holdings
FT Real Estate Inc. Aquistion of Interests in Lofts 21 LLC & AdvanceStar
LLC
-Correspondence
-Assignment of Membership Interests-AdvanceStar LLC
-Joinder Agreement-Advancestar LLC
-Operating Agreement-AdvanceStar LLC
-Assignment of Membership Interst-Lofts 21 LLC
-Joinder Agreement -Lofts 21 LLC
-Operating Agreement -Lofts 21 LLc
-Wire Transfer Instructions
-Wire Transfer
-Disclaimer of Consent Rights
-Lender Consent
-Project Reports
-Due Diligence
-Annual Report, June 30,2012
FT REAL ESTATE INC'S INVESTMENT IN 183 COLUMBIA HOLDING LLC
-Correspondence
-Offering Memorandum
-Subscription Agreement
-Operating Agreement
-Schedule of Capital Contributions as of May 14, 2013
-Press Clippings
-Superseded Subscription Agreement by Mort Inc
SITRICK VS JEFFREY EPSTEIN
-Correspondence
-American Arbitration Association Selection of Arbitrator Letter April 10,
2012
-Notice of Appointment Letter from American Arbitration, May 4, 2012
-Hannigan Dorman Letter Representing Sitrick
-Sitrick Engagement Letter to Roy Black
-American Arbitration Invoices
-Summary of Sitrick Engagement Letter Provisions
-Sitrick Invoices
-Proof of Service for Demand Arbitration
-Attorney's Notes
-Memo from Re Improper Service of Summons & Complaint
-Summons & Complaint
-Legal Research
-Summons & Complaint Mailed to 358 El Brillo, Rec'd 6-11-13
-Case Management Statement
-Notice of Default
-Request For Entry of Default Judgement
-Order Re Default Judgment Hearing (Oct. 16, 2013)
2011 CATERPILLAR TRUST
-2011 Caterpillar Trust Agreement
2011 BUTTERFLY TRUST
-2011 Butterfly Trust Agreement
GRATITUDE AMERICA, LTD.
-Articles of Incorporation
- Application for Recognition of Exemption Form 1023
SOUTHERN TRUST CO, INC ORGANIZATIONAL FILE
-Certificate of Amendment To Articles of Incorporation of Financial Infomatics,
Inc.
-Annual Report Domestic/Foreign Corporation for Financial Infomatics, Inc.
-Business License
-First Bank Bank Account Documents
SOUTHERN TRUST CO, INC. EDC APPLICATION
-EDC Application
-Annual Report Domestic/Foreign Corp
PURCHASE & SALE BY BLACK FAMILY PARTNERS, LP FROM FINANCIAL TRUST
COMPANY, INC. OF INTERESTS IN ENVIRONMENTAL SOLUTIONS WORLDWIDE,
INC, AP SHL INVESTORS, LLC & AP TECHNOLOGY PARTNERS LLC
-Purchase & Sale Agreement
-Schedule 3.2-Allocation Schedule
-Consent by Managing Member of AP SHL
-Consent by Manager of AP Tech
-Assignment & Assumption Agreement for Membership Interest in AP SHL
- Assignment & Assumption Agreement for Membership Interest in AP Tech
-Limited Liability Company Agreement Member Signature Page for AP SHL
-Limited Liability Company Agreement Member Signature Page for AP Tech
-Irrevocable Stock Power for 13,198,711 Shares of ESWW Common Stock
-Irrevocable Stock Transfer Instruction for 151,494 Shares of ESWW Common
Stock
-Copies of Stock Certificates for ESWW Common Stock with Stock Powers Signed
in Blank
-Notice of Wire Transfer Instructions to Eileen Alexanderson
-Old Backup Documentation for ESWW Interests
AIRCRAFT REGISTRATION
-N909JE
-N908JE
-N331JE
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN TRUST & INSURANCE TRUST
DISSOLUTION & LIQUIDATION FORMS
PURCHASE OF SERIES 5 PREFERRED STOCK & COMMON STOCK OF ALIPHCOM
-Correspondence
-Research
-Capitalization Table
-Valuation Reports
-Financial Statements
-Evidence of Payment
-Series 5 Preferred & Common Stock Purchase Agreement
-Schedule of Exceptions to Representation & Warranties
-Secretary's Certificate (Includes: Amended & Restated Articles of Incorporation
of AliphCom, Bylaws of AliphCom, Resolution of the Board of Directors of
AliphCom)
-President's Compliance Certificate
-Legal Opinion
-Waiver & Acknowledgement Series 5 Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement
-Side Letter Agreement
-Amendment to Sixth Amended & Restated Investor Rights Agreement
-Amendment to fourth Amended & Restated Voting Agreement
-Amendment to Third Amended & Restated Right of First Refusal Agreement
-Series 5 Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement of Prior Investors
-Sixth Amended & Restated Investor Rights Agreement
-Fourth Amended & Restated Voting Rights Agreement
-Third Amended & Restated Right of First Refusal Agreement
-Copy of Series 5 preferred Stock Certificate
-Copy of Common Stock Certificate
CHOCOLATE CHARITABLE REMAINDER UNITRUST
-Trust Agreement
STC- LEON BLACK
-Estate Plan Service Letter
ADFIN SOLUTIONS
-Stock Certificates
-Series A Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement
-2" Amendment to Series A Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement
-Capitalization Table
-Written Consent of Stockholder to Amendment to Amended & Restated 2012
Equity Incentive Plan
-$2MM Bridge Note Financing Dec. 2013
DRAWER TWO:
GULFSTREAM FLIGHT LOGS 2006
BOEING FLIGHT LOGS 2006
CELLULAR RECORD
TRANSFER INCARCERATION TO USVI MEMO
GUEST WAIVER
GUESTS -WAIVER HORSES
JEE SPECIAL RESIDENCY
LIABILITY AGREEMENT
GUEST RELEASE FORMS & CONTACTS
RAYTHEON TRAVEL AIR BINDER #1
RAYTEHON TRAVEL AIR BINDER #2
JEE TAX FILINGS/TAX RETURNS 2007
TAX RETURNS
THE 2001 JEE INSURANCE TRUST
WILL & ESTATE PLANNING
-The JEE 2001 Trust One
-The JEE 2001 Trust Two
-Last Will & Testiment
THE 2007 JE INSURANCE TRUST #1. #2. #3
DKI PERSONAL & CONFIDENTIAL MEMOS FROM CLIENT JE
POWER OF ATTORNEY JEE TO DKI
SCHANTZ/WEXNER EXECUTED AGREEMENT
JE INSURANCE TRUST 1996
1998 JE INSURANCE TRUST DATED 8/20/1998
DURABLE GENERAL POWER OF ATTORNEY
ESTATE PLAN JAMES CAYNE
SUPERSEDED LAST WILL & TESTIMENT ASW & LHWOK
DRAWER THREE:
New York Strategy Group. LLC Organizational File

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memoranda
5. Articles of Organization
6. Publication

7. Biennial Statement
8. Operating Agreement
Sale of New York Strategy Group. LLC to Darren K. Indyke
1. Sale Agreement

2. Pledge Agreement ( See Wall file)
3. Assignment and Acceptance
4. Secured Non-Recourse Promissory Note( See WCTII File)

5. Fund Transfer
6. Fire Safety Plan for Office at 301 E. 66th Street
The Haze Trust
I. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes

3. Research
4. Memoranda
5. Trust Agreement
6. Bear Stearns Trading Authorization
7. Bear Stearns Customer Agreement

8. Bear Stearns transactions
9. Goldman Sachs Futures Account
10. Certificate of Trustees Regarding Authority To Open or Administer Securities
Accounts

II. Authorization Letter
12. Form W-9
13. Substitute Form W-9
14. SS-4
15. FINRA Rule 5131, April 28, 2011

16. Transfer of 5 Million Dollars to JP Morgan
JE MISC. 2012
OLD CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENTS FROM ALL ENTITIES
FIREARM LICENSING
Dershowitz Legal Fees
Dershowitz Lexus/Gift Tax
PURCHASE OF SCORPIOS ISLAND
NICK LAMBROSE LETTER FROM DARREN & COMPLAINT
2ND PASSPORT FOR
2ND PASSPORT FOR JEFFREY EPSTEIN
PASSPORT
WOODY ALLEN PASSPORTS (FAMILY INCLUDED)
SCORPIOS ISLAND
LARRY NEWMAN
PORT AUTHORITY PROPOSAL FOR LEASE & DEVELOPMENT OF NEW HANGER
VOTING RIGHTS 2010 VI ELECTION
JE MISC JEFF SCHANTZ
LOCK INFORMATION FOR 11B (also how to Hard Reset Lock)
DAVID MITCHELL/INVESTMENT IN CARNEGIE DELI
FBI FOIA REQUEST (FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT)
CRAIG MARTIN
DIVORCE SUBPOENA
BORIS NIKOLIC HEALTH CARE PROXY
US CUSTOMS & BORDER PROTECTION FOIA REQUEST
NSA FOIA Request
JOHN DUFFY-JP MORGAN- TERMINATE RELATIONSHIP
STEVE HOFFENBERG
REPUTATION MANAGEMENT
-Ian Osborne
-Macintyre Internet Representation Agreement
-Arctic Management Services
Promissory Notes

A. Promissory Note Miles and Cathy Alexander
B. Promissory Note Emad Hanna
C. Promissory Note to Victor Cosmeceuticals Inc.

D. Promissory Note
E. Promissory Notes
F. Promissory Note Tatiana Siminava and Settlement Agreement
G. Promissory Note Dave Lampert

H. Promissory Note
I. Promissory Note Anat Barak and Yoed Nir
J. Promissory Note
K. Promissory Note Hank and Rona Klien

L. Port Authority Proposal for Lease & Development of New Hanger
M. General Release of Claims
N. Jerry Goldsmith Promissory Note

O. Adam Bly Promissory Note and Membership Interest Pledge Agreement-
Adam Bly Promissory Note/Judgement
P. Barry Josephson Promissory Note
Q. Sept. 19, 2011
R. Delson Note, May 2, 2013
S. Eileen Visoski Loan
Adam Bly Collection
Correspondence
Barry Fertel Retainer
Exemption Notice
Notice to Judgement Debtor or Obliger
Retraining Notice to Garnishee
Restraining Notice Judgment Debtor
- Research
The United Fund
-Correspondence
-Attorney's Notes
-Trust Agreement
-Tax ID
-Application for Exemption
-NY Registration
-Grant Agreement
PALM BEACH CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENTS
Palm Beach Confidentiality Agreements Signed
Blank PB Confidentiality Agreement
FINANCIAL BALLISTICS TRUST
Certificate of Trust
Declaration of Trust
Agreement with CT Corp
Annual Report, June 30, 2012
SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC, JP Morgan Docs
-Account Docs (JP Morgan)
-Subscription & Transfer Docs (JP Mogan)
SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC OPERATING FILE
-$50 Million Line of Credit w/JPM
-Transfer of Funds (Highbridge Capital, Tudor, ABS)
-Dodd Frank
SOUTHERN TRUST CO LLC , JP MORGAN DOCS
-Account Docs (JP Morgan)
-Laurie Cameron
SOUTHERN TRUST CO LLC, OPERATING FILE
-Account Docs (JP Morgan)
-Credit Card Indemnity
-Documents for 10 <Million Line of Credit for JPM Credit
-Dodd Frank
ALAN DLUGASH
-Confidentiality and Non Solicitation Agreement
ADFIN SOLUTIONS
2013 CATERPILLAR/BUTTERFLY TRUSTS
-MARKS PANETH DETERMINATION OF ANNUITY PERCENTAGE FOR CATERPILLAR
GRAT
-IRREVOCABLE STOCK POWER FOR 1000 SHARES OF COMMON STOCK OF MORT,
INC
-THE 2013 CATERPILLAR TRUST
-THE 2013 BUTTERFLY TRUST
-GIFT TAX RETURN
-ANNUITY TRANSFERS
-TRANSFER TO 2013 BUTTERFLY TRUST
DRAWER FOUR:
Blank Confidentiality Agreements
ZWIRN
-Zwirn Litigation Fee Agreement from Steve Susman
-Signed Susman Agreement to represent JE in JAMS Arbitration Against DB Zwirn (W9
included)
-Susman Godfrey Invoices for DB Zwim
ZWIRN SETTLEMENT
-Correspondence
-Master Settlement Agreement
-Fully Executed Assignment of Economic Interest Agreement (Dubin)
-Fully Exectued Settlement & Release Agreement (Dubin)
-Inducement Agreement (Corbin)
-Interest Purchase Agreement (Corbin)
-Consent & Release Agreement (Corbin)
-Assignment & Assumption Agreement (Corbin Capital Partners, LP)
-Assignment & Assumption Agreement (Corbin Capital Partners Mngt, LLC)
-Corbin Due Diligence
-Contextual Analysis of Tax Ownership
-Master Settlement Agreement Mediation
-Settlement Terms to be Read Into the Record
-Fortress Value Recovery Fund I, LLC: Authorizations to Provide Information
-Notification to Fortress Re Authorization of Harry Beller
COUO Operatinu File
House Ethics Committee
Biosocial Research Foundation
Grant to Biosocial Research Foundation
Grant Agreement March 15, 2010
Grant Agreement Junl, 2009
Grant Agreement March 16, 2009
Grant Agreement Oct. 1, 2008
Reports to Enhanced Education
COUQ Foundation, Inc. Organizational ( cl/b/a Florida Science Foundation)

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Certificate of Incorporation
6. By-Laws

7. Minutes and Consents
8. Notification/Release of Information Form
9. IRS Determination Letter
10. NY Application for Authority to do Business

11. S5-4
12. 1023 Application for Recognition as Exemption
13. Annual Franchise Tax Report
14. Annual Invoice for Statutory Representation

15. Charities Registration Request 9-9-99
16. NY Charities Registration Statement
17. Determination of Exempt Status

18. Balance Sheets
19. Tax Returns 2006
20. COUQ Tax Preparation February 2008
21. Filed 2007 Form 990-PF

22. Qualification to conduct Business in Florida
23. Fictitious Name Registration as Florida Science Foundation

24. Distribution Carryover
25. Florida Science Foundation Wachovia Bank Account
26. FSF Phone Lines
27. FSF Liability Insurance

28. FSF Office Lease @ One Clearlake and Amendment
29. FSF Application for Consumer Certificate of Exemption

30. FSF Security
31. FSF Expenses
32. FSF Invoices from Comiter, Singer, Baseman and Braun
33. FSF Correspondence

34. FSF Office Lease Second Amendment (April 1, 09- July 31, 09)
35. Grant Agreement Oct. 1, 2008 (btwn J Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation aka
Enhanced Education & the COUQ Foundation

36. Info Regarding Replacement of Florida Accountant
37. Expenditure Responsibility Grant from Enhanced Education

38. COUQ FSF Establishing Presence in PB (Cert. of Incorp., Fictitious Name
Registration, Florida Qualification, IRS Tax Exemption Ltr, Minutes)

39. FSF LLC Operating Agreement
40. IRS change of address form for COUQ
41. FSF, LLC Annual Reports
42. Annual Report, June 30, 2012
DISSOLUTION OF THE COUQ FOUNDATION, INC
-Consent of Board Directors Authorizing Renewal & Revival of Charter
-Certificate of Renewal & Revival of Charter
-Plan of Liquidation
-Consent of Board of Directors Authorizing Dissolution
-Certificate of Dissolution-Delaware
-Evidence of Filing of Termination with the Secretary of State of the State of New York
-Form Char 500
-990 PF
-Transmittal Letter to NY Charities Bureau

J. Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation -Organizational
1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum

5. Minutes
6. Article of Incorporation
7. By-Laws
8. EIN
9. 2007 Form 990-PF
10. Chase Account Documents

11. Bear Stearns Account Documents
12. Goldman Sachs Account Documents
13. 501(c)(3) Application
14. Form 8718 Determination Letter Request

15. Determination Letter
16. 2007 990-PF
17. Resignations of & Jeanne Brennan as Trustees and Officers,
Effective as of Feb. 29, 2012

18. Resignation of Darren K. Indyke as President, Effective as of Feb 29, 2012
19. Consent of Sole Trustee Electing Jeffrey Epstein & Erika Kellerhals as directors,
Effective as of March 1, 2012

20. Unanimous Consent of Trustees Electing Officers, Effective as of March 1, 2012
ENHANCED EDUCATION
1. Trade Name Registration

2. Goldman Sachs
3. Morgan Stanley/Dean Witter
4. Bear Stearns
5. Acceptance of Conditions of Gift-Antilles School

6. Invoices
7. Certificate of Good Standing
8. Perry Partners and "hot issues"
9. Schedule K-1 2003
10. Thank you Letters

11. GS Capital II Consent to Extend the Fund Term Until 4/15/09
12. Consulting Agreement Enhanced Education & Ben Goertzel

13. Edge Foundation/John Brockman
14. Marvin Minsky
15. Distribution Carryover
16. Form 990
17. First Bank of the VI online banking authorization

18. Grant Agreement Oct. 1, 2008 (btwn J Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation aka
Enhanced Education & the COUQ Foundation)

19. Grant to the United Fund
20. Grant Agreement March 15, 2010
21. Grant Agreement June 1, 2009
22. Grant Agreement March 16, 2009

23. Grant Agreement Oct. 1, 2009
24. Reports From COUQ Foundation
25. Scientist Symposium Island, Nov. 12, 2010 and Jan. 8, 2011

26. Agreement w/Yoed Nir (re cello)
27. Consulting Agreements w/Marvin Minsky & Gloria Rudish
28. Annual Report, June 30, 2012

29. Cello Agreement with Yoed Nir
EPSTEIN INTERESTS 2012 (AKA J. EPSTEIN FOUNDATION
-TRUST AGREEMENT & AMENDMENT(S)
Darren K. Indyke PLLC

I. Articles of Organization
2. EIN
3. Form TR-570 Information Request
4. JP Morgan Chase Account
5. Agreement with

6. Agreement with Scott Denett (to work for HBRK)
7. Retainer Agreement with HBRK Associates
8. Biennial Statement 2010

9. 2011 IT204 E-Filing
HBRK Associates Inc.
1. Certificate of Incorporation
2. EIN
CDE INC Organizational
Correspondence
Attorneys Notes
Research
Memoranda
Articles of Incorporation
Consent of Agent for Service of Process
Bylaws
Waiver of Notice of the 1" Meeting of Incorporators
Minutes of 151 Meeting of Incorporators
Resignation of Incorporators
Employer ID#
VI S Election
Minutes of Board of Directors
Minutes of Shareholders
Stock Issuance
Annual Report, June 30, 2012
MORT INC. Organizational
Correspondence
Attorneys Notes
Research
Memoranda
Articles of Incorporation
Consent of Agent for Service of Process
Bylaws
Waiver of Notice of the 1" Meeting of Incorporators
Minutes of 151 Meeting of Incorporators
Resignation of Incorporators
Employee ID #
VI S Election
Minutes of Board of Directors
Minutes of Shareholders
Stock Issuance
Transfer of DKI Shares to Mort Inc.
Annual Report, June 30, 2012
TRANSFER OF 358 EL BRILLO WAY (DARREN HAS THESE FOLDERS)
-DEED
-ASSIGNMENT AGREEMENT OF ASSETS JE TO LAUREL, INC.
-WARRANTY DEED SEPT. 17, 1990 FROM HERBERT GLASS TO JEFFREY EPSTEIN
FLIGHT LOGS 2011 Binder
FLIGHT LOGS 2012 BINDER
FLIGHT LOGS 2013
MORT INC CORPORATE BINDER
PLAN D, INC. CORPORATE BOOK
POPLAR INC CORPORATE BINDER (This is NOT in the Cabinet AS OF
10-10-12!)
THE COUO FOUNDATION INC CORPORATE BINDER
CDE INC CORPORATE BINDER
FT REAL ESTATE INC CORPOR 11 L BINDER
NAUTILUS CORPORATE BINDER
CYPRESS INC. CORPORATE BINDER
LESLIE H. WEXNER SALE OF NINE EAST 71ST STREET
CORPORATION TO NES, LLC
DRAWER FIVE:
22 Avenue Foch, PARIS APARTMENT

1. JEP
2. Wealth Tax
3. Banking
4. Damage from the Third Floor Apartment
5. Marie Joseph Experton Invoices

6. Annual General Meeting of Co-Owners (Agenda and Power of Attorney doc)
7. Units Owned by SCI JEP as of July 12, 2011 at 22 Ave. Foch

8. Transfer of DKI Shares to Mort, Inc.
9. 2012 Annual Meeting
10. June 2013 Annual Meeting
11.2013 Annual Meeting
NES. LLC Organizational File and Rich Barnett Union Docs

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Articles of Organization
6. Operating Agreement

7. Form SS-4
8. Notice of Formation
9. Rich Barnett Union Document
10.Form of Confidentiality Agreement
11.Estate Reports
12.Operating Agreement
Zorro Development Corp. Organizational File

1. Certificate of Incorporation
2. SS-4
Zorro Ranch, LLC Organizational File (Gave to Darren ON APRIL 21, 2010-GAVE BACK on July 9,
2010-some folders are missing}

10. Zorro Trust Agreement
11. Articles of Organization
12. Operating Agreement
13. Franchise Tax Report
14. Invoice for Statutory Representation

15. Sale and Purchase Agreement LHW to JEE
16. JP Morgan POA 6-26.08
17. Form of Confidentiality Agreement
Zorro Ranch, LLC Operating File
-Larry Visoski Property Purchase (Transaction)
-April 2010 Docs from Janice Ahern
-April 2010 Subpoena
-Transfer of Discharge Permit
-Discharge Permit change of Responsible Party 6-28-13
Zorro Ranch Well Development

1. Well Development 2005 - 2006
2. Well Development 2007-2008
3. Zorro Ranch Water Rights Abstract Report 9-1-2005 (LOCATED ON TOP OF CABINET IN
WHITE BINDER)

4. Dakota Well Beneficial Use (Order Requesting Status) Oct. 19, 2010
5. Zorro Trust Settlement (Dakota Well)

6. Water Rights Documents
Zorro Ranch Grazing Leases
I. BLM Grazing Leases
2. Eddy L. Burns Grazing License
7. State Agricultural Lease
ZORRO WATER 2012-2013
-WELL K DRILLING & TESTING MEMO, OCT. 12, 2012
TRANSFER OF ZORRO RANCH TO CYPRESS, INC
Correspondence
Quit Claim Deed from JE to Cypress
Specialty Warranty Deed
Zorro Trust Assignment
Change Ownership of Water Rights for File No. E-06009
Change Ownership of Water Rights for File No. E-06010
Change Ownership of Water Rights for File No. E-08976
Change Ownership of Water Rights for File No. E-07871
Change Ownership of Water Rights for File No. E-06008
Change Ownership of Water Rights for File No. E-05509
Change Ownership of Water Rights for File No. E-06478
Assignment of State Land Office Grazing Lease No. GR-2088
Assignment of State Land Office Grazing Lease No. GR-2122
Assignment of State Right of Way Easement No. RW-30137
Bureau of Land Management (BLM) Lease Transfer Packet
2013 Real Property Tax Protest
Application for Extension of Time to Perfect Appropriation of Underground Water
ZORRO RANCH, LLC
-Co-tenancy with Larry Visoski
TRANSFER OF 9 EAST 71sT STREET
-Recorded Deed
-Assignment and Assumption Agreement NES to Maple, Inc
Ownership
-Assignment and Assumption Agreement JEE to Maple, Inc.
-Assignment and Assumption Agreement NES to Maple, Inc
-NYCRPT Return
-NYS Real Property Transfer Tax Return
-Smoke Detector Affidavit
-E Tax Forms Questionnaire
-Transfer Docs Executed in NY- Not Used/Superceded
9 East 715 Street Operating File
Otis Elevator
Con Edison Residential VS Commercial Building Analysis
Neptune, LLC Organizational File
-Correspondence
-Attorney's Notes
-Articles of Organization
-Operating Agreement
-Bank Account
-Employee Identification if
-Certificate of Formation
-Consent to Use of Name, May 11, 2012
MAPLE INC Organizational
Articles of Incorporation
Incorporators Consents
Bylaws
Subscription Agreement
Stock Certificate
. of Beneficial
of Assets
. of Assets
Initial Consent of Directors
Initial Stockholder's Consent
Tax Identification Number (ID #)
Virgin Islands S Election
NY S Election
Maple I Trust
Maple II Trust
Annual Report, June 30, 2012
CYPRESS INC Organizational
Articles of Incorporation
Incorporators Consents
Bylaws
Subscription Agreement
Stock Certificate
Initial Consent of Directors
Initial Stockholder's Consent
Tax Identification Number (ID #)
Virgin Islands S Election
Cypress I Trust
Cypress II Trust
Annual Report, June 30, 2012
LAUREL INC Organizational
Articles of Incorporation
Incorporators Consents
Bylaws
Subscription Agreement
Stock Certificate
Initial Consent of Directors
Initial Stockholder's Consent
Tax Identification Number (ID #)
Virgin Islands S Election
Laurel I Trust
Laurel II Trust
Annual Report, June 30, 2012
Landmark Application for 328 El Vedado Road
LAUREL, INC.-ZONING VARIANCE APPLICAION FOR 319 EL VEDADO ROAD BY
VIRGINIA MORTARA
-Variance Application by Mortara
-Florida DEP Petition by Mortara
-Retainer Letter for Lewis Longman & Walker
-Request for Enlargement of Time to Petition for DEP Hearing
-Palm Beach Ordiances RE Bulkheads & Pierheads on Lake Worth
-Petition for Formal Administration Hearing before the Florida DEP
NAUTILUS INC organizational
Articles of Incorporation
Incorporators Consents
Bylaws
Subscription Agreement
Stock Certificate
Initial Consent of Directors
Initial Stockholder's Consent
Tax Identification Number (ID #)
Virgin Islands S Election
Nautilus I Trust
Nautilus II Trust
Settlement Agreement between VI Government Dept of Planning & Natural
Resources & Nautilus
Annual Report, June 30, 2012
Payment of $50,000 for Notice of Violation Issued to Nautilus
-Notice of Violation/Settlement
SUBSEQUENT CLOSING OF PURCHASE BY SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC. OF
1,142,857 SHARES OF SERIES A PREFERRED STOCK OF AdFin SOLUTIONS, INC, A
DELAWARE CORP AS OF APRIL 10,2013
CLOSING DOCS
-Table of Contents for Closing Docs
-Series A Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement, dated Dec. 28, 2012 (STC signed in
a subsequent closing as of April 10, 2013)
-Schedule of Exceptions from Dec. 28, 2012 Closing
-Amendment to Series A Preferred Stock Purchase Agreement, dated April 10,
2013
-Compliance Certificate/Schedule of Exceptions/Bring Down for April 10, 2013
Closing
-Investors Rights Agreement, dated Dec. 28,2012 (STC signed in a subsequent
closing as of April 10,2013)
-Amendment to Investors Rights Agreement, dated April 5, 2013
-Right of First Refusal & Co-Sale Agreement, dated Dec. 28, 2012 (STC signed in a
subsequent closing as of April 10, 2013)
-Amendment to Right of First Refusal & Co-Sale Agreement, dated April 5, 2013
-Voting Agreement, dated Dec. 28, 2012 (STC signed in a subsequent closing as of
April 10,2013)
-Amendment to Voting Agreement dated April 5, 2013
-Unanimous Written Consent of the Board of Directors, dated Dec. 28, 2012
-Written Consent of Sole Stockholder, dated Dec. 28, 2012
-Amended & Restated Cert. of Incorporation of AdFin Solutions, Inc
-Delaware Good Standing Certificate, Dated Dec. 28, 2012
-Certified Copy of Date Stamped New York Application for Authority of AdFin
Solutions Inc
-SCS Letter, dated April 8, 2013, that AdFin Solutions Inc, is Active and in Good
Standing w/the NY & Delaware Secretaries of State
-Unanimous Written Consent of the Board of Directors, dated April 5, 2013
-Written Consent of Stockholders dated April 4, 2013, signed by Jonathan
Leitersdorf & David Mitchell
-Certificate of Amendment of Amended & restated Certificate of Incorporation of
AdFin Solutions, Inc, filed on April 10, 2013
-Capitalization Table as of April 10, 2013
-Stock Certificate for 1,142,857 shares of Series A Preferred Stock
-July 16, 2013 Investment
POPLAR, INC Organizational
-Annual Report, June 30, 2012
-The James E. Cavne Trust #5
BILLING DISPUTE BINDER FOR FOWLER WHITE
MAPLE INC CORPORATE BINDER
LAUREL INC CORPORATE BINDER
NINE (9) EAST 7151 STREET CORPORATE BINDER
EFTA00247131 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI search warrant for New York house
(date: 2019-07-07)
AO 03 (SONY Rev. Oil! 7) Search and Saluda Warm)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
Southern District of New York
In the Matter of the Search of
(Briefly describe the properly to be searched
or ;den* the person by name and address)
See Attachment A
) .
) Case No.
)
oMAG 6571
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the  Southern  District of  New 'MA__
(identify the person or describe the properly to be seareMed and give its location):
See Attachment A
The person or property to be searched, described above, is believed to conceal (Wen* the person or describe the property
to be seized):
See Attachment A
The search and seizure are related to violation(s) of (insert statutory citations):
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 371 and 1591
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the person or
property.
YOU ARE COMMANDED to execute this warrant on or before  July 7, 2019
(not to exceed 14 days)
O in the daytime 6:00 a.m. to 10 p.m. GI at any time in the day or night as I find reasonable cause has been
established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property
taken to the person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the
place where the property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present during the execution of ire s c r alaant,, must prepare an
inventory as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to the Oar or t *twin.
O Upon its return, this warrant and inventory should be filed under seal by the Clerk of theCoari.,
- i''' ' r — ' . 1pyr Initials
O I find that immediate notification may have an adverse result listed irt!.):137U,S.6. V2705 (excepLii delay
of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay notice to the person who,,or.,whose '00.4*, will be
searched or seized (check the appropriate box) O for days (not no exceed 3.0).- ' ,.:-. • - ' i
O until the facts justifyi latei:aliedtfic date o .:‘ I /
V.`•-;
1 -1 In 3'-cs7za . Date and time issued:
City and state: New York, NY
Judge'S signhture
Hon. Barbara Moses, U.S. Magistrate Judge
Printed name and title
A093 (SDNY Rev. 01/17)Starch and Seizure Warrant (Page 2)
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy of warrant and inventory left with:
Inventory made in the presence of :
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized:
Certification
I declare under penalty of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant
to the Court.
Date:
.
Executing officer's signature
Printed name and title
ATTACHMENT A

I. Premises to be Searched—Subject Premises
I. The premises to be searched (the "Subject Premises") are described as a multi-story
single-family residence located at 9 East 7Ist Street, New York, Ncw York, and include all locked
and closed containers found therein. A photograph of the front entrance to the Subject Premises
is included below:

H. Items to Be Seized
A. Evidence, Fruits, and Instrumentalities of the Subject Offenses
This warrant authorizes the seizure of certain evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of
violations of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of minors) and 371
(sex trafficking conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

i. Any and all taxidermied dogs.
ii. Any and all massage tables and massage paraphernalia.
iii. Any and all busts or three-dimensional representations of female human
torsos.

iv. Any and all photos or representations depicting nude or partially nude
women located in the Massage Room, as defined herein.
v. Any and all sex toys and sex paraphernalia located in the Massage
Room, as defined herein.
2017.08.02
AO93 (SDNY Rev. 01/17) Search and Seizure Warrant
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
Southern District of New York
In the Matter of the Search of
(Briefly describe the property to be searched
or identify the person by name and address)
See Attachment A
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the  Southern  District of  New York
(ia'entlfr the person or describe the property to be searched and give its location):
See Attachment A
The person or property to be searched, described above, is believed to conceal (+dent°, the person or describe the 
property
to be seized):
See Attachment A
The search and seizure are related to violation(s) of (insert statutory citations):
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 371 and 1591
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the person or
property.
YOU ARE COMMANDED to execute this warrant on or before  1 .20.  to • tett (not to exceed 14 days)
et in the daytime 6:00 a.m. to 10 p.m. Cl at any time in the day or night as 1 find reasonable cause has been
established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property
taken to the person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the
place where the property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present during the execution of the warrant, must prepare an
inventory as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to the Clerk of the Court.
O Upon its return, this warrant and inventory should be filed under seal by the Clerk of the Court.
USW Millais
O I find that immediate notification may have an adverse result listed in 18 U.S.C. § 2705 (except for dejay
of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay notice to the person who, or whose property, will 
be
searched or seized (check the appropriate box) Ofor  days (not to exceed 30).
Ountil, the facts justifying, jtte.latfr specific date of
Date and time issued: 1-.6. \ of•L‘k ck• itA •
City and state: New York, NY
Judge's signature,
Hon. Barbara Moses, U.S. Magistrate Judge
Printed name and title
AO 93 (SDNY Rev. 01/17) Search and Seizure Warrant (Page 2)
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy of warrant and inventory left with:
Inventory made in the presence of:
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized:
Certification
I declare under penalty of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant
t0 the Court.
Date: Executing officer's signature
Printed name and title
ATTACHMENT A

I. Premises to be Searched—Subject Premises
1. The premises to be searched (the "Subject Premises") are described as a nearly
19,000 square foot multi-story single-family residence located at 9 East 71st Street, New York,
New York, and include all locked and closed containers found therein. A photograph of the front
entrance to the Subject Premises is included below:

II. Items to Be Seized
1. This warrant authorizes executing agents to photograph, video record and otherwise
document the full interior of the Subject Premises, including any items, furnishings, or possessions
therein.

2. In addition, this warrant authorizes the seizure of certain evidence, fruits, and
instrumentalities of violations of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of
minors) and 371 (sex trafficking conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

a. Evidence concerning occupancy or ownership of the Subject Premises,
including utility and telephone bills, mail envelopes, addressed correspondence,
diaries, statements, identification documents, address books, telephone
directories, and photographs of its occupant(s).
b. Evidence concerning the layout, furnishings, decorations, and floor pattern of
the Subject Premises, including photographs and blueprints of the Subject
Premises.
2017.08.02
AO 93 (Rev. 11/13) Search and Seizure Warrant
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
District of Virgin Islands
In the Matter of the Search of
(Briefly describe the property to be searched
or identify the person by name and address)
Premises Known as Little Saint James Island, USVI, and
Any Buildings, Structures or Containers Thereupon
Case No. 2_01g -
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the   District of  the Virgin Islands
(identify the person or describe the property to be searched and give its location):
Premises Known and Described as LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND, U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS, and Any Buildings or Other
Structures Contained Thereon, and Any Locked or Closed Containers/Items Contained Therein.
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the person or 
property
described above, and that such search will reveal (identify the person or describe the property to be seized):
See Attachments A, ekerrtd-19
YOU ARE COMMANDED to execute this warrant on or before  August 24, 2019  (not to exceed /4 days)
O in the daytime 6:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. coat any time in the day or night because good cause has been established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property taken to 
the
person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the place where the
property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present during the execution of the warrant, must prepare an inventory
as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to  the Honorable Ruth Miller
(United States Magistrate Judge)
O Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 3103a(b), I find that immediate notification may have an adverse result listed in 18 U.S.C.
§ 2705 (except for delay of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay notice to the person who, 
or whose
property, will be searched or seized (check the appropriate box)
O for  30  days (not to exceed 30) O until, the facts justifying, the later sRecific date of
Date and time issued: (24 ,S bitlir  /lags
City and state:
Judge's signature

St. Thomas, VI Ruth Miller, United States Magistrate Judge
Printed name and title
AO 93 (Rev 11/13) Search and Seizure Warrant (Page 2)
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy of warrant and inventory left with:
Inventory made in the presence of:
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized:
Certification
I declare under penalty of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant to 
the
designated judge.
Date:
Executing officer's signature
Printed name and title
ATTACHMENT A

I. Premises to be Searched —Subject Premises
The Subject Premises are particularly described as a private island in the U.S. Virgin
Islands known as Little Saint James, any buildings or other structures contained thereon, and any
closed containers/items contained therein. Little Saint James is an approximately 75 acre island
located approximately four (4) miles off the southeast coast of St. Thomas. The Subject Premises
is depicted in the following photograph:
• t (tk.. a' I •tle %; J411/Cr.

40. 1•
The Subject Premises contains multiple structures, including but not limited to:
a. On the northeast end of the Subject Premises, there is a single story structure next
to a pool.

b. On the southwest end of the Subject Premises, there is a single-story, four-wall
structure. The walls are painted with blue and white stripes. The structure has large double doors
as its main entrance and large windows on the three remaining walls.

c. On the north east end of the Subject Premises, there are multiple structures. The
main structure is a single story residence (the "Main Residence") with a stone exterior, a blue roof,
and a white detailed exterior that includes white columns.

d. A separate structure ("Residence One") with a blue roof and stone exterior is at the
back of the Main Residence, located at the end of the northeast tip of the island and surrounded by
coastline on two of its sides.
2017.08.02

e. A second larger structure ("Residence Two) is set between the Main Residence and
the coastline.
f. Four smaller single story structures (the "Four Cabanas") are next to the Main
Residence and a large pool. All four smaller structures have blue roofs.

g. A third large structure ("Residence Three") set off from the four smaller structures
and next to the coast line is painted white and has a blue roof. Residence Three appears to have
two levels throughout and also appears to be at a lower elevation than the Main Residence,
Residence Two, and the Four Cabanas.

h. Behind Residence Three and along the coastline is a small roofed structure at the
end of a wooden dock (the "Dock House").

i. There are two single story sheds ("Shed One" and "Shed Two") that are located
just southwest of the Main Residence. Shed One and Shed Two appear to have a metal-like
exterior that is a green-blue color.

j. Next to Shed One and Shed Two is a four wall structure that appears to have several
sally port type doors ("Maintenance One"). A second structure ("Maintenance Two") is next to
Maintenance One and has a white exterior with four sets of white double doors and three single
white doors.

k. Near the center of the island is a single story structure ("Residence Four") that has
a stone exterior and blue roof. The front of Residence Four has three dark double doors.

1. Next to the helicopter landing pad are two small structures with blue roofs
("Helipad Buildings").
m. On the west side of the Subject Premises on the coast is an approximately two-level
structure with a blue roof ("Residence Five").

II. Items to Be Seized
A. Evidence, Fruits, and Instrumentalities of the Subject Offenses
This warrant authorizes the seizure of certain evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of
violations of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591 (Sex Trafficking of Minors), and 371
(Sex Trafficking Conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

1. Any documents or communications with or regarding victims or potential victims
of the Subject Offenses or between EPSTEIN and co-conspirators to the Subject Offenses;

2. Any photographs of victims or potential victims of the Subject Offenses or co-
conspirators to the Subject Offenses.
2017.08.02

3. Any nude, partially nude, or sexually suggestive photographs of individuals who
appear to be teenage girls, or younger.

4. Any documents evidencing the presence of co-conspirators at the Subject Premises.
5. Records or other items that evidence ownership, control, or use of, or access to
devices, storage media, and related electronic equipment used to access, transmit, or store
information relating to the Subject Offenses, including, but not limited to, sales receipts,
warranties, bills for Internet access, handwritten notes, registry entries, configuration files, saved
usernames and passwords, user profiles, e-mail contacts, and photographs.

6. Any child erotica defined as suggestive visual depictions of nude minors that do
not constitute child pornography, as defined by 18 U.S.C. § 2256(8).

7. Any computer devices and storage media believed to be owned or used by
JEFFREY EPSTEIN including, but not limited to, desktop and laptop computers, disk drives,
modems, thumb drives, personal digital assistants, smart phones, digital cameras, scanners,
routers, modems, and network equipment used to connect to the Internet. In lieu of seizing any
such computer devices or storage media, this warrant also authorizes, in the alternative, the
copying of such devices or media for later review.

8. Any items or records needed to access the data stored on any seized or copied
computer devices or storage media, including but not limited to any physical keys, encryption
devices, or records of login credentials, passwords, private encryption keys, or similar information.

9. Any items or records that may facilitate a forensic examination of the computer
devices or storage media, including any hardware or software manuals or other information
concerning the configuration of the seized or copied computer devices or storage media.

10. Any evidence concerning the identities or locations of those persons with access to,
control over, or ownership of the seized or copied computer devices or storage media.
11. Any evidence concerning the ownership of the Subject Premises, and any maps or
other geographical guides to the Subject Premises.
2017.08.02
AO 93 (Rev. 11/13) Search and Seizure Warrant
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
District of Virgin Islands
In the Matter of the Search of
(Briefly describe the property to be searched
or identify the person by name and address)
Premises Known as Little Saint James Island, USVI, and
Any Buildings, Structures or Containers Thereupon
Case No. a-c; 2_0t9 -MCA
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the   District of  the Virgin Islands
(identiry the person or describe the property to be searched and give its location):
Premises Known and Described as LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND, U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS, and Any Buildings or Other
Structures Contained Thereon, and Any Locked or Closed Containers/Items Contained Therein.
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the person or 
property
described above, and that such search will reveal (identify the person or describe the property to be seized):
See Attachments A,4374Td -I9,
YOU ARE COMMANDED to execute this warrant on or before  August 24, 2019  (not to exceed 14 days)
O in the daytime 6:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. Oat any time in the day or night because good cause has been established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property taken to 
the
person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the place where the
property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present during the execution of the warrant, must prepare an inventory
as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to  the Honorable Ruth Miller
(United States Magistrate Judge)
O Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 3103a(b), I find that immediate notification may have an adverse result listed in 18 U.S.C.
§ 2705 (except for delay of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay notice to the person who, 
or whose
property, will be searched or seized (check the appropriate box)
O for  30  days (not to exceed 30) O until, the facts justifying, the later s ecific date of
Date and time issued: (LS bn l  J•/z2q;
City and state:
Judge's signature

St. Thomas, VI Ruth Miller, United States Magistrate Judge
Printed name and title
AO 93 (Rev. 11/13) Search and Seizure Warrant (Page 2)
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy of warrant and inventory left with:
Inventory made in the presence of :
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized:
Certification
I declare under penalty of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant to 
the
designated judge.
Date:
Executing officer's signature
Printed name and title
ATTACHMENT A

I. Premises to be Searched —Subject Premises
The Subject Premises are particularly described as a private island in the U.S. Virgin
Islands known as Little Saint James, any buildings or other structures contained thereon, and any
closed containers/items contained therein. Little Saint James is an approximately 75 acre island
located approximately four (4) miles off the southeast coast of St. Thomas. The Subject Premises
is depicted in the following photograph:
•••:
,Ledjes te Jarrm., ,
The Subject Premises contains multiple structures, including but not limited to:

a. On the northeast end of the Subject Premises, there is a single story structure next
to a pool.
b. On the southwest end of the Subject Premises, there is a single-story, four-wall
structure. The walls are painted with blue and white stripes. The structure has large double doors
as its main entrance and large windows on the three remaining walls.

c. On the north east end of the Subject Premises, there are multiple structures. The
main structure is a single story residence (the "Main Residence") with a stone exterior, a blue roof,
and a white detailed exterior that includes white columns.

d. A separate structure ("Residence One") with a blue roof and stone exterior is at the
back of the Main Residence, located at the end of the northeast tip of the island and surrounded by
coastline on two of its sides.
2017.08.02

e. A second larger structure ("Residence Two) is set between the Main Residence and the coastline.
f. Four smaller single story structures (the "Four Cabanas") are next to the Main Residence and a large pool. All four 
smaller structures have blue roofs.

g. A third large structure ("Residence Three") set off from the four smaller structures and next to the coast line is 
painted white and has a blue roof.
Residence Three appears to have two levels throughout and also appears to be at a lower elevation than the Main 
Residence, Residence Two, and the Four Cabanas.

h. Behind Residence Three and along the coastline is a small roofed structure at the end of a wooden dock (the "Dock 
House").

i. There are two single story sheds ("Shed One" and "Shed Two") that are located just southwest of the Main Residence. 
Shed One and Shed Two appear to have a
metal-like exterior that is a green-blue color.

j. Next to Shed One and Shed Two is a four wall structure that appears to have several sally port type doors 
("Maintenance One"). A second structure
("Maintenance Two") is next to Maintenance One and has a white exterior with four sets of white double doors and three 
single white doors.

k. Near the center of the island is a single story structure ("Residence Four") that has a stone exterior and blue roof.
The front of Residence Four has three
dark double doors.

1. Next to the helicopter landing pad are two small structures with blue roofs ("Helipad Buildings").
m. On the west side of the Subject Premises on the coast is an approximately two-level structure with a blue roof 
("Residence Five").

II. Items to Be Seized
A. Evidence, Fruits, and Instrumentalities of the Subject Offenses
This warrant authorizes the seizure of certain evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of violations of Title 18, United
States Code, Sections 1591 (Sex
Trafficking of Minors), and 371 (Sex Trafficking Conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

1. My documents or communications with or regarding victims or potential victims of the Subject Offenses or between 
EPSTEIN and co-conspirators to the Subject
Offensei;

2. Any photographs of victims or potential victims of the Subject Offenses or co-conspirators to the Subject Offenses.
2 2017.08.02

3. My nude, partially nude, or sexually suggestive photographs of individuals who
appear to be teenage girls, or younger.

4. Any documents evidencing the presence of co-conspirators at the Subject Premises.
5. Records or other items that evidence ownership, control, or use of, or access to
devices, storage media, and related electronic equipment used to access, transmit, or store
information relating to the Subject Offenses, including, but not limited to, sales receipts,
warranties, bills for Internet access, handwritten notes, registry entries, configuration files, saved
usernames and passwords, user profiles, e-mail contacts, and photographs.

6. Any child erotica defined as suggestive visual depictions of nude minors that do
not constitute child pornography, as defined by 18 U.S.C. § 2256(8).

7. Any computer devices and storage media believed to be owned or used by
JEFFREY EPSTEIN including, but not limited to, desktop and laptop computers, disk drives,
modems, thumb drives, personal digital assistants, smart phones, digital cameras, scanners,
routers, modems, and network equipment used to connect to the Internet. In lieu of seizing any
such computer devices or storage media, this warrant also authorizes, in the alternative, the
copying of such devices or media for later review.

8. Any items or records needed to access the data stored on any seized or copied
computer devices or storage media, including but not limited to any physical keys, encryption
devices, or records of login credentials, passwords, private encryption keys, or similar information.

9. My items or records that may facilitate a forensic examination of the computer
devices or storage media, including any hardware or software manuals or other information
concerning the configuration of the seized or copied computer devices or storage media.

10. Any evidence concerning the identities or locations of those persons with access to,
control over, or ownership of the seized or copied computer devices or storage media.
11. My evidence concerning the ownership of the Subject Premises, and any maps or
other geographical guides to the Subject Premises.
2017.08.02
AO 93 (Rev. 11/13) Search and Seizure Warrant
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
District of Virgin Islands
In the Matter of the Search of
(Briefly describe the property to be searched
or identfr the person by name and address)
Premises Known as Little Saint James Island, USVI, and
Any Buildings, Structures or Containers Thereupon
Case No. 2_01631-60C/O
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the   District of  the Virgin Islands
identify the person or describe the property to be searched and give its location):
Premises Known and Described as LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND, U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS, and Any Buildings or Other
Structures Contained Thereon, and Any Locked or Closed Containers/Items Contained Therein.
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the person or 
property
described above, and that such search will reveal °demi& the person or describe the property to be seized):
See Attachments A, 437Cmd -19,
YOU ARE COMMANDED to execute this warrant on or before  August 24, 2019  (not to exceed 14 days)
O in the daytime 6:00 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. Oat any time in the day or night because good cause has been established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property taken to 
the
person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the place where the
property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present during the execution of the warrant, must prepare an inventory
as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to  the Honorable Ruth Miller
(United States Magistrate Judge)
O Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 3103a(b), I find that immediate notification may have an adverse result listed in 18 U.S.C.
§ 2705 (except for delay of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay notice to the person who, 
or whose
property, will be searched or seized (check the appropriate box)
O for 30 days (not to exceed 30) O until, the facts justifying, the later specific date of
Date and time issued: as tir4r Raiff
City and state:
( MO Judge's signature

St. Thomas, VI Ruth Miller, United States Magistrate Judge
Printed name and title
AO 93 (Rev. 11113) Search and Seizure Warrant (Page 2)
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy of warrant and inventory left with:
Inventory made in the presence of :
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized:
Certification
I declare under penalty of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant to 
the
designated judge.
Date:
Executing officer's signature
Printed name and title
ATTACHMENT A

I. Premises to be Searched —Subject Premises
The Subject Premises are particularly described as a private island in the U.S. Virgin
Islands known as Little Saint James, any buildings or other structures contained thereon, and any
closed containers/items contained therein. Little Saint James is an approximately 75 acre island
located approximately four (4) miles off the southeast coast of St. Thomas. The Subject Premises
is depicted in the following photograph:
The Subject Premises contains multiple structures, including but not limited to:

a. On the northeast end of the Subject Premises, there is a single story structure next
to a pool.
b. On the southwest end of the Subject Premises, there is a single-story, four-wall
structure. The walls are painted with blue and white stripes. The structure has large double doors
as its main entrance and large windows on the three remaining walls.

c. On the north east end of the Subject Premises, there are multiple structures. The
main structure is a single story residence (the "Main Residence") with a stone exterior, a blue roof,
and a white detailed exterior that includes white columns.

d. A separate structure ("Residence One") with a blue roof and stone exterior is at the
back of the Main Residence, located at the end of the northeast tip of the island and surrounded by
coastline on two of its sides.
2017.08.02

e. A second larger structure ("Residence Two) is set between the Main Residence and
the coastline.
f. Four smaller single story structures (the "Four Cabanas") are next to the Main
Residence and a large pool. All four smaller structures have blue roofs.

g. A third large structure ("Residence Three") set off from the four smaller structures
and next to the coast line is painted white and has a blue roof. Residence Three appears to have
two levels throughout and also appears to be at a lower elevation than the Main Residence,
Residence Two, and the Four Cabanas.

h. Behind Residence Three and along the coastline is a small roofed structure at the
end of a wooden dock (the "Dock House").

i. There are two single story sheds ("Shed One" and "Shed Two") that are located
just southwest of the Main Residence. Shed One and Shed Two appear to have a metal-like
exterior that is a green-blue color.

j. Next to Shed One and Shed Two is a four wall structure that appears to have several
sally port type doors ("Maintenance One"). A second structure ("Maintenance Two") is next to
Maintenance One and has a white exterior with four sets of white double doors and three single
white doors.

k. Near the center of the island is a single story structure ("Residence Four") that has
a stone exterior and blue roof. The front of Residence Four has three dark double doors.

1. Next to the helicopter landing pad are two small structures with blue roofs
("Helipad Buildings").
m. On the west side of the Subject Premises on the coast is an approximately two-level
structure with a blue roof ("Residence Five").

II. Items to Be Seized
A. Evidence, Fruits, and Instrumentalities of the Subject Offenses
This warrant authorizes the seizure of certain evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of
violations of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591 (Sex Trafficking of Minors), and 371
(Sex Trafficking Conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

1. Any documents or communications with or regarding victims or potential victims
of the Subject Offenses or between EPSTEIN and co-conspirators to the Subject Offenses;

2. Any photographs of victims or potential victims of the Subject Offenses or co-
conspirators to the Subject Offenses.
2017.08.02

3. Any nude, partially nude, or sexually suggestive photographs of individuals who appear to be teenage girls, or 
younger.

4. Any documents evidencing the presence of co-conspirators at the Subject Premises.
5. Records or other items that evidence ownership, control, or use of, or access to devices, storage media, and related 
electronic equipment used to access,
transmit, or store information relating to the Subject Offenses, including, but not limited to, sales receipts, 
warranties, bills for Internet access,
handwritten notes, registry entries, configuration files, saved usemames and passwords, user profiles, e-mail contacts, 
and photographs.

6. Any child erotica defined as suggestive visual depictions of nude minors that do not constitute child pornography, as
defined by 18 U.S.C. § 2256(8).

7. Any computer devices. and storage media believed to be owned or used by JEFFREY EPSTEIN including, but not limited 
to, desktop and laptop computers, disk
drives, modems, thumb drives, personal digital assistants, smart phones, digital cameras, scanners, routers, moderns, 
and network equipment used to connect to
the Internet. In lieu of seizing any such computer devices or storage media, this warrant also authorizes, in the 
alternative, the copying of such devices or
media for later review.

8. Any items or records needed to access the data stored on any seized or copied computer devices or storage media, 
including but not limited to any physical
keys, encryption devices, or records of login credentials, passwords, private encryption keys, or similar information.

9. Any items or records that may facilitate a forensic examination of the computer devices or storage media, including 
any hardware or software manuals or other
information concerning the configuration of the seized or copied computer devices or storage media.

10. Any evidence concerning the identities or locations of those persons with access to, control over, or ownership of 
the seized or copied computer devices or
storage media.
11. Any evidence concerning the ownership of the Subject Premises, and any maps or other geographical guides to the 
Subject Premises.
3 2017.08.02
AO 106 (SDNY Rev. 01/17) Application fora Search Warrant
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
Southern District of New Ilk MAG 5 7 8 In the Matter of the Search of •
(Erich describe the property to be searched or identify thethe person to, name and address)
Six binders with various CDs
Case No.
APPLICATION FOR A SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
I, a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government, request a search warrant and state under
penalty of perjury that I have reason to believe that on the following person or property (Went°, the person or describe
the
property robe searched and give its location):
located in the Southern District of New York , there is now concealed (Eden* the
person or describe the property to be seized):
See Attached Affidavit and its Attachment A
The basis for the search under Fed. R. Crim. P. 41(c) is (check one or more):
X O evidence of a crime;
O contraband, fruits of crime, or other items illegally possessed;
O property designed for use, intended for use, or used in committing a crime;
O a person to be arrested or a person who is unlawfully restrained.
The search is related to a violation of:
Code Section(s)
18 USC 1591
18 USC 371
Offense Description(s)
Sex Trafficking of Minors
Sex Trafficking Conspiracy
The application is based on these facts:
See Attached Affidavit and its Attachment A
61 Continued on the attached sheet
O Delayed notice of 30 days (give exact ending date if more than 30 days:
under 18 U.S.C. § 3103; the basis of which is set forth on theettached
Sworn to before me and signed in my presence.
Date:
City and state:  New York, NY
Applicant's signature
) is requested
pi Printed nanteeiditi le 00 u ast
JudgCs-stgaffir
- • "cf.,::; Cott, United. otatkaagistra,teW
Fringed namiranIftlyeitli " n"
•--irrett'SN
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
In the Matter of the Application of the United
States Of America for a Search and Seizure
Warrant for six binders with various CDs
TO BE FILED UNDER SEAL
Agent Affidavit in Support of
Application for Search and Seizure
Warrant
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK) ss.:
S ing duly sworn, deposes and says:

I. Introduction
A. Affiant
1. I have been a Task Force Officer with the Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBP")
since 2017. As such, I am a "federal law enforcement officer" within the meaning of Federal Rule
of Criminal Procedure 41(a)(2)(C), that is, a government agent engaged in enforcing the criminal
laws and duly authorized by the Attorney General to request a search warrant. I am also a detective
with the New York Police Department ("NYPD") and have been employed by the NYPD for
approximately thirteen years. I am currently assigned to investigate violations of criminal law
relating to the'sexual exploitation of children as part of an FBI Task Force. I have gained expertise
in this area through classroom training and daily work related to these types of investigations. As
part of my responsibilities, I have been involved in the investigation of sex trafficking cases, and
have participated in the execution of search warrants for electronic devices and electronic storage
media.

2. I make this Affidavit in support of an application pursuant to Rule 41 of the Federal
Rules of Criminal Procedure for a wan-ant to search certain electronic devices, compact disks and
related electronic media specified below (the "Subject Items") for the items and information
2017.08.02
described in Attachment A. This affidavit is based upon my personal knowledge; my review of
documents and other evidence; my conversations with other law enforcement personnel; and my
training, experience and advice received concerning the use of computers in criminal activity and
the forensic analysis of electronically stored information ("ESP'). Because this affidavit is being
submitted for the limited purpose of establishing probable cause, it does not include all the facts
that I have learned during the course of my investigation. Where the contents of documents and
the actions, statements, and conversations of others are reported herein, they are reported in
substance and in part, except where otherwise indicated.

B. The Subject Items
3. The. Subject Items are particularly described as follows':
a. Two blue binders with CDs, which were seized by Special Agent M ,
_from a blue suitcase on or about July 11, 2019 ("Subject Item-1").

b. Three blue binders with various CDs and one clear binder with a green spine
with various CDs, all four of which were seized by Special Agent _horn a black
suitcase on or about July 11, 2019 ("Subject Item-2").

4. The Subject Items are all presently located in the Southern District of New York.
C. The Target Subjects and the Subject Offenses

5. For the reasons detailed below, I believe that there is probable cause to believe that
the Subject Device contains evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of violations of Title 18, United
States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of minors), and 371 (sex trafficking conspiracy) (the
To the extent that the Subject Items contain any removable storage media, including CDs, the
description of each such item encompasses those other media.
2017.08.02
S.
"Subject Offenses"). The Target Subjects of this investigation are known and unknown co-
conspirators of JEFFREY EPSTEIN, including but not limited tici

II. Probable Cause
A. Probable Cause Regarding the Commission of the Subject Offenses
6. On or about July 2, 2019, a grand jury in this District returned an Indictment
charging JEFFREY EPSTEIN with the Subject Offenses. A copy of the Indictment is attached
hereto as Exhibit A and is incorporated by reference. EPSTEIN was arrested pursuant to the
Indictment on or about July.6, 2019, and had been detained pending trial at the Metropolitan
Correctional Center ("MCC") in New York, New York.

7. On or about August 10, 2019, the Bureau of Prisons confirmed that JEFFREY
EPSTEIN had been found unresponsive in his cell at the MCC that morning, and was pronounced
dead shortly thereafter.

8. Notwithstanding EPSTEIN's death, the sex trafficking investigation that led to his
indictment remains ongoing. In particular, Count One of the Indictment alleged that EPSTEIN
conspired with others to traffic minors, and further identified three individuals who worked for
EPSTEIN (identified in Exhibit A as "Employee-1", "Employee-2," and "Employee-3") and
facilitated EPSTEIN's at?use of minor girls by, among other things, arranging victims' encounters
with EPSTEIN and paying victims after these encounters. The individual identified in Exhibit A
is "Employee-2" is , a Target Subject of this investigation.

9. On or about November 28, 2018, the Miami Herald began publishing a series of
articles relating to the defendant, his sexual misconduct with minors, and a previous investigation
into his conduct in Florida from in or about 2005 through 2008. The article included information
about role in EPSTEIN's sexual abuse of minors. Based on my participation
in this investigation, I have learned that bank records obtained by the Government appear to show
2017.08.02
that just days later, on or about December 3, 2018, the defendant wired $250,000 from a trust
account to a This course of action, and in particular its timing, suggests. that EPSTEIN
was attempting to influence who might have been able to provide information against
him in light of the recently re-emerging allegations.

B. Probable Cause Justifying Search of the Subject Items
The Indictment and Victim-1
10. As set forth in Exhibit A, from at least in or about 2002, up to and including at least
in or about 2005, JEFFREY EPSTEIN sexually abused multiple minor girls in the Southern
District of New York and elsewhere. During that time and continuing to the present, EPSTEIN
possessed and controlled a multi-story, single-family residence located at 9 East 71st Street, New
York, New York, which is described in Exhibit A as "the New York Residence."

11. As further set forth in paragraphs 8 through 10 of Exhibit A, from at least in or
about 2002, up to and including at least in or about 2005, EPSTEIN sexually abused numerous
minor victims at the New York Residence. In particular, and as alleged in the Indictment, when a
victim arrived at the New York Residence, she would be escorted to a room inside the Subject
Premises with a massage table, where she would perform a massage on EPSTEIN. The victims,
who were as young as 14 years of age, were told by EPSTEIN or other individuals to partially or
fully undress before beginning the "massage." During the encounter, EPSTEIN would escalate
the nature and scope of physical contact with his victim to include, among other things, sex acts
such as EPSTEIN typically
would also
FolloWing each
encounter, EPSTEIN or one of his employees or associates paid the victim in cash.
2017.08.02

12. As set forth in paragraphs 12 through 13 of Exhibit A, to further facilitate his ability
to abuse minor girls in New York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN asked and enticed certain of his victims to
recruit additional minor girls to perform "massages" and similarly engage in sex acts with
EPSTEIN. When a victim would recruit another minor girl for EPSTEIN, he paid both the victim-
recruiter and the new victim hundreds of dollars in cash. EPSTEIN knew that his victims were
underage, including because certain victims told him their age.

13. One of the victims identified in paragraph 22 of Exhibit A is Victim-1. As part of
the FBI's investigation of EPSTEIN, other law enforcement officers and I have interviewed
Victim-1.2 During those interviews, Victim-1 has said, in substance and in part, that EPSTEIN
sexually abused Victim-1 on multiple occasions between approximately 2002 and 2005 in the New
York Residence. This sexual abuse all occurred when Victim-1 was under the age of 18.
The July 6.2019 and July 7.2019 Search Warrants for the New York Residence

14. On or about July 6, 2019, the Honorable Barbara Moses, United States Magistrate
Judge, signed a search warrant authorizing a search of the New York Residence. The search
warrant is attached as Exhibit B and incorporated by reference herein.

15. At approximately 6 p.m. on or about July 6, 2019, law enforcement officers (the
"Search Team") commenced executing the search warrant at the New York Residence.
2 In meetings with the Government, Victim-1 has disclosed that, approximately a decade ago, she
committed marriage fraud in order to obtain a green card and, subsequently, U.S. citizenship. She
has also disclosed personal substance abuse, primarily involving the abuse of prescription drugs,
during various periods between the early 2000s and 2019. Victim-1 has also disclosed having
worked for approximately a year at a "happy-ending" massage parlor, performing paid sex acts.
Victim-1 is currently pursuing a civil damages claim against EPSTEIN for his sexual abuse of her.
Information provided by Victim-1 has proven reliable and has been corroborated by independent
evidence, including documents and records obtained during the investigation and the accounts of
other victims whom Victim-1 has never met.
2017.08.02

16. Based on the Search Team's observations during an initial search of the New York
Residence, at approximately 7 pan., the Search Team stopped the search and froze the scene in
order to seek a new search warrant.

17. On or about July 7, 2019, the Honorable Barbara Moses, United States Magistrate
Judge, signed a second search warrant authorizing a search of the New York Residence (the
"Second Warrant"). The Second Warrant is attached as Exhibit C, and incorporated by reference
herein. At approximately 2:30 a.m., the Search Team resumed the search, and commenced
searching pursuant to the Second Warrant.

18. Based on my conversations with members of the Search Team, I have learned the
following:
a. The Search Team observed a number of computing devices, including computers
and tablet devices, throughout the New York Residence.

b. Inside a safe in a closet on the third floor (the "Safe"), the Search Team discovered
and seized, among other items, several binders containing sleeves of compact discs, most of which
are labeled with handwriting. In total, the binders contain dozens of compact discs. One disc is
labeled ` and " Another disc is labeled "Nudes 00-24." Another is
labeled "Misc. Nudes." Yet another is labeled "Girl Pics Nude." Some discs contain the word
"Zorro" or "LS.J." For example, one disc is marked (IM Zorro Pies." Based on my
conversations with law enforcement agents who have participated in this investigation, I believe
the name "Zorro" refers to Zorro Ranch, EPSTEIN's property in New Mexico, and the name LSJ
refers to Little Saint James, EPSTEIN's property in the U.S. Virgin Islands. The majority of the
discs contain titles that include female names. Some of the discs in the binders seized by the
Search Team have titles that appear to refer to trips or vacations.
2017.08.02

c. At the time of the search, the Search Team did not seize certain binders of discs
located in the Safe, where the majority of the discs in the binder were labeled in a manner that did
not appear to refer to girls or nudes. The Search Team also did not seize at that time several
unlabeled hard drives, which were also located in the Safe. As detailed below, those additional
. binders of discs are among the subjects of this application.

d. In addition to the Safe, in the drawer of a dresser in a room on the Fifth floor of the
New York Residence, the Search team discovered and seized, among other items, a shoebox (the
"Shoebox") which contained numerous compact discs. The majority of the discs are labeled, in
handwriting, with female names. One disc is labeled "Thai Massage." Mother disc is labeled
"Blonde Girl Photo Shoot." Yet another disc is labeled "Misc. Girls Nude/Dinner—Scientists."
The discs in the Shoebox were seized by the Search Team. In another drawer of that same dresser,
the Search Team discovered loose polaroid photographs depicting young, nude females who, based
on the training and experience of law enforcement officers who observed them, appear to be
teenagers. In that same drawer, the Search Team discovered a folder marked, in handwriting,
".," which contained photographs, including nude and sexually suggestive photographs of a
young girl who, based on the training and experience of law enforcement officers who observed
them, appears to be younger than 18. The folder also contained other nude photographs of young
girls who appear to be teenagers, based on my training and experience. Inside the folder is a
compact disc marked ". at LIS 6/03" (the "Elise"), which was seized by the Search Team.

e. In a closet on the Fifth Floor of the New York Residence, the Search Team
discovered, among other items, a box marked "women/old photos." The box contained, among
other items, approximately seven compact discs, which are labeled with hand-written titles. One
disc is labeled "nudes 00-24." Mother is labeled Thotographera '03" The remaining
2017.08.02
discs contain titles that include female names. All of the foregoing discs were seized by the Search
Team.

f. In that same closet, the Search Team discovered numerous black binders containing
what appear to be print outs of digital photographs (with file names underneath) and compact discs.
The Search Team seized approximately ten binders (the "Seized Binders") 3 which appeared to
contain, among other photographs, photographs of nude or partially nude young girls, some of
which are in sexually suggestive poses. Based on the training and experience of law enforcement
officers who observed them, at least some of the young girls depicted in the photographs appear
to be teenagers, including some who appear to be under the age of 18. The Seized Binders also
include photographs of what appear to be personal functions, events, and travel.

g. The compact discs seized by the Search Team and described in paragraphs 16(a)-(d)
are currently stored within the Southern District of New York in containers marked for
identification with FBI evidence numbers 15, 16, 17, 18, and 22 (the "Seized Discs").
The-Julv-7,201-9-Seareh-Wanant-for-the-Seized-Discs

19. On or about July 7, 2019, the Honorable Barbara Moses, United States Magistrate
Judge, signed a third search warrant to search and seize electronic media stored on the Seized Discs
(the "Third Search Warrant"). The Third Warrant is attached as Exhibit D, and incorporated by
reference herein.

20. Based on my conversations with law enforcement agents who have reviewed the
Seized Discs pursuant to the Third Search Warrant (the "Reviewing Agents"), I have learned the
following:
3 The Search Team did not seize the remaining binders.
2017.08.02
C •

a. The discs contain approximately thousands of nude or partially nude photographs
of girls or young women, many of which are in sexually suggestive poses. Based on my
conversations with the Reviewing Agents, who have particular training and experience relating to
child erotica and visual depictions of children in child exploitation cases, I have learned that the
Reviewing Agents believe that many of the nude or partially nude images they have reviewed
appear to depict girls under the age of 18. Moreover, many of the photographs appear to be labeled
with file names that suggest the photographs depict these girls at properties associated with
JEFFREY EPSTEIN. For example, some file names are labeled "Zorro" or "LSJ."

b. Among the photographs on the Seized Discs, the Reviewing Agents identified
partially-nude photographs of a young girl, labeled with an associated name that matched a
particular individual ("Individual-1"). After identifying those photographs, the Government was
advised by Individual-I's counsel that Individual-1 recalls the month and year during which she
believes those partially-nude photographs were taken, and also the location where they were taken,
and that she was 17 years old at the time.'

21. In addition, I have learned that some of the file names are marked." which are
the initials of
reported that
photos may have been taken by
. As set forth below, I have interviewed an individual who has
photographed her. Accordingly, I believe that a portion of these
4 A preliminary review of the metadata from these photographs has been inconclusive. In
particular, some of die photographs of Individual-1 contain metadata suggesting the photographs
were taken on a date when Individual-1 would have been 18 years old. Other photographs of
Individual-1, which appear based on Individual-I's appearance and surroundings to have been
taken around the same time, contain metadata suggesting the photographs were taken on a date
when Individual-1 would have been 15 years old.
2017.08.02

22. Among the photographs seized from the New York Residence, the Reviewing
Agents identified partially-nude photographs of a young girl, labeled with die name of a particular
individual ("Individual-1"). In or about August 2019, I participated in an interview of Individual-
1, with her counsel present. Based on my personal observations, I believe that the photographs
described in Paragraph 20(b) depict Individual-1. I have also spoken with another law enforcement
agent who interviewed Individual-1 on a separate occasion in or about July 2019, with her counsel
present. During the course of these interviews, Individual-1 stated, in sum an substance that she
met EPSTEIN in 2003 when she was approximately 17, and that she travelled to several of
EPSTEIN's properties before she turned 18. EPSTEIN paid for the trips, and would give
Individual-1 money and gifts while she traveled with him. During these trips, EPSTEIN sexually
abused and assaulted Individual-1 on approximately four different occasions, all of which occurred
before she turned 18. Individual- I reported that EPSTEIN raped her during two of these incidents.
Individual-1 further reported that, when she was approximately 17, asked to
photograph her, and did in fact photograph Individual-1.
The July 11, 2019 Search Warrant for All Electronic Devices and Storage Media in the
New York Residence

23. Following the initiation of the FBI's review of the Seized Discs, on or about July
11, 2019, the Honorable Henry B. Pitman, United States Magistrate Judge, signed another search
warrant authorizing another search of the New York Residence and specifically authorizing the
seizure and search of all electronic devices and storage media inside the New York Residence (the
"Fourth Warrant"). The Fourth Warrant is attached as Exhibit E and incorporated by reference
herein.

24. Later on July 11, 2019, the Search Team executed the Fourth Warrant at the New
York Residence.
2017.08.02

25. Based on my conversations with members of the Search Team, I have learned the
following, among other things, regarding the execution of the Fourth Warrant:

a. During the July 11, 2019 execution of the Fourth Warrant inside the New
York Residence, the Search Team found that the Safe described above was empty and, in
particular, that the collection of discs and hard drives described in paragraph 16(b), above, that the
Search Team had not seized during its prior search of the New York Residence on July 7, 2019,
had been removed.

b. After discovering that the Safe was empty, the Search Team spoke with an
employee who worked at the New York Residence (the "Employee"). During that conversation,
the Employee told the Search Team that after the completion of the prior search on July 7, 2019,
the Employee had been instructed by a third party ("the Third Party") to take the contents of the
Safe out of the New York Residence and deliver those items to the Third Party. The Employee
further told the Search Team that after receiving that instruction, the Employee packed the contents
of the Safe into two suitcases and delivered those suitcases to the Third Party. The Employee
provided the Search Team with the Third Party's contact information.

c. The Search Team then contacted the Third Party. During the ensuing
conversation, the Third Party confirmed receipt of two suitcases from the Employee but also told
the Search Team that the Third Party had not opened the suitcases or touched or tampered with
their contents. The Third Party also agreed to deliver the two suitcases to the Search Team.

d. Later on July 11, 2019, and consistent with the conversation described
above, the Third Party met the Search Team outside of the New York Residence and provided
Special Agent with the two suitcases described above, one of which was blue and
one of which was black. Consistent with standard law enforcement protocol, the Search Team
2017.08.02
conducted an inventory of both suitcases before taking custody of them. While taking an inventory
of the blue suitcase, the Search Team discovered, among other items, Subject Item-1. While taking
an inventory of the black suitcase, the Search Team discovered, among other items, Subject Item-

2. These items, i.e., Subject Items -1, and -2, appeared to be the same items observed in the Safe
by the Search Team during the July 7, 2019 search of the New York Residence.
The July 15, 2019 Search Warrant for Certain Items Located Inside the Blue and Black
Suitcases

26. On or about July 15, 2019, the Honorable Kevin Nathaniel Fox, United States
Magistrate Judge, signed a search warrant authorizing the search of several items, including items
recovered from the black and blue suitcases seized by Special Agent on or about
July 11, 2019 (the "Fifth Warrant"). The Fifth Warrant is attached as Exhibit F and incorporated
by reference herein.

27. In support of the Government's request for the Fifth Warrant, a Special Agent of
the FBI submitted an affidavit in which she described some of the contents of the black and blue
suitcases seized by Special Agent on or about July 11, 2019. Before submitting
that affidavit, that agent had not personally reviewed the contents of those suitcases; rather, those
descriptions were based on her conversations with other FBI agents who had seized the suitcases.
Based on those conversations with other agents, she requested that the Fifth Warrant authorize the
search of, among other items, (a) two black binders with CDs, which were seized by Special Agent
from a blue suitcase on or about July 11, 2019, and (b) two binders with various
CDs, which were seized by Special Agent from a black suitcase on or about July
11, 2019. The Fifth Warrant authorized the search of those specific items.

28. After the Fifth Warrant was issued, other law enforcement agents retrieved some
of the items listed in the Fifth Warrant from the blue and black suitcases, which were and remain
2017.08.02
in FBI custody in the Southern District of New York. Those other agents initiated searches of
certain items inside the two suitcases, including of Subject Item-1.

29. Subsequently, I personally inspected the contents of these suitcases, and realized
that there had been a miscommunication about the color and quantity of the binders of CDs in each
suitcase. In particular, the blue suitcase in fact contained two blue binders with CDs (defined
herein as Subject Item-1), not two black binders. Additionally, the black suitcase in fact contained
a total of four binders with CDs, three of which are blue and one of which is clear with a green
spine, (defined herein as Subject Item-2), not two binders.

30. In light of these discrepancies, the FBI ceased its search of Subject Item-1 and never
initiated a search of Subject Item-2. Accordingly, I now respectfully request a warrant authorizing
a search of the binders that are in fact located inside the two suitcases, which have been identified
as Subject Item-1 and Subject Item-2 herein.
Request to Search the Subject Items

31. Based on my training and experience and .participation in this investigation, I
respectfully submit that there is probable cause to believe that the Subject Items will contain and/or
constitute additional fruits, evidence and instrumentalities of the Subject Offenses. As an initial
matter, all of the Subject Items were originally found in the same Safe in which EPSTEIN was
storing discs and other media already reviewed and which contain hundreds of not thousands of
nude and suggestive images of young females, some of whom appear to be under 18. Given as
much, and because there is probable cause to believe that EPSTEIN and his co-conspirators,
including engaged in sex trafficking of underage girls, there is probable cause
to believe that the additional storage media in EPSTEIN' s possession and control—Le., the Subject
Items-Lwill contain evidence of the Subject Offenses. Moreover, that efforts were made to remove
2017.01:02
Subject Items -1 and -2 from the New York Residence after the initial search only further reinforces
the probable cause to believe that those Subject Items contain and constitute fruits, evidence and
instrumentalities of the Subject Offenses.

32. I further know from my training and experience that computer files or remnants of •
such files can be recovered months or even years after they have been created or saved on an
electronic device such as the Subject Items. Even when such files have been deleted, they can
often be recovered, depending on how the device has subsequently been used, months or years
later with forensics tools. Thus, the ability to retrieve from information from the Subject Items
depends less on when the information was first created or saved than on a particular user's device
configuration, storage capacity, and computer habits.

33. Based on the foregoing, I respectfully submit there is probable cause to believe that
evidence of JEFFREY EPSTElN's commission of the Subject Offences is likely to be found on
the Subject Items.
III. Procedures for Searching ESI

A. Review of ESI
34. Law enforcement personnel (who may include, in addition to law enforcement
officers and agents, attorneys for the government, attorney support staff, agency personnel
assisting the government in this investigation, and outside technical experts under government
control) will review the ESI contained on the Subject Items for information responsive to the
warrant.

35. In conducting this review, law enforcement may use various techniques to
determine which files or other ESI contain evidence or fruits of the Subject Offenses. Such
techniques may include, for example:
2017.08.02

• surveying directories or folders and the individual files they contain (analogous to
looking at the outside of a file cabinet for the markings it contains and opening a drawer
believed to contain pertinent files);

• conducting a file-by-file review by "opening" or reading the first few "pages" of such
files in order to determine their precise contents (analogous to performing a cursory
examination of each document in a file cabinet to determine its relevance);

• "scanning" storage areas to discover and possibly recover recently deleted data or
deliberately hidden files; and

• performing electronic keyword searches through all electronic storage areas to
determine the existence and location of data potentially related to the subject matter of
the investigations; and
• reviewing metadata, system information, configuration files, registry data, and any
other information reflecting how, when, and by whom the computer was used.

36. Law enforcement personnel will make reasonable efforts to restrict their search to
data falling within the categories of evidence specified in the warrant. Depending on the
circumstances, however, law enforcement may need to conduct a complete review of all the ESI
from the Subject Items to evaluate its contents and to locate all data responsive to the warrant.

B. Return of the Subject Items
37. If the Government determines that the Subject Items are no longer necessary to
retrieve and preserve the data on the Subject Items, and that the Subject Items are not subject to
seizure pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 41(c), the Government will return the.
Subject Items, upon request. Computer data that is encrypted or unreadable will not be returned
unless law enforcement personnel have determined that the data is not (i) an instrumentality of the
s Keyword searches alone are typically inadequate to detect all relevant data. For one thing,
keyword searches work only for text data, yet many types of files, such as images and videos, do
not store data as searchable text. Moreover, even as to text data, there may be information properly
subject to seizure but that is not captured by a keyword search because the information does not
contain the keywords being searched.
2017.08.02
offense, (ii) a fruit of the criminal activity, (iii) contraband, (iv) otherwise unlawfully possessed,
or (v) evidenCe of the Subject Offenses.

IV. Conclusion and Ancillary Provisions
38. Based on the foregoing, I respectfully request the court to issue a warrant to seize
the items and information specified in Attaclunent A to this affidavit and to the Search and Seizure
Warrant.

39. In light of the confidential nature of the continuing investigation, I respectfully
request that this affidavit and all papers submitted herewith be maintained under seal until the
Court orders otherwise.
Sworn to before me on
September i Z- 2019
S L. COTS
STATES MAOIS,TRATE JUDGE
Task Force Officer
Federal Bureau of Investigation
; •
• -t• - •
2017.08.02
Attachment A

I. Items Subject to Search and Seizure
The Subject Items are particularly described as follows:
a. Two blue binders with CDs, which were seized by Special Agent
a from a blue suitcase on or about July 11, 2019 ("Subject Item-I").

b. Three blue binders with various CDs and one clear binder with a green spine
with various CDs, all four of which were seized by Special Agent from a black
suitcase on or about July 11, 2019 ("Subject Item-2").

II. Review of ESI on the Subject Items
Law enforcement personnel (who may include, in addition to law enforcement officers and
agents, attorneys for the government, attorney support staff; agency personnel assisting the
government in this investigation, and outside technical experts under government control) are
authorized to review the ESI contained on the Subject Items for evidence, fruits, and
instrumentalities of violations of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of
minors), and 371 (sex trafficking conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

1. Any documents or communications with or regarding victims or potential victims
of the Subject Offenses;

2. Any photographs of victims or potential victims of the Subject Offenses;
3. Any nude, partially nude, or sexually suggestive photographs of individuals who
appear to be teenage girls, or younger;

4. Records, data, or other items that evidence ownership, control, or use of, or access
to the Subject Items, including, but not limited to access history data, historical location data,
configuration files, saved usemames and passwords, user profiles, e-mail contacts, and
photographs;
5. Any child erotica, defined as suggestive visual depictions of nude minors that do
not constitute child pornography as defined by 18 U.S.C. § 2256(8).
To the extent that the Subject Items contain any removable storage media, including CDs, the
description of each such item encompasses those other media.
2017.08.02
In conducting this review, law enforcement personnel may use various techniques to
determine which files or other ESI contain evidence or fruits of the Subject Offenses. Such
techniques may include, for example:

• surveying directories or folders and the individual fi les they contain (analogous to
looking at the outside of a file cabinet for the markings it contains and opening a drawer
believed to contain pertinent files);

• conducting a file-by-file review by "opening" or reading the first few "pages" of such
files in order to determine their precise contents (analogous to performing a cursory
examination of each document in a file cabinet to determine its relevance);

• "scanning" storage areas to discover and possibly recover recently deleted data or
deliberately hidden files; and

• performing electronic keyword searches through all electronic storage areas to
determine the existence and location of data potentially related to the subject matter of
the investigation; and
• reviewing metadata, system information, configuration files, registry data, and any
other information reflecting how, when, and by whom the computer was used.
Law enforcement personnel will make reasonable efforts to search only for files,
documents, or other electronically stored information within the categories identified in Section II
of this Attachment. However, law enforcement personnel are authorized to conduct a complete
review of all the ESI from seized devices or storage media if necessary to evaluate its contents and
to locate all data responsive to the warrant.
2017.08.02.
EXHIBIT A
2017.08.02
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED •STATES OF AMERICA
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
x
SEALED
INDICTMENT
19 Cr.
19 CRIM
COUNT ONE
(Sex Trafficking Conspiracy)
490 '
The Grand Jury Charges:
OVERVIEW

1. As set forth herein, over the course of many
years, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, sexually exploited and•
abused dozens of minor girls at his homes in Manhattan, New
York, and Palm Beach, Florida, among other locations.

2. In particular, from at least in or about 2002, up
to. and including at least in or about 2005, JEFFREY EPSTEIN", the
defendant, enticed and recruited, and caused to be enticed and
recruited, minor girls to visit his mansion in Manhattan, New
York (the "New York Residente") and his estate in Palm Beach,
Florida (the "Palm Beach ResIdende") to engage in sex acts with
him, after which he would give the victims hundreds of dollars
in cash. Moreover, and in order to maintain and increase his
supply of victims, EPSTEIN also paid certain of his victims to
recruit additional girls to be similarly abused by EPSTEIN. In
. r
this way, EPSTEIN created a vast network of underage victims for
him to sexually exploit in. locations including New York and
Palm Beach.

3. The victims described herein were as young as 14
years old at the time they were abused by JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, and were, for various reasons, often particularly
vulnerable to exploitation. EPSTEIN intentionally sought out
minors and knew that many of his victims were in fact under the
age of 18, including because, in some instances, minor victims
expressly told him their age. •

4. In creating and maintaining this network of minor
victims in multiple states to sexually abuse and exploit,
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, worked and conspired with
others, including employees and associates who facilitated his
conduct by, among other things, contacting victims and
scheduling their sexual encounters with EPSTEIN at the New York
Residence and at the Palm Beach Residence.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND

5. During all time periods charged in this
Indictment, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, was a financier with
multiple residences in the continental United States, including
the New York Residence and the Palm Beach Residence.

6. Beginning in at least 2002, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, enticed and recruited, and.caused to be enticed and •
•
recruited, dozens of minor girls to engage in sex acts with him,
after which EPSTEIN paid the victims hundreds of dollars in
cash, at the New York Residence and the Palm Beach Residence.
7: In both New York and Florida, JEFFRBY EPSTEIN,
the defendant, perpetuated this abuse in similar ways. Victims
were initially recruited to provide 'massages' to EPSTEIN, which
would be perforded nude or partially 'nude, would become
increasingly seXual in nature, and would typically include one
or more sex acts. EPSTEIN paid his victims hundreds of dollars
in cash for each encounter. Moreover, EPSTEIN actively
encouraged certain. of his victims to recruit additional girls to
be similarly sexually abused. EPSTEXN:incentivized hie victims
to become recruiters by paying these victim7tecruiters hundreds
of dollars for each girl that they broUght to EPSTEIN. In so
doing, EPSTEIN maintained a steady supply of new victims to
exploit.
The New York Residence

8. At all times relevant to this Indictment, JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, the defendant, possessed and controlled a multi-story
pritate residence an the Upper East Side of Manhattan, New York,
i.e., the New-York Residence. Between at least in or about 20Q2
and in or about 2005, EPSTEIN abused numerous minor victims at
the New York Residence by causing theSe victims to be recruited
to engage in paid sex acts with him.

9. When a victim arrived at the New York Residence,
she typically would be escorted to a room with a massage table,
where she would perform a massage on JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant. The victims, who were as young as 14 years of•age,
were told by EPSTEIN or other individuals to partially or fully
undress before beginning the "massage." During the encounter,
"EPSTEIN would escalate the nature and scope of physical contact
with his victim to include, among other things, sex acts such as
■
EPSTEIN typically would also
•
•

10. In connection with each sexual encounter, JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, the defendant, or one of his employees or associates,
paid the victim in cash. Victims typically were paid hundreds
of dollars in cash for each encounter.

11. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, knew that many of
his New York victims were underage, including because certain
victims told him their age. Fuither, once these minor victims
were recruited, many were abused by EPSTEIN on multiple
subsequent occasions at the New York Residence. EPSTEIN
sometimes personally contacted victims to schedule appointments
at the New York Residence. In other instances, EPSTEIN directed
employees and associates, including a New York-based employee
("Employee-1"), to communicate with victims via phone to arrange
for these victims to return to the New York Residence for
additional sexual encounters with EPSTEIN.

12. Additionally, and to further facilitate his
ability to abuse minor girls in New York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, asked and enticed certain of his victims to recruit
additional girls to perform "massages" and similarly engage in
*sex acts with EPSTEIN. When a victim would recruit another girl
for EPSTEIN, he paid both the victim-recruiter and the new
victim hundreds of dollars in cash. Through these victim-
recruiters, EPSTEIN gained access to and was able to abuse
dozens of additional minor girls.

13. In particular, certain recruiters brought dozens
of additional minor girls to the New York Residence to give
massages to and engage in sex acts with JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant. EPSTEIN encouraged victims to recruit additional
girls by offering to pay these victim-recruiters for every
additional girl they brought to EPSTEIN. When a victim-
recruiter accompanied a new minor victim to the New York
Residence, both the victim-recruiter and the new minor victim
were paid hundreds of dollars by EPSTEIN for each encounter. In
addition r certain victim-recruiters routinely scheduled these

• or
encounters through Employee-1, who sometimes asked the
recruiters to bring a specific minor girl for EPSTEIN.
The Palm Beach Residepde

14. In addition to reoruiting and. abusing minor girls
in Pew York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, created a similar
network of minor girls to victimize in Palm Beach, Florida,
where EPSTEIN owned, possesSed and controlled another large
residence, i.e., the Palm Beach Residence. EPSTEIN frequently
traveled from New York to Balt Beach by private jet, before
which an employee or associate would ensure that minor victims
were •available for encounters upon his arrival in Florida.

15. At the Palm Beach Residence, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, engaged in a similar course of abusive conduct.
When a victim initially arrived at the Palm Beach Residence, she
would bp-escorted to a room, sometimes by an employee of
EPSTEIN's, including, at times, two assistants ("Employee-2" and'
"Employee-S/ who, as described herein, Jere .also responsible
for scheduling sexual encounters with minor victims. Once
inside, the victim would provide a nude or'semi-nude massage for
EPSTEIN, who would himself typically be naked. During these
encounters, EPSTEIN would escalate the nature and scope of the
physical contact to include. IF
also typically la .
EPSTEIN would
•

16. In connection with each sexual encounter, JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, the'defendant, or one of his employees or associates,
paid the victim in cash. Victims typically were paid hundreds
of dollars for each encounter.

17. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, knew that certain
of his victims were underage, including because certain victims
told him their age. In addition, aS with New York-based
victims, many Florida victims, once recruited, were abused by
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, on multiple additional
occasions,

18. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, who during the
relevant time period was frequently in New York, would arrange
for Employee-2 or other employees to contact victims by phone in
advance. of EPSTEIN'S travel to Florida to ensure appeintments
were scheduled for when he. arrived. I.n particular, in certain
in's'tances, Employee-2 placed phone calls to minor victims in
Florida to schedule encounters at the Palm Beach Residence. at
the time of certain of those phone calls, EPSTEIN and Employee-2
were in New YOrk, New York. Additionally, certain of the
individuals victimized at the Palm 'Beach Residence were
contacted by phone by Employee-3 to schedule these encounters.

19. Moreover, as in New York, to ensure a steady
stream of minor victims, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, asked
and enticed certain victims in Florida to recruit other girls to
engage in sex acts. EPSTEIN paid hundreds of dollars to victim-
recruiters for each additional girl they brought to the Palm
Beach Residence.
STATUTORY ALLEGATIONS

20. From at least in or about 2002, up to and
including in or about 2005, in the Southern District of New York
and elsewhere, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, and others known
and unknown, willfully and knowingly did combine, conspire,
confederate, and agree together and with each other to commit an
offense against the United States, to wit, sex trafficking of
minors, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section.
1591(a) and (b).

21. It was a part and object of the conspiracy that
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, and others known and unknown,
would and did, in and affecting interstate and foreign commerce,
recruit, entice, harbor, transport, provide, and obtain, by any
means a person, and to benefit, financially and by receiving
anything of value, from participation in a venture which has
engaged in any such act, knowing that the person had not
attained the age of 18 years and would be caused to engage in a
commercial sex act, in violation of Title 18, United States
Code, Sections 1591(a) and (b)(2).
Overt Acts

22. In furtherance of the conspiracy and to effect
the illegal object thereof, the following overt acts, among
others, were committed in the Southern District of New York and
elsewhere:

a. In or about 2004, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, enticed and recruited multiple minor victims,
including minor victims identified herein as Minor Victim-I,
Minor Victim-2, and Minor Victim-3, to engage in sex acts with
EPSTEIN at his residences in Manhattan, New York, and Palm
Beach, Florida, after which he'provided them with hundreds of
dollars in cash for each encounter.

b. In or about 2002, Minor Victim-1 was
• recruited to engage in sex acts with EPSTEIN and was repeatedly
sexually abused by EPSTEIN at the New York Residence over a
period of years and was paid hundreds of dollars for each
encounter. EPSTEIN also encouraged and enticed Minor Victim-1
to recruit other girls to engage in paid sex acts, which she
did. EPSTEIN asked Minor Victim-1 how old she was, and Minor
Victim-1 answered truthfully.

c. In or about 2004, Employee -1, located in the
Southern District of New York, and on behalf of EPSTEIN, placed
a telephone call to Minor Victim-1.in order to schedule an
appointment for Minor Victim-1 to engage in paid sex acts with
EPSTEIN.

d. In or about 2004, Minbr Victim-2 was
recruited to engage in sex acts with OSTEIN and was repeatedly
sexually abused by EPSTEIN at the Palm Beach Residence over a
period of years and was paid hundreds of dollars after each
encounter. EPSTEIN also encouraged and enticed Minor Victim-2
to recruit other girls to engage in paid sex acts, which she
did. .

e. In or about 2005, EmplOyee-2, located in the
Southern District of New York, and on behalf of EPSTEIN, placed
a telephone call to Minor Victim-2 in order to schedule an
appointment for Minor Victim-2 to engage in paid sea acts with
EPSTEIN.

f. In or about 20.05, Minor Victim-3 was
recruited to engage in set acts with EPSTEIN and was repeatedly
sexually abused by EPSTEIN at the Palm Beach Residence over a
period of years and was paid hundreds of dollars for each
encounter. EPSTEIN also encouraged and enticed Minor Victim-3
to recruit other girls to engage in paid sex acts, which she
did. EPSTEIN asked Minor Victim-3 how 61d she was, and Minor
Victim-3 answered truthfully.
g'. In or about 2005, Employee-2, located in the
Southern District of New York, and on behalf of EPSTEIN, placed
a telephone call to Minor Victim-3 in Florida in order to
schedule an appointment for Minor Victim-3 to engage in paid sex
acts with EPSTEIN.

h. In or about 2004, Employee-3 placed a
telephone call to Minor Victim-3 in order to'schedule an
appointment for Minor Victim-3 to engage in paid sex acts with.
EPSTEIN.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.)
COUNT TWO
(Sex Trafficking)
The Grand Jury further charges:

23. The allegations contained in paragraphs.]:
through 19 and 22 of this Indictment are repeated and realleged
as if fdlly set forth within.

24. From at least in or about 2002, up to. and
including in or about 2005, in the Southern District of New
York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, willfully and knowingly,
in and affecting interstate and foreign commerce, did recruit,
entice, harbor, transport, provide, and obtain by any means a
person, knowing that the person had not attained the•age of 18
years and would be caused to engage in a commercial sex act, and
did aid and abet the same, to wit, EPSTEIN recruited, enticed,
harbored, transported, provided, and obtained numerous
individuals who were less than 18 years old, including but not
limited to Minor Victim -1, as described above, and who were then
caused to engage in at least one commercial sex act in
'Manhattan, New York.
. (Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591(a),
(b)(2), and 2.)
•
FORFEITURE ALLEGATIONS

25. As a result of committing the offense alleged in
Count Tice of this Indictment, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant,
shall forfeit to the United States, pursuant to Title 18, United
States Code, Section 1594(c)(1), any property, real and
personal, that was used or intended to be used to commit or to
facilitate the commission of the offense alleged in Count Two,
and any property, real or personal, constituting or derived from
any proceeds obtained, directly or indirectly, as a result of
the offense alleged in Count Two, or any property traceable to
such property, and the following specific property:

a. The lot or parcel of land, together with its
buildings, appurtenances, improvements, fixtures, attachments.
and easements, located at 9 East 71st Street, New York, New
York, with block number 1386 and lot number 10, owned by
Maple, Inc.
Substitute Asset Provision

26. If any of the above-described forfeitable
property, as a result of any act or ()passion of the defendant: •

(a) cannot be located upon the exercise of due diligence;
(b) has been transferred or sold to, or deposited with, 4
third person;

(c) has been placed beyond the jurisdiction of the Court;
(d)• has been substantially diminished in value; or

(e) has been commingled with other property which cannot
be subdivided with6ut difficulty;
it is the intent of the United States, pursuant to 21 U.S.C.
S 853(p) and 28 S 2461(c), to seek forfeiture of any
other property of the defendant Up to the value. Of the above
forfeitable property.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 1594; Title 21,
United States Code, Section 853(p); and
Title 28, United States Code, Section 2461..)
GEOFF cl IT BERMAN.
United States Attorney
4 PertL—_,
Form No. USA-33s-274 (Ed. 9-25-58)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
v.
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
'INDICTMENT
418 U.S.C. §§ 371, 1591(a), (b)(2),
and 2)
GEOFFREY S. BERMAN
United States Attorney
Forepe -on
EXHIBIT B
2017.08.02
AO 93 (SDNY Rev. 01/17)Search and Seizure Wammt
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
Southern District of New York
In the Matter of the Search of
(Briefly describe the property to be searched
or identify the person byname and address)
See Attachment A
Case No.
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or en attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the  Southern  District of  New York
(Identify the perm: or describe the property to be searched and glee its location):
see Attachment A
The person or property to be searched, described above, is believed to conceal (idea* the person or describe the 
property
to be settecO: .
See Attachment A
The search and seizure are related to violation(s) of Oaten statutory citations):
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 371 and 1591
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the perion or
property.
YOU ARE COM:WIANDED to execute this warrant on or before  1- • rte )
(not to exceed 14 days)
21 in the daytime 6:00 a.m. to 10 p.m. Oat any time in the day or night as I find reasonable cause has been
established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property
taken to the person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the
place where the property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present during the execution of the warrant, must prepare an
inventory as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to the Clerk of the Court.
O Upon its return, this warrant and inventory should be filed under seal by the Clerk of the Court
O I find that immediate notification may have an adverse result listed in 18 U.S.C. § 2705 (except for delay
of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay notice to the person who, or whose property, will 
be
searched or seized (check the appropriate box) Ofor days (not to exceed 30).
Ountil, the facts justifying, r specific date of
Date and time issued: 1- lAtk ek • V\ • Judge's signature
City and state: New York, NY Hon. Barbara Moses, U.S. Magistrate Judge
Printed name =Mk
AO 93 (SONY Rev. 01!17) Search and Seth= Warrant ahle
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy of warrant and inventory left with:
Inventory made in the presence of :
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized:
Certification
I declare under penalty of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant
to the Court
Date: Executing officer's signature
Printed name and title
ATTACHMENT A

I. Premises to be Searched —Subject Premises
1. The premises to be searched (the "Subject Premises") are described as a nearly
19,000 square foot multi-story single-family residence located at 9 East 71st Street, New York,
New York, and include all locked and closed containers found therein. A photograph of the front
entrance to the Subject Premises is included below:

II. Items to Be Seized
1. This warrant authorizes executing agents to photograph, video record and otherwise
document the full interior of the Subject Premises, including any items, furnishings, or possessions
therein.

2. In addition, this warrant authorizes the seizure of certain evidence, fruits, and
instrumentalities of violations of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of
minors) and 371 (sex trafficking conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

a. Evidence concerning occupancy or ownership of the Subject Premises,
including utility and telephone bills, mail envelopes, addressed correspondence,
diaries, statements, identification documents, address books, telephone
directories, and photographs of its occupant(s).
b. Evidence concerning the layout, furnishings, decorations, and floor pattern of
the Subject Premises, including photographs and blueprints of the Subject
Premises.
2017.08.02
EXHIBIT C
2017.08.02
ISDNY Rcs 01/17 :itch and Scrture Warrant
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
Southern District of New York
In the Matter of the Search of
tarn* describe die property to be searched
or identify  the person by name and address)
See Attachment A
Case No.
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the Southern  District of  New York_
lidentifi• the person or describe the property• to be searched and give its location):
See Attachment A
The person or property to be searched, described above, is believed to conceal (identib the person or describe the 
property
io be seized,:
See Attachment A
the search and seizure are related to violation(s) of (Insert statutory Cit011OILV
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 371 and 1591
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the person or
property.
YOU ARE COMMANDED to execute this warrant on or before
(not to exceed 14 daYs)
O in the daytime 6:00 a.m. to l0 p.m. al  at any time in the day or night as I find reasonable cause has been
established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property
taken to the person from whom, or from whose premises. the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the
place where the property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present during the execution of the warrant, must prepare an
inventory as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to the Clerk of the Court.
O Upon its return, this warrant and inventory should be filed under seal by the Clerk of the Court.
(SW Initials
July 7, 2019
O I find that immediate notification may have an adverse result listed in IS U.S.C. § 2705 (except for delay
of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay notice to the person who, or whose property, will 
be
searched or seized (check the appropriate box) Ofor  days (not to exceed 30).
Ountil. the facts justifyi later specific date o
Date and time issued: 1  - rkota4k . Judge's signature
City and state: New York, NY  Hon. Barbara Moses. U.S. Magistrate Judge
Printed name and title
AO93 (SDNY Rev. OM 7)Search and Seizure Warrant (Page 2)
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy of wan-ant and inventory left with:
Inventory made in the presence of:
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized:
Certification
I declare under penalty
to the Court.
Date:
of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant
Executing officer's signature
Printed name and title
ATTACHMENT A

I. Premises to be Searched—Subject Premises
The premises to be searched (the "Subject Premises") are described as a multi-story
single-family residence located at 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York, and include all locked
and closed containers found therein. A photograph of the front entrance to the Subject Premises
is included below:

II. Items to Be Seized
A. Evidence, Fruits, and Instrumentalities of the Subject Offenses
This warrant authorizes the seizure of certain evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of
violations of Title IS, United States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of minors) and 371
(sex trafficking conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

i. Any and all taxidermied dogs.
ii. Any and all massage tables and massage paraphernalia.
iii. Any and all busts or three-dimensional representations of female human
torsos.

iv. Any and all photos or representations depicting nude or partially nude
women located in the Massage Room, as defined herein.

v. Any and all sex toys and sex paraphernalia located in the Massage
Room, as defined herein.
1017.03.02
vi. A binder labeled "PB Girls" and any other documents or
communications with or regarding victims or potential victims of the
Subject Offenses.
2017.0E.02
EXHIBIT D
2017.08.02
AO 93 (SDNY Rev. 01/17) Search and Seizure Warrant
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
Southern District of New York
En the Matter of the Search of
(Briefly describe the property to be searched
or identin the person by name and address)
See Attachment A
Case No.
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the  Southern  District of  New York
(identify the person or describe the property to be searched and give its location):
See Attachment A
The person or property to be searched, described above, is believed to conceal (Meng, the person or describe the 
property
to be seized):
See Attachment A
The search and seizure are related to violation(s) of (insert statutory citations):
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 371 and 1591
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the person or
property.
YOU ARE COMMANDED to execute this warrant on or before
(not to exceed 14 days)
O in the daytime 6:00 a.m. to 10 p.m. a at any time in the day or night as I find reasonable cause has been
established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property
taken to the person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the
place where the property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present during the execution of the warrant, must prepare an
inventory as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to the Clerk of the Court.
O Upon its return, this warrant and inventory should be filed under seal by the Clerk of the Court.
IJSAL1 Initials
July 21, 2019
O I find that immediate notification may have an adverse result listed in 18 U.S.C. § 2705 (except for delay
of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay notice to the person who, or whose property, will 
be
searched or seized (check the appropriate bar) O for  days (not to exceed 30).
Ountil, the facts justifying, the later specific date of
•-•
Date and time issued: 1-4 -Ick 11`-n? -1,A • Ju signature
City and state: New York, NY Hon. Barbara Moses, U.S. Magistrate Judge
Printed name and title

AC) 93 (SONY Rev. 01/17) Search and Seizure Warrani (Page 2)
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy of warrant and inventory left with:
Inventory made in the presence of:
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized:
Certification
I declare under penalty of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant to 
the Court.
Date:
Executing officer's signature
Printed name and title .
ATTACHMENT A

I. The Subject Devices to Be Searched
The Subject Devices are particularly described as compact discs stored in containers marked with FBI evidence numbers 
15, 16, 17, 18, and 22, seized from the
residence located at 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York, on or about July 7, 2019.

II. Items to Be Seized
A. Evidence, Fruits, and Instrumentalities of the Subject Offenses
This warrant authorizes the seizure of certain evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of violations of Title 18, United
States Code, Sections 1591 (sex
trafficking of minors), and 371 (sex
trafficking conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

1. Any documents or communications with or regarding victims or potential victims
of the Subject Offenses;

2. Any photographs of victims or potential victims of the Subject Offenses;
3. Any nude, partially nude, or sexually suggestive photographs of individuals who appear to be teenage girls, or 
younger;1,

4. Motion pictures, films, videos, and other recordings of visual or written depictions
of minors engaged in sexually explicit conduct, as defined in 18 U.S.C. § 2256(2);

5. Records or other items that evidence ownership, control, or use of, or access to devices, storage media, and related 
electronic equipment used to access,
transmit, or store information relating to the Subject Offenses, including, but not limited to, sales receipts, 
warranties, bills for Internet access,
handwritten notes, registry entries, configuration files, saved
usemames and passwords, user profiles, e-mail contacts, and photographs;

6. Any child erotica, defined as suggestive visual depictions of nude minors that do not constitute child pornography as
defined by 18 U.S.C. § 2256(8).
B. Review of ESI
Law enforcement personnel (including, in addition to law enforcement officers and agents, and depending on the nature of
the ESI and the status of the
investigation and related proceedings,
attorneys for the government, attorney support staff, agency personnel assisting the government in this investigation, 
and outside technical experts under
government control) will create a forensic
image of the Subject Devices (if practicable) and review the ESI contained therein for information responsive to the 
warrant.
In conducting this review, law enforcement personnel may use various techniques to determine which files or other ESI 
contain evidence or fruits of the Subject
Offenses. Such techniques may include, for example:
2017.08.02

• surveying directories or folders and the individual files they contain (analogous to
looking at the outside of a file cabinet for the markings it contains and opening a drawer believed to contain pertinent
files);

• conducting a file-by-file review by "opening" or reading the first few "pages" of such files in order to determine 
their precise contents (analogous to
performing a cursory examination of each document in a file cabinet to determine its relevance);

• "scanning" storage areas to discover and possibly recover recently deleted data or deliberately hidden files; and

• performing electronic keyword searches through all electronic storage areas to determine the existence and location of
data potentially related to the subject
matter of the investigation6; and

• reviewing metadata, system information, configuration files, registry data, and any other information reflecting how, 
when, and by whom the computer was used.
Law enforcement personnel will make reasonable efforts to search only for files, documents, or other electronically 
stored information within the categories
identified in Section II.A of this Attachment. However, law enforcement personnel are authorized to conduct a complete 
review of all the ESI from seized devices
or storage media if necessary to evaluate its contents and to locate all data responsive to the warrant.
6 Keyword searches alone are typically inadequate to detect all relevant data. For one thing, keyword searches work only
for text data, yet many types of files,
such as images and videos, do. not store data as searchable ten Moreover, even as to text data, there may be information
properly subject to seizure but that is
not captured by a keyword search because the information does not contain the keywords being searched.
2 2017.08.02
EXHIBIT E
2017.08.02
• r
r .
AO 93 (SDNY Rev. 01/17) Search end Seizure Warrant
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
In the Matter of the Search of
for the
Southern District of New York
1 9 MAG 6 4 a 9 (Briefly describe the property to be searched
or gent& the person by name and address)
See Attachment A
Case No. 19 Cr. 490 (RMB)
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the  Southern  District of  flew York
(ldent& the person or describe the property to be searched and give its location):
See Attachment A
The person or property to be searched, described above, is believerlto conceal °dent& the person or describe the 
property
to be seirecp:
See Attachment A
The search and seizure are related to violation(s) of (insert statutory citations):
Title 18, United States Code, Sections 371 and 1591
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the person or
property.
YOU ARE COMMANDED to execute this warrant on or before  Jury 12, 2019
(not to exceed 14 dens)
in the daytime 6:00 a.m. to 10 p.m. at any time in the day or night as I find reasonable cause has been
k established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you• must give a copy-of the warrant and a receipt for the property
taken to the person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the
place where the property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present during the execution of the warrant, must prepare an
inventory as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to the Clerk of the Court.
0 Upon its return, this warrant and inventory should be filed under seal by the Clerk of the Court.
Uniarrtia4
O I fmd that immediate notification may have an adverse result listed in 18 1/,$)Cr § 2705 (except for delay
of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay notice to thcpeivnlio, pc :..,hose property, will 
be
searched or seized (Check the appropriate box) D for days (not to exce00).$ • / ' ;
°until, the facts justifying, tkielatei•sPecific date of
Date and time issued:
City and state: New York, NY Hon. Hen& i?firean; Uc9.,'Iv?t.cjistrate Judge
AO 93 (SONY Rev. 01/17) Search and Seizure Warrant (Page 2)
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy' f warrant and inventory left with:
Inventory made in the presence of :
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized:
. .
•
J
•
Certification
I declare under penalty of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant
to the Court.
Date: , &tasting officer's signature
Printed name and tide
i
ATTACHMENT A

I. Premises to be Searched —Subject Premises
I. The premises to be searched (the "Subject Premises") are described as a multi-story
single-family residence located at 9 East 7Ist Street, New York, New York, and include all locked
and closed containers found therein. A photograph of the front enhance to the Subject Premises
is included below:

11. Items to Be Seized
A. Evidence, Fruits, and Instrumentalities of the Subject Offenses
This warrant authorizes the seizure of certain evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of
violations of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of minors), and 371 (sex
trafficking conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:
The items to be seized from the Subject Premises are any computer devices and storage
media that may contain any electronically stored information falling within the categories set forth
in Section B of this Attachment, including, but not limited to, desktop and laptop computers, disk
drives, modems, thumb drives, personal digital assistants, smart phones, digital cameras, scanners,
routers, modems, and network equipment used to connect to the Internet. In lieu of seizing any
such computer devices or storage media, this warrant also authorizes, in the alternative, the
copying of such devices or media for later review.
The items to be seized from the Subject Premises also include:
2017.08.02

1. Any items or records needed to access the data stored on any seized or copied
computer devices or storage media, including but not limited to any physical keys, encryption
devices, or records of login credentials, passwords, private encryption keys, or similar information.

2. Any items or records that may facilitate a forensic examination of the computer
devices or storage media, including any hardware or software manuals or other information
concerning the configuration of the seized or copied computer devices or storage media.

3. Any evidence concerning the identities or locations of those persons with access to,
control over, or ownership of the seized or copied computer devices or storage media.

B. Search and Seizure of Electronically Stored Information
As set forth in Section A to this attachment, this warrant authorizes the search of the Subject
Premises for any computer devices and storage media that may contain any electronically stored
information falling within the categories set forth below:

4. Any documents or communications with or regarding victims or potential victims
of the Subject Offenses;

5. Any photographs of victims or potential victims of the Subject Offenses;
6. Any nude, partially nude, or sexually suggestive photographs of individuals who
appear to be teenage girls, or younger;

7. Records or other items that evidence ownership, control, or use of; or access to
devices, storage media, and related electronic equipment used to access, transmit, or store
information relating to the Subject Offenses, including, but not limited to, sales receipts,
warranties, bills for Internet access, handwritten notes, registry entries, configuration files, saved
usernames and passwords, user profiles,-e-mail contacts, and photographs;

8. Any child erotica, defined as suggestive visual depictions of nude minors that do
not constitute child pornography as defined by 18 U.S.C. § 2256(8).
C. Review of ESI
Law enforcement personnel (including, in addition to law enforcement officers and agents,
and depending on the nature of the ESI and the status of the investigation and related proceedings,
attorneys for the government, attorney support staff, agency personnel assisting the government in
this investigation, and outside technical experts under government control) will create a forensic
image of the Subject Devices (if practicable) and review the ESI contained therein for information
responsive to the warrant, that is, for the materials specified in Section B of this Attachment.
In conducting this review, law enforcement personnel may use various techniques to
determine which files or other ESI contain evidence or fruits of the Subject Offenses. Such
techniques may include, for example:
2017.08.02

• surveying directories or folders and the individual files they contain (analogous to
looking at the outside of a file cabinet for the markings it contains and opening a drawer
believed to contain pertinent files);

• conducting a file:by-file review by "opening" or reading the first few "pages" of such
files in order to determine their precise contents (analogous to performing a cursory
examination of each document in a file cabinet to determine its relevance);

• "scanning" storage areas to discover and possibly recover recently deleted data or
deliberately hidden files; and

• performing electronic keyword searches through all electronic storage areas to
determine the existence and location of data potentially related to the subject matter of
the investigation6; and

• reviewing metadata, system information, configuration files, registry data, and any
other information reflecting how, when, and by whom the computer was used.

• . Law enforcement personnel will make reasonable efforts to search only for files,
documents, or other electronically stored information within the categories identified in Section
ILA of this Attachment. However, law enforcement personnel are authorized to conduct a
complete review of all the EST from seized devices or storage media if necessary to evaluate its
contents and to locate all data responsive to the warrant
6 Keyword searches alone are typically inadequate to detect all relevant data. For one thing,
keyword searches work only for text data, yet many types: of files, such' as images and videos, do
not store data as searchable text. Moreover, even as to text data, there may be information properly
subject to seizure but that is not captured by a keyword search because the information does not
contain the keywords being searched.
2017.08.02
EXHIBIT F
2017.08.02
J •
AO 93 (S13NY Act 01/17) Stara and Want Warrant

• UNI.I.ED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
Southern Dktrict of New York
pliOLOI•led CMS Stit•Ci oe meet ,t, seek pul
Wit smIkare; A.4 0O4 Cht se2,4 SEARCH AND SETiIIRE WARRANT it-a. flofivo 61.
it iVerinjyA: glee j and itop6iitarrs os•k ce.s.ki 2,0frame..
To: Anir orined law enforcement officer
'1/TAG 6581
In the Matter ofithe Search of )
(Briefly deem& the property to be:earthed ) or dent* the person byname ant I rectelayse)
A 1./or( r Now. w ita. 1..mcs No zst to to irnt.-46),
$'ef..Attach ./
Alb,  in 'Pa a Subtitle. O tuts te 3 19J)42tAd rhe )
qv ne IMIlit Fest Per : no,. iirkrcirkets 6.4th CbSjeilee, frwsri- biatt44+0 s.e
An application by a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government requests the search
of the following person or property located in the  Southern  District of  New York
(?dandily the person or describe the properly to be strathed and give ter location):
See Attachment A
The person or property to be searched, described above, is believed to conceal Went* the person or describe the properly
to be setrecp:
See Attachment A
The search and seizure are related to violation(s) of (mseri statutory dtations):
I find that the affidavit(s), or any recorded testimony, establish probable cause to search and seize the person or
property.
YOU ARE COMMANDED to TA? 21 1160 this warrant on or before
(not to exceed14
has *hi the daytime 6:06 am. to io p.m. at any time in the day or night as I find reasonable cause  been
established.
Unless delayed notice is authorized below, you must give a copy of the warrant and a receipt for the property
taken to the person from whom, or from whose premises, the property was taken, or leave the copy and receipt at the
place where the property was taken.
The officer executing this warrant, or an officer present dining the execution of the warrant, must prepare an

• inventory as required by law and promptly return this warrant and inventory to titsCleSof lite Court
1 Upon its return, this warrant and inventory should be filed under seal by? t (Id of thbcourt  iNc
, . •
find that immediate notification may have an adverse result listot S.d,.§ 2705 gizcot..k.t for delay
of trial), and authorize the officer executing this warrant to delay noticeg th.4erson.lifs,Oosmvirsip property, will be
searched or seized (check the appropriate r  30  days (not  icre-eetl'0). ,•!
Ountil„ the facts justifying, tiie litO fspecifk ,chic of:
6): 3s-JUL 1 5 2019
-Date and time issued:
City and state: New York, NY
•.4
nttnn
vrivgfit _fa r,,Y
:;t!PIM5VAIO:N50401ickfox

• unitsnRAStmlistv 4i1(7: Southern District of New York.
•
AO 93 (SDNY Rev. 01M) Search and Seizure Waist (No 2)
Return
Case No.: Date and time warrant executed: Copy of warrant and inventory leR with:
Inventory made in the presence of :
Inventory of the property taken and name of any person(s) seized: •
•
Certification
I declare under penalty of perjury that this inventory is correct and was returned along with the original warrant
to the Court


• Date:. . ,  - Perot, officer': "%what
. ' Prbgaincore and Me
Attachment A

I. Items Subject to Search and Seizure .
The Subject Items are particularly described as follows':

• A black iPhone with. NEI number 357201093322785, which was seized from
. JEFFREY EPSTEIN on or about July 6, 2019 ("Subject Item-1").

• A silver iPad with serial number DLXQGM3KOlvfW3, which was seized from
JEFFREY EPSTEIN on or about July 6, 2019 ("Subject Item-2").

• Two black binders with CDs, which were seive/rom a blue suitcas
July 11, 2019 ("Subject Item-3"). /hi) Sett') 0,(

• Two black bard drives, which were seized rom a blue suitcase
2019 ("Subject Item-4").
bit il'eC 4..1 Ar•E

• A box of CDs, which was seized from a b ue suitcase on or ... T
("Subject Item-5"). r._
It(\ Seci,4,1 Al
• 'Two binders with various CDs, whiaa were seized! \from
July 11, 2019 ("Subject Item-6"). .
IC Review of ESI on the Subject Items
Law enforcement personnel (who may include, in addition to law enforcement officers and
agents, attorneys for the government, attorney support staft agency personnel assisting the
government in this investigation, and outside technical experts under government control) are
authorized to review the ESI contained on the Subject Items for evidence, fruits, and
instrumentalities of violations of Title .18, United States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of
minors), and 371 (sex trafficking conspiracy) (the "Subject Offenses") described as follows:

1. Any documents or communications with or regarding victims or potential victims
of the Subject Offenses;

2. Any photographs of victims or potential victims of the Subject Offenses;
3. ' • Any nude, partially nude, or sexually suggestive photographs of individuals who
appear to be teenage girls, or younger,

4. Records, data, or other items that evidence ownership, control, or use oZ or ace eqc
to the Subject Items, including, but not limited to Racer history data, historical location data,
To the extent that the Subject Items contain any sib cards or other removable storage media, the
description of each such item encompasses those SD cards and other media.
2017.08.02 '
configuration files, saved usemames and passwords, user profiles, e-mail contacts, and
photographs;

5. Any child erotica, defined as suggestive visual depictions of nude minors that do
not constitute child pomograpb.y as defined by 18 U.S.C. § 2256(8).
As to Subject Item-1 and Subject Item-2, Law enforcement personnel (who may include,
in addition to law enforcement officers and agents, attorneys for the government, attorney support
staff, agency personnel assisting the government inthis investigation, and outside technical experts
under government control) are further authorized to review the ESI contained on Subject Item-1
and • Subject Item-2 for evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of violations of Title 18, United
States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of minors), and 371 (sex trafficking conspiracy) (the
"Subject Offences.") described as follows:
1. Any documents or communications with or regarding co-conspirators in the Subject
Offenses.
In conducting this review, law enforcement personnel may use various techniques to

• determine which files or other ESI contain evidence or fruits of the Subject Offenses. Such •
techniques may include, for example:.

• • surveying directories or folders and the individual files they 'contain (analogous to
looking at the outside of a file cabinet for the markings it contains and opening a drawer
believed to contain pertinent files);

• conducting a file-by-file review by "opening" or reading the first few "pages" of such
files in order to determine their precise contents (analogous to performing a cursory
examination of each document in a file cabinet to determine its relevance);

• "scanning" storage areas to discover and possibly recover recently deleted data or
deliberately hidden files; and

• performing electronic keyword searches through all electronic storage areas to
determine the existence and location of data potentially related to the subject matter of
the investigation; and
• reviewing metadata, system information, configuration files, registry data, and any
other information reflecting how, when, and by whom the computer was used.
Law enforcement personnel will make reasonable efforts to search only for files,
documents, or other electronically stored information within the categories identified in Section II
of this Attachment. However, law enforcement personnel are authorized to conduct a complete
review of all the ESI from seized devices or storage media if necessary to evaluate its contents and
to locate all dataresponsive to the warrant.
2017.08.02
SAO 106 (SDNY Rev. 01/17) Application fora Search Warrant
Yr:
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
Southern Disf;c: hoef Newt  RAG 857 9 In the Matter of the Search of
(Briefly describe the property to be searched or identi( the person by name and address)
27 electronic devices seized on
August 12, 2019 from Little Saint James in the
Virgin Islands
Case No.
APPLICATION FOR A SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRANT
I, a federal law enforcement officer or an attorney for the government, request a search warrant and state under
penalty of perjury that I have reason to believe that on the following person or property (identifr the person or 
describe the
property to be searched and give its location):
located in the  Southern  District of  New York  , there is now concealed (identifi  the
person or describe the property to be seized):
See Attached Affidavit and its Attachment A
The basis for the search under Fed. R. Crim. P. 41(c) is (check one or more):
X O evidence of a crime;
O contraband, fruits of crime, or other items illegally possessed;
O property designed for use, intended foruse, or used in committing a crime;
O a person to be arrested or a person who is unlawfully restrained.
The search is related to a violation of:
Code Section(s)
18 USC 1591
18 USC 371
Offense Description(s)
Sex Trafficking of Minors
Sex Trafficking Conspiracy
The application is based on these facts:
See Attached Affidavit and its Attachment A
sr Continued on the attached sheet
O Delayed notice of days (give exact ending date if more than 30 days:
under 18 U.S.C. § 3103a, the basis of which is set forth on the atta
Sworn to before me and signed in my presence.
Date:
City and state:  New York, NY
Applicant's signature
Task Force Office
Printed nom and Mk
\
ge:ss. t
Cott; linited Sta6t Magitt
prundromendoe
) is requested
FBI
• „•• rl
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
i9MAG 857 9
C,57 9
In the Matter of the Application of the United
States Of America for a Search and Seizure
Warrant for 27 electronic devices seized on
August 12, 2019 from Little Saint James in the
Virgin Islands.
TO BE FILED UNDER SEAL
Agent Affidavit in Support of
Application for Search and Seizure
Warrant
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK) ss.:
being duly sworn, deposes and says:

I. Introduction
A. Affiant
1. I have been a Task Force Officer with the Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI")
since 2017. As such, I am a "federal law enforcement officer within the meaning of Federal Rule
of Criminal Procedure 41(a)(2)(C), that is, a government agent engaged in enforcing the criminal
laws and duly authorized by the Attorney General to request a search warrant. I am also a detective
with the New York Police Department ("NYPD") and have been employed by the NYPD for
approximately thirteen years. I am currently assigned to investigate violations of criminal law
relating to the sexual exploitation of children as part of an FBI Task Force. I have gained expertise
in this area through classroom training and daily work related to these types of investigations. As
part of my responsibilities, I have been involved in the investigation of sex trafficking cases, and
have participated in the execution of search warrants for electronic devices and electronic storage
media.

2. I make this Affidavit in support of an application pursuant to Rule 41 of the Federal
Rules of Criminal Procedure for a warrant to search the electronic devices specified below (the
"Subject Devices") for the items and information described in Attachment A. This affidavit is
2017.08.02
based upon my personal knowledge; my review of documents and other evidence; my
conversations with other law enforcement personnel; and my training, experience and advice
received concerning the use of computers in criminal activity and the forensic analysis of
electronically stored information ("ESI"). Because this affidavit is being submitted for the limited
purpose of establishing probable cause, it does not include all the facts that I have learned during
the course of my investigation. Where the contents of documents and the actions, statements, and
conversations of others are reported herein, they are reported in substance and in part, except where
otherwise indicated.

B. The Subject Devices
3. The Subject Devices were all recovered from a search of a private island in the U.S.
Virgin Islands, known as Little Saint James, which is an approximately 75 acre island located
approximately four miles off the southeast coast of St. Thomas Island (the "Virgin Islands
Residence") on or about August 12, 2019. The Virgin Islands Residence consists of multiple
structures, including a main residence as well as several other smaller structures on the island,
including a pool house, sheds, a beach house, an office, and multiple cabanas. However, as
detailed below, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, who was a Target Subject of this Investigation until his death
in August 2019, is the only known occupant of the Virgin Islands Residence. The Subject Devices
are particularly described as follows:

a. A gray Mac desktop computer labeled "kitchen mac," which was recovered from
a desk in the main residence on the island ("Subject Device-1");

b. A silver Mac laptop labeled "JE big laptop," bearing serial number W8 111772QT,
which was recovered from a desk in the main residence on the island ("Subject
Device-2");
2017.08.02

c. A silver MacBook Pro bearing serial number c02qmOgugwdp, which was
recovered from a desk in the main residence on the island ("Subject Device-3");

d. A silver iPad model A1567 bearing serial number drnpq125ng5ypy, which was
recovered from a desk in the main residence ("Subject Device-4");

e. A silver iPad model A1567 bearing serial number dinpqL1rmg5y, which was
recovered from a desk in the main residence ("Subject Device-5"),

f. A silver Mac desktop computer bearing serial number cO2nm1m0fy14, which was
recovered from a desk in the pool house on the island ("Subject Device-6"),

g. A silver Mac desktop computer, which was recovered from a desk in a cabana on
the island ("Subject Device-7");

h. A Toshiba Laptop, which was recovered from a box on the floor near a desk in a
shed on the island ("Subject Device-8");

i. An HP laptop bearing serial number cnd81368v5, which was recovered from a desk
in a shed on the island ("Subject Device-9");

j. A silver Mac desktop computer, which was recovered from a desk in a cabana on
the island ("Subject Device 10");

k. A silver Macbook desktop computer, which was recovered from a desk in a cabana
on the island ("Subject Device-11");

I. A Dell Inspiron Tower computer model D19M QC1IFA335, which was recovered
from a desk in the beach house on the island ("Subject Device-I2");

m. A silver Mac desktop computer model A1311 bearing serial number
W804736DDAS, which was recovered from a desk in the beach house on the island
("Subject Device-13");
2017.08.02
a
a

n. A Unfi video bearing mac ID 1829f b4fbe426ea90, which was recovered from a
server rack inside a shed on the island ("Subject Device-I4");

o. A Unifi Server bearing mac ID 1735K 788A20463234-8uuu9f, which was
recovered from a server rack inside a shed in on the island ("Subject Device-15");

p. An HP server with four 500 GB drives, bearing serial number MXQ3220187, which
was recovered from a shed on the island ("Subject Device-16");

q. A Panasonic KX TDE100 computer bearing serial number KX-TDa0104
9LCCD005398, which was found on a server rack in a shed on the island ("Subject
Device-17");

r. A 6 bay with 146 GB drives bearing serial number MXQ824A IR, which was found
on a server rack in a shed on the island ("Subject Device-18");

s. A silver Mac desktop computer, which was recovered from a desk in a cabana on
the island ("Subject Device-19");

t. An HP desktop tower model 260-A010, bearing serial number cnv7160050, which
was recovered from the maintenance office on the island ("Subject Device-20");

u. An HP tower model 260-A010, bearing serial number cnv716004y, which was
recovered from the maintenance office on the island ("Subject Device-21");

v. A Mac desktop computer model A1312, bearing serial number w89524czspj, which
was recovered from the maintenance office on the island ("Subject Device-22");

w. A Lenovo tower machine type 90J0, bearing serial number mj07yg6u, which was
recovered the maintenance office on the island ("Subject Device-23");

x. A Lenovo tower bearing serial number 153306g2umjxekgx, which was recovered
the maintenance office on the island ("Subject Device-24");
2017.08.02

y. An HP Tower bearing serial number CNV74213M3 570-P056, which was
recovered the maintenance office on the island ("Subject Device-25");

z. A Unifi cloudkey with FCCID: SWX-UCCK IC 6545A-UCCK and Mac ID
1843kb4fbe4d30c69-dcrgm9, which was found on a server rack in a shed on the
island ("Subject Device-26"); and

a. A red Nikon digital camera, which was recovered on a file cabinet next to a desk in
a cabana on the island ("Subject Device-27").

4. Subject Device-I through Subject Device-25 are all computers and/or storage
devices capable of storing electronic picture and message files.

5. Subject Device-26 is a device that identifies a user to a service over the Internet. It
acts as a key that allows users to access other data on other devices, such as Subject Device-1
through Subject Device-25.

6. Subject Device-27 is a digital camera capable of taking and storing electronic
picture files.
7. The Subject Devices have all been transported by the FBI from the Virgin Islands
to FBI offices in the Southern District of New York. At this time, all of the Subject Devices are
presently located in the Southern District of New York.

C. The Subject Offenses
8. For the reasons detailed below, I believe that there is probable cause to believe that
the Subject Device contains evidence, fruits, and instrumentalities of violations of Title 18, United
States Code, Sections 1591 (sex trafficking of minors), and 371 (sex trafficking conspiracy) (the
"Subject Offenses"). The Target Subjects of this investigation are known and unknown co-
conspirators of JEFFREY EPSTEIN, including but not limited to
2017.08.02

II. Probable Cause and the Initial Search Warrants
A. Probable Cause Regarding the Target Subjects' Commission of the Subject
Offenses

9. On or about July 2, 2019, a grand jury in the Southern District of New York returned
an Indictment charging JEFFREY EPSTEIN with violations of Tide 18, United States Code,

Section 1591 (sex trafficking of minors); and Title 18, United States Code, Section 371 (sex
trafficking conspiracy). A copy of the Indictment is attached hereto as Exhibit A and is
incorporated by reference. EPSTEIN was arrested pursuant to the Indictment on or about July 6,
2019, and had been detained pending trial at the Metropolitan Correctional Center ("MCC") in
New York, New York.

10. On or about August 10, 2019, the Bureau of Prisons confirmed that JEFFREY
EPSTEIN had been found unresponsive in his cell at the MCC that morning, and was pronounced
dead shortly thereafter.

11. Notwithstanding EPSTEIN's death, the sex trafficking investigation that led to his
indictment remains ongoing. In particular, Count One of the Indictment alleged that EPSTEIN
conspired with others to traffic minors, and further identified three individuals who worked for
EPSTEIN (identified in Exhibit A as "Employee-1", "Employee-2," and "Employee-3") and
facilitated EPSTEIN's abuse of minor girls by, among other things, arranging victims' encounters
with EPSTEIN and paying victims after these encounters. The individual identified in Exhibit A
as "Employee-2" is a a Target Subject of this investigation.

12. On or about November 28, 2018, the Miami Herald began publishing a series of
articles relating to the defendant, his sexual misconduct with minors, and a previous investigation
into his conduct in Florida from in or about 2005 through 2008. The article included information
about a role in EPSTEIN's sexual abuse of minors. Based on my participation
2017.08.02
in this investigation, I have learned that bank records obtained by the Government appear to show
that just days later, on or about December 3, 2018, the defendant wired $250,000 from a trust
account to II= This course of action, and in particular its timing, suggests that EPSTEIN
was attempting to influence who might have been able to provide information against
him in light of the recently re-emerging allegations.

13. As set forth in Exhibit A, from at least in or about 2002, up to and including at least
in or about 2005, JEFFREY EPSTEIN sexually abused multiple minor girls in Manhattan, New
York; West Palm Beach, Florida; and elsewhere. During that time and continuing to the present,
EPSTEIN possessed and controlled a residence, which is described in Exhibit A as "the New York
Residence."

14. As anther set forth in paragraphs 8 through 10 of Exhibit A, from at least in or
about 2002, up to and including at least in or about 2005, EPSTEIN sexually abused numerous
minor victims at the New York Residence. In particular, and as alleged in the Indictment, when a
victim arrived at the New York Residence, she would be escorted to a room inside the New York
Residence with a massage table, where she would perform a massage on EPSTEIN. The victims,
who were as young as 14 years of age, were told by EPSTEIN or other individuals to partially or
fully undress before beginning the "massage." During the encounter, EPSTEIN would escalate
the nature and scope of physical contact with his victim to include, among other things, sex acts
such as groping and direct and indirect contact with the victims' genitals. EPSTEIN typically
would also masturbate during these sexualized encounters, ask victims to touch him while he
masturbated, and touch victims' genitals with his hands or with sex toys. Following each
encounter, EPSTEIN or one of his employees or associates paid the victim in cash.
8 2017.08.02

15. As set forth in paragraphs 12 through 13 of Exhibit A, to further facilitate his ability
to abuse minor girls in New York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN asked and enticed certain of his victims to
recruit additional minor girls to perform "massages" and similarly engage in sex acts with
EPSTEIN. When a victim would recruit another minor girl for EPSTEIN, he paid both the victim-
recruiter and the new victim hundreds of dollars in cash. EPSTEIN knew that his victims were
underage, including because certain victims told him their age.

16. One of the victims identified in paragraph 22 of Exhibit A is Victim-1. As part of
the FBI's investigation of EPSTEIN, I have participated in interviews with Victim-1, along with
other law enforcement officers. I Based on my participation in those interviews and my
conversations with other law enforcement officers, I know that Victim-1 has provided the
following information, in substance and in part:

a. Between approximately 2002 and 2005, EPSTEIN sexually abused Victim-1 on
multiple occasions in the New York Residence. This sexual abuse all occurred when Victim-1
was under the age of 18.

b. During that same period, Victim-1 observed multiple floors of the New York
Residence and numerous individual rooms within the New York Residence. Victim-1 has
provided detailed descriptions of certain aspects of the interior of the New York Residence,
including Victim-l's memory of specific details regarding the layout, furnishings, decorations, and
In meetings with the Government, Victim-1 has disclosed that, approximately a decade ago, she
committed marriage fraud in order to obtain a green card and, subsequently, U.S. citizenship. She
has also disclosed personal substance abuse, primarily involving the abuse of prescription drugs,
during various periods between the early 2000s and 2019. Victim-1 has also disclosed having
worked for approximately a year at a "happy-ending" massage parlor, performing paid sex acts.
Victim-1 is currently pursuing a civil damages claim against EPSTEIN for his sexual abuse of her.
Information provided by Victim-1 has proven reliable and has been corroborated by independent
evidence, including documents and records obtained during the investigation and the accounts of
other victims whom Victim-1 has never met.
2017.08.02
floor pattern of various areas within the New York Residence. Among other details, Victim-1
recalled that EPSTEIN typically abused her in a room she described as a "massage room," (the
"Massage Room"), which contained a massage table, and was decorated with artwork depicting
naked women, hung on walls that appeared to be adorned with fabric. In describing the sexual
abuse that occurred in the Massage Room, Victim-1 has stated that EPSTEIN would often touch
her genital area with a vibrating sex toy during these abusive encounters.
The Search of the New York Residence

17. On or about July 6, 2019, the Honorable Barbara Moses, United States Magistrate
Judge, signed a search warrant authorizing a search of the New York Residence. The search
warrant is attached as Exhibit B and incorporated by reference herein.

18. At approximately 6 p.m. on or about July 6, 2019, law enforcement officers (the
"Search Team") commenced executing the search warrant at the New York Residence. JEFFREY
EPSTEIN had been arrested on the charges contained in the Indictment shortly before the
execution of the search warrant. Based on the Search Team's observations during an initial search
of the New York Residence, at approximately 7 p.m., the Search Team stopped the search and
froze the scene in order to seek a new search warrant. On or about July 7, 2019, the Honorable
Barbara Moses, United States Magistrate Judge, signed a search warrant authorizing a search of
the New York Residence (the "Second Warrant"). The Second Warrant is attached as Exhibit C,
and incorporated by reference herein. At approximately 2:30 a.m., the Search Team resumed the
search, and commenced searching pursuant to the Second Warrant. Later on July 7, 2019, the
Honorable Barbara Moses, United States Magistrate Judge, signed a third search warrant to search
and seize certain electronic media stored on discs seized during the execution of the Second
2017.08.02
Warrant (the "Compact Disc Search Warrant"). The Compact Disc Search Warrant is attached as
Exhibit D, and incorporated by reference herein.

19. During the execution of the warrants described above in the New York Residence,
the Search Team located evidence of the Subject Offenses. In particular, the Search Team located
the following, among other things, the following:

a. Inside the New York Residence, the Search Team observed a room that, based on
my participation in interviews of Victim-1, appears to be consistent with Victim-l's descriptions
of the Massage Room. The room contained a table covered with a sheet, and appeared to be a
massage table. The room also contained several vibrating sex toys. The walls appeared to be
covered in a type of felt-like tapestry fabric. I further observed two paintings and three
photographs hanging on the walls of the Massage Room. The paintings and photographs depict
nude females. One of the photographs appears to depict a nude girl. Thus, it appears that the
Massage Room was in substantially the same condition as Victim-1 observed the room more than
18 years ago.

b. Inside a safe in a closet on the third floor, the Search team discovered and seized,
among other items, several binders containing sleeves of compact discs, most of which are labeled
with handwriting. In total, the binders contain dozens of compact discs. Some discs contain the
word "Zorro" or "LSJ." Based on my conversations with law enforcement agents who have
participated in this investigation, I believe the name "Zorro" refers to Zorro Ranch, EPSTEIN's
property in New Mexico, and the name LSJ refers to Little Saint James, i.e., the Virgin Islands
Residence. The majority of the discs contain titles that include female names. Some of the discs
in the binders seized by the Search Team have titles that appear to refer to trips or vacations.
2017.08.02
S

c. In the drawer of a dresser in a room on the Fifth floor of the New York Residence,
the Search team discovered and seized, among other items, a shoebox (the "Shoebox") containing
numerous compact discs. The majority of the discs are labeled, in handwriting, with female names.
One disc is marked "Thai Massage." Another disc is marked "Blonde Girl Photo Shoot." Yet
another disc is marked "Misc. Girls Nude/Dinner--Scientists." The discs in the Shoebox were
seized by the Search Team. In another drawer of that same dresser, the Search Team discovered
loose polaroid photographs depicting young, nude females who, based on the training and
experience of law enforcement officers who observed them, appear to be teenagers.

d. In a closet on the Fifth Floor of the Manhattan Residence, the Search Team
discovered, among other items, a box marked "women/old photos." The box contained, among
other items, approximately seven compact discs, which are labeled with hand-written titles. One
disc is marked "nudes 00-24." Another is labeled "Photographera '03" The remaining
discs contain titles that include female names. All of the foregoing discs were seized by the Search
Team.

e. In that same closet, the Search Team discovered numerous black binders containing
what appear to be print outs of digital photographs (with file names underneath) and compact discs.
The binders appeared to contain, among other photographs, photographs of nude or partially nude
young girls, some of which are in sexually suggestive poses. Based on the training and experience
of law enforcement officers who observed them, some of the young girls appear to be teenagers,
some of whom appear to be under the age of 18.
The Virgin Islands Residence

20. Based on my review of property records, I believe that JEFFREY EPSTEIN has
been the owner of the Virgin Islands Residence since at least in or about 1998. In particular, it
2017.08.02
appears that an entity named "L.S.J., LLC" held title to the Virgin Islands Residence from in or
about 1998. In or about 2011, L.S.J., LLC transferred title to the Virgin Islands Residence to an
entity named "Nautilus, Inc.," for $10. On the transfer paperwork, EPSTEIN signed as the "sole
member" of L.S.J., LLC and as the "president and sole beneficial owner" of Nautilus, Inc.

21. In addition, I believe that up until his arrest, the Virgin Islands Residence was
JEFFREY EPSTEIN's principal residence. In particular, I have reviewed sex offender registration
data, and have learned that, on or about June 17, 2019, EPSTEIN listed the Virgin Islands
Residence as his primary residence. At the time of EPSTEIN's arrest on or about July 6, 2019, I
and other law enforcement officers conducted an inventory search of EPSTEIN's personal effects,
and observed that EPSTEIN was carrying a driver's license that listed the Virgin Islands Residence
as EPSTEIN's home address.

22. Based on my participation in this investigation, I have reason to believe that
EPSTEIN and his co-conspirators committed the Subject Offences in and around the Virgin Islands
Residence. Some of the evidence of that conduct was recovered from the New York Residence.
In particular, based on my conversations with law enforcement agents who have conducted an
initial review (the "Reviewing Agents") of the compact discs seized at the New York Residence
as described in paragraphs 15(b)-(e) above (the "Seized Discs"), I have learned that the discs
contain approximately thousands of nude or partially nude photographs of girls or young women,
many of which are in sexually suggestive poses. Based on my conversations with the Reviewing
Agents, who have particular training and experience relating to child erotica and visual depictions
of children in child exploitation cases, I have learned that the Reviewing Agents believe that many
of the nude or partially nude images they have reviewed appear to depict girls under the age of 18.
Certain of these images appear to have been taken at a tropical location, and/or were labeled "LSJ"
2017.08.02
either in the image file name, or on the compact disc that contained the image. Based on the
foregoing, I believe that a portion of the foregoing photographs appear to have been taken at the
Virgin Islands Residence. In addition, I have learned that some of the file names are marked
which are the initials of a As set forth below, I have interviewed an individual
who has reported that l= photographed her at the Virgin Islands Residence.
Accordingly, I believe that a portion of these photos may have been taken by I=E

23. Further, based on my conversations with law enforcement agents who have
conducted an initial review of the Seized Discs, I have learned the following:

a. Many of the photographs appear to be labeled with file names that include "LSJ,"
which I believe stands for Little St. James, which is the name of the Virgin Islands Residence.

b. As discussed above, photographs seized from the New York Residence appear to
depict nude or partially nude young girls, and a portion of those photos appear to have been taken
at the Virgin Islands Residence, based on the fact that (i) some of the photos appear to have been
taken in a tropical location, and (ii) some of the file names of the photographs and/or the labels
on the discs containing the files of nude or partially nude young girls in a tropical location are
marked "LSJ," i e., the Virgin Islands Residence.

c. Among the photogiaphs seized from the New York Residence, the Reviewing
Agents identified partially-nude photographs of a young girl, labeled with the name of a particular
individual ("Individual-1"). The photographs appear to depict Individual-1 on a beach in what
appears to be a tropical location similar to the landscape of the Virgin Islands Residence.

24. In or about August 2019, I participated in an interview of Individual-1, with her
counsel present. Based on my personal observations, I believe that the photographs described in
Paragraph 23(c) depict Individual-I. I have also spoken with another law enforcement agent who
2017.08.02
C
interviewed Individual-1 on a separate occasion in or about July 2019, with her counsel present.
During the course of these interviews, Individual-1 stated, in sum an substance that she met
EPSTEIN in 2003 when she was approximately 17, and that she travelled to several of EPSTEIN's
properties, including properties in New Mexico, Florida, and the U.S. Virgin Islands, i.e., the
Virgin Islands Residence, before she turned 18. EPSTEIN paid for the trips, and would give
Individual-I money and gifts while she traveled with him. During these trips, EPSTEIN sexually
abused and assaulted Individual-1 on approximately four different occasions, all of which occurred
before she turned 18. Individual-I reported that EPSTEIN raped her during two of these incidents.
Indivdual-1 recalled that one or more of these instances of sexual abuse occurred on the Virgin
Islands Residence. Individual-I further reported that, when she was approximately 17,
a asked to photograph her, and did in fact photograph Individual-1 at the Virgin Islands
Residence.

25. In or about August 2019, I and another law enforcement officer interviewed an
individual ("Individual-2") who regularly performed work for JEFFREY EPSTEIN as a contractor
at the Virgin Islands Residence from approximately 1999 to 2005 or 2006. Individual-2 reported
that, on several occasions, Individual-2 observed photographs of what appeared to be nude or
partially nude young girls in several locations throughout the main residence of the Virgin Islands
Residence. Individual-2 recalled a photograph depicting and two girls, all of
three whom were topless; Individual-2 estimated that the two girls in the photograph appeared to
be approximately 15 or 16 years old. Individual-2 knew to be EPSTEIN's assistant at
that time.

26. Based on my review of flight logs from a private jet owned by JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
I have learned that traveled to the U.S. Virgin Islands at least approximately
2017.08.02
once a month between October 2001 and November of 2005. These records do not include any
travel may have taken on commercial airlines.

27. For all of these reasons, I am aware that has spent significant
time at the Virgin Islands Residence and that evidence of her involvement, and potentially the
involvement of other co-conspirators, may be located at the Virgin Islands Residence. In
particular, flight logs from EPSTEIN's private jet reflect that the individual identified in the
Indictment as "Employee-3" traveled to the U.S. Virgin Islands on approximately nine separate
occasions. These records do not include any travel Employee-3 may have taken on commercial
airlines. As set forth in the Indictment, Employee-3 scheduled victims' encounters with EPSTEIN.
The Search of the Virgin Islands Residence

28. On or about August 11, 2019, United States Magistrate Judge Ruth Miller of the
District of the Virgin Islands signed a warrant authorizing the search of the Virgin Islands
Residence (the "Virgin Islands Warrant"). The Virgin Islands Warrant is attached as Exhibit E,
and incorporated by reference herein. The next day, other law enforcement agents and I executed
the Virgin Islands Warrant at the Virgin Islands Residence.

29. Based on my personal participation in the August 12, 2019 search of the Virgin
Islands Residence, as well as my conversations with other law enforcement agents who
participated in that same search, and my review of documents prepared by other law enforcement
agents who participated in that same search, I have learned that during the August 12, 2019 search
of the Virgin Islands Residence:

a. Subject Device-1 was recovered from a desk in the main residence on the island.
b. Subject Device-2 was recovered from a desk in the main residence on the island.

c. Subject Device-3 was recovered from a desk in the main residence on the island.
2017.08.02
d. Subject Device-4 was recovered from a desk in the main residence on the island.

e. Subject Device-5 was recovered from a desk in the main residence on the island.
f. Subject Device-6 was recovered from a desk in the pool house on the island.

g. Subject Device-7 was recovered from a desk in a cabana on the island.
h. Subject Device-8 was recovered from a box on the floor near a desk in a shed on
the island.

i. Subject Device-9 was recovered from a desk in a shed on the island.
j. Subject Device-10 was recovered from a desk in a cabana on the island.

k. Subject Device-11 was recovered from a desk in a cabana on the island.
1. Subject Device-12 was recovered from a desk in the beach house on the island.

m. Subject Device-13 was recovered from a desk in the beach house on the island.
n. Subject Device-14 was recovered from a server rack inside a shed on the island.

o. Subject Device-15 was recovered from a server rack inside a shed in on the island.
p. Subject Device-16 was recovered from a shed on the island.

q. Subject Device-17 was found on a server rack in a shed on the island.
r. Subject Device-18 was found oh a server rack in a shed on the island.

s. Subject Device-I9 was recovered from a desk in a cabana on the island.
t. Subject Device-20 was recovered from the maintenance office on the island.

u. Subject Device-21 was recovered from the maintenance office on the island.
v. Subject Device-22 was recovered from the maintenance office on the island.

w. Subject Device-23 was recovered the maintenance office on the island.
x. Subject Device-24 was recovered the maintenance office on the island.
Subject Device-25 was recovered the maintenance office on the island.
2017.08.02

z. Subject Device-26 was found on a server rack in a shed on the island.
aa. Subject Device-27 was recovered on a file cabinet next to a desk in a cabana on the
island.

B. Probable Cause Justifying Search of the Subject Devices
30. Based on my training, experience, and participation in this investigation, I believe
that there is probable cause that evidence of the Subject Offenses, such as photographs of
EPSTEIN's victims and co-conspirators, will be found on the Subject Devices. In particular,
information provided by Individual-I, with whom EPSTEIN engaged in sex acts at the Virgin
Islands Residence while Individual-1 was a minor, confirms that EPSTEIN engaged in conduct
relevant to the Subject Offenses at the Virgin Islands Residence. In addition, photographs on the
Seized Discs recovered during the search of the New York Residence depict other young and
partially nude girls photographed at the Virgin Islands Residence, which suggests that EPSTEIN
brought those girls to the Virgin Islands Residence and that, consistent with the accounts provided
by Individual-1, Victim-1 and other victims identified in the Indictment, EPSTEIN likely sexually
abused them at the Virgin Islands Residence and maintained evidence of that abuse there on the
Subject Devices. Moreover, evidence of co-conspirators' presence at the Virgin Islands Residence
at times when victims were abused, including photographs, may also be found on the Subject
Devices. Indeed, as noted above, Individual-2 has observed a photograph of  partially-
nude young girls at the Virgin Islands Residence, suggesting that similar photographs may have
been saved on the Subject Devices. Similarly, there is probable cause to believe that evidence of
victims' andior co-conspirators' travel arrangements, contact information, and communications
will be located on the Subject Devices. •

31. Moreover, though the sexual abuse described above occurred principally between
approximately 2002 and 2005, as evidence recovered from the New York Residence including the
2017.08.02
Seized Discs makes clear, EPSTEIN continued to maintain substantial evidence of the Subject
Offenses up until the time he was arrested in 2019. Indeed, as described above, in addition to the
Seized Discs, Epstein continued to maintain a "massage room" complete with a massage table and
various sex toys that remained similar in makeup and appearance to descriptions of the same room
provided by Victim-1 based on Victim-I's encounters with EPSTEIN in 2004. Accordingly, there
is probable cause to believe that the Subject Devices, which were seized from a residence where
EPSTEIN and his co-conspirators committed the Subject Offenses, will similarly contain evidence
of the Subject Offenses.

32. In addition, I believe that evidence of the Subject Offenses, including but not
limited to photographs/evidence created at the Virgin Islands Residence, may be located on the
Subject Devices because (i) the Virgin Islands Residence was the location of multiple photo shoots
of young girls; (ii) the Virgin Islands Residence appears to have been, for the last several years
and up until the time of his arrest, EPSTEIN's primary residence; and (iii) given its location, the
Virgin Islands Residence is JEFFREY EPSTEIN's most private residence. Therefore, given that
EPSTEIN has maintained evidence of the Subject Offenses in the New York Residence, he is likely
to have similarly maintained some of that evidence in the Subject Devices maintained at the Virgin
Islands Residence. Moreover, given that there is probable cause to believe that JEFFREY
EPSTEIN and others, including conspired to commit the Subject Offenses,
evidence of EPSTEIN's involvement in trafficking minors would also be relevant to the
investigation of, and any future charges against, other members of the conspiracy, such as

33. According to international flight records that I have reviewed, a private jet owned
and utilized by Epstein has traveled to or from the U.S. Virgin Islands at least on or about April
19 2017.08.02
14, 2019; May 5, 2019; May 18, 2019; and June 11, 2019. Accordingly, there is probable cause
to believe that EPSTEIN was present at the Virgin Islands Residence a short time before the
recovery of the Subject Devices.

34. Based on my training and experience in investigating individuals who engage in
sex trafficking of minors, and who sexually exploit minors, such individuals often maintain
photographs of their victims, and/or other erotic images of minors, at their residences. Individuals
who engage in such offenses often hoard such images in the privacy of their residences. In
particular, data related to their illegal activity is often stored on their computers.

35. In my training and experience, individuals who store nude and/or sexually
suggestive photographs of minors on compact discs or other external storage devices typically
access those images from computers and other electronic devices in order to view those images,
and individuals who store such materials on compact discs typically store similar files on other
computing devices and storage devices.

36. Like individuals engaged in any other kind of activity, individuals who engage in
sex trafficking of minors store records relating to their illegal activity and to persons involved with
them in that activity on electronic devices such as the Subject Device. Such records can include,
for example, logs of online communications with co-conspirators; email correspondence; contact
information of co-conspirators, including telephone numbers, email addresses, and identifiers for
instant messaging and social medial accounts; travel records for victims and/or co-conspirators;
payment records for victims and/or co-conspirators; and/or photographs of victims and/or co-
conspirators. Individuals engaged in criminal activity often store such records in order to, among
other things, (1) keep track of co-conspirator's contact information; (2) keep a record of illegal
transactions for future reference; (3) remain in contact with co-conspirators and victims; (4) enable
2017.08.02
╔═══════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Matthew Goldstein [journalist] New York Times reporter 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00040076 (Jmail)
 [article] New York Times article about Epstein's death
(date: 2019-07-08)
Jeffrey Epstein Dead in Suicide at Manhattan Jail. Officials Say. The New York Times
the New Bork Q.,times
Jeffrey Epstein Dead in Suicide at
Manhattan Jail, Officials Say

Mr. Epstein, the financier indicted on sex trafficking charges, was not
under suicide watch at the time of his death.
2 2 2 By William K. Rashbaum, Benjamin Weiser and Michael Gold
Aug. 10, 2019
Jeffrey Epstein, the financier who was long dogged by accusations of sexual abuse of girls
and who was able to cultivate a stream of high-profile friends despite his lurid lifestyle,
killed himself in his Manhattan jail cell, officials said on Saturday.

Mr. Epstein hanged himself, the officials said. He was found at roughly 6:30 a.m. Saturday at
the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan and was taken to a hospital, where he
was pronounced dead, the federal Bureau of Prisons said in a statement.
Last month, a week after being denied bail on federal sex trafficking charges, Mr. Epstein
was found unconscious in his cell at the jail with marks on his neck. Prison officials had been
investigating that incident as a possible suicide attempt.
Mr. Epstein had been on suicide watch after he was found injured on July 23 and received a
daily psychiatric evaluation, according to a person familiar with his detention. He was
removed from suicide watch on July 29 and returned to the special housing unit, a
segregated area of the prison with extra security, this person said.
The authorities did not immediately explain why he was taken off suicide watch. The F.B.I.
said it was investigating, and Attorney General William P. Barr said in a statement that a
special inquiry would be opened into what had happened.
"I was appalled to learn that Jeffrey Epstein was found dead early this morning from an
apparent suicide while in federal custody," Mr. Barr said. "Mr. Epstein's death raises serious
questions that must be answered. In addition to the FBI's investigation, I have consulted
with the Inspector General who is opening an investigation into the circumstances of Mr.
Epstein's death."
httpsiNnvw.nytimes.com/2019/08/10Myregion/jeffrey-epstein-suicide.html 1.16
8/10/2019 Jeffrey Epstein Dead in Suicide at Manhattan Jail, Officials Say - The New York Times
Manhattan federal prosecutors last month charged Mr. Epstein, 66, with sex trafficking of
girls as young as 14. The indictment renewed attention toward how Mr. Epstein — who had
opulent homes, a private jet and access to elite circles — had escaped severe punishment in
an earlier investigation into his abuse of girls more than a decade ago in Florida.
He had avoided federal criminal charges in 2008 after prosecutors brokered a widely
criticized deal that allowed him to plead guilty to state charges of solicitation of prostitution
from a minor and serve 13 months in jail. Even while in custody, Mr. Epstein was allowed to
leave the jail for 12 hours a day, six days a week, to work at his office in Florida.
The new federal indictment also focused scrutiny on an array of luminaries in government,
politics, business, academia, science and fashion with whom Mr. Epstein had associated
over the years, including Donald J. Trump, Bill Clinton, Prince Andrew of Britain and the
retail billionaire Leslie H. Wexner.

Mr. Epstein's defense team — the lawyers Reid Weingarten, Marty Weinberg and Michael
Miller — declined to comment on his cause of death. "We are enormously sorry to learn of
today's news. No one should die in jail," they said in a statement.

Mr. Epstein's death brought an abrupt end to a prosecution that his accusers had hoped
would finally shed light on how he had been allowed to commit what they said was a string
of depraved crimes for so many years — and what role his wealth, privilege and connections
played.
who said she had been raped by Mr. Epstein after being recruited into his
circle outside her Manhattan high school in 2001, said she was angry that he would not have
to face his accusers in court.
"We have to live with the scars of his actions for the rest of our lives, while he will never face
the consequences of the crimes he committed — the pain and trauma he caused so many
people," Ms. said. She said she hoped investigators would pursue charges against
people who had aided and protected Mr. Epstein.
A cache of previously sealed legal documents, released on Friday by a federal appeals court,
provided new, disturbing details about what was going on inside Mr. Epstein's homes and
how his associates recruited young women and girls, including from a Florida high school.
The documents — among the most expansive sets of materials publicly disclosed in the 13
years since Mr. Epstein was first charged with sex crimes — include depositions, police
incident reports, photographs, receipts, flight logs and even a memoir written by
who said she was a sex trafficking victim of Mr. Epstein and his acquaintances.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/10/nyregionfieffrey-epstein-suicide.html 2/6
6/10/2019 Jeffrey Epstein Dead in Suicide at Manhattan Jail, Officials Say - The New York Times

Mr. Epstein was arrested on July 6 at Teterboro Airport in New Jersey after his private
plane landed on a flight from Paris. Federal prosecutors charged him with sex trafficking
and sex trafficking conspiracy.
Prosecutors said in their indictment that he and his employees had engaged in a scheme to
bring girls as young as 14 to both his Upper East Side mansion and his palatial waterfront
home in Palm Beach, Fla., between 2002 and 2005.
He pleaded not guilty to the charges. If convicted, he would have faced up to 45 years in
prison.

Mr. Epstein had initially sought home detention at his Upper East Side mansion while he
awaited trial. His lawyers had proposed allowing Mr. Epstein to post a substantial bond and
stay in his luxurious seven -story townhouse, watched by 24-hour security guards, at his
expense.
But a federal judge denied the request, concluding that Mr. Epstein was a flight risk, citing
his "vast wealth," which prosecutors have placed at more than $500 million.

Mr. Epstein hanged himself and his body was found at roughly 6:30 Saturday morning at
the Metropolitan Correctional Center, officials said. Yana Paskova for The New York Times
https://vnvw.nytimes.com/2019/08/10Myregionfieffrey-epstein-suicide.html 3/6
6/10/2016 Jeffrey Epstein Dead in Suicide at Manhattan Jail, Officials Say - The New York Times

Mr. Epstein, a former money manager with Wall Street experience, depicted himself as a
wealthy financier with stellar investment savvy. In addition to his homes in Florida and New
York, he also owned a private island in the United States Virgin Islands, a massive ranch in
New Mexico and a residence in Paris. He had numerous high-end vehicles and access to
private planes and helicopters.

Mr. Epstein's younger brother, Mark, was his "only living immediate family member?"
according to a memo filed in federal court last month by Mr. Epstein's lawyers. The memo
described the pair as close.
Even after he served time in a Florida jail a decade ago and became a registered sex
offender, Mr. Epstein successfully maintained a reputation as a billionaire investor,
philanthropist and sophist.
Still, in the time since Mr. Epstein's arrest last month, evidence has suggested that the
former money manager's business acumen was more myth than fact. His client list was not
as extensive as believed, and the services he offered were less remarkable than once
portrayed.
Earlier this week, perhaps Mr. Epstein's most notable client, Mr. Wexner, the executive
behind Victoria's Secret and Bath & Body Works, accused Mr. Epstein of misappropriating
"vast sums of money" from him and his family.
Mr. Epstein's recent arrest prompted renewed scrutiny of his longstanding connections to
prominent executives on Wall Street, in the corporate world and even in the scientific
community.
Some Wall Street titans found themselves forced to answer questions as to why they had
continued to socialize or do business with Mr. Epstein after his 2008 conviction. They
included the private equity billionaire Leon Black, the longtime banking executive Jes
Staley and the hedge fund manager
The executives all said they had no idea he had engaged in sex trafficking, and had sought
to minimize their contacts with Mr. Epstein in recent years.
Also drawing attention were a number of big universities — including Harvard University
and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology — that had accepted large contributions
from foundations established by Mr. Epstein even after his 2008 conviction, which had
required him to register as a sex offender.
https://www.nytimes.comf2019/08/10Myregion/jeffrey-epstein-suicide.html 4/6
8/10/2019 Jeffrey Epstein Dead in Suicide at Manhattan Jail, Officials Say - The New York Times
The contributions to the universities and to scientists at those schools were part of a
campaign by Mr. Epstein to polish his image and get himself back into the good graces of the
academic and corporate elite, The Times found.
But even as Mr. Epstein was trying to rebrand himself, he continued to peddle in ideas that
should have given some reason to pause.
A number of scientists said he had showed an interest in biogenetic engineering and had
discussed a plan to seed the human race with his DNA by having young women
impregnated at his Zorro Ranch in New Mexico. There is no indication that Mr. Epstein ever
took steps toward carrying out those plans, but some in the scientific world continued to
meet with him and take his money.
Much of the wealth Mr. Epstein did amass can be attributed to his work for one man: Mr.
Wexner, the billionaire real estate magnate, whose L Brands company developed iconic
brands like Victoria's Secret and The Limited.

Mr. Wexner, 81, was Mr. Epstein's biggest client. In 1991, Mr. Wexner gave Mr. Epstein vast
and unfettered authority to manage his personal fortune for roughly 16 years. Managing Mr.
Wexner's fortune enabled Mr. Epstein to become hugely wealthy himself and gave him the
Wall Street bona fides he needed to seek business from other corporate executives.
Along the way, Mr. Epstein would acquire a mansion on Manhattan's Upper East Side that
had once belonged to Mr. Wexner. He would also obtain a Boeing 727 jet from Mr. Wexner's
company. The money he made working for Mr. Wexner enabled Mr. Epstein to buy his own
island in the United States Virgin Islands — where he relocated much of his financial
advisory business in 1999.

Mr. Wexner has said he had severed all ties to Mr. Epstein in late 2007. Just this week, he
said in a letter to his charitable foundation that he had learned in 2007 that Mr. Epstein had
misappropriated vast sums from him.
But Mr. Wexner apparently never notified authorities of the suspected misappropriation —
even though Mr. Epstein at the time was being investigated in Florida for engaging in sex
with underage girls.

Mr. Wexner has said he was horrified to learn of the new charges against his longtime
financial adviser. But the real estate magnate has not fully explained why he gave Mr.
Epstein such wide-ranging discretion to manage his financial affairs.
Katie Benner, Emily Steel and Matthew Goldstein contributed reporting.
https://vnvw.nytimes.com/2019/08/10/nyregionfieffrey-epstein-suicide.html 5/6
8/10/2019 Jeffrey Epstein Dead in Suicide at Manhattan Jail, Officials Say - The New York Times
Related
Opinion I The Editorial Board
Jeffrey Epstein Is Dead. His Victims Still Deserve Justice. July 8, 2019
'Massage' Was Code for 'Sex': New Epstein Abuse Revelations Aug. 9, 2019
1;
•
William K. Rashbaum is a senior writer on the Metro desk, where he covers political and municipal corruption,
courts, terrorism and broader law enforcement topics. He was a part of the team awarded the 2009 Pulitzer
Prize for breaking news. @WRashbaum Facebook
Benjamin Weiser is a reporter covering the Manhattan federal courts. He has long covered criminal justice,
both as a beat and investigative reporter. Before joining The Times in 1997, he worked at The Washington
Post. @BenWeiserNYT
A version of this article appears in print on Aug. 11. 2019 of the New York edition with the headline: EPSTEIN IS FOUND 
DEAD IN HIS CELL IN
NEW YORK JAIL
READ 990 COMMENTS
hupsiNnvw.nytimes.com/2019/0W10/nyregionneffrey-epstein-suicide.html 6/6
╔════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 NTOC [government] National Threat Operations Center, FBI center 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01249232 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from <REDACTED> about an Epstein party with little girls and boys
(inferred timestamp: 2019-07-08 19:08:00)
50D -NY -3027571 Serial 56
Crisis :Make (Rev. 5.2317) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Crisis Intake
Case ID S: 31E-NY-3027571
Drafted By:
Date: 07/08/2019

(U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Date/Time Received: 07/08/2019 03:08 PM EDT
Details:
On 07/08/2019, at 03:08 PM Eastern Time, , date of birth
called the FBI
National Threat Operations Center (NTOC) with information regarding
Jeffrey Epstein.
provided the following information:
In the summer of 1999, was  where
she met (correct spelling not obtained). invited
to a party in saying they would make about $2000.
went to the party with which was in a private, secluded area, and
when they arrived there were old men and little girls. said,
"Bitch, what the fuck it this! It's like kiddie porn stuff."
wanted to leave and right as she was about to, Epstein touched her
shoulder and was telling , "You did a good job!" Epstein asked
what was wrong and she said this wasn't her kind of party.
Epstein asked if she wanted more money but she refused. said she
remembers seeing Alan Dershowitz and several other people who are now
involved in politics.
said there were little girls, one who didn't even have breasts,
probably aged only 10-11 years old, as well as little boys who they would
dress like little girls. said they were bringing them on a yacht
and after about an hour, another batch was dropped off.
discovered was a recruiter for Epstein and they would go to middle
schools to recruit these children by offering them $100 to do outrageous
3501.253-001
Page I of 2
50D -NY -3027571 Serial 56
Re: 31E-NY-3027571, 07/08/2019
things. The next day at work, asked why she was doing this
and she said she had been doing this for Epstein since she was about 14
years old.
A few months later when saw
that party we were at? One of those little girls said she was raped."
said to her, "You know
• •
2
3501.253-001
Page 2 of 2
EFTA01244926 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from ANONYMOUS about Rupert Murdoch's granddaughter
(inferred timestamp: 2019-07-09 20:28:00)
50D -NY -3027571 Serial 88
Outs Intake (Rev. 5-2347) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Crisis Intake
Date: 07/09/2019
Case ID II: 31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 07/09/2019 04:28 PM EDT
Details:
On 07/09/2019, at 4:27 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female
(Anonymous) calling from caller ID called the FBI National
Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to report information on the Jeffrey
Epstein investigation.
Anonymous provided the following information:
In 2000, Anonymous went to a family friend's mansion near
for Thanksgiving or Passover. While at dinner, Anonymous was introduced
to Jeffrey Epstein, and Rupert Murdoch's Granddaughter Name Unknown
(UNSUB) . UNSUB was in her 30's to 40's with a small build, brown hair and
brown eyes. UNSUB had formally dated Epstein and they remained friends.
Anonymous was seated by UNSUB and they "hit it off." UNSUB disclosed
during their conversation that she (UNSUB) would get young girls for
Epstein. Anonymous indicated that she found it odd and remembered telling
UNSUB she could never setup an ex. Anonymous also remembered the men
(Epstein and other unidentified men) talking about young girls.
In 2008 when the news about Epstein came out, a family member told
Anonymous that Epstein and Kevin Spacey were bad men, and that is why
their family friend (the owner of the mansion) no longer interacted with
Epstein or Spacey.
• •
3501.000-024
Page I of I
EFTA01265978 (Jmail)
 [money] Charles Schwab account opened 3 months before death
(date: 2019-07-10)
CA111517 - Transaction Summary
Date Range of Reviewed Transactions:

• Date range of transactions is less than the standard 12 month review as accounts were recently established.

• Date range of transactions reviews will capture from account inception until 07/08/2019 as follows:
o Account 11481413 - Opened on 04/19/2019 to 07/10/2019
o Account 14332170 - Opened on 05/13/2019 to 07/10/2019
c, Account 41224708 - Opened on 04/11/2019 to 07/10/2019
Scope of Accounts Reviewed:
All Accounts Reviewed
o Accounts identified under the clients included within the Client Profile subpages.
[See Subpages for Account Details]
CQNFIDNTIpd_ CA 1151 - Transaction ummary Page
ACCT: 11481413 - FSOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
AccountType/Registration/Roles:  Account Openedon 04/19/2019
AilouM DSOs (c.04 11411.013
- AMINO /St La glA
••••14•••rt HMS
Na
rrrr
Sari, Ow
••••••••••
um LAM, Cron
Elpkbpsylon "Haase lied
SILOC,.•4 • 0%
a-- Ma
a
- SaMMINilinile
• •Par ,_
tic SOJnOiri PMCV.u.0 00 0710712 1101020.
• Pak Mi. ILOWCitael
CMINnan TOJ'aillin AS CO*. 44477.4. ;Halal
Pill(TIP•Pms 10011IOUSI
- PO•stalgailits
us ism D Ccasneil If %fifty
(-0
- saes. Gan CO
D %Conn
lirar.17.71T
ASI
Transaction Details:
Credits:
Transaction Type It Trans Amount
IN-STATE CHECK DEPOSITS FROM:
06/17/19 DARREN K INDYKE 8 42.700.00
MICHELLE F SAIPHER
06/10/19 COATUE ENTERPRISES LLC 14.300.00
05/0509 COATUE ENTERPRISES LLC 70.200.00
05/09/19 COATUE ENTERPRISES LLC 16300.00
04/22/19 SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC 250.000.00
WIRED FUNDS RECEIVED FROM:
(SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC)
ADJUSTING ENTRY (1,000 shares GS - canceled)
CASH DIVIDEND
QUAUFIED DIVIDEND
SCHWAB 1 INTEREST
5
3
332,500.00
285,278.60
1 198,384.95
1 121,052.22
1 850.00
3 242.54
Incoming TOA from TD AMERITRADE
DATE SHARES SYM
04/25/19 3,000 GOOG
04/25/19 263.157 APO
04/25/19 25.000 CVNA
04/25/19 1,000 AMZN
04/25/19 25.000 KPD
DESCRIPTION STATUS
ALPHABET INC SOLD
APOLLO GLOBAL MGMT LP SOLD
CARVANA CO SOLD
AMAZON.COM INC SOLD
KARYOPHARM THERAPTIC SOLD
Debits:
Transaction Type
JOURNALED SHARES & FUNDS TO:
41224708 (SOUTHERN FINANCIAL)
DATE AMT
06/24/19 S540.589.91
07/02/19 5953.45
14332170 [SOUTHERN COUNTRY INTL.)
DATE SHARES SYM
06/27/19
06/27/19
06/27/19
06/27/19
06/27/19
06/27/19
3.000
263.757
1.000
25,000
1.000
25,000
GOOD
APO
GS
CVNA
AMZN
KPTI
BUY OF INVESTMENTS:
2,000 shares of GS
1,000 adjusted (4198,384.95)
1,000 shares of GS purchased
IP Trans Amount
2 -541,543.36
2 -396,764.95
Transaction Spreadsheet Attached /Screenshot (Limited or No Transactions): 04/19/19 - 07/10/19
CA111517 -
cQN.IFon umI preN2 TIAL ransacti muy age
fla
CA111517 -
Transacti...
Investments:
No investments as of 07/1W2019
Li.ilti113 AM /il l )1'1
See the following wire(s) and/or check image(s) subpage(s) if applicable to accounttransactions as noted above.
c97_NuE,In u„ ENTIAL SDNY_GM_00006047

╭──────────────────────────────────────────────── Page 3, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ cauisi7-                                                                                                         │
│ Transact                                                                                                         │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ Investments:                                                                                                     │
│ No investments as of 07/10/2019                                                                                  │
│ Positions Account 1148-1413                                                                                      │
│ Positions Dispiyby Sino) ¥ OudeeSatue Onder Ey Postion States 0}                                                 │
│ Tyee | Quantity | Smoot ne Quote |More Yate                                                                      │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ See the following wire(s) and/or check image(s) subpage(s) if applicable to account transactions as noted above. │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ CGQNEIDENTIAL =="                                                                                                │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00120106                                                                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Incoming Wires
Incoming Wires:
ACCOUNT ID ACTIVITY DT IRAN AM WIRE TAG CD
11481413 05/01/2019 156,947.36 :20:
11481413 05/01/2019 156,947.36 :32A:
11481413 05/01/2019 156,947.36 :50K:
11481413 05/01/2019 156,947.36 :52A:
11481413 05/01/2019 156,947.36 :53D:
11481413 05/01/2019 156,947.36 :59:
11481413 05/01/2019 156,947.36 :70:
11481413 05/01/2019 156,947.36 :72:
11481413 05/03/2019 51,000.00 :20:
11481413 05/03/2019 51,000.00 :32A:
11481413 05/03/2019 51,000.00 :50K:
11481413 05/03/2019 51,000.00 :52A:
11481413 05/03/2019 51,000.00 :53D:
11481413 05/03/2019 51,000.00 :59:
11481413 05/03/2019 51,000.00 :70:
11481413 05/03/2019 51,000.00 :72:
11481413 05/16/2019 77,331.24 :20:
11481413 05/16/2019 77,331.24 :32A:
11481413 05/16/2019 77,331.24 :50K:
11481413 05/16/2019 77,331.24 :52D:
11481413 05/16/2019 77,331.24 :53D:
11481413 05/16/2019 77,331.24 :59:
11481413 05/16/2019 77,331.24 :70:
11481413 05/16/2019 77,331.24 :72:
WIRE TX
FO19121O646701
190501USD156947,36
/0042952771 42952771 -
SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC C/O HBRK ASSOCIATES, INC
575 LEXINGTON AVENUE,4TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 10022
BKTRUS33PWM
/C/4O553953 CHARLES SCHWAB + CO INC Aft CASH ACCOUNTNG
120 8 101 MONTGOMERY ST SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104
/40553953 CHARLES SCHWAB AND CO INC . .
FOR FURTHER CREDIT TO
ACCOUNT NAMES OUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
ACCOUNT NO 114 8 1413
IMAD 20190501B1Q8383C012734
/INS/BKTRUS33XXX
FO19123O791701
19O503USD5100O,
/0042952771 42952771 -
SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC C/O HBRK ASSOCIATES, INC
575 LEXINGTON AVENUE,4TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 10022
BKTRUS33PWM
/C/4O553953 CHARLES SCHWAB + CO INC An CASH ACCOUNTNG
120 8 101 MONTGOMERY ST SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104
/40553953 CHARLES SCHWAB AND CO INC . .
FOR FURTHER CREDIT TO
ACCOUNT NAMES OUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
ACCOUNT NO 114 8 1413 IMAD 2O19O503B1Q8383C0O9O35
/INS/BKTRUS33XXX
FO19136O294B01
19O516USD77331,24
/867730320
SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC ATTN: JEFFRE
6100 RED HOOK QTRS STE B-3 ST THOMAS VI 008021348
/000004123214579
TD AMERITRADE CLEARING INC
OUTGOING WIRE ACCOUNT
200 S. 108TH AVE., 11TH FLOOR OMAHA NE US 68154
/C/4O553953 CHARLES SCHWAB + CO INC An CASH ACCOUNTNG
120 8 101 MONTGOMERY ST SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104
/40553953 CHARLES SCHWAB CO., INC.
FFC SOUTHERN FINANICAL LLC 1148-141 3
IMAD 201905161167031R007209 /RFB/18598437
/INS/WFBIUS6SXXX
ccgibl. Fail? Pt mmar
NBAL SDNY_GM_00006O48
Incoming Check Deposits
Incoming Check Deposits:
Incoming
Check Ima...
Date Remitter Remitter: Drawee Bank Check Number & Memo: Deposit Amt
06/17/19 CHECK DEPOSIT DARREN K INDYKE & TO Bank *427 42,700.00
MICHELLE F SAIPHER Account Memo:
Promissory Note Dated 6-13-18
and 6-17-16 - Interest Pmts
06/1W19 CHECK DEPOSIT COATUE ENTERPRISES LLC JPMorgan k *109 14,300.00
Account
05/09/19 CHECK DEPOSIT COATUE ENTERPRISES LLC JPMorga k *108 10,200.00
Account
05/09/19 CHECK DEPOSIT COATUE ENTERPRISES LLC JPMorgan k *107 15,300.00
Account
04/22/19 CHECK DEPOSIT SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC Deutsche Bank Trust *300 250,000.00
Account *42952771
Q,P5NEIE?sP NaT5IAL SDNY_GM_00006049
Incoming Transfer of Account (TOA)
Incoming AccountTransfer
Incoming TOA from TD AMERITRADE
Date Quantity
04/25/19
04/25/19
04/25/19
04/25/19
04/25/19
3,000
263,157
25,000
1,000
25,000
Symbol
GOOG
APO
CVNA
AMZN
KPTI
TOM M NOM Si, AIM MA :AI /.'.xv
t> :AO  07/04/11 Mena a  - MOM= ACIACIPT DETAIL
Al '; MO DTA: AA MA Mt ACM CTL
LOT S 11411411 Au Or OM: S101 MA AMA
MO: $00114011 rnescua AC LAC IOC: SIG MAD COO.:
CMG ACM. AM:
r 4441-11•4112 an MCA CAA: 20111114404141
MA II RN, ILC 09 1416
Ma Mt CO TOOL TAMS:
TAM AM OA CTL ID: «414524' CATO CORM:
13:MITIO DMA VaL0.11
ZOCIt Olte IOOCY. Yft COO MIA TO AN12114104 OSAMM. IK
Mar COMM 0121/Alai TM 1013
ant: CVO MCT MA CO TAX 202:
AMA
411141; CAM 0•411i 04/12/11 Ono, OTO MLA N/22/14
OAT,: 52 AMT: 04/11/11 01:10 TICJ PDX /APR:
USZLI
MIA •
04/24/111 TO An OM 04412 - 1R Ni, OM TIM PA RATA
041/21/14 CVO TIT TIMONITTM AMR
04/22/11 AO 145141 MITA= TOM:Cil 04011.CONINOTICO TA00100710
A-TOCA Ala M-MOS : A 1:012110A 41 X1 414-1TR
rs-topo micas m-tou. =at ne-ns T24-TO
Description
ALPHABET INC.
APOLLO GLOBAL MGMT LP
CARVANA CO
AMAZON.COM INC
KARYOPHARM THERAPTIC
- we, Worn Is:/ IVA 1, 1 P 'OM
or FIT
ly « M/01/10 IA/OM a meows - lam kettan MAIL
NSA ITO OUT: MA TAT: PA JCAT CTL I: 201411)0004141
ACCT 11441411 Init At 4141 3 "a PMA VALID:
an, 000TOM MAC= LLC lY OM: MCI MAO oar.: 04/25/14
010 A011" WO:
CMG ACM ATM: TAX101..: 440-14-1142 TAXIM:
IS; Al NA LLC CATINICO:
MAT ACCT TIM: CO
alp AO:
11:12
TOMS TAMA: 14.014.115.11
PIO al ID: 241542044 CATO COMA:
OATIO 1.122 KILIAN
Old l. 0111 MOO: Mn ON MINT: a 13011441 Call/0, MC.
COMM: COMACT: TAX 101:
MTh: CTRII ACCT TIM CO TAX 1021
NAM:
MATO! CCM MOH 04/21/14 ODIC: OTCA 04/21/14
aA: SI ACAS: 04/21/14 17:10 MI AM ACIRA MAY.
Mat:
44214/14 era TRIOITTII COMMA - 1 11411411
04/14/14 OMA TIT TIMOCITTM TO MCC
N/241/14 OTO TRIMATII ISITIMMID AMMO OTCACIATIMATIM 15.054417441
A -1W M -M43. : BOO Mill -ACAS: rtl-rat 114-0T•
11-1C010 11:-TOM T11•1011. AMA mks'. 1/24-44
CQNFIDNTIN__ CA 1151 - Transaction . ummary Page
ACCT: 14332170 - [SOUTHERN COUNTRY INTERNATIONAL1
Account Type/Registration/Roles: Account Opened on 05/13/2019
ACCOUnt °egad%
Apse. whim 01 ,
A.. ea I.m. Tel> 0•14. a l
Coo WWI. Ol.rete Pe 46012 128 645081
t a. bar. MO 0 PI D UM
WI CM Sue Net MTN LIX•10).3 m
Ca% liessInialti.•801AISI 13;
4.10)ROD <tr. Q-k-5 SR 8 3
*STICKILY: OM:
- 10••••1011erlit(0,
,_ TAD Canienilled IA 6.0.1.; La
- Msel Clumn(O
',SNP
Lant , CPSIIPt
Transaction Details:
0
fl aw*
last
• Credits:
Transaction Type
SELL OF INVESTMENTS:
Date Quantity Description 41224708 (SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY)
Date Amount 15.000 (UM 06/18/19
06/25/19 56,149,343.64 05/18/19 1030.000 'CITIGROUP INC. VAR 99
DUE 12/31/99' 06/25/19 92,000,000.00
05/19/19 2.000.000 JBS INVESTMENTS 7.25% 06/24/19 97,356,568.00
24F OUE 04/03/24
05/21/19 79.000 'CITIGROUP IN 6.875%
05/21/19 2.000.000 *ASSURANT, INC. OUE
03/27/48'
06/21/19 5.760.000 JPMORGAN CHASE 8 VAR
07/10/19 25.000 CVNA
07/10/19 3.000 GOOG
07/10/19 2.000 GS
07/10/19 25.000 KARYOPHARM THERAPTIC
07/10/19 10.000 EKON MOBILE
Debits:
# Trans Amount Transaction Type # Trans Amount
37 +23,731,527.61 JOURNAL FUNDS TO:
CHECK DEPOSIT FROM:
SOUTHERN COUNTRY INTERNATIONAL LTD
JOURNAL OF SHARES RECEIVED FROM:
41224708 (SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY)
Date Quantity Symbol
06/27/19 10.000 XOM
06/27/19 10.000 ILMN
06/27/19 1,000 GS
11487413 (SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LW)
Date Quantity Symbol
06127/79 3.000 GOOG
06/27/79 263.157 APO
+250,000.00
LiONuiEul OP\ITIAL
3 -17,505,911.64
06/27/19 7,000 GS
06/27/79 25.000 CVNA
06/27/79 7,000 AWN
06/27/79 25.000 KIM
CD INTEREST PAYMENT
INTEREST PAYMENTS
Incoming TOA:
1
2
Dnaiption
+35,681.25
+620.39
Status DATE /Sham
05/20/19 79.000 CITIGROUP IN 6.875%9CD IC4K) SOLD
05/20/19 1.903.000 LLOYDS BANKING G 7.5%99F DUE 12/31/99 HEW IN ACCT
05/20/19 2.003.000 JBS INVESTMENTS 7.25%249 DUE 04/03/24 SOLD
05/20/19 3.003.000 CITIGROUP INC. VAR 99 DUE 12/31/99 SOLD
05/20/19 2.003.000 ASSURANT. INC. VAR 48 DUE 03/27/48 SOLD
05/20/19 5.760.000 JPMORGAN CHASE 8. VAR SOLO
05/20/19 15.000 UNITED TECHNOLOGIES(UTX) SOLD
05/20/19 80.000 GMAC CAPITAL T 8.125%PfD DUE 02/15/40 HEW IN ACCT
SUBJ TO XTRO REDEMPTION IALLY4A)
Transaction Spreadsheet Attached /Screenshot (Limited or No Transactions):  05/13/19 - 07/10/19
a
CA111517 -
Transacti...
Investments:
Positions
hales 08•91909 90 , 90I
T 9e Quantity $44/44
AcCOont /413-2170
titan erases erwnaaar
Mote Ulm
1.0:0 M4DI 4462(.O,411 1C 241741 2,017,410.00
2.1.117 NO SALO GLCOAL 1.04T IP 11.16 9.436.910.02
0164 0/0911A 03 6745 0
CLASS A
I 0 CO.I C004 OM OMP 7751 0
I MOM ALLTPRA CPAC GAPTrAL T9.125140193 MU 2.101,0:0.00
0 6$
0110211$14,
SUL TO rntoriSOCTIO.
GOLDMAN SACHS GIMP 21.97 0
1 10.0:0 ELM WAN(MC 312.70 3,727,030.00
0 On KARTOPS,01 THERAPTK 7.79 0
1.903.000 LLOYDS WONG G 7.3%991. 105.79 2,012,172.30
OIt 1)/1IA9
1O1:38 AM 1/11/2019
See the followingwire(s) and/or check image(s) subpage(s) if applicable to account transactions as noted above.
LONE' QgNTIAL SDNY_GM_00006052
Incoming Transfer of Account (TOA)
Incoming AccountTransfer:
Incoming TOA:
Date Quantity Description
05/20/19 79,000 CITIGROUP IN 6.875% PFD (C+K)
05/20/19 1,903,000 LLOYDS BANKING G 7.5%99F DUE 12/31/99
05/20/19 2,00&000 JIBS INVESTMENTS 7.25%24F DUE 04/03/24
05/20/19 3,00&000 CITIGROUP INC. VAR 99 DUE 12/31/99
05/20/19 2,000,000 ASSURANT, INC. VAR 48 DUE 03/27/48
05/20/19 5,76&000 JPMORGAN CHASE & VAR
05/20/19 15,000 UNITED TECHNOLOGIES (UTX)
05/20/19 8&000 GMAC CAPITAL T 8.125%PFD DUE 02/15/40
SUBJ TO XTRO REDEMPTION (ALLY4A)
• Appears the incoming TOA was from TD Ameritrade account, however, unable to locate documents.
Client Overview
IdentlIkatbe Infoneatke
Voice AutheritkatIOn
Nave
ItIOURIDKA/IN
Da act al Sues
"re fro Miami ka >a •.c.i Cal
Date of Bleb
12/06/1972 (46 veers old)
Mother's Heiden Name
Cust RH BenefltS Bal Stu Trades/yr 0
Ms ID &Aetna Aeconab
Refiesh
watit s  Nan  tett
Walk-In Meeting
Rich came in to open the new colpetate account. Otliarrida Took the application in.
neteritrai As I undreamt there is one equity and multiple bend positions.
nes are coming from W.
o
latest sale  He would also like to give authoreation to Paul Barret who is the trader and
ida genrator for Mr. Fppaein. He would like to get street srnsrt edge
ACthitylltie software. Would like to get 5 years of free trades as sera for this account.
Pei weeds about...
Repro
Add renew,
9:51:30 AM 1012019
CQNFIDNTIpd_ CA 1151 - Transacuon ummary Page
Incoming Check Deposits
Incoming Check Deposits:
SOUTHERN COUNTRY INTERNATIONAL, LTD.
MS/WA IMMTORCO 1022
ST MOI/At. VI
6100 IMO HOOK WATERS. SUITE 64 99•2019 •
. . ' '
I PAY TO TIE i onceux
Charles sdasb & Co Inc. $ - 250,000.00
j Two H undroi FiftyThousand and 0011
Charles Sch,iab S CD; Inc.'• •
r00 10 2 2e it
•Seierronwiwunnismal
CO.LARS {6
-1
Date Remitter Remitter: Drawee Bank Check Number Deposit Amt
05/13/19 CHECK DEPOSIT SOUTHERN COUNTRY INTERNATIONAL LTD FirstBank Puerto Rico #1022
Account
QPNEILIFIlaTJAL
250.000.00
ACCT: 41224708 - [SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY/
Account Type/Registration/Roles: Account Opened on 04/11/2019
An%Snit Ueda,
f Cd.
Aocra4 14114•••(4)
tf•
attOitt 4121-47,311
=WAS ,..C7 CO.* ,  'C
'IMAM PIXIK pure. , Bl
ri1s:at 4
T. 9 Cu. D
rr
In  apt. ItICMOD
ritOIAROCArn
ARC, 0.7391
POA•••40tbnilllibiele
Vow
•o.  0-  03
rem
FA,PI
/9.C ,  M . .. .1
f091016.1
T.13 D.eerdeu ErclAqtA.
•••• D
Transaction Details:
Credits: Debits:
Transaction Type # Trans Amount
JOURNALED FUNDS/SHARES FROM:
# 11481413 (SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC]
Date Amount
5 18,047,455.00
Transaction Type N Trans Amount
FX WIRED FUNDS DISBURSED TO:
MARC LEON in MOROCCO (returned)
MARC LEON (2nd attempted )
1 -12,708,324.00
06/24/19 $540,589.91
07/02/19 $953.45
#14332170 (SOUTHERN COUNTRY INT.]
JOURNAL OF SHARES TO:
14332170 (SOUTHERN COUNTRY INT]
Date Quantity Symbol
06/27/19 10,000 XOM
Date Amount
06/27/19 10,000 ILMN
06/25/19 $8,149,343.64
06/27/19 1,030 GS
06/25/19 $2,000,000.00
06/24/19 $7.356568.00 BUY 1 -198,460.00
05/21/19 (1,000 shares of GS)
FX RETURNED WIRE - MARC LEON 2 12,070,506.60 REINVEST DIVIDENDS 3 -4,841.18
WIRED FUNDS RECEIVED FROM: 1 2,000,000.00 WIRE FEE 1 -25.00
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC
SELL 1 1,059,144.44
06/21/19 1,000,000 BANK OF AMERICA
FUNDS RECEIVED FROM: 1 250,000.00
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC
QUALIFIED DIVIDEND 2 9,550.00
CASH DIVIDEND 3 4,841.18
SCHWAB INTEREST PAYMENT 3 1,792.30
incoming  TOA:
Date Quantity Symbol Description STATUS
04/30/19 10,000 XOM EXXON MOBIL CORP SOLD
04/30/19 10,000 ILMN ILLUMINA INC ACCT-2170
04/30/19 1,000,000 BANK OF AMERICA C VAR SOLD
N.F I DENTIAL cAIP5,7_.ransaction Summary age I
99 DUE 12/31/99
Transaction Spreadsheet Attached /Screenshot (Limited or No Transactions): 04/11/19 - 07/10/19
a
CA111517 -
Transactio...
Investments:
No investments as of 07/10/2019
Positions
Positions Displayby
Type QtJanbly Symbol
Symbol
Account 4122-4708
WKS= grststrall Positions are:epos
Name Quote I Market Value
7:08:39 AM 7/11/2019
See the following wire(s) and/or check image(s) subpage(s) if applicable to accounttransactions as noted above.
cNEIDENTIAL Al;;?5,7_ iransaction Summary age I_
EFFA_00120115
Incoming Wires
Incoming Wires:
ACCOUNT ID ACTIVITY DT IRAN AM WIRE TAG CD WIRE TX
41224708 04/17/2019 2,000,000.00 :20:
41224708 04/17/2019 2,000,000.00 :32k
F01910707AB501
190417USD2000000,
41224708 04/17/2019 2,000,000.00 :50K: /0044129244 44129244 -
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, C/O HBRK ASSOCIATES, INC
575 LEXINGTON AVENUE,4TH FLOOR NEW YORK, NY 10022
41224708 04/17/2019 2,000,000.00 :52A: BKTRUS33PWM
41224708 04/17/2019 2,000,000.00 :53D: /C/40553953 CHARLES SCHWAB + CO INC ATT CASH ACCOUNTING
120 8 101 MONTGOMERY ST SAN FRANCISCO CA 94104
41224708 04/17/2019 2,000,000.00 :59: /40553953 CHARLES SCHWAB AND CO INC
399 PARK AVE NEW YORK NY 10022
41224708 04/17/2019 2,000,000.00 :70: FOR FURTHER CREDIT TO
ACCOUNT NAMES SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC
ACCOUNTNUMBER 41224708
IMAD 20190417B1Q8383C 015657
41224708 04/17/2019 2,000,000.00 :72: /INS/BKTRUS33XXX
CQNFIDENTIAL CA 1517 - ransaction Summary Page 13
Outgoing Wires
Outgoing Wires:
Wire requested to be returned:
11110••••••• • 41m-11•90 1•01•91 WILMS
Case Delo& One Ti. St
Coe ID red Rt. PO "td 'Wt. ',el
Coo Woo Rachod•Cookeed Pak WI KS0000•2123.04 in Sal
••••e 'no Nor at& owe WPC LEON
Tater DetAls
News Dot
ONtowes DO fl  PACO 1ST RCM 6? 01E Zoi
clWatOli NOWT:Ot
06Soso
Vibe 016 %a %' Tao SA Cony PCAOCCO
Poor Connor foe IEUQ DTA* %WC KC
Owego,
No4 Mow
1 UM
IT YO 10
OAPROCI
No
knot°, AM IL191100.03 Owe No
Ilideorellowles USD AniPatl $12.701.31•00 Nast SAM ALLA Mw0 COACD..21.4%
IQ 14
tertrott
kryl AWCP WI
IQ
PO
Wows WpfeaSTRASSE 36 t 0 OM .010 AA
AJAX, *
LOA lentepow
Goatee Oc
OS • WON by LIFPIQ
0Q26/2019
Care, santramo
CceoNO K.
Ototed LOW
NOM Wee 0
eas
OW VOA fl VW I) 11•Ws
1799:93
OSCONC019 Q 19
00/31/2019 1PAL19
05,76/M9 OOP 19
OVW500
100
10Q
W.Q
POST IttASCP4 AJTICOMJ, AACK • WAIT IWO ACC
WO PESACH ZAIWCALLCC 109 • OAR IOC
100 P/MCO ant= OM . MAY WM PM
AQ • PfASO. AINCO1213) EVA EXEOFE cro
Palim wool Wats
7:21:53 AM 7/11/2019
Secondary wire request, but was requested to be canceled.
Wow Pawn Ow-1mo (Cow I
Case DNA&
oVaroto.
Caw '•9••• RenWOCowied
Trader toetalls
:Now:We
Wow
Net Fee
leI F. WroPaQ.
LW whew
Otase o.
(weld O.,
Cooed El•
SAW WSW
1211.dde
0f/D/519
114.990):03 00
129
vas • wiled LALQ
07OVA:99
AKA
I oPP1 loci Po
Bank RAI to
Ate • We Ma-o/so
One Leak
Dow
OlcoN!
NW*
SWAT Az
MAWS
AMY, MM MM A00 C001'0 . LAX
sperm 1/•494:0STRASSC X • 0 5a SOD SA
WL104
Carty SI47T IISSYO
Sae
not Part. Ta
Iam TM a WOOL Z7 (COI 6 Y WO leo ow:
CAPOWLOZO• ewo
CoNwor HMCO
Nola
Ca I 'Pa LQ)
0)I14/51G to Ps al WQ anositarcoed • see larg car 'MNY IN"
0000010 14•26W
070111319 11.1947
0/105/2019
07AQQ019 11•74.47
1. 1w D Noes
Arkainal Mites
WQ SYSTRUCCTICA•CLLED
'Z W • OA:04 COoliC •NriVACCr WI COT
YIN MASCO COWED LOA •VINIELOANININ
wry masa Amour visr.curr W  Q
7:11219 AM 7/11/2019
CONFIDENTIAL CAI 11517 -"transaction Sunuittry Page 14
SONY_GM_00006058
Incoming Transfer of Account (TOA)
Incoming Account Transfer:
Incoming TOA from MERRYL LYNCH Account #603118
Date Quantity Symbol Description
04/30/19
04/30/19
04/30/19
10,000 XOM
10,000 ILMN
1,000,000
EXXON MOBIL CORP
ILLUMINA INC
BANK OF AMERICA C VAR 99 DUE 12/31/99

• • JIM NOM Mt MUMS MA 0101LAI:
« 01/04/10 1111aarn Or ACCOOM - TLLYMIC AMOR OMIT
xat: ITO& 1:M. TST: On Aar CT:. MOM
nal: 41224700 lat: UT Trn: S101. 1TOJD VALID:
900100 MITI COMIC IOC 5104 010,0 COO.:
001G Aar nTL:
ACAT COLO:
Al REG: C P OrrinCO: OnCO:
77 ACC, TM: CO
JOS: 101:
0471 1110.30:
TOTAL TWOS:
OM CM ID: 1249)42W <TM COOTIO:
00111111 Oita 101101011
CM JAM: NIMIRILL
COMO. OTITACT: TAX 102:
CTPA ACCT 1TPC: CO TAX 102:
1: Oat OVEN: 04/22/19 ORIG: 01011 OILY:
ACAT: NU MO: MO APPAL:
ACCEL:
X:1111:
19 TOn r0 CASK TA-1311141 rOR POCCIMING

• 19 ton MOW OW1101:0 111004: KILO to: GILM
-1 19 CM CLIOIT 00104.11/10 Ta VIA ASIA. ta. CLAM WV IMAM=
r3-000 11-11:01: : N10 Ka-ACIa: 11)-1111. n4-T: rn TI:•1.110 111-1011 n• -r0 r:4•FT•
49AM 7/9.7019
:. Met 10.C12 A.A:LAba
kit; U:
n _ « 01/04/10 TrAxarn Or ACCOUNT: - LLLYMIC ACCOUNT OMIT
Mr1 OP.: SOL Tar: tin WAX CT 10M-ACAT
maX: 41224701 n: O nn: S10: 1TOJD VALID:
Joanna lint MOM IF OM: *104 010,0 COO.: 01/02/19
001G Aar IRE:
ACAT 404.77-9941 TAX102:
Iltir : CORP Cirn9CD: aCMCD:
ACC1 Trn: CO TOTAL Taani:
?A-1/35141 M CIL ID: 574/01144 <MD CONTRA:
... • • • • • • 0011TIM um toting
11:30
0.00
!MX Mal MA NNW: Milt Or ANTIC. MINI LL LOICH
COMM moon: TAX 1DI:
CTPA ACCT Tin: CO TAX 102:
COO 0110: 04/23/19 TOR OILY
44 AM: 11111 PM. APPAL:
lT GM nnJiLLIONT fin • COPT
:0 10r1 1111.1011101:111 nn • CM
:9 AN rOtriLUeln TriPt • COPT

• •• THICO 11-1100 : ADO wa-ocn: rn-M. m-ns nI.101E AM: 1111•0111 n4•101.
C S? bi ll- FAQ
NTIAL SDNY_GM_00006059
Incoming Check Deposits
Jo.
•
Incoming Check Deposits:
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY. INC.
EGO RED HOOK QUARTERS B) ST THOMAS. C0001
.•
I PM' C: 414 TO0F trIC Charles SC/Hap & Co, iInc i $ "260.99090o
Two
niton vi coke •01.7216/2r4
418)2019-
1997
Hundred Fit Thousand and
lEitzraccaAa samx7.
Daum I 4mai CnarkoSerevab S Co . Icc
•
4'1:M99V C221142B51C 721 1m098521;•
k
Ia
Date Remitter Remitter: Drawee Bank Check Number Deposit Amt
04/12/19 CHECK DEPOSIT SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC FirstBenk
Account e
QAQ5KEIETNITIJAL
#1997 250.000.00
EFTA01249586 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip about abduction by Jay-Z, Harvey Weinstein, and Jeffrey Epstein
(inferred timestamp: 2019-07-10 12:20:00)
',OD-NY -3027571 Serial qr
CrisIMSIm(tev.5-2347) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Crisis Intake
Date: 07/10/2019
Case ID #: 31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 07/10/2019 08:20 AM EDT
Details:
On 07/10/2019, at 8:20 a.m. Eastern Time,
called the FBI
Operations Center (NTOC) to identify herself as
Jeffrey Epstein and others.
provided the following
In approximately 1994,
information:
as a past victim of sex abuse
abuse occurred during parties
as a friend o
In approximately 1996,
unknown man abducted •
presence of Harvey Weinstein and
inserted his fingers into
Epstein's mansion in Florida.
National threat
a victim of sex abuse by
by Epstein.
resided with
from her
revealed herself to
described the
further identified
in An
home whence she later awoke in the
Shawn Carter (Jay-2) while Weinstein had
believed she was in
estimated she was abducted on seven occasions, awaking each time
in an opulent indoor setting. suffered from sex abuse on
multiple of those occasions, in which Epstein participated.
recalled Leon Black and William Barr, current United State Attorney
General, being present during some of the occasions of abuse. In
approximately 2006, last recalled being abused by Epstein. ON
3501.351-001
Page I of 2
SOD-NY-3027571 Serial 96
Re: 31E-NY-3027571, 07/10/2019
each occasion, believed she was drugged, clouding her memory.
attributed the drugging as frequently performed by persons
assigned as handlers, whom she described as persons who established
friendships with the victims. Among her handlers, identified the
artist Pusha T.
In approximately 2007, attended a party
following invitation from an unknown man who approached her as she walked
down a street. Weinstein and Pusha T also attended the party and drugged
her before engaging in sexual abuse.
claimed to have additional information of other persons involved
in the enterprise and information related to racketeering conducted in
support of the trafficking. further believed she was under
surveillance and stalked at the direction of the people involved in the
sex abuse.
confirmed she was not diagnosed with any mental illness.
refused to provide her physical address, advising that she
maintained no permanent address; rather she moved between staying at
different hotels.
• •
3501.351-001
Page 2 of 2
╔════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Andrew Gallivan [bank] manager at Deutsche Bank 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00168946 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank KYC information about Southern Financial
(date: 2019-07-11)
KYC Print Page I of 20
DB P1A/N1 GLOBAL KYC/NCA: PART A
rA
KYC Case # : 01977694
ne sheet must be established per relationship - list all accounts Included In the relationship
Status : 6. Approved

1. Relationship Details
Relationship Name: SOUTHERN FINANCIAL REIATIONSNIP:00000483290 Booking Cater: New York
Relationship Manager: Stewart Wiled
O New PWM Relatenship la edging PWPI Relationship
Relationship to %W14:
If existing, please Indicate since when the relationship esists, provide reason for new work and attach old prolle. m • 
m 2018 Periodic
Review - KR Overdue KYC -•,
Last Approved KYC 8 Plan D LLC - 1790820; NES LLC - 1790739;
The 2007 Jerre/ E Epstein Insurance Trust & The Haze Trust - 1804531.
IDs foe. Damn froyea a Richard Kahn can be found in 'Repository' of GCIS r 486405.
O Client Referral O RP1 Prospect • Intemediwy/FIM O Other Son (CB, a.)
How Was the Client(s)
Introduced? How long has the Rm Kev3KaKK m own the * Kw Please provide details (e.g. name of referral sate, how many 
yews RI4 wsonally has known dent, etc.):
Jeffrey Epstein reached
out to Stew Cildield on 3/7/17 to have a new acct opened under this relationship..
Ooes Deutsche Bank pay a
retrocession or similar
O Yes I l° No
compensation to a third pay
for the introduction of the
relationsNp?
arras, desolbei
List all existing and new accounts Involved in this relationship
Legs Entity
Acecungs)
Account Name / Weber Opening Date (ntendediacual)
I O Its LLC - 42953758 - DDA-42953758 11/8/2013
2 21 Plan D LLC - 42953467 - DDA-42953467 10/18/2013
3 g The Haze Trust - 77000949 - DOA-7701:0949 2/21/2017
4 RI The Haze Trust - N4G024943 - DESI-N413024943 9/23/2013
5 0 The Haze trust - 42967297 - DDA-42967287 7/27/2 17
'Ate 6 he primary contact
poison or the Stal? (Note: This
prison needs to have signatory
I opts and/or Inforwatkin right
roe the accounts.):

K. inchteDarren Preferred method of contact
(Indicate phone no., fax no.,
e-mail adtress, etc.):
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0000326
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servletintegration?lid=0 I N30000000D9Di&e... U§192824 289
EFIA_00019199
KYC Print Page 2 of 20
One sheet must be established for each account to be
2. Account Ownership Summary
Account Name: Nes LLC - 92953758 - ODA Acct. !timber (i I evadable): 92953758
Accown Manager: Stewart Criteld
What is the purpose of the account (e.g. portfolio management, Weary account, custody smites, long-term Investment, 
payMentiesPense account)? TM Is a sine*
checking account to take care of the expenses associated with running Jeffrey Epstein's NY home
Indicate from where the assets are expected to arrive?
rr ..4 DB Group: Sane Backing Center (Indicate account nuttier): Eesting
O DB Grow: Mt Booking Center (Indicate DB location and account details):
O Other Institution — (Indicate name & location):
O Physical Deposits (specify cash, securities, cheques....):
What is the copected axe and frequency of regular Mims aid outflows (or the accowit (Indicate estimated number and 
volume per month)?: ••• 10-20/month; $30 -
S20K
What is the expected yr:tome of assets and currency for the ao:ount approx. 90 days anis
°Penne?
252,347.66 I ardency I USD
What is the copected volume of assets and currency for the account apprce. one year after
opening?
254347.65 I ardency I USD
Ooesfwill the dent have Assets Under Management (AuM) within DB under Eur. 3M? O Yes lil No
Please list all parties related to the account.
For each party:

• Check if a source of wealth description is required for the party.
• Cried( the appropriate box to desaite the relationship of the party to this account (> I can be selected).

• U none of the check boxes apply, dew be the party's relation to the account In the "Other mann.
• Always desalbe the relationship between the parties in the last column.

• Please drill down to the ultimaWundedying Beneficial Owner(s).
agar
Enfityof
Desolation
Smote
of Wealth
tan- ed
Parties
dated to
Ns account
AccountPIC
ridder CnvnerTruSt
Senior of
/
Founder of
Foundation
Lttimate
Benelkial
Owner
Signatay‘imitedFirandal
or Full
POA
?OA ntemeciaryStarehorder
FIM)
Significant
>=2514)
;Ion-PIC
entity
inchcate
ownership
%
Legal
Representative
Grantor/Seale:founding
Donor
Cther (please
describe other
roles and/or
ndicate
relationship
between
I g 51 NES, LLC 1 5
O
O D O DO O O O
2 O O Darren K. Inoyte O O O O O O O O O
O Auth Sena;
3 O O Haw Beier O OO O I21 O O O O O Atrch Sena;
4 O 0 Epstein
Jeffrey E. O O O O O O O ix O O O
Beneficiary;Sole
Member:Primary
Decision
alaker;Sole
Owner;
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0000327
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=0IN30000000D9Di&e... UM92814290
EFIA_000 19200
KYC Print Page 3 of 20

2. Account Ownership Summary
Account Plane: Plan D LLC - 42953467 - DDA Acct. Number Of available: 42953467
Account Manager: Stewart Oldieki
What Is the purpose of the account (e.g. portfolio management, adhscry account, custody services, long-tam investment, 
payment/expense account)? 11% Is a simple
checking axowit for pay for costs associated for Jeffrey Epstein's airplanes
Indicate Iran where the assets we expected to anive?
0 DB Group: Sane Backing Center (Indicate account nLenber): 06sting

• DB Group: Cther Booking Center (Indicate DB location and account details):
O Other Institution — (Indicate name & location):
O Physical Deposits (specify cash, securities, cheques....):
What Is the expected size and frequency of regular Inflows and outflows for the ao:owit (indicate estimated number and 
vane per month)?: ..., 1-$/month, $100 -
$500K
What Is the copected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. 90 days after
opening?
1 790,453.14 1Cwyercy 1 USD
What Is the expected volume of asses and currency for the account appiox. one year after
opening?
1 790,453.14 'Gummy 1 USD
Does/will the ctent have Assets Under Management (AuM) %thin DB under Eur. 3M? O YcsEa No
Please list all parties related to the account.
For each party:

• Died( if a source of wealth descr1tion is required for the party.
• Check the appropriate box to describe the relationship d the party to this account (> 1 can be selected).

• U none of the check boxes apply, desc, be the party's rdation to the account In the 'Mee coin.
• Always desc,lbe the notatenship between the parties In the last column.

• Please drill down o the ulUrnaWunderlying Benefidal Owner(s).
egs
EnUtyof
bee:notion
Saute
of Wealth
requeed
Partes
related to
this account
AccountPIC

KV. de OrrnerTrust
Senior of
/
rounder of
roundaUcri
litimate
Beneficial
Owner
Bgnatcry‘Imitectirandal
or Full
POA
POA nterniectaryShareholder
,FIM)
tgnificant
>=25%)
Yon-PIC
entity
inckate
)wnership
%)
Legal
Ftepresentatna
toantor/SetUcerFouncling
Donor
Geier (please
desc,lbe other
roles and/or
ndicate
relationship
between pates)
I M EI Mai D, LLC O O O O O O O O O O
2 O a EPstein
Beneficiaty;Scte
O O O a a • El O O O Mernber;PrImary
Dedsion Maker;
3 O O Dwen  ICIndyre O O O O a O O O O O Aunt Signor;
4 O O 1*M Beier O OO O a O O O O O Auth Signor;
5 O O
Lawrence
Pall Visoeld
Jr
O O O O O O O 12 O O Manager:
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0000328
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=0IN30000000D9Di&e...
UM92814291
EFIA_000 19201
KYC Print Page 4 of 20
2. Account Ownership Summary
Account Nam: The Haze Trust - 77000949 - ODA Acct. Number (Java/able). 77000949
Accown Manager: Stewart OWNS
What is the purpose of the account (e.g. portfolio management, adhsory account, custody services, longterm investment, 
paymaniexpense account)? INS San
interest bearing cheddng account for costs (taxes, etc.) related to the Trust
Indicate from where the assets are expected to wive?
El DB Group: Same Backing Center (Indicate account number): EXeting

• DB Group: Other Booking Center (indicate DB location and account details):
O Other Institution — (Indicate name & location):

• Phyrical Deposits (specify cash, securities, cheques, ...):
What is the ("peeled size aid frequency of regular Inflows aid outflows for the acicowit (indicate estimated number and 
volzme per month)?: ..- I-3/month; Sink
-
MIMI
What is the opected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. 90 days after
°Penne?
17,707,707.25 larrency
I USD
What is the expected volume of asses and currency for the account approx. one year after
opening?
17,707,707.25 'aplenty I USD
Ooes/will the ctent have Assets Under Management (Ault) within DB under Eur. 3M? annO tao
Please li st all parties related to the account.
For eadi party:

• Oiedc if a source of wealth (description is required for the party.
• C,eck the appropriate box to describe the telationshi of the party to this account (> I can be selected).

• U none &the check boxes apply, describe the party's Mallon to the account In the "Other column.
• Always describe the relationship between the parties n the last column.
• Please drill down to the ulUrnaWundetlying Benet Idal Onner(s).
cgs
Enntyof
besalption
Scarce
of Wealth
reseed
Parties
related
to this
account
AccounIPIC
Holder Owns
Sella of Illitknate
Trust /
Founder of
Foundation
Beneficial/or
Omer
5Ignatoty;rniteC
Full
POA
POA
Financial
IntornediaryShareholder
(Fill)
tignificaM
(>=25%)
tion-PIC
entity
(Indicate
ownership
%)
Legal
Reptesentatiw
Giantor/Setto ,Founding
Donor
Other (please
desert* other roles
and/a lnlcate
relationship between
Nunes)
I 2• The
haze Trust
5 O D O O O El O O O
2 O •
Damn
K.
I richece
O O O O 5 • 2 O O O Trustee:Trustee;Auth
Slone, as Trustee:
O5
Jeffrey
E.
Epstein
O O 15 B O DO O O 2
Senior:Beneficiary;
Trustee:Trustee;Auth
Sigma as Trustee &
Primary Decision
'taker:
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000329
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=0 I N30000000D9Di&e... U§192824292
EFIA_000 19202
KYC Print Page 5 of 20
2. Account Ownership Summary
Account Plane: The Haze that - N4G024943 - OBSI Patt. Number (if areatleA N4G024943
Account Manager: Stewart Ordeal
What Is the purpose of the account (e.g. portfolio management, advisory account, custody services, longterm Investment, 
paymentiopense account)? TNs Is a
brokerage account for the Dust to hod and make investments in marketable securdes Is the purpose of the axmot.
Indicate from where the assets are expected to anlye?
0 DB Grow: Same Booking Center (ndcate account number): EX6Ung
O DB Grow: Other Booking Center (Indicate DB location and account details):
O Other Institution — (Indicate name & location):
O Physical Deposits (specify cash, securities, cheques, ...):
What is the expected site aid frequency of regular Inflows aid outflows for the xcoLMt (indicate estimated number and 
vaunt per month)?: -- 3-10/month; $10-
$2MM
What is the demoted volume of assets and currency for the account approx. 90 days after 120,355,143.12
°Perlin?
I Currency
I
USD
What is the expected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. one year after
opening?
120,355,143.12 I Currency I USD
Does/will the denthave Assets Under Management (NM) within DB under Eur. 3M? ❑O yes 0  No
Please Ust all parties related to the account.
For each party:

• Check if a source of wealth description is required for the party.
• Chock the appropriate box to describe the dationship of the party to this account (> 1 can be selected).

• U none of the check boxes apply, describe the partyY relation to the account In the "Other column.
• Always describe the nalatenship between the parties I the last column.

• Please drill down to the ulUrnaWunderlying Beneficial Owner(s).
_egal
EnUtyflowte
besalption
of Wealth
required
Parties
related to
tNs
account
Accountant
Holder OwnerTrust/
Senior of
Founder of
Foundation
ideate
Benerbaer
Owner
Signatory
Full
POA
_imtedinancial
POA Interneda
',FIN)
Sgnificant
eateholdeneprosentabve
(>-25%)
Non.PIC
allay
(Indicate
ownership
%)
_egal `3rantor/Settlart-ounding
Donor
Other (pease
describe other roles
and/or inch:ate
relationsNp between
Duties)
I 2 s The
Haze
Trust
0 O O O O LI O O O O
2 O O jeffielE. Epstein O O 2 O o o o . O o
Settlor;Bencliciary;
Trustee:Trustee;Aurn
Signor as TIUStee &
Primary Decision
Maker:
3 O O Darren

K. Indywe O O O O O O O O O O Trustee:Trustee;Aurn
Senor as Trustee;
4 O • PaulBarrett O O O O O O • O • •
Pail has Limited
Trading
/wthotization for
Brokerage account;
O O B"  am O O O O 0 O O O O O POA In Bickelage
Account;
6 ID Li
Jean
Anne
Brenran
Webrach
"❑r—r l O O O O O O O • O
POA In Brokerage
Account;
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000330
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... U§192824 293
EFIA_000 19203
KYC Print Page 6 of 20
2. Account Ownership Summary
Account Nam: The Naze trust - 92967287 - WA Acct Number (t ravailed/0: 42967287
Accost Manager: Stewart Oldfield
What Is the purpose of the account (e.g. portfolio management, advisory account, custody services, long-term investment,
payment/expense account)? The a a
simple
checking account for costs (taxes, etc) related to this Trust
Indicate from where the assets are expected to arrive?
El DB Group: Sane Backing Center (Indicate account number): Fasting

• DB Group: Other Booking Caller (Indicate DB location and account details):
O Other Instihtlon — (Indicate name & location):

• Physical Deposits (specify cash, securities, cheques....):
What is the wetted size aid frequency of regular Inflows and outflows for the accowit (Whale estimated number and vcaime
per month)?: There are regular
transactions in The Maze brokerage acccunt, whet) is where most of the activity is. The deposit cocure Just herds cash 
to earn the interest. Wouldn't apect many
transactions there.
What is the expected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. 90 days after
Opening?
12,5D3,667.84 I Currency I USD
What is the expected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. one year after
'wring?
12,5D3,667.84 I Currency
I USD
Ooesfwill the dent have Assets Under Management (AuM) %OUP DB under Eur. 3M? O Yes @ No
Please list all parties related to the account
For each party:

• Cried( if a source of wealth description is reciLited for the party.
• a led( the appropelate box to describe the relationshi of the party to this account (> I can be selected).

• f none of the check boxes apply, describe the party's relation to the account In the "Other column.
• Always describe the relationship between the parties n the last column.
• Please drill down to the ul mate/underlyi .9 eeneria Owner(s).
Legal
Entity)f
Desoiption
Source
of Wealth
requited
Parties
related
to this
account
AocounUNC
Holder Ovine
Settler of (Ultimate
Trust)
Founder ore...vier
ccundation
ISigratonn..inuteC
Benelidalor Full
POA
POA
Financial
IntermediarySharehokter
(FIN)
Significant
(>=25%)
Non-PIC
entty
(Indicate
ownership
%)
Legal
Representative
Cy/error/Sett° ,Founding
Domr
Other (please
descrbe other roles
,idler indicate
iNationship between
)arties)
I O 0
The
Haze
Trust
a O O O O O O O O O
2 O •
Jeffrey
E.
Epstein
O O El El D • O D O O
Setidor:Benefleary;
Trustee:Trustee;Auth
Wry as Trustee &
Primary Decision
Maker:
3 O •
Damen
K.
I
O O O El 5 O O O O O Trustee:Trustee;Auth
S et as Trustee'
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0000331
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e...
UM92814294
KYC Print Page 7 of 20
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY In Section 2 Account Ovmershl Summary
3/3/4. Individual Details (tor all pates)
Individual's Name: Jeffrey E. Epstein - 00000483289 Dated Birth: 1/20/1953
Country of Residence: Virgin Islands, U.S Country of OUzenship: United States
Adctess of plenary residence: Little Saint lames Salt Thomas 00802 Virgin Islands, U.S.
Has dent resided outside of
his/Mr countryof nationality fa
5 yeas or more?
O yes ®No
Profession/Occupation: Self Ernpolyed I Tax ID! SSN:
Current Employer: Southern Trust Company Inc Position/Title/Rank: President
Address of employer: 6100 Red Hook Quarter B3 St. Thomas Virgin Islands, US. 00802
Does the person wok as senior executive of a CO-recognized regulated entity in the Mandel
Industry? or an entity listed on a DB-reel:gilded exchange? (Not applicable for operating entities 0  Yes 0 No
Is the mew/dual a politically Exposed Person (PEP)?(/ Yes, despite) Comectlon with Prince Andrew
and Bill Clinton
2 Yes D No
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual related to an employee of the DB group?(YFatra), Or
FrivaArtez descnbe) N/A
O Family O Friendship g Now
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual party to a non-banking relatlonsNp with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or services)?(a
Yesdesothe) NA
Oyes 2 No
If applicable, notate which bank officers have met the person: Indicate where and when the died meeting(s) took place:
Bank Officer Name(s) Bank Office: Client Private
Client e:
Client Place of
&Hitless: other incadon (specify): Date:
Stewart geoid 0 0 0 6/29/2017
0 O O
O O D
0 Wealth Details fa this individual are not filled in, because they we the same as for the following person:
36. wealth Details (Only for parties requiring sows of wealth description as indicated in Section 2)
Nature of the Individual's Busness: Private investments
thimay Country of sows of wealth/soiree of Funs? Unted States
thimay industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funs? High Rid Financial Institutions
Summarize Source of Wealth: 5 Business Owner • Salary/Earnngs ril Investment O Inheritance/Oils O0ther:
Further Desote Source of Wealth /Detail the history of wealth for each
farnly acurmulate weath?For business owners, how long in busness,
business Jeffrey Edward Epstein January
of the sources: (e.g. For Create, how cid senior accumulate wealth? For Obedience, how did
how many employees, level of prentability? Indicate type of business, countries of major activities,
20, 1953) is an American (bander and registered sex offender in the united States. He waked at
& Co. He Wes in the US Virgin islands. Epstein taught calculus and physics at the Dalton Schad
Alan C. Greenberg, chairman of Bear Stearns.
he waked in the special products dedrion, advising high-net-worth dents co tax strategies.
partner at tear Stearns.
& Co, managing the assets d dents with more than $1 Son in net worth. In 1987, Leslie
woolen's clothing stores, became a well-known client. Wooer a:quiree Abercrombie & Fitch the
East Sole into an enormous residence. Epstein later bought that property, in the wealthiest part of
Trust Company and, for tax advantages, based it on the island of St. Thomas in the U.S.
advertising exec love Donny Deutsch, investor Nelson Pet, media mogul and publeher Malmo
Weinstein. They were ultimately outbid by Duce Wasserstein, a longtime Wall Street investor.
Radar a celebrity and pop culture magazine founded by Maer Roshan. Epstein and Zuckerman
a wall ownership stake.
consoling company that invests the assets of thew clients and gels their revenue from the return
to their dents and makes their revenue based on the returns and the fees associated with
important partners.) (ban
Bear Stearns early in his career and then formed his own firm, 1. Epstein
in Manhattan from 1973 to 1975. Among Ns students was awn 0
In 1976, Epstein started week as an options nada at Bear Stearns where
Provng successful in his financial career, n 1980 Epstein became a
In 1982, Epsten founded his own firancal management firm, 1. Epstein
Werner, founder and chairman of Ohio-based The Limited than of
folowing year. In 1992 he converted a private school on the Upper
Manhattan. In 1996, Epstein changed the name of InS firm to the Financial
Virgin Islands.
In 2003, Epstein bid to acquire New York magazine. Other bidders were
Zuckerman, who had the New York Daily News, and film producer Haney
who paid $55 minion.
In 2004, Epstein and Zuckerman committed up to $25 million to finance
were equal patties in the venture. Restart, as its editor-In-chief, retained
Presently, W. Epstein founded Southern Trust Company Inc, a private
of these Invetmens. Seuthern Trust Invests In afferent port/dos catered
managing their dent's assets
Estimated Annual Indine(S): 110,000,000.00 I Estimated amount of invstable asseu,($): I $501M1 - 100 MM
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(a) DB-SONY-0000332
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=0 I N30000000D9Di&e... / I/192814 295
EFIA_000 19205
KYC Print Page 8 of 20
Estimated Net Wort1($): $500 MM + I Arrant of assets pained to invest with INVI4($): 2,300,000.00
Other Known Mandel Instautbns:
InsUtutico: Country: Est Assets Under MA:
InsUtutico: Canby: Est Assets Under Mgt
InsUtutico: Cotritry: Est Assets Under Mgt
Please Indicate the family situation of the Individual (marital status, other fanely members, etc.): N/A
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000333
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlethervlet.Integration?lid=0IN30000000D9Di&e...
4492824296
EFIA_000 19206
KYC Print Page 9 of 20
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY In Section 2 Account Ownershl Summary
3k Individual Details (lor all pates)
Individual's Name: Darren K. Indyke - Dated Birth:
Country of Residence: Untal States Country of Otizenship: United States
of plenary
Has trent resided outside of
his/her country of nationality faO
5 yeas or more?
yes ®NoAdtress
Profession/Occupation: Accountant Tax ID i SSN:
Current Employer: Southern Financial I1C Position/Tele/Rank: Accountwit
Address of employer: 6100 Red Hook Quarter B3 LiVingston Virgin Islands, U.S. 00E:02
Does the person work as senior executhe of a CB-recognized regulated entity in the financial
Industry? or an entity listed on a DB-recognael exchange? (Not applicable for operating entities 0 Yes 0 No
Is the incfMclual a Politically Exposed Pence (PEP)?0,  Yes, tote) N/A O yes Ica No
To the best of your knowledge, a the inchAdual related to an employee of the DB group/ti tan/P.71, 0r
Fnc.413.47, desmbe) N/A
O Family O Friendship g None
To the best of your knowledge, a the inchAdual party to a min-barking relationship with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, diem referral source, supplier of goods or sentes)?Or
ves,deso-ibe) N/A
Oyes 2 No
if applicable, indicate which balk officers have met the person: Indicate where and when the client meeting(s) took 
place:
Bank Officer Name(s) Bank Offke: Client Private
Derriere:
Client Place of
Business: Other Locatbn (specify): Date:
Stewart adfield 0 0 0 12/12/2016
0 O O
O O CI
0 Wealth Details fa this individual are not filled in, because they are the same as for the following person:
3B. wealth Details (Only for parties requiring plate of math description as imitated in Seek.) 2)
Nature of the IndNiduars &mines:
Prepay Country of palate of wealth/source of Funds?
thimay industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds?
Summarize Source of Wealth: O Business Owner O Salary/Earnings O Investment O Inheritance/Gas O Other:
Further Desete Source of Wealth /Detail the history of wealth fa each of the sources: (e.g. For trusts, how Ad senior 
accumulate wealth? For inheritance, how
did
Vanity accumulate wealh?For business owners, how long in business, how many employees, level of profitability? Indicate 
type of business, countries of major
activities,
important Cosines panties.)
Estimated Annual Incane(S): Estimated amount &investable assets(s):
Estimated Net WortI(S): Amount of assets planned to invest with PWM($)
Other Known Randal Instiutbns:
Insttturion: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
Insttturion: Country: Est Assets Under Mgt
Insbtution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
Please indicate the family situation of the InciNidual (renal stabs, other tan/ members, etc.):
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(a) DB-SONY-0000334
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=0IN30000000D9Di&e... /I/192814 297
EFIA_000 19207
KYC Print Page 10 of 20
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY in Section 2 Account Ownershi Summary
3k Individual Details (for all pates)
Individual's Pin: Harry Beier - Date of Earth:
Country of Residence: United Stabs Country of Otter hip: United States
Adtress of plenary residence:
Has tient resided outside of
his/her countryof nationallyfe
5 yeas a more?
O yes ®No
Profession/Occupation: Accountant Tax ID ISSN:
Current Employer: HBRK Assodates, Inc Postbag itle/Rat Accountant
Address of employer: 575 teengton Avenue, 4th Hoot Matey NY United States 10022
Does the person wet as senior executive 04 a DO-recognized regulated entity in the financial
Industry? or an entity listed on a DB-recognsel exchange? (Not applicable for operating entities 0 Yes Iii No
Is the ince/dual a Politically Exposed Pencil (PEP)7(lYes, tote) N/A Oyes Ica No
To the best of your knowledge, is the inclyidual related to an employee of the DB group?(rf Fat* Or
Flic...bhp, ctsmbe) N/A
O Family O Friendship g None
To the best of your knoMedge, is the inclyidual party to a non-barking relationship with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or serykes)?(t
YeS,62SOthe) NA
0 Yes 12 No
If applicable, indicate which balk officers have met tie person: Indicate where and when the client meeling(s) took 
place:
Bark 0mcer Name(s) Bank Cake' '
Client Private
Donde:
Diet Place of
Business: Oilier Locatbn (specify): Date:
0 O 0
0 O O
0 Wealth Details fa this individual are not filled in, because they are the same as for the following person:
3B. wealth Details (Only for parties requiring soiree of wealth description as imitated in Seiko 2)
Nature of the Inclividuars Business:
Pitney Country of solace of wealth/source of Funds?
',limey industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds?
Summarize Source of Wealth: OBusiness Owner O Salary/Earnings O Investment O Inheritance/Gas O Other:
Further Describe Source &Wealth /Detail the history of wealth for each of the sources: (e.g. For trusts, how id setUor 
accumulate wealth? For inheritance, how
did
famly accumulate weallh?For business owners, how long in business, how many employees, level of prontability? Indicate 
type of business, woollies of major
beanies,
important Wines partners.)
Estimated Annual Income(S): Estimated amount of investatle assets(s):
Estimated Net WortI(S): Amount of assets planned to invest with PW14($)
Other Known Financial Institutions:
InstRurico: Counby: Est. Assets Under Mgt
InstRurico: Country: Est Assets Under Mgt
InsUtutico: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
Please indicate the family situation of the Indeldual (natal status, other Yana members, etc.):
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(a) DB-SONY-0000335
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=0 I N30000000D9Di&e... UM92814298
EFIA_000 19208
KYC Print Page 11 of 20
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY in Section 2 Account Ownershl Summary
3k Individual Details (for all pates)
Individual's Nave, Paul Barrett Date of Earth:
Country of Residence: United Sates Country of Otizenship: United States
Adiess of plenary residence:
Has dent resided outside of
his/her country of nationality fa
5 yeas or more?
O yes ®No
Profession/Occupation: Investment Adis& Tax ID! 5511:
Current Employer: JP. Morgan Seaulties LLC Positioncritle/Rank: Investment Advisor
Address of employer: 277 Pak Ave New York NY United States 10172
Does the person work as senior executive of a 06-recognized regulated entity in the financial
Industry? or an entity listed on a DB-recognsel exchange? (Not applicable for operating entities 0 Yes Iii No
Is the incanclual a Politically Exposed Person (PEP)7(// Yes, despite) N/A ❑O yes g No
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual related to an employee of the DB group?(if Fat* Or
Frivabh0, desmbe) N/A
O Family O Friendship g None
To the best of your knoMedge, is the individual party to a non-barking relationshe with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or sentes)?(l
vesdeso-ibe) N/A
Oyes I2 No
If applicable, indicate which bank officers have met the person: Indicate where and when the client meeting(s) took 
place:
Bark Officer Name(s) Bank 0ffke:
Client Private
wide:
Client Place of
Cosiness: tbn Other Loca (specify): Date:
0 O 0
0 O O
0 Wealth Details for this individual are not filled in, because they are the same as for the following person:
3B. wealth Details (Only for parties requiring soiree of wealth description as imitated in Section 2)
Nature of the IndMduars &skies:
Primary Country of solace of wealth/source of Funds?
thimay industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds?
Summarize Source of Wealth: O Business Owner O Salary/Earnings O Investment O Inheritance/Gas O Other:
Further Desolbe Source of Wealth /Detail the history of wealth for each of the sources: (e.g. For trusts, how id setUor 
accumulate wealth? For nhentance, how
did
Vanity accumulate weallh?For business owners, how long in business, how many &helmets, level of profitability? Indicate 
type of business, countries of major
activities,
inmate/It bushes partners.)
Estimated MEM& Incane(S): Estimated amount &investable assets(s):
Estimated Net WortI(S): Amount of assets planned to invest with PW14($)
Other Known Financial Instiutbns:
Insteurion: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
Insteurion: Country: Est Assets Under Mgt
InsUtution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
Please indicate the family situation of the individual (maital stabs, other family members, etc.):
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(a) DB-SONY-0000336
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... /I/192824 299
EFIA_000 19209
KYC Print Page 12 of 20
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY in Section 2 Account Ownershl Summary
3k Individual Details (lor all pates)
Individual's Name: Jean Anne Brennan Wiebracht - Date of Earth:
Country of Residence: Virgin Islands, U.S. Country of Otizenship: Virgin Islands, U.S.
Adcaess of plenary residence:
Has dent resided outside of
his/her country of nationality fa O yes ®N o
5 yeas or more?
Profession/Occupation: Novice Tax ID i SSD:
Current Employer: Southern Financial I1C Position/Title/Rank: Finance
Address of employer: 6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3 St, Thomas Virgin Islands, U.S. 00802
Does the person wait as senior executhe of a CO-recognized regulated entity in the financial
Industry? or an entity listed on a DB-recognsel exchange? (Not applicable for operating entities 0  Yes Iii  No
Is the inert/dual a Politically Exposed Person (PEP)?(A.  Yes, desoibe) N/A O yes g No
To the best of your knowledge, S the inclyidual related to an employee of the DB group?&FatrWor
Frivabh0, desmbe) N/A
O Family O Friendship g None
To the best of your knoMedge, S the inclyidual party to a non-barking relationshp with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or sentespOr
ves,desothe) N/A
Oyes I2 No
If applicable, instate which balk officers have met the person: Iodate where and when the dieM meeting(s) took place:
Bark Officer Name(s) Bank Cake' '
Client Private
Dorricie:
Client Place of
Business: Other location (fly) . Date:
0 O 0
0 O O
0 Wealth Details fa this individual are not filled in, because they are the same as for the following person:
311. wealth Details (Only for parties requiring soiree of wealth description as imitated in Section 2)
Nature of the Indhiduars &sines:
Airway Canby of solace of wealth/source of Funds?
thimay industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds?
Summarize Source of Wealth: O Business Owner O Salary/Earnings O Investment O Inheritance/Gas O Other:
Further Desete Source of Wealth /Detail the history of wealth fa each of the sources: (e.g. For trusts, how old senior 
accumulate wealth? For nhallance, how did
rawly accumulate weallh?For business owners, how long in business, how many employees, level of profitability? Indicate 
type of business, countries of major
activitks,
important bushes partners.)
Estimated Annual Incane(5): Estimated amount of investable assets(s):
Estimated Net WortI(S): Amount of assets planned to invest with PW14($)
Other Known Mandel Instiutbns:
Institution: Canby: Est. Assets Under Mgt
Institution: Country: Est Assets Under Mgt
InsUtution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
Please indicate the family situation of the Individual (Marital status, other family members, etc.):
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(a) DB-SONY-0000337
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... UM92814300
EFIA_00019210
KYC Print Page 13 of 20
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY In Section 2 Account Ovmershl Summary
3k Individual Details (lor all pates)
Individual's Name: Lawrence Paul Viscid Jr - Date of Eirth:
Country of Residence: United States Country of Otizenship: United States
Address of plenary residence:
Has dent resided outside of
his/her country of nationality for
5 years or more?
O yes ©No
Profession/Occupation: Manager Tax ID / SSW
Current Employer: Plan D LLC Poston/Title,/Rank: Manager
Address of employer: 6100 Red Hook, Quarter B3 St, Thomas Wgln Islands, U.S. 00802
Does the person work as senior executive of a 08-recognized regulated entity in the financial
Industry? or an entity listed on a DB-recognsel exchange? (Not applicable for operating entities El Yes Ii3 No
Is the inctiVidual a Politically Exposed Person(PEP)?(if Yes, despite) N/A ❑O Yes Ica No
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual related to an employee of the DB group?&Farna),  or
Flicvabb0, ctsmbe) N/A
O Family O Friendship g None
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual party to a non-barking relationsNp with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or serykes)?(if
Yes,desoitie) N/A
O Yes I2 No
If applicable, indicate which balk officers have met the person: Indicate where and when the client meeting(s) took 
place:
Bark Officer Name(s) Bank 0ffke: Client Private
Don de:
Get Place of
Ebsiness: Other Location (specify): Date:
O O O
O O O
O O O
O Wealth Details fa' this Individual are not filled in, because they are the same as for the following person:
311. wealth Details (Only for parties requiring mate of wealth description as imitated In Section 2)
Nature of the Indloduars Eusines:
Repay Country of opiate of wealth/source of Funds?
thimay industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds?
Summarize Source of Wealth: OBuriness Owner O Salary/Earings O Investment O Inheritance/GIs O Other:
Further Desosbe Source of Wealth /Detail the history of wealth for each of the sources: (e.g. For trusts, how id senior 
accumulate wealth? For inheritance, how
did
famly accumulate weallh?For business owners, how long in business, how many employees, level of prontability? Indicate 
type of business, countries of major
&intim,
impatant bistros partners.)
Estimated Annual Incane(S): Estimated amount &investable assets(s):
Estimated Net WOrtIXO: Amount of assets planned to invest with PWM($)
Other Known Mandel Instiutbns:
Insttturicet Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
Insttturicn: Country: Est Assets Under Mgt
InsbtuUcet Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
Please Indicate the family situation of the InclNidual (natal slabs, other randy members, etc.):
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(a) DB-SONY-0000338
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... /I/192814 3°1
EFIA_00019211
KYC Print Page 14 of 20
One sheet must be established for EACH LEGAL ENTITY In Section 2 Account Summary
3C. Legal Entity Details (Fee al Legal Entities)
Legal Entity Name: The Haze Trust - 00000486428
Type of Entity: O Fourglabon/Association ®Trust O Company O Estate O p urpose of Entity: ga Private Investment O
Partnership Mantle Charitable ['Commercial
Type d Entity Other (specify): Purposed Entity Other
(sPeetv):
Comity of
Magadan:in/registration:
United States Date of inarporaten /
regatration:
2/9/1999
Vokker Status: Identified on Customer ProNe Volcker Rag: No
Actress (city, street, post code): 6100 Red Hook Quarter B3 St, Thomas 00802 Virgin Islands, U.S. U.S. TIN/EIN:
Provide a description of the entity's organizational structure, Ls ownership savage and its Top Management. For 
trusts/foundations, inside informagan about
reocabllity,settr and benenciariesatc.:
This Is a Revocable Trust.
Jeffrey Epstein: GrantralTrustee/Benefioary
Darren Indyke: Trustee
Please Indicate how ownership of the legal entity is reflected: Trust Agreement
O SpecIal attention: Bearer Stares - Indicate where Males are custodied:
Describe the d ain from the direct owner of file entity to the ultimate bendkal owner (if not the game persons) Jeffrey 
Epstein: GrantorrfrusteelBeneadary
Darren [We: Trustee
To the best of your knowledge, Is the entity party to a non-banldng relationship nth Deutsche Bank
(e.g. eternal legal counsel, client referral source, suppler of goods or services)?: Yes O No
N/A
Describe Nature of Entity's Primary Business and Investment Activities
The trust was initially funded with $100. The trust makes and holds imastements are the gains it
Nature of the business: makes from those invariants is its soiree of rewsnue. The trust, in turn, pas these gains back 
into
the trust and reinvests.
Counties where business is trartssaed: United States
Number of employees: 2
3D. Wealth Profile (Only rot pa ties requiring source of wealth description as Indicated in Section 2)
thinwy Country of son of %earth/since of Funds? United States
Primary industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds? high Rea Financial Institutions
Provide Evidence of Corporate Assets (e.g. balance sheet or equ Arent summary of assaglIabilitses):
The trust was mealy raided %Rh $100 from Jeffrey Epstein. The trust makes and hods Investements and the gains It makes 
from those nvestments Is its source of
e,enue. The trust, Si turn. puts these gains back into the bust and tekivests.
Estimated gross receipts p.a.(3): 300,000.00
Estimated net profit p.a. ($): 200,000.00
Estimated investable assets ($): $20 MM - SO MM
Potential Amount to be Invested with PWPI ($): 200,000.00
Other Known Firandal Institutions:
Institution: County: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution: County: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution: County: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
One sheet must be established for EACH LEGAL ENTITY In Section 2. Account Summary
3C. Legal Entity Details (For al Legal Entitles)
Legal Entity Name:
Type of Entity:
Plan D, LLC 00000487219
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(a)
Purpose of Entity:
DB-SONY-0000339
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... /I/JP/2814 3°2
EFFA_00019212
KYC Print Page 15 of 20
O Fourdation/Assooaten . Trust 2Company . Estate D @Private Investment O
Phlarehropir./Charitable OCommercial Partnership
Type of Entity Other (specify): Purpose of Entity Other
(seedy):
Country of
incorecretbn/regiroation:
Virgin Islands, U.S. Date of incorporation /
retie:salon:
10/19/2012
Vetter SLatus: Identified on Customer Roble Wicker Rag: No
Adcress (city, street, Post code): 6100 Red Hook, Quarter 03 A, Thomas 00802 Virgin Islands, US U.S. TIN/EIN:
ProAde a description of the entity's organizational structure, ts ownership struaLre and its Top Management For 
trusts/fouidaUctis, include nformatem about
revocabikty,setIce and beneficial mete.:
Snare member LLC. Sole member is Jeffrey Emhart. The signers on this account are Jeffrey EDStall. Harry Beller and 
Darren Indyke
Please indicate how ownership of the legal entity Is reflected: Operating Agreement
D Special attention: Bearer Shares - Inctcate where shares are custodled:
Describe the chain from the direct owner of the entity to the ulUmate beneficial owner (loot the same pgiSi9(6). Single 
member LW. Sole member Is Jeffrey
Epstein.
The signors on this account are Jeffrey Epstein, Harry BelIer and Danen Indite
Lawrence Pad Visoskl Jr is the manager.
To the best of your knowledge, Is the entity party to a non-banWng relationship Web Deutsche Bank
(e.g. external legal counsel, client referral source, suppler of goods or services)?:
WA
Yes O No
Describe Nature of Entity's Primary Business and Invesbnent Activities
Nature of the business: LW created to hold funds to pay for costs associated with one of Jeffrey Epstein's planes. 
Personal
airplanes er rdare leased cult° others when the owner is not uslnq the pane.
Countries where business is transacted: United States
Number of employees: 1
3D. Wealth Profile (Only for parties requiting source of wealth description as indicated In Section 2)
Primary Country of soLete of wealth/source of Funs? UMW States
Primary industry of source d Wealth/Soiree of Funs? High Risk Financial Ingham
Provide Evidence of Corporate Assets (e.g. balance sheet or equivalent airman/ of asses/liabilities):
J.0 mated to hold funds to pay for costs associated with one of Jeffrey Epsten's planes. Initial contribution d $1000 
from Jeffrey Epstein and all source of
funds come
ran Jeffrey Epstein.
An airplane Is equipment. Personal airplanes are generally leased oil to others when the ovals , Is not using the plane.
Estimated gross receipts p.a.(5): 1,000,000.00
Estimated net pont pa. ($): 500,000.00
Estimated investable asses ($): <$1 MM
Potential Amour to be invested with PYfli (5): 200,000.00
Other Known Financial Institutions:
Institution: County: BE. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution: County: BL Assets Under Mgt:
InsteLtico. Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
ne sheet must be established for EACH LEGAL ENTITY In Section 2. Account Summary
3C. Legal Entity Details (Fa an Legal Entities)
Legal Entity Mame: NES, LLC - 00000487265
Type of Entity: O Fourglaflon/Associatka ❑O Trust @ Company ❑O Btate ❑O
Partnership
pumps. of Enuty: a Private Investment O
Phlanthropic/Charitable OCommerdal
Type d Entity Other (specify): Purpose of Entity Other
(SecifY):
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(a) DB-SONY-0000340
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... /I/JP/2824 3°3
EFFA_00019213
KYC Print Page 16 of 20
Country of
incorporation/registration:
United States
Date of Inv:mower:in /
regStrabon:
8/13/1998
Volker Status: Identified co Customer Profile Wicks Rag: No
Access (city, stree( post code): 6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3 St, Thomas 00802 Virgin Islands, US U.S. TIN/E1N:
Provide a description of the entity's organizational structure, as ownership struaLre and Its Top Management For 
trusts/foundaUces, Include information about
revocability,settle and beneficiar es,etc.:
Single member LLC. Jeffrey Eostein is the sole member. The signors on tNs account we Jeffrey Epste n, Darren Indyke and 
Hany Beller
Please incicate how ownershp or the legal entity Is reflected: Operating Agreement
- Incbeate where shares are custodied: • Special attention: Bearer Shares
Describe the chain from the direct owner of the entity to the ultimate beneficial owner (Float the same persons). Single
member LLC. Jeffrey Epstein is the sole
reenter. The signors on tNs account we Jeffrey Epstein, Darren Indyke and Hany Bele
To the best of your knowledge, Is the entity party to a non-banWng relationship veil Deursche Bank
(e.g. external legal counsel, client referral source, suppler of goods or senAces)?:
WA
yeS IMI No 5
Describe Nature of Entity's Primary Business and Invesbnent Activities
Nature o The boimess: NES, LLC was famed to take care of the expenses annealed with running one of Jeffrey Epstein's
homes
Countries where business is transacted. United States
Number or employees: 1
3D. Wealth Profile (Ony for parties requiring son of wealth descrther as indicated in Secher 2)
Primly Country of source of wealth/scarce of Funs? United States
Primary industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds? Nigh Risk Wendel Institutions
Provide Evidence of Corporate Assets (e.g. balance sheet or eo II/Went summary of assetsfilablInS):
All funds come from Jeffrey Epstein. who has been KYCd previousN
Estimated gross receipts p.a.(S): 1.000.000.00
Estimated net wilt p.a. (5): 503,000.00
Estimated nyestable asses (5): <S1 Mal
Potential MioLMt to be Invested with OWN (5): 15%000.00
Other Known Randal Institutions:
InsUturion: Country: Est. ASS Under Mgt
InsUhtJam Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
InstItuUctm Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0000341
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... /I/192814 3°4
EFIA_00019214
KYC Print Page 17 of 20
DB PWM GLOBAL KYC/NCA: US/LatArnfinti PART B
Relationship Name SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP
Risk Rating Garments:
The Haze-Ovena-HIGH,EnUty-HIGH,Industry-HIGH,Countiy-MEDIUM,Produa-HGH.The 2007 Jeff rey-Cnerarl-HIGH,EntIty.
HIGH,Industry-li GH,Country-MEDIUMProduct-HIGH.PLan D & NES LLC- Overall-HIGH Entity-MEDIUM,Inclusay-HIGH,Country-
MEDIUM,Product HIGH.
Booking Center @ NY O NY/Offshore O Offshore 0 Moderate
Risk mi  Gm High Risk
(Compliance Signalise)
O DB Employee O Gs Managed PIC O DB is Trustee/Co-Trustee O Bearer Shares

4. Attachments
A. Type of Photo ID Provided 0 Drivers Ucense ®Passport O rttaucoaustate ID O Other
B. Checklist of names (individuals andbx (Mites) that were submitted for database searches is attached gives El No

C. Please indicate the results of the database searches performed
RDC searches compete 1.! Yes O No negative resits found O Yes ID No
PCR checks complete !d Yes O No negative rests found 0 Yes O No
OFAC checks amplete 2 Yes O No negative rests found Dyes 12 No
BIS searches amplete (Lexls/Nexis, FacUva, Reuters, Dow Jones, DEB) Fe. Yes O he negative resift found 2 Yes O No
Denial Orders chedd complete 2 Yes Ell No negative resters found 0 Yes M
No
Martindale-Hubbell searched (Lawyers/Law Firms only) • Yes 171 No negative resters found O Yes O No
D. Please suwnante any negative results from the database searches indicated above: Plan D:
- No negative media
- No court cases
The Hate Trust:
- No negative media
- No MLitt cases
The 2007 Jeffrey E. Epstein Insurance Trust 13:
- No negative mead
- No court cases
NES LLC:
- No negative mesa,
- Court case was sled way back in 4/5/2005 which pertains to NES LLC that is InvoNed in doing tuskless as National 
Educational Service and the status of the use
stands dosed. This doesnot pertain to our entity as our airily is not into educational service.
Rally Beller:
- No negative mesa
- Harry Beller is the plaintiff in the court case, also it has been disposed.
Jeffrey Edward Epstein:
- Adverse results in Google relates to Jeffrtys Sex offence in the past which are cleared already. Attached clearances 
in the case
- Negative meda reviles to the sex offence in the past vAsich are already cleared. (KYC K - 01790655)
- Court cases relates to Jeffreys sex offence in the past vAsich is already cleared, another (Gerber El Al V. The 
Financial Trust Corrpany Et a) is a recent
ongoing civil
lawsuit pertaining to hard which has been dismissed (attached document), but part of normal business operations for this
client. And in one of the case he's
nether
defendant nor plaintiff. Hes Just named as a respondent and the case is immaterial in nature
- Criminal Filings relates to sex offence which is already cleared in the past
- RDC alert found - Sec offences in the past which has been dears - Clearance attached
Darren Indyke:
- Negative news in Google relates to Jeffrey Epslein's Foundation and are net material in nature.
- Court case mentioned in Google search relates to Jeffrey Epstein's sex offence in the past wNch has been cleared 
already. Darren is just an attorney for
Jeffrey In
the case.
- Fircosoft alert has been cleated by AML Compliance. Clearance attached.
Richard Kiln:
- No negative meda
- Court case was dismissed and he was not barred from NYSE Arca and was dears in the previous KYC5. Attached clearances
- RDC alert found - realates to violation of NYSE Arca Egalks Rule - Clearance attached.
•.
- No negative meda
- No court cases
Pad S Barrett :
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000342
https://dbforcepb.rny.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... ITt928c4 3°5
KYC Print Page 18 of 20
- No negative mead
- NO court cases
- RDC art found - False positives, does not pertain to our diet Clearance attached.
Jean Mne Brennan Wietracht:
- No negative media
- No MLitt cases
Lawrence Paul Vlsoski Jr:
- No negative mode
- No MLitt cases
Southern TIUSt Company Inc:
- No negative mead
- No court cases
The Randal Trust Company:
- Negative news In research is false positive and immaterial in nature. The hit is on IRA Financial Trust Company and 
not our SOW catty The Mendel Trust
Company.
- Court case pertains to Fest Wendel Trust Company and not our SOW entity The Finandal Trust Company

E. To the best of your knowledge, has the diem ever been corniced of a criminal offense? ®yes
O No
F.
To the best of your knowledge, has the customer ever been Involve:litany past litigation against
Deutsche Bank AG Cr any of t subsidiaries or is the customer threatening litigadon against Deutsche I—I _ D i
Bank AG or any of its subsidiaries? (ft Yes, provide Odd ham ero sr =Oct Quately Mgt (fin/MT)  or '—' ' es No
the Reattetoty Control Group ono r henry Comaence aromas(*)

G. Does the dlent or related party have any firencial or other association (interactions vAthin countries or Llr-i
regimes sanctioned by the Office of Foreign Asses Control (OFAC)? Ya 2 No

H. Does the dent or related pasty have any financial or other assodation/ interactions within high risk
°contra? Own ga No

I. Corporate Doamentation Attached (Legal Entities Only) LIF4 Yes • No O Not Applicable
J. Undisclosed PrOdpal Fern Complete (Intemedaries Cory) O Yes O No 0 Not Applicable

K. If Las/axis Search Results, Corporate Documents or Other Supporting Documentation Is not in Engleh, please provide an
Engash summary of the natureicoreets
of the non-English Documentation:

I. Speoal Risk Factors
Does the account have Nexus to Special Risk Cambia? O Yes O No
Is the account structure unusualy complex? Oyes O No
Is there any indcation the client set up a non operating company expressly for r--i
the purpose of trwslerring Mares to third parties? Li Yes O No
Is thee any indication tints could be a prohibited business relatbnship? Oyes O No
Are the bearer shares identified suthect to acceptable controls? Oyes O No
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0000343
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e...
UM92814306
EFFA_00019216
KYC Print Page 19 of 20

M. Case Comments
Created By Date Comments
Aka Bab 11/5/116 4:18 AM Daman Indere on 10/22/18 confirmed that there are no material charges.
Vaunts) Chung 11/16/118 L32 PM Ftll CoMmied that the diet via be deang the accounts before the end of the year. Case Si 
be dosed. 11/16/18
Dutra Manley 11/19111811:42 AM
This KYC serves as Periodic Review for the 'elbowing °Astir* teens:
(I) Nes I1C
(2) Flan D LLC
(3) The Haze Trust
Risk factors Include:

• Source of Wealth (SOW) Industry: Financial Management (managing client assets)
• PEP/RCA: Jeffrey Epstein, U60 8 SOW, is conedered an RCA based on Ns dose relationship with Bill anton (Fenner
US President) aid Prime Mdrew (BOUM Royal Family)

• Media: NegatNe media related to Jeffrey Epsbain has been previously reviewed aid escalated for reputations risk
concerns. Evidence of pile approval to proceed with the reatonship Is attached to this case, Including a stipulation to
review fuller If new media Is identified. Accordingly, approval from the Divisional Control Officer is attached to Ns
KYC in regards to a recency filed (and dismissed) court case. (Please see clearances for more details)
We are comfortable signing-off on the KYC for the 'glowing reasons:

• Information and supporting documents required by ow, API_ Polley were provided and reviewed. As a result, we have
a reasonable understandng of the purpose of the account and expected transaction activity.
• The source of wealth was sufficiently detailed and appears plausible.
• We performed due diligence searches on all parties and did not Md the names searched to be on any sanctions lists.
Yowsun Chung 11/16/118 4:45 PM 'Me ally acoaunt clasIng is the issuance Wig,
Atca Bab 8/24/116 5:48 AM No material changes confirmation serail' attached in the case
ONSHORE APPROVALS
Cent Facing Professional (CFP): Bradley Gain (Sgnature)
Bradley Galin
10/5/2018
Office Director/Business Head: Andrew F Gallivan (Signature)
Mdrew F Galilean
10/9/2018
Regional Office Director: (Signature)
AML Business Risk:
(Signature)
AML Compliance:
Dimity.) Manley
(Signature)
CU-ultra Manley 11/19/2018
LATAM/INTERNATIONAL APPROVALS
Dreg Ming Professional (CFP): (Signature)
Accout Manager: (Signature)
Global Market Team Head (GMTH)/Sub-
tarket Team Head (SSITH):
(Signature)
AML Business Risk:
(Signature)
AML Compliance
(Signature)
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. e(a) DB-SDNY-0000344
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... /I/192814 3°7
EFIA_00019217
KYC Print Page 20 of 20
PRIVATE WEALTH MANAGEMENT POLICY STATEMENT: Deutsche Bank Private Wealth Management (PWM)
worldwide is committed to professionally serve the interests of its clients. To do so, Client Facing Professionals!(!) 
(CFP's)
should establish and maintain business relationships only with persons who satisfy our high standards of suitability,
background and character. Due diligence obtained on the client must be appropriately documented by the CFP. It is the
responsibility of CFP's to demonstrate that they know their client both at the inception of a relationship and on an 
ongoing
basis.
DECLARATION FOR ALL SIGNERS OF THIS FORM: To the best of my knowledge and belief the above information  is
correct and up to date. I confirm that! have no suspicions relating to the money laundering or unethical activities on 
the part
of the client(s) and that I have followed all the procedures relating to account opening as described in the PWM 
Americas
Procedures and the PWM Global KYC Policy

(I) Client Facing Professionals (CFP's) include: Relationship Managers, Wealth Advisors, Product Officers, Brokers, 
Client
Managers, etc.
Deutsche Bank Americas New York rA
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(0) DB-SONY-0000345
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servletiservletintegration?lid=0 IN30000000D9Di&e... 11MP/2814 3°8
EFFA_00019218
EFTA00015532 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in US v. Jeffrey Epstein alleging Epstein tried to buy victim's silence
EFTA01249281 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from unknown girl
(inferred timestamp: 2019-07-12 23:43:00)
50D-NY-3027571 Serial 125
CrivisliMIte(Rm5.2347) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Crisis Intake
Date: 07/12/2019
Case ID #:: 31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 07/12/2019 07:43 PM EDT
Details:
On 07/12/2019, at 6:30 p.m. Eastern Time, II<REDACTED> II
date of birth <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>, called
the FBI National Threat Operations Center (NTOC), to provide information
regarding case number no.: 31E-NY-3027571.

<REDACTED> provided the following information:

In 20013-2014, <REDACTED> was <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED>. <REDACTED> was asked by a group of very wealthy men, including
Jeffrey Epstein, <REDACTED> <REDACTED> was then summoned by
Epstein to meet him <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> where Esptein
turned the lights off, put his pants down and sexually assaulted
<REDACTED>.

<REDACTED> thought the security guard would come and help her, because
there is a security camera in every room. <REDACTED> mentioned to Epstein
everything was being recorded but, he just laughed and said "I have
everything covered."

Epstein gave <REDACTED> his business card and said she could make a lot of
money with him. <REDACTED> noticed <REDACTED> was with the group of
men. <REDACTED> told the security guard what has happened but he only
shrugged his shoulders.

3501.281-001
Page I of 2
50D-NY-3027571 Serial 125
Re: 31E-NY-3027571, 07/12/2019
<REDACTED> <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> never talked to anyone until today
she mustered the courage to call the crisis line to ask for help and then
to the FBI. <REDACTED> said she can be contacted by phone.

3501.281-001
Page 2 of 2
EFTA01265973 (Jmail)
 [money] large transfers around time of Epstein arrest
(inferred date: 2019-07-15)
CA11517 - JEFFREY EPSTEIN
REFERRAL DETAILS:
Case Creation Date: 07/08/2019
Notification Source: Financial Crimes Risk Management- AML Media Review Team
Referring Concern:
Incident report opened due to negative media for JEFFREY EPSTEIN. he has been charged with one count of sex trafficking
of minors, and one count of conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking of minors. FCI Media is in the process of exiting 
the client
Previous or Related Compliance Cases (in the prior 24 months':

• N/A - No previous related Compliance cases were identified as of 07/10/2019
o SELS query on the Compliance/TPA/Investigations tabs & Oracle ECM
INVESTIGATION NOTES:
Sublect(s):  Customer ID(sl:

• JEFFREY EPSTEINSOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC.
• SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLCSOUTHERN COUNTRY INTERNATIONAL LTD
• RICHARD KAHN
JEFFREY EPSTEIN (66 years old) established a relationship with Schwab in April 2019 maintaining three active accounts 
for which
he maintains a role as an internal control person and beneficial owner. These roles do not grant him any authority to 
act on an
account, however, he is included within this investigation due to the negative media surrounding Mr. Epstein. His 
disclosed
suitability is employed as an executive/senior management at Southern Trust Company, Inc.
RICHARD KAHN (46 years old) established a relationship with Schwab in April 2019 maintaining three active accounts for 
which he
maintains an agent role granting him the authority to conduct activity within the three corporate accounts. His 
disclosed suitability
is an executive/senior management of HRBK ASSOCIATIONS INC.
Transaction Summary:
This investigation encompassed the period between account inception and 07/10/2019.
" (all accounts established within April/May 2079) (see individual subpages in the Transaction Summary tab)**
The following activity was identified:
Account
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY LLC
Agent: KAHN
Internal Control: KAHN & EPSTEIN
Beneficial Owner: EPSTEIN (100%)
Credits Debits
Funds received via check/wires from: Foreign wire sent to:
MARC LEON (MOROCCO)
06/26/19 -12.708.324.00 Client requested returr
07/10/19 -14.950.000.00 Client canceled wire
SHARES Transferred to #14332170
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY .2.250.000
TOA of stocks from Merryl Lynch
FX Returned Wire Credit of:
412,070,506.60
Client assumed loss of-$113,527.80
Credits
Date Shares Symbol
06/27/19 10,000 XOM
06/27/19 10,000 ILMN
06/27/19 1,000 GS
CC9 IN- Ee lSiu2ancaN i TIAL
Debits
SONY_GM_00006024
Account
SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
Agent: KAHN
Internal Control: KAHN & EPSTEIN
Beneficial Owner: EPSTEIN (?%)
Account Balance $0.00
Account
SOUTHERN COUNTRY
INTERNATIONAL INC.
Agent: KAHN
Internal Control: KAHN & EPSTEIN
Beneficial Owner: EPSTEIN (100%)
DARREN/ea:ME& AftWELLE SOO:14ER
Funds received via check/wires from:
SOUTHERN FINANCJAL LLC +S35,27840
COATUE ENTERPRISES LW .39,000.00
.42200.00
TOA of stocks from TD Ameritrade
Credits
Funds received via check from:
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY .250.000
TOA of Fixed Income & Stocks from:
TD Ameritrade
SALE of Investments • I7.255.875.48
CASH Transferred to
Total -$547,543.36
SHARES Transferred
SHARES SYMBOL
3,000 GOOG
263,157 APO
1.000 GS
SHARES
25.000
7.000
25.000
SYMBOL
CVNA
AMZN
KPO
Debits
CASH Transferred to
Total -$17,505,911.64
Investigation Research:
Negative Media - EPSTEIN:
EPSTEIN was arrested and charged on 07/08/2019 with sex trafficking of minors and conspiracy to comment sex trafficking
to minors, the first federal charged brought against him. The indictment alleges the acts took place between 2002 
through
2005, through engaging in acts in exchange for money.
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, 66, is charged with one count of sex trafficking of minors, which carries a maximum sentence of 40
years in prison, and one count of conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking of minors, which carries a maximum sentence
of five years in prison.
He is currently in jail, but on 07/15/2019 he will appear in court for his bait hearing. Articles indicate urges to not 
grant bail
to EPSTEIN as they worry he is a flight risk due to the extent of EPSTEIN's wealth.
OTHER INFORMATION REGARDING REMITTERS OF FUNDS:
COATUE ENTERPRISES LLC

• Actively registered in the state of NY with agent listed as HBRK ASSOCIATES INC. (KAHN'S company)
DARREN K INDYKELawyer in New York
• Per CLEAR, connected to EPSTEIN (see CLEAR subpage in the Client Profile tab)
• Per PRABOOK.com - worked at EPSTEIN & Company

• Per an article (The Daily Beast) posted on 03/12/2019 indicates DARREN INDYKE is EPSTEIN's attorney
RICHARD KAHN

• Linked in various business connections to EPSTEIN and INDYKE.
FX WIRE RESEARCH:
Per notes in MyQ the purpose of the outgoing wire to MARC LEON on 06/26/2019 for -$12,708,324.00 was for real estate
purposes. The client was sending euros in which trades were placed. The following day, 06/27/2019, Richard Kahn called
into Schwab asking if it's possible to stop and terminate the wire.
Why does he want to cancel?
Kahn states "for a concentrated real estate transaction, and uh, what uh, terms we were told we had on uh an
agreement, were uh, not, were reneged on this morning. So uh we are hoping it still can be a deal, but at this point
the terms that I accepted are not agreeable to him I want to retract the wire ..."
Schwab agrees to attempt to recall the wire on a best efforts basis with the understanding that there might be financial
cgiN_EeispgaNTIAL EFTA (H) 120084
consequences and Richard Kahn agreed to assume any losses.
Schwab successfully recalled the wire, converting the EU back into USD, the loss Richard Kahn absorbed was -$113,527.80

• Additional calls identified the following statements:
• Wire was sent prematurely, but will need to send a wire for even more to a different escrow account

• If the EU goes in our benefit, do we get the profit?
• Kahn asked on 07/10/2019 if the wire request requires more than one signature ... asked to check as he needs to send
a few more wires out.
? WHO IS MARC LEON:
Google search of MARC LEON identified a real estate company, KENSINGTON MOROCCO, where MARC LEON is listed
as a partner, working for pharmaceutical, real estate businesses, etc.
The address provided on the outgoing wire matches with the address listed on Kensington Morocco's website.
Appears customers have the ability to research luxury properties in the countries MOROCCO and FRANCE.
On 07/04/2019 a secondary wire request was submitted for a -$14,950,000.00 wire to be remitted to a different account 
for
the benefit of MARC LEON.
However, on 07/09/2019, Richard Kahn secure messaged Schwab asking to have the wire canceled.
The wire request form was signed by both KAHN and EPSTEIN on 07/05/2019.
Proposed Decision:
Investigator determined to file a SAR reporting the outgoing international wire attempts for real estate purposes in 
light of
the negative media in which articles indicate EPSTEIN is a possible flight risk. While source of funds do not appear of
concern, the narrative will detail how the funds came to Schwab.
MEETING NOTES:
All meeting notes related to this AML Investigation can be identified within the Oracle ECM "Audit" tab within the 
respective case.

• Notes should reflect supporting points of the case review decision, and if applicable, can be updated after case 
review.
cgIN EacaNTIAL SDNY_GM_00006026
EFTA01249191 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from Les Wexner's former bodyguard
(inferred timestamp: 2019-07-16 16:56:00)
50D -NY -3027571 Serial 141
Crisis Intake (Rev. 5.23.17) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Crisis Intake
Date: 07/16/2019
Case ID #:: 31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 07/16/2019 12:56 PM EDT
Details:
On 07/16/2019, at 12:56 III. Eastern Time, Richard Adrian,
, called the FBI National Threat
Operations Center (NTOC), to report information regarding Jeffrey
Epstein.
Adrian provided the following information:
Adrian is from and
Between 1991 and 1992, Adrian was the bodyguard for Les Wexner (Wexner),
the CEO of L Brands (Victoria Secret); Wexner was best friends with
Epstein. Adrian stated that he had information that could help the
investigation and fill in some of the blanks. Adrian stated he had been
to Epstein's Palm Beach home and noted that there were young girls there,
but assumed they were family. Adrian was told by another bodyguard to
keep to yourself and not ask questions. Adrian stated that he spoke to
Epstein a few times, the last being in 1992. Adrian also stated that
Epstein got all of his money from Wexner, and that in 1993 Wexner sold
his mansion in New York to Epstein for $20.
• •
3501.234-001
Page I of I
╔═════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 John Houshmand [employee] contractor 
╚══════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01249562 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip John Houshmand about cameras
(inferred timestamp: 2019-07-18 12:14:00)
50D -NY -3027571 Serial 15
CeiuMele(tev.5-2347) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Crisis Intake
Date: 07/18/2019
Case ID 31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 07/18/2019 08:14 AM EDT
Details:
On 07/18/2019, at 8:14 a.m. Eastern Time, John Houshmand,
, called the FBI National
Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to report information pertaining to the
Epstein case.
Houshmand provided the following information:
Houshmand was a contractor in NYC. During his time as a contractor,
Houshmand did a project for Jeff Epstein; the project took approximately
4-5 months. Houshmand is unsure what year the project took place, but
believes it may have been in 2006 (according to emails he has).
Houshmand's primary contact for the project was Doug, last name unknown.
Doug jokingly told Houshmand that he and several other staff members were
instructed to use the security camera in front of the house to look up
and down the street. Doug stated, if they saw any attractive, young
women, they were to go out on the street and approach them with the offer
of a modeling job. Additionally, Epstein kept a photo gallery in his
exercise room that contained black and white head shots of the various
girls.
3501.333-001
Page I of I
EFTA01249623 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from New Mexico police officer about Zorro Ranch
(inferred timestamp: 2019-07-19 23:48:00)
50D -NY -3027571 Serial lhr
CrisisIntalm(ter.54347) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Crisis Intake
Date: 07/19/2019
Case ID #: 31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 07/19/2019 07:48 PM EDT
Details:
On 07/19/2019, at 7:48 p.m. Eastern Time, Retired New Mexico State Police
Officer, , telephone number , other personal
identifiers refused, called the FBI National Threat Operations Center
(NTOC), regarding information related to Jeffrey Epstein, main case no.:
31E-NY-3027571.
provided the following information:
lives in the neighborhood of a property owned by Jeffrey Epstein.
The property which is on Zorro Ranch Road, Stanley, NM, his recently had
a large barn constructed. The barn is suspicious as there is a garage
door that appears to be a sally port, and there is a chimney. is
concerned the property could potentially have an incinerator concealed
within the barn. An old 1970's mobile home was recently put right behind
the barn, which believes does not follow Santa Fe County
regulations. There have been a lot of high profile people seen
frequenting the property. has heard rumors that the property was
used for recruited girls to visit with Epstein, but he has no factual
evidence to support this claim. heard rumors that girls from
Albuquerque and the Moriarty area were recruited for Epstein.
patrolled this area for 15 years before he retired. The property
was owned previously by the governor of New Mexico, but the property was
sold to Epstein before the governor's passing. The property that
is reporting, is about three miles away from Epstein's mansion.
explained that there is a lot of security for the properties including
3501.371-001
Page I of 2
EFFA_00 109358
SOD -NY -3027571 Serial 160
Re: 31E-NY-3027571, 07/19/2019
cameras, sally ports, and other security measures. explained that
the barn that was constructed doesn't look like a
barn you would use for ranching. wanted to report the information
to the FBI because he is concerned evidence could be destroyed here.
• •
3501.371-001
Page 2 of 2
EFTA00034275 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons initial form filed about Epstein's suicide attempt
(date: 2019-07-23)
TYPOPricilferrt,
❑ Assault On Inmate
❑ Assault On Staff
❑ Assault, Attempted On Inmate
❑ Assault, Attempted On Staff
❑ Disruptive Behavior
❑ Escape From Non-secure Facility
❑ Escape From Secure Facility
❑ Escape, Attempted From Non-secure Facility
❑ Escape, Attempted From Secure Facility
❑ Fight
❑ Inmate Death
❑ Institution Disturbance
❑ Introduction Of Contraband
❑ Lethal Weapons Discharge
❑ Self Mutilation
❑ Setting A Fire
❑ Sexual Act, Non-consensual On Inmate
❑ Sexual Assault On Staff
❑ Sexual Contact, Abusive On Inmate
❑ Sexual Harassment, Repetitive
❑ Staff Homicide
❑ Strike, Food
❑ Strike, Work
❑✓ Suicide Attempt
❑ Use Of Force
❑ Use Of Force/Applications Of Restraints
❑ Use of Restraints, Pregnant/Postpartum
Method: Hanging/Asphyxiation
Form 583 Report of Incident
Incident ft: NYM-19- Submitted By:
0076
Date/Time Of Incident 7/23/2019 1:27 AM

Section 1: General Information
Staff Aware Date: 7/23/2019 1:27 AM
FBI Notified: No USMS Notified: No Indicate Where Incident Occurred: Main Facility
Location Level 1: SHU Level 2: Housing Unit, Special (SHU) Level 3: 9 SOUTH SHU
Institution Locked Down: No
Modified Operations: No
Cause Of Incident Known? No
Cause Of Incident
❑ Alcohol
❑ Commissary
❑ Debts
❑ Disrespect Issue
❑ Drugs
❑ Ethnic Conflict
❑ Food Issue
❑ Geographical Conflict
❑ Interfering with Staff duties
❑ Property Issue
❑ Racial Conflict
❑ Recreation Equipment
❑ Religious Issue
❑ Security Threat Group Conflict
❑ Sexual Pressure
❑ Sporting Events
❑ Telephone
❑ Theft
❑ Visiting
❑ Work Issue

Section 2: Inmates Involved
UNCLASSIFIED/LIMITED OFFICIAL USE ONLY/LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
This document is marked Unclassified/Limited Official Use Only/Law Enforcement Sensitive and may be disseminated, with 
proper
attribution, to active Law Enforcement, DOD. or U.S. Intelligence Agencies. This document, or any segmenVattachment 
thereof, may
not be released without the approval of the Bureau of Prisons to any media sources, any non-law enforcement entity, the 
general
public or those without a 'need to know: It contains information that may be exempt from public release under the 
provisions of the
Privacy Act (5 U.S.C. 552).
1 of 3
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10632
Form 583 Report of Incident
Incident #: NYM-19-
0076
Submitted By: Date/Time Of Incident: 7/23/20191: AM
Reg tt: 76316054 Name: EPSTEIN, JEFFREY
Role: Victim Medical Attention Required: No
Weapon (per inmate): No Use of Force (per inmate): No Chemical Used (per Inmate): No
CIMS: No STG: Yes
Restraints (per inmate): Escort Only
Death (per inmate): No
Reg #: Name:
Role: Not Known Medical Attention Required: No
Weapon (per Inmate): No Use of Force (per inmate): No
CIMS: Yes STG: Yes
Restraints (per inmate): No
Death (per inmate): No
Injury Category: Minor lnju
Injury Category: No Injury
Chemical Used (per inmate): No

Section 3: Others Involved
Name:
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault: No
Name:
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault: No
Name:
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault: No
Name:
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault: No
Name
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault: No
Name: Thomas, Michael
Medical Attention Required: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
UNCLASSIFIED/LIMITED OFFICIAL USE ONLY/LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
This document is marked Unclassified/Limited Official Use Only/Law Enforcement Sensitive and may be disseminated, with p
'per
attribution, to active Law Enforcement. DOD. or U.S. Intelligence Agencies. This document, or any segment/attachment 
thereof. may
not be released without the approval of the Bureau of Prisons to any media sources, any non-law enforcement entity, the 
general
public or those without a 'need to know: It contains information that may be exempt from public release under the 
provision of the
Privacy Act (5 U.S.C. 552).
2 of 3
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10633
Form 583 Report of Incident
Incident NYM-19- Submitted By:
0076
Date/Time Of Incident: 7/23/2019 1:27 AM
Injury Category: No Injury Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Sexual Assault: No

Section 4: Lethal Weapon Discharge
No data found.

Section 5: Use of Force
No data found.

Section 6: Description of Incident
DESCRIPTION OF INCIDENT (If Use Of Force, Include details such as name of supervisor applying the chemical
agent and/or restraints, masons for use of hard restraints instead of soft restraints, etc.) Please be clear about
cause(s) of the incident in your description.
On July 23. 2019 at approx. 1:27 a.m., a call for assistance on the Special Housing Unit was announced by the Control
4)Center. Upon my arrival I was informed that an inmate had attempted suicide and proceeded to cell, Z05-124LA . I
observed inmate Epstein, Jeffrey #76318-054 lying in the fetal position on the floor of his cell wearing a t-shirt an 
boxers.
He was breathing heavily and was snoring. I called out to inmate Epstein and observed him flicker his eyes and continue
snoring. His neck was red with no abrasions. I observed no further injuries to his person. An attempt was made to get
the inmate to stand on his own with negative results. The inmate was placed in hand restraints and staff was di ed to
retrieve the stretcher. As inmate Epstein was being placed on the stretcher by responding staff, he would open h s eyes
and observe staff. When staff made eye contact with him, he would hurriedly shut his eyes. The inmate was lak n to
HA-Unit, dressed in the suicide smock and placed on suicide watch.
Upon the arrival of medical staff, inmate Epstein was examined and treated by, MLP for a circular line of
erythema at the base of the neck, one section on the front with marks of friction and a sma e hema on his left nee.

Section 7: Attachments
iftenarde*
No data found.
Approved By: NOT COMPLETED
Orfalnal.Entered By
UNCLASSIFIED/LIMITED OFFICIAL USE ONLY/LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
This document is marked Unclassified/Limited Official Use Only/Law Enforcement Sensitive and may be disseminated, with p
r
attribution, to active Law Enforcement. DOD, or U.S. Intelligence Agencies. This document. or any segmenVattachment 
there f. may
not be released without the approval of the Bureau of Prisons to any media sources, any non4aw enforcement entity, the 
general
public or those without a *need to know.' It contains information that may be exempt from public release under the 
provisions of the
Privacy Act (5 U.S.C. 552).
3 of 3
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10634
UNITEL TATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York New York 10007
July 23, 2019
MEMORANDUM FO
FROM:
SUBJECT: Possible Suicide Attempt
On July 23, 2019 at approx. 1:27 a.m., a call for assistance on the Special Housing Unit
was announced by the Control Center. Upon my arrival I was informed that an inmate
had attempted suicide and proceeded to cell, Z05-124LAD. I observed inmate
Epstein, Jeffrey #76318-054 lying in the fetal position on the floor of his cell wearing a
t-shirt and boxers. He was breathing heavily and was snoring. I called out to inmate
Epstein and observed him flicker his eyes and continue snoring. His neck was red
with no abrasions. I observed no further injuries to his person. An attempt was made
to get the inmate to stand on his own with negative results. The inmate was placed in
hand restraints and staff was directed to retrieve the stretcher. As inmate Epstein was
being placed on the stretcher by responding staff, he would open his eyes and observe
staff. When staff made eye contact with him, he would hurriedly shut his eyes. The
inmate was taken to HA-Unit, dressed in the suicide smock and placed on suicide
watch. While awaiting the arrival of an inmate companion, inmate Epstein sat on the
edge of the bed and began moving forward as if he was attempting to fall over head
first. When I looked away, he straightened up. As I turned to look at him again, he
attempted the same act. I laid him down on the bed and directed him to cease his
action or he would be placed in restraints for his safety. At that moment, he stated,
"Okay, I won't do it again," and gave the thumbs up. Because of his unpredictable
behavior, the decision was made to have a staff member observe inmate Epstein. I
left HA-Unit in order to make staff notifications. Moments later, I spoke with Officer
Clark- wh sta tein was alert and had indicated that his cellmate,
had attempted to kill him and had been harassing
im e state e inmate had indicated that he'd informed his attorney of this
matter.
I photographed and spoke with inmate  who stated
that he was asleep with his headphones on when he felt something hit his legs and
said, "Jeff, what you're doing?" He didn't answer, so he got up, turned on the light and
saw him with a string around his neck. He stated that he then called the guards and
ASensilive Limited Official Use Onlvir.
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010635
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010636
they ran down. Upon f,....ner questioning, inmate ..fated that he sleeps on
the bottom bunk, but gave it to inmate Epstein because he's old. He stated that he
sleeps on the floor on a mattress. He stated that when he got up, he couldn't
remember if he sat up or stood up to check on Epstein. He stated that Epstein was
sitting on the floor leaning to the side with his eyes opened, but wasn't responding. He
stated that the last time he saw him he was snoring really loud.
Inmate Epstein stated that he came in fricau legal visit at approx. 8:00PM and staff
handed him a copy of the Daily News. "M" was on the floor reading the Daily News.
He stated that he had given it to him. He stated that mentioned that he'd
been in court all day in Westchester and was carrying on. At that point, inmate
paused as if he was making the story up as he went along, and stated that
stated, "These fucking niggers. This place is inhumane, I wish I could
report it. (Officer), that nigger hobbit mother fucker." He then turned to a page in
the Daily News that had his picture on it and stated that Epstein was worth seventy
seven million dollars. Epstein stated that he took his picture, balled it up and threw it in
the garbage. I asked inmate Epstein what happened prior to staffs arrival. He stated
that at approx. 1:00 AM, he'd gotten up to get a drink of water, as he gets up every
thirty minutes. He remember walking back to his bunk and waking up with staff there
in his cell. I asked if he'd waken up and seen staff, why didn't he respond when we
were calling out to him? He stated that he only remembered hearing himself making a
noise like snoring. When asked about the allegations against his cellmate, he stated
that he was told, if he hurt him, staff wouldn't care.
Duty medical,  was notified and briefed. It was determined no further
medical attention was needed. A medical assessment was not conducted at the time
of this incident, due to the fact, there was no medical staff available after 10:00 PM.
iU on the arrival of medical staff, inmate Epstein was examined and treated by, MLP I
for a circular line of erythema at the base of the neck, one section on the front
wit marks of friction and a small erythema on his left knee.
ASensitive Limited Official Use Only=
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010637
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010638
I) 7 r 3-2019
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
SUBJECT: Suicide Attempt Inmate Epstein#76318-054
On the above date at approx. I :27am While working in the Special Housing Unit Myself and S/O
heard noise coming from the M tier Cell 124. Upon arrival inmate Epstein's cell mate (Um
was at the door stating I/M Epstein 476318-054 had attempted to hang himself.
I ke t a visual while Officer grabbed door keys and called for assistance. After securing I/M
and removing him from the cell, I entered then placed I/M Epstein on his side and removed
an orange homemade rope from his neck. IIM was breathing at this time, But unresponsive. As I began
chest compressions addition staff and Ops arrived, IIM was then removed from the Special
I-lousing Unit without further incident.
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10639
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010640
DATE: July 23, 2
TO: Operations Li nt,
FROM:
SUBJECT: Inmate Epstein reg# 76318-054
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
On July 23, 2019 at approximately 1:27 AM while assigned to the Special Housing Unit, myself and Senior Officer
Specialist heard some noises coming from M Tier. Upon checking cell Z05-124 I observed inmate Epstein
reg# 76318-054 laying down near his bunk with what appeared to be a piece of handmade orange cloth around his
neck. I immediately called Control Center for staff assistance. Officer kept a visual of inmate Epstein while I
proceeded to retrieve the door keys and the cutter from the main cabinet located in the MPA. Officer applied
restraints to his cell mate inmate . I secured inmate inside the bathroom while
Officer provided assistance to inmate Epstein. When additional staffarrived inmate Epstein was removed from
his cell without further incident.
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010641
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010642
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
July 23, 2019
SUBJEC • '
On July 23, 2019 at approximately 1:27, I. responded to a body alarm on the
Special Housing Unit. While the 9-South officer was conducted rounds inmate Epstein, Jeffrey
#76318-054 was found in his cell with a noose around his neck and appeared to be unresponsive.
I assisted with taking inmate Epstein #76318-054 from his cell and putting him on a stretcher.
The inmate was taken to the second floor and placed on suicide watch, where he was monitored by
staff. Moments afterwards, inmate Epstein became responsive. While observing inmate E stein
he sat u on the bed and began telling me that he think his Bunkie,
tried to kill him. Inmate Epstein also stated that his Bunkie also tried to extort
money from him and stated that if he didn't pay him that he would beat him up. He stated that
this has been going on for a week. I asked inmate Epstein if he told staff about this and he told
me no, that he'd only told his lawyer. He went on to say that his Bunkie told him that if he beat
him up, because of his charges, the officers would not report it and because of this he was not
comfortable telling the officers about the prolong threats and alleged attempts to extort him. I
immediately reported this to the lieutenant.
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010643
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010644
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
DATE: July 23,
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT: Epstein, Jeffrey # 76318-054
At approximately 1:27AM, I responded to a radio transmission asking for staff assistance
on 9 South (Special Housing Unit). Once I was granted access to said unit I made my way to the
location (M Tier) in which the disturbance stemmed from. I was told by Officer that
Epstein, Jeffrey I/M# 76318-054 has attempted to hang himself. Upon arrival to cel!" 124
in which he was housed, I noticed J. Epstein I/M# 76318-054 on the floor and OfficerS
placing restraints on him. Officer and I entered said cell attempting to
assist in said process.
Now that I am inside of the cell I notice that J. Epstein I/M# 76318-054 was snoring on the
floor of his cell, he appeared to be asleep. We made several verbal commands for him to wake up
and attempted to get him to his feet but they were all unsuccessful. After said attempts
a asked for a stretcher to be retrieve to safely remove him out of his cell. Once
stretcher arrived, Officer..., Officer.M and I lifted J. Epstein I/M# 76318-054 off
the floor and placed him on the stretcher. Once we secured him safely on the stretcher, Officers
IM and I lifted J. Epstein I/M# 76318-054 who is now on the stretcher safely out of 9 SouTh
(Special Housing Unit) and into the awaiting elevator.
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010645
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_00010646
UNITEL 'TATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York New Ynrk 10007
July 23, 2019
MEMORANDUM FOR ALL CONCERNED
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Material Handler Supervis
Possible Suicide Attempt
On July 23, 2019 at approx. 1:27 a.m., the Control Center announced a call for
assistance on the Special Housing Unit. Upon my arrival to 9-South, I/M Epstein,
Jeffrey #76318-054 was lying on the floor of his cell handcuffed. I assisted with
carrying inmate Epstein to HA-Unit on a stretcher, where he was dressed in a suicide
smock and placed on Suicide Watch observation with staff.
ASensitive Limited Official Use Only=
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010647
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010648
MCC NEW YORK
NEW YORK, NY
Daily Assignment Roster
Tuesday July 23. 2019
Page 1
6 07:00 .15:00 9 12:00 - 20:00
Post Split Shift 2 00:00 - 08:00 3 06:00 - 14:00 8 08:00 - 16:00 10 14:00 -22:00 12 16:00 00:00
CAPTAIN 6 $
6tC
-6=s
CAPTAIN SEC
OPS LT
ACT LT
2
3 "10S IS
OT
12
ADMIN LT 6
SHU LT ••10 <unassigned>
SIS LT 6 <unassigned>
SIS LT #2 6 <unassigned>
SIA 8 <unassigned>
SIS TECH #1 8 <unassigned>
SIS TECH #2 3
PHONE MONITOR 8
SEC OFFICER #1 3 <unassigned>
SEC OFFICER #2 8 Reyes, d $
TOOL ROOM '16 <unassigned>
SEARCH OFFICER
2 SALLY OFF
3 SALLY OFF
LOBBY
CONTROL #1 a$  8 12 <unassigned>
CONTROL #2
3 10
10
INTERNAL "2
OT IMO 01:30
"12
INTERNAL #2 "12
CT
ATTY CONF "'8
OT
12 I
UNIT 2
UNIT 3
2 8_$ 12 IIII
OT
$ 8 12 5
5 NORTH
OT *-8 12
5 SOUTm $
OT
8 <unassigned> 12
7 NORTH "2
OT
B <unassigned>
7 SOUTH 2 $ "ES 5
OT
12
/ 12
9 NORTH "8
OT
SHU 01 "2 W
OT
12
I
SHU #2 12 <unassigned>
OT OT
SHU #3
(NCI
10
SHU #4
OT
$ "12 <unassigned>
10 SOUTH #1 2 12
10 SOUTH #2 3 <unassigned> "10
OT
7/23/2019 7.02.27 AM
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010649
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10650
Tuesday July 23, 2019
Page 2
REC OFFICER #1
MC OFFICER 02
11 NORTH a I=I
o
-a WM 12
11 SOUTH
;Sy '1 <unassigned> i
11 SOUTH #2 12
REAR GATE
OSP 01 $ $ I $
SANITATION OFF $
VISIT #1
VISIT 02
OT
VISIT 03
****Special Assignments'
EPO OFFICE
ESCORT OFF Al
D $ ESCORT OFF #2
LOBBY #2 g <unassigned>
PHONE RM ai
TOWN DRIVER 10MID
SUICIDE WATCH
OT (NC) 01:30 08:00
8 <unassigned> 12 <unassigned>
**** Back Page Categorise*"
DAY OFF
a tosSICK LEAVE
ANNUAL LEAVE
LWOP
LWOP(M)
AWOL
SUSPENSION
OFFICIAL TIME
7/23/2019 7:02:34 AM
SDNY_00010651
Tuesday July A ale
Pare3
COP
WM ,
IF TRAINING
- Change Records""
Post
TOOL ROOM
Spit Shit Officer
8
Relieved Officer's Relieving Officer's Ret
Now Status Relieving Officer Provious Status Shit Changed By
[Sick / Annual] <Unassigned> 7/14 13:31
[Sick/ Annual] (Removed) 7/14 13:52
CONTROL #2 3 Annual Leave <Unassigned> 7/16 07:54
(sp)PHONE RM 2 8 3 CONTROL *2 <Unassigned> S 7/16 07:54
SHU #1 8 LWOP(M) <Unassigned> S 7/16 09:22
INTERNAL 8 Annual Leave <Unassigned> S 7/180929
INTERNAL 8 <Unassigned> 87 SOUTH 7/1612:07
UNIT 3 2 <Unassigned> EM 5
Shift
UNIT 3
Annual Leave $
Annual Leave
ill S
Y W 7/1718:58
T/CT Stan End
ATTY CONF 8 <Unassigned> MM $
Shift
ATTY CONF
Annual Leave
Annual Leave
III $
Y 7/18 08,00
/CT Start
T
End
7 SOUTH 8 <Unassigned> 2 9 NORTH
s is $
7/18 10:11
T/CT Start End Shift
7 SOUTH
9 NORTH
SHU LT 10 Sick Leave <Unassigned> 7/1810:19
LWOP 8 PHONE RM 2(sp) 7/1611:35
5 SOUTH 2 <Unassigned>
(Inserted NCS) (Sick/Annual)
INTERNAL 2 <Unassigned>
10 SOUTH #2 10 <Unassigned>
ACT LT 10 <Unassigned>
SHU #2 2 <Unassigned>
VISIT #2 9 <Unassigned>
Shift
5 SOUTH
10 SOUTH N1
810 SOUTH #1 Y 7/18 12:10
OT/CT Start End
DT
7/19 10:19
[Sick / Annual] IIIN 7/1910:19
$ Annual Leave
Shift
10 SOUTH #2 IS $
Annual Leave
I S 8 OPS LT
Shift
ACT LT ii  J$
OPS LT ,J$ 12 SHU 04
Shift
SHU #2
IIIIIII $SHU *4
Dubenerie, D $ 3 REC OFFICER #1
Shift
MISR 102 1
$
REC OFFICER #1
`V
FrT/CT
7/19 12:15
Start
QT
End
Y Jr7/21 14:10
MT Stan
•T
End
7/22 08 21
•T/CT Start
T
End
Y RAN 7/22 08:28
OT/CT Start
OT
End
7/23/2019 7:02:35 AM
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10652
Tuesday July 23, 2019
Page 4
Post Spit Shft Officer
Relieved Officers
New Status
VISIT #2 9 $ (Sick / Annual)
[Sick / Annual) $ [Removed]
7 NORTH 2 <Unassigned>
11 NORTH 2 <Unassigned>
(sp}PHONE RM 2 8 Sick Leave
SHU #1 2 <Unassigned>
[Inserted NCS] (Sick/Annual)
SHU #3 3 <Unassigned>
SHU #4 8 <Unassigned>
SHU #1 8 <Unassigned>
SHU #2 8 <Unassigned>
7 NORTH 2 pick /Annual]
(Sick / Annual) [Removed)
9 NORTH 8 <Unassigned>
11 NORTH 8 <Unassigned>
5 NORTH 8 <Unassigned>
INTERNAL #2 2 <Unassigned>
7 NORTH 2 <Unassigned>
VISIT #2 9 <Unassigned>
5 NORTH 2 <Unassigned>
Relieving Officer's Ret
Relieving Officer Previous Status Shft Changed By
<Unassigned> RW 72208:27
RW 7/22 08:27
12 7 NORTH Y RW 72208:34
Shift Staff prim' Start End
7 NORTH OT
7 NORTH
$ Day Off Y RW 7/22 08:45
Shift Staff OT/CT Start End
11 NORTH
I S
OT
Day Off
KR 7/22 09:05
Shift
SHU #1
SHU #1
12 SHU #1 Y PJAI 7/22 09:20
Staff pT/CT Start End
[Sink / Annual)
7/22 09:39
7/22 09:39
2 SANITATION OFF Y R.N 7/22 10:04
Shift Staff OT/CT Start End
SHU #4 OT
SANITATION OFF
7/23/2019 7:02:35 AM
$ 8 SHU #2 RW 72210:19
Shift
SHU #2
Day Off
Day Off
Staff
Y 7/22 10:19
TICT Start T T
End
<Unassigned> RW 722 10:43
RW 7722 10:43
Shift
9 NORTH
UNIT 2
2 UNIT 2 Y
Staff
$
RW 7/22 11.04
OT/CT Start
OT
End
2 11 SOUTH AIR 722 14:34
r 2 5 NORTH MR 7/22 14:37
Shift
INTERNAL #2
Annual Leave
Annual Leave V
Staff
RRW7/22 14:45
OT/CT Start
CT
End
Shift
7 NORTH
Day Off
Day Off Y
Staff
7/22 14:58
T/CT Start
T
End
$ 3 REC OFFICER #1 Y W 7/22 15:28
Shift Staff OT/CT Start End
VISIT #2 OT
REC OFFICER #1
$ 12 UNIT 3 Y MR 7/22 18:12
Shift Staff OT/CT Start End
5 NORTH ■ $ OT
UNIT 3 $
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010653
Tuesday July 23, 2019
Pago 5
r
Post Spit Shft Officer New Status
- - -
Relieving Officer Previous Status Shft C41811Qed By
11 SOUTH 2 <Unassigned> 12 UNIT 2 Y SJ 7/22 1921
Shift 07/C7 Start End
11 SOUTH
if
OT
UNIT 2
INTERNAL 12 <Unassigned> $ 12 SHU 04 SJ 7221922
SHU 02 2 $ (Sick / Annual) <Unassigned> & 7/2221:14
[Sick / Annual) $ (Removed) & 7/22 21:14
SHU 02 2 <Unassigned> 12 INTERNAL 02 Y S, 7/2221:14
Shift 11 OT/Cr Start End
SHU 02 01
INTERNAL 02
5 SOUTH 2 Echandi. M (Sick /Annual) <Unassigned> 11 7/22 22:08
[Sick / Annual) [Removed] 11722 22:08
5 SOUTH 2 <Unassigned> 12 INTERNAL
tall OT/CT
$
$
Y 7/22 22:12
Start
OT
End Shift
5 SOUTH
INTERNAL
Unsoiled NCS) (Sick/Annual]  7/23 04:30
(ap)Suickle Watch 2 <Unassigned> [Sick / Annual) 7/23 C4:31
(sp)Suicide Watch 2 (Time Change]
Shift
Suicide Watch
l'i
el 7/23 04:31
OT/CT Start
OT 01:30
End
08:00
INTERNAL 2 (Time Change]
Shift
INTERNAL
Staff
k 7/23 04:32
0T/CT Start
QT 00:00
End
01:30
11 SOUTH 8 Sick Leave <Unassigned> ik 7/23 05:05
""Recapitulation""
Morning Watch 8
AM Watch 7
Day Watch 23
PM Watch 6
Evening Watch 17
—Back Pago Categories"
Sick Leave 4
Day Off 20
Annual Leave 7
LWOP 1
LWOP(M) 4
AWOL 9
SUSPENSION 1
OFFICIAL TIME 1
COP 2
IF TRAINING 3
Total Correctional Svcs. Staff: 113
Non Correctional Svcs. Staff: 2
Overtime Occurrences: 18
Comptlme Occurrences: I
Ops Lt. Evening Watch Signature:
Captain's Signature:
7/23/2019 7:02:36 AM
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10654
Bureau of Prisons
Health Services
Clinical Encounter
Inmate Name: EPSTEIN, JEFFREY EDWARD
Date of Birth: 01/20/1953
Encounter Date: 07/23/2019 06:20
Reg #: 76318-054
Sex: M Race: WHITE Facility: NYM
Provider: Unit: H01
Injury Assessment - Non-work related encounter performed at Health Services.
SUBJECTIVE:
INJURY 1 Provider: MLP
Date of Injury: 07/23/2019 01:27 Date Reported for Treatment:
Work Related:
Pain Location:
No Work Assignment: UNASSG
Pain Scale: 0
Pain Qualities:
Where Did Injury Happen (Be specific as to location):
Special Housing Unit Z05-Cell 124 L
Cause of Injury (Inmate's Statement of how injury occurred):
1 do not know. Just went to drink a little water and wake up snorting'.
Symptoms (as reported by inmate):
None
OBJECTIVE:
Temperature:
ade Time Fahrenheit  Celsius  Location  Provider
07/23/2019 06:30 NYM 97.5 36.4 Oral MLP
07/23/2019 08:25
Pulse:
DAM Time Rate Per Minute Location  .BMttlam Provider
07/23/2019 06:30 92 Via Machine Regular
Respirations:
Date Time Rate Per Minute  Provider
07/23/2019 06:30 NYM 16 . MLP
Blood Pressure:
Date Time Value Location  Position  Cuff Size Provider
07/23/2019 06:30 NYM 140/85 Right Arm Sitting Adult-regular
SaO2:
S[ t Time Valuer/id  Air Provider
07/23/2019 06:30 NYM 96 Room Air MLP
MLP
MLP
Exam:
General
Affect
Yes: Cooperative
Appearance
Yes: Appears Well, Alert and Oriented x 3
No: Appears Distressed, Lethargic, Dyspneic, Appears in Pain. Pallor, Cyanotic, Diaphoretic, Disheveled,
Generated 0723/201909 05 by MM. MLP Bureau of Prisons - NYM Page 1 of 2
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010655
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010656
Inmate Name: EPSTEIN. JEFFREY EDWARD Reg #: 76318.054
Date of Birth: 01/20/1953 Sex: M Race: WHITE Facility: NYM
Encounter Date: 07/23/2019 06:20 Provider: MLP Unit: H01
Exam:
Acutely Ill
Pulmonary
Auscultation
Yes: Clear to Auscultation, Vesicular Breath Sounds Bilaterally
No: Crackles, Rhonchi, Wheezing
Exam Comments
Inmate for injury report as requested by Operational Lt.
He is ambulatory, oriented x 3. In not apparent distress, smiling during this clinical encounter. Alleges, that he does 
not
know what happened. Can not explain the marks on his neck. Responded: 1 don't know".
He does not want to talk of the events leading to the marks on his neck.
He does not look in any distress or pain.
Has an circular line of erythema at the base of the neck. Reaching 2/3 of the neck circumference, 2 inches wide, sparing
the back of the neck. Has one section of this erythema in the front with marks of friction.
No inflammation, no deformities, no hematomas, no lacerations, no tenderness. Patient moving his neck without any
restriction. Denies having any pain or discomfort. Denies any respiratory problem.
Has another small erythema on left knee about 2cm in diameter(mild).
As per information from custody staff inmate Epstein was found in his cell with a rope around his neck and sitting on 
the
floor.
Inmate is currently placed on suicide watch.
ASSESSMENT:
Injury, unspecified. T1490 - Current - RIO self inflicted injuries.
PLAN:
Disposition:
Follow-up at Sick Call as Needed
Placed on Suicide Watch
Follow-up in 2-4 Hours
Other:
For follow up with psychology service.
Patient Education Topics:
Date Initiated  Format Handout/Topic  provider  Outcome
07/23/2019 Counseling Access to Care Verbalizes
Understanding
07/23/2019 Counseling Plan of Care Verbalizes
Understanding
Copay Required: No Cosign Required: Yes
TelephoneNerbal Order: No
Completed by MLP on 07/23/2019 09:05
Requested to be cosigned by MD.
Cosign documentation will be displayed on the following page.
Generated 07/23/2019 09:05 by MLP Bureau of Prisons - NYM Page 2 of 2
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY 00010657
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt
Date and Time of Incident 07/23/19 - 1:27 AM
Inmate Name/Register Number Epstein, Jeffrey #76318-054
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
1
Special Housing Unit
a , Lieutenant
07/23/19 -1:45 AM
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010658
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt
Date and Time of Incident 07/23.779- 1:27 All
Inmate Name/Register Number Epstein, Jeffrey #76318-054
Location of Incident Special Housing Unit
Photograph(s) by Lieutenant
Date and *lime of Photo 07;23:19-1:45 Adl
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10659
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Tune of Incident
Possible Suicide Attempt
07/23/19- 1:27 AM
Inmate Name/Register Number Epstein, Jeffrey #76318-054
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Special Housing Unit
. Lieutenant
07/23/19 -1:45 AM
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10660
reittenatil .s Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
07/23/19- 1:27 AM
Epstein, Jeffrey #76318-05.1
Special !lousing Unit
, Lieutenant
07,23,19 -1:45 .4.t1
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_00010661
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Timc of Photo
Possible Suicide Attempt
07723 19 1:2' Al!
Epstein, Jeffrey #76318-0.5-1
Special Housing Unit
07/23.19 -1:.15.4.11
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10662
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
r-- Possible Suicide Attempt
07/23/19 1:27,4A/
Epstein. Jeffrey 1176318-054
Special Housing Unit
07 23;19 -1:45 AM
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10663
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
I)atc and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Possible Suicide Attempt
O..23/9 1:27A,11
Epstein, Jeffrey #76318-054
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Special Housing Unit
. Lieutenant
OT 23 • 19 -1:45 AM
.O,0 L.,:
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010664
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
N lite
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
_ Date and Time of Photo
Possible Suicide Attempt
07/23/19 — 1:27 AAtt
Epstein, Jeffrey #76318-054
Special Housing Unit
I . , Lieutenant
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10665
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt(Cellmate)
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
07/23/19- 1:2 7 AM
Special Housing Unit
Photograph(s) by Lieutenant
Date and Time of Photo 07/23/19 -2:25 AM
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10666
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt(Celltnate)
Date and Time of Incident 07/23/19 1:27 AM
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident Special Housing Unit
Photograph(s) by I. , Lieutenant
Date and Time of Photo 07 23/19 -2:25 A.11
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010667
Lieutenant'. (1ilice
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Aueinpt(Cellmate)
Date and Time of Incident 07/23/19 - 1:27 AM
Inmate Name/Register Number  #78514-054
Location of Incident Special Housing Unit
Photograph(s) by I. . Lie:dentin!
Date and Time of Photo rr 23 /9 -2:25 AM
1-v v
SDNY_000 10663
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Possible Suicide Attempt(Cellmate)
07/23/19 - 1:27 AM
Special housing 11th/!
, Lieutenant
07/23/19 -2:25 AM
1;2 Av
(COpy)
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_00010669
Lieurenatult Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt(Cellmate)
Date and Time of Incident 07/23/19 1:27 A.11
Inmate Name/Register Number 478514-054
Location of Incident Special Housing Unit
Photograph(s) by a Lieutenant
Date and Time of Photo 07:23; 19 -2:25 All
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10670
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt(Cellmate)
Date and 'lime of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
07/23/19 - 1:27 AM
Special Housing Unit
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Lieutenant
07/23/19 -2:25 AM
g
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10671
ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION ORDER U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
NEWYORK MCC
InstitutOn
asiomme 07-10-2019
TO Speommonmin humaffires_
FROM (Name/Title)
SUBJECT Placement of EPSTEIN. JEFFERY  . Reg. No.  7-10-2019  in Administrative Detention

(a) Is pending an investigation for a violation of Bureau regulations;
(b) Is pending an SIS investigation

(c) Is pending investigation or trial for a criminal act:
(d) Is to be admitted to Administrative Detention

(I) Since the urinate has requested admission for protection.
I hereby request placement in Adminstrative Detention for my own protection
Inmate Signature/Register No.:
Staff Witness Printed Name Signature'

(2) Since a serious threat exists to indmduars safety as perceived by staff. although person has not requested 
admission. referral of
the necessary information will be forwarded for an appropriate hearing by the SRO

(e) Is pending transfer or is in holdover status during transfer
it  (I) Is pending classification or
Is terminating confinement in Disciplinary Segregation and has been ordered into Administrative Detention by the 
Warden's
designee.
Kis this Correctional Supervisors decision based on all the circumstances that the above named inmates continued 
presence in the general
population poses a serious threat to life. properly. self, staff. other inmates. or to the secunty or orderly running of
the institution because
PENDING CLASSIFICATION
Therefore, the above named inmate is to be placed In Administrative Detention until further notice. The inmate received 
a copy of Iris Order on
(dale/ time)  - t
StallWitness Signature/Printed Name
Supervisor 24 hour review of placement: Signature/Printed name
' In the case of OHO anon, reference to that order is sufficient. In other cases. the Correctional supervisor wit make 
an independent review and decision, wnich
is
documented here.
Record Copy • Inmate Concerned (not necessary if placement is a result of holdover status): Copy • Captain. Copy - Unit 
Manager: Copy - Oper
- Administrative Detention Unit: Copy — Psychology. Copy - Central File
'COPY
PDF Prescribed by P5270 (Replaces BP-A0308 of JAN 88) Isli et
1 6
Date  / C 5 " ?
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_000 10672
INCIDENT REPORT
J.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS

1. institution' ' MCC New York
27Inmates Name:
Epstein , Jeffery
S. Place of Incident:
SEW M-Tier Cell 124

9. Incident: Self -Mutilation
Part I — Incident Report
Incident Report Numbe
3. Register Number:
76318-054

7. Assignment
Unassigned
4. Date of Inciden
07/23/2019 1:27am
. Unit:
ZA
1 10. Prohibited Act Code (S)r 228

11. Desaiption of Incident (Date: 07/23/2019 Time: 1:27AM Stall became aware of incident):
On July 23.2019 at approx. 1:27am While working in the S ecial Housing Unit Myself and 5/0 lEheard noise corning from 
the M tier cell 124 Upon arrival um's
Epstein.Jefferylt76318.054 cell mate (UM as at the door  slating UM Epstein.Jeff 76318-054 had attempted to hang himself
I kept a visual while 5/0 rabbed I ie
oor teys an ca for assistance. After Sec—urine- 9M wand removing him from the calif entered-then placed pstein on his 
side and removed a orange homemade rope
from his n . wasbreathing at thusBut unresponsive. Addition staff and 0 s rrived UM was then removed from SHU

12. Typed Name Employee: 13. Date And Time
14. Incident Repot Inmate by (Type Name 15. Date InJ ent Repon Delivered:
07/23/2019 3:30am

18. Time Incident Report Delivered:
Part II — Committee Action
17. Comments of Inmate to Committee Regarding Above Incident:

18. A. It is the finding of the committee that you:
Committed the Prohibited Act as charged:
Did not Commit a Prohibited Act.
Committed Prohibited Act Code (s).

B.  1   The Committee is referring the Charge(s) to the OHO for further Heargia_,
C I I The Committee advised the inmate of its finding and of the right to Me an appeal within 20 calendar days.

19. Committee Decision is Based on Specific Evidence as Follows:
20. Committee action and/or recommendation if referred to OHO (Contingent upon DHO finding inmate committed proNbited 
act):

21. Date and Time of Action:  (The UDC Chairmanws signature certifies who sat on the UDC and that the completed report 
accurately reflects the UDC proceedings).
airman (Typed Name/Signature). Member (Typed Name): Member ( fyped Name):
INS1RUCT IONS: All items outside of heavy rule are for staff use only. Begin entries with the number 1 and work up. 
Entnes not completed wilt be voided by
staff.
DisInbule: Onginal.Central File Record: COPY-WHO COPY.2-Inniate after UDC Action. COPY 3.Inniale within 24 hours of Part
I Preparation
PDF
CONFIDENTIAL
Presuibed by P5270 Replaces BP-A0288 of AUG 11
SONY_000 10673
Part III - Investigation 22. Date And Time Investigation Began

23. Inmate Advised Of Right To Remain Silent: You are advised of your right to remain silent at all
stages of the discipline process. Your silence may be used to draw an adverse inference against you
at any stage of the discipline process. Your silence alone may not be used to support a finding
that you have committed a prohibited act.
The Inmate Was Advised Of The Above Right By   At (Date/time)

24. Inmate statement and attitude
25. Other facts about the incident, statements of those persons present at scene, disposition of
evidence, etc.
26. investigator's comments and conclusions
27. Action taken
Date and Time Investigation Completed
Printed Name/Signature Of Investigator 7ith:
PDF
CONFIDENTIAL
Prescribed by P5270 Replaces BP-S288 052 Of MAY 94
SDNY_00010674
~oP _ Air
/e9 / a..// IA/ k i k et,
7-43/4
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010675

╭──────────── Page 44, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ | ~                                      │
│                                          │
│ ~                                        │
│                                          │
│ 1 Lega! Cin light a€ Evesst ws Zettai am │
│ Dadi -/8                                 │
│                                          │
│ A igs                                    │
│                                          │
│ tal                                      │
│                                          │
│ CONFIDENTIAL                             │
│                                          │
│ ‘SDNY_00010675                           │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────╯

Bureau of Prisons
Health Services
Clinical Encounter
Inmate Name: Reg tt: 78514-054
Date of Birth: Sex: M Race: WHITE Facility: NYM
Encounter Date: 07/31/2019 14:11 Provider: PA-C Unit: Z06
Mid Level Provider - Evaluation encounter performed at Special Housing Unit.
SUBJECTIVE:
COMPLAINT 1 Provider: PA-C
Chief Complaint: No Complaint(s)
Subjective: "I feel good today, can't complain. My anxiety is getting better and I have no side effect from
the new anxiety medication"
IM being seen in the SHU as per the request of lieutenants.
States he's been doing well and has no acute complaints.
For what happened to his previous cell mate about a week ago, states "I have no idea what
was going on. I didn't do anything and I have no injury"
Pain: No
OBJECTIVE:
Pulse:
pate Time Rate Per Minute  Location &Winn Provider
07/31/2019 14:19 71 Via Machine PA-C
Respirations:
Date Time Rate Per Minute  ProvideC
07/31/2019 14:19 NYM 15 PA-C
Blood Pressure:
Date lime Value Location Position Cuff Size Provider
07/31/2019 14:19 NYM 118/70 Left Arm Sitting Adult-regular PA-C
SaO2:
Date Time ValuefToi Air Provider
07/31/2019 14:19 NYM 98 Room Air PA-C
Exam Comments
General: AAOx3. NAD
HEENT: PERRLA. EOMI. Nares patent.
Neck: Supple
Heart: S1, S2. RRR
Lungs: CTAB
EXT: No edema.
Neuro: Grossly normal CN
ASSESSMENT:
Encounter for general adult medical exam without abnormal findings, Z0000 - Current
PLAN:
Disposition:
Follow-up at Sick Call as Needed
Other:
Generated 07/31/2019 14:39 by PA-C Bureau of Prisons- NYM Page 1 of 2
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_00010676
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_00010677
Inmate Name: 1 Reg #: 78514.054
Date of Birth: 10110/1967 M Race: WHITE Facility: NYM
Encounter Date: 07/31/2019 14:11 Provider: Unit: Z06
IM states he feels as himself and denies being in acute distress.
Patient Education Topics:
Date Initiated  Format Handout/Topic
07/31/2019 Counseling Access to Care
Copay Required: No Cosign Required: Yes
TelephoneNerbal Order: No
Completed by -PA-C on 07/31/2019 14:39
Requested to be cosigned by MD.
Cosign documentation will be displayed on the following page.
Generated 07/31/2019 14:39 by PA•C
Provider
MEM
Outcome
Verbalizes
Understanding
Bureau of Prisons • NYM Page 2 of 2
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00010678
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                               Efrain Reyes [crime] Epstein's cellmate at MCC 
 Nicholas Tartaglione [crime] former NYPD, convicted of drug trafficking and murder, Epstein cell mate at MCC 
 Konstantin Ignatov [russian girl] OneCoin fraud, brother of billionaire crypto fugitive Ruja Ignatova [wiki] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00108533 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons roster of inmates at Metropolitan Correctional Center
(date: 2019-07-23)
acnicia 1 NYMD9 530*07 *
PAGE 001
FUNCTION: R-P
ZERO/NBR: NO
OPTION:
DUP SUPR: YES
COLUMNS 1: REG 2:
CONDITIONS (GRP 1)
CMCI NE G
CMCI NE P
G TOT
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
POPULATION MONITORING CENSUS/ROSTER • 07-23-2019
GENERALIZED RETRIEVAL • 04:04:37
SELECTION CATEGORY: QTR EQ ALL
ORGANIZATION: FACL EQ NYM
TYPE OF FACILITY: TOF EQ T
FACILITY MANAGED BY: FMB EQ AP
LN 3: LN2 4: FN 5: ARSD 6: ARS 7: 8:
SEQ: 234 NP:
JUDG: C SORT COL: COL SEQ:
OR CONDITIONS (GRP 2) OR CONDITIONS (GRP 3) OR CONDITIONS (GRP 4)
766 740 26
-W- -El- -0-
401 348 2 15 309 457
NYMD9 530*07
PAGE 002
* ROSTER * 07-23-2019
04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
I05N I05 -936L 85828-054 ABERHANTE ANNEL 12-11-2018 A-HLD
G118 G11 -783U 86957-054 ACOSTA-LIRIANO JUANCARLOS 06-13-2019 A-PRE
EOIN E01 -502U 86640-054 ACOSTA -SALAZAR ABEL 03-05-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-026L 29116-379 ACOSTA -VENTURA LINCOLN 04-04-2019 A-PRE
E078 507-5540 25404-038 ADAMS GARY 05-20-2019 A-DES
E118 E11 -588U 49259-054 ADAMS RAMON 06-04-2019 A-DES
El2S E12-594U 14340-067 ADAMS RICHARD 01-14-2019 A-DES
K02N K02-115U 85564-054 AGUDELO-AGUDELO ORLANDO 10-31-2018 A-PRE
GO6N G06 -743L 74458-053 AGUILAR EUDALDO 04-29-2019 A-HLD
K10S K10-043L 85650-053 AL-HAMIDI ALI 01-10-2019 A-PRE
G09S G09 -768U 93031-083 ALEXANDER BARRY 07-02-2019 A-PRE
2078 Z07-305LAD 77704-054 ALIMEHMETI SAJMIR 11-27-2018 A-HLD
E08S E08-5640 27933-055 ALLS RODNEY 06-24-2019 A-DES
K095 K09-036L 85978-054 ALMANZAR NELSON 07-26-2018 A-PRE
KO6N K06-148L 86049-054 ALVAREZ CARLOS 01-22-2019 A-PRE
GO1N GO1-708U 77312-054 ANDREWS CHRISTOPHE 07-02-2019 A-PRE
E09S E09-565L 79767-054 ANGEVINE JAQUAN 08-03-2018 A-DES
GO5N 005-740L 90118-053 ANTNEY JOHAN 01-28-2019 A-PRE
GO9S G09-765U 86374-054 ANTONIUS STEVEN 11-30-2018 A-PRE
E03N E03-5230 86434-054 APSKALNS MARTINS 12-21-2018 A-PRE
BO1A 801-215U 86821-054 ARAMBUL DALIA 04-16-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04 -930U 91126-053 ARAUJO GUSTAVO 10-18-2018 A-PRE
E07S E07-5500 90522-054 ARDILA RANDOLPH 04-23-2019 A-DES
EO1N E01-5010 85794-054 ARIAS MINEL 05-06-2019 A-PRE
206A Z06-217UAD 79562-054 ARMENTA GILBERT 07-19-2019 A-PRE
ZO3A Z03-112LAD 86123-054 ARROYO ANGEL 04-24-2019 A-PRE
I01N I01-9050 85885-053 ARTIS SOLOMAN 05-28-2015 A-PRE
Z078 Z07-302LAD 91782-053 ASAINOV RUSLAN 07-19-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-0030 72419-019 ASHU CYRIL 05-29-2019 A-PRE
204A Z04-212LAD 86710-054 AVILA PATRICK 03-13-2019 A-PRE
KOIN K01-1060 86953-054 AYALA RICARDO 06-12-2019 A-PRE
GO3N G03-721L 94890-038 AYBAR GERONIMO 11-01-2018 A-PRE
GO6N G06-741L 86268-054 AYLLON HOWARD 01-29-2019 A-HLD
KO6N K06-1410 76157-054 BARROW LORENZO 10-19-2018 A-PRE
E04N E04-532L 77128-054 BALDE SOULEYMANE 01-18-2019 A-PRE
Z04A 204-210LAD 79781-054 BALDEO HAKEEM 06-24-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-0620 77863-112 BANG CHI 04-23-2019 A-PRE
GllS G11-785L 85714-054 BANKS EARL 07-22-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-077L 86820-054 BARBER BYRON 04-16-2019 A-PRE
E07S E07-551L 61881-054 BARNETT LATSEN 12-17-2018 A-DES
K078 K07-0080 23789-057 BARRERA ESTABAN 07-18-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04 -929U 45655-054 BARRIENTOS RENE 02-28-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-2100 86154-054 BATISTA SAMANTHA 09-28-2018 A-PRE
KO4N K04-1270 85858-054 BATURI MUBARAK 02-08-2019 A-HLD
801A B01-209L 71423-018 BAUTA ELIANA 04-16-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMD9 530*07
PAGE 003
* ROSTER * 07-23-2019
04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
I06N I06-947U 86463-054 BENJAMIN LUIDJI 01-07-2019 A-HLD
E075 E07-554U 11608-082 BENJAMIN SEBASTIAN 07-08-2019 A-DES
E08S E08-560L 25001-052 BENNETT EDWARD 01-22-2019 A-DES
I06N I06-946L 86721-054 BERNCS PAVELS 07-16-2019 A-HLD
K05N KOS-13SL 92404-054 BETTIS ZUBEARU 07-03-2019 A-HLD
206A Z06-214UAD 70897-054 BINYARD EDWARD 04-24-2019 A-PRE
K11S K11-060L 71246-054 BLACKWELL TAYSHAWN 07-16-2019 A-HLD
202A 202-203LAD 79407-054 BLADES CHRISTAN 08-17-2017 A-HLD
K12S K12-072U 86403-054 BLANCHE NAZAE 03-13-2019 A-PRE
G09S G09-767L 24301-052 BOARIU MARCEL 07-02-2019 A-HLD
K12S K12-067U 86884-054 BOKOV JEVGENI 05-09-2019 A-PRE
E01N E01-506L 50501-054 BOOTH RONNELL 06-05-2019 A-PRE
K11S K11-056U 79593-054 BRADFORD DAVID 04-17-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-035U 86412-054 BRAHAM DARIEL 12-12-2018 A-PRE
K12S K12-070U 72612-067 BRANT JOSEPH 07-03-2019 A-PRE
E085 E08-563L 15015-055 BRENON TIMOTHY 07-22-2019 A-DES
E06N E06 -547L 76309-054 BRIGHT PETER 05-23-2019 A-PRE
K05N K05-139U 76269-054 BRISSETT JAMAL 03-13-2019 A-PRE
K04N K04-125U 86857-054 BRITO MAXIMILIAN 04-26-2019 A-HLD
206A 206-213UAD 86460-054 BROCK MARK 01-04-2019 A-PRE
E11S E11-581L 85410-054 BROWN ALLEN 03-18-2019 A-DES
E08S E08-564U 70786-050 BROWN CHAD 07-08-2019 A-DES
GI2S G12-793L 19278-104 BROWN JOHN 03-11-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-003L 81131-053 BROWN KAREEN 07-20-2016 A-PRE
G011.1 G01-703U 83053-053 BROWN MICHAEL 07-02-2019 A-PRE
K04N K04-131L 12750-054 BROWN MICHAEL 06-05-2018 A-PRE
K07S K07-010L 87035-054 BROWN RAKIM 07-19-2019 A-PRE
G01N G01 -707U 66351-054 BRUEN DUANE 06-24-2019 A-HLD
E10S E10 -573U 17190-052 BRUNNER KENNETH 12-17-2018 A-DES
E02N E02 -512U 86489-054 BRYANT WARREN 01-10-2019 A-PRE
E12S E12 -593U 57297-083 BUCHANAN JOHN 07-08-2019 A-DES
805N E05 -535L 86409-054 BULLOCK CHRISTOPHE 12-12-2018 A-PRE
E11S E11 -582L 11729-082 BUNCH JASON 01-14-2019 A-DES
K06N K06-147U 86792-054 BURGOS ANTONIO 05-31-2019 A-HLD
G08S GOB -758U 68456-298 BURGOS-CABADA JOSE 05-08-2018 A-PRE
E01N E01-506U 55210-053 BUSSEY JAVON 04-03-2019 A-PRE
G07S G07 -750U 86554-054 BUTLER DENARD 01-30-2019 A-PRE
KO1N K01-101U 86919-054 BUTLER RAHSAAN 05-24-2019 A-PRE
IO2N I02-911U 86630-054 BUTLER TUREAN 02-28-2019 A-HLD
K03N K03-12311 85984-054 CABA BATISTA HECTOR 08-27-2018 A-PRE
K03N K03-117L 85981-054 CABA BATISTA LUIS 08-27-2018 A-PRE
E02N E02-509U 85706-054 CABAN SAMMUEL 05-17-2018 A-HLD
E11S E11-585U 65759-050 CABRERA CHRISTIAN 07-08-2019 A-DES
G03N G03-719U 79701-054 CABRERA JOHN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
G09S G09-766L 89972-053 CALABRIA JOSEPH 09-26-2018 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMD9 530.07 •
PAGE 004
ROSTER
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG  LN
EOIN E01-503L 23513-053
IO2N IO2-912L 86115-054
GOIN G01-705L 79355-054 K09S K09-035L 86566-054
E08S E08-561U 86052-054 KO7S K07-002U 41682-054 E05N E05-5370 67687-050
GO5N G05-736U 86509-054
KI1S K11-056U 86951-054 BOLA B01-202L 76049-054 KO7S K07-00713 86996-054
I05N I05-938L 00633-748 KO2N K02-115U 77281-054 BOLA B01-219U 54630-479 E03N E03-518L 76139-054 K1OS K10-037L 79458-054 
E02N E02-514U 76276-054
GO7S G07-753L 86164-054
K106 K10-046L 85942-054 I03N I03-921U 90859-053 ElOS E10-573L 90370-053
I03N I03-920U 85467-054
IOIN I01-901U 86113-054 E01N E01-501L 83736-053 GOBS G08-757L 78548-054
KOIN K01-108L 76218-054
KO2N K02-116L 86765-054
E01N E01-504L 67319-054 GO3N G03-719L 75605-054 KO5N K05-134U 86110-054
E12S E12-593U 68683-066
EllS E11-582U 70675-054
E02N E02-511U 86712-054
G12S G12-79313 79046-054
G123 G12-795U 86959-054
E03N E03-524U 86700-054 G1OS G10-779U 89520-053 E07S E07-549L 92299-054 KO2N K02-113U 86655-054
K1OS K10-047U 14661-479 E03N E03-522U 76280-054
GO2N G02-711L 85804-054
E075 E07-554U 86341-054 KO2N K02-113L 15051-053
G12S G12-792U 85632-054
CALABRIA
CALDERON
CAMACHO
CAMILO-POLANCO CAPELLAN
CARABELLO
CARABUS
CARDONA-CARDONA
CARRASCO
CARRILLO
CARRILLO
CASTELLE CASTILLO
CASTILLO-RODRIGUEZ
CASTILLO-ROSARIO CASTILO
CASTRO CAVE
CAZAREZ
CHACON
CHAN
CHAN BAYARDO
CHARDON
CHARLES
CHERRY
CHERRY
CHERRY
CHRISTIAN CIFUENTES-VILLA CITRONELLE
CLARK
CLARKE
COLDS
COLLAZO
COLLINS
CONLEY
CONTRERAS
COOPER
CORLEY
CORONADO-LOZANO CORREA-YUSTY
COTTO
COTTO COTTON CROOKS
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
FN
MICHAEL
JUAN FERDINAND
JUAN
BRIAN
FRED
ALIN
DAVID
ALBERTO
CINDY
JONATHAN
EUGENE JUAN LIUDMYLA
GABRIEL
FELIX RICHARD
ETHAN
CORNELIO
JOSE
MICHAEL
MAURICO
MILTON NALERTON
DAVID
ERIC ROBERT
RAYMOND HILEEBRAND GEORGE
ROBERT
WAYNE
JALEN
HIRAM
VANCE
DWAYNE
JHONNY
MATTHEW ANTHONY
MARCO
WILMER
EDDIE
JOSHUA MELVIN ALFRED
• 07-23-2019
04:04:37
ARSD  ARS
02-22-2017 A-PRE
09-12-2018 A-HLD
02-16-2018 A-HLD
06-07-2019 A-PRE
07-15-2019 A-DES
01-04-2019 A-HLD
07-10-2019 A-HLD
04-29-2019 A-PRE
06-12-2019 A-PRE 01-30-2019 A-HLD
07-03-2019 A-HLD
06-19-2019 A-PRE
05-09-2019 A-PRE
06-12-2019 A-HLD 02-01-2019 A-PRE
05-10-2019 A-PRE 05-20-2019 A-PRE
10-02-2018 A-PRE
07-19-2018 A-PRE
06-21-2018 A-HLD
03-26-2019 A-DES
07-10-2019 A-PRE
09-12-2018 A-PRE
05-07-2019 A-PRE
11-09-2018 A-HLD
07-08-2019 A-PRE
03-28-2019 A-PRE
08-22-2014 A-HLD
03-15-2019 A-PRE 09-12-2018 A-PRE 02-15-2019 A-DES
01-31-2019 A-DES
03-13-2019 A-PRE
05-02-2019 A-PRE
06-13-2019 A-PRE
03-20-2019 A-PRE
02-20-2018 A-PRE 05-20-2019 A-DES 03-08-2019 A-PRE
12-04-2017 A-PRE
04-03-2019 A-PRE
05-23-2019 A-PRE
07-02-2019 A-DES 05-29-2019 A-HLD
07-03-2019 A-HLD
NYMD9 530+07 *
PACE 005
GRP. SPECIFIC. REG
K02N K02-115U 86972-054
E05N 205-5340 76258-054
GO9S G09-7710 91662-053
2095 E09-568U 89936-053
El2S E12-589L 77306-054
I06N I06-948L 86725-054
KO5N K05-1330 76256-054
KO6N K06-144L 86548-054
K08S K08-0220 85928-054
Kl2S K12-0720 79647-054
SOGN 206-5420 89380-053
K125 K12-0630 86427-054
K03N K03-122U 19435-104
G01N GO1-706L 76167-054
2075 207-555L 16520-055
K125 K12-0670 86828-054
K08S K08-018L 85417-054
EllS E11-582U 79251-054
K02N K02-116U 76278-054
E12S E12-593L 05386-090
GOIN G01-706U 86132-054
K02N K02-1120 86830-054
I04N I04-928U 76300-054
E09S 209-5650 55381-066
E08S E08-5640 89424-053
K09S K09-034L 79491-054
KO1N K01-1010 78018-054
202A 202-203LAD 77930-054
K03N K03-117U 86248-054
K09S K09-0300 76156-054
K08S K08-023U 71471-054
205A 205-121LDS 72042-066
KOIN K01-102L 86805-054
E07S E07-5490 60685-050
201A 201-102LAD 86214-054
BO1A 801-216L 76187-054
EO1N E01-505L 77665-054
Kl2S K12-0650 86764-054
GO7S G07-7550 79949-054
ZOIA 201-103UAD 86124-054
IO2N IO2-916L 72418-019
G01N GO1-703L 90791-054
G01N GO1-7010 86079-054
K04N K04-1310 86282-054
E098 E09-569U 78965-054
ROSTER
LN
CRUZ PIMENTEL
CUEVAS
CUMMINGS
CUYLER
DANSOWAH
DARAND
DAVILA
DAVIS
DAVIS
DAVIS
DAVIS
DAVIS
DE FREITAS
DE LA CRUZ
DECAPUA
DEL CARMEN
DEL ORBE LUNA
DELACRUZ
DELAROSA
DELATORRE
DELEON
DELOSANTOS
DEMANE DEBIH
DESILVA
DHANNA
DIAZ
DIAZ
DIAZ
DIAZ-HERNANDEZ
DIAZ-MORALEZ
DIAZ-PALMER
DIAZ-TORRES
DISLA
DOCKERY
DONES
DREIKSENA
DUMES
DUNCAN
DUPREY-VASQUEZ
DURANT
EKE
ELANSKY
ELIAS
ELLISON
EMILIEN
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
07-23-2019
04:04:37
FN  ARSD  ARS
NELSON 06-20-2019 A-HLD
JAVIER 01-24-2019 A-PRE
JASON 06-28-2019 A-PRE
KEVIN 03-27-2019 A-DES
FRANKLIN 12-12-2018 A-DES
ROLANDO 03-20-2019 A-PRE
ARMANDO 01-17-2019 A-PRE
DARIUS 01-25-2019 A-PRE
GARY 07-13-2018 A-PRE
GARY 10-16-2017 A-PRE
HOWARD 09-27-2018 A-PRE
KAREEM 12-19-2018 A-PRE
FABIO 02-12-2019 A-PRE
DIONICIO 10-05-2018 A-PRE
BRANDON 02-25-2019 A-DES
DERIAN 04-18-2019 A-PRE
WINSTON 02-28-2018 A-PRE
HECTOR 07-08-2019 A-DES
AMADO 04-03-2019 A-PRE
PAUL 12-17-2018 A-DES
OMAR 06-25-2019 A-HLD
MARIO 04-18-2019 A-PRE
MARC 07-02-2019 A-PRE
MICHAEL 01-14-2019 A-DES
ANDRE 07-19-2019 A-HLD
ALEXIS 09-04-2018 A-PRE
JOSE 08-10-2016 A-HLD
ROBERT 01-04-2019 A-PRE
AUGUSTIN 10-25-2018 A-PRE
VICTOR 05-23-2019 A-PRE
OMAR 11-01-2018 A-PRE
MISAEL 01-23-2019 A-DES
JOSE 04-11-2019 A-HLD
MARTIN 04-29-2019 A-DES
MANOLO 01-16-2019 A-HLD
SANTA 06-21-2018 A-PRE
CHRISTIAN 11-29-2018 A-HLD
KARL 03-28-2019 A-PRE
HECTOR 04-04-2019 A-PRE
LAVELL 09-18-2018 A-HLD
IFEANYI 05-29-2019 A-PRE
MICHAEL 07-16-2019 A-PRE
MARCUS 02-04-2019 A-PRE
ANTHONY 11-06-2018 A-PRE
ANDRE 03-15-2019 A-DES
NYMD9 530*07 *
PAGE 006
GRP. SPECIFIC. REG
G11S G11-788U 76263-054
E05N E05-539L 78107-054
KO1N K01-108U 86975-054
HO1A HO1-001L 76318-054
EMS E11-582U 25383-014
206A Z06-214UAD 86918-054
I04N I04-932L 81357-053
KO5N K05-136U 76275-054
E04N E04-525U 86846-054
201A 201-105LAD 86102-054
GO6N G06-748L 86626-054
K09S K09-025U 51702-069
I05N I05-933L 86404-054
IO1N I01-903L 90863-053
ElOS E10-573L 60103-380
G11S G11-785U 86226-054
ZO1A 201-108LAD 85775-054
G11S G11-784L 78341-054
GO6N G06-743U 34814-054
EllS E11-582U 64006-037
205A Z05-123UDS 78002-054
G1OS G10-777L 86824-054
KO2N K02-114U 76268-054
K1OS K10-038L 78695-054
E03N 503-519U 92339-054
E07S E07-554U 79793-054
G02N G02-714U 85707-054
GO8S G08-760L 86993-054
G1OS G10-778L 86800-054
IO2N I02-915U 73822-053
KO1N KO1-103U 86954-054
GO2N G02-716L 90774-053
EOBS E08-561L 59632-053
KO3N K03-121L 90462-053
E095 E09-571L 71121-050
I05N I05-934U 64593-054
G11S G11-787U 76243-054
G08S 008-764U 86368-054
KO6N K06-143U 76195-054
ZO2A Z02-204LAD 75885-054
I06N I06-942U 91182-054
G09S G09-767U 76320-054
E05N E05-533L 85918-054
I04N I04-925L 76162-054
I05N I05-935U 90914-054
ROSTER
LN
ENCARNACION
ENGLISH
EPPS
EPSTEIN
ESCARRAMAN
ESPINAL
ESPINAL-GOMEZ
ESTEBAN
ESTEVEZ
ESTEVEZ
ESTEVEZ-GONZALEZ
ESTRADA-RODRIGUEZ
ETHERIDGE
FANFAN
FAVELA
FELIPE
FELIX
FELIZ
FELTON
FERGUSON
FERNANDEZ
FERNANDEZ
FERNANDEZ
FERNANDEZ
FERNANDEZ-ROSA
FERRER
FERTIDES
FEVERIE
FIGUEROA
FIGUEROA
FIGUEROA
FLORES
FLORES
FLORES-CACHO
FLOYD
FOSTER
FRASCO
FUENTES
GAITHER
GALAN
GALLICCHIO
GALVEZ-CHIMBO
GAMA-PINEDA
GANAN RAMIREZ
GARCIA
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
FN
JESUS
CLAUDIUS
KEVIN
JEFFREY
ELIAS
GYANCARLO
JOSE ARNUL
OMAR
BRANDON
STEVEN
CARLOS
RAYMOND
TYHEEM
JIMMY
FELICIANO
JOHN
KERRY
RICHARD
JAMES
LAMONT
HENRY
LEONARDO
LUIS
MARK
HECTOR
GREGORY
YASMIL
JANSON
ANGEL
BENJAMIN
CHARLES
ISRAEL
MARKO
ALEJANDRO
DISHAWN
TOSHNELLE
AGUSTIN
MIGUEL
KEVON
CARLOS
VITO
ROBER
JOSE
CARLOS
BRIAN
07-23-2019
04:04:37
ARSD  ARS
02-08-2019 A-PRE
05-15-2018 A-HLD
06-22-2019 A-PRE
07-08-2019 A-PRE
08-20-2018 A-DES
05-23-2019 A-PRE
05-16-2019
03-21-2019
04-24-2019
09-05-2018
02-28-2019
04-04-2019
12-11-2018
10-03-2018
09-11-2018
03-28-2019
04-23-2019 A-HLD
03-05-2019 A-HLD
06-24-2019 A-HLD
06-24-2019 A-DES
06-27-2018 A-DES
05-06-2019 A-PRE
03-13-2019 A-PRE
02-21-2019 A-HLD
02-05-2015 A-PRE
03-28-2019 A-DES
08-20-2018 A-PRE
07-02-2019 A-PRE
07-19-2019 A-PRE
02-13-2019 A-PRE
06-12-2019 A-HLD
12-07-2018 A-PRE
03-11-2019 A-DES
02-06-2018 A-PRE
05-15-2019 A-DES
05-06-2019 A-HLD
12-06-2018 A-PRE
11-29-2018 A-HLD
04-16-2019 A-HLD
03-05-2019 A-HLD
01-17-2019 A-HLD
07-12-2019 A-PRE
05-30-2019 A-HLD
05-28-2019 A-HLD
05-01-2019 A-PRE
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-DES
A-HLD
NYMD9 530'07 ' ROSTER
PAGE 007
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG
GlOS G10-7760 86878-054
ZO5A Z05-119LAD 86290-054
KO4N K04-132U 77823-054
K02N K02-1090 79043-054
012S G12 -789U 91359-053
GO6N G06-7470 79792-007
K02N K02-1160 86933-054
KO8S K08-0160 86325-054
GO1N G01 -705U 86292-054
El2S E12-596U 81342-053
E09S E09-567U 79460-054
E03N E03-522L 73746-298
KO3N K03-122L 53634-424
ZO3A 203-116UAD 86825-054
KOES K08-013L 86021-054
GO8S 008-762U 78715-054
ZO4A Z04-212LAD 86617-054
ElOS E10-579L 15657-179
K125 K12-062L 86097-054
E06N E06 -548L 79984-054
KO1N K01-105L 71628-054
GO3N 003-723L 79486-054
KO3N K03-120L 75954-054
ZO4A Z04-207LAD 23152-014
205A Z05-123LAD 76161-054
GO9S 009-766U 76229-054
Kl2S K12-072L 85835-054
007S 007-749U 86639-054
ZO3A Z03-115UAD 70887-054
ElOS E10-5750 90504-053
E03N E03-520U 76231-054
K075 K07-007L 85966-054
E04N E04-52713 37897-054
IO2N IO2-914L 86114-054
G05N GOS-733L 08820-070
005N 005-733U 79465-054
IO1N I01-902L 86256-054
K09S K09-025L 86317-054
E07S E07-54913 84831-054
ZO6A 206-217LAD 86562-054
011S G11 -787L 85796-054
GO3N G03 -722U 76151-054
E085 E08 -564U 21066-014
E12S E12-595L 50645-037
E02N E02 -516L 86988-054
LN
GARCIA
GARCIA
GARCIA
GARCIA-PENA
GASS
GEBREMARIAM
GEORGE
GIL
GIL-CABRAL
GOBA
GODBOLD
GOMEZ
GOMEZ-LATOREE
GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ
GONZALEZ-SOLIZ
GOSWAMI
GOULDBOURNE
GRANADOS-CORONA
GRANDE
GRANDY
GRAY
GRAYSON
GREEN
GREENWOOD
GRIFFIN
GRIFFIN
GRULLAR
GUILLEN
GUILLEN
GULIJEV
GUO
GUPTA
GUZMAN
GUZMAN-CASTILLO
HADDOW
HAILEY
HALEY
HALL
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
FN
DAVID
JACINTO
JOSUE
PEDRO
JUSTIN
BEREKET
WILLIAM
CESAR
JUAN
YOUSEF
RONALD
JESUS
FERNANDO
DANIEL
GODOPREDO
JAIME
MARCOS
OSMAR
PETER
RICO
TEODORO
JOSE
VIJAY
MARK
EPRAIN
ARTHUR
CLARENCE
KARL
MARK
RAYQUTAN
KARL
LAMAR
RODNEY
WILLIAM
GABRIEL
WILSON
MIRAGA
QIANG
RONNISH
RANDY
BERNARDO
RENWICK
CARL
ANDRE
STEVEN
* 07-23-2019
04:04:37
ARSD  ARS
05-02-2019 A-HLD
07-08-2019 A-HLD
09-20-2018 A-PRE
03-05-2019 A-PRE
12-21-2018 A-PRE
07-16-2019 A-PRE
06-05-2019 A-HLD
11-14-2018 A-HLD
11-08-2018 A-PRE
06-24-2019 A-DES
01-03-2019 A-DES
03-26-2019 A-PRE
01-04-2019 A-PRE
04-18-2019 A-PRE
08-30-2018 A-PRE
02-13-2017 A-HLD
06-24-2019 A-HLD
08-21-2017 A-DES
07-12-2019 A-HLD
03-26-2019 A-HLD
06-18-2019 A-PRE
03-23-2018 A-PRE
07-19-2019 A-PRE
05-07-2019 A-PRE
04-26-2018 A-PRE
10-11-2018 A-PRE
01-29-2019 A-PRE
03-05-2019 A-PRE
05-30-2018 A-HLD
05-24-2019 A-DES
10-19-2018 A-PRE
01-09-2019 A-PRE
04-03-2018 A-PRE
10-05-2018 A-HLD
05-13-2019 A-HLD
06-06-2019 A-HLD
02-15-2019 A-HLD
11-14-2018 A-PRE
12-26-2018 A-DES
06-25-2019 A-HLD
07-10-2019 A-PRE
06-01-2019 A-PRE
06-03-2019 A-DES
05-20-2019 A-DES
07-01-2019 A-PRE
NYMD9 530*07 *
'PAGE 008
ROSTER * 07-23-2019
04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
E05N E05-5390 87014-054 HARGROVE JAKEEM 07-11-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-0610 86771-054 HARRIS DARRELL 04-01-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06-541L 79410-054 HARRIS NICHOLAS 08-17-2017 A-HLD
E09S E09 -572L 13510-067 HARRIS PERCY 08-21-2018 A-DES
E086 E08 -557L 57084-056 HARRISON MICHAEL 07-11-2018 A-DES
BOLA B01-204L 85973-054 HATCHER SHARON 07-26-2018 A-PRE
GO7S 007-751L 75633-053 HAYES NICHOLAS 01-29-2018 A-PRE
ZO3A 203-115LAD 14728-055 HEMINGWAY ANDRE 07-13-2019 A-DES
K02N K02-110L 06809-000 HERNANDDEZ-VALDEZ PEDRO 01-08-2019 A-PRE
GO3N G03-7180 76287-054 HERNANDEZ FRANCISO 07-08-2019 A-HLD
IO1N I01-901L 68126-054 HERNANDEZ WILLIAM 12-21-2018 A-PRE
I04N I04-931U 17838-104 HERNANDEZ-ALVARDO JUAN 12-18-2018 A-PRE
KO8S K08-0180 56032-018 HERNANDEZ-CLAUDIOS ESTEVAN 06-25-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-210L 79305-054 HERRERA KARILIE 02-12-2019 A-HLD
KO3N K03-1210 25253-052 HERRERA SERGIO 10-16-2018 A-PRE
K05N K05-1360 77211-054 HEYWARD CORY 08-07-2018 A-HLD
E05N E05-537L 86287-054 HIDALGO-MENDOZA VICTOR 06-26-2019 A-PRE
G02N 002-710L 79455-054 HILL JAQUEZ 08-17-2017 A-PRE
GO6N 006-742L 86271-054 HINES CUTIS 01-29-2019 A-PRE
K03N K03-123L 76101-054 HO CHI PING 03-26-2019 A-HLD
ZO6A Z06-215UAD 45623-007 HOGAN CHRISTOPHE 06-10-2019 A-STDY
012S G12-7960 86372-054 HOLLAND DAVID 11-30-2018 A-PRE
IO1N I01-906L 86200-054 HOOKER DARNEL 07-03-2019 A-HLD
Z06A Z06-216LAD 68152-054 HOYT KENNETH 05-21-2019 A-PRE
009S 009-769L 87002-054 HUDSON CALVIN 07-09-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-0110 86046-054 HUDSON DARRELL 08-13-2018 A-PRE
E060 506-5470 62670-054 HUSSETT DEVON 07-18-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03 -918U 86776-054 IBANEZ-FELIX LIBRADO 05-22-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-526L 79606-054 I DELFONSO ANDRES 05-03-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-0730 77737-112 IGNATOV KONSTANTIN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-9160 88595-479 IKEJIMBA JOSHUA 06-04-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04 -527L 61743-054 INNIS PATRICK 11-20-2018 A-HLD
I03N I03-918L 77588-054 INZUNZA ABRAHAM 02-07-2019 A-HLD
GO8S 008-7590 71776-018 IRIZARRY JORGE 04-09-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-922U 86979-054 ISOM-JENKINS JABARI 06-26-2019 A-HLD
ElOS E10 -573U 85687-054 JACKSON ERIK 06-27-2019 A-DES
G095 009-769U 86944-054 JACKSON HARVEY 06-06-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05-939L 86174-054 JACKSON JEROME 04-11-2019 A-HLD
ZO5A 205-123LAD 79729-054 JACKSON RAMEL 11-06-2017 A-HLD
IO5N I05-9400 68430-054 JAQUEZ CARLOS 06-27-2019 A-PRE
G03N 003-7200 79306-054 JAQUEZ LUIGI 07-06-2017 A-PRE
G03N G03-7240 76212-054 JARQUIN ARMAND° 09-08-2018 A-PRE
G1OS 010-773L 79466-054 JIMENEZ EDWARD 08-22-2017 A-PRE
I03N I03-920U 86269-054 JIMENEZ RICHARD 01-29-2019 A-PRE
GO2N G02-7150 76319-054 JIMENEZ-CASTILLO JUNIOR 07-12-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMD9 530.07
PAGE 009
* ROSTER • 07-23-2019
04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
K09S K09-031U 76235-054 JIMENEZ-GONZALEZ ALBERT 04-25-2019 A-HLD
G08S 008-763U 85890-054 JOHNSON DANDRE 06-28-2018 A-HLD
K115 K11-053U 61876-054 JOHNSON JAMAL 06-11-2019 A-HLD
ZO2A Z02-201LAD 50972-054 JOHNSON JAMEL 11-14-2018 A-HLD
I03N I03-917L 86461-054 JOHNSON JERMAINE 01-04-2019 A-PRE
I06N I06-943U 86885-054 JOHNSON TORRIE 07-01-2019 A-PRE
K12S K12-069U 86627-054 JONES CHAZ 02-28-2019 A-PRE
G11S 011-786U 86947-054 JONES DARRYL 06-11-2019 A-PRE
GOBS 008-763L 85880-054 JONES JAFARI 03-28-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-941L 06176-104 JONES JOHNNY 07-02-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-065L 17742-104 JONES MICHAEL 10-30-2018 A-HLD
Z02A 202-201LAD 68302-054 JONES RAYSHAUN 06-03-2019 A-HLD
201A 201-106UAD 87016-054 JONES THERYN 07-11-2019 A-HLD
G06N 006-745U 69033-054 JORDAN MARKEEM 06-30-2019 A-HLD
K066 K06-141L 75996-054 JOSEPH DENFORD 05-24-2017 A-PRE
K056 KOS-135U 86931-054 KABA MORA 06-05-2019 A-PRE
E016 E01-502L 83565-098 KALABA ZEF 05-31-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-053U 86535-054 KAMARA ABRAHIM 04-23-2019 A-HLD
207B 207-106LAD 90479-053 KANDIC MIRSAD 11-01-2017 A-PRE
Z05A 205-121LDS 86108-054 KEARSE RA KING 09-11-2018 A-PRE
KO1N KO1-105U 76306-054 KELLY JAMES 05-16-2019 A-PRE
E046 E04-528L 86018-054 KENNEDY JABARI 08-30-2018 A-PRE
G12S G12 -792L 87003-054 KENYATTA CHARLES 07-09-2019 A-PRE
EO1N E01 -508U 22484-040 KERNS JAMES 07-17-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-073L 26178-017 KHUKHIASHVILI TENGIZ 02-12-2019 A-HLD
K125 K12-067U 60899-054 KING BOB 03-29-2018 A-HLD
E06N E06-545U 26868-055 KING BRUCE 05-31-2019 A-HLD
Z03A Z03-112LAD 86587-054 KINTEA MCKENZIE 06-17-2019 A-PRE
E075 E07 -556U 50659-018 KIRK ANTHONY 06-24-2019 A-DES
I05N I05-934L 67531-054 KNOX WILLIAM 10-11-2018 A-HLD
G12S 012-790L 92398-054 KOLMNELA LEOM 09-18-2018 A-HLD
K10S K10-076L 76312-054 KORETSKYY MYKHAYLO 05-31-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-008L 79196-054 KOURANI ALI 05-16-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-011L 86956-054 KROMAH MOAZU 06-13-2019 A-PRE
E10S 610-574U 76140-066 LAHENS VLADIMIR 06-10-2019 A-DES
E10S E10 -576L 89579-053 LAMARCO DANIEL 03-13-2019 A-DES
G09S 009-770L 86357-054 LANS LEROY 03-14-2019 A-HLD
BO1A BO1-202U 56431-479 LAURE-TESISTECO RITA 01-28-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-917U 85838-054 LAWRENCE CHRISTOPHE 06-24-2019 A-HLD
E11S E11-582U 48958-054 LAWTON ANTOINE 05-20-2019 A-DES
G02N 002-716U 85782-298 LEAL RAYMUNDO 07-16-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-076U 05585-070 LEBRON HECTOR 04-23-2019 A-HLD
IO2N I02-910U 86343-054 LEE NICK 07-17-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03 -520L 18028-104 LEON-MAAL ALEJANDRO 03-26-2019 A-PRE
E02N E02-511L 86389-054 LEVINSON NIKOLAY 12-04-2018 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMD9 530*07
PAGE 010
* ROSTER * 07-23-2019
04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
KO4N K04-129U 68417-054 LEWIS DEVON 03-11-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-075U 86748-054 LI TIAN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
KO7S K07-004U 86570-054 LITVINTSUK VIKTOR 02-06-2019 A-PRE
I01N I01-904U 85832-054 LLANES TITO 05-29-2019 A-HLD
G09S G09 -770U 76244-054 LLOYD THOMAS 06-14-2019 A-PRE
E095 E09 -570L 79440-054 LOGAN RAMEL 04-01-2019 A-DES
K07S K07-012L 79246-054 LOMISHVILI GIORGI 08-23-2018 A-PRE
K08S K08-015U 76291-054 LONDONO OSVALDO 04-16-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04 -529U 91661-053 LOPEZ ALFRED 06-28-2019 A-PRE
I04N 104-929L 86656-054 LOPEZ ANDRE 03-08-2019 A-PRE
KO6N K06-145U 20472-038 LOPEZ CARLOS 01-08-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-008U 51698-054 LOPEZ JOEL 05-16-2019 A-PRE
GO5N G05 -739U 86571-054 LOPEZ JOSE 02-06-2019 A-PRE
E095 509-567L 79990-054 LOPEZ JUSTIN 01-28-2019 A-DES
KO3N K03-118L 90325-053 LOPEZ LOUIS 10-16-2017 A-PRE
E12S E12-591U 15934-014 LOPEZ STEVEN 06-24-2019 A-DES
K04N K04-132L 70381-054 LOPEZ -HERNANDEZ JACKSON 02-28-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-033L 76245-054 LORA JOSE 12-06-2018 A-PRE
G07S G07 -754L 86375-054 LOVELL SHERVINGTO 11-30-2018 A-PRE
ZO4A Z04-210UAD 86356-054 LOVICK FUGUAN 11-27-2018 A-HLD
205A 205-123UAD 85841-054 LUCRE BENJAMIN 06-20-2018 A-PRE
GOSN G05 -737L 70583-054 LYNCH DANIEL 01-08-2019 A-PRE
GO8S G08 -761U 65947-056 MABLE TEVIN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
G05N G05 -737U 86943-054 MACK ALJERMIAH 06-06-2019 A-PRE
E02N E02 -512L 86602-054 MACK MICHAEL 02-14-2019 A-HLD
K1OS K10-043U 86883-054 MAGERRAMOV AMID 05-09-2019 A-PRE
G03N G03-722L 76185-054 MAGNI FILIPPO 03-11-2019 A-HLD
El2S E12-596L 24988-014 MAHMOOD TALLAT 07-08-2019 A-DES
BO1A B01-216L 76261-054 MAKSIMOVIC DIANA 07-10-2019 A-PRE
E075 E07 -554L 20170-052 MALANGA DANIEL 06-24-2019 A-DES
G10S G10-774L 72280-054 MALDONADO JONATHAN 05-02-2019 A-HLD
K118 K11-055U 86917-054 MALHOTRA GUNJIT 05-23-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-022L 89744-053 MALKEYEV VYACGESLAV 08-10-2018 A-PRE
KO6N K06-142L 86569-054 MANAF HAJI ABDUL 02-06-2019 A-PRE
I01N I01-905L 64708-007 MANSARAY NABIU 05-16-2018 A-PRE
K085 K08-016L 01558-112 MANSON ERIC 08-31-2018 A-PRE
I01N I01-902U 76003-054 MARAT-UULU BAKAI 03-27-2019 A-HLD
IO2N IO2-909U 37756-034 MARGOLIES WOLFE 06-24-2019 A-PRE
E075 E07 -551U 69572-054 MARGOLLA ROBERTO 06-10-2019 A-DES
GO3N G03-720L 76178-054 MARQUEZ-ORTIZ JERYLAN 03-28-2019 A-STDY
KO8S K08-014U 86351-054 MARRERO JOHNATHON 11-26-2018 A-PRE
GO1N G01-704U 76539-067 MARRERO NORMAN 06-03-2019 A-PRE
E07S 1307-555U 11867-087 MARSHALL MICHAEL 07-08-2019 A-DES
I04N I04-931L 90514-054 MARTES JOSE 06-06-2019 A-PRE
204A Z04-207UAD 86887-054 MARTIN ANTHONY 05-10-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
NYMD9 530*07
'PAGE 011
* ROSTER * 07-23-2019
04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD ARS
KOIN K01-101U 25768-050 MARTINEZ ELLIOT 06-25-2019 A-PRE
KO9S K09-027U 85976-054 MARTINEZ JOSE 05-31-2019 A-HLD
GOSS 008-760U 69055-054 MARTINEZ LENNO 06-25-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-912U 86111-054 MARTINEZ NOEL 06-10-2019 A-HLD
KO2N K02-111L 27758-050 MARTINEZ RICHARD 07-12-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-927L 76279-054 MARTINEZ-LOPEZ MODESTO 04-03-2019 A-PRE
201A 201-107LAD 66171-054 MATTHEWS CHARLES 06-11-2019 A-DES
IOUs' I01-908L 91753-054 MATTHEWS MICHAEL 05-13-2019 A-HLD
GIIS G11-782U 85716-054 MATUTE EMIL 05-22-2018 A-PRE
801A 801-217L 33919-171 MCCASKILL ELIZABETH 01-23-2019 A-PRE
K06N K06-143L 90800-053 MCCLOUD 05-02-2019 A-PRE
E02N E02 -509L 19039-054 MCCOY SAMUEL 02-15-2019 A-HLD
K12S K12-064L 86768-054 MCDUFFIE ALBERT 03-28-2019 A-PRE
E11S E11 -584L 71694-050 MCFADDEN DAVID 06-25-2019 A-DES
205A 205-117LDS 85989-054 MCGRIER FREDDIE 04-19-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04 -928L 66881-050 MCINTYRE BRANDON 10-01-2018 A-PRE
G07S G07 -754U 89196-053 MCKAY RASHAWN 05-23-2018 A-PRE
E08S E08-5640 65135-054 MCKINNON JOHN 06-01-2019 A-DES
K01N K01-101U 69309-054 MCQUEEN ALIE 06-05-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-924L 79339-054 MEDINA WILFRED 01-11-2019 A-HLD
K12S K12-065U 92150-054 MEIGHAN AKBAR 07-03-2019 A-HLD
KO3N K03-124L 91114-054 MEJIA-VARGAS MARIO 01-29-2019 A-HLD
KO2N K02-109L 85799-054 MELENDEZ LUIS 05-01-2019 A-PRE
£03N E03-518U 61162-054 MENA-CANCEL JESUS 06-19-2019 A-HLD
805N E05-540L 84246-054 MENDOZA HECTOR 05-23-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-532U 57916-054 MENDOZA-SOLAN ALEX 07-19-2019 A-PRE
GO6N 006-748U 85606-054 MERCADO GABRIEL 05-30-2018 A-HLD
K12S K12-061L 86026-054 MERCHANT SEAN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
E12S E12 -592U 89673-053 MERSEY WILLIAM 06-06-2019 A-DES
K1OS K10-047L 85941-054 MEZA SINOHE 07-19-2018 A-PRE
202A 202-201LAD 86160-054 MICKENS DION 07-16-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-054L 85771-054 MILLER DARREN 06-27-2019 A-HLD
GO6N G06 -742U 79412-054 MILLER RAHIEM 08-17-2017 A-HLD
E01N E01-504U 79487-054 MINJAREZ SANTOS 05-23-2019 A-HLD
203A 203-116LAD 85605-054 MOBLEY COREY 04-24-2018 A-HLD
K125 K12-068L 79047-054 MODESTO AMAURY 01-24-2019 A-HLD
K10S K10-044U 86044-054 MOHAMED MOHAMED 09-24-2018 A-PRE
201A 201-108LAD 91268-054 MOJICA JASON 02-19-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-074L 86024-054 MONASTERIO LUIS 08-30-2018 A-PRE
G07S G07 -756U 19735-104 MONES-CORO VICTOR 06-13-2019 A-PRE
EllS E11 -583L 19668-052 MONGO EQUAN 03-19-2019 A-BOP HLD
GlOS G10 -778U 77708-054 MONSANTO LOPEZ DANIEL 05-23-2019 A-HLD
KO6N K06-148U 86272-054 MONTAS HUGO 10-31-2018 A-PRE
GIOS G10 -777U 86353-054 MONTHS BRANDON 06-25-2019 A-HLD
E04N E04 -529L 63901-054 MOODY ANDREW 01-23-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMD9 530*07 * ROSTER • 07-23-2019
'PAGE 012 04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
K1OS K10-042L 79784-054 MOORE DERRICK 10-22-2018 A-HLD
K06N K06-1450 14532-104 MOORE JAMES 06-10-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-0510 87036-054 MORA ANTONIO 07-19-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-002L 86701-054 MORA ARTURO 06-10-2019 A-HLD
206A 206-2130AD 86384-054 MORA BRIAN 12-03-2018 A-HLD
Kl1S K11-0550 86260-054 MORA KEVIN 10-29-2018 A-PRE
ZO6A 206-2200AD 86432-054 MORCILIO RUBEN 12-20-2018 A-HLD
BO1A BO1-2090 91449-053 MOREAU MAGEN 07-11-2019 A-HLD
BOXA B01-2040 90780-053 MOREL -CRUZ CAROLINA 07-01-2019 A-PRE
E050 E05 -536L 87022-054 MUNOZ HECTOR 07-15-2019 A-PRE
GO1N G01 -702L 85769-054 MURPHY ERNEST 06-06-2018 A-PRE
204A Z04-211UAD 57497-054 MURRAY DONNELL 04-11-2019 A-HLD
KO5N K05-1380 86974-054 MURRAY EZZARD 06-22-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-922U 86019-054 MYRIE JERMAINE 08-30-2018 A-PRE
E060 E06-5440 86968-054 NAGI BILAL 06-19-2019 A-HLD
El2S E12 -594L 76311-053 NAGI FIKRI 05-02-2019 A-DES
GO7S G07 -755L 76172-054 NAJERA-MONTOYA FREDY 03-15-2018 A-PRE
I03N I03-924U 90218-054 NAUT JUAN 06-06-2019 A-HLD
201A ZO1-107UAD 86719-054 NAVEDO CHRISTIAN 03-14-2019 A-PRE
KO6N K06-1420 86301-054 NAWAZ AHMED 06-25-2019 A-HLD
BOIA BO1-219U 85954-054 NAZINA IELYZAVETA 03-15-2019 A-HLD
ElOS E10 -575L 79492-054 NEGROPONTE GIANFRANCO 12-11-2018 A-DES
GO1N GO1-7020 85772-054 NEWTON DEVONTAE 05-17-2019 A-HLD
E060 E06-548U 86923-054 NICHOLAS MALIK 05-30-2019 A-HLD
K06N K06-1460 78838-054 NOBLE KASAN 11-01-2018 A-HLD
K07S K07-009L 91349-053 NOBOA MARIO 12-20-2018 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-069L 86407-054 NORRIS SAEED 12-12-2018 A-PRE
G07S G07-7520 85738-054 NORVILLE DWAYNE 05-30-2018 A-HLD
E10S E10-5730 68111-054 NUNEZ FRANKLIN 06-25-2019 A-DES
K02N K02-112L 70164-054 NUNEZ JOSE 06-10-2019 A-HLD
K095 K09-033U 78025-053 NUNEZ STARLIN 03-26-2019 A-HLD
GO2N G02 -715L 76194-054 OCAMPO-ALVAREZ RUBEN 04-20-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-020L 86074-054 OCHOA OVIDIO 06-06-2019 A-PRE
I020 IO2 -912U 86452-054 OCHOA PERCY 01-02-2019 A-PRE
GO5N G05 -738U 85780-054 OGARRO TYREEK 05-17-2019 A-HLD
GO5N G05 -735U 72661-054 OJEDA CALVIN 05-31-2018 A-HLD
KO4N K04-128L 91980-054 OLANGIAN REZA 01-25-2019 A-HLD
BOIA B01-218L 75936-054 OLIVERA JUDIE 06-28-2019 A-HLD
KOSS K08-021L 76249-054 OROZCO JOSÉ 07-17-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-9250 19732-104 ORSINI-QUINTERO MICHOLS 04-09-2019 A-PRE
Klos K10-039L 85805-054 ORTIZ ERVIN 06-13-2018 A-PRE
KO4N K04-1260 65410-054 ORTIZ LUIS 08-31-2018 FED WRIT
09-11-2018 A-HLD
ZO3A 203-1130AD 85875-054 OUTLAW KEITH 06-27-2018 A-HLD
GllS G11 -781L 79551-054 OWEN WALSTON 11-13-2017 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMD9 530*07
'PAGE 013
* ROSTER * 07-23-2019
04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD ARS
G06N G06 -745L 79415-054 OWENS DOUGLAS 08-17-2017 A-HLD
G07S G07 -752L 74125-053 PAGETT LARRY 10-05-2018 A-HLD
204A Z04-212UAD 79166-054 PALERMO HECTOR 11-20-2018 A-HLD
E03N E03-519L 85979-054 PAPOSHVILI GOCHA 08-09-2018 A-PRE
E10S E10-576U 76364-066 PARR ROBERT 06-10-2019 A-DES
G06N G06-747L 70497-050 PECORELLA ALAN 06-25-2019 A-STDY
K11S K11-051U 13717-041 PEJIC VEDRAN 03-06-2019 A-HLD
R09S K09-031L 90649-054 PENA EDWARD 11-27-2018 A-PRE
G10S G10-776L 85977-054 PENA ROBERT 07-26-2018 A-PRE
203A 203-111UAD 86222-054 PERALTA ORLANDO 02-25-2019 A-HLD
G12S G12 -791U 86198-054 PEREZ ANTHONY 04-16-2019 A-HLD
E02N 502-514L 85435-054 PEREZ BILLY 03-08-2018 A-HLD
206A 206-219LAD 78346-054 PEREZ CHRISTIAN 05-24-2018 A-HLD
G0BS G08 -759L 79095-054 PEREZ NOEL 06-30-2019 A-HLD
K04N K04-132U 91200-053 PEREZ SANCHEZ HUGO 10-26-2018 A-PRE
G03N G03 -723U 90898-053 PEREZ-SANCHEZ OVIDIO 06-15-2018 A-PRE
206A 206-216LAD 14949-057 PIERCE RICHARD 08-25-2015 A-DES
G08S G08 -758L 76193-054 PINEDA-OTALVARO JOSE 06-27-2018 A-PRE
106N I06-944L 18346-037 PINKNEY ANTHONY 05-22-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03 -523L 86435-054 PIRINS IGORS 12-21-2018 A-PRE
E02N E02-513L 78702-054 POLANCO JASON 04-20-2018 A-HLD
K08S K08-021U 86369-054 POLANCO SERGIO 03-24-2019 A-HLD
G08S G08-761L 58001-054 POLK TERRELL 02-06-2017 A-HLD
EOBS E08-560L 62541-050 POWELL BARRY 05-29-2018 A-DES
I06N I06-947L 85484-054 POWELL MARIO 03-24-2018 A-PRE
KO8S K08-014L 76149-054 PRICE GREGORY 04-17-2018 A-PRE
GO2N G02 -712L 92418-054 PROFIT TRAVIS 11-15-2018 A-HLD
K05N K05-133L 71538-019 PULIDO-LOPEZ MARIO 04-10-2018 A-PRE
G12S G12 -794U 85822-054 QU JIAN 06-18-2018 A-PRE
201A ZO1-104UAD 86210-054 QUI ROGA FRANK 07-08-2019 A-PRE
G02N G02 -709L 86608-054 RAGONESE RYAN 02-21-2019 A-PRE
K06N K06-142U 91752-053 RAI GURSIMARDE 07-09-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-008U 89329-053 RAKHMATOR AZIZJON 05-20-2016 A-PRE
G1OS G10 -774U 86879-054 RAMIREZ ADONIS 05-02-2019 A-HLD
E085 E08-562L 81219-054 RAMIREZ EDGARDO 07-15-2019 A-DES
IO2N IO2-914U 79252-054 RAMIREZ MIGUEL 10-24-2018 A-HLD
G12S G12-795U 86958-054 RAMIREZ RAMON 06-13-2019 A-PRE
G07S G07-756L 86551-054 RAMIREZ RONNY 01-29-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03-521L 90860-053 RAMIREZ SAUDI 01-25-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-913U 86827-054 RAMIREZ YISANDER 04-18-2019 A-PRE
BO1A 801-212L 68610-054 RAMIREZ ZORAIDA 10-22-2018 A-HLD
K11S K11-059L 55278-054 RAMOS DANIEL 05-29-2019 A-HLD
IO1N I01-907L 78693-054 RAMOS DOMINGO 04-01-2019 A-HLD
K05N K05-136U 90137-053 RAMOS FRANCISCO 07-17-2017 A-PRE
G02N G02 -710U 85428-054 RAMOS JASON 04-26-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
NYMD9 530•07
TAGE 014
• ROSTER • 07-23-2019
04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD ARS
205A 205-1190AD 69258-054 RANCIER-MEDRANO FEDERICO 09-02-2016 A-HLD
E05N 1305-5350 90880-053 RAPHAEL KEVIN 06-08-2018 A-PRE
GO2N G02 -709U 16296-049 RAWSON KENNETH 06-10-2019 A-STDY
K12S K12-070L 75971-112 RAZUMOVSKIY ALEKSANDR 06-26-2019 A-HLD
GO9S G09 -768L 43667-007 REESE DEMITRI 05-22-2019 A-STDY
205A 205-123LAD 85609-054 REID MICHAEL 07-03-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04 -926L 86623-054 REINALDO ROMAN 02-27-2019 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-078U 86022-054 REINGOUD MURVIN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
E095 E09-571U 08200-070 RENE CHRISTOPHE 05-29-2018 A-DES
GO2N G02 -713L 86526-054 REYES ANGEL 05-10-2019 A-HLD
206A Z06-218LAD 85993-054 REYES EFRAIN 08-01-2018 A-PRE
GO8S G08 -762L 79102-054 REYES FRANKIE 05-17-2017 A-PRE
K07S K07-0010 86319-054 REYES -BONILLA JUAN 07-15-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-914U 61643-054 REYES-VAZQUEZ RAUL 07-17-2019 A-HLD
B01A B01-203L 89522-053 RICHARDSON CAROLYN 06-04-2019 A-HLD
GO7S G07 -753U 85735-054 RICHARDSON DAVID 06-25-2019 A-HLD
GO3N G03-718L 69781-479 RINCON-VEGA MARIO 05-24-2019 A-PRE
GO3N G03-717U 76284-054 RIOS JESUS 04-11-2019 A-PRE
GO3N G03 -717L 92336-054 RIVER-MARADIAGA DEVIS 02-20-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-920L 91104-054 RIVERA JESSE 09-28-2017 A-HLD
203A 203-109UAD 86225-054 RIVERA JOSE 10-18-2018 A-PRE
205A 205-1170AD 72008-054 RIVERA JOSE 05-08-2019 A-DES
GO8S G08-764U 86815-054 RIVERA JUSTIN 04-11-2019 A-HLD
K095 K09-026U 86848-054 RIVERA LOUIS 04-24-2019 A-HLD
K115 K11-0550 06303-082 RIVERA LUIS 06-05-2019 A-HLD
K08S K08-019U 79752-054 RIVERO RICARDO 07-09-2019 A-PRE
5125 E12-594U 12558-036 ROBERSON CHARLES 07-08-2019 A-DES
BO1A 801-201L 86411-054 ROBERTS ADRIENNE 07-05-2019 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-0720 86791-054 ROBERTS DAEQUAN 05-16-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06 -541U 85846-054 ROBERTS PARIS 06-20-2018 A-PRE
I06N I06-9480 34801-058 ROBINSON PHILLIP 06-06-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-0030 85773-054 ROBINSON TYQUAN 04-18-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06 -946U 78258-112 RODDUBNOV SALMAN 07-02-2019 A-HLD
E04N 504-525L 86831-054 RODRIGUEZ ADONIS 04-18-2019 A-PRE
KO4N K04-1300 91278-054 RODRIGUEZ DANIEL 06-12-2019 A-PRE
G12S G12-796L 29216-050 RODRIGUEZ HENRY 04-05-2019 A-HLD
204A 204-209LAD 79168-054 RODRIGUEZ JUAN 01-24-2019 A-HLD
G11S G11 -781U 86224-054 RODRIGUEZ MALI 03-18-2019 A-HLD
E075 E07 -550L 04883-104 RODRIGUEZ MANUEL 06-03-2019 A-DES
I04N I04 -932U 86117-054 ROJAS ADÁN 09-13-2018 A-PRE
E03N E03-5210 76160-054 ROJAS -ROMERO EMILIO 04-26-2018 A-PRE
G125 G12 -791L 85670-054 ROLON EDWIN 05-30-2019 A-HLD
ZOLA 201-107UAD 74203-054 ROMERO MIGUEL 12-09-2015 A-PRE
I03N I03 -923U 78841-054 ROMERO RAFAEL 11-19-2018 A-HLD
K09S K09-0360 76223-054 ROMERO YEURY 05-23-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMD9 530*07 * ROSTER * 07-23-2019
'PAGE 015 04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
KlOS K10-045U 85927-054 ROMERO-GRANADOS JUAN 07-12-2018 A-PRE
E03N E03 -524L 86840-054 RONDAN CARLOS O4-23-2019 A-PRE
I06N I06-943U 86025-054 ROOPWAH MOSES 08-30-2018 A-PRE
E06N E06-543U 77980-054 ROPER COREY 12-10-2018 A-HLD
GO5N G05-734U 86324-054 ROSA RICKY 11-14-2018 A-PRE
E01N E01 -503U 86169-054 ROSARIO JOELKIN 10-03-2018 A-PRE
KO3N K03-124U 26488-038 ROSARIO OSCAR 02-27-2019 A-HLD
E11S E11-587L 58588-037 ROSS DEVIN 09-12-2018 A-DES
E11S E11 -584U 06084-082 ROSS MICHAEL 04-15-2019 A-DES
GO2N G02 -713U 85778-054 ROYSTER KELLY 05-29-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05 -536U 76220-054 RUGARD RUBEN 06-30-2019 A-HLD
GO3N G03 -724L 28408-054 RUIZ RENAN 10-30-2017 A-HLD
K11S K11-049U 87034-054 RUSSELL TSANI 07-18-2019 A-HLD
K115 K11-077U 77749-054 RUSSO ROBERT 06-27-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-942L 87009-054 SAAB ALI 07-10-2019 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-069L 70704-054 SAADIA MOISE 07-11-2019 A-PRE
B01A B01-208L 89767-053 SAFANI HAWWA 03-22-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-030L 76005-054 SAINZ-FLORES JULIO 06-08-2017 A-PRE
207B Z07-304LAD 79715-054 SAIPOV SAYFULLO 11-01-2017 A-PRE
KO4N K04-125L 86530-054 SALAHUDDIN KHALIL 01-23-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-930L 49953-018 SALAS TORRES FERNEY 02-07-2019 A-HLD
GO3N 003-721U 07687-036 SALDANA YEISON 04-19-2019 A-HLD
K08S K08-020U 85571-054 SALEH REDHWAN 07-03-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05-540U 86263-054 SALVADOR GUSTAVO 03-12-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-019L 08322-018 SAMUELS-DURAN CARLOS 10-17-2016 A-HLD
BO1A B01-213L 56234-054 SANCHEZ AURORA 04-25-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05-937U 85759-054 SANCHEZ RAY 04-01-2019 A-HLD
G1OS 010-775U 85756-054 SANDERS REGINALD 06-05-2018 A-PRE
K12S K12-067L 86027-054 SANDS REUBEN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
K09S K09-0280 48816-066 SANTANA JOSE 02-27-2019 A-HLD
GOBS G08-7570 86352-054 SANTIAGO JONATHAN 11-26-2018 A-PRE
203A 203-115UAD 08224-082 SANTIAGO LEON 05-07-2019 A-PRE
E11S E11 -585U 80341-083 SANTIAGO-MENDOZA OMAR 04-09-2019 A-DES
K115 K11-054U 79699-054 SANTOS AOUL 10-27-2017 A-PRE
E10S E10-576L 99462-038 SANTOS ELLIS 07-22-2019 A-DES
EOIN E01 -505U 85816-054 SANTOS JOSE 05-08-2019 A-HLD
G1OS 010-779L 86638-054 SANTOS -FELIX CRISTOPHER 03-04-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-001L 01735-007 SATTAN HAROLD 11-02-2018 A-HLD
K05N K05-134L 78531-054 SAUNDERS CRAIG 04-25-2019 A-BOP HLD
E08S E08-5590 08765-094 SAXON JOSEPH 03-18-2019 A-DES
201A Z01-104LAD 17781-104 SAYOC CESAR 03-26-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-009L 53413-083 SCALES SYDNEY 02-21-2019 A-PRE
012S 012-794L 17437-104 SCHIFANO VINCENT 07-18-2019 A-HLD
207B Z07-301LAD 79471-054 SCHULTE JOSHUA 05-02-2019 A-PRE
GO6N G06-7410 76292-054 SEARLES JARED 04-17-2019 A-PRE
00002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMD9 530*07 *
-PAGE 016
GRP. SPECIFIC. veG
Z06A Z06-219LAD 8569-057
G05N G05-736L 83721-053
E01N E01-508L 08379-068
ZO1A Z01-108LAD 53267-054
K05N K05-136L 86277-054
E04N 504-526U 71996-054
K10S K10-046U 86819-054
G09S G09 -771L 86960-054
K11S K11-051L 68555-066
BO1A B01-217L 76323-054
E07S E07-553L 24263-052
BO1A 801-217U 85797-053
I05N I05-933U 19494-104
G12S G12-790U 72229-054
K125 K12-068U 86891-054
I03N I03 -920U 90311-053
EllS E11 -588U 78175-054
K07S K07-007U 76322-054
E04N E04 -531U 85833-054
EllS E11 -586U 90517-053
I05N I05 -938U 85408-054
I03N I03-923L 86516-054
K02N K02-110U 86909-054
K02N K02-114L 26142-038
IO1N I01-906U 77179-054
BO1A B01-207U 86961-054
Z03A 203-111UAD 69065-054
E06N E06-545L 86796-054
Kl2S K12-063L 86616-054
I01N I01-908U 91161-053
K08S K08-013U 86023-054
GOSN G05 -735U 85781-054
E02N E02 -516U 85991-054
Z03A 203-110LAD 79662-054
K11S K11-052L 11714-052
206A 206-215UAD 78514-054
E03N E03 -517L 73974-112
E03N E03 -517U 86553-054
E05N E05-538U 86995-054
K07S K07-007U
KO1N K01-101U
E02N E02 -510L
K11S K11-051U
I04N I04-927U
K01N K01-102U
30772-069
09521-054
91183-054
86934-054
91251-054
56772-054
LN
SEARS
SEGUI
SEIBER
SELLERS
SEMIDAY
SEPULVEDA
SERRANO
SHARPERSON
SHERAK
SHOKRALLA
SHOWERS
SIDDIQUI
SIMON
SISNERO-GIL
SMALLS
SMART
SMITH
SMITH
SMITH
SOBERS
SOSA
SOSA-DIAZ
SOSA-ORTIZ
SOTO
SOUTHWELL
SPINELLI
SPRULL
STAFFORD
STEVEN
STUART
SUCRE
SUMPTER
SUVERIN
TABAR
TABOADA
TARTAGLIONE
TAVARES
TAVARES-BRITO
TAVAREZ-MOTA
TAVERAS
TAYLOR
TAYLOR
TAYLOR
TEJADA
THERIAULT
ROSTER
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
07-23-2019
04:04:37
FN  ARSD  ARS
JOSHUA 03-11-2019 A-DES
FRANK 02-25-2019 A-PRE
RONALD 04-19-2019 A-HLD
DOUGLAS 06-04-2018 A-PRE
LUIS
ANGEL
11-01-2018 A-PRE
07-23-2018 A-HLD
JOE 04-16-2019 A-PRE
LEROY 06-13-2019 A-HLD
STEPHEN
MARY
11-06-2018 A-HLD
07-12-2019 A-PRE
RONALD 04-29-2019 A-DES
ASIA 07-11-2019 A-PRE
JAMAL 02-12-2019 A-PRE
MARLON 04-12-2019 A-PRE
LEON 05-10-2019 A-PRE
SHAUN 12-21-2017 A-PRE
BRANDON 06-03-2019 A-DES
DAVID 07-12-2019 A-PRE
SHASHIEME 06-20-2018 A-PRE
BRENT 03-11-2019 A-DES
PEDRO 04-30-2019 A-HLD
HENYEL 02-19-2019 A-PRE
NESTOR 05-20-2019 A-PRE
LUIS 06-30-2019 A-HLD
MARQUIS 06-11-2019 A-PRE
DOREEN 06-17-2019 A-HLD
MATTHEW 03-06-2019 A-PRE
SIRRON 04-10-2019 A-PRE
WILLIAM 03-05-2019 A-HLD
JOSHUA 05-06-2019 A-PRE
NERIDIO 08-30-2018 A-PRE
TYRELL 06-06-2018 A-HLD
MAXIM 07-31-2018 A-PRE
HALLIL 03-13-2019 A-HLD
RICARDO 02-07-2019 A-PRE
NICHOLAS 03-19-2019 A-PRE
ALEX 08-10-2018 A-HLD
YIRAN 01-30-2019 A-PRE
DORLYN 07-03-2019 A-PRE
JAIRO 07-18-2019 A-HLD
CLIFFORD 05-22-2019 A-HLD
DAVID 12-06-2018 A-PRE
NATHANIEL 06-25-2019 A-HLD
JOEL 06-17-2019 A-PRE
MICHAEL 04-12-2019 A-PRE
NYMD9 530+07 *
PAGE 017
ROSTER
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG  LN
ElOS E10-580L
KOIN K01-103L
KIOS K10-044L
GO1N GO1-708L
KO8S K08-074U
GO6N 006-744L
E11S E11-581U 78359-053
KOSS K08-015L 86107-054
203A 203-111LAD 86179-054
GO2N G02 -712U 86367-054
E04N 204-528U 85608-054
E02N E02-513U 85382-054
KO2N K02-115L 14103-052
E095 E09 -566U 85621-054
KO5N KOS-136U 85896-054
E06N E06-543L 86521-054
ZO1A 201-106LAD 34957-054
205A Z05-118UAD 86020-054
GlOS G10 -780L 85742-054
E09S E09-572U 76518-067
I06N I06-945L 25352-083
GO1N G01 -701L 79827-054
GO5N G05 -734L
KO9S K09-075L
K04N K04-125L
IO2N 102-911L
KOBS K08-024L
KOTS K07-003U
I05N I05-938U
I06N I06-943U 86408-054
K10S K10-039U 29381-050
E05N E05 -538L 86880-054
KI1S K11-049U 86145-054
ZO5A Z05-118LAD 76290-054
GIOS G10-773U 79099-054
I03N
G11S
BO1A
E05N
I05N
K09S
I04N
KOSN
7301A
Kl2S
79823-054
66151-054
79965-054
79310-054
79652-054
16725-028
28631-054
68339-054
76277-054
65709-054
24772-057
77662-054
79919-054
I03-919U
G11-784U
B01-214U
E05 -534L
I05-936U
K09-032U
I04-926U
K05-1350
B01-220U
K12-071U
76242-054
79831-054
86297-054
86285-054
85992-054
30982-054
85922-054
58614-054
23003-021
86882-054
THOMAS
THOMAS
THOMAS
THOMAS
THOMAS
THOMPSON
TISDALE
TIURIN
TOLENTINO
TOMLINSON
TOPPIN
TORO
TORRES
TORRES
TORRES
TORRES
TORRES
TORRES
TOWNSEND
TURNER
TURNER
ULLAN
URENA
URENA
URENA
VALAZQUEZ SAMMY
VALENZUELA-LIZARRAGA RAMON
VALERIO DAVID
VAN MANEN
VANIER
VARGAS
VARGAS
VARGAS
VASQUEZ
VEGA
VEISYON
VENTURA
VENTURA
VICIOSO-LIMA
VICKERS
VIERRA
VILLANUEVA
VIZZARI
VO
VORONJUK
FN
DAVID
GLENN
JASON
LARRY
WILLIAM
JAHEED
MICHAEL
ANDREI
DOMINGO
JOWAYNE
MICHAEL 05-21-2019 A-HLD
TYLER 12-10-2018 A-HLD
ANTHONY
FAUSTO
FRANCISCO
JOSHUA
MARTIN
OMAR
DOUGLAS
CLAUDE
WI LEERT
AKAYED
ILARIO
JUAN
RICHARD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
07-23-2019
04:04:37
ARSD  ARS
12-10-2018 A-DES
08-22-2014 A-HLD
02-06-2019 A-HLD
07-12-2019 A-PRE
02-07-2019 A-HLD
07-18-2019 A-HLD
01-14-2019 A-DES
09-07-2018 A-PRE
10-09-2018 A-PRE
07-22-2019 A-PRE
PAUL
CARLTON
DAVID
JOSE
MIGUEL
PERCY
OVED
EDWARD
CHARLES
MINERVA
PEDRO
NAZEER
MARK
MICHAEL
GINO
KIM ANH
VITALI
07-10-2019
05-06-2019
02-13-2019
04-24-2019
10-13-2018
08-30-2018
05-31-2018
07-22-2019
04-11-2019
11-07-2018
04-06-2019
05-23-2019
04-03-2019
02-27-2019
12-20-2017
07-22-2019
01-17-2018
12-12-2018 A-PRE
12-08-2017 A-PRE
05-06-2019 A-HLD
02-15-2019 A-HLD
04-16-2019 A-PRE
05-17-2017 A-PRE
06-28-2019 A-PRE
08-06-2018 A-PRE
07-19-2019 A-STDY
11-08-2018 A-PRE
04-08-2019 A-PRE
11-08-2018 A-PRE
05-10-2019 A-PRE
07-11-2019 A-PRE
06-27-2019 A-HLD
05-09-2019 A-PRE
A-HLD
A-DES
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-DES
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
NYMD9 530'07 * ROSTER
'PAGE 018
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG
GO6N G06-746U 68342-054
K05N K05-138L 86480-054
E06N E06 -546L 86900-054
K04N K04-127L 02259-748
GllS G11 -788L 85544-054
GllS G11 -786L 86336-054
K10S K10-048U 77269-112
EllS E11 -587U 63274-037
KO6N K06-146L 81078-053
ZO2A Z02-201LAD 77510-054
K08S K08-017U 76135-054
I03N I03-919L 92373-054
Kl2S K12-078L 85377-054
101N I01-904L 39715-013
E04N E04-531L 57969-054
K03N K03-120U 56622-056
ZO1A Z01-102UAD 85644-054
K11S K11-049U 76273-054
E06N E06 -542L 06600-052
Z03A Z03-113LAD 78640-054
IO2N I02-909L 85310-054
GO6N G06 -746L 79417-054
203A 203-112UAD 86162-054
GO5N G05-739L 79954-054
E085 E08-557U 09310-041
KO4N K04-132U 87008-054
G1OS G10-780U 75973-054
GO7S 007-749L 86239-054
GO5N G05-738L 69068-054
KO1N KO1-106L 57610-018
ZO2A Z02-201LAD 76232-054
K09S K09-029U 86315-054
Kl1S K11-053L 85369-054
GOIN G01-707L 76248-054
EIOS E10 -580U 84115-083
K1OS K10-037U 86477-054
E06N E06 -546U 86858-054
G123 G12 -789L 77167-112
GO7S G07 -750L 86428-054
GO7S G07 -751U 86868-054
G09S G09 -765L 86373-054
K125 K12-066U 86925-054
E06N E06-544L 86718-054
K115 K11-060L 86331-054
BO1A 801-211L 86475-054
LN
WAGNER
WAITERS
WALKER
WALKER
WALSH
WALTER
WANG
WARE
WASHINGTON
WASHINGTON
WATKINS
NATTIER
WEBER
WEBSTER
WESTON
WHITAKER
WHITE
WHITE
WILLIAMS
WILLIAMS
WILLIAMS
WILLIAMS
WILLIAMS
WILLIAMS
WILLIAMS
WILLIAMS
WILLIS
WILSON
WILSON
WOLF
HONEY
WONG
WOOLASTON
WRIGHT
WRIGHT
WU
XIA
YANG
YOUNG
YOUNG
ZAPATA-COSTRO
ZAPOLSKIJ
ZELAYA
ZHOU
ZHUANG
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
* 07-23-2019
04:04:37
FN  ARSD  ARS
MYRON 01-11-2019 A-PRE
MARK 01-09-2019 A-PRE
ALLEN 07-12-2019 A-PRE
DELROY 06-25-2019 A-HLD
PATRICK 01-14-2019 A-HLD
FAHEEM 04-08-2019 A-PRE
SHUAIQUI 12-18-2018 A-PRE
CRAIG 11-26-2018 A-DES
MAURICE 02-25-2019 A-PRE
VAUGHN 06-03-2019 A-HLD
THOMAS 02-14-2018 A-PRE
MICHAEL 03-29-2016 A-HLD
JEFFREY 05-29-2019 A-HLD
MARK 06-26-2019 A-HLD
BOBBY 07-01-2019 A-PRE
TYRELL 08-22-2014 A-HLD
KHALIF 05-02-2019 A-DES
LARRY 03-21-2019 A-HLD
CURTIS 07-22-2019 A-PRE
DAYVON 06-19-2019 A-PRE
JAMES 07-10-2019 A-PRE
JIHAD 08-17-2017 A-HLD
SHARIEF 03-26-2019 A-HLD
SHAWN 01-25-2018 A-HLD
TIMOTHY 04-30-2019 A-DES
TONY 07-09-2019 A-HLD
SHANNON 03-14-2019 A-HLD
LEROY 05-07-2019 A-PRE
SHAWN 05-16-2019 A-HLD
LEONARD 04-04-2016 A-HLD
ISHI 04-15-2019 A-PRE
ZXIYU 11-14-2018 A-PRE
TYRONE 02-21-2019 A-PRE
CIMMIE 12-12-2018 A-PRE
JEFFREY 03-13-2019 A-DES
HUALONG 01-09-2019 A-PRE
XIU 05-21-2019 A-PRE
BINGQIN 12-04-2018 A-PRE
AARON 12-19-2018 A-PRE
ANTHONY 04-30-2019 A-HLD
ARGEMIRO 11-30-2018 A-PRE
VLADISLAV 05-31-2019 A-PRE
EDUARDO 03-14-2019 A-HLD
LEI 04-19-2019 A-PRE
LIQING 07-02-2019 A-PRE
NYMD9 530.'07 • ROSTER • 07-23-2019
PAGE 019 OF 019 04:04:37
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
K05N K05-134U 83742-053 ZOTTOLA ANTHONY 06-26-2019 A-PRE
G02N G02 -714L 64662-053 ZUBIATE MIGUEL 02-15-2019 A-HLD
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
EFTA00108552 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons roster of inmates at Metropolitan Correctional Center
(date: 2019-07-23)
NYMES 530.07 *
PAGE 001
FUNCTION: R-P
ZERO/NBR: NO
OPTION:
DUP SUPR: YES
COLUMNS 1: REG 2:
CONDITIONS (GRP 1)
CMCI NE G
CMCI NE P
G TOT
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
POPULATION MONITORING CENSUS/ROSTER
GENERALIZED RETRIEVAL
07-24-2019
02:47:39
SELECTION CATEGORY: QTR EQ ALL
ORGANIZATION: FACL EQ NYM
TYPE OF FACILITY: TOF EQ T
FACILITY MANAGED BY: FMB EQ AP
LN 3: LN2 4: FN 5: ARSD 6: ARS 7: 8:
SEQ: 234 NP:
JUDG: C SORT COL: COL SEQ:
OR CONDITIONS (GRP 2) OR CONDITIONS (GRP 3) OR CONDITIONS (GRP 4)
766 740 26
-W-
401
-0-
348 2 15 309 457
Cortd CifftO-

╭────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ usp oe st                                   │
│                                             │
│ ere tor                                     │
│                                             │
│ a a a oe                                    │
│                                             │
│ (¥ 489) SNOILIGNOD YO (€ 4¥D) SNOTLIGNOD HO │
│                                             │
│ 20S "109                                    │
│ ran vez :Oas                                │
│ 8                                           │
│ 6etLyiz0 .                                  │
│ etoz-¥2-L0 .                                │
│                                             │
│ Too EOS                                     │
│ tL sew #9 asuw                              │
│ av 0s ana                                   │
│ 40a 40x                                     │
│                                             │
│ WAN Oa TOVE                                 │
│ ‘iy 03 BIO                                  │
│                                             │
│ WAST ELE                                    │
│                                             │
│ ¥aLSOU/SASNID ONT                           │
│                                             │
│ s                                           │
│                                             │
│ + + MoTIog OL saDva BHOW                    │
│ 9z ope 99k                                  │
│ -d- 0 -W -i- -O-                            │
│                                             │
│ (z a0) SNOTLIGNOD YO (T uD) SI              │
│                                             │
│ pane                                        │
│                                             │
│ Nate @NT IC ONT 'Z Sau                      │
│                                             │
│ AG GHOWNWW ALITIOVE Sax                     │
│ ALITIOWA dO BAKt                            │
│                                             │
│ NOLLWZINVDYO on                             │
│ AYODSLYO NOILOSTSS a8                       │
│ aazrTwsana .                                │
│ AYOLINON NOTLWINgoa + Lovoes                │
│                                             │
│ z0005                                       │
│ OLD                                         │
│                                             │
│ a SN TOD                                    │
│ © SN TOW                                    │
│ NOLLIGNOD                                   │
│                                             │
│ { SNANTOD                                   │
│ Fwans ang                                   │
│ NOILdO                                      │
│                                             │
│ wan /OuaZ                                   │
│ NOLIONNa                                    │
│                                             │
│ Too gow                                     │
│ ‘SAWN                                       │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯

NYMES
530.07
PAGE
002
•
ROSTER
07-24-2019 02:47:39
GRP.
SPECIFIC.
.
REG
LN
FN
ARSD

ARS
I05N
I05
-936L
85828-054
ABERHANTE
ANNEL
12-11-2018
A-HLD
GllS
G11
-783U
86957-054
ACOSTA-LIRIANO
JUANCARLOS
06-13-2019
A-PRE
E018
E01-50213
86640-054
ACOSTA-SALAZAR
ABEL
03-05-2019
A-PRE
KO9S
K09
-026L
29116-379
ACOSTA-VENTURA
LINCOLN
04-04-2019
A-PRE
E07S
E07
-554U
25404-038
ADAMS
GARY
05-20-2019
A-DES
E11S
E11
-588U
49259-054
ADAMS
RAMON
06-04-2019
A-DES
E12S
E12-59413
14340-067
ADAMS
RICHARD
01-14-2019
A-DES
K02N
K02
-115U
85564-054
AGUDELO-AGUDELO
ORLANDO
10-31-2018
A-PRE
GO6N
G06
-743L
74458-053
AGUILAR
EUDALDO
04-29-2019
A-HLD
K1OS
K10
-043L
85650-053
AL-HAMIDI
ALI
01-10-2019
A-PRE
GO9S
G09-76813
93031-083
ALEXANDER
BARRY
07-02-2019
A-PRE
207B
Z07-305LAD
77704-054
ALIMEHMETI
SAJMIR
11-27-2018
A-HLD
EO8S
E08-56413
27933-055
ALLS
RODNEY
06-24-2019
A-DES
KO9S
K09
-036L
85978-054
ALMANZAR
NELSON
07-26-2018
A-PRE
KO6N
K06
-148L
86049-054
ALVAREZ
CARLOS
01-22-2019
A-PRE
GO1N
G01-7080
77312-054
ANDREWS
CHRISTOPHE
07-02-2019
A-PRE
E09S
E09
-565L
79767-054
ANGEVINE
JAQUAN
08-03-2018
A-DES
GO5N
G05
-740L
90118-053
ANTNEY
JOHAN
01-28-2019
A-PRE
GO9S
G09-7650
86374-054
ANTONIUS
STEVEN
11-30-2018
A-PRE
E038
E03-52313
86434-054
APSKALNS
MARTINS
12-21-2018
A-PRE
801A
801-215U
86821-054
ARAMBUL
DALIA
04-16-2019
A-PRE
I04N
I04
-930U
91126-053
ARAUJO
GUSTAVO
10-18-2018
A-PRE
E07S
E07
-550U
90522-054
ARDILA
RANDOLPH
04-23-2019
A-DES
E018
E01-5010
85794-054
ARIAS
MINEL
05-06-2019
A-PRE
206A
206-217UAD
79562-054
ARMENTA
GILBERT
07-19-2019
A-PRE
203A
Z03-112LAD
86123-054
ARROYO
ANGEL
04-24-2019
A-PRE
I018
101-905U
85885-053
ARTIS
SOLOMAN
05-28-2015
A-PRE
2078
Z07-302LAD
91782-053
ASAINOV
RUSLAN
07-19-2019
A-PRE
K07S
K07-0030
72419-019
ASHU
CYRIL
05-29-2019
A-PRE
204A
Z04-212LAD
86710-054
AVILA
PATRICK
03-13-2019
A-PRE
K018
K01
-106U
86953-054
AYALA
RICARDO
06-12-2019
A-PRE
GO3N
G03
-721L
94890-038
AYBAR
GERONIMO
11-01-2018
A-PRE
GO6N
G06
-741L
86268-054
AYLLON
HOWARD
01-29-2019
A-HLD
KO6N
K06-14113
76157-054
BABROW
LORENZO
10-19-2018
A-PRE
E04N
E04
-532L
77128-054
BALDE
SOULEYMANE
01-18-2019
A-PRE
204A
204-210LAD
79781-054
BALDEO
HAKEEM
06-24-2019
A-HLD
Kl2S
K12-0620
77863-112
BANG
CHI
04-23-2019
A-PRE
GllS
G11
-785L
85714-054
BANKS
EARL
07-22-2019
A-HLD
K11S
K11
-077L
86820-054
BARBER
BYRON
04-16-2019
A-PRE
E07S
E07
-551L
61881-054
BARNETT
LATSEN
12-17-2018
A-DES
KO7S
K07-0080
23789-057
BARRERA
ESTABAN
07-18-2019
A-HLD
I04N
I04
-929U
45655-054
BARRIENTOS
RENE
02-28-2019
A-PRE
BOLA
801-2100
86154-054
BATISTA
SAMANTHA
09-28-2018
A-PRE
KO4N
K04
-127U
85858-054
BATURI
MUBARAK
02-08-2019
A-HLD
BOLA
B01
-209L
71423-018
BAUTA
&LIANA
04-16-2019
A-HLD
G0002
MORE
PAGES
TO
FOLLOW
.
.
.
NYMES
530*07
*
PAGE
003
GRP.
SPECIFIC.
REG
I06N
I06
-947U
86463-054
E07S
E07
-554U
11608-082
E085
E08
-560L
25001-052
I06N
I06
-946L
86721-054
KO5N
KOS-135L
92404-054
Z06A
Z06-214UAD
70897-054
K115
K11
-060L
71246-054
ZO2A
Z02-203LAD
79407-054
Kl2S
K12
-072U
86403-054
GO9S
G09
-767L
24301-052
Kl2S
K12
-067U
86884-054
E0114
E01
-506L
50501-054
K11S
K11
-056U
79593-054
KO9S
K09
-035U
86412-054
Kl2S
K12
-070U
72612-067
E0GS
E08
-563L
15015-055
E0611
E06
-547L
76309-054
KO5N
K05
-139U
76269-054
KO4N
K04
-125U
86857-054
Z06A
Z06-213UAD
86460-054
E11S
E11
-581L
85410-054
E08S
E08
-564U
70786-050
012S
G12
-793L
19278-104
E05N
E05
-533L
81131-053
GO1N
G01
-703U
83053-053
K04N
K04
-131L
12750-054
K07S
K07
-010L
87035-054
GO1N
G01
-707U
66351-054
E10S
E10
-573U
17190-052
E02N
E02-5120
86489-054
E12S
E12
-593U
57297-083
E0511
E05
-535L
86409-054
E11S
E11
-582L
11729-082
K06N
K06
-147U
86792-054
G08S
008-758U
68456-298
EO1N
E01-5060
55210-053
0075
007-750U
86554-054
KO1N
K01
-101U
86919-054
IO2N
IO2
-911U
86630-054
K03N
K03
-123U
85984-054
K03N
K03
-117L
85981-054
E02N
E02-5090
85706-054
E11S
E11
-585U
65759-050
G03N
003-719U
79701-054
0095
G09
-766L
89972-053
ROSTER

LN BENJAMIN BENJAMIN BENNETT BERNCS BETTIS BINYARD BLACKWELL BLADES BLANCHE BOARIU BOKOV BOOTH BRADFORD BRAHAM BRANT 
BRENON BRIGHT BRISSETT BRITO BROCK BROWN
BROWN BROWN BROWN BROWN BROWN BROWN BRUEN BRUNNER BRYANT BUCHANAN BULLOCK BUNCH BURGOS BURGOS-CABADA BUSSEY BUTLER 
BUTLER BUTLER CABA
BATISTA
CABA
BATISTA
CABAN CABRERA CABRERA CALABRIA
G0002
MORE
PAGES
TO
FOLLOW
.
FN LUIDJI SEBASTIAN EDWARD PAVELS ZUBEARU EDWARD TAYSHAWN CHRISTAN NAZAE MARCEL JEVGENI RONNELL DAVID DARIEL JOSEPH 
TIMOTHY PETER JAMAL MAXIMILIAN MARK ALLEN
CHAD JOHN KAREEN MICHAEL MICHAEL RAKIM DUANE KENNETH WARREN JOHN CHRISTOPHE JASON ANTONIO JOSE JAVON DENARD RAHSAAN 
TUREAN HECTOR LUIS SAMMUEL CHRISTIAN JOHN
JOSEPH
ARSD 01-07-2019 07-08-2019 01-22-2019 07-16-2019 07-03-2019 07-23-2019 07-16-2019 08-17-2017 03-13-2019 07-02-2019 
05-09-2019 06-05-2019 04-17-2019 12-12-2018
07-03-2019 07-22-2019 05-23-2019 03-13-2019 04-26-2019 01-04-2019 03-18-2019 07-08-2019 03-11-2019 07-20-2016 07-02-2019
06-05-2018 07-19-2019 06-24-2019
12-17-2018 01-10-2019 07-08-2019 12-12-2018 01-14-2019 05-31-2019 05-08-2018 04-03-2019 01-30-2019 05-24-2019 02-28-2019
08-27-2018 08-27-2018 05-17-2018
07-08-2019 03-26-2019 09-26-2018
07-24-2019 02:47:39

ARS A-HLD A-DES A-DES A-HLD A-HLD A-HLD A-HLD A-HLD A-PRE A-HLD A-PRE A-PRE A-HLD A-PRE A-PRE A-DES A-PRE A-PRE A-HLD 
A-PRE A-DES A-DES A-PRE A-PRE A-PRE A-PRE
A-PRE A-HLD A-DES A-PRE A-DES A-PRE A-DES A-HLD A-PRE A-PRE A-PRE A-PRE A-HLD A-PRE A-PRE A-HLD A-DES A-PRE A-PRE
NYMES
530*07
PAGE
004
*
ROSTER
•
07-24-2019 02:47:39
GRP.
SPECIFIC.
.
REG
LN
FN
ARSD

ARS
E01N
E01
-503L
23513-053
CALABRIA
MICHAEL
02-22-2017
A-PRE
IO2N
IO2
-912L
86115-054
CALDERON
JUAN
09-12-2018
A-HLD
GOIN
G01
-705L
79355-054
CAMACHO
FERDINAND
02-16-2018
A-HLD
K09S
K09
-035L
86566-054
CAMILO
-POLANCO
JUAN
06-07-2019
A-PRE
BOBS
E08-5610
86052-054
CAPELLAN
BRIAN
07-15-2019
A-DES
K07S
K07
-002U
41682-054
CARABELLO
FRED
01-04-2019
A-HLD
E05N
E05
-537U
67687-050
CARABUS
ALIN
07-10-2019
A-HLD
GO5N
G05-7360
86509-054
CARDONA
-CARDONA
DAVID
04-29-2019
A-PRE
K11S
K11-0560
86951-054
CARRASCO
ALBERTO
06-12-2019
A-PRE
BOLA
B01
-202L
76049-054
CARRILLO
CINDY
01-30-2019
A-HLD
K07S
K07
-007U
86996-054
CARRILLO
JONATHAN
07-03-2019
A-HLD
I05N
I05
-938L
00633-748
CASTELLE
EUGENE
06-19-2019
A-PRE
KO2N
K02-1150
77281-054
CASTILLO
JUAN
07-23-2019
A-HLD
BOlA
BO1-219U
54630-479
CASTILLO-RODRIGUEZ
LIUDMYLA
06-12-2019
A-HLD
E01N
803-518L
76139-054
CASTILLO
-ROSARIO
GABRIEL
02-01-2019
A-PRE
K10S
K10
-037L
79458-054
CASTILO
FELIX
05-10-2019
A-PRE
E02N
802-514U
76276-054
CASTRO
RICHARD
05-20-2019
A-PRE
GO7S
007-753L
86164-054
CAVE
ETHAN
10-02-2018
A-PRE
K1OS
K10
-046L
85942-054
CAZAREZ
CORNELIO
07-19-2018
A-PRE
I03N
I03
-921U
90859-053
CHACON
JOSE
06-21-2018
A-HLD
ElOS
E10
-573L
90370-053
CHAN
MICHAEL
03-26-2019
A-DES
I03N
I03
-920U
85467-054
CHAN
BAYARDO
MAURICO
07-10-2019
A-PRE
IO1N
I01
-901U
86113-054
CHARDON
MILTON
09-12-2018
A-PRE
801N
E01
-501L
83736-053
CHARLES
NALERTON
05-07-2019
A-PRE
GOBS
008-757L
78548-054
CHERRY
DAVID
11-09-2018
A-HLD
KO1N
K01
-108L
76218-054
CHERRY
ERIC
07-08-2019
A-PRE
KO2N
K02
-116L
86765-054
CHERRY
ROBERT
03-28-2019
A-PRE
EDIN
E01
-504L
67319-054
CHRISTIAN
RAYMOND
08-22-2014
A-HLD
GO3N
003-719L
75605-054
CIFUENTES-VILLA
HILEEBRAND
03-15-2019
A-PRE
K05N
K05-1340
86110-054
CITRONELLE
GEORGE
09-12-2018
A-PRE
El2S
812-5930
68683-066
CLARK
ROBERT
02-15-2019
A-DES
E11S
EII-582U
70675-054
CLARKE
WAYNE
01-31-2019
A-DES
I05N
I05
-936U
86712-054
COLDS
JALEN
03-13-2019
A-PRE
G125
G12-7930
79046-054
COLLAZO
HIRAM
05-02-2019
A-PRE
Gl2S
G12-7950
86959-054
COLLINS
VANCE
06-13-2019
A-PRE
E03N
E03
-524U
86700-054
CONLEY
DWAYNE
03-20-2019
A-PRE
010S
G10
-779U
89520-053
CONTRERAS
JHONNY
02-20-2018
A-PRE
807S
E07
-549L
92299-054
COOPER
MATTHEW
05-20-2019
A-DES
K02N
K02
-113U
86655-054
CORLEY
ANTHONY
03-08-2019
A-PRE
K10S
K10
-047U
14661-479
CORONADO
-LOZANO
MARCO
12-04-2017
A-PRE
E03N
803-522U
76280-054
CORREA-YUSTY
WILMER
04-03-2019
A-PRE
GO2N
002-711L
85804-054
COITO
EDDIE
05-23-2019
A-PRE
8075
E07
-554U
86341-054
COTTO
JOSHUA
07-02-2019
A-DES
K02N
K02
-113L
15051-053
COTTON
MELVIN
05-29-2019
A-HLD
G125
G12
-792U
85632-054
CROOKS
ALFRED
07-03-2019
A-HLD
G0002
MORE
PAGES
TO
FOLLOW
.
.
NYMES 530*07
PAGE 005
• ROSTER 07-24-2019
02:47:39
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD ARS
KO2N K02-115U 86972-054 CRUZ PIMENTEL NELSON 06-20-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05 -534U 76258-054 CUEVAS JAVIER 01-24-2019 A-PRE
GO9S G09-7710 91662-053 CUMMINGS JASON 06-28-2019 A-PRE
E09S E09 -568U 89936-053 CUYLER KEVIN 03-27-2019 A-DES
El2S E12-589L 77306-054 DANSOWAH FRANKLIN 12-12-2018 A-DES
I06N I06-948L 86725-054 DARAND ROLANDO 03-20-2019 A-PRE
KO5N K05-133U 76256-054 DAVILA ARMANDO 01-17-2019 A-PRE
K06N K06-144L 86548-054 DAVIS DARIUS 01-25-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06 -543U 79647-054 DAVIS GARY 10-16-2017 A-PRE
K08S K08-0220 85928-054 DAVIS GARY 07-13-2018 A-PRE
E06N E06-542U 89380-053 DAVIS HOWARD 09-27-2018 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-063U 86427-054 DAVIS KAREEM 12-19-2018 A-PRE
KO3N K03-1220 19435-104 DE FREITAS FABIO 02-12-2019 A-PRE
GO1N G01 -706L 76167-054 DE LA CRUZ DIONICIO 10-05-2018 A-PRE
E075 E07 -555L 16520-055 DECAPUA BRANDON 02-25-2019 A-DES
K125 K12-0670 86828-054 DEL CARMEN DERIAN 04-18-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-0181, 85417-054 DEL ORBE LUNA WINSTON 02-28-2018 A-PRE
E11S E11 -582U 79251-054 DELACRUZ HECTOR 07-08-2019 A-DES
KO2N K02-1160 76278-054 DELAROSA AMADO 04-03-2019 A-PRE
E12S E12 -593L 05386-090 DELATORRE PAUL 12-17-2018 A-DES
GO1N G01-7060 86132-054 DELEON OMAR 06-25-2019 A-HLD
K02N K02-1120 86830-054 DELOSANTOS MARIO 04-18-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04 -928U 76300-054 DEMANE DEBIH MARC 07-02-2019 A-PRE
E09S E09-5650 55381-066 DESILVA MICHAEL 01-14-2019 A-DES
E08S E08 -564U 89424-053 DHANNA ANDRE 07-19-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-034L 79491-054 DIAZ ALEXIS 09-04-2018 A-PRE
K0114 K01-1010 78018-054 DIAZ JOSE 08-10-2016 A-HLD
202A 202-2031AD 77930-054 DIAZ ROBERT 01-04-2019 A-PRE
KO3N K03-1170 86248-054 DIAZ -HERNANDEZ AUGUSTIN 10-25-2018 A-PRE
K09S K09-0300 76156-054 DIAZ-MORALEZ VICTOR 05-23-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-0230 71471-054 DIAZ -PALMER OMAR 11-01-2018 A-PRE
205A 205-121LDS 72042-066 DIAZ -TORRES MISAEL 01-23-2019 A-DES
KMS K01-102L 86805-054 DISLA JOSE 04-11-2019 A-HLD
E07S E07-5490 60685-050 DOCKERY MARTIN 04-29-2019 A-DES
201A 201-102LAD 86214-054 DONES MANOLO 01-16-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-216L 76187-054 DREIKSENA SANTA 06-21-2018 A-PRE
EO1N E01 -505L 77665-054 DUMES CHRISTIAN 11-29-2018 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-0650 86764-054 DUNCAN KARL 03-28-2019 A-PRE
GO7S G07-7550 79949-054 DUPREY-VASQUEZ HECTOR 04-04-2019 A-PRE
201A 201-103UAD 86124-054 DURANT LAVELL 09-18-2018 A-HLD
IO2N I02-916L 72418-019 EKE IFEANYI 05-29-2019 A-PRE
GO1N G01 -703L 90791-054 ELANSKY MICHAEL 07-16-2019 A-PRE
GO1N G01-7010 86079-054 ELIAS MARCUS 02-04-2019 A-PRE
KO4N K04-1310 86282-054 ELLISON ANTHONY 11-06-2018 A-PRE
E09S E09-5690 78965-054 EMILIEN ANDRE 03-15-2019 A-DES
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
NYMES 530.'07 '
PAGE 006
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG
G11S G11-788U 76263-054
E05N E05 -539L 78107-054
K011.1 K01-108U 86975-054
HOLA H01-001L 76318-054
E11S E11-582U 25383-014
ZO6A Z06-214UAD 86918-054
I04N I04-932L 81357-053
KO5N K05-1360 76275-054
E04N E04-525U 86846-054
ZOlA 201-105LAD 86102-054
GO6N G06 -748L 86626-054
KO9S K09-025U 51702-069
I05N I05 -933L 86404-054
IO1N I01-903L 90863-053
ElOS E10 -573L 60103-380
G11S G11 -785U 86226-054
ZOLA Z01-108LAD 85775-054
G11S G11 -784L 78341-054
GO6N G06 -743U 34814-054
EllS E11 -582U 64006-037
ZO5A Z05-123UDS 78002-054
G1OS G10 -777L 86824-054
KO2N K02-114U 76268-054
K1OS K10-038L 78695-054
E03N E03 -519U 92339-054
E07S E07 -554U 79793-054
GO2N G02 -714U 85707-054
GO8S G08 -760L 86993-054
G1OS G10 -778L 86800-054
IO2N IO2 -915U 73822-053
KOIN K01-103U 86954-054
GO2N G02 -716L 90774-053
E08S E08 -561L 59632-053
KO3N K03-121L 90462-053
E095 E09 -571L 71121-050
I05N I05-934U 64593-054
G11S G11 -787U 76243-054
GO8S G08 -764U 86368-054
KO6N K06-143U 76195-054
202A Z02-204LAD 75885-054
I06N I06-942U 91182-054
GO9S G09 -767U 76320-054
E05N E05 -533U 85918-054
I04N I04-925L 76162-054
I05N I05-935U 90914-054
ROSTER
LN
ENCARNACION
ENGLISH
EPPS
EPSTEIN
ESCARRAMAN
ESPINAL
ESPINAL -GOMEZ
ESTEBAN
ESTEVEZ
ESTEVEZ
ESTEVEZ-GONZALEZ
ESTRADA-RODRIGUEZ
ETHERIDGE
FANFAN
FAVELA
FELIPE
FELIX
FELIZ
FELTON
FERGUSON
FERNANDEZ
FERNANDEZ
FERNANDEZ
FERNANDEZ
FERNANDEZ -ROSA
FERRER
FERTIDES
FEVERIE
FIGUEROA
FIGUEROA
FIGUEROA
FLORES
FLORES
FLORES -CACHO
FLOYD
FOSTER
FRASCO
FUENTES
GAITHER
GALÁN
GALLICCHIO
GALVEZ-CHIMBO
GAMA -PINEDA
GANAN RAMIREZ
GARCIA
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
FN
JESUS
CLAUDIUS
KEVIN
JEFFREY
ELIAS
GYANCARLO
JOSE ARNUL
OMAR
BRANDON
STEVEN
CARLOS
RAYMOND
TYHEEM
JIMMY
FELICIANO
JOHN
KERRY
RICHARD
JAMES
LAMONT
HENRY
LEONARDO
LUIS
MARK
HECTOR
GREGORY
YASMIL
JAHSON
ANGEL
BENJAMIN
CHARLES
ISRAEL
MARKO
ALEJANDRO
DISHAWN
TOSHNELLE
AGUSTIN
MIGUEL
KEVON
CARLOS
VITO
ROBER
JOSE
CARLOS
BRIAN
07-24-2019
02:47:39
ARSD  ARS
02-08-2019 A-PRE
05-15-2018 A-HLD
06-22-2019 A-PRE
07-08-2019 A-PRE
08-20-2018 A-DES
05-23-2019 A-PRE
05-16-2019 A-HLD
03-21-2019 A-PRE
04-24-2019 A-HLD
09-05-2018 A-PRE
02-28-2019 A-PRE
04-04-2019 A-PRE
12-11-2018 A-HLD
10-03-2018 A-PRE
09-11-2018 A-DES
03-28-2019 A-HLD
04-23-2019 A-HLD
03-05-2019 A-HLD
06-24-2019 A-HLD
06-24-2019 A-DES
06-27-2018 A-DES
05-06-2019 A-PRE
03-13-2019 A-PRE
02-21-2019 A-HLD
02-05-2015 A-PRE
03-28-2019 A-DES
08-20-2018 A-PRE
07-02-2019 A-PRE
07-19-2019 A-PRE
02-13-2019 A-PRE
06-12-2019 A-HLD
12-07-2018 A-PRE
03-11-2019 A-DES
02-06-2018 A-PRE
05-15-2019 A-DES
05-06-2019 A-HLD
12-06-2018 A-PRE
11-29-2018 A-HLD
04-16-2019 A-HLD
03-05-2019 A-HLD
01-17-2019 A-HLD
07-12-2019 A-PRE
05-30-2019 A-HLD
05-28-2019 A-HLD
05-01-2019 A-PRE
NYMES 530•07
PAGE 007
• ROSTER 07-24-2019
02:47:39
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
010S G10 -776U 86878-054 GARCIA DAVID 05-02-2019 A-HLD
205A 205-119LAD 86290-054 GARCIA JACINTO 07-08-2019 A-HLD
K04N K04-1320 77823-054 GARCIA JOSUE 09-20-2018 A-PRE
K02N K02-1090 79043-054 GARCIA-PENA PEDRO 03-05-2019 A-PRE
G125 G12 -789U 91359-053 GASS JUSTIN 12-21-2018 A-PRE
GO6N G06 -747U 79792-007 GEBREMARIAM BEREKET 07-16-2019 A-PRE
KO2N K02-116U 86933-054 GEORGE WILLIAM 06-05-2019 A-HLD
K08S K08-0160 86325-054 GIL CESAR 11-14-2018 A-HLD
GO1N GO1-705U 86292-054 GIL-CABRAL JUAN 11-08-2018 A-PRE
El2S E12-5960 81342-053 GOBA YOUSEF 06-24-2019 A-DES
E098 E09-5670 79460-054 GODBOLD RONALD 01-03-2019 A-DES
E03N E03 -522L 73746-298 GOMEZ JESUS 03-26-2019 A-PRE
K03N K03-122L 53634-424 GOMEZ-LATOREE FERNANDO 01-04-2019 A-PRE
203A Z03-116UAD 86825-054 GONZALEZ DANIEL 04-18-2019 A-PRE
KOSS K08-013L 86021-054 GONZALEZ GODOFREDO 08-30-2018 A-PRE
GO8S 008-762U 78715-054 GONZALEZ JAIME 02-13-2017 A-HLD
204A Z04-212LAD 86617-054 GONZALEZ MARCOS 06-24-2019 A-HLD
E1OS E10 -579L 15657-179 GONZALEZ OSMAR 08-21-2017 A-DES
K125 K12-062L 86097-054 GONZALEZ PETER 07-12-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06 -548L 79984-054 GONZALEZ RICO 03-26-2019 A-HLD
K0114 K01-105L 71628-054 GONZALEZ TEODORO 06-18-2019 A-PRE
GO3N G03 -723L 79486-054 GONZALEZ-SOLIZ JOSE 03-23-2018 A-PRE
KO3N K03-120L 75954-054 GOSWAMI VIJAY 07-23-2019 A-PRE
204A 204-207LAD 23152-014 GOULDBOURNE MARK 05-07-2019 A-PRE
205A 205-123LAD 76161-054 GRANADOS-CORONA EFRAIN 04-26-2018 A-PRE
GO9S G09 -766U 76229-054 GRANDE ARTHUR 10-11-2018 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-072L 85835-054 GRANDY CLARENCE 01-29-2019 A-PRE
GO7S G07 -749U 86639-054 GRAY KARL 03-05-2019 A-PRE
Z03A Z03-115UAD 70887-054 GRAYSON MARK 05-30-2018 A-HLD
ElOS E10 -575U 90504-053 GREEN RAYQUTAN 05-24-2019 A-DES
E03N E03-5200 76231-054 GREENWOOD KARL 10-19-2018 A-PRE
K07S K07-007L 85966-054 GRIFFIN LAMAR 01-09-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-5270 37897-054 GRIFFIN RODNEY 04-03-2018 A-PRE
IO2N IO2 -914L 86114-054 GRULLAR WILLIAM 10-05-2018 A-HLD
GO5N 005-733L 08820-070 GUILLEN GABRIEL 05-13-2019 A-HLD
GOSN G05-7330 79465-054 GUILLEN WILSON 06-06-2019 A-HLD
IO1N I01-902L 86256-054 GULIJEV MIRAGA 02-15-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-025L 86317-054 GUO QIANG 11-14-2018 A-PRE
E07S E07-549U 84831-054 GUPTA RONNISH 12-26-2018 A-DES
GlOS G10 -775L 86562-054 GUZMAN RANDY 06-25-2019 A-HLD
011S G11 -787L 85796-054 GUZMAN-CASTILLO BERNARDO 07-10-2019 A-PRE
G03N 003-722U 76151-054 HADDOW RENWICK 06-01-2019 A-PRE
E08S 508-564U 21066-014 HAILEY CARL 06-03-2019 A-DES
El2S E12 -595L 50645-037 HALEY ANDRE 05-20-2019 A-DES
E02N E02 -516L 86988-054 HALL STEVEN 07-01-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
NYMES 530*07 * ROSTER 07-24-2019
PAGE 008 02:47:39
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
E05N E05-5390 87014-054 HARGROVE JAKEEM 07-11-2019 A-HLD
K12S K12-0610 86771-054 HARRIS DARRELL 04-01-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06 -541L 79410-054 HARRIS NICHOLAS 08-17-2017 A-HLD
E095 E09 -572L 13510-067 HARRIS PERCY 08-21-2018 A-DES
E08S E08 -557L 57084-056 HARRISON MICHAEL 07-11-2018 A-DES
BO1A B01 -204L 85973-054 HATCHER SHARON 07-26-2018 A-PRE
G07S G07 -751L 75633-053 HAYES NICHOLAS 01-29-2018 A-PRE
203A 203-115LAD 14728-055 HEMINGWAY ANDRE 07-13-2019 A-DES
K02N K02-110L 06809-000 HERNANDDEZ-VALDEZ PEDRO 01-08-2019 A-PRE
G03N G03-718U 76287-054 HERNANDEZ FRANCISO 07-08-2019 A-HLD
IO1N I01-901L 68126-054 HERNANDEZ WILLIAM 12-21-2018 A-PRE
I04N I04-931U 17838-104 HERNANDEZ-ALVARDO JUAN 12-18-2018 A-PRE
KO8S K08-0180 56032-018 HERNANDEZ-CLAUDIOS ESTEVAN 06-25-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01 -210L 79305-054 HERRERA KARILIE 02-12-2019 A-HLD
K03N K03-1210 25253-052 HERRERA SERGIO 10-16-2018 A-PRE
K05N K05-1360 77211-054 HEYWARD CORY 08-07-2018 A-HLD
E05N E05 -537L 86287-054 HIDALGO-MENDOZA VICTOR 06-26-2019 A-PRE
G02N G02 -710L 79455-054 HILL JAQUEZ 08-17-2017 A-PRE
GO6N G06 -742L 86271-054 HINES CUTIS 01-29-2019 A-PRE
K03N K03-123L 76101-054 HO CHI PING 03-26-2019 A-HLD
Z06A 206-2150AD 45623-007 HOGAN CHRISTOPHE 06-10-2019 A-STDY
G12S G12-7960 86372-054 HOLLAND DAVID 11-30-2018 A-PRE
I01N I01-906L 86200-054 HOOKER DARNEL 07-03-2019 A-HLD
Z06A 206-216LAD 68152-054 HOYT KENNETH 05-21-2019 A-PRE
G09S G09 -769L 87002-054 HUDSON CALVIN 07-09-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-0110 86046-054 HUDSON DARRELL 08-13-2018 A-PRE
5060 E06-54713 62670-054 HUSSETT DEVON 07-18-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03 -918U 86776-054 IBANEZ-FELIX LIBRADO 05-22-2019 A-PRE
E040 E04 -526L 79606-054 IDELFONSO ANDRES 05-03-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-073U 77737-112 IGNATOV KONSTANTIN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
IO2N I02-916U 88595-479 IKEJIMBA JOSHUA 06-04-2019 A-PRE
E04N 1304-527L 61743-054 INNIS PATRICK 11-20-2018 A-HLD
I03N I03-918L 77588-054 INZUNZA ABRAHAM 02-07-2019 A-HLD
G08S 008-759U 71776-018 IRIZARRY JORGE 04-09-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-9220 86979-054 ISOM-JENKINS JABARI 06-26-2019 A-HLD
E1OS E10-5730 85687-054 JACKSON ERIK 06-27-2019 A-DES
G09S G09 -769U 86944-054 JACKSON HARVEY 06-06-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05 -939L 86174-054 JACKSON JEROME 04-11-2019 A-HLD
205A 205-123LAD 79729-054 JACKSON RAMEL 11-06-2017 A-HLD
I05N I05-940U 68430-054 JAQUEZ CARLOS 06-27-2019 A-PRE
003N G03 -720U 79306-054 JAQUEZ LUIGI 07-06-2017 A-PRE
G03N G03 -724U 76212-054 JARQUIN ARMANDO 09-08-2018 A-PRE
GlOS G10 -773L 79466-054 JIMENEZ EDWARD 08-22-2017 A-PRE
I03N I03 -920U 86269-054 JIMENEZ RICHARD 01-29-2019 A-PRE
G02N 002-715U 76319-054 JIMENEZ-CASTILLO JUNIOR 07-12-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMES 530*07 *
PAGE 009
GRP. SPECIFIC. REG
K09S K09-031U 76235-054
G08S G08 -763U 85890-054
K11S K11-053U 61876-054
Z02A Z02-201LAD 50972-054
I03N I03 -917L 86461-054
I06N I06 -943U 86885-054
K123 K12-069U 86627-054
G11S G11 -786U 86947-054
GOBS G08 -763L 85880-054
I06N I06-941L 06178-104
KI2S K12-065L 17742-104
Z02A 202-201LAD 68302-054
201A ZO1-106UAD 87016-054
GO6N G06 -745U 69033-054
K06N K06-141L 75996-054
K05N K05-135U 86931-054
E01N E01 -502L 83565-098
K115 K11-053U 86535-054
2078 Z07-306LAD 90479-053
Z05A Z05-121LDS 86108-054
KO1N KO1-105U 76306-054
E04N E04 -528L 86018-054
G125 G12 -792L 87003-054
E01N E01 -508U 22484-040
K075 K07-073L 26178-017
Kl2S K12-067U 60899-054
E06N E06 -545U 26868-055
Z03A 203-112LAD 86587-054
6075 E07 -556U 50659-018
I05N I05 -934L 67531-054
G125 G12 -790L 92398-054
K10S K10-076L 76312-054
K07S K07-008L 79196-054
K07S K07 -011L 86956-054
5105 E10 -574U 76140-066
5108 E10 -576L 89579-053
G09S G09 -770L 86357-054
601A B01 -202U 56431-479
I03N I03 -917U 85838-054
E115 E11 -582U 48958-054
G02N G02 -716U 85782-298
K10S K10-076U 05585-070
IO2N I02-910U 86343-054
E03N E03 -520L 18028-104
602N E02 -511L 86389-054
ROSTER
LN
JIMENEZ-GONZALEZ
JOHNSON
JOHNSON
JOHNSON
JOHNSON
JOHNSON
JONES
JONES
JONES
JONES
JONES
JONES
JONES
JORDAN
JOSEPH
KABA
KALABA
KAMARA
KANDIC
KEARSE
KELLY
KENNEDY
KENYATTA
KERNS
KHUKHIASHVILI
KING
KING
KINTEA
KIRK
KNOX
KOLMNELA
KORETSKYY
KOURANI
KROMAH
LAHENS
LAMARCO
LANS
LAURE-TESISTECO
LAWRENCE
LAWTON
LEAL
LEBRON
LEE
LEON-MAAL
LEVINSON
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
FN
ALBERT
DANDRE
JAMAL
JAMEL
JERMAINE
TORRIE
CHAZ
DARRYL
JAFARI
JOHNNY
MICHAEL
RAYSHAUN
THERYN
MARKEEM
DENFORD
MORA
ZEF
ABRAHIM
MIRSAD
RA KING
JAMES
JABARI
CHARLES
JAMES
TENGIZ
BOB
BRUCE
MCKENZIE
ANTHONY
WILLIAM
LEOM
MYKHAYLO
ALI
MOAZU
VLADIMIR
DANIEL
LEROY
RITA
CHRISTOPHE
ANTOINE
RAYMUNDO
HECTOR
NICK
ALEJANDRO
NIKOLAY
ARSD
04-25-2019
06-28-2018
06-11-2019
11-14-2018
01-04-2019
07-01-2019
02-28-2019
06-11-2019
03-28-2019
07-02-2019
10-30-2018
06-03-2019
07-11-2019
06-30-2019
05-24-2017
06-05-2019
05-31-2019
04-23-2019
11-01-2017
09-11-2018
05-16-2019
08-30-2018
07-09-2019
07-17-2019
02-12-2019
07-23-2019
05-31-2019
06-17-2019
06-24-2019
10-11-2018
09-18-2018
05-31-2019
05-16-2019
06-13-2019
06-10-2019
03-13-2019
03-14-2019
01-28-2019
06-24-2019
05-20-2019
07-16-2019
04-23-2019
07-17-2019
03-26-2019
12-04-2018
07-24-2019
02:47:39
ARS
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-DES
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-DES
A-DES
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-DES
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
NYMES 530*07
PAGE 010
* ROSTER * 07-24-2019
02:47:39
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
K04N K04-129U 68417-054 LEWIS DEVON 03-11-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09 -075U 86748-054 LI TIAN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-0040 86570-054 LITVINTSUK VIKTOR 02-06-2019 A-PRE
IOIN I01-904U 85832-054 LLANES TITO 05-29-2019 A-HLD
G09S G09 -770U 76244-054 LLOYD THOMAS 06-14-2019 A-PRE
E095 E09 -570L 79440-054 LOGAN RAMEL 04-01-2019 A-DES
K07S K07 -012L 79246-054 LOMISHVILI GIORGI 08-23-2018 A-PRE
K08S K08-015U 76291-054 LONDONO OSVALDO 04-16-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04 -529U 91661-053 LOPEZ ALFRED 06-28-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04 -929L 86656-054 LOPEZ ANDRE 03-08-2019 A-PRE
K06N K06-145U 20472-038 LOPEZ CARLOS 01-08-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07 -008U 51698-054 LOPEZ JOEL 05-16-2019 A-PRE
GOSN G05 -739U 86571-054 LOPEZ JOSE 02-06-2019 A-PRE
E09S E09 -567L 79990-054 LOPEZ JUSTIN 01-28-2019 A-DES
K03N K03-118L 90325-053 LOPEZ LOUIS 10-16-2017 A-PRE
El2S E12 -591U 15934-014 LOPEZ STEVEN 06-24-2019 A-DES
KO4N K04-132L 70381-054 LOPEZ-HERNANDEZ JACKSON 02-28-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-033L 76245-054 LORA JOSE 12-06-2018 A-PRE
G07S 007-754L 86375-054 LOVELL SHERVINGTO 11-30-2018 A-PRE
204A 204-210UAD 86356-054 LOVICK FUGUAN 11-27-2018 A-HLD
205A 205-123UAD 85841-054 LUCRE BENJAMIN 06-20-2018 A-PRE
GOSN G05 -737L 70583-054 LYNCH DANIEL 01-08-2019 A-PRE
G08S G08 -761U 65947-056 MABLE TEVIN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
GOSN 005-737U 86943-054 MACK ALJERMIAH 06-06-2019 A-PRE
E02N E02-512L 86602-054 MACK MICHAEL 02-14-2019 A-HLD
K10S K10-043U 86883-054 MAGERRAMOV AMID 05-09-2019 A-PRE
GO3N G03 -722L 76185-054 MAGNI FILIPPO 03-11-2019 A-HLD
El2S E12 -596L 24988-014 MAHMOOD TALLAT 07-08-2019 A-DES
801A B01-216L 76261-054 MAKSIMOVIC DIANA 07-10-2019 A-PRE
E07S E07 -554L 20170-052 MALANGA DANIEL 06-24-2019 A-DES
G10S G10 -774L 72280-054 MALDONADO JONATHAN 05-02-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-055U 86917-054 MALHOTRA GUNJIT 05-23-2019 A-PRE
KOBS K08-022L 89744-053 MALKEYEV VYACGESLAV 08-10-2018 A-PRE
K06N K06-142L 86569-054 MANAF HAJI ABDUL 02-06-2019 A-PRE
I01N I01 -905L 64708-007 MANSARAY NABIU 05-16-2018 A-PRE
KO8S K08-016L 01558-112 MANSON ERIC 08-31-2018 A-PRE
IO1N I01 -902U 76003-054 MARAT-UULU BAKAI 03-27-2019 A-HLD
IO2N I02-909U 37756-034 MARGOLIES WOLFE 06-24-2019 A-PRE
E07S E07-551U 69572-054 MARGOLLA ROBERTO 06-10-2019 A-DES
G03N 003-720L 76178-054 MARQUEZ-ORTIZ JERYLAN 03-28-2019 A-STDY
K08S K08-014U 86351-054 MARRERO JOHNATHON 11-26-2018 A-PRE
GO1N G01 -704U 76539-067 MARRERO NORMAN 06-03-2019 A-PRE
E07S E07 -555U 11867-087 MARSHALL MICHAEL 07-08-2019 A-DES
I04N I04-931L 90514-054 MARTES JOSE 06-06-2019 A-PRE
204A 204-207UAD 86887-054 MARTIN ANTHONY 05-10-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
NYMES 530.07 * ROSTER 07-24-2019
PAGE 011 02:47:39
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
K01N K01-101U 25768-050 MARTINEZ ELLIOT 06-25-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-027U 85976-054 MARTINEZ JOSE 05-31-2019 A-HLD
GOBS G08 -760U 69055-054 MARTINEZ LENNO 06-25-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-912U 86111-054 MARTINEZ NOEL 06-10-2019 A-HLD
K02N K02 -111L 27758-050 MARTINEZ RICHARD 07-12-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-927L 76279-054 MARTINEZ-LOPEZ MODESTO 04-03-2019 A-PRE
ZO1A 201-107LAD 66171-054 MATTHEWS CHARLES 06-11-2019 A-DES
IO1N I01 -908L 91753-054 MATTHEWS MICHAEL 05-13-2019 A-HLD
GUS G11 -782U 85716-054 MATUTE EMIL 05-22-2018 A-PRE
BO1A BO1-217L 33919-171 MCCASKILL ELIZABETH 01-23-2019 A-PRE
K06N K06-143L 90800-053 MCCLOUD JAMES 05-02-2019 A-PRE
E02N E02 -509L 19039-054 MCCOY SAMUEL 02-15-2019 A-HLD
K12S K12-064L 86768-054 MCDUFFIE ALBERT 03-28-2019 A-PRE
E11S E11 -584L 71694-050 MCFADDEN DAVID 06-25-2019 A-DES
Z05A Z05-117LDS 85989-054 MCGRIER FREDDIE 04-19-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04 -928L 66881-050 MCINTYRE BRANDON 10-01-2018 A-PRE
G07S G07 -754U 89196-053 MCKAY RASHAWN 05-23-2018 A-PRE
E08S E08 -564U 65135-054 MCKINNON JOHN 06-01-2019 A-DES
KO1N KO1-1010 69309-054 MCQUEEN ALIE 06-05-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-924L 79339-054 MEDINA WILFRED 01-11-2019 A-HLD
K12S K12-065U 92150-054 MEIGHAN AKBAR 07-03-2019 A-HLD
K03N K03-124L 91114-054 MEJIA-VARGAS MARIO 01-29-2019 A-HLD
K02N K02-109L 85799-054 MELENDEZ LUIS 05-01-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03 -518U 61162-054 MENA-CANCEL JESUS 06-19-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05 -540L 84246-054 MENDOZA HECTOR 05-23-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04 -532U 57916-054 MENDOZA-SOLAN ALEX 07-19-2019 A-PRE
G06N G06 -748U 85606-054 MERCADO GABRIEL 05-30-2018 A-HLD
K12S K12-061L 86026-054 MERCHANT SEAN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
E12S E12 -592U 89673-053 MERSEY WILLIAM 06-06-2019 A-DES
K10S K10-047L 85941-054 MEZA SINOHE 07-19-2018 A-PRE
202A Z02-201LAD 86160-054 MICKENS DION 07-16-2019 A-HLD
X11S K11-054L 85771-054 MILLER DARREN 06-27-2019 A-HLD
G06N G06 -742U 79412-054 MILLER RAHIEM 08-17-2017 A-HLD
E01N E01-504U 79487-054 MINJAREZ SANTOS 05-23-2019 A-HLD
203A Z03-116LAD 85605-054 MOBLEY COREY 04-24-2018 A-HLD
K12S K12-068L 79047-054 MODESTO AMAURY 01-24-2019 A-HLD
K10S K10-044U 86044-054 MOHAMED MOHAMED 09-24-2018 A-PRE
ZOIA Z01-108LAD 91268-054 MOJICA JASON 02-19-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-074L 86024-054 MONASTERIO LUIS 08-30-2018 A-PRE
G07S G07 -756U 19735-104 MONES-CORO VICTOR 06-13-2019 A-PRE
E11S E11 -583L 19668-052 MONGO EQUAN 03-19-2019 A-BOP HLD
G10S G10 -778U 77708-054 MONSANTO LOPEZ DANIEL 05-23-2019 A-HLD
K06N K06-148U 86272-054 MONTAS HUGO 10-31-2018 A-PRE
G10S G10 -777U 86353-054 MONTES BRANDON 06-25-2019 A-HLD
E04N E04 -529L 63901-054 MOODY ANDREW 01-23-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
-
NYMES
530*07
PAGE
012
*
ROSTER
•
07-24-2019 02:47:39
GRP.
SPECIFIC.
.
REG
LN
FN
ARSD

ARS
K1OS
K10
-042L
79784-054
MOORE
DERRICK
10-22-2018
A-HLD
KO6N
K06-1450
14532-104
MOORE
JAMES
06-10-2019
A-HLD
Kl1S
K11-0510
87036-054
MORA
ANTONIO
07-19-2019
A-HLD
KO7S
K07
-002L
86701-054
MORA
ARTURO
06-10-2019
A-HLD
206A
206-2130AD
86384-054
MORA
BRYAN
12-03-2018
A-HLD
Kl1S
K11-0550
86260-054
MORA
KEVIN
10-29-2018
A-PRE
IO1N
I01
-903U
86432-054
MORCILIO
RUBEN
12-20-2018
A-HLD
SOLA
B01-2090
91449-053
MOREAU
MAGEN
07-11-2019
A-HLD
BOIA
501-2040
90780-053
MOREL
-CRUZ
CAROLINA
07-01-2019
A-PRE
E05N
E05
-536L
87022-054
MUNOZ
HECTOR
07-15-2019
A-PRE
GO1N
GO1-702L
85769-054
MURPHY
ERNEST
06-06-2018
A-PRE
204A
Z04-211UAD
57497-054
MURRAY
DONNELL
04-11-2019
A-HLD
KO5N
K05-1380
86974-054
MURRAY
EZZARD
06-22-2019
A-PRE
I03N
I03
-922U
86019-054
MYRIE
JERMAINE
08-30-2018
A-PRE
206N
E06
-544U
86968-054
NAGI
BILAL
06-19-2019
A-HLD
E12S
E12
-594L
76311-053
NAGI
FIKRI
05-02-2019
A-DES
G07S
007-755L
76172-054
NAJERA-MONTOYA
FREDY
03-15-2018
A-PRE
I03N
I03
-924U
90218-054
NAUT
JUAN
06-06-2019
A-HLD
201A
201-1070AD
86719-054
NAVEDO
CHRISTIAN
03-14-2019
A-PRE
K06N
K06-1420
86301-054
NAWAZ
AHMED
06-25-2019
A-HLD
801A
B01-2190
85954-054
NAZINA
I ELYZAVETA
03-15-2019
A-HLD
2105
E10
-575L
79492-054
NEGROPONTE
GIANFRANCO
12-11-2018
A-DES
GO1N
G01-7020
85772-054
NEWTON
DEVONTAE
05-17-2019
A-HLD
E06N
E06
-548U
86923-054
NICHOLAS
MALIK
OS
-30-2019
A-HLD
KO6N
K06-1460
78838-054
NOBLE
KASAN
11-01-2018
A-HLD
K07S
K07
-009L
91349-053
NOBOA
MARIO
12-20-2018
A-PRE
Kl2S
K12
-069L
86407-054
NORRIS
SAEED
12-12-2018
A-PRE
GO7S
007-7520
85738-054
NORVILLE
DWAYNE
05-30-2018
A-HLD
ElOS
210-5730
68111-054
NUNEZ
FRANKLIN
06-25-2019
A-DES
KO2N
K02
-112L
70164-054
NUNEZ
JOSE
06-10-2019
A-HLD
K09S
K09-0330
78025-053
NUNEZ
STARLIN
03-26-2019
A-HLD
G02N
002-715L
76194-054
OCAMPO-ALVAREZ
RUBEN
04-20-2019
A-PRE
K08S
K08
-020L
86074-054
OCHOA
OVIDIO
06-06-2019
A-PRE
IO2N
IO2
-912U
86452-054
OCHOA
PERCY
01-02-2019
A-PRE
005N
G05-7380
85780-054
OGARRO
TYREEK
05-17-2019
A-HLD
GO5N
G05-7350
72661-054
OJEDA
CALVIN
05-31-2018
A-HLD
K04N
K04
-128L
91980-054
OLANGIAN
REZA
01-25-2019
A-HLD
801A
B01
-218L
75936-054
OLIVERA
JUDIE
06-28-2019
A-HLD
K08S
K08
-021L
76249-054
OROZCO
JOSE
07-17-2019
A-HLD
I04N
I04
-925U
19732-104
ORSINI-QUINTERO
MICHOLS
04-09-2019
A-PRE
K1OS
K10-0391
85805-054
ORTIZ
ERVIN
06-13-2018
A-PRE
K04N
K04-1260
65410-054
ORTIZ
LUIS
08-31-2018
FED
WRIT
09-11-2018
A-HLD
203A
203-1130AD
85875-054
OUTLAW
KEITH
06-27-2018
A-HLD
0118
011-781L
79551-054
OWEN
WALSTON
11-13-2017
A-PRE
G0002
MORE
PAGES
TO
FOLLOW
.
.
.
NYMES
530*07
*
ROSTER
*
07-24-2019
PAGE
013
02:47:39
GRP.
SPECIFIC.
.
REG
LN
FN
ARSD

ARS
GO6N
G06
-745L
79415-054
OWENS
DOUGLAS
08-17-2017
A-HLD
GO7S
G07
-752L
74125-053
PAGETT
LARRY
10-05-2018
A-HLD
ZO4A
204-212UAD
79166-054
PALERMO
HECTOR
11-20-2018
A-HLD
E03N
E03
-519L
85979-054
PAPOSHVILI
GOCHA
08-09-2018
A-PRE
Elf/5
E10
-576U
76364-066
PARR
ROBERT
06-10-2019
A-DES
GO6N
006-747L
70497-050
PECORELLA
ALAN
06-25-2019
A-STDY
K11S
K11
-051U
13717-041
PEJIC
VEDRAN
03-06-2019
A-HLD
K09S
K09
-031L
90649-054
PENA
EDWARD
11-27-2018
A-PRE
GIOS
010-776L
85977-054
PENA
ROBERT
07-26-2018
A-PRE
K11S
K11
-053U
86222-054
PERALTA
ORLANDO
02-25-2019
A-HLD
G125
012-791U
86198-054
PEREZ
ANTHONY
04-16-2019
A-HLD
E02N
E02
-514L
85435-054
PEREZ
BILLY
03-08-2018
A-HLD
206A
Z06-219LAD
78346-054
PEREZ
CHRISTIAN
05-24-2018
A-HLD
G08S
008-759L
79095-054
PEREZ
NOEL
06-30-2019
A-HLD
KO4N
K04
-132U
91200-053
PEREZ
SANCHEZ
HUGO
10-26-2018
A-PRE
GO3N
003-723U
90898-053
PEREZ
-SANCHEZ
OVIDIO
06-15-2018
A-PRE
206A
206-216LAD
14949-057
PIERCE
RICHARD
08-25-2015
A-DES
GOBS
G08
-758L
76193-054
PINEDA-OTALVARO
JOSE
06-27-2018
A-PRE
I06N
I06
-944L
18346-037
PINKNEY
ANTHONY
05-22-2019
A-PRE
E03N
E03
-523L
86435-054
PIRINS
IGORS
12-21-2018
A-PRE
E02N
E02
-513L
78702-054
POLANCO
JASON
04-20-2018
A-HLD
KO8S
KOB-021U
86369-054
POLANCO
SERGIO
03-24-2019
A-HLD
GO8S
008-761L
58001-054
POLK
TERRELL
02-06-2017
A-HLD
E085
E08
-560L
62541-050
POWELL
BARRY
05-29-2018
A-DES
I06N
I06
-947L
85484-054
POWELL
MARIO
03-24-2018
A-PRE
K08S
K08
-014L
76149-054
PRICE
GREGORY
04-17-2018
A-PRE
GO2N
002-712L
92418-054
PROFIT
TRAVIS
11-15-2018
A-HLD
KO5N
K05
-133L
71538-019
PULIDO-LOPEZ
MARIO
04-10-2018
A-PRE
G125
G12
-794U
85822-054
QU
JIAN
06-18-2018
A-PRE
ZO1A
Z01-104UAD
86210-054
QUIROGA
FRANK
07-08-2019
A-PRE
GO2N
002-709L
86608-054
RAGONESE
RYAN
02-21-2019
A-PRE
KO6N
K06
-142U
91752-053
RAI
GURSIMARDE
07-09-2019
A-PRE
K07S
K07
-008U
89329-053
RAKHMATOR
AZIZJON
05-20-2016
A-PRE
010S
G10
-774U
86879-054
RAMIREZ
ADONIS
05-02-2019
A-HLD
E08S
508-562L
81219-054
RAMIREZ
EDGARDO
07-15-2019
A-DES
IO2N
IO2
-914U
79252-054
RAMIREZ
MIGUEL
10-24-2018
A-HLD
G128
012-795U
86958-054
RAMIREZ
RAMON
06-13-2019
A-PRE
G07S
007-756L
86551-054
RAMIREZ
RONNY
01-29-2019
A-PRE
E03N
E03
-521L
90860-053
RAMIREZ
SAUDI
01-25-2019
A-PRE
IO2N
IO2
-913U
86827-054
RAMIREZ
YISANDER
04-18-2019
A-PRE
801A
BO1-212L
68610-054
RAMIREZ
ZORAIDA
10-22-2018
A-HLD
K115
K11
-059L
55278-054
RAMOS
DANIEL
05-29-2019
A-HLD
IO1N
I01
-907L
78693-054
RAMOS
DOMINGO
04-01-2019
A-HLD
KO5N
K05
-136U
90137-053
RAMOS
FRANCISCO
07-17-2017
A-PRE
GO2N
002-710U
85428-054
RAMOS
JASON
04-26-2019
A-HLD
G0002
MORE
PAGES
TO
FOLLOW
.
.
NYMES 530*07
PAGE 014
* ROSTER • 07-24-2019
02:47:39
GRP. SPECIPIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
ZO5A 205-119UAD 69258-054 RANCIER-MEDRANO FEDERICO 09-02-2016 A-HLD
E05N E05 -535U 90880-053 RAPHAEL KEVIN 06-08-2018 A-PRE
GO2N G02-7090 16296-049 RAWSON KENNETH 06-10-2019 A-STDY
K125 K12-070L 75971-112 RAZUMOVSKIY ALEKSANDR 06-26-2019 A-HLD
G09S 009-768L 43667-007 REESE DEMITRI 05-22-2019 A-STDY
ZO5A Z05-123LAD 85609-054 REID MICHAEL 07-03-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-926L 86623-054 REINALDO ROMAN 02-27-2019 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-078U 86022-054 REINGOUD MURVIN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
E095 E09-571U 08200-070 RENE CHRISTOPHE 05-29-2018 A-DES
GO2N 002-713L 86526-054 REYES ANGEL 05-10-2019 A-HLD
ZO6A 206-218LAD 85993-054 REYES EFRAIN 08-01-2018 A-PRE
G08S 008-762L 79102-054 REYES FRANKIE 05-17-2017 A-PRE
K07S K07-001U 86319-054 REYES -BONILLA JUAN 07-15-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2 -914U 61643-054 REYES-VAZQUEZ RAUL 07-17-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-203L 89522-053 RICHARDSON CAROLYN 06-04-2019 A-HLD
GO7S G07-753U 85735-054 RICHARDSON DAVID 06-25-2019 A-HLD
GO3N G03-718L 69781-479 RINCON-VEGA MARIO 05-24-2019 A-PRE
GO3N 003-717U 76284-054 RIOS JESUS% 04-11-2019 A-PRE
GO3N 003-717L 92336-054 RIVER-MARADIAGA DEVIS 02-20-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03 -920L 91104-054 RIVERA JESSE 09-28-2017 A-HLD
ZO3A Z03-109UAD 86225-054 RIVERA JOSE 10-18-2018 A-PRE
ZO5A Z05-117UAD 72008-054 RIVERA JOSE 05-08-2019 A-DES
0085 G08-7640 86815-054 RIVERA JUSTIN 04-11-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-026U 86848-054 RIVERA LOUIS 04-24-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-0550 06303-082 RIVERA LUIS 06-05-2019 A-HLD
K08S K08-0190 79752-054 RIVERO RICARDO 07-09-2019 A-PRE
El2S E12 -594U 12558-036 ROBERSON CHARLES 07-08-2019 A-DES
801A B01-201L 86411-054 ROBERTS ADRIENNE 07-05-2019 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-072U 86791-054 ROBERTS DAEQUAN 05-16-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06 -541U 85846-054 ROBERTS PARIS 06-20-2018 A-PRE
I06N I06 -948U 34801-058 ROBINSON PHILLIP 06-06-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-003U 85773-054 ROBINSON TYQUAN 04-18-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-946U 78258-112 RODDUBNOV SALMAN 07-02-2019 A-HLD
E04N E04 -525L 86831-054 RODRIGUEZ ADONIS 04-18-2019 A-PRE
KO4N K04-130U 91278-054 RODRIGUEZ DANIEL 06-12-2019 A-PRE
012S 012-796L 29216-050 RODRIGUEZ HENRY 04-05-2019 A-HLD
ZO4A Z04-209LAD 79168-054 RODRIGUEZ JUAN 01-24-2019 A-HLD
011S G11-7810 86224-054 RODRIGUEZ MALI 03-18-2019 A-HLD
E075 E07 -550L 04883-104 RODRIGUEZ MANUEL 06-03-2019 A-DES
I04N I04-932U 86117-054 ROJAS ADAN 09-13-2018 A-PRE
E03N E03 -521U 76160-054 ROJAS -ROMERO EMILIO 04-26-2018 A-PRE
G125 G12 -791L 85670-054 ROLON EDWIN 05-30-2019 A-HLD
ZO1A Z01-107UAD 74203-054 ROMERO MIGUEL 12-09-2015 A-PRE
I03N I03 -923U 78841-054 ROMERO RAFAEL 11-19-2018 A-HLD
K09S K09-0360 76223-054 ROMERO YEURY 05-23-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PACES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMES 530*07
PAGE 015
* ROSTER • 07-24-2019
02:47:39
GAP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD ARS
KlOS K10-045U 85927-054 ROMERO-GRANADOS JUAN 07-12-2018 A-PRE
E03N E03 -524L 86840-054 RONDAN CARLOS 04-23-2019 A-PRE
I06N I06 -943U 86025-054 ROOPWAH MOSES 08-30-2018 A-PRE
IO1N I01 -904L 77980-054 ROPER. COREY 12-10-2018 A-HLD
GO5N G05 -734U 86324-054 ROSA RICKY 11-14-2018 A-PRE
E01N E01-5030 86169-054 ROSARIO JOELKIN 10-03-2018 A-PRE
KO3N K03-124U 26488-038 ROSARIO OSCAR 02-27-2019 A-HLD
EllS E11 -587L 58588-037 ROSS DEVIN 09-12-2018 A-DES
EllS E11 -584U 06084-082 ROSS MICHAEL 04-15-2019 A-DES
G02N G02 -713U 85778-054 ROYSTER KELLY 05-29-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05 -536U 76220-054 RUGARD RUBEN 06-30-2019 A-HLD
G03N G03 -724L 28408-054 RUIZ RENAN 10-30-2017 A-HLD
K11S K11-049U 87034-054 RUSSELL TSANI 07-18-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-077U 77749-054 RUSSO ROBERT 06-27-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-942L 87009-054 SAAB ALI 07-10-2019 A-PRE
K12S K12-069L 70704-054 SAADIA MOTSE 07-11-2019 A-PRE
BOJA 801-208L 89767-053 SAFANI HANNA 03-22-2019 A-PRE
KO9S K09-030L 76005-054 SAINZ-FLORES JULIO 06-08-2017 A-PRE
Z078 207-304LAD 79715-054 SAIPOV SAYFULLO 11-01-2017 A-PRE
KO4N K04-125L 86530-054 SALAHUDDIN KHALIL 01-23-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-930L 49953-018 SALAS TORRES FERNEY 02-07-2019 A-HLD
GO3N G03 -721U 07687-036 SALDANA YEISON 04-19-2019 A-HLD
K08S K08-020U 85571-054 SALEN REDHWAN 07-03-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05 -540U 86263-054 SALVADOR GUSTAVO 07-23-2019 A-HLD
K08S K08-019L 08322-018 SAMUELS -DURAN CARLOS 10-17-2016 A-HLD
BO1A 801-213L 56234-054 SANCHEZ AURORA 04-25-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05 -937U 85759-054 SANCHEZ RAY 04-01-2019 A-HLD
G1OS G10 -775U 85756-054 SANDERS REGINALD 06-05-2018 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-067L 86027-054 SANDS REUBEN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
K09S K09-028U 48816-066 SANTANA JOSE 02-27-2019 A-HLD
G08S G08 -757U 86352-054 SANTIAGO JONATHAN 11-26-2018 A-PRE
ZO3A 203-115UAD 08224-082 SANTIAGO LEON 05-07-2019 A-PRE
E118 E11-585U 80341-083 SANTIAGO-MENDOZA OMAR 04-09-2019 A-DES
K11S K11-054U 79699-054 SANTOS AOUL 10-27-2017 A-PRE
ElOS E10 -576L 99462-038 SANTOS ELLIS 07-22-2019 A-DES
E01N E01 -505U 85816-054 SANTOS JOSE 05-08-2019 A-HLD
G1OS G10 -779L 86638-054 SANTOS -FELIX CRISTOPHER 03-04-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-OO1L 01735-007 SATTAN HAROLD 11-02-2018 A-HLD
KO5N K05-134L 78531-054 SAUNDERS CRAIG 04-25-2019 A-BOP
BOBS E08 -559U 08765-094 SAXÖN JOSEPH 03-18-2019 A-DES
ZOLA 201-104LAD 17781-104 SAYOC CESAR 03-26-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-009L 53413-083 SCALES SYDNEY 02-21-2019 A-PRE
Gl2S G12 -794L 17437-104 SCHIFANO VINCENT 07-18-2019 A-HLD
Z078 Z07-301LAD 79471-054 SCHULTE JOSHUA 05-02-2019 A-PRE
GOON G06 -741U 76292-054 SEARLES JARED 04-17-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
HLD
NYMES 530.07 • ROSTER
PAGE 016
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG
Z06A Z06-219LAD 28569-057
GO5N G05 -736L 83721-053
E010 E01-508L 08379-068
ZO1A 201-108LAD 53267-054
KO5N K05-136L 86277-054
E04N E04-5260 71996-054
K1OS K10-046U 86819-054
GO9S G09 -771L 86960-054
K113 K11-051L 68555-066
BO1A 801-217L 76323-054
E07S E07 -553L 24263-052
BO1A B01-217U 85797-053
I05N I05-933U 19494-104
Gl2S G12-7900 72229-054
K12S K12-0680 86891-054
I03N 103-920U 90311-053
E115 E11-5880 78175-054
KO7S K07-0070 76322-054
E04N E04-5310 85833-054
E11S E11-5860 90517-053
I05N I05-938U 85408-054
I03N 103-923L 86516-054
KO2N K02-1100 86909-054
KO2N K02-114L 26142-038
IO1N I01-9060 77179-054
BO1A B01-2070 86961-054
ZO3A 203-1110AD 69065-054
E060 E06 -545L 86796-054
K12S K12-063L 86616-054
IO1N I01-908U 91161-053
K08S K08-013U 86023-054
GO5N G05 -735U 85781-054
E02N E02 -516U 85991-054
ZO3A Z03-110LAD 79662-054
K118 K11-052L 11714-052
206A Z06-215UAD 78514-054
E03N E03 -517L 73974-112
1303N E03 -517U 86553-054
E05N E05 -538U 86995-054
KO7S K07-0070 30772-069
KO1N K01-1010 09521-054
EO2N E02 -510L 91183-054
K11S K11-0510 86934-054
I04N I04 -927U 91251-054
KO1N K01-102U 56772-054
LN
SEARS
SEGUI
SEIBER
SELLERS
SEMIDAY
SEPULVEDA
SERRANO
SHARPERSON
SHERAK
SHOKRALLA
SHOWERS
SIDDIQUI
SIMON
SISNERO-GIL
SMALLS
SMART
SMITH
SMITH
SMITH
SOBERS
SOSA
SOSA-DIAZ
SOSA-ORTIZ
SOTO
SOUTHWELL
SPINELLI
SPRULL
STAFFORD
STEVEN
STUART
SUCRE
SUMPTER
SUVERIN
TABAR
TABOADA
TARTAGLIONE
TAVARES
TAVARES-BRITO
TAVAREZ-MOTA
TAVERAS
TAYLOR
TAYLOR
TAYLOR
TEJADA
THERIAULT
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
07-24-2019
02:47:39
FN  ARSD  ARS
JOSHUA 03-11-2019 A-DES
FRANK 02-25-2019 A-PRE
RONALD 04-19-2019 A-HLD
DOUGLAS 06-04-2018 A-PRE
LUIS 11-01-2018 A-PRE
ANGEL 07-23-2018 A-HLD
JOE 04-16-2019 A-PRE
LEROY 06-13-2019 A-HLD
STEPHEN 11-06-2018 A-HLD
MARY 07-12-2019 A-PRE
RONALD 04-29-2019 A-DES
ASIA 07-11-2019 A-PRE
JAMAL 02-12-2019 A-PRE
MARLON 04-12-2019 A-PRE
LEON 05-10-2019 A-PRE
SHAUN 12-21-2017 A-PRE
BRANDON 06-03-2019 A-DES
DAVID 07-12-2019 A-PRE
SHASHIEME 06-20-2018 A-PRE
BRENT 03-11-2019 A-DES
PEDRO 04-30-2019 A-HLD
HENYEL 02-19-2019 A-PRE
NESTOR 05-20-2019 A-PRE
LUIS 06-30-2019 A-HLD
MARQUIS 06-11-2019 A-PRE
DOREEN 06-17-2019 A-HLD
MATTHEW 03-06-2019 A-PRE
SIRRON 04-10-2019 A-PRE
WILLIAM 03-05-2019 A-HLD
JOSHUA 05-06-2019 A-PRE
NERIDIO 08-30-2018 A-PRE
TYRELL 06-06-2018 A-HLD
MAXIM 07-31-2018 A-PRE
HALLIL 03-13-2019 A-HLD
RICARDO 02-07-2019 A-PRE
NICHOLAS 03-19-2019 A-PRE
ALEX 08-10-2018 A-HLD
YIRAN 01-30-2019 A-PRE
DORLYN 07-03-2019 A-PRE
JAIRO 07-18-2019 A-HLD
CLIFFORD 05-22-2019 A-HLD
DAVID 12-06-2018 A-PRE
NATHANIEL 06-25-2019 A-HLD
JOEL 06-17-2019 A-PRE
MICHAEL 04-12-2019 A-PRE
NYMES 530*07 * ROSTER
PAGE 017
07-24-2019
02:47:39
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG  LN FN ARSD ARS
ElOS E10 -580L 79823-054 THOMAS DAVID 12-10-2018 A-DES
K01N K01-103L 66151-054 THOMAS GLENN 08-22-2014 A-HLD
K1OS K10-044L 79965-054 THOMAS JASON 02-06-2019 A-HLD
GOIN G01 -708L 79310-054 THOMAS LARRY 07-12-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-074U 79652-054 THOMAS WILLIAM 02-07-2019 A-HLD
G06N G06 -744L 16725-028 THOMPSON JAHEED 07-18-2019 A-HLD
EllS E11 -581U 78359-053 TISDALE MICHAEL 01-14-2019 A-DES
K08S K08-015L 86107-054 TIURIN ANDREI 09-07-2018 A-PRE
K01N K01-105U 86179-054 TOLENTINO DOMINGO 10-09-2018 A-PRE
GO2N G02 -712U 86367-054 TOMLINSON JOWAYNE 07-22-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04 -528U 85608-054 TOPPIN MICHAEL 05-21-2019 A-HLD
E02N E02 -513U 85382-054 TORO TYLER 12-10-2018 A-HLD
KO2N K02-115L 14103-052 TORRES ANTHONY 07-10-2019 A-HLD
E095 E09 -566U 85621-054 TORRES FAUSTO 05-06-2019 A-DES
KO5N K05-136U 85896-054 TORRES FRANCISCO 02-13-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06 -543L 86521-054 TORRES JOSHUA 04-24-2019 A-HLD
GO6N G06 -744L 34957-054 TORRES MARTIN 10-13-2018 A-PRE
ZO5A Z05-118UAD 86020-054 TORRES OMAR 08-30-2018 A-PRE
G105 G10 -780L 85742-054 TOWNSEND DOUGLAS 05-31-2018 A-PRE
E095 E09 -572U 76518-067 TURNER CLAUDE 07-22-2019 A-DES
I06N I06 -945L 25352-083 TURNER WILBERT 04-11-2019 A-PRE
GOIN GO1-701L 79827-054 ULLAH AKAYED 11-07-2018 A-HLD
GO5N G05 -734L 28631-054 URENA ILARIO 04-06-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-075L 68339-054 URENA JUAN 05-23-2019 A-HLD
K04N K04-125L 76277-054 URENA RICHARD 04-03-2019 A-PRE
IO2N I02-911L 65709-054 VALAZQUEZ SAMMY 02-27-2019 A-PRE
KOBS K08-024L 24772-057 VALENZUELA-LIZARRAGA RAMON 12-20-2017 A-HLD
K07S K07-003U 77662-054 VALERIO DAVID 07-23-2019 A-BOP HLD
I05N I05 -938U 79919-054 VAN MANEN PAUL 01-17-2018 A-PRE
I06N I06 -943U 86408-054 VANIER CARLTON 12-12-2018 A-PRE
KlOS K10-039U 29381-050 VARGAS DAVID 12-08-2017 A-PRE
E05N E05 -538L 86880-054 VARGAS JOSE 05-06-2019 A-HLD
K118 K11-049U 86145-054 VARGAS MIGUEL 02-15-2019 A-HLD
ZO5A Z05-118LAD 76290-054 VASQUEZ PERCY 04-16-2019 A-PRE
G10S G10 -773U 79099-054 VEGA OVED 05-17-2017 A-PRE
I03N I03 -919U 76242-054 VEISYON EDWARD 06-28-2019 A-PRE
G11S G11 -784U 79831-054 VENTURA CHARLES 08-06-2018 A-PRE
801A BO1-214U 86297-054 VENTURA MINERVA 07-19-2019 A-STDY
E05N E05 -534L 86285-054 VICIOSO-LIMA PEDRO 11-08-2018 A-PRE
I05N I05-936U 85992-054 VICKERS NAZEER 04-08-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-032U 30982-054 VIERRA MARK 11-08-2018 A-PRE
I04N I04 -926U 85922-054 VILLANUEVA MICHAEL 05-10-2019 A-PRE
KOSN K05-135U 58614-054 VIZZARI GING 07-11-2019 A-PRE
B01A B01-220U 23003-021 VO KIM ANH 06-27-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-071U 86882-054 VORONJUK VITALI 05-09-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
NYMES 530.07
PAGE 018
* ROSTER • 07-24-2019
02:47:39
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
GO6N G06-7460 68342-054 WAGNER MYRON 01-11-2019 A-PRE
KO5N K05-138L 86480-054 WAITERS MARK 01-09-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06 -546L 86900-054 WALKER ALLEN 07-12-2019 A-PRE
K04N K04-127L 02259-748 WALKER DELROY 06-25-2019 A-HLD
G11S G11 -788L 85544-054 WALSH PATRICK 01-14-2019 A-HLD
G11S G11 -786L 86336-054 WALTER FAHEEM 04-08-2019 A-PRE
K1OS K10-0480 77269-112 WANG SHUAIQUI 12-18-2018 A-PRE
E11S E11-5870 63274-037 WARE CRAIG 11-26-2018 A-DES
K06N K06-146L 81078-053 WASHINGTON MAURICE 02-25-2019 A-PRE
Z02A Z02-201LAD 77510-054 WASHINGTON VAUGHN 06-03-2019 A-HLD
KOBS K08-0170 76135-054 WATKINS THOMAS 02-14-2018 A-PRE
I03N I03 -919L 92373-054 NATTIER MICHAEL 03-29-2016 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-078L 85377-054 WEBER JEFFREY 05-29-2019 A-HLD
IO1N I01 -904L 39715-013 WEBSTER MARK 06-26-2019 A-HLD
E04N E04 -531L 57969-054 WESTON BOBBY 07-01-2019 A-PRE
K03N K03-1200 56622-056 WHITAKER TYRELL 08-22-2014 A-HLD
201A Z01-102UAD 85644-054 WHITE KHALIF 05-02-2019 A-DES
K11S K11-0490 76273-054 WHITE LARRY 03-21-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06 -542L 06600-052 WILLIAMS CURTIS 07-22-2019 A-PRE
ZO3A 203-113LAD 78640-054 WILLIAMS DAYVON 06-19-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2 -909L 85310-054 WILLIAMS JAMES 07-10-2019 A-PRE
G06N G06 -746L 79417-054 WILLIAMS JIHAD 08-17-2017 A-HLD
203A Z03-112UAD 86162-054 WILLIAMS SHARIEF 03-26-2019 A-HLD
GO5N G05 -739L 79954-054 WILLIAMS SHAWN 01-25-2018 A-HLD
E085 E08-5570 09310-041 WILLIAMS TIMOTHY 04-30-2019 A-DES
KO4N K04-1320 87008-054 WILLIAMS TONY 07-09-2019 A-HLD
G105 G10-7800 75973-054 WILLIS SHANNON 03-14-2019 A-HLD
G07S G07 -749L 86239-054 WILSON LEROY 05-07-2019 A-PRE
GO5N G05 -738L 69068-054 WILSON SHAWN 05-16-2019 A-HLD
KO1N K01-106L 57610-018 WOLF LEONARD 04-04-2016 A-HLD
ZO2A Z02-201LAD 76232-054 WONEY ISHI 04-15-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-029U 86315-054 WONG ZXIYU 11-14-2018 A-PRE
K11S K11-053L 85369-054 WOOLASTON TYRONE 02-21-2019 A-PRE
001N G01 -707L 76248-054 WRIGHT CIMMIE 12-12-2018 A-PRE
EIOS E10-5800 84115-083 WRIGHT JEFFREY 03-13-2019 A-DES
K10S K10-0370 86477-054 WU HUALONG 01-09-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06 -546U 86858-054 XIA XIU 05-21-2019 A-PRE
G128 G12 -789L 77167-112 YANG BINGQIN 12-04-2018 A-PRE
G07S 007-750L 86428-054 YOUNG AARON 12-19-2018 A-PRE
GO7S 007-751U 86868-054 YOUNG ANTHONY 04-30-2019 A-HLD
G09S 009-765L 86373-054 ZAPATA-COSTRO ARGEMIRO 11-30-2018 A-PRE
K125 K12-066U 86925-054 ZAPOLSKIJ VLADISLAV 05-31-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06 -544L 86718-054 ZELAYA EDUARDO 03-14-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-060L 86331-054 ZHOU LEI 04-19-2019 A-PRE
BOLA B01-211L 86475-054 ZHUANG LIQING 07-02-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
NYMES 530.07 *
PAGE 019 OF 019
ROSTER * 07-24-2019
02:47:39
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD ARS
K05N K05-134U 83742-053 ZOTTOLA ANTHONY 06-26-2019 A-PRE
G02N G02 -714L 64662-053 ZUBIATE MIGUEL 02-15-2019 A-HLD
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
EFTA00009658 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in US v. Jeffrey Epstein
EFTA00036062 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-07-29)
7/23/19 @ 1:27 a.m.: Found in fetal position in cell breathing but not responding to staff. Neck was
red. Placed on suicide watch and medical evaluation. Cellmate, Tartaglione,
was medically evaluated with no injuries. Provided daily psychological
evaluation while on suicide watch.
7/29/19: Removed from suicide watch after daily interaction with Psychology Services
and returned to the Special Housing Unit with cellmate Reyes 85993-054. Was
with same cellmate until 8/9/19.
8/9/19 @ 8:00 a.m.:
8/9/19 @ 7:00 p.m.:
Cellmate Reyes out of institution for Court. Reyes is release from Court to
community and does not return to the institution. Epstein in legal visit all day
until 6:45 p.m. Returned to cell with no cell mate (was on PSYCH Alert and
required cell mate).
Unit Manager gave Epstein a telephone call (Comm Tech on way in to verifying
who and number). Unit Manager reports pleasant call in good spirits; nothing
unusual.
8/10/19 12:00 a.m.: Officer conducts count and Epstein waves at Officer. One Officer reports they
failed to conduct 3am and 5am official counts. Officer asked if conducted 30
minute checks; didn't respond, just put her head down. Second Officer refuses
to discuss. Both are seen by EAP this morning.
8/10/19 @ 6:33 a.m.: Staff serving breakfast meal find Epstein unresponsive in cell. Staff call for
assistance and begin CPR. Epstein moved to the Health Svc Department at
6:45am and EMS arrived 6:59am. Transported to hospital at 7:23am and
pronounced dead at 7:36am. Institution medical staff reported bruising around
neck and Institution staff report orange make-shift noose laying in cell. Cell
secured for possible crime scene.
╔═══════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 John Engerman [usvi] Albert Bryan campaign manager 
 Garrett Jones [lawyer] represented Epstein in USVI 
     Sebastiano Cassinelli Paiewonsky [lawyer] USVI 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00096249 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip about Epstein wiring money to Albert Bryan and other corruption in the Virgin Islands
(date: 2019-07-29)
Received a call approximately 4:20 PM July 29, 2019.

https://www.iustice.gov/usao-sdnv/contact-us  Reporting a Crime (212) 637-0850
U.S. Attorneys X. Southern District of New York Programs >> Victim & Witness Services

United States v. Jeffrey Epstein, 19 Cr. 49O (101B)

If you believe you were a victim of Jeffrey Epstein or have information about the allegations in
the Indictment, please call 1-800-Call -FBI.

July 19, 2019 update:
On July 18, 2019, a status conference was held in the case of United States v. Jeffrey Epstein, 19 Cr.
490 (RMB). The court announced its ruling that the defendant will be incarcerated pending trial. The
next conference, which is expected to address scheduling and administrative matters, is scheduled for
Wednesday, July 31, 2019, at 11:30 a.m. before the Honorable Richard M. Berman, United States
District Judge for the Southern District of New York, Daniel Patrick Moynihan United States
Courthouse, 500 Pearl Street, New York, New York, in Courtroom 17B.

July 16, 2019 update:
On July 15, 2019, the continuation of a bail hearing was held in the case of United States v. Jeffrey
Epstein, 19 Cr. 490 (RMB). The court heard arguments regarding the status of the defendant's bail,
and reserved decision. The defendant currently remains detained. The next conference, which is
expected to include the court's ruling on the defendant's application for pretrial release, is scheduled
for Thursday, July 18, 2019, at 9:30 a.m. before the Honorable Richard M. Berman, United States
District Judge for the Southern District of New York, Daniel Patrick Moynihan United States
Courthouse, 500 Pearl Street, New York, New York, in Courtroom 17B.

July 9, 2019 update:
On July 8, 2019, an initial presentment and arraignment was held in the case of United States v.
Jea•ey Epstein, 19 Cr. 490 (RMB). The defendant consented to detention pending a subsequent bail
hearing. The next conference, which will include a bail hearing, is scheduled for Monday, July 15,
2019, at 10:00 a.m. before the Honorable Richard M. Berman, United States District Judge for the
Southern District of New York, Daniel Patrick Moynihan United States Courthouse, 500 Pearl Street,
New York, New York, in Courtroom 17B.
Pursuant to the Crime Victims' Rights Act, Title 18, United States Code, Section 3771(a)(4), a crime
victim has the right to be reasonably heard at certain public proceedings in the district court,
including proceedings involving release. If you believe you are a victim in connection with this case,
and would like to be heard in connection with the hearing scheduled for July 15, 2019, please contact
Wendy Olsen, Victim/Witness Coordinator, at the telephone number or email address listed below.

July 8, 2019 update:
On July 8, 2019, the United States Attorney's Office announced the unsealing of federal felony
charges against JEFFREY EPSTEIN on charges of sex trafficking of minors and conspiring to
commit sex trafficking of minors. EPSTEIN is accused of committing these crimes in locations
including, but not limited to, New York, New York, and Palm Beach, Florida.
1
If you believe you are a victim of JEFFREY EPSTEIN, from during any time period and in any
location, please contact the Victim / Witness specialists at the U.S. Attorney's Office listed below.
The charges are contained in Indictment 19 Cr. 490 (RMS). You may view a copy of the Indictment
here.
Updates regarding the progress of this case will be posted on this site.
The United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York is committed to protecting
the rights of crime victims. If you believe you are a victim of the offense charged, our Victim/Witness
Unit can make sure that you are notified of important stages of the case to help you exercise your
rights. In addition, our Victim/Witness Unit can help refer you to agencies that provide other services
to witnesses, such as compensation (under certain circumstances) and counseling. If you believe you
are a victim, of if you would like information or assistance with referrals, please contact:
Victim/Witness Coordinator
United States Attorney's  Office
New York, New York 10007
Attachments:
Download U.S. v. Jeffrey epstein indictment redacted.pdf

TELEPHONE CI stated:

The CI disclosed that they had information that; Jeffery Epstein wired over $380,000 to
the Bryan/Roach Campaign during 2018, and possibly in 2019. One of the last
transactions was for $70,000. The wires were sent to Sebastiano Cassinelli Paiewonsky,
Esq., of St. Thomas, USVI. An Attorney (female) for Paiewonsky set up the fund to place
the money into, as a IRS 501 c(4) tax-exempt, specifically for the operation of social
welfare organizations. The funds were deposited into the fund. It was stated that the
funds were used for campaign expenses and to pay persons to do things for the team.

A contact for Epstein for St Thomas Insured Property was Nantilus Inc., AmWins of New
York. Also, Marcello Piacento was mentioned as the Broker involved in insurance
settlement. A man named Garrett Jones from New York represents Epstein for local
transactions, including insurance settlements and purchases. The contact person for
the loss survey in St Thomas was Ms. <REDACTED> (approx. 37 years old) an
employee of Epstein's VI Companies. She claims to buy clothing and other things for
Epstein when he is here. He likes polo shirts. She claims to be paid as the Executive
Assistant to Epstein and the St. James Property. She has received gifts from Epstein,
including a boat. Epstein is 1/2  owner of the American Yacht Harbor facility at Red Hook
St Thomas, VI. He also owns a boat docked there and on the island. He is owner of AH
Riise and Isidor Paiewonsky Association Inc., in St Thomas, VI. Recently he and former
Governor John P de Jongh, Jr., as partners, purchased the Nisky Shopping Center in St
Thomas, VI. Another transaction took place in October 2018 where Sebastiano
Piaewonsky received approval for $10 million from the Chamber of Commerce to
partially fund building of a new hotel at Yacht Haven Grande in St. Thomas, VI. Other
activities in the VI have references to Sebastiano Cassinelli Paiewonsky.

httos://stthomassource.com/content/2016/11/08/bdo-usvi-announces-new-managing-member-john-engerman/
BDO, the world's fifth largest accountancy
network, has announced the appointment of a new managing member in the St.
Thomas office. Native Virgin Islander John A. Engerman was appointed in July 2016.
He brings to BDO USVI 20 years of progressive accounting and consulting
experience.

After serving the Virgin Islands community as a CPA for over 36 years, Katherine
Gibson is stepping down as managing member but will remain on staff. Engerman
and the staff have pledged to provide BDO USVI's existing and new clientele even
more comprehensive auditing, accounting, taxation and advisory services.

"I am so happy to be back home in the Virgin Islands and, especially, to bring my
many years of experience to the people, entrepreneurs and businesses of the Virgin
Islands," Engerman said. "I am thrilled with the addition of John Engerman and
additional staff in the BDO USVI office to bolster the services that we provide for
our clients. I am confident that with this fusion of ideas, energy and leadership,
BDO USVI is becoming the go-to firm for all those corporate and private clients in
need of auditing, accounting, taxation and advisory services in the Virgin Islands,"
said Giblson. In appreciation of its many clients and Gibson's contributions to the
firm and community, BDO USVI will hold a special meet and greet party on
Wednesday, Nov. 9, at Grande Cru Restaurant in Yacht Haven Grande.

In 2017 BDO USVI got the Single Audit Contract with the VI Department of Finance.
It was alleged that the bidding process was questionable and Commissioner Val
Collens had some personal interest. No one knows where Mr. Collens now works.
Recently someone went to the VI Board of Elections and asked for a copy of the
Campaign Contributions Reports for Bryan/Roach Team the employee there refused to
provide a copy of anything.

501(c)(4) refers to a section of the U.S. federal income tax code concerning social
welfare organizations. Corporations that have been granted 501(c)(4) status by the
Internal Revenue Service are exempt from federal income tax. ... These organizations
may engage in political lobbying and political campaign activities.
To be tax-exempt as a social welfare organization described in Internal Revenue Code
(IRC) section 501(c)(4), an organization must not be organized for profit and must be
operated exclusively to promote social welfare. The earnings of a section 501(c)(4)
organization may not inure to the benefit of any private shareholder or individual. If the
organization engages in an excess benefit transaction with a person having substantial
influence over the organization, an excise tax may be imposed on the person and any
managers agreeing to the transaction. See Introduction to IRC 4958 for more information
about this excise tax. For a more detailed discussion of the exemption requirements for
section 501(c)(4) organizations, see IRC 501(c)(4) Organizations.
3
New legislation enacted at the end of 2015 added Section 506 to the Internal Revenue
Code. Section 506 requires an organization to notify the IRS of its intent to operate as a

Section 501(c)(4) organization. The IRS has developed a new form - Form 8976 — that
organizations should use to provide this notification. For information about applying for
exemption, see Application for Recognition of Exemption.
This requirement only applies to organizations intending to operate under Section 501(c)(4).
Organizations operating under any other 501(c) section should not file this notice.To be
operated exclusively to promote social welfare, an organization must operate primarily to
further the common good and general welfare of the people of the community (such as by
bringing about civic betterment and social improvements). For example, an organization that
restricts the use of its facilities to employees of selected corporations and their guests is
primarily benefiting a private group rather than the community and, therefore, does not
qualify as a section 501(c)(4) organization. Similarly, an organization formed to represent
member-tenants of an apartment complex does not qualify, because its activities benefit the
member-tenants and not all tenants in the community, while an organization formed to
promote the legal rights of all tenants in a particular community may qualify under section
501(c)(4) as a social welfare organization. An organization is not operated primarily for the
promotion of social welfare if its primary activity is operating a social club for the benefit,
pleasure or recreation of its members, or is carrying on a business with the general public in
a manner similar to organizations operated for profit.
Other names in the campaign and funding controlled through this special 501 c(4) fund were:
John Engerman, campaign manager for Bryan/Roach 2018
ontractor who worked for Epstein on St. James Islands
Anna H. Paiewonsky, Attorney, St. Thomas, VI
Campaign Committee or Political Action Committee (PAC)
Virgin Islands Campaign Disclosure Rules and Regulations defines a
political committee as:
Any political action committee, club, association, principal campaign committee, political
party, or other group of one or more persons which receives or anticipates receiving
contributions or makes or anticipates making expenditures to or on behalf of any elected
official, proposition, candidate, principal campaign committee, or other political action
committee.
Statement of Organization
If a political committee (other than a Principal Campaign Committee formed
by a candidate) receives contributions or makes expenditures in excess of
$1,000, the committee must file a Statement of Organization Form within 10
days of reaching that threshold or within 10 days of forming. The statement
and subsequent campaign finance pre-election reports are filed with the
4
Office of the Supervisor of Elections, if the PAC supports candidates or issues
at the Territorial level or with the local candidates or issues.
Financial Disclosure Reports
Candidates and PACs are required to file when they participate in an election,
but all political committees must file biannual Reports.
Notification of Material Change
Changes in officers, phone number or address, e-mail address or a name
change for a political action committee must be reported within 10 days of
the change.
Termination of Committee
Once a political committee becomes inactive, the chairperson should dissolve
the committee by filing a Statement of Dissolution with the Office of the
Supervisor of Elections. This form must be accompanied by a final report
showing all contributions and expenditures not previously reported and
stating how any excess funds will be distributed.
Advertising
When a political committee sponsors any political advertising for or against a
candidate or ballot issue, the advertising must be clearly identified by the
organization. Additional information on Campaign Disclosure Information.
Political Committees
The Rules and Regulations require that receipts and canceled checks must be
kept for six years from the date of expenditure. The Rules and Regulations
specify that the political committee's money shall not be commingled with
any personal funds of officers, members or associates of the political
committee.
s
Tax Information
Some PACs are not tax exempt. For additional information, contact the
Internal Revenue Bureau, 340-715-1040, and the Internal Revenue Service.
https://www.vivote.gov/candidates/advertising-guidelines
One Person noted: John A. Engerman, the head of BDO Virgin Islands, primarily an
auditing firm with millions of dollars in local, federally funded contracts, told The Consortium Monday that
he was in the process of buying the Virgin Islands arm of the company. Once the process is complete,
Mr. Engerman said he would then change the name BDO VI to something entirely different in an effort to
untie the company from the scandal currently rocking Puerto Rico, in which BDO PR Managing Director
Fernando Scherrer was arrested as part of a 32-count federal indictment. While Mr. Engerman is in
charge of BDO VI, his superior is Mr. Scherrer, who Mr. Engerman revealed is a licensed CPA in the U.S.
Virgin Islands. But Mr. Scherrer resigned from BDO Puerto Rico following his arrest. "As a result of the
accusations issued today by the federal authorities, Mr. Fernando Scherrer has submitted his resignation
to the position he held at BDO Puerto Rico, which will allow Mr. Scherrer to focus on his defense, while
this will allow BDO to concentrate its efforts to provide services to their customers," BDO PR said in a
statement.
This has caused some problems from Mr. Engerman's operation in the U.S. Virgin Islands: since Mr.
Scherrer, who was the head of the U.S. Virgin Islands operations, has resigned, it essentially leaves the
Virgin Islands BDO arm in a dilemma. The Consortium was told that BDO VI could be in violation of local
law caused by Mr. Scherrer's resignation. Mr. Engerman is scheduled to meet with the Virgin Islands CPA
Board today to discuss next steps. During the interview with The Consortium, however, he said BDO VI
was not in violation of local statutes because Mr. Scherrer was still a licensed CPA in St. Thomas.
And although there are reports about Mr. Scherrer's resignation, made known through a statement that
BDO PR issued, Mr. Engerman said he believed Mr. Scherrer was placed on administrative leave, not
fired, and was removed from his managing partner position.
In a statement following the initial interview, Mr. Engerman added, "BDO PR has informed me that they
have already started their ongoing internal investigation and review of former Manager Partner Fernando
Scherrer, considering the allegations of misconduct against him and others. They will provide a statement
and any further updates at the appropriate time."
Amid the Puerto Rico scandal, Mr. Engerman sees it prudent to unbind himself and his colleagues from
any BDO PR-related dealings. His aim is to be "separate from the BDO brand altogether." He added,
"This caught everybody by surprise."
BDO or Binder Dijker Otte, is an international network of public accounting, tax, consulting and business
advisory firms which perform professional services under the name of BDO. Each BDO member firm is an
independent legal entity in its own country.

Mr. Engerman said he called Janice Hodge, chair of the CPA Board, to inform her of the developments.
"I called to let her know what's going on and I need to dean things up and get things together. We will
continue to serve the people of the Virgin Islands with the same staff, same people," he said.

Mr. Engerman said the turnaround from buyout to new name should take about 30 days. He also said he
would own 100 percent of the new company.
6
"I can't go faster than the paperwork and lawyers will allow it to go," he said of the transition. "Again,
everything happened so fast. No one knew it was coming. I had no idea what was going on in Puerto
Rico."
Mr. Scherrer was charged with wire fraud, conspiracy/theft, and money laundering conspiracy. He
pleaded not guilty in a Puerto Rico federal court, according to El Nuevo Dia. Velazquez Pitiol, who was a
consultant for a company that oversaw the Health Insurance Administration of Puerto Rico (ASES) and
who acted as a subcontractor for BDO, was charged with wire fraud, conspiracy/theft, money laundering,
and money laundering conspiracy. He turned himself in to authorities in Connecticut. Rosa Emilia
Rodriguez Velez, the U.S. attorney for Puerto Rico, said the men used their political influence to
improperly obtain contracts, and then used that money for illegal lobbying, according to the New York
Times.
"This type of corruption is particularly egregious because it not only victimizes taxpayers, it victimizes
those citizens and students that are in need of education assistance," said Neil Sanchez, the special agent
in charge of the southern region of the inspector general's office at the United States Department of
Education, which first flagged that something was amiss in Puerto Rico.
The Department of Justice accused those involved of unlawfully steering about $15.5 million in federal
contracts to politically connected consultants.
Contracts totaling $2.5 million were steered to BDO PR by Avila Marrero, who provided internal
information to the firm. BDO then subcontracted the work and paid unauthorized commissions, which
inflated the cost of the contracts, the Justice Department alleged, according to Bloomberg. Mr. Pihol,
owner of Azur LLC, was the connection between BDO PR, the Department of Education, and ASES,
according to the indictment, which also claims Mr. Pihol used his connections with Keleher and Avila
Marrero to give BDO PR more contracts within each agency.
Last week, The Consortium reported that the unfolding scandal in Puerto Rico made for bad optics in the
Virgin Islands, where Mr. Engerman — Governor Albert Bryan's close friend and confidant, — leads BDO
VI, which has gotten millions of dollars in contracts. Mr. Engerman was also Mr. Bryan's campaign
manager during the primary and general elections (2018).
Yet, though the optics may not look good, there has been no evidence that BDO VI received its lucrative
contracts because of Mr. Engerman's connections.
entities predate Mr. Bryan's election.
And BDO VI's contracts with government-owned
"As you may already know, there have been no allegations of impropriety or misconduct against any of
BDO VI senior staff or its employees," Mr. Engerman said in a statement.
Calls for PR governor's resignation because of corruption scandal
Washington lawmakers are calling for Puerto Rico Governor Ricardo to resign following the federal
indictment, as many of those accused in the investigation served in Mr. Rossello's administration.
According to the Washington Post, the arrests also fueled concerns on Capitol Hill about the billions of
dollars in aid that Congress has approved for the island.
President Donald Trump, who has long complained about corruption in Puerto Rico, may view the latest
indictment as validation to his stance, and may use it as reason enough to curtail aid to the island,
Puerto Rico politicians complained.
According to the federal indictment, the former secretary of the Puerto Rico Department of Education,
Julia Keleher; and the former director of the Health Insurance Administration were arrested along with
7
others. The indictment also charged Glenda E. Ponce Mendoza, who worked as Ms. Keleher's special
assistant despite not being a department employee, and her sister, Mayra Ponce Mendoza, owner of
consulting firm Colon & Ponce.
Rep. Raul M. Grijalva (D-Ariz.), chairman of the Natural Resources Committee that oversees Puerto Rico,
called on Mr. Rossello to resign amid the ongoing federal investigation, according to The Post.
"We've crossed that crucible now," said Mr. Grijalva, who later reiterated on Twitter that he supports Mr.
Rossello's resignation. "The restoration of accountability is so key going forward."
According to the Associated Press, Mr. Rossello was not involved in the investigation. The governor said
on Twitter he would cut short a vacation to return to the island, vowing to fight corruption.
San Juan Mayor Carmen Yulin Cruz and political opponent of the governor, said while the allegations "do
not represent what the people of Puerto Rico are about," it would to bolster Mr. Trump's criticism of the
island and hinder potential aid. "The governor of Puerto Rico and his administration have now given
President Trump the ammunition he needed," she said.
Congress has approved $42 billion for the island's recovery, but only about $14 billion of that money has
been spent, according to The Post, citing federal data.
Calls for Mr. Rossello's resignation grew louder following the leak of hundreds of pages showing
Telegram communications of Mr. Rossello and members of his administration deriding opponents and
even some allies. The governor has since begged for forgiveness, but that has not quelled the furor, with
Puerto Ricans taking to the streets demanding that he step down.
A problem for PR could be a Problem for the VI
In many ways, Puerto Rico's woes, as they relate to federal disaster recovery aid, affect the U.S. Virgin
Islands also, as the islands are usually lumped in one regarding the release of disaster funds, even as
Puerto Rico, because of its population, has received most of the money. Take for example the recent
Congressional approval of a $19.1 disaster aid package. The approval process of the funds was
protracted because Mr. Trump sought to limit the amount Puerto Rico was slated to receive from the
allotment. This, of course, has caused a delay in the release of badly needed disaster dollars to the
territory — in this case, $27 million.
According to The Post, a 2019 study by the University of Michigan found that the federal response was
both faster and more generous after hurricanes struck Florida and Texas than it was for Puerto Rico.
Congress also let expire emergency food stamp aid for Puerto Rico in March, causing reductions in critical
federal help for more than 1 million island residents. "What we found is that there was a very significant
difference in not only the timing of the responses but also in the volume of resources distributed in terms
of money and staffing," said lead author of the study Charley Willison, a doctoral candidate in U-M's
School of Public Health. https://viconsortium.com/breaking-news/john-engerman-to-buyout-bdo-vi-and-
change-companv-name-following-bdo-puerto-rico-corruption-scandal/
BDO, A USVI FIRM, PARTNERS WITH WITT O'BRIEN'S TO MANAGE
TERRITORY'S DISASTER RECOVERY PROJECTS
Noss / Virgin Islands / February 11, 2019
Fourteen highly skilled local professionals have been hired by St. Thomas-based BDO USVI, a
professional services firm partnering with FEMA contractor Witt O'Brien's to implement a program
management office (PMO) that will work across all governmental entities receiving federal disaster
8
funding to help ensure the territory's hundreds of reconstruction projects are completed in the most
efficient and cost-effective manner, a release BDO issued Monday said.
According to the release, the close-knit BDO USVI PMO group will operate within the Public Finance
Authority's (PFA) newly established Office of Disaster Recovery, which will provide strategic oversight for
the expected $8 billion in federal disaster recovery funds allotted to the USVI.
The new hires selected for the PMO, a first in the territory, have many years of experience in analytics,
project management and communications in various industries, the release said. One employee, Melania
Girigoria, who joined BDO USVI's PMO as a project analyst, was in the process of relocating when she
was contacted about the new opportunity.
"I was literally packing items into a moving box and had already ended my lease when I received the
call," she said.
It didn't take long for Ms. Girigoria to agree to come on board—a decision she was happy to make,
according to the release.
"There aren't many opportunities locally for persons with my project management or technical skills, so I
was very thankful for this role, which gives me the opportunity to give back to my community while doing
work that I love," she said.
At the start of the USVI recovery program, Witt O'Brien's and the Government of the Virgin Islands made
a commitment to transition some of the management of the program and skilled technical positions to
local professionals as soon as possible. The release said the this transition is being accelerated by the
new partnership between BDO USVI and Witt O'Brien's, whose business relationship began shortly after
the hurricanes in late 2017.
The release said BDO USVI's PMO Director Alain Leroy praised the partnership with Witt O'Brien's as one
that puts local professionals back to work and contributes to stopping the local 'brain drain'—a
phenomenon that sees skilled professionals leaving the Territory in search of better employment and
career opportunities.
"Our partner Witt O'Brien's has afforded BDO USVI a remarkable opportunity that has allowed us to hire
topnotch, homegrown talent from St. Thomas and St. Croix," he said. "This shows the commitment of
Witt O'Brien's to ensure federal funds for local disaster recovery benefit the local community in every
way."
"We're happy to welcome the BDO USVI team," said Brad Gair, USVI recovery program principal for Witt
O'Brien's. "Our mission is to help the Virgin Islands to accelerate recovery and to build back stronger. The
best way to achieve that is by combining the best and the brightest island professionals with the recovery
expertise our firm has nationwide."
Witt O'Brien's recovery expert, Norberto Duefias, joined the USVI recovery team within a few months of
retiring as the City Manager of San Jose, Ca., America's tenth largest city, bringing with him hands-on
experience managing large capital improvement programs. He said, "I'm excited to be supporting the
USVI CDBG-DR program and look forward to working with the BDO USVI team to train and transition
more recovery program roles to local staff over the next year."
The PMO duties will include collecting and analyzing data related to federally funded disaster-recovery
projects across government agencies and instrumentalities in order to ensure projects start and end on
time, and remain within pre-determined budgets.
9
John A. Engerman, Governor Albert Bryan's campaign manager, said he is a partner of BDO VI. Here's
the official statement from the company on Mr. Engerman's involvement: "BDO USVI has been providing
the Virgin Islands community with consulting and professional services since 2014. Mr. Engerman has
built a strong reputation as an astute businessman that serves his clients with integrity and one who
avidly gives back to the community. While Mr. Engerman volunteered to serve as Governor Bryan's
territorial campaign manager in the recent elections, he has not joined the Bryan Administration and
remains a private citizen, operating a private business that provides excellent employment opportunities
for Virgin Islanders. Witt O'Brien's partnership with BDO USVI is a testament to BDO's ability to handle
the complex tracking and reporting matters surrounding the USVI's long-term recovery."
Engerman reportedly returned to the USVI in 2016. It appears he may have been working in
Washington, DC.
https://viconsortium.com/virgin-islands-2/bdo-usvi/
10
EFTA00120617 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons "Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver" forms
(date: 2019-07-30)
Prepared on C7/302019
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
SOUTHERN NEW VOA%
DtsInd 54
TO: MCC New York DATE: 07/30/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
tl USMS NO. Local Jail No. Name
[X] are herewith remanded to your custody
[ ] are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 79954054 WILLIAMS, SHAWN
RECEIPT
THE ONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:
BY:
TITL
DIST ICT OR ORGAN. ADDRESS:
. chap) Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
Prepared on 07/3(Y2019
• •
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
SOUTHERN NEW YORK
District 54I
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York DATE: 07/30/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
USMS NO. Local Jail No. Nome
[XI are herewith remanded to your custody
[ J are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 85609054 REID, MICHAEL
D: THE ABOV
BY:
TITLE:
DISTRICT OR ORGAN. ADDRESS: BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
Prepved Oe 07/3Te7019
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
SOUTHERN NEW YORK
D144154
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York DATE: 07/30/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
tx1 are herewith remanded to your custody
f are to be delivered to representative
presenting and sigNng this order
N USMS NO. Local Jail No. me
1 72419019 HU, CYRIL
2 85942054 CAZAREZ-MADRID, CORNELIO
3 86972054 RUZ PIMENTEL, NELSON
4 86248054 -HERNANDEZ, AUGUSTIN
5 76268054 RNANDEZ, LUIS
6 87002054 // EDSON CALVIN
7 87003054 ENYATTA, CHARLES
8 88748054 LI, TIAN
9 85941054 /MEZA, SINOHE
io V4V-5.-091 0/41e6Z, reuX
THE ABOVE
BY:
TITLE:
DISTRICT 0
MARSHAL
BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
BP-S377.055 PRISONER REMAND CDFIRM
FEB 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
IIIVIDW•109.10.00t
BP-53/1.058 PRISONER REMAND CDFM4
FEB 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
CJ
U.S. Department ofJustlee
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correction Center
New York, NY 10007
Date: July 30, 2019
MEMORANDUM
FOR: J. garden, Captain
FROM:
M. ROvSpecial
Housing Unit Lieutenant
SUBJECT:
RELEAgE ORDERS FROM THE SPECIAL HOUSING UNIT
The following inmates are to be released from the Special Housing Unit.
NAME
REG.
NUMBER
UNIT
RELEASE
DATE
REASON
SEPARATEES
BALDEO, HAREEM 79781-054
Ztt -  210 LA

11-NORTH 7-30-2019
DS TIME
COMPLETED
NONEOMCC,
NY
Please provide a reason the inmate is being release New Commit, D/S Time Served,
SIS Investigation
Complete PENDING BED SPACE WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED
*I1Nrs should be cleared by the Captain, SIS, Unit Team, And AW (0), before an inmate
is returned to the unit where the infraction was committed
The release of this inmate (s) is authorized as indicated below:
( X ) Completion
of Disciplinary
Segregation,
no further action pending
( X ) Action by the Unit Disciplinary
Committee,
no further action pending.
( X ) Completion
of an Investigation,
no further action pending, No incident Report
( ) Completion
of Classification
Wending Review by Unit Team I Captain.
( ) New Commit/ Cleared by edical
REQUESTED
REVIEWED BY:
REVIEWED BY
REVIEWED BY:
API'ROVED:
15 i.r te, t

╭──── Page 6, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

Prepare., cri Ora: MI5
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York DATE: 07/30/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
USMS NO. Local Jail No. Name
[X] are herewith remanded to your custody
[ ] are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 86269054 JIMENEZ, RICHARD
2 86551054 RAMIREZ, RONNY
RECEIPT
THE ABOVE NAMED R S WERE RECEIVED:
BY:
\1TIIE:
prP
DISTRICT OR ORGAN. ADDRESS:
.3
nsta.vto UNITED STATES MARSHAL
G • "1:2T---Fe.c) BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Uso ROW On
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
Prisoner Remand or Older to Deliver
and Receipt for United States Prisoners
Eastern District of New York
TO:  MCC NEW YORK DATE:  JULY 30,2019
(Name &Tittle)
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONER(S): N are herewith remanded to your custody
Elarc to he delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
CIFUENTES-VILLA;HILDEBRANDO 75605-06 20
2 ZOTTOLA;ANTHONY 83742-053 21
3 CUMMINGS;JASON 91662-053  22
4  LOPEZ;ALFRED 91661-053 23
5   24
6   25
7   26
8   27
9   28
10  29
11  30
12  31
13  32
14  33
15  34
I6  35
I7   36
18  37
19 38
RECEIPT
THE ABOVI NA NI TED STATES PRISONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:
BY:
TITLE:
DISTRI R ORGAN. ADDRESS:
1~0f
BRYAN MULLEE D'"" 9"`""" mmuaffDate:2019.01.01 14:13:35 -0SW
United States Marshal
BRYAN MULLEE Date:
Dieta
2019.02O1
ry signed by BRYAN ARMEE
lel 353 -05'00
By: Deputy U.S. Marshal
Form USM-40
Rev. 07/15
(01/81 Version May Also Be Used)
0 Rowed on:07/3022019 SOW FIFFtN NEW YORK
lY
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver stric1 54
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York DATE: 07/30/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
• USMS NO. Local Jail No. Name
N are hereWth remanded to your custody
( 1 are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 79471054 SCHULTE. JOSHUA
THE ABOVE NAMED
BY:
TITLE:
DISTRICT ORGAN. ADDRESS:
44 ‘erg UNITED STATES MARSHAL
DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
NYMEO 530*07 *
PAGE 006 OF 006
GRP.
C
C
C
ROSTER 07-29-2019
19:40:22
SPECIFIC. . REG  LN  FN  CMC  QTR  CALT
COURT SDNY 86551-054 -RAMIREZ RONNY O07 -756L 12:31
COURT SDNY 86269-054 .JIMENEZ RICHARD SEPARATION I03-920U 12:31
COURT SDNY 85609-054 ,REID MICHAEL 205-123LAD 12:31
--)1.lakts
G0000 . TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
r--1S°-tsse
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
MCC NEW YORK
150 PARK ROW, NEW YORK, NY, 10007
TRANSFER RECEIPT DATE: Tuesday July 30, 2019
RECEIVED FROM Lamina N'Diaye, WARDEN MCC NEW YORK, 150 PARK ROW, NEW YORK, NY 10007. THE
FOLLOWING UNITED STATES PRISONERS, TOGETHER WITH COMPLETE FILES FOR TRANSFER AS
INDICATED: WAB/USM-SDNY/NYCDOC
REG.NO. NAME QTR DST RELEASE STATUS
16296-049 RAWSON,KENNETH 7N USM/SDNY PRE REMOVE
TOTAL: 1
*** ALL 64, 71, Medication PAPERWORK ACCOUNTED FOR
*** ALL PD 15's CHRONO & PENDING CHECKED BY:
14ti Z6414.=__so..14
USM/SDNY
MCC NEW YORK MOVEMENT OFFICER 646-836-6300 EXT 6321
BP-3377.058 PRISONER REMAND CDF
FEB 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE E L BUREAU OF PRISONS

╭────────────────── Page 12, Image 1 ──────────────────╮
│ 5 PRISONER REMAND D ne AY                            │
│                                                      │
│ EB OA                                                │
│                                                      │
│ ry                                                   │
│ U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS │
│ Eatin Canam Tee er 0 eS                              │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Revved cm 07-3C:2019
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
SOUTHERN NEW YORK
Ownci 54
CJ 1 PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York DATE: 07/30/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
USMS NO. Local Jail No. ame
11
are herewith remanded to your custody
are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 86947054 ✓ J NES, DARRYL
2 79919054 AN MANEN, PAUL
C.5610 -0 0
dS11
owhiemk baugtmc
ctirti -
RECEIPT
THE ABOVE N4M P ISONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:
BY:
TITLE:
DISTRICT ORORGAN. ADDRESS:
6teerr
UNIS8D STATES MARSHAL
et)1714,Arn
BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
Freored en: 07M ,2019
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
SOIHNIRN NEW YORK
!awe" 54
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
DATE: 07/30/2019
p() are here dth remanded to your custody
I are to be delivered to representative
N USMS NO. Local JaII No.
presenting and signing this order
Name
1 86918054 ESPINAL, GYANCARLOS
2 86954054 FIGUEROA, CHARLES
3 87018054 JONES, THERYN
4 85782298 LEAL, RAYMUNDO
5 92150054 MEIGHAN, AKBAR
6 85979054 PAPOSHVIU. GOCHA
7 88027054 SANDS, REUBEN
RECEIPT
THE ABOVE N ED PRISONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:
BY: (TITLE:
DISTRIC OR ORGAN. ADDRESS: ,VIII
)0et622 NITED STATES MARSHAL
BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
BP-5377.058 PRISONER REMAND CDFRM
FEB 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
BP -8377.05S PRISONER REMAND CDHOf
FEB 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
V.
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
• ••
BP-S377.058 PRISONER REMAND CDFM4
FEB 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
64 5f FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
U.S.
Department
of
Justice
United
States
Marshals
Service
RECEIPT
FOR
UNITED
STATES
PRISONERS
PRISONER
REMAND
OR
ORDER
TO
DELIVER
AND
UNITED
STATES
MARSHAL

DISTRICT
OF
TO:

DATE:

(Ndrize
8
Tale)
THE
FOLLOWING
NAMED
UNITED
STATES
PRISONER(S):
1

4

are
herewith
remanded
to
your
custody
ri
are
to
be
delivered
to
representative
I—I
presenting
and
signing
this
order
2

5

3

6

RECEIPT
THE
ABOVE
NAMED
UNITED
STATES
PRISONER(S)
WERE
RECEIVED:
BY: TITLE: DISTRICT
OR
ORGAN.
ADDRESS
United
States
Marshal
BY:
Deputy
U.S.
Marshal
(PRIOR
EDITIONS
MAY
BE
USED)
Fcerr
USh141
,.REV
11:83
a
ItOO10 ',MP
'R., SFER RECEIPT JPATS/USMS/BOP
REMANDED FROM
REMAND TO
NYM
VANU
DATE OF TRIP/TRIP NUMBER
MNORF 1
2
st 93031083 ALEXANDER, BARRY_
07/30/2019
Page 1
Ó1/4-k>r
5HT00526-19
MSNYK-NYM-KSWF-NYM-MSNYK
7616205 GANAN RAMIREZ, ' DRJ r or
CARLOS
_3 79792007
4 45623007
GEBREMARIAM, dReEKET
-7
HOGAN, CHRISTOPHE_Rik.
vti5 22484040 KERNS, JAMES .__In ___,. .
I vil
, —fisr
7 _ i 68555066 SHEFtAK, STEPHEN /
Li_l 1-86145054 /VARGAS, MIGUEL ../ BEC
31Y
3JY
7PK ✓
MAR
_
/ RSO
RSO
✓ RSO
TRCC7- 1
/ JCB
Signature: Remanded From
Signature: Remanded To
of 7
Date
1130 iam
Date
a-7 /3, /for
NYM -> VANU (inmates: Segment: Transfer Receipt 5HT00526-19-200

╭──────────────────────── Page 24, Image 1 ─────────────────────────╮
│ TRa..SFER RECEIPT JPATS/USMS/BOP Page 1                           │
│ } ow                                                              │
│                                                                   │
│ NYM                                                               │
│                                                                   │
│ VANU :                                                            │
│                                                                   │
│ 07/30/2019 SHT00526-19                                            │
│ MSNYK-NYM-KSWF-NYM-MSNYK                                          │
│                                                                   │
│ CODE                                                              │
│                                                                   │
│ | 4 |                                                             │
│                                                                   │
│ 1 93031083 “ALEXANDER, BARRY y\_| MNORF 7                         │
│ | — |                                                             │
│ |                                                                 │
│ | 2 | 76162054 | GANAN RAMIREZ, lou                               │
│                                                                   │
│ i CARLOS                                                          │
│                                                                   │
│ 3. 79792007 ceonemannn, Eee av, V RsO _f                          │
│ | | . |                                                           │
│ | 445623007 HOGAN, CHRISTOPHER, 31. |~*RSO = 4                    │
│ | | | | |                                                         │
│ 5 22484040 KERNS, JAMES wk v4 Rso                                 │
│ 6 62 oe ont Canceled.                                             │
│ |7_| 68555066 “ SHERAK, STEPHEN |e) sca | _                       │
│ ry \.                                                             │
│ a se1asos¢ Y vargas, miGueL ica -                                 │
│ Signature: Remanded From Date                                     │
│ . 5 ;                                                             │
│ db) 2idun tec] a helaorq                                          │
│ ‘Signature: Remanded To Date ‘ed                                  │
│ Jie4                                                              │
│ fd = CD30 f 14                                                    │
│                                                                   │
│ NYM-> VANU (inmates: 9) Segment: Transfer Receipt SHT00526-19-200 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

BP-S377 . 058 PRISONER REMAND aut3N
FEB 04

U. S . DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
Vu-Letr --
O EIM1EU011
RECYCLED AIM
(i)PiePer00 On 07/29/2019
•
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
SOUIHERN NEW YORK,
Dimmt 54
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
USMS NO. Local Jail No. Name
DATE: 07/29/2019

(X) are herewith remanded to your custody
I I are to be delNered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 85981054 CAM BATISTA, LUIS
2 86566054 CAMILO-POLANCO. JUAN
RECEIPT
THE ABOVE NAMED PRISONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:
TITLE: C.5
DISTRICT OR ORGAN. ADDRESS:
UNITED STATES MARSHAL
. JCNCti
BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
NYMOZ 530*07 * ROSTER • 07-26-2019
PAGE 003 19:47:09
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG  LN  FN  CMC QTR CALT
C COURT SDNY 86025-05e ROOPWAHL, MOSES..." I06-943U 07:30
C COURT SONY 76275-054 ESTEBAN ye OMAR K05-1360 07:30
C COURT SDNY 77737-112- IGNATOnecKONSTANTIN SEPARATION K07-0730 07:30
C COURT SDNY 86021-054- GONZALEZ't GODOFREDO K08-013L 07:30
C COURT SONY 86023-054 • SUCRE I.,' NERIDIO K08-0130 07:30
C COURT SDNY 86024-054- MONASTERIO‘BOIS K08-074L 07:30
C COURT SONY 86022-054 -REINGOUDI..0"WORVIN „.. K12-078U 07:30
C COURT SDNY 86020-054 "TORRES3.006- OMAR.../ KOS-11811AD 07:30
vmsk _roui _5xoero 54 -
s Ira Al`
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGZ 530*07
PAGE 004
SPECIFIC..
*
REG
ROSTER
LN  FN  CMC.
07-26-2019
19:47:09
QTR  CALT

TC. COURT SDNY 76280-054 WrtiMBR^ Co.,4=11-44 E03-522U 07:31 L6fl rys
/c • ifteCOURT
COURT
SDNY
SDNY
85846-054
76194-054
'ROBERTS' SARIS SEPARATION
JOCAMPO-ApeRUBEN
E06-541U
G02-715L
07:31
07:31
COURT SDNY 85738-054 JNORVILLE/ DWAYNE G07-752U 07:31
COURT SDNY 87008-054 WET' 1.43)FeLL1 K04-132U 07:31 itsbusamb
COURT SDNY 68152-054 /HOYT KENNETH 206-216LAD 07:31
356
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
Propuied on 07/29,7319 SOUTHERN NEW YORK,
Distoct S4
. Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
ft USMS NO. Local Jail No. Name
DATE: 07/29/2019
[X] are herewith remanded to your custody
[ ] are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 76275054 ESTEBAN, OMAR
2 87008054 WILLIAMS, TONY
RECEIPT
THE ABOVE D PRISONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:
BY.
TITLE &OikC . so' E •
DISTRICT OR GROAN. ADDRESS: i I 0 PI"
r • n f-CLO
UNITED STATES MARSHAL
BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
BP -8377.058 PRISONER REMAND CDFRM
In
Ca iti
Pnignred an: 0MR/2019
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
SOUTHERN NEW YORK
()son 54
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York DATE: 07/29/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
USMS NO. Local Jail No. Name
V) are herewith remanded to your custody
are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 68152054 HOYT, KENNETH
2 76194054 OCAMPO-ALVAREZ, RUBEN
WERE RECEIVED:
RECEIPT
THE ABOVE ED PRISONE
BY:
TITLE: Q -A- 7
DISTRICT OR ORGAN. ADDRESS:
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
NYMGZ 630*07 * ROSTER
PAGE 006 OF 00607-26-2019
19:47:09
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG  LN  FN  CMC  QTR  CALT
C COURT SDNY 86566-054 CAMILO-POL JUAN K09-035L
7/15/c 2i/vi
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
NYMGZ 530*07 * ROSTER
PAGE 005
* 07-26-2019
19:47:09
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG riN  FN  CMC  QTR  CALT
C COURT SDNY 85981-054 CADA BATIS LUIS K03-1171. 12:00
JL~c - ,
2115((5
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
t z3 Ph
ePrepared co 07/29/2919
f
•
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
SOUTHERN NEW YORK ADave, M
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York DATE: 07/29/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
Ixl
USMS NO. /Local Jail No. Name
1 86021054 GONZALEZ, GODOFREDO
2 86024054 MONASTERIO, LUIS
3 86022054 REINGOUD, MURVIN
4 86025054 ROOPWAH, MOSES
5 86023054 SUCRE. NERIDIO JULIAN
6 86020054 TORRES, OMAR
RECEIPT
THE OV ED PRISONER lAE RE RECEIVED:
BY:
TITLE: 0
DISTRICT OR ORGAN. ADDRESS:
I I
are herewith remanded to your custody
are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
el • G late
UNITED STATES MARSHAL
•N cre
BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
Prepared on 0109/20i9
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
SOUTHERN NEW YORK.
Chstrict 54
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
TO: MCC New York
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
USMS NO. Local Jail No. Name
DATE: 07/29/2019
(XI are herewith remanded to your custody
( I are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 77737112 IGNATOV, KONSTANTIN
RECEIPT
nTHE ABA VE NAMED PRISONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:
Br i e( C
TITLE: d..5,0
DISTRICT OR ORGAN. ADDRESS:
1m. Lc:to UNITED STATES MARSHAL
C-)
BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
NYMHM 531.01 *
PAGE 001 OF 001 *
REG NO..: 76318-054 NAME
CATEGORY: QTR FUNCTION:
FCL ASSIGNMENT DESCRIPTION
INMATE HISTORY * 08-14-2019
QUARTERS 10:19:57
EPSTEIN, JEFFREY EDWARD
PAT FORMAT:
START DATE/TIME STOP DATE/TIME
NYM 204-206LAD HOUSE Z/RANGE 04/BED 206L AD 08-10-2019 0734 08-10-2019 0736
NYM Z04-206LAD HOUSE 2/RANGE 04/BED 206L AD 07-29-2019 1221 08-10-2019 0747
NYM H01-001L HOUSE H/RANGE 01/BED 001L 07-23-2019 0324 07-29-2019 1221
NYM 205-124 LAD HOUSE 2/RANGE 05/BED 124L AD 07-10-2019 1526 07-23-2019 0324
NYM HO1-001L HOUSE H/RANGE 01/BED 001L 07-08-2019 1803 07-10-2019 1526
NYM 202-201LAD HOUSE Z/RANGE 02/BED 201L AD 07-08-2019 1749 07-08-2019 1803
NYM 202-201LAD HOUSE Z/RANGE 02/BED 201L AD 07-07-2019 1920 07-08-2019 0920
NYM E06-547U HOUSE E/RANGE 06/BED 547U 07-06-2019 2136 07-07-2019 1920
NYM R01-001L HOUSE R/RANGE 01/BED 001L 07-06-2019 2124 07-06-2019 2136
EFTA00166863 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank Southern Financial Know Your Customer form filled out by Paul Morris
(date: 2019-07-30)
KYC Print Page 1 of 12
DB PWM GLOBAL KYC/NCA: PART A
KYC Case ♦ : 01141322

One sheet must be established per relationship list all accounts included in the relationshi

1. Relationship Details
Relationship Name: SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP:00000463290 I Becki-g Center: I New York
Relationship Manager: Paul Morris

O New PWM Relationship O Existing PWM Relationship
Relationship to AVM:
If existing, please indicate skxe when the relations p exists, provide reason for nev profile and attach old profile:

O Client Referral I0 RM Prospect ll O Intermechary/FIM I O Other Source (CIB, etc.)
How Was the Client(s) Introduced? How long has the RM personally known the client?
Please provide details (e.g. name of referral source, how many years RM personally has known cent, etc.): Jeffrey 
Epstein
is a current client of the Bank. Wants to open a new account Introduction details of Paul and Jeffrey: Jeffrey Epstein 
was a
dent of Paufs at JP Morgan. Paul and Jeffrey Epstein had a mutual friend/colleague who Introduced them while Paul was at
II:Horgan. Over the course of a few meetings Paul was able to get Jeffrey to bring some of his funds over to Deutsche 
Bank

Does Deutsche Bank pay a retrocession or similar compensation to a third party
O Yes I 0 No

roc the introduction of the
relationship,
(If Yes, desenbel.
Int all existing and new accou is involved in this relationship
Legal Entity
Account(s)
Account Name / Number Opening Date (Intended/actual)
1 0 NES, LLC 10/28/2013
2 gi NES, LLCMoney Market 10/28/2013
Who is the primary contact
linen for the Rter (Note:
This person needs to have
signatory rights and/or
information right for the
accounts.):
Harty Seller Preferred method of contact
(indicate phone no., fax no.,
e-mail address, etc.):
Status : 6. Approved
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
7/30/2019
DB-SDNY-0002637
KYC Print Page 2 of 12
One sheet must be established for each account to be o
2. Account Ownership Summary
Account Name: NES, LLC Acct. Number (if evadable).
Account Manager Paul Morris
What s the purpose of the account (e.g. portfolio management, advisory account ustody services, long-term investment 
payment/expense
account)' Checkng account to boil the funds necessary to cover the costs associated mac running one of Jeffrey Epsteln's
homes
Indicate from inhere the assets are expected to arrive'

• 08 Group: Same Booking Center (Indicate account number):
0 06 Group: Other Booking Center (indicate DB location and account details):
O Other Institution (Indicate name & location): II/Morgan. New York
O Physical Deposit (specify cash, securities, cheques, ..):
What is the expected size and frequency of regular rflows and outlaws for the account (Indicate estimated number and 
volume per month)': Roughly 10
inflows and outflows per month ranging from $1000 to $20000
What is the expected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. 90 days after opening' 1100000 I Currency I 
USD
What is the expected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. one year after opening' 1100000 I Currency I 
USD
Does/wi the client have Assets Under Management (AuM) within DB under Eur. 3M' O Yes No
Please list all parties related to the account.
For each party:

• Check if a source of wealth description is requied for the party.
• Check the appropriate box to describe the relationship of the party to this account (> 1 can be selected).

• If none of the check boxes apply, describe the partys relation to the account In the "Other" column.
• Always describe the relationship between the parte in the last column.
• Please drill down to the ultimate/underlying Beneficial Owner( ).
_egal
Intitycf
Description
Source
of Wealth
required
Parties
related
to this
account\
AccanthlC
Holder OwnerTrust
Bettor of
/
Founder of
Foundation
Jitimate
Benefkiator
Owner
%natty
Full
POA
ArniteciFinancial
?OA IntermediaryShareholder
(FIM)
Significant
(>•25%)
Non-PIC
entity
(Indicate
ownership
%)
,egal
Representative
Grantor/Setdcricundmg
Donor
O
Other
(please
describe
other roles
and/c.
indicate
relationship
between
cartes)
1 21 5 "Es' LLC El O O O O • O O O
2 O O Harry
❑Beller ri  "3 O O O 2 O O O O O
3 • 5 ;ter
n m  Epst ei • O O 2 F2) El • O • •
https://dbforcepb.my. sal esforce.com/seMet/servl et. Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DS-SDNY-0002638
KYC Print Page 3 of 12
2. Account Ownership Summary
Account Name: NES, LLCMoney Market Acct Number (1 avar:rO4r)
Account Manager Paul Morris
what is the purpose of the account (eq. portfolio managem nt, advisory account. custody services, long-berm kwestrrkrit,
payment/expense
account),  Money market account to hold the funds necessary to cover the costs associated with running one of Jeffrey 
Epstein's homes and earn interest
Indicate from where the assets are expected to amve,
O DB Group: Same Booking Center (indicate account number):
O DB Group: Other Booking Center (indicate DB location and account details):
21 Other Institution (Indicate name & location): )PMorgan. New York
O Physical Deposits (specify cash, securities, cheques, ...):
What is the expected she and frequency of regSar nflows and outflows for the account (indicate estimated number and 
volume per month)': Roughly 1.3
inflows and outflows per month ranging from $1000 to $10000
What s the expected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. 90 days after opening, 1 100000 I Currency I 
USD
What 6 the expected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. one year after
opening,
1 100000 I Currency I uSD
Does/wit the client have Assets Under Management (AuM) within DB under Eur. 3M' Dyes RI Flo
Please list all parties related to the account.
For each party:

• Check If a source of wealth description Is required for the party.
• Check the appropriate box to describe the relationship of the party to his account (> 1 can be selected).

• f none of the check boxes apply, describe the palls  relation to the account In the -Other column.
• Always describe the relationship between the parties in the last column.

• Please drill dorm to the ulbrnate/ ndeelying Beneficial Owner( ).
_egal
Mayor
Description
Source
of Wealth
reputed
Pastes
related
to this
account
AccountrIC
Molder Ciwnertnnt
babe of
/
Founder of
Foundation
Jltimate
Beneficiabor
Ovmer
Signatoryirritealeinancial
Poi
POA
POA Intemserharytehareholder
(FIN)
Signifcant
(>=25%)
Non-PIC
entity
(indicate
ownership
%)
-egal
Representative
Grantor/SettlorlFoundng
Donor
•
Other
(please
describe
other roles
and/ct
indicate
relationship
between
parties)
1 2 2 sea, LLC e a o 0 • 0 . • D
2 E] O Harry
Beller
ri
"1 • O O lifi O • O O O
3 O El Jeffrey Epstein s—, ,—. O O O O • O O
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-0IN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002639
KYC Print Page 4 of 12
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY in Section 2. Account Ownstship  Summa
3A. Individual Details ( all parties)
Individuars Name: Jeffrey Epstein - 00000483289 Date of Birth 1/20/199
Country of Residence: USVI Country of Citizenship: USA
Address of primary residence Lae Sant lames Saint Thomas 00802 US Virgo Islands
Has client resided outside of
hie/her country of natharsalRy
ter 5 years or mete?
O yes ?allo
Profession/Occupation: Self Empotyed Tax ID / 5511:
Current Employer Southern Financial LLC Position/Title/Rank: President
Address of employer: 6100 Red Hook Quarter B3 St Thomas USVI 00802
Does the person work as senior executive of a DB-recognized regulated entity in the financial
ndustre or an entity listed on DB-recognised exchange? (Not applkable for operating
nutlet
L.J yes 0 No
Is the individual a Politically Exposed Person (PEP)'('/ Yes, describe) O yes INo
To the best of your knoWedge, is the Individual related W an employee of the 08 group/(A
Faint or FnencIsixA describe )
0 Family 0 Friendship eg None
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual party to a non-banking relabcrishp with
Deutsche Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or
services)'() Yes, desert.)
O Yes iN No
If applicable, indicate which bank celkers have met the
person:
Indkate where and Wien the client meetkg(s) took place:
Bank Officer Name(s) Bank Office Client Private
cile.
Client Place of Other Location (specify): Date:
Paul Morris O O 0 10/21/2013
O O O
❑ O u
O Wealth Debit for this individual are not filled in, because they are the same as for the following person:
38. Wealth Details (Only for parties requiring source of wealth description as indicated in Section 2)

Nature of the Individual's Business: Private investments
Primary Country of source of wealth/source of Funds?
Primary industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds'

Surrrnarize Source of Weakly E Business Conner O Sa lary/Eamings J Investment O Inheritance/Gifts • Other:
Further Descrbe Source of Wealth /Detail the history of neath for each of the sources: (e.g. For trusts, how did settlor
&cumulate weal h? For inheritance,
how did family accumulate wealth>For business owners, how long In business, how many employees, level of profitability' 
Indicate type of business,
counties of major activities. important business partners.) Epstein began It financial career in 1976 as an options 
trader at Bear Stearns and became a
partners n 1980. In 1982, Epstein founded his own financial management firm, 3. Epstein & Co., managing the assets of 
dents with more than a billion in net
north. In 1996, Epstein changed the name of his firm to The Financial Trust Company and based it on the island of SL 
Thomas in the US Virgin Islands. All
of his clients were anonymous except for the very wealthy businessman Leslie Wexner. His wealth has come from his days 
at Bear Stearns and his financial
management Roos

Estimated Annual Income(S) 10,000,000.00 Estinated amount of investable asseW(S): $100 MM - SOO MM

Estimated Net Worth(S): $100 MM - 500 mil Amount of assets planned to invest vii PWN(S):
Other Known Financial Institutions:
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
7/30/2019
DB-SDNY-0002640
KYC Print Page 5 of 12
Institution: JPmorgan
Institution: Deutsche Bank
Institution:
Country: USA Est. Assets Under Mgt 40,000,000.00
Country: USA Est Assets Under Mgt 154,000,000.00
Country: Est Assets Under Mgt:
Please imitate the farm& situation of the indrvidual (marital status, other famty members, etc.):
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002641
KYC Print Page 6 of 12
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY in Section 2. Account ownstship  Sustssnry_
3A. Individual Details (for all parties)
Individual's Name. Harry Beller - Date of Birth:
Country of Residence: USA Country of Citizenship: USA
Address of primary residence:
Has client resided outside of
his/her country of natlenalky
for 5 years or more?
No Dyson
Profession/Occupation: Accountant Tax ID / 5511:
Current Employer KIRK Associates, Inc Position/Trtle/Rank:
Address of employer: 575 Lexington Avenue, 4th Floor Monsey NY USA 10022
Does the person work as senio executive of a DB-recognized regulated entity in the financial
ndustry' or an entity listed on CB-recognised exchange' (Not applicable for operating
nutlet
O Yes 0 No
Is the individual a Politically Exposed Person (PEP)(/ Yes describe) O yes EZI No
To the best of your knowledge, IS the Individual related Wan employee of the DB group"(r/
Faint or (nencIsixA describe )
0 Family 0 Friendship eg None
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual party to a non-banking relabccishp with
Deutsche Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or
services)'at Yes, desrnb e I
O Yes rA No
If appeal*, indicate with bank cfrKers have met the
person:
Indicate where and when the client meet:4(s) took place:
Bank Officer Name(s) Bank Office: Client Private
Domicile:
Client Place of
Business: Other Locabon (specify): Date:
Paul Morris O O 0 10/21/2013
O O O
O O u
El Wealth Debin for this individual are not filled in, because they are the same as for the following person:
38. Wealth Details (Only for parbes requiring source of wealth description as indicated in Section 2)
Nature of the Individual's Business:

Primary Country of source of wealth/source of Funds'
Primary industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds'

Summarize Source of Wealth: OBusiness Owner O Salary/Eamings 00ther: iii
Investment O Inheritance/Gifts
Further Desoto Source of We Rh /Detail the history of weath for each of the sources: (e.g. For trusts, how did setUor 
accumulate wealth' For inheritance,
how did family accumulate we Ith'For business owners, how long In business, how many employees, level of profitability' 
Indicate type of business,
countries of major acbvitles, important business partners.)
Estimated Annual Incorne(f): Estimated amount of Investable assets($):
Estimated Net Worth(S): Amount of assets planned to invest with PWM(S):
Other Known Financial Institutions:
Institution: Country: Est Assets Under Mgt:
Insbtubon: Country: Est Assets Under Mgt
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
7/30/2019
DB-SDNY-0002642
KYC Print Page 7 of 12
Institution: Country Est Assets Under Mgt
Please incicat the family situation of the indmdual (marital status, other family members, etc.):
One sheet must be established for EACH LEGAL ENTITY in Section 2. Account Summary
3C. Legal Entity Details (For all Legal Enbties)
Legal Entity Name: NES, LLC - 00000487265
Type of Entry El Foundation/Associatice DTrust R Company O Estate
O Partnership
Purpose of Entity:
RI Pnvate Investment Ell
Philanthropic/Chartable 1r...)
Commercial
Type of Entity Other
(specify).
Purpose of Entity
Other (specify):
Country of
incorporation/registration:
USA Date of
incorporation/
registration:
8/13/1998
Vokker Status: Volcker Flag:
Address (city, street, post
code):
6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3 St, Thomas 00302 USVI U.S. TIN/EIN: 13.4146141
Provide a description of the entity's organizational structure, its ownership structure and its Top Management. For 
trusts/foundations, include information
about revccabillty,settfor and beneficiaries,etc..
Single member LLC. Jeffrey Epstein is the sok member
Please indicate how ownership of the legal entity is reflected: Single member LLC. Jeffrey Epstein 's the sole member
D Special attention: Bearer Shares • Indicate where shares are custodied:
Describe the chain from the direct owner of the entry to the ultimate beneficial owner (if not x same persons) Single 
member LC. Jeffrey Epstein is the
sole member
To the best of your know/edge, Is the entity party to a non-banking relationship with
Deutsche Bank (e.g. external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or
services)':
YeS O No W
Describe Nature of Entity's Primary Business and Investment Activities
Nature of the buuness- NES, LLC was formed to take care of the expenses associated with running one of Jeffrey
Epstein's homes
Counties where business is transacted: USA, USVi
Hunter of employees: 1
3D. Wealth Profile (Only for part es requiring source of wealth description as indicated in Section 2)
Primary Country of source of wealth/source of Funds'
Primary industry of source of WealthrSour« of Funds'
Provide Evidence of Corporate Assets (e g balance sheet or equivalent summary of assets/kat:rites):
AI funds come from Jeffrey Epstein, who has been KYCd previously
Estimated gross receipts Noy
Estimated net profit. (3):
Estimated investable assets ($): <31. MM
Potential Amount to be invested with RAM ($): 200,000.00
Other Known Fnancial Institutions:
Institution: JPMorgan Country: USA Est Assets Under Mgt: 200,000.00
Institution: Country: Est Assets Under Mgt:
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
7/30/2019
DB-SDNY-0002643
EFFA_00016117
KYC Print Page 8 of 12
Institution: County: Est Assets Under Mgt
I
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002644
KYC Print Page 9 of 12
DB PWM GLOBAL KYC/NCA: US/LatAm/Int'l PART B
Relationship Name SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP
Risk Rating Comments:
Bookng Center
NY/

Offshore C Offshore Risk n  Moderate Janice Franklin re-..I NY JHigh Risk
(Compliance Signature)
O CB Managed PIC 7 DB is Trustee/Co-TrusteeDB Employee • Bearer Shares

4. Attachments
A. Type of Photo ID Provided 4 Drivers License A Passport • Nabonal/State ID O Other
Checklist el names (individualsand/or'Mites) that were submitted for database searches is B. @Yes O No attached

C. Please Indicate the results of the database searches performed
RDC searches complete @Yes • No negative results found FA Yes ONO
PCR checks complete 121Yes O No negathe results found O Yes No
OFAC checks complete 121Yes O No negative results found O Yes 0 No
BIS searches complete (Lexis/Nexis, Peak., Reuters, Dow Jones, MI CZ Yes • No negative results found O Yes 21No
Denial Orders checks complete El Yes CI No negabve results found O Yes ®No
Martindale-Hubbell searched (Lawyers/Law Firms only) O Yes 'Zi No negative results found • Yes ONo
Please sum Se any negative results from the database searches indicated above: JEFFREY EPSTEIN:
Previously = and approved in: 01082293 and 01121718
HARRY BELLER

D. Previously and approved: 01133624
NES, LLC:
Negative media does not pertain to our client. Ow dent is an LLC that is only used to pay for the costs associated with 
running a private home
No court CMOS

E. To the best of your knowledge, has the client ever been convicted of a criminal offense' ri Yes • No
To the best of your knowledge, has the customer ever been evolved in any past litigation against
AG is litigation Deutsche Bank or any of is subsidiaries or the customer threatening against ID Yet i& No F
Deutsche Bank AG Yes, del below or any of Rs subsidiaries' (If provide IS and contact Quaely
Mgt. (LatAnyint7) or the Regulatory &awl Group and notify Compeance immediatey)
financial Does the client or related party have any or other association / interacbons within G. • Yes @No Foreign 
Assets countries or regimes sanctioned by the
Office of Control (OFAC)'
financial H. Does the client or related party have any or other association/ Interactkos within high ra • Yes Ml No risk
countries'

I. Corporate Documentation Attached (Legal Entities Only) WI Yes O No O Not Applicable
J. Undisclosed Principal Form Complete (Intermediaries Only) • Yes ON* !i Not Applicable

K. If Leds/Nexis Search Results, Corporate Documents or Other Supporting Documentation is net in English, please provide
an Englsh summary of the
nature/contents of the non-English Documentation:

L. Special Risk Factors
Does the account here Nexus to Special Risk Countries' O Yes (21No
Is the account strucbme unusual/ complex' D Yes No
Dyes n No
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e)
7/30/2019
DB-SDNY-0002645
KYC Print Page 10 of 12
Is there any indication the client set up a non operating occipany
expressly for the purpose of transferring shares to third patties'
Is there any bxlicabon this could be a prohibited business relationship? ❑ yes He
Me the bearer shares kkribfied subject to acceptable controls> ❑Yes No
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002646
KYC Print Page 11 of 12

M. Casa ammonia
!to records to display.
ONSHORE APPROVALS
Dent Facing Professional (CFP): Paul Marls rignature)
ul Mont 10/22/2013
Office DirecbX/Business Head: Brian M. Biggar (Signature)
Brian M. Biggar
10/23/200
Regional Orrice Director (Signature)
AFIL Business Risk,
(Signature)
AML Compliance:
Jacqueline Lightbody
Janice Franklin
(Signature)
Jacqueline Ughtbody
Janice Franklin
11/8/3013
11/e/2013
LATAM/ INTERNATIONAL APPROVALS
Client Facing Professional (CFP): (Signature)
Account Manager. (Signature)
Global Market Team Head
•GHTH)/Sub-Ilarket Team Head
SlilTH)
(Signature)
AML Business Risk
(Signatuie)
ANL Compliance:
(Signature)
PRIVATE WEALTH MANAGEMENT POLICY STATEMENn Deutsche Bank Private Wealth Management
(PWM) worldwide is committed to professionally serve the interests of its clients. To do so, Client Facing
Professionals1(I) (CEP is)should establish and maintain business relationships only with persons who satisfy our
high standards ofsuitability, background and character. Due diligence obtained on the client must be appropriately
documented by the CFP. It is the responsibility ofCFP's to demonstrate that they know their client both at the
inception ofa relationship and on an ongoing basis.
DECLARATION FOR ALL SIGNERS OF THIS FORM: To the best ofmy knowledge and belief the above
information is correct and up to date. I confirm that I have no suspicions relating to the money laundering or
unethical activities on the pan of the client(s) and that I have followed all the procedures relating to account opening
as described in the PWM Americas Procedures and the PWM Global KYC Policy

(I) Client Facing Professionals (CPT's) include: Relationship Managers. Wealth Advisors. Product Officers.
Brokers. Client Managers, etc. •
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforee.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-0IN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002647
KYC Print Page 12 of 12
I Douro Bonk Arnorkos Now York
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R CRIM. P. 6(e)
7/30/2019
DB-SDNY-0002648
EFTA00019348 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons report on Epstein's failed suicide attempt, see quote: "staff observed inmate Epstein, Jeffrey lying in the fetal 
position on the floor with a homemade fashioned noose around his neck"
(date: 2019-08-02)
Inmate Investigative Report
Institution: New York MCC
Case Number: NYM-19-0061
Investigation Type: Investigative / Threat Assessment
Inmates Involved:
Register Number Name Role
EPSTEIN, JEFFREY Not Known
TARTAGLIONE, NICHOLAS Not Known
Staff Involved:
Name
"No information was found for the given criteria."
Others Involved:
Name
"No information was found for the given criteria."
Title
Title
;U.S. Deparl ent of Justice
Federal Su au of Prisons
Investigator: Date: 8/1/2019 5:06:24 AM CST
Captain: Date: 82!101910:06:35 AM CST
Associate Warden: Date: 82201910:32:28 AM CST
Warden: Date: 82201911:34:41 AM CST
SBU - Sensitive But Unclassified Page 1 of 5 FOIA Exempt
Summary:
On July 23, 2019 at approximately 1:27 a.m., while making routine rounds inside the Special Housing Unit, staff
observed inmate Epstein, Jeffrey Reg. No. MOM lying in the fetal position on the floor with a homemade
fashioned noose around his neck. Inmate Epstein was breathing heavily, however appeared to be responsive.
Inmate Epstein was directed by staff to stand and submit to restraints. Inmate Epstein would not stand on his own
and would not comply with staff directives. Staff entered the cell and placed inmate Epstein in both hand and leg
restraints. Inmate Epstein was searched, metal detected, placed on a gurney and escorted from the scene without
further incident. Inmate Epstein was photographed, medically examined and determined to have sustained a circular
line of erythema at the base of the neck and friction marks on the front of neck, and small 2cm erthema on left knee.
Inmate Epstein was placed on suicide watch with all necessary notifications made. There were no staff injuries
reported.
Inmate Data:
r.
Name:
Role: Not Known
Security Level: UNASSG
Facility Arrival Date: 7/7/2019
Charges:
Description
No Charges Found
STGs:
HISTORY OF COMMITTING
Name:
Role: Not Known
Security Level: UNASSG
Facility Arrival Date: 1/23/2018
Charges:
Description
- EPSTEIN, JEFFREY
No Charges Found
STGs:
EX LAW ENFORCEMENT
POSTED PICTURE CARD FILE
Victim Statements:
**No information was found for the given criteria.**
Assailant Statements:
**No information was found for the given criteria.**
Age: 66 Race: WHITE
Custody Level: IN
Projected Release Date:
Sentencing District
CIMs:
No CIMs Found
- TARTAGLIONE, NICHOLAS
Age: 51 Race: WHITE
Custody Level: IN
Projected Release Date:
Sentencing District
CIMs:
SEPARATION
SBU - Sensitive But Unclassified Page 2 of 5 FOIA Exempt
Other Statements:
Date: 7/31/2019 9:00 AM
Interviewer:
Interviewee: - EPSTEIN, JEFFREY
Location: Receiving And Discharge
Title: LIEUTENANT
On July 31, 2019, at approximately 9:10 AM., inmate Epstein, Jeffrey; Reg. No. was interviewed the Receiving
and Discharge Area. During the interview Epstein stated he did not have any sleep in approximately twenty d and he was
extremely tired the night he was found on the floor. Epstein stated he got up off his bed at approximately 1:3O .M.. to 
get a drink
of water, and all he can recall is being on the floor and hearing someone snorin that's when he realized the ng was 
coming
from him. Epstein alleged that his cell mate Tartaglione, Nicholas; Reg. No. was on the floor sleepi g at the time.
Epstein stated he has never had any Issues with Tartaglione, he is not three one y artaglione. and he do not want to 
make up
something that isn't there. Additionally, Epstein stated he can recall an incident that occurred two days prior whOn 
Tartaglione
went out to court and when Tartaglione returned he was upset. Epstein stated he attempted to talk to Tartaglione and 
Tartaglione
called him a pedophile. Epstein also stated he knew Tartaglione was upset and he let him cool off. Epstein stated he 
does not
have any issues with Tartaglione and he feels safe being housed with Tartaglione. Epstein stated he does not feel 
suicidal, he
has a new cell mate whom he gets along with, and he is able to sleep now that he has his C-Pap machine. Epstein stated 
if he
remembered anymore details he would reach out to staff or Psychology.
Date: 7/31/2019 10:00 AM Location: SHU All Other
Interviewer: Title: LIEUTENANT
Interviewee: - TARTAGLIONE, NICHOLAS
On July 31, 2019, at approximately 10:00 A.M., inmate Tartaglione, Nicholas; Reg. No. was inte ed in the
Special Housing Unit. During the interview Tartaglione stated he was asleep on the floor insi is cell, his lead was 
covered
with a sheet, and he had his headphones in his ear when he felt something hit his foot. Tartaglione stated when he 
uncovered his
head he observed Epstein, Jeffrey; Reg. No. sitting on the floor in the corner with his eyes open. Tartaglione stated
he began to call Epstein's name and when Eps e n i not answer he began to bang on the door for the officer. Tartaglione 
stated
he thought Epstein was having a heart attack because his eyes was open and he appeared to be snoring. Tartaglione stated
he
does not have any issues being housed with Epstein although he keeps his conversation to a minimal. Tartaglione stated 
he does
not understand Epstein's motive and what he Is trying to do. Tartaglione stated previously during one of their 
conversations
Epstein made him uncomfortable when Epstein stated' fourteen (14) is legal in most states and I don't understand what's 
the
problem here. Additionally, Tartaglione stated Epstein normally paces the cell and complains about his attorney's not 
doing their
Job and he needs to fire them. Tartaglione stated he does not have any issues being housed with Epstein however he does 
not
want to be involved with any plots Epstein have in mind in order to try to get released.
Factual Findings:
"No item information was found for the given criteria."
SBU - Sensitive But Unclassified Page 3 of 5 I FOIA Exempt
Type Subtype File Name Original Entered By
Inmate Discipline Administrative Detention Order ADO.pdf TF18813
Detention Order dated July 10, 2019, placing Epstein, Jeffrey; Reg. No. , in Administrative Detention
pending classification.
Inmate Discipline Incident Report INMATE EPSTEIN TF18813
IR.pdf
On July 23, 2019, staff wrote Epstein an incident report for code 228- Self Mutilation.
Medical Inmate Assessments MEDICAL TF18813
ASSESSMENT.pdf
SW, 2019, a medical assessment was conducted on Inmate Epstein, Jeffrey; Reg. No. , by
MLP. During the assessment Epstein was identified with a circular line of erythema a I lse of his
neck rea ing 2/3 of the neck circumference, 2 inches wide, sparing the back of the neck. Additiona ly, one section
of this erythema In the front has marks of friction, and Epstein was observed with a small erythema on the left
knee about 2cm in diameter(mild). During the assessment Epstein denied any respiratory problems and Epstein
denied any pain or discomfort.
Statements & Written Operation's Lieutenant OPS LT MEMO.pdf TF18813
Memorandums
On July 23, 2019, at approximately 1:27 A.M., the Operations Lieutenant submitted a memorandum which
indicated the Control Center Officer requested assistance in the S ' IHousing Unit Upon enterin the Special
Housing Unit staff made notification that Epstein, Jeffrey; Reg. No. , was observed laying in a fetal
position on the floor. Epstein was removed from the Special Housing Unit and escorted to the Health Services
Area.
Medical Inmate Assessments TARTAGLIONE TF14688
MEDICAL.pdf
1 2019, a medical assessment was conducted on inmate Tartaglione, Nicholas; Reg. No. 7W es , by
Ita
S
.
, PA-C. During the assessment Tartaglione was not identified with any injuries by Health
Photographs Contraband PHOTOGRAPH OF TF14688
HOMEMADE
ROPE.pdf
PHOTOGRAPH OF HOMEMADE ROPE ECN#NYM-19-0147
Evidence Control Chain Of Custody CHAIN OF TF14688
CUSTODY.pdf
CHAIN OF CUSTODY FORM
Conclusion:
No.
On July 23, 2019 at approximately 1:27 a.m. w i king routine rounds inside the Special Housin Unit, staff
observed inmate Epstein, Jeffrey lying in the fetal position on the floor with a homemade
fashioned noose around his neck. Inmate pstein was breathing heavily, however Epstein appea to be
responsive. Inmate Epstein was directed by staff to stand and submit to restraints. Inmate Epstein uld not stand
on his own and would not comply with staff directives. Staff entered the cell and placed inmate Epst in in both hand
and leg restraints. Inmate Epstein was searched, metal detected, placed on a gumey and escorted om the scene
without further incident. Inmate Epstein was photographed, medically examined and determined to ave sustained a
circular line of erythema at the base of the neck and friction marks on the front of neck, and small 2 erythema on
left knee. Inmate Epstein was placed on suicide watch with II necessary notifications made. On Ju 31, 2019, at
approximately 9:10 A.M., inmate Epstein, Jeffrey; Reg. No. , was interviewed in the Rece ving and
Discharge Area by SIS Staff. During the interview Epstein s e e id not have any sleep in appro imately twenty
days and he was extremely tired the night he was found on the floor. Epstein stated he got up off hi bed at
approximately 1:30 A.M., to get a drink of water, and all he can recall is being on the floor and heart g someone
snoring that's when reali the snoring was coming from him. Epstein alleged that his cell mate artaglione,
Nicholas; Reg. No. , was on the floor sleeping at the time. Epstein stated he have never ad any issues
with Tartaglione, he is not t reatened by Tartaglione, and he do not want to make up something tha isn't there.
Additionally, Epstein stated he can recall an incident that occurred two days prior when Tartaglione ent out to court
and when Tartaglione returned he was upset. Epstein stated he attempted to talk to Tartaglione and Tartaglione
SBU - Sensitive But Unclassified Page 4 of 5 FOIA Exempt
called him a pedophile. Epbtein also stated he knew Tartaglione was upset and he let him cool off. stein stated he
does not have any issues with Tartaglione and he feels safe being housed with Tartaglione. Epstein stated he does
not feel suicidal, he has a new cell mate, and he is able to sleep now that he has his C-Pap machln . Epstein stated
if he remembered anymore details he would reach out to staff or Psychology.
interviewed by SIS Staff in the Special Housing Unit. During the interview Tartaglione stalin'asleep on the On July 31, 
2019, at approximately 10:00 A.M.,
inmate Tartaglione, Nicholas; Reg. No. was also
floor inside of his cell, his head was covered with a sheet, and he had his headphones in his ear when he left
hit his foot Tartaglione stated when he uncovered his head he observed Epstein, Jeffrey Reg. No.
sitting on the floor in the corner with his eyes open. Tartaglione stated he began to call Epstein's name
and when Epstein did not answer he began to bang on the door for the officer. Tartaglione stated he thought Epstein
was having a heart attack because his eyes was open and he appeared to be snoring. Tartaglione stated he does
not have any issues being housed with Epstein although he keeps his conversation to a minimal. Tartaglione stated
he does not understand Epstein's motive and what he is trying to do but previously during one of their conversations
Epstein made him uncomfortable when Epstein stated " fourteen (14) is legal in most states and I don't understand
what's the problem here°. Additionally, Tartaglione stated Epstein normally paces the cell arid complains about his
attorney's not doing their job and he needs to fire them. Tartaglione stated he does not have any issixits being
housed with Epstein however he does not want to be involved with any plots Epstein may have in mind in order to
try to get released. As a result of a threat assessment being conducted a medical assessment was onducted on
inmate Tartaglione and Tartaglione was not identified with any Injuries. Based on the information retleived
throughout the course of the investigation there is insufficient evidence to support Epstein was assaulted by
Tartaglione. Additionally, based on the fact that during the interview with SIS staff Epstein indicated that he does not
feel threatened by Tartaglione, and he has a new cell mate whom he get along with it cannot be determined that
Epstein safety is in jeopardy at MCC New York.
Recommendation:
Based on the information received and the fact thatateigeffrey; Reg. No. indicated that he does not
feel threatened by Tartaglione, Nicholas; Reg. No. there are no CIMment of Separations
warranted at this time.
CIMS Separation Warranted: No
SBU - Sensitive But Unclassified Page 6 of 6 FOIA Exempt
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
NEW YORK
JEFFREY, EPSTEIN
REG. NO.
583 REPORT OF
INCIDENT
NYM-19-0076
Form 583 Report of Incident
Incident NYM-19- Submitted By:
C076
Date/Time Of Incident 7/23/2019 127 AM

Section 1: General Information
Staff Aware Date: 7/23/2019 1:27 AM
FBI Notified: No USMS Notified:
Location Level 1: SHU
Type•Ot Incident
❑ Assault On Inmate
❑ Assault On Staff
❑ Assault, Attempted On Inmate
❑ Assault, Attempted On Staff
❑ Disruptive Behavior
❑ Escape From Non-secure Facility
❑ Escape From Secure Facility
❑ Escape, Attempted From Non-secure Facility
❑ Escape, Attempted From Secure Facility
❑ Fight
❑ Inmate Death
❑ Institution Disturbance
❑ Introduction Of Contraband
❑ Lethal Weapons Discharge
❑ Self Mutilation
❑ Setting A Fire
❑ Sexual Act, Non-consensual On Inmate
❑ Sexual Assault On Staff
❑ Sexual Contact, Abusive On Inmate
❑ Sexual Harassment. Repetitive
❑ Staff Homicide
❑ Strike, Food
❑ Strike. Work
El Suicide Attempt
❑ Use Of Force
❑ Use Of Force/Applications Of Restraints
❑ Use of Restraints, PregnanVPostpartum
Method: Hanging/Asphyxiation
No Indicate Where Incident Occurred: Main Facility
Level 2: Housing Unit, Special (SHU) Level 3: 9 SOUTH SHU
Institution Locked Down: No
Modified Operations: No
Cause Of Incident Known? No
Cause Of Incident
❑ Alcohol
❑ Commissary
❑ Debts
❑ Disrespect Issue
• Drugs
❑ Ethnic Conflict
❑ Food Issue
❑ Geographical Conflict
❑ Interfering with Staff duties
❑ Property Issue
❑ Racial Conflict
❑ Recreation Equipment
❑ Religious Issue
❑ Security Threat Group Conflict
❑ Sexual Pressure
❑ Sporting Events
❑ Telephone
❑ Theft
❑ Visiting
❑ Work Issue

Section 2: Inmates Involved
UNCLASSIFIED/LIMITED OFFICIAL USE ONLY/LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
This document is marked Unclassified/Limited Official Use Only/Law Enforcement Sensitive and may be disseminated, with 
proper
attribution, to active Law Enforcement, DOD. or U.S. Intelligence Agencies. This document or any segment/attachment 
thereof. may
not be released without the approval of the Bureau of Prisons to any media sources, any non-law enforcement entity, the 
general
public or those without a 'need to know.' It contains Information that may be exempt from public release under the 
provisions of the
Privacy Act (5 U.S.C. 552).
1 of 3
Form 583 Report of Incident
Incident #: NYM-19-
0076
Submitted By: Date/Time Of Incident: 7/23/2019 1: AM
Reg Si:
Role: Victim
Weapon (per inmate):
CIMS: No
Restraints (per inmate)
Death (per inmate):
Reg
Role: Not Known
Weapon (per Inmate):
CIMS: Yes
Name: EPSTEIN, JEFFREY
Medical Attention Required: No
No Use of Force (per inmate): No Chemical Used (per inmate): No
STG: Yes
: Escort Only
No
Name: TARTAGLIONE, NICHOLAS
Medical Attention Required: No
No Use of Force (per inmate): No
STG: Yes
Restraints (per inmate): No
Death (per inmate): No
Injury Category: Minor Injury
Injury Category: No Injury
Chemical Used (per inmate): No
Name:
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault: No
Name: M,
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault: No
Name: M.
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault No
Name:
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault: No
Name: M.
Medical Attention Required: No
Injury Category: No Injury
Sexual Assault: No
Name:
Medical Attention Required: No Death: No

Section 3: Others Involved
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
Death: No
Staff Injury by Inmate: No
Person Type: Staff
UNCLASSIFIED/LIMITED OFFICIAL USE ONLY/LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
This document is marked UnclassreedlUmbed Mier Use Only/Law Enforcement Sensrove and may be disseminated, with proper
attribution. to active Law Enforcement DOD, or U.S. Intelligence Agencies. This document, or any segment/attachment 
thereof., may
not be released without the approval of the Bureau of Prisons to any media sources, any non-law enforcement entity. the 
general
public or those without a *need to know." It contains information that may be exempt hom public release under the 
provisions of the
Privacy Act (5 U.S.C. 552).
2 of 3
Form 583 Report of Incident
Incident it: NYM-19- Submitted By:
Ir
S
N
N
D
a
c
H
C
F.
N
Date/Time Of Incident: 7/23/2019 1:27 AM
l$VIV
ijury Category: No Injury Staff Injury by Inmate: No
exual Assault: No

Section 4: Lethal Weapon Discharge
o data found.

Section 5: Use of Force
0 data found.

Section 6: Description of Incident
ESCRIPTION OF INCIDENT (If Use Of Force, include details such as name of supervisor applying the the
gent and/or restraints, reasons for use of hard restraints Instead of soft restraints, etc.) Please be clear a
3use(s) of the incident in your description.
n July 23, 2019 at approx. 1:27 a.m., a call for assistance on the Special Housing Unit was announced by the
enter. Upon my arrival I was inf n inmate had attempted suicide and proceeded to cell, Z05-124LAD
nerved inmate Epstein, Jeffrey lying in the fetal position on the floor of his cell wearing a t-shirt and
e was breathing heavily and was snoring. I called out to inmate Epstein and observed him flicker his eyes and
losing. His neck was red with no abrasions. I observed no further injuries to his person. An attempt was made t
e inmate to stand on his own with negative results. The inmate was placed in hand restraints and staff was dir
itrieve the stretcher. As inmate Epstein was being placed on the stretcher by responding staff, he would open his
id observe staff. When staff made eye contact with him, he would hurriedly shut his eyes. The inmate was taken
A-Unit, dressed in the suicide smock and placed on suicide watch.
pon the arrival of medical staff, inmate Epstein was examined and treated by, MLP for a circular line of
ythema at the base of the neck, one section on the front with marks of friction and a sma erythema on his left
ical
out
trot
I
xers.
ntinue
get
ed to
eyes
to

Section 7: Attachments
le Date Fl    .enterecitai 7: W a
o data found.
Approved By: NOT COMPLETED
4641.
UNCLASSIF1ED/LJMITED OFFICIAL USE ONLY/LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
This document is marked Unclassified/LimIted Official Use Only/Law Enforcement Sensitive and may be disseminated, with 
proper
attribution, to active Law Enforcement, DOD, or U.S. Intelligence Agencies. This document or any segment/attachment 
thereof., may
not be released without the approval of the Bureau of Prisons to any media sources, any non-law enforcement entity, the 
general
public or those without a 'need to know.' It contains information that may be exempt from public release under the 
provisions o the
Privacy Act (5 U.S.C. 552).
3 of 3
MEMORANDUM FOR ALL CONCERNED
FROM:
SUBJECT:
UNITE. TATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York New York 10007
July 23, 2019
Operations Lieutenant
Possible Suicide Attempt
On July 23, 2019 at approx. 1:27 a.m., a call for assistance on the Special Housing Unit
was announced by the Control Center. Upon my arrival I was informed that an inmate
had attempted suicide and roceeded to cell, Z05-124LAD. I observed inmate
Epstein, Jeffrey lying in the fetal position on the floor of his cell wearing a
t-shirt and boxers. He was breathing heavily and was snoring. I called out to inmate
Epstein and observed him flicker his eyes and continue snoring. His neck was red
with no abrasions. I observed no further injuries to his person. An attempt was made
to get the inmate to stand on his own with negative results. The inmate was placed in
hand restraints and staff was directed to retrieve the stretcher. As inmate Epstein was
being placed on the stretcher by responding staff, he would open his eyes and observe
staff. When staff made eye contact with him, he would hurriedly shut his eyes. The
inmate was taken to HA-Unit, dressed in the suicide smock and placed on suicide
watch. While awaiting the arrival of an inmate companion, inmate Epstein sat on the
edge of the bed and began moving forward as if he was attempting to fall over head
first. When I looked away, he straightened up. As I turned to look at him again, he
attempted the same act. I laid him down on the bed and directed him to cease his
action or he would be placed in restraints for his safety. At that moment, he stated,
"Okay, I won't do it again," and gave the thumbs up. Because of his unpredictable
behavior, the decision was made to have a staff member observe inmate Epstein. I
left HA-Unit in order to make staff notifications. Moments later, I spoke with Officer
R who stated that inmate E stein was alert and had indicated that his cellmate,
hone, Nicholas had attempted to kill him and had been harassing
him. He stated that the inmate had indicated that he'd informed his attorney of this
matter.
I photographed and spoke with inmate Tartaglione, Nicholas who stated
that he was asleep with his headphones on when he felt something ha his legs and
said, "Jeff, what you're doing?" He didn't answer, so he got up, turned on the light and
saw him with a string around his neck. He stated that he then called the guards and
ASensitive Limited Official Use Only=
'a,
1
they ran down. Upon fi....rier questioning, inmate Tartaglione ..sated that he sleeps on
the bottom bunk, but gave it to inmate Epstein because he's old. He stated that he
sleeps on the floor on a mattress. He stated that when he got up, he couldn't
remember if he sat up or stood up to check on Epstein. He stated that Epstein was
sitting on the floor leaning to the side with his eyes opened, but wasn't responding. He
stated that the last time he saw him he was snoring really loud.
Inmate Epstein stated that he came in from a legal visit at approx. 8:00PM and staff
handed him a copy of the Daily News. "Nick" was on the floor reading the Daily News.
He stated that he had given it to him. He stated that Tartaglione mentioned that he'd
been in court all day in Westchester and was carrying on. At that point, inmate
Tartaglione paused as if he was making the story up as he went along, and stated that
Tartaglione stated, "These fucking niggers. This place is inhumane, I wish I could
report it. I ), that nigger hobbit mother fucker." He then turned to a page in
the Daily News that had his picture on it and stated that Epstein was worth seventy
seven million dollars. Epstein stated that he took his picture, balled it up and threw it in
the garbage. I asked inmate Epstein what happened prior to staffs arrival. He stated
that at approx. 1:00 AM, he'd gotten up to get a drink of water, as he gets up every
thirty minutes. He remember walking back to his bunk and waking up with staff there
in his cell. I asked if he'd waken up and seen staff, why didn't he respond when we
were calling out to him? He stated that he only remembered hearing himself making a
noise like snoring. When asked about the allegations against his cellmate, he stated
that he was told, if he hurt him, staff wouldn't care.
Duty medical, Dr. was notified and briefed. It was determined no further
medical attention was needed. A medical assessment was not conducted at the time
of this incident, due to the fact, there was no medical staff available after 10:00 PM.
witi llU on the arrival of medical staff, inmate Epstein was examined and treated by, MLPI.
for a circular line of erythema at the base of the neck, one section on the front
marks of friction and a small erythema on his left knee.
ASensitive Limited Official Use Oita'
fra• fins
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
DATE: 07
TO: Ops
FROM:
SUBJECT: Suicide Attempt Inmate
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
On the above date at approx. I:27am While working in the Special Housing Unit Myself d S/O
heard noise coming from the M tier Cell 124. Upon arrival inmate Epstein's cell mate (Urn
Tartaglione a) was at the door stating I/M Epstein had attempted to hang himself.
I kept a visual while Officer grabbed door keys and..or assistance. After securing UM
Tartaglione and removing him from the cell, I entered then placed UM Epstein on his side and removed
an orange homemade rope from his neck. I/M was breathing at this time, But unresponsive. As I began
chest compressions addition staff and Ops Lt arrived, I/M was then removed from the Special
Housing Unit without further incident.
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
DATE: July 23, 2
TO: Operations Lieytett nt, LT
PROM: OM Senior Officer iserZiltr —
SUBJECT: Inmate Epstein reg#'
On July 23, 2019 at approximately 1:27 AM while assigned to the Special Housing Unit, myselfand Senior Officer
Specialist heard some noises coming from M Tier. Upon checking cell Z05-124 I observed inmate Epstein
reg# laying down near his bunk with what appeared to be a piece of handmade orange cloth around his
neck. I immediately called Control Center for staff assistance. Officer kept a visual of inmate Epstein while I
proceeded to retrieve the door keys and the cutter from the main cabinet located in the MM. Officer applied
restraints to his cell mate inmate Tartaglione reef I secured inmate Tartaglione inside the bathroom while
Officer provided assistance to inmate Epstein. When additional staffarrived inmate Epstein was removed from
his cell without further incident.
n Pas
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
CM,TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
July 23, 2019
On July 23, 2019 at approximately 1:27, I, S.O.S responded to a body alarm on the
S ecial Housing Unit. While the 9-South officer was conducted rounds inmate Epstein, Jeffrey
was found in his cell with nd his neck and appeared to be unresponsive.
I assisted with taking inmate Epstein Mfrom his cell and putting him on a stretcher.
The inmate was taken to the second floor and placed on suicide watch, where he was monitored by
staff. Moments afterwards, inmate Epstein became responsive. While observing inmate Epstein
he sat u on the bed and began telling me that he think his Bunkie, Tartaglione, Nicholas
tried to kill him. Inmate Epstein also stated that his Bunkie also tried to extort
money from him and stated that if he didn't pay hint that he would beat him up. He stated that
this has been going on for a week. I asked inmate Epstein if he told staff about this and he told
me no, that he'd only told his lawyer. He went on to say that his Bunkie told him that if he beat
him up, because of his charges, the officers would not report it and because of this he was not
comfortable telling the officers about the prolong threats and alleged attempts to extort him. I
immediately reported this to the lieutenant.
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
DATE: July 23
TO:
FROM:
SUBJECT: Epstein, Jeffrey
ations Lieutenant
At approximately 1:27AM, I responded to a radio transmission asking for staff assistance
on 9 South (Special Housing Unit). Once I was granted access to said unit I made my way to the
location (M Tier) in which the disturbance stemmed from. I was told by Officer W. that
Epstein, Jeffrey I/M# has attempted to han himself. Upon arrival to cell number 124
in which lie was housed, I noticed J. Epstein I/M# on the floor and Officer J.
placing restraints on him. Officer D. , Lt. and I entered said cell attempting to
assist in said process.
Now that I am inside of the cell I notice that J. Epstein I/M# was snoring on the
floor of his cell, lie appeared to be asleep. We made several verbal commands for him to wake up
and attempted to get him to his feet but they were all unsuccessful. After said attempts Lt.
asked for a stretcher to be retrieve to safely remove him out of his cell. Once the
stretcher arrived, Officer D. , Officer J. and I lifted J. Epstein UM# off
the floor and placed him on the stretcher. Once we secured him safely on the stretcher, Officer D.
and I lifted J. Epstein UM# who is now on the stretcher safely out of ? South
(Special Housing Unit) and into the awaiting elevator.
es rs

╭──── Page 21, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

UNITEL 'TATES GOVERNMENT
Memorandum
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
MEMORANDUM FOR ALL CONCERNED
FROM:
SUBJECT:
July 23, 2019
, Material Handler Supervis
Possible Suicide Attempt
on,
On July 23, 2019 at approx. 1:27 a.m., the Control Center announced a call for
assistance on th pecial Housing Unit. Upon my arrival to 9-South, UM Epstein,
Jeffrey was lying on the floor of his cell handcuffed. I assisted with
carrying inmate pstein to HA-Unit on a stretcher, where he was dressed in a suicide
smock and placed on Suicide Watch observation with staff.
ASensitive Limited Official Use Only=
n PM
ES
MCC NEW YORK
NEW YORK, NY
Daily Assignment Roster
6 07:00 - 15:00
Post Split Shift 2 00:00 • 08:00 3 06:00 - 14:00 8 08:00 - 16:00
Tuesday July 23, 2019
Pago 1
9 12:00 - 20:00
10 14:00 - 22:00 12 16:00 -00:00
CAPTAIN
CAPTAIN SEC
OPS LT
ACT LT
AOMIN LT
SHU LT
SIS LT
SIS LT #2
SIA
SIS TECH #1
SIS TECH #2
PHONE MONITOR
SEC OFFICER #1
SEC OFFICER #2
TOOL ROOM
SEARCH OFFICER
2 SALLY OFF
3 SALLY OFF
LOBBY
CONTROL #1
CONTROL #2
INTERNAL
INTERNAL #2
ATTY CONF
UNIT 2
UNIT 3
5 NORTH
5 SOUTH
7 NORTH
7 SOUTH
9 NORTH
SHU #1
SHU #2
SHU #3
SHU #4
10 SOUTH #1
10 SOUTH #2
7/23/2019 7:02:27 AM
ems
,foo
Tuesday July 23, 2019
Page 2
REC OFFICER a1
REC OFFICER #2
11 NORTH
11 SOUTH
11 SOUTH #2
REAR GATE
VISIT 01
VISIT #2
VISIT #3
""Special Assignments•"'
EPO OFFICE
ESCORT OFF #1
ESCORT OFF #2
LOBBY #2
PHONE RM
9 <unassigned>
TOWN DRIVER
SUICIDE WATCH 8 <unassigned 12 <unassigned>
""Back Page Categories""
DAY OFF
ANNUAL LEAVE
LWOP
LWOP(M)
AWOL
SUSPENSION
Mewled& c
OFFICIAL TIME
Covington, T
7/23/2019 7:02:34 AM
Tuesday July 23, 2019
Pago 3
COP
IF TRAINING
—"Change Records""
Post
Relieved Officers RoHaving Officers
Spit Shft Officer Now Status Relieving Officer Previous Status
Ret
Shft Changed By
TOOL ROOM 6 ICS 711413:31
[Sick / Annual] KO 7/14 13:52
CONTROL d2 Ka 7/18 07:54
(sp)PHONE RM 2 8 " 7/18 07:54
SHU 11 8 7/18 09:22
INTERNAL 8 7/18 09:29
INTERNAL 8 KS 7/1812:07
UNIT 3 Rf/ 7/17 15:58
OT/CT Start End
OT
ATTY CONE
7 SOUTH
SHU LT 10
LWOP
5 SOUTH
rinse/led NCSI
INTERNAL 2
10 SOUTH #2 10
ACT LT 10
SHU #2
VISIT #2
RW 7/18 08 00
OT/CT Start End
07
RV/7/18 10.11
OT/CT Start End
CT
KS 7/18 10:19
7/18 11:35
RW 7/1812:10
OT/CT Start End
EIT
RW 7/19 10 19
RV/ 7/19 10:19
RW 7/19 12:15
OT/CT Start End
OT
JD 7/21 14:10
OT/CT Stott End
OT
RW 7/220821
07/CT BMW End
01
RW 722 0826
OT/CT Start End
7/23/2019 7:02:35 AM
Tuesdsy July 23, 2019
Page 4
Post Splt Stift Officer
MIT 82 9
[Ska / Annua!'
7 NORTH
11 NORTH
(sp)PHONE RM 2
SHU 81
gnserted NCSJ
SHU
SHU
SHU 81
SHU 82
7 NORTH
gikk /Annua!)
9 NORTH
11 NORTH
5 NORTH 8
INTERNAL
7 NORTH
VISIT 82
5 NORTH
Relleved Opkels RellevIng Officers Ret ,
New Status Rekning Officer Prwlous Status Shfl Changod Sy
Y
Y
RW 7/22 08:27
RW 7/22 0827
RW 7/22 08:34
OT/CT Start End
OT
RW 7/22 0845
OT/CT Start End
OT
Ks 7/22 09:05
Y RW 7/22 09:20
T/CT Start End
OT
7/22 0939
F'W 7/22 0939
Y RW 7/22 moe
OT/CT Start End
OT
RW 72210:19
Y RW 7/22 1019
OT/CT Start End
OT
RW 7/22 10:43
Wiig 7/22 10:43
Y RW 722 11:04
Over Stad End
OT
MV 7/22 14:34
72214:37
Y RW 7/22 14:45
OT/CT Start End
CT
RV'/ 7/22 14:58
OT/CT Start End
Rik 7/22 15:28
OT/CT Stad End
OT
Y MR 7/2218:12
/CT Start End
OT
7/23/2019 7:02:35 AM
Tuesday July 23, 2019
Page 5
Post Spit Stift Officer
11 SOUTH 2
INTERNAL
SHU 112
Relieved Officers
New Status
Relieving Officers Ret
Relieving Officer Previous Status Shft Changed By
iJ 7/22 1921
O7/CT Stott End
OT
12 in2 1922
2 7/22 21:14
[Sick / Annual)
SHU 02
7/22 21:14
2 Y 7/22 21:14
5 SOUTH
POT T/CT Start End
2 r 7/22 22:08
[Sick Annuag CIA 7/22 22:08
5 SOUTH 2 Y CIA 7/22 22:12
1T/CT Start End
T
[Inserted NCSJ 7/23 04:30
(sp)Strickle Watch 2 GA 7/23 04:31
(sp)Suidde Watch
INTERNAL
GA 7/23 04:31
OT/CT Start End
OT 01:30 08:00
GA 7/23 04:32
dT/CT Start End
OT 00:00 01:30
11 SOUTH 8 GA 7/23 05:05
""Recapitulation""
Morning Watch 8
AM Watch 7
Day Watch 23
PM Watch 6
Evening Watch 17
"Back Page Categories"
Sick Leave 4
Day Off 20
Annual Leave 7
LWOP 1
LWOP(M) 4
AWOL 9
SUSPENSION 1
OFFICIAL TIME 1
COP 2
IF TRAINING 3
Total Correctional Svcs. Staff: 113
Non Correctional Svcs. Staff: 2
Overtime Occurrences: 18
Comptime Occurrences: 1
Ops Li Evening Watch Signature:
Captain's Signature:
7/23/2019 7.02:36 AM
Bureau of Prisons
Health Services
Clinical Encounter
Inmate Name: EPSTEIN. JEFFREY EDWARD Reg #:
Date of Birth: Sex: M Race: WHITE Facility: NYM
Encounter Date: 07/23/2019 06:20 Provider: MLP Unit: H01
Injury Assessment - Non-work related encounter performed at Health Services.
SUBJECTIVE:
INJURY 1 Provider: MLP
Date of Injury: 07/23/2019 01:27 Date Reported for Treatment: 07/23/2019 08:25
Work Related: No Work Assignment: UNASSG
Pain Location:
Pain Scale: 0
Pain Qualities:
Where Did Injury Happen (Be specific as to location):
Special Housing Unit Z05-Cell 124 L
Cause of Injury (Inmate's Statement of how injury occurred):
"I do not know. Just went to drink a little water and wake up snorting".
Symptoms (as reported by inmate): 1,3
2None
OBJECTIVE:
Temperature:
Data Time Fahrenheit  Celsius  Location
07/23/2019 06:30 NYM 97.5 36.4 Oral
provider
MLP
Pulse:
Date Time Rate Per Minute Location alistthin provider
07/23/2019 06:30 92 Via Machine Regular MLP
Respirations:
Date Time Rate Per Minute  provider
07/23/2019 06:30 NYM 16 MLP
Blood Pressure:
Date. Time Value Location  position  Cuff Size provider
07/23/2019 06:30 NYM 140/85 Right Arm Sitting Adult-regular MLP
S3O2:
Data Time Valuerki  Air Provider
07/23/2019 06:30 NYM 96 Room Air MM. MLP
Exam:
General
Affect
Yes: Cooperative
Appearance
Yes: Appears Well, Alert and Oriented x 3
No: Appears Distressed, Lethargic, Dyspneic, Appears in Pain, Pallor, Cyanotic. Diaphoretic. Disheveled.
Generated 07/23/2019 09:05 by MLP Bureau of Prisons - NYM Page 1 of 2
em1
7 o
C.1";)
Inmate Name: EPSTEIN. JEFFREY EDWARD Reg ff:
Date of Birth: Sex: M Race: WHITE Facility: NYM
Encounter Date: 3/2019 06:20 Provider. MLP Unit: H01
Exam:
Acutely III
Pulmonary
Auscultation
Yes: Clear to Auscultation, Vesicular Breath Sounds Bilaterally
No: Crackles. Rhonchi, Wheezing
barn Comments
Inmate for injury report as requested by Operational Lt.
He is ambulatory, oriented x 3. to not apparent distress, smiling during this clinical encounter. Alleges, that he does 
not
know what happened. Can not explain the marks on his neck. Responded: "I don't know".
He does not want to talk of the events leading to the marks on his neck.
He does not look in any distress or pain.
Has an circular line of erythema at the base of the neck. Reaching 2/3 of the neck circumference, 2 inches wide, sparing
the back of the neck. Has one section of this erythema in the front with marks of friction.
No inflammation, no deformities, no hematomas. no lacerations, no tenderness. Patient moving his neck without any
restriction. Denies having any pain or discomfort. Denies any respiratory problem.
Has another small erythema on left knee about 2cm in diameter(mild).
As per information from custody staff inmate Epstein was found in his cell with a rope around his neck and sitting on 
the
floor.
Inmate is currently placed on suicide watch.
ASSESSMENT:
Injury, unspecified, T1490 - Current - R/O self inflicted injuries.
PLAN:
Disposition:
Follow-up at Sick Call as Needed
Placed on Suicide Watch
Follow-up in 24 Hours
Other:
For follow up with psychology service.
Patient Education Topics:
Date Initiated  Format  flandoutrrooic
07/23/2019 Counseling Access to Care
07/23/2019 Counseling Plan of Care
Copay Required: No Cosign Required: Yes
TelephoneNerbal Order: No
Completed by . MLP on 07/23/2019 09:05
Requested to be cosigned by MD.
Cosign documentation will be displayed on the following page.
Provider Outcome
Verbalizes
Understanding
Verbalizes
Understanding
ao°
Generated 07/23/2019 09:05 by MB MLP Bureau of Prisons - NYM Page 2 of 2
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
L Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Possible Suicide Attempt
07/23/19 —1:27 AM
Inmate Name/Register Number Epstein, Jeffrey
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Special Housing Unit
Date and Time of Photo 07/23/19 -1:45 AM
/41)
lemenetin's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Possible Suicide Attempt
07/23719 i:27 AM
Epstein, Jeffrey
Special Housing Unit
07/23/19 -1:45 AM
0 -1')
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Possible Suicide Attempt
07/23/19 — 1:27 AM
Epstein. Jeffrey
Special Housing Unit
MIMMI, Lieutenant
07/23/19 -1:45 AM
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt
Date and Time of Incident 07/23/19 — 1:27 AM
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Special Housing Unit
Lieutenant
07/23/19 -1:45 AM
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
07/23/19 - 1:27 AM
Epstein, Jeffrey
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Special Housing Unit
. Lieutenant
Date and Time of Photo 07423/19 -1:45 AM
Lieutenattr's Quiet
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Possible Suicide Attempt
07/23/19-1:27AM
Special Housing OM
07/23/19 -1:45 AM
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York,  N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Possible Suicide Attempt
Date and Time of Photo
07/23/19 — 1:27 AM
Epstein, Jeffiey
Special Housing Unit
. Lieutenant
0-723/19 -1:45 AM
ieutenant 's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident Possible Suicide Attempt
Date and Time of Incident 0723/19 — 1:27 AM
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Epstein, Jeffrey
Special Housing Unit
Lieutenant
Date and Time of Photo 07/23/19 -1:45 4 M
lieutenant Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York,  N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investintive Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
r Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Possible Suicide Attempt(Cellmatel
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
07/23/19 — 1:27 .411
Tartaglione, Nicholas
Special Housing I 'nit
Lieutenant
07/23/19 -2:25 A Al
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
r Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Possible Suicide Attempt(Cellmato
07/23/19 - 1:27 AM
Special Housing Unit
07;23/19-2:25 AM
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Possible Suicide Attempt(Celbnato
(1723/19 — 1:27 AM
Inmate Name/Register Number Tartaglione, Nicholas
Location of Incident Special Housing Unit
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo

P. Lieutenant
0723/19 -2:25 AM
'COP
I
Lieutenant's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York,  N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Possible Suicide Attempt(Cellmate)
07/23/19 - 1:27 AM
Tartaglione, Nicholas
Special Housing Unit
07/23/19 -2:25 AM
teurenam's Office
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Possible Suicide Attempt(Cellmato
07/23/19 1:27 AM
Tartaglione, Nicholas
Location of Incident Special Housing Unit
Photograph(s) by Lieutenant
Date and Time of Photo 07/23/19 -2:25 /1
COPY) t
Metropolitan Correctional Center New York, N.Y.
( t ut,van
Photo Sheet
Special Investigative Section
Type of Incident
Date and Time of Incident
Inmate Name/Register Number
Location of Incident
Photograph(s) by
Date and Time of Photo
Possible Suicide Attetnpt(Cellmatei
07/23/19 - 1:27 A Al
Tartaglione. Nicholas 1178514t
Special Housing Unit
Ma Lieutenant
07/23/19 - 7: 2. 5 JIM
copy
BPAffir0ll ADMINISTRATIVE DETENTION ORDER U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
JAN 17
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
TO: Special H ing Unit Officer
FROM:  IE ENANT
SUBJECT : Placement of EPSTEIN, JEFFERY
(Name1Title)

(a) Is pending an investigation for a violation of Bureau regulations:
(b) Is pending an SIS investigation

(c) Is pending nvesbgabon or trial for a animal act:
(0) Is to beadmitted to Administrative Detention
Reg No

(1) Since the mambas requested admission for protection:
NEWYORK MCC
Ingle/bon
Damarme 07-10-2019
7-10-2019 in Adrniristrative Detention
I hereby request placement in Admirestrabve Detention for my own protection.
Inmate Signature/Register No.:
Staff Witness Printed Name Signature:

(2) Since a serious threat exists to individual's safety as perceived by staff. although person has not requested 
admission: referral of
the necessary information will be forwarded for an appropriate hearing by the SRO.

(e) Is pending transfer or is in holdover status during transfer.
✓  «)
(9)
Is pending classification: or
Is terminating confinement in Disciplinary Segregation and has been ordered into Aceninisuative Detention by the 
Warden's
designee.
II is Ilia Correctional Supervisors decision based on all the Cif amstances that the above named Inmate' s continued 
presence in the general
population poses a serious threat to life. property, sell. staff. other inmates. orb  the security or orderly running of
the institution because'
PENDING CLASSIFICATION
Therefore. the above named inmate is to be placed In Administratne Detention until further notice. The innate received a
copy of Pis Order on
(date / tine)  ( 0 -(
Staff Witness Signature/Printed Name Date  1  / —1
Supervisor 24 hour review of placement: Signature/Printed name c-AC
• In the case of DHO action reference to that order Is sufficient. In other cases. the Correctional supervisor will make
an Mependent review and decision. which
is
documented here.
(Kg)Record Copy - Inmate Concerned (not necessary if placement is a result of holdover status): Copy - Captain: Copy - 
Und Manager: Copy - Oper • rinsor
- Admiristratne Detention tint. Copy — Psychology. Copy - Central File
COPY
PDF Prescribed by P5270 (Replaces BP-A0308 of JAN 88 ) s
le
INCIDENT REPORT
J.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
I —Institution MCC New York
2 Inmate's Name:
Epstein Jeffery

8. Place of incident:
SHU M-Tier Cell 124
9. Incident s ell w eelatiee
Part I — Incident Report
1 Inadeni Repee( Numbe
4
/sister Number.

7. Assignment:
Unassigned
. Dale of Inn3dem:
07/23/2019
8. Un
ZA
4saFbc5c 1:27am
10. Prohibited Act Code (s): 228

11. Description of Incident (Dale: 07/23/2019 Time: 127AM Staff became aware of incident):
On Jul 23.2019 at x. 1:27am While workin in it M elf and S/O heard noise n • from her cell 124.Upon arrival UM% Epstein•
a male (I was at the door staling r
pstem had attempted to hang himself. I kept a visual while I grabbed the door keys and caned or assistance. After 
Securing UM and remown tam(rain the colt
entered then placed a m  on his side and removed a orange homemade rope from his no- was • ea ng at is me But 
unresponsive. Addition staff and Ops Lt arrived WM
was then removed from SHU

12. Typed Name/Sig
INS 14. Incident Repo
(Typo Name/Sig
fling Employee:
veftd to Above Inmate By 15. Date Ina(

13. Dale And Time.
07/23/2019 3:30am
em Report Delivered: 16. Time Incident Report Delivered:
Part II — Committee Action

17. Comments of Inmate to Committee Regarding Above Incident:
18. A. It is the finding of the committee that you:
n Committed the Prohibited Act as charged:
Did not Commit a Prohibited Act.
Committed Prohibited Act Code (s).

B.   The Committee is referring the Charge(s) to the DHO for further Rearm—,
C.  I I The Committee advised the inmate of its finding and of the right to file an appeal within 20 calendar days.

19. Committee Decision is Based on Specific Evidence as Follows:
20. Committee action and/or recommendation if referred to DHO (Contingent upon DHO finding inmate committed prohibited 
act):

21. Dale and Time of Action: (The UDC Chainnantis signature certifies who sat on the UDC and that the completed tenon 
acaxately reflects the UDC proceedings).
Chairman Owed Nome/Signalure): Member (Typed Name): Member (Typed Name):
INSI RUC IONS: All Items outside of heavy rule are for staff use only. Begin entries with the number 1 and work up. 
Entnes not completed will be voided by
staff.
Distribute. Original-Central File Record; COPY-1-DHO: COPY-2-Inmate after UDC Action: COPY 3-Inmate within 24 hours of 
Part I Preparation
PDF Prescribed by P5270 Replaces OP-A0288 of AUG 11
Part III - Investigation 22. Date And Time Investi< ation Began

23. Inmate Advised Of Right To Remain Silent: You are advised of your right to remain silent at all
stages of the discipline process. Your silence may be used to draw an adverse inference against you
at any stage of the discipline process. Your silence alone may not be used to support a finding
that you have committed a prohibited act.
The Inmate Was Advised Of The Above Right By   At (Date/tine)

24. Inmate statement and attitude
25. Other facts about the incident, statements of those persons present at scene, disposition of
evidence, etc.
26. Investigator's comments and conclusions
27. Action taken
Date and Time Investigation Completed
Printed Name/Signature Of Investigator   Title
er
PDF Presaibed by P5270 Replaces BP-S288.052 Of MAY 94
cot .. dor 715/v - or/ /427A tau C
/ 4e3 &//
7-03/4
hi, t zr-F ratted A., Rk
Bureau of Prisons
Health Services
Clinical Encounter
Inmate Name: TARTAGLIONE, NICHOLAS JOHN Reg #: 78514-054
Date of Birth: 10/10/1967 Sex: M Race: WHITE Facility: NYM
Encounter Date: 07/31/2019 14:11 Provider: PA-C Unit: Z06
Mid Level Provider - Evaluation encounter performed at Special Housing Unit.
SUBJECTIVE:
COMPLAINT 1 Provider: IMIMPA-C
Chief Complaint: No Complaint(s)
Subjective: 1 feel good today, can't complain. My anxiety is getting better and I have no side effect from
the new anxiety medication"
IM being seen in the SHU as per the request of lieutenants.
States he's been doing well and has no acute complaints.
For what happened to his previous cell mate about a week ago, states "I have no idea what
was going on. I didn't do anything and I have no injury"
Pain: No
OBJECTIVE:
Pulse:
Date Time Rate Per Minute 1.12fatit211 Rhythm Provider
07/31/2019 14:19 71 Via Machine PA-C
Respirations:
Date Time Rate Per Minute provider
07/31/2019 14:19 NYM 15 PA-C
Blood Pressure:
Date Time Value Location Position  Cuff Size Provider
07/31/2019 14:19 NYM 118/70 Left Arm Sitting Adult-regular PA-C
SaO2:
Date Time Value(%) Air Provider
07/31/2019 14:19 NYM 98 Room Air PA-C
Exam Comments
General: AAOx3. NAD
HEENT: PERRLA. EOMI. Nares patent.
Neck: Supple
Heart: S1, S2. RRR
Lungs: CTAB
EXT: No edema.
Neuro: Grossly normal CN
ASSESSMENT:
Encounter for general adult medical exam without abnormal findings. Z0000 - Current
PLAN:
Disposition:
Follow-up at Sick Call as Needed
Other:
Generated 07/31/2019 14:39 by PAC Bureau of Prisons - NYM Page 1 of 2
a q
it() c',3)
Inmate Name: TARTAGLIONE. CHOLAS JOHN Reg it: RIM
Date of Birth: 10/10/1967 Sex: M Race: WHIM Facility:
Encounter Date: 07/31/2019 14:11 Provider: IPA -C Unit: Z06
IM states he feels as himself and denies being in acute distress.
Patient Education Topics:
Date Initiated  Format Handout/Topic
07/31/2019 Counseling Access to Care
Copay Required:No Cosign Required: Yes
TelephoneNerbal Order: No
Completed by IIIMIMPA-C on 07/31/2019 14:39
Requested to be cosigned by a MD.
Cosign documentation will be displayed on the following page.
Provider
IEEE
Outcome
Verbalizes
Understanding
Generated 07/31/2019 14:39 by PAC Bureau of Prisons - NYM Page 2 of 2
╔═══════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 MDC [government] Metropolitan Detention Center 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00109783 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons prisoner assignments
(date: 2019-08-03)
ki u 14 2 7'35 -
Post
•••••• 4 ••••
Splk Shift 2 00:00 08:00 3 06:00 - 14:00
MCC NEW YORK
NEW YORK, NY
Daily Assignment Roster
6 0 .00 - 15:00
8 8:00 - 16:00
Saturday August 03, 2019
Page 1
9 12:00 - 20:00
10 14:00 - 22:00 12 16:00 - 00:00
OPS LT 2 "8Mi. 5
06:00 14:00
- 12=. D
ACT LT
OT 08:00 16:00 OT
S
SHU LT 8 <unassigned>
8 <unassigned> SIS TECH #1
PHONE MONITOR ms SEARCH OFFICER 8im
LOBBY "3 <unassigned> 10=. g 5
CONTROL #1 " .2r , a S T 125.1
CONTROL 02 "3 Bonilla, B 10
INTERNAL 2M. d S "8=,1 S
OT (NC)
"12 <unassigned>
INTERNAL #2 as
OT
12 J
ATTY CONF
OT
"12
OT
k S
UNIT 2 -N. 2 s "8
8IM t S
a J
D 12 kS
12EIM a S
12= e
UNIT 3
5 NORTH
2 N
\ "2
OT
.b5
5 SOUTH 2.1
OT (NC)
"12.1 T
OT
7 NORTH
7 SOUTH
9 NORTH

• —2=
"2-T
• 21.1. s S
SIM —61<unassigned>
" 8lIIIIIIP
"8 d S
OT
12
12
'2
SHU #1 "2
OT
12 Noe: T
SHU #2 • **2 r
OT
"8 Noel, T
OT
"12 <unassigned>
SHU #3 N
OT 08:00 14:00
10 mS
SHU #4 <unass•gned> 12 <unassigned>
"12 10 SOUTH #1 N"2-, k
OT
8 .M
10 SOUTH #2 3 <unassigned> 10 <unassigned>
11 NORTH \2 J 8 . E "12
OT
11 SOUTH "2
OT
<unassigned> 12 L
11 SOUTH #2 12 C
OSP #1 • 2 .0S KS
OT
rn
SANITATION OFF **2
O1" (NC)
VISIT #1 8 (S
VISIT #2
OT
C
VISIT #3 "8
""Special Assignments ."'"
STAFF SEARCH 10 Farag. S
11212019 11:50:17 PM
• NYMBB 530*07
PAGE 018 OF 018
* ROSTER 08-04-2019
02:32:13
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG LN FN ARSD ARS E04N E04 -531L 57969-054 WESTON BOBBY 07-01-2019 A-PRE K07S K07-010U 56622-056 
WHITAKER TYRELL 08-22-2014 A-HLD ZO1A
201-102UAD 85644-054 WHITE KHALIF 05-02-2019 A-DES KI1S K11-049U 76273-054 WHITE LARRY 03-21-2019 A-HLD GO2N 002-709U 
87072-054 WILLIAMS ANDRE 08-02-2019 A-HLD
ZO6A Z06-217LAD 78640-054 WILLIAMS DAYVON 06-19-2019 A-PRE IO2N IO2 -909L 85310-054 WILLIAMS JAMES 07-10-2019 A-PRE GO6N
006-746L 79417-054 WILLIAMS JIHAD
08-17-2017 A-HLD Kl2S K12-071U 68283-054 WILLIAMS KARLIEK 07-31-2019 A-PRE GOSN 005-738L 86162-054 WILLIAMS SHARIEF 
03-26-2019 A-HLD GO5N 005-739L 79954-054
WILLIAMS SHAWN 01-25-2018 A-HLD E085 E08-557U 09310-041 WILLIAMS TIMOTHY 04-30-2019 A-DES KO4N K04-132U 87008-054 
WILLIAMS TONY 07-09-2019 A-HLD GlOS G10 -780U
75973-054 WILLIS SHANNON 03-14-2019 A-HLD G07S G07 -749L 86239-054 WILSON LEROY 05-07-2019 A-PRE 202A 202-204LAD 
69068-054 WILSON SHAWN 05-16-2019 A-HLD KOIN
KO1-106L 57610-018 WOLF LEONARD 04-04-2016 A-HLD ZO2A 202-201LAD 76232-054 WONEY ISHI 04-15-2019 A-PRE K09S K09-029U 
86315-054 WONG ZXIYU 11-14-2018 A-PRE KI1S
K11-053L 85369-054 WOOLASTON TYRONE 02-21-2019 A-PRE GO1N 001-707L 76248-054 WRIGHT CIMMIE 12-12-2018 A-PRE KIOS 
K10-037U 86477-054 WU HUALONG 01-09-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06-546U 86858-054 XIA XIU 05-21-2019 A-PRE G12S 012-789L 77167-112 YANG BINGQIN 12-04-2018 A-PRE G07S 007-750L 
86428-054 YOUNG AARON 12-19-2018 A-PRE G07S
007-751U 86868-054 YOUNG ANTHONY 04-30-2019 A-HLD G09S 009-765L 86373-054 ZAPATA-COSTRO ARGEMIRO 11-30-2018 A-PRE K12S 
K12-066U 86925-054 ZAPOLSKIJ VLADISLAV
05-31-2019 A-PRE E06N E06 -544L 86718-054 ZELAYA EDUARDO 03-14-2019 A-HLD K11S K11-060L 86331-054 ZHOU LEI 04-19-2019 
A-PRE BOIA B01-220L 86475-054 ZHUANG
LIQING 07-02-2019 A-PRE KO5N K05-134U 83742-053 ZOTTOLA ANTHONY 06-26-2019 A-PRE GO2N 002-714L 64662-053 ZUBIATE MIGUEL 
02-15-2019 A-HLD
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
Saturday August 03, 2019
Page 2
LOBBY #2
anBack Page Categories.""
DAY OFF
SICK LEAVE
;34 ---- ran H ZHZ
Mr O
> \
O 0 111 Kr Z
Z
O
>O W
M CO
.3
I)
m
n
wr • . mm o mm moo ,
8 to 00
6 w . 0, I
. tfi 0 H ...3w
8 ..".., z .0 CO
t.0
I-I
a w z it, v a
NYMGK 530*07
PAGE 002
ROSTER 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
I05N I05-936L 85828-054 ABERRANTE ANNEL 12-11-2018 A-HLD
GllS G11-783U 86957-054 ACOSTA-LIRIANO JUANCARLOS 06-13-2019 A-PRE
E01N E01-502U 86640-054 ACOSTA-SALAZAR ABEL 03-05-2019 A-PRE
KO9S K09-026L 29116-379 ACOSTA-VENTURA LINCOLN 04-04-2019 A-PRE
E075 E07-554U 25404-038 GARY 05-20-2019 A-DES
EllS E11-588U 49259-054 RAMON 06-04-2019 A-DES
El2S E12-594U 14340-067 RICHARD 01-14-2019 A-DES
K02N K02-115U 85564-054 AGUDELO-AGUDELO ORLANDO 10-31-2018 A-PRE
K1OS K10-043L 85650-053 AL-HAMIDI ALI 01-10-2019 A-PRE
K12S K12-071U 70105-050 ALAMO EDWIN 08-01-2019 A-PRE
207B 207-305LAD 77704-054 ALIMEHMETI SAJMIR 11-27-2018 A-HLD
2085 E08-564U 27933-055 ALLS RODNEY 06-24-2019 A-DES
KO9S K09-036L 85978-054 ALMANZAR NELSON 07-26-2018 A-PRE
KOSN K06-148L 86049-054 ALVAREZ CARLOS 01-22-2019 A-PRE
G06N G06-741L 77312-054 ANDREWS CHRISTOPHE 07-02-2019 A-PRE
E095 E09-565L 79767-054 ANGEVINE JAQUAN 08-03-2018 A-DES
GO5N G05-740L 90118-053 ANTNEY JOHAN 01-28-2019 A-PRE
G09S G09-765U 86374-054 ANTONIUS STEVEN 11-30-2018 A-PRE
E03N E03-523U 86434-054 APSKALNS MARTINS 12-21-2018 A-PRE
BO1A B01-219L 86821-054 ARAMBUL DAIIA 04-16-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-930U 91126-053 ARAUJO GUSTAVO 10-18-2018 A-PRE
E078 E07-550U 90522-054 ARDILA RANDOLPH 04-23-2019 A-DES
EO1N E01-501U 85794-054 ARIAS MINEL 05-06-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-909U 79562-054 ARMENTA GILBERT 07-19-2019 A-PRE
203A 203-112LAD 86123-054 ARROYO ANGEL 04-24-2019 A-PRE
I01N I01-905U 85885-053 ARTIS SOLOMAN 05-28-2015 A-PRE
207B 207-302LAD 91782-053 ASAINOV RUSLAN 07-19-2019 A-PRE
KO7S K07-003U 72419-019 ASHU CYRIL 05-29-2019 A-PRE
204A 204-212LAD 86710-054 AVILA PATRICK 03-13-2019 A-PRE
KO1N K01-106U 86953-054 AYALA RICARDO 06-12-2019 A-PRE
GO3N G03-721L 94890-038 AYBAR GERONIMO 11-01-2018 A-PRE
206A 206-217LAD 76157-054 BABROW LORENZO 10-19-2018 A-PRE
E04N E04-532L 77128-054 BALDE SOULEYMANE 01-18-2019 A-PRE
KO1N K01-103U 79781-054 BALDEO HAKEEM 06-24-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-062U 77863-112 BANG CHI 04-23-2019 A-PRE
GllS G11-785L 85714-054 BANKS EARL 07-22-2019 A-HLD
G11S G11-783U 66471-054 BANKS JAMIE 07-30-2019 A-PRE
K118 K11-077L 86820-054 BARBER BYRON 04-16-2019 A-PRE
E075 E07-551L 61881-054 BARNETT LATSEN 12-17-2018 A-DES
KO7S X07-008U 23789-057 BARRERA ESTABAN 07-18-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-929U 45655-054 BARRIENTOS RENE 02-28-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-210U 86154-054 BATISTA SAMANTHA 09-28-2018 A-PRE
KO4N K04-127U 85858-054 BATURI MUBARAK 02-08-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-221L 71423-018 BAUTA ELIANA 04-16-2019 A-HLD
HOlA H01-001L 86463-054 BENJAMIN LUIDJI 01-07-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGK 530.07
PAGE 003
* ROSTER • 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
E07S E07-554U 11608-082 BENJAMIN SEBASTIAN 07-08-2019 A-DES
E08S E08-560L 25001-052 BENNETT EDWARD 01-22-2019 A-DES
K05N K05-135L 92404-054 BETTIS ZUBEARU 07-03-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-0700 67290-054 BINNS RASHEED 08-01-2019 A-HLD
Z02A 202-203LAD 79407-054 BLADES CHRISTAN 08-17-2017 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-072U 86403-054 BLANCHE NAZAE 03-13-2019 A-PRE
G09S G09-767L 24301-052 BOARIU MARCEL 07-02-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-067U 86884-054 BOKOV JEVGENI 05-09-2019 A-PRE
EO1N E01-506L 50501-054 BOOTH RONNELL 06-05-2019 A-PRE
K11S K11-0560 79593-054 BRADFORD DAVID 04-17-2019 A-HLD
X09S K09-0350 86412-054 BRAHAM DARIEL 12-12-2018 A-PRE
K12S K12-070U 72612-067 BRANT JOSEPH 07-03-2019 A-PRE
E08S E08-563L 15015-055 BRENON TIMOTHY 07-22-2019 A-DES
E0614 E06-547L 76309-054 BRIGHT PETER 05-23-2019 A-PRE
Z03A Z03-109UAD 76269-054 BRISSETT JAMAL 03-13-2019 A-PRE
G05N G05-7340 65773-054 BRITO HASSEN 08-02-2019 A-PRE
KO4N K04-1250 86857-054 BRITO MAXIMILIAN 04-26-2019 A-HLD
ZO6A 206-2130AD 86460-054 BROCK MARK 01-04-2019 A-PRE
E11S E11-581L 85410-054 BROWN ALLEN 03-18-2019 A-DES
Z06A 206-219LAD 70786-050 BROWN CHAD 07-08-2019 A-DES
G12S G12-793L 19278-104 BROWN JOHN 03-11-2019 A-PRE
EOSN E05-533L 81131-053 BROWN KAREEN 07-20-2016 A-PRE
G01N G01-7050 83053-053 BROWN MICHAEL 07-02-2019 A-PRE
K04N K04-131L 12750-054 BROWN MICHAEL 07-25-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-010L 87035-054 BROWN RAKIM 07-19-2019 A-PRE
G0114 GO1-7070 66351-054 BRUEN DUANE 06-24-2019 A-HLD
E10S E10-5730 17190-052 BRUNNER KENNETH 12-17-2018 A-DES
E02N E02-5120 86489-054 BRYANT WARREN 01-10-2019 A-PRE
E12S E12-5930 57297-083 BUCHANAN JOHN 07-08-2019 A-DES
E05N E05-535L 86409-054 CHRISTOPHE 12-12-2018 A-PRE
E1IS E11-582L 11729-082 BUNCH JASON 01-14-2019 A-DES
K06N K06-1470 86792-054 BURGOS ANTONIO 05-31-2019 A-HLD
G0BS G08-7580 68456-298 BURGOS-CABADA JOSE 05-08-2018 A-PRE
E02N E02-5130 55210-053 BUSSEY JAVON 04-03-2019 A-PRE
G07S G07-7500 86554-054 BUTLER DENARD 01-30-2019 A-PRE
KO1N KO1-1010 86919-054 BUTLER RAHSAAN 05-24-2019 A-PRE
IO2N I02-911U 86630-054 BUTLER TUREAN 02-28-2019 A-HLD
K03N K03-123U 85984-054 CABA BATISTA HECTOR 07-30-2019 A-PRE
E0214 E02-50913 85706-054 CABAN SAMMUEL 05-17-2018 A-HLD
5118 E11-585U 65759-050 CABRERA CHRISTIAN 07-08-2019 A-DES
G03N G03-7190 79701-054 CABRERA JOHN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
G09S G09-766L 89972-053 CALABRIA JOSEPH 09-26-2018 A-PRE
E01N E01-503L 23513-053 rATABRIA MICHAEL 02-22-2017 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-912L 86115-054 CALDERON JUAN 09-12-2018 A-HLD
GO1N G01-705L 79355-054 CAMACHO FERDINAND 02-16-2018 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
NYMGK 530.07
PAGE 004
* ROSTER 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
EOSS E08-5610 86052-054 CAPELLAN BRIAN 07-15-2019 A-DES
KO7S K07-0020 41682-054 CARABELLO FRED 01-04-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05-5370 67687-050 CARABUS ALIN 07-10-2019 A-HLD
GO5N G05-7360 86509-054 CARDONA-CARDONA DAVID 04-29-2019 A-PRE
K11S K11-0560 86951-054 CARRASCO ALBERTO 06-12-2019 A-PRE
K075 K07-0040 87058-054 CARRASQUILLO MIGUEL 07-31-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-202L 76049-054 CARRILLO CINDY 01-30-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-941U 86996-054 CARRILLO JONATHAN 07-03-2019 A-HLD
I05N I05-938L 00633-748 CASTELLE EUGENE 06-19-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-221L 54630-479 CASTILLO-RODRIGUEZ LIUDMYLA 06-12-2019 A-HLD
E03N E03-518L 76139-054 CASTILLO-ROSARIO GABRIEL 02-01-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-037L 79458-054 CASTILO FELIX 05-10-2019 A-PRE
205A 205-1230AD 86164-054 CAVE ETHAN 07-26-2019 A-HLD
K1OS K10-046L 85942-054 CAZAREZ CORNELIO 07-31-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-921U 90859-053 CHACON JOSE 06-21-2018 A-HLD
KO7S K07-0060 76325-054 CHAIREZ FELIPE 07-30-2019 A-PRE
E1OS E10-573L 90370-053 CHAN MICHAEL 03-26-2019 A-DES
I03N I03-9200 85467-054 CHAN BAYARDO MAURICO 08-02-2019 A-HLD
IO1N I01-901U 86113-054 CHARDON MILTON 09-12-2018 A-PRE
E01N E01-501L 83736-053 CHARLES NALERTON 05-07-2019 A-PRE
GOBS G08-757L 78548-054 CHERRY DAVID 11-09-2018 A-HLD
KO1N K01-108L 76218-054 CHERRY ERIC 07-08-2019 A-PRE
KO2N K02-116L 86765-054 CHERRY ROBERT 03-28-2019 A-PRE
E01N E01-504L 67319-054 CHRISTIAN RAYMOND 08-22-2014 A-HLD
G03N G03-719L 75605-054 CIFUENTES-VILLA HILEEBRAND 03-15-2019 A-PRE
K05N K05-1340 86110-054 CITRONELLE GEORGE 09-12-2018 A-PRE
El2S E12-5930 68683-066 CLARK ROBERT 02-15-2019 A-DES
K116 K11-0560 53358-054 CLARK ROBERT 07-29-2019 A-PRE
E11S E11-5820 70675-054 CLARKE WAYNE 01-31-2019 A-DES
I05N I05-9360 86712-054 COLDS JALEN 03-13-2019 A-PRE
G125 G12-7930 79046-054 COLLAZO HIRAM 05-02-2019 A-PRE
Gl2S G12-7950 86959-054 COLLINS VANCE 06-13-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03-52413 86700-054 CONLEY DWAYNE 03-20-2019 A-PRE
206A 206-213UAD 89520-053 CONTRERAS JHONNY 02-20-2018 A-PRE
205A 205-122LAD 92299-054 COOPER MATTHEW 05-20-2019 A-DES
KO2N K02-1130 86655-054 CORLEY ANTHONY 03-08-2019 A-PRE
K1OS K10-0470 14661-479 CORONADO-LOZANO MARCO 12-04-2017 A-PRE
E03N E03-5220 76280-054 CORREA-YUSTY WILMER 04-03-2019 A-PRE
GO2N G02-711L 85804-054 COTTO EDDIE 05-23-2019 A-PRE
E07S E07-55417 86341-054 COTTO JOSHUA 07-02-2019 A-DES
KO2N K02-113L 15051-053 COTTON MELVIN 05-29-2019 A-HLD
G09S G09-770L 85632-054 CROOKS ALFRED 07-03-2019 A-HLD
K02N K02-1150 86972-054 CRUZ PIMENTEL NELSON 06-20-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05-5340 76258-054 CUEVAS JAVIER 01-24-2019 A-PRE
GO9S G09-7710 91662-053 CUMMINGS JASON 06-28-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGK 530*07
PAGE 005
GRP. SPECIFIC..
*
REG
ROSTER
LN FN
08-03-2019
00:57:27
ARSD  ARS
GO1N G01-708U 68395-054 CUNNINGHAM ANDRE 08-02-2019 A-PRE
E095 509-568U 89936-053 CUYLER KEVIN 03-27-2019 A-DES
El2S E12-589L 77306-054 DANSOWAH FRANKLIN 12-12-2018 A-DES
KO5N K05-134U 86725-054 DARAND ROLANDO 03-20-2019 A-PRE
KO5NK05-133U 76256-054 DAVILA ARMANDO 01-17-2019 A-PRE
K06N K06-144L 86548-054 DARIUS 01-25-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06-543U 79647-054 GARY 10-16-2017 A-PRE
K08S K08-022U 85928-054 GARY 07-26-2019 A-HLD
201A 201-106UAD 89380-053 HOWARD 09-27-2018 A-PRE
K125 K12-063U 86427-054 KAREEM 12-19-2018 A-PRE
KO3N K03-122U 19435-104 DE FREITAS FABIO 02-12-2019 A-PRE
GO1N G01-706L 76167-054 DE LA CRUZ DIONICIO 10-05-2018 A-PRE
2075 E07-555L 16520-055 DECAPUA BRANDON 02-25-2019 A-DES
K125 K12-067U 86828-054 DEL CARMEN DERIAN 04-18-2019 A-PRE
KO8S K08-018L 85417-054 DEL ORBE LUNA WINSTON 02-28-2018 A-PRE
E11S E11-582U 79251-054 DELACRUZ HECTOR 07-08-2019 A-DES
KO2N K02-116U 76278-054 DELAROSA AMADO 04-03-2019 A-PRE
El2S E12-593L 05386-090 DELATORRE PAUL 12-17-2018 A-DES
203A Z03-113LAD 86132-054 DELEON OMAR 06-25-2019 A-HLD
KO2N K02-112U 86830-054 DELOSANTOS MARIO 04-18-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-925U 76300-054 DEMANE DEBIH MARC 07-02-2019 A-PRE
E095 E09-565U 55381-066 DESILVA MICHAEL 01-14-2019 A-DES
E085 E08-564U 89424-053 DHANNA ANDRE 07-19-2019 A-HLD
KO9S K09-034L 79491-054 DIAZ ALEXIS 09-04-2018 A-PRE
202A 202-203LAD 77930-054 DIAZ ROBERT 01-04-2019 A-PRE
K03N K03-117U 86248-054 DIAZ-HERNANDEZ AUGUSTIN 10-25-2018 A-PRE
KO9S K09-030U 76156-054 DIAZ-MORALEZ VICTOR 05-23-2019 A-PRE
KO8S K08-023U 71471-054 DIAZ-PALMER OMAR 11-01-2018 A-PRE
E075 E07-552U 72042-066 DIAZ-TORRES MISAEL 01-23-2019 A-DES
KOINK01-102L 86805-054 DISLA JOSE 04-11-2019 A-HLD
205A Z05-123LAD 60685-050 DOCKERY MARTIN 04-29-2019 A-DES
201A 201-103LAD 86214-054 MINES MANOLO 01-16-2019 A-HLD
BOIA B01-218L 76187-054 DREIKSENA SANTA 06-21-2018 A-PRE
EOIN E01-505L 77665-054 DUMES CHRISTIAN 11-29-2018 A-HLD
K125 K12-065U 86764-054 DUNCAN KARL 03-28-2019 A-PRE
GO7S G07-755U 79949-054 DUPREY-VASQUEZ HECTOR 04-04-2019 A-PRE
201A 201-103UAD 86124-054 DURANT LAVELL 09-18-2018 A-HLD
IO2N IO2-9161 72418-019 EKE IFEANYI 05-29-2019 A-PRE
001N 001-703L 90791-054 ELANSKY MICHAEL 07-16-2019 A-PRE
GO1N G01-701U 86079-054 ELIAS MARCUS 07-26-2019 A-HLD
K04N K04-131U 86282-054 ELLISON ANTHONY 11-06-2018 A-PRE
E095 E09-569U 78965-054 EMILIEN ANDRE 03-15-2019 A-DES
G115 G11-788U 76263-054 ENCARNACION JESUS 02-08-2019 A-PRE
E05N E05-539L 78107-054 ENGLISH CLAUDIUS 05-15-2018 A-HLD
204A Z04-206LAD 76318-054 EPSTEIN JEFFREY 07-08-2019 A-PRE
00002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGK 530*07
PAGE 006
• ROSTER 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
KO4N K04-129L 86918-054 ESPINAL GYANCARLO 05-23-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-932L 81357-053 ESPINAL-GOMEZ JOSE ARNUL 05-16-2019 A-HLD
KO5N K05-136U 76275-054 ESTEBAN OMAR 03-21-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-525U 86846-054 ESTEVEZ BRANDON 04-24-2019 A-HLD
ZO1A ZO1-106LAD 86102-054 ESTEVEZ STEVEN 09-05-2018 A-PRE
GO6N G06-748L 86626-054 ESTEVEZ-GONZALEZ CARLOS 02-28-2019 A-PRE
KO9S K09-025U 51702-069 ESTRADA-RODRIGUEZ RAYMOND 04-04-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05-933L 86404-054 ETHERIDGE TYHEEM 12-11-2018 A-HLD
IO1N I01-903L 90863-053 FANFAN JIMMY 10-03-2018 A-PRE
EIDS E10-573L 60103-380 FAVELA FELICIANO 09-11-2018 A-DES
G116 G11-785U 86226-054 FELIPE JOHN 03-28-2019 A-HLD
206A 206-217UAD 85775-054 FELIX KERRY 04-23-2019 A-HLD
G11S G11-784L 78341-054 FELIZ RICHARD 03-05-2019 A-HLD
GO6N G06-743U 34814-054 FELTON JAMES 06-24-2019 A-HLD
E11S E11-582U 64006-037 FERGUSON LAMONT 06-24-2019 A-DES
E07S E07-549U 78002-054 FERNANDEZ HENRY 06-27-2018 A-DES
ZO5A Z05-123LAD 86824-054 FERNANDEZ LEONARDO 05-06-2019 A-PRE
KO2N K02-1140 76268-054 FERNANDEZ LUIS 07-31-2019 A-HLD
K10S K10-038L 78695-054 FERNANDEZ MARK 02-21-2019 A-HLD
E03N E03-519U 92339-054 FERNANDEZ-ROSA HECTOR 08-02-2019 A-HLD
Z04A Z04-206UAD 79793-054 FERRER GREGORY 03-28-2019 A-DES
GO2N G02-714U 85707-054 FERTIDES YASMIL 08-20-2018 A-PRE
G08S G08-760L 86993-054 FEVERIE JAHSON 07-02-2019 A-PRE
I06N I06-947U 73822-053 FIGUEROA BENJAMIN 02-13-2019 A-PRE
KO1N KO1-103U 86954-054 FIGUEROA CHARLES 06-12-2019 A-HLD
GO2N G02-716L 90774-053 FLORES ISRAEL 12-07-2018 A-PRE
808S E08-561L 59632-053 FLORES MARKO 03-11-2019 A-DES
KO3N K03-121L 90462-053 FLORES-CACHO ALEJANDRO 02-06-2018 A-PRE
E09S E09-571L 71121-050 FLOYD DISHAWN 05-15-2019 A-DES
I05N I05-934U 64593-054 FOSTER TOSHNELLE 05-06-2019 A-HLD
G11S G11-787U 76243-054 FRASCO AGUSTIN 12-06-2018 A-PRE
Z05A Z05-122LAD 86368-054 FUENTES MIGUEL 11-29-2018 A-HLD
K06N K06-143U 76195-054 GAITHER KEVON 04-16-2019 A-HLD
ZO3A Z03-110UAD 75885-054 GALAN CARLOS 03-05-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-942U 91182-054 GALLICCHIO VITO 01-17-2019 A-HLD
GO9S G09-767U 76320-054 GALVEZ-CHIMBO ROBER 07-12-2019 A-PRE
E05N E05-5330 85918-054 GAMA-PINEDA JOSE 05-30-2019 A-HLD
I05N I05-935U 90914-054 GARCIA BRIAN 07-30-2019 A-HLD
G1OS G10-776U 86878-054 GARCIA DAVID 05-02-2019 A-HLD
205A Z05-119LAD 86290-054 GARCIA JACINTO 07-08-2019 A-HLD
KO4N K04-132U 77823-054 GARCIA JOSUE 09-20-2018 A-PRE
KO2N K02-109U 79043-054 GARCIA-PENA PEDRO 03-05-2019 A-PRE
G12S G12-789U 91359-053 GASS JUSTIN 12-21-2018 A-PRE
KO2N K02-116U 86933-054 GEORGE WILLIAM 06-05-2019 A-HLD
K08S K08-016U 86325-054 GIL CESAR 11-14-2018 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
NYMGK 530.07
PAGE 007
• ROSTER * 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
GO1N GO1-7O6U 86292-054 GIL-CABRAL JUAN 07-29-2019 A-PRE
E126 812-596U 81342-053 GOBA YOUSEF 06-24-2019 A-DES
8095 2O9-567U 79460-054 GODBOLD RONALD 01-03-2019 A-DES
EO3N 13O3-522L 73746-298 GOMEZ JESUS 03-26-2019 A-PRE
K03N KO3-122L 53634-424 GOMEZ-LATOREE FERNANDO 07-25-2019 A-PRE
ZO3A ZO3-116UAD 86825-054 GONZALEZ DANIEL 04-18-2019 A-PRE
Kl1S K11-O6O13 87064-054 GONZALEZ EDWIN 08-01-2019 A-HLD
KO8S KO8-O13L 86021-054 GONZALEZ GODOFREDO 08-30-2018 A-PRE
GOBS GO8-762U 78715-054 GONZALEZ JAIME 02-13-2017 A-HLD
ZO4A ZO4-212LAD 86617-054 GONZALEZ MARCOS 06-24-2019 A-HLD
ElOS E10-579L 15657-179 GONZALEZ OSMAR 08-21-2017 A-DES
K12S K12-O62L 86097-054 GONZALEZ PETER 07-12-2019 A-HLD
EO6N EO6-548L 79984-054 GONZALEZ RICO 03-26-2019 A-HLD
KOIN KO1-1O5L 71628-054 GONZALEZ TEODORO 06-18-2019 A-PRE
GO3N OO3-723L 79486-054 GONZALEZ-SOLIZ JOSE 03-23-2018 A-PRE
1O33N KO3-12OL 75954-054 GOSWAMI VIJAY 07-24-2019 A-PRE
ZOSA ZO5-12OUAD 23152-014 GOULDBOURNE 05-07-2019 A-PRE
KO7S KO7-OO7L 76161-054 GRANADOS-CORONA EFRAIN 04-26-2018 A-PRE
GO9S GO9-766U 76229-054 GRANDE ARTHUR 10-11-2018 A-PRE
X12S K12-O72L 85835-054 GRANDY CLARENCE 01-29-2019 A-PRE
GO7S GO7-749U 86639-054 GRAY KARL 07-30-2019 A-HLD
ZO5A 2O5-117OAD 70887-054 GRAYSON MARX 05-30-2018 A-HLD
81OS E1O-575U 90504-053 GREEN RAYQUTAN 05-24-2019 A-DES
EO3N 13O3-52OU 76231-054 GREENWOOD KARL 10-19-2018 A-PRE
K07S KO7-OO7L 85966-054 GRIFFIN LAMAR 01-09-2019 A-PRE
13O4N 13O4-527U 37897-054 GRIFFIN RODNEY 04-03-2018 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-914L 86114-054 GRULLAR WILLIAM 10-05-2018 A-HLD
ZO6A ZO6-214LAD 44543-054 GUERRERO JOSE 08-01-2019 A-PRE
ZO5A ZO5-121UAD 08820-070 GUILLEN GABRIEL 05-13-2019 A-HLD
ZO5A ZO5-12OLAD 79465-054 GUILLEN WILSON 06-06-2019 A-HLD
IO1N IO1-902L 86256-054 GULIJEV MIRAGA 02-15-2019 A-HLD
KO96 KO9-O25L 86317-054 GUO QIANG 11-14-2018 A-PRE
G1O6 G1O-775L 86562-054 GUZMAN RANDY 06-25-2019 A-HLD
G116 G11-787L 85796-054 GUZMAN-CASTILLO BERNARDO 07-10-2019 A-PRE
003N GO3-722U 76151-054 HADDOW RENWICK 06-01-2019 A-PRE
BOOS EO8-564U 21066-014 BAILEY CARL 06-03-2019 A-DES
E12S 812-595L 50645-037 HALEY ANDRE 05-20-2019 A-DES
EO2N 13O2-516L 86988-054 HALL STEVEN 07-01-2019 A-PRE
EO5N 13O5-539U 87014-054 HARGROVE JAKEEM 07-11-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-O61U 86771-054 HARRIS DARRELL 04-01-2019 A-PRE
EO6N 8O6-541L 79410-054 HARRIS NICHOLAS 08-17-2017 A-HLD
13O9S 8O9-572L 13510-067 HARRIS PERCY 08-21-2018 A-DES
8086 8O8-561L 57084-056 HARRISON MICHAEL 07-11-2018 A-DES
B01A 8O1-2O4L 85973-054 HATCHER SHARON 07-26-2018 A-PRE
GO7S GO7-751L 75633-053 HAYES NICHOLAS 01-29-2018 A-PRE
GOOO2 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGK 530.07
PAGE 008
• ROSTER • 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN PN ARSD  ARS
205A 205-117LAD 14728-055 HEMINGWAY ANDRE 07-13-2019 A-DES
KO2N K02-110L 06809-000 HERNANDDEZ-VALDEZ PEDRO 01-08-2019 A-PRE
GO3N GO3-7180 76287-054 HERNANDEZ FRANCISO 07-08-2019 A-HLD
I01N I01-901L 68126-054 HERNANDEZ WILLIAM 12-21-2018 A-PRE
I04N I04-931U 17838-104 HERNANDEZ-ALVARDO JUAN 12-18-2018 A-PRE
KO8S K08-018U 56032-018 HERNANDEZ-CLAUDIOS ESTEVAN 06-25-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-210L 79305-054 HERRERA KARILIE 02-12-2019 A-HLD
KO3N K03-1210 25253-052 HERRERA SERGIO 10-16-2018 A-PRE
KO5N K05-136U 77211-054 HEYWARD CORY 08-07-2018 A-HLD
E05N E05-537L 86287-054 HIDALGO-MENDOZA VICTOR 06-26-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-928U 87048-054 HILARIO-GONZALEZ CARLOS 07-26-2019 A-PRE
GO2N G02-710L 79455-054 HILL JAQUEZ 08-17-2017 A-PRE
GO6N G06-742L 86271-054 HINES CUTIS 01-29-2019 A-PRE
KO3N K03-123L 76101-054 HO CHI PING 03-26-2019 A-HID
G12S G12-796U 86372-054 HOLLAND DAVID 11-30-2018 A-PRE
IO1N I01-906L 86200-054 HOOKER DARNEL 07-03-2019 A-HLD
Z02A 202-201LAD 87049-054 HOSSAIN DELOWAR 07-26-2019 A-PRE
ZO4A 204-207LAD 68152-054 HOYT KENNETH 05-21-2019 A-PRE
GO9S G09-769L 87002-054 HUDSON CALVIN 07-09-2019 A-PRE
KO7S K07-0110 86046-054 HUDSON DARRELL 08-13-2018 A-PRE
E06N E06-542L 62670-054 HUSSETT DEVON 07-18-2019 A-HID
I03N I03-918U 86776-054 IBANEZ-FELIX LIBRADO 05-22-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-526L 79606-054 IDELFONSO ANDRES 05-03-2019 A-PRE
KO7S K07-0730 77737-112 IGNATOV KONSTANTIN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-916U 88595-479 IKEJIMBA 06-04-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-527L 61743-054 INNIS PATRICK 11-20-2018 A-HLD
I03N I03-918L 77588-054 INZUNZA ABRAHAM 02-07-2019 A-HID
0085 G08-7590 71776-018 IRIZARRY JORGE 04-09-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-9220 86979-054 ISOM-JENKINS JABARI 06-26-2019 A-HID
11106 E10-5730 85687-054 JACKSON ERIK 06-27-2019 A-DES
GO9S G09-7690 86944-054 JACKSON HARVEY 06-06-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05-939L 86174-054 JACKSON JEROME 04-11-2019 A-HID
806N E06-542L 79729-054 JACKSON RAMEL 11-06-2017 A-HID
I05N I05-9400 68430-054 JAQUEZ CARLOS 07-25-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-9200 79306-054 JAQUEZ LUIGI 07-06-2017 A-PRE
GO3N 003-724U 76212-054 JARQUIN ARMANDO 09-08-2018 A-PRE
206A Z06-217UAD 79466-054 JIMENEZ EDWARD 08-22-2017 A-PRE
GOBS G08-764U 87067-054 JIMENEZ LEOCADIO 08-01-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-920U 86269-054 JIMENEZ RICHARD 07-31-2019 A-HID
GO2N G02-7150 76319-054 JIMENEZ-CASTILLO JUNIOR 07-12-2019 A-PRE
K09S KO9-0310 76235-054 JIMENEZ-GONZALEZ ALBERT 04-25-2019 A-HLD
GOBS G08-7630 85890-054 JOHNSON DANDRE 06-28-2018 A-HLD
KIIS K11-053U 61876-054 JOHNSON JAMAL 06-11-2019 A-HID
ZO4A Z04-211LAD 50972-054 JOHNSON JAMEL 11-14-2018 A-HID
I03N I03-917L 86461-054 JOHNSON JERMAINE 01-04-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGK 530.07 * ROSTER * 08-03-2019
PAGE 009 00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
I06N I06-943L 86885-054 JOHNSON TORRIE 07-01-2019 A-PRE
K12S K12-069U 86627-054 JONES CHAZ 02-28-2019 A-PRE
GllS G11-786U 86947-054 JONES DARRYL 06-11-2019 A-PRE
I06N I06-941L 06178-104 JONES JOHNNY 07-02-2019 A-HLD
K12S K12-065L 17742-104 JONES MICHAEL 10-30-2018 A-HLD
202A 202-201LAD 68302-054 JONES RAYSHAUN 06-03-2019 A-HLD
KOSN K05-139U 87016-054 JONES THERYN 07-11-2019 A-HLD
G06N G06-74513 69033-054 JORDAN MARKEEM 06-30-2019 A-HLD
K06N K06-141L 75996-054 JOSEPH DENFORD 05-24-2017 A-PRE
201A 201-106LAD 86931-054 KABA MORA 06-05-2019 A-PRE
E01N E01-502L 83565-098 KALABA ZEF 05-31-2019 A-HLD
KI1S K11-053U 86535-054 KAMARA ABRAHIM 04-23-2019 A-HLD
2078 207-306LAD 90479-053 KANDIC MIRSAD 11-01-2017 A-PRE
E06N E06-5480 86108-054 KEARSE RA KING 09-11-2018 A-PRE
K01N K01-105U 76306-054 KELLY JAMES 05-16-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-528L 86018-054 KENNEDY JABARI 08-30-2018 A-PRE
GI2S G12-792L 87003-054 KENYATTA CHARLES 07-09-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-073L 26178-017 KHUKHIASIIVILI TENGIZ 02-12-2019 A-HLD
K12S K12-0670 60899-054 KING BOB 07-23-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06-5450 26868-055 KING BRUCE 05-31-2019 A-HLD
203A 203-112LAD 86587-054 KINTEA MCKENZIE 06-17-2019 A-PRE
E075 207-55613 50659-018 KIRK ANTHONY 06-24-2019 A-DES
G09S G09-768L 47186-044 KIRKLAND DAJUAN 07-30-2019 A-STDY
I05N I05-934L 67531-054 KNOX WILLIAM 10-11-2018 A-HLD
G12S G12-790L 92398-054 KOLMNELA LEOM 09-18-2018 A-HLD
K10S K10-076L 76312-054 KORETSKYY MYKHAYLO 05-31-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-008L 79196-054 KOURANI ALI 05-16-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-011L 86956-054 KROMAH MOAZU 06-13-2019 A-PRE
E10S E10-574U 76140-066 LAHENS VLADIMIR 06-10-2019 A-DES
ZOSA ZOS-122LDS 86357-054 LANS LEROY 07-29-2019 A-PRE
206A 206-220LAD 79427-054 LATIMER COREY 07-24-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-202U 56431-479 LAURE-TESISTECO RITA 01-28-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-917U 85838-054 LAWRENCE CHRISTOPHE 06-24-2019 A-HLD
EllS E11-58213 48958-054 LAWTON ANTOINE 05-20-2019 A-DES
G02N G02-71613 85782-298 LEAL RAYMUNDO 07-16-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-0760 05585-070 LEBRON HECTOR 04-23-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-948U 86343-054 LEE NICK 07-17-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03-520L 18028-104 LEON-MAAL ALEJANDRO 03-26-2019 A-PRE
E02N E02-511L 86389-054 LEVINSON NI KOLAY 12-04-2018 A-PRE
K04N K04-1290 68417-054 DEVON 03-11-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-075/3 86748-054 LI TIAN 07-31-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-00413 86570-054 LITVINTSUK VIKTOR 02-06-2019 A-PRE
I01N I01-904U 85832-054 LLANES TITO 05-29-2019 A-HLD
G09S G09-7700 76244-054 LLOYD THOMAS 06-14-2019 A-PRE
E095 E09-570L 79440-054 LOGAN RAMEL 04-01-2019 A-DES
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGK 530*07 *
PAGE 010
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG
K07S K07-012L 79246-054
K08S K08-015U 76291-054
E04N E04-529U 91661-053
I04N I04-929L 86656-054
K06N K06-141L 20472-038
K07S K07-008U 51698-054
G05N 005-739U 86571-054
E095 E09-567L 79990-054
K03N K03-118L 90325-053
El2S E12-591U 15934-014
K04N K04-132L 70381-054
K09S K09-033L 76245-054
G07S G07-754L 86375-054
204A 204-210UAD 86356-054
K05N K05-139L 85841-054
G05N G05-737L 70583-054
G08S G08-761U 65947-056
G05N G05-737U 86943-054
E02N E02-512L 86602-054
K10S K10-043U 86883-054
GO3N 003-722L 76185-054
BO1A B01-218U 76261-054
E07S E07-554L 20170-052
G1OS G10-774L 72280-054
KI1S K11-055U 86917-054
K08S K08-022L 89744-053
K06N K06-142L 86569-054
I0114 I01-905L 64708-007
K08S K08-016L 01558-112
206A 206-213LAD 76003-054
IO2N I02-909U 37756-034
E075 E07-551U 69572-054
G03N G03-720L 76178-054
K08S K08-014U 86351-054
G01N G01-704U 76539-067
E075 E07-555U 11867-087
I04N I04-931L 90514-054
G05N 005-733U 86887-054
KO1N K01-101U 25768-050
K09S K09-027U 85976-054
G08S G08-760U 69055-054
IO2N I02-915L 86111-054
K02N K02-111L 27758-050
I04N I04-927L 76279-054
201A Z01-107LAD 66171-054
ROSTER
LN
LOMISHVILI
LONDONO
LOPEZ
LOPEZ
LOPEZ
LOPEZ
LOPEZ
LOPEZ
LOPEZ
LOPEZ
LOPEZ-HERNANDEZ
LORA
LOVELL
LOVICK
LUCRE
LYNCH
MABLE
MACK
MACK
MAGERRAMOV
MAGNI
MAKSIMOVIC
MALANGA
MALDONADO
MALHOTRA
MALKEYEV
MANAF
MANSARAY
MANSON
MARAT-UULU
MARGOLIES
MARGOLLA
MARQUEZ-ORTIZ
MARRERO
MARRERO
MARSHALL
MARTES
MARTIN
MARTINEZ
MARTINEZ
MARTINEZ
MARTINEZ
MARTINEZ
MARTINEZ-LOPEZ
MATTHEWS
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
08-03-2019
00:57:27
FN  ARSD  ARS
GIORGI 07-30-2019 A-HLD
OSVALDO 04-16-2019 A-PRE
ALFRED 06-28-2019 A-PRE
ANDRE 03-08-2019 A-PRE
CARLOS 01-08-2019 A-PRE
JOEL 05-16-2019 A-PRE
JOSE 02-06-2019 A-PRE
JUSTIN 01-28-2019 A-DES
LOUIS 10-16-2017 A-PRE
STEVEN 06-24-2019 A-DES
JACKSON 02-28-2019 A-PRE
JOSE 12-06-2018 A-PRE
SHERVINGTO 11-30-2018 A-PRE
FUGUAN 11-27-2018 A-HLD
BENJAMIN 06-20-2018 A-PRE
DANIEL 01-08-2019 A-PRE
TEVIN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
ALJERMIAH 06-06-2019 A-PRE
MICHAEL 02-14-2019 A-HLD
AMID
FILIPPO
DIANA
DANIEL 06-24-2019 A-DES
JONATHAN 05-02-2019 A-HLD
GUNJIT 05-23-2019 A-PRE
VYACGESLAV 08-10-2018 A-PRE
HAJI ABDUL 02-06-2019 A-PRE
NABIU 05-16-2018 A-PRE
ERIC 08-31-2018 A-PRE
BAKAI 03-27-2019 A-HLD
WOLFE 06-24-2019 A-PRE
ROBERTO 06-10-2019 A-DES
JERYLAN
JOHNATHON
NORMAN
MICHAEL
JOSE
ANTHONY
ELLIOT
JOSE
LENNO
NOEL
RICHARD
MODESTO
CHARLES
05-09-2019 A-PRE
03-11-2019 A-HLD
07-10-2019 A-PRE
03-28-2019 A-STDY
11-26-2018 A-PRE
06-03-2019 A-PRE
07-08-2019 A-DES
06-06-2019 A-PRE
05-10-2019 A-PRE
06-25-2019 A-PRE
08-01-2019 A-HLD
06-25-2019 A-PRE
06-10-2019 A-HLD
07-24-2019 A-HLD
04-03-2019 A-PRE
06-11-2019 A-DES
NYMGK 530*07 *
PAGE 011
ROSTER 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
I01N I01-908L 91753-054 MATTHEWS MICHAEL 05-13-2019 A-HLD
011S G11-782U 85716-054 MATUTE EMIL 05-22-2018 A-PRE
KO6N K06-143L 90800-053 MCCLOUD JAMES 05-02-2019 A-PRE
E02N E02-509L 19039-054 MCCOY 02-15-2019 A-HLD
K128 K12-064L 86768-054 MCDUFFIE ALBfiR 03-28-2019 A-PRE
E11S E11-584L 71694-050 MCFADDEN DAVID 06-25-2019 A-DES
ZO5A 205-122LDS 85989-054 MCGRIER FREDDIE 04-19-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-928L 66881-050 MCINTYRE BRANDON 07-26-2019 A-PRE
GO7S G07-754U 89196-053 MCKAY RASHAWN 05-23-2018 A-PRE
E085 E08-5640 65135-054 MCKINNON JOHN 06-01-2019 A-DES
KO1N K01-1010 69309-054 MCQUEEN ALIE 06-05-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-924L 79339-054 WILFRED 01-11-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-0650 92150-054 MEIGHAN AKBAR 07-03-2019 A-HLD
KO3N K03-124L 91114-054 MEJIA-VARGAS MARIO 01-29-2019 A-HLD
E03N E03-5180 61162-054 MENA-CANCEL JESUS 06-19-2019 A-HLD
GOIN G01-703U 87071-054 MENDEZ-FELIZ MARCO 08-02-2019 A-PRE
E05N E05-540L 84246-054 MENDOZA HECTOR 05-23-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-5320 57916-054 MENDOZA-SOLAN ALEX 07-19-2019 A-PRE
GO6N G06-7480 85606-054 MERCADO GABRIEL 05-30-2018 A-HLD
K125 K12-061L 86026-054 MERCHANT SEAN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
El2S E12-592U 89673-053 MERSEY WILLIAM 06-06-2019 A-DES
K10S K10-047L 85941-054 MEZA SINOHE 07-31-2019 A-HLD
202A 202-201LAD 86160-054 MICKENS DION 07-16-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-054L 85771-054 MILLER DARREN 06-27-2019 A-HLD
GO6N 006-742U 79412-054 MILLER RABIEN 08-17-2017 A-HLD
E01N E01-504U 79487-054 MINJAREZ SANTOS 05-23-2019 A-HLD
GO9S 009-7680 85605-054 MOBLEY COREY 04-24-2018 A-HLD
K12S K12-068L 79047-054 MODESTO AMAURY 01-24-2019 A-HLD
K10S K10-0440 86044-054 MOHAMED MOHAMED 09-24-2018 A-PRE
Z01A 201-108LAD 91268-054 MOJICA JASON 02-19-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-074L 86024-054 MONASTERIO LUIS 08-30-2018 A-PRE
GO7S G07-7560 19735-104 MONES-CORO VICTOR 06-13-2019 A-PRE
E11S E11-583L 19668-052 MONGO EQUAN 03-19-2019 A-BOP
GlOS G10-778U 77708-054 MONSANTO LOPEZ DANIEL 05-23-2019 A-HLD
K06N K06-1480 86272-054 MONTAS HUGO 10-31-2018 A-PRE
GlOS G10-7770 86353-054 MONTES BRANDON 06-25-2019 A-HLD
GO5N 005-734L 85982-054 MONTESINO DORFI 08-02-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-529L 63901-054 MOODY ANDREW 01-23-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-042L 79784-054 MOORE DERRICK 10-22-2018 A-HLD
K06N K06-1450 14532-104 MOORE JAMES 06-10-2019 A-HLD
K115 K11-0510 87036-054 MORA ANTONIO 07-19-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-002L 86701-054 MORA ARTURO 06-10-2019 A-HLD
G125 G12-7920 86384-054 MORA BRYAN 12-03-2018 A-HLD
IO1N I01-903U 86432-054 MORCILIO RUBEN 12-20-2018 A-HLD
801A B01-2090 91449-053 MOREAU MAGEN 07-11-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
HLD
NYMGK 530*07
PAGE 012
* ROSTER 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
E05N E05-536L 87022-054 MUNOZ HECTOR 07-15-2019 A-PRE
GO1N GO1-702L 85769-054 MURPHY ERNEST 06-06-2018 A-PRE
204A Z04-211UAD 57497-054 MURRAY DONNELL 04-11-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-922U 86019-054 MYRIE JERMAINE 08-30-2018 A-PRE
E06N E06-5440 86968-054 NAGI BILAL 06-19-2019 A-HLD
E12S E12-594L 76311-053 NAGI FIKRI 05-02-2019 A-DES
0075007-75SL 76172-054 NAJERA-FREDY 03-15-2018 A-PRE
I03N I03-924U 90218-054 NAUT JUAN 06-06-2019 A-HLD
KO5N K05-139L 86719-054 NAVEDO CHRISTIAN 03-14-2019 A-PRE
KO6N K06-142U 86301-054 NAWAZ AHMED 06-25-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-219U 85954-054 NAZINA IELYZAVETA 03-15-2019 A-HLD
E10S E10-575L 79492-054 NEGRO PONTE GIANFRANCO 12-11-2018 A-DES
GO1N GO1-702U 85772-054 NEWTON DEVONTAE 05-17-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06-548U 86923-054 NICHOLAS MALIK 05-30-2019 A-HLD
E02N E02-510U 86340-054 NIEVES IVAN 08-01-2019 A-PRE
E01N E01-508U 87066-054 NIFTALIJEV NIKOLAS 08-01-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-009L 91349-053 NOBOA MARIO 12-20-2018 A-PRE
K125 K12-069L 86407-054 NORRIS SAEED 12-12-2018 A-PRE
GO7S 007-752U 85738-054 NORVILLE DWAYNE 05-30-2018 A-HLD
E10S E10-573U 68111-054 NUNEZ FRANKLIN 06-25-2019 A-DES
KO2N K02-112L 70164-054 NUNEZ JOSE 06-10-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-033U 78025-053 NUNEZ STARLIN 03-26-2019 A-HLD
GO2N002-715L 76194-054 OCAMPO-ALVAREZ RUBEN 04-20-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-020L 86074-054 OCHOA OVIDIO 06-06-2019 A-PRE
204A Z04-206UAD 86452-054 OCHOA PERCY 01-02-2019 A-PRE
GO5N GO5-738U 85780-054 OGARRO TYREEK 05-17-2019 A-HLD
GO5N G05-735U 72661-054 OJEDA CALVIN 05-31-2018 A-HLD
KO4N K04-128L 91980-054 OLANGIAN REZA 01-25-2019 A-HLD
BOZA B01-215L 75936-054 OLIVERA JUDIE 06-28-2019 A-HLD
K08S KOS-0211i 76249-054 OROZCO JOSE 07-17-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-925U 19732-104 ORSINI-QUINTERO MICHOLS O4-09-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-039L 85805-054 ORTIZ ERVIN 06-13-2018 A-PRE
KO4N K04-126U 65410-054 ORTIZ LUIS 08-31-2018 FED WRIT
07-30-2019 A-HLD
G06N G06-743U 85875-054 OUTLAW KEITH 06-27-2018 A-HLD
011S 011-781L 79551-054 OWEN WALSTON 11-13-2017 A-PRE
GO6NG06-745L 79415-054 OWENS DOUGLAS 08-17-2017 A-HLD
GO7SG07-752L 74125-053 PAGETT LARRY 10-05-2018 A-HLD
Z04A Z04-212UAD 79166-054 PALERMO HECTOR 11-20-2018 A-HLD
E03N E03-519L 85979-054 PAPOSHVILI COCHA 07-31-2019 A-HLD
ElOS E10-576U 76364-066 PARR ROBERT 06-10-2019 A-DES
GO6N G06-747L 70497-050 PECORELLA ALAN 06-25-2019 A-STDY
K11S K11-051U 13717-041 PEJIC VEDRAN 03-06-2019 A-HLD
K098 K09-031L 90649-054 PENA EDWARD 11-27-2018 A-PRE
G1OS G10-776L 85977-054 PENA ROBERT 07-26-2018 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGK 530*07
PAGE 013
* ROSTER * 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GAP. SPECIFIC. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
K11S K11-053U 86222-054 PERALTA ORLANDO 02-25-2019 A-HLD
202N E02-514L 85435-054 PEREZ BILLY 03-08-2018 A-HLD
206A Z06-219LAO 78346-054 PEREZ CHRISTIAN 05-24-2018 A-HLD
KO4N K04-132U 91200-053 PEREZ SANCHEZ HUGO 10-26-2018 A-PRE
G03N G03-723U 90898-053 PEREZ-SANCHEZ OVIDIO 06-15-2018 A-PRE
BO1A B01-216L 86709-054 PERKINS GERALDINE 08-02-2019 A-HLD
206A 206-216LAD 14949-057 PIERCE RICHARD 08-25-2015 A-DES
G08S G08-758L 76193-054 PINEDA-OTALVARO JOSE 06-27-2018 A-PRE
I06N I06-944L 18346-037 PINKNEY ANTHONY 05-22-2019 A-PRE
E030 E03-523L 86435-054 PIRINS IGORS 12-21-2018 A-PRE
E020 E02-513L 78702-054 POLANCO JASON 04-20-2018 A-HLD
K08S K08-0210 86369-054 POLANCO SERGIO 03-24-2019 A-HLD
GO8S G08-761L 58001-054 POLK TERRELL 02-06-2017 A-HLD
E08S E08-560L 62541-050 POWELL BARRY 05-29-2018 A-DES
I06N I06-947L 85484-054 POWELL MARIO 03-24-2018 A-PRE
K08S K08-014L 76149-054 PRICE GREGORY 04-17-2018 A-PRE
G02N 002-712L 92418-054 PROFIT TRAVIS 11-15-2018 A-HLD
K05N K05-133L 71538-019 PULIDO-LOPEZ MARIO 04-10-2018 A-PRE
Gl2S G12-7940 85822-054 00 JIAN 06-18-2018 A-PRE
202A 202-204LAD 86210-054 QUIROGA FRANK 07-08-2019 A-PRE
G02N G02-709L 86608-054 RAGONESE RYAN 02-21-2019 A-PRE
K06N K06-1420 91752-053 RAI GURSIMARDE 07-09-2019 A-PRE
KO7S K07-0080 89329-053 RAKEMATOR AZIZJON 05-20-2016 A-PRE
G10S G10-7740 86879-054 RAMIREZ ADONIS 05-02-2019 A-HLD
BOBS E08-562L 81219-054 RAMIREZ EDGARDO 07-15-2019 A-DES
IO2N IO2-914U 79252-054 RAMIREZ MIGUEL 10-24-2018 A-HLD
G12S G12-795U 86958-054 RAMIREZ RAMON 06-13-2019 A-PRE
GO7S G07-756L 86551-054 RAMIREZ RONNY 07-31-2019 A-HLD
E03N E03-521L 90860-053 RAMIREZ SAUDI 01-25-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-913U 86827-054 RAMIREZ YISANDER 04-18-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-212L 68610-054 RAMIREZ ZORAIDA 10-22-2018 A-HLD
K11S K11-059L 55278-054 KAMOS DANIEL 05-29-2019 A-HLD
I010 I01-907L 78693-054 KAMOS DOMINGO 04-01-2019 A-HLD
K05N K05-1360 90137-053 KAMOS FRANCISCO 07-17-2017 A-PRE
G02N G02-710U 85428-054 KAMOS JASON 04-26-2019 A-HLD
2050 E05-5350 90880-053 RAPHAEL KEVIN 06-08-2018 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-070L 75971-112 RAZUMOVSKIY ALEKSANDR 06-26-2019 A-HLD
205A 205-123LAD 85609-054 REID MICHAEL 07-03-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-926L 86623-054 REINALDO ROMAN 02-27-2019 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-078U 86022-054 REINGOUD MURVIN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
E09S E09-571U 08200-070 RENE CHRISTOPHE 05-29-2018 A-DES
G02N G02-713L 86526-054 REYES ANGEL 05-10-2019 A-HLD
206A Z06-218LAD 85993-054 REYES EFRAIN 08-01-2018 A-PRE
205A 205-118LDS 79102-054 REYES FRANKIE 05-17-2017 A-PRE
K07S K07-0010 86319-054 REYES-BONILLA JUAN 07-15-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGK 530*07 *
PAGE 014
CAP. SPECIFIC.. REG
IO2N IO2-914U 61643-054
801A B01-203L 89522-053
G07S G07-7530 85735-054
GO3N G03-718L 69781-479
GO3N 003-717U 76284-054
GO3N 003-717L 92336-054
I03N I03-920L 91104-054
ZO6A Z06-218LAD 72008-054
Z06A Z06-218LAD 86225-054
G08S 008-764U 86815-054
K09S K09-0260 86848-054
K11S K11-0550 06303-082
K08S K08-0190 79752-054
E12S E12-5940 12558-036
BOLA B01-201L 86411-054
Kl2S K12-0720 86791-054
E06N E06-5410 85846-054
Z04A Z04-212LAD 34801-058
K07S K07-003U 85773-054
IO1N I01-902U 78258-112
E04N E04-525L 86831-054
KO4N K04-130U 91278-054
Gl2S G12-796L 29216-050
ZO4A Z04-209LAD 79168-054
0115 G11-7810 86224-054
E07S E07-550L 04883-104
G03N 003-720U 85737-054
I04N I04-932U 86117-054
E03N 1303-521U 76160-054
Gl2S G12-791L 85670-054
ZOLA 201-107UAD 74203-054
I03N I03-923U 78841-054
KO9S K09-036U 76223-054
K10S K10-045U 85927-054
E03N E03-524L 86840-054
I06N I06-943U 86025-054
IO1N I01-904L 77980-054
ZO3A 203-111UAD 86324-054
EO1N E01-5030 86169-054
K03N K03-1240 26488-038
E11-587L 58588-037
EllS E11-584U 06084-082
G02N G02-7130 85778-054
E0SN E05-5360 76220-054
G03N 003-724L 28408-054
ROSTER * 08-03-2019
00:57:27
LN  FN  ARSD  ARS
REYES-VAZQUEZ RAUL 07-17-2019 A-HLD
RINCON-VEGA
RIOS
RIVER-MARADIAGA
RIVERA
RIVERA
RIVERA
RIVERA
RIVERA
RIVERA
RIVERO
ROBERSON
ROBINSON
ROBINSON
RODDUBNOV
RODRIGUEZ
RODRIGUEZ
RODRIGUEZ
RODRIGUEZ
RODRIGUEZ
RODRIGUEZ
RODRIGUEZ
ROJAS
ROJAS-ROMERO
ROLON
ROMERO
ROMERO
ROMERO
ROMERO-GRANADOS
RONDAN
ROOPWAH
ROPER
ROSA
ROSARIO
ROSARIO
ROSS
ROSS
ROYSTER
RUGARD
RUIZ
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
CAROLYN 06-04-2019 A-HLD
DAVID 06-25-2019 A-HLD
MARIO 05-24-2019 A-PRE
JESUS O4-11-2019 A-PRE
DEVIS 02-20-2019 A-HLD
JESSE 09-28-2017 A-HLD
JOSE 05-08-2019 A-DES
JOSE 10-18-2019 A-PRE
JUSTIN 04-11-2019 A-HLD
LOUIS O4-24-2019 A-HLD
LUIS 06-05-2019 A-HLD
RICARDO 07-09-2019 A-PRE
CHARLES 07-08-2019 A-DES
ADRIENNE 07-05-2019 A-PRE
DAEQUAN 05-16-2019 A-HLD
PARIS 06-20-2018 A-PRE
PHILLIP 06-06-2019 A-HLD
TYQUAN 04-18-2019 A-HLD
SALMAN 07-02-2019 A-HLD
ADONIS O4-18-2019 A-PRE
DANIEL 06-12-2019 A-PRE
HENRY 04-05-2019 A-HLD
JUAN 01-24-2019 A-HLD
MALI 03-18-2019 A-HLD
MANUEL 06-03-2019 A-DES
RICARDO 08-02-2019 A-PRE
ADAN 09-13-2018 A-PRE
EMILIO 04-26-2018 A-PRE
EDWIN 05-30-2019 A-HLD
MIGUEL 12-09-2015 A-PRE
RAFAEL 11-19-2018 A-HLD
YEURY 05-23-2019 A-HLD
JUAN 07-12-2018 A-PRE
CARLOS O4-23-2019 A-PRE
MOSES 08-30-2018 A-PRE
COREY 12-10-2018 A-HLD
RICKY 11-14-2018 A-PRE
JOELKIN 10-03-2018 A-PRE
OSCAR 02-27-2019 A-HLD
DEVIN 09-12-2018 A-DES
MICHAEL 04-15-2019 A-DES
KELLY 05-29-2019 A-HLD
RUBEN 06-30-2019 A-HLD
RENAN 10-30-2017 A-HLD
NYMGK 530407 * ROSTER 08-03-2019
PAGE 015 00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
K11S K11-049U 87034-054 RUSSELL TSANI 07-18-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-077U 77749-054 RUSSO ROBERT 06-27-2019 A-HLD
BOXA B01-212U 34249-045 RYAN SONIA 08-01-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-942L 87009-054 SAAB ALI 07-10-2019 A-PRE
K125 K12-069L 70704-054 SAADIA MOISE 07-11-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-208L 89767-053 SAFANI HAWWA 03-22-2019 A-PRE
KO9S K09-030L 76005-054 SAINZ-FLORES JULIO 06-08-2017 A-PRE
207B 207-304LAD 79715-054 SAIPOV SAYFULLO 11-01-2017 A-PRE
KO4N K04-125L 86530-054 SALAHUDDIN KHALIL 01-23-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-930L 49953-018 SALAS TORRES FERNEY 02-07-2019 A-HLD
003N G03-721U 07687-036 SALDANA YEISON 04-19-2019 A-HLD
KO8S K08-0200 85571-054 SALEN REDHWAN 07-03-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05-5400 86263-054 SALVADOR GUSTAVO 07-23-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-213L 56234-054 SANCHEZ AURORA 04-25-2019 A-PRE
K118 K11-0530 76122-054 SANCHEZ FRANCISCO 07-31-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05-937U 85759-054 SANCHEZ RAY 04-01-2019 A-HLD
G1OS G10-7750 85756-054 SANDERS REGINALD 06-05-2018 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-067L 86027-054 SANDS REUBEN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
KO9S K09-028U 48816-066 SANTANA JOSE 02-27-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-029U 77575-054 SANTANA JOSE 07-31-2019 A-PRE
008S G08-7570 86352-054 SANTIAGO JONATHAN 11-26-2018 A-PRE
201A Z01-102LAD 08224-082 SANTIAGO LEON 05-07-2019 A-PRE
201A Z01-105LAD 80341-083 SANTIAGO-MENDOZA OMAR 04-09-2019 A-DES
K11S K11-054U 79699-054 SANTOS AOUL 10-27-2017 A-PRE
ELOS E10-576L 99462-038 SANTOS ELLIS 07-22-2019 A-DES
EOIN E01-5050 85816-054 SANTOS JOSE 05-08-2019 A-HLD
ZOSA Z06-213LAD 86638-054 SANTOS-FELIX CRISTOPHER 03-04-2019 A-PRE
KO7S K07-001L 01735-007 SATTAN HAROLD 11-02-2018 A-HLD
KOSN K05-134L 78531-054 SAUNDERS 07-24-2019 A-PRE
E08S E08-559U 08765-094 SAXON JOSEPH 03-18-2019 A-DES
GO2N 002-711U 17781-104 SAYOC CESAR 03-26-2019 A-HLD
KO7S K07-009L 53413-083 SCALES SYDNEY 02-21-2019 A-PRE
012S G12-794L 17437-104 SCHIFANO VINCENT 07-18-2019 A-HLD
207B 207-301LAD 79471-054 SCHULTE JOSHUA 05-02-2019 A-PRE
GO6N G06-741U 76292-054 SEARLES JARED 07-31-2019 A-PRE
GOSN G05-736L 83721-053 SEGUI FRANK 02-25-2019 A-PRE
EO1N E01-508L 08379-068 SEIBER RONALD 04-19-2019 A-HLD
KOSN K05-140L 53267-054 SELLERS DOUGLAS 06-04-2018 A-PRE
KOSN K05-136L 86277-054 SEMIDAY LUIS 11-01-2018 A-PRE
E04N E04-526U 71996-054 SEPULVEDA ANGEL 07-23-2018 A-HLD
K105 K10-046U 86819-054 SERRANO JOE 04-16-2019 A-PRE
GO9S 009-771L 86960-054 SHARPERSON LEROY 06-13-2019 A-HLD
E07S E07-553L 24263-052 SHOWERS RONALD 04-29-2019 A-DES
BO1A B01-2170 85797-053 SIDDIQUI ASIA 07-11-2019 A-PRE
IO5N I05-933U 19494-104 SIMON JAMAL 02-12-2019 A-PRE
00002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMGK 530*07
PAGE 016
* ROSTER * 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
G12S G12-7900 72229-054 SISNERO-GIL MARLON 04-12-2019 A-PRE
K12S K12-068U 86891-054 SMALLS LEON 05-10-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-920U 90311-053 SMART SHAUN 12-21-2017 A-PRE
Z03A Z03-115LAD 78175-054 SMITH BRANDON 06-03-2019 A-DES
KO7S K07-007U 76322-054 SMITH DAVID 07-12-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-5310 85833-054 SMITH SHASHIEME 06-20-2018 A-PRE
E11S E11-586U 90517-053 SOBERS BRENT 03-11-2019 A-DES
I05N I05-938U 85408-054 SOSA PEDRO 04-30-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-923L 86516-054 SOSA-DIAZ HENYEL 02-19-2019 A-PRE
KO2N K02-110U 86909-054 SOSA-ORTIZ NESTOR 05-20-2019 A-PRE
KO2N K02-114L 26142-038 SOTO LUIS 06-30-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-2070 86961-054 SPINELLI DOREEN 06-17-2019 A-HLD
ZO3A Z03-114UAD 69065-054 SPRULL MATTHEW 03-06-2019 A-PRE
EOGN E06-545L 86796-054 STAFFORD SIRRON 04-10-2019 A-PRE
K12S K12-063L 86616-054 STEVEN WILLIAM 03-05-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-948L 91161-053 STUART JOSHUA 05-06-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-0130 86023-054 SUCRE NERIDIO 08-30-2018 A-PRE
GO5N 005-735U 85781-054 SUMPTER TYRELL 06-06-2018 A-HLD
E02N E02-516U 85991-054 SUVERIN MAXIM 07-31-2018 A-PRE
GO5N G05-733L 79662-054 TABAR HALLIL 07-25-2019 A-HLD
K118 K11-052L 11714-052 TABOADA RICARDO 02-07-2019 A-PRE
Z06A Z06-215UAD 78514-054 TARTAGLIONE NICHOLAS 03-19-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03-517L 73974-112 TAVARES ALEX 08-10-2018 A-HLD
E03N E03-5170 86553-054 TAVARES-BRITO YIRAN 01-30-2019 A-PRE
E05N E05-538U 86995-054 TAVAREZ-MOTA DORLYN 07-03-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-0070 30772-069 TAVERAS JAIRO 07-18-2019 A-HLD
KO1N K01-101U 09521-054 TAYLOR CLIFFORD 05-22-2019 A-HLD
E02N E02-510L 91183-054 TAYLOR DAVID 12-06-2018 A-PRE
Kl1S K11-051U 86934-054 TAYLOR NATHANIEL 06-25-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-927U 91251-054 TEJADA JOEL 06-17-2019 A-PRE
KO1N K01-102U 56772-054 THERIAULT MICHAEL 04-12-2019 A-PRE
EIOS E10-580L 79823-054 THOMAS DAVID 12-10-2018 A-DES
KO1N K01-103L 66151-054 THOMAS GLENN 08-22-2014 A-HLD
K1OS K10-044L 79965-054 THOMAS JASON 02-06-2019 A-HLD
G01N 001-704L 79310-054 THOMAS LARRY 07-12-2019 A-PRE
KO8S K08-074U 79652-054 THOMAS WILLIAM 02-07-2019 A-HLD
GO1N G01-708U 86307-054 THOMPSON DAQUON 07-31-2019 A-PRE
GO6N G06-744L 16725-028 THOMPSON JAHEED 07-18-2019 A-RLD
E11S E11-581U 78359-053 TISDALE MICHAEL 01-14-2019 A-DES
K08S K08-015L 86107-054 TIURIN ANDREI 09-07-2018 A-PRE
KO1N K01-1050 86179-054 TOLENTINO DOMINGO 10-09-2018 A-PRE
GO2N 002-712U 86367-054 TOMLINSON JOWAYNE 07-22-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-5280 85608-054 TOPPIN MICHAEL 05-21-2019 A-HLD
E075 E07-5520 85382-054 TORO TYLER 07-29-2019 A-DES
K02N K02-115L 14103-052 TORRES ANTHONY 07-10-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
NYMGK 530*07
PAGE 017
* ROSTER 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
8096 E09-566U 85621-054 TORRES FAUSTO 05-06-2019 A-DES
806N E06-543L 86521-054 TORRES JOSHUA 04-24-2019 A-HLD
GO6N G06-744L 34957-054 TORRES MARTIN 10-13-2018 A-PRE
ZO5A Z05-118UAD 86020-054 TORRES OMAR 08-30-2018 A-PRE
G1OS G10-780L 85742-054 TOWNSEND DOUGLAS 05-31-2018 A-PRE
E09S E09-5720 76518-067 TURNER CLAUDE 07-22-2019 A-DES
I06N I06-945L 25352-083 TURNER WILBERT 07-26-2019 A-PRE
GO1N GO1-701L 79827-054 ULLAH AKAYED 11-07-2018 A-HLD
Z03A Z03-111LAD 28631-054 URENA ILARIO 04-06-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-075L 68339-054 URENA JUAN 05-23-2019 A-HLD
K04N K04-125L 76277-054 URENA RICHARD 04-03-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-911L 65709-054 VALAZQUEZ SAMMY 02-27-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-024L 24772-057 VALENZUELA-LIZARRAGA RAMON 12-20-2017 A-HLD
KO7S K07-003U 77662-054 VALERIO DAVID 07-23-2019 A-HOP HLD
I05N I05-938U 79919-054 VAN MANEN PAUL 01-17-2018 A-PRE
I06N 106-9430 86408-054 VANIER CARLTON 12-12-2018 A-PRE
KlOS K1O-039U 29381-050 VARGAS DAVID 08-02-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05-538L 86880-054 VARGAS JOSE 05-06-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-207L 87056-054 VASQUEZ ANAMARIA 07-31-2019 A-PRE
ZO5A 205-118LAD 76290-054 VASQUEZ PERCY 04-16-2019 A-PRE
Z06A 206-215LAD 79099-054 VEGA OVED 05-17-2017 A-PRE
I03N I03-919U 76242-054 VEISYON EDWARD 06-28-2019 A-PRE
G11S G11-7840 79831-054 VENTURA CHARLES 08-06-2018 A-PRE
801A 801-2140 86297-054 VENTURA MINERVA 07-19-2019 A-STDY
E05N E05-534L 86285-054 VICIOSO-LIMA PEDRO 11-08-2018 A-PRE
IOSN I05-9360 85992-054 VICKERS NAZEER 04-08-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-0320 30982-054 VIERRA MARK 11-08-2018 A-PRE
I04N I04-9260 85922-054 VILLANUEVA MICHAEL 05-10-2019 A-PRE
K05N K05-1350 58614-054 VIZZARI GINO 07-11-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-2200 23003-021 VO KIM ANH 06-27-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-071U 86882-054 VORONJUK VITALI 05-09-2019 A-PRE
GO6N G06-7460 68342-054 WAGNER MYRON 01-11-2019 A-PRE
K05N K05-138L 86480-054 WAITERS MARK 01-09-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06-546L 86900-054 WALKER ALLEN 07-12-2019 A-PRE
K04N K04-127L 02259-748 WALKER DELROY 06-25-2019 A-HLD
GllS G11-788L 85544-054 WALSH PATRICK 01-14-2019 A-HLD
GllS G11-786L 86336-054 WALTER FAHEEM 04-08-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-0480 77269-112 WANG SHUAIQUI 12-18-2018 A-PRE
E11S E11-5870 63274-037 WARE CRAIG 11-26-2018 A-DES
K06N K06-146L 81078-053 MAURICE 02-25-2019 A-PRE
Z02A Z02-201LAD 77510-054 VAUGHN 06-03-2019 A-HLD
KOSS K08-017U 76135-054 WATKINS THOMAS 02-14-2018 A-PRE
I03N I03-919L 92373-054 NATTIER MICHAEL 03-29-2016 A-HLD
K126 K12-078L 85377-054 WEBER JEFFREY 05-29-2019 A-HLD
E04N E04-531L 57969-054 WESTON BOBBY 07-01-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
NYMOK 530*07
' PAGE 018 OF 018
* ROSTER • 08-03-2019
00:57:27
GRP. SPECIFIC. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
KO7S K07-010U 56622-056 WHITAKER TYRELL 08-22-2014 A-HLD
201A 201-1020AD 85644-054 WHITE KHALIF 05-02-2019 A-DES
Kl1S K11-049U 76273-054 WHITE LARRY 03-21-2019 A-HLD
GO2N G02-7090 87072-054 WILLIAMS ANDRE 08-02-2019 A-HLD
206A Z06-217LAD 78640-054 WILLIAMS DAYVON 06-19-2019 A-PRE
I020 I02-909L 85310-054 WILLIAMS JAMES 07-10-2019 A-PRE
GO6N G06-746L 79417-054 WILLIAMS JIHAD 08-17-2017 A-HLD
K12S K12-0710 68283-054 WILLIAMS KARLIEK 07-31-2019 A-PRE
GO5N G05-738L 86162-054 WILLIAMS SHARIEF 03-26-2019 A-HLD
GO5N G05-739L 79954-054 WILLIAMS SHAWN 01-25-2018 A-HLD
E08S E08-5570 09310-041 WILLIAMS TIMOTHY 04-30-2019 A-DES
K04N K04-1320 87008-054 WILLIAMS TONY 07-09-2019 A-HLD
010S G10-7800 75973-054 WILLIS SHANNON 03-14-2019 A-HLD
G07S 607-749L 86239-054 WILSON LEROY 05-07-2019 A-PRE
202A Z02-204LAD 69068-054 WILSON SHAWN 05-16-2019 A-HLD
KO1N K01-106L 57610-018 WOLF LEONARD 04-04-2016 A-HLD
202A 202-201LAD 76232-054 WONEY ISHI 04-15-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-029U 86315-054 WONG ZXIYU 11-14-2018 A-PRE
KIIS K11-053L 85369-054 WOOLASTON TYRONE 02-21-2019 A-PRE
GO1N GO1-707L 76248-054 WRIGHT CIMMIE 12-12-2018 A-PRE
K108 K10-0370 86477-054 WU HUALONG 01-09-2019 A-PRE
E06N 206-546U 86858-054 XIA XIU 05-21-2019 A-PRE
Gl2S G12-789L 77167-112 YANG BINGQIN 12-04-2018 A-PRE
GO7S 607-750L 86428-054 YOUNG AARON 12-19-2018 A-PRE
G07S G07-751U 86868-054 YOUNG ANTHONY 04-30-2019 A-HLD
G09S G09-765L 86373-054 ZAPATA-COSTRO ARGEMIRO 11-30-2018 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-0660 86925-054 ZAPOLSKIJ VLADISLAV 05-31-2019 A-PRE
E060 E06-544L 86718-054 ZELAYA EDUARDO 03-14-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-060L 86331-054 ZHOU LEI 04-19-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-220L 86475-054 ZHUANG LIQING 07-02-2019 A-PRE
KO5N K05-1340 83742-053 ZOTTOLA ANTHONY 06-26-2019 A-PRE
GO2N G02-714L 64662-053 ZUBIATE MIGUEL 02-15-2019 A-HLD
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
RUNNING BOARD
DATE: Saturday, August 03, 2019
Page: 1
TIME: 14:00 Pm E/W OPS
STAMP: GPKJ (RIGHT) NYPD: 2 3 7/1.
STARTING COUNT: 761
VISITING: ES
NUMBER NAME FROM TO TIME BA CA EN ES GN GS HA IN KN KS RA ZA ZB TOTAL
Pre Check 26 10 87 78 78 82 1 87 88 142 0 77 5 761
5/5-7i Hp/ frAlt-frh Las? Of !gib 17 -74.2
Pre Check
Post Check 2 3 5N SS 7N 7S HOSP 9N 11N 115 R&D SHU 10S END COUNT
MDC BROOKLYN: 718-840-4200 NATIONAL LOCATOR CENTER: 202-307-3126 TOMBS: 212-225-7311
NYMGK 530*07 *
PAGE 001
FUNCTION: R-P
ZERO/NBR: NO
OPTION:
DUP SUPR: YES
COLUMNS 1: REG 2:
CONDITIONS (GRP 1)
CMCI NE G
CMCI NE P
POPULATION MONITORING CENSUS/ROSTER * 08-03-2019
GENERALIZED RETRIEVAL • 00:57:27
SELECTION CATEGORY: QTR EQ ALL
ORGANIZATION: FACL EQ NYM
TYPE OF FACILITY: TOP EQ T
FACILITY MANAGED BY: FMB EQ AP
LN 3: LN2 4: FN 5: ARSD 6: ARS 7: 8:
SEQ: 234 NP:
JUDG: C SORT COL: COL SEQ:
OR CONDITIONS (GRP 2) OR CONDITIONS (GRP 3) OR CONDITIONS (GRP 4)
-0-
G TOT 751 725 26
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
-W- -B-
394 342
-I- -A--H- -0-
2 13 308 443
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                        Narrow Holdings [epstein] Epstein company 
                        Chris Christie [republican] former governor of New Jersey, Trump 1.0 transition team head 
                                                                     Edmond de Rothschild [rothschild] Swiss bank 
                                                                          DBAGNY [bank] Deutsche Bank AG New York 
 Sultan Ahmed Bin Sulayem [mideast] chairman of ports in Dubai, CEO of DP World, resigned over Epstein ties [bbc] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00027019 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-08-06)
EXHIBIT A: LEON BLACK / ROTHSCHILD GROUP TRANSACTIONS
DUI
10/15/2013
Pk\ I It
Leon and Debra Black
RI ( II'll \ I
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
k MI \ I
$8,500,000
li klES#
DB-SDN Y-0002962
12/18/2013 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003484
4/25/2014 Leon and Debra Black Southern Trust Company, Inc. $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003819
4/25/2014 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003819
4/29/2014 Leon and Debra Black Southern Trust Company, Inc. $15,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003819
7/15/2014 Narrow Holdings LLC do Elysium
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $20,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004009
10/16/2014 Leon and Debra Black Southern Trust Company, Inc. $7 000 000 DB-SDNY-0004172
10/16/2014 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $13,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004172
10/22/2014 Leon and Debra Black do Apollo Management Southern Trust Company, Inc. $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004173
10/22/2014 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004173
10/13/2015 Leon and Debra Black do Apollo Management Southern Trust Company, Inc. $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004990
10/13/2015 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004990
10/14/2015 BV70 LLC Gratitude America, Ltd. $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004999
12/17/2015 Edmond de Rothschild (Suisse) SA Geneva,
Switzerland
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005122
12/18/2015 Black Family Partners, LP Southern Trust Company, Inc. $10 000 000 DB-SDNY-0005122
12/21/2015 Benjamin Edmond de Rothschild Southern Trust Company, Inc. $14,999,980 DB-SDNY-0005122
12/30/2015 Leon and Debra Black do Apollo Management Southern Trust Company,Inc. $10 000 000 DB-SDNY-0005123
3/31/2017 BV70 LLC Plan D, LLC $22 500 000 DB-SDNY-0006113
4/17/2017 BV70 LLC Plan D, LLC $8,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006197
4/25/2017 Leon and Debra Black do Apollo Management Southern Trust Company, Inc. $8,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006240
10/2/2018 Plan D, LLC BV 70th LLC' $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007669
I Please note that the account statement for this transaction lists the entity as "BV 70th LLC" instead of "BV70 LLC.
EXHIBIT B: TRANSACTIONS INVOLVING HEDGE / INVESTMENT FUNDS
DATE
5/2/2014
Pk\ rat
Southern Financial LLC
RECil'inT
Boothbay Multi Strategy Fund LP
AMOUNT
$10,000,000
B‘I I•L:
DB-SDNY-0003845
5/14/2014 Southern Financial LLC Barack Ferrazzano Kirschbaum and
Nagelberg Client Fund $99999 DB-SDNY-0003846
7/2/2014 Southern Financial LLC Joichi Ito $250,000 DB-SDNY-0003972
8/4/2014 Tudor Futures Fund Southern Financial LLC $12,826,541 DB-SDNY-0004032
8/8/2014 Tudor Futures Fund Southern Financial LLC $677,400 DB-SDNY-0004032
9/9/2014 Southern Financial LLC Joichi Ito3 $500,001 DB-SDNY-0004084
1/21/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $150,000 DB-SDNY-0004346
2/12/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $900,000 DB-SDNY-0004412
3/12/2015 Southern Financial LLC Joichi Ito4 $250,000 DB-SDNY-0004441
3/30/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $2 700 000 DB-SDNY-0004487
4/13/2015 Southern Financial LLC Neoteny 3, LP $1,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004518
6/30/2015 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004675
7/24/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $600,000 DB-SDNY-0004790
7/28/2015 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP $7,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004745
8/5/2015 Joichi Ito Southern Financial LLC $483,915 DB-SDNY-0004815
9/24/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $1,950,000 DB-SDNY-0004924
9/28/2015 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP $4,250,000 DB-SDNY-0004881
3/1/2016 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005280
3/31/2016 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LLP $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005281
5/31/2016 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $20,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005457
6/23/2016 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $250,000 DB-SDNY-0005526
8/18/2016 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $1,250,000 DB-SDNY-0005667
12/2/2016 Kyara Investments I Southern Financial LLC $10,000 DB-SDNY-0005882
12/12/2016 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $3,750,000 DB-SDNY-0005932
2 Wire details read: "Southern Financial LLC investment in Kyara Investments LLC." See DB-SDNY-0000478.
3 Wire details read: "subcr to Kyara Investments III, LLC to fund Blockstream Investment." See DB-SDNY-0000478.
Wire details read: "suber to Kyara Investment IV, LLC to fund OH2 Laboratories." See DB-SDNY-0000478.
1).k 11
1/6/2017
II \NI It
Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies LP
141.(11'11 \ I
Southern Financial LLC
kW/1 \ 1
$10,000,000
BATES #
DB-SDN Y-0005951
4/20/2017 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006240
5/5/2017 Southern Financial LLC Coatue Enterprises LLC $500,000 DB-SDNY-0000478
7/10/2017 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Ventures I LP $1,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006407
7/24/2017 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $4,250,000 DB-SDNY-0006407
10/11/2017 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $2 250 000 DB-SDNY-0006652
1/5/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $1 500 000 DB-SDNY-0006901
1/12/2018 Southern Financial LLC Coatue Enterprises LLC $500,000 DB-SDNY-0006847
2/15/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $500,000 DB-SDNY-0006985
2/21/2018 Blockchain Capital IV, LP The 2017 Caterpillar Trust $10,500,000 DB-SDNY-0006982
2/21/2018 Blockchain Capital III Digital Liquid
Venture Fund, LP The 2017 Caterpillar Trust $2,625,000 DB-SDNY-0006982
2/21/2018 Blockchain Capital Parallel Fund IV, LP The 2017 Caterpillar Trust $1,875,000 DB-SDNY-0006982
4/20/2018 Neoteny 3 LP Southern Financial LLC $30,000 DB-SDNY-0007110
6/1/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $1 750 000 DB-SDNY-0007348
6/13/2018 Southern Financial LLC Coatue Enterprises LLC $500,000 DB-SDNY-0007289
6/27/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007348
6/28/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007348
9/5/2018 Kyara Investments I Southern Financial LLC $11,392 DB-SDNY-0007568
9/28/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $8,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007623
11/20/2018 Southern Financial LLC Coatue Enterprises LLC $500,000 DB-SDNY-0007748
1/8/2019 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0007987
3/13/2019 The 2017 Caterpillar Trust Honeycomb Ventures IV LP $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0008151
3/28/2019 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0008154
4/17/2019 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $1,500,000 DB-SDNY-0008222
EXHIBIT C: CAPITALIZATION OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN'S NOW/SUPERNOW ACCOUNTS5
10/11/2013 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0002926
11/13/2013 Barry Jay Josephson $200,000 DB-SDNY-0002992
11/14/2013 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0002994
12/20/2013 Jee ers Inc. B Brokers: e Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003427
1/24/2014 $225,000 DB-SDNY-0003538
1/30/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003538
2/18/2014 Adam RI $7,500 DB-SDNY-0003640
2/20/2014 Jeepers Inc. DB Brokerage Account $4,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003640
3/18/2014 Adam RI $3,500 DB-SDNY-0003709
4/11/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $3,400,000 DB-SDNY-0003769
5/6/2014 Jeerers Inc. DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003832
5/16/2014 Island Global Yachtin: LTD $292,655 DB-SDNY-0003833
5/21/2014 Michelle Saipher / Darren Indyke $698,000 DB-SDNY-0003833
5/21/2014 Michelle Saipher / Darren Indyke $525 000 DB-SDNY-0003834
6/11/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003896
7/16/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003960
8/19/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0004022
9/17/2014 Adam Bly $3,000 DB-SDNY-0004074
10/2/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0004126
10/15/2014 Adam Bly $3,000 DB-SDNY-0004127
11/14/2014 Adam Bly $7,500 DB-SDNY-0004183
11/17/2014 Jeffrey E Epstein c/o HBRK Associates (Non-DB Account) $1 928 647 DB-SDNY-0004183
11/21/2014 Adam Bly $100,000 DB-SDNY-0004184
1/5/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0004296
5 According to KYC records, Jeffrey Epstein used the Now/SuperNow accounts (also referred to as "Elite Checking with 
Interest") for his "personal daily use."
See DB-
SDNY-0002607. The attached chart reflects incoming wire transfers from Deutsche Bank brokerage accounts and accounts 
held at third party financial institutions.
The chart
does not capture internal cash transfers between Deutsche Bank deposit accounts.
6 In early 2016, Jeffrey Epstein moved his assets from one Now/SuperNow account to a different Now/SuperNow account. We 
are still unclear as to why this
transition
occurred, but expect electronic communications to provide additional insight. To date, the only functional difference 
between the two accounts that we have
identified is the
account number, which is reflected in the "Recipient" column.
2r 10;'2015 Jee ers Inc. DB Brokera e Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004359
3/9/2015 Adam BI $10,484 DB-SDNY-0004431
3/13/2015 Jee ers Inc. DB Brokerage Account $2 000 000 DB-SDNY-0004431
3/27/2015 Jee ers Inc. DB Brokerage Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004432
4/16/2015 Jee ers Inc. B Brokerage Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004509
5/18/2015 Jee ers Inc. B Brokerage Account $2 000 000 DB-SDNY-0004587
6/3/2015 Adam BI $10 484 DB-SDNY-0004665
6/12/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004665
7/6/2015 AIC Title Agency $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004735
7/9/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $3,200,000 DB-SDNY-0004736
8/13/2015 Seed Media Group $170,000 DB-SDNY-0004806
8/20/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004807
10/7/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004937
10/19/2015 Stone & Ma anini LLP $1 000,000 DB-SDNY-0004937
10/29/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0004938
11/13/2015 Kellerhals Ferguson Kroblin PLLC $23,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005003
1/8/2016 The Haze Trust (DB Brokerage Account) $20,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005135
2/2/2016 Kellerhals Fer uson Kroblin PLLC $75,000 DB-SDNY-0005201
4/19/2016 Gol Muchnik $500,000 DB-SDNY-0005342
9/9/2016 Jee ers Inc. DB Brokerage Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005683
9/28/2016 Jeffre E stein on-DB Account $700,000 DB-SDNY-0005684
10/7/2016 Delson International Inc. $50,000 DB-SDNY-0005747
10/26/2016 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005748
10/27/2016 Delson International Inc. $50,574 DB-SDNY-0005749
7/18/2017 Sultan Bin Sulayem $6,200 DB-SDNY-0006349
10/26/2017 Jamie Mitchell $100,000 DB-SDNY-0006594
12/20/2017 NLR Resorts International LLC $50,000 DB-SDNY-0006756
1/16/2018 NLR Resorts International LLC $25,000 DB-SDNY-0006839
1/23/2018 NLR Resorts International LLC $25,000 DB-SDNY-0006839
3/30/2018 David J Mitchell $50,000 DB-SDNY-0007012
9/18/2018 David J Mitchell $50,000 DB-SDNY-0007561
9/28/2018 Jeffrey Epstein (Non-DB Account) $700,000 DB-SDNY-0006510
i) kl I
10/11/2018
i) kl I It
David J Mitchell
RI ( II'll \l '' \\MI NI
$125,000
i311 1,, ,,
DB-SDNY-0007651
10/24/2018 David J Mitchell $10,000 DB-SDNY-0007652
10/25/2018 Link Rockenbach P.A. $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007653
11/9/2018 David J Mitchell $80,000 DB-SDNY-0007741
12/13/2018 David J Mitchell $50,000 DB-SDNY-0007834
1/10/2019 David J Mitchell $100,000 DB-SDNY-0007924
1/11/2019 Jeffrey Epstein (Non-DB Account) $100,000 DB-SDNY-0007924
2/7/2019 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $3,276,640 DB-SDNY-0008016
3/5/2019 David J Mitchell $25,000 DB-SDNY-0008097
3/5/2019 David J Mitchell $14,000 DB-SDNY-0008097
3/5/2019 David J Mitchell $4,000 DB-SDNY-0008097
3/18/2019 David J Mitchell $5,500 DB-SDNY-0008099
4/1/2019 David J Mitchell $3,000 DB-SDNY-0008179
4/2/2019 $54 000 DB-SDNY-0008180
4/11/2019 David J Mitchell $7,800 DB-SDNY-0008181
4/12/2019 David J Mitchell $2,200 DB-SDNY-0008181
EXHIBIT D: TRANSACTIONS INVOLVING THE HAZE TRUST ACCOU \ I s'
1)x II i) %NI It RECIPIENT ICNIOI \ I fiN. I11#
3/10/2017 The Haze Trust Brokerage (a) The Haze Trust Checking ( $36,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006153
3/10/2017 The Haze Trust Checking a) The Haze Trust DBAGNY a $35,999,000 DB-SDNY-0006153
3/27/2017 The Haze Trust DBAGNY a) Plan D, LLC Checking ( $15,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006168
6/19/2017 Christie's Inc. The Haze Trust Checking I $7,725,000 DB-SDNY-0006320
9/25/2017 Sotheby's The Haze Trust Checking i $11,536,544 DB-SDNY-0006565
9/26/2017 The Haze Trust Checking I The Haze Trust DBAGNY al) $15,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006565
10/24/2017 Sotheby's The Haze Trust Checking I $11,249,417 DB-SDNY-0006646
10/26/2017 The Haze Trust Checking I The Haze Trust DBAGNY (=M[) $13,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006646
6/22/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGNY a) Southern Financial LLC Checking a $9,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007361
8/20/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGNY a) Southern Financial LLC Checking a $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007544
9/17/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGNY a) Southern Financial LLC DBAGNY a $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007635
9/28/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGNY a) Southern Financial LLC Checking a $8,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007635
10/1/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGNY a) Southern Trust Company Checking a $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007725
10/24/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGNY Southern Financial LLC Checking $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007725
11/20/2018 The Haze Trust Checking a) Southern Financial LLC Checking ( $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0007798
12/13/2018 HSBC Bank Bermuda Limited 11 The Haze Trust Checking a $58,328 DB-SDNY-0007888
12/19/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGNY (a) Southern Financial LLC Checking a $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007908
1/10/2019 The Haze Trust DBAGNY a) The Haze Trust Checking I $2,727,941 DB-SDNY-0007979
1/10/2019 The Haze Trust Brokerage I The Haze Trust Checking I $6,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007979
2/7/2019 The Haze Trust Checking I Southern Financial LLC Checking a$8,791,283 DB-SDNY-0008063
2/19/2019 The Haze Trust Brokerage The Haze Trust Checking $12,608,253 DB-SDNY-0008064
2/19/2019 The Haze Trust Brokerage The Haze Trust Checking $167,414 DB-SDNY-0008064
2/19/2019 Southern Financial LLC Checking ( The Haze Trust Checking I $11,715,364 DB-SDNY-0008063
2/19/2019 Jeffrey Epstein Checking a) The Haze Trust Checking a $7,000,000 DB-SDNY-0008063
2/22/2019 The Haze Trust Checking ) Jeffrey Epstein Checking 1 I $7,000,000 DB-SDNY-0008063
2/22/2019 The Haze Trust Checking O Southern Financial LLC Checking ( $24,564,037 DB-SDNY-0008063
7 The below chart reflects the flow of money through two deposit accounts and one brokerage account belonging to "The 
Haze Trust." The Haze Trust Checking
account
was opened with Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas. The Haze Trust DBAGNY account was opened with Deutsche Bank's New 
York branch office. The latter account
offers higher interest rates than the former. We have yet to determine how the Haze Trust Brokerage account was 
initially capitalized.
EXHIBIT E: TRANSACTIONS INVOLVING GRATITUDE AMERICA MONEY MARKET DEPOSIT ACCOUNT ("MMDA") 8
10/14/2015 BV70 LLC Gratitude America, LTD I I $10 000 000 DB-SDNY-0004999
1/7/2016 Gratitude America MMDA (a) Bruce and Marsha Moskowitz Fotmdation $50,000 DB-SDNY-0005198
1/21/2016 Gratitude America MMDA (
Gratitude America Ltd
(First Bank of Puerto Rico)
$50,000 DB-SDNY-0005198
1/29/2016 Gratitude America MMDA ( I Melanoma Research Alliance Foundation $225 000 DB-SDNY-0005198
2/3/2016 Gratitude America MMDA ( I Gratitude America Checkin ( ) $150,000 DB-SDNY-0005264
3/2/2016 Gratitude America MMDA (
Gratitude America Ltd.
(Morgan Stanley / Citibank) 10
$5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005334
3/8/2016 Gratitude America MMDA ( Gratitude America Checking $250,000 DB-SDNY-0005334
3/8/2016 Gratitude America MMDA ( Gratitude America Checking $250,000 DB-SDNY-0005334
4/6/2016 Gratitude America MMDA (
Gratitude America Ltd
(First Bank of Puerto Rico)
$250,000 DB-SDNY-0005401
7/12/2016
7/14/2016
Gratitude America MMDA ( Bruce and Marsha Moskowitz Foundation $50,000 DB-SDNY-0005605
Gratitude America MMDA (
Gratitude America Ltd.
Mor an Stanle / Citibank)
$2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005605
7/19/2016 Gratitude America MMDA ( I
Gratitude America Ltd.
Mor. an Stanle / Citibank)
$500,000 DB-SDNY-0005605
1/20/2017 Gratitude America MMDA I Gratitude America Checkin ( $200,000 DB-SDNY-0006006
3/6/2017 Gratitude America MMDA I Gratitude America Checkin $250,000 DB-SDNY-0006165
6/1/2017 Gratitude America MMDA I Gratitude America Checkin $250,000 DB-SDNY-0006333
6/7/2017 Gratitude America MMDA ( Gratitude America Checking l ) $200 000 DB-SDNY-0006333
10/2/2017 Gratitude America MMDA Cancer Research Wellness Institute $25,000 DB-SDNY-0006658
11/1/2017 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checking $50,000 DB-SDNY-0006739
8 The Gratitude America MMDA was primarily capitalized via a $10 million deposit from BV70 LLC. Bloomberg has reported 
that Leon Black controls BV70 LLC. See
Tom Metcalf, Jeffrey Epstein's Endgame: One Last Shot to Stay in Wall Street's Favor, Bloomberg (August 6, 2019), 
available at:
hops:l/www.bloomberg.comtnewslarticles/2019-08.06/epstein-s-endgame-one-last-shot-to-stay-in-wall-street-s-favor. 
Exhibit E demonstrates how those funds were
spent.
9 Account statements reflect that this payment was made to "First Clearing LLC." However, wire records clarify that the 
payment was intended for the Bruce and
Marsha
Moskowitz Foundation. See DB-SDNY-0000478.
10 Account statements reflect that his payment was made to "Morgan Stanley." However, wire records indicate that the 
payment was intended for an account held by
Gratitude America Ltd. See DB-SDNY-0000478.
11/1/2017
11/13/2017
Gratitude America MMDA ( Gratitude America Checkin : $100,000 DB-SDNY-0006739
Gratitude America MMDA ( Gratitude America Checkin : $100 000 DB-SDNY-0006739
12/6/2017
12/11/2017
Gratitude America MMDA ( Bruce and Marsha Moskowitz Foundation $50,000 DB-SDNY-0006822
Gratitude America MMDA
Gratitude America Ltd
(First Bank of Puerto Rico
$150,000 DB-SDNY-0006822
12/11/2017 Gratitude America Checking Gratitude America MMDA $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0006822
1/30/2018 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checkin $2 000 000 DB-SDNY-0006907
2/28/2018 Gratitude America MMDA Cancer Reasearch Wellness Institute $25,000 DB-SDNY-0006991
4/2/2018 Gratitude America MMDA NPO Baleto Teatras $18,493 DB-SDNY-0007170
9/17/2018 Gratitude America MMDA VSJ Baleto Teatras $10,000 DB-SDNY-0007629
1/10/2019 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checking ( ) $314,876 DB-SDNY-0007994
EFTA00035921 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons Lieutenant's Logs
(date: 2019-08-06)
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER, NEW YORK, NY
DAILY LIEUTENANT'S LOG
Shift -Day-Date: M/W Tuesday, August 06, 2019 Beginning Count: 759 SHU: 78/5
M/W
Daily Sensitive Information:
I/M on Suicide Watch w/inmate companion
I/M awaiting bed space(SHU)
TIME CHRONOLOGICAL EVENTS BC SHU
12:00 AM Lieutenant assumes duties as the Morning Watch 759 78/5
Operations Lieutenant. The fire alarm and sprinkler system are
operational w/exception of Control Center Fire Panel. PREA
announcement conducted via the Institution Public Address System
and/or Radio. Restraint Equipment Cage inventory conducted. All
equipment accounted for. Metal Detector checks conducted. All
operative w/the exception of Rear Gate/Facilities/R&D. Roof
Check completed. All secure. Temporary Chit Inventory: #1:2;
#2:5; 13:5; #4:6; #5:5; #6:0; Hosp:0
12:00
AM
Institution Count in progress
12:00
AM
NYPD Phone Check #1581
12:07
AM
Body Alarm testing in progress
12:14
AM
Body alarm testing completed
12:30
AM
Watch Calls cont.
12:55
AM
Good Verbal count announced
12:58
AM
Clear Institution count announced 759 78/5
3:00 AM Institution Count in progress
3:33 AM Good Verbal count announced
3:35 AM Clear Institution count announced 759 78/5
5:00 AM Institution Count in progress
5:22 AM Good Verbal count announced
5:25 AM Clear Institution count announced 759 78/5
8:00 AM Relieved of duties by Lt. as D/W Operations Lieutenant 759 78/5
STG International Terrorist phone calls monitored:
WITSEC inquiry(s) was/were received during my tour of duty:
The following Inmate(s) were placed in Administrative Detention:
Name Reg: Number Reason Unit Time AD Order
Ops Lt.
Ending Count: 759 SHU: 78; 10-South: 05; SHU OBS: 00;
Local Hosp: 00; H/A OBS: 01; B/A OBS: 00; Dry Cell: 00;
H/A(PBS); 01
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00012423
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER, NEW YORK, NY
DAILY LIEUTENANT'S LOG
SHIFT -DAY -DATE: D/W - Tuesday, August 06, 2019 Beginning Count: 759 SHU:7$/5
i)dtiq Daily Sensitive Information:
I/M on 2" floor pending bed space. w/inmate companion
I/M on 2 nd fl pending bed space. w/inmate companion
8:00 AM Lieutenant assumes duties as the Day Watch Operations
Lieutenant. The fire alarm and pump system is inoperable at this
time. Fire Watch is in Progress. Unable to conduct PREA
announcement over the Institution Public Address System, due to,
system malfunction. Restraint Equipment Cage inventory conducted.
All equipment accounted for. Metal Detector checks conducted.
All operative w/the exception of Rear Gate. Roof Check
completed. All secure. Temporary Chit Inventory: #1:0; #2:5;
#3:5; #4:6; #5:6; #6:5; Hosp:0
Daily Hand Stamp :DJBE/LEFT HAND
759 78/5
8:00 AM NYPD Phone Check #2505
8:20 AM Body Alarm Test Initiated.
8:30 AM AM Census Conducted
8:44 AM Body Alarm Testing Complete.
9:20 AM I/M Ignatov #77737-112 out to Court 758 78/5
10:00 AM I/M removed from Suicide Watch
10:22 AM Triple Deuce Testing begin
11:00 AM 2 I/M Placed in SHU Ramos #85428-054, Hill #79455-054 758 80/5
11:20 AM Triple Deuce Testing Complete
12:30 PM PM Census Conducted 758 80/5
1:30 PM 1 I/M released from SHU Marat #76003-054
1:45 PM -1 I/M from Unit CA out to L-Hosp w/bop staff 758 79/5
3:45 PM Institutional lockdown for count. 757 79/5
4:00 PM Relieved of duties by Lt. E/W Operations Lieutenant. 757 79/5
Visitation:
Inmates Adults Children Total
ION SCANNING TESTED HITS: 0
STG/High Alert phone calls monitored:
WITSEC inquiry(s) was/were received during my tour of duty: 0
The following Inmate(s) were placed in Administrative Detention: 0
Name Reg Number Reason Unit TIME A/D Order
RANDS 85428-054 POSSESSION OF WEAPON GN 11:00 AM YES
HILL 79455-054 POSSESSION OF WEAPON GN 11:00 AM YES
Ops Lt Ending Count:757 ; SHU:79 ; 10-South: 05; SHU OBS: 00;
Local Hosp: 01; H/A OBS: 02; B/A OBS: 00; Dry Cell: 00
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00012424
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER, NEW YORK, NY
DAILY LIEUTENANT'S LOG
Act Lt
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00012425
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER, NEW YORK, NY
DAILY LIEUTENANT'S LOG
SHIFT -DAY -DATE: E/W - Sunday, August 5, 2019 Beginning Count: 756 SHU:78/
5
igitiq Daily Sensitive Information.
I/M on Psych Obs. w/inmate companion
TIME CHRONOLOGICAL EVENTS B/C SHU
4:00 PM
Lieutenant assumes duties as the Evening Watch Operations
Lieutenant. Unable to conduct PREA announcement over the
Institution Public Address System, due to, system malfunction.
Restraint Equipment Cage inventory conducted. All equipment
accounted for. Metal Detector checks conducted. All operative
w/the exception of Rear Gate. Roof Check completed. All secure.
Temporary Chit Inventory: #1:4; #2:4; #3:5; #4:5; #5:5; #6:3;
756 78/5
4:00 PM Institution count in progress.
4:01 PM NYPD Phone Check #3291
4:15 PM Body Alarm testing in progress.
4:52 PM Good verbal announced.
4:53 PM Body alarm testing completed.
4:55 PM Clear institutional count.
6:00 PM Watch call in progress
6:35 PM +1 I/M Baez -Pena #87074-054 new commit to RA. 757 78/5
6:39 PM +1 I/M Townzen #79847-054 new commit to RA. 758 78/5
7:45 PM Trash run in progress
7:46 PM +1 I/M Russo #77749-054 from L Hosp USM to KS. 759 78/5
8:36 PM Trash run complete
10:00
PM
Institutional count in progress.
10:31
PM
Good verbal count announced.
10:39
PM
Clear institutional count announced. 759 78/5
12:00
AM
Relieved of duties by as the M/W Lieutenant.
VISITING:
DOMES ADULTS I CHILDREN
I
TOTAL
STG/High Alert phone calls monitored: 9
WITSEC inquiry(s) was/were received during my tour of duty: 0
The following Inmate(s) were placed in Administrative Detention: 0
NAME REG NUMBER REASON UNIT TIME A/D ORDER
Ops. Lt.
Act. Lt.
Ending Count:759 ; SHU: 78; 10 -South: 05; SHU OBS: 00;
Local Hosp: 00; H/A OBS: 01; B/A OBS: 00; Dry Cell: 00;
B/A SHU: 00
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_00012426
EFTA00080260 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-08-06)
EXHIBIT A: LEON BLACK / ROTHSCHILD GROUP TRANSACTIONS
DUI
10/15/2013
Pk\ I It
Leon and Debra Black
RI ( II'll \ I
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
k MI \ I
$8,500,000
li klES#
DB-SDN Y-0002962
12/18/2013 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003484
4/25/2014 Leon and Debra Black Southern Trust Company, Inc. $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003819
4/25/2014 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003819
4/29/2014 Leon and Debra Black Southern Trust Company, Inc. $15,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003819
7/15/2014 Narrow Holdings LLC do Elysium
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $20,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004009
10/16/2014 Leon and Debra Black Southern Trust Company, Inc. $7 000 000 DB-SDNY-0004172
10/16/2014 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $13,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004172
10/22/2014 Leon and Debra Black do Apollo Management Southern Trust Company, Inc. $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004173
10/22/2014 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004173
10/13/2015 Leon and Debra Black do Apollo Management Southern Trust Company, Inc. $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004990
10/13/2015 Black Family Partners, LP c/o Apollo
Management
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004990
10/14/2015 BV70 LLC Gratitude America, Ltd. $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004999
12/17/2015 Edmond de Rothschild (Suisse) SA Geneva,
Switzerland
Southern Trust Company, Inc. $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005122
12/18/2015 Black Family Partners, LP Southern Trust Company, Inc. $10 000 000 DB-SDNY-0005122
12/21/2015 Benjamin Edmond de Rothschild Southern Trust Company, Inc. $14,999,980 DB-SDNY-0005122
12/30/2015 Leon and Debra Black do Apollo Management Southern Trust Company,Inc. $10 000 000 DB-SDNY-0005123
3/31/2017 BV70 LLC Plan D, LLC $22 500 000 DB-SDNY-0006113
4/17/2017 BV70 LLC Plan D, LLC $8,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006197
4/25/2017 Leon and Debra Black do Apollo Management Southern Trust Company, Inc. $8,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006240
10/2/2018 Plan D, LLC BV 70th LLC' $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007669
I Please note that the account statement for this transaction lists the entity as "BV 70th LLC" instead of "BV70 LLC.
EXHIBIT B: TRANSACTIONS INVOLVING HEDGE / INVESTMENT FUNDS
DATE
5/2/2014
Pk\ rat
Southern Financial LLC
RECIPIFNT
Boothbay Multi Strategy Fund LP
AMOUNT
$10,000,000
B‘I I•L:
DB-SDNY-0003845
5/14/2014 Southern Financial LLC Barack Ferrazzano Kirschbaum and
Nagelberg Client Fund $99999 DB-SDNY-0003846
7/2/2014 Southern Financial LLC Joichi Ito $250,000 DB-SDNY-0003972
8/4/2014 Tudor Futures Fund Southern Financial LLC $12,826,541 DB-SDNY-0004032
8/8/2014 Tudor Futures Fund Southern Financial LLC $677,400 DB-SDNY-0004032
9/9/2014 Southern Financial LLC Joichi Ito3 $500,001 DB-SDNY-0004084
1/21/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $150,000 DB-SDNY-0004346
2/12/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $900,000 DB-SDNY-0004412
3/12/2015 Southern Financial LLC Joichi Ito4 $250,000 DB-SDNY-0004441
3/30/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $2 700 000 DB-SDNY-0004487
4/13/2015 Southern Financial LLC Neoteny 3, LP $1,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004518
6/30/2015 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004675
7/24/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $600,000 DB-SDNY-0004790
7/28/2015 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP $7,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004745
8/5/2015 Joichi Ito Southern Financial LLC $483,915 DB-SDNY-0004815
9/24/2015 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Global Fund II LP $1,950,000 DB-SDNY-0004924
9/28/2015 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP $4,250,000 DB-SDNY-0004881
3/1/2016 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005280
3/31/2016 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LLP $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005281
5/31/2016 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $20,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005457
6/23/2016 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $250,000 DB-SDNY-0005526
8/18/2016 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $1,250,000 DB-SDNY-0005667
12/2/2016 Kyara Investments I Southern Financial LLC $10,000 DB-SDNY-0005882
12/12/2016 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $3,750,000 DB-SDNY-0005932
2 Wire details read: "Southern Financial LLC investment in Kyara Investments LLC." See DB-SDNY-0000478.
3 Wire details read: "subcr to Kyara Investments III, LLC to fund Blocicstream Investment." See DB-SDNY-0000478.
Wire details read: "suber to Kyara Investment IV, LLC to fluid O112 Laboratories." See DB-SDNY-0000478.
1“ II
1/6/2017
P \ l I It
Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies LP
RI ( II'll \I
Southern Financial LLC
kW/I \ I
$10,000,000
li klINg
DB-SDNY-0005951
4/20/2017 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006240
5/5/2017 Southern Financial LLC Coatue Enterprises LLC $500,000 DB-SDNY-0000478
7/10/2017 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Ventures I LP $1,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006407
7/24/2017 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $4,250,000 DB-SDNY-0006407
10/11/2017 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $2 250 000 DB-SDNY-0006652
1/5/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $1 500 000 DB-SDNY-0006901
1/12/2018 Southern Financial LLC Coatue Enterprises LLC $500,000 DB-SDNY-0006847
2/15/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $500,000 DB-SDNY-0006985
2/21/2018 Blockchain Capital IV, LP The 2017 Caterpillar Trust $10,500,000 DB-SDNY-0006982
2/21/2018 Blockchain Capital III Digital Liquid
Venture Fund, LP The 2017 Caterpillar Trust $2,625,000 DB-SDNY-0006982
2/21/2018 Blockchain Capital Parallel Fund IV, LP The 2017 Caterpillar Trust $1,875,000 DB-SDNY-0006982
4/20/2018 Neoteny 3 LP Southern Financial LLC $30,000 DB-SDNY-0007110
6/1/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $1 750 000 DB-SDNY-0007348
6/13/2018 Southern Financial LLC Coatue Enterprises LLC $500,000 DB-SDNY-0007289
6/27/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007348
6/28/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007348
9/5/2018 Kyara Investments I Southern Financial LLC $11,392 DB-SDNY-0007568
9/28/2018 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $8,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007623
11/20/2018 Southern Financial LLC Coatue Enterprises LLC $500,000 DB-SDNY-0007748
1/8/2019 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0007987
3/13/2019 The 2017 Caterpillar Trust Honeycomb Ventures IV LP $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0008151
3/28/2019 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Honeycomb Partners LP $10,000,000 DB-SDNY-0008154
4/17/2019 Southern Trust Company, Inc. Valar Globaal Fund III LP $1,500,000 DB-SDNY-0008222
EXHIBIT C: CAPITALIZATION OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN'S NOW/SUPERNOW ACCOUNTS5
D.0 I. P kl I It RI C( II'll \ I" kNIOI NI ii \IINa
10/11/2013 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0002926
11/13/2013 Barry Jay Josephson $200,000 DB-SDNY-0002992
11/14/2013 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0002994
12/20/2013 Jeepers I DB Br k ra Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003427
1/24/2014 $225,000 DB-SDNY-0003538
1/30/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003538
2/18/2014 Adam RI $7,500 DB-SDNY-0003640
2/20/2014 Jee.ers Inc DB Brokerage Account $4,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003640
3/18/2014 Adam RI $3,500 DB-SDNY-0003709
4/11/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $3,400,000 DB-SDNY-0003769
5/6/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003832
5/16/2014 Island Global Yachtin: LTD $292,655 DB-SDNY-0003833
5/21/2014 Michelle Saipher / Darren Indyke $698,000 DB-SDNY-0003833
5/21/2014 Michelle Saipher / Darren Indyke $525,000 DB-SDNY-0003834
6/11/2014 Jee.ers Inc. DB Brokerage Account $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003896
7/16/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0003960
8/19/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0004022
9/17/2014 Adam Bly $3,000 DB-SDNY-0004074
10/2/2014 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0004126
10/15/2014 Adam Bly $3,000 DB-SDNY-0004127
11/14/2014 Adam Bly $7,500 DB-SDNY-0004183
11/17/2014 Jeffrey E Epstein c/o HBRK Associates (Non-DB Account) $1 928 647 DB-SDNY-0004183
11/21/2014 Adam Bly $100,000 DB-SDNY-0004184
1/5/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0004296
5 According to KYC records, Jeffrey Epstein used the Now/SuperNow accounts (also referred to as "Elite Checking with 
Interest") for his "personal daily use."
See DB-
SDNY-0002607. The attached chart reflects incoming wire transfers from Deutsche Bank brokerage accounts and accounts 
held at third party financial institutions.
The chart
does not capture internal cash transfers between Deutsche Bank deposit accounts.
6 In early 2016, Jeffrey Epstein moved his assets from one Now/SuperNow account to a different Now/SuperNow account. We 
are still unclear as to why this
transition
occurred, but expect electronic communications to provide additional insight. To date, the only functional difference 
between the two accounts that we have
identified is the
account number, which is reflected in the "Recipient" column.
DA 1 E
2r 10;'2015
I' V11 II
Jee.ers Inc. DB Brokera e Account
RI (MI \ 1" k\1O1 \ 1
$2,000,000
Bki i ,, ,t
DB-SDNY-0004359
3/9/2015 Adam BI $10,484 DB-SDNY-0004431
3/13/2015 Jee.ers Inc. DB Brokera.te Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004431
3/27/2015 Jee.ers Inc. DB Brokera.te Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004432
4/16/2015 Jee.ers Inc. 0B Brokera:e Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004509
5/18/2015 Jee.ers Inc. 0B Brokera:e Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004587
6/3/2015 Adam BI $10 484 DB-SDNY-0004665
6/12/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004665
7/6/2015 AIC Title Agency $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004735
7/9/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $3,200,000 DB-SDNY-0004736
8/13/2015 Seed Media Group $170 000 DB-SDNY-0004806
8/20/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004807
10/7/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0004937
10/19/2015 Stone & Magnanini LLP $1 000,000 DB-SDNY-0004937
10/29/2015 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0004938
11/13/2015 Kellerhals Ferguson Kroblin PLLC $23,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005003
1/8/2016 The Haze Trust (DB Brokerage Account) $20,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005135
2/2/2016 Kellerhals Fer!uson Kroblin PLLC $75,000 DB-SDNY-0005201
4/19/2016 Gol Muchnik $500,000 DB-SDNY-0005342
9/9/2016 Jeepers Inc. DB Brokera:e Account $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005683
9/28/2016 Jeffre E.stem on-DB Account $700,000 DB-SDNY-0005684
10/7/2016 Delson International Inc. $50,000 DB-SDNY-0005747
10/26/2016 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005748
10/27/2016 Delson International Inc. $50,574 DB-SDNY-0005749
7/18/2017 Sultan Bin Sulayem $6,200 DB-SDNY-0006349
10/26/2017 Jamie Mitchell $100,000 DB-SDNY-0006594
12/20/2017 NLR Resorts International LLC $50,000 DB-SDNY-0006756
1/16/2018 NLR Resorts International LLC $25,000 DB-SDNY-0006839
1/23/2018 NLR Resorts International LLC $25,000 DB-SDNY-0006839
3/30/2018 David J Mitchell $50,000 DB-SDNY-0007012
9/18/2018 David J Mitchell $50,000 DB-SDNY-0007561
9/28/2018 Jeffrey Epstein (Non-DB Account) $700,000 DB-SDNY-0006510
10/11/2018 David J Mitchell $125,000 DB-SDNY-0007651
10/24/2018 David J Mitchell $10,000 DB-SDNY-0007652
10/25/2018 Link Rockenbach P.A. $3,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007653
11/9/2018 David J Mitchell $80,000 DB-SDNY-0007741
12/13/2018 David J Mitchell $50,000 DB-SDNY-0007834
1/10/2019 David J Mitchell $100,000 DB-SDNY-0007924
1/11/2019 Jeffrey Epstein (Non-DB Account) $100,000 DB-SDNY-0007924
2/7/2019 Jeepers Inc. (DB Brokerage Account) $3,276 640 DB-SDNY-0008016
3/5/2019 David J Mitchell $25,000 DB-SDNY-0008097
3/5/2019 David J Mitchell $14,000 DB-SDNY-0008097
3/5/2019 David J Mitchell $4,000 DB-SDNY-0008097
3/18/2019 David J Mitchell $5,500 DB-SDNY-0008099
4/1/2019 David J Mitchell $3,000 DB-SDNY-0008179
,z(:)) 44 II 111111-111111/'-(1111) 11))
zz.. II 111)11.. Aril $7,800 DB-SDNY-0008181
$2,200 DB-SDNY-0008181
EXHIBIT D: TRANSACTIONS INVOLVING THE HAZE TRUST ACCOU \ I s'
Dk II
3/10/2017
I'.\\ I It
The Haze Trust Brokerag.
RECIPIENT
The Haze Trust Checking
1.\1Ol \ I
$36,000,000
B\IIN#
DB-SDNY-0006153
3/10/2017 The Haze Trust Checking The Haze Trust DBAGNY $35,999,000 DB-SDNY-0006153
3/27/2017 The Haze Trust DBAGNY Plan D, LLC Checking ( $15,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006168
6/19/2017 Christie's Inc. The Haze Trust Checking $7,725,000 DB-SDNY-0006320
9/25/2017 Sotheby's The Haze Trust Checking $11,536,544 DB-SDNY-0006565
9/26/2017 The Haze Trust Checking I The Haze Trust DBAGNY $15,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006565
10/24/2017 Sotheb s The Haze Trust Checkin $11 249 417 DB-SDNY-0006646
10/26/2017 The Haze Trust Checking The Haze Trust DBAGNY $13,000,000 DB-SDNY-0006646
6/22/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGNY Southern Financial LLC Checking $9,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007361
8/20/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGN Southern Financial LLC Checkin $5 000 000 DB-SDNY-0007544
9/17/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGN Southern Financial LLC DBAGN $5 000 000 DB-SDNY-0007635
9/28/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGN Southern Financial LLC Checkin $8 000 000 DB-SDNY-0007635
10/1/2018
10/24/2018
The Haze Trust DBAGN
The Haze Trust DBAGN
Southern Trust Conn an Checkin
Southern Financial LLC Checkin
$10 000,000
$5 000,000
DB-SDNY-0007725
DB-SDNY-0007725
11/20/2018 The Haze Trust Checking Southern Financial LLC Checkin: $2,500,000 DB-SDNY-0007798
12/13/2018 HSBC Bank Bermuda Limited II The Haze Trust Checkin $58,328 DB-SDNY-0007888
12/19/2018 The Haze Trust DBAGNY Southern Financial LLC Checkin: $5 000 000 DB-SDNY-0007908
1/10/2019 The Haze Trust DBAGNY The Haze Trust Checkin $2,727,941 DB-SDNY-0007979
1/10/2019 The Haze Trust Brokera:e I The Haze Trust Checkin $6,000,000 DB-SDNY-0007979
2/7/2019
2/19/2019
The Haze Trust Checkin:
The Haze Trust Brokerage I
Southern Financial LLC Checkin
The Haze Trust Checking
$8 791 283
$12,608,253
DB-SDNY-0008063
DB-SDNY-0008064
2/19/2019 The Haze Trust Brokerage The Haze Trust Checkin: $167,414 DB-SDNY-0008064
2/19/2019 Southern Financial LLC Checkin: The Haze Trust Checking $11,715,364 DB-SDNY-0008063
2/19/2019 Jeffrey Epstein Checkin: The Haze Trust Checking $7,000,000 DB-SDNY-0008063
2/22/2019 The Haze Trust Checkins. Jeffrey Epstein Checking $7,000,000 DB-SDNY-0008063
2/22/2019 The Haze Trust Checkin Southern Financial LLC Checking $24,564,037 DB-SDNY-0008063
7 The below chart reflects the flow of money through two deposit accounts and one brokerage account belonging to "The 
Haze Trust." The Haze Trust Checking
account
was opened with Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas. The Haze Trust DBAGNY account was opened with Deutsche Bank's New 
York branch office. The latter account
offers higher interest rates than the former. We have yet to determine how the Haze Trust Brokerage account was 
initially capitalized.
EXHIBIT E: TRANSACTIONS INVOLVING GRATITUDE AMERICA MONEY MARKET DEPOSIT ACCOUNT ("MMDA") 8
DkII
10/14/2015
I) kl ER
BV70 LLC
RI( II'll \ I .
Gratitude America, LTD
kNIOI \ I
$10 000 000
B \II •N#
DB-SDNY-0004999
1/7/2016 Gratitude America MMDA Bruce and Marsha Moskowitz Foundation $50,000 DB-SDNY-0005198
1/21/2016 Gratitude America MMDA
Gratitude America Ltd
(First Bank of Puerto Rico)
$50,000 DB-SDNY-0005198
1/29/2016 Gratitude America MMDA Melanoma Research Alliance Foundation $225,000 DB-SDNY-0005198
2/3/2016 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checking $150,000 DB-SDNY-0005264
3/2/2016 Gratitude America MMDA
Gratitude America Ltd.
(Morgan Stanley / Citibank 10
$5,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005334
3/8/2016 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checkin $250,000 DB-SDNY-0005334
3/8/2016 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checking $250,000 DB-SDNY-0005334
4/6/2016 Gratitude America MMDA
Gratitude America t
(First Bank of Puerto Rico)
$250,000 DB-SDNY-0005401
7/12/2016 Gratitude America MMDA Bruce and Marsha Moskowitz Foundation $50,000 DB-SDNY-0005605
7/14/2016 Gratitude America MMDA
Gratitude America Ltd.
(Morgan Stanley / Citibank)
$2,000,000 DB-SDNY-0005605
7/19/2016 Gratitude America MMDA
Gratitude America Ltd.
(Morgan Stanley / Citibank
$500,000 DB-SDNY-0005605
1/20/2017 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checkin: $200 000 DB-SDNY-0006006
3/6/2017 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checkin: $250 000 DB-SDNY-0006165
6/1/2017 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checkin: $250 000 DB-SDNY-0006333
6/7/2017 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checkin: $200 000 DB-SDNY-0006333
10/2/2017 Gratitude America MMDA Cancer Research Wellness Institute $25,000 DB-SDNY-0006658
11/1/2017 Gratitude America MMDA Gratitude America Checkin $50,000 DB-SDNY-0006739
8 The Gratitude America MMDA was primarily capitalized via a $10 million deposit from BV70 LLC. Bloomberg has reported 
that Leon Black controls BV70 LLC. See
Tom Metcalf, Jeffrey Epstein's Endgame: One Last Shot to Stay in Wall Street's Favor, Bloomberg (August 6, 2019), 
available at:
hops:l/www.bloomberg.cominews/articles/2019-08.06/epstein-s-endgame-one-last-shot-to-stay-in-wall-street-s-favor. 
Exhibit E demonstrates how those funds were
spent.
9 Account statements reflect that this payment was made to "First Clearing LLC." However, wire records clarify that the 
payment was intended for the Bruce and
Marsha
Moskowitz Foundation. See DB-SDNY•0000478.
10 Account statements reflect that his payment was made to "Morgan Stanley." However, wire records indicate that the 
payment was intended for an account held by
Gratitude America Ltd. See DB-SDNY-0000478.
'
11/1/2017 Gratitude America MMD Gratitude America Checkin: $100 000 DB-SDNY-0006739
11/13/2017 Gratitude America MMD Gratitude America Checkin: $100 000 DB-SDNY-0006739
12/6/2017 Gratitude America MMD Bruce and Marsha Moskowitz Foundation $50,000 DB-SDNY-0006822
Gratitude America Ltd $150,000 DB-SDNY-0006822
12/11/2017 Gratitude America MMD First Bank of Puerto '
12/11/2017 Gratitude America Checkin Gratitude America MMDA $2 500 000 DB-SDNY-0006822
1/30/2018 Gratitude America MMD Gratitude America Checkin $2 000,000 DB-SDNY-0006907
2/28/2018 Gratitude America MMD Cancer Reasearch Wellness Institute $25,000 DB-SDNY-0006991
4/2/2018 Gratitude America MMD NPO Baleto Teatras $18,493 DB-SDNY-0007170
9/17/2018 Gratitude America MMD VSJ Baleto Teat • $10 000 DB-SDNY-0007629
1/10/2019 Gratitude America MMD Gratitude America Checkin: $314 876 DB-SDNY-0007994
EFTA00005971 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-08-07)
1
FBI - Philadela
Name/Squad:
8th Floor
William I Green Jr., FOB
600 Arch Street
Philadelphia, PA 19106-1675
--------------------------------
(215) 418-4000
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY
Cl2-D
TO: =Albany
0 Albuquerque
0 Anchorage
0 Atlanta
0 Baltimore
°Birmingham
(=Boston
(=Buffalo
=Charlotte
=Chicago
o Cincinnati
°Cleveland
=Columbia
Dallas
°Denver
=Detroit
cEl Paso
oFBIHQ
=Honolulu
(=Houston
o Indianapolis
c= Jackson
0 Jacksonville
0 Kansas City
O Knoxville
=Las Vegas
o Little Rock
o Los Angeles
0 Louisville
=Memphis
°Miami
0 Milwaukee
=Minneapolis
°Mobile
°Newark
=New Haven
ONew Orleans
*New York City
=Norfolk
0 Oklahoma City
0 Omaha
Di Philadelphia
o Phoenix
o Pittsburgh
o Portland
0 Richmond
0 Sacramento
0 Saint Louis
(=Salt Lake City
=San Antonio
0 San Diego
°San Francisco
=San Juan
0 Seattle
Springlidd
C3 Tampa
o Washington Field
o Butte OSC I=I Quantico (CIRG)
0 Clarksburg (CHS) 0 Quantico (Training)
°Pocatello (PSCU) 0  Quantico (ERF-OTD)
0 Quantico (Lab)
=Savannah OSC
°Winchester (RMD)
O
o Allentown, RA
0 Ft. Washington, RA
=Harrisburg, RA
°Newtown Square, RA
°Philadelphia Regional
Computer Forensic Lab
(PIIRCFL)
Scranton, RA
0 South Jersey, RA
o State College, RA
al Williamsport, RA
0
=Abu Dhabi
0Abuja
(=Accra
=Addis Ababa
=Amman
°Ankara
oAstana
=Athens
°Baghdad
0Bangkok
=Beijing
=Berlin
OBern
°Bogota
°Brasilia
=Bridgetown
°Brussels
(=Bucharest
0Budapest
(=Buenos Aires
=Cairo
oCanberra
°Copenhagen
Via FBIR0
(=Dakar
=Doha
°Hong Kong
olslamabad
=Jakarta
o Kabul
=Kuala Lumpur
O Kyiv
OLondon
(=Madrid
=Manila
(=Mexico City
°Moscow
°Muscat
(=Nairobi
oNewDelhi
°Ottawa
(=Panama City
=Paris
(=Phnom Penh
(=Prague
°Pretoria
(=Rabat
=Riga
(=Riyadh
ORome
oSan Salvador
(=Sanaa
oSantlago
=Santo Domingo
=Sarajevo
CSeoul
°SIngapore
°Sofia
OTbihsi
°Tel Aviv
°The Hague
(=Tokyo
°Tunis
(=Vienna
° Warsaw
CLASSIFICATION LEVEL
(CHECK ONE)
IDIJNCLASSIFIED, NOT SENSITIVE
°SENSITIVE, BUT UNCLASSIFIED
(=CONFIDENTIAL
=SECRET

• ATTENTION:
ma Atnagnmat rfetam
NLETS RESPONSE
'DR. nominee .
TXT
NAME: 1.;
ADDRESS:
DR LIC NO:S BIRTH DATE: LIC CLASS: D.w.' LICEIJO: "-"'
SOC: PREVIOUS CLASS: "as PRM CLASS:
LIC ISSUE DATE: 20180305 LIC EXPIRATION DATE: 20260305 ORGAN DONOR: YES
EYES: BL HAIR: BR SEX: F RACE: W HEIGHT: S FT 7 IN WEIGHT: 150
NON-CDL STATUS: Valid NON-CDL ELIGIBILITY DATE: 00000000
CDL STATUS: None CDL ELIGIBILITY DATE: 00000000
PERMIT STATUS: None GUN-PERMIT-STATUS: None
CURRENTLY REVOKED IN TN FOR DUI?: NO DUI ON-AFTER 19970101: NO
TOTAL NON-COL RECS: 0 TOTAL CDL RECS: 0
LIC RESTRICTIONS: CORRECTIVE LENSES
PRM ISSUE DATE: 00000000 PRM EXPIRATION DATE: 00000000 PRMEND: "*"
PERMIT RESTRICTIONS: NONE
image
Page 3 of 3
Court Agency
Subject's Name
Charge
Charge Number
Charge Tracking Number
Charge Literal
Charge Description
Counts
Severity
Disposition
TN0190100 METROPOLITAN NASHVILLE PD
************************* INDEX OF AGENCIES
**************************
Agency METROPOLITAN NASHVILLE PD; TN0190100;
Agency METROPOLITAN NASHVILLE PD; TN0190100;
Agency METROPOLITAN NASHVILLE PD; TN0190100;
* * * END OF RECORD * * *
https://www.portalxljnet.pa.gov/portabd/XLMain.aspx?s=S0ZCSTUxMjYyNQ%3d%3d&L.. 8/7/2019
╔═══════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Jennifer Aros [girls] abused by Epstein starting at age 14 [x] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02858481 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Jennifer Aros, Epstein and Trump accuser
(date: 2019-08-07)
FD-302 (Rev. 3-8-I0)
31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
-1 of 10-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Date of Entry:  08/22/2019

<REDACTED> <REDACTED> (PROTECT SOURCE, hereinafter "<REDACTED>"), date of birth
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
advised the <REDACTED> High School yearbooks for <REDACTED> (she was a
freshman) and <REDACTED> (she was a sophomore) would have photographs of <REDACTED> at
approximately 15 and 16 years old, closer to the timeframe of JEFFREY
EPSTEIN's abuse of . Her last name at the time the yearbooks were
published was <REDACTED>. She recalled the <REDACTED> High School mascot
was possibly <REDACTED> and one of their school colors may have been <REDACTED>.
II also provided the interviewing Agents with two photographs (undated) that
include her at approximately 13-16 years old. The first photograph included
two females laying on a bed. II identified herself as the female on the
right (not smiling). II believed this photograph may have been taken prior
to her meeting EPSTEIN. The second photograph shows five individuals
sitting down as a group, with an additional individual sitting approximately
two feet away. All individuals appear to be female. II is the second from
the right (appearing to sit somewhat behind the other girls. She has white
sunglasses on her head.) II advised she recalled this photograph was most
likely taken after she met and was abused by EPSTEIN. She noted the Solo
cups in the photograph and inferred they contained alcohol. II indicated
the party atmosphere would have occurred after she met EPSTEIN.

Investigation on 08/07/2019  at
File # 31E—NY-3027571
United States (In Person)
by SA
Date dialled 08/09/2019

CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 1 of 10

FD-302.8 (Ito. 5-8-10) 31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
31E-NY-3027571
(U//FOUO) (PROTECT SOURCE)
C00088804:0 of FD-102 of Interview #2 .On 08/07/2019 ,p age 2 of 10

At the start of the interview, II advised she now felt comfortable enough
to provide details regarding (sexual and physical) abuse she suffered at the
hands of not only JEFFREY EPSTEIN, but also certain individuals associated
with him. She advised that she met EPSTEIN (referred to as "JEFF" by II)
through fraud and misrepresentation, and that he and others took advantage
of her mother. II stated that EPSTEIN blackmailed her mother through
explicit photographs of II, which resulted in her mother embezzling from her
real estate company to pay him. II stated that her mother, "tried to buy
back the photos and secrets" over the years. A man named JIM ATKINS
(phonetic), a friend/associate of EPSTEIN (background of relationship
unknown), participated with EPSTEIN in blackmailing mother. ATKINS
also sexually assaulted II on more than one occasion. II described ATKINS
as a white male with gray hair, "big ears", and hairy body. ATKINS was
possibly in his 50's in the early 1980s, and lived in Ohio. ATKINS was
somehow associated with an Ohio university (unidentified); he may have been
the Dean, or the "money guy" at the school at the time. ATKINS either owned
or rented a residence on <REDACTED> Island, where he stayed when he came to
the Island. II stated that the home she and her mother lived in on the
Island would not have been nice enough for ATKINS to stay in. II met ATKINS
not long after EPSTEIN began sexually assaulting her. She estimated she met
him when she was approximately 14 or 15 years old, and recalled meeting him
in her mother's office; however, she did not know why he was in her mother's
office initially. II could not recall how her mother and ATKINS were
originally introduced. ATKINS came off as a, "rich prick [who would] throw
his weight around and talk about money. He would expect people to respond
immediately to him. ATKINS was a "pervert" and looked at II like she was a
"piece of meat." He developed a romantic relationship with mother who
he claimed he loved, but mother appeared annoyed with him at times.
They dated for approximately a year and ATKINS would fly on and off the
Island to see her. II looked back on the relationship and thought her
mother and ATKINS may have been "secretly dating" (if he was married in
Ohio). He was rude to II and her brothers, he had a short temper, and he
was a drinker. brother would recognize ATKINS. II recalled
seeing EPSTEIN and ATKINS together at least once at EPSTEIN's house. She
recalled it was most likely at the second house she knew him to live in
while he resided on <REDACTED> Island.

CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 2 of 10

FD-302a (Ito. 54-10) 31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
31E-NY-3027571
(U//FOUO) (PROTECT SOURCE)
Continuahon of FD-30?of Interview #2 . On 08/07/2019 - page 3 of 10

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

ATKINS and his accountant (Black male named "Cecil" Last Name Unknown)
assisted mother in "fixing" her real estate books so that she could
embezzle funds and pay EPSTEIN. At some point, ATKINS and mother had a
falling out, and ATKINS, EPSTEIN and possibly CECIL turned mother's in
to the Real Estate Commission by providing her accurate real estate
book/records. mother was sent to prison for a period of time for
embezzlement, and she was not able to pay the restitution ordered. II was
not aware of the blackmailing when it began to occur. Her mother informed
her late into the process that they were in trouble, that she had seen
photographs of II, and that she was paying people money. II recalled
calling ATKINS at the school where he was employed to ask whether he could
help II and her mother. Prior to II meeting EPSTEIN, her mother had been
sober. II advised that the threat must have been very real because her
mother was a very strong woman and it affected her substantially. After
EPSTEIN blackmailed her, mother began to drink alcohol again.

II continued the chronological discussion of incidents involving EPSTEIN
that II began to detail during the previous interview. With respect to what
II believed to be the fourth incident, the two men involved (in addition to
EPSTEIN), described by II to be "fat" and "disgusting", also "seemed to have
money". II was asked more than once about the contact between herself and
the men and what transpired during that fourth interaction. II did not
recall the men's names. At the time of the interview, II was not

CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 3 of 10
FD-302a(RmS440 31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
31E-NY-3027571
(U/ /MUM (PROTECT SOURCE)
Continue:on of FD-30?of Interview #2 on 08/07/2019 ,page 4 of 10
comfortable going into specifics regarding the sexual abuse the men
subjected her to.
After approximately the fourth interaction with EPSTEIN that summer, a
period of time elapsed (within the same summer) and EPSTEIN began
living/staying at a different residence (location details unknown) . On one
occasion, II an• h r friends were at a •ool on- ni•h •o i•ly at the
Marriott Hotel <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>. She recalled
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
being present. EPSTEIN showed up, alone, at the pool.
believed that when he showed up someone (one of her friends) must have seen
him. II left with EPSTEIN, and he got her to leave without using violence.
They went back to his house (she reiterated it was a different residence
than his previous home). When they arrived, it was the, "same kind of bull
shit". EPSTEIN asked ■ who her friends were, if she told her friends, and
if her friends wanted to "come party". II responded no, she did not tell
her friends and no, they did not want to come party. II stated that EPSTEIN
sent her on what she referred to as "missions" to find, "young girls who
wanted to party."

On approximately the fifth interaction II recalled having with EPSTEIN,
other people were present. II vaguely remembered other girls around and
older men, but she did not recognize anyone. Two of the men were "fat and
disgusting" and had "Santa stomachs"; however, one man was heavier than the
other. With respect to recognizing other individuals from the area, II
stated that Island was small; she knew most girls her age and
the fact she did not recognize any of the girls partying with EPSTEIN and
his friends made her wonder where they came from. There was a beach near
the hotels known by locals and some vacationers to be a place to "party".
When asked about the men present during the fifth interaction, II advised
one of the men (unidentified) physically and verbally abused her. She
remembered he pulled her hair and, "beat the shit out of me." She thought
it was strange that he stomped on her big toe. He hit her with a belt or
similar object. She had, "no idea what that was about." His abusive
actions toward II were not sexual, except he masturbated at certain points
while abusing her. She could not recall having bruises after the man beat
her. II stated, "It was a very long evening that went into morning."
CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 4 of 10
FD-302a (Ito. 5-8-10) 31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
31E-NY-3027571
(U//FOUO) (PROTECT SOURCE)
Continue:on of FD-102 of Interview #2 On 08/07/2019 . page 5 of 10
mother was not concerned that she did not go home that night because it was
normal for her to stay at a friend's home overnight sometimes. At that
point, her mother was not aware of ongoing abuse by EPSTEIN and his
associates.

With respect to bruising incurred from any of the abusive interactions
with EPSTEIN, II stated, "I must have had bruises but I don't remember my
friends saying anything." She did not go to the hospital, and she did not
incur any broken limbs. II thought she may have had a few knots on her head
after interactions with EPSTEIN.

II knows EPSTEIN took photographs of her during sexual activity because
she found images of herself in a drawer during her third interaction with
him (previously documented) and she vaguely recalled EPSTEIN taking the
pictures. EPSTEIN took Polaroid pictures of her; some were of just her
breasts, others depicted only her face, and some showed her whole body.
remembered she was wearing one of EPSTEIN's shirts in at least one
photograph he took. She described the shirt as "very crispy", and possibly
blue or white. II advised a tripod came to mind as well and was possibly
involved at some point. II did not recall any other men taking photographs
of her. • pointed out that just because she could not remember whether
they took photographs did not mean they did not.

II estimated she had more than 6 and less than 20 sexual interactions
with EPSTEIN over time.

EPSTEIN told II on at least one occasion that "dark" was his time (no
further information). II was EPSTEIN's "main contact" on the Island. When
they were with others, EPSTEIN appeared to be the leader, and others
deferred to him. II generally only talked to EPSTEIN, "They abused me, but
I didn't talk to them." II wanted to be in a "good place" with EPSTEIN,
"better to get him people to party with, than to be partied on." At this
point, attorney, <REDACTED> advised, "You felt shame." II
responded, "Yeah." II advised that during several of her interactions with
EPSTEIN she was "drugged", which was "not fine, but better than being sober"
with respect to the sexual abuse she endured by him and his associates. II
remembered that once she began introducing EPSTEIN to girls she met on the
CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 5 of 10

FD-302a (Rev. 5-73-10) 31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
31E-NY-3O27571
(U//FOUO) (PROTECT SOURCE)
Continue:on of FD-102 Interview #2 .on 08/07/2019 ,page 6 of 10

beach, he and II seemed to come to an understanding. The situation, while
still horrible, did not seem as horrible. In EPSTEIN's subsequent
interactions with her she felt like he looked at her as a,"good girl." He
acted as though he thought, "You're my good girl now." II began thinking
she had to, "eat or be eaten."

II could not recall ever seeing another underage girl being abused during
the time she knew EPSTEIN. She vaguely remembered hearing screaming and
crying, but she was segregated and did not hang out with anyone. She
reiterated that she did not talk to the girls or the men who associated with
EPSTEIN. II did not know whether there were "group setting" sex situations
involving the girls. She was not asked or forced to participate in sex with
more than one individual.

On more than one occasion while in EPSTEIN's company, II observed a woman
[around EPSTEIN's age at the time (30's)] present who did not appear to be
Black or Caucasian, but had darker skin and long dark wavy hair. The woman
did not appear to have a lot of money, nor did she appear to be in a
relationship or married to any of EPSTEIN's associates. The woman may have
been with EPSTEIN in some way. The woman never spoke to II and gave off a,
"cold feeling." II was not aware of whether the woman abused any girls;
however, she did not abuse II.

II was "probably given drugs" on almost every interaction she had with
EPSTEIN. She was always given alcohol and marijuana, and usually cocaine.
EPSTEIN's drink of choice was gin and tonic. He enjoyed listening to
Classical music, and he "blared" Neal Diamond.

Not long ago, friend and house mate, <REDACTED> wore two
different colognes in presence that she did not like. One specifically
repulsed her. It "instantly put [her] back there." It was the, "same smell
as JEFFREY [EPSTEIN] ." In the interviewing Agents' presence, II placed a
call to in speakerphone mode. II asked if he remembered
her having a strong (negative) reaction to one of his colognes, and asked if
he could tell her what the name of the cologne was. responded that
he did remember that incident, and that he thought it was possibly "Grey
Flannel" cologne. II did not initially tell <REDACTED> why the cologne
CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 6 of 10
FD-302.8 (Ito. 5-8-10) 31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
31E-NY-3027571
(U//FOUO) (PROTECT SOURCE)
Cominuanon of FD-102 of Interview #2 .On 08/07/2019 ,p age 7 of 10
repulsed her; however, she recently disclosed details of her abuse to
and his wife, as well as why the cologne was relevant.

Investigating Agents inquired as to exposure to recent news media
stories  regarding  EPSTEIN. II advised at some point she "Googled" his name
and " Island" to see whether any victims from the area had come
forward. She thought she found one; however, the result she found was just
a story about EPSTEIN that was previously published in the
Island paper.

II detailed a separate and possibly the sixth incident involving
EPSTEIN. '?hen II was approximately 15 years old, she went to a Rick James
concert with her friend and
Georgia. EPSTEIN was at the concert and surprised her. When II saw EPSTEIN
she knew she had to go with him. She recalled EPSTEIN had a flask and "got
her drunk". She was also high on marijuana. He kept her isolated at the
concert so long that and mother left her, and drove back to
Island. They later told II they looked for her for a long
period of time. She stated that she imagined they were terrified when they
could not find her. II could not recall the entire evening; however, she
knew that EPSTEIN left her at some point, and she found herself walking
around alone, high on marijuana. She kept thinking, "how am I going to get
back to the Island. I've been left here, I have no way to get home." At
some point while was walking around, the police picked her up. II recalled
thinking her mother was going to be "pissed" at her because she got her ears
pierced. The police photographed her and kept her alone in a "real jail"
cell. She could not remember whether they fingerprinted her, or if she was
formally arrested. She did recall she ate really good fried chicken while
in jail. At some point, her mother and brother, , picked her up and
drove her home.
mother in Savannah,

II recalled at least one incident in which EPSTEIN took her off of the
Island when she was between 13 to 15 years old. He drove her and/or flew
her to either New York or New Jersey. She was, "introduced to someone with
money, money... It was Donald Trump." II and EPSTEIN were with others, to
include TRUMP, in a very tall building with huge rooms. TRUMP did not like
II, "from the get-go, he didn't like that I was a boy-girl" (referencing a
CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 7 of 10
FD-302a (Re'. 5-810) 31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
31E-NY-3027571
(U//FOUO) (PROTECT SOURCE)
Cominuahon of FD-102 of Interview #2 .On 08/07/2019 ,p age 8 of 10
tomboy). II could not recall the identities of the other individuals
present; however, they all exited when TRUMP asked everyone to leave the
room. TRUMP mentioned something to the effect of, "Let me teach you how
little girls are supposed to be." TRUMP unzipped his pants and put
head, "down to his penis". II, "bit the shit out of it." TRUMP struck II
and said words to the effect of, "get this little bitch the hell out of
here." II advised she bit TRUMP's penis because he disgusted her. "He had
money, it reeked off of him." At that point, people reentered the room no
further information provided). II recalled a blond beautiful woman
approaching her at some point that day after her interaction with TRUMP.
The woman said, "let me give you a tip little girl about your breasts, wear
a bra every night." Those words have stayed with her throughout the years.

II got the feeling the relationship between EPSTEIN and TRUMP included a
certain amount of jealousy. She thought TRUMP appeared jealous of EPSTEIN,
but at some point, they ended up on level playing fields. TRUMP and EPSTEIN
sometimes used the terms "fresh meat", "untainted" and "not jaded" while
referring to girls. At the time she heard it, II did not understand the
term "not jaded". She subsequently looked up the word "jaded". II stated
she had two additional interactions with TRUMP, but she asked that the
interview move on to a different subject for the time being.
II discussed an additional interaction with EPSTEIN and his associates
wherein EPSTEIN and the "group" brought acid (identities of additional
individuals not provided). EPSTEIN asked II if she knew anything about
acid; she replied that she did not. He asked her to try it first, then tell
her friends where the party was going to be. EPSTEIN gave II some of the
acid to give to her friends. She did not recall hearing about acid on the
Island before EPSTEIN introduced it, but she recalled that after he did,
acid "swept the Island."
Reflecting on the interactions she had with EPSTEIN up to that point, II
advised that while she continued to be sexually abused by him, she began to
feel like EPSTEIN trusted her. The situation was "still horrific", but she
began to feel important; he knew she was keeping his secrets, specifically
the things he said in front of her.
CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 8 of 10
FD-302a Die% . 5-73-10) 31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
31E-NY-3027571
(U/ / FOUO) ( PROTECT SOURCE)
Cominmucm FD-302 Interview #2 .On 08/07/2019 ,page 9 of 10
On one occasion, II asked EPSTEIN, "why he (EPSTEIN) does those things to
me?" EPSTEIN responded by disclosing he had been molested as a child by a
"boy" in his family, and possibly his aunt. II thought the boy was either
an uncle or a cousin; he definitely mentioned abuse by both a male and
female. EPSTEIN was starting to say intimate things about himself. He was
sharing and it began to make her feel like she had some of the power. She
recalled thinking at the time, "Wow, this is the same asshole who is
horrible." EPSTEIN had two sides to his personality. Looking back on the
situation now, II stated EPSTEIN was, "probably grooming me." II, "got
super fascinated" in the sexual acts that involved EPSTEIN being submissive
to II. She felt relieved to be the one not being abused. recalled they
did not "mix" the sexual abuse, meaning the interactions wherein EPSTEIN
physically abused ■ were separate interactions than those that involved
EPSTEIN being submissive to II. Every time they entered a bedroom, sexual
abuse of some sort was involved, and in general, every interaction included
sexual abuse. The one exception was the concert in Georgia (detailed
above). Even though EPSTEIN was alone at the concert, they did not have a
place where he could engage in sexual activity with her.
When asked whether EPSTEIN had any notable sexual fetishes, • advised he
liked having "little rubber things" put into his anus, and, "he had (her] do
it." II recalled inserting a pencil, a big eraser, little rubber things,
and a water bottle tube into EPSTEIN's anus for his sexual gratification.
EPSTEIN liked to be violated and dominated. He wanted her to take control.
She recalled he turned into a different person (personality), and since it
was her first time experiencing that type of sexual behavior, she did not
know what to do. EPSTEIN liked her to use a kitchen oil (instead of sexual
lubricant) when she put things in his "butt". EPSTEIN told II that when he
was younger he could contort his body so that he could almost put his penis
in his mouth. She asked him to show her and he tried, but was unsuccessful.
II was asked whether EPSTEIN ever asked her to engage in "threesomes"
(orgies) . EPSTEIN always wanted to bring her friend; however, it never
happened.
EPSTEIN spoke another language around II once in a while. She believed
the language may have been Hebrew. At this point in the interview, II
CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 9 of 10
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8.-10)
31E—NY-3027571
(U//FOUO)
cominumic, of F.D.302 of Interview 12
31E -NY -3027571 Serial 252
(PROTECT SOURCE)
,on 08/07/2019 Page 10 of 10
imitated the sound of the language she recalled EPSTEIN speaking indicating
it included a throat -clearing guttural sound. She was unaware of whether
EPSTEIN was Jewish. She knew the language he spoke was not Italian.
EPSTEIN talked about blackmailing people in front of U.  U was
confident TRUMP knew EPSTEIN blackmailed people because she heard EPSTEIN
and TRUMP talking about it. II stated she knew TRUMP had illegal building
permits. She heard him (TRUMP) talking about washing money through
casinos. Number 6 is Donald Trump's favorite number. was not sure how
she knew that, but she had heard it at one point. II stated that EPSTEIN's
blackmailing of her mother, "ruined my family".
II asked the Agents to keep her safe stating, "Throughout my life his
(EPSTEIN's) people have found me... have kept tabs on me."
CONFIDENTIAL
3501.045-003
Page 10 of 10
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 The 1953 Trust [epstein] Epstein financial trust, trustees: Darren Indyke, Richard Kahn 
                      Paul Krassner [journalist] 60s counterculture guy, Merry Prankster 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00099303 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein death bequests of The 1953 Trust naming Darren Indyke, Richard Kahn as trustees
(date: 2019-08-08)
THE 1953 TRUST
THIS nusT AGREEMENT is made as of August 8, 2019 ("Agreement"), by and among JEFFREY

E. EPSTEIN, as Grantor (the "Grantor"), and DARREN K. INI3YKI-: and RICHARD D. KAHN, as
Trustees (the "Trustees").
WHEREAS, Grantor, residing at Little St. James Island, St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands established
The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2019 Trust dated January 18, 2019, with Darren K. Indyke, and Richard D.
Kahn, as Trustees; and
WHEREAS, the Grantor retained the power to amend the trust in whole or in part, by a written
instrument executed and acknowledged solely by the Grantor and delivered to no less than one
Trustee of this Trust and exercised such right to amend the trust on February 4, 2019;
NOW THEREFORE, the Grantor has chosen again to exercise the power to amend and restate the
Trust expressly granted to him in Section 1.3 of the Trust to amend and restate the Trust, in its
entirety, as follows:
The Grantor hereby pays over, assigns, grants, conveys, transfers and delivers to the Trustees the
property described in Schedule A annexed hereto and made a pan hereof, to be administered and
disposed of as provided in this Agreement, with any additions, changes, or amendments to this
Agreement.
Further, The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2019 Trust shall henceforth be known as the "The 1953 Trust".
Article I
During My Lifetime
The following provisions shall apply during my lifetime:

Section 1.1. - Disbursement of Income
All of the income derived from the property held in this Trust (the "Trust Estate") shall be paid to me,
or accumulated or paid as I may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1,2. - Disbursement of Principal
The Trustees may distribute any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate to me as I may direct in
writing from time to time.

Section 1.3. - Specific Rights Reserved to Me

A. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to amend this Agreement, in
whole or in part, by a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me and delivered to no
less than one Trustee of this Trust.

B. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, in my sole and unfettered
discretion, to remove any Trustee by delivering to no less than one Trustee of this Trust a written
GJ 00001
instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

C. I reserve the right, at any time, to revoke this Trust in its entirety or, at any time and
from time to time, to revoke any provision hereof by delivering to no less than one Trustee of this
Trust a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

D. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to withdraw or appoint any part
or all of the principal of the Trust Estate by delivering to no less than one Trustee of this Trust a
written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.
E. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to transfer to the Trustees, by
gift, by Will or by beneficiary designation, such additional property, including life insurance policies, as
I may desire. Any such additional property shall be held on the same temis as are then applicable to
the original Trust Estate, except that it may be transferred subject to conditions and provisions of
special application to such additional property.
Article U
After My Death
The following provisions shall apply after my death:

Section 2.1. - Payment of My Debts and of Taxes and Expenses
The Trustees shall pay from the principal of the Trust Estate (a) my debts, funeral and burial expenses
and the administration expenses of my probate estate which are not paid by the Executors of my
probate estate, and (b) the federal, state and territorial estate, inheritance, succession, generation
skipping and similar taxes imposed by reason of my death which are the obligations of the Trustees
(including any of such taxes which the Executors of my probate estate direct the Trustees to pay by
written direction delivered to the Trustees). For purposes of this Section 2.1, the principal of the Trust
Estate shall not include (a) any assets which are not included in my Gross Estate or (b) any assets which
are not subject to, or available to creditors for the payment of, my debts, my funeral and burial
expenses or the administration expenses of my probate estate.

Section 2.2. -Bequests and Devises under My Will and Trust
If my probate estate is insufficient to satisfy all pecuniary bequests (or bequests payable in cash or in
kind in the discretion of the Executors of my probate estate) provided in my Will, the Trustees shall
pay such unpaid bequests from the principal of the Trust Fate. If my Will provided for a specific
bequest or devise of specified assets and such bequest or devise could not be satisfied from my
probate estate because such assets were held by the Trustees at my death, the Trustees shall distribute
such assets to satisfy such bequest or devise.
To the extent the assets of the Trust are insufficient to satisfy all bequests provided for in this
Agreement, I direct the Trustees to first pay all specific bequests in Article II, Sections 2.3(A)(1), (2),
and (3), of this Agreement. To the extent assets are insufficient to pay all of the remaining bequests in
Article II, Section 2.3(A) of this Agreement, then the Trustees shall pay the bequests in the order in
which they are listed in this Trust. To the extent the Trust funds are insufficient to satisfy all of the
bequests listed in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41), the bequests that cannot be satisfied shall be
GJ 00002
deemed to have lapsed.

Section 2.3. Bequests

A. I make the following general bequests:
1. to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives mc, Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000). In
addition to said bequest, as soon as practicable after my death, the Trustees are directed to
purchase an annuity for the benefit of KARYNA SHULIAK from a reputable financial
institution in the amount of Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000), which annuity shall be payable
monthly for the life of KARYNA SHULIAK. Upon the death of KARYNA SHULIAK, the
Trustees shall distribute the remaining principal balance of said annuity, and any income, pro
rata to the beneficiaries listed in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41M in the same percentage that
their initial bequest bears to the total amount of bequests made in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-
It is my intention to fund a separate trust for KARYNA SHULIAK prior to my death. In the
event that a separate trust is created and funded by me for KARYNA SHULIAK then the
amount bequeathed by this section shall be reduced by the amount of principal conveyed by me
to the separate mist.

2. to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, if he survives me, Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000).
3. to RICHARI) I)AVII) KAHN, if he survives me, Twenty Five Million Dollars ($25,000,000).

4. to • ($10,000,000). if she survives me, the amount of Ten Million Dollars
5. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, the amount of Ten Million
Dollars ($10,000,000),. In addition, if she survives me, my 'Trustees are directed to pay an
additional Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to be distributed as per
instructions.

6. to <REDACTED>, if she survives mc, the amount of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).
7. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, the amount of Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).

8. to <REDACTED>, the amount of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).
9. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, the amount of Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).

10. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, the amount of Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000)
11. to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., if he survives me, Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).

12. to BELLA KLEIN, if she survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).
13. to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR., if he survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).

14. to MERWIN DELA CRUZ, if he survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).
15. to VALDSON VIERA CON'IRIN, if he survives mc, Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).

16. to GHISLAINE MAXWFT I,  if she survives me, Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).
17. to ANN RODRIQUEZ, if she survives me, the amount of Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000),.

18. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).
19. to DAVID ROGERS, if he survives me, Four Million Dollars ($4,000,000).

20. to PETER ST. OMER, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
21. to DUPSON DONISSAINT, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).

22. to PIERRE JULES, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
23. to CECILE DE JONGH, if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).

24. to JEANNE BRENNAN WIEBRACHT, if she survives mc, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
25. to JERMAINE RUAN, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).

26. to DAPHNE WALLACE, if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
27. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

28. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).
29. to BRICE GORDON, if he survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

30. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).
31. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).

32. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).
33. to EDWARD ROED LARSEN, if he survives me, Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).

34. to MARTIN NOWACK, if he survives me, Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).
35. to ARLINE M. TOYLO, if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000.00).

36. to CARLUZ N. TOYLO, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000.00).
37. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).

38. to UNA PASCAL, if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
39. to MARK EPSTEIN, if he survives me, the sum of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000),
to be held by him, in trust, for the benefit of his children.

40. to PERRY BARD, if she survives me, the sum of Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000)..
41. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, the sum of Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).

42. to MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if she is then married to DARREN KEITH
INDYKE, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000), which funds shall be distributed and used for
the sole purpose of repaying FT Real Estate, Inc. the funds it previously paid to KCAC, LLC in
connection with a real estate purchase contract between FT Real Estate, Inc., as purchaser, and
KCAC, LLC, as seller, for the purchase of the real property known as and located at 2 Kean
Court in Livingston, New Jersey, and terminating said real estate purchase contract. It is my
express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from
my estate, the Trustees shall treat said $3,000,000 as having been distributed by the Trust to
MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, as the sole member of KCAC, LLC, as then having been
repaid by MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER on behalf of KCAC, LLC to FT Real Estate, Inc. and
as then having been distributed by FT Real Estate, Inc. to the Trust, as the sole shareholder of
FE Real Estate, Inc. It is further my express desire and intention, as the sole shareholder of FT
Real Estate, Inc., that upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate,
FT Real Estate, Inc. be directed to cancel and terminate said real estate purchase contract as
contemplated herein; provided, however, that such distribution shall not be made or deemed to
have been made and such termination shall not occur if the transfer of such real property to FT
Real Estate, Inc. pursuant to such real estate purchase contract has been completed prior to my
death or if prior to my death said real estate purchase contract has been terminated or is
otherwise no longer in effect.

43. to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR., or his heirs, successors and assigns, whether or
not LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR. survives me, all of my interest in the property,
improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the real property located
at, and known and referred to as, 18 Teneyck Avenue, Valley Stream, New York. My interest
consists of 100% of the issued and outstanding Membership Interests in Lyn & Jojo, LLC, a
New York limited liability company which holds legal title to said real property, improvements,
fixtures, permits and other rights, which Membership Interests arc held in the name of Darren

K. Indyke, as nominee for me, and which I direct the Trustees to transfer to LUCIANO A.
FONTANILLA, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns.

44. whether or not survives me, to or
her heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the total outstanding debt, including,
without limitation allprincipal and all accrued and unpaid interest thereon, due from
to FT Real Estate, Inc. to be used sole for the purpose of repaying
said principal and interest in full. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and
the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the full amount of
said outstanding debt, including, without limitation, all principal and accrued and unpaid
interest thereon, as having been distributed by the Trust to , or her
heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to a all such outstan
debt and accrued but unpaid interest, as then having been repaid by
to FT Real Estate, Inc., and then as having been distributed to the Trust as the sole shareholder
of FT Real Estate, Inc.

45. I forgive any loans which I made to the following individuals or entities:
a) LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR.
b)

c) (A/K/A
ac r (A/K/A
e)
f) KARYNA SHULIAK
1)
A/K/A
GJ 00006
n) PAUL KRASSNER
o) DAVID MITCHELL
p) LAWRENCE BRUCE DELSON and
jointly and severally
q) MARK LLOYD
r)
s)
t) NLR VENTURES, LIE
u) SIX DESIGNS, LLC
v) JSC INTERIORS, LLC
46. Upon my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to DARREN KEITH
INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial
obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LIE, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability
company, from DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, MICHEI  I .F FERN SAIPHER, if
she is then married to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation, limited liability
company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by
one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Harlequin
Dane, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be
distributed to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole
purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my
express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from
my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial obligations and liabilities as
having been distributed by the Trust to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors
or assigns, and as then having been repaid by DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs,
successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due to me,
or any corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me
immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from
DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if she is then
married to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation, limited liability company,
limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both
of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Harlequin Dane, LLC, or
its successor entities.
47. Upon my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to RICHARD DAVID KAHN,
or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations and
liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust, or
other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited
GJ 00007
to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company, from RICHARD
DAVID KAHN, his spouse, LISA KAHN, if she is then married to RICHARD DAVID
KAHN, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general
partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior
to my death, including, but not limited to, Coatue Enterprises, LLC, a New York limited
liability company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be distributed to RICHARD
DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to repay
all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my express desire and intention
that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall
treat the total sum of all such financial obligations and liabilities as having been distributed by
the Trust to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having
been repaid by RICHARD DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in
repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from RICHARD DAVID KAHN, his
spouse, LISA KAHN, if she is then married to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, and/or any
corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other
entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but
not limited to, Coatue Enterprises, LLC, or its successor entities.
48. Upon my death, the Trustees arc directed to distribute to LAWRENCE PAUL
VISOSKI, JR, or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial
obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability
company, from LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., his spouse, EILEEN VISOSKI, if she is
then married to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., and/or both of them jointly, and/or any
corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other
entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death. Said funds
shall be distributed to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR, or his heirs, successors or assigns,
for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and
liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the
Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial
obligations and liabilities as having been distributed by the Trust to LAWRENCE PAUL
VISOSKI, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid by
LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR, or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in
repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from LAWRENCE P. VISOSKI, JR,
his spouse, EILEEN VISOSKI, and/or both of them jointly, and/or any corporation, limited
liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially
owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death.

49. U onm des the Trustees are directed to distribute to each of
, BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ,
DAVID ROGERS, and MERWIN DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or assigns,
an amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due
from her or him to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity
beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to,
GJ 00008
Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company, and FT Real Estate
Inc. a U.S. V Islands co oration. Said funds shall be distributed to each of
, BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ,
DAVID ROGERS, and MERWIN DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or assigns,
for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and
liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the
Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial
obli a tions and liabilities as ha vin been distributed by the Trust to each of
, BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ,
DAVID ROGERS, and MERWIN DELA CRU or her or his heirs successors or ass'
and as then having been repaid by each of
BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ, DAVID ROGERS, and MERWIN
DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such
liabilities and obligations due from her or him to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC and FT Real Estate, Inc

50. It is my express desire and intention that all amounts due and owing to me by
the persons listed in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(45) of this Agreement shall be cancelled upon
my death. While at the date of execution of this Amendment, the cancellation of said loans will
not result in taxable income to any such persons, in the event any changes are made to the
applicable tax law, the Trustees are directed to take any and all steps necessary to ensure that
the cancellation of such indebtedness does not result in any negative tax consequences to such
persons. In that regard, as necessary, all such amounts due and owing to me by the persons
enumerated in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(45) of this Agreement may be deemed to have been
distributed by the Trust to such persons and repaid by such persons to the Trust It is also my
express desire and intention that all financial obligations and liabilities enumerated in Article
II, Sections 2.3(A)(42), (43), (44), (46), (47), (48), and (49) of this Agreement shall be deemed
to be terminated upon my death, and that such termination shall not result in taxable income
to any of the Beneficiaries enumerated in such Sections, and the Trustees are directed to take
any and all steps necessary to ensure that the termination of such obligations and liabilities
does not result in any negative tax consequences to such Beneficiaries. In the event that the
termination of any obligation does result in tax consequences to the Beneficiaries enumerated
in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(42), (43), (44), (46), (47), (48), and (49), the Trustees are hereby
directed to distribute an amount necessary to satisfy said tax consequences to each Beneficiary
to the extent necessary.

51. If and at such time or times as the Trustees shall determine in their sole and
absolute discretion that it would be beneficial for the protection of the exclusive and
unimpeded tight to the use and enjoyment by KARYNA SHULIAK of the outright
distribution which pursuant to the provisions of Section 2.3(A)(1) then notwithstanding the
provision of this Agreement directing the Trustees to make such distribution directly to
KARYNA SHULIAK, the Trustees shall be authorized to make such distribution in Trust for
the benefit of KARYNA SHULIAK payable for her lifetime. Upon her death, the remaining
income and principal shall be distributed pro rata to the beneficiaries listed in Article II,

Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41) in an amount equal to the percentage which their individual bequest
bears to the total amount of bequests in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41).

52. The Trustees shall retain the sum of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000) for as
GJ 00009
long as they shall determine in their discretion is necessary or appropriate to enable them to
defend against and, in their discretion, settle any and all claims made regarding the validity of
this Trust and any of its provisions or any accompanying Will executed by me. The Trustees
shall have complete discretion to determine if, when, for how much and upon what other
terms to settle each and any such claims, and shall have the right to pay each and all such
settlements out of said Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000) so retained. If and at such time or
times, if any, as the Trustees shall determine in their discretion that it is no longer necessary or
appropriate to retain all or any portion of said Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000) so retained,
the amount the Trustees determine no longer necessary or appropriate to be retained shall be
distributed as provided in Section 2.4 of this Article II.

53. The Trustees shall retain the sum of Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000) for as
long as they shall determine in their discretion is necessary or appropriate to enable them to
defend against and, in their discretion, settle any and all claims to any and all assets of my
estate asserted by any persons against my estate, the Trustees or this Trust. The Trustees shall
have complete discretion to determine if, when, for how much and upon what other terms to
settle each and any such claims, and shall have the right to pay each and all such settlements
out of said Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000) so retained. If and at such time or times, if any,
as the Trustees shall determine in their discretion that it is no longer necessary or appropriate
to retain all or any portion of said Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000) so retained, the amount
the Trustees determine no longer necessary or appropriate to be retained shall be distributed as
provided in Section 2.4 of this Article II.

(B) I make the following specific bequests:
1. I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, the following:

(a) all of my interest in the property, leases, rights, permits, improvements and fixtures
comprising and pertaining to Zorro Ranch, located at 49 Zorro Ranch Road,
Stanley, New Mexico. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of
Cypress, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which holds legal title to
the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "New Mexico Property".
In addition, I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all Household
Goods (as defined in Section 2.3(B)(4) of this Article II) associated with the use,
recreational use, maintenance or repair of the New Mexico Property.

(b) all of my interest in the property, rights, permits, improvements and fixtures
comprising and pertaining to the island known as Little St. James, located in the
U.S. Virgin Islands. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of
Nautilus, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which holds legal tide to
the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "LSJ Property". In addition,
I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all Household Goods associated
with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair of the LSJ Property.

(c) all of my interest in the property, rights, permits, improvements and fixtures
comprising and pertaining to the island known as Great St James, located in the
U.S. Virgin Islands. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of
GJ 00010
Poplar, Inc. a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which holds all of the
membership interests of Great St. Jim, LLC, a United States Virgin Islands limited
liability company, which holds legal title to said property, rights, permits,
improvements and fixtures comprising and pertaining to the said island known as
Great St. James. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "GSJ Property". In
addition, I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all Household Goods
associated with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair of the GSJ Property.
(c1) all of my interest in all apartments, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights
of and pertaining to the premises located in the building known and referred to as
22 Avenue Foch, 75016, Paris, France. The interest consists of units 47 with
mezzanine, 48 and 81 on the 2nd floor, units 63 and 74 on the 5th floor and units 5
and 22 (cellars) in the basement. The units are currently all owned by SCI JEP, a
French company of which I own 999 of the 1,000 outstanding shares. Such interest
is hereinafter referred to as the "Paris Property". In addition, I give to KARYNA
SHULIAK, if she survives me, all Household Goods associated with the use,
recreational use, maintenance or repair of the Paris Property.

(e) all of my interest in the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights
of and pertaining to the real property located at, and known and referred to as, 358
El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of
common stock of laurel, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which
holds legal tide to the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "Florida
Property". In addition, I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all
Household Goods associated with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair
of the Florida Property.
(0 all of my interest in the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights
of and pertaining to the real property located at, and known and referred to as, 9
East 71" Street, New York, New York. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of
common stock of Maple, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which
holds legal tide to the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "New
York Property". In addition, I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all
Household Goods associated with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair
of the New York Property.

2. I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, in a separate mist, the provisions of
which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement, the sum of Five Million
Dollars ($5,000,000) for each property that KARYNA SHULIAK takes title to, to pay for the
operating expenses of the properties. Operating expenses shall include, but not be limited to,
property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities, general maintenance and repairs and common
charges.

3. If KARYNA SHULIAK does not survive me, or if KARYNA SHULIAK advises at least
one of the Trustees in writing that she has renounces her right to take or otherwise disclaims
her interest in any of the properties listed in Section 2.3(B)(1) then those ro erties that are
renounced or disclaimed by KARYNA SHULIAK shall pass to , if
GJ 00011
she survives me. In addition, in the event that property passes from KARYNA SHULIAK to
pursuant to the terms of this Agreement, I also give to
in a separate trust, the provisions of which are set forth in Article III,

Section 3.1 of this Agreement, the sum of Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) for each property
that she takes tide to, to pay for the operating expenses of the properties. Operating expenses
shall include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities, general
maintenance and repairs and common charges.

3. In the event renounces her right or refuses to take any of the
properties listed in Section 2.3(B)(1) or otherwise disclaims her interest, the properties shall be
disposed of in accordance with the provisions of Article II, Section 2.6 and all proceeds shall be
distributed to KARYNA SHULIAK.  In the event KARYNA SHULIAK declines the proceeds
of the sales, or has predeceased then the Trustees are directed to
distribute the sales proceeds pro rata to the Beneficiaries listed in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-

(41) in the same percentage that their initial bequest bears to the total amount of bequests made
in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41).
4. For purposes of this Agreement, "Household Goods associated with the use, recreational
use, maintenance or repair" of any of the New Mexico Property, the Florida Property, the GSJ
Property, the LSJ Property, the Paris Property or the New York Property shall mean all tangible
personal property which in the discretion of the Trustees is determined to be necessary or
appropriate in connection with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair of the New
Mexico Property, the Florida Property, the GSJ Property, the LSJ Property, the Paris Property
or the New York Property, as the case may be, including without limitation, household
appliances, household furniture, household furnishings, window treatments, linens, carpets,
household electronic equipment, recreational equipment, dishes, utensils, cutlery, cooking
equipment, cleaning equipment, tools and other items, materials and equipment associated with
such use, recreational use, maintenance or repair, and also including any and all livestock, and
materials, tools, equipment and vehicles associated with such livestock, and any and all
mechanical equipment, construction equipment, vehicles and watercraft determined by the
Trustees in their discretion to be necessary or appropriate for such use, recreational use,
maintenance or repair. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Household Goods shall not include any
of items of tangible personal property which the Trustees in their discretion determine to be my
personal possessions, even if located at any of the New Mexico Property, the Florida Property,
the GSJ Property, the LSJ Property, the Paris Property or the New York Property, including
without limitation, clothing, jewelry, watches, gemstones, artwork, sculpture, antiques, coins,
currency, or other items of personal property determined by the Trustees in their discretion to
be personal effeus of mine ("Personal Possessions"). For the sake of further clarification, no
assets constituting securities, accounts, equity investments, debt investments, financial
instruments, or other financial assets or investment assets of any kind shall be included in the
definitions of Household Goods or Personal Possessions under this Agreement In addition,
the Trustees shall have the sole discretion to determine whether or not an item of tangible
personal property shall be deemeds be within the definition of Household Goods or Personal
Possessions under this Agreemenerett iutcl an t "ir timit uksol t sL "54295setre eac' S Ele
c.-crosaituaatm arAVattha. Nip% Weir WIZZOWLS t4or ccr4amAtigna),
V I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, my diamond ring, set with a rectangular-cut diamond, a r
weighing approximately 32.73 carats, flanked by baguette-cut diamonds mounted in platinum, jar
cc/ Safi/404012 lbari
which rectangular-cut diamond is described in GIA Certificate Number 11197600 dated July
12, 2000, which accompanies the said diamond ring, as D Color and VSI clarity. If KARYNA
SHULIAK does not survive me, the diamond ring shall be sold and the proceeds distributed
as provided in Section 2.4 of this Article R., ' cts: 41" zwrscuric t l..95,M IThist  tozoe""erp -
ABED ea mu WI 0/41104PLIIIICU aspobsee, 1N The evalt Tire Meccas, IS Plot nti 'ft. I give eo KARYNA SHULIAK all of my 
loose diamonds, including but not limited
to,
48 separate loose diamonds, identified by accompanying GIA Certificate Numbers 11143371,
12813480, 12811989, 12813533, 12813246, 12813303, 11143338, 12813451, 12811971,
11143872, 12813183, 11143179, 12813216, 12813010, 12813292, 12813247, 11382484,
12813201, 12813180, 11383591, 12811956, 12813254, 11143341, 11143180, 11143350,
11383569, 11383584, 12263407, 10421632, 10768120, 12813255, 10177902, 12378695,
13100048, 13096420, 11383481, 12811577, 10429438, 12811796, 11383663, 11137800,
12263667, 12811562, 11137812, 12811824, 12811822, 11383651, 12811792. If KARYNA
SHULIAK does not survive me, the loose diamonds shall be sold and the proceeds distributed
as provided in Section 2.4 of this Article II.

7. All of my remaining Personal Possessions, which for the sake of clarity excludes
all Household Goods associated with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair of any of
the New Mexico Property, the Florida Property, the GSJ Property, the LSJ Property, the Paris
Property or the New York Property, shall be sold by the Trustees, whether at auction or
otherwise and the proceeds shall be added to the residuary of the Trust and disposed of as
provided in Section 2.4 of this Article II.

Section 2.4. Residuary of Trust Estate
The residuary of the Trust Estate, after the distributions provided in Article II, Sections 2.1, 2.2 and
2.3 of this Agreement, shall be distributed to those persons named in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41)
pro ram in an amount equal to the percentage their individual bequest bears to the total amount of
bequests in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4) — (41).

Section 2.5. — Condition Anplicable to Certain Bequests
A. Except as expressly provided herein, no bequest to any Beneficiary of this
Agreement who, during my lifetime, was employed by or provided services to me or any entity that
was owned directly or indirectly by me during my lifetime or I RK Associates, Inc. or any entity
owned by Darren K. Indyke, shall be distributed to said Beneficiary prior to the expiration of two
years following the date of my death. Any Beneficiary of this Agreement who, during my lifetime, was
employed by or provided services to me or any entity that was owned directly or indirectly by me
during my lifetime or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K. Indyke, and who,
after my death, shall voluntarily discontinue, or as a result of said Beneficiary's misconduct, cause to
be terminated, said Beneficiary's employment with or provision of services to my estate or any entity
or parcel of real property directly or indirectly owned by me during my lifetime or HBRK Associates,
Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K. Indyke, prior to the expiration of two years following the date
of my death, shall be ineligible to receive any bequest hereunder; provided, however, that in the event
that prior to the expiration of two years following the date of my death, there is a cessation in the
specific operations of my estate or said real property or entity or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity
owned by Darren K. Indyke, in respect of which said Beneficiary is employed or provides services,
GJ 00013
and prior to that cessation, said Beneficiary had not voluntarily discontinued, or as a result of said
Beneficiary's misconduct, caused to be terminated, said Beneficiary's employment with or provision of
services to my estate or said real property or entity or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by
Darren K Indyke, then the Trustees shall distribute the bequest hereunder to said Beneficiary within
sixty days following the date of such cessation or as soon as is reasonably practicable thereafter.

B. In order to provide for the continued and uninterrupted maintenance and
operation of the assets in my Trust Estate following my death, the Trustees shall ensure that all
persons who were employed by, or provided services to, me or any entity directly or indirectly owned
by me or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K. Indyke, shall continue to be so
employed or to so provide such services for a period of two (2) years following the date of my death;
provided, however, that the Trustees shall have the right terminate the employment or the
engagement of any such employees or service providers if and at such times as the Trustees determine
in their discretion that there is cause for such termination. For purposes of this Section 2.5 of this
Article II, cause for such termination shall include, without limitation, physical or mental incapacity,
intentional misconduct, insubordination, breach of duty, disloyalty, dishonesty, fraud, embezzlement,
theft, abusive or inappropriate workplace behavior, substance abuse, criminal misconduct (whether or
not pertaining to the assets in the Trust Estate), decrease or cessation of the need for employment or
services, or any other circumstances canting the Trustees to determine in their discretion that there is
cause for such termination. The obligation of the Trustees to ensure such continued employment or
provision of services shall include, without limitation, payment out of the assets of the Trust Estate
for the costs and expenses of all items of compensation, remuneration and benefits as shall then be in
effect at the then current rates and in the then current amounts immediately prior to my death.

C. The provisions of this Section 2.5 of this Article II shall not apply to the
Trustees so long as they continue to serve as the Trustees hereunder.

D. The provisions of this Section 2.5 of this Article II shall not apply to the
provisions of Article II, Sections 2.3(A)(42), (43), (44), (46), (47), (48), and (49), of this Agreement.

Section 2.6. — Trust Property that Is Real Property
An trust roc that is real property, that is renounced or disclaimed by KARYNA SHULIAK and
including, but not limited to, improvements, fixtures, permits and other
rights of and pertaining to such real property, held directly by me, or indirectly through ownership of
shares of capital stock of a corporation or membership interests in a limited liability company of which
I was the sole beneficial owner prior to my death, shall be sold by the Trustees and the proceeds
thereof held in said trust as soon as is reasonably practicable following my death. In marketing and
effectuating the sale of said real property, the Trustees shall be guided as nearly as the Trustees
determine in their discretion is possible or appropriate under the then prevailing circumstances by my
last express wishes with respect to the sale of said real property, as shall be contained in the last writing
signed by me and notarized and delivered to at least one of the Trustees prior to my death. The
proceeds of said sales shall be distributed in accordance with the provisions of Section 2.4.
GJ 00014
Article III
Trust for Operating Expense
3.1 Trust for Operating Expenses

A. All sums directed to be held in trust for KARYNA SHULIAK in accordance with the provisions
of this Section 3.1 of this Article III shall be administered as follows:

1. DARREN IC INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees of
the trust administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.1(A) of this
Article III.

2. Unless and until such trust terminates as provided in Article III, Section
3.1(A)(5) of this Agreement, the Trustees may, in their discretion, apply at any time
and from time to time any part or all of the income of such trust and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of such trust to the payment of any and all operating
expenses for the properties.

3. For purposes of this Section 3.1(A) of this Article III, "operating expenses"
shall include, but not be limited to, all expenses that the Trustees, in their discretion,
determine are required or appropriate in order to pay property insurance, real estate
taxes, utilities and general maintenance and repairs for the said properties.

4. For the sake of clarity, the Trustees shall not be required to pay from the
income or principal of such trust any operating expenses for any property that is not
personally used and occupied by KARYNA SHULIAK or that is sold by KARYNA
SHULIAK

5. After the death of KARYNA SHULIA1C, no further payments shall be made
from the income or principal of such trust other than for operating expenses that
accrued prior to the date of such event, and the Trustees shall distribute all remaining
principal and income then remaining in such trust pursuant to the provisions of
Article II, Section 2.4 of this Agreement.

B. All sums directed to be held in trust for in accordance with the
provisions of this Section 3.1 of this Article III shall be administered as follows:

1. DARREN K INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees of
the trust administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.1(B) of this
Article

2. Unless and until such trust terminates as provided in Section Article III,
3.1(8)(5) of this Agreement, the Trustees may, in their discretion, apply at any time
and from time to time any part or all of the income of such trust and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of such trust to the payment of any and all operating
expenses for any or all of the properties.
GJ 00015

3. For purposes of this Section 3.1(B) of this Article III, "operating expenses"
shall include, but not be limited to, all expenses that the Trustees, in their discretion,
determine are required or appropriate in order to pay property insurance, real estate
taxes, utilities and general maintenance and repairs for the said properties.

4. For the sake of clarity, the Trustees shall not be required to pay from the
income or principal of such trust an o >eratin ea enses for an property that is not
personally used and occupied by or that is sold by
•

5. After the death of the trust for her benefit under
the provisions of this Section 3.1(B) of this Article III shall terminate, no further
payments shall be made from the income or principal of such trust other than for
operating expenses that accrued prior to the date of such event, and the Trustees
shall distribute all remaining principal and income then remaining in such trust
pursuant to the provisions of Article II, Section 2.4 of this Agreement.
Article IV
Trust Administration

Section 4.1. - Exercise of Discretionary Powers
Except as hereinbefore specifically provided, in connection with the exercise of a discretionary power
to distribute income or principal to any person, there shall be no requirement to take into account
such person's other income or capital resources, the interest of such person in any other fund or the
duty of anyone to support such person, although these factors may be taken into account.

Section 4.2. - Discretionary Distributions
Any discretionary payment from any trust hereunder shall be charged against such trust as a whole,
and shall not be charged against the individual share of any person at any time.

Section 4.3. - Allocation of Assets

A. For each distribution, partial distribution, allocation, or division of assets into
shares or 111.1stS involving a fraction, the Trustees shall apply such fraction to the fair market value of
the relevant assets on the date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurs. The
Trustees shall appropriately adjust such fractions to reflect the effect of any partial distributions,
allocations, or divisions, taking into account the fair market value as of the date of distribution,
allocation, or division, whichever first occurred, of the assets so distributed, allocated, or divided.

B. The Trustees shall value any assets distributed, allocated, or divided to satisfy
cm whole or in part) a pecuniary distribution at the fair market value of such assets on the date of such
distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurs.
GJ 00016

Section 4.4. - Accounting Allocations

A. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement and except as
provided in Paragraph B of this Section 4.4, the Trustees shall allocate receipts and disbursements in
accordance with sound trust accounting principles and have discretion to allocate receipts and
disbursements when, in the judgment of the Trustees, the treatment is uncertain under applicable laws
or generally accepted accounting principles.
B. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, the Trustees
shall not treat any part of the principal amount of the proceeds of sale of any asset of any trust as
income distributable to or for the benefit of any beneficiary entitled to distributions of income;
provided, however, that the Trustees shall treat a portion of any proceeds of sale of any financial
instrument originally issued or acquired at a discount equal to the amount which (1) has previously
been characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes or (2) will be characterized as ordinary
income for income tax purposes in the year of such sale, as income for trust accounting purposes.

Section 4.5. - Spendthrift Provision
During the term of any trust hereunder, no money or other assets (either principal or income) payable
or distributable under the provisions of this Agreement shall be pledged, assigned, transferred, given,
conveyed, hypothecated, sold, anticipated, charged, or encumbered by any of the Beneficiaries
hereunder, nor shall the income and principal of any trust, while in the possession of the Trustees, be
liable for any debts, contracts, obligations, or undertakings of such Beneficiaries, voluntary or
involuntary, or for any riaitos or judgments against any Beneficiary, including claims for alimony or
for the support of any Beneficiary's spouse or children, or for reimbursement of a federal, state or
local government, or any agency of any federal, state, or local government, for the support of any
Beneficiary hereunder, prior to the time such money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such
Beneficiary. Any attempted pledge, assignment, transfer, gift, conveyance, hypothecation, anticipation,
charge, or encumbrance of any money or assets (either income or principal) payable or distributable
under the provisions of this Agreement by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder prior to the time such
money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary shall be null and void and shall not
be recognized by the Trustees. This Section 4.5 of this Article V shall not apply to me.

Section 4.6. - Limitation on Distributions
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, no discretionary distribution of income or
principal of any trust hereunder shall be applied to pay for medical care, residential facilities, or any
other care or service that would otherwise be provided for any Beneficiary hereunder by any federal,
state, or other governmental agency; and no such discretionary distribution of income or principal
shall be made for reimbursement for any such care, facilities or services previously provided. Before
making any discretionary payment to or for the benefit of any such Beneficiary hereunder, the
Trustees shall consider the amounts such Beneficiary is or may be entitled to receive from any
governmental agency for such care, facilities, or services. If such amounts are available, discretionary
distributions of income and principal from any trust hereunder shall be made only to supplement such
amounts, and to provide liberally for needs and comforts over and above the basic maintenance,
support, and medical care that may be paid for by any such agency.
GJ 00017

Section 4.7. - Division and Combination of Trusts

A. For any administrative, tax or other purpose determined by the Trustees to be
in the best interests of any Beneficiary (including any remainderman) hereunder, the Trustees may at
any time and from time to time (whether before or after funding), without approval of any court,
divide any trust under this Agreement into two or more separate trusts or combine two or more mists
with substantially identical terms (whether or not such trusts resulted from division of a prior trust).

B. If property is directed to be added to any trust hereunder (the "Original
Trust"), whether by the terms of this Agreement any other agreement, or the Will of any person, the
Trustees may hold such property as one or more separate trusts on terms identical to the terms of the
Original Trust The Trustees may allocate such property among the separate trusts (if any) into which
the Original Trust was divided, whether or not pro-rata, using specific assets or undivided interests
therein (Including allocation of all such property to one of such separate trusts).
C. Any time during the existence of separate trusts created by division of a trust
hereunder, the Trustees may exercise all discretionary powers differently with respect to the separate
trusts and take all other actions consistent with such mists being separate entities. Furthermore, the
holder of any power of appointment with respect to such separate mists may exercise such power
differently with respect to each such trust.

Section 4.8. - Consolidation of Trusts
If at any time after my death there is in existence a mist under my Will or any trust agreement created
by me having identical beneficiaries and substantially the same terms as any trust under this
Agreement, the Trustees may terminate the mist hereunder and transfer the assets thereof to the
Trustees of such other mist, to be administered by the Trustees thereof. Different termination dates
under the applicable Rule Against Perpetuities shall not be deemed a difference in the terms of such
trusts, but the portion of the mist representing the transferred assets shall retain the same termination
date as the original trust.

Section 4.9. -Termination of Trusts
Notwithstanding anything herein, any trust created hereunder for any person shall (unless terminated
earlier) terminate upon the day preceding the expiration of the maximum period permitted under the
United States Virgin Islands Rule Against Perpetuities, for the vesting of an interest in a mist and
upon such date the assets of such trust shall be distributed to such person.

Section 4.10,  - Equitable Adjustment
If any of the Trustees decides to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this
Agreement or by law (including, without limitation, any election available to any Trustee) and the
exercise or nonexercise of such power confers a benefit on one Beneficiary or class of Beneficiaries
hereunder and imposes a detriment upon another Beneficiary or class of Beneficiaries hereunder, the
Trustees shall not attempt to restore the interests of the Beneficiaries or classes of Beneficiaries to the
position otherwise contemplated by this Agreement through adjustment between income and
principal or otherwise.
GJ 00018

Section 4.11. - Lapsed Distribution
Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, a provision for distribution to an
individual who is not surviving at the date such individual otherwise becomes eligible for such
distribution shall lapse notwithstanding any law to the contrary.

Section 4.12. - Notice
Any notice required hereunder shall be delivered personally or sent by first class or certified mail
addressed to the last known address of the intended recipient.

Section 4.13. - Termination of Trust
An instrument in writing completely revoking this Agreement shall, without more, upon delivery
to any of the Trustees, completely terminate all of the Trustees' right, title, and interest to any life
insurance proceeds, death benefits, pension, profit sharing, or other retirement benefits or any
other assets otherwise payable to the Trustees.
Article V
Powers of Trustees

Section 5.1. - Exercise of judgment and Powers
The Trustees of each trust hereunder have the entire care and custody of all assets of such trust.
The Trustees have the power to do everything the Trustees in good faith deem advisable without
necessity of any judicial authorization or approval, even though but for this power it would not
be authorized or appropriate for fiduciaries under any statutory or other rule of law. The Trustees
shall exercise the Trustees' best judgment and discretion for what the Trustees believe to be in the
best interests of such trust and the Beneficiaries of such trust. If two Trustees are empowered to
participate in a decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement
or by law, such decision must be made unanimously by the Trustees. If more than two Trustees
are empowered as the Trustee to participate in the decision to exercise or not exercise any
fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, a majority of such Trustees shall be
empowered to make such decision.

Section 5.2. - Compensation of the Trustees
Each Trustee acting hereunder (without regard to the number of separate trusts for which such
Trustee is so actin& shall be entitled to annual compensation for services performed hereunder in
the amount of Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) per year, in addition to any
bequest to which they may be entitled under this terms of this Agreement. No other
compensation shall be payable to the Trustees hereunder, provided, however, that the Trustees
shall be reimbursed for all reasonable costs, expenses, charges, and liabilities incurred or paid in
connection with acting as Trustee or performing services hereunder, including, but not limited to,
fees and expenses of counsel or any other agents hired by the Trustees, and the Trustees shall not
be liable therefor individually. The Trustees have discretion to pay such compensation and such
reimbursements from trust assets, without obtaining judicial authorization or approval.
GJ 00019

Section 5.3. - General Investment Powers

A. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, the Trustees have the
power with respect to each and every trust created hereunder

1. To enter upon and take possession of the assets of such trust and collect
the income and profits from such assets, and to invest and reinvest such assets in real,
personal, or mixed assets (including the common trust funds of a corporate fiduciary) or
in undivided interests therein without being limited by any present or future investment
laws;

2. To retain all or any part of the assets of such mist (without regard to the
proportion that any one asset or class of assets may bear to the whole) in the form in
which such assets were received or acquired by the Trustees;

3. To sell or dispose of, exchange, transfer, invest, or loan all or any part of the
assets of such trust which the Trustees hold, at any time, for such sums or upon such terms as
to payment, security, or otherwise as the Trustees determine, either by public or private
transactions;

4. To buy and sell options, warrants, puts, calls or other rights to purchase or sell
(collectively called "options') relating to any security or securities, regardless of whether such
security or securities are then held by the Trustees, and whether such options are purchased or
sold on a national securities exchange, and to exercise with respect to such options all powers
which an individual owner thereof could exercise, including, without limitation, the right to
allow the same to expire;
5. With respect to oil, natural gas, minerals, and all other natural resources and
rights to and interests therein (together with all equipment pertaining thereto) including,
without limiting the generality of the foregoing, oil and gas royalties, leases, or other oil and
gas interests of any character, whether owned in fee, as lessee, lessor, licensee, concessionaire
or otherwise, or alone or jointly with others as partner, joint tenant, or joint venturer in any
other noncorporate manner, (a) to make oil, gas and mineral leases or subleases; (b) to pay
delay rentals, lease bonuses, royalties, overriding royalties, taxes, assessments, and all other
charges; (c) to sell, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge or otherwise hypothecate any or all of
such rights and interests; (d) to surrender or abandon, with or without consideration, any or all
of such rights and interests; (e) to make farm-out, pooling, and unitization agreements; (0 to
make reservations or impose conditions on the transfer of any such rights or interests; (g) to
employ the most advantageous business form in which properly to exploit such rights and
interests, whether as corporations, partnerships, limited partnerships, mining partnerships,
joint ventures, co- tenancies, or otherwise exploit any and all such rights and interests; (h) to
produce, process, sell or exchange all products recovered through the exploitation of such
rights and interests, and to enter into contracts and agreements for or in respect of the
installation or operation of absorption, reprocessing or other processing plants; (i) to carry any
or all such interests in the name or names of a nominee or nominees; G) to delegate, to the
extent permitted by law, any or all of the powers set forth herein to the operator of such
property; and (k) to employ personnel, rent office space, buy or lease office equipment,
GJ 00020
contract and pay for geological surveys and studies, procure appraisals, and generally to
conduct and engage in any and all activities incident to the foregoing powers, with full power
to borrow and pledge in order to finance such activities; together with the power to allocate
between principal and income any net proceeds received as consideration, whether as royalties
or otherwise, for the permanent severance from lands of oil, natural gas, minerals, and all
other natural resources;

6. To hold all or any part of the assets of such trust in cash or in bank accounts
without the necessity of investing the same;

7. To improve, repair, partition, plat, or subdivide all or any part of the assets
of such mist;
8. To litigate, defend, compromise, settle, abandon, or submit to mediation or
arbitration on such terms and conditions as the Trustees determine any claims in favor of or
against such trust or the assets of such trust;

9. To loan or borrow money in such amounts and upon such terms and conditions as the
Trustees determine, assume such obligations or give such guarantees as the Trustees
determine, for the purpose of the acquisition, improvement, protection, retention, or
preservation of the assets of such trust, or for the benefit of any of the Beneficiaries who are
entitled or permitted to receive income from such trust;

10. To create or invest in any entity with all or part of the assets of such trust and
to carry on for as long and in such manner as the Trustees determine any business enterprise
held or created by the Trustees or in which I owned any interest at my death, either
individually or as a partner, joint venturer, stockholder, trust beneficiary, or member; to sell
such business enterprise as an ongoing business; to consolidate, merge, encumber, dissolve,
liquidate or undertake any other extraordinary corporate transaction relating to such business
enterprise;

11. To vote in person or by proxy any and all stock or securities and to become a
party to any voting trusts, reorganization, consolidation, or other capital or debt readjustment
of any corporation, association, partnership, limited liability partnership, limited liability
company, or individual with respect to stocks, securities, or debts held by such trust;

12. Except as provided in Sections 5.3(B), (C), and (D) of this Article V, to enter
into any good faith transactions with the Trustees individually or with any corporation,
partnership, limited liability partnership, limited liability company, or other entity in which any
of the Trustees has an ownership interest;

13. To purchase from my estate any stocks, bonds, securities, real or personal
property, or other assets, or make loans to my estate even though the same person or persons
occupy the office of the Trustee and the office of the Executor of my estate;

14. To lease, mortgage, pledge, grant a security interest in, or otherwise encumber
all or any part of the assets of such trust for any term of years whether or not beyond the tenn
of such trust (including, without limitation, any such action for the benefit of any of the
Beneficiaries of such trust);
GJ 00021

15. To abandon any property of such trust, real or personal, which the Trustees
may deem worthless or not of sufficient value to warrant keeping or protecting; to abstain
from the payment of taxes, water rents or assessments and to forego making repairs,
maintaining or keeping up any such property; and to permit such property to be lost by tax
sale or other proceedings or to convey any such property for a nominal consideration or
without consideration so as to prevent the imposition of any liability by reason of the
continued ownership thereof;

16. To elect the mode of distribution of the proceeds from any profit-sharing
plan, pension plan, employee benefit plan, individual retirement plan, insurance contract, or
annuity contract pursuant to the terms of such plan or to change to another custodian of
such plan;

17. To conduct any audit, assessment, or investigation with respect to any
asset of such mist regarding compliance with any law or regulation having as its object
protection of public health, natural resources, or the environment (referred to as
"Environmental Laws'); to pay from the assets of such trust to remedy any failure to
comply with any Environmental Law (even to the exhaustion of all of the assets of such
trust); and, as may be required in the Trustees' judgment by any Environmental Law, to
notify any governmental authority of any past, present, or future non-compliance with any
Environmental Law; and

18. To refuse to accept any asset distributable to such trust
B. No Trustee shall directly or indirectly buy or sell any property for the
trust from or to himself, or from or to his relative, employer, employee, partner or other
business associate.
C.
of another trust.
No Trustee shall as trustee of one trust sell property to himself as trustee

D. No Trustee shall lend mist funds to himself, or to his relative, employer,
employee, partner, or other business associate.

Section 5.4. - Administrative Powers
Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, the Trustees have the power with respect to
each trust

A. To employ agents, attorneys -at-law, consultants, investment advisers (to
whom the Trustees have discretion to delegate the Trustees' investment authority and
responsibility), other trustees and other fiduciaries in the administration of the Trustees' duties,
to delegate to such persons, or to one or more of the Trustees, the custody, control, or
management of any part of the assets of such trust as the Trustees determine and to pay for
such services from the assets of such trust, without obtaining judicial authorization orapprovab
GJ 00022

B. To delegate, in whole or in part, to any person or persons the authority
and power to (1) sign checks, drafts or orders for the payment or withdrawal of hinds, securities
and other assets from any bank, brokerage, custody or other account in which funds, securities
or other assets of such mist shall be deposited, (2) endorse for sale, transfer or delivery, or sell,
transfer or deliver, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any and all property, stocks, stock warrants,
stock rights, options, bonds or other securities whatsoever, (3) gain access to any safe deposit
box or boxes in which assets of such trust may be located or which may be in the name of any
of the Trustees and remove part or all of the contents of any such safe deposit box or boxes and
release and surrender the same, and (4) take any other action that the Trustees may have the
power to take with respect to such trust and the property thereof; no person or corporation
acting in reliance on any such delegation shall be charged with notice of any revocation or
change of such delegation unless such person or corporation receives actual notice thereof;

C. To pay any property distributable to a Beneficiary under a legal disability
or who has not attained the age of 21, without liability to the Trustees, by paying such property

(1) to such Beneficiary, (2) for the use of such Beneficiary, (3) to a legal representative of such
Beneficiary appointed by a court or if none, to a relative for the use of such Beneficiary, or (4)
to a custodian for such Beneficiary designated by the Trustees, to hold until age 21 or such
earlier age as shall be the maximum permitted under applicable law;

D. To divide such mist into subsidiary accounts if the Trustees determine
that such division is necessary to maintain fair and accurate records;

E. To permit the Beneficiary of such trust to use, possess, and enjoy real
property, tangible personal property, or dub memberships held by such trust,

F. To distribute to such trust or any of the Beneficiaries of such trust in kind
or in cash, or partly in kind and partly in cash, and to allocate different kinds or disproportionate
shares of assets or undivided interests in assets among all of such trusts or all of such
Beneficiaries;

G. In making the division into one or more trusts hereunder (if such trusts
have the same Trustees), to keep the assets of such trusts invested and handled as a single fund
without actual division and to designate such trusts on the Trustees' books as owning a
designated undivided interest in such fund;

H. To have evidence of ownership of any security maintained in the records
of a Federal Reserve Bank under the Federal Reserve Book Entry System; to deposit funds in
any bank or trust company; to carry in the name of any of the Trustees or the nominee or
nominees of the Trustees and with or without designation of fiduciary capacity, or to hold in
bearer form, securities or other property requiring or permitting of registration; and to cause any
securities to be held by a depository corporation of which a Trustee is a member or by an agent
under a safekeeping contract; provided, however, that the books and records of the Trustees
shall at all times show that such investments are part of such trust;

I. To register or not register such trust with the probate division of the
Superior Court of the United States Virgin Islands or otherwise and to make all decisions which
GJ 00023
relate thereto;

J. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, to give any
Beneficiary of any trust hereunder a general power of appointment exercisable in such
Beneficiary's Will over all or part of such trust, subject to any terms and conditions as the
Trustees determine, by written notice to such Beneficiary; to eliminate any such power of
appointment by written notice to the Beneficiary; and to irrevocably release the power under this
paragraph to give a power of appointment or to eliminate a power of appointment,

K. To renounce and disclaim, in whole or in part, and in accordance with
applicable law, any assets, interests, rights, or powers (including any power of appointment)
which are payable to (or exercisable by) such mist or over which the Trustees have any right,
tide, interest, or power; and

L. To make, execute, and deliver any and all such instruments in writing as
shall be necessary or proper to carry out any power, right, duty, or obligation of the Trustees or
any disposition whatsoever of such trust or any asset of such trust and to exercise any and all
other powers incidental or necessary to catty out or to fulfill the terms, provisions and purposes
of such trust.

Section 5.5. - Restrictions on Exercise of The Trustee's Powers

A. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, a
Trustee shall not participate in a discretionary decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power to (1) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder to himself or herself; or

(2) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder for the health, support,
maintenance or education of a Beneficiary if such Trustee has a legal obligation to provide for
the health, support, maintenance or education of such Beneficiary from such Trustee's personal
assets. For purposes of this paragraph, a person whose interest in a trust hereunder is limited to
a remote contingent interest (for example, a contingent remainderman whose interest depends
upon another person failing to survive to a specified age or a person designated to receive assets
only in the event a power of appointment is not exercised) shall not be treated as a person who
is or may be a Beneficiary of such mist.

B. A Trustee of any trust hereunder may by a written notice delivered to the
other Trustee (or Trustees) of such trust decline to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or bylaw.
C. If a Trustee of any trust hereunder is not empowered (because of a
conflict of interest, declination to act or otherwise) to participate in the decision to exercise or
not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, then the remaining
Trustee or Trustees of such trust shall be empowered to make such decision. If no Trustee or
successor Trustee is empowered to participate in such decision, the Trustees may designate a
substitute Trustee to serve as Trustee of such trust who shall be empowered to make such
decision but has no other power or authority of the Trustees. Such designation shall be by
written notice delivered to such substitute Trustee.
GJ 00024
Article VI
Provisions Concerning Trustees

Section 6.1. - Successor Trustees
In the event a Trustee of the Trust resigns, is removed, becomes incapacitated or is unwilling or
is unable to serve, a successor Trustee shall be appointed to fill the vacancy thereby created, such
that the total number of Trustees acting on behalf of the Trust at all times shall be two. BORIS
NIKOLIC shall be appointed to fill any such vacancy, and if he is unwilling or unable to serve,
BARNABY MARSH shall be appointed to fill any such vacancy. If BARNABY MARSH is
unwilling or unable to serve, then ANTHONY BARRETT shall be appointed to fill such
vacancy. If ANTHONY BARRETT is unwilling or unable to serve, then KATHY REUMMLER
shall be appointed to fill such vacancy. If KATHY REUMMLER is unwilling or unable to serve,
then DAVID MITCHELL, shall be appointed to fill such vacancy. If DAVID MITCHELL is
unwilling or unable to serve, then STEVE HANSON shall be appointed to fill such vacancy. If
STEVE HANSON is unwilling or unable to serve, then EVA DUBIN shall be appointed to fill
such vacancy and thereafter the successor Trustee appointed to fill any such vacancy shall be
appointed by the Trustees then acting, or, if as a result of said vacancy, only one Trustee is then
acting, by the sole remaining Trustee then acting.

Section 6.2. - Apnointment of Trustee
The appointment of a successor Trustee hereunder shall become effective when such successor
Trustee signs an acceptance of the trust.

Section 6.3. - Resignation of Trustees
Any Trustee may resign at any time, without the approval of any court, by an instrument in writing
filed with the trust records. In addition, if there is filed with the trust records a written certification
from any attending physician of any individual Trustee of a trust that he or she is no longer able to
make decisions with respect to such trust, then from the date of filing of such certification, such
individual Trustee shall be deemed to have resigned for all purposes of this Agreement.

Section 6.4. - Vacancy in Office
If there is a vacancy in the Trustees and no successor Trustee is designated pursuant to Section 7.1
who is willing to act, the legally competent adult Beneficiary (or a majority in beneficial interest of the
legally competent adult Beneficiaries if there are multiple Beneficiaries) then entitled or permitted to
receive income from such trust shall designate a successor Trustee by an instrument in writing
delivered to the designated Trustee. If the legally competent adult Beneficiaries do not designate a
successor Trustee within sixty days after receipt of notice of such vacancy or if there is no legally
competent adult Beneficiary of such trust, then a successor Trustee shall be named by order of a court
of competent jurisdiction. All of the fees and expenses of the Trustees (Including attorneys' fees)
attributable to the appointment of a successor Trustee of a trust shall be paid from the assets of such
trust.

Section 6.5. - Elimination of Bond
GJ 00025
No bond or other security shall be required Many Trustee hereunder in any jurisdiction.

Section 6.6. - Exculpation and Indemnification of the Trustees
No one serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be accountable or responsible
to any person interested in any trust hereunder for the manner in which the Trustees shall in good
faith exercise any discretionary authority or any power of the Trustees. No one serving as the Trustee
of any trust under this Agreement shall be liable for any loss or depreciation in value occasioned by
reason of any negligence, error or mistake of judgment in entering into any transaction, in making any
sale or investment, in continuing to hold any property, or by reason of any action or omission,
whether by the Trustees or any other fiduciary, unless such Trustee has acted in bad faith. In the
absence of proof by affirmative evidence to the contrary, each Trustee shall be deemed to have acted
within the scope of the Trustees' authority, to have exercised reasonable care, diligence, and prudence
and to have acted impartially as to all interested persons. A Trustee shall not be liable for the acts or
defaults of another Trustee.
In the event a legal action is brought against any individual serving as the Trustee of any trust under
this Agreement, all legal fees and related expenses inclined in connection with the defense of such
legal action shall be paid by such trust without court authorization; provided, however, that (a) no
such payment shall (or shall continue to) be made if a court enters an order prohibiting such payment,
and (b) such Trustee shall refund to the trust any such payments that previously had been made if a
court enters an order directing that such payments be refunded, or if a court concludes that such
Trustee acted in bad faith.

Section 6.7. - Relief from Virgin Islands Statutory Provisions
Pursuant to Section 1212, Tide 15, of the Virgin Islands Code, I hereby relieve the Trustees and any
successor Trustees of the requirements imposed by Chapter 59, Title 15 of the Virgin Islands Code, or
any similar successor law respecting public filings of inventories and accountings by Trustees.
Furthermore, pursuant to Section 1107, Tide 15, of the Virgin Islands Code, I hereby relieve the
Trustees and any successor Trustees, to the extent allowable, from any and all duties, restrictions, and
liabilities which would otherwise be imposed upon the Trustees by Chapter 57, Title 15, Virgin Islands
Code. This Section 7.7 of this Article VII shall not be deemed a waiver of any and all other rights,
powers, or restrictions otherwise granted to the Trustees in this Agreement.
Article VII
Miscellaneous Provisions

Section 7.1. - Representation of Person Under a Disability
To the extent allowed by law, where a party to any proceeding with respect to any trust hereunder has
the same interest as a person under a disability, legal process shall not be required on the person under
a disability.

Section 7.2. Simultaneous Deaths
If a Beneficiary under this Agreement and I die simultaneously or under such circumstances that it is
difficult to determine who died first, then for all purposes of this Agreement such Beneficiary shall be
deemed to have predeceased me.
GJ 00026

Section 7.3. - Law Governing
This Agreement and each trust created by it shall in all respects and for all purposes be governed and
regulated by the laws of the Territory of the United States Virgin Islands, as they now exist and may
from time to time be enacted, amended, or repealed. All questions regarding the validity, construction
and administration of this Agreement, or any of its provisions, and of any trust created by it shall be
determined solely by the laws of that Tenitory. The courts of the State of Delaware and the U.S.
Virgin Islands shall have primary supervision over the administration of each trust created by this
Agreement. It is intended that each such trust shall be a U.S. domestic trust as defined in Tide 26
section 7701(2)(30) of the Code by virtue of meeting the court and control test As provided in
Treas. Reg. section 301.7701-7(c)(4)(D), if both a United States court and a foreign court are able to
exercise primary supervision over the administration of the trust, the trust meets the court test.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, the Trustees of each trust created under
this Agreement have discretion at any time or times following my death to transfer the sites of such
trust to such other country, or such other jurisdiction as the Trustees determine, without obtaining
judicial authorization or approval (unless such judicial authorization or approval is required by
applicable law) and without the filing of any bond. The Trustees' determination to transfer the sinus of
any mist under this Agreement shall be evidenced by an instrument in writing signed, witnessed and
acknowledged by the Trustees in the same manner as would be required for a deed. The Trustees arc
authorized to take whatever actions arc necessary to effect such a transfer of sinus. If judicial
authorization or approval is required to effect such a transfer of sinus, I intend and desire that the
appropriate court accept the determination of the Trustees concerning the transfer of the sinus of such
trust even if one or more Beneficiaries disagree with such determination. From and after the Trustees'
transfer of the sims of a trust pursuant to this Section 7.3 of this Article VII the administration of
such trust shall be governed by the law of the new sims of such trust

Section 7.4. - Definition of Terms
Except as otherwise specifically provided herein, as used in this Agreement,

A. The term "Trustee" means all persons or entities who occupy the office of
Trustee of any trust hereunder while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more
persons or entities occupy the office of Trustee at the same time or times, and includes any successor
Trustee or Trustees. The term "Executor" of a person's estate means all persons or entities who
occupy the office of personal representative, administrator, executor, or ancillary administrator while
such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more persons or entities occupy such
office at the same time or times, and includes any successor or successors to that office. A reference to
a person's Will means such person's Last Will and Testament and any Codicil or Codicils thereto.

B. A reference to any tax also includes any interest or penalties thereon. The
term "my Gross Estate" means my gross estate as finally determined for purposes of computing my
federal estate tax.
C. Whenever the singular number  is used, the same shall include the plural, and
the masculine gender shall include the feminine and neuter genders.
GJ 00027

Section 7.5. - No Contest
If any Beneficiary under this Agreement shall in any way directly or indirectly (a) contest or object to
the probate of my Will or to the validity of any disposition or provision of my Will or of this
Agreement or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or indirectly instrumental in the
institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest, objection or claim for the purpose of
setting aside or invalidating my Will or this Agreement or any disposition therein or herein or
provision thereof or hereof, then I direct that (aa) any and all provisions in this Agreement for such
Beneficiary and his issue in any degree shall be null and void and (bb) my estate whether passing under
my Will or this Agreement or pursuant to the laws of intestacy shall be disposed of as if such
Beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all failed to survive me.

Section 7.6. -Trustee Notice
The Trustees may have duties and responsibilities in addition to those described in this Agreement.
If the Trustees have questions, the Trustees should obtain legal advice.
CONCLUSION
Whereas I have duly executed this Agreement on the date set opposite my signature.
Jeffrec E. ein
Witnesses:
ell
buallogn -7;44.1
STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
residing at
residing at
)ss:
August 8, 2019
Subscribed and sworn to before me by JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, the Grantor, who is personally known to me-se
whe-has-predneerl----as-idcatifiestiorc and byr4a1ve— ca -al , a witness who is personally
known to me ce-wherhas-produced as identification, and Coo uniccus.teht_.i  a
witness who is personally known to me or .1“,  as identification, on August 8, 2019.
Sworn to before me this 8th day of August, 2019.
qadevvt. Notary Public
MARIAN* A. MELENDSZ
NoNey Punk, State of Nov Yea

No. COM:86371741
Quelefied to New *York County
Coonruanco Lewes Meat Sea 20 a
GJ 00028
\kJ Darren K. Indyke Trustee
STATE OF FLORIDA
)ss:
COUNTY OF PALM )
BEACH
August 1$, 2019
residing at
residing at
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this 15Lth day of August, 2019, by
DARRF.N K. INDYKE, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this   day of
August, 2019.
Notary Public
29 GJ 00029
Richard D. Kahn, Trustee
STATE OF NEW YORK )
)ss:
COUNTY OF -NEW-)
x URK Qate ti t
nA ft•
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this  ow  day of August, 2019, by
AICHARD KAHN, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
August)'° ,2019
residing at
residing at
Sworn to before me this
clo day of August, 2019.
Nota ublic
ANDRES ,1 MUNOZ
Notary Public - State of New York

NO. 01MU6349473
Oualif NO In Owens County
My Commission Expires Oct 17. 2020
GJ 00030
STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
GRANTOR'S AFFIDAVIT
,
We, Jeffrey E. Epstein tAA.Ile_1 Cok6v, t-tvr O  and  Stilnore -i Ter 11
the Grantor and the witnesses respectively, whose names are signed to the attached instrument in those
capacities, personally appearing before the undersigned authority and first being duly sworn, do hereby
declare to the undersigned authority under penalty of perjury that the Grantor declared, signed, and
executed the instrument as his trust agreement including the handwritten changes made on pages
se, 12- 4 13 • he signed it willingly; he executed it as his free and
voluntary act for the purposes therein expressed; and each of the witnesses, at the request of the
Grantor, in his or her hearing and presence, and in the presence of each other, signed the Trust
Agreement as witness and that to the best of his or her knowledge, the Grantor was at that time
eighteen (18) years of age or older, of sound mind and under no constraint or undue influence.
resiidin¢ at
residing at
)ss:
Subscribed and sworn to before me by JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, the Grantor, who is personally known to me or
who has produced as identification, and by a witness who is personally
known to me or who has produced as identification, and a
witness who is personally known to me or who has produced as identification, on August 8, 2019.
Sworn to before me this 8th day of August, 201.
44441 U 'Afted- , b—
Notary Public
MARIANAA MEM0&
N—., Pa Sts. cOin Yak
NAMMUMM41
Cmileml Ns/ Yak Comm
Canaria Ilapire IONE MA 20 ata
GJ 00031
SCHEDULE A
Description of Trust Property
$100.00
G.1_00032
EFTA00109163 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons Metropolitan Correctional Center forms showing Konstantin Ignatov
(date: 2019-08-08)
‘14/
NYMDK 530.03 * BUREAU OF PRISONS COUNT SHEET 08-08-2019
PAGE 001 NEW YORK MCC 16:42:21
QTRG EQ **** OCTG EQ ****
OUTCOUNT SECTION
T N N N S
T J Y Y
COUNT Y E S
AREA CENSUS
A F F F F H M R S TR V
O S & A N I
S D N W S
P I D I
V T
OC
UO
TU
N VERIFY COUNT
T COUNT COUNT AREA
______________________________________________________________________________
26 B-A
.0)‹.( 10 C-A
2 83 E-N
5 75 E-S
1   77 G-N
1 79 G-S
4 H-A
1 85 I-N
88 K-N
. 13 124 K-S
01(  0 R-A
2 73 Z-A
5 Z-B
. 26 729
B-A 26
C-A 10
E-N 85
E-S 80
G-N 78
G-S 80 1
H-A 4
I-N 86 1
K-N 89
K-S 137
R-A 0
Z-A 75 1 1
Z-B 5
TOTAL 755 3 1
COUNT
VERIFY
r
Unit:
Count:
Print Na,, e.
Signature:
Pri nt Nn e:
Signature:
kintrrthc,14a n
Ont-rnnt-irin Onn terNietr0-
Official Count Slip
bate:
1
2 11
6 14 2
OFFICIAL PREPARING COUNT:
OFFICIAL TAKING COUNT:
COUNT CLEARED TIME:11 1.G' PI4
c( er Lc 14111

╭───────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ─────────────────────╮
│ 0 0                                                       │
│                                                           │
│ NYMDK 530.03 * BUREAU OF PRISONS COUNT SHEET * 08-08-2019 │
│ PAGE 001 * NEW YORK MCC * 16:42:21                        │
│ QTRG EQ **** ocTG EQ ****                                 │
│ OUTCOUNT SECTION                                          │
│ A F F F F HM R S TRV O                                    │
│ T N NN S 0 S & A N I UO                                   │
│ To Ye Y S D N Ws TU                                       │
│ COUNT Y ES P I D I N VERIFY COUNT                         │
│ ARE ; T COUNT COUNT AF                                    │
│                                                           │
│ 26 B-A                                                    │
│                                                           │
│ 10 C-A                                                    │
│                                                           │
│ 83 E-N                                                    │
│                                                           │
│ Q                                                         │
│ 1                                                         │
│ na                                                        │
│ o                                                         │
│ °                                                         │
│ An                                                        │
│                                                           │
│ 85 I-N                                                    │
│                                                           │
│ 88 K-N                                                    │
│                                                           │
│ 124 K-S                                                   │
│                                                           │
│ .)                                                        │
│ a                                                         │
│ r                                                         │
│ rv                                                        │
│ i)                                                        │
│                                                           │
│ }                                                         │
│ 1                                                         │
│                                                           │
│ J                                                         │
│                                                           │
│ uo                                                        │
│                                                           │
│ gS                                                        │
│ es                                                        │
│ x                                                         │
│ x                                                         │
│ 4 a 4 H-A                                                 │
│ .                                                         │
│ 2 XS                                                      │
│ eS                                                        │
│ x                                                         │
│ oS                                                        │
│                                                           │
│ OFFICIAL TAKING coo                                       │
│                                                           │
│ COUNT CLEARED TIME: Y!Yf Par                              │
│                                                           │
│ yood verbel YY) pm                                        │
│                                                           │
│ Pes §                                                     │
│ | Count: te                                               │
│                                                           │
│ Prine n                                                   │
│                                                           │
│ 4me;                                                      │
│ |                                                         │
│                                                           │
│ | Signature,                                              │
│                                                           │
│ 'SNature.                                                 │
│                                                           │
│ ~<—=                                                      │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip Unit:
Unit: Date:
Count:
Count: Time: Print Name: _
Print Name: Signature: _
Signature: Print Name
SignaturePrint Name:
Signature:
Nmal••••
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Unit:   Date:
Count: ertl i    Time:
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature:
gin
Unit:
Count:
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Date:  4797 117
Time:  err.) 1)
Metropolitan Correctional Cetiter
New York, New York
Official Count Slip
if: j IV)t
nit:
-
17 / —
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature:
Date:
Time:
•
Metropolitan Correctional Center
New York, New York
Official Count Slip
Unit:
Count:
1. Print Name:
1. Signature:
2. Print Name:
2. Signature:
Date:
Time:
Unit:  f
Count:  I if
Print Name: .
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature:
Unit:
Count:
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:.
Signature:
Unit:
Count:
Print Na
Signature
Print Na
Signature
Date ELT
Time:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Date:
Time:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Date: 8E3 Joe IA
Time: 14 ). 4_: te) .
Count:  n
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature
Unit:
Count:
Print Name: _
I Signature.
Print Name
Signature
Date
t _
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Unit. Date
lime:  \31e411 %
Metropolitan Corre ional Center
Official Count Slip
t:
unt:
t Name:
gnature•
tint Name:
ure:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Date:
Time:
Date:
Time:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Da
•.q COp( A unt:
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature
Unit:
Count:
Official Count Slip
Metropolitan Correctional Center Official Count Slip
Print Name: _
Signature: _
Print Name: . _
Signature:
Date: Eri-friq
■unitl—vmk<pi
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Unit:
Official Count Slip
15N Date:
Count: Tim
Print Name:
Signature:'
Print Name:
Signature:
lea
Unit:
Count:
Print Name:
Signature: •
Print Name:
Signature:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Date: 8

╭─────────────────────────────── Page 2, Image 1 ───────────────────────────────╮
│ Metropolitan Correctional Center                                              │
│                                                                               │
│ Z |                                                                           │
│ Official Count Slip y                                                         │
│ “wy                                                                           │
│ Unit Date: _O74= é |                                                          │
│ Count Time “ee                                                                │
│ Print Name _ |                                                                │
│ Metropolitan Correctional Center T Center Metropolitan Correctional Center    │
│ Official Count Sti Official Count Slip ae Official Count Sli                  │
│ Unit Date it 2 Date 7 Unit                                                    │
│ Unit a aa Ol                                                                  │
│ Coun Time: _ CP'Q2 peg Time: Cee vo Count: KS Tim x                           │
│ Count                                                                         │
│ Print Nan                                                                     │
│ Signature |] Signature                                                        │
│ Signature                                                                     │
│ Print Nan                                                                     │
│ Signature                                                                     │
│ Metropolitan Correctional Center — _                                          │
│ le al Center                                                                  │
│ Metropolitan Correetional Center Oficial Count Slip __ Metropaiin o coant Sp  │
│ Official Count Slip B le |iF Official Cot ~f Metropolitan Correctional Center │
│ P a enter                                                                     │
│ te 4 eff? 5a pare: BIE pate: PPP Official Count Slip                          │
│ pis _| Gg Date: _ & HS it: ! 5                                                │
│ rime: MSO pm | wie Spm’. Unit: _LY oP Dat                                     │
│ Te > H Count: Time: _A™ 240 L a ate “                                         │
│ Print Name -int Name: ~                                                       │
│ - Signature: , Print Name                                                     │
│ Signature ee 4 gnature: —                                                     │
│ Print Name Signature _                                                        │
│ Print Name: _ ie rint Name:                                                   │
│ Print Name                                                                    │
│ Signature ignature: |                                                         │
│ = --— Signature                                                               │
│ Metropolitan Correctional Center                                              │
│ m . Official Count ip t « ter                                                 │
│ Metropolitan Correctional Center | Count Slip Metropolitan Correctional Cente │
│ New York, New Yor | Unit: _FS Date; 2-8 -¢g Official Count Slip =,            │
│ Official Count Slip / Date iy                                                 │
│ P Count: Time: Yigops Uni ci                                                  │
│ it: _ ate: ¥ | od Time:                                                       │
│ -L 1c - Dat ea Print Count 2                                                  │
│ ants Time: ae sition Print Name                                               │
│ Print ane |                                                                   │
│ _| Print Name: Signature:                                                     │
│ Signature: | Signature Print Name                                             │
│ Print Name s                                                                  │
│ Signatur                                                                      │
│                                                                               │
│ Metropolitan Correctional Center                                              │
│ | New York, New York |                                                        │
│ Official Count Slip                                                           │
│                                                                               │
│ Unit: F pp| > _ Date TS |1¢                                                   │
│                                                                               │
│ 1 |                                                                           │
│ } count: Ly Time ras                                                          │
│                                                                               │
│ | 1. Print Name:                                                              │
│ 1. Signature:                                                                 │
│                                                                               │
│ Print Name:                                                                   │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

3.
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
NEW YORK, NY
OFFICIAL OUT COUNT
DATE:
FROM:
APPROVED:
q -S-19 COUNT TIME: V'e0P-t,
it/texcw•h'e  LOCATION:  liosp(Staff Motnber Preparing Out Count)
(Operations Lieutenant)
REG # NAME UNIT REG # NAME UNIT

1. 90 ?70- 0$73 Cifor,
2.
6 o  - to,, )0 7/
4.
5.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
6. 18.
7. 19.
8. 20.
9. 21.
10. 22.
11. 23.
12. 24.
OUT-COUNT BY UNIT
B-A   C-A   E-N  (  E-S   G-N   G-S
I-N K-N K-S   R-A   Z-A   Z-B
Total Out -Counted:
H-A
This form must be submitted to the Counts and Assignments Officer FORTY-FIVE MINUTES PRIOR to the affected count.
Prepare this form in ink. Group the inmates according to their respective housing units. This form is to be used only as
an
Out-Count. No other form will be accepted in lieu of the Out-Count Form.
NYMDK 530*05 * INMATE ROSTER * 08-08-2019
PAGE 001 OF 001 15:40:03
CATEGORY: OCT GROUP CODE:
ASSIGNMENT: HOSP FACILITY: NYM
OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT
NUM ASSIGNMENT REG NO NAME OCT DATE QTR WRK
0001 HOSP 90370-053 CHAN 08-08-2019 E10-573L EDUCATION
SUICIDE OR
0002 86700-054 CONLEY 08-08-2019 E03-524U SUICIDE OR
UNASSG
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED

• OFFICIAL OUT-COUNT FORM
Metropolitan Correctional Center
New York, New York 10007
Date: 08-08-2019
From:
(Staff Member Supervising Inmates)
Approved:
(Operations Lieutenant)
Count Time:  4:00  pm
Location: FNYE
REG  LN  FN  QTR. . .
89380-053 DAVIS HOWARD Z01-106UAD
B-A C-A E-N E-S G-N G-S
H-A I-N K-N K-S R-A Z-A 1  Z-B
Total Out-Counted:  1
This Form must be submitted to the Counts and Assignments Officer FORTY-FIVE MINUTES PRIOR
To The affected account. Prepare this form in ink. Group the inmates according to their respective
housing units. This is to be used only as an Out Count.
NYMDK 530*05 * INMATE ROSTER * 08-08-2019
PAGE OO1,OF 001 15:40:38
CATEGORY: OCT GROUP CODE:
ASSIGNMENT: FNYE FACILITY: NYM
OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT
NUM ASSIGNMENT REG NO NAME
0001 FNYE 89380-053 DAVIS
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
OCT DATE QTR WRK
08-08-2019 Z01-106UAD UNASSG
• UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
OFFICIAL OUT-COUNT FORM
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Date: 08-08-2019
From:
Count Time: 4:00 pm
Location: FNYS
(Staff Member Supervising Inmates)
Approved:
PP
REG
(Operations Lieutenant)
86340-054
65773-054
57343-054
19435-104
30772-069
77737-112
B-A C-A
H-A 1 I-N
LN
NIEVES
BRITO
HERRERA
DE FREITAS
TAVERAS
IGNATOV
E-N 1 E-S
K-N 1 K-S 2
Total Out-Counted: 6
FN
IVAN
HASSEN
LOUIS
FABIO
JAIRO
KONSTANTIN
QTR
E06 -547L
G05 -740U
H01 -001L
K03 -122U
K07 -007U
K07 -073U
G-N 1 G-S
R-A Z-A Z-B
This Form must be submitted to the Counts and Assignments Officer FORTY-FIVE MINUTES PRIOR
To The affected count. Prepare this form in ink. Group the inmates according to their respective housing
units. This is to be used only as an Out Count.
NYMDK 530*05 *
PAGE 001 OF 001
CATEGORY:
ASSIGNMENT:
INMATE ROSTER 08-08-2019
15:41:06
OCT GROUP CODE:
FNYS FACILITY: NYM
OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT
NUM ASSIGNMENT REG NO NAME OCT DATE QTR WRK
0001 FNYS 65773-054 BRITO 08-08-2019 G05-740U UNASSG
0002 19435-104 DE FREITAS 08-08-2019 K03-122U SUICIDE OR
UNASSG
0003 57343-054 HERRERA 08-08-2019 H01-001L UNASSG
0004 77737-112 IGNATOV 08-08-2019 K07-073U UNASSG
0005 86340-054 NIEVES 08-08-2019 E06-547L UNASSG
0006 30772-069 TAVERAS 08-08-2019 K07-007U UNASSG
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
_J
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
NEW YORK, NY
DATE:
FROM:
APPROVED:
OFFICIAL OUT COUNT
COUNT TIME:
(Staff Member Preparing Out Count)
(Operations Lieutenant)
LOCATION: r/f
REG # NAME UNIT REG If NAME UNIT
1.
"/ 74 , 3 -i/o? 3q,-) A-  13.
-Lr (A.5& - 0 1/4.53/ 7 1 tometo
/1 J l ogos3-0&& L/arA" ES  14. 7 9G5---05 (
3-n74ev-0-5( Jon can 4. 5 / 7 0d- 06 Y s1 ra da,  16.

5. 76 /W - 05 c≤ re)r) a cloy f  17.
6. Sh5,15 - ,0 tOrYM itcr i
7.50 59- - V/ r X 'irk
8. e5-97- 055 /72a e
9.
84, WG - 0,57 /12 e reAa4 I X if 22.
1°. 7,3-o53 : /22er-fe E-cf'
IL& Odd -on/ cid iN 24.
23.
8-s12.
" Ya -osY e /('-j
15.
18.
19.
20.
21.
OUT-COUNT B UNIT
B-A   C-A   E-N E-S   G-N   G-S
I-N   K-N   K-S   R-A   Z-A   Z-B
Total Out-Counted: //
H-A
This form must be submitted to the Counts and Assignments Officer FORTY-FIVE MINUTES PRIOR  to the affected count.
Prepare this form in ink. Group the inmates according to their respective housing units. This form is to be used only as
an
Out -Count. No other form will be accented in lieu of the Out -Count Form.
NYMGW .530*05 *
PAGE 001 OF 001
CATEGORY:
ASSIGNMENT:
OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT
INMATE ROSTER * 08-08-2019
14:21:08
OCT GROUP CODE:
FS FACILITY: NYM
OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT
NUM ASSIGNMENT REG NO NAME OCT DATE QTR WRK
0001 FS 77863-112 BANG 08-08-2019 K12-062U PS PM
SUICIDE OR
0002 68683-066 CLARK 08-08-2019 E12-593U FS PM
0003 86764-054 DUNCAN 08-08-2019 K12-065U FS PM
SUICIDE OR
0004 51702-069 ESTRADA-RODRIGUEZ 08-08-2019 K09-025U FS PM
0005 76161-054 GRANADOS-CORONA 08-08-2019 K07-007L FS PM
0006 86535-054 KAMARA 08-08-2019 K11-053U FS PM
0007 50659-018 KIRK 08-08-2019 E07-556U FS PM
0008 85976-054 MARTINEZ 08-08-2019 K09-027U FS PM
0009 86026-054 MERCHANT 08-08-2019 K12-061L FS PM
0010 89673-053 MERSEY 08-08-2019 E12-592U FS PM
SUICIDE OR
0011 86022-054 REINGOUD 08-08-2019 K12-078U FS PM
0012 85927-054 ROMERO-GRANADOS 08-08-2019 K10-045U FS PM
0013 79652-054 THOMAS 08-08-2019 K08-074U FS PM
0014 79965-054 THOMAS 08-08-2019 K10-044L FS PM
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
METROPOLITAN
CORRECTIONAL
CENTER
NEW YORK, NY
DATE:
FROM:
APPROVED:
taff ember Prepa
OFFICIAL OUT COUNT
COUNT TIME:
LOCATION:
Out Count)
(Operations Lieutenant)
REG # NAME
UNIT
REG #
NAME
UNIT
L 7", -o5- Ora) O
2.
14.
09-t /N.) 7,4,
13.
3.
15.
4. 1 - 01 6 Tr) Z.A
CI 5  16.
5.
17.
6.
18.
7.
19.
8.
20.
9.
21.
10.
22.
11.
23.
12.
24.
OUT-COUNT BY UNIT
B-A   C-A   E-N   E-S   G-N   G-S I II-A
I-N  j   K-N   K-S   R-A   Z-A  j
Z-B
Total Out -Counted:
This form must be submitted to the Counts and Assignments Officer FORTY-FIVE MINUTES PRIOR to the affected count.
Prepare this form in ink. Group the inmates according to their respective housing units. This form is to be used only as
an
Out-Count. No other form will be accepted in lieu of the Out-Count Form.
*NYMDK 530*05 * INMATE ROSTER 08-08-2019
PAGE O01 OF 001 15:15:05
CATEGORY: OCT GROUP CODE:
ASSIGNMENT: ATTY FACILITY: NYM
OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT
NUM ASSIGNMENT REG NO NAME OCT DATE QTR WRK
0001 ATTY 91126-053 ARAUJO 08-08-2019 I04-930U UNASSG
0002 76318-054 EPSTEIN 08-08-2019 Z04-206LAD UNASSG
0003 71776-018 IRIZARRY 08-08-2019 G08-759U UNASSG
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
NYMDK 530.03 * 08-08-2019 BUREAU OF PRISONS COUNT SHEET *
PAGE 001 * NEW YORK MCC * 21:37:13
QTRG EQ **** OCTG EQ ****
OUT COUNT SECTION
A F F F F H
T N N N S O
T J Y Y S
COUNT Y E S P
AREA CENSUS
M R S TR V OC
S & A N I UO
D N W S TU
I D I N
V T T
VERIFY COUNT
COUNT COUNT AREA
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
B-A 26
C-A 10
E-N 84
E-S 79
G-N 78
G-S 85
H-A 3
I-N 86
K-N 89
K-S 137
R-A 0
Z-A 77
Z-B 5
TOTAL 759
COUNT
VERIFY
MPtrnr%"1:‘ ,.-__
2
26 B-A
10 C-A
84 E-N
79 E-S
78 G-N
85 G-S
3 H-A
86 I-N
89 K-N
2 2 135 K-S
0 R-A
77 Z-A
5 Z-B
2 757
OFFICIAL PREPARING COUNT:
OFFICIAL TAKING COUNT:
COUNT CLEARED TIME:ifs. '
Ud liflp In
Metropolitan Correctional Center
fficial Count Slip
Unit:
Count:
Print Nam
Signature:
Print.I&I)
Signature:
Date:
Time:

╭────────── Page 13, Image 1 ──────────╮
│ * 08-08-2019                         │
│                                      │
│ NYMDK 530.03 * BUREAU OF PRISONS COL │
│ PAGE 001 * NEW YORK MCC              │
│ OCTG EQ ****                         │
│                                      │
│ OUTCOUNT SECTION                     │
│                                      │
│ A F F F F H M R Ss                   │
│ T N N N Ss le} Ss & A                │
│ Tt J Y Y Ss D N                      │
│                                      │
│ o P I                                │
│                                      │
│ COUNT Y E Ss                         │
│                                      │
│ B-A 26                               │
│ C-A 10                               │
│ E-N 84                               │
│ 78                                   │
│ 85                                   │
│ 3                                    │
│ I-N 86                               │
│ 89                                   │
│ K-S 137 2                            │
│ R-A 0                                │
│ Z-A 77                               │
│ Z-B 5                                │
│                                      │
│ TOTAL                                │
│                                      │
│ COUNT                                │
│ VERIFY                               │
│                                      │
│ OFFICIAL PREPARING COUNT             │
│ OFFICIAL TAKING COUNT:               │
│                                      │
│ COUNT CLEARED TIME: |b YA            │
│ i                                    │
│ pr                                   │
│                                      │
│ Cam. ————                            │
│                                      │
│ Print Nam                            │
│                                      │
│ Signature:                           │
│                                      │
│ Signature                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────╯

Unit:
Count:
Print Name
Signature:
Print Namc
clanature:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
/Official Count Slip
cr
Date:
Time:
Metropolitan Correctional Center Official Count Slip
KrN
true:
me:
pet
Time: I
S
Metropolitan Correctional Center
"Tidal Count Slip
8
%fame:
ire:
ame:
re:
Date:
Unit:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Count: 71
Date:
Time:
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Unit:  Date
Count: /0
gisfiqinme:_LC2oDwn
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature
Metropolitan Correctional Center
fficial Count Slip
Unit:
Count:  Time:
Print Name: _A
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Unit:
Count:
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Date:
Z6  Time:  70 17  (Al l
Unit:
Count:
Print Name:
signature:
Print Name:
Signature:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
New York, New York
Official unt Slip
Unit:  Z .  Date:
,
1. Print Nattie:_
1. Signature:_
2. Print Name:-
2. Signature:
I
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Of ial Count Slip
Date:
Time:
yell? I
/Op rti
Unit:
Count:
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature:
Metropolit
Correctional Center fictal Count Slip
Date:
Time:
Metropolitan Correctional Center Official Count p
Count: -- O
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature
Unit:
Count:
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name:
Signature
Time:
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
Time: /

╭─────────────────── Page 14, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ Metropolitan Correctional Center                       │
│                                                        │
│ Official Count Slip Unit LA                            │
│                                                        │
│ olitan Correctional Center                             │
│                                                        │
│ Metre S                                                │
│ Pfficial Count Slip . Unit: Az Date “3 | Count         │
│ unit: =| Date: QO" COO! Count: 9 a Time: Print N oC Dh │
│ = nt Name                                              │
│ x Time Print Name: < ¢ 4                               │
│ Count ——f tt on Signatur 7                             │
│                                                        │
│ —s Signature:                                          │
│                                                        │
│ Print Name                                             │
│ | /                                                    │
│ Signature >                                            │
│                                                        │
│ Print Name                                             │
│                                                        │
│ |                                                      │
│ e. Print Name:                                         │
│                                                        │
│ Signature:                                             │
│                                                        │
│ css Signatui                                           │
│                                                        │
│ Print Nam¢                                             │
│                                                        │
│ sionature: Mi                                          │
│ Metropolitan Correctional Center                       │
│                                                        │
│ bags Count Slip /                                      │
│                                                        │
│ Unit: _BA S Date: _                                    │
│                                                        │
│ Print Name                                             │
│                                                        │
│ tropolitan Correctional Center 5 >                     │
│ e Metropolitan Correctional Center                     │
│                                                        │
│ Cotticial Count si Official Count Slip van             │
│ Cpe F/B {LF                                            │
│ /                                                      │
│ - 2                                                    │
│ time LODO                                              │
│                                                        │
│ Print Name:                                            │
│                                                        │
│ Signature: Signature                                   │
│                                                        │
│ Pri                                                    │
│ Signature: Print Name: Name:                           │
│                                                        │
│ Signature                                              │
│                                                        │
│ Print Name: Signature:                                 │
│                                                        │
│ Signature                                              │
│                                                        │
│ ‘Metropolitan Correctional Center                      │
│ _Dfficial Count Slip Sa                                │
│                                                        │
│ Ss Date: _ 8-8 -/9                                     │
│  oSe Time: 4014394                                     │
│                                                        │
│ /                                                      │
│ | unit: (10 pate: 810/17)                              │
│                                                        │
│ Count: 2 : £09? po                                     │
│ Print Name: ___ Zz                                     │
│ Signature: fit                                         │
│                                                        │
│ Signatui                                               │
│                                                        │
│ ew York, New York                                      │
│ Count Slip                                             │
│                                                        │
│ Unit                                                   │
│                                                        │
│ | 1. Print Name:                                       │
│                                                        │
│ I                                                      │
│ 1. Signature                                           │
│ 2. Print Name                                          │
│                                                        │
│ Signature                                              │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
NEW YORK, NY
DATE:
FROM:
APPROVED:
03-os--/9
OFFICIAL OUT COUNT
COUNT TIME:
l ot:ALDO(Staff Member Preparing Out Count)
(Operations Lieutenant
LOCATION:
70z 2ioni-
REG # NAME UNIT
1.
9 /3  119 -0 -C3 44 ,&Z.- X-5
2.
aik 4e-v- ,es 3.
4.
5.
REG # NAME UNIT
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.

6. 18.
7. 19.
8. 20.
9. 21.
10. 22.
11. 23.
12. 24.
OUT-COUNT BY UNIT
B-A   C-A   E-N E-S   G-N   G-S
I-N   K-N   K-S -------  R-A   Z-A   Z-B
Total Out -Counted:
H-A
This form must be submitted to the Counts and Assignments Officer FORTY-FIVE MINUTES PRIOR to the affected count.
Prepare this form in ink. Group the inmates according to their respective housing units. This form is to be used only as
an
Out -Count. No other form will be accepted in lieu of the Out -Count Form.
NYMDK 530*05 * INMATE ROSTER * 08-08-2019
PAGE 001 OF 001 20:22:02
CATEGORY: OCT GROUP CODE:
ASSIGNMENT: HOSP FACILITY: NYM
OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT OPER CATG ASSIGNMENT
NUM ASSIGNMENT REG NO NAME OCT DATE QTR
0001 HOSP 91349-053 NOBOA 08-08-2019 K07-009L
0002 85377-054 WEBER 08-08-2019 K12-078L
G0000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
i
WRK
FS AM
SUICIDE OR
SUICIDE OR
UNASSG
EFTA00109654 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons roster of inmates at Metropolitan Correctional Center
(date: 2019-08-08)
NYMB5 530.07 •
PAGE 001
FUNCTION: R-P
ZERO/NBR: NO
OPTION:
DUP SUPR: YES
COLUMNS 1: REG
POPULATION MONITORING CENSUS/ROSTER • 08-08-2019
GENERALIZED RETRIEVAL • 06:28:35
SELECTION CATEGORY: QTR EQ ALL
ORGANIZATION: FACL EQ NYM
TYPE OF FACILITY: TOF EQ T
FACILITY MANAGED BY: FMB EQ AP
2: LN 3: LN2 4: FN 5: ARSD 6: ARS
CONDITIONS (GRP 1)
CMCI NE G
CMCI NE P
G TOT
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
7: 8:
SEQ: 234 NP:
JUDG: C SORT COL: COL SEQ:
OR CONDITIONS (GRP 2) OR CONDITIONS (GRP 3) OR CONDITIONS (GRP 4)
753 727 26
-W-
390
\\‘
350 2 11
-H- -0-
309 444
NYMBS 530*07 * ROSTER
PAGE 002
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG
I05N I05-936L 85828-054
GllS G11-783U 86957-054
E01N E01-502U 86640-054
KO9S K09-026L 29116-379
E07S E07-554U 25404-038
E11S E11-588U 49259-054
E12S E12-594U 14340-067
KO2N K02-115U 85564-054
K1OS K10-043L 85650-053
Kl2S K12-071U 70105-050
ZO7B Z07-301LAD 77704-054
E08S E08-564U 27933-055
HOLA H01-001L 85978-054
KOSN K06-148L 86049-054
Bogs E09-571L 83706-053
G06N 006-741L 77312-054
E09S E09-565L 79767-054
GOSN GOS-740L 90118-053
GO9S G09-765U 86374-054
E03N E03-523U 86434-054
BO1A 801-219L 86821-054
I04N I04-930U 91126-053
E07S E07-550U 90522-054
E01N E01-501U 85794-054
IO2N IO2-909U 79562-054
ZO3A Z03-113LAD 86123-054
IO1N I01-905U 85885-053
Z07B 207-306LAD 91782-053
G12S G12-791U 72419-019
ZO4A 204-206LAD 86710-054
KO1N K01-106U 86953-054
GO3N G03-721L 94890-038
ZO6A Z06-217LAD 76157-054
GO1N G01-703U 87074-054
E04N E04-532L 77128-054
KO1N K01-103U 79781-054
K12S K12-062U 77863-112
GllS G11-785L 85714-054
GllS G11-783U 66471-054
K11S K11-077L 86820-054
E07S E07-551L 61881-054
K07S K07-008U 23789-057
I04N I04-929U 45655-054
801A B01-210U 86154-054
KO4N K04-127U 85858-054
LN
ABERHANTE
ACOSTA-LIRIANO
ACOSTA-SALAZAR
ACOSTA-VENTURA
ADAMS
ADAMS
ADAMS
AGUDELO-AGUDELO
AL-NAMIDI
ALAMO
ALIMEHMETI
ALLS
ALMANZAR
ALVAREZ
AMISSAH
ANDREWS
ANGEVINE
ANTNEY
ANTONIUS
APSKALNS
ARAMBUL
ARAUJO
ARDILA
ARIAS
ARMENTA
ARROYO
ARTIS
ASAINOV
ASHU
AVILA
AYALA
AYBAR
BABROW
BAEZ-PENA
BALDE
BALDEO
BANG
BANKS
BANKS
BARBER
BARNETT
BARRERA
BARRIENTOS
BATISTA
BATURI
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
FN
ANNEL
JUANCARLOS
ABEL
LINCOLN
GARY
RAMON
RICHARD
ORLANDO
ALI
EDWIN
SAJMIR
RODNEY
NELSON
CARLOS
HECTOR
CHRISTOPHE
JAQUAN
JOHAN
STEVEN
MARTINS
DALIA
GUSTAVO
RANDOLPH
MINEL
GILBERT
ANGEL
SOLOMAN
RUSLAN
CYRIL
PATRICK
RICARDO
GERONIMO
LORENZO
AMARUIS
SOULEYMANE
HAKEEM
CHI
EARL
JAMIE
BYRON
LATSEN
ESTABAN
RENE
SAMANTHA
MUBARAK
08-08-2019
06:28:35
ARSD  ARS
12-11-2018 A-HLD
06-13-2019 A-PRE
03-05-2019 A-PRE
04-04-2019 A-PRE
05-20-2019 A-DES
06-04-2019 A-DES
01-14-2019 A-DES
10-31-2018 A-PRE
01-10-2019 A-PRE
08-01-2019 A-PRE
11-27-2018 A-HLD
06-24-2019 A-DES
07-26-2018 A-PRE
01-22-2019 A-PRE
08-05-2019 A-DES
07-02-2019 A-PRE
08-03-2018 A-DES
01-28-2019 A-PRE
11-30-2018 A-PRE
12-21-2018 A-PRE
04-16-2019 A-PRE
10-18-2018 A-PRE
04-23-2019 A-DES
05-06-2019 A-PRE
07-19-2019 A-PRE
04-24-2019 A-PRE
05-28-2015 A-PRE
07-19-2019 A-PRE
05-29-2019 A-PRE
03-13-2019 A-PRE
06-12-2019 A-PRE
11-01-2018 A-PRE
10-19-2018 A-PRE
08-05-2019 A-PRE
01-18-2019 A-PRE
06-24-2019 A-HLD
04-23-2019 A-PRE
07-22-2019 A-HLD
07-30-2019 A-PRE
04-16-2019 A-PRE
12-17-2018 A-DES
07-18-2019 A-HLD
02-28-2019 A-PRE
09-28-2018 A-PRE
02-08-2019 A-HLD
NYMBS 530*07
PAGE 003
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG
B01A 801-221L
H01A H01-001L
E07S E07-554U
E08S E08-560L
K05N K05-135L 92404-054
I02N I02-910U 87079-054
K12S K12-070O 67290-054
Z01A 201-101LAD 79407-054
K12S K12-072U 86403-054
G098 G09-767L 24301-052
K12S K12-067U 86884-054
E01N E01-506L 50501-054
K118 K11-056O
K12S K12-064U
K09S K09-035O
K12S K12-070O
E08S E08-563L
E02N E02-  110  76309-054
Z03A 203-1090 '162b9-U54
GOSH G05-740O 65773-054
K04N K04-125O 86857-054
Z06A 206-213OAD 86460-054
E11S E11-581L 85410-054
Z06A
Gl2S
E05N
G01N
K07S
G01N
El0S
E02N
E12S
E05N
E11S
K06N
G08S
E02N
G07S
K01N
Z04A
K03N
E02N
EllS
G03N
G09S
ROSTER
LN
71423-018 BAUTA
86463-054 BENJAMIN
11608-082 BENJAMIN
25001-052 BENNETT
BETTIS
BILAL
BINNS
BLADES
BLANCHE
BOARIU
BOKOV
BOOTH
79593-054 BRADFORD
87078-054 BRADLEY
86412-054 BRAHAM
72612-067 BRANT
15015-055 BRENON
206-219LAD 70786-050
G12-793L 19278-104
E05-533L 81131-053
G01-705O 83053-053
K07-010L 87035-054
G01-707O
E10-573O
E02-512U
812-592U
E05-535L
E11-582L
K06-14711
G08-758U 68456-298
E02-513U 55210-053
G07-750U 86554-054
K01-101O 86919-054
204-211LAD 86630-054
K03-123O 85984-054
E02-509O 85706-054
E11-585O 65759-050
G03-719O 79701-054
G09-766L 89972-053
BRIGH2_,
BRISSETT
BRITO
BRITO
BROCK
BROWN
BROWN
BROWN
BROWN
BROWN
BROWN
66351-054 BRUEN
17190-052 BRUNNER
86489-054 BRYANT
57297-083 BUCHANAN
86409-054 BULLOCK
11729-082 BUNCH
86792-054 BURGOS
BURGOS-CABADA
BUSSEY
BUTLER
BUTLER
BUTLER
CABA BATISTA
CABALA
CABRERA
CABRERA
CALABRIA
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
FN
ELIANA
LUIDJI
SEBASTIAN
EDWARD
ZUBEARU
ELIJAH
RASHEED
CHRISTAN
NAZAE
MARCEL
JEVGENI
RONNELL
DAVID
WILLIAM
DARIEL
JOSEPH
TIMOTHY
PETER
JAMAL
HASSEN
MAXIMILIAN
MARK
ALLEN
CHAD
JOHN
KAREEN
MICHAEL
RAKIM
DUANE
KENNETH
WARREN
JOHN
CHRISTOPHE
JASON
ANTONIO
JOSE
JAVON
DENARD
RAHSAAN
TUREAN
HECTOR
SAMMUEL
CHRISTIAN
JOHN
JOSEPH
* 08-08-2019
06:28:35
ARSD  ARE
04-16-2019 A-HLD
01-07-2019 A-HLD
07-08-2019 A-DES
01-22-2019 A-DES
07-03-2019 A-HLD
08-07-2019 A-PRE
08-01-2019 A-HLD
08-17-2017 A-HLD
03-13-2019 A-PRE
07-02-2019 A-HLD
05-09-2019 A-PRE
06-05-2019 A-PRE
04-17-2019 A-HLD
08-06-2019 A-PRE
12-12-2018 A-PRE
07-03-2019 A-PRE
07-22-2019 A-DES
05-23-2019 A-PRE
03-13-2019 A-PRE
08-02-2019 A-PRE
04-26-2019 A-HLD
01-04-2019 A-PRE
03-18-2019 A-DES
07-08-2019 A-DES
03-11-2019 A-PRE
07-20-2016 A-PRE
07-02-2019 A-PRE
07-19-2019 A-PRE
06-24-2019 A-HLD
12-17-2018 A-DES
01-10-2019 A-PRE
07-08-2019 A-DES
12-12-2018 A-PRE
01-14-2019 A-DES
05-31-2019 A-HLD
05-08-2018 A-PRE
04-03-2019 A-PRE
01-30-2019 A-PRE
05-24-2019 A-PRE
02-28-2019 A-HLD
07-30-2019 A-PRE
05-17-2018 A-HLD
07-08-2019 A-DES
03-26-2019 A-PRE
09-26-2018 A-PRE
NYMBS 530.07 •
PAGE 004
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG
E01N E01-503L 23513-053
IO2N IO2-912L 86115-054
G01N 001-705L 79355-054
B08S 208-5610 86052-054
K07S K07-002U 41682-054
E05N E05-5370 67687-050
GO5N G05-736U 86509-054
1(115 K11-056U 86951-054
1(075 K07-004U 87058-054
801A 801-202L 76049-054
I06N I06-941U 86996-054
I05N I05-938L 00633-748
1101A B01-221L 54630-479
203N E03-518L 76139-054
K10S K10-037L 79458-054
205A 205-123UAD 86164-054
I05N I05-936U 78162-054
I03N I03-921U 90859-053
K07S K07-0060 76325-054
2105 E10-573L 90370-053
I03N I03-920U 85467-054
IO1N I01-901U 86113-054
E01N E01-501L 83736-053
Kl2S K12-064L 87077-054
GOBS 008-757L 78548-054
KO1N K01-108L 76218-054
K02N K02-116L 86765-054
201N E01-504L 67319-054
G03N 003-719L 75605-054
K05N KOS-134U 86110-054
E12S E12-593U 68683-066
1(115 K11-056U 53358-054
I05N I05-936U 86712-054
012S 012-793U 79046-054
O12S 012-795U 86959-054
E03N E03-524U 86700-054
206A 206-213UAD 89520-053
205A 205-122LAD 92299-054
K02N K02-1130 86655-054
ROBS E08-563L 19446-058
203N E03-522U 76280-054
002N 002-711L 85804-054
207S E07-554U 86341-054
K02N K02-113L 15051-053
210S E10-576U 62833-054
ROSTER
LN
CALABRIA
CALDERON
CAMACHO
CAPELLAN
CARABELLO
CARABUS
CARDONA-CARDONA
CARRASCO
CARRASQUILLO
CARRILLO
CARRILLO
CASTELLE
CASTILLO-RODRIGUEZ
CASTILLO-ROSARIO
CASTILO
CAVE
CERUTI
CHACON
CHAIREZ
CHAN
CHAN BAYARDO
CHARDON
CHARLES
CHAVIS
CHERRY
CHERRY
CHERRY
CHRISTIAN
CIFUENTES-VILLA
CITRONELLE
CLARK
CLARK
COLDS
COLLAZO
COLLINS
CONLEY
CONTRERAS
COOPER
CORLEY
CORPENING
CORREA-YUSTY
CvTTO
00770
COTTON
CROSBY
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
FN
MICHAEL
JUAN
FERDINAND
BRIAN
FRED
ALIN
DAVID
ALBERTO
MIGUEL
CINDY
JONATHAN
EUGENE
LIUDMYLA
GABRIEL
PELIX
ETHAN
SAMUEL
JOSE
PELIPE
MICHAEL
MAURICO
MILTON
NALERTON
UNIQUE
DAVID
ERIC
ROBERT
RAYMOND
HILEEBRAND
GEORGE
ROBERT
ROBERT
JALEN
HIRAM
VANCE
DWAYNE
JHONNY
MATTHEW
ANTHONY
MICHAEL
WILMER
EDDIE
JOSHUA
MELVIN
DAVID

• 08-08-2019
06:28:35
ARSD  ARS
02-22-2017 A-PRE
09-12-2018 A-HLD
02-16-2018 A-HLD
07-15-2019 A-DES
01-04-2019 A-HLD
07-10-2019 A-HLD
04-29-2019 A-PRE
06-12-2019 A-PRE
07-31-2019 A-PRE
01-30-2019 A-HLD
07-03-2019 A-HLD
06-19-2019 A-PRE
06-12-2019 A-HLD
02-01-2019 A-PRE
05-10-2019 A-PRE
07-26-2019 A-HLD
08-07-2019 A-HLD
06-21-2018 A-HLD
07-30-2019 A-PRE
03-26-2019 A-DES
08-02-2019 A-HLD
09-12-2018 A-PRE
05-07-2019 A-PRE
08-06-2019 A-PRE
11-09-2018 A-HLD
07-08-2019 A-PRE
03-28-2019 A-PRE
08-22-2014 A-HLD
03-15-2019
09-12-2018
02-15-2019
07-29-2019
03-13-2019
05-02-2019
06-13-2019
03-20-2019
02-20-2018
05-20-2019
03-08-2019
08-07-2019
04-03-2019
05-23-2019
07-02-2019
05-29-2019
08-05-2019
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-DES
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-DES
A-PRE
A-DES
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-DES
A-HLD
A-DES
NYMBS 530*07
PAGE 005
• ROSTER 08-08-2019
06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
KO2N K02-115U 86972-054 CRUZ PIMENTEL NELSON 06-20-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05-534U 76258-054 CUEVAS JAVIER 01-24-2019 A-PRE
GO9S 009-771U 91662-053 CUMMINGS JASON 06-28-2019 A-PRE
GO1N GO1-708U 68395-054 CUNNINGHAM ANDRE 08-02-2019 A-PRE
E095 E09-56813 89936-053 CUYLER KEVIN 03-27-2019 A-DES
E12S E12-589L 77306-054 DANSOWAH FRANKLIN 12-12-2018 A-DES
KO5N K05-134U 86725-054 DARAND ROLANDO 03-20-2019 A-PRE
KO5N K05-133U 76256-054 DAVILA ARMANDO 01-17-2019 A-PRE
KO6N K06-144L 86548-054 DAVIS DARIUS 01-25-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06-543U 79647-054 DAVIS GARY 10-16-2017 A-PRE
201A 201-106UAD 89380-053 DAVIS HOWARD 09-27-2018 A-PRE
K12S K12-063U 86427-054 DAVIS HAREEM 12-19-2018 A-PRE
K03N K03-122U 19435-104 DE FREITAS FABIO 02-12-2019 A-PRE
GO1N G01-706L 76167-054 DE LA CRUZ DIONICIO 10-05-2018 A-PRE
E075 507-555L 16520-055 DECAPUA BRANDON 02-25-2019 A-DES
Kl2S K12-067U 86828-054 DEL CARMEN DERIAN 04-18-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-018L 85417-054 DEL ORBE LUNA WINSTON 02-28-2018 A-PRE
EllS E11-582U 79251-054 DELACRUZ HECTOR 07-08-2019 A-DES
KO2N K02-116U 76278-054 DELAROSA AMADO 04-03-2019 A-PRE
El2S E12-593L 05386-090 DELATORRE PAUL 12-17-2018 A-DES
Z03A Z03-113LAD 86132-054 DELEON OMAR 06-25-2019 A-HLD
KO2N K02-112U
I04N I04-925U
86830-054
76300-054
DELOSANTOS
DEMANE DEBIH
MARIO
MARC
04-18-2019 A-PRE
07-02-2019 A-PRE
205A 205-123LAD 55381-066 DESILVA MICHAEL 01-14-2019 A-DES
E08S E08-5640 89424-053 DHANNA ANDRE 07-19-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-034L 79491-054 DIAZ ALEXIS 09-04-2018 A-PRE
205A 205-121UAD 77930-054 DIAZ ROBERT 01-04-2019 A-PRE
KO3N K03-117U 86248-054 DIAZ-HERNANDEZ AUGUSTIN 10-25-2018 A-PRE
K09S K09-030U 76156-054 DIAZ-MORALEZ VICTOR 08-05-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-023U 71471-054 DIAZ-PALMER OMAR 11-01-2018 A-PRE
E075 E07-5520 72042-066 DIAZ-TORRES MISAEL 01-23-2019 A-DES
KOIN K01-102L 86805-054 DISLA JOSE 04-11-2019 A-HLD
205A Z05-123LAD 60685-050 DOCKERY MARTIN 04-29-2019 A-DES
201A Z01-103LAD 86214-054 DONES MANOLO 01-16-2019 A-HLD
BOIA B01-218L 76187-054 DREIKSENA SANTA 08-07-2019 A-PRE
EO1N E01-505L 77665-054 DUNES CHRISTIAN 11-29-2018 A-HLD
K123 K12-065U 86764-054 DUNCAN KARL 03-28-2019 A-PRE
007S G07-755U 79949-054 DUPREY-VASQUEZ HECTOR 04-04-2019 A-PRE
201A 201-104UAD 86124-054 DURANT LAVELL 09-18-2018 A-HLD
ZO5A 205-124LAD 72418-019 EKE IFEANYI 05-29-2019 A-PRE
G01N G01-703L 90791-054 ELANSKY MICHAEL 07-16-2019 A-PRE
KO4N K04-131U 86282-054 ELLISON ANTHONY 11-06-2018 A-PRE
E095 E09-569U 78965-054 EMILIEN ANDRE 03-15-2019 A-DES
GllS G11-788U 76263-054 ENCARNACION JESUS 02-08-2019 A-PRE
E05N E05-539L 78107-054 ENGLISH CLAUDIUS 05-15-2018 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMB5 530.07 • ROSTER • 08-08-2019
PAGE 006 06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
ZO4A Z04-206LAD 76318-054 EPSTEIN JEFFREY 07-08-2019 A-PRE
KO4N K04-129L 86918-054 ESPINAL GYANCARLO 05-23-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-932L 81357-053 ESPINAL-GOMEZ JOSE ARNUL 05-16-2019 A-HLD
KO5N K05-1360 76275-054 ESTEBAN OMAR 03-21-2019 A-PRE
E04N 504-5250 86846-054 ESTEVEZ BRANDON 04-24-2019 A-HLD
ZO1A Z01-106LAD 86102-054 ESTEVEZ STEVEN 09-05-2018 A-PRE
GO6N G06-748L 86626-054 ESTEVEZ-GONZALEZ CARLOS 02-28-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-0250 51702-069 ESTRADA-RODRIGUEZ RAYMOND 04-04-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05-933L 96404-054 ETHERIDGE TYHEEM 12-11-2018 A-HLD
I01N I01-903L 90863-053 FANFAN JIMMY 10-03-2018 A-PRE
E10S E10-573L 60103-380 FAVELA FELICIANO 09-11-2018 A-DES
GUS G11-7850 86226-054 FELIPE JOHN 03-28-2019 A-HLD
ZO6A Z06-217UAD 85775-054 FELIX KERRY 04-23-2019 A-HLD
GllS G11-784L 78341-054 FELIZ RICHARD 03-05-2019 A-HLD
GO6N G06-7430 34814-054 FELTON JAMES 06-24-2019 A-HLD
EllS E11-582U 64006-037 FERGUSON LAMONT 06-24-2019 A-DES
E078 E07-552L 78002-054 FERNANDEZ HENRY 06-27-2018 A-DES
ZO5A Z05-123LAD 86824-054 FERNANDEZ LEONARDO 05-06-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-038L 78695-054 FERNANDEZ MARK 02-21-2019 A-HLD
E03N E03-5190 92339-054 FERNANDEZ-ROSA HECTOR 08-02-2019 A-HLD
ZO4A Z04-2060AD 79793-054 FERRER GREGORY 03-28-2019 A-DES
GO2N G02-7140 85707-054 FERTIDES YASMIL 08-20-2018 A-PRE
GOBS G08-760L 86993-054 FEVERIE JANSON 07-02-2019 A-PRE
I06N I06-947U 73822-053 FIGUEROA BENJAMIN 02-13-2019 A-PRE
K0114 K01-1030 86954-054 FIGUEROA CHARLES 06-12-2019 A-HLD
GO2N G02-716L 90774-053 FLORES ISRAEL 12-07-2018 A-PRE
E08S E08-561L 59632-053 FLORES MARKO 03-11-2019 A-DES
KO3N K03-121L 90462-053 FLORES-CACHO ALEJANDRO 02-06-2018 A-PRE
E09S E09-571L 71121-050 FLOYD DISHAWN 05-15-2019 A-DES
IO2N IO2-909L 87081-054 FLYNN ANTHONY 08-07-2019 A-HLD
I05N I05-9340 64593-054 FOSTER TOSHNELLE 05-06-2019 A-HLD
GllS G11-7870 76243-054 FRASCO AGUSTIN 12-06-2018 A-PRE
ZO5A Z05-122LAD 86368-054 FUENTES MIGUEL 11-29-2018 A-HLD
ZO3A Z03-110UAD 75885-054 GALAN CARLOS 03-05-2019 A-HLD
GO9S G09-7670 76320-054 GALVEZ-CHIMBO ROBER 07-12-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03-519L 85918-054 GAMA-PINEDA JOSE 05-30-2019 A-HLD
I05N I05-9350 90914-054 GARCIA BRIAN 07-30-2019 A-HLD
GIOS G10-7790 86878-054 GARCIA DAVID 05-02-2019 A-HLD
ZO5A Z05-118LAD 86290-054 GARCIA JACINTO 07-08-2019 A-HLD
KO4N K04-1320 77823-054 GARCIA JOSUE 09-20-2018 A-PRE
K02N K02-109U 79043-054 GARCIA-PENA PEDRO 03-05-2019 A-PRE
G12S G12-7890 91359-053 GASS JUSTIN 12-21-2018 A-PRE
I05N I05-939U 89762-053 GAYLE LAMAR 06-15-2017 FED WRIT
08-05-2019 A-BOP HLD
K08S K08-016U 86325-054 GIL CESAR 11-14-2018 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMBS 530*07
PAGE 007
* ROSTER • 08-08-2019
06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
COIN G01-70611 86292-054 GIL-CABRAL JUAN 07-29-2019 A-PRE
E12S E12-59613 81342-053 GOBA YOUSEF 06-24-2019 A-DES
E09S 809-567U 79460-054 GODBOLD RONALD 01-03-2019 A-DES
E03N E03-522L 73746-298 GOMEZ JESUS 03-26-2019 A-PRE
KO3N K03-122L 53634-424 GOMEZ-LATOREE FERNANDO 07-25-2019 A-PRE
203A Z03-113UAD 86825-054 GONZALEZ DANIEL 04-18-2019 A-PRE
K11S K11-060U 87064-054 GONZALEZ EDWIN 08-01-2019 A-HLD
KO8S K08-013L 86021-054 GONZALEZ GODOFREDO 08-30-2018 A-PRE
GOSS G08-76211 78715-054 GONZALEZ JAIME 02-13-2017 A-H1M
KO9S K09-029U 76326-054 GONZALEZ JOSE 08-06-2019 A-PRE
203A 203-116UAD 86617-054 GONZALEZ MARCOS 06-24-2019 A-HLD
ElOS E10-579L 15657-179 GONZALEZ OSMAR 08-21-2017 A-DES
K125 K12-062L 86097-054 GONZALEZ PETER 07-12-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06-548L 79984-054 GONZALEZ RICO 03-26-2019 A-HLD
K0114 K01-105L 71628-054 GONZALEZ TEODORO 06-18-2019 A-PRE
GO3NG03-723L 79486-054 GONZALEZ-SOLIZ JOSE 03-23-2018 A-PRE
KO3N K03-120L 75954-054 GOSWAMI VIJAY 07-24-2019 A-PRE
205A 205-120UAD 23152-014 GOULDBOURNE MARK 05-07-2019 A-PRE
KO7S K07-007L 76161-054 GRANADOS-CORONA EFRAIN 04-26-2018 A-PRE
GO9S G09-766U 76229-054 GRANDE ARTHUR 10-11-2018 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-072L 85835-054 GRANDY CLARENCE 01-29-2019 A-PRE
GO7S G07-749U 86639-054 GRAY KARL 07-30-2019 A-HLD
205A Z05-117UAD 70887-054 GRAYSON MARK 05-30-2018 A-HLD
ElOS E10-575U 90504-053 GREEN RAYQUTAN 05-24-2019 A-DES
E03N E03-520U 76231-054 GREENWOOD KARL 10-19-2018 A-PRE
KO7S K07-007L 85966-054 GRIFFIN LAMAR 01-09-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-527U 37897-054 GRIFFIN RODNEY 04-03-2018 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-914L 86114-054 GRULLAR WILLIAM 10-05-2018 A-HLD
I06N 106-942L 44543-054 GUERRERO JOSE 08-01-2019 A-PRE
205A Z05-121UAD 08820-070 GUILLEN GABRIEL 05-13-2019 A-HLD
IOIN I01-906L 79465-054 GUILLEN WILSON 06-06-2019 A-HLD
KO9S K09-025L 86317-054 GUO QIANG 11-14-2018 A-PRE
G105 G10-779L 86562-054 GUZMAN RANDY 06-25-2019 A-HLD
GllS G11-787L 85796-054 GUZMAN-CASTILLO BERNARDO 07-10-2019 A-PRE
GO3NG03-722U 76151-054 HADDOW RENWICK 06-01-2019 A-PRE
E08S E08-564U 21066-014 HAILEY CARL 06-03-2019 A-DES
E12S 512-595L 50645-037 HALEY ANDRE 05-20-2019 A-DES
E02N E02-516L 86988-054 HALL STEVEN 07-01-2019 A-PRE
E05N E05-539U 87014-054 HARGROVE JAKEEM 07-11-2019 A-HLD
K125 K12-061U 86771-054 HARRIS DARRELL 04-01-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06-543L 79410-054 HARRIS NICHOLAS 08-17-2017 A-HLD
E09S E09-572L 13510-067 HARRIS PERCY 08-21-2018 A-DES
E08S E08-561L 57084-056 HARRISON MICHAEL 07-11-2018 A-DES
BOIAB01-204L 95973-054 HATCHER SHARON 07-26-2018 A-PRE
GO7S G07-751L 75633-053 HAYES NICHOLAS 01-29-2018 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMBS 530*07
PAGE 008
* ROSTER • 08-08-2019
06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
205A 205-117LAD 14728-05 5 HEMINGWAY ANDRE 07-13-2019 A-DES
E07S E07-554U 30912-06 9 HEREDIA-ORTIZ ISMAEL 08-05-2019 A-DES
K02N K02-110L 06809-00 0 HERNANDDEZ-VALDEZ PEDRO 01-08-2019 A-PRE
G03N 003-718U 76287-05 4 HERNANDEZ FRANCISO 07-08-2019 A-HLD
I01N I01-901L 68126-054 HERNANDEZ WILLIAM 12-21-2018 A-PRE
I04N I04-931U 17838-104 HERNANDEZ-ALVARDO JUAN 12-18-2018 A-PRE
K08S K08-018U 56032-018 HERNANDEZ-CLAUDIOS ESTEVAN 06-25-2019 A-HLD
SOLA B01-210L 79305-A54 HERRERA KARILIE 02-12-2019 A-HLD
H0lAtR01-002L 57343-054 -HERRERA] LOUIS 08-07-2019 A-PRE
K03N K03-121O 25253-052 HERRERA SERGIO 10-16-2018 A-PRE
K05N K05-136U 77211-05 4 HEYWARD CORY 08-07-2018 A-HLD
E050 E05-537L 86287-05 4 HIDALGO-MENDOZA VICTOR 06-26-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-928U 87048-05 4 HILARIO-GONZALEZ CARLOS 07-26-2019 A-PRE
Z06A 206-214LAD 79455-05 4 HILL JAQUEZ 08-17-2017 A-PRE
G06N G06-742L 86271-05 4 HINES CUTIS 01-29-2019 A-PRE
K03N K03-123L 76101-05 4 HO CHI PING 03-26-2019 A-HLD
Gl2S G12-796U 86372-05 4 HOLLAND DAVID 11-30-2018 A-PRE
El0S E10-573L 60073-06 6 HOMAN DONALD 08-05-2019 A-DES
I010 I01-908L 86200-05 4 HOOKER DARNEL 07-03-2019 A-HLD
Z02A 202-201LAD 87049-05 4 HOSSAIN DELOWAR 07-26-2019 A-PRE
Z04A 204-207LAD 68152-05 4 HOYT KENNETH 05-21-2019 A-PRE
G09S G09-769L 87002-05 4 HUDSON CALVIN 07-09-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-011U 86046-05 4 HUDSON DARRELL 08-13-2018 A-PRE
E060 E06-542L 62670-05 4 HUSSETT DEVON 07-18-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-918U 86776-05 4 IBANEZ-FELIX LIBRADO 05-22-2019 A-PRE
E040 E04-526L 79606-054 IDELFONSO ANDRES 05-03-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-073U 77737-112 IGNATOV KONSTANTIN 08-06-2019 A-PRE
K05N K05-136U 88595-479 IKEJIMBA JOSHUA 06-04-2019 A-PRE
E040 E04-527L 61743-054 INNIS PATRICK 11-20-2018 A-HLD
I03N I03-918L 77588-054 INZUNZA ABRAHAM 02-07-2019 A-HLD
GOBS O08-759U 71776-018 IRIZARRY JORGE 04-09-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-922U 86979-054 ISOM-JENKINS JABAR/ 06-26-2019 A-HLD
E10S E10-573U 85687-054 JACKSON ERIK 06-27-2019 A-DES
G09S G09-769U 86944-05 4 JACKSON HARVEY 06-06-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05-939L 86174-05 4 JACKSON JEROME 04-11-2019 A-HLD
E060 506-542U 79729-05 4 JACKSON RAMEL 11-06-2017 A-HLD
I05N I05-940U 68430-05 4 JAQUEZ CARLOS 07-25-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-920U 79306-05 4 JAQUEZ LUIGI 07-06-2017 A-PRE
G03N G03-724U 76212-05 4 JARQUIN ARMANDO 09-08-2018 A-PRE
Z06A 206-217UAD 79466-05 4 JIMENEZ EDWARD 08-22-2017 A-PRE
G08S 008-764U 87067-05 4 JIMENEZ LEOCADIO 08-01-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-920U 86269-05 4 JIMENEZ RICHARD 07-31-2019 A-HLD
G02N O02-715U 76319-05 4 JIMENEZ-CASTILLO JUNIOR 07-12-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-031U 76235-05 4 JIMENEZ-GONZALEZ ALBERT 04-25-2019 A-HLD
G08S O08-763U 85890-05 4 JOHNSON DANDRE 06-28-2018 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMBS 530*07 * ROSTER 08-08-2019
PAGE 009 06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
K11S K11-053U 61876-054 JOHNSON JAMAL 06-11-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-917L 86461-054 JOHNSON JERMAINE 01-04-2019 A-PRE
I0114 I01-908U 86885-054 JOHNSON TORRIE 07-01-2019 A-PRE
K12S K12-0690 86627-054 JONES CHAZ 02-28-2019 A-PRE
011S G11-7860 86947-054 JONES DARRYL 06-11-2019 A-PRE
I06N I06-941L 06178-104 JONES JOHNNY 07-02-2019 A-HLD
K12S K12-065L 17742-104 JONES MICHAEL 10-30-2018 A-HLD
201A Z01-108LAD 68302-054 JONES RAYSHAUN 06-03-2019 A-HLD
K05N K05-1390 87016-054 JONES THERYN 07-11-2019 A-HLD
G06N G06-7450 69033-054 JORDAN MARKEEM 06-30-2019 A-HLD
K06N K06-141L 75996-054 JOSEPH DENFORD 05-24-2017 A-PRE
ZO1A Z01-106LAD 86931-054 KABA MORA 06-05-2019 A-PRE
E01N E01-502L 83565-098 XALABA ZEF 05-31-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-0530 86535-054 KAMARA ABRAHIM 04-23-2019 A-HLD
Z07B Z07-304LAD 90479-053 KANDIC MIRSAD 11-01-2017 A-PRE
EO1N E01-5060 86108-054 KEARSE RA KING 09-11-2018 A-PRE
KO1N K01-1050 76306-054 KELLY JAMES 05-16-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-528L 86018-054 KENNEDY JABARI 08-30-2018 A-PRE
Gl2S G12-792L 87003-054 KENYATTA CHARLES 07-09-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-073L 26178-017 KHUKHIASHVILI TENGIZ 02-12-2019 A-HLD
GO1N G01-701L 77684-053 KILGORE JULIO 08-05-2019 A-PRE
K12S K12-067U 60899-054 KING BOB 07-23-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06-54 26868-055 KING BRUCE 05-31-2019 A-HLD
E08S 08-561U 24774-052 KINSELLA JOSEPH 08-05-2019 A-DES
Z03A - 13LAD 86587-054 KINTEA MCKENZIE 06-17-2019 A-PRE
E07S E07-5560 50659-018 KIRK ANTHONY 06-24-2019 A-DES
G09S 009-768L 47186-044 KIRKLAND DAJUAN 07-30-2019 A-STDY
I05N I05-934L 67531-054 KNOX WILLIAM 10-11-2018 A-HLD
Gl2S G12-790L 92398-054 KOLMNELA LEOM 09-18-2018 A-HLD
K10S K10-076L 76312-054 KORETSKYY MYKHAYLO 05-31-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-008L 79196-054 KOURANI ALI 05-16-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-011L 86956-054 KROMAH MOAZU 06-13-2019 A-PRE
ElOS E10-5740 76140-066 LAHENS VLADIMIR 06-10-2019 A-DES
EllS E11-58613 64252-037 LAMBIRTH MICHAEL 08-05-2019 A-DES
Z05A Z05-122LDS 86357-054 LANS LEROY 07-29-2019 A-PRE
ZO6A 206-220LAD 79427-054 LATIMER COREY 07-24-2019 A-PRE
BO1A BO1-2020 56431-479 LAURE-TESISTECO RITA 01-28-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-917U 85838-054 LAWRENCE CHRISTOPHE 06-24-2019 A-HLD
E11S E11-58213 48958-054 LAWTON ANTOINE 05-20-2019 A-DES
G02N G02-71611 85782-298 LEAL RAYMUNDO 07-16-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-0760 05585-070 LEBRON HECTOR 04-23-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-948U 86343-054 LEE NICK 07-17-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03-520L 18028-104 LEON-MAAL ALEJANDRO 03-26-2019 A-PRE
E02N E02-511L 86389-054 LEVINSON NIKOLAY 12-04-2018 A-PRE
K04N K04-1290 68417-054 LEWIS DEVON 03-11-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMBS 530.07 * ROSTER 08-08-2019
PAGE 010 06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
KO7S K07-004U 86570-054 LITVINTSUK VIKTOR 02-06-2019 A-PRE
IO1N I01-904U 85832-054 LLANES TITO 05-29-2019 A-HLD
GO9S G09-770U 76244-054 LLOYD THOMAS 06-14-2019 A-PRE
E09S E09-570L 79440-054 LOGAN RAMEL 04-01-2019 A-DES
KO7S K07-012L 79246-054 LOMISHVILI GIORGI 07-30-2019 A-HLD
KO8S K08-0150 76291-054 LONDONO OSVALDO 04-16-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-529U 91661-053 LOPEZ ALFRED 06-28-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-929L 86656-054 LOPEZ ANDRE 03-08-2019 A-PRE
KO6N K06-141L 20472-038 LOPEZ CARLOS 01-08-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-008U 51698-054 LOPEZ JOEL 05-16-2019 A-PRE
GO5N G05-739U 86571-054 LOPEZ JOSE 02-06-2019 A-PRE
KO3N K03-118L 90325-053 LOPEZ LOUIS 10-16-2017 A-PRE
E12S E12-591U 15934-014 LOPEZ STEVEN 06-24-2019 A-DES
KO4N K04-132L 70381-054 LOPEZ-HERNANDEZ JACKSON 02-28-2019 A-PRE
KO9S K09-033L 76245-054 LORA JOSE 12-06-2018 A-PRE
GO7S G07-754L 86375-054 LOVELL SHERVINGTO 11-30-2018 A-PRE
ZO4A 204-211LAD 86356-054 LOVICK FUGUAN 11-27-2018 A-HLD
KO5N K05-139L 85841-054 LUCRE BENJAMIN 06-20-2018 A-PRE
GO5N G05-737L 70583-054 LYNCH DANIEL 01-08-2019 A-PRE
GOBS G08-761U 65947-056 MABLE TEVIN 03-26-2019 A-PRE
E05N E05-5400 92123-054 MACCOW ANDY 02-22-2016 FED WRIT
08-05-2019 A-BOP HLD
GO5N G05-7370 86943-054 MACK ALJERMIAH 06-06-2019 A-PRE
E0224 E02-512L 86602-054 MACK MICHAEL 02-14-2019 A-HLD
KlOS K10-043U 86883-054 MAGERRAMOV AMID 05-09-2019 A-PRE
GO3N 003-722L 76185-054 MAGNI FILIPPO 03-11-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-2180 76261-054 MAKSIMOVIC DIANA 07-10-2019 A-PRE
E07S E07-554L 20170-052 MALANGA DANIEL 06-24-2019 A-DES
GlOS G10-774L 72280-054 MALDONADO JONATHAN 05-02-2019 A-HLD
Kl1S K11-0550 86917-054 MALHOTRA GUNJIT 05-23-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-022L 89744-053 MALKEYEV VYACGESLAV 08-10-2018 A-PRE
KO6N K06-142L 86569-054 MANAF HAJI ABDUL 02-06-2019 A-PRE
IO1N I01-905L 64708-007 MANSARAY NABIU 05-16-2018 A-PRE
K08S K08-016L 01558-112 MANSON ERIC 08-31-2018 A-PRE
G10S G10-7800 76003-054 MARAT-UULU BAKAI 03-27-2019 A-HLD
I05N I05-937L 37756-034 MARGOLIES WOLFE 06-24-2019 A-PRE
G03N G03-720L 76178-054 MARQUEZ-ORTIZ JERYLAN 03-28-2019 A-STDY
K08S K08-0140 86351-054 MARRERO JOHNATHON 11-26-2018 A-PRE
GO1N G01-7040 76539-067 MARRERO NORMAN 06-03-2019 A-PRE
E07S E07-5550 11867-087 MARSHALL MICHAEL 07-08-2019 A-DES
I04N I04-931L 90514-054 MARTES JOSE 06-06-2019 A-PRE
GO5N G05-7330 86887-054 MARTIN ANTHONY 05-10-2019 A-PRE
KO1N KO1-1010 25768-050 MARTINEZ ELLIOT 06-25-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-0270 85976-054 MARTINEZ JOSE 08-01-2019 A-HLD
GOBS G08-7600 69055-054 MARTINEZ LENNO 06-25-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
NYMBS 530*07 • ROSTER • 08-08-2019
PAGE 011 06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
IO2N IO2-915L 86111-054 MARTINEZ NOEL 06-10-2019 A-HLD
KO2N K02-111L 27758-050 MARTINEZ RICHARD 07-24-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-927L 76279-054 MARTINEZ-LOPEZ MODESTO 04-03-2019 A-PRE
6075 E07-5530 66171-054 MATTHEWS CHARLES 06-11-2019 A-DES
GllS G11-7820 85716-054 MATUTE EMIL 05-22-2018 A-PRE
KO6N K06-143L 90800-053 MCCLOUD JAMES 05-02-2019 A-PRE
E02N E02-509L 19039-054 MCCOY SAMUEL 02-15-2019 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-064L 86768-054 MCDUFFIE ALBERT 03-28-2019 A-PRE
EI'S 211-584L 71694-050 MCFADDEN DAVID 06-25-2019 A-DES
205A 205-122LDS 85989-054 MCGRIER FREDDIE 04-19-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-928L 66881-050 MCINTYRE BRANDON 07-26-2019 A-PRE
G07S G07-7540 89196-053 MCKAY RASHAWN 05-23-2018 A-PRE
E085 E08-5640 65135-054 MCKINNON JOHN 06-01-2019 A-DES
KO1N K01-1010 69309-054 MCQUEEN ALIE 06-05-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-924L 79339-054 MEDINA WILFRED 01-11-2019 A-HLD
K125 K12-065U 92150-054 MEIGHAN AKBAR 07-03-2019 A-HLD
K03N K03-124L 91114-054 MEJIA-VARGAS MARIO 01-29-2019 A-HLD
KO2N K02-109L 85799-054 MELENDEZ LUIS 08-03-2019 A-PRE
E03N E03-5180 61162-054 MENA-CANCEL JESUS 06-19-2019 A-HLD
GO6N G06-7470 87071-054 MENDEZ-FELIZ MARCO 08-02-2019 A-PRE
E05N E05-540L 84246-054 MENDOZA HECTOR 05-23-2019 A-PRE
504N E04-5320 57916-054 MENDOZA-SOLAN ALEX 07-19-2019 A-PRE
GO6N G06-7480 85606-054 MERCADO GABRIEL 05-30-2018 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-061L 86026-054 MERCHANT SEAN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
El2S E12-5920 89673-053 MERSEY WILLIAM 06-06-2019 A-DES
205A 205-1220AD 86160-054 MICKENS DION 07-16-2019 A-HLD
K115 K11-054L 85771-054 MILLER DARREN 06-27-2019 A-HLD
GO6N G06-742U 79412-054 MILLER RAHIEM 08-17-2017 A-HLD
EO1N E01-504U 79487-054 MINJAREZ SANTOS 05-23-2019 A-HLD
G09S G09-7680 85605-054 MOBLEY COREY 04-24-2018 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-068L 79047-054 MODESTO AMAURY 01-24-2019 A-HLD
K1OS K10-0440 86044-054 MOHAMED MOHAMED 09-24-2018 A-PRE
201A 201-107LAD 91268-054 MOJICA JASON 02-19-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-074L 86024-054 MONASTERIO LUIS 08-30-2018 A-PRE
GO7S G07-7560 19735-104 MONES-CORO VICTOR 06-13-2019 A-PRE
2115 E11-583L 19668-052 MONGO EQUAN 03-19-2019 A-BOP
G10S G10-778U 77708-054 MONSANTO LOPEZ DANIEL 05-23-2019 A-HLD
K06N K06-1480 86272-054 MONTAS HUGO 10-31-2018 A-PRE
G10S G10-7770 86353-054 MONTES BRANDON 06-25-2019 A-HLD
GOSN G05-734L 85982-054 MONTESINO DORFI 08-02-2019 A-PRE
804N E04-529L 63901-054 MOODY ANDREW 01-23-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-042L 79784-054 MOORE DERRICK 10-22-2018 A-HLD
K06N K06-145U 14532-104 MOORE JAMES 06-10-2019 A-HLD
K115 K11-0510 87036-054 MORA ANTONIO 07-19-2019 A-HLD
KO7S K07-002L 86701-054 MORA ARTURO 06-10-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
HLD
NYMB5 530*07
PAGE 012
* ROSTER • 08-08-2019
06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
G126 G12-792U 86384-054 MORA BRYAN 12-03-2018 A-HID
I02N I02-916L 86432-054 MORCILIO RUBEN 12-20-2018 A-HLD
B0lA BO1-209U 91449-053 MOREAU MAGEN 07-11-2019 A-HLD
EOSN E05-536L 87022-054 MUNOZ HECTOR 07-15-2019 A-PRE
G01N G01-702L 85769-054 MURPHY ERNEST 06-06-2018 A-PRE
Z04A Z04-209LAD 57497-054 MURRAY DONNELL 04-11-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-922U 86019-054 MYRIE JERMAINE 08-30-2018 A-PRE
806N E06-544U 86968-054 NAGI BILAL 06-19-2019 A-HLD
612S E12-594L 76311-053 NAGI FIKRI 05-02-2019 A-DES
G07S 007-755L 76172-054 NAJERA-MONTOYA FREDY 03-15-2018 A-PRE
I03N I03-924U 90218-054 NAUT JUAN 06-06-2019 A-HLD
K05N K05-139L 86719-054 NAVEDO CHRISTIAN 03-14-2019 A-PRE
K06N K06-142O 86301-054 NAWAZ AHMED 06-25-2019 A-HLD
601A 801-2190 85954-054 NAZINA IELYZAVETA 03-15-2019 A-HLD
E105 310-575L 79492-054 NEGROPONTE GIANFRANCO 12-11-2018 A-DES
G01N G01-702O 85772-054 NEWTON DEVONTAE 05-17-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06-547O 86923-054 NICHOLAS MALIK 05-30-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06-547L 86340-054 NIEVES IVAN 08-01-2019 A-PRE
601N E01-508O 87066-054 NIFTALIJEV NIKOLAS 08-01-2019 A-PRE
K06N K06-146O 78838-054 NOBLE KASAN 08-07-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-009L 91349-053 NOBOA MARIO 12-20-2018 A-PRE
K12S K12-069L 86407-054 NORRIS SABED 12-12-2018 A-PRE
G076 G07-752O 85738-054 NORVILLE DWAYNE 05-30-2018 A-HLD
E10S E10-575O 68111-054 NUNEZ FRANKLIN 06-25-2019 A-DES
K02N K02-112L 70164-054 NUNEZ JOSE 06-10-2019 A-HLD
K096 K09-033O 78025-053 NUNEZ STARLIN 03-26-2019 A-HLD
G02N G02-715L 76194-054 OCAMPO-ALVAREZ RUBEN 04-20-2019 A-PRE
K086 K08-020L 86074-054 OCHOA OVIDIO 06-06-2019 A-PRE
Z04A Z04-206UAD 86452-054 OCHOA PERCY 01-02-2019 A-PRE
G0SN G05-738O 85780-054 OGARRO TYREEK 05-17-2019 A-HLD
G05N G05-735O 72661-054 OJEDA CALVIN 05-31-2018 A-HLD
KO4N K04-128L 91980-054 OLANGIAN REZA 01-25-2019 A-HLD
B0lA 601-215L 75936-054 OLIVERA JUDIE 06-28-2019 A-HLD
K086 K08-021L 76249-054 OROZCO JOSE 07-17-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-925U 19732-104 ORSINI-QUINTERO MICHOLS 04-09-2019 A-PRE
K106 K10-039L 85805-054 ORTIZ ERVIN 06-13-2018 A-PRE
K04N K04-126O 65410-054 ORTIZ LUIS 08-31-2018 FED WRIT
07-30-2019 A-HLD
G06N G06-743O 85875-054 OUTLAW KEITH 06-27-2018 A-HLD
G116 G11-781L 79551-054 OWEN WALSTON 11-13-2017 A-PRE
G06N G06-745L 79415-054 OWENS DOUGLAS 08-17-2017 A-HLD
0075 G07-752L 74125-053 PAGETT LARRY 10-05-2018 A-HLD
Z04A Z04-208LAD 79166-054 PALERMO HECTOR 11-20-2018 A-HLD
El0S E10-576O 76364-066 PARA ROBERT 06-10-2019 A-DES
G06N G06-747L 70497-050 PECORELLA ALAN 06-25-2019 A-STDY
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMB5 530.07
PAGE 013
* ROSTER 08-08-2019
06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC. REG LN FN ARSD ARS
K11S K11-051U 13717-041 PEJIC VEDRAN 03-06-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-031L 90649-054 PENA EDWARD 11-27-2018 A-PRE
010S G10-776L 85977-054 PENA ROBERT 07-26-2018 A-PRE
K06N K06-147U 86222-054 PERALTA ORLANDO 02-25-2019 A-HLD
E02N E02-514L 85435-054 PEREZ BILLY 03-08-2018 A-HLD
ZO4A Z04-205LAD 78346-054 PEREZ CHRISTIAN 05-24-2018 A-HLD
KO4N K04-132U 91200-053 PEREZ SANCHEZ HUGO 10-26-2018 A-PRE
GO3N 003-723U 90898-053 PEREZ-SANCHEZ OVIDIO 06-15-2018 A-PRE
BO1A B01-216L 86709-054 PERKINS GERALDINE 08-02-2019 A-HLD
ZO6A 206-219UAD 14949-057 PIERCE RICHARD 08-25-2015 A-DES
GOBS G08-758L 76193-054 PINEDA-OTALVARO JOSE 06-27-2018 A-PRE
I06N I06-944L 18346-037 PINKNEY ANTHONY 08-07-2019 A-HLD
E03N E03-523L 86435-054 PIRINS IGORS 12-21-2018 A-PRE
E02N E02-513L 78702-054 POLANCO JASON 04-20-2018 A-HLD
KO8S K08-021U 86369-054 POLANCO SERGIO 03-24-2019 A-HLD
GOBS 008-761L 58001-054 POLK TERRELL 02-06-2017 A-HLD
EOBS E08-560L 62541-050 POWELL BARRY 05-29-2018 A-DES
I06N I06-947L 85484-054 POWELL MARIO 03-24-2018 A-PRE
KO8S K08-014L 76149-054 PRICE GREGORY 04-17-2018 A-PRE
GO2N G02-712L 92418-054 PROFIT TRAVIS 11-15-2018 A-HLD
KO5N K05-133L 71538-019 PULIDO-LOPEZ MARIO 04-10-2018 A-PRE
202A 202-204LAD 86210-054 QUIROGA FRANK 07-08-2019 A-PRE
E1OS E10-578L 78023-053 RAGHUNATH I SHWARDAT 08-05-2019 A-DES
GO2N 002-709L 86608-054 RAGONESE RYAN 02-21-2019 A-PRE
KO6N K06-142U 91752-053 RAI GURSIMARDE 07-09-2019 A-PRE
K075 K07-008U 89329-053 RAKHMATOR AZIZJON 05-20-2016 A-PRE
010S 010-774U 86879-054 RAMIREZ ADONIS 05-02-2019 A-HLD
E085 E08-562L 81219-054 RAMIREZ EDGARDO 07-15-2019 A-DES
IO2N IO2-914U 79252-054 RAMIREZ MIGUEL 10-24-2018 A-HLD
G12S 012-795U 86958-054 RAMIREZ RAMON 06-13-2019 A-PRE
GO7S 007-756L 86551-054 RAMIREZ RONNY 07-31-2019 A-HLD
E03N E01-521L 90860-053 RAMIREZ SAUDI 01-25-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-913U 86827-054 RAMIREZ YISANDER 04-18-2019 A-PRE
BOLA B01-212L 68610-054 RAMIREZ ZORAIDA 10-22-2018 A-HLD
K11S K11-059L 55278-054 RAMOS DANIEL 05-29-2019 A-HLD
IO1N I01-907L 78693-054 RAMOS DOMINGO 04-01-2019 A-HLD
KO5N K05-1360 90137-053 RAMOS FRANCISCO 07-17-2017 A-PRE
HO1A H01-001L 85428-054 RAMOS JASON 04-26-2019 A-HLD
E05N 505-535U 90880-053 RAPHAEL KEVIN 06-08-2018 A-PRE
1(125 K12-070L 75971-112 RAZUMOVSKIY ALEKSANDR 06-26-2019 A-HLD
201A 201-107LAD 85609-054 REID MICHAEL 07-03-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-926L 86623-054 REINALDO ROMAN 02-27-2019 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-078U 86022-054 REINGOUD MURVIN 08-30-2018 A-PRE
ZO2A Z02-203LAD 08200-070 RENE CHRISTOPHE 05-29-2018 A-DES
GO2N 002-713L 86526-054 REYES ANGEL 05-10-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMBS 530*07 * ROSTER
PAGE 014
08-08-2019
06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG  LN FN ARSD ARS
Z06A 206-2200AD 85993-054 REYES EFRAIN 08-01-2018 A-PRE
205A Z05-118LDS 79102-054 REYES FRANKIE 05-17-2017 A-PRE
K07S K07-OO1U 86319-054 REYES-BONILLA JUAN 07-15-2019 A-PRE
IO2N IO2-914U 61643-054 REYES-VAZQUEZ RAUL 07-17-2019 A-HLD
801A B01-203L 89522-053 RICHARDSON CAROLYN 06-04-2019 A-HLD
007S G07-7530 85735-054 RICHARDSON DAVID 06-25-2019 A-HLD
G03N 003-718L 69781-479 RINCON-VEGA MARIO 05-24-2019 A-PRE
GO3N 003-717U 76284-054 RIOS JESUS O4-11-2019 A-PRE
GO3N G03-717L 92336-054 RIVER-MARADIAGA DEVIS 02-20-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-920L 91104-054 RIVERA JESSE 09-28-2017 A-HLD
206A Z06-218LAD 72008-054 RIVERA JOSE 05-08-2019 A-DES
206A Z06-218LAD 86225-054 RIVERA JOSE 10-18-2018 A-PRE
G08S 008-764U 86815-054 RIVERA JUSTIN 04-11-2019 A-HLD
KO9S K09-0260 86848-054 RIVERA LOUIS O4-24-2019 A-HLD
K11S K11-0550 06303-082 RIVERA LUIS 06-05-2019 A-HLD
K088 K08-019U 79752-054 RIVERO RICARDO 07-09-2019 A-PRE
E12S E12-596U 05247-015 ROANE
E128 E12-5940 12558-036 ROBERSON \ TYRONE
CHARLES
08-05-2019
07-08-2019
A-DES
A-DES
BO1A B01-201L 86411-054 ROBERTS ADRIENNE 07-05-2019 A-PRE
K125 K12-0720 86791-054 ROBERTS DAEQUAN 05-16-2019 A-HLD
E06N E06-541U 85846-054 ROBERTS PARIS 06-20-2018 A-PRE
ZO4A Z04-212LAD 34801-058 ROBINSON PHILLIP 06-06-2019 A-HLD
K07S K07-003U 85773-054 ROBINSON TYQUAN 04-18-2019 A-HLD
205A Z05-120LAD 76328-054 ROBLES VICENTE 08-07-2019 A-PRE
101N I01-902U 78258-112 RODDUBNOV SALMAN 07-02-2019 A-HLD
E04N E04-525L 86831-054 RODRIGUEZ ADONIS O4-18-2019 A-PRE
ZO6A Z06-215LAD 91278-054 RODRIGUEZ DANIEL 06-12-2019 A-PRE
Gl2S G12-796L 29216-050 RODRIGUEZ HENRY 04-05-2019 A-HLD
204A Z04-2080A0 79168-054 RODRIGUEZ JUAN 01-24-2019 A-HLD
G118 G11-7810 86224-054 RODRIGUEZ MALI 03-18-2019 A-HLD
E07S E07-550L 04883-104 RODRIGUEZ MANUEL 06-03-2019 A-DES
GO3N G03-7200 85737-054 RODRIGUEZ RICARDO 08-02-2019 A-PRE
I04N I04-932U 86117-054 ROJAS ADAN 09-13-2018 A-PRE
E03N E03-521U 76160-054 ROJAS-ROMERO EMILIO 04-26-2018 A-PRE
012S G12-791L 85670-054 ROLON EDWIN 05-30-2019 A-HLD
ZOlA ZO1-107UAD 74203-054 ROMERO MIGUEL 12-09-2015 A-PRE
I03N I03-923U 78841-054 ROMERO RAFAEL 11-19-2018 A-HLD
K09S K09-0360 76223-054 ROMERO YEURY 05-23-2019 A-HLD
K10S K10-0450 85927-054 ROMERO-GRANADOS JUAN 07-12-2018 A-PRE
E03N E03-524L 86840-054 RONDAN CARLOS O4-23-2019 A-PRE
I06N I06-943U 86025-054 ROOPWAH MOSES 08-30-2018 A-PRE
IO1N I01-904L 77980-054 ROPER COREY 12-10-2018 A-HLD
203A Z03-111UAD 86324-054 ROSA RICKY 11-14-2018 A-PRE
E01N E01-5030 86169-054 ROSARIO JOELKIN 10-03-2018 A-PRE
KO3N K03-1240 26488-038 ROSARIO OSCAR 02-27-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
NYMBS 530.07 •
PAGE 015
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG
E11S E11-587L 58588-037
E11S E11-584U 06084-082
G02N G02-7130 85778-054
E05N E05-5360 76220-054
G03N G03-724L 28408-054
K11S K11-0490 87034-054
K11S K11-0770 77749-054
BO1A BO1-2120 34249-045
I01N I01-902U 87009-054
K12S K12-069L 70704-054
BO1A B01-208L 89767-053
K09S K09-030L 76005-054
207B 207-303LAD 79715-054
K04N K04-125L 86530-054
I04N I04-930L 49953-018
G03N G03-7210 07687-036
K08S K08-020U 85571-054
ZOJA 201-1050AD 76327-054
BO1A B01-213L 56234-054
K11S K11-0530 76122-054
I05N I05-937U 85759-054
G05N G05-7340 85756-054
Kl2S K12-067L 86027-054
K09S K09-0280 48816-066
K09S K09-0290 77575-054
GOBS G08-7570 86352-054
ZO1A 201-102LAD 08224-082
ZO1A 201-105LAD 80341-083
K11S K11-0540 79699-054
E10S E10-576L 99462-038
E01N E01-5050 85816-054
206A 206-213LAD 86638-054
K07S K07-001L 01735-007
KOSN K05-134L 78531-054
202A 202-203LAD 08765-094
G02N G02-711U 17781-104
K07S K07-009L 53413-083
Gl2S G12-794L 17437-104
2078 207-305LAD 79471-054
G06N G06-741U 76292-054
G05N G05-736L 83721-053
EOIN E01-508L 08379-068
KOSN K05-140L 53267-054
KOSN K05-136L 86277-054
E04N E04-5260 71996-054
ROSTER
LN
ROSS
ROSS
ROYSTER
RUGARD
RUIZ
RUSSELL
RUSSO
RYAN
SAAB
SAADIA
SAFANI
SAINZ-FLORES
SAIPOV
SALAHUDDIN
SALAS TORRES
SALDANA
SALEH
SALGADO-BRECEDA
SANCHEZ
SANCHEZ
SANCHEZ
SANDERS
SANDS
SANTANA
SANTANA
SANTIAGO
SANTIAGO
SANTIAGO-MENDOZA
SANTOS
SANTOS
SANTOS
SANTOS-FELIX
SATTAN
SAUNDERS
SAXON
SAYOC
SCALES
SCHIFANO
SCHULTE
SEARLES
SEGUI
SEIBER
SELLERS
SEMIDAY
SEPULVEDA
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . .
FN
DEVIN
MICHAEL
KELLY
RUBEN
RENAN
TSANI
ROBERT
SONIA
ALI
MOISE
HAWWA
JULIO
SAYFULLO
KHALIL
FERNEY
YEISON
REDHWAN
LUIS
AURORA
FRANCISCO
RAY
REGINALD
REUBEN
JOSE
JOSE
JONATHAN
LEON
OMAR
AOUL
ELLIS
JOSE
CRISTOPHER
HAROLD
CRAIG
JOSEPH
CESAR
SYDNEY
VINCENT
JOSHUA
JARED
FRANK
RONALD
DOUGLAS
LUIS
ANGEL
• 08-08-2019
06:28:35
ARSD  ARS
09-12-2018 A-DES
04-15-2019 A-DES
05-29-2019 A-HLD
06-30-2019 A-HLD
10-30-2017 A-HLD
07-18-2019 A-HLD
08-05-2019 A-HLD
08-01-2019 A-HLD
07-10-2019 A-PRE
07-11-2019 A-PRE
03-22-2019 A-PRE
06-08-2017 A-PRE
11-01-2017 A-PRE
01-23-2019 A-PRE
02-07-2019
04-19-2019
07-03-2019
08-07-2019
04-25-2019
07-31-2019
04-01-2019
06-05-2018
08-30-2018
02-27-2019
07-31-2019
11-26-2018
05-07-2019
04-09-2019
10-27-2017
07-22-2019
05-08-2019
03-04-2019
11-02-2018
07-24-2019
03-18-2019
03-26-2019
02-21-2019 A-PRE
07-18-2019 A-HLD
05-02-2019 A-PRE
07-31-2019 A-PRE
02-25-2019 A-PRE
04-19-2019 A-HLD
06-04-2018 A-PRE
11-01-2018 A-PRE
07-23-2018 A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-PRE
A-DES
A-PRE
A-DES
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-HLD
A-PRE
A-DES
A-HLD
NYMBS 530*07
PAGE 016
* ROSTER * 08-08-2019
06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
K10S K10-046O 86819-054 SERRANO JOE 04-16-2019 A-PRE
G09S G09-771L 86960-054 SHARPERSON LEROY 06-13-2019 A-HLD
2073 E07-553L 24263-052 SHOWERS RONALD 04-29-2019 A-DES
B01A B01-217O 85797-053 SIDDIQUI ASIA 07-11-2019 A-PRE
I05N I05-933O 19494-104 SIMON JAMAL 02-12-2019 A-PRE
Gl2S G12-790U 72229-054 SISNERO-GIL MARLON 04-12-2019 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-068O 86891-054 SMALLS LEON 05-10-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-920U 90311-053 SMART SHAUN 12-21-2017 A-PRE
203A Z03-115LAD 78175-054 SMITH BRANDON 06-03-2019 A-DES
K07S K07-007O 76322-054 SMITH DAVID 07-12-2019 A-PRE
E04N E04-531O 85833-054 SMITH SHASHIEME 06-20-2018 A-PRE
E11S E11-586O 90517-053 SOBERS BRENT 03-11-2019 A-DES
I05N I05-938O 85408-054 SOSA PEDRO 04-30-2019 A-HLD
I03N I03-923L 86516-054 SOSA-DIAZ HENYEL 02-19-2019 A-PRE
K02N K02-110O 86909-054 SOSA-ORTIZ NESTOR 05-20-2019 A-PRE
K02N K02-114L 26142-038 SOTO LUIS 06-30-2019 A-HLD
B01A B01-207O 86961-054 SPINELLI DOREEN 06-17-2019 A-HLD
G02N G02-710L 69065-054 SPRULL MATTHEW 03-06-2019 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-063L 86616-054 STEVEN WILLIAM 03-05-2019 A-HLD
I06N I06-948L 91161-053 STUART JOSHUA 05-06-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-013O 86023-054 SUCRE NERIDIO 08-30-2018 A-PRE
G0SN 005-7350 85781-054 SUMPTER TYRELL 06-06-2018 A-HLD
E02N E02-516O 85991-054 SUVERIN MAXIM 07-31-2018 A-PRE
G0514 1305-733L 79662-054 TABAR HALLIL 07-25-2019 A-HLD
KIAS K11-052L 11714-052 TABOADA RICARDO 02-07-2019 A-PRE
206A 206-215OAD 78514-054 TARTAGLIONE NICHOLAS 03-19-2019 A-PRE
E03N 203-517L 73974-112 TAVARES ALEX 08-10-2018 A-HLD
803N E03-517O 86553-054 TAVARES-BRITO YIRAN 01-30-2019 A-PRE
E05N E05-538O 86995-054 TAVAREZ-MOTA DORLYN 07-03-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-007O 30772-069 TAVERAS JAIRO 07-18-2019 A-HLD
K01N KO1-101O 09521-054 TAYLOR CLIFFORD 05-22-2019 A-HLD
502N E02-510L 91183-054 TAYLOR DAVID 12-06-2018 A-PRE
K11S K11-051O 86934-054 TAYLOR NATHANIEL 06-25-2019 A-HLD
I04N I04-927O 91251-054 TEJADA JOEL 06-17-2019 A-PRE
K01N K01-102O 56772-054 THERIAULT MICHAEL 04-12-2019 A-PRE
El0S E10-580L 79823-054 THOMAS DAVID 12-10-2018 A-DES
K01N K01-103L 66151-054 THOMAS GLENN 08-22-2014 A-HLD
KU'S K10-044L 79965-054 THOMAS JASON 02-06-2019 A-HLD
G01N G01-704L 79310-054 THOMAS LARRY 07-12-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-074O 79652-054 THOMAS WILLIAM 02-07-2019 A-HLD
G01N G01-708O 86307-054 THOMPSON DAQUON 07-31-2019 A-PRE
G06N G06-744L 16725-028 THOMPSON JAHEED 07-18-2019 A-HLD
K08S K08-015L 86107-054 TIURIN ANDREI 09-07-2018 A-PRE
K01W K01-105O 86179-054 TOLENTINO DOMINGO 10-09-2018 A-PRE
G02N G02-712O 86367-054 TOMLINSON JOWAYNE 07-22-2019 A-PRE
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
NYMB5 530.07
PAGE 017
* ROSTER 08-08-2019
06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
E04N E04-528U 85608-054 TOPPIN MICHAEL 05-21-2019 A-HLD
E07S E07-549L 85382-054 TORO TYLER 07-29-2019 A-DES
K02N K02-115L 14103-052 TORRES ANTHONY 07-10-2019 A-HLD
E09S E09-5660 85621-054 TORRES FAUSTO 05-06-2019 A-DES
E06N E06-5410 86521-054 TORRES JOSHUA 04-24-2019 A-HLD
G06N G06-744L 34957-054 TORRES MARTIN 10-13-2018 A-PRE
203A Z03-110LAD 86020-054 TORRES OMAR 08-30-2018 A-PRE
G10S G10-780L 85742-054 TOWNSEND DOUGLAS 05-31-2018 A-PRE
K11S K11-060L 79847-054 TOWNZEN PATRICK 08-05-2019 A-PRE
E095 E09-572U 76518-067 TURNER CLAUDE 07-22-2019 A-DES
I06N I06-945L 25352-083 TURNER WILBERT 07-26-2019 A-PRE
G01N G01-701L 79827-054 ULLAH AKAYED 11-07-2018 A-HLD
E05N E05-5330 28631-054 URENA ILARIO 04-06-2019 A-HLD
K09S K09-075L 68339-054 URENA JUAN 05-23-2019 A-HLD
K04N K04-125L 76277-054 URENA RICHARD 04-03-2019 A-PRE
I02N I02-911L 65709-054 VALAZQUEZ SAMMY 02-27-2019 A-PRE
K08S K08-024L 24772-057 VALENZUELA-LIZARRAGA RAMON 12-20-2017 A-HLD
K07S K07-003U 77662-054 VALERIO DAVID 07-23-2019 A-HOP
I05N I05-938U 79919-054 VAN MANEN PAUL 01-17-2018 A-PRE
I06N I06-943U 86408-054 VANIER CARLTON 12-12-2018 A-PRE
K10S K10-0390 29381-050 VARGAS DAVID 08-02-2019 A-HLD
E05N E05-538L 86880-054 VARGAS JOSE 05-06-2019 A-HLD
BO1A B01-207L 87056-054 VASQUEZ ANAMARIA 07-31-2019 A-PRE
ZOSA 205-119LAD 76290-054 VASQUEZ PERCY 04-16-2019 A-PRE
Z06A 206-215LAD 79099-054 VEGA OVED 05-17-2017 A-PRE
I03N I03-919U 76242-054 VEISYON EDWARD 06-28-2019 A-PRE
GllS G11-7840 79831-054 VENTURA CHARLES 08-06-2018 A-PRE
BO1A B01-2140 86297-054 VENTURA MINERVA 07-19-2019 A-STDY
E05N E05-534L 86285-054 VICIOSO-LIMA PEDRO 11-08-2018 A-PRE
I05N I05-936U 85992-054 VICKERS NAZEER 04-08-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-0320 30982-054 VIERRA MARK 11-08-2018 A-PRE
I04N I04-926U 85922-054 VILLANUEVA MICHAEL 05-10-2019 A-PRE
KOSN K05-135U 58614-054 VIZZARI GINO 07-11-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-2200 23003-021 VO KIM ANH 06-27-2019 A-HLD
K125 K12-0710 86882-054 VORONJUK VITALI 05-09-2019 A-PRE
G06N G06-746U 68342-054 WAGNER MYRON 01-11-2019 A-PRE
K05N K05-138L 86480-054 WAITERS MARK 01-09-2019 A—PRE
E05/s7 E06-546L 86900-054 WALKER ALLEN 07-12-2019 A—PRE
K04N K04-127L 02259-748 WALKER DELROY 06-25-2019 A-HLD
GllS G11-788L 85544-054 WALSH PATRICK 01-14-2019 A-HLD
GllS G11-786L 86336-054 WALTER FAHEEM 04-08-2019 A-PRE
K10S K10-0480 77269-112 WANG SHUAIQUI 12-18-2018 A-PRE
E11S E11-5870 63274-037 WARE CRAIG 11-26-2018 A-DES
K06N K06-146L 81078-053 WASHINGTON MAURICE 02-25-2019 A-PRE
Z04A Z04-211UAD 77510-054 WASHINGTON VAUGHN 06-03-2019 A-HLD
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
HLD
NYMBS 530*07 * ROSTER * 08-08-2019
PAGE 018 OF 018 06:28:35
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN ARSD  ARS
K08S K08-017U 76135-054 WATKINS THOMAS 02-14-2018 A-PRE
I03N I03-919L 92373-054 NATTIER MICHAEL 03-29-2016 A-HLD
K125 K12-078L 85377-054 WEBER JEFFREY 05-29-2019 A-HLD
E04N E04-531L 57969-054 WESTON BOBBY 07-01-2019 A-PRE
K07S K07-010U 56622-056 WHITAKER TYRELL 08-22-2014 A-HLD
ZO1A 201-103LAD 85644-054 WHITE KHALIF 05-02-2019 A-DES
K115 K11-049U 76273-054 WHITE LARRY 03-21-2019 A-HLD
G02N G02-709U 87072-054 WILLIAMS ANDRE 08-02-2019 A-HLD
206A Z06-217LAD 78640-054 WILLIAMS DAYVON 06-19-2019 A-PRE
I03N I03-917U 85310-054 WILLIAMS JAMES 07-10-2019 A-PRE
006N G06-746L 79417-054 WILLIAMS JIHAD 08-17-2017 A-HLD
Kl2S K12-071U 68283-054 WILLIAMS KARLIEK 07-31-2019 A-PRE
005N G05-738L 86162-054 WILLIAMS SHARIEF 03-26-2019 A-HLD
G05N G05-739L 79954-054 WILLIAMS SHAWN 01-25-2018 A-HLD
E085 E08-557U 09310-041 WILLIAMS TIMOTHY 04-30-2019 A-DES
K04N K04-132U 87008-054 WILLIAMS TONY 07-09-2019 A-HLD
K05N K05-136U 75973-054 WILLIS SHANNON 03-14-2019 A-HLD
G07S G07-749L 86239-054 WILSON LEROY 05-07-2019 A-PRE
E06N 506-548U 69068-054 WILSON SHAWN 05-16-2019 A-HLD
KO1N K01-106L 57610-018 WOLF LEONARD 04-04-2016 A-HLD
203A 203-113UAD 76232-054 HONEY ISHI 04-15-2019 A-PRE
K09S K09-029U 86315-054 WONG ZXIYU 11-14-2018 A-PRE
K115 K11-053L 85369-054 WOOLASTON TYRONE 02-21-2019 A-PRE
GO1N G01-707L 76248-054 WRIGHT CIMMIE 12-12-2018 A-PRE
K10S K10-037U 86477-054 WU HUALONG 01-09-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06-546U 86858-054 XIA XIU 05-21-2019 A-PRE
G125 012-789L 77167-112 YANG BINGQIN 12-04-2018 A-PRE
G07S 007-750L 86428-054 YOUNG AARON 12-19-2018 A-PRE
G07S 007-751U 86868-054 YOUNG ANTHONY 04-30-2019 A-HLD
G09S G09-765L 86373-054 ZAPATA-COSTRO ARGEMIRO 11-30-2018 A-PRE
Kl2S K12-066U 86925-054 ZAPOLSKIJ VLADISLAV 05-31-2019 A-PRE
E06N E06-544L 86718-054 ZELAYA EDUARDO 03-14-2019 A-HLD
Kl1S K11-060L 86331-054 ZHOU LEI 04-19-2019 A-PRE
BO1A B01-220L 86475-054 ZHUANG LIQING 07-02-2019 A-PRE
K05N K05-134U 83742-053 ZOTTOLA ANTHONY 06-26-2019 A-PRE
G02N 002-714L 64662-053 ZUBIATE MIGUEL 02-15-2019 A-HLD
00000 TRANSACTION SUCCESSFULLY COMPLETED
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
MCC NEW YORK
150 PARK ROW, NEW YORK, NY, 10007
TRANSFER RECEIPT DATE: August 8, 2019
RECEIVED FROM L. N'DIAYE, WARDEN, MCC NEW YORK, 150 PARK ROW, NEW YORK, NY 10007. THE
FOLLOWING UNITED STATES PRISONERS, TOGETHER WITH COMPLETE FILES FOR TRANSFER AS
INDICATED: ALLENWOOD LOW FCI
REG.NO. NAME QTR DST RELEASE STATUS
14949-057 PIERCE, RICHARD Z06 ALF TRANSFER
TOTAL: 01
*** ALL 64's MED's & PAPERWORK ACCOUNTED FOR
••• ALL PD 15's CHRONO & PENDING CHECKED BY:
Lost Mae
PIERCE
fit. •tee
RICHARD
Kiddie Nam Dut tin
*tight
5'08"
Weir
BLACK
sego*
14949-05 7
'tint
190
BROWN
vacuity
NYN
"MI FBOP-MCC/NY STAFF 4*.#
MCC NEW YORK MOVEMENT OFFICER 646-836.6300 EXT 6321
se-mn91
JUIR, 10
RELEASE  AUTHORIZATIO NU.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
Release Date
08-08-2019 0 9:00 AM
Custody Will Be Taken by: N/A
CDFR61 a /
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PR/EO
CERTIFICATION: I certify that this release is in accordance with applicable and controlling rules, regulations and 
statutory provisions. If this is a final
release, it is based on a final release audit of the sentence computation provided by the Designation and Sentence 
Computation Center. I have personally
reviewed all Judgment and Commitment Orders, U.S. Parole Commission Warrants, Notice of Actions, and detainer 
information, and there is no information which
would preclude the release of this inmate.
Name/Title

W. SMITH/ SCSS
Thumborint
3' Winchell Mountain Road
Blerton, NY 12546
Date
ve received the above named prisoner, together with personal property and funds in the amount
RECEIPT OF AGENT TARING CUSTODY
3/Title Signature Date
ation
A Copy - Receiving a Discharge File in Judgment a Commitment File; Copy - Case Management, Central Fil(
:ion 5); Copy - Control Room; Copy - Hospital; Copy - Transporting Officer
Replaces 82-392(58) dtd HAY 9 Prescribed by P5800
BP-A0392
JUNE 10
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
RELEASE AUTHORIZATION COMM
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
Inmate Name
LOGAN, PANEL
Register No.
79440-054
Institution
MCC NEW YORK, NY
Date
08-05-2019
Release Date
08-08-2019 8 9:00 AM
Method
GCT REL
Detainer:
•
Yes
No
Custody Will Be Taken by: N/A
CERTIFICATION: I certify that this release is in accordance with applicable and controlling
rules, regulations and statutory provisions. If this is a final release, it is based on
a final release audit of the sentence computation provided by the Designation and Sentence
Computation Center. I have personally reviewed all Judgment and Commitment Orders, V.S.
Parole Commission Warrants, Notice of Actions, and detainer information, and there is no
information which would preclude the release of this inmate.
Name/Title
W. SMITH/ SCSS
608 Warburton Avenue, #25
Yonkers, NY 10701
04414019 LagNme
LOGAN Ffrai MM.
RAMEL SOU
^.5'11" wk 150
BLK eY BRO
Re'79440-054 NYM nemeN men.
RELEASE ACTION
ified Released by:
Funds Paid Date of Release: Time` Bp:lease:
i of
(VS-4n\ RECEIPT OP AGENT TAXING CUSTODY
I have received the above named prisoner, together with personal property and funds in the amount
of S
Name/Title I Signature Date
Location
Record Copy - Receiving a Discharge File in Judgment & Commitment File; Copy - Case Management, Central File
(Section 5); Copy - Control Room; Copy - Hospital; Copy - Transporting Officer
PDF Prescribed by P5800 Replaces BP-392(503) dtd MAY 94
YES/NO MEDS
PRISONER REMAND
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
/
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
ARRESTING OFFICER WILL COMPLETE ALL REQUIRED
DATA ON THIS FORM PRIOR TO COMMITTING TO
MCG/MCCS.
Name: Last
AKAs:
Race
B W A I
(Check) Sex
M
(Check)
F
Ethnic Origin
Hispanic or
CHARGES
CHECK CATEGORY OF CHARGES($) :
FELONY
OTHER
NARRATIVE:
Title: USC:
NARRATIVET --
Title: USC:
MISDEMEANOR
Middle
(Check)
Other
D.O.B.  SSN: FBI:
INS:
Other:
CIVIL CONTEMPT MATERIAL WITNESS
Date of Offense:  Date of Arrest:  Place of Arrest:
State of Birth Country of Birth Citizenship Current Address - I Zip Code
Height
Ft: In:
Weight Hair Eyes Scars / Marks / Tattoos
Injuries / Medication Emergency Contact: (Name,
Number)
Address, Phone
Arraigned I Sentenced Special Handling:
Remarks:
.1 or __N
Remanding Official (Name)
Sign
Print
Remov n• Official (Name)
Sign,
Print
Receivild)OAficial (Name)
Sign
Priril
Sentry Load data: (Must Initial)
Name Search ompleted by:
Clearance/Separate Checked by:
Agency/District
Agency/District
)."
Phone/24 Hour Number
Phone/24 Hour Number
-”-Official (Name) Time
(OPTIONAL U.' .
ARS Code it Staff I:, .
Add AKA'e----' At Create Cash t
Deposit Cash Amt.
Detainers
Court
Clothing Bag V
RIGHT THUMBPRINT
/ /).t3,\s-\
Original -for ISM as Remanding -Removal receipt; Copy-for Control as Removal Receipt (NCIC); Copy-For
Removing Official; Copy-for Control as Remanding Receipt (Inmate); Copy-INS-Alien in Custody.
(This form may be replicated via WP) This form replaces BP-S377(58) and BP-377(58) of JUL 91
OSIIICCAI ••••
AeMMGZ
530.07
•
AGE
003
ROSTER
•
08-07-2019 20:00:59
P.
SPECIFIC.
.
REG

LN

FN

CMC

QTR

CALT
C
COURT
SDNY
68430-054
JAQUEZ
CARLOS
I05
-940U
07:30
C
COURT
SDNY
77737-112
IGNATOV
KONSTANTIN
SEPARATION
K07
-073U
07:30
4
G0002
MORE
PAGES
TO
FOLLOW
.
.
.
BF-n, PRISONER REMAND CL'I1
)4
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
ARRESTING OFFICER WILL COMPLETE ALL REQUIRED
DATA ON THIS FORM PRIOR TO COMMITTING TO
MCC/MDCs.
Name: Last First
AKAs:
Race (Check)
B W A I
Sex (Check)
M F
Ethnic Origin
FEDERAL BUREAU OF DRTAAMP ,--------
Last nail
CAMACHO
Sisst Naga
FERDINAND
)116:11 NW !dila
most Weight
5,07" 180
Nafr
BALD
Mlle 79355-054
Hispanic or _Ot
CHARGES
CHECK CATEGORY OF CHARGES(S):
FELONY
OTHER
NARRATIVE:
Title: USC:
NARRATIVET --
Title: USC:
MISDEMEANOR CIVIL CONTEMPT
ty.
BLUE
facility
NYM
MATERIAL WITNESS
Date of Offense:  Date of Arrest:  Place of Arrest:
State of Birth Country of Birth Citizenship Current Address Zip Code
Height
Ft: In:
Weight Hair Eyes Scars / Marks / Tattoos
Injuries / Medication Emergency Contact:(Name,
Number)
Address, Phone
Arraigned
Y N
Sentenced
Y N
Special Handling: Y or
Remarks:
-:yvflrziw4Ag
Remanding Official (Name)
Sign
Print
Removing Official (Name)
T.-- Sign
FOR SOP USE ONLY
.104T40 ,414A/IN14,
Phone/24 Hour Number
Phone/24 Hour Number
Receiving Official (Name)
Sign
Print
Date / Time Releasing Official (Name)
Sign
Print
Date / Time
Sentry Load Data: (Must Initial)
Name Search Completed by:
Clearance/Separate Checked by:
(OPTIONAL USE)
ARS Code Staff Init.
Add AKA's
Create Cash Account
Deposit Cash Amt.
Detainers
Court
Clothing Bag 4
Original -for ISM as Remanding -Removal receipt; Copy-for Control as Removal Receipt (NCIC); Copy-For
Removing Official; Copy-for Control as Remanding Receipt (Inmate); .Copy-INS-Alien in Custody.
(This.form may be replicated via WP) This form.replaces BP-S377(58) and BP-377(58) of JUL 91
PRISONER REMAND CUM FEB
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
FIr4t Name4e-Last
I t-
AKAs:
Race (Check)
W A I
Sex (Check)
4i1 F
Ethnic Origin
Hispanic or 2
CHARGES
CHECK CATEGORY OF CHARGES(S) : FELONY
OTHER
NARRATIVE:
Title: USC:
NARRATIVE7--
Title: USC: I ST P Ath eu ) s P7 A ty tit/ mew--7 Date of Offense:  Date of Arrest: / Plac4 of Arrest:
MISDEMEANOR
Ou-r-
FEDERAL BUREAU  OF PRISONS
024i400
SCALES Fxyliwre
SYDNEY Oa"
5' 7" - 217
- BLK BRO
me-53413-083 NYM WISW OCWA
DTILCIGOZ
State of Birth
/kite -
Country of Birth Citizenship Current Address - Zip Code
Height
Ft: In:
Weight Hair Eyes Scars / Marks / Tattoos
Injuries / Medication Emergency Contact:(Name, Address, Phone Number)
Arraigned
Y N
Sentenced
Y N
Special Handling: Y or Remarks:
.Remanding Official (Name) Sign
Print
Phone/24 Hour Number Agency/District
Removing Official m 7 Sign
)4:Print
qAgency/District Phone/24 Hour Number
Receiving Official (Name) Date / Time Releasing Official (Name) Date / Time Sign Sign)
Print Prinl___Aukev„ ark.A. ttqj - Sentry Load Data: (Must Initial) (OPTIONAI/SE) RIGHT THUMBPRINT Name Search Completed
by: ARS Code /; ( Staff Init. Add AKA's
Clearance/Separate Checked by: Create Cash Account
Deposit Cash Amt. Detainers
Court
Clothing Bag 4
%.4Original -for ISM as Remanding -Removal receipt; Copy-for Control as Removal Receipt (NCIC): ;Copy -For Removing 
Official; Copy-for Control as Remanding
Receipt (Inmate); Copy-INS-Alien in Custody.
(This form may be replicated via WP) ' This form replaces BT-S3,1(58) and BP-377(58) of JUL 91
PRISONER REMAND )ct U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
AKAs:
Race (Check)
_B _W A I
Sex
M
(Check) Ethnic
_Hispa
CHARGES
CHECK CATEGORY OF CHARGES(S):
FELONY
OTHER
NARRATIVE:
Title: USC: bL b
NARRATIVE:
1
Title: USC:
MISDEMEANOR ...AvIL CONTEMPT
Date of Offense:  Date of Arrest:
PRISONS
MATERIAL WITNESS
Plactfof Arrest?
Stativfl•mirth
Heil "
Ft: In:'
Country of Birth
Injuries / Medication
Citizenship Current AddressY', Zip Code
itc Scars / Marks / Tattoos
Emergency Contact: (Name, Address, Phone
Number)
Arraigned Sentenced
Remanding Official (Name)
Sign
Print
Special Handling: Y or N
Remarks:
Agency/District Phone/24 Hour Number
Removin
Sign
Print
fici (Name) Agency/District
Receiving Official (Name) Date / Time
Sign
Print
Phone/24 Hour Number
Releasing Official Name) Date / Time
Sign
Print
Sentry Load Data: (Must Initial)
Name Search Completed by:
Clearance/Separate Checked by:
(OPTIONAL USE)
ARS Code . Staff Init.
Add AKA's
Create Cash Accou'ra
Deposit Cash Amt.
Detainers
Court
Clothing Bag
RIGHT THUMBPRINT
Original -for ISM as Remanding -Removal receipt; Copy -for Control as Removal Receipt (NCIC); Copy -For
Removing Official; Copy -for Control as Remanding Receipt (Inmate); Copy -INS -Alien in Custody.
(This form may be replicated via WP) This form replaces BP-S377(58) and BP-377(58) of JUL 91
PH

╭───────── Page 26, Image 1 ──────────╮
│ PRISONER REMAND                     │
│                                     │
│ U.S__ DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE PRISONS │
│ Sd                                  │
╰─────────────────────────────────────╯

A
BP-S377.058 PRISONER REMAND 'DERN
FEB 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
Cent Nen
ROBLES tint NS".
VICENTE *semi. Now Svfnx
Motght
160 ARRESTING OFFICER WILL COMPLETE ALL REQUIRED
DATA ON THIS FORM PRIOR TO COMMITTING TO
MCC/MDCs.
Himight
5'09"
Salt
Name: Last First
BLACK :Wpm
76328-054
AKAs: Nt)Ne -
Race (Check)
B W A I
Sex
M
(Check)
F
Ethnic Origin
Hispanic or
(Check)
Other
I D.O.B. I SSN:
2019.0..07
Kr.
BROWN lscility
NYI4
FBI:
INS:
Other:
CHARGES,..se,m,
CHECK TEGORY OF CHARGESIS):
FELONY MISDEMEANOR   CIVIL CONTEMPT MATERIAL WITNESS
OTHER
NARRATI :
Title: `•-cUSC:
NARRAT I :
Title: USC: Lib >iv S y c
Date of Offense:  ; I ("-0A-i µL •1 !Date of Arrest: :
State of Birth Country of Birth Citizenship
Ili
Current Address
Place of Arrest:  17(2: GV Lt.1 i 3 3 RA/
Zip Code /
Height
Ft: In:
Weight Hair Eyes Scars / Marks / Tattoos
Injuries / Medication
JO \ 6-
Emergency Contact:(Name, Address, Phone
Number)
Arraigned/ 1
Y rN
Sentenced Special Handling: Y or
Remarks:
IN IN IN IN IN
Reman lDq Official (Name)/'
Sign f17
Print
Agency/District Phone/24 Hour Number i?
711 2 —
OUT OUT OUT OUT OUT
Remov‘m(,e0licklA_4Name)
Sign
Print -1
Agency/District Phone/24 Hour Number
(H/( - 2 I c Y(‘f
Receiving Official (Name)
Sign
Print
Sentry Loa d Data. (Must Initial)
Name Search Completed by:
Clearance/Separate Checked by:
FOR BOP 7SZ ONLY
Date / Time
(OPTIONAL USE)
ARS Code a Staff Init.
Add AKA's
Create Cash Account
Deposit Cash Amt.
Detainers
Court
Clothing Bag 4
Time
Original -for ISM as Remanding -Removal receipt; Copy-for Control as Removal Receipt (NCIC); Copy-For Removing Official;
Copy-for Control as Remanding Receipt
(Inmate); Copy-INS-Alien in Custody.
(This form may be replicated via WP) This form replaces BP-5377(58) and BP-377(58) of JUL 91
IRINT(DON
RECYCUIDNIfil
BP-5377.055 PRISONER REMAND r:DFRM
FEB 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
INISLMMO
HERRERA
first "Nal
LOUIS
fi ddle XSiis
REYNALDO
Noisht
ARRESTING OFFICER WILL COMPLETE ALL REQUIRED 5'08't
DATA ON THIS. FORM PRIOR TO CCMMITTING TO Hair
ECOPIDOS •• • i• BLACK
209=0
57343-059 Name: Last / First/
AKAs:
Suffix
wtyae
220
sr.
BROWN
riCUSty
NY"
Race (Check)
_B 2,LW _A _I
Sex (Check)
__F_ _Hispanic or Other Other:
Ethnic Origin. (Check) D.O.B. SSN:
INS:
CHARGES
CHECK CATEGORY
/  FELONY
OTHER
NARRATIVE:
Title:
NARRATIVE7--
Title: _____ USC:_____
OF CHARGES(S):
MISDEMEANOR
usc.5,AL
•
Date of Offense:  RNA
CIVIL CO
Date of Arrest:ROM
MATERIAL'. WITNESS
Place of Arrest:
State of Birth -.Country of Birth Citizenship r.
l) _
Height
Ft:
Weight . •
110 Hag7L-C
Exes.,,. iCT p-.1
'Current -Address Zip Code
WM
Scars / Marks / Tattoos-
Injuries / Medication Emergency. Contact:(Name( Address, Phone
Number) •
Arraigned
Remanding 0
Sign
Print
Sentenced
•
?2r
Removing OffiCial
Sign
Print
Special Handling: Y or N
Remarks:
Agency/District
• Cnyv..(
Agency!: Crict
Phone/24 Hour Number
2 33, • ;Vol;
Phone/24 Hour Number.
Receiv 0 clai (Name)
Sign
Prin
Sentry Load eta: (Must Initial)
Name Search Completed by:
Ziearance/Separate Checked by:
FOR BOP. USE: ON
Daze / Time
(OPTI
ARS od taff Ini Add AKA's
Create Cash
Deposit Cash Amt.
Detainers
Court
Clothing Bag 4
Releasing .Official:IName) Date / Time .
S4gn
Pr inter
RIGHT THUMBPRINT '
Original -for ISM as Remanding -Removal receipt; Copy-for Control as Removal Receipt (NCIC); Copy-For Removing Official;
Copy-for Control as Remanding Receipt
(Inmate); Copy-INS-Alien -in Custody.
(This form may be-replicated-via WP) This form replaces BP-5377(58) and BP-377(58).of JUL 91:
BP-S377.058 PRISONER RE ID rDFRM
FEB 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
ft\ DERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
ARREST:NG OFFICER WILL COMPLETE ALL REQUIRED
DATA ON THIS FORM PR:OR TO COMMITTING TO
ECC/XDCs.
Name: Las
a.)VNEkCYN6 yr 'tciNNNIL AKAs:
Race (Check)
B W A I
Sex (Check)
M F
Ethnic Origin (Che
_Hispanic or Ot
CHARGES
CHECK CATEGORY OF CHARGES(S):
FELONY MISDEMEANOR
OTHER
NARRATIVE:
Title: USC:
NARRATIVE .--
Title: USC:
Date of Offense: .
Caot lI mM
CAMACHO
fl i“N”.
FERDINAND
XiddlcMWR Su:In
tc..ight w<sght
5'07" 180
BALD
ge5no
79355-054
CIVIL CONTEMPT
BLUE
facilacy
NYM
. MATERIAL WITNESS
L-\ 10s4? Date of Arrest:  (lace of Arrest:
State of Birth. Country of Birth' Citizenship CUrrent Address' zip Code
Height
Ft: In:
Weight Hair Eyes. Scars / Marks / Tattoos
Injuries ./ Medication Emergency Contact:(Name, Address, Phone
Number)
Arraigned
Y N
Sentenced
Y N
Special Handling: Y or N
Remarks:
Remanding
Sign
Print
Remov
--Sig

1. int
Receiving
Sign
Print
ficial (Name) Date / Time
Agency/District -.
Agency/District
ame) Date / Time
5c 4/ /9, au 4,1
Sentry Load Data: (Must Initial)
Name Search Completed by:
Clearance/Separate Checked by:
Bele/is-4%g
Signs...
,4 •
Print
0 Staff Init.
(OPTIONALips I
ARS Code  1- 1
g1
Create Cash AccpUnt)
Add AKA's „
Deposit Cash  1./1.....,,Amt.
Detainers
Court
Clothing Bag
Phone/24 Hour Number
Phone/24 Hour Number
Ig )11 MOA Tr'
RIGHT THUMBPRINT
Original -for ISM as Remanding -Removal receipt; Copy-for Control as Removal Receipt (NCIC); Copy-For Removing Official;
Copy-for Control as Remanding Receipt
(Inmate); Copy-INS-Alien in Custody.
(This form may be replicated via WP) This form replaces BP-S377(58) and BP-377(58) of JUL 91
"? . 0 58 PRISONER REMAND :DFRN
FEH 04
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
ARRESTING OFFICER WILL COMPLETE ALL REQUIRED
DATA ON THIS FORM PRIOR'TO COMMITTING TO
MCC/MDCs.
_ Name: Last
4;1.4 LriA /Th( ) ri21-)A
AKAs: j L,./ h.) Fr
First
I UIS
Race (Check)
B ,/W A I
Sex (Check)
_214 F
Lan mum
SAL OADO-BRECEDA rivet Ease
LUIS
X1001* Mae Marl],
6'00«
SLACK
maim
76327-054
165
ay.
BROWN
recllity
NYM
)SHispanic or Other
Ethnic Origin (Check) D.O.B. SSN: FBI:
Other:
INS:
CHARGES
CHECKAATEGORY OF CHARGESISI:
L./FELONY    MISDEMEANOR
OTHER
Title: USC: Li 1/41NARRATIVE?
NARRATIVE=
Title:  -4 IUSC:LC. 4I  b er• of c,
CIVIL CONTEMPT MATERIAL WITNESS
Date of Offense:  Cl --4-i 2‘)I4  Date of Arrest:  CI 17•-11
State of Birth
I P. I 2 4:•40A
Height
Ft: (P In: (_,
Country Of Birth
Si.
Weight
itP 5
Injuries / Medication
71, 61 1-h_
Hair
eK
^itizenship
SA
EY5!,
,)
6/4:. •
Place of Arrest:  ij/ HS it; /.7.73
N
I . r
'Scars / Marks / TattoAs
(- 4  fr T 4 74413
Emerg
Numbe
3
Arraign:4, , Sentence.41/ Special Handling: Y or 4.1(9
Remarks:
IN IN IN IN IN
Remanding ,.
Sign [)( I
Print
OUT
Agency/District
(A ; / A' y
Phone/29 Hour Number get/ vJ
- Jr ≥ 322
OUT OUT OUT
Removing" ffit.ial (Name)
Sign y
Print
Agency/District
bt -17//1A7
Phone/24 Hour Number
Receiving Official (Name)
Sign
Print
Sentry Load Data: (Must initial)
Name Search Completed by:
Clearance/Separate Checked by:
Date / Time
FOR BOP SE ONLY 13
ReleasiggrOic.41 (Name)
Print
Sign (1
(OPTIONAL USE) -
ARS Code • . f I Staff Init. --
Add AKA's'
Create Cash Account
Deposit Cash Amt.
Detainers
Court
Clothing Bag #
Date / Time
7 fl 11, :li ,1, RIGHT THUMBPRINT
Original -for ISM as Remanding -Removal receipt; Copy-for Control as Removal Receipt (NCIC); Copy-For
Removing Official; Copy -for Control as Remanding Receipt (Inmate); Copy-INS-Alien in Custody.
•
(This form may be replicated via WP) This form replaces BP-S3TT(58) and BP-377458) of JUL 91
IIINTEOCOI RECICLIONOVI
Prepared on OWDS070
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
SOUTHERN NEW YORK
Otmeet
/fie*k
TO: MCC New York DATE: 08/08/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
SI USMS NO. Local Jail No. Name
(XI are herewith remanded to your custody
I are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 68430054 JAQUEZ, CARLOS
RECEIPT
THE ABOVE NAMED PRISONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:
BY:
TITLE: 7:"
DISTRI ORGAN. ADDRESS:
UNITED STATES MARSHAL
BY: DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1
NYMGZ 530*07 * ROSTER 08-07-2019
?AGE 006 20:00:59
GFP. SPECIFIC. REG  LN  FN  CMC  QTR  CALT
C COURT SDNY 86452-054 OCHOA PERCY 204-206UAD 12:00
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW . . .
BP-A03713
APR 10
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
MARSHAL'S RECEIPT CDFRM
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
DATE:
08/06/2019
INSTITUTION: METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
LOCATION/ADDRESS:
RECEIVED FROM:
150 PARK ROW. NEW YORK NY 10007

L. DIANYE. WARDEN
SOUTHERN NEWYORK UNITED STATES MARSHAL FOR THE: DISTRICT OF:
BY:
DEPUTY UNITED STATES MARSHAL
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS, TOGETHER WITH COMMITMENT PAPERS:
TAVERAS. JAIRO FEIOP# 30772-069 K07
NINE•--CaLLE_E.X.644.1TD7E - CrEerrak :
BY (SIGNATURE) :
PDF Prescribed by P5800
This form replaces BP-378(58) of JUL 36
prop_ on OR 0
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
SOUTHERN NEW YORK
DetrXt 11
TO: MCC New York DATE: 08108/2019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
USMS NO. Local Jail No. ame
( 1
are herewith remanded to your custody
are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
1 79306054 OUEZ. LUIGI
2 17742104 JJ NES..MCHAEL
3 76139054 TILLO-ROSARIO, GABRIEL
4 86239054 WILSON. LEROY
RECEIPT
THE ABOVE NAMED PRI S 1 WERE RECEIVED:
BY:
TITLE:
DISTRICT ORGAN. ADDRESS:
12.
UNITED STATES MARSHAL
/ Bill DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limit d Official Use Page 1 of 1
NYMGZ
530*07
PAGE
007
OF
007
*
ROSTER
09-07-2019
\
20:00:59
"J.
SPECIFIC.
REG
LN
PM
CMC
OTR
CALT
C
COURT
SDNY
65773-054
BRITO
HASSEN
SEPARATION
005-740U
12:01
C
COURT
SDNY
19435-104
DE
PREITAS
FABIO
-4WE--
,12231
---
12:01
.
G0000
TRANSACTION
SUCCESSFULLY
COMPLETED
190-7—eetti—rnr MtretrOle--1-2-79-1--
"CC'
ta
eel

╭──────────── Page 35, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ PN OV o> Coe na nont ot                  │
│                                          │
│ | -to:Zt__przt~eor—                      │
│ va \ \ TO?Zt _AOvL-S0D Noruwavaas        │
│ DI \ Ae ee gma <2" Ta6                   │
│                                          │
│ stoe-u0-80 af                            │
│ 4                                        │
│                                          │
│ SW                                       │
│                                          │
│ GgLaTaMOD KTINSSSEDONS NOTLOVSNVEL 00005 │
│                                          │
│ ouryp___-swnigavi—soo-zetee—aNes—itiAeS. │
│ * m Bee oe ANGE                          │
│                                          │
│ Olav SWLISYd BA YOT-SEVET ANGS LUND      │
│                                          │
│ vue                                      │
│                                          │
│ nasswi  OuTUE ¥50-cLLs9 ANGS LANG        │
│ "Na INT tot)" "ome ““DTaTORaS “a         │
│ iS 400 g0 £00 Bova                       │
│ uaisou + LO¥0eS ZDARN                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────╯

BP-A092 RELEASE AUTHORIZATION CMTM
Min 10
Q.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE  FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
AMMIMMO
Inmate Name Register No. Institution Date
JONES, JOHNNY 06178-104 M.C.C./ New York 08/08/2019
Release Date Method
Yes
08/08/2019 Trty Trans Detainer:
21 No
Custody Will Be Taken by:
Prisoner Escorts: kl)1\\A-99-% Cocoo, cric „WA- &).-ic) 14 --v)‘ Es\ANDA,N a locla 1
CERTIFICATION: I certify that this release is in accordance with applicable and controlling WO rules, regulations and 
statutory provisions. If this is a final
release, it is based on '
a final release audit of the sentence computation provided by the Designation and Sentence
Computation Center. I have personally reviewed all Judgment and Commitment Orders, O.S.
Parole Commission Warrants, Notice of Actions, and detainer information, and there is no
information which would preclude the release of this inmate.
Date
nRln0Pom0
CIT•024011
JONES FM, Mime
JOHNNY was. Hell Willg •
HENRY
P., 6' 0" " 202
w BLK EY BRO
m0.06178-104 NYM N+7« 104 "Di
RELEASE ACTION
Identified b   Released by:
Funds Pa . Date of Release:
C co 08/08/2019
RECEIPT OF AGENT TAKING CUSTODY
Tim of Release:
1* /)
I have received the above named prisoner, together with personal property and funds in
the amount of $
Location
-2-7• 3 ° ((AY)
I li* .Signature
Record Copy - Receiving 6 Discharge File in Judgment 6 Commitment File; Copy - Case Management, Central File (Section 
5); Copy - Control Room; Copy - Hospital;
Copy - Transporting Officer
PD£ Prescribed by P5800 Replaces BP-392(58; dtd MAY 94
RELEASE ACTION
BP-A0392 RELEASE AUTHORIZATION CDFR.M
JUNE 10
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
Inmate Name Register No. Institution Date
PECORELLA, ALAN 70497-050 M.C.C./ New York 08/08/2019
Release Date Method
Yes
08/08/2019 PRE REMOVE Detainer:
No
Custody Will Be Taken by:
CERTIFICATION: I certify that this release is in accordance with applicable and controlling
rules, regulations and statutory provisions. If this is a final release, it is based on
a final release audit of the sentence computation provided by the Designation and Sentence
Computation Center. I have personally reviewed all Judgment and Commitment Orders, V.S.
Parole Commission Warrants, Notice of Actions, and detainer information, and there is no
information which would preclude the release of this inmate.
Name/Title
W. SMITH, SCSS
RELEASED TO:
45 BURNETT sne k raCC_
WEST ORPOE, N.J. 07052
Identified by:
Funds Paid by:
cid)
Date
08/08/2019
Iwl Na
PECORELLA F l ramie
ALAN tAb
MATHEW
5' 7" 139
N,. BRO r,. BRO
REG•70497-050 NYM
RECEIPT OF AGENT TAKING CUSTODY
ime of Release:
0444401
7007450 PEC0MMA
I have received the above named prisoner, together with personal property and funds in
the amount of $
Name/Title Signature Date
Location
Record Copy - Receiving S Discharge File in Judgment 6 Commitment File; Copy - Case Management, Central
File (Section 5); Copy - Control Room; Copy - Hospital; Copy - Transporting Officer
Par Prescribed by P5800 Replaces BP-392(58) <led MAY 94
NYMGZ 530.07 • ROSTER • 08-07-2019
PAGE 002 20:00:59
GRP. SPECIFIC. . REG  LN  FN  CMC  QTR  CALT
C COURT EDNY 89380-053 DAVIS HOWARD ROI-1061)AD 07:00
',mit xi..
DAVIS
Tint Kno
HOWARD
middle Mao Puff ix
meaint
5'08"
Heir
BLACK
aciguo
89380-053
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
Weight
177
”.
BROWN
Tocility
NYM
\,Ar
eceedcn ".',4 ad 2: - ] SOUTHERN NEW YORK
Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver
PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER
AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)
!Mina 54
TO: MCC New York DATE: 08/0812019
THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS:
are herewith remanded to your custody
(  1 are to be delivered to representative
presenting and signing this order
USMS NO. Local Jail No. j Name
1 86124054 LAVELL
2 86404054
wo/C6FtANT.
/ETHERIDGE. TYHEEM
3 86019054
/ A:
TA
IE.EJzERMAINE
4 86995054 i DORLYN
5 76277054
v l
URENA. RICHARD
RECEIPT
THE ABOVE P ISONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:
BY:
TITLE:
UNiliED STrSHAL
DISTRI RGAN. ADDRESS:
/
yv BY. DEPUTY U.S. MARSHAL
Limited Official Use Page 1 of 1

╭────────────────────────────────── Page 39, Image 1 ───────────────────────────────────╮
│ Prisoner Remand or Order to Deliver evi                                               │
│ c                                                                                     │
│                                                                                       │
│ rv)                                                                                   │
│                                                                                       │
│ PRISONER REMAND OR ORDER TO DELIVER                                                   │
│                                                                                       │
│ AND RECEIPT FOR UNITED STATES PRISONERS (SHORT FORM)                                  │
│                                                                                       │
│ TO: MCC New York DATE: —o8/08’2019                                                    │
│                                                                                       │
│ THE FOLLOWING NAMED UNITED STATES PRISONERS: Pd sre herewith remanded to your custody │
│                                                                                       │
│ (1 are to be delivered to representative                                              │
│                                                                                       │
│ Presenting and signing this order                                                     │
│                                                                                       │
│ 2 s6e0d0sa - ETHERIDGE, TYHEEM ae a                                                   │
│                                                                                       │
│ RECEIPT                                                                               │
│                                                                                       │
│ THE ABOVE WANE PRISONER(S) WERE RECEIVED:                                             │
│                                                                                       │
│ Limited Oficial Use Page Tort                                                         │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

NYMGZ 530.07 * ROSTER 08-07-2019
PAGE 004 20:00:59
GRP. SPECIFIC.. REG LN FN CMC QTR CALT
C COURT SDNY 76139-054 FCASTILLO-R GABRIEL SEPARATION E03-518L 07:31
C COURT SDNY 86995-054 •TAVAREZ-MO DORLYN SEPARATION E05-538U 07:31
C COURT SDNY 86340-054 •NIEVES IVAN E06-547L 07:31
C COURT SDNY 86239-054 P WILSON LEROY G07-749L 07:31
C COURT SDNY 79306-054 •JAQUEZ LUIGI SEPARATION I03-920U 07:31
C COURT SDNY 86019-054 •MYRIE JERMAINE SEPARATION I03-922U 07:31
C COURT SDNY 86404-054 'ETHERIDGE TYHEEM I05-933L 07:31
C COURT SDNY 76277-054 •URENA RICHARD K04-125L 07:31
C ILLL=DASD---07•aa- otaisdri5
C COURT SDNY 17742-104 *JONES MICHAEL K12-065L 07:31
C COURT SDNY 86124-054: DURANT LAVELL 201-104UAD 07:31
C COURT SDNY 79471-054 SCHULTE JOSHUA SEPARATION Z07-305LAD 07:31
G0002 MORE PAGES TO FOLLOW .
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
MCC NEW YORK
150 PARK ROW, NEW YORK, NY, 10007
TRANSFER RECEIPT DATE: Thursday August 8, 2019
RECEIVED FROM pieffffiffEEffily..WARDEN MCC NEW YORK, 150 PARK ROW, NEW YORK, NY 10007. THE
FOLLOWING UNITED STATES PRISONERS, TOGETHER WITH COMPLETE FILES FOR TRANSFER AS
INDICATED: WAB/USM-SDNY/NYCDOC
REG.NO. / NAME QTR DST RELEASE STATUS
87014-054 14 HARGROVE JAKEEM 5N USM/SDNY HLD-REMOVE
TOTAL: 1
*** ALL 64, 71, Medication PAPERWORK ACCOUNTED FOR
*** ALL PD 15's CHRONO & PENDING CHECKED BY:
USM/SDNY
MCC NEW YORK MOVEMENT OFFICER 646.836-6300 EXT 6321
EFTA01266204 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein death bequests of The 1953 Trust amended 2 days before death naming Darren Indyke, Richard Kahn as trustees
(date: 2019-08-08)
THE 1953 TRUST

THIS TRUST AGREEMENT is made as of August 8, 2019 ("Agreement"), by and among JEFFREY

E. EPSTEIN, as Grantor (the "Grantor"), and DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN, as
Trustees (the "Trustees").

WHEREAS, Grantor, residing at Little St. James Island, St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands established
The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2019 Trust dated January 18, 2019, with Darren K. Indyke, and Richard D.
Kahn, as Trustees; and

WHEREAS, the Grantor retained the power to amend the trust in whole or in part, by a written
instrument executed and acknowledged solely by the Grantor and delivered to no less than one
Trustee of this Trust and exercised such right to amend the trust on February 4, 2019;

NOW THEREFORE, the Grantor has chosen again to exercise the power to amend and restate the
Trust expressly granted to him in Section 1.3 of the Trust to amend and restate the Trust, in its
entirety, as follows;

The Grantor hereby pays over, assigns, grants, conveys, transfers and delivers to the Trustees the
property described in Schedule A annexed hereto and made a part hereof, to be administered and
disposed of as provided in this Agreement, with any additions, changes, or amendments to this
Agreement.

Further, The Jeffrey E. Epstein 2019 Trust shall henceforth be known as the "The 1953 Trust".

Article I
During My Lifetime

The following provisions shall apply during my lifetime:

Section 1.1. - Disbursement of Income
All of the income derived from the property held in this Trust (the "Trust Estate") shall be paid to me,
or accumulated or paid as I may direct in writing from time to time.

Section 1.2. - Disbursement of Principal
The Trustees may distribute any part or all of the principal of the Trust Estate to me as I may direct in
writing from time to time.

Section 1.3. - Specific Rights Reserved to Me

A. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to amend this Agreement, in
whole or in part, by a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me and delivered to no
less than one Trustee of this Trust.

B. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, in my sole and unfettered
discretion, to remove any Trustee by delivering to no less than one Trustee of this Trust a written
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007748
instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

C. I reserve the tight, at any time, to revoke this Trust in its entirety or, at any time and
from time to time, to revoke any provision hereof by delivering to no less than one Trustee of this
Trust a written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.

D. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to withdraw or appoint any part
or all of the principal of the Trust Estate by delivering to no less than one Trustee of this Trust a
written instrument executed and acknowledged solely by me.
E. I reserve the right, at any time and from time to time, to transfer to the Trustees, by
gift, by Will or by beneficiary designation, such additional property, including life insurance policies, as
I may desire. Any such additional property shall be held on the same terms as are then applicable to
the original Trust Estate, except that it may be transferred subject to conditions and provisions of
special application to such additional property.
Article II
After My Death
The following provisions shall apply after my death:

Section 2.1. - Payment of My Debts and of Taxes and Expenses
The Trustees shall pay from the principal of the Trust Estate (a) my debts, funeral and burial expenses
and the administration expenses of my probate estate which are not paid by the Executors of my
probate estate, and (b) the federal, state and territorial estate, inheritance, succession, generation
skipping and similar taxes imposed by reason of my death which are the obligations of the Trustees
(including any of such taxes which the Executors of my probate estate direct the Trustees to pay by
written direction delivered to the Trustees). For purposes of this Section 2.1, the principal of the Trust
Estate shall not include (a) any assets which are not included in my Gross Estate or (b) any assets which
arc not subject to, or available to creditors for the payment of, my debts, my funeral and burial
expenses or the administration expenses of my probate estate.

Section 2.2. -Bequests and Devises under My Will and Trust
If my probate estate is insufficient to satisfy all pecuniary bequests (or bequests payable in cash or in
kind in the discretion of the Executors of my probate estate) provided in my Will, the Trustees shall
pay such unpaid bequests from the principal of the Trust Estate. If my Will provided for a specific
bequest or devise of specified assets and such bequest or devise could not be satisfied from my
probate estate because such assets were held by the Trustees at my death, the Trustees shall distribute
such assets to satisfy such bequest or devise.
To the extent the assets of the Trust are insufficient to satisfy all bequests provided for in this
Agreement, I direct the Trustees to first pay all specific bequests in Article II, Sections 2.3(A)(1), (2),
and (3), of this Agreement To the extent assets are insufficient to pay all of the remaining bequests in
Article II, Section 2.3(A) of this Agreement, then the Trustees shall pay the bequests in the order in
which they are listed in this Trust To the extent the Trust funds are insufficient to satisfy all of the
bequests listed in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41), the bequests that cannot be satisfied shall be
deemed to have lapsed.
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007749

Section 2.3. Bequests

A. I make the following general bequests:

1. to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives mc, Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000). In
addition to said bequest, as soon as practicable after my death, the Trustees are directed to
purchase an annuity for the benefit of KARYNA SHULIAK from a reputable financial
institution in the amount of Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000), which annuity shall be payable
monthly for the life of KARYNA SHULIAK. Upon the death of KARYNA SHULIAK, the
Trustees shall distribute the remaining principal balance of said annuity, and any income, pro
rata to the beneficiaries listed in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41M in the same percentage that
their initial bequest bears to the total amount of bequests made in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41):
It is my intention to fund a separate trust for KARYNA SHULIAK prior to my death. In the
event that a separate trust is created and funded by me for KARYNA SHULIAK then the
amount bequeathed by this section shall be reduced by the amount of principal conveyed by mc
to the separate trust.

2. to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, if he survives me, Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000).
3. to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, if he survives me, Twenty Five Million Dollars ($25,000,000).

4. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, the amount of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).
5. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, the amount of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000),.
In addition, if she survives me, my Trustees are directed to pay an
additional Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) to be distributed as per <REDACTED> <REDACTED>
instructions.

6. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, the amount of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).
7. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, the amount of Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).

8. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, the amount of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).
8. to <REDACTED> the amount of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).

9. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, the amount of Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).
10. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, the amount of Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).

11. to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., if he survives me, Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).
12. to BELLA KLEIN, if she survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).

13. to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR., if he survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).
14. to MERWIN DELA CRUZ, if he survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).

15. to VALDSON VIERA CON1RIN, if he survives mc, Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).
16. to GHISLAINE MAXWELL, if she survives me, Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000).

17. to ANN RODRIQUEZ, if she survives me, the amount of Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000),.
18. to SIMONA PETREIKE, if she survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).

19. to DAVID ROGERS, if he survives me, Four Million Dollars ($4,000,000).
20. to PETER ST. OMER, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).

21. to DUPSON DONISSAINT, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
22. to PIERRE JULES, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).

23. to CECILE DE JONGH, if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
24. to JEANNE BRENNAN WIEBRACHT, if she survives mc, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).

25. to JERMAINE RUAN, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
26. to DAPHNE WALLACE, if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).

27. to ERIKA KELLERHALS, if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).
28. to KATHY LINDEMAN, if she survives me, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).

29. to BRICE GORDON, if he survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).
30. to <REDACTED> if she survives me, Two Million Dollars ($2,000,000).

31. to <REDACTED>, if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).
32. to EMMA ROED LARSEN, if she survives me, Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).

33. to EDWARD ROED LARSEN, if he survives me, Five Million Dollars aspoopoq.
34. to MARTIN NOWACK, if he survives me, Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).

35. to ARLINE M. TOYLO, if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000.00).
36. to CARLUZ N. TOYLO, if he survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000.00).

37. to CAROLINE LANG, if she survives me, Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000).
38. to UNA PASCAL, if she survives me, One Million Dollars ($1,000,000).

39. to MARK EPSTEIN, if he survives me, the sum of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000),
to be held by him, in trust, for the benefit of his children.

40. to PERRY BARD, if she survives me, the sum of Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000)..
41. to MISHA GRAMANOV, if she survives me, the sum of Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000).

42. to MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if she is then married to DARREN KEITH
INDYKE, Three Million Dollars ($3,000,000), which funds shall be distributed and used for
the sole purpose of repaying FT Real Estate, Inc. the funds it previously paid to KC-AC, LLC in
connection with a real estate purchase contract between FT Real Estate, Inc., as purchaser, and
KCAC, LLC, as seller, for the purchase of the real property known as and located at 2 Kean
Court in Livingston, New Jersey, and terminating said real estate purchase contract. It is my
express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from
my estate, the Trustees shall treat said $3,000,000 as having been distributed by the Trust to
MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, as the sole member of KCAC, LLC, as then having been
repaid by MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER on behalf of KCAC, LLC to FT Real Estate, Inc. and
as then having been distributed by FT Real Estate, Inc. to the Trust, as the sole shareholder of
FT Real Estate, Inc. It is further my express desire and intention, as the sole shareholder of Fr
Real Estate, Inc., that upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate,
FT Real Estate, Inc. be directed to cancel and terminate said real estate purchase contract as
contemplated herein; provided, however, that such distribution shall not be made or deemed to
have been made and such termination shall not occur if the transfer of such real property to FT
Real Estate, Inc. pursuant to such real estate purchase contract has been completed prior to my
death or if prior to my death said real estate purchase contract has been terminated or is
otherwise no longer in effect

43. to LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR., or his heirs, successors and assigns, whether or
not LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR. survives me, all of my interest in the property,
improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights of and pertaining to the real property located
at, and known and referred to as, 18 Teneyck Avenue, Valley Stream, New York. My interest
consists of 100% of the issued and outstanding Membership Interests in Lyn & Jojo, LLC, a
New York limited liability company which holds legal title to said real property, improvements,
fixtures, permits and other rights, which Membership Interests arc held in the name of Darren

K. Indyke, as nominee for me, and which I direct the Trustees to transfer to LUCIANO A.
FONTAN1LLA, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns.

44. whether or not <REDACTED> survives me, to <REDACTED> or
her heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the total outstanding debt, including,
without limitation, all principal and all accrued and unpaid interest thereon, due from
<REDACTED> to FT Real Estate, Inc. to be used sole for the purpose of repaying
said principal and interest in full. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and
the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the full amount of
said outstanding debt, including, without limitation, all principal and accrued and unpaid
interest thereon, as having been distributed by the Trust to , or her
heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding
debt and accrued but unpaid interest, as then having been repaid by
to FT Real Estate, Inc., and then as having been distributed to the Trust as the sole shareholder
of FT Real Estate, Inc.

45. I forgive any loans which I made to the following individuals or entities:
a) LUCIANO A. FONTANILLA, JR.

b) <REDACTED>
c) <REDACTED>
e) LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF
f) KARYNA SHULIAK
g) <REDACTED>
h) <REDACTED>
i) <REDACTED>

1) <REDACTED>
k) <REDACTED>
1) <REDACTED>
m) NINA KEITA
n) PAUL KRASSNER
o) DAVID MITCHELL
p) <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

q) MARK LLOYD
r) <REDACTED>
s) <REDACTED>
t) NLR VENTURES, LLC
u) SLIC DESIGNS, LLC
v) JSC INTERIORS, LLC

46. Upon my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to DARREN KEITH
INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial
obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, must, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability
company, from DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if
she is then married to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation, limited liability
company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by
one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Harlequin
Dane, LLC, a Florida limited liability company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be
distributed to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole
purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my
express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from
my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial obligations and liabilities as
having been distributed by the Trust to DARRF.N KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs, successors
or assigns, and as then having been repaid by DARREN KEITH INDYKE, or his heirs,
successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due to me,
or any corporation, limited liability company, tmst, or other entity beneficially owned by me
immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from
DARREN KEITH INDYKE, his spouse, MICHELLE FERN SAIPHER, if she is then
married to DARREN KEITH INDYKE, and/or any corporation, limited liability company,
limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both
of them immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to, Harlequin Dane, LLC, or
its successor entities.

47. Upon my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to RICHARD DAVID KAHN,
or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations and
liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, mist, or
other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited
to, Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company, from RICHARD
DAVID KAHN, his spouse, LISA KAHN, if she is then married to RICHARD DAVID
KAHN, and/or any corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general
partnership, trust or other entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior
to my death, including, but not limited to, Coatue Enterprises, LLC, a New York limited
liability company, or its successor entities. Said funds shall be distributed to RICHARD
DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, for the sole purpose of being used to repay
all such outstanding and due obligations and liabilities. It is my express desire and intention
that, upon my death and the receipt by the Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall
treat the total sum of all such financial obligations and liabilities as having been distributed by
the Trust to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having
been repaid by RICHARD DAVID KAHN, or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in
repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from RICHARD DAVID KAHN, his
spouse, LISA KAHN, if she is then married to RICHARD DAVID KAHN, and/or any
corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other
entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death, including, but
not limited to, Coatue Enterprises, LLC, or its successor entities.

48. Upon my death, the Trustees arc directed to distribute to LAWRENCE PAUL
VISOSKI, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns, an amount equal to the sum of all financial
obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, II.C, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability
company, from LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., his spouse, EILEEN VISOSKI, if she is
then married to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., and/or both of them jointly, and/or any
corporation, limited liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other
entity beneficially owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death. Said funds
shall be distributed to LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns,
for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and
liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the
Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial
obligations and liabilities as having been distributed by the Trust to LAWRENCE PAUL
VISOSKI, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns, and as then having been repaid by
LAWRENCE PAUL VISOSKI, JR., or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in
repayment of all such liabilities and obligations due to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC, from LAWRENCE P. VISOSKI, JR.,
his spouse, EILEEN VISOSKI, and/or both of them jointly, and/or any corporation, limited
liability company, limited partnership, general partnership, trust or other entity beneficially
owned by one or both of them immediately prior to my death.

49. Upon my death, the Trustees are directed to distribute to each of LESLEY
KATHERINE GROFF, <REDACTED>, BELLA ICLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ,
DAVID ROGERS, and MERWIN DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or assigns,
an amount equal to the sum of all financial obligations and liabilities then outstanding and due
from her or him to me, or any corporation, limited liability company, trust, or other entity
beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death, including, but not limited to,
Southern Financial, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company, and FT Real Estate,
inc., a U.S. Virgin Islands corporation. Said funds shall be distributed to each of LESLEY
KATHERINE GROFF, <REDACTED>, BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ,
DAVID ROGERS, and MERWIN DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or assigns,
for the sole purpose of being used to repay all such outstanding and due obligations and
liabilities. It is my express desire and intention that, upon my death and the receipt by the
Trust of the assets from my estate, the Trustees shall treat the total sum of all such financial
obligations and liabilities as having been distributed by the Trust to each of I Rd' . EY
KATHERINE GROFF, , BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ,
DAVID ROGERS, and MERWIN DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or as
and as then having been repaid by each of LESLEY KATHERINE GROFF,
, BELLA KLEIN, ANN RODRIQUEZ, DAVID ROGERS, and MERWIN
DELA CRUZ, or her or his heirs, successors or assigns, to the Trust in repayment of all such
liabilities and obligations due from her or him to me, or any corporation, limited liability
company, trust, or other entity beneficially owned by me immediately prior to my death,
including, but not limited to, Southern Financial, LLC and FT Real Estate, Inc.

50. It is my express desire and intention that all amounts due and owing to me by
the persons listed in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(45) of this Agreement shall be cancelled upon
my death. While at the date of execution of this Amendment, the cancellation of said loans will
not result in taxable income to any such persons, in the event any changes are made to the
applicable tax law, the Trustees are directed to take any and all steps necessary to ensure that
the cancellation of such indebtedness does not result in any negative tax consequences to such
persons. In that regard, as necessary, all such amounts due and owing to me by the persons
enumerated in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(45) of this Agreement may be deemed to have been
distributed by the Trust to such persons and repaid by such persons to the Trust. It is also my
express desire and intention that all fi nancial obligations and liabilities enumerated in Article
II, Sections 2.3(A)(42), (43), (44), (46), (47), (48), and (49) of this Agreement shall be deemed
to be terminated upon my death, and that such termination shall not result in taxable income
to any of the Beneficiaries enumerated in such Sections, and the Trustees are directed to take
any and all steps necessary to ensure that the termination of such obligations and liabilities
does not result in any negative tax consequences to such Beneficiaries. In the event that the
termination of any obligation does result in tax consequences to the Beneficiaries enumerated
in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(42), (43), (44), (46), (47), (48), and (49), the Trustees are hereby
directed to distribute an amount necessary to satisfy said tax consequences to each Beneficiary
to the extent necessary.

51. If and at such time or times as the Trustees shall determine in their sok and
absolute discretion that it would be benefit-61 for the protection of the exclusive and
unimpeded right to the use and enjoyment by KARYNA SHULIAK of the outright
distribution which pursuant to the provisions of Section 2.3(A)(1) then notwithstanding the
provision of this Agreement directing the Trustees to make such distribution directly to
KARYNA SHULIAIC, the Trustees shall be authorized to make such distribution in Trust for
the benefit of KARYNA SHULIAIC payable for her lifetime. Upon her death, the remaining
income and principal shall be distributed pro rata to the beneficiaries listed in Article II,

Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41) in an amount equal to the percentage which their individual bequest
bears to the total amount of bequests in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41).

52. The Trustees shall retain the sum of Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000) for as
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007756
long as they shall determine in their discretion is necessary or appropriate to enable them to
defend against and, in their discretion, settle any and all claims made regarding the validity of
this Trust and any of its provisions or any accompanying Will executed by me. The Trustees
shall have complete discretion to determine if, when, for how much and upon what other
terms to settle each and any such claims, and shall have the right to pay each and all such
set-dements out of said Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000) so retained. If and at such time or
times, if any, as the Trustees shall determine in their discretion that it is no longer necessary or
appropriate to retain all or any portion of said Ten Million Dollars ($10,000,000) so retained,
the amount the Trustees determine no longer necessary or appropriate to be retained shall be
distributed as provided in Section 2.4 of this Article II.

53. The Trustees shall retain the sum of Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000) for as
long as they shall determine in their discretion is necessary or appropriate to enable them to
defend against and, in their discretion, settle any and all claims to any and all assets of my
estate asserted by any persons against my estate, the Trustees or this Trust. The Trustees shall
have complete discretion to determine if; when, for how much and upon what other terms to
settle each and any such claims, and shall have the right to pay each and all such settlements
out of said Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000) so retained. If and at such time or times, if any,
as the Trustees shall determine in their discretion that it is no longer necessary or appropriate
to retain all or any portion of said Fifty Million Dollars ($50,000,000) so retained, the amount
the Trustees determine no longer necessary or appropriate to be retained shall be distributed as
provided in Section 2.4 of this Article H.

(B) I make the following specific bequests:
1. I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, the following:

(a) all of my interest in the property, leases, tights, permits, improvements and fixtures
comprising and pertaining to Zorro Ranch, located at 49 Zorro Ranch Road,
Stanley, New Mexico. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of
Cypress, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which holds legal tide to
the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "New Mexico Property".
In addition, I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all Household
Goods (as defined in Section 2.3(B)(4) of this Article II) associated with the use,
recreational use, maintenance or repair of the New Mexico Property.

(b) all of my interest in the property, rights, permits, improvements and fixtures
comprising and pertaining to the island known as Little St. James, located in the
U.S. Virgin Islands. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of
Nautilus, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which holds legal tide to
the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "LSJ Property". In addition,
I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all Household Goods associated
with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair of the LSJ Property.

(c) all of my interest in the property, rights, permits, improvements and fixtures
comprising and pertaining to the island known as Great St. James, located in the
U.S. Virgin Islands. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of common stock of
10
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007757
Poplar, Inc. a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which holds all of the
membership interests of Great St. Jim, LLC, a United States Virgin Islands limited
liability company, which holds legal title to said property, rights, permits,
improvements and fixtures comprising and pertaining to the said island known as
Great St James. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "GSJ Property". In
addition, I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all Household Goods
associated with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair of the GSJ Property.

(d) all of my interest in all apartments, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights
of and pertaining to the premises located in the building known and referred to as
22 Avenue Foch, 75016, Paris, France. The interest consists of units 47 with
mezzanine, 48 and 81 on the 2nd floor, units 63 and 74 on the 5th floor and units 5
and 22 (cellars) in the basement The units are currently all owned by SCI JEP, a
French company of which I own 999 of the 1,000 outstanding shares. Such interest
is hereinafter referred to as the "Paris Property". In addition, I give to KARYNA
SHULIAK, if she survives me, all Household Goods associated with the use,
recreational use, maintenance or repair of the Paris Property.

(e) all of my interest in the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights
of and pertaining to the real property located at, and known and referred to as, 358
El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of
common stock of Laurel, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which
holds legal title to the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "Florida
Property". In addition, I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all
Household Goods associated with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair
of the Florida Property.

(f) all of my interest in the property, improvements, fixtures, permits and other rights
of and pertaining to the real property located at, and known and referred to as, 9
East 71' Street, New York, New York. My interest consists of 10,000 shares of
common stock of Maple, Inc., a United States Virgin Islands corporation, which
holds legal title to the same. Such interest is hereinafter referred to as the "New
York Property". In addition, I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, all
Household Goods associated with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair
of the New York Property.

2. I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, if she survives me, in a separate trust, the provisions of
which are set forth in Article III, Section 3.1 of this Agreement, the sum of Five Million
Dollars ($5,000,000) for each property that KARYNA SHULIAK takes tide to, to pay for the
operating expenses of the properties. Operating expenses shall include, but not be limited to,
property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities, general maintenance and repairs and common
charges.

3. If KARYNA SHULIAK does not survive me, or if KARYNA SHULIAK advises at least
one of the Trustees in writing that she has renounces her right to take or otherwise disclaims
her interest in any of the properties listed in Section 2.3(B)(1) then those properties that  are
renounced or disclaimed by KARYNA SHULIAK shall pass to <REDACTED>, if
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007758
she survives me. In addition, in the event that property passes from KARYNA SHULIAK to
pursuant to the terms of this Agreement, I also give to <REDACTED>, in a separate trust,
the provisions of which are set forth in Article III,

Section 3.1 of this Agreement, the sum of Five Million Dollars ($5,000,000) for each property
that she takes title to, to pay for the operating expenses of the properties. Operating expenses
shall include, but not be limited to, property insurance, real estate taxes, utilities, general
maintenance and repairs and common charges.

3. In the event renounces her right or refuses to take any of the
properties listed in Section 2.3(B)(1) or otherwise disclaims her interest, the properties shall be
disposed of in accordance with the provisions of Article II, Section 2.6 and all proceeds shall be
distributed to KARYNA SHULIAK. In the event KARYNA SWAIM( declines the proceeds
of the sales, or has predeceased then the Trustees are directed to
distribute the sales proceeds pro rata to the Beneficiaries listed in Article U, Section 2.3(A)(4)-

(41) in the same percentage that their initial bequest bears to the total amount of bequests made
in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41).
4. For purposes of this Agreement, "Household Goods associated with the use, recreational
use, maintenance or repair" of any of the New Mexico Property, the Florida Property, the GSJ
Property, the LSJ Property, the Paris Property or the New York Property shall mean all tangible
personal property which in the discretion of the Trustees is determined to be necessary or
appropriate in connection with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair of the New
Mexico Property, the Florida Property, the GSJ Property, the LSJ Property, the Paris Property
or the New York Property, as the case may be, including without limitation, household
appliances, household furniture, household furnishings, window treatments, linens, carpets,
household electronic equipment, recreational equipment, dishes, utensils, cutlery, cooking
equipment, cleaning equipment, tools and other items, materials and equipment associated with
such use, recreational use, maintenance or repair, and also including any and all livestock, and
materials, tools, equipment and vehicles associated with such livestock, and any and all
mechanical equipment, construction equipment, vehicles and watercraft determined by the
Trustees in their discretion to be necessary or appropriate for such use, recreational use,
maintenance or repair. Notwithstanding the foregoing, Household Goods shall not include any
of items of tangible personal property which the Trustees in their discretion determine to be my
personal possessions, even if located at any of the New Mexico Property, the Florida Property,
the GSJ Property, the LSJ Property, the Paris Property or the New York Property, including
without limitation, clothing, jewelry, watches, gemstones, artwork, sculpture, antiques, coins,
currency, or other items of personal property determined by the Trustees in their discretion to
be personal effects of mine ("Personal Possessions"). For the sake of further clarification, no
assets constituting securities, accounts, equity investments, debt investments, financial
instruments, or other financial assets or investment assets of any kind shall be included in the
definitions of Household Goods or Personal Possessions under this Agreement. In addition,
the Trustees shall have the sole discretion to determine whether or not an item of tangible
personal property shall be deemeds_be within the definition of Household Goods or Personal
Possessions under this Agreement'.'  tu° 9- ag iuuer ic c"4071vOtt igu t 456ametr=r ir
ceNciaisaiosi onseeethise. N-me wee- matuzseca-tst4or ...ettaw.ann",
5C I give to KARYNA SHULIAK, my diamond ring, set with a rectangular-cut diamond, a
weighing approximately 32.73 carats, flanked by baguette-cut diamonds mounted in platinum,
-1 4Z-2
12 -4tor' CONFIDENTIAL 8.DgrWCI2S17759
which rectangular-cut diamond is described in GIA Certificate Number 11197600 dated July
12, 2000, which accompanies the said diamond ring, as D Color and VSI clarity. If KARYNA
SHULIAK does not survive me, the diamond ring shall be sold and the proceeds distributed
asprovided in Section 2.4 of this Article 11.41;-'irce ,,,,,a.4 leag ue',  )4 IA..  'vie e a jos 964.O.12, imiatricortew
°Fitts -must r r
BED eaCig CeetteMPLAVON OF daeratee, -pc et.ta.tr Monesize is got fl aw It. I give io KARYNA SHULIAK all of my loose 
diamonds, including but not limited to,
48 separate loose diamonds, identified by accompanying GIA Certificate Numbers 11143371,
12813480, 12811989, 12813533, 12813246, 12813303, 11143338, 12813451, 12811971,
11143872, 12813183, 11143179, 12813216, 12813010, 12813292, 12813247, 11382484,
12813201, 12813180, 11383591, 12811956, 12813254, 11143341, 11143180, 11143350,
11383569, 11383584, 12263407, 10421632, 10768120, 12813255, 10177902, 12378695,
13100048, 13096420, 11383481, 12811577, 10429438, 12811796, 11383663, 11137800,
12263667, 12811562, 11137812, 12811824, 12811822, 11383651, 12811792. If KARYNA
SHULIAK does not survive me, the loose diamonds shall be sold and the proceeds distributed
as provided in Section 2.4 of this Article II.

7. All of my remaining Personal Possessions, which for the sake of clarity excludes
all Household Goods associated with the use, recreational use, maintenance or repair of any of
the New Mexico Property, the Florida Property, the GSJ Property, the LSJ Property, the Paris
Property or the New York Property, shall be sold by the Trustees, whether at auction or
otherwise and the proceeds shall be added to the residuary of the Trust and disposed of as
provided in Section 2.4 of this Article II.

Section 2.4. Residuary of Trust Estate
The residuary of the Trust Estate, after the distributions provided in Article II, Sections 2.1, 2.2 and
2.3 of this Agreement, shall be distributed to those persons named in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4)-(41)
pro rata in an amount equal to the percentage their individual bequest bears to the total amount of
bequests in Article II, Section 2.3(A)(4) — (41).

Section 2.5. — Condition Applicable to Certain Bequests
A. Except as expressly provided herein, no bequest to any Beneficiary of this
Agreement who, during my lifetime, was employed by or provided services to me or any entity that
was owned directly or indirectly by me during my lifetime or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity
owned by Darren K. Indyke, shall be distributed to said Beneficiary prior to the expiration of two
years following the date of my death. Any Beneficiary of this Agreement who, during my lifetime, was
employed by or provided services to me or any entity that was owned directly or indirectly by me
during my lifetime or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K. Indyke, and who,
after my death, shall voluntarily discontinue, or as a result of said Beneficiary's misconduct, cause to
be terminated, said Beneficiary's employment with or provision of services to my estate or any entity
or parcel of real property directly or indirectly owned by me during my lifetime or HBRK Associates,
Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K Indyke, prior to the expiration of two years following the date
of my death, shall be ineligible to receive any bequest hereunder; provided, however, that in the event
that prior to the expiration of two years following the date of my death, there is a cessation in the
specific operations of my estate or said real property or entity or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity
owned by Darren K. Indyke, in respect of which said Beneficiary is employed or provides services,
13
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007760
and prior to that cessation, said Beneficiary had not voluntarily discontinued, or as a result of said
Beneficiary's misconduct, caused to be terminated, said Beneficiary's employment with or provision of
services to my estate or said real property or entity or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by
Darren K. Indyke, then the Trustees shall distribute the bequest hereunder to said Beneficiary within
sixty days following the date of such cessation or as soon as is reasonably practicable thereafter.

B. In order to provide for the continued and uninterrupted maintenance and
operation of the assets in my Trust Estate following my death, the Trustees shall ensure that all
persons who were employed by, or provided services to, me or any entity directly or indirectly owned
by me or HBRK Associates, Inc. or any entity owned by Darren K. Indyke, shall continue to be so
employed or to so provide such services for a period of two (2) years following the date of my death;
provided, however, that the Trustees shall have the right terminate the employment or the
engagement of any such employees or service providers if and at such times as the Trustees determine
in their discretion that there is cause for such termination. For purposes of this Section 2.5 of this
Article II, cause for such termination shall include, without limitation, physical or mental incapacity,
intentional misconduct, insubordination, breach of duty, disloyalty, dishonesty, fraud, embezzlement,
theft, abusive or inappropriate workplace behavior, substance abuse, criminal misconduct (whether or
not pertaining to the assets in the Trust Estate), decrease or cessation of the need for employment or
services, or any other circumstances causing the Trustees to determine in their discretion that there is
cause for such termination. The obligation of the Trustees to ensure such continued employment or
provision of services shall include, without limitation, payment out of the assets of the Trust Estate
for the costs and expenses of all items of compensation, remuneration and benefits as shall then be in
effect at the then current rates and in the then current amounts immediately prior to my death.

C. The provisions of this Section 2.5 of this Article II shall not apply to the
Trustees so long as they continue to serve as the Trustees hereunder.

D. The provisions of this Section 2.5 of this Article U shall not apply to the
provisions of Article II, Sections 2.3(A)(42), (43), (44), (46), (47), (48), and (49), of this Agreement.

Section 2.6. — Trust Property that Is Real Property
Any trust property that is real property, that is renounced or disclaimed by KARYNA SHULIAK and
including, but not limited to, improvements, fixtures, permits and other
rights of and pertaining to such real property, held directly by me, or indirectly through ownership of
shares of capital stock of a corporation or membership interests in a limited liability company of which
I was the sole beneficial owner prior to my death, shall be sold by the Trustees and the proceeds
thereof held in said trust as soon as is reasonably practicable following my death. In marketing and
effectuating the sale of said real property, the Trustees shall be guided as nearly as the Trustees
determine in their discretion is possible or appropriate under the then prevailing circumstances by my
last express wishes with respect to the sale of said real property, as shall be contained in the last writing
signed by me and notarized and delivered to at least one of the Trustees prior to my death. The
proceeds of said sales shall be distributed in accordance with the provisions of Section 2.4.
14
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007761
Article III
Trust for Operating Expenses
3.1 Trust for Operating Expenses

A. All sums directed to be held in trust for KARYNA SHULIAK in accordance with the provisions
of this Section 3.1 of this Article III shall be administered as follows:

1. DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees of
the trust administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.1(A) of this
Article III.

2. Unless and until such trust terminates as provided in Article III, Section
3.1(A)(5) of this Agreement, the Trustees may, in their discretion, apply at any time
and from time to time any part or all of the income of such trust and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of such trust to the payment of any and all operating
expenses for the properties.

3. For purposes of this Section 3.1(A) of this Article III, "operating expenses"
shall include, but not be limited to, all expenses that the Trustees, in their discretion,
determine are required or appropriate in order to pay property insurance, real estate
taxes, utilities and general maintenance and repairs for the said properties.

4. Fot the sake of clarity, the Trustees shall not be required to pay from the
income or principal of such trust any operating expenses for any property that is not
personally used and occupied by KARYNA SHULIAK or that is sold by KARYNA
SHULIAK.

5. After the death of KARYNA SHULIAK, no further payments shall be made
from the income or principal of such trust other than for operating expenses that
accrued prior to the date of such event, and the Trustees shall distribute all remaining
principal and income then remaining in such mist pursuant to the provisions of
Article II, Section 2.4 of this Agreement.

B. All sums directed to be held in trust for in accordance with the
provisions of this Section 3.1 of this Article III shall be administered as follows:

1. DARREN K INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN shall be the Trustees of
the trust administered in accordance with the provisions of this Section 3.1(B) of this
Article III.

2. Unless and until such mist terminates as provided in Section Article III,
3.1(B)(5) of this Agreement, the Trustees may, in their discretion, apply at any time
and from time to time any part or all of the income of such trust and such sums from
any part or all of the principal of such trust to the payment of any and all operating
expenses for any or all of the properties.
IS
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007762

3. For purposes of this Section 3.1(B) of this Article III, "operating expenses"
shall include, but not be limited to, aR expenses that the Trustees, in their discretion,
determine are required or appropriate in order to pay property insurance, real estate
taxes, utilities and general maintenance and repairs for the said properties.

4. For the sake of clarity, the Trustees shall not be required to pay from the
income or principal of such trust any operating expenses for an property that is not
personally used and occupied by I  or that is sold by

5. After the death of the trust for her benefit under
the provisions of this Section 3.1(B) of this Article III shall terminate, no further
payments shall be made from the income or principal of such trust other than for
operating expenses that accrued prior to the date of such event, and the Trustees
shall distribute all remaining principal and income then remaining in such trust
pursuant to the provisions of Article II, Section 2.4 of this Agreement
Athcle  IV
Trust Administration

Section 4.1. - Exercise of Discretionary Powers
Except as hereinbefore specifically provided, in connection with the exercise of a discretionary power
to distribute income or principal to any person, there shall be no requirement to take into account
such person's other income or capital resources, the interest of such person in any other fund or the
duty of anyone to support such person, although these factors may be taken into account.

Section 4.2. - Discretionary Distributions
Any discretionary payment from any trust hereunder shall be charged against such trust as a whole,
and shall not be charged against the individual share of any person at any time.

Section 4.3. - Allocation of Assets

A. For each distribution, partial distribution, allocation, or division of assets into
shares or trusts involving a fraction, the Trustees shall apply such fraction to the fair market value of
the relevant assets on the date of such distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurs. The
Trustees shall appropriately adjust such fractions to reflect the effect of any partial distributions,
allocations, or divisions, taking into account the fait market value as of the date of distribution,
allocation, or division, whichever first occurred, of the assets so distributed, allocated, or divided.

B. The Trustees shall value any assets distributed, allocated, or divided to satisfy
(m whole or in part) a pecuniary distribution at the fair market value of such assets on the date of such
distribution, allocation, or division, whichever first occurs.
16
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007763

Section 4.4. - Accounting Allocations

A. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement and except as
provided in Paragraph B of this Section 4.4, the Trustees shall allocate receipts and disbursements in
accordance with sound trust accounting principles and have discretion to allocate receipts and
disbursements when, in the judgment of the Trustees, the treatment is uncertain under applicable laws
or generally accepted accounting principles.
B. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, the Trustees
shall not treat any part of the principal amount of the proceeds of sale of any asset of any trust as
income distributable to or for the benefit of any beneficiary entitled to distributions of income;
provided, however, that the Trustees shall treat a portion of any proceeds of sale of any financial
instrument originally issued or acquired at a discount equal to the amount which (1) has previously
been characterized as ordinary income for income tax purposes or (2) will be characterized as ordinary
income for income tax purposes in the year of such sale, as income for trust accounting purposes.

Section 4.5. - Spendthrift Provision
During the term of any mist hereunder, no money or other assets (either principal or income) payable
or distributable under the provisions of this Agreement shall be pledged, assigned, transferred, given,
conveyed, hypothecated, sold, anticipated, charged, or encumbered by any of the Beneficiaries
hereunder, nor shall the income and principal of any trust, while in the possession of the Trustees, be
liable for any debts, contracts, obligations, or undertakings of such Beneficiaries, voluntary or
involuntary, or for any claims or judgments against any Beneficiary, including claims for alimony or
for the support of any Beneficiary's spouse or children, or for reimbursement of a federal, state or
local government, or any agency of any federal, state, or local government, for the support of any
Beneficiary hereunder, prior to the time such money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such
Beneficiary. Any attempted pledge, assignment, transfer, gift, conveyance, hypothecation, anticipation,
charge, or encumbrance of any money or assets (either income or principal) payable or distributable
under the provisions of this Agreement by any of the Beneficiaries hereunder prior to the time such
money or assets are actually paid or distributed to such Beneficiary shall be null and void and shall not
be recognized by the Trustees. This Section 4.5 of this Article V shall not apply to me.

Section 4.6. - Limitation on Distributions
Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement, no discretionary distribution of income or
principal of any trust hereunder shall be applied to pay for medical care, residential facilities, or any
other care or service that would otherwise be provided for any Beneficiary hereunder by any federal,
state, or other governmental agency; and no such discretionary distribution of income or principal
shall be made for reimbursement for any such care, facilities or services previously provided. Before
making any discretionary payment to or for the benefit of any such Beneficiary hereunder, the
Trustees shall consider the amounts such Beneficiary is or may be entitled to receive from any
governmental agency for such care, facilities, or services. If such amounts are available, discretionary
distributions of income and principal from any trust hereunder shall be made only to supplement such
amounts, and to provide liberally for needs and comforts over and above the basic maintenance,
support, and medical care that may be paid for by any such agency.
17
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007764

Section 4.7. - Division and Combination of Trusts

A. For any administrative, tax or other purpose determined by the Trustees to be
in the best interests of any Beneficiary (including any remaindertnan) hereunder, the Trustees may at
any time and from time to time (whether before or after funding), without approval of any court,
divide any trust under this Agreement into two or more separate trusts or combine two or more mists
with substantially identical terms (whether or not such trusts resulted from division of a prior trust).

B. If property is directed to be added to any trust hereunder (the "Original
Trust"), whether by the terms of this Agreement any other agreement, or the Will of any person, the
Trustees may hold such property as one or more separate trusts on terms identical to the terms of the
Original Trust The Trustees may allocate such property among the separate trusts (if any) into which
the Original Trust was divided, whether or not pro-rata, using specific assets or undivided interests
therein (including allocation of all such property to one of such separate trusts).
C. Any time during the existence of separate trusts created by division of a trust
hereunder, the Trustees may exercise all discretionary powers differently with respect to the separate
trusts and take all other actions consistent with such trusts being separate entities. Furthermore, the
holder of any power of appointment with respect to such separate trusts may exercise such power
differently with respect to each such trust.

Section 4.8. - Consolidation of Trusts
If at any time after my death there is in existence a trust under my Will or any trust agreement created
by me having identical beneficiaries and substantially the same terms as any trust under this
Agreement, the Trustees may terminate the mast hereunder and transfer the assets thereof to the
Trustees of such other trust, to be administered by the Trustees thereof. Different termination dates
under the applicable Rule Against Perpetuities shall not be deemed a difference in the terms of such
trusts, but the portion of the trust representing the transferred assets shall retain the same termination
date as the original trust.

Section 4.9. -Termination of Trusts
Notwithstanding anything herein, any trust created hereunder for any person shall (unless terminated
earlier) terminate upon the day preceding the expiration of the maximum period permitted under the
United States Virgin Islands Rule Against Perpetuities, for the vesting of an interest in a trust and
upon such date the assets of such trust shall be distributed to such person.

Section 4.10.  — EquitableAdjustment
If any of the Trustees decides to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this
Agreement or by law (including, without limitation, any election available to any Trustee) and the
exercise or nonexercise of such power confers a benefit on one Beneficiary or class of Beneficiaries
hereunder and imposes a detriment upon another Beneficiary or class of Beneficiaries hereunder, the
Trustees shall not attempt to restore the interests of the Beneficiaries or classes of Beneficiaries to the
position otherwise contemplated by this Agreement through adjustment between income and
principal or otherwise.
18
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007765

Section 4 .11. - Lapsed Distribution
Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, a provision for distribution to an
individual who is not surviving at the date such individual otherwise becomes eligible for such
distribution shall lapse notwithstanding any law to the contrary.

Section 4.12. - Notice
Any notice required hereunder shall be delivered personally or sent by first class or certified mail
addressed to the last known address of the intended recipient.

Section 4.13. - Termination of Trust
An instrument in writing completely revoking this Agreement shall, without more, upon delivery
to any of the Trustees, completely terminate all of the Trustees' tight, title, and interest to any life
insurance proceeds, death benefits, pension, profit sharing, or other retirement benefits or any
other assets otherwise payable to the Trustees.
Article V
Powers of Trustees'

Section 5.1. - Exercise of Judgment and Powers
The Trustees of each mist hereunder have the entire care and custody of all assets of such trust.
The Trustees have the power to do everything the Trustees in good faith deem advisable without
necessity of any judicial authorization or approval, even though but for this power it would not
be authorized or appropriate for fiduciaries under any statutory or other rule of law. The Trustees
shall exercise the Trustees' best judgment and discretion for what the Trustees believe to be in the
best interests of such trust and the Beneficiaries of such trust. If two Trustees are empowered to
participate in a decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement
or by law, such decision must be made unanimously by the Trustees. If more than two Trustees
are empowered as the Trustee to participate in the decision to exercise or not exercise any
fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, a majority of such Trustees shall be
empowered to make such decision.

Section 5.2. - Compensation of the Trustees
Each Trustee acting hereunder (without regard to the number of separate trusts for which such
Trustee is so acting) shall be entitled to annual compensation for services performed hereunder in
the amount of Two Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($250,000) per year, in addition to any
bequest to which they may be entitled under this terms of this Agreement. No other
compensation shall be payable to the Trustees hereunder, provided, however, that the Trustees
shall be reimbursed for all reasonable costs, expenses, charges, and liabilities incurred or paid in
connection with acting as Trustee or performing services hereunder, including, but not limited to,
fees and expenses of counsel or any other agents hired by the Trustees, and the Trustees shall not
be liable therefor individually. The Trustees have discretion to pay such compensation and such
reimbursements from trust assets, without obtaining judicial authorization or approval.
19
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007766

Section 5.3. - General Investment Powers

A. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, the Trustees have the
power with respect to each and every trust created hereunder.

1. To enter upon and take possession of the assets of such trust and collect
the income and profits from such assets, and to invest and reinvest such assets in real,
personal, or mixed assets (including the common trust funds of a corporate fiduciary) or
in undivided interests therein without being limited by any present or future investment
laws;

2. To retain all or any part of the assets of such mist (without regard to the
proportion that any one asset or class of assets may bear to the whole) in the form in
which such assets were received or acquired by the Trustees;

3. To sell or dispose of, exchange, transfer, invest, or loan all or any part of the
assets of such trust which the Trustees hold, at any time, for such sums or upon such terms as
to payment, security, or otherwise as the Trustees determine, either by public or private
transactions;

4. To buy and sell options, warrants, puts, calls or other rights to purchase or sell
(collectively called "options') relating to any security or securities, regardless of whether such
security or securities are then held by the Trustees, and whether such options are purchased or
sold on a national securities exchange, and to exercise with respect to such options all powers
which an individual owner thereof could exercise, including, without limitation, the right to
allow the same to expire;
5. With respect to oil, natural gas, minerals, and all other natural resources and
rights to and interests therein (together with all equipment pertaining thereto) including,
without limiting the generality of the foregoing, oil and gas royalties, leases, or other oil and
gas interests of any character, whether owned in fee, as lessee, lessor, licensee, concessionaire
or otherwise, or alone or jointly with others as partner, joint tenant, or joint venturer in any
other noncorporatc manner, (a) to make oil, gas and mineral leases or subleases; (b) to pay
delay rentals, lease bonuses, royalties, overriding royalties, taxes, assessments, and all other
charges; (c) to sell, lease, exchange, mortgage, pledge or otherwise hypothecate any or all of
such rights and interests; (d) to surrender or abandon, with or without consideration, any or all
of such rights and interests; (e) to make farm-out, pooling, and unitization agreements; (f) to
make reservations or impose conditions on the transfer of any such rights or interests; (g) to
employ the most advantageous business form in which properly to exploit such rights and
interests, whether as corporations, partnerships, limited partnerships, mining partnerships,
joint ventures, co- tenancies, or otherwise exploit any and all such rights and interests; (la) to
produce, process, sell or exchange all products recovered through the exploitation of such
rights and interests, and to enter into contracts and agreements for or in respect of the
installation or operation of absorption, reprocessing or other processing plants; (i) to carry any
or all such interests in the name or names of a nominee or nominees; G) to delegate, to the
extent permitted by law, any or all of the powers set forth herein to the operator of such
property; and (k) to employ personnel, rent office space, buy or lease office equipment,
20
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007767
contract and pay for geological surveys and studies, procure appraisals, and generally to
conduct and engage in any and all activities incident to the foregoing powers, with full power
to borrow and pledge in order to finance such activities; together with the power to allocate
between principal and income any net proceeds received as consideration, whether as royalties
or otherwise, for the permanent severance from lands of oil, natural gas, minerals, and all
other natural resources;

6. To hold all or any part of the assets of such trust in cash or in bank accounts
without the necessity of investing the same;

7. To improve, repair, partition, plat, or subdivide all or any part of the assets
of such trust;
8. To litigate, defend, compromise, settle, abandon, or submit to mediation or
arbitration on such terms and conditions as the Trustees determine any claims in favor of or
against such mist or the assets of such trust;

9. To loan or borrow money in such amounts and upon such terms and conditions as the
Trustees determine, assume such obligations or give such guarantees as the Trustees
determine, for the purpose of the acquisition, improvement, protection, retention, or
preservation of the assets of such trust, or for the benefit of any of the Beneficiaries who are
entitled or permitted to receive income from such oust;

10. To create or invest in any entity with all or part of the assets of such mist and
to carry on for as long and in such manner as the Trustees determine any business enterprise
held or created by the Trustees or in which I owned any interest at my death, either
individually or as a partner, joint venturer, stockholder, trust beneficiary, or member; to sell
such business enterprise as an ongoing business; to consolidate, merge, encumber, dissolve,
liquidate or undertake any other extraordinary corporate transaction relating to such business
enterprise;

11. To vote in person or by proxy any and all stock or securities and to become a
party to any voting trusts, reorganization, consolidation, or other capital or debt readjustment
of any corporation, association, partnership, limited liability partnership, limited liability
company, or individual with respect to stocks, securities, or debts held by such trust;

12. Except as provided in Sections 5.3(B), (C), and (D) of this Article V, to enter
into any good faith transactions with the Trustees individually or with any corporation,
partnership, limited liability partnership, limited liability company, or other entity in which any
of the Trustees has an ownership interest,

13. To purchase from my estate any stocks, bonds, securities, real or personal
property, or other assets, or make loans to my estate even though the same person or persons
occupy the office of the Trustee and the office of the Executor of my estate;

14. To lease, mortgage, pledge, grant a security interest in, or otherwise encumber
all or any part of the assets of such trust for any term of years whether or not beyond the term
of such trust (including, without limitation, any such action for the benefit of any of the
Beneficiaries of such trust);
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007768

15. To abandon any property of such trust, real or personal, which the Trustees
may deem worthless or not of sufficient value to warrant keeping or protecting; to abstain
from the payment of taxes, water rents or assessments and to forego making repairs,
maintaining or keeping up any such property; and to permit such property to be lost by tax
sale or other proceedings or to convey any such property for a nominal consideration or
without consideration so as to prevent the imposition of any liability by reason of the
continued ownership thereof;

16. To elect the mode of distribution of the proceeds from any profit-sharing
plan, pension plan, employee benefit plan, individual retirement plan, insurance contract, or
annuity contract pursuant to the terms of such plan or to change to another custodian of
such plan;

17. To conduct any audit, assessment, or investigation with respect to any
asset of such trust regarding compliance with any law or regulation having as its object
protection of public health, natural resources, or the environment (referred to as
"Environmental Laws"); to pay from the assets of such trust to remedy any failure to
comply with any Environmental Law (even to the exhaustion of all of the assets of such
trust); and, as may be required in the Trustees' judgment by any Environmental Law, to
notify any governmental authority of any past, present, or future non-compliance with any
Environmental Law; and

18. To refuse to accept any asset distributable to such trust.
B. No Trustee shall directly or indirectly buy or sell any property for the
trust from or to himself, or from or to his relative, employer, employee, partner or other
business associate.
C.
of another trust.
No Trustee shall as trustee of one trust sell property to himself as trustee

D. No Trustee shall lend trust funds to himself, or to his relative, employer,
employee, partner, or other business associate.

Section 5.4. - Administrative Powers
Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, the Trustees have the power with respect to
each trust

A. To employ agents, attorneys-at-law, consultants, investment advisers (to
whom the Trustees have discretion to delegate the Trustees' investment authority and
responsibility), other trustees and other fiduciaries in the administration of the Trustees' duties,
to delegate to such persons, or to one or more of the Trustees, the custody, control, or
management of any part of the assets of such trust as the Trustees determine and to pay for
such services from the assets of such trust, without obtaining judicial authorization orapproval;
22
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007769

B. To delegate, in whole or in part, to any person or persons the authority
and power to (1) sign checks, drafts or orders for the payment or withdrawal of funds, securities
and other assets from any bank, brokerage, custody or other account in which funds, securities
or other assets of such trust shall be deposited, (2) endorse for sale, transfer or delivery, or sell,
transfer or deliver, or purchase or otherwise acquire, any and all property, stocks, stock warrants,
stock rights, options, bonds or other securities whatsoever, (3) gain access to any safe deposit
box or boxes in which assets of such trust may be located or which may be in the name of any
of the Trustees and remove part or all of the contents of any such safe deposit box or boxes and
release and surrender the same, and (4) take any other action that the Trustees may have the
power to take with respect to such trust and the property thereof; no person or corporation
acting in reliance on any such delegation shall be charged with notice of any revocation or
change of such delegation unless such person or corporation receives actual notice thereof;

C. To pay any property distributable to a Beneficiary under a legal disability
or who has not attained the age of 21, without liability to the Trustees, by paying such property

(1) to such Beneficiary, (2) for the use of such Beneficiary, (3) to a legal representative of such
Beneficiary appointed by a court or if none, to a relative for the use of such Beneficiary, or (4)
to a custodian for such Beneficiary designated by the Trustees, to hold until age 21 or such
earlier age as shall be the maximum permitted under applicable law;

D. To divide such trust into subsidiary accounts if the Trustees determine
that such division is necessary to maintain fair and accurate records;
F:. To permit the Beneficiary of such trust to use, possess, and enjoy real
property, tangible personal property, or dub memberships held by such trust;

F. To distribute to such trust or any of the Beneficiaries of such trust in kind
or in cash, or partly in kind and partly in cash, and to allocate different kinds or disproportionate
shares of assets or undivided interests in assets among all of such trusts or all of such
Beneficiaries;

G. In making the division into one or more trusts hereunder (if such trusts
have the same Trustees), to keep the assets of such trusts invested and handled as a single fund
without actual division and to designate such trusts on the Trustee? books as owning a
designated undivided interest in such fund;

H. To have evidence of ownership of any security maintained in the records
of a Federal Reserve Bank under the Federal Reserve Book Entry System; to deposit funds in
any bank or trust company; to carry in the name of any of the Trustees or the nominee or
nominees of the Trustees and with or without designation of fiduciary capacity, or to hold in
bearer form, securities or other property requiring or permitting of registration; and to cause any
securities to be held by a depository corporation of which a Trustee is a member or by an agent
under a safekeeping contract provided, however, that the books and records of the Trustees
shall at all times show that such investments are part of such trust;

I. To register or not register such trust with the probate division of the
Superior Court of the United States Virgin Islands or otherwise and to make all decisions which
23
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007770
relate thereto;

J. Except as otherwise specifically provided in this Agreement, to give any
Beneficiary of any trust hereunder a general power of appointment exercisable in such
Beneficiary's Will over all or part of such trust, subject to any terms and conditions as the
Trustees determine, by written notice to such Beneficiary; to eliminate any such power of
appointment by written notice to the Beneficiary; and to irrevocably release the power under this
paragraph to give a power of appointment or to eliminate a power of appointmenr,
K To renounce and disclaim, in whole or in part, and in accordance with
applicable law, any assets, interests, rights, or powers Including any power of appointment)
which are payable to (or exercisable by) such trust or over which the Trustees have any right,
title, interest, or power; and

L. To make, execute, and deliver any and all such instruments in writing as
shall be necessary or proper to carry out any power, tight, duty, or obligation of the Trustees or
any disposition whatsoever of such mist or any asset of such trust and to exercise any and all
other powers incidental or necessary to carry out or to fulfill the terms, provisions and purposes
of such trust.

Section 5.5. - Restrictions on Exercise of The Trustee's Powers

A. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, a
Trustee shall not participate in a discretionary decision to exercise or not exercise any fiduciary
power to (1) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder to himself or herself or

(2) distribute income from or principal of any trust hereunder for the health, support,
maintenance or education of a Beneficiary if such Trustee has a legal obligation to provide for
the health, support, maintenance or education of such Beneficiary from such Trustee's personal
assets. For purposes of this paragraph, a person whose interest in a trust hereunder is limited to
a remote contingent interest (for example, a contingent remainderman whose interest depends
upon another person failing to survive to a specified age or a person designated to receive assets
only in the event a power of appointment is not exercised) shall not be treated as a person who
is or may be a Beneficiary of such trust.

B. A Trustee of any trust hereunder may by a written notice delivered to the
other Trustee (or Trustees) of such trust decline to participate in the decision to exercise or not
exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or bylaw.
C. If a Trustee of any trust hereunder is not empowered (because of a
conflict of interest, declination to act or otherwise) to participate in the decision to exercise or
not exercise any fiduciary power granted by this Agreement or by law, then the remaining
Trustee or Trustees of such trust shall be empowered to make such decision. If no Trustee or
successor Trustee is empowered to participate in such decision, the Trustees may designate a
substitute Trustee to serve as Trustee of such mist who shall be empowered to make such
decision but has no other power or authority of the Trustees. Such designation shall be by
written notice delivered to such substitute Trustee.
24
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007771
Article VI
Provisions Concerning Trustees

Section 6.1. - Successor Trustees
In the event a Trustee of the Trust resigns, is removed, becomes incapacitated or is unwilling or
is unable to serve, a successor Trustee shall be appointed to fill the vacancy thereby created, such
that the total number of Trustees acting on behalf of the Trust at all times shall be two. BORIS
NIKOLIC shall be appointed to fill any such vacancy, and if he is unwilling or unable to serve,
BARNABY MARSH shall be appointed to fill any such vacancy. If BARNABY MARSH is
unwilling or unable to serve, then ANTHONY BARRETT shall be appointed to fill such
vacancy. If ANTHONY BARRETT is unwilling or unable to serve, then KATHY REUMMLER
shall be appointed to fill such vacancy. If KATHY REUMMLER is unwilling or unable to serve,
then DAVID MITCHELL shall be appointed to fill such vacancy. If DAVID MITCHELL is
unwilling or unable to serve, then STEVE HANSON shall be appointed to fill such vacancy. If
STEVE HANSON is unwilling or unable to serve, then EVA DUBIN shall be appointed to fill
such vacancy and thereafter the successor Trustee appointed to fill any such vacancy shall be
appointed by the Trustees then acting, or, if as a result of said vacancy, only one Trustee is then
acting, by the sole remaining Trustee then acting.

Section 6.2. - Appointment of Trustee
The appointment of a successor Trustee hereunder shall become effective when such successor
Trustee signs an acceptance of the trust.

Section 6.3. - Resignation of Trustees
Any Trustee may resign at any time, without the approval of any court, by an instrument in writing
fled with the trust records. In addition, if there is filed with the trust records a written certification
from any attending physician of any individual Trustee of a trust that he or she is no longer able to
make decisions with respect to such trust, then from the date of filing of such certification, such
individual 'frustee shall be deemed to have resigned for all purposes of this Agreement.

Section 6.4. - Vacancy in Office
If there is a vacancy in the Trustees and no successor Trustee is designated pursuant to Section 7.1
who is willing to act, the legally competent adult Beneficiary (or a majority in beneficial interest of the
legally competent adult Beneficiaries if there are multiple Beneficiaries) then entitled or permitted to
receive income from such trust shall designate a successor Trustee by an instrument in writing
delivered to the designated Trustee. If the legally competent adult Beneficiaries do not designate a
successor Trustee within sixty days after receipt of notice of such vacancy or if there is no legally
competent adult Beneficiary of such trust, then a successor Trustee shall be named by order of a court
of competent jurisdiction. All of the fees and expenses of the Trustees (including attorneys' fees)
attributable to the appointment of a successor Trustee of a trust shall be paid from the assets of such
trust.

Section 6.5. - Elimination of Bond
25
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007772
No bond or other security shall be required of any Trustee hereunder in any jurisdiction.

Section 6.6. - Exculpation and Indemnification of the Trustees
No one serving as the Trustee of any trust under this Agreement shall be accountable or responsible
to any person interested in any trust hereunder for the manner in which the Trustees shall in good
faith exercise any discretionary authority or any power of the Trustees. No one serving as the Trustee
of any trust under this Agreement shall be liable for any loss or depreciation in value occasioned by
reason of any negligence, error or mistake of judgment in entering into any transaction, in making any
sale or investment, in continuing to hold any property, or by reason of any action or omission,
whether by the Trustees or any other fiduciary, unless such Trustee has acted in bad faith. In the
absence of proof by affirmative evidence to the contrary, each Trustee shall be deemed to have acted
within the scope of the Trustees' authority, to have exercised reasonable care, diligence, and prudence
and to have acted impartially as to all interested persons. A Trustee shall not be liable for the acts or
defaults of another Trustee.
In the event a legal action is brought against any individual serving as the Trustee of any trust under
this Agreement, all legal fees and related expenses incurred in connection with the defense of such
legal action shall be paid by such trust without court authorization; provided, however, that (a) no
such payment shall (or shall continue to) be made if a court enters an order prohibiting such payment,
and (b) such Trustee shall refund to the trust any such payments that previously had been made if a
court enters an order directing that such payments be refunded, or if a court concludes that such
Trustee acted in bad faith.

Section 6.7. - Relief from Virgin Islands Statutory Provisions
Pursuant to Section 1212, Tide 15, of the Virgin Islands Code, I hereby relieve the Trustees and any
successor Trustees of the requirements imposed by Chapter 59, Tide 15 of the Virgin Islands Code, or
any similar successor law respecting public filings of inventories and accountings by Trustees.
Furthermore, pursuant to Section 1107, Title 15, of the Virgin Islands Code, I hereby relieve the
Trustees and any successor Trustees, to the extent allowable, from any and all duties, restrictions, and
liabilities which would otherwise be imposed upon the Trustees by Chapter 57, Tide 15, Virgin Islands
Code. This Section 7.7 of this Article VII shall not be deemed a waiver of any and all other rights,
powers, or restrictions otherwise granted to the Trustees in this Agreement.
Article VII
Miscellaneous Provisions

Section 7.1. - Representation of Person Under a Disability
To the extent allowed by law, where a party to any proceeding with respect to any trust hereunder has
the same interest as a person under a disability, legal process shall not be required on the person under
a disability.

Section 7.2. Simultaneous Deaths
If a Beneficiary under this Agreement and I die simultaneously or under such circumstances that it is
difficult to determine who died first, then for all purposes of this Agreement such Beneficiary shall be
deemed to have predeceased me.
26
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007773

Section 7.3, - Law Governing
This Agreement and each trust created by it shall in all respects and for all purposes be governed and
regulated by the laws of the Territory of the United States Virgin Islands, as they now exist and may
from time to time be enacted, amended, or repealed. All questions regarding the validity, construction
and administration of this Agreement, or any of its provisions, and of any trust created by it shall be
determined solely by the laws of that Tenitory. The courts of the State of Delaware and the U.S.
Virgin Islands shall have primary supervision over the administration of each trust created by this
Agreement. It is intended that each such trust shall be a U.S. domestic trust as defined in Title 26
section 7701(2)(30) of the Code by virtue of meeting the court and control test. As provided in
Treas. Reg. section 301.7701-7(c)(4)(D), if both a United States court and a foreign court are able to
exercise primary supervision over the administration of the trust, the trust meets the court test.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, the Trustees of each trust created under
this Agreement have discretion at any time or times following my death to transfer the sires of such
trust to such other country, or such other jurisdiction as the Trustees determine, without obtaining
judicial authorization or approval (unless such judicial authorization or approval is required by
applicable law) and without the filing of any bond. The Trustees' determination to transfer the situs of
any trust under this Agreement shall be evidenced by an instrument in writing signed, witnessed and
acknowledged by the Trustees in the same manner as would be required for a deed. The Trustees arc
authorized to take whatever actions are necessary to effect such a transfer of situs. If judicial
authorization or approval is required to effect such a transfer of situs, I intend and desire that the
appropriate court accept the determination of the Trustees concerning the transfer of the situs of such
trust even if one or more Beneficiaries disagree with such determination. From and after the Trustees'
transfer of the situs of a mist pursuant to this Section 7.3 of this Article VII the administration of
such trust shall be governed by the law of the new situs of such trust.

Section 7.4. - Definition of Terms
Except as otherwise specifically provided herein, as used in this Agreement,

A. The term "Trustee" means all persons or entities who occupy the office of
Trustee of any trust hereunder while such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more
persons or entities occupy the office of Trustee at the same time or times, and includes any successor
Trustee or Trustees. The term "Executor" of a person's estate means all persons or entities who
occupy the office of personal representative, administrator, executor, or ancillary administrator while
such persons or entities occupy such office, whether one or more persons or entities occupy such
office at the same time or times, and includes any successor or successors to that office. A reference to
a person's Will means such person's Last Will and Testament and any Codicil or Codicils thereto.

B. A reference to any tax also includes any interest or penalties thereon. The
term "my Gross Estate" means my gross estate as finally determined for purposes of computing my
federal estate tax.
C. Whenever the singular number is used, the same shall include the plural, and
the masculine gender shall include the feminine and neuter genders.
27
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007774

Section 7.5. - No Contest
If any Beneficiary under this Agreement shall in any way directly or indirectly (a) contest or object to
the probate of my Will or to the validity of any disposition or provision of my Will or of this
Agreement or (b) institute or prosecute, or be in any way directly or indirectly instrumental in the
institution or prosecution of, any action, proceeding, contest, objection or claim for the purpose of
setting aside or invalidating my Will or this Agreement or any disposition therein or herein or
provision thereof or hereof, then I direct that (aa) any and all provisions in this Agreement for such
Beneficiary and his issue in any degree shall be null and void and (bb) my estate whether passing under
my Will or this Agreement or pursuant to the laws of intestacy shall be disposed of as if such
Beneficiary and his issue in any degree had all failed to survive me.

Section 7.6. -Trustee Notice
The Trustees may have duties and responsibilities in addition to those described in this Agreement.
If the Trustees have questions, the Trustees should obtain legal advice.
CONCLUSION
Whereas I have duly executed this Agreement on the date set opposite my signature.
August 8, 2019
Jeffrey E. pstein
STATE OF NEW YORK
residing at
residing at
)ss:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
Subscribed and sworn to before me by JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, the Grantor, who is personally known to me-or
whet-ban-preatteed- as_ideratifittetionrand by So'elea— CO-O4  a witness who is personally
known to me or-vrho-kras-prochrcetl-as-ideatification, and Cou Li4cfus. Tom-'  a
witness who is personally known to me t F>  as identification, on August 8, 2019.
Sworn to before me this 8i6 day of August, 2019.
il1/O14vol, 1 /
Notary Public
NIIJIANA A.MBLINDEZ
Nay PeNclites • f Nei York
Na 0261B6371741
QuoLintod Nag York Cate ,
Comosion loomMoir 5040 •"n4
28
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007 775
August IS, 2019
residing at _
residing at
STATE OF FLORIDA
)ss:
COUNTY OF PALM )
BEACH
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this 1512 day of August, 2019, by
DARRF.N K. INDYICE, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
as identification.
Sworn to before me this  03 ch clay of
August, 2019.
r
Notary Public
29 CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007776
ahlia  ill il l°
Richard D. Kahn, Trustee
STATE OF NEW YORK )
)ss:
COUNTY OF -NEW—)
QJGeti
August." ,2019
residing at
residing at
The foregoing instrument was subscribed and sworn to before me this a_. day of August, 2019, by
RICH AND LKAHN, a Trustee, who is personally known to me or who has produced
r S 1)  as identification.
Sworn to before me this
; 4 day of August, 2019.
Nota blic
sbase.e.....esesestest
4 ANDRES J MUNOZ
Notary Pune • State of New York

NO. OIMU6349473
Queen in Ovens County
My Commission Expires Oct IT. 2020 0
30
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00007777
GRANTOR'S AFFIDAVIT
We, Jeffrey E. Epstein tAO4.‘ Pc. Cok m o  and  aillnora z the Grantor and the witnesses respectively, whose names are 
signed to the attached instrument in
those
capacities, personally appearing before the undersigned authority and first being duly sworn, do hereby
declare to the undersigned authority under penalty of perjury that the Grantor declared, signed, and
executed the instrument as his trust agreement including the handwritten changes made on pages
S, 12- 4 13 • he signed it willingly; he executed it as his free and
voluntary act for the purposes therein expressed; and each of the witnesses, at the request of the
Grantor, in his or her hearing and presence, and in the presence of each other, signed the Trust
Agreement as witness and that to the best of his or her knowledge, the Grantor was at that time
eighteen (18) years of age or older, of sound mind and under no constraint or undue influence.
STATE OF NEW YORK
residing at
residing at
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
)ss:
Subscribed and sworn to before me by JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, the Grantor, who is personally known to me or
who has produced as identification, and by a witness who is personally
known to me or who has produced as identification, and , a
witness who is personally known to me or who has produced as identification, on August 8, 2019.
Sworn to before me this 8th day of August, 201.
flazin Notary Public
MARIANA A- MBIZPIDEZ
Noway Putts, Sate of New York

No. 02)4B6311741
Qualified in New You County
ra^mtlaiCIO Expires Marcia 5111. 20 2  a
31
CONFIDENTIAL SONY_GM_00007778
SCHEDULE A
Daslipliallsanuiatnixax
CONFIDENTIAL ---- EFT,00120,151

╭─ Page 32, Image 1 ─╮
│ SCHEDULE A         │
│                    │
│ Descripti          │
│                    │
│ $100.00            │
│                    │
│ CONFIDENTIAL "“*"" │
│                    │
│ EFTA_00120451      │
╰────────────────────╯
EFTA01660676 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip about recently convicted rapists Tal and Oren Alexander at Epstein's house, see quote: "<REDACTED stated Oren raped <REDACTED 
and Oren's brother, Tal, raped a 14 year old girl named <REDACTED. <REDACTED tried to slit her wrist after the incident" [bbc]
(date: 2019-08-08)
Crisis Intake (Rev. 5-23-17)     UNCLASSIFIED     OFFICIAL RECORD
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Crisis Intake
Date: 08/08/2019

Case ID #: 31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX TRAFFICKING
Drafted By: <REDACTED>

Date/Time Received: 08/08/2019 09:23 AM EDT

Details:
On <REDACTED> at <REDACTED> p.m. Eastern Time, <REDACTED> [PROTECT
IDENTITY], date of birth <REDACTED> cellular telephone number <REDACTED>
home address called  <REDACTED> <REDACTED> <REDACTED>
National Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to report being sexually abused
by Jeffrey Epstein and other "powerful" men in New York.

<REDACTED> provided the following information:
<REDACTED> was modeling in 2015, at the age of <REDACTED>, when she met Epstein. She
attended <REDACTED> parties at Epstein's residence in New York. During one of
the parties, Epstein asked <REDACTED> to take a tour of <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED>. Once Epstein asked to "take off her panties." When
she didn't comply, he said, "It's fine, I'll pay you five hundred
dollars." <REDACTED> complied because she thought he was a very important
person.

In 2016 Epstein "slid" his fingers up her dress and "fingered" her.
At one of the parties, two twin brothers, Allen and Oren, who were
involved in real estate lured <REDACTED> and her friend <REDACTED> upstairs and
locked the door. <REDACTED> "knocked the door back open" and the two ran
back downstairs.

<REDACTED> stated Oren raped <REDACTED> and Oren's brother, Tal, raped a
14 year old girl named <REDACTED>. <REDACTED> tried to slit her wrist after the
incident.
Re: 31E-NY-3027571, 08/08/2019
<REDACTED> also met three women in the "parlor room" of Epstein's home. One
woman she recognized as Epstein's "British socialite." The woman would
find young girls to have sex with Epstein. Epstein liked younger girls
that were clean shaven with small breasts.

<REDACTED> also went to his "St. Tomas island," which he referred to as "St.
Jeffrey." Epstein and other "powerful" men, including Bill Clinton and
Donald Trump, would have "big orgy parties" with her, other young girls,
and older Victoria's Secret models.

<REDACTED> was offered to be paid off by a lawyer associated with the Epstein
case. <REDACTED> is friends with <REDACTED> <REDACTED>. When out to dinner
with <REDACTED> and the lawyer <REDACTED> <REDACTED> <REDACTED> <REDACTED>
that's when the lawyer offered to pay "a couple grand" to "silence" her.

<REDACTED> is terrified that they might "put out a hit" on her and they know
where she lives.

<REDACTED> had contact with Epstein from 2015-2019. Last contact was <REDACTED>
<REDACTED> ago.

<REDACTED> was also contacted by one of Epstein's clienteles, <REDACTED> before
his arrest, asking her to meet up with Epstein.

<REDACTED> can be contacted on her cellular telephone for questioning.
Note: A LexisNexis query for <REDACTED> revealed <REDACTED> <REDACTED>
address <REDACTED> <REDACTED> <REDACTED> <REDACTED> social security account
<REDACTED> <REDACTED>. A LexisNexis query for <REDACTED> <REDACTED> <REDACTED>
<REDACTED> <REDACTED> and date of birth <REDACTED> <REDACTED>
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Steve Scully [employee] Epstein island employee 1999-2005, quit after seeing young girls 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00090602 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Steve Scully
(date: 2019-08-09)
FD-302   (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 3-     Official Record
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION

Date of entry  01/14/2020

STEVE SCULLY, date of birth was interviewed at the Federal
Bureau of Investigation St. Thomas Resident Agency in the Virgin Islands by
Detective and Special Agent-. After being advised of
the identities of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview,
SCULLY provided the following information:

SCULLY advised that he worked for JEFFREY EPSTEIN on his private island
from approximately 1999-2005 or 2006. During this time period he primarily
worked as EPSTEIN's telecommunications technician and helped to install
internet and phone systems on the island. During this time period SCULLY
estimated that he visited/ worked on the island approximately 100 times. He
described EPSTEIN as "a pretty bad guy" and "an intense man". SCULLY knew
of two property managers that worked on the island named MILES ALEXANDER and
CATHY ALEXANDER. EPSTEIN would not let them both leave the island at the
same time. At least one of them would have to be on the island at all
times. SCULLY believed they may have moved to South Africa. CATHY hated
EPSTEIN. In EPSTEIN's bedroom there were many pictures of young girls and
that disgusted CATHY.

SCULLY stated EPSTEIN was always very concerned about having proper phone
and internet service available at all points on his island. Money never
seemed to be a concern for EPSTEIN when it came to these matters. He
discussed setting up services between his island and his New York, Florida
and Paris homes.

SCULLY recalled seeing a pool guy on the island, who EPSTEIN brought from
West Palm Beach. This pool guy tells SCULLY "what's with the young girls"
and "I turned a blind eye". He also told SCULLY that it was worse in West
Palm Beach. SCULLY ended up quitting the next day over hearing this.
SCULLY discussed seeing a picture of <REDACTED> topless in EPSTEIN's

Investigation on 08/09/2019 at St Thomas, Virgin Islands, United States (In Person)
File# 50D-NY-3027571 Datedrafted 10/01/2019 by
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
S0D-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Steve Scully Interview o f 08/09/2019 ins, 2 of 3

office. In this picture <REDACTED> was with two other girls, who were also
topless and believed to be about 15-16 years old. This picture was taken on
the island.

SCULLY recalled seeing BOSCO, the engineer, on the island often. BOSCO
tells SCULLY that <REDACTED> is like EPSTEIN's daughter, and she does special
projects for him. BOSCO told SCULLY, "If you like working here you do not
ask about <REDACTED>"

SCULLY was to never talk to the guests, and if needed, he would have to
go through MILES. SCULLY never asked any of the girls their ages.

SCULLY recalled EPSTEIN's attorneys staying at the island on one
occasion. One of EPSTEIN's attorneys name was ALAN and he was a "dick".
EPSTEIN would have a chef that traveled with him to the island to cook
when he hosted "special parties". "Special Party" meant that there was
going to be young teenaged girls there.

LES WEXNER was always #1 speed dial on all of EPSTEIN's phones.

SCULLY recalled seeing three young girls and a man in the "grotto" area
of the island. These girls did not look 18 and they were all naked.
On one occasion, SCULLY was on a boat with EPSTEIN and two young teenaged
girls. SCULLY believed these girls were about 14 years old because that's
how old his daughter was at the time. They seemed very comfortable with
EPSTEIN and stood next to him at the wheel as he drove. SCULLY sensed
something was wrong.

SCULLY met GHISLAINE MAXWELL on the island. MAXWELL is a gutsy and
manipulative woman. MAXWELL shared an office with EPSTEIN.

At one point, EPSTEIN required all of his personal bodyguards to carry
guns. Some of them would be kept on ankle holsters. This started after
2001.

There was an area in EPSTEIN's room for his massage table to be set up.
The table was portable and sometimes would be set up in the bedroom or on
the deck outside. SCULLY never observed him getting massages and this was
not a topic of conversation. SCULLY presumed the massages were done by the
girls on the island and he believed that the massages were sexual.
Sometimes these girls would stay in his bedroom and not in guest rooms.
SCULLY would observe massage oils in the bathroom. SCULLY observed a list
of persons to give good massages and "extras" in EPSTEIN's office.
Prince Andrew was observed to be there with a bodyguard. SCULLY recalled
him grinding against some young girl in the pool.
EFTA00120459 (Jmail)
 [government] handwritten log of prisoner movements
(date: 2019-08-09)
handwritten log of prisoner movements
EFTA00143071 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons memo about Epstein and his cellmate Efrain Reyes
(inferred date: 2019-08-09)
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
DATE: August 12, 2019
TO: Warden
FROM: S/O/5
SUBJECT: Passed information from Special Housing Unit
On Friday August 9, 2019 at approximately 1:50 p.m, I assed on to oncoming staff
member Officer and present shift staff S/O/S n tcet That Inmate Reyes
#85993-054 was going WAB and possibly may not return. Also that Inmate Epstein #76318-054 will be
needing a cell mate upon arrival from his attorney visit.
EFTA00034357 (Jmail)
[government] Bureau of Prisons
internal message about 
discovery of Epstein's body
EFTA00036336 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons memo about Epstein's final phone call (he claime it was to his mother, it was to Karyna Shuliak)
(date: 2019-08-10)
U. S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correctional Center
New York, NY
August 10, 2019

MEMORANDUM FOR FILE
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER

FROM: <REDACTED>
SUBJECT: Inmate Epstein, Jeffery Reg. No. 76318-054
This memorandum is in regards of inmate Epstein, Jeffery Reg. No. 76318-054. On
August 9, 2019, I spoke with inmate Epstein concerning him making a call to his family. I told
inmate Epstein I was leaving the facility around 7:00 p.m. Inmate Epstein agreed to shorten his
attorney visitation to make his social call. I escorted inmate Epstein to Special Housing Unit
around 7:00 p.m. I placed inmate Epstein in the shower on (G) Tier and escorted the phone for
him to make a social call. I placed the phone in the first jack to the left on G tier. Inmate Epstein
explain to me that he didn't have his phone set up to use his Pac and Pin number. I asked inmate
Epstein who he was calling, he stated his mother. I remember dialing a number starting with 347,
but the number was note notated. Inmate Epstein began talking on the phone. I told the staff to
end inmate Epstein's call after 15 minutes. They complied.

UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York

DATE: August 10th, 2019
TO: Lieutenant <REDACTED>
FROM: <REDACTED>, Correctional Officer
SUBJECT: Response to Institution

On August 10, 2019 at approximately 8:45 am I, Officer, responded to MCC NY
at the request of the Operations Lieutenant for emergency ospital detail. Upon arriving I
was detail to New York Presbyterian hospital room A9 in emergency room where inmate
Epstein, Jeffrey # 76318-054 remains where located. I was responsible for watching the
remains until further instruction was given along with another correctional officer. Shortly
thereafter Institution Duty Officer (1OO) arrived and took command of detail. The timeline
for detail is as followed (times are approximate)

1030 Remains was prepared by hospital staff to be moved to hospital morgue
1045 Hospital staff escort remains to hospital morgue area cooling unit
1050 Area is ensured as secure by officers on detail at direction of IDO
1135 IOO communicates with Director Wiggins of Office of City Medical Examiner
.    (OCME) in regards to receiving remains to be transported to city morgue
1137 A/W notified by IDO
1138 IDO attempts to communicate with Director Wiggins of OCME (left message)
1139 IDO receives return communication from Director Wiggins (OCME)
1204 IDO receives communication from A/W
1208 IDO receives communication from A/W in regards to instruction on remains
1210 IDO communicates with Director Wiggins of OCME and coordinate movement
1257 Staff from OCME depart from New York Presbyterian hospital and transport
.    remains to city morgue location
1303 Hospital detail staff arrive back at MCC New York

Federal Correction Officer
US Dept of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
MCC-NewYork

From: Elissa Visok
To:
Date: 8/10/2019 8:31 PM
Subject: Last contact with Epstein
I visited Inmate Epstein in SHU on Thursday. He was getting ready to meet with his attorneys for the day
so I had gone to visit him right after the SHU meeting. He had a cell mate at the time with whom I saw
him interact with. He did not report any mental health concerns and he denied any suicidal thoughts or
intention. He was asking this writer to go to general population and was making requests for various
needs he had at the time. He wanted social calls without them being on a speaker phone. He wanted a
book he had left in the suicide watch area. His mood was not depressed or anxious. There were no signs
of distress. He had planned on meeting with his attorneys to work on his legal situation.
Sent from my iPhone
EFTA00142820 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons After Action Review on death of Jeffrey Epstein
(date: 2019-08-10)
AFTER ACTION REVIEW
Inmate Suicide
Metropolitan Correctional Center
New York, NY
August 10, 2019
Submitted by
Regional Director
Southeast Region
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
Table of Contents
Introduction  3
Executive Summary  3
Chronology of Events  3-10
Analysis of Events  10
Other Factors  11-15
Conclusion  15-16
Recommendations  16-17
Cost/Impact Statement  17
Attachments 18
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 3 of 18
INTRODUCTION
The Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC) New York is an
administrative level facility located in New York, New York. The
primary mission of the facility is to house individuals in pre-
trial status. On August 10, 2019, the facility had a base count
of 758 inmates.
An After Action Review team was appointed by
Regional Director, Southeast Region, to review the inmate suicide
which occurred at MCC New York on August 10, 2019. The review
team members included:
The following analysis was compiled through a review of written
documentation, electronic databases and limited staff
conversations. Due to potential criminal investigations, care was
taken to not conduct formal interviews with any staff and a
specific exclusion on discussions with involved staff. Written
documentation was taken at face value, with limited ability to
verify times of events, staff perceptions, or stated practices at
the institution. Discrepancies were noted with various documents
and systems. Precise details such as times, should be considered
approximations as many cannot be verified.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
On August 10, 2019, at approximately 6:33 AM, Inmate Jeffrey
Epstein, Register Number 76318-054, was found unresponsive in his
cell within the Special Housing Unit (SHU). Inmate Epstein was
transported to the local hospital where he was later pronounced
dead. The initial cause of death, although unofficial, would
indicate suicide by hanging.
CHRONOLOGY OF EVENTS
July 6, 2019
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 4 of 18
9:24 PM - Inmate Epstein is entered into SENTRY as arriving at MCC
New York as a pre-trial inmate.
9:36 PM - Inmate Epstein placed in general population cell E06-
547U.
July 7, 2019
7:20 PM - Inmate Epstein was placed in SHU cell Z02-201LAD with
Inmate Nicholas Tartaglione, Register Number 78514-054.
July 8, 2019
9:24 AM - Psychology intake screening conducted with a risk of
sexual abusiveness documented. No mental health
concerns reported by staff.
10:41 AM -The Chief Psychologist consulted with the Suicide
Prevention Coordinator, Central Office. The decision
was made to place Inmate Epstein on psychology
observation upon his return from court pending a mental
health evaluation.
5:49 PM - Inmate Epstein returns from court.
5:49 PM - SENTRY shows a cell change transaction from Z02-201LAD
to the same cell. There is no documented explanation
for this peculiar change.
6:03 PM - Inmate Epstein is placed on psychology observation in
cell H01-001L.
July 9, 2019
7:30 AM - Psychology conducts a suicide risk assessment indicating
suicide watch was not indicated, but psychology
observation is continued "pending suitable housing
placement."
10:13 AM -Psychology develops a diagnostic and care level
formulation assigning "no diagnosis" and CARE 1 Mental
Health.
12:35 PM -Health Services completes a History & Physical for
Inmate Epstein. This assessment was done in lieu of an
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 5 of 18
Intake Screening, which should have been conducted
within 24-hours of arrival (PS6031.04).
July 10, 2019
3:26 PM - Psychology conducts a Psychology Observation contact and
ends observation. Inmate returned to SHU with
documented recommendations for a cellmate and next-day
contact by psychology. Inmate placed in cell Z05-
124LAD, again with Inmate Tartaglione.
July 11, 2019
3:21 PM - Inmate Epstein is seen by psychology for follow-up in
the presence of his attorneys while conducting a legal
visit. This visit recommended follow-up the following
week.
July 16, 2019
12:48 PM -Inmate Epstein is seen by psychology in the presence of
his attorneys while conducting a legal visit. This
visit was at the request of Inmate Epstein. This visit
recommended no follow-up.
July 18, 2019
30-Day Psychology reviews are conducted for the entire SHU
population. Inmate Epstein was not in SHU at the time due to an
attorney visit. The review was never conducted.
July 23, 2019
1:27 AM - SHU staff heard noises coming cell Z05-124. Upon
arrival staff observed Inmate Tartaglione, standing at
the door of the cell stating Inmate Epstein attempted to
hang himself. Staff observed Inmate Epstein lying on the
floor near his bunk with what appeared to be a piece of
homemade orange cloth around his neck. Inmate Epstein
was removed from the cell and placed on suicide watch by
the Operations Lieutenant and the on-call Psychologist
was notified.
6:20 AM - Health Services conducted a medical assessment of Inmate
Epstein. The following injuries were reported: "circular
line of erythema at the base of neck reaching 2/3 of the
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 6 of 18
neck circumference, 2 inches wide, sparing the back of
the neck. Has one section of this erythema in the front
with marks of friction. Small erythema on left knee
about 2cm in diameter (mild)." Medical record note
states follow-up in 2-4 hours. This follow-up does not
appear to have occurred.
7:56 AM - Psychology administrative note
completed on July 24, 2019.
opened and later
9:10 AM - Psychology began a suicide risk assessment note.
July 24, 2019
8:45 AM - Psychology ended suicide watch
observation for Inmate Epstein.
and began psychology
July 25, 2019 - July 27, 2019
Daily psychology contact while on psychology observation.
July 28, 2019
8:33 AM - Daily psychology contact while on psychology observation
indicated Inmate Epstein would be moved to another cell
due to toilet issues. This move is not shown by SENTRY
to have occurred.
July 29, 2019
10:01 AM -Daily psychology contact while on psychology
observation.
July 30, 2019
12:01 PM -Daily psychology contact while on psychology
observation. Psychology observation status discontinued
with a recommendation for a cellmate while in SHU.
12:30 PM -A Staff Psychologist distributed a mass email stating
Inmate Epstein will require a cellmate upon return to
SHU. Inmate Epstein was placed in Cell Z04-206LAD with
Inmate Efrain Reyes, Register Number 85993-054. SENTRY
is inaccurate regarding this transaction, as it shows to
have occurred the previous day.
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 7 of 18
3:58 PM - A medical record note is completed stating Inmate
Epstein will be issued a Continuous Positive Air
Pressure (CPAP) machine. Although there is no SENTRY
transaction, Inmate Epstein and Inmate Reyes are moved
to cell Z06-220. This move was done to accommodate the
electrical needs of the CPAP.
July 31, 2019
10:35 AM -Psychology contact completed for post removal from
psychology observation.
Prisoner custody documentation shows Inmate Epstein left the
institution with the USMS and returned at unspecified times.
Neither SENTRY nor the Lieutenant's Log reflect this event.
August 1, 2019
8:30 AM - Psychology documented they were notified by Correctional
Systems of a form received from the United States
Marshals Service (USMS) the previous day stating Inmate
Epstein had reported suicidal tendencies.
1:00 PM - Psychology conducts a suicide risk assessment noting
watch is not indicated with a recommendation for follow-
up in one week. The delay in conducting this assessment
is not justified in the report.
August 2, 2019
11:34 AM -An SIS Investigation into the July 23, 2019 incident was
completed. The investigation stated there is
insufficient evidence to support either Inmate Epstein
harmed himself or was harmed by his cellmate.
August 8, 2019
10:02 AM -Psychology contact for suicide risk assessment follow-
up conducted. No concerns or follow-up noted.
INCIDENT
August 9, 2019
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 8 of 18
8:00 AM - Inmate Reyes (Cellmate) departs for court. Inmate Reyes
does not return to the institution.
8:30 AM - Epstein arrives in attorney conference room to meet with
several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 PM - Epstein departs the attorney conference room and returns
to SHU cell Z06-220LAD (SENTRY does not reflect this
accurately) . Inmate Epstein remains in the cell alone
until the time of the incident.
7:00 PM - Epstein was provided a social call by the Institution
Duty Officer (IDO). This call was done on an
unmonitored line. It is extremely concerning why this
call would have been placed and why it would be done on
an unmonitored line. Without further interviews it is
not possible to determine the reason for this call.
August 10, 2019
6:33 AM - A body alarm is activated in the Special Housing Unit
(SHU). SHU staff reported Inmate Epstein was
unresponsive in cell Z06-220LAD (SENTRY does not reflect
this accurately). Staff entered the cell and attempted
to wake Inmate Epstein. Control Center announced a
medical emergency and Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation
(CPR) was initiated.
6:35 AM - The on-duty Physician Assistant arrives in SHU and
continues CPR and applies an Automated External
Defibrillator (AED).
6:40 AM - Associate Warden notified.
6:45 AM - Emergency Medical Services (EMS) arrives and continues
CPR. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three rounds of
Epinephrine, Intravenous (IV) access established,
Intraosseous (IO) initiated. The AED indicated there
was no pulse found and no shock advised. Inmate Epstein
is prepared for medical transport.
7:10 AM - Inmate Epstein departs the institution for transport to
Beekman Hospital.
7:20 AM - Special Investigative Supervisor (SIS) Lieutenant
notified.
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 9 of 18
7:30 AM - Warden arrives at the intuition.
7:36 AM - Inmate Epstein pronounced dead by the emergency room
physician.
8:10 AM - Associate Warden of Programs and Captain arrive at the
institution.
8:10 AM - Case Management Coordinator (CMC) and Supervisory
Correctional Systems Specialist (SCSS) notified.
8:34 AM - Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) notified.
9:00 AM - Assistant United States Attorney (AUSA) notified.
9:00 AM - Associate Warden of Operations and SIS Lieutenant arrive
at the institution.
9:15 AM - CMC arrives at the institution.
9:30 AM - Acting Chief Psychologist arrives at the institution.
9:50 AM - SCSS arrives at the institution.
9:55 AM - CMC and IDO depart to Beekman Hospital.
10:00 AM -CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital. Inmate Epstein
is fingerprinted, photographed, and his clothing is
secured.
10:00 AM -Judge Richard M. Beerman is notified.
10:15 AM -CMC returns to the institution.
10:45 AM -Public Information Officer (PIO) arrives at the
intuition.
11:00 AM -CMC notifies Inmate Epstein's brother as next of kin.
11:12 AM -Press release is issued to the media.
11:15 AM -Press release is provided to Judge Beerman.
11:15 AM -Crisis Support Team (CST) is activated.
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 10 of 18
12:15 PM -Inmate Epstein's body is released to the medical
examiner for autopsy.
12:19 PM -FBI arrives at the institution.
1:40 PM - Office of the Inspector General (OIG) contacts the
Warden and advises an agent is being dispatched to the
institution.
3:10 PM - OIG arrives and escorted to SHU.
3:35 PM - A Referral for Alleged Misconduct is sent to Office of
Internal Affairs (OIA), Regional Director (RD), and
Office of General Counsel (OGC).
ANALYSIS OF EVENTS
Inmate Epstein arrived at MCC New York on July 6, 2019, as a pre-
trial commit. It appears the staff receiving Inmate Epstein were
not aware of his broad publicity and placed him within general
population as a typical inmate. The following day he was placed
in SHU, reportedly at the direction of the Warden. It is unclear
how his cellmate was chosen or what method was used to determine
appropriateness. A review of the assigned cellmate raises
questions concerning the selection process.
From his initial placement in SHU, until the date of the incident,
Inmate Epstein was outside the institution on four occasions to
attend court appearances and spent a considerable amount of time
in attorney visitation. His interactions with the various
departments was considered ordinary, although Inmate Epstein had
many interactions with the Psychology Department.
On July 23, 2019, Inmate Epstein was found in a state of
unresponsiveness within his SHU cell. The investigation into this
incident was inconclusive to determine if the cellmate was
involved, if Inmate Epstein had made a suicide attempt or gesture,
or if he was feigning the incident in an attempt to gain single
cell status. The investigation was completed properly and
appropriately without a definitive conclusion.
Following the July 23, 2019 incident, psychology staff maintained
appropriate contact with Inmate Epstein to assess his condition
and level of supervision. Psychology was clear in their
recommendation for Inmate Epstein to be housed with another inmate
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 11 of 18
when returned to SHU. Although this information was distributed
on several fronts, by email from a staff psychologist, through
individual conversations by the Captain to his Lieutenants, and
verbally between SHU Officers, there was ultimately a failure to
place a cellmate with Inmate Epstein.
On August 10, 2019, the two assigned morning watch SHU Officers
failed to make their designated rounds or count the SHU inmates
for two counts. At 6:33 am, upon finding Inmate Epstein
unresponsive in his cell, with a torn bedsheet around his neck,
staff utilized a body alarm to initiate a call for assistance.
The medical response to the incident was timely, efficient, and
exhaustive. Staff utilized an AED, as well as continuous CPR
until care was assumed by EMS personnel.
OTHER FACTORS
(Directly Related to the Incident)
Significant discrepancies exist within SENTRY regarding cell
quarters assignments (QTR). Although it is well documented Inmate
Epstein was housed with two other inmates during his assignment in
SHU, SENTRY does not reflect this information accurately. Inmate
Epstein was found within cell 220, yet SENTRY never reflects him
being housed within that cell at any time.
Significant discrepancies exist within SENTRY regarding
admission/release status (ARS). SENTRY does not reflect Inmate
Epstein being escorted from the institution by the USMS on
July 31, 2019, although a signed Prisoner Remand form is
documented receiving him from the USMS.
SHU has multiple cells equipped with video recording capability.
Inmate Epstein was not housed in one of these cells and there
appears to be no set guidance on when to utilize these cells.
No notations concerning a requirement for a cellmate were entered
into the SHU program, and subsequently available for SHU Officers
to reference.
An outside person sent $200 each to Inmate Epstein and his
cellmate Inmate Reyes. The outside person appears to be Inmate
Epstein's attorney. The purpose of this transaction is
undetermined at this point.
In an email to the Warden, dated post incident, the Supervisory
Staff Attorney reported details of a conversation with Inmate
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 12 of 18
Epstein's attorneys. Inmate Epstein's attorneys requested he be
housed in a single cell, the staff attorney stated Inmate Epstein
could not be housed alone due to previous suicide attempt/gesture.
During the immediate response to the incident both SHU officers
made reference to not completing required rounds and counts. This
was documented by the responding Lieutenant.
In an email to the Warden, the Captain reported he had "informal
training sessions" regarding SHU conditions and the housing of
Inmate Epstein specifically. This meeting was held with
Correctional Services supervisors and line staff during the week
of July 31, 2019. Additionally, the Captain states he spoke with
the SHU Lieutenant concerning the need to house Inmate Epstein
with a cellmate.
The Psychology intake screening contains errors in identifying
details. Inmate Epstein is referred to as a black inmate and a
different inmate name is used within the report.
There are errors within the Risk of Sexual Abusiveness report,
such as referencing an inaccurate program statement and noting a
history of prior prison sexual predation.
Correctional Services and Health Services are not completing
regular rounds of inmates housed under psychology observation.
On July 16, 2019, a psychologist met with Inmate Epstein in the
presence of his attorneys. This was done at the request of Inmate
Epstein and appears to have been for the purpose of airing
grievances with conditions of confinement.
The Suicide Risk Assessment dated July 23, 2019, refers to the
ligature as a "string" when in fact it was a sizable portion of
torn bed sheet.
On August 1, 2019, Correctional Systems staff reported the USMS
concerns from the previous day regarding Inmate Epstein's suicidal
tendencies to Psychology staff. It is unknown why this issue was
not reported to Psychology the previous day. There was a time
delay between this report and Psychology conducting a suicide risk
assessment.
On August 9, 2019, during a shift change in SHU, the SHU #3
6:00 am-2:00 pm officer briefed his 2:00 pm-10:00 pm relief and
the other two 8:00 am-4:00 pm officers of the likelihood Inmate
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 13 of 18
Reyes, Register Number 85993-054 would not be returning and Inmate
Epstein would require a cellmate upon returning from an attorney
visit. Inmate Epstein was not placed with a cellmate upon his
return to SHU.
SHU 30-minunte check documentation shows a trend of missing rounds
and rounds which extend beyond the 40-minute limit.
Count documentation for August 9, 2019, could not be located.
Official count documentation shows all counts were conducted as
scheduled, but based on the statements of the responsible
officers, this appears to be inaccurate for at least the 3:00 am
and 5:00 am counts.
The initial medical screening noted essential hypertension, but
did not provide treatment. Upon further review it appears this
diagnosis should not have been issued.
On July 6, 2019, Health Services notes Inmate Epstein has no known
allergies. On July 30, 2019, a Modified Diet Request is issued by
Health Services with no accompanying medical record note.
All psychologists at the institution are state licensed
clinicians.
Psychology Observation procedures dictate a Physician's Assistant
perform daily rounds. This is clearly not possible based on
Health Services staffing.
It is not uncommon for staff working vital posts, which require
effectuating SENTRY transactions, to not have the needed access.
A review of inmates housed within the suicide watch cells, during
the period of this review, revealed the inmates were not properly
assigned within SENTRY.
Institution Duty Officers (IDO) do not routinely visit SHU each
day as required by the Institution Supplement (255502.11) .
Additionally, the IDO reports consistently documents the condition
of SHU as "satisfactory", when observations have shown the SHU to
be less than satisfactory.
The Correctional Services roster requires a complete review to
best utilize staffing resources. Currently, the roster appears to
have posts which could be reprioritized.
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 14 of 18
A review of discontinued suicide watches for the past 30-days
shows a history of placing inmates returned to SHU with a cellmate
on each occasion.
OTHER FACTORS
(Not Directly Related to the Incident)
Staffing
Staffing changes within the Correctional Services department have
changed significantly over the past several years. In May of
2018, during pay period 5, the institution lost 21 positions as a
result of phase 1 and 2 reductions. These positions consisted of
19 correctional officers, 1 lieutenant and 1 SIS technician.
The current complement for Correctional Services is 135
authorized, with 117 filled.
Staffing levels at pay period 26 for previous years
Year Authorized On Board
2015 153 150
2016 152 132
2017 152 143
2018 (No staffing report available.
Numbers are based on December 23, 2017.)
153 128
Correctional Services staff in an unavailable status
(LWOP / Sick Leave / AWOL / COP / Suspension / Official Time)
August 2, 2019 27
August 1, 2019 23
July 31, 2019 26
July 30, 2019 28
July 29, 2019 26
July 28, 2019 12
July 27, 2019 10
July 26, 2019 22
July 25, 2019 23
July 24, 2019 22
July 23, 2019 25
July 22, 2019 25
July 21, 2019 13
Overtime
The two morning watch SHU staff did not work an unusual amount of
overtime leading up to the incident. The SHU #1 was assigned to
SHU on mandatory overtime during the incident. This staff member
does not typically work a large quantity of overtime. The SHU #2
was assigned to SHU on voluntary overtime. This staff member
typically works a high volume of overtime on a volunteer basis.
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 15 of 18
Overtime hours for the August 10, 2019 morning watch SHU Officers
SHU #1 SHU #2
Voluntary OT Mandatory OT Voluntary OT Mandatory OT
August 24 8 32 0
July 24 0 152 0
June 8 0 150 0
May 0 0 184 0
Correctional Services overtime (8-Hour occurrences) by pay period
based  on the pay rate for a GL-8/5
PP 20 17.1
PP 21 20
PP 22 19.4
PP 23 23
PP 24 21
PP 25 19.5
PP 26 Incl. PP 1
PP 1 37.6
PP 2 23.1
PP 3 21.9
PP 4 22.9
PP 5 19
PP 6 22.7
PP 7 22.4
PP 8 25
PP 9 25.3
CONCLUSION
PP 10 25.9
PP 11 23.6
PP 12 21.2
PP 13 22.3
PP 14 27.4
PP 15 23.1
After a thorough review of all available evidence, the review team
concluded there was a significant breakdown in basic correctional
practices and communication within the institution. Inmate
Epstein was an inmate who fell within multiple suicide risk
groups. He was also an inmate who had risk factors for assault by
other inmates and did require careful selection for appropriate
cellmates. Although these issues were noted, well documented, and
communicated, a failure still occurred by allowing Inmate Epstein
to be placed in a cell alone. Although feasible for an inmate to
effectuate suicide while housed with a cellmate, the odds of this
occurring are significantly lowered when housed with another
inmate. Without the use of compelled interviews, it is not
possible to determine the true root of the communication
breakdown.
Concerning deficiencies were noted in common functions within the
institution. It appears a less than satisfactory state of
condition within the Special Housing Unit has become acceptable to
responsible staff. The review team observed significant failures
in basic tasks such as SENTRY entries for quarters changes to the
base count of the facility. Failure in the area of inmate
accountability is a substantial finding which will require
immediate attention.
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 16 of 18
Although inmate suicides do occur, the Bureau of Prisons has
developed substantial training resources and processes to mitigate
an environment leading to a suicide. While many correctional
professionals completed their responsibilities within these
processes, the failure to carry out all aspects of the suicide
prevention process laid the groundwork for an environment
vulnerable to suicide. At the core of this event was a direct
dereliction of duty by the assigned correctional workers within
the Special Housing Unit. Their failure to perform the most basic
of correctional tasks should be viewed as the primary factor which
exposed the institution to this event. Had they performed the
basic task of counting and viewing inmates within their assigned
area, it is possible this suicide could have been detected or a
minimum, responded to the event quicker.
RECOMMENDATIONS

• A multi-disciplinary team assessment should be conducted
throughout the institution to determine shortcomings and
provide a corrective action plan.

• Regional Psychology Administrators should be considered for
reinstatement to provide a direct contact to field staff.

• The Institution Supplement on Suicide Prevention is not
required and occasionally not followed. It is recommended to
review the need for having this supplement.

• Currently the Drug Abuse Prevention Coordinator (DAPC) has
responsibilities between MCC New York and MDC Brooklyn. It
is recommended this be reviewed to determine if the
responsibilities are appropriately distributed or if they
would be better served with an independent DAPC.

• A single post should be designated to document all movement
within the facility. This should include internal, court,
releases, etc.

• The Correctional Services roster should undergo a complete
review to determine the best possible use of staff resources.

• A Deputy Captain should be considered to provide additional
higher level supervision.
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 17 of 18

• Psychology Observation procedures should be reviewed to
ensure consistency and accuracy in the expectations.

• Procedures should be established on when and how the video
capable cells in SHU are utilized.
COST/IMPACT STATEMENT
Correctional Services Overtime (Estimate 16-Hrs) $741.60
Health Services Overtime $0.00
Medical Expenses (Historical Estimate) $10000.00
Death Related Expenses (Not Yet Released) $0.00
TOTAL: $10741.60
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
After Action Review
MCC New York - Admin
August 10, 2019
Page 18 of 18
ATTACHMENTS
Attachment 1: Inmate Involvement Listing
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
EFTA00003095 (Jmail)
 [government] handwritten evidence inventory of photos from Little St. James Island
(date: 2019-08-12)
handwritten evidence inventory of photos from Little St. James Island
EFTA00147020 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about status of Epstein death investigation
(date: 2019-08-13)
SITUATIONAL REPORT (SITREP)
Jeffrey Epstein — Victim;
Irregularities in a Federal Penal Institution;
Death Investigation;
90A-NY-3 151227

(U) Current Situation of Epstein Death investigation, as of 4:00 p.m. EDT 08/13/2019:

• (U//FOUO) NYO CART continues efforts to download any potentially usable video from
the MCC's video surveillance system. In an effort to potentially obtain any corrupted
video, and to speed up the recovery process, FBINY has requested that the entire video
system be removed for analysis at FBINY CART.

• (U//FOUO) No MCC staff interviews were conducted today. No staff interviews have
been scheduled at this time.

• The interview of has been tentatively scheduled for Friday, 8/16/2019.
• A proffer of Efrain Reyes has been tentatively scheduled for Friday, 8/16/2019.

(U) Current Situation of the search of Epstein's private island, Little St. James, as it relates
to the ongoing Sex Trafficking investigation.

• The Child Exploitation Human Trafficking Task Force (CEHTTF) conducted 12
interviews with the following positive results: A witness who constructed the IT network
over 10 years ago identified pictures of a co-conspirator, victims, and other guests as
being on Little St. James (LSJ) island; Southern Trust, a business on St. Thomas, was
identified as being associated with Epstein and his Property Manager, Daphne Wallace.

• Efforts to interview two property managers met with negative results as attorney Dan
Horowitz (NY, NY) advised they would not be available for interviews.

• Efforts are ongoing to identify individuals employed by Epstein in the past year and may
have information about the removal of property from LSJ island.

• On 8/14/2019, 45 personnel (I EM, 16 ERT, 4 SWAT,1 CART, 2 THRU, 21
Investigation) will depart at 0900 via the Q400

• On 8/14/2019, 2 case agents will depart via comair.
• On 08/15/2019, 4 personnel (RDT) will depart via comair.

(U) Investigative Plan:
The 08/13/2019 proposed plan is as follows:

• (U//FOUO) Members of the NYO's VCTF will continue efforts to complete the
interviews of all the members of the MCC that is pertinent to the death investigation.

• (U//FOUO) Members of the VCTF will continue attempts to interview Efrain Reyes.
• (U//FOUO) NYO CART will continue efforts to download any usable surveillance video
from MCC.

• (U//FOUO) Members of the VCTF will continue to coordinate with the SDNY to
facilitate the interview of

(U) Detailed Background:

• (U//FOUO) On 7/6/2019, Epstein was remanded to the Metropolitan Correctional Center
(MCC), 150 Park Row, New York, NY.

• (U//FOUO) On 7/8/2019, Epstein was placed on suicide watch and evaluated by MCC
Psychologist and underwent observations until 7/10/2019.

• (U//FOUO) On 7/23/2019, Epstein first attempted suicide via hanging, and was
discovered unconscious in his cell at approximately 1:27 a.m. EDT. Epstein was placed
on suicide watch until 7/29/2019.

• (U//FOUO) In the morning hours of 8/9/2019, Epstein's cell mate, Efrain Reyes, was
released from the MCC, leaving Epstein alone in his cell.

• (U//FOUO) On 8/9/2019 at approximately 7:19 p.m. EDT, an MCC Correctional Officer
allows Epstein to make a phone call on an unsecured and unmonitored line. The call was
to and was approximately 20 minutes in length.

• (U//FOUO) On 8/10/2019, at approximately 6:30 a.m. EDT, Jeffrey Epstein was found
unresponsive in his jail cell at the MCC. Epstein was found with a make-shift noose
around his neck in an apparent suicide. Emergency medical response efforts to revive
Epstein were unsuccessful, and he was pronounced dead at approximately 7:30 a.m.

• (U//FOUO) Initial incident reports generated at the MCC and sent to BOP HQ on
8/10/2019, documented that two MCC Correctional Officers falsified observation logs for
Epstein's cell for the overnight hours of 8/9 - 8/10/2019. This prompted a criminal
investigation by the Office of Inspector General (O1G).
2
EFTA00036136 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons memo about camera project
(inferred date: 2019-08-14)
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
August 13, 2019

MEMORANDUM FOR <REDACTED>, WARDEN
FROM: <REDACTED>, FACILITIES MANAGER
SUBJECT: CAMERA PROJECT / RECORDERING

On Saturday August 10, 2019 I was informed that there was no recording of the closed circuit
cameras (CCTV) from recorder 2 (Nice). I had Electronic Technician see
about getting the recorder operational again by replacing the two (2) hard drivers and start the
rebuilding process. Mr. called Signet Technologies to make sure what he was doing was
correct and not going to make the problem worse. As the process of the rebuilding of the records
the FBI came to the institution to retrieve all video needed. They took all eighteen (18) hard
drives, two bad ones that were being replaced and the sixteen (16) that were in the RAID. While
this was happening I made phone calls to Steve Smith from Signet Technologies to see about
getting a technician from Signet to come to the institution to get the new CCTV equipment up
and recording. On Sunday August 11, 2019 Steve Smith called me back and informed me that a
technician will be on site Monday afternoon, Mr. Smith informed me to get Mr. to get all
the new equipment on the racks and ready for when Jeff McKenzie arrives. On Monday August
12, 2019 Jeff McKenzie from Signet arrived and started to look at the existing and new
equipment with Mr. . While they were looking the FBI came back and had question on
how the system worked and information about the old equipment. Mr. McKenzie assisted with
them on how to download what they were asking for. Since it was taking so long to download
the Agents left and would return the next day to pick up what was downloaded.

On Tuesday August 13, 2019 I had a teleconference with Signet Technli•eve Smith, Jeff
McKenzie, Northeast Regional Staff <REDACTED>, MCC staff <REDACTED> <REDACTED> and myself to
figure the best and fastest way to get the recording of cameras at the institution. During the
conversation of what took place we found out that when the FBI took the sixteen (16) hard drives
out of the RAID without it finishing the rebuild it might have corrupted any data on the drives.
Signet also told us that they would be able to get us recording of the operational cameras by
August 14, 2019.
EFTA00075281 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of prison guard, death of Epstein
(date: 2019-08-16)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 2-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Oano
•
Date of entry  09/06/2019
, Corrections Officer at Bureau of Prison's (BOP)
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER (MCC), 150 Park Row, New York, New York,
date of birth (DOB) was interviewed by FBI Special Agent (SA)
FBI Task Force Officer (TFO) and Office of the
Inspector General (OIG) at the United States Attorneys
Office (USAO), Southern District of New York (SDNY), 1 St. Andrews Plaza,
New York, New York. TFO advised that there is an on-going
criminal investigation and he has an obligation to answer questions
truthfully and that it would be a federal crime to lie to a federal agent
during the meeting. SA provided with an OIG "Warnings and
Assurances to Employee Requested to Provide Information on a Voluntary
Bases" form, which
SA
signed and was witnessed by SAs and
retained the original and a copy is attached in the IA
section of this report.
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing investigators and
the nature of the interview, provided the following information:
has worked for BOP for four years. ?as working an overtime
shift in the Special Housing Unit (SHU), 10 South, on a 12am-8am shift at
the time that JEFFREY EPSTEIN was found unresponsive in his cell.
couldn't recall the exact date but did recall that it was the previous
Saturday. had worked a 12pm-8pm shift the previous day, had a four
hour break, and then started the overtime shift of 12a-8a. Unit 10 South is
a completely locked down unit where the Corrections Officer is alone in the
unit.
recalled he did the 12am count with and that Office
helped him do the Sam and 5am counts. further stated that for the Sam
and 5am counts, the control center had called about the counts and he
advised control that he wanted someone to assist him in doing the counts
Investigation on 08/16/2019 m New York, New York, United States (In Person)
File # 90A-NY-3151227, 90C-NY-3154599 Date drafted 08/19/2019
by

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
90A-NY-3151227
In rvi w of Corrections Officer
Continuation of FD-302 0 .on 08/16/2019 ,page 2 of 2
because he was by himself said that there should always be a double
staff count and that he always wanted a partner to do the count and wouldn't
do a count without a partner. Illillidvi hat while doing the counts, an
officer should see breathing flesh. Whet and did the 3am and 5am
counts, they counted five inmates.
Officer relieved at some point during the shift to give him
a break. Lieutenant came by at some point to check on
however, didn't remember the exact time.
was in 10 South when the call came over, referring to when EPSTEIN
was found unresponsive in his cell.IIIIIII[hen worked another shift in the
SHU, 8am-4pm.
stated that he once fed EPSTEIN because EPSTEIN had not received
his meal and that EPSTEIN was grateful. ADAMS said that EPSTEIN didn't
appear to be dangerous and that EPSTEIN never offered him money for
anything stated that he was shocked that this had happened, referring
to EPSTEIN's death. said that EPSTEIN was supposed to be watched more
closely and that the rounds should have been conducted regardless of
whether EPSTEIN had previously been on suicide watch or not.
was then shown a picture of When looked at
the picture, said that he wanted a lawyer. Investigators discontinued
questioning at that time.
On his own accord then stated something to the effect of "I want
to be clear, I never brought stuff into the jail or allowed stuff in. I
never did that."
was advised that his cell phone, which had been surrendered at the
security checkpoint at the entrance of the USAO was seized by the FBI. The
cell phone, a Motorola was seized pursuant
to a search warrant issued by SDNY. was then told that he could get
his phone back that day if he gave investigators his passcode. told
investigators that he was not going to give them his passcode. was
given an FD-597, receipt for property, which was signed by and TFO
EFTA00135082 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of prison guard, death of Epstein
(date: 2019-08-16)
FD-302(Rev.5-840) .1 of 2 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
OFFICIAL RECORD1
Dec ofentry  09/06/2019
pnrairansal,  Corrections Officer at Bureau of Prison's (BOP)
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER (MCC), 150 Park Row, New York, New York,
, was interviewed by FBI Special Agent (SA)
, FBI Task Force Officer (TFO) , and Office of the
Inspector General (OIG) SA at the United States Attorneys
Office (USAO) , Southern District of New York (SDNY),
New York, New York. TFO advised that there is an on-going
criminal investigation and he has an obligation to answer questions
truthfully and that it would be a federal crime to lie to a federal agent
during the meeting. SA provided with an OIG "Warnings and
Assurances to Employee Requested to Provide Information on a Voluntary
Bases" form, which signed and was witnessed by SAs and
. SA retained the original and a copy is attached in the lA
section of this report.
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing investigators and
the nature of the interview, provided the following information:
has worked for BOP for four years. was working an overtime
shift in the Special Housing Unit (SHU), 10 South, on a 12am-8am shift at
the time that JEFFREY EPSTEIN was found unresponsive in his cell.
couldn't recall the exact date but did recall that it was the previous
Saturday. had worked a 12pm-8pm shift the previous day, had a four
hour break, and then started the overtime shift of 12a-8a. Unit 10 South is
a completely locked down unit where the Corrections Officer is alone in the
unit.
recalled he did the 12am count with and that Officer NOEL
helped him do the 3am and Sam counts. further stated that for the 3am
and 5am counts, the control center had called about the counts and he
advised control that he wanted someone to assist him in doing the counts
Investigationon 08/16/2019  at New York, New York, United States (In Person)
File# Date drafted 08/19/2019
by
This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FRI. It is the property of the FBI and is loaned 
to your agency: it and its contents arc
not
to be distributed outside your agency. SDNY_00007SSO
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
:terview of Corrections Officer
Continuation of FD-302 o2 paranYmeg .on 08/16/2019  .page 2 of 2
because he was by himself. said that there should always be a double
staff count and that he always wanted a partner to do the count and wouldn't
do a count without a partner. advised that while doing the counts, an
officer should see breathing flesh. When and NOEL did the 3am and Sam
counts, they counted five inmates.
Officer THOMAS relieved at some point during the shift to give him
a break. Lieutenant came by at some point to check on
however, didn't remember the exact time.
was in 10 South when the call came over, referring to when EPSTEIN
was found unresponsive in his cell. then worked another shift in the
SHU, 8am-4pm.
stated that he once fed EPSTEIN because EPSTEIN had not received
his meal and that EPSTEIN was grateful. Mill said that EPSTEIN didn't
appear to be dangerous and that EPSTEIN never offered him money for
anything. stated that he was shocked that this had happened, referring
to EPSTEIN's death. said that EPSTEIN was supposed to be watched more
closely and that the rounds should have been conducted regardless of
whether EPSTEIN had previously been on suicide watch or not.
said that he wanted a lawyer. Investigators discontinued
questioning at that time.
On his own accord, then stated something to the effect of "I want
to be clear, I never brought stuff into the jail or allowed stuff in. I
never did that."
•
5O1)1C00007Mg
EFTA00040794 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of prison guard OFFICER 1, death of Epstein
(date: 2019-08-19)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 2 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
OFFICIAL RECORD 1
Date of entry  09/06/2019

OFFICER 1, Corrections Officer at Bureau of Prison's (BOP) METROPOLITAN
CORRECTIONAL CENTER (MCC), 150 Park Row, New York, New York,
was interviewed by FBI Special Agent (SA)
FBI Task Force Officer (TFO) , and Office of the Inspector
General (OIG) SA at the United States Attorneys Office
(USAO), Southern District of New York (SDNY), 1 St. Andrews Plaza, New York,
New York. TFO advised OFFICER 1 that there is an on-going criminal
investigation and he has an obligation to answer questions truthfully and
that it would be a federal crime to lie to a federal agent during the
meeting. SA provided OFFICER 1 with an OIG "Warnings and
Assurances to Employee Requested to Provide Information on a Voluntary
Bases" form, which OFFICER 1 signed and was witnessed by SAs and
. SA retained the original and a copy is attached in the lA
section of this report.

After being advised of the identity of the interviewing investigators and
the nature of the interview, OFFICER 1 provided the following information:
OFFICER 1 has worked for BOP for four years. OFFICER 1 was working an
overtime shift in the Special Housing Unit (SHU), 10 South, on a 12am-8am
shift at the time that JEFFREY EPSTEIN was found unresponsive in his cell.
OFFICER 1 couldn't recall the exact date but did recall that it was the
previous Saturday. OFFICER 1 had worked a 12pm-8pm shift the previous day,
had a four hour break, and then started the overtime shift of 12a-8a. Unit
10 South is a completely locked down unit where the Corrections Officer is
alone in the unit.

OFFICER 1 recalled he did the 12am count with OFFICER 2 and that Officer
NOEL helped him do the 3am and 5am counts. OFFICER 1 further stated that for
the 3am and 5am counts, the control center had called about the counts and
he advised control that he wanted someone to assist him in doing the counts
Investigationon 08/16/2019  at New York, New York, United States (In Person)
File# 90A-NY -3151227, 90C—NY-3154599
by •
Datedrafted 08/19/2019

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
90A-NY-3151227
(U) Interview of Corrections Officer
Continuation of FD-302 of OFFICER 1 .on 08/16/2019 .page 2 of 2
because he was by himself. OFFICER 1 said that there should always be a
double staff count and that he always wanted a partner to do the count and
wouldn't do a count without a partner. OFFICER 1 advised that while doing
the counts, an officer should see breathing flesh. When OFFICER 1 and NOEL
did the 3am and 5am counts, they counted five inmates.

Officer THOMAS relieved OFFICER 1 at some point during the shift to give
him a break. OFFICER 2 came by at some point to check on OFFICER 1, however,
OFFICER 1 didn't remember the exact time.

OFFICER 1 was in 10 South when the call came over, referring to when
EPSTEIN was found unresponsive in his cell. OFFICER 1 then worked another
shift in the SHU, 8am-4pm.

OFFICER 1 stated that he once fed EPSTEIN because EPSTEIN had not
received his meal and that EPSTEIN was grateful. OFFICER 1 said that EPSTEIN
didn't appear to be dangerous and that EPSTEIN never offered him money for
anything. OFFICER 1 stated that he was shocked that this had happened,
referring to EPSTEIN's death. OFFICER 1 said that EPSTEIN was supposed to be
watched more closely and that the rounds should have been conducted
regardless of whether EPSTEIN had previously been on suicide watch or not.
OFFICER 1 was then shown a picture of . When OFFICER 1
looked at the picture, OFFICER 1 said that he wanted a lawyer. Investigators
discontinued questioning at that time.

On his own accord, OFFICER 1 then stated something to the effect of "I
want to be clear, I never brought stuff into the jail or allowed stuff in. I
never did that."
OFFICER 1 was advised that his cell phone, which had been surrendered at
the security checkpoint at the entrance of the USAO, was seized by the FBI.
The cell phone, a Motorola G6/XT1921-5, IMEI 99000544589395, was seized
pursuant to a search warrant issued by SDNY. OFFICER 1 was then told that he
could get his phone back that day if he gave investigators his passcode.
OFFICER 1 told investigators that he was not going to give them his
passcode. OFFICER 1 was given an FD-597, receipt for property, which was
signed by OFFICER 1 and TFO
EFTA00084954 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of prison guard, death of Epstein
(date: 2019-08-19)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 2 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
OFFICIAL_RECORD 1 . . . . . . .
nateefemly  09/06/2019
IMMAGEILI, Corrections Officer at Bureau of Prison's (BOP)
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER (MCC), 150 Park Row, New York, New York,
, was interviewed by FBI Special Agent (SA)
, FBI Task Force Officer (TFO)
Inspector General (OIG) SA
Office (USAO), Southern District of New York (SDNY), 1 St. Andrews Plaza,
New York, New York. TFO advised that there is an on-going
criminal investigation and he has an obligation to answer questions
truthfully and that it would be a federal crime to lie to a federal agent
during the meeting. SA
and Office of the
at the United States Attorneys
provided with an OIG "Warnings and
Assurances to Employee Requested to Provide Information on a Voluntary
Bases" form, which signed and was witnessed by SAs
M . SA retained the original and a copy
section of this report.
is
and
attached in the lA
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing investigators and
the nature of the interview, provided the following information:
shift in
the time
couldn't
Saturday.
has worked for BOP for four years. was working an overtime
the Special Housing Unit (SHU), 10 South, on a 12am-8am shift at
that JEFFREY EPSTEIN was found unresponsive in his cell.
recall the exact date but did recall that it was the previous
had worked a 12pm-8pm shift the previous day, had a four
hour break, and then started the overtime shift of 12a-8a. Unit 10 South is
a completely locked down unit where the Corrections Officer is alone in the
unit.
recalled he did the 12am count with and that Officer NOEL
helped him do the 3am and 5am counts.
and 5am counts, the control center had called about the counts and he
advised control that he wanted someone to assist him in doing the counts
\,/
further stated that for the 3am
Investigationon 08/16/2019 at New York, New York, United States (In Person)
File # Date drafted 08/19/2019
by

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)

(u) :nterview of Corrections Officer
Continuation of ED-302 parancranag .on 08/16/2019  .page 2 of 2
because he was by himself. said that there should always be a double
staff count and that he always wanted a partner to do the count and wouldn't
do a count without a partner. advised that while doing the counts, an
officer should see breathing flesh. When and NOEL did the 3am and Sam
counts, they counted five inmates.
Officer THOMAS relieved at some point during the shift to give him
a break. Lieutenant came by at some point to check on
however, didn't remember the exact time.
was in 10 South when the call came over, referring to when EPSTEIN
was found unresponsive in his cell. then worked another shift in the
SHU, 8am-4pm.
stated that he once fed EPSTEIN because EPSTEIN had not received
his meal and that EPSTEIN was grateful. Wit said that EPSTEIN didn't
appear to be dangerous and that EPSTEIN never offered him money for
anything. stated that he was shocked that this had happened, referring
to EPSTEIN's death. said that EPSTEIN was supposed to be watched more
closely and that the rounds should have been conducted regardless of
whether EPSTEIN had previously been on suicide watch or not.
said that he wanted a lawyer. Investigators discontinued
questioning at that time.
On his own accord, then stated something to the effect of "I want
to be clear, I never brought stuff into the jail or allowed stuff in. I
never did that."
•
EFTA00128987 (Jmail)
 [crypto] FBI tip from Deutsche Bank anti-money laundering employee about Jared Kushner co. RealCadre crypto payments to suspicious Russians (she was 
overruled), see quote: "REAL CONTRAD appeared to be paying an employee in crypto-currency. HILL-MCFADDEN thought the activity was mind boggling and 
she had never seen a flow like that"
(date: 2019-08-21)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 7 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  08/21/2019
On July 12, 2019, TAMMY HILL-MCFADDEN (HILL-MCFADDEN), was interviewed at
the Jacksonville, FL field office of the Federal Bureau of Investigation.
HILL-MCFADDEN'S legal representation present during the interview consisted
of KRISTEN DOOLITTLE and BRIAN MCCAFFERTY. Assistant United States
Attorneys consisted Also present during
the interview were Special Agents HILL-
MCFADDEN was advised it was imperative she provide truthful information.
After being advised of the identities of the interviewing Agents and the
nature of the interview, HILL-MCFADDEN provided the following information:
HILL-MCFADDEN had over 18 years of anti-money laundering (AML) and know
your client (KYC) experience in the banking industry. She began her career
at Bank of America (BOA) in Jacksonville, FL as a loan officer. During her
approximately seven years of employment at BOA, she held several positions
including Assistant Branch Manager, Operations Manager and KYC Compliance
Officer. Following her BOA experience, she worked in contract positions for
CHASE and FIDELITY. In 2008, HILL-MCFADDEN began her employment with
DEUTSCHE BANK (DEUTSCHE) as a Senior Operations Specialist. She worked in
tax, audit and loan operations. Eventually, she became a KYC Manager and
the AML Compliance Officer. HILL-MCFADDEN held several certifications,
including but not limited to, AML and University of Cambridge
certifications.
After working in loan operations with DUETSCHE Securities for
approximately two years , HILL-MCFADDEN moved to the the role of KYC Manager
in or around 2010. While in that role, she managed eight to ten people.
The department was responsible for reviewing KYC documents for new customer
trading and equity accounts. The documents included, but were not limited
to, financial statements and articles of incorporation received from the
client on-boarding team. Once the documentation was received and reviewed
by HILL-MCFADDEN and her team, a decision to proceed or not was made and the
Investiptionon 07/12/2019  at Jacksonville, Florida, United States (In Person)
Filet Date drafted 07/24/2019
I

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Continuation oil:D-302 of (U) Interview - Tammy Hill -McFadden a 07/12/2019 m g, 2 of 7
on-boarding team was notified. HILL-MCFADDEN'S team would ensure the
information provided made sense. Part of this process was required by
section 326 of the Patriot Act.
Since HILL-MCFADDEN'S group made the final decision on opening an account
for new customers, typically individuals, she regularly received pressure
from relationship managers (RM) and individuals in New York, to get the
account opened. For example, a RM would tell HILL-MCFADDEN they needed an
account open by two o'clock. HILL-MCFADDEN typically replied to these
requests with an email explaining the issues and the protections for the RM
and the bank. At times, people would go above HILL-MCFADDEN to get what
they wanted, but she was not sure how successful they were. HILL-MCFADDEN
could not recall specific names or regions of where the pressure came from,
but she did recall a contact in New York named ZANAIB, who was a Senior Vice
President (SVP) on the KYC side.
HILL-MCFADDEN'S group was part of DEUTSCHE Securities, which was a part
of GTO, that included financial investments and equities. Although her
group worked out of Jacksonville, FL, she ultimately reported to New York.
Her chain of command was ELENITA ESCOBAR, Assistant Vice President (AVP),
STEVE HELLINGER, Vice President (VP), and PAUL KAVANAUGH, all in New York.
HILL-MCFADDEN held that role until 2014, when the work was outsourced to
India.
In 2014, HILL-MCFADDEN interviewed for and received the role of AML
Compliance Officer. HILL-MCFADDEN, who was no longer a manager, originally
reported to CLARRISA DELAFUENTE (DELAFUENTE), VP of transaction monitoring
in New York. HILL-MCFADDEN worked with private bank clients. She and one
other AML Compliance Officer, ALMARIE WORLDS, sat in Jacksonville, FL and an
additional two, YING WANG (WANG) and YANG WONG (WONG), sat in New York. The
work volume was astronomical. Additional Jacksonville, FL Compliance
Officers, MICHELLE GABRIEL, KEVIN WILSON, DANYA FRIEDMAN and CRIPA APAL were
added to the team. SHERI QUIGLEY (QUIGLEY), VP, took over for DELAFUENTE in
2015. QUIGLEY reported to WAYNE SALIT (SALIT), Director.
The transaction monitoring process began when one of the DEUTSCHE systems
created an alert. DEUTSCHE used MELAVANTE, aka PRIME, for compliance,
ACTIMIZE for trading activity, and other systems such as NORCOM. Senior
management created the alert parameters within these systems, such as dollar
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Contimmtion of FD-302 or ( U ) Interview - Tammy Hill-McFadden 07/12/2019 .page 3 of 7
amount, country, etc. Some, not all, of these parameters were visible to
HILL-MCFADDEN, but she never really questioned them. Alerts were generated
on a bi-weekly basis and cases were generated on a monthly basis in the
MELAVANTE system. Once these were generated, QUIGLEY would disseminate them
to the team to review. From there, a recommendation was made to QUIGLEY for
her approval. QUIGLEY was the one who made the decision to open up a case.
Alerts were supposed to be looked at immediately, but their team was busy
and that did not always happen. Alerts did not stop the account activity.
As part of her reviews, HILL-MCFADDEN looked at the accounts in the system,
the account activity, performed GOOGLE searches and used her judgement
accordingly to make a recommendation. The usual deadline for this work was
30 days. If deemed appropriate, an internal suspicious activity report
(SAR) was written. Although she was never directly told that she could not
write in internal SAR, HILL-MCFADDEN and her team often felt that doing so
was useless because it didn't go anywhere. The general consensus in the
private banking department was that if an internal SAR was submitted, there
would be pushback because all of the reviewers sat together and discussed
what was submitted.
QUIGLEY was not diligent and was incompetent. QUIGLEY instructed HILL-
MCFADDEN, by email or phone, to do things that were not part of written
policy. HILL-MCFADDEN followed QUIGLEY'S instruction but would write what
she did in an email and state that QUIGLEY instructed her to do so. QUIGLEY
once wrote her an e-mail and told her to never do that again. For example,
QUIGLEY made her Compliance Officers write case narratives before an
internal SAR was written. QUIGLEY would then decide if an internal SAR was
created or not. This was QUIGLEY'S process and it was not in the manual.
The Compliance Officer should have decided whether an internal SAR was
written, not QUIGLEY. Ultimately, the Managing Director, i.e. DOUG SLOAN
and/or SALIT, determined whether to file a SAR with FINCEN. The Compliance
Officer never knew whether or not their internal SAR actually went to
FINCEN.
In or around December of 2015, DELAFUENTE went on maternity leave and
provided HILL-MCFADDEN a formula to check the status of cases within the
system. HILL-MCFADDEN was working on a case and saw related cases to the
one she was working on from the previous months. In order to obtain more
information, HILL-MCFADDEN used the formula that was provided to her by
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Continuation oil:D-302 of (U) Interview - Tammy Hill -McFadden Dn 07/12/2019 m g, 4 of 7
DELAFUENTE. While in the system, HILL-MCFADDEN came across 102 politically
exposed persons (PEP) pending in deferred status. PEP'S were high risk
individuals and they should have been addressed immediately. New PEP'S
were reviewed by SALIT and existing PEP clients were reviewed by QUIGLEY.
All 102 referenced above were existing clients.
The system had three typical case/alert statuses: open, waved and
deferred. Deferred status was basically like "cyber space." In order for
something to be in deferred status, someone would have needed to change the
status accordingly. In HILL-MCFADDEN'S experience, although she had the
ability to do so, there was typically no real reason to put anything in
deferred status. If for some reason a deferred status was appropriate, it
should have only remained in that status for a few days.
After HILL-MCFADDEN discovered the PEP'S in deferred status, she emailed
QUIGLEY and asked her about the situation. At first, HILL-MCFADDEN assumed
it was just an oversight and she wanted to know what she needed to do to
address the issue. Approximately two hours later, QUIGLEY began rejecting
all of HILL-MCFADDEN'S work product in order to make her life difficult. As
a result, HILL-MCFADDEN'S productivity numbers went down and her bonus was
impacted. She believed QUIGLEY was extremely upset with her and as a
result, began intentionally rejecting her work. HILL-MCFADDEN thought
QUIGLEY knew about the PEP'S. She noticed that all 102 of them were placed
into deferred status by WANG, who sat next to QUIGLEY in New York. HILL-
MCFADDEN never spoke to him about the issue. HILL-MCFADDEN also noted
DELAFUENTE calculated the deferred cases into her reporting numbers and
QUIGLEY did not.
Approximately one month after HILL-MCFADDEN'S discovery of the 102 PEP'S,
she emailed SALIT and told him she believed QUIGLEY was intentionally
rejecting her work and hurting her productivity numbers. SALIT never
responded to the email. Eventually, HILL-MCFADDEN reported her issue with
QUIGLEY to FRANCESCA BENSON (BENSON) in human resources (HR) and they
subsequently opened an investigation in early 2016. After their
investigation and approximately one year after her reporting, HR determined
that no wrong doing occurred. Prior to 2016, HILL-MCFADDEN had received
great performance reviews. She received several awards and honors.
However, JOSEPH ACEDEBO (ACEDEBO), Director of Anti-Financial Crime (AFC),
continued to allow QUIGLEY to write HILL-MCFADDEN'S performance review even
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Continuation oil:D-302 of (U) Interview - Tammy Hill -McFadden a 07/12/2019 m g, 5 of 7
after she told him about the PEP'S issues and her issues with QUIGLEY.
ACEDEBO would always support QUIGLEY and SALIT. In her 2016 performance
review, HILL-MCFADDEN came across unusual and alarming language and detail.
It contained words, such as "inconsistent", that she had never before seen
used in her reviews. QUIGLEY'S retaliation towards HILL-MCFADDEN continued
until HILL-MCFADDEN was terminated in 2018.
At some point in 2016, HILL-MCFADDEN requested a transfer to a different
department. She applied for 12 to 16 jobs and did not receive any of them.
She also requested to be placed in the KYC department, where she previously
worked. Her former manager told her he never saw her resume come through.
On numerous occasions, HILL-MCFADDEN expressed her issues and desire to
transfer to JOSH BLAZER (BLAZER), Director, but nothing came of those
conversations. Every time she applied for a position in the HR system she
was instantly unsuccessful.
In or around late 2016, HILL-MCFADDEN came across an LLC account, REAL
CONTRAD, LLC (REAL CONTRAD), owned by JARED KUSHNER (KUSHNER) as part of a
case. The majority of the transactions were in crypto-currency and she was
unable to validate the origination or the recipient of the funds. It was
easy to determine the activity was suspicious and there was an issue. REAL
CONTRAD appeared to be paying an employee in crypto-currency. HILL-MCFADDEN
thought the activity was mind boggling and she had never seen a flow like
that. She examined the July and/or August 2016 activity. HILL-MCFADDEN
notified QUIGLEY about the activity and she was instructed to write a case
narrative and send it to her. HILL-MCFADDEN wrote the case narrative, sent
it to QUIGLEY, who determined HILL-MCFADDEN'S claims were unfounded. HILL-
MCFADDEN came across the name of a Russian individual. She GOOGLE searched
that individual and found a website that appeared to be made up. The
website said he was in the United States but there was no picture, just an
avatar. On the website, the individual was listed as an employee of REAL
CONTRAD but everything, including the job description, looked bogus. She
then went to one of KUSHNER'S website's and noted the individual was not
listed as an employee.

HILL-MCFADDEN continued to push QUIGLEY on the REAL CONTRAD issue.
QUIGLEY instructed her to speak with the RM, a woman named ROSE (ROSE).
Typically, when potentially suspicious activity was brought to the attention
of the RM, they used the information they knew or had to look into the
issues. They were not supposed to contact the client or ask them questions
related to the activity. It was the RM'S duty to monitor the due diligence
of their client's. However, in this situation, the RM contacted KUSHNER'S
company and was provided information about the person receiving the crypto-
currency. All of this information was documented. HILL-MCFADDEN
recommended the associated accounts be closed. SALIT and QUIGLEY were
involved in all REAL CONTRAD email discussions. After that, the case was
closed. HILL-MCFADDEN did not know if KUSHNER or DONALD TRUMP (TRUMP) were
in the original 102 PEP'S she discovered.

A few days after HILL-MCFADDEN raised concerns about the KUSHNER
accounts, BENSON told HILL-MCFADDEN that QUIGLEY wanted to meet with her.
QUIGLEY attended the meeting by phone while HILL-MCFADDEN and ERICA PRADA in
HR were present. During the meeting, HILL-MCFADDEN was told her
productivity was low and was asked if she was happy. It was during this
meeting that HILL-MCFADDEN realized QUIGLEY knew about her original HR
complaint.

In April of 2017, HILL-MCFADDEN transitioned to the role of AFC
Compliance Officer. She requested to work in KYC. but ACEDEBO told her no
and that AFC was her opportunity. Since MARLA LICONTE was the head of AFC
and SAR's, HILL-MCFADDEN was essentially working with the same group of
individuals. Since DEUTSCHE tended to discount concerns and sweep issues
under the rug, she felt this move was part of a plan to terminate her. One
day she received a message to come down stairs. She knew this meant she was
going to be terminated so she took her purse to her car prior to the
meeting. The meeting was with BLAZER and an individual named ERIN. Reading
from a piece of paper, they told her her productivity and performance was
low. HILL-MCFADDEN asked for a copy of the paper but they only provided her
the portion of the form that addressed benefits. They did not give her the
portion of the form that explained why she was terminated.
Also while employed by DEUTSCHE, HILL-MCFADDEN also raised concerns about
client JEFFREY EPSTEIN (EPSTEIN) . It appeared that EPSTEIN sent wires to
young women, perhaps in their twenties. He also sent wires to a woman in
France that owned an art gallery. HILL-MCFADDEN gathered this information
through GOOGLE searches. The entire Jacksonville, FL team wanted to
terminate the relationship with EPSTEIN. In 2015, HILL-MCFADDEN e-mailed
her concerns to QUIGLEY and told her she no longer wanted to work on
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Continuation oil:D-302 of (U) Interview - Tammy Hill -McFadden a 07/12/2019 m ile 7 of 7
EPSTEIN'S accounts and requested to have that work redistributed. QUIGLEY
replied that EPSTEIN served his time and the accounts were not closed at
that time. The EPSTEIN RM was (ROSE) . Also, in or around late 2016, an
internal SAR was filed on EPSTEIN'S lawyer, DARIN MCINKE. HILL-MCFADDEN
remembered learning about this SAR because the Federal Reserve was in the
bank at the time with QUIGLEY.
HILL-MCFADDEN also reviewed TRUMP'S old post office portfolio cases.
Since the DEUTSCHE systems did not talk to each other, she was unable to
determine a sound origin of the funds. The funds were being pulled from one
spot and moved to another for payments.
HILL-MCFADDEN filed complaints against DEUTSCHE with OSHA, FINRA and the
SEC. However, she did not file a lawsuit against DEUTSCHE.
EFTA01683641 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ video download of MCC cameras failed
(date: 2019-08-22)
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology

(U//FOUO) UNSUB; JEFFREY EPSTEIN — VICTIM; DEATH INVESTIGATION
Digital Evidence Tracking

(U//FOUO) Executive Summary: The New York Division (NY) initiated a death investigation for the apparent suicide of 
Jeffrey
EPSTEIN at the Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC) which occurred on 10 August 2019. On 12 August 2019, OTD was
contacted by the NY Division for assistance with a MCC video surveillance system consisting of two Digital Video 
Recorders (DVR1 -
operational and DVR2 — not operational) and a controller. The NY Division Computer Analysis Response Team (NY CART) has
collected digital evidence items associated with this investigation. OTD is currently tracking 37 digital evidence items
(associated
with DVR1 and DVR2):

(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 1B Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019599 — Hard Drive
— Seagate Barracuda
500GB HDD,
STSOODM002, S/N
Z3T6CJJA (DVR2 —1 of 18)
NYCO23578
1B1 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1822
(HCIC1019619). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 18 Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HCK1019600 - Hard Drive
— Hitachi 500GB HDD,
HDS721050CLA662, S/N
JP15721E36A13K (DVR2 —
2 of 18) NYCO23579
1B2 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1823
(HQQ019620). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ019601 — Hard Drive
— Seagate Barracuda
500GB HDD,
STSOODM002, S/N
Z3T6CFSX (DVR2 — 3 of

18) NYCO23580
1B3 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1824
(H00019621). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 1B Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019602 — Hard Drive
— Seagate Barracuda
500GB HDD,
ST350032ONS, S/N
9QM8MT9P (DVR2 4 of

18) NYCO23581
1B4 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1825
(HQQ019622). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ019603 — Hard Drive
— Hitachi 500GB HDD,
HDS721050CLA662, S/N:
JP15721E36MWNK (DVR2
- 5 of 18) NYCO23582
1B5 OTD -
DFAU
8/22/2019 — Data recovery 33% completed. Not
likely to be completed before 8/26/2019.
8/21/2019 — Repaired, data is being recovered -
26% complete.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD. Data
Recovery Program assessment ongoing.
Pending delivery of donor parts for repair.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
Damaged N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 19 Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019604 — Hard Drive
— Seagate Barracuda
500GB HDD,
ST350032ONS, S/N
9QM8EC75 (DVR2 - 6 of

18) NYCO23583
1B6 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1826
(HQQ019623). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ019605 — Hard Drive
— Seagate Constellation ES
500GB HDD,
ST500NM0011, S/N
Z1M1PZPE (DVR2 — 7 of

18) NYCO23584
187 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1827
(H00019624). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
• UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(UHFOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 1B Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019606 — Hard Drive
- Western Digital 500GB
HDD, WD5000AVDS-
63U7B1, S/N
WCAV9Z911026 (DVR2 -
8 of 18) NYC023585
188 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1828
(HQQ019625). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ019607 — Hard Drive
- Western Digital 500GB
HOD, WD5000AAKX-
60U6AA0, S/N
WCC2EJUC34CJ (DVR2 —9
of 18) NYC023586
189 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1829
(HQQ019626). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 1B Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019608 — Hard Drive
- Seagate Barracuda
500GB HDD,
ST3500320NS, S/N
9QM8MSEZ (DVR2 - 10 of

18) NYCO23587
1810 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1830
(HQQ019627). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ019611 — Hard Drive
- Seagate Constellation ES
500GB HDD,
STSOONMO011, S/N
Z1M1PX26 (DVR2 — 11 of

18) NYCO23588
1B11 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1831
(HQQ019628). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
UNCLASSIFIEDRFOUO
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 16 Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019612 — Hard Drive
- Seagate Constellation ES
500GB HDD,
STS00NM0011, S/N
Z1M1Q1FX (DVR2 —12 of
18) NYC023589
1B12 OTD -
DFAU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 - Confirmed clone 1832
(HQQ019629). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ019613 — Hard Drive
- Western Digital 500GB
HDD, WD5000AVDS-
63U7B1, S/N
WCAV9T870016 (DVR2 -
13 of 18) NYC023590
1B13 OTD -
DFAU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — 100% acquired. Forensic Image
made to DFAU OpWan. Clone being created
and turned over to Examiner.
8/19/2019 — Damaged heads. DFAU performed
head stack swap, data is slowly imaging. 97%
complete.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD. Data
Recovery Program assessment ongoing.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
Damaged N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 1B Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019614 —Hard Drive
- Western Digital 500GB
HDD, WDS000AAKX-
60U6AAO, S/N
WCC2EODE83YK (DVR2 -
14 of 18) NYCO23591
1B14 OTD -
DFAU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Imaged to DFAU OpWan. Clone
created (HQQ) and turned over examiner.
8/21/2019 — Repairs Completed, data
recovered, multiple bad sectors.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD. Data
Recovery Program assessment ongoing.
Pending delivery of donor parts for repair.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
Damaged N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HOO019615 — Hard Drive
- Seagate Barracuda
500GB HDD,
ST3500320NS, S/N
9QM8MT6D (DVR2 — 15
of 18) NYCO23592
IBIS OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1833
(HQQ019630). Forensic Image on NYO Op Wan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 16 Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019616 — Hard Drive
- Seagate Constellation ES
500GB HDD,
ST500NM0011, S/N
Z1M1PZ07 (DVR2 —16 of

18) NYCO23593
1B16 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Confirmed clone 1834
(HQQ019631). Forensic Image on NYO OpWan.
No further processing required. Item returned
to OTD ECU pending shipment back to NYO.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ019617 — Hard Drive
- Seagate Constellation ES
500GB HDD,
STSOONMO011, S/N
Z1M1LOYG (DVR2 — 17 of
18) NYCO23594, Former
Bay 9 Drive
1B17 OTD -
DFAU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Forensic Image completed to DFAU
OpWan. Clone created (H00019354) and
turned over to examiner.
8/19/2019 — DFAU reports 100% data recovery,
device is currently imaging.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD. Data
Recovery Program assessment ongoing.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
Damaged N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 1B Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019618 - Hard Drive
- Seagate Barracuda
500GB HDD,
51350032MS, S/N
9QM8MSRR (DVR2 -18
of 18) NYCO23595,
Former Bay 14 Drive
1B18 OTD -
DFAU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Forensic Image Completed to DFAU
OpWan. Clone created(HQQ019355) and
turned over to examiner.
8/19/2019 — DFAU reports partial data recovery
(44 bad sectors not recovered), device is
imaging.
8/16/2019 — Device arrived at OTD. Data
Recovery Program assessment ongoing.
8/15/2019 - Collected, in evidence control
pending shipment to OTD.
Damaged N/A 5/tarted:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ019595 — Disk Array
Chassis; Nice Systems
Model#: SA-66405, SN:
F96168201-004 (DVR2)
1819 OTD -
DFAU
8/16/2019 — Chassis for inoperable DVR2
arrived at OTD. Drives removed prior to arrival
at OTD
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
HQQ019596 - Disk Array
Controller; NICE Systems
Model#: NP-2000, SN:
43144902 (DVR2)
1B19 OTD -
DFAU
8/16/2019 — Controller for inoperable DVR2
arrived at OM. Contains 2 Drives
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOU0
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(U//FOUO) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 1B Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
HQQ019331 — Hard Drive
— Seagate Model#:
51-3320620AV, SN:
9QFCN325, 320GB (Top
Drive of HQQ019596 -
Disk Array Controller)
1B19 OTD -
ECU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 - No further processing required.
Item returned to OTD ECU pending shipment
back to NYO.
8/19/2019 — Clone created (HQQ019332) and
imaged to DFAU OpWan.
8/16/2019 — Top Hard drive for HQQ019596 -
Disk Array Controller arrived at OTD
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ019332 — Hard Drive
- Western Digital, 320GB,
Model#: WD3200JB, SN:
WCAMR1020769
none OTD —
DFAU
08/21/2019 — Created by examiner for use in
disk array.
N/A N/A Started:
8/21/2019
HQQ019594
— DVR Controller - Dell
PowerEdge R420 DVR
Controller, Barcode#
SBMQZ12, Express service
Code #: 11587249622,
Manufacturer date:
20140829 (DVR1)
1B20 OTD -
DFAU
8/22/2019 - Contains 2 drives Bay 1(HQQ) and
Bay 2(HQQ). Drives Imaged to DFAU OpWan
and clones created (HQQ)
8/16/2019 — DVR controller for operable DVR1
arrived at OTD.
TBD TBD Started:
8/16/2019
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(UHFOU0) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 18 Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
H00019597 — DVR
System - Disk Array
Chassis containing 16
hard Drives; Model#:
Premium 8600, SN:
232476
1B21 OTD -
DFAU
8/22/2019 — Drives being labeled with HQQ
identifiers, imaged and cloned.
8/16/2019 — Operable DVR1 system arrived at
OTD. 16 Drives
TBD N/A Started:
8/16/2019
HQQ019598 - Disk Array
Controller; Model#: NP-
2000, SN: 43144901
(DVR1)
1621 OTD -
DFAU
8/16/2019 — Operable DVR1 system arrived at
OTD. Contains 2 drives: 1 damaged, 1
functional. Drives given HQQ identifiers,
imaged and cloned.
TBD N/A Started:
8/16/2019
HQQ0I8525 — Hard drive
— Maxtor DiamondMax
10, 80GB, Model#:
6L080P0, SN: L25C8D3G,
Top Drive
1B21 OTD —
DFAU
COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Drive imaged and Cloned(HQQ)
and Clone turned over to examiner.
8/21/2019 — Damaged hard drive repaired, data
is being recovered (10 bad sectors).
8/16/2019 — Arrived at OTD as part of 1B21.
Top Drive (1 of 2)
Damaged N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Completed:
8/22/2019
HQQ018526 — Hard Drive
- Maxtor DiamondMax
10, 80GB, Model#:
6L080P0, SN: L25CF5QG,
Bottom Drive
1B21 OTD -
DFAU
8/16/2019 — Arrived at OTD as part of 1821.
Bottom Drive (2 of 2)
N/A N/A Started:
8/16/2019
Operational Technology Division
Countering Threats Through Technology
(UHFOU0) 90A-NY-3151227 Digital Evidence items — As of 22 August 2019 1400
Description 18 Physical
Location
Status Challenges Lawful
Access
Time in Process
1B22 -1836 - Derivative
Evidence —14 Hard Drives
containing clone copies of
multiple Hard Drives from
DVR2.
1B22 OTD -
DFAU
8/21/2019 — Arrived at QT on 8/20, in process
with DFAU.
8/20/2019 — Drives delivered to OTD.
8/19/2019 — Derivative evidence — clone copies
of hard drives removed from DVR2. Collected
by DFAU UC Petronella to be delivered to OTD
on 8/20/2019
N/A N/A Started:
8/20/2019
1640 — Hard Drive - One

(1) Seagate 500GB hard
drive, serial number
W2AEXSJV, containing
video downloaded from
DVR1 at MCC
1840 NY CART COMPLETE
8/22/2019 — Item not at OTD. Nothing further
to report.
8/19/2019 — Copy of all video available for
download for 8/10/2019, All relevant video
from Special Housing Unit floor 9 and Attorney
Visit area floor 3 from 7/23 to 8/10/2019, All
video available to download for 8/9 (THIS
DOWNLOAD FAILED) and video downloaded by
tech, (that is the wrong camera).
N/A N/A N/A
EFTA00129169 (Jmail)
 [article] Front Page article about Epstein visit to Cuba with Pastrada in 2003
(date: 2019-08-23)
8:18 0 N ✓ wG',, 91%s
V Q •
https://williamsonsource
.com/westhaven-golf
-club-hires-general
-manager-perry
-lancianese-executive
-chef-bill-brown/
Thursday, August 29, 2019
3 Sorry it's late... Danny
from Miami knows
Epstein and said
procured girPrk Cuba
for Glenn and Epstein
3 I I have a terrible
memory ... so I had to tell
you now
https://www
.frontpagemag.com
/fprn/274680/epsteins
± Enter message
10:58 AM
III 0
8:19 g° 91%III
etA httpS://www
.frontpagemag.com
/fpm/274680/epsteins
-castro-odyssey-humberto
-fontova
I'm sure you already
know all about this but
obviously now I'm going
down the rabbit hole and
everything said is
making sense I had no
idea he had some kind
of link to Cuba
11:02 PM
0 Sorry now I'm remem-
bering a trip that Glenn
took with Craig/ to Cuba
several years ago
to Craig/ made him a
book and printed it out
that C;IPnn leant in hic
+ 'Enter message tr,
11:03 PM
III 0
8:19 0 N 91%Ii
/fpm/274680/epsteins
-castro-odyssey-humberto
-fontova
I'm sure you already
know all about this but
obviously now I'm going
down the rabbit hole and
everything said is
making sense I had no
idea he had some kind
of link to Cuba
0  Sorry now I'm remem-
bering a trip that Glenn
took with Craig/ to Cuba
several years ago
-10 Craig/ made him a
book and printed it out
that Glenn kept in his
bedroom on his yacht
+ Enter message ir
11:04 PM
III 0
Epstein's Castro Odyssey I Frontpage Mag Page 1 of 2
EPSTEIN'S CASTRO ODYSSEY
Did Fidel's secret police have something on him?
aura zs.zoit Nutria raison
'Epstein traveled to Cuba at Castro's invitation. former Colombian president says.. Amid journalistic revelations about 
nomfying and reprehensible sex scandals
of
financier Jeffrey Epstein. a trip of mine on his ptane to Nassau. Bahamas has appeared. to transfer to the final 
destination of Havana. Cuba. invited by
President Fidel
Castro (on March 20031? (Former Colombian Pres. Andres' Pastrana as recently quoted in the Miami 
Herekt)(htlps1/www.miamdlerald cominewsMation-
worldhforkflamericaskubalarficie234OO9227.htmf)
in Cuba. the link between tourism and prostitution is perhaps more direct than in any other country that hosts sex 
tounsts (The ECPAT Network - End Child
Prostitution in Asian Tourism - n a study titled Child Prostitution and Sex Tounsm in Cuba 'I (IVO /rbabalublog
comr2018/12/28Avorkl.chammons-of-chtIO-prostrtution-
honor-fidel-castro-st•un-how-Mling4
'Since she la Cuban woman or girl] is usually desperate. he [a sex tounstj can usually secure sexual access to her very 
cheaply Sex tourists state that it costs
them less
to spend two weeks indulging themselves in Cuba than it does in Mier Centers of sex tourism such as Thailand Girls aged 
14.15 are even more desperate for
dollars
and therefore more vulnerable.' (Dr. Julia O'Connell Davidson of Britain's Univ. of Nottingham in her study titled 'The 
Rights and VVrongs of Prostitution ")
Maori/books google.comibooks?idadwuN8y-SeYtICapgrPTI82tdpg=PT18240vhumberto•fonfovseDr Julia•0%E2%80%
99ConnelHDavidson•Wba6souu=blaofs=m-a5NBUR n&sg=ACILI3U1Uu1DjAd2w8RIYYgPU 
OZKonMWABhl=ariasa•XBved=2shUKEwid9s2584XkAnVO/KBKHZZnC/c
'My job was to bug their hotel rooms. Famous Amencans are the priority objectives of Castro's intelligence. Wien the 
celebrity visitors arrived al the Hotels
Nacional.
Melte Habana and Melia Cohiba. we already had their rooms completely bugged with sophisticated taping equipment. But not
just the rooms. we'd also follow the
visitors
around. sometimes we covered them 24 hours a day. They had no idea we were tailing them " (High-ranking Cuban 
intelligence defector Delfin Fernandez.)
(httpslAimwamazon.com/Longest-Romence-Mainstream-Media-Castro/dp/1594O365754ef=sr 7_1?
snbooksaie•UTF8.5q4.13713276O498sr=1-18keywords.theslongest+rOmanCe•humberto+fontova)
In fairness. convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein visited the Castro Family Fiefdom before the sex-abuse allegations 
against him surfaced. And chances are the
going
rate of desperate child prostitutes per hour (extremely low in Cuba) weren't a major consideration for this 
multi.misionaire... but still.
The above quotes describe the desperation of the brutalized and impoverished residents of a nation that prior to the 
glorious Castro/Ch0 revolution enjoyed a
higher per
capita income than Japan and half the nations of Europe and who welcomed more immigrants (primarily from Europe) per 
CafMa than the U.S. Prior to the glorious
Communist liberation. people were as desperate to enter Cuba as they are now to escape.
For many folks who grew up in pre-Castro Cuba an amateur film by Canadian Andrew Lindy titled 'The Cuba Prostitution 
Documentary' proved more heartbreaking than
anything they'd seen on their homeland to that date. Lindy. by the way, is a Canadian and winner of the Canadian 
National Magazine Award—hence no 'Cuban exile
with an axe to grind'! 
(httpsfibabefublog.com,20)8/02/12//iffnears-ot-fake-news-lake-movies-and-lake-history-on-che-guevare-and-640-castro-dern
olishechin-rock-
rottin-yal-spHOM
'Prostitution is rampant,' he narrates upon his visit to Cuba as a tounst in 2011. Indeed. during his entire stay Lindy 
was hard-pressed to find a single Cuban
woman or
gut who wouldn't offer sex for pay, of some sort AM half the males he encountered were at least part-time pimps.
Oh. I know...I know. That pre-Castro Cuba was 'Bordello to the Americas,* is a Fake News/Fake History mantra. But 
actually in 1961 the Castrates rounded up what
they determined were all the prostitutes in Cute and herded them into re-education camps to ream more seemly 
professions-Mtecianas, for instance. The total
number
of women rounded up in this 'brothel of the Americas,' as the Fake News/Hollywood mantra has claimed for over half a 
century was about 14,000 (out of a Cuban
population of 6.7 million at the time)
But a study by the American Journal of Nursing estimates there are 50.000 prostitutes in New York City alone.
Indeed. the blatant fakeness of the KGB-concocted propaganda meme about pre-Castro Cuba as a 'big brother was exposed 
and demolished years ago. In lone(. Fredo
Coneys, would find many, MANY more hookers in Castro's Havana than he did during The Godfather ll. (https.kbabalublog
corn/2015,06/291cuba.bordello-to-the-norkl-
now-not-during-the-1940-503-when-prostitubon-was-trmal-m-companson-waming-this-post-contradicts-godfather-20
https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/274680/epsteins-eastro-odyssey-humberto-fontova 8/30/2019
Epstein's Castro Odyssey I Frontpage Mag Page 2 of 2
Interestingly, in a 2003 interview Epstein, who recently committed suicide in his jail cell (or so the official story 
goes), spoke about the care he took
against the risk of blackmail: 'My concern is that people can make spurious allegations all the belle: he said. •The 
Idea Is if nothing else hell buy me off.
I'll attack his reputation and he'll
buy me off? 
(MtpslAvww.bloomberg.cominewsleatures2019-08-14rthe-epsteuNapes-unearthecl-recoduigs•In3m-his-private-island-pbmb3p1)
So I'm guessing that--unlike so many others among the nth and famous and unscrupulous—Epstein was too cagey for Castro 
to blackmail or otherwise swindle.
Indeed,
one of Epstein's rich and famous Mends (ho shows up on Epstein's now-notorious Little Black Book) named Amado Fahkre 
paid dearly for his visits to the Castro
Crime
Fiefdom.
The millionaire investor and developer is a Lebanese-born British national who owned Coral Capital and invested heavily 
in Castro's Cuba, developng 9011 courses
and hotels. One evening in 2011 Fahkre and his business associate and fellow Brit Stephen Purvis were the back-slapping 
toasts and celebrated business partners
of the Castro Crime Family. The next morning they woke up to find themselves robbed blind by Castro and in a 
KGB-designed torture chamber. where they languished
for two years on charges of corruption. (Actually the Castro Family Crime Syndicate Simply wanted to burglarize their 
hard-won but ill-gotten Cuban assets.)
'Rabid-Right-1AIng-Cuban-Americans-with-an-Axe-to-Grindr (i.e. people who, owing to direct experience. know essay how 
the Castro Crime Syndicate works and by to
wain others) had a ball playing the word's smallest violins with the travails of Fakhre and Purvis. who th ose not to 
heed our warnings.
(httpslibabalublog.conv2013/07/06/castros-long-time-batish-business-partner-stephenpuntis-has-apiphantatter-arres0
Maybe Epstein's instincts saved him from this earlier humiliation at the hands of Castro? But who really knows what kind
of videos Castro's secret pace might
have had on him in their little Black Books?
https://www.frontpagemag.com/fpm/274680/epsteins-castro-odyssey-humberto-fontova 8/30/2019
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Wexner Foundation [business] Les Wexner pro-Israel charity of Les Wexner where Epstein had decision making authority [dropsite] 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01249854 (Jmail)
 [government] letter from Erez Zadok to FBI tip about Wexner Foundatoin and Epstein
(date: 2019-08-26)
Continuing your investigation of registered sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, I'm writing to express my
concern regarding the relationship between Mr. Epstein, the Wexner Foundation, located in Ohio and

Mr. Ehud Barak.

The foundation appointed Jeffrey Epstein to the trustee of the fund. Mr. Epstein is also one of the fund's
main donors.

In 2001, Mr. Epstein transferred approximately 9 million USD to the Wexner Foundation.

During the years 2004.2006, the Wexner Foundation transferred at least 2.3 million USD to the Israeli
former Prime Minister Ehud Barak. Mr. Epstein signed personally on few of the transfers' forms.

Mr. Epstein new Mr. Barak in person, while he hold his contact details in the phone book that was
caught by the FBI, and Mr. Barak has been seen visiting Mr. Epstein's apartment in NYC.

The Wexner Foundation make donations to programs that develop Jewish leaders, and to other Jewish
charities

The amounts transferred to Mr. Barak were described as 'research', but Mr. Barak and the Wexner
Foundation refuse to reveal the research issue or any other details.

It doesn't make sense for a small charity fund such as the Wexner Foundation, to pay a relatively huge
amount of money, for an unknown research.

It doesn't make sense that a charity fund will refuse to reveal the issue and goals of such a research.
The Wexner Foundation activities are identified with the left wing of the political map in Israel, and so is

Mr. Barak.

Taking all that into consideration, the exception, weird and unusual payment from the Charity Fund to

Mr. Barak, while he is running for the Israeli Parliament during that period, before it and after it, looks
like a forbidden political contribution.

Also there is a suspicion for Money Laundering violation, when Mr. Epstein uses The Wexner
Foundation, to wire millions to Mr. Barak.

I thought you must be aware to the above, especially when Mr. Epstein has been arrested again last
Saturday.

Thank you for your time and attention to this matter.
Most Sincerely,
Erez Zadok
Israel
3501.457-002
Page 1 of 1
╔═════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 MLAT [government] Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00040006 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ Personal History of Defendant Jeffrey Epstein + grand jury indictment
(date: 2019-08-27)
LA1% LNMRCENIE\ I MASI FIVE
I N. l)rpartment of Justice
oiled States .%larshals Sin ice Personal History of Defendant
liken i to Federal custody by the following:
Street Arrest (not from a correctional detention facility )
O Custodial Arn:si (from a correctional detention facility) ❑
estrrit 1 sed (Must pros ide copy of yyrit) / 4141 :'-'r
Prior Federal Arrest or Safi:keeper - Register u:
O lyarckecper Location:
Blind( \PIM \I INISIlt \ I \ I lit\
Last Name: 7-
Sex: r Transgendcr
flair: 6
City of Birth: et
1:10 N:
Resident Address/City/State/ZIP: 9 ex* home Phone: Cell Phone: 1
First Name:
Eyes: S/oct
Statett'ountry of Birth:
State Inn:
rivy9
Middle Name:
lull RI ( v.!
Agent Last Name
Agent Phone N:
I.ocation/Facility of Arrest:
Court Docket 0: Al SA(s) Assigned:
gencv 0121:
01 I I NNI
I NCR' Code Charge Description SitlArr/C.,11,/j
t.st.  7/
Known Detainers/%Varranis: eft'  O •i• - Agency:
( \I 'Inv. \\I) \ii 1)11
tAiusi pan lilt a rap) of am ;Mann n)
Lung Term Medical Conditions bean problem.. Jabot.. mama. Where uloth. I II V. AIDS. Seim ItIK. met O
Psychiatric/Emotionally Disturbed ir.s.. mental health f011talli...ultid Al. etc.1:
Injuries/Medical Ailments/Post-Op Recovery:  D
Do the shove conditions empire:
Medical attention? N O 1'
Medication? \ ❑ 1'
Medical clearance by a licensed physician: Nit] \ ❑ 1'
Is Defendant under the influence of drugs or alcohol: ism ❑ 1'
Languages - F:nglivh: ❑ N .16❑ i.imited
Other Language: N • i.ist:
Security Cautions:
C rrent or former military
t or former public official
I gild,: liw diplomatic immunity
Ihreal to witness (Describe Moo/
0 Current or former I.I. corrections
❑ Assault on LI: corrections
❑ Leadership mk
O Ci /Describe below,
El Current or runner intelligence
❑ SAM subjr:ct or candidate
❑ Separation weds ilktecrine Mott I
❑ Other !Describe helm.;
Title/Code
TES
Page I or 3
Form USM-312
Rev 11/17
LAW liNFORCEMIA
Remarks:
Date of Birth
\\]O( l.\11  O-O1,1 \ I) \ REI I I\ Is, I 1111 tilti %.11;NII I( %NJ ()I
;Relationship Last Name
Sea rh)I a rkflattOn (Specif))
License Number
NI Est F %NI (11 S Ni \I111 Its
Location
Register N
Color(s) chicle Style
License State
Rank Na me Account Type Attain Branch Address Phone N
Nliscellancuus Number r) (Select from dropdroor mend or /we below;
State Driver's License
Resident Address. City. State,
ZIP Code
State and
Plate
Phone
Registration
Date
Remarks (e.g.. Issuing Matt or 1 sunlit. etc.)
Occupation: LO/ Cy Company/Employer Name:
Employment Address: Vi Rood' hive"
Start Date: End Dale: Point of Contact:
. Entry Discharge
Br itch Rank Date Date  Discharge 1) pe Nlilitar) Occupation Remarks t
Ailitiltorral Inform:4 tion/RemarksicontinultiOn:
Defendant Ricks: 4Requires rentarkr hermr
Escapee O Planned Murder
O Organized ('rinte• O Protected Witness
O Intonational 'lerroeist ❑ Domestic Terrorist
o Gang \limber' O Significant Criminal I listor)
E Multiple Defendants O Math Penahy Case
AES
Page 2 or 3
Sex Offender:
C Arrest
O Registered
O Convielion
O Registration Violation
Form tiSk4,3i2
Rev 11117
LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVI.
Criminal History (Select/ront dtrynhnen menu or type offense below) Arrest (a) Conviction (N)
Remit e.g.. name of gang or criminal organization. tic.):
Pc
O Money Launderer O Kingpin O Violent ()Ifender
I\ I I I(\ I I 1/4.1. /1 1(1
I Internet Source Remarks (e.g.. email address. website address, usernamc. etc.)
NOTICE TO ARRESTING AGENTS: As a courtesy. the USMS may temporarily hold an arrestee received by nOn•USMS personnel in 
the cellblock until the arresting agents) make arrangements for
the prisoners initial appearance before a United States Magistrate. A prisoner remains the responsibility of the 
arresting agency until remanded to the custody of the USMS b) the
coons. When a counesy hold is allowed by the USMS to be housed in a USMS celiblock, a minimum alone agent from the 
arresting agency must be available to respond to the teak& in order
to address any issues with their prisoner (e.g.. medkal. disciplinary ). If the arresting agency refuses to comply with 
USMS procedures. the courtesy bold may be refused. Meals are
not provided by the ISMS. and remain the responsibility of the arresting agent(s).
ARRF.STF.F. PROCT.SSING CHECKLIST
For Attesting Officer OnlY
141 . SNI•i ll 2 (Personal )(isn't). of lkfendant)
‘ledical clearance Ilium licensed physician). it necessary
opy of Arrest Warrant. if issued
Copy of Complaint. Information. or Indictment. if completed
O Copy Of Uletainens). if issued
O Copy of Writ. if applicable
❑ Correctional facility discharge papas. if applicable
O Correctional facility prisoner receipt. ilapplicable
❑ Correctional facility medical summary. if applicable
Prepared Sy - Name:
gilt piee7,6e/e (etechitte)
ARRESTEE PROCESSING ClitTIO.IST
For Personnel Only
D Confirm all arresting agent documentation is employs' and
inserted into prisoners fik
O 15.312 (Personal History of Defundam). rev/crew/..
urn/run/.Armor awoke /HSI/ M.O
❑ I SM-552 (Prisoner Medical Records Release Form) •
comp/wed rignediroiriLms/hr inmActri 111.0
CI I NNI-Ig (Federal Prisoner Property Receipt - tompleteil
si)net, tun! dated ht intake Ill Sll Ohl)
❑ USNI-10 41 (Prisoner Remand). libelled Mel prisoner's Ilk
O USN1•130 (Prisoner Custody A kn Notice). if applicable -
bnerreriinro prisoner's. fi le
O ED-249 (Fingerprint Card) - twit:wawa inserted into
prisoner's
O Prisoner Photograph (km. Booking Package) -11/4 trued mar
howler/it

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C)
U
I'aµc Perm USIS1•312
Rev l I/17
STATE 0530E
WV SE0:00
54.7347,39703 isup,a7773,air 0.A5.3 Aulknace•
STAN
SCeonlint a inroad n7,73(
L3.3T rW11LLLL. 3.40037. a 5,0 Foe
2P2TRIN, J2291222 EDWARD
Wan Neuter's:, aht Sun
µuSF1\SY111
LA37 vat fig37 OWE. 744,00LE WAL
EPSTRIN,JR20223 2
LI 1133.0
OATI, CI OATH eau CO Y.'
01/20/1953
• n 7.740tt
let MCI
N W
MTIGHT *TICK: PLIS run
1273 115 SW SRO
-..---.
--V....
CRIMINAL JUSTICE INFORMATION SERVICES DIVISION, CLARKSBURG, WV 26306 PRI WAD • ACT Of I$71 I0L 953795 REQUIRES THAT 
FEDERAL STATE OR LOCAL AGENCIES INFORM •NOWIDLIALS WHOSE SOCIAL
SECUIRTY NUMBER IS REQUESTED W
ST/CH CITSCLOSJITE IS MANDATORY OR VOLUNTARY RASPS OF AUTHORITY FOR SUCH SOLICI TATION. AND USES WHIGS WILL BE MADE  OF 
IT
JMVAN It FINGERPRINT I OR,
SUBMISSION YES CONTRIBUTOR
A000155
tale •5 ADULT •II
SEND COP• TO
,ENTER ORR
MiSCILLANI
PP 566672615
PP-516923892
PP-469911707
(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7
DATE OF ARREST
1111 00 VT
07/08/2019
DAIL Of CFI IWO
MM OD v•
07/08/201,
UNIIT/TITSVFACIARSHALS SERVICE
Naykr_71•1 you.  fly
REPLY YES I—
Ot/TREOf • —T
•LACL OF BIRTH STATE OR COUNTRY,
MT
SCARS.  . TATTOOS. •NO AMPUTATION{
9 SNOT 91S7
MOM VOldt
IL A000451
WE 10011 VI
OENTIFTGAT ON , NCR
C AGENCY
m Law., %LH 01 AHD SERIAL NO
CHARGETC ON
I 07/0e/2019
369S-Sex Offense
•0051,0%.,
OCCUPATION
WOUCIR
COUNTRY OP Cal 10
CITY STATE
•HOTO ATIAMIMMIT 444
PALM PAINTS TAKEN> TES
0 ,100$••ION
•00.510ITA.
ADDIT..ONAL iNFORMATkOmrEASTS FOR CALITIJN STATE BUREAU STAMP
F02191RY. 5 T1 0,1)(TUEH U S GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE OW3 ,20101309 43
DOCKET No. DEFENDANT
AUSA
INTERPRETER NEEDED
DEF.'S COUNSEL
❑ RETAINED O FEDERAL DEFENDERS 0 OA O PRESENTMENT ONLY
O DEFENDANT WAIVES PRETRIAL REPORT
CI Rule 5 O Rule 9 O Rule 5(cX3) O Detention Hrg. DATE OF ARREST  O VOL SURR.
TIME OF ARREST  DON WRIT
O Other: TIME OF PRESENTMENT
DAIL DISPOSITION
O SEE SEP. ORDER
❑ DETENTION ON CONSENT W/O PREJUDICE O DETENTION: RISK OF FLIGHT/DANGER O SEE TRANSCRIPT
O DETENTION HEARING SCHEDULED FOR:
O AGREED CONDITIONS OF RELEASE
O DEF. RELEASED ON OWN RECOGNIZANCE
❑ $ PRB ❑ FRP
O SECURED BY $ CASH/PROPERTY:
O TRAVEL RESTRICTED TO SDNY/EDNY/
O TEMPORARY ADDITIONAL TRAVEL UPON CONSENT OF AUSA & APPROVAL OF PRETRIAL SERVICES
O SURRENDER TRAVEL DOCUMENTS (& NO NEW APPLICATIONS)
O PRETRIAL SUPERVISION: O REGULAR O STRICT O AS DIRECTED BY PRETRIAL SERVICES
O DRUG TESTINGITREATMT AS DIRECTED BY PTS O MENTAL HEALTH EVAL/TREATMT AS DIRECTED BY PTS
O DEF. TO SUBMIT TO URINALYSIS; IF POSITIVE, ADD CONDITION OF DRUG TESTING/TREATMENT
O HOME INCARCERATION O HOME DETENTION O CURFEW O ELECTRONIC MONITORING O GPS
O DEF. TO PAY ALL OF PART OF COST OF LOCATION MONITORING, AS DETERMINED BY PRETRIAL SERVICES
O DEF. TO CONTINUE OR SEEK EMPLOYMENT [OR] O DEF. TO CONTINUE OR START EDUCATION PROGRAM
O DEF. NOT TO POSSESS FIREARM/DESTRUCTIVE DEVICE/OTHER WEAPON
O DEF. TO BE DETAINED UNTIL ALL CONDITIONS ARE MET
O DEF. TO BE RELEASED ON OWN SIGNATURE, PLUS THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS:
; REMAINING CONDITIONS TO BE MET BY:
ADDITIONAL CONDITIONS/ADDITIONAL PROCEEDINGS/COMMENTS:
O DEF. ARRAIGNED; PLEADS NOT GUILTY O CONFERENCE BEFORE DI. ON
O DEF. WAIVES INDICTMENT
❑ SPEEDY TRIAL TIME EXCLUDED UNDER 18 U.S.C. § 316l(h)(7) UNTIL
For Rule Man Cases:
O IDENTITY HEARING WAIVED O DEFENDANT TO BE REMOVED
O PRELIMINARY HEARING IN SDNY WAIVED O CONTROL DATE FOR REMOVAL:
PRELIMINARY HEARING DATE:  O ON DEFENDANT'S CONSENT
DATE: ?5"
WWI (onitnal) - COURT FILE
Rev 4 2)I TH • 2
PJ016- US. ATTORNEY'S OFFICE YiI
UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE, S.D.N.Y.
IOW  V S MARSHAL GRFPN PRETRIAL SERVICES AGENCY
Prepared on: 0812912019
UMW States Marshals Sarirke - LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
USM-129 Individual Custody/Detention Report
I Name: EPSTEIN,JEFFFtEY EDWARD

I. IDENTIFICATION DATA
USMS Number. 76318-054 F1D: 10127184
USN'S NUMBER: 76318-054
ADDRESS: 9
DOB: 01/20/1953
HAMS:
EAST 71ST NEW YORK, NY PHONE:
AGE: 66 PUB:
RPSTRIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
C.
/
BROOKLYN, NY
SEX: M RACE: N HAIR: BRO EYE: BLU HEIOOT: 6'00" WRIGHT: 185
" - (6 1)1( q(1 SSN: FBI NBR/UCH ALIEN NBR:
OTHER NUMBER OTHER NUMBER TYPE ISSUE DATE
Passport Number
Passport Number
Originating Police
or Identification
Number
Originating Police
or Identification
Number
Passport Number 03/08/2019
EXP DATE REMARK
US PASSPORT
NY SID $
03/07/2029 US PASSPORT *
REMARKS
Suicidal Tendencies
SEPARATES " SPECIAL CAUTIONS
AND MEDICAL
Mental Concerns
TB CLEARANCE STATUS ASSESSMENT DATE
NOT CLEARED
EXPIRED
DNA TEST DATE TAKEN? DEPUTY
N/A No N/A
RENARES/XIT 4
FBI ARREST
DETAINER DATE L/R ACTIVE? AGENCY
.splisis.*. N
REMARK
PRISONER ALIAS ALIAS REMARK
EPSTEIN,JEFFREY 6

II. CUSTODY INFORMATION
Custody 1 I CUSTODY START DATE: 07/08/2019 END DATE: 08/10/2019
Printed by District: 54 "Limited Official Use"
This Infonnabon is the Properly of the U.S. Marshals Sant* end Shall Not be Pubhely Released or Disseminated Without 
U.S. Marshals Service /Whacky.
Page 1 of 2
Prepared ow 08/29/2019
United States Marshals Service - LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
USM-129 individual Custody/Detention Report
Name:EPSIONdEFFREYEDWARD IUSMS Number: 76318-054 FID. 10127184 1
CUSTODY STATUS OFFICE START DATE: END DATE REMARK
WT-CASE -RESOLVE 054 07/C8/2019 08/10/2019
RL SUICIDE 054 08/10/2019 08/10/2019
COURT CASE 1 DISTRICT OFFICE JUDOS US ATTORNEY DEFENSE ATTORNEY
NY/S 500 PEARL ST. 19-CR-00490 (MANHATTAN)
Arrests
ARREST DATE ARRESTING AGENCY ARREST LOCATION WARRANT
NUMBER
07/08/2019 FEDERAL BUREAU OF
INVESTIGATION
Offenses
CONE OFFENSE REMARK DISPOSITION
18 USC 372 SEX TRAFFICKING 3699 Sex Offense Other CONSPIRACY
COURT CASE STATUS START DATE END DATE REIARK
ARREST 07/08/2019 07/08/2019
WT TRIAL 07/08/2019 08/10/2019
CASE -RESOLVED 06/10/2019 08/10/2019
INST INSTITUTION NAME ADMIT RELEASE BOARDED ACTION OR DISPOSITION
NYM MCC New York 07/08/2017 08/10/2019 33
TOTAL DAYS BOARDED 33 (0 BID, 0 NED)
III. MEDICAL CONDITION/TREATMENT HISTORY
DATE SERVICE
PROVIDED VENDOR SERVICE PROVIDED
• / • • • * * •
Printed by District 54 ''Limited Official Usr
This Infoonation Is the Property of the U S Marsha Semce and Shall Not be Pubicly Released or Disseminated Without U.S 
Marshals Service Authority
Page 2012
L.S. Virgin Islands
Ok1VEK,S g pi SE
LTTTLE ST. JAMES
ST THOMAS VI 00802
se. M .;....get 6.0" F • BLU
:e.e 1/20/1953
E r e. 1, 2O(2O24
3/6/2019
943 s:435 F
(b) (6), (b) (7)(C)
.EFFREY E crPSTEIN
PAM BCH, FL 3460-4730
DO8: 0140495,3 SEX M KOI 6.00
■
'DJI 3905210033
CLASS: A- Private Endorsement(s)
REPLACEMENT LICENSE REWIRED 0 DAYS OF ADCRESS ORANGE OR
= NAME CHANGE
rivesbnv vl got
. 52u^fat Flonde ratWis OR W OP ngt""4000,
Yr
Kytty
truPs'en  pk$S
r joue  erLert ort:
noNOMNAM
reaMmWs.MMA.A.
I UnitedHealtheare
Health Plan (80840
Member ID Group Number: 272605 Member SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Payer ID 87726
Office $20 ER 1200
Urgeare STS Spec 130
OPIUM -
Rx Bin. 610279 Rx PCN- 9999
Rx Grp UHC
UnitedHealthcare Choice Plus Underwaen by Unileallealthcave Entrance COMPanY
1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227)
NAME OF BENEFICIARY
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
sec
MALE
EFFECTIVE GATE
HOSPITAL (PART A) 01-01-2018
MEDICAL (PART B) 02y2018
' • I": b"
l (6). (b) (7)(0
SIGN
HERE asp
t£09 .29E -008-I
&Iwo hq p.mo Mau Jnott
parttapai encl.! UJ njuOD aseaid
'V^
Ported 12)17 16
1 Ed AVSlilik
Members: We're here to help. Check benefits, view claims, find
a doctor, ask a question and more.
Web: www.myuhc.com Call anytime to speak
Email: Advocate4me©uhc.com with a %Me
Phone: 800-782-3740
Mental Health. 800-842-2065
Providers:.ms: 877-1342-3210 or www.UnitedHeatthcareOnline.com
Medical Cla  P.O.BOX 740800 A TA GA 303740800
PR - MAPFRE - PO pat170297, San Juan,PR 00936-8297
itaa 4MultiPan mApsite ' FuttitatkOle .«:+
Pharmacists= 888-290-64i 6
Pharmacy Claims: OptumRx PO Box 29044 Hot Springs, AR 71903
' ry your card with you when you're at:a,
_et your hospital or doctor see your card when you ncu
hospital, medical, or health services under Medicare.
Your card is good wherever you live in the United State,
WARNING: Issued only for use of the named beneficiary.
,ntentional misuse of this card is unlawful and may be
punishable by fines, imprisonment, and other penalties.
If found, drop in nearest U.S. Mail Box.
Questions about Medicare
,ot no c' • wok 4tent ,• •
•
visit Medicare.gov
call 1-800-MEDICARE
for Medicare &
Services
MD 21244.1850
(1-800-633-4227);
(TTY: 1-877-486-2048)
Centers
Medicaid Battimorta
tt- CmSt1966 (04/201s)
NamelNombre
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Local Boaters Option
Registration Card
Name:
Number: BR- Mall
U.S. Customs and
Border Protection
MEDICARE HEALTH INSURANCE
fe Number Nu Medicare
Entitled tolCon derecho a Coverage startsiCobertura empleza
HOSPITAL (PART A) 01-01-2018
MEDICAL (PART B) 02-01-2018
To Report Arrival, Call:
Puerto Rico 1-877-529--6840
or (787) 729-6840
Port of St. Thomas (340) 774-6755
Port of St. John (340) 776-6741
Port of St. Croix (340) 773-1011
You may be asked to show this card when you get health care
services. Only give your personal Medicare information to health
care providers, your insurers. or people you (rust who work with
Medicare on your behalf. WARNING: Intentionally misusing this ce'
may be considered fraud andior other violation of federal law and
pumshable by law.
Es posible clue le p'dan quo muestre esta tarjeta cuando reciba
servicios de cuidado medico. Solamente de su informaciein persor
de Medicare a los proveedores de salud. sus aseguradores o
personas de su confianza clue trabajan con Medicare en su romtrf
iADVERTENCIA! El mal use intencionai de esta tarjeta puede ser
cons derado corno fraude y'u otra violacien de la ley federal y es
sancionada por la ley.
1-800-MEDICARE (1.800.633.4227 /
TTY: 1.877.486.2048): Medlcare.gov
Mod AO 442 (09/13) Anest vhina AUSA Name Toluca, 212-837-2225
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
for the
Southern District of New York
United States of America
v.
Jeffrey Epstein
Defendant
To: Any authorized law enforcement officer
) Case No.
19Cithl 49a -I
ARREST WARRANT
YOU ARE COMMANDED to arrest and bring before a United States magistrate judge without unnecessary delay
(Name of Person as? he antes& Jeffrey Epstein
who is accused of an offense or violation based on the following document filed with the court:
d Indictment O Superseding Indictment Cl Information Cl Superseding Information Cl Complaint
Cl Probation Violation Petition Cl Supervised Release Violation Petition O Violation Notice Cl Order of the Court
This offense is briefly described as follows:
Tide 18, United States Code, Section 371 (sex trafficking conspiracy)
Title 18, tinned States Coda, Sections 1591(a), (b)(2), and (2) (sex trafficking of minors)
Date: 07/02/2019
City and state: New York, NY  The Honorable Barbara Moses,l).S,  Maglitrate Judge
Printed manse ands/fie
Return
This warrant was received on (done)  , and the person was arrested on (date)
at (sip and state)
Date:
Mewing officer's signature
Printed none and (ilk
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
ARFOTEE INFOR$ATION Before any arrntee can be processed by the USMS any and all medical probleniskoaditions must be 
declared. This form mum be completed for each arrestee sad given to
the responding USMS personnel before the a termite Arrester name:  7 2FroCi fi tdert. Ceig
will be received for processing.
Does arreste have a prior arrest? Circle: NO If yes, please list the urestee's USMS number. If you cannot identify USMS 
number, please provide arrest information (IE: date, arresting
agency, location)
Arrestee's representation for this days proceeding: (Circle) Legal Aid CIA If legal aid, has arrester met with counsel? 
Circle: YES NO Does the arrester have any current detainers?
Circle: YES If yes, please list:
Doe arrester have and tong to ..iedical condition or cond (to include: lei 1 problems e bees, asthmr tuberculosis, HIV, 
AIDS, hepatitis etc)? Circle: YES Does arrester require
medication/medical attention for this condition? Circle: YES Do you, as the arresting frailly possess at least one days 
dosage of the arrestee's medication? Circle: YES Explain:
NO
Does arresiee have/display/Loma any other medical aikr.:nts(IE: broken bones, open wounds etc.)? Circle: YES NO Does 
arrester require medication/medical attention for this condition?
Circle: YES NO Do you, as the arresting rrently possess ig least one days dosage of the arrestee's medication? Circle: 
YES Explain:
Is the arrester a drug addict/user? Circle: YES NO If yes, does this require any special medical program (IE: methadone 
treatment)? Explain:
NO
Do you. as the arresting agent,Efist ,licable, possess
) (Please attack)
a medical cleanesce/ftt for confinement letter from a healthcare professional? Circle: YES
ARRESTEE PROCESSING CHECKLIST
11 ave you completed any and all USMS paperwork.
To include: USMS 312 (Please 1W oat all (onus as completely as possible) Attache' a photo of arres:ce to paperwork.
A
AGENCY:
CONTACT II WHILE IN THIS BUILDING:
NOTE TO ALL ARRESTING AGENTS Bo advised, the USMS provides the COURTISt  of Inkling sad modals( nista prior to the 
arrmter's magistrate court appearance. However, thee nine Soot
rommidered a USMS printer arta a U.S. Magistrate Judge WANDSsaid arrester to USMS custody. This mew that as the 
arresting agent. you most be available at all tines to respond to any
cad all matters conarrakag your arrester, as you are the responsible party. tinned Stores Wisher Stroke Polity and 
Prot-Ethan Manua .1.1-1.k)

3. Fingerprint cards
°I for USMS file
the BOP-9.
°I for the FBI for FPC classification
/Filled out and attached

5. Strip searched arrester.
ING
_6.
eVIT:
any
sf (b) (6), (b) (7)(C)., (b) (7)(F)
Taken
wawa states Marshals Service (USMS)
PRISONER MEDICAL RECORDS RELEASE FORM
:?4:;raUCTIONC:osa,inn, ; is w tw ctstupivivi by tin: ISSIviS intake Officer. Sections ii ee !ii are to be completed by 
the prisoner. Section It may be completed by the USMS Intake
Offica if the prisoner is unable •
or unwilling, but Section III must be signed by the prisoner. If prisoner refuses to sign, note that in the signature 
block. All refusals should be immediately reported to the Otftce
of Interagency Medical Services. Prisoner Services Division. The completed USM form 552 is to be retained in the 
prisoner's files,
Section I - USMS Prisoner Information

I. nisoner Name (Last. First. MO 2 USMS Prisoner
c .7 -0/d tc Je Fre e  103  t? 3. CY riet Name / 4 Diann it
SPA T    Ocr  7
5 Cu,' gyts o
Section I! - Prisoner Personal Data And Medlesi Information

6. Dale Of Birth lMolbaylYr)
r  0 --  S -2
S. Medical Insurance Information
Ay buitrawc comgany Same ,
ofo th.t.#1714
Section III - Medical Consent And Records Release
10 Motu Number
(b) (6), (b) (7)(C)
I entity 'tot the inform:Wool have provided above is trac Iodic bat of my knowledge.
I hereby senhaire the United States Marshal SCIVIDC to request review. and haw aecas to all medical records of caw 
perivulett to rne daring the time that I am in she aural), of dui
agency. sod to all other medal recce& deemed necessary for the purposes of providing me with appropriate medic:alarm. 
Audicating medial bills for beakte earc galas provided la me
while ir4die custody of tit gaited Is Serviee.and for infectious disease
Original —Prisoner File Copy to District File Cupy coon Transfer Iwg,11%.4. 462
l 4 * 4•11
Arant/i4 4.111
Prepared on: 07/0812019
United States Marshals Barnes • MUTED OFFICIAL USE
Booking Package Photos
OBBB FORUM 76310-050
ORIt NYUBM0300
Last Neat EPSTEIN
First Rases JEFFREY
Middle Name: EDWARD
Best Pt
Race Cods: W
DOB. 01/20/1953
View FRONT
Date Taken:07/08/2019
FBI• cd Arra 7 2019
FBI
Nuaber/UCNt
Height:6'00" Bye Color: BLU
Weights185 LBS Bair Color: BRO
"Limited Official Use"
Th s Inforrration is the Properly of the U S Marsha Service and Shall Not be Publicly Released or Orsseminated Without U
S Marshals Service Authority
Page I of 3
Prepxp.t on 07, nC.
View : RIGHT
Data Taken:07/08/2019
United States Marshals Service - LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
Booking Package Photos
"Limited Oficial Use"
This Informal:on is the Property oldie U.S. Marshals Sennce and Shall Nol be Publicly Released or Disseminated Wahout 
L.S Marshals Service Aurnoiny
Page 2 ci 3
Promised on. 070492019
UMISSUSealeshaisSmoke-UMITEDGMCMLUSE
Booking Package Photos
MINS NUMBER: 76318-054
011: NYUSN0300
Lest Name: PPSTRIN
First Name: JEFFREY
Middle Name: EDWARD
Sex: N
Race Code: W
000: 01/20/1953
Date of An 9
POI
Mumber/0Cat
Reightr6'00• Eye Colors BLU
Weights18S LBS Nair Colors BR0
"Limited Official Use"
This Information is the Properly of the U.S Marshals Service and Shall Not be Publicly Released or Disseminated Without 
U.S. Marsha's Service Authority
Page 3 of 3
POD Forms - LISM552 I Page 1 of
POt. Corm! • PopeS •
I S. Department of Juliet Fete Out :8/8/7018
aged States Marshals kis ice at$MM
PRISONER MEDICAL RECORDS RELEASE FORM Dotoetnt Number: 84(6.1 " 1
INSTRUCTIONS:

Section 1. II & III is to be compkied by the USMS Intake Meets Sectitiel Ill new be stirred b) the peiminer
I I %NI% t. I

I. Prisoner %mine I Lul. Pint. LID: 2.1.511.5 Putout: 3. Dotter Birth (‘la Dail) •• it
IPSTE 011.01KY COWARD 7011140.1 i,ions,

4. Disirks N: !L District Sante & (Dike
54 Scollotto 04100011404 400 SOO KM. ST
I . .', ...o.  1nit
7. Italica' Insurance Coverage 0
Medical Insurance Irionnanoo
Insermice Company Same:
unites S.Mecn

C) Same °floor Ph) Os Phone humility:
Mm• MMOWit •
B. hledkarr/Medicaid Co•erege! O 1M 0 %o
5..tlino Ili I 5,..I Hi 04% R.I. i.•
C010.5 thOt the 1111001131100 I haw pukka Soren RUC to the best of ni) know Wye
I hit+t awborire the Vniled Stars Marshals Semite to 404004. ICS leo. IOW Made access be all inestwal recoils of care 
pot Wed to me 40 tot: the
lime teal ism in the custody of that erne). and mall other medical records droned necessar) for the purports of pros 
;ding me with appropriate
medical cxc. ilif toltoottog medical bills Co. hahh case semis prattled to me while in the custody *film United States 
Macshalt Seri and fe•
infectious it maw ckaraiwts
Stammerer:of Primmer:
termed Sebes 0
5%15 It rettouthe:
Dale:
7/441011
Dote
7/1/2019
Firm ufm SS24m2 :8

I) (7)(E) 7'812019
USMI8 D54 Page 1 of I
PVC) FOrnr, •
Departmitat *titmice Unitcd Slates Marshals &nice
Rtttipl DAtt 7,V2019
Federal Prisoner Property Receipt
PRIM SI It 11O'
Reecept Ne mint 54•O54- 2007
Primmer Nana (host, Fint, MI>
e0STOKSASETCOVIMO
District Ili
M
It I »Ng IS I I St
0 cromomitc O ~sr O WU»
"Ma
District Ns:
anthem Rovret Shiba«.
OMM O Ouresv
Signature •I Pristine: Date:
2010.01.09
alke
eV me Igniters I ettnoMedee thet I henna peelrhel property to din are Side et US Marshal, Serrce testa"
USIMS representative:
Swirnt $•.<<•Ww are F.4 maw EnitINAI/RIYEDWARS/2O19 0109111 33 01.
FOIT USM4MnJ 16

b) (7)(E) 1?»
• ham* C•••••• ••••••••• Voi•,,,,r IONS AI
••• • r7 - 1.•
11•••••••
' I
?
L
! ! !
llSr.1-285 is'a 5-part form. Fil l nut the form and print 5 cupies. Sign as needed and route as specified below.
U.S. Department of Justice
Linked States Marshals Service
PLAINTIFF
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
ROCESS RECEIPT AND RETURN
"Instructions for &Mee ofProcess by U.S. Mansital"
COURT CASE NUMBER
19 CR 490
DEFENDANT
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
TYPE OFIROCESS
Notice of Lis Pendens
NAME OF INDIVIDUAL. COMPANY. CORPORATION. ETC. TO SERVE OR DESCRIPTION OP PROPERTY TO SEIZE OR CONDEMN
SERVE United States Marshal Service- Southern District of New York
AT ADDRESS grim or RFD, AparonenrMa. Chy. Sloe and ZIP Cork)
500 Pearl Street, New York, New York 10007
SENDNOTICE OF SERVICE COPY TO REQUESTER AT NAME AND ADDRESS BELOW
GEOFFREY S. BERMAN, U.S. ATTORNEY -SDNY
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Number of process to be
served with this Form 255
Number of parties to be
served in this use
ONE SAINT ANDREW'S PLAZA Check for nuke
WIEW YORK. NY 111107-1701 on U.S.A.
SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS OR OTHER INFORMATION THAT WILL. ASSIST IN EXPEDITING SERVICE Pernik MUSIX end Afriewore nrierectsr,
All Telephone Nome's:, and Esehriarted Mews Awdlable for Semite):
rate Feld
Please execute the attached Notice of Lis Pendens in New York County, NY with regards to the property located at 9 East 
71st
Street, New York, NY 10021, Block No. 1386, Lot No. 10 owned by Maple Inc.
rel.,• tits, flrtairainr rentectti 'no WEN, IV Signature of)
AUSA

b) (7)(E) nhrl,l f ! GA
b) (6), (b) (7)(C)
TELEPHONE NUMBER DATE
212-637 (b) (6). (b) (7)(C) 7/8/19
SPACE BELOW FOR USE OF U.S. MARSHAL ONLY- DO NOT WRITE  BELOW THIS LINE
I acknowledge receipt for the total
munber of process indicated.
(Sign onWor VW 28. f amore
than one USN 285 Is sibmbreap
Total Process District of
Origi
No.
District to
!
- a Date
I(1) (6), (b) (7)(C),  (b) (7)(F)
a...
thereby certtfy and return that t El have personally served .O have legal evidence of stiviee.O have eamlfied as shown 
in • Iteminks'. the process deltenbed
en the individual company, corporation, etc., at the address shown above on the on the individual, company emporation, 
etc. tam at the address inserted below.
O thereby artily and return that l an unable to locate the individual. company, corponuion. ere robed above (Sea remarks
below)
Name end title of individual served (I/not shown above) El A person of suitelge age and discretion
then raiding in defendants usual place
of abode
Address (combine only el(Arent than shown abort)
ScVierl ENs r
REMARKS:
II
Total M Rage Charges
Including endeavors)
Fonvarding Fee Toni Charges Advise Deposits
Date Time
O am

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F) Amount U.S. Marshal*
(Amount of Itellmde)
$0.00
rill\ I ' t Pt •
glint_ Moho c List:lens kl `Mt 1. CLERK OF THE COURT PRIOR EDITIO Y BE USED
2.118143 RECORD

3. NOTICE OF SERVICE
4. BILLING STATEMENT*: To be mama' to the U.S. Marshal with payment,
irony anima is owed. Please remit promydy payable to US. MentaL
5. ACKNOWLEDGMENT QP RECEIPT
COUNTY
N.Y. •
2119 JUL I I PH 3:43
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
X
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
X
NOTICE OF PENDENCY
19 Cr. 490 (RMB)
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that an action has been commenced
in this Court upon the indictment of the above-named defendant and
against the named property for forfeiture thereto, which premises
are known generally as follows:
NEW YORK COUNTY, NEW YORK
9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021, in the
Borough of Manhattan, City and State of New York, designated on
the Tax Map of the City of New York for said Borough, as Block
Number 1386, Lot Number 10, which is more particularly described
in Schedule A attached hereto.
Please index this notice of pendency against the above-
described property and also against the name of Maple, Inc.
Dated: New York, New York
July 8, 2019
GEOFFREY S. BERMAN
United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New York
United States of America
By:
Assistant United States Attorney
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York New York 10007
Tel. No.
SCHEDULE A
ALL that certain plot, place or parcel of land, with the buildings and improvements thereon erected,
situate, lying and being in the Borough of Manhattan, City, County and State of New York, bounded
and described as follows:
BEGINNING at a point on the northerly side of 71n Street distant 225 feet easterly from the corner
Conned by the intersection of the restudy side of Sth Avenue with the northerly side of 71" Street;
running
thence Easterly along the northerly side of 71- Street 50 feet;
thence Northerly and parallel with 5‘11 Avenue 102 feet 2 inches to the center line of the block
between 71" and 72"3 Streets;
thence Westerly along the said center line and parallel with 71" Street 50 feet;
thence South* and parallel with 5" Avant 102 feet 2 inches to the northerly side of 71" Street at
the point or place of beginning.
New York County Clerk's Office
Paym 752375 87/11/2019 3:37p
Cashier TLTRAINER Register # 2
Tr.979002
$35.00
Notice of Pendency
RM 109P FILING NOTICE OF PENDENCY
#32 FOR SDNY SEALED INDICTMENT
Total:
$35.00
Check
$35.09

╭──── Page 29, Image 1 ────╮
│ grits office             │
│                          │
│ CHRAINER Fi Pll ster ahe │
│                          │
│ 435.08                   │
│                          │
│ 1n 979082                │
│ 3 Bate «oo ~             │
│                          │
│ FILING NO  pEADENCT      │
│ ‘OR SDNY ale © Apretnei  │
│ $38.06                   │
│                          │
│ Check $35.08             │
╰──────────────────────────╯

Order #5853 2019-07-11
ASSET
Address. .: 9 East 71st Street
New York, NY 10021
Code
APN  BLOCK: 1386 LOT: 10
District. : NYS
Owner  MAPLE INC.
Type  SFR/SFD (1 4)
Status.. .: Off Market
Occupancy: Unknown
Value • $0.00
(1)) (7)( )
Date of Act Giving Rise to Forfeiture. .:
Preliminary Order of Forfeiture Date. ..:
Final Order of Forfeiture Date
REQUESTER
Name
Email
) (6), (b) (7)(C)
.) (6), (b) (7)(C)
District.: NYS
Date • 2019-07-11
ORDER
Ordered • 2019-07-11
Completed..:
Sent
Billed
PRODUCTS AND SERVICES
Number • 3
Total • $1,092.00
see next page for details
Signature
Products and Services: Page 1
456987   $451.00
PreaesSeizure Analysis
549886   $216.00
Residential Desktop Brokers Price Opinion
570806   $425.00
Preliminary Title Commitment - NTE

╭──────────── Page 31, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ Products and Services: Page 1             │
│                                           │
│ 456987 . epgaeed = $451.00                │
│ Pre&€eSeizure Analysis                    │
│                                           │
│ 549886 . atoa sores $216.00               │
│ Residential Desktop Brokers Price Opinion │
│                                           │
│ 570806 . pooab0a6 $425.00                 │
│                                           │
│ Preliminary Title Commitment - NTE        │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────╯

Ile (b) (7)(E) k...) III
Standard Fenn 1031 •/..)
It Vied Oclota 'PST
Cowmen, of Ort Mussy
1 Tal 4-2003
PUBLIC VOUCHER FOR PURCHASES AND
SERVICES OTHER THAN PERSONAL
U.S. MARMOT. EUREAU.
United States
CR ESTABLISHMENT ANDLOCATION
Department of Justice
DATE VOUCI•ER PREPARED
07110/2019
SOCOUlt ?C
United States
500 Pearl Street,
Marshals Service
Suite 400
CONTRACT KILMER ANDOATE

B) (.6 (b) ( 7)(C). 04 (7XE)
REOULSITOI tA.INGIER MO DATE New York, NY 10007
PAYEES
Flew York County Clerk -1 Centre
NAME
AND
GO Street
Room 109B
DATE MANCE RECEIVED
07/10/2019
ADDRESS New York, NY 10007
I
DISCOUNT TERMS
— --I PAYEES ACCOUNT NUMBER
SHIPPEOFROal TO HEIGHT GOVERNMENT EM. NUMBER
MAU " "Cain  '
OFCR  OER
GATE Of
DELTVERY
OR WRAC.
ARTICLES CR SERVICES
(Emir doscapOogt an numbiw *loaners:I or ENVY an* what.
NV Ogler mlornaboo Owned DPOPFTFIY1
°JAN* nTY
uMT PACE AMOUNT
COST PER (I)
Notice of Pendency Filing Foo
USA vs. Jeffrey Epstein
9 East 71st Street, New York, NY 10021
19 CR 490
1 35 35.00

(b) (7)(E)
Ma conammeco anon )• naansady) (Payee must NOT use the space below) TOTAL 35.00
PAYMENT
• PROVISIONAL
0 COMPL PI E
0 PARTIAL
• FINAL
• PROGRESS
Ei ADVANCE
APPROVED FOR
= 5
EXCHANGE RATE
41.00 DIFFERENCES
81, 2
Ann( •V463. Caner be pty0•Oni
TITLE (*peen Of initials)
Pursuant to authorrty V. ' • • - -
07/10/2019 (b) (6), (b) (7)(C) . dministrative Officer
(Dale) (A6AR)
s . • • ..L CLASSIFICATION

h) (7)(1:) $35.00
P A
I
CHECK NUMBER ON ACCOUNT Of U.S. TREASURY CHECK NUMBER ON (Name of bank)
D
I.
v
CASH DATE
s
PAYEE 3
I Phan Mad A bugn orancy. marl rang of orwiry.
7 Irma atv ty to coney Ana towel to swots ma Caribined el as F....Man One ago-mute oaf ea somas y; Sawn Om *prowl.)
mteer WV *glint* mem peOvIdad VAN In CROW ORO
1 Yam • wow; I meow m vw nano as colony cc cora:cam am flan ,  a Ole Pannm 11102 Tm company Pi PorPonve
Ittl10. = WS as Uo cepaoty pato:A ha Rene, Mg wow For eAargto "-ben Doe Con/opt pc( no Si-lp Socrelorr. a
-Ymasumr.ssf*4**Mby te
PER
TITLE
Previous matron used° NSN 7540-06 BOO-2234
PRIVACY ACT STATEMENT
The Hamann nnuested on on bills rectumIsm RV/00MR 31 US C BA arciMe. b me Dowse el ocKang FOOORF
navy The ifecnnshon reaAnktO a le don* ma parbols aVrilot sad IlelaTKulls *Os paid Fiala to t•TIII/1 Ihs fl ormobon nil
nrdrd CIACIINgoe 01 014 payment obbaeliOn
U.S. Department of Justice
United Slates Marshals Service
tmLniszusaa
Requisition for Procurement of
Supplies, Service, and Equipment

1. REQUISITION NO.: 2. REQUESTED BY (Name/Title/Organization):
MIN
4. ORGANIZATIONAL BUDGET OFFICER: I do hereby certify that funds
are available and authorize an Increase of funds but not to exceed $100.00.
Stacy Rider Administrative Otter
NAME
PMS/USMS
nn F

b) (6), (b) (7)(C) stC7A)-uct
11(el 1 ( 1
DA.F
4a. APPROVAL by (" , 11, 2^ - Alt Head, U S. Marshal or Designee:

b) (6), (b) (7)(C) SAM
b) (6), (b)  (7)(C) SIGNATURE
211 gig
6. DELIVER
U.S. Marshals Service-SDNY
500 Pearl Street, Suite 400
New York, NY 10007
O USMS Warehouse
2604 Jefferson Davis Highway. fUexandrla, VA 22301
O Receasibon forwarded to warehouse an (date):
TEL NO.: 3. DATE:
711W2019

6. SOURCES OF FUNDING: 6a. PROGRAM APPROVALS: (much betore
semalf to Innfraele ContsacIng Once ter pIXesatvg)
O rand struseakiraa: (NOW [.sown TWA Wry Rsausson slow amend PrOaettnOrd Crow %emcee Al artasoes, Bureau
Proc. Caw ss Mane, by FARIOR)
❑
tolitaaXale r it (Al neneem. seesaw emit es. none ws smart Ceammocatons (FA)[ cehme.eiren.Telscbc.8 Equ* 4 Wilier Inca
❑ Appropriated
O Other.
O Reimbursement Auth No •
O AFF Case No
O Chillid Funds
O wpn.Apprepristed
O traustamolelyessathaibra man wholes Moses end /lapin) Pvtithing Stenc.dis (Co,., PmteO)
O lexrdr.lso Chnortna neon.
ESUE•prier4
O IstralParalanalloo. eosins cesmunnabere ewe (Bews. eremers tar )
O Oa= Economy Act /SAC HU is required by FARLAR
O Noun Onclec Non.SU Marti Anna kWarans Seta. anima hauls Oernevs; Amen taw se Koreas*.
linvliaguntroialli $1O3K
O usa ?mows Of An
PAd 4thonefieneli
O Canto _

7. STOCK NO.
(a)
Notice of Pendency
Filing Fee
New York County Oak
ITEM DESCRIPTION (b)
Include Accounting Classification Stmchwe (ACS)
with each line item. Attach SOM. Justifications
Other Documentation.
Include make. model or salient characteristics.
9 East 71st Street New York. NY 10027
Us Pendence Filing Fee
USA vs Jeffrey Epstein

(b) (7)(E)
Ot3JECI CLASS
(c)
UNIT OF
ISSUE
9. DC NUMBER:
QUANTITY
(e)
UNIT COST TOTAL COST
(9)
$35.00 $35.00

8. ACCOUNTING CLASSIFICATION STRUCTURE:
Fiscal Year
Fund Code
b) (7)(E)
Organization Code Project Code
(For acquisilions of property, $25.000 dr more per item)
APPROVED BY THE OFFICE OF PROPERTY MANAGEMENT:
SIGNATORE BATE

10. ESTIMATED COST:
TOTAL: $35.00
VENDOR LNFORMATION•
Sugges!ecl Source New York County Clerk's Office
Contact.
Date Ordereo:
Order No.,
Phone:
Date Received.
Page 1 of 1 PRIOR EDITIONS ARE OBSOLETE.
Tars reposition is not lo be used For pealing eopecebro.compostbn gran Octal production requirements. Use Fenn thSt4.21a
Fenn USIA-157
Rev. 12/12
RP STO I Blank Form Page 1 of 2
Real Property Sub -Task Order (USM-378) - New/Blank Form
Isom's Print Preiew

US. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
USM.31$ / Rev. 02/3019
I My Submisslonsj [Instructions)
Real Property Contract Sub -Task Order
INSTRUCTIONS: District Offices should use this form to procure Pre-Seizure products, Custody & Ongoing Maintenance 
and/or
Disposition of real property assets. Submit completed form to AFD Real Property Unit (RPlaskordersausms doj.gov).
PART I: USMS CONTACT INFORMATION
Requester: External Email Address (tgusdoi.gov): Phone: District:
ugm•ihi loi, iht i - oi. ) NY/S(D54) CI If your contact infommtlon needs to be updated, select the following Ink POW 
Contacts I HQ Conte=  or send an email to

RP. Task.Orders@usdot.gov.
PART II: SUBJECT PROPERTY INFORMATION
Is CATS ID available?: PreSelzureNumber/UFMSk  CATS Asset ID:
No CI (b) (
Has an IndictmentlComplaInt been filed?
Yes
Court Case Number:
19 CR 490
Relation Back Doctrine Date: tr. Dario/ Art Goyim/ Ma so Folart.)
0 01/01/2002
District Whoro Property Is Located: Street Address:
NYS Ej 9 East 71st Street
APT/Unit No.: City:
New York
County: State: ZIP: Country:
New York NY hd 10021 United States of America
APN:
BLOCK 1386 LOT: 10
Owner's Name: Target/Defendant's Name:
MAPLE INC. JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Occupancy Status: Property Classification:
Unknown Ed Single Family (1-4 units)
Has any Pre-Seizure Package been ordered for this asset prior to today? No
Mote:  If Pre-Seizure Package has not been ordered for this asset below. the Product/Service(s) Requested' field 
veil:default to
Tie -Seizure Package")
GPS Coordinates:
Product/Service(s) Requested:
Pre-Seizure Package [Preliminary Title Commitment, Valuation, and Analysis {Net Equity Worksheet+)]
Comments:
USA v. JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Covert Desktop BPOrAppraisal
PART III: PROPERTY INFORMATION CHECKLIST
Note: The Me size limit for all attachments per one form is 5MB. If you need to add more than one attachment per slot or
need
to attach anic size that is bigger than 5MES please contact RP Task.Oictersfausdol goy
CI
.4 list of required documents will display based on the Product/Service(s) Requested.
There is no required document for Pre-Seizure Package.
Submit
RP S1O I Blank Form Page 2 of 2
PART IV: AFD REAL PROPERTY UNIT INMAL  REVIEW (AFD Use Only)
Assign to COR: select 2
13 Closet aPrintPreview
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
X
•
: NOTICE OF PENDENCY
19 Cr. 490 (RMB)
X.
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that an action has been commenced
in this Court upon the indictment of the above -named defendant and
against the named property for forfeiture thereto, which premises
are known generally as follows:
NEW YORK COUNTY, NEW YORK
9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021, in the
Borough of Manhattan, City and State of New York, designated on
the Tax Map of the City of New York for said Borough, as Block
Number 1386, Lot Number 10, which is more particularly described
in Schedule A attached hereto.
Please index this notice, of pendency against the above --
described property and also against the name of Maple, Inc.
Dated: New York, New York
July 8, 2019
GEOFFREY S. BERMAN
United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New York
United States of America
By:
SCHEDULE  A
ALL that catain plot, place or parcel of land, with the buildings and improvements thereon erected,
situate, lying and being in the Borough of Manhattan, City, County and State of New York, bounded
and described as follows:
BEGINNING at a point on the nottherly side of 71" Street distant 225 feet easterly from the comer
formed by the intersection of the easterly side of 5m Avenue with the meted) , side of 71" Street
running
thence Easterly along the northerly aide of in n Street 50 feet;
thence Northerly and parallel with 5' Avenue 102 feet 2 inches to the center line of the block
between 71" and 72" Streets;
thence Westerly along the said center hoe and psmlli1 with 7? Street 50 feet;
thence Southerly and parallel with 5`b Awn.= IO2 feet 2 inches to the northetly side of 7V Street at
the paint or place of beginning.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
x
UNITED.STATES OF AMERICA
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
SEALED
INDICTMENT
19 Cr.
19 CRIM 490
COUNT ONE
(Sex Trafficking Conspiracy)
The Grand Jury charges:
OVERVIEW

1.  As set forth herein, over the course of many
years, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, sexually exploited and.
abused dozens of minor girls at his homes in Manhattan, New
York, and Palm Beach, Florida, among other locations.

2. In particular, from at least in or about 2002, up
to and including at least in or about 2005, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, enticed and recruited, and caused to be enticed and
recruited, minor girls to visit. his mansion in Manhattan, New
York (the "New York Residence") and his estate in Palm Beach,
Florida (the "Palm Beach Residence") to engage in sex acts with
him, after which he would give the victims hundreds of dollars
in cash. Moreover, and in order to maintain and increase his
supply of victims, EPSTEIN also paid certain of his victims to
recruit additional girls to be similarly abused by EPSTEIN. In
this way, EPSTEIN created a vast network of underage victims for
him to sexually exploit in. locations including New York and
Palm Beach.

3. The victims described herein were as young as 14
years old at the time they were abused by JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, and were, for various reasons, often particularly
vulnerable to exploitation. EPSTEIN intentionally sought out
minors and knew that many of his victims were in fact under the
'age of 18, including because, in some instances, minor victims
expressly told him their age.

4. In creating and maintaining this network of minor
victims in multiple states to sexually abuse and exploit,
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, worked and conspired with
others, including employees and associates who facilitated his
conduct by, among other things, contacting victims and
scheduling their sexual encounters with EPSTEIN at the New York
Residence and at the Palm Beach Residence.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND

5. During all time periods charged in this
Indictment, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, was a financier with
multiple residences in the continental United States, including
the New York Residence and the Palm Beach Residence.

6. Beginning in at least 2002, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, enticed and recruited, and caused to be enticed and •
recruited, dozens of minor girls to engage in sex acts with him,
after which EPSTEIN paid the victims hundreds of dollars in
cash, at the New York Residence and the Palm Beach Residence.

7. In both New York and Florida, JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
the defendant, perpetuated this abuse in similar ways. Victims
were initially recruited to provide "massages" to EPSTEIN, which
would be performed nude or partially 'nude, would become
increasingly sexual in nature, and would typically include one
or more sex acts. EPSTEIN paid his victims hundreds of dollars
in cash for each encounter. Moreover, EPSTEIN actively
encouraged certain of his victims to recruit additional girls to
be similarly sexually abused. EPSTEIN incentivized his victims
to become recruiters by paying these victim-recruiters hundreds
of dollars for each girl that they brought to EPSTEIN. In so
doing, EPSTEIN maintained a steady supply of new victims to
exploit.
The New York Residence

8. At all times relevant to this Indictment, JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, the defendant, possessed and controlled a multi-story
private residence on the Upper East Side of Manhattan, New York,
i.e., the New York Residence. Between at least in or about 2002
and in or about 2005, EPSTEIN abused numerous minor victims at
the New York Residence by causing these victims to be recruited
to engage in paid sex acts with him.

9. When a victim arrived at the New York Residence,
she typically would be escorted to a room with a massage table,
where she would perform a massage on JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant. The victims, who were as young as 14 years of'age,
were told by EPSTEIN or other individuals to partially or fully
undress before beginning the "massage." During the encounter,
EPSTEIN would escalate the nature and scope of physical contact
with his victim to include, among other things, sex acts such as
groping and direct and indirect contact with the victim's
genitals. EPSTEIN typically would also masturbate during these
sexualized encounters, ask victims to touch him while he
masturbated, and touch victims' genitals with his hands or with
• sex toys.

10. In connection with each sexual encounter, JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, the defendant, or one of his employees or associates,
paid the victim in cash. Victims typically were paid hundreds
of dollars in cash for each encounter.

11. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, knew that many of
his New York victims were underage, including because certain
victims told him their age. Further, once these minor victims
were recruited, many were abused by EPSTEIN on multiple
subsequent occasions at the New York Residence. EPSTEIN
sometimes personally contacted victims to schedule appointments.
at the New York Residence. In other instances, EPSTEIN directed
employees and associates, including a New York-based employee
("Employee -1"), to communicate with victims via phone to arrange
for these victims to return to the New York Residence for
additional sexual encounters with EPSTEIN.

12. Additionally, and to further facilitate his
ability to abuse minor girls in New York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, asked and enticed certain of his victims to recruit
additional girls to perform "massages" and similarly engage in
sex acts with EPSTEIN. When a victim would recruit another girl
for EPSTEIN, he paid both the victim-recruiter and the new
victim hundreds of dollars in cash. Through these victim-
recruiters, EPSTEIN gained access to and was able to abuse
dozens of additional minor girls.

13. In particular, certain recruiters brought dozens
of additional minor girls to the New York Residence to give
massages to and engage in sex acts with JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant. EPSTEIN encouraged victims to recruit additional
girls by offering to pay these victim-recruiters for every
additional girl they brought to EPSTEIN. When a victim-
recruiter accompanied a new minor victim to the New York
Residence, both the victim-recruiter and the new minor victim
were paid hundreds of dollars by EPSTEIN for each encounter. In
addition, certain victim-recruiters routinely scheduled these
encounters through Employee -1, who sometimes asked the
recruiters to bring a specific minor girl for EPSTEIN.
The Palm Beach Residence

14. In addition to recruiting and abusing minor girls
in New York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, created a similar
network of minor girls to victimize in Palm Beach, Florida,
where EPSTEIN owned, possessed and controlled another large
residence, i.e., the Palm Beach Residence. EPSTEIN frequently
traveled from New York to Palm Beach by private jet, before
which an employee or associate would ensure that minor victims
were available for encounters upon his arrival in Florida.

15. At the Palm Beach Residence, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, engaged in a similar course of abusive conduct.
When a victim initially arrived at the Palm Beach Residence, she
would be escorted to a room, sometimes by an employee of
EPSTEIN's, including, At times, two assistants ("Employee -2" and'
"Employee -3") who, as described herein, were also responsible
for scheduling sexual encounters with minor victims. Once
inside, the victim would provide a nude or semi-nude massage for
EPSTEIN, who would himself typically be naked. During these
encounters, EPSTEIN would escalate the nature and scope of the
physical contact to include sex acts such as groping and direct
and indirect contact with the victim's genitals. EPSTEIN would
also typically masturbate during these encounters, ask victims
dos
to touch him while he masturbated, and touch victims' genitals
with his hands or with sex toys.

16. In connection with each sexual encounter, JEFFREY
EPSTEIN, the defendant, or one of his employees or associates,
paid the victim in cash. Victims typically were paid hundreds
of dollars for each encounter.
. 17. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, knew that certain
of his victims were underage, including because certain victims
told him their age. In addition, as with New York-based
victims, many Florida victims, once recruited, were abused by
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, on multiple additional
occasions.

18. JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, who during the
relevant time period was frequently in New York, would arrange
for Employee-2 or other employees to contact victims by phone in
advance of EPSTEIN's travel to Florida to ensure appointments
were scheduled 'for when he arrived. In particular, in certain
instances, Employee-2 placed phone calls to minor victims in
Florida to schedule encounters at the Palm Beach Residence. At
the time of certain of those phone calls, EPSTEIN and Employee-2
were in New York, New York. Additionally, certain of the
individuals victimized at the Palm Beach Residence were
contacted by phone by Employee-3 to schedule these encounters.

19. Moreover, as in New York, to ensure a steady
stream of minor victims, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, asked
and enticed certain victims in Florida to recruit other girls to
engage in sex acts. EPSTEIN paid hundreds of dollars to victim-
recruiters for each additional girl they brought to the Palm
Beach Residence.
STATUTORY ALLEGATIONS

20. From at least in or about 2002, up to and
including in or about 2005, in the Southern District of New York
and elsewhere, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, and others known
and unknown, willfully and knowingly did combine, conspire,
confederate, and agree together and with each other to commit an
offense against the United States, to wit, sex trafficking of
minors, in violation of Title 18, United States Code, Section.
1591(a) and (b).

21. It was a part and object of the conspiracy that
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, and others known and unknown,
would and did, in and affecting interstate and foreign commerce,
recruit, entice, harbor, transport, provide, and obtain, by any
means a person, and to benefit, financially and by receiving
anything of value, from participation in a venture which has
engaged in any such act, knowing that the person had not
attained the age of 18 years and would be caused to engage in a
commercial sex act, in violation of Title 18, United States
Code, Sections 1591(a) and (b)(2).
Overt Acts

22. In furtherance of the conspiracy and to effect
the illegal object thereof, the following overt acts, among
others, were committed'in the Southern District of New York and
elsewhere:

a. In or about 2004, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the
defendant, enticed and recruited multiple minor victims,
including minor victims identified herein as Minor Victim-1,
Minor Victim-2, and Minor Victim-3, to engage in sex acts with
EPSTEIN at his residences in Manhattan, New York, and Palm
Beach, Florida, after which he provided them with hundreds of
dollars in cash for each encounter.

b. In or about 2002, Minor Victim-1 was
recruited to engage in sex acts with EPSTEIN and was repeatedly
sexually abused by EPSTEIN at the New York Residence over a
period of years and was paid hundreds of dollars for each
encounter. EPSTEIN also encouraged and enticed Minor Victim-I
to recruit other girls to engage in paid sex acts, which she
did. EPSTEIN asked Minor Victim-1 how old she was, and Minor
Victim-1 answered
c.
Southern District
truthfully.
In or about 2004, Employee-1, located in the
of New York, and on behalf of EPSTEIN, placed
a telephone call to Minor Victim-1 in order to schedule an
appointment for Minor Victim-1 to engage in paid sex acts with
EPSTEIN.

d. In or about 2004, Minor Victim-2 was
recruited to engage in sex acts with EPSTEIN and was repeatedly
sexually abused by EPSTEIN at the Palm Beach Residence over a
period of years and was paid hundreds of dollars after each
encounter. EPSTEIN also encouraged and enticed Minor Victim-2
to recruit other girls to engage in paid sex acts, which she
did.

e. In or about 2005, Employee-2, located in the
Southern District of New York, and on behalf of EPSTEIN, placed
a telephone call to Minor Victim-2 in order to schedule an
appointment for Minor Victim-2 to engage in paid sex acts with
EPSTEIN.

f. In or about 2005, Minor Victim-3 was •
recruited to engage in sex acts with EPSTEIN and was repeatedly
sexually abused by EPSTEIN at the Palm Beach Residence over a
period of years and was paid hundreds of dollars for each
encounter. .EPSTEIN also encouraged and enticed Minor Victim-3
to recruit other girls to engage in paid sex acts, which she
did. EPSTEIN asked Minor Victim-3 how old she was, and Minor
Victim-3 answered truthfully.

g. In or about 2005, Employee-2, located in the
Southern District of New York, and on behalf of EPSTEIN, placed
a telephone call to.Minor Victim-3 in Florida in order to
schedule an appointment for Minor Victim-3 to engage in paid sex
acts with EPSTEIN.

h. In or about 2004, Employee-3 placed a
telephone call to Minor Victim-3 in order to schedule an
appointment for Minor Victim-3 to engage in paid sex acts with'
EPSTEIN.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 371.)
COUNT TNO
(Sex Trafficking)
The Grand Jury further charges:

23. The allegations contained in paragraphs'l
through 19 and 22 of this Indictment are repeated and realleged
as if fully set forth within.

24. From at least in or about 2002, up to and
including in or about 2005, in the Southern District of New
York, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant, willfully and knowingly,
in and affecting interstate and foreign commerce, did recruit,
entice, harbor, transport, provide, and obtain by any means a
person, knowing that the person had not attained the age of 18
years and would be caused to engage in a commercial sex act, and
did aid and abet the same, to wit, EPSTEIN recruited, enticed,
harbored, transported, provided, and obtained numerous
individuals who were less than 18 years old, including but not
limited to Minor Victim-1, as described above, and who were then
caused to engage in at least one commercial sex act in
Manhattan, New York.
. (Title 18, United States Code, Sections 1591(a),
(b)(2), and 2.)
FORFEITURE ALLEGATIONS

25. As a result of committing the offense alleged in
Count Two of this Indictment, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the defendant,
shall forfeit to the United States, pursuant to Title 18, United
States Code, Section 1594(c)(1), any property, real and
personal, that was used or intended to be used to commit or to
facilitate the commission of the offense alleged in Count Two,
and any property, real or personal, constituting or derived from
any proceeds obtained, directly or indirectly, as a result of
the offense alleged in Count Two, or any property traceable to
such property, and the following specific property:

a. The lot or parcel of land, together with its
buildings, appurtenances, improvements, fixtures, attachments
and easements, located at 9 East 71st Street, New York, New
York, with block number 1386 and lot number 10, owned by
Maple, Inc.
Substitute Asset Provision

26. If any of the above-described forfeitable
property, as a result of any act or omission of the defendant:

(a) cannot be located upon the exercise of due diligence;
(b) has been transferred or sold to, or deposited with, a
third person;

(c) has been placed beyond the jurisdiction of the Court;
(d), has been substantially diminished in value; or

(e) has been commingled with other property which cannot
be subdivided without difficulty;
it is the intent of the United States, pursuant to 21 U.S.C.
S 853(p) and 28 U.S.C. S 2461(c), to seek forfeiture of any
other property of the defendant up to the value of the above
forfeitable property.
(Title 18, United States Code, Section 1594; Title 21,
United States Code, Section 853(p); and
Title 28, United States Code, Section 2461.)
eartua-- •--
GEOFFR . BERMAN
United States Attorney
Form No. USA-33s-274 (Ed. 9-25-58)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
v.
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
INDICTMENT
(18 U.S.C. S§ 371, 1591(a), (b)(2),
and 2)
GEOFFREY S. BERMAN
United States Attorney
United States Marshals Service
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
Subject Report for EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD (RD 10127184)
Name : EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
FID# : 10127184
USMS#: 76318054
Case Status : Active Subject is NOT in NCIC for USMS
Prisoner Status: Historical
Alias List
Seq. # Alias
1 EPSTEINJEFFREY E
DOB List
Seq. # Date of Birth Place of Birth NCIC Valid?
1 01/20/1953 NY - New York Yes
Social Security Number List
Seq. # ' umber
FBI Number/UCN List
Seq. # FBI Number/UCN
1 MEM
Subject Description List
Seq. # Eyes Hair Height Weight Skin Race Sex NCIC Valid?
1 BLU BRO 600" 185 W M Yes
Picture/Image List
Seq. # District Remark
3 054
4 054
1 W00 7-25-2013
2 W00 4-27-2018
USMS Number List (from PTS/PPMS)
Seq. # USMS Number
1 76318-054
Miscellaneous Number List
Seq. # Miscellaneous Number Issue Date Exp. Date Remark
2 03/08/2019 03/07/2029 US PASSPORT #
4 US PASSPORT
5 NY SID #
Occupation List
Seq. # Occupation Begin End
1 BANKER
2 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY
3 SELF EMPLOYED
Subject Address List
Seq. # Address
1 9 EAST 71ST, NEW YORK, NY 10021 United States
2 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, B3
ST THOMAS, VI 00802
3 9 E 71 ST, NEW YORK, NY 10021
Start Date End Date
Subject Phone Number List
Seq. # Typc Country Code Phone Number Extension Remark From To
08/27/2019 11:37 AM EDT
United States Marshals Service
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
Subject Report for EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD (RD 10127184)
1 (212) 533-3739
Associate(s) of this Subject
FID# Associate Name Type
10925031 EPSTEIN,MARK BROTHER
State/Local ORI: Unknown
License Plate Information
Seq. # Plate Type State Year
Operator License List
Seq. # Operator License State Year
1 0000025874 VI 2024
Profile Information
Money Launderer No DEA - GDEP
"Kingpin" No DEA Violator (Historical)
Triggerlock Case No International Lookout Placed No
Violent Offender No
Criminal History
Offense Arrests Convictions Offense Arrests Convictions
Immigration Homicide 0 0
Kidnapping Rape/Sex Assault I 1
Assault/Battery Robbery 0 0
Burglary/Larceny Narcotics 0 0
Weapons (Firearms) Extortion 0 0
Weapons (Other)
Forgery/Fraud
Failure to Register (Sex Offense) Failure to Comply (Sex Offense) 0 0
Sex Offenses
Arrest No Conviction No
Registered No Registration Violation No
Profile Remarks:LIFETIME SO REGISTRANT IN NY AND FLORIDA
Usm I Is exist for this fugitive.
Caution and Medical Conditions
Seq. # Code Description
1 MTL Mental Concerns
Other Documents
Upload Date Filename Description
09/26/2016 Epstein, Jeffrey.pdf Intl. Travel form
04/04/2017 Jeffrey Epstein.xml J Epstein Travel Document
07/03/2019 Epstein, Jeffrey.pdf Intl. Travel form
01/29/2019 EPSTEIN FDLE SO EPSTEIN FDLE SO Registration Documents part I of 2
Registration Documents
part I of 2.pdf
03/29/2017 Jeffrey Epstein.xml J Epstein Travel Document
03/27/2017 Jeffrey Epstein.xml J Epstein Travel Document
07/25/2016 Epstein, Jeffrey.pdf Intl. Travel form
08/27/2019 11:37 AM EDT
United States Marshals Service
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
Subject Report for EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD (RD 10127184)
01/08/2019
01/29/2019
02/28/2019
01/29/2019
01/08/2019
03/02/2018
05/25/2018
Seq. #
US Virgin Islands SOR
EPSTEIN International
Travel.pdf
EPSTEIN Information
and Conviction
Information.pdf
Jeffrey Epstein.pdf
EPSTEIN FDLE SO
Registration Documents
part 2 of 2.pdf
CBP Person Encounter
List 2016.10.1 to
2019-1-4.pdf
Jeffrey Epstein.xml
Jeffrey Epstein.xml
Reliability:
Validity:
Associate FID:
Relationship:
Remarks:
State/Local ORI:
Case Number:
Address:
US Virgin Islands SOR EPSTEIN International Travel
EPSTEIN Information and Conviction Information
J Epstein Travel Document
EPSTEIN FDLE SO Registration Documents part 2 of 2
CBP Person Encounter List 2016-10-1 to 2019.1.4
J Epstein Travel Document
J Epstein Travel Document
Associations
Associate: EPSTEIN,MARK
Unknown
Unknown
BROTHER
Unknown
n/a
US
Social Details
Sexual Preference Marital Status
Single
Case List
Request Case List
Case Number: 1600-0725.7296-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 07/25/2016
Date Executed: 07/25/2016
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: SOO
To Be Prosecuted: U
Case Number: 1600-0926-8873-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 09/26/2016
Date Executed: 09/23/2016
08/27/2019 11:37 AM EDT 3
United States Marshals Service
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
Subject Report for EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD (RD 10127184)
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: S00
To Be Prosecuted: U
Case Number: 170041327-5165-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 03127/2017
Date Executed: 03127/2017
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: S00
To Be Prosecuted: U
Case Number: 1700-0329.5243-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 03129/2017
Date Executed: 03129/2017
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: S00
To Be Prosecuted: U
Case Number: 1700-0404-5418-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 04/04/2017
Date Executed: 04/04/2017
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: S00
To Be Prosecuted: U
Case Number: 1800-0302-4407-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 03/0212018
Date Executed: 03/0212018
08/27/2019 11:37 AM EDT 4
United States Marshals Service
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
Subject Report for EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD (RD 10127184)
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: S00
To Be Prosecuted: U
Case Number: 1800-0525.7516-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 05125/2018
Date Executed: 05/24/2018
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: S00
To Be Prosecuted: U
Case Number: 1900-0228.4145-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 02,28/2019
Date Executed: 02,28/2019
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: S00
To Be Prosecuted: U
Case Number: 1900-0620-7922-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 06/20/2019
Date Executed: 06/19/2019
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: S00
To Be Prosecuted: U
Case Number: 1900-0703.8325-R
Sealed Warrant?: No
Case Status: Closed
Originating District: S00 - HQTS - NSOTC
Close Information
Date Closed: 07/03/2019
Date Executed: 07/03/2019
08/27/2019 11:37 AM EDT 5
United States Marshals Service
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
Subject Report for EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD (RD 10127184)
Execution Code: Request Satisfied by USMS
Arrested in District: S00
To Be Prosecuted: U
Criminal Case List
Case Number: 1900-0108-2923-G
Case Status: Active
Lead Deputy:
Originating District:
Case Information
Agency: USMS
Investigative Type: MSO4IML
Case Initiated: 01/08/2019
OCDE:
Contact/Phone:
Case Number: 1900-0613.7745-C
Case Status: Active
Lead Deputy:
Originating District:
Case Information
Agency: USMS
Investigative Type: MSO4IML
Case Initiated: 06/13/2019
OCDE: No

n. 41111:1. (b)(7X1,
14 Iv
08/2712019 11:37 AM EDT 6
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page 1 of 1
1. HD: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0613.7745-G

2. DATE OF REPORT: 08/19/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:

6. TYPE OF REPORT:
[ I REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
[ COLLATERAL LEAD
[ I WITNESS INTERVIEW
[ I ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
[ I CS REQUEST
[ I ARREST/CLOSE
[ I INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
[x] MEMORANDUM TO FILE (USM I 1359934)
[ I DUE DILIGENCE
['OTHER

7. HOURS WORKED:
On August 10, 2019 EPSTEIN committed suicide while in custody in New York. On August 12, 2019 Senior
Inspector (SD= spoke with the US Virgin Islands AUSA's office in regards to this case. Based upon the
above information a I parties agreed this case would be dropped.
As such the search warrant for EPSTEINs phone was cancelled, the MLAT requests for all countries were
cancelled, and all investigative activities were cancelled.
This case is now closed.

(b) (6), (b) MO, (b) (7XF)
8. SIGNATURE (Name and Tide) 9. DATE
08/19/2019 2:07 PM EDT
nnun nvestigator
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) 11. DATE
08/21/2019 9:42 AM EDT
sprrtor

12. DISTRIBUTION
_DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:43 AM EDT

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page 1 of 2

I. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-I900 -0613.7745-G
2. DATE OF REPORT: 07/10/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD

3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
6. TYPE OF REPORT:
[I REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
[ COLLATERAL LEAD
[x] WITNESS INTERVIEW (USM II 1342335)
[ ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
[ I CS REQUEST
[ I ARREST/CLOSE
[ I INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
[ I MEMORANDUM TO FILE
[ I DUE DILIGENCE
['OTHER

7. HOURS WORKED:
On July 10, 2019 at approximately 6:15 pm Senior Inspector (SI)= contacted by
phone. SI introduced himself as a Deputy United States Marshal and eirai erece one
number from a Miami Herald reporter. SI explained Ms. told him she would be
expecting his c. stated she did not recognize the phone number but suspected thats what that call was
for.
SI explained why he was calling and asked- if she had a few moments. She stated yes.
SI Masked her to start from the beginning with what she had said to Ms. regarding Jeffrey
EP . stated that she is an Air Traffic Controller and that Jeffrey parks his plane at the base
of the contrIter at the airport when he arrives. stated she has seen EPSTEIN get off the plane with
young girls. M recalled two specific times with Mrst being two girls who appeared to be eleven (11) to
twelve (12) years old with white skin. = stated another time a girl looked to be sixteen (16) maybe seventeen

(17) or eighteen (18) and appeared tol pf mixed race. M stated the dates of these occurrences were between
June/ July of 2018 through November of 2018. M statTdihe started working at SIT in April of 2018 and was
fully qualified after May so it was after that. She in only worked on STI' for about one (1) year.
SI= asked how far away was EPSTEIN from the control tower when they observed him. M stated
maybe fi fty (50) yards but they were using binoculars to look.
SI asked if they get the flight plans? stated that they typically get the out bound but not the inbound
fli•ans.
SI asked what information is in the flight plans? M stated ATC information and mute.

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Title) 9. DATE
07/10/2019 6:42 PM EDT
nnun nvestigator
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) II. DATE
07/11/2019 10:35 AM EDT
spector

12. DISTRIBUTION
_DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:42 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page 2 of 2
1. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0613.7745-G

2. DATE OF REPORT: 07/10/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
SI asked if it shows who is on the flight and where they are from? stated no.
SI Mi asked if there was anyone else who would be willing to talk to him that worked with-. M stated
there might be another person and that she would check and call SI back.
SI thanked- for her time and concluded the phone call.
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:42 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page 1 of I
I. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0613.7745-G

2. DATE OF REPORT: 06113/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:

6. TYPE OF REPORT:
REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
COLLATERAL LEAD
WITNESS INTERVIEW
ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
CS REQUEST
ARREST/CLOSE
INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
] MEMORANDUM TO FILE
DUE DILIGENCE
Dcl OTHER: (APPROVAL FOR INVESTIGATION)

7. HOURS WORKED:
On June 30, 2008 Jeffrey Epstein (DOB: 01/20/1953) was convicted of F.S 796.03 in the state of Florida for
procuring a person under the age of 18 for prostitution and sentenced to 13 months incarceration. As a result of
this conviction EPSTEIN must register as a sex offender.
On March 15, 2019 EPSTEIN went to the US Virgin Island Department of Justice located on the island of St.
Thomas and spoke in person to the Sex Offender Registry Coordinator. During this meeting EPSTEIN signed
the Notification of Duty to Report travel.
On 3/19/2019 the USMS received notification from the US Virgin Islands Sex Offender Registry that EPSTEIN
was traveling to France from 3/19/2019 through 03/29/2019 via his private jet (N212JE). No other countries are
listed on the notification form. According to a public website that tracks flight activity EPSTEIN traveled on
March 22, 2019 to Vienna, Austria and on March 27, 2019 to Monaco. These countries are not listed on the
notification form.
Based on the above information, an MSO4 investigation has been initiated to determine if EPSTEIN is in
violation of 18 USC 2250 (b) regarding his failure to report international travel.

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Tide) 9. DATE
06/13/2019 2:01 PM EDT
nnun nvestigator
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) II. DATE
06/13/2019 3:46 PM EDT
spector

12. DISTRIBUTION
_DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:41 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page 1 of I
1. HD: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0613.7745-G

2. DATE OF REPORT: 08/05/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:

6. TYPE OF REPORT:
REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
COLLATERAL LEAD
WITNESS INTERVIEW
ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
CS REQUEST
ARREST/CLOSE
INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
[x] MEMORANDUM TO FILE (USM I I 1353667)
DUE DILIGENCE
OTHER

7. HOURS WORKED:
On July 14, 2019 Senior Inspector (SI) an dM traveled to the US Virgin Islands (SIT) to work on an
operation involving International Megans there SI met with the AUSA's office to
discuss this case.
- On July 17, 2019 SI spoke with the AUSA = in ards to submitting an MLAT request to the
countries of France, onaco, Austria, and Moroccc USA= stated he would submit the requests.
- On or about July 19, 2019 SI and  spoke with Customs and Border Protection (CBP) in regards
to obtaining flight logs and rect.! EPSTEINs private plane. CBP stated these could be obtained through
the pilots themselves or maybe the FAA.
- On July 22, 2019 SI= submitted a search warrant to AUSA = for EPSTEINs phone number that he
listed he can be reach l during international travel. SI= isEl:Ting to gain historical information that
may provide insight to countries EPSTEIN visited while on international travel.
- On August 5, 2019 SI received information from the FAA in regards to flight plan histories. This
information reveals numerous more Countries of international travel by EPSTEINs jet. It will be investigated
further.
The investigation continues..

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Tide) 9. DATE
08/05/2019 12:23 PM EDT
nnun nvestigator
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) II. DATE
08/06/2019 1:21 PM EDT
spector

12. DISTRIBUTION
_DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:42 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page 1 of 2
1. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-I900 -06I3.7745 -G

2. DATE OF REPORT: 06/24/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:

6. TYPE OF REPORT:
[ I REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
[ COLLATERAL LEAD
[x] WITNESS INTERVIEW (USMI1 1335209)
[ ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
[ I CS REQUEST
[ I ARREST/CLOSE
[ I INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
[ I MEMORANDUM TO FILE
[ I DUE DILIGENCE
['OTHER

7. HOURS WORKED:
On June 24, 2019 at approximately 1100 hours Supervisory Inspector (SI) and Senior Inspector (SI)
met with Investigative reporter (Miami Herald) at the oclk i de Diner located in Hollywood,
During the interview SI asked Ms. if she knew of anyone who may have information in regards to
EPSTEIN. Ms state she has an informant who worked at the airport and the informant stated she has
seen EPSTEIN R!!!g with girls under the age of 18 within the last seven months. Her informant has
witnessed the irls board a helicopter at his island (Little St. James) and fl to the airport to board EPSTEIN's
airplane. SI asked if the informant had any records of this. Ms. stated the informant an .mve
text messages t at she sent to her friends upon witnessing the events. is informant now lives in ,
. Ms. gave her phone number to SI

Ms. stated she also knows a female who was employed for one week at EPSTEIN's residence before
being re  by him. This informant's boyfriend is still employed by EPSTEIN and Ms. will reach out
to see if he will speak with SI

Ms. also stated is one of EPSTEIN's disgruntled attorneys who may have information,
but requested SI not contact im yet.

Ms. stated owned a modeling company and helped recruit girls for EPSTEIN.
Ms. M stated was the Police Chief during the original EPSTEIN investigation and may be able
to provide more insig t concerning their investigation with EPSTEIN.

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Tide) 9. DATE
06/24/2019 1:05 PM EDT
noun nvestigator
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) II. DATE
06/28/2019 11:15 AM EDT
spector

12. DISTRIBUTION
_DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:41 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page 2 of 2
1. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0613.7745-G

2. DATE OF REPORT: 06/24/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
The interview concluded at approximately noon and S)_ told Ms he would be in touch.
Case continues...
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:41 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page 1 of I
I. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0108.2923-G

2. DATE OF REPORT: 01/08/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:

6. TYPE OF REPORT:
[]REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
[]COLLATERAL LEAD
[]WITNESS INTERVIEW
[ ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
[ CS REQUEST
[ ARREST/CLOSE
[ INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
[ ] MEMORANDUM TO FILE
[ ] DUE DILIGENCE
[x] OTHER: (APPROVAL FOR INVESTIGATION)

7. HOURS WORKED:
Jeffrey EPSTEIN was referred to the USMS IML Unit by the US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of
New York as a convicted Sex Offender from the state of Florida who travels frequently Internationally and may
have not reported all his International travel as required by International Megan's Law.
EPSTEIN was convicted in 2008 in the state of Florida of procuring a person under the age of 18 for
prostitution, sentenced to 13 months incarceration and is required for life as a sex offender in the state of
Florida.
EPSTEIN is currently registered as a sex offender in the US Virgin Islands as his primary address and he has
secondary addresses in Florida, NY, New Mexico, and Paris France. In NY state, EPSTEIN is classified as a
Level 3 sex offender (highest-risk) with a lifetime registrant requirement.
Investigation reveals EPSTEIN travels Internationally quite frequently using private planes and may have
failed to report all his International travel. Based upon this information, a MSO4 investigation has been
initiated to determine if EPSTEIN is in Violation of Title 18 Section 2250(b) regarding his failure to report
International travel.
End of Report

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Tide) 9. DATE
01/08/2019 10:56 AM EST
Scmor Inspector
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) II. DATE
01/08/2019 3:51 PM EST
( hiel Inspector

12. DISTRIBUTION
_DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:41 AM EDT
Prepared on 08/27/2019
United States Marshals Service - LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
USM-129 Individual Custody/Detention Report
Name: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD

I. IDENTIFICATION DATA
USMS Number: 76318-054 FID: 10127184
USMS NUMBER: 76318-054 NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
ADDRESS: 9 EAST 71ST NEW YORK, NY PHONE:
DOB: 01/20/1953 AGE: 66 POB: BROOKLYN, NY
lice:
• lin: .
. I
SEX: M RACE: W HAIR: BRO EYE: BLU HEIGHT: 6'00' WEIGHT: 185
SSN: “ FBI NBR/UCN: 787075K6 ALIEN NBR:
OTHER NUMBER OTHER NUMBER TYPE ISSUE DATE EXP DATE REMARK
Passport Number
Passport Number US PASSPORT
Originating Police
or Identification NY SID #
Number
Originating Police
or Identification
Number
Passport Number 03/08/2019 03/07/2029 US PASSPORT #
4,* SPECIAL CAUTIONS REMARKS SEPARATES AND MEDICAL
Mental Concerns Suicidal Tendencies
TB CLEARANCE STATUS ASSESSMENT DATE EXPIRED
NOT CLEARED
DNA TEST DATE TAKEN? DEPUTY REMARKS/KIT #
N/A No N/A FBI ARREST
DETAINER DATE L/R ACTIVE? AGENCY REMARK
•*/•*/•••• N
PRISONER ALIAS ALIAS REMARK
EPSTEIN,JEFFREY E

II. CUSTODY INFORMATION
Custody 1 CUSTODY START DATE: 07/08/2019 END DATE: 08/10/2019
Printed by District 92 "Limited Official Use"
This Information is the Property of the U.S. Marshals Service and Shall Not be Publicly Released or Disseminated Without
U.S. Marshals Service Authority.
Page 1 of 2
Prepared on: 08/27/2019
United States Marshals Service - LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
USM-129 Individual Custody/Detention Report
Name: EPSTEIN JEFFREY EDWARD USMS Number: 76318.054 FID: 0127184
CUSTODY STATUS OFFICE START DATE: END DATE REMARK
WI-CASE -RESOLVE 054 07/08/2019 08/10/2019
RL-SUICIDE 054 08/10/2019 08/10/2019
COURT CASE 1 DISTRICT OFFICE JUDGE US ATTORNEY DEFENSE ATTORNEY
19-CR-00490 NY/S 500 PEARL ST.
(MANHATTAN)
Arrests
ARREST DATE ARRESTING AGENCY ARREST LOCATION WARRANT
NUMBER
07/08/2019 FEDERAL BUREAU OF
INVESTIGATION
Offenses
CODE OFFENSE REMARK DISPOSITION
18 USC 371 SEX TRAFFICKING 3699 Sex Offense Other CONSPIRACY
COURT CASE STATUS START DATE END DATE REMARK
ARREST 07/08/2019 07/08/2019
WT-TRIAL 07/08/2019 08/10/2019
CASE -RESOLVED 08/10/2019 08/10/2019
INST INSTITUTION NAME ADMIT RELEASE BOARDED ACTION OR DISPOSITION
NYM MCC New York 07/08/2019 08/10/2019 33
TOTAL DAYS BOARDED 33 (0 END, 0 MED)
III. MEDICAL CONDITION/TREATMENT HISTORY
DATE SERVICE
PROVIDED VENDOR SERVICE PROVIDED
Printed by District 92 **Limited Official Use"
This Information is the Property of the U.S. Marshals Service and Shall Not be Publicly Released or Disseminated Without
U.S. Marshals Service Authority.
Page 2 of 2
Prepared off 08/27/2019
United States Marshals Service - LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
USM-312 Personal History of Defendant
Name: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD

I. IDENTIFICATION DATA
USMS Number 76318-054
USMS NUMBER: 76318-054 NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
ADDRESS: 9 EAST 71ST NEW YORK, NY 10021 PHONE:
DOB: 01/20/1953 AGE: 66 POB: BROOKLYN, NY
SEX: M RACE: W HAIR: BRO EYE: BLU HEIGHT: 6'00" WEIGHT: 185
SSN: FBI NBR/UCN: 787075K6 ALIEN NBR:
OTHER NUMBER: OTHER NUMBER TYPE:
Originating Police or Identification Number
Passport Number
Passport Number
Passport Number
Originating Police or Identification Number
•• SPECIAL CAUTIONS
AND MEDICAL REMARKS 1312PARATEE
Mental Concerns Suicidal Tendencies
DNA TEST
DATE TAKEN? DEPUTY REMARKS/KIT •
N/A No N/A FBI ARREST
DETAINER DATE ACTIVE? AGENCY REMARK
N
PRISONER ALIAS ALIAS REMARK
EPSTEIN,JEFFREY E

II. ASSOCIATE DATA (b) (6). (b) (7)(C)
"Limited Official Use"
This Information is the Property of the U.S- Marshals Service and Shall Not be Publicly Released or Disseminated Without
U.S. Marshals Service Authority
Page 1 of 2
Prepared on: 08/27/2019
United States Marshals Service - LIMITED OFFICIAL USE
USM-312 Personal History of Defendant
Name: EPSTEIN JEFFREY EDWARD USMS Number: 76318.054
EMPLOYMENT
START
EMPLOYMENT
END
DETAILS
**/**/**" **/**/**** Occupation: BANKER
Address:
Employer:
Contact:
**/**/**'' **/**/**** Occupation: SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY
Address:
Employer:
Contact:
**/**/**** **/**/**** Occupation: SELF EMPLOYED
Address:
Employer:
Contact:
III. MISCELLANEOUS INFORMATION
LICENSE PLATE
CTR: 1 CUSTODY START DATE: 07/08/2019 END DATE: 08/10/2019
PROPERTY MAILINGS
NO PROPERTY RECEIVED

IV. OFFENSE INFORMATION
CTR COURT CASE NO. CUST DATE ARREST AGY STATUS ARREST DATE
:9-C2-G049C :'/08/X 17 FEDERAL BUREAU
OF
:NVESTIGATION
Case is
resolved
OFFENSE =NARK
3699 - Sex Offense 18 USC 371 SEX TRAFFICKING CONSPIRACY
*Limited Official Use"
This Information is the Property of the U.S. Marshals Service and Shall Not be Publicly Released or Disseminated Without
U.S. Marshals Service Authority.
Page 2 of 2
EFTA00019493 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings
EFTA01249848 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from Erez Zadok about Epstein's connection to the Wexner Foundation
(inferred timestamp: 2019-08-28 07:29:00)
SOD -NY -3027571 Serial
ammis(Rcv.)046.2009)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Import Form
Form Type: FD-71A Data: 08/28/2019
Title:U WEXNER FOUNDATION - financial connection to JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Synopsis: U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 08-28-2019 07:29 AM--SEE
GUARDIAN 579223_CV FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA.
On, 26 August 2019, the Cleveland Field Office received an email  from
EREZ ZADOK, telephone ; the
email is attached. ZADOK stated that the WEXNER FOUNDATION in
Cleveland, OH, had appointed JEFFREY EPSTEIN as a trustee, EPSTEIN
gave the WEXNER FOUNDATION approximately 9 Million USD. ZADOK also
stated that the WEXNER FOUNDATION transferred at least 2.3 Million USD
to Israeli former Prime Minister Ehud Barak; EPSTEIN allegedly signed
some of these transfer documents.
Enclosure(s): Enclosed are the following items:
1. U Email from EREZ ZADOK
3501.457-001
Page 1 ofl
EFTA01249643 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from Robert Morosky about Les Wexner
(inferred timestamp: 2019-08-28 13:48:00)
500 -NY -3027571 Serial 259
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Crisis Intake
Date: 08/28/2019
Case ID #: 31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 08/28/2019 09:48 AM EDT
Details:
On 08/28/2019, at 09:48 a.m. Eastern Time, Robert Morosky, date of birth
called the FBI
National Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to report possible knowledge of
airline use of Jeffery Epstein in
Morosky provided the following information:
Morosky said he had information regarding the use of "Limited" brand
aircraft's used in the 1990's to transport young girls from Mexico to the

US. Morosky admitted he was the Vice-Chair of the Limited airline. He
went on to say he was business partners and close personal friends with
Les Wexner. Morosky did not not wish to give any additional information
at that time, however if someone would like to pursue this information he
could be reached on his personal cellular phone.
••
3501.381-001
Page I of I
EFTA00005783 (Jmail)
 [misc] heavily redacted handwritten note, 30+ completely redacted pages
(date: 2019-08-29)
CELL
Mine
ArA-TerD YD A etv-e- 4ety /,/ -yozvic i
w/
m ).9/ n_v_e_ bvic.ogiwthoAl
She Ant' 070/ve. same ,e /if
/4.4r-,6/4 bvi --eAuie ti re 3,4/2 el fAt5 "
V/ CTI
natairr.
[Rom 41. -7
C a eta, NC 2 f?, //
1-72 77,0
di<
e A4/%20 e, NC Z //

╭────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────╮
│ Cet                          │
│ ane fom DL                   │
│                              │
│ Chareotlé, VC ZPZ            │
│ E, ‘ ’                       │
│ Kept 70 prtve heed wyeved o* │
│                              │
│ ‘                            │
│ et ave. INFaeNd fio) ei >    │
│ 1                            │
│                              │
│ She has done Some Sype 0F    │
│                              │
│ SILO A Iteau                 │
│ 100s 7 “JTE*                 │
│ victim eC egnR dwg JE .      │
│                              │
│ Charlatge, MC ZELY           │
╰──────────────────────────────╯

NJP Response Page 1 of 2
Unautharind Dan!, reproduction. or dissemination It prohibited.
RE CEIVED AT 08'29/2019 IC:45:54
DR.NCDCI0000
10:45 08/29/2019 08353
10:45 08/29/2019 05727 NY10100T2
'04517928D7
TXT
NAME:
RESIDENCE ADDRESS:
COUNTRY: UNITED STATES
DATE OF BIRTH:
HEIGHT: 508
EYE COLOR: BLUE
HAIR COLOR: BLONDE
GENDER: Female
RACE: white
DRIVER LICENSE DETAILS ***
DRIVER AUTHORIZATION ID:
JURISDICTION AUTHORITY CODE: NC
ISSUE DATE: 2019-07-31
CHARLOTTE,NC 282113896
https://www.ejustice.ny.gov/JWI/ViewMessagejsp?msgid=27828988cpager.offset=0 8/29/2019
NJP Response Page 2 of 2
EXPIRATION DATE: 2027-07-01
DRIVER LICENSE PERMIT QUANTITY: 0
DRIVER LICENSE NON-COMMERCIAL CLASS: C
DRIVER LICENSE NON-COMMERCIAL CLASS CODE: C
LICENSED COMMERCIAL DRIVER: NO
LICENSED NON-COMMERCIAL DRIVER: YES
DRIVER LICENSE NON-COMMERCIAL STATUS: CLS C ACTIVE (CRD TRNS:0025384166 )
Unauthorized access, reproduction, or dissemination is prohibited.
hups://wsvw.ejustice.ny.gov/JWINiewMessagejsp?msgid=2782898&pager.offset=0 8/29/2019

╭──── Page 12, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 13, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 25, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 29, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00129017 (Jmail)
 [article] Virgin Islands Daily News
(inferred date: 2019-08-29)
influence
local
politicians,
and
says
deJongh
even
asked
Epstein
to
suggest
changes
to
the
territory's
sex
offender
law
"Epstein's
primary
conduit
for
spreading
money
and
influence
throughout
the
USVI
government
was
First
Lady
delongh,"
who
worked
as
Epsteins
local
fixer
for
two
decades,
including
throughout
her
husband
John
delongh
Jns
tenure
as
V.I.
gover-
nor
from
2007
to
2015,
according
to
the
filing. Delongh
told
Epstein
which
govern-
ment
officials
to
pay
off,
and
devised
ways
to
justify
his
victims'
presence
in
the
territory
by
enrolling
them
at
the
University
of
the
Virgin
Islands
so
they
could
obtain
student
visas,
according
to
the
filing.
In
a statement
to
The
Daily
News
on
Th
ursday,
UV[
President
David
Hall
denied
all
allegations
in
the
bank's
filing. Attorneys
for
the
bank
say
docu-
ments
obtained
during
the
discovery
process,
which
is
still
ongoing,
show
that
deJongh
asked
Epstein
-- a
registered
sex
offender
—
to
suggest
changes
to
the
territory's
sex
offender
law
in
2011,
and
apologized
profusely,
via
email,
when
not
all
of
his
revisions
were
included
in
the
final
version.
As
a sex
offender,
Epstein
occasion-
ally
encountered
difficulties
traveling
through
the
airport
with
young
wom-
en.
But
Epstein
needed
only
"to
email
the
US
VI's
First
Lady,
who
gamely
intervened
on
his
behalf"
by
reaching
out
to
her
husband,
according
to
the
fil-
ing,
which
cites
a Nov.
15,
2012,
email
from
Epstein
to
delongh,
"regarding
sending
'all
78
[USVI
customs
agents]
a turkey'
for
'thanksgiving"
In
return,
Epsteimpaid
delongh
well,
and
she
received
"a
salary,
bonuses,
and
other
benefits,
including
$200,000
in
2007
alone,"
according
to
the
filing.
Epstein
also
paid
tuition
for
the
children
of
the
then
-governor
and
first
lady
—
which
allowed
the
delonghs
to
funnel
more
of
their
personal
money
into
the
campaign
—
and
said
he
would
fluid
the
former
governor
defense
in
a criminal
corruption
case
that
was
later
dropped,
offering
to
"play
any
role
in
this
you
guys
like:
Former
first
lady
Cecile
deJongh
and
her
husband,
former
Gov.
John
deJongh
Jr.
according
to
the
filing.
"Lest
there
be
doubt
that
Epstein's
goal
was
to
gain
influence,
First
Lady
delongh
explicitly
advised
Epstein
on
how
to
buy
control
of
the
USVI
political
class,"
according
to
the
filing,
telling
hint
"how
to
vote
and
whom
to
The
filing
cited
an
nil
exchange
between
Epstein
and
deJongh,
in
which
he
asked
her
for
a list
of
candi-
dates
he
should
vote
for.
Delongh
also
suggested
ways
to
influence
senators,
writing
to
Epstein
that
he
should,
"consider
putting
Celestino
[White]
on
some
sort
of
monthly
retainer.
That
is
what
will
get
you
his
loyalty
and
access,"
according
to
the
filing.
De
Jongh
also
"crafted
a plan
to
facilitate
Epstein
easy
travel
to
and
from
USVI,"
and
told
him
that,
"we
will
need
to
work
through
[then-USVI
Senator
Carlton]
Dowe
— and
White,
according
to
the
filing.
Epstein
had
particularly
close
ties
to
the
Executive
Director
of
theV.I.
Port
Authority,
and
"could
count
on
his
'great
relationship"'
with
airport
of-
ficials
"to
avoid
scrutiny
or
detection"
when
traveling
with
young
women
as
a registered
sex
offender,
according
to
the
filing.
Ellsworth
also
cited
a communica-
tion
from
Cecile
de
Jongh
to
Epstein,
on
behalf
of
her
husband,
asking
"if
he
would
'support
[then-USVI
sena-
tor]
Carlton
Dove%
bid
to
go
back
to
VIPA'
who
would
be
a 'good
person
for
us'
there
Prior
to
his
election,
Gov.
Albert
Bryan
Jr.,
in
2018,
also
"facilitated
do-
nations
by
Epstein
to
USVI's
schools
and
little
leagues?'
and
Epstein
also
gave
money
to
local
politicians
like
V.I.
Delegate
to
Congress
Stacey
Plaskett,
and
"asked
that
his
contributions
be
kept
secret,"
according
to
the
filing.
Bryan
has
publicly
denied
receiving
campaign
contributions
from
Epstein,
but
according
to
the
filing,
there
are
re-
cords
of
Epstein
"discussing
a $25,000
private
gift
to
current
Governor
Bryans
inaugural
committee?"
Bryan
is
scheduled
to
be
deposed
on
June
6,
and
Plaskett
admitted
to
ac-
cepting
$30,000
in
campaign
contribu-
tions
from
Epstein
and
his
employees
during
her
May
9 deposition.
"For
two
decades.
and
for
long
after
JPMC
exited
Epstein
as
a client,
the
entity
that
most
directly
failed
to
protect
public
safety
and
most
actively
facilitated
and
benefited
from
Epstein's
continued
criminal
activity
was
the
plaintiff
in
this
case—
the
USVI
gov-
ernment
itself?"
according
to
the
filing.
The
allegations
arc
contained
in
a 30
-page
document
by
Felicia
Ellsworth,
an
attorney
representing
J PMorgan
Chase
in
its
defense
of
a
lawsuit
filed
by
the
V.I.
Justice
Depart-
ment
in
the
U.S.
District
Court
for
the
Southern
District
of
New
Yodc
The
government
has
accused
the
bank
of
facilitating
and
profiting
from
Epstein's
aimes.
But
attorneys
for
the
bank
say
the
government
provided
a
safe
haven
for
Epstein
and
allowed
him
to
continue
bringing
victims
to
the
territory
without
scrutiny;
even
reward-
ing
him
with
lucrative
tax
benefits.
Ellsworth
initially
submitted
the
30
-
page
filing
on
Tuesday
with
redactions
through
more
than
half
of
the
docu-
ment,
and
some
pages
were
almost
completely
blacked
out.
On
Thursday,
Ellsworth
mfiled
the
document
with
the
majority
of
redac-
tions
removed,
although
several
pages
arc
still
not
fully
public..
The
new
filing
came
after
District
Court
Judge
Jed
Rakoff
entered
an
order
Tuesday,
granting
the
bank
motion
to
compel
Epsteins
estate
to
produce
all
email
correspondence
cc
itaining
the
search
terms
"Cecile
de
)(nigh,"
"CIA,"
or
"De
Jongh."
After
briefing
by
both
parties,
Rakoff
ruled
that
'The
requested
docu-
ments
arc
relevant
and
that
the
burden
of
producing
them
is
not
excessive?'
That
will
allow
lawyers
for
the
bank
to
further
delve
into
de
Jongh's
work
for
Epstein.
after
years
of
speculation
about
her
level
of
involvement
in
his
Inc
government
the
court
to
deny
certain
affirmative
defenses.
But
Ellsworth
responded
in
the
bank's
latest
filing
that
it's
the
V.I.
government
that
bears
responsibility
for
enabling
Epstein
crimes.
"To
grant
USVI
immunity
from
these
defenses
would
be
to
allow
it to
profit
from
Epstein
twice:
first
directly,
then
again
in
a civil
suit
which
it could
just
as
easily
see
reflected
in
a mirror?'
according
to
the
filing.
A
judge
has
not
yet
ruled
on
the
dispute
over
affirmative
defenses
Meanwhile,
the
bank'S
lawyers
are
naming
Cecile
de
Jongh
and
other
Virgin
Islanders
as
key
parties
respon-
sible
for
helping
Epstein
thrive
in
the
territory,
despite
his
status
as
a sex
of-
fender
convicted
of
procuring
children
for
prostitution
in
Florida
in
2008.
The
V.I.
JUstice
Department
is re-
sponsible
for
monitoring
sex
offenders
in
the
territory;
including
Epstein,
who
claimed
Little
St.
James
island
off
St.
Thomas
as
his
primary
residence
for
two
decades
before
his
August
2019
suicide.
Several
sections
of
Ellswarth'S
filing
that
remain
partially
redacted
refer
to
the
territorys
lack
of
enforcement
of
its
sex
Offendts
laws,
and
the
unre-
dotted
sections
indicate
that
Epstein
was
given
"leniency"
and
leeway
other
sex
offenders
were
not.
"Even
as
to
the
regulations
USVI
did
enforce,
it did
so
incompetently?'
according
to
the
filing,
which
goes
on
with
several
additional
paragraphs
that
remain
redacted
as
of
Thursday
night.
Another
unredacted
line
says
that,
"Further,
while
the
USVI
did
conduct
site
visits
of
Epstein's
residence,
those
inspections
were
cursory
at
best."
VI.
Justice
Department
spokes-
woman
Sandra
Goomansingh
did
not
respond
to
a request
for
comment
Thursday. Dates,
dollar
amounts
unclear
Some
of
the
allegations
in
JPMor-
gan's
tiling
conflict
with
previous
public
statements.
For
example,
the
filing
says
Cecile
defongh
arranged
for
several
of
Epstein's
victims
to
enroll
at
liV1
so
they
could
See
EPSTEIN,
page
4
EFTA00165518 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about investigation update
(date: 2019-08-29)
JEFFREY EPSTEIN INVESTIGATION
08/29/2019 UPDATE
Child Sex Trafficking: 31E-NY-3027571

• On 08/28/2019, FBI NY conducted three victim interviews.
• On 08/29/2019, a Federal Judge dismissed the sex trafficking indictment against Epstein.

• On 08/29/2019, FBI NY conducted one victim interview.
• On 09/03/2019, FBI NY tentatively plans to travel to Florida to conduct a proffer session with co-conspirator
and will conduct additional interviews.
Digital Media

• FBI NY CART decrypted one hard drive and upon review only contained Woody Allen videos.
• FBI NY CAST analysis is complete for and CO cell phones. Analysis
confirmed and CO cell phones were located near MCC during the first drug transaction.
cell phone was also located at the hotel. No records were retrieved for CO cell phone near
the hotel due to his cell phone being turned off. FBI NY CAST is currently reviewing historical data for CO
cell phone.

• OTD reports that all DVR systems are powered up using clones of the original disks. The DVR Main Controller
is currently password protected, and the Administrator password is needed to gain access. FBI NY is working
to obtain this password from MCC. The DVR 1 System is currently up and running. The disk array appears to
have assembled, but access to the DVR Main Controller is needed for visibility of the data. The DVR 2 System
(priority system) is currently problematic. The system is powering up, but the disk array is NOT assembling.
It appears the configuration of the 16 disks in the array has been lost (likely from being pulled out of the
system live). Three of the disks had to undergo repair before being useable. OTD will attempt to reassemble
this array manually (if possible) by looking at the structure of the disks and finding patterns that potentially
give clues into how they were assembled. A preliminary review today did not prove insightful. FBI NY has
been contacted to request any documentation that may be available or technical personnel from the MCC
that could provide details regarding the configuration of the disk array.
Death investigation: 90A-NY-3151227

• On 08/29/2019, FBI NY conducted five interviews at MCC, to include one interview with Chief Psychologist

Dr. was unaware Epstein changed his will. Dr. was the last medical staff employee
to meet with Epstein on 08/08/2019.

• FBI NY CART concluded its review of the only one of four viewable cameras of the cell block area. The review
corroborates witness and CO interviews. CO Novel Tovas did attempt to conduct checks on inmates. The
review also confirmed CO conducted his checks.
Color of Law: 282B-NY-3156749

• On 08/29/2019, FBI NY will meet with the owner and manager of the Hutchinson Motel in the Bronx to
obtain the subpoenaed records.

• On 09/04/2019, a second proffer will be conducted with
Public Corruption: 72-NY-3157147
• On 08/23/2019, CO
described CO as a serial complainant, with most complaints being unfounded.

• On 08/28/2019, FBI NY interviewed CO M., who advised he had no direct knowledge of the shredding of
documents related to Epstein. CO surmised the After Action Team was shredding documents after
observing inmate Steven Lopez carrying three bags of shredded documents instead of his normal two bags
during his working duties. Inmate Lopez was previously interviewed on 08/21/2019. Due to no evidence to
support the complaint, FBI NY will be closing this matter.
lodged a complaint about potential obstruction of justice. Dal-OIG has
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 The Terramar Project [epstein] clean oceans environmental nonprofit launched by Ghislaine Maxwell for reputation repair 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00261337 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about Bank Secrecy Act, firearm, and border crossing information
(date: 2019-08-29)
50D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS Serial 1
FD-1057 (Rcv. 5-8-10) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Electronic Communication
Title: (U) Subfile Opening Document Date: 08/29/2019
From: NEW YORK
Contact:
Approved By: SIA
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-NY-3027571- (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
INTELPRODS TRAFFICKING
Synopsis: (U) To open an intelligence products file.
Details:
The creation of a Subfile for intelligence products.
.•
5OD-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS Serial 2
FD-I036 (Rev. 10.16-2009) UNCLASSIFIED//LES
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Import Form
Form Type: IntelProd-TIR - Tactical Intelligence
Report
Title: (U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of
Approved By: SIA
Drafted By:
Case ID II: 31E-NY-3027571-
INTELPRODS
31E-NY-3027571

(U) EPSTEIN,
TRAFFICKING
(U) EPSTEIN,
TRAFFICKING
Date: 10/01/2019
JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
BANK SECRECY ACT INFORMATION
This document contains information that was collected and disseminated under
provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) and U.S. Department of the Treasury
regulations implementing the BSA. The information is sensitive in nature and is
to be treated accordingly. The information may be used only for a purpose
related to a criminal, tax, or regulatory investigation or proceeding, or in the
conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities to protect against
international terrorism, or for a national security matter. The information
cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed, or transmitted without
prior approval of the Director of the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network or an
authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be
treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations
of possible criminal activity, akin to confidential informant tips. Such
reports, or the fact they have been filed, may not be disclosed by a government
employee to any person involved in the transaction, other than as necessary to
fulfill the official duties of the government employee. Unauthorized release of
information collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil penalties.
Synopsis: (U//FOUO) This Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) details
tactical analysis regarding the identity of
subject in a child sex trafficking investigation.
UNCLASSIFIED//LES
a
50D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS Serial 2
uNcLAssIFIED/Azs
Title: (U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of
-NY -3027571 -INTELPRODS, 10/01/2019
♦♦
UNCLASSIFIED//LES
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
TACTICAL INTELLIGENCE REPORT
FBI New York
1 October 2019
31E-NY-3027571, ID-13
(U) LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE: The information marked (U//LES) in this document is the property of the
Federal Bureau of Investigation and may be distributed within the federal government (and its contractors), U.S.
intelligence. law enforcement. public safety or protection officials. and individuals with a need to know. Distribution
beyond these entities without FBI authorization is prohibited. Precautions should be taken to ensure this information
is stored and/or destroyed in a manner that precludes unauthorized access. Information bearing the LES caveat may
not be used in legal proceedings without first receiving authorization from the originating agency. Recipients are
prohibited from subsequently posting the information marked LES on a website on an unclassified network without
first obtaining FBI approval.
(U//FOUO) BANK SECRECY ACT (BSA) CAVEAT - Some of the enclosed Financial Database information was
collected and disseminated under provisions of the BSA and U.S. Department of the Treasury regulations
implementing the act (31 U.S.C. 5311. et seq.; 31 CFR Part 103). The information is sensitive in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only for a purpose related to a criminal, tax, or regulatory
investigation or proceeding, or in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities to protect against
international terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be further released, disseminated. disclosed, or
transmitted without prior approval of the Secretary of the Treasury or his authorized delegate. Unauthorized release
of information collected under die BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
THE INFORMATION IN THIS DOCUMENT MAY NOT BE UPLOADED TO ANY DATABASES, USED FOR
ANY PURPOSES, OR DISSEMINATED TO ANY OTHER RECIPIENT R7THOUT THE ADVANCED
AUTHORIZATION OF ITIE FBI. THIS PRODUCT EXPRESSES THE PERSPECTIVE OF THIS OFFICE AND
MAY NOT BE REFLECTIVE OF THE NATIONAL PERSPECTIVE OF THE FBL

(U) Research and Key Findings Regarding
Associate of Jeffrey Epstein
a Reported
(U//LES) FBI New York C-20 was contacted by the Southern District of New York regarding
several victims who were sexually abused by Jeffrey Epstein in the mid 2000s. Epstein invited
minors into his residences, and paid them to provide massages to him which turned sexual in
nature, and wanted the minors to bring other minors to massage him. Epstein would also have an
assistant in New York set up appointments for minors to go to Epstein's other residences outside
of New York [REF: 31E-NY-3027571, Serial 1, 6 December 2018 .On 22 March 2019 FBI New
York received re' rtin • that an individual idenitifed as
F: 31E-NY-3027571, en: 1•, 17 Apn 2019
(U//FOUO) Biographical Information

• (U) Name:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASIFIEDHLAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
Template Effective 10.1.2018
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

• (U) Alias:
• (U) DOB:
• (U) SSN:
• (U) Address:
(U//LES) Based upon this information, FBI New York Squad C-20 requested FBI New York
Intelligence Division ew York-ID-13) conduct research and analysis to identify information
regarding her possible address, and pedigree data. This Tactical Intelligence
Report ad sses FBI New York's Band II threat — Violent Crimes Against Children and Band
DI threat — Human Trafficking.
(U)

• /(U  As of 22 August 2019, searches in DIVS for the name
returned the following information from a credible source:
DOB:
o (U//FOUO) was referenced in a fmancial document dated 9/8/2014
as a signer or t e account associated to On
6/30/2014 Jeffrey Epstein sent a wire to is
located at ew or wl to ep one num r
sted as with tele hone numbers
and the a ess , New
o (U//FOUO) was referenced in a financial document dated 6/20/2014
in the amouni11371.386  for her close association to Jeffrey Epstein. Epstein
wired $20,000 to on 4/2/2014.
5/17/2011 tugg leMer close association to Jeffre E stein. was listed
o (U//FOUO) was referenced in a financial document dated on
with the address: New York, NY.
was is on t i e account ota in 37. 93. The telephone
num t er and email a were listed for her.

• SFOUO) As of 3 September 2019, searches in DIVS for telephone number
returned the following information:
o (U//FOUO was referenced as the contact name and number for the
individual DOB: on a visa application dated
5/23/2012.
o (U//FOUO) alias for as the contact name and number
for the indivi DOB: on a visa application dated
9/13/2011.
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
o (U//FOUO) The telephone number was listed as the contact
number associated to Jeffrey Epstein or e m individual , DOB:
on a visa application dated 6/7/2004.
o (U//FOUO)
record:
(alias for was listed in the following Experian

• (U) Name:
• (U) AddressWIMI
• (U) Transaction Date: 12 2019
• fiFOUO) As of 3 September 2019, searches in DIVS for telephone number
returned the following Experian:
• (U) Name:
• (U) Address:
• (U) Transaction Date: 3 1 2017
• fiFOUO) As of 3 September 2019, searches in DIVS for telephone number
returned the following information:
o (U//FOUO) Telephone number is listed as the work number for
on a visa application dated 3/20/2006.
o (U//FOUO) The telephone number was listed as the contact
number associated to Jeffrey Epstein or e m individual DOB:
on a visa application dated 4/22/2004.
o (U//FOUO) The telephone number was listed as the contact
number associated to Jeffrey Epstein or e m individual , DOB:
on a visa application dated 8/19/2005.
o (U//FOUO) The telephone number was listed as the contact
number accociated to Jeffrey Epstein or e individual , DOB:
on a visa application dated 9/20/2005.
o (U//FOUO) The telephone number was listed as the contact
number associated to Jeffrey Epstein for the individual DOB:
on a visa application dated 9/20/2005.
o (U//FOUO) The telephone number was listed as the contact
number associated to Lesley Groff for the individual , DOB:
on a visa application dated 11/2/2017.
FBI INTERNAL l'SE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
o
o
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
listed as the contact
DOB:
listed as the contact
DOB:
(U//FOUO) The telephone number was
number associated to for the individual
on a visa application to 11/25/2013.
(U//FOUO) The telephone number was
number associated to Jeffrey Epstein or tern individual
on a visa application dated 5/17/2005.
o (U//FOUO) The telephone number was listed as the contact
number associated to Jeffrey Epstein or e m individual
DOB: on a visa application dated 5/17/2005.
o (U//FOUO) The telephone number was listed as the contact
number associated to Jeffrey Epstem or e m vidual , DOB:
on a visa application dated 1/31/2006.
o (U//FOUO) The telephone number was listed in several documents
as being associated to Jeffrey Epstein from a credible financial source.

• (CT//FOUO) As of 3 September 2019, searches in DIVS for telephone number
returned negative results.
• (U//FOUO) As of 3 September 2019, searches in DIVS for the email addresses:
and did not return new information.

• (U//FOUO) As of 3 September 2019, searches in DIVS for the email address
did not return information associated to

• (U//FOUO) As of 231.019, searches in eJustice/NCIC for and
DOB: returned negative results.
• (U//FOUOjs of 28 /tap ist 2019, a request to NYPD for searches in NYPD databases
for and= DOB: did not return a criminal record.

• , FOUO) According ab curint, as of 22 August 2019 searches for the name
and DOB: returned the following information:

• (U) Name: L and L
• (U) DOB:
• (U) SSN:
• (U) Address: (Oct 2014-June
2019)
• (U) Address 2: New York, NY 10012 (Oct 2013-
August 2019)

• (U) Telephone: and
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY -DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FYI9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

• Email Addresses:
New York, NY 10065)
(Associated to
DOB: for travel status identified to be in tEmt.ir

• (U//FOUO As of 21 August 2019, searches in TECS for the name
travel recur' or occurred onl iaTan inbound flight from Nassau
International in e to Douglas, Charlotte in North Carolina. Vicker's US
Passportg was issued on 7/9/2012 and expired on 5/3/2019.

• (U//FOUO) As of 28 August 2019 a Silent Hit was put on
variations) to notify of any international travel.
(to include name

• (U/NOUO As of 12 September 2019 searches in TECS identified a current US Passport
for' DOB: . US PP was issued on 10/1/2013 and
expires on 3 2 3.

• (UHFOUO) (Analyst Note: Additional travel records will be referenced in a separate
tactical intelligent report).

(U) Open Source
illAs of 24 May 2019 open source searches for the telephone numbers
returned negative results.

(U) As of 23 August 2019 open source searches for the telephone number
identified the following accounts:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY -DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Repot
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

• (U) Venmo
o (U) No additional information
• (U) WhatsApp
o (U) No additional information
• (U) Telegram
o (U) User ID: . 1 1
o (U) Display ame:
o (U) No additional ormation

(U) As of 23 August 2019 open source searches for the telephone number
identified the following accounts:

• (U) Slcype
o (U) User Name:
o (U) Display Name:
o (U) No additional ormation
• (U) WhatsApp
o (U) No additional information

• (U) Venmo
o (U) No additional information
• (U) Skype
Name:

(U) User Name:
o (U) Display Na
o Photo:
(U) As of 23 August 2019 open source searches for the email address
identified the following accounts:

• (U) Spotify
o (U) No additional information
• (U) Google
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
6 FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
o (U) User 1D:
o (U) No additional information

• (U) Apple
o (U) No additional information
• (U) Skype
o (U) User Name:
o (U) Display Name:
o (U) No additional ormation

(U) As of 23 August 2019 open source searches for the email address
identified the following accounts:

• (U) Google
o (U) User 1D:
o (U) No additional information
• (U) Apple
o (U) No additional information

• (U) Twitter
o (U) No additional information
• (U) Spotify
o (U) No additional information

(U) As of 28 August 2019 open source searches for the email address
identified the following accounts:
• (U) Google
o (U) User ID:
o (U) No additional information
• (U) MySpace
o (U) No additional information

(U) As of 12 September 2019, additional open source searches identified the following articles:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 1:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FYI9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 3:
(U) Photo 4:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
Pf 19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 5:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
I0
FYI9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 6:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
II
FY 19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 7:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY 19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 8:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY IR Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 1:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 naiad Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 2:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 3:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY I9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 4:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 5:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY 19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 6:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY I9 Tactical Intelligence Rcpon
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 7:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY 19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 8:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY 19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 9:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 10:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY I9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 11:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY I9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 12:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY I9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 13:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
r
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 14:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY I9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Investigative/Intelligence Gaps
• (U) Gap 1: Did
• (U) Gap 2: What
Maxwell teach
• (U) Gap 3: How
• (U) Gap 4: Did

(U) Scope Note
act in the ca aci as a bottom for Jeffrey Epstein? ii
of relationship did have with Ghislaine Maxwell? Did
how to work for Epstein.
recruit minors?
engage in sex acts with Epstein and minors?

(U) Information in this report was derived from numerous open-source, secure and classified
systems to include: Comprehensive Criminal History (CCH), Interstate Identification Index and
National Crime Information Center (DINCIC), and New York Driver's Licenses via eJustice
NY; New York Police Department (NYPD); Administration for Children Services (ACS); DIVS;
Sentinel; Treasury Enforcement Communications System (TECS); Acauint; Google.com; and
social media accounts. All the open-source, secure, and classified information was last collected
between 22 August 2019 and 12 September 2019, and all collection is current as of 12
September 2019.

(U) Consumers: SSA
SA
Det.
(U) Approval: SIA
(U) This tactical intelligence report was prepared by the New York Field Office of the FBI. Comments and queries
may be addressed to the New York Intelligence Division a
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Tice Report
50D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS Serial 3
FD-I036 (Rev. 10.16•2009) UNCLASSIFIED//LES
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Import Form
Form Type: IntelProd-TIR - Tactical Intelligence Date: 10/02/2019
Report
Title: (U//FOU0) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records for
Approved By: SIA
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-NY-3027571- (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
INTELPRODS TRAFFICKING
31E-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN,
TRAFFICKING
JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
Synopsis: (U//FOUO) This Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) details
tactical analysis regarding travel information for
subject in a child sex trafficking investigation.
Enclosure(s): Enclosed are the following items:
1. (U//F000) Travel Records
2. (U//FOUO) Travel Records
••
UNCLASSIFIED//LES
a
08/21/2019 18:27 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 1 of 9
Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date -Time Carder
Code
Carrier
Nunt
U0 Site Insp Type Status Ref Ali
be
Dap
lac
F 05/13/2010
16:28
ZZ N909J I A5:2 4:R-.,,,
(NOT
API)
STT
FD 03/29/2010
16:35
99 N9093 I A512 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
STT
FD 03/05/2010
15:42
999 N909 I A512 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
STT
FD 02/16/2010
15:27
999 N9093 I A512 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
STT
FD 02/05/2010
15:37
99 N909 I A512 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
SIT
FD 01/15/2010
15:39
99 N9093 I A512 , AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
SIT
P 03/07/2009
17:21
ZZ 909JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
P 12/15/2008
19:41
AA 2160 I A524 APIS MIA SXM
P 12/11/2008
00:00
AA 687 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS SXM NIA
P 09/24/2008
15:13
AA 672 I A512 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
SIT STT
p 07/18/2008
16:28
AO 1 I A103 APIS EWR ORY
P 07/09/2008
00:00
LK 403 0 Name No
Name No
APIS FRA EWR
P 06/24/2008
16:45
UNKN I A512 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
P 06/07/2008
13:54
NK 710 I A512 , AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
SIT
P 05/17/2008
08:15
ZZ 909JG I A512 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
SIT
04/29/2008
19:21
4UU 909JE I A461 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
TEB
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive

╭─────────────────────────────────────────── Page 33, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 08/21/2019 18:27 EDT.                                                                                   │
│                                                                                                         │
│ U.S. Customs and Border Protection                                                                      │
│ U.S. Department of Homeland Security                                                                    │
│ TECS - Person Encounter List                                                                            │
│                                                                                                         │
│ For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive                                                       │
│                                                                                                         │
│ Generated ) Page 1 of 9                                                                                 │
│ ‘LastName [FirstName [DOB [Doc Document [Date-Time |Carrer|carrier v0 [site |insp Type |status far [Dep │
│ [Type_|Number_ |Code_|Num. Loc _|Loc                                                                    │
│ — —_ [| fos 72000 ze soos |r asia pees sr                                                               │
│ Aer)                                                                                                    │
│ — —_ — — zon fos frooss |r asia MA [aseeave ae                                                          │
│ apr)                                                                                                    │
│ — —_ —- — oie feos frou |r asia MR faseesne Ser                                                         │
│ Aer)                                                                                                    │
│ — —_ —« Yo 3c720i0 sos roves |e fase I ase ae                                                           │
│ — —_ — fe zros2o foo pee el ae                                                                          │
│ — —_ — — ow fos frsoss |r fsa mm er                                                                     │
│ — —_ [> [03/07/2000 fez  __— per                                                                        │
│ ——_ fe ee ee faa faser                                                                                  │
│ — = — > MJ 2/22/2008 [aa o lars [sso fara                                                               │
│ aa %0a                                                                                                  │
│ — —_ [oo 28 72008 [a F — ser fae                                                                        │
│ Aer)                                                                                                    │
│ fl eel el A ee mo fs : |: A [2x5 lone                                                                   │
│ = _ _ _ ce [aoa fo ners Fea fear                                                                        │
│ — —_ (oe oe 2 6 2008 i ol fArRLINe                                                                      │
│ esas (io!                                                                                               │
│ Beal                                                                                                    │
│ — —_ em > foc 07 72008 face fof ace fed                                                                 │
│ Aer)                                                                                                    │
│ — —_ fem = foc 2008 foe ross |e fase feseesne ae                                                        │
│ oacas oF                                                                                                │
│ Aer)                                                                                                    │
│ — —_ —- — eva a fee                                                                                     │
│ Jarry                                                                                                   │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

08/21/2019 18:27 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 2 of 9
LastNene First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date -Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
NO Site In p Type Status Ref An
Loc
Dip
Loc
P 04/15/2008 NN 909VE I A512 AIRLINE STT
15:02 (NOT
API
P 04/04/2008 AI 144 0 Name No APIS CDC BWR
00:00 Name, No
P 03/22/2008 DL 726 I 7512 AIRLINE STT
12:53 (NOS
API)
P 03/05/2008 M4 909JE I A512 AIRLINE STT
07:09 (NOT
API)
P 02/24/2008 ZZ N909J I 11512 AIRLINE STT
14:32 (NOT
API)
P 01/29/2008 AI 191 I A103 APIS EWR COG
17:42
P 01/21/2008 AP 7 0 Name No APIS CIO MIK
00:00 Name, No
P 01/17/2008 XX 999 I A512 AIRLINE STT
07:05 (NOT
API)
P 01/03/2008 AA 856 I A512 AIRLINE STT
14:30 (NOT
API)
P 12/18/2007 MICR I A512 AIRLINE
10:46 (NOT
APIL
P 12/11/2007 ONICI4 I A512 AIRLINE
14:59 (NOT
API)
P 12/02/2007 CO 1883 I A512 AIRLINE STT STT
13:56 (NOT
API)
P 10/21/2007 AA 5119 I 7512 AIRLINE STT STT
15:50 (NOT
API)
P 10/13/2007 CO 1883 I A512 AIRLINE STT STT
13:30 (NOT
API)
P 10/12/2007 XX 999 I A511 AIRLINE STT
10:07 (NOT
API)
09/27/2007 AA 1312 I A512 AIRLINE STT
15:13 (NOT I API)
P 09/02/2007 N 909JE I A512 AIRLINE INS STT
15:07 (NOT
API)
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/211201918:27 EDT Generated By: Page 3 or 9
Last Name First Name DOB Doc Document Date - Time Carrier Carrier I 0 Site Insp Type Status Ref Ir Mr Ds p
Type Number Code Num. Loo Leo
P 68/08/2007 AA 412 . AS:2 AIRLINE SIT STT
11:41 (NOT
API)
P 08/02/ 067 C. . 4 IAN SJD
P 07/26/2007 CO 1769 0 Name No APIS SJD IAN
00:00 Name, No
P 07/24/2007 Ah 5119 I AS12 AIRLINE SIT SIT
16:08 (NOT
API)
P 07/17/2007 UNKN I AS12 AIRLINE
08:18 (NOT
API)
P 07/05/2007 AA 5163 I A512 AIRLINE SIT
11:29 (NOT
API)
P 06/22/2007 AA 412 I AS12 AIRLINE SIT SIT
11:37 (NOT
API)
P 06/05/2007 UNKN I AS12 AIRLINE
08:25 (NOT
API)
P 05/23/2007 CO 1883 I A512 AIRLINE SIT STT
13:55 (NOT
API)
P 03/28/2007 Y7 101 I A103 APIS ENR LTH
13:05
P 03/24/2007 Y7 102 0 Name No APIS LTN EWR
00:00 Name No
P 03/20/2007 UNKN I AS12 AIRLINE
08:08 (NOT
API)
P 02/06/2007 CO 1883 I AS12 AIRLINE SIT SIT
13:49 (NOT
API)
01/03/2007 AA 412 I A512 AIRLINE SIT STT
11:46 (NOT
API)
P 12/30/2006 AA 1 I AS11 AIRLINE SIT
16:16 (NOT
API)
P 12/23/2006 ZZ N908 I AS11 AIRLINE STT
10:18 (NOT
API)
P 10/16/2006 ZZ 909JE I A461 AIRLINE IEB
23:39 (NOT
API)
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/21/2019 18:27 EDT Generated B Page 4 of g
I Last Name First Name DOB Doc Document Date - Time Carrier Carrier I 0 Site Insp Type Status Ref Arr W
Type Number Code Num. Lee Loc
P 08/31/2006 UNKN . Aa:1 AIRLINE
18:09 (NOT
API)
P 06/09/2006 22 1 I A511 AIRLINE STT
17:33 (NOT
API)
P 05/29/2006 AA 1080 1 7073 APIS JFK PLS
16.30
P 05/27/2006 AA 1015 o Name % APIS PLS JFK
00:00 Name. ',.
04/07/2006 AA 1568 I A512 AIRLINE STT
15:44 (NOT
API)
P 12/28/2005 AA 412 I A512 AIRLINE STT
11:24 (NOT
API)
P 12/27/2005 )0( N4916 I A511 AIRLINE STT
15:55 (NOT
API)
P 12/13/2005 CO 37 I A105 APIS NCO EDI
11:49
P 12/08/2005 VS 46 o Name No APIS LHR JFK
00:00 Name, No
P 12/07/2005 AA 412 I A512 AIRLINE STT
11:46 (NOT
API)
P 11/23/2005 AA 412 I A512 AIRLINE STT
11:52 (NOT
API)
P 11/20/2005 ZZ N908J I A511 AIRLINE STT
14:47 (NOT
API)
P 10/19/2005 AA 5143 I A512 AIRLINE STT
09:18 (NOT
API)
P 09/10/2005 TN 4 I A471 APIS JFK SYD
15.18
P 09/03/2005 TN 3 o Name No APIS SYD JFK
00.00 Name, No
P 08/30/2005 AA 412 I A512 AIRLINE STT
11:14 INOT
API)
P 06/04/2005 PV 1 I A492 AIRLINE SJU
16:51 (NOT
API)
06/02/2005 SW 427 O Name No APIS TAB JFK
i 00:00 Name, No
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive

╭───────────────────────────────────────────── Page 36, Image 1 ──────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ U.S. Customs and Border Protection                                                                          │
│ U.S. Department of Homeland Security                                                                        │
│ TECS - Person Encounter List                                                                                │
│                                                                                                             │
│ 08/21/2019 18:27 EDT Generated 5y Page 4 of 9                                                               │
│                                                                                                             │
│ ‘LastName [FirstName [DOB [Doc Document [Date-Time |Carrer|carrier 0 [site |insp Type [Status [Ret far [Dep │
│ |Type_|Number |Code_|Num. Loc _|Loc                                                                         │
│ — fn > fos 22 2006 a eo                                                                                     │
│ Aer)                                                                                                        │
│ — —_ [> ffocro572005 fae f2 a ae                                                                            │
│ _ apr)                                                                                                      │
│ — nm ee | es sex [exs                                                                                       │
│ 6:30                                                                                                        │
│ — | = — > MMM Josy27/2006 faa sors o Name wo apts pus [arK                                                  │
│ oo%oa Name, wo                                                                                              │
│ — —_ — grozzanoe [am [asco |x |asia MAIN [acncswe srr                                                       │
│ apr)                                                                                                        │
│ — —_ fmm zee fe foe see cen ae                                                                              │
│ apr)                                                                                                        │
│ — —_ fmf: ffs Pfs fee er                                                                                    │
│ apr)                                                                                                        │
│ ——_ | eee iP [anos | ars reco eae                                                                           │
│ ia                                                                                                          │
│ — = fem | eso 2005 fos fe 5 INane wo [aras caw [ore                                                         │
│ ao%oa Name, wo                                                                                              │
│ — —_= (ms > 2209/2005 fan fase F [ass2 Naren srr                                                            │
│ apr)                                                                                                        │
│ = = a — 11/23/2005 Jan 412 ft |as2 SD farecive [STT                                                         │
│ Aer)                                                                                                        │
│ — —_ (> ff 20 2005 Co | peers Se                                                                            │
│ aes)                                                                                                        │
│ — —_ fm ft fe fe |e fase face Se                                                                            │
│ oosae fed                                                                                                   │
│ Beal                                                                                                        │
│ —_— = ee fe eamrecry ars fare [axe                                                                          │
│ isi                                                                                                         │
│ — _ > MME Josyo3/2005 [rw [3 e Name No lapis [syo                                                           │
│ boso0 Name, wo                                                                                              │
│ — — (i > s20/2005 Jan fase > | fareniNe srr                                                                 │
│ aes)                                                                                                        │
│ — —_ [> foc 02 2005 7 F (|e a0                                                                              │
│ 16:82 fed                                                                                                   │
│ se                                                                                                          │
│ —=— fe cm ff 5 ane wo [arzs fae faex                                                                        │
│ oosoa Name, No                                                                                              │
│                                                                                                             │
│ For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive                                                           │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

08/21/2019 18:27 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 5 of 9
Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date -Time Carrier
Code
Cartier
Num.
I/O Site Insp Type Status Ref Air
Loc
Dap
Lac
P 03/11/2005
17:17
GAA I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
P 02/21/2005
20:17
*UV 908JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
P 01/28/2005
23:02
BA 183 I A471 APIS JPIC IJIR
P 01/25/2005
00:00
AA 62 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS )C NIA
P 01/14/2005
18:33
ZZ 908JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
P 01/01/2005
16:21
*UV 909JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
12/29/2004
15:57
*UV 909JE I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
STT
P 12/12/2004
06:10
AA 5131 I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
STT
P 10/16/2004
20:16
•011 908JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
P 10/02/2004
22:00
ZZ 908JE I AS23 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
P 09/11/2004
11:09
AA 115 I A473 APIS JFK LHR
P 09/04/2004
13:17
AA 1692 I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
STT
P 08/25/2004
17:46
ZZ 908JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
P 08/22/2004
18:11
BA 209 I A520 APIS MIA LHR
P 08/12/2004
00:00
LH 405 0 1-,,, 1-> APIS PRA Jig(
P 08/06/2004
22:35
+HU 908JE I AS23 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
P 07/22/2004
22:00
*UN 908JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
P 07/15/2004
00:50
VS 17 I A103 APIS ENR LHR
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/21/2019 18:27 EDT Generated By: Page 6 of g
(Last Name First Name ¶DOB Doc Document DMe-Tfrne Carrier Carrier 10 Site Insp Type Status Ref I An Dap
Type Number Code Num. Loc Loc
U7/11/2004 VS 46 0 Name No APIS LHR JFK
00:00 Name, No
P 06/17/2004 9K 810 I A512 AIRLINE STT STT
10:43 (NOT
API)
P 05/26/2004 BA 179 I A472 APIS JFK LHR
21:06
P 05/14/2004 ZZ 908JE I AS23 AIRLINE PBI
10:35 (NOT
API)
P 04/08/2004 AA 1892 I AS12 AIRLINE SIT
15:22 (NOT
API)
P 03/29/2004 BA 183 I A472 APIS JFK INR
21:43
P 03/25/2004 BA 176 0 Name No APIS LHR JFK
00:00 Name, No
03/19/2004 ZZ 909JE I A523 AIRLINE PBI
15:51 (NOT
API)
01/04/2004 AA 1078 I A520 APIS MIA BGI
18:42
12/30/2003 AA 5433 I A512 AIRLINE SIT
07:20 BERNARD (NOT
API)
12/30/2003 AA 5360 o Name No APIS BGI SJU
00:00 Name, No 111
12/12/2003 AA 5441 I A512 AIRLINE SIT
09:01 (NOT
GILBERTO API)
P 11/30/2003 JM 91 1 A471 APIS JFK BGI
23:26
P 11/25/2003 JM 90 0 Name No APIS WSJ JFK
00:00 Name, No
P 11/11/2003 ZZ 1 I A311 J APIS ANC
09:27
P 11/02/2003 AF 9 0 Name No Name APIS CDG JFK
00:00 N
F. 08/15/2003 DL 71 I A171 APIS ATL FCO
16:45
P 08/10/2003 DL 148 o Name No Name APIS FCO JFK
00:00 N
F. 08/08/2003 AA 412 I A512 APIS SIT
12:37
P 07/12/2003 CO 28 0 Name N, Same APIS LGti ENR
i 00:00
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/21/2019 18:27 EDT Generated By: Page 7 of 9
Last Name First Name DOB Doc Document Date - Time Carrier Carrier I 0 Site Insp Type Status Ref
Arr .1W I
Type Number Code Num. We Loc
P k.6/28/200.$ UNKN . A5:2 AIRLINE
15:56 (NOT
API)
P 06/27/2003 UNKN I A511 AIRLINE
17:45 (NOT
API)
P 05/28/2003 LTA 979 I A472 APIS JFK LHR
20.50
P 04/11/2003 ZZ 1 I A523 G APIS PBI
00.45
03/23/2003 ZZ 909JE I A523 P APIS PBI
21:43
02/21/2003 BA 175 I A471 APIS JFK LHR
13:58
01/02/2003 RA 615A T A491 Name No Name APIS SIT EIS
00.00 N
P 12/31/2002 144 222 T A491 Name No Name APIS SBH STT
00:00 N
04/18/2002 ZZ 908JE I A523 AIRLINE
17:58 (NOT
API)
P 03/13/2002 AF 2 I 4701 APIS JFK CDG
08:57
P 12/26/2001 ZZ 2 I A523 AIRLINE
20:44 (NOT
API)
P 12/23/2001 I A511 AIRLINE
16:22 (NOT
API)
P 03/30/2001 JL 72 I APIS HNL NET
14:48
Total Number of Records: 119
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
08/21/2019 18:27 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 8 of 9
Codes Velum
CDG PARIS, CH. DE GAULLE
LIN LUTON INTERNATIONAL
HNL HONOLULU INT'L
SXM ST MAARTEN, PRINCE JULIANA
EDI TURNHOUSE
SJD LOS CABOS
JFK JOHN F KENNEDY INTL
NRT NARITA, TOKYO
SIT C.E. KING
MBJ MONTEGO BAY, SANGSTER INTL
PBI WEST PALM BEACH
PLS PROVIDENCIALES
ORY PARIS, ORLY
LHR LONDON / HEATHROW INTL
SBH ST. BARTHELEMYIARPT,GUADELOUPE
SYD KINGSFORD SMITH -SYDNEY
SJU SAN JUAN, LUIS MUNOZ MARIN INTL
EWR NEWARK INTERNATIONAL
MIA MIAMI INTL, FL
BGI BARBADOS, GRANTLEY ADAMS INTL
EIS BEEF ISLAND, VIRGIN ISLAND (BRITISH)
TEE TETERBORO
IAH HOUSTON INTERCONTINENTAL
FCO ROME, FIUMICINO
FRA FRANKFURT INT'L
TAB TOBAGA, TRINIDAD
ANC ANCHORAGE
MCO ORLANDO
ATL WILLIAM B HARTSFIELD
LGW LONDON / GATWICK INTL
P
F
FD
P - PASSPORT
F - FACILITATION DOCUMENT
FD - FACILITATION DOCUMENT
SIII•Cods
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/21/2019 18:27 EDT
. " Value
AS24 A524 - CBP-MIAMI, AIRPORT CNTRL TERML
AS11 AS11 - CBP-CYRIL E KING, INTL AIRPORT
AS12 AS12 - CBP-ST THOMAS, VI PREDEPARTURE
AS23 AS23 - CBP-PALM BEACH, INTERNATIONAL
AS34 AS34 - CBP-HOUSTON, BUSH INTL AIRPORT
A105 A105 - NEWARK, INTL AP TERMINAL C
AS20 AS20 - CBP-MIAMI, AIRPORT N TERMINAL
A311 A311 - CBP-ANCHORAGE, INTL AIRPORT
A103 A103 - CBP-NEWARK, INTL AIR TERM B
A461 A461 - CBP-TETERBORO AIRPT HANGER 2
A472 A472 - NEN YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 7
A473 A473 - NEW YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 8
A492 A492 - CBP-SAN JUAN, MUNOZ MARIN IAP
A471 A471 - NEW YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 4
A171 A171 - CBP-ATLANTA, HARTSFIELD INTLAP
A491 A491 - SAN JUAN, PASSENGER BRANCH
4701 4701 - 4701
Generated B Page 9 of 9
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 1 of 10
Leiters First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date -Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
UO Site Insp Type Status Ref An
Loc
Dip
Loc
08/08/2019
00:00
AA 859 ;PIS CLT NAS
05/29/2019
13:31
AA 859 A741 INTERNATIONA
L GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
NAS
APIS PASSENGER CLT NAS
05/24/2019
00:00
DL 494 0 APIS ON BOARD NAS JFK
05/24/2019
00:00
YX 4560 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
NAS MIA
05/23/2019
00:00
AA 893 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
NAS CLT
04/26/2019
00:00
AC 795 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LAX YYZ
P 04/25/2019
00:00
AA 2676 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
YYZ MIA
P 04/17/2019
16:20
TP 223 I A524 TERM GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
CENTRAL
AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MANUAL
ADD
MIA LIS
P 04/17/2019
00:00
TP 223 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
MIA LIS
P 04/08/2019
00:00
BA 206 0 APIS ON BOARD LHR MIA
P 03/05/2019
00:00
AA 39 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
MIA LHR
P 02/28/2019
20:47
BA 179 I A472 7 LANE 23
K04 GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
TERM
APIS PASSENGER JFK LHR
P 02/25/2019
00:00
AA 38 0 APIS ON BOARD LHR MIA
02/24/2019
00:00
AA 38 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LHR MIA
F. 02/03/2019
19:50
LH 460 I A52G GLOBAL ENTRY
KI MIA11
APIS PASSENGER MIA MUC
P 01/28/2019
18:32
LH 461 0 A520 PASSENGER
ATS UNIFIED
APIS MUC NIA
01/05/2019
16:15
YX 4409 I A520 KIOSK 7
GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK,
NORTHTERMD
APIS PASSENGER MIA MHH
P 12/29/2018
00:00
AA 1609 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
NAS MIA
P 12/28/2018
00:00
UP 228 0 APIS ON BOARD NAS MIA
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT Generated B Page 2 of 10
Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date-llme Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
10 Site Insp Typo Status Ref gr Mr
UK
Dip
We
.1/05/2018
11:28
DL 372 : A741 INTERNATIONA
L GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
NAS
APIS PASSENGER JFK NAS
11/02/2018
00:00
UP 206 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
NAS FLL
P 11/02/2018
00:00
B6 1993 0 APIS ON BOARD NAS FLL
09/28/2018
00:00
AA 44 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
CDG JFK
P 09/04/2018
14:29
UA 169 I A105 GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK, EWR7
APIS PASSENGER EWR VCE
09/04/2018
00:00
AA 235 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK FCO
P 08/27/2018
00:00
EK 206 0 APIS ON BOARD MXP JFK
P 08/04/2018
17:21
AA 745 I A152 GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK, CLT3
APIS PASSENGER CLT BCN
P 07/21/2018
00:00
EK 210 0 APIS ON BOARD ATH EWR
P 07/01/2018
20:49
•GA N117MS I A102 APIS PASSENGER KHPN NMQT
07/01/2018
00:00
MQ 3517 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
DFW QRO
06/27/2018
00:00
MQ 3551 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
QRO DFW
06/26/2018
00:00
AA 1863 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
ME% CLT
P 06/26/2018
00:00
DL 481 0 APIS ON BOARD ME% JFK
P 05/31/2018
15:15
AA 113 I A520 KIOSK 8
GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK,
NORTHTERMD
APIS PASSENGER MIA BCN
05/18/2018
00:00
AA 2721 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
YYZ MIA
05/11/2018
12:55
VA 1539 I A741 INTERNATIONA
L GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
NAS
APIS PASSENGER EWR NAS
05/08/2018
00:00
YX 4692 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
NAS NIA
04/04/2018
00:00
*GA N9997% 0 APIS PASSENGER TAPA KMIA
02/23/2018
12:45
UA 957 I A103 GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK, EWR9
APIS PASSENGER EWR GVA
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT Generated By: Page 3 of 10
(Last Name First Name DOB Doe
Type
Document
Number
Date-Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
10 Site Msp Type Status Ref lir Art
Loc
Dap
Loc
02/20/2018
00:00
AA 717 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
PHL NUC
02/15/2018
00:00
LH 401 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
FRA JFK
02/14/2018
00:00
UA 70 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
AMS EMI
02/14/2018
00:00
AA 716 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
MIX PHL
02/13/2018
00:00
BA 206 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LHR NIA
02/12/2018
00:00
AA 38 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LHR MIA
P 01/15/2018
18:16
*GA N9997X I A52B APIS PASSENGER !GHIA TAPA
P 01/12/2018
00:00
*GA N9997% 0 APIS PASSENGER TAPA !CHIA
P 09/04/2017
08:26
B6 622 I A741 INTERNATIONA
L GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
NAS
APIS PASSENGER JFK NAS
P 08/31/2017
00:00
B6 1221 0 APIS ON BOARD NAS JFK
P 06/30/2017
00:00
AA 732 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LHR CLT
P 06/28/2017
00:00
AA 732 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LHR CLT
P 06/27/2017
00:00
AA 104 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LHR JFK
P 06/11/2017
22:08
AA 141 I A473 8 LANE 21
KO1 GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
TERM
APIS PASSENGER JFK LHR
05/17/2017
00:00
AA 104 0 APIS ON BOARD LHR JFK
05/16/2017
00:00
AA 106 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LHR JFK
P 05/08/2017
12:02
YX 4433 I A741 INTERNATIONA
L GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
NAS
APIS PASSENGER MIA NAS
P 05/05/2017
00:00
YX 4433 0 APIS ON BOARD NAS MIA
P 04/28/2017
09:11
AC 550 I A338 MAIN TERM
GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK, YVR
APIS PASSENGER LA% YVR
04/23/2017
00:00
AA 2369 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
YVR DEW
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT Generated By: Page 4 of 10
(Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Daba-TIme Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
10 Site Insp Typo Status Ref II Arr
Loe
Dip
Loo
P U4/22/2017
00:00
AC 549 0 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
YVR EWR
04/21/2017
00:00
BA 8005 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK ORY
P 04/20/2017
00:00
BA 173 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK LNR
P 04/13/2017
00:00
QR 704 o APIS NOT ON
BOARD
DOH JFK
P 04/12/2017
00:00
QR 704 o APIS ON BOARD DOH JFK
P 04/09/2017
18:05
B6 1528 I A470 TERMINAL 5
GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK, JFK
APIS PASSENGER JFK POP
04/09/2017
00:00
AA 935 = APIS NOT ON
BOARD
MIA POP
P 04/06/2017
00:00
AA 935 o APIS ON BOARD POP NIA
04/06/2017
00:00
B6 627 o APIS NOT ON
BOARD
POP JFK
P 04/03/2017
10:09
ix 4590 : A741 INTERNATIONA
L GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
NAS
APIS PASSENGER MIA NAS
04/03/2017
00:00
YX 4590 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
MIA NAS
P 04/02/2017
00:00
*GA N604VG I APIS PASSENGER KOPF MYNN
P 03/29/2017
00:00
YX 4692 o APIS ON BOARD NAS MIA
03/29/2017
00:00
B6 1221 o APIS NOT ON
BOARD
NAS JFK
P 12/11/2016
12:16
AA 1204 I A520 KIOSK 9
GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK,
NORTHTERMD
APIS PASSENGER MIA SJO
12/06/2016
00:00
AA 2247 o APIS NOT ON
BOARD
SJO MIA
11/12/2016
00:00
VES 9677076 I Name No
Name, No
CRUISE
SHIP
PASSENGER 5201 7423
11/10/2016
00:00
VES 9677076 o Name No
Name, No
CRUISE
SHIP
PASSENGER 7423 A1/04
20/27/2016
16:11
NH 104 I A472 7 LANE 28
K02 GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
TERM
APIS PASSENGER JFK NRT
20/17/2016
00:00
NH 9 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD NRT JFK
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT Generated By: Page 5 of 10
(Last Name First Name DOB DOC
Typo
Document
Number
Dabs -Time Carder
Code
Carrier
Num.
10 Site Insp Typo Status Ref Arr
Loc
Dip
Loc
P 10/17/2016
00:00
JL 3 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
NRT JFK
P 09/29/2016
00:00
MU 587 I Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK PVG
P 09/28/2016
17:58
UA 87 I A105 GLOBAL
ENTRY EWR16
APIS ON BOARD EWR PVG
P 09/27/2016
00:00
CA 981 I Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK PEK
P 09/26/2016
00:00
CA 819 I Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
EWR PEK
P 09/12/2016
00.00
SO 25 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD FRA JFK
P 06/03/2016
14:20
DL 212 I A471 4 LANE 79
K17 GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
TERM
APIS ON BOARD JFK NCE
P 06/03/2016
00:00
BA 175 I Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK LHR
P 06/02/2016
00:00
BA 175 I Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK LHR
P 06/02/2016
00:00
DL 212 I Name No
Name, No
APIS REGUES: JFK NCE
P 05/18/2016
00:00
DL 402 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD LHR JFK
P 02/14/2016
00:00
CP 5907 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
YVR LAX
P 02/13/2016
00:00
AA 504 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
YVR PH%
P 01/26/2016
16:36
AA 69 I A520 NTERMDKIOSK
4 GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK,
MIA
APIS ON BOARD MIA MAD
P 01/18/2016
00:00
AA 62 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD CDG MIA
P 12/13/2015
09:10
B6 622 7 A741 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MANUAL
ADD
CUSTOMS JFK NAS
P 12/13/2015
00:00
UA 1462 I Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
EWR NAS
P 12/10/2015
00:00
YX 4284 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
NAS MIA
PN 11/16/2015
00:00
VES 9606924 I Name No
Name, No
CRUISE
SHIP
PASSENGER 5201 7423
PN 11/13/2015
00:00
VES 9606924 o Name No
Name, No
CRUISE
SHIP
PASSENGER 8015 AV04
P 07/31/2015
19'02
UA 1081 I A105 GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK, EWR21
APIS ON BOARD EWR SJO
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT
ILastName First Name ¶DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date - Time Carder
Code
Carder
Num.
Iffa Site Insp Type Status Ref r Air . IMP
Loc Loc
P U7/29/2015
00:00
VA 1080 0 Name No Name
N
APIS ON BOARE SJO EWR
P 06/20/2015
15:41
AC 720 I A791 GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK Y
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LGA YYZ
P 06/20/2015
00:00
AC 718 I Name No Name
N
APIS ON BOARD LGA YYZ
P 06/19/2015
00:00
EV 4883 0 Name No Name
N
APIS ON BOARD YYZ DTW
P 04/26/2015
18:38
AA 109 I A273 14 GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK
K
APIS ON BOARD LAX LHR
P 04/26/2015
00:00
AA 135 I Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LAX LHR
P 04/25/2015
00:00
AA 109 I Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LAX LHR
P 04/16/2015
00:00
EK 204 0 Name No Name
N
APIS ON BOARD DXB JFK
P 04/13/2015
00:00
AA 1328 I Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
MIA SJO
P 04/12/2015
00:00
AA 2362 0 Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
SJO MIA
P 04/11/2015
00:00
AA 1137 0 Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
SJD DFW
P 01/26/2015
05:57
US 797 I A111 GLOBAL ENTRY
P
APIS ON BOARD PHL TLV
P 01/20/2015
00:00
AA 62 0 Name No Name
N
APIS ON BOARD CDG MIA
P 01/18/2015
00:00
AA 38 0 Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LHR MIA
P 12/12/2014
00:00
AA 1089 0 Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
BGI MIA
P 07/24/2014
15:30
AA 41 I A392 5 SIDE A K03
GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK T
APIS ON BOARD ORD CDG
P 07/24/2014
00:00
AA 45 I Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK CDG
P 07/14/2014
00:00
AA 120 0 Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
CDG JFK
P 07/13/2014
00:00
BA 202 0 Name No Name
N
APIS ON BOARD LHR BOS
P 06/26/2014
12:37
UA 246 I A338 MAIN TERM
GLOBAL ENTRY
KIOSK Y
APIS ON BOARD ORD YVR
P 06/24/2014
00:00
UA 56 0 Name No Name
N
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
YVR SFO
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: KIMBERLY MEDER Page d 10
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT Generated By: Page 7 d 10
(Last Name First Name DOB Doe
Type
Document
Number
DMe-TIme Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
10 Site Insp Type Status Ref Mr •'bsp
Lee Loc
P 65/21/2014 AA 45 1 Name No Name APIS NOT ON JFK CDG
00:00 N BOARD
P 05/18/2014 AA 44 0 Name No Name APIS N0T ON CDG JFK
00:00 N BOARD
P 01/26/2014 AA 141 I A473 8 LANE 22 APIS ON BOARD JFK LHR
23:00 K02 GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK
T
P 01/02/2014 CX 845 0 Name No Name APIS ON BOARD HKG JFK
00:00 N
P 01/01/2014 B6 1222 T A741 APIS ON BOARD JFK NAS
16:07
P 12/29/2013 MO 3464 0 Name No Name APIS NOT ON NAS MIA
00:00 N BOARD
P 11/26/2013 AA 63 I A520 NTERMO KIOSK APIS ON BOARD MIA CDG
13:54 3 GLOBAL
ENTRY KIOSK
P 11/21/2013 BA 8006 0 Name No Name APIS ON BOARD DRY JFK
00:00 N
P 10/15/2013 US 858 0 Name No Name APIS NOT ON NAS CLT
00:00 N BOARD
Total Number of Records 130
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 8 of 10
Codes %due
PVG PU DONG, SHANGHAI
NAS NASSAU INTL
LAX LOS ANGELES, CA INTL
MXP MILAN, MALPENSA
8015 BAHAMAS
CDG PARIS, CH. DE GAULLE
CLT DOUGLAS, CHARLOTTE
MHH MARSH HARBOUR
JFK JOHN F KENNEDY INTL
NRT NARITA, TOKYO
DFW DALLAS/FT WORTH INTL
MUC MUNICH AIRPORT, GERMANY
DOH DOHAIINTERNATIONAL, QATAR
MIA MIAMI INTL, FL
BGI BARBADOS, GRANTLEY ADAMS INTL
HKG HONG KONG
AMS AMSTERDAM-SCHIPHOL
WA LA GUARDIA
HOS BOSTON / LOGAN INTL
BCN BARCELONA
DX8 DUBAIIINTL, U. A. EMIRATES
POP PUERTO PLATA, LA UNION
NCE COTE D'AZUR
MAD MADRID, BARAJAS
FCO ROME, FIUMICINO
GVA GENEVA, SWITZERLAND
KHPN KHPN
VCE MARCO POLO
TAPA TAPA
YYZ TORONTO, PEARSON INTERNATIONAL
ORD O'HARE INTERNATIONAL
MEX MEXICO CITY, JUAREZ INTERNATIONAL
5201 MIAMI
DTN DETROIT INTL / WAYNE COUNTY
FLL FORT LAUDERDALE, FL
7423 NASSAU
MYNN MYNN
SJD LOS CABOS
ORD QUERETARO, QU, MEXICO
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 9 of 10
Codes Value
YVR VANCOUVER INTL
PHL PHILADELPHIA
LHR LONDON / HEATHROW INTL
ORY PARIS, ORLY
KNIA KMIA
SJO SAN JOSE, JUAN SANTAMARIA INTL
SFO SAN FRANCISCO INTL AIRPORT
TLV BEN GURION INTL
EWR NEWARK INTERNATIONAL
PHX SKY HARBOR INTL, PHOENIX
MOT MOT
AVO4 UNKNOWN
FRA FRANKFURT INT'L
ATH HELLINIKON, ATHENS
LIS LISBON, LISBOA
PEK BEIJING CAPITAL INTERNATIONAL
KOPF KOPF
P
PN
P - PASSPORT
PN - PASSPORT
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
08/29/2019 12:07 EDT
Calm law W
AS24 AS24 - CBP-MIAMI, AIRPORT CNTRL TERML
A338 A338 - CBP-VANCOUVER, INTL APT PRE -CL
A1OS A1OS - NEWARK, INTL AP TERMINAL C
AS20 AS20 - CEP -MIAMI, AIRPORT N TERMINAL
A102 A102 - CEP-WESTCHESTER, COUNTY APT
A741 A741 - CBP-NASSAU, BAHAMAS PRECLEAR
A103 A103 - CBP-NEWARK, INTL AIR TERM B
A111 A111 - CBP-PHILADELPHIA, INTL AIRPORT
A472 A472 - NEN YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 7
A791 A791 - TORONTO CD, PEARSON, TERM 1
A473 A473 - NEN YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 8
A470 A470 - NEN YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM SI
A152 A152 - CBP-CHARLOTTE, DOUGLAS AIRPORT
A471 A471 - NEN YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 4
A273 A273 - LOS ANGELES, BRADLEY AP LAX
A392 A392 - CBP-CHICAGO, OHARE AIRPORT
AS2G AS2G - CBP-MIAMI, AIRPORT SO TERMINAL
AS2B AS2B - MIAMI, AIRPORT, GEN AVIATION
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 70 of 10
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
TACTICAL INTELLIGENCE REPORT
FBI New York
1 October 2019
31E-NY-3027571, ID-13

(U) LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE: The information marked (U//LES) in this document is the property of the
Federal Bureau of Investigation and may be distributed within the federal government (and its contractors). U.S.
intelligence. law enforcement. public safety or protection officials. and individuals with a need to know. Distribution
beyond these entities without FBI authorization is prohibited. Precautions should be taken to ensure this information
is stored and/or destroyed in a manner that precludes unauthorized access. Information bearing the LES caveat may
not be used in legal proceedings without first receiving authorization from the originating agency. Recipients are
prohibited from subsequently posting the information marked LES on a website on an unclassified network without
first obtaining FBI approval.
THE INFORMATION LV THIS DOCUMENT MAY NOT BE UPLOADED TO ANY DATABASES, USED FOR
ANY PURPOSES, OR DISSEMINATED TO ANY OTHER RECIPIENT WITHOUT THE ADVANCED
AUTHORIZATION OF ITIE FBL THIS PRODUCT EXPRESSES THE PERSPECTIVE OF THIS OFFICE AND
MAY NOT BE REFLECTIVE OF THE NATIONAL PERSPECTIVE OF THE FBL

(U) Travel Records Regarding a Reported Associate of
Jeffrey Epstein
(U//LES) FBI New York C-20 was contacted by the Southern District of New York regarding
several victims who were sexually abused by Jeffrey Epstein in the mid 2000s. Epstein invited
minors into his residences, and paid them to provide massages to him which turned sexual in
nature, and wanted the minors to bring other minors to massage him. Epstein would also have an
assistant in New York set up appointments for minors to go to Epstein's other residences outside
of New York [REF: 31E-NY-3027571, Serial 1, 6 December 2018 .On 22 March 2019 FBI New
York received reporting that an individual idenitifed as was like a live-in
for Epstein. The reporting stated showed a victim ow to
[REF: 31E-NY-3027571, Serial 16, 17 Apn 2
(U//FOUO) Biographical Information

• (U) Name:
• (U) Alias:
• (U) DOB:
• (U) SSN:
• (U) Address:
(U//LES) Based upon this information, FBI New York Squad C-20 requested FBI New York
Intelligence Division (New York-ID-13) conduct research and analysis to identify travel
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASIFIEDHLAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
Template Effective 10-1-2018
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
information regarding This Tactical Intelligence Report addresses FBI New York's
Band II threat — Violent  Against Children and Band fig threat — Human Trafficking.
(U)

• (U//FOUO As of 29 August 2019, searches in TECS for the name
DOB: for travel status identifiedgn to be in "runty. MP
travel recur or occurred on on an inbound fli t from Nassau
International in t e amas to Dous.l arlotte in North Carolina. US
Passport# was issued and expired on

• (U//FOUO) As of 28 August 2019 a Silent Hit was put on
variations) to notify of any international travel.
(to include name
• (U//FOUO As of 12 September 2019 searches in TECS identified a current US Passport
fora DOB:-. US PP was issued on and
expires on
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical lotelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
8/21/2019 identified 119 travel records between 3/30/2001 and 5/11.11e were 29 records
(INFOUO) As of 21 August 2019 searches in TECS for the name from 1/1/2000 to
identified with flying on Jeffrey Epstein's airplane with the tag number 9097E and 908M.
Below are the 1 t records on Epstein's airplane.
Number
Line
Name Passport Date Carrier
Number
Direction Arrival Departure
1 5/13/2010 N909J Inbound C.E.
Kin
Not listed
2 3/29/2010 N909J Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
3/5/2019 N909 Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
2/16/2010 N909J Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
2/5/2010 N909 Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
1/15/2010 N909J Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
3/7/2009 909JE Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
5/17/2008 909JG Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
4/29/2008 9097E Inbound Teterboro Not listed
10 4/15/2018 909VE Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
I I 3/5/2008 9097E Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
12 2/24/2008 N909J Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
9/2/2007 9097E Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
14 12/23/2006 N908 Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
1 5 10/16/2006 9097E Inbound Teterboro Not listed
16 11/20/2005 N908J Inbound C.E.
Kin
Not listed
17 2/21/2019 N908JE Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
18 1/14/2005 9087E Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
FBI INTERNAL USE. ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Taaicallotelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
Number
Line
Name Passport Date Carrier
Number
Direction Arrival Departure
19 1/1/2005 909JE Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
20 Not listed 12/29/2004 909JE Inbound C.E.
King
Not listed
21 10/16/2004 908JE Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
22 10/2/2004 908JE Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
23 8/25/2004 9087E Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
24 8/6/2004 908JE Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
25 7/22/2004 9087E Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
26 5/14/2004 9081E Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
27 3/19/2001 909JE Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
28 3/23/2003 909JE Inbound West
Palm
Beach
Not listed
29 Not listed 4/18/2002 9087E inbound Not listed Not listed
(U//FOUO) (Analyst Note: Flight records are attached as a 1A document).
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical lotelligeoce Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
(U//FOUO) As of 29 August 2019 searches in TECS for the name from 1/1/2013
to 8/28/2019 identified 130 travel records between 10/15/2013 an 2 1 . e ow are the top
ten most recent flight records:
Number
Line
Name Passport Date Carrier
Number
Direction Arrival Departure
1 Not listed 8/8/2019 859 Inbound Douglas.
Charlotte
Nassau
Intl
2 5/29/2019 859 Inbound Douglas,
Charlotte
Nassau
Intl
3 5/24/2019 494 Outbound Nassau Intl John F
Kennedy
Intl
4 Not listed 5/24/2019 4560 Outbound Nassau Intl Miami.
Intl
5 Not listed 5/23/2019 893 Outbound Nassau Intl Douglas,
Charlotte
6 Not listed 4/26/2019 795 Inbound Los, Angeles, CA
Intl
Toronto
Pearson
Intl
7 4/25/2019 2676 Outbound Toronto Pearson
Intl
Miami.
Intl
8 4/17/2019 223 Inbound Miami, Intl Lisbon,
Lisboa
9 4/17/2019 206 Inbound Miami. Intl Lisbon.
Lisboa
10 4/8/2019 39 Outbound London/Heathrow
Intl
Miami.
Intl
(U//FOUO) (Analyst Note: Flight records are attached as a IA document).
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Investigative/Intelligence Gaps
• (U) Gap 1: Did
• (U) Gap 2: Did
(U) Scope Note
continue contact with Jeffrey Epstein after 2010?
travel to Jeffrey Epstein's island after 2010?

(U) Information in this report was derived from numerous open-source, secure and classified
systems to include: Comprehensive Criminal History (CCH), Interstate Identification Index and
National Crime Information Center (DYNCIC), and New York Driver's Licenses via eJustice
NY; New York Police Department (NYPD); Administration for Children Services (ACS); DIVS;
Sentinel; Treasury Enforcement Communications System (TECS); Accurint; Google.com; and
social media accounts. All the open-source, secure, and classified information was last collected
between 21 August 2019 and 12 September 2019, and all collection is current as of 12
September 2019.
(U) Consumers: SSfi
SA
Det
(U) Approval: SIA
(U) This tactical intelligence report was prepared by the New York Field Office of the FBI. Comments and queries
may be addressed to the New York Intelligence Division at
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
50D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS Serial 4
FD-I036 (Rev. 10-16-2009) UNCLASSIFIED//LES
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Import Form
Form Type: IntelProd-TIR - Tactical Intelligence
Report
Title: (U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Ghislaine Maxwell
Approved By: SIA
Drafted Sy:
Case ID #: 31E -NY -3027571- (U) EPSTEIN,
INTELPRODS TRAFFICKING
31E -NY -3027571 (U) EPSTEIN,
TRAFFICKING
Date: 10/18/2019
JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
BANK SECRECY ACT INFORMATION
This document contains information that was collected and disseminated under
provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) and U.S. Department of the Treasury
regulations implementing the BSA. The information is sensitive in nature and is
to be treated accordingly. The information may be used only for a purpose
related to a criminal, tax, or regulatory investigation or proceeding, or in the
conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities to protect against
international terrorism, or for a national security matter. The information
cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed, or transmitted without
prior approval of the Director of the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network or an
authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under the BSA must be
treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations
of possible criminal activity, akin to confidential informant tips. Such
reports, or the fact they have been filed, may not be disclosed by a government
employee to any person involved in the transaction, other than as necessary to
fulfill the official duties of the government employee. Unauthorized release of
information collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil penalties.
Synopsis: (U//FOUO) This Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) details
tactical analysis regarding the identity of Ghislaine Maxwell a subject
in a child sex trafficking investigation.
.•
UNCLASSIFIED//LES
o ssier ile. 4.
•er., , :%.
c Ii9 *
4 %-- i 4,
.b.zz o scP
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
FBI New York, ID-13
18 October 2019
31E-NY-3027571

(U) LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE: The information marked (U//LES) in this document is the property of the
Federal Bureau of Investigation and may be distributed within the federal government (and its contractors). U.S.
intelligence, law enforcement, public safety or protection officials, and individuals with a need to know. Distribution
beyond these entities without FBI authorization is prohibited. Precautions should be taken to ensure this information
is stored and/or destroyed in a manner that precludes unauthorized access. Information bearing the LES caveat may
not be used in legal proceedings without first receiving authorization from the originating agency. Recipients are
prohibited from subsequently posting the information marked LES on a website on an unclassified network without
first obtaining FBI approval.
(U//FOUO) BANK SECRECY ACT (BSA) CAVEAT - Some of the enclosed Financial Database information was
collected and disseminated under provisions of the BSA and U.S. Department of the Treasury regulations
implementing the act (31 U.S.C. 5311, et seq.; 31 CFR Part 103). The information is sensitive in nature and is to be
treated accordingly. The information may be used only for a purpose related to a criminal, tax, or regulatory
investigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities to protect against
international terrorism. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed, or
transmitted without prior approval of the Secretary of the Treasury or his authorized delegate. Unauthorized release
of information collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.

(U) Research and Key Findings Regarding Ghislaine Maxwell, a Reported
Associate of Jeffrey Epstein
(U//LES) FBI New York C-20 was contacted by the Southern District of New York regarding
several victims who were reportedly sexually abused by Jeffrey Epstein in the mid-2000s.
According to the allegations, Epstein invited minors into his residences and paid them to provide
massages to him which turned sexual in nature, and wanted the minors to bring other minors to
massage him. Ghislaine Maxwell worked for Epstein as the estate manager prior to
taking over the role [REF: 31E-NY-3027571, Serial 289, 16 September 2019]. On
FBI New York received reporting that an individual identified as Ghislaine Maxwell took over
running Epstein's house sometime in 1993 and was observed approaching young females who
would then visit Epstein's residence [REF: 31E-NY-3027571, Serial 188, 13 July 2019].
(U//FOUO) Biographical Information

• (U) Name: Ghislaine Maxwell
• (U) DOB:
• (U) SSN:
• (U) Address: Boston, MA 02114
(U//LES) Based upon this information, FBI New York Squad C-20 requested FBI New York
Intelligence Division (New York-ID-13) conduct research and analysis to identify information
regarding Ghislaine Maxwell, her possible address, and pedigree data. This Tactical Intelligence
Report addresses FBI New York's Band II threat — Violent Crimes Against Children and Band
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY20 Tactical Intelligence Report
Template Effective 10-1-2019
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
III threat — Human Trafficking.
(U) Ghislaine Maxwell

• (U//FOLIO 1.s of 1 October 2019, searches in DIVS for the name Ghislaine Maxwell,
DOB: returned the following information from a credible financial source.
o (U//FOUO) Ghislaine Maxwell was referenced in a financial document dated
8/7/2019 for her association to the entity: TerraMar Project Inc and an inability to
identify the purpose and legitimacy of payments made in connection to TerraMar.
The amount involved totaled $43,512 between 12/30/2016-10/11/2016 and listed
the email as being associated to Maxwell.
o (U//FOUO) Ghislaine Maxwell was referenced in a financial document dated
9/11/2019 in the amount of $56,919,231.00 as 1 of 51 subjects referenced
regarding 543 transactions between 10/17/2003-7/24/2019 with regards to the
media allegations involving sex trafficking of minors and allegations Epstein
misappropriated funds while employed as a money manager.
o (U//FOUO) Ghislaine Maxwell was referenced in a financial document dated
8/13/2019 in the amount of $200,979,535.93 as 1 of 35 subjects referenced
regarding 469 transactions between 10/1/2003-5/29/2019 with regards to the
negative media involving alleged sex trafficking of minors and allegations Epstein
misappropriated funds while em lo ed as a mone manager. Tel hones listed
include: and . Email
address ste or axwe

• //FOUO As of 1 October 2019, searches in DIVS for name Ghislaine Maxwell, DOB:
returned several travel records and foreign bank accounts.

• (U//FOUO) (Analyst Note: Additional travel records will be referenced in a separate
tactical intelligent report).

• (U//FOUO) As of 1 October 2019, searches in DIVS for telephone number
returned the following Experian record:

• (U) Name: Ghislaine Maxwell
• (U) Address:
• (U) Transaction Date: 6/19/2018
Boston, MA 02114
• (U//FOUO) As of 1 October 2019, searches in DIVS for telephone number
retuned the following Experian record:

• (U) Name:
• (U) Address: ew ork, NY 10007
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

• (U) Transaction Date: 4/11/2016
• (U//FOUO As of 19 September 2019, searches in eJustice/NCIC for Ghislaine Maxwell,
DOB: returned did not returned a criminal record. However, there is an
application record from the NYCPD Licensing Division, dated on 2/21/2006 for a Pistol
Permit.

• (IN/FOUO) As of 8 October 2019 a r uest to NYPD for searches in NYPD databases
for Ghislaine Maxwell, DOB: did not return a criminal record. However, a
record indicated Maxwell sol er pisto as detailed below:

• (IN/FOUO) Application Date:
o (U//FOUO) Application Info #:
• (U//FOUO) Name: Ghislaine Maxwell
• (INFOUO) Address: New York, NY 10021
o (U//FOUO) License Permit Detai

• (U/NOUO) Type: Residence Premises
• (U/NOUO) Status: Cancelled
• (U//FOUO) Permit Number:
o (U//FOUO) Gun Purchase:

• (IN/FOUO) Type: Pistol, semiautomatic
• (U//FOUO) Model: 19
• (U//FOUO) Caliber: 9MM
o (U//FOUO) Application Details:

• (U//FOUO) Person:
• (U//FOUO) Address Port Washington, New York
• (U//FOUO) Telephone:
o (U/NOUO) Permit Details:

• (U//FOUO) Reason: Moved out of city or state
• (U//FOUO) Details: Licensee moved to Florida
• (U//FOUO As of 23 August 2019, searches in TECS for the name Ghislaine Maxwell,
DOB: for travel status identified Ghislaine Maxwell to be in the country. The
last trave reco or Ghislaine Maxwell occurred on 6/11/2019 on an inbound flight from
London to Boston International.

• (U//FOUO) As of 27 August 2019 a Silent Hit was put on Ghislaine Maxwell to notify of
any international travel.

• (U//FOUO) As of 23 September 2019 searches in TECS identified a current US Pas rt
for Ghislaine Maxwell DOB: . US PP was issued on
and expires on . Maxwell also has citizenship in France and the UK.
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) PP Photo
(U) Ghislaine Maxwell

• (UHFOUO) According to Accurint, as of 18 September 2019 searches for the name
Ghislaine Maxwell and DOB: returned the following information:

• (U) Name: Ghislaine Maxwell
• (U) DOB:
• (U) SSN:
• (U) Address: Boston, MA 02114 (May 2018-
Aug 2019)

• (U) Address 2: Boston, MA 02114 (Sept 2018)
• (U) Address 3: New York, NY 10065 (Sept 2007-June
2018)

• (U) Telephone:
• (U) Email Addresses:

(U) As of 2 October 2019 open source searches for the telephone number
identified the following accounts:

• (U) Google
o (U) User B3:
o (U) No additional information
• (U) WhatsApp
o (U) No additional information

(U) As of 2 October 2019 open source searches for the email address
identified the following accounts:
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Iotelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

• (U) LinkedIn
o (U) Full Name:
o (U) No additionl iff ation
• (U) Apple
o (U) No additional information

• (U) Instagram
o (U) No additional information
• (U) Twitter
o (U) No additional intonation

(U) As of 2 October 2019 open source searches for the email address
identified the following accounts:

• (U) Google
o (U) User ID:I
o (U) No additional information
• (U) Instagram
o (U) No additional information
• (U) Apple
o (U) No additional information
As of 2 October 2019 o n source searches for the telephone numbers:
and returned negative results.

(U) As of 2-3 October 2019, additional open source searches identified the following articles:
(U) Article 1: Vanityfair.com: "They're Nothing, These Girls": Unraveling the Mystery of
Ghislaine Maxwell, Epstein's Enabler
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Itstelhgence Repot
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 1:
a IMMIll•14 I V E
"THEY'RE NOTHING, THESE GIRLS":
UNRAVELING THE MYSTERY OF
GHISLAINE MAXWELL, EPSTEIN'S
ENABLER
An nowt pan kw hen nnmorl tnlan rah Ran Cannunnynaand In- nanny la Mel new No own bra akin} nl eiWinenstlyr -

(U) Photo 2:
(- 4 C
vanoriPaireomfrernoivene rune marvel' epstewenabeir
BVTIPIR -H I V E
Ur Limlpnl. 6n l'  .1t.nr.11i life is ilk litna.piewilik. lurid la own) lino. iilloruku lira larriolaruitpiraus thugs.
IV Wein* 0-1140-ItUiD45
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTEFtNALIN
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 3:
1 sit possible prosecutors have lost track of Ghlslaine Max-well, Jeffrey
Epstein's alleged co-conspirator in his pedophile ring? For the past few
weeks, rumors have circulated that she's -too pounds and living in Florida. or
that she's living the high life in London or the Continent, but according to the
Washington Post. authorities are having a hard time locating her. Those who know
her say that it's possible she is as much of a Houdini as Epstein. Both of them liked
having secrets, and the way those secrets kept people off balance. "Jeffrey always
wanted to give the impression that he was an international man of mystery —.1
control everyone and everything. I collect people. I own people. I can damage
people. — says an ex-girlfriend.

(U) Photo 4:
As part of Epstein's original plea deal, negotiated with Alexander Acosta, the
others implicated were also given immunity from prosecution. s‘bich is partly why
victims like pursued her and others in civil courts. But
Epstein's death has not stopped the current investigation. "We remain committed to
standing for you." Geoffrey Berman, U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of
New York, wrote in a statement after Epstein's death. -and our investigation of the
conduct charged in the Indictment —which included a conspiracy count —remains
ongoing." There were rumors on Monday afternoon that indictments of five people
were imminent.
The nature of the relationship between Epstein and Maxwell, the favorite daughter
of embezzling press baron Robert Maxwell. who died when he fell or was pushed
from his yacht. the Lady Ghislaine. is not well known. Multiple victims claim she
was both part of the sex trafficking ring. often bringing girls to Epstein. and a sexual
participant. But Epstein told of-age women he courted that Maxwell was a former
girlfriend fallen on hard times. and that he had taken it upon himself to maintain
her position in society. -Ghislaine floated in and out of the house with the keys. and
even though Jeffrey told me they didn't have a sexual relationship. she'd drop under
her breath that she was sleeping in his bed from time to time. - says an ex-girlfriend.
Another woman in Maxwell's orbit says she used to joke about keeping herself rail
thin because Epstein liked thin girls. Maxwell. whose father was Jewish, liked to
shock. "She said. 'I do it the way Nazis did it with the Jews. the Auschwitz diet. I just
don't eat. —
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 5:
INTIFAIR H I VE
The sinister depravity of Epstein's sexual world. and Maxwell's role in enabling it.
was mostly kept hidden. The two were fixtures on a certain rarefied Manhattan
circuit. Epstein was as a practical joker who liked messing with people he regarded
as lower on the food chain. A prominent 19905 Sports Illustrated model who dated
Epstein describes meeting Donald Trump at one of Trumps parties in the
penthouse of the Plaza Hotel back then. and Trump goading Epstein to get her
number. "Jeffrey said he wouldn't give it to him and he had to get it from me," she
says. She finally gave it to him on another occasion. but he lost the number. 'Trump
called Jeffrey trying to get it again. saying 'She gave it to me! You know she gave it
to me! You can give it to me now!' but Jeffrey wouldn't do it." She laughs. "Donald
was such a joke to all of the models back then —we all knew he was bankrupt and
had no game. I remember Jeffrey once saying he was going to be late to pick me up
because he had to drop off food for Donald —he was at home cning under the
covers."
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Repot
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
(U) Photo 6:
IANITYFAIR H I VE
Maxwell seemed to adore Epstein, who was a grinning grifter with the gift of gab,
and always had a story• to tell, even about his home. "He was obsessed with jewelry
boxes and very detailed, ornate designs—he told me the Pope actually gave him
artisans who teamed up with this one jewelry-box maker from Paris to make his
dining room look like a giant version of the inside of a Parisian jewelry box," says an
ex-girlfriend. Epstein also said that his friend Lynn Forester, now married to
billionaire Evelyn de Rothschild, needed his financial help during her 1990s
divorce from politician Andrew Stein, and that he had graciously floated her.
("10096 false," says a spokesperson for Forester.) He claimed that the producers of
The Apprentice had first approached him to make a show about a reclusive
billionaire living an extravagant life, but he said no, and then introduced them to
Trump. (A spokesperson for Mark Burnett denies this).
On the weekends in the mos, Maxwell would have her Rollerblades FedExed to
Epstein's island in the Caribbean, and said she got her helicopter's license so she
could transport anyone she liked without pilots knowing who they were. Maxwell
also said the island had been completely wired for video: the friend thought that she
and Epstein were videotaping everyone on the island as an insurance policy, as
blackmail. A source close to Maxwell says she spoke glibly and confidently about
getting girls to sexually service Epstein, saying this was simply what he wanted, and
describing the way she'd drive around to spas and trailer parks in Florida to recruit
them. She would claim she had a phone job for them, "and you'll make lots of
money, meet everyone, and I'll change your life." The source continues, "Ghislaine
was in love with Jeffrey the way she was in love with her father. She always thought
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 7:
was in love with Jeffrey the way she was in love with her father. She always thought
if she just did one more thing for him, to please him, he would many her."
Maxwell had one other thing to tell this woman: "When I asked what she thought of
the underage girls, she looked at me and said, `they're nothing. these girls. They are
trash.'"

(F) Investigative/Intelligence Gaps

• (U) Gap 1: Did Ghislaine Maxwell entice minors to engage in sexual encounters with
adult males, if so, what means did she use to recruit them?
• (U) Gap 2: What was the extent of the relationship between Ghislaine Maxwell and
Jeffrey Epstein?
• (U) Gap 4: Did Ghislaine Maxwell participate in sexual activity involving Epstein and
minor aged children?

(U) Scope Note
(U) Information in this report was derived from numerous open-source, secure and classified
systems to include: Comprehensive Criminal History (CCH), Interstate Identification Index and
National Crime Information Center (II0NCIC), and New York Driver's Licenses via eJustice
NY; New York Police Department (NYPD); Administration for Children Services (ACS); DNS;
Sentinel; Treasury Enforcement Communications System (TECS); Accurint; Google.com; and
social media accounts. All the open-source, secure, and classified information was last collected
between 23 August 2019 and 8 October 2019, and all collection is current as of 8 October 2019.

(U) Consumers: SS
SA
Det.
(U) Approval: SIA1
(U) FBI New York Field Office prepared this Tactical Intelligence Report. Please address comments and queries to
the New York Intelligence Division at 1-212-384-1000.
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
50D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS Serial 5
FD-1036 (Rcv. 10-16-2009) UNCLASSIFIED//LES
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Import Form
Form Type: IntelProd-TIR - Tactical Intelligence
Report
Date: 10/18/2019
Title:(U//FOU0) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records for
Ghislaine Maxwell
Approved By: SIA
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-NY-3027571-
INTELPRODS
31E-NY-3027571

(U) EPSTEIN,
TRAFFICKING
(U) EPSTEIN,
TRAFFICKING
JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
Synopsis: (U//FOUO) This Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) details
tactical analysis regarding travel information for Ghislaine Maxwell a
subject in a child sex trafficking investigation.
Enclosure(s):
1. (U//FOLIO)
2. (0//FOU0)
3. (U//FOLIO)
.•
Enclosed are the following items:
Ghislaine Maxwell Travel
UK citizenship record
French citizenship record
UNCLASSIFIED//LES
09/23/201914:20 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page I of 14
Loot Name Flit Name DOB Doc
T • t
Document
Number
Date -Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Mum.
U0 Site Imp Type Status Rel An
Loc
Dap
Loc
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
06/11/2019
21:42
11S 1 A041 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
APIS ON BOARD BOS LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
MARION
P 06/02/2019
00:00
212 0 APIS ON BOARD LHR BOS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 12/27/2018
17:08
8 I A041 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
APIS ON BOARD BOS NRT
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 12/17/2018
00:00
7 0 APIS ON BOARD NRT BOS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
MARION
P 08/29/2018
00:00
743 I APIS NOT ON
BOARD
BOS DOH
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 08/15/2018
12:05
59 I A041 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
APIS ON BOARD BOS LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 08/01/2018
00:00
58 0 APIS ON BOARD LHR BOS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 05/30/2018
13:20
213 I A041 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
APIS ON BOARD BOS LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
MARION
P 05/21/2018
00:00
744 0 APIS ON BOARD DOH BOS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 11/28/2017
11:46
59 I A041 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
APIS ON BOARD BOS LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 11/21/2017
00:00
12 0 APIS ON BOARD LHR BOS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 09/09/2017
12:32
59 I A041 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
APIS ON BOARD BOS LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE MAR
i P 08/22/2017
00:00
58 0 Name No
Name No
APIS ON BOARD LHR BOS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/08/2017
2L:32
11 I A041 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
APIS ON BOARD BOS LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 01/02/2017
00:00
APIS ON BOARD LHR BOS
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
09/23/2019 14:20 EDT Generated By: Page 2 of 14
Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date -Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
10 Site Insp Type Status Ref Ir. Ali
Loc
Dep
Loc
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/20/2016 213 I A041 APC APIS OS &JAKE BOS LHR
NOELLE 13:42 AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/13/2016 212 o Name No APIS ON BOARD LHR BOS
NOELLE 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/18/2016 11 I A041 APC APIS ON BOARD BOS LHR
NOELLE 15:57 AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/25/2016 12 0 Name No APIS ON BOARD LHR BOS
NOELLE 00:00 Name No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/27/2015 I L382 VEHICLE
NOELLE 15:30
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/28/2015 I A041 APC APIS ON BOARD BOS LHR
NOELLE 13:26 AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, BOS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE O6/18/2015 112 o Name No APIS ON BOARD LHR JFK
NOELLE 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 07/02/2015 9 I A471 APC APIS ON BOARD JFK LHR
NOELLE 19:07 AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/15/2015 474 o Name No APIS ON BOARD VCE JFK
00:00 Name No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/29/2015 4363 I A741 APC APIS ON BOARD MIA NAS
11:15 AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, NAS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/27/2015 4270 o Name No APIS NOT ON NAS MIA
00:00 Name, No BOARD
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/19/2014 1048 I A471 APIS PASSENGER JFK LTN
04:57
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/19/2014 193 I Name No APIS NOT ON DFM LHR
00:00 Name No BOARD
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/15/2014 214 o Name No APIS ON BOARD LHR BOS
NOELLE 00:00 Name No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/09/2014 7462 I A792 APC APIS ON BOARD LGA YUL
NOELLE 17:35 AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL YUL
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/07/2014 5089 o Name No APIS ON BOARD YUL LGA
00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/02/2014 615 I A472 APIS ON BOARD JFK KEF
NOELLE 18:22
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/29/2014 630 o Name No APIS ON BOARD KEF BOS
NOELLE 00:00 Name, No
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
09/23/201914:20 EDT
Latham, FIrstl4min DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date -Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
10 Site Insp Type Status A n .
Loc
Dip
Loc
Ref lir
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P k.9/01/2014
20:22
215 1. A041 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, SOS
APIS OS 30/tRE BOS LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE MAP
P 07/30/2014
00:00
292 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD LAIR IAD
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 01/04/2014
26:37
45 I A471 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, JFK
APIS ON BOARD JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 12/27/2013
00:00
5 I Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
MIA LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 12/27/2013
00:00
1487 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
SXM JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 12/26/2013
00:00
175 I Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 12/09/2013
00:00
208 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD LHR MIA
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 11/09/2013
16:00
45 I A471 APC
AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL JFK
APIS ON BOARD JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 10/30/2013
00:00
10 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS REQUEST LAIR JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/29/2013
00:00
22 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LAIR IAD
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 10/14/2013
19.30
617 I A472 APIS ON BOARD JFK KEF
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 10/09/2013
00:00
614 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD KEF JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 09/02/2013
12:16
3 : A471 APIS ON BOARD JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 07/18/2013
00:00
46 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD LHR JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 06/22/2013
12:33
7732 : A795 APIS ON BOARD LGA YOW
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 06/21/2013
00:00
7733 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD YON LGA
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 06/19/2013
12:36
25 : A471 APIS NOT ON
BOARD
JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 06/19/2013
00:00
3 = Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 06/03/2013
00:00
10 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD LHR JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 06/01/2013
00:00
,Name,
Name No
No
APIS NOT ON
BOARD
LHR JFK
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 3 d 14
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
09/23/2019 14:20 EDT Generated By: Page 401 14
Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date - Time Carder
Code
Carrier
Num.
1 O Site Insp Typo Status Ref Ell
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P k.4/05/20Is 183 I A4,- APIS JFK LHR
NOELLE 22:51
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/22/2013 22 0 Name No APIS LHR IAD
NOELLE 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/14/2013 177 Name No APIS JFK LHR
NOELLE MAP 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 02/08/2013 687 0 Name No APIS SXM NIA
00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/07/2013 9103 I A151 APIS ILM SXM
14:52
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/02/2013 2144 I A528 Name No APIS MIA SXM
00.00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 12/22/2012 177 I AB52 Name No APIS JFK LHR
NOELLE MAP 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 11/16/2012 845 0 Name No APIS HKG JFK
00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 11/15/2012 841 0 Name No APIS HKG JFK
00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 11/14/2012 10 0 Name No APIS LHR JFK
NOELLE 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 10/03/2012 1031 I A27G APIS LAX LIN
NOELLE 03:52
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/03/2012 1031 I A27F Name No APIS LAX LIN
NOELLE 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/03/2012 17 I ABSJ Name No APIS EBB LHR
NOELLE 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/02/2012 1031 I A27F Name No APIS LAX LIN
NOELLE 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 09/28/2012 78 0 Name No APIS LHR DEW
00.00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 09/28/2012 738 0 Name No APIS YYZ SFO
NOELLE 00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 09/03/2012 83 I AB52 Name No APIS JFK NCE
00.00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/30/2012 MFALC I APIS BGR XXX
13.22
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/30/2012 MFALC I Name No APIS TEB XXX
00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/15/2012 8057 0 Name No APIS GIG MIA
00.00 Name No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 05/29/2012 45 I A471 APIS JFK LHR
16:35
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 05/21/2012 172 0 Name No APIS LHR JFK
00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/12/2012 7 0 Name No APIS CDG JFK
CO:00 Name No
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
09/231201914:20 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 5 of 14
Last Name First Name DOB
ll
Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date - Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
NO Site Insp Type Status Ref An
Loc
Dep
Lee
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/05/2012
00:00
651 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS BGI MIA
MAXWELL CHISLAINE
NOBLLB
P 01/05/2012
18:26
5239 I A461 APIS TEE DAV
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/05/2012
00:00
2192 I ABET Name No
Name, No
APIS MIA PIT
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 12/28/2011
00:00
687 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS SXN MIA
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOEL
P 12/21/2011
18:06
219 I A337 APIS ■ DEN LER
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOBLLB
P 12/09/2011
00:00
286 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS LER SFO
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/29/2011
00:00
268 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS TLV JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/28/2011
18:55
1078 I A524 APIS NIA BGI
MAXWELL GRISLAINE
NOELLE
P 07/27/2011
00:00
182 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS
■
LER JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 05/08/2011
00:00
N2767 I Name No
Name, No
APIS BGR XXX
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 05/07/2011
00:00
N2767 I Name No
Name, No
APIS FIGR XXX
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/29/2011
00:00
N2767 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS XXX NIPQ
MAXWELL CHISLAINE P 04/26/2011
19:04
1078 I 7524 APIS MIA BGI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 04/20/2011
00:00
871 O Name No
Name, No
APIS BGI JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/28/2011
13:10
3 I A471 APIS JFK LER
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 02/14/2011
16:14
45 I A471 APIS JFK LER
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOBLLB
P 02/14/2011
00:00
3 I AB52 Name No
Name, No
APIS JFK LER
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 02/09/2011
00:00
46 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS LER JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 11/06/2010
21:29
179 I A472 APIS JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/29/2010
00:00
262 O Nams No
Name, No
APIS ANN JFK
MAXWELL GRISLAINE P 10/01/2010
15:43
N923CL I APIS TEE XXX
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 10/01/2010
14:09
923CL I A1OD AIRLINE
(NOT
API
TEB
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
09/23/2019 14:20 EDT Generated By: Page 6 01 14
Last Name First Name DOB Doc Document Date - Time Carrier Carrier 1 O Site Insp Type Status Ref An Dap
Type Number Code Num. Loc Lot
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/01/2010 N923CL I Name No APIS TEB XXX
00:00 Name, No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 09/28/2010 N923CL 0 Name No APIS XXX TEB
00.00 Name No
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/29/2010 183 I A472 APIS JFK LHR
NOELLE 20.11
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/29/2010 115 I AB52 Name No Name APIS JFK LHR
NOELLE 00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/01/2010 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX TEB
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/26/2010 N17ND I APIS APA XXX
01.29
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/12/2010 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX TEB
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/11/2010 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX TEB
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/10/2010 N17ND I Name No Name APIS FRG XXX
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/21/2010 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX TEB
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/12/2010 N17ND I APIS IAD XXX
11.54
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/11/2010 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX IAD
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/16/2010 N17ND I A276 AIRLINE PSP
22:06 (NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/16/2010 N17ND I Name No Name APIS PSP XXX
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/05/2010 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX SAN
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/21/2010 N17ND . ' APIS SAN XXX
18.46
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/20/2010 N17ND Name No Name APIS SAN XXX
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/16/2010 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX OPF
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/03/2010 N17ND = APIS TEB XXX
17.24
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/03/2010 17ND I AlOD AIRLINE TEB
17:13 (NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/03/2010 N17ND I Name No Name APIS HPN XXX
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/01/2010 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX SAN
00:00 N
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
09/23/2019 14:20 EDT Generated By: Page 701  14
Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date - Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
1:O Site Insp Typo Status Ref= An
Loa
Dip
lac
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 4 01/22/2010 .N. •, APIS TEB XXX
23:48
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/22/2010 NI •,. AIRLINE TEB
NOELLE 23:43 (NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/22/2010 N17ND I Name No Name APIS HPN XXX
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/19/2010 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX KSA
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/07/2010 N17ND = APIS HPN XXX
21.23
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/06/2010 N17ND I Name No Name APIS HPN XXX
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 12/27/2009 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX KSA
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/14/2009 N17ND I APIS SAN XXX
17.20
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/08/2009 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX PAN
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/31/2009 N17ND I APIS HPN XXX
10.12
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/30/2009 N17ND Name No Name APIS HPN XXX
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/28/2009 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX KIA
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/13/2009 N17ND I Name No Name APIS SAN XXX
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/30/2009 N17ND I Name No Name APIS SAN XXX
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/19/2009 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX KSA
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/18/2009 269 I A273 I APIS LAX LHR
NOELLE 22.07
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/11/2009 278 0 Name No Name APIS LHR LAX
NOELLE 00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/08/2009 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX KOM
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/05/2009 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX KOS
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/28/2009 N17ND I Name No Name APIS SAN XXX
00.00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/15/2009 N17ND 0 Name No Name APIS XXX KSA
00:00 N
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 05/03/2009 N17ND I A262 AIRLINE TUS
NOELLE 12:37 (NOT
API)
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
09/23/201914:20 EDT Generated By: Page 8 01 14
Last Name First Nome DOB Doe
Type
Document
Number
Date - Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
1O Site Insp Typo Status Ref I Arr
Loc
Dip
We
MAXWELL GHISLAINENOE
LLE
66/12/2008
19:02
10 APIS JFK CDG
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE MAR
P 06/06/2008
00:00
112 0 No Name APIS LHR JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 000 06/02/2008
21:35
17 I AlUE AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
TEB
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/30/2008
10:26
428NT I A100 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
TEB
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/24/2008
18:31
428WT I A100 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
TEE
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/17/200?
09:53
614RD I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 08/22/200?
00:00
208 0 Name No Name
N
APIS LHR MIA
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/21/2007
13:23
1 I A471 APIS JFK STN
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/01/2007
16:41
UNKN I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
■
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 12/23/2006
10:19
N908 I A511 I AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
STT
MAXWELL GHISLAINE C 09/26/2006
14:21
2 I A5211 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MIA
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/28/2006
22:51
4 I A528 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MIA
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 05/28/2006
16:39
279 I A273 APIS LAX LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/02/2006
11:57
401NJ I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
STT
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 12/22/2005
14:22
491GM I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
STT
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE MAR
P 11/20/2005
00:00
268 0 Name No Name
N
APIS LHR LAX
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/17/2005
09:18
312P I A311 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
ANC
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE
P 07/04/2005
00:00
182 Name No Name
N
APIS LHR JFK
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
09/23/2019 14:20 EDT Generated By: Page 9 01 14
Last Name First Name ¶DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date - Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
I O Site Insp Type Status Ref
I
Mr
Loc
Dip
Lot
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/29/2005
11:56
401W3 1 A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/04/2005
16:51
1 I A492 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
SJU
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 05/29/2005
18:17
909JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 02/19/2005
20:13
909JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 02/12/2005
20:48
I A5211 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/02/2005
13:19
401NJ 1 A52i I AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/25/2004
17:42
908,1b = A523 I AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/18/2004
22:03
9 I A471 APIS JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/11/2004
00:00
46 0 Name No Name
N
APIS LHR JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE
NOELLE MAP
P 06/04/2004
00:00
174 0 Name No Name
N
APIS LHR JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 05/12/2004
21:10
8 I A477 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
JFK CDG
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 02/07/2004
14:43
207 I A520 0 APIS MIA LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/02/2004
18:03
1 I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 12/24/2003
17:52
909JE 1 A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 11/02/2003
00:00
23 0 Name No Name
N
APIS CDG JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/08/2003
19:09
115 I A472 APIS JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 09/30/2003
00:00
2 0 Name No Name
N
APIS LHR JFK
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 06/14/2003
20:29
909JE I A52.) I APIS PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 05/29/2003
17:43
1 I A472 APIS JFK LHR
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
09/23/2019 14:20 EDT Generated By: Page 0 of 14
Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date • Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
I 0 Site Insp Type Status R r
Loc
W
Loc
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/11/2003
00:45
1 I A523 I APIS PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 04/01/2003
14:38
49104 I A511 APIS STT
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 03/23/2003
21:43
909JE I A523 I APIS PBI
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 02/21/2003
09:33
1 I A471 APIS JFK LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 01/02/2003
00:00
615A T A491 Name No Name
N
APIS STT EIS
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 12/31/2002
00:00
222 T A491 Name No Name
N
APIS SBH STT
MAXWELL GHISLAINE A 08/30/2002
12:50
672 I A512 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/04/2002
19:00
283 I 2720 APIS LAX LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE A 04/18/2002
17:57
908JE I A523 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE A 03/18/2002
09:45
5 I A511 I
AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE A 01/13/2002
20:59
1 I A523 I
AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE A 12/23/2001
16:21
I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 10/01/2001
18:20
209 I 5206 I
APIS MIA LHR
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 08/01/2001
18:31
6 I 4701 APIS JFK CDG
MAXWELL GHISLAINE A 07/01/2001
15:04
1 I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE A 06/29/2001
00:36
909 I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE A 02/21/2001
14:02
672 I A511 AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE A 09/05/2000
18:15
115 I A472 I AIRLINE
(NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE P 07/17/2000
_7:59
115 I 4701 I APIS JFK LHR
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
09/23/2019 14:20 EDT Generated By: Page 1 of 14
Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date - Time Carrier
Code
Carrier
Num.
1:0 Site Insp Type Status Ref
I
Mr
Loc
Dap
Lot
MAXWELL 06/23/2000 1 I 4701 APIS JFK LHR
09:22
MAXWELL 04/16/2000 733TA I A523 AIRLINE
20:59 (NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 03/09/2000 175 I 4701 APIS JFK LHR
13:28
MAXWELL GHISLAINE 02/05/2000 20700 2 A611 AIRLINE
15:34 (NOT
API)
MAXWELL GHISLAISE 01/21/2000 505LS I A523 G AIRLINE
23:35 (NOT
API)
ToNMMmtmedRwert:NN
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
09/23/201914:20 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 12 of 14
Cedes Value
YON OTTAWA
NAS NASSAU INTL
LAX LOS ANGELES, CA INTL
OPF OPA LOCKA
CDG PARIS, CH. DE GAULLE
SXM ST MAARTEN, PRINCE JULIANA
ILM NEW HANOVER COUNTY
STN LONDON, STANSTED
JFK JOHN F KENNEDY INTL
NRT NARITA, TOKYO
STT C.E. KING
DFW DALLAS/FT WORTH INTL
PHI WEST PALM BEACH
KDS KDS
DOH DOHAIINTERNATIONAL, QATAR
AIM QUEEN ALIA INTL
KIA KIA
MIA MIAMI INTL, FL
GIG RIO DE JANEIRO
HKG HONG KONG
BGI BARBADOS, GRANTLEY ADAMS INTL
BOS BOSTON / LOGAN INTL
LGA LA GUARDIA
BGR BANGOR
PSP PALM SPRINGS
KEF REYKJAVIK / KEFLAVIK INTL
IAD DULLES INTL
EIS BEEF ISLAND, VIRGIN ISLAND (BRITISH)
YUL DORVAL, MONTREAL
NCE COTE D'AZUR
ANC ANCHORAGE
VCE MARCO POLO
YYZ TORONTO, PEARSON INTERNATIONAL
SAN LINDBERG FLD S.DIEGO
LTN LUTON INTERNATIONAL
HPN WESTCHESTER
PTY PANAMA, OMAR TORRIJOS H
LHR LONDON / HEATHROW INTL
KSA KOSRAE, CAROLINE IS. IARPT, P. OCEAN
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
09/23/201914:20 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 13 of 14
orlilli Value
SBH ST. BARTHELEMYOARPT,GUADELOUPE
XXX UNKNOWN AIRPORT (USED ONLY WHEN THE AIRPORT CODE IS UNKNOWN)
SFO SAN FRANCISCO INTL AIRPORT
TLV BEN GURION INTL
SJU SAN JUAN, LUIS MUNOZ MARIN INTL
EWR NEWARK INTERNATIONAL
KOM KOM
NUQ MOFFETT FIELD
DEN DENVER INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
TEB TETERBORO
APA ARAPAHOE CO
TUS TUCSON
DAV ENRIQUE MALEK
FRG REPUBLIC FIELD
PAN PAN
Codes Value
P P - PASSPORT
000 000
A A - U.S. ALIEN REGISTRATION CARD
C C - PERMANENT RESIDENT CARD
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
09/23/2019 14:20 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By: Page 14 of 14
Codes Value
L382 L382 - CEP -DETROIT, WINDSOR TUNNEL
ABSJ ABSJ - INS-NEWARK ASYLUM •HIST•
A524 AS24 - CEP -MIAMI, AIRPORT CNTRL TERML
A523 AS23 - CEP -PALM BEACH, INTERNATIONAL
A520 A520 - CEP -MIAMI, AIRPORT N TERMINAL
A741 A741 - CEP -NASSAU, BAHAMAS PRECLEAR
A461 A461 - CEP-TETERBORO, AIRPT HANGER 2
A041 A041 - CEP -BOSTON, LOGAN AIRPORT
A262 A262 - CEP -TUCSON, IAP ARRIVALS
2720 2720 - 2720
4701 4701 - 4701
A27F A27F - CEP -LOS ANGELES, ATLANTIC AVN
A27G A27G - CEP -LOS ANGELES, LANDMARK GAF
AB52 AB52 - INS-JFK AIRPORT
A337 A337 - CEP -DENVER, INTL AIRPORT
AS11 AS11 - CBP-CYRIL E KING, INTL AIRPORT
A512 AS12 - CEP -ST THOMAS, VI PREDEPARTURE
A795 A795 - OTTAWA, MCDONALD-CARTIER INTL
A311 A311 - CEP -ANCHORAGE, INTL AIRPORT
A477 A477 - NEN YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 1
A276 A276 - CEP -PALM SPRINGS, REGIONAL APT
A472 A472 - NEW YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 7
A792 A792 - MONTREAL CD, DORVAL, PRECLEAR
ABET ABET - INS-MIAMI OGC •HIST•
A151 A151 - CEP -WILMINGTON, INT'L AIRPORT
A492 A492 - CBP-SAN JUAN, MUNOZ MARIN TAP
A471 A471 - NEW YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 4
A273 A273 - WS ANGELES, BRADLEY AP LAX
A491 A491 - SAN JUAN, PASSENGER BRANCH
AS2B AS2B - MIAMI, AIRPORT, GEN AVIATION
AIOD AIOD - CEP-TETERBORO, JET AVIATION
5206 5206 - 5206
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
09/23/2019 15:13 PM EDT
TECS RECORD ID:
IMAGE INFORMATION - PART I (0)
PERSON SUBJECT QUERY DETAILS INFORMATION
Tea Record ID Entry Date Update Date
01/18/1992
I
07/14/1998
Record Status Category
NP NON-SUSPECT, PRIVATE AIRCRAFT INSPECTION
Query Notification
0 - No notification
Prknary Action Start Date Stop Date
o - NOT ON PRIMARY
Last Name First Name Middle Name
MAXWELL CRISLAINE
Alias (0)
Approval Status Hispanic Indicator
U - UNKNOWN
Date of Birth (1) Race (0) Gender (0)
1)
No Fly Indicator I Selectee Indicator
N N
REMARKS INFORMATION (1)
No Date Remarks
1 03/18/1992 PRIVATE AIRCRAFT ENFORCEMENT SYSTEM
PERSONAL DATA INFORMATION
Nickname (0) Hair (0) Eyes (0)
Height Weight Units Scars/Marks/Tattoos
ENGLISH
PERSONAL IDENTIFICATION INFORMATION
Citizenship (1) SSN (0) Residency Status
1: GEM - MI:TED KI11TCN
BIRTH PLACE INFORMATION (0)
ALIEN INFORMATION (0)
EXCLUSION INFORMATION (0)
PASSPORT INFORMATION (0)
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Query
Generated By: Page 1 of 2
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
09/23/2019 15:13 PM EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Query
Generated By: Page 2 of 2
'ADDRESS INFORMATION (0)
DRIVERS' LICENSE INFORMATION (0)
PHONE INFORMATION (0)
ALTERNATE COMMUNICATION INFORMATION (0)
ELLANEOUS INFORMATION (0)
RIMINAL AFFILIATION INFORMATION (0)
CONTACT INFORMATION
Organization Full Name Telephone
CO? F:ELD OPS HO, PRIVA7E AIRCRAF: CPS
'CASE NUMBER INFORMATION (0)
FINGER PRINT INFORMATION
No Left RI, ht
Code Description Code Description
SPOUSE INFORMATION (0)
WARRANT INFORMATION (0)
ATF PROFILE INFORMATION (0)
BAGGAGE DECLARATION (CF6059) INFORMATION (0)
FINANCIAL INFORMATION (0)
EMPLOYMENT INFORMATION (0)
PILOT LICENSE INFORMATION (0)
IMAGE INFORMATION - PART II (0)
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
09/23/2019 15:10 PM EDT
TECS RECORD ID
IMAGE INFORMATION - PART I
PERSON SUBJECT QUERY DETAILS INFORMATION
Tea Record ID Entry Date Update Date
07/22/2002
I
07/22/2002
Record Status
NP NON-SUSPECT, PRIVATE AIRCRAFT INSPECTION
ICatspory
Query Notification
0 - No notification
Prin ay Action Start Date Stop Date
0 - NOT ON PRIMARY
Last Name First Name Middle Name
MAXWELL CHISLAINE
Alias (0)
al Stetta? is .___ .iis Hispanic Indicator
0 - UNKNOWN
Date of Birth (1) Race (0) Gender (0)
1)
No Fly Indicator I Selectee Indicator
N N
REMARKS INFORMATION (0)
PERSONAL DATA INFORMATION
Nickname (0) Halr (0) I Eyes (0)
Height 'Weight Units Scars/Marks/Tattoos
ENGLISH
PERSONAL IDENTIFICATION INFORMATION
Citizenship It ) SSN (0) Residency Status

1) FRA - FRANCE
BIRTH PLACE INFORMATION (0)
ALIEN INFORMATION (0)
EXCLUSION INFORMATION (0)
PASSPORT INFORMATION (0)
ADDRESS INFORMATION (0)
DRIVERS' LICENSE INFORMATION (0)
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Query
Generated By: Page 1 of 2
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
09/23/2019 15:10 PM EDT
PHONE INFORMATION (0)
ALTERNATE COMMUNICATION INFORMATION (0)
MISCELLANEOUS INFORMATION 0
CRIMINAL AFFILIATION INFORMATION (0)
CONTACT INFORMATION
Organization Full Name Telephone
CRP FIELD CRS IC. PRIVh-E AIRCRAF: CPS
CASE NUMBER INFORMATION (0)
FINGER PRINT INFORMATION ll
No
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Query
Generated By: Page 2 of 2
Left
Code Description
Right
Code Description
SPOUSE INFORMATION (0)
WARRANT INFORMATION (0)
ATF PROFILE INFORMATION (0)
BAGGAGE DECLARATION (CF6059) INFORMATION (0)
'FINANCIAL INFORMATION (0)
'EMPLOYMENT INFORMATION (0)
PILOT LICENSE INFORMATION (0)
'IMAGE INFORMATION - PART II (0)
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
FBI New York, ID-13
18 October 2019
31E-NY-3027571

(U) LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE: The information marked (U//LES) in this document is the pwyo,ty of the
Federal Bureau of Investigation and may be distributed within the federal government (and its contractors). U.S.
intelligence, law enforcement, public safety or protection officials, and individuals with a need to know. Distribution
beyond these entities without FBI authorization is prohibited. Precautions should be taken to ensure this information
is stored and/or destroyed in a manner that precludes unauthorized access. Information bearing the LES caveat may
not be used in legal proceedings without first receiving authorization from the originating agency. Recipients are
prohibited from subsequently posting the information marked LES on a website on an unclassified network without
first obtaining FBI approval.

(U) Travel Records Regarding Ghislaine Maxwell, a Reported Associate of
Jeffrey Epstein
(U//LES) FBI New York C-20 was contacted by the Southern District of New York regarding
several victims who were reportedly sexually abused by Jeffrey Epstein in the mid-2000s.
According to the allegations, Epstein invited minors into his residences, and paid them to provide
massages to him which turned sexual in nature, and wanted the minors to bring other minors to
massage him. Ghislaine Maxwell worked for Epstein as the estate manager prior to
taking over the role [REF: 31E-NY-3027571, Serial 289, 16 September 2019]. On Ruig. FBI New York received reporting that
an individual identified as Ghislaine
Maxwell took over
running Epstein's house sometime in 1993 and was observed approaching young females who
would then visit Epstein's residence [REF: 31E-NY-3027571, Serial 188, 13 July 2019].
(U//FOUO) Biographical Information

• (U) Name: Ghislaine Maxwell
• (U) DOB:
• (U) SSN:
• (U) Address: Boston, MA 02114
(U//LES) Based upon this information, FBI New York Squad C-20 requested FBI New York
Intelligence Division (New York-ID-13) conduct research and analysis to identify travel
information regarding Ghislaine Maxwell. This Tactical Intelligence Report addresses FBI New
York's Band II threat — Violent Crimes Against Children and Band lII threat — Human
Trafficking.

(U) Ghislaine Maxwell
m o• (U//FOUO) As of 23 September 2019, searches in TECS for the name Ghislaine
Maxwell, DOB: for travel status identified Ghislaine Maxwell to be in the
country. The last trave record for Ghislaine Maxwell occurred on 6/11/2019 on an
inbound flight from London/Heathrow International to Boston, Massachusetts.
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY20 Tactical Intelligence Repot
Template Weave 10-1-2019
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

• (U//FOUO) As of 27 August 2019 a Silent Hit was placed on Ghislaine Maxwell to
notify of any international travel.
• (U//FOLIO) As of 23 September 2019 searches in TECS identified a current US Pa's t
for Ghislaine Maxwell DOB: . US PP was issued on
and expired on

(U) PP Photo
(U) Ghislaine Maxwell
(U//FOUO) As of 23 September 2019, additional queries in TECS identified two additional
citizenship records for Maxwell in the United Kingdom and France.
(U//FOUO) (Analyst Note: Records are attached as a lA document).
(U//FOUO) As of 23 September 2019 searches in TECS for the name Ghislaine Maxwell from
1/1/2000 to 9/23/2019 identified 203 travel records between 1/21/2000 and 6/11/2019. There
were 8 records identified with Maxwell flying on Jeffrey Epstein's airplane with the tag number
909JE and 908JE and one entered as N908. Below are the flight records on Epstein's airplane.
(U//FOUO) (Analyst Note: Open source research identified Maxwell as having her pilot's
license and frequently flying individuals and alleged young girls to Epstein's island in the
Caribbean. The flight records depicted do not show when Maxwell was flying as the pilot).
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY -DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
Number
Line
Name Passport Date Carrier
Number
Direction Arrival Departure
1 Ghislaine
Maxwell
12/23/2006 14908 Inbound C.E. King Not listed
2 Ghislaine
Maxwell
5/29/2005 909JE Inbound West Palm
Beach
Not listed
3 Ghislaine
Maxwell
2/19/2005 908.TE Inbound West Palm
Beach
Not listed
4 Ghislaine
Maxwell
8/24/2004 908.TE Inbound West Palm
Beach
Not listed
5 Ghislaine
Maxwell
12/24/2003 909JE Inbound West Palm
Beach
Not listed
6 Ghislaine
Maxwell
= 6/14/2003 909JE Inbound West Palm
Beach
Not listed
7 Ghislaine
Maxwell
3/23/2003 909JE Inbound West Palm
Beach
Not listed
8 Ghislaine
Maxwell
4/18/2002 908JE Inbound Not listed Not listed
(W/FOUO) (Analyst Note: Flight records are attached as a IA document).

(U) As of 16 October 2019, open source searches identified a news article describing Maxwell
being a pilot for Jeffrey Epstein. Below is the article identified:

(U) Article 1: dailymail.co.uk: "Exclusive: Jeffrey Epstein paid for Ghislaine Maxwell's pilot's
license and then bought her this S4M executive helicopter so she could ferry underage girls to his
Pedophile Island"
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY -DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FYI9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 1:

• ..laslyme cri . I MOSSI/Arthey Suwon cad Coelucc-Phurdi caula icucc lary tplINJ ler I
•••• ••••• • • F glIV•IIPIOP ,••••••••••IIP
.E0111
Home U.K. &penal US Shoyebs I Australia I rental I Health Sconce I letone
EXCLUSIVE: Jeffrey Epstein paid for
Ghislaine Maxwell pilot's license and
then bought her this $4M executive
helicopter so she could ferry underage
girls to his 'Pedophile Island'

• Jeffrey Epstein paid lot his closest aide Ohlslain• Maxwell pilot's Ilc•nser and
then bought he. a Sem executive helicopter. DelyMall.com can reveal

• The pedophile splashed out on a Sikorsky 5-76C nicknamed Air Ghislaine 2 . so
she could transport a tr anche of girls to tat le St James in the US Virgin Islands
• M. Awell her been amguard of aettno at.oani. woomino unsar•o.
"J.lu for he. hew to ellugualy uesur aux.
-taire's visitors fume Cyril E. King Airport on St

(U) Photo 2:
Jeffrey Epstein paid for his closest aide Ghislaine Maxwell pilot's license and then
bought her a $4 million executive helicopter to ferry young girls to his private Island,
DailyMail.com can reveal.
The pedophile splashed out on the top of the range Sikorsky S-76C - nicknamed Air
Ghislaine 2 so she could transport a tranche of girls to Little St James in the US
Virgin Islands.
And these photos, obtained exclusively by DailyMail.com, show the interior of the
luxury twin turboshaft chopper that transported guests to the now infamous island.
Epstein and his guests will have traveled in style sat on plush brown leather seats
aboard the spacious aircraft.
The plush cabin also boated mahogany trim and storage compartments, recessed
lighting, an iPhone dock and sleek tinted windows.
Pilot Maxwell • who has been accused of acting as Epstein's Madam, grooming
underage girls for her boss would pick up the billionaire's visitors from Cyril E. King
Airport in Charlotte Amalie on St Thomas Island and transport them directly to the
70-acre Epstein property.
FBI INTERNAL. USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EX. ERNALIN
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FYI9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 3:
leflrey Epstein paid for his closest aide Ghialaine Maxwell pilots license and then bought her a
trim executive helicopter, DallyMall.com can reveal
The pedophile splashed out on a Sikorsky 5.760 - nicknamed Air Chisloins 2 - so she could
transport a tranc he of girls to Little St lames in the US Virgin Islands

(U) Photo 4:
Personal Information
GHISLAINE NOELLE MAXWELL
Address is not avadahle
Medical Information:
Medical Class: Second Medical Date: 6/2011
BasicMed Course Date: None BasicMed CMEC Date: (lone
Certificates
[Leman
Certificates Description
Certificate: PRIVATE PILOT
Date of Issue: 10/2/2007
Ratings:
PRIVATE P➢ OT
ROTORCRAFT-HELICOPTER
The 57•year•ald received her One* II to fly helicopter ,* In 2007 • the same year Epstein
struck a sweetheart non-prosecution deal with the Florida DA
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 5:
The private island - which Epstein nicknamed 'Little St Jeff's' but which locals have
dubbed 'Pedophile Island' sits off the coast of St Thomas and includes a villa-style
compound, library, cinema, detached bathhouse, a temple and cabanas.
Epstein flew underage girls there as recently as this year, according to a report in
Vanity Fair.
And following the money manager's arrest on two charges of child sex trafficking
earlier this month the disgraced mogul's fleet of luxury aircraft has once again come
under the microscope.
Prosecutors have accused the 66-year-old billionaire of abusing girls as young as 14
in a 'vast network of underage victims' and his fleet - which includes two private
jets has always been considered either a venue for some of the abuse or a means of
secretly trafficking the underage girls.
According to FAA records Epstein's former long term girlfriend and closest aide
Maxwell received her pilot's license to fly helicopters in 2007 the same year Epstein
struck a sweetheart non-prosecution deal with the Florida DA.
Despite serving some time in prison Epstein bought Maxwell a brand new $4 million
Sikorsky S-76C in 2008.

(U) Photo 6:
Tie Hinter ', tee /wealthiest
Repetweder
"ntairC ,', 64frett,ang
""easel . rah "ZIA
SowlAte.One
rho helicopter. tall numbeire47221E. was 'eche:wed to hk DoIrwate bucriese Freedom Ale
International. whkh lists tho same edema. es aware company tlleCileslekte. Ire
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 7:
(U) Photo 8:
Epstein nee bin goatee .111
spode.* aircraft
n needed in mt. on nn pleat brown lostka• own abeend the
The helicopter, tail number N7221E. was registered to his Delaware business
Freedom Air International, which lists the same address as another company Air
Ghislaine, Inc.
It's now understood that Epstein continued his criminal activity almost immediately
after being released from prison and will have made use of the chopper to fulfill his
sordid fantasies.
Maxwell, daughter of late publishing tycoon Robert Maxwell, has denied accusations
made in civil suits of aiding and participating in Epstein's sexual abuse of minors
despite being implicated by several of his alleged victims.
But the 57-year-old British socialite has been among the financier's closest
associates for almost three decades.
According to a report last week in Vanity Fair locals on St Thomas said Epstein had
been transporting underage girls to his island by helicopter for years, some as
recently as this year.
This a decade after he was forced to register as a convicted sex offender.
Two employees who worked at the local airstrip on St Thomas told Vanity Fair that
they witnessed Epstein boarding his private plane on many occasions in the
company of girls who appeared to be under the age of consent.
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY — DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 9:
Records show that Epstein also had another helicopter, a Bell Jet Ranger, which Maxwell flew
at his sprawling Zorro Ranch in New Mexico. The blue and white chopper (pictured) has the tail
number N491GM - GM standing for Ghislaine Maxwell - and was nicknamed Air Ghislaine 1

(U) Photo 10:
According to the staff, the girls arrived with Epstein aboard one of his two
Gulfstream jets before boarding a helicopter.
'On multiple occasions I saw Epstein exit his helicopter, stand on the tarmac in full
view of my tower, and board his private jet with children • female children,' a former
air traffic controller at the airstrip told the magazine.
FAA registration records show the S-76 was eventually sold to another company
called ASI Wings, LLC.
Epstein replaced it with a more modern Bell 430 executive chopper which Maxwell is
understood to also have flown and was also piloted by
The sleek jet black helicopter, tail number N3311E, is a four-bladed. twin-engined,
nine-seat aircraft marketed as a high-speed corporate chopper capable of speeds up
to 257km/h.
Seen here in more exclusive photos the Bell 430s are sold for around $6 million.
On August 11 last yearElEposted a photo of the Bell 430 alongside Epstein's
Gulfstream IV private jet, with the tag: 'How we Roll, Black on Black, *Be11430,
'Gulfstream, lAvgeek, 'aviation *flying IIGIV *430 "IslandLife, *MAGA
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY -DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 11:
C
P ir:  S i
"if/ -
ke_instagrae
AA registration records show the S.76 was eventually sold. Epstein replaced it with this Bell
430 executi • understood to also have flown and was also piloted
by Epstein's een here In more exclusivephotos the Bell 430s are
sold for around S6 mill on

(U) Photo 12:
Records show that Epstein also had another helicopter, a Bell Jet Ranger, which
Maxwell flew at his sprawling Zorro Ranch in New Mexico.
The blue and white chopper has the tail number N491GM - GM standing for Ghislaine
Maxwell • and was nicknamed Air Ghislaine 1.
Epstein's runs Epstein's fleet of private jets and helicopters and
has flown the hedge fund mogul around the world for 20 years.
NotablyMflew Epstein's larger 727 jet - the infamous Lolita Express - which
carried prominent passengers including President Bill Clinton, British royal Prince
Andrew as well as Hollywood stars Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker and supermodel
Naomi Campbell.
And the 59-year-old veteran pilot - nicknamed •n his Instagram page
- liked to show off his billionaire boss' expensive toys on social media - that is until a
DailyMail.com exposé led to him quickly removing his personal profile.
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FYI9 Tactical Iotelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Photo 13:
Records show that Epstein also had another helicopter, a Bell Jet Ranger, which
Maxwell flew at his sprawling Zorro Ranch in New Mexico.
The blue and white chopper has the tail number N491GM - GM standing for Ghislaine
Maxwell - and was nicknamed Air Ghislaine 1.
Epstein's runs Epstein's fleet of private jets and helicopters and
has flown the hedge fund mogul around the world for 20 years.
Notablyalew Epstein's larger 727 jet - the infamous Lolita Express - which
carried prominent passengers including President Bill Clinton, British royal Prince
Andrew as well as Hollywood stars Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker and supermodel
Naomi Campbell.
And the 59-year-old veteran pilot - nicknamed n his Instagram page
- liked to show off his billionaire boss' expensive toys on social media - that is until a
DailyMail.com exposé led to him quickly removing his personal profile.

(U) As of 16 October 2019, open source searches identified Maxwell's Pilot's License
Certificate from the Federal Aviation Administration: www.faa.coin

(U) Photo 1:
steam Feaeral Avxan Aom "swat on
Federal Aviation
Administration
U.S Department of Transportation
Federal Aviation Administration
Air man Details Report
Personal Informat tr
GHISLALNE NOELLE MAXWELL
Awana opted-out of ieleatmg :War.;
MISIIICAUSLI0LInall0LL
Medical C lass: Second Medical Date: 6 2011
Basic:Med C Count Date: None BasioMed (MEC Date: None
Certificate Information:
C enificare: PRIVATE PILOT
Date of Issue: 10 2 200-
Ratings:
PRI \ATE PILOT
ROTORCRAFT-HELICOPTER
FBI INTERNAL I 'sE ONLY — DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FYI9 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) As of 16 October 2019, open source searches identified the tail number N722JE as being
associated to Jeffrey Epstein's address in the Caribbean, St Thomas,
Virgin Islands 00802:

(U) Photo 1:
FAA REGISTRY
Malumberhotay Resells
/1727JF is Mame
Data Updated oat Sabah Wafting Day at leitlart
Ca l
Saar Number
manelacerer Mare
Model
Twe A. «di
perces Name' L range
Date Ceae P UITIOTIIC4
MFR roar
Tsp. 900allarlan
KEYStaat HELICOPTER
Slabs
Cabloate bane Owe
vale
aril7/2011
P.f 6C Cad neon Dots 07/31/2022
Rooaell TYPO DOM Tunn-seal
none Dead
Homo Ibtlo $ t oft lease al) 70?
209E Wee 6TMa Mato 16
Friel-04AI CIIIMN
ail abfiCT
lr
Nan*
Wow
HYPERI0N AIR Lie
Cty
C'unty
S1 11-IDIAAS Stab
Zip Cede
FOREIGN
COUrarT %IRON ISLAPCO
rapine Oranateenser TuROOMCCA aeon:aloe airbag
Engine WOO
4W Dee
APR°. 232
ta0fir200$
Caffarra
lanai Cede
bawl
no
The poem/mon ow... snob read flayed to be meg WWI Artheareesa inforneeen fin.11tle in he PDX)1C0' *WO record Mutter. Mk 
deb Mane Pan not web Its ono
mita delINTWISICII mewing the antarlaneb d an aff daft Cr tie wird aouap confipbrame Fet ;pecilc inbinerion you may 
requests caw of the MUM reoxi ll
nturiweata.901:arallQ.
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) As of 16 October 2019, open source searches identified the tail number N331JE as being
associated to Jeffrey Epstein's address in the Caribbean, B3 St Thomas,
Virgin Islands 00802:

(U) Photo I:
FAA REGI STRY
IC/INTL:et Foully Resets
Nina S As meet
Gat. UpdaIeC each FeOti al %Hereto Day et MIcnot
Soisl N0mber 49078
Nan•betner Mae BELL
Nuclei a10
lype Atter ..Ritatrat
routing Me mt..' Change Now
Cot Chance Auttocue0 NTT
MN Yes: .ICCe
Tyr.. Rep etretion LLC
Status
Cer•Beele Inn Date
Feittelkei Dab
Iwo F row*
Doe*
Mode SCa0e NTH* 1CCO
M000 SCCO1 EOM t01 MN A39063
Enceinte Owner NO
EvOice4
BSt02013
BV3W20I9
Tutlio4hat
No
piano
Sorel
City
County
[Gately VIRGIN I3LNIDS
ITTERON AIR LLC
ST TI.ICITAS Stale FOREIGN
bp Cede MATT*
E03Me LientfeClutet AMMETER
Envie ih,de I INII(NOMI ENG
NW Cate • 040120CI
Cle Metal
Cele00y
Excel:Noe Coda
••••0•10
Trieste"!
Yes
Tie nfonellon cit.:v*0in Inis wad Ovate the toil cunentiNneennoess intornellon valetas Y tie !lateral ataatrt:Po 
Nosever, Pb Oaa acne doe not provide tie MN
Nra deletranxice regat0n01e arecenewet elan stain a tee :went vent contganitoi ice Kettle ItIonvistea. Yee may reCuail a
spy OThe alr0at %Cad at
Nb venal tee  cast:oil/DI

(U) Investigative/Intelligence Gaps

• (U) Gap 1: How often did Ghislaine Maxwell fly the helicopter?
• (U) Gap 2: How was Maxwell's travel piloting the helicopter documented?

• (U) Gap 3: When did Maxwell stop flying the helicopter for Jeffrey Epstein?
(fl Scope Note

(U) Information in this report was derived from numerous open-source, secure and classified
systems to include: Comprehensive Criminal History (CCH), Interstate Identification Index and
National Crime Information Center (BUNCIC), and New York Driver's Licenses via eJustice
NY; New York Police Department (NYPD); Administration for Children Services (ACS); DIVS;
Sentinel; Treasury Enforcement Communications System (TECS); Accurint; Google.com; and
social media accounts. All the open-source, secure, and classified information was last collected
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical ha:Hiram Report
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
between 23 September 2019 and 16 October 2019, and all collection is current as of 16 October
2019.

(U) Consumers: SS
SA
Det
(U) Approval: SIA
(U) FBI New York Field Office prepared this Tactical Intelligence Report. Please address comments and queries to
the New York Intelligence Division
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FY19 Tactical Intelligence Report
EFTA00164480 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about Epstein death investigation (Powerpoint slides)
(approximate date: 2019-09-01)
Child Exploitation & Human Trafficking Task Force
Jeffrey Epstein
NYO Investigations
Child Sex Trafficking: 31E-NY-3027571
Aggravated or Overt Threats: 9A-NY-3144791
IFPI — Crime of Violence: 90A-NY-3151227
IFPI — All Others: 90C-NY-3 154599
Color of Law — Non Brutality: 282B-NY-3156749
Timeline

7/6: Jeffrey Epstein arrested at Teterboro airport in NJ
7/8: Detained and held at MCC Psych evaluation and observation
7/9: Placed with Nicholas Tartaglione
7/23: Suicide attempt
7/24-29: Suicide watch
7/29: MCC Chief Psychologist approves Epstein to be removed from suicide watch
8/9: Cellmate released
8/10: Suicide

<floorplan>

<floorplan>
Epstein Cell

<floorplan>
╭── Page 5, Image 1 ──╮
│ Key Access          │
│ Only                │
│ Held by             │
│ SHU Officer         │
│                     │
│ ‘Control or Key.    │
│ Access ~ Key held   │
│ by SHU Officer      │
│                     │
│ PB                  │
│                     │
│ ‘Control I          │
│                     │
│ Access only         │
│                     │
│ #1                  │
│                     │
│ Kontrol             │
│ ‘Recess only #2     │
│                     │
│ ‘Access ~ Key held  │
│ by Visiting Officer │
│                     │
│ Key Access ¢__      │
│ Only                │
│ Held by             │
│ Visiting Officer    │
╰─────────────────────╯

╭─ Page 7, Image 1 ─╮
│ Spherical Photos  │
│ Multipurpose Area │
│                   │
│ L Tier            │
│ (Epstein cell)    │
│                   │
│ Entrance #1       │
│ Entrance          │
│                   │
│ Entrance #2       │
│ and #3            │
│                   │
│ Cameras           │
╰───────────────────╯

MCC Video System
Total 192 Cameras

DVR 1
16 Hard drives
2 camera angles of interest record to DVR 1

• Data available 7/23 - 8/10

128 Cameras
DVR 2
16 Hard drives
• DVR 2 System failure on 7/29
• DVR 2 Hard drive failure (2 hard drives) on 8/8

• Only available video 7/15-7/29
• 3 of 4 camera angles of interest in the SHU record to DVR 2
• Sally port camera (elevator bank #1 and #2)

Death Investigation

Guards of interest

• Officer Michael Thomas (suspended and likely charged)
• Officer Tova Noel (suspended and likely charged)

18 USC § 1001
Whoever, in any matter within the jurisdiction of the executive,
legislative, or judicial branch of the government of the United States,
knowingly and willfully falsifies, conceals, or covers up by any trick,
scheme, or device a material fact; makes any materially false, fictitious, or
fraudulent statement or representation; or makes or uses any false
writing or document knowing the same to contain any materially false,
fictitious, or fraudulent statement or entry

.     Death Investigation

Significant Interviews:

• Lt. <REDACTED>Efrain Reyes - Epstein's cellmate
• Officer <REDACTED> (proffer)
• Officer <REDACTED>

Video recovery/reconstruction:

• Operational Technology Division (MD), Digital Forensics and Analysis Section (DFAS)
• Approximately 450 hours of video review — 7/23-8/10

• 5 times jail count was not conducted 7/23-8/9
• Officer Michael Thomas was working 3 of those shifts

Interviews conducted:

• 26 MCC Staff Members
• 15 Inmates
• Total 41

Cell phone call detail analysis
Tlnio-/Sey Tnvectio-atinn

.     DRUG / SEX INVESTIGATION

Guard of Interest

• Officer <REDACTED>

Visitors of Interest
• <REDACTED><REDACTED>
•   • Payments and drug deliveries to <REDACTED>

Guard of interest

• Officer
Visitors of interest

• Inmate of interest
• <REDACTED>

Significant Interviews:
• <REDACTED><REDACTED>

Investigative Strategies
• CAST/Call Detail Analysis of cell phones
• Financial analysis

• Subpoena Cash AppMCC visitor log analysis
• Correlation to MCC inmates
• Correlation to cell phone records

Child Sex Trafficking Investigation

• Co-conspirators:
• <REDACTED> — Attorney proffer scheduled for 10/18/19<REDACTED>Ghislaine Maxwell — Attorney proffer scheduled for 10/8/19<REDACTED> - Proffer scheduled for 10/11/19<REDACTED> - cooperating

• Victims:
• Approximately 80 victims identified

• 2 Victim briefings scheduled
• Miami10/15/19NYC10/23/19

• Hotline:
• 194 calls to date of which 26 related to victims and 10 to co-conspirators
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                              Alfa-Bank [russia] largest private bank in Russia, often used by FSB 
                        Day One Ventures [russia] silicon valley venture fund run by Masha Drokova 
                                                       Camille Lang [arts] Sotheby's auction house 
                                                    Caroline Sophie [arts] Sotheby's auction house 
                                                           Etienne Binant [arts] art advisor (???) 
                                Latham & Watkins [law firm] law firm where Kathryn Ruemmler worked 
 Arda Beskardes [lawyer] NYC immigration attorney allegedly involved in sex-trafficking operations 
                                                Ossa Properties [real estate] Mark Epstein company 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01681865 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank explanations of all of Epstein's large payments prepared for DOJ
(date: 2019-09-12)
DEUTSCHE BANK PRESENTATION TO THE
OFFICE OF THE UNITED STATES ATTORNEY FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
September 12, 2019

Exhibit A: Breakdown of Southern Financial Relationship Accounts 2
Exhibit B: Nature and Purpose of Active / Capitalized Southern Financial Relationship Accounts 3
Exhibit C: Jeffrey Epstein Affiliates Onboarded by Deutsche Bank 7
Exhibit D: Parties to Active / Capitalized Southern Financial Relationship Accounts 9
Exhibit E: Timeline of The Butterfly Trust 14
Exhibit F: Biographical Information on Female Butterfly Trust Beneficiaries 15
Exhibit G: Summary of Payments to Butterfly Trust Beneficiaries 17
Exhibit H: Timeline of Direct Payments to Butterfly Trust Beneficiaries 19
Exhibit I: Summary of Payments to Ostensible Foreign Models
Exhibit J: Cash Withdrawals in Excess of $10,000 23
Exhibit K: Hedge Fund Investments 25
Exhibit L: Potential Settlement Payments 26
Exhibit M: Suspected Payments for Legal Expenses of Co-Conspirators 27
Exhibit N: Timeline of Payments to (or on Behalf of) Alleged Co-Conspirators (Payments ≥ $10,000) 29
Exhibit 0: Payments to Epstein-Affiliated Individuals & Entities (Not Onboarded by Deutsche Bank) 34
Exhibit P: Notable Payments to High Profile Individuals 38
Exhibit Q: Potentially Notable Payments 41
Exhibit R: Tuition Payments on Behalf of Children / Women 46 ao
Exhibit S: Epstein Links to Other Financial Institutions / Wealth Management Firms 51

CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. atm. P. 6(e)

EXHIBIT A: BREAKDOWN OF SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP ACCOUNTS

ACCOUNT TYPE    TOTAL   INTENTIONAL     CAPITALIZED     EPSTEIN-CONTROLLED  EPSTEIN-CONTROLLED+CAPITALIZED
Brokerage Advisory 12 7 7
DBAGNY Preferred' 4 4 4 4 4
Checking 29 29 22 23 19
Domestic Custody I 1 I 1 I
Money Market Business2 24 24 4 17 2
Money Market Individual 2 2 0 1 0
NOW & SuperNOW) 4 4 4 3 3
TOTAL 764 71 42 56 36

1 DBAGNY is the New York branch of Deutsche Bank AG ("Deutsche Bank" or "the Bank"). DBAGNY Preferred Deposit accounts 
offer higher interest rates
than accounts opened through Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas ("DBTCA"). However, DBAGNY Preferred Deposit accounts 
do not receive the same FDIC
insurance protections as DBTCA accounts.
2 Money market accounts offer higher interest than checking accounts; however, there are restrictions on the number of 
withdrawals that can be made from
money market accounts in a given month. There are no such restrictions on checking accounts.
3 "NOW" & "SuperNOW" refer to checking accounts with interest, sometimes referred to in Bank records as an "Elite 
Checking" account.
Note that we have identified two additional types of accounts, referred to in Bank records as "PIC Desk" and "Structured
Transaction" accounts, which we
understand to be administrative or "dummy accounts." It is our understanding that Epstein and related parties would have
had no awareness or understanding of
these
accounts. For this reason, we have excluded these accounts from the tallies above.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
444 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 33333 3n.V.IMJJJJJ.P.MJJ.141.3JJ41MJ
EXHIBIT B: NATURE AND PURPOSE OP ACTIVE / CAPITALIZED SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP ACCOUNTS
NATURE OF k( «)1 \ I ACCOUNT I) \ ACCOUNT ACCOUNT NAND. LI PE NUNIBER \ I I)
HOLDER
KYC PURPOSE`
Aircraft
Management
Hyperion Air, Inc. Checking 10/18/2013

• Checking account to hold the funds necessary for the
costs associated with owning/running one of Jeffrey
Epstein's airplanes.
Hyperion Air, LLC Checking 10/18/2013

• Checking account to hold the funds necessary for the
costs associated with owning/running one of Jeffrey
Epstein's airplanes.
JEGE, Inc. Checking 10/18/2013

• Checking account to hold the funds necessary for the
costs associated with owning/running one of Jeffrey
Epstein's airplanes.
JEGE, LLC Checking 10/18/2013

• Checking account to hold the funds necessary for the
costs associated with owning/running one of Jeffrey
Epstein's airplanes.
Plan D, LLC Checking 10/18/2013

• Checking account to hold the funds necessary for the
costs associated with owning/running one of Jeffrey
Epstein's airplanes.
Art Acquisition /
Investment Prytanee, LLC Checking 1/20/2017

• The purpose of this account is to manage the monthly
expenses of the company. Deposit account related to art
purchases.
Charitable
Organizations
[501(c)(3)s)
J. Epstein Virgin
Islands Foundation Brokerage 9/24/2013 • The purpose of this account is to manage the foundation's
securities and trade investments.
Gratitude America,
Ltd. NOW 3/3/2015 • Checking account to deal with the day-to-day running of
the foundation.
Gratitude America,
Ltd.
Money
Market 3/3/2015Money market account to hold funds and earn interest.
5 Clients must provide a purpose before opening accounts. The purpose is then memorialized in a "Know Your Client" or 
"KYC" record generated for each
account. The "KYC Purpose" listed here is the purpose that was provided to the Bank for each account. Note that KYCs are
periodically reviewed and updated. In
several instances, the wording used in the KYC Purpose section changed slightly. To avoid redundancy, we have only 
listed one purpose for each account.
CONFIDENTIAL -PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
wry - 11- 1111111111111 11 1131101131111313 113 3 333 33.3.333331.13
NATURE OF ACCOI NI
lin! m it
ACC n! \! \ ‘Mu \( < !n \!
1 ) PI
ACCOUNT D \ i i
NUMBER (>r! \I I)
JO( P! '<PI .' '
Epstein
Employees /
Affiliates
Darren Indyke PLLC Checking 11/1/2013 • Checking account for the daily use of this law firm. HBRK Associates,
Inc. Checking 11/1/2013 • Checking account to hold funds for daily use for the
company.
New York Strategy
Group, LLC
Money
Market 11/1/2013Money market account to hold funds for the company and
earn interest.
JSC Interiors LLC Checking 12/4/2013 • Checking account for daily activities associated with
running an interior design company. Jennifer Kahn &
Karyna Shuliak NOW 12/13/2013 • This is a checking account for Individuals. They use the
funds for daily expenses. Darren Indyke PLLC
(Attorney Trust
Account)
Mone y
Mark et 2/27/2018Money market account for client's escrow. Funds are
placed here to earn interest.
Personal
Accounts
Jeffrey Epstein NOW 9/12/2013 • Checking account for Jeffrey Epstein's personal daily use.
Jeffrey Epstein Brokerage 9/19/2013 • The purpose of this account is to hold marketable
securities and cash.
Jeffrey Epstein Custody 4/10/2014 • The purpose of this account is to hold FX cash deposits. Jeffrey Epstein NOW 
3/8/2016 • Checking account for Jeffrey
Epstein's personal daily use.
Holding/
Investment
Companies
Southern Trust
Company, Inc.
Brokerage 8/19/2013 • The purpose of this account is to hold marketable
securities & cash.
Checking 8/27/2013 • Checking account. To hold funds for company.
Money
Market 8/27/2013Money Market account. To hold funds for the company.
DBAGNY
Preferred 2/21/2017 • N/A
Southern Financial
LLC
Brokerage 8/19/2013 • The purpose of this account is to invest long term with the
bank.
Checking 9/5/2013 • Checking account to hold funds for the company.
Brokerage 10/29/2013 • N/A
DBAGNY
Preferred , 2/27/2017 • The purpose of this account is to manage the daily
expenses of the company.
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
IIJARMJAJJJAMJAIIMJWIJIMMJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
NATURE OF
ACCOUNT
HOLDER
Aft ot N. i N %NI< ACCOI 'NT ACCOUNT DATE
TIP,: NUMBER OPENED KYC PuRPosEs
The Haze Trust
Brokerage 9/19/2013 • This is a brokerage account for the trust to hold and make
investments in marketable securities.
DBAGNY
Preferred 2/21/2017 • This is an interest bearing checking account for costs
(taxes, etc.) related to this Trust.
Checking 2/27/2017 • This is a simple checking account for costs (taxes, etc.)
related to this Trust.
The 2017 Caterpillar
Trust
Checking 2/16/2018 • The purpose of this account is to hold member interest in
IGO Company LLC.
DBAGNY
Preferred 3/16/2018 • N/A
Mort, Inc. Checking 2/6/2015 • Checking account to hold assets for the company.
Jeepers Inc. Brokerage 9/19/2013 • The purpose of the account is to manage the securities
purchases of the company.
Property
Management
LSJE, LLC Checking 2/25/2015 • Checking account for the daily expenses associated with
running one of Jeffrey Epstein's private homes.
Neptune, LLC Checking 10/18/2013

• This is a checking account to pay for all expenses (i.e.
electric, maintenance, cable, etc.) on Epstein's NYC
home.
NES, LLC Checking 11/8/2013

• This is a simple checking account to take care of the
expenses associated with running Jeffrey Epstein's NY
home.
Zorro Management,
LLC Checking 4/25/2014 • The purpose of this account is to manage the daily
expenses of the company.
Zorro Management,
LLC
(House Account)
Checking 3/13/2017

• The purpose of the account is to manage the monthly
expenses of the company.
Zorro Development
Corp. Checking 4/25/2014

• Checking account for the day-to-day expenses associated
with running the ranch in New Mexico that Zorro owns.
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
ittistisissisisiii111313131.11111311311113133
NATURE OF
ACCOUNT
HOLDER
ACCOUNT NAME ACCOUNT
TYPE
ACCOUNT
NUMBER
DATE KYC PURPOSE` OPENED
Traditional
Trusts
The Butterfly Trust Money
Market

• This is a money market deposit account to pay all
1/24/2014 expenses / disbursements related to the trust. Expenses
are taxes. trust fee, etc.
The 2007 Jeffrey E.
Jeffrey Epstein
Insurance Trust
Checking
• Checking account to hold funds for this trust.
11/1/2013
5.A- ,ort, go./
as tenk(loo
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
ssissississis11441113111111111111111111111111
EXHIBIT C: JEFFREY EPSTEIN AFFILIATES ONBOARDED BY DEUTSCHE. BANK'
KYC PROFESSION \ \\ii AFFII. I \'I 'FD ENTITIES' DIRECT
PAA NIEN'TS'. TM %I. D.P. AFFILIATED
PA1 MEN I ti",, TOTAL A.P.
Attorney
Darren K. Indyke Darren K. Indyke PLLC (A) $480,000 3 $2,200,000'
Erica Kellerhals Kellerhals Ferguson Kroblin PLLC (A)
Gratitude America, Ltd. (A) 0 N/A 40* $46,221,541"
Lesley Groff Darren K. Indyke PLLC (E) 12* $420,235 N/A N/A
Accountant Harry Beller HBRK Associates, Inc. (A) 2 $26,000* N/A N/A Richard Kahn Coatue Enterprises LLC (A) 3 $485,755 
4 $2,000,000'
Contemporary Art Caroline Sophie
Camille Lang Sotheby's (E) 0 N/A N/A" N/A
Investment Advisor Paul Barrett Alpha Group Capital LLC (A) 0 N/A 5 $241,886"
Finance
Jean Anne Brennan N/A Irot 0 N/A N/A N/A Etienne Jean Binant Prytanee LLC (E)' II $1,400,000 N/A N/A Daphne Wallace 
Southern Trust Company. Inc. (E) 0 N/A N/A
N/A Pilot Lawrence Visoski N/A 22 $757,926 N/A N/A
Property Manager
Brice Gordon Lee McKenzie Consultants, LLC (A) 12* $22,788 33 $600,000
NES, LLC (E) 9 $330,782 N/A N/A
N/A 2 $2,174 N/A N/A
The term "onboarded" signifies that the listed individual is a signatory, ultimate beneficial owner, legal 
representative or authorized user of a Southern
Financial Relationship ("SFR") account. SFR is an internal classification for accounts controlled by Jeffrey Epstein or 
affiliated individuals/entities that
Epstein brought to the Bank.
This term indicates that the individual is either an employee ("E") or agent ("A") of the listed entity.
"'Direct Payments" refers to payments made to a personal bank account held by the listed individual.
° "Affiliated Payments" refers to payments made to an affiliated entity that may have been intended for the listed 
individual.
10 This figure reflects payments to a TD Bank account held by Darren K. Indyke PLLC.
" This figure reflects payments to an Alostar Bank of Commerce account held by Kellerhals' law firm, Kellerhals Ferguson
Kroblin PLLC.
12 This figure reflects payments to Coatue Enterprises, LLC. There is little publicly available information about Coatue
other than that Kahn is a registered
agent.
n An Epstein-controlled account made a single payment totaling $50,728 to Sotheby's, but there is no indication that the
payment was intended for Lang. 14 This
figure reflects payments to Paul Barren's private wealth management firm, Alpha Group Capital LLC.
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
KYC PROFTssio \
Interior Design MECIMEMMEIN
•
AFFILI VITO ENTITn •
JSC Interiors LLC
JSC Interiors LLC A
Art II I ‘TED TOT x I.U.P. P\1 Tor A.P. i'\) \II NI , ‘ \1 \II NIS'
MENEMIIIMM=
MEDMEIHMEMNIfi
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
N/A
N/A
EXHIBIT H: PARTIES TO ACTIVE / CAPITALIZED SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP ACCOUNTSis
ACCOI \I 111I
Butterfly Trust
1( «•I NI
\I NII4FR
AA cel. NI
TYPE
Money
Market
GRANTOR ("C") OR
URO

• Jeffrey Epstein (G)
SIGNATORY ("S") OR
REP. ("LR")
• Richard Kahn (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)
• Erica Kellerhals (S)

• Many Beller (S)
BENEFICIARY ("B") OR
LIMITED POA ("LPOA")
•
•
hislaine Maxwell (B)
•
• Richard Kahn (B)

• Darren Indyke (B)
• Shuliak )
•
•
•
• Darren Indyke PLLC Checking • Darren Indyke (UBO) • Darren Indyke (S) • N/A Darren Indyke PLLC
(Attorney Trust Account)
Money
Market

• Darren Indyke (UBO) • Darren Indyke (S) • N/A
Gratitude America, Ltd
NOW • Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
• N/A
Money
Market
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Darren Indyke (5)

• N/A
HBRK Associates, Inc. Checking • Richard Kahn (UBO)
• Harry Beller (L/8O)
• Richard Kahn (S)
• Harry Beller (S)

• N/A
Hyperion Air, Inc. Checking
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harty Beller (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)

• N/A
Hyperion Air, LLC Checking • Jeffrey Epstein (118O) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• N/A
IS Epstein frequently added, removed, or modified parties to the listed accounts. This chart does not reflect all of 
those changes.
CONFIDENTIAL- PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
JP a SS a a 4444., .4 4 • 4 14-11-114 141-1 3-1 ,1 II I I I JII.I I 1 11
cit I \ \V H i " N kt «it \ I
NI min I<
ACCOUNT
TYPE
GRANTOR ("G") OK
UBO
SIGNATORY ("5") OR
Isr; X I RFT. ("Lir)

• Darren Indyke i \ ,
• Lawrence Visoski LK
BENEFICIARY ("B") OR
LIMITED POA ("LPOA")
J Epstein Virgin Islands
Foundation BrokerageJeffrey Epstein (UBO/G) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Erika Kellerhals (S/LR)
• Darren Indyke (S)
• Paul Barrett (LPOA)
Jeepers Inc. BrokerageJeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Jean A. Brennan (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)

• N/A
Jeffrey Epstein
NOW
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Many Beller (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)

• N/A
BrokerageJeffrey Epstein (UBO)
• Darren Indyke (S)
• N/A
Custody
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO)
• Harry Beller (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
N/A
NOW
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)_

• N/A
JEGE, Inc. Checking
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)

• N/A
JEGE, LLC Checking
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Darren Ind ceS

• N/A
& NOW • •
• IC na Shuliak S
• N/A Karyna Shuliak • K na Shuliak UBO
JSC Interiors LLC Checking • • Richard Kahn (S) • N/A
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
r31433513333333333313331333333333333333311311
ACCOUNT NAN1E ACCOll • i
NUMBI lt
ACCOUN I
fl  Pt
CRANTOR ("G") OR
I BO
SIC• % I oln ("S") oR
LEGAI. RI I'. ("LR")
BENEFICIARY ("B") OR
LI%IITED POA ("LPOA")
LSJL. 1 1 t Checking • Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jetfrey Epstein (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
• • A
Mort, Inc. Checking
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harry Beller (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
—
• N/A
Neptune, LLC Checking
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harry Beller (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
• N/A
NES, LLC Checking
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harry Beller (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
• N/A
New York Strategy Group,
LLC
Money
Market
• Darren Indyke (UBO) • Darren Indyke • N/A
Plan D, LLC Checking

• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)
• Lawrence Visoski (LR)

• N/A
Prytanee, LLC Checking
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO)
• Caroline Lang (UBO)
• Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)

• Caroline Lang (S)
• Etienne Bilsant (S)
• N/A
Southem Financial LLC
BrokerageJeffrey Epstein (UBO)
.

• Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Jean A. Brennan (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)
• Paul Barren (LPOA)
Checking
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Jean A. Brennan (S)
• N/A
1 Brokerage • TBD • TBD • l'ElD
DBAGNY
Preferred

• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Jean A. Wiebracht (S)
• N/A
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R CRIM. P. 6(e)
rishiniiiiiiii111151551111111111133331333413
ACCOUNT NAME V ( or  I ACCOUNT GR 1NTOR ("G") OR
NI MIMEN TYPE 1180
SIG' ‘ i ORY ("S") OR BENEFICIARY ("B") OR
I i (. xi. HI P. ("Ur) LIMITED POA ("LPOA")

• Darren Indyke (S)
Southern Trust Company
Inc.
BrokerageJeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)

• Jean A. Brennan (S)
• Darren Indyke (S/LR)
• Richard Kahn (LR)
• Paul Barrett (LPOA)
Checking
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Jean A. Brennan (S)
• N/A
Money
Market
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)

• Darren Indyke (S/LR)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Jean A. Brennan (S)
• Richard Kahn (LR)
• N/A
DBAGNY
Preferred

• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Jean A. Brennan (S)

• N/A
The 2007 Jeffrey E. Jeffrey
Epstein Insurance Trust Checking • Jeffrey Epstein (G) • Damn Indyke (S)

• Richard Kahn (S)
•
The 2017 Caterpillar Trust
Checking • Jeffrey Epstein (UBO/G) • Daphne Wallace (S)

• Lesley Groff (S)
• Jeffrey Epstein (B)
DBAGNY
Preferred
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO/G) • Daphne Wallace (S)

• Lesley Groff (S)
• Jeffrey Epstein (B)
The Haze Trust
BrokerageJeffrey Epstein (UBO/G) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
• Harry Beller (S)
• Jean A. Brennan (S)
• Jeffrey Epstein (B)
• Paul Barrett (LP)
DBAGNY
Preferred

• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO/G) • Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)
• Jeffrey Epstein (B)
Checking • Jeffrey Epstein (UBO/G) • Jeffrey Epstein (S) • Jeffrey Epstein (B)
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
ACCOUNT NAME ACCOUNT LAMM 7NT GRANTOR ("G") OR
NUMBER TYPE UBO
SILK U(IR) ("S") DR
I.U. a RI ("LIZ")
BENEFICIARY ("B") OR
LIMITED POA ("LPOA")
Zorro Development Corp.
Zorro Management. LLC
Zorro Management. LLC
(House Account)
Checking
Checking Checking
Checking

• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO)
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO)
• Jeffrey Epstein (UBO)
• Darren Indyke (S)
• Jeffrey Epstein (S)

• Darren Indyke (S)
• Jeffrey Epstein (S)
• Darren Indyke (S)
• Jeffrey Epstein (S)
•~
• Brice Gordon (S)
• N/A
• N/A
• N/A
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
eitailtiOMMAIPMSJJAMMIPMJIMJIMI-1121J1
EXHIBIT E: TIMELINE OF THE BUTTERFLY TRUST
um i \ I \ I
November 2006 According to the Miami Herald, the FBI began interviewing witnesses in connection with its sex trafficking
probe into
Epstein in November 2006.16
December 27, 2006 Epstein settles the Butterfly Trust, naming and "Gishlaine N. Maxwell" as
beneficiaries. Richard Kahn and Darren Ind ke are named trustees.
March 24, 2011 Darren Indyke and Richard Kahn add as a beneficiary.
March 28, 2011 Darren Indyke and Richard Kahn add " ' and''' as beneficiaries.
January 24, 2014 The Bank opens a business checkin account and mone market business account for the Butterfly Trust. In 
the
applicable KYC record, Maxwell, are listed as beneficiaries.
April 25, 2014 The Butterfly Trust checking account appears to close after four months of inactivity.
December 9, 2014
January 27, 2015
H Beller and Erika Kellerhals are identified in trust documents as "acting trustees." Beller and Kellerhals add
I. It na Shu ' any_ " ' "Darien K. Indyke," ," as beneficiaries.
eller  and Kellerhals te
well" as beneficiaries.
H Beller an' rika Kellerhals a as a benefici:
February 6, 2015 Harry = eller and Erika Kellerhals add " an as beneficiaries.
Feb 11, 2015 H: Beller and Erika Kellerhals add' ' as a benefici .
February 24-27, 2015
A KYC update is conducted on the Butterfly Trust money market and checking accounts (unclear why the checking
account was included in the review). The beneficiaries remain the same, but Epstein replaces Richard Kahn and Darren
Indyke as trustees with Harry Beller and Erika Kellerhals.
March 30, 2015 Harry Beller and Erika Kellerhals add as a beneficiary.
April24 2015 Harry Beller and Erika Kellerhals add' ' as a beneficiary.
December 2016 —
February 2017
Fall 2018
According to KYC records, Epstein reaches out to his relationship man r, Stewart Oldfield, and asks to char e the
beneficiaries on the Butterfly Trust. Three beneficiaries are removed: Maxwell. and name
' • ht beneficiaries are added: K na Shuliak,
Darren Ind ke and Richard Kahn.
According to interviews and records, Epstein attempts to open a brokerage account for the Butterfly Trust.
July 8, 2019 The Butterfly Trust money market account is closed in connection with the oftboarding of the Southern 
Financial
Relationship. The funds appear to be transferred to a Fidelity account belonging to The Butterfly Trust.
Julie K. Brown, For Years. Jeffrey Epstein Abused Teen Girls, Police Say. A 77meline of His Case, Miami Herald (Nov. 28,
2018).
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. It CRIM. P. 6(e)
rtlfitt -11111I tivili11111111.11,1331111141 -111311
EXHIBIT F: BIOGRAPHICAL INFORMATION ON FEMALE BUTTERFLY TRUST BENEFICIARIES"
Nvin I) O B CITIZENSHIP ADDRESS PROFESSION DATE DATE
ADDED RENIOYED
PI BLB
CONNECT lov,
TO EPs i r I\
Ghislaine
Maxwell N/AIS N/A
cio FIBRK Associates
575 Lexington Ave.
4th Floor
New Yo NY
N/A 12/27/2006 12/9/2014 Yes
N/A N/A N/A 12/27/2006 12/9/2014 Yes
N/A
12/27/2006 12/9/2014
Yes
1/27/2015 Current"
N/A N/A N/A 3/28/2011 12/9/2014 No
N/A
3/24/2011 12/9/2014
Yes 2/6/2015 Current
Homemaker 3/28/2011 Current Yes
17 The dates of birth, citizenship, address, and profession are all derived from KYC records. The date ranges for the 
beneficiaries arc drawn from trust
documents provided to the Bank. The "Public Connections to Epstein" column is based on Google searches.
16 It is our understanding that the Bank began collecting more detailed KYC information on trust beneficiaries around 
the time that Maxwell, were removed as
beneficiaries. We therefore have more detailed information on some beneficiaries than others.
19 "Current" refers to current status as of the most recent information received by the Bank, prior to the account's 
offboarding.
IS
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
N xmi 9/0/B CITIZENSHIP ADDRESS PROFESSION DATE DATE
ADDED REMOVED
PUBLIC
CONNECTIONS
TO EPSTEIN
Karyna Shuliak Slovakian Student / Interior
Decorator 12/9/2014 Current No
N/A 2/6/2015 Current No
N/A 12/9/2014 Current Yes
N/A 12/9/2014 Current Yes
N/A 3/30/2015 Current No
N/A 4/24/2015 Current Yes
N/A 2/11/2015 Current No
30 Note that there is a discrepancy between the information provided to the Bank and the information listed in the KYCs.
A document containing passports or
driver's licenses for each Butterfly Trust beneficiary identifies Jennifer Kahn's address as 301 East 66th Street, Apt. 
2G. In the KYC records, however, Kahn's
address is listed as 301 East 66th Street, Apt. 8H. Note that this is the same address as Karyna Shuliak, who has been 
identified to the Bank as Kahn's wife.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
rittite111113111 anl intrn
EXHIBIT G: SUMMARY OF PAYMENTS TO BUTTERFLY TRUST BENEr:CIA RI ES
BENEFICIARS
N k NIU
DIN I I I
E \.1 \ II \ I s I ()I ‘I. DJ'.
$9
I •'s DIRE(' f
PAY mENTs2 I
No
R ‘TIONA LES LISTED
FOR PAYMENTS
N/A
BENEFICIARY EFSTEIN-AFFILIATED BASICS ACCOUNT N/A N A 0 $0 Yes Hotel Expenses N/A Jeffrey Epstein
G is ame Maxwell 0 $0 TBD . N/A N/A Darren K. Indyke PLLC 2 $475,821 No N/A AO Raiffeisenbank
Standard Chartered Butterfly Trust
Jeffrey Epstein 9 $330,782 No Expense Reimbursements Wells Fargo Jeffrey Epstein
NES, LLC Karyna Shuliak 6 $631,00022 Yes Tuition JP Morgan Chase Butterfly Trust
Jeffrey Epstein K na Sh • 4 $70,400 No Rent Deutsche Bank Jeffrey Epstein 5 $29,357 No N/A Bank of America Butterfly 
Trust 4 $26,970 Yes Unknown Banca Del
Fucino
Butterfly Trust
Jeffrey Epstein
LSJE, LLC 8 $290,625 Yes Unknown JP Morgan Chase
TD Bank Butterfly Trust
Jeffrey Epstein
63 $552,243 Yes
Expense Reimbursements
Immigration Services
Loans
Rent
Tuition
TD Bank
Wells Fargo Butterfly Trust
Jeffrey Epstein
I $250,000 TBD Unknown Bank of America Butterfly Trust 8 $106,686 No Expense Reimbursements Bank of America
Barclays Bank
JP Morgan Chase
Butterfly Trust
Jeffrey Epstein
LSJE,LLC
71 See Exhibits NI, N, and R for more information on indirect payments. " This total includes a single 5150,000 payment 
to "WINS LLC." The wire details reflect
that this payment was credited to Shuliak's JP Morgan account. 17
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRIM. P. 6(e)
■1[11111111111111111111111111111111111111111
$63,254 No
Grand Prix Driving
Reimbursements for
Classes & JE Purchases
JP Morgan Chase
Standard Chartered Bank
Butterfly Trust
Jeffrey Epstein
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
MP' ..... 'JP D112.112JP243.P.113411 .11JJSI
EXHIBIT H: TIMELINE OF DIRECT PAYMENTS TO BUTTERFLY TRUST BENEFICIARIES
Dui
12/5/2013
I : i \i I li i xio k‘iiit \I
$20,000
B \\I•
Wells Fargo
II \( «II \I
NES, LLC
JE ACCOUNT #
12/18/2013 $50,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein 12/19/2013 $25,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein 12/19/2013 $100,000 Wells Fargo 
NES, LLC 1/9/2014 $40,000 TD Bank Jeffrey
Epstein 1/17/2014 $125,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein 1/21/2014 $14,000 JP Morgan Jeffrey Epstein 5/30/2014 $25,000 JP 
Morgan Jeffrey Epstein 6/3/2014 $64,000 JP
Morgan Jeffrey Epstein 6/11/2014 K na Sh • $25,000 JP Morgan Jeffrey Epstein 9/22/2014 $49,649 Wells Fargo Jeffrey 
Epstein 10/22/2014 $50,000 TD Bank Jeffrey
Epstein 11/18/2014 $10,000 JP Morgan Jeffrey Epstein 1/28/2015 $25,000 JP Morgan Butterfly Trust 1/28/2015 $50,000 JP 
Morgan Butterfly Trust 2/6/2015 $15.000 JP
Morgan Butterfly Trust 2/6/2015 $20,000 TD Bank Butterfly Trust 2/6/2015 K na Shul $50,000 JP Morgan Butterfly Trust 
2/11/2015 $10,000 Deutsche Bank Butterfly
Trust 3/27/2015 $238,551 AO Raiffeisenbank Jeffrey Epstein 3/30/2015 $237,270 Standard Chartered Butterfly Trust 
4/22/2015 $50,000 JP Morgan Butterfly Trust
4/24/2015 $10,000 Bank of America Butterfly Trust 5/15/2015 $51,091 Wells Fargo Jeffrey Epstein 8/25/2015 $14,000 JP 
Morgan Jeffrey Epstein 9/24/2015 $23,625 JP
Morgan Butterfly Trust 11/3/2015 $10,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein 11/3/2015 $15,000 Wells Fargo Jeffrey Epstein 2/25)2016
a Karyna Shuliak $13,800 Deutsche Bank
Jeffrey Epstein
23 For the sake of brevity, we have only included payments equaling or in excess of $10,000.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRIM. P. 6(e)
put
4/14/2016
Itl N. I I 14 I \It)
.' Karyna Shuliak
k‘141I \I
$21,600
I4\\K
Deutsche Bank
.Iii .\r tin \I
Jeffrey Epstein
JE ACCOUNT #
5/5/2016 $10,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein
7/15/2016 $14,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein
10/26/2016 $72,455 Wells Fargo Jeffrey Epstein
11/4/2016 Ka na Shuliak $350.000 JP Morgan Jeffrey Epstein
3/13/2017 $10,000 Deutsche Bank Jeffrey Epstein
3/24/2017 $45,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein
8/1/2017 $30,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein
9/25/2017 iltateShuliak $28,000 JP Morgan Jeffrey Epstein
3/8/2018 Karyna Shuliak $10,000 Deutsche Bank Jeffrey Epstein
7/6/2018 Karyna Shuliak $28,000 JP Morgan Jeffrey Epstein
7/9/2018 $20.000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein
7/31/2018 $30,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein
8/6/2018 Karyna Shuliak $25,000 Deutsche Bank Jeffrey Epstein
8/8/2018 $30,000 Bank of America Butterfly Trust
12/3/2018 $250,000 Bank of America Butterfly Trust
1/14/2019 $12,841 Barclays LSJE, LLC
4/8/2019 $27,000 Wells Fargo Butterfly Trust
4/30/2019 $19,395 Barclays LSJE, LLC
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
assisisssittinlit31111111111111111111111)111
EXHIBIT I: SUMMARY OF PAYMENTS TO OSTENSIBLE FOREIGN MODEL,.
MODEL # OF DIRECT SUM OF DIRIXT 'NOIRE( I RATIONALES
PAYMENTS PAYMENTS PAYMENTS LISTED
BENEFICIARY
BANKS
EPSTEIN-AFFILIATED
ACCOUNT
$192,244 Yes
i him,
Trips
Tuition
JP Morgan
HBRk Associates. In).
Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)24
The Butterfly Trust
18 $156,283 Yes Immigration
Services25 Bank of America Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
8 $56,831 Yes Rent Alfa Bank
Barclays
LSJE, LLC
The Butterfly Trust
17 $51,769 Yes Tuition Sberbank
BCN, PLA De Palaue WE, LLC
7 $49,928 No N/A
Alior Bank
Citibank
Deutsche Bank
Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
13 $49,050 No N/A BNP Paraibas
Jeffrey Epstein (DC)t'
Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
LSJE, LLC 3 S38,615 Yes Tuition JSC VTB Bank LSJE, LLC
4 $38,500 Yes Tuition Citibank
Sberbank
Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
LSJE, LLC 7 $31,500 No N/A JP Morgan Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
8 528,425 Yes Tuition Bank of America
Deutsche Bank Jeffrey Epstein (DC)
7 526,480 Yes N/A Sberbank
Tinkoff Bank LSJE, LLC
4 Jeffrey Epstein (NOW) signifies Jeffrey Epstein's personal checking account, also referred to as a NOW or SuperNOW 
account.
" Jeffrey Epstein made numerous payments to a New York-based immigration attorney, Mehmet Beskardes. The wire details 
frequently reference foreign women who
have received payments from Epstein.
a Jeffrey Epstein (DC) signifies Jeffrey Epstein's domestic custody account.
" We have identified an ma=' that appears to be a Russian model.
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRIM. P. 6(e)
[SSD 15 15 15 35 IWIZZaZiarnai liZalZAJJJZ.2441) .9.41/orn4liadlia4iiiii
Moon. # OF DIRECT
PAYMENTS
NUM OF DIRECT
P tN MENTS
$19,563
I \ DIRECT
1' ‘NMENTS
Yes
RATIONALES
LISTED
No
Ili si i n i kin
If ‘ \K'
Swedbank
AB DNB Lithuania
EPSTEIN-AFFILIATED
ACCOUNT
Jeffrey Epstein (DC)
LSJE, LLC
5 $18,985 Yes N/A Seb Banka
Jeffrey Epstein (DC)
Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
LSJE, LLC
5 $13,861 No N/A Wells Fargo Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
7 $13,078 No N/A Sberbank LSJE, LLC
3 $12,900 No N/A
National Economic Bank for
Foreign Economic Activity
for the Republic of
Uzbekistan
Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
2 $12,500 No N/A JP Morgan Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
6 $11,834 No N/A Tatra Bank Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
5 $10,000 No N/A Bank of America Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
I $9,263 No N/A Alfa Bank LSJE, LLC
3 $8,500 No WA JP Morgan Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
3 $7,000 Yes Tuition Swedbank LSJE, LLC
1 $5,000 No N/A Bank of America Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
1 $4.000 No N/A Bank of America Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
1 $2,926 No WA BNP Paraibas LSJE, LLC
I $2,714 No N/A Swedbank Jeffrey Epstein (DC)
1 $2,500 No N/A Sberbank LSJE, LLC
I $400 No N/A PJSC CB Privatbank LSJE, LLC
0 $0 Yes Immigration
Services N/A Jeffrey Epstein (NOW)
a  This may be a Russian woman who goes by the name'-' on li tstagram.
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. It CRIM. P. 6(e)
monanissiniii3133/3/131111111111341111331
EXHIBIT J: CASH WITHDRAWALS IN EXCESS OF S10,000
TRANS.
DATE
Tit N. \ ‘,. ON PERSON
COSMIC I ING BEHALF OF TRANS.
V 1 ril \ I
\N. \II
&CCM NI
NI mBER
US
DOI I %RS ., I/R \ n \
EURO\
DR t‘\ \
TOTAL
DRAWN
(IND)
CTR CONINIENTS
11/15/2013 Jettro AFEX ' Epstein Harry Beller Jeffrey
Epstein N/A E15,000 $20,723 FX for 15,000 EUROS
12/17/2013 Jeffrey
Epstein Harry Beller Epstein
Jeffiey N/A €15,100 $21,150
AFEX FX for 15,100 EUROS
(21,150 USD). Client originally
wanted 15,00 Euros but due to FX
rate change, amends to 15,100
EUROS.
1/31/2014 Jeffrey
Epstein Harry Beller Jeffrey
Epstein cashed $40,000 €15,000 $60,775 AFEX FX for 15,000 EUROS Client
check for 40k at branch
5/27/2014
Darren K
Indyke
PLLC
Darren Indyke
Darren K
Indyke
PLLC
$40,000 N/A $40,000
Client cashed check for 40k at
branch
2/11/2016
Darren K
Indyke
PLLC
& Jeffrey
Epstein
Darren Indyke
Darren K
Indyke
PLLC;
Jeffrey
Epstein
$4,000 (DIU)
$7 500 (JE) , N/A $11,500
Client is Jeffrey Epstein's personal
attorney, withdrew 7.5k from
Epstein's account and in addition,
withdrew 4k from his own account
for Darren K Indyke PLLC.
12/13/2016
Darren K
Indyke
PLLC
& Jeffrey
Epstein
Darrenen Indyke
Darren K
Indyke
PLLC;
Jeffrey
Epstein
(DKI)
$7,500 (JE) N/A $11,500
Client is Jeffrey Epstein's personal
attorney, withdrew 7.5k from
Epstein's account and in addition,
withdrew 4k from his own account
for Darren K Indyke PLLC.
9/19/2017 Jeffrey
Epstein Ep Darren Indyke rey
Jeff stein $35,000 N/A $35,000
35k cashed check from Jeffrey
Epstein account, as per previous
conversation, Indyke was adivsed
against withdrawing cash on
consecutive days and this is the first
CTR since.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRIM. P. 6(e)
It$111.1111311,11333,1131 313.11.1.111413Miiiii4144141
P/ ItsoN TRANS. TRANS. ON CONDI ( I INC DATE BEIIALF OF TR ‘s s.
US ACCOUNT ACCOUNT DOLLARS NAME NUMBER DRA11N
TOTAL EUROS DRAWN D/LtIVN (USD)
CTR CONINIEN1S
10/6/2017 Jeffrey
Epstein Darren Indyke Jeffrey
Epstein $7,500 C6,000 $14,700
Acct had 7.5k cashed check from
Jeffrey Epstein account, in addition
there was 7.2k check for 6000
EUROs. Client states he is traveling
to Paris. Total cash out is $14,700
USD.
12/19/2017 Jeffrey
Epstein Darren Indyke Jeffrey
Epstein $7,500 67,000 $15,991
Acct had 7.5k cashed check from
Jeffrey Epstein account, in addition
there was $8,491 for 7000 EUROs.
Client states he is traveling to Paris.
Total cash out is $8,491 USD.
1/17/2018 Jeffrey
Epstein Darren Indyke Jeffrey
Epstein $100,000 E7,000 $108,778
Acct had 100k cashed check from
Jeffrey Epstein account, in addition
there was $8,778 for 7000 EUROs.
Client is taking out cash because
branch is closing. Total cash out is
$108,778 USD.
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. It. CRIM. P. 6(e)
iJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJtliiiLWiln
ctr i"~≤c
EXHIBIT K: HEDGE FUND INVESTMENTS
12" I( \i) ,fl \Ni lo , lui \I • I P•i i i• \( c ) •I N( i ,n NI #
Boothbay Absolute Strategies Fund LP 5 $28,250,000 Southern Financial LLC Boothbay Multi Strategy Fund LP I 510,000,000 
Southern Financial LLC Honeycomb
Partners LP 71'1°i 6 $63,000,000 s Southern Trust Company Inc. Honeycomb Ventures IV LP I $10,000,000 The 2017 
Caterpillar Trust Valar Global Fund II LP 5
$6,300,000 Southern Trust Company Inc. Valar Global Fund III LP II $22,500,000 Southern Trust Company Inc.
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
6112 22122 2 222 innntinniinnintininallaaa
EXHIBIT L: POTENTIAL SETTLEMENT PAYMENTS
\ I I
6/13/2017
RI i \ I
Jeffrey S Pop
kNioi
S10,000
ACCOUNT ACCOUNT #
Jeffrey Epstein
WIRE Dix.VLS
Reference Doe 43 v Epstein et
al" 12/19/2018 Boles Schiller Flexner $500,000 Jeffrey Epstein "Payment pursuant to
settlement" 1/4/2019 Searcy Denney Scarola
Barnhart PA
S7,000,000 Jeffrey Epstein "Settlement payment as per

Section 2 of settlement
[agreement]"
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRIM. P. 6(e)
EXHIBIT M: SUSPECTED PAYMENTS FOR LEGAL EXPENSES OF CO-CONSPIRATORS
L tw FIRM BENEFICIARY PA1 MEN IS Tor.u. i r‘i i I. ‘c «fi \i BACKGROUND
A I ston & Bird , $150,000
Co t 10-0
Darren K. Indyke
PLLC
Alston & Bird represented in the lawsuit
Jane Doe 43 v. Epstein. 21) A I ston did not represent
Epstein. The transaction dates coincide with the
lawsuit.
Coffey
Burlington Alan Dershowitz 3 $37,036 Jeffrey Epstein
Coffey Burlington represented Dershowitz in a
lawsuit filed by an Epstein accuser? The payments
coincided with Dershowitz's involvement in the
suit. Epstein was not represented by Coffey
Burlington.
Haddon, Morgan
and Foreman
P.C.
Ghislaine Maxwell 6 587,902
Darren K. Indyke
PLLC
Haddon represented Maxwell in connection with a
lawsuit filed by Epstein accuser 31
Epstein was not represented by Haddon in the suit.
5 Gut.
th Link &
Rockenbach,
P.A.
Lesley Groff 19 $5,509,464 Jeffrey Epstein
Link & Rockenbach represented Groff and
Epstein in the Jane Doe 43 lawsuit. It is possible
that these payments were made solely for the benefit
of Epstein. The transaction dates coincide with the
lawsuit.
" See Jane Doe v. Epstein, I :17-cv-00616 (S.D.N.Y. filed January 26, 2017).
" Doe v. United Stares of America, 9:08-cv-80736 (S.D. Fla filed July 7, 2008).
" See v. Maxwell, l:15-cv-07433 (S.D.N.Y. filed Sept. 21, 2015).
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
411,  AP ar 41,  Cr 41. ANI er
Scott J. Link le y Groff I $100.000 Jeffrey Epstein See Link and Rockenbach entry, supra.
Steptoe &
Johnson LLP Lesley Groff 8 $490,001 Jeffrey Epstein
Steptoe & Johnson represented both Groff and
Epstein in connection with the Jane Doe 43 lawsuit.
As before, it is possible that these payments were
made solely for services rendered to Epstein. The
transaction dates coincide with the lawsuit.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO PEDAL CRIM. P. 6(e)
............ .110 dia dal -40 --110 4IF • 4I1 41 eV 41
EXHIBIT N: TIMELINE OF PAYMENTS TO (OR ON BEHALF OF) ALLEGED CO-CONSPIRATORS (PAYMENTS ≥$10,000)
DNI I
11/1/2013
BF:NI:FRIAR\
NAME AMOUNT
$1,500
BENEFICIAR\
B %NE
Citibank
BENEFICIARY
ACCOUNT W WIRING ACCOUNT
Jeffrey Epstein
\ \ MINI.
Auto t \T #
WIRE DETAILS/
INSTRUCTIONS
N/A >esigns LLC 12
12/2/2013 Designs LLC $1,500 Citibank Jeffrey Epstein N/A
12/4/2013 MC2 Model
Management" $25,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein N/A
12/10/2013 MC2 Model
Management $29,440 SunTrust Bank Jeffrey Epstein N/A
12/11/2013 Larry Visoski" $225,000 Bank of America Jeffrey Epstein N/A 12/20/2013 Larry Visoski $16,676 Bank of America 
Jeffrey Epstein Petty cash
1/21/2014 MC2 Model
Mana ement $25,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein N/A
1/21/2014 f $14,000 JP Mor • an Chase Jeffre Epstein N/A 4/2/2014  Designs LLC $20,000 Citibank Jeffre Epstein N/A
4/10/2014 301/66 Owners
Corp" $182,219 Citibank Jeffrey Epstein N/A
5/2/2014 301/66 Owners Corp $50,000 Citibank Jeffrey Epstein N/A
32 SLK Designs LLC is a controlled business entity
" Jeffrey Epstein has been accused of conspiring with the owner of MC2 Model Management, Jean Luc Brunel, to lure young 
European models to the United States for
illicit purposes. Epstein and Brunel allegedly housed the models in apartments located at 301 East 66th Street, New 
York, NY.
Larry Visoski or "Lawrence P. Visoski" is Epstein's longtime pilot.
has not been publicly identified as a co-cons irator. Howeverillp. name appears in flight records for Jeffrey Epstein's 
private plane at the time the alleged
activity took place. Jeffrey Epstein adde neficiary to e Butterfly Trust between March 2011 and January 2014. In the 
Bank's KYC records, lists her primary
address as 301 East 66th ree , New York, NY 10065—the address where Epstein allegedly housed young models.
J6 This appears to be the entity that owns the property at 301 East 66 St., the property where Epstein allegedly housed 
young models. A publication, Crain's New
York. has reported that 301/66 Owners Corp. is an affiliate of Ossa Properties. See Will Bredderman, Unraveling the Web 
of Epstein's Manhattan Real Estate,
Crain's New York Business (July I I, 2019), available at: 
https://www.crainsnewyoric.com/real-estate/unraveling-web-epsteins-manhattan-real-estate. Ossa
Properties is a real estate company owned by Mark Epstein—Jeffrey's brother.
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Lis. , 1:a))).))1J3J1J21J11111JJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ
D VIE
12/28/2015
BENEFICIARY Nn il
Horizon Title
Services
(Larry Visoski)4i
%mot • i
$1,235,900
BENEFICIARY
BANK
N/A
BENEFICIARY
ACCOUNT ft WIRING ACCOUNT
Jeffrey Epstein
WIRING
ACCOUNT #
WIRE DETAIIS /
I‘s I in c [ un.•
Visoski Purchase
of 1132 San
Michelle Way
2/1/2016 Lesley Groff° $100,000 First Republic
Bank Southern Financial N/A
3/21/2016 Alan Dershowitz
Consultin LLC $85,000 Bank of America Jeffrey Epstein do CBIZ MHM
LLC
7/15/2016 $14,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein N/A
1/3/2017 Lesley Groff $100,000 Bankwell Bank Southern Financial N/A
1/27/2017 301/66 Owners Co i $210,614 JP Morgan Chase NES, LLC 2016 J Epstein
3/24/2017 $45 000 TD Bank Jeffre E 'stein N/A
3/28/2017 Lawrence P 'mos t $50,000 Bank of America Southern Financial Promissory note
6/21/2017 Larry Visoski $12,500 Bank of America Jeffrey Epstein N/A
8/1/2017 $30,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein N/A
12/19/2017 Lesley Groff &
Daniel Groff $100,000 E Trade Bank Southern Financial N/A
1/12/2018 Lawrence P Visoski $150,000 Bank of America Southern Financial Promissory note
2/2/2018
Haddon, Morgan and
Foreman, P.C.
(Ghislaine
Maxwell 's
$21,379 Wells Fargo Bank Darren K. Indyke
PLLC N/A
2/12/2018 $40,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein N/A
" This payment was made direct) to Horizon Title Services, but the wire details indicate that Epstein purchased a home 
for Visoski. The wire details read:
"Visoski Purchase of
42 Lesley Groff was one of the four co-conspirators given immunity in connection with Epstein's Non-Prosecution 
Agreement.
4) Through his attorney, Darren Ind l leffry Epstein appears to have paid for Ghislaine Maxwell's legal expenses in 
connection with a 2015 lawsuit filed
against Maxwell by an Epstein accuser. See v
e
. Maxwell, 1:15-cv-07433 (S.D.N.Y. 2015). Maxwell was represented by Haddon, Morgan and Foreman in the suit,
Epstein was not.
CONFIDENTIAL- PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
w Ar 41 ar SJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJJ4IP
Dui BENEFICIARY
N niE \Nun \I BENEFICIY R1
II cs:
BENS] i i I \ ii \
ACCOt • I t. \‘ ilini. ‘i «Ii \I • WIRING WIRE DETAILS!
ACCOUNT0 INSTRt ( I iov,
2/12/2018
Haddon, Morgan and
Foreman, P.C.
(Ghislaine Maxwell)
$25,000 Wells Fargo Bank Darren K. Indyke
PLLC
Reference
Mai iinerli
vEpstein
3/7/2018 Alston and Bird LLP 5 $50,000 Wells Fargo Bank Darren K. Indyke
PLLC
Reference
invoice
2017 I Epstein 4/26/2018 301166 Owners Corp $202,840 JP Morgan Chase NES, LLC
6/12/2018 Alston Sc Bird $100,000 TBD44 Darren K. Indyke
PLLC
Client 065749;
matter: 491993.
Full and final
payment for
services
rendered through
June 12, 2018. 8/8/2018 $30,000 Bank of America Butterfly Trust N/A
9/21/2018
Haddon, Morgan and
Foreman, P.C.
(Ghislaine $22,902 Wells Fargo Bank Darren K. Indyke
PLLC
Reference
Statement No
309394 Ace
No2592.0002 11/27/2018 $45,000 TD Bank JEGE, LLC N/A 11/30/2018
oil $100,000 TD Bank Butterfly Trust N/A 12/3/2018
Lawrence P Visoski
$250,000
$175,000
Bank of America Butterfly Trust N/A _12/19/2018 Bank of America Southern Financial Promissory note
12/19/2018 Lesley Groff $110,000 First Republic
Bank Southern Financial N/A
*Alston & Bird represented in the lawsuit referenced in Footnote 11. Alston & Bird did not represent Epstein. "This is a
check payment. We are still trying to
identify the beneficiary bank.
° Jeffrey Epstein's personal attorney, Darren Indyke, made three additional payments to Haddon, Morgan and Foreman, P.C.
that may have been use to cover
Ghislaine Maxwell's legal expenses. A $6,422 wire transfer on October 5, 2017; a $7,756 transfer on June 14, 2018; and a
$3,795 wire transfers on June 19, 2018.
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. It CRIM. P. 6(e)
L1113333.313133313333111111311JIMMididdidi El
1/14/2019
1/16/2019
2/15/2019
4/30/2019
BENEFICIARY
NAND
Lawrence P Visoski
301/66 Owners Corp
301 East 66th Street
Condominium Corp
$12,841
$229,800
$19,395
BENEFICIARY BENEFICIARY WIRING ACCOUNT
WIRING WIRE DETAILS/
BANK k( ot ACCOUNT # INSTRUCTIONS
Barclays Bank
Bank of America
JP Morgan Chase
JP Morgan Chase
LSJE, LLC
Southern Financial
NES, LLC
NES, LLC
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRIM. P. 6(e)
N, A
Loan
2018 J Epstein
Reference 2018
Storage fees
ren wawa an aaaaniiiii30060,41100 IP I I APO
EXHIBIT 0: PAYMENTS TO EPSTEIN-AFFILIATED INDIVIDUALS & ENTITIES (NOT ONBOARDED BY DEUTSCHE BANK)
\\\n I{ \t kcitoi Nu PAYMENTS TO FAL BEN EFICI.%R1 BANK EPSTEIN AccotINT
Bella Klein
A Linkedln profile belonging to Bella Klein
indicates that she has worked as an accountant
and "assistant controller" at HBRK from
November 1999 until the present. Her profile
describes HBRK as "a financial advisory firm
servicing high net worth individuals with assets
in excess of $1 billion." Klein describes her
duties as "manading] all operational day-to-
day activities for 'high net worth individuals."
Klein's profile suggests that she is a native of
Ukraine; she is also fluent in Russian. The wire
details for two of the payments totaling
$200,000 from Southern Financial indicate that
the payments were "Loan(s)."
3 $215.000 JP Morgan Souther's. IC
ti
3 $27,900 JP Morgan HBR LLC
Charles Pickett
III
Based on the profile of the payments and the
paying entities (aircraft management entities),
Charles Pickett may be Epstein's pilot.
7 $101,993 Vectra Bank Plan D, LLC
5 $32,879 TB1348 Jla.
Christopher
Higgins
Higgins is likely a private pilot used by
Epstein. A Linkedln account belonging to
"Christopher Higgins" identifies Higgins as a
Chief Pilot and 727 First Officer. Jeffrey
Epstein's  private jet, the so-called Lolita
Express, is reportedly a Boeing 727.
8 $17,010 TBD JEGI Inc
Coatue
Enterprises LLC
Coatue Enterprises was registered in New York
on April 27, 2015. Its address listed is "HBRK
Associates, Inc., 575 Lexington Ave., 4th
Floor, New York, NY." Richard Kahn is
identified as the director / officer.
4 $2,000,000 JP Morgan Soli.. LLC
" These are check payments. We are still confining  where the checks were cashed.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
NAME BAckl.Not to P 111NIENTS Tut tl il l \il l( 1 ‘ It \ It \MN F.NiFi• A( ( ot • i
Cypress Inc.
l'uhl IC report, indicate that Cypress, Inc. is a
holding company associated with Epstein's
New Mexican property, the Zorro Ranch.
9 $1,025,000 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
Je rc E stein
David Rodgers
Jeffrey Epstein's former pilot. On July II,

2018. Epstein wired Rodgers $50,000. The
wire details indicate that the payment was a
"Loan." Rodgers does not appear to have
repaid the loan; we have yet to identify a wire
transfer from Rodgers to Epstein.
2 $60,000 PNC National Bank Southern Financial LLC
FT Real Estate
DA. ?IAA -
1110 4 '24:11
This entity appears to be controlled by Epstein.
In September 2014, a New Mexico newspaper
reported that several entities sharing an address
with Jeffrey Epstein's USVI home donated
money to the gubernatorial candidacy of Gary
King." FT Real Estate was among the entities
listed.
11 $12,368,277 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
Jeffrey E stein
Harlequin Dane
LLC
Harlequin Dane filed as an LLC in Florida on
April 17, 2015. Darren Indyke is identified as
the managing member. Notably, this entity was
registered ten days before the creation of
Coatue Enterprises LLC.
5 $4,750,000 TD Bank Southern Financial LLC
Larry E.
Morrison
Morrison is Epstein's former pilot. On May 5,
2014, Epstein wrote a single check for $1,500
to Morrison.
1 $1,500 TBD
JEGE, Inc.
la
Laurel Inc.
Laurel. Inc. appears to be an Epstein-controlled
entity. Similar to FT Real Estate, this entity
shares a USVI address with Epstein and made
contributions to New Mexico gubernatorial
candidate, Gary King.
3 $455,000 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
Jeffrey Epstein
6 $995,000 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
Jeffrey Epstein
iiiii.IIIN
a Steve Terrell, King Donors' Address Tied to Sex Offender, Santa Fe New Mexican (Sept. 8, 2014),
https://onvw.santafenewmexican.cominews/local_news/lcing-donors-address-tied-to-sex-offender/article_705feb90-3868-11e4-
a341-0017a43b2370.html
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Lti111O111111111111314114144iiiiiiiiiiIiiiiii
\ \\II II \I. KI. IiIil \II I' \1 \ I I \ IS Toni, BENEFICI %RV B‘NI, ErsrriN Arent iN i
Maple, Inc.
Maple appears to be an Epstein-controlled
entity. Similar to FT Real Estate, this entity
shares a USVI address with Epstein and made
contributions to New Mexico gubernatorial
candidate, Gary King.
5 $650,000 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
Jeffrey E stein
5 $1,725,000 First Bank of Puerto
Rico jiiiiiiiii
We have been unable to confirm the identity of
this individual. Wire details suggest that the
payments were for expense reimbursements
and services rendered. The payment dates
suggests worked for Epstein in
some capacity from November 2013 to
September 2017.
87 $202,823 First Command Bank NES, LLC
Michelle Saipher
Saipher is the wife of Epstein's personal Darren
Indyke. It is unclear whether she works for
Epstein in some capacity. The referenced
payment was made on May 16, 2014.
1 $1,825,000 TD Bank Jeffre stein
Michelle's
Transport Co.
The payments fit the profile of an Epstein- Epstein-
controlled  i.e.,large, round number
payments to a First Bank of Puerto Rico bank
account. Michelle also is the name of Darren LLC Fi rst
Indyke's wife (Michelle Saipher).
2 $30,000 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
Jefaifin
5 $350,000 Bank of Puerto
Rico
Jeffre E stein
Nautilus, Inc.
Nautilus appears to be an Epstein-controlled
entity. Similar to FT Real Estate, this entity
shares a USVI address with Epstein and made
contributions to New Mexico gubernatorial
candidate, Gary King.
2 $150,000 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
J ffre E stein
3 $200000 , First Bank of Puerto
Rico
Jeffrey Epstein
Southwestern
Trust Company
Inc.
Fits profile for Epstein-controlled entity, i.e.,
large, round number payments to a First Bank
of Puerto Rico bank account. The entity name
also closely resembles Southern Trust
Company, Inc.
2 $450,000 First Bank of Puerto Rico
Southern Trust Company,
Inc.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
t11 111)1111)31b)3415V5V51424hAllAIMMJIMIJJJ
\ \ \II BACKGROUND PAYMENTS TOTAL BENEFICIARY BANK EPSTEIN AccotNT
Thomas World
Air LLC
Fits profile for Epstein-controlled entity, i.e.,
large, round number payments to a First Bank
of Puerto Rico bank account. The entity name
3 $150,000 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
. Jeiiiiiiii
may be a reference to St. Thomas. Epstein
reportedly reached his private island, Little St.
James, by flying a helicopter from an
international airport in St. Thomas.
4 $400,000 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
Jas .
Valdson Vieira
Cotrin
Fits the profile of an Epstein employee. From
May 2014 to May 2019, Epstein-controlled
accounts made monthly payments to Valdson.
The payments were often for the same amount
(e.g., $3,371.94). Epstein appears to have used
his custody account to pay Valdson in foreign
currency, e.g., Euros. Cotrin's name appears in
Epstein's "black book."
65 $201,278 Credit Lyonnais Jeffrey Epstein (Custody)
8 $25,788 Credit Lyonnais Jeffrey Epstein
5 $29,174 Banco do Brasil LSJE, LLC
William G.
Hammond
Jeffrey Epstein's pilot. The wire details
reference "Pilot Services" and "Expense
Reimbursement." Epstein-controlled accounts
made payments to Hammond from August
2015 until May 2019.
6 $67,159 JP Morgan Plan D LLC
IIIIIMIIIM
16 $207,278 JP Morgan JEGE, LLC
4 $21,908 TBD JILCIE Inc.
William J.
DiMauro
Jeffrey Epstein's pilot. The wire details
reference "Pilot Service." The payments were
made from November 2013 to January 2019.
8 $34,893 TBD JEGE, LLC
8 $63,781 Bank of America Jeffre stein
Epstein made
payments to am July 2014 to
March 2019. The wire details for a $54,000
payment to n March 28, 2019
indicates that the payment was a "Loan."
I $1,000 TBD Jeffigiiin
3 $80,122 Bank of America Jeffrey Epstein
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
EXHIBIT P: NOTABLE PAYMENTS TO HIGH PROFILE INDIVIDUALS
Ri ( Olt NI H\11 Ho kc.R01 \11 AMOI \I ( IA A( ( oi Ni N %MI A( ( ol N I 4
Achrayut
Leumit Ltd. 3/6/2017
Achrayut Leumit appears to be an Israeli NGO founded to support Ehud Barak's political endeavors. Barak served as the 
Prime Minister of Israel from July 1999 to
March 2001. Barak reportedly frequents a property, 301 E 66th St., where Epstein allegedly housed underage models.
$40,000 W HBRK Associates,
Inc.
Alan
Dershowitz
1/15/2015 Dershowitz has been accused in a civil lawsuit of engaging in sex acts with Epstein's underage victims. The 
later payment was made to "Alan Dershowitz
Consulting LLC."
$15,487 C Jeffrey Epstein
3/21/2016 $85,000 W Jeffrey Epstein
Barry Jay
Josephson 10/17/2013
This may be an American film producer and former President of Columbia Pictures (1991 — 1997). The wire details identify
this transaction as a "Promissory
Note."
$200,000 W Jeffrey Epstein
Benny Shabtai
CP' TA ° 1403-1\
4/13/2017
Shabtai is an Israeli-born, American businessman. He was the President of Raymond Weil USA until 2009. He and his family
also owned a controlling share of an
Israeli instant-messaging app called Viber until 2014.
$6,100 W Jeffrey Epstein
est VA
7/1:i
Marsha ‘ Moskowitz
Foundation
1/7/2016 andBruce Moskowitz appears to be a Mar-A-Lago member
Moskowitz and two other individuals interfered with the work of Veterans Affairs officials. VA officials referred to 
Moskowitz in emails as "a POTUS
friend/doctor" and as "the [Doctor] from W Palm that is connected to Trump."
$50,000 W Gratitude America,
7/12/2016 $50,000 W Gratitude America,
Ltd.
12/6/2017 $50,000 W Gratitude America,
Ltd.
Cecile de Jongh 12/29/2015
De Jongh is the former First Lady of the U.S. Virgin Islands. There have been public reports that she worked as an 
"Office Manager" for Epstein's companies
during her husband's tenure as Governor. John de Jongh's term ended in January 2015.
$200,000 W Southern Trust
Company, Inc.
Joichi Ito
7/2/2014 Ito is a Japanese entrepreneur, the director of the MIT Media Lab, and a current Board Member at the New York 
Times Company. Epstein appears to have
provided capital for multiple Ito-led ventures. For example, the wired details for the September 2014 transaction read: 
"subcr to Kyara Investment III, LLC to
fund Blockstream Investment."
$250,000 W Southern Financial
LLC
9/9/2014 $500 001 , W Southern Financial
LLC
3/12/2015 $250 ,000 W Southern Financial
LLC
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
PP Il ligeDDOOMOD00000150041300430.CMCIDGCEDICCII•6•0
RECIPIENT D vi t.
10/5/2016
BACKGROUND ANKH • I
81.983
(/W'
C
Ac c ot • I N nll
Jeffrey Epstein
V ( ot • i it
Joichi Ito
(Neoteny 3, LP)
This payment was made directly to Neoteny 3, LP, which is
a Joichi Ito-led investment vehicle. The wire details
indicate that the payment is a "Subscription and Capital
Call."
,000,000 W Southern Financial
LLC
Kathy
Rueminler 5/1/2019
Ruemmler is President Barack Obama's former White
House Counsel. She is currently a Partner at Latham &
Watkins where she has represented George Nader in
connection with the Mueller probe. Epstein did not pay
Ruemmler directly. The wire was sent to "JetSuite Air," a
private jet charter company. The wire details read:
"Reference Kathy Ruemmler."
$53,750 W Jeffrey Epstein
L H Summers
Economic
Consulting LLC
11/7/2014 This appears to be the consulting firm for Larry Summers, a
former Hary
Administration official. The wire details indicate that the
payment was for "Travel Expenses."
$1,196 W Southem Trust
11/24/2014
$37 W Southern Trust
Company, Inc.
Lawrence
Krauss
4/5/2018
Krauss is a physicist, and former professor at Yale and
Arizona State University ("ASU"). In February 2018,
Krauss was publicly accused of making unwanted sexual
advances to young women and groping a woman's breast.
In July 2018, ASU fired Krauss after conducting an internal
investigation.
$15,000 W Gratitude America,
Ltd.
11/5/2018 $10,000 W Jeffrey Epstein
Maria Drokova 12/29/2017
Maria "Masha" Drokova is the Founder and General partner
of a venture capital firm called Day One Ventures. She was
recently named to Forbes' 2019 30 Under 30 for Venture
Capital. She has gamered attention because she previously
led a Russian patriotic youth movement called Nashi, which
has been implicated in harassing people critical of President
Putin's regime.
$7,027 C Jeffrey Epstein
Noam Chomsky 12/3/2018
Chomsky is a renowned linguist and part-time professor at
the University of Arizona. Chomsky's Wikipedia page
indicates that his salary is covered by philanthropic
donations. The wire details don't identify the purpose of the
wire.
$269,159 W Darren K. Indyke
PLLC
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. FL CIUM. P. 6(e)
TT4431111111111111S1144.14444411114411414441441
REVIPIF • I Ihri IIWICGMM) %Thu • i ( /NV k( ( ()I \"F N. \MI V ( (II \ I .-
Paul Krassner 10/30/2018
Krassner was the founder of the freethought magainze The
Realist. He was also a prominent figure in the
counterculture movement. In the 1960s he was a member of
Ken Kesey's Merry Pranksters and helped found the
Yippies.
$2,000 C Jeffrey Epstein
Peggy
Inc
Siegal,
7/13/2017 Siegal is a high profile New York-based publicist and event
planner. The wire details for two payments indicate that the
payments were "consulting fee[s]." Netflix and the FX
Channel recently severed ties with Siegal based on her
connections to Epstein.
$30,000 W Jeffrey Epstein
8/4/2017 $25,000 W Jeffrey Epstein
7/30/2018 $30,000 C Jeffrey Epstein
Sultan Bin
Sulayem 7/19/2017
Sulayem is a member of one of Dubai's most prominent
business and political families. He is currently the CEO of
DP World—a global port operator.
$6,200 W Jeffrey Epstein
Terje Roed
Larsen 12/21/2015
Larsen is a Norwegian diplomat who
prominence as a key figure in the negotiations
Oslo Accords. Epstein appears to have
benefactor of Larsen's New York-based
International Peace Institute, Inc. ("I
came to international
that led to the
been a significant
think tank—the
I").
$250,000 W Southern Trust
Company. Inc.
Woody Allen 11/21/2017 Allen has been photographed leavin
home thrown in honor of Prince A drew.
a party at Epstein's $3,134. C Jeffrey Epstein
SiLnL
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRIM. P. 6(e)
lir, bit i I PS be feettatedledl iDeOCCADCCIDOCCOnwiwiviiiirn
EXHIBIT Q: POTENTIALLY NOTABLE PAYMENTS
N \\II \( KI.I21/1"I)
We have been unable to confirm the identity of
this individual; however, the payments fit the
profile of an Epstein employee, i.e., recurring
llv in eoual amounts.
Andrey
Gennadevich
Silinsky
Ann M.
Rodriquez
We have been unable to confirm the identity of
this individual. These payments are being
flagged because the payments were sent to a
Russian bank account and the wire details don't
explain the purpose of the transactions.
Rodriquez maintained a bank account at First
Bank of Puerto Rico, in line with many other
Epstein-affiliated entities. In 2018 and 2019,
Epstein wired two "Loan(s)" totaling $25,000
to Rodriquez. On April 8, 2019, Epstein
wired $5,000 to Rodriquez. The wire details
read simply We know that Epstein
has made tuition/summer camp payments on
behalf of a minor named
In late December 2015/early January 2016,
Epstein purchased a "2009 Dodge 3500 XLT
Wheeled Coach Ambulance" from a Montana-
based ambulance dealer.
We have been unable to identify the identity of
this individual; however, the payments fit the
Apgar
Ambulances
\N \II TOI BENEFICIARY BANK EPSTEIN ACCOUNI
4 $21,325 Banco do Brasil Jeffrey Epstein (Custody)
6 $35,457 Banco do Brasil LSJE, LLC
5 $28,840 TBD
3 $30,000 Bank of America Jeffre E stein
1 $32,600 First Bank of Puerto
Rico
Jeffrey Epstein
2 $43,634 First Interstate Bank
of Bozeman
LS LLC
26 $68,009 Societe Generale Jeffrey Epstein (Custody)
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
WV Ma go /7 A7 rt 85 OD A RY irt R7 A It KJ ID ID II V V IQ IO el 49 VI V efs Viagoips up gpineees
's. \\II B ‘i k(.14O1 NI) I) \ N Nil \ I % Toni, Bi NI ii( I tin B\\K E'S' is iN A( ( Ol \I
profile of an Epstein employee. The wire
details for trips reference trips to Milan,
Portugal, and Bologna, as well as hotels in St.
Petersburgh and Moscow. There is also a
single wire transfer that reads: "
expenses."
a foreign woman who has also
received multiple payments from Epstein.
3 $8,195 Societe Generale
33 $75,209 Societe Generale LSJE LLC
I $27,000 Societe Generale The Bu rusttterfl T
Atlantic State
Consultants LLC
There is limited public information about this
entity. Public records indicate that "Russell
Hernandez" is the entity's registered agent. On
January 22, 2018, the wire details for a $4,757
payment reference an "Island Trip."
3 $41,600 JP Morgan LSIE, LLC
Bais Yaakov of
Ramapo
This appears to be a private, Jewish, all-girls
high school in Suffern, New York. The wire
details do not specify why the payments were
made.
2 $40,720 TBD
Bernard M.
Kruger, MD
Kruger is a New York-based internist and
oncologist. Each of the five payments listed
was for exactly $25,000. Four of the five
payments were checks. The wire details for the
sole wire transfer reads: "Priority Private Care
for Mr. Epstein and 5 assistants." In a
recently filed lawsuit, Katlyn Doe v. Indyke,
the plaintiff alleged that she was "provided
with gifts such as .. .medical care for the
purpose of causing her to feel indebted to
Jeffrey Epstein."
3 $75,000 TBD Jeffrey Epstein
1 $25,000 TBD Jeffrev Epstein
I 525,000 JP Morgan Jeffre E stein
Cabinet Alberto
Pinto SARI,
MIN Iclaimed that she dined with
French interior designer, Alberto Pinto, and his
sister, Linda Pinto, in Paris before she was
taken to London to have sex with Prince
Andrew. Alberto Pinto died in 2012. Linda
11 $2,873,001 Credit Agricole
Centre D'Affaires
Jeffrey Epstein (Custody)
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
0401001.16 ha 4 4 44144 4 44 4ii ma aoddid
Nk\ii Fl \el:GROUND
Pinto now manages Cabinet Alberto Pinto
SARL. In Jan 2015, Linda Pinto was
asked about the allegations."
She did not deny dining withabut
denied that she was aware of age.
Alberto Pinto SARL continued to do
substantial amounts of business with Epstein
after these allegations came to light. All of the
payments referenced payments were made
between November 2015 and December 2018.
P.‘VMENTs TOTAL BENEFICIARY BANG EPSTEIN ACCot NT
Fedor Chouliak
We have been unable to confirm the identity of
this individual. We are flagging the payment
because it is an unexplained, round number
payment to an individual with a Belarusian
bank account.
1 $25,000 TBD51 Jeffre E stein
CPRI23, Inc.
CPR123, Inc. is a Manhattan-based CPR
training service. These payments are being
flagged as notable given Epstein's prior
purchase of an ambulance.
2 $667 TBD JeffristAn
I $650 TBD NES, LLC
ese payments may, owever,
have been intended for a different individual.
The NES, LLC account was traditionally used
to make payments for employees of Epstein's
3 $6,518 JP Morgan NES, LLC
MM.
"Natalie O'Neill, Epstein Took 'Sex Slave' on Trip before Pimping Her Out", Page Six (Jan. 8, 2015), 
https://pagesix.com/2015/01/08/cpstein-rendenoused-
with-sex-slave-before-pimping-her-outt
51 The wire details suggest that this payment was routed to a bank in Belarus.
$
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRUM P. 6(e)
IsnishisibliiihhhhAhitilkhol4144444444444441444441i
\\\u II ‘( lo,Rot \i) P %1 \II \ I \ TO I \I Ill \Li I( I kin 81\I; EPSTEIN Arcot \ I
New York properties, and'- is
not a unique name.
John Christensen
We have been unable to confirm the identity of
this individual. In 2013, however, a South
Florida-based doctor, John Christensen, was
arrested and charged with first degree murder
in the deaths of two patients from painkillers.
In January 2017, Christensen pleaded guilty to
two manslaughter counts and was sentenced to
four years in prison. Given that Epstein owned
a home in South Florida, it is possible that this
is the same individual. Notably, the wire
details for an April 30, 2014 transaction
appears to reference a private charter flight in
the U.S. Virgin Islands: "Charter stt to stx." If
Christensen was unable to leave the state of
Florida at the time, then it may rule out Dr.
Christensen as the beneficiary of these
payments.
9 $43,863 Bank of America IIBBAssoc.
2 $6,626 Bank of America LSJE, LLC
I $5,000 Bank of America NES, LLC
Joseph P. Dwyer
Dwyer appears to be a retired New York police
officer turned private investigator. In 2016,
Dwyer was convicted of illegally paying to
access restricted information regarding
witnesses in criminal defense cases. Epstein
I $15,000 JP Morgan  E stein
made the payment o4Xpril 4, 2013
NLR Resorts
International,
LLC
In a 2018 court filing, icholast. Ribis is
identified as the principal of NLR Resorts
International LLC.53 That lawsuit is ongoing
and contains allegations that Ribis perpetrated a
$2.5 million fraud on the plaintiff, Churchill
Downs, Inc. Ribis has connections to the
Trump Organization. He previously served as
1 $125,000 TD Bank Jeffrey Epstein
37 See Churchill Downs, Ma v. MLR Entertainment, LLC, 2:14-ev-03342 (D.N.I. Sept. 25, 2018), ECF No. 95.
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
no rgriffilPilli fitiStrilli fillillillionsit
\ DUI Bu kt.BO1 \B Bk) \B NIS III' \I BI:NEFICIARN B \ \ K EPSTEIN ACCOUNT the President and CEO of Trump Entertainment 
Resorts, Inc.
NLR Ventures
LLC
See entry for NLR Resorts International LLC. 1 $75,000 TD Bank Jeffrey E stei
Roadruck
Investigations,
Inc.
Roadruck is a Jacksonville-based private investigation firm. Each of the listed payments were checks, although only one 
check lends insight into the purpose of
the payment. On January 18, 2017, Darren Indyke wrote a check from the NES, LLC account to Roadruck with the following 
memo line: "R-4-17: Marilyn Morales
Fabro." Nine months later, on October IS, 2017, Darren Indyke wrote a $200 check to Fabro from Epstein's checking 
account. The memo line reads: "Travel
passport."
3 $450 TBD JEGE LLC
1 $150 TBD Darren K. Ind ke LLC
1 $150 TED NES, LLC
I $2,563 TIM Jeffrey Epstein
IIIIIIMI
St. Michael's
Cemetery
Epstein appears to have paid for some type of funeral services. The wire details reference "Contract 15392." The payment
occurred on November 12, 2016.
1 $4,950 TED Jeffrey Epstein
Terrence Rabsatt
A Linkedln account belonging to "Terrence Rabsatt" indicates that Rabsatt is a U.S. Virgin Islands-based "network 
solutions manager." lie appears to provide
wireless installation services. The payment is being flagged because the size of the payments suggest that Rabsatt 
undertook a large project on behalf of
Epstein.
4 $416,120 Banco Popular
Southern Trust Company,
Inc.
Women's Health
of Manhattan
The payment took place on March 14 201 Thew* tails reed' ENS isit 03/0 . I $375 TBD Jeffrey Epstein
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. It CRIM. P. 6(e)
Mr WY IP FP NV FP IV PP FP FTSF IV I -FP Fp rp FJF rI 7/// 14P WV 4/ II VI # 11/ 4/ i/ 41/ -40 i # .10 TIM CP Weal
1:.\ HMI I It: TI I I In \ '‘N \II \ u\ H i l l IT OF CHILDREN /WOMEN
Evilly BENEFICEM H ‘( Rcitot \I) I) % I F. A\IGI \ I EPSTEIN ACCOI \I
The Allen-
Stevenson School
Allen-Stevenson is a New York-based private 7/30/2014 $41,000 jetiic. 1 p‘tein day school for boys.
of Epstein employee Richard Kahn. 2/4/2014 $42,846
The American
University of Paris Unknown There is no beneficiary listed in the wire details. 2/9/2015 $16,583 Jeffrey Epstein
Admiral Farragut
Academy
Admiral Farragut Academy is a private,
preparatory school in St. Petersburg, Florida.
Th children do not share a surname
8/1/2017 $4,600 Jeffrey Epstein
8/1/2017 $4,600
7/1/2015 $25,236 Jeffrey Epstein (Custody)
with an known Epstein affiliates. However,
10/12/2017 $8,643
Jeffrey Epstein
11/21/2017 $8,643
12/20/2017 $17,286
1/12/2018 $26,672
Mef-Bet Child Care,
Inc.
Alef-Bet Child Care is a day care is a private
school in Cambrid Massachusetts.
Bach is
an artificial intelligence expert who previously
worked for the Massachusetts Institute of
Technology Media Lab. Epstein has made
numerous other payments to or on behalf of
Bach.
7/10/2015 $12,480 Jeffrey Epstein
Antilles School
Antilles is a private Pre-K through 12 school in
St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands. We have
identified payments from Epstein to employees
named ant none of the beneficiaries
7/17/2015 $8,697 Jeffrey E stein
8/26/2016 $8,688 Je eyEpstein
1/17/2018 $8,875
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
ENTITY BENEFI( I tit\ 13 ‘). id.rmi \I) 1)‘11 ANIOI\I El's II I\ A('( Of NI
University of
California Regents
appear to have performed work in the U.S.
Virgin Islands.
•
This payment is likely for tuition to the
University of California, Berkeley School of
Law. The wire details reference a "tuition
balance" and "SHIP fee."MIIIIIIIMfl
4/29/2016 $26,2 IS Jeffrey Epstein
Circle F Dude
Ranch Camp LLC
Circle F is a summer camp for children ages 6
through 16. See the Admiral Farragut Academy
entry for information on 5115/2015 $11,340 Jeffrey Epstein
Comfort
Corporation Limited
Comfort Corporation appears to be related to a
language school. The wire details reference
"Intensive Chinese." ppears to be a
Russian model.
1/4/2019 $2 222 , Jeffrey Epstein
Escuela Superior de
Alta Gestion
Escuela Superior is an educational services
company based out of Spain. pears
to be a Russian model.
2/1/2019 $26,505 LSJE LLC
Fairleigh Dickinson
University
Fairleigh Dickinson is a private university
located in New Jersey.
of Epstein employee Harry Beller.
I/20/2015 $7,172 Jeffrey Epstein 4/20/2015 $3,586
8/28/2015 $9,109
Farber's Center for
Academic Success
Farber's is a Brookl n-based tutorin • center.
of
Epstein employee Bella Klein. We have
1/9/2014 $560
Jeffrey Epstein 2/6/2015 $880
2/27/2015 $1,100
4/1/2015 $1,100
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Ik ID F5 RI RD RI nD FD RD n5 ID r0 n5 n5 11 ID ID 10 rl I, 'A 15 1, /I 1 I IP IP IP II ra ra s ra s IN
i \ I I I\ BENEEICIAK1 I{ k( IN(.Rill \I) I)\I I \\IIII \I EPSTEIN ACCOUNT
identified other tuitions payments on behalf of 4/1/2015 $880
4/10/2015 $880
Fashion Institute of
Technology
FIT is a public college in New York City.
inppears to be a Swedish model.
7/11/2016 $8,076 Jeffrey Epstein
il
12/5/2016 $8,076
9/15/2017 $3,589
German
International School
Boston
The school is a German-lan a immersion
school for children.
appear to be the children of Joscha Bach. See
the entry for Alef-Bet Childcare for more
information on Joscha Bach.
6/25/2015 $4,713 Jeffrey Epstein
4/14/2016 $16,850 Jeffrey Epstein
7/13/2017 $14,280
GIBE Sarl
The Glion Institute of Higher Education is a
hospitality management school in Switzerland.
pears to be a Russian model.
8/21/2018 $42,113 HBRK Associates, Inc.
ppears to be a Russian model. 9/15/2017 $42,469 HBRK Associates, Inc.
Institut Villa
Pierrefeu Karyna Shuliak
Institut Villa Pierrefeu is a Swedish "finishing
school." The school specializes in teaching
international etiquette to women. See Exhibit G
and  F for more information on Shuliak.
10/25/2018 $34,586 LSJE, LLC
International
University of
Monaco
IUM is a university in the principality of
Monaco. appears to be a model
based out of the United Kingdom.
10/3/2018 $3,147 LSJE, LLC
Machon Raaya Unknown
Machon Raaya may be a Jewish seminary in
Jerusalem, Israel. The payment was made via
eck contains the memo line: "c/o 7/13/2017 $19,500 Jeffrey Epstein
Mill Basin Day
Camp Unknown Mills Basin is a day camp in Brooklyn, New
York for children aged from Pre-K to 9th grade.
4/13/2015 $1,500 Jeffrey Epstein
12/20/2013 $2,900
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
w win ru re mg FIT re, rty n; 3133311111111111111111111111C
E• i I 1 \
Mississippi College
BENEFICIARY BACKGROUND
Mississippi College is a private Ba list colle e
in Clinton, MS.
of long time Epstein pi of arty isos u.
DATE A\toi Ni
$10,000
EPSTEIN ACCOUNT
1/21/2014 Jeffrey Epstein
The New School
The New School is a private research university
in New York City. ppears to be a
Russian model. She is also listed as a
beneficiary of the Butterfly Trust.
2/4/2014 $29,025
Jeffrey Epstein
1/5/2015 $15,704
6/12/2015 $4,730
8/6/2015 $16,083
12/9/2015 $16,656
6/14/2016 $4,420
1St
7/8/2016 $16,850
1/13/2017 $3,756
1/10/2019 $8,790
New York Film
Academy
NYFA is a for-profit film and acting school.
ppears to be a Russian model. 3/10/2017 $3,442 Jaiisi etein
Nika Ballet Studio
Nika Ballet Studio is a Brooklyn-based dance
studio for young girls.
are likely the daughters Yee
Bella Klein.
11/22/2013 $3,300 Jeffrey Epstein
1/30/2014 $4,160
4/10/2015 $4,370 Jeffrey Epstein
5/19/2016 $7,178
North Broward Prep
School
North Broward is a private, Pre-K through 12
preparatory school in Coconut Creek, Florida.
See above entry for  Academy for more
information on the
2/26/2018 $6,000 Jeffrey Epstein
Q Language Limited
Q Language Limited appears to be a Hong
Kong-based language school. The wire details
reference payments fora 4-and 8-week term.
ppears to be a Russian model.
1/7/2019 $2,221
LSJE, LLC
3/11/2019 $1,109
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
'111/11 .34 I i i JP di i ill,
I \I I I ) BENEFICIARN R\ ( kcitut 'I D‘i i \mot \1 I. PNI i I' A( «)( \I
Seton Hall
University
Seton Hall is a New Jersey-based private,
Catholic university.
Epstein employee Harry Beller.
10/3/2018 $17,060 Jeffrey Epstein
7/8/2017 $11,749
7/13/2018 $4,068
Sh'or Yoshuv
Institute
Sh'or Yoshuv may be an Orthodox Jewish
rabbinical school in Lawrence, NY.
of Epstein employee Harry Beller.
2/19/2019 $15,100 Jeffrey Epstein
Winston Preparatory
School
Winston Preparatory School has locations in
New York, New Jersey, and Connecticut. It
caters to students with learning disabilities.
woes not share a surname with any
known Epstein employees. We also have not
identified any other connections between
Epstein and any individuals with the surname
8/30/2017 $56,850
Jeffrey Epstein 7/21/2014 $5,000
3/27/2015 $26,500
Yeshiva Gedola Ohr
Yisrael Unknown
Yeshiva Gedola is a private, all-boys, Orthodox
Jewish school located in Brooklyn, NY for
grades 10-12. The payment was made via
check, but the memo line does not identify the
intended beneficiary of the payment. It is
possible that the payment was intended for
as he subsequently attended an Orthodox
rabbinical school.
6/5/2015 $24,500 Jeffrey Epstein
IIIIIININSIN
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
WV Ur UP re We re is IP fir I P IP IP IN 'JP fl tlf fie re re re re re re re re re rl riP re re 'P
\Mull S: EPSTEIN LINKS TO OTHER FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS / WEALTH MANAGEMENT FIRMS
FINANCIAL. 1':\ 1111
First Bank Puerto
Rico
Al( ill \ I \\\II
Cypress, Inc.
RI I I\ \\( I
Epstein-Controlled Entity
\< ofNTNI'NIBL'. R ILN•T K•om N WIRI
3/29/2019
FT Real Estate Inc. Epstein-Affiliated Entity 9/29/2017
Jeffrey Epstein N/A 5/10/2019
Gratitude America Ltd. Epstein-Controlled Entity 3/1/2019
Great St. Jim LLC Epstein-Controlled Entity 3/29/2019
IGO Company LLC Entity Partially Acquired by Epstein 12/4/2014
Laurel, Inc. Epstein-Controlled Entity 3/29/2019
LSJE LLC Epstein-Controlled Entity 3/29/2019
3/7/2019
Maple, Inc. Epstein-Controlled Entity 2/22/2019
Michelle's Transport Co. LLC Suspected Epstein-Controlled Entity
Epstein-Controlled Entity
3/29/2019
Nautilus, Inc. 3/29/2019
Southern Trust Company, Inc. Epstein-Controlled Entity 5/16/2019
3n/2019
Southwestern Trust Company, Inc. Suspected Epstein-Controlled Entity 12/16/2013
12/19/2013
Thomas World Air LLC Suspected Epstein-Controlled Entity 2/22/2019
JP Morgan
301/66 Owners Corp. Mark Epstein-Affiliated Entity 2/15/2019
301 East 66th Street Condominium
Corporation Suspected Affiliation with Mark Epstein 2/22/2019
Bella Klein Epstein Employee 4/5/2019
Coatue Enterprises Richard Kahn-Affiliated Entity 11/20/2018
Jeffrey Epstein N/A 12/26/2013
Karyna Shuliak Butterfly Trust Beneficiary 4/11/2019
Alleged Epstein Co-Conspirator 9/24/2015
NES, LLC Epstein-Controlled Entity 11/6/2013
Richard Kahn Epstein's Accountant/CFO 6/22/2018
Butterfly Trust Beneficiary 2/6/2015
Butterfly Trust Beneficiary 11/27/2017
CONFIDENTIAL— PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRIM. P. 6(e)
II ur IP IP Ir am IP mr mo mr pp mo mR mg ty MI MI Mi MR MP MI MI el MI MI MI fp rp fp rdp ri rp fp fp ral fp fp 11
TD Bank
11/30/2018 Darren n.y a Epstein's Personal Attorney 12/19/2018
Darren Indyke PLLC Epstein's Personal Attorney 4/26/2019
4/18/2019 Harlequin Dane LLC Darren Indyke-Affiliated Entity 11/20/2018
HBRK Associates Inc.'' Richard Kahn's Accounting Firm
5/10/2019
3/26/2019
5/14/2019
5/14/2019
5/10/2019
5/3/2019
5/10/2019
5/3/2019 JSC Interiors LLC 3/26/2019
MC2 Model Management Alleged Epstein Co-Conspirator 12/4/
1/21/2014
2013 Michelle Sai . her Wife of Darren Indyke 5/16/2014
Alleged Epstein Co-Conspirator 811/2017
Butterfly Trust Beneficiary 3/15/2019
Bank of America
Lawrence P Visoski Epstein's Personal Pilot 1/16/2019
12/19/2018
Epstein Affiliate 7/14/2015
Epstein Affiliate 12/26/2018
Epstein Employee 4/24/2015
Alleged Epstein Co-Conspirator 12/3/2018
Butterfly Trust Beneficiary 8/8/2018 Fidelity
(National Financial
Service LLC)
Southern Trust Company . Epstein-Controlled Entity 4/16/2019
Prytanee LLC Epstein-Controlled Entity 5/10/2019
Butterfly Trust Epstein-Controlled Entity 5/10/2019
"The accounts listed may belong to Epstein personally and Epstein-controlled entities as opposed to HBRK Associates Inc.
The wire details reference Plan D, NES,
LLC, "SEE" (or Jeffrey Edward Epstein), Plan D, Neptune LLC, Hyperion Air, Zorro, JEGE, LSJE, and Neptune LLC. Hence, it
appears that Epstein may have moved a
number of his accounts to TD Bank in May 2019.
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. IL atm. P. 6(e)
Wells Fargo
Lee McKenzie Consultants LLC Brice Gordon-Controlled Business Entity 3/29/2019
LSJE LLC Epstein-Controlled Entity 2/28/2019
Former Epstein Employee 5/15/2015
12/19/2013
Butterfly Trust Beneficiary 4/8/2019
Charles Schwab Southern Trust Company Epstein-Controlled Entity 4/17/2019
Southern Financial LLC Epstein-Controlled Entity 5/3/2019
Morgan Stanley
Gratitude America Ltd. Epstein-Controlled Entity 2/7/2019
The Butterfly Trust Epstein-Settled Trust 3/18/2019
Southern Trust Company, Inc. Epstein-Controlled Entity 6/20/2017
TD Ameritrade Southern Financial LLC Epstein-Controlled Entity 1/18/2019
Alostar Bank of
Commerce Kellerhals Ferguson Kroblin Epstein's Personal Attorney's Law Firm 1/8/2016
Banco Popular de
Puerto Rico
Jeffrey Epstein N/A 4/9/2019
Southern Trust Company, Inc. Epstein-Controlled Entity 3/1/2016
Bankwell Bank Lesley Goff Alleged Epstein Co-Conspirator 1/3/2017
Barclays Butterfly Trust Beneficiary 5/1/2019
BNP Paribas Jeffrey Epstein N/A 3/3/2014
Citibank 301/66 Owners Corp. Mark Epstein-Affiliated Entity 12/4/2015
E Trade Bank Lesley Groff Alleged Epstein Co-Conspirator 1/3/2017
First National Bank
of Omaha Southern Financial LLC Epstein-Controlled Entity 5/12/2014
First Republic Bank Lesley Groff Alleged Epstein Co-Conspirator 12/19/2018
Merrill Lynch Gratitude America Ltd. Epstein-Controlled Entity 1/30/2018
SunTrust Bank MC2 Model Management Alleged Epstein Co-Conspirator 3/21/2014
Standard Chartered Butterfly Trust Beneficiary 5/20/2014
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. IL CRIME. P. 6(e)
EFTA00039356 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-09-17)
LIST OF EXHIBITS - INTRODUCTION

1. Predicating information.
2. Office of Chief Medical Examiner, City of New York, Autopsy Report, dated August 11, 2019,
regarding the autopsy of Jeffrey Epstein.

3. Indictment filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York against
Jefferey Epstein, dated July 2, 2019.

4. Federal Bureau of Prisons Psychological Reconstruction dated September 17, 2019,
regarding inmate Jeffrey Epstein.

5. Decision and Order Remanding Defendant filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern
District of New York against Jeffrey Epstein, dated July 18, 2019.
U.S. Department of Justice
Office of the Inspector General
CASE NUMBER:
DATE:
EFTA00036859 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about Epstein investigation
(date: 2019-09-24)
L. OFFICIAL RECORD FD-1036(Rcv. 10-16-2009) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Import Form
Form Type: OTHER - Other
Title: (U) Phone Records for MCC Caller Station 6317
Approved By: SSA
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 90A-NY-3151227 (U) UNSUB(S);
JEFFREY EPSTEIN - VICTIM;
DEATH INVESTIGATION
Date: 09/24/2019
Synopsis: (U) On August 12, 2019, OIG SA provided the
phone records for MCC Caller Station 6317.
SDNY_00017798
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Gloria Allred [victim lawyer] victim's lawyer on many well known sexual harassment cases 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00022133 (Jmail)
 [girls] table listing Epstein accusations collated from the press and court hearings
(inferred date: 2019-12-02)
Epstein Accusations (from Press Reporting)
Name • Accusation Location Source(s)

• Recruited by unidentified female brunette in her 20s outside of her
high school in the fall of 2001, when she was 14.

• Joint visits with unidentified female for a month. Then solo trips to
Epstein's house.
• Regularly gave Epstein massages. Sometimes he masturbated.
Manipulated into stripping down to her panties during the massages.
Paid $300 each time.

• "He would also like when I would play with his nipples. He used to get
turned on by that. And then he would finish himself off and then that
would be the end of it."

• Over the next several months, visits followed a familiar
routine. Epstein's secretary would contact her by email, beeper or
her family's landline to set up a meeting, said. When she
arrived, she'd be escorted to the elevator and head straight to the
massage room. Once or twice a week for a year.

• In the fall of 2002, Epstein said "Why don't we try something a little
bit different?" she recalls him saying. "Why don't you do the massage
on top of me?" said she told him that she wanted to "stick to
the normal routine," but she ultimately removed her underwear. He
fondled her privates, she said. Then he "brought me up there and it
was very aggressive, it was forceful," she said. said she was
terrified and told him to stop. "He was like, 'It's okay. You're fine.
You're not doing anything wrong,' added=l, who said he did not
use a condom. After it was over, said, she rushed out of the
house angry and shaken.
New York https://www.nbenews.cominews/us-newilnew-jeffrerepsteln-accuset-
he.caped-me.when+was-n1028011

• Met Epstein in 1997 in Santa Monica, LA.
• Took her back to his hotel for a Victoria's Secret tryout. There he
groped her buttocks a ainst her will, and told her to undress.
Los Angeles httPslAwAv.rotingstontoomkutureculture.newsttererepstein-
evictorsts-seattfl64095/

• Recruited by • and in South Africa when she was Cape Town,
NYC, Paris,
NM and
USVI
Boies Schiller Lawsuit
20.

• Within two weeks, arrived in New York. A car picked her up
from the airport and brought her to an apartment building on 66th
Street, where Epstein housed some of the other models who he was
abusing. But was not there for long. Shortly after arriving at
the apartment, another one of Epstein's co-
conspirators, called and told that
Name • Accusation Location Source(s)

• was going to the Caribbean. did not understand why
she was traveling to the Caribbean so soon after arriving in New York
City, but hoped it was fora modeling job.

• was taken on Epstein's private plane. During the flight,
Epstein began sexually touching leg. She felt trapped and
terrified, and feared that she would be killed.

• They arrived at Epstein's home in the Virgin Islands. Epstein's abuse
of there began when sent to Epstein's room to
massage him. For the rest of the trip, Epstein repeatedly raped
by forcible compulsion. repeatedly sent to
Epstein's room, where he would touch her, use massage devices on
her, force her to perform oral sex on him, and sexually force himself
on her. also witnessed another young girl performing oral sex
on Epstein in front of while they were watching a movie.
Epstein's abuse of lasted for years. Epstein forced her to
travel to the United States many times to see Epstein and be
subjected to repeated sexual abuse for one to two weeks at a time,
sometimes staying in his New York apartment.

• was also forced to travel to Epstein's home in Paris where she
had to stay with Ghislaine Maxwell, one of Epstein's main recruiters
of young females, and where forced her to be
photographed nude for Epstein. During that trip, witnessed
that young females were on call to sexually pleasure Epstein.

• final trip to the United States was in 2004. She flew to see
Epstein at his New Mexico ranch, called "Zorro Ranch." Epstein
abused at Zorro Ranch.

• Epstein attempted to keep in contact with through e-mail
over the years. For example, in 2016, Epstein e-mailed to ask
if she knew another woman who was a victim of
Epstein's sex trafficking scheme. In June 2019, only two months
before his death, Epstein sent an e-mail asking her to send
him nude photographs.

• Recruited by a woman named Rena in the fall of 2000 New York Hearing Transcript
• Shown into a room with Alan Dershowitz and Epstein. Deshowitz left
the room. Rena and Epstein took off their clothes.
httPsiNeww.rriamiherald.cominews/state/florida/article23 52476 37.html

• "sexually assaulted by both Rena and Epstein"
• "I remember thinking 'I've never done this before, what's going on, I
just... don't know"
Name • Accusation Location Source(s)

• 16 when she met Epstein in 2000
• Told her that he could make her a Victoria's secret model.
• Epstein took off his robe and started pushing her head toward his
groin, saying, "You know what to do. If you want me to help you then
you have to help me,"

• When he was finished, he allegedly told her to come back sometime
"with her 14-, 15- and 16-year-old girlfriends." "I love girls your age,"

• "I love how young you are. You have a tight butt like a baby," he's
quoted as saying.
• He also told her that "I would love for you to come with me to
Thailand to pick up other girls your age" — and even "took preliminary
steps" to take her there, the suit claims.
New York httPs://nyposccom/2007/10/18/rwas-teen-prerol-pervert-tycoOn/

• Recruited by Maxwell
• 21 when she met Epstein. Studying to be a massage therapist. Flown
down to PB.

• told her Jeffrey wanted a massage. In massage room, he
immediately stripped and asked a lot of questions.

• Flipped onto his back and asked if he could touch himself. I gave him
the OK to touch himself because I didn't know what else to say or do
in that moment. And he finished and jumped off the table and got in
the shower and said, OK, that's all now; thank you. And I left the
room, you know, with my head spinning, trying to figure out what the
hell just happened.

• Raped a few months later after a handful of massage sessions.
• In USVI, Tugged her towards bed during massage, unbuttoning her
shorts, pulling body onto his already naked body. She said "please
stop". He proceeded to rape her.

• "abuse would continue for the next three years"
• Raped 3-4 times total.
Recruitment
in NYC, first
meet in PB
First rape in
USVI,
https://www.nprcwg/2019/09/02/756823299 s-
corning-lonvard-as-epuein-accuser
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/how-billish-teen-model-was-
lured-jelfrey-epstein-s-web-n1056901
httpswwww.nbthews.commewsius.newsmow.blitish-teen.model.was-tured-jelfrery-epstein-s-web-n1056901
Hearirg transcript

• 17 at the time (2002)
• Introduced in LA — Flew her to NM. During a massage, he fondled her
genitals.

• "For the next two years, Epstein flew her around the world on his
private jets and repeatedly raped and molested her at his homes in
New York, Florida, the US Virgin Islands and Paris"

• Epstein raped her while she was sleeping at his Florida home in
December 2002. He allegedly flew her out to Paris in 2003 shortly
after her semester abroad ended and raped her again as she slept.
NYC, NM
PB, USVI,
Paris
httos://nvoost.com/2019/11/21/eostet-accuser-says-she.vut aided
out-aver-her-eating-disorder/
httooneavymntnewspoom
Name • Accusation Location Source(s)

• "Virtually every few days, Epstein would bring to a different
home of his, including his Manhattan townhouse and throughout the
country, where he continued to sexually assault her on a frequent
basis."

• says Epstein arranged for her to live in an apartment at 301 E.
66th St. in 2004 — just blocks from his Manhattan mansion.

• Epstein tried to farm her out to other high-powered men
• Rubbed hand & leg in movie theatre in NYC
• Foot massages in NM with Maxwell, pointers on how to do it how
Epstein likes it

• Another round of movie theatre petting/touching in NM
• Epstein climbs into bed with M, spooning + touching

• Maxwell gives her a nude massage. Epstein does not participate, but
"could feel his presence"
NYC & NM NYT Daily + Article
hups://www.nyhmexcom/2019/08/26/u epstein isters-at
maxwell.hvnl

• On bed with Epstein & Maxwell — asked to give foot massage
• Between the two of them — they both started groping breasts,
commenting on her features, twisting her nipples

• Afraid of rape, ran away
• Nude photos missing
Ohio NYT Daily + Article
htlps://www.meines.eom/2019/08/26/uxtepstein isters-
maxwen.htmi

• Met in London
• Was raped numerous times over the course of several years — not
many details
• Grooming/Recruitment: "It wasn't zero to 100 in one day. It was
introduced piecemeal, along with constant emotional, financial
reinforcement that this was the path, the only path"
Recruited in
London,
abused in
USVI, NYC,
Paris
httpal/www.nbcnewaxeminews/usmews/haw.bMish-teemmodel-was-
lu red lellrey-epstei n-s -web-n 1056901

• Recruited by Maxwell from Mar-a-Lago in 2000
• Maxwell taught her how to give Epstein massages, oral sex, and
sexual toys.

• She "had to have sex with Epstein many times"
• Forced to recruit other girls
• "In 2001, alleges that Epstein brought her to London, where
she was introduced to Prince Andrew and went dancing at a
nightclub with Epstein, his then-girlfriend Ghislaine Maxwell and the
prince." Andrew ordered her a vodka and asked her to dance.

• Raped by Prince Andrew at Maxwell's in London. Instructed by
Maxwell to "do for Andrew what I do for Jeffrey". "It didn't last very
long. The whole thing, procedure — it was disgusting," Was in the
Recruitment
at Mar-a-
Lago. Sex
with Epstein
in NYC, PB,
NM, and
USVI.
Prince
Andrew in
London,
NYC, and
USVI
https://edinon.cnn.com/2019/12/02/uk/onnce-andra
not ma .intl-ebehndex.h tml pa a
dussibtomumusikesamfraignracd  AD tb01)0 td
htlps://www.washingtonpost.com/politimbhe-was-shakinteowhfienp-
desalbe-systermjellterepsteinwIlegedly-used-to-procure-
gitts/2019/08/09/8309311wbabe-lle9-badfa-609175W971 slory.html
hheqinvpost.com/2019/12/02/sewmth.prave.andrew-was-quick-and-
sowsuoteobeitsSt hetes:Mame thesun.co.ukinews/996649at
engem-sex-slave-prince-a ndrew wodkaj
httpsWwww.vankyfair.cominews/2019/013/newndetaik-imunsealed-
fen  rewepstelnacumenu
Name • Accusation Location Source(s)
bathroom and bedroom. "He wasn't mean or anything," the now-36-
year-old mom of three said of the prince. "He got up and said thanks
and walked out. I sat there in bed and felt ashamed and dirty."

• Had sex with Prince Andrew 3 times.
• Epstein directed her to have sex with Glen Dubin
• also alleges Epstein and Maxwell told her to have sex with
former New Mexico governor Bill Richardson; former Democratic
Senate Majority Leader George Mitchell; the late MIT computer
scientist Marvin Minsky; and MC2 model agency cofounder Jean Luc
Brunel, as well as an unnamed "prince," "foreign president," and
owner of "a French hotel chain." previously alleged she had
been forced by Epstein and Maxwell to have sex with lawyer Alan
Dershowitz and Britain's Prince Andrew.

• Had sex with Dershowitz at least 6 times, aged 16-19
• In 2007 Maxwell and Epstein (separately) called her to ask her to
keep quiet.

• Recruited by in LA when she was 22. NYC Hearing transcript
• About two weeks after her initial interview with =, told
that the couple wanted to fly her to New York for another
interview. The couple bought her a ticket for a flight from California
to New York City.
Boies Schiller Lawsuit

• Gave Maxwell a massage. Maxwell told her she'd be massaging
Epstein. She then paid $100 for the massage and told her to
give Epstein "whatever he wants" during his massage because
Epstein "alwaiawhat he wants."

• Epstein asked to sit down and began asking her personal
questions. He eventually asked her to give him a foot massage. She
agreed and placed his foot in her lap so that she could begin the
massage. As began massaging Epstein's foot, he started
pressing his foot against intimate parts of body.
became uncomfortable, adjusted her position, and moved Epstein's
foot up to keep it away from her body. But Epstein continued pushing
his foot into her body.

• While still on the couch in Epstein's office, Epstein got close to
M, grabbed her chin with his hand, turned her face towards him,
and said that he knew he could trust . Specifically, he said, "I
know I can always trust a woman who shows her gums when she
smiles." Epstein's actions terrified
Name • Accusation Location Source(s)

• Epstein then got up to walk out of the room. was
walking in front of Epstein when he abruptly grabbed her and
proceeded to sexually assault her against her will. stopped
walking and Epstein then forcefully grabbed her and sexually
assaulted her again. was frozen with shock and fear. Once
Epstein released her she continued walking towards the front door of
the mansion.

• Just before stepped out the front door, Epstein grabbed her
buttocks and said, "Don't do anything I wouldn't do."
proceeded to leave Epstein's mansion, and went back to the 66th
Street apartment building.

• Met when she was 14
• Massages. Came out in a towel. Told her to undress to her
underwear. Masturbated himself. Asked her to play with his nipples
and he did the same.

• Paid $200 each time
Palm Beach https://www.youtube.comiwatchN=IJDP2W9C0sU
• 16 years old at the time, recruited by another high school girl to give
Epstein a massage.

• During massage, he asked her to rub his back. Kept asking to go lower
and lower. Kept talking to her about her sex life.

• Masturbated in front of her.
• Tried to put his finger in her underwear, and she jumped back. He
continued feeling her genitals, but said "just on the outside"
Unclear busaglAtiminsulatsamlwaulthtgateatOs4
htto://www.youtubetom/watennippiviscosu

• Epstein raped her in 1993
• "He said, 'If you tell anybody anything I'll crush whatever career you
might have,' or something like that. He was just so mean so quickly.

• "It literally went from awkward to mean to rape so fast," she told the
UK paper.
• She recalled how he made her feel "embarrassed and ashamed and
stupid" — and that he got "irritated, almost angry" when she told
him she was 21.

• "He said something like, 'You're too, you're too old. You're getting
too old for this. What are you doing?'"
NYC https://nypou.com/2019/11/27/ex-mode accuses-jell rey-
epstei n-of -1993- rape

• 22 at the time (2006)
• Recruited by an unidentified female.
• Went to the movies, then was invited to USVI. There was an orgy on
the plane, but she did not participate.

• On the island, she was called in for massages.
USVI https://www.telegra ph.co.uk/news/2019/09/13/prosecutors -must-probe-
jeffrerepstelns-Uafficking-network/amp/
Name • Accusation Location Source(s)

• Ultimately made a series of trips to the island. Maxwell was usually
present.
• "There were some days I was raped three times a day. And then he
would rape others."

• "We had to be always around the house, so it would be easy to get
there. For him and his friends, who he lent us out to.

• "In six months I never saw him do a day's work. I never saw him
work. He was literally sexually abusing us all day long."

• Lived in an UES apartment paid for by Epstein.
• In early 2007 Miss was sent to South Africa to look for a
personal assistant for Epstein — he insisted that she had to be 18, and
had to be found through a modelling agency.

• said under oath that Maxwell approached her on New York,
UK
httos://www.vanitslait.cominews/2019/08/new-detaik-in-unsealtd-
letheY*PStein.d0CurtientS
her college campus with the promise of a job answering Epstein's
phones, but within a day she was coerced into having sex with
Epstein. Epstein once told her "he needed to have three orgasms a
day. It was biological, like eating," she recalled.

• Groped by Prince Andrew during visit to the UK with Epstein. "I just
remember someone suggesting a photo, and they told us to go get on
the couch," she said in court documents. "And so Andrew and
sat on the couch, and they put the puppet, the puppet on her
lap. "And so then I sat on Andrew's lap, and I believe on my own
volition, and they took the puppet's hands and put it on
breast, and so Andrew put his on mine."
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/9764107 <lsims.
a ainst • 1st lksce- 11
httptalseavyzentinews/2019/11

• 21 at the time (2004)
• Greeted at the door by Maxwell
• As talked about her experience in halting English, she said Epstein
moved to the massage table and began to remove his clothes. He was
naked on the table and asked her to approach. He handed her a
vibrator. "I just grabbed the vibrator and threw it at his head". She
ran out of the room.
New York https://nypost.com/2019/07/10/inside-the-settalas-secret-pipellne-to-
jeffrey-epsteln/

• Met when she was 14
• Massaged Epstein for 30 minutes. Epstein asked her to take her
clothes off to get comfortable, but can leave bra and panties on. She
stood next to him as he touched her and masturbated.

• Epstein asked her to bring other high school girls. For every girl, he'd
pay her $200.
Unclear wor thy. ',nolo,. com/watshNsXSttirvv8Ot4
tatps://nypost.com/2019/07/08/jelfrerepsteln-accuses-i-was-14-years-
old.antl-still-in-braces-when.alsose-began/
Name • Accusation Location Source(s)

• "By the time I was 16, I had probably brought him 70 to 80 girls who
were all 14 and 15 years old. He was involved in my life for years."
"He told me he wanted them as young as I could find them" "If I had
a girl to bring him at breakfast, lunch and dinner, then that's how
many times I would go a day. He wanted as many girls as I could get
him. It was never enough."
Jane Doe 1
(Brad
Edwards)
At hearing — did not specifically detail abuse n/a Hearing Transcript
Jane Doe 2
(Brad
Edwards)
At hearing — did not specifically detail abuse n/a Hearing Transcript
Jane Doe 3
(Brad
Edwards)

• "sexually assaulted by Epstein"
• Recruited by unidentified female
New York Hearing Transcript
Jane Doe 4
(Brad
Edwards)
At hearing — did not specifically detail abuse n/a Hearing Transcript
Jane Doe 5
(Brad
Edwards)
At hearing — did not specifically detail abuse n/a Hearing Transcript
Jane Doe 6
(Lisa Bloom)
At hearing — did not specifically detail abuse n/a Hearing Transcript
Jane Doe 7
(Lisa Bloom)
At hearing — did not specifically detail abuse n/a Hearing Transcript
Jane Doe 8
(Lisa Bloom)
At hearing — did not specifically detail abuse n/a Hearing Transcript
Jane Doe 9
(Gloria Allred)

• "Sexually molested by him for many hours"
• "positioned me by laying me on his floor so that I was confronted by
all the framed photographs on his dresser of him smiling with
wealthy celebrities and politicians."

• "After he finished with me, he told me to describe in detail how good
my first sexual experience felt."
New Mexico Hearing Transcript
Jane Doe 10
(Gloria Allred)

• Recruited by unidentified female
• Epstein asked if she would give him a massage.
• Over the course of four visits, eventually progressed to "forced oral
copulation"

• Paid money
New Mexico Hearing Transcript
Name • Accusation Location Source(s)
Jane Doe 11 • Raped by Epstein at 16 years old New York Hearing Transcript
(Gloria Allred) • Innocent massage turned sexual almost immediately

• "Here, come. Come help me with a kink in my shoulder while we
finish our discussion." A large vibrator and a couple of hundred
dollars, disgust and dirty secret, more praise and imparted wisdom
from a godlike figure, a deliberate diabolical depression of grooming
and submission for his pleasure and release. Even if I resisted, I was
no match for him. I felt powerless, ashamed, and embarrassed. I
wanted to vomit remembering these moments."

• "washed my entire body compulsively in the shower"
• "He forcefully penetrated me. I was numb. There was pain, but his
use of the vibrator and his fingers in previous sessions with me had
left a black hole-like void between my legs. I protested, but he forced
my face into the bed to stifle my cries. That was my first time."

• Paid a few hundred dollars
Jane Doe 12 • Recruited by unidentified woman New York Hearing Transcript
(Gloria Allred) • In Epstein mansion, he had a white robe on, then he took it off and
locked the door.

• Got close to her, and touched her genitals. She refused him. He went
to the massage table and showed her the vibrator.
EFTA02731069 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2019-12-05)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
MEMORANDUM
TO: Geoffre S. Berman. U.S. Attorne
FROM: AUSAs
DATE:
RE:
December 5, 2019
Analysis of Possible Corporate Prosecution
In connection with the investigation of Jeffrey Epstein for sex trafficking, we have been
asked to analyze the feasibility of bringing criminal charges against one or more Epstein-controlled
co ..rate entities that fonnall owned 'ro. dies at which he abused certain minor victims.
As described herein, the well-established requirements for prosecution of a corporation
are that its agent or agents committed criminal acts' while (1) acting within the scope of corporate
duties, and (2) intending at least in part to benefit the corporation itself.
This memorandum presumes familiarity with relevant prior case memoranda as well as the
charges set forth in United States v. Jeffrey Epstein, 19 Cr. 490 (RMB), and similarly presumes
that the corporate agent—Epstein himself—committed criminal acts, namely sex trafficking
offenses in violation of Tide 18, United States Code, Section 1591.
1
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
I. Background and Ownership of Property
On July 2, 2019, a federal grand jury in the Southern District of New York returned an
indictment (the "Indictment") charging Jeffrey Epstein with one count of sex trafficking of minors,
in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591, and one count of conspiracy to commit sex trafficking of minors,
in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371. Beginning in at least 2002, Epstein enticed and recruited dozens
of minor girls to engage in sex acts with him, for which he paid the victims hundreds of dollars in
cash. He undertook this activity in several locations, including his mansion in Manhattan, New
York (the "New York Residence") and his estate in Palm Beach, Florida (the "Palm Beach
Residence").
Between 1962 and 1989, prior to Epstein's ownership, the New York Residence was
operated as a school, under the auspices of the Birch Wathen Lenox School (the "Birch School").
In 1989, the Birch School sold the property to the Nine East 71st Street Corporation, which at the
time was wholly owned by Leslie Wexner, the billionaire founder of the Limited Company.2 In
or about 1998, Wexner agreed to sell the New York Residence to Epstein for $20 million. We
believe the change of ownership occurred through a transfer of control of the Nine East 71st Street
Corporation, the LLC that had purchased the New York Residence in 1989. Documents we have
reviewed reflect that in 2011, ownership of the New York Residence was transferred from one
Epstein-controlled entity to another: from Nine East 71st Street Corporation, of which Epstein was
President, to Maple, Inc? The New York Residence is valued at approximately $55-86 million,
and its parent company owner is herein referred to as the "Corporation.s 4
2 From approximately the early 1990s through 2007, Epstein managed certain finances and
financial projects for Wexner, including through having power of attorney for Wexner; it also
appears that Epstein stole or otherwise misappropriated more than $100 million from Wexner, in
addition to receiving other fees in the tens or hundreds of millions of dollars during the duration
of their decades-long financial relationship.
3 Relevant documents list Epstein as the President of the Nine East 71st  Street Corporation, and
no other officers or members are listed in those documents. Accordingly,
this memorandum assumes for its analysis that Epstein was
the sole member of the Nine East 71st Street Corporation during the relevant time period of
approximately 2002 through 2005.
4 We have obtained ownership paperwork for the New York Residence that suggests Epstein was
the sole owner or member of these entities. Moreover, neither entity appears to have had a bank
account or other indicia of operating costs, employees, etc. Additionally, Epstein also owned
domestic properties during the relevant period including residences in Florida, New Mexico, and
the U.S. Virgin Islands, at which he engaged in criminal conduct. Each of those properties is
owned by a separate corporation, respectively, for which Epstein is the sole member, and none of
which appears to have a bank account or other indicia of operations or employees. While Epstein
did have employees working at each of those locations, these employees were generally paid out
of a separate operating account controlled by Epstein, not directly by the LLC that owned the
h sical pro
2
PRIVILEGED -ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)

II. Principles and Requirements of Corporate Prosecution
A. Legal Framework and Application
Under federal law, corporate criminal liability is confined to offenses (a) committed by
the corporation's officers, employees, or agents; • within the sco of their lo ent• and
at least in art for the benefit of the co ration.
3
PRIVILEGED -ATTORNEY WORK. PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
li
4
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK. PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Here, the Corporation—which appears to have existed only as an on-paper holding
company for the New York Residence—had no formal business or corporate purpose, and Epstein,
who appears to have been its sole officer or member, was not an "employee" and had no defined
corporate responsibilities. We have not identified any documents that reflect a statement of
corporate purpose or other mission statement for the entity itself, and it does not appear to have
had any employees or operations, other than as a holding co
6 Under the principles of agency law more generally, "the scope of an agent's authority is not
unlimited and does not extend to actions that harm the interests of the principal." See United States

v. Hilton, 701 F.3d 959 (4th Cir. 2012) (citing In re Am. Biomaterials Corp., 954 F.2d 919, 924-
25 (3d Cir. 1992) (noting that an employee who embezzles from his corporation does not act within
the scope of his employment in doing so)).
7 Case law does not appear to draw any distinction between the legal standard applicable to an
entity based on its corporate structure—Le., an incorporated entity as opposed to a limited liability
company, as was the case here. This Office has also recently reached corporate resolutions with,
and has criminally charged, LLCs. See, e.g., United States v. S.A.C. Capital Partners LP SAC
Capital Partners LLC et at, 13 Cr. 541.
5
PRIVILEGED -ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
■
6
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
7
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK. PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
III. Prudential Considerations
S
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK. PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
J
-I
■
9
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK. PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
—I
10
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
11
PRIVILEGED -ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
12
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK. PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
W. Assessment
13
EFTA00810312 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures is a fintech focused Peter Thiel fund Epstein was invested in
(inferred date: 2019-12-15)
Valar Global Fund III LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Financial Statements
Year Ended December 31, 2018
The report exemparging these fi nancial statements was imsed by
BOO USA. LLP. a Delaware limited liability partnership and the U.S. mentor
of BDO International Linked. a UK company 'anted by "manta..
IBDQ
Valar Global Fund III LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Financial Statements
Year Ended December 31, 2018
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Contents
Independent Auditor's Report
Financial Statements
3
Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Partners' Capital 5
Schedule of Investments 6 - 7
Statement of Operations 8
Statement of Changes in Partners' Capital 9
Statement of Cash Flows 10
Notes to Financial Statements 11 - 20
I BDO
Independent Auditor's Report
To the General Partner of
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
0 One Bush Street
Suite 1800
San Francisco. CA 94104
We have audited the accompanying financial statements of Valar Global Fund III LP (a Delaware Limited
Partnership), which comprise the statement of assets, liabilities and partners' capital, including the
schedule of investments, as of December 31, 2018, and the related statements of operations, changes in
partners' capital, and cash flows for the year then ended, and the related notes to the financial statements.
The General Partner's Responsibility for the Financial Statements
The General Partner is responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of these financial statements
in accordance with accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America; this includes
the design, implementation, and maintenance of internal control relevant to the preparation and fair
presentation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or
error.
Auditor's Responsibility
Our responsibility is to express an opinion on these financial statements based on our audit. We conducted
our audit in accordance with auditing standards generally accepted in the United States of America. Those
standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the
financial statements are free from material misstatement.
An audit involves performing procedures to obtain audit evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the
financial statements. The procedures selected depend on the auditor's judgment, including the assessment
of the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements, whether due to fraud or error. In making
those risk assessments, the auditor considers internal control relevant to the entity's preparation and fair
presentation of the financial statements in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the
circumstances, but not for the purpose of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of the entity's internal
control. Accordingly, we express no such opinion. An audit also includes evaluating the appropriateness of
accounting policies used and the reasonableness of significant accounting estimates made by the General
Partner, as well as evaluating the overall presentation of the financial statements.
We believe that the audit evidence we have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for our
audit opinion.
Opinion
In our opinion, the financial statements referred to above present fairly, in all material respects, the
financial position of Valar Global Fund III LP as of December 31, 2018, and the results of its operations, its
changes in partners' capital, and its cash flows for the year then ended in accordance with accounting
principles generally accepted in the United States of America.
USA, LLE
March 20, 2019
E00 USA. ILO. a Delaware limited liability partnership. is the U.S. member of EDO International Limited. a Ulf company 
limited by guarantee. and forms part of
the international BDO network of independent member firms.
EDO is the brand name for the 8D0 network and for each of the BOO Member Firms.
3
Financial Statements
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Partners' Capital
December 31, 2018
Assets
Investments, at fair value (cost $56,289,593) $ 167,590,032
Cash 787,228
Interest receivable 15,300
Total Assets $ 168,392,560
Liabilities
Contributions received in advance $ 525,000
Due to affiliates 4,668
Total Liabilities 529,668
Partners' Capital
Cumulative capital contributions $ 61,486,320
Syndication costs (170,655)
Cumulative net operating loss (4,753,212)
Net unrealized appreciation on investments 111,300,439
Total Partners' Capital 167,862,892
Total Liabilities and Partners' Capital $ 168,392,560
See accompanying notes to financial statements.
5
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Schedule of Investments
December 31, 2018
Geographic
Classification'
Number
of shares
Privately Held Stock Other Total
Unrealized
Appreciation
(Depreciation) Cost Fair Value Cost Fair Value Cost Fair Value
Stash Financial. Inc. (f/k/a Collective Returns. Inc.) United States
Series B Preferred Shares 1.647.819 $ 10.200.000 $ 33.774.753 S $ $ 10.200.000 S 33.774.753 $ 23.574.753
Series A Preferred Shares 693.529 1.937.997 14.215.014 1.937.997 14.215.014 12.277.017
Series C Preferred Shares 217.494 2.692.576 4.457.896 2.692.576 4.457.896 1.765.320
Series 0 Preferred Shares 46.103 679.991 944.957 679.991 944.957 264.966
Olinda S.A.S (cVb/a Oonto) France
Series A Ordinary Shares 26.165 5.378.771 34.043.516 5.378.771 34.043.516 28.664.745
Series Seed Ordinary Shares 6.351 344.546 8.263.343 344.546 8.263.343 7.918.797
N26 GmbH Germany
Preferred B Shares 1.098 4.334.464 24.419.437 4.334.464 24.419.437 20.084.973
Octane Lending. Inc. United States
Series A-Ill Convertible Preferred Stock 1.562.226 8.473.658 12.460.760 8.473.658 12.460.760 3.987.102
Series B Convertible Preferred Stock 294.122 2.040.001 2.346.001 2.040.001 2.346.001 306.000
Common Stock 129.127 516.508 1.029.954 516.508 1.029.950 513.446
Petal Card. Inc. United States
Series A Preferred Shares 4.485.326 5.405.889 11.693.245 5.405.889 11.693.245 6.287.356
Series B Preferred Shares 652.090 1.699.999 1.699.999 1.699.999 1.699.999
Series 6-1 Preferred Shares 161.325 378.517 420.574 378.517 420.574 42.057
Common Stock 78.100 70.532 203.607 70.532 203.607 133.075
Coya AG Germany
Series A Preferred Shares 11.914 4.422.963 7.927.383 4.422.963 7.927.383 3.504.420
Jetty National. Inc. United States
Series A Preferred Shares 2.375.745 5.505.551 7.419.454 5.505.551 7.419.454 1.913.903
Spaceship Financial Services Pty Ltd Australia
Series Al Preferred Shares 20.878 521.876 599.550 521.876 599.550 77.670
See accompanying notes to financial statements.
6
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Schedule of Investments
December 31, 2018
Geographic
Classification•
Number
of Shares
Privately Held Stock Other Total
Unrealized
Appreciation
(Depreciation) Cost Fair Value Coat Fair Value Cost Fair Value
Brolly UK Technology Limited United Kingdom
Series Seed Preferred Shares 592.449 S 2' 0.58,2, S 216.478 $ - $ - $ 210,580 $ 216,178 $ 5898
Convertible Notes 237,575 216,512 237,575 216,512 (21.063)
Peak Ventures Rod United States
Limited Partnership Interests 371,000 374,000 371,000 374,000
Seed Platform, Inc. United States
Simple Agreement for Future Equity 310,000 340,000 310,000 310,000
Symple. Inc. United States
Simple Agreement for Future Equity 217,600 217,600 217,600 217.600
Mirror Al Inc. United States
Convertible Notes 170,000 170,000 170.000 170.000
Anduril Industries. Inc. United States
Series Seed Preferred Stock 123.113 68.000 68,000 68.000 68.000
Brat Inc. United States
Series Seed Preferred Stock 83.563 67.999 67.999 67.999 67.999
Total Investments, all in the technology industry $ 54,950,418 $ 166,271,920 $ 1,339,175 $ 1,318,112 $ 56,289,593 S 
167,590,032 S 111,300,439
Percentage of Partners' Capital 99.05% 0.79% 99.84%
' M used herein. Geographic Classification' has the meaning given to it under applicable AICPA guidelines. For these 
purposes. 54.75% of Partners Capital is
classified in the United States. 25.20% in France. 19.27% in Germany. 0.36% in
Australia and 0.26% in the United Kingdom.
See accompanying notes to financial statements.
7
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Statement of Operations
Year Ended December 31, 2018
Investment Income
Interest income $ 11,092
Expenses
Management fee 1,826,250
Professional fees 190,021
General and administrative 88,279
Total expenses before management fee waiver 2,104,550
Less: management fee waiver (142,080)
Less: management fee reduction for syndication costs (63,000)
Total expenses after management fee waiver and reduction 1,899,470
Net Operating Loss (1,888,378)
Unrealized Appreciation on Investments
Balance at beginning of year 25,240,354
Balance at end of year 111,300,439
Net Change in Unrealized Appreciation on Investments 86,060,085
Net Increase in Partners' Capital Resulting from Operations $ 84,171,707
See accompanying notes to financial statements.
8
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Statement of Changes in Partners' Capital
Year Ended December 31, 2018
General
Partner
Limited
Partners Total
Partners' Capital, December 31, 2017 S 5,034,781 $ 67,739,704 $ 72,774,485
Capital contributions 22,200 10,957,500 10,979,700
Syndication costs (63,000) (63,000)
Net operating loss (2,680) (1,885,698) (1,888,378)
Net change in unrealized appreciation on investments 861,625 85,056,380 85,918,005
Recapture of General Partners deemed contributions -
priority allocation 142,080 142,080
Carried interest reallocation 16,621,536 (16,621,536)
Partners' Capital, December 31, 2018 $ 22,679,542 $ 145,183,350 $ 167,862,892
See accompanying notes to financial statements.
9
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Statement of Cash Flows
Year Ended December 31, 2018
Cash Flows from Operating Activities
Net increase in partners' capital resulting from operations $ 84,171,707
Adjustments to reconcile net increase in partners' capital resulting from
operations to net cash used in operating activities:
Net change in unrealized appreciation on investments (86,060,085)
Purchase of investments (5,257,083)
Changes in operating assets and liabilities:
Increase in interest receivable (8,500)
Decrease in due to affiliates (4,890)
Net Cash Used in Operating Activities (7,158,851)
Cash Flows from Financing Activities
Capital contributions, net of change in contributions received in advance
and contributions receivable 11,504,790
Line of credit proceeds 2,090,000
Line of credit repayments (6,090,000)
Syndication costs (63,000)
Net Cash Provided by Financing Activities 7,441,790
Net Increase in Cash
Cash, beginning of year
282,939
504,289
Cash, end of year 787,228
Supplemental Disclosures of Cash Flow Information
Conversion of convertible notes and accrued interest to preferred shares 900,393
Interest paid during the year 17,655
See accompanying notes to financial statements.
10
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements
1. The Partnership
The accompanying financial statements include the accounts of Valar Global Fund Ill LP (the
"Partnership"). The Partnership was organized as a Delaware limited partnership on July 1, 2016
(Commencement) to make investments in early-stage technology companies for long-term capital
appreciation. The Partnership will continue until the tenth anniversary of the final closing date,
unless extended in accordance with the limited partnership agreement (the "Agreement"), or by
the election of the general partner. The general partner of the Partnership is Valar Ventures GP Ill
LLC (the "General Partner"), a Delaware Limited Liability Company. Valar Ventures LLC (the
"Management Company") serves as the management company of the Partnership.
If a limited partner informs the General Partner that it must abstain from any specific vote taken
or consent granted by the limited partners under the Agreement or the Partnership Agreement of a
parallel fund, such limited partner's interest shall be deemed not to be outstanding for purposes of
such determination and such limited partner shall be excluded from such vote or consent.
Allocation of Net Income or Net Loss
The allocation of income and loss is performed in accordance with the executed Agreement. The
allocation of ordinary income or ordinary loss, defined as all income received by the Partnership
from investments of idle funds in short term securities, shall be allocated to the capital accounts of
all partners in proportion to their respective partnership percentages. The allocations have been
calculated and financial statements presented on a hypothetical liquidation basis, as prescribed by
accounting principles generally accepted in the United States of America ("U.S. GAAP").
First, realized profits from sale or disposition of securities will be allocated to the General Partner
equal to the aggregate amount of Fee Adjustments, as defined in the Agreement.
Remaining profits and losses will be allocated:

a) Until the cumulative amount allocated to each limited partner is equal to 300% of such
limited partner's capital commitment, 80% of the profits will be allocated to the partners
in proportion to their respective partnership percentages and 20% to first restore any
previously allocated contingent losses of the partners and the remaining profits shall be
allocated to the General Partner.

b) From and after the time that the cumulative amount allocated to each limited partner is
equal to 300% of such limited partner's capital commitment, allocation of cumulative profits
shall be made 75% to all partners in proportion to their respective partnership percentages
and 25% to first restore any previously allocated contingent losses of the partners and the
remaining profits shall be allocated to the General Partner, until the cumulative amount
distributed to each limited partner is equal to 600% of such limited partner's capital
commitment.

c) From and after the time that the cumulative amount allocated to each limited partner is
equal to 600% of such limited partner's capital commitment, allocation of cumulative profits
shall be made 70% to all partners in proportion to their respective partnership percentages
and 30% to first restore any previously allocated contingent losses of the partners and the
remaining profits shall be allocated to the General Partner.
11
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements
Losses of the Partnership are allocated as follows:

a) First, to the extent of the profits allocated as outlined above, items of loss shall be allocated
in proportion to and in reverse order of such profit allocations.

b) Any remaining items of loss shall be allocated 20% to the General Partner and 80% to all
partners in proportion to their respective partnership percentages.
If after these allocations result in a balance of the General Partner that is less than the product of
(i) the sum of the Adjusted Capital Account balances of all Partners multiplied by (ii) the quotient
of (A) the sum of (x) the amount of the General Partner's capital contributions made in cash as of
such time plus (y) aggregate allocations of net Profit to the General Partner pursuant to waived
management fees divided by (B) the sum of (x) the amount of all of the Partners' capital
contributions made in cash as of such time plus (y) aggregate allocations of net Profit to the General
Partner pursuant to waived management fees, then an amount (the "Contingent Loss") shall be
reallocated from the General Partner's capital account to all of the partners' capital accounts in
proportion to their respective partnership percentage. There is no contingent loss balance at
December 31, 2018.
Distributions
The General Partner may make a distribution of cash or marketable securities to the partners in
proportion to their respective partnership percentages until each such partner has received
distributions in an amount equal to such partner's aggregate capital contributions, less the net
ordinary losses, if any, previously allocated to such partner.
First, to the partners in proportion to their respective partnership percentages until each such
partner has received distributions in an amount equal to such partner's aggregate capital
contributions less the net Ordinary Losses.
Second, until the cumulative amount distributed to each limited partner is equal to 300% of such
limited partner's capital commitment, distributions shall be made 80% to all partners in proportion
to their respective partnership percentages and 20% to the General Partner.
Third, from and after the time that the cumulative amount distributed to each limited partner is
equal to 300% of such limited partners capital commitment, distributions shall be made 100% to the
General Partner until the General Partner has received aggregate distributions equal to 25% of the
cumulative distributions.
Fourth, until the cumulative amount distributed to each limited partner is equal to 600% of such
limited partner's capital commitment, distribution shall be made 75% to all partners in proportion
to their respective partnership percentages and 25% to the General Partner.
Fifth, from and after the time that the cumulative amount distributed to each limited partner is
equal to 600% of such limited partners capital commitment, distributions shall be made 100% to the
General Partner until the General Partner has received aggregate distributions equal to 30% of the
cumulative distributions.
Any remaining distribution shall be made 70% to all partners in proportion to their respective
partnership percentages and 30% to the General Partner.
12
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements
The General Partner may at any time waive a distribution of cash or marketable securities that
would otherwise be made and instead make such distribution 100% to all partners in accordance
with their respective partnership percentages; provided, however, that the Partnership may make
subsequent distributions of cash to the General Partner to the extent of any such waived distribution
at such times as the General Partner shall determine.
Whenever more than one type of marketable securities are being distributed in kind in a single
distribution or whenever more than one class of marketable securities of a portfolio company are
distributed in kind by the Partnership, each partner shall receive its ratable portion of each type,
class or portion of such class of marketable securities distributed in kind (except to the extent that
a disproportionate distribution is necessary to avoid distributing fractional shares).
Marketable securities distributed in kind shall be subject to such conditions and restrictions as the
General Partner determines are legally required or appropriate. Whenever types or classes of
Securities are distributed in kind, each partner shall receive its ratable portion of each type or class
of securities distributed in kind.
Each partner shall be paid in cash after the end of each fiscal year during the term of the Partnership
an amount equal to the net taxable income allocated to such partner as a result of such partner's
ownership of an interest in the Partnership for the current fiscal year multiplied by the highest
blended federal, state and local marginal income tax rate then applicable to an individual residing
in any state applied by taking into account the character of the taxable income in question (i.e.,
long-term capital gains, ordinary income, etc.); provided, however, that the General Partner shall
not be required to make any such distribution if the total amount to be distributed to all partners
is less than $1,000,000.
2. Significant Accounting Policies
Basis of Presentation
The financial statements are presented in accordance with U.S. GAAP. The Partnership is an
investment company and applies accounting and reporting guidance in accordance with Financial
Accounting Standards Board ("FASB") Accounting Standards Codification ("ASC") Topic 946,
"Financial Services - Investment Companies."
Use of Estimates
U.S. GAAP requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the reported
amounts of assets and liabilities and disclosure of contingent assets and liabilities at the date of the
financial statements and the reported amounts of income and expenses during the reporting period.
Actual results could differ from those estimates.
Valuation of investments at Fair Value - Definition and Hierarchy
The Partnership follows the guidance in the Fair Value Measurements and Disclosures Topic of FASB
ASC 820. Under this guidance, fair value is defined as the price that would be received to sell an
asset or paid to transfer a liability (i.e., the "exit price") in an orderly transaction between market
participants at the measurement date.
13
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements
In determining fair value, the Partnership uses various valuation approaches, as may be appropriate
in the circumstance, including market, income and/or cost approaches. Investments are valued on
a quarterly basis taking into consideration any changes, projections and assumptions, as well as any
changes in economic and other relevant conditions. ASC 820 establishes a fair value hierarchy for
inputs used in measuring fair value that maximizes the use of observable inputs and minimizes the
use of unobservable inputs by requiring that the most observable inputs be used when available.
Observable inputs are inputs that market participants would use in pricing the asset developed
based on market data obtained from sources independent of the Partnership. Unobservable inputs
are inputs that reflect the Partnership's assumptions about the assumptions market participants
would use in pricing the asset or liability developed based on the best information available in the
circumstances. The valuations of the Partnership's investments are reviewed quarterly by the
General Partner. The valuations are further tested by comparison to actual sales prices obtained on
disposition of the investments. The fair value hierarchy is broken down into three levels based on
the reliability of inputs as follows:
Level 1 - Valuations based on unadjusted quoted prices in active markets for identical assets that
the partnership has the ability to access. Valuation adjustments and block discounts are not applied
to Level 1 instruments. Since valuations are based on quoted prices that are readily and regularly
available in an active market, valuation of these products does not entail a significant degree of
judgment.
Level 2 - Valuations based on inputs that are other than quoted prices in active markets, which are
either directly or indirectly observable as of the reporting date, and fair value is determined through
the use of models or other valuation methodologies.
Level 3 - Valuations based on inputs that are unobservable and include situations where there is
little, if any, market activity for the investment. The inputs into the determination of fair value
require significant management judgment and estimation.
The availability of valuation techniques and observable inputs can vary from instrument to
instrument and is affected by a wide variety of factors, including, for example, the type of
instrument, whether the instrument is new and not yet established in the marketplace, and other
characteristics particular to the transaction. To the extent that valuation is based on models or
inputs that are less observable or unobservable in the market, the determination of fair value
requires more judgment. Those estimated values do not necessarily represent the amounts that may
be ultimately realized due to the occurrence of future circumstances that cannot be reasonably
determined. Because of the inherent uncertainty of valuation, those estimated values may be
materially higher or lower than the values that would have been used had a ready market for the
securities existed. Accordingly, the degree of judgment exercised by the Partnership in determining
fair value is greatest for instruments categorized in Level 3. In certain cases, the inputs used to
measure fair value may fall into different levels of the fair value hierarchy. In such cases, for
disclosure purposes the level in the fair value hierarchy within which the fair value measurement in
its entirety falls is determined based on the lowest level input that is significant to the fair value
measurement in its entirety.
Fair value is a market-based measure considered from the perspective of a market participant who
holds the asset or owes the liability rather than an entity -specific measure. Therefore, even when
market assumptions are not readily available, the Partnership's own assumptions are set to reflect
those that market participants would use in pricing the asset or liability at the measurement date.
14
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements
The valuation methodologies used to estimate the fair value the Partnership's classes of investments
is described below:
Investments in Portfolio Companies - The General Partner primarily uses a market approach in
estimating the fair values of its investments in portfolio companies. This approach usually includes
referencing recent or pending transactions in the same or similar securities of the issuer. Investment
carrying value may also be supported by reference to observable valuation measures for comparable
companies, such as an enterprise value or acquisition value to revenue multiple, where
unobservable data of the issuer is viewed in the context of a relevant range of comparable
companies or transactions. Such information may be derived from unaudited input sources. In
certain instances, the General Partner may use a combination of the market and income approaches
for certain portfolio investments. The Partnership's investments may also be valued at cost for a
period of time after an investment is made as the best indicator of fair value. Debt instruments are
recorded at fair value using cost. In assessing portfolio investment companies for impairment,
management considered these companies' product line portfolio, customers and related commercial
agreements, labor agreements and other factors for which identifiable cash flows are largely
independent.
The fair values of venture capital investments are determined by reference to multiple inputs,
including: the original transaction price, recent transactions in the same or similar securities,
completed or pending third-party transactions in the same or similar securities, subsequent rounds
of financing by the issuer, recapitalization of the issuer, expected near term acquisition or merger
of the issuer, significant changes in operating performance, financial ratios and cash flows of the
issuer, historical and projected revenues, public market or private market transactions, valuations
for comparable companies, information obtained from portfolio company 409A valuations, and other
measures which, in many cases, are unaudited at the time received. Valuations may be derived by
reference to observable valuation measures for comparable companies or transactions (e.g.,
multiplying a key performance metric of the investee company such as revenues by a relevant
valuation multiple observed in the range of comparable companies or transactions), adjusted by
management for differences between the investment and the referenced comparables, and in some
instances by reference to option pricing models or other similar methods. The fair value
measurement of such investments does not include transaction costs that may have been capitalized
as part of such investments' cost basis.
Interest Income
Interest income represents interest earned from bank interest and the Partnership's investments
in debt instruments. Interest is recorded on an accrual basis.
Taxes on Income
The Partnership accounts for uncertainty in tax positions by determining whether a tax position of
the Partnership is more likely than not to be sustained upon examination, including the resolution
of any related appeals or litigation processes, based on the technical merits of the position. For
tax positions meeting the more likely than not threshold, the tax amount recognized in the financial
statements is reduced by the largest benefit that has a more likely than not position of being
realized upon ultimate settlement with the relevant taxing authority.
15
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements
The Partnership files tax returns as prescribed by the tax laws of the jurisdictions in which it
operates. In the normal course of business, the Partnership is subject to examination by federal,
state, local and foreign jurisdictions, where applicable. As of December 31, 2018, the tax years that
remain subject to examination by the major tax jurisdictions (U.S. Federal and California State)
under the statute of limitations are from 2016 forward.
The Partnership accrues all amounts under relevant tax laws as incurred. As of December 31, 2018,
the General Partner has determined that the Partnership does not have a liability for uncertain tax
positions nor did the Partnership incur a liability for interest and penalties. The General Partner
does not anticipate any unrecognized tax benefits in the next twelve months that would result in a
material change to the Partnership's financial position.
Foreign Currency Transactions
Investment securities and other assets and liabilities denominated in foreign currencies are revalued
into U.S. dollar amounts at the date of valuation. Purchases and sales of investment securities and
income and expense items denominated in foreign currencies are translated into U.S. dollar amounts
on the respective dates of such transactions.
The Partnership does not isolate the portion of the results of operations resulting from changes in
foreign currency rates on investments from the fluctuations arising from changes in unrealized or
realized gains and losses from investments.
Recent Accounting Pronouncement
In August 2018, the Financial Accounting Standards Board ("FASB") issued Accounting Standards
Update CASU-9 2018-13- Fair Value Measurement (Topic 820): Disclosure Framework - Changes to
the Disclosure Requirements for Fair Value Measurement, which includes amendments intended to
improve the effectiveness of disclosure requirements for recurring and nonrecurring fair value
measurements. The standard removes, modifies and adds certain disclosure requirements and
affects companies that are required to include fair value measurement disclosures.
For nonpublic entities, the disclosure for the changes in the unrealized gains and losses included in
earnings for recurring Level 3 fair value measurements held at the end of the period are no longer
required. In lieu of a rollforward for Level 3 fair value measurements, a nonpublic entity is required
to disclose transfers into and out of Level 3 of the fair value hierarchy and purchases and issues of
Level 3 assets and liabilities.
The amendments in this update are effective for fiscal years beginning after December 15, 2019,
and interim periods within those fiscal years. Early adoption for amendments that remove or modify
disclosures are permitted and the Partnership has early adopted these amendments.
3. Fair Value Measurements
The Partnership's assets recorded at fair value have been categorized based upon a fair value
hierarchy in accordance with ASC 820. See Note 2 for a discussion of the Partnership's policies
regarding this hierarchy.
16
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements
The following table presents the investments carried on the statement of assets, liabilities and
partners' capital by level within the valuation hierarchy as of December 31, 2018.
Investments at Fair Value as of December 31, 2018
Level 1 Level 2 Level 3 Total
Preferred stock - $ $ 165,038,359 $ 165,038,359
Common stock 1,233,561 1,233,561
Partnership interest' 374.000
Other 944.112 944.112
Total investments - $ $ 167,216.032 $ 167,590.032
'Under ASC 820. partnership interests presented in the table above are not required to be categorized within the fair 
value
hierarchy, as fair value of these investments are determined using NAV as a practical expedient.
The following table includes a summary of activity for the year ended December 31, 2018 for
investments classified within Level 3. The classification of an investment within Level 3 is based
upon the significance of the unobservable inputs to the overall fair value measurement.
Preferred Common
Stock Stock Other Total
Purchases $ 4,419,990 $ $ 837,093 $ 5,257,083
There were no transfers between Level 3, Level 2 or Level 1 investments during the year presented.
At December 31, 2018, all Level 3 investments were valued based on most recent observable
transaction price.
While the General Partner believes its valuation methods are appropriate and consistent with those
used by other market participants, the use of different methodologies or assumptions to determine
the fair value of certain financial instruments could result in a different estimate of fair value at
the reporting date. Those estimated values may differ significantly from the values that would have
been used had a readily available market for such investments existed, or had such investments
been liquidated, and these differences could be material to the financial statements.
4. Management Fee
The General Partner shall be compensated in cash, payable quarterly in advance, for services
rendered to the Partnership by the payment in advance by the Partnership in cash to the General
Partner on the first day of each fiscal quarter of a management fee. The management fee for each
fiscal quarter shall be an amount equal to the aggregate limited partners' capital commitments as
of the first day of each such quarter multiplied by 0.625%. The management fee otherwise payable
by the Partnership to the General Partner shall be offset by one hundred percent (100%) of the
amount of any cash or noncash compensation in the form of stock, options, warrants or other similar
rights (net of the amount paid for any such stock or securities) paid as directors, consulting,
management service, advisory, consultant, transaction, commitment, breakup or broken deal fees
or similar fees to the General Partner, the Management Company, or the respective managing
members or managers of such entities, during the immediately preceding quarter by or in connection
with any company in which the Partnership holds an investment or any company in which the
Partnership actively sought to invest but did not, net of any unreimbursed expenses of the General
Partner or the Management Company, or the managing members or managers of such entities,
provided, however, the foregoing shall not apply to any cash or non-cash compensation paid to any
such parties by a company in which an "Affiliated Party" (as defined in the Agreement) or a member,
17
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements
employee or Affiliate thereof holds an investment as of the date hereof and by the amount of capital
that the General Partner elected not to contribute in cash in the preceding quarter ("Fee
Adjustment").
During the year ended December 31, 2018, total management fees were $1,826,250, of which there
was a (1) Fee Adjustment of $142,080 as a result of the General Partner not contributing in cash
80% of its capital contributions of $177,600 from October 1, 2017 to September 30, 2018 and (2) a
management fee reduction of $63,000 as a result of syndication costs for placement agent fees.

5. Partners' Capital
As of December 31, 2018, the Partnership had a total capital commitment of $73,790,000, including
the General Partner's capital commitment of $740,000, of which a combined 84% has been called
with $61,486,320 funded into the Partnership.

6. Commitments
The Partnership agrees to indemnify, out of the assets of the Partnership only the General Partner,
the Management Company, the members of the advisory committee, the tax matters partner and
their respective managers, members, partners, principals, officers, employees, affiliates and agents
to the fullest extent permitted by law for good faith actions taken on behalf of the Partnership. The
Partnership is unable to develop an estimate of the maximum amount of potential future payments
from the Partnership as a result of potential claims, but expects the risk of having to make
significant indemnification payments to be remote.

7. Related Parties
The General Partner also provides management services to an affiliated fund, Valar Global Principals
Fund Ill LP, which co-invests pari passu with the Partnership in the same portfolio companies the
Partnership invests in.
Members or assignees of the General Partner serve as a member of the Board of Directors for certain
portfolio companies of the Partnership as of December 31, 2018.
The Partnership has amounts due to related parties for payment of expenses on behalf of the
Partnership in the normal course of business. As of December 31, 2018, $4,668 is due to related
parties.

8. Line of Credit
On August 3, 2016, the Partnership entered into a line of credit agreement with a major U.S. bank
(the "Lender") that allowed the Partnership to borrow cash through August 3, 2019. The Lender has
committed to provide up to the lesser of $4,760,000 or 50% of callable capital less borrower's
contingent obligations. The principal amount outstanding under the line shall accrue interest at a
floating per annum rate equal to one half of one percentage point (0.50%) below the Wall Street
Journal prime floating rate. The line of credit agreement contained certain nonfinancial covenants
and the Partnership was in compliance with all covenants as of December 31, 2018. The outstanding
balance at December 31, 2018 was $0.
18
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements
9. Risk Factors
The Partnership's investing activities expose it to various types of risk that are associated with the
financial instruments and markets in which it invests. The significant types of financial risks to which
the Partnership is exposed include, but are not limited to market risk, illiquidity risk and other
additional risks. Certain aspects of those risks are addressed below.
Credit Risk - In the normal course of business, the Partnership maintains its cash balances in
financial institutions, which at times may exceed federally insured limits. The Partnership is subject
to credit risk to the extent any financial institution with which it conducts business is unable to
fulfill contractual obligations on its behalf. Management monitors the financial condition of such
financial institutions and does not anticipate any losses from these counterparties.
Market Risk - The Partnership's investments are long-term and highly illiquid and there is no
assurance that the Partnership will achieve investment objectives including targeted returns. Due
to the illiquidity of the investments, valuation of the assets may be difficult, as there generally will
be no established markets for these assets. As the Partnership's financial instruments are carried at
fair value with fair value changes recognized in the statement of operations, all changes in market
conditions will directly affect the net asset value of the Partnership.
illiquidity Risk - Most of the portfolio companies in which the Partnership expects to make
investments will initially be privately held. As a result there will be no readily available secondary
market for the Partnership's interests in such portfolio companies, and those interests will be
subject to legal restrictions on transfer. Therefore, there is no assurance that the Partnership will
be able to realize liquidity for such investments in a timely manner, if at all.
Foreign Currency Risk - The Partnership may enter into transactions denominated in currencies
other than its functional currency. Consequently, the Partnership may be exposed to risks that the
exchange rate of its currency relative to other foreign currencies may change in a manner that may
have an adverse effect of the value of that portion of the Partnership's assets or liabilities
denominated in currencies other than the functional currency.
Industry Risk - The Partnership focuses on investments in the technology industry. Thus, the
performance of the Partnership will be closely linked to the performance of this industry and the
Partnership could be severely impacted by adverse developments affecting this industry.
Geographic Risk - The Partnership has not adopted policies requiring that its portfolio companies
be diversified in different geographic areas. If several Partnership investments are concentrated in
one geographic area, the Partnership could be severely impacted by adverse developments affecting
that geographic area.
Technology Risk- The technologies developed by the portfolio companies may not work.
19
Valar Global Fund Ill LP
(a Delaware Limited Partnership)
Notes to Financial Statements

10. Financial Highlights
The Partnership is required to disclose financial highlights for the common interest in the
Partnership (i.e. the limited partners' interest). These financial highlights consist of the operating
expenses, priority allocation, carried interest reallocation and net operating loss ratios for the year
ended December 31, 2018 and the net internal rate of return ("IRR") since inception of the limited
partners, net of all fees and carried interest reallocation to the General Partner, through December
31, 2017 and 2018. The following summarizes the limited partners' financial highlights:
Net operating loss 0)
Total expenses before management fee waiver and deduction for
syndication cost 0)
Less: management fee waiver with respect to the General Partner's capital
commitment
Less: deduction of syndication cost with respect to the General Partner's
capital commitment
Net expenses after management fee waiver
Priority allocation
Carried interest reallocation
Total net expenses, priority allocation and carried interest reallocation
(0.06%)
1.95%
0.15%
17.10%
19.20%
Cumulative net IRR through December 31, 2017 (2) 52.02%
Cumulative net IRR through December 31, 2018 (2) 72.76%
is The net operating loss, carried interest reallocation and expense ratios are computed as a percentage of
quarterly weighted average limited partners' capital balance.
X21 The net IRR was computed based on the cash inflows (capital contributions), outflows (cash and stock
distributions), and the ending limited partners' capital balance at the end of the year (residual value) of the
limited partners' capital account as of each measurement date. The IRR is net of carried interest reallocation.
These financial highlights may not be indicative of the future performance of the Partnership.

11. Subsequent Events
The Partnership has evaluated subsequent events through March 20, 2019, the date the
accompanying financial statements were available to be issued and did not note any items that
would adjust the financial statements or require disclosure.
20
╔══════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
           Lyn and Jojo, LLC [epstein] Epstein company 
                   VT&T, LLC [epstein] Epstein company 
 Wladimir van der Laan [crypto] bitcoin core developer 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00076491 (Jmail)
 [money] inventory of Epstein's estate
(date: 2019-12-31)
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE VIRGIN ISLANDS
DIVISION OF ST. THOMAS & ST. JOHN

IN THE MATTER OF THE ESTATE OF                          PROBATE NO. ST-I9-PB-80
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, Deceased.                           ACTION FOR TESTATE
.                                                       ADMINISTRATION

VERIFIED INVENTORY

PERSONAL PROPERTY                   VALUE2              VOUCHER
Cash
• First Bank xxxxx2601 (Personal)3           -0-        1
• First Bank xmcxx5901 (Estate)     6,645,429.00        2
• Banco Popular xxxxx7567             820,210.00        3
• Escrow Account (Paris)4             133,200.00        4
.           SUBTOTAL               $7,598,839.00

VALUE
Vehicles Titled in Decedent's Names
• 2018 Chevrolet Suburban6 S        38,000.00 5
• 2017 Maverick ATV                  8,000.00 6 • 1964
• Dune Buggy                         7,000.00 7
SUBTOTAL                           $53,000.00

----------
1 Estimated, pre-appraisal values of entities are exclusive of value of subsidiaries; subsidiaries are separately 
reflected on this inventory.
2 Values provided are as of 12/31/2019, unless otherwise noted.
3 The entirety of Decedent's personal account, $8,554,622.64, was transferred into the Estate's checking account held at
First Bank on 10/08/2019.
4 The sums held in escrow represent the proceeds from the sale of a 2018 Mercedes Maybach which was located in Paris. 
The sales price was E120,000.00 Euro.
Using the current conversion rate of 1.1, the value in USD is $133,200.00.
5 The vehicles titled in the Decedent's name are located outside of the U.S. Virgin Islands but have been included to 
ensure consistency with the quarterly
accountings, as the proceeds of the sales of these vehicles will be deposited into the Estate checking account. 6 The 
valuation is based upon the current Kelly
Blue Book Value.

Estate of Jejj5wy E. Epstein Probate No. S7:19-PB-80
Verified Inventory Page No. 2

Artwork, Collectibles, Furnishings & Equipment  To be determined by appraisal
Jewelry & Watches                               To be determined by appraisal

Limited Liability Companies Wholly Owned by Decedent
.                                          VALUES VOUCHER
• LSJE, LLC S                        2,641,393.00 8
• Freedom Air Petroleum, LLC            22,512.00 9
• Michelle's Transportation, LLC       323,907.00 10
• L.S.J, LLC                             6,400.00 11
• Zorro Management, LLC                       -0- 12
• Neptune, LLC                                -0- 13
• NES, LLC                                    -0- 14
• Plan D, LLC 10                    17,000,000.00 15
• JEGE, LLC                                   -0- 16
• Hyperion Air, LLC II               4,200,000.00 17
• Thomas World Air, LLC                 25,000.00 18
• LSJ Emergency, LLC                          -0- 19
• Southern Financial, LLC 12       176,961,338.00 20
• Lyn and Jojo, LLC I3                 356,000.00 21
• Great St. Jim, LLC              See footnote 14 22
.                   SUBTOTAL      $201,536,550.00

---------------
7 A full inventory and appraisal of the decedent's artwork, collectibles, furnishings & equipment located in the U.S. 
Virgin
Islands has not yet been completed. Upon completion, an updated inventory with values for these assets will be submitted
to
the court.
8 A full inventory and appraisal of the decedent's jewelry and watches located in the U.S. Virgin Islands has not yet 
been
completed. Upon completion, an updated inventory with values for these assets will be submitted to the Court.
9 The value of the limited liability companies provided below are solely based upon available cash on hand, unless 
otherwise
noted. The following entities hold other assets which must be appraised: Zorro Management, LLC; Neptune, LLC; NES, LLC;
JEGE, LW; LSJE, LLC; Michelle's Transportation, LLC; Thomas World Air, LLC; and LSJ Emergency, LLC. The value of
these entities shall be updated to reflect appraised value upon completion.
10 Plan D, LLC holds title to a 2007 Gulfstream Aerospace G-550 with an insurable value of $17,000,000.00. This aircraft
will
be appraised, and the value of the entity will be updated upon completion of an appraisal of this aircraft.
11 Hyperion Air, LLC holds title to a 2001 Bell 430 helicopter with an insurable value of $1,200,000.00 and a 2008 
Sikorsky
S76C helicopter with an insurable value of $3,000,000.00. These aircraft will be appraised, and the value of the entity 
will be
updated upon completion of an appraisal of these aircraft.
12 Southern Financial, LLC has an estimated value of $176,961,338.00. This entity will be appraised, and an updated 
value will
be provided upon completion.
13 Lyn and Jojo, LLC holds title to real property and all appurtenant rights, which for purposes of this inventory has 
been
valued at the underlying real property's most recent taxed assessed value. The underlying real property and rights will 
be
appraised, and an updated value will be provided upon completion.

Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein
Verified Inventory
Corporate Entities Wholly Owned by the Decedent
Probate No. ST-19-PB-80
Page No. 3
.                                            VALUE  VOUCHER
• Poplar, Inc.' s                   $23,392,188.00  23
• Laurel, Inc.' s                    13,814,238.00  24
• Maple, Inc. 16                     56,257,200.00  25
• Cypress, Inc."                     17,760,284.00  26
• Nautilus, Inc.' s                  63,292,637.00  27
• Southern Trust Company, Inc. 19   233,611,964.00  28
• FT Real Estate, Inc.20              5,486,046.00  29
• Southern Country International, Ltd.  499,759.00  30
• Haze Trust 22                       2,287,231.00  31
• SCI JEP 23                          9,842,122.00  32
.                        SUBTOTAL  $426,243,669.00

-----------------
14 Poplar, Inc. is the sole owner of Great St. Jim, LLC. Great St. Jim LLC holds cash on hand and title to the real 
property
known as Great St. James island and all appurtenant rights, which for purposes of this inventory has been valued at the
underlying real property's most recent tax assessed value of $22,998,600.00. The underlying real property and tights 
will be
appraised and an updated value will be provided upon completion.
15 Laurel, Inc. holds cash on hand and title to real property located at 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida and all
appurtenant rights which for purposes of this inventory has been valued at the underlying real property's most recent 
tax
assessed value of $13,618,230.00. The underlying real property and rights will be appraised, and an updated value will 
be
provided upon completion.
16 Maple, Inc. holds cash on hand and tide to the real property located at 9 East 7I" Street, New York, New York and all
appurtenant rights which for purposes of this inventory has been valued at the underlying real property's most recent 
tax
assessed value S55,861,000.00. The underlying real property and rights will be appraised, and an updated value will be
provided upon completion.
17 Cypress, Inc. holds cash on hand and title to the real property known as Zorro Ranch in Stanley, New Mexico and all
appurtenant rights, which for purposes of this inventory has been valued at the underlying real property's most recent 
tax
assessed value of $17,703,427.00. The underlying real property and rights will be appraised, and an updated value will 
be
provided upon completion.
18 Nautilus, Inc. holds cash on hand and tide to the property known as Little St. James island and all appurtenant 
rights, which
for purposes of this inventory has been valued at $63,000,000.00, the underlying property's estimated cost basis. The
underlying real property and rights will be appraised, and an updated value will be provided upon completion.
19 Southern Trust Company, Inc. has an estimated value of $233,611,964.00. This entity will be appraised, and an updated
value will be provided upon completion.
20 FT Real Estate, Inc. has an estimated value of 55,486,046.00. This entity will be appraised, and an updated value 
will be
provided upon completion. 21 Southern Country International, Ltd. has an estimated value of $499,759.00. This entity 
will be appraised, and an updated
value will be provided upon completion.
22 Haze Trust has an estimated value of $2,287,231.00. This entity will be appraised, and an updated value will be 
provided
upon completion.
23 The assets of SCI JEP included cash on hand and title to property located at 22 Avenue Foch, Paris, France. For 
purposes of
this inventory, the value of the underlying property is estimated at f8,672,823.00, which is based on a valuation 
previously
provided by an independent third party. Using the current conversion rate of 1.11, the value in USD is $9,626,833.00. 
The
underlying property will be appraised, and an updated value will be provided upon completion.

Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein Probate No. ST.194'1840
Verified Inventory Page No. 4

Other Entities in Which Decedent Held an Ownership Interest
• IGY-AYH ST. Thomas Holdings, LLC d/b/a
.      American Yacht Harbor (50% Interest) 24 To be determined by appraisal 33
• Prytanee, LLC (50% Interest) 2 $700,000.00 34
.                       SUBTOTAL $700,000.00

Dormant/Inactive Entities Wholly Owned by Decedent
• CDE, Inc.                               $ -0-
• VT&T, LLC 26                              -0-
• Little St. Jim, LLC                       -0-
• Financial Ballistics, LLC                 -0-
• Southern Country Opportunity Fund, LLC    -0-
• Financial Ballistics Trust                -0-
• JSC Interiors, LLC 27                     -0-
• FSF, LLC 211                              -0-
• Jeepers, Inc. 29                          -0-
.                                SUBTOTAL $ -0-

TOTAL PERSONAL PROPERTY: $636,132,058.00
TOTAL ESTATE PROPERTY:   $636,132,058.00

----------
24 The ownership interest in 1GY-AYH St. Thomas Holdings, LLC will be appraised. Upon completion of the appraisal an
updated value will be provided. zs The ownership interest in Prytanee, LLC will be appraised. The estimated value 
provided is based upon internal valuations.
Upon completion of the appraisal, an updated value will be provided.
26 VT&T, LLC held an FCC license which was terminated after the Decedent's death. VT&T, LLC will be dissolved.
27 The entire balance of the JSC Interiors, LLC bank account was transferred into the Estate checking account on 
12/31/2019.
JSC Interiors, LLC will be dissolved.
28 The entire balance of the FSF, LLC bank account was transferred into the Estate checking account on 12/31/2019. FSF, 
LLC
will be dissolved.
" The entire balance of the Jeepers, Inc. bank account was transferred into the Estate checking account on 12/312019.
Jeepers, Inc. will be dissolved.
" The inventory reflects a total value of personal property that is $1,335,011.00 greater than the value as of 
12/31/2019
included in the first quarterly accounting. This is a result of an increase in value of Thomas World Air of $25,000.00, 
an
increase in value of SCI JEP of $954,011.00 (a result of values in Euros being included in the First Quarterly 
Accounting rather
than values in US Dollars), and the inclusion of Lyn and Jojo, LLC. These increases in value will be reflected on the 
Amended
First Quarterly Accounting to be submitted to the Court.
Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein Probate No. ST-19-PB-80 Verified Inventory Page No. 5
Respectfully,
Dated: February 28, 2020 W r ae-Ck
CHRATOP R ALLEN ICROBLIN, ESQ.
ANDREW W. HEYMANN, ESQ.
WILLIAM L. BLUM, ESQ.
SHARI N. D'ANDRADE, ESQ. RA A D /ADM Ulill A I CM Veil
Estate offeffrey E. Epstein
Verified Inventory Page No. 6
Probate No. ST-19-PB-80
VERIFICATION OF INVENTORY
I, Darren K. Indyke, hereby verify that I have read the foregoing Inventory and that I know the
same to be true and accurate to the best of my knowledge.
Dated: Cebatooti 2.131.2c2o
Darren K. Indyke
STATE/TERRITORY OF floriA., )
)ss: COUNTY/DISTRICT OF c).A.vt13tiAcIN )
On this 2-V Arlay of February, 2020 before me the undersigned, personally appeared Darren K.
Indyke, known or proven to me to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and
acknowledged under oath that he executed the same for the purposes therein contained.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I hereunto set my hand and official seal.
NOTARY PUBLIC
My Commission Expires: II/2 1 it, o 2.-3
Notary No. GO% qts740
Estate ofJeffiey E Epstein Probate No. ST-19-P8-80
Verified Inventory Page No. 7
VERIFICATION OF INVENTORY
I, Richard D. Kahn, hereby verity that I have read the foregoing Inventory and that I know the
same to be true and accurate to the best of my knowledge.
Dated: 20 ( g 1/444, Richard D. Kahn
STATE/TERRITORY OF
COUNTY/DISTRICT OF
) A Je n" --7oeut •
Jive)7044
On this 2tday of February 2020, before me the undersigned, personally appeared Richard D.
Kahn, known or proven to me to be the person whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and
acknowledged under oath that he executed the same for the purposes therein contained.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, I hereunto set my hand and official
AASIiitK NOTARY PUBLIC
My Commission Expires:
Notary No.
NURALLAN NAZEMLI Not, SPut seNow No 01
Owned In Pin Yak rem Evans Sootondmse/ligon
Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein Probate No. ST- I9-PB-80
Verified Inventory Page No. 8
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that on this 286 day of February 2020, I caused a true and exact copy of
the foregoing Verified Inventory to be served upon:
Via Electronic Mail by Agreement of the Parties:
John H. Benham, Esq. A. Jeffrey Weiss, Esq.
Law Office of Jahn 14 ReTthann_Pr_ALWeissteissocia
Douglas B. Chanco, Esq. Sean Foster, Esq.
ChancoSchiffer P.C.  Mariorie Rawls Roberts, P.C.
Richard Bourne-Vanneck, Esq. Kevin F. D'Amour
Law Offices of Richard Boume-Vanneck Gaylin Vogel, Esq.
John K. Dema
Law Offices of John K. Dema Melody D. Westfall. Esti.
Via First-Class Mail:
Denise N. George, Esq.
Attorney General
Chief, Civil Division
Virgin Islands Department of  Justice
ars Rw Oiroo Rees To
PO Oss 0140
%nam PR S140
ISSOM4/0/ 11101011015
ma _ •
NOV 6 2016
1 First Beat
ISTATEMBIIT OF ACCOUNT
20741(0MDUAL CHEt2010
~II. 7301
12/O:»Uk %, gg54 ,El gigtfik. ,
w, ^k.s .!
-K.r.
a
0.554.220M 0 .L0 1 000450544 110 Do
1211,013110 aCCOMT liOneacrttio
OOMS Na=
Dan Hooit 02011110/1
70/01 1,154,555.44 CL0111212 OURSIMOI
02121~22 Ass Aø11 na MI laasa•
ormoran ral/ TM ~Oe 0.00
TOM Ornizalin om/ 1IMM VO MS 0.00
10.2111. Mam =MS 17511/T02 r22200 0.00
rom n nar 0232/FOLL TO Dis 20.00
Da32.2 Laan ZIWORMSIOR
DOS Smal ars Maa WE 114131211
11130 11,451 p 335.44 10/0I1 .00
ir ne MOOI Olga ro m10< Tin ni ren
MI. ta ARD man na ni or roat Raintaniat
ns laar. RUL MAT 717.723.1511 Ot 1.144.405.2511.
WOLOW•M •01111bita Sepolzed-In
EXHIBIT

╭─ Page 9, Image 1 ─╮
│ é                 │
│ deh               │
│                   │
│ NOV 05 2019,      │
│                   │
│ em ae en omen     │
╰───────────────────╯

After Fere Days Return To:
PO Box 9140
San Juan PR 00808-0148
00001101 lif SPRY' 0,11911203e0V I OCCOCOCCC
REESTATE OF JEFFREY E EPS TEIN
9363 ESTATE THOMAS STE 101
' ST THOMAS VI 03802
First Bank
STATEMENT OF ACCOUNT
STATEMENT DATE I
09/30/19
MS -COMMERCIAL CHECKING
X901
BEENIONNEI sauce WOWS, Ma ONNIn Wiwi I WS MWM sawn
San.
IMMO DALANCE most NOW 091111180 men Aiiiver nets
.00 0 .00 0 .00 .00 .00
DAILY BALANCE INFORMATION
DATE BALANCE DATE BALANCE DATE BALANCE
09/26 .00
IF YOU FORGOT OR RANT TO CEA= YOUR VISA DEBIT PIN
CALL US AND SELECT TOE PIN OF YOUR PREFERENCE.
ITS EASY. CALL TODAY 787.725.2511 OR 1.866.695.2511.
EXHIBIT
Tat 101 toi cam -cal /A FB<gVIT1101 I XCLOVOI 4
Attar Five Days Return To.
PO Box 9148
San Juan PR 00908-0148
0:03730 MFBPRVI1011130747240V 3 COODX033
M" . .— ESTATE OF JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
9053 ESTATE THOMAS STE 101
ST THOMAS VI 00802
First Bank
STATEMENT OF ACCOUNT
STATEMENT DATE
10131119 ----.-.-- ----
200-COMMERCIAL CHECKING
S31
BEYOMMMOMMJ.KM DEPOSITS/OTKERCREOff$ CNICKS(OTHEREIUM11 SERVICE
"ARO"
EMIMOWUJACE
NUMBER AMOUNT CREDRED NUMBER AMOUNT DEBUT D
.00 4 19630386.64 33 367982.67 11.50 19262,392.47
CHECKING ACCOUNT TRANSACTIONS
DEPOSITS AND OTHER CREDITS
DATE AMOUNT ....... DESCRIPTION
10/07
10/25
10/08
10/11
30,293.00
3,947.05
8,554,555.44
11,041,591.15
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT -0000000016
CR INCOMING WIRE TRANS
OTHER DEBITS
DATE AMOUNT  DESCRIPTION
10/16 25,000.00 *CR DB -101519-051000013711665
EIS8777143739
10/16 25,000.00 ACH DB -101519-051000013711661
EIS8777143739
10/16 25,000.00 ACH DB -101519-051000013711662
EIS8777143739
10/16 25,000.00 ACH DB -101519-051000013711663
10/16 25,000.00 ACH DB -101519-051000013711659
6I48777143739
10/16 25,000.00 ACH DB -101519-051000013711660
10/16 25,000.00 ACH DB -101519-051000013711664
RI88777143739
10/16 23,125.10 ACH DB -101519-051000013711655
&148777143739
10/16 14,774.83 ACH DB -101519-051000013711666
EISB777143739
10/16 13,659.86 ACH DB -101519-051000013711656
EIS8777143739
10/16 3,927.57 ACH DB -101519-051000013711658
E198777143739
10/16 3,724.03 ACH DB -101519-051000013711657
EIS8777143739
10/16 90.59 ACH DB -101519-043305136468131
EXTRA VALUE CHEC
COCC030.3eNtall-CCO3A06PRV110111X/4/20Y ,01 L
Page 2
1 First Bank
CREWKING ACCOONT TRANSACTIONS
OTHER DEBITS
DATE
10/18
10/18
10/18
10/18
AMOONT
284.73
153.98
120.91
89.71
DESCRIPTION
ACH DB -101719-0430002641317403
TIME WARNER CABL
ACH DB -101719-043000264817377
TIME WARNER CABL
ACH DB -101719-043000264816939
TIME WARNER CABL
ACH DB -101719-043000264815851
TIME KARNER CARL
10/18 80.47 ACH D8 -101719-043000264816301
10/18 69.99
TIME KARNER CARL
ACH DB -101719-043000264816937
10/18 65.75
TIME WARNER CABL
ACH DB -101719-043000264817379
10/18 59.17
TINE KARNER CABL
ACH DB -101719-043000264816303
10/18 48.53
TIME WARNER CABL
ACH DB -101719-043000264816833
10/18 40.24
TIME WARNER CABL
ACH D8 -101719-043000264815889
10/18 28.20
TIME WARNER CABL
ACH DB -101719-043000264816313
10/21 465.05
TIME WARMAR CABL
ACH DB -101819-091000014209684
10/21 371.17
VERIZON
ACH DB -101819-091000014209683
10/22 10,333.55
VERIZON
ACH DB -102119-021000029548810
10/22 125.27
CON ED OF NY
ACH DB -102119-021000029549733
10/28 366.70
CON ED OT NY
ACH DB -102819-021000021806037
10/28 166.92
COMCAST 8535114
ACH DB -102819-021000021805821
10/30 66.62
COMCAST 8535114
ACH DB -103019-043000264083413
10/31 0.75
TIME WARMER CARL
SERVICE CHARGE
GABLE PAY
10/31 10.75 SERVICE CHARGE
10/16 27,572.65 FORCED PAT CHECK 1297
10/16 93,171.08 PORCED PAY CHECK 1298
0:002312-3630-0O22 C033 10BPRVI 1011GC14 7240V 011
After Flys Days Return To:
PO Sox 9146
8an Juan PR 009084)148
®WWI N19PM12W190..2W 20V 2 0201:01)20
ESTATE OF JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
9053 ESTATE THOMAS STE 101
ST THOMAS VI 00802
1 First Bank
STATEMENT OF ACCOUNT
I STATEMENT DATE I
/30119
205-COMIIERCIAL CHECKING
MISszool
ISOWIMMOIL4LANCII /0/14. CNBOWSIOWWWWWMW ememme
CHAMOIS MIIMMOIMaNat maim Ammon 44___ mom ANOWFMMERO
19,262,392.47 2 213434300 14 200321.89 11.50 19,275,489.08
CHECKING ACCOUNT TRANSACTIONS
DEPOSITS AND OTHER CREDITS
DATE AMOUNT DESCRIPTION
11/26
11/26
204,215.00
9,215.00
CHECKS
DATE. . CHECK NO AMOUNT
DEPOSIT
DEPOSIT
DATE ....CHECK NO AMOUNT
11/26
OTHER DEBITS
DATE
11/07
11/12
11/13
11/14
1003 160,000.00
AMOUNT
20,037.07
326.36
206.14
490.38
DESCRIPTION
ACE DB -110729-043000096286969
OXFORD HEALTH
ACH DB -111219-031100207172881
ATT
ACH DB -111319-031000032535721
VERIZO9
ACH DB -111419-021000028688573
PREMIUMS
Payment
PAMMENTREC
11/18 142.46
VERIZON WIRELESS
ACH D8 -111819-043000263260059
PAYMENTS
11/20 359.62
DISH NETWORK
ACH DB -112019-031100207383915
DISH NTWRA
11/20 335.89
An
ACH DB -112019-031100207383903
Payment
11/26 7,482.50
ATT
AC8 DB -112619-021000024184767
Payment
11/26 1,170.85
CON ED OF NY
ACE DB -112619-043301603830079
INTELL CX
11/27 9,215.00
ADS SECURITY HER
RETURNED DEP CHECK
ADTPAPACB
11/27 366.70 ACH DO -112719-021000024997993
11/27 166.92
COMCAST 8535114
ACH DO -112719-021000024997139
11/27 20.00
COMCAST 8535114
RETURNED CHECK In
11/29 1.00 SERVICE CHARGE
CO:01077 51460001 We WIIPAY1202190720137/ D14.
ACCOUNTMI(401 Page 2
1 First Bank
CHECKING ACCOUNT TRANSACTIONS
OTHER DEBITS
DATE AMOUNT DESCRIPTION
11/29 10.50 SERVICE CHARGE
DATE BALANCE
DAILY BALANCE INFORMATION
DATE BALANCE DATE BALANCE
10/31 19,262,392.47 11/14 19,241,330.52 11/27 19,275,300.58
11/07 19,242,355.40 11/18 19,241,180.06 11/29 19,275,489.08
11/12 19,242,027.04 11/20 19,240,492.55
11/13 19,241,820.90 11/26 19,285,269.20
IF YOU FORGOT OR KANT TO CHANGE YOUR VISA DEBIT PIN
CALL US AND SELECT THE PIN OF YOUR PREFERENCE.
ITS EASY. CALL TODAY 787.725.2511 OR 1.866.695.2511.
CCON0/741400XQ0:024.011PRVI202•03729120Y-014.
After FMe Days Return To:
PO Box 9148
San Juan PR 0090B-0148
CXOXO61 PAMPRV0I D13007 X.110/ 4 000000000
ESTATE OF JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
9063 ESTATE THOMAS STE 101
ST THOWS VI 00802
1 First
203-OO1AMERCIAL CHECKING
a3901
Bank
STATEMENT DATE
12J31/1D
semismoswomr, wommetommmotrons omecomoluprimirs service
mimosa BIDING "lamWHAM AMOVIR can* muss raiDUM mina
1927509.08 9 329791582 45 15927976.42 19.50 6,645,428.98
CHECKING
DEPOSITS
DATE
ACCOUNT TRANSACTIONS
AND OTHER CREDITS
AMOUNT DESCRIPTION
12/10 68,000.00 DEPOSIT
12/13 9,215.00 DEPOSIT
12/23 2,600,000.00 DEPOSIT
12/23 2,500.00 DEPOSIT
12/31 210,124.09 DEPOSIT
12/31 192,383.80 DEPOSIT
12/31 100,322.12 DEPOSIT
12/18 80,000.00 CR INCOMING WIRE TRANS
12/12 35,390.81 CR INCOMING WIRE TRANS
CHECKS
DATE. ...CBECK NO  AMOUNT DATE. .. .CHECK NO AMOUNT
12/19 1004 566.59 12/30 1017 1,028.64
12/16 1005 630.00 12/27 1020* 9,145.50
12/13 1006 750.00 12/23 1021 44,623.90
12/13 1007 1,088.75 12/31 1023' 742.00
12/30 1008 3,179.34 12/31 1024 742.00
12/13 1009 4,788.42 12/31 1028* 20,000.00
12/30 1010 4,803.53 12/23 1030* 179,308.12
12/19 1011 630.00 12/23 1031 12000,000.00
12/23 1013* 14,983.94 12/23 1032 3500,000.00
12/23 1014 368.10 12/31 1038* 378.00
12/19 1015 256.95 12/31 1041* 68,030.00
12/18 1016 1,163.50
OTHER DEBITS
DATE AMOUNT DESCRIPTION
12/04 28.84 ICH DB -120419-021000024668443
12/05 397.11
CON ED or NY
ACE DH -120519-021000023671913
INTELL CK
12/05 125.26
UM0C/EZ-PAT
A.CH OH -120519-021000023671713
UTILITY
!PVC/la-PAY UTILITY
0:03:001.5/934:C01 a0M1 16PRWI01 200)2041CIV Olt
Page 2
1 First Bank
COMING ACCOUNT TRANSACTIONS
OTHER DEBITS
DATE
12/06
12/20
12/11
AMOUNT
20,037.07
10,071.41
967.07
DESCRIPTION
ACH DB -120619-043000098921963
OXFORD HEALTH
ACH DB -121019-091000014725928
CNMEC
ACB DB -121119-021000022054425
PREMIUMS
ELEC PTMNT
12/11 152.37
VERIZON WIRELESS
ACH DB -121119-043000263171983
PAYMENTS
12/12 144.98
DISH NETWORK
ACB DB -221219-043000264227669
DISH NTWRK
12/13 152.22
TIME WARNER CABL
ACB DB -121319-043000262934277
CABLE PAY
12/16 113.12
DISH NETWORK
ACH DB -121619-043000260983261
DISH NTMRK
12/28 142.46
DISH NETWORK
ACH DB -121819-043000263659591
DISH ATMRK
12/19 4,599.42
DISH NETWORK
ACE DB -121919-021000020932395
DISH MMUS
12/23 3,131.23
ConturyLink
ACH DB -122319-028000087892009
Payment
12/24 1,369.18
NYC WATER BD/DEP
ACH DB -122419-043305139935865
WATER4SWE
12/27 366.70
WASTE MANAGEMENT
ACH DB -122719-021000026590563
INTERNET
12/27 166.92
COICAST 8535114
ACH DB -122719-021000026603597
12/30 6,420.93
CONCABT 8535124
ACH DB -123019-021000021911493
12/31 10,361.76
CON ED OF NT
ACH DB -123119-043000097363224
INTELL CZ
12/31 6,728.63
PAYCHEX
ACE DB -123119-04300009736322/
PAYROLL
12/31 5,262.46
PAYCHEx
ACE DB -123119-043000097363223
PAYROLL
12/31 7.75
PAYCBEX
SERVICE CHARGE
PAYROLL
12/31 11.75 SERVICE CHARGE
12/18 15.00 WIRE TRANSFER FEE
12/12 15.00 WIRE TRANSFER FEE
C0Z0DSI 5704 COZQ CON 4,4FEWRY01Q12COT204 ICN.014.
ACCOUNT 7211126901 Page 3
1 First Bank
DATE. . .....BALANCE
DAILY BALANCE INFORMATION
DATE BALANCE DATE  BALANCE
11/30 19,275,489.08 12/12 19,346,940.78 12/24 6,279,974.88
12/04 19,275,460.24 12/13 19,349,376.39 12/27 6,270,295.76
12/05 19,274,937.87 12/16 19,348,633.27 12/30 6,254,863 32
12/06 19,254,900.80 12/18 19,427,312.31 12/31 6,645,428.98
12/10 19,312,829.39 12/19 19,421,259.35
12/11 19,311,709.95 12/23 6,281,344.06
IF YOU FORGOT OR MINT TO CHANGE YOUR VISA DEBIT PIN
CALL US AND SELECT THE PIN OF YOUR PREFERENCE.
ITS EASY. CALL TODAY 787.725.2511 OR 1.866.695.2511.
BANCO POPULAR DE PUERTO RICO P.O. BOX 362708 SAN JUAN PR 00936-2708
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Y/0 DARREN K INDYKE
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER
STE B 3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
cvv's 30010
BANCO POPULAR.
196-077567
POPULAR Par*
This ebterneet reflect your
Bank Relationship Summary
EXPOSITS
CREDIT
fl _tt  Accosts
020209.93
+ liovIngs/Noneg Plena
0.00
• CietRIalemo/IRA/CAE
0.00
mg TONI
020,20930
Rana
0.00
I. Credit Coot
0.00 OAO
• WAS
0.00
Checkkg Azeures
020,209.93
I00.00%
Popular Plus Account Detail
CHECKING BALANCE INFORMATION
1:7737 1.6": Balance "% tr .
- CliedN/Delib • Clow • ESNs Belga I
0.00 0.00 820,209.50
Average Dolly lances 07.01 haeolemeinede Perko* Rote
020,137.62   32 0.000274%
REGULAR AND EteaRctac Crews
I Dote Dualodon
12.31 Innate cneittee
Mimi ,' BstmcE
IOat Delalption
1202 leginum balance during tint cycle 820,137.62
Man
An-ount
AaaMM PereeMege
Ylatl Emceed
00.10%
NENF.RT t4i A:150(71 17:S NP l'A'RES
NOTAIRFS AW
/admis NENERT
Dais lie Drei
leaChnstophe NENERT
Patrick MONTAGNE
Antoine KROELL
Stéphan SIROT
Matir-ka ROQUE
NOTAIRES
Christine BERNARD
leon.Plulippe BRUNET
Sébastien FERNANDES
Florent FOSSET
Donnai GED
Arec GOURANTON
Sophie GUERIN TOURNIER
Tbkriore LALIEU
Cree LAURIE
Lionel MAUCLAIR
Aurae NENERT
Cedric NISSEN
Poulenc RICSSER
Urie« 2ERBIB
!flint SIMON Dossier suivi T Maître So I UERIN-TOURNIER
SUCCESSIONJEP
183612 /SS iSGT
Chère Maitre.
Maitre Nadine VOISIN
Avocate à la Cour
Cabinet HUGHES HUBBARD & REED LLP
PARIS, k 21 février 2020
Dans k prolongement de notre conversation téléphonique, vous voudrez bicn trouver sous ce pli le relevé du compte de la 
succession de Monsieur /effrey E.
Epstein (ouvert par soucis de confidentialité sous le nom JEP) sur lequel nous avons encaissé k prix de vente de la 
Mercedes.
Je vous confirme que ce compte est ouvert en nos livres sur un compte spécifique et que les fonds sont destinés à régler
les factures, frais et droits de
succession attachés à ce dossier au nom et pour les compte des légataires.
Après 3 mois d'immobilité, ce compte sera automatiquement consigné à la CDC où il générera 1% d'intérêt annuel.
Votre bien dévouée
Mare S• GUERIN-TOURNIER
SCP NENERT ET ASSOCIES
Notaires
RELEVE DE COMPTE
Vos references 108449 SUCCESSION XP -XP 183612 Ma references Notalre - Oerc SGT
A PARIS 8erne arrondissement, le 21/02/2020
SUCCESSION JEP
Pour la ode du 2 1 2019 au 0&0212020
Date Melte d'ecriture Debits Credits 2/102019 C5120I910201SIS67 HP SS4GT SUCCESSION /EP A SPE SHOOS PARIS $ 14.60
HY IO 2019 DOE K BLS + ETAT HORT • SAUV TC PARIS /EP - SOT CM
20413019 Reps de MR 0I2 ADAC OIL BERT boo IX VIE VOITURE 120 000.00
0602/2030 Troulth Ai DIM iii I6906)1 Osi 2101 ai3Z0 • INTESKOGATION CMOON OU 26010010 H mu I2010
• : takure(s) Pros (soma) Total final 252.63 120 00000
Ciampic Crtditcur Ilae 119 747,34
Le comp:c lint pas 10in 110Mren DO
Ripon Rion des fish d'arte(s)
Ems's mails d'acics 0.00 Debora 0.00
Emolurnenis de formalises 000 Elm - spr !Enregisuenseni 0.00
I loitomiles 0.00 End - WA my 0.00 0.00
Remise sus tencilvincnn
toimmeal
0.00 Debases et Etat
0.00
Rembouesemem <Mimi ions 000
Remuneration Elude 000 0,00
WO a 21/02 1202011? 4,14 Pop I .v,1
AM Lan teMsmon to: ome M woven aufelv W IMr Maim IeS II.Mmen t.a TrAstwases, M pram
rionlartko lent. Yror — IIIM T lady r- Wr-LIM 2 — Wm! No. -r TIM Mute - I
IIONSKJKC7JR222801 12018 logy UT I 5831 I I 130104940 I
Registered Owner. Date of I..00 02/14/2018
A041n
um Sum
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MAW a IN &rat MOS a MRS Seem!
308 EL IRILLO WAY
PALM BCH FL 33480 - 4730
MA8 To
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
368 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BCH FL 33480 - 4730
I I III &II I I III t1I 1111 11 I ill II III I It II III III II II.II ISI II Ill
si:Ii.  I Yam -r Isn 'sr r Wr.irt.  vissm's" S. 7 Ista  1 tIm Rein
siscocc74222soi I 20181CHE V LIST I chill 1130104440  War a er. 'Miami mon Is ANON
Lir. •-• $ISLA unman  ans  _71 . A z  F  IN  Hamm Ea 1 Sy
_I  PH/BAn I Onlor   AvelY !Dm
I I
TUr
Oils
noom7012 IIITOMOBEEO11
1. Wren ownership of Os veNcll• doscrend Stein Is
turalimml. IS seller FAUST complete In MIN,
Tonsfsr of TIM by Seller maim al OM belkm or
It. osrdflarlo of Ms.
2. Upon solo of lids vehicle, Um saner mod °ample&
IM Roam offal, on the emerso skis of IMO° rm
3. Asmara your Hansa pis from &a vsbed•
4. Soo Ihs mob add nom below lot mole Iftromodon •
ths approptIme tomes required bum purchaser to
Ole DS regime the mthirls. mobile le nto or mast:
POpitimmv.flettme.00sihoskIllInf hml
Olonslit IBM ot Ifismi rilamticIn or 04...
7 NILES 01/26/2018 ACTUAL
R4IMRInd Ch•Tier
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
388 EL SRI LLO WAY
PALM BCH FL 33480 -4730
111 Lieoholda
NONE
IM MOM Aoa or ales
I 0211412016  I
DIMON Of MOTORIST
Papi
SFR/ICES TALLAHASSEE
eosin.' Number
FLORIDA
134489555 kW ft RAMA
OHMS
OEYMTUDIF OF HIGIMAY SAFETY NO MOTOR UNCLES
fr er47/e1 41 4.
TWO L. Sue
Use* OIMIst
TRANSFER Of ME BY maul ors ..an not It tOttOlotfdallio Ilea a In)
Point toritoo smarm mph Rom Me semi nal.. FS moon •••• 0004•110••• oaf foitaid I. ••••••filoo elthintoesofortomet•
Rrilm•vembirommilass bin emisismm IsM le S..
1..mmWo le Sr Moan lhomorm or minim Sam stimodllor eillsoormthle ommlarrollol DM*, IrmanS1
Idler al tow forttmoottlfs
Sella. W Far talon Prior  Mamie/ false ttelo14-
Wm am irm S s O4 fel Malt We I (so oalSoRm dams& riMCIP es Is m 1 th e lomMill lb re " 8"r
❑ I IMMO AMA'. -SAM ❑ L Annum or in ameammcm.Lpon. 0 Lumen nosnattmanag
GOER PIOUS Of MU MY.  OMAR, THAT I WAS NIUD TOE fORPOONII 0001 1T NO MAT IS Piltti SLUM NIT NIE TIM
&WO —
so Hot
PAW Pim
StOlog osin IJa...IS.r
AtoOkto Nom
ILLOIAUR Moot
Yip Mot
PIP' Ma:
Ollerialas
S PAM
Tab MlY
Us TM:
2144 Dire
who Rore
MOTU. FavLry emu= or Late • la 'Quinn:nose  MINIX DAM MA SAW Of maws
EXHIBIT
1 5
•

╭────────────────── Page 21, Image 1 ──────────────────╮
│ — 7 Yea ate 7 By Wt Tenet age Ne. Te ber             │
│ HyewskuKc7unzzzeo1 __|                               │
│ Regitered Oxmer Tate of Kare 0271472018              │
│                                                      │
│ UEFFREY © EPSTEIN                                    │
│ EL BRILLO WAY                                        │
│ PALM BCH FL 93490-4730                               │
│                                                      │
│ ‘your as een brn                                     │
│ ‘Taneiecot Tat by Sareea ha boo ot                   │
│ Maid To: ‘he coca o                                  │
│ 2. Upon lao hig vail, satay ma                       │
│ nae of eae ort irate aie tna om                      │
│ EL BRILLO WAY 3. Ramove your lone pu rom the vehicle │
│ PALM BCH FL 33460-4730 + Satemabadinebaeieinom bans  │
│ ‘Site roger tha vat mab ome oremma                   │
│ epson tha Got                                        │
│                                                      │
│ CERTIFICATE OF TITLE=                                │
│                                                      │
│ em pone ene Do ee                                    │
│                                                      │
│ corey oe cea                                         │
│                                                      │
│ ox/te/2010|                                          │
│                                                      │
│ commen 134489555 en cae -                            │
│                                                      │
│ ‘TRS FEROF THLE BY SELLER Te ton mtb opted he re fe) │
│ Fed tm ee mp be te ag prs me                         │
│ eeu pring me at Urn                                  │
│ ‘Water ey aga on af ld es ee hy dr                   │
│ Sete ht ne Pre Soa                                   │
│ te Mae ang = ‘tr arb                                 │
│ em tts Js] nr I                                      │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

2018 Chevrolet Suburban LT Sport Utility 4D Trade In Values I Kelly Blue Book 2/2f1/20. 3:30 PM
Home Car Values Cars for Sale Car Reviews Car Repair Pricing Research Tools •
's My Car Worth a Style a Options & Condition > LT Sport Utility 4D
A 3 Recalls Found • Servkeli Repair Estimator
a Is my car affected? What's a fair price?
A Important Info
"I' &definitions
Track this
cars values
Condition: Excellent
Vafid for ZIP Code 33480 through 02/28/2020
Ovenl Consumer Rating 4 / 5
***** 10 Ratings
Write a review
TRADE4N VALUE
This estimated value helps you
confidently negotiate with dealers.
Average Tine to Trade•In:
DAYS
Live: of Effort
Medium
See Overview of Values
Start the Trade-in Process Online
P get a no-obf rgai ion quote for your next tar.
You re Interested In:
Chevrolet Suburban
Change vehicle
Choose up to 3 dealers
https://www.kbOcornichavrolausuburban/2018/It-sport-cat any-ad/WO...a 
-1000084prIcatypastrads-In&conditionvexcallant&options4170589itrue Papa 1 of 4
Satan is Dia al l4101•••ir Bawl, W Weir *Kan. NO Kass Scalirq. lellal••••• /141714440
idarabler
3/8 PRO >K83000621
•••., w, l yr➢ Visa Pea a
2017 CA/J4 OH
tis Watt
TI 944222602
si 1253144
IIIIIIIIIII IIIIIIII
Repine., Cvl)Cr Cato of Lana 01/12/2011 LION ROMP.
Mal 0 an Onata adapt haft ~el
MOTILE! COMA= IFS/81H 04
358 EL BRILL') WAT DM
PALM REACH, FL 33480 4730 Oa
Mod To
BRCNAS4) MOTORSPORTS OF PALK BEACH
2300 04018CMCIMI RV
WEBT PALM BCH, FL 33409
MORONI 1313.31661SICIR
I Ma swan* a S seas Orated tan is
Mama& Is SS MST analis a AI
UMW el Nola taw wan M fa town
• 4444k • 40
2 lam Sio din WAS no meat mat tavola
to era d IS ants Mono ito el Pis ban
1 Roma awe Sr.. allo Hot ut  wade
4 100044410 Sane brae In non amnia ma
ae sacra taw naiad a Cos paean( to
War ragiast la alba. Mott tome a amid
lapateamm• Matt taffillalar4
:r". 1 W-•• ..1( --
U 1.
1.
a
;44-,*CERTIFICATE,OF-JITLE-4-, .,•••
Nana* Ma taw Oda Oar Wra14 4 Vaal Ras Oa at ante
Saltuttas000 67; 2017 CAM Cl 125943430 1441 Pan neMOW WM Omaha a 14 Mita Mph*
Row ram ma Omer Oak  Hoo Pa. ow Os to Ebb
mint
Oasaw issa nos salaam • 01.16
OW - not suitable for highway un
Rasatard 0•14./
45/114ZT *Dia= Inn in
359 9L MILW ST
PALM BRACE, IL 33490-4730
IstLienbc4da
CoASCK CO 14010AST SECMCES uu.sAmaal
Pak Raba I( preei
Nina
kg, Ma am. P.,••••• Ora
la wow*,
Parini
lb
sae Om a sa.
01/12/2017 Om
' 1-1' 125895872 1 /3 125695872
aroatota OP NailaalANITAPONOW.MCISS
lett faalse
I — Dada
mate IA CO Met6.StWRfl34 raga ma a maws a re Mehl
hid ea as la mow.aob.i m *swam a baso rho samoionamonoo....a.faaido
haw woman, radars Ss ram agoras as .414.4pamma
lYa ols obt in boo. larnwonnoa ons lopaotailiononboandononosoosstaawmamoin
fa• as is. $414aMs. 2040541.40a Sol
4144,444444  14, 0 4441444.4010•Inin.... --n. -../ .:414alolbOota rani.---__ al las soarlsolasdatoosallasamlase•
El 1 ata/C41/ALIMINSI 0 1•144:044 a 1131004marsteall f 3 • an siasnuaaassa
vac. 44,414.411110FERRIPROIMOIS AM allialala IHMIII0309000WIONT Me ISM Oa /ant tine a Mal AUL
Man— Mauls ma
*PM ,  Sans
Pio Hoe Pm Ha
•••• •••••Pril#01.10
gadPIM. town Naas
Pa CW&$JI 44a 0144ACIWO4 Ma
ta. HOY niana
.4 /Vans
441.12:12,044LW a liabilitinanairallierinaliThIPIIIMMIN 444.014115404Tinalialt
STATE OF FLORIDA
I
EXHIBIT
• ''./* . 24
1,1 •
A
r
m
--4
.
(' )

╭────────────────────── Page 23, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ smpmaszasoooe:7 «207k 125903690                              │
│                                                              │
│ Repiuered Owner: Date of tence 01/32/2017                    │
│ Ermer rooso everETH                                          │
│                                                              │
│ ‘358 £1 marito war                                           │
│                                                              │
│ ‘ALAC REACH, 71 33400-4730                                   │
│                                                              │
│ 01/2/2037                                                    │
│                                                              │
│ 350 EL anruio war                                            │
│ ‘ala BEACH, FL. 33480-4730                                   │
│                                                              │
│ Int Lenbelder                                                │
│                                                              │
│ Range ~~ | Te Cina                                           │
│ =e Cale 125895872                                            │
│                                                              │
│ 1p om                                                        │
│                                                              │
│ nF He or SEER maa opment)                                    │
│                                                              │
│ Rasen het rr ea drs a et ye                                  │
│                                                              │
│ ‘ta Sg paren                                                 │
│                                                              │
│ Pormect (he [seers A | tA en ne hy rh a ah cl a              │
│ sone nchitbaace Cisne er mueruscuinen —"* Tystierneccscaamce │
│                                                              │
│ = [=o                                                        │
│                                                              │
│ STATE OF-FLORIDA                                             │
│ BIT                                                          │
│                                                              │
│ “NOILOVASILVS N31                                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

00amir UR OATS IWO
0 METER - EXEMP
oCCISTI(0:0•111 RANT BANE Mt)
A03001
LIEN 1ST Lail 0
111.1ASIS END LIEN P O6í~Ai11A8 TIIIE DAIL
[ 0 ,/~CaTa PAROt,
RICUT.K80 T.rEA IOW M111 FRIO
164 YOLR
van Motiti
.4Stx REG% NO
Mg  ~It*
EPSTEIN JEFFREY
358 EL BRILLO NAY
PALM BEACH FL 33480-4730
CIAVI a OW
ADDITIONAL LIENS
'AIWA.< Win MOO/ of peen wen au. tworartha Went 11COOI 311 13/103. 1:0141‘ SIMON, Ti011 TO n5 5crg« au a vamp male> MEOW
et YU repels»! ~MD pa» ea N4 5~4
alano•I a mu • 5 5• 5
(OR MD 110110111/4K1i OR runt
mu 100Cit I •1131 I lIrTn•Sfir r .44.. mot le0. ~Its
YOU IC7 1 2100 I  76811694 O. CCROR nR VIII
S 8
ETE
LIN B
JEF
LO WAY
FREY (-)
3, RIL
-PAIN BEACH PL 33480 - 4730
NIT ItiFtl DOI OASI
DO I no nni
NONE
PIVS0 5 /4 OP monn %%Man
Cam OS liuk
01/26/99
uw sac ~TONI MOW 04803810 MC* 5 MOT 551510>
et in
TALLA~ • ~IDA
dad Peer 36860253
ISEPAITMENT OF FRIBWAY SAFETY
'
AND w0T01 VE14ICLiss
tfl1100108 b Mum cOONME ~AT» • rioted ad me low Pm** oft. 884 h ••••••••.• e *rd. ~55 hi« 5
I II et 'eves • We ~se me. ~eh effin ~h. ~ea
Ty .b toned el b. No DS es Do 4a0 Do DO S. M MO ~SS ad Si ~Or ••••in vsa k lrN.wA.w
Dom goldLAW Ids cm,,, Mw  Go memijil ow CI 8 64Woolmmiar we lode cep cm 8 he model
Mk*. -.• ••••  r,. me tom ig O^I temeolo*
ORI ds
COMM ri I. liege .,w I I Me rlei *I of 5.5%.5. Sr leers cede Sets to
SIM -4 •Ilii.110 IN w, a".  0 Om nos ore:" SON DO DOT OW I... seams el odletzt  et MO .1~ tat
or e., MIls•alv .stas1  Vo•Na ili d~4 BOX • Acne& n 1. ~iv S Gm ~b. II  rt i.  atm.
WA« 1- 4 WS • 0005ETIE 011einNicr.
HAM MAURY Of MARY, I DECLARE ~THAW' MAD NE ~OM DOME« AND DAAT TNE FACTS STARRY IN IT ARE ME
arai pieeshmo rnme d 1s•
:
sl
k ..2": a  Ass wromay   ,.,..,M .•
len
c.. L
bi ...~   ..I
:
Met ea gt
i.m.: «I  . •
ergs  AYH tow M
4-IIdoe   , tri) ins. Amdfahhl
ha Oilhod $gat ME ..Y Ustms A.J.  he Ík , 4 ,
' Aedn As  •  Om% Offilkor   .\Çj
-
N CHH )
-•••“...-.. 8.,U N.' ,.›... — ..,
EXHIBIT

╭── Page 24, Image 1 ───╮
│ {STATE OF FLORIDA     │
│                       │
│ rmx                   │
│ atzase                │
│                       │
│ rseroies              │
│                       │
│ SESTELN, JEFFREY (-)  │
│ 358 EL BATLLO wal     │
│ PALW BEACH FL         │
│                       │
│ Lathedlesbdletdla     │
│                       │
│ (“)                   │
│ RIDE Hlbcay           │
│                       │
│ 0 gs Ih Co eer oe OIC │
│ Sas a                 │
│                       │
│ SSNOMOVASILVS Nalt    │
╰───────────────────────╯

GOVERNMENT OF
THE VIRGIN ISLANDS OF THE UNITED STATES
-O-
CHARLOTTE AMALIE, ST. THOMAS, VI 00802
Corp. No. 581737
OFFICE OF THE LIEUTENANT GOVERNOR
To Whom These Presents Shall Come:
I, GREGORY R. FRANCIS, Lieutenant Governor of the Virgin Islands, do hereby
certify that:
LSJ EMPLOYEES, LLC
a Virgin Islands Limited Liability Company, filed in the Office of the Lieutenant Governor on
March 13, 2013, as provided for by law, Articles of Amendment to Articles of Organization,
duly acknowledged; changing its name to
LSJE, LLC
WHEREFORE the said Correction is hereby declared to have been duly recorded in this
office on the aforesaid and to be in full force and effect from that date.
In Witness Whereof, 1 have hereunto set my
hand and affix the seal of the Government of the
United States Virgin Islands, at Charlotte
Amalie, this 21" day of March, A. D., 2013.
I-
GRSeeWY R. FRANCIS
Lieutenant Governor of the Virgin Islands
EXHIBIT
1 8
OPERATING AGREEMENT
OF
LSJ EMPLOYEES, LLC
A U.S. Virgin Islands Limited Liability Company
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT (this "Agreement') is made and entered into as of
December -, 2011 by Jeffrey E. Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Sole Member"), with an
address at 6100 Red Hook Quarter, Suite 13-3, St. Thomas, USVI 00802 and who hereby forms LSJ
EMPLOYEES, LLC, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company (the "Company") pursuant to
the U.S. Virgin Islands Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (the "Act") upon the following
terms and conditions:
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Sole Member makes and executes this Operating Agreement on
the day and year fast written above.
WIlNESSETH:
EXHIBIT A
MEMBER LISTING; CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS
Members Capital Contributed Membership Units Percentage Interest
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN $1000.00 100 100%
•
APCEPTED ‘ANRA.Alltkr6: -
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
C),.-4-obtr ai l aril
DATE
Particulars of Annual Report Filing 2019
FREEDOM AIR PETROLEUM, LLC (581842)
Filing Date 07/31/2019 10:32 AM
Handling Option
Annual Report for Filing Year
Tax Identifier Number
Standard Processing
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of
Business
Mailing Address
Changed
6100 Red Hook Quarter B2, St Thomas, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Amount of Capital Used in Conducting Business in USV1
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
Total Capital
Previous Value
Capital Withdrawn
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of
this Report
Previous Value
Highest Capital Amount
during the reporting Period
Business Details
Managed By
Managers/Members
1,000.00
0.00
1000.00
0.00
1,000.00
1,000.00
Manager Managed
EXHIBIT
Individual
Name Jeffrey E EPSTEIN
Status Active
Physical Address 6100 Red Hook Quarter 83, St Thomas, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Member
Individual
Name Larry VISOSKI
Status Active
Physical Address Royal Plams Professional Building, 9053 Estate Thomas Suite 101,
Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Manager
Documents
Balance Sheet Crewed
BALANCE SHEET.docx07/31/20I9 I 0:32 AM
Income Statement Crewed
INCOME STATEMENT.docx07/3 I/20 I9 10:32 AM
Signature(s)
Name Ms. Erika KELLERHAI S
Position Attorney in Fact
On Behalf Of Manager
Name Larry VISOSKI
Date 07/31/2019
I DECLARE, UNDER Yes
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
FULL KNOWLEDGE THAT
ALL STATEMENTS MADE
IN THIS APPLICATION
ARE SUBJECT TO
INVESTIGATION AND
THAT ANY FALSE OR
DISHONEST ANSWER TO
ANY QUESTION MAY BE
GROUNDS FOR DENIAL,
SUBSEQUENT
REVOCATION OF
REGISTRATION, OR
OTHER FINES AND
PENALTIES PURSUANT TO
THE FRAUDULENT
CLAIMS STATUTE AS SET
FORTH IN 14 V.I.C. § 843.
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Yes
Submitted By ERIKA KELLERHAIS
Particulars of Annual Report Filing 2019
MICHELLE'S TRANSPORTATION COMPANY, L.L.C. (573529)
Filing Date 07/31/2019 6:18 PM
Handling Option
Annual Report for Filing Year
Tax Identifier Number
Standard Processing
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of
Business
Mailing Address
Changed
9053 Estate Thomas, Ste 101, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Amount of Capital Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
Total Capital
Previous i'alue
Capital Withdrawn
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of
this Report
Previous Value
Highest Capital Amount
during the reporting Period
Business Details
Managed By
Managers/Members
1,000.00
0.00
1000.00
0.00
1,000.00
1,000.00
Member Managed
EXHIBIT
Individual
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Status Active
Physical Address 6100 Red Hook Qtr, B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Member
Documents
Balance Sheet rated
BALANCE SHEET xlocx07/31,2019 6:18 PM
Income Statement 'reared INCOME STATEAENT-doc‘07/3 12019 6:18 PM
Signature(s)
Name Ms. Erika KELLERHALS
Position Attorney in Fact
On Behalf Of Member
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Date 07/31/2019
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Yes
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
FULL KNOWLEDGE THAT
ALL STATEMENTS MADE
IN THIS APPLICATION
ARE SUBJECT TO
INVESTIGATION AND
THAT ANY FALSE OR
DISHONEST ANSWER TO
ANY QUESTION MAY BE
GROUNDS FOR DENIAL,
SUBSEQUENT
REVOCATION OF
REGISTRATION, OR
OTHER FINES AND
PENALTIES PURSUANT TO
THE FRAUDULENT
CLAIMS STATUTE AS SET
FORTH IN 14 V.I.C. § 843.
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Yes
Submitted By ERIKA KELLERHALS
UNITED STATES, 00802,9053 ESTATE THOMAS, SUITE 101,
CHARLOTTE AMALIE, UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
12/1P/2002 12:43 PAX 2002 04:(16/80 18;17 FAX 614 404 8280 V.S.S.&P. COLS 81009/00.
L.S.J., LLC
jitnitart t i2hfflizi Company Agreement
TBIS LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY AGREEMENT (this "Agnmartenti, dated April 18  199E by Jeffrey E. Epstein (tha "M mbar");
EXHIBIT
I  It
12/10/2002 12:43 FAX V.01£0,[01 Iniat CAL 014 INM 5WOU v.0.5-AF. COLS e003
S9Govoch
in WITNESS VrA239iEGE, the undersigned has duly
liability Company Agreemmt of L.SJ., LLC, affective as of the virtual.
YEPPREY E. BPS
-2-
this Limited
and year finit above
THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Annual Report Filing 2019
ZORRO MANAGEMENT, LLC (587081)
USVI Lieutenant Governor
Filed: August 01,201909:15 AM
BID: 587081
Changed
Handling Option Standard Processing
Annual Report for Filing Year 2019
Tax Identifier Number
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of 9053 Estate Thomas Ste 101, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Business Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Amount of Capital Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital 1,000.00
Additional Capital 0.00
Previous I 'due
Total Capital 1000.00
Previous I'a/ue
Capital Withdrawn 0.00
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of 1,000.00
this Report
Previous Value
Highest Capital Amount 1,000.00
during the reporting Period
Business Details
Gene
EXHIBIT
I  II 7AM I of 3
Managed By
Managers/Members
Individual
Name
Status
Physical Address
Mailing Address
Email Address
Position
Documents
Balance Sheet
Income Statement
Signature(s)
Name
Position
On Behalf Of
Name
Date
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
Member Managed
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Active
6100 Red Hook Qtr B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Member
B A LA NCE. S H LET .clocx07/3 9 8:38 PM
INCOME STATEMENT Aocx07/3I /2019 8:38 PM
Ms. Erika KELLERHALS
Attorney in Fact
Member
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
07/31/2019
Yes
Generated on February 21,2020 10:17 AM 2of3
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER TILE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
FULL KNOWLEDGE THAT
ALL STATEMENTS MADE
IN THIS APPLICATION
ARE SUBJECT TO
INVESTIGATION AND
THAT ANY FALSE OR
DISHONEST ANSWER TO
ANY QUESTION MAY BE
GROUNDS FOR DENIAL,
SUBSEQUENT
REVOCATION OF
REGISTRATION, OR
OTHER FINES AND
PENALTIES PURSUANT TO
THE FRAUDULENT
CLAIMS STATUTE AS SET
FORTH IN 14 V.I.C. § 843.
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Yes
Generated on February 21.2020 10:17 AM 3 of 3
OPERATING AGREEMENT
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT OF NEPTUNE, LLC (the "Company"), dated DecemberZ) , 201 1, is adopted and executed by Jeffrey 
E. Epstein ("Member"), as the sole member
of the Company.
EXHIBIT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, this Operating Agreement xecuted by the so • ember of the
Company this 21," day of December, 2011.
E. EP
SOLE MEMBER
OPERATING AGREEMENT
OF
NES, LLC
A New York Limited I,iability Company
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT (this "Agreement") of NES, LLC, a New York limited
liability company (the "Company"), organized under the Limited Liability Company Law of the
State of New York (this "LLC Law") is adopted as of January 1, 2014 by the Company's sole
member, Jeffrey E. Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Sole Member"), with an address at 6100 Red
Hook Quarter, B3, St. Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands 00802, who has determined that the Company's
activities and the rights and responsibilities of its members shall be governed by the following terms
and conditions:
EXHIBIT
1  1
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Sole Member makes and executes this Operating
Agreement on the day and year first written above.
z sciii MEW)
( Jeffrey E. Epstein
)
OPERATING AGREEMENT
OF
PLAN D, LLC
A U.S. Virgin Islands Limited Liability Company
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT (this "Agreement") is made and entered into as of
October 19, 2012 by Jeffrey E. Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Sole Member"), with an address
at 6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3, St. Thomas, USVJ 00802, who hereby forms PLAN D, LLC, a U.S.
Virgin Islands limited liability company (the "Company") pursuant to the U.S. Virgin Islands
Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (the "Act") upon the following terms and conditions:
EXHIBIT
1  15
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Sole Member makes and executes this Operating Agreement on
the day and year first written above.
WITNESSETH:
SOU MEr3ER:
Jeffrey E: stein
EXHIBIT A
MEMBER LISTING; CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS
Number of Percentage
Capital Membership Membership
Members Contributed
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN S1000.00 100 100%
ACCEPTED AND AGREED:
By:  - DATE: October 19, 2012
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
OPERATING AGREEMENT
OF
JEGE, LLC
A U.S. Virgin Islands Limited Liability Company
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT (this "Agreement") is made and entered into as of October 19, 2012 by Jeffrey E. Epstein 
(hereinafter referred to as "Sole Member"),
with an address at 6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3, St. Thomas, USVI 00802, who hereby forms JEGE, LLC. a U.S. Virgin Islands 
limited liability company (the
"Company") pursuant to the U.S. Virgin Islands Uniform limited liability Company Act (the "Act") upon the following 
terms and conditions:
EXHIBIT
1  16
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Sole Member makes and executes this Operating Agreement on
the day and year first written above.
alIIBIT A,
MEMBER LISTING; CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS
Member
Number of Percentage
Capital Membership Membership
Contributed 1211i1§ )lures(
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN S1000.00 100 100%
ACCEPTED AND AGREED:
By: _ DATE: October 19, 2012
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
OPERATING AGREEMENT
OF
HYPERION AIR, LLC
A U.S. Virgin Islands Limited Liability Company
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT (this "Agreement") is made and entered into as of
October 19, 2012 by lenity F. Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Sole Member"), with an address
at 6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3, St. Thomas, USVI 00802. who hereby forms HYPERION AIR,
Ile, a U.S. Virgin Islands limited liability company (the "Company") pursuant to the U.S. Virgin
Islands Uniform Limited Liability Company Act (the "Act") upon the following terms and
conditions:
EXHIBIT
I  II
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Sole Member makes and executes this Operating Agreement on
the day and year first sstitten above.
EXHIBIT A
MEMBER LISTING; CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS
Number of Percentage
Capital Membership Membership
Igmbgt4 Contributed Unit.$ Interest
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN $1000.00 100 100%
ACCEPTED AND AGREED:
83.. JEFFREY E.EPSilTIN
DATE: October 19. 2012
THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Annual Report Filing 2019
THOMAS WORLD AIR, LLC (576399)
USVI Lieutenant Governor
Filed: July 31,201908:28 PM
BID: 576399
Changed
Handling Option Standard Processing
Annual Report for Filing Year 2019
Tax Identifier Number
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of 9053 Estate Thomas Ste 101, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Business Islands,00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Amount of Capital Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
1,000.00
0.00
Total Capital 1000.00
Previous Paine
Capital Withdrawn 0.00
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of 1,000.00
this Report
Previous Value
Highest Capital Amount 1,000.00
during the reporting Period
Business Details
EXHIBIT
Generated i I  18  I I of 3
Managed By Member Managed
Managers/Members
Individual
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Status Active
Physical Address 6100 Red Hook Qtr B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Member
Documents
Balance Sheet
Income Statement
Signature(s)
BALANCE SHEEI .docx07/3 I /20I9 8:28 PM
INCOME STATEMENT Aloc ‘07/3 U20198:28 PM
Name Ms. Erika KELLERHALS
Position Attorney in Fact
On Behalf Of Member
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Date 07/31/2019
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
Yes
( rented
Created
Generated on February 21.2020 10:21 AM 2 of. 3
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
FULL KNOWLEDGE TliAT
ALL STATEMENTS MADE
IN THIS APPLICATION
ARE SUBJECT TO
INVESTIGATION AND
THAT ANY FALSE OR
DISHONEST ANSWER TO
ANY QUESTION MAY BE
GROUNDS FOR DENIAL,
SUBSEQUENT
REVOCATION OF
REGISTRATION, OR
OTHER FINES AND
PENALTIES PURSUANT TO
THE FRAUDULENT
CLAIMS STATUTE AS SET
FORTH IN 14 V.I.C. § 843.
Ms. Erika Kcllcrhals
Yes
Generated on February 21, 2020 10:21 AM 3 of I
Particulars of Annual Report Filing 2019
LSJ EMERGENCY, LLC (585911)
Filing Date 07/31/2019 4:03 PM
Handling Option
Annual Report for Filing Year
Tax Identifier Number
Standard Processing
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of
Business
Mailing Address
Changed
9053 Estate Thomas Ste 101, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Amount of Capital Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
Total Capital
Previous l'alise
Capital Withdrawn
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of
this Report
Previous Value
Highest Capital Amount
during the reporting Period
Business Details
Managed By
Managers/Members
1,000.00
0.00
1000.00
0.00
1,000.00
1,000.00
Member Managed
EXHIBIT
Individual
Name
Status
Physical Address
Mailing Address
Email Address
Position
Documents
Balance Sheet
Income Statement
Signature(s)
Name
Position
On Behalf Of
Name
Date
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Active
6100 Red Hook Qtr, Suite B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Member
BALANCE SHEET Aocx07/3 120 19 4:03 PM
INCOME STATEMENT.docx07/1I/20I9 4:03 PM
Erika KELLERHA LS
Attorney in Fact
Member
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
07/31/2019
Yes
( reared
Geared
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF TILE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
FULL KNOWLEDGE THAT
ALL STATEMENTS MADE
IN THIS APPLICATION
ARE SUBJECT TO
INVESTIGATION AND
THAT ANY FALSE OR
DISHONEST ANSWER TO
ANY QUESTION MAY BE
GROUNDS FOR DENIAL,
SUBSEQUENT
REVOCATION OF
REGISTRATION, OR
OTHER FINES AND
PENALTIES PURSUANT TO
THE FRAUDULENT
CLAIMS STATUTE AS SET
FORTH IN 14 V.I.C. § 843.
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Yes
Submitted By ERIKA KELLERHALS
UNITED STATES, 00802,9053 ESTATE THOMAS, SUITE 101,
CHARLOTTE AMALIE, UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Particulars of Annual Report Filing 2019
SOUTHERN FINANCIAL, LLC (583164)
filing Date 07/31/2019 8:16 PM
Changed
Handling Option Standard Processing
Annual Report for Filing Year 2019
Tax Identifier Number
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of 9053 Estate Thomas Ste 101, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Business Islands,00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Amount of Capital Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
1,000.00
0.00
Total Capital 1000.00
Previous Value
Capital Withdrawn 0.00
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of 1,000.00
this Report
Previous Value
Highest Capital Amount 1,000.00
during the reporting Period
Business Details
Managed By Manager Managed
Managers/Members
EXHIBIT
j
Individual
Name
Status
Physical Address
Mailing Address
Email Address
Position
Registered Business Entity
Entity Name
Business Identifier
Status
Physical Address
Mailing Address
Email Address
Position
Documents
Balance Sheet
Income Statement
Signature(s)
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Active
6100 Red Hook Qtr, B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Manager
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
Active
9053 Estate Thomas, Ste 101, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Member
BALANCE SHEET dont07/31 /2019 8:16 PM
INCOMb. STA l'EMENTAlocx07/311019 8:16 PM
Creak?,
Name
Position
On Behalf Of
Name
Date
Name
Position
Date
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
FULL KNOWLEDGE THAT
ALL STATEMENTS MADE
IN THIS APPLICATION
ARE SUBJECT TO
INVESTIGATION AND
THAT ANY FALSE OR
DISHONEST ANSWER TO
ANY QUESTION MAY BE
Ms. Erika KELLERHALS
Attorney in Fact
Member
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
07/31/20 I9
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Manager
07/31/2019
Yes
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Yes
CT-07 F06033O00a)g ARTICLES OF ORGANIZATION
OF
LYN AND JaK) LLC
Under Section 203 of the Limited Liability Company Law
FIRST: The name of the limited liability company is: LYN AND J0.10 LLC (the 'Company).
SECOND: The County within this State In which the office of the Company is to be located is: Nassau County
THIRD: The Secretary of State of the State of New York is designated as agent of the Company upon whom process against 
it may be served. The post office address
within or without this State to which the Secretary of State of the State of New York shall mall a copy of any process 
against the Company served upon him or
her is:
Darren K Indyke, Esq.
457 Madison Avenue
4th Floor
New York, NY 10022
FOURTH: The name and street address within this State of the registered agent of the Company upon whom and at which 
process against the Company can be served
is:
Darien K Indyke, Esq.
467 Madison Avenue
4th Floor
New York, NY 10022
Darren K Indyke
Organizer
EXHIBIT
1 21
CT-07
CT-07
F 060330000R) g
ARTICLES OF ORGANIZATION
OF
LYN AND JOJO LLC
Under Section 203 of the Limited Liability Company Law
Filed by:
( ME OF NEW YORK DEPARTMENT OF STATE FILED MAR 30 2006 WS_
Amanda Kern
GC :6 WV OC NVW 9334 Wd 63 OW 9001
a3A, 03AFJOMi
Notice of Tentative Assessed Value for 2018/2019 2/28/20, 2:24 PM
NASSAU COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF ASSESSMENT 24O Old Country Road, Mineola, New York 11501 (516)571-1500
January 2018
18 TENEYCK AVE
VALLEY STREAM NY, 11580
Section-Block-Lot: 37169 01141
Tax Class: 1
NOTICE OF TENTATIVE ASSESSED VALUE FOR 2019/2020
Valuation Date Valuation Date Change
1/2/2018 1/2/2017 from 1/2/2017
Full Market Value: $356,000 $356,000 +$0
Level of Assessment: 0.25% 0.25%
Tentative Assessed Value: 890 890 +0
Transitional Assessed Value:
*The Transitional Assessed Value will be reduced by any exemption amount you qualify for each year.
The Full Market Value figure shown, as of 1/2/18, does not take into consideration any potential change in
value that is currently being considered by the Assessment Review Commission (ARC). Should ARC reduce
the assessed value for this property, they will provide the owner or the owner's representative with a written
settlement.
You can help the Department of Assessment improve its valuation efforts by reviewing your property's
inventory utilizing our Land Records Viewer on-line at www.mynassallpmperty.com and follow the link to
"Property Search." Please inform us - in writing - of any corrections that need to be made. Some inventory
discrepancies may require an inspection of your home.
• Full Market Value is the estimate of your property's market value as of January 2, 2018.
• Level of Assessment is the percentage of Full Market Value at which properties are assessed.
• Tentative Assessed Value (TAV) is calculated using your property's Full Market Value multiplied by
htlps://tv.nossoucounlyny.govicorrespond.php?plth371694•011408ryret 2020 Pagel of 2
Notice of Tentative Attend Value for 2019/2019 2/28/20, 2:24 PIA
the current Level of Assessment of .25%. (Example: A Full Market Value of $400,000 x .0025% =
1000 in TAV)
SPECIAL NOTICE:  Be advised that County Executive Laura Curran reversed the former administration's
decision not to provide a paper Notice of Tentative Assessed Value for the 2020-21 tax year and directed the
Department of Assessment to continue to mail its annual Notice of Tentative Assessed Value to all property
owners.
If you would like to challenge your assessment or property's classification or exemption status, you may file
an "Application for Correction of Assessment" with the Assessment Review Commission (ARC) between
January 2,2018 and March 1,2018. The application is available and can be obtained on-line at
wwwenassaucountynygoviarc,  in person at the Department of Assessment's office located at 240 Old
Country Road in Mineola, or by contacting ARC at (516) 571-3214 after January 2,2018. The Department
of Assessment's hours of operation are from 8 A.M. to 4:45 P.M.
C-2
httpt://Irv.nanaueountyny.gov/cOrreepOnd.php?pid-37169++01140ayr•2020 Page 2 of 2
ASSIGNMENT AND ASSUMPTION AGREEMENT
ASSIGNMENT AND
Op RI Inc., having an address at 9100 Port of Sale Mall, Suite 15, St. Thomas, USVI 00802 (the 'Assignee").
RECITALS:
A. is the sole Member of Great Saint Jim, LLC, a United Suites Virgin Islands
limited liability company (the "Company"), holding 100% of the Membership Interests therein (the
"Membership Interest").
D. and the Assignee intend that the Assignee be admitted to the Company as
a substitute Member i lace with respect to the Assigned Interest.
EXHIBIT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have executed this Agreement on the date first above
written.
EL
POPLAR, INC.
By: Jeffrey Epstein, President
THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Franchise Tax and Annual Report Filing 2019
POPLAR, INC. (581872)
USV1 Lieutenant Governor
Filed: September 09, 201907:32 PM
Changed
Handling Option Standard Processing
Capital Stock Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
1,000.00
0.00
Total Capital 1000.00
Previous Value
Capital Withdrawn 0.00
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of 1,000.00
this Report
Previous 1 aloe
Highest Capital Amount 1,000.00
during the reporting Period
Handling Option Standard Processing
Annual Report for Filing Year 2019
Tax Identifier Number
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of 610 Red Hook Qtr B3, Charlotte Amalie, United Suites Virgin Islands,
Business 00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Gene
EXHIBIT
I  2 AM I of .1
Directors/Officers
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Status Active
Physical Address 6100 Red Hook Qtr 83, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position President
Tenn Expiration Perpetual
Name Darren INDYKE
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Secretary
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Richard KAHN
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Treasurer
Term Expiration Perpetual
Documents
Did the entity have Economic No
Activity during the reporting
period?
Previous I ahte
Balance Sheet Poplar BS Dec 20 I8.pdf0909/20I9 7:32 PM
Cleated
Generated on February 21, 2020 10:42 AM 2 of 4
Income Statement
Signature(s)
Name
Position
On Behalf Of
Name
Date
Name
Position
Date
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER TILE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
Poplar ICS Dec MIS:p.:1039/09/2019 7:32 PM
Ms. Erika KELLERHALS
Attorney in Fact
President
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
07/31/2019
Richard KAHN
Treasurer
07/31/2019
Yes
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Ycs
Crefittel
Generated on February 21,202010:42 AM 3 of 4
• GOVERNMENT OF Pay Onent:Giml  if neenlvtet hat o. THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS Casa WNW, 106007 OFFICE OF Dia LJ 
BUTENANT GOVERNOR Awoke Marin 23028169
TAX ASSESSOR'S OFFICE No. 5049 Kansans Gide 111
Charlene Amalie, Si. Thomas, Virgin Wands LIOSEQ-6487
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ASSESSMENT AND REAL PROPERTY TAX BILL Deer Property Crew.
Tom 2719 Nader et Cheese of /aware al and Ertl rem* Tot SEI lose bear ROWS r • anal 'toot Ryou InelForlete4 Own fl an", 
taa bit, MN be Miele • papaw* Mae pp
Baines Dr Wed trierElbereN atll aes+rpriere tbiteddNeeel aterIl robe wooed lows the MSS he OI.Weird* Um Feel Datum M Gil
cutaway target, Ilia• IrilicatnIC no re
nrvenr Jae PI Etta
Tar May haw Pal YOSPDOIlly at* air a of7Sysmendy•ac a. • Mum errniop•I adore for Sao corrowir II ru anon to Pry yew et] 
by it  Mad Me Oar PSSII et Or or Mil and
aril /1 In the wear nee sworn der your Seta or money order matte merit Ow OOVERIOAEXT OF Ile UNITED STATES VIRG /ISLANDS
DO NOT WO CAEN.
tar may th e pay h person by ta  Vint money ceder, a crier mad (UsslerCerd a Awl The cabs •111 retain h haw aaen a par 
OP Pay Ka Rea Papery Tax fa by DUE DATE
OP AUGUST T4 We IAN crags of l prowls MIS NOW Si. OCTOSEllia, alit. You mink/es INPORMAL REVIEW DV re Sr Tax Aseraseane 
Mee In weir ring via 47 Wendy drys aner
the ton a/ of Sr timbal by sending se IR finals gar t,._lorry., „ssylessatity, You may Wm mall Is ate IA Fern er an Se 
!mitre to rill/m:1r ••••••et• Ora In row
tralet Whoa Mr eat 'Della- COI fat 17 seem or Ala LI I a W•W pOVAi ser V1C.T 33, 7451 . a legrlre1 with this leasesset 
you may Se • PORNAL ayprd b On hard et Ta
Tinier. Deperonwe of rhyme& ACT OM antereterl ACT 7114 r oratelaft • mtniouro tea motel of $140 Ace Stan, tedot. and 
Cambay art lot tor 701E fax yaw nod • roll
awn in Send of $160 kr ALL bererind ovate In lh• Mart ye rid pros land.
IOTA RtAL. PROPERTY TAX SASS ARE SENT TO Ins DANIR AS Of JANUARY 1. 2V to
2019 NOTICE OP CHANGE OF ASSESSMENT ARO REAL PROPERTY TAX BELL GOVERNMENT of THE UNIT® STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
SI. Mann
r aMES MUM No. BA RED HOOK QTR. ASSESS® {AND
MARLON
ASIOSED IIIPROVIDAHT
OXIA00
NISOMMIO
TOTAL
AMOUNT
OF TAX Lass 'ma AMOUNT CINDITE DIE
EEO
at Vallerria I:flea *tan RIZ. fey.' Pyre Proton: u, EiVidry GREAT SLOE tiC 101
SOD Ermetrars
et Deem IS tea
wAtteWATut
LEER FEE
OAD
TAXMAN: .003T70
t to, 0 I • : ti
Mir
• GOVERNMENT OF M Oakla Rfalaptpshaul iate ME UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS Cordsol Mayin1068157 OFFICE OF THE LIEUTENANT
GOVERNOR Sae Nara 23028160 TAX
ASSESSOR'S OFFICE
No. 5049 Kalisz's Ode Alt
Charlotte Amalie, St. Tau, Virgin Was 00802-6487
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ASSESSMENT AND REAL PROPERTY TAX SILL Os Propose, Ownar.
Your 20 TO Nada it Choir Maapootrans sat Roil Priam Tax MO too ban mad Ma Man bias. S you had an ovorpoyment boa you* ME
tube, ITIM ASIIMS• nyntrat. MOM Ms
liaisinom Out Mad balsa Cabal at ammummIlaatat aril all bo applied Maeda Or me to tall Wastorson thie For ergot rd St y 
ostuarens moody I saes an asplaissd a,
Ito rams ado/lila GI] You ray now pry yos properly ES MEM St SOIS.Mil=e404Silt. Or. mart ..-aY artlooM bl parr act maw= 
Naas Moan t• My So elf by ITS. a off Po
boar pat' rd Or as El sod NSa a ra* 'Scud alum ronalapa pa (NO at Pay ay MON Meta GOVERNMENT OF IRE UN rm STATES MR0E4 
SUNOS DO NOT BIND CASK.
You ray fl u pay a Krim by can. Crock money odor. a mat oard ChtssateCasd a 164 TM Cana la ran Po Ma ma 01 a tan Pay pa 
Rad Prowl); Tax bill by OWE CATE Of
AIJOUST 14, 2019 late charm it  1 proms free bawl Mar OCTOISOR K Mt. You nay Ma at INFORMAL REVIEW SR) CI ate Tax 
Assonaes Once in your district within4a abed,.
din Aar tbs an of Mta fax bLi by soft an R Fs to • YOU may Moo wan In M IP Sans or you on oleo Imas0 ha HA the Yu 
Mallasof Oltoa In row male  alms you Gin Mth.
cia fit% macs or vitt to r staa.gor .v1 tor data. VIC, TM, 1451, OppWed with a swam you may Nea FCSIM spgalm W 101.0  
Tax Itsvlosr, satsannt or Mamma ACT DM rad
ACT 7164 b. 161 a albasaun, tax amount of MU kr Veen halos, oad Olutdsty maks for Os 201 a Is., yes sno s rranaours to 
noun al MS tor ALL bar -teed NC, In Ira
1011 taw year and ON Iowa
20t1 REAL PROPERTY TAX MU.1 AR! WC TO THE OWNER AS OP JANUARY t, roe
2019 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ASSESSMENT AND REAL PROPERTY TAX BILL GOVERNMENT OF THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
& Thomas
IMIKES14/4-2.5410041.1144 QREATIT.Inn  WAND NO. IA  RIO KOOK QM
AIMPEESIO AS:ISM AVM= MONO a TAX AMMAR' VAMRSVATER oMEEPSIMMT TOTS& OP TAIt CREWS 01.4 SURF=
USER 0
GREAT ST JIM LIC
SUITE 101
P353 Eta Thomas
& Dam, VI 00802
2.75 luso \Goo is ate
TM 16 1E 40.10
Des Property Owls,
Yes 2019 Mae Mawr es Ameaarees end Res Ptr Tax NI haa hem ~on • meePerl Rena hew >in "I ~meat Prom your Ole bls. Mee Si 
rage a pnimmaid. Penn pay Balms Der
Ualael bolas KORN In eal an awapayemet M MciNianal war ata ba appINS Mamba the Zia at  MIL WastlitesIst User Fem chaages
ed ar t meaning ptepty was et uplartme
se um nu rede d Me PG
You may mom Pay YOU nely as MI Wane« Or, Sr nernan b endued for yaw ainlawm you ~sloppy per be Pi eta bear cal the beer 
palm al IM bEl Grad return la the ended
ratan iamMope Mir 0%9001 irceey only omOn Inglin WA GOA WOAENT OF TIE UNITED STATES MRI3 IN MANG& GORKY? ISNO CASK
may abo pay in pow by aen, chadr, moray oldie a am& owe (111~Card aV u) TM oohed so MS es loser sac br a yoti mi Pay yar
Rs& Property Tax tO by Du E GATE OP
AUGUST 14, 2011. Wadraeeal pmeent a POW Nave altar OCT0118R 14. WI. Tau soy Me tywoftliaL REVIEW R) aria the Tax Maesta 
Oils In yew OM« MOM as alandat day@ Mir
IM Maumee of the tax IM by ~NV an M Pont b sustotEML~emolms, Yee may Sae mar% IR Fom if you as So knits ea eta Nu Taa 
Messea Onto* In pew dieriel saws year on
Ilk Um US caw (me) 7714S00 wpm s at yeteraler.1.1 ear Oa VIC, 113.f 2.431, Ft ~eyed ren thle ussarrent pu may Ma a 
FEWMAL VMS le Ilea Bee IN Ta %Mew, Dippenni
or rnenos ACT •013 anctad ACT 7104 b.alaxen • red ~tun ma amount es MOON war^ Sass, me Osattaty ermine Fa Um 2018 to 
year sod a inicastuae • armours M t110 Fa
ALL hertafled await In the MIS Na yes arla atria ~-
EOM RD/ PROPERTY TM MIS ARS SENT TO THE OWNER AS Of JANUARY I, !OM
GOVERNMENT OF Pay owns  022taL010kbliakiSt THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS 04aboi Normben 10686$ OFFICE OF THB 
LJELTTENANT GOVERNOR /meta Mahan 23026180 TAX
ASSESSOR'S OFFICE No. 5049 Karp* Gale III Chaska Amine, St, Thomu, Vi'gb Wands 00802.6487
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ASSESSMENT AND REAL PROPERTY TAX BILL
2019 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ASSESSMENT AND REAL PROPERTY TAX ELI. GOVERNMENT Of THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
St Themas 2019
a' Ima ga siall MWEIMED Mee matatra ~LINT
OP TM
LIU CREME TM Mawr
CUE wASTAWATIR
GOMM TOTAL
2.720.100 2,73t100 le/47J1 MO
TM RATE'
*AO L1441.60 040 13.14188
GREAT ST JIM, LIC
SUITE 101
9053 Lea Dicta
St Thom«. VI 00802
.OW46
Lkt At'PhitO
ale
THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Franchise Tax and Annual Report Filing 2019
LAUREL, INC. (581980)
USVI Lieutcnani Governor
Filed: September 09,2019 07:33 PM
BID: 581980
Handling Option Standard Processing
Capital Stock Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
Total Capital
Previous Value
Capital Withdrawn
Previous l'alue
Amount of Capital at Date of
this Report
Previous lalue
Highest Capital Amount
during the reporting Period
Handling Option
Annual Report for Filing Year
Tax Identifier Number
1,000.00
0.00
1000.00
0.00
1,000.00
I ,000.00
Standard Processing
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of
Business
Mailing Address
Changed
6100 Red Hook Qtr B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Gencn'Ic
EXHIBIT
1 1 9 M I of 4
Directors/Officers
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Status Active
Physical Address 6100 Red (look Qtr 83, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position President
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Darren INDYKE
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Vice-president, Secretary
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Richard KAHN
Status Active
Physical Address
Email Address
Posit ion
Term Expiration
Documents
Treasurer
Perpetual
Did the entity have Economic No
Activity during the reporting
period?
Previous Value
Balance Sheet
the Physical Address
laurel HS Ike 2018.pdf09/09/2019 7:33 PM
(
Generated on February 21.2020 10:44 AM 2 of 4
Income Statement
Signature(s)
Name
Position
On Behalf Of
Name
Date
Name
Position
Date
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
Laurel ICSDec 2018009/09/20197:33 PM
Ms. Erika KELLERHALS Esq
Attorney in Fact
President
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
07/31/2019
Richard KAHN
Treasurer
07/31/2019
Yes
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Yes
Generated on February 21.2020 10:44 AM 3 of 4
COUNTY OF PALM BEACF CE OF AD VALOREM TAXES AND  M.D VALOREM ASSESSMENTS
pSO4ROpERTT CONTROL NO.
3-43-27-06-000-0391 2019
BBL NO.
CM C MIMED MORMON(3)
Nil atIVOITtiatqlfritiii7;614 :Nar<W&II VI
LAUREL INC
9100 PORT OF SALE MALL SIT 15 ST THOMAS VI 00802-3802
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
SUPPLAINTRY PL OF El. BRAVO PARKIN 24,30 PT OF LT 39 a LT 40 6TH PT OF FILLED SUBMRGED LTLAND AS IN OR4208P1926 ADJ TO 
40
ANNE M. GANNON
caorminonn TAR cellthia Suring PJw Bath Canty
wew.pbotAM.com I ED©coune
2019 REAL ESTATE PROPERTY TAX BILL RIAXIZERSE SE BEFORE CALLING Al AL17140RITY OUNTY
COUNTY DEBT
TOWN OF PALM BEACH cPutofte48 SERVICES COUNCIL FAH.D.
Cat
UARE DISTRICT
AngS CONST PROJECT 50 5I.A WA AN  DIST 50 FLA WATER MOW • OKEE BASIN
RAH/ RE5 54 BERRI CALLING LEI/NINO A THORITY
PALM REACH UNDERGROUND UTILITIES 30: -ID WAS TEAUTHORITY OF PSC
AD VALOREM TAXES TELEPHONE ASSESSED
5814554996 13,618,230
5814533396 13 018,230 581438-5444 13,84430 581.740.7000 13.618230 561427-3386 13018,230 541469-1270 13.816230 
561.4348837 13,007.789 5814344537 13067.789
5814384800 13,818230 581460-6800 13,818,230 561486.8800 13.618230
EXEMPTION READ REINPSE SIDE BEFORECAD/NG TAxAbLE MILLAGE
13.618230 4.7815 13.618.230 0.0785
13018,230 3.0681 13,618,230 0.8497 13,818230 0.0320 13018230 07281 13.967.789 32480 13067,788 3.9160 13,618,230 0.0307
13,618,230 0.1162 13,618,2X 0.1248
TAX AMOUNT
65,116.57
1D41.79
41,782.09
8.1147.78
435,78
9086.20
45.387.38
SAWA
503.84
1.56802
1,838.83
TOTAL AD VALOREM 230,882.72 NION•AD VALOREM ASSUSIMINTS READ REVERSE SIDE BEFORE PAWS* TELEPHONE RATE AMOUNT 5.814364444
1579.59 1,979.59 5614404030 525.00
625.00
TOW 11011-AD VALOREM 2,504.69 TOTAL AD VALOREM AND MONAD VAU)Rait COMBISED 233,41721
1;L1 $ AMOUNT Dui WHIM REAMED DY
,D0Y34,1110 DEC mains Win= R3 29, MO MAR SI. 2020
TAXES ARE DELINQUENT
APRIL 1, 2029
5224,14141 5228,482.70 5218.817.56 $231,152.44 5233,487.31
I 4% : I 3% 2% 1% NO DISCOUNT
MSTRUCTIORS ANb INFORMATON•• MERE
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH: NOTICE OF AD VALOREM TAXES AND NON-AD VALOREM ASSESSMENTS I i 140114
titer,
tkiiint
t °LIM. YEAR (WINO.
443-43-2t708-000-0391 2019 101481016
11ALEAMIL STE 15 001102.3602
DESCPARTON
3:1.1.9ortY ft OF EL BRAVO PARKW
MD ro AS IN OR4215591
FT F LT09 & LT 40
ORTH pl if trkfry0 P.O. BOX 3353
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33402-3353
201910 14 810150233487314
MAKE PAYMENT TO:
TAX COLLECTOR, PALM BEACH COUNTY
AMOUNT DUE MCI WORM WY
lA *HMS Oct st. 2011 IAN AI, 2019 FEB 24, 2020 MAI 31., 2020
TAMS ARE DOJNQ BENT
APRIL 1,2020
4224.14741 6226,482.70 5225.817.68 $231,152.44 5233.487.31
4% 3% 2% 1% NO DISCOUNT
RE PI m 08/21/2019 2019 REAL ESTATE PROPERTY TAX BILL
THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Franchise Tax and Annual Report Filing 2019
MAPLE, INC. (581976)
USVI Lieutenant Governor
Filed: September 09,2019 07:32 PM
BID:581976
Handling Option Standard Processing
Capital Stock Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
Total Capital
Previous Value
Capital Withdrawn
Previous Paine
Amount of Capital at Date of
this Report
Previous I Win
Highest Capital Amount
during the reporting Period
Handling Option
Annual Report for Filing Year
Tax Identifier Number
1,000.00
0.00
1000.00
0.00
1,000.00
1,000.00
Standard Processing
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of
Business
Mailing Address
Changed
9053 Estate Thomas Suite 101, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Generate
EXHIBIT
1 ZS M of 4
Directors/Officers
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Status Active
Physical Address 6100 Red Hook Qtr 83, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position President
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Darren INDYKE
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Secretary
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Richard KAHN
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Treasurer
Term Expiration Perpetual
Documents
Did the entity have Economic No
Activity during the reporting
period?
Previous. I able
Balance Sheet Maple BS Dec 2018.p:1309/09,2019 7:32 PM
Created
Generated on February 27.2020 08:39 AM 2 of 4
Income Statement
Signature(s)
Name
Position
On Behalf Of
Name
Date
Name
Position
Date
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
Maple ICS Dec 20IS.pdf09/09,20I9 7:32 PM
Ms. Erika KELLERHALS
Attorney in Fact
President
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Richard KAHN
Treasurer
07/31/2019
Yes
Ms. Enka Kellerhals
Yes
C
Generated on February 27.202008:39 AM 3 old
NYC Finance ktostfis836-pts-access.nyc.govicarekholetsidataktespx?mode...
fseponflob
Awe SS*
Mooted Warr
Pared Notary
R0M10 thstort
Noises M Progeny Yaks
Pompey As 80s
Besets - Pup. Oarsers
Oath. - Stains &
Caisructort
Osnetits • Oar & Non- rot
* Sweet InInslisti ADS forlbsauelane MOW
Propenitigkiallsiinh
Narfult Whin •
Ancesmerte
2020.2011 Teranhe
2010-200)Ra
Prior Yen
EAST 71 STREET
IMMO
2020 • 2021 lints** Assessiamil
savour autiurrom sect 1208 Lot 10
8800.8 Assestred Rolla
Taxebb Stela On
Owns Sens
Proper/ Ana
Mc Nunn snd Adana
Ths Cless
Baena Chas
Propwl• 0 07107118
mono I aty ol 7677101b 1
Jonsay 6.2079
12O/86112NMASSEZMIULLB0LL MAPLE. PC.
9 EAST 71 STREET ICC121
MAPLE. IOC
SE 718T ST
NEW YORK NY 10021-416Q
AS NJALY ATTACHED OR SEA -
DETACHED
MAPLE. INC.
1.0•11000.471441
Lot Sae
R0 117age 814(
Depth 8.68)
Land Noe NCR)
FtscHa. / Inegukr
Carer
Number at SAOInge
&WAN Sin
Frage sew,
Down OW/
slam
trunnion
Aaaearent 17domoason
60.00
102 17
Wee
172.17
•
N
130001011on
ESTRAMED MARKET VALUE
6.20% 1700krt AV
PHIPTVAUX
Matt Allatia Rwelmmenfalue
land Tel
145M0.000 K861.=
470217 1.758,413
Asseed Vsiae
SAWN To Atlatriants, Tow 2027.1/21 TIM WV Be lewd On 1,761..013
Mirka 110010002
la tear larks1 Wta
2020 2021 (wns) IPS
2016 2928 65.931,60)
2018 2012 76,0111.603
2017 2018 77.47/1SCO
2018 2017 50.881.000
left
1•4474N Sewn lima
a
Snrecidlumme
cosssitsmom.
Semis
Cb
I oft 1/22/20, 9:49 AM
THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Franchise Tax and Annual Report Filing 2019
CYPRESS, INC. (581974)
USVI Lieutenant Governor
Filed: July 31,2019 10:05 AM
BID: 581974
Handling Option Standard Processing
Capital Stock Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
Total Capital
Previous Value
Capital Withdrawn
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of
this Report
Previous Value
Highest Capital Amount
during the reporting Period
Handling Option
Annual Report for Filing Year
Tax Identifier Number
1,000.00
0.00
1000.00
0.00
I ,000.00
1,000.00
Standard Processing
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of
Business
Mailing Address
Changed
6100 Rcd Hook Quarter B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
•esGenerated
EXHIBIT
I Li, I of 4
Directors/Officers
Name Mr. Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Status Active
Physical Address 6I(X) Red Hook Quarter B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position President
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Darren INDYKE
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Secretary
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name
Status
Physical Address
Mailing Address
Email Address
Position
Term Expiration
Documents
Richard KAHN
Active
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Treasurer
Perpetual
Did the entity have Economic No
Activity during the reporting
period?
Previous. t'altie
Balance Sheet BALANCE SHEET.docx07/31/2019 10:04 AM
Generated on February 21, 2020 10:47 AM 2 of 4
Income Statement
Signature(s)
Name
Position
On Behalf Of
Name
Date
Name
Position
Date
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
INCOME STATEME.NT.docx07/3 I /2019 10:04 AM
Erika KELLERHALS
Attorney in Fact
President
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
07/31/2019
Richard KAHN
Treasurer
07/31/2019
Yes
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Yes
Crenred
Generated on February 21.2020 10:47 AM 3 of 4
lielar~nffiliffiE
ROCA PACZ IMAMTY 11lL CEICAPII0k
02.21.222331n AND SEC 23.4.40.10.11.14 1417
1124RM 916 7$5447 AC 15045
R171t'iA70o06 E201.011MCHRD
IPS PCRT OF 0/00M"1 STE 1510 ST MOMS VI 031412
~nod ~ant CYCL,IC ØO ZAJ
It Palatal PT till If! TOW ‘10X2
roe NO CMS assay PAYS VOW ~Mr rant PLO 1OM10M0l S NOTICS.
2019 TAX BILL PATRICK `PAT' VARELA
ST
aeon/ 1/0. 844002114% Pimp401/ ~I WM ~MI sr •• MIS?, I q• lie m. non can nint.
MEASURER
JENNIFER -jar MOU~E1 COO Ian Son
SANTA H 001M PA lox T • so" v( f WL) SON. la WM ~Tit .....~4~ 14/444~
X2ESSEIRtaLZOOL2MUE
"IA« vo alinoininn INICS
nin CZ"
?tar 1054750
allilli a ffi rcli
IM 71 1
we
"a 50119 it" WEEP.. ..,., ...:. fifi •:au IMAM IXIM43 52 2 ii 2 93 Fir4at,51," MI tm 1311 ~ea
Vona
Pn na 17~27 rIMA:25
MI ISM
IC OM
fl an
TOTAL NU YAWS SUMO
101540110 • 2019 TAX DUE
NOS tans • An. WIT O Ha nil WORN ACCIPPTINIO OMISIT Tw PAY111117.
NONT WV Millar • CUE CECES4 IS MIT 111E woo was PINERY N DUE Ant 14 252 MD IS MUMMY AMER "IV ti ffi l MO N CEUNIMIXT MIR
MY NI MR =1111•250
MOOD MU PATIENT CM« MI5 1.L• DUE BY APRIL 10. Mt 113 AVOID 1111131CIT MD MALTY (MARCEL iffl eingPAY BT: MAY 14 *020.
J FIRST HALF PAYMENT COUPON
MS it s IS DUEM: DECEMBER 10.2M0. TO MUD MEREST AND MALTY ~Mk PAY BE JANUARY W. 2000.
• Mgr view BEMs aims, pa~ due re tar DM Dimwit 14 20t.
FULL YEAH PAYMENT COUPON
7M11 MIAS CUE BY: DECEMBER 10. 2010 TO AVOID IN TERM AND PENALTY CWAROFi. PAY BY: JANUARY 14 2420.
**prior year balsa pad:, ~lent ks Se no Ytr lb» Noseber 10. 2010.
1 Mt":
fer :iradatt wt to it tiler Lealinsaut
it /ULF 5071125
ranatal
ET Ell REIS 1111101115 Nt 0:6•3D1
CZ= 5400426421
THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Franchise Tax and Annual Report Filing 2019
NAUTILUS, INC. (581975)
USVI Lieutenant Governor
Filed: July 31.2019 06:39 PM
BID: 581975
Changed
Handling Option Standard Processing
Capital Stock Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
1,000.00
0.00
Total Capital 1000.00
Previous. Value
Capital Withdrawn 0.00
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of 1,000.00
this Report
Preriuus 1 alue
Highest Capital Amount 1,000.00
during the reporting Period
Handling Option Standard Processing
Annual Report for Filing Year 2019
Tax Identifier Number
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of 6100 Red Hook Qtr 133, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
Business 00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
EXHIBIT
Gene .8 AM Iota
Directors/Officers
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Status Active
Physical Address 6100 Red Hook Qtr B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position President
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Darren INDYKE
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Secretary
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Richard KAHN
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Treasurer
Term Expiration Perpetual
Documents
Did the entity have Economic No
Activity during the reporting
period?
Previous 1 ante
Balance Sheet BALANCE SHEET.docx07/31 /2019 6:38 PM
Cream"
Generated on February 21.2020 10:48 AM 2 of 4
Income Statement Craned INCOME STATEMENT.docx07/3 I /2019 6:38 PM
Signature(s)
Name Ms. Erika KELLERHALS
Position Attorney in Fact
On Behalf Of President
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Date 07/31/2019
Name Richard KAHN
Position Treasurer
Date 07/31/2019
I DECLARE, UNDER Yes •
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Yes
Generated on February 21,2020 10:48 AM 3 of 4
THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
Franchise Tax and Annual Report Filing 2019
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC. (581871)
USV I Lieutenant Governor
Filed: July 31, 2019 07:41 PM
RID: 581871
Handling Option Standard Processing
Capital Stock Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital
Additional Capital
Previous Value
Total Capital
Previous Value
Capital Withdrawn
Previous Value
Amount of Capital at Date of
this Report
Previous Value
Highest Capital Amount
during the reporting Period
Handling Option
Annual Report for Filing Year
Tax Identifier Number
I ,000.00
2248,643.00
2249643.00
0.00
2,249,643.00
2,249,643.00
Standard Processing
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of
Business
Mailing Address
Changed
9053 Estate Thomas, Ste 101, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin
Islands, 00802, United States
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Generat1
EXHIBIT
120 M 1 of 4
Directors/Officers
Name Jeffrey EPSTEIN
Status Active
Physical Address 6100 Red Hook Qtr, B3, Charlotte Amalie, United States Virgin Islands,
00802, United States
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position President
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Darren 1NDYKE
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Email Address
Position Secretary
Term Expiration Perpetual
Name Richard KAHN
Status Active
Physical Address
Mailing Address Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Entail Address
Position Treasurer
Term Expiration Perpetual
Documents
Did the entity have Economic Yes
Activity during the reporting
period?
Previous l (flue
Balance Sheet BALANCE SHEET.clocx07/31 /2019 7:22 PM
can
Generated on February 21.2020 10:51 AM 2 of 4
Income Statement
Signature(s)
Name
Position
On Behalf Of
Name
Date
Name
Position
Date
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Daytime Contact
Name
Telephone
Email
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OR PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS THAT ALL
STATEMENTS CONTAINED
IN THIS APPLICATION,
AND ANY
ACCOMPANYING
DOCUMENTS, ARE TRUE
AND CORRECT, WITH
INCOME STATEMENT.docx073O0 19 7,22 PM
Ms. Erika KELLERHALS
Attorney in Fact
President
Jeffrey EPSTEIN
07/31/2019
Richard KAHN
Treasurer
07/31/2019
Yes
Ms. Erika Kellerhals
Yes
Crewed
Generated on February 21.2020 10:31 AM 3 of 4
-ee.,Gezareneel
iunanaddeiCiaa9gargt4P .424W
-494,9a4Wilienzlen+141 , &% ,  .or+ek#Arie.14,riS
e_Cift,rnereyiamseernmeiselela fr 0.9+meiozged
K VPAtitebinaec4,-.X". .dfae.wee.smatfer •
Il

╭──── Page 92, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

O ISIS CORPCX SAMICNOTE CO.. SAY 5500E N.Y
TOTAL AUTHORIZED ISSUE 1,000,000 SHARES PAR VALUE 55.00 EACH
COMMON STOCK
Cliffs ifsto CertifP tbat  EPSTEli  tix cob= of
Ti-igpSANt   My/wida/nd non-calemaa; dier4reo ?dee criove -06,fiation• examlexal4 only op& ate Gook or de -aiyie,,,,tam.
4 a, Adie,, 4+ a.d.a.dsfiet,~y coo. O/
emetAa4/./.4 ../6 wed. witmos, dze ?de -6.00.4i. amide ,..tatte/Xed r t4t Ctedt(WiCed
Akita
C n 4
-1-1\CA(CL1
The Haze Trust
TRUST AGREEMENT dated Iltir'ar1 9 , 1991 , between
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, as Grantor, and JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN, as Trustee.
(ii)On the death of the Grantor, to dispose of the remaining income
and principal of the Trust, including any property received by the
Trust as a result of the Grantor's death to the estate of the
Grantor.
EXHIBIT
1  31
From;
SubjellITL,.. 1mi a mllm:,,,,,,OT:wpo -T- SUR LA FORTUNE IMMOBIUERE
Date: May 2, 2019 at 10:42:11 AM ED
To: 'Rich n'
Cc:
Dear Richard,
I come back to you concerning the evaluation proposal for the apartment (22 avenue Foch) : 2019 Value + 5,6 % a 11 072 
Um' x 783,30 m2 8 672 823 E.
SIM
Let me know what your position about that and when you'll be able to answer my questions.
Best regards
F.-M. PICHARD el Associes
EXHIBIT
THE UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
USVI Lieutenant Governor
Filed: July 05.2019 08:25 AM
BID: 571605
Annual Report Filing 2019
IGY-AYH ST.THOMAS HOLDINGS, LLC (571605)
Changed
Handling Option Standard Processing
Annual Report for Filing Year 2019
Tax Identifier Number
Business Mailing Addresses
Principal Office or Place of 6100 Red Hook Quarters #2, St Thomas, United States Virgin Islands,
Business 00802, United States
Mailing Address
Amount of Capital Used in Conducting Business in USVI
Amount of Capital I ,000.00
Additional Capital 0.00
Previous l'alue
Total Capital 1000.00
Previous Value
Capital Withdrawn 0.00
Previous l'alue
Amount of Capital at Date of 1,000.00
this Report
Previous l'alue
Highest Capital Amount 1,000.00
during the reporting Period
Business Details
Generated
EXHIBIT
1  35 M I of 3
Managed By Member Managed
Managers/Members
Individual
Name
Status
Physical Address
Mailing Address
Position
Non-Registered Entity
Non-Registered Entity Name
Status
Physical Address
Mailing Address
Position
Signature(s)
Name
Position
Organization
Date
I DECLARE, UNDER
PENALTY OF PERJURY,
UNDER THE LAWS OF THE
UNITED STATES VIRGIN
ISLANDS, THAT THIS
OFFICER HAS AGREED BY
RESOLUTION TO THE
CHANGES MADE IN THIS
APPLICATION.
Jeffery EPSTEIN
Active
6100 Red Hook Quarters, Ste B-3, St Thomas, United States Virgin
Islands, 00802, United States
Member
ISLAND GLOBAL YACHTING FACILITIES LTD
Active
Mailing Address is the same as the Physical Address
Member
Mark LANDE
Entity Representative
Island Global Yachting Facilities LTD
07/05/2019
Yes
Generated on November 22,2019 10:30 AM 2 of 3
PRYTANEE, LLC
OPERATING AGREEMENT
THIS OPERATING AGREEMENT is made as of the ,3a, day of November, 2016 by and among Prytanee, LLC, a United States Virgin
Islan s limited liability company (the
"Company"), the Company's sole members, Southern Trust Company, Inc. a United States Virgin Islands corporation "STC' 
and
EXHIBIT
i 51+
RECITALS
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the undersigned parties here executed this Agreement
as of the date first set forth above.
The
S-1
EXHIBIT A
The names, addresses and Membership Interests of the Members are set forth below.
Name and Address
Southern Trust Company, Inc.
6100 Red Hook Quarter, B3
St. Thomas, USVI 00802
Facsimile: 340.775-2528
Percentage
Ownership
50%
Initial
Capital
Contribution
$(TBDI
EFTA00128379 (Jmail)
 [government] analysis of two of Epstein's desktop computers
(date: 2020-01-08)
Examination Notes for 2019-010614
New AUX assigned for the Analysis of two Desktop Computers
Review AUX Request in LIMA
Search Authority is Administrative
Images Received from ASAC
Sent via Apricorn Drive
Images:
Z6E8KD3N.E01
JP15721E36LSNK.E01
Working Copies Created
Working Copies Verified
Z6E8KD3N.E01
Image Verification Results:
Verification started: Mon Sep 16 14:03:21 2019
Verification finished: Mon Sep 16 14:44:51 2019
MD5 checksum: 629694386155e0f49e7a8cOda0da2840 : verified
SHA1 checksum: 3ac4c0fa2b1cb97020e22bc3966d4b3609c89d57 : verified
JP15721E36LSNK.E01
Image Verification Results:
Verification started: Mon Sep 16 14:03:23 2019
Verification finished: Mon Sep 16 14:45:30 2019
MD5 checksum: 0dd9c2ad818c4a5a58bab2f78d57f2d7 : verified
SHA1 checksum: 0d78251b33302e327c56c1ef28e9ccc8f353bd46 : verified
Forensic Workstation X26958 utilized for forensic examination.
2019-010614 Notes Page 1 of 24
Forensic Software Utilized:
EnCase 8.10.00.209
FTK 7.1.0.290
AXIOM 3.7.0.16279
Images Added to EnCase
Verified in EnCase
Updated Time Zone Information (EST)
Search for Volume Shadow Copies
No Volume Shadows Found for either Device
Verified Volume Shadows in FTK
None Found
Process both Devices in EnCase
Recover Folders
Reconstruct folder structure of NTFS 3.0 files
File signature analysis
Protected file analysis
Thumbnail creation
Hash analysis
MD5
SHA1
Expand compound files
Find email
PST (Microsoft Outlook)
OST(Microsoft Outlook)
NSF (Lotus Notes)
DBX(Microsoft Outlook Express)
EDB(Microsoft Exchange)
AOL
MBOX
EMLX
Find Internet artifacts
Search unallocated space for Internet Artifacts (True)
Jeffrey Edward Epstein
Jeffery
Edward
2019-010614 Notes Page 2 of 24
Epstein
76318-054
Reyes
Index text and metadata
System Info Parser
User Activity
Operating System
Hardware
Software
Accounts/Users
Network
Shared/Mapped Devices
USB Devices
Network Shares
AutoRuns
PROCESSING COMPLETED SUCCESSFULLY
Images Processed in AXIOM
Z6E8KD3N.E01
AXIOM 3.7.0.16279 Copyright 2009-2020 Magnet Forensics* Inc.
Build 3.7.0.16279
Case Number: 2019-010614
Case Type: Other
Examiner: LITS
Case Information Generated At: Jan 08, 2020 08:23:28
Operating System: Microsoft Windows NT 10.0.17134.0
Runtime Version: 4.0.30319.42000
Settings:
Remove duplicates enabled: True
Acquire image segmentation enabled: False
Acquire image segmentation size: -1
Acquire image hashing enabled: True
Acquire image compression type: Fast
Acquire device cleanup enabled: True
Search Alerts entered: 6
Keywords entered: 6
Keyword regex count: 0
Dynamic app finder enabled: False
Picture and video categorization enabled: False
Files skipping by hash enabled: False
Case logo configured: True
Search archives: True
2019-010614 Notes Page 3 of 24
Search mobile backups: True
Max nested container depth: 5
Output Folder: F:\ 2019-010614 \AXIOM Second Request \ Z6E8KD3N
Z6E8KD3N.E01 - Partition 1 (Microsoft NTFS, 461.1 GB)
Evidence number: Z6E8KD3N
Searches selected:
pagefile.sys
swapfile.sys
$MFT
$LogFile
hiberfil.sys
Volume Shadow Copies
Unallocated Clusters
File Slack Space
All Files and Folder
Uninitialized File Area
Z6E8KD3N.E01 - Unpartitioned Space
Evidence number: Z6E8KD3N
Searches selected:
Unpartitioned Space
Search items selected:
Platform: Computer
$LogFile Analysis
360 Safe Browser
Adium
Adobe Flash Cookies / Local Shared Objects
AIM
AmCache
Android Backups
Application Install States
Ares
Audio
AutoRun Items
Bebo
Bing Toolbar
Bitcoin
BitLocker Recovery Key
Calc
Calendar Events (ics)
Carbonite
Carved Archives (content not searched)
2019-010614 Notes Page 4 of 24
Carved Audio
Chatroulette
Chatstep
Chrome
Cortana
CSV Documents
Dropbox
DS Store
Edge/Internet Explorer
EGG Archives
EML(X) Files
Emule
Encrypted Files
Encryption / Anti -forensics Tools
Excel
Facebook
File System Information
Firefox
Flickr
Gigatribe v2 and v3
Gmail
GMX Webmail
Google Analytics
Google Docs
Google Drive
Google Maps
Google Talk
Google Toolbar
Google WebP Images
Google+
Hangul Word Processor
Hotmail Webmail
Hush mail
iChat
ICQ
IME Suggestions
iMessage
Impress
Instagram
Installed Programs
iOS Backups
IP Addresses - Audio/Video Calls
ISO Files
Jump Lists
2019-010614 Notes Page S of 24
Kakaolalk
Keyword Searches
Known DLLs
Limerunner
Limewire / Frostwire
LINE
Linkedln
LNK Files
Luckywire
Lync / Office Communicator
Mail.ru
Mailinator
Malware/Phishing URLs
MBOX E-mails
mIRC
Most Recently Used
MSN Plus!
MUICache
MySpace
Network Interfaces
Network Profiles
Network Share Information
Network Usage
Notification Center
Omegle
OneDrive
ooVoo
Opera
Operating System Information
Outlook
Outlook Web App
Outlook Webmail
Paltalk
PDF
Photoshop Files
Pictures
Pidgin
Pornography URLs
Potential Browser Activity (Incl. Private/ Incognito URLs)
PowerPoint
Prefetch Files
QQ
QuickBooks Files
RealPlayer
2019-010614 Notes Page 6 of 24
Rebuild Webpages
Recycle Bin
Remote Desktop Protocol
RTF Documents
Safari
Scheduled Tasks
Second Life
Services
Shareaza
SharePoint
Shellbags
Shim Cache
Sina Weibo
Skype
SRUM
Startup Items
Text Documents
Timezone Information
TorChat
Torrents
Trillian
Twitter
USB Devices
Usenet Binary Files
User Accounts
UserAssist
Viber
Videos
Virtual Machines
VK
VLC Media Player
Web Video Fragments
WebKit
WeChat
WhatsApp
Windows Event Logs
Windows Live Messenger / MSN Messenger
Windows Logon Banner
Windows Mail
Windows Timeline
Word
WordPerfect Files
World of Warcraft
Writer
2019-010614 Notes Page 7 of 24
Xbox Internet Explorer History
Yahoo! Messenger
Yahoo! Webmail
Your Phone
Zoom
Summary:
Start Time: Jan 08, 2020 08:23:28
End Time: Jan 09, 2020 02:20:08
Search Duration: 17:56:30
Indexing Duration: 00:01:06
Search Outcome: Success
Final results of search:
$LogFile Analysis: 15793 items
AmCache Device Containers: 34 items
AmCache Driver Binaries: 262 items
AmCache Driver Packages: 14 items
AmCache File Entries: 662 items
AmCache Pnp Devices: 97 items
AmCache Program Entries: 150 items
AmCache Shortcuts: 719 items
Audio: 2240 items
AutoRun Items: 851 items
Carved Archives (content not searched): 9451 items
Carved Audio: 3080 items
Carved Video: 1285 items
Chrome Autofill: 28 items
Chrome Autofill Profiles: 1 items
Chrome Cache Records: 25506 items
Chrome Cookies: 848 items
Chrome Current Session: 10 items
Chrome Current Tabs: 5 items
Chrome Favlcons: 53 items
Chrome Keyword Search Terms: 1 items
Chrome Last Session: 9 items
Chrome Last Tabs: 3 items
Chrome Logins: 7 items
Chrome Top Sites: 2 items
Chrome Web History: 5 items
Chrome Web Visits: 11 items
Classifieds URLs: 103868 items
Cloud Services URLs: 71 items
CSV Documents: 12 items
2019-010614 Notes Page 8 of 24
Dating Sites URLs: 56 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Content: 3163978 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Cookies: 74039 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Daily/Weekly History: 184489 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Dependency Entries: 3884 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Downloads: 43 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Main History: 382359 items
Email Attachments: 10 items
EML(X) Files: 549 items
eMule GUIDs: 1 items
Encrypted Files: 172 items
Encryption / Anti-forensics Tools: 3 items
Excel Documents: 155 items
Facebook Chat: 209 items
Facebook Pages: 11 items
Facebook Status Updates/Wall Posts/Comments: 6 items
Facebook URLs: 4670 items
File Associations: 2191 items
File System Information: 1 items
Firefox Add-ons: 5 items
Firefox Bookmarks: 100 items
Firefox Cache Records: 19953 items
Firefox Cookies: 2554 items
Firefox Favlcons: 45 items
Firefox FormHistory: 10 items
Firefox Input History: 2 items
Firefox SessionStore Artifacts: 891 items
Firefox Web History: 1242 items
Firefox Web Visits: 1455 items
Flash Cookies: 5622 items
Google Analytics First Visit Cookies: 4942 items
Google Analytics First Visit Cookies Carved: 13075 items
Google Analytics Referral Cookies: 4669 items
Google Analytics Referral Cookies Carved: 11477 items
Google Analytics Session Cookies: 2719 items
Google Analytics Session Cookies Carved: 7193 items
Google Analytics URLs: 1955 items
Google Analytics URLs Carved: 404 items
Google Drive: 1 items
Google Maps: 903 items
Google Maps Queries: 301 items
Google Maps Tiles: 5131 items
Google Searches: 30921 items
Google WebP Images: 64 items
2019-010614 Notes Page 9 of 24
Hangul Word Processor: 2 items
Human Trafficking Site URLs: 7 items
Identifiers: 3848 items
IE InPrivate/Recovery URLs: 19981 items
Installed Microsoft Programs: 300 items
Installed Programs: 220 items
Internet Explorer Cache Records: 309421 items
Internet Explorer Cookie Records: 867 items
Internet Explorer Cookies: 256351 items
Internet Explorer Daily History: 595 items
Internet Explorer Favorites: 4336 items
Internet Explorer Leak Records: 343 items
Internet Explorer Main History: 1299 items
Internet Explorer PrivaclE Records: 19623 items
Internet Explorer Redirect Records: 25976 items
Internet Explorer Typed URLs: 1895 items
Internet Explorer Weekly History: 123 items
lump Lists: 12004 items
Keyword Searches: 69 items
Known DLLs: 56 items
LNK Files: 31311 items
Locally Accessed Files and Folders: 61125 items
Malware/Phishing URLs: 33 items
MRU Folder Access: 315 items
MRU Opened/Saved Files: 1624 items
MRU Recent Files & Folders: 7459 items
MRU Run Commands: 3 items
MUICache: 23173 items
Network Interfaces (Registry): 2 items
Network Profiles: 2 items
Network Share Information: 730 items
Operating System Information: 2 items
Parsed Search Queries: 24131 items
Passwords and Tokens: 7 items
PDF Documents: 1280 items
Photoshop Files: 76 items
Pictures: 953022 items
Potential Browser Activity: 57165 items
Potential Facebook Pictures: 3923 items
PowerPoint Documents: 47 items
Prefetch Files - Windows XP/Vista/7: 179 items
QuickBooks Files: 115 items
Rebuilt Webpages: 45227 items
Remote Desktop Protocol: 66 items
2019410614 Notes Page 10 of 24
RTF Documents: 1175 items
Safari History: 4 items
Shellbags: 10648 items
Shim Cache: 7 items
Shipping Site URLs: 2794 items
Social Media URLs: 6561 items
Startup Items: 263 items
System Services: 880 items
Tax Site URLs: 1060 items
Text Documents: 109494 items
Timezone Information: 1 items
Torrent URLs: 77 items
USB Devices: 126 items
User Accounts: 258 items
UserAssist: 9678 items
Videos: 5194 items
VLC Recently Played Files: 118 items
Web Chat URLs: 1 items
Web Video Fragments: 282 items
WebKit Browser Web History (Carved): 631 items
Windows Event Logs: 343316 items
Windows Logon Banner: 1 items
Word Documents: 1813 items
WordPerfect Files: 71 items
Yahoo! Non-Encrypted Chat: 938 items
JP1572.IE36LSNK.E01
AXIOM 3.7.0.16279 Copyright 2009-2020 Magnet Forensics° Inc.
Build 3.7.0.16279
Case Number: 2019-010614
Case Type: Other
Examiner: LITS
Case Information Generated At: Jan 09, 2020 07:07:34
Operating System: Microsoft Windows NT 10.0.17134.0
Runtime Version: 4.0.30319.42000
Settings:
Remove duplicates enabled: True
Acquire image segmentation enabled: False
Acquire image segmentation size: -1
Acquire image hashing enabled: True
Acquire image compression type: Fast
Acquire device cleanup enabled: True
Search Alerts entered: 6
2019-010614 Notes Page 11 of 24
Keywords entered: 6
Keyword regex count: 0
Dynamic app finder enabled: False
Picture and video categorization enabled: False
Files skipping by hash enabled: False
Case logo configured: True
Search archives: True
Search mobile backups: True
Max nested container depth: 5
Output Folder: F:\ 2019-010614 \AXIOM Second Request VP1572.IE36LSNK
JP1572.IE36LSNK.E01 - Partition 1 (EXT-family, 156.85 MB)
Evidence number: JP1572.1E36LSNK
Searches selected:
Unallocated Clusters
All Files and Folder
JP1572.IE36LSNK.E01 - Partition 2 (Microsoft NTFS, 95 MB) System Reserved
Evidence number: JP1572.1E36LSNK
Searches selected:
pagefile.sys
swapfile.sys
$MFT
$LogFile
hiberfil.sys
Volume Shadow Copies
Unallocated Clusters
File Slack Space
All Files and Folder
Uninitialized File Area
JP1572.IE36LSNK.E01 - Partition 3 (Microsoft NTFS, 465.51 GB)
Evidence number: JP1572.1E36LSNK
Searches selected:
pagefile.sys
swapfile.sys
$MFT
$LogFile
hiberfil.sys
Volume Shadow Copies
Unallocated Clusters
File Slack Space
All Files and Folder
Uninitialized File Area
2019-010614 Notes Page 12 of 24
JP15721E36LSNK.E01- Unpartitioned Space
Evidence number: JP1572JE36LSNK
Searches selected:
Unpartitioned Space
Search items selected:
Platform: Computer
$LogFile Analysis
360 Safe Browser
Adium
Adobe Flash Cookies / Local Shared Objects
AIM
AmCache
Android Backups
Application Install States
Ares
Audio
AutoRun Items
Bebo
Bing Toolbar
Bitcoin
BitLocker Recovery Key
Calc
Calendar Events (ics)
Carbonite
Carved Archives (content not searched)
Carved Audio
Chatroulette
Chatstep
Chrome
Cortana
CSV Documents
Dropbox
DS_Store
Edge/Internet Explorer
EGG Archives
EML(X) Files
Emule
Encrypted Files
Encryption / Anti -forensics Tools
Excel
Facebook
File System Information
2019-010614 Notes Page 13 of 24
Firefox
Flickr
Gigatribe v2 and v3
Gmail
GMX Webmail
Google Analytics
Google Docs
Google Drive
Google Maps
Google Talk
Google Toolbar
Google WebP Images
Google+
Hangul Word Processor
Hotmail Webmail
Hushmail
iChat
ICQ
IME Suggestions
iMessage
Impress
Instagram
Installed Programs
iOS Backups
IP Addresses - Audio/Video Calls
ISO Files
Jump Lists
Kakaolalk
Keyword Searches
Known DLLs
Limerunner
Limewire / Frostwire
LINE
Linkedln
LNK Files
Luckywire
Lync / Office Communicator
Mail.ru
Mailinator
Malware/Phishing URLs
MBOX E-mails
mIRC
Most Recently Used
MSN Plus!
2019-010614 Notes Page 14 of 24
MUICache
MySpace
Network Interfaces
Network Profiles
Network Share Information
Network Usage
Notification Center
Omegle
OneDrive
ooVoo
Opera
Operating System Information
Outlook
Outlook Web App
Outlook Webmail
Paltalk
PDF
Photoshop Files
Pictures
Pidgin
Pornography URLs
Potential Browser Activity (Incl. Private/ Incognito URLs)
PowerPoint
Prefetch Files
QQ
QuickBooks Files
RealPlayer
Rebuild Webpages
Recycle Bin
Remote Desktop Protocol
RTF Documents
Safari
Scheduled Tasks
Second Life
Services
Shareaza
SharePoint
Shellbags
Shim Cache
Sina Weibo
Skype
SRUM
Startup Items
Text Documents
2019-010614 Notes Page 15 of 24
Timezone Information
TorChat
Torrents
Trillian
Twitter
USB Devices
Usenet Binary Files
User Accounts
UserAssist
Viber
Videos
Virtual Machines
VK
VLC Media Player
Web Video Fragments
WebKit
WeChat
WhatsApp
Windows Event Logs
Windows Live Messenger / MSN Messenger
Windows Logon Banner
Windows Mail
Windows Timeline
Word
WordPerfect Files
World of Warcraft
Writer
Xbox Internet Explorer History
Yahoo! Messenger
Yahoo! Webmail
Your Phone
Zoom
Summary:
Start Time: Jan 09, 2020 07:07:34
End Time: Jan 09, 2020 23:01:40
Search Duration: 15:53:56
Indexing Duration: 00:01:03
Search Outcome: Success
Final results of search:
$LogFile Analysis: 21601 items
AmCache Device Containers: 29 items
AmCache Driver Binaries: 267 items
2019-010614 Notes Page 16 of 24
AmCache Driver Packages: 19 items
AmCache File Entries: 820 items
AmCache Pnp Devices: 94 items
AmCache Program Entries: 157 items
AmCache Shortcuts: 585 items
Audio: 2995 items
AutoRun Items: 918 items
Carved Archives (content not searched): 9683 items
Carved Audio: 4655 items
Carved Video: 1376 items
Classifieds URLs: 84789 items
Cloud Services URLs: 57 items
3V Documents: 18 items
Dating Sites URLs: 412 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Content: 3274517 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Cookies: 66140 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Daily/Weekly History: 182627 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Dependency Entries: 4610 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Downloads: 69 items
Edge/Internet Explorer 10-11 Main History: 376240 items
Email Attachments: 11 items
EML(X) Files: 214 items
Encrypted Files: 128 items
Encryption / Anti-forensics Tools: 3 items
Excel Documents: 198 items
Facebook Chat: 374 items
Facebook Pages: 14 items
Facebook URLs: 3085 items
File Associations: 2172 items
File System Information: 3 items
Firefox Add-ons: 8 items
Firefox Bookmarks: 66 items
Firefox Cache Records: 9410 items
Firefox Cookies: 1479 items
Firefox Downloads: 71 items
Firefox Favlcons: 90 items
Firefox FormHistory: 5 items
Firefox Input History: 3 items
Firefox SessionStore Artifacts: 886 items
Firefox Web History: 1062 items
Firefox Web Visits: 1150 items
Flash Cookies: 4790 items
Gmail Fragments: 13 items
Gmail Webmail: 225 items
2019410614 Notes Page 17 of 24
Google Analytics First Visit Cookies: 3370 items
Google Analytics First Visit Cookies Carved: 8883 items
Google Analytics Referral Cookies: 3181 items
Google Analytics Referral Cookies Carved: 7674 items
Google Analytics Session Cookies: 1807 items
Google Analytics Session Cookies Carved: 4483 items
Google Analytics URLs: 2240 items
Google Analytics URLs Carved: 657 items
Google Maps: 727 items
Google Maps Queries: 177 items
Google Maps Tiles: 2435 items
Google Searches: 20802 items
Google WebP Images: 35 items
Hangul Word Processor: 2 items
Human Trafficking Site URIs: 1 items
Identifiers: 3088 items
IE InPrivate/Recovery URLs: 152 items
Installed Microsoft Programs: 306 items
Installed Programs: 233 items
Internet Explorer Cache Records: 2 items
Internet Explorer Cookies: 220671 items
Internet Explorer Daily History: 2 items
Internet Explorer Favorites: 4507 items
Internet Explorer Main History: 7 items
Internet Explorer Typed URLs: 1682 items
lump Lists: 12877 items
Keyword Searches: 121 items
Known DLLs: 56 items
LNK Files: 33257 items
Locally Accessed Files and Folders: 72708 items
Malware/Phishing URIs: 112 items
MRU Folder Access: 329 items
MRU Opened/Saved Files: 1740 items
MRU Recent Files & Folders: 7802 items
MRU Run Commands: 1 items
MUICache: 25441 items
Network Interfaces (Registry): 2 items
Network Profiles: 3 items
Network Share Information: 775 items
Operating System Information: 1 items
Parsed Search Queries: 21943 items
PDF Documents: 1613 items
Photoshop Files: 102 items
Pictures: 903684 items
2019-010614 Notes Page 18 of 24
Pornography URLs: 3 items
Potential Browser Activity: 45589 items
Potential Facebook Pictures: 3654 items
PowerPoint Documents: 31 items
Prefetch Files - Windows XP/Vista/7: 248 items
QuickBooks Files: 109 items
Rebuilt Webpages: 43866 items
Remote Desktop Protocol: 61 items
RTF Documents: 801 items
Safari History: 4 items
Shellbags: 19087 items
Shipping Site URLs: 1626 items
Social Media URLs: 5160 items
Startup Items: 285 items
System Services: 902 items
Tax Site URLs: 572 items
Text Documents: 91547 items
Timezone Information: 1 items
Torrent URLs: 23 items
Trillian: 6 items
USB Devices: 164 items
User Accounts: 271 items
UserAssist: 10360 items
Videos: 6061 items
VLC Recently Played Files: 45 items
Web Chat URLs: 5 items
Web Video Fragments: 15 items
WebKit Browser Web History (Carved): 251 items
Windows Event Logs: 345190 items
Windows Logon Banner: 1 items
Word Documents: 2066 items
WordPerfect Files: 24 items
Yahoo! Non-Encrypted Chat: 9 items
Build Timeline in AXIOM for both images
Z6E8KD3N.E01 Completed Successfully
JP1572.IE36LSNK.E01 Completed Successfully
Perform Timeline Analysis for User Activity on the System for Z6E8KD3N.E01
Identified user for 08/09/2019 to 08/10/2019
2019-010614 Notes Page 19 of 24
User:
Username: 8OP18923
SID: S-1-5-21-1079978788-711783815-1788341251-1015
08/09/2019 16:05:07 User 8OP18923 Successfully Logged onto the System
08/09/2019 16:07:47 User 8OP18923 Successfully Reset their Password
08/09/2019 16:10:58 GroupWise (grpwise.exe) is launched.
08/09/2019 16:17:54 Internet Explorer (iexplorer.exe) is launched.
08/09/2019 16:17:59 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 16:18:00 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 16:18:42 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 16:29:54 Internet Explorer (iexplorer.exe) is launched.
08/09/2019 16:29:57 Internet Activity: "https://10.33.56.106/TRUACCESS"
08/09/2019 16:53:50 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 17:11:40 User 8OP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 17:25:53 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 17:27:33 User 8OP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 17:28:17 User launches GroupWise (grpwise.exe)
08/09/2019 17:32:58 Microsoft Access (MSACCESS.exe) is launched.
08/09/2019 17:54:24 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 17:54:44 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 17:54:46 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 17:57:58 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 17:58:42 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 18:00:57 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 18:02:38 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 18:02:47 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 18:09:34 Internet Explorer (iexplorer.exe) is launched.
08/09/2019 18:09:50 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 18:11:16 Internet Activity Recorded
2019-010614 Notes Page 20 of 24
08/09/2019 18:46:46 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 18:47:52 User 8OP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 18:59:38 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 19:03:19 User 8OP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 19:21:44 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 19:38:44 User 8OP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 19:57:45 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 19:59:56 User 8OP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 20:26:35 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 20:42:12 User 8OP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 20:52:37 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 21:12:17 User BOP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 21:22:41 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 21:30:34 User BOP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 21:39:49 GroupWise (grpwise.exe) is launched.
08/09/2019 21:56:40 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 22:14:35 User BOP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 22:25:37 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/09/2019 22:27:46 User BOP18923 Successfully Unlocked the System
08/09/2019 22:30:58 GroupWise (grpwise.exe) is launched.
08/09/2019 22:31:24 Internet Explorer (iexplorer.exe) is launched.
08/09/2019 22:34:37 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 22:34:39 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 22:42:36 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 22:42:47 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 22:51:04 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 22:51:33 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 22:51:46 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:02:39 Internet Activity Recorded
2019-010614 Notes Page 21 of 24
08/09/2019 23:09:11 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:25:22 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:26:05 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:26:33 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:31:57 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:32:00 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:32:55 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:35:14 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:38:59 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:39:01 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:39:59 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:40:02 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:42:16 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:43:30 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:44:19 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:46:03 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:46:03 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:56:35 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:57:26 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:59:45 Internet Activity Recorded
08/09/2019 23:59:48 Internet Activity Recorded
08/10/2019 00:02:02 Internet Activity Recorded
08/10/2019 00:03:08 Internet Explorer (iexplorer.exe) is launched.
08/10/2019 00:05:03 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
08/10/2019 14:04:11 User BOP55722 (Robert Adams) Successfully Logged onto the System
NO USER ACTIVITY on 08/10/2019 at 00:05:03 to 08/10/2019 at14:04:11
Perform Timeline Analysis for User Activity on the System for JP15721E36LSNK.E01
NO USER COMPUTER USAGE BETWEEN 08/08/2019 AT 08:26:59 AND 08/10/2019 AT 08:09:24
2019-010614 Notes Page 22 of 24
08/08/2019 07:50:31 User BOP19020 Successfully Unlocked the System for the last time
08/08/2019 08:26:59 Screen Pass is Executed by System/User - Computer System is Locked
Identified user for 08/08/2019:
User:
Username: 8OP19020
SID: S-1-5-21-4149918864-1167637649-3318576334-1026
08/10/2019 08:09:24 User BOP19502 Successfully Unlocked the System
Identified user for 08/10/2019:
User:
Username: BOP19502
SID: S-1-5-21-4149918864-1167637649-3318576334-1040
Preliminary Spreadsheet Generated for Timeline
Search AXIOM for Keywords
Jeffrey Edward Epstein
Jeffery
Edward
Epstein
76318-054
Reyes
Search Complete
Review Search Hits
Bookmarked One Documents for Search Term Reyes on Z6E8KD3N.E01
Bookmarked Four Documents for Search Term Reyes on JP1572JE36LSNK.E01
No Document or Communication Hits for Epstein on both Devices.
No work type documents being accessed/edited (PDF, RTF, DOC, DOCX, XLS, XLSX, WPD) around notable
time for both devices.
2019-010614 Notes Page 23 of 24
did not identify any communication on the devices regarding inmates Reyes or Epstein. BOP
uses GroupWise for email communication, which does not cache email locally to BOP systems. Emails
can be requested from BOP for analysis.
Forensic Analysis Complete
Begin Report of Forensic Examination (ROFE)
2019-010614 Notes Page 24 of 24
╔═════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Michael Turnball [employee] security starting 2019 at the island 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00090600 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Michael Turnball
(date: 2020-01-10)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) .1 of 1.
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  01/10/2020
MICHAEL TURNBALL, date of birth telephone number
, was interviewed on the island of Little St. James. After being
advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the
interview, TURNBALL provided the following information:
TURNBALL started working security on Little St. James on July 31, 2019.
He was hired by DAPHNE WALLACE, telephone numbe . WALLACE had
gotten TURNBALL's number from someone and called him to come out and take a
look at the island. TURNBALL met with ANNA RODRIGUEZ, who was the property
manager, telephone number . TURNBALL was told his job entailed
looking for people that were coming to the island, including paparazzi.
TURNBALL owns MT Security. He has seven people who work under him for
both Little St. James and Great St. James, both of which JEFFREY EPSTEIN
owned. TURNBALL asked if they had security at the islands prior to him and
they told him no. TURNBALL was paid and he in turn paid his employees.
The only people TURNBALL has seen on the island are the staff, attorneys,
maintenance, and boat captains. TURNBALL did not interact with workers.
TURNBALL was not able to go into the structures on the islands; he was only
allowed to patrol the beaches. He was allowed to use the staff bathroom. If
people were to come onto the island, he was to approach them.
TURNBALL was required to sign a non-disclosure agreement as part of his
employment.
Investigation on 08/12/2019  at Little St James, Virgin Islands, United States (In Person)
Heti 31E-NY-3027571 Dated:ailed 12/23/2019
by
EFTA00811490 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2020-01-15)
Valuation Report
4/30/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - APRIL 30, 2017
3/31/17 4/30/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 110,396,021 121,833,887 11,437,866
Fixed Income 75,106,683 75,508,486 401,803
Equities 83,337,233 84,663,760 1,326,526
Equity ETF's 3,037,200 3,064,200 27,000
Options 574,280 226,206 (348,074)
Hedge Funds 72,702,058 71,500,131 (1,201,927)
Investments 47,006,000 52,506,000 5,500,000
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 26,600,000 26,600,000 -
Loans Receivable 9,632,446 9,632,446 -
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 17,400,000 9,400,000 -8,000,000
Total Assets 445,791,921 454,935,115 9,143,194
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
Leon loan via BJAV to Plan D LLC 8,000,000
STC Fee - Leon 8,000,000
King Street Audit Holdback - Haze 2,137,874
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 396,000
King Street - Sale from Special Fund - Haze 169,229
DIS - sold 1000 shares Enhanced DB 114,120
Enhanced - Education Advance (50,000)
New Mexico RE Taxes (55,770)
Gratitude - Univerity of Arizona / Science of Consciousness (100,000)
Miscellaneous (100,087)
ING - bought 25000 shares - STC ML (373,500)
Monthly Spending (1,200,000)
Valar III Capital Call 4 (2,500,000)
Valar III Capital Call 5 (3,000,000)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50 000 11,437,866
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan ID
Asset Description Bank Bank BNP Paribas Fargo Stanley Merrill Parttrade Totals
Cash
Southern Trust Company Inc. 35,509.685 715,889 300,000 713,630 14,096,741 51,335,925
Southern Financial LLC 29,263.589 51,682 29.315.271
Haze Trust 25,494,432 25,494,432
Gratitude America, Ltd. 1.142608 78,918 2,935,739 4.155265
JEE 4,152,209 711 057 456,765 5320,031
Jeepers Inc. 1.472,438 8,876 t481,314
LSJE LLC 345,807 542,943 249,255 1,138,005
JEGE Inc. 983,188 963,188
Southern Country International LTD 455,022 455,022
Maple Inc. 354,415 354,415
JEGE LLC 299,961 299.961
Zaro Ommlopment Corp I Management LLC 269.845 269,845
Neptune LLC 250.390 250.390
Plan D LLC 247,335 247,335
NES LLC 179.047 179,047
Enhanced Education 23,075 117,126 140,201
Hyperion Air LLC 100.592 100.592
Thomas World Air LLC 76,077 76.077
JEE - Pads (US S) 67,608 67.606
Cypress Inc. 48,036 48.036
Nautilus Inc. 42,859 42,859
FT Real Estate 42.299 42.299
Freedom Air Petroleum 23,112 23,112
Michelles Transportation Co LLC 13,573 13,573
Great St Jim LLC 8,877 8,877
LSJ LLC 5,150 5,150
Laurel Inc. 4,220 4,220
FSF LLC 937 937
IGO Company LLC 690 690
The JEE Life Ins Trust #3 206 206
Mort Inc 3 3
Butterfly Trust 3 3
Total Cash 99,714,414 3,248,056 824,371 249,255 3,649,369 14,096,741 51,682 121,833,887
Purchase Quantity 3/31/17 4/30/17 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/30/2049 05/10/11 3,000 000 3,337,958 3,207,500 3,135,000 -202,958
1paymont Inc 10.25% 5/15/2018 10/02/12 500,000 485,566 454,361 523.490 37,924
JPM Tr Fit Rate Income Fund 01122(13 238.788.480 2,392,852 2,249,429 2,256.551 -136,301
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 49,033.00 1,180,739
3,670,430
1,269,955
3,910,045
1,260,638
3,881.361
79,899
210,931 Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/29/14 150,967.00
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000.00 1 999 419 2 238.070 2.326 550 327.131
Total Haze Trust- Fixed Income (DB) 13,066,965 13,329,360 13,383,690 316,625
Jeepers - Fixed Income (DB)
JPM Trust FLT RT Income fund 02/13/13 178,878.055 1.789.537 iaig,g§a j.anai§ 2i,ia
1,685,062 1,690,398 -99,139 Total Jeepers - Fixed Income (DB) 1,789,537
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Western Digital Corp 7.375% Matures 4-1-2023 06/09/16 2,000,000 ?.083.319 2.266.250 2.201.882 na.a%3
Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 2,083.319 2.266,250 2,201,812 118,663
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB)
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP callable 6/20/2019 4/15114 2,000,000 3.439.193 2.573 558 2 736.380 -702.813
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fired Income (DB) 3,439,193 2,573,558 2,736,380 -702,813
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Monti!)
Allergen mandatory convert/Me weltered 5.5%31112018 08/15/16 1,000.000 881,500 848,430 866,780 -15,720
LSCCOM 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 26,250.000 2,859,332 2,839,457 2,74gg -112,901
Frontier Communications 10.5%9/152022 11/9/16 4.000.000 4,160,000 4.050,000 4,0 -140,000
Kindred Healthcare 7.25% 1/15/2020 STC ML 10/13/16 3,000 000
1,00400
3 125 750
'001'153
11,928,332
3,099 417
5771014
11,414,303
3,128(2 07:1
11,371,378
42 417
-330knia
-556,954
lava mandatory converUble proffered 7.0%12/1512016 08/15/16
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill)
Southern Trust Ca - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred $25 par 7/27/15 40,000 1,000,000 1,067,200 1,096,000 96,000
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $25 par 08/04/16 8.000 200,000 170,800 172,640 -27,360
Wells Fargo 5.7% Preferred $25 par 1/19/16 120.000 3,000,000 3,020,400 3,062.800 52.800
Ebay 6% Preferred $25 par matures 2-1-2056 2/22/16 80,000 2,000,000 2,115,200 2,120,800 120,800
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 8/16/16 500,000 500,000 516,833 522.750 22,750
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 2,500,000 2,623,122 2,581,000 2,610.781 -12,341
Royal Bans Scotland 7.64% Fixed to 9-29-2017 then 3M Libor *232bp 11/10/15 5,000,000 5,298,817 4,672,500 4.700.083 
-598,734
Goldman Sachs 5.375% Fixed to 5-10.2020 then 392.2 over 3 ny fiber 6/4/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 5,217,760 5310,560
3.188.913
276 314
th i.0.911 Capkal One 5.55% Fixed to 9.1-2020 then 380 over 3 motor 5/14/15 3.000.000 3.009.819 3.168.000
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 22,666,104 22,529,693 22,776,427 109,322
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB)
Bank of America 8.125% Pfd Dec 29 2049 1(10/11 2,000,000 2 055,000 2,146,389 2,169,479 114,479
Bardays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 4/3/13 300,000 300,000 325,819 315,974 15,974
Ciligroup Inc - Series 05.95% 8/6/15 3,000,000 3,000,006 3,150,309 3,191,988 191,982
General Bectric Co GTD Fixed to Float 4.0% Dec 15 2065 12(3/15 2,469,000 2,175,016 2,454,872 2,478259 303,243
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500.000 2,687,500 2,672,917 2,612,500 -75,000
JP Morgan Chase 8 Co Pfd 7.9% Apri 30 2049 6/15(11 2,500,000 2,675,000 2,672,917 2,612,500 -62,500
LBO Capital 7.5% 12/29/49 5/21/13 1.903.000 1,948,500 2,014,199 2.063.566 115.066
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,000,000 2,995,764 3,331,250 3 387,604 391,840
GMAC Cap TR I GTD Pfd Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80.000 1.812.774 2034.400 236 8110 154 026
1,149,109 Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 19,719,660 20,803,072 20,868,669
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) Biwa/0
Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 d CBI var 7/26/2033 11/19/13 568.995 924.312 505.385 480783 45.373
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fired Income (DB) 435,387 505,385 480,763 45,376
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 76,128,397 76,106,683 76,608,488 380,089
Note - Accrued interest has been Included In month end fixed Income values
Purchase Quantity 3/31/17 4/30/17 Unrealized
Asset Description Data Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LW - Equities (DB)
Akom Inc. 8/10/15 5,000 234,206 120,400 187,250 436.956
Alibaba Group 6/10/15 5,000 444,749 539,150 577,500 132751
Allianz SE ADR 4/13/15 6000 90,056 92,650 95.045 4989
Apple Inc 9/5/14 64,000 6,33Z800 9,194,240 9,193,600 2,860,800
11,162,494 Apple Inc 1/11/16 250,000 24,750,008 35,915,000 35,912,500
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 263,157 4,999,983 6,399,978 7,044,713 2,044,730
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Barn 1.3.11) 1/16/01 70,500 1,500,000 300,330 275.655 -1,224,345
Avalanche Blotechnologles now called Adverum Blotedinologles 4/20/15 10,000 398,606 27,000 28,500 -370,106
BASF ADR 4/13/15 5,000 508,056 495,875 486.430 -21,626
Bank of New York Mellon 6/25/14 250.000 9,078,406 11,807,500 11,765.000 2,688,594
Biogen Wee Inc 2/14/12 2.095 250,455 572,815 568.185 317,730
Bloveratiy Inc 2/1/17 1,047 20,254 57,020 61,574 41,320
Centene Corp 918/14 15 986,497
1
108 093
'317:450
1 156,920 170,423
Dish Network Corp 6/10/15 5.600550 384,978 322.200 -42,778
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17,500 665,000 2,485,875 2,629,375 1,964,375
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49,830 1,265,037 1,607,018 1,798.965 533,928
General Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3,585,947 3,448,484 3,378,266 -207,681
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 496,109 685,400 666,777 170,668
Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 5,000 396,407 339,600 342,750 -53,657
Gilead Sciences Inc 3/7/14 3,100 248,797 210,552 212,505 -34,292
Glaxo Smith Kline PLC 6/10/15 5,000 215,006 210,800 204 500 -10,506
Global Partner Acquisition Corp 7/3&15 2,000 20,000 19,600 19,700 -300
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/15 700 14,000 26.530 27,244 13,244
Match 11/19/15 200 2 400 3266, 3,726 1,326
Mobileye NV Amstelyeen Ord Shares 8/1/14 800 20',000 49,120 49,536 29,538
Square 11/19/15 200 1,800 3 456 3,648 1,848
-lam Sangamo Biosciences Inc 5/28/13 50,000 422,214 2661,000 240.000
Santander Consumer USA 1/28/14 1,000 24,000 13,320 12,740 -11,260
Terraform Global 7/31/15 400 6,000 1,920 1,900 -4 100 _ _.
Twitter Inc 11/7/13 1,500 39,000 22,426 24.720 -14,280
Viacom Inc 6/10/15 5,000 338,745 233,100 212,800 -125,945
Volkswagen AG 4113/15 5,000 254,306 149,950 160.800 -93,506
VVisdombee Investments Inc 3/31(15 15000 -
19,476,297 Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 58,293,977 76,854,117 77,770,274
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
Barclays PLC ADR 7/18/16 100,000 805,096 1,124,000 1,081.000 275,904
Credit Suisse Group 7/18/16 100,000 1,137,626 1,484,000 1,526.000 388 374
ZTO Express 10/27/16 3,500 68.259 45.815. 48755 -19,495
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stank ) 2,010,972 2,663,816 2,655,755 644,783
Southern Trust Co. • Equities (Merrill)
ING 4/4/17 25,000 373.54 - 407 000 33,500
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill) 373,600 0 407,000 33,500
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morqa
Colony Capital->Colony Northslar Inc. 9/26/16 73,315 928,837 946,497 958,227 29,391
Sequential Brands 9/23/16 50.000 402,134 194,500 168,500 -233.634
ZTO Express 10/27/16 1,150 22,425 15,054 16,020 -6,406
Bank of America 3/2/16 7,500 100,825 176,295 175,050 74.225
Editas Medicine 3/2/16 3,200 102,199 71,424 60.320 41,879
Tencent Holdings 7/18/16 50,000 lfzijilat_1-441.492 1/¢2,22Q 403.738
Total Gratitude America, LTD- Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,72fl82 2,846,769 2,945,617 225,434
J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DS)
Bristol Myers Squkb 10/30(15 5,000 334,712 271,900 280,250 -54,462
Disney 10/30/15 456,040 566,950 462.400 6,360
Pfizer Inc 10/30Al5 1 0 145.028 jjlEa lgZag 2N2a0
935,780 982,532 885,114
-
-50,666 Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB)
TOTAL EQUITIES 64,334,411 83,337,233 84,663,760 20,329,348
Southern Financial LLC - Equity E s (DB)
Wisdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60 000 2556.555 5.55Zill2 LO59.255 ift-Utl
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETPS (DB) 2,966,099 3,037,200 3,064,200 98,101
Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill Lynch)
AAPL May 19 2017 150 Cans 3/29/17 2.500 502,500 432,576 184,686 -317,814
ILI • al h eshotall Imo See WO nen is assm • TAP maims knedi ito 12(9/16 604,174 250.008 14U0k 4131k -208,481,
-526,294 Total Southern Trust Co. - Options (Merrill Lynch) notional 752,500 574,E80 226,206
3/31/17 4130/17 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern Financia ISFLLC) Mild 10mm sins
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 44 990 912 45 217 785 0.50% 2.98% added Sem 3/31/16
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 44,990,912 45,217,785 wihd,w lomm til0f17
total Invest:madOforn
2016 Mum 3.77%
Hedge Funds - Haze
King Street 5.753.576 3.446.473 0.00% 0.00% 2011/17 paid to Oat':
Hedge Funds - Haze 5,753,576 3,446,473 4/27/16 $.967,43400
7/27/16 6.102,324 paid
2017. april Mum 10127116 6.18001 P•11
of capital of 1f27/17 3.994,644 paid
2.307,103 2016 rotas 4.60%
Hedge Funds-STC
Honeycomb 21 957 570 22 835 873 4.00% 13.60% added 2Dmm 931116
Total Hedge Funds - STC 21,957,570 22,835,873 2016 mum 0.4a%
Total Hedge Funds 72,702,058 71,500,131
SFL
Mort Southern FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profit 0
Kyara II (investment amount) 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0
Kyara IV (Investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (grat at cost) 11,250,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000.000 sic
Adfin Solutions (investment amount) 875,000 buttwfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston, NJ 3,000.000
Coinbase STC 3,001,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Valor Global Fund II (investment amount - 16mm committment) 13,650,000
Valor Global Fund III (investment amount - 25mm committment) 10,750,000
Totals I 11,250,000 3,000,000 28,775,000 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total Investments 52,506,000
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles a Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 6,500,000 6,500,000
1988 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 Plan D LLC 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 900,000 900.000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 2,500,000 6,500,000 250,000 17,350,000 26,600,000
Asset Description JEE SFL STC FIRE Totals
Oficeivable
100,000 100,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Karyna 350,000 350,000
Nick Ribis 75,000 75,000
Larry / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
1,500,000 David Mitchell 1,500,000
302,000 302.000
Harlequin Dane, LLC 3,750,000 3,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 1,000,000 1,000,000
Lesley 200,000 200,000
Cecile 50,000 50,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
LV Home & Other 1,300,000 1,300,000
525.000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,697,446 4,950,000 50,000 1,935,000 9,632,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques 8 Jewelry haze trust
Giacometti 25,000,000 25,000,000
Braque 5,000,000 5,000,000
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) -30,500,000 -30,500,000
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Cwrot Emerald Cut Diamond - Insurance value 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques 8, Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 33,050,000 9,400,000
EFTA00039416 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2020-01-29)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Si!lo J. Mollo Building
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York, New York 10007
March 10, 2020
BY EMAIL
Jason E. Foy
Fo & Se lowitz LLC
Montell Figgins, Esq.
Re: United States v. Tova Noel and Michael Thomas, No. 19 Cr. 830
Dear Counsel:
We write in response to your discovery request letters, dated January 29, 2020. This letter
is designated as Protected Material pursuant to the Protective Order entered in this matter.
Thomas Request. The Government refers to its prior response to this request, as stated at
the November 25, 2019 pretrial conference.
Noel Request No. 1-10, 12-13. With respect to your other requests, we note, at the outset,
that many of these requests are extremely broad and pertain to information that does not appear to
be relevant to the case. To the extent material called for by these requests is within the
Government's possession and subject to disclosure at this time, the Government has already
disclosed such information to you, including by letter dated January 24, 2020. To the extent these
requests call for information that is not currently in the Government's possession or which is not
subject to disclosure, you identify no legal basis or authority for these requests, and we are not
aware of any authority requiring us to obtain and/or disclose this information.
Noel Request No. 11. The name of the MCC technician referenced in the Government's
previous letter is XX.
Noel Request No. 16. The Government has already produced the available video
surveillance in its possession for July 23, 2019 for the Special Housing Unit. The Government
attaches hereto two public filings in United States v. Tartaglione, 16 Cr. 832 (KMK), which
reference these issues.
06.20.2018
Page 2
Noel Requests No. 14-5, 17-23. These requests, in general terms, call for information about
where particular evidence may be located within the discovery produced to date. As you note, you
seek this information to "assist in expediting the ability of the defense to be ready for trial."
Accordingly, with respect to Noel Requests No. 14-15, 17-23, at your request and solely as a
courtesy to aid you in your review of discovery, the Government is providing the information that
follows. The Government's response to your requests should not be used for any other purpose,
nor should it be construed as a representation that only these files or portions of the surveillance
video are potentially relevant to the Government's case or any potential defense, or as a
representation that the identified portions are the only portions of surveillance video that would be
responsive to your requests. The Government expressly reserves the right to identify and/or offer
at trial additional material as probative of any of the issues identified in these requests.
Noel Request No. 14. With respect to August 9, 2019, we direct your attention to the
following video files: CH0080_20190809195956; CH0080 20190809205956,
CH0080_20190809215956; CH0080_20190809225956. With respect to August 10, 2019, the
following video files contain this activity: CH0080_20190809235959;
CH0080 20190810005959; CH0080 20190810025959; CH0080 20190810035959;
CH0080:20190810045959; and CH0080_2-0190810055959.
Noel Request No. 15.  While the Government has not conducted a review of every time
Jeffrey Epstein was captured on MCC surveillance during the more than 30 days he was housed
there prior to his death and does not purport to provide such an exhaustive response, as a courtesy
and to aid in your review of the discovery, we direct your attention to the following: on August 9,
2019 Epstein was captured leaving his cell to make a phone call at approximately 18:53:54 -
18:54:46 (CH0080_20190809175956). Epstein was escorted back to his cell at approximately
19:49:2519:49:39 (CH0080_20190809185956).
Noel Request No. 17. We direct your attention to files CH0080_20190809145956 and
CH0080_20190809155956, during approximately 15:45:0016:15:00 on August 9, 2019.
Noel Request No. 18. We direct your attention to files CH0080_20190809205956 and
CH0080_20190809215956, during approximately 19:45:0020:15:00 on August 9, 2019.
Noel Request No. 19. We direct your attention to file CH0080_20190809215956, during
approximately 22:29:0022:34:00.
Noel Request No. 20. We direct your attention to files CH0080_20190809225956
CH0080_20190809235959, during approximately 23:45:00 (August 9) - 00:15:00 (August 10).
Noel Request No. 21. The Government does not presently believe this interaction was
captured by surveillance video.
Noel Request No. 22. The Government refers you to the forensic examination of the
computers used by defendants Noel and Thomas during August 9 to 10, 2019, which were
previously produced in discovery (SDNY_00000021 - SDNY00000075). The Government also
refers you to the following files during the following times, which show the defendants at the desk
06.20.2018
Page 3
during the periods of time in which they were using computers, as shown by the forensic
examination referenced above: files CH0080_20190809225956, CH0080_20190809235959
CH0080_20190810005959, CH0080_20190810025959, CH0080_20190810035959,
CH0080_20190810045959, and CH0080_20190810055959, during approximately (8/9) 23:39:00
— (8/10) 00:15:00, (8/10) 03:54:0003:57:00, (8/10) 04:29:0005:04:00, and (8/10) 05:10:0006:20:00 as to defendant Noel, and approximately (8/10) 00:35:0001:15:00 and (8/10) 06:00:0006:20:00 as to defendant Thomas.
Noel Request No. 23.  The Government refers you to files CH0080_20190810005959,
CH0080 20190810015959, and CH0080 20190810025959 during approximately 00:01:0003:15:00 on August 10, 2019.
We are available at your convenience to discuss any further.
Very truly yours,
GEOFFREY S. BERMAN
United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New York
By: /s/
Assistant United States Attorneys
06.20.2018
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Buryat [russia] Mongol ethnic group native to southeastern Siberia 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01273102 (Jmail)
 [money] payment from Epstein to Renata Bolotova's father's account at Sberbank
(inferred date: 2020-02-02)
FEDWIRE PAYMENT DEBIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originator
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originators Bank
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Originator to Beneficiary
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
BURYAT BRANCH 8601/107
IMAD 20160211 BIB7T41C 000104
Date 11-Feb-2016
Transaction Number 201602110003548
Sending Bank Reference P201602110003548
Related Bank Reference
Instructed Amount
Debited Amount
Paid Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
BOLOTOV BALDAN BADMAEVICH
BURYAT BRANCH 8601/107
IRKUTSK
10,000.00 USD
10,000.00 USD
10,000.00 USD
75.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
SBERBANK (BAIKALSKY HEAD OFFICE)
32, DEPUTATSKAY STREET
664047 IRKUTSK
RUSSIAN FEDERATION
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON
NEW YORK
NY
Bank-to-Bank Information
/CTS/
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
BURYAT BRANCH 8601/107
SWIFT: SABRRU66
Debit Advice PRINT
11123ank .
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
CONFIDENTIAL
CERTIFIED TO BE A TRUE AND
EXACT COPT OF THE ORIGINAL
' ^
BY: SCIti;r  th A:00020206
CONFIDENTIAL FirstBankPR007361
FEDWIRE PAYMENT DEBIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originator
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originators Bank
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
Originator to Beneficiary
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
IMAD 20160211 BIB7T41C 000105
Date 11-Feb-2016
Transaction Number 201602110003694
Sending Bank Reference P201602110003694
Related Bank Reference
Instructed Amount
Debited Amount
Paid Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
NI41.111soilissi
20,000.00 USD
20,000.00 USD
20,000.00 USD
75.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
SABRRUM3XXX
SBERBANK (SREDNERUSSKY HEAD OFFICE)
8 B. ANDRONIEVSKAYA UL.
109544 MOSCOW
RUSSIAN FEDERATION
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON
NEW YORK
NY
Bank-to-Bank Information
/CTS/
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
N9040/01500 BIC:044525225
Debit Advice PRINT
CONFIDENTIA
Bank
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
L
CERTIFIED TO RE .1 TRUE .IND
ENACT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
BY:  SDNi ;  SU0020207
111"1110R111.10 Slli \ Ill RI:
CONFIDENTIAL FirstBankPR007362
FEDWIRE PAYMENT DEBIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originator
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originators Bank
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
Originator to Beneficiary
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
IMAD 20160301 BIB7T41C 000133
Date 01-Mar-2016
Transaction Number 201603010001749
Sending Bank Reference P201603010001749
Related Bank Reference
Instructed Amount
Debited Amount
Paid Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
LT387300010129516294
1,089.00 USD
1,089.00 USD
1,089.00 USD
75.00 USD
VILNUS LITHUANIA
Beneficiary's Bank
HABALT22XXX
SVVEDBANK AB
KONSTITUCIJOS 20A
LT-03502 VILNIUS
LITHUANIA
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERICAS
NEW YORK
NY
Bank-to-Bank Information
/CTS/
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
Debit Advice PRINT
CONFIDENTIA
CIZIank
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
L
CERTIFIED TO RE a TRUE AND
EXACT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
In: SIMi;'' OWL00020208
Art 11OR111. 0 SIb \HIRI
CONFIDENTIAL FirstBankPR007363
FEDWIRE PAYMENT DEBIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originator
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originators Bank
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Originator to Beneficiary
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
IMAD 20160301 BIB7T41C 000141
Date 01-Mar-2016
Transaction Number 201603010001751
Sending Bank Reference P201603010001751
Related Bank Reference
Instructed Amount
Debited Amount
Paid Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
GB29LOYD30647226234560
4,355.00 USD
4,355.00 USD
4,355.00 USD
75.00 USD
LONDON SW1W 8AT
Beneficiary's Bank
LOYDGB21674
LLOYDS BANK PLC
33-33A KINGS ROAD
LONDON SW3 4LX
UNITED KINGDOM
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON
NEW YORK
NY
Bank-to-Bank Information
/CTS/
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
Debit Advice PRINT
CONFIDENTIA
Bank
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
L
CERTIFIED TO BE A TRUE AND
EXACT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
BY:  Stitirek000 20209
ArTHOMILIP SH, \ tII HI
CONFIDENTIAL FirstBankPR007364
FEDWIRE PAYMENT DEBIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originator
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originators Bank
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
Originator to Beneficiary
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
IMAD 20160301 BIB7T41C 000138
Date 01-Mar-2016
Transaction Number 201603010001753
Sending Bank Reference P201603010001753
Related Bank Reference
Instructed Amount
Debited Amount
Paid Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
FR7630003037150005054672133
2,175.00 USD
2,175.00 USD
2,175.00 USD
75.00 USD
FRANCE
Beneficiary's Bank
SOGEFRPPXXX
SOCIETE GENERALE
PARIS
FRANCE
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
SOCIETE GENERALE
NEW YORK
NY
Bank-to-Bank Information
/CTS/
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
Debit Advice PRINT
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
CONFIDENTIAL
CERTIFIED TO BE A TRUE AND
EXACT COPT OF THE ORIGINAL
BY: SDN'r GM 00020210
AUTHORIZI.II sn III II I:
CONFIDENTIAL FirstBankPR007365
FEDWIRE PAYMENT DEBIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originator
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originators Bank
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Originator to Beneficiary
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
IMAD 20160301 BIB7T41C 000136
Date 01-Mar-2016
Transaction Number 201603010001757
Sending Bank Reference P201603010001757
Related Bank Reference
Instructed Amount
Debited Amount
Paid Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
FR7630003032900005054038502
liessclosk 75007 PARIS FRANCE
4,355.00 USD
4,355.00 USD
4,355.00 USD
75.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
SOGEFRPPXXX
SOCIETE GENERALE
PARIS
FRANCE
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
SOCIETE GENERALE
NEW YORK
NY
Bank-to-Bank Information
/CTS/
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
Debit Advice PRINT
CONFIDENTIA
IMEank
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
L
CERTIFIED TO RE .1 TRUE AND
ENACT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
1, I
BY: SI)ti? Gt;L00CH20211
ArtlIMUni, 111 III:
CONFIDENTIAL FirstBankPR007366
FEDWIRE PAYMENT DEBIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originator
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI
Originators Bank
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
Originator to Beneficiary
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
IMAD 20160301 BIB7T41C 000126
Date 01-Mar-2016
Transaction Number 201603010001796
Sending Bank Reference P201603010001796
Related Bank Reference
Instructed Amount
Debited Amount
Paid Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
2,722.00 USD
2,722.00 USD
2,722.00 USD
75.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
JPMORGAN CHASE BANK, NA
NEW YORK
NY
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
JPMORGAN CHASE BANK, NA
NEW YORK
NY
Bank-to-Bank Information
EXPENSE REIMBURSEMENT
Debit Advice PRINT
CONFIDENTIA
First Bank
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
L
CERTIFIED TO BE A TRUE AND
EXACT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
84: s j00020212
ArTHORIZED SIGN „I  It I:
CONFIDENTIAL FirstBankPR007367
FEDWIRE PAYMENT DEBIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE ST JAMES
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE ST JAMES
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originators Bank
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Originator to Beneficiary
INTERBANK TRANSFER
IMAD 20170928 BIB7T41C 000091
Date 28-Sep -2017
Transaction Number 201709280001132
Sending Bank Reference 201709280001132
Related Bank Reference
Instructed Amount
Debited Amount
Paid Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
6100 RED HOOK QTR B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
VIRGIN ISLANDS (U.S.)
700,000.00 USD
700,000.00 USD
700,000.00 USD
0.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERICAS
345 PARK AVENUE
NEW YORK NY 10154
US
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERICAS
NEW YORK
NY
Bank-to-Bank Information
Debit Advice
CONFIDENTIA
1ank
RECORDS & IJNIAL REQUIREMENTS
L
CERTIFIED TO BE A TRUE AND
MCI COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
? ;
BY: SDNYleM_00020213
WIROBIZED ',Hi% i RI:
CONFIDENTIAL FirstBankPR007368
FEDWIRE RECEIVE CREDIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator
35269691 - JEFFREY EPSTEIN
C/O HBRK ASSOCIATES, INC
575 LEXINGTON AVENUE,4TH FLOOR
NEW YORK, NY 10022
Originators Bank
BKTRUS33PWM
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA
NEW YORK,NY
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERICAS
NEW YORK
NY
Originator to Beneficiary
IMAD
CONFIDENTIAL
20190307 B1Q8383C 015378
Date
Transaction Number
Sending Bank Reference
Related Bank Reference
Received Amount
Credit Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
07-Mar-2019
2,000,000.00 USD
2,000,000.00 USD
0.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Bank-to-Bank Information
Credit Advice
Bank
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
CERTIFIED TO RE A TRUE AND
EXACT COPT OF THE ORIGINAL
RI:  SDNVG&000' 20214
CONFIDENTIAL ArTHORIII.to s \ tit
FirstBankPR007369
FEDWIRE RECEIVE CREDIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator
35269691 - JEFFREY EPSTEIN
C/O HBRK ASSOCIATES, INC
575 LEXINGTON AVENUE,4TH FLOOR
NEW YORK, NY 10022
Originators Bank
BKTRUS33PVVM
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA
NEW YORK,NY
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERICAS
NEW YORK
NY
Originator to Beneficiary
IMAD
CONFIDENTIAL
20190326 B1Q8383C 009341
Date
Transaction Number
Sending Bank Reference
Related Bank Reference
Received Amount
Credit Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
26-Mar-2019
640,000.00 USD
640,000.00 USD
0.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Bank-to-Bank Information
Credit Advice
Bank
1RECORDS & IJWAL REQUIREMENTS
CERTIFIED TO RE A TRUE AND
ENACT COPT OF THE ORIGINAL
, P
BY: SDN 00020216
CONFIDENTIAL
AUTHORIZED SIGN HE
FirstBankPR007370
FEDWIRE RECEIVE CREDIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator
35269691 - JEFFREY EPSTEIN
C/O HBRK ASSOCIATES, INC
575 LEXINGTON AVENUE,4TH FLOOR
NEW YORK, NY 10022
Originators Bank
BKTRUS33PVVM
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA
NEW YORK,NY
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERICAS
NEW YORK
NY
Originator to Beneficiary
IMAD
CONFIDENTIAL
20190409 B1Q8383C 013112
Date
Transaction Number
Sending Bank Reference
Related Bank Reference
Received Amount
Credit Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
09-Apr-2019
690,000.00 USD
690,000.00 USD
0.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Bank-to-Bank Information
Credit Advice
Bank
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
CERTIFIED TO BE .1 TRUE AND
EXACT COPT OF THE ORIGINAL
BY: SDNY_GM_00020216
CO N Fl DENT IA._ Arrilintim•SibNin w.
FirstBankPR007371
FEDWIRE RECEIVE CREDIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator
35269691 - JEFFREY EPSTEIN
C/O HBRK ASSOCIATES, INC
575 LEXINGTON AVENUE,4TH FLOOR
NEW YORK, NY 10022
Originators Bank
BKTRUS33PVVM
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA
NEW YORK,NY
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERICAS
NEW YORK
NY
Originator to Beneficiary
IMAD
CONFIDENTIAL
20190410 B1Q8383C 014886
Date
Transaction Number
Sending Bank Reference
Related Bank Reference
Received Amount
Credit Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
10-Apr-2019
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Beneficiary's Bank
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
2,000,000.00 USD
2,000,000.00 USD
0.00 USD
SAN JUAN
PR
Bank-to-Bank Information
Credit Advice
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
CERTIFIED TO RE A TRUE AND
EXACT COPT OF THE ORIGINAL
BY: SONY' G&00020217
CONFIDENTIA_ Arniollinoso.,,„ It li
FirstBankPR007372
FEDWIRE RECEIVE CREDIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator
35269691 - JEFFREY EPSTEIN
C/O HBRK ASSOCIATES, INC
575 LEXINGTON AVENUE,4TH FLOOR
NEW YORK, NY 10022
Originators Bank
BKTRUS33PVVM
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA
NEW YORK,NY
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERICAS
NEW YORK
NY
Originator to Beneficiary
IMAD
CONFIDENTIAL
20190416 B1Q8383C 009783
Date
Transaction Number
Sending Bank Reference
Related Bank Reference
Received Amount
Credit Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
16-Apr-2019
520,000.00 USD
520,000.00 USD
0.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Bank-to-Bank Information
Credit Advice
=Bank
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
CERTIFIED TO BE A TRUE AND
EXACT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
CONFIDENTCONFIDENTIAL Br: SCINY GM_00020218 ii"111111tI/1  \ %II  RI
FirstBankPR007373
FEDWIRE RECEIVE CREDIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator
35269691 - JEFFREY EPSTEIN
C/O HBRK ASSOCIATES, INC
575 LEXINGTON AVENUE,4TH FLOOR
NEW YORK, NY 10022
Originator's Bank
BKTRUS33PVVM
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICA
NEW YORK,NY
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST CO. AMERICAS
NEW YORK
NY
Originator to Beneficiary
IMAD
CONFIDENTIAL
20190510 B1Q8383C 011315
Date
Transaction Number
Sending Bank Reference
Related Bank Reference
Received Amount
Credit Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
10-May-2019
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Beneficiary's Bank
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
334,459.29 USD
334,459.29 USD
0.00 USD
SAN JUAN
PR
Bank-to-Bank Information
Credit Advice
Bank
RECORDS & IJNIAL REQUIREMENTS
CERTIFIED TO RE .1 TRUE AND
EXACT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
j4.
BY:  SDh& thk00020219
C 0 N FIDENTIA_ AUTHORIZED !ID.% III RI
FirstBankPR007374
FEDWIRE RECEIVE CREDIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator
Z400217761
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator's Bank
NFSCUS3BXXX
NATIONAL FINANCIAL SERVICES LLC
VVTC
BOSTON,MA 02109
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Instructing Bank
NATIONAL FINANCIAL SERVICES LLC
CLS
100 SALEM STREET MAIL CODE O1S1
SMITHFIELD RI 02917-
Sending Bank
JPMORGAN CHASE BANK, NA
NEW YORK
NY
Originator to Beneficiary
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC
IMAD
CONFIDENTIAL
20190611 B1QGC07C 007720
Date
Transaction Number
Sending Bank Reference
Related Bank Reference
Received Amount
Credit Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
11-Jun-2019
5051948162FS
VAC OF 19/06/11
2,500,000.00 USD
2,500,000.00 USD
0.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Bank-to-Bank Information
Credit Advice
Bank
RECORDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
CERTIFIED TO BE A TRUE AND
EXACT COPY OF THE
SD
_GM_00ORIGINAL
In' rii 020220
CON F I DENTI A._ ArtlIORIZI IP %lli til
FirstBankPR007375
FEDWIRE RECEIVE CREDIT ADVICE
(ADVICE WITHOUT SIGNATURE)
To JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
Originator
INTERNATIONAL AIRCRAFT TITLE AND ES
10324 GREENBRIAR PLACE SUITE D
OKLAHOMA CITY
73159 US OK
Originators Bank
BOFAUS3NXXX
BANK OF AMERICA, N.A.
222 BROADWAY
NEW YORK,NY 10038
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Instructing Bank
Sending Bank
BANK OF AMERICA, N.A., NY
NEW YORK
NY
Originator to Beneficiary
IMAD
CONFIDENTIAL
20190626 B6B7HU3R 011837
Date
Transaction Number
Sending Bank Reference
Related Bank Reference
Received Amount
Credit Amount
Charge Amount
Beneficiary
7101r26(51
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LITTLE SAINT JAMES ISLAND
ST THOMAS VI 00802
26-Jun-2019
N120JE
2,800,000.00 USD
2,800,000.00 USD
0.00 USD
Beneficiary's Bank
Intermediary Bank
Receiving Bank
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
SAN JUAN
PR
Bank-to-Bank Information
Credit Advice

• Bank
ItECOItDS & LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
CERTIFIED TO BE .1 TRUE AND
EXACT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
BY' SDNY_GM_00020221
C 0 N FIDENTI  Artiliam,,,,,,,tit FirstBankPR007376
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                                                                                  Rudy Giuliani [republican] disbarred former mayor of NYC 
 Paul Manafort [trump] Trump campaign manager, partner of Roger Stone, worked for Russians in Ukraine, convicted of financial fraud [wiki] 
                                                Roger Stone [trump] infamous political trickster with a tattoo of Nixon's face on his back 
                                                            Denise George [usvi] Virgin Islands Attorney General from 2019, sued JP Morgan 
                                                             Cyrus Vance Jr. [government] Manhattan District Attorney 2010-2021 [politico] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00104913 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI news clips
(date: 2020-02-12)
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
SDNY News Clips
Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Contents
Public Corruption 2
Avenatti 2
Epstein 3
Violent and Organized Crime 5
Ray 5
Gomez 9
Berry 10
Securities and Commodities Fraud 11
Madoff 11
General Crimes 13
Reynolds and Cohen 13
Money Laundering and Transnational Criminal Enterprises 14
Ackerman 14
Matters of Interest 16
Stone 16
Weinstein 25

╭─────────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────────────────────╮
│ SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020                 │
│                                                               │
│ SDNY News Clips                                               │
│ Wednesday, February 12, 2020                                  │
│                                                               │
│ Contents                                                      │
│ Public Corruption ... ond                                     │
│ Avenatti nnn ond                                              │
│ Esteli. 3                                                     │
│ Violent and Organized Crime... 5                              │
│ Ray... 5                                                      │
│ GOMEZ nnn 8                                                   │
│ Ber ene 10                                                    │
│ Securities and Commodities Fraud <1                           │
│ Madoff... <1                                                  │
│ General Crimes. 13                                            │
│ Reynolds and Cohen 13                                         │
│ Money Laundering and Transnational Criminal Enterprises... 14 │
│ Ackerman... 14                                                │
│ Matters of Interest. 16                                       │
│ SOME sone 16                                                  │
│ Weinstein.... 28                                              │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Public Corruption
Avenatti
Michael Avenatti jury deliberations begin in Nike case
Fox News
By Marta Dhanis
2/12/2020
Attorney Michael Avenatti's future is now in the jury's hands in the Nike-related extortion and fraud case.
The disgraced lawyer is accused of trying to extort up to $25 million from Nike by threatening to go public with 
evidence
that the company had paid off the families of young NBA-bound athletes.

At 11:31 am, federal Judge Paul Gardephe sent a group of six women and six men to start deliberating.
The 12 jurors need to consider if prosecutors proved that Avenatti is guilty on three counts: transmission of interstate
communications with intent to extort, attempted extortion, and wire fraud. If convicted on all counts, he could spend up
to 42 years in prison.

For about two weeks, prosecutors called several witnesses, including lawyers and Nike employees, and played
recordings of Avenatti at his meeting with Nike attorneys.

The defense's case consisted of documents and stipulations insisting that Avenatti was only being an aggressive attorney
and was working on behalf of his client. However, the client, Gary Franklin, the founder and coach of youth basketball
team California Supreme, testified in court that Avenatti didn't keep him in the loop of the negotiations with the 
athletic
giant.

"In the words of Nike itself, he went in there to 'Just Do It,' for his client," defense attorney Howard Srebnick said 
in
closing arguments, begging the jury to return a "not guilty" verdict.

Jurors heard instructions earlier this morning. Avenatti walked into the courtroom wearing a blue suit, white shirt and
striped blue tie. He sat at the defense's table facing the jury.

Avenatti is in custody after violating bail conditions in a federal case against him in California. He is currently 
being
housed at Manhattan's Metropolitan Correctional Center while this trial is underway.
The once famed lawyer for porn starn Stormy Daniels faces two other trials. In a second one in Manhattan, he faces
charges that he cheated Daniels out of the proceeds of a book deal. The most serious charges are in a federal case in 
Los
Angeles, where he is accused of defrauding clients and others.

Avenatti has denied all charges and insisted that they are part of an ongoing vendetta by the Trump administration after
he represented Daniels in her litigation against the president.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
EpsteEn
Epstein's lawyers in dispute with Virgin Islands over settlements with victims
The Guardian
By Edward Helmore
2/12/2020
Efforts to settle sex abuse claims against Jeffrey Epstein's estate are being thwarted by the attorney general of the US
Virgin Islands, lawyers for the disgraced late financier have claimed in court.

The dispute arises from efforts by the territory's attorney general, Denise George, to claim that Epstein, who owned two
islands in the Virgin Islands and where monetary claims on his estate are focused, fraudulently obtained benefits 
related
to a banking licence as part of his alleged criminal enterprise.

In court documents, George said she planned to name the disgraced financier's lawyers as co-defendants and fight his
estate's involvement in creating a victims' compensation fund.

In July last year, Epstein was arrested on fresh federal sex trafficking and conspiracy charges. He had previously 
pleaded
guilty in 2008 to a Florida state prostitution charge and completed a 13-month jail sentence. Epstein pleaded not guilty
to the new allegations but died by suicide in a New York jail cell in August.

His death has triggered a wide-ranging investigation into his associates and members of his powerful social circle and
also many victim claims for compensation.

Bennet Moskowitz, who is representing Epstein's estate, claimed that liens against the estate have left him unable to
release money from Epstein's $570m fortune to a victim's compensation fund.

"The attorney general for the Virgin Islands has decided for whatever reason to impede the program," Moskowitz said at
the hearing in Manhattan federal court.

But George countered that claim, saying she was in fact looking out for victims who may yet come forward.
"The attorney general's office has opposed the approval of the fund as currently proposed because it lacks fairness,
accountability, impartiality and sensitivity to victims at a level they deserve," George said in the statement.
"Further, victims who have not yet come forward or who may not wish to use the fund must be supported and
protected, with funds for counseling and for their claims, too," she said, adding: "There must be full accountability, 
not
only of the estate, but those who participated in, facilitated, and covered up Epstein's crimes."
Last month, George brought charges against Epstein's estate and alleged that his lawyers, Darren Indyke and Richard
Kahn, may have been part of Epstein's alleged fraud. George also put claims on Epstein's two islands.
Epstein named Indyke and Kahn as his executors to a will he modified so that it would be executed in the Caribbean
territory two days before he was found dead in a Manhattan jail cell on 10 August.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
In November, it was reported that Epstein's estate had asked the courts to allow a voluntary resolution program for the
late sex offender's accusers overseen by Ken Feinberg, the settlement's expert who oversaw claims from victims of the
9/11 terrorist attacks, the Catholic church's sex abuse scandals, and the BP-Blue Water Horizon oil spill.
But lawyers for several victims have argued that a victims fund would maintain the shroud of secrecy over Epstein's
alleged crimes and prevent the release of any new information while minimizing the threat of large jury awards from
individual legal actions.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Violent and Organized Crime
Ray
The Bizarre Life of the Man Accused in the Sarah Lawrence Sex Case
NYT
By Sharon Otterman
2/12/2020
Lawrence V. Ray was charged with conspiracy, extortion, sex trafficking, forced labor and related charges.
Credit...Jefferson Siegel for The New York Times
He has known mobsters and politicians and high-ranking American military officers. He has portrayed himself as an
international man of mystery who played a role in helping to end the war in Kosovo in the late 1990s.
He had contacts with foreign leaders and arranged Mikhail Gorbachev's visit to City Hall in 1997 to meet with the then-
mayor, Rudolph W. Giuliani. For the last 19 years, he has been in and out of legal trouble for everything from
involvement in a mob stock pump-and-dump scheme to custody issues involving his children.
For decades, Lawrence V. Ray, 60, who was charged by federal law enforcement on Tuesday in a bizarre scheme that
included extortion, forced prostitution and forced labor involving a group of students he met while he was living with 
his
daughter at Sarah Lawrence College, has been described by some as a master manipulator.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Burly and intense, Mr. Ray has put himself at the center of local politics. In 1998, he was the best man at the wedding 
of
a former New York police commissioner, Bernard B. Kerik.

But he's also turned on those who have trusted him — first as an F.B.I. informant against the mob, and then as a
cooperating witness in an investigation that would ultimately land Mr. Kerik in prison.
In 2010, apparently down and out, Mr. Ray, who had recently been released from prison on a custody charge, moved
into his daughter's dorm room at Sarah Lawrence College in Yonkers, N.Y., federal investigators said.
He is now facing decades in prison, accused of manipulating students from the school to the point that they were willing
to falsely confess to crimes. He is charged with coercing one woman into prostitution, and with stealing $1 million from
his victims, according to the indictment unsealed on Tuesday.

"Larry Ray is a psychotic con man who has victimized every friend he's ever had," Mr. Kerik, who has said he cut ties 
with

Mr. Ray in 2000, was quoted as saying in the 2019 New York magazine article that prompted the government's
investigation. "It's been close to 20 years since I last heard from him, yet his reign of terror continues."
The following portrait of Mr. Ray was put together from interviews, court documents and news coverage by The Times
over the years.
Here's what we know about him:
Ties to reputed mobsters, fears of o hit mon

Mr. Ray, who is also known as Lawrence Grecco, grew up in Brooklyn and New Jersey. In the 1980s, he became a partner
in a bar in Scotch Plains, N.J., called Club Malibu and JJ Rockers. At the bar, he began meeting people from all walks 
of
life, including politicians from New York and New Jersey.

In the early 1990s, he formed a commercial insurance brokerage firm, helping insure people for projects such as
construction.

In this role, he met a reputed mobster who owned a company called U.S. Bridge of New York, according to federal
investigators. Mr. Ray agreed to help the company get insurance for a major project.
At some point in the mid-1990s, Mr. Ray began to believe that someone from the mob attached to the company was
trying to kill him. Mr. Kerik helped him contact the F.B.I., according to emails between the two men. Mr. Ray began
serving as an informant in a federal investigation related to a wide-ranging security fraud scheme involving the pumping
and dumping of stocks. He ended up being indicted himself, along with 18 others, for a role in the scheme.
In 2000, federal investigators charged Mr. Ray with agreeing to pay a $100,000 bribe to a bond brokerage firm
executive, according to a 2004 federal court filing. He pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit security fraud and was
sentenced to five years probation.
Friendship with Mayor Giuliani's police commissioner
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Appointed New York City police commissioner in 2000, Mr. Kerik became a national figure after the Sept. 11 terror
attacks. In 2004, President George W. Bush nominated Mr. Kerik to lead the Department of Homeland Security. But a
series of scandals, some of which involved Mr. Ray, destroyed that chance.

Mr. Kerik and Mr. Ray had become friends in the mid-1990s. The two men worked out together and rode motorcycles.
At the time, Mr. Kerik was a rising star in the New York City Department of Correction. He became the commissioner of
the department early in 1998.

In November 1998, Mr. Kerik got married in New Jersey, and Mr. Ray served as best man. Mr. Ray and another friend,
also a partner in Club Malibu, wrote checks to cover parts of Mr. Kerik's wedding and reception.
In 1999, Mr. Kerik wanted to renovate his new apartment in Riverdale, in the Bronx, according to emails between Mr.
Ray and Mr. Kerik. The scandal over who paid for his renovation ended up engulfing Mr. Kerik.
Through Mr. Ray, Mr. Kerik befriended a man named Frank DiTommaso, who ran a construction company, the Interstate
Industrial Corporation, with his brother. The company hired Mr. Ray as its security director, according The Times's
coverage of a resulting case that accused the former city police commissioner of, among other things, accepting illegal
renovations on his Bronx apartment.

The company had performed more than $200,000 in renovations on the apartment for almost no cost. State and federal
investigators discovered the arrangement after Mr. Kerik withdrew from consideration for Homeland Security secretary.

Mr. Ray agreed to cooperate with investigators looking into Mr. Kerik. In 2006, Mr. Kerik pleaded guilty to misdemeanor
charges related to $165,000 in gifts received from the construction company. He was jailed three years later after
pleading to eight federal felony charges.
Arranging a visit by Mikhail Gorbachev

Mr. Ray had contacts with at least one American general and Russian officials. He liked to talk about how he helped
broker a deal to end bombing in Kosovo in the late 1990s, a claim at least partly backed up by a letter from NATO in
court records, The Washington Post reported in 2007.

Somehow, he also formed a connection with someone who worked for Mr. Gorbachev, the former leader of the Soviet
Union. In 1997, Mr. Ray helped to arrange for Mr. Gorbachev to visit New York, where he met with Mr. Giuliani at City
Hall. He later said he arranged the visit, on Dec. 18, 1997, at Mr. Kerik's request.
A photograph from the time shows Mr. Ray outside City Hall that day, standing behind Mr. Gorbachev, with Mr. Kerik in
the foreground. Mr. Kerik and Mr. Gorbachev are both gesturing with their hands in opposite directions.
Beaten up in a lobby
Mr. Ray would end up cooperating with authorities in cases against not only Mr. Kerik but also Mr. DiTommaso. Mr. Ray
testified against Mr. DiTommaso in a 2012 perjury trial related to the renovation scandal.
Years later, the slight was not forgotten. Mr. Ray popped up in the news in 2017, when a video from two years earlier of
his being pummeled in the lobby of the Hudson Hotel by Mr. DiTommaso was obtained by the Daily News.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
The video shows Mr. Dilommaso walking past Mr. Ray, and then back toward him after apparently recognizing him. Mr.
DiTommaso then attacked Mr. Ray. Two people nearby in the lobby rushed over and tried to stop the attack.
The beating left Mr. Ray with a skull fracture as well as permanent speech and other neurological problems, Mr. Ray's
lawyer, Edward Hayes, said at the time. Federal investigators now charge that by that point Mr. Ray was already years
into his extortion schemes involving the students from Sarah Lawrence College.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Gomez
DEA Agent Sentenced to 4 Years for Helping Drug Traffickers
AP
By AP
2/12/2020
NEW YORK — A federal narcotics agent was sentenced Wednesday to four years in prison for his role in a decade-long
drug conspiracy that involved the smuggling of thousands of kilograms of cocaine from Puerto Rico to New York.
Prosecutors accused Fernando Gomez of infiltrating the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration in 2011 and assisting a
drug-trafficking ring known for slaughtering its rivals.

Gomez pleaded guilty last year to selling firearms to a high-volume cocaine trafficker while working as a police officer
outside Chicago.

He also helped La Organization de Narcotraficantes Unidos avoid detection from law enforcement, picked up money for
the drug ring and improperly accessed DEA records about a cooperator he believed had information about his co-
conspirators.

Gomez, a former U.S. Marine, broke down in Manhattan federal court, apologizing for "poor judgment" that he said
stemmed from misguided efforts to protect family members involved in the drug trade.
"The government wants you to make an example out of me," he told U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman. "I'm not that
example. I wasn't running around like a cowboy with a badge."
Furman said he was moved by the agent's contrition but added that Gomez's betrayal of his badge had left a "stain on
the Drug Enforcement Administration and all of law enforcement."
Federal sentencing guidelines called for Gomez to spend at least seven years behind bars. But a term that long would be
unjust, the judge said, given Gomez's public service and cooperation with the investigation.
"People are complicated," Furman said, "and Mr. Gomez is a prime example of that."
The judge said there are unanswered questions about why Gomez joined the DEA in 2011, where he worked until his
2018 arrest.

Prosecutors said he lied during his employment screening, but Furman said the government failed to offer persuasive
evidence — beyond the claims of a cooperating witness — that Gomez had become a "double agent" in the traditional
sense.

Gomez, 42, had been assigned to the DEA's Chicago field division at the time of his arrest.
"This is a breach of duty," Assistant U.S. Attorney said, condemning both the "serious actions" Gomez
took and his years of silence about La ONU's drug-trafficking activity.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Berry
Bronx murder suspect arrested in Bethlehem 19 years after shooting
Lehigh Valley Live
By Sarah Cassi
2/12/2020
A man wanted in a fatal shooting almost 20 years ago in the Bronx was arrested Friday in Bethlehem.
Ralph Berry, 52, and Frank Lopez, 43, are both charged in the June 2000 shooting of Caprice Jones on East 161st Street 
in
the Bronx, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York said.

Jones did not die the day he was shot, but ultimately died from his wounds in 2010, when he was 42.
Berry and Lopez were part of a crack-dealing operation at the time of the shooting, prosecutors said. Federal
prosecutors allege Berry handed Lopez the gun, and Lopez opened fire, hitting Jones.
On Friday, Berry was arrested in Bethlehem and Lopez was arrested in Plano, Texas. Berry appeared in federal court in
Philadelphia. He was being held there while awaiting transfer to New York.

Each man faces two charges that carry maximum sentences of death or life in prison: murder through use of a firearm
and murder in connection with drug trafficking.

Before Jones died, Berry in 2009 pleaded guilty to felony drug charges and was sentenced to 20 years in prison, followed
by 10 years of supervised release, according to court records.

Last October, Berry's sentence was reduced to time-served, followed by eight years of supervised release. Federal
prosecutors are appealing the reduced sentence.

"Many years have passed since Caprice Jones was murdered, but the detectives of the NYPD continued investigating,
working to see that justice would be done. Now, thanks to their extraordinary efforts, in partnership with the special
agents of our office, Ralph Berry and Frank Lopez face federal murder charges," U.S. Attorney Geoffrey S. Berman said in
a news release.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Securities and Commodities Fraud
Madoff
Bernie Madoff's future: Where does Ponzi king go from here?
Fox News
By Stephanie Pagones
2/12/2020
Ponzi scheme mastermind Bernie Madoff shockingly announced last week he was suffering from terminal kidney failure
— and was, in turn, seeking to have his 150-year prison sentence shortened.

Madoff pleaded guilty in March 2009 to multiple charges in connection to his scheme — the largest Ponzi scheme in
history — in which he scammed nearly 5,000 people out of more than $64 billion. He was sentenced in June of that year.
The 81-year-old has since spent just more than a decade behind bars and is currently serving the century-and-a-half-long
sentence at a federal medical center in Butner, North Carolina. His release date is identified on the Bureau of Prisons
website as Nov. 14, 2139.

But his Feb. 5 request to the court, made through his attorney and called a "Motion for Compassionate Release,"
detailed what lawyers called change in circumstances.

"It was clear that Madoff's 150-year prison sentence was symbolic for three reasons: retribution, deterrence, and for 
the
victims," the court papers state. "This Court must now consider whether keeping Madoff incarcerated, in light of his
terminal kidney failure and a life expectancy of less than 18 months, is truly in furtherance of statutory sentencing 
goals
and our society's value and understanding of compassion."
But former federal prosecutor and longtime attorney Robert Appleton, now a New York-based white-collar defense
attorney, said having motions like Madoffs granted is "rare."
"The judge has a lot of discretion, which is pretty much unfettered... But they're also very difficult to get," Appleton
told
FOX Business on Wednesday. "One of the things to keep in mind is that the Bureau of Prisons has very good medical
facilities, medical care. They have certain facilities that treat or house gravely ill prisoners."
Though doubtful, Appleton said, prosecutors could consent to the motion. Nonetheless, the government will file a
response to the court, which will be followed by a hearing on the matter.

Appleton, who handled a "motion for compassionate release" while working as a federal prosecutor in Connecticut, said
the court will take into account factors such as the length of Madoff's sentence, the amount of time he has served, the
extent of the crime and the imminence of his death.

"These things are typically done, if they're done at all, with prisoners facing two, three months of life," he said. 
"Eighteen
months is — I have to look at the cases — but I can't think of a case where it's been granted with that much time
remaining."
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
The U.S. Bureau of Prisons previously rejected Madoffs request, telling him on Dec. 5, 2019, that his early release 
would
"minimize the severity of his offense." Months earlier, in July, he filed papers asking President Donald Trump to 
shorten
his prison sentence.

Prosecutors — who have not yet submitted a written response to the Feb. 5 motion — will also take into account the
victims and the damage Madoff caused.

On Friday, prosecutors announced those who suffered financial losses in the scheme have until the end of February to
submit emails to Judge Denny Chin through the prosecutor's office.

If the judge were to ultimately grant Madoff's request, he would "order supervised release and impose conditions,"
Appleton said. If such were the case — if the terminally ill octogenarian were released early because of his health — 
what
family does he have to turn to?
Madoff's wife, Ruth Madoff, moved out of New York City and initially lived in Boca Raton, Florida, the New York Post's
Isabel Vincent reported in May 2017.

She was most recently reported to be living a quiet, private life in Connecticut. The Post described in detail how Ruth
Madoff was virtually living in "exile" in Old Greenwich, where she moved in 2012.
Bernie Madoff's sons, Mark and Andrew Madoff, worked as business and regulatory managers at Bernard Madoffs
private investment securities business. Both denied any involvement in their father's scheme and have since died in
unrelated incidents.

Mark Madoff committed suicide in 2010, leaving behind his wife, Stephanie (Madoff) Mack and children. Mack owns a
styling business and moved to Brooklyn in 2016, according to a 2017 New York Times report, which noted that Mack and
Ruth Madoff were in contact regularly.

Andrew Madoff died in 2014 from cancer, leaving behind a fiancee, Catherine Hooper, and children. Hooper moved into
a studio apartment in Manhattan after briefly moving to the Bahamas with her 12-year-old daughter, who was enrolled
in a marine biology program, according to a 2017 profile in People.

Bernice Madoff's brother, Peter Madoff, was the convicted schemer's chief compliance officer who worked for the firm
for 40 years, according to a Bloomberg report. Peter Madoff denied knowing anything about the massive scheme until
its demise. He was sentenced to 10 years behind bars and is currently housed in a residential re-entry management
program in Miami, Florida, as he awaits his August 2020 release, according to BOP inmate records.
Shana Madoff, Peter's Madoffs daughter, also worked for the firm, where she served as a compliance officer and in-
house counsel, according to the Bloomberg report. While she was initially sued for allegedly using client money to pay
off credit card bills and other expenses, the suit was later dropped. She was not criminally charged.
She met Eric Swanson, an attorney for the Securities and Exchange Commission, during the investigation into her uncle's
scheme, according to the report. The pair later married.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
General Crimes
Reynolds and Cohen
Pair busted by feds in sprawling Manhattan prostitution operation
NY Post
By Gabrielle Fonrouge and Ben Feuerherd
2/11/2020
A Colorado woman and an Israeli man were arrested by federal authorities for allegedly running a sprawling, high-end
prostitution ring that operated in Manhattan, authorities said Tuesday.

The suspects, Tracy Reynolds and Izhak Cohen, allegedly laundered more than $10 million through thousands of bank
accounts and financial institutions in the US and overseas, according to federal prosecutors from the Southern District 
of
New York.

Reynolds and Cohen allegedly set up their prostitution company, called "VIP Escorts," in 2012 and arranged for
prostitutes to meet clients in Manhattan and other areas across the country, prosecutors said in a statement.
After the prostitutes charged the clients thousands of dollars for sex work, they deposited their profits into thousands
of
different bank accounts controlled by Reynolds, authorities said.

More than $10 million in total was passed through accounts owned by Reynolds in the prostitution operation, according
to prosecutors.

Reynolds then allegedly passed more than $1 million to Cohen in Israel in small amounts to hide the transactions.
Reynolds was arrested in Florida Tuesday morning at Tampa International Airport while boarding a flight to Mexico.
Cohen was taken into custody by Israeli authorities, and federal authorities are seeking his extradition to the United
States.

They were each hit with money laundering and a conspiracy charge and face a maximum of 60 years in prison if
convicted.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Money Laundering and Transnational Criminal Enterprises
Ackerman
Feds Indict Crypto Scheme Operator In $33M Fraud
Law360
By Philip Rosenstein
2/11/2020
Law360 (February 11, 2020, 10:09 PM EST) -- Ohio resident Michael Ackerman was indicted in the Southern District of
New York on Tuesday for allegedly masterminding a scheme in which he raised more than $33 million from more than
150 investors by promoting a cryptocurrency trading algorithm he said would generate "extraordinary profits."
In addition to charges of wire fraud and money laundering brought by the U.S. attorney in the Southern District of New
York, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission filed civil
complaints against Ackerman.

"Today's arrest should remind would-be investors to take extreme caution and thoroughly vet investment opportunities,
especially when promised abnormally high rates of return," U.S. Attorney Geoffrey Berman said in a statement.
According to the SEC complaint, Ackerman ran his alleged fraud through two companies, Q3 Trading Club and Q3 I LP
from July 1, 2017, to at least Dec. 1, 2019. Ackerman's alleged victims were mostly physicians, according to the SEC.
"Many fraudsters take advantage of the trust that having something in common creates, such as a common profession,"
the SEC said in a press release.

"As alleged in our complaint, Ackerman lured investors, many in the medical rofession, into falsely believing that he
generated extraordinary profits from his algorithmic trading strategy,' director of the SEC's Miami
regional office, said in a statement. "Ackerman exploited popular interest in digital assets as a means to obtain 
millions
of dollars for his personal use."
The SEC complaint outlines that Ackerman told investors that he had created a trading algorithm that could take
advantage of volatility in the cryptocurrency market "while minimizing risks." After receiving at least $33 million in
investor funds, Ackerman only used up to $10 million of those funds to invest in cryptocurrencies, "and the profits
generated by the algorithm were minimal, at best."
In order to continue the fraud, Ackerman provided investors with false account balances for trading accounts and touted
15% profits in newsletters sent to investors, the SEC alleged in its complaint.

In fact, his companies' trading balances averaged at $1.7 million on a monthly basis, and he paid out around $4 million 
of
investor funds in undisclosed fees to himself and his associates, according to the SEC.
SEC is alleging securities fraud and misappropriation of funds.

According to the CFTC complaint, a total of more than $25 million of customer funds were transferred to personal bank
accounts held by Ackerman and his two partners, with Ackerman himself receiving over $7 million.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
The CFTC alleges violation of the Commodity Exchange Act.

"This case underscores, once again, that the commission will continue working with our regulatory partners to ensure
the integrity of our markets, including those involving digital assets," the CFTC's director of
enforcement, said in a statement. "Rooting out misconduct is essential to furthering the responsible development of
these innovative financial products."
Counsel for Ackerman did not respond to requests for comment.
Ackerman is represented by Lisa Braganca of Braganca Law.
of the U.S. Attorney's Office in the Southern District of New York
are in charge of the prosecution.
The SEC is represented by
The CFTC is represented by
The cases are USA v. Ackerman, case number 20 cr 93, SEC v. Ackerman, case number 1:20-cv-01181, and CFTC v.
Ackerman, case number 1:20-cv-01183, all in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Matters of Interest
Stone
Prosecutors quit amid escalating Justice Dept. fight over Roger Stone's prison term
The Washington Post
By Matt Zapotosky, Devlin Barrett, Ann E. Marimow and Spencer S. Hsu
2/11/2020
All four career prosecutors handling the case against Roger Stone withdrew from the legal proceedings Tuesday — and
one quit his job entirely — after the Justice Department signaled it planned to undercut their sentencing
recommendation for President Trump's longtime friend and confidant.

The sudden and dramatic moves came after prosecutors and their superiors had argued for days over the appropriate
penalty for Stone, and exposed what some career Justice Department employees say is a continuing pattern of the
historically independent law enforcement institution being bent to Trump's political will.
Almost simultaneously, Trump decided to revoke the nomination to a top Treasury Department post of his former U.S.
attorney in the District of Columbia, who had supervised the Stone case when it went to trial.
The cascade of controversy began Monday, when career prosecutors handling the case recommended that a judge
sentence Stone — convicted in November of obstructing Congress and witness tampering — to between seven and nine
years in federal prison.

Stone has been a friend and adviser to Trump since the 1980s and was a key figure in his 2016 campaign, working to
discover damaging information on Democratic opponent Hillary Clinton. His was the last conviction secured by special
counsel Robert S. Mueller Ill as part of the investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election. The president
suggested angrily on Twitter that Stone deserved more-lenient treatment.

"This is a horrible and very unfair situation," Trump wrote early Tuesday. "The real crimes were on the other side, as
nothing happens to them. Cannot allow this miscarriage of justice!"
Hours later, a senior Justice Department official told reporters that the agency's leadership was "shocked" by the
recommendation of a seven-to-nine-year sentence and would soon revise it.

"That recommendation is not what had been briefed to the department," the official said, speaking on the condition of
anonymity to discuss a sensitive case. "The department finds the recommendation extreme and excessive and
disproportionate to Stone's offenses."
One by one, the career prosecutors, two of whom had worked on Mueller's investigation, filed notices in court of their
intention to leave the case. Though none of the prosecutors gave a reason, their asking to do so was highly unusual and
suggested they could not ethically affix their names to the government's revised position.
Career Justice Department lawyers similarly moved in 2018 to withdraw from a case when the Trump administration
decided it would not defend the Affordable Care Act against a challenge to its constitutionality. One of those lawyers
resigned over the matter.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
a Justice Department spokeswoman, said that the White House did not communicate with the agency on
Monday or Tuesday about the Stone case, and that the decision to reverse course was made before Trump's tweet.
Trump told reporters later Tuesday, "I have not been involved in it at all," though in the same remarks he called the
career prosecutors' initial recommendation "an insult to our country."
"That was a horrible aberration. These are, I guess, the same Mueller people that put everybody through hell and I think
it was a disgrace," Trump said. "They ought to be ashamed of themselves."
He doubled down Tuesday evening on Twitter, alleging the prosecutors "cut and ran after being exposed for
recommending a ridiculous 9 year prison sentence to a man that got caught up in an investigation that was illegal, the
Mueller Scam." He also raised questions about the judge in the case.

one of the prosecutors on the Stone case, wrote in a court filing that he had resigned as an assistant
U.S. attorney, leaving government altogether. Three others —
filed notices with the judge saying "please notice the withdrawal" from the case.
a former member of Mueller's team, also indicated in a filing he was quitting his special assignment to the U.S.
attorney's office in the District, though a spokeswoman said he will remain an assistant U.S. attorney in Baltimore.
Through a spokeswoman,
immediately be reached.
declined to comment. Jed and Kravis also declined to comment could not
As the drama unfolded Tuesday afternoon, Trump also decided to withdraw his nomination of the District's former U.S.
attorney, Jessie K. Liu, to serve as Treasury Department undersecretary for terrorism and financial crimes, people
familiar with the matter-said. The withdrawal was first reported by Axios.

The reason for the withdrawal was not clear. Liu had left her U.S. attorney post last month in a somewhat unusual move,
because she had not yet received Senate confirmation for her new job. She was replaced on an interim basis by Timothy
Shea, a former counselor to Attorney General William P. Barr.

An administration official said Trump has been lobbied extensively against Liu by those who did not like how she
handled the U.S. attorney's office — particularly as it related to the Mueller probe. Several people familiar with the
matter said Liu had no role in Stone's sentencing recommendation, having left the office before it was sent to
supervisors for approval. Liu, whose confirmation hearing had been scheduled for Thursday, did not immediately
respond to requests for comment.

Former Justice Department officials and others characterized the department's abrupt shift on the Stone case as an
egregious example of the president and his attorney general manipulating federal law enforcement to serve their
political interests.

Senate Minority Leader Charles E. Schumer (D-N.Y.) asked the Justice Department's inspector general to investigate,
writing, "This situation has all the indicia of improper political interference in a criminal prosecution."
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
David Laufman, a former Justice Department official, called it a "shocking, cram-down political intervention" in the
criminal justice process.

"We are now truly at a break-glass-in-case-of-fire moment for the Justice Dept.," he wrote on Twitter.
Eric H. Holder Jr., attorney general under President Barack Obama, said it was "unprecedented, wrong and ultimately
dangerous."
Rep. Bill Pascrell Jr. (D-N.J.) said the move amounted to "obstruction of justice."
"We are seeing a full-frontal assault on the rule of law in America," Pascrell said. "Direct political interference in 
our
justice system is a hallmark of a banana republic. Despite whatever Trump, William Barr, and their helpers think, the
United States is a nation of laws and not an authoritarian's paradise."
In its revised sentencing recommendation, the Justice Department essentially took aim at its own line attorneys, saying
their previous guidance "could be considered excessive and unwarranted under the circumstances." The memorandum
was signed by Shea and his criminal division supervisor,
"Ultimately, the government defers to the Court as to what specific sentence is appropriate under the facts and
circumstances of this case;' they wrote.

The decision to file a new sentencing memo was made by officials in the attorney general's office and the deputy
attorney general's office, according to a senior Justice Department official. The official could not point to another
instance of Justice Department headquarters overruling and replacing a sentencing memorandum a day after a filing but
insisted it was not unusual for law enforcement officials to "correct the record."
"I don't think anyone thinks this went smoothly," the official said, while declining to discuss who knew what inside the
department about the Stone sentencing recommendation.

Like the original sentencing recommendation, the official said, the withdrawal of the Stone prosecution team came as a
surprise.

Barr has previously faced criticism for seeking to protect Trump and undercut the special counsel's work.
In perhaps the most notable instance, he sent Congress a letter before the special counsel's report was publicly
released, describing what he called the investigation's principal conclusions. Mueller, Barr wrote, did not find that 
the
Trump campaign coordinated with Russia to influence the 2016 election, and reached no conclusion on whether Trump
had obstructed justice. Barr wrote that he and then-Deputy Attorney General Rod J. Rosenstein reviewed the matter
and concluded there was insufficient evidence to make an obstruction case.

The bare-bones description so infuriated the special counsel's team that Mueller wrote to Barr to complain that the
attorney general's summary "did not fully capture the context, nature, and substance" of the Russia probe. Barr, though,
repeated his description at a news conference before Mueller's full report was released, drawing criticism that he was
trying to shape public opinion in a way favorable to Trump.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Mueller closed his office in May, though some members of his team stayed on special assignments to the U.S. attorney's
office in the District to handle cases — including Stone's — that were not resolved. People familiar with the matter say
there was tension between them and their supervisors on what penalty to recommend.
As Monday's court deadline neared for prosecutors to give a sentencing recommendation, it was still unclear what the
office would do, even after days of internal debates, according to people familiar with the matter who, like others, 
spoke
on the condition of anonymity to discuss internal deliberations.

Front-line prosecutors argued for a prison sentence on the higher end, while their bosses wanted to calculate the
guidelines differently to get to a lower sentence. The debate centered on whether they should seek more prison time
for obstruction that impedes the administration of justice, these people said.

In the end, the office filed a recommendation keeping with the line prosecutors' goals, and rejecting the lighter
recommendation sought by their superiors, the people said.

Hours before the filing was due Monday, Shea, the new head of the D.C. office and a former close adviser to Barr, had
not made a final decision on Stone's sentencing recommendation, they said.

A Justice Department official said senior leaders were led to believe it would be lighter than what was ultimately 
filed.
But some legal observers were skeptical, and the department declined to provide a more detailed account.
Stone is scheduled to be sentenced by Judge Amy Berman Jackson on Feb. 20.

Mary McCord, a former prosecutor and acting assistant attorney general for the department's national security division,
said that decisions related to the sentencing of such high-profile political figures would not be made without initial
consultation between a U.S. attorney's office and Justice Department headquarters, and that it was hard to imagine the
department was truly taken aback.

"There is no way you can come away from this with anything other than an impression that Justice is taking its orders
from the president and pandering to the president," McCord said. "This is causing lasting and long-term damage to the
department's reputation and credibility."
It can be common for prosecutors to disagree about sentencing recommendations, especially when it comes to
politically sensitive cases. It would have been unusual, however, for the U.S. attorney's office to endorse a sentence
below the guideline range after winning conviction at trial, according to former federal prosecutors.
In the initial 22-page sentencing recommendation, the career prosecutors wrote that a sentence of 87 to 108 months
"consistent with the applicable advisory Guidelines would accurately reflect the seriousness of [Stone's] crimes and
promote respect for the law."
were part of the U.S. attorney's office in the District were members of Mueller's
team on special assignment to the office. revealed the resignations in formal notices of withdrawal
from the Stone case. asked to withdraw but gave no immediate indication they were resigning from
the government.

=the head of the D.C. office's criminal division and also a career prosecutor, entered the case in their place.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Stone's defense on Monday asked for a sentence of probation, citing his age, 67, and lack of criminal history. They also
noted that of seven Mueller defendants who have been sentenced, only one faces more than a six-month term: former
Trump campaign chairman Paul Monoton e who is serving 7311 years.

Given the hardships and loss of professional standing suffered by Stone and his family, "No one could seriously contend
that a [reduced . . .1 sentence would cause anyone to walk away from these proceedings believing that one can commit
the offenses at issue here with impunity," defense attorneys Bruce S. Rogow, Robert C. Buschel and Grant J. Smith
wrote.

Federal sentencing guidelines are calculated using mathematical formulas. While prosecutors and defense lawyers make
recommendations based on their calculations, ultimately it is up to the judge to decide which factors to consider in
sentencing someone, and whether to adhere to the recommendation or depart.

In Stone's case, the prosecutors came up with a recommendation of seven to nine years based on a number of
aggravating factors including an alleged threat to harm a witness — to whom Stone sent the message "prepare to die"
— and because prosecutors decided Stone's conduct resulted in "substantial interference in the administration of
justice."
Under the federal sentencing guidelines' point system, those factors add years to Stone's prospective prison sentence.
Stone and the witness in question, both have maintained Stone's statement was not a threat of violence,
but part of Stone's history of making bombastic statements.

In their Monday filing, prosecutors argued that more time should be added to Stone's sentence because of his extensive
criminal conduct, which stretched over two years, and because they say he obstructed the prosecution of the case after
he was charged.

In a Tuesday filing from Shea and the government argued that those enhancements were overkill, noting that
Stone's victim has asked for leniency for him and did not view the statement as an actual threat. The new filing also
contended that the enhancements endorsed in the previous government filing were not in keeping with the sentences
generally doled out to nonviolent offenders.

Tuesday's filing suggested — but did not outright recommend — that a sentence of three to four years would be
reasonable, and "more in line with the typical sentences imposed in obstruction cases."
Prosecutors in another case brought by the special counsel's office, against Trump's first national security adviser,
Michael Flynn, also recently walked back a sentencing recommendation — though the move was subtle.
In early January, prosecutors recommended that Flynn, who pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI about his contacts with
Russia's ambassador to the U.S., be sentenced "within the Guidelines range" of zero to six months in prison. But in
another filing just weeks later, they made clear they agreed with Flynn "that a sentence of probation is a reasonable."
Prosecutors did not explain in the later filing why they emphasized probation as a reasonable sentence for Flynn. Both
documents were signed by career prosecutors — though-
not signed some later filings in the case. Flynn is now seeking to withdraw his guilty plea, alleging a variety of
government misconduct.
has
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Barr has been critical of the FBI's 2016 investigation into Trump's campaign that Mueller ultimately took over. When the
Justice Department inspector general found last year that the bureau had adequate cause to open the case, Barr issued
a remarkable public statement registering his disagreement. lie said the case was initiated "on the thinnest of 
suspicions
that, in my view, were insufficient to justify the steps taken."
"It is also clear that, from its inception, the evidence produced by the investigation was consistently exculpatory," he
added.

Barr has tasked the U.S. attorney in Connecticut with exploring the origins of the case, and current and former law
enforcement officials have expressed concern that it might be an effort to undercut an investigation because Trump did
not like it.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Trump attacks federal judge, prosecutors in Twitter tirade defending Roger Stone
The Washington Post
By Allyson Chiu
2/12/2020
As the fallout from the controversy surrounding Roger Stone's prison term continued Tuesday night, President Trump
defended his longtime confidant by firing off a barrage of heated tweets attacking the federal judge and prosecutors
involved in the case.

Over the course of roughly two hours, Trump cranked out six blasts about the handling of Stone's sentencing, including
one that targeted U.S. District Judge Amy Berman Jackson, who is presiding over the case.
He implied that Jackson harbored some broad bias, linking the Stone case to her role in the sentencing of his former
campaign chairman Paul Manafort and her dismissal of a lawsuit against former secretary of state Hillary Clinton related
to Benghazi, Libya.

"Is this the Judge that put Paul Manafort in SOLITARY CONFINEMENT, something that not even mobster Al Capone had
to endure?" Trump wrote, sharing another tweet that named Jackson. "How did she treat Crooked Hillary Clinton? Just
asking!"
Jackson is scheduled to sentence Stone, who was convicted in November of lying to Congress and witness tampering, on
Feb. 20.

The timing of Tuesday's online attack prompted many to accuse Trump, who has a long history of mounting public
crusades against judges and courts over unfavorable rulings, of attempting to intimidate Jackson and secure a more
lenient sentence for Stone.
The White House did not respond to a request for comment late Tuesday.

Trump's fusillade of tweets came shortly after news broke that the Justice Department had overruled the sentencing
recommendation for Stone submitted by federal prosecutors, an action that followed Trump blasting it as too harsh.
The prosecutors, citing federal sentencing guidelines, said Stone should serve seven to nine years in federal prison.
In an early-morning tweet Tuesday, Trump lambasted the proposed punishment as "a miscarriage of justice!" Hours
later, the Justice Department announced that it would be revising the recommended prison term — a stunning decision
that sparked widespread concern about the president undermining the traditional independence of the agency when it
comes to individual prosecutions. (The Justice Department said it did not communicate with the White House about
Stone's case this week and Trump told reporters Tuesday that he has "not been involved in it at all," The Washington
Post reported.)
The growing scrutiny of Trump's perceived effect on the Stone case did little to keep him from weighing in again Tuesday
night.

Amid slinging barbs at 2020 Democratic presidential candidates battling it out in the New Hampshire primary, Trump
was in full attack mode as he griped about the original sentencing recommendation and demanded to know the
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
identities of the prosecutors behind it. All four prosecutors withdrew from the case, with one quitting his job, 
following
Tuesday's events.

"Who are the four prosecutors (Mueller people?) who cut and ran after being exposed for recommending a ridiculous 9
year prison sentence to a man that got caught up in an investigation that was illegal, the Mueller Scam, and shouldn't
ever even have started?" Trump tweeted, referencing the Russia investigation overseen by special counsel Robert S.
Mueller III that led to Stone's conviction.

In a later tweet, Trump appeared to suggest that he was considering the possibility of pardons for Stone and former
national security adviser Michael T. Flynn, who pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI during the Mueller investigation.
Many seemed to be most taken aback by Trump's tweet about Jackson, including Clinton, his Democratic opponent in
2016.

In the tweet, Trump questioned Jackson's treatment of Clinton, probably referencing her dismissal in 2017 of a wrongful
death claim brought against the former secretary of state in connection with Benghazi. The suit alleged that Clinton's
use of a private email server caused the deaths of two Americans at the U.S. diplomatic compound in the Libyan city.
Stone also tried to bring attention to the lawsuit last year when he shared an inflammatory Instagram post targeting
Jackson, which earned him a harsh scolding from the judge.

"Do you realize intimidating judges is the behavior of failed-state fascists?" Clinton tweeted Tuesday in response to
Trump.

Trump has repeatedly gone after judges who rule against him and questioned the judiciary's constitutional authority.
The president's pattern of attacks have been condemned by lawyers and law professors, who have called his rants
"worse than wrong" and "dangerous."
His frequent references to "Obama judges" prompted Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. to issue a rare rebuke of the
president in 2018.

Trump has repeatedly gone after judges who rule against him and questioned the judiciary's constitutional authority.
The president's pattern of attacks have been condemned by lawyers and law professors, who have called his rants
"worse than wrong" and "dangerous."
His frequent references to "Obama judges" prompted Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. to issue a rare rebuke of the
president in 2018.

On Tuesday, Trump's swipe at Jackson was similarly received. People rushed to fact-check the tweet and denounced
Trump for "siccing his 70 million Twitter followers" on Jackson, as one person put it. Within moments of the tweet
getting posted, Trump's supporters were already chiming in, calling Jackson "truly evil" and slamming her as "a far-left
activist Judge."
But, the tweet misrepresented Jackson's involvement in the Manafort case since the judge only sentenced Trump's
former campaign manager to 7% years and was not responsible for the conditions of his confinement while awaiting
trial.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Meanwhile, Trump resumed tweeting early Wednesday morning about the case, praising Attorney General William P.
Barr and railing against "Rogue prosecutors."
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
Weinstein
Is Harvey Weinstein a rapist? As trial concludes, jury will be faced with a complicated case and a heavy task.
The Washington Post
By Shayna Jacobs
2/12/2020
NEW YORK — Allegations of sexual assault and harassment against Harvey Weinstein helped kick-start a cultural
movement in late 2017.

But did the high-powered producer, who was cast out of Hollywood high society in the wake of the many accusations
against him, commit a crime?
That's the heavy question a Manhattan jury will face early next week as Weinstein's headline-making trial nears its 
close.
The jury of seven men and five women is set to begin deliberations after the Presidents' Day long weekend.
The jury has sat through about three weeks of testimony from 28 prosecution witnesses and another seven called by
Weinstein's legal team. Weinstein was not one of them. Though he was inclined to testify, he took the advice of his
attorneys to rest the case in silence. Lawyers consider it a risky prospect for a defendant to testify in any case.
"He was ready, able and anxious to testify to clear his name, to clear the facts of this case," Weinstein lawyer Arthur
Aidala told reporters on Tuesday. Aidala said Weinstein was advised by counsel that "he did not need to (testify)
because the evidence presented in this case was anemic at best."
"If his name was not Harvey Weinstein and was John Doe, the Manhattan District Attorney's Office would have never
brought these charges," Aidala said.
With jury deliberations near, here's how the trial has played out so far.
the alleged victims
was the first to take the witness stand. In a break from custom at the New York Supreme Court building in
Manhattan, the victim was not shielded from news cameras that lined the hallway outside the
courtroom.
In her testimony, the story was rehashed in meticulous detail.

aid she met Weinstein early in her career at a party in Los Angeles. Their professional lives intertwined when
she starred
Weinstein told he would only produce the film if he could cast her as the female lead, a role slated for Sarah
Jessica Parker, according to the accuser's testimony. found herself at dinners and events with Weinstein around
that time.

does not recall the date of her alleged rape, but testified it was late 1993 or early 1994. She said she went
upstairs to the 17th-story unit rental she was subleasing but was met with an interruption as she got ready for bed.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
"There was a knock on the door," she testified, telling jurors she had already changed into a white nightgown
I opened the door to see who it was thinking it was a neighbor or the doorman."
Weinstein "was there and he pushed the door open. I didn't have an opportunity to understand why he was there and
he started to walk in. .. . In hindsight I think he was looking to see if there was somebody else there, and he started 
to
unbutton his shirt and I then realized that he thought we were going to be having sex," said.
described being physically overpowered by Weinstein after telling him to leave.

"What were you trying to do to get him off?" Assistant District Attorney -asked her.
"Punching him, kicking him, just trying to get him away from me,"Msaid in emotional testimony on Jan. 23. He
pinned her hands above her head and forced penetration, the witness said, fighting the emotion welling up inside of her.
In response to her powerful testimony, lawyers for Weinstein called two witnesses they hoped would dilute her
credibility.
One was vho said she told him around that time that she did something
"crazy" with Weinstein. He said he understood it to mean some kind of consensual "hookup."
But also proved to be a loyal friends to Weinstein, admitting he's been a recent source of support to the
defendant at a time when he has few confidants, and that he hasn't talked to in years.
Another defense witness, is a manager at Sciorra's old building. He said a doorman is on duty 24 hours a
day. Prosecutors have suggested Weinstein paid one off to get upstairs unannounced, or went upstairs unnoticed. "I
don't think they could be bribed," said of his staff.
In 2006, she said she was invited to Weinstein's hotel room at the Cannes Film
Festival to discuss possible jobs. When she got there, he requested a massage.

"I was extremely humiliated and just felt very stupid that I had been so excited to go and see him and that he treated 
me
that way," a tearful said.

A Weinstein deputy offered her a $125-per-day temp job working on the TV show "Project Runway" in New York.
Around this time he invited her for drinks and tried to talk her into a trip to Paris with him on a private jet, which 
she
declined. She accepted an offer to go to Los Angeles, but on a commercial flight. On the eve of that trip, testified,
she was assaulted. She went to his SoHo apartment "to stop by and say hi. I had no reason not to," she testified. "It
would have been odd to decline when I had accepted to go to L.A."
described him turning what was "normal conversation" into an unwanted advance.

"I just kind of tried to reject him and push him away; and he would just pull me back and keep kissing and fondling me
. . . I was walking backwards trying to get away, but he would just come at me," the witness said.
"I don't want this to happen," she said, according to the testimony. "I'm on my period."
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
"He held me down on the bed and he forced himself on me orally," the witness said, blotting tears from her reddening
face during her testimony. "I was on my period, I had a tampon in there . . . I was mortified."
admitted to having a sexual encounter with Weinstein a short time after.
"I didn't resist physically," she said of the encounter. "I just laid there."
The trial's most dramatic moments were during questioning of a woman who carried on a five-year
consensual relationship with him. Prosecutors tried to build an image ofMas a "naive" girl from rural Washington
state.

She testified that Weinstein raped her twice — although Weinstein has only been charged in the 2013,
alleged incident at the Doublelree hotel on Lexington Avenue in New York.

Her testimony, spanning three days with about 10 hours of brutal cross-examination, was at times baffling. She insisted
she was repulsed by Weinstein but had "compassion" for him after seeing what she described as a deformed body and
genitals.

story is the most complicated. Years of email records show an ongoing flirtation and an affectionate vibe with
Weinstein. She testified that she also thought of him as a father figure.

-dmitted she couldn't pin down when a second alleged rape at the Peninsula hotel in Los Angeles would have
happened.

For jurors to convict Weinstein on predatory sexual assault, he needs to be found guilty of attacking
and/or
The three additional accusers and their impact on the trial
Weinstein faces individual counts of rape and criminal sex act. He's charged with raping in 2013 and with forcing a
sex act on in 2006.= whose allegations were considered by prosecutors to be time-barred from being
charged as its own criminal act, is represented by a pair of predatory sexual assault counts.
Weinstein faces the most time in prison — a minimum of a decade and up to life — on those charges.
The three main accusers were supported by three more alleged victims, allowed by the judge to help prosecutors show
what they say is a history of bad conduct. Jurors have been told that testimony from
has limited value. Weinstein's legal team has argued from the start that their testimony is prejudicial.
was an aspiring actress who met Weinstein while waitressing at a trendy lounge. She said she grew to trust
Weinstein, who invited her to industry events. She was glad to have a powerful connection in the business. said
she was in a Weinstein business suite at a New York hotel in 2004 when she was summoned alone to his bedroom
where she alleges that he reached up her skirt.
SDNY News Clips, Wednesday, February 12, 2020
a model and former cocktail waitress a said Weinstein masturbated in front of her after
taking her to a secluded landing during one of her shifts. She testified that she stepped out of the venue with him
because he said she had a "great look" and suggested he could help her get acting gigs.
The witness, also testified that she was sent in 2005 from his office (where she thought she was reading a
script) to Weinstein's Crosby Street apartment. There, she said, he raped her after telling her not to worry because 
he's
"had a vasectomy."
said the Miramax founder and an accomplice "trapped" her in a Montage hotel suite in Los
Angeles in 2013. Weinstein groped her and pleasured himself, she said. is one of the two victims who are part of a
case against Weinstein in Los Angeles for rape and sexual assault; those charges against him were announced on Jan. 6,
the day his New York trial officially started.

His lawyers argued it was a "coordinated" effort to smear him before jury selection.
What's on the line for the Manhattan district attorney?
The case is high-stakes for the Manhattan district attorney, who has taken heat over his office's handling of sex 
crimes.
Cyrus Vance Jr. has personally been in the courtroom for almost the entirety of the trial, intently watching his
prosecutors in action.

Vance's office was widely criticized for declining to charge Weinstein in 2015 after
said the producer groped her at his Tribeca office. She confronted Weinstein and recorded their interaction, where he
can be heard apologizing on the tape.

Vance has also been under scrutiny recently for his handling of a sex abuser gynecologist, Columbia University doctor
Robert Hadden. Hadden was allowed to take a jail-free plea deal in 2016 even though at least 20 women, many of whom
were pregnant, have stories of being sexually abused in the exam room by him. One is
Vance is up for reelection next year. Several challengers are already campaigning. Many in the city's legal community
speculate that his decision to seek or decline to seek reelection will be based on the outcome of the case. A Vance
spokesperson declined to comment on whether his decision will be tied to the Weinstein outcome.
EFTA00158608 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Interlochen Center for the Arts related
(date: 2020-03-11)
FD-302 (Rea. 5-S-10) -1 of 6 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Plaza, New York, New York.
AUSA
Special Agent
above listed individuals
following information:
O•notaL Amato
Nftolinry  03/11//020
, was interviewed at One Saint Andrews
Present for the interview was AUSA
AUSA Detective , and
After being advised of the identities of the
and the nature of the interview, provided the
attended INTERLOCHEN in approximately'''.
In IIIII attended
but was not sure if also attended.
and in the summer of at INTERLOCHEN  was when first
started talking about a man (JEFFREY EPSTEIN) for whom she had a sense of
admiration.
EPSTEIN approached at the picnic tables. told
the day of or shortly after she met EPSTEIN. would have been 14 years
bwasaicem 01/14/2020 al New York, New York, United States (In Person)
Fie M SOD-NY-3027571 Dine drafted 01/16/2020
by
This docusnein cowmen neither iecommendations DIX COW IUNIOM of the FBI It is the piopcity of the FBI and is loaned to 
yoga agency. it and its contents ate on
to be clistnbuted outside you agent ,:
3510-001
Page I of 6
FD-302a (Rev. 54.10)
SOD-NY -3027571
Conitnuation olTD-302 or  (U) Interview of El 0, 01/14/2020 jaw 2 of 6
old when she met EPSTEIN. III did not recall if referred to him as
"JEFFREY" or "JEFFREY EPSTEIN". It became clear that EPSTEIN lived in Palm
Beach, which was a "cool coincidence". III did not recall the first time
he met EPSTEIN. The first memory III had of meeting EPSTEIN was in
at a movie theater. III met EPSTEIN, and and
GHISLAINE MAXWELL were also present. III assumed that MAXWELL was
EPSTEIN's girlfriend/partner. III did not remember if that was the first
time he met EPSTEIN, but did recall that it was the first time that he met
MAXWELL. When III met MAXWELL, he was approximatelyillyears old, while
was 15 years old. III did not recall meeting EPSTEIN while at
INTERLOCHEN, so assumed he met EPSTEIN for the first time in Palm Beach.
III assumed EPSTEIN just started hanging out with or she was going to
his house.
The second or third year at INTERLOCHEN, III and
stayed at EPSTEIN's cabin at INTERLOCHEN. EPSTEIN was not there
when they stayed. EPSTEIN communicated to that they could stay there.
told III that MAXWELL had told her, "Oh I would teach your brother
a thing or two".
EPSTEIN was a "godfather figure" and wanted to help EPSTEIN
wanted to do a lot of nice things
heard this from and III reported that it never felt
weird, but now looking back it does. III recalled that was going to
EPSTEIN's home days/weeks/months after first meeting EPSTEIN. III felt that
it was pretty soon after camp. III felt that had gone over in the day
time. III did not think had stayed the night at EPSTEIN's home, but
she could have. EPSTEIN sent a driver, who III described as a very nice
Latin man. III only remembered EPSTEIN's driver because he was very
friendly. They talked about Latin music together. III could not recall his
name.
When III and his family had moved to another house in approximately
he recalled answering the phone and EPSTEIN was on the other
line. always told them to be polite. EPSTEIN was always curt
and to the point saying something like, "Can I speak to please?". III
spoke to EPSTEIN on the phone a handful of times and it was always the
same. III did not remember if he talked with MAXWELL on the phone.
3510-001
Page 2 of 6
ED-302a (Rev. 54.10)
SOD —NY-3027571
commumionormmor  (U) Interview of III 0, 01/14/2020page 3 of 6
When III met EPSTEIN in person, EPSTEIN seemed weird; EPSTEIN was in
sweatpants and seemed like a homeless person. had told III at some
point that she remembered EPSTEIN having dinner at their home; III did not
remember this but thought it would have made sense because had
people over all the time.
went to in approximately for her
year of high school. Before she left for her year, told -
about EPSTEIN's house. would have been when she told him
this. III did not know who made travel arrangements for ; he did not
know if they were commercial or private. III recalled that
IM has
spoken to over the years about it. III recalled
said she went with to buy a dress EPSTEIN's
New York City house had seven stories; talked about the house. -
felt that MAXWELL always traveled with and EPSTEIN. mentioned
MAXWELL a lot. would go to events and places with EPSTEIN and
MAXWELL; talked with III about it. III remembered that had told
him that she met DONALD TRUMP at MAR-A-LAGO in approximatelyIIIIIIIIII
told III about this meeting at the time it happened. III felt that he
met EPSTEIN and MAXWELL a couple times. III remembered approximately 10
years ago seeing EPSTEIN's face in the media. III recognized him so he
believed that he had met EPSTEIN more than once.
In approximately told him to write music for
EPSTEIN's birthday. III spent six hours writing music, titled "Fanfare for
Jeffrey".
EPSTEIN purchased III and his family a computer that was delivered to
their home by his driver. III thought this happened shortly after
INTERLOCHEN. III thought it was used before EPSTEIN gave it to them. This
is the only thing III remembered receiving from EPSTEIN. III seemed to
think that there was no doubt that received gifts from EPSTEIN; III
thought this made sense that EPSTEIN would do this. III had no specific
memory of receiving a gift. told III that she had been to
EPSTEIN's New Mexico ranch.
III has had conversations with over the years where
that EPSTEIN gave large amounts of cash.
told him
3510-0)1
Page 3 of 6
FD-302a (Rev. 54.10)
SOD-NY -3027571
ConlimmtionorM302or  (U) Interview of III .O, 01/14/2020 .Pag,• 4 of 6
When III was in New York City, he stayed in an
apartment in Manhattan owned by EPSTEIN for a couple of days. III did not
know how he was able to stay at EPSTEIN's apartment. There was a friendly
door man, who III thought may have given him a key; III thought the doorman
may have told him that he was friends with EPSTEIN. While in the apartment,
a girl walked in and introduced herself as-. did not know
III was staying there. III was 19 years old when he met who was 23
years old. When walked in, she told him that she worked for EPSTEIN.
III had not seen in over a decade when she reached out. III saw
her in in November 2019. III told that they needed to talk
about EPSTEIN. told III that she was surprised it took him so long
to ask about EPSTEIN. III asked if she knew, and told him
no. told III that this situation has ruined her life and that
had written a book with in it. III believed
when she said that she did not know the extent of what EPSTEIN was doing.
was paid to work for EPSTEIN; she was basically a slave. met
BILL CLINTON with MAXWELL present. CLINTON asked , "What do you
do?". MAXWELL told CLINTON that was her slave. told III that
she knew nothing about what has been reported about EPSTEIN. III had wanted
to talk to because he knew she had worked for EPSTEIN and figured
that had to have known something. Throughout friendship over
the years with , they never talked about EPSTEIN and MAXWELL.
told III that she was MAXWELL's assistant and described herself as MAXWELL'S
slave.
III did not exchange emails with EPSTEIN, nor has he been to any of
EPSTEIN's other properties. told III recently that she had been to
EPSTEIN's Palm Beach house. III felt tha had been to EPSTEIN's
Palm Beach house but was not sure.
When III saw the news reports, he thought that there was no way something
had not happened to told him that she had taken out
for lunch and told that she knew something had happened to her,
telling her that she knew she was raped. At first, denied it to
then she broke down.
Approximately 10 years ago when the investigation of EPSTEIN first came
in the news, subtly mentioned what happened to her. never
3510-001
Pagc4of6
FD-302a (Rev. 54.10)
SOD —NY-3027571
cominumionorm3o2or  (U) Interview of III On 01/14/2020 paw 5 of 6
overtly told III and III never asked. There was a lot that was implied.
III thought that he had asked her if she was ok, and replied, "How do
you think I feel; I was raped by a pedophile for years". has opened
up more in recent years.
In the early 2000's, when , a massage
therapist came to give him a massage. This masseuse worked for EPSTEIN.
EPSTEIN was still very much in life at this time.
III did not remember if he had talked with in person or over the
phone when the investigation all came out. III did text when EPSTEIN
died, telling her that EPSTEIN was now out of her life. III then realized
that was not true, that things were just beginning.
When
told him that EPSTEIN co-signed for their lease.
When they sublet the apartment, the person
did not pay the rent and EPSTEIN contacted and told her that she
needed to take care of it.
said that EPSTEIN paid for INTERLOCHEN.
Early on, had respect for EPSTEIN; she loved how smart he was.
EPSTEIN said things like, "An ozone repairs itself before a man could
ruin". III did not know what the turning point was for
would say that it was the lunch she had with that was her turning
point.
3510-0)1
Pagc5of6
FD-302a (Rev. 54.10)
SOD —NY-3027571
commumionorED402or  (U) Interview of III 0, 01/14/2020 Pag,• 6 of 6
The news outlets were blackmailing saying that she needed to give
an interview or they would write whatever they wanted. III thought that she
may have paid an attorney to make the media go away.
III recalled seeing a
saying that a woman name was raped.
expressed that she did not want this to ruin her life. III told
that he would support her in whatever she decided. This conversation
happened approximately six months prior to this interview.
3510-001
Pagc6of6
EFTA00064309 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of MCC camera technician, "Only one hard drive of the camera system was working at the time of [Epstein's death]", see 
quote: "advised that he knew that by replacing both hard drives, the system would be wiped"
(date: 2020-03-12)
FD-302 (Rev.5-8-I0)   -1 of 2 -     OFFICIAL RECORD
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  03/04/2021

On March 12, 2020, <REDACTED> , date of birth , telephone
number was interviewed by Assistant United States Attorney
<REDACTE>, Task Force Officer Detective and Special
Agent <REDACTED> at the United States Attorneys Office (USAO), Southern
New York (SDNY), 1 St. Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. During
the interview, <REDACTED> provided the following details:

<REDACTED> started working for the Bureau of Prisons (BOP) in 2003 and worked
in both New York and Indiana. <REDACTED> had some college education, was with
the <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>, and had 10 years experience in
electronics.

In 2016, <REDACTED> was put in charge of all the cameras at the Metropolitan
Correctional Center (MCC). advised that the cameras at MCC were out
of date, the recorders frequently went bad, and the cameras were all
analog and not maintained properly. The camera system was over 20 years old.
Sometimes the screen would be active indicating that the camera was working,
however, the video would not be recording.

<REDACTED> advised that only one hard drive of the camera system was working
at the time of the incident on August 10, 2019. When a DVR went bad, none of
the cameras recorded. There was a system failure of DVR 2 on July 29, 2019
and the motherboard failed on DVR 2 on August 8, 2019. The hard
drive failure occurred on August 10, 2019.

<REDACTED> recalled that there was a body alarm around 6am on August 10, 2019
and he was one of the MCC personnel who responded. stated that he was
one of the personnel who briefly tried to resuscitate JEFFREY EPSTEIN.
After the incident, was asked about the cameras. There were two
new hard drives to install but installing the new hard drives would mean
that all prior data would be lost. The Warden wanted video and so <REDACTED> was

Investigation on 03/12/2020 at New York, New York, United States (In Person)
File # 90A-NY-3151227                      Date drafted 03/04/2021
by <REDACTED>

SDNY_00018001

told to start working on the in order to rebuild the DVR. <REDACTED> started removing the bad drives
in order to rebuild the DVR. <REDACTED> advised that an FBI Agent was the one who pulled out the DVR.
<REDACTED> also advised that he knew that by replacing both hard drives, the system would be wiped
and that he had advised personnel at MCC of that.
EFTA02731524 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2020-03-18)
LISTON ABRAMSON New York Office
Main -
The Chrysler Building Invidesrontmson.com
405 Lexingron Avenue. 46th Floor
New York. New York 10174
PERSONAL AND CONFIDENTIAL
March 6, 2020
VI.A FEDERAI. EXPRESS
l.con Black
Re:
Dear Mr. Black:
As noted in our letter dated February 18, 2020 (copy enclosed), has
retained our firm to investigate certain matters related to your prior interactions with her and to
advise and represent her in connection with same.
To assist our firm in that regard, I once again request that you provide to my firm copies
of any and all written agreements entered into between you and Ms.
I look forward to hearing from you, or from counsel on your behalf, by the close of
business Wednesday, March 18, 2020, via phone at , via email at
, or at the above mailing address.
Sincerely,
Enclosure
David G. Liston
EFTA01255984 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2020-03-29)
RPTXD: 168.9010D0
DATE: 07/12/2017
ACCOUNT RR I/O C/W DESCRIPTION
INCOMING/OUTGOING WIRES,CHECKS AND ACH REPORT
IBD: 6XE OFF: N4G
ADDITIONAL INFO BENEFICIARIES
ISSUER NA
PAGE: 1
NET AMOUNT
J 0 W
J 0 W
J I W
SIGNATURE BANK
NEW YORK NY
JPMORGAN CHASE BANK, NA
NEW YORK NY
SIGNATURE BANK
565 FIFTH AVENUE
NEW YORK NY 10017
1502370704
LJJ NYC MULTI -FAMILY REAL ESTA
1024 BROADWAY
WOODMERE NY 11598
510 MADISON AVE 8TH
FLOORE NEW YORKEY
6X
FORTRESS VALUE
RECOVERY FUND I LLC
DISTRIBUTION DATED
07 07 2017 6X
SIGNATURE BANK..
FIFTH AVENUE NEW
YORK NY 10017
VOID
/REC/PERSHING LLC
//101 BARCLAY STREET
//NEW YORK NY 10286
GER CAPITAL
GLENN DUBIN AND EVA ANDERSSON-DUBIN
REC PERSHING LLC
1/101 BARCLAY STREET
//NEW YORK NY 10286
FFC BUTENHOFF FAMILY LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP
BEY COST RRN - 0/8 SIGNATURE BA
1750000.00
46853.96
9756.10
SIGNATURE BANK
J I C CHECK RECEIVED WESTHOFF 10000.00
0 W 32-52 61ST STREET HSBC HONG KONG SWIFT: HMICIDCHEMBH 1300.00
HSBC BANK USA, NA
BUFFALO NY
1ST FLOOR WOODSIDE
NY 11377-2030 6%
HONG KONG
MAK SHUN LINO
A 0 C CHECK NUMBER - 0369 862.50
A 0 C 186.60 CHECK NUMBER - 0373
I W GB REVOCABLE TRUST FFC: ACCT 3910.00 DEUTSCHE
STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMPANY PARK AVENUE
1 LINCOLN ST FL 1 NEW YORK NY 10154 BNY COST RRN -
BOSTON MA 02111
33451025.1
VOID
/REC/PERSHIIIG
GB REVOCABLE TRUST FFC: ACCT
N40030502
GB REVOCABLE TRUST
2020 ROCKWOOD
SACRAMENTO CA 95864
BNY GUST RRN -
8 I W DEUTSCHE
STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMPANY BANK 345 PARK AVENUE
1 LINCOLN ST FL 1
BOSTON MA 02111
33451958.2
PATRICK J. MCADARAGH REVOCABLE TRUS
15465 LUCERNE CIRCLE
BURNSVILLE MN 55306
NEW YORK NY 10154
VOID
/REC/PERSHINO LLC
STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMPANY
PATRICK J MCADARAGH REVOCABLE
TRUSTFFC: ACCT
BNY CUST RRN -
PATRICK J MrADADArH REVOCABLE
TRUSTFFC: AC=
BHT COST RRN - I
STATE STREET BANK AND TRUST COMPANY
90000.00
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(fc ONFIDENTIAL
DB-SONY-0028476
EFTA00029432 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2020-04-02 12:21:16)
Event: Accepted: Jeffrey Epstein Estate/Southern Country International
Bank/USVI
Start Date: 2020-04-03 15:00:00 +0000
End Date: 2020-04-03 16:00:00 +0000
Location: Conference Line Call-In (see below)
Class: X-PERSONAL
Comment:
Date Created: 2020-04-02 12:21:16 +0000
Date Modified: 2020-04-02 12:21:16 +0000
Priority: 5
DTSTAMP: 2020-04-02 12:06:08 +0000
Attendee: (USAVI) <
EFTA02731200 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ memo about potential prosecution of Epstein's assistant
(inferred date: 2020-04-14)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
Privileged and Confidential -- Attorney Work Product
Do Not Disseminate Outside of the SDNY USAO
USAO # United States v. 20 Cr. ( ) April 14, 2020

This memorandum addresses the investigation into <REDACTED> who worked as
an assistant to Jeffrey Epstein. In particular. this memorandum analyzes a potential prosecution
against <REDACTED> for participating in a sex trafficking conspiracy with Epstein. <REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

Page 2
This memorandum incorporates the Prosecution Memo regarding Jeffrey Epstein.
dated June 17, 2019 (the "Epstein Memo"). and the Investigation Update Memo dated December
19, 2019 (the "Update Memo"). but also includes a brief summary of the facts relevant here.

I. Overview of The Scheme

From at least 1994 through approximately 2005, Epstein engaged in a pattern of
enticing minor girls to engage in illicit sex acts, including by engaging in paid sex acts between
approximately 2002 and 2005. This conduct is roughly divided into two time periods and courses
of conduct: First, starting approximately no later than 1994, Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell, his
romantic and business partner, groomed and ultimately abused a relatively small number of
victims, including <REDACTED> in the course of longer-term abuse. This grooming and abuse
included befriending <REDACTED> and bestowing generalized financial benefits separate from
payment for particular sex acts, as well as regular travel with <REDACTED>.

Second. starting in approximately 2002. this pattern changed significantly, when a few
of Epstein's initial victims began to recruit local girls and women to provide Epstein with
"massages" that would include sex acts. Epstein would pay both the participant and the recruiter
on a per-session basis. At this time, which also was approximately when Maxwell became less
involved in Epstein's daily life, the girls who began to provide sexualized massages to Epstein
themselves began to recruit friends and acquaintances, who recruited their own friends, leading to
the "pyramid scheme" operation for which we charged Epstein with sex trafficking in 2019.

When victims visited Epstein's residences, they usually were contacted via telephone
by individuals who worked for Epstein to arrange additional massages. In New York, the primary
scheduler was Leslie Groff, one of Epstein's assistants, who worked at an office off-site from the
E stein's mansion in New York (the "New York Residence"). In Florida. the primary contact was
<REDACTED> who began working as Epstein's travelin assistant in <REDACTED>; another contact for
sc ing for certain Florida victims was <REDACTED> during her employment as another
traveling assistant to Epstein <REDACTED>. Groff does not appear to have ever been present
when victims arrived for massages in New York: <REDACTED> both were regularly present at
Epstein's Florida estate (the "Florida Residence") when girls amved, and they would sometimes
escort the girls to Epstein's massage room there.

In order to maintain a steady stream of underage girls to perform sexual acts, Epstein
also directed many of his victims to recruit other girls to engage in massages, including as
conveyed through his assistants. Some victims brought just one or two friends, while others
become prolific recruiters, bringing Epstein dozens of other girls. Epstein typically paid the
recruiters hundreds of dollars for each girl they brought tilein's residences, and those
payments also were sometimes made by employees including <REDACTED> and <REDACTED>.

While our Office's charges against Epstein principally focused on conduct occurring
in New York or with connections to New York—and <REDACTED> did contact victims for schedulin
purposes while she was physiairiesent in Manhattan— e investigation as it related to <REDACTED>
largely focuses on Florida. <REDACTED> was primarily responsible for scheduling at the F on
Residence, where she also sometimes met and/or paid certain minor victims.
Page 3

II. Summary of Personal Background and Employment with Epstein

We have learned about <REDACTED> background and employment with Epstein through our
investigation, including from numerous interviews with victims and other Epstein employees;
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>; and two proffers with <REDACTED> herself. We do not have
reason to dispute the below information,derived from those sources, ess otherwise specified.

1. Upbringing, marriage, and early employment

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> was raised in a conservative
<REDACTED> community, an her experiences as a child likely made her
unusua y susceptible to abuse and manipulation by Epstein. In particular,<REDACTED> credibly
describes having been sexually abused well before meeting Epstein <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED> and marriage the following year, after which <REDACTED> moved <REDACTED> from
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED> Afterward she sought employment <REDACTED> working part time jobs
at <REDACTED>. She also pursued modeling jobs which had been suggested to her by <REDACTED>
and others since she was younger. In connection with those attempts, following
<REDACTED> divorce she briefly lived with a much-older photographer who also sexually exploited
her. <REDACTED> then moved to <REDACTED>to take a job at <REDACTED>during which time she was in debt
and largely socially isolated. Shortly thereafter, a colleague <REDACTED> who knew Epstein
suggested to him as a prospective assistant in approximately 2001.

2. Initial Employment with Epstein

In fall 2001, Epstein flew <REDACTED> to his private island in the U.S. Virgin Islands
("USW) and then to New York for an Muction, and shortly thereafter brought her to Florida
for an unpaid "training" period to be a traveling personal assistant to Epstein. Initially, <REDACTED>
believed she would primarily be working for Maxwell, and her initial "training" was with Maxwell
and <REDACTED>. who was then Maxwell's assistant and who returned to her native England
shorty after <REDACTED> was hired. Although <REDACTED>initially answered to both Maxwell and Epstein,
early in her interactions with them it became clear to her that she would work primarily for Epstein,
though she also was expected to perform tasks assigned by Maxwell.

1 <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

Page 4

Following her travel to the island, <REDACTED> worked as an unpaid assistant for several
months, during which Epstein escalated sexual comments and behavior. This culminated with
Epstein directing <REDACTED> to join him in a bath and telling her she had the job and "now [needed] to
keep it." In the initia months of <REDACTED> employment, among other tasks, she was instructed by
Epstein and Maxwell that Epstein received regular massages, and it was <REDACTED> responsibility to
schedule those massages in Florida. She did so by calling individuals w ose names and phone
numbers were maintained in a written and electronically-stored list. During this time, in 2001 and
2002, <REDACTED> reports that Maxwell became significantly less of a regular presence with Epstein,
which is consistent with the accounts of other individuals who interacted with Epstein at that time,
including numerous victims we have interviewed. <REDACTED> describes having limited interactions
with Maxwell, and being afraid of and intimidated by er. This is consistent with the accounts of
victims from that period, most of whom regularly interacted with <REDACTED> but never met or even
saw Maxwell.

In the subsequent months and years, <REDACTED> tasks as an assistant for Epstein were
wide-ranging and largely menial, including but not limited to packing for Epstein's trips; making
his bed and doing laundry; purchasing, stocking, and preparing food; massaging Epstein's feet and
shoulders at his direction; organizing social events with academic and finance luminaries;
purchasing and categorizing various household items for each of Epstein's several properties;
running errands and carrying purchases for Epstein and Maxwell; making personal appointments,
including doctor, dentist, and personal trainer visits; and various household administrative tasks.
<REDACTED> also scheduled many of the massages that gave rise to the indictment of Epstein for sex
tra is ing, including with numerous minor girls. All of these tasks occurred at whatever property
Epstein traveled to; <REDACTED> was expected to travel with him at all times. When Epstein was in New
York, <REDACTED> stayed in an apartment complex controlled by Epstein; when he was in the USVI,
New , or Florida, she stayed in a room in the main residence at each of those respective
locations.

According to <REDACTED> her salary was approximately $25,000 per year when she first
started working for Epstein, an that over her approximately ten years of employment her salary
rose to a high of around $100,000. This is generally consistent with the account of <REDACTED> who was
hired a few years later at approximately $36,000. Based on our interviews with other Epstein
employees, we understand that <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> were paid substantially less than other
employees, including his permanent assistant base in New York, his pilots, his house managers,
and certain other staff.

<REDACTED> duties were relatively consistent from when she was hired in 2002 through
2005, when the Florida investigations began and her responsibilities generally remained the same
but the massage appointments ceased.

-----

2 This is principally why there is no material factual or witness overlap between a possible <REDACTED>
prosecution and a possible Maxwell prosecution. In short, Maxwell was much more invo ve in
longer-term abuse in the 1990s of a much smaller number of victims, many of whom traveled
extensively with Epstein, whereas <REDACTED> was hired just as Epstein began to build a more
localized—but much higher volume—system of abuse through massage appointments, beginning
in approximately 2002.

-------
Page 5

3. Epstein's arrest and <REDACTED> subsequent employment

In 2005. Epstein's conduct became the subject of an investigation by the Palm Beach
Police Department, and then the FBI, after the parents of a victim reported to law enforcement that
Epstein had abused their daughter. Those investigations ultimately spanned approximately two
years and included, among other things. interviews with  approximately 35 victims, nearly all of
whom were based in Florida. <REDACTED> describes learning that the police were
investigating Epstein's sexual abuse of minors in the initial stages of the investigation. <REDACTED>
admits that Epstein subsequently directed her to speak with certain victims and ask them to contact
Epstein's investigators, as well as to convey the message that Epstein would financially provide
for individuals who "helped" him. <REDACTED> also admits that she understood this as an effort to have
the girls not cooperate with, and cones information from, law enforcement.

<REDACTED> has described that Epstein initially denied to her the allegations against him,
before ultimate y admitting that at least one of the girls who came to the Florida mansion and with
whom he engaged in sexual activity for money was a minor. She recalls that he minimized his
conduct by describing it as involving a very limited number of girls, particularly as compared to
the large number of women who were young but technically of age, and also claimed he was being
"blackmailed" and that the accusations were, in effect, a shakedown. This is consistent with what
Epstein also told Groff and <REDACTED> at the time, and Groff was similarly told by Darren Indyke,
an attorney for Epstein, that Epstein was being blackmailed.3

Following Epstein's brief period of incarceration, <REDACTED> continued her employment as
his assistant until marrying her current husband <REDACTED>. She as recounted that she still believed
it was effectively impossible to leave him, and to find other employment or friendships, given her
lack of family or network outside of Epstein's circle—and that once she found a person who was
recounted observing that others around Epstein continued their associations with him, inc.
actually supportive (her current husband), she separated from Epstein. Additionally <REDACTED>
significant figures in academia, finance, and social circles. <REDACTED> conveys that her continued
association with Epstein was influenced by, among other things, manipulation of her and her
continuing desire to please him and to gain his approval despite his mistreatment of her the fact
that many other notable and respected individuals in finance, politics, and academia continued to
associate with Epstein despite knowing about his convictions and seeing his interactions with
young women and girls: and her concern about finding other employment, having never even
graduated from high school and having no transferable skills. When <REDACTED> married her current
husband <REDACTED>, Epstein gave them $100,000 as a wedding gift: <REDACTED> received no additional
payments our pstein between then and 2018, when he gave her $250,000. as further discussed
below.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> describes that she now deeply regrets
remaining with Epstein, and that her decision to do so at the time was significantly influenced by
Epstein's manipulation.

3. We discuss in detail below the issue of <REDACTED> knowledge at the time. In brief, <REDACTED> has
denied specifically knowing that any of theinom she scheduled for massages weregirage.
and in particular that she did not pay attention to or focus on the ages of the girls.
Page 6
4. Abuse by Epstein

<REDACTED> recounts, <REDACTED> that she was the victim of long-term sexual abuse by li=
Epstein in various forms. <REDACTED> account of understanding that her employment was contingent
upon acquiescence to unwanlsexual advances b Epstein is consistent with the what we have
heard from another Epstein assistant, <REDACTED> who was similarly situated to (and worked
with) <REDACTED> for approximately two years. <REDACTED> describes gradually-increasing unwanted
physical contact, sexual references, and efforts to control her physical appearance. weight, and
food consumption, all of which are consistent with the accounts of other individuals we have
interviewed and found credible—in particular <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> who was not formally
an assistant but whom E stein maintained as a "sex slave" an putative gir friend for several years trim
in the 2000s. as well as <REDACTED> who traveled with Epstein extensively and was abused by
him between the ages° 17 an 20.

<REDACTED> describes that over the course of years. these sexual overtures escalated from
instructions t at s e massage his feet or shoulders, to requests that she sit on his lap, to him entering
her room while she was lying down or sleeping and getting into her bed. He would refer to his
later requirements that she join him nude in his bed as serving as his "hot-water bottle," and
eventually directed her to perform oral sex on him. Consistent with the accounts of other victims,
discussed with others. Also consistent with the accounts of <REDACTED>
<REDACTED> recounts that Epstein treated his escalating demands as unremarkable and normal for a man
of his power and wealth but also not to be discussed with others. Also consistent with the accounts
of others including <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> describes initially being terrified that Maxwell
would discover that Epstein was engaging in sexual activity with her, before realizing that Maxwell
knew about his conduct, and finally being instructed to engage in sexual activity with both Epstein
and Maxwell simultaneously.

<REDACTED> has described that Epstein forcibly raped her on one occasion, under
circumstances at are consistent with the accounts of other victims—specifically, that he appeared
to have "snapped" or become suddenly aggressive, out of context of any other sexual activity.
Despite this abuse, <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> has explained that she
viewed Epstein as a father figure and confidant. <REDACTED> describes having felt dependent on
Epstein, who presented himself as extraordinarily wealthy, socially and politically connected, and
sophisticated; he manipulated <REDACTED> into constantly seeking his approval for "nearly every aspect
of her life." This is consistent with the accounts of other Epstein victims, including other
employees, such as <REDACTED> other individuals who were in his orbit as long-term victims, such as
<REDACTED> and <REDACTED> and numerous victims who provided Epstein with sexualized
massages re ative y few times. Because <REDACTED> had been disfellowshipped from her church and
effectively disowned by her family, she not believe she had meaningful alternatives to
remaining with Epstein—but even if she had, she recounts that she believed Epstein truly cared
about her, despite the ongoing abuse. This traumatized understanding of her relationship with her
abuser is consistent with the accounts of similarly-situated victims in this case and in others.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

Page 7

III. <REDACTED> Investigation

The following is a discussion of the evidence we have gathered in ow investigation that
relates to <REDACTED> in particular, including <REDACTED> conduct as well as the anticipated testimony of
the witnesses at a potential trial.

1. Conduct relating to sex trafficking

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

As an assistant, <REDACTED> regularly called women and girls, including individuals who
were under the age of 18, to sc ule them to come to the Florida Residence for a massage. <REDACTED>
also sometimes met victims when they arrived, walked them up to the massage room, and/or paid
Page 8
them after the massage was complete. <REDACTED> also occasionally (though not routinely) did the
same for masse es atth New York Residence. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> Regarding the relevant
conversations, some victims recall having discussions with <REDACTED> about topics such as living
w parents or not having a driver's license, as well as one individual <REDACTED> whom <REDACTED> knew was
studying for the SAT exam.4 However, none of the many dozens of victims we have interviewed
described telling <REDACTED> how old they were, or discussing their age in reference to a birthday, year
in school, etc.5

The evidence of <REDACTED> knowledge that Epstein was sexually abusing these girls
through the • e of "massages" rests principally on the testimony of three victims, each of whom
recalls <REDACTED> having seen them en a e in sexual conduct or in a state of undress in connection
with Epstem. As discussed below, <REDACTED> recounts that <REDACTED> was present when Epstein
touched her sexually in the context of a massage: <REDACTED> recalls that <REDACTED> walked in on
<REDACTED> while <REDACTED> was alone nude or partially nude in the massage room after a massage: and
<REDACTED> describes <REDACTED> having walked in on her performing oral sex on Epstein in
ia hallway in the New York Residence, unrelated to a massage.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> she does not deny these victim accounts, and she
acknowledges t at Epstem ultimately directed her to engage in sex acts and nude photo shoots
with others. <REDACTED> described that although Epstein touched her sexually when they
were alone, eventually there was an incident in which Maxwell was present, and Maxwell touched
<REDACTED> and instructed her how to touch Epstein while he masturbated. <REDACTED> also described two

---

4. <REDACTED> does not recall discussin the SATs with <REDACTED> recalls. asking <REDACTED> to research
SA prep classes for <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> acknowledged in a proffer t ts erecalle Epstein asking
her about SAT prep. but says s e not know at what age a person would take the SAT because
she did not attend high school after her parents pulled her out in 10th grade. We note that
<REDACTED> recalls believing <REDACTED> was at least 18 while involved with Epstein, including because
<REDACTED> an I.D. that she used to get into 18-and-older venues.

5. <REDACTED> the other primary Florida-based assistant and scheduler, would testify that at the time she
did not know the ages of the individuals she scheduled for massages and did not realize anv were
under the age of 18. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED> who had sexua contact with underage victims also <REDACTED> states
that she did not realize the victims were underage. Both <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> now say they
believe they should have known that some of the girls were minors, given all the circumstances

Page 9
other incidents, on Epstein's island and at the New York Residence, respectively, in which Epstein
directed her to engage in sexual activity with other individuals, neither of whom was one of the
girls she scheduled for massages. Both of them were young women—but not minors, <REDACTED>
believed and we have confirmed, based on their identities—and <REDACTED> understood them to be two
of Epstein's regular girlfriends at the time. Regarding the incident involving <REDACTED> which was
described in a publicly-filed complaint. <REDACTED><REDACTED> while she does
not specifically recall that event, <REDACTED> does not dispute that it could have happened. <REDACTED> also
said that as a general matter if Epstein had instructed her to be present during a massage, that she
would have acquiesced, as she did in the other instances in which Epstein instructed her to be
present for, or to participate in. sexual conduct with others.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED> recounts being desperate for Epstein's approval, particularly because she
viewed him as essentially God-like and because he effectively dominated her existence—
financially but also mentally and emotionally. She acknowledges that she blindly followed his
instructions and gave little thought to anything else—including how old the girls were or what
iran was having them do. Regarding their ages in particular, <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
was taught from a young age that sexual activity between an older man and a younger girl
was common and normal, and that she therefore would not have been as attuned to whether a girl
who appeared to be willingly meeting with Epstein was underage as she otherwise might have
been. <REDACTED> also describes having been emotionally shut down due to her own abuse, effectively
being incapable of considering what others might be experiencing with Epstein, particularly where
she observed that the girls who provided massages did not leave crying or upset, and appeared to
be willing participants—including regularly returning for additional massage appointments.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

2. Concealment and obstructive conduct

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
particularin  relating to victim-witnesses. <REDACTED> recalls that after the
on investigation became public, she called Epstein's house and <REDACTED> picked up the phone.

---

6. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

7. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

When <REDACTED> asked what was happening, <REDACTED> said, in sum and substance, that <REDACTED> shouldn't
worry an at if she didn't say anything ens e would be taken care of. <REDACTED> undertood this to
mean that Epstein would help her if she did not speak to law enforcement.
materials, including computers and paper directories with the names. phone numbers of

We also gathered evidence regarding incidents involving <REDACTED> collecting certain
"masseuses," around the time of the Florida investigation, prior to the search warrant executed on
the Florida Residence. Specifically, <REDACTED> recalled that Epstein instructed <REDACTED to remove
computers and paper directories from the Florida Residence, and that <REDACTED> was present for those
instructions. <REDACTED> also recalled that <REDACTED> subsequently gave <REDACTED> similar instructions to gather
materials from Epstein's USVI residence, and to shred a co stein's directory. <REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED> recalled being destroyed was an extra copy o Epstein's directories. <REDACTED> counsel advises
that <REDACTED> believed that any hard copies were superfluous to electronic copies Epstein maintained,
and we have confirmed that numerous copies of the directories were in fact maintained on his
computers. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED> had directed <REDACTED> to dispose of certain sex toys and photographs in the New
York residence, but because the incident occurred after Epstein's conviction, around when he was
incarcerated in Florida. there would have been no active investigation at that time.
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

Separately, and more recently, within a few days of the publication of the Miami Herald
article series in 2018, Epstein made a one-time payment to <REDACTED> of $250,000. <REDACTED> described
the payment as having been made due to financial woes e d been having for a period of
months, and that the payment had been discussed for some time and was not part of an exchange.
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
By comparison, <REDACTED> similarly received a large sum at the same time, $100,000, and she has
<REDACTED> advise • us t the payment was related to Epstein's acknowledgement that critical press
a ut im had negative effects on others—specifically, the ability to obtain employment and
reputational damage for being associated with him. <REDACTED> understood the payment to be as
compensation for those effects, rather than for any particular ture action or inaction.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

Although there are many victims who interacted with <REDACTED> in connection with their
victimization by Epstein, in particular through speaking with her on t e phone and/or seeing her
at the Florida Residence, the vast majority of those victims do not have significant evidence of
<REDACTED> knowledge of age and/or sex acts. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

Page 11
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
Page 12
<REDACTED><REDACTED>

I. <REDACTED> met with us several times, and informed us that she visited the Florida Residence
dozens of times, includin recruiting approximately 20 to 30 other women and girls ranging from
15 to 20 years of age. <REDACTED> primaril coordinated the a u. • laments for herself and others through
<REDACTED> though also throu <REDACTED>. <REDACTED> recalled that <REDACTED>  would occasionally call from New
York and ask if could "work" when Epstein returned • to Florida. <REDACTED> also recalled <REDACTED>
occasionally taking  to the massage room and/or paying her following completion of the
massage. <REDACTED> told Epstein that she was 18 years old, though believes it would have been
obvious based on her appearance that she was younger—approximately 15 years old when she
out of school around  time she first met <REDACTED> and she does not recall ever seeing, or
first met does not recall any conversations with about her a e. dropped
participating in, any sex acts with Epstein. advised us that when she was 16 and 17 years
old, she began working at a strip club, where she pretended to be 18. When the Florida
investigations became public, after <REDACTED> had stopped visiting Epstein, <REDACTED> recalls having a phone
conversation with <REDACTED> in which <REDACTED> stated, in sum and substance, that <REDACTED> would be taken
care of if she didn't say anything.

<REDACTED> <REDACTED>

<REDACTED> met with us twice, and described having been recruited by a high school friend.
<REDACTED> went to the Florida Residence several times and brought two additional friends for massages.
<REDACTED> primarily coordinated the appointments for herself and others through <REDACTED> and she
recalled that <REDACTED> would sometimes call from New York to schedule massages in Florida in
advance. <REDACTED> recalled occasionally taking her to the massage room. <REDACTED> recalls having
told <REDACTED> she was in high school and could not provide massages at certain times due to
schoo conflicts. <REDACTED> does not recall any conversations with <REDACTED> specifically about her age,
and does not recall ever seeing, or participating in, any sex acts with Epstein.

<REDACTED> <REDACTED>

<REDACTED> met with us twice, and described having been introduced to Epstein in New
York <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> at age 16. Over approximately two years, Epstein victimized
<REDACTED> during massages at New York Residence, including instances of oral sex and an
instance of forcible rape. During part of that period, <REDACTED> lived in an apartment at Epstein's
66th Street property. <REDACTED> recalled that <REDACTED> occasionally would schedule her massages with
Epstein.  and that <REDACTED> sent money via Western Union on at least one occasion while
<REDACTED> was traveling in Europe. <REDACTED> also recalled an incident when <REDACTED> walked in on
<REDACTED> performing oral sex on Epstein at the New York Residencetot y inadvertently;
sometime after that incident, <REDACTED> recalled that Epstein referred to <REDACTED> as his "best little
cocksucker" and "one of my girls" to <REDACTED>

<REDACTED> <REDACTED>

<REDACTED> met with us three times, and described having met Epstein through <REDACTED>
who also worked for him as a "masseuse." <REDACTED> primarily interacted with Epstein through
traveling with him, including to New Mexico, Florida , New York, the USVI, and Paris. In
particular. <REDACTED> recalls that when she was 17, she traveled to New Mexico. where Epstein asked
Page 13
her to give him a masseage while <REDACTED> was present. <REDACTED> recalls that Epstein initially asked
<REDACTED> to remove <REDACTED> top. and that he fondled <REDACTED> and then touched <REDACTED> gentitals in
<REDACTED> presence. In an initial interview. <REDACTED> indicated <REDACTED> had "participated"  in abuse
but she later stated that <REDACTED> had been present but that only Epstein had touched her.
<REDACTED> also does not recall any conversations with <REDACTED> about her age until subsequent 19th
and 20th birthdays which she celebrated with Epstein and for which <REDACTED> was present. <REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED> described having been recruited by a high school friend. Over approximately
two years. <REDACTED> visited the Florida Residence dozens of times, and her abuse escalated to include
instances of oral sex and rape. as well as sexual interactions with others, including <REDACTED> at
Epstein's direction. <REDACTED> does not recall any conversations with <REDACTED>  specifically about her age,
but she does generally recall aking with Epstein about taking the SAT and applying to college.
<REDACTED> also recalled that <REDACTED> sometimes organized drivers to pick up <REDACTED> from her mother's
house, where she lived. <REDACTED> recalled having been paid primari l by Epstein but also sometimes
by <REDACTED><REDACTED> and a former Epstein housekeeper. <REDACTED> does not recall any specific
conversations she had with <REDACTED> about sexual activity with Epstein, but she recalled that <REDACTED>
sometimes walked her to the massage room, and that on one occasion <REDACTED> walked in on <REDACTED>
nude or partially nude in the massage room following a massage.

<REDACTED> <REDACTED>

<REDACTED> described ving been recruited y a friend at approximately age 13 or 14 to
give massages to Epstein at the Florida residence. Over approximately two years. visited
dozens of times, and recruited dozens, and as many as 100 - other girls. She became pregnant at
age 15, after which Epstein no longer wanted to see her, but she continued to act as a paid recruiter.
<REDACTED> primarily coordinated the appointments for herself and others through <REDACTED> and she
recalled <REDACTED> occasionally taking her to the massage room and/or paying her afterward. <REDACTED>
also recalled that sometimes droved to the Florida Residence. <REDACTED> also conveyed
gifts from Epstein to including a bid baby shower gifts when was pregnant at
age 15. believe t at knew she was in high school, but s e oes not recall any
specific conversations with a out her age or that she was in high school does not
recall ever seeing. or participating in. any sex acts with Epstein.
Page 14

IV. Potential Charge and Legal Analysis
Sex trafficking conspiracy, 18 U.S.C. § 371 (to commit sex trafficking. 18 U.S.C. § 1591).
The crime of sex trafficking conspiracy has three elements: First, that two or more
persons unlawfully agreed to violate § 1591; second, that the defendant knowingly and willfully
became a member of the conspiracy; and third, that the defendant committed an act in furtherance
of the conspiracy."
" The substantive crime of sex trafficking requires proof that the defendant knowingly recruited,
enticed, harbored, transported, provided, or obtained by any means a person; in or effecting
interstate commerce; knowing that the victim is under the age of 18 and would be involved in a
commercial sex act.
Page 15
s.
Page 16

V. Interests of Justice and Analysis
Precedent and balancing of equities
Page 17Page 18
at the time, or at east consciously avoided owing. that the massages were sexual in nature an
Page 19
substantially overlaps with in terms of role and conduct: she was hired at
a e
Page 20

Views of victim-witnesses
Page 21

Views of the SDNY human trafficking coordinators
Page 22

Efficiencies in process and antrome

VI. Other Relevant Offenses and Recommendation
Page 23
I I I
I
Page 24
I I
I
Page 25
I I
—i
* * *
■
Page 26
By:
╔═════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Next Models [modeling] modeling agency co-founded by Faith Kates 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00086868 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of employee of Next Models
(date: 2020-04-23)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 9-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  04/23/2020
, date of birth was interviewed at 9150
Wilshire Blvd, Beverly Hills, California. Present for the interview was
, along with AUSA , AUSA
AUSA , Special Agent and Detective
. After being advised of the identities of the above listed individuals
and the nature of the interview, provided the following
information:
grew up in until she was about 11 years old. She
then moved to in She went to high school and college
in the United States. She had a tough childhood in Her father died
and it hit her hard. He had a good job and then was diagnosed with cancer.
Her family kept it from her. He passed two days before her 17th birthday.
would work full time eventually while going to school full time at
She fell into a depression for two years of college.
would read self help books to get out of it.
She began to get an interest in modelling and started when she was about
19-20 years old. She worked 9-5 at a medical office and put modelling off
full time until she was done with school. She was going to school at night
at this time and she had a boyfriend.
A modeling agent called her about a hostess job at a high end restaurant
in the night club industry. She started working as a hostess at 20 years
old and graduated college at 21 with a degree in management information
systems. After college, decided to give modeling a shot. She
would give it two years and then go to work.
On March 14, 2004 she moved to Manhattan at 22 years old. She moved into
an apartment that was walking distance to Union Square. On her first night
off (a Saturday) she was invited to a party. met a girl named
Investigation on 02/28/2020
File # SOD—NY-3027571
at Beverly Hills, California, United States (In Person)
Date drafted 03/27/2020
by

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
SOD-NY -3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of ( U ) Interview of
They chatted and danced.
a 02/28/2020 ,page 2 of 9
asked if wanted to make
$300. herself went to see a wealthy guy who liked to get massages from
girls in underwear for about half an hour, or 20 minutes. wasn't
initially interested but said he was a playboy type and really smart
and had a place in the Caribbean. At the end of the massage he would touch
himself. asked if she could come in a bathing suit and decided to
give it a shot. gave the phone number of the girl who
introduced her ( ).
The next day (Sunday) received a phone call from
was asked to meet at 86 th street and Broadway. They meet and
repeated what told her. asked about her background.
said that was really pretty and that EPSTEIN would like her.
The next day (Monday) took a cab to EPSTEIN's.
and she
was
initially with her but did not go with her in cab. went back to
EPSTEIN's about 4-5 times after the first incident before she was invited to
travel with him.
The first time she visited EPSTEIN nothing happened. The second time she
thought he tried to escalate it. clenched up and he told her to
relax. EPSTEIN told her that if there was something that he was doing that
she doesn't like to tell him. He told her it's not fun if they are both not
having fun.
After a few times, EPSTEIN got to know personally and wanted to
know if she wanted to travel. went to Florida with him and a few
others then they flew to the island. They traveled with other girls and
EPSTEIN's assistant or girlfriend. During these trips, EPSTEIN would make
promises. He told that she was smart and it seemed like he was
interested in her. He asked what he could help her with and asked if he
could help her with her modeling. To take this trip she had to quit her job
and needed to get gigs to support herself. It was implied that if
traveled with EPSTEIN to give him massages that he would financially support
her.
EPSTEIN invited on trips from time to time. EPSTEIN would call
her while in New York for her to come by his office for social visits, and
not for massages. The girls that traveled with him just massaged him while
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
SOD-NY -3027571
Comthuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of
traveling and not while they were in New York.
,04, 02/28/2020 ,page 3 of 9
In May of 2006, was frustrated. She was in limbo and was doing
night club promos and modeling promos. She was not getting help and wanted
a career path. She looked into getting her real estate license. She told
EPSTEIN and he offered to get her a job.
EPSTEIN asked almost from the beginning if she had girlfriends
for him. learned eventually that he asked other girls the same
thing. EPSTEIN told what he didn't like. He didn't like
strippers, heaver drinkers, smokers, liars. He liked 18-23 year old who
were clean cut, slim, and attractive girls.
In the beginning, asked the girl who introduced her and asked a
girl she worked with if they knew anyone interested. Early on she asked
about ten girls. EPSTEIN wanted her to chat girls up at castings which she
felt uncomfortable doing. EPSTEIN pressured her and she did it once but
felt uncomfortable. She would let people who may be interested come talk to
her.
EPSTEIN helped with some monthly expenses. She felt that as
long as they were friends that he was going to look out for her.
took state and school tests for real state. While she was taking the state
tests, EPSTEIN reached out and told her that he was thinking of buying a
modeling agency and he would like for to manage it. EPSTEIN told
her she needed to work in the industry for six months to get experience. In
August of 2006, learned that EPSTEIN had been arrested. EPSTEIN
told her this but she didn't know the details. He told her it was an enemy
out to get him. The only info had was from the papers and it
wasn't talked about. It was like an awkward silence. EPSTEIN told her to
call DARREN INDYKE if contacted by law enforcement and not to speak with law
enforcement. EPSTEIN did not specifically say not to talk to law
enforcement but to contact INDYKE. EPSTEIN told her not to introduce him to
anybody and he was not interested in meeting new people for massages.
was scared and freaked out. She just wanted a regular job and
to move on. She spoke with EPSTEIN back and forth about jobs and EPSTEIN
suggested she intern with a friend of his, JEAN-LUC BRUNEL. did
not like BRUNEL, she thought he was creepy. He was disrespectful and
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
S0D-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of o, 02/28/2020 mg, 4 of 9
misogynistic. She heard he mistreated women on a regular basis. She heard
from more than one person that he slipped "roofies" in a girl's drink in
Miami.
then went to work for NEXT MODEL MANAGEMENT. EPSTEIN told
to check in with FAITH. She workde there from November to
February. In the middle of February, EPSTEIN ttold that he had an
opportunity of a lifetime. The son of a friend of his was looking for an
assistant in finance. It was a good career opportunity and she worked there
from March 2007- May 2008. relationship with EPSTEIN changed.
They no longer traveled together; there were maybe 1-2 more trips. It
became more of EPSTEIN giving her advice working at BEAR STEARNS. Their
contact become less and less and wasn't physically available and he
was on the phone all the time.
The job was tough on . She recalled a story coming out
and people were reading it and gossiping about her in the work environment.
overheard this. No one trained her because she didn't have a lot
of experience because EPSTEIN had got her the job. told EPSTEIN
that she would like to leave and he told her she had to take the brokers
test or it was a waste. She took the test and passed. EPSTEIN then set
up with job interviews. did not like these opportunities.
EPSTEIN then went to jail. spent one day with him before he
went.
met through friends. wanted to meet a
sponsor. A group of them went to the movies. brought people.
invited to the movies and that's how met EPSTEIN.
EPSTEIN emailed and said there was a fake lawsuit where was
suing EPSTEIN and , and that she should get a lawyer and not talk to
EPSTEIN about it. had been in touch via email and called and saw
EPSTEIN two times after he got out of jail. moved to Los Angeles
in 2011. In 2014, wrote him an email apologizing for ghosting him
and to wish him a Merry Christmas and happy birthday.
was shocked in 2010 when EPSTEIN directly asked her to look for
girls for him. He had just gotten out of jail and had a job. In
2010, was having a casual conversation with EPSTEIN when all of a
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
50D-NY -3027571
Comthwdion of FD-302 of (U) Interview of 02/28/2020 ,page 5 of 9
sudden he asked, "When are you going to start producing?". was
shocked that he would expect that from her at this point. He wanted her to
find girls for massages. This conversation happened when she was walking
home and on the phone with him. cried for four hours and thought
about ways to leave New York.
In 2013, became a massage therapist. She had already been
interested in massage prior to meeting EPSTEIN.
for a mobile massage company and she likes her job.
currently works
EPSTEIN once stated that he was not interested in girls
old. impression was that he liked girls between
although she was not sure if he ever said as young as 18 or
age. did not speak with INDYKE.
over 23 years
18-23 years old
gave a specific
EPSTEIN specifically told , "Uou do not want to see me angry or
upset". stated that EPSTEIN could be intimidating. On one
occasion in Florida the housekeeper woke him up. EPSTEIN came downstairs
and he seemed upset, trying to contain his anger. He said "Don't ever wake
me up again. I don't care if there's a fire in the house. You carry me
out".
was not aware of specific people but she knew that EPSTEIN had
three appointments a day for massages. She heard him on the phone asking
someone if they had any friends. He may have mentioned someone by name but
it was in passing.
In 2004,
and (from
girl from
from time to time
met
and met
in love
EPSTEIN at a party that
that she was in love with EPSTEIN and he was the
with. had her emotions hurt. EPSTEIN
or
though 2006.
) around 2006.
was present when
who came during the summers)
was there though 2005.
was there around 2005 and
met
and a
came
is from and was quiet on a lot of the trips.
asked her how she met EPSTEIN and she said she was a young model
invited her to. told
only man she was
ignored her and
called her when it was convenient. A lot of girls had their emotions hurt.
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
SOD-NY -3027571
Comthwdion of FD-302 of (U) Interview of ,o, 02/28/2020 ,page 6 of 9
EPSTEIN told that she needed to lose weight and said that her
hair color looked like a lemon. thought these people were
successful and nice for the first year. On the phone EPSTEIN would hang up
sharply. He would be cold sometimes. The girlfriends he spent the most
time with slept in his bed.
was impressed that EPSTEIN was from Brooklyn and made his money
himself. He seemed like motivation. She looked at him as a
mentor. thought that he was interested in her as a woman. He told
her she was smart and would do well. There were other girls that he didn't
think were smart.
came on some trips. She would follow him with a notebook and take
care of projects he wanted done. would hang out with them when there
was common time, or they were having dinner, or going to the movies.
was a very nice, neutral quiet person. EPSTEIN and were
friendly with each other. EPSTEIN was too familiar with her; he would ask
her to take her top off. He did have professional conduct with her while in
the office.
On the island, on one occasion, everyone was sitting by the pool and
EPSTEIN said "OK everyone take your clothes off". was surprised.
was there and she was the first to take her top off, which she did
with ease. was surprised because she was his assistant.
There were two other incidents that didn't think were
professional. The first was in 2006 with GHISLAINE MAXWELL and
possibly in New Mexico. was not present for this but she was with
a group of people when they were discussing the incident. chatted
with these individuals about this and made a point to ask questions.
MAXWELL wanted to make a mold of breasts. had heard that
did not want to do it. They mixed the solution incorrectly and
got a 2nd degree burn. did not notice or pay attention to
any scars she may have had because of this.
The second incident was an occasion in which got a stomach bug.
EPSTEIN would tease her that she needed to lose weight in front of other
people. got a haircut and said to EPSTEIN, "Doesn't she
look nice?", and he responded, "Yes, she looks like a good little
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
SOD-NY-3027571
comimmthmofmaeof (U) Interview of
cocksucker". dismissed that comment.
a 02/28/2020 mg, 7 of 9
met on her first trip to Florida. told
EPSTEIN saved her life. EPSTEIN paid for school. EPSTEIN sent
to Spain. talked to about . was the second
assistant when couldn't run errands. gave regular
massages on the island. did not know how and met
EPSTEIN.
was a very nice, •
was 19 years old when
girl wither
met her.
eyes. She spoke English.
was more friends with
was funny and chatty. She was more of a real person and less of
a model. She was a ballerina. Her mother was a hippie and grew up in
She was 23 years old. and did not get along at
some point.
became aware of MAXWELL very soon. Maybe around the 3rd or 4th
time with EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN changed his mind at some point and gave
him a foot massage. and EPSTEIN went to Spice Market on one
occasion. MAXWELL and a scientist were there that they met.
searched them on the internet after they met. met MAXWELL for the
second time when was on the island. MAXWELL came in the middle of
the trip and introduced herself. They were on a speed boat together and
MAXWELL said "if you ever need me, take my number".
MAXWELL was intimidating and kind of harsh. heard that MAXWELL
and EPSTEIN used to date or be engaged. From what observed,
MAXWELL would arrange social interactions. heard EPSTEIN speak
with MAXWELL numerous times over the phone and in person. MAXWELL would set
up meetings with celebrities and businesses. EPSTEIN would say, "Did you
set up that meeting". EPSTEIN would talk about MAXWELL. EPSTEIN would
mention that MAXWELL was the original girl finder. MAXWELL would find girls
for him.
MAXWELL was the original girl finder and had an understanding
that her role was to introduce him to women. She would also find women to
waitress for him. He would hire women to serve lunch and dinner to him for
$15 an hour years ago when he first started getting massages.
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
50D-NY -3027571
Continuation of FU-302 of ( U ) Interview of ,04, 02/28/2020 ,page 8 of 9
MAXWELL was mean to the girls. heard this through gossip.
EPSTEIN would talk about MAXWELL's exes.
jealous of each other. MAXWELL was jealous
jealous of
His girlfriends would be
of ) and III was
On one occasion, asked EPSTEIN how he got the idea to have three
massages a day, and how did he find the girls.
was a sex addict and if he didn't have
work. During a 2004 conversation that
EPSTEIN explained that he
his release that it would affect his
had with EPSTEIN he said
that about 15 years ago he would go to BLOO MINGDALES to pick up girls during
his lunch break. He had a conversation with a male friend at the time who
told him he could relieve himself by getting massages with happy endings.
EPSTEIN said that he had an ex-girlfriend from Minnesota. III and
were his girlfriends when he was younger. In September of 2004
a girl who said she was his ex-girlfriend. She was a model for
agency.
In late 2004
herself on CRAIGSLIST. She noticed one post that was requesting "model
looking girls".
either or
was looking for a promotional modelling job for
recalled that the email address on this ad was
put this email into
GOOGLE and found at least two more similar postings possibly on other
websites. was asked if BACKPAGE sounded familiar to which she
answered, "I think so, not sure".
met
EPSTEIN brainwashed a lot. EPSTEIN said that "after 23 women
get sour attitudes, they are not fun". EPSTEIN made feel as though
most men felt this way.
assumed MAXWELL stopped getting girls because she didn't hear
anything.
was asked about sexual contact with others present. She stated
that EPSTEIN surprised her a couple times. On another occasion, he asked
. On one occasion, organized the encounter. On one
occasion, a girl named was present; she was about 20-21 years old
with hair and eyes. On another occasion, a girl named
was pr rt. Sometimes EPSTEIN would be in the massage room with another
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
S0D-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of o, 02/28/2020 ins, 9 of 9
woman and he would ask to join. These occasions
know them and the room would be dark.
would not
FAITH was the owner of NEXT MODEL MANAGEMENT. met her before
she started interning. When was in the hospital, FAITH was her
agent. FAITH and EPSTEIN came to the hospital and met her there.
was not sure what and FAITH's relationship was. EPSTEIN knew her
since 1985. FAITH was an agent at WILHELMINA MODELS prior to this. EPSTEIN
would talk down to FAITH. In the fall of 2006, heard EPSTEIN ask
FAITH when she was going to find a girl for him. FAITH responded by saying
something like, "I introduced you to last year". EPSTEIN responded
or implied that was out of commission and did not look the same.
EPSTEIN had a mentor named taught him how to dress
and was a personal and social mentor. He changed the perception of the
world, and learned how to dress appropriately.
was asked if anyone ever asked her to delete or get rid of
anything to which she answered "no".
In 2006, EPSTEIN told everything. He told her that email and
text messages could be monitored. did not know what that meant.
expressed that he preferred to speak over the phone.
was asked if EPSTEIN asked her to see other men to which she
responded by stating "yes". At some point, EPSTEIN suggested that
see some of his acquaintances. He suggested this more than once. At this
time, preferred not to share the names of these individuals.
was told by EPSTEIN to set up one of his friends with
confirmed this appointment.
In late 2006-2007, EPSTEIN introduced to his friend LEON BLACK.
said that she threw up in her mouth and laughed about it.
never witnessed or heard of giving EPSTEIN a massage.
EFTA02731168 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2020-04-29)
I. Overview
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
Prosecution Memorandum
Privileged and Confidential -- Attorney nark Product
Do Not Disseminate Outside of the SDNY USAO
United Stales v. Maxwell, 20 Cr. ( ) April 10, 2020
This memorandum seeks authorization to charge GHISLA1NE MAXWELL with one
count of conspiracy to violate 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a), which prohibits the transportation of a minor
for illegal sexual activity, and one count of conspiracy to violate 18 U.S.C. § 2422, which prohibits
the enticement of a minor to travel to engage in illegal sexual activity. These charges arise from
Maxwell's role in facilitating Jeffrey E tein's sexual abuse of minors. In particular, the proposed
charges focus on the victimization o who was abused by E stein for several years.
beginning when she was fourteen years o an ving in . Several months
after Maxwell and Epstein met they began to encourage er to travel with them, and
brought her to Epstein's mansion in ew York, where she was also abused. As discussed in
greater detail below. Maxwell had a significant role in grooming for abuse and facilitating
Epstein's access to
Victim Interviews and Corroborating Evidence
and moved towas born
wit...when she was a
In
S e turn 14 years o at summer. reca s t at,
one day, she was sitting at a picnic to le with friends when Ghislaine Maxwell wa ed by with her
Page 2
dog and said hello. Jeffrey Epstein followed behind and introduced himself as a donor,
ho gave scholarships to students. E stein and Maxwell asked where was
om. an when she told them she was from asked
for her phone number, which provide
Several weeks later, when was home from camp, she recalls someone from
Epstein's office calling her house and inviting her to come to Epstein's house in Palm Beach for
tea. ',and her mother went to the house, where they had tea with Epstein by his pool. Epstein
told t em t at he liked to mentor young talented individuals, that he gave scholarships, and that he
wanted to help mother reacted positively, and encouraged l.to spend time
with Epstein.' subsequently began regularly spending time at Epstem's ouse in Palm
Beach, beginning at age 14, and continuing until she was 17, when she relocated to New York
City. During those visits, Epstein regularly gave her $200-300 in cash, and told her to give the
mone to her mother, remarking that he knew her mother needed the money. Epstein also paid for
lessons.
During the fust few months, Epstein and Maxwell took im to the movies, went
shopping with her, and spent time with her at Epstein's Palm Beac ouse, often by the pool.
During these visits. Maxwell and Epstein would talk with about school, her classes, her
family. and other aspects of her life. has explained that these visits were strange. but that
she felt comfortable because Maxwell was there. She has characterized these early months as a
time when, in retrospect, she now believes that Maxwell and Epstein were "grooming" her for
sexual abuse.
Several months into this arrangement, when" was alone with Epstein in the pool
house, he asked her what she wanted to do with her 1 e, an she told him she wanted
Epstein told her that if she was going to be involved ' e she
needed to be prepared for what might do. Epstein then put her on his lap and began
masturbating. After this inci ent, encounters with Epstein began to include sexual
contact. Over time, the sexual abuse esca ated and included Epstein digitally penetrating
using a vibrator on her, and Epstein directing to massage him while he masturbated. The
abuse occurred so frequently that does not have specific memories of each particular
incident.
We interviewed mother, who lives
noting. owever, t at
reca 1 s Maxwe ca 1 mg er ome, an as g or to come over. She recalls t at Maxwe
told her that she wanted to take under her wing and be "like a big sister" to
Page 3
From this point forward, recalls that Epstein also frequently brought her into
his massage room for group sexual encounters with other women, often including Maxwell. In
IRthese encounters, and the women would strip down to their underwear and begin massaging
Epstein, who wou le own on a massage table, face down. After a period of time, Epstein would
turn over and begin touching the women and engaging in sex acts that, over time, and in various
instances, included Epstein masturbating, receiving oral sex, and engaging in intercourse. During
these encounters, recalls that Maxwell would sometimes guide the women and give
instructions about what to do. In the beginning, when was approximately 14 or 15, she El
would massage Epstein's feet and try to remain at the periphery of the sexual activity, but over
time, she believes she became more involved in the sexual activity, which varied in each encounter.
has not been able to provide details about what sex acts she participated in during these
group sessions, as compared to the sexual abuse that occurred when she was alone with Epstein.
However, she recalls that the most significant sexual abuse she experienced with Epstein occurred
later, when they were alone together. Although Maxwell was not present during these types of
encounters, she was often in the house, and Epstein would lead into a different room to get
her alone.
Though Maxwell was not present during the initial episodes of sexual abuse by Epstein,
as noted above, Maxwell was sometimes present for the types of group encounters/abusive
sessions described above. At times, Maxwell would undress, and Epstein would give both
WIMaxwell and instructions about what he wanted them to do during these encounters.
remem rs t e first time she saw Maxwell naked during one of these sessions, and she
recalls being struck by how skinny Maxwell was. has ex lained that Maxwell would
"normalize" the situation by behaving casually, and act as if she was "cool older sister."
Maxwell would tell her that everything was "okay" and "make it seem like this is what grown-ups
do."
FpBecause the abuse was so frequent and so long ago, does not recall the specifics
of these episodes with Epstein and Maxwell. She recalls genera y t e types of things that occurred
during these kinds of encounters, but she is unable to narrate a specific episode. She has explained
that these memories run together, and while she is confident that Maxwell was present for at least
several of these group incidents, she does not recall specifically what sex acts occurred during
these episodes while Maxwell was present.
Beginning when was approximately 14, she began to travel with Epstein and
Maxwell to New York City on occasion. During what believes was an early trip, she stayed
at Epstein's mansion, and Maxwell and Epstein took er s opping. She recalls that Epstein and
Maxwell bought her white cotton underwear, and she described it as looking like little kids'
underwear. recalls that on either this trip or another early trip, she took a commercial flight
home, but did not have identification, so Maxwell came to the airport and helped her get on the
flight.
Over the years, from ages fourteen to seventeen, Epstein periodically flew to
New York, where she would stay with him (and sometimes Maxwell) at his house in Manhattan.'
As discussed below, relationship with Epstein continued for several years after
became an adult.
Page 4
Eirecalls that Epstein sexually abused her during the trips to New York, but she does not
reca t e specific details of the abuse, or whether Maxwell was present on any particular occasion,
because she was abused in Epstein's New York townhouse so many times—both on these trips as
well as later, when she moved to New York. estimate is that she was abused on
a • .roximaThel nine out of ten tri. s to New York durm • ht is timeframe.
recalls that Maxwell would generally tell her about upcoming trips to New
York. and silieves Maxwell would call mother to make travel arrangements.'
also believes Maxwell arranged for her trave on commercial flights to and/or from New Ala
does not recall any specific trip for which she remembers Maxwell being involved in the planning.
also recalls traveling to Epstein's ranch in New Mexico with Epstein and
Maxwell. S e as few specific memories from these trips, and does not recall whether Epstein
abused her at that location.
In the summer o . a few months before she turned 18. moved to New York
City, She maintained contact with Epstein during
that year in New Yor t, an e continue to a use her at his New York townhome.
Our team has met with four times, beginning in September 2019 and most
recently in February 2020. We also liter additional questions by phone in April 2020. Mid
from her interviews with our team. has never sunken with law enforcement re ardin
Epstein.
Corroboration of Documentary Evidence
Although we have not been able to identify particular commercial flights from the
1990s, because the airlines we have subpoenaed did not retain records from that time period, we
have reviewed flight records from Epstein's private jet, which were written and maintained by
3
4
Page 5
pilot David Rodgers, whom we have interviewed as further described below. There appear to be
several flights on which is listed by name as a assenger. The following three flights
appear on logs from Epstem's private jet, on dates when was a minor:
• A flight
o The passengers listed on the lo are: JE,
o was 16 on that date.
• A flight
o 11.assengers listed on the log are: "JE, GM,
o was 16 on that date.
was 17 on at e. As iscussed below, the relevant age of consent for the
I.c ge we are considering is 17, and thus while was a minor under federal
law at the time of this flight, she was not a minor for purposes of consenting under
New York state law.
We believe that "GM"
in the latter two flights refers to Ghislaine Maxwell.
In addition to the foregoing records, flight records also a ar to
corroborate.. account of meeting Epstein and Maxwell at . In particu ar, t
records show that E stein flew
e passengers st on e i t are " , ." Maxwe
is not st as a passenger on that flight, but flight records re ect t at Maxwe was on the plane
The listed passengers for that flight were "JE, GM, ." Accordingly, it
appears that Maxwell may have travelled separately, pe aps on a commercial flight,
and returned on Epstein's private jet.
The date of this trip would have been just weeks after
fourteenth birthday. We have obtain recd that confirm
We have also obtained records from
unng c se was 18
years o .
We have also reviewed physical evidence seized from Epstein's Florida residence by
the Palm Beach Police Department in October 20, 2005, pursuant to a search warrant. That
evidence includes framed photographs from Epstein's office, one of which is-of
Page 6
when she appears to be a teenager.
thanks for rocking my world! You're e st!"
wrote: "Jeffrey.
Finally, we have attempted to obtain airline records for commercial flights took
As noted above, we have subpoenaed multiple airlines, but they no onger have
recor s . A travel agency utilized by Epstein and his associates produced records
that show commercia flight ticket purchases for individuals including but those records
only date back to 1999, and do not inc u edeparture or arrival
location information. The presence of commercial records from the available time periods do at
least corroborate the notion that Epstein would also have flown on commercial flights
(beyond those on his private plane) during the earlier, relevant time periods.
Corroboration on Witness Testimony
Juan Alessi
We have interviewed Juan Alessi, who worked as Epstein's house manager in Palm
Beach from 1990 to 2002.5 When Alessi first began working for Epstein, he recalls that Epstein's
girlfriend was Eva Anderson (now Eva Dubin), who he describes as having been pleasant and
friendly. Alessi recalls that after Anderson and Epstein broke up, Epstein began dating Maxwell.
In approximately 1993, Maxwell began coming to the house in Palm Beach, and became in charge
of the whole house. Epstein told Alessi to go to Maxwell for his orders, and he began taking
directions from Maxwell about house operations. Alessi described Maxwell as extremely difficult
and unpleasant to work for. Although Alessi's previous interactions with Epstein were casual and
informal in nature, he recalls that after Maxwell took over, the rules for house staff became strict.
the environment became more formal, and work obligations increased. These trends slowly
increased over the years, and Alessi recalls that the working environment changed more
significantly in approximately 2000. At that point, Alessi was told that Epstein did not want to see
workers in the same room with him; if Epstein entered a room, workers were required to
immediately leave. Maxwell also told Alessi that he should not look Epstein in the eyes and should
not speak to guests at the house.
Alessi has a firm memory of seeing at Epstein's house. She made a
strong impression because he remembers that srvas very young. very pretty. and a talented
singer. He recalls Epstein telling him that Epstein was helping et her career started.
Alessi remembers being sent by both Epstein and Maxwell to pick up from her house and
drive her to Epstein's house, and he recalls thespecific neighborh ere lived. He si
recalls Maxwell and Epstein spending time with at the Palm Beach house, and he also
remembers being sent to buy movie tickets, and driving Maxwell, and Epstein to the
movies. Although he has told us that nothing at the time alerted him tows going on between
Epstein and behind closed doors, he does remember seeing Epstein kissing on the
cheek and patting er bottom.
Alessi's wife. Maria Alessi, also worked for Epstein part-time as housekeeper. We have
interviewed Ms. Alessi and do not believe she has relevant information.
Page 7
Part of Alessi's job was to schedule massages for Epstein. He recalls that the masseuses
in the 1990s and very early 2000s were generally young women in their 205 whom he believed
were professional massage therapists. During his last few months working for Epstein, in 2002,
he noticed that the masseuses appeared to be getting younger. This is also consistent with our
investigation, which has shown that Epstein's sex trafficking operation—as charged in our
indictment of him—became routinized and more brazen starting in approximately 2002, following
a longer period in which Epstein abused a much smaller number of minor girls over lengthier
periods of time.
In approximately 2002. Alessi came to understand that Epstein and Maxwell wanted
him to leave, and he noticed faxes in the office regarding applicants for his position. Alessi and
his wife left Epstein's employment in December 2002, and received a $50,000 severance payment.
Several months after leaving, Alessi broke into Epstein's house and stole several
thousand dollars in cash from Epstein's briefcase. Epstein reported the incident to the police, and
Alessi admitted to stealing the money" He agreed to pay the money back, and Epstein did not
pursue charges. Alessi was not arrested or charged in connection with this incident.
David Rodgers
We have also interviewed David Rodgers, one of Epstein's ilots. Based on that
interview, we would expect Rodgers to testify that he specifically recalls being on
flights on Epstein's private jet, but that he did not know age at e time. Rodgers was
employed as one of Epstein's pilots for his private jets m 1 91 through Epstein's arrest in
2019. Although he missed the occasional flight for vacation or training, Rodgers piloted the vast
majority of private fli is Epstein took during that period. During the period between
approximately , Rodgers recalls that either Maxwell or one of Epstein's secretaries
would inform R gers, us y over the phone, of Epstein's anticipated flight schedule a few days
or so in advance. Rodgers recalls that Maxwell primarily focused on scheduling the flights that
she planned to be on and took less interest in the flights that she would not be joining. During that
same period, Epstein ordinarily flew on his jet for domestic travel but travelled commercial for
most international trips until 1996. Rodgers also recalls that there were occasions when Maxwell
would arrive at a particular destination by flying separately and would then join Epstein for the
next leg of a trip on the jet.
Rodgers kept a log of every flight that he piloted, including for the period between.
The log reflected the date, departure airport, arrival airport, and technical information
regarding the flight. It was also Rodgers's practice to note how many passengers were on board
each flight and to note the names of those passengers he knew. When he did not know the name
of a passenger, Rodgers ordinarily would make a generic notation (e.g.. 1 female, 1 male, or 1
passenger. etc.). He explained he was not required to identify his passengers unless crossing an
international border, and he was not always introduced to his passengers, so he often flew with
passengers whose names he did not know. As a result, his log does not list flights that Rodgers
6 E stein alsoreported his firearm missing. According to police reports. Alessi told the police that
he wanted to steal the gun, but did not find it. and took the money instead. ■
Page 8
on th Nights
are likely referencing
Rodgers initially remem
but when shown the dates on the flight logs, Rodgers said he could ve met
that.
remembers sister te g her that a man approac
MI:other. He is
did not personally fly, and it does not include the names of passengers whose names he did not
know at the time of a flight. When Rodgers learned the name of a passenger who had previously
flown on other flights, Rodgers would use that passenger's name going forward but would not go
back to add in that passenger's name on prior flight lo
R. gers personally visited one o those
, Epstein would travel to Rodgers recalls that in
c y reca s airport he would fly to fortthose trips. gers understood
to . Looking back at his flight log. Rodgers conformed that
. and that Maxwell joined Epstein for the return
s on y t erea er. R. gers also remembers learning that Epstein and
wring one of those annual trip Rodgers recalls having been
at some point, but he cannot reca a  of that introduction, and he
.
only ever interact • with her on Epstein's plane. Rodgers understood that
and he recalls her fl in on Epstein's plane multiple times. Rod ers onl remem members ever ying
two females named on Epstein's planes: the first was and the second was
R gers recalls that began flying on e plane much later in time
on a review of his fh og, gers confirmed that the name appears
7 Based on the timing of those records. Rodgers believesthose entries
retirbut he does not have a specific memory of those flights.
ing met and flown in , plus or minus a few years,
earlier than
tnps an spec[
t pstein donated mone
he flew E stein to
flight
Maxwe I met
introduced to
. He recalls that she spoke about this man with a tone of
a tion. At some pow, earned that this man was Jeffrey Epstein. and that by coincidence
he also lived in Palm Beach.
recalls that when they returned home to Palm Beach,. began meeting E stem
at his house. He had the impression that E stein was agodfather figure w o wanted to help
because he admired . He recalls that Epstein would sen
a driver to pick up
recalls that IR went to New York City with Epstein during her junior year of
high schoolind he remem rs er describing Epstein's house in New York. He does not know
whether Maxwell was on the trip (or trips), but he had the impression that Maxwell would travel
with them, because would often mention Maxwell.
7
Page 9
■ does not recall the first time he met Epstein, but he remembers meeting Maxwell
and Epstein at a movie theater when was 15 and• After met, told
that Maxwell had said to her: "I won teach your brother a g or two." remembers this
.
in particular. because he found it creepy.
Other Victim Interviews
In addition to account, we have interviewed tw
and
outer victims —
Brew ug in in a fairly well-to-do family. She recalls
that when s e was 17 , a end in Migintroduced her to Maxwell
who immediately took an interest her anbegan spending time wi er in
recalls that Maxwell was nice to her and acted as though they were sisters. She described Maxwell
as immature, and that Maxwell behaved as though the two of them were "naughty little school
girls," even though Maxwell was sixteen years older. Maxwell would frequently talk about her
boyfriend, Epstein. and say, "I know how much he's going to like you."
One day. when was still 17. she recalls that Maxwell called and said
E stein was visiting in should drop everything and come over.8
went to Maxwe 's townhouse in Lon on, where Maxwell introduced her to Epstein,
telling him: "she's so pretty, she's so strong." As they were standing in the kitchen, talking,
recalls that Maxwell told her to massage Epstein's shoulders, to show him how strong
s e was, w ch she did. Later during this same visit, Maxwell told her: "Since you're so strong,
I'd appreciate it if you could give Jeffrey a massage. because he needs a massage every day or I
get in trouble." Maxwell led her to a room, where Epstein was waiting in a robe. Maxwell left
her at the room, where Epstein proceeded to take off his robe and get on his bed. As
was massaging his back. Epstein turned over, with an erection, and said: "Well, that oesn't e
was shocked. and E stein told her: "It's natural. You're not scared, are you?" When'
ou uncomfortable, does it?" Epstein then reached out to her and put her hand on his penis.
encounter ended, and left the room, Maxwell was outside, and asked her: "Did you
have fun? Did he like ft?" felt as thou Maxwell knew what was going on in the
room, based on her tone. Shorty t erea er, recalls that Maxwell called her and said.
in sum and substance: "Well aren't you a clever gm . Je ey was very impressed."
Shortly after this incident, but during Epstein's same trip to London, .l went
back to Maxwell's residence. in substance: ' Godrecalls Maxwell sa
you're here. If it's not you or someone, it a falls to me." Once heard Maxwell say
• .
believes this occurred when she was 17,
. but does not recall the date with any greater specificity.
Page 10
that, she felt as though Maxwell knew what had happened. Maxwell walked up the stairs with
and opened the door to the room, where Epstein was standing naked. Maxwell said:
"I'll leave you guys to it."
After these first two encounters, Epstein and Maxwell invited to travel
with them to Palm Beach, the U.S. Virgin Islands, Paris, and New York. These trips spanned
several years, and does not recall whether these trips began before or after her
eighteenth birthday. owever, recalls that she was sexually abused by Epstein
during all of these trips, typically in t e context of a "massage." The abuse included, among other
things, Epstein groping her and using a massager device on her genitals. Epstein would typically
recalls that she would sometimes leave the room to find Maxwell "lurking" near'.
ive her $300 after these sessions. Maxwell was not in the room during these encounters, but
axwe would ask her: "How was it? Is he happy?" She also recalls Maxwell telling her at some
point, in sum and substance: "You know how he is when he's not happy, and you know what
makes him happy. He has to have sex all the time, he's like a super hero." Based on these sorts
of interactions — and, in particular, the explicit reference to Epstein's need to have "sex all the
time" — inferred that Maxwell was generally aware of the true nature of the
"massages" s e was providing to Epstein.
recalls that during a trip to Palm Beach, after she turned 18, she
discovered a sc oo -gir outfit on her bed in her guest room. She confronted Maxwell, who said:
"Oh, I thought it'd be so adorable if you took Jeffrey his tea wearing it. Don't be so frigid."
did not know what to do, so she put on the outfit, which she felt was humiliating. She
went to find Epstein in the house, and Epstein slapped her bottom and then reached under her skirt
and began touching her. Later that day, she recalls Maxwell telling her: "I heard you did well."
During the same trip to Palm Beach, Epstein forcibly raped after which Epstein told
her, in sum and substance: "Look what you've made me do, you've made me cheat on her, that's
not my deal with her." Epstein told that he had an arrangement with Maxwell, and
that he was permitted to have "fool aroun wit other women, but not permitted to have "full
sex."
recalls that, during the years she was in contact with Maxwell and Epstein,
Maxwell wou sometimes ask her if she knew anyone who could massage Epstein.
She recalls Maxwell saying, on some occasions, "Do you now anyone who can give him a blow
job today? I don't feel like it." However, in conversations in which Maxwell would ask her to
bring girls, recalls Maxwell saying: "They have to look young at least." Although
Maxwell wou encourage her to bring other girls, never did.
When was approximately 20 years old, Maxwell introduced her to a
person named Mic ae 'ar and. Maxwell told Garland (in front of that Maxwell
had known since she was 17 years old. Based on Maxwe s comment,
believes that Maxwell knew that was under 18 when they met.
9 recalls that Maxwell sent a handbag as a gift for her eighteenth
birthday with a note that said: "All of our love, Jeffrey and Ghislaine."
Page 11
relationship with Maxwell and E • stein continued in this manner for
several ears, unn w ich time
However,
prow' us wi i emai • e exc wi Epstein, as recent y as 2012, which are
en it y in tone. In one email from 2008, writes to Epstein in prison, expressing her
love and support. cracking jokes about Epstem's imprisonment, and offering to visit.
has explained that it took her a long time to process her abuse, and she felt bonded to Epstein for
a long period of time. Looking back on her emails, she is upset and embarrassed that she felt this
way about Epstein.
1=Pril
currently liv
Our team has met with three times, gm= in Au t 2019
an most recent y in December 2019. Aside om er interviews with our team, has
never spoken with law enforcement regarding Epstein.
In approximate y , whence was 16 and ving ,
a, m.io has alleged that Maxwell and E stein sexually assaulted her
wen was an adult. has been interviewed by several news outlets
since Epstein's 2019 arrest, and she
Page 12
she recalls receiving a phone call from her sister who told her that Epstein was interested in
meeting her and helping with her college applications. was a junior in high school at the
time.
In flew on a commercial airline to New York City to spend a
weekend with an meet Epstein. does not recall how her travel arrangements were
made. During t e trip, sta ed at and saw Epstein twice. During the
first meeting, a driver plc up an to e t em to see the Phantom of the Opera,
as a gift from Epstein. Before hea mg to the eater, the car stopped at Epstein's townhouse, where
met E stein and discussed her plans for college applications with him. Epstein offered to
e p, and was impressed by Epstein. She got the impression that Epstein intended to help
her obtain a summer trip or summer experience that would strengthen her college applications. No
themselves. During that same trip, saw Epstein or a seconi. when she and met
physical contact occurred during that meeting, and and went to the theater by
Epstein at a movie theater, where they saw "12 Monkeys." During the movie, Epstein put d
on leg, and held her hand while rubbing her arm and brushin her foot with his foot.
was uncomfortable, but did not say anything during this encounter. did not think
noticed what was happening. and she did not tell her what had occurre
After returning to Arizona, began researching trips for the summer. She recalls
that Epstein contacted her to invite her or a weekend at his ranch in New Mexico in
called her mother to discuss the trip." She was under the impression that Maxwell would be on
the trip as well, and although she had not met Maxwell at this point. her sister had mentioned her
many times. was looking forward to meeting Maxwell, and felt more comfortable going on
the trip because s e knew Maxwell would be there.
MIflew to REM on a commercial airline in R.. when she was 16.
She recalls meeting Maxwe w en s e arrived. Maxwell was frien y an appeared to already
know about her, and describes feeling as though she already knew Maxwell. Maxwell took
on a shopping trip in the town, where they talked and bought small items. recalls
having extensive conversations with Maxwell, during which they discussed her life, er plans to
go to college, how her junior year of high school was going, the homework that she had brought
with her, and her sister.
recalls that only Maxwell and Epstein were at the ranch, and the stayed together
in a small area on the property. While they were at the ranch, Maxwell told that Epstein
loved foot massages, and showed her how to massage Epstein's feet. was uncomfortable,
but followed Maxwell's lead. Later in the weekend, Maxwell and Epstein took to a movie
theater, where they saw "Primal Fear." During the movie. Epstein again held hand and
rubbed her arm, but this time felt as though Epstein did this more ope y, even though
mother to. the travel arrangements. did not re•la how the travel arrangements were
" When was originally interviewed b the FBI • she said that Maxwell called her
made when we interviewed her during our investigation.
Page 13
Maxwell was there. Later in the weekend, Maxwell asked if she had ever had a massage,
and offered to massage her. Maxwell set up a massage to e in an open area of the house, and
massaged  During the ma. Maxwell folded down the sheet, exposing breasts.
and rub around her chest. was uncomfortable and concerned that Epstein would see
this, because the door was open. However, she does not recall Epstein being present during the
massage."
During the last morning of the trip, E stein came into her bedroom and got into her i .
bed, saying that he wanted to cuddle with her. did not want him to do this, but he was
behaving in a joking manner and she felt that she co d not say no. Epstein began spooning her,
and she got up to go to the bathroom in order to stop what was happening. Maxwell was not in
the room when this occurred." flew home that da . and Epstein arrasarranged for her to take a
trip to that summer. e she was in spoke with , who
said she to n assaulted by Epstein, and tol "We're done with em." d no
contact with Epstein or Maxwell thereafter.
has provided us with a copies of excerpts from her diary from which
include entries lscussing the trip to New York. and her feeling that Epstein's conduct was creepy.
The diary does not include entries for the
commercial flight records for trove ut we
jet to determine whether Epstein was in New York and
described. Records show that Epstein flew to New Yor
on I , which is consistent with the timeframe
occurred, and is consistent with her diary en showin that s
. With respect to the tri to
Epstein was in
reflect that E

II. Proposed Charges. Elements of the Offenses, and Venue
trip. We have not been able to obtain
ye reviewed records for Epstein's vate
during the timeframes
, and left New York
reports this trip to have
e returned from New York on
, the flight records do not reflect that
thinks this trip occurred, but they do
a month later, in late Ma
We propose to charge Maxwell with one count of conspiring to violate 18 U.S.C.
§ 2423(a) (transporting minors with intent to engage in criminal sexual activity), in violation of 18
U.S.C. § 371, and one count of conspiring to violate 18 U.S.C. § 2422 (enticing a minor to travel
to engage in illegal sexual activity), in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371. Count One carries a statutory
12 When was originally interviewed by the FBI
present or this incident.
investigation.
" When was originally interviewed by the FBI
into the room and saw that Epstein was in her bed.
investigation, she did not recall this.
did not recall this
, she recalled that Epstein was
en we interviewed her during our
ir she recalled that Maxwell walked
iwe interviewed during our
Page 14
maximum penalty of five years' imprisonment, with no mandatory minimum. Count Two carries
a statutory maximum penalty of five years' imprisonment, with no mandatory minimum. The
elements of both offenses are set forth below. Both conspiracies would cover the time period 1994
to 1997.
Count One, 18 U.S.C. § 371 (Conspiracy, with the object to commit 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a))
Charged period: 1994 to 1997
Count Two, 18 U.S.C. § 371 (Conspiracy, with the object to commit 18 U.S.C. § 2422)
Charged period: 1994 to 1997
STATUTE Flamm PROOF AS TO EACH ELEMENT
18 U.S.C. § 371 1) Two or more persons
unlawfully agreed to violate:

Section 2423(a) [Count Onel

Section 2422 (Count TwoJ

• See above
2) Defendant knowingly and
willfully became a member of
the conspiracy; and
• See above
3) An overt act in furtherance of
the conspiracy.
• See above
Venue • Some of the conduct occurred at
Epstein's Manhattan residence
Below, we address the case law regarding the respective objects of the offenses—violations of
Title 18, United States Code. Sections 2423(a) and 2422—before turning to the specific proof as
to each element of the proposed charges.

Section 2423(a): Transporting a Minor for Illegal Sexual Activity
Title 18, United States Code, Section 2423(a) provides:
A person who knowingly transports any individual under the age of 18 years in
interstate or foreign commerce, or in any Territory or Possession of the United
States, with intent that such individual engage in prostitution, or in any sexual
Page 15
activity for which any person can be charged with a criminal offense, shall be fined
under this title or imprisoned not more than ten years, or both.
"To secure a conviction under § 2423(a), the government . . . must prove beyond a
reasonable doubt that the defendant: (1) knowingly transported a minor across state lines and (2)
with the intent that the minor engage in sexual activity for which some person could be criminally
charged." United States r. Vargas-Cordon, 733 F.3d 366, 375 (2d Cir. 2013).
Transportation
The statute 'lures roof that the victim was trans ..rted across state lines.
Knowledge of Age
Regarding the victim's age, because Section 2423(a) is a crime of intent, the statute
requires proof — as of the time of the victim's transportation across state lines — that the defendant
knew that the intended sexual act would be unlawful because of the victim's age.
Intent Requirement.
The statute requires proof that the defendant transported the victim with intent that the
victim engage in "sexual activity for which any person can be charged with a criminal offense."
18 U.S.C. § 2423(a). Section 2423(a) is a crime of intent, and according!y the government need
not prove that the intended sexual activity ultimately occurred.
Page 16
It bears noting that the government is not required to prove that the unlawful sexual
activi was the defendant's onl for rtin • the victim.
Unlawfirl Sexual Activity
IS
Page 17
Page 18
-i
Page 19

Section 2422: Enticing a Minor to Travel for Illegal Sexual Activity
Title 18. United States Code. Section 2422' s provides:
Whoever knowingly persuades, induces, entices, or coerces any individual to travel
in interstate or foreign commerce, or in any Territory or Possession of the United
States, to engage in prostitution. or in any sexual activity for which any person can
be charged with a criminal offense, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not
more than five years. or both.
The terms "sexual activity," and "criminal offense" are defined in the same 'limner as discussed
above.
19 This provision is now located at 18 U.S.C. § 2422(a), but during the relevant time period, this
provision did not contain subdivisions, as § 2422(b) (enticement of minors through facilities of
interstate commerce) did not exist until 1996.
Page 20
ADDliCatt011
With respect to both conspiracy charges, as described above, we believe that
testimony—corroborated by additional witness testimony and limited documentary evi ence—
would establish that Maxwell entered into a conspiracy with Epstein to transport to New
York so that Epstein could sexually abuse her.
New York. llumall three ears of the ro sed cons'irac char es.
testimony would clearly establish that Epstein abused in Florida and
As not e, Maxwe l panic!
behavior, discussed the upcoming trips with
m grooming activity • y norma g sexua
and accompanied her on certain flights.
Although does not have a specific memory of discussing her exact age with
Maxwell at any given time, we nevertheless believe the evidence easily proves Maxwell knew
was younger than 17. In particular, Maxwell met at . when she was
fourteen years old, and spent a considerable amount of time wit urmg e three-year an
of the proposed charges, during which time she: (1) met mother, 2) traveled with
and (3) spoke with about her school and home i e. In addition, never concea
her age from Epstein and Maxwell, and in fact the entire pretense of their re ationship was that
was a young student who needed mentoring and sponsorship.
Page 21
Statute of Limitations
Amendments to Statute of Limitations for Crimes Against Children
Although a federal criminal case ordinarily is subject to a five-year statute of
limitations, since at least 1994 there have been expanded statutes of limitations for sexual offenses
against children. In 1994, the statute of limitations in effect for sexual offenses against children
ran until "the child reaches the age of 25." 18 U.S.C. § 3283 (1994) ("No statute of limitations
that would otherwise preclude prosecution for an offense involving the sexual or physical abuse
of a child under the age of 18 years shall preclude such prosecution before the child reaches the
age of 25.").
However, in Apri
2003, Section 3283 was revise to permit e prosecution o sex o enses against minors at any
time during the lifetime of the minor victim. 18 U.S.C. § 3283 (2003) ("No statute of limitations
that would otherwise preclude prosecution for an offense involving the sexual or physical abuse,
Page 22
or kidnaping, of a child under the age of 18 years shall preclude such prosecution during the life
of the child.").20
20 Section 3283 was further revised in January 2006 to permit the prosecution of such offenses
during the lifetime of the victim or ten years after the offense, whichever is longer. That
amendment is not relevant to our analysis here.
Page 23
Application of the Statute of Limitations in This Case
Application of Section 3283 to the Proposed Charges
Page 24
III. Anticipated Defenses
Factual Arguments
Page 25
Legal Defenses
Page 26

IV. Cooperating Defendants
None currently and none expected.
V. Discover Issues
We have reviewed the SDNY Discovery and Disclosure Policy and believe we will be
able to provide all limns:try discovery materials to the defense on a timely basis. That assumes,
however, that the FBI adequately processes and provides us with materials gathered through
numerous search warrants of Epstein's properties and residences. To date, we have not received
most of the materials seized in July and August of 2019, which comprise many terabytes of data.
Assuming we eventually receive those materials and appropriately review them for pertinence, we
nevertheless note that discovery in this case will be significant, due to the prior investigations. On
this score, we require significant assistance from the FBI that to date has not been forthcoming.
We are aware of two substantial historical sets of materials (in addition to materials we
have obtained as part of our current investigation) that will require discovery and disclosure
processes: files maintained by the Department of Justice FOIA office, and files maintained by the
FBI in Florida in connection with the initial investigations.
Page 27
We also expect to need to determine what protections should cover discovery materials,
potentially including the need for redactions of victim identifying information.

VI. Charges Not Applicable Or Not Currently Recommended
Page 28
Page 29
Page 30
VII. Recommendation
I
I
I
I
Page 31
■
VIII. Forfeiture / Restitution
We expect to seek restitution in this case. Restitution is mandatory under the Victims
of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000 (the "TVPA"). and includes "the full amount
of the victim's losses" including "any costs incurred by the victim for—(A) medical services
relating to physical, psychiatric, or psychological care; (B) physical and occupational therapy or
rehabilitation; (C) necessary transportation, temporary housing, and child care expenses; (D) lost
income; (E) attorney's fees, as well as other costs incurred; and (F) any other losses suffered by
the victim as a proximate result of the offense." 18 U.S.C. § 1593(b)(3) (incorporating by
reference 18 U.S.C. § 2259(6)(3)). The statutory language is circumscribed by a requirement of a
causal connection between the offense of conviction and victim's harm, but "mathematical
precision" is not required.

IX. Coordinated Proceedings
Does the offense conduct involve fraud/false claims on a federally funded program, or
fraud on or committed by a federally insured financial institution? No.

X. Victim Issues
Does the case involve victims? Yes. The case involves at least three victim-witnesses.
We will be highly attuned to victims' rights and associated processes, and we will coordinate with
the SDNY victim and witness coordinators as well as with the FBI victim liaisons. To date, all of
the victims discussed in this memorandum have been entered into the Victim Notification System
and have been connected with an FBI victim specialist.

XI. Speedy Trial Act Calculations & Deadline
The defendant has not yet been indicted.
Page 32
XII. Plans for Arrest
We expect to arrest the defendant following the filing of the proposed indictment. The
arrest plan will vary depending on Maxwell's location when the FBI is prepared to make an arrest.
By: /s
Assistant United States Attorneys
EFTA00009016 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Alex Acosta pages 201-300
(date: 2020-04-30)
Page 200
1 day, you were calling for some edits that really reflected --
2 seemed to reflect a real discomfort --
3 A
4 Q -- as you identify.
5 A Again, I'm perhaps supporting -- I'm supporting the
6 point you're trying to make that we were focused on getting
7 this done, and real concern that he would not go to jail.
8 And a question that I think is a valid one in my mind is, did
9 the focus on, let's just get this done and get a jail term,
10 mean that we didn't take a step back and say, let's evaluate
11 how this train is moving?
12 Q You --
13 A From my perspective.
14 Q Okay. I want to just sort of round out the little
15 bit of this -- the state -- the state only resolution. You
16 used the term a couple of times backstopping. What do you
17 mean by that?
18 A What I mean by that is, a sense that the state
19 wasn't doing enough, and perhaps backstopping is a polite way
20 of saying encouraging the state to do a little bit more.
21 Q MM-hmm. All right. Did you have any discussions
22 about whether this disposition comported with the Ashcroft
23 memo in that you were hunting to the state for a minor
24 charge, for a fairly minor charge, what you -- your office
25 had already understood from the evidence was a quite wide
1 ranging scheme of predatory, my term, behavior regarding
2 minor victims?
3 A So, I don't recall a discussion around the Ashcroft
4 memo. I would characterize what we did differently, in that
5 there are any number of instances where the federal
6 government or the state government can proceed, and state
7 charges are substantially less and different, and on a fairly
8 regular basis, the federal government allows the state no:
9 allows, but stands aside and lets the state proceed.
10 Q But in this case, you actually had an active
11 investigation that had been proceeding for a year.
12 A So, let's take the drug context, where there might
13 be any number of active investigations where the federal
14 charges can be rather substantial, but ultimately, the
20 Q But the state goes forward with what?
21 A Forward with different charges that -- that have a
22 lesser term. And so, I don't think it's unusual. We can
23 talk about, you know, whether this was the best disposition
24 or not, but I don't think it's unusual to have fact patterns
25 that are under investigation that proceed in state court,
federal government says just let the state proceed with this,
or violent crime cases where the federal government could
bring gun charges using felon in possession or another
mandatory minimum, but the state goes forward with -- so, in
that sense --
Page 202
1 where the disposition is different than -- and would have
2 been if it had proceeded in federal court.
3 Q All right. Do you have anything on that?
4 : On the two years, or something else?
5 : No. I'm going back to the two
6 years.
7 : Okay.
8 BY
9 Q Did you think -- did you believe at the time, if
10 this was part of your thinking, that because it was so
11 important to get sex offender registration, and even later
12 developed damages -- monetary damages for the victims, under
13 the state plea arrangement, that pretty much the only thing
14 that the government had -- the federal government had to give
15 up in this negotiation was jail time? If you wanted -- you
16 wanted --
17 A Right.
18 Q -- three things --
19 A Correct.
20 Q -- you've said, jail time, sex offender status, and
21 some kind of restitution or damages --
22 A Right.
23 Q -- mechanisms. Sex offender registration, there's
24 no -- really no give there. You either register or you
25 don't. I'm being binary --
Page 203
A Right.
Q -- again, I'm sorry.
A But it is binary, so --
Q It is binary.
A Yes.
Q And likewise, the --
A Right.
Q -- monetary recovery provisions. So, really, the
9 only thing to negotiate is time, right?
10 A And so, your question is why did we not start at
11 three so we ended up at two?
12 Q Well, that's -- that's -- that's a consequence of
13 what --
14 A So --
15 Q -- I was asking.
16 A So, again, my recollection is I understood this to
17 reflect what he would have received as opposed to some
18 arbitrary, let's start at three so we end up at two. I
19 also -- I'm sorry, you have a question?
20 Q No, go ahead. Go ahead. I'll get to my question.
21 A You know, I also -- from my perspective, was, you
22 know, early on when we set firm on the two years, I thought
23 two years would have been the right outcome. We ended up on
24 18 months. I can't say how. There's some documents that
25 might help, but I -- but I was at least initially firm on
Page 204
1 those two years.
2 Q Right, so you -- when you say, I thought the two
3 years was the right amount, is that based on your
4 understanding that that's what he would have gotten in the
5 state?
6 A Correct.
7 Q All right.
8 A That -- and the point I'm trying to convey there is
9 that this wasn't, to my understanding, a random number, but
10 it was informed by, this is what he would have received, and
11 therefore it is a reasonable -- agree or disagree with the
12 analysis, but it was an informed number to begin with.
13 BY
14 Q But you don't recall how that analysis was done, or
15 who conducted --
16 A
17 Q -- that analysis?
18 A -- don't recall that.
19 BY -:
20 Q Or even whether it was accurate, actually?
21 A I -- again, I don't recall that.
22 Q All right.
23 BY
24 Q And I understand the explanation.
25 A Right.
Page 205
1 Q And --
2 A Right.
3 Q -- what it's tied to, but was there any
4 consideration -- because this case --
5 A Right.
6 Q -- was not about one or two victims. It was a very
7 large scheme by this older, wealthy man, to essentially turn
8 minors into prostitutes, have sex with them, oral sex, get
9 other people involved.
10 You've described it in prior statements as
11 grotesque and deserving of punishment. What I'm not hearing
12 through this process is anybody taking a look at this overall
13 conduct, and saying, what is the appropriate punishment for
14 this man's conduct? Was there such a consideration, and did
15 you feel that two years adequately punished him for the scope
16 of his conduct?
17 A Fair question, and perhaps going back to where we
18 started, which is petite. To my mind at the time, there was
19 a distinction between what would be the adequate punishment
20 if this was a purely federal case, versus what is necessary
21 so that it is not a -- to put it in petite language a
22 manifest injustice, so that it wouldn't have come to the
23 office in the first place.
24 And that I think is the important distinction,
25 because if the two years is what he would have received, and
Page 206
1 therefore it would not have come into the office under
2 petite, then if there is a state disposition to that, that is
3 one possible outcome.
4 It would be a different outcome if this was truly a
5 federal pro=section independent of the state, which goes back
6 to the point I was making about concern about a federal
7 precedent with this kind of sentence, because then when the
8 next person comes along, they say, well, here is this
9 precedent under 371, or whatnot.
10 And so, this was, rightly or wrongly, and I
11 understand the -- the pushback -- an analysis that
12 distinguished between what is necessary to prevent manifest
13 injustice, versus what is the appropriate federal outcome to
14 that. Agree or disagree with the logic is one thing, but did
15 I explain the logic?
16 Q You've -- yes, you've explained the logic.
17 A Okay.
18 Q And I'm going to push back a little bit --
19 A Right.
20 Q -- on that, because the petite policy specifically
21 says it does not apply where the state conduct is only a
22 minor part -- an insignificant part of the entire course of
23 conduct, and they give examples about where you have some
24 type of a RICO scheme, and the state has indicted or
25 convicted the perpetrator based on something that could be
one single overt act in the government's conspiracy, and
2 doesn't that really show what is going on here, that what the
3 state had done was really just a small, minor part of this
4 scheme that the federal government had a --
A Right.
6 Q -- had a real opportunity to punish him for this
7 entire course of conduct?
8 A So, possibly, but if I can circle back to your
9 question previously, it's interesting that you characterize
10 this as, he's turning these girls into prostitutes, and then
11 I think that's really interesting, because in 2019, 13 years
12 afterwards, despite all the changes in the law, there is
13 still some element somewhere that says he's turning these
14 girls into prostitutes, whereas this was a typical
15 trafficking case of the kind that you'd see in the Lou De
16 Baca days where, you know, it was called modern day slavery.
17 That's a very different fact pattern.
18 So, you know, a girl that's held captive, is forced
9 to service multiple men per day, where this is part of an
20 ongoing business arrangement. And so, I hear what you're
21 saying, but if here at this table at least some element of
22 that characterization is live, what would it mean in 2006
23 when these laws are still being developed? And that
24 consideration, rightly or wrongly, was part of this analysis.
25 BY
1 Q Was it explicitly -- in other words, was -- was
that aspect of it, the -- I -- the perception that this was
perhaps activity that -- in which the victims cooperated?
4 Was that part of the --
S A No, no. Let me -- let me distinguish. I didn't
6 say the perception that this was activities in which the
7 victims cooperated. What I was going to -- what I -- and
8 I've gone to before is, would jurors -- is there at least one
9 juror that might say, look, we've got conflicting victim
10 testimony.
1.1 Some of them said he did nothing wrong. They all
12 knew each other. They kept going back and taking payment.
13 Is this trafficking, or is this prostitution? I'm not --
14 not saying I agree with that, and I don't think -- I don't
15 think prosecutors do, I'm saying is there -- is there at
16 least a possibility of that? And --
17 Q Was that articulated to you by the people you were
18 listening to by and --
19 A So --
21 A So, that certainly was part of the discussions when
22 I talk about the victim issues, would at least some jurors
23 view it that way, rightly or wrongly?
24 Q And you recall having that -- those --
25 A
Page
Q -- conversations?
2 A I recall having not only how would the witnesses
3 stand up in court, but how would jurors view them? And then
4 the second part of that is, as it goes up in the appellate
5 process with respect to the -- the federal nexus. And so, I
6 hear you, but you know, I -- it's -- it's sort of one of the
7 factors. And so --
8 BY
9 Q And so --
10 A
11 Q -- what I'm getting though is that there didn't
12 seem like there was a consideration or discussion about, is
13 this two years capturing the scope of his conduct, versus,
14 we're just going to tie it to this potential state crime that
15 could have been charged?
.6 A Fair, and I would -- I would say that the two years
17 was not meant -- so, the petite policy has several prongs,
18 and to my recollection, the petite analysis was not based
19 on -- and let's not even call it petite analysis. That
20 overstates it.
21 But it was much more of a, is this a manifest
22 injustice, and -- and if the original -- and so, you sort of
23 see it in the Exhibit 3. This would not have been brought to
24 the office in the first place if -- you know, if he had plead
25 to jail time and registration, and rightly or wrongly, that
Page 210
1 was understood from the very beginning of the case, and was a
2 factor in how the case was viewed.
3 Q And how do you know that it wouldn't have -- that
4 wouldn't have been upset with a minimal jail
5 time, even if there was sex registration?
6 A So, I can't 12 years later say how we knew that. I
12 : They did.
13 THE WITNESS: I can't speak for certain, but you
14 probably have that from the record, and that when they
15 changed the ASA involved and took it to grand jury, the
16 charges that came back were substantially less.
17 BY
18 Q Do you remember the circumstances? Did you know
19 the circumstances under which that ASA was changed?
20 A I don't know.
21 Q All right. The -- by the way, do you remember an
22 occasion in which came to your office in Miami
23 to press you on what was going to be happening with the
can say that my -- my general impression was that this was
proceeding at the state, that there were certain charges, and
that those charges changed when it went to a grand jury, and
that it went from -- I think they even changed the ASA
involved.
24 federal case?
25 A I don't recall.
•
1 Q You don't recall. I --
2 : Just one more,
: Yeah.
4 THE WITNESS: Yeah.
5 BY
6 Q So, before we --
7 A Yeah.
8 Q -- leave this --
9 Yeah.
10 Q -- one little thing. So, if this case had come
11 into the federal system as apart from the --
2 Ficht.
Q -- taken the digression through the --
A Rlunt.
-- state system, do you think that the two years
was an appropriate punishment, given the scope of his
conduct?
A I think if it had come into the federal system
19 apart from the whole state and the petite considerations and
20 all that, we may have ended up in a different place. I
21 viewed the two years, to my recollection, as a manifest
22 injustice standard, and not an appropriate punishment
23 standard.
24 Q Meaning whether it was manifestly unjust that he
25 get two years?
Page 212
1 A No, whether it was -- so, let me -- let me -- let
2 me rephrase. No jail time was a manifest injustice. If he
3 had gone to jail for two years in the state system and
4 registered, the question of whether it would have come to the
5 office at all, and to my recollection, the consensus was, and
6 based on Exhibit 3, agrees with that, that it would
7 never have come to the office in the first place, because we
8 would not view that under petite as a manifest injustice.
9 There are any number of cases that are prosecuted
10 around the country where an individual gets a jail time that
11 the federal government may not agree with, but that doesn't
12 mean that the federal government reprosecutes those cases.
13 The instances where the federal government reprosecutes a
14 state case are pretty rare, to my knowledge.
15 And so, under the petite standard, and the
16 petite -- the manifest injustice would -- it would have been
17 a manifest injustice to have zero jail time, and zero
18 registration, but if the original charges had remained, that
19 would be a different matter. That does not mean that that is
20 the best outcome in the state system.
21 and so, perhaps beating a -- you know, an issue,
22 but let me maybe give an example. One concern that I had was
23 that in the violent crime side, the state brings a case, and
24 you know, there is a deferment, no jail time. The state then
25 brings a second case, and there's minimal jail time. Well,
Page 213
1 now the person has done three violent crimes, they have a
2 gun, they go federal, and it's like, please don't do that.
3 Pretty please don't do that.
4 You know, we're going to punish you a little bit,
5 and then all of a sudden in comes the federal government with
6 the big, big punch to the face, because the federal sentences
7 are so different than the state sentences. And that happens
8 all the time in any number of contexts in Florida. That
9 doesn't mean that all of those cases get reprosecuted as gun
10 cases in Florida.
11 That means that we understand that the Florida
12 system is different than the federal system. And so, the way
13 we looked at, at least based on my recollection, those two
14 years was not, what would he have received if this was a
15 purely federal case, but would this case have been prosecuted
16 by the federal system additionally if he had received jail
17 time and registration in the state system?
8 Q And would -- is it fair to say that this particular
9 concern about, for lack of a better word, federalism or the
20 petite policy, was that a primary concern of yours versus any
21 of your employees in terms of or
22 A I think it's fair to say that I focused more on the
23 legal side of things, and my team focused more on the trial
24 and how this would play out at trial, and both of them
25 both of them sort of informed the outcome.
Page 214
1 Q And are you including this petite policy in your
2 consideration of the legal issues?
A Yes. Yeah. I think those are all tied together.
BY
Q So, you mentioned victim --
A But -- but could I -- could I --
Q Yes.
A But to clarify, I thought we had sufficient to go
9 forward so it wasn't an ethical violation to proceed.
10 Q Mm-hmm. Okay. The victim -- you mentioned the
11 victims coming into state court, and you talked about all the
12 victims coming into state court. Do you have any idea what
13 victims formed the basis for the original charge that --
14 A I do not.
15 Q -- he was indicted on? Do you know whether it was
16 one -- was it a felony assault pros of a non-minor.
17 A Mm-hmm.
18 Q It could have been -- it was three instances to
19 felonize it. You don't know whether it was one person three
20 times, three people?
21 A I do not.
22 Q And you don't know whether that person was a minor
23 or not?
24 A I do not.
25 Q All right.
Page 215
1 A I would assume they were, but I do not.
2 Q Likewise, do you know who was the victim, or who
3 the victims were who formed the basis for the 796.03 charge
4 to which Epstein ultimately pled in June of 2008?
5 A I did not at the time. I've read various accounts
6 of that, but that's based on matters that I've read and not
7 an independent recollection.
8 Q And what's your understanding?
9 A My understanding is that there's some that there
10 is at least some issue in the media over whether the -- the
11 right or the best victims were chosen from the prosecution's
12 perspective.
13 Q And do you know -- was there any indication of who
14 the victims were? Do you know who the victims were who were
15 the subject of the state charges?
16 A Which particular names? No, I don't.
17 Q Right, I'm not asking you --
18 A Yeah.
19 Q -- other than names --
20 A Yeah.
21 I just want to know if you know who they are or
22 how many they were.
23 A I -- I do not.
24 Q Right, it could be one, right? For this -- for the
25 solicitation. It could be one conceivably. Both the charges
Page 216
1 could relate to one victim.
2 A Right. So -- so, those matters were very much part
3 of the negotiation that  and to some extent Andy were
4 involved in. I did not --
5 Q What makes you think that -- that -- the -- your
6 people were negotiating which victims would form the basis?
A Fair. Fair point.
Q Okay.
A Fair point. I withdraw. They may not have. I
10 don't know -- I don't know how in the weeds and how much our
11 folks, as a federal system, sort of interacted with the state
12 in terms of what punishment. I -- there's at least some
13 discussion in the media regarding whether the punishment was
14 a function of the victims and registration, and I can't speak
15 to that.
16 Q All right. Are you aware, just as a point of
17 interest, that the public record of the proceedings in the
18 state court related to Epstein are utterly silent as to who
19 or how many victims form the basis of the charges to which he
20 pled?
21 A I -- no. I was not aware.
22 Q Okay. So, this idea of many victims coming forth
23 in state court and so on are not -- is not -- it's not really
24 in play. All right. So, you have a two year -- two years
25 has been now -- a two year state deal has been announced to
Page 217
1 the team by
2 A Yeah.
3 Q With your knowledge and approval, right? Because
4 he wouldn't do it otherwise. Is that right?
A Fair.
6 Q Though at least one was surprised. Do you know
7 what drove the timing of the plea offer? In other words, why
8 did it have to be made at that point?
9 A I do not.
10 Q Okay. You know that submitted his
11 resignation on the 23rd of July.
12 A I saw that in the --
13 Q Right.
14 A -- in the -- in the documents.
15 Q In the documents, and he submitted that to you
16 among other -- as well as the --
17 A Yeah.
18 Q HR people. Why not -- well, then there was a
19 July 31st meeting at which the term sheet was presented.
20 This document 15 is the term sheet that was presented, as
21 indicates in her September 6th cover note -- cover e-
22 mail. And you said you approved it. You happen to be copied
24 A Right.
25 Q -- though --
A So --
Q
A Let me --
Q -- forwards this, but --
A Let me -- let me be -- let me be accurate. I
6 approved these terms, whether it was this specific term sheet
7 or another -- another document that might have been earlier
8 that looked highly similar to this.
9 My recollection is approving a, you know,
10 approving a resolution that had him pleading to certain state
11 counts that had a binding two-year plus recommendation that -
12 - and that provided for 22.55 restitution.
13 Q Right, but you don't know if it was this sheet of
14 paper?
15 A I can't say 12 years after the fact whether it was
16 this specific sheet --
17 Q Right.
19 Q All right.
20 A -- or others. I -- based on the fact that this was
21 in the e-mail, I think it's safe to -- to assume, but --
22 Q To assume what?
23 A To assume that it was this.
24 Q oh.
2S A But it's possible that there was as slight
Page 219
1 difference in --
2 Q All right. In fact, this -- this same document
3 with a couple of --
A Right.
Q -- additional bullets that had to do with the date
6 of entry of the plea, sort of ministerial, is what was
7 prepared by on or about the 31st -- on or
8 before the 31st of July, and this document, as indicated --
9 A Mm-hmm.
10 Q -- here, along with the attached guidelines
11 calculation is what was provided to the folks who met on the
12 31st --
13 A Fair.
14 Q -- of July. Okay. So, on that 31st, it was
15 , Jerry Lefcourt, Sanchez, and the purpose of
16 the meeting with Sloman, Menchel, Lourie, and as
17 well as the case agents was to present the plea offer. And
18 did you get briefed on how that plea offer went?
19 A I don't recall being briefed, but in the regular
20 course, I would have been.
21 Q All right, and at that meeting, there was an
22 expression of concern by the defense team that Epstein wanted
23 to avoid being incarcerated in the state system because of
24 concerns for his physical safety, and that concern was
25 accommodated to the extent that the U.S. Attorney's Office
Page
team agreed to explore federal resolution. How does that
2 square with your decision that a state plea is how this case
3 was going to be --
A Right.
Q -- decided?
A So, I think I indicated later that it's a little
7 bit more fluid than a decision here or a decision you
8 know, than binary situations. My recollection is we were
9 very focused on, this man should go to jail, and this man
10 should register.
11 The two year plea to the state charges seemed
12 reasonable and seemed a way to go. We can agree or disagree.
13 Reasonable in terms of -- not in terms of, was it the -- the
14 most just outcome, but seemed like a disposition that we
Is would agree to.
:6 But ultimately, the focus was on getting him to
:7 jail, and if that meant exploring a 371, it's at least worth
18 exploring. And so, I don't think it was inconsistent,
19 because the focus really was on, he needs to go to jail.
20 Q Okay. In this case, that -- that push back of
21 the -- that resulted --
22 A Right.
23 Q -- in the agreement to explore a federal plea --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- was because Epstein was afraid to be in prison.
Page 221
1 Why would the U.S. Attorney's Office accommodate that? And
2 here, we're getting to -- we're beginning to talk about a
3 major point of criticism of this whole process and the
4 outcome and that is that it appeared that the U.S. Attorney's
5 Office was bending over backward to accommodate the concerns
6 of Jeffrey Epstein, and in this case, he was uncomfortable
7 going to a federal or state prison, but all child sex
8 predators who go to prison are going to face some --
9  Yeah.
10 Q -- challenges, right?
11 A Right, and I remember along the way a heavy push
12 that he be incarcerated at this home under some kind of home
13 confinement, and my reaction to that was no way.
14 Q Right.
15 A And okay, you don't like prison, but that doesn't
16 mean you get to be incarcerated in your house.
17 Q Mm-hr.
18 A Which is interesting, because subsequently
19 Q Yeah.
20 A And so --
21 Q Because subsequently, what? You might as well
22 finish --
23 A Well, because --
24 Q -- that.
25 A -- subsequently, the way that the state executed
Page 22
1 the terms of incarceration were not what I would have
2 expected. And so, again, the focus from my perspective is,
3 he needs to go to jail. If the team agreed to explore it,
4 you know, the 371 was on the table to the extent we had
5 been -- I'm speculating now. This is not to make the record
6 clear.
7 Q Mm-hmm. Thank you.
8 A I'm speculating, not recalling. I can speculate a
9 371 with a two year rule 11 had been discussed based on the
10 contemporaneous record, and so, to the extent it had already
11 been discussed, even if it was not the direction we were
12 taking, would it have been unusual for folks in the room to
13 say, well, look, we've discussed that, let's go back. You
14 know, let's see where it goes. I can't fault -- to the
15 extent it had been discussed -- I can't fault anyone for
16 saying, let's go back and look at it. I think that's
17 distinguishable at least from subsequent --
18 Q All right. At that point, the defense was given
19 two weeks to take it or leave it, and if not, you would
20 indict, and there were several occasions --
21 A Correct.
22 Q -- when that kind of ultimately was made. Did that
23 mean -- I mean, given all of your concerns about barriers to
24 what you would consider a successful federal prosecution, was
25 that a bluff?
A
Q
A
Q
Page 223
No.
It was not.
It was not.
You were at some level at least prepared to approve
5 the presentation of the -- or, the presentment of --
6 A We --
7 Q -- an indictment?
8 A We should not have gone forward with these
9 negotiations if we weren't ready to --
10 Q All right.
11 A -- to approve. Whether in this form or a different
12 form and indictment, and I say that because it was very much
13 a draft indictment that hadn't been reviewed fully by the
14 chain, but it wasn't a bluff.
15 Q Well, by this time it -- it had been reviewed, and
16 it --
A Had it been reviewed, and revised, and --
Q It had -- there -- there had been some efforts to
begin revising, so --
20 A So --
A
A
Yeah.
Some --
It wasn't finalized.
Yeah. Some efforts to begin --
25 Q Exactly.
Page 224
1 A Right.
2 Q Okay. Looking at 11a, this is a letter that
3 drafted to sort of actually respond to a
4 counteroffer by the defense. The counteroffer is represented
5 in Exhibit 10b, which is a letter from Sanchez
6 which we don't need to go into in detail, because as you've
7 already pointed out, essentially it was a home confinement,
8 and you know, very, very soft --
9  Yeah.
10 Q -- landing counteroffer. In 11a,
11 tweaks letter, you're copied on this, and the date is
12 August 2, Thursday, and he notes that he hadn't discussed it
13 in detail with you, but he wanted to -- he hoped that
14 tomorrow, Friday the 3rd --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- he'd have a chance to, and what's notable here
17 is that -- is that the -- there's strong language that the
18 "Office believes that the federal interest would not be
19 vindicated in the absence of a two year term of state
20 imprisonment for Mr. Epstein. That offer was not meant as a
21 starting point for negotiation. It is the minimum term of
22 imprisonment that will obviate the need for federal
23 prosecution."
24 A You're on paragraph two?
25 Q One.
Page 225
A One, yes.
Q Oh, two.
A Yeah.
Q It's the first --
A Right.
Q -- long paragraph. And then he also states that --
7 that you in the last paragraph -- the U.S. Attorney, "U.S.
8 Attorney Acosta has asked me to communicate that the two year
9 term of incarceration is non-negotiable."
10 A Yes.
11 Q That's pretty firm. That's a -- that's a line --
12 A It is.
13 Q -- in the concrete that is setting, right?
14 A Right.
15 Q And lib is the letter as it actually went out the
16 next day.
17 A And it's got the same language.
18 Q It's identical. It has the same language. It has
19 one typo corrected. This is last day in the
20 office.
21 A Yes.
22 Q And he's gone after that. Do you think that this
23 was an -- the appropriate timing to extend this offer, or to
24 set this as the minimum offer, or was it something that you
25 would've liked to have seen more fully developed in
Page 226
1 negotiations with defense counsel?
2 A I'm sorry, I don't understand your question when
3 you say more fully developed.
4 Q Well, you -- you have two years. Would -- would
5 further consideration have led the U.S. Attorney's Office to
6 decide that, well, maybe the two years is too much of a
7 giveaway; we should stick with a five year federal plea?
8 A Yeah. I can't -- so, I can't speculate this far
9 after the fact whether waiting an additional time period and
10 further discussion would have changed things. I can tell you
11 how we came up with it, but that -- that's a lot of
12 speculation.
13 Q Would you say that was -- as the
14 criminal chief, was essentially the driver of this -- of the
15 resolution --
16 A Right.
17 (2 -- presented in this letter?
18 A I can't. Again, you're asking me to speak to
19 something from 12 years ago. I can't speak to it. I was
20 aware of the multiple prongs. I approved it. If we had had,
21 you know, if -- if a -- at some point -- is your question is
22 if at some point there had been a, let's sit down and
23 reconsider meeting, would we have gone in a different
24 direction? Perhaps, but I can't, 12 years after the fact,
25 speculate as to what may have happened if something had
Page 227
1 happened.
2 Q All right.
3 A That's just a lot of hypotheticals.
4 Q Understood. The question though is whether Matt
5 Menchel, who was the author --
6 A Right.
7 Q -- of this, who first raised it --
8 A Right.
-- with 9 Q Sanchez --
10 A Yeah.
11 Q -- in an informal discussion, and who presented it
12 to the U.S. Attorney's Office team, was this really his baby?
13 A I can't --
14 Q Approved by you.
15 A I can't -- I don't remember who I talked to about
16 what, and so it wouldn't be fair for me to -- you know, I
17 can't single out any one person as having a greater or lesser
18 role.
19 Q Well, you were not the architect of this, right?
20 You approved it as you've described it.
21 A No, I haven't said I wasn't the architect. What I
22 said is I don't recall --
23 Q Right.
24 A I recall approving it. You know, I -- I think what
25 I'm trying to convey is these discussions are much more fluid
Page 228
1 than I think any one single architect. You've got multiple
2 lawyers. They interact on a daily basis. They talk back and
3 forth.
4 To -- to sort of put it in an OPR context, there's
5 probably not going to be a single author to the report.
6 You're all going to go back and forth, and there might be
7 someone that has maybe there is a single author. Who
8 knows? But it's -- I think it's difficult to say there's a
9 single person, and ultimately I was U.S. Attorney, and so I
10 approved it and
11 Q To your knowledge, did anyone in that chain of
12 A Right.
13 Q -- that five person chain or anyone else disagree
14 with this offer?
15 A To --
16 Q I'm not talking about --
17 A To my knowledge -- to my knowledge, I think
18 at sometimes may have felt uncomfortable, but whether there
19 was explicit disagreement or not, I don't recall. In terms
20 of my management chain, I don't recall any disagreement.
21 Q That you were aware of?
22 A That I was aware of. I -- I recalled discussions.
23 So, for example, might say I might proceed with a 371
24 with a two year cap under rule 11, but then we move in this
25 other direction, and I don't recall anyone saying, let's take
Page 229
1 a time out, let's reconsider.
2 Q All right.
3 A And let me -- let me just clarify, I think at
4 various points in this case -- and it's hard -- it's hard to
5 sort of single out the timeline. Ms. was
6 supportive, or maybe I wish we would go in a different
7 direction, and that sort of went in and out a little bit.
8 Q On her part?
9 A Yes.
10 Q Let me ask you this. Having reached the decision
11 that you approved --
12 A Right.
13 Q -- that this was the offer, and the term sheet, or
14 the terms, having that decision made, would you have expected
15 your line AUSA to frustrate that, or to not abide by that,
16 since it was your decision?
17 A No, with a caveat that if at any point someone felt
18 truly uncomfortable, I would expect them to come and talk to
19 me about it.
20 Q And can you recall any instance in which an AUSA --
21 a line AUSA came and talked to you about a disposition that
22 he or she was uncomfortable with?
23 A Yes. So, I'll give you an example. I don't recall
24 who, before you ask me, but there was this AUSA who was new
25 to the office who impressed the hell out of me. I'm sorry,
Page 230
1 that's not appropriate language -- who impressed me
2 significantly.
3 He had inherited a case, and it was a fraud case,
4 and the -- the bigger players had been charged, and he was
5 basically given a lesser player to -- to basically just
6 finish up on, right?
7 It was a done deal. The person was ready to plead
13 Q Me-hom.
14 A Which, for a new AUSA in the office is pretty gusty
15 and unusual, but if this person really felt that this lesser
16 player wasn't deserving, then that was the right thing to do.
17 Q Right.
18 A And so, I don't -- and the person was not punished
19 for it.
20 Q Mm-hem.
21 A If anything --
22 Q Mm-hmo.
23 A -- you know, I recounted that story to others.
24 Q Okay. A question, shifting gears --
to some minor count, no jail time, and he felt uncomfortable
with it, and went to his supervisor, and then ultimately came
up to me, and I had a discussion with this person about it,
and it ended up with my telling him to go back and call the
defense counsel and tell them we were dropping the case.
Page 231
1 Q -- a little bit, about 18 USC 22.55.
Yes, okay.
Q Not to be confused with 22 -- 28 USC 22.55, which
every prosecutor is familiar with. So, whose idea was that?
It's, it's a civil provision, a civil -- it's not
restitution, it's damages. It's a damages recovery provision
7 in the criminal code.
8 A Right.
9 Q Who came up with that?
A I can't speak to who came up with it.
11 Q Okay.
12 A I can speak to -- to the reasoning behind it.
13 Q Your reasoning, or the proponent's reasoning?
14 A My recollection of the reasoning as to why we
15 thought it was important.
16 Q And the importance was to provide a mechanism for
17 recovery of damages?
18 A To -- yeah.
19 Q Okay.
20 A Yeah. I mean, the victims bad situation, and we
21 just and here is -- well, go on.
22 Q All right.
23 A I might circle back on something.
24 Q So, is it fair to say that's a fairly -- had you
2'. ever heard of it before? Had you come across it before?
Page 232
1 A I don't know, but I don't think so.
2 Q Okay. So, is it fair to say it was novel to the
3 office? To you, and to this team?
4 A I don't want -- I don't think it's fair to say that
5 it's novel to the office.
6 Q Well, to the -- do you -- do you recall whether
7 anybody in the team had had experience with 18 USC 22.55 in a
8 criminal --
9 A I don't have a recollection of any discussion as to
10 whether people had experience with this or not.
11 Q Did you believe that any legal research was needed,
12 or should be undertaken to ensure that the procedure was in
13 fact legally sound when embedded, as it was in this case, in
14 a criminal plea?
15 A So, I would have expected to the extent that there
16 were concerns. Again, we had incredibly experienced --
17 between the various individuals on my management team, we
18 probably had 50 years plus of criminal experience. I would
19 have expected to the extent their concerns, for those
20 concerns to be raised.
21 Q Did you raise any -- any such concerns about it, or
22 did it seem to make sense to you?
23 A From my perspective, I recall -- I don't know if it
24 was at the time or subsequent to it, reading it, and and
25 it seemed -- it seemed to -- to make sense.
Page 233
1 Q Okay. After letter went out on the
2 3rd of August, you almost immediately -- it appears you
3 received a telephone call from Kirkland S Ellis, is that
4 correct?
5 A That -- I don't recall it independently, but that's
6 what the record shows.
7 Q All right, and that's reflected in Exhibit 12. Do
8 you remember who called you?
9 A I do not.
10 Q Do you recall -- it apparently was from the context
11 of this Exhibit 12, it -- and the caption, Epstein.
12 A Right. Right.
13 Q It appears that the call related to Epstein,
14 correct?
15 A Correct. Again, I don't remember the phone call,
16 but from the e-mail, I accept that it happened.
17 Q So, what had been your knowledge and relationship
18 of -- with Ken Starr of Kirkland S Ellis --
19 A Right.
20 Q -- up to this point?
21 A So, I had been an associate at Kirkland, I think I
22 indicated, what was it --
23 Q Mm-hmm.
24 A -- from '94 to '90 -- what was it? Was it '96 or
25 '97?
Page 234
Q A couple of years.
2 A For a couple of years. I worked on at least one
3 case that I recall with him. I was the junior associate on a
4 merits brief that he argued. He, at the time, was also
5 special counsel. And so he wasn't in the office nearly as
6 much because he was double hatting as special counsel --
7 Q Me-ham.
8 A -- and partner.
9 Q mm-hmm. All right, and what about
10 A Sc, was a partner at the time.
11 don't recall working with him on any particular case,
12 although I think I worked with him on at least a matter. He
13 was on my hallway. He had an outside office. I had the
14 typical inside office.
15 Q Had you had any interaction -- any contact with
16 them in the intervening years, socially or professionally?
17 A Off and on, I was in Washington. They -- you know,
18 Ken Starr was in Washington. I think III had moved to New
19 York but then came back to Washington to be in the
20 administration, and he was in the policy office, and we may
21 have -- not may have. We likely interacted.
22 Q And while you were here at the criminal -- at the
23 civil rights division?
24 A Correc. .
25 Q All right, and did you -- were you friends? Were
Page 235
1 you professional acquaintances? Were you what? How would
2 you characterize that?
3 A We were professional acquaintances that had worked
4 together several years ago that continued to interact.
5 Q Is that true as to the two of them?
6 A I mean, it's hard to characterize these things. I
7 think -- I think that's fair to say.
8 Q Did Ken Starr know who you were?
9 A Yes.
10 Q And obviously as well?
11 A Yes.
12 Q Okay. So, what was your reaction to being
13 contacted by them in -- by their firm, them, presumably one
14 of --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- them perhaps?
17 A So --
18 Q In --
19 A So, I don't know who called based on the e-mail. I
20 can infer that it was one of them.
21 Q 14M-hmm.
22 A And you know -- and I think my reaction is captured
23 by not my e-mail, but -- but by Jeff's comment, and what -- I
24 don't have a clear recollection, but I'm going to
25 speculate/infer that I heard they were being brought onto the
Page 23E
1 case, and I probably walked down to Jeff's office and said,
2 hey, Kirkland's coming onto the case, I bet you they're going
3 to come on to try to take this up to D.C.
4 And then I get a phone call, and -- you know, and
5 then I tell Matt, who tells Jeff, you know, I didn't know,
6 maybe -- Kirkland made a call to -- you're right,
7 unbelievable.
8 And then I say they're likely to go to D.C. We
9 should strategize a bit. My concerns behind that are, will
10 D.C. look at this as sort of legally troubled, going back to
11 the earlier points that I made about the policy issues around
12 the trafficking issues up here in D.C.
13 Q Mm-hmm.
14 A And I really do think he should go to jail. And
5 so, I want to strategize a bit.
16 Q So, did you have concern about the fact that you
17 were -- that the defense team was sort of appealing you to
18 the big house?
19 A I think based on this, I almost predicted this
20 would happen.
21 Q Yeah.
22 A And Jeff is saying, you were right, unbelievable,
23 where I in some way, shape, or form predicted that something
24 would -- someone would be hired, or something would happen to
25 take this all up to D.C.
Page 237
Q And had you experienced other cases other
2 instances in which defense team went to D.C. while you were
3 at U.S. Attorney's Office -- while you were the U.S.
4 Attorney?
5 A Yes.
6 Q Was that a concern to you?
7 A It wasn't a concern. It was a, how do we address
8 this so that we can back our position and our office.
9 Q Did you have concerns about the disposition that
10 was underway? About -- main justice scrutiny of the NPA
11 scheme?
12 A So, I had no concerns about main justice scrutiny
13 of the NPA scheme. In fact, I invited Drew to come down --
14 Q Right.
15 A -- and he was part of the meeting where we
16 discussed the NPA. And so, I say that because if I had
17 concerns, I wouldn't have invited him. If anything, my
18 concern was, is main justice on board, or are we going to
19 basically be told to drop this case when it goes up to main
20 justice?
21 MM-hmm. In your e-mail to , when
22 Sloman's on vacation --
23 A Yeah.
24 Q -- you say that -- you make reference to a process
25 foul, that the attorneys in the defense team want to go to
Page 238
1 D.C. on the case on the grounds of a process foul, i.e., that
2 I have not met with them, and you expressed concern that that
3 would delay matters. Is that what led you to agree to meet
4 with the defense team on the 7th of September?
5 A It is. My concern was it they came up to D.C., and
6 the first talking about was the U.S. Attorney didn't even
7 agree to meet with us, that's not the best -- that's not the
8 best foot to start with when you're having your case
9 reviewed.
10 Q So, what was your understanding of what the purpose
11 of the meeting on September 7th was supposed to be?
12 A They wanted to argue -- they, being defense
13 counsel, wanted to argue why we should not pursue this case.
14 Q And in this case, it was Starr and Lefkowitz from
15 Kirkland & Ellis, and Lilly Ann Sanchez, I believe who met
16 with you.
17 A Fair. I remember it was Starr and Lefkowitz. I
18 don't know if it was Lilly Ann.
19 Q All right, and our information is it was you, Drew
20 Oosterbaan, Sloman, , and John MacMillan. Do you --
21 do you know John MacMillan?
22 A Vaguely.
23 Q All right. He was an AUSA as well.
24 A Right.
25 Q Correct? In West Palm?
Page 239
1 A Right, and if I can just add, again, I -- I invited
2 Drew --
3 Q Mm-hmm.
4 A -- so, Drew became fully aware of that, and my
5 concern in getting Drew into the meeting was to not have them
6 appeal us, and then having Drew say, not a good case.
7 Q All right. So, were you aware that Drew Oosterbaan
8 had, in preparation for this, gone to West Palm and actually
9 gone through the evidence and met with the case agent and the
10 line AUSA
11 A I was not. Drew is an independent actor and could
12 do what -- yeah, what he thought appropriate.
13 Q Did that -- does that seem like an appropriate
14 thing for him to have done in your eyes?
15 A Sure.
16 Q Okay. Would you describe the meeting -- oh, and
17 two other people who were there were, again ASAC Val Parlave
18 and Junior Ortiz --
19 A Right.
20 Q -- the SSA. So, and the meeting I think was in
21 West Palm Beach.
22 A Yes.
23 Q So, what do you recall about the meeting? The
24 dynamics? Who spoke? How did it go down?
25 A I recall there were a lot of people. I think Mr.
Page 240
Starr spoke most of the time. I think -- my recollection, as
best as I can -- you know, with the caveat I thought
was there and clearly he wasn't. So, presented
4 several arguments. I then either left the room with my team,
5 or I think I most likely asked them to leave the room. I
6 then went around and --
7 Q Asked who to leave the room?
A Asked the --
Q The defense?
10 A -- defense. I then went around the table, and
11 said, does anyone have any concerns, or something to that
12 effect. And then hearing none, I asked them to come back in,
and I reaffirmed the position of the office.
'4 Q In other words, you sort of decided -- you ruled
from the bench, as it were. Fair enough?
16 A Fair enough.
17 Q Okay. You didn't take -- take it under advisement.
18 You gave them what your position was right then and there.
19 A That -- that's my recollection. I don't know if
20 you have information contrary, but at least --
21 Q Okay.
22 A -- that's my recollection.
23 Q Okay. So, is it fair to say it was more of a
24 presentation on the part of Ken Starr and his side rather
2; than a debate or discussion?
Page 241
1 A I think that that's fair to say. I may have asked
2 a question or two, but my -- my recollection was not was
3 not a negotiation, but a, let's hear you out.
4 Q And so, we understand it was mainly a federalism
5 presentation, as opposed to evidence, is that accurate?
6 A I believe that's accurate, yes.
7 Q And in your letter to Ken Starr dated -- the letter
8 is actually not dated, but we know that it was sent on the
9 4th of December --
10 A Okay.
11 Q -- of 2007, and it's in this package. You noted
12 that --
13 A Which exhibit?
14 MR. GONZALEZ: 34.
15 BY
16 Q Thank you. Exhibit 34. You note on page four --
17 I'm sorry, page five, you -- you referred to the federalism
18 arguments, and you say that after considering the arguments
19 and conferring with the FBI and Drew Oosterbaan, you decided
20 to proceed with the indictment, but that you would delay
21 presentation of the indictment to allow the defense to appeal
22 to D.C. Does that mean that you didn't find the federalism
23 arguments sufficiently persuasive to you to change your
24 position?
25 A Yes, with the position defined as some concern, but
Page 242
1 if we need to -- if we don't come to a resolution based on
2 the sheet, then we indict.
3 Q And there is a letter of --
4 BY
Q I'm sorry, when you say some concern, some concern
6 about the federalism argument?
7 A Yeah. Going -- going back to what we talked about
8 with respect to the earlier conversation about solicitation
9 versus trafficking, and the federal nexus. But back in July,
10 we had decided that we were going forward, that either there
11 is this pre-indictment resolution, or we go forward with an
12 indictment. The September meeting did not alter or shift our
13 position.
14 BY
15 Q Even though you had some federalism concerns of
16 your own, they didn't rise to a sufficiently high level.
17 A So, their request -- their request was to drop the
18 matter.
19 Q Right.
20 A And -- and --
21 Q Okay.
22 A -- going back again, understood. There is -- there
23 is legal risk. There is witness risk. All of these. If we
24 can get pre-indictment resolution, good. If not, the
25 indictment was not a bluff. It was -- it was real.
Page 243
1 Q So, was -- I mean, Ken Starr is of course well
2 known.
3 A Right.
4 Q He was solicitor general, he's -- you know,
5 etcetera. Did you find his arguments well set forth?
6 Impressive?
7 A So, you're asking for something that's 12 years
8 if I had to characterize, by the time this meeting took
9 place, there had been a fair amount of thought around these.
10 There had been a fair amount of -- and I at least felt
11 comfortable that while there was some legal risk, he
12 needed -- we needed -- you've got to balance the legal risk
13 and the precedent risk with -- with outcomes, and Mr. Epstein
14 should go to jail, and should register, and I felt
15 comfortable -- I felt comfortable enough to basically
16 reiterate our position that --
17 Q But my -- but my question with respect to --
18 A Right.
19 Q -- was, did you enjoy the give and take with --
20 with a man of Mr. Starr's --
21 A In all candor, no.
22 Q -- standing?
23 A No.
24 Q No? Not at all.
25 A Not at all, because --
Page 244
1 Q All right.
2 A -- it would have been easier to not have the
3 meeting in the first place.
4 Q All right. Do you recall an exchange -- was he --
5 was -- were you the parson to whom he was directing most of
6 his comments?
7 A Most most likely.
8 Q And do you recall any exchange with him about the
14 A Do you mean --
15 Q -- a bell?
16 A -- was he trying to butter me up?
17 Q Was he? I mean, was he?
18 A I don't -- I -- look, this was 12 years ago. I
19 don't recall. You know, I think as we talk about this, it's
20 important to note that the position did not change. Whatever
21 exchange there may have had, our position did not change.
22 Q Right. After this meeting, within a few days, in
23 furtherance of the resolution that had been offered,
24 and Lourie met with the state attorney's
25 office to sit down and try to work out how this thing would
fact that -- sort of an observation that the two of you, you
and he, were the only two people in the room who had been
presidentially nominated and senate confirmed to any position
so that the two of you had kind of that commonality. Does
that ring --
Page 245
1 work, and mind you, this was before -- well before the NPA
2 is --
3 A Right.
4 Q -- actually formulated. Did you learn what
5 happened at that meeting? Do you know how it devolved?
6 A I may have. I don't -- I don't recall, you know,
7 sitting here today.
8 Q All right. It's at this meeting that somehow, the
9 three charges that you specified -- your office specified in
10 the term sheet became one. So, suddenly Epstein was to plead
11 only to one charge, and this was agreed to by the U.S.
12 Attorney's Office folks who were there. Do you know how or
13 why that happened?
14 A I haven't the slightest idea.
15 Q If you had known -- if they had called you on the
16 phone, sort of the mid-trial --
17 A Right.
18 Q -- call to the boss, asking what you wanted them to
19 do, what would you have said?
20 A So from my perspective, when I said -- you know,
21 when I indicated I approved this term sheet, this is the
22 minimum, I meant what I said. I also recognize that AUSAs in
23 the usual course need some degree of discretion to negotiate.
24 and so, my assumption after that September meeting, I think I
25 indicated that there was a deadline --
Page 246
1 Q mm-hmm.
2 A -- that was fairly short, was that and UM
3 and some -- working together would go back and work out an
4 agreement based on those terms, and you know, in the give and
5 take, if they think that this is an important concession,
6 that's within their discretion, but I would have been
7 comfortable sticking to that --
8 Q With --
9 A -- charge sheet. With -- something that drove me
10 is when I -- when I said something, I -- as a general matter,
11 I didn't bluff. I really meant what I said.
12 Q So, in that terms sheet, I mean, to be fair, what
13 Menchel's letter says is two years --
14 A Right.
15 Q -- is the minimum. If the decision to agree to let
16 him plead to one as opposed to all three had no impact on
17 that two years, would -- would you have cared?
18 A Fair enough, and so going -- going back to where
19 I -- you know, to an earlier discussion -- can I get another
20 Red Bull? Going -- going back to earlier discussion, I think
21 I indicated that the charges -- the state charges I wasn't
22 familiar with. And so if in the give and take, those charges
23 changed, my focus was on two years registration and
24 restitution, as long as those charges were -- captured the
25 conduct in some appropriate way.
1 Q
Page 247
So, later -- rather much later, the defense counsel
2 admitted that at this meeting, they thought --
A Yes.
Q -- that under misinformation from the state
5 attorney's office that that charge that they got the U.S.
6 Attorney's Office, or somehow the -- the U.S. Attorney's
7 Office approved, the 793 -- 796.03 charge was not sex
8 offender registerable, and that's a -- that's pretty --
9 that's a pretty major mistake, right?
A It is, and --
Q I mean, that's -- that goes to the heart of you --
A And --
4 -- one of your major concerns.
A And they tried -- they tried to get us to change
15 that, and I said no.
16 Q The defense tried to get you off sex offender
17 registration.
18 A Pretty vigorously.
19 Q Right? But at this point, the focus is on the
20 charge, and the defense is -- one might characterize it as
21 trying to pull a fast one by agreeing wholeheartedly to plead
22 to one charge, knowing or at least believing incorrectly that
23 it was not registerable, and the U.S. Attorney's Office not
24 having that belief, but thinking it was registerable.
25 So, there's a disconnect. There is error, and the
Page 248
1 error stems, as they later learned, from the ASA herself.
2 So, we look at that, and wonder whether that shouldn't have
3 raised some concern that this plan to put things back in the
4 hands of the state, which had kind of mishandled the case to
5 being with, as at this point even not a good idea, because
6 they were continually -- continuing to be -- well, I won't
7 characterize it, but less than reliable. Was that a -- is
8 that a fair comment of concern?
9 A So, one question I would have is, at what point did
10 we become aware that there had been, first, the error was in
11 our favor, not the defense's favor, because got it
12 right as opposed to the ASA.
13 Q Correct.
14 A And secondly, at what point did our team become
15 aware of them trying to pull a fast one? Was it before or
16 after the signing of the NPA?
17 Q It was well after.
18 A Right.
19 Q But the -- the point here is that the V.S.
20 Attorney's Office folks were not as familiar with the state
21 procedure -- the state criminal procedure, and the ins and
22 outs of the sentencing and incarceration, as you learned
23 later.
24 So, didn't this put the U.S. Attorney's Office side
25 at a substantial disadvantage in trying to play in the
Page 249
1 sandbox in which both the defense -- local defense counsel
2 and the ASA, were very comfortable?
3 A Possibly, although I would point out that it was
4 the AUSA who got it right.
5 Q Eventually.
6 A Not eventually. The AUSA --
7 Q Oh.
8 A -- was correct in her analysis.
9 Q Right.
10 A So, in this case, she was more familiar than the
11 state attorney.
12 Q Not by practice, but by research, or --
13 A By research, and so --
14 Q Right.
15 A -- my point is we had good people that were able
16 to, if they weren't familiar with something, the research
17 clearly worked.
18 Q But it took, as you saw in the -- in the -- in the
19 process of dealing with the work release and all of that, it
20 took a lot of --
21 A It --
22 Q -- work to keep up with those --
23 A It did.
24 errors.
25 A Which is why I say in hindsight, if, given all the
Page 250
1 effort that took place after this defer to the state was
2 reached, if all that had been known, I really think the
3 analysis would have proceeded differently, because that
4 was -- what was a lot of work. That was probably as much
5 work, if not more than a trial.
6 Q Right. Right. Right. Meanwhile, the -- we'll
7 talk about the actual text of the NPA in a moment, but
8 following that -- actually, no, before it was being
9 finalized -- before it was finalized, was
10 working to identify a federal charge, as we discussed before.
11 In that process, she came up with a plan that would have
12 resulted -- cobbling things together in an 18 month sentence
13 instead of --
14 A Mm-hmm.
15 Q -- 24 months. Somehow, that became the new floor.
16 The -- the new standard. Do you know how that came about,
17 and who actually agreed to that?
18 A I -- I don't. I -- I referenced the one e-mail
19 where I think says, he argued 12.
20 Q Right.
21 A I said 24. We agreed to 18. I assume in the give
22 and take, this was an agreement that was reached, and --
23 Q But that was 18, as -- as to the potential federal
24 charges. It somehow became imported --
25 A
Page 251
1 Q -- into the state disposition.
2 A I can't -- I can't speak to that. This was -- this
3 was something that the "trial team" was negotiating, and from
4 my perspective, this is -- these were the terms that we
5 wanted. These were the terms that I expected if they came
6 back and said, no deal. Disappointed, but go forward, but
7 they tried to get a deal, and -- and --
8 Q The defense tried?
9 A No, but our prosecutors.
10 Q Oh.
11 A And to some extent, you know, they -- and the give
12 and take of any negotiation, I don't think it's unfair for an
13 AUSA to -- to give up some things.
14 Q But did -- you had -- had stated clearly to not
15 only the defense team through the Menchel letter, but also I
16 believe at the end of the September 7 meeting, that two years
17 was the deal. So, did somebody come to you and say, looks
18 like it's going to be 18 months, and allow you to then
19 approve that?
20 A I don't recall if someone came to me separately or
21 independently of the final language. I clearly approved it
22 at some point.
23 Q MM-hmm.
24 A And so to the extent it was approved, that's --
25 that's on me, but I would -- I would argue that, you know,
Page 252
1 someone's negotiating, one said says 24, another side says
2 12. They say, let's agree to 18. To some extent as U.S.
3 Attorney, I think I have to back the -- the negotiating
4 discretion of my AUSAs.
5 But you -- you explained quite eloquently the
6 reasoning for the two year plea as being what Epstein would
7 have faced if he'd been prosecuted --
8 A Right.
9 Q -- you know, absentia, by the state appropriately,
10 and then suddenly, without any apparent relationship to that
11 analysis, the 18 months pops up from an effort to try to get
12 federal charges. And so how do you -- how -- does that not
13 undercut the basis for the two years?
14 A So, I can provide the reasoning for the two years.
15 I also though think as a as a supervisor, as U.S.
16 Attorney, it's important to understand that when individuals
17 go out into the field, negotiations take place. And if every
18 time there is some give, they need to come back to the U.S.
19 Attorney, or there is a fear that the U.S. Attorney will not
20 back us.
21 You know, there is -- there's a certain -- I think
22 there's a management issue there in that if an AUSA speaking
23 on behalf of the U.S. makes an agreement, as long as that
24 agreement is within a certain range, the U.S. Attorney should
25 back that, because they're the ones that are in the -- on the
Page 253
1 line. They're the ones that are managing the case, and it's
2 sort of unfair to consistently second guess those late
3 night -- I don't -- I don't want to characterize it --
4 Q Okay.
5 A -- as a late night negotiation, but those -- that
6 give and take that happens sometimes in a conference room or
7 on the phone.
8 Q Do you know exactly what give and take occurred in
9 this case regarding the 18 months?
10 A I do not. I read that one document.
11 Q Okay.
12 A But I do not.
13 Q All right. Any other questions on this one?
14 BY
15 Q Really quick. I agree with what you're saying in
16 principle, but in this case, you had had a -- almost like a
17 mandatory, two years is the minimum that the --
18 A Right.
19 Q -- V.S. Attorney will accept. Under those
20 circumstances, where you have come out and said, this is the
21 minimum we'll accept, would you have expected them to have to
22 come back to you to get approval for any kind of reduction in
23 that amount?
24 A Would I have expected them? I think Ms.
25 was in a tough position, because opposing counsel was coming
Page 254
1 at her. It was a tough negotiation. Would I have wanted two
2 years? Yes. Would I fault her for agreeing to 18 months? I
3 don't think that's fair to her.
4 BY
5 Q You could have said no, right?
6 A I could have, but it was an -- but she had agreed
7 to it. The process had gone further down, and to some
8 extent, I think there is a need to respect that process.
9 That happens -- I guess I was getting -- you know, this is
10 not the only case where a supervisor sort of says, this is
11 our -- this is our standard, and -- and at some point, things
12 move, and you've got to provide some discretion.
13 Q All right.
14 BY
15 Q Do you think she misunderstood the priorities?
16 That she thought you wanted to get to a resolution, and so
17 the two years could -- could be undercut, versus taking your
18 words literally and saying this is the line in the sand
19 beyond which you should not go, even if it means kill this
20 kill the resolution?
21 A So, if I had to speculate, I don't think it was a
22 misunderstanding of priorities as opposed to opposing counsel
23 was exhausting, and if you go through the full record, it
24 really was an exhausting -- opposing counsel in this case was
25 very good at taking any slight millimeter, and turning it
Page 255
1 into, oh, so you said we could do this, and in that back and
2 forth, sometimes there is a, can't we just agree in the
3 middle?
4 Q And I understand what you're saying, but weren't
5 they exhausting because the U.S. Attorney's Office would not
6 say no to them? And so they always believed from the get-go,
7 because they have a two year minimum that the --
A Right.
Q -- that the office is willing to then say, oh, we
10 can go down from there, and that that set the tone from then
11 on that they could continually chip away at you on virtually
12 every single term that came about? So, yes, they were
13 exhausting, but isn't that because the V.S. Attorney's Office
14 would not tell them no?
15 A So I would push back, because after the agreement
16 was signed, I would argue they did not chip away. They --
17 they certainly kept appealing collaterally, and we can talk
18 about that, because there were other concerns raised there,
19 but once we had that September meeting, between that
20 September meeting and the signing of the deferment in favor
21 of the state, that was all negotiated by the trial team.
22 That wasn't a, come back to the U.S. Attorney, or come to the
23 first assistant. That really, to my recollection, was, go
24 negotiate with the state -- with the line.
25 Q Well, but there were a number of things that came
about later on. I mean, they -- they continually griped
2 about the 22.55, and that got -- you know, that got modified.
3 A Later on -- and I think later on's are different
4 for some reasons we can talk about now or later, but there
5 was an attempt to work this out later on that was clearly
6 there.
7 : The --
8 THE WITNESS But I think that's very different
9 than, how was the agreement negotiated? And I think that's a
10 very different -- a different sort of timeline.
11 BY
12 Q So in your mind, was she prepared to walk away from
13 the deal if need be?
A After it was signed?
15 Q Before it was signed.
16 A Before it was signed, it honestly was, get a deal
17 or ultimately if we have to indict, we indict, and that's
18 what I said, and -- and look at it this way. After having
19 said that, if that really was a bluff, what would I look
20 like, right? I would look awful.
21 And so, for that reason, that was not a bluff.
22 That was a thought through, this is what we will do, and if
23 you don't agree to this, then we indict, and we indict. You
24 can't make those kinds of statements and not follow through.
25 The office loses credibility if you do.
Page 257
1 Q Right, but you can keep giving on certain terms.
2 A But we and my point is we did not give, with the
3 exception of that 24 to 18, we did not give.
4 BY
5 Q Well, you also gave up two charges.
6 A Again, I'm thinking of a two years, registration,
7 restitution, and so with the exception of that 24 to 18, we
8 did not give.
9 Q I want to go back. This morning, we were talking
10 about our tracks, and we talked about the legal track, and a
11 little bit about the evidence track. There's another aspect
12 of the evidence track that is in play here, because there was
13 a substantial type of evidence, and the question is, to what
14 extent were you aware of this.
15 In October of 2005, the local police executed a
16 search warrant on Epstein's residence, and among things they
17 found there were cables and cords where there had been
18 computers -- computer equipment, video surveillance, cameras,
19 and CPUs, all of that, that computer based stuff. It had
20 been removed, forgetting why necessarily. If you look at
21 Exhibit 29, were you aware of that, by the way? That that
22 had occurred?
23 A I was aware that the state had gathered evidence,
24 but not much more --
25 Q Beyond that.
Page 258
1 A -- beyond that.
2 Q Okay. So, 29 is --
A I'm sorry, I'm on 21.
Q Wait a minute, this is not the one I'm looking for.
5 73? Let's do -- do you know what? Okay. That's not -- this
6 is not the exhibit I'm looking for, and the numbers are a
7 little bit messed up.
8 There is a -- an e-mail, which I may or may not be
9 able to put my hands on -- in which informs
10 you that she really wants to get her hands on important
11 potential -- on computer evidence, that it's important
12 potential evidence, and she had a plan to get it.
13 So, the question is whether you knew at the time
14 that there was -- that the investigators had identified this
15 computer evidence as being out there, and that they believed
16 it contained a potentially very significant evidence against
17 Epstein, computers, surveillance cameras, given his
18 activity --
19 A Right.
20 Q -- in his home --
21 : He's not on it.
22 BY
23 Q All right. She did not inform you. She informed
24 someone else that we -- she informed Sloman and Manche]. on
25 July 3rd, and Lourie. My apologies. You're not on this.
Page 259
1 Where she advises them that she wants -- we want to -- "we
2 want to get the computer equipment that was removed from
3 Epstein's home prior to the state search warrant as soon as
4 possible." So, there was the stuff out there, and
5 A Right.
6 Q -- as of July, there was an abiding keen interest
7 in getting it, and the defense team was resisting the
8 prosecutors efforts to get it. Were you aware of that at
9 all?
10 A So, you -- I think you asked about that in your
11 questions to me.
12 Q Right, I did.
13 A I have no recollection of -- of this computer
14 evidence that --
15 Q All right.
16 A Did the question say that -- without getting into
17 specifics, that there was a grand jury issue around this?
18 Q It does. It --
19 A I don't have that --
20 Q It is addressed in the non-prosecution agreement if
21 you look at the final non-pros --
22 A Yeah. I don't have --
23 Q It's referred to --
24 A The question that you asked, what question was
25 that?
Page 260
1 Q The question was whether you were aware that that
2 was something that the prosecutors wanted to get?
3 A I don't -- I don't have a recollection of some
4 computer evidence.
5 Q All right, and -- and --
6 A But I think -- is there?
7 Q Are you --
8 A What was the question?
9 Q aware that was instructed by her managers
10 to delay her efforts to get this computer evidence, because
11 the defense were resisting those efforts, and it became an
12 issue of -- an issue that was in play in the negotiations?
13 A I have -- I have no recollection of that.
14 Q Okay.
15 A If you can give me one second?
16 Q Sure.
17 A Pending federal -- and so, your question said that
18 there was litigation pending in federal court relating to the
19 U.S. Attorney's efforts to obtain --
20 Q Yeah.
21 A -- computer evidence?
22 Q Without going into further detail.
23 A I -- I have no recollection of any litigation
24 pending in federal court regarding that.
25 Q All right, and were you -- did anyone suggest to
Page 261
1 you and your team that the -- or, getting to a plea deal was
2 premature, because it -- you needed to get this evidence
3 first, so that you knew whether you had potentially some very
4 important evidence again Epstein?
5 A I have no recollection, and if anything --
6 Q Okay.
7 A -- I think there was a desire to move quickly as
8 opposed to slowly.
9 Q On the plea?
10 A Yes.
11 Q And do you -- do you know where that energy came
12 from? Who was --
13 A
14 Q --wanting to --
15 A I don't, but --
16 Q move quickly?
17 A as I recall -- so, for example, when we were
18 setting up the meeting in September, there was a -- a request
19 to set it up in August as opposed to September, and we had to
20 push it back to September because of vacations or something.
21 Q All right. So, in addition to not getting the
22 computer evidence, the government curtailed the investigation
23 to a large extent, despite finding more victims. There were
24 witnesses who were not interviewed, things that were not
25 searched, property that wasn't searched, target letters not
Page 262
1 served. Do you -- so, these all would have been steps taken
2 by the FBI to enhance the federal investigation, right? As
3 opposed to back to the state --
12 BY
13 Q Were you aware of all -- of those steps that were
14 being foregone, or foreclosed?
15 A No. My -- my assumption would have been, we may
16 have to go to trial, and so we should continue to develop the
17 basis for trial. So, if I could, for example, I think I --
18 after Drew came down, I said if we go to trial, can you be on
19 the trial team? I cite that, because I'm thinking, we may
20 have to go to trial.
21 Q Right.
22 A Why not get Drew who's from Miami on the trial
23 team?
24 Q So, is it -- is it your understanding that the
25 federal investigation, notwithstanding the drafting of this
A Right.
Q -- case that this was sort of --
A Yeah.
Q -- being returned to.
A Right.
Q Was this --
MR. TODD: Are you asking Alex if he's aware of all
the things you just said?
Page 263
1 NPA, was still continuing?
2 A Yes. We -- you know, my understanding is you run
3 these on parallel tracks, and again, I'm -- I'm sitting here
4 inviting the head of CEOS to be part of the trial team, and
5 talking about how to formulate the trial team.
6 Q Okay.
7 A That -- that implies that I was clearly thinking we
8 might be going to trial.
9 Q All right. When you first received the draft of
10 the non-pros agreement, and this is 16a, it's a draft by
11 . Do you know who came up with the -- the --
12 it sounds like you didn't, but who came up with the name or
13 the moniker non-prosecution agreement?
14 A i do not.
15 Q Do you know what this was modelled on, if anything?
16 Where it --
17 A I --
18 Q What the genesis was?
19 A I do not. I noticed from the contemporaneous e-
20 mails that initially it was done differently, and I think it
21 was Lourie who said write it as a contract, or I think
22 there is -- there is an e-mail to that effect. Someone may
23 recall it better than I, but --
24 Q This version of September 10, which is the first
25 business day after that --
Page 264
1 A Yeah.
Q -- September 7th meeting, from
3 goes to her management up through you, and you do a rewrite
4 almost right away, adding original state charges which at
5 that point were all still in play, and you also added -- this
6 is Exhibit 16b -- a statement that it would be Epstein's job
7 to move the state to add additional charges, and that -- that
8 latter piece is on page three, just below paragraph eight.
9 So, you were --
A Can I -- can I back up a second?
Q Sure.
A When you say I did a rewrite, is there some
13 indication of what I did a rewrite of?
14 Q Yes. If you compare the two --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- there's -- there are things that are bracketed
17 in yellow in Exhibit 16b, which represent --
18 A Right.
19 Q -- the changes from 16a.
20 A Right.
21 Q Okay. So, those are the two things that are
22 different, and they're referenced in your -- your message --
23 A Yeah.
24 Q -- at the beginning. We bracketed them just to
25 make it easier for you to -- to recognize --
Page 265
1 A Right.
2 Q -- that. So, my point is that right from the
3 beginning, you were participating in the process -- in the
4 drafting process.
5 A Oh. So -- so, I would -- I would characterize that
6 as not participating in the drafting process, but approving a
7 draft. There is -- there is a --
8 Q I --
9 A -- slight --
10 Q -- I did a small --
11 A -- difference.
12 Q -- rewrite.
13 A Yeah. And so, something comes -- here's how I
14 would distinguish. Someone that's participating in the
15 drafting process is sitting at the table with two or three
16 people, drafting it as they go, versus something goes through
17 the management chain, and someone in the supervisory chain
18 says, can you change A, B, or C?
19 Q All right.
20 A I -- I clearly -- you know, here and in other
21 places, it looks like I'm inserting the same themes, which is
22 deferring to the state -- let's mention the state charges
23 Q 14M-hmm.
24 A -- and we can't force the state to do anything.
25 And so, I -- I'm adding to this. I'm clearly aware of it and
Page 266
1 approving it, but I wouldn't say that I was drafting.
2 Q Fair enough. Did you read it?
3 A I would assume that I read it, or else I wouldn't
4 have edited it.
5 Q All right. So, we have a draft from
6 working draft on September 10 with a small rewrite from you.
7 There is in the Exhibit 17 series indication that -- of the
8 kind of activity that was going through to come up
9 with a federal plea, but eventually she and the defense
10 attorney who is most actively working on this, Jay Lefkowitz,
11 turn back to the NPA, and if you look at 17d, just to make
12 the sort of staffing clear, you know, of course
13 has left, is going on vacation as of September
14 15, and so Lourie has helped finalize. So, the
15 finalizing of the NPA, the final version of which is in
16 Exhibit 22, falls to with , right?
17 A Yes.
18 Q Okay, and puts you on notice in 18b in that
19 process. This e-mail in 18b is sort of a follow on to 18a.
20 Do you see it comes one minute after your e-mail in 18a?
21 It's a response from her to you, only in which she makes note
22 that the defense, "tried to reopen all the loopholes that I
23 had sewn shut."
24 A Yes.
25 Q So, it's fair to say that you're kind of -- you're
Page 267
1 on notice that they're being difficult?
A I -- I -- that's fair.
Q Okay. In the course of that being difficult, 19a
4 is an e-mail to you from  on September 18 in which she
5 represents that -- or, explains that the defense is -- is --
6 that things are kind of falling apart with the negotiations,
7 and she fears the deal is going to fall apart completely.
8 MR. TODD: Should we take a quick break here?
9 You're losing your voice.
10 : I'm fine.
11 MR. TODD: You could probably use a minute.
12 : All right. We'll take a break.
13 THE WITNESS All right.
14 : A four minute break.
15 MR. TODD: Four minutes, that's --
16 : Okay.
17 (Off the record.)
18 BY
19 Q Back on the record. Looking at Exhibit 19c, you
20 say -- you write to regarding whether you're
21 available to -- at a time when she's going to be hashing out
22 language. You advise her that -- but I -- "I don't think I
23 should be part of negotiations. I'd rather leave that to you
24 if that's okay."
25 A Yes.
Page 268
1 Q Why did you say that to her?
2 A Because she was the line lawyer involved, and I
3 thought -- I think it's important for a U.S. Attorney to,
4 absent truly exceptional circumstances, to not get involved
5 in sort of the negotiations. You can meet, like I did in
6 September, reaffirm the position of the office, back your
7 AUSA, but ultimately, I think your trial lawyer needs
8 discretion to do their job.
9 Q At this point, of course we know
10 vacation.
11 A Right.
12 Q And you were aware, were you not, that
is on
Lourie
13 was about to decamp for Washington? In other words, he left
14 at the end of September --
15 A Yes.
16 Q -- to become the chief of staff and principle
17 deputy, assistant attorney general --
18 A Correct.
19 Q -- for
20 A Yes.
21 Q -- who headed the criminal division. Okay, so it
22 was really just the two of them at this point, and with
23 nobody apparently involved between them and you.
24 A So, fair, but when you say just the two of them,
25 is an incredibly experienced lawyer. So, to say just
Page 269
1 the two of them is not to take -- not -- should not imply
2 that there was an experience in that --
Q
A -- table.
Q I certainly in no way intended to --
A Right.
8 A Fair.
Q -- suggest that.
10 A Fair enough.
• Looking at 19d, in which is on page
• two, looking at the latest draft from meaning
:3 , and this is in the -- in the -- in the throes of
14 negotiating the NPA. is essentially telling you
15 he agrees with observations that the defense are just
16 up to all kinds of nonsense in this deal, and constantly
17 changing their terms, and just not apparently negotiating or
18 dealing with these warring drafts with the drafting process
19 in good faith.
20 Again, that's my characterization, but
21 says to you in this e-mail, "I suggest we simply tell him,
that his counteroffer is rejected, and that we
intend to move forward with our case." Right? And then
response is interesting. You say to him, why don't we
just -- why don't we just call him? Tell him, one, you
your
Page 270
agree, and then change things. Two --
2 A You being III agrees and changes things?
3 Q Correct. Tell him you agree, meaning, agrees?
4 A No. No.
5 Q I see.
6 A Yeah.
7 Q Tell him --
8 A Tell him, you, III, agree, and you change things.
9 Q I see.
10 A That is not acceptable to us, and is in bad faith.
11 Stop it, or we'll just indict, and then try to work it out.
2 Q So, is the try to work it out -- if the -- if
13 numbers one and two are what you should tell -- what
:4 should tell , is number three something
15 should tell or what you're telling III"? Try to work it
16 out?
17 A It's what I'm -- what I'm -- what I'm telling
8 Q okay. So, just to be clear, you say, tell him,
19 meaning you, , tell Jay, number one --
20 A So --
21 Q -- and number two, but number three is then what
22 you're instructing to do? I --
23 A Yes.
24 Q -- I'm just trying to understand.
25 A Yes. So --
1 Q Okay.
2 A So, my understanding of this is, they're being
3 difficult. Hey, this isn't the first time that an attorney
4 agrees to something and then goes back and tries to pull a
5 fast one. So, tell him you're onto this, that they need to
6 stop it, or we'll indict, but then that we'll try to -- you
7 know, should try to work it out.
8 Q Okay.
A But they need to stop this tactic.
10 Q Did you really think that was going to be effective
11 with this defense --
12 A I don't know.
13 Q -- team?
14 A You know, I think one of the hard things with this
15 is, if it was right on September 6th, it remained right,
16 irrespective of really -- I think I say, sorry, I know it's a
17 pain.
18 Q You do.
19 A This negotiation was a pain, but if it was the
20 right position, the fact that you've got annoying counsel on
21 the other side doesn't it make it less of a right position.
22 You tell them stop being annoying, you try to work it out,
23 and if not, then you indict.
24 Q All right, and is that sort of --
25 A You had a question?
Page 272
1 : I was going to, but was going
2 ahead.
3 BY
4 Q Is that -- is that consistent with your sort of way
5 of doing business, being even, and working it out?
6 A Yeah. This is our position. It's not a bluff.
7 It's what we want. You work it out. People yell and scream
8 on the other side. You work it out. If not, then we indict.
9 Q What would have been the tipping point for you?
10 What would have caused you to say, okay, I agree with you,
11 I agree with you, . Let's indict?
12 A So, it's really difficult to speculate, but I think
13 the tipping point would have been a failure to reach -- it
14 was pretty clear. Jail time, registration, restitution.
15 Okay, we moved from 24 to 18 months. That was a give and
16 take. But ultimately, if they came back and said, we can't
17 agree to these terms, then we indict.
18 Q All right.
19 BY
20 Q It seemed like your troops were telling you, we've
21 reached the end of our rope. We really want to just go
22 forward and indict.
23 A Right.
24 Q And you were coming back with, tell them again that
25 the defense is being difficult, but I want you to work it
Page 273
1 out. Does that tell your troops basically that where your
2 priority is, you want them to get to this resolution, and if
3 they have to give up stuff, it's okay -- it's really okay,
4 but you want this resolution?
5 A So, it's not if you have to give up stuff. I'm not
6 telling them to give up stuff. I'm not telling them to
7 negotiate things away, but I think -- the dynamic from my
8 perspective is incredibly -- so, there's a tactic that
9 counsel sometimes take where they negotiate, and then they
10 try to come back and renegotiate, and that is, to my
11 thinking, one of the most annoying tactics that you can have,
12 and it -- and it creates a lot of -- of frustration, and what
13 I'm trying to say is, look, they might be frustrating folks,
14 but if this had been worked out -- so -- so, looking at this,
15 we thought we had an agreement, and then they changed things,
16 and I'm saying, look, if you thought you had an agreement,
17 tell them you had an agreement.
18 Don't let them change things. I understand it's
19 frustrating to you, but if it was right two weeks ago, the
20 fact that they are frustrating attorneys doesn't change the
21 underlying legal analysis. The attorney's behavior doesn't
22 inform the rightness or wrongness of a certain disposition,
23 to a point.
24 BY
25 Q What's that point?
Page 274
A So, I think after the -- now I'm calling it an NPA.
2 I was personally very frustrated with the failure to report
3 on October 20, and had I envisioned that entire collateral
4 attack, I think I would have looked at this very differently.
Q In what respect?
A To the extent that this was -- going back to, for
7 example, the public corruption prosecutions that we had, one
8 of the values of it was to have a public figure stand up and
9 say, I did this, and plead.
10 One of the values was the, you know, avoiding a
11 long and messy legal process. And so when you put all of
12 that together, those -- you know, this is why I say it's not
13 quite -- this was the factor that we'd consider, that it's
14 all of this put together, and in something that could have
15 been very positive for the victims and for sending a signal,
16 as it dragged on, became exhausting and negative for the
17 victims.
18 It put us in a position of what do we do with
19 notifications. It put us in the position of a lot of appeals
20 to Washington. It put us in the position of having to deal
21 with complicated legal issues that actually got more messy in
22 terms of how does a federal 22.55 relate to a -- to a state
23 charge, and had all of that been known, I do think this would
24 have proceeded differently.
25 Q Differently in what way?
Page 275
1 A So -- so, if I had factored all of that -- like, I
2 can't predict it's --
3 Q Right.
4 A -- what I would have done, but I think if I had
5 known all that, this could have proceeded very differently.
6 I was very frustrated with the October to June time period.
7 Q So, if you had been back in that timeframe in early
8 September, looking at this with, I don't know, what, Harry
9 Potter character it is --
10 A Right.
11 Q -- but whoever can see into the future, and -- and
12 anticipated or foresaw --
13 A Right.
14 Q -- what would have happened, would you have simply
15 said, look, we're not going to go the state route, we'll go
16 the federal route?
17 A Quite possibly.
18 Q All right.
19 A And let me sort of -- we'll probably get into it,
20 but at some point, I do think the post versus the pre-
21 signature time period was different for any number of
22 reasons, and we'll probably want to talk about that.
23 Q All right. We will, but now, I'd like to turn to
24 some of the terms of the --
25 A Fair.
Page 276
1 Q the NPA, because you did make -- let me -- let
2 me make sure that this is correct
3 : You skipped this one.
4 BY
5 Q Oh yeah, before that -- thank you, my colleague
6 reminds me 19e is an exhibit that has a -- an exchange
7 between you and Lourie about the -- at a time when the
8 plea agreement -- the federal plea agreement --
9 A Right.
10 Q -- was still in play, and the issue is whether you
11 should sign it, and --
12 A Right.
13 Q -- you didn't want to, because you never do, but
14 you say at the bottom, we should only go forward if the trial
15 team supports and signs this agreement. What did you mean by
16 that? The -- the first part of it?
17 A So -- so, what I meant by that was I got something
18 that the -- that is -- the document was unusual. So, my
19 signature appearing on this document is not in and of itself
20 unusual.
21 Q And this would have been the plea agreement -- not
22 the federal plea agreement, not the -- or was this about the
23 NPA?
24 A This was about the NPA.
25 Q Okay.
Page 277
1 A Right, and so the NPA had my signature. Now, the
2 NPA's almost too generous.
3 Q MM-hmm.
4 A So, that in and of itself is not indicative of
5 something, but it does raise my concern. Is this something
6 that ultimately the trial team does not feel comfortable
7 with? And if it's something they don't feel comfortable
8 with, then they should speak up and let me know, because we
9 shouldn't go forward with it.
10 Q And did you ever have a conversation or a
11 discussion about that issue, other than mentioning it?
12 A Not -- not to my recollection. I would --
13 Q Okay.
14 A -- assume based on this that would read it and
15 would take me at my word and say, look, if -- I think you're
16 going in the wrong direction, Alex. You know, I think you're
17 going in the wrong direction, or I'm uncomfortable with it.
18 Q Okay. All right.
19 BY
20 Q Did you ever have a direct conversation with
21 about wanting her to sign the agreement as opposed
22 to yourself?
23 A I -- I did not. This was my -- my communications
24 with , and -- and I really meant that if at the end of
25 the day, my team isn't comfortable, then you shouldn't go
Page 278
forward.
2 Q You never recall hearing from that she was
3 not comfortable moving forward with the plea agreement?
4 BY
5 Q The NPA?
6 A I did not hear -- I don't recall hearing from
7 that she was not comfortable. I know that at various points
8 she became frustrated. At various points, became
9 frustrated, but they were negotiating this. If at some point
10 they did not -- they thought this was a mistake, or wrong, or
11 unjust, I would think that they would tell me.
12 Q What would you have done?
13 A Sit down and really have a serious conversation
14 about where this is going, and sit down and hear them out,
15 again, even if -- at this late phase.
16 Q Right.
17 A Would be -- I would -- I would think that that's
18 what I would have done.
19 Q All right. Let's turn to the NPA. What is it?
20 Exhibit 22? Did you read it? We know that you made some
21 final tweaks to it. 22.
22 A So --
23 Q Is the final -- as signed --
24 A 22. And so, I would -- again, I don't have an
25 independent recollection of reading it. I would not have
Page 279
1 made tweaks to it without reading it.
2 Q Okay.
3 A And so, I think you can infer that I read it.
4 Q All right, and let me say, you -- you were clerk to
5 an appellate -- a very eminent appellate judge, and you
6 did -- did you do appellate work --
7 A I did.
8 Q -- yourself? So, you were somebody who's an
9 appellate lawyer, who has that experience at a high level, is
10 often more sensitive to words, and phrasings, and to
11 documents, contents, than might be, again, to be -- to
12 caricaturize a little bit, but a more of a shoot from the hip
13 trial attorney who spends his days, you know, in a -- in a
14 rough and tumble courtroom, and is it fair to say that you
15 were more of the former, and more --
16 A So, I would push back. I think that's not
17 respecting the talent of the trial lawyer, and particularly
18 on these types of agreements or documents, these are folks
19 that sort of have expertise, because even if this was sui
20 generis, they have seen a lot of this.
21 Q I am not suggesting that and
22 Lourie --
23 A Right.
24 Q -- were not up to this.
25 A Right.
Page 280
1 Q Because certainly she also had a lot of appellate
2 experience. I'm simply noting that -- that this seems to be
3 sort of in your wheelhouse.
4 A What -- look, I apologize. Whether -- I'm not sure
5 what in my wheelhouse means. I -- you know, I appear to have
6 read this. I suggested some edits. As I would have
7 approached this document, my assumption would have been I'm
8 looking at it from my earlier concerns, that -- the policy
9 level concerns.
10 Does it capture that we're deferring to the state?
11 Going back to the put in the petite policy versus not. Does
12 it capture the policy concerns of -- of appropriately
13 understanding that we can't force the state to do something?
14 And does it capture the essential elements of the terms that
15 we had looked for, the
16 Q All right.
17 A -- you know, the imprisonment, registration, and
18 restitution.
19 Q All right. So, one of the things that is a little
20 striking that's different from the original draft NPA, even
21 as amended by you. So, let's pull out the 16b. Is that --
22 is what I would call the non-admission of guilty, so, in
23 the -- in the first page of 16b, the first paragraph that's
24 the first clause after the one through five statutes listing,
25 in 16b, reads, "It appearing that Epstein has accepted
Page 2
1 responsibility for his behavior by his signature on this
2 agreement."
3 A I'm sorry, you're on 16b?
4 Q 16b.
5 A Okay. It appearing, yes.
6 Q Okay. So, his is -- and this is not I mean,
7 this seems to be fairly typical sort of plea agreement
8 language, right?
10 Q And if you look at the top of the final NPA, 22,
11 the third, it appearing clause
12 A I'm sorry. Where --
13 Q Fine.
14 A -- where are you?
15 Q 16b.
16 A Right.
17 Q Has
18 A The third, it appearing?
19 Q It appearing he has -- the down at the bottom.
20 A Yeah.
21 Q It says -- refers to at the --
22 A It has accepted responsibility.
23 Q second up.
24 A Yes.
25 Q Exactly. He's accepted responsibility.
Page 282
A Right.
Q And then above in the fourth, it appearing --
A Yeah.
Q -- it references the fact that, it appearing,
5 "Epstein has committed offenses against the United States."
A Yes.
Q Okay? So, he -- there's a sense of acceptance of
8 responsibility. In the final NPA, which is 22 in your right
9 hand, the --
10 A Right.
11 Q -- third it appearing clause says nothing about
12 Epstein committing offenses. It simply references the U.S.
13 Attorney's Office and the FBI having conducted their own
14 investigation into Epstein's background and any offenses that
15 may have been committed by Epstein, including --
16 A Right.
17 Q -- the enumerated statutes. And then following the
18 enumerated federal statutes, there's no reference at all to
19 Epstein accepting responsibility. Do you -- do you -- do you
20 view that -- the removal of that acceptance of responsibility
21 to be something that was appropriate?
22 A So, trying to reconstruct, the focus was on -- and
23 I know I'm repeating myself, but jail time, registration,
24 restitution. Whether he accepted responsibility for a
25 federal or for a state, I think my focus would have been on,
Page 283
1 these were the terms. Does this encompass those terms?
2 Q So, as that concession is not something material as
3 far as -- I don't want to use the legal term material, but it
4 wasn't important --
5 A So -- so --
6 Q -- to your objectives?
7 A So --
8 Q Is that right?
9 A First, I'm not sure -- so, it wasn't a concession
10 from that -- that -- those four bullets, right? It was a
11 concession from an earlier draft.
12 Q Right.
13 A And so to say it's not important is, again, there
14 was an early draft. It changed. The focus was in any give
15 and take, drafts change. The focus was, did he go to jail?
16 Did he have to register? Did we have restitution?
17 Q All right.
18 BY
19 Q Do you remember noticing that change, and thinking
20 it --
21 A
22 Q -- just doesn't matter?
23 A I don't. In all -- in all candor, until right now,
24 I was not aware of that -- of that change. I doubt I would
25 have taken two documents and sort of put them side by side,
Page 284
1 as opposed to, does this capture what we're trying to get to.
2 BY
3 Q So, does that --
4 A I was aware of the 24 to 18.
5 Q Me-ham.
6 A But up until this question, I wasn't aware of that
7 change, to my recollection.
8 Q So --
9 BY
Q And you're aware of the 24 to 18 because you
noticed it in the NPA, or because somebody told you
separately? Or do you know?
A I can't -- I can't say other than I was aware.
BY
Q In the final NPA on page five, there's a series of
things that are included at the bottom of that page, in that
long paragraph, and the one that I want to focus on is the
16 immunity portion.
19 That was certainly not in the original draft
20 proposed by the U.S. Attorney's Office. In this paragraph,
21 the United States agrees, "That it will not institute any
22 criminal charges against any potential coconspirators of
23 Epstein, including but not limited t
Did you notice
25 that provision?
Page 285
A I -- I don't recall focusing on the coconspirator
2 provision. To the extent I reviewed this coconspirator
3 provision, I can speculate that my thinking would have been
4 the focus is on Epstein's -- Epstein's going to jail.
Whether some of his employees go to jail, or other, lesser
6 involved, is not the focus of this.
7 Q All right. This particular provision, as you know,
8 has been --
9 A It has --
10 Q -- enormously --
11 A -- generated --
12 Q -- criticized.
13 A Enormous, yes.
14 Q For a number of reasons. One of which is that it
15 is blanket transactional immunity. It gives blanket immunity
16 to unnamed, unidentified --
17 A Yes.
18 Q -- potential coconspirators. People who, even in
19 the future, if evidence is developed against them, as long as
20 they could be considered coconspirators of Epstein in this
21 conduct, they have a get out of jail free card. Do you have
22 any idea where that came from?
23 A I don't, and I don't want to characterize it as
24 giving -- I understand how it could be read that way in the
25 record. I don't want to characterize it, but I don't know
Page 286
1 where this could have come from.
2 I was -- I would have reviewed this for the policy
3 concerns. Did it do the -- the sort of the bullet points,
4 and my assumption, rightly or wrongly, would have been that
5 al and would have looked at this, and that this
6 was -- was appropriate. I understand your point.
7 Q All right, and I believe the point you were
8 referring to is that when I use the term jail -- get out of
9 jail free card, that you recognize this is limited to your
10 district?
11 A And that's an important point --
12 Q Of course.
13 A -- to recognize.
14 Q Of course, but nonetheless, this does give blanket
15 immunity to people -- you have no idea who they might be,
16 correct? If you had focused on it, would that have raised
17 some question in your mind?
18 A If -- if there was a discussion like what we're
19 having here, then it very possibly could have raised. It's
20 difficult to say it would have, but I understand your
21 concern.
22 Q All right, and the named individuals,
23 are all
24 individuals who were described in the pros memo and so on,
25 and the pros memo does identify that at least one of these
Page 287
1 women herself engaged in sexual activity with minor -- with
2 minor girls.
A Yeah.
Q So that she has liability in and of her own --
A So, I don't have an independent recollection of
6 that, but when I reviewed the pros memo, I did notice that.
7 Q All right. Now, you told us this morning that you
8 have no recollection of that actually having read the pros
9 memo back at that time.
10 A I think what I said was I don't have a recollection
11 of whether I did or did not read the pros memo. I have
12 since, when you've provided it, read it, and I note that it
13 does reference her.
14 Q Having read it now, does that change your view of
15 anything that we've talked about so far today?
16 A So, reading it 12 years later, knowing all of this,
17 possibly, and part of it is I do think we approach these
18 cases differently, and I think these cases would play out
19 very differently in court today. I think it's very difficult
20 to sort of go back and recreate a thought process from 12
21 years ago.
22 Q And if you were relying back then on the
23 characterization and summary and recounting of this case to
24 you by your people -- your senior people,
25 A Mm-hmm.
Page 288
1 Q -- and in particular,
2 A Right.
3 Q would you -- do you -- do you have a did --
4 did anyone in that ground, including IIIIILourie, in any way
5 to your recollection characterize this case as not serious,
6 or as trivial, or as involving non-important -- unimportant
7 victims? In any way try to diminish either the conduct or
8 the victims?
9 A Not to my recollection. I -- I do think there was
10 a concern as to how the victims would present in court, given
11 impeachment, and given contradictory statements, but that's
12 different than trivializing the case.
13 Q All right. Okay. Back to the immunity provision.
14 Were you aware that none of the four named coconspirators had
15 cooperated?
16 A I was not. To my recollection.
17 Q And do you recall any other case in which blanket
18 immunity in the V.S. Attorney's Office --
19 A Right.
20 Q -- was -- in which blanket immunity, really
21 without -- virtually without limitation --
22 A I -- SO, I --
23 Q -- was granted?
24 A I don't recall discussion around this provision,
25 and a general matter, I did not discuss the -- in typical
Page 289
1 cases that came -- that bubbled up to my level, it was -- the
2 focus was on who the prime, you know, target is, and not on
3 what we would do with the coconspirators. And so, I don't
4 recall, but that doesn't mean it didn't happen. That's just
5 not typically something that I got involved with.
6 Q And likewise, non -- immunity being given to non-
7 cooperating coconspirators, or codefendants? Is that
8 something that was done in your office?
9 A Again, I -- as a typical matter, we -- I did not
10 get involved with these, but let me -- let me also say that
11 this wasn't a federal prosecution in the first place. And
12 so, this whole thing is sui generis to some extent.
13 Q /t is, but the -- but the grant of immunity is
14 real, right?
15 A I understand where you're coming from.
16 Q All right. If you had focused on that provision,
17 would you have insisted it come out?
18 A One question I would have had is, if we're
19 naming -- as I sit here and sort of focus as we are now, but
20 this is with the benefit of hindsight and criticism --
21 Q MM-hmm.
22 A -- if there are specific folks, why do we have any
23 potential language? Because that seems quite broad.
24 Q It's -- it's without limitation as to people as
25 long as they're coconspirators, right?
Page 290
A But -- and so what is -- what is the need for that?
Q Okay.
A And I would --
Q i see.
A And so, if we had this kind of discussion, I would
6 be sending an e-mail saying, what's the need for this?
7 What's up?
8 Q But to be clear, as we sit here today, you have no
9 recollection of having noticed that?
10 A I -- I don't have a recollection of -- if I read
11 over it, my assumption would have been that and
12 thought this through and sort of addressed it for a reason.
13 Q All right, and if --
14 BY
15 Q And did you have any -- anyone ever come to you
16 with the evidentiary issues and say, we need to track this
17 down before we give such a blanket immunity?
18 A I don't recall any conversation around
19 coconspirators.
20 BY
21 Q This is where there is a mention of computer
22 equipment. There is a provision later in that -- in that
23 same paragraph that provides that, "The federal grand jury
24 investigation will be suspended, and all pending federal
25 grand jury subpoenas will be held in abeyance unless and
Page 291
1 until the defendant," --
2 A Right.
3 Q -- "violates any term of this agreement. The
4 defendant likewise agrees to withdraw his pending motion to
5 intervene and quash certain grand jury subpoenas. Both
6 parties agree to maintain their evidence, specifically
7 evidence requested by or directly related to the grand jury
8 subpoenas that have been issued, and including certain
9 computer equipment in violate until all of the terms of the
10 agreement have been satisfied." Do you -- do you -- do you
11 view that this agreement to suspect the -- at least certain
12 aspects of the federal investigation to have been an
13 appropriate concession?
14 A You know, again, my -- my focus was on certain
15 points. I would have assumed reading this that this was
16 thought through.
17 Q Okay.
18 A And that -- and that people had.
19 Q Had -- had --
20 A Had thought it through, you.
21 Q All right. Okay. There is what's been criticized
22 as a confidentiality provision.
23 A Yes.
24 Q Right? And that's on that same page, page five,
25 paragraph -- numbered paragraph 13, which provides that, "The
Page 292
1 parties anticipate that this agreement will not be made part
2 of any public record."
3 And then there is an exception for FOIA or
4 compulsory process from a court, in which the government will
5 provide notice to Epstein. That seems to be limited to the
6 placing of this document on the public record, right? As
7 opposed to sharing it, or disclosing it for whatever purpose
8 to individuals. Did -- is that -- is that a distinction that
9 makes sense?
10 A That is -- that is a fair distinction upon reading
11 this. I'm not sure that that is a distinction that was -- I
12 mean, I'm basing that on my reading currently, and not as a
13 recollection.
14 Q And in fact the parties, both defense counsel and
15 even the U.S. Attorney's Office took the position that this
16 should never have seen the light of day, even to be disclosed
17 to, you know, victims or other parties and interest, except
18 for filing it, or except for sharing it on a limited basis
19 with law enforcement. I think there were e-mails that talk
20 about if we share it, we'll tell them not to disclose it.
21 A Mm-hmm.
22 Q Is that sort of overstating what this paragraph
23 requires?
24 A Possibly. I can you know, we can get into that,
25 and we can discuss it. I would need to understand a little
Page 293
1 bit more. I know there was litigation around disclosure on
2 this, and I'd need to understand much more the positions that
3 we took and the why before commenting on them.
4 Q There's -- in Exhibit 23, there is a discussion of
5 the -- the -- whether the NPA after it has been signed could
6 be revealed -- the existence of it could be revealed to the
7 police chief, or even the FBI, or the girls, and
8 in the middle of page one, or two thirds of the way
9 down on page one of Exhibit 23, proposes that if we tell
10 anybody about the NPA, you just ask that -- that the
11 recipient of that information not disclose it.
12 And you then at the top of the page to Lourie and
13 who is going to take over
14 Lourie's position as the managing AUSA in West Palm Beach,
15 should talk with you about it on Wednesday, about the -- you
16 should talk about who we tell, and how much. Do you remember
17 that conversation, and --
18 A I -- I don't. I know there were several concerns
19 about leaks and media, and I imagine that we had a
20 conversation quite literally about who to tell, and how much.
21 Q And did you -- did you feel that this -- at the
22 time, as best as you recall, did you feel that that clause
23 bound you to not tell anyone?
24 A So, my recollection of the clause, whether it
25 was -- whether it was this clause or whether there was a
Page 294
1 discussion, I was was aware of this provision, and my
2 recollection of this provision is at some point it was raised
3 as something that -- that was the subject of negotiation.
4 Q Okay.
5 A That the office policy was that we -- that these
6 types of deferred prosecution agreement is not made part of
7 the public record, and --
8 Q Me-hmm.
9 A -- therefore that this is not a substantial
10 concession --
11 Q Me-hmm.
12 A -- because in the typical course of business, this
13 would not be part of the public record.
14 Q And that's because it's a non-prosecution as
15 opposed -- agreement as opposed to a deferred prosecution
agreement?
A So, deferred prosecution is not -- to analogize
18 from a non-prosecution to a deferred prosecution, these
19 are -- you know, if the non-prosecution is not typically part
20 of the public record, the deferred prosecution, it makes
21 sense that it follows the same.
22 And so, it seemed that -- it seemed a concession --
23 I understand how it was perceived publicly after the fact.
24 At the time, it seemed that we weren't giving up much,
25 because the typical policy is this is not part of the public
Page 295
1 record, and individuals need to file a FOIA. And so by
2 saying it's not part of the public record, and individuals
3 need to follow FOIA, if that -- if that is viewed as a
4 concession, it really isn't.
5 Q So, how would -- I mean, did -- is it -- is it
6 understandable that Epstein would not want this document to
7 see the light of day, because it describes the existence and
8 nature and scope of the federal investigation --
9 A Right.
10 Q -- and also his concession to liability under
11 22.55?
12 A It's understandable. It was also my impression at
13 the time that it would see the light of day, because --
14 Q Mm-hmm.
15 A -- if victims have 22.55, the ability to get 22.55,
16 they obviously have to hear about it from somewhere, and
17 given the press interest, eventually this would be FOIA'd.
18 And so, from my thinking at the time, rightly or wrongly,
19 this is a concession that's basically saying we'll follow
20 office policy, and we're likely going to be FOIA'd on this
21 anyhow, and it can play out in the FOIA. And so, is this
22 really a --
23 Q Yeah.
24 A -- concession?
25 Q All right. Another piece of the -- the agreement
Page 296
1 is -- is something that is absent, and that's the sort of
2 typical language that you find in a -- I think in pretty much
3 any federal plea agreement, which is, this agreement
4 only -- the defendant understands that this agreement only
5 binds the U.S. Attorney's Office for whatever district he or
6 she is in, or --
7 A Right.
8 Q -- you know, and that -- and that truly what you
9 would call global dispositions are unusual
:0 A Right.
Q -- for the federal government.
12 A And I would note, you know, and this is after the
13 fact that it does say this district agrees.
14 Q okay. Understood, and it's also has you as a
15 party, not the Department of Justice.
16 A Right.
17 Q But it does omit that standard language, and do you
18 know whether that was done sort of by mistake, or
19 consciously?
20 A I -- I have no -- I can't speak to that.
21 Q All right. another piece is phrasing that you
22 injected at the -- when you addressed the first -- where it
23 was -- it was toward the end. Where --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- you talked about injecting the best efforts
Page 297
1 language.
2 A Yes.
3 Q Okay. Does it -- what -- what's -- I believe you
4 made clear why you did that. That is, to avoid the
5 appearance of having the federal government be dictating
6 anything, but why rely on best efforts, and to what extent is
7 that even enforceable?
8 A So, first, let me -- let me say it was not to avoid
9 the appearance. It was to avoid the actual legal discovery
10 dictating, but -- so, Epstein understands that he has no
11 authority to require -- that -- to undertake discussions and
12 to use -- so, as I recall, if he did not plead, then there
13 was no agreement.
14 Q No, no, no. This -- I'm sorry.
15 A Yes.
16 Q I don't mean to -- it appears in paragraph --
17 numbered paragraph --
18 A Right.
19 Q -- 11, Epstein shall use his best efforts to enter
20 his guilty plea and be sentenced no later than the --
21 A Right.
22 Q -- set date, and then in the first paragraph after
23 numbered clause 11, he will use his best efforts to ensure
24 compliance with certain procedures, and best efforts to
25 convince the judge of the Florida court to accept his binding
Page 298
1 recommendation. So, best efforts kind of became a sticking
2 point in enforcement, didn't it? Because what does it mean? F
3 What does best efforts mean?
4 A So, I think it's fair to say that one of the issues
5 that came up after this was entered into was the U.S.
6 Attorney's Office, at least from my perspective, was in a
7 little bit of a bind because we had agreed to this, yet he
8 wasn't turning himself in. And so, how do we deal with that?
9 And so, that's not a phrase that I focused on at the time. I
10 understand your point.
11 Q All right. I'm going to move on from those. Is
12 there anything else on those NPA clauses?
13 A And finally, let me -- let me just say you didn't
14 ask, we had incredibly experienced attorneys in the office.
15 I assumed, rightly or wrongly, that this language had been
16 thought through and vetted, and you know, sitting here 12
17 years later, I understand the issues that have arisen from
18 it, but at the time, these were not issues that were focused
19 on.
20 Q to your knowledge, who was involved in the
21 drafting, other than on your side --
22 A Right.
23 Q -- and Lourie, and you, to some extent?
24 A So, I can't say 12 years after the fact, but again,
25 Lourie, very experienced head of the Palm Beach Office
Page 299
1 has prosecuted any number of cases.
2 Q In -- again, just to keep --
3 A Right.
4 Q -- perspective and context, the final week that
5 this was being negotiated, Lourie was in Washington, and
6 bouncing back and forth on the weekends, because he was in
7 transition to the front office here in the criminal division
8 in this building. That's a factor in terms of being able to
9 give attention to some details. Would you agree with that?
10 It could be a factor?
11 A So, it could be a factor. On the other hand, I'd
12 say that wasn't leaving the department. He is
13 professional. He knows his stuff, and you would expect a
14 professional -- if they're reviewing a document, whether
15 they're on vacation, whether they're looking to move from one
16 part of the department to another, that you would expect them
17 to review it, you know, fulfilling their -- their
18 responsibility to sort of focus in and make sure that -- that
19 it's -- that it encompasses what it should. And that's not a
20 criticism of . That -- that's saying that, well, that
21 might be a factor. That doesn't lessen from my perspective
22 reliance on his expertise.
23 Q NM-hmm. Understood. After the NPA was signed --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- and came back --
╔═══════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Bill Cosby [arts] comedian, rapist 
╚════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00009116 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Alex Acosta pages 300-411
(date: 2020-04-30)
Page 300
1 A Yeah.
2 right about that same time, he quite quickly
3 identified a potential problem, and that was the commitment
4 for the -- or, the agreement that the U.S. Attorney's Office
5 would identify the representative for the victims. Do you
6 recall him raising that?
7 A I don't recall him raising that as an issue, but I
know it was an issue.
Q All right. /t was an issue, and it was one that he
10 raised as soon as he came back. So, there was an effort,
11 which he conducted then in Ma absence to craft
12 an NPA addendum to address that issue.
13 Do you -- are you -- are you aware that MI
received a copy of the NPA in November when Ken
Starr wrote a letter to asking her to review the
22.55 portion of it? Do you -- do you remember that issue?
A I remember that the issue was appealed to CEOS.
Q Okay. Well, it was -- it was appealed initially by
19 letter to , raising an issue that was new to --
20 that had not been raised with you, and that is what led to
21 your letter to Ken Starr on December 4.
22 A I will accept the timeline.
Q Okay.
24 A It's difficult without all the documents --
Q Sure.
Page 301
A -- but yes.
Q And at the time theta/MEM saw the NPA,
3 he sent a message to MO about the -- about his view
4 of the NPA, and you didn't see it, but I just wanted to name
5 some problems that he identified with the disposition, and
6 get your reaction --
7 A Mm-hmm.
8 Q -- to it. So, first, he says I'm not thrilled
9 about the agreement, but he acknowledges that's out of his
10 hands. He says in terms of the charging and sentencing
11 provisions, he's getting -- Epstein is getting a much better
12 deal than the average defendant, with the exception of
13 defendants who have done physical harm to their victims or
14 abused very young children, we haven't seen more egregious
15 conduct, because of its serial nature. The area we need to
16 be most careful about relates to the victims.
17 The U.S. should seek to ensure that the plea, which
18 is not giving him serious jail time, provides the best means
19 possible to address the harm he caused to the victims. That
20 generally means restitution and/or therapy. While the
21 agreement provides facility for the victims, the relevant
22 terms still seem pretty advantageous for the defendant, and
23 not all that helpful to the victims.
24 They get an attorney who will be paid by the
25 defendant, which involves at least some conflict of interest,
Page 302
1 or they could hire their own attorneys on a contingency
2 basis, and they get waivers from the defendant when his plea
3 would facilitate their civil cases in any event. Then, they
4 still have to sue him to get anything.
Most times with wealthy defendants, we make them
6 agree to a restitution fund, and then still provide that the
7 victims can sue the defendant independently if they choose.
We always make them clearly admit their guilt, no nolo pleas.
9 This is incredibly important to the victims. I
10 would have taken the guy to trial unless the victims were
11 clearly against it, and I don't think most of them are here.
12 He then says to , who by this time is working
13 for --
14 A Mm-hmm.
16 A Right.
17 Q So, that's the context in which he's addressing it.
18 specifies that, ' wouldn't and
19 shouldn't address the agreement." So, that -- so that the
20 issue that was then before put there by Ken
21 Starr, was the -- whether this 22.55 scheme or scenario set
22 out in the NPA was appropriate. It appears that she then
23 sent that back to you to address.
24 A Right.
25 Q But as far as commentary on the NPA,
Pagel 303
if you had been aware of this perspective at the time you
were -- that you and your people were fashioning the NPA,
would that have been helpful to you in -- in deciding out to
proceed?
A So, may I?
Q Yes.
A Okay. I assume you've read the whole thing, but
8 let me just take a
9 Q I have.
10 A And so, a few comments. First, let me say, he was
11 part of the September meeting.
12 Q Me-hmm.
13 A And -- and to my recollection, these
14 perspectives -- so, so, at least the outlines of the
15 agreement were -- were disclosed at that meeting, and I don't
16 recall this type of communication at that time.
17 Q Okay.
18 A I also recall that there was a lot of back and
19 forth around this restitution fund concept, and our
20 perspective was that the restitution fund puts the victim at
21 a disadvantage --
22 Q Me-hmm.
23 A -- because -- let me -- let me try to recreate. I
24 don't recall the details, but I recall that there was a
25 perspective that the restitution fund --
Page 304
Q MO-hmm.
-- put the victims as a disadvantage --
4 Mm-hmm.
A -- and there is some reference to --
Q It's the --
A Was it an Alaska case?
Q It's called the case.
5 MR.
THE WITNESS I'm sorry?
IC MR.
11 THE WITNESS NM
12 MS. or
13 THE WITNESS a=?
14 BY MS.
15 Q Yeah.
16 A And so to the extent that there were better ways of
17 crafting this, that certainly would have been -- been highly
18 relevant, because to my recollection, we were not wed to any
19 particular way of crafting it.
20 The -- the intent of the 22.55 was to come as close
21 as possible to putting the victims in the -- in the position
22 they would have been had he been tried and convicted
23 federally. And so, the answer to your question is yes.
24 Q Is yes, that would have --
25 A Would have been helpful.
Page 305
1 Q Okay. As you set about addressing the 22.55, you
2 consulted with . Do you recall that?
3 A I -- I recall consultations. I don't recall that
4 it was specifically with a but --
5 Q Did you know her?
6 A Yes.
7 Q Okay, and do you recall the nature of your
8 interaction with her?
9 A I -- I don't. I know from contemporary review of
10 the record, that there is an e-mail from her.
Q It's 41a.
A 41a.
Q And what I -- what I want to ask is, is simply, 41a
is -- is an e-mail in which you ask -- you note to
15 , who was
16 A Right.
Q -- one of her deputies, and she oversaw CEOS. She,
18 , mentioned to you that was looking at
19 this, which is the --
A 22.55.
21 Q -- 22.55, she contacts her counterpart in the civil
22 division, and there's an e-mail from him,
23 which is the second page of this exhibit, which he copies you
24 on. So, my question is, is this the extent of your
25 interaction with on this issue?
Page 306
1 A I -- 12 years --
2 Q Okay.
3 A -- after the fact, I don't remember.
4 Q Okay. All right. The -- in Exhibit 35, there is a
5 letter from Jay Lefkowitz in which -- I'm sorry, it's an e-
6 mail from Jay Lefkowitz.
7 A Exhibit?
8 Q Exhibit 35 to you, and this is substantially later,
9 but it has a sentence that -- or a phrase that we'd like to
10 ask you about, and -- all right, it's highlighted at the top.
11 It says, back in the beginning of -- back at the beginning of
12 January, when we both agreed that there were significant
13 irregularities with the deferred prosecution agreement, you
14 called a time out. Is that accurate? Did you and he agree
15 that --
16 A No.
17 Q -- there were significant irregularities?
18 A No.
19 Q Okay.
20 A And if I could, there are -- there are several
21 instances where not just, to me, but to other people as well,
22 Jay recharacterizes conversations.
23 Q Recharactorizes them inaccurately?
24 A Inaccurately.
25 Q Or misleadingly?
Page 307
1 A Or misleadingly.
2 Q All right.
3 A What I recall agreeing to at some point is there
4 was an appeal to the DAG, or there was an appeal in place,
5 and I basically said -- I think there was a letter that I
6 sent, saying if you want to appeal, go ahead. We're not
7 concerned about this.
8 Q MM-hmm.
9 A But that doesn't mean that I agree that there were
10 irregularities --
11 Q All right.
12 A -- or that there was a time out, that's -- I'm part
13 of a department. I'm part of a hierarchy. If someone wants
14 to overrule me, that's okay by me.
15 Q All right. So, the NPA addendum was worked out,
16 and the defense team continued its sort of multi-pronged
17 assault. In the middle of the negotiations between
18 and Lefkowitz about the NPA addendum, that's when you had the
19 much commented on breakfast --
20 A Correct.
21 Q -- on October 12, and you have stated publicly that
22 at -- perfectly accurately that the NPA was signed, and that
23 was a done deal. And so, that -- that this was not tied in
24 any way to any effort to influence the terms of the NPA,
25 fair?
Page 308
1 A Fair, because the way this was reported was that I
2 negotiated it over breakfast. It was signed, and that's
3 really important.
4 Q Of course. There were, however, a number of open
S issues --
6 A Yes.
7 Q -- right? And in Exhibit 28, Jay Lefkowitz on page
8 two, this is an e-mail to you, acknowledges your -- your
9 breakfast on Friday. This is dated October 18, and -- and
10 following -- following up on -- your conversation with him
11 about the date for Epstein's plea.
12 So, he notes that, "You said you didn't want to
13 dictate a schedule to the state." So, all I want to note is
14 that when you had the breakfast, there was there was
15 there were issues still open that were the subject of
16 discussions between the defense and the U.S. Attorney's
17 Office.
18 And -- and so, I guess my question is, while that
19 was a meeting of convenience in a public place, in a location
20 where you had business later that day, a speech, I believe,
21 optically, do you understand the public concern that this was
22 sort of a one on one negotiation on pending issues?
23 A So, I -- I understand how there can be concern.
24 This, you know, it is -- it was not unusual -- in this case,
25 I actually very intentionally waited, and tried not to have
Page 309
1 one on one meetings, but there are other instances where :
2 might from time to time have one on one conversations with
3 the opposing counsel.
4 I don't remember the breakfast. I can speculate
5 that one of the issues that was informing this was somewhere
6 around this time, and I can't say with certainty that this
7 was what it was, but somewhere around this time, there arose
8 allegations that had directed the designation to her
9 boyfriend's partner, or something along those lines.
10 Q A former -- I believe it was a former law school
11 classmate of her former -- of her then boyfriend.
12 A 1 don't -- yeah, and so I don't remember what the
13 details --
14 Q Okay.
15 A -- were, but I know that that was a topic that he
16 wanted to raise --
17 Q
18 A -- with me.
19 Q Did he at that breakfast?
20 A I honestly -- I don't recall the breakfast.
21 Q Okay.
22 A You asked me about one characterization of what I
23 said in the record, you know, of that breakfast. I think I
24 responded --
25 Q Mm-hmm.
Page 310
1 A through, or my counsel responded, and they're
2 pointing out that I seem fairly perturbed at how he
3 inaccurately characterized something that I said. And so, we
4 don't need to revisit that, but --
5 Q Uh-uh. All right. If you look at Exhibit 27,
6 another sort of point, just to kind of --
7 A All right.
8 MR. : Could we -- before we --
9 MS. : Yes?
10 MR. : -- leave -- are we leaving the
11 breakfast meeting?
12 MS. : No. This is --
13 THE WITNESS Okay.
14 MS. : -- this is directly related.
15 MR. : Okay.
16 BY MS.
17 Q And that is, Exhibit 27 is the second e-mail down,
18 is from to Jay Lefkowitz. The date is October
19 12, so that's the same day as your breakfast.
20 A Right.
21 Q And the date of it is not I'm sorry, the time is
22 9:48 a.m. Your breakfast was at 7:00. So, this would have
23 been pretty shortly after your breakfast, and writes
24 to Jay Lefkowitz with a copy to you and
25 stating that he just got off the phone with you, that is,
1 S
Page 311
just got off the phone with you, and then he furnishes
2 a revised paragraph one, which suggests -- I mean, I infer
3 from that that shortly after the breakfast, you had a phone
4 conversation with i a about a revision to this
5 paragraph, and that -- that that was likely something that
6 you talked to him about. Again, I'm not --
A Right.
Q -- suggesting that this --
A Again, I -- I don't -- I don't recall the
10 breakfast, so I can't say one way or the other. I -- I
11 take -- I take your point. I don't recall seeing this.
12 Q All right. Well, it was --
13 A But --
14 Q -- you were copied on it. Okay. All right.
15 you wanted to --
16 BY MR.
17 Q I just wanted to point to Exhibit 30.
18 A Can -- can we back up a second?
19 MS. : Sure.
20 THE WITNESS , I'm not sure whether your
21 concerns are -- so, I would -- I would only raise the
22 question where -- or, the point where, based on this, and I
23 don't recall, so I can't speak, but is saying, Jay
24 suggests revision has been rejected. Here is our latest,
Page 312
1 And so, to -- there are multiple ways to read this.
2 One is that this was raised. Another is that we're rejecting
3 something that Jay had proposed, and --
MS. : Mm-hmm.
THE WITNESS -- because I was meeting with Jay, I
6 asked that not reject it until after I met with him, and
7 I -- I'm speculating, because I don't recall the topic, but
8 it does appear that it says, Jay suggested revision has been
9 rejected. Here is our latest.
10 MS. : All right. Thank you.
11 BY MR.
12 Q Can we just go to Exhibit 30 quickly? There's some
13 highlighted language. This is a letter from Lefkowitz to you
14 on October 23rd, 2007, where he recounts, again, the things
15 that happened, or his version of the October 12th breakfast
16 meeting.
17 A Yes.
18 Q Are you at that --
19 A Yes.
20 Q -- at that point right there, Exhibit 30?
21 A Yeah, I'm there.
22 Q Okay. So, in the highlighted language, if you
23 could just take a look at that quickly?
24 A Yes.
25 Q So, he is recounting that you had assured him that
1 EVEN/NG SESSION
2 6:00 P.M.
3 the office would not intervene with the state's attorney's
4 office, and -- or contact the civil claimants, or intervene
S regarding the sentence that Epstein receives pursuant to a
6 plea agreement.
Q So, is he correct in his recounting that?
A Can you -- can you find that for me?
Q Yeah.
A So, again, I don't have an independent
12 recollection. Oh, no, I'm looking --
13 MS. : Oh, you have it.
14 THE WITNESS -- for something -- I don't have an
15 independent recollection of that breakfast, but in the
16 contemporaneous e-mails and the contemporaneous record, there
17 is correspondence between -- between and I, and you all
18 asked for this, and I I spoke with my counsel, who then
19 responded, and there's an e-mail exchange where there's an
20 October 20 -- this was an October 23rd e-mail -- October 23rd
21 letter.
22 And then there is a response that's drafted on
23 October 25th. I don't know if we can find that. From
24 to Jay that specifically addresses the point, and then I
25 respond -- runs that by me, and I respond -- I edit the
Page 314
1 letter, and I move it -- I sort of emphasize -- like, I make
2 it firmer, and my edit says our office cannot and will not
3 agree to this, and then my comment to  is, what do you
4 think of this rewrite? Is it too strong?
S
BY MR.IIMIE:
Q What day was that?
A That was two days after this. I don't know if we
8 can find that in the -- in the chronological record. That
9 was October 25th. Let's just take a minute. Is that what
10 you have?
11 MR. : Sorry, apparently my ability to separate
12 paper has failed.
13 THE WITNESS Okay. So, this is --
14 MR. : Oh, I see.
15 THE WITNESS So --
16 MR. : Sorry, go ahead.
17 THE WITNESS So, October 25th, I'm writing to
18 what do you think of this rewrite? Is it too strong? And it
19 says, dear Jay, I'd like to take this opportunity to document
20 our conversation of October 24th which clarified some of the
21 representations in your October 23rd letter.
22 I write in particular because you indicated that
23 your intent in writing the letter was to memorialize our
24 conversations. Our agreement is limited to blank, blank,
25 blank, dot, dot, dot.
Page 315
1 I specifically want to clarify one of the items
2 that I believe was inaccurate in the October 23rd letter.
3 Your office claims that this office would not intervene with
4 the state attorney's office regarding this matter, or contact
5 any of the individuals, potential witnesses, or potential
6 civil claimants, and their respective counsel in this matter,
7 and neither your office nor the FBI would intervene regarding
8 the sentence Mr. Epstein received.
9 I'm quoting Jay's letter. As we discussed and
10 hopefully clarified, and as the U.S. Attorney previously
11 explained in an earlier conference call, such promises equate
12 to the imposition of a gag order. Our office cannot and will
13 not agree to this. It is the intent of this office to treat
14 this matter like any other case.
15 Thus, as is typical, we do not desire or intend to
16 "intervene" the state attorney's office. The non-prosecution
17 agreement provides sufficient mechanisms to achieve the goals
18 of the federal investigation. You should understand,
19 however, that there are some communications that are typical
20 in these matters.
21 And so, I go on, and so my point is this was
22 pretty -- based on -- if you reviewed my -- my e-mails and
23 language, for me to write something up saying, what do you
24 think of this rewrite, is it too strong?
25 Q Mist-hmm.
Page 31E
1 A And to edit language to, our office cannot
2 and will not agree to this, is not my agreeing with this
3 characterization, but my polite way of saying, this ain't
4 what I said.
5 Q Mn-hmm.
6 A Let me be clear.
7 Q And then --
8 A Again, no independent recollection. This is just
9 based on inferring from the contemporaneous e-mails.
0 Q Okay.
1 BY MS.
What I would like to do is ask a couple of
questions in a couple of areas about the main justice review.
Q Then take a short break, and then has some
6 questions that are CVRA related, and then we have some
summary questions.
8 A
9 Q Is that all right?
20 A Can I -- before you -- you move on, can I address
21 something that was getting at, but it's getting late,
22 so I'm going to circle back to -- to --
23 Q Please.
24 A -- something that I thought you would bring up.
25 MS. : Sure.
Page 317
1 THE WITNESS So, I think something to talk about
2 is, pre-agreement and post-agreement, I think are different,
3 and one concern that I had, and I certainly shared with --
4 with Mr.e was once it was signed -- so, we had the
5 initial issues with the case.
6 Once the agreement was signed, we now have an
7 overlying issue of, is there is the agreement binding? To
8 what extent it's binding. And so, you -- your question was,
9 why this level of process after the agreement was signed, and
10 I said I think you'll get back to that. And I think to some
11 extent, there are two parts to that.
12 One is, the office shouldn't be afraid of review.
13 We're part of the Department of Justice, and review, whether
14 it by main justice or now you all, is -- is part of the
15 process.
21 criminal case, but we're litigating a civil/criminal issue on
22 top of that, which is, did the agreement bind? And that's
23 something that did inform the exhausting amount of process
24 that they -- that they received, which didn't change any of
25 the outcome.
And so, to the extent that they want to appeal to
main, it would be unseemly to sort of say, don't review us,
and I don't think it would help reviewing this, but the
second part of it is if we were to walk away from the
agreement, that not only are we litigating the underlying
Page
BY MS.
2 Q Didn't bind what?
3 A So, if we were to walk away, were -- could we still
4 prosecute?
5 Q I see.
6 A Right? Because having signed that, we were now
7 parties to an agreement, and that would overlay any sort of
8 prosecution. And So, you had these collateral issues coming.
9 BY MS.
10 Q Just to make sure we're clear, are you saying that
11 there is -- there would have been difficulty in declaring a
12 breach so that you could then indict?
13 A Correct, and so we'd have to litigate over a
14 breach, because as much as they had collateral challenges,
15 they are very careful in saying, this is not a breach, we
16 would just like review.
17 And so, one of the issues that overlaid the post --
18 the October going forward time period is on top of this, do
19 we now want litigation over a breach? And so, I think that
20 is why the post-agreement time period is different than the
21 pre-agreement --
22 MS. Mm-hmm.
23 THE WITNESS -- time period.
24 BY MS.
25 Q But was part of that problem the result of the
change from, here is the date that you must comply, to, you
2 must use best efforts to comply?
3 A Possibly. I would -- whether it was that, or
4 others, or other parts of the agreement, we can talk about,
5 but how -- once the agreement was signed, and they do not --
6 and they start pushing the date, there becomes a legal issue
7 over, are they really in breach or not?
8 And I'm not -- I understand your perspective. I'm
9 just saying, you know, earlier I said that there was a
10 difference. You asked about the process, and I said from my
11 perspective, there's a difference between the pre-agreement
12 and the post-agreement time period.
13 And much of that difference is informed by, if we
14 declare a unilateral breach, how does this hold up in court?
15 Because now there's a signed agreement that the United States
16 is a party to.
17 Q And are you saying that part of the reason, or
18 maybe all of the reason that you continued to give
19 accommodations and process and delay was because of the
20 concern that you couldn't actually win a breach argument?
21 A I think that was a consideration. Another part of
22 the considerations are if someone -- if a party wants to
23 take -- I mean, main justice gave a lot of process. It
24 wasn't -- it wasn't, you know, it wasn't just to -- to
25 but it was up to the -- it was just up to the assistant
Page 32C
1 attorney general for criminal division, to be polite, but it
2 was up to the DAG.
3 And so, if main justice is going to give this
4 degree of process, we should -- we should be in the position
5 of saying go forward, as opposed to, I don't think it looks
6 positive for the office to be viewed as fearing department
7 review.
8 Q But were you giving the impression to the
9 Department of Justice that you were the one who wanted this
10 review so that they felt like, well, it's not just these
defense attorneys who we can blow off, it is an United States
Attorney who is asking for this review, and so therefore we
13 need to give the courtesy of reviewing this?
14 A I don't think I asked for it as opposed to saying,
15 if you would -- so, from the very beginning, they said that
16 they're going to take this to the Deputy Attorney General and
17 Attorney General.
18 And I said, if you want to, fine. They just
19 finally did, but that was not -- that was not -- I think they
20 raised that as early as August or September. And so, I'm not
21 surprised that it ended up there. I also thought it was
22 important to not be in the position of fearing review.
23 think if you look at the contemporaneous record, there's an
24 effort on our part to expedite the review.
25 BY MS.
Page 321
1 Q But there's a difference between, have at it, go,
2 do what you want, up at main, and getting that --
3  Right.
4 Q -- that non-opposition, and actually sending a
5 signal to -- in the -- in the case of the criminal division,
6 the assistant attorney general, in the case of the DAG's
7 office, Mark Filip or his assignee, that you supported their
8 review, that the -- this appeal process. You could have
9 said, look, we're going to go ahead and get on with our
10 business.
11 If they want to -- if -- you could have not so much
12 opposed a review, but not seconded their request for -- the
13 defense request for reviews, or not in fact invited the
14 reviews.
15 A So, I'd be curious as to the timeline. I would
16 take issue with, I invited the reviews, and I question
17 whether, did they initiate the reviews on their own, and then
18 I said have at it, or did I -- based on -- I mean, you've got
19 more of a record than I do, or did I invite -- I don't -- I
20 would say I did not invite the reviews.
21 Q Well, let me -- bad terminology, perhaps. Let me
22 ask you this. If -- would've -- did you convey to the
23 criminal division that you wanted them to review this matter,
24 as requested by the defense attorneys?
25 A So, from my perspective, I'm thinking back 12 --
Page 322
1 Q Min-hmm.
2 A -- 12 years now. The very reason that we invited
3 to come down to Miami back in August was a sense that it
4 would end up up here. And so, if it's going to end up up
5 here, let's bring down.
6 Let's make him part of the initial meeting. You
7 know, if there are concerns, let's raise these. Let's
8 address them. Let's get them out so that we don't end up,
9 after we go forward with all of this, back in front of
10 and And it's much better to involve main justice
11 earlier.
12 And so, I would say I was trying, if anything,
13 to to involve main justice so that we didn't end up where
14 we were, and it had been my expectation that that October
15 date would have been met.
16 The collateral reviews afterwards, the collateral
17 appeals, obviously did not go as -- as we planned, and -- and
18 it was my sense, we were going to end up at main justice one
19 way or another.
20 Q So, my question is in December, after the December
21 meeting --
22 A Right.
23 Q -- that you had with defense counsel, and they told
24 you they were going to go to main justice.
25 A Correct.
Page 323
1 Q To the criminal division. Did you convey to main
2 justice criminal division that you wanted them to conduct the
3 review that defense counsel were seeking?
4 A So, I don't recall what I may or may not have
5 conveyed. I think my recollection was, if they want a
6 review, that's their right. We're not -- as a department,
7 we're not in the business of telling individuals that they
8 can't take something to your supervisor, or your superior.
9 Whether -- whether main justice takes this on or not is
10 ultimately at their discretion.
11 Q Would it surprise you to learn that the criminal
12 division front office understood you to be requesting their
13 review, the review that was sought by defense counsel?
14 A Would it surprise me? Perhaps. My -- my -- my
15 understanding -- recollection is we shouldn't fear it. If
16 they want it --
17 Q mm-hmm.
18 A -- that's their right. I thought by inviting
19 down in the first place that we had at least tried to address
20 that early on, but I also thought that we might end up there
21 in the first place.
22 Q Were you -- were you aware that a decision was made
23 to grant the decision by your office to grant defense
24 counsel's request their insistence that
25 role in the criminal division review be limited to review
Page 324
1 only, and that he not be permitted to -- or that the criminal
2 divisions -- that the -- I'm sorry, I misspoke. That because
3 IIIMINIMIllhad already been involved in essentially
4 being a prosecutor on the case --
5 A Right.
6 Q -- that the -- the criminal division and CEOs' role
7 vis a vis this review should be review only. That is, they
8 should be taken off the case as a -- as a partner?
9 A So, I sought e-mails to that affect in the record.
10 I don't have an independent recollection 12 years --
11 Q you --
12 A
13 Q Do you think you were involved in that decision?
14 A To take them off?
15 Q Yes.
16 A To my recollection, I wanted them on as a partner,
17 and I think the contemporaneous --
18 Q ME-hmm.
19 A -- e-mails from is, can you please come on
20 board?
21 Q But that was earlier, before this review process?
22 A No. No. Even after the --
23 Q All right.
24 A -- review process, I think there are
25 contemporaneous e-mails where we're saying it's important
Page 325
1 that you be part. If we go to trial, it's important that you
2 be part of the trial. As I -- as I went through the record,
3 at least I remember --
4 Q Me-hmm.
5 A -- an e-mail, perhaps from to that I'm
6 copied on saying, hey, can you reconsider? It's important
7 that you be part of this.
Q Reconsider the review only limitation?
A No, no. Reconsider being a part of the trial
Q Oh. All right.
A -- team.
Q All right. So, to be clear, do I understand that
13 you -- correct me, that you don't have a recollection one way
14 or the other whether you requested the criminal division to
15 conduct the review, or could it have happened, or --
16 A So --
17 Q -- what?
18 A -- to the extent I -- again, I'm going back --
19 Q Nm-hmm.
20 A -- 12 years. To the extent there is a request to,
21 it would be in the context of, this is going to Washington.
22 We're not fearful of this. Have at it.
23 Q And you would have conveyed that to Washington?
24 Not just to the defense attorneys, is that correct?
25 A I imagine in some way. It's --
Page 326
Q All right.
BY MS.
Q And just one --
A Yeah.
Q -- just one point. This one -- this one was a
6 little bit of an --
7 A Yeah.
8 Q -- odd posture, however, because you had a signed
9 agreement. And so, you know, basically a contract between
10 parties --
11 A Right.
12 Q -- and particularly on Mr. Epstein's side, a party
13 who was -- who was extremely well represented. So, was there
14 any consideration on your part, instead of saying, hey,
15 everybody's got a right to review, knock yourself out, go up
16 to Washington, as opposed to saying something like, that ship
17 has sailed, guys. You signed this agreement. We're going
18 forward. You don't go forward. You're in breach. End of
19 story?
20 A So, his counsel are raising serious issues that go
21 to ethics and go to fundamental relationships between
22 sovereigns. Is this 22.55 appropriate as a matter of federal
23 policy? Is what we're doing an overreach, you know, is what
24 we're doing contrary to law? Are we extracting -- I'm
25 characterizing. This may or may not
Page 327
1 Q MM-hmm.
2 A -- be accurate. Are we extracting unduly? Are we
3 using criminal law to extract civil concessions in an
4 ethically suspect way? Those are serious issues. That isn't
5 just, is this a good case?
6 Those are -- those are genuine issues. I happen to
7 think that, as I recall, that we were in the right or we
8 wouldn't have agreed to it, but by the same token, let's
9 assume that main justice ultimately disagreed. Is that from
10 a main justice perspective? And maybe I'm coming at this
11 from a -- you know, being informed by having been at main
12 justice.
13 Q mm-hmm.
14 A Where there was talk about, can you believe what
15 this AUSA -- this AUSA may have done or may not have done
16 without consulting, that these are serious issues. They
17 establish precedent.
18 They -- you know, maybe the DAG would have said,
19 this is not the kind of thing we'd support, and this is
20 wrong. And so, at the end of the day, let's move forward,
21 but if -- once these issues are raised, I don't think a U.S.
22 Attorney should say main justice should not review this.
23 I think we're part of one department, and these are
24 valid issues. Main justice doesn't need to take months to
25 review this. Main justice can expedite their review, but
Page 328
1 those are valid issues for the deputy and the AAG to review.
2 Q But one could look at it and say, well, those are
3 all issues that the defense certainly knew about before they
4 signed that agreement, and having signed the agreement, they
5 are waiving all of that. That's what contracts are for.
6 You've got all these issues, don't sign the contract.
7 A And if I could, I think there's a December letter.
8 I don't know if it's -- if it's in the exhibits, but there's
9 a December letter that I wrote that, for me, is --
10 Q This is the 19th?
11 A Maybe it's the 19th. Let me --
12 Q Or the --
13 M . The 19th is the -- your sort of
14 ill-fated NPA addendum effort.
15 THE WITNESS No. No, a letter to -- to Ken Starr
16 that I -- that I wrote. But --
17 MR. : The 4th letter is to Ken Starr.
18 THE WITNESS I'm sorry?
19 MR. : Is it the December 4th letter?
20 THE WITNESS Yeah, it's probably --
21 MR. : December 4?
22 THE WITNESS It's the December 4th.
23 MS. : Yeah, it didn't have a date.
24 MS. : All right. That's the one you
25 wrote --
Page 329
1 THE WITNESS So --
2 MS. : -- to him --
3 THE WITNESS -- so --
4 MS. : -- in response to the --
5 THE WITNESS So --
6 MS. -- 22.55 issue.
7 THE WITNESS I think, you know, I -- you know, I'm
8 starting on page four. I have responded personally in some
9 detail to your concerns because I care deeply about both the
10 law and the integrity of this office. I have responded
11 personally and in detail as well, because your letter
12 troubled me on a number of levels. Upon your understanding
13 of the negotiations are. The 22.55 was first discussed July
14 31st.
15 You know, and one of these four points in -- in the
16 middle of 2007, your defense team decides -- asked to meet
17 with me. On September 7th, I met. After considering of the
18 arguments, and after conferring with FBI and
19 our office decided to proceed with the indictment. At that
20 time, I offered to delay -- our prosecutors to delay
21 presentation to allow you to appeal our decision if you
22 choose. You chose not to.
23 Instead, you elected to enter into the NPA. Since
24 the signing of this agreement, the feds in our office have
25 addressed several issues that have arisen, although the
Page 330
1 exchanges at the time were a bit litigious.
2 BY MS.
3 Q This -- could I -- could I thought point out --
4 i•. Yeah.
5 Q -- that this letter is in response to not the at
6 the request for a review by the criminal division, that comes
7 later. This is in response to Ken Starr's letter to
8 about -- raising 22.55 -- 22.55 issues that had not
9 been raised with you before.
10 A Right, which is -- which is in essence a review.
11 mean, he -- they're coming to main justice, and you know,
12 it's against these many previous foregone opportunities to
13 object that I receive with surprise your letter requesting an
14 11th hour after the fact review of our agreement. Although
15 it happens rarely, I don't mind this office's decision being
16 appealed to Washington, and have previously directed our
17 prosecutors to delay.
18 Indeed, I'm confident in our prosecutor's evidence
19 and legal analysis. I nonetheless
20 directed them to consult with subject matter experts in the
21 criminal CEOS division to confer to our interpretation of the
22 law before proceeding with this indictment. So, I guess, you
23 know, we consulted CEOS.
24 I'm thus surprised to read a letter addressed to
25 the department headquarters that raises issues that either
Page 331
1 have not been raised with this office previously, or have
2 been raised and in fact resolved in your client's favor.
3 I'm troubled likewise by the apparent lack of
4 finality in this agreement. The AUSAs have been negotiating
5 with defense counsel and have for sometimes complained to me
6 regarding the tactics used by the defense team. It appears
7 to them that as soon as resolution is reached on one issue,
8 defense counsel finds ways to challenge the resolution
9 collaterally.
10 Q So, this is your protest of, it sounds like Starr's
11 effort to bypass you and go to with new issues?
12 A It is, and I'm pushing back in that, was I inviting
13 this, or was I sort of saying -- you know, that said, there
14 must be some closure on this matter.
15 Some in our office are deeply concerned that
16 defense counsel will continue to mount collateral challenges
17 to provisions of this agreement, even after Mr. Epstein has
18 entered his guilty plea and thus rendered the agreement
19 difficult, if not impossible to unwind. In closing, I ask
20 that you consult with co-counsel.
21 If after consultation with your defense team you
22 believe that our agreement is unethical, unlawful, or
23 unconstitutional, I'd ask us that you notify us immediately
24 so we can discuss the matter by phone or in person. I've
25 consulted the chief prosecutor in this case who has advised
Page 332
1 me that she's ready to unwind the agreement and proceed to
2 trial if necessary, or appropriate.
3 Q So, are you suggesting that this represents your
4 protest of their appeal to
5 A So
o' Q -- on this point?
7 A So, protest is a is a loaded word. What I'm
8 suggesting is, this is not an invitation to appeal to main
9 justice. This is sort of saying, enough is enough is enough.
10 Q But Mr. Acosta, in fairness, this, to clarify --
11 A Right.
12 Q -- this is in response to a letter directed to
13 dated November 28th --
14 A Right.
Q -- 2007 raising issues that he had not raised with
16 you. The appeal subsequently that I was asking about was --
17 A Right.
18 Q -- an appeal for a de novo review -- a de novo
19 review of the whole case.
20 A Understood, and my -- the reason that I -- that I
21 read this, you know, is this is not -- on the one hand, I'm
22 saying we do not fear review, but I don't -- this is not an
23 invitation to defense counsel to do a de novo -- I am not
24 inviting them. I'm not saying, let's have more review. I'm
25 saying, enough's enough. If they appeal, that's fine, but
Page 333
1 this is not an invitation to appeal.
2 Q But there was nothing you could do to stop their
3 appeal, right? Except indict?
4 A And so the department shouldn't stop an appeal to
main justice by -- you know, by threatening.
6 Q Fair enough.
7 A Because main justice has a right to review.
8 Q I should have said that -- that this -- that this
9 appeal process was stymying progress in resolving the Epstein
10 case.
11 A It was.
12 Q And you had no way -- you had no recourse, other
13 than, at least theoretically, you could have just said, you
14 know, we're --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- going to tear it up and indict, because you're
17 in breach, in effect.
18 A Which would have raised civil litigation --
19 Q Litigation.
20 A -- overlays, which is the point that I thought
21 merited --
22 Q All right.
23 A -- at least flushing out.
24 BY MS. :
25 Q So, short of the department itself getting a move
Page 334
1 on, and getting this thing through expeditiously, did you
2 feel like you just had to sit there and wait for everything
3 to get done?
4 A I'm not sure sit there and wait, but -- but
5 ultimately, the case did not get better with time, and there.
6 was frustration on our apart about, you know, the witnesses
7 are not getting better. You know, time
8 Q They're getting older.
9 A They're getting -- which goes back to how a juror
10 may see them.
11 MS. : Right.
12 THE WITNESS And I do recall conversations of their
13 getting older, you know, this case is not getting better. We
14 now have the civil overlay that we need to deal with. And
15 so, yes, that -- there was process, but while there was,
16 should we just call it a day, all of that factored into,
17 well, if the department is reviewing the department is
18 reviewing.
19 BY MS.
20 Q Okay. Are you -- what is your view of whether the
21 criminal division's review encompassed the NPA itself?
22 A So, the criminal division, by its terms, did not
23 did not encompass the -- the NPA. I would say that's
24 different than the deputy's review that encompassed the
25 totality of the -- of the circumstances.
Page 335
1 Q Okay. Did you discuss the -- did you have
2 conversations with the DAG -- with Mark Filip about this
3 case?
4 A Not to my recollection.
5 Q Okay, and we've already talked about the submission
6 that  made on behalf of your office?
7 A Which -- which -- yes, which I thought was a
8 fulsome submission, and included the draft indictment, the
9 NPA. I believe it included the term sheet and other
10 documents.
11 Q Did you or anyone else to your knowledge ask ODAG
12 to review or assess the NPA, or approve it?
13 A Not to -- before signature, not to my recollection,
14 but it was part of the ultimate review when submitted
15 the matter to the deputy, he included the --
16 Q It was --
17 A -- the agreement.
18 Q It was included. Their very brief letter, you
19 remember --
20 A Mm-hmm.
21 Q -- the letter that
22 A Yes.
23 Q -- authored, that he authored. Addressed really
24 only the issue of the appropriateness of the case for
25 prosecution in your office. It did not in any way reference
Page 336
1 the disposition, the plea agreement, or the NPA.
2 A So -- so, it was a brief letter. Based on
3 submission, I would have read that letter as, they had all
4 the material in front of them, and they were saying that
5 there was no misconduct or abuse of discretion.
6 Q That's correct, but they did not say that they
7 contacted -- that they addressed or assessed, reviewed even.
8 They didn't say they reviewed or approved the NPA.
9 A They -- I again, you know, I -- if the letter is
10 here, I don't know, but --
11 Q Yeah. I have it right here. It's not marked as an
12 exhibit, but this is an letter to Jay Lefkowitz and
13 Ken Starr dated --
14 A Right.
15 Q -- June 23, 2008 It states that this office,
16 meaning the Office of the Deputy Attorney General, has
17 completed a thorough review of the U.S. Attorney's handling
18 of the matter involving your client.
19 A And --
20 Q And addresses the -- or, states that they've
21 received and reviewed submissions from both parties, and then
22 states that the deputy attorney general, "Will intervene only
23 in the most unusual of circumstances," in a U.S. Attorney's
24 matter, and, "we do not believe such intervention is
25 warranted here. Even if we were to substitute our judgement
Page 337
1 for that of the U.S. Attorney, we believe that federal
2 prosecution of this case is appropriate. Moreover, having
3 reviewed your allegations of prosecutorial misconduct, and
4 the facts underlying them, we see nothing in the conduct of
5 the U.S. Attorney's Office that gives us any reason to
6 alter," --
7 A Right.
8 Q -- "our opinion."
9 A And so, so, if I could point out, this office has
10 completed a thorough review of the U.S. Attorney's handling
11 of the matter. And so, handling is a broad -- is a broad
12 term, and in reference to, we believe that federal
13 prosecution of this case is appropriate, the way I recalled
14 reading that is, the federal prosecution of this case, the
15 argument was that the agreement was inappropriate because
16 this case should not have even been prosecuted, and therefore
17 that the disposition -- the federal prosecution of this case,
18 was appropriate.
19 And so, the handling of the matter, we reviewed the
20 handling of the matter, not -- not the agreement, but the
21 handling of the matter, and that the ultimate disposition,
22 if -- you know, is at least not an abuse of discretion, or is
23 appropriate.
24 Q That's how you read it?
25 A That -- that is how I read it.
Page 338
1 Q And did you ever discuss that -- did you ever
2 discuss with anyone in ODAG what the scope of their review
3 was?
4 A Not to -- not to my recollection. It was a fulsome
5 submission.
6 Q Correct, but if -- if -- but the issues presented
7 by the defense were essentially federalism issues, right?
8 A So, the -- the -- again, this is -- this is based
9 on, you know, as much recollection as contemporaneous record.
10 The issues presented by the defense were, it -- in essence,
11 it was the heart of the non-prosecution agreement, which is,
12 was it -- was it an abuse of discretion to -- to proceed in
13 this case in the way that we did on the grounds that there
14 may not -- there should not have been a federal prosecution
15 in the first place, or that we were using federal criminal
16 law to -- to elicit a civil outcome.
17 And so, I don't think it's fair to sort of
18 narrow -- you can't -- you can't say that our handling was --
19 you know, that their handling was reviewed without reviewing
20 the non-prosecution agreement.
21 Q Do you have any reason to believe that the -- that
22 either ODAG or the criminal division did -- well, that the
23 ODAG, let's stick with that --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- did in fact review the NPA, other than to be
Page 339
1 aware it existed, whatever its status might have been?
2 A So, again, it was clearly submitted. It was
3 clearly referenced.
4 Q ME-hmm.
5 A And it was clearly part of the complaint. The
6 complaint -- the heart of the complaint about our office was
7 that we were using this agreement to impose civil liability.
8 And so, I think it is fair to infer if the complaint
9 implicates the agreement, that the agreement would have been
10 reviewed.
11 Q That -- but that's your inference. You don't have
12 any -- you don't -- didn't have any specific communications
13 with ODAG --
14 A I don't --
15 Q -- to that effect?
16 A I don't recall a specific communication.
17 Q All right. Okay. I would like to take a short
18 break. We're getting there.
19 A I hear you.
20 Q There is --
21 A I'm good.
22 Q -- one area that my colleague, will
23 take on --
24 A Mm-hmm.
25 Q -- which has to do with the CVRA
Page 340
1 A Right.
-- and then we have some kind of wind up questions.
3 A Okay.
4 MR. IIIIIIII Can we -- before we take a break,
5 can I just --
6 MS. IIIIIIII/  Yes.
7 MR. IME I'll try to queue up what's going to
8 be coming next --
9 THE WITNESS Mm-hmm.
10 MR. -- and maybe that'll help us move
11 through it, because --
12 THE WITNESS Right.
13 MR. -- you've been through a very long
14 day.
15 THE WITNESS Yeah.
16 MR. We appreciate your -- the time
17 you've put into this. You've been here for quite a long
18 time.
19 THE WITNESS Well, yeah.
20 BY MR.
21 Q The area that I want to discuss after the break has
22 to do with the ultimate notification to the victims about the
23 resolution of the case, the state plea, and the result of the
24 federal investigation, and there's going to be -- we have
25 documents that are in your -- that are already marked there
Page 341
1 that might be helpful if you take a look at a couple of them
2 so we don't have to go through -- maybe during the break so
3 we don't have to go through them one by one, or I can just
4 give you a very quick overview of sort of where we're going.
5 / want to find out basically how you were getting
6 from there -- what would be the -- the state asking for the
7 U.S. Attorney's Office to make the notification to the
8 victims about the upcoming state plea that happens in
9 November of 2007.
10 That would be document 32b, to the defense then
11 finding out that the government want to notify the victims by
12 letter, and then demanding that they see the letter and have
13 some kind of comment on it. That would be document 33, an e-
14 mail from Lefkowitz.
15 Then we have an exchange of letters, but the one
16 I'd like you to look at is document 37, which is a letter
17 coming from to the defense -- not now, but you know,
18 during the break. So, I want to find out how we get from
19 that document, 36, where is writing --
20 MS. 36.
21 BY MR.
22 Q -- as letter saying that -- citing the CVRA
23 regulations saying that the government is obligated to notify
24 the victims about the resolution of the case, and attaching a
25 draft letter to the victims telling them the time and date of
Page 342
1 the state resolution and plea, inviting them to come.
2 To ultimately a letter from you coming on the 19th
3 of December 2007, which is No. 41b agreeing to not notify the
4 victims of the state plea, and agreeing with the defense to
5 have the state be responsible for putting out that
6 notification.
7 And then we end ultimately with a letter or draft
8 letter that we have that goes out to the victims in the case
9 on -- after the plea in July. Well, we have the draft I'm
10 going to show you, which comes in June, showing that the
11 letter was clearly meant to be sent after the plea as per the
12 agreement, and that is document number 51.
A Okay. That's --
Q So, it's a lot to --
A That's a --
Q -- unpack there.
A That's a lot to unpack. We should probably take it
18 a step at the time?
19 Q Yes. I just wanted to --
20 A All right.
21 Q -- give you an overview, because I think that some
22 of what you had mentioned earlier -- and I know -- I know
23 it's --
24 A Yeah.
25 Q -- been a long time, so --
Page 343
1 A Yeah.
2 Q -- I'll try to orient you for the timelines. So,
3 if you'd just have a -- I've highlighted the sections of
4 those letters that we want to talk about, and if you have a
S chance while we're taking a break to look through them, that
6 may help orient you so that we're not --
7 A Right.
Q -- spinning our wheels on this. I don't want to
waste any of your time.
A Fair.
MS. : All right. Off the record.
(Off the record.)
MS. : All right. Back on the record.
14 MR. : Are we back on the record?
15 MS. : Yes.
16 BY MR.
17 Q Okay, great. So, I know I gave you a lot to unpack
18 over the short break we just had. One -- basically what
19 we're trying to get to find out is how the -- your decision
20 making process regarding the victim notification issue. So,
21 maybe if you could just give us a -- anything with your
22 December 19th decision, could you give us an explanation
23 about how you got there?
24 A So, I think we should probably take this in stages.
25 Q Okay.
Page 344
1 A As a general matter, I recall that there was back
2 and forth regarding -- after the agreement -- regarding how
3 to notify the victims, and there was back and forth between
4 and Jay Lefkowitz and around all that.
5 Sorry, I'm losing my voice.
6 I recall that there was an issue in particular that
7 was raised that I tried to address in the letter, and I
8 recall at the end of the day, it was my impression that once
9 there was an agreement for him to plead, that there was an
10 attempt by to provide notice to the victims, but it was
11 a very -- it was I think on a Friday, and he was pleading on
12 a Monday morning or something along those lines.
13 And finally, I recall that the view of the office
14 was that the CVRA did not apply, and so that this was a
20 g Okay.
21 A And look, let me -- let me add, I -- so, I think
22 it's important -- so, I came in and out of the case at
23 stages, and -- and I was involved in certain aspects more
24 than others, and while we had a long discussion about the
25 terms sheet and matters like that, while I was clearly
discretionary balancing that included consideration of what
impact notification of the 22.55s would have at trial -- the
22.55 provision, if we had to go to trial. So, we can -- we
can unpack that, but those are my -- my general
recollections.
Page 345
involved in at least one dispute around the 22.55, the nuts
2 and bolts of how victims were notified is not something that
3 I have a recollection about.
4 Q Okay. Fair.
5 A But we can unpack it.
6 Q Okay. Let's start with the Exhibit 33. So, there,
7 we have an -- as you can see, it's an e-mail from Lefkowitz -
9 A Mm-hmm.
10 Q -- to you, and to ISM, objecting to the
11 letter being sent to the victims, unless the defense gets to
12 review it. And later on in some of your other
13 correspondence, you discuss that you -- you extended to the
14 defense the courtesy of allowing them to review these
15 letters. Is this the genesis of that courtesy?
16 A I can't -- I don't have a recollection as to what
17 the genesis might be. I know that there was back and forth
18 between our office and the defense about the -- that letter.
19 Q Okay, but as you can see on 33 that you're not on
20 the response from but instructs to
21 send the proposed letter to Lefkowitz, and --
22 A Yeah.
23 Q -- I assume that wouldn't have done that had
24 you objected to it.
25 A Again, I don't -- I don't recall any specific
Page 346
1 conversation. As a general matter, this is not something I
2 was getting into the weeds on unless I had to. There was a
3 lot of back and forth.
4 Q MM-hmm.
5 A a is someone that I trusted. He was handling
6 this matter. He's incredibly experienced. I know that there
7 were concerns and issues around the impact that notification
8 would have on the witnesses. I know there were -- there were
9 issues around the language, and I trusted that folks were
10 working those out.
11 Q Mm-hmm. One of the -- the criticisms that's come
12 post, you know, the CVRA --
13 A Right.
14 Q -- litigation that's been the government allowing
15 the defense to have review of these letters, or potential
16 victim notification letters coming out of the government, and
17 that that's unusual. Have you ever -- have you had any other
18 cases where you've let the defense review such documents?
19 A I've had no other cases where I'm even aware of
20 victims being notified, because I assume it all operates
21 without it rising to management level.
22 Q MM-hmm.
23 A And so this is the first and only time that how
24 individuals are notified, to my recollection, was even in the
25 executive suite.
Page 347
1 Q Mm-hmm. Isn't that usually done -- accomplished by
2 almost a computerized task?
3 A I -- I would assume so, so yes.
4 Q And it's a -- given that that's the usual way that
5 notifications are made by a victim witness specialist, who is
6 usually that person?
A Yes.
Q Do I have that right? And so, the FBI has their
9 victim witness specialist?
A Yes.
Q And your office, the U.S. Attorney's Office has
12 dedicated people who do that job as well?
13 A Correct.
14 Q So, why in this case, not direct, the -- this --
15 this notification to that person to be done in the usual
16 course, why elevate to something that the defense is going to
17 be able to review?
18 A So, so, I can't address the second half of that,
19 but the first half of that question, why -- why was it
20 elevated? You know, I think addressed some of that in
21 her, was it 2017 affidavit, and -- and so, we had an
22 agreement that had been signed, and we also had substantial
23 questions as to whether that agreement -- whether ultimately
24 Jeffrey Epstein would plead in court or not.
25 And so, one of the questions is, how do you deal
Page 348
1 with notification of a possibility, where that possibility
2 could be used to impeach potential future witnesses who are
3 also the victims, and that is a matter that was being worked
4 out by the AUSAs in the office.
5 Q And the -- and the impeachment is what?
6 A And so, the impeachment -- and I -- I would -- :
7 believe  went into it in some detail, is you stand
8 you, Miss Victim, stand to gain quite a bit of money if
9 there's a conviction, correct?
10 Isn't -- weren't you aware of this agreement, if we
11 have to go to trial? Weren't you aware of this agreement?
12 And this isn't based on my recollection. This is based on
13 the affidavit, where she says that she had concerns
14 that the impeachment go along -- somewhere along the lines
15 of, were you aware that if Mr. Epstein's convicted, you stand
16 to receive substantial sums? Yes. Were you influenced by
17 this?
18 And there was some -- according to her affidavit,
19 this isn't my independent recollection, this is according to
20 her affidavit, there had already been dispositions of the
21 victims -- of at least some of the victims that raised these
22 issues. And so, I do think it was a valid concern by the
23 AUSAs how these notifications took place.
24 Q Okay, but isn't that the -- that type of line of
25 cross examination the same for any case where there's a super
Page 349
1 wealthy defendant?
2 A It may be. The 22.55 may make it a little
3 different because it's automatic, but ultimately, these are
4 the judgements that line attorneys make, and as U.S.
5 Attorney, I think it's appropriate to back up their judgment
6 unless there was some reason for me to believe it was
7 incorrect.
8 Q Was there any thought ever to just giving the
9 victims notification that there will be a proceeding that
10 will end the federal case, just separating that in a -- maybe
11 a later notification about the 22.55?
12 A I can't speak to what thought there was or was not.
13 I can say around this time frame, it was far from clear that
14 there would ever be -- that Epstein would ever go into court,
15 and we were thinking we may have to just go to trial, because
16 these collateral attacks keep going.
17 Q Okay. Okay. Let's get back on track to the -- the
18 question that I asked earlier about allowing the defense the
19 courtesy to look at these letters. Is -- can you just remind
20 us again, what was -- what was the reasoning that you're --
21 that they're allowed to look at the --
22 A So --
23 Q -- victim notification letters?
24 A I can't speak to that. This is something that --
25 that and would have handled. I think that, you
Page 350
1 know, I'm responsible for the office. I'm not shirking, I'm
2 just saying that this is -- that this was for the most part
3 within their wheelhouse, and not something that -- that I was
4 involved in. I can -- I can speculate.
Q Sure.
A The agreement was notifying them -- the letter was
7 notifying them of certain rights in the agreement, and
8 therefore, this is a time when we weren't sure what was
9 happening with the agreement. And so, perhaps this was a way
10 to -- to address some of the concerns around the 22.55. I
11 don't know. I'm just speculating.
12 Q Okay. Let's move onto Exhibit 36. This is a
13 letter that goes out to Lefkowitz under signature.
14 You are cc'd on the letter.
15 A All right.
16 Q And what he is doing is sending a draft victim
17 notification letter, which is attached as the attachment
18 there, dated December 6th, 2007. And I wanted to get your
19 impressions of -- if you go to page three of the letter,
20 please? And that -- the first little paragraph there, when
21 it --
22 A Mm-hmm.
23 Q -- refers to the Victims' Rights and Restitution
24 Act, and then ultimate for the CVRA, if you could just read
25 that paragraph to yourself, please?
Page 351
1 A Are you referring to paragraph 10?
2 Q I'm sorry, I'm not on the -- I'm on the letter,
3 not -- I'm sorry, I'm on the --
4 A Oh.
5 Q -- left -- the letter to --
6 A Sorry.
7 Lefkowitz, not the draft letter. This one right
8 here.
9 A The additionally?
10 Q Yes, additionally, pursuant to the Victims' Rights
11 and Restitution Act of 1990, our office is obligated,
12 etcetera.
13 A Okay.
14 Q Do you agree with that language? That
15 interpretation of the victims' rights, as far as the
16 notification?
17 A So, let's -- let's sort of take this -- this one
18 sentence at a time. With respect to notification of other
19 information that we were supposed to disclose, the statute
20 requires that we provide victims with the earliest possible
21 notice of -- I -- I will assume that that is a restatement of
22 the statute.
23 I don't have it in front of me, but let's assume
24 that that's a restatement of the statute. Just as in 18,
25 these sections are not limited to -- the victims, through
Page 352
1 this federal -- should be appropriately informed that a non-
2 pros does not require to forego its legal obligation. On a
3 sentence by sentence basis, I mean, do I agree, sitting here?
4 Sure, but I would want to sort of sit down before I gave a
5 legal opinion and spent more time with it, but --
6 Q Okay, because coming out of your office, sort of
7 this and that -- well, let's go to the next page, page four.
8 A Yeah.
9 Q There is a citation to the right to confer in the
10 first paragraph there, citing the CVRA's reasonable right to
11 confer with the attorneys of the government in this case.
12 A Okay.
13 Q So, we have -- you know, it looks like to me -- I
14 mean, let's --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- well, it -- it appears that there is two
17 references to the CVRA obligations that the government has
18 that ultimately the government argues that it did not have.
19 Can you explain why that is a correct interpretation?
20 A So, what I can say is I recall -- so, it looks like
21 at least some of the victims were notified. I recall a
22 discussion and a view that the CVRA did not require it -- it
23 was discretionary, because it wasn't -- the case had not
24 indicted, so it did not attach on its terms. That doesn't
25 mean that it's not something you aspire to. That just means
Page 353
1 it wasn't legally binding.
2 Q So -- and in the same manner though, while the CVRA
3 isn't legally binding, it also doesn't prevent you from
4 notifying the victims, does it?
S A It does not, no.
6 Q And you have the discretion to notify, should you
7 choose to.
8 A Correct.
9 Q Okay. And so, if you look at the letter that's
10 attached to this, this is a draft that goes out where on page
11 one -- two -- page three of the letter, and the second to
12 last paragraph, the letter is giving notice of Mr. Epstein's
13 change of plea and sentencing that will occur on -- well, at
14 this time, it was December 14th at 2007, and it gives the
15 address, and it says underneath there you are entitled to be
16 present and make a statement under oath.
17 If you choose, you can submit a written statement
18 under oath, etcetera, etcetera. So, this is a letter that's
19 actively inviting victims to come to the state. Would you
20 agree that that's inviting victims to come to the state plea?
21 A That -- I think that's fair.
22 Q And with the letter's reasoning that the government
23 is sending -- would like to send this letter because it
24 believes it's obligated to, because it resolves the federal
25 case?
Page 354
A So, I -- I don't want to speak to the reasoning,
2 but it's clearly a draft that the government is saying, it
3 intends to send.
4 Q Okay. Now, ultimately, just this is not a
5 question, just --
6 A Got it.
7 Q -- some information that will help to move us
8 along.
9 A Right.
10 Q The -- obviously, this letter is never sent. Ms.
11 drafts, we have them, and I'm not going to show
12 them to you, 30 letters, copies of the letter
13 A Right.
14 Q -- to different victims, addresses them, puts them
15 in envelopes, and is then told not to send the letters.
16 A All right. Well, the plea never -- it's scheduled
17 for December 14th, so yeah.
18 Q Yes, but one of the issues that's still percolating
19 until the end of December is who is going to make this
20 notification? Because as you can expect, the defense pushes
21 back on this letter.
22 And so now we go to the -- the -- number 39,
23 please? And this is a December 11th, 2007 letter from Ken
24 Starr to you, and if you look on page two, at the front -- at
25 the top of the -- the top of the page there, he is -- this
Page 355
1 letter is complaining about an oral notification that Ms.
2 gave to a -- one of the defense -- one of the
3 victim's attorneys that a letter would be coming.
4 And so, Mr. Starr is writing you to complain about
5 it, and he mentions in -- later in that paragraph that we
6 have thought that the notification process had been in
7 abeyance until completion of our ongoing discussions with
8 respect to that process. So, were you having discussions
9 with Mr. Starr about the process at this time?
10 A I don't recall discussions. I -- I think there was
11 at least correspondence, or -- I'm sorry, where are you? I
12 was reading the -- reading the letter. This -- I'm sorry,
13 where are you? What paragraph?
14 Q Let's take a look -- and it's been a long day.
15 Let's slow down here. We're on the second page of the Starr
16 letter.
17 A Yes.
18 Q And it would be this and that, the -- the language
19 in there -- in the second sentence, which goes towards the
20 bottom.
21 A This notification, but quite apart from our
22 substantive concerns, which -- we had thought the
23 notification process had been in abeyance until the
24 completion. That appears not to be so. This is
25 respectfully -- so, where does it imply that I was having
Page 356
1 I don't recall communications with Mr. Starr, that's why I'm
2 curious where -- at least verbal communications. I'm curious
3 where you're reading that from.
4 Q I thought he -- he's saying, we had thought that
5 the notification process had been held in abeyance until
6 completion of our ongoing discussions. Are you saying that
7 that's -- he's --
8 A So, I don't know where that may have come from, and
9 I don't recall. I recall at one point -- I think I sent a
10 letter saying we'll hold off for a week. I don't recall the
11 date of that letter, while you review some matters. Where
12 the abeyance came from, I can't -- I can't speak to.
13 Q Okay. Let's go to Exhibit 41b. This is your
14 December 19th letter, and what I'd like to draw your
15 attention to is page two, the second to last paragraph there.
16 A Yes.
17 Q So, could you tell us how your decision making
18 around this paragraph, how you got to this decision?
19 A So, so, you're asking me to recreate -- I -- at
20 some point, the issue clearly moved from interacting
21 with defense counsel to -- to my desk, and my recollection 12
22 years after the fact is -- so, you're saying we shouldn't
23 notify them about the state proceeding, and sure, the
24 state -- this was negotiated between Epstein and the state
25 attorney.
Page 357
1 We did not direct the state proceeding. So,
2 whatever state process is appropriate for the state process
3 will be given. But with respect to the federal resolution,
4 we intend to provide victims with notice of the federal
5 resolution as required by law, and your question is if we
6 thought it was discretionary.
7 I recall our believing it was discretionary, but
8 you could also -- it doesn't hurt to in a letter say we're
9 kind of required to do this, and I think it was the right
10 thing to provide them notice of the federal resolution.
11 And once that resolution was reached, and part of
12 the key word is what the resolution is, my understanding is
13 that made efforts to notify victims of that resolution
14 and let them know that -- that there would be a hearing the
15 following Monday, that they should attend, because these --
16 it would bring an end to the case.
17 Q Well, let's just back up real quick. As far as --
18 so, do you -- as far as the state attorney notifying people
19 of -- victims of the --
20 A Right.
21 Q -- state resolution, did you have any concerns with
22 that particular part of it?
23 A So, difficult to recreate the thought process 12
24 years later, but ultimately you've got federal, and you've
25 got state, and the state attorney will do what the state
Page 358
1 attorney thinks is appropriate. It's not for me to direct
2 the state attorney.
3 I'm inferring, based on this language, it's not for
4 me to direct the state attorney, or for our office to direct
5 the state attorney's office on its obligations with respect
6 to the state outcome.
7 Q Okay. I'm just asking because, you know, the whole
8 case came to your office because of some issues with the
9 state attorney's resolution of the case. So, now it's going
10 back, and they're going to be in charge of the notification.
11 Did that raise any flags with you, or did you have any
12 concern about whether it would be done correctly, or done at
13 all?
14 A So, again, you've -- I -- this has come up in
15 different contexts, and I think it's -- there was obviously a
16 concern about how it was being charged, but that doesn't mean
17 that they will not fulfill whatever obligations they have.
18 Let's not assume that -- that the state attorney's office is
19 full of bad actors.
20 Q Okay.
21 BY MS.
22 Q But even if not assuming that they're full of bad
23 actors --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- it's going to be difficult for them to notify
Page 359
1 the victims, wasn't it, that they didn't even necessarily
2 know the same list as the federal victims, because you had
3 found more victims.
4 A So, we could certainly have shared that list with
5 them. I mean, there are -- there are ways that this could
6 have happened. I don't know how -- what the communication
7 were, but as a conceptual matter, having the state notify
8 them of the state hearing and having the federal government
9 say, and this is the federal resolution, is consistent with
10 the law.
11 Q But since the federal resolution is tied to the
12 state plea, is -- why not just combine the two of them in the
13 notification? Here's the federal resolution. We're tying it
14 to the state plea, and here's --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- the date of the state plea?
17 A I can't speak to the why not. I can -- you know, I
18 can speak to my belief that this would be consistent with
19 law. That could also be one approach. I can't speak to why
20 A versus B.
21 Q Did somebody instruct you that -- or did you have a
22 conversation consulting with somebody about whether this was
23 the better approach?
24 A I -- I would have said -- you know, based on
25 practice -- not recollection, but based on practice, I would
Page 36C
1 have sat down with , most likely, since he was handling
2 this matter, and we would have talked about it. I would
3 not have sent this without running it by at least if
4 not other individuals in the office. I don't know if based
5 on your record there is -- there's e-mails with drafts, but
6 you know, every document that I'm aware of was sort of shared
7 within the management team, and this would have been one of
8 those.
9 Q With respect to that one specific decision about
10 this should be at the discretion of the state's attorney, did
11 you consult with anybody in D.C. about that issue?
12 A I don't recall consulting with someone in D.C.
13 about this issue. I recall a general perspective that the
14 CVRA as a technical matter did not attach because ultimately
15 this was not -- it hadn't -- this was not an indictment.
16 BY MR.
17 Q Oh, can we -- before we leave this letter --
18 A If I could, I -- I -- and I understand your
19 questions, but I feel some obligation to raise the tension
20 between, did you consult in D.C. versus should you allow D.C.
21 review.
And so, just, you know, we certainly were allowing
23 review, but U.S. Attorney's Offices don't consult on every
24 matter, especially offices that have the kind of
25 experience --
Page 361
1 MS. Mm-hmm.
2 THE WITNESS -- that Miami does.
3 MR. Back to me?
4 MS. in Mm-hmm.
5 MS. Mm-hmm.
6 MS. : Back to you.
7 BY MR.
8 Q Before we finish with this latter from the 19th,
9 can we look at page three, please? There is -- if you could
10 read the first paragraph on page three to yourself, please?
11 A Okay.
12 Q Could you -- in that section, you mention that
13 prosecutors had asked you to declare a breach, and you
14 resisted. Can you discuss that?
15 A So -- sure. That's -- that's referencing -- I
16 think increasing frustrations by the -- by the prosecutors,
17 and I think that's reflected in contemporaneous e-mails
18 saying, why don't we just rip this up?
19 And I recall conversations with and that goes
20 a little bit to what we talked about earlier, which is
21 concern that a unilateral breach would overlay not just the
22 initial issues that we had, and not just the fact that the
23 victims are getting older and the case isn't getting better,
24 but then we have, was the unilateral breach a valid breach,
25 or was it not a valid breach?
Page 362
1 And is -- is the delay justified or not justified.
2 And ultimately, that additional -- that additional
3 liability -- not liability, that additional legal uncertainty
4 was -- would have made the case even harder, because they
S were very careful to always say there is no breach.
6 MS. Mm-hmm.
7 THE WITNESS Let me -- let me address, because I
8 went on to read the next paragraph as well. And so let me
9 circle back to an earlier issue --
10 MR. Great.
11 THE WITNESS -- because I at least want to address
12 it because the next paragraph then says, and it's clear that
13 I'm increasingly frustrated. It's against that -- that my
14 frustration with it appears to be an 11th hour appeal weeks
15 before the now scheduled July 4th plea date. That said, the
16 issues raised are important and must be fully vetted
17 irrespective of timelines concerns. We hope to preserve the
18 July 4th date.
19 I understand defense counsel shares our -- with
20 this in mind, and in the event the defense counsel may wish
21 to seek review of our determination in Washington, I spoke
22 this past Monday with Attorney Gen confirming if it's
23 possible appearing to ask her to grant the potential request
24 for review, and to in fact review this case in an expedited
25 manner in an attempt to preserve the July 4th date.
Page 363
1 MR.IIIIF: January 4th.
MS. : That address -- January.
3 THE WITNESS I'm Sorry, the January 4th plea date.
4 Sorry, it's --
5 BY MS.
6 Q And that addresses the question I was asking.
7 A And that goes to the question you're asking, and
8 again, I'm recreating and I'm speculating. Having that
9 following the -- another 11th hour appeal here, I would say
10 I -- I wouldn't say, let's appeal this again. I think I'm
1 saying pretty clearly, it's against my frustration with what
12 appears to be an 11th hour appeal weeks before the now
13 scheduled July -- January 4th plea date that this is not an
14 invitation to do another appeal, because the appeal is
15 already in Washington.
16 But my -- my saying, if -- if we're going to do
17 this appeal, let's get it over and done with, then I'm sort
18 of speculating based on the language, so that we can get this
19 pled on January 4th, and let's not put it off until after the
20 holidays.
21 Q But you did say, "To ask her to grant the potential
22 request," --
23 A Which is --
24 Q -- "for review."
25 A Which is why I wanted to on my own raise it,
Page 364
1 because is that saying please appeal me, or is that saying --
2 this is an 11th hour appeal that you have now taken to
3 Washington.
4 It is December 19th. We're about to go into the
5 holidays. There's a January 4th plea date. This should not
6 be another way to put it off. And so, if you're going to do
7 this, I'm going to try to expedite it so we can get this
8 done.
9 Q And in fact, it took until May --
10 A Yeah.
11 Q -- 15.
12 A And it did, and apologies, I just realized my voice
13 is --
14 Q All right.
15 A -- rising. So, I don't know if that's my
16 frustration at reading this again, or it's getting late, but
17 it -- but it was a frustrating matter. Apologies.
18 BY MR.
19 Q Let's just move to Exhibit 46. So, this is an e-
20 mail from Ms. to you and discussing how she
21 has interviewed some victims that day. There's a mention
22 that one of the victims said that she would rather not get
23 any money and she'd have she would rather have Epstein
24 spend a significant time in jail. Did that piece of
25 information go into your character list at all about how the
Page 36
1 case should be resolved?
2 A So, again, not based on recollection, because this
3 is maybe if not 12, 11 years ago.
4 Q Okay.
5 A But at this point, there had been an agreement.
6 The agreement was signed. It was being reviewed. Based on
7 this e-mail, we're trying to get and expedite the criminal
8 division, because I -- I see it says please reach to to
9 make her decision.
10 And I -- I think at this point, as I said, if --
11 we knew earlier -- if we knew that it was going to go this
12 long and take all of this, I think we may have approached the
13 case differently, but we were so far along on this, there was
14 a signed agreement.
15 The United States can't unwind an agreement just
16 because it's frustrated, or just because some victim
17 indicates that they don't like it. That's not -- you know,
18 if the agreement is not legally valid, if there are some
19 other concerns, but I don't think this in and of itself would
20 have been grounds for unwinding an agreement.
21 Q Do you think it's misleading for the government to
22 have been interviewing these witnesses and preparing them for
23 a trial when there's already a signed NPA that resolves the
24 issue?
25 A So, that was part of the judgement that there's a
Page 366
1 signed agreement, but based on the course of conduct, is that
2 agreement really an agreement that will be honored? And so
3 there was an ongoing investigation as well, because we didn't
4 know if we'd go to trial, and I know that -- not I know.
5 My recollection is that the judgement was until we
6 know that this agreement is really going to be performed
7 fully, that to inform victims of the possibility of civil
8 recovery is problematic, and -- and I can't say that
9 judgement's incorrect. That -- I think that's a valid
10 judgement.
11 Q Fair enough, and then the last question on this e-
12 mail is at the bottom, Ms. invites you to attend
13 interviews with four of the girls who would be coming in the
14 following day.
15 A Mm-hmm.
16 Q Did -- did you attend?
17 A I -- I did not, and as U.S. Attorney, I don't think
18 I attended -- that's not -- that wasn't typical for our
19 office.
20 Q Would -- was that ever -- had you ever had that
21 type of request come from a line assistant?
22 A Not to my recollection, but I also tended not to
23 have communications come from line assistants in the first
24 place.
25 Q Were you at all curious, given the -- you discussed
Page 367
1 the issues with the witnesses in this case --
2 A Right.
3 Q -- that, potential impeachment, and that -- you
4 know, that caused you to -- that went into the negotiation
phase. Did you have any interest in seeing these people --
6 even interacting with them personally so you could make your
7 own assessment?
8 A So, any interest is --
9 Q Would there be value in doing that?
10 A So, we had very experienced prosecutors. It's not
11 just interacting with the -- the -- the victims were in a
12 really hard position. It's not -- how I would draw a
13 distinction between a victim being interviewed by an agent,
14 and how a victim holds up in court, in a public setting under
15 cross examination, and in that, I don't think anyone in the
16 office was questioning the pain or the suffering of the
17 victims. I think that the issues were how would they hold up
18 in court, which are uniquely trial issues.
19 what Okay. Then let's move onto what what
20 was your understanding that -- that the federal government
21 was going to do as far as the notification about the
22 resolution of the case?
23 A So, my understanding was that once we believed that
24 the case was going to be -- that the -- that the plea was
25 going to go forward, that we would notify the victims of the
Page 368
1 resolution, and of the agreement, and how -- basically, how
it played out.
3 Q Now, are you saying now -- now, you had agreed to
4 not notify -- well, did you -- I mean, you're -- one would
5 read your December 12th -- 19th letter as an agreement that
6 the federal government is not going to notify the victims of
7 the state plea. That's -- and that will end that part of the
8 case. Is that correct?
9 A So, so, I would parse my letter differently, and
10 this is 12 years after the fact, and so this isn't based on
11 recollection, but on my reading and my understanding of the
12 course of conduct in this case, sitting here now.
13 Q Me-hmm.
A My understanding was that our office was
15 notified -- was it on a Friday afternoon?
16 Q Yes.
17 A That he would be pleading on Monday, and that at
18 that time, made efforts to notify victims that he would
19 be pleading, and that that would terminate the federal
20 resolution of this matter, and that the victims should attend
21 that hearing, which wasn't the state resolution of the case.
22 It was the federal resolution.
23 Q And so, you -- you're saying that the state plea
21 was also the federal resolution of the case?
5 Based on my understanding of what happened, that's
Page 369
1 how my recollection -- based on having reviewed the record,
2 that's how I believe it proceeded, although I think
3 attempted to do so, couldn't reach some attorneys, and
4 exercised best efforts to let them know, but did not get
5 ahold of all of the victims --
6 Q Let's --
7 A -- over the weekend.
8 Q Before we get too deep into that, let's just take a
9 quick look at Exhibit 51. So, this is an e-mail forwarded to
10 you from from January -- June 25th, 2008. So, that is
11 five days prior to the plea in this case.
12 A Yes.
13 Q Or, the state court plea, and the attachment there,
14 you'll notice is a letter with a notification of identified
15 victims, and the letter is written, would you disagree --
16 it's written with, on June 30th, Epstein pled guilty. Do you
17 see that?
18 A Yes.
19 Q So, the inference -- it appears to be that this
20 letter was to be sent after the plea.
21 A I -- I see that. I also -- based on my review of
22 the record, where I think I'm recalling the
23 affidavit, where she said that she made an attempt to notify
24 the victims as soon as she was made aware that he would be
25 pleading -- that he would be pleading in state court.
Page 370
Q Well, the -- what says in affidavit --
A Correct.
Q -- I believe is that she made notification, and the
4 police department -- Chief police department made
5 notifications. Is that -- is that correct? Does that ring a
6 bell?
7 A
8 MR. TODD: Do you have a copy of the affidavit, so
9 we can just look at it?
10 MR. : Do you have affidavit e-
11 mail?
12 MS. : It's right here. One copy.
13 THE WITNESS I'll hand it back.
14 MR. : Almost done.
15 THE WITNESS So, relevant to this paragraph 34, and
16 then another paragraph, these and other attacks and efforts
17 to avoid the NPA's terms led the FBI investigative team, the
18 office, and me to conclude that prosecution at trial remained
19 a possibility, and we should prepare as such.
20 This meant that the victim notification letters had
21 to cease, because one, we no longer knew whether Epstein
22 would perform under the NPA, and hence, we did not know
23 whether providing information about the NPA would be
24 accurate, until we believed that Epstein, through his
25 counsel, would attempt to use victim notification concerning
Page 371
1 the NPA to suggest that victims had been encouraged by the
2 FBI or the office to overstate the victimization for monetary
3 compensation. And then fast forwarding because you can read
4 it on your own.
5 On Friday, June 27th at approximately 4:15,
6 received a copy of Epstein's proposed state plea agreement,
7 and learned that Epstein's state court change of plea was
8 scheduled for 8:30 a.m. on Monday.
9 The Palm Beach Police Department and I attempted to
10 notify the victims about the hearing in the short time
11 available to us. I specifically called to Attorney Edwards
12 to provide notice to his clients regarding the hearing.
13 I believe it was during this. I never told that
14 the state charges involved other victims, and neither the
15 state court charging instrument nor the factual proffer
16 limited the procurement of prostitution charges to a specific
17 cell.
18 So, that was what I was referring to. Again,
19 am -- I am basing this based on my review of the affidavit
20 and not on recollection of how this may or may not have
21 proceeded 12 years ago.
22 Q Okay. You know, would it surprise you to learn
23 that Ms. only communicated with Mr. Edwards that
24 day? That's because she was under the direction from a
25 manger to only contact Edwards regarding this -- the
Page 372
1 potential plea for that Monday?
2 A The affidavit said she attempted to notify the
3 victims, so I can't speak to that.
4 Q Okay.
5 A And I don't have an independent recollection of
6 this going back 12 years.
7 Q Were you aware that Ms. was directed to
8 have no communication with the state's attorney's office, and
9 probably during the later period of the case in 2008?
10 A Not to my recollection.
11 Q Okay, so did you have -- would you not recall
12 hearing anyone directing her to not communicate with the
13 state attorney's office?
14 A I can't speak 12 years later, what role I may or
15 may not have had. I question how, if we need -- if there is
16 a -- an attempt to schedule a plea in all that, how can there
17 not be communication? But I can't -- I can't say whether I
18 did or did not. When I say I have no recollection, I mean
19 that in the broadest sense of the word.
20 Q Okay. In your December 19th letter, you -- you did
21 agree that the state attorney's office would notify the
22 state's victims, right?
23 A Yes.
24 Q And do you have any idea how that was to be
25 accomplished?
Page 373
A I can't speak to that, no.
Q And would you have any knowledge of who the state
3 victims are?
4 A I would infer that -- that our office would have
5 had sufficient communication with the state attorney's office
6 to communicate who the victims were in this case, because it
7 was an ongoing -- it was an ongoing matter, and -- but I
8 don't know.
9 Q Do you want to go on?
10 MS. Okay. Are you -- are you done with
11 your -- that portion at least, for the moment?
12 MR. =mg Yes. Thank you.
13 BY MS.
14 Q I'd just want to clarify something you said a
15 moment --
16 A Sure.
17 Q -- ago, Mr. Acosta. You said you referred to the
18 agreement, the NPA, as having been -- it was signed and was
19 being reviewed. Were you talking about Washington?
20 A Right.
21 Q The criminal division, but we established earlier,
22 did we not, that the NPA was not the subject of the criminal
23 division review. They expressly declined to review it.
24 A I stand corrected.
25 Q Okay. I just wanted to be clear on the record.
Page 374
1 Thank you. So, we -- we've had a lot of conversation about
2 facts. We are fortunate in this case to have a plethora of
3 documents upon which we can rely even 12 years or so after
4 the fact, and we've tried to plum your -- the depths of your
5 memory as to the events.
6 Are there any facts -- any conversations, any
7 incidents, anything based on the questions that you've heard
8 here today that you recall, have recalled, that you want to
9 tell us about, want us to know?
10 A So, give me a minute to just sort of think this
11 through.
12 Q Of course.
13 A I think we've covered most of the issues pretty
14 clearly. I guess I would have two general comments. The
15 first is, whether folks agree or disagree with the initial
16 two years, you know, registration and restitution.
17 The office's focus was on having Mr. Epstein go to
18 jail at a time when, from our perspective, these -- these
19 cases were, at least presented with these facts, federally at
20 least unusual, and that most trafficking cases involved
21 different -- a different sort of nexus.
22 It involved bringing individuals into the country,
23 or holding individuals against their will, or doing something
24 like that, and -- and this will go to my second point which
25 is, you know, sitting here, we now see several high profile
Page 375
1 individuals who abused power, and have now been prosecuted --
2 who were known at the time who abused drugs, like Bill Cosby
3 and -- who were -- there were rumors at the time, and you
4 know, and -- and so, looking back, maybe it was the right
5 call.
6 Maybe it wasn't the right call, but there is some
7 degree of -- I'm not sure what the right adjective is.
8 Frustration, that -- and certainly, some of this goes to me,
9 but I think a lot of this goes to and the individuals
10 involved, that the attempt to put someone in jail as opposed
11 to decline the case and say this is just a state case,
12 that -- that the -- that the federal issues are too tricky,
13 that ultimately, this is sort of novel interpretations, that
the attempt to come up with an outcome has rebounded in the
way that it has, and I'm not -- I'm not saying, look, that
that's life, and I understand that.
But I do think it's important to look back on this,
and try to be in the shoes of the thought process in 2006 and
'07 when trafficking prosecutions were fairly new, when, you
know, more so than today, some jurors may have looked at this
as prostitution, and were -- perhaps more so than today --
judge's tolerance for victim shaming may have both caused
23 more hesitation on the part of victims, but also created more
24 issues at trial. And so, I think we've touched on that, but
25 I think as we sort of wrap up --
Page 376
1 Q MM-hmm.
2 A -- this portion of it, it's important to just
3 restate that.
4 Q And -- and to -- in addition, are there any facts
5 that you -- conversations, or anything that you --
A Fair, you did ask this.
Q -- that we have -- that we've not really elicited
8 from you that you want us to know? And to be clear, you'll
9 have an opportunity to --
A Right.
Q -- supplement this.
A Not that I can think of
Q All right.
A -- sitting here.
Q All right. How do you respond to public criticism
16 that the defense attorneys -- the Epstein defense team, were
17 gaining extraordinary access to an influence on prosecutors
18 from the line level all the way up through the department?
19 A So, I would point out early on in the case -- when
20 I said early, you pushed back, but from my perspective, early
21 on in the case. Not when it was first investigated, but when
22 it first bubbled up for decision.
23 Q And that would be mid-2007?
24 A Mid-2007. June-ish, May to June 2007, May, June,
25 July. We determined, here are -- here is what we'd need for
Page 377
resolution. And I -- I think I addressed some of this in the
2 Daily Beast's letter.
3 Q Mm-hmm.
4 A Because we were receiving criticism back then, and
5 I think that letter has been misconstrued to some extent,
6 because it was not, oh, here are influential people, we're
7 backing off.
8 It was, we, early on, set three criteria. Two
9 years, registration, restitution. Despite all these
10 attorneys, despite all these appeals, despite all these
11 efforts, the office did not budge with the caveat of the 24
!2 to 18 months, which we've discussed, and from my perspective,
13 despite all of that, I backed the office in sticking by that
14 resolution in the various appeals to Washington.
15 And so ultimately, it was a year-long process, but
16 we ended up a year later exactly where we started with the
17 caveat of the 24 to 18. And so, to the extent that there was
18 influence, there was -- there was no change in position.
19 Q Well, my question was access. That this team of
20 defense attorneys --
21 A Right.
22 Q -- had extraordinary access, that they asked for
23 meetings, they --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- pressed for -- with communications, and they had
Page 378
that access. Was -- did that seem extraordinary to you?
2 A So, they asked for a meeting with me before the
3 agreement was signed.
4 Q Mm-hmm.
5 A I granted that. That's not the first and only time
6 that I granted a meeting to -- to defense attorneys. I don't
7 think it's atypical, particularly as a case is coming to --
8 to resolution for a U.S. Attorney to sit down and meet
9 with opposing counsel, and I can think of several cases where
10 that happened There was certainly a lot of access in
11 Washington. I would speak to -- you know, I think that's a
12 question to direct to this building.
13 Q MM-hmm.
14 A Because the process here was lengthy, and
15 frustrating. But I think we successfully held firm in our
16 positions, despite all the process in this building.
17 Q And again, my focus is not on your response, but on
18 the access.
19 A And --
20 Q Based on the prominence and the -- the prominence
21 of the defense attorneys. If these had been local attorneys,
22 your sort of average criminal defense attorney from, you
23 know, name where they hang out in --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- Miami coming to you and pressing for this, you,
1 writ large, the department, do you believe they would have
2 had the same or a comparable level of access?
A So --
Q I don't know the answer. I'm asking.
A Yeah. So, I guess I'd respond this way. If an
6 attorney after meeting with my management staff asked for a
7 meeting with me, I believe I did and would have granted it,
8 and I can think of several matters on which those types of
9 meetings were granted. And so, that was not unusual.
10 Q All right.
11 A With respect to the back and forth after the
12 agreement was signed? This was an unusual agreement, and to
13 some extent, as a result, the back and forth quickly
14 elevated, particularly because matters would elevate in
15 particular when they were being addressed at main justice.
16 That would be one natural way for matters to elevate within
17 the office. And so, the fact that they were being addressed
18 and reviewed, and letters were coming here, would naturally
19 elevate the way the matter was treated in Miami.
20 Q In particular, Jay Lefkowitz had ready access to --
21 of course, he was involved in the negotiations with
22 directly in creating the NPA, but after that, it appears from
23 the record that he was often contacting you, and running or
24 going above the people who worked for you, and on numerous
25 occasions, you -- again, my characterization -- reprimanded
Page 380
1 him, or instructed him not to do that, and to direct his
2 communications to the line attorney or her supervisors. Is
3 that -- is that --
4 A
5 Q -- a fair characterization?
6 A Yes, on -- I think on several occasions, I said
7 direct them, and again, that was after the agreement was
8 signed, but yes.
9 Q But there were many issues still pending, correct?
10 A Yes.
11 Q Okay, and that was his ability to reach out to you
12 as a function of your personal association. Is that fair?
13 A So, I don't think that's a fair characterization.
14 I think it -- you could also say that it was the ability
15 of -- a function of his -- his insistence in not doing what
16 we asked, and the fact that in a typical course, a Miami
17 attorney would not have done this, because they would have to
18 interact with the office on an ongoing basis.
19 Q Mm-hmm.
20 A And so, the repeat litigator behaves very
21 differently than the one time razed earth litigator.
22 Q Mm-hem. Razed, R-a-z-e-d?
23 A Correct.
24 Q Is it reasonable to -- for us to understand that
25 you have followed the media coverage of what happened in the
Epstein case over the years?
Q In your view overall, and in whatever specific
respect you wish to address, is -- has it been accurate or
$ not so?
6 A I think it has been inaccurate in several ways, and
7 we can go through them, but --
8 Q If you could just tick those off?
9 A So, I think it's inaccurate in that it has been
10 characterized as our approving a state plea, and --
11 Q Mm-bean.
12 A -- the complexity of this case was a state plea,
13 and we were deferring to -- in favor of a state prosecution
14 has been lost, and it's something that I have attempted to
15 correct, but it's very difficult to sort of explain that in
16 the media.
17 You know, this is a bad analogy, and so I haven't
18 used it in the media, but I've thought about it, and so I'll
19 share it. So, after the Jessie Smollett plea in Chicago,
20 there was some discussion of whether the federal government
21 should bring charges, and I remember the media saying that,
22 and I haven't used this analogy, because I don't want to
23 compare, and I think it would be disrespectful to compare the
24 facts of that case to what happened to these victims, and I
25 still -- and I don't want the comparison to be drawn, but
Page 382
1 there is a legal comparison, right?
2 The U.S. Attorney in Chicago could have stepped in
3 and said, whether or not the state takes this plea, we may
4 investigate this federally, and sort of stopped that plea
5 from going forward, or at least put a wrench in those gears,
6 or the U.S. Attorney could have pursued that under petite
7 policy, and did not.
8 And so, our stepping into this sort of reminded me
9 of how many times cases that are viewed as a manifest
10 injustice do occur, and yet the federal government does not
11 step in? And the fact that we stepped in has been construed
12 as, this became a federal prosecution, and sort of going --
13 going to -- is it or --
15 A sort of question earlier, the
16 distinction between -- it was not a manifest injustice versus
17 this was the right outcome, is something that I think has
18 been lost in the coverage of this matter.
19 I think a second issue that has been lost in the
20 coverage of this matter is, there are references to Prince
21 Andrew, and Alex Dershowitz and Governor Richardson and Bill
22 Clinton, and thing happening in London, and the so called
23 Lolita Express where things may have happened on airplanes.
24 And so, this is viewed from the public as this international
25 matter, where the victims were local, the actions, to my
Page 383
1 recollection, was local.
2 And so, the distinction between this Palm Beach
3 incident and what the media likes to cover, which is, you
4 know, was, you know, did Mr. Epstein force a minor to have
5 sexual relations with Prince Andrew, is a very different fact
6 pattern both in terms of the public perception of forcing a
7 minor to have sex with a third party, that they have -- you
8 know, that is outside the solicitation context.
9 It's sort of -- I'm travelling with these women,
and forcing them to have sex, versus a more local matter
11 that -- I don't want to say solicitation, because I think
12 we've covered that, but that some may view as that.
13 Q Mm-hmm.
14 A And I think those are two major elements --
15 Q Right.
A -- that have been lost in the coverage.
17 Q The case has been criticized as having involved
18 improper influences, or favors, or payments that affected
19 decisions that were made within your office, and you're aware
20 of all those --
22 Q -- allegations as well. In connection with this
23 case. Were you yourself ever offered any -- any payments, or
24 any favors, or any promises or job assistance or anything
25 like that --
Page 384
A No.
Q -- in connection with this case?
A No.
Q And to your knowledge, was there any such offer to
5 anyone associated with this case in your office?
A Not to my knowledge.
Q It's been asserted also that the -- the handling of
8 the case in the office was affected by Epstein's wealth and
9 influence in the Palm Beach community. Do you -- what is
10 your -- what's your response to that criticism?
11 A Again, my response would be, you know, sometime in
12 May or June we came up with these three points, and we stuck
13 to them, and -- and you know, I -- despite all of this, you
14 know, when people make these assertions, somewhere along the
15 way, the fact that we stuck to those points is lost and is
16 not talked about.
17 And so, we did stick to those points. You know,
18 and -- and questioned whether the case would have come to us
19 in the first place but for -- and so, you know, I think that
20 could also go the other way.
21 Q I don't understand that.
22 A That it's highly unusual for a case to be brought
23 to the state -- to the U.S. Attorney's Office after the state
24 attorney declined not declines, but --
25 Q Fails to fully prosecute?
Page 385
A Right, and so, so one question that at -- that also
2 doesn't get asked is, you know, to what extent was this case
3 brought to us in the first place because of this, because of
4 his profile?
5 Q In other words, are you suggesting that his wealth
and influence in the community affected the state
authorities?
8 A I'm not suggesting that. What I'm suggesting is
9 the case came in, the case proceeded, and someone can make
10 the argument that the only reason that Chief brought
it to us was because it had such a high profile -- are there
12 other matters that take place in Palm Beach that a state
13 attorney declines in the first place that isn't brought to
14 the state attorney because it doesn't rise to that
15 Q You mean to the V.S. Attorney.
16 A -- to the -- to the U.S. Attorney because it
17 doesn't rise to that profile.
18 Q All right. All right.
9 BY MS.
20 Q Well, in fairness, he might've done it because of
the number of victims too, right?
22 A He may have. I don't know. What I'm suggesting is
23 we tried to treat it fairly, not looking at, hey, how wealthy
24 is he, but also not saying we need to do this because he is
25 so wealthy.
Page 386
2 Q What do you think about the media's treatment of
3 the line assistant, =ME?
4 A I think she -- I wish her name wouldn't be in the
11 not why they take the pay cuts that they take to go into
12 federal service, and you know, I think the media coverage of
13 this case has been unfair, and has lost a lot of the
14 complexities.
15 It's not surprising, because I mean, here, we're
16 talking about -- about a lot of those complexities, and it
17 takes a fairly sophisticated discussion, but I think it's
18 particularly unfair on
19 Q In your attorney's written response, he used the
20 term relentless for -- to characterize the team of lawyers --
21 the defense lawyers, and in that Daily Beast article that
22 you --
23 F.•
24 Q -- wrote, you referred to the yearlong assault on
media. You know, to some extent, U.S. Attorneys, when they
take the job, realize that part of their job is to take the
slings and arrows.
You know, there are instances when AUSAs were
accused of misconduct, and -- and I always sort of felt that
that was -- I don't want to say below the belt, but that's
25 the prosecution and the prosecutors, you noted that the
Page 387
1 defense was, "More aggressive than any of which I or the
2 prosecutors in my office had previously encountered." You
3 noted that the defense investigated prosecutors and tried to
4 disqualify two, and I believe that those two are
5 and . Is that --
6 A That is correct.
7 Q All right.
A Yeah.
9 Q And you also noted, or asserted that there were
10 investigations into the family lives of individual
11 prosecutors, accusations of bias and misconduct against
12 individual prosecutors, and even the threat of a book on
13 prosecutorial zeal. Do you still regard that
14 characterization as accurate?
15 A I do. You know, whether I would use those same
16 words now, we can spend a lot of time talking about it, and
17 I'd want --
18 Q All right.
19 A -- to think about, but I do think that's accurate.
20 I think this really was a razed earth type of matter, and in
21 the office's typical interactions, the prosecutors know they
22 have to come back to the office. And so, they would not
23 sorry, not the prosecutors. It's getting late, though. The
24 defense counsel.
25 And so, they would not -- it's not just the
Page 388
1 accusations against the attorneys, but the
2 mischaracterization. I -- you know, I could go through the
3 record, and there's several instances where my words, or
4 other AUSAs words are being mischaracterized, or where
5 going back to one of the Mlle -mails, people walk out of the
6 meeting believing they have an agreement, and then that's
7 unwound, and -- that that is not -- I don't know if that's
8 typical in Washington, but that's certainly not typical in
9 the Miami office.
0 Q All right, in that Daily Beast article, I think you
also used the term peccadillos.
What did you mean by that in particular?
14 A Could I see the -- could I see the --
15 Q Mm-hmm. I was afraid you'd ask that. I have it
right in front of me, and I don't at the moment, but --
MS. Are you talking about the to whom it
8 may concern letter?
MR. : Yes.
20 THE WITNESS Yes.
21 BY MS.
22 Q Yes. Thank you, and it's a reference on the second
23 numbered page of this copy, to personal peccadillos, in the
24 middle of the page.
25 A Also, individual prosecutors and their families
Page 389
looking for personal peccadillos that provide a -- so,
was, to my recollection, she wasn't investigated. I tri
and I haven't encountered that in other cases.
I recall it -- at one point, they also looked in , and
family, and his background, and I thought that was
little out of line.
Q
Q
15 F.
:8
Q

╭───── Page 90, Image 1 ──────╮
│ Page 389                    │
│                             │
│ s that provide a -- so, Jl  │
│                             │
│ in other cases.             │
│                             │
│ , and his background, and I │
│                             │
│ ©                           │
│                             │
│ >                           │
│                             │
│ BEBEAs                      │
│                             │
│ ©                           │
│                             │
│ a                           │
╰─────────────────────────────╯

Ni
A
tl
lilt the point I was trying to convey is, this is
not a -- this is not typical behavior by defense counsel.
Q Did --
A And despite all this, my point was, despite all
this, we did not budge.
Q And again, that's not the focus of --
Right.
Q -- of this guestion.I
16 A
Q
Q All right. Are there any other examples where
defense counsel came to you that have not otherwise been
21 addressed with --
Q -- allegations about someone --
25 A I'm hesitating --
Page 391
1 Q -- else --
2 A -- just because I'm trying to think through, and
3 not to my recollection, no.
4 Q Did they ever raise or imply that there were
5 that there was information regarding you of whatever respect,
6 that was in the nature of a sort of a threat, or a veiled
7 warning?
8 A So, the book reference was that I might be
9 personally embarrassed by pursuing this matter, because I
10 would be the subject of a chapter in a book on prosecutorial
11 overreach.
12 Q And who was going to write that book? Do you know?
13 A Professor Dershowitz.
14 Q MM-hmm. Okay. Did you consider him a professional
15 friend at all?
16 A I had not, to my recollection, met him. I -- I
17 understand in this letter I sort of grouped him in.
18 Q ma-hmm.
19 A But I would -- I'd say for the record that it's
20 hard to know what my intent was in 2011, but that's for
21 simplicity of grouping individuals, because I did go to
22 Harvard.
23 I may have run into him at Harvard, but he was not
24 my professor, and I don't -- I didn't work for him as a
25 teaching assistant. I had some interest in criminal law, so
Page 392
1 I may have chatted with him, but -- but that would have been
2 it.
Q And did you consult with him at all in connection
with your efforts -- your interest in potentially teaching or
being involved in the -- sort of the law school world, either
at Harvard, or at Florida International, or anywhere else?
A Not to my recollection. At some point when I
8 applied for the deanship -- I wasn't aware of the deanship
9 until -- so, let's -- let's take this -- let's take this in
0 part. I thought about looking at Harvard for a teaching
1 position. To my recollection, I never followed through on
2 that.
Q Mn-bmm.
A I knew Elena Kagan, and may have had a conversation
with her that would have been a preliminary, how does this
6 process work? But I don't recall taking it -- if I took it
that far, and I'm not saying that I did -- this was a long
time ago -- I never sort of went through -- the way law
19 schools hire is a very -- they call it the "meat market."
20 Q Min-hmm.
21 A Take that for what it's worth. It's something that
22 happens at the hotels here, at the -- at the Marriott here
23 in -- on Connecticut, and it's a very formalized process, and
24 I never --
25 Q Mm-hmm.
Page 393
1 A -- went through that. I don't recall any
2 conversation with Professor Dershowitz about that. To the
3 extent I was thinking about it, it'd be natural for me to
4 talk to but I don't recall talking to him. With
5 respect to Professor Dershowitz, with respect to FIU, the
6 dean process is very decentralized.
7 To the extent a faculty member spoke to him, I
8 don't know. To my recollection, and again, this is a long
9 time ago, I did not ask him for a reference or a letter or
10 something to that regard, although I may have. It was a
11 long, long time ago. I was also no longer active in this
12 case at the time.
13 Q All right, and what about with respect to that same
14 process on your part, Ken Starr, who actually was a dean of a
15 law school at the time? Did -- did he provide you with a
16 reference, or --
17 A Not --
18 Q -- advice?
19 A Not to my recollection.
20 Q Ail right.
21 A As -- as the letter from -- from Ken at the end,
22 there was some -- by the time this was over, there was some
23 degree of tension between us on my resolution of this matter.
24 Q But it also appeared to be tension that both of you
25 were eager to leave aside.
Page 394
1 A I'm a big believer, and I had good relationships
2 with the defense bar. I think lawyers can disagree and not
3 be disagreeable, and we would be a better profession if we
4 all learned to do that.
5 Q So would the world.
6 A Yes.
7 Q There is an -- sort of investigative journalist
8 author named
9 A Yes.
10 Q Do you know that name?
11 A Yes.
12 Q Did you ever speak with her?
13 A So, she was the recipient of the do -- to whom it
14 may concern letter at the Daily Beast.
15 Q Oh, really?
16 A Yes.
17 Q All right. All right. Thank you. I didn't -- we
18 didn't know that. Did she comment back to you on it?
19 A It was a long time ago. I don't -- I don't recall.
20 Q So, she wrote a book called trafficking. Have you
21 read that --
22 A She did --
23 Q -- about this case?
24 A She did. I haven't read it recently, but I read it
25 a while ago.
Pane 395
1 Q And she says in that book that you told her a few
2 years after the NPA was signed that as she writes, "He felt
incapable of going up against those eight powerful attorneys.
He felt his career was at stake." Did you say that to her?
5 A Not to my recollection, and what I tried to do was,
6 for the record, provide this letter to her, and the purpose
7 of this letter was to say the exact opposite, which is -- and
8 you know, we have this -- you know, and she and the New York
9 Times, and I think the New York Times called it -- what --
10 what's the word? Like, apologia? Does anyone know what --
11 Q Apologia.
12 A Apologia.
13 Q It's a -- it's an --
14 A --
15 Q -- apology. It's a fancy way of saying --
17 Q -- you're --
18 A Ye4h.
19 Q -- explaining yourself.
20 A Yeah. I looked it up, and it's a little more
21 derogatory than explaining yourself, because I felt a need
22 Q Ma-ham.
23 A -- to look it up, but the New York Times called
24 this letter an apologia.
25 Q Ma-ham.
Page 396
1 A And this was recently, and I say this, because when
2 folks read this letter, they read it as, this is why, you
3 know, we had these -- they -- I think sometimes they
4 selectively read language. The prosecutors and agents in
5 this case -- and what followed was a yearlong assault. I
6 used the word assault as it was more aggressive than anything
7 in which I or the prosecutors in my office had previously
8 encountered.
9 Excuse me. Mr. Epstein hired an army of legal
10 superstars, Harvard Professor Dershowitz, former judge and
11 then Pepperdine lodging Ken Starr, former deputy assistant to
12 the president then Kirkland & Ellis law partner Jay
13 Lefkowitz, and several others, including prosecutors that
14 formerly worked in the U.S. Attorney's Office, the child
15 exploitation section -- I'm not sure who that was -- of the
16 Department of Defense, and they --
17 Q Department of Defense?
18 A No, no, in the child exploitation and obscenity
19 section of the Justice Department. Defense attorneys next
20 requested a meeting with me. And they read that as saying
21 these -- there were all these powerful lawyers in the case,
22 but they don't then go on to talk about, despite this army of
23 attorneys, the office held firm to the terms first presented
24 to Mr. Black in the original meeting.
25 Q So, is it your -- so, what I understand you saying
Page 397
1 is that the panoply, this pantheon of attorneys did not have
2 the influence on you that's alleged?
3 A And -- and the purpose of this letter was to say,
4 despite all this
O
Q Right.
A -- we held firm. So, how can you say that there's
influence if we held firm?
Q So, the --
A And I would -- I would also -- I'm sorry.
Q No, no.
A I would also note, and I think we talked about
12 this, that those terms were developed before many of these
13 individuals came on board.
14 Q Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
15 A So, it's not like these terms were developed
16 because, oh, now these individuals are on board.
17 Q All right. And we haven't, of course, talked about
18 the whole work release issue, but --
19 R Yeah.
20 Q -- I think that speaks -- the record --
21 A Yeah.
22 Q -- speaks for itself on that.
23 A Yeah.
24 BY MS.
25 Q So, I'm not sure I'm clear. Did you have an
interview, or give a -- have a conversation with Ms.
2 aside -- or, just sent her this letter?
3 A I spoke to her briefly saying, I'm not going to
4 speak on the record. I'm not going to address even off the
5 record details of this case, but I will provide a letter to
6 you. I've had a lot of requests over the years to talk about
7 this case.
8 There were enough requests coming that I thought it
9 important to provide a statement to defend the actions of the
office. I didn't want it to be to one reporter in
1 particular, because I did not want to play favorites. And
12 so, I provided a to whom it may concern letter that was a
13 public letter, but then I gave it to her.
14 MS. : All right. Go on?
15 BY MS.
16 Q And just one thing on the work release issue. Did
17 you tell the defense that -- that the U.S. Attorney's Office
18 would not object if he got work release as long as he was
19 treated like every -- like every other defendant?
20 A So -- so, I don't recall what I may or may not have
21 said specifically around work release. My recollection of
22 our general position is, you're pleading in state court to
23 incarceration of 18 -- it's now 18 months, it was 24.
24 Whether it was 18 or 24, this would have been -- any
25 conversation I would have had would have been after the
Page 399
1 agreement was signed.
2 It's our expectation that he be treated just like
3 everyone else, if -- if it was typical to provide that kind
4 of work release in these cases, that would have been news to
S me. I certainly would not have expected that, and I think
6 based on our subsequent communications with the state
7 attorney's office, that was not what our office envisioned.
8 By the same token, I don't think our office envisioned that
9 he be treated worth that the typical offender.
10 Q Well, did you know that was in fact trying to
11 make sure that he didn't get work release?
12 A Yes. And so, I don't see any reason why I would
13 have contradicted that, is -- is my point.
14 Q All right. You've mentioned a number of times that
15 the sexual offender registration was the -- one of the three
16 important prongs for you and the office.
17 A Yes.
18 Q What was it that you saw the sex offender
19 registration as accomplishing?
20 A So, to some extent it's putting the community on
21 notice that, irrespective of whether he's in Florida or
22 elsewhere, he's a registered sex offender. To some extent, I
23 don't know if this is -- but I'll say it anyhow. This was a
24 serious crime, and there is a public sanction associated with
25 this, and I thought to the extent that he committed the types
Page 400
1 of acts that typically are associated with registration that
2 that should go forward, but the primary motivation there was,
3 put the public on notice that he is a registered sex
4 offender.
5 Q And did you see any conflict with that as being a
6 goal with the provision in the NPA that was -- that the NPA
7 was going to be kept confidential, and the communications in
B which the -- in which the U.S. Attorney's Office was having
9 with the defense about continuing to keep things
10 confidential? Do you see any inconsistency between those
11 two?
12 A No, in that I -- I genuinely was of the opinion
13 that this NPA would go public, and certainly his public
14 his state court plea would be public, and his registration
15 would be public. And so, it would -- what he did would be
16 known.
17 Q And given what you know about these office's back
18 and forth on notifying the victims, do you think, looking at
19 the entire course of conduct of the office, that the victims
20 were treated fairly, and with dignity and respect?
21 A So, I want to be careful, not because I'm fudging,
22 but because it's a complex question. If, looking back in
23 hindsight, we knew that there would be a -- what was it? Two
24 eight months period, when -- do we have an agreement, do we
25 not have agreement, is this concluded, is this not concluded?
Page 401
1 Is this an ongoing investigation?
2 How do we deal with all these notification issues?
3 If we had foreseen all of that, I think I've said before,
4 that -- that something I certainly think should have been
5 considered, and it's very possible we would have done
6 something very different.
7 But that was not foreseen. And so, it's then a
8 very difficult judgement to be made, because there is an
9 agreement. There is concern as to if we have to go to trial,
10 how do you address this?
11 There is, you know, going to the
12 affidavit, at least one instance -- and I'm merging my
13 recollection here, and -- and my knowledge after the fact,
14 because your question sort of calls for an after the fact
15 assessment.
16 So, you've got the affidavit, which
17 points out that defense counsel did all they could, but is
18 using this to impeach and weaken witness credibility in a
19 case where there's already questions around witness
20 credibility.
21 And so, it's a very imperfect situation with
22 discretionary judgements to -- to do the best, to sort of
23 balance all these factors. Is that the best outcome?
24 Probably not, but that's where the -- that's where we were,
25 and that's why I think this case would have been very
Page 402
1 differently if what was it, October 24
2 Q MM-hmm.
3 A -- he would have gone in and plead and taken his
4 time and served his time like so many other people have done
5 as opposed to mount all these legal challenges that we then
6 had to work through.
7 Q And I'll preface my question with the -- with the
8 fact that we're still investigating this. We've made no
9 conclusions --
10 A Mm-hmm.
11 Q -- with respect to this, but if OPR determines that
12 your office should be criticized for its handling of this --
13 A Right.
14 Q -- matter, does that criticism fall on you, or does
15 it fall on your senior managers? Because as a non-
16 prosecutor, you were relying on them to keep you informed,
17 and for their judgement.
18 A So, I was the U.S. Attorney. I certainly relied on
19 my staff, but ultimately, I was the U.S. Attorney, and I
20 don't think it's justifiable or fair to sort of say this was
21 on them. I was sufficiently aware of matters that -- that --
22 it was my office, and -- and while I'll say that I was -- I
23 might not recall this, or I was relying on A, B, or C for
24 guidance, or to handle this matter, ultimately, I think those
25 judgements always sort of bubble up.
Page 403
1 BY MS.
2 Q In your press conference, you reference -- this is
3 the -- I think July 10, 2019 press conference. You
referenced victims, what they went through was
A Mm-hmm.
6 Q -- horrific, you said, and then you said, I've seen
7 these videos. I've seen the interviews. I have seen the
8 interviews on television of these victims, and their stories.
9 Just to be clear, are you talking about interviews and
10 television coverage and videos recently, or back in 2006
11 and --
12 A Recently.
13 Q -- 2007? Okay. I just wanted to be very clear
14 about that. The U.S. Attorney's manual requires us all in
15 the department to conduct the fair, even handed
16 administration of the federal criminal laws. What's your
17 view as to how the handling of this case comported with that
18 principle?
19 A So, I do think it was fair, and even handed. We --
20 you know, after the fact, may look back and say that two year
21 may not have -- you know, it shouldn't have been a manifest
22 injustice standard. It should have been, you know, a sort of
23 a de novo, let's treat this as a new prosecution.
24 That's a judgement you'll all make, but -- but
25 those judgements were made with an eye toward fairness and
Page 404
1 impartiality, and once those judgements were made, despite
2 all the attorneys involved, and despite all the litigation,
3 and all the -- all the stuff, all the appeals to Washington
4 and the -- you know, we stuck to that position.
5 Q Mm-hmm.
6 A And I think that speaks to the way the office
7 approached this matter.
8 Q All right. We -- I -- we spoke sort of offline
9 earlier about an issue that was raised in that press
10 conference that was not clearly answered on your part in that
11 context, and the question was -- and this is on page 15 of
12 the internet transcript of --
13 A Right.
14 Q -- that press conference. You were asked whether
15 you were ever made aware that Mr. Epstein was "an
16 intelligence asset of some sort." And you -- you in your
17 response you said you couldn't answer it -- couldn't address
18 it directly because of guidelines. Can you clarify -- first
19 of all, were you ever made aware of that --
20 A If he was --
21 Q -- assertion?
22 A -- I'm not aware of it.
23 Q All right. Did defense counsel ever say to you
24 that Epstein had that status?
25 A Not to my recollection.
Page 405
Q All right.
2 A And -- and to clarify, I also don't know where
3 press reports from multiple sources -- not from multiple
4 sources, but from multiple media outlets that I told someone
that he was an intelligence asset.
6 I do not know where that came from. If -- if I can
just -- so, there are questions that I may be asked publicly,
8 that I don't think it's right for me to comment as to what
9 classified information I may or may not know, because that's
10 not the kind of stuff you'd go into, but the answer is no,
11 and no.
12 • All right. Without reservation, without any --
A No, and no.
• All right. Excellent. Thank you. A couple of
▪ final questions. As you can tell --
16 A Can I -- can I --
17 Q Yes.
18 A -- address as second issue that has come up at
19 times?
20 Q Yes.
21 A There are also media reports that this was because
22 of cooperation in some financial
23 Q Me-hmm.
24 A -- financial matters. I don't know where that may
25 have -- I don't know where that may have come from.
Page 406
1 Q All right. Thank you, and we are familiar with
2 that, what you're referring to.
3 A Was -- was there cooperation related to financial
4 matters?
Q We didn't ask you about it.
A Okay.
Q As you can tell, OPR obtained many electronic
8 records --
9 A Yeah.
10 Q -- mainly e-mails, but other electronic holdings
11 from the department. The Department of Justice, however, has
12 not been able to find/recover a portion of your e-mail
13 account as U.S. Attorney that contained e-mails received by
14 you between May 26th, 2007, and March 2008.
15 A Correct.
16 Q A period of time rather relevant to this. We have
17 obtained many records of course from senders and from other
18 people copied. So, we have many of the records, but the fact
19 is, that's a --
20 A Mm-hmm.
21 Q -- gap in the holdings, and this is despite the
22 fact that as you no doubt know, the law requires that U.S.
23 Attorney records be maintained and archived --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- indefinitely. Can you give us any insight, any
Page 407
idea why that might be the case?
2 A I can't, and my recollection was after -- after
3 several issues that took place, the department had some sort
4 of records retention software that automatically retained
5 these e-mails. Is that not accurate?
Q There was a -- there was a switchover from --
A Right.
Q -- a period in which that record retention
9 responsibility resided with each U.S. Attorney's Office, and
10 at the switchover, it became centralized.
A Right.
And this appears to have sort of gotten lost in
13 the --
14 A Been caught in the switchover. I -- my
15 recollection is that there was some automatic retention
16 mechanism --
17 Q Okay.
18 A -- and I can't address that, although there's
19 certainly a fulsome -- a fulsome record.
20 Q But just to ask the inevitable question --
21 A Right.
22 Q -- did you take any action to discard, destroy, or
23 dispense with any official records --
94 F. Not --
7 Q -- related to this matter?
Page 408
1 A Not to my recollection. I think there's a fulsome
2 record, and not to my recollection.
3 Q All right, and is there any particular gap that
4 you've discerned in the records that we've provided to you?
5 A Not that I recall. Do you have the e-mails that I
6 sent, out of curiosity?
7 Q We do.
8 A Okay. So, you have the sent, but not received.
9 Q Yes.
10 A Just checking.
11 Q And lik , we retrieved from the federal records
12 center --
13 A Right.
14 Q -- records that were boxed up and sent there, hard
15 copy documents, after your term ended, and there is nothing
16 that relates to the Epstein case. There were records that
17 were maintained that were kept in the main office --
18 A Right.
19 Q -- after you left, because it was an ongoing
20 matter, but it -- do you have any idea why there are not any
21 in the records of yours --
22 A So --
23 Q -- that were sent?
24 A So, I have a recollection that when I left, there
25 were some binders that I passed along to , because it was
Page 409
1 an ongoing case, and we sort of had binders out that sort of
2 had correspondence back and forth.
3 Q All right, and you've already made we've
4 we -- I asked you about facts, but you addressed a sort of a
5 broader statement to us for the record about the case. Is
6 there anything else you want to tell us at this point?
7 A Give me a second to --
8 Q Sure.
9 A -- sort of think this through.
10 Q In fact, if you'd like to take a quick break and
11 talk to your attorney, and that will be the last question.
12 A Do we need a break?
13 MR. : No.
14 MS. : Your attorney says god no.
15 THE WITNESS I will -- I will follow up on this.
16 MS. All right.
17 THE WITNESS Nothing that I -- if something comes
18 up, my understanding is that we're receive the transcript,
19 and have enough time given the length of this to review and
20 comment.
21 BY MS.
22 Q Exactly, yes, and for the record --
23 A Right.
24 Q when the transcript is prepared, which should be
25 within a couple of weeks, we'll ship that off to your
Pac ,-
1 attorney.
2 A Mm-hmm.
3 Q We'll ask you to review it, to make not only any
corrections, but also clarifications, and to add to it --
5 A Mm-hmm.
6 Q -- if you feel having read something that it needs
7 to be clarified or expanded upon, you're invited to do so.
8 A And if I could ask one -- one other question. Is
9 there -- and I'm not familiar enough with the way OPR
10 operates, and this may be suigeneris, so you may not be
11 prepared to answer, if there is a report as opposed to a
12 letter, which is what I typically am familiar with, will that_
13 report be shared in advance for comment?
14 Q I am going to --
15 A Or is that to be determined?
16 MS. I am going to defer to Ms.
17 for that.
18 MS. : That's a question that doesn't need to
19 be on the record. Do you have anything else that you'd want
20 to put on the record before we close out?
21 THE WITNESS: I do not.
22 MS. All right.
23 MS. : All right. Thank you. I want to
24 extend our great appreciation for your willingness --
25 THE WITNESS No problem.
1 MS.
Page 411
-- to come in and help us with this
2 case.
3 THE WITNESS So, so, let me -- now that we're off
4 the record, let me say --
5 MS. : Are we off the record?
THE REPORTER: Not yet.
THE WITNESS Not yet? Oh.

MS. No?
THE REPORTER: You didn't say it.
10 MS. : All right. That's it. We're off
11 the record.
12 (Whereupon, at 8:38 p.m. the interview of r".
13 Alexander Acosta was concluded.)
IA * * *
Page 412
CERTIFICATE
THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA )
IN THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA )
I, Beth Roots, Notary Public, before whom the foregoing
deposition was taken, do hereby certify that the witness
whose testimony appears in the foregoing pages was duly sworn
by me; that the testimony of said witness was reported by me
by electronic record, and thereafter reduced to typewritten
form; that said deposition is a true record of the testimony
given by said witness; that I am neither counsel for, related
to, nor employed by any of the parties to the action in which
this deposition was taken; and, further, that I am not a
relative or employee of any attorney or counsel employed by
the parties thereto, nor financially or otherwise interested
in the outcome of this action.
Beth Roots
Notary Public in and for the
District of Columbia
My commission expires:
April 30, 2020
EFTA00009229 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Alex Acosta pages 1-100
(date: 2020-04-30)
Page 1
THE UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
OFFICE OF PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY
x
INTERVIEW OF R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA :
x
Washington, D.C.
Friday, October 18, 2019
Interview of:

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
a witness of lawful age, taken on behalf of the United States
Department of Justice in the above -entitled action, before
Beth Roots, Notary Public in and for the District of
Columbia, in the offices of the U.S. Department of Justice,
950 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W., commencing at 9:34 a.m.
Diversified Reporting Services, Inc.
Page 2
APPEARANCES:
On Behalf of the Department of Justice:
Department of Justice
950 Pennsylvania Avenue N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20530
On Behalf of the Witness:
GORDON D. TODD, ESQ.
T.J. HERRON, ESQ
Sidley Austin LLP
1501 K Street Northwest
Washington, D.C. 20005
Page
PROCEEDINGS
2 Whereupon,
3 R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
was called as a witness and, having been first duly sworn,
5 was examined and testified as follows:
6 EXAMINATION
BY MS.
Q So, would you tell us your name, please?
A Rene Alexander Acosta.
Q And Mr. Acosta, you're accompanied by your
11 attorney, Gordon Todd, is that correct?
2 ,
• And Mr. Todd, would you identify the associate you
have with you?
MR. HERRON: Yes, T.J. Herron.
MS. : H-e-r-r-o-n?
17 MR. HERRON: Correct.
18 MS. : Thank you. Mr. Acosta, I'm
19 I am a counsel with the Office of Professional
20 Responsibility here at the Department of Justice, and with me
21 are my fellow OPR counsel, and IIII
22 . We are in a conference room at the Department of
23 Justice main building on today, October 18, 2019, and we're
24 starting at about 9:30 in the morning. Before we start, I'd
25 just want to put on the record that Mr. worked in
Page 4
1 the Civil Rights Division at the time that you were the AAG
2 heading that division, and I believe had an occasion to
3 briefly meet you in connection with a matter.
4 THE WITNESS: Could I ask what section?
5 MR. I was in the special litigation
6 section.
7 THE WITNESS: Oh, okay.
8 MR. : And I provided Mr. Acosta some
9 talking points for a press situation that we had in that
10 case.
11 THE WITNESS: 14141.
12 MR. : Yes.
13 THE WITNESS: Probably.
14 BY MS.
15 Q All right. Thank you. Mr. Acosta, OPR is
16 investigating two things. As you know, one, whether one or
17 more federal prosecutors in the Southern District of Florida
18 U.S. Attorney's Office may have committed professional
19 misconduct by entering into the non-prosecution agreement, or
20 NPA, in 2007 with Jeffrey Epstein, who at the time was under
21 investigation by that office, and the FBI, for engaging in
22 widespread sexual misconduct involving underage females.
23 The second thing we're investigating is Judge
24 Marra's finding of February of this year, 2019, that the
25 government may have violated -- or, actually, he found the
Page 5
1 government did violate the CVRA, or Crime Victims' Rights Act
2 when it entered into the MPA without first providing the
3 victims with notice and a reasonable right to confer with the
4 government.
5 You are a subject of the OPR investigation, that
6 is, one of -- somebody whose conduct is being reviewed and
7 evaluated by OPR, and specifically as U.S. Attorney at the
8 time for the Southern District of Florida, you had the
9 ultimate authority over the Epstein for a period of two and a
10 half years, as we understand it, from the time the line AUSA
11 first briefed you and then criminal chief
12 in July of 2006, and until you were formally
13 recused from the case on or about the 8th of December, 2008,
14 after notifying the executive office of the U.S. Attorneys
15 that you were seeking employment with Kirkland S Ellis, a
16 firm of which two attorneys, Ken Starr and Jay Lefkowitz had
17 been representing Jeffrey Epstein. Is that correct?
18 A We may -- we may get into it a little bit later,
19 but I think the characterization of my seeking employment is
20 not accurate, we can talk about that a little bit later.
21 Q All right. We have the documents that relate to
22 that. So, that's what we're -- we're basing it on.
23 A Correct.
24 Q And I believe the term that's used is seeking
25 employment.
Page 6
1 A That -- that is the term used in the e-mail. I
2 think I addressed that in my -- I believe Mr. Todd addressed
3 that in the letter that was sent to --
Q All right.
A -- OPR.
Q All right. Thank you. So, we recognize that
7 you're not longer with the Department of Justice --
8 A Right.
9 Q -- and that it is your choice to come and talk to
10 us, and we very much appreciate your willingness to
11 voluntarily do so and help us figure this case out. OPR
12 provided you with a few thousand pages of records, e-mails,
13 and correspondence and some other documents that reflect your
14 involvement in the Epstein matter over that two and a half
15 year period.
16 Now that you've had a chance to review, I hope,
17 those e-mails and other documents, we hope you can be
18 specific in helping us understand what happened. Have you in
19 fact been able to review those documents?
20 A Yes, I have.
21 Q Thank you. OPR asked you for a written response to
22 certain questions, and we've received and reviewed a written
23 response prepared and submitted not by you, but by your
24 attorney, Mr. Todd, on your behalf. Have you reviewed his
25 response to --
Page 7
A Yes.
Q -- you?
A Yes, I have.
Q And will you now under oath subscribe to that
5 response as if you had submitted to it yourself?
6 A So, Mr. Todd spoke to me and conveyed the
7 investigation that I provide him. I believe he conveyed that
8 information accurately, and the statements that he ascribes
9 to me in that letter I believe are accurate.
10 Q All right. Do you have any changes or corrections
11 to that written response?
12 A No, I do not.
13 Q Is there anything in it that you do not agree with?
14 A Again, I think that the statements that he ascribes
15 to me are accurate, and I agree with them.
16 Q All right. So, we are going to accept that
17 statement as representing accurately your -- what you would
18 have responded if you had responded to us directly. Is that
19 correct?
20 A I -- yes, the statements, he basically gives my
21 positions, and I believe that he gave my positions
22 accurately.
23 Q Perfect. Thank you. So, as we ask questions and
24 refer to documents, we would like you to correct any
25 misstatements in our questions, or any misstatements or
Page 8
1 errors that are in the documents themselves, because we want
2 to make sure the entire record --
3 A Mm-hmm.
4 Q -- is correct. Also, there's been an enormous
5 amount of publicity about the Epstein case, particularly this
6 year, including about the events and decisions made back in
7 2006 to 2010 that are the subject of our investigation. And
8 so as best you can, we ask you to try to answer today from
9 your knowledge, understanding, and recollections as of that
10 period of time. However, to the extent you are asked or do
11 speak retroactively, retrospectively, we'll just make it
12 clear that you're doing so.
13 A All right.
14 Q Okay?
15 A And if I could just say, one of the difficulties is
16 with everything that -- all the publicity and all the
17 documents that have made it to the press and in litigation
18 distinguishing between recollection versus after the fact
19 Q Right.
20 A -- speculation, and I will try, but I would
21 appreciate reminders along the way, because it's, it's an
22 important distinction, but it's kind of hard sometimes.
23 Q we recognize particularly the importance of it.
24 A Right.
25 Q That's -- that's precisely the heart of --
Page 9
1 A Yeah.
2 Q -- our matter. So, Mr. Acosta, your professional
3 background is a matter of public record. I have a couple of
4 questions. By what state bar are you currently licensed?
5 A So, I am inactive in I believe inactive in
6 Pennsylvania and also in D.C.
Q All right, and not in Florida?
A Not in Florida.
Q So, are -- is it -- do I understand that you are
10 not currently an active member of any bar?
11 A I would have to confirm with D.C. I said not
12 inactive in Pennsylvania and in D.C. because I am not certain
13 whether I'm currently active or inactive in D.C. I am not
14 currently practicing, and so I would have renewed under
15 either active or inactive.
16 Q All right.
17 A And we can --
18 Q we --
19 A We can --
20 Q We --
21 A We can verify that and get that.
22 Q We would appreciate it if Mr. Todd could let us
23 know your current status. I also would like to know the
24 status -- your bar status in the period of 2006 through 2008.
25 Do you know what that was?
Page 10
1 A Most likely -- I can -- I can speculate. I don't
2 know as a fact. Mostly likely active in D.C.
3 Q Mm-hmm.
4 A And inactive in Pennsylvania.
5 Q Okay, but likely active somewhere, correct?
6 A Yes. Yes, I think that's a requirement.
7 Q Yes, that is a --
8 A And so --
9 Q -- requirement.
10 A So, it would be D.C., the distinction between
11 active and inactive in D.C. is more minor, as I recall, than
12 Pennsylvania where there's a large fee difference.
13 Q All right, thank you, and we look forward to
14 hearing confirmation of that from you, Mr. Todd. So, after
15 serving nearly two years as the assistant attorney general in
16 charge of the department's civil rights division, you were
17 presidentially appointed the interim U.S. Attorney for the
18 Southern District of Florida in June of 2005, and then as we
19 understand it, you were formally nominated as U.S. Attorney
20 in June of 2006, and after being confirmed by the United
21 States Senate, you were sworn in by the U.S. Attorney -- as
22 U.S. Attorney in late October 2006.
23 A I think that may be inaccurate. I would have to
24 confirm. When you say presidentially appointed, I believe it
25 may have been appointed by the chief judge at the request of
Page 11
1 the Attorney General. The chief judge has appointing
2 authority.
3 Q Okay.
4 A And you'd have to go back and confirm whether it
5 was either an AG designation or the chief judge --
6 Q All right.
7 A -- which is different than presidential.
8 Q And I understand, and again, I would appreciate if
9 you could --
10 A Yeah.
11 Q -- follow up on that --
12 A I -- I'm --
13 Q -- Mr. Todd.
14 A -- not certain how to confirm that. That's
15 something that in all candor the department would know --
16 Q All right.
17 A -- much better than I.
18 Q Then we will pursue it. My point is that there was
19 a change in your status from interim to -- you -- the U.S.
20 Attorney with the -- with the full --
21 A Correct.
22 Q -- confirmation. How if at all did that change in
23 status affect your view of and your exercise of your
24 authority as U.S. Attorney?
25 A So, it's difficult to recall. You're now asking
Page 12
1 that just ten years back, but even further back. I was
2 interim for a sufficiently long period of time that -- that
3 by the time the change in status took place, I would
4 speculate that I was, in my mind, the, you know, acting as
5 U.S. Attorney whether you have an adjunctive interim, or
6 acting in front of your name or not.
7 You know, I -- I had great people. I don't recall
8 when -- when came on board as first assistant, but he
9 was my crim chief, and I thought for the continuity of the
10 office it was important to promote him to first assistant,
11 and --
Q He was promoted actually effective October of 2006.
3 You made a series -- according to e-mails -- the
14 announcement -- the personnel announcement was made to be
15 effective in October 2006 naming
16 chief, and as first --
17 A Right.
18 Q -- assistant.
19 A Right, and they -- they were both long serving
20 professionals within the office, and basically, as my
21 recollection, everyone just moved up one wrung.
22 Q Okay.
as criminal
23 A You would know better than I, because you have
24 those records. And so, sitting here today, I don't recall
25 any specific way in which that shift would have impacted --
Page 13
1 Q All right.
2 A -- my thinking.
3 Q You had not served as a -- as a prosecutor before,
4 and had -- didn't have direct criminal experience is my
5 understanding.
6 A The -- that is correct. I had supervised -- civil
7 rights, for example, had supervised criminal prosecutions,
8 but I had not been a line prosecutor previously.
9 Q So, as the U.S. Attorney supervising a couple of
10 hundred --
11 A Right.
12 Q -- line prosecutors, most involved in criminal
13 work, how -- what -- what -- what interested you most, or
14 appealed to you most as you undertook your -- and carried out
15 your duties as U.S. Attorney?
16 A What interested me and appealed to me. So, the
17 work of the office, I mean, the -- it's a broad question, but
18 the work of --
19 Q )t-hmm.
20 A -- that office and any U.S. Attorney's Office I
21 think is incredibly impactful to any local community, and I
22 very much enjoyed being a part of the effort to bring folks
23 to justice, to move policy initiatives. You know, I recall
24 early on, we identified healthcare fraud
25 Q Ha-hmm.
Page 14
1 A -- as one big -- one big area, and we had one of
2 the largest out of our -- the largest healthcare fraud
3 initiative. You know, we focused quite a bit on gun
4 violence, and we did a great job on that, and it's one of
5 those jobs where people feel very good about what they do,
6 and it's great to be part of it. I'm sure what --
7 Q No, that's --
8 A -- okay.
9 Q That's helpful. It just gives us a
10 A Yeah.
11 Q -- some perspective.
12 A Yeah.
13 Q Was there any aspect of it that you particularly
14 disliked?
15 A To the extent you're dealing with personnel issues,
16 I think personnel issues are -- are rarely the preferred part
17 of any executive function.
18 Q You mean the conflicts among attorneys, things like
19 that, or performance issues?
20 A Performance issues.
21 Q All right.
22 A And you know, when you've got -- in any large
23 office, you get personnel issues, disciplinary issues, and
24 those are never --
25 Q Mm-hmm.
Page 15
1 A -- those are never fun.
2 Q MM-hmm. So, we talked about the personnel -- high
3 level personnel changes you made sort of after your first
4 year there. I= had, we understand, been functioning
5 de facto as a first assistant while IS was not.
6 He -- we understand had been first assistant, but
7 he stepped away, and ME NM came in to essentially take
8 over his brief until he was formerly appointed first
9 assistant. Is that consistent with your memory?
10 A So, you might have characterized that more strongly
11 that I would have.
12 Q Okay.
13 A Again, it's difficult to recreate from back then,
14 but there was certainly a transition period from Mr.
15 to Mr. , and if I could, because when you
16 said high level changes, my intent -- it was a great office.
17 Great professionals. My intent in elevating Mr. was
18 just you go from criminal chief to first assistant, and I
19 don't recall Mr. prior position, but I know that he
20 was also elevated. I think he might have been major crimes,
21 but --
22 Q That's correct.
23 A -- I'd be -- I'd be speculating.
24 Q We can --
25 A I could guess it.
a e 1
1 Q We can verify that.
2 A Okay.
3 Q Yes. What was your assessment of His
4 capabilities, his judgement, and his working relationship
5 with you on a day to day basis?
6 A Outstanding. He had been in the office for
7 decades. He was respected by everyone. He had a good tone
8 to him. He was someone, you know, I wanted individuals
9 around me that were respected within the office and that were
10 trusted and that had been there for a long time, and then I
11 think I was very lucky to -- to have that in my management
12 team.
13 Q As we understand it, your office as U.S. Attorney
14 was sort of on one side of the reception area, and the first
5 assistant's office is on the other side. Is that correct?
_E A Thi,t Ls _erred.
17 Q Or, at the time --
18 A Correm
19 Q -- that was correct. So, did you and
20 have a sort of easy back and forth --
21 A Walking --
22 Q -- open door?
23 A -- into each other's offices multiple times a
24 day --
4 All right.
Page 17
A -- kind of relationship.
Q All right, and given that he had had experience
3 throughout his career at the department in the criminal arena
4 and you had not, to what extent would you rely on him, among
5 others, for guidance, perspective, information, and so on?
6 A I named him first assistant because I valued his
7 guidance and his perspectives and I thought those were
8 valuable.
9 Q Okay. You also, as we pointed out, appointed
10 to succeed as criminal chief effective
11 October of 2006, and he served for about ten months before he
12 left for private practice. He left at the beginning of
13 August --
14 A Mm-hmm.
15 Q -- 2007. What -- you -- you did -- you said you
16 didn't recall, as we sit here today, what section he'd come
17 from.
18 A Right. I guessed it was major crimes.
19 Q All right. Were you -- what was your assessment of
21 A Outstanding as well, and if I could say, when I say
22 I don't recall but I guess, when you're going back 12 years,
23 sometimes you get an impression but you can't say it's a
24 recollection, and that's going to come up multiple times
25 today, just because it's a while ago.
Page 18
1 Q As long as we make that distinction --
2 A Right.
3 Q -- both are helpful.
4 A Right, and so -- so, whether it's a recollection or
5 a construction after the fact, I can't can't say, but
6 you know, I -- I thought that one of the helpful factors with
7 is he had spent a lot of time -- and major crimes is the
8 most active -- active unit. I assume you all know the
9 structures of the office --
10 Q Mm-hmm.
11 A -- but major crimes is not major crimes, it's sort
12 of the entry level crimes, and I valued the fact that he had
13 trained and, you know, so many AUSAs, and really spent a lot
14 of time reviewing -- the major crimes chief as opposed to the
15 other chiefs spends a lot of time reviewing the work of
16 AUSAs, and so, he would be someone who is very experienced
17 and able to get in the weeds.
18 Q And he in fact was around -- during that time
19 period, had gone back in the courtroom, if you recall, to
20 actually try a major case. Do you recall that? /t was a --
21 A I didn't until you --
22 Q -- major fraud case.
23 A -- mentioned -- I didn't until you mentioned it,
24 and now there's something in the back of my head that's
25 saying that sounds right, but I can't give you more detail.
Page 19
1 Q All right. What was your assessment of
2 sort of working style, and particularly working
3 with you?
4 A You know, again, positive. You know, we didn't --
5 I didn't see him as often as Mr. , but --
Q He -- was he located on the same floor?
A He was located on the same floor, but not within
8 the same suite.
9 Q MM-hmm.
10 A And -- and that -- that affects interaction, but a
11 positive working relationship.
12 Q All right, and how how -- to what extent would
13 you, as criminal chief, was he relied on by you as
14 distinguished from with regard to the criminal
15 matters pending?
16 A Also relied on. Depend -- that would depend almost
17 on the matter for --
18 Q Okay.
19 A -- as in a typical situation, he would bring things
20 to who would them bring them to me along, and so he
21 would bring things to , and then depending on their
22 discussion, they might both walk into my office. But he
23 would typically run things through before coming to me.
24 Q Were there occasions when he would come to you
25 directly?
Page 20
A Sure. That's why I said in a typical --
Q Okay.
A It's difficult to sort of recreate the
4 interactions, but he certainly could come to me directly, and
5 in some cases, I would say probably would.
6 Q Again, it being a large office with several
7 physical locations, and we understand it, a very high
8 volume --
9 A Mm-hmm.
10 Q -- of cases --
11 A Right.
12 Q -- and particularly in the criminal context, is it
13 fair to say you didn't review every prosecution as it was
14 brought?
15 A It -- it is not just fair, but accurate. I recall
16 a conversation with a U.S. Attorney from a small district
17 early on at one U.S. Attorney's conference where we compared
18 notes, and the interaction of an office with 30 prosecutors
19 is very different than one with --
20 Q Hm-hmm.
21 A -- a few hundred prosecutors.
22 Q So, when you did engage on a -- on a criminal case,
23 would you -- whether it was a planned prosecution or a case
24 heading to trial, would you generally rely on written
25 submissions, or would you -- this is really an --
Page 21
1 A Mm-hmm.
2 Q -- inquiry into --
3 A Right.
4 Q -- your style, or would you have everybody
S together, and talk about it, or would you rely on your most
6 immediate subordinates to be briefing you? How -- which one
7 of those --
A So --
9 Q -- kinds of --
10 A So --
11 Q -- approaches --
12 A So --
13 Q -- did you take?
14 A I would say that really depended, and probably
15 varied based on -- on individual needs. For the most part, I
16 would most likely just speak with my first assistant and/or
17 criminal chief, and assess what else needed to be done.
18 Q In other words, you would sort of do it on a --
19 sort of on a verbal, or based on oral --
20 A Correct.
21 Q -- interaction and --
22 A Correct.
23 Q -- presentation as opposed to going through stacks
24 of papers?
25 A For -- for the -- I would say that was typical.
Page 22
1 Q Yeah.
2 A I don't want to say that was the case every single
3 time, but that was -- was typical.
4 Q All right, and to what extent did you go out and
5 about to encounter the line attorneys, or example? Was that
6 something that you were able to do and wanted to do?
7 A Yes, and yes, and you know, I -- when I started, I
8 made it a point of walking every floor and meeting everyone,
9 and in -- toward the end of the day, I would also if I could
10 make it a point -- particularly of major crimes of just
11 walking down to the floor and seeing who was there and what
12 they were doing and -- and sort of popping my head in and
13 just saying hi because I think it's the right thing to do.
14 Q Okay. Okay. Was that a way to support the troops,
15 or was it more a way for you to find -- to become informed
16 about what was going on?
17 A Probably a little of both, of support the troops,
18 but also get the temperature for the office, see how matters
19 are progressing.
20 Q You at the criminal -- or, rather, the civil rights
21 division, had experience with human trafficking and child sex
22 trafficking cases --
23 A Correct.
24 Q -- under your supervision. We understand that you
25 brought that concern, or your concern about those issues with
Page 23
1 you to the U.S. Attorney's Office, and that -- we know that
2 under your tenure, the U.S. Attorney's Office had many
3 successful prosecutions involving conduct ranging from
4 internet child pornography --
5 A Mm-hmm.
6 Q -- to international sex tourism --
7 A Correct.
8 Q -- victimizing children in particular. In mid-
9 2007, you -- according to press reports, you set up a new
10 special prosecutions unit --
11 A Correct.
12 Q -- to focus on, among other things, sex crimes
13 against children. Could you tell us what importance those
14 kinds of cases held for you as U.S. Attorney?
15 A Sure. If I could -- if I could just back up a
16 little bit, because the -- the question goes -- the special
17 prosecutions unit, and let me address that part of it. There
18 are a few things embedded in that.
19 Q MM-hmm.
20 A There's -- there's -- the special prosecutions unit
21 was set up because there were some issues that -- that I
22 thought were important to pursue in particular, and one of
23 those was -- was sort of the trafficking issues. Another one
24 was the gun violence, and the intent of special prosecutions
25 was to have a group of individuals that would sort of be
Page 24
1 dedicated and not part of the usual major crimes group. So,
2 it wasn't exclusively -- I -- your question may have implied
3 it was exclusively for sex crimes, and it --
4 Q Oh, no.
5 A -- and it wasn't -- yeah.
6 Q No, I understand it was not.
7 A Right.
8 Q Okay.
9 A And so, I thought it was sufficiently important,
10 and so, it was one of the -- one of the initiatives that we
11 were certainly pursuing.
12 Q And was that something that you can -- that -- to
13 which you brought your experience as head of the civil rights
14 division as well?
15 A It was. I think -- not I think I know when I was
16 head of civil rights that that's something that I'd put
17 particular emphasis on, and I thought civil rights really
18 stepped up and did a great job on that.
19 Q Did you yourself ever -- I recognize you were never
20 a prosecutor as such.
21 A Right.
22 Q But did you ever have experience being involved in
23 a prosecution that -- sort of the nitty-gritty of the
24 prosecution of that kind of case? Sort of seconding yourself
25 to a trial team, for example, or an investigation?
Page 25
1 A So, if by nitty-gritty you mean seconding myself to
2 a trial team the answer would be no.
3 Q All right.
4 A There are a number of cases that I recall being
5 briefed on and talking about, but --
7 A
9 program,
10 A
12 appointed
13 A Correct.
14 Q -- coordinator, and she was also of course the line
15 attorney on the Epstein case. How well did you know
16 , and can you -- can you give us your assessment of
17 her capabilities, judgement, and her interaction with you?
18 A So, a few things in there. How well did I know her
19 prior to appointment? I don't recall. I'm not -- I don't
20 think I knew her particularly well prior to appointment. She
21 was clearly respected within the office, and / don't recall
22 but I can speculate that she was appointed based on
23 recommendations of management, and her interest and some
24 combination -- and prior work and some combination thereof.
25 You asked me to characterize --
But at that high level?
Correct.
All right. The department set up in 2006 a PSC
a Project Safe Childhood program --
Correct.
-- focused on internet child pornography, and you
as your first PSC --
Page 26
1 Q Her -- your view of
2 A Right.
3 Q -- her capabilities, her judgement
4 A Right.
5 Q her acumen, her knowledge of the law.
6 A I think she was a good, strong, professional AUSA.
7 I mean --
8 Q Do you have any -- did you have any negative -- you
9 know, anything less than fully positive in your assessment of
10 her?
11 A No.
12 Q Okay.
13 A I think she was a good, strong, dedicated AUSA.
14 Q All right.
15 A Yeah.
16 Q -- was the managing AUSA at the West Palm Beach
17 office.
18 A Correct.
19 Q At least -- and would -- and worked
20 there. How closely did you work with and again,
21 that --
22 A 24m-hmm.
23 02 -- assessment question --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- what was your assessment of him?
Page 27
1 A So, less so, only because of geographic distance.
2 Q Mt-hmm.
3 A I would also say he was a respected professional.
4 He had a good reputation. He went on to be chief of staff
5 here at the -- at the criminal division, which I think speaks
6 to how he was viewed within the department.
7 Q min-hmm.
8 A And so, I would say positive.
9 Q Okay. So, now turning to the Epstein case.
10 A Yeah.
11 Q Now that your recall has been refreshed by virtue
12 of the documents we've provided, before we get into the
13 actual sort of documents and some of the details of the
14 events, would you please give us a general overview of what
15 you currently remember, refreshed, about how the case came
16 into the U.S. Attorney's Office, how it was assessed for
17 prosecution, and how and why the decision was made to resolve
18 it with a two-year state plea that ultimately became an 18 --
19 A Okay.
20 Q -- I mean, yeah, a two year state plea that
21 ultimate became --
22 A All right.
23 Q -- an 18 month state plea.
24 A Okay, so --
25 MR. HERRON: Before you answer the question, let me
Page 28
1 just jump in on the notion of refresh your recollection,
2 which is -- of course has a very specific legal meaning, and
3 I think to assert that Mr. Acosta's recollection has been
4 refreshed generally probably overstates it. It's really a
5 document by document, issue by issue thing. So, I'd push
6 back on that --
7 MS. : I --
8 MR. HERRON: -- a little bit, but the question is
9 fair and accurate.
10 MS. : If you're talking about handing him
11 a document to refresh an exhausted recollection, that's not
12 the process we're talking about. We're using it in a more
13 lay term that, you know, if we asked you this before, giving
14 you all these documents, you'd probably would have not been
15 able to be as full in your responses. So, we're asking for
16 your full response. Thank you.
17 MR. HERRON: We appreciate the opportunity to
18 review the documents, and Alex, in your answers, try to
19 distinguish what you actually recall --
20 THE WITNESS: Yeah.
21 MR. HERRON: -- in your own head versus what you
22 saw in the documents.
23 MS. : Yeah.
24 MR. HERRON: And that would make for --
25 MS. . Thank you.
Page 29
MR. HERRON: -- the cleanest record.
2 THE WITNESS: Okay. So, three parts. How did it
3 come into the office? How did -- I'm sorry --
4 BY MS.
5 Q How was -- how did it come in?
6 A Right.
Q How was it assessed for prosecution --
8 A Right.
Q -- and then how and -- how and why the decision was
made --
A
• -- to resolve it the way it was.
13 A So, so, let's begin with how did it come into the
14 office. Putting all the documents aside, I can't say with
5 certainty how it came in. I can speculate how it came in,
16 and the way it would have come into the office is can
17 speculate that the chief -- the chief rider from Palm Beach
18 County would have brought it to either the FBI or to the Palm
19 Beach Office. I'm not certain that I would have asked who
20 brought this case to the office as opposed to the case is now
21 in the office, so let's --
22 Q Right.
23 A -- let's discuss it, right? The format, or the
24 mode in which it came in I think is important, because my
25 recollection is it arrived to us in the position that the
Page 30
1 state attorney had negotiated a plea, and that the reason
2 that we looked at it was that that plea was going to be --
3 that there had been an initial charge that wasn't pursued,
4 and that required jail time and registration, and that the
S plea that was going to be taken was a charge that didn't
6 require jail time, and didn't require registration, and based
7 on the preliminary assessment of the facts, that seemed --
8 that seems wrong. So, that's how did it arrive. The next
9 question was --
10 Q How was it assessed for federal prosecution?
11 A So -- so, it was assessed for federal prosecution,
12 my recollection, from -- from very early on, and I'm sure
13 we'll talk about this some more, is you have a case that,
14 while technically it wasn't final at the state level, but for
15 federal involvement, would have been final, and -- and so
16 from the earliest point, we were thinking federal versus
17 state and petite, and the contemporaneous record sort of
18 shows at least the material that I got, the earliest
19 communication was Mr. telling me that is
20 preparing a petite policy waiver -- that Ms. is
21 preparing a petite policy waiver, and that's consistent with
22 my recollection of how it was assessed, and -- and then
23 brought in -- assessed, you know, does it make sense to go
24 forward, yes, investigate, and circle back. And then -- and
25 then the third part was the --
Page 31
Q How and why the disposition.
A So, my general recollection is the view was that if
3 the state had followed through on an original charge -- I
4 don't recall which -- that called for jail time and that
5 called for registration, that the local police or whoever
6 brought it would not have seen the need to refer it.
7 And so, that was in terms of pre-indictment
8 resolution, a -- a logical and reasonable place given all the
9 other sort of factors, both the petite concerns, the witness
10 concerns, and the legal concerns.
11 And to that, I would add a fourth concern, which is
12 it had already been reviewed by a grand jury at the state
13 level, is my recollection. And so, to some extent, that's
14 indicative of how some individuals may sort of view this
15 matter.
16 Q Okay. We're going to pick that apart.
17 A I figured.
18 Q But thank you for that.
19 A You -- you asked for an overview, so I tried to
20 just be very --
21 Q Yeah.
22 A -- general.
23 Q That doesn't -- that doesn't -- the second part of
24 that last prong was -- was why a two year state plea. In
25 other words, you talked about -- you talked about assessing
PaGe
the case and why resolve it, but why with a two year state
2 plea? What's the --
A And so --
4 -- overview?
A And so my general recollection is -- my
6 understanding -- if I was asked, what is the best
7 understanding that I have of why two years, is that is what
8 would have been obtained in one of the original state
9 charges. Again, this is --
10 Q How do you know that?
A
12 Q How did you know that?
13 A I'm -- that's why I say general recollection. I'm
14 reconstructing memories of that 12 years ago. I can
15 speculate that at some point, the matter came up, and I or
16 someone else said if, you know, what would the original --
17 what would the original plea have -- you know, what would the
18 original charges have likely brought? And someone said this
19 amount.
20 Q How would have said that?
21 A I -- I'm speculating at this point. I don't have a
22 recollection, but -- but that's -- that's my general
23 understanding.
24 Q All right. All right. We'll now unpack --
25 A Yeah, I --
Page 33
Q -- some of that.
A -- I noticed.
Q And by the way, my colleagues, we're all in this
4 boat together. So, they're going to feel free to --
A I know.
Q -- chime in --
A Yeah.
Q as they see fit. So, the first thing going --
9 going to the intake of the case, we know from the records
10 that -- and by the way, we've obviously done a great deal of
11 other investigation --
12 A Right.
13 Q -- and spoken to many people. So,
14 briefed you and pretty much when the case first
15 came in --
16 A Mm-hmm.
17 Q -- in mid-2006, after the FBI and indeed the
18 office -- the U.S. Attorney's Office in West Palm had opened
19 the case, but before Epstein was indicted. So, this first
20 exhibit, Exhibit No. 1 that you have in your binder before
21 you -- or, in your folder before you -- is that e-mail from
22 to you that you just referred to dated July 24 --
23 A Right.
24 Q -- 2006, in which he's sort of passing on the
25 information that Epstein has by now been arrested -- been
Page 34
1 indicted -- arrested and indicted by the state. Do you
2 recall anything about that original briefing from
4 A I -- I don't.
5 Q All right. Did you know at the time that -- at the
6 time she briefed you --
7 A Mm-hmm.
8 Q -- which is prior to Exhibit 1, did you know who
9 Epstein was?
10 A I did not.
11 Q Never heard of him, to your knowledge?
12 A To my knowledge, I don't recall having heard of
13 him.
14 Q And what did you understand at that early point the
15 case to be about?
16 A So, I don't recall the briefing, and so I can't
17 give an independent recollection. You know, based on this, I
18 mean, the --
19 Q You're talking about Exhibit 1, and you're --
20 A Based on --
21 Q -- looking at --
22 A -- based on Exhibit 1, you know, I can -- I can
23 infer that this would have been my general understanding of
24 the case, and you know, and the key things that I point here
25 is pre-trial diversion, which is code for no jail time, and
Page 35
1 petite policy.
2 Q But this -- what -- Exhibit No. 1 --
3 A Right.
4 Q -- does not make it clear to you that this case
5 involved allegations that Jeffrey Epstein had been enticing,
6 coercing, whatever verb you want to use, young, underage
7 females -- we will for the record call them girls here --
8 A Mm-hmm.
9 Q -- as opposed to women, and these underage females
10 were being paid to provide him essentially with sex, or
11 sexual activity or conduct, of a pretty salacious nature. Do
12 you recall that as being essentially what you were briefed on
13 from the beginning?
14 A Again, I don't recall the initial briefing. I take
15 it based on your review that there was an initial briefing.
16 I can't say the degree of detail. I can't say what it was
17 about. As a -- as a typical matter, I wouldn't be briefed
18 when a case comes into the office other than being made
19 aware, this is a case, this is what we're looking at.
20 Q So, then, if you --
21 A Sure.
22 Q -- understanding you don't remember the briefing,
23 is it fair to say that you did have some understanding of
24 what the case that was that West Palm Beach was pursuing as
25 of mid-2006?
Page 36
1 A I certainly had an understanding of the general
2 facts of the case early on. I can't speak to whether it was
3 mid-2006 versus late 2006 versus 2007, but --
4 Q Mm-hmm.
5 A -- early on, I certainly had an understanding that
6 it was a case that involved, you know, a billionaire who was
7 doing sordid things with young women or girls who were
8 minors.
9 and the records indicate that her
10 concern in bringing this all the way to you --
A Km-hmm.
Q -- and her first at that time criminal chief --
A Right.
Q -- but sort of acting First Assistant
was because she was afraid of political pressure that
might be brought to bear against the U.S. Attorney's Office
17 in this case. Do you have any recollection of that being a
18 concern that was laid before you?
19 A I don't -- again, I don't recall the early -- that
20 briefing. I've reviewed this e-mail, and -- and I can -- you
21 know, I take it it would have been natural for me to say,
22 should we approach the state attorney, because we had lots of
23 ongoing matters with the state attorney, and it seems that
24 said no for fear it'll be leaked straight to Epstein,
25 and I assumed I'd let it be at that point.
Page 37
1 Q And do you know -- oh, do you know what he meant by
2 it being leaked to Epstein by the state -- by Barry -- Barry
3 Krischer, the then State Attorney?
4 A So -- so, based on the context --
5 Q Mm-hmm.
6 A -- what I would assume is that if the state
7 attorney is cutting this kind of deal, and it appears that
8 things have already leaked, because you know, there's clearly
9 and article here with leaked -- you know, so, something has
10 already leaked.
11 Q You're referring to Exhibit 1?
12 A Exhibit 1. Other things would leak.
13 Q Had you ever met Barry Krischer?
14 A Sure.
15 Q What was your relationship with him?
16 A So, there were multiple state attorneys within the
17 district. He was -- it was a professional relationship. We,
18 you know --
19 Q It was an elected position, correct?
20 A It was an elected position.
21 Q And what was your assessment of his aggressiveness
22 as a prosecutor, and his capabilities?
23 A On the public -- my -- most of my assessment with
24 him was on the public corruption front, where we had brought
25 several cases, and I was a little disappointed that these
Page 38
1 were cases he could have brought that he chose not to bring.
2 Q Right. So, is it -- can I -- am I accurate in
3 inferring from that that you didn't regard him as a
4 particularly hard charging prosecutor?
5 A So, I -- with any state attorney, I hesitate to
6 sort of paint broad brush strokes. I don't think that's
7 always fair, but my experience had been in the public
8 corruption space.
9 Q Yeah.
10 A And in that space, I did not think -- whether it
11 was him, or whether it was his office, I can't speak, but I
12 did not think they had done as much as they could have done.
13 Q Is there any area in which you thought he and his
14 office did pursue aggressively?
15 A So, as I recall, we had had -- we had emphasized
16 gun crimes quite a bit, and really had had a lot of success
17 moving -- moving the ball in the gun crimes space in Palm
18 Beach.
19 Q What --
20 A But let me -- let me just say, it's also very
21 difficult to reconstruct time frames.
22 Q MM-hmm.
23 A And so, I hesitate, because I don't know if that
24 was 2006 or 2007, or -- but you asked in another area, and --
25 Q In this Exhibit 1, you ask whether it's
Page 39
1 appropriate -- appropriate to approach Barry Krischer and
2 give him a heads up as to where the U.S. Attorney's Office
3 might go, presumably --
4 A Right.
5 Q -- with this case?
6 A Correct.
7 Q Why would you want to extend that difference to
8 him? Why would it matter?
9 A A colleague in law enforcement. I thought it was
10 important for the office to work with -- with state attorneys
11 as a general matter, and I found that the office worked best
12 when it had good working relationships with state attorneys
13 and with -- you know, with -- for that matter, the agency
14 SACs and others, and --
15 Q Right.
16 A -- but again, you know, rather than my asserting,
17 I'm asking , and was saying no, and I don't know
18 what the ultimate outcome was, but I would guess that we'd
19 just defer and let it be.
20 Q Turning to Exhibit 2, this is an e-mail that was
21 forwarded to you by
22 mail is from
, the original forwarded e-
copying , and it
23 essentially relates to a dust up between and
24 over chain of command, and her workload, but
25 in the first paragraph, she specifies that, "When I first
Page 40
1 heard about the Epstein investigation, I spoke with
2 about it. was not here."
3 said that she would back me up on the case,
4 but I knew what has happened to the state prosecution can
5 happen to the federal prosecution if the U.S. Attorney's
6 Office isn't on board. So, I spoke with about the case,
7 and he spoke with Alex, and they gave the green light."
8 So, that -- that actually appears to be an initial
9 contact with that she's talking about prior to the
10 briefing of you, so, way early when the case first came in in
11 May of 2006. Do you recall being contacted or having a
12 conversation with --
13 A Mm-hmm.
14 - - about that case so early?
15 A Again, the early recollection, whenever -- whenever
16 it might have taken place, was I was made aware of the
17 matter. It seemed a reasonable matter to pursue, and that's
18 the level of detail that I recall.
19 Q So, if said back in the day that she got from
20 you all the green light, what did you understand her to be
21 being authorized to do -- authorize may be too strong a word,
22 but --
23 A So, to pursue -- to investigate -- to pursue --
24 Q Yeah.
25 A -- to someone, you know, I -- I'm speculating here,
Page 41
1 but there's a case, and they want to know, should we spend
2 our time on this? And the answer is it seems reasonable.
3 Sure.
4 Q Okay, and do you -- do you recall making that
5 explicit to her?
6 A I -- I don't, and -- and it wouldn't have been my
7 practice to -- to sort of make it explicit to -- yeah, go
8 spend your time, as opposed to, thank you for letting me
9 know, that sounds reasonable.
10 Q All right.
11 A And whatever, you know, details it looks like based
12 on Exhibit 1, there was subsequent follow up between her and
13 , or with her and the management team, and they said, you
14 know, go back, work on A, B, and C.
15 Q Do you know what was talking about
16 when she referred to something happening to a federal
17 prosecution if the U.S. Attorney is not on board? Had there
18 been a case in which you were not supportive of a particular
19 prosecution that was being proposed?
20 A None -- none that I recall, and -- and I knew that
21 what has happened to the state prosecution can happen to a
22 federal prosecution if the U.S. Attorney's not on board. I
23 don't recall any federal prosecution that I wasn't supportive
24 of, at least in -- in this context.
25 Q What do you mean by this context?
,1 1•111•1
Page 42
1 A It was my way of narrowing an answer so I didn't
2 spend the time to go through every office and every division.
3 For the most part, as I sit here, I'm sort of running through
4 each office. I don't recall any, and -- and if I could,
5 based on this -- on Exhibit 2, I'm not sure that she's
6 referring to a specific case as opposed to concerns that the
7 state prosecution started at point -- you know, with charges
8 that required jail time and ended up somewhere else, and it
9 may have been because management --
Q All right.
A -- wasn't.
Q But that's -- that's a current -- a reading of --
A Yeah.
Q -- this, rather --
A That -- that's my --
Q -- than a recollection?
A -- that's my reading, not --
Q All right. Based on the early description you got
19 of the case --
20 A Right.
21 Q -- did you have any idea how many victims were
22 involved?
23 A I did not.
24 Q Did you know what the name of the case was? What
25 the investigation's name was? You know, cases get names.
Page 43
1 A So, I know that based on review of the
2 correspondence, I may have known that then. I did not
3 independently recall that.
Q That being Operation Leap Year?
A Correct.
Q All right, and do you know where that comes from?
A I have -- well, I mean, other than February 20 --
8 yeah, I don't know.
9 Q Well, the original allegations that came in
10 involved 28 victims, and then subsequently
11 she was uncovering more victims, so there were --
12 A Yeah.
advised that
13 Q -- over 30 victims.
14 A
15 Q Well over 30.
16 A I did not know that.
17 Q All right. You did not -- you -- as you sit here
18 today, you didn't know it?
19 A I don't recall knowing that.
20 Q But is it -- is it reasonable that the number of
21 victims would be one of the factors that you would have been
22 informed of at the time?
23 A I -- I don't know. I -- it all depends how
24 detailed that briefing was. Again, as a typical matter early
25 on, this is what is being done. I would trust my AUSAs and
Page 44
1 my management staff --
2 Q Right.
3 A -- to pursue it. It wouldn't be a, here are all
4 the facts associated with this case, just heads up. There is
5 a high profile case involving a very wealthy man abusing
6 young women, a state attorney is prosecuting, but you know,
7 there's dissatisfaction. I wanted to give you a heads up,
8 both to inform me, but also so that I'm aware in my
9 interactions with -- with other Palm Beach officials.
10 Q Okay. Based on whatever information you got at the
11 time, did you think that there was a federal interest to be
12 served by pursuing a federal prosecution potentially?
21 glossary convention --
22 A Right.
23 Q -- that we are using is -- and we can use in this
A Yes.
Q And what was that?
A So, the exploitation of young women.
Q Girls.
A Girls.
Q I want to be -- I want to be --
A Minors. Minor females.
Q All right. I -- you know, for a -- for a sort of a
24 interview, is girls --
25 A Right.
Page 45
1 Q -- for the victims who at the time of the conduct
2 were minors, and women, for those who were not, even though
3 the girls at a later time became age of --
4 A Fair.
5 Q -- majority.
6 A Fair.
7 Q Okay. So, here, we're really talking about the
8 girls --
9 A Okay.
10 Q -- who were victims.
11 A Yeah, yeah.
12 Q Okay.
13 A Girls, minor females. I just don't sometimes
14 that term is viewed differently. And so --
15 Q Right.
16 A Yeah, so the exploitation of girls or minor
17 females, and that certainly is an important federal interest.
18 Q Well, and is the number and the breadth of the
19 scheme -- the scope of the activity also a factor there? In
20 other words, it wasn't one or two on one or two occasions.
21 A So, there's several factors that probably go into
22 what's the federal interest. The acts, the sordidness of the
23 acts, the -- the number, the likelihood or the importance of
24 registration was important to my mind because that -- that
25 goes to future prevention to putting the community on notice.
Page 46
1 Q And were you aware that the individual in this
2 case, Epstein, also had homes in other districts, and that
3 there were -- it was an interstate activity on his part, the
4 interstate travel and so on?
5 A
6 MR. HERRON: I'm sorry, let me just -- we're still
7 in the original intake time frame --
8 MS. : Yes.
9 MR. HERRON: -- here?
10 THE WITNESS: Yeah. Again, for the intake time, I
11 can't I can't speak to the details, because I don't
12 remember what the extent of that -- that intake briefing.
13 BY MS.
14 Q But as i -- as I -- as i --
15 A Could I -- could I ask --
16 Q Yes.
17 A -- a question? Was there -- was there a clear
18 briefing as opposed to a heads up based on the record?
19 Q Yes. That came to Miami to conduct
20 a briefing of you and --
21 A Okay.
22 Q in order to tell you about this
23 case, and get from you
24 A Okay.
25 Q -- a green light --
Page 47
1 A
Q -- to proceed with it.
A I ask, because I recall an e-mail, and I don't know
4 what the time would have been, where she's coming to Miami,
5 and says, why don't you stop by my office first?
6 Q Right.
7 A And -- and -- and I keep -- I would -- I would
8 speculate that, why don't you stop by my office first is, why
9 don't you give me a bunch of details, and then we will walk
10 across to the U.S. Attorney --
11 Q Right.
12 A -- and fill him in, and so that would have been
13 almost a two-tiered discussion.
14 Q And is that --
15 A And I don't know if that -- if that -- the timeline
16 on that e-mail is when you say briefing.
17 Q Well, we are -- we are asking --
18 A
19 Q What it -- what it would --
20 A Yeah.
22 A I'm speaking just based on review of the record,
23 not based on recollection here.
24 Q All right. So, you have -- to be clear, you have
25 no recollection of any specific briefing in 2006?
Page 48
A I accept that I was made aware of the matter.
Q Okay.
A I can't say how or in what context or to what
4 degree of detail.
Q Or by whom?
A Or by whom. I knew the matter -- it's easier to
7 recollect at least for me what I knew as opposed to who told
8 me what.
9 Q All right. All right. At this point, would you
10 have had -- did you have -- if you -- at any point, did you
11 have any reservation about investigating and potentially
12 prosecuting Jeffrey Epstein, a reservation stemming from his
13 wealth, and reported standing in the community at all, and
14 influence?
15 A No, and we had prosecuted lots of influential folks
16 in the office. So, while he had wealth, it's not unusual --
17 UBS was in the office at the time. I mentioned several high
18 profile Palm Beach public corruption cases.
19 Q So, there was no concern about possible negative
20 blowback in the press or the community or even at Main
21 Justice if you went after someone like Jeffrey Epstein?
22 A There was no concern stemming from his wealth or
23 his status.
24 Q What would it have stemmed from?
25 A At some point, I think there was concerns regarding
Page 49
1 the -- the law, and we'll probably get into that. I alluded
2 to that earlier in the overview. I don't know if that would
3 have been developed this early on, but -- but that's not a
4 function of his wealth. That's a function of the fact
5 pattern.
6 Q Right. Right. Okay. So, as you mentioned petite
7 policy concerns, petite policy, petite policy, could you tell
8 us what your position was on the -- on the policy as it
9 applied in this case as you understood it from -- in the
10 beginning?
11 A So -- so, the policy, you know, on its face,
12 doesn't specifically apply. Based on Exhibit 1, I'm now
13 inferring, not recalling, it looks like either on her
14 own, or asked for a -- or, Mr. , asked for a
15 petite policy waiver memo to be prepared, in part on the
16 assumption that the state prosecution may or may not have
17 gone for it.
18 I don't know, but I know -- I do recall that early
19 on, this was unusual, because it had been -- he had been
20 arrested or arraigned. It was going forward on the part of
21 the state, and so here is the big bad federal government
22 stepping on a sovereign, you know, state, saying you're not
23 doing enough, and to my mind, when, you know, the whole idea
24 of the petite policy is to recognize that that estate has --
25 you know, is an independent entity, and that we should
Page 50
1 presume that what they're doing is correct, even if we don't
2 like the outcome, except in the most unusual of
3 circumstances.
4 Q And what kinds of -- well, so, the petite policy
5 exists because there's a recognition that there are cases
6 that are appropriately pursued. I mean, you were the head of
7 the civil rights division, after all.
8 A Correct, which is why I say except in the most
9 appropriate of circumstances.
10 Q Right.
11 A But let me add that based on this, I was
12 comfortable, you know, saying, let's go forward, because the
13 lack of jail time, you know, to use -- to use petite policy
14 language, a plea that did not include jail time or
15 registration would seem like a manifest injustice.
16 Q All right. So, did you have any doubt that you'd
17 get a waiver if you applied for one?
18 A I'm not -- so -- so, I'm now speculating. I don't
19 recall, but I'm not sure I would have said, is there a doubt
20 that I'd get a waiver as opposed to, is this something I feel
21 comfortable doing, or not? And --
22 Q And this being the prosecution, or this being
23 the -- applying for a waiver?
24 A Applying for a waiver. And so, you know, either
25 main justice gives it or doesn't give it. That doesn't mean
Page 51
1 you don't apply for it if you think it's the right thing to
2 do.
3 So, for example, in the UBS case, which was one of
4 our big tax, you know, prosecutions, we asked for a Bank of
5 Nova Scotia --
6 Q ME-hum.
7 A -- authorization to the Bank of Nova Scotia
8 subpoena, and I didn't think Main Justice would -- you know,
9 I pushed really hard, and I got into the weeds in that case
for that purpose, but I still thought, let's go for it, and
we did, and Main Justice didn't give in to it, and that's
12 okay. That's how it works.
13 Q Okay. So, they denied that request?
14 A They denied that request, and I say that as an
15 example of -- as a typical matter, I don't think what's main
16 justice going to say, as opposed to how do we how should
17 we approach this matter?
18 Q I don't understand about what you mean by, how
19 should we approach this matter.
20 A So, honestly, how do I -- how do I explain this?
21 So, I think there's a difference in saying, let me predict
22 how main justice will come out, and follow that prediction,
23 versus, folks, what do you all think? Okay. If we're
24 comfortable with this, let's write it up, and let's see what
25 Main Justice does.
Page 52
1 One is trying to predict what folks in this
2 building are going to think. Another one is trying to
3 predict -- another one is saying, what do we in Miami think,
4 and then let main justice figure it out.
Q And which is the approach you typically took?
6 A And my point is the approach that I typically took
7 is, what do we think, and let main justice give it a thumbs
8 up or a thumbs down.
9 Q All right, and in this case, did you do that with
10 regard to the petite policy?
11 A So, in this case, we didn't get that far in that we
12 didn't have to submit to DOJ.
13 Q MM-hmm.
14 A But -- but we were approaching it not based on what
15 main justice was going to think, but what do we feel is the
16 right outcome in this office.
17 Q So, as I understand, the bottom line is that you
18 didn't as I hear you, I believe you're saying that you
19 didn't stand down, or in any way cease or limit pursuing this
20 case on petite policy grounds. You pursued it as you -- as
21 you would --
22 A So, we went forward with the matter, although there
23 were petite policy concerns in the background. So -- so
24 you're setting this up as a binary -- as a -- did -- was it a
25 fact -- as a binary, you did not limit yourself on petite
Page 53
1 policy grounds, and I'm pushing back a little bit, because I
2 don't think it's, it's part or it's not, as opposed to when
3 you look at a case, there are all sorts of factors, and it is
4 a factor in how you think of a matter going forward.
BY MS.
Q If you had those petite policy concerns -- you or
members of your staff?
8 A I would say a combination of me and my management
9 staff.
BY MS.
Q Who? Who?
A I can't -- I can't recreate --
Q But who are you dealing with on this case?
A Primarily, it would be my first assistant and
15 criminal chief as I typically -- so, there is, you know, to
16 sort of put it in main justice terms, you know, a line
17 attorney has a deputy section chief and a section chief and a
18 DAG and an AAG, and the AAG usually deals with the section
19 chief, or the DAG. And so, I was dealing with my first
20 assistant and my crim chief.
21 Q Right, and they were there in Miami.
22 A And they were there in Miami.
23 Q And by the way, first line
24 supervisor was
25 A rect.
Page 54
1 Q Do you know why she was not actively participating
2 in this chain of command?
3 A I noticed that in the correspondence, and I
4 couldn't speak to that.
5 Q All right.
6 A But the -- but it goes to the point that if you
look at the -- she reported to , who reported to
8 who reported to who reported to . And so, as a
9 typical matter, I tried to empower my first assistant and my
10 criminal chief and my office heads and work through them, not
11 bypass them.
12 Q In this particular case with regard either to the
13 petite policy --
14 A Right.
15 Q -- or any other aspect, was there anyone other than
16 that group of five, if you will, in that chain --
17 A Correct.
18 Q -- from you down to through
20 A Right.
21 Q -- and that you were dealing with?
22 A I can't recall. I -- I can -- I can say as a
23 general matter, it would not be unusual for me to walk
24 down -- walk down the hall and talk to someone that I trust
25 and say, hey, I've got this fact pattern. What do you think?
Page 55
1 Q Do you recall ever doing that in connection with
2 this case?
3 A I -- I don't recall the specific briefings or who I
4 talked to. I'm just saying as a general matter that there
5 are folks on my -- on the eighth floor that were in
6 management that I would often just walk down the hall, and --
Q But do you recall doing that --
A I don't --
Q -- in this case?
A I don't recall.
Q Okay. So, we shared with you in Exhibit 3 a pretty
12 lively exchange between and
13 You didn't -- we have no reason to believe you saw this
14 before, but it makes some representations about you, and
15 that's why we brought it to your attention.
16 A Okay.
17 Q Do you recall this e-mail exchange?
18 A I don't recall the e-mail exchange.
19 Q I mean, you --
20 A But I --
21 Q -- didn't see it then. Do you recall having read
22 it before today?
23 A I recall reviewing it, yes.
24 Q All right. Okay. So, starting from the end,
25 using Blackberry, which is a little
Page 56
1 confusing to begin with -- notifies .= that -- of a -- of
2 a particular conversation he had with one of the defense
3 attorneys. At this point, what I want to do is draw your
4 attention to the -- the comment, and his response, and we're
5 looking at page --
6 A Page --
7 Q -- three.
8 A -- page three.
9 Q So, in the third paragraph --
10 A Yeah.
11 Q -- "it was made clear to you by the U.S. Attorney
12 and the first assistant from the time when you were first
13 authorized to investigate Mr. Epstein that the office had
14 concerns about taking the case because of petite policy and a
15 number of legal issues." And then later he says that, "You
16 were never given authorization by anyone to seek an
17 indictment in this case."
18 And -- close quote -- and then on the first page,
19 presents her version of that original contact
20 with you, meeting with you, at the bottom of the page.
21 Halfway through the last paragraph, she says, "My
22 recollection of the original meeting with Alex and is
23 quite different than your summary. In that meeting, I
24 summarized the case and the state attorney's office handling
25 of it."
Page 57
acknowledged that we needed to do work to
2 collect the evidence establishing a federal nexus, and I
3 noted the time and month," -- that -- I'm sorry, "I noted the
4 time and money that would be required for an investigation.
5 I said I was willing to invest time and the FBI was willing
6 to invest the money, but I didn't want to get to the end of
7 it," -- "to the end, and then have the office be intimidated
8 by the high powered lawyers. I was assured that would not
9 happen." Can you tell us which version of that initial --
10 which version --
A Right.
Q -- is correct?
A So, again, I don't remember that initial briefing,
14 so I can't tell you which version is correct. I would also
15 say that it's possible neither version is correct and that
16 there's a little bit of truth -- now I'm just speculating --
17 Q All right.
18 A that there's a little bit of truth in either
19 one, because it's certainly possible to say, I hear you,
20 righteous case, go forward and investigate, work on the
21 federal nexus, which is what Exhibit 3 is saying, go work on
22 the federal nexus and find evidence for the federal nexus.
23 But we have concerns about petite policy and legal matters,
24 so there's a lot of work to be done.
25 Q So, what kind of a direction does that amount to
Page 58
1 for the line AUSA? What's her job then?
2 A So, the job would then be to go back and
3 investigate, and develop facts and report back.
4 Q And if she developed enough facts, and supportive
5 law to present proposed prosecution?
A Right.
Q Okay.
A And so -- so, a lot of times in this he said, she
9 said, there's a little bit of truth to both sides of the
10 discussion. I'm just -- I'm just saying as a general matter,
11 I wouldn't -- your questions are sometimes either or, and
12 sometimes --
13 Q Right.
14 A -- it can be a combination of both.
15 Q All right, and -- but in fact you don't recall?
16 A But I'm speculating.
17 Q All right. Is there anything in either of those
18 that two accounts -- two versions that you say didn't happen,
19 couldn't happen?
20 A I can't, because I don't recall it. I can't --
21 Q Okay.
22 A -- speak to that. I would speculate that there's
23 probably a little bit of truth on both sides that -- and if
24 you read it closely, you'll see that acknowledges the
25 need to work on a federal nexus. So, that goes to, you know,
Page 59
1 where or, Mr. la I'm sorry, I'm calling -- I'm
2 using first names.
3 Q Its' all right.
4 A So, I'm going to just start --
4 This is an informal interview.
6 A I'm going to just start using first names. I don't
7 mean that disrespectfully -- where, you know, Illlisays, you
8 know, because of petite policy and legal issues, and is
9 acknowledging the legal issues, because she's saying needed
10 work to do to collect evidence establishing the federal
11 nexus.
12 Q All right.
13 A So --
14 Q Yeah.
15 A So, they're not as inconsistent as presented
16 Q All right.
17 A -- arguably.
18 Q Sack in 2006, in this Exhibit No. 1,
19 tells you in his e-mail that the indictment target date is
20 August 25, 2006.
21 A Mm-hmm.
22 Q In other words, very shortly --
23 A Right.
24 Q -- thereafter, within a month or so. Do you know
25 why the line AUSA, , was keen on getting the
federal case against Epstein brought on a fairly -- on a
2 quick basis?
3 A So, I can't speak to that, and -- and can I
4 I ask, based on your record, was that that the -- was that
5 the state indictment target date, or was that --
6 Q He already --
A -- a federal --
B Q -- Epstein had already been indicted and arraigned
on the --
10 A Right.
11 Q -- indictment, so that's the federal.
12 A So -- so, that's --
1: Q That's talking about a federal indictment.
14 A All right.
15 Q The point --
16 A Correct.
17 Q -- is that early on --
18 A Right.
19 Q -- the investigative team, the FBI --
20 A Right.
21 Q -- and were hot to trot to get
22 this --
23 A Right.
24 Q -- case moving from a federal standpoint. That may
25 well have been quite unrealistic given --
Page 61
1 A Correct.
2 Q -- all of the issues that we've been discussing,
3 but the question is, do you know why there was some urgency?
4 A I haven't the slightest idea. When was it -- when
5 was it initially brought to the office?
6 Q It was brought to the office in May of --
7 A Right.
8 Q -- 2006.
9 A That -- that would be a really, really fast
10 timeline.
11 Q Right. So, the question is, aspirational though it
12 may have been, there was a hope --
13 A
14 Q -- to get it done quickly.
15 A Right.
16 Q So, the question is, can you think of factors that
17 would have led a prosecutor to want to pursue --
18 A I --
19 Q -- this quickly?
20 A I don't recall. I can speculate that was
21 very hard charging and wanted to do a lot, and --
22 Q Was that your experience of her?
23 A So, based on this, I see, you know, so, Exhibit 2
24 is, you know
25 Q Excuse me, would -- but just from your memory, is
Page 62
1 that your recollection of hove operated? Hard charging?
2 A Yeah. I'd say -- so, a lot of really good
3 prosecutors are hard charging. That's --
4 Q All right.
5 A -- that's part of the job description.
6 Q Okay.
7 A And so, yes.
8 Q Okay. Did -- so, in the child sex offender
9 context, are you familiar with a -- the belief on the part of
10 people who do that kind of case, as did and
11 others in your office -- that those offenders typically don't
12 stop offending, even after somebody's onto them? So that
13 there was a concern that he -- that in this case, Jeffrey
14 Epstein might be continuing to offend, and therefore getting
15 him off the streets was --
16 A Right.
17 Q -- a priority?
18 A I have heard that discussed recently in the media.
19 I don't recollect that back in -- part of a discussion back
20 in 2006.
21 Q All right. Okay. Do you recall that
22 -- and this is just a, do you recall --
23 A Mm-hmm.
24 Q -- that she periodically would give you in that
25 early period of 2006, updates -- written updates?
Page 63
A I don't.
Q Did you think that it was appropriate for a line
3 AUSA to be shooting e-mails updating on a case that was under
4 investigation directly to you and your first assistant?
5 A It was unusual, and -- and so, so, did I think of
6 a -- look, I can't reconstruct what I would have thought, but
7 you know, you're asking not just what did I know, but what
8 would I have thought 12 years ago.
9 But I can say that based on general practice, it
10 would have been unusual, and my best guess as to how I would
11 have reacted would have been, hey, , this is unusual, is
12 the chain being fully informed? Are feathers being --
13 Q Right.
14 A ruffled? Figure it out, because, you know, you
15 asked me early on to characterize qualities. I think
16 one of the things that I said was he was very good at
17 smoothing things --
18 Q MW-hmm.
19 A -- over. And sort of the interaction, because he
20 was respected, and so I might say, that's kind of unusual.
21 Go figure it out.
22 Q But you wouldn't necessarily jump that chain
23 yourself, and be --
24 A
25 Q -- in direct communication?
Page 64
1 A I tended not to --
2 Q Okay.
3 A -- do that.
4 BY
5 Q Would she have sent this to you -- something
6 unusual, if she thought that this was a case that you wanted
7 to be involved in?
8 A Even in -- even in those, I tried to be, as a
9 general matter, fairly sensitive to the chain, because I had
10 found that if you start jumping the chain too much, even if
11 you become informed, managers feel, you know, out of -- out
12 of the loop, and that's not -- that's not conducive to sort
13 of allowing them to do their job of supervising. It's a big
14 enough office, you have to empower your folks to do their
15 jobs.
16 Q So the concern on your part would not be that she
17 was communicating directly to you, but that as long as all of
18 the chain was informed as well?
19 A Yeah. I mean, if you're -- if you're
20 or you know, if you're , or you know, don't you want to
21 talk to the line attorney before the line attorney talks to
22 your boss?
23 And so, it's not just informed, but it's respecting
24 your supervisor. And it's a difficult balance, because often
25 really good AUSAs are also the ones that, you know, just want
Page 65
1 to get things done.
2 BY MS.
3 Q Did you have any reason to believe during this
4 investigative phase that ME was not pursuing
5 this case -- this investigation adequately, appropriately,
6 and fully?
7 A No, I did not.
8 Q Did you --
9 A Not to my recollection.
10 Q Did you feel that she did not have appropriate
11 oversight?
12 A Not to my recollection.
13 Q Okay. Do you -- did you feel that she had any
14 resource problem? That is, did she have, as far as you knew,
15 sufficient resources available to pursue her investigation?
16 A To my recollection, yes, I noted her early -- you
17 know, I noted more recently the e-mail where -- you know,
18 that was shared with me by about resource concerns, and
19 I would just note that I would allow the management chain to
20 figure that out.
21 Q All right. Were you -- did you at any point
22 consider, based on what you then knew, expanding the scope of
23 the investigation? Did you ever suggest or propose that
24 instead of simply looking at Epstein's conduct in West Palm
25 Beach vis a vis these girls, that the federal authorities
Page 66
1 could use their resources to look at other aspects of
2 Epstein's activities?
3 A So, I -- so, I think it's important to take a step
4 back, and I was aware of any number of cases going on in the
office, and based on what that stage of case was at, I would
6 get more involved for a time.
7 It wasn't my practice to direct AUSAs in how they
8 should investigate, or what the scope of a case investigation
9 should be. They -- the Miami office, before I got there, and
10 after I left, had a reputation for knowing their stuff. It's
11 a large office. It's got good people. I would assume that
12 AUSAs and their management would follow their natural leads.
13 Q All right. Were you aware that during this
14 period -- and by this period, I'm talking about the
15 investigative period from the time that the case came in in
16 mid-2006 --
17 A Right.
18 Q -- up until May 1 when put forth
19 her pros memo --
20 A Right.
21 Q -- and proposed indictment. During that sort of
22 ten month period, or almost a year, were you aware that
23 defense counsel for Epstein were reaching out to
24 and to to pitch their view of how the
25 case --
Page 67
1 A Right.
2 Q -- should proceed?
3 A So, I don't have a specific recollection of who
4 reached out at what time. I would assume as a general matter
that defense counsel -- defense counsel were clearly involved
6 before the case came to the office. and so, I would assume
7 that defense counsel would remain involved while the office
8 was investigating. I say that not based on independent
9 recollection, but --
Q Right.
A -- why would they stop being involved?
Q And is it in your experience as a U.S. Attorney,
13 was it common or uncommon for defense counsel to approach the
14 line prosecutor and supervisor to make whatever pitch they
15 want with respect to a prosecution?
16 A Fairly common.
17 Q All right, and was it also common for those
18 approaches to be entertained? In other words, for the line
19 AUSA and supervisor --
20 A Right.
21 Q -- to meet with defense counsel?
22 A As a -- as a general matter, yeah.
23 Q And did you view that as appropriate?
24 A As a general matter, it was typical. It happened
25 before I got there, and is probably happening now.
Page 68
1 Q And you view it as an appropriate part of the
2 process? Do you?
3 A I think AUSAs need to have discretion to meet with
4 defense counsel, and defense counsel certainly should be able
5 to present perspectives.
6 Q There is an outlook -- this is Exhibit 4, and this
7 is something --
8  Okay.
9 Q -- it's really sort of a point of information here.
10 This is an outlook that shows you and and had
11 a scheduled meeting with Roy Black.
12 A Mm-hmm.
13 Q Roy Black, a prominent --
14 A Right.
15 Q -- local criminal defense attorney at the time in
16 the Miami area. This was a meeting scheduled in your office
17 for the 23rd of February of 2007. Do you have any -- he was
18 a -- he at the time --
19 A Right.
20 Q -- was one of Epstein's attorneys. Do you have any
21 idea whether this meeting related to Epstein or some other
22 case?
23 A I don't. I noticed that and I don't know whether
24 it was this or another matter.
25 Q But you have not particular recollection of meeting
Page 69
1 with him on the Epstein matter --
2 A I don't.
3 Q -- at this time? Okay. So, I want to --
4 A And let me note, I think most of the correspondence
5 was from other attorneys and not him. And so, yeah.
6 Q All right. Are you -- are you okay? Do you want
7 to take a short break, or --
19 broken at 11:00. Mr. Acosta, we're going to move to that
20 time frame I mentioned a moment ago, May of 2007 when
21 submitted her prosecution memo of more than 80
22 pages, and her proposed indictment -- her initial proposed
23 indictment, which was more than 50 pages.
24 She submitted that by transmittal memo to her
25 entire chain,
A Yeah.
Q Do you --
A Let's -- what time is it? Oh, 11:00.
Q Five minutes?
A Yeah.
Q Five minutes?
A Yeah. Let's take a five minute break.
Q Off the record.
(Off the record.)
BY MS.
Q All right, back on the record at 11:12, having
Page 70
1 , and you. Was that a typical way for an indictment
2 and proposed prosecution? The memo to come?
3 A To my recollection, it was not, and I don't recall
4 that happening in other cases. I'm trying -- I'm hesitating,
5 just because I'm trying to think through if there's -- I
6 don't have any recollection of it happening in another case.
7 Q Why do you think it happened in this case? And who
8 caused it to happen?
9 A I don't know, and I don't know.
10 Q All right. All right. So, you when you
11 before you saw it -- I don't know if you even knew about
12 it -- you -- by reference to Exhibit 6, you learned
13 essentially from that the FBI was planning to do
14 a press conference two weeks after that, and told
15 this office has not approved the indictment,
16 therefore, "please do not commit us to anything at this
17 time." Were you -- and eventually that e-mail chain --
18 A Right.
19 Q -- gets to you, apparently by blind carbon, because
20 there's no indication you actually get it.
21 A Right.
22 Q But you advise Alicia Valle, who I think was your
23 press person --
24 A Correct.
25 Q -- that, ' hasn't even finished her
Page 71
1 recommendation i.e. , we are a long way off." So,
2 did you have any idea why the FBI was planning a press
3 conference on Epstein?
4 A I don't -- I don't know if I did. I don't recall
5 if I did.
6 Q Was it -- how typical was it for the FBI to plan a
7 press conference on an indicted -- on a case that was being
8 indicted at the time of an indictment or arrest without
9 coordinating that with you and your office?
10 A Under highly atypical.
11 Q He was the SAC at the time?
12 A He was the SAC -- he was the SAC -- I know he was
13 the SAC at the time as of September, and I'm almost certain
14 he was the SAC at the time.
15 Q All right. And when you said that we are a long
16 way off, and hasn't even finished her recommendation to
17 , can -- do you know whether you had any idea that she
18 had actually submitted her pros memo, and that she had made a
19 recommendation to
20 A I can't -- I can't recollect --
21 Q Okay.
22 A -- but I'll take my words as reflective of, if I
23 say she hasn't finished her recommendation, then I assume she
24 hasn't finished her recommendation, but I don't recall --
25 Q Does that mean --
Page 72
1 A -- that level of detail.
2 Q -- as you -- as you look at your own words, does
3 that suggest to you that you were unaware as of that moment
4 that she'd actually submitted her pros memo?
5 A That suggests that I would not have been aware that
6 she submitted it. If -- you know, because it sounds like I'm
7 saying she hasn't even submitted her memo to So --
8 Q All right.
9 A -- we're a long way off.
10 Q All right, so, is --
11 A But again, this is based on practice, not
12 recollection.
13 Q All right, and when you said we are a long way off,
14 did that reflect, if you recall, an assessment of the length
15 of time to get to a pros --
16 A Right.
17 Q -- memo, a recommendation, and an assessment of
18 that, or your expectation that even when you saw a pros memo
19 and an indictment, it would be a long process before it was
20 approved?
21 A So, I would assume -- and again, this is just based
22 on speculating from the way that I write, that I'm thinking
23 she hasn't submitted her recommendation to needs
24 to review it.
25 He may -- you know, he'd probably want to talk to
Page 73
1 . It needs to be scrubbed. You know, this could be --
2 this ain't happening next week.
3 Q All right, but in your -- do you have any reason to
4 believe that whatever that process is that you were
5 describing would be any -- any different in any particular
6 measure in this case from the ordinary complex case?
7 A So, from my language, I would take that it's the
8 same process, but that there is a process, and the process
9 hasn't yet been followed.
10 Q All right. Okay.
11 A So, it would be the typical process in a typical
12 complex case.
13 Q All right, and is it fair to characterize this as a
14 relatively complex case, given the legal issues?
15 A I think it is, yes.
16 Q Okay. In Exhibit 8, you actually got the in
17 Exhibit 7, you see that in the bottom part of that that you
18 received a copy of the pros memo on the second page of that
19 exhibit at the top.
20 A Right.
21 is forwarding to you the pros memo.
22 A Right.
23 Q In Exhibit 8, you see that is
24 forwarding or sending to that chain, excluding
25 , that is, and you, additional
Page 74
1 items in Operation Leap Year, and that's a summary of the
2 indictment, and evidence regarding the individual victims.
3 Okay? So, as of May 11, you had before you the pros memo,
4 the proposed indictment, and this substantial amount of
5 additional --
6 A Right.
7 Q -- information. Did you read the pros memo?
8 A Right. So, I don't recall -- and I know you're
9 going to say, why don't I, but this was a long time ago. I
10 don't recall if I read it, or if I went back to the office
11 and sat down with and and went over it. I can't
12 recall from this far. I can say that it looks based on this
13 that I was at the U.S. Attorney's conference.
14 Q Mm-hmm,
15 A The idea of printing this out on a hotel printer, I
16 wouldn't -- I can't believe I would have printed this out on
17 a hotel printer.
18 Q Let alone read it on an airplane, correct?
19 A Let alone read it on an airplane. That just
20 wouldn't --
21 Q Right.
22 A -- have been my practice.
23 Q But going back -- arriving back --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- to your office, was it your practice to take
Page 75
1 voluminous documents like this and go through them yourself,
2 or did you rely on your senior staff?
3 A I would typically rely on senior staff. They --
4 they're the experienced ones that have seen these matters
5 before. They would go through it. We'd sit down. We'd talk
6 about the issues. We might have it in front of us, almost
7 like you've got all those
Q Okay.
9 A -- binders there, but you know, you're calling my
10 attention to particular issues, and we'd sort of talk it
11 through.
12 Q And do you recall doing that in this case?
13 A I recall having discussions with senior staff about
14 this case.
15 Q Who?
16 A Certainly and at various points, and
17 I can't say that I did that in May versus April versus June.
18 I can't give you
19 Q All right.
20 A -- timelines.
21 Q Well, we're talking now about May.
22 A Right.
23 Q Because you've got the actual --
24 A Yeah.
25 Q -- process.
Page 76
1 A It would have been my practice based on this to go
2 back and discuss it, and so based on my practiced, I would
3 have gone back and likely discussed it. I doubt I would have
4 printed this out at whatever hotel I was at.
5 Q But even when you got back to the office, would you
6 have had somebody print it out so you would've had it
7 available?
8 A I may have had someone print it out so it's
9 available. I may have focused on particular parts of it.
10 Q What kinds of issues would you have focused on? In
11 other words -- in other words, some might go straight to the
12 facts.
13 A Right.
14 Q Some might be interested in the legal theories.
15 What was -- what was your approach?
16 A So, I think that depended on the case.
17 Q Okay.
18 A Here, you had legal questions, and you also had --
19 had witness issues, and I would think those would have been
20 the two primary areas.
21 Q Would you have gone through the indictment and the
22 pros memo and all of those other materials, or just relied on
23 your experience seeing your people, and
24 A As a general practice, probably some combination.
25 As a general -- a general recollection, the concerns in this
Page 77
1 case weren't about the sordid details of what happened,
2 because we believed he did what he did. The concerns were
3 about some of the legal issues around it, and some of the
4 issues in terms of testimony.
5 Q Of the victims?
6 A Of the victims.
7 Q All right. On page --
8 A And I say that because that would have been what I
9 would naturally focus on as opposed to reading the sordid
10 details, because I think everyone believed the victims.
11 Q All right. Exhibit 9 is an e-mail that you are not
12 on, but that -- notes that is advising that
13 you, , "Has your memo and Lefcourt's letter." Gerald
14 Lefcourt was --
15 A Mm-hmm.
16 Q -- a New York attorney who was one of the members
17 of the Epstein defense team. Did you know him?
18 A I did not.
19 Q Did you ever encounter him as far as you recall?
20 A I did not.
21 Q All right. He had, according to the documents we
22 have, made two substantial submissions to and
23 in --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- February of that year in an effort to dissuade
Page 78
1 them from pursuing a prosecution, and we have every reason to
2 believe and no reason not to believe that that's what is
3 being referred to. Do you recall reviewing substantial
4 submissions from defense counsel at this time attacking in
5 very granular detail --
6  Mm-hmm.
7 Q -- the credibility of the witnesses, and so on?
8 A I don't recall reviewing those. Again, I recall
9 discussions with my senior team about issues that included
10 the credibility, and I'm not sure if it's -- credibility is
11 the right word, but how the victims would do on the stands.
12 Q Okay, and who do you recall talking to you about
13 that?
14 A So, some combination of and would have
15 bene the likely -- I recall the discussion. I don't recall
16 whether it was , or whether it was or but the
17 logical inference would have been it would have been some
18 combination of and
19 Q has told us that during this period, he
20 was not actively involved in this case --
21 A Mm-hmm.
22 Q -- but that was. Would that be
23 consistent with your memory, or would --
24 A That -- sure, it -- I mean, they were a team. They
25 became more or less involved based on needs.
Page 79
1 Q And was there any particular -- if We EMI was
2 working with you directly on reporting
3 A Right.
4 Q -- on his assessment of this case, was there any
5 reason for Mi to be involved?
6 A I might bounce ideas off him. I mean, he was he
7 was right across, so we worked closely, but you know,
8 was the criminal chief, and if he was in the weeds, , I
9 would speculate would sort of, much like me, defer to his
10 judgement, because they've known each other, and they've
11 worked together, and they had a good working relationship.
12 Q And is it -- do we understand correctly that as
13 first  tant, had a brief that really encompassed
14 the entire office?
15 A He did.
16 Q All right.
17 A He -- so, he supervised the civil, the criminal,
18 the appellate, and the forfeiture.
19 Q All right. There is here in this e-mail that you
20 did not see back in the day, Exhibit 9, a pushback from
21 regarding the rush that is in to
22 pursue the case, and he says, "This is obviously a Very
23 significant case, and Alex wants to take his time making sure
24 he is comfortable before proceeding." Do you -- can you tell
25 us what the basis would be for, or was, for that assertion by
Page ".7.;.
2 A So, I can't -- well, I can't tell you from
3 recollection what the basis is. I can -- I can speculate
4 that the materials being transmitted Friday morning -- oh, I
5 guess it was -- yeah, so --
6 Q The 11th.
A Yeah.
Q Friday.
9 A So, Friday morning, it hasn't been reviewed by
10 anyone in the management chain, much less approved and
11 edited, and that Monday is saying why don't I have a
12 decision?
13 And -- and so, absent truly extenuating
14 circumstances, typically, you'd have -- give -- you know,
15 it'd go through the management chain up to the U.S. Attorney.
16 And so, he's pushing back, saying, hey, it's been a day, or
17 it's been a weekend. I'm --
18 Q Right.
19 A -- I'm just reading between the lines here.
20 Q Who had authority to sign off on the Epstein
21 prosecution? To, say, indict?
22 A So, as a delegated matter, had
23 signature authority.
24 Q Me -hmm.
25 A As did -- as did , as did
Page 81
1 obviously I did. As a practice matter, this is something
2 that would have gone through the chain, and that we would
3 have then discussed.
4 Q But why up at your level? Is it because it is, as
5 says, "Obviously a very significant case?"
6 A So, at my level, not only because of the facts,
7 because it's not about the facts, but I do think that there
8 are legal issues that -- that implicated policy, that -- that
9 we were thinking through.
0 Q And what were -- what were the legal issues, and
11 what were the policy issues?
12 A So -- so, the legal issues, and also factual issues
13 in terms of the witnesses. So, the legal issues so, and
14 there's an e-mail from based on the -- you know, the
5 contemporaneous record that alludes to some of this. In my
16 experience at the civil rights division, trafficking cases
17 involved -- you know, I can -- I can describe some -- some
18 horrific cases of girls being held against their will, you
19 know.
20 You had child pornography matters with young women,
21 sometimes incredibly young, that the office prosecuted. As
22 the trafficking laws were being developed, there was a lot o
23 discussion about, what's the difference between trafficking
24 and solicitation, and that discussion took place as the
25 trafficking laws were being developed. And so, this
Page 82
1 implicated that, and it implicated the -- what is local and
2 what is federal.
3 Q All right. So, in the first, you're talking -- in
4 the first category, you're talking about the individual
5 charges that had been -- that were being proposed, which
6 included both trafficking and coercion and enticement -- or,
7 enticement.
8 A Correct.
9 Q All right. And in the latter, you felt that -- did
10 you to what extent did the witness -- victim witness kind
11 of credibility issues implicate policy?
12 A So -- so, I think I said policy and victim in that.
13 Q All right.
14 A In that there was certainly discussion between me
15 and my management about concerns as to how these victims
16 would sort of stand up in court.
17 Q So, what would have -- what would make you
18 comfortable before -- before proceeding? What would make
19 you -- what at that point would have made you comfortable
20 about proceeding?
21 A So, I think that at this point, I don't think it's
22 what would or would not have made me comfortable, and I'm
23 speculating here. I think it's, it came in on Friday, let's
24 talk this through.
25 Q But there -- but you've just identified for us
Page 83
1 issues that --
2 A Issues that --
3  -- in your mind
4 A -- we would have --
5 Q -- had to be resolved.
6 A -- wanted to talk through.
7 Q All right. Okay. At that point, did you -- to
8 your recollection, have any doubt that some form of
9 indictment or charging instrument against Epstein was likely
10 to be -- become viable?
11 A So, I don't -- it was a case that I thought it very
12 important that we do something. How that something played
13 out, I think had all along been a matter of discussion.
14 Q As something other than what the U.S. Attorney's
15 Office does, which is prosecute?
16 A Well -- well, no, I mean, what the U.S. Attorney's
17 Office does is ensure that justice is served.
18 Q Right.
19 A And whether -- and in partnership with state
20 attorneys, and sometimes that means state attorneys take the
21 lead. Sometimes that means the U.S. Attorney's Office takes
22 the lead, and it -- and a lot of times, we actually had, you
23 know, we -- we would share staff, because sometimes it made
24 sense for -- you know, for one part of the other to take the
25 lead.
Page 84
1 So, writ large, I thought throughout it was very
2 important that something happen. There were these concerns
3 all along. I can speculate that this is just a reflection of
4 those continuing concerns.
5 Q As expressed by you to in the ordinary
course?
7 A As developed as a group throughout this -- I can
so, if we go back to -- what was the Exhibit?
Q June of -- June of 2006.
A So, Exhibit 3, says, "In that meeting, I
summarized the case and the state attorney's office handling
12 it. I acknowledged that we needed to do work to collect
13 evidence establishing a federal nexus, and I noted the time
14 and money that would be required for an investigation." And
15 so, as far back as that initial meeting, there is the
16 discussion about the federal nexus, and is this a state or a
17 federal --
18 Q Right.
19 A -- case?
20 Q All right. Exhibit 7 is an early e-mail from=
21 to you. Early, meaning it proceeds the one --
22 A Correct-.
23 Q -- we just looked at, and early in that it's right
24 as you're
25 A 5
Page 85
1 Q -- receiving the pros memo, and you ask him, have
2 you read the memo? And curious why you
3 rather than
ask MI
A I don't recall. I can -- I can speculate, and I
5 have two thoughts that I'll speculate. One is, ME her
6 direct supervisor.
7 Q Mm-hmm.
A And I might be thinking --
Q Second line supervisor.
10 A Her second line supervisor, so why is sending
11 me this? , have you read this? I.e., did you jump the
12 chain? Secondly, I think it I may have wanted to have
13 multiple opinions on this.
14 Q Ms-hmm.
15 A It's most likely that I had talked to
16 already, because and I talked more often, and I'm asking
17 another person in the management chain, hey, what do you
18 think? Let's have multiple opinions on the table here.
19 Q Well, this is the first time other than that
20 we see you getting a recommendation.
21 A Right.
22 Q When says, he thinks that you should
23 charge him -- you, the office, should charge Epstein. He has
24 issues with the charging strategy proposed by but
25 one, he says, "We all need to get on the same page as to
Page 86
1 whether the statute's covered the conduct, and whether the
2 conduct is the type we should charge. I think the answer to
3 both is yes, although there is some risk on some of the
4 statutes." He proposes that the office start with a
5 complaint, which is not unusual, is it?
A It -- it happens, yes.
Q All right, which allows the defendant to be
8 arrested, and ideally detained, and then the defendant is
9 then highly motivated or incentivized --
12 what
A Okay.
Q -- to work a pre-indictment resolution. That's
is proposing. He also notes that it's
13 important to -- in his view, to "cap him with conspiracy
14 counts to make a plea attractive," and the court could give
15 us a hard time with that if we had to dismiss indicted
16 counts.
17 A Right.
18 Q Okay. The proposed indictment included one
19 conspiracy -- a conspiracy that has a five year
20 A Five year cap.
21 Q -- statutory maximum, and this notion is that
22 Epstein be charged with a five-year conspiracy count, and
23 take it from there. Do you know what he was referring to
24 when he noted that a court could give you a hard time in
25 dismissing indicted counts in this case?
Page 87
1 A So -- so, as a typical matter, once there's an
2 indictment, the -- a pre-indictment -- well, by definition, a
3 pre-indictment resolution comes off the table, but in cases
4 of this nature, the resolutions tend to happen before
5 indictment, because once the indictment is done, at least in
6 South Florida, dismissal of charges -- for example, if -- you
7 know, if is saying, let's think about a 371 with a five
8 year cap a rule 11 --
9 Q Mm-hem.
10 A -- that's something that South Florida judges, they
11 tend not to -- you know, dismissing a number of counts, and
12 then doing a rule 11 is not something that judges tend to do.
13 Q All right. Two -- two pieces to that. One is --
14 A Okay.
15 Q -- the issue of dismissing substantive --
16 A Right.
17 Q -- counts -- substantive counts. Is that -- was
18 that a particular concern in this case because of the nature
19 of the conduct represented in the --
20 A So --
21 Q -- substantive counts?
22 A -- so, so, your question -- you asked a general
23 question, and then now you're moving to a
24 Q Right.
25 A -- specific. As a general matter, not just in this
Page 88
1 case, but in other cases, it is -- it was rare that the
2 office after an -- in cases like this, after a full charge
3 was done, that that substantive counts were dismissed. So,
4 for example, in the public corruption cases that I referenced
5 earlier out of Palm Beach, those were all negotiated pre-
6 indictment, and agreed to, and then by the time the -- the
7 case was indicted, it was all -- it was all sort of set on
8 auto-pilot.
9 Q So, typically, in my experience, the -- a
10 disposition like that is -- results in a criminal
11 information, not an indictment.
12 A Correct, and --
13 Q Are you saying that you would go ahead and indict
14 then?
15 A No, no, no, what I'm saying is that they were -- it
16 was all negotiated in advance, and then there was an
17 information --
18 Q Oh, okay.
19 A -- and the information would go forward, not an
20 indictment.
21 Q All right.
22 A And so, that is how a number of high profile cases
23 typically proceeded, as opposed to indict and dismiss.
24 Q And that is the experience of the Southern District
25 of Florida in general?
Page 89
1 A It -- it was in particularly the Palm Beach office
2 with other high profile cases that were there at the time.
3 Q Do you recall any case in which a judge in an
4 indicted case refused to dismiss counts when the
5 government --
A Yeah.
Q -- in an indictment under those circumstances?
A I don't recall specific cases, but I can -- I can
9 say that typically in the higher profile cases you'd
10 negotiated with opposing counsel, presenting information.
11 The information would have agreed to an agreed to guideline,
12 and it would proceed in that way.
13 Q Understood, but in this case, I'm focusing on the
14 assertion by that the court could give us a hard
15 time, and that's a little different from, you know,
16 exercising discretion to negotiate and proceed by
17 information. So, is there any judge that -- that was
18 particularly concerning with regard to an unwillingness to --
19 A
20 Q -- dismiss?
21 A I don't -- so, first, this is 12 years ago, and I
22 don't recall any specific judge, but I can -- I can sort of
23 that say that was not the practice of the office. The
24 practice of the office was to proceed by information rather
25 than indictment with dismissal, because there is more --
Page 9C
1 there is -- there -- you can -- you can -- you can lay out
2 more what you've negotiated. I think later there's a letter
3 from.. that sort of presents the same perspective.
4 Q All right. In --
5 MS. One moment?
6 MS. : Go ahead.
THE WITNESS: Yeah.
8 BY MS. a:
Q You said in cases of this nature, the resolution
10 happens before indicting. What is the -- this cases of this
nature?
A Higher profile. Higher profile cases.
13 Q So, not necessarily sex offense cases?
14 A Not necessarily sex offense, no, no, no, higher --
15 higher profile cases where --
16 Q And this made -- this was a higher profile case
17 because --
18 A This was a -- just, a -- so, I would say it's a
19 combination of all of the above, and to my mind, one of
20 the -- one of the parts of this case is the legal theories
21 were, if not novel, they were novel within the Southern
22 District of Florida. At least, some of the legal theories,
23 and I -- we'll probably get into that.
24 Q Did his wealth make it a high profile case?
25 A Well, it was clearly in the paper. And so, that
Page 91
1 made it a high profile case. I don't think it -- I don't
2 think it was his wealth. I think it was all of the above.
3 This was a matter that the state attorney had been ready to
4 charge that the federal government is now jumping into and
S saying, by its presence, that the state did not do enough.
6 That in and of itself makes it a very high profile
7 case. I can't remember any other instance, certainly during
8 my time, when we jumped in and said, you know, the state
9 dropped charges, and so we are going to do more.
10 BY MS.
11 Q As opposed to, or as distinguished from what you'd
12 described a few moments ago, a situation in which the federal
13 authorities and the state authorities kind of worked together
14 to sort out what would be charged, where, and do it
15 cooperatively?
16 A And that was more cooperative, and I --
17 Q Right.
18 A i would -- you know, I do recollect that -- and
19 I think the record bears this out, that this was not a
20 particularly cooperative relationship between us and the
21 state attorney.
22 Q Mm-hmm. Yes, we will get to that. Were you --
23 A If I could -- if I could return, I think your
24 question -- the way you posed your question, you said a
25 recommendation from , and let me -- let me push back a
Page 92
1 little bit on that.
2 Saying what are your thoughts? Have you read it,
3 what are your thoughts? And he says, yes, we can talk next
4 week, my current thoughts are is very different than,
5 we've sat down, we've discussed this, this is my now informed
6 position.
7 Q Understood, and I -- I should have been clearer. I
8 was referring to his recommendation that if you were going to
9 proceed, you should start with a --
I 4
A Right.
Q -- complaint.
A Right.
Q Just to be clear.
A And I'm just saying --
Q Okay.
A -- initial thoughts are -- yeah.
Q All right. So, were you aware that
18 bootlegged a copy of the pros memo to at
CEOS?
23 Q
Q He did at that time.
A 0k:Fcf.
And did you -- did you know
A A little bit. I certainly knew of him.
Q Had you encountered him when -- he was the chief of
Page 93
1 the child exploitation and obscenities section
2 A Right.
3 Q in the criminal division here, correct? Had you
4 encountered him while you were in this building also?
5 A Most likely. I knew of him enough that the
6 correspondence shows -- and I recall asking to involve him
7 pretty early on.
8 Q So, it does read as if you were acquainted with
9 him.
10 A Yeah.
Q All right. And did you have any -- did his
12 opinion, his views as chief of CEOS and as
3 who had been an AUSA --
14 A Right.
15 Q
A In Miami.
Q -- Miami, did his views have influence on your
8 thinking about this case?
19 A I don't think at this time I was aware that
20 had been consulted.
21 Q All right, and in July, just so you know, and I --
22 and this is not something you saw -- he provided a fairly
23 strong statement to -- by e-mail to and
24 in which he advises that he reviewed the pros memo
25 closely.
Page 94
1 It's terrific. He says did a terrific job,
2 and he says, "we agree with her legal analysis. Her charging
3 decisions are legally sound," and then goes
4 through the different statutes, and concludes that they are
5 all properly charged, and that although there are some
6 issues, legally, that in his view we should, "We should
7 prevail." "Our position should prevail."
8 And that he also reviewed the arguments contained
9 in the letters from defense counsel, and he found none of
10 their arguments persuasive. So, at least as of July 18,
11 your --
12 A Right.
13 Q -- three levels of supervisors down were on notice
14 that CEOS was on board and wanted to --
15 A Right.
16 Q see the case move forward, but is it -- am I
17 correct in understanding that at that time, you were unaware
18 of that?
19 A I do not recall being aware of that.
20 Q All right. Okay. If you had been aware of it, if
21 they had sent this --
22 A Yeah.
23 Q -- pretty -- I don't want to overstate it, but it
24 is a pretty strong endorsement of the proposed prosecution,
25 would you have been influenced by that?
Page 95
1 A Sure, I would have. I mean, I -- I respected MI,
2 and clearly wanted him to be part of the team, and later
3 invited him down, and so, yes.
4 Q Okay. All right. Do you know why they wouldn't
have shared -- your people wouldn't have shared this with
6 you?
A I can't -- I don't know.
8 Q All right. So, when -- as far -- based on the
9 briefings that you got at -- in this time period when there
10 was an effort to try to figure out --
11 A Right.
12 Q -- what you were going to do, were there any issues
13 of concern of fact or evidence or the charges that were left
14 unaddressed? In other words, if there were issues about
15 victim credibility, were steps being taken to address those?
16 A Unaddressed is a -- again, it -- it's a very
17 binary, and it's not about addressed versus unaddressed. And
18 so, let me -- let me sort of come at it, if I can try to
19 get -- there were concerns around some legal issues. There
20 were concerns about how the victims would do when put on the
21 stand.
22 Q Right.
23 A As a general matter, we thought there was enough if
24 we had to go forward, we could, as an ethical matter, go
25 forward. That doesn't mean that there was not value in a
Page 96
1 pre-indictment resolution.
2 And so, here, you havellIII, based on this Exhibit
3 7, saying, we need to get on the same page as to what to
4 charge, pre-indictment resolution, cap him with conspiracy
5 count to make up the attractive.
6 So, a five year cap, something less than five
7 years, you have  in her affidavit that was submitted to
8 the court saying she favored a pre-indictment resolution.
9 And so, it's not a, have you addressed everything, yes or no,
10 as opposed to putting all of this, how do we --
11 Q All right.
12 A -- how do we move forward?
13 Q Right, but there is a binary point here, and that
14 is, you either indict or you don't indict. You either
15 present an indictment to the grand jury, or you don't, right?
16 That's a decision. Right?
17 A So, I would -- I would actually push back in that
18 in many cases, it's not quite that binary. In many cases,
19 you sit down with opposing counsel and say, look, we can go
20 to a grand jury, and we can present this indictment and
21 indict, or we can resolve this now. If we resolve this now,
22 this is the path that can go forward. Alternatively, we can
23 go here. And so, it's not an A versus B.
24 Q I understand that nuance, but the decision to
25 indict does -- I mean, you either indict or you don't. If
Page 97
1 you don't indict, it's for any number of reasons. If under
2 these circumstances, the choices that are available are you
3 have a case that's been brought in -- taken in from --
4 A Right.
5 Q -- the state. You can -- you can decline it. Send
6 it back to the state, make it go away, whatever.
7 A Right.
8 Q We're not interested. You can indict. You can
9 indict and go to trial. These are the subcategories. Or you
10 can indict and have the defendant plead to the indictment, or
11 you can indict and work a post-indictment plea deal, which
12 raises the issues you talked about, or you can negotiate
13 an -- or you can charge -- proceed by complaint, and do as
14 was suggesting --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- work a pre-indictment but post charge
17 disposition, or you can work a pre-charge disposition, right?
18 I mean, that's really --
19 A So, so --
20 Q That's the parade of possibles.
21 A Sure, but that's more than indictment or don't
22 indict. That's six or seven options.
23 Q I understand that. That's how it will play out,
24 but the decision as to whether to indict is binary. You're
25 either indicting or you're not indicting. The -- the act of
Page 98
1 indicting is a -- is something that either happens or doesn't
2 happen. That's all I'm saying.
3 A Sure.
4 Q Okay? So, what I'm getting at is, with respect to
5 the indictment -- so, as you're looking at this case,
6 you're -- it sounds as if you're doing sort of one analytical
7 track, which is, what do we do with this case? The other
8 piece of that, and a track that could have been followed
9 exclusively is, what do we need to do to get an indictment
10 that is legally sound and evidentiary -- evidentiarily solid?
11 I'd like to focus on that track --
12 A Okay.
13 Q -- because they're not unrelated.
14 A Sure.
15 Q If you never get down the, do we have a viable
16 indictment road, then you're not going to be able to do
17 anything in the other
18 A Sure.
19 Q -- road. So, at this point, you had identified,
20 and you collectively -- you and your people had identified
21 some witness -- victim witness issues, and some legal issues.
22 My question is, were steps being taken to -- i used -- I used
23 the term address --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- let me -- let me clarify, with respect to the
e ,
1 witnesses, was the FBI and the line attorney with the
2 assistance perhaps of the grand jury, taking steps to
3 corroborate --
4 A Right.
5 Q -- shore up victim witness testimony, find new
6 victims, find additional evidence, and so on?
7 A So -- so, taking that in part is helpful. So, with
8 respect to the witness issues, I recall, and goes into
9 much more detail in her affidavit, but I recall concerns that
10 were communicated to me about, in essence, to sort of
11 summarize my impression or recollection, these girls are
12 young.
13 They're impressionable. They are scared. Will
14 they stand up in court? There are any number of -- there's
15 any number of things that could be used against them. Some
16 of them are -- and this is uncomfortable, but some of them
17 thought he actually cared for them, and that's not atypical
18 in these cases where they -- they sort of develop thoughts
19 that are wrong, but -- but they are what they are, and were
20 actually saying he did nothing wrong, and because many of
21 them knew one another, how would that all play out?
22 Q Right.
23 A And so, it would be my assumption, particularly
24 given, you know, how much work was doing on this
25 case -- Ms. was doing on this case -- that she, in
Page 100
1 combination with the FBI, would be pursuing those matters,
2 and looking to develop the evidence and corroborate, and
3 throughout this process, it would have been my assumption and
4 hope that she was continuing to develop the facts, because
5 that can only help.
6 Q And so as U.S. Attorney, would it indeed have been
7 your expectation?
8 A Yes.
9 Q And the expectation that her -- that all those
10 interim supervisors would have been supporting her and
11 encouraging her and guiding her?
12 A It would have been, and that -- that's what happens
13 in typical cases.
14 Q Right.
15 A Just because we're having a legal discussion
16 doesn't mean you stop pursuing leads.
17 Q All right. Let me stick with the evidence piece of
18 that.
19 A Yeah.
20 Q I'm going to keep these --
21 A Helpful.
22 Q -- strains going. You got a very detailed
23 accounting in -- reflected in Exhibit 8 from of the
24 different Jane Does, and there were a lot of them, and there
25 were -- there were many counts in the indictment, and many
EFTA00009329 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Alex Acosta pages 101-200
(date: 2020-04-30)
Page 101
1 carefully -- the -- each -- each victim was tied to a
2 particular set of criminal activity. In other words, these
3 victims were not lumped in an aggregate sort of formless
4 petri dish.
5 A Yes.
6 Q They were individuals. had met -- was
7 meeting with them, *indeed was finding new victims along with
8 the FBI, and they were conducting individualized assessments
9 of the viability of each victim witness, and indeed
10 submitted a follow on pros memo, a pros memo addendum in
11 July, and another one in September, and tailored -- continued
12 to tailor her indictment -- proposed indictment to these
13 individualized acts.
14 The question -- when I -- when I hear the victims
15 referred to in the aggregate, I wonder what effort there was
16 to sit down and address each individual victim, because there
17 were so many, and a credibility issue that could be very
18 troubling with one victim, if -- or, two victims, or four
19 victims --
20 A Fair.
21 Q -- could well be overcome by other victims who had,
22 not those credibility issues, perhaps others, and if I may
23 finish, that in the aggregate, when presented individually in
24 total, a kind of a persuasive case could be made that would
25 be impossible with one or two or three? Does that -- is that
Page 102
1 a fair --
2 A So, that is fair, and I think -- and your point
3 that we shouldn't sort of talk about the victims in aggregate
4 is a fair point. I would -- I would respond, and Ms.
5 goes into this in her affidavit a little bit, and
6 I've got it -- and I have a recollection of some discussion
7 of this between myself, and you're going to ask me who, so
13 another victim that said horrendous things happened, to what
14 extent does defense cast this as, they are trying to recover,
15 they're trying to do -- and so one of the concerns was when
16 you have victims that know one another, that brought one
17 another in, even if you've got similar patterns, if some of
18 them cast doubt, how would that be taken by -- by the jury?
19 Q Is that assessment or analysis your own, or is it
20 one that you developed with the people you talked to about
21 this case?
22 A So, that -- that assessment would have been, in my
23 general recollection, but also based on my practice, that
24 kind of witness assessment is the kind of thing that I would
25 have relied more on the AUSA -- on my management team for,
let me just say I don't know who.
But the concern is when you have victims that know
one another, to what extent would defense -- if you've got
two victims that say A happened, even if it's similar sets of
facts, and another victim that said he did nothing wrong, and
Page 103
1 because that was more within their -- their area of
2 expertise.
3 Q Right, and in particular was known as
4 a trial attorney.
5 A Right.
6 Q Correct?
7 A Right.
8 Q Do you recall having discussions with about
9 that?
10 A He would have been the logical --
11 Q Right.
12 A -- person. I know that we had those discussions,
13 and we talked about what happened, how will they -- how will
14 they play out at trial, and -- and the takeaway was, it could
15 play out well, it could not play out well.
16 Q So, as of the time that all --
17 A And again, I say they as a collective.
18 Q Right.
19 A Understanding that some would say exonerating
20 things. Some would have contradictory statements. Some may
21 not want to testify, and -- and so, that conversation was
22 had.
23 Q So, was had, it -- you and talked about it?
24 A I can't say -- and I can say, I recall the
25 discussion, you know, I don't know -- 12 years ago, you might
Page 104
1 recall a discussion from 12 years ago. What -- what you
2 presented to me, for the record, I'm pointing to , or I'm
3 indicating the -- the issue about civil rights, do you
4 recall who else was in the room or wasn't in the room at the
5 time?
14 substance without remembering who was in the room at the
15 time.
16 Q And understanding --
17 A Right.
18 Q -- that this was one case of thousands that were
19 under your --
20 A Correct.
21 Q -- authority, although a particularly sensitive and
22 high profile one, but the -- a -- the question to you is, do
23 you know what individualized assessment did of
24 the victim witnesses?
25 A I -- I can't speak to that.
A Yeah, I --
Q It's a rhetorical question.
A It's a rhetorical question.
Q We'll take it, I guess.
A But --
Q
A -- you know, it's very -- it -- one can remember
Page 105
1 Q Do you know whether he actually met with any of the
2 victim witnesses?
3 A I can't speak to that.
Q Do you know whether went to West Palm
5 and sat down and actually went through the evidence as to
6 each one of the potential --
7 A I --
8 Q -- witnesses?
9 A I can't speak to that.
10 Q Do you know any of that information as to
11 SNP
12 A Again, I can't -- I can't speak to that. I
13 would -- I would say that -- that was first assistant,
14 and to the extent he relied on the criminal chief, that would
15 be -- he used to be criminal chief, and so --
16 Q Right.
17 A -- he would naturally view the role of criminal
18 chief as being important, and someone that would naturally
19 review matters before they went to the first assistant.
20 Q Okay. So, when you talk -- when you were -- as you
21 recall, having these conversations about the -- the victim
22 issues, as -- as matters of evidence, it -- it -- you cannot
23 tell us what the basis for analysis was?
24 A I can't. I mean, as a general matter, I don't
25 recall the specific. As a general matter, when I talk to
Page 106
1 individuals about a case, I would assume that they had
2 informed themselves, and had done the diligence necessary to
3 have that discussion with me.
4 Q Do you remember him parsing out for you, or --
6 Q -- you know --
7 A -- I don't recall that --
8 4 -- the individual --
9 A -- that level of granularity.
10 Q All right. The -- to finish my sentence, to the
11 individual witnesses, and you're saying you don't.
12 A Yeah.
13 Q And by witness, I mean victim witness. Did you
14 ever sit down with and have her present to
15 you each witness -- each victim as a potential witness, and
16 her individualized credibility issues, and how as a -- as a
17 prosecutor and an experienced trial attorney,
18 was going to overcome those issues?
19 A I don't recall doing that, and as a matter of
20 general practice, particularly when it came to what I'll call
21 trial issues --
22 Q mm-bms.
23 A -- we had really experienced individuals in the
24 office, and that's not something that I would typically do on
25 this or other high profile cases, because they're the trial
Page 107
1 lawyers. They -- this is what they do. I would tend to
2 focus more on the legal issues.
3 Q All right. I want to stay with the -- the witness
4 issues, and the evidence of that for the moment.
5 A Mm-hmm.
6 Q In Exhibit 3, this lively exchange between
7 and , she asks to make a presentation to you in the last
8 major paragraph of her e-mail on page four. She says, "I
9 would like to make a presentation to the U.S. Attorney,
10 and you, with our side of the investigation and a
11 revised indictment. The presentation will address the points
12 raised by Epstein's counsel, and will convince you of the
13 strength of the case." Bearing in mind that by this time,
14 and had in front of them --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- her pros memo, her proposed indictment, this
17 analysis she did as evidenced in Exhibit 8, but also the
18 submissions from Jerry Lefcourt, and that -- that had
19 not had a chance to actually make a presentation to them.
20 response is on page three, his last paragraph.
21 He chides and tells her that, "You may
22 not dictate the dates and people you will meet with about
23 this or any other case. If the U.S. Attorney or the first
24 assistant desired to meet with you, they will let you know."
25 She, in her final response on page one points out that she's
Page 108
1 not trying to dictate anything. She's just asking. Are you
2 aware that -- bear in mind, you didn't see --
A Correct.
Q -- Exhibit 3, were you aware that
5 very much wanted to make a presentation to you and to
6 and about her case, and her evidence?
7 A So, I don't recall this.
8 Q By this, you mean --
9 A I don't -- I don't recall being aware of this
10 request.
11 Q All right.
12 A As a -- as a general matter, it seemed that there
13 was communications going back and forth. And so, she
14 certainly felt comfortable e-mailing me when she wanted to, I
15 guess is my point, rightly or wrongly. And so, I wasn't
16 aware of that request, and --
17 Q So, are you suggesting that she could easily have
18 e-mailed you and said, Alex, I really want to make a
19 presentation to you?
20 A I'm not suggesting -- let me -- what I'm suggesting
21 is from my perspective, there was a lot of communication in
22 this case, more than is typical. I wasn't aware of -- I
23 don't recall the request, but there was communication in this
24 case.
25 Q What do you -- what do you mean by communication?
al •
Page 109
1 I mean, there are a lot of e-mails, but --
2 A There is. There are a lot of e-mails, right.
3 Q But a lot of them are because there are draft --
4 later on, we have drafts and so on, but --
5 A
6 Q -- we don't --
7 A So, what I mean by that is, I do not recall an
8 impression that she wasn't being -- that she didn't have
9 access, or wasn't being heard.
10 Q To you?
11 A Correct.
12 Q You've already seen two e-mails here where she was
13 scolded pretty seriously, and in one case for approaching --
14 A Correct.
15 Q and you without being
16 involved back when --
17 A Correct.
18 Q was crim chief, and then here, she --
19 the -- what says to her is quite strong, isn't
20 it? Would you have ever used that language to a subordinate?
21 A You've seen my e-mails and my style.
22 Q I think not.
23 A I -- so, what I -- what I am saying is, from my
24 perspective at the time to the best of my recollection, this
25 was not a case where she was not -- where she was frozen out.
Page 110
1 This was a case where there was ample communication --
2 MR. : Well --
3 BY MS.
4 Q Did ever tell you, hey boss, this line
5 assistant, she's being a pain. You know, she's asked for to
6 make a presentation to you. Do you want to do it?
7 A I -- I don't -- look, this was 12 years ago. I
8 don't recall it. Whether he did or not, I can't say, but I
9 don't recall it.
10 Q If he or or even had
11 directly asked you for that opportunity, would you have
12 entertained it? Would you have agreed to a presentation from
13 the line attorney?
14 A As a general matter, if someone makes a direct --
15 saying, this is a case that I have worked, I need to sit down
16 and talk to you, I would have said, yes.
17 Q Do you recall any occasion when a line assistant on
18 his or her own initiative came to you and made such a request
19 and you granted it?
20 A I don't, because it rarely got to that level.
21 from my impression and my recollection, we had pretty good
22 communications in the office.
23 Q All right, I'm sorry, I --
24 MR. : That's okay.
25 MS. : -- cut you off.
Page 111
1 BY MR.
2 Q You've talked about needing to respect the chain of
3 command.
4 A Right.
Would there have been any repercussions for a line
6 assistant actually trying to approach you about this
7 presentation?
A I would hope not. I mean, it's -- I think it's
9 important for line assistants to be respectful and to, you
10 know, let their supervisor know, and issues -- you know, and
11 to do it with -- with respect, and not go around supervisors,
12 but I would hope -- I mean --
13 Q Well --
14 A -- not --
15 Q If she had raised it with a supervisor first, and
16 that supervisor said, no, that's not your place, would you
17 have expected her to have followed what the supervisor had
18 told her on that regard?
19 A Fair. Look, fair point. I'm not aware of this e-
20 mail. I can't speak to that. AS a general matter, I would
21 -- you know, going back to where I started, you know, I would
22 at 6:00 o'clock walk around the office and say, how are
23 things going? What case are you working on? In part,
24 because I thought it was important to.
25 BY MS.
Page 112
1 Q Did you wander up down -- up to West Palm and do
2 that too?
3 A Less often, but yes.
4 BY MR.
5 Q You talked a little bit about the experience of
6 your senior staff.
7 A Right.
8 Q What do you know about the experience
9 had in handling these types of cases?
10 A You -- when you say these types, you mean --
11 Q Sex crimes --
12 A
24 had
A I can't.
Q -- cases involving children --
A I can't --
Q -- or child victims?
A I can't speak to that. I don't know.
Q What about
A I can't speak to that.
Q or
A I can't speak to that.
BY MS.
Q But you do know that
substantial experience with child sex crimes?
Page 113
1 A
2 Q You named her PSA coordinator.
3 A I know that she had experience with prior cases.
4 Q All right.
5 A Yeah.
6 Q Okay. We're going to go for half an hour more,
7 then we'll take our break, and then we'll --
8 A Okay.
9 Q -- come back. I -- and we will get back to that
10 other piece of the evidence and the legal issues --
11 A Right.
12 Q -- and then -- and then we'll spend a lot of time
13 on the alternatives. Haven't forgotten that. In June of
14 2007, there was a meeting that defense counsel requested of
15 the sort of next level up from . In other words,
16 they had already made a --
17 A Right.
18 Q -- presentation to the line assistant, and her
19 supervisor. They wanted to come to Miami and talk to, in
20 this case, and --
21 A Mm-hmm.
22 Q -- and they did meet with them. Were you aware --
23 do you have a recollection of whether you were aware that
24 they -- there was such a meeting?
25 A It -- so, / don't have a recollection, but it rings
Page 114
1 a bell. I don't know if that distinction is a fair one.
2 Q Well, I can -- I may help amplify the bell a little
3 bit. One of the defense attorneys who was present there in
4 addition to Gerald Lefcourt, Roy Black, and Lillian Sanchez
5 was Alan Dershowitz.
6 A Yeah.
7 Q Does that ring a bell?
8 A So, it does. There's --
9 Q Okay.
10 A I -- I can't say it's a recollection, but it sounds
11 like there -- it sounds right, and in my usual course, once
12 was meeting with someone, he would typically have let me
13 know.
14 Q All right. All right, and where would such a
15 meeting take place? Would it be in office? Was it
16 big enough? Or would you use the executive conference room?
17 A Based on the number of people, almost definitely
18 the executive conference room.
19 Q And is that -- do people have to go by your office
20 to get there?
21 A They do not.
22 Q Okay, and would you in a case like this make a --
23 as you said a moment ago, pop your head in --
24 A Right.
25 Q -- and say hello?
Page 115
1 A Right. As a typical matter, I probably would not,
2 because then it very rapidly turns into a meeting with me as
3 opposed to a --
4 Q Mn-hmm.
5 A -- meeting with --
6 Q 14M-hmm. Okay.
7 A If that makes sense.
8 Q There was some written submissions also submitted.
9 Pretty substantial ones. These addressing more of the legal
10 issues --
11 A Mm-hmm.
12 Q -- both before and after this. Did someone -- and
13 if so, who -- brief you about what happened at the meeting,
14 and what was contained in the written submissions?
15 A So, I do not recall a briefing. I would assume
16 that, again, based on practice, there's a senior level
17 meeting in the office. Based on practice, would have
18 told me, and then afterwards, he would have said this is what
19 happened.
20 Q All right, but you have no actual recollection of
21 what happened in this case?
22 A I have no actual recollection of -- other than the
23 meeting sounding familiar, I have no recollection.
24 Q So, Exhibit 50 in this packet, it's almost at the
25 end. It's the next to last, really, is a letter that
Page 116
1 IMP offered to the DAG -- the then DAG --
2 A Yes.
3 Q -- in June of 2008, a whole year later. The DAG,
4 Deputy Attorney General Mark Filip, and this is -- you
5 certainly recall that there was an appeal, if you will, a
6 small appeal to the DAG's office --
7 A Right.
8 Q -- by defense counsel, and submitted a
9 fairly substantial accounting of what had gone before in the
10 case, and he also submitted a number of other documents
11 relevant to that.
12 He says on page three that at this June 26th, 2007
13 meeting, which he characterizes arguments, legal and factual,
14 were presented against a federal indictment, and
15 writes that, "The arguments and written materials provided by
16 the defense were examined by the SDFL and rejected." Do
17 you -- is that consistent with any understanding you have of
18 what happened at this meeting?
19 A So, I don't recall, so I'm going to speculate, and
20 the speculation is that by the time this happened, we were
21 fairly far along in how we were viewing this matter.
22 Q This being 2008, or --
23 A No, June.
24 Q June 26th, 2007. Okay.
25 A You know, and as I reviewed the documents, I tried
Page 117
1 to establish a timeline, but clearly, by July 31st, we had --
2 you know, we had sort of concluded how we were approaching
it.
4 And so, I'm going to speculate that when he said
the arguments and written materials provided to defense
6 counsel were examined by the SDFL and rejected, it was they
7 asked us to drop the matter, and we said we're not dropping
8 the matter.
9 Q Okay. Okay, and by the way, is -- just to clean
10 this up, this letter was -- to the DAG, was signed by
11 under your type name, as is --
12 A Right.
13 Q -- standard but you're not cc'd on it. Do you
14 do you recall why you didn't sign this letter? why it was
15 sent by
16 A
18 A I do not recall.
19 Q I just -- that's a -- that's a point of interest.
20 and so, I'll draw your attention to
21 A All right.
22 Q -- Exhibit 49, which is actually dated the day
23 prior, that is, June 2, 2008, and this is an e-mail to
24 you from
25 A Yes.
III, who is -- was and is the ethics --
Page 118
1 Q -- officer for the U.S. Attorney's Office, correct?
2 Reporting back to you an assessment by the executive office
3 of U.S. Attorneys general counsel's office that they did not
4 see you as having an either actual or apparent conflict of
5 interest that would necessitate your recusal from the Epstein
6 matter by virtue of the fact that you apparent, according to
7 this, intended to seek employment with Harvard Law School.
8 A Right, or was considering seeking.
9 Q Was considering. All right. Right. Should you
10 seek employment, it says. So, is it -- is it reasonable for
11 us to infer that this potential recusal --
12 A Right.
13 Q -- was pending at the time the letter to Mark Filip
14 was being drafted, and that's why it went out over
15 signature, and without you as a CC?
16 A So, I would not infer that.
17 Q Okay.
18 A In part because it was potential -- and in part
19 because had the facts at his disposal, and was
20 the natural -- this was a very detailed letter. I did not
21 feel that -- I'm speculating here -- as a general matter,
22 things don't have to go out under my name, and some letters
23 went out under his name, and some letters went out under my
24 name, and the ones that went out under my name tended to be
25 ones that I had more authorship in, and the ones that went
Page 119
1 out under his name in this case were the ones that he had
2 more authorship in. And so, I would just say that this was
3 the continuing course of that.
4 Q Okay. Thank you. Minor technical issue.
5 BY MS. line:
6 Q Would you have read the letter before it went out?
7 A Probably. I would say in my usual course, he would
8 have shown it to me, but not always.
9 Q Not always letters that would have been sent to the
10 Deputy Attorney General's Office, or just letters in general?
11 A Well, he would have I think he would have shown
12 this to me because it's going to the deputy's office. The
13 flip side is, I trust . I think he's a professional.
14 Something that I -- so, an important distinction tc
15 draw, I remember talking to an AUSA that had spent time at
16 main justice, and contrasting the experience of an AUSA with
17 the experience of a trial lawyer here, and sort of the line
18 was you can't send a letter from main justice without three
19 letters of approval, whereas an AUSA in their case typically
20 doesn't even get approval from their line supervisor. And
21 so, as a usual matter, particularly in this case, would
22 run letters by me.
23 That doesn't mean that every letter had to be run
24 by me, and you know, I was certainly aware that the letter
25 was being transmitted. I was aware of the appeal to D.C.
Page 120
1 had comfort in what we had done, and so I thought the appeal
2 would be fine, and if I was out of the office, or if there
3 was some reason that I wasn't going to be consulted, was
4 quite capable of doing it without my review.
5 Q But if you were in the office, it would have been
6 typical for him to run it by you first?
A It would have been.
BY MS.
Q Did you read the letter in preparation for --
A I did.
Q -- this, and is there anything in it that is --
12 that in your view is not accurate?
13 A I think it's accurate. I think the letter, as it
14 should be, is an advocacy piece for what the office has done
15 as opposed to a, on the one hand, on the other hand, analysis
16 piece. But at this point, we're defending the actions of the
17 office, and I think it appropriately should be an advocacy
18 piece.
19 Q All right. Do you disagree with any of the points
20 of advocacy, or the points made in advocacy?
21 A We -- we'd have to go through it --
22 Q All right.
23 A -- paragraph by paragraph.
24 Q Okay. Okay.
25 A But --
Page 121
Q But nothing struck you so much that you --
A I think --
Q -- recall?
A -- I think he fairly presented the totality of
5 everything to the DAG for the DAG to review her for whoever
6 the DAG designated, and I think that was -- that was an
7 appropriate presentation.
8 Q All right. Thank you. So, now I'd like to launch
9 into -- and before we break for lunch, sort of the core
10 question.
11 A Mm-hmm.
12 Q Which we addressed a little bit earlier, and that
13 is who at the U.S. Attorney's Office made the decision to
14 resolve this case with an offer of a two year state plea, and
15 why?
16 A Right. So, how we got to the two years, I can't
17 tell you, because I can give you my general impression.
18 Ultimately, all the cases in the U.S. Attorney's Office were
19 under me.
20 Ultimately, I saw what we'll call that, you know,
21 three pronged resolution, two years -- you know, registration
22 and restitution, and ultimately that was approved on my
23 authority.
24 Q So, who came -- did you -- did you come up with it?
25 Was it your idea --
Page 122
1 A
2 Q -- of an issue?
3 A I don't -- I don't know. The -- this is
4 reconstructing conversations -- I'm going to speculate now.
5 This was not, let's all get in a room and figure out the
6 resolution in the next half hour.
7 Q Mh-hmm.
8 A But this was a course as things are discussed and
9 there's a back and forth over the course of some days or a
10 week or two, and then people get together and discuss, and a
11 view develops, and then the office proceeds with that. But
12 ultimately -- let me -- let me just sort of push back. Look,
13 ultimately, I approved it, and so, I --
14 Q Okay.
15 A -- accept that. I'm not -- I'm not pushing away
16 responsibility for it. I'm just saying I can't recall how we
17 got to, for example, two years. I can speculate as to
18 particular parts of it, but I can't -- you know, but
19 ultimately I'm not pushing away responsibility.
20 Q I understand, and we're going to delve into that
21 A Right.
22 Q -- that two years -- shortly, but I want to turn
23 back to Exhibit No. 3, in which sort of the statement that
24 launches this -- what I keep calling a lively exchange, is on
25 page four, the -- the statement from , and this
Page 123
1 is in response to an inquiry from  to her management,
2 not including you, about what conversations any of them has
3 had with defense counsel --
4 A Right.
5 Q -- about any resolution, because her plan was to
6 talk to Lilly Ann Sanchez about working a plea to federal
7 time concurrent to the state -- whatever the state time was,
8 and in response, tells her, "I told Lilly that a state
9 plea with jail time and sex offender status may satisfy the
10 USA," meaning the U.S. Attorney --
11 A Right.
12 Q -- I believe. So, that's a -- that's a closed
13 quote after USA. Had he discussed that with you? How did he
14 know that that might satisfy you?
15 A So, I don't recall. I can I can speculate based
16 on Mr. course of conduct, I don't think he would
17 have raised that possibility in a case of this profile
18 without having discussed it with me.
19 Q But you have no specific --
20 A I have no --
21 Q -- recollection?
22 A -- specific recollection, but I don't think he
23 would have done that without having come by and said.
24 Q All right. At this point, bearing in mind that you
25 don't have any specific recollection, at this point, do you
Page 124
1 believe you had any understanding of what amount of jail time
2 was in play at this point when tells Lilly Ann
3 Sanchez --
A I can't pinpoint that timeline --
Q All right.
A -- to that degree.
Q All right.
A Of accuracy.
Q He also says later in this e-mail that he told this
10 to Lilly Ann Sanchez a couple of weeks prior before the June
11 26th meeting.
12 A Correct.
13 Q All right. Were you aware that had
14 been communicating directly with Sanchez about the case, and
15 specifically that he represented that you might go for a
16 state disposition if it included jail time and sex offender
17 registration?
18 A I -- I don't recall whether I was aware or not. I
19 recall at some point adopting the concept of jail time plus
20 registration, and then plus restitution. And so, I don't
21 know when that would have happened. Let me also speculate
22 that the U.S. Attorney might go could also refer to, this
23 is being talked about, no final decision has been made.
24 Q Right. If had made that informal
25 discussion comment to Lilly Ann Sanchez without having told
Page 125
I you, without having gotten your clearance ahead of time to
2 tell her that, would that -- would that surprise you, or
3 would you have expected him to consult with you about whether
4 it was okay to go ahead and raise this?
5 A So, as a general matter, yes, but -- and let me
6 let me explain that. AUSAs on occasion, and because this is
7 a high profile -- higher profile case -- a criminal chief may
8 run an idea across opposing counsel and say, look, I don't
9 have authorization.
10 I don't know how the office will react, but it's
11 certainly possible that X, Y, or Z may work out. And that's
12 a very different conversation than, you know, the office will
13 accept.
14 And so, a lot of that really depends on how that
15 conversation goes, and you know, certainly if he's
16 representing my view, I would expect him to check on what my
17 view is, if he's, as criminal chief, saying, this is
18 something that I could support. I don't know how the office
19 will react, that may -- you know, but I can run it up the
20 flagpole, that might be a different type of conversation.
21 Q Okay, and did you know Lilly Ann Sanchez?
22 A I did. She was an AUSA in the office.
23 Q And she left about a month after you came on board?
24 A Was it that -- was it that quick?
25 Q That's our information, yes.
Page 126
1 A Okay.
2 Q Although she apparently remained a periodic
3 present.
4 A Hence, the wasn't that quick.
5 Q Did you know that she'd been
6 at major crimes?
7 A I don't remember that.
deputy
8 Q All right. Did you -- what did -- what did you
9 remember about her? And had you had any dealings with her
10 after she left the office up to this point?
11 A So, I remember that she was in the office, that she
12 was a senior attorney. Whether within the management
13 structure or not, I -- I didn't recollect until you just
14 raised it, and that I can't swear to it, but it rings a bell
15 that she was in major crimes, and she was someone that you
16 would see at bar functions that would --
17 Q Ma-hmm.
18 A -- she -- she was active in the local bar, and I
19 would see her on occasion at a bar function and say hello.
20 Q All right. Did you encounter her in connection
21 with a case, to your recollection, in the period before
22 Epstein?
23 A I'm hesitating not to avoid, but I'm running
24 through my --
25 Q Ma-hmm.
Page 127
1 A Not that I recall.
2 Q What's your impression of her as a as a
3 practitioner?
4 A She did -- she did quite well after she left the
5 office. She set up -- I think she set up her own practice.
6 Q At the time -- at this time, she was with something
7 called Fowler White Burnett.
A Okay, so --
Q She --
A -- she went to Fowler White.
Q -- subsequently --
A She subsequently set up her own practice, and I
13 thought she's done well for herself.
14 Q Okay. Were you aware that had a close
15 personal relationship with Lilly Ann Sanchez, both because
16 they had worked together as chief and deputy chief --
17 A Mm-hmm.
18 Q -- in major crimes, but also because they'd had a
19 dating relationship sometime prior?
20 A I don't recall them having dated, but I don't
21 Q Do you recall knowing that they had dated in the
22 past?
23 A I don't recall knowing that, and in all candor,
24 that's not the kind of thing I ask about.
25 Q But in this case with her representation of
Page 128
1 somebody in a matter being ultimately supervised by...
2 would you have expected= to disclose to you that
3 he'd had a prior romantic relationship with Lilly Ann
4 Sanchez, a member of Epstein's defense team, if only to
address a potential appearance of impropriety or conflict of
6 interest?
7 A I think some of that might have depended on how
8 recently. Was it ten years ago? Was it two years ago? If
9 they were in the supervisory chain that this happened, that
10 could raise other -- other issues. So, if to the extent --
11 so, for example, disclosed to me a potential conflict --
12 Q Mm-hmm.
13 A -- to the extent that these arise, if there is a
14 potential conflict, I'd like to know. I was aware of
15 conflict. I said, keep going.
16 Q And in fact, , you're talking about the
17 Herman --
18 A Yes.
19 Q -- connection, the prior --
20 A Yes.
21 Q -- short lived law firm connection. Are you aware
22 that in fact vetted that through your
23 ethics person?
24 A I am -- I don't recall that independently, but I
25 recall knowing about it. He may have told me he vetted it
Page 129
1 through IIIIII is highly respected in the office,
2 and --
3 Q Mm-hmm.
A -- that would be the appropriate --
Q So, are you also aware that raised,
6 again with III, the potential, again, appearance of a
7 conflict of interest, or appearance of impropriety, because
8 of his supervision of the Epstein case, and his concurrent
9 close friendship with Mike Tein, who was an attorney who was
10 representing Epstein, as well as Guy Lewis, former U.S.
11 Attorney?
12 A So, I was not aware of that.
13 Q You were not aware of it, but -- but I guess what
14 I'm -- what I'm noting is that both and
15 perceived appearance issues, and went through the process
16 that's provided for them to get the blessing to go ahead and
17 proceed with the case by the -- the blessing by the ethics
18 expert --
19 A Right.
20 Q -- but apparently did not in this case
21 vis a vis Lilly Ann Sanchez.
22 A Yeah.
23 Q Does that surprise you, or disappoint you, or
24 perplex you, or do you care?
25 A I would want to know more.
Page 130
1 Q Right.
2 A But certainly it would provide -- I would want to
3 know more before saying I'm disappointed, but again, was it
4 ten years ago? Was it two years ago? What's the
5 continuing -- there are a lot of facts, but certainly it --
6 that's the kind of -- it's the kind of discussion one would
7 typically have with
8 Q And in this case, what we're talking about is an
9 informal conversation, or informal discussion, to use
10 own term, with Sanchez as opposed to any of the
11 other attorneys in Epstein's team about a particular
12 resolution that we're going to spend all afternoon talking
13 about, because it has some problematic aspects. Okay? So,
14 you see why we're --
15 A I get it. No, I get it.
16 Q Okay.
17 BY MR.
18 Q So, before we break, I'm -- should he have talked
19 about this potential resolution with the line assistant
20 before actually making it?
21 A In a typical case, yes. So, in a typical case, I
22 fostered communication. I would -- I would come -- I'd get
23 involved in cases, but we'd want to know what the line
24 assistant thinks, and they can agree or disagree, but we'd
25 want -- we'd want input.
Page 131
1 BY MS.
2 Q What do you make of this really acid tone between
and IIIII? Between and in this Exhibit 3
4 exchange? I mean, is really -- as I read it, it's
pretty strong.
6 A I -- I can't -- I -- I'm not sure what to make of
7 it.
8 Q All right. All right. There are a couple of --
9 let's -- could we go off the record for a split second?
Off the record.)
BY MS.
Q Okay, back on the record. Going back to Exhibit
13 No. 3, there are a few things here that we think are
14 important to raise with you, albeit you not having seen this
15 at the time.
16 says that the -- she complains
17 about this soft -- that's my term -- plea offer that
18 extended to Epstein through Lilly Ann Sanchez. She says that
19 such an offer is completely unacceptable to the FBI, ICE, the
20 victims, and me, meaning . Did you have an
21 understanding of what the FBI's position about prosecuting
22 this case was?
23 A My recollection of interaction with the FBI is with
24 who was the SAC, and as I recall, he supported
25 the eventual direction of this case.
Page 132
1 Q Is he the individual who you identify I believe in
2 actually your -- your attorney's written response as the SAC
3 who called you to congratulate you about the --
4 A He is.
5 Q -- the case? About the result?
6 A Yes.
7 Q And was SAC -- in that same written
8 response from your attorney, there's a mention that he was
9 present at many meetings on this case?
10 A He was present at, at least some, and in part that
11 was at my request, because this was a high enough profile
12 case that I wanted to bring him into this.
13 Q So, the -- we know he was present at the December
14 14, 2007 meeting, right?
15 A Yeah.
16 Q With Ken Starr and company. He is not present
17 at -- to -- according to our investigation, at any other case
18 with defense counsel. Others are. His ASAC, is
19 present.
20 A So, recollections aren't nearly as good as
21 documents. I don't recall the December meeting. I would
22 have said that he was present at the September meeting, but
23 it may be that I am, because this was so long ago, mixing the
24 two.
25 Q Okay.
Page 133
1 A Because I thought he would have come to the
2 September meeting.
3 Q No, according to all the information we have, just
4 so you know --
5 A Right.
6 Q was there as ASAC, but not --
7 actually, I'm not sure she was at the -- at any rate, she
8 was -- she was --
9 A Right.
10 Q -- he was present, was present at the
11 December meeting only.
12 A Right.
13 Q So, just so --
14 A Fair.
15 Q Okay. Would he have been present at meetings other
16 than with defense counsel meetings about this case?
17 A Typically no. Typically, he and I would have
18 talked on the phone or had discussion, and I know that he was
19 aware of the matter.
20 Q so --
21 A I recall his being aware of the matter, and
22 generally positive as to the direction that we were going.
23 Q By the direction or the eventual outcome?
24 A The eventual outcome.
25 Q All right. So, what about the prosecution? Do you
Page 134
1 know what the FBI's view was about the prosecution?
2 A I can't speak to the timeline. I would have -- and
3 I'm contradicting the documents here, but I would have -- if
4 you had asked me, said that he was present at the September
5 meeting, and was aware of the terms that were presented at
6 the September meeting. Clearly, I'm --
7 Q Right.
8 A -- my recollection is incorrect, and I take that
9 for what it is.
10 Q Just to finish on -- with this point though, my
11 question was an understanding of the FBI's position of the
12 case, not the ultimate disposition. In other words, as of --
13 as of the date of Exhibit 3, there was no deal on the table.
14 So, the question is, what was the FBI's view about the case?
15 A So -- so, I -- I'm not trying to be difficult. At
16 some point, when you say view, the FBI, to my recollection,
17 thought that what Mr. Epstein did was sordid and disgusting
18 and that we should proceed. How we proceeded, I don't recall
19 having -- hearing specific views as to the how as opposed to
20 the, we should.
21 Q All right. Let's -- thank you. Let's take a
22 break, 45 minutes. Thank you.
23 (Off the record.)
24 BY MS.
25 Q All right. We're going to go back on the record.
Page 135
1 We're beginning after the break at 1:30 in the afternoon.
2 Thank you.
3 A Before get started --
4 Q Yes.
5 A -- you referenced an e-mail from that wasn't
6 part of the packet.
7 Q Correct.
8 A Is that something that I could see and review, or
9 is there discomfort on that?
10 Q Yes. No, I am not -- as long as we make it on the
11 record. Do you -- do you need to do it now, or can we do it
12 during the next break?
13 A It depends how long -- how long is it? It would
14 just take --
15 Q One page.
16 A -- a minute, if you don't mind.
17 Q Do you want to go off the record while Mr.
18 Acosta --
19 (Off the record.)
20 BY MS.
21 Q All right. On the record again. For the record,
22 Mr. Acosta has just reviewed and e-mail from-
23 to , and
24 dated July 18, 2007 at 2:07 p.m. It's one that I described
25 to Mr. Acosta a moment -- this morning. Do you have any
Page 136
1 comments?
2 A I don't.
3 Q All right. Before we broke, we were -- I mentioned
4 your statement about SAC  having attended many
5 meetings. That to be clear was a representation you made in
6 your March 2007 letter to the Daily Beast, not the written
7 response.
8 Looking briefly at -- back at Exhibit 3 and
9 -- you don't have to read it yourself.
10 representation that in her view the plea offer
11 was completely unacceptable to the victims. Do you -- do you
12 believe that she was correct in her view that the victims'
13 views should have been solicited before a plea offer was
14 made?
15 A So, I would have to think that was one through.
16 There were concerns -- and I don't know about the timeline
17 about communications with the victims. They're sort of laid
18 out in the affidavit. So, whether or not victims'
19 views were elicited is something I think was the focus of the
20 trial team and not something that I was focused on at least
21 at this time.
22 Q But do you believe as a matter of sort of principle
23 that the views of victims should be elicited before a plea
24 offer --
25 A Right.
1 Q -- is made?
2 A So, as a general matter, yes.
3 Q Okay.
4 A I think that the -- the reason I'm pushing back is
5 because you're saying plea offer, and the CVRA does talk to
6 plea offers as opposed to a situation where deferring
7 prosecution in favor of a state is a very different thing
8 than a plea offer, and at the time, that was not a, it must.
9 That was a depending on the facts and circumstances, that's a
10 judgment call. At least that's how the department, to my
11 understanding, viewed it.
And was it also your view that it would have, as a
13 general matter, it's a better practice or better approach to
14 talk to the victims before?
15 A As a general practice, yes.
16 Q All right. Do you think that would have been
17 particularly important in this case where the proposal
18 involved sending the case back to the state, which the
19 victims were aware had already mishandled the case to begin
20 with?
21 A So, a few -- there are -- there are a few things in
22 that question that I think are packed. Whether the victims
23 were aware and were of the view, from my perspective and my
24 recollection, were of the view that the state had mishandled
25 the case, I can't speak to.
Page 138
Some of the victims were, to my recollection,
2 exonerating him. There was concern that some of the victims
3 were more on his side than on the prosecution's side. And
4 so, that judgement call of which victims are notified and how
5 much I think is something that really is a judgement call
6 that needs to be done almost on a case by case basis by
7 individuals that are aware of sort of the facts and
8 circumstances surrounding each victim.
9 In the general in a general case, you want to
10 have fulsome communication. I can understand in cases where
11 victims might be giving exonerating information, where -- or,
12 there is restitution at stake, that could be different.
13 Q And by the people involved, are you talking at
14 the -- at the trial team level?
15 A At the trial team level with whatever appropriate
16 supervisors
17 Q MM-hram.
18 A -- are engaged in the victim notification issues.
19 Q And in this case, that would not include you, is
20 that correct?
21 A That -- I don't recall cases where I got -- where I
22 became part of the victim notification judgements.
23 BY MS.
24 Q Did you ever issue an instruction to the trial team
25 that they should not consult with the victims before the NPA
Page 139
1 was signed?
2 A So, not that I recall. I know that there's some
3 instances where after the NPA was signed, I said, you know,
4 I'm directing that we withhold notification for five days, or
X period of time to work this out.
6 But before the NPA was signed, I don't recall -- in
7 all candor, I don't recall discussions about victim
8 notification until after the NPA was signed. I don't know if
9 there's e-mail traffic before the NPA was signed, but I don't
10 recall victim notification issues until after the NPA was
11 signed.
12 Q Okay.
13 BY MR.
14 Q And I just -- one more question on this topic is
15 that prior to -- we interviewed other people, obviously, in
16 this --
17 A Mm-hmm.
18 Q -- case, and we interviewed Ms. , and one
19 of the things that she told us, she has a recall of a -- of a
20 meeting with you present, Mr. , and Mr. , where
21 this issue of victim notification was discussed in the
22 timeframe of prior to the FBI, and at that meeting, she was
23 specifically instructed that we are not going to talk about
24 it with the victims. Do you recall that meeting?
25 A I don't -- I don't recall. If that's her
Page 140
1 recollection, that's her recollection. I don't -- I don't
2 recall that. I -- I recall knowing that there were issues
3 around victim notification. I recall, particularly after the
4 NPA was signed, I recall efforts, I believe, to notify as it
5 was being signed -- to notify the victims of the upcoming
6 state plea.
7 Q Mm-hmm.
8 A And I recall discussions -- if not discussions --
9 let me not say discussions -- a general concern about the
10 victim notification, what does that do? Because the victim
11 is also a witness, and a --
12 Q Mm-hmm.
13 A -- potential witness, and in some cases and adverse
14 witness. And so, how does all that balance out?
15 Q Okay. Well, we're going to drill down into
16 those --
17 A Right.
18 post-NPA issues later on.
19 A Right.
20 Q Just now, focusing on --
21 A Right.
22 pre-NPA, before it's signed, when the
23 negotiations are going back and forth.
24 A Right.
25 Q You have memory of this topic coming up?
Page 141
1 A I don't recall discussing the victim notification
2 issues.
3 Q Okay, and what would your response be though to --
4 are you -- are you aware of the CVRA litigation that went on?
A Yes.
Q From Judge Marra?
A Yes.
Q So, one of the issues that comes up in Judge
9 Marra's decision is, he made a finding that the government
10 violated the CVRA because they didn't inform -- consult with
11 the victims --
12 A Right.
13 Q -- prior to signing the NPA, and there is a
14 perception, or he -- from his opinion that the government did
15 this -- failed to communicate that in order to eventually
16 keep the victims in the dark and protect the resolution. Why
17 is that an incorrect assumption?
18 A And so -- so, I would say that sets out her
19 reasoning in her affidavit. She talks about --
20 BY MS.
21 Q Are you referring to the -- her 2017 affidavit?
22 A Her 2017 affidavit. She talks about -- I believe
23 she notified at least some victims, and it became an issue,
24 and there's concern -- you know, you have this NPA.
25 Whether -- whether or not that NPA will ultimately remain is
Page 142
I a very open question, because from our office's expectations,
2 we expected him to plead shortly after that, and he did not.
3 And so, are we going to trial or are we not is a
4 very open question, and I think there is -- has to be
5 discretion, where there is no legal requirement. There has
6 to be discretion to judge how much you can tell the victims
7 and when.
8 BY MR. •
9 Q Okay, just -- just one other point, and this is
10 that -- we've reviewed --
-- Ms. declaration, and the
notifications that she's referring to there, those
discussions take place after the signing of the NPA. So,
we're just talking about here still --
A Right.
Q -- just the pre-NPA --
18 A Yeah.
19 Q -- pre-signing of that. So, does that change your
20 answer at all?
21 A Again, I don't -- I don't recall the victim
22 notification being issued before the NPA. I recall a lot of
23 discussions afterwards. I don't recall. That doesn't mean
24 they didn't happen. That just means I don't recall them.
25 Q Was there any concern with you or among any of the
Page 143
1 other people involved in this negotiation phase that if the
2 victims were to find out that we are negotiating this NPA
3 that it will blow up the NPA, that it will cause us trouble
4 in some way?
5 A Our -- my focus before the NPA was signed was, here
6 are -- here are these terms. You know, and then for the
7 team, go negotiate this. And so, from my perspective, it was
8 much more of a, what are the terms, than the victim
9 notification issues around that.
10 BY MS.
11 Q Right, but just to follow up
12 A Right.
13 Q -- did you hear any discussion amongst the people
14 that you were dealing with --
15 A
16 Q -- that they were afraid that the victims might
17 raise such objections, or go to the press that this whole
18 thing would be -- you know, come to a -- come to a halt?
19 A So, I tried to think -- I don't recall -- I believe
20 we notified the victims in advance of the state hearing so
21 that they would be aware. We didn't notify them before we
22 signed the NPA to my recollection, but we certainly notified
23 them of the state hearing. And so, I was aware generally of
24 what was being done, but the NPA and what we -- you know, the
25 NPA was the focus, not the victim notification --
MS.
THE WITNESS:
MS.
Page 144
: When --
-- part of that.
: -- when you talk about -- go ahead.
4 MR. : We -- we're going to get into the
5 plea --
6 THE WITNESS: Right.
7 MR. : -- and what we're --
8 MS. : All right.
9 THE WITNESS: Right.
10 MR. : -- a little bit later on.
11 THE WITNESS: Right.
12 BY MR.
13 Q Just one -- can I just direct you to --
14 A Yeah.
15 Q -- document number 15?
16 MS. : Exhibit 15?
17 THE WITNESS: Yeah.
18 BY MR.
19 Q Okay. So, do you -- that was an e-mail that is
20 from Ms. to , then forwarded to you?
21 A Yeah.
22 Q Do you see the reference in there where she
23 mentions that she spoke to , or
24 reminded her -- where is it?
25 MS. : It's in the second paragraph --
Page 145
1 THE WITNESS: Yeah, no, I --
2 MS. S : in the middle.
3 THE WITNESS: I see it.
4 MR. : The middle --
5 THE WITNESS: It's highlighted.
6 BY MR.
7 Q Could you just read that? The agents and I have
8 not reached out to the victims to get their approval, which
9 as i politely reminded me, is required under the law. Do
10 you -- do you -- do you recall that e-mail?
11 A I -- again, I don't recall this specific e-mail.
16 and
17 how you interact with -- with victims who are also potential
18 witnesses, and I was aware -- I support what the office did.
19 I'm not backing away from it.
20 I'm just saying I can't, 12 years later,
21 reconstruct what the thought process was other than there was
22 no legal obligation. It was a discretionary issue, and this
23 is how the discretion was exercised.
24 Q But did -- do you remember -- so, there's two
25 things. Any -- do you remember any discussions coming up
My recollection is a view that there is no requirement to
notify, because it's not a plea, it's deferring in favor of a
state prosecution.
And therefore, it becomes a discretionary issue,
what notification is appropriate is really a function of
Page 146
1 about the topic of what we have to do as far as notification
2 in the pre-NPA negotiations?
A I -- again, I really don't. I know there was a lot
of discussion after the NPA. I don't recall pre-NPA
discussions on this.
6 Q Last question on this.
7 A Sure.
8 MS. : By him.
9 THE WITNESS: Yeah.
10 BY MR.
11 Q You're getting at least forwarded to you an e-mail
12 from the trial attorney in the case showing that she is
13 concerned about the notification issue, and she's raising at
14 least the -- referencing the head of --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- CEOS about this issue. Did this ring any bells
17 to you? Raise any --
18 A So, from this, I would infer that a discussion was
19 had as to what the obligations had -- were, and whether we
20 had to or not, because -- so, I think it's fair to infer she
21 is, you know, e-mailing my first assistant.
22 I don't know what the attachment here -- oh, the
23 attachment here is the term sheet, so to speak, and my first
24 assistant is forwarding it to me in large part so that I get
25 the attachment, and I think from here, it's fair to infer
Page 147
1 that -- that some conversation or discussion was had. I
2 don't remember the conversation or discussion.
3 My focus was on the terms. I'm willing to accept
4 that the conversation was had. My recollection of the
5 obligations under the CVRA is that they did not attach,
6 because this was not an indictment, it was not a plea, and
7 that it was entirely discretionary how we proceeded, and
8 therefore how you proceed is a function of, should you notify
9 victims?
10 Yes, but there are concerns because they're also
11 witnesses. There are concerns because we are going out of
12 our way to provide for restitution, and all of that played
13 into a complex calculus.
14 Q That was it.
15 BY MS.
16 Q So, you said that there was a view that there's no
17 requirement to notify the victims. Who was that view coming
18 from?
19 A I can't -- I can't speak to person A, B, or C.
20 can say that if -- if the office thought there was a legal
21 obligation, there are too many professionals involved in this
22 that if they thought there was a legal obligation to notify,
23 they would have done so.
24 At some point in this process, whether it was pre
25 or post, I know that there was some explicit consideration of
Page 148
1 what are the obligations, and some discussion of, this is not
2 the obligations don't attach until indictment, and therefore,
3 this is a discretionary matter.
4 Whether that happened in September or in August or
5 October, I can't speak to. But I know that that was -- that
6 was talked about, and I think later on in the record, there's
7 an e-mail from our appellate chief in a different case that
8 highlights, well, there is this Texas case that just ruled
9 the other way. So, clearly, it's an issue that had been
10 talked about, and I recall it being talked about. I just
11 can't tell you the when, or the with who.
12 Q And would there have been any -- you've spoken on
13 one concern --
14 A Right.
15 Q -- concerning impeachment of the victims regarding
16 their --
17 A Yeah.
18 Q -- financial aspect of the NPA. Would there have
19 been any downside to consulting with the victims concerning,
20 hey, the U.S. Attorney's Office is considering a resolution
21 short of a plea that involves charges in state court. How do
22 you feel about that, victims?
23 A So, there may not have been a downside. It's
24 difficult to recreate. My understanding, going back 12
25 years, was that the victims would be aware of what was
Page 149
1 happening in the state court and have an opportunity to speak
2 up at the state court hearing.
3 Q And where does that -- where does this come from?
4 A So, my understanding is that when he was going to
5 go into state court that they would have been notified that
6 that was an all-encompassing plea, that that state court
7 sentence would also mean that the federal government was not
8 proceeding.
9 Q But again, in terms of --
10 A Before -- your point is before it was signed.
11 Q Correct, so that they could have input --
12 A Right.
13 Q -- into trying, perhaps, if they wanted to, to
14 persuade you that that --
15 A Right.
16 Q -- was not a good idea.
17 A It may have -- it may have been a -- look, looking
18 back on it, it may have been a very good idea. I can't speak
19 to what the thought process was then, other than it was
20 discretionary and it was not legally required.
21 Q But at least as we sit here today, you cannot
22 recall a particular problem that somebody brought up to you
23 and said, we should not consult because of this problem?
24 A I don't recall that, and clearly, given the way
25 it's played out, it may have been much better if we had.
Page 150
BY MS.
2 Q In the last 15 or --
A Right.
4 Q -- 20 minutes, you've several times referred to
discussions and we.
A Right.
7 Q I want to make it clear that so far, the people who
were involved in this case, the Epstein case in your shop
were you, , and If -- is
there anyone else who was involved in those discussions other
than those five?
2 A Not to my recollection at this phase.
13 Q Okay. Okay. I just want to make sure --
14 A Yes.
15 Q -- we understand who you --
lE A Yeah.
Q -- who is encompassed --
8 A Right.
19 Q -- in that general discussion --
2C A Right.
21 Q -- of -- of the matter. Okay. So, on July 26, so,
22 we're now a month after that -- that presentation by the
23 defense counsel to the team, including and
24 A Correct.
2 Q There was a meeting in Miami, and it was, again,
Page 151
1 among by telephone,
2 , as well as the two case agents --
3 A Mm-hmm.
4 and . Did you
5 know them, by the way?
6 A I did not, not to my recollection.
7 Q Okay, and also their supervisor, ? Did
8 you know
9 A Somewhat.
10 Q All right, and they were all in West Palm, of
11 course.
12 A Yeah.
13 Q And then ASAC
14 A Yeah.
15 Q Do you recall her?
16 A Somewhat.
17 Q All right. They arrived -- or, at least, the trial
18 team -- the investigative team arrived ostensibly to discuss
19 the case. It turned out to be a very brief meeting
20 essentially consisting of coming in, announcing
21 that you had decided on a two year state resolution, and then
22 essentially leaving without that is, left the
23 meeting without discussion.
24 This was -- this has been described to us as
25 stunning to the investigative team. They had no idea this
Page 152
1 was coming. This was -- they were completely blindsided.
2 The question is, were you aware that was going
3 to announce that you had decided on this resolution?
4 A So, I don't recall that, but I had decided and
S endorsed this resolution at some point. And so, the fact
6 that I don't recall doesn't mean that -- I wasn't at the
7 meeting, I don't recall. But I clearly had endorsed this
8 resolution, and so --
9 Q Mm-hmm.
10 A -- his announcement would have been consistent with
11 my decision.
12 Q And again, that decision was reached without
13 consultation and discussion with -- and input from the line
14 AUSA. Does that trouble you?
15 A Sitting here today, I wouldn't have said that there
16 was no input from the AUSA. So, to the extent that she felt
17 there was no consultation or input, that would. From my
18 perspective, trying to recreate things from 12 years ago,
19 there had been discussions and consultations, and she had
20 spoken with and and -- and it would have been my
21 guess that views were known and articulated, and there was
22 good communication back and forth.
23 Q But again, that's your expectation of your people,
24 is that correct?
25 A Correct.
Page 153
1 Q Okay. So -- and also, from our interviews, it --
2 there's -- our -- it's our understanding that you popped your
3 head into that meeting and said hello to the folks --
A Okay.
Q -- gathered. Do you have any --
A Again, I --
Q -- recollection of that?
A -- I don't remember the meeting.
Q All right.
10 A I may have -- I may have done that.
Q And it's not --
A Right.
Q -- completely uncharacteristic of you?
A Right.
Q Okay.
A It's not.
Q All right.
A No, because that was an internal meeting. That
19 wasn't --
20 Q Right, or -- correct, as opposed to the --
21 A Right.
22 Q -- scenario we were discussing this morning. Ail
23 right, this deal, and we're not talking about
24 A Right.
25 Q -- the term sheet yet, two major prongs me want to
Page 154
1 talk about. One -- the first one is forgoing federal
2 prosecution, right? Going for a state only disposition, and
3 I talked to you this morning about the five -- sort of the
4 five ways a case could proceed when it comes from the state.
5 You can either decline it and give it back to the state. You
6 can go ahead and indict, but the guy -- let the defendant or
7 defendants go to trial, or plead to the indictment. You can
8 indict, negotiate a deal, although you talked about some of
9 the issues there, and you can also file a complaint and
10 negotiate pre-indictment, or negotiate something.
11 A Right.
12 Q So, why was it that all of those other options were
13 rejected, and the state only deal was settled on?
14 A So, let me -- let me back up a minute, because I
15 think it was a little more -- a little more fluid. The way
16 the matter came to the office was, the state wasn't doing
17 enough.
23 Alternatively, we could look at a pre-indictment
24 resolution, and at various points, the office went back and
25 forth between a federal pre-indictment resolution, and a
It didn't provide for prison time. It didn't
provide for registration, and then you had the restitution
issue. There were legal issues, which I'm sure we'll talk
about. There were witness issues. And -- and we could go to
trial, potentially, and we may or may not prevail.
Page 155
1 state pre-indictment resolution. I think you showed me an
2 exhibit where  said a 371 with the rule 11. There was
3 some discussion of other statutes at some point. I don't
4 recall the timeline.
5 And so ultimately, the focus was as an initial
6 matter, what -- how do we get this to resolution with some
7 flexibility for state versus federal? I think -- not I
8 think. I -- you know, there was a preference for deferring
9 to the state.
10 Q Where does that come from? What --
11 A In part because the legal issues are to some exter.
12 also present in a federal resolution, because that then
13 becomes a precedent for other similarly situated cases.
14 Q Did you want to avoid a precedent?
15 A So, should we talk about the legal issues? Because
16 we we say we keep coming back to the legal issues, but --
17 Q All right. Talk about the legal issues.
18 A So -- so, when I was at civil rights, one of the
19 areas of responsibility that I had was trafficking. I was
20 very supportive. We set up some of the first human
21 trafficking task forces. I thought civil rights really
22 became aggressive. I think III was one of the point
23 people.
24 We brought in to be a point person on
25 human trafficking. One of the background issues that -- that
Page 156
1 informed the time and all those prosecutions and also the
2 development of the trafficking law was, what is the
3 distinction between trafficking and solicitation, and how --
4 and what is the distinction between a truly federal case and
5 a local case?
6 Because there was a lot of concern at the time
7 about federalizing something that is traditionally local.
8 Now, that was 12 years ago, and I think that those concerns
9 are no longer in play today nearly -- and certainly not to
10 the extent that they were 12 years ago.
11 Q This was the state of play at the time you were the
12 AAG for --
13 A At the AAG and afterwards as I was U.S. Attorney to
14 some extent, there was a lot of discussions about
15 federalizing state issues generally, and certainly in the
16 legislative issues that went back and forth, that was -- that
17 was a consideration.
18 Q Wasn't that trend very swift as of -- was it '06
19 when the Adam Walsh Act was enacted?
20 A So -- so, sure. I think we're trending in a
21 certain direction.
22 Q All right.
23 A And I think that trend has continued and
24 accelerated, but these were very -- these were valid, in my
25 opinion, considerations at the time, and one question to be
Page 157
1 considered is, how would a court look at this -- because
2 different judges may look at these statutes differently. And
3 how would a court consider federal nexus issues?
4 And so, that was, to my mind, an important
5 consideration, because this was at the time to some extent
6 uncharted territory, and while we might prevail, and probably
7 would prevail, we may not have, and how is that weighed
8 against a certain plea with registration that would make sure
9 that the public knew that this person was a sex offender?
10 Q Okay, a couple of things. One, did you engage in
11 that -- that discussion, based on your experience, with
12 ? Did -- did you -- did you engage in that kind of
13 conversation?
14 A I don't recall who I may have talked to, but this
15 was -- when -- when -- you will see in the record reference
16 to legal issues. This -- these were the legal issues, at
17 least to my mind, that that's referring to.
18 Q But did you sit -- I mean, not to be silly about
19 it, but --
20 A Right.
21 Q -- did you sit in your office and ponder them, or
22 did you in the context of --
23 A We would have -- we would have discussed them.
24 Q All right, we, being you, and --
25 A I and -- whether it's or or
Page 158
1 wouldn't have sat and pondered them on my own, but we would
2 have had some level of discussion about these.
So, conversely, is it your understanding that --
that those three guys understood from you at least your
perspective on these legal issues?
A I -- let me -- let me push back. Those -- those
7 three professionals, because they are --
8 Q Oh --
9 A Yeah.
10 Q I'm sorry.
A Well, in this context, it's --
12 Q Colleagues, yes.
13 A Yeah. Yeah. So, there were two large buckets of
14 issues. One was the witness issues, and on those, I would
15 have deferred more to folks that are experienced trial
16 prosecutors. The other one are these legal issues.
17 Q Mis-hmm,
18 A And you see it with the fed -- with the reference
19 at the very beginning to the federal nexus --
20 Q Mit-hmm.
21 A -- and you see it throughout where -- these were
22 discussions that we had, and from the very beginning, what is
23 the federal nexus, and how do we make it clear that we are
24 not stepping on something that is a purely local matter,
25 because we don't want bad precedent for the sake of the
Page 159
1 larger human trafficking issue.
2 Q Did you have those conversations with your three
3 subordinate colleagues in this case?
4 A I would have had those conversations with those
5 colleagues. Whether it was with all three, or with two, I
6 can't recall, but I would have had those conversations.
7 Q And do you recall whether anyone -- anyone among
8 them pushed back as, for example, indicated
9 his view of some of those issues?
10 A So -- so, I don't recall specific pushback. I
11 can I can say where we concluded, which is there we are
12 comfortable enough with the law to believe that we are
13 that if we need to go to court, we can do so ethically, and
14 we have a good chance of winning. Because if we could not go
15 forward --
16 Q Of course.
17 A Then -- then we just can't go forward, right? No
18 matter what outcome you want. Was it a slam dunk? Was there
19 some legal risk? Yes, there was some legal risk.
20 Q Mr. Acosta, you use the term a roll of the dice in
21 your press conference.
22 A Yes.
23 Q In -- there's a different -- I mean, at one end,
24 you have a slam dunk. I would submit that no criminal
25 prosecution --
Page 160
1 A Right.
2 Q -- is a slam dunk.
3 A Correct.
4 Q Likewise, I would ask you to comment on whether any
5 prosecution is really a roll of the dice, given that a
6 prosecuting authority, in this case, the U.S. Attorney's
7 Office, will have always done investigation, persuaded at
8 least a majority of grand jurors to -- that they -- that
9 there is sufficient proof to bring an indictment --
10 A Right.
11 Q and so on. Do you -- do you -- would you still
12 hang your hat on a roll of the dice hook?
13 A So, I don't know if I would use that exact phrase.
14 Q All right.
15 A But let me -- let me just say, because you --
16 prodding grand jurors. From our perspective, sitting in the
17 office in 2006 and 2007, this is a case that someone comes to
18 you and says, this has been presented, we have no reason to
19 believe the state attorney acted -- we're not happy with what
20 they did, but we have no reason to believe that there was
21 funny business.
22 Q Misconduct?
23 A Misconduct.
24 Q All right.
25 A And let's assume that there is no misconduct,
Page 161
1 because you don't want to assume that again still. So, the
2 state attorney took this, reviewed it, presented it to a
3 grand jury, and the grand jury came out with this kind of
4 recommendation. That at least is indicative of some -- some
5 other authority looking at this and making a judgement as to
6 what it looks like.
7 Q Are you aware that at least at the investigative
8 and line assistant level, there was -- they had understanding
9 and reason to believe that the state prosecutors had put in
10 witnesses into their grand jury and set about impeaching
11 them? I'm not --
12 A Right.
13 Q -- suggesting that this is misconduct, but it's a
14 way of approaching evidence before a grand jury, and if they
15 did that, it would be perhaps charitably for the purpose of
16 making it abundantly clear to the grand jurors how the
17 witness would fair --
18 A Right.
19 Q -- or not fair under aggressive cross-examination
20 at a trial and so on.
21 A Right.
22 Q So, were you aware of that at the time?
23 A I was not.
24 Q You were not.
25 A Right.
Page 162
1 Q You were not aware that that was an actual concern
2 and understanding --
3 A That -- that there was --
4 Q -- by your team?
A That there was a concern that they basically --
6  Tanked the case.
7 A Tanked.
8 Q Yes.
9 A So, there was -- I --
10 Q You -- I just --
11 A
12 Q You didn't know that?
13 A I was aware of a concern about how the state
14 attorney -- how aggressive they were.
15 Q Right.
16 A There's a -- there's a distance between how
17 aggressive they were versus tanking a case.
18 Q Right, but I am telling you the concern by your
19 people at the ground level
20 A Right.
21 Q -- was the latter.
22 A Understood.
23 Q Okay.
24 A Aware of lack of aggression, tanking the case, very
25 specifically, I mean, there might have been, hey, you know,
Page 16 -:
1 is there -- this looks really odd, but you've given a level
2 of granularity as to highly unusual conduct. So, my point,
3 there is at least a perspective coming out of the state.
4 There are legal concerns.
5 We believed -- at the end of the day, I thought we
6 would prevail, but they're valid, and then you overlay that
7 with witness concerns, and concerns as to how juries, which
8 were different in 2006 on these issues.
9 Q What do you base that on, by the way?
10 A It's --
11 Q Because you're not a trial attorney anymore.
A So, experience with how juries in South Florida
3 looked at these matters, and with how South Florida looked a-.
the project Safe Neighborhood -- I'm sorry, --
It's childhood.
16 A Project Safe Childhood run initiative generally,
17 and so there had been -- there had been prior instances where
18 we had talked about this, and we had gotten some pushback.
19 Q From --
20 A From within the office, from within the FBI.
21 Q On what?
22 A On -- on sort of sex cases more generally.
23 Q And pushback in what regard?
24 A Where should we put our resources? And so, there
25 was -- there was just a general -- just general pushback.
Page 164
1 Q Okay, but there are a couple things there. One is,
2 the juries -- the juries -- the petite juries, and
3 which --
4 A Right.
-- you -- I'd still like the answer on.
6 A Yeah.
7 Q And then the other is the FBI being loath to muck
8 around with these cases that they were not --
9 A Yeah.
10 Q -- yet --
11 A So --
12 Q -- engaged with.
13 A So, let's -- let's take them one at a time, you
14 know, and -- and in all candor, I think we're looking at this
15 through a 2019 lens. You know, at the time, and I've said
16 this in different forms, but you know, Weinstein was known
17 and about, and actions weren't taken, and Bill Cosby was
18 known about. And they're each -- go with me. They're each
19 different --
20 Q All right.
21 A -- but I do think the public looked at these cases
22 differently in 2006, and there are at least some
23 individuals -- I'm not saying it was the right view -- but
24 there are at least some individuals who would have looked and
25 said, this is a solicitation case, not a trafficking case.
Page 165
1 Q All right. Who in your office who in the U.S.
2 Attorney's Office ever said that?
3 A So, this was -- this came up in the context of, how
4 would the victims do in court? And it wasn't just, you know,
5 how will they be impeached, but how will jurors look at the
6 fact patterns around this generally?
7 Q And who was -- who was talking --
8 A I can't --
9 Q about that?
10 A I can't say. I know that it was discussed. I
11 can't say A, B, C, or D. I
12 Q Well, it wouldn't have been D, because it would --
13 D would be , and I think you would agree with
14 me that she would not --
15 A I would agree --
16 Q -- concede that.
17 A I would agree with you.
18 Q All right.
19 A With that, but my point is that when we're
20 talking -- so, when you're looking at victims in court today,
21 I think it's fair to say that the way we approach -- there's
22 been -- you know, there's been a lot of changes in victim
23 shaming, and the degree to which all of that is permitted.
24 The degree to which I think the public understands
25 that -- that girls, minor females, may be scared and may
Page 166
1 testify differently. And I'm suggesting that it's important
2 to sort of think back to 2006 and understand that these
3 issues may have been viewed differently.
4 Q You -- you're -- you have not -- since leaving the
5 U.S. Attorney's Office -- been engaged in the investigation
6 and prosecution or handling in any respect of child sex
7 crimes, is that correct?
A That is correct.
Q So, on what do you base this -- is it -- is it a --
10 your cultural observation? Your perspective on the evolution
11 of popular culture, not in a derogatory way, that leads you
12 to that assessment?
13 A So, on a few -- certainly the law has changed, and
14 the law has become much more aggressive. So, for example, I
15 believe the law on proof of age has changed where proof of
16 age is no longer required.
17 Q The law has, but the case law even at this time was
18 already --
19 A What was --
20 Q -- reasonably clear on that.
21 A Was reasonably clear, and certainly moving in that
22 direction.
23 Q Correct. Wouldn't you have wanted to be at the
24 forefront of this?
25 A So, I believe I was at the forefront of trafficking
Page 167
1 issues, and I think if you were to look at my civil rights
2 record, I really was at the forefront of trafficking issues.
3 Q Even the U.S. Attorney's Office had a very robust,
4 as we discern it now, a very robust initiative. It maybe
5 wasn't a formal initiative, but commitment to prosecute these
6 cases.
7 A Correct, and -- and I fully supported that. All
8 the more reason why, if there is an issue, and there is a
9 potential for some judge, rightly or wrongly, whether I agree
10 or not -- because you can't always predict -- even though you
11 think you'll prevail, you can't always predict where holdings
12 go. To --
13 Q Are you talking about on appeal?
14 A On appeal or in trial to
15 Q Right.
16 A -- to issue a negative precedent on travel for
17 purpose of, or on federal nexus, and if you think back at the
18 time, on appear, there were -- there's a lot of case law on
19 commerce clause and federal nexus.
20 Q Right.
21 A And so, I think that that is an important and valid
22 factor that goes into the decision making that assesses the
23 risk of trial, not just from the -- this -- you know, how the
24 victims will testify in this particular case, but also what
25 this means to the greater -- to the greater effort.
Page 168
1 Q I understand that completely. What I -- what I am
2 not hearing is where a voice other than you and your team in
3 this case was being heard, like Did --
4 did you --
5 A And --
6 Q -- talk to him about these issues? Because --
7 A Not --
8 Q -- CEOS --
9 A Not to --
10 Q -- was at the forefront of --
11 A Not to my recollection.
12 Q All right. Wouldn't --
13 MR. TODD: Let finish her questions.
14 THE WITNESS: Okay. Sorry. Sorry.
15 MS. : We're all --
16 THE WITNESS: I apologize.
17 MS. : We're on a mutual role here.
18 THE WITNESS: Okay.
19 BY MS.
20 Q But wouldn't -- if you'd had those concerns,
21 perfectly well founded, why not reach out and engage with
22 CEOS and see what their assessment was about the
23 vulnerability that this case might expose your office to?
24 A So, I can't reconstruct that 12 years later. You
25 know, one interesting question is would CEOS have come to
Page 169
1 mind versus civil rights crim, because coming from civil
2 rights crim, I -- you know, my primary trafficking contacts
3 would have been --
4 Q Did you pick up the phone and --
5 A Not --
6 Q -- call them?
7 A Not to my recollection.
8 Q So, I guess what I'm -- what I'm getting at is you,
9 based on substantial experience and a commitment to these
10 cases in your office -- the U.S. Attorney's Office -- had
11 formed your own analytical analysis -- your own analysis
12 legally.
13 You've told us you've discussed this or made those
14 issues and concerns known to the people who were below you,
15 at least immediately below you, and that it -- that's where
16 it sort of rested. There was not an effort to go out and
17 enhance or add to your understanding of the case, and legal
18 issues.
19 A So, to my recollection, I don't recall, and it's --
20 we'll get into perhaps -- you know, I -- from my impression,
21 I actually thought I was being more aggressive than main
22 justice would feel comfortable with, and --
23 Q More aggressive in what respect?
24 A In my interpretation and how comfortable I was
25 going forward than main justice, and we can get into that,
Page 170
1 but I thought I was being more aggressive, not less, and so I
2 had these concerns. I did not vet them at main justice.
3 Q Okay. When you said more -- more aggressive, are
4 you talking about the fact that you crafted this state
5 disposition, or that you were more forward leaning on the
6 potential of prosecuting Epstein federally?
7 A More forward leaning.
8 Q And yet you didn't. You didn't -- you didn't lean
9 sufficiently far forward to actually pull the trigger and
10 have an indictment returned.
11 A So, I would push back on that, and that from my
12 perspective, we were leaning forward, because we did
13 prosecute him by deferring to the state, and ensuring that at
14 the state --
15 Q All right.
16 A -- he had a sentence that he -- where he went to
17 jail.
18 Q All right. Okay. I want to sort of move on. I
19 want to ask you a question about 11C1C, please, that you
20 mentioned earlier.
21 A Okay.
22 Q And sort of alluded to here, when we --
23 A Right.
24 Q -- talked about judges, and we talked about
25 dismissing charges from an indictment. Was your -- what was
Page 171
1 your position as U.S. Attorney with regard to the binding
2 pleas in an 11C1C plea agreement?
3 A We used them very rarely.
4 Q But why?
5 A As a typical matter, judges did not like them.
6 Q And -- and was that something that as U.S.
7 Attorney, you engaged with the judges on, or was that simply
8 a matter of seeing what they did with them?
9 A It -- it happened before I got there. I suspect it
10 continued to happen after I left.
11 Q All right. Okay. That said, were there some
12 occasions in which the office, if you recall at all, did do
13 11C1C --
14 A There --
15 Q -- plea agreements?
16 A -- may have been. I don't recall.
17 Q Okay. All right.
18 MR. : And , before we move onto --
19 MS. : Yes.
20 MR. -- another issue, can I --
21 MS. : Yeah. I'm --
22 MR. : -- go back a second --
23 MS. -- still with federal -- I'm still
24 on the federal prosecution, but go ahead.
1 25 BY MR.
=,=3e,
1 Q We had talked about the -- you talked about the
2 state grand jury, and how their decision informed your
3 decision, and you said, well, what state grand jury did with
4 this. What was your understanding of what this was? Like,
5 what exactly the state grand jury looked at?
6 A So, so, let me back up. I said it was a factor
7 that informed, not just --
Q I understand.
A -- determined. So, my understanding is that at
10 least some core amount of facts were presented, and I
11 understand that since it was at the state, the FBI may have
12 found additional witnesses, but when it was presented, the
13 very reason the office took it in the first place was because
14 it was presented to the state, and it went to a grand jury,
15 and the recommendation from the grand jury was for a -- you
16 know, a statute that would not require jail time, and that
17 seemed wrong.
18 But the very fact that it was presented to a grand
19 jury certainly was one of several factors that we considered,
20 because it at least indicated some level of how individual
21 jurors may view this.
Q Do you have any recollection that the state grand
23 jury presented a single witness, who, as talked about
24 earlier, that they impeached?
2i have -- I have read that it was a single witness.
Page 173
1 Since then, I don't have an independent recollection of that.
2 Q Okay.
3 BY MS.
4 Q And were you -- how familiar were you with Florida
5 state criminal procedure?
12 Florida bar.
13 A Correct.
14 Q Correct. So, really any knowledge you had would
15 have sort of been picked up?
16 A I should -- I should point out that a number of
17 AUSAs in Florida are not a member of the Florida bar, so
18 that's not unusual.
19 Q Oh, okay. No -- I'm not -- I'm not --
20 A Right.
21 Q -- suggesting --
22 A Right.
23 Q -- otherwise.
24 A And in federal employment, you can move from
A It depends what -- what area.
Q Well, you never practiced there, right?
A Correct.
Q I forget what law school you went to.
A Not Florida.
Q Not in Florida, and you were not a member of the
25 Q Right.
Page 174
1 A Yeah. So, I had been U.S. Attorney for quite a
2 while, and then I -- you know, I think we would have been
3 interacting with the state system sufficiently, and if there
4 was something that I had questions on, I could certainly ask.
5 Q Were you aware that in the Florida system, grand
6 juries ware not required to be used to bring federal criminal
7 charges except in capital cases?
A Yes.
Q Okay, so even bringing a case to a grand jury was
10 an -- in a non-capital context, was somewhat unusual?
11 A An indication that there were some concerns or
12 something, so the state attorney, presenting it in the best
13 possible light, is looking to test the case.
14 Q All right, and without getting into any substance,
15 did you at any point become aware of the kind of reaction
16 that the line AUSA, , was getting from the
17 federal grand jurors to whom she was presenting?
18 A I did not.
19 Q All right. Another aspect of concern that I think
20 you mentioned in your press conference was the concern about
21 labelling or putting the girls -- the girls -- the victims in
22 a position where they would be labelled as prostitutes,
23 right? Do you recall --
24 A I'm not sure --
25 Q -- mentioning that?
Page 175
1 A -- I phrased it that way, but I -- I take -- I take
2 your --
3 Q We'll defer to the record.
4 A Right.
5 Q But -- but you did -- you did express concern, and
6 our understanding is there was some expression of concern in
7 the U.S. Attorney's Office among the folks about the victims
8 having to self -identify, or --
9 A Right.
10 Q -- admit that they were sort of prostitutes. The
11 disposition that was reached in the state -- and that -- and
12 that -- avoiding that was something to be desired --
13 A Yes.
14 Q -- right?
15 A Yes.
16 Q The charge to which Epstein was ultimately require
17 to plead guilty did just that. It was a solicitation to
18 prostitution of minors. Was that -- did that factor in at
19 all as a -- as a -- as an issue of -- that -- that was not
20 being addressed at all --
21 A Right.
22 Q -- by the state disposition?
23 A So, I -- I was aware of and signed off on this
24 three point
25 Q The term sheet?
Page 176
1 A -- it's in here somewhere -- term sheet. In terms
2 of the negotiation over which state statute was used, and
3 which victims, that is something that -- that -- to my
4 understanding, was being handled by Ms. , and from
5 my perspective, she would certainly have had sensitivity to
6 that.
7 Q And do you have any idea how that three -- those
8 three counts or charges were reduced to simply one?
9 A I do not. That would be a function of the course
10 of the negotiations.
11 Q Why was -- why wasn't any reasoning for this
12 disposition -- deferring to the state -- set forth in
13 writing? Why didn't anyone do a memo explaining what your
14 reasoning was, or what the office's reasoning was?
15 A I can't speak to that directly, but I can say that
16 it would have been unusual. I don't recall other cases where
17 there was a, this is the reason for our disposition type
18 memo. At least not memos that came to me.
19 Q Okay. I'm showing you two, and the caption is --
20 is all that's relevant here, but there are two memos that are
21 both dated February 2006, and March 2006. One of them is in
22 fact addressed to you from , and it attaches a
23 memo, which is a require for pretrial diversion to resolve
24 case against an individual named Ronald Sasse, S-a-s-s-e.
25 And it is a child pornography possession case in
Page 177
1 which the conclusion was that the defendant merely possessed
2 it, and that it was a case that should be resolved by
3 pretrial diversion, and I'm just only bringing that to your
4 attention --
5  Right.
6 Q -- as well as this second one that I'll show you,
7 to show you that there are cases involving, you know, child
8 sex crimes, where it's -- the office did see fit to set forth
9 its analysis and reasoning for the proposed result.
10 The second document, dated February 15, 2006, is a
11 memo, not to you, but to in his capacity as chief
12 of the criminal division, and it requests authorization to
13 enter into a plea agreement with a five year cap, and it --
14 it is a C1C plea, and the handwritten notes indicate that the
15 supervisors concurred in it. Again, I'm simply suggesting
16 that there -- that there are at least some examples where the
17 office, you know, in these kinds of cases --
18 A Right.
20 A So --
21 Q -- put it to paper.
22 A So, I can only speculate.
23 Q mm-hmm.
24 A And questions I would have is, to what extent was
25 this put on paper, because it was a case that or others
Page 17E
1 were not involved with. So, this was the way that in this
2 case, the chief of the -- you know, the economic crimes, or
3 in this case, you know, at is chief of the criminal
4 division, we're communicating information rather than walking
5 in and having a discussion.
6 We're just communicating it on paper as a way to
7 obviate a discussion. In this particular case, there were --
8 there was discussion, there was communication, and so a memo
9 to sort of establish -- in other words, is this a required
10 approval memo, or is this a memo that says, in lieu of
11 getting together, where are the facts, let me know what you
12 think.
13 Q All right, and was there not a practice, or even a
14 requirement in the office that plea dispositions should be
15 memorialized in writing in -- in -- with the rationale?
4 A So, to the extent that a line attorney might be
17 seeking permission from a supervisor --
18 Q Mm-hmm.
19 A -- on a plea disposition, I would think that they
20 would communicate that in writing as the cleanest, most
21 typical way when you've got 20 or 30 line attorneys and one
22 supervisor. That is not necessarily the only way, and
23 certainly as U.S. Attorney, I don't recall a -- you know, a
24 practice of memorializing to me what plea dispositions would
25 be.
Page 179
1 Q Okay, and in this case, you were involved in the
2 case, right?
3 A And in this case, I was involved, and so to be
4 clear, I'm not -- I -- I'm not saying that I disagreed with
5 this, and I'm not walking away with it. And so, to the
6 extent that I may have in a meeting said this looks good,
7 that may have obviated a need to --
8 Q All right.
9 A -- write that up.
10 Q Okay. Thank you. Another aspect of the state
11 resolution that raises concern -- and it -- and let me make
12 clear that -- that many of our questions are framed in this
13 way, but we are also reflecting a concern that's been
14 expressed in the press, and in the public, and by others.
15 A I understand. Understood.
16 Q So --
17 A Understood.
18 Q -- we're sort of coming through that lens. So,
19 another aspect of the state resolution that raises concern
20 is, doesn't it appear that the -- that by going -- sending
21 this matter back to the state, there's more federal
22 interference, more federal involvement in the state process
23 than there would have been if you had just kept the case?
24 A So in hindsight, one of the issues I think in this
25 case is after the agreement, and you know, we keep calling it
Page 180
1 a non-prosecution agreement, and I kept saying call it an
2 agreement to defer in favor of state prosecution.
3 Q A DPA instead of an NPA?
4 A Right.
5 Q Why wasn't it called a DPA, by the way?
6 A I don't know. There's one e-mail where I suggested
7 putting in reference to petite policy.
8 Q Right.
9 A And said, looks strange, take it out.
10 There's another e-mail in the record where I keep saying --
11 everyone keeps calling it an NPA, call it a deferred to
12 state. So, I can't -- you know, I can't say why not, but
13 it's an important distinction.
14 Q But if you had said -- it -- I don't want to go --
15 A Yeah.
16 Q to far afield, but if you had said, uh-uh, call
17 it, no, call it a deferred prosecution
18 A Right.
19 Q -- agreement, they would have changed it, right?
20 A They would have, and I -- I actually asked that we
21 have a clause based -- I don't have the independent
22 recollection of this, but based on the record that we include
23 a clause saying that we were doing this in light of the
24 petite policy to defer, and pushes back and says,
25 I haven't seen that, and he's the local expert, so I deferred
Page 181
1 to him. I take responsibility, but it's an important
2 distinction. And so -- I'm sorry, I just lost track of your
3 question.
4 Q We were talking about, doesn't this involve more
5 federal interference?
6 A Could I -- could I grab a Red Bull from you that I
7 bought?
11 break?

MR. HERRON: Yeah.
THE WITNESS: Sorry, just a --
MS. : Do you want to take a five minute
THE WITNESS: Would you mind?

MS. : Not at all.
14 THE WITNESS: Yeah.
15 MS. : Call it, please, at any time.
16 THE WITNESS: Let me grab the Red Bull.
MS. : Off the record.
(Off the record.)
BY MS.
All right. Thank you. All right. Back on the
21 record. So, Mr. Acosta, I was asking you about -- didn't
22 this -- didn't this resolution end up injecting the feds into
23 the state business in a pretty aggressive way?
24 A And -- and so what I was saying is in hindsight,
25 one of the -- one of the issues here is I think this would
Page 182
1 have gone very differently if after the agreement to defer in
2 favor of state prosecution, all the victims knew about this,
3 they had gone into state court, he had pled October --
4 whatever the date was -- had been sentenced, had served his
5 sentence, and case over.
6 And so, one -- you know, to the extent there are
7 lessons learned, an attempt to provide a -- an attempt to
8 backstop the state here, rebounded, because in the process,
9 it got convoluted, and complex, and ended up being arguably
10 more intrusive than it would have had this just been, here is
11 what we'll do, go back to the -- if you go back to the state
12 and work this out, but --
13 Q Would that have required or depended on cooperation
14 from the state authorities?
15 A So, I think I was clear, and my recollection is
16 this was an issue where I said it is up to you, and one of
17 the -- I edited a few parts of this. I got involved
18 selectively.
19 Q Exhibit 21b is --
20 A Oh.
21 Q -- your edits.
22 A Okay. So, let's -- before I say I think, let's go
2.3 to --
24 Q But --
25 A -- 21.
Page 183
1 Q But before me talk about 21b, as a general matter,
2 you talked earlier about the more -- the sort of more
3 typical, usual way in which the U.S. Attorney's Office and
4 local authorities prosecutive authorities would work, and
5 that is cooperatively, and would decide who gets what, and --
6  Right.
7 Q -- who has what responsibilities. Here, there was
8 not such cooperation, apparently.
9 A There wasn't, and I was going to say, to my
10 recollection, we can look at whether it's in 21b or not, one
11 of my edits was make it clear that it's up to him to figure
12 this out with the state attorney, because we as federal
13 prosecutors are not going to walk in and dictate to the state
14 attorney.
15 Q But in affect, you did.
16 A
17 Q By -- you did -- you did it through Epstein.
18 A I understand. And so, in an attempt to -- in
19 an attempt to reach a resolution, particularly as convoluted
20 as this got, I do think a lesson learned is that it ended up
21 perhaps being worse that if we would not have in the first
22 place.
23 Something -- I -- we, my team, we very much thought
24 that it was important that he go to jail. That it was
25 important that he register. How we got to that ending is
Page 184
unusual, and as an attempt to factor in, here are all the
2 issues around the federal statutes, the concerns about
3 trafficking law, here are the victim issues as to trial, and
4 how -- you know, here is -- here are all these things. And
5 so, on the one hand, deferring to state to the state,
6 appears -- appears logical.
7 On the other hand, the way it played out was a lot
8 more confrontational with the state than I would have hoped,
9 particularly because rather than go back to the state and
10 work it out, in the collateral -- subsequent collateral
11 attacks, they almost tried to state to circumvent and to --
12 you know, to get the state to circumvent and undermine our
13 agreement.
And that was -- when you say they, you mean the
defense team?
So, you could have -- you could have obviated that
18 whole thing if you had just offered the same result, which
17 would be a plea to a criminal charge with, for sake of
2C argument, a two-year cap, which would have required a C1C
plea.
22 A Right.
23 Q And you'd get your restitution, because federal law
24 requires it. They would have been able to proceed under 18
25 USC 22.55 anyway, and he would have gone to jail and been
Page 165
1 registered as a sex offender. All just within the normal
2 course of doing business as the U.S. Attorney's Office. Why
3 not pursue that? Who was -- who was calling the shots that
4 said, yeah, we'll do it, but it's got to be with the state?
5 Was that the defense?
6 A So, something that -- that wasn't the defense.
7 Something that I think is important to sort of lay out here,
8 is the -- the -- sort of the terms sheet was developed really
9 early in the case.
10 Q Excuse me, it's dated, it's presented to the team
11 by on the 31st of July. Do you consider that
12 early?
13 A So, from -- let me -- let me clarify from my
14 perspective. It was developed and approved by me before I
15 became involved with interactions with the defense team.
16 Q In the sense that you only met with the defense
17 team for the first time in the person of Ken Starr and Jay
18 Lefkowitz and company on the 7th of September.
19 A And it wasn't the 7th of -- yeah, the 7th of --
20 Q The 7th of September.
21 A -- September.
22 Q 2007.
23 A And that is important, because it goes to -- there
24 is a lot of buzz in the media, did they influence this
25 outcome? To my recollection, they may not even have been
Page 186
1 attorneys of record in this case, and I don't know when they
came onto the case.
3 Q Well, there's an e-mail in the package that
4 indicates that you got a call from K and E
A Right.
Q -- on -- on or about the 6th of August.
A After the terms sheet was --
Q Correct.
A -- presented, and so I say that because we can --
10 we can -- and probably will talk about whether those terms
11 were the best judgement or not, but once those terms were
agreed and approved, with the exception of the 24 to 18 as a
13 material, and then we can talk about how that happened, we
14 stuck, and I backed the office, and I backed in her
15 negotiations on those. And so, I just -- I think that's
16 important to note.
17 Q I understand. I -- that's not, for the moment, the
18 focus.
19 A Fair.
20 Q It's the terms themselves, and in this case, the
21 state court disposition, everything that you wanted to get
22 with the state court disposition, you could have gotten with
23 a federal plea --
24 A We --
Q -- much more easily.
Page 18-
1 A We could have, and there was certainly some
2 consideration of a 371, and that may be -- you know, in
3 retrospect, it would have obviated a lot of issues.
4 Q So, who said no, that's not --
5 A So --
6 Q -- acceptable?
7 A So, there is e-mails that at the time spoke to
8 me about it. I don't recall, but I'll take responsibility
9 for -- for favoring -- or, not for favoring, but if that's --
10 if that's what happened, I will take responsibility. From my
11 perspective, and my recollection, there are two -- two
12 factors here.
13 Well, I don't know if it's two factors, but at
14 least two factors. One, concerns about how this interacts
15 with federal law, and what precedents this might mean for
16 other trafficking cases. Two, a southern district's general
17 dislike for rule 11, and -- and then third, there were other
18 federal statutes that were considered at various points, and
19 I remember looking at those and saying, yeah, I don't -- it
20 doesn't quite -- it doesn't quite fit.
21 Q To -- just to be clear, that process of looking for
22 the square peg that --
23 A
24 Q -- would fit into the round hole of -- of the two
25 years that had been committed to was a process that came
Page 188
1 before the NPA was actually negotiated, at a time when
2 was working with defense counsel to see if there
3 was a federal charges that could be within the two year --
4  Correct.
5 Q -- scope that would allow Jeffery Epstein to serve
6 his time in a federal facility, rather than in a state
7 facility. Is that --
A That --
Q -- is that correct?
A -- iS correct.
Q Okay.
A And I recall -- I recall at least one of those
13 ideas, and I recall that my general reaction to it was, we're
14 pushing the law that just looks odd, and we don't want to go
15 there.
16 Q Are you talking the assault on an airplane, or the
17 obstruction of a witness, or --
18 A I actually -- my recollection is not about the
19 assault on the airplane --
20 Q Okay.
21 A -- but about his home being a special maritime
22 jurisdiction.
23 Q Oh.
24 A Which is -- no.
25 Q Definitely square peg in round hole.
Page 189
1 A Right.
2 Q Correct? But there were -- so, I guess it -- is
3 it -- is it -- is it accurate that from your standpoint, an
4 11C1C federal disposition was not going to be acceptable?
5 That that's not something that you would approve?
6 A It would have been unusual, I don't recall with
7 specificity, but I can -- based on circumstances, infer that
8 it would have been unusual, and -- and I would have looked at
9 it and said this isn't -- this isn't typical. I'm not
10 comfortable.
11 Q So, why not -- why not offer the five year hit, and
12 say that's it?
13 A I wish I could speculate. I mean, I could sit here
14 and speculate after the fact. I can speak to what I recall.
15 I can speak to what I approved. I can speak to the
16 considerations that went into it. There are all sorts of
17 things that in hindsight we may or may not have done, which
18 may have worked out well or not. I -- I can't answer that.
19 Q So, I guess -- I guess the -- sort of the big
20 unanswered as yet question is, why was there a fixation on
21 the two years when that's not something that comported with
22 anything that was possible in the federal scheme?
23 A So, speaking to the two years, I don't remember
24 with specificity. I -- let me give you my general
25 recollection --
Met-hum.
2 A -- and then let me speculate.
3 Q Mel-hmm.
4 A My general recollection is that there were earlier
5 charges, you all may know those in more detail than I do, but
6 there were earlier state charges that were brought.
Q That were brought?
A That -- I'm sorry, not that were brought, that were
9 contemplated.
10 Q Of which there is no public record?
11 A There is -- I don't know if there's public record
12 or not. I can just say my recollection is that there were
13 earlier state charges that were contemplated. The state
14 attorney chose to not pursue those earlier state charges and
15 take it to a grand jury.
16 From public information, my understanding is that
7 that's why Chief became upset. My general
18 recollection is that the two years represented what he would
19 have received if the original recommendation, or the original
20 view of the state attorney's office had gone through, and it
21 hadn't been brought to the grand jury, and I would -- I would
22 sort of point to -- you know, in this Exhibit 3 -- I thought
23 it was in Exhibit 3.
24 Somewhere, there's a reference to -- as you can see
25 it -- Exhibit 3, page three, as you and the agents conceded,
Page 191
1 had Epstein been convicted of a felony that resulted in a
2 jail sentence and sex offender status, neither the FBI nor
3 our office would have interceded.
4 Q But that is completely silent as to what those
5 original charges may have been, or --
6 A
7 Q -- how they related to --
8 A I understand.
9 Q Okay.
10 A And so, so, to just close the loop, my
11 understanding is that those two years reflected what that
12 would have been such that the case would not have come to
13 federal authorities in the first place.
14 Q Okay. Where did that information come from? Who
15 said, oh, those charges would have resulted in a two year
16 sentence? Was that something that was analyzed by your
17 office, or did it come from defense counsel, or --
18 A
19 Q -- from who?
20 A I can't -- I can't speculate. It had to come from
21 someone.
22 Q It did not come from you, is that correct?
23 A So, I would not have the knowledge to know what
24 that charge would have resulted. As an initial matter, a
25 penalty that says up to blank years is rarely that number of
Page 192
1 years, right?
2 Q Right.
3 A By the time you apply guidelines and all that, and
4 so I would not have the knowledge to know how to calculate
5 that state sentence.
6 Q And in fact were you aware that Florida did have
its own state guidelines -- sentencing guidelines?
8 A Generally, I -- I know that --
9 Q Right.
A -- there is a process.
11 Q Right.
12 A Might I at some point have said, you know, Mr. or
13 Ms. AUSA, or management team member, if this had been done
14 the right way in the state, what would he have gotten, and
15 someone comes back to me, possibly, maybe someone at some
16 point had said, look, this would never have come to us if it
17 was done the right way in the state, and this was the term
18 that he would've gotten.
19 At some point in this process, my general
20 understanding is we got to that two years based on not
21 random, but based on, this was the calculation that he would
22 have received.
23 Q Right, and to make sure we understand, is that your
24 actual recollection, or is it your belief based on what you
2. know happened that that's the way it --
Page 193
1 A So --
2 Q -- happened?
3 A So, it is my recollection of my understanding,
4 which is convoluted, so let me --
5 Q yeah.
6 A /t is how I recall viewing the term sheet when I
7 approved it.
8 Q Okay.
9 A How it got into -- and so, if we got to the term
10 sheet --
11 Q It's 21 -- no, it's not.
12 A It's -- it's one of these exhibits.
13 MR. 15.
14 BY MS.
15 Q Thank you, 15.
16 A 15. So, if we go to the terms sheet, Epstein
17 pleads guilty -- contender to an information follow
18 charging him with -- these particular statutes are -- I am
19 not familiar with, but I would have assumed that either
20 or someone else would have selected them appropriately. It
21 makes a binding recommendation to serve at least two years in
22 prison.
23 Q Let me back up if I could. Those three statutes,
24 did you understand those three statutes to be the three
25 statutes that -- or, to be the statutes that the state
Page 194
1 originally was going to bring?
A I can't speak to that.
Q You don't know.
A I don't know.
Q So, you don't know what the statutes were?
A Yeah.
Q Okay.
A Yeah. You know, it makes a joint binding
9 recommendation at least two years in prison My -- my
10 understanding, my recollection of my understanding, when I
11 reviewed these terms, is that that reflected what he would
12 have received if he had -- if the state had gone through with
13 an initial -- with an initial charge, and from our
14 perspective at the time, that would have obviated the need in
15 the first place to have engaged federal authorities. Agree
16 or disagree with the logic, I'm trying to explain the logic.
17 Q Mm-hmm. No, I understand. Thank you for that
18 clarification. Is it -- you posited a couple of
19 possibilities that you might have said, you know, gee, what
20 would --
21 A Right.
22 Q -- he be looking at if --
23 A Right.
24 Q -- the state had done what it originally set out to
25 do or was supposed to do. Is it -- how also likely is it
Page 195
1 that someone came to you, one of your people, and said, hey,
2 I suggest we go with two years, because the same reason.
3 A It's --
4 Q In other words, it came from --
5 A Right.
6 Q -- somebody else to you, and you agreed.
7 A So, it's very difficult to reconstruct this in
8 retrospect, in part because I don't want to leave the
9 impression that there was one meeting where this was
10 discussed --
11 Q MM-hmm.
12 A -- as opposed to, you've got -- you're sitting
13 across the hall from someone, you're sitting down the hall
14 from someone. There are ongoing discussions, how do we
15 resolve a matter that has some thorny legal questions, some
16 difficult victim witness questions, and this is the kind of
17 back and forth where I might have indicated a concern,
18 someone was trying to address that concern, or I might have
19 asked the question. It -- it's --
20 Q Well, you've already told us that you did express
21 concern --
22 A Right.
23 Q -- about the case, and somebody -- and you were
24 having conversations with
25 correct?
, possibly
Page 196
1 A Correct.
2 Q And is it possible does it -- is it reasonable
3 that one of them might have come up with a solution for you
4 to your problems?
5 A And that's the point that I'm --
6  Okay.
7 A -- trying to make. It's certainly possible, and
8 it's difficult to reconstruct that 12 years after the fact.
9 Q All right. All right. I want to go back to wind
10 up this -- this concern about engagement with the federal --
11 I mean, engaging the federal system into the state process.
12 21b is the exhibit that is your comments really on the very
13 final version of --
14 A Right.
15 Q -- the NPA on September 24, and the -- the language
16 is quite striking to us in this regard, looking at the -- at
17 the first e-mail there, you've talked about deleting the
18 petite policy portion upon recommendation, and
19 inserting global resolution language which you've proposed.
20 And then you then say, "I'm not comfortable with
21 requiring the state attorney to enter into a joining
22 recommendation," and then you propose essentially taking out
23 a mention of the state attorney's office regarding the -- the
24 sentence recommendation, and then you also note, "I'm not
25 comfortable with requiring a state court to stick with our
Page 197
1 timeline," and you ask that the reference be softened -- your
2 term is to soften.
3 You also use soften below when you talk about
4 your -- making it -- a concern about making Epstein an agent
5 of the U.S. regarding negotiations. So, you're really -- and
6 then at the very top, in the -- in the later follow up e-
7 mail, you express concern about, "Do we really need to set a
8 date for his reporting? I'm very nervous about that. If I
9 were a judge, / would be upset by the federal government
10 telling a state court how to manage their calendar. Can we
11 delete?"
12 A Right.
13 Q So, clearly you're very mindful, right, of the
14 importance of not injecting the federal sovereign into the
15 state sovereign.
16 A Correct.
17 Q Fair? All right, but yet, this whole set up, the
18 whole NPA did require certain actions to occur, however they
19 came about, in the state, because of the federal requirement.
20 A Yes.
21 Q And why was that a good idea?
22 A In hindsight, the complexity that this took on
23 clearly is something that -- that if I was advising a fellow
24 U.S. Attorney today, I would say, think it through. I do
25 think it would have played differently if he had actually not
Page 198
1 done all the collateral deals and stuck to what was --
Q But that came later.
A It --
Q This is before it's signed.
A It came it came later, but let me -- let me at
6 least say that, and stuck to October 26th, but look, I
7 understand your point, and -- and the response that I can
8 give was, you have -- we had these concerns, but we also
9 thought it was very important that he serve some real
10 punishment, and that he register. And whether -- whether we
11 balance that or not, a lot of people are going to be
12 questioning for a long, long time, but that's how we balanced
13 it.
14 Q Because the state disposition was not a
15 precondition to achieving those two objectives. You could
16 have done it with a federal plea, serving time --
17 A Arguably --
18 Q -- and the offender registration.
19 A Arguably, we could have done it with a federal plea
20 if judges would have gone -- if judges would have gone for
21 rule lls, which in the Southern District they tend not to,
22 but arguably.
23 Q Okay. Okay. I just wanted to --
24 A And you know, again, this is -- this is a hindsight
25 thing, but yes.
Page 199
1 Q It is, but what we're focusing on is not so much
2 the hindsight as the -- at the time, did this make sense?
3 And it seems that you all were putting in so much effort, and
4 it was so hard to make this come together and work, that
5 it -- it's striking that it didn't collapse of its own -- of
6 its -- of its own weight.
7 A And to that point, let me say, you know, it's also,
8 if I had to speculate, one question that I'd -- that I'd ask
9 is, everyone's putting in all this effort. You know,
10 put in a lot of work on the negotiations with the defense
11 counsel that were somewhere between zealous and difficult.
12 Q Meaning defense counsel were --
13 A Yeah.
14 Q -- between zealous and --
15 A Yeah.
16 Q -- difficult?
17 A Yeah. Whether there's zealous advocates or cross
18 line to rude, we can have conversations about, and at what
19 point, you know, would it have proceeded differently if folks
20 said, let's take a big step back, and let's seriously
21 reconsider? But everyone was very, let's get the job done,
22 let's put him in jail. And I -- look, I'm speculating in
23 hindsight.
24 Q But could you not have pulled the plug at any time
25 before it was signed? I mean, clearly by the morning of that
EFTA01249718 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Michael Reiter
(date: 2020-04-30)
ID.302 (Rev. 5440) -1 of 4 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION          04/23/2020

<REDACTED> date of birth <REDACTED> was interviewed at<REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> . Present for this interview was
Detective IIII and Special Agent . Prior to beginning
this interview, <REDACTED> was served with a subpoena requesting his
participation in this interview and that he turn over materials in his
possession pertaining to this investigation. <REDACTED> then turned over to
agents two (2) boxes containing case related materials that states he
recovered from deceased case detective <REDACTED> home. After being
advised of the identities of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the
interview, <REDACTED> provided the following information:

<REDACTED> stated that in one of the boxes was an imaged copy of JEFFREY
EPSTEIN's kitchen counter laptop that had phone messages that <REDACTED> hadn't
seen before.

An employee was stealing from EPSTEIN and EPSTEIN called the Palm Beach
Police Department (PBPD) . This was how met EPSTEIN.

EPSTEIN donated $40,000 to PBPD to help purchase a machine to help PBPD
review security footage. He also wrote a check for $90,000 to help them
purchase a finger print machine (AFIS terminal) . This was around the same
time that EPSTEIN's first victim had come forward to the PBPD. <REDACTED> did
not cash this check. It was very common for PBPD to receive donations from
the wealthy like this.

EPSTEIN donated to the police scholarship fund for children. He donated
more than others. asked who EPSTEIN is.

<REDACTED> said that EPSTEIN supports law enforcement and is an important guy. PBPD
checked him out and saw a New Yorker article about him.

<REDACTED> became the police chief in 2001. In the early 2000's, maybe 2003,
a call came into the tip line that attractive women were coming in and out
Mwstpmmon 10/18/2019 m
500 -NY-3027571
(In Person)
OmcooNA 04/03/2020
by

3501.401-001
Page 1 of4
FD•302a (Rev. 5.8.10)
SOD-NY-3027571
ComiiwmionoIFD•302oI (U) Interview of a 10/18/2019 pm, 2 of 4
of EPSTEIN's house. PBPD did surveillance on EPSTEIN's house and 2 separate
women were stopped. They were both students of both
adults, and said that they were working for him.
The stepmother of the first victim, whose name thought was
was the one who made her come forward. (Agent note: last name was
The stepmother called and said her daughter was having sex with
a man in Palm Beach. They were brought in to the precinct and she said,
"I'm not the only one, there are other girls doing it". This case was
assigned to who interviewed a few days later. The case
started to grow rapidly. i experience inside the house was then
corroborated. More surveillance was done on EPSTEIN's house. Some kids
were observed, prepubescent with braces and backpacks coming from school.
Aviation personnel spoke with PBPD about who was coming and going. One
employee said there were dozens of girls in one day. The PBPD then put
together a case and brought it to the State's Attorney's office. At this
point, believed they were already in communications with the
defense.
spoke with the states attorney whom he had a good relationship
with. was to get a detective and speak with the sex crimes unit on
who to use. When the states attorney asked who the case was about
said it was about EPSTEIN. The states attorney told that he had
never heard of him. Then after he spoke with the defense, the states
attorney told to write EPSTEIN a notice to appear for a misdemeanor
(lewd and lascivious behavior) . debated on whether to arrest EPSTEIN
on probable cause but said it would be problematic with the state's
attorney.
PBPD tried to keep the case very tight. They would type up their reports
and put them on a hard drive which they would put in a safe. They would not
input these reports into the computer. They had sexual battery cases
against the co-conspirators. When PBPD presented it they wouldn't approve
it. The state's attorneys said the victims were not credible and would show
their MYSPACE pages and such. They would refute minute details in the
probable cause affidavit. thought it was leaked by the attorney's
office. thought the defense attorneys thought they weren't doing
enough to talk them out of it. This case died at the state level.
then wrote a letter to the State Attorney asking him to recuse himself.
3501.401-001
Page 2 of 4
FD•302a (Rev. 5.8.10)
SOD-NY -3027571
c ontinuatio„r m.302 or (I ) Interview of •On 10/18/2019 •per  3 of 4
After this, private investigators began harassing and playing games with
EPSTEIN had go to and tell him "these girls
are just prostitutes, these are just happy endings, these are minor cases".
Private investigators began pulling the police officers' trash.
About 6 months after
investigator who was represented by attorney
that he had some safety concerns for him.
(EPSTEIN's trainer) recently purchased a townhouse
retired, he was contacted by a private
He told
was told that IGOR
received a call about a target letter that he had received. This
individual told that he doesn't have to worry because EPSTEIN is not
in Palm Beach anymore and that he sold his house. stated this was
not true and it was a weird call.
PBPD referred this case to the FBI and introduced the victims to the
FBI. Everyone was very motivated. Eventually there was a lack of
communication. heard there was a discussion of a plea deal or a non-
prosecution. asked to speak to the United States Attorney,
ALEXANDER ACOSTA. asked him if he was going to own up to what he
promised when he was sworn in. ACOSTA said the defense had him very
frustrated with the case. He said that there was a lot of interest from
higher up. The state did not want to take it back. It took months to
convince them to take it back. It was very disappointing that the system
failed in this case. was told that the non-prosecution would include
a fund for counseling and medical. There was a hurry to make this case go
away.
After giving the $90,000 check, EPSTEIN came back to office. He
talked about Harvard donations. EPSTEIN just wanted to know about
it was like he was sizing up. Afterwards, walked with EPSTEIN
to the lobby and was there. She was like a statue.
Palm Beach Country Club is a Jewish country club. A lot of wealthy
people are there and they flock together. Mar-A-Lago is a mixture of
everyone. DONALD TRUMP told that he threw EPSTEIN out of his club.
TRUMP called the PBPD to tell him "thank goodness you' re stopping him,
everyone has known he's been doing this". TRUMP told him people in New York
3501.401-001
Page 3 of 4
FD•302a (Rev. 5.8.10)
SOD-NY-3027571
CamiiwmionorED•302of (U) Interview of .O, 10/18/2019 pag, 4 of 4
knew EPSTEIN was disgusting. TRUMP said MAXWELL was EPSTEIN's operative,
"she is evil and to focus on her". TRUMP told that he was around
EPSTEIN once when teenagers were present and TRUMP "got the hell out of
there". TRUMP was one of the very first people to call when people found
out that they were investigating EPSTEIN.
No one could explain how EPSTEIN made his money. They knew he worked for
BEAR STEARNS. was told that EPSTEIN was kind of a technical guy that
would make it happen but you didn't want to know how.
None of the victims that PBPD spoke with said they had sexual contact
with men other than EPSTEIN while in EPSTEIN's orbit. had
one time went out screaming.
PRINCE ANDREW was a fixture in Palm Beach and he had no protection while
there.
has done interviews in the past with
People/victims thought that PBPD was paid off by EPSTEIN which was why
went and did these interviews. He felt he needed to defend PBPD.
An interior designer told the PBPD that rooms in the Virgin Islands had
been decorated for teenage girls. contacted the Virgin Island Police
Department, but they were not helpful.
In the end when EPSTEIN had turned himself in to plea to the misdemeanor,
was not notified and found out from the newspaper.
3501A01-001
Page 4 of 4
EFTA00139235 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons psychological profile of Jeffrey Epstein
(date: 2020-05-14)
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Reentry Services Division
Washington, DC 20534
May 14, 2020
MEMORANDUM FOR REGIONAL DIRECTOR
NORTHEAST REGION
FROM:
SUBJECT:
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
Date: 2020.05.14 11:36:21 04'00-
, Assistant Director
Reentry Services Division
Institution Response
Psychological Reconstruction
Inmate Epstein, Jeffrey (Reg. No. 76318-054)
I have reviewed your Institution Response, dated January 27, 2020,
to the Psychological Reconstruction of an inmate suicide at
MCC New York.
The corrective actions and plans for implementation in your response
are appropriate. Please thank your staff for their efforts in
addressing the recommendations outlined in the Psychological
Reconstruction Report.
If you have questions or concerns, please feel free to contact me at
cc: Warden, MCC New York
SDNY_00017728
PSYCHOLOGICAL RECONSTRUCTION OF INMATE DEATH
This is an interim report, due to an inability to gather all necessary data. Formal interviews were
not conducted as a part of this reconstruction to avoid interference with pending investigations
by other Department of Justice components. A copy of the video is normally made by Special
Investigative Staff following a significant incident, but there was no such video in this case since
the original video was confiscated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) prior to the
beginning of this reconstruction. The absence of these two sources of information severely
limited the ability to establish accurate timelines, confirm subjective reports, establish
converging and diverging lines of facts, or discover new areas of inquiry. As a result,
information typically gathered, reviewed and consolidated during a reconstruction to support
actionable findings and recommendations is limited.
Name: Jeffrey Epstein
Register Number: 76318-054
Date of Death: 08-10-2019
Prepared by: National Suicide Prevention Coordinator,
Psychology Services Branch, Central Office
BACKGROUND INFORMATION

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein was a 66-year-old, White male who died on August 10, 2019, while housed
at the Metropolitan Correctional Complex (MCC), in New York, New York. James C. Wills,
former Acting Assistant Director, Reentry Services Division a inted a team to conduct a
psychological reconstruction. The team consisted of National Suicide Prevention
Coordinator, Central Office: . Sex Offender Treatment Programs Coordinator,
Central Office; Mental Health Treatment Coordinator, Central Office; and
Correctional Services Administrator, Northeast Regional Office. This
reconstruction was established in accordance with Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) Program Statement
5324.08, Suicide Prevention Proeram,
Social History: Mr. Epstein did not have a Pre-Sentence Report (PSR) available at the time of
the reconstruction; therefore, no official information regarding social history was accessible.
The following was gathered from publicly available documents. Mr. Epstein was born in 1953
and grew up in a middle-class family in the neighborhood of Sea Gate on Coney Island,
Brooklyn, New York, with one brother. After early promotion in two grades, Mr. Epstein
graduated from Lafayette High School in 1969, at the age of 16. He attended Cooper Union and
New York University but did not graduate from either. Mr. Epstein taught at the Dalton School,
a private school on the Upper East Side of Manhattan from September 1974 until he was
1
SDNY_00017729
dismissed in June 1976 for inadequate development as a teacher. Following that, he held a
number of positions in the financial industry to include a position as a limited partner at
Bear Stearns until he was dismissed for unknown policy violations in 1981. He also worked as a
financial consultant and founded at least two separate companies.
Mr. Epstein had two significant periods of employment. The first of these was his position as a
consultant with Steven Jude Hoffenberg in the late 1980s. Mr. Hoffenberg was described as his
first mentor. Mr. Hoffenberg was later convicted and incarcerated for running a large Ponzi
scheme. He implicated Mr. Epstein in fraudulently diverting company funds for his own
personal use. Years later, Leslie Wexner, Mr. Epstein's sole client at J. Epstein and Company,
granted him power of attorney over his affairs. Despite also being identified as Mr. Wexner's
mentee, Mr. Epstein was again accused of misappropriating funds-more than 46 million
dollars. These large sums are believed to be the seed money Mr. Epstein used to establish his
considerable fortune. These events are indicative of Mr. Epstein's highly -regarded intelligence
and charismatic personality.
Legal History: Mr. Epstein had a history of adult criminal charges and convictions. In
June 2008, he entered into a non-prosecution agreement and pleaded guilty to one count
Solicitation of Prostitution and one count Procuring a Person Under the Age of 18 for
Prostitution in the state of Florida. He was sentenced to 30 months: 18 months of incarceration
and 12 months of probation. He was also mandated to register as a sex offender under the
National Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act. Mr. Epstein served 13 of his I8 -month
incarceration and then successfully completed 12 months of probation. It is unclear whether he
followed the sex offender registration guidelines in each place he owned a residence.
In regard to pending charges, Mr. Epstein was formally charged with Sex Trafficking Conspiracy
in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371 and Sex Trafficking in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 159I(a), (b) (2), 2
on July 2, 2019. Specifically, he was accused of sexually exploiting and abusing minor females
over the course of several years. Charging documents allege Mr. Epstein enticed and recruited
minor females to engage in sexual activity. The minor females were reportedly compensated
with cash following the sexual encounters and some were encouraged to find other minor
females to accompany them to Mr. Epstein's residences in New York or Florida. He pleaded not
guilty to these charges and was in pretrial status at the time of his death.
In a 37-page Decision & Order Remanding the Defendant, signed by Judge Richard M. Berman
on July 18, 2019, 18 pages were dedicated to detailing the danger Mr. Epstein posed to others
and the community. The document also alleged he was a flight risk. As a result, Mr. Epstein's
proposed bail package was determined to be inadequate. He was denied pretrial release and held
on remand.
2
SDNY_00017730
Institutional History: On July 6, 2019, Mr. Epstein was arrested at Teterboro Airport in
New Jersey upon his return from Paris, France. It is unknown whether he was anticipating this
arrest. He was transported to MCC New York and keyed into SENTRY at 9:24 p.m. that
evening. Mr. Epstein was placed in a general population housing unit for approximately 22
hours. On July 7, 2019, at approximately 7:20 p.m. he was moved to the Special Housing Unit
(SHU) pending reclassification due to the significant increase in media coverage and awareness
of his notoriety among the inmate population.
With regard to his adjustment to a correctional setting, Mr. Epstein received one incident report
while in BOP custody for Self-Mutilation on July 23, 2019. As of August 15, 2019, the incident
report had been expunged though it is unclear why it had been expunged and whether

Mr. Epstein knew this. Also, a review of financial transactions associated with Mr. Epstein's
prison account revealed one of his attorneys was depositing funds into his cellmate's (inmate
Reyes) commissary account for unknown reasons.
JIEALTH CARE AND PERSONALITY DESCRIPTION
BOP Electronic Medical Records (BEMR) indicate Mr. Epstein was diagnosed with
hyperlipidemia, sleep apnea, hypertension, constipation, prediabetes, neuralgia, and neuritis
unspecified. He was prescribed the following mediations: docusate sodium, milk of magnesia,
omega 3, methylprednisone, and bisacodyl. Mr. Epstein was also prescribed insulin, and the
prescription required him to go to the institution pharmacy for administration of this medication.
However, the dates for which it was prescribed have a notation indicating "dose not indicated,"
thus it does not appear insulin was routinely medically necessary. The rest of the medications
prescribed were self-carry. He also had a continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) machine
which is typically used to treat sleep apnea. Mr. Epstein was provided with his personal CPAP
machine on July 30, 2019, per BEMR.
In regard to mental health history and treatment, there are no known available records. Any
records that may have been maintained relating to Mr. Epstein's incarceration in Florida were
not available for review as of the date of this re ort. With regard to Psychology Data System
records in BEMR (PDS-BEMR), Forensic Psychologist at
MCC New York completed a routine Intake Screening on July 8, 2019. During this screening,

Mr. Epstein denied any history of mental health problems, substance abuse, and treatment. No
symptoms of mental illness were observed. He was classified as Mental Health Care Level 1 and
was not diagnosed with a mental illness.
Following a consultation with -, National Suicide Prevention Coordinator on
July 8, 2019, Chief Psychologist at MCC New York determined Mr. Epstein
should be pre-emptively evaluated for suicide risk upon his return from court. Primary
consideration was given to his various risk factors for suicide such as his high profile case and
media attention, pending sex offense charges, pre-trial status, and an ongoing court proceeding.
Mr. Epstein returned from court on July 8, 2019, after normal business hours. He denied suicidal
3
SDNY_00017731
thoughts at that time, but due to the potential for other risk factors listed above, the on-call
psychologist placed Mr. Epstein on Psychological Observation in one of the suicide watch cells
until he could be assessed in person by a BOP psychologist. Psychological Observation is a
form of individual monitoring that is less restrictive than Suicide Watch. It is used for inmates
who are stabilizing and not yet prepared for placement in general population or restrictive
housing. It is often used to transition inmates off of Suicide Watch in order to monitor their
transition and safety after an acute suicidal crisis. On  9, 2019, Mr. Epstein underwent a
formal, in-person suicide risk assessment with Dr. . She determined that, while suicide
watch was not warranted at that time, Mr. Epstein should remain on Psychological Observation
status out of an abundance of caution. He was removed from Psychological Observation on
July 10, 2019.
On July 23, 2019, Dr. the on-call psychologist was notified Mr. Epstein had been found
in his cell with a piece of orange cloth around his neck. Reportedly, he was observed lying in the
fetal position on the floor with a noose around his neck. Medical staff evaluated Mr. Epstein and
found friction marks and superficial reddening of the neck skin and one knee. He was placed on
suicide watch by the Operations Lieutenant at approximately 1:40 a.m. pending a formal in-
person suicide risk assessment. Dr. Staff Psychologist at MCC New York,
assessed Mr. Epstein for risk of suicide later in the morning of July 23, 2019, and determined he
should remain on suicide watch. Mr. Epstein denied any knowledge of how he received marks
on his neck and initially informed staff he believed his cellmate,Nicholas Tartaglione, had
attempted to kill him. Special Investigative Services (SIS) staff opened an investigation to assess

Mr. Epstein's safety and collect facts surrounding the episode. Despite this investigation, staff
was unable to determine whether he was assaulted or engaged in self-directed violence.

Mr. Epstein was removed from suicide watch on July 24, 2019, after 31 hours and 5 minutes.
Thereafter, he remained in the suicide watch cell and was placed on Psychological Observation,
where he remained housed until July 30, 2019, according to PDS-BEMR records. A discrepancy
exists regarding when he was removed from Psychological Observation. His cell assignment,
per SENTRY, indicates he was transferred back to the Special Housing Unit (SHU)on
July 29,2019, whereas PDS-BEMR indicates he was removed from Psychological Observation
on July 30, 2019, at approximately 8:15 a.m.

Mr. Epstein attended a court hearing on July 31, 2019, and, upon his return, the United States
Marshals Service (USMS) provideSaperwork to Receiving and Discharge (R&D) staff that
noted "suicidal tendencies." Dr. was notified on August 1, 2019, about this paperwork.
She consulted with Dr. and then met with Mr. Epstein to conduct a suicide risk
assessment. She determined suicide watch was not warranted at that time.

Mr. Epstein remained classified as a Mental Health Care Level 1 throughout his time at
MCC New York. During his contacts with psychologists, Mr. Epstein routinely denied current
mental health symptoms to include suicidal ideation, and he did not exhibit symptoms of a
serious mental illness. However, there was evidence Mr. Epstein was experiencing challenges
4
SDNY_00017732
adjusting to his environment and changes in his lifestyle. He reported frequent complaints of
difficulty sleeping. He did not have access to his CPAP machine until it was reportedly provided
to him on July 30, 2019. Mr. Epstein also reported he was bothered by noise in the SHU. At
times, he noted concerns related to his safety in SHU or on a general population housing unit.
On two occasions, July 26, 2019, and July 27, 2019, he described himself as a coward and as
someone who does not like pain. On July 28, 2019, he told Dr. the toilet in his cell would
not stop flushing for an extended period of time, and he then took to sitting in the corner with his
hands over his ears. Mr. Epstein indicated he was agitated following this incident and was
unable to sleep that night.
ANTECEDENT CIRCUMSTANCES

Mr. Epstein entered BOP custody on July 6, 2019, with a history of convictions for sexual
offenses and allegations comprised of more serious charges. The current indictment alleged
sexual crimes against minors, and he was facing up to 45 years in prison. On July 18, 2019,

Mr. Epstein's request for bail and pretrial release was denied.
On July 23, 2019, Mr. Epstein was found unresponsive in his cell. The motivation and context
were never fully determined. After 31 hours and 5 minutes on Suicide Watch, he was then
placed on Psychological Observation. On July 30, 2019, Mr. Epstein was removed from
Psychological Observation. Dr. sent an e-mail reporting Mr. Epstein had been removed
from Psychological Observation and needed to be housed with an appropriate cellmate. This
e-m ail was sent to 71 MCC New York staff and, as of August 13, 2019, only 27 staff members
had opened the message.
On August 9, 2019, a federal court unsealed approximately 2,000 pages of documents into the
public domain. These included graphic allegations against Mr. Epstein. Included was a book
order receipt for titles such as SM 101: A Realistic Introduction; SlaveCraft: Roadmaps for
Erotic Servitude; and Training with Miss Abernathy: A Workbook for Erotic Slaves and Their
Owners. Additional high profile public figures were also named in the released documents. The
documents were part of a defamation lawsuit filed by . a woman who
alleged Mr. Epstein had victimized her, against a British socialite, Ghislaine Maxwell, who was

Mr. Epstein's ex-girlfriend, associate, and alleged to have assisted with his criminal activities.
According to staff report, Mr. Epstein was afforded telephone calls on two different days
although it is unknown whether they were legal or social calls. No recording of the calls exist
and it is not known with whom he was speaking. One occurred on or around July 16, 2019, and
the other on August 9, 2019. Legal calls are not monitored, and would not be recorded. A
social call would be recorded; given the limited information known about Mr. Epstein,
knowledge of the content of any social calls would have been crucial to helping staff work with
him.
Following his final telephone call on the evening of August 9, 2019, Mr. Epstein was moved into
his SHU cell. He was single-celled at that time because his cellmate (Efrain Reyes #85993-054)
5
SDNY_00017733
did not return from court. The need for a cellmate was communicated between Day Watch

(DW) and Evening Watch (EW) shifts in the SHU, but no cellmate was laced with him by the
EW staff. According to a memorandum from Senior Officer Specialist , SHU
staff were informed at approximately 1:50.  .. at Mr. Epstein's cellmate would likely not
return from court. Furthermore, Officer noted Mr. Epstein would need a cellmate upon
arrival from his attorney visit.
A review of the 30-minute rounds forms indicate unit rounds were com leted for the entire MW
shift on August 10, 2019. However, a memorandum from Lieutenant indicates
Officer Tova Noel and Material Handler Supervisor Michael made a statement after

Mr. Epstein's death that they did not complete proper 30-minute rounds at 3:00 a.m. or 5:00 a.m.
DESCRIPTION OF SCF.NFt
A detailed description of the scene was unavailable because the officers who discovered
Mr. Epstein did not write memorandums and could not be interviewed. According to the Report
of Incident, on August 10, 2019, at approximately 6:33 a.m., while serving the breakfast meal in
the SHU, Range 9 South, Mr. Epstein was found unresponsive in his cell. Staff reportedly called
for medical assistance, activated the body alarm, and began life-saving measures. Arriving staff
stated they brought an automated external defibrillator (AED) and stretcher. Cardiopulmonary
resuscitation (CPR) reportedly continued while the AED was placed on Mr. Epstein. The AED
reportedly indicated no shock advised and CPR was continued. Mr. Epstein was escorted to
Health Services at approximately 6:39 a.m., and Emergency Medical Services (EMS) arrived at
6:43 a.m. He was transported to the local hospital at approximately 7:10 a.m. Mr. Epstein was
pronounced deceased at 7:36 am. It was not possible to confirm this timeline without viewing
video footage.
CONCLUSIONS/RECOMMENDATIONS
A general appreciation of risk factors for suicide specific to sex offenders is necessary when
reviewing Mr. Epstein's death. These factors, as well as more general risk factors for suicide,
were likely present. There are several common factors that increase risk for suicide in
individuals with a history of a sexual offense. These include stigma due to the nature of
sexually -based crimes (both within society and the prison system), a disruption of the ability to
utilize sex as a coping mechanism (which can lead to increased levels of distress and negative
affect), and grief about loss experienced in regards to arrest. This grief may be secondary to the
loss of former lifestyle, loss of physical items or collections related to sexual offenses, and/or the
loss of perceived relationships with victims. Other factors that may increase risk for suicide
among individuals accused of a sex offense include safety concerns, potentially long sentences,
and lack of skills necessary to navigate social relationships in prison.

Mr. Epstein was a high-profile, pretrial detainee awaiting trial on sex trafficking offenses. He
had been a successful, wealthy businessman with a number of high-profile acquaintances that he
accumulated through a combination of charisma, charm, and intelligence. Despite his many
associates, he had limited significant or deep interpersonal ties. Although Mr. Epstein appeared
6
SDNY_00017734
to cultivate a large social and professional network, he was estranged from his only
brother. Indeed, his identity appeared to be based on his wealth, power, and association
with other high- profile individuals. Approximately two-and-a-half weeks before his death,

Mr. Epstein appeared to attempt suicide, but ultimately denied it was a suicide attempt. He
was convincing in his denial. On that occasion, he was saved because his cellmate notified
BOP staff. In the weeks before his death, he made statements that he was "a coward" and
was having difficulty adapting to his diminished circumstances. He also frequently
referenced poor sleep and an inability to tolerate the noise of prison. On the day before his
death, a number of documents in his case were unsealed, further eroding his previously-
enjoyed elevated status and potentially implicating some of his associates. The lack of
significant interpersonal connections, a complete loss of his status in both the community
and among associates, and the idea of potentially spending his life in prison were likely
factors contributing to Mr. Epstein's suicide.
The following recommendations concern institution operations: Corr Svc/ Psych

1. Single Celline: It is recommended that all inmates be double-celled unless safety
concerns or an odd number of inmates precludes this. Priority should be given to inmates
with a history of mental illness, self-directed violence, recent stressors (e.g., losses, newly
sentenced, etc.)
It is recommended that a system of control be implemented explaining who will be
notified when a Suicide Watch or Psychological Observation ends and how that
communication will take place. Because this is a life safety issue, the system of control,
once approved by the warden, should be reviewed in formal meetings such as staff
recalls, department head meetings, and lieutenants meetings.

1. Single Cell Placement
A system has been put in place to ensure inmates are not single celled. A single cell
report is completed during each shift by the SHU Lieutenant during Day Watch and the
Operations Lieutenant during the Morning Watch and Evening Watch. Notifications
are made to the Institution Duty Officer (IDO) and Executive Staff.
Psychology discusses the status of inmates who are at-risk for suicidality, their housing
needs, as well as their needs for cellmates during staff meetings, department head
meetings, SHU meetings, morning meetings, and close out meetings.
When inmates are placed on and off suicide watch, the Warden is notified verbally.
regardless of the time of day. The Warden then determines which suicide watch area a
suicidal inmate will be housed and if they will be observed with an inmate companions
or a staff member.
7
SDNY_00017735
Psychology verbally notifies the Lieutenant when inmates are removed from suicide
watch and communicates to the Lieutenant that they will need to be placed with a
cellmate (Providing direct communication and instructions). Cellmates are
recommended not only for SHU inmates being removed from suicide watch, but also
for inmates returning to the general population setting.
Once an inmate is removed from suicide watch, psychology staff sends an e-mail to the
Executive Staff, IDO, and Lieutenants informing them the inmate is being removed
from suicide watch and can return to a cell with a cellmate. The e-mail contains the
name of the staff member whom psychology verbally spoke with. This
recommendation for a cellmate and conversation with the Lieutenant is also
documented in the Post Suicide Watch Report and placed in BEMR/PDS.
Psychology Services has eliminated the use of Psychological Observation to avoid any
confusion as to the needs of inmates on a watch status.
Exec/IDO

2. Rounds; 30-minute rounds are required by P5500.14 Correctional Services Procedures
Manual.
Corr Svc / Legal

3. fellmate Assignments• When Mr. Epstein was placed in SHU on July 7, 2019,
Executive Staff decided Mr. Tartaglione would be his cellmate. As explained by

Dr. , input was not sought from Psychology Services and it is not clear if or how
sex offender-specific needs and associated risk were incorporated into the housing plan.

Mr. Tartaglione was also a high profile inmate-an ex-police officer charged in multiple
murders. However, he and Mr. Epstein did not share the risk associated with being a sex
offender and their pairing may have aggravated Mr. Epstein's risk for self-directed
violence. In an effort to treat Mr. Epstein the same as other inmates, a statement repeated
by multiple staff, Executive Staff may have inadvertently overlooked the need to consider
unique risk factors associated with individuals who have been charged with and
convicted of a sex offense. On July 25, 2019, Dr. sent an e-mail to
m rAssociate Warden explaining a consultation between Dr.
and , National Suicide Prevention Coordinator. In the e-mail, Dr.

3. Cellmate Assignments: The psychological reconstruction suggests MCC New York
Executive Staff did not take into account Mr. Epstein's sex offender-specific needs in
assigning him a cellmate in SHU. However, that is not correct. MCC New York
Executive Staff considered a variety of factors in determining the most appropriate
cellmate for Mr. Epstein, including but not limited to history of sex offenses, nature of
the inmate, cooperation status, etc.
8
SDNY_00017736
MCC New York administrators initially housed Mr. Epstein with Mr. Tartaglione as
both had high profile cases. Mr. Tartaglione is also a certified death penalty eligible
inmate and, thus, based on correctional judgment, less likely to assault or otherwise
try to extort Mr. Epstein. Indeed, Mr. Tartaglione notified staff immediately when he
realized Mr. Epstein first made a possible suicide attempt/gesture on July 23, 2019.
Prior to Mr. Epstein being taken off suicide watch, MCC New York Executive Staff,
with input from psychology staff, assessed all the inmates in SHU at that time and
narrowed the list down to the most appropriate candidates. Mr. Tartaglione was not
chosen as the investigation at the time had not yet cleared him of any wrongdoing.
Most of the other inmates in SHU at the time were there for disciplinary reasons and
were otherwise not appropriate to be housed with Mr. Epstein. The other notable
inmate in SHU with a history of sex offenses, Mr. Hoyt, was deemed dangerous to

Mr. Epstein due to his threatening nature. Accordingly, MCC New York Executive
Staff narrowed the possibilities to cooperators. Specifically, Efrain Reyes, reg. no.
85993-054, was placed in SHU for claims he was being threatened and extorted on his
unit, and he was confirmed as proffering with the U.S. Attorney's Office. As both he
and Mr. Epstein were in SHU for safety reasons, Mr. Reyes was deemed an
appropriate cellmate.
Based on the above, consideration was made for Mr. Epstein's sex-offender -specific
needs in choosing his cellmate in SHU. His charged crime was just one of the factors
reviewed in making the determination. MCC New York Executive Staff also
considered high publicity inmates with ample reasons not to hurt Mr. Epstein, and
cooperators who are not only vulnerable themselves, but also had a lot to lose should
they harm Mr. Epstein.

3. Cellmate :Assignments
Inmates with serious mental illness and those at-risk for suicidality are discussed
during staff meetings, department head meetings. SHU meetings. morning meetings,
and close out meetings. The Captain, Associate Wardens. Warden and Psychology
discuss the inmate's needs. The Staff Attorney also assists when the inmate's attorney
or court are concerned about an inmate's mental health. Psychology Services are
involved in making recommendations regarding the types of cellmates that inmates at-
risk for suicidality should celled with. Psychology Services takes into consideration
the suicide risk factors involved with a particular inmate and share their knowledge
with Executive Staff.
Leal
reviewed the consult and recommendation from the Psychology Services Branch, Central
Office that Mr. Epstein be housed with another inmate who had also been accused of
9
SDNY_00017737
committing a sex offense. There is no evidence this information was considered beyond
this e-mail, and Mr. Epstein was never housed with another inmate charged or convicted
of a sexual offense.
Exec Staff
It is recommended Executive Staff and Correctional Services staff include a psychologist
in decisions about cellmates as a means of incorporating expertise about suicide risk,
mental health needs, and interventions for psychological stability.
Psvc Svc

4. Documentation Accuracy  On July 23, 2019, Mr. Epstein was found unresponsive in his
cell. He had abrasions on his neck and knee. There are inconsistencies between
documents describii.e circumstances of the scene. In a General Administrative Note
in PDS-BEMR. Dr. documented information received from Operations Lieutenant
that Mr. E stein. "was found with a string loosely hanging around his
neck." In contrast, Officer who responded to this emergency, wrote a
memorandum dated July 23, 2019. In that memorandum, Officer Silva wrote he saw

Mr. Epstein "laying down near his bunk with what appeared to be a piece of handmade
orange cloth around his neck." It is critical that all descriptions of the incident accurately
reflect objective evidence.
Officer wrote Mr. Epstein an incident report for Self-Mutilation on
July 23, 2019, after he was found unresponsive in his cell but prior to having the
necessary facts to determine whether he likely engaged in a Bureau violation. BOP
policy expects staff to write an incident report within 24 hours of having the information
that an inmate likely violated BOP rules but without making a presumptive decision
about guilt. A Special Investigative Services Threat Assessment was completed
August 2, 2019, but results were inconclusive as to whether Mr. Epstein engaged in self-
directed violence, willingly fought with his cellmate, or was assaulted by his cellmate. It
is recommended that staff remain open to all reasonable explanations for a behavior and
take the appropriate actions when a final determination is made. Although the incident
report was later expunged, inmates frequently experience significant stress when they
contemplate the potential consequences associated with findings of guilt.

Dr. entered a Psychology Services Intake Screening into PDS-BEMR on
July 8, 2010. The document has three typographical errors. She selected the No Sexual
Offense Convictions check box when, in fact, Mr. Epstein was previously convicted of
S9licitation of Prostitution and Procuring a Person Under the Age of 18 for Prostitution.
Second, Mr. Epstein was erroneously identified as a Black male in this document.
Finally, there is one instance where he was mistakenly referred to as Mr. Brown.
1. Documentation Accuracy
I
SDNY_00017738
Psychology considers the information from more than one source when making decisions about
suicide watch placement. Clinical judgment is used to make determinations taking into
consideration each person's self-report of a situation as they may be perceived differently.
The Chief Psychologist has spoken to all psychology staff members concerning proof reading all
documents entered to reduce typos and to improve information accuracy. Additionally, there is
a second Staff Psychologist in the department which helps reduce the workload on current
psychologists, allowing more time for documentation review.
The Chief Psychologist and Drug Abuse Coordinator counseled the Drug Treatment Specialist
(DTS) concerning her documentation in the suicide watch log book. There was no ill -intent on
the part of the DTS as all log books were maintained: the original log book written by the officer
and the one documented by the DTS. The DTS indicated a desire to assist the officer as he had
written in the wrong log book. Specifically, he wrote in the inmate companion log book rather
than the staff log book. However, she was informed that this is not her role and she is not to
document in a log book for anyone else observing an inmate on suicide watch. In the future.
only the staff member watching the inmate on suicide watch documents in the suicide watch log
book. Log books are now being closely monitored on a daily basis by the Chief Psychologist.
The Psychology Department has eliminated Psychology Observation at MCC-NY. Both Staff
and the Lieutenants received additional training on when they are required to complete rounds
and sign Suicide Watch log books. With regard to suicide watch log books signatures,
Correctional Staff are required to perform routine rounds every hour. The 2 Sally Officer on
Monday- Friday during Day Watch is required to perform rounds on suicide or observation
watch inmates as prescribed by the Captain. After-hours, the Unit 2 Officer will be responsible
for making rounds, feeding meals, collecting trash in the area, and performing the count with the
Internal I or Internal 2 assisting with duties as assigned by the Captain. Additionally,
Psychology staff check the suicide watch logs daily when they interview the inmates on suicide
watch. If it is noted hourly rounds are not being conducted by the Unit Officer and/or the
Lieutenants are not rounding and signing the books each shift, the Associate Warden over
Programs and the Captain are notified immediately and enforce accountability.
1
SDNY_00017739
Dr. completed a Risk of Sexual Abusiveness document on July 8, 2019. She
marked "History of prior prison sexual predation" in the affirmative. This is not accurate.
Mid-Level Practitioner, completed a History and Physical on
July 9, 2019. An Intake Screening should have been conducted within 24 hours of his
entry into Bureau custody which was on July 6, 2019, according to P6031.04, Patient
Care.
4: Inmate Jeffery Epstein #76318-05, arrived in the Receiving and Discharge (R&D),
area, on July 6, 2019, at approximately 9:24 p.m. His medical Intake Screening was
conducted at approximately 9:38 p.m., by Health Services staff, Physician Assistant (PA)
Kang on July 6, 2019. the same night he arrived in R&D. On July 9, 2019. he was placed
on Psychological Observation and at approximately 12:38 p.m.. he was escorted from
Psychological Observation to Health Services for a Medical Assessment and a History and
Physical, which was performed by PA . According to P6031.04, Patient Care, a
provider must perform a History and Physical within 14 days of the inmate arriving at
BOP facility. The History and Physical and Intake Screening was conducted timely and in
accordance to policy.
ays
Officer was responsible for observing Mr. E stein and documenting his
behavior while on suicide watch on July 23, 2019. Officer mistakenly used a
Suicide Watch Log Book intended for inmate companion documentation between
1:40 a.m. and 6:00 a.m. on July 23 2019 when he should have been using the Staff
Suicide Watch Log Book. Ms. Drug Treatment S ecialist, reportedly
noticed this error and subsequently hand copied all of Officer entries from 1:40
a.m. to 6:00 a.m. into a Staff Suicide Watch Log Book. She then initialed these entries,
and this makes it appear as if she was the one conducting the watch. This information
was discovered and conveyed in an e-mail from Ms. Associate Warden
to Dr. with a carbon copy to Warden on August 12, 2019. Of note,
Ms. did not make an entry explaining why she was making the log book changes.
Additionally, Ms. then wrote entries for 6:15, 6:30, 6:45 and 7:00 a.m. in the
Staff Suicide Watch Log Book. These were not a part of the original entries made by
Officer nor was Ms. assigned to work the Suicide Watch post. Due to the
inabilit to interview staff at this time, it is unknown why Ms. attempted to correct
Officer error, or made any of the subsequent log entries. It is recommended that
if a staff member makes an entry error (e.g., writes in the incorrect suicide watch log
book), the staff member should describe the error in the correct log book, to include
indicating when they became aware of the error. The staff member should then notify the
Chief Psychologist.
Corr Svc
9
SDNY_00017740
A review of Special Housing Unit Records (BP-A0292) revealed a number of incomplete
entries. This document is used to monitor provision and receipt of basic services such as
recreation, medical rounds, showers, meal consumption, etc. The Officer in Charge
signature is missing on 10 occasions and a medical provider's signature is missing in
seven instances. There are six instances in which it is not clear if Mr. Epstein ate his
meal. There are nine instances in which it is not clear if Mr. Epstein took a shower.
There are ten instances in which it is not clear if Mr. Epstein was offered recreation.
P5500.15 Correctional Services Manua  requires accurate and complete information on
the BP-A0292.
A review of Psychology Observation Log Books revealed significant discrepancies from
the approved Psychological Observation Procedural Memorandum, dated April 15, 2019.
A Correctional Officer is required to complete hourly rounds and sign the log book; 179
10
SDNY_00017741
out of 183 round signatures were missing. The lieutenant is required to sign the log book
one time per shift and signatures were missing in 10 of 23 instances. A Physician
Assistant is required to sign one time per shift and 16 of 16 instances were missing. It is
recommended that a further review of Psychological Observation procedures be
conducted.
AW Edge

5. Telephone Ca  In a PDS-BEMR note written by Dr. on July 16, 2019, she was
informed by an unnamed staff member that a lieutenant facilitated two telephone calls for

Mr. Epstein. It is unknown when and to whom these calls were placed and no evidence
that they took place on a monitored telephone.
According to a memorandum from Unit Manager on August 10, 2019,

Mr. Epstein terminated his legal visit early on August 9, 2019, in order to place a
telephone call to his family. Mr. Bullock (who was the Institutional Duty Officer that
week) escorted Mr. Epstein to SHU around 7:00 p.m. that evening and he was placed in
the shower area on G tier. While there, he was provided the telephone to make a call.
Since Mr. Epstein reportedly did not have his PAC or PIN number, which is required to
use the inmate telephone system, the Unit Manager placed the call, dialing a number that
reportedly began with area code 347. Mr. Epstein told Mr. Bullock he was calling his
mother who, according to public records, has been deceased since 2004.
It is recommended that all telephone calls, other than legal calls, be made on monitored
lines to be available for post-call review or on a speaker phone so staff can monitor what
is discussed.

Section 5: There is no documentation to substantiate that a Lieutenant facilitated two
telephone calls to Mr. Epstein. However, there is documented evidence that Unit
Mana ernrovided a call to Mr. Epstein on July 30. 2019, at 5:15 p.m.. to a
. friend, on a monitored telephone/speaker phone. The call was documented in a
log that is maintained in the Correctional Systems Department. Mr. Epstein was
provided a call because he had not been able to conduct voice recording on the inmate
telephone. This is standard procedure by the Unit Team at MCC New York, to
occasionally provide a call to new arrivals, when necessary.

6. Direct Observation;  Mr. Epstein was on suicide watch from July 23, 2019, until
July 24, 2019. While on suicide watch on July 23, 2019, Mr. Epstein attended an
attorney visit from approximately 12:40 p.m. until 7:15 p.m. During this time, he was
without "direct, continuous observation" by a dedicated BOP staff member as required by
P5324.08. While on Psychological Observation, he attended attorney visits on
July 24, 2019, for 11.25 hours; on July 25, 2019, for 11.25 hours; on July 26, 2019, for
9.25 hours; on July 27, 2019, for 11.33 hours; on July 28, 2019, for 10.5 hours; and on
July 29, 2019, for 8 hours. On July 30, 2019, Psychology Observation was terminated.
11
SDNY_0001 7742
During these visits, continuous observation by a dedicated BOP staff member was not
maintained as required by MCC New York's Procedural Memorandum for Psychological
Observation.

6. Direct Observation
The Psychology Department has eliminated Psychology Observation at MCC-NY.
Inmates on Suicide Watch are only provided legal visits under special circumstances as
deemed by the Court.

7. Follow -Ur  Mr. Epstein arrived at MCC New York on Saturda July 6, 2019. While
conducting the 10:00 p.m. institution count that evening,  Facilities Assistant
N ed she observed Mr. E stein in his cell. In an e-mail she sent to Drs. and
and Lieutenant later that evening, she described Mr. Epstein as
"distraught, sad and a little confused." She said she then asked Mr. Epstein if he was
7. Follow Un
Staff have been trained when they have concerns for an inmate's mental health, they need to
make verbal contact with either Psychology Staff or a Lieutenant. If Psychology is not in the
institution, an inmate is placed on suicide watch, and the on-call psychologist and Warden is
notified.
All Psychology Staff added a response to their incoming emails. This automatic replay
states. "If you are emailing about an inmate that may be at risk for suicide or self-harm, this
is an emergency situation. Please make sure that you make contact (verbally) to Psychology
Staff or the on-call psychologist. Please ensure to maintain constant visual observation of the
inmate until formal steps can be taken to ensure his/her safety pending a formal assessment
by a Psychologist."
The Psychology Department uses PSY ALERT codes more frequently with high profile cases
and with inmates with a history or charge of a sex offense. The PSY ALERT code is applied
more immediately and not just when an inmate is about to leave the institution. If an inmate
is moved in and out of our institution for court, etc., the inmate is assessed more immediately
prior to being released to a unit.
R&D staff have been reminded of the Marshall and Court alert notices. Psychology Staff are
notified immediately if there are suicidal concerns noted by the Courts. If Psychology is not
in the institution, an inmate that enters the institution with an alert notice is placed on suicide
watch, and the on-call psychologist and Warden is notified. These inmates receive a suicide
risk assessment by a psychologist before being released to the general population.
12
SDNY_00017743
Psvc Svc,
okay, and he reportedly said he was. However, Ms. noted in her e-mail she was
not convinced of this, adding, "He seems dazed and withdrawn." She went on to say, "So
just to be on the safe side and prevent any suicidal thoughts can someone from
Psychology come and talk with him." Despite the fact that Lieutenant opened
the e-mail there is no evidence that he contacted the on-call psychologist as is required by
P5324.08, Suicide Prevention Prowl= Additionally, if Ms. was concerned about
suicide risk, P5324.08 Suicide Prevention Prom- re tyres her to maintain direct,
continuous observation of Mr. Epstein. When Dr. o ened the e-mail the following
Monday morning, Mr. Epstein was evaluated by Dr. at approximately
9:30 a.m.
Psvc Svc

Mr. Epstein was denied bail on Thursday, July 18, 2019. This was a significant
disappointment for Mr. Epstein and likely challenged his ability and willingness to adapt
to incarceration. Given the potential impact of the judge's decision, a psychologist
should have assessed Mr. Epstein's mental status upon his return to the institution. The
BOP developed a SENTRY assignment of PSY ALERT for purposes such as this.
Specifically PSY ALERT is used "to ensure, if movement occurs, that all staff consider
the special psychological and management -related risks associated with the inmate."
Furthermore, P5324.07 SF.NTRY Psvcholozv Alert Function  states, "When a decision to
move [any PSY ALERT] inmate occurs, any special psychological needs of the inmate
are reviewed and considered by Psychology Services staff [and] any safety and security
concerns are highlighted for non-Psychology Services staff." Psychologists should use
the PSY ALERT assignment more frequently with high profile cases and with inmates
who have a history or charge of sex offense. Both of these groups of inmates are
susceptible to exaggerated or unrealistic fears about correctional settings and experience
stress associated during movement and periods of transition (e.g., cell/unit changes,
movement to and from court, institutional movement, and release of information through
the media).
PP-63 Func

Mr. Epstein was reportedly in court on July 31, 2019. It is unknown what time he
departed or returned to MCC New York because this information was not entered in
SENTRY. Regardless, upon his return, the United States Marshals Service (USMS)
provided R&D staff with a Prisoner Custody Alert Notice regarding Mr. Epstein. The
notice indicated Mr. Epstein had "MTL Mental Concerns Suicidal Tendencies." The
USMS requested R&D staff sign the form and they then departed with the signed copy.
On August I, 2019, at 8:46 a.m., Dr. sent Dr. an e-mail reporting she had
just become aware of the above information. In the absence of additional information
about this notation, this should have been considered a referral to Psychology Services
about a potentially suicidal inmate and procedures should have been followed as outlined
in P5324.08, Suicide Prevention Profram,  Specifically, when a staff member becomes
aware an inmate may be thinking about suicide during normal working hours, that staff
13
SDNY_0001 7744
member must contact Psychology Services and maintain the inmate under
direct,continuous observation until he is placed on Suicide Watch or seen by a
psychologist. There is no evidence Mr. Epstein was monitored under these conditions
from the time he returned from court until he was seen by Dr. for a suicide risk
assessment on August 1, 2019, at approximately 1:30 p.m.
Exec

8. Jnmate Accountability and Assignment Accuracy. According to a SENTRY quarters
roster generated on August 10, 2019, at 12:51 a.m., there were three inmates assigned to
Mr. Epstein's SHU cell, Z04-206LAD, including him, at the time of his death. However,
his SHU cell was only a double occupancy cell. Inmate Patrick Avila (#86710-054),
inmate Gregory Ferrer (#79793-054), and Mr. Epstein were all assigned to the same cell.
On August 13, 2019, at 12:06 p.m. and 12:08 p.m., a quarters history roster was
generated for inmate Avila and Ferrer, respectively. Inmate Avila's cell assignment was
Z04-206LAD from August 5, 2019, until August 11, 2019, when he was moved to cell
Z04-212UAD. Inmate Ferrer's cell assignment was Z04-206UAD from August 1, 2019,
until August 11, 2019, when he was moved to cell 2.04-207LAD. A quarters history
roster was generated for Mr. Epstein on August 13, 2019, at 9:07 a.m. His cell
assignment was 2.04-206LAD from July 29, 2019, until August 10, 2019.
On Monday, August 12, 2019, photographs ofnametags on SHU cell doors and SHU
locator forms were sent to the Correctional Service Department in the Northeast Region.
The SHU locator form is dated August 9, 2019. It shows inmate Ferrer in cell 207L
(SENTRY states he was moved to this cell on August 11, 2019), inmate Avila in cell
212U (SENTRY states he was moved to this cell on August 11, 2019), inmate Epstein in
cell 220L (SENTRY never shows him in this cell) along with inmate Reyes (#85993-
054). The locator shows inmate Copper (#92299-054) and inmate Dockery (#60685-050)
in cell 206. The photo sheets show the cell being 220 with inmates Epstein and Reyes'
identification cards on the door. Inmate Reyes, Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 was in cell
Z06-220U from August 5, 2019 to August 9, 2019.
Psvc Svc
MCC New York has four suicide watch cells and each is for single occupancy use. The
suicide watch cells are located in Health Services. Each cell is abbreviated with the unit
code HO1 in SENTRY followed by the four-digit cell number. The doors are identified
by a painted number from one to four. Two reviews were conducted. The first revealed

Mr. Epstein was in H01-001L according to SENTRY but the Suicide Watch Log Books
indicate he was in cell 4. A second review was conducted on August 13, 2019, while
there were four inmates on in these cells. SENTRY showed two inmates assigned to
HO1-001L, one assigned to H01-002L, and the fourth inmate assigned to a general
population housing unit. Through physical observation of the dedicated suicide watch
cells there were four HOI cells, however a review of the BOPWARE Inmate Housing
Format, only shows three cells.
14
SDNY_00017745
Exec
Inmate movement and assignments are not accurately reflected in SENTRY as
required by P5500.14 Correctional Service Procedures Manual

8. Inmate Accountability and Assignment Accuracy
With regard to the accuracy and accountability of inmates placed on suicide watch status in
the hospital area, Psychology Services now runs a daily Sentry roster of all the inmates on
suicide watch in the hospital area. The roster is examined to ensure that the inmates placed
on suicide watch in a suicide watch cell are keyed into SENTRY with the correct cell
assignment noted. The Associate Warden, Programs, is notified if there are any
inconsistencies. Moreover, the four suicide watch cells now all have Sentry Assignments of
HO I -001L - H01-004L.
Exec Staff

9. Attorney 102 Books; Four log books were not secured following Mr. Epstein's
death. Specifically, three Attorney Log Books located in the Attorney Visiting
and Front Lobby areas and an Inmate Search Log Book located in the Attorney
Visiting area were not secured. All four books were still in use at the outset of
the reconstruction and after the reconstruction team advised staff to secure them.
P5324.08 states, "In the event of a suicide, institution staff, particularly
Correctional Services staff, and other law enforcement personnel, will handle the
site with the same level of protection as any crime scene in which a death has
occurred." This policy further states, "All possible evidence and documentation
will be preserved to provide data and support for subsequent investigators doing
a psychological reconstruction."
Further, a review of the attorney log books identified many errors and signify a
systemic concern. For example, there were two concurrently open attorney log
books in the Attorney Visiting area. Further, the different purposes of the two
attorney log books, one in the Attorney Visit area and one in the Front Lobby,
could not be explained. BOP staff were unable to articulate a system of control
for the log books, and during the reconstruction, some of the log books could not
be accounted for. Within the log books, entries were made out of chronological
order, attorneys did not consistently sign in and out, significant information was
illegible or missing, columns were not consistently labeled, log book opening
and closing dates were inconsistent, and the cover had been tom off of several
books. At the current time, these log books are not functioning as an adequate
system of control and monitoring.
15
SDNY_0001 7746

10. Automatic External Defibrillators: A review of available AEDs in the
institution revealed that the list used for accountability and inspection purposes
was inaccurate and incomplete.
10: A review of the Automatic External Defibrillators (AED) report presented by
Great Lakes Biomedical Services dated July 22, 2019, revealed that all AEDS were
accounted for and were placed in the correct perspective areas. The report was
accurate and complete. New AEDs have been purchased and will be inspected Great
Lakes Biomedical Services, upon their arrival. It must be noted that the list reviewed
by the reconstruction team was an old and outdated list (January 8, 2018).

II. Post Orders & SHU Training:, SHU Post Orders Sign-In Sheets were reviewed
for the 3`d Quarter, spanning June 9, 2019, to September 7, 2019. Officer L. Grey
failed to sign post orders for SHU #3 post.
Quarterly SHU Training Sign-In Sheets were reviewed. The 2019 3s Quarter SHU
Training was conducted on June 6, 2019. Three staff assigned to the 3s Quarter
SHU Roster in SHU did not attend or receive the SHU Training:  Officer David

11. Post Orders & SHU Training
The Suicide Watch Post Orders is located in the Lieutenant's Office with a quarterly
sign-in sheet. All staff members assigned to a suicide watch post are responsible for
signing the post orders prior to performing the staff suicide watch.
With regard to SHU Suicide Prevention training, this continues to be carried out on a
quarterly basis. However, the sign-in sheets for this training are now be examined by the
SHU Lieutenant for accuracy. If a staff member who is assigned to SHU misses the
training, they see the Chief Psychologist and schedule a time to receive a make-up
session for the SHU Suicide Prevention Training.
Psvc Svc

12. Stuffing: The Drug Abuse Program Coordinator positon at MCC New York was
abolished during Phase 1 of the staff realignment during fiscal year 2018. Re-
establishing
the Drug Abuse Program Coordinator position would provide the institution with
an additional supervisory psychologist to provide critical clinical services.
Staffing in the Correctional Services department is relevant to the
reconstruction. However, the details about this topic are provided in an After
Action Review completed separately from this report.
16
SDNY_0001 7747

12. Staffing
The current Drug Abuse Coordinator position is currently a shared position. The
Warden is currently working on re-establishing the Drug Abuse Coordinator position
as a full-time position to provide the Psychology Department with an additional
supervisory psychologist to perform critical clinical services. At the current time, the
position has been formally announced.
Psvc Svc

13. Sex Offense Risk Factors: A broad understanding of risk factors associated with
sex offenders, by staff at MCC New York, did not appear to be present in all
staff but was vital to his adjustment and safety in prison. A more focused
management strategy is recommended, particularly in complex and high profile
cases. Supplemental training on sex-offender specific risk factors is
recommended for all staff and should be provided by Executive Staff and
Psychology Services.

13. Sex Offense Risk Factors
The Chief Psychologist or her representative continues to be present at all Executive
Staff Meetings, Department Head Meetings, and SHU meetings. During these
meetings, the Chief Psychologist offers feedback regarding the treatment and
management of sex offender inmates. Additionally, the Chief Psychologist
continues to educate all staff during Institution Familiarization (IF) and Annual
Training (AT), about the sex offender specific risk factors and suicidality.
17
SONY 00017748
DOCUMENTS EXAMINED
TRU-INTEL Download Report of Incident (583), 586, & Global Report
TRUVIEW - Money Exchanged; Phone, Email, & Visitor Lists; Calls: Messages; Visits;
Timeline
TRU-SCOPE - Logs, High Risk Inmates, Inmates Lists, etc.
Staff Memorandums
Staff E-Mail
Photographs of Scene; Deceased, Autopsy
Video Showing Scene and Staff Response
Sentry Documentation
SIS Case File Index
Psychology File PDS-BEMR
Psychological Observation Procedural Memorandum
Post Orders
Lieutenant Logs
Attorney Logs
Staff Roster
Medical Information/Records (BEMR)
BOP Twenty -Four Hour Death Report
he -Sentence Report
Note(s) Left Behind by Deceased
Time Line
Autopsy Request & Report
Inmate Central File
Court Return Screening Form
Prisoner Remand Form (If applicable)
USM 129 Individual Custody/Detention Report (If applicable)
Prisoner Custody Alert Notice
Staff Sign -In Log I Week Prior to Suicide (If applicable)
Detention Orders (If applicable)
30 minute SHU rounds
BP 292's & 295's
18
SDNY_0001 7749
EFTA01379915 (Jmail)
 [government] grand jury proceedings subpoena of Eric Schmidt's Hillspire
(approximate date: 2020-06-29)
Barry Pechenik Credit Suisse
Court, Suite 1100" Dallas TX 75201 US
Vice President "200 Crescent
bpechenl 0/0/00
SMTP
Unspecified
False
Judy
0/0/00
Normal False
Christian
Participant
0/0/00
Barry Pechenik (
B.P.
Normal
Cumberbatch
Normal
Cram Credit Suisse
"One Atlantic Center
1201 West Peachtree Street,ne
SMTP Judy Cumberbatch
Unspecified
Normal
0/0/00
J.C.
SAEN 2: PCS ATLANTA Associate Program
Suite 3650" Atlanta GA 30326 US

• ccram 0/0/00
/o=CREDIT-SUISSE/ou=Exchange Administrative Group
(FYDIBOHF23SPDLT)/cn=Recipients/cn=christian.cram
Unspecified C.C.
Normal False Normal
Forrestal Capital
0/0/00 0/0/00
Unspecified
Annette Franqui
Carlos Hernandez-Artigas
Jonathan Fischer
Joshua Green Corp
0/0/00
Unspecified
It
Hillspire
Menlo Park
0/0/00
Unspecified
Scott Olle
F.C.
Normal False
J.G.C.
0/0/00
Normal False
LLC
CA 94025
0/0/00
Amber Caska, Investment CFO
Hillspire LLC
(direct)
Normal
Normal
0/0/00
EX "Cram, Christian"
Monarch Plaza
"1010 El Camino
United States of America
H.L.
"Woods Staton - ARCO
"Stan McCammon
Real, Suite 200"
"Eric Schmidt family office
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0077858
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00224042
╔════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Alexander Guest [friend] socialite, son of CZ Guest 
         Mozilla [tech] maker of the Firefox browser 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01249291 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from former escort about Alexander Guest, Ghislaine, and Epstein
(inferred timestamp: 2020-07-03 20:44:00)
500-NY-3027571 Serial 416
Inlake (Rev. 5-2347) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Intake
Date: 07/03/2020
Case ID #: SOD-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted Hy:
Date/Time Received: 07/03/2020 04:44 PM EDT
Details:
NTOC2020-MC3185vkav01
On 07/03/2020, at 4:44 p.m. EST,
submitted a tip to the FBI
National Threat Operations Center to report her involvement with Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine
Maxwell in Manhatten, NY in 2005.
provided the following information:
Date Submitted: 07/03/2020 04:44:21 PM ET
Transaction Number: D3D48BB1-8362-4632-9276-11529076D11A
Threat To Life: False
Submitted Text:
Hello, I am who has been living in NYC from 1999 to 2006. I was an escort working
for high end escorts services. Ghislaine Maxwell reached out to me to meet Epstein. She had my
number thru a friend of one of the agency I was working with. She asked me to meet Estein in a
hotel in Manhattan , she was specific about the lingerie I had to wear. Met Epstein with at least 4 or
5 other girls, I was more than 20, I can t rememeber the age of the other girls. She paid me very
cheap. I remember Epstein who was ok and very passive but also recall her. When I finished with
Epstein, she called being very angry about me not sending her money.(300$/half for her, she
insulted me and threatened me Not usual for me to have to deal with such an attitude for so little
money. I do know about clients who were regulars and proof of them being obviously pedophiles. I
do not want money or anything from them. I am honnest and sincere. Alexander Guest NYC
socialite was one of them. I want to help as much as I can as those people destroyed a part of me.
Violation: Other
3501.284-001
Page I of 3
SOD-NY-3027571 Serial 416
Re: 500-NY-3027571, 07/03/2020
Violation Questions:
What was the exact crime that occurred?: Ghislaine Maxwell informations
When did the crimeAncident occur? (Please provide an approximate date and time): 2005
Where did the crime/incident occur? (Please provide the specific location/address if possible): New
York City
Complainant Information:
First Name:
Middle Name:
Last Name:
Age:
DOB
Additional Info:
Type: Home
Phone
Extension:
Account:
Type: Other
Address:
City:
Zip:
Country:
Subject Information:
First Name: Ghislaine
Middle Name:
Last Name: Maxwell
Age: 50
DOB:
Additional Info: I v said all in first request.
How is Contact Known: Thru an Escort service.
Type: Other
Address:
City:
Zip:
Witness Information:
First Name:
Middle Name:
Last Name:
Age:
3501.284-001
Page2of3
50D-NY-3027571 Serial 416
Re: 50D-NY-3027571, 07/03/2020
DOB:
Additional Info: Said all above.
How is Contact Known: Escort service
Type: Other
Address:
City:
Zip:
Remote IP:
Remote Host: api.fbi.gov
Http Referrer: https://wwwmooale.com/
User Browser: Mozilla/5.0 (Linux; Android 8.0.0; SM-G930F) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like
Gecko) Chrome/83.0.4103.106 Mobile Safari/537.36
Country: BE
• •
3501.284-001
Page 3 of 3
EFTA01249294 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from former escort about Alexander Guest, Ghislaine, and Epstein
(inferred timestamp: 2020-07-03 21:21:00)
500 -NY -3027571 Serial Lri'
Inlake (Rev. 5-2347) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
intake
Date: 07/03/2020
Case ID I: 50D-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 07/03/2020 05:21 PM EDT
Details:
On 07/03/2020, at 5:21:13 PM Eastern Time,
IDENTITY],
[PROTECT
, called the FBI National Threat Operations Center
(NTOC) to report solicitation for prostitution by Alexander Guest,
Jeffrey Epstein, and Ghislaine Maxwell.
provided the following information:
was an escort from age 19 to 22 years old. One
client was NY socialite, Alexander Guest (Alexander), son of Lucy Douglad
"CZ" Guest. Alexander paid $4,000 a night for sex one night every
week for two years and gave $50,000 cash as a birthday gift.
Alexander stopped seeing when was 22 years old stating that
was too old.
Alexander only liked young girls as sexual partners and fantasized about
having sex with 15 year old
Alexander's ex-wife, Elizabeth Guest (Elizabeth) of the relationship with
Alexander. Elizabeth advised that
). advised
3501.284-002
Page I of 2
500 -NY -3027571 Serial 418
Re: 50D-NY-3027571, 07/03/2020
. Elizabeth advised that Alexander is associated with
Jeffrey Epstein, and Alexander claimed to know President Clinton.
In a separate incident when was 20 years old, Ghislaine Maxwell
hired via telephone and instructed to purchase a black bra and
lingerie and meet Epstein. and ten other girls, unknown
identifiers and ages (UNSUBS2), massaged Epstein and gave him a "hand
job". Epstein was cheap and didn't want to pay. was paid $300 for
the hour. returned home and Maxwell threatened via telephone II
if did not transfer $150
to Maxwell's bank account.
transferred the money to Maxwell.
stopped escorting at 22 years of age.
• •
2
3501.284-002
Page 2 of 2
EFTA00008631 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Ghislaine Maxwell
EFTA00008920 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Ghislaine Maxwell
╔══════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Icarine [modeling] agency with connections to Jean Luc Brunel 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00077200 (Jmail)
 [girls] French Ministry of Justice allegations that Jean Luc Brunel drugged a model and Epstein + Ghislaine assaulted a minor
(date: 2020-07-08)
FRENCH REPUBLIC
MINISTRY OF JUSTICE
APPEAL COURT OF PARIS
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR'S OFFICE OF
PARIS COURT OF JUSTICE
Paris, July 8, 2020
DIVISION
Section P4 - Public Prosecution Service for Minors. The Public Prosecutor
To
Prosecutor-General at the Appeal Court of
Paris.
SUBJECT: Request for international legal assistance in criminal matter addressed to the United States authorities 
concerning the investigation related to Jean
-Luc BRUNEI., and others, in connection with the "EPSTEIN case".
N/REF : prosecution number : 19 235 449
V/REF :
APPLICANT AUTHORITY
The Public Prosecutor at the Paris Court of Justice.
AUTHORITY ADDRESSED TO
The competent authorities of the United States of America.
Having regard to the accord between the European Union and the United States of America dated June
25, 2003 which entered into force on February 1, 2010 ;
Having regard to the Article 14 of the Treaty on Mutual Legal Assistance between France and the United
States dated December 10, 1998, we request that this application and the acts resulting therefrom be
kept confidential, without condition as to the duration, in accordance with the provisions of Article 11
of the French Code of Criminal Procedure relating to the secrecy of the investigation and the inquiry;
Having regard to the reciprocity;
The Public Prosecutor at the Paris Court of Justice, expressing high regards to the competent judicial
authority of the United States of America, submits a request for mutual legal assistance in criminal
matters in the investigation related to Jean-Luc BRUNEL and others in connection with the case termed
as "EPSTEIN" case.
LNVESTIGATIVE FRAMEWORK
Preliminary investigation initiated on August 30, 2019 on charges of rape committed against a minor of 15 years of age, 
rape committed against a minor of over
15 years of age, rape, sexual assault on a minor
over 15 years of age, sexual assault, participation in an association
Public Prosecutor Section of Court of Justice
Pavia du Tribunal de Paris
75859 PARIS CEDEX I7
re
ct
orn Translator
registered with
the Appeal
Court of Paris
(English)
of criminals for the preparation of a crime, participation in an association of criminals for the preparation of an 
offence punishable by at least 5 years'
imprisonment;
Article 11 of the Criminal Procedure Code
Unless otherwise provided by law and without prejudice to the rights of the defense, the proceedings during the 
investigation and inquiry shall be secret.
Any person who assists in such proceedings shall be bound by professional secrecy under the conditions and is subject to
the penalties laid down in articles 226
-13 and 226 -14 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
However, in order to prevent the dissemination of fragmented or inaccurate information or to put an end to a disturbance
of public order, the public prosecutor
may, ex officio and at the request of the investigating court or the parties, make public objective elements taken from 
the proceedings that do not include any
assessment of the merits of the charges against the persons concerned.
Article 75 of the Criminal Procedure Code
The judicial police officers and, under their supervision, the investigating officers designated in Article 20 shall 
conduct preliminary investigations either
on the instructions of the public prosecutor of the Republic or ex officio
These operations shall be under the supervision of the public prosecutor.
Article 75 -1 of the Criminal Procedure ..e
When instructing the judicial police officers to carry out a preliminary investigation, the public prosecutor shall set 
the time limit within which the
investigation must be carried out. He may extend it based on the justifications provided by the investigators. Where the
investigation is conducted ex officio,
the judicial police officers shall report to the public prosecutor on the progress of the investigation when it has been
under way for more than six months.
Article 75 -2 of the Criminal Procedure Code A criminal investigation officer conducting a preliminary investigation 
into a crime or misdemeanour shall notify
the public prosecutor as soon as a person against whom there is evidence that he or she has committed or attempted to 
commit the offence is identified.
Artidellimiaftcdminainic
French criminal law is applicable to anyone who is guilty on the territory of the French Republic, as an accomplice, of 
a crime or offence committed abroad if
the crime or offence is punishable both by French law and by foreign law and if it has been established by a final 
decision of the foreign court.
Article 113 - 6 of the Criminal Procedure Code French criminal law is applicable to any crime committed by a French 
person outside the territory of the French
Republic.
It is applicable to crimes committed by French nationals outside the territory of the Republic if the acts arc 
punishable under the law of the country where
they were committed.
It is applicable to infringements of the provisions of Regulation (EC) No 561 /2006 of the European Parliament and of 
the Council of March 15, 2006 on the
harmonization of certain social legislation relating to road transport, committed in another Member State of the 
European Union and established in France,
subject to the provisions of Article 692 of the Code of Procedure
Public Prosecutor Section of the court of justice Parvis du Tribunal de Paris 75859 PARIS CEDEX 17
v% AT 7:4
e 4,„,tr -sr,J sworn Translator .15 e t registered with
ct the Appeal
* Court of Paris .....
0 (English) /7 ( English)
44/ertin -
*
criminal or the justification of an administrative sanction that has been enforced or can no longer be enforced.
This article shall be applied even if the accused has acquired French nationality after the act attributed to him.
Article 113 - 7 of the Criminal Procedure Code
French criminal law is applicable to any crime, as well as to any offence punishable by imprisonment, committed by a 
French person or by a foreigner outside the
territory of the French Republic when the victim is a French national at the time of the offence.
Article 222 - 23 of the Criminal Code
Any act of sexual penetration, of whatever nature, committed on another person or on a person perpetrated through 
violence, coercion, threat or surprise is
rape. Rape is punishable by 15 years' imprisonment.
Article 222 - 24 of the Criminal Code
Rape is punishable by twenty years' imprisonment:

(1) Where it has resulted in mutilation or permanent disability
(2) When it is committed on a minor under fifteen years of age;

(3) When it is committed on a person whose particular vulnerability, due to age, illness, infirmity, physical or 
psychological disability or pregnancy, is
apparent or known to the perpetrator;
(3 A) When it is committed on a person whose particular vulnerability or dependence resulting from the precariousness of
his economic or social situation is
apparent or known to the perpetrator;

(4) When it is committed by an ascendant or by any other person having de jure or de facto authority over the victim;

(5) When it is committed by a person who abuses the authority conferred on him by his functions;
(6) When it is committed by several persons acting as perpetrator or accomplice;

(7) When it is committed with the use or threat of a weapon;
(8) When the victim has been put in contact with the perpetrator through the use of an electronic communication network 
for the dissemination of messages to an
unspecified public;

(9) (Repealed)
(10) When it is committed in conjunction with one or more other rapes committed on other victims,

(11) Where it is committed by the spouse or partner of the victim linked to the victim by a civil solidarity pact ;

(12) When it is committed by a person acting in a state of manifest intoxication or under the influence of narcotic 
products;
Public Prosecutor Section of coup of justice Parvis du Tribunal do Paris
75859 PARIS CEDEX 17
0
NArrq
Sworn Translator
registered with
the Appeal
Court of Paris
(English)
*
3 / 7
Martin 7513

(13) Where it is committed, in the exercise of this activity, on a person who engages in prostitution, including 
occasionally ;

(14) Where a minor was present at the time of the offence and participated.
(15) Where a substance has been administered to the victim, without his knowledge, in order to impair his discernment or
the control of his acts.
Article 222 - 29 of the Criminal Procedure Code
Sexual assaults other than rape are punishable by seven years' imprisonment and a fine of 100,000 curos when perpetrated
:
(I) On a minor of fifteen years;
(2) On a person whose particular vulnerability due to age, illness, infirmity, physical or psychological
disability or pregnancy is apparent or known to the perpetrator.
Article 450 - 1 of the Criminal Procedure Code
An association of criminals is any group formed or agreement established for the purpose of preparation, characterized 
by one or more material facts, one or
more crimes or one or more offences punishable by at least five years' imprisonment.
Where the offences prepared are crimes or misdemeanours punishable by ten years' imprisonment, participation in a 
criminal conspiracy shall be punishable by ten
years' imprisonment and a fine of 150,000 euros.
Where the offences prepared are crimes or misdemeanours punishable by at least five years' imprisonment, participation 
in a criminal conspiracy shall be
punishable by five years' imprisonment and a fine of EUR 75 000.
STATEMENT OF CASE
On August 23, 2019, the Minors' Section of the Paris Public Prosecutor's Office initiated a preliminary investigation 
into the charges of rape, rape of a minor
over 15 years of age, rape of a minor under 15 years of age, sexual assault, sexual assault of a minor over 15 years of 
age, sexual assault of a minor under 15
years of age, participation in a criminal association with a view to committing a crime punishable by at least 5 years' 
imprisonment for the actions of Jeffrey
EPSTEIN and his possible accomplices, at the prejudice of French victims. The investigations is initiated at the Central
Office for the Repression of Violence
against Persons of the Central Directorate of the Judicial Police.
In fact, on 23 July 2019 and 12 August 2019, the Public Prosecutor's Office received a report from the association for 
the defense of children's interests
"Innocence en danger" in which it was stated that "France is concerned by this case since the investigations conducted 
by the FBI have brought to light several
persons of French nationality. From a reliable source, "Innocence en danger" recently confirmed that several victims of 
the prostitution network created by
Jeffrey Epstelia Ces are also of French nationality. Attached to this report was a letter from Mrs. in which she related
that she had made otest-photograph" for
the agency "Karin Models" during the summer of when she was 18 years old. During this session, Jean-Luc BRUNEI, - 
director of the model agency - had sexually
assaulted her. The acts are barred by statutes of limitations.
According to reports in the national and international press, the EPSTEIN case had arisen several weeks earlier in the 
context of an investigation by the
Federal Bureau of Investigations - Ncw York office -following the revelations of several young women who had been 
sexually assaulted by the latter, in AT Li
Public Prosecutor Section of coun of justice 4 / 7 0 -1  4, Parris du Tribunal de Paris
75859 PARIS CEDEX 17 Sworn Translator
registered with
the Appeal
Court of Paris 41? (English) (tt
5d3n)//tin - 7
United States and abroad. He is suspected of having sexually exploited dozens of young girls, some of them very young, 
between 2002 and 2005, and of having set
up a "network" that would have benefited several other men, including French nationals, including Jean-Luc BRUNEL, a 
close friend of Jeffrey EPSTEIN who would
have provided him with young girls from his agency's pool, and Ghislaine MAXWELL, who would have organized the arrival 
and stay in Jeffrey EPSTEIN's various
residences of the future victims..
And according to press reports, the victims heard by the American investigation services reported sexual assaults and 
rapes committed by Jeffrey EPSTEIN both in
the United States and in France - in PARIS, a city where he owned a mansion not far from the Arc de Triomphe, and by 
Jean-Luc BRUNEL, in various places but
especially at his Parisian home on Avenue Roche.
In the summer of 2019, upon his return from a stay in Paris, Jeffrey EPSTEIN was arrested, charged and detained in 
Manhattan. He was found hanging in his cell
some time later.
The French investigation gathered several elements objectivizing the relationship between Jeffrey EP-STEIN and Jean-Luc 
BRUNEL. In addition, several testimonies
collected reported the sexual abuses committed by Jean-Luc BRUNEL, these offences being barred by statutes of 
limitations :
born on of_ nationality, indicated having introduced herself, in
and when she was 18 years old, to several modeling agencies, including the ICARINE agency. There she met Jean-Luc BRUNEL
and they agreed fora  session at the
latter's home in Paris, in the Bourse district. Both of them were having dinner. felt that she had been drugged, since 
she could not explain how she had
suddenly, without understanding how, found herself in the room with Jean-Luc BRUNEL. She had not wanted sexual 
intercourse but had felt powerless in the face of
the solicitations and insistence of the respondent, who penetrated her with his sexual organ. Another man, unidentified,
had been in the apartment at the time
of the rape, without participating in it. The photo session did not take place. She stated that at the time Jean-Luc 
BRUNEL used to bring in girls from the
East, particularly young girls. stated that she had felt strong repercussions following the events. She had had no 
further contact with Jean-Luc BRUNEL after
this specific episode, and did not wish to lodge a complaint.
born on EIMIS of= nationality, stated that she had met Jeffrey EP-STEIN and his partner Ghislaine MAXWELL at the age of 
16, in the south of France near Saint
Tro-pez. They had made friends and she went to their Parisian apartment on Avenue Focb in 2000. The same year, she left 
for Miami with the couple, 6 months
later, she was invited to New York by Ghislaine MAXWELL, near the 5th avenue. It was during these 5 days that Jeffrey 
EPSTEIN was touching the girl, who tried
in vain to resist him. Shc remembered in particular that he had penetrated her with a vibrator. She had never met 
Jean-Luc BRUNEL.
born said she had met Jean-Luc BRUNEL through her raoaeling activities (t o e s agency, located in Paris 8th district, 
Avenue Roche). She had been invited to
his Parisian apartment, drank a cocktail prepared by the defendant, then lost consciousness. The next day, she woke up 
in a bathrobe and noticed bruises on her
thighs and crotch. She remembered that a man posing as Prince Albert de Monaco had called Jean-Luc BRUNEL while she was 
in the apartment.
born oilinina tional , said she had met Jean-Luc BRUNEL through the Paris Planning agency (mo e ing agency) and Karin 
Models. She s Parisian apartment at the
invitation of lean-Luc BRUNEL, with him and a certa' worked at Paris Planning. They were leaving for the countryside to 
an undetermined p ace, where Jean-Luc
BRUNEL tried to rape the young woman, who was resisting him. He then proceeded to young woman.
Public Prosecutor Section
Parris du Tribunal de Paris
75859 PARIS CEDE< 17
in a
who
Sworn Translator
registered with
the Appeal
Court of pans
(English)
On August 12, 2019, the Paris Public Prosecutor's Office also re iv m a Parisian lawyer
reporting the accusations of  born on , against Ghislaine
MAXWELL, Jeffrey EPSTEIN and Jean-Luc BRUNEL, claiming that Ghislaine MAXWELL had
recruited her at the age of 16 for sexual exploitation.
The Parisian residence of Jeffrey EPSTEIN located at 22 avenue Foch. Paris 16th district, was
searched on Monday, September 23, 2019. It allowed the seizure of two MAC computers, several
storage media such as USB keys, documents relating to Ghislaine IsAAX_WPT I y photographs
of young and even very young women, including photographs of
The computer verification of the seized material made it possible in particular to reveal the following
elements:
- Numerous photographs showing young girls partially or totally undressed were found in the
hard disk;
- 30 videos with shooting dates between 2011 and 2015, showing young girls, sometimes
dancing in an apartment,
- Documents relating to the former Jeffrey EPSTEIN trials.
In addition, Jeffrey EPSTEIN's Gmail account (jeevacationegmail.com) was analyzed. 4500 emails were
apprehended, notably referring to Jean-Luc BRUNEL, in addition to emails related to Jeffrey
EPSTEIN's accusations, women or appointments.
Finally, a CD ROM with the inscription "CONFIDENTIAL - COMPREHENSIVE CHART" was used
to retrieve an excel file containing a list of 62 names of women.
OBJECT OF THE REQUEST
With regard to the above-mentioned elements, we would be thankful to the competent authorities of the
United States of America if they could communicate to us the acts of investigation carried out in the
United States of America and in particular :
Any hearing (hearing as a defendant or as a witness) and any investigative acts (search, computer
exploitation, documents seized, written statements), concerning the sexual exploitation of minors or
adults, relating to the following persons:
- Jean-Luc BRUNEL,
-  Ghislaine MAXWELL, arrested on American soil on Thursday, July 2, 2020,
Any information, hearings and acts of investigation concerning victims of French nationality, having
been in contact with Jeffrey EPSTEIN, Jean-Luc BRUNEL or Ghislaine MAXWELL;
Any information useful to bring out the truth;
- Provide the results of the requested investigations in the form of a working copy that can be used.
We also inform them that we will make available to them all the investigative documents resulting from
the procedure carried out in France.
DEADLINE
The competent authorities of the United States of America are requested to provide assistance as soon
as possible.
Public Prosecution Sention of Court of Justice
Pais du Tribunal de Pins
75859 PARIS CEDEX 17
Ct.\
%. Swot"' Translator
registged with
4 the Appeal.
Court of Paris
(English)
ar±in - 7
A
CONFIDENTIALITY
The competent authorities of the United States of America are requested to keep this application and its
contents confidential.
CONTACTS
French Central Authority :
Office of International Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters
Criminal Affairs and Pardons Branch
Ministry of Justice
Magistrate who issued this request for mutual legal assistance:
Aude GROUALLE, Vice-Prosecutor, Head of the Paris Public Prosecutor's Office for Minors
Barthelemy HENNUYER, Substitute
Minors' Section of the Paris Public Prosecutor's Office
The Public Prosecutor of the Republic at the Judicial Court of Paris thanks the judicial authorities of the
United States of America for their helpfulness and valuable collaboration, assures them of its reciprocity
and renews the expression of its highest consideration.
July 8, 2020
For the Public Prosecutor
Barthelemy HENNUYER, Substitute
Seal of the Parts court ofJustice
Signature Illegible.

I. the undersigned Arindam ahattacharya,
Sworn translator registered with the
Appeal Court of Paris, certify that the
following translation is true to the original
document in French ,, AA
bearing the number .r  I no  v .
Paris, Date: IS I lets
Public Prosecutor Section of the Court o (*Justice
Parvis du Tribunal de Paris
75859 PARIS CEDEX 17
e lb
its Sworn e TranslatorAppeei  .73,)
4
, registered with
* * 4. Court of Paris
Pt Ag
(English) it
Martin
-1
t1ATTgc
7 / 7
EFTA00079597 (Jmail)
 [girls] French Ministry of Justice allegations of sexual assault by Jean Luc Brunel
(date: 2020-07-08)
FRENCH REPUBLIC
MINISTRY OF JUSTICE
APPEAL COURT OF PARIS
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR'S OFFICE OF
PARIS COURT OF JUSTICE
Paris, July 8, 2020
DIVISION
Section P4 - Public Prosecution Service for Minors. The Public Prosecutor
To
Prosecutor-General at the Appeal Court of
Paris.
SUBJECT: Request for international legal assistance in criminal matter addressed to the United States authorities 
concerning the investigation related to Jean
-Luc BRUNEI., and others, in connection with the "EPSTEIN case".
N/REF : prosecution number : 19 235 449
V/REF :
APPLICANT AUTHORITY
The Public Prosecutor at the Paris Court of Justice.
AUTHORITY ADDRESSED TO
The competent authorities of the United States of America.
Having regard to the accord between the European Union and the United States of America dated June
25, 2003 which entered into force on February 1, 2010 ;
Having regard to the Article 14 of the Treaty on Mutual Legal Assistance between France and the United
States dated December 10, 1998, we request that this application and the acts resulting therefrom be
kept confidential, without condition as to the duration, in accordance with the provisions of Article 11
of the French Code of Criminal Procedure relating to the secrecy of the investigation and the inquiry;
Having regard to the reciprocity;
The Public Prosecutor at the Paris Court of Justice, expressing high regards to the competent judicial
authority of the United States of America, submits a request for mutual legal assistance in criminal
matters in the investigation related to Jean-Luc BRUNEL and others in connection with the case termed
as "EPSTEIN" case.
LNVESTIGATIVE FRAMEWORK
Preliminary investigation initiated on August 30, 2019 on charges of rape committed against a minor of 15 years of age, 
rape committed against a minor of over
15 years of age, rape, sexual assault on a minor
over 15 years of age, sexual assault, participation in an association
Public Prosecutor Section of Court of Justice
Pavia du Tribunal de Paris
75859 PARIS CEDEX I7
re
ct
orn Translator
registered with
the Appeal
Court of Paris
(English)
of criminals for the preparation of a crime, participation in an association of criminals for the preparation of an 
offence punishable by at least 5 years'
imprisonment;
Article 11 of the Criminal Procedure Code
Unless otherwise provided by law and without prejudice to the rights of the defense, the proceedings during the 
investigation and inquiry shall be secret.
Any person who assists in such proceedings shall be bound by professional secrecy under the conditions and is subject to
the penalties laid down in articles 226
-13 and 226 -14 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
However, in order to prevent the dissemination of fragmented or inaccurate information or to put an end to a disturbance
of public order, the public prosecutor
may, ex officio and at the request of the investigating court or the parties, make public objective elements taken from 
the proceedings that do not include any
assessment of the merits of the charges against the persons concerned.
Article 75 of the Criminal Procedure Code
The judicial police officers and, under their supervision, the investigating officers designated in Article 20 shall 
conduct preliminary investigations either
on the instructions of the public prosecutor of the Republic or ex officio
These operations shall be under the supervision of the public prosecutor.
Article 75 -1 of the Criminal Procedure ..e
When instructing the judicial police officers to carry out a preliminary investigation, the public prosecutor shall set 
the time limit within which the
investigation must be carried out. He may extend it based on the justifications provided by the investigators. Where the
investigation is conducted ex officio,
the judicial police officers shall report to the public prosecutor on the progress of the investigation when it has been
under way for more than six months.
Article 75 -2 of the Criminal Procedure Code A criminal investigation officer conducting a preliminary investigation 
into a crime or misdemeanour shall notify
the public prosecutor as soon as a person against whom there is evidence that he or she has committed or attempted to 
commit the offence is identified.
Artidellimiaftcdminainic
French criminal law is applicable to anyone who is guilty on the territory of the French Republic, as an accomplice, of 
a crime or offence committed abroad if
the crime or offence is punishable both by French law and by foreign law and if it has been established by a final 
decision of the foreign court.
Article 113 - 6 of the Criminal Procedure Code French criminal law is applicable to any crime committed by a French 
person outside the territory of the French
Republic.
It is applicable to crimes committed by French nationals outside the territory of the Republic if the acts arc 
punishable under the law of the country where
they were committed.
It is applicable to infringements of the provisions of Regulation (EC) No 561 /2006 of the European Parliament and of 
the Council of March 15, 2006 on the
harmonization of certain social legislation relating to road transport, committed in another Member State of the 
European Union and established in France,
subject to the provisions of Article 692 of the Code of Procedure
Public Prosecutor Section of the court of justice Parvis du Tribunal de Paris 75859 PARIS CEDEX 17
v% AT 7:4
e 4,„,tr -sr,J sworn Translator .15 e t registered with
ct the Appeal
* Court of Paris .....
0 (English) /7 ( English)
44/ertin -
*
criminal or the justification of an administrative sanction that has been enforced or can no longer be enforced.
This article shall be applied even if the accused has acquired French nationality after the act attributed to him.
Article 113 - 7 of the Criminal Procedure Code
French criminal law is applicable to any crime, as well as to any offence punishable by imprisonment, committed by a 
French person or by a foreigner outside the
territory of the French Republic when the victim is a French national at the time of the offence.
Article 222 - 23 of the Criminal Code
Any act of sexual penetration, of whatever nature, committed on another person or on a person perpetrated through 
violence, coercion, threat or surprise is
rape. Rape is punishable by 15 years' imprisonment.
Article 222 - 24 of the Criminal Code
Rape is punishable by twenty years' imprisonment:

(1) Where it has resulted in mutilation or permanent disability
(2) When it is committed on a minor under fifteen years of age;

(3) When it is committed on a person whose particular vulnerability, due to age, illness, infirmity, physical or 
psychological disability or pregnancy, is
apparent or known to the perpetrator;
(3 A) When it is committed on a person whose particular vulnerability or dependence resulting from the precariousness of
his economic or social situation is
apparent or known to the perpetrator;

(4) When it is committed by an ascendant or by any other person having de jure or de facto authority over the victim;

(5) When it is committed by a person who abuses the authority conferred on him by his functions;
(6) When it is committed by several persons acting as perpetrator or accomplice;

(7) When it is committed with the use or threat of a weapon;
(8) When the victim has been put in contact with the perpetrator through the use of an electronic communication network 
for the dissemination of messages to an
unspecified public;

(9) (Repealed)
(10) When it is committed in conjunction with one or more other rapes committed on other victims,

(11) Where it is committed by the spouse or partner of the victim linked to the victim by a civil solidarity pact ;

(12) When it is committed by a person acting in a state of manifest intoxication or under the influence of narcotic 
products;
Public Prosecutor Section of coup of justice Parvis du Tribunal do Paris
75859 PARIS CEDEX 17
0
NArrq
Sworn Translator
registered with
the Appeal
Court of Paris
(English)
*
3 / 7
Martin 7513

(13) Where it is committed, in the exercise of this activity, on a person who engages in prostitution, including 
occasionally ;

(14) Where a minor was present at the time of the offence and participated.
(15) Where a substance has been administered to the victim, without his knowledge, in order to impair his discernment or
the control of his acts.
Article 222 - 29 of the Criminal Procedure Code
Sexual assaults other than rape are punishable by seven years' imprisonment and a fine of 100,000 curos when perpetrated
:
(I) On a minor of fifteen years;
(2) On a person whose particular vulnerability due to age, illness, infirmity, physical or psychological
disability or pregnancy is apparent or known to the perpetrator.
Article 450 - 1 of the Criminal Procedure Code
An association of criminals is any group formed or agreement established for the purpose of preparation, characterized 
by one or more material facts, one or
more crimes or one or more offences punishable by at least five years' imprisonment.
Where the offences prepared arc crimes or misdemeanours punishable by ten years' imprisonment, participation in a 
criminal conspiracy shall be punishable by ten
years' imprisonment and a fine of 150,000 euros.
Where the offences prepared are crimes or misdemeanours punishable by at least five years' imprisonment, participation 
in a criminal conspiracy shall be
punishable by five years' imprisonment and a fine of EUR 75 000.
STATEMENT OF CASE
On August 23, 2019, the Minors' Section of the Paris Public Prosecutor's Office initiated a preliminary investigation 
into the charges of rape, rape of a minor
over 15 years of age, rape of a minor under 15 years of age, sexual assault, sexual assault of a minor over 15 years of 
age, sexual assault of a minor under 15
years of age, participation in a criminal association with a view to committing a crime punishable by at least 5 years' 
imprisonment for the actions of Jeffrey
EPSTEIN and his possible accomplices, at the prejudice of French victims. The investigations is initiated at the Central
Office for the Repression of Violence
against Persons of the Central Directorate of the Judicial Police.
In fact, on 23 July 2019 and 12 August 2019, the Public Prosecutors Office received a report from the association for 
the defense of children's interests
"Innocence en danger" in which it was stated that "France is concerned by this case since the investigations conducted 
by the FBI have brought to light several
persons of French nationality. From a reliable source, "Innocence en danger" recently confirmed that several victims of 
the prostitution network created by
Jeffrey Ces are also of French nationality. Attached to this report was a letter from in which she related that she had 
made otest-photograph" for the agency
"Karin Models" during the summer of 1980, when she was 18 years old. During this session, Jean-Luc BRUNEI, - director of
the model agency - had sexually
assaulted her. The acts are barred by statutes of limitations.
According to reports in the national and international press, the EPSTEIN case had arisen several weeks earlier in the 
context of an investigation by the
Federal Bureau of Investigations - New York office -following the revelations of several young women who had been 
sexually assaulted by the latter, in
Public Prosecutor Section of coon ofjustice
Parris du Tribunal de Paris
75859 PARIS CEDEX 17
4 I 7
registered with
the Appeal
Court of Paris
(English) S.2
O bi/tin - 7
United States and abroad. He is suspected of having sexually exploited dozens of young girls, some of them very young, 
between 2002 and 2005, and of having set
up a "network" that would have benefited several other men, including French nationals, including Jean-Luc BRUNEL, a 
close friend of Jeffrey EPSTEIN who would
have provided him with young girls from his agency's pool, and Ghislaine MAXWELL, who would have organized the arrival 
and stay in Jeffrey EPSTEIN's various
residences of the future victims..
And according to press reports, the victims heard by the American investigation services reported sexual assaults and 
rapes committed by Jeffrey EPSTEIN both in
the United States and in France - in PARIS, a city where he owned a mansion not far from the Arc de Triomphe, and by 
Jean-Luc BRUNEL, in various places but
especially at his Parisian home on Avenue Hoche.
In the summer of 2019, upon his return from a stay in Paris, Jeffrey EPSTEIN was arrested, charged and detained in 
Manhattan. He was found hanging in his cell
some time later.
The French investigation gathered several elements objectivizing the relationship between Jeffrey EP-STEIN and Jean-Luc 
BRUNEL. In addition, several testimonies
collected reported the sexual abuses committed by Jean-Luc BRUNEL, these offences being barred by statutes of 
limitations :
icated having introduced herself,.
en s e was years o , to several modeling agencies, including the ICARINE agency. There she met Jean-Luc BRUNEL and they 
agreed for a photo session at the
latter's home in Paris, in the Bourse district. Both of them were having dinner. felt that she had been drugged, since 
she could not explain how she had
suddenly, without understanding how, found herself in the room with Jean-Luc BRUNEL. She had not wanted sexual 
intercourse but had felt powerless in the face of
the solicitations and insistence of the respondent, who penetrated her with his sexual organ. Another man, unidentified,
had been in the apartment at the time
of the rape, without participating in it. The photo session did not take place. She stated that at L___t_he time 
Jean-Luc BRUNEL used to bring in girls from the
East, particularly young girls. stated that she had felt strong repercussions following the events. She had had no 
further contact with Jean-Luc BRUNEL after
this specific episode, and did not wish to lodge a complaint.
stated that she had met Jeffrey EP-STEIN and his partner Ghislaine MAXWELL at the age of 16, in the south of France near
Saint Tro-pez. They had made friends
and she went to their Parisian apartment on Avenue Foch in 2000. The same year, she left for Miami with the couple, 6 
months later, she was invited to New York
by Ghislaine MAXWELL, near the 5th avenue. It was during these 5 days that Jeffrey EPSTEIN was touching the girl, who 
tried in vain to resist him. Shc
remembered in particular that he had penetrated her with a vibrator. She had never met Jean-Luc BRUNEL.
said she had met Jean-Luc BRUNEL through her modeling activities (Karin Models agency, located in Paris 8th district, 
Avenue Roche). She had been invited to
his Parisian apartment, drank a cocktail prepared by the defendant, then lost consciousness. The next day, she woke up 
in a bathrobe and noticed bruises on her
thighs and crotch. She remembered that a man posing as Prince Albert de Monaco had called Jean-Luc BRUNEL while she was 
in the apartment.
said she had met Jean-Luc BRUNEL through the Paris Planning agency (modeling agency) and Karin Models. She said she had 
met in a Parisian apartment at the
invitation of lean-Luc BRUNEL, with him and a certain Gerald MARIE, who worked at Paris Planning. They were leaving for 
the countryside to an undetermined
place, where Jean-Luc BRUNEL tried to rape the young woman, who was resisting him. He then proceeded to young woman.
Public Prosecutor Section
Parris du Tribunal de Pans
75859 PARIS CEDE< 17 Sworn Transiatcr
registered with
the Appeal.
Court of Pans
(English)
4'
7>
an T5Q1
On August 12, 2019, the Paris Public Prosecutor's Office also received a reoort from a Parisian lawyer
reporting the accusations of  I against Ghislaine
MAXWELL, Jeffrey EPSTEIN and Jean-Luc BRUNEL, claiming that Ghislaine MAXWELL had
recruited her at the age of 16 for sexual exploitation.
The Parisian residence of Jeffrey EPSTEIN located at 22 avenue Foch. Paris 16th district, was
searched on Monday, September 23, 2019. It allowed the seizure of two MAC computers, several
storage media such as USB keys, documents relating to Ghislaine MAXWELL, and lany photographs
of young and even very young women, including photographs o
The computer verification of the seized material made it possible in particular to reveal the following
elements:
- Numerous photographs showing young girls partially or totally undressed were found in the
hard disk;
- 30 videos with shooting dates between 2011 and 2015, showing young girls, sometimes
dancing in an apartment,
- Documents relating to the former Jeffrey EPSTEIN trials.
In addition, Jeffrey EPSTEIN's Gmail account ) was analyzed. 4500 cmails were
apprehended, notably referring to Jean-Luc BRUNEL, in addition to emails related to Jeffrey
EPSTEIN's accusations, women or appointments.
Finally, a CD ROM with the inscription "CONFIDENTIAL - COMPREHENSIVE CHART" was used
to retrieve an excel file containing a list of 62 names of women.
OBJECT OF THE REQUEST
With regard to the above-mentioned elements, we would be thankful to the competent authorities of the
United States of America if they could communicate to us the acts of investigation carried out in the
United States of America and in particular :
Any hearing (hearing as a defendant or as a witness) and any investigative acts (search, computer
exploitation, documents seized, written statements), concerning the sexual exploitation of minors or
adults, relating to the following persons:
- Jean-Luc BRUNEL,
- Ghislaine MAXWELL, arrested on American soil on Thursday, July 2, 2020,
Any information, hearings and acts of investigation concerning victims of French nationality, having
been in contact with Jeffrey EPSTEIN, Jean-Luc BRUNEL or Ghislaine MAXWELL;
Any information useful to bring out the truth;
- Provide the results of the requested investigations in the form of a working copy that can be used.
We also inform them that we will make available to them all the investigative documents resulting from
the procedure carried out in France.
DEADLINE
The competent authorities of the United States of America are requested to provide assistance as soon
as possible. 7:4
Public Prosecution Section of Court of Justice
Purvis du Tribunal de Pins
75859 PARIS CEDEX 17
<C‘ 70 Swotrbgie
Appeal
Transiator
.9. teg *tided with
* Court of Paris
(English)
al Uri -7
A
CONFIDENTIALITY
The competent authorities of the United States of America arc requested to keep this application and its
contents confidential.
CONTACTS
French Central Authority :
Office of International Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters
Criminal Affairs and Pardons Branch
Ministry of Justice
M 'strate who issued this request for mutual legal assistance:
Vice-Prosecutor, Head of the Paris Public Prosecutor's Office for Minors
Substitute
Minors' Section of the Paris Public Prosecutor's Office
The Public Prosecutor of the Republic at the Judicial Court of Paris thanks the judicial authorities of the
United States of America for their helpfulness and valuable collaboration, assures them of its reciprocity
and renews the expression of its highest consideration.

I. the undersigned Arindam ahattacharya,
Sworn translator registered with the
Appeal Court of Paris. certify that the
following translation is true to the original
document in French ,.," I nobearing the number .r  •••• Paris. Date:, 131 2020
Public Prosecutor Section of the Court of Justice
Psis du Tribunal de Paris
75859 PARIS CEDEX 17
July 8, 2020
For the Public Prosecutor
Substitute
Seal of the Paris court of Justice
Signature Illegible.
vi AT T
• S• worn e TAprapnesalal tor
registered with
t o  Court of Paris
(English)
7 I 7
╔════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Isabel Maxwell [epstein] sister of Ghislaine, wife of Al Seckel 
             The Sweater Trust [epstein] Epstein financial trust 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01648787 (Jmail)
 [money] JP Morgan Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) about $1.1 billion in Epstein transfers
(inferred date: 2020-07-10)
SAR - 31000154806804

JP Morgan Chase Bank NA ('JPMC') and JP Morgan Securities LLC are filing this
Suspicious Activity Report ('SAR') to report 4,725 wire transactions, totaling
$1,081,819,653, that occurred from 10/01/2003 to 07/22/2019, involving current, former
and non-JPMC customers: JEFFREY E EPSTEIN ('EPSTEIN'), <REDACTED>,
<REDACTED>, <REDACTED>, <REDACTED>, DARREN K INDYKE, <REDACTED>,
<REDACTED>, <REDACTED>, HARRY I BELLER, INNER BEAUTY
WELLNESS INC, <REDACTED>, JOSEPH P DWYER, KARYNA SHULIAK,
<REDACTED>, SL COMMUNICATIONS AND LIFESTYLE LLC, <REDACTED>,
<REDACTED>, FAMILY INTERESTS LP, FINANCIAL TRUST COMPANY
INC, FORUMS LLC, GHISLAINE NOELLE MARION MAXWELL, HBRK ASSOCIATES
INC, HYPERION AIR LLC, JEGE LLC, <REDACTED>, <REDACTED>,
NEPTUNE LLC, NES LLC, NEW YORK STRATEGY GROUP LLC, <REDACTED>,
<REDACTED>, THE 2001 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN INSURANCE TRUST, THE C.O.U.Q.
FOUNDATION INC, WEXNER CHILDREN'S TRUST II DATED 02/25/1998, <REDACTED>,
<REDACTED><REDACTED>, LSJ EMPLOYEES LLC, <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED>, THE SWEATER TRUST, EVA BIRGITTA ANDERSSON-DUBIN, <REDACTED>
<REDACTED>, DARIIA BIELOVA, <REDACTED>, ALAN MORTON DERSHOWITZ,
GLENN RUSSELL DUBIN, CHARLES GERALD GOLDSMITH, LISA GAYLE KAHN,
RICHARD DAVID KAHN, BELLA KLEIN, ISABEL SYLVIA MAXWELL, MICHELLE F
SAIPHER, JEFFREY A SCHANTZ, BUTTERFLY TRUST, COATUE ENTERPRISES
LLC, COMMUNITY INTERESTS, DARREN K INDYKE ATORNEY AT LAW, DARREN
K INDYKE PLLC, EDUCATION ADVANCE, ENHANCED EDUCATION, EPSTEIN
INTERESTS DATED 12/26/91, FT REAL ESTATE INC, GRATITUDE AMERICA LTD,
HYPERION AIR INC, I CORRECT COM LLC, INTERNATIONAL CHARITABLE
INTERESTS, J EPSTEIN FOUNDATION, JEEPERS INC, JEGE INC, LCP COMPANY
LLC, LSJ LLC, MAPLE INC, MC2 MODEL MANAGEMENT, PLAN D LLC, SOUTHERN
FINANCIAL LLC, SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC, THE 2007 JEFFREY E
EPSTEIN INSURANCE TRUST NO 3 DATED 11/01/2007, THE 2017 CATERPILLAR
TRUST, THE HAZE TRUST, ZORRO DEVELOPMENT CORP, ZORRO TRUST, LEON
D BLACK, DEBRA RESSLER BLACK, and BLACK FAMILY PARTNERS LP, to report
wire activity consistent with negative media involving alleged sex trafficking of minors
and allegations that EPSTEIN misappropriated funds while employed as a money
manager; the use of multiple accounts; the high risk jurisdiction of the Russian
Federation; and politically exposed person EPSTEIN, due to his relationships with two
US presidents.

SAR - 31000171404867

Conclusion: This investigation identified the suspicious transfers of funds appearing to
have been completed in order to conceal the origin of funds used to purchase property,
and fund daily living expenses and legal defense fees of an individual indicted for sex
trafficking crimes. The origin of the funds is unknown, and may originate from proceeds
derived from Human Trafficking, transferred through accounts of an individual and
business in order to conceal the likely connection to Ghislaine . The suspicious
activity occurred from 11/12/19 to 7/09/20 totaling $17,883,176.30.

SAR - 31000174054068

UBS Financial Services Inc. (UBS FS) is filing this Suspicious Activity Report (SAR)
under the suspicion that Ghislaine may have attempted to hide her assets from
federal courts, via various UBS accounts funded by Ghislaine , by issuing wires
to external accounts held or controlled by Scott Borgerson. According to recent media
reports, Borgerson, who is the trustee on several of Maxwells UBS FS trust accounts,
may be married to <REDACTED> but she has refused to identify her spouse to court officials.
In total, UBS FS is reporting twenty-nine (29) payments, which includes three (3) credit
and twenty-six (26) debit payments, totaling $18,289,739.65, which occurred from
December 18, 2014 to July 10, 2020, involving Maxwells UBS FS accounts and external
bank accounts associated with Scott Borgerson.
EFTA01249591 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip about Henry Jarecki
(inferred timestamp: 2020-07-10 00:29:00)
50D -NY -3027571 Serial /1',J,
Intake (Rem 5.23.17) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Intake

Date: 07/09/2020
Case ID #: 50D-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX TRAFFICKING
Drafted By: <REDACTED>
Date/Time Received: 07/09/2020 08:29 PM EDT

Details:
(U)On 07/09/2020 at 8:29 p.m. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> called the FBI
National Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to provide information on Henry
Jarecki townhouse address <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
(a.k.a "The greatest private house in NY City"), a former friend of
Jeffery Epstein.

<REDACTED> provided the following information:

<REDACTED> said she worked <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>, business address <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>. <REDACTED> said Jarecki brought Epstein onto
the Board of Trustee's in 2002 or 2003. <REDACTED> said Epstein donated $10
Million and Jarecki donated $10-20 Million to
<REDACTED>, while he was on the board of Trustee's. <REDACTED> said Jarcki and
Epstein were good friends.

<REDACTED> said after Epstein had been arrested, Jarecki wanted <REDACTED> to go
through the internet on Jarecki's personal computer and to delete any
noticeable pictures of him and Epstein together. Once <REDACTED> had deleted
3501.353-001
Page I of 2

SOD-NY -3027571 Serial 438
Re: SOD-NY-3027571, 07/09/2020
any photographs of Jarecki and Epstein, <REDACTED> was to report it to
Jarecki's assistant.

Jarecki is the Vice Chairman of <REDACTED> and CEO of <REDACTED>, buying and
selling of gold and silver, his primary investment and how he receives
revenue. , "might" be based in Cayman Island, Caribbean.
Jarecki also owns, Island of Guana and Epstein helped buy "Little Saint
James Island".

<REDACTED> said Jarecki use to go with Epstein to the "Atlantic Grill" in NY to
hit on younger girls (minors) and would touch, rub the girls' backs,
nothing to aggressive but just flirting. <REDACTED> said Jarecki did touch her
but nothing that she could deal with.

<REDACTED> said Julian Johnson, now CEO of Seizing Every Opportunity (SEO),
email address <REDACTED><REDACTED>, worked for <REDACTED> as the Director
of <REDACTED> and at the time brought/ recruited Epstein on to be a Trustee,
Johnson would be able to provide further information.

<REDACTED> said there are other testimonies from other people, board members,
and director at <REDACTED>
3501.353-001
Page 2 of 2
EFTA01249296 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from former escort about Alexander Guest, Ghislaine, and Epstein
(inferred timestamp: 2020-07-16 01:45:00)
50D -NY -3027571 Serial 456
Mtge (Rev .5-234-0 UNCLASSIFIED//FOU0
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Intake
Date: 07/15/2020
Case ID #:: 50D-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 07/15/2020 09:45 PM EDT

Details:          NT0C2020 197ab02

On 07/15/2020 at 9:45p.m. Eastern Time, <REDACTED>, date of birth
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>, called the FBI
National Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to report her relation with
Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, and Alexander Guest.

<REDACTED> provided the following information:

<REDACTED> stated she called 10 days ago about Maxwell and Epstein who the
caller used to know. <REDACTED> used to live in NY from 1999-2006- she met
Epstein through Maxell, Maxwell wanted the <REDACTED> to meet Epstein.
<REDACTED> at the age of 15 was groomed to come to the US in 1999. <REDACTED>
worked for high end escort agencies. <REDACTED> met Epstein through Maxwell
when she was 19, when she met him in a hotel, and Epstein paid cheap
money to sleep with him. <REDACTED> had sex with Epstein and afterwards
Maxwell threatened kill or hurt <REDACTED> if <REDACTED> spoke out. Maxwell
took money from <REDACTED> after she prostituted <REDACTED> to Epstein.

In the past <REDACTED> was given 5k to sleep with Alexander Guest who was an
associate of Epstein and Maxwell. At one point Guest expressed his
interest in having a sexual relationship with his own 13 year old niece.
Guest told <REDACTED> she was took old when she was 20 years old and that he
wanted to have sex with younger girls. <REDACTED> was there with other young
girls with Maxwell. Maxwell would set up the meetings for Epstein and
Guest. <REDACTED> witnessed Epstein with underage girls.

<REDACTED> received a call from <REDACTED> who said he was from NYPD
said he was a cop from NYPD working for underage felonies with the FBI
asked questions about Alexander Guest. <REDACTED> said he was from NYPD
collaboration with FBI He asked the caller about Alexander. Sent email
with FBI name in Email and said he wanted to know more about the Guest in
New York. They asked specific questions about Mr. Guest.
.•
3501.284-003
Pagc
EFTA01249593 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip about Les Wexner
(inferred timestamp: 2020-07-18 04:13:00)
50D -NY -302.7571 Serial 46 1
Iniae(Rem 5.23.17) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Intake
Date: 07/18/2020
Case ID 50D-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 07/18/2020 12:13 AM EDT
Details:
NTOC2020 200ko I Information Regarding Jeffery Epstein Human Trafficking case.: 50D -NY -3057571
On 07/18/2022 at 12:13 a.m. Eastern Time date of birthl
ailed the FBI National Threat Operations Center
(NTOC) reporting information regarding Jeffery Epstein Human trafficking.
provided the following information:
aid that she worked
said that often she would see Epstein with Les Wexner. stated that often Wexner
would have models who could not have been over 18 years old do private viewings for him and Epstein. She said
the models would be wearing swim suites and some were in lingerie.
said that she would help with gettin o le to work at parties at Wexner's compound in catering and other
positions. She thought it was weird that would be guarding the compound checking
identifications. She said that anyone who went to work there had to have a full background check and there were
certain areas of the house were they could not go without an approved escort. She said the Ed Rank would also be
present at many of these functions. stated that in Wexner's building no one was allowed to go on the 12th
floor but no one could explain why not when ask. said that one time her another stylist were dressing some
mannequins and they bras and panties all over the floor. She said that while they were bent over it felt like
someone was watching them. When they stood up and turned around Epstein and Wexner were watching them.
Wexner asked them if that is what their rooms looked like with the bras and panties everywhere. said that
she pictures of all of the models that would go the houses of Wexner and Rank and contact information for them
also. said that their was always a woman who she did not that was around at these parties and seemed to be
in charge of the models.
3501.354-001
Page lof2
EFrA_00109242
50D-NY-3027571 Serial 463
Re: 500-NY-3027571, 07/18/2020
• •
3501.354-001
Page 2 of 2
EFTA00005578 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Ghislaine Maxwell
EFTA00008708 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Ghislaine Maxwell
EFTA00003931 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003942 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00004049 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00004055 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00004064 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00004066 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00004975 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00005561 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007546 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007560 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007561 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007570 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007576 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007641 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007652 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007680 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007965 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00008015 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00008018 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
╔════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Alison J. Nathan [government] judge in SDNY 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00009664 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in US v. Ghislaine Maxwell
EFTA00039895 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in New York Times v. Bureau of Prisons
EFTA00039908 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in New York Times v. Bureau of Prisons
EFTA00020490 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from woman who thinks she encountered Epstein as a young girl
(inferred timestamp: 2020-08-11 11:26:00)
[make IRev. 5-23-171 OFFICIAL RECORD
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Intake
Date: 38/11/2020
Case ID #: 50D-NY -3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 08/11/2020 07:26 AM EDT
Details:
On 08/11/2020, at 7:26 a.m. Eastern. Time, Last Name Unknown
(LNU), email address , who resides in Virginia Beach,
VA, Internet Protocol (I?) address , which resolves to
Virginia Beach, VA 23464, submitted an online tip to the FBI National
Threat Operations Center (NT0C) via tips.fbi.gov, to report a sexual
encounter with Jeffrey Epstein when she was 15 years old.
Date Submitted: 08/11/2020 07:26:56 AM ET
Transaction Number: 0B153A14-9B5A-425F-ACAB-46CC624AD735
Threat To Life: False
Submitted Text:
Hi, my name is
I think I may have been a victim by jeffrey epstein. I was about 15 at
the time. My friend said we could make some quick money just by giving a
massage. So we met with her friend who his name was Andy. When we went I
sat down while she went inside the bedroom. She came out & Andy said he
wanted me to come in. When I walked in there was another man sitting on
I don't know who I need to talk to about this but
Re: 50D-NY-3027571, 08/11/2020
the bed which made me even made hesitate to go in but I went in. I gave a
quick massage to a man who looks very much like him. Then he proceeded to
take my clothes off without my permission. All I remember is getting
touched, touching a man,& then having a on me. After it was all
done he gave us money & we left. I'm really trying to remember if it was
him or not since I've blocked absolutely so much of those years out of my
head. But he looks so familiar & that voice of his as well.Not only that
but months later Andy drives by the place I stayed at & asked me was
there anyone in the government or law enforcement looking for him. He
said that he was part of a thing with a powerful man & he has to get out
of town if they were looking for him. I told him they weren't which it
was the case. I know Andy & other men he knew would give girls but mostly
Russian girls places to stay & help them with work. Much of that work was
prostitution for rich men that Andy pimped them out to. So I am hoping
you can help me figure out if I was Epstein victims by answering some
questions so I can piece it together. Such as could you please tell me if
you have proof that jeffrey epstein was in Virginia Beach,Virginia in the
2000's? Did Epstein have Russian girls in Virginia Beach, Virginia? Do
you have a Virginia Beach home address on file for him that I could
verify back to you? Finally has the name Andy ever come up in ur files
that's related to Epstein in anyway? If you would be so kind to email me
back it would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.
Violation: Other
Violation Questions
What was the exact crime that occurred?: It's about Jeffery Epstein
When did the crime/incident occur? (Please provide an approximate date
and time) : 2000's
Where did the crime/incident occur? (Please provide the specific
location/address if possible) : Virginia Beach, VA
Re: 50D-NY-3027571, 08/11/2020
Complainant Information
First Name:
Middle Name:
Last Name:
Age:
DOB:
Additional Info:
Account:
Type: Other
Address:
City: Virginia Beach
State: Virginia
Zip:
Country: United States
Subject Information
First Name: Jeffery
Middle Name:
Last Name: Epstein
Age: N/A
3
Re: 50D-NY-3027571, 08/11/2020
DOB:
Additional Info: No
How is Contact Known: Written above
Type: Other
Address:
City:
Zip:
Witness Information
First Name:
Middle Name:
Last Name:
Age:
DOB:
Additional Info: N/A
How is Contact Known: N/A
Type: Other
Address:
City:
Zip:
4
Re: 50D-NY-3027571, 08/11/2020
Remote IP:
Remote Host: api.fbi.gov
Http Referrer: https://www.fbi.gov/tips
User Browser:
Latitude:
Longitude:
Country: US
Region: Virginia
City: Virginia Beach
Postal Code: 23464
Timezone: -04:00
Domain Awareness Caveat: When collected, this information was determined
to be of no current lead value and did not provide a basis to investigate
further. No investigative action should be taken with regard to this
information alone.
Databases Queries:
Re: 50D -NY-3027571, 08/11/2020
Sentinel, Guardian, and DIVS queries revealed zero results.
.•
0
EFTA01309589 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Anthony Figueroa, recruiting from high schools
(date: 2020-08-27)
ED-302 (Rev 5 -8-10) -1 of 4 - OFFICIAL RECORD-1
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  08/27/2_020
ANTHONY FIGUEROA, date of birth was interviewed via video
conference on 8/19/2020 by Detective Paul Byrne and Special Agent Amanda
Young. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents and
the nature of the interview, FIGUEROA provided the following information:
FIGUEROA advised interviewing agents that approximately 5 years ago he
was deposed by BRAD EDWARDS for a lawsuit pertaining to GHISLAINE MAXWELL.
Additionally he recalled speaking with the FBI around the time that
JEFFREY EPSTEIN first went to jail.
FIGUEROA currently lives with his parents in Georgia where he has been
for the last year and a half. He has a girlfriend who has 2
children. FIGUEROA has a biological son who lives with his mother in Kansas
City. FIGUEROA works at Longhorn Steakhouse as a server.
FIGUEROA was born in Plantation Florida, and lived there and around South
Florida until he was about 25 years old. After 25 he moved back and forth
between Georgia and Florida.
FIGUEROA attended several high schools including Piper High School, Royal
Palm, Wellington, Gold Coast, South Area and Survivor Charter School. He
eventually received his GED and then continued on to work in various
restaurants at various positions up until current day.
FIGUEROA described that he briefly dated
approximately in 10th grade. She stayed at
brother picked her up and she went
when he was
his house. At some point
to rehab. FIGUEROA does not see
again until he is about 18 years old.
FIGUEROA described being at his friend JJ's apartment and seeing a picture
of on his refrigerator. They talked about and JJ advised
FIGUEROA that she was currently going by 1IIIII", living at this apartment
New York, New York, United States (, Other (Video
hivemIgummion 08/19/2020  at Conference))
nka 50D-NY-3027571
by BYRNE PAUL WILSON, Amanda Nicole Young
Date drafted 08/21 / 2020
Thn document contains neither recornmendanom nor conclusions of the FBI It it the ploperty of the FBI and is loaned to 
you, agency. it and its content' are not
to be distributed outside yaw agency
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM00332932
FD-302a (Re/. 5-8-I0)
50D-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of ANTHONY FIGUEROA ,On 08/19/2020 ,page 2 of 4
and engaged to a man named MICHAEL. Additionally he learned from JJ that
was working for a rich guy in Palm Beach as a traveling massage
therapist. He learned that she was only at the apartment about two weeks
out of the month because the other 2 weeks she traveled with this man
(EPSTEIN).
The next day while at this apartment returned home and she and
FIGUEROA reconnected. Within two weeks, broke off her engagement,
kicked everyone else out of the apartment, FIGUEROA moved in and they began
dating again.
continued to work for EPSTEIN after this time and would travel
with him on and off for two weeks at a time, leaving FIGUEROA home at the
apartment. She would go to Santa Fe, New York and the Island. FIGUEROA
learned that EPSTEIN was paying for the apartment, but did not meet him
right away. would either get picked up or dropped off. At the
time, had told FIGUEROA she was a masseuse but had assumed that
there was more going on. FIGUEROA knew that had previously worked
at Mar-A-Lago and thought she met MAXWELL there.
A few months into being back with , FIGUEROA dropped her off at
EPSTEIN's house as she was going on a trip. FIGUEROA went inside the house
and met EPSTEIN in the kitchen. EPSTEIN said they were traveling somewhere
but FIGUEROA does not recall where.
Sometime later, askde FIGUEROA if he knew any other girls that
wanted to make money giving EPSTEIN massages. She tells FIGUEROA that if he
knows more girls to give massages then will not have to go over as
much. FIGUEROA wanted to see his girlfriend more so he helped. FIGUEROA
recruited a few girls and then EPSTEIN would try to get those girls to bring
more girls.
FIGUEROA recalled two girls' names that he recruited, and
. FIGUEROA told these girls that there was a guy that likes to get
massages. He stated that he went to Survivors High School with
and she was one of his friend's girlfriends. EPSTEIN would pay
FIGUEROA $200 in cash for each girl. EPSTEIN would be the only person to
pay FIGUEROA. FIGUEROA would drive the girls he knew to EPSTEIN's and he
would get paid when he brought them. If EPSTEIN liked them enough he would
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00332933
FD-302a (Re/. 5-8-10)
50D-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of ANTHONY FIGUEROA , On 08/19/2020 Jive  3 of 4
stay in touch with them and get them their own rides.
FIGUEROA met MAXWELL a couple of times in which they would talk for a
couple of minutes. FIGUEROA doesn't recall MAXWELL calling him but stated
he thought SARAH called him.
would talk about MAXWELL and EPSTEIN. told FIGUEROA that
she and MAXWELL would go out and get girls together for EPSTEIN.
FIGUEROA was asked if he recalled a girl named . FIGUEROA
stated that he thought that was the girl who he brought over who was dating
his friend. He said, "it's (not )". When asked to
describe he stated she had decent sized breasts, thinks she had
crooked teeth and brownish/reddish hair. FIGUEROA thought that
brought to EPSTEIN. FIGUEROA and would tell that
there was a guy that wanted to get massages. They would say that sometimes
the guy (EPSTEIN) would ask the girls to do more than massage and sometimes
girls would get paid more to do so, but you did not have to do more.
FIGUEROA was asked if he recalled the name to which he stated he
thought that was boyfriend. He did not recall the boyfriend's
last name. FIGUEROA described him as a skinny white dude.
FIGUEROA was asked if the name sounded familiar to which he
stated he was not sure.
FIGUEROA stated at some went to Thailand. After that,
EPSTEIN called FIGUEROA a few times asking him about whereabouts.
told FIGUEROA at some point while away that she was getting
married.
EPSTEIN would tell FIGUEROA to make sure the girls are 18 years old. As
far as FIGUEROA knew they were all his age at the time. EPSTEIN said to
make sure they are not fat.
FIGUEROA was directed to a statement he previously made to the FBI in
which he stated MAXWELL would call him and "ask him to pick up a specific
girl and bring them to EPSTEIN's residence" (31E -MM-108062 serial #
104). FIGUEROA stated he did not recall making that particular statement.
He said that MAXWELL may have called him once or twice but he did not really
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00332934
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
SOD-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-M12 of (U) Interview of ANTHONY FIGUEROA  On 08/19/2020 page 4 of 4
deal with her. FIGUEROA only met her a handful of times.
EPSTEIN would give cash. EPSTEIN said that he would pay
for FIGUEROA's phone bill when he was talking with while she was in
Thailand. EPSTEIN paid for anything. FIGUEROA was living with his parents
back then and said, "you know EPSTEIN will pay for it when I come
back. ..he will take care of it". The bill racked up and EPSTEIN never paid
for it and FIGUEROA's parents eventually paid for it.
EPSTEIN would call FIGUEROA's cell phone after
call every other day looking for her.
EPSTEIN would not contact FIGUEROA if
the time she was in Thailand. would ask
her. Sometimes would call FIGUEROA when
ask for girls for when they returned to Florida.
left. He would
wasn't around other than
FIGUEROA to get girls with
she was with EPSTEIN and
was approached by MAXWELL at Mar-A-Lago. said she and
MAXWELL were sexually active with each other and would go out and get girls
together.
FIGUEROA had gotten a call from someone working on
check. He sometimes gets random calls from the media.
CONFIDENTIAL
book to fact
EFTA00617222 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2020-09-01)
Valuation Report
7/31/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - JULY 31, 2017
6/30/17 7/31/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 127,228,936 135,985,107 8,756,171
Fixed Income 72,806,515 73,841,829 1,035,314
Equities 87,293,777 73,617,040 (13,676,737)
Equity ETF's 3,120,000 3,138,000 18,000
Options 0 91,350 91,350
Hedge Funds 71,455,541 73,055,554 1,600,012
Investments 52,506,000 47,506,000 (5,000,000)
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 26,875,000 23,375,000 (3,500,000)
Loans Receivable 11,207,446 10,907,446 (300,000)
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 1 583 200 1,583,200 0
Total Assets 454,076,415 443,100,525 -10,975,890
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
STC ML - Sold 250,000 shares BK 51.84 12,955,276
STC ML - Sold 97,525 shares GM 35.592 3,471,110
STC ML - Sold 23,000 shares GE 25.4032 584,274
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 304,386
STC ML - Sold 8,000 shares MU 31.64 253,120
SFL DB - Sale of AKRX, GPACU, MTCH, SQ, GLBL 199,453
STC MS - Sold 6,484 NGL Energy Partners 24.81 160,858
Enhanced - Sold 1,500 Disney 159,804
STC MS - Sold 5,000 Altice 31.5484 157,532
Enhanced - BBB (25,000)
Legal - Erika Mapp Invoice (50,717)
Miscellaneous (76,715)
Enhanced - DPNR (160,000)
NES - Pinto 400k Euro (456,128)
STC MS - Bought 2,000 NTES 308.5245 (617,049)
STC ML - Bought 20,000 shares TER 35.2016 (704,032)
STC MS - Bought 40,000 NLY 25.00 (1,000,000)
Spotify Investment via Honeycomb (1,000,000)
Monthly Spending (1,150,000)
Valar III Capital Call (4,250,000)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50 000 8,756,171
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan 10
Asset Description Bank Bank SNP Paribas Fargo Stanley Merrill Aaudrnd• Totals
Cash
Southern Trust Company Inc. 21,524,297 343,180 299,452 1,478,105 34,538,973 58,184,007
Haze Trust 34,019.387 34,019,367
Southern Financial LLC 28,971,576 51,691 29.023.267
JEE 4,539,461 743,738 468,950 5.740,149
Gratitude America, Ltd. 625259 71,806 2,960,685 3,657.750
Jeepers Inc. 1.475.399 7,853 1.483.252
JEGE Inc. 963.188 963,188
LSJE LLC 393,800 327,261 157,161 878,221
Southern Country International LTD 453,880 453,880
Zorro Management LLC 380,501 380,501
Plan 0 LLC 220,654 220,854
NES LLC 211,421 211.421
JEGE LLC 141,777 141,777
Enhanced Education 86 512 22,126 108,639
Hyperion Air LLC 10092 100.292
JEEParis (US 6) 89,177 89.177
69.089 Neptune LLC 69.063
Thomas World Air LLC 57,579 57,579
Cypress Inc. 47,857 47,857
FT Real Estate 42,149 42.149
Maple Inc. 26,768 26.768
Freedom Alr Petroleum 22,812 22,812
Michelins Transportation Co LLC 22,736 22.736
Nautilus Inc. 15,137 15,137
Great St Jim LW 8 857 8,857
LSJ LLC 6).150 6,150
Mort Inc 4,853 4,853
Laurel Inc. 4,070 4,070
FSF LLC 937 937
IGO Company LLC 390 390
The JEE Life Ins Trust P3 206 206
Butterfly Trust 3 3
Total Cash 93,727,627 2,225,285 845,579 157,161 4,438,790 34,538,973 51,691 135,985,107
Purchase Quantity 6/30/17 741117 Unrealized
Gain (Lose) Asset Description Date Coet Value Value
Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/30/2049 05/10/11 3,000,000 3.337,958 3,158,000 3,112.500 -225,456
JPM Tr Pk Rate Income Fund 01/22/13 240,973.957 2,413,469 2,261,257 2,279,614 -133.656
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 49,033.00 1180739 1,276,819 1,264,071 83,332
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/29/14 150.967.00 3.810,430 3,931,181 3,891.929 221.499
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000.00 1 999.419 2.337.619 Law 630 368.211
Total Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB) 12,602,018 12,984,687 *915,744 313,728
Anvers - Fixed Income OM
JPM Trust FLT RT Income fund 02/13/13 180,515.211 1.804.981 1.693.923 1 707 674 -97 307
Total Jima, - Fixed Income (DB) 1,804,981 1,693,923 1,707,674 -97,307
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Western Digital Corp 7.375% Matures 4-1-2023 06/09/16 2,000,000 2.008.048 .2221,2O 2 244 167 158.161
Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stealer) 2,086,006 2,231965 2.244,167 158,161
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (O8)
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP callable 6/20/2019 4/15/14 2,000,000 3.439.193 2.668.513 2.779_068 -680.107
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (DB) 3,439,193 2,668,513 2,779,086 460,107
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (Merrill)
Allergen mandatory convertible preffered 5.5% 3/1/2018 08/15/16 1,00%000 881,500 867,410 894,010 12,510
LSCCOM 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 26250.000 2,789,125 2.814889 2,850,774 61.649
Kindred Healthcare 7.25% 1/15/2020 STC ML 10/13/16 3,000,000 3,060,528 3260 667 3,025 667 -34.862
Teva mandatory convertible weltered 7.0% 12/1512018 08/15/16 1,000,000 901.750 694.600 04.00 -317 750
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill) 7,632,903 7,537,466 7,354,451 -278,452
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred $25 per 7/27/15 40,000 1,000,000 1,086,400 1,106,000 106,000
Annaly Cap Management 7/25/17 40,000 1.000.000 - 994,000 -8.000
NGt. Energy Partners 9%325 per 6/6/17 40,000 1,000,000 1,151,874 996,800 -3,200
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $25 par 08/04/16 8,000 200,000 166.320 174,080 -25.920
Wells Fargo 5.7% Preferred $25 par 1/19/16 120,000 3.000.000 3,108,000 3,115,200 115,200
Ebay 6% Preferred $25 par matures 2-1-2056 2122/16 80,000 2,000.000 2,189,600 2,166,400 166,400
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9.15.2028 then boats 8/18/16 500,000 500,000 530,000 548,300 48,300
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9.15.2026 Men boats 10/11/16 2,500,000 2,623,122 2,650,000 2,730,083 106,961
Royal Sank Scotland 7.94% 'tad to 9.29.2017 than 311 Libor +2320p 11/10/15 5,000,000 5.298.817 006.000 4,931,082 467,735
Goldman Sadie 5.375% Fixed to 5-10-2020 then 3922 over 3 mo Wog 6/4/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 5,291,326 5,285,469 251,122
Capital One 5.55% Fixed to 9-1-2020 then 380 over 3 mo nor 5114/15 3.000,000 3.009.618 3J63.413 1 199.000 179.199
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 24,666,104 24,231,933 25,236,414 570,310
Southern Financial LLC • Fixed Income (08)
Bank of America 8.125% Pfd Dec 29 2049
14/3/13 2 300,000
2,055,000 2,100,013 2,123,626 68„626
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 4/3/13 300,000 300,030 317,167 316.919 1(019
Citigroup Inc - Series 0 5.95% 816/15 3,000,000 3,000,006 3223,598 3.238.988 238,962
General Electric Co GTD Faed to Float 4.0% Dec 15 2065 12/3/15 2,489,000 2,175,016 485,460 2.458.929 281,913
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7.9% April 30 2049 8116/11 2,500,000 2,687,500 2,631,667 2,643,125 -44,375
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500,000 2,675,000 2,631,667 2,643,125 -31.875
LBG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49 5/21/13 1,903,000 1,948,500 2,100,446 2,130,567 182,067
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,009000 2,996,074 3,400,104 3,438,750 442.676
GMAC Cap TR I GM PM Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 60,000 1)682.774 2.096.000 2 124 000 241.226
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 19,719,870 20,986,120 21,116,009 1,396,139
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 0tallgia
Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 d Cal var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 562,781 430.64Q 489 4QQ2e55 57_64k
tiViThouthern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 430,840 4 6, 57,645
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 72,381,714 72,806,616 73,841,829 1,480,116
ore - Accrued interest has been included in month end fixed Income values
Purchase Quantity 6130/17 7/31117 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
Akom Inc 6(1 0/15 5 000 167,700 - 0
Alibaba Group 6/10/15 5.360 444,749 704,500 774,750 330.001
Allis= SE ADR 4/13/15 5,000 90,056 98,875 106,750 16,694
Apple Inc 9/5/14 84,000 6,332,800 9,217,280 9,518,720 3.185.920
Apple Inc 1/11/16 250,000 24.750,006 36.005,000 37,182,500 12,432,494
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 263.157 4,999,983 6,960,503 7,394,712 2,394,729
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Bam 1.3.11) 1/16/01 70,500 1,500,000 151,575 164,970 -1.335.030
Avalanche Biotechnologies now called Adverum Biotechnologies 4/20/15 10.000 398,608 25,000 25,500 -373,106
BASF ADR 4/13/15 5,000 508,056 466,450 478,350 -31,706
Bank of New York Mellon 6/25/14 2561,000 12,755,000 - 0
Blogen Ides Inc 2/14/12 2.095 250.455 568,499 606,691 356238
Bioverativ Inc 2/1/17 1,047 20,254 62,998 64 883 44,629
248.484 Centene Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1.242,134 1,234981
Dish Network Corp 6/10/15 5000 364978 313,800 320,150 -44,828
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17,500 665,000 2.642.150 2.961.875 2,296,875
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49,830 1,265,037 1,980,743 1,761,491 496,454
General Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3.406,548 - 0
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 621,230 - 0
Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 5,000 396,407 353.900 380,450 -15,957
Gilead Sciences Inc 3/7/14 3,100 246,797 219,418 235,679 -10.918
Glaxo Smith Kline PLC 6/10/15 5,000 215,006 215,600 202,600 -12.406
Global Partner Acquisition Corp 7/30/15 2,000 19,700 0
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/15 700 14,000 29,694 30,086 16,086
Match 11/19/15 200 3,476 - 0
Mobileye NV Amstelveen Ord Shares 811/14 800 20.000 50,240 50,640 30,640
Square 11/19/15 200 3,476 - 0
Sangamo Biosciences Inc 5/28/13 50 000 422,214 440,000 430t000 7,786
Santander Consumer USA 1/28/14 1:000 24,000 12,760 12810 -11,190
Terraform Global 7/31/15 400 2,020 0
-14.865 Twitter Inc 11/7/13 1,500 39,000 26,805 24,135
Viacom Inc 620/15 5,000 338,745 167,850 174,600 -164,145
Volkswagen AG 4/13/15 5,000 254,306 155,625 157250 -97.056
VvIsdomtree Investments Inc 3/31/15 15000 324.158 152.550 156.604 t18Z.a8
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 44,871,109 79,243,099 64,449,372 19,578,263
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
Barclays PLC ADR 7/18/16 100,000 805,096 1,059,000 1,073,000 267,904
Mice 6/2287 5,000 161,500 0
Netease.com Inc 7/11/17 2,000 617,135 - 822,560 5,425
Credit Suisse Group 7/18/16 100,000 1,137,626 1,460,000 1.535.000 397,374
ZTO Express 10/27/16 3 5IILI 22222 4=2 12,129 aiala
2,628,107 2,729,360 3,282,990 654,883 Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill)
Teradyne Inc 7/20/17 20,000 704,832 - 691,800 -13,032
Micron Technology 6/20/17 8,000 238,880 0
XLF Flnenaciel Sector 6/20/17 20,000 487,600 493,400 501.800 14200
ON Semiconductor 6/8/17 12,000 200,038 168,480 179,400 -20,638
ING 4/4/17 25,000 373.500 434.750 468.250 94.75Q
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill) 1,765,970 1,335,510 1,841,250 75,280
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanie
Colony Capital->Colony Northstar Inc. 9/26/16 73,315 928,837 1,033,008 1,073,332 144,495
Sequential Brands 9/23/16
10/27/16
50,000
1,150
402,134
22,425
199.500 160,500 -241,634
ZTO Express 16.054 17,227 -5,198
Bank of America 3/2/16 7,500 100,825 181,950 180,900 80,075
Edites Medicine 3/2/16 3,200 102,199 53.696 54,144 -48.055
Tencent Holding !____ /16 50,000 1 163.782 1.7_±3131) . 1_998.004 834238
Total Gratitude America, LTD - E Sties (Morgan Stanley) 2,720,182 3,282,208 3,484,103 763,920
J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB)
'Bristol Myers Squibb 10/30/15 5,000 334,712 278,600 284,500 -50,212
Disney 10/30/15 2,500 2O125 _425.00 274 825 :10.2.012
Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 619,737 703,600 559,325 40,412
TOTAL EQUITIES 52,605,105 87,293,777 73,617,040 21,011,935
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF's (DB) -
Vi4sdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60,000 2,966.099 2.124,444 1138.000 171.901
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF'S (DB) 2,966,099 3,120,000 3,138,000 171,901
Southern Financial LLC - Options (08)
Long FXE 113 Calls - exp Sep 15 2017 7/19/17 450 36.006 0 98.550 62.544
Short FXE 110 Puts - exp Sep 15 2017 7/19/17 (450) -31.043 0 -7200 23.843
Total Southern Financial LW - Options (DB) 4,963 0 91,350 86,387
6130/17 7131117 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern Financial SFLLC) added i0nim VIM
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 45 393 564 45 746 548 0.78% 4.19% adds Sun 3/31/18
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 45,393,564 45,746.548 mildew 10mm 1110117
total Innsinunn 40mm
2016 mum 3.77%
Hedge Funds - Haze
King Street 3.516.505 3.648, paid to date:
Hedge Funds - Haze 3,516,505 3,648,710 2017 -api alum iron 5,967,954 paid
of capital of 7/27111-6,102,924 pM0
2,307,103 10/27/16 1,10621$1 pak
11/15 113,5114 1/27117 4994,044 paid
dstrItowthoon 2015 rem 4.45%
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb 22.545.473 g3 4.94% 17.78% maid 20mm 931/16
Total Hedge Funds - STC 22,545,473 23,660,296 2016 tarn 0A%
Total Hedge Funds 71,455,541 73,055,554
SFL
Mort Southern FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profip 0
Kyara II (investment amount) 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0
Kyara IV (investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (grat at cost) 1,000,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,000 sit
Adfin Solutions (investment amount) 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston. NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase STC 3,001,000
Spotify via Honeycomb 1,000,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Valar Global Fund II (amount funded vs 15mm committmen ) 13,650,000 (5,302017 Is Wows 5.8rtainawealzed gek0
Velar Global Fund Ill (amount funded vs 25mm committment) 15,000,000 nor ft sawn 6.120. unreal:ad pain)
Totals 1,000,000 3,000,000 34,025,000 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total Investments 47,506,000
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Alr LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 3,000,000 3,000,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 Plan D LLC 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 1,175,000 1,175,000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile 8 Boats g 2,500,000 3,000,000 250,000 17,625,000 23,375,000
Asset Description JEE SFL STC FTRE Totals
Loans Receivable
Nina Keita 150,000 150.000
Mark Lloyd 100.000 100,000
Nick Ribis 200,000 200,000
Larry / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
David Mitchell 1,500,000 1,500,000
302,000 302,000
Harley uir—inie, LL 4,750,000 4,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 1 500 000 1,500,000
200,000 200,000
a  Home 133,000 133,000
LV Home & Other 1,300,000 1,300,000
525.000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,522,446 6,450,000 0 1,935,000 10,907,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry In=
Gi8001110111 (17,084,000 pounds @ 1.30) 22,183,200 22,183,200
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) -30,500,000 -30,500,000
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - insurance value 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 -29,725,000 25,233,200 1,583,200
EFTA00811552 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2020-09-01)
Valuation Report
7/31/2017
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - JULY 31, 2017
6/30/17 7/31/17 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 127,228,936 135,985,107 8,756,171
Fixed Income 72,806,515 73,841,829 1,035,314
Equities 87,293,777 73,617,040 (13,676,737)
Equity ETF's 3,120,000 3,138,000 18,000
Options 0 91,350 91,350
Hedge Funds 71,455,541 73,055,554 1,600,012
Investments 52,506,000 47,506,000 (5,000,000)
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 26,875,000 23,375,000 (3,500,000)
Loans Receivable 11,207,446 10,907,446 (300,000)
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 1 583 200 1,583,200 0
Total Assets 454,076,415 443,100,525 -10,975,890
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
STC ML - Sold 250,000 shares BK 51.84 12,955,276
STC ML - Sold 97,525 shares GM 35.592 3,471,110
STC ML - Sold 23,000 shares GE 25.4032 584,274
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions - per brokerage stmts 304,386
STC ML - Sold 8,000 shares MU 31.64 253,120
SFL DB - Sale of AKRX, GPACU, MTCH, SQ, GLBL 199,453
STC MS - Sold 6,484 NGL Energy Partners 24.81 160,858
Enhanced - Sold 1,500 Disney 159,804
STC MS - Sold 5,000 Altice 31.5484 157,532
Enhanced - BBB (25,000)
Legal - Erika Mapp Invoice (50,717)
Miscellaneous (76,715)
Enhanced - DPNR (160,000)
NES - Pinto 400k Euro (456,128)
STC MS - Bought 2,000 NTES 308.5245 (617,049)
STC ML - Bought 20,000 shares TER 35.2016 (704,032)
STC MS - Bought 40,000 NLY 25.00 (1,000,000)
Spotify Investment via Honeycomb (1,000,000)
Monthly Spending (1,150,000)
Valar III Capital Call (4,250,000)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 50 000 8,756,171
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan 10
Asset Description Bank Bank SNP Paribas Fargo Stanley Merrill Aaudrnd• Totals
Cash
Southern Trust Company Inc. 21,524,297 343,180 299,452 1,478,105 34,538,973 58,184,007
Haze Trust 34,019.387 34,019,367
Southern Financial LLC 28,971,576 51,691 29.023.267
JEE 4,539,461 743,738 468,950 5.740,149
Gratitude America, Ltd. 625259 71,806 2,960,685 3,657.750
Jeepers Inc. 1.475.399 7,853 1.483.252
JEGE Inc. 963.188 963,188
LSJE LLC 393,800 327,261 157,161 878,221
Southern Country International LTD 453,880 453,880
Zorro Management LLC 380,501 380,501
Plan 0 LLC 220,654 220,854
NES LLC 211,421 211.421
JEGE LLC 141,777 141,777
Enhanced Education 86 512 22,126 108,639
Hyperion Air LLC 10092 100.292
JEEParis (US 6) 89,177 89.177
69.089 Neptune LLC 69.063
Thomas World Air LLC 57,579 57,579
Cypress Inc. 47,857 47,857
FT Real Estate 42,149 42.149
Maple Inc. 26,768 26.768
Freedom Alr Petroleum 22,812 22,812
Michelins Transportation Co LLC 22,736 22.736
Nautilus Inc. 15,137 15,137
Great St Jim LW 8 857 8,857
LSJ LLC 6).150 6,150
Mort Inc 4,853 4,853
Laurel Inc. 4,070 4,070
FSF LLC 937 937
IGO Company LLC 390 390
The JEE Life Ins Trust P3 206 206
Butterfly Trust 3 3
Total Cash 93,727,627 2,225,285 845,579 157,161 4,438,790 34,538,973 51,691 135,985,107
Purchase Quantity 6/30/17 741117 Unrealized
Gain (Lose) Asset Description Date Coet Value Value
Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB)
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/30/2049 05/10/11 3,000,000 3.337,958 3,158,000 3,112.500 -225,456
JPM Tr Pk Rate Income Fund 01/22/13 240,973.957 2,413,469 2,261,257 2,279,614 -133.656
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/28/14 49,033.00 1180739 1,276,819 1,264,071 83,332
Citibank Preferred Ser C 5.8% 10/29/14 150.967.00 3.810,430 3,931,181 3,891.929 221.499
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000.00 1 999.419 2.337.619 Law 630 368.211
Total Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB) 12,602,018 12,984,687 *915,744 313,728
Anvers - Fixed Income OM
JPM Trust FLT RT Income fund 02/13/13 180,515.211 1.804.981 1.693.923 1 707 674 -97 307
Total Jima, - Fixed Income (DB) 1,804,981 1,693,923 1,707,674 -97,307
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Western Digital Corp 7.375% Matures 4-1-2023 06/09/16 2,000,000 2.008.048 .2221,2O 2 244 167 158.161
Total Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stealer) 2,086,006 2,231965 2.244,167 158,161
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (O8)
Nationwide Society 6.875% GBP callable 6/20/2019 4/15/14 2,000,000 3.439.193 2.668.513 2.779_068 -680.107
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (DB) 3,439,193 2,668,513 2,779,086 460,107
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (Merrill)
Allergen mandatory convertible preffered 5.5% 3/1/2018 08/15/16 1,00%000 881,500 867,410 894,010 12,510
LSCCOM 8.75% 10/15/2023 01/13/17 26250.000 2,789,125 2.814889 2,850,774 61.649
Kindred Healthcare 7.25% 1/15/2020 STC ML 10/13/16 3,000,000 3,060,528 3260 667 3,025 667 -34.862
Teva mandatory convertible weltered 7.0% 12/1512018 08/15/16 1,000,000 901.750 694.600 04.00 -317 750
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill) 7,632,903 7,537,466 7,354,451 -278,452
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred $25 per 7/27/15 40,000 1,000,000 1,086,400 1,106,000 106,000
Annaly Cap Management 7/25/17 40,000 1.000.000 - 994,000 -8.000
NGt. Energy Partners 9%325 per 6/6/17 40,000 1,000,000 1,151,874 996,800 -3,200
Seaspan 7.875% Preferred $25 par 08/04/16 8,000 200,000 166.320 174,080 -25.920
Wells Fargo 5.7% Preferred $25 par 1/19/16 120,000 3.000.000 3,108,000 3,115,200 115,200
Ebay 6% Preferred $25 par matures 2-1-2056 2122/16 80,000 2,000.000 2,189,600 2,166,400 166,400
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9.15.2028 then boats 8/18/16 500,000 500,000 530,000 548,300 48,300
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9.15.2026 Men boats 10/11/16 2,500,000 2,623,122 2,650,000 2,730,083 106,961
Royal Sank Scotland 7.94% 'tad to 9.29.2017 than 311 Libor +2320p 11/10/15 5,000,000 5.298.817 006.000 4,931,082 467,735
Goldman Sadie 5.375% Fixed to 5-10-2020 then 3922 over 3 mo Wog 6/4/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 5,291,326 5,285,469 251,122
Capital One 5.55% Fixed to 9-1-2020 then 380 over 3 mo nor 5114/15 3.000,000 3.009.618 3J63.413 1 199.000 179.199
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 24,666,104 24,231,933 25,236,414 570,310
Southern Financial LLC • Fixed Income (08)
Bank of America 8.125% Pfd Dec 29 2049
14/3/13 2 300,000
2,055,000 2,100,013 2,123,626 68„626
Barclays Bank PLC 7.75% 4/10/2023 4/3/13 300,000 300,030 317,167 316.919 1(019
Citigroup Inc - Series 0 5.95% 816/15 3,000,000 3,000,006 3223,598 3.238.988 238,962
General Electric Co GTD Faed to Float 4.0% Dec 15 2065 12/3/15 2,489,000 2,175,016 485,460 2.458.929 281,913
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7.9% April 30 2049 8116/11 2,500,000 2,687,500 2,631,667 2,643,125 -44,375
JP Morgan Chase & Co PM 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 2,500,000 2,675,000 2,631,667 2,643,125 -31.875
LBG Capital 7.5% 12/29/49 5/21/13 1,903,000 1,948,500 2,100,446 2,130,567 182,067
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,009000 2,996,074 3,400,104 3,438,750 442.676
GMAC Cap TR I GM PM Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 60,000 1)682.774 2.096.000 2 124 000 241.226
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 19,719,870 20,986,120 21,116,009 1,396,139
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 0tallgia
Washington Mutual Mtg 2004-RA2 d Cal var 7/25/2033 11/19/13 562,781 430.64Q 489 4QQ2e55 57_64k
tiViThouthern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 430,840 4 6, 57,645
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 72,381,714 72,806,616 73,841,829 1,480,116
ore - Accrued interest has been included in month end fixed Income values
Purchase Quantity 6130/17 7/31117 Unrealized
Asset Description Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
Akom Inc 6(1 0/15 5 000 167,700 - 0
Alibaba Group 6/10/15 5.360 444,749 704,500 774,750 330.001
Allis= SE ADR 4/13/15 5,000 90,056 98,875 106,750 16,694
Apple Inc 9/5/14 84,000 6,332,800 9,217,280 9,518,720 3.185.920
Apple Inc 1/11/16 250,000 24.750,006 36.005,000 37,182,500 12,432,494
Apollo Global Management 3/31/11 263.157 4,999,983 6,960,503 7,394,712 2,394,729
Ascena Retail Group Inc. (Formerly Dress Bam 1.3.11) 1/16/01 70,500 1,500,000 151,575 164,970 -1.335.030
Avalanche Biotechnologies now called Adverum Biotechnologies 4/20/15 10.000 398,608 25,000 25,500 -373,106
BASF ADR 4/13/15 5,000 508,056 466,450 478,350 -31,706
Bank of New York Mellon 6/25/14 2561,000 12,755,000 - 0
Blogen Ides Inc 2/14/12 2.095 250.455 568,499 606,691 356238
Bioverativ Inc 2/1/17 1,047 20,254 62,998 64 883 44,629
248.484 Centene Corp 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1.242,134 1,234981
Dish Network Corp 6/10/15 5000 364978 313,800 320,150 -44,828
Facebook Inc 5/17/12 17,500 665,000 2.642.150 2.961.875 2,296,875
Foundation Medicine Inc 1/16/14 49,830 1,265,037 1,980,743 1,761,491 496,454
General Motors Co 12/9/10 97,525 3.406,548 - 0
General Electric Co 4/23/13 23,000 621,230 - 0
Gilead Sciences Inc 2/5/14 5,000 396,407 353.900 380,450 -15,957
Gilead Sciences Inc 3/7/14 3,100 246,797 219,418 235,679 -10.918
Glaxo Smith Kline PLC 6/10/15 5,000 215,006 215,600 202,600 -12.406
Global Partner Acquisition Corp 7/30/15 2,000 19,700 0
GoDaddy Inc. 4/1/15 700 14,000 29,694 30,086 16,086
Match 11/19/15 200 3,476 - 0
Mobileye NV Amstelveen Ord Shares 811/14 800 20.000 50,240 50,640 30,640
Square 11/19/15 200 3,476 - 0
Sangamo Biosciences Inc 5/28/13 50 000 422,214 440,000 430t000 7,786
Santander Consumer USA 1/28/14 1:000 24,000 12,760 12810 -11,190
Terraform Global 7/31/15 400 2,020 0
-14.865 Twitter Inc 11/7/13 1,500 39,000 26,805 24,135
Viacom Inc 620/15 5,000 338,745 167,850 174,600 -164,145
Volkswagen AG 4/13/15 5,000 254,306 155,625 157250 -97.056
VvIsdomtree Investments Inc 3/31/15 15000 324.158 152.550 156.604 t18Z.a8
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 44,871,109 79,243,099 64,449,372 19,578,263
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
Barclays PLC ADR 7/18/16 100,000 805,096 1,059,000 1,073,000 267,904
Mice 6/2287 5,000 161,500 0
Netease.com Inc 7/11/17 2,000 617,135 - 822,560 5,425
Credit Suisse Group 7/18/16 100,000 1,137,626 1,460,000 1.535.000 397,374
ZTO Express 10/27/16 3 5IILI 22222 4=2 12,129 aiala
2,628,107 2,729,360 3,282,990 654,883 Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill)
Teradyne Inc 7/20/17 20,000 704,832 - 691,800 -13,032
Micron Technology 6/20/17 8,000 238,880 0
XLF Flnenaciel Sector 6/20/17 20,000 487,600 493,400 501.800 14200
ON Semiconductor 6/8/17 12,000 200,038 168,480 179,400 -20,638
ING 4/4/17 25,000 373.500 434.750 468.250 94.75Q
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill) 1,765,970 1,335,510 1,841,250 75,280
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanie
Colony Capital->Colony Northstar Inc. 9/26/16 73,315 928,837 1,033,008 1,073,332 144,495
Sequential Brands 9/23/16
10/27/16
50,000
1,150
402,134
22,425
199.500 160,500 -241,634
ZTO Express 16.054 17,227 -5,198
Bank of America 3/2/16 7,500 100,825 181,950 180,900 80,075
Edites Medicine 3/2/16 3,200 102,199 53.696 54,144 -48.055
Tencent Holding !____ /16 50,000 1 163.782 1.7_±3131) . 1_998.004 834238
Total Gratitude America, LTD - E Sties (Morgan Stanley) 2,720,182 3,282,208 3,484,103 763,920
J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB)
'Bristol Myers Squibb 10/30/15 5,000 334,712 278,600 284,500 -50,212
Disney 10/30/15 2,500 2O125 _425.00 274 825 :10.2.012
Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 619,737 703,600 559,325 40,412
TOTAL EQUITIES 52,605,105 87,293,777 73,617,040 21,011,935
Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF's (DB) -
Vi4sdomtree Japan Hedged Equity 12/16/13 60,000 2,966.099 2.124,444 1138.000 171.901
Total Southern Financial LLC - Equity ETF'S (DB) 2,966,099 3,120,000 3,138,000 171,901
Southern Financial LLC - Options (08)
Long FXE 113 Calls - exp Sep 15 2017 7/19/17 450 36.006 0 98.550 62.544
Short FXE 110 Puts - exp Sep 15 2017 7/19/17 (450) -31.043 0 -7200 23.843
Total Southern Financial LW - Options (DB) 4,963 0 91,350 86,387
6130/17 7131117 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds - Southern Financial SFLLC) added i0rtim 3/1/16
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 45 393 564 45 746 548 0.78% 4.19% addedSun 341/16
Total Hedge Funds - SF LLC 45,393,564 45,746.548 mildew l0rnm 1110117
total lansirneat 4020.
2016 mum 3.77%
Hedge Funds - Haze
King Street 3.516.505 3.648.71Q 2016/17 paid to datir
Hedge Funds - Haze 3,516,505 3,648,710 2017 -aprN alum 4227116 4,967,956 paid
al capital al 7127116 5,102,02.4 pM0
2,301,103 10/27/16 1,10641$1 pak
Ilt16 113,401 1/27111 499004 paid
dsldbuddon MI rem LW%
Hedge Funds - STC
Honeycomb ?2.545.473 g3 4.94% 17.78% maid 20mm 931/16
Total Hedge Funds - STC 22,545,473 23,660,296 2616 tarn 044%
Total Hedge Funds 71,455,541 73,055,554
SFL
Mort Southern FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara I (repaid 100 cost + 201k profip 0
Kyara II (investment amount) 250,000
Kyara III -> 483,915 repaid 8/5/2015 0
Kyara IV (investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount) 1,000,000
Prytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,000,000
Jawbone Investment (grat at cost) 1,000,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,000 sit
Adfin Solutions (investment amount) 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston, NJ 3,000,000
Coinbase STC 3,001,000
Sootily via Honeycomb 1,000,000
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Valar Global Fund II (amount funded vs 15mm committmen ) 13,650,000 (6,302017 Is Wows 5.8rtamtratalzed gar)
Velar Global Fund III (amount funded vs 25mm committment) 15,000,000 two  ft sawn 5.120. unreal:ad pain)
Totals 1,000,000 3,000,000 34,025,000 3,001,000 6,480,000
Total Investments 47,506,000
Hyperion JEGE JEGE
Asset Description Air LLC LLC Inc Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 2,500,000 2,500,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 3,000,000 3,000,000
1968 Boeing 727 N908JE 250,000 Plan D LLC 250,000
2008 G550 15,750,000 15,750,000
Automobiles 1,175,000 1,175,000
Boats 700,000 700,000
Total Aviation, Automobile 8 Boats g 2,500,000 3,000,000 250,000 17,625,000 23,375,000
Asset Description JEE SFL STC FTRE Totals
Loans Receivable
150,000 150,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Nick Ribis 200,000 200,000
Larry / Eileen Visoski 225,000 225,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
David Mitchell 1,500,000 1,500,000
302,000 302,000
Harlequin Dane, LLC 4,750,000 4,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 1,500,000 1,500,000
Lesley 200,000 200,000
Louella Home 133,000 133,000
1,300,000 1,300,000
525 000 525,000
Total Loans Receivable 2,522,446 6,450,000 0 1,935,000 10,907,446
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry =that
Gi8001110111 (17,084,000 pounds @ 1.30) 22,183,200 22.183,200
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) -30,500.000 -30.500,000
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
32.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diamond - insurance value 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Art Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 -29,725,000 25,233,200 1,583,200
EFTA00020506 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about Epstein investigation, see quote: 'chauffeur also told Epstein "I have something on you, remember what I buried!"'
(inferred timestamp: 2020-09-14 16:12:00)
OFFICIAL RECORD [make IRcv.5 23-17r UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Intake
Date: 09/14/2020
Case ID #: SOD-NY -302757i (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 09/14/2020 12:12 PM EDT
Details:
On 09/L4/2320, at 12:12 a.m. Eastern Time, date of birth
telephone number , address refused, stated he
deported himself to Canada, email address , called
the National Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to provide information on
the Jeffrey Epstein/Ghislaine Maxwell case.
saw a Facebook post regardinc Maxwell, which triggered a memory
of him meeting Epstein and Maxwell. remembered vividly a night
in 2008, when he and Epstein were at a strip club called SCORES, located
on US 1 Federal Highway, between Oakland Park and Commercial.
struck up a conversation with Epstein, in which Epstein kept repeating
that he was a billionaire. Epstein told he came to the club
often, that he lived in Palm Beach, and said he wanted a young girl,
younger than 16 years. made a remark about that being
disgusting and Epstein's chauffeur showed up immediately, grabbed
and told him to leave Epstein alone. threatened the
chauffeur and pushed him. away. then saw a female, who he later
came to know was Ghislaine Maxwell, running toward Epstein. Maxwell asked
Epstein if he told anything. The chauffeur said Epstein told
e verything. The chauffeur also told Epstein "I have something
on you, remember what I buried!" Maxwell told the chauffeur, they had
that same thing on him.
Later, -overheard Maxwell tell Epstein she spoke to one of the
girls who worked at the club. The worker told Maxwell she had a 15 year
old friend from high school who is out on the street, and who needed
help. Maxwell told Epstein they were going to pick her up when they left
the club.
kept telling writer to talk to the chauffeur, he was a small
Re: 50D-NY-3027571, 09/14/2020
man, maybe 5 foot, with black hair. The Chauffeur knows information about
something worse than what is on the surface. also reported
Epstein's height as 5'4-5'5.
.•
2
EFTA01436428 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank client list showing Hillspire, Third Lake, Southern Financial, Elysium all managed by Stewart Oldfield
(inferred date: 2020-10-16)
Americas
Region First name Last name
tle (if applicable) DB invited by
Oct 2-7 NextGen Innovation
Oct 16-20 Napa Conference
Oct 24-26
New York Brad Wechsler
art Oldfield $7bn Yes - Nominate
New York Brad Briner Client
n Yes - Nominate
New York Kelly Masuda Prospect
$lbn Yes - Nominate
New York George Lindemann
- Nominate
New York Greg Martin Prospect
ield $500mm Yes - Nominate
New York
m Yes -
New York
$5bn Yes -
New York
mm Yes -
New York
- Nominate
New York
to
New York
- Nominate
New York
art Oldfield
New York
ield $5bn
New York
$lbn Yes - Nominate
4"arial unicode ms,Regular"Confidential
Ken Jones Client
Nominate
Robert Forsythe
Nominate
Frohman Anderson Prospect Private Client Stewart Oldfield $500
Nominate
Matt Womble Prospect Private Client Stewart Oldfield $500mm Yes
Glenn Warren Prospect Private Client New York $lbn Yes - Nomina
Client / Prospect Company (if applicable) Corporate Ti
Net worth comments Frieze London Event
Client Elysium (Leon Black family office) CEO Stew
Willett (Bloomberg) CIO Stewart Oldfield
Caruso Affiliated CIO Stewart Oldfield
Client Private Client Stewart Oldfield
Shamrock Holdings (Disney) CEO
$20b
$250mm Yes
Stewart Oldf
Third Lake (Wanek) CEO Stewart Oldfield $10m
Client Third Lake (Wanek) PM Stewart Oldfield
Heather Crosby Client Mathey's Lane Capital CEO New York $100mm Yes
James Burritt Prospect Pacific Life Head, Private Investments Stew
$20mm Yes - Nominate
Chuck Chai Prospect Hillspire (Eric Schmidt) CIO Stewart Oldf
Yes - Nominate
Paul Barrett Client Southern Financial (Epstein) PM Stewart Oldfield
Compliance info
Euro Parent ID USD
Frieze London
Dinner & Preview 679 Euro 226590 785.02
Preview 326 Euro 226591 376.90
Private View 213.03 Euro 3ULN 246.29
Day ticket 133 Euro 226595 153.77
Innovation Summit 1458 Euro 3ULQ 1685.71
Napa conference 3MAC 3771.99
&aerial unicode ms,Regular"Confidential
Do not use
Chicago Client Dinner and Preview Yes - Nominate
Los Angeles Prospect Wed Preview No
Miami Thurs Private View
New York Day Pass
San Francisco
LatAm
&aerial unicode ms,Regular"Confidential
EFTA00020515 (Jmail)
 [crypto] FBI tip about Howard Lutnick and financial irregularities
(inferred timestamp: 2020-10-19 16:11:00)
OFFICIAL RECORD [make IRev. S 23-Ill UNCLASSIFIED TI
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Intake
Date: 10/19/2020
Case ID #: 50D-NY -3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Drafted By:
Date/Time Received: 10/19/2020 12:11 PM EDT
Details:
On 10/19/2020, at 11:43 AM Eastern. Time, date of birth
cellular telephone number mail address
postal code called the FBI National
Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to report information about Howard
Lutnick, CEO of , who could be connected to Jeffrey
EpsLein.
provided the following information:
was calling from the United Kingdom, but stated he worked in. New
York from 2015 to 2017 for
was a who acted as an
after witnessing some financial irregularities. The CEO of
Cantor Fitzgerald, Howard Lutnick, was Jeffrey Epstein's neighbor and he
believes some of the suspicious financial activities could be related to
Epstein's case. says that BGC does a huge amount of charity work
relating to 9/11 because Cantor Fitzgerald lost many employees that day,
but he thinks the charity day is fraudulent. has documentation
he is willing to provide to the FBI to back these claims.
claims that Cantor Fitzgerald
causing him to have a heart attack and
Re: 50D-NY-3027571, 10/19/2020
seven subsequent hospitalizations. He has also submitted this
documentation to the Internal Revenue Service.
.•
2
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Bobbi C. Sternheim [epstein] Ghislaine Maxwell's criminal defense attorney 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00091391 (Jmail)
 [government] letter from DOJ to Bobbi C. Sternheim, Christian Everdell, Laura A. Menninger evidence list
(date: 2020-10-20)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Silvio I. Motto Building
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York. New York 10007

October 20, 2020
BY ELECTRONIC MAIL
Christian Everdell, Esq.
Mark Cohen, Esq.
Cohen & Gresser LLP
800 Third Avenue
New York, NY 10022
Laura Menninger, Esq.
Jeffrey Pagliuca, Esq.
Haddon, Morgan and Foreman, P.C.
150 East Tenth Avenue
Denver, CO 80203
Bobbi Sternheim, Esq.
Law Offices of Bobbi C. Sternheim
33 West 19th Street-4th Fl.
New York, NY 10007
Re: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
Dear Counsel:
In recognition of the Government's ongoing discovery obligations, today we are producing
copies of the materials listed in the below index, which materials are stamped with control numbers
SDNY_GM_00328070 through SDNY_GM_00356148. The password for the drive is
"USAOsdnyl!". The materials are available for pickup at the U.S. Attorney's Office in Manhattan.
Please note that both this letter and the enclosed materials are governed by the July 31,
2020 Protective Order in this case.' This letter is itself designated as "confidential," because it
includes information regarding records designated as "confidential" under the Protective
Order. An index of the materials contained in this production is below:
Files in PDF format designated as "confidential" under the protective order have been stamped
"confidential." However, certain files cannot be individually labeled as confidential on the
documents themselves due to their file format. Such files include in their electronic names the
word "Confidential."
0620.2018
Page 2
Bates Start Bates End Summary Description Confidential
Designation
SDNY_GM_00328070 SDNY_GM_00328072 2020.07.02, Aerial Video
SDNY_GM_00328073 SDNY_GM_00328092 FBI Florida Documents Confidential
SDNY_GM_00328093 SDNY_GM_00328289 FBI NY Documents
SDNY_GM_00328290 SDNY_GM_00328461 Misc. Photos Confidential
SDNY_GM_00328462 SDNY_GM_00328667 PBPD Materials
SDNY_GM_00328668 SDNY_GM_00329968 PBPD Materials Confidential
SDNY_GM_00329969 SDNY_GM_00330052 PBPD Materials Highly Confidential
SDNY_GM_00330053 SDNY_GM_00332355 PBSA Materials Confidential
SDNY_GM_00332356 SDNY_GM_00332436 Scans of FBI Evidence
SDNY_GM_00332437 SDNY_GM_00332863 Scans of FBI Evidence Confidential
SDNY_GM_00332864 SDNY_GM_00332869 Scans of FBI Evidence Highly Confidential
SDNY_GM_00332870 SDNY_GM_0033287 I Video from Florida
Investigation
Highly Confidential
SDNY_GM_00332872 SDNY_GM_00332887 Videos from Florida
Investigation
Confidential
SDNY_GM_00332888 SDNY_GM_00332890 SDFL Materials Confidential
SDNY_GM_0033289 I SDNY_GM_00332891 SDFL Materials Highly Confidential
SDNY_GM_00332892 SDNY_GM_00332894 FBI Florida Documents
SDNY_GM_00332895 SDNY_GM_00332928 FBI FL Documents (included
with 328073-328092)
Confidential
SDNY_GM_00332943 I SDNY_GM_00332958 3-D Blueprints, in PBPD
Materials (included with
328462-328667)
SDNY_GM_00332949 SDNY_GM_00356148 FBI FL Documents from Discs Confidential and
Highly Confidential
Additionally, as you are aware, the Government has seized and extracted data from
multiple electronic devices in connection with search warrants executed at Jeffrey Epstein's
properties in New York and the Virgin Islands. The data from those devices has been subject to a
privilege review, based on privileges asserted by Jeffrey Epstein's estate. Because the estate has
not waived any of those privileges, the Prosecution Team in this case will not have access to any
materials from those devices identified as privileged by the taint review team, and the Government
will not produce any such privileged material to the defense in this case.
Further, it is the Government's current understanding that none of the seized devices
belonged to the defendant, Ghislaine Maxwell, and as a result, it is the Government's
understanding that the Prosecution Team is not legally permitted to provide you with the full set
of non-privileged materials that were extracted from the devices. Instead, the Government
anticipates producing only the materials designated responsive to the relevant warrants authorizing
the search of these devices. Correspondingly, upon completion of the responsiveness review, the
Prosecution Team will only have access to that same set of non-privileged materials deemed
responsive to the relevant warrants. The Government expects to produce these responsive, non-
privileged materials to you by the November 9, 2020 deadline for completion of discovery.
0620.2018
Page 3
The Government recognizes that its discovery obligations are ongoing and will promptly
produce any additional discoverable material of which it becomes aware. Please do not hesitate
to reach out if you have any difficulty accessing these materials or if you wish to arrange a time to
review physical items in the FBI's custody.
Very truly yours,
AUDREY STRAUSS
Acting United States Attorney
by:
Assistant United States Attorneys
0610.2018
EFTA00090339 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Epstein employee
(date: 2020-11-04)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 9- Ongtouu. Ream,Clone DencensPamnot nes
fronts., ts. mimes •
use to **sewn ...I
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  01/) 3/2021
, date of birth-, was interviewed at the FEDERAL
BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION at 290 Broadway, New York, New York. Present for
the interview was attorneys Brad Edwards and Brittany Henderson.
Also present for the interview was Assistant United States Attorney-
III and Special Agent-. After being advised of the identities
of the above listed individuals and the nature of the interview,
provided the following information:
grew up in Astoria with her family; was the youngest of
five children. has a European background and grew up in a strict
household. has a big family. went to school in Astoria.
When was 15 years old, her mother passed away and she was pretty
much left on her own being the youngest child. aunts and uncles
went their own way.
met (known to law enforcement as
and her life took a different turn. worked for JEFFREY EPSTEIN.
still has trouble dealing with it; she normalized it in her mind for
so long. knew meeting EPSTEIN was wrong but he was smart and he
felt like her friend. EPSTEIN would hug and made her feel like he
was the only person she had. wanted to feel mad about it but
EPSTEIN was all she had for so many years; did not completely know
how to feel about it. Saying it all out loud, realized how messed
up it was and it took a long time for to get to that point.
has seen movies and always wondered why people did not leave when in similar
situations. has asked herself why she continued to have the
relationship with EPSTEIN. still talks to III (known to law
enforcement as ) and (known to law enforcement as
has also talked to her sister and a therapist
no longer speaks with
Investiptionon 11/04/2020 at New York, New York, United States (In Person)
Heft SOD-NY-3027571 Date drafted 01/05/2021
by

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
50D-NY -3027571
Comthuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of .On 11/04/2020 ,page 2 of 9
When was 15 years old, her mother was in the hospital for four
months before she passed away. and her sister had no guardian.
When met they smoked weed together. was independent
and also 15 years old. was living with her mother and a "go
getter". mom was strict while was not. A month after
mother passed away,
about a guy
her friend
problems.
(EPSTEIN) who
saw EPSTEIN.
would pay for
worked at a Greek restaurant
tried to get a job like that.
met EPSTEIN.
talked about like he
talked to
food -
that had
had told
was a god.
■ about her
always had money.
Greek music.
was angry with her family after her mother's passing.
agreed to meet EPSTEIN. had told
and
to massage EPSTEIN and that
he liked pretty girls and she may have to massage him in her bathing suit.
EPSTEIN was nice, comforting, and
EPSTEIN's house as hug and like a
when she would go there.
welcoming to
dream.
described
stated it felt like a high
The first time met EPSTEIN he knew everything about her. EPSTEIN
listened, hugged her, and comforted her. EPSTEIN came at the right time in
life as he seemed like a savior. There was no thought process as
just went with it. EPSTEIN reassured that he would always
be there if she ever needed anything. recalled the feeling that
EPSTEIN loved and cared about her. The first time she went to EPSTEIN's
home in Manhattan, was nervous and recalled fixing her makeup and
wanting to look older. recalled walking up to EPSTEIN's front door
because it was so massive. took to meet EPSTEIN. They
walked into his Manhattan mansion as people let them in, then they waited in
the office. EPSTEIN came in and showed around. recalled
walking by his office and seeing leopard print chairs and thinking it was so
cool because she loved leopard print. recalled going to different
floors before going to the massage room.
recalled the massage room as having a table with a little desk by
it. The room had a full cabinet with so many lotions, including Bath and
Body Works products. recalled orange scented products and stress
relief products. felt cool because it felt like she was a real
masseuse. described there being paintings on the walls.
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
50D-NY -3027571
continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of 11/04/2020 .page 3 of 9
recalled seeing a painting of a "fat lady" that was naked but look
depressed. would joke because she "had a butt" and would say that
was her while the skinny one was recalled she would never
forget the ceiling as it was not flat and there were clouds all over.
Ninety percent of the time, EPSTEIN would be on the phone while he was
getting a massage, then he would get off of the phone then flip over.
EPSTEIN would brag about who he was talking to on the phone, saying he was
on with the president or be on the phone with models. The president went on
a trip with EPSTEIN on EPSTEIN's private jet. felt that EPSTEIN
would brag about these calls on purpose.
EPSTEIN was always talking to someone in power. was very
intimidated by him. EPSTEIN was very powerful and had a very strong
presence. EPSTEIN would come in wearing "stupid sweaters" that had "JE" on
them. stated EPSTEIN "was so extra". EPSTEIN had towels that had
his initials on them. described that EPSTEIN was funny and had a
good sense of humor and would make them laugh. wanted to be a
superstar; her screen name at the time was " '. EPSTEIN told
that he had all these connections with models, and he knew the head
of Victoria's Secret. EPSTEIN made a lot of promises.
A few times, EPSTEIN drove home with a driver. recalled
they were in a black pickup suburban. EPSTEIN tried to ask to do
stuff. EPSTEIN told he could take her places and she could fly
with him. mother was in a car accident and was scared to
be in cars and flying. EPSTEIN bought things including Victoria's
Secret lingerie. EPSTEIN really liked EPSTEIN did not care if
had someone; he just wanted to see her. and
told that EPSTEIN really liked her and she should go with
him. did not like flying so she did not travel with EPSTEIN.
would call the office and talk to girls. EPSTEIN always had
LESLEY (known to law enforcement as LESLEY GROFF) call then he would
come on the phone. EPSTEIN never called direct. Eventually EPSTEIN
started asking for friends. brought to meet
EPSTEIN. estimated saw EPSTEIN 3 to 4 times. EPSTEIN
would get tired of the same girls. knew EPSTEIN saw III; he wanted
to see her.
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
SOD-NY -3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of .On 11/04/2020 ,page 4 of 9
If ever needed anything she would call because she was a
girl and felt comfortable talking to her. would rarely call
EPSTEIN personally. would ask for money or Broadway show tickets,
then would usually go to the office to pick up the money or
tickets. If needed something and it was after office hours she
would call EPSTEIN. recalled giving her identification when
she went to the office for tickets. checked her ID before giving her
the tickets. was picking up approximately six tickets. just
looked at her ID and gave it back to her. thought she was looking
at it to maybe just make sure it was her. This was in the beginning during
one of her first encounters with thought this was around
2003. The first time had gone to the office was a few months after
she started seeing EPSTEIN. thought the office was in Midtown.
Sometimes, went with some of the girls, including or
, to the office. did not go to the office with III as III
and EPSTEIN formed their own relationship and he saw III on his own. Most
of the times went in a cab to the office by herself.
EPSTEIN was straight to the point, asking when he would see or if
she had anyone new. EPSTEIN would tell her she could come at a certain
time. Sometimes, went to EPSTEIN's residence 2 to 3 times a day to
give him a massage. They did not speak over the phone about it.
would massage EPSTEIN
Then about six months later, EPSTEIN took to a different room, which
was an open room that included a jacuzzi and a lot of shower heads. This
was EPSTEIN's bedroom.
EPSTEIN did not always every time he saw her.
Sometimes, EPSTEIN just wanted
Other times, EPSTEIN wanted to
in different rooms of the house, including one time in the
room that had a stuffed dog and a tiger in it.
Seeing EPSTEIN became more personable to as it felt like EPSTEIN
was her boyfriend. EPSTEIN would spend time with her and drive her home.
knew he was not her boyfriend because he was still seeing her
friends.
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
50D-NY -3027571
Comthwdion of FD-302 of (U) Interview of .On 11/04/2020 .page 5 of 9
knew the massages were sexual because had told her.
told that she met EPSTEIN through her friend-
told that EPSTEIN was rich, he would help her, and give her money.
told that she would have to massage EPSTEIN and it would lead
to a "happy ending" and that EPSTEIN sometimes "jerked himself off".
told her she would get $300 each time. The massages turned sexual right
away when started seeing EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN always gave her $300,
sometimes he gave her $400. If went with someone, sometimes it was
would get $300 and or another girl would get $300.
EPSTEIN paid himself. If EPSTEIN gave the full amount,
sometimes only gave $200 and kept the rest for herself.
asked LESLEY if she could borrow $1000 and EPSTEIN said she
could. went to the office to pick it up. described
as blonde and nice. would tell LESLEY to tell EPSTEIN that her
friend could not make it and asked if he wanted to see instead.
would mention different girls' names to LESLEY. felt it was
pretty obvious LESLEY knew what was going on. When was 17/18 years
old she found out she was pregnant. called the office to talk to
LESLEY, saying she needed to speak to EPSTEIN as soon as possible because
she needed money to get an abortion. said the procedure would cost
her $400. LESLEY was able to get EPSTEIN on the phone right away and
EPSTEIN gave $1000 in an envelope. then went to Planned
Parenthood. EPSTEIN would send to his dentist and medical care
providers if she needed it.
was supposed to go to school in 9th grade but with her mother
passing away and her family not around, she could not focus. With
"selling her body to an older man" she felt she was "fucked up".
would rather call LESLEY than EPSTEIN when she needed money.
LESLEY knew she was staying in hotels. was too young to get an
apartment in her name as she was 16 years old at the time, so she stayed in
hotels, including Super 8. would call LESLEY, who knew she was
living in hotels, and tell her she needed money for hotels. said to
LESLEY that she could not sign a lease because she was not 18 years old.
remembered the conversation she had with LESLEY because it was when
she first booked a hotel. was staying with III for approximately 2
to 3 days when mother started "bitching" about her staying there. She
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
S0D-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of o, 11/04/2020 m g, 6 of 9
and III stormed out and they slept on the roof that night. then
called the office and talked to LESLEY. told LESLEY that she could
not get an apartment because she was not 18. told LESLEY that it
was $100 night and if she stayed for the week then she could get a better
rate. It was a hotel near house. LESLEY said she would relay the
message to EPSTEIN. ended up staying with for a while.
would take girls out, get their nails done, get a girl to be her
friend then convince her to go to see EPSTEIN. would tell this to
LESLEY and ask her if EPSTEIN could give her money to do so. Key words she
would say to LESLEY was, "I have a new friend and I was going to take her to
dinner and get her nails done". LESLEY would tell her "ok", put her on
hold, and get EPSTEIN on the line. had a deeper conversation with
LESLEY in person. There was a time when had to wait because the
money was not ready when she went to pick it up from the office - usually
the money was ready but that time it was not and she and LESLEY talked.
felt it was clear her relationship with EPSTEIN was based on money
and she felt it was clear she was underage.
said things stopped when EPSTEIN was arrested in Florida.
EPSTEIN had gone to Florida and she did not see him for a while and did not
know what had happened. just thought that he went away. had
gotten a notice when EPSTEIN was arrested. told EPSTEIN and
remembered being scared about it. EPSTEIN said he got in trouble in
Florida. remembered being mad for him. EPSTEIN said that if she
saw or heard anything, she did not know anything and to ignore it.
said EPSTEIN was still in Florida. did not think she knew what was
going on and did not mention it.
When EPSTEIN came back to New York, there were rules. One of the rules
was that girls had to bring ID and had to be 18 years old. This was for a
few months. When was around 21 years old, things with EPSTEIN "died
off". There were times where told EPSTEIN she had a girl who was 21
years old and he told that was too old. It became challenging for
to find girls that EPSTEIN liked. Sometimes lied to EPSTEIN
and told him the girl was younger than she was if she looked young, but
EPSTEIN would catch her in the lie.
had conversations with EPSTEIN on how old she was. They had
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
SOD-NY -3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of .On 11/04/2020 ,page 7 of 9
conversations about why she could not get an apartment. EPSTEIN knew
age because he asked right away, also asking where she was from
and what was her birthday. told him she was a Cancer and EPSTEIN
told her he was an Aquarius.
Two to three months after meeting EPSTEIN, brought
was best friend at the time, before had met
EPSTEIN would ask questions about her day and she would talk about
, so EPSTEIN told her that she should bring her. Sometimes,
lied to EPSTEIN that she did not have anyone. would try to find a
girl to go with her if he was not seeing her as much. EPSTEIN wanted a
certain age group, even 20 was too old for him. EPSTEIN liked 15 to 18
years old girls and liked them on the "slim side". When was 16
years old, she started training and her "butt got bigger" and EPSTEIN told
her that she
her to bring
needed to
girls, he
lose
said
the slim side?". After the
ten pounds. When EPSTEIN first started asking
something like, "Do you have any friends, but on
first few conversations with him he did not have
to tell her anymore. EPSTEIN would settle if he had to if the girl looked
young but would tell never to bring her again. EPSTEIN did not like
aggressive or experienced girls. EPSTEIN hated one girl because she tried
to do more with him and initiated more. EPSTEIN liked shy and timid girls.
EPSTEIN did not want anyone over 18 years old. and III talked about
it once and they brought a girl just to shut him up and EPSTEIN replied
"really". EPSTEIN would turn them down. There would be certain girls
knew would be willing to go. To the money she received at
the time felt like a lot of money. would tell girls that they would
massage EPSTEIN and sometimes he would masturbate. made it seem
like it was normal. normalized it in her own brain. When
would take a girl the first time, she would stay with the other girl.
Sometimes EPSTEIN would want her to stay in the room with the girl she
brought and sometimes he would want her to leave the room. EPSTEIN would
give a vibrator and tell her to go wait in the other room. When
would bring a girl, she would bring them one or two times then
would filter through friends and bring different girls.
friendships at the time were based on who was working with her to see
EPSTEIN.
remembered but dealt with more. Was
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
SOD-NY -3027571
continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of a 11/04/2020 ,page 8 of 9
EPSTEIN's go to person. was one of the girls who also worked in the
office. mostly dealt with but then later dealt with someone
else, but did not recall the person's name. recalled someone with
brown hair who worked out of the office at the house sometimes; was
not sure if this was she was recalling or someone else.
recalled talking to the last time and she said she would speak to
EPSTEIN but EPSTEIN never called
met CHRIS TUCKER in EPSTEIN's house and just said hi to him.
interaction with TUCKER was brief and just said it was nice to
meet him - they did not really talk and nothing happened with him. EPSTEIN
always told he was going to get her into Victoria's Secret, telling
her he knew NAOMI CAMPBELL. There was one time where EPSTEIN introduced
to CAMPBELL while they were in EPSTEIN's office with the stuffed
tiger. recalled something about MIKE TYSON but did not remember
what it was. EPSTEIN may have been talking to TYSON on speaker phone and
heard. EPSTEIN was always on the phone with others including, BILL
CLINTON and DONALD TRUMP.
EPSTEIN and talked via phone call but never through email or
text. EPSTEIN gave her lingerie. still has the first bra EPSTEIN
gave her; it was a white lace Victoria's Secret bra. had picked the
lingerie up from the office; LESLEY gave it to her in a Victoria's Secret
bag. EPSTEIN also gave earrings, but she gave those away.
When was not around EPSTEIN she did not want to go see him, but
when she was around him she wondered why she was beating herself up about
seeing him. EPSTEIN was only source of income for a while.
was able to get a job with " " for a while.
felt that LESLEY knew the massage appointments were sexual.
would talk with LESLEY about different girls and LESLEY was always
connecting her with EPSTEIN. LESLEY would get back on the call with
when EPSTEIN was done talking to him, so did not know if LESLEY was
on the whole time. never said anything to LESLEY about the
massages.
recalled a time when she and III were underage drinking and were
arrested. thought they were on 77th and York and went to a police
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
50D-NY -3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of .On 11/04/2020 .Page 9 of 9
station downtown. called LESLEY and EPSTEIN bailed them out. They
went to court and and III had to do community service. Was
around 17 year sold and thought III would have been 16 years old when this
happened. thought this happened in or around 2004 probably around
the end of summer.
The last time saw EPSTEIN was when she was 21 years old.
thought she spoke with EPSTEIN sometime afterwards because she had a bill
from EPSTEIN's dentist DR KAPLAN and had called LESLEY. EPSTEIN had
returned her call while she was in Walmart with her boyfriend.
thought she was around 23/24 years old at the time of this call. EPSTEIN
told her not to worry about the bill. thought the bill was around
$5000. EPSTEIN told her he was going through stuff but everything was ok
and that he hoped to see her soon. EPSTEIN never called her again.
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Jennifer Freeman [victim lawyer] victim attorney at Marsh Law Firm 
                      Marsh Law Firm [victim lawyer] victim counsel 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00078198 (Jmail)
 [girls] letter from Marsh Law Firm to USANYS allegations of sexual abuse at Epstein's house
(date: 2020-11-10)
MARSH law firm pllc
Box 4668 #65135
Ncw York, New York 10163-4668
November 10, 2020
By email
Audrey Strauss, Esq.
U.S. Attorney
U.S. Attorney's Office
Southern District of New York
1 Saint Andrews Plaza
New York, NY 10007
Dear Ms. Strauss:
and First Class Mail
Information about Possible Childhood Sexual Abuse
by Ohislaine Maxwell
On behalf of the Marsh Law Firm PLLC I anc Jo ina Silberg, PhD, 2 we write to
provide information about one of our clients, "I", a woman who has reported
that in she was sexually abused by individuals meeting the descriptions and
I I am an attorney with the Marsh Law Firm, representing hundreds of victims and survivors of
childhood sexual abuse in courts around the United States. I also chair CHILD USAdvocacy, a
non-profit organization in the United States dedicated to reforming the statutes of limitation for
child sexual abuse claims, and have helped advance statutory change for survivors by advocating
for the Amy Vicky & Andy Act in Congress and New York's Child Victims Act.
https://wwwjamesmarshlaw.com/people/jennifer-freeman/#.Xq8ZU6hKg2w.  On this matter, I
have worked with Dr. Silberg to collect evidence and other information regarding 5 turn over
child sex abuse images to law enforcement, research, compile and analyze information, advise 5 and represent her 
regarding any civil claims.
2 Dr. Silberg is an internationally renowned expert on severe childhood sexual abuse and
dissociation, was the Senior Consultant for Child and Adolescent Trauma at Sheppard Pratt
Health System in Baltimore, Maryland, and is President of the Leadership Council on Child
Abuse & Interpersonal Violence. www.thechildsurvivor.com. Dr. Silberg received a Harry and
Jeannette Weinberg grant for her work supervising Israeli therapists and studying dissociative
disorders in children. She has written up her study and findings of the abuse, dissociation and
treatment of the child victims in "A Case Series of 70 Victims of Exploitation From Child Sexual
Abuse Imagery", a chapter in a book in press by Routledge Press entitled Rearing children with
dissociative disorders: Attachment trauma, theory and practice (Sinason & Marks eds.). . See
also Silberg and Chevy Schwartz Lapin, "Expanding Our Toolkit through Collaboration:
DIR/Floortime and Dissociation-Informed Trauma Therapy for Children," Frontiers in the
Psychotherapy of Trauma and Dissociation 45-64 (2017).
1
circumstances of Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. She also has information about
other possible co-conspirators with them.
Much of
the sexual abuse, some of it documented in ima es she has rovided, has been violent and
sadistic.
she is articulate and recalls in detail certain events relating to her abuse in New York. Her
statements appear to be corroborated by documents and photographs that she has
provided.
I traveled to New York with her parents and brother soon after she turned
her passport visa, which we have a co of, confirms this. Her arents and
brother went to Atlanta seeking treatmen leaving with "foster
parents" "Mike" and "Sheila" in Brooklyn. does not think these are their real names;
she believes that Sheila's real name is Barbara Levin or Levine (she is unsure of the
spelling and the vowel sounds.) I reported that her foster parents sexually abused her and
trafficked her to others, including at "parties" at a "fancy rich house" in New York City.
There is evidence that suggests that the fancy rich house was Epstein's New York City
mansion and that Epstein and Maxwell groomed and sexually abused I at the house.
I described the owner of the fancy rich house as someone with curvy hair on top
and big fat eyebrows. She heard him called Jeffrey. She recalls massaging him with oil
and being abused by him. He wore suits or, when he wanted I to engage in sexual
activity with him, he wore a towel.
I also remembers a woman at the fancy rich house who seemed very important
and in charge at the house. She was tall, thin with short dark brown hair and brown eyes,
wore suits and other sophisticated clothing, and spoke with a British accent. I remembers
the woman standing on the big stone staircase inside the fancy rich house, sometimes
wearing yellow. I said that the woman's name had an "n" sound in it, and was something
like "Lane"," but maybe longer. I said that Lane told I that II eyes were simliar
to hers.
I reported that Lane taught I and other iris like her and older than her how to
use oil to touch men like Jeffrey. Lane took off clothes and showed I what to do by
putting oil on body. Jeffrey was in the room when Lane showed I what to do. Lane
said that I had to do whatever the men told her to do after I rubbed the oil.
I said that she was abused many times in this house by Jeffrey, and abused by
other men there too. I remembers being raped at the fancy rich house.
description of the fancy rich house matches the location and features of the
Manhattan mansion owned or controlled by Epstein in 1997. She said that the rich fancy
house was located at "9 on 71 street" in Manhattan near the big park — Epstein's mansion
2
was located at 9 East 71' Street in Manhattan just east of Central Park. She said that the
house was at least 6 stories, off-white in color, with many bedrooms, a large arched door
with a scary man on top and two smaller doors on either side with women on top —
Epstein's mansion, the largest single-family residence in Manhattan, is reportedly 7
stories, off-white, and has a large, dark brown arched front door with a male gargoyle
above it and female gargoyles on large windows on either side with doors below grade.
reported a large chandelier with a large adult doll on it and many photographs of
important people — this is consistent with media descriptions of the house furnishings.
She also said that around the house there were images which were like "scribbles" or
abstract art and images of body parts, such as a photograph of a female's buttocks. She
also remembers pictures of important people in suits.
According to I there were manysirls at the fancy rich house with Jeffrey and
Lane, but most of them were older than I reported that bigger girls were placed in
certain rooms at the fancy rich house, while younger girls, such as I and a young girl
namea were placed in other rooms. Sheila told I that it cost more money to be
with the younger girls like I and_.
At the "parties", I saw Sheila interact with Maxwell in a friendly way, indicating
that they knew each other and had attended such events together previously. She believes
Mike knew Epstein as well.
I said that last year, soon after she started openin up and disclosing the abuse to
a new therapist (not Dr. Silberg, who does not treat I), I started receiving on her phone
photographs of her abuse and other frighteningjmages. The therapist has confirmed that
she told no one except Dr. Silberg about what I disclosed. At about the same time,
foster father Mike, who has continued to contact her over the years, called I saying that
if she disclosed the abuse to anyone the horrible things that previously happened to her
would continue. I believes that Mike and others delivered the images to her as threats to
keep her quiet and perhaps to cause her to hurt herself. I provided the images, many of
which depicted childhood sexual abuse, to Dr. Silbe who understood the were ille al
to rosess and rom tl turned them over t
Two of the images sent to I which Dr. Silberg reviewed and forwarded to
were of a girl resembling I being raped by an adult male on a turquoise couch. I
believes that this rape occurred at the fancy rich house. Dr. Silberg has reported that one
of the two images shows a window, perhaps with a dark mullion, behind the adult male,
and a vista beyond the window of an off-white building and trees. Here is a cropped, non-
sexually explicit portion of the image showing the upper torso of the man, the couch, and
the window.
3
This vista appears to correspond to what might have been seen from a mullioned
bedroom window on a high floor room on the front of the Epstein mansion, looking south
over the back of the Frick Museum or another limestone building on the South side of
71St street between Madison and Fifth Avenues. Here is a photograph of the exterior of
the upper floor windows of the mansion, showing dark mullions on the upper floor
windows.
Here is a May 2009 googlemap street -level image of East 71" Street looking west
towards Central Park: Epstein's mansion is on the right side of the photo, and the back of
the Frick Museum and another limestone building is on the left side.
Here is a street-level view of East 71' Street looking east: the back of the Frick Museum
and another limestone building is on the right of the photograph, and the Epstein mansion
is further down the street on the left.
• "" n
t ' C w 0 • infirsevezioals..no.a.n...a".••••xure•afms .nrsoan, askos miss —
ft •••• • ow.. • ••• • ••• • •••• • ••••••. MOSO••••••44. m  lirea.**M•4 • CaPei..•••
Law enforcement, with access to the two original images regarding the young girl
being raped on the turquoise couch and other information, may be able to sharpen the
images, examine any metadata (presumably doubtful due to the age of the photo), and
compare them with known information to confirm whether the vista out the window in
the photographs matches the view from Epstein's mansion. In addition, images and
recollections of unreported details in the mansion could be compared with the attributes
and contents of the mansion, including whether the house contained "scribbled" abstract
artwork, images with body parts, or a turquoise couch in an upper floor room.
In order to comere the victim in the image on the turquoise couch with here is
a family photograph of. on a return flight from New York to Israel, wearing headphones
and leaning against what looks like an airplane passenger seat. The photograph shows
significant injury to her face and neck.
5
The headphone on U head and the passenger seat are similar to that of El Al air travel in
this 1994 photo --
http://www.israelairlinemuseum.orWel-al-israels-flying-star/chapter-8-the-heart-takes-off-
expansion-in-the-early-90s-1990-1996/
We also have a document comparing her face when visible in the pornographic
images held by M with pictures from her childhood to help substantiate that these
pictures are of her. We are happy to share that document if desired. Several of the
pornographic pictures have her full face in view.
Here is another family photo of I at about age..
Here is a photo, which I believes was from Mike, of I (in the blue shirt) and
Olivia, with Mike standing behind them. The image was sent to . phone.
6
has an additional image showing part of Mike's face, this time visibly participating
in abusing 13 Together, the two partial images of Mike's face, may help identify him.
Last year, in addition to sending I images, I stated that Mike told that her
foster mother Sheila was goin to come to Israel and would take I t
to a "nice" family did not believe that would be nice at all.
While media stories have stated that Epstein and Maxwell's victims were mostly
teenagers, there is evidence that suggests that they also abused younger girls. Jean-Luc
Brunel reportedly provided Epstein a birthday gift of 12 year old triplets; Epstein victim
stated in the Netflix documentary "Who Killed Jeffrey Epstein" (Episode
wh en she worked as a receptionist at the NYC mansion in about 1995, "Many
girls, little girls, were always goin in and out"; a hone message slip referred to Russian
lessons from "2x8 years old"; an' in an exposé from Australian
television said that Epstein sought girls, the younger the better.
images presumably could be shown to other Epstein/Maxwell victims to see if
they remember her. It is our understanding that at the Epstein NYC mansion I was
3 The photo shows a girl, her face visible, who looks prepubescent with medium length
dark hair. Several Caucasian men are holding the girl's legs spread open, her vagina is
visible and gashed, and there is blood coming out. In the photo's foreground, a man with
a white shirt appears to be inserting his hand or something into her vagina. A round
imprinted symbol of some kind is visible on the girl's leg on the underside of her left
thigh. In the photo's right hand corner, there is an arm with a green shirt visible. An arm
holds the girl's knee in the air. In the photo's left foreground, there is a profile of aman
with long sideburns, a beard and a small bald spot on hishead. In the photo's background
on the left there appears to be the unclothed top torso of a man. A man with what appears
to be a black t-shirt and a blue shirt appears to the left of the girl's face. On the photo's
lower left, there is a green structure which is hard to identify. The girl's mouth looks
bloody and her tongue is extended. There is a bruise under her left eye and a red mark on
the left side of her neck. Her left shin is bleeding, and there are purplish bruises on her
abdomen. I recalls the actions taking place in this additional image.
7
referred to Maxwell could be interviewed about her association with Mike
and "Sheila"/Barbara as well as her memory ofd
There appears to have been and continue to be a connection between some of the
perpetrators and Ukraine/Russia. I has provided us with two phone numbers she was
instructed to call to connect to her traffickers, which have been confirmed to us by
DeliverFund (Mike Fullilove) to be located in Ukraine -- which resolves to
a mobile number in Ukraine, and which resolves to a landline in Ukraine
For example, on September 3, 2019, after one of the traffickers had arranged
through one of the Ukranian phone numbers to see and did not show up, received
the following message.
, 00i
'nr
T1/4
71N MR
I1N 11971
wpm) onm
nip»
I N
10
rall•pr•
The English translation for the above message in Hebrew is "Garbage, where are you,
where are you. Where are you, we are waiting, at the train, come". Note there is a
number at the top of this message which might be traceable.
I has continued to be threatened with phone messages about what would happen
to her if she disclosed the abuse. For example, in August 2019, received a message on
her phone depicting a mutilated woman with the message in Hebrew, "This is what will
happen to you if you talk, so be quiet." The sending number on her phone was
When thinks about what happened to her,
It is very hard for her to talk about the
abuse. Sometimes, other parts of herself that appear as little children can remember more
than I remembers. But she does remember the house, Jeffrey, "Lane", Mike, Sheila,
some of the abuse, and sometimes the names of other people in the house who abused
her.
8
I does not watch the news and does not know about any of this from television or
news shows. Dr. Silberg told her that there was news about it, but she said that she did
not look at it. I stated that any memories she recalled were from her own mind and
memory, not from any other source.
There is a storehouse of additional evidence about the abuse of including
names of other adults who were at the NYC mansion. has approximately 30 images
showing the abuse of a girl who looks strikingly like some of which include
identif in features in the ima es. We continue to work with of•
, Mike Fullilove of DeliverFund
from HSI ( -
), all of whom know we are writing to you and are available
to speak with you.
We suspect that some of the evidence we have may relate to current abuse
happening to children, which we are also happy to discuss with you as well.
Last year, we reached out to AUSA advising him of.
connection to Jeffrey Epstein and seeking visa assistance for who at that time
considered coming to the U.S. for medical treatment. We also communicated with FBI
representatives. At this point, we have more complete information to provide, including
informationspecifically relevant to Ghislaine Maxwell during 1997.

Dr. Silberg and I are available to discuss this matter, contribute our information,
and answer any questions that you may have.
Sincerely,
Jennifer Freeman
cc: Dr. Joyanna Silberg I
Stephen Sauer
Mike Fullilove
Noel Engels
9
EFTA00039282 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2020-11-18)
EFFECTIVE NOVEMBER 18. 2020
Elements of Prohibited Acts

I. Elements of Prohibited Acts: Elements of prohibited acts are the definitions of the
conduct which constitutes commission of the prohibited acts. Elements are facts which
must be present in order to prove the commission of a prohibited act. There are specific
facts which constitute or make up each prohibited act that must be established in the record
before you can find guilt or commission of the act.
Elements consist of four or five categories (depending on the offense) which must be
present in order to prove commission of the prohibited act. They are:

A. Subject: The inmate accused of committing the prohibited act must be properly
identified and described in the -description of the incident' and in the "specific
evidence relied upon. Normally, the name and register number is sufficient.

B. Time: Usually described as the day and hour the incident occurred.
C. Location: The place or places the offense was committed. Gives notice of what to
defend and establishes our right to regulate the inmate's conduct.

D. Act: The description of the actions or conduct of the inmate which constitute the
commission of the specific prohibited act. **This Li the most significant element
and presents the most problems in definition.

E. Victim: Must be described and identified in those instances where the prohibited
act or offense is against another person. An assault requires a victim. Failing to
provide a urine sample does not.

II. Elements Determine What Offense is to be Charged
A. Description: The description of the incident on the incident report.

1. Staff must describe in factual terms what they observed, heard, tasted or
smelled.
2. Section I I must contain all elements of prohibited acts.
3. This description provides the Wolff notice requirement.
Elements of Offense
Code Offense
100 Killing. Deprive of life.
101 Assaulting any person, or an armed assault on
the institution's secure perimeter (a charge for
assaulting any person at this level is to be used
only when serious physical injury has been
attempted or accomplished).
An attempt or threat to do violence to
another; includes battery, or the unconsented
touching of another.
102 Escape from escort; escape from any secure or
non-secure institution, including community
confinement, escape from unescorted
community program or activity; escape from
outside a secure institution.
Escape - departure from custody without
permission or authority or before official
release.
103 Setting a fire (charged with this act in this
category only when found topose a threat to life
or a threat of serious bodily harm or in
furtherance of a prohibited act of Greatest I
severity, e.g., in furtherance of a riot or escape;
otherwise, the charge is properly classified Code
218 or 329).
To cause ignition or combustion; includes
destructive burning.
104 Possession, manufacture, or introduction of a
gun, firearm, weapon, sharpened instrument,
knife, dangerous chemical, explosive,
ammunition, or any instrument used as a
weapon.
Possess - to have on ones person or under
one's dominion or control. Manufacture - to
make or fashion something.
Introduce - to bring in from outside the
institution; any of the objects listed.
105 Rioting. Participates with two or more other persons
in a disturbance for purpose of preventing or
coercing official action with actual or threats
of violence.
106 Encouraging others to riot. Promotes or urges others to participate in a
riot.
107 Taking Hostage(s). To take someone captive with threats to kill
or harm if demands are not met.
108 Possession, manufacture, introduction, or loss of
a hazardous tool (tools most likely to be used
in an escape or escape attempt or to serve as
weapons capable of doing serious bodily harm to
others; or those hazardous to institutional
security or personal safety; (e.g., hacksaw blade,
body armor, maps, handmade rope, or other
escape paraphernalia, portable telephone, pager
or other electronic device).
Possess - to have on ones person or under
ones dominion or control Manufacture - to
make or fashion something.
Introduce — to bring in from outside the
institution; any of the objects listed.
I H) Refusing to provide a urine sample; refining to
breath into a Breathalyzer; refusing to take part
on other drug abuse testing.
Voluntary or intentional decision not to
provide a specimen of urine for testing; a
stated inability to provide a urine sample
within reasonable time, normally two hours.
Voluntary or intentional decision not to
breathe into a Breathalyzer for alcohol or
other intoxicant testing. Voluntary or
intentional decision not to take part in other
alcohol/intoxicant testing/drug abuse testing
as required.
111 Introduction or making of any narcotics,
marijuana, drugs, alcohol, intoxicants, or related
paraphernalia, not prescribed for the individual
by the medical staff.
Introduce - to bring in from outside the
institution.
Making- to make or construct any narcotics,
drugs, alcohol, intoxicants, or related
paraphernalia.
112 Use of any narcotics, marijuana, drugs, alcohol,
intoxicants, or related paraphernalia, not
prescribed for the individual by the medical
staff.
To be seen using or testing positive for the
use of any narcotics, marijuana, drugs,
alcohol, intoxicants, that has not been
prescribed for the individual by the medical
staff.
113 Possession of any narcotics, marijuana, drugs,
alcohol, intoxicants, or related paraphernalia, not
prescribed for the individual by the medical
staff.
To possess means to have on ones person or
under ones dominion or control of the hard
contraband identified.
114 Sexual assault of any person, involving non-
consensual touching by force or threat of force.
Sexual assault includes the unconsented
intimate physical contact with another
person which includes an attempt or threat
of physical violence.
115 Destroying and/or disposing of any item during a
search or attempt to search.
Includes throwing items away from staff or
flushing items when a search is being
conducted or attempting to conduct a search.
196 Use of the mail for an illegal purpose or to
commit or further a Greatest category prohibited
act.
Use of the mail to commit or aid in the
commission of a crime or a Greatest
category prohibited act.
197 Use of the telephone for an illegal purpose or to
commit or further a Greatest category prohibited
act.
Using the telephone to commit or aid in the
commission of a crime or a Greatest
category prohibited act.
198 Interfering with a staff member in the
performance of duties most like another Greatest
category prohibited act. This charge is to be used
only when another charge of Greatest severity is
not accurate. The offending conduct must be
charged as "most like' one of the listed Greatest
categories prohibited acts.
Interfering - to hamper, hinder, or disturb a
staff member performing his duties. Must be
related to 100 level activities.
Code
199 Conduct Conduct which disrupts or interferes with the
orderly running of the institution or the Bureau
of Prisons most like another Greatest category
prohibited act. This charge is to be used only
when another charge of Greatest severity is not
accurate. The offending conduct must be
charged as "most like one of the listed Greatest
categories prohibited acts.
Any act of Greatest Severity level which is
not specifically described in other prohibited
acts listed above, but which causes disorder
or turmoil in the operation of a prison.
HHIIH Offense Elements
200 Escape from a work detail, non-secure
institution, or other non-secure confinement,
including community confinement, with
subsequent voluntary return to the Bureau of
Prisons custody within four hours.
Departure from custody without permission
or authority or before release; includes
failure to follow instructions of staff as to
the limits of the activity; or commission of
an act which prevents the inmate from
returning at the time and place prescribed
(such as an arrest based on probable cause),
and the inmate voluntarily returns within
four hours.
201 Fighting with another person. A light' is a hostile, physical or verbal
encounter or engagement between two or
more persons.
203 Threatening another with bodily harm. A communication of an intent to inflict
physical or other harm on any person or on
property.
204 Extortion, blackmail, protection, demanding or
receiving money or anything of value in return
for protection against others, to avoid bodily
harm, or under threat of informing
To obtain anything of value from another
induced by the wrongful use of actual or
threatened force, violence or fear.
205 Engaging in sexual acts. Take part in intimate physical contact with
self or another.
206 Making sexual proposals or threats to another. Offering or encouraging another to engage
in a sexual act or in intimate physical
contact; a threat is a communicated intent to
inflict physical or other harm on the person
or on property.
207 Wearing a disguise or a mask. Have on one's face or other portion of one's
body an item which conceals, changes or
alters identity or appearance.
208 Possession of any unauthorized locking device,
or lock pick, or tampering with or blocking any
lock device (includes keys), or destroying,
altering, interfering with, improperly using, or
damaging any security device, mechanism, or
procedure.
Possess - have on ones person or have
under ones control.
Tamper - to meddle with for purpose of
altering, destroying, etc.
209 Adulteration of any food or drink. Adulterate - to debase or make impure.
211 Possessing any officer's or staff clothing. Possess - have on ones person or have under
ones control or dominion.
Code Offense Elements
212 Engaging in or encouraging a group
demonstration.
To participate or promote others to
participate with two or more persons
gathering together to support a cause.
213 Encouraging others to refuse to work, or to
participate in a work stoppage.
To promote or urge other inmates to refuse
to work or participate in a work stoppage.
216 Giving or offering an official or staff member a
bribe, or anything of value.
Bribe - giving something of value to
persuade or induce favor or action.
217 Giving money to, or receiving money from, any
person for the purpose of introducing contraband
or any other illegal or prohibited purpose.
Contraband - anything an inmate is not
permitted to have in his possession, i.e., not
issued or not authorized to retain.
218 Destroying, altering, or damaging government
property, or the property of another person,
having a value in excess of $100.00, or
destroying, altering, damaging life-safety
devices (e.g., fire alarm) regardless of financial
value.
The $100+ value applies to both government
and personal property; othenvise, it is a
Code 329 offense.
219 Stealing; theft (including data obtained through
the unauthorized use of a communications
device, or through unauthorized access to disks,
tapes, or computer printouts or other automated
equipment on which data is stored).
Stealing - to take or appropriate the property
of another without permission or right.
220 Demonstrating, practicing, or using martial arts,
boxing (except for use of a punching bag),
wrestling, or other forms of physical encounter,
or military exercises or drill (except for drill
authorized by staff).
"Martial' refers to war or warlike; we
prohibit all but punching a bag because this
conduct may be mistakenly perceived as
fighting or may precipitate disruption or a
disturbance. It also encourages militant
group behavior which is inconsistent with
security.
221 Being in an unauthorized area with a person of
the opposite sex without staff permission.
An area may be 'unauthorized'because of a
written rule, an oral order or direction by
staff, or because of circumstances. The
'person of the opposite sex' refers to inmates
or visitors, not staff. A prohibited act
described to cover a situation where two
inmates of opposite sex at co-correctional
institution are discovered in an inappropriate
area, but before there is any evidence of
sexual intent or content.
Code Offense Elements
224 Assaulting any person (a charge at this level is
used when less serious physical injury or contact
has been attempted or accomplished by an
inmate).
Sec Code 101. Assault is an attempt or
threat to do violence to another and includes
battery or the unconsented touching of
another.
225 Stalking another person through repeated
behavior which harasses, alarms, or annoys the
person, after having been previously warned to
stop such conduct.
A documented pattern of repeated behavior
which harasses, alarms, or annoys a person
after being ordered or previously warned to
cease such conduct.
226 Possession of stolen property. To have in ones possession, control, or
domain any stolen item(s).
227 Refusing to participate in a required physical test
or required examination unrelated to testing for
drug abuse (e.g., DNA, HIV, tuberculosis).
Voluntary or intentional decision not to take
part in a required physical test or
examination unrelated to drug abuse or
alcohol testing.
228 Tattooing or self-mutilation. To put indelible patterns on the skin; to
injure, disfigure or make imperfect by
removing or irreparably damaging parts of
the body (wrist cutting falls within this
offense).
229 Sexual assault of any person, involving non-
consensual touching without force or threat of
force.
Sexual assault includes the unconsented
intimate or non-sexual physical contact with
another person which does not include a
threat of physical violence.
23I Requesting, demanding, pressuring, or otherwise
intentionally creating a situation, which causes
an inmate to produce, display his/her own court
documents for any unauthorized purpose to
another inmate.
Requesting, demanding, pressuring, or
otherwise intentionally creating a situation,
which causes an inmate to produce or
display his/her own court documents for any
unauthorized purpose to another inmate.
296 Use of the mail for abuses other than criminal
activity which circumvent mail monitoring
procedures (e.g. use of the mail to commit or
further a High category prohibited act, special
mail abuse, writing letters in code; directing
others to send, sending, or receiving a letter or
mail through unauthorized means; sending mail
for other inmates without authorization; sending
correspondence to a specific address with
directions or intent to have the correspondence
sent to an unauthorized person.
Use of the mail in violation of the policy on
mail regulations which circumvents mail
monitoring procedures.
Code Offense
297 Use of the telephone for abuses other than
criminal activity which circumvent the ability of
staff to monitor frequency of telephone use,
content of the call, or the number called; or to
commit or further a High category prohibited
act.
Using the telephone in violation of the
policy on telephone regulations which
circumvents telephone monitoring
procedures.
298 Interfering with a staff member in the
performance of duties, most like another High
severity prohibited act. This charge is to be used
only when another charge of High severity is not
accurate. The offending conduct must be charged
as "most like one of the listed High severity
prohibited acts.
See Code 198.
299 Conduct which disrupts or interferes with the
security or orderly running of the institution or
the Bureau of Prisons most like another High
Severity prohibited act This charge is to be used
only when another charge of High severity is
not accurate. The offending conduct must be
charged as most like* one of the listed High
severity prohibited acts.
See Code 199.
Code Offense Elements
300 Indecent Exposure. Indecent means offending against
recognized standards of propriety; exposure
means to display; non-accidental display of
genitals.
302 Misuse of authorized medication. To use authorized/prescribed medication in
a manner contrary to instructions.
303 Possession of money or currency, unless
specifically authorized, or in excess of the
amount authorized.
Possess - to have on ones person or under
one's control.
304 Loaning of property or anything of value for
profit or increased return.
To grant temporary use for the purpose of
gaining money or an advantage.
305 Possession of anything not authorized for
retention or receipt by the inmate, and not issued
to him through regular channels.
To possess means to have on ones person or
under one: dominion or control; although
notice of what constitutes contraband
generally is presumed, look to policies,
rules, procedures and law to establish where
reasonably questioned.
306 Refusing to work or accept a program
assignment.
Declining or expressing a determination not
to perform assigned tasks; also, includes
program assignments like general
population and educational classes.
307 Refusing to obey an order of any staff member
(may be categorized and charged in terms of
greater severity, according to the nature of the
order being disobeyed, e.g., failure to obey an
order which furthers a riot would be charged as
Code 201, ( Fighting; refusing to provide a urine
sample when ordered would be charged as 110).
Declining or expressing a determination not
to follow commands (instructions and
restrictions) of a BOP employee and others
placed in a position of authority by a BOP
employee.
308 Violating a condition of furlough. To break or fail to follow rules listed on the
furlough form.
309 Violating a condition of a community program. Failure to follow established rules other than
those set forth on furlough papers; usually
CCC's.
310 Unexcused absence from work or any program
assignment.
Not at an assigned placed at a certain time.
311 Failing to perform work as instructed by the
supervisor.
Similar to 319; use when specific orders of
the work supervisor are violated.
312 Insolence towards a staff member. Contemptuously rude or impertinent in
behavior or speech toward a staff member.
313 Lying or providing a false statement to a staff
member.
Self-explanatory offense; must disrupt
security, order or discipline.
Code Offense Elements
314 Counterfeiting, forging or unauthorized
reproduction of any document, article of
identification, money, security, or official paper
(may be categorized in terms of greater severity
according to the nature of the item being
reproduced; (e.g.., counterfeiting release papers
to affect escape, Code 102).
Self-explanatory offense as described.
315 Participating in an unauthorized meeting or
gathering.
To take part in meeting or gathering of
inmates without staff permission.
316 Being in an unauthorized area without staff
authorization.
Located in a place that an inmate is
forbidden to be in because of orders,
policies or established procedures.
317 Failure to follow safety or sanitation regulations
(including safety regulations, chemical
instructions, tools, MSDS sheets, OSHA
standards).
Nonperformance of established rules
concerning safety and sanitation.
318 Using any equipment or machinery without staff
authorization.
Self-explanatory offense as described.
319 Using any equipment or machinery contrary to
instructions or posted safety standards.
Similar to 317; specifically covers use of
equipment or machinery.
320 Failing to stand count. Absent during count or failing to stand up
during count.
321 Interfering with the taking of count. Any action which hampers or inhibits staff
from taking a count other than those actions
listed in Code 320.
324 Gambling. To play any game of chance for stakes.
325 Preparing or conducting a gambling pool. See Code 324; to be used where evidence
establishes the inmate is responsible for
setting up or running the game of chance.
326 Possession of gambling paraphernalia. See Code 324; where evidence only shows
possession of gambling items, but not used
in a game.
327 Unauthorized contacts with the public. Self-explanatory offense: to be used where
an inmate needs permission to contact
someone outside the institution.
328 Giving money or anything of value to or
accepting money or anything of value from
another inmate, or any other person without staff
authorization.
Self-explanatory offense as described. See
also Code 217 where evidence shows the
purpose of giving is for introducing
contraband or other illegal purpose.
Code Offense Elements
329 Destroying, Altering, or Damaging Government
Property, or the Property of Another Person,
Having a Value of $100 or Less.
Self-explanatory offense; see Code 218 for
higher severity offense for value more than
5100.
330 Being Unsanitary or Untidy; Failing to Keep
One's Person and One's Quarters in Accordance
with Posted Standards.
Self-explanatory offense: used where living
area is unclean or not maintained in an
acceptably clean and tidy manner.
331 Possession, Manufacture, or Introduction of a
nonhazardous tool or other Non-Hazardous
Contraband (tool not likely to be used in an
escape attempt or to serve as a weapon capable
of doing serious bodily harm to others, or not
hazardous to institutional security or personal
safety; other nonhazardous contraband includes
such items as food or cosmetics).
Self-explanatory offense; see Code 104 for
description of possession, manufacture or
introduction. See also Code 108 for greater
severity offense.
332 Smoking where prohibited. Smoking in an area that is designated by
policy to be a non- smoking area.
333 Fraudulent or deceptive completion of a skills
test (e.g., cheating on a GED, or other education
or vocational skills test).
Self-explanatory offense; used when
cheating on an educational or vocational
test.
334 Conducting a business; conducting or directing
an investment transaction without staff
authorization.
To direct, engage, carry on an occupation,
profession, or trade. Occupation means the
person's usual or principal work. A
profession usually refers to an occupation
which requires extensive education. Trade
refers to buying, selling, or exchanging
commodities or other items.
335 Communicating gang affiliation; participating in
gang related activities; possession of
paraphernalia indicating gang affiliation.
Used when an inmate is wearing clothing,
items, etc. to show gang affiliation, making
hand signals, etc. Use other higher and
greater severity codes when behavior
involves fighting, assaults, and group
demonstrations.
336 Circulating a petition. Circulating a petition to protest conditions
or to effect a change of some sort.
396 Use of the mail for abuses other than criminal
activity which do not circumvent mail
monitoring; or use of the mail to commit or
further a Moderate category prohibited act.
Use of the mail in violation of policy which
does not circumvent mail monitoring
procedures.
397 Use of telephone for abuses other than illegal
activity which do not circumvent the ability of
staff to monitor frequency of telephone use,
content of the call, or the number called; or to
commit or further a Moderate category
prohibited act.
Use of the telephone in violation of policy
which does not circumvent telephone
monitoring procedures.
Code
MET 398 Interfering with a Staff Member in the
Performance of Duties, Most Like Conduct must
be of the Moderate severity nature. This charge
is to be used only when another charge of
moderate severity is not applicable.
See Code 198.
399 Conduct which Disrupts or Interferes with the
Security or Orderly Running of the Institution or
the Bureau of Prisons, Most Like Conduct must
be of the Moderate severity nature. This charge
is to be used only when another charge of
moderate severity is not applicable.
See Code 199.
Code Offense Elements
402 Malingering, Feigning Illness. Malingering means to feign illness.
404 Using Abusive or Obscene Language. Using coarsely insulting, indecent or lewd
language.
407 Conduct with a Visitor in Violation of Bureau
Regulations.
Inappropriate actions with a visitor after
notice of written rule (would include
excessive sexual contact short of engaging
in a sex act, Code 205).
409 Unauthorized Physical Contact. Unacceptable physical contact, usually with
another inmate; see also Code 205,
Engaging in Sexual Acts, and Code 407 for
visitor related activities.
498 Interfering with a Staff Member in the
Performance of Duties, Most Like Conduct must
be of the Low Moderate severity nature. This
charge is to be used only when another charge of
low moderate severity is not applicable.
See Code 198.
499 Conduct which Disrupts or Interferes with the
Security or Orderly Running of the Institution or
the Bureau of Prisons, Most Like Conduct must
be of the Moderate severity nature. This charge
is to be used only when another charge of
moderate severity is not applicable.
See Code 199.
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ted Waitt [epstein] boyfriend of Ghislaine Maxwell, guest at Chelsea Clinton wedding 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01249968 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of unknown girl
(date: 2021-01-12)
-1 of 12-ID.302 (Rev. 54440)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
01/12/2021

<REDACTED> date of birth (DOB) , was interviewed via
video conference. Present on the video call was <REDACTED> attorney <REDACTED>
Also present on the video call was Assistant United States Attorneys
<REDACTED> and <REDACTED>, along with Detective IIII and Special
After being advised of the identities of the above
listed individuals and the nature of the interview, <REDACTED> provided the
following information:

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

In the fall of 2004, <REDACTED> thought she worked with <REDACTED>
<REDACTED> was originally placed  in a model's apartment for
teenagers because she was <REDACTED>. <REDACTED> was moved to an apartment
with three older girls in their twenties, <REDACTED> LAST NAME UNKOWN (LNU),
<REDACTED> LNU, and <REDACTED> LNU. <REDACTED> was approximately 22-25 years old,
<REDACTED> was approximately 20-21 years old, and <REDACTED> was approximately 25-
26 years old. They told <REDACTED> she could massage a guy (JEFFREY EPSTEIN) for
a couple hundred dollars. <REDACTED> was told she would have to be in lingerie
while giving the massage. They told <REDACTED> he was nice and would talk on the
phone taking business calls and would ask questions about her. They told
<REDACTED> he would tell you what to do and would have to rub his feet and
calves. All three of the girls in the apartment with <REDACTED> went and all
said he was nice. Looking back on it <REDACTED> does not know why she did not
think it was creepy because that is how her <REDACTED> self feels.
New York, New York, United States U Other (Video
MWMISMWMOn 08/13/2020 m Conference))
Hem SOD-NY-3027571
Date drafted 08/26/2020

3501.483-004
Page 1 of12
ED•302a (Rev. 5.810)
500 -NY -3027571
They put <REDACTED> in touch with <REDACTED> thought she first
met <REDACTED> in the park. <REDACTED> told <REDACTED> that EPSTEIN was nice, he
helps people, and has connections in the modeling world. <REDACTED> met<REDACTED>
on a different day around the subway station at Hunter College, where they
walked to EPSTEIN's New York residence at 9 <REDACTED> 71st. <REDACTED> did not
remember if <REDACTED> had stayed with her and did not recall who answered the
door when they arrived. <REDACTED> remembered being in the massage room.
EPSTEIN came in the room and told <REDACTED> to start massaging his feet.
EPSTEIN asked <REDACTED> questions. <REDACTED> did not remember everything that
happened the first time she went. <REDACTED> thought EPSTEIN paid her but was
not sure. <REDACTED> stated bits and pieces all melded together.

<REDACTED> called telling her EPSTEIN really liked her and would like
to see her again, so <REDACTED>  went back. <REDACTED>  went back a couple times. In
2004, <REDACTED> called her and invited her to the island. <REDACTED> said she
could not go to the island because she had to work to pay her rent. <REDACTED>
was supposed to be working at <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>.<REDACTED> was
going to receive $50 for two days of work. <REDACTED> told that <REDACTED> EPSTEIN
would pay her rent for a month if she went to the island. <REDACTED> was told
she would have a photo shoot on the island; <REDACTED> recalled this because she
had written this down. <REDACTED> did not recall if she flew with <REDACTED> to
the island. Once she arrived on the island, <REDACTED> remembered meeting
<REDACTED>. <REDACTED> was nervous and <REDACTED> was really nice and a calm and
easy person. <REDACTED> remembered KATHY ALEXANDER and MILES ALEXANDER, who
worked on the island. <REDACTED> remembered EPSTEIN, <REDACTED> and <REDACTED> all
being on the island with her. <REDACTED> did not recall if there was anyone
else. <REDACTED> did not remember what contact happened with EPSTEIN on the
island during this trip. <REDACTED> did not recall if it was this first time she
went to the island or a different time where EPSTEIN sexually penetrated
<REDACTED>. <REDACTED> described "it's all a blur".

<REDACTED> recalled going to every property EPSTEIN owned, including New York,
Palm Beach, Little St. James, New Mexico, and Paris. <REDACTED> also recalled
EPSTEIN having an apartment in Boston that she had visited. <REDACTED> has also
been in OHISLAINE MAXWELL's London house.

<REDACTED> spent years with EPSTEIN. <REDACTED> time with EPSTEIN tapered off in
approximately 2006/2007. <REDACTED> did not recall exactly when EPSTEIN had been
involved with the "court stuff" but her time with him went on during that
time period. In 2009, when EPSTEIN was on work release, <REDACTED> traveled to
see him. <REDACTED> thought there was another time where "they" asked her to
help them on Little St James when EPSTEIN was hosting a science convention.

<REDACTED> had seen MAXWELL's name on notepads. <REDACTED> asked <REDACTED> who
that was. <REDACTED> told <REDACTED> that MAXWELL used to be EPSTEIN's girlfriend.
<REDACTED> also told <REDACTED> that MAXWELL traveled with them and helped manage
EPSTEIN's properties. <REDACTED> first met MAXWELL in New Mexico at EPSTEIN's
Zorro Ranch. <REDACTED> described MAXWELL as seeming to be a badass woman,
because she was a helicopter pilot and would share stories, one of which
MAXWELL described a robber coming onto the ranch and MAXWELL pretended to
have a fake gun and put it to the robber's back.

<REDACTED> described <REDACTED> as EPSTEIN's right hand woman. <REDACTED> was an
assistant who did everything for EPSTEIN.

<REDACTED> described other individuals that she met in EPSTEIN's circle.

- <REDACTED>, who was EPSTEIN's girlfriend
- <REDACTED> who <REDACTED> recalled seeing her mainly in Florida, and also
on Little St James
- who was EPSTEIN's other girlfriend in approximately 2006
- IGOR ZANOVEV, who was EPSTEIN's trainer
- ALEX or ALEC, who was another Russian trainer who was friends with <REDACTED>

<REDACTED> flew with DAVE RODGERS, which according to his flight logs showed
<REDACTED> on approximately 25 flights. <REDACTED> also flew with another pilot LARRY
VISOSKI. <REDACTED> recalled flying every week. <REDACTED> remembered traveling more
to Palm Beach and the island.

While in Palm Beach, <REDACTED> waited around for EPSTEIN to tell her what to
do. EPSTEIN and <REDACTED> told <REDACTED> to ask if she needed anything
before doing something. <REDACTED> recalled a time where EPSTEIN and were
upset with her because she took a four -wheeler out on the island without
them knowing.

Initially, <REDACTED> thought EPSTEIN liked her. <REDACTED> thought she was
EPSTEIN's girlfriend before she realized that she was not his girlfriend.
felt like a floater; felt all over the place. EPSTEIN offered
to put her on the payroll, so was like an assistant. thought
3501.483-004
Page 3 of 12
FD.302.1(ReV.5.840)
50D —NY-3027571
Continuation olTD•302 or (U) Interview of JM 08/13/2020 ,page 4 of 12
she was put on EPSTEIN's payroll around 2005. Some of
responsibilities as an assistant included asking iif she needed help
with something, making EPSTEIN sandwiches, and running errands. felt
like a "schlepper". Around the end of 2005, started going to
MAXWELL's office and helping organize the office and helping with Christmas
stuff.
would ask EPSTEIN if he wanted to see anyone and at what time he
wanted to see someone. It would be underage girls would schedule to
see EPSTEIN. This happened every time was in Palm Beach.
would schedule either on the plane when they were traveling to Palm Beach or
when they arrived. observed one girl come a day. thought she
was there because EPSTEIN needed three massages a day. EPSTEIN would say
that he needed three orgasms a day; this was something EPSTEIN would say to
whoever was around him. If was not giving EPSTEIN a massage, it would
have been someone else who had to give him one. Being that massaged
EPSTEIN, she understood there to be massages happening in Palm Beach. The
massages were sexual. EPSTEIN would tell "you to do something and you just
did it". did not hear much about anything occurring in New York.
recalled a couple girls' names, including , and
remembered name and her face. recalled it
seemed like there were people who came with similar names.
did not recall having conversations with about massage
appointments. felt that she was so embarrassed by the massage
situation herself that she did not ask questions. thought did
set things up in the massage ro on someone came in, did not know
what happened but did know that or would go up to the room to
prepare.
would ask EPSTEIN who he wanted to see and EPSTEIN would say a
name. would tell EPSTEIN a girl would be available at a certain
time, then ask EPSTEIN if he wanted to see her. did not recall
specific conversations about girls, including and
EPSTEIN attempted to have more than two of them at one time. In Palm
Beach, EPSTEIN offered to use the steam room. set it up.
described as a "free bird" who was comfortable being nude. was
3501.483-004
Page 4 of 12
50D —NY-3027571
c ontinuation or FD.302 or (U) Interview of
in a towel and made it seem ok. At some
tried to make things seem ok. EPSTEIN made it
for her future boyfriend. EPSTEIN told
and said, "That's why a man likes a woman; see
was topless. EPSTEIN was talking about the curve of back.
thought was behind her and touching her.
remember anything else.
to have a threesome.
.On 08/13/2020 .ftv 5 of 12
point, EPSTEIN came up and
seem like he was helping
to touch skin,
how soft the skin is".
froze. did not
was the only one who EPSTEIN tried to get
saw an
.m
assage feet, head, and shoulders.
not recall if she saw MAXWELL massage.
In the Virgin Islands, EPSTEIN had told them to go to sleep.
up to and told her, "Don't tell Ghislaine that I'm sleeping with
Jeffrey; she'll kill me and hate me". did not originally think
was sleeping with EPSTEIN.
"kind of" taught how to massage.
did
came
would rub EPSTEIN's
head. advice was not on sexual matters but rather told not
to burp, fart, curse, or drink around EPSTEIN. There was no alcohol on
EPSTEIN's properties. If someone was in a bad mood, they would get sent
home. could not recall anything specific MAXWELL may have told her.
thought EPSTEIN and MAXWELL's relationship was "more than
friends". MAXWELL gave instruction on things to do to the staff. Both
EPSTEIN and MAXWELL had a "dirty sailor type mouth". recalled MAXWELL
saying something about blowjobs.
assumed that people knew massages were sexual. No one talked about
it, but they knew.
thought was a real masseuse, but later found out
that she was not.
always considered
apartment
apartment.
EPSTEIN. MAXWELL
move in that day.
out. MAXWELL told
lived in a New York
EPSTEIN and MAXWELL put her in this
thought this was around a few months after she met
told that needed to use MAXWELL's driver and
was told that at any time she could be told to move
, "I don't want your shitty furniture in the
3501.483-004
Page5of12
FD•302a (Rev. 5.810)
SOD-NY-3027571
Continuation olTD•302 or (U) Interview of .O F, 08/13/2020 .ruse 6 of 12
apartment". lived in the studio apartment by herself. Other people
that also lived at were who
was MAXWELL's office assistant, and one of the chefs DAVID MULLEN.
stayed on EPSTEIN's payroll until MAXWELL separated from EPSTEIN,
then was on MAXWELL's payroll. thought MAXWELL's boyfriend at
the time, TED WAITT, paid salary. At this time, all of MAXWELL's
assistants had left around December 2007. was the "last man
standing". salary was $20,000 in the beginning. While on EPSTEIN's
payroll, was an errand runner including gathering food for the plane
for trips and getting EPSTEIN whatever he needed. MAXWELL wanted to
pick up clothes. salary was $60,000 when MAXWELL "got rid" of her;
this was around October 2017.
In Palm Beach, did not remember the schedule or times of massages,
as she did not see a lot. Sometimes, was sent out to run an errand or
to go for a run. EPSTEIN always wanted 4 o'clock massages. knew of
other people giving massages but could not recall all of the female names.
heard names of people they would talk about or set up times for them.
remembered seeing a couple younger females. saw them come into
the kitchen and saw them stand there before going upstairs. The females
looked young but did not ask. thought the females were her age
or younger. or would say that someone would be at the house at
a specific time. There were no further conversations about it. did
not tell anyone she met EPSTEIN through a massage. did not want
people to ask questions. They just said that EPSTEIN was getting a massage.
EPSTEIN did not have massage appointments with men. When asked about
EPSTEIN's preferences, said "younger". EPSTEIN teased
about being younger than her. talked about a time where it was
just she and EPSTEIN when he told her the reason he liked younger girls.
EPSTEIN told that up until the age of 23 the brain is still forming so
the brain is moldable. EPSTEIN was very open about this. was
present when EPSTEIN talked about his preferences. EPSTEIN said it all the
time. EPSTEIN joked with because she became older as she wa
years old at the time. EPSTEIN made comments about younger females.
EPSTEIN's favorite book was "Lolita". EPSTEIN made comments about teenage
years, but did not realize that meant girls. MAXWELL and EPSTEIN
would make stuff a joke and they would laugh. could not remember
3501.483-004
Page6of12
II).302.1 (Rev. 5.8.10)
SOD-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD.302 (U) Interview of ,On 08/13/2020 .page 7 of 12
anything specifically. advised if MAXWELL was there and EPSTEIN said
something about younger females, MAXWELL would probably joke back about
EPSTEIN liking younger women.
The first time had a hint that something was wrong was on EPSTEIN's
plane. remembered seeing frantic. They ended up flying
somewhere different than originally planned. thought they were in
Miami but she did not remember specifically. thought EPSTEIN and
started talking about the investigation, but they did not talk in
front of her.
not recall, but
in Palm Beach.
the investigation.
thought
apartment in , so
so scared because she had no idea what was
going to get in trouble for prostitution.
to see her boyfriend. MAXWELL called
tellin her that she needed to come back right then. told MAXWELL
that had told her she could not stay at her New York apartment.
MAXWELL told that she did not care. had flown to New York to
get her visa and yelled at her, saying, "I told you not to
go to New York". was terrified and in Central Park with her
suitcase. thought there were investigators that did not want
her to talk with. found out at some point that the investigation was
about underage girls, but did not recall how she found out.
thought the investigators may have been from the Palm Beach Police
Department, but when thought of investigators, she thought of the
FBI. thought there was someone serving papers at
had told to leave through the back door.
overheard and EPSTEIN on the plane talking about
visited by investigators. Knowing what knows now,
told EPSTEIN that someone was asking questions.
flight back from and went back to MAXWELL's office.
to was not approached by investigators.
di not reca I talking about the investigation.
asked if she met someone, whose name could
was one of the younger females. did not meet people
did not remember EPSTEIN specifically talking about
and EPSTEIN told she needed to go to
told her someone would be serving her papers at her
should not be there to be served. was
going on. thought she was
booked a flight to
, asking where she was, and
EPSTEIN went off on
being
thought
took the next
went back
in approximately 2006. thought EPSTEIN
3501.483-004
Page 7 of 12
FD•302a (Rev. 5.810)
SOD-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD•302 or (U) Interview of .On 08/13/2020 .Paso 8 of 12
was going to beat her or kill her. EPSTEIN's hands were on the door frame
and his knuckles were white with spit coming out of his mouth. EPSTEIN's
face looked like it was going to explode. was in a ball on the floor
when MAXWELL came down and told her to get up. felt safe around
MAXWELL at that time and wanted to work for her.
was at a London restaurant with EPSTEIN when she asked to go to the
bathroom and called her boyfriend. was going to to see her
boyfriend. EPSTEIN thought she disrespected him by calling her boyfriend.
EPSTEIN had asked RON BURKLE to buy him a coke. EPSTEIN then came out and
yelled at
wanted to work for MAXWELL so she still had a job. This was around
December 2007. Sometimes, EPSTEIN still wanted to see her. MAXWELL would
tell that EPSTEIN wanted to see her. This was at least a handful of
times. MAXWELL told "I told him it's ok with me if it's ok with you"
when referring to EPSTEIN seeing . It was ok for to leave the
office while working to go and see EPSTEIN. could not say no.
would see EPSTEIN at his New York residence generally in the massage room.
There was one time where went to the doctor's office with EPSTEIN.
When saw EPSTEIN, it was sexual encounters. did not have
conversations with MAXWELL about what happened when she went to see
EPSTEIN. felt that it was common knowledge that MAXWELL knew.
felt that this was separate from the responsibilities she had for MAXWELL.
EPSTEIN gave cash afterwards, but when
payroll she did not think EPSTEIN gave her cash.
was no longer on his
MAXWELL tried to separate herself from EPSTEIN. Up to that point it was
always EPSTEIN's people and accountants who did things for MAXWELL. Then it
switched to WAITT's people. understood it to be that MAXWELL wanted
to distance herself from EPSTEIN.
MAXWELL would hide it when she saw EPSTEIN. There was one time where
thought MAXWELL was traveling with WAITT but had gone to EPSTEIN's
island instead.
Back when EPSTEIN first went to jail, was kind of relieved.
When EPSTEIN was on work release, MAXWELL told her that help was needed
in the office answering phones. went to Florida and saw EPSTEIN when
3501.483-004
Page 8 of 12
FEO02“Rm.544%
50D-NY-3027571
ConlinualionaFD.302or (U) Interview of .On 08/13/2020 ,page 9 of 12
he was on work release. remembered having to sign in with a plain
clothed sheriff. thought it was or also present, then
said that it would not have been recalled made the
bed. remembered thinking "at that point it was like fuck". Everyone
had left and the sheriff was gone. This happened a couple times. There was
one time when was there and EPSTEIN again tried to get to have a
threesome with them. recalled that the sexual encounters happened at
least twice. recalled a time where folded out the sofa and put
the sheet down. The other time would have been when was there.
went back to New York to work for MAXWELL.
thought EPSTEIN had asked her to go to the movies with him.
EPSTEIN was nice to sometimes. It was like a "teeter totter" with
EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN tried a couple times after he was released to see
The last time saw EPSTEIN was in or around 2012 in the Virgin
Islands when EPSTEIN was hosting a science convention. When EPSTEIN tried
to turn it sexual,
for the rest of the trip. thought it was approximately three days.
EPSTEIN gave
money.
shut down. EPSTEIN stopped and did not talk to her
an iPad on her birthday. EPSTEIN also gave
started on MAXWELL's payroll in approximately
was MAXWELL's assistant. was responsible for MAkrua,k•s casenua and
setting up travel. MAXWELL hung on with EPSTEIN to pay her for as long as
possible before moving  to WAITT's payroll. stayed on MAXWELL's
payroll until around
described that MAXWELL could be charming but also have a two year
old tantrum in a grown adult body. recalled a time drinking wine with
MAXWELL when MAXWELL told her, "When you walk into a room people don't know
you're there", then MAXWELL would go back to talking about herself.
described her relationship with MAXWELL as being a love/hate relationship.
husband would tell her that if she did not like working for MAXWELL
to leave. felt that working for MAXWELL was her only option as she
did not go to school or feel like she had other skills.
Some of responsibilities included keeping track of MAXWELL's
3501.483-004
Page 9 of 12
II).302.1 (Rev. 5.8.10)
SOD-NY -3027571
Continuation of FD•302o1 (U) Interview of .On 08/13/2020 ,prase 10 of 12
calendar, her travels, and helping with interior decorating. When MAXWELL's
houseman left, became responsible for house repairs, including
changing the hot water filters, carrying the ladder, fixing faucets, etc.
MAXWELL had "God awful dogs" that went to the bathroom everywhere so
had to clean up after them. The dogs were show dogs so also had to
manage their schedule.
asked MAXWELL how she made her money and MAXWELL told her from the
stock market. knew MAXWELL's bank accounts and knew that she switched
her accounts and moved money to SCOTT BORGERSON. MAXWELL moved money during
the defamation suit with . MAXWELL said was a
liar. MAXWELL was super stressed and awful to . MAXWELL told
said she had sex with me". thou ht MAXWELL was trying to
fish for information. had never met was served a
subpoena. When she told MAXWELL, MAXWELL got a lawyer. MAXWELL told
she did not remember the stuff about could tell
MAXWELL knew because MAXWELL deflects. could tell from MAXWELL's body
movements and could tell that MAXWELL was feeling threatened.
recalled EPSTEIN saying he sent someone to Thailand, but did not think
EPSTEIN said name when referring to who he sent.
MAXWELL transferred money to BORGERSON's name. There were rental
apartments in Boston. MAXWELL was paying for that year up front.
worked from home and occasionally went to Manchester when MAXWELL and
BORGERSON bought the house there. thought it was MAXWELL's money and
MAXWELL and BORGERSON's house together. MAXWELL was getting new
accountants. MAXWELL and BORGERSON bought an apartment in Boston; had
not been to that apartment.
When asked if knew about MAXWELL being married, responded "it
has to be Scott". MAXWELL spoke about getting married. thought
MAXWELL may have gotten married in Holland or somewhere in that area where
there would be no public record of it. MAXWELL never told did
see in an email where BORGERSON referred to MAXWELL as "Mrs. Borgerson".
WAITT nor EPSTEIN wanted to marry MAXWELL. MAXWELL is a private person and
the media was relentless.
MAXWELL fired
MAXWELL made it clear that she had to be number
3501.483-004
Page 10 of 12
FD.302.1(Rev.5.840)
SOD —NY-3027571
confirm:stimuli:D.302a (U) Interview of .On 08/13/2020  .Paso 11 of 12
one. MAXWELL called and heard the baby crying, telling "shut
that baby up". nd
MAXWELL told her she
was the answer to all of
everything did.
lost a reservation for MAXWELL. When told MAXWELL that it was ok and
worked out, MAXWELL asked "oh you didn't find cheaper". MAXWELL was paying
a lot in legal fees, while also paying for her nephew's school, so was
fired.
MAXWELL sent to BORGERSON with
MAXWELL gave the note to BORGERSON. When
o check her calendar, she saw an email
in which MAXWELL said it
"fuck ups". MAXWELL found blame in
recalled a hotel switched computer systems and
KATIE VON EDWARDS was MAXWELL's London assistant. MAXWELL had VON
EDWARDS call to smooth things over.
When was asked if anyone told her to lie or cover up, she said
"no".
When was not around, IIII would schedule massages for EPSTEIN.
was told that MAXWELL approached both
Beach asking them if they wanted to answer phones.
and min Palm
had to do what EPSTEIN and MAXWELL said because she did not want to
piss them off or get fired.
introduced a roommate she had in New York. brought
who lived in Palm Beach, to meet EPSTEIN. found out online that he
had touched her breasts. also had a friend who was pregnant and
introduced her to EPSTEIN in Boston, but not for a massage.
In or around 2005, was with EPSTEIN and MAXWELL on Zorro Ranch.
They had gone to an outdoor market when MAXWELL lifted skirt
multiple times. MAXWELL was laughing while was mortified and
uncomfortable.
MAXWELL talked about sex all the time. MAXWELL would talk about sex in
general conversations. When was asked if MAXWELL made sexual comments
about EPSTEIN, replied "I'm sure she did".
3501.483-004
Page 11 of 12
F1).3(12.1(Rev.5.84(1)
SOD-NY-3027571
cominaalion"ffD•3o2of (U) Interview of .On 08/13/2020 .Page 12 of 12
asked her friend who had introduced her to EPSTEIN if she would be
willing to speak with law enforcement, and her friend will not talk.
friend was friend and MAXWELL were on
treadmills when MAXWELL said that she should stay in New York.
After was no longer on MAXWELL's payroll, she had to help clear out
a storage unit and sort out accounts. MAXWELL sometimes emailed and
would respond. On Memorial Day in 2020, MAXWELL called saying,
"I'm just calling to tell you I'm alive". MAXWELL was being her charming
self. MAXWELL told she was learning boxing and could "punch a nose on
a bee". MAXWELL asked what she was doing but MAXWELL did not care as
she was just making small talk.
MAXWELL has an AMEX account. MAXWELL used social security number
to add a card to MAXWELL's account. learned of this when she was
trying to open a new utility account in
and she was asked what address she had in Massachusetts. trace it to
a UPS address in Boston. called MAXWELL to confront her. MAXWELL
told that there was something wrong with her credit. told AMEX
that she thought it was her boss. On the card MAXWELL opened was "G
MAXWELL".
While MAXWELL was in Massachusetts, she went by a different name.
"JENNIFER TURNER" was MAXWELL's name of choice. Sometimes MAXWELL used "G
Max". Sometimes MAXWELL would go into a store and give name.
spoke to MAXWELL after EPSTEIN's arrest in 2019 and also after his
death. MAXWELL had called . After EPSTEIN's arrest, MAXWELL told
that she hated EPSTEIN. MAXWELL called and stated, "you wereilliwhen
you met Jeffrey. ..oh well I'm sorry whatever you did". knew MAXWELL
did not mean it because it was just something she said. thought
MAXWELL was running from the media. changed her number because she
was receiving calls nonstop. did not know where MAXWELL was.
3501.483-004
Page 12 of 12
EFTA02731226 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ memo about charging Ghislaine Maxwell with additional offenses
(date: 2021-03-14)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
Prosecution Memorandum
Privileged and Confidential - Attorney Work Product
Do Not Disseminate Outside of the SDNY USAO (or other DOS COMPONENT, as needed)
USAO #: United States v. Maxwell,
S2 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
3/14/2021
I. Overview
This memorandum seeks authorization to charge GHISLAINE MAXWELL with
additional criminal offenses based on her participation in the recruitment, grooming, and abuse of
minor girls with Jeffrey Epstein in a superseding indictment.
Our Office previously obtained a six-count Indictment charging Maxwell with one
count of conspiracy to transport a minor for illegal sexual activity, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371;
one count of transporting a minor, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a); one count of conspiracy to
entice a minor to travel to engage in illegal sexual activity, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371: one
count of enticing a minor to travel, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2422; and two counts of perjury. in
violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1623. The evidence supporting those charges and the legal issues
surrounding those charges were discussed at length in previous prosecution memos dated April
10, 2020 and April 28. 2020. As detailed in those memos, the current charges focus on the
victimization of , all of whom were
sexually abused by Epstein, with assistance from Maxwell, between 1994 and 1997. The perjury
charges arise from false statements Maxwell made during a civil deposition in 2016. which
statements are directly contradicted by the evidence we have gathered regarding-
Since obtaining the original Indictment charging Maxwell, our investigation has
continued, including through the interviews of multiple Epstein victims who previously either
declined to be interviewed or had not previously been identified. The charges we propose
expanding and adding in a superseding indictment against Maxwell are based on the experiences
of one victim in particular named who was sexually abused by Epstein at his
Palm Beach residence from in or about 2001 throu 2005 when was between the ages
of 14 and 18.1 As discussed in greater detail below, was one o e earliest recruits into
S s "pyramid scheme" of paid sexualized massages m Palm Beach. As a result, when
first met Epstein in or about 2001. Maxwell was still directly involved in the scheme to
2021.01.26
Page 2
arrange for minor girls to provide sexualized massages to Epstein. In this vein, recalls
multiple interactions with Maxwell that demonstrate Maxwell's knowledge of a e,
Maxwell's knowledge that the massages were sexual, Maxwell's attempts to entice to
travel with Epstein. and actions in the Southern District of New York in furtherance of the scheme
to sexually abuse
As detailed below, we have identified evidence from documents and at least one
witness that corroborate account.
With the addition of= as "Minor Victim-C to the charges against Maxwell, we
believe that a superseding indictment could contain the following charges:

• Count One: Conspiracy to Transport Minors from 1994 to 2004, in violation of
18 U.S.C. § 371. This charge would expand the end date of the conspiracy from
1997 to 2004 and would add an overt act involving Minor Vicitm-4.

• Count Two: Transportation of a Minor from 1994 to 1997, in violation of 18
U.S.C. § 2423(a). This charge would be identical to Count Two of the original
Indictment.

• Count Three: Conspiracy to Entice Minors from 1994 to 2004, in violation of
18 U.S.C. § 371. This charge would expand the end date of the conspiracy from
1997 to 2004 and add an overt act involving Minor Vicitm-4.

• Count Four: Enticement of a Minor from 1994 to 1997, in violation of 18 U.S.C.
§ 2422. This charge would be identical to Count Four of the original
Indictment.

• Count Five: Conspiracy to Commit Sex Trafficking from 2001 to 2004, in
violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371. This charge would be entirely new and would
exclusively reference Minor Vicitm-4.

• Count Six: Sex Trafficking of a Minor from 2001 to 2004, in violation of 18
U.S.C. § 1591. This charge would be entirely new and would exclusively
reference Minor Victim-4.
• Counts Seven & Eight: Perjury, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1623. These charges
would be identical to Counts Five and Six, respectively, in the original
Indictment.
2021.01.26
Page 3

A. 's Anticipated Testimony
Our team first attem . ted to interview during our initial investigation in March of 2019.
At that time, however, was not willing
I.
to be interviewed. In or about July 2020, after
Maxwell was arrested on e original Indictment, attorney contacted our team and
indicated that was re ared to be interview
Base on a o t ese interviews, we expect t at
below.
was born on
amil moved to
In or about 2001.
wo testi at tna to t i e m ormation
and grew up in
a t 17 years o at e time. e our teenagers —
would sometimes hang out to ether and smoke marijuana. One time w ou was smo g
together, asked if she wanted to make some fast money. said she was
intereste an arrang to take to Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beac residence.
In 1999,
met
was
The first time traveled to Epstein's Palm Beach residence, she went with who
drove there. When ey arrived at Epstein's residence.
kitchen door, where they were greeted by Maxwell. oes not rec owing Maxwell's
first name and only referred to her as "Maxwell." mils entered the kitchen, Maxwell
greeted by name and introduced herself to who told Maxwell her name.
2
went t    side
3 As discussed below, we have interviewed who corroborates much ox account.
4 Our team has interviewed both
of how she was introduced to Epstein but recalled little about Maxwell in partic ar. also
told us that Epstein expressed a preference for females who were at least 18 years o . We ve
disclosed the 302 containing that statement from interview to Maxwell's counsel.
corroborated account
2021.01.26
Page 4
Maxwell then told in substance, to show what to do. then took
upstairs through Epstein's m to his bathroom,  there was a c oset with a massage to e
inside. Once in the massage room, showed where the lotions and vibrators were
kept in drawers. recalled seeing p otographs o nu e females on the walls of the massage
room, including nu e p otogra hs of Maxwell. Epstein then came into the massage room and got *
onto the massage table. After and massaged Epstein together for a bit, Epstein
in rolled over, and
front o pstem did not touch
got on top o hinsstem then had sexual intercourse with
during this first massage.
After that first visit, memories of her interactions with Epstein largely run together
because there were so many visits over the course of multiple years between 2001 and 2005.
eli re began gout by herself. At some point during either the first or second visit to
recalled that may have gone to Epstein's residence one or two more times with
Epstein's, someone asked for number, and she provided it. From then on,
would schedule appointments to see pstein directly and no longer through er .
primarily went to Epstein's residence by herself, though occasionall would drive
er, or she would bring a young female friend, as discussed below. that
met E stem once in the driveway outside of Epstein's residence. After y met, Epstein s ow
and the cars in his arage. Otherwise, did not meet anyone else who
worked for Epstein. told that she was giving massages to Epstein, but she did not
tell him the details o w at appen during the massages.
In total, estimates that she provided more than 100 sexualized massages to Epstein
between the ages o 14 and 18. For the majority of these massages, and Epstein were
alone in the massage room together. On those instances, would egin by massaging
Epstein. At some point during the massage, Epstein would roll over and be masturbating
himself. Epstein would then direct to touch his ni les and would touch breasts
and buttocks. On two or three occasions, Epstein touched vagina, but s e to Epstein
she was not comfortable with him touching her there, and e stopped. On one occasion, Epstein
attempted touch vagina with a vibrator, but pulled away, so he stopped. Every
massage ended wit Epstein ejaculating.
%Earlier on when was first going to Epstein's house, she would keep her underwear on,
but after a few times, would routinely massage Epstein while filly nude. Before each
massage,.. won go upstairs to the massage room, set up the massage table, et out oil or
lotion, an y undress before Epstein came into the room. After each massage, would
was paid $300 in one-hundred dollar s a er each get dressed quickly and leave.
massage. Usually the money was ai out on the table or by the sink in the bathroom. Toward the
beginning of her time massaging Epstein, Maxwell paid after a few of the massages.
To schedule massage appointments, would either receive calls or would call Epstein's
residence. The calls received wo come to cellphone, her mother's cellphone,
her house phone, or phone. indicated that if her mother answered, the caller
would just ask for and her mother would not ask who was calling or otherwise talk with
2021.01.26
Page 5
the caller.5 When would answer one of these calls, he would hand the phone to
and tell her that it was regarding Epstein. recalls giving both Maxwell an
additional numbers they could use to call her. S e remembered one time when Maxwell sat e
and Epstein were going out of town and asked if there were any other numbers they could use to
contact In response, gave Maxwell one of her mother's numbers.
recalls that for approximately the first several months of going to Epstein's residence,
Maxwe would call to schedule appointments for to massage Epstein. During these calls,
Maxwell would ask whether would be available at a particular time. During a couple of
these calls, Maxwell stated that e was calling from New York and that Epstein would be back in
Florida on a particular day. Maxwell would say that she and Epstein would be leaving New York
and arriving in Florida on a articular day and would ask if should be available after they
arrived. During these calls, remembers Maxwell ca ing om a phone number with a New
York area code. At other times. Maxwell called from Palm Beach. When Maxwell
scheduled for an appointment. she would as or address so that a car could
pick up. At the time, was 14 or 15 years o • an d not have a license.
Earlier on in her time oin to Epstein's residence, recalls that Maxwell would engage *
her in conversation when would first arrive at t e ouse before going up to the massage
room. For example, Maxwe would ask questions about her family and her life. During
those conversations, told Maxwe tat er parents were separated, that her parents would
fight, and that her parents used drugs. also told Maxwell she had been raped in the past.
Once. Maxwell asked for bra an '15 size, after which received Victoria's
Secret lingerie, as detailed ow. another occasion, Maxwell as e if she had ever
used sex toys on herself or had masturbated. During this same conversation. Maxwell also asked
if she was sexually active. told Maxwell she had a boyfriend and was sexually
active with him but had never used any sort of sex toy. Maxwell laughed and joked during the
conversation. recalls that the massage immediately after that conversation was the
massage when Epstein placed a vibrator on her vagina.
During at least one of these conversations. Maxwell asked if, would be able to travel
with Maxwell and Epstein. told Maxwell that she woul ove to travel but she was only
14 years old, and her mother would not allow her to travel. Later when was in the massage
room with Epstein, he also asked if he could get her a passport so e could travel with
him and Maxwell. Epstein told
to a massage school in Thailan . He ask
5
2021.01.26
had traveled with him and that he sent
wanted go on any trips with him, too.
Page 6
responded that she was 14 years old and her mother would not allow her to travel.
reca s additional conversations when Epstein and/or Maxwell would again bring up nat.
suggesting the travel could be for massage school. Ultimately, never traveled with them,
and they eventually stopped asking her to travel.
recalled that approximate) one to three times. Maxwell saw fully nude in the
massage room. This happened when had already undressed in preparation for the massage
but before Epstein had come into the room. One particular instance stands out in mind.
had set up the masse e table and was fully nude, when Maxwell walked into e massage
room. Maxwell told that she had nice breasts and asked if her breasts were real. When
responded yes, Maxwell touched breasts and told her she had a nice body.
was not uncomfortable because Maxwe was a woman. Maxwell then left the room.
A few weeks after began massaging Epstein, she met A few months
after she met began receiving calls primarily from an' no lo er form
Maxwell, to sc. massage appointments. During those calls, would ask if she
would be available at a particular time. only recalls ca mg her from P Beach.
Other assistants would also sometimes c to sched e appointments or would answer the
phone when called to ask if she co massage Epstein, but does not recall their
names. When went to appointments that had schedul . s e would still sometimes
see Maxwell aroun the house, who would sometimes say hello to her, but she did not really
interact with Maxwell much anymore.
When was about 15 years old, called and said that Epstein would like
u . When
to take photos o
at
• g her swimsuit and sent a car to pick
arriv at e house, told her to undress and took nude photos o
and I.1 en aced in conversations, during which101
During t e photoshoot, which too p ace inside a bedroom and bathroom in the house.
en o the p otos oot, paid $500.6
mentioned her age. At the
In addition to cash payments for each massage, loll recalled receiving multiple gifts from
Epstein. received multiple s of lingerie orm Victoria's Secret, which were shipped to
her home by either UPS or FedEx.
had a New York address.? She also reca
recalls seeing that the return address for these packages
s that the packages either had Epstein's or Maxwell's
name on the return address. At least once, Maxwell called to tell her to be on the lookout
fora package the Epstein was sending her, and a short time ater received a package.
also received flower deliveries from Epstein to her house. On one occasion Epstein
provided with a "Massage for Dummies" book because he had discussed wanting to pay
for to attend massage school. later provided the book to the FBI when she was
rrn6 The FBI is still reviewing the thousands of photographs seized during searches of Epstein's
residences to see whether any of these photographs o are among those recovered during
our investigation. To date, our team has not identified any photographs of among those
seized.
7 As discussed below, we have identified one FedEx invoice from 2002 reflecting a package sent
from Epstein's business address in Manhattan to home address in
2021.01.26
Page 7
first interviewed in or about 2007.° Epstein also provided with tickets to see the band
Incubus.
At some point Epstein asked if she had any young friends she could bring. Maxwell
also asked if she could bring any younger girls. ended up bringing multiple girls
to massa e E stem. Althou she cannot remember everyone she brought, recalls
bringin 9 1° and .11 among others. These s were all
around age—some were a it older, ut was younger than When she
brought gir s to massage Epstein, both the girl and would be paid $300. recalls
being present for sexualized massages with some o ese girls and Epstein, but not
At various points between 2001 and 2004. Min provided sexualized massages to Epstein
with another female in the room. In addition to mg present in the room with friends
brought, there were two occasions when Epstein brought another female into the massage room
himself. During one of those massages. Epstein brought in a young model, who performed oral
sex on while Epstein had sexual intercourse with the model. During the other massage,
Epsteinbrought a second oun model into the room. On that occasion, Epstein attempted to have
sexual intercourse with and although he briefly penetrated her va vith his penis,
told him to stop. In response, Epstein stopped trying to have sex with and instead
had sex with the other girl.
On two occasions, In was asked to massage men other than Epstein at Epstein's Palm
Beach residence. First. pstem told
the friend instead of Epstein. ten massaged the man in her underwear, ut t ere was no
sexual contact or activity during t massage. Second. Maxwell told that E stein had to
leave and he had a friend stayin at the house, who could massage. described
the man as chunky and bald.12 wore Victoria's Secret lingerie to prow e im with a
massage. During the massage, e man said he would pay her extra money if she did more with
he had a friend in town and asked to massage
As discussed below, the FBI still has this book in its custody, and the 302 from 2007
interview with the FBI notes that she provided the book to the FBI at that time.
9 As discussed in ow December 19. 2019 memorandum, our team has interviewed
Although she confirmed that first brought her to Epstein's residence, she does not recall
ever interacting with Maxwe
10- declined to be interviewed by our team. When the FBI approached her in 2007,
she staff  "good a "good friend" of hers had introduced her to Epstein. insisted in 2007 that
Epstein had not engaged in any sex acts in with her, but she said she eyed the "friend" had
engaged in "more."
11- is now deceased.
12 attorneys informed us that they showed her a photograph of Harvey Weinstein, and
she r ent ed him as the chunky. bald man involved in this incident.
2021.01.26
Page 8
him. agreed, and had sexual intercourse with the man during the massage. The man then
paid approximately $600 or 5700.13 never saw him again.
school ailinever attended high school. told both Epstein and Maxwell that she was no
was able to make so much money from Epstein that she decided to drop out of middle
longer in school and could come over at any time. As continued to provide sexualized
massages to Epstein, she and would use the mone s e made primarily to purchase chugs,
including marijuana and cocaine. encouraged to continue going to Epstein's
house, and as she continued using gs, became a cted to cocaine. As a result, when
was out of money and needed dru s, s e would call to ask if she could massage Epstein
so that she could get more money. explained that she used drugs in part to help numb the
pain of what happened during massages with Epstein. She felt degraded and humiliated by her
experiences with Epstein, but she also felt happy to receive so much money.
to grilse.. massages to Epstein t oin i le first ew months of her pregnancy. Once
In . became pregnant with child. continued to use drugs and
was visibly pregnant, however, she stopped providing Epstein with massages and instead
brought friends to massage Epstein.
gave birth to when she was . For several months after the delivery,
not see E stem. At various point . when needed money.
s e would reach out to to ask to massage pstem. As a result, continued to provide
paid sexualized massages to Epstein when she was 17 years old in also did so on at least nu
some occasions ' when she was 18 years old. As described below, throughout this  id
was addict to drugs and sought to massage Epstein in order to buy drugs to use.
e t uncomfortable going to Epstein's after she turned 17 because she felt too old. rims
repeatedly asked to bring other, younger girls, and she got the impression that she had aged out of
massaging Epstein. As a result, ultimately stopped reaching out to schedule appointments
to massage Epstein, and she stop receiving calls from his staff.
B. Corroborating Evidence
We have interviewed
years older than Mreca e that in approximate 2001 or 2002 wheil.vas hanging out
with and one day, suggested could make $200 by
E who corroborated account. 14 who is three
13 explained that Epstein never offered her extra money, which is why she never agreed
to engage in sexual intercourse with him.
14 still has some contact with because , but they have not
been romantically together for years, an eir relationship is very strained. As a result.
and rarely communicate directly with each other unless necessary to discuss
Most of ir communications are mediated by
has a criminal histo and was recently re ease mom on, ut e current as a o
and appears to be stable.
2021.01.26
Page 9
massaging an old
recalled that
M:greed, and .11 brought.. do Epstein's house.
was about 15 years o when she
■
r t went to Epstein's.
subsequently went with to Epstein's house on multiple occasions so she could massage
him. i= recalled taking taxis to and from Epstein's home. He also received phone
calls om people who worked for Epstein, including a woman named MI asking to schedule
appointments with At times, heard on the phone that Epstein was not in town but
met Epstein once in Epstein's driveway, and MM recalls was comin on a certain
that MI brought several en to massage Epstein as well. mention meeting and
interacting with someone named Maxwell at Epstein's house. He eyed Maxwell was supposed
than just massage going on. massages, ut e suspected there was likely someWre
to tell what to do during the massages. did not tell she did duiiii.e
encouraged to go to Epstein's house because she made so much money there, whitTh7
Rwould use to uy gs. When
It u
turned 16, Epstein bou t her Incubus tickets.
also recalled that Epstein had sent lingerie from Paris. recalled saying
she was asked to bring other girls, witnessed nngng other gir s to E stein's
house to provide massages, including gir named 15
that Elear-old could not go back because she was too old. eves
recalled that was toonce brought another girl who was 1 years o
stop providing massages to Epstein after she gave birth to their son w en s e was.
and broke up when was less than one year old.
Photographs from Epstein's Palm Beach residence taken during the Palm Beach Police
Department's 2005 search of the residence confirm description of the residence,
including the massage room. Message pads seized during t at same search contain nine entries
from between 2003 and 2005 with name and phone number, confirming that
went to Epstein's Palm Beach residence urmg that time. Those message pads are limits to
2003 to 2005 time period because those were the only pads in the house when the search was
conducted in October 2005.
We have identified one FedEx invoice dated . which was obtained during the
Florida investigation, for a package that was address to residence in Palm Beach. The
return address is a business address for Epstein in Manhattan. e FBI has confirmed that FedEx
no longer has records dating back to 2001-2005, so we are unable to obtain additional FedEx
records.
15 The FBI has identified this individual as
recruited
_Our team interviewed by WebEx on February 24, 2021. Durin
confirmed that recruited her to massage Epstein when
mo d, and I. specifically recalled that Maxwell paid both and
first visit to t e residence. impression based on the conversation she witnessed
was  already knew We were unable to fully debrief.. during that first
interview, and we have repeat y attempted to schedule follow-up interviews, but is
difficult to contact. The FBI plans to travel to w ere
and attempt to connect with her in person.
2021.01.26
that interview.
was about 13
on
Page 10
Phone records from 2004 confirm that
least two occasions during that period.16
was in communication with on at
The FBI still has the "Massage for Dummies" book that provided in 2007 in its
custody.
Juan Alessi. who worked for E stein as detailed in the prior prosecution memo, confirms that
Maxwell recruited from her job in Mar-a-Lago to massage Epstein. Flight
records confirm traveled with Epstein and Maxwell in when was
17 years old.
Finally, the testimony o would be admissible to prove Maxwell's
knowledge and intent when interacting wit
C. Impeachment Material
1. Past Statements
Illiwas first interviewed by the FBI on August 13, 2007. During that interview,
desert ing introduced to Epstein by massaging Epstein approximately 100 times,
telling Epstein her age, Epstein inviting her on trips, bringing friends to massage Epstein.
calling her to schedule massages, receiving gifts, being paid $500 for to photograph her
nude, and providing sexualized massages with at least one other female m t e room. She did not,
however, mention Maxwell at all. She was not interviewed by the FBI again until we interviewed
her in 2020.
sued E tern and was deposed as part of that lawsuit on During
that eposition, testified that Maxwell and  were the two people she remembered
calling her to schedule appointments with Epstein. was not asked any follow-up questions
about Maxwell during the deposition. Later that same month. Epstein settled the civil suit with 17
16 We have subpoenaed additional phone records from the 2001 to 2005 period and are awaiting
their production.
17 attorney has indicated that he is willing to provide us with the settlement agreement,
but he believes he requires a subpoena in order to produce it to us. Accordingly, we intend to seek
authorization to serve the attorney with a "friendly" subpoena for the 2009 settlement agreement
between and Epstein.
2021.01.26
EFI'A_00023129
Page 11
during her civil deposition, =I was asked about a period when she worked for
an escort service when she was about 18 years o . insisted during her deposition that she
only went on dates and did not engage in sex acts wit any clients during her time at the escort
service. During our in-person interviews, thou admitted that she had engaged in paid
sex acts during her time at the escort service. exp ained that she was ashamed of working
as a prostitute and she did not want to admit todoing so in a room full of hostile men during her
deposition. She understands that she will need to admit to lying under oath during her deposition
if she testifies at trial in our case.
When asked why she did not mention any details about Maxwell until her 2020 interviews with
the FBI, explained that no one ever asked her about Maxwell during either the first FBI
interview or er deposition. She further explained that she did not think Maxwell was important.
The focus was on Epstein, and she mentioned primarily because she paid her $500 to take
nude photos of her, which thought was important. also explained that since she
first spoke with our team in 2 20. she has spent time thinkin a ut er interactions with Maxwell mi
and trying to remember more details about Maxwell. also emphasized that she has nothing
to gain from making anything up about Maxwell. S e is not suing Maxwell, has already settled a
lawsuit with Epstein, and is participating in the Victim's Compensation Fund run by Epstein's
estate. She has no desire to speak to the press. In short, she has no incentive to make something
up about Maxwell just so she can testify in our case.
When asked whill would still want to testify as part of our case, became
emotional. She explain t she wanted to get justice not just for what was done to er, which
was very wrong. but for everyone else who was hurt by Epstein's scheme. She also explained that
she feels obligated as a mother of daughters to stand up against predators and to help inspire other
victims to stand up for themselves.
does not follow the news, and she told us that she intentionally avoids any
media regarding Epstein because she feels ill when she sees anything relating to him. As a result,
was genuinely concerned for years that was dead because she never
and her husband ed to watch the Mocumentary series about Epstein. became
ear m after she left for earn atd was alive when she
physically ill and could not watch the documentary, but her husband watched it and told her that
was alive. Otherwise, has not seen any media reporting regarding Epstein or
Maxwell. As discussed further a ow, is now married and lives with her husband and

2. Effects of Severe Trauma
enced si  ficant trauma in her youth. which resulted in
. As reference
2021.01.26
Page 12
As a result of that instability, ended up in situations that left her vulnerable to
additional abuse on multiple occasions w en she was about 13 years old.
The cumulative effect of all this trauma left extremely vulnerable when she met
Epstein and helps explain how she was such an ea target for him. The com unded trauma of
bein sexually abused by E stein for years led to become
e combination o
aro me to ave a c °tic em e ears after she sto seem E tem.
18
2021.01.26
Page 13
In the ears sinc
She has very little contact with
life has stabilized.
and some contact with her
or examp e, t regar' gw o t too. ' 'wn er p i one
num r, exact y w age s e told Maxwell she was (in one interview said., but later
she said.), and the circumstances surrounding her massaging other men van between the video
interviews and the in-person interviews.
She remembered
seem a oto o Maxwe • re ant.
so stat 'at 'e 'e ev
Epstein a • cameras in is c oc an • t at tie FBI was survet mg Epstein's residence from across
the street. She clarified that she did not have confirmation of those facts, but she nevertheless
believed them to be true.
was epos or approximate y et t ours in er civt suit, an se
2021.01.26
Page 14
In. Epstein sett just a ew ys a er er eposinon, an tie e en tats e
criminal trial was convicted.
II. Proposed Charge, Elements of the Offense, and Venue
In light of the evidence regarding 's experiences with Epstein and
Maxwell, our Office. could seek a superseding in ictment charging Maxwell with the following
offenses, referring to as "Minor Victim-4":

• Count One: Conspiracy to Transport Minors from 1994 to 2004, in violation of
18 U.S.C. § 371. This charge would expand the end date of the conspiracy from
1997 to 2004 and would add an overt act involving Minor Vicitm-4.

• Count Two: Transportation of a Minor from 1994 to 1997, in violation of 18
U.S.C. § 2423(a). This charge would be identical to Count Two of the original
Indictment. Because this charge remains unchanged, we do not further discuss
it in this memorandum.

• Count Three: Conspiracy to Entice Minors from 1994 to 2004, in violation of
18 U.S.C. § 371. This charge would expand the end date of the conspiracy from
1997 to 2004 and add an overt act involving Minor Vicitm-4.

• Count Four: Enticement of a Minor from 1994 to 1997. in violation of 18 U. S.C.
§ 2422. This charge would be identical to Count Four of the original
Indictment. Because this charge remains unchanged, we do not further discuss
it in this memorandum.

• Count Five: Conspiracy to Commit Sex Trafficking from 2001 to 2004, in
violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371. This charge would be entirely new and would
exclusively reference Minor Vicitm-4.
19
2021.01.26
Page 15

• Count Six: Sex Trafficking of a Minor from 2001 to 2004, in violation of 18
U.S.C. § 1591. This charge would be entirely new and would exclusively
reference Minor Victim-4.
• Counts Seven & Eight: Perjury, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1623. These charges
would be identical to Counts Five and Six, respectively, in the original
Indictment. Because these charges remain unchanged, we do not further discuss
them in this memorandum.
Below we analyze the law and the evidence that would support the expansions of the
conspiracies charged in Counts One and Three, as well as the addition of sex trafficking offenses
in Counts Five and Six.
A. Expansion of Counts One and Three: Conspiracies to Transport and Entice Minors
From 1994 to 2004
Counts One and Three would both charge Maxwell with participating in a conspiracy, in
violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371, with the objects to commit 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a), which prohibits the
transportation of minors with intent to commit an illegal sex act, and 18 U.S.C. § 2422, which
prohibits the enticement of minors to travel with intent to commit an illegal sex act, respectively.
The conspiracy charge requires (1) an agreement to violate 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a) or 18 U.S.C.
§ 2422: (2) which agreement Maxwell knowingly and willfully joined: and (3) at least one overt
act in furtherance of the conspiracy. The elements of these crimes are discussed in detail in our
April 10, 2020 prosecution memorandum. We would propose expanding the conspiracy alsad
charged in Counts One and Three to continue through 2004, which is the last year when
went to Epstein's home as a minor. testimony would establish that Maxwell agreed
wit  to commit each element o t 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a) and 18 U.S.C. § 2422 as to
First._ will test' that both Maxwell and E stein invited her to travel across state lines.
The reference to getting a passport and to similar trips during these
conversations support the erence that these trips wo ve involved transporting
across state lines. account of these conversations is corroborated both by flight recd
demonstrating that did indeed travel across state lines with Epstein and Maxwell, and by
prior consistent statement to the FBI in 2007 that Epstein invited her to travel with him.
Second. will testify that she told both Maxwell and Epstein that she was under the age
of 18 during t e same conversations when they invited her to travel. account on this
point is corroborated by recollection that first met Epstein w en she was about
15 years old.
Third, the testimony of both and multiple other victims would demonstrate that
Maxwell's intent when inviting to travel was that she engage in one or more illegal sex
acts with Epstein. testimony that Maxwell saw her nude in the massage room, touched
her breasts, and discuss sexual topics with Maxwell all demonstrate Maxwell's knowled e that
saw E stein for the purpose of engaging in sex acts with him. Testimony from
regarding Maxwell's encouragement of and participation in sex acts involving
2021.01.26
Page 16
minors and Epstein Anther demonstrates that her intent when inviting to travel was that
she would engage in sex acts with Epstein.
Fourth, the contemplated sexual activity, was unlawful. Both Epstein and Maxwell touched
breasts, and Epstein touched buttocks and vagina, among other sex acts. All
o at activity would have violated New Yor Penal Code § 130.05(3). Altho does
not recall Epstein or Maxwell expressly stating that they intended to transport to New
York, a jury could reasonably infer from their frequent travel to and from New Yo as well as
their communications with from New York. that they would have taken to New
York had she agreed to be transported.
Fifth. venue is proper in the Southern District of New York as to because both
Maxwell and Epstein took steps in furtherance of the irac while in Man. In order to
build rapport with and mom her, Epstein sent gifts from New York to Florida.
The FedEx receipt form 2002 corroborates testimony that Epstein would send those gifts
from Manhattan. Additionally, test that Maxwell stated on at least some occasions
that she and Epstein were in New York when Maxwell would call to schedule a massage
appointment with
Finally, the similarities between Maxwell and Epstein's interactions with and those
with the other three victims support the conclusion that all were part of Me ongoing
conspiracy. With all four victims, Maxwell engaged in the same grooming behavior, which
involved asking the girls questions about their personal lives and families, as well as bringing up
sexual topics. Maxwell's presence as an adult woman helped all four victims feel more at ease
and normalized Epstein's abusive behavior. Epstein and Maxwell invited all four victims to travel
and suggested to three of the victims =I that Epstein could help pay
for educational opportunities. Accordingly. a jury could reasons y conclude that Maxwell and
Epstein's conspiracy to transport minors continued through the period when they interacted with
2021.01.26
Page 17

B. Counts Five and Six: Conspiracy to Commit Sex Trafficking and Sex Trafficking
from 2001 to 2004
Count Five would charge Maxwell with conspiracy, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 37120
with the object to violation 18 U.S.C. § 1591, which prohibits sex trafficking of minors. Count
Six would charge Maxwell with sex trafficking. in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 1591 and 2.21
Sex trafficking has the following elements:

1. Maxwell, or someone she aided and abetted, knowingly recruited, enticed,
harbored, transported, provided, or obtained by any means a victim;

2. In or affecting interstate or foreign commerce:
3. Knowing that the victim had not yet attained the age of 18:
4. Knowing that the victim will be caused to engage in a commercial sex act; and
5. Venue is proper in the Southern District of New York.
Regarding the first element, which requires that the defendant knowingly "recruited. enticed.
transported, provided, or obtained by any means a person," that language—which focuses on the
supply rather than demand side of sex trafficking—reflects the statute as it existed between
enactment in October 2000 through certain revisions established in May 2015.22
In ar, and in addition to Epstein's own conduct, he also
y instructs of ers including a  to recruit, entice, and solicit additional minor victims.
zo
21
22
2021.01.26
Page 18
The third and fourth elements require that the defendant knew the fact that (i) an underage
minor (ii) would be caused to engage in a commercial sex act.23 With respect to the former, we
will need to prove that Maxwell knew that was under the age of 18. Specifically, the
model jury instruction for pre-2008 conduct or t is element is: "The second element [. . .] is that
the defendant knew that the victim was under the age of 18." Sand et al., Modem Federal Jury
Instructions, Criminal Instruction 47A-20. This element can be proved through circumstantial and
inferential evidence. including through proof of conscious avoidance. See, e.g., United States v.
Paris. No. 06 Cr. 064. 2007 WL 3124724, at '9 (D. Conn. Oct. 24. 2007) (Droney, J.) (following
a sex trafficking conviction, rejecting a Rule 29 argument on sufficiency grounds relating to
knowledge of age of the victim, and upholding a conscious avoidance jury instruction on the issue,
because the defendant "had sex with her and saw her naked body [.. .] when she was 14 years old
[. . .] bought cigarettes for [her], knew that [she] had young friends who were still in high school,
and never asked er for her identification"). Here, in addition to the direct evidence of knowledge
of age from testimony about at least one conversation with Maxwell regarding her age,
F.the evidence supporting conscious avoidance would be strong, including the fact that Maxwell had
to order taxis for because she did not have a li cense and the fact that Maxwell saw
fully nude when s e was only 14 or 15 years old.
With respect to the fourth element, i.e., the knowledge that the victim would engage in a
"commercial" sex act, Section 1591(c)(1), as passed in 2000, 24 defines the "commercial"
component of this element as "any sex act on account of which anything of value is given to or
received by any person." Here, the was paid hundreds of dollars, including by Maxwell
herself on some occasions, satisfying the "commercial" aspect of this prong.
U
23
24 Currently the relevant provision, with identical language, is under Section 1591(eX3).
2021.01.26
Page 19
2021.01.26
Page 20
Here, will testify that E stein touched her enitals,
and that he also penetrated her vagina
with ms on one occasion. As iscusse a ove m t e context of Counts One and Three,
testimony regarding instances when Maxwell saw her nude in the massage room, the
ent when Maxwell touched breast, and the conversation when Maxwell brought up
testimony of further confirmed by t be e  and
owledge that I would en, sex acts with
Epstein. That knowledge would
sexual topics all demonstrate Maxwe s
who both recall Maxwell knowing that Epstein engaged in sex acts with them in the context o
massages.
With respect to the second element, the statute r
interstate commerce,"
2021.01.26
uires that the conduct be "in or affectin
25
Page 21
Our evidence of the interstate commerce element here would include testimony
regarding phone calls she received from New York while in Florida to arran e massages, as well
as Victoria's Secret lingerie that Epstein sent from New York to home in Florida.
Additionally, the labels on the massage table and sex toys recov m Epstein's Palm Beach
residence during the October 2005 search indicate that those products were manufactured outside
of the state of Florida.
Finally, we would propose to establish venue through the same evidence referenced in our
discussion of Counts One and Three. Conspiracy charges may be brought "in any district in which
an overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy was committed." United States v. Lange, 834 F.3d
58, 68 (2d Cir. 2016). Here, the calls from New York to schedule appointments and the packages
2021.01.26
Page 22
containing gifts sent from New York, as corroborated by a FedEx invoice, establish by a
preponderance of the evidence that Maxwell and Epstein each took at least one act in furtherance
of the conspiracy to traffic while in the Southern District of New York.
As to substantive sex trafficking offenses, the Second Circuit recently affirmed an SDNY sex
trafficking conviction under 18 U.S.C. § 1591 where the minor victim testified that she was in
SDNY when the defendant first contacted her over Facebook and encouraged her to travel to meet
him in Queens. See United States v. Walsh, 827 F. App'x 30, 33 (2d Cir. 2020). The remaining
conduct, including in-person grooming and all commercial sex acts, then took place in EDNY. Id.
The panel concluded that "this evidence was sufficient for a reasonable jury to find by a
preponderance of the evidence that [the defendantl recruited or enticed the minor, while she
resided in the Southern District of New York. to engage in prostitution and that venue was
therefore proper for both counts of conviction." Id. Here, because both the phone calls to
and the packages containing gifts were a fundamental part of recruiting and enticing to
continue to engage in commercial sex acts with Epstein. when Epstein and Maxwell came out
those acts from the Southern District of New York, they were part of the "conduct constituting the
offense" of sex trafficking. United States v. Davis, 689 F.3d 179. 185 (2d Cir. 2012): see also
United States v. Ramirec, 420 F.3d 134, 138 (2d Cir. 2005) ("Venue is proper only where the acts
constituting the offense — the crime's 'essential conduct elements' — took place."). Accordingly,
testimony, corroborated by the FedEx record, establish that venue for the substantive
sex Ira cking count is proper in the Southern District of New York.

M. Anticipated Defenses,
A. Factual Defenses
2021.01.26
Page 23
B. Legal Defenses
2021.01.26
Page 24
■
2021.01.26
Page 25

IV. Cooperation Defendants and/or Immunized 'Witnesses
In presenting this case at trial, we anticipate presenting the testimony of no cooperating
defendant(s).
In presenting this case at trial, we anticipate presenting the testimony of no witness(es),
who would testify under a grant of immunity.
V. Discovery & Disclosure Plan
The following law enforcement agencies are part of the prosecution team: FBI C-20,
NYPD, USAO-SDNY. I have completed an agency file review for each of those agencies.
2021.01.26
Page 26
In addition, consistent with a letter filed with the Court on October 7, 2020, our office
has obtained and reviewed for Rule 16 material agency files from the FBI's Miami Field Office,
the Palm Beach Police Department, and the Palm Beach State's Attorney's Office.
Also consistent with the October 7, 2020 letter, we have taken the following steps to
obtain additional agency files to review for Brady, Giglio, and Jencks Act material. First, we have
confirmed with the U.S. Attorney's Office in Georgia that it does not possess any substantive
witness statements or any material regarding Ghislaine Maxwell. Second, we have obtained all
emails from the lead AUSA who handled the USAO-SDFL investigation of Epstein, and have run
keyword search terms through those emails to identify correspondence potentially relevant to our
case. We are in the process of reviewing that subset of emails. Third, we are still in the process
of loading scans of the full USAO-SDFL file into Relativity so that our team can conduct a full
review of that file. Due to technical issues with the vendor who scanned the files in Florida and
the vendor who handles loading the files into Relativity, this process remains ongoing.
We have also reviewed with the following members of the prosecution team — FBI
Special Agent and FBI TFO/NYPD Detective — the guidance under
JM 9-5.004 reg ing e-communications in a federal criminal case. n particular, the following is
our plan to preserve for later review and possible disclosure all substantive e-communications
created or received by team members during the course of an investigation and prosecution, and
all e-communications sent to or received from lay witnesses, regardless of content: all AUSAs
have made it their practice to save all emails related to this case in a separate folder within Outlook.
has saved all emails related to this case from his inbox on the share drive.
AU As wi review t eir own emails and will divide up the review of emails
for any disclosures that need to be made in advance of trial. Although it is not the team's practice
to exchange substantive text communications regarding any case or to exchange any text messages
at all with lay witnesses, all AUSAs will review their own text messages on their government-
provided cellphones to confirm no such text messages exist or need to be disclosed. The AUSAs
will confer with SA and TFO and confirm that they have similarly preserved and
reviewed all of their emails and text messages for any disclosures that need to be made. The
AUSAs will also confirm that SA and TFO M . have similarly collected and reviewed
and made any necessary disclosuresfrom any e-communications made or received by any other
FBI or NYPD employee, including victim-witness personnel, regarding this case or from any lay
witness.
This case is not a spin-off from, or a case with significant factual overlap with, another
SDNY case.
As discussed above, parts of this case were the subject of an investigation by the
USAO-SDFL and the Palm Beach State's Attorney's Office. We have reviewed the PBSA file for
disclosures and will similarly review the USAO-SDFL file once it is loaded into Relativity.
This case is not being conducted in coordination with another prosecutor's office or
another federal or state agency.
2021.01.26
Page 27
I am familiar with the SDNY Discovery and Disclosure Policy, and, as discussed
above, I have completed my review of the USAO-SDNY files, the FBI files, the PBPD files, and
the PBSA files for compliance with our Rule 16 and Brady obligations, including materials
relevant to any anticipated defenses. The review of AUSA emails from the USAO-SDFL and the
USAO-SDFL files, as discussed above, will be completed as soon as is technologically feasible.
The Rule 16 discovery materials in this case identified to date have already been
produced to defense counsel. We have received authorization from the Court to delay production
of a small subset of Rule 16 discovery relating to victims who do not form the basis of the charges
in the pending Indictment.
I have identified Brady material or potential Brady material in this case, all of which
has been disclosed to the defense during discovery productions, including disclosures of witness
statements. I do not intend to ask the court for authorization to delay production of Brady material.
VI. Forfeiture/Restitution
We expect to seek restitution in this case. Restitution is mandatory under the Victims
of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000 (the "TVPA"), and includes "the full amount
of the victim's losses" including "any costs incurred by the victim for—(A) medical services
relating to physical, psychiatric, or psychological care; (B) physical and occupational therapy or
rehabilitation; (C) necessary transportation, temporary housing, and child care expenses; (D) lost
income; (E) attorney's fees, as well as other costs incurred; and (F) any other losses suffered by
the victim as a proximate result of the offense." 18 U.S.C. § 1593(bX3) (incorporating by
reference 18 U.S.C. § 2259(bX3)). The statutory language is circumscribed by a requirement of a
causal connection between the offense of conviction and victim's harm, but "mathematical
precision" is not required.
We are still exploring whether we have a basis to seek forfeiture in this charging
instrument, but we note that it would be more complicated to pursue the properties involved in the
offense conduct because none belonged to Maxwell. Should we move forward with charges, we
would want to consult carefully with MLAF to ensure we are considering any viable forfeiture
theories.
VII. USAO Civil/Criminal Coordinated Proceedings
Does the offense conduct involve fraud/false claims on a federally funded program, or
fraud on or committed by a federally insured financial institution? No
VIII. Victim Issues
Does the case involve victims? Yes. The case involves multiple victim-witnesses. We
have been and will continue to be highly attuned to victims' rights and associated processes, and
we will coordinate with the SDNY victim and witness coordinators as well as with the FBI victim
2021.01.26
Page 28
liaisons. To date, all of the victims discussed in this memorandum have been entered into the
Victim Notification System and have been connected with an FBI victim specialist.

DC. Speedy Trial Act Calculations & Deadline
The defendant was attested on July 2. 2020. Trial is scheduled to commence on July
12, 2021, and Judge Nathan has excluded time under the Speedy Trial Act through that date.

X. Plans for Arrest
The defendant was arrested on July 2. 2020 and has been detained ever since. She is
currently in custody at the MDC.
By: /s/
Assistant United States Attorneys
2021.01.26
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Aubin Securities [crime] Ponzi scheme run by U.S. marine Christopher Aubin [golocalprov] 
      Parabridge International Services [crypto] entity associated with Cantor Fitzgerald 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01249207 (Jmail)
 [crypto] FBI tip linking American commerce secretary and Tether asset custodian Howard Lutnick to Ponzi schemes and Russian money
(inferred date: 2021-03-17)
FD.302 (Rev. 54.10)
50D-NY-3027571 Serial 593
-1 of 3 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  04/05/2071
<REDACTED> (<REDACTED>), date of birth <REDACTED> Home telephone
number +<REDACTED>, was interviewed telephonically by FBI Special Agents
<REDACTED> <REDACTED> <REDACTED>. After being advised of
the identities of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview,
<REDACTED> provided the following information:

<REDACTED> had been in the securities business for 32 years. He was at <REDACTED>
<REDACTED> from 2012 to 2017. From 2012 to 2015 he was based <REDACTED>
<REDACTED> <REDACTED>. In 2015, he transferred to <REDACTED> New York location at
<REDACTED>. <REDACTED> was running the <REDACTED> <REDACTED>
branches of his unit out of his location in the New York
office. He held a Series 30 license which meant he supervised regulatory
reporting and held the most senior position in his unit. managed 50
people. He was in New York until March of <REDACTED> when he left <REDACTED>.

Related to the fraud allegations <REDACTED> made in his initial complaint
to the FBI, <REDACTED> highlighted rope traders were gaining access to the
electronic trading platform at <REDACTED> from their homes. <REDACTED>
<REDACTED>, the co-head of brokerage, was able to override controls that
were in place. To cover losses at <REDACTED>, people within the company
tried to rob <REDACTED> pool of trading funds. The people trying to cover
these losses would come to <REDACTED> because he had the Series 30 license.
By robbing the various trading pools to cover losses, <REDACTED> advised it
materialized the losses and the brokers were being robbed of revenue.

<REDACTED> was involved in a global Ponzi scheme because they forced
employees to pay 10% of their salary/bonus into a share scheme they never
became vested in. Employees were told they could sell shares if they signed
on to work at <REDACTED> for four more years. Employees were never given
voting rights for this scheme and the share prices were dropping.
mvemipthmm 02/16/2021 m New York, New York, United States (Phone)

Ellen 272-NY-0, 50D-NY-3027571 Dmedrafted 03/17/2021 by
This document contain, neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI. It is the property of
the FBI and 1% loaned to your agency; it and its contents are not to be distributed outside your agency.
1101
3501.238-002
Page I of 3
FD•302a (Rev. 5.8.10) 50D-NY-3027571 Serial 593
272-NY-0
Continuation a ED•302 or (U) 02.16.2021 ,on 02/16/2021 ,page 2 of 3

<REDACTED> advised <REDACTED> and CANTOR FITZGERALD were well known for
money laundering. CANTOR FITZGERALD had a history of crime. Senior
officials have spoken about the money laundering occurred. PARABRIDGE
INTERNATIONAL SERVICES (PIS) was an affiliate of <REDACTED> and CANTOR
FITZGERALD. PIS was where payroll passed through in addition to the money
raised on charity days. They were part of the compliance division.
<REDACTED> thought there were illegal wire transfers involving PIS. PIS was
associated with DEUTSCHE BANK accounts in Singapore and Hong Kong. CANTOR
FITZGERALD was paying brokers from foundations in other countries through
PIS. PIS had hired an ex DEUTSCHE BANK CEO as Global President. The Panama
Papers connected CANTOR FITZGERALD to shell companies.

HOWARD LUTNICK (LUTNICK) ran everything and he maintained a very small
circle. LUTNICK instructed all of the fraud being committed. He used
philanthropy as a smokescreen for illegal activity. CANTOR FITZGERALD was
not doing well pre-9/11. After the events of September 11, 2001, CANTOR
FITZGERALD was doing well. CANTOR FITZGERALD couldn't afford people's
salaries and then was able to hire people and give people opportunities.

CANTOR FITZGERALD ran a global charity day in New York and London. They
invited high profile celebrities to come in and join staff on the trading
floor for the day. The charity day revenue was raised through the trades
placed that day and employees gave up their salaries for the day. Brokers
are paid on commission, and <REDACTED> advised if CANTOR FITZGERALD was
stealing the entire global revenues for the charity day, brokers couldn't
earn their commission, even if they did not participate in the charity day.
Charity days raised $9-10 million each year, and thought it was
strange it raised nearly the same amount every year. Brokers were not given
tax relief for the loss of revenue on charity days.

PIS handled all the funds raised in the United Kingdom on charity days
and the associated wire transfers.
ANDREISZ advised the day of the charity day trading would shift if the
publicized day was not a successful trading day.

LUTNICK was a neighbor of JEFFREY EPSTEIN (EPSTEIN) in the adjoining
property at 11 E 71st Street, New York, New York. LUTNICK bought the
property for $10 through a trust. LES WEXNER (WEXNER) and EPSTEIN owned the
3501.238.002
Page 2 of 3
FD•302a (Rev. 5.8.10) SOD-NY-3027571 Serial 593
272 —NY-0
Conlemation or FD•302 (U) 02.16.2021 .on 02/16/2021 •per  3 of 3
building. LUTNICK bought it in a very roundabout way from EPSTEIN.

<REDACTED> advised there was a relationship between LIQUID FUNDING and
executives at BEAR STERNS. When BEAR STERNS collapsed, the executives moved
to <REDACTED> or they went to a Russian hedge fund. <REDACTED> advised
BGC INTERNATIONAL was involved in crime and money laundering. BEAR STERNS
had hundreds of subsidiaries in 2018. BGC INTERNATIONAL was the parent
company of many of these subsidiaries to include JP MORGAN CHASE and
BLACKROCK. BGC PARTNERS made subsidiaries all over the world to include
Delaware, Cyprus, and Malta. BGC INTERNATIONAL used many of the same
intermediaries as INTER JURA, which was associated with PAUL MANAFORT.
RENAISSANCE CAPITAL was another company they were associated with.

<REDACTED> advised he thought the money being laundered through CANTOR
FITZGERALD and BGC INTERNATIONAL was from the Russian Mafia. That was what
senior people in the trading market thought. It could also have been money
made by CANTOR FITZGERALD through the frauds they were committing.
AUBIN SECURITIES was associated with banned Russian entities.
LUTNICK gave SARAH FERGUSON (FERGUSON) office space above CANTOR
FITZGERLAD in New York for the CHILDREN IN CRISIS (CIC) charity. GHISLAINE
MAXWELL (MAXWELL) and FERGUSON would attend Dolce Vita Parties which raised
money for CIC and STOW SCHOOL. CIC no longer existed.

<REDACTED> advised he has never interacted with LUTNICK. He had contact
with SEAN LYNN, the Chairman of BGC PARTNERS. ROBERTO "BOB" VELEZ was
a whistleblower who had contact with LUTNICK through the board. VELEZ was
an American citizen.
<REDACTED> had never met EPSTEIN or MAXWELL. thought he met
FERGUSON on a charity day, but wasn't sure.
<REDACTED> was working with the COMMODITY FUTURES TRADING COMMISSION
(CFTC)and he was eligible for their whistleblower program.
(Agent Note: After the conclusion of the interview, <REDACTED> contacted SA
telephonically <REDACTED> asked if he could provide her contact information to
the CFTC. SA <REDACTED> provided that information to <REDACTED>.)
3501.238.002
Page 3 of 3
EFTA00099817 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip about rape at knifepoint by Epstein
(inferred timestamp: 2021-03-22 23:51:00)
• OFFICIAL RECORD Intake (Rev. 5-23-17) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Intake
Case ID #: 50D-NY-3027571
Drafted By:
Date: 03/22/2021
(U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX
TRAFFICKING
Date/Time Received: 03/22/2021 07:51 PM EDT
Details:
On 3/22/2021, at 7:51 p.m. Eastern
Cell telephone number
the FBI National Threat Operations
Jeffery Epstein in 2001 or 2002 in
Time, , date of birth
, zip code , called
Center (NTOC) to report being raped by
New York, NY. (NY)
provided the following information:
stated that she was a rape victim of Jeffery Epstein. This
incident happened back in either 2001 or 2002, was taken to a
conference by her parents and was staying at an apartment on the upper
east side, but does not remember who's apartment it was. was
returning to the lobby one night and an unknown male subject (UNSUB),
believed to be Epstein based on his appearance, was waiting in the lobby
and joined her in the elevator.
During the elevator ride UNSUB stated that he saw her on TV last night.
did not know at the time, but Epstein had cameras in all his
buildings, and she think this meant he was watching her on camera. Once
the and UNSUB got off the elevator UNSUB said he was always
curious about how the apartment that she was staying at looked on the
inside. let him in because he seemed trustworthy and she sat down
waiting for him to leave, but he was just staring at her.
Re: 50D-NY-3027571, 03/22/2021
then decided to try to leave but the man blocked her and demanded
that she take her shirt off and threatened to cut throat.
took off her shirt and does not remember a lot after this point,
but she remembers being verbally assaulted and "being scratched in her
vagina very hard." believed at some point that night she was
drugged before these events.
The following night believes she was drugged again by a man named
Victor Lee who organized the conference, is Chinese, and believes he was
born in the 40s or 50s and lived in Manhattan NY. Lee claimed to be a
herbal doctor and gave her a drink which she accepted, she believes this
was drugged as well. had no further information on Victor Lee.
.•
2
EFTA00008744 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of FBI grand jury testimony of Child Exploitation & Human Trafficking Task Force member
(date: 2021-03-29)
UNITED STATES GRAND JURY
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
-x
-V- : January 19, 2021 Additional
GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(2018R01618)
APPEARANCE S:
x
United States Courthouse
Foley Square
New York, New York
March 29, 2021
10:05 a.m.
States Attorney
d States Attorney
M inury Reporter
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
ONLOLSDNYJMONn23
03/29/2021 2
(Colloquy Precedes)
(Witness Enters Room)
(Time Noted: 10:14 a.m.)
called as a witness, having been duly sworn by
the Foreperson of the Grand Jury, was examined and
testified as follows:
BY MS.

Q. Good morning.
A. Good morning.
Q. Would you please state your name for the record?
A. Detective
Q. Detective where do you work?

A. New York City Police Department.
Q. I'm going to ask you to please keep your voice up,
and speak as slowly as you can.
BY MS.
Q.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER.
And you can pull the microphone toward you so that
everyone in this big room can hear you. Thank you. Where
do you work?

A. New York City Police Department.
Q. What is your title there?
A. Detective.
Q. How long have you been with the NYPD?

A. About 15 years.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000224
03/29/2021 3

Q. Are you currently part of a federal task force?
A. Yes.
Q. What task force?
A. The Child Exploitation and Human Trafficking Task
Force with the FBI.

Q. What is your title on the task force?
A. Task force officer.
Q. How long have you been a task force officer with
the FBI?

A. Since about 2017.
Q. Generally, what are your duties and
responsibilities on the task force?
A. We address cases of child sex-trafficking, adult
sex-trafficking, child pornography, and child enticement.

Q. Over the last, approximately, three years have you
been involved in an investigation into Jeffrey Epstein and
his associates, including an individual named
Ghislaine Maxwell?

A. Yes.
Q. During your investigation have you spoken with
other people, including other law enforcement officers?

A. Yes.
Q• Have you reviewed reports and documents prepared
by others, and transcripts of testimony in other court and
grand jury proceedings?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000225
03/29/2021

A. Yes.
Q. Will your testimony today be based in part on
those conversations and documents that you have reviewed?

A. Yes.
MS. Ladies and gentlemen, some of the
testimony you are going to hear from Detective will
include hearsay. That means he is not going to testify only
from his own personal observations, he will also be
testifying about what other people have told him and what he
has read in documents.
Hearsay evidence, as you know, is admissible and
proper in these proceedings, and you are permitted to rely
on it in determining whether there is probable cause to
indict the defendant, but if you want to hear testimony from
other witnesses, or see particular documents, please let me
know, and I will make my best efforts to bring those before
you.
BY MS.

Q. Detective over the course of your
investigation has another member of the FBI task force
you're a part of testified before a different grand jury
about the facts of this case?

A. Yes.
Q. I'd like to ask you to please pick up what should
be in front of you and marked as Grand Jury Exhibit 3. Do
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000226
03/29/2021
you recognize that?

A. Yes.
Q. Is this document a fair and accurate transcript of
testimony given by FBI Special Agent before a
different grand jury, on June 29, 2020?

A. Yes.
Q. I'd like to read back a portion of this
transcript. We will start at Page 2, Line 18. I will read
the questions, you read the answers.

Q. "Where do you currently work?"
A. "The Federal Bureau of Investigation."
Q. "What is your title?"
A. "Special agent."

Q. "How long have you worked as a special agent?"
A. "About three years now."
Q. "Where are you currently assigned?"

A. "I work on the Violent Crimes Against Children's
Squad."
Q. "What are your duties and responsibilities as -
special agent on that squad?"

A. "We investigate crimes that have to do with child
sexual abuse material, sextortion, exploitation, and
enticement of minors, sex-trafficking."

MS. You can stop there. I'll now jump to
Page 4, line 13.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000227
03/29/2021
BY MS.

Q. "Have you participated in an investigation of
Ghislaine Maxwell?"
A. "Yes, I have."
Q. "Have you spoken to other people, including other
law enforcement officers about this investigation?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Have you reviewed reports and documents prepared
by others regarding this case?"
A. "Yes."

Q. "Is your testimony today based in part on those
conversations with other law enforcement officers and
documents that you have reviewed?"

A. "Yes."
MS. Stepping out of the read back. At
this point the AUSA provided the same hearsay instruction to
the grand jury, at that time, as I just provided to you all.
So that instruction applies with respect to
Detective
testimony the same way it applies to
testimony.
We can now go down to Page 5, line 17.
BY MS.

Q. we've placed on the desk in
front of you a PowerPoint that is Grand Jury Exhibit 2 which
we're entering into the record. Do you recognize this?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_000002.28
03/29/2021

A. "Yes."
Q. "What is it?"
A. "It's a PowerPoint presentation to assist in
testifying today."
Q. "Did you participate in preparing this Exhibit in
connection with your testimony today?"

A. "Yes, I did."
Q. "If you could please turn to the first slide. Who
are the individuals depicted in these photographs?"

A. "The picture on the left is Ghislaine Maxwell, and
the picture on the right is Jeffrey Epstein with
Ghislaine Maxwell."

Q. "Based on your participation in this investigation
and your review of public source materials, have Maxwell and
Epstein been photographed together many times over the
years?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Based on your participation in this investigation
and your review of public materials, where is Maxwell from?"

A. "Maxwell was born in France, she grew up in United
Kingdom, was educated in Oxford and is from a wealthy
family."

Q. "Is she a citizen of France, the United Kingdom,
and the United States?"
A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000229
03/29/2021

Q. "How old is she currently?"
A. "Fifty-eight."
Q. "Has the FBI investigated Maxwell and Epstein' :
conduct with minors during the 1990s?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Generally speaking, what have you learned about
the relationship between Maxwell and Epstein during the
1990s?"

A. "Epstein and Maxwell had a romantic relationship,
and she also worked for him; managing his homes, hiring and
firing individuals."

Q. "During that time period, was she one of his
closest associates?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "During the course of this investigation have you
learned where Epstein maintained properties in the 1990s?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Where did he maintain properties?"
A. "New York, Palm Beach, and New Mexico."
Q. "Turning to the next slide, did he maintain an
address in Manhattan located at 9 East 71st Street?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Does this slide fairly and accurately depict that
residence?"
A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000230
03/29/2021
4• "Can you please describe that property for the
grand jury?"

A. "It's a seven-story home. It's located near
Central Park. It's reportedly the largest residence in
Manhattan."

Q. "Based on your participation in this
investigation, did that house include a room that was used
as a massage room?"

A. "Yes, it did."
Q. "All right. We'll talk more about that later but
for now, moving on to the other properties. Did he maintain
an address in Palm Beach, Florida, located at
358 El Brillo Way?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Turning to the next slide. Does this slide
fairly and accurately depict the residence?"
A. "Yes, it does."

Q. "Could you please describe that property for the
grand jury?"
A. "It's a water-front estate. It has an in-ground
pool and a detached dwelling, or pool house, on the property
as well."

Q. "Aside -- and from your participation in this
investigation and your review of other materials, did that
house include a room that was used as a massage room?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNI_GLSDNYJX*Min31
03/29/2021 10
A.
Q.
"Yes."
"Turning to the next property. Did Epstein also
own a ranch in New Mexico?"

A. "Yes, he did."
Q. "And turning to the next slide, was that a
property located at 49 Zorro Ranch Road in Stanley,
New Mexico?"

A. "Yes."
4. "Looking at the photograph on this slide does this
accurately depict that property?"
A. "Yes, it does."

Q. "And we've been talking about the properties that
Epstein owned during this time period. Did he also own a
private jet?"
A.
4•
"Yes."
"Is it fair to say that he was a multi-millionaire
during this time period?

A. "Yes."
Q. "During the 1990s did Epstein have an employee,
■ who ran his house in Palm Beach?"
A. "Yes, he did."

Q. "What was his job?"
A. "His job was making sure that everything in the
house ran smoothly. He referred -- he described that
Epstein liked to have his house run like a five-star hotel;
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000232
03/29/2021 11
that everything had to be in its proper place. So he was
responsible for managing that."

Q. "Have you interviewed
A. "Yes."
Q. "How many times?"
A. "Twice."
Q. "And is the information you're about to provide
based on your interviews with

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did begin working for Epstein in the early
1990s?"
A. "Yes, he did."
Q. "At the time came to work for Epstein in
Palm Beach, was Epstein dating Ghislaine Maxwell at that
point?"

A. "Not at that time."
4• "Was it a few years before Epstein began dating
Maxwell after started working there?"

A. "Yes."
MS. I'm going to step out of the read
back. It sounds like the grand jurors are having difficulty
hearing. Are you having difficulty hearing me, the witness,
or both?
GRAND JURORS. The witness.

MS. So Detective I'm going to ask
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNI_GLSDNY_0O0OM3
03/29/2021 12
you to please keep your voice up. Try to shout into the
microphone. Can you pull the microphone toward you? Lift
it and pull it all the way up to you? Thank you. We left
off reading at Page 10, line 12.
BY MS.

Q. "From what told you, how did
work change once Maxwell arrived on the scene?"
A. ''I'll' described Epstein as being of more
pleasant to work with prior to Maxwell coming into the
picture. Once she came into the picture, he said things
became more secretive. He wasn't allowed to be in the room
with guests, wasn't allowed to talk with them, associate
with them; it became a different environment."

MS. Detective I'm going to ask you
to take the microphone and try to put it right under where
your mouth would be when you're reading because as you're
looking down, you're moving your mouth away from the
microphone. Thank you. Picking back up at Page 10,
line 20.
BY MS.

Q. "You talked about some of the rules that were
placed, changing. Were there any rule changes about eye
contact once Maxwell began staying at the Palm Beach house?"

A. "Yes. wasn't allowed to make eye contact
with Epstein and others."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000234
03/29/2021

MS. We're going to jump now to Page 11,
Line 6.
BY MS.
Q. "Shifting gears. I want to talk to you about
someone else that you've interviewed during this
investigation. During the course of this investigation,
have you participated in interviews with an individual named

A. "Yes."
Q. "So for these purposes, I'm just going to refer t
her as . Is that okay?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "How many times have you interviewed ?"

A. "Approximately five times."
Q. "If you could please just page through the next
two slides in front of you? Are these photographs of
II

A. "Yes."
Q. "Is it your understanding that these photographs
depict from approximately ages 13 to approximately
17?"

A. "Yes, it does."
4• "Okay. Let's take a look at some of those
photographs. I'm going to publish the next slide.
's date of birth
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000235
03/29/2021 14

A. "Yes."
Q. "Are these two photographs of ?"
A. "Yes, they are."
Q. "If you could turn to the second slide of
photographs, are these also photographs of

A. "Yes."
Q.
?It
"Based on your participation in this investigation
and your interviews with , where was she living when
she was approximately 14 years old?"

A. "She was living in Palm Beach, Florida."
Q. "Who was she living with when she was 14?"
A. "Her mother and her siblings."

Q. "What was her whole life like at that time?"
A. "At that time her father had passed away the year
prior, so the family was struggling financially and having
some difficulties."

Q. "What did 's father do before he passed away?
What was his profession?"
A. "He was involved in
Q. "Was
.'
involved in ?"

A. "Yes, she was."
Q. "Were her siblings?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "What kinds of were they involved in?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000236
03/29/2021

A. "Singing. She was a singer."
Q. "Like, what kind of singer?"
A. "Opera."
Q. "In the summer of 1994, how old was

A. "She was 13 going on 14."
Q. "You testified earlier that her birthday was in
. So did she turn 14 in

A. "Yes."
Q. "What did she do that summer?"
A. "She attended an arts camp at Interlochen Center
for the Arts."

Q. "And is Interlochen summer arts program located in
Michigan?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did meet Jeffrey Epstein and
Ghislaine Maxwell that summer?"

A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Did she meet them at summer camp?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "What did she tell you about that?"

A. "She said that she was sitting at a picnic table
with friends when Epstein and Maxwell walked by. They
stopped to talk to her, engaged her in conversation, asked
her if she liked her classes; her teachers. During that
conversation she found out that she was also from Palm Beach
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000237
03/29/2021 16
and that he said he gives scholarships to students."

Q. "How did they leave the conversation? Was there
any contact information exchanged?"
A. "They asked for
Q.
's phone number."
"As part of your investigation have you attempted
to gather records to corroborate that , Maxwell, and
Epstein were all at that summer camp that summer?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "If you could turn to the next slide, please.
Have you obtained records from Interlochen for the summer of
1994?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And what are we looking at on this slide?"
A. "This shows who -- some of the individuals that
were there, were present for that camp in '94. On here is
Q.
If
"And have you investigated whether Maxwell and
Epstein were also at Interlochen that summer of 1994 as
described?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Based on your review of records from Interlochen,
what is your understanding of Epstein's relationship with
Interlochen?"

A. "My understanding was that he was a donor to the
school."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJX000238
03/29/2021

Q. "Did he make any substantial donations?"
A. "He did."
Q. "Did he donate a lodge to the camp in the summer
of 1994?"

A. "Yes, he did."
Q. "Did he have a long-standing relationship as a
donor to Interlochen?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Turning to the next slide. Is this an excerpt of
a letter from Interlochen to Epstein?"

A. "Yes, it is."
Q. "And does this letter thank Epstein for donating a
scholarship lodge?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Does it invite Epstein to visit in August of
1994?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "In 1994 did Epstein have a private jet?"
A. "Yes, he did."
Q. "Have you obtained the flight logs for that -iet?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Do those logs include passenger lists and the
airport code for the airports the plane flew into and out
of?"

A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000239
03/29/2021 18

Q. "Turning to the next slide. Is this a page of the
flight logs that you reviewed?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "And on this excerpt of the flight logs, where the
red arrow is, is that a log entry showing an August 18, 1994
flight to an airport with the airport code TBC?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Is TBC the airport code for Cherry Capitol
Airport in Traverse City, Michigan?"
A. "Yes, it is."

Q. "About how far is that airport from Interlochen by
car?"
A. "About 25 minutes, give or take."
Q. "And who were the listed passengers on this
flight?"

A. "Jeffrey Epstein, (ph), and
(ph)."
Q. "Turning to the next slide. Is it the same
excerpt just with a different arrow?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Okay. So a few lines down is there a flight out
of Traverse City just two days later, on August 20, 1994?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And do the passengers listed in the flight out of
Traverse City include the initials GM?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0O00O24O
03/29/2021 19

A. "Yes, they do."
Q. "Are those Ghislaine Maxwell's initials?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Have you obtained any records from Interlochen to
indicate that Maxwell was at Interlochen in 1994?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "If we could turn to the next slide. Can you
please explain for the grand jury what we're looking at on
this slide?"

A. "This was a letter from Interlochen
explaining -- addressed to Maxwell -- telling her that they
had found an envelope in the lodge that they had been
staying."

Q. "All right. We were talking a few minutes ago
about how described meeting Maxwell and Epstein at
summer camp and you testified that she provided them with
her phone number. Did explain to you whether or not
she had any contact with Epstein or Maxwell after she
returned home to Palm Beach?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "When was the next time that happened?"
A. "Shortly thereafter."
Q. "And how did that occur?"

A. "She was invited to his house, so her and her
mother went to Epstein's house to visit."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNYJNMONAI
03/29/2021 20

Q. "What did tell you about that visit to
Epstein's house with her mother?"
A. "She said it was -- wait, can you rephrase that?"

Q. "Of course. Did go to the house by
herself or with her mother?"
A. "With her mother."
Q. "Okay. When they went to the house what did they
do there?"

A. "They had tea."
Q. "Who was there when they had tea at the house?"
A. "Epstein and Maxwell."
Q. "What did they discuss as they had tea?"

A. "They just talked about her life and, you know,
what she wanted to do."
Q. "Did Epstein make any offers?"

A. "He said that he gives scholarships; he likes to
mentor people."
Q. "How did 's mother react when Epstein said
this?"

A. "She was happy for her daughter and often times
referred to Epstein as 's godfather."
Q. "After that occasion when they went over to the
house, thereafter, did subsequently begin regularly
spending time with Maxwell and Epstein at Epstein's house in
Palm Beach?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000242
03/29/2021 21
14?"

A. "Yes."
Q.
A.
4•
"Did that start when she was approximately age
"Yes."
"Did it continue until she was about age 17?"

A. "Yes, it did."
Q. "And during those years does she regularly go over
to Epstein's house in Palm Beach and spend time with Maxwell
and Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "What happened in the summer of 1997 when
was 17, about to turn 18?"
A. "She moved to New York City."

Q. "Why did she move to New York City?"
A. "She wanted to pursue a career in acting and
modeling."
Q. "We'll talk about that in a moment, but for now, I
want to focus on the years you talked about, in Palm Beach,
from the ages 14 to 17, when would regularly go to
Epstein's house. In the beginning, in the first few months
when she went there, what kinds of things did she do when
she would visit the house when Maxwell and Epstein were
there?"

A. "They'd hang out by the pool. He -- they would
take her to the movies, take her shopping. She described
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GUDNYJNMONA3
03/29/2021 22
that behavior as grooming."

Q. "When you say grooming, did she explain what she
meant by that?"
A. "She meant that they were building a relationship
with her, giving her things, taking her places, and then
usually when the grooming happens, an offender will -- once
they gain that trust -- they will make their relationship
turn sexual."

Q. "Now you testified just a moment ago that
described to you that she felt at this time period they were
grooming her, is that right?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Is that something that she realized at the time
when she was 14, or is that something she's described to you
now?"

A. "Something she's described now. She didn't
realize that at the time."
Q. "So we'll talk a little bit more about grooming in
a moment, but just to give context, are you familiar with
the term grooming based on your experience investigating
crimes involving sexual exploitation of minors?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Generally speaking, you were touching on this a
moment ago, but if you could just explain it in full, what
is grooming?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000244
03/29/2021 23

A. "Grooming is when someone builds a relationship
with a child. They will find a vulnerability or a need and
then they work on gaining that child's trust. And then
often times gaining a parent's trust. Once they have that
trust, they show that in ways that they can care about them;
like giving them gifts and promises. And then once that's
established, they then turn the relationship sexual; often
times, making sexual comments and normalizing the behavior."

Q. "Now during these visits that you've been
describing, that told you about, did say whether
Epstein ever gave her anything?"

A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "What did he give her?"
A. "He gave her cash. Sometimes he'd tell her to
give the cash to her mom because he knew that they needed

it. He paid for her voice lessons as well."
Q. "Now you were describing how has
characterized these visits now, but based on your
conversations with her, at the time did she feel that these
visits were strange at all?"

A. "She thought they were strange, but Maxwell
normalized it for her. She was like a cool, older sister
and made comments like, this is what grownups do."

Q. "You used the phrase cool, older sister. Is that
a phrase that used to describe how she felt about
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0(100NA5
03/29/2021 24
Maxwell at the time, and what Maxwell was like?"

A. "Yes. Those are her words."
Q. "Did there come a time -- these visits --
saw Maxwell topless by the pool?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "What did she tell you about that?"
A. "She was a little taken back, but Maxwell just
acted normal."

Q. "Did tell you about an incident several
months into this arrangement when she was alone with Epstein
in the pool house?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And when they were alone together, did Epstein
ask what she wanted to do with her life?"
A. "He did."

Q. "What did she say?"
A. "She said she wanted to be an actress and n
model."
Q. "How did Epstein respond?"

A. "He told her that he was best friends with the
owner of Victoria's Secret. Told her that she would have to
have photographs taken and that she had to be comfortable in
her underwear and not be a prude. When she was asked what
she meant by that, he pulled her into his lap and
masturbated."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000246
03/29/2021 95
1 Q• "What was her reaction?"

A. "She felt paralyzed. She froze."
Q. "After this incident did 's encounters with
Epstein begin to include sexual contact?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Over time did the sexual abuse escalate?"
A. "It did."
Q. "From what she's described to you, did the abuse
include Epstein digitally penetrating

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did it include Epstein using a vibrator on her?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she describe to you that there were times
when Epstein would direct to massage him while he
masturbated?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did explain to you what her memories are
like of the abuse?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "What did she say about that?"

A. "She said that it happened so often that it al
kind it all runs together for her. That it's hard to
separate out some of the different instances of abuse."

Q. "You were describing how explained to you
that the abuse began. Did that occur, based on what
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNY_00000247
03/29/2021 26
told you, within the first year that she met Epstein and
Maxwell?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Now did also describe to you that once this
abuse started Epstein would also bring her into his massage
room in his house?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And were there times, where he did this, where
there were other women present, including Maxwell?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Was abused during those episodes?"
A. "Yes, she was."
Q. "During these group encounters what were and
the adult women wearing?"

A. "They were usually just in their underwear."
Q. "Once they were all in the massage room, how would
these episodes generally start?"

A. "They would generally start with one of the girls
massaging Epstein. was usually massaging his feet.
Maxwell was kind of teasing the other girls. She'd grab the
girl's breasts, and she would direct the girls on what to
do."

Q. "When these episodes would start, in general, was
Epstein generally lying face down on the massage table?"

A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNI_GLSDNY_NMOMW8
03/29/2021 27

Q. "What would happen as things progressed, generally
speaking, from what she described to you?"
A. "When Epstein would decide he was kind of done
with the regular massage, he would turn over on his back,
and he'd grab whichever girl he wanted to, either, touch him
or whatever girl he wanted to touch."

Q. "Did these episodes include sex acts that over
time, in various instances, included Epstein masturbating,
Epstein receiving oral sex, and Epstein engaging in
intercourse?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "You were describing for a moment what tos,
you about Maxwell's role during these group encounters.
Would Maxwell sometimes guide the women and give
instructions about what to do?"

A. "Yes, she would."
Q. "What would typically do during these
episodes?"
A. "She would try not to look at Maxwell because she
gave off that sister-vibe, so it felt weird for her. She
would try to be invisible in the room so they would ignore
her as much as possible."

Q. "In the beginning, when 's approximately 16
or 15, would she generally begin by just massaging Epstein's
feet?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000249
03/29/2021 2R

A. "Yes."
Q. "Is that something she was told to do?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she -- you mentioned that she tried to be
invisible -- was -- I believe that was your testimony?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And over time has she described to you that over
time she believed she became more involved in the sexual
activity which varied in each encounter?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Were there times let me rephrase that. How
did -- you touched on this for a moment, but just to be
clear -- how did describe Maxwell's attitude during
these incidents?"

A. "It was very casual; she acted like this was
normal. She gave off that vibe to her and yeah."
Q. "Did that make her feel more comfortable with what
was happening?"

A. "It did."
Q. "Was sometimes fully nude during these
episodes?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "And during these episodes did the abuse include
Epstein touching 's breasts?"

A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000250
03/29/2021 29

Q. "Did it include directing to touch Epstein's
genitals?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Beginning when 's approximately 14, does
she begin to travel with Epstein and Maxwell to
New York City on occasion?"

A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Was that to the property you testified about
earlier; the townhouse on the upper-east side?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "When traveled to New York City, did she
stay in Epstein's townhouse in New York City?
A. "Yes, she did."

Q. "Did she recall that Maxwell and Epstein took her
shopping on one of her early trips to New York City?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she remember them buying her anything?"
A. "She recalled them buying her white cotton
underwear. Her description was that they were like little
girl's underwear."

Q. "From ages 14 to 17 did Epstein ask to
periodically fly to New York for weekends at that townhouse
in New York?"

A. "I'm sorry, say it again?"
Q. "You testified that she began travelling to
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNI_GLSDNYJX*Min51
03/29/2021 30
New York City at age 14. Did she then periodically travel
to New York City, in a similar manner, from ages 14 to 17?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Were there times, when she travelled on those
trips, when she flew on Epstein's private jet?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she also sometimes fly commercially?"
A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Was Maxwell sometimes present on the trips to New
York?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "You testified earlier that was sexually
abused in Palm Beach. Did she describe to you that she was
also sexually abused on these trips to New York?"

A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Did Maxwell encourage to go on these
trips?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "What does -- what did tell you about
her memory of how these trips were arranged?"

A. "She recalled that Maxwell was usually the one
that would schedule her flights. If she was flying
commercially she would schedule the flights, sometimes
calling her mother to schedule."

Q. "Was that the general impression of how they were
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNI_GLSDNY_NX0Y252
03/29/2021 31
arranged?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "In addition to the trips to New York City you
just described, did also remember travelling, at least
once, to Epstein's ranch in New Mexico?"

A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Does she remember whether or not she was sexually
abused in New Mexico?"
A. "She couldn't recall. She couldn't remember."

Q. "In general, how would get to the airport in
Florida when she would fly on Epstein's jet; what did she
describe to you?"

A. "Usually a driver; one of Epstein's drivers would
pick her up from her house and take her to the airport."

Q. "Now you testified earlier that you reviewed
flight records for Epstein's private jet, is that correct?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And have you reviewed records from the 1990s to
see if there -- whether there's a person named listed
on the records?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Turning to the next slide. Is this an excerpt
from those records?"
A. "Yes, it is."
Q. "And does the red arrow point to does the red
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNY_00000253
03/29/2021
arrow point to a November 11th, 1996 flight?"

A. "Yes, it does."
Q. "And does this say -- does this flight log reflect
that it was a flight from Palm Beach, Florida to Teterboro,
New Jersey?"
A.
Q.
"Yes."
"Is there a private airfield in Teterboro,
New Jersey?"

A. "Yes, there is."
Q. "What's it called?"
A. "Teterboro Airport."
■
Q. "Are the passengers listed on this entry JE?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Are the -- do the entries also include
(ph) plus friend, Jeff Shamf's (ph), family,
(ph), (ph), (ph), and ?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Was , based on your awareness of 's
date of birth and the date of this flight, was on
the date of this flight?"

A. "Yes, she was."
Q. "Turning to the next slide. You testified earlier
about Teterboro Airport. What are we looking at on this
slide?"

A. "This is directions from Teterboro Airport to
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0O00O254
03/29/2021
Epstein's residence here in Manhattan."

Q. "So based on your review of this map, if someone
were to fly into Teterboro and travel to New York City,
would they -- would the most natural route be to travel to
Teterboro Airport and crossing into New York through
Manhattan?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Turning to the next slide. Is this also an
excerpt from the flight records that you've reviewed?"

A. "Yes, it is."
Q. "And does this show a May 9, 1997 flight from
Teterboro, New Jersey to Santa Fe, New Mexico?"

A. "Yes, it does."
Q. "And are the passengers listed on this log JE, GM,
and ? II
A. "Yes."
Q. "Based on your knowledge of 's birthdate and
the date of this flight, would have been 16 on the
date of this flight?"

A. "Yes, she would have been."
Q. "Turning to the next flight -- slide. Is this
also an excerpt from the flight records?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And does the red arrow point to a flight entry on
May 3, 1998?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNY_00000255
03/29/2021 34

A. "Yes, it does."
Q. "Based on the airport codes, did this reflect that
there is a flight on that date from Palm Beach, Florida to
Teterboro, New Jersey?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And are the passengers listed on this log JE, GM,
ET,
(ph),
, Glenn (ph),
A. "Yes."
(ph) ?"
(ph), (ph), Manny

Q. "Based on your knowledge of 's birthday and
the date of this flight, would
date?"
A. "Yes."
Q.
have been 17 on this
"Am I correct that you testified earlier that in
addition to sometimes flying on Epstein's private jet, she
also travelled on commercial airlines, is that right?"

A. "Yes, it is."
Q. "Based on your review of these flight logs, does
every flight entry list the name of every single passenger;
or are there sometime when a passenger is noted female?"

A. "There's times where a passenger is just noted
female."
Q. "I'm going to walk -- talk to you about two
examples of that. Turning ahead two slides. Looking at
Slide 18, does this reflect a January 3rd, 1995 flight where
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDN Y_00000256
03/29/2021 35
the flight log says JE, two females?"

A. "Yes, it does."
Q. "And do the two entries below, also, just list
female next to the initials JE?"
A. "Yes, they do."

Q. "Turning to the next slide, Slide 19. Is this
another example of an entry like that; focusing on the entry
on February 12, 1995?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Does that entry also say, female?"
A. "Yes, it does."
Q. "Now, you testified that sometimes flew on
commercial airlines and that arrangements for her travel
were made for her to fly commercially for these trips, is
that right?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Have you been able to obtain commercial flight
records?"
A. "We tried. We were not able to obtain those
records."

Q. "Why is that?"
A. "Airlines do not keep records past a certain
year."
Q. "Does recall group sexualized massages
involving Epstein and Maxwell, in both the New York and
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000257
03/29/2021 36
Florida residences, during the time period we've been
talking about?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "You testified earlier about the time that Epstein
and Maxwell would spend together and the activities that
they were involved in. During this time period did
have occasions to talk with Maxwell?"

A. "She -- I'm sorry, can you ask the question
again?"
Q. "During the beginning when she was 14, when she
began spending time with Epstein and Maxwell, and through
the years, did often have conversations with Maxwell
about her life?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did they talk about that often?"
A. "They did."
Q. "Did Maxwell ask about her family, her
classes, and other aspects of her life?"

A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "You testified earlier, just before she turned 18,
moved to New York City, is that right?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she go to school there in New York City her
senior year?"
A. "Yes, she did."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNYJKONn58
03/29/2021

Q. "What school did she go to?"
A. "She went to the
Q. "What is the
A. "They cater to individuals who want to pursue
careers in the arts."

Q. "Have you reviewed records from the
VI
A. "Yes."
Q. "If you could turn to Slide 17. Can you please
explain for the grand jury what we're looking at here?"

A. "This is an excerpt from 's application to
the On it is listed, who is
financially responsible for her, and that is
Jeffrey Epstein."

Q. "From what told you did Maxwell encourage
to accept Epstein's financial help?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "When moved to New York City who was she
living with?"

A. "She lived with her mother and her brother
in -- apartment."
Q. "Did Epstein help pay for her rent?"

A. "He did."
Q. "During that year, her senior year of high school,
when she was in New York City, did remain in contact
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0O00O259
03/29/2021 38
with Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
Q• "What was the nature of their contact like during
that time period?"
her."
A. "During this time he was still sexually abusing

Q. "Did that continue to occur at his townhouse in
Manhattan that year?"
A. "Yes, it did."
Q. "What happened at the end of her senior year of
high school?"

A. "She moved to Los Angeles to pursue a career in
acting."
Q. "Did she get a job as an actress when she turned
18?"

A. "She did."
Q. "Has lived in Los Angeles and worked as an
actress on television ever since then?"
A. "Yes."

Q. "After she moved to Los Angeles, did she continue
being in touch with Epstein?"
A. "For a short period of time."

Q. "Did she ultimately break contact with him?'
A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Is currently pursuing a civil lawsuit
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000260
03/29/2021 39
against Maxwell and Epstein's estate?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Have you talked with about whether, when
she was a teenage girl and all of this was happening,
whether she told anyone that she was being sexually abused?"

A. "Yes. She said she didn't tell anyone. She felt
like she couldn't. She -- the -- nothing was talked about
outside of that room, so it made it so that she couldn't
talk about it. And then she also -- her mother is Middle
Eastern, and her mother raised her that women are supposed
to do what they're told even if someone is beating you.
When she was 13 and her father passed, she, she
went to a guidance counselor at school to talk about it, and
her mother found out about it and smacked her. She felt
like she couldn't talk to anyone about it."

Q. "Did 's mother encourage her to accept
Epstein's financial assistance?"
A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Have you become aware that in 2005 police
officers from the Palm Beach Police Department executed
search warrant at Epstein's house at the
El Brillo Way address in Palm Beach?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Have you reviewed some of the materials seized
during the search?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNI_GLSDNYJX000261
03/29/2021 40

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did they find massage tables and sex toys?"
A. "Yes, they did."
Q. "Did they find any photographs of

A. "Yes."
Q. "Was one of the photographs signed by
A. "Yes, it was."
Q. "Did it say,
A. "Yes."
Q. "During your interviews with , did tell
you how she felt about Epstein and Maxwell in the 90s when
she was a young girl?"

A. "She did. She expressed that she felt like they
loved her. She felt they were her family; that they
supported her, and that they felt like -- she was made to
feel that she was needed to be grateful to them."

Q. "Okay. Did she tell you that she felt like they
were trying to help her?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Have you talked with about how she feels
about this now?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "What was 's demeanor like when she described
to you what Epstein and Maxwell had done to her?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000262
03/29/2021 41

A. "She was upset. She recognized that now. It's
affected her life to a great degree. She's struggled in
relationships with opening up to people and trusting people;
both personal and professional relationships."

Q. "Did she tell you that she struggled to tell
anyone what had happened to her for most of her adulthood?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "When was the first time you interviewed
A. "Last fall."
Q. "Was that the first time she ever reported this to
law enforcement?"

A. "Yes, it was."
Q. "Now you testified earlier about your interviews
with who worked at Epstein's Palm Beach house.
Did he remember a girl named coming to the house
during that time?"

A. "Yes, he did."
Q. "Did he recall , Maxwell, and Epstein meeting
in the Palm Beach house together?"
A. "Yes."

Q. "What was his understanding of why
there?"
A. "He thought that Epstein was helping her. That's
what Epstein had told him, and had told him that
Epstein was helping her."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJX0000263
03/29/2021 42

Q. "Did he ever observe Epstein interacting with
physically?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "What did he see?"
A. "He saw Epstein kiss 's cheek and pat her on
the bottom."

Q. "Did he have any knowledge about what was
happening with Epstein or Maxwell when he wasn't present?"

A. "He didn't."
Q. "Did ever recall picking up from her
house?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "And when he would pick her up from her house,
would he then bring her back to the Palm Beach house?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did he remember who, in general, would tell him
to pick up from her house?"
A. "Maxwell would be the one to tell him to pick her
up."

Q. "Did he recall ever driving to the movies?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "What did he tell you about that?"
A. "That would usually be Epstein, Maxwell, and
; they would go to the movies, and it would usually be
late at night."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000264
03/29/2021 43

Q. "Did he tell you about what his memory was about
how old was?"
A. "He said she was young, and that he knew that
because he had picked her up from school, and that he knew
she was too young to drive."

Q. "Switching gears. I want to talk to you about a
different aspect of your interviews with Based
on what he told about his job duties, were there ever times
where he would have to clean Epstein's massage room?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "What did he tell you about that?"
A. "He said that he found sex toys in the massage
room, and he had to wash them afterwards."

Q. "Aside from those experiences, was he aware it
there were any sex toys in the house?"
A. "Yes. There was a basket of sex toys that were
kept in Maxwell's closet."

Q. "Did stop working for Epstein in
approximately 2002?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Was he told that he was being replaced?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And was he generally aware that the person who
replaced him was much younger?"
A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0O00O265
03/29/2021 44

Q. "Did tell you that a few months after he
left working for Epstein he became suicidal because of
issues in his marriage?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did he tell you that he went to Epstein's house
and tried to take Epstein's gun?"
A. "Yes, he did."

Q. "Did he tell you that it's worth several thousand
dollars?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did Epstein discover this and confront him about
it?"

A. "Yes, he did."
Q. "Did admit to Epstein and the police what
he had done?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did Epstein also tell the police his gun was
missing?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Were there any charges filed?"
A. "No."
Q. "Was he ever arrested?"
A. "I don't believe so."
Q.
incident?"
"And did Epstein pursue any charges about this
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000266
03/29/2021 4?

A. "No. He didn't pursue anything."
Q. "Have you interviewed one of Epstein's former
pilots?"
A. "Yes."

Q. "Is that pilot named David Rodgers?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Was he one of the pilots for Epstein's private
jet in the 1990s?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did he remember travelling on the
jet in the 90s?"
A. "He remembered her travelling, but he didn't
remember specifics."

Q. "So just to be clear, is your testimony that he
didn't remember the specific dates of the flights, but he
remembered her travelling on the jet during the 1990s?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And did he remember specifically as
a person who travelled?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did you discuss with him the flight records that
we talked about earlier that lists a person named as a
passenger?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did he have a specific memory of those exact
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000267
03/29/2021 46
flights?"

A. "No."
Q. "But was he aware of any other flying on the
jet, besides , in the 1990s?"
A. "No. No other at the time."

Q. "Earlier, when we were looking at Interlochen
attendance records for the summer of 1994, you noted that
was one of the names on that record, is that
right?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Is that ?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Have you interviewed ?"
A. "Yes, I have."
Q. "Did he tell you that he remembered talking
that summer at camp about having met Jeffrey Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did he tell you that he remembered going
over to Epstein's house in Palm Beach when they were in high
school?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did he remember that would often talk about
spending time with Maxwell and Epstein during this time?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did he remember telling him they -- when
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNI_GLSDNYJNIONn68
03/29/2021 47
they were in high school -- about at least one trip to
New York City that she took with Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did he remember describing Epstein's
townhouse in Manhattan?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "And does he remember talking often about
Ghislaine Maxwell?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Now based on your interviews with
■,
did he
tell you whether he knew back then, when they were in high
school, whether was being sexually abused by Epstein?"

A. "He didn't know back then."
Q. "Did ■ ever meet Ghislaine Maxwell?"
A. "Yes, he did."
Q. "What did he remember about that?"

A. "He remembered Epstein, Maxwell, and being
near a movie theatre, and he was approximately 16 at the
time and would have been 15, and just the little bit
of interaction they had. And then after that, had
told him that Maxwell had said something to the effect of, I
could teach a thing or two."

Q. "Is that something that he remembers telling
him back then, that Maxwell said?"
A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000269
03/29/2021 48
Q• "During the course of this investigation have you
participated in any interviews with an individual named
?II

A. "Yes."
Q. "So for today's purposes, I'm just going to refer
to her as . How many times have you referred to
(verbatim) ?"

A. "Approximately, twice."
MS. Excuse me.
BY MS.
Q. "How many times have you interviewed
A. "Approximately twice."

Q. "Now does know ? Have they
ever met before as far as you know?"
A. "As far as I know, no."
Q.
? 11
"Turning to the next slide. Are these photographs
of when she was in high school?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And is her date of birth ?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "When was approximately 16 and a junior in
high school where was she living?"

A. "She was living in with her mother."
Q. "Does she have any siblings?"
A. "An older sister."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000270
03/29/2021 49

Q. "What did her older sister do?"
A. "Her older sister lived -- worked for Epstein."
Q. "Where did she work for Epstein?"

A. "Here in New York."
Q. "Did there come a time, in approximately December
1995, when had a phone conversation with her sister
about travelling to New York City?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "What did they discuss?"
A. "They discussed her coming to New York and meeting
Epstein."
Q. "What did her sister tell about why she
should meet Epstein?"

A. "She said that he could help her with her
college."
Q. "And did she say -- does the sister say whether
the sister wanted her to meet Epstein, or did she say
whether Epstein wanted to meet

A. "Epstein wanted to meet
Q. "Now let me just pause here. You testified that
this happened in approximately December of 1995. Just for
context, the years that we were talking about with
, was that 1994 through 1997?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "So is this approximately the same time period
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJX100O271
03/29/2021 50
while what you described telling you happened?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "So in January of 1996 did fly on a
commercial airline to New York City to spend a weekend with
her sister and meet Jeffrey Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she tell you that?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "During the trip did tell you that she met
Epstein at his townhouse in New York City?"

A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Did she tell you that Epstein discussed her plans
for college applications and offered to help her?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "What was • s first impression of Jeffrey
Epstein?"
A. "She was very impressed by him."
Q. "What did she -- what was her impression, based on
this conversation, of what Epstein was going to do for her?"

A. "That he was going to help her with her future
plans for college."
Q. "During that trip to New York City did she stay at
Epstein's townhouse or at her sister's apartment?"

A. "Her sister's apartment."
Q. "During that trip did she tell you that she saw
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000272
03/29/2021 51
Epstein a second time when he took and her sister to
the movies?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "What did she tell you happened at the movies?"
A. "She said that they were sitting in the theatre
and Epstein was between and her sister, and Epstein
put his hand on her leg; he rubbed her arm and held her
hands -- held hands with her."

Q. "From what she told you, what was her impression
about whether her sister could see what was going on?"

A. "She felt like her sister couldn't see."
Q. "What was her reaction to this happening?"
A. "She was uncomfortable."

Q. "After the movie did she tell her sister what hac
happened?"
A. "No, she didn't."
Q. "Did she say why not?"

A. "She said that she knew , her sister, really
liked Epstein and that Epstein could help them. So she
didn't tell her."

Q. "After this trip did go back home to
7"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did Epstein contact her afterwards?"
A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJNI000273
03/29/2021 52

Q. "Did he discuss with her, her ongoing college
plans?"
A. "Yes, he did."
Q. "Did he invite her to a weekend at his ranch in
New Mexico in the spring of 1996?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Was she 16 at the time?"
A. "Yes, she was."
Q. "From what she told you, what was
impression of who would be on this trip to New Mexico?"

A. "She knew Maxwell would be there."
Q. "Did she -- was she told anyone else was going to
be present during this trip?"

A. "She said that there would be like other students
her -- kids her age."
Q. "And what was her understanding of who these other
kids were and why they would be there? Sorry, let me --"

A. "Rephrase."
Q. "Rephrase that question. You testified that she
was told that on this trip that there would be other
students. Was she under the impression that there would be
other students like her on the trip who were also being
mentored by Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Now you testified just a moment ago that she was
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000274
03/29/2021 53
also told that Maxwell would be there. Are you referring to
Ghislaine Maxwell?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "At the point that she was told that
Ghislaine Maxwell would be on this trip, had she ever met
Ghislaine Maxwell?"

A. "No, she hadn't."
Q. "Had she heard her sister talk about
Ghislaine Maxwell?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "How did -- from what she described to you -- how
did her expectation that Maxwell would be on this trip make
her feel about the trip?"

A. "It made her comfortable. Her sister had talked
highly of Maxwell."
Q. "Did tell you that she flew to New Mexico
that spring when she was 16?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she meet Ghislaine Maxwell when she arrived
in New Mexico?"
A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "How did she describe Maxwell's demeanor and
attitude when she met her?"

A. "She described Maxwell as being very charming.
She gave her a tour of the house, and Maxwell took
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0O00O275
03/29/2021 94
shopping which made her feel special."

Q. "What does she remember talking about with
Ghislaine Maxwell?"
A. "They talked about school, homework, trips."

Q. "Did she talk with her about applying to college?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she talk about her classes in high school?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she talk with her about the homework that she
had to do that weekend?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she talk with Maxwell about her family?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she talk with her about her home life and
living with her mother?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "From what told you, when she got there, who
else was at the ranch besides Ghislaine Maxwell and
Jeffrey Epstein?"

A. "It was just them."
Q. "Was it just the three of them there the entire
weekend of the visit?"
A. "Yes."

Q. "Were there any other school kids there?"
A. "No."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000276
03/29/2021 55

Q. "When they were at the ranch, from what to_
you, did Maxwell say anything to about massages?"
A. "Yes."

Q. "Did she say anything about -- to her about foot
massages?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "What did tell you about that?"

A. "Maxwell told to give Epstein a foot massage
and then showed her and instructed her on how to do it.
was a little uncomfortable, but Maxwell was joking
around so she just followed her lead."

Q. "Did tell you what Maxwell and
Epstein -- took her to the movies that weekend?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "What did she tell you about that trip to the
movies?"

A. "She said that when they went outside the theatre
Maxwell was joking around and pulled Epstein's pants down a
little bit. And then once they went inside the theatre,
Epstein, when they were sitting down, touched 's leg,
and rubbed her arm, held her hand. And that this time
he -- felt -- he wasn't trying to hide it from
Maxwell.

Q. "What was 's reaction to all of this?"
A. "She was uncomfortable."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000277
03/29/2021

Q. "During the same weekend was there another
occasion when Maxwell talked about massages?"
A.
Q.
"Yes."
"What happened?"

A. "Maxwell had asked if she had ever had a
massage, and Maxwell told her she could give her one.
was on her back, and Maxwell pulled the sheet down
exposing her chest; she was nude from the top up and
proceeded to massage around her chest and breast area."

Q. "From what told you when she was describing
to you what you just described to the grand jury, how did
she feel while this was happening?"

A. "She felt really uncomfortable."
Q. "Did also tell you about an incident that
happened one morning when she was in New Mexico?"

A. "Yes."
4. "What did she tell you happened?"
A. "She said that she was in bed, and Epstein came
into the room and told her that he wanted to cuddle. So he
laid down next to her and spooned her. She told him that
she had to go to the bathroom to get out of the situation."

Q. "What was her reaction to that, when Epstein got
into her bed?"
do."
A. "She felt uncomfortable. She didn't know what to
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJKOMY278
03/29/2021

Q. "Did go back home to when the
weekend was over?"
A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Did she tell anyone, when she got home, about
what had happened?"

A. "No."
Q. "Is that for the same reason you described
earlier?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did Epstein end up paying for to go on
trip to Thailand that summer?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did have any contact with Maxwell or
Epstein after that trip?"
A. "Not that she recalled."

Q. "When you interviewed , what was her demeanor
like when she described her interactions with
Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell?"

A. "She became upset and emotional."
Q. "Is currently pursuing a civil lawsuit
against Maxwell and Epstein's estate?"

A. "Yes, she is."
Q. "What does do for a living now?"
A. "She's a psychologist who works with trauma
victims."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000279
03/29/2021 58
1 Q. "During the course of this investigation have you
2 interviewed someone named
3 A. "Yes."
4 Q. "For today's purposes I'm just going to refer to
5 her as . How many times have you interviewed
6 , approximately?"
7 A. "Approximately three times."
8 Q. "Turning to the next slide. Is this a photograph
9 of that she provided to you?"
10 A. "Yes."
11 Q. "And did she tell you that this was taken when she
12 was in -- approximately 16 or 17 years old?"
13 A. "Yes."
14 Q. "Is 's date of birth
15 A. "Yes."
16 Q. "Did grow up in England?"
17 A. "Yes, she did."
18 Q. "Did she tell you that there came a point where
19 she met Ghislaine Maxwell when she was about 17?"
20 A. "Yes."
21 Q. "How did she tell you that they met?"
22 A. "She said they met through a mutual friena."
23 Q. "Did she tell you that this would have happened in
24 around 1994 or 1995?"
25 A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000280
03/29/2021 59

Q. "And is that within the same time period that
we've been talking about today?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "What happened after she was introduced to
Ghislaine Maxwell, from what she told you?"

A. "She said Maxwell treated her like they were
sisters. Her quote was 'like naughty school girls' is how
Maxwell treated with her."

Q. "Did she tell you that Maxwell seemed to
immediately take an interest in her?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she tell you that they began spending time
together in London?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And just to be clear was Maxwell in her thirties
while this is happening?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did Maxwell -- did ever remember Maxwell
ever talking about having a boyfriend named
Jeffrey Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "What did she tell about that?"
A. "Maxwell told that Epstein was going to
like her."
Q. "Did there come a time when she was 17 that
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJX0000281
03/29/2021 rn
described that Maxwell introduced her to
Jeffrey Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "How did she describe that occurring?"
A. "Epstein had flown into London. He was at
Maxwell's residence in London, and Maxwell had called
over. So went over, and when she got there
Maxwell was saying to Epstein, kind of -- the words
used was -- giving him a resume of her attributes, saying,
she's so pretty, she's so strong; and then Maxwell asked hel
to give Epstein a massage."

Q. "Now you've testified just a moment ago that
Maxwell -- that described to you that Maxwell asked
her to give Epstein a massage during this first meeting, is
that correct?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did Maxwell state to her, in sum and substance,
since you're so strong, I'd appreciate it if you'd give
Jeffrey a massage because he needs a massage every day or I
get in trouble?"

A. "Yes, she said that."
Q. "Is that what said to you, in sum and
substance?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "When that happened did remember Maxwell
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000282
03/29/2021 1!
leading her to a room in the house?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "When
what happened?"
A. "When
went in the room -- oh excuse m(
went in the room Epstein was in
robe. He took off his robe, and she started massaging him.
And then he touched and pulled her hand to his
penis."

Q. "What does
did this?"
A. "Don't be frigid."
Q. "What was her reaction to this happening, from
what she told you?"

A. "She was taken back by it."
Q. "When this episode ended and left the
remember Epstein saying when he
room, did she tell that she remembered Maxwell being just
outside the room when she left?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she remember Maxwell saying to her, did you
have fun? Did he like it?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Does she remember Maxwell calling her several
Jays afterwards, or at some short period of time
afterwards?"

A. "Yes, she did."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDN Y_00000283
03/29/2021 62

Q. "Did remember Maxwell saying to her on the
phone call, in sum and substance, well, aren't you a clever
girl, Jeffrey was very impressed?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Shortly after this incident does she remember
Maxwell asking her to come back over to the house?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And when she got there did she tell you she
remembered Maxwell saying to her, in substance, thank God
you're here, if it's not you or someone else it falls to
me?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Does she remember Maxwell bringing her up the
stairs to the house on that occasion?"
A. "Yes, she did."

Q. "What does she remember happening when Maxwell
opened the door to the room?"
A. "Epstein was standing there nude."

Q. "Does she remember Maxwell then saying, I'll leave
you guys to it?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "After these first two encounters, did Epstein and
Maxwell invite to travel with them to
Palm Beach, U.S. Virgin Islands, Paris, and New York, for
the next several years?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000284
03/29/2021 63

A. "Yes, they did."
Q. "Does she remember whether these trips began
before or after her 18th birthday?"

A. "She couldn't remember specifically."
Q. "Before these trips started, you were describing
earlier when told you about the time she spent with
Maxwell when they first met, when she was 17, is that right?

A. "Yes."
Q. "During these conversations when she would spend
time with Maxwell, did remember talking with her
about her life, and her family, and her personal
circumstances, with Maxwell?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Now you testified a moment ago that told
you that at some point she began travelling with Maxwell and
Epstein, and she wasn't sure whether or not these trips
started before she turned 18, is that right?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did describe to you that Epstein sexually
abused her during these trips, typically in the context of a
sexualized massage?"

A. "Yes, he did."
Q. "Did Epstein give her money?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she tell you that he would give her cash?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000285
03/29/2021 64

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she describe to you that the abuse included,
among other things, Epstein groping her and using a massager
device on her genitals?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And was the massager device like a vibrator?"
A. "Yes, it was."
Q. "From what told you, was Maxwell in the
room during these encounters?"

A. "Maxwell wasn't in the room."
Q. "What did she tell you would typically happen when
left the room after these episodes; was Maxwell
typically nearby?"

A. "Yes. She was usually right near the room."
Q. "Does she remember Maxwell asking her, after she'd
leave the room from one of these sessions, how was it; is he
happy?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did she also tell you that she remembers Maxwell
telling her at some point, in sum and substance, you know
how he is when he's not happy, and you know what makes him
happy; he has to have sex all the time; he's like a super
hero?"

A. "Yes, she said that."
Q. "Did tell you about an incident that
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000286
03/29/2021 65
occurred, after she turned 18, in Palm Beach when she was
staying at the Palm Beach house?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did the incident she described to you involve a
school-girl outfit?"
A. "Yes, it did."
Q. "Could you please describe for the grand jury what
told you about that incident?"

A. said that Maxwell had shown her a bedroom
and upon the bed was a school-girl outfit. Maxwell had told
her -- when confronted her about it -- and Maxwell
said, well, I thought it would be adorable if you gave
Jeffrey his tea in this; so felt like she had to put
it on. And so she put it on, took Epstein his tea, and
Epstein then slapped her on the buttocks and reached under
the skirt and touched her."

Q. "What was her demeanor like when she described
this incident to you?"
A. "She was crying. She was very upset."

Q. "When described seeing the school-girl
outfit and talking to Maxwell about it, did she remember
Maxwell telling her, don't be so frigid?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Does she remember that later in the day, after
she had delivered Epstein his tea and he assaulted her, does
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000287
03/29/2021 66
she remember Maxwell telling her, I heard you did well?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "During the years that was in contact with
Maxwell and Epstein, did she remember whether Maxwell had
ever asked her if she knew any other girls who could massage
Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Does she remember Maxwell saying, in sum and
substance, do you know anyone who could give him a blowjob
today, I don't feel like it?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Does she remember Maxwell saying, when she asked
her to bring other girls, that they have to look young at
least?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "From your conversations with , did she
tell you whether or not she ever brought any other girls?"
A.
'"'I'll didn't bring any girls."

Q. "Did she tell you why not?"
A. "She didn't want anyone else to go through that."
Q. "From your interviews with , did she tell
you that there came a time, when she was in her early
twenties, when she stopped travelling with Maxwell and
Epstein?"

A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJX000288
03/29/2021 67

Q. "Was she struggling with substance abuse at that
point?"
A. "Yes, she was."
Q. "Did she tell you that she got sober in her
twenties?"

A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "What is her current profession?"
A. "She runs a non-profit for people who struggle
with addiction and trauma."

Q. "Did provide you with several emails that
she exchanged with Epstein in the early 2000s?"
A. "Yes, she did."

Q. "And were those emails very friendly in tone?"
A. "Yes, they were."
4• "What did she say to you when you talked with her
about those emails?"

A. "She said she didn't, at the time, want to
acknowledge what was going on to her. That looking
back -- on -- it's different."

Q. "Did your squad at the FBI execute a search
warrant at Jeffrey Epstein's townhouse in Manhattan in July
of 2019?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Did you personally participate in the search of
Epstein's residence?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000289
03/29/2021 6P

A. "Yes, I did."
Q.
A.
"Did the townhouse include a massage room?"
"Yes."
Q. "Have you yourself been in that massage room?"

A. "Yes, I have."
Q. "Could you please describe for the grand jury what
that massage room looked like?"

A. "It was dark. It had dark draperies covering the
windows. There was a massage table; there were oils, there
was a handheld massager in there; along with handcuffs, a
whip, and along with -- walls were nude photographs of young
females."

Q. "I believe you testified a moment ago that
told you that there was a time when Maxwell
asked her to wear a school-girl outfit for Epstein when they
were in Palm Beach. Did you find a school-girl outfit in
Epstein's New York townhouse?"

A. "Yes, we did."
Q. "Where did you find it?"
A. "It was found in a room next to the massage room."
Q. "And to be clear did the FBI find sex toys during
the search?"
A.
Q.
"Yes."
"What was found?"

A. "Butt plugs, dildo, and vibrators."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0O00O29O
03/29/2021 69

Q. "We've talked about three minor girls today;
, is that right?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Have you reviewed the proposed indictment marked
Grand Jury Exhibit 1?"

A. "Yes, I have."
Q. "Is the individual referred to as Victim 1
in the proposed indictment?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Is the individual referred to as Victim 2
in the proposed indictment?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Is the individual referred to as Victim 3
in the indictment?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "During all of Maxwell's interactions with the
victims when they were underage girls, based on the
timeframe and your knowledge of Maxwell's birthdate, was she
in her thirties?"

A. "Yes, she was."
Q. "Just one moment. All right. Switching gears.
Have you become aware that in or about 2016 Maxwell gave
sworn testimony in a civil deposition in connection with a
lawsuit?"

A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJX000291
03/29/2021 70

Q. "Could you please explain for the grand jury, what
is a deposition?"
A. "It is a statement made under oath."

Q. "And in the course of civil litigation is it
common for witnesses or parties of the lawsuit to give a
deposition, under oath, where they testify about the
substance of the case?"

A. " Yes. "
Q. "And is deposition testimony live, and in-person,
and under oath?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "Is a court reporter present when a deposition
takes place?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Now before we talk about Maxwell's deposition
testimony, I want to talk to you about the lawsuit that the
testimony was about. Have you become aware that in or about
2015 an individual named filed a lawsuit
against Ghislaine Maxwell here in the Southern District of
New York?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And was suing Maxwell for defamation?"
A. "Yes, she was."
Q. "Was the lawsuit captioned
against Ghislaine Maxwell, the docket number 15CB 7433, here
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. a Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0000029.2
03/29/2021 71
in the Southern District of New York?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Generally speaking, in broader strokes, what was
the lawsuit about; what was the claim that was
bringing against Maxwell?"
WITNESS. I'm sorry. What line are we on again?

MS. Page 68, line 4.
WITNESS. had stated that she had been
sexually abused by Epstein and Maxwell as a minor. Maxwell
came forward publically and called her a liar, so
sued her for defamation."
BY MS.

Q. "So just a small legal instruction on this topic.
Ladies and gentlemen, I instruct you that the allegations in
the lawsuit are not being presented to you as evidence that
those incidents occurred. I instruct you that you should
not consider those allegations for their truth. Instead,
the circumstances of the lawsuit are being presented to you
so that you can consider the context of the case and the
circumstances under which Maxwell made statements under
oath. Turning back to the deposition, did Maxwell's
deposition take place over two different days?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "On both days does she give testimony in
Manhattan?"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJNI0Nn93
03/29/2021 12

A. "Yes, she did."
Q. "Is that where the deposition took place?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "And on both days was Maxwell sworn under oath?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "If you could flip through the remaining slides of
the presentation, do those slides contain true and accurate
excerpts of the transcript of that deposition?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Turning to the next slide, is this the cover page
of the transcript of the first deposition that took place on
April 22, 2016?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And does it have the case caption on it?"
A. "Yes, it does."
Q. "Turning to the next slide. Is this an excerpt
from the transcript?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "I imagine the grand jurors can't read it from
their seats so if you could read it with me, I'll read the
questions, and if you could read the answers."
"'Did Jeffrey Epstein have a scheme to recruit
underage girls for underage massages?'"

MS. And it appears there was an objection
from the lawyer.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000294
03/29/2021
BY MS.

Q. "'If you know.'"
A. "'I don't know what you are talking about. '"
Q. "Just to be clear, was the question and
answer is the answer here Maxwell's testimony?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Just to be clear you testified earlier that
participated in sexualized massages with Epstein and
Maxwell, is that right?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And was a minor when that occurred?"
A. "Yes."
Q. "And did you also testify earlier that
Maxwell -- that told you that Maxwell
asked her to give Epstein massages when she was a minor?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "If you could turn to the next slide please. Is
this another excerpt from that same deposition?"

A. "Yes, it is."
Q. "All right. I'll read the question and you can
read the answer."
"'Was all the people, under the age of 18 that
you've interacted at with, at any of Jeffrey Epstein's
properties?'"

A. "'I'm not aware of anybody that I interacted with,
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000295
03/29/2021 74
other than, obviously, who was 17 at this point.'"

Q. "Just to be clear, you testified earlier about two
girls under the age of 18 who interacted with Maxwell at
Epstein's properties, is that correct?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And those individuals were and
who told you that, correct?"
A. "Yes, that's correct."
Q. "Turning to the next slide. Is this the cover
page of the transcript from the deposition that took place
on July 22, 2016?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And again, was this Maxwell giving testimony as
part of the testimony under oath here in Manhattan?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "If you could please turn to the next slide. Is
that an excerpt -- are these two excerpts from that
deposition?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Again, I'll read the questions, if you could
please read the answers."
"'Were you aware of the presence of sex toys or
devices used in sexual activities in Mr. Epstein's
Palm Beach house?'"

MS. There is an objection from the
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000296
03/29/2021 75
lawyer.
WITNESS. "'No, no. Not that I recall.'"
BY MS.

Q. "'Do you know whether Mr. Epstein possessed sex
toys or devices used in sexual activities?'"
MS. There's an objection from the lawyer.
WITNESS. "'No."
BY MS.

Q. "Just to be clear you testified earlier that
told you he found sex toys and a massager in
Palm Beach and also that he had seen Maxwell had a basket of
sex toys in her closet there, is that correct?"

A. "Yes, that's correct."
Q. "And is it correct you testified earlier that
Epstein used a vibrator on , is that correct?"

A. "Yes, that's correct."
Q. "And did you also testify earlier that
told you he did that as well?"
A. "Yes, that's correct."

Q. "And did you also testify earlier that sex toys
were found by the police in the Palm Beach house in 2005, is
that right?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And did you also testify earlier that the FBI
found sex toys in Epstein's New York City townhouse in
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000297
03/29/2021 76
2019?"

A. "Yes, that's correct."
Q. "If you could please turn to the next slide. This
is on Page 27. It says, are these also excerpts from that
same deposition?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Again, I'll read the questions if you could
please read the answers."
4. "'Other than yourself, and the blonde and brunette
that you have identified as having been involved in
three-way sexual activities, with whom did Mr. Epstein have
sexual activities?'"

MS. There's an objection from the lawyer.
WITNESS. "'I wasn't aware that he was having
sexual activities with anyone when I was with him, other
than myself.'"
BY MS.

Q. "'I want to be sure that I'm clear. Is it your
testimony that in the 1990s and 2000s you were not aware
that Mr. Epstein was having sexual activities with anyone
other than yourself and the blonde and brunette on those few
occasions when they were involved with you?'"

A. "'That is my testimony. That is correct.'"
Q. "Have you reviewed the deposition transcript?"
A. "Yes."
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNLGUDNYJNI00O298
03/29/2021

Q. "In full? Now the excerpt we just read has the
reference to a blonde and a brunette. Are those individuals
completely different from the individuals we've been talking
about today?"

A. "Yes."
4• "Just to be clear, is it correct that you
testified earlier that and told you that
Epstein sexually abused them repeatedly, is that correct?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "And did you also testify earlier that Maxwell was
occasionally present when Epstein was abusing , based
on what she told you?"

A. "Yes, that's correct."
Q. "Turning to the next slide. Is this also an
excerpt from the same deposition?"

A. "I'm sorry?"
Q. "I'm so sorry. Turning to the next slide, on
Page 28. Is this also an excerpt from the same deposition?"

A. "Yes."
Q. "Thank you. Okay. Again, if we could read that
together. I'll take the question and you can take the
answer."

Q. "'Let's just tie that down. Is it your testimony
that you've never given anybody a massage?'"
A. "'I've not given anyone a massage.'"
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000299
03/29/2021 78

Q. "'You never gave Mr. Epstein a massage? Is that
your testimony?'"
A. "'That is my testimony.'"
Q. "'You never gave a massage? Is that
your testimony?'"

A. "'I never gave a massage.'"
Q. "Just to be clear, as you testified earlier, is it
correct that told you that Maxwell gave her a
massage when they were in New Mexico?"

A. "Yes."
MS. We're going to stop the read back
there. Ladies and gentlemen, let's take a five minute break
and we'll come back to finish the presentation in about five
minutes. With the Foreperson's permission, I will ask that
the witness please be excused.
FOREPERSON. Yes, he may.

MS. Thank you.
(Witness Temporarily Excused)
(Time noted: 11:21 a.m.)
(Recess taken)
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0O00O30O
03/29/2021 79
(Colloquy Precedes)
(Witness Resumes)
(Time Noted: 11:34 a.m.)
BY MS.

Q. Welcome back, Detective.
A. Thank you.
Q. I have placed in front of you what has been marked
as Grand Jury Exhibit 5. Do you recognize that?

A. I do.
Q. Is this a PowerPoint presentation concerning some
of the facts and evidence that you have gathered in your
investigation?

A. Yes.
Q. Did you participate in preparing this Exhibit in
connection with your testimony today?
A. Yes.

Q. Will it assist you in testifying today?
A. Yes.
Q. Then we're going to have it up on the screen and
we'll use it as you testify. During the course of this
investigation have you participated in multiple interviews
with an individual named ?

A. Yes.
Q. Did those interviews take place in the year 2020
and the year 2021?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDN Y_000003 0 I
03/29/2021 80

A. Yes.
Q. Were there approximately five of those interviews
in total?
A. Yes.
Q. For today's purposes I'm going to refer to her as
Have you also reviewed reports from other law
enforcement interviews for

A. Yes.
Q. And is your testimony today based on both the
review of those reports and your personal participation in
interviews with

A. Yes.
Q. Turning to the next slide. Are these photographs
A. Yes.
Q. Did tell you approximately how old she was
in one of these photographs?

A. Yes.
Q. Which photograph did she identify?
A. The one on the right.
Q. Where is the one on the right from, according to

A. Oh, I'm sorry. That was from her MySpace page.
Q. And about how old did
photograph from her MySpace page?
recall being in this
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000302
03/29/2021 81

A. Sixteen years old.
Q. What is date of birth?
A.
Q. Where was living when she was about 14
/ears old?

A. West Palm Beach, Florida.
Q. What was home life like when she was 14
years old?
A. It was troubled. She grew up -- she had been
molested multiple times as a child. Her mother was addicted
to drugs and alcohol. Her parents were separated, she often
fought with her brother and her mother.

Q. When
boyfriend?
A. Yes.
Q.
when
A.
Q•
was 14 years old, did she have a
What was his name?
How old was
was 14 years old?
when they were dating

A. Approximately 17.
Q. So was about three years older than
A. Yes.
Q. Did there come a time when learned of and
met Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Yes.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. 6 Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000303
03/29/2021 82

Q. According to how did that happen?
A. Her boyfriend was friends with someone named
(ph) who was dating
The four of them would often hang out together.
On one particular occasion was asked by them and
if she would like to make some money by massaging
an older man.

Q. How did respond?
A. She agreed to do it.
Q. About what year does remember this
conversation taking place?

A. 2001.
Q. So how old was at that time?
A. Fourteen.
Q. During your investigation have you learned of
date of birth?

A. Yes.
Q• How old was
conversation with
guy?
at the time of the
in 2001, about massaging an old
A. Seventeen.

Q. After that conversation with
meet Epstein?
A. Yes.
Q. What did
did
remember happening the first time
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000304
03/29/2021 83
she met Epstein?

A. She was brought there by She recalls
going in through the side door and being introduced to
Maxwell as they entered.

Q. Based on her interactions with Maxwell, as she and
entered, what was understanding of
whether and Maxwell had met before?

A. She understood that they had met before.
Q. And did Maxwell, in substance, tell
show
up the
to
what to do?

A. Yes.
Q. What happened next?
A. They went upstairs to the massage room. They set
massage room, waited for Epstein to enter. At that
point they participated in giving him a massage.

Q. How did describe the massage room in the
Florida house?
A. She described it as having a few doors inside of
it, some of them entering a closet. She described there
being a -- it's like a bathroom, basically, that had a sink
inside of it. And inside of the closet had a massage table
which they had to take out in order to set it up.

Q. What, if any, photographs did recall
seeing in and around the massage room?
A. She recalls nude photographs of Maxwell.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDN Y_00000305
03/29/2021 84

Q. And of other females?
A. Yes.
Q. After and had set up the massage
table, what happened next?
A. Jeffrey Epstein came into the room; they massaged
him. At some point during the massage he turned over and
got on top. They had sex, and
couch and tried not to watch.

Q. According to did
Jeffrey Epstein
massage?
A. Yes.
Q.
A.
and they
Q. So to clarify, did
receive $300?

A. Yes.
Q.
sat on the
and
engage in sexual intercourse during that
At the end of the massage what happened?
Jeffrey left, they got dressed, and each got paid,
walked downstairs. They got paid $300 each.
and each
And how did they receive that money; in what
denomination?

A. Crisp one hundred dollar bills.
Q. After that first visit did go to Epstein's
Palm Beach residence on multiple occasions to provide
sexualized massages to Jeffrey Epstein between 2001 and
2004?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000306
03/29/2021 85

A. Yes.
Q. Approximately how many times does
she massaged Jeffrey Epstein?
A. About one hundred times.
estimate

Q. Do memories of the events at Epstein's
residence run together after that first visit with
A. Yes.
Q. At some point after her first or second visit to
Epstein's residence, did give her phone number to
someone at Epstein's house?

A. Yes.
Q. After that did go to Epstein's house by
herself without
A. Yes.
Q. After
accompanying her?
provided her phone number, how did
she schedule times to massage Epstein at his house?

A. She would either call herself or she would receive
a phone call.
Q. Did explain why she would call herself to
ask to schedule a time to massage Epstein?

A. Yes. At the time she wanted to make more money so
she could buy drugs.
Q. During her time seeing Epstein did become
addicted to certain drugs?

A. Yes.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDN Y_00000307
03/29/2021 og

Q. What drugs was she primarily using?
A. Cocaine and marijuana.
Q. When someone would call to schedule her
for massages with Epstein, who does remember making
those calls?

A. Maxwell or
Q. And were there particular time periods, over the
course of the years when was interacting with
Epstein, that one or the other of those two individuals
would call?

A. Yes.
Q. What did say about that?
A. She recalled that for the first several months of
going to Epstein she would get calls primarily from Maxwell.
After that, she would receive calls primarily from
but at the same time, occasionally receiving calls from
Maxwell.

Q. And did she also remember receiving calls from
other Epstein employees whose names did not know?
A. Yes.

Q. Did refer to Maxwell as Maxwell?
A. Yes.
4• And then you mentioned another person; what was
the other person's name?
A.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNYJX*0O308
03/29/2021 87

Q. And did she primarily refer to -- did
primarily refer to as
A. Yes.
Q. Who was , according to
A. She was another employee of Epstein's. She was an
assistant who made phone calls, arranged massage
appointments, and took photographs.

Q. When Maxwell would call to schedule
massage appointments with Epstein, did Maxwell ever tell
where Maxwell was calling from?

A. Yes.
Q. What did remember about that?
A. She recalls her saying that they were in New York,
and that they would be travelling to Florida at a certain
time period and asking if she would be available for that
time when they return.

Q. And when you
was referring
A. Epstein
Q. So did
say "they" would be in New York, who
to?
and Maxwell.
understand from these conversations
that Maxwell and Epstein, at the time of those phone calls,
were in New York?

A. Yes.
Q. What phone numbers would Epstein's employees call
to schedule appointments for to massage Epstein?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. 6 Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000309
03/29/2021 88

A. They would call multiple phone numbers, including
cell phone, her mother's phone, her landline, or
her home line, and her boyfriend 's phone.

Q. How did get to Epstein's residence for
each massage appointment?
A. She would either be driven by her boyfriend; she
would drive herself on occasion even though she did not have
a license; she had been driven there by
Epstein or
picked up.

Q. Did
Epstein's house?
A. Yes.
Q. What did
and also
Maxwell would send him send her a cab to be
boyfriend ever meet anyone at
remember about that?

A. She recalls that he met Epstein.
Q. What did she say about that?
A. He met in the driveway. There was a car that
Epstein was driving at the time and that he was showing to
And she recalls that really liked the car, and
she had to hear about him talking about the car for several
days to weeks after that.

Q. According to did ever meet any of
Epstein's employees?
A. No.
Q. When arrived at Epstein's house for each
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNI_GLSDNYJW10003M
03/29/2021 89
appointment, what happened when she first arrived?

A. She would arrive through the side door and
generally be greeted by someone.
Q. Would that be in the kitchen?

A. Yes.
Q. Does she recall, at times, Maxwell being the
person who would greet her in the kitchen?
A. Yes.

Q. After being greeted in the kitchen, what would
do next?
A. She would go upstairs and arrange the massage room
and the massage table.

Q. Once was in the massage room, what
happened during each appointment?
A. Epstein would generally come out, he would get on
the table. She would begin her massage. During the massage
he would flip over and she would generally play with
nipples. He would masturbate, he would touch her breasts
and buttocks, and she said that every instance ended with
Epstein ejaculating.

Q. What would be wearing during these
appointments?
A. At first she just started wearing her underwear
but was told that she would make more money to be completely
nude, so she started getting totally nude.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GNI_GLSDNYJOMI0311
was she -- did it become
during the massages?

A. Yes.
Q.
03/29/2021 90
Q. And so after her first few visits to Epstein's,
practice to be fully nude
On a few occasions during these massages did
Epstein touch vagina?

A. Yes.
Q. On one occasion does
touching her vagina with a vibrator?
A. Yes.
Q. And you mentioned that
recall Epstein
recalled each
massage ended with Epstein ejaculating; so is it
recollection that every single massage she performed for
Epstein involved a sex act?

A. Yes.
Q. After each massage, what happened?
A. Epstein would get up, would get dressed;
she would get paid. The money would generally be on the
table or on the sink, or she would go downstairs and be paid
by Maxwell.

Q. How much did recall being paid for each
massage?
A. Three hundred dollars.
Q. In what denomination?
A. One hundred dollar bills.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GALGLSDNY2M000312
03/29/2021 91

Q. You mentioned that would sometimes be
greeted by Maxwell when she arrived at Epstein's house.
Earlier on in her visits to Epstein's, would Maxwell engage
in conversation?

A. Yes.
Q. And then later on, after started primarily
being the person to schedule these appointments, would
Maxwell still be present sometimes?

A. Yes.
Q. But during those later periods would Maxwell
primarily just say hello and not really have extended
conversations with

A. Yes.
Q. During the earlier period when was going
over to Epstein's Palm Beach house, what types of
conversations does she recall having with Maxwell?

A. She talked with Maxwell about her home life. She
talked with Maxwell about her abuse that occurred when she
was younger. She recalled Maxwell asking about her sexual
experiences that she's had. She recalled Maxwell asking her
if she used a vibrator or a toy ever on herself.

Q. Did she also recall conversations about travel?
A. Yes.
Q. I'd like to go through each of those topics that
recalled discussing. First, what did
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
tell
GM_Gl_SDNY_000003B
03/29/2021 92
Maxwell about home life in response to Maxwell's
questions?

A. She told her that she -- her mother was addicted
to drugs and that she had been molested several times as a
child.

Q. Did she also tell Maxwell that the parents were
separated?
A. Yes.
Q. You also mentioned sexual topics coming up. What
does recall about the time or times when sexual
topics came up with Maxwell?

A. Maxwell has asked her if she was sexually active.
had told her that she's currently sexually active
with her boyfriend. Maxwell asked her if she'd ever used a
toy to pleasure herself, and she had said no.

Q. Did recall that, the same day that Maxwell
asked about whether she ever used a toy, was the day that
Epstein placed a vibrator on genitals during the
massage?

A. Yes.
Q. What did recall about conversations with
Maxwell about travel?
A. She recalls that on multiple occasions Maxwell
asked her if she wanted to travel, specifically, overseas.
She had told her that she was 14 years old and that her
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. 6 Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000314
03/29/2021
mother wouldn't let her. Maxwell offered to get her a
passport so she would be able to travel.

Q. When you said "she had told her that she was
14 years old," did you mean that told Maxwell that
was 14 years old?

A. Yes.
Q. Does recall that these conversations took
place when she was about 14 years old?
A. Yes.
Q. Does recall Maxwell saying specifically
where Maxwell wanted to travel with Epstein?

A. No.
Q. Did Epstein ever invite to travel with
him?
A. Yes.
Q. What did remember about that?
A. They were similar conversations where she had
told -- he had asked her if she would like to travel and
said that had also travelled with him. She
had told him that she was 14 and, likely, her mother
wouldn't let her travel. He had also offered to get her
passport.

Q. Did ever actually travel with Maxwell or
Epstein?
A. No.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000315
03/29/2021 94

Q. After told Maxwell and Epstein that she
was 14 years old, did Maxwell still call her to schedule
massage appointments for Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. Did still see Maxwell at the Palm Beach
residence after telling Maxwell that she was 14 years old?

A. Yes.
Q. Did Maxwell ever see naked?
A. Yes.
Q. In particular does recall that there were
between one and three times when Maxwell saw her naked?

A. Yes.
Q. How did that happen, according to
A. It happened in the massage room.
Q. And was there one time, in particular, when
recalls Maxwell touching her while was
naked?

A. Yes.
Q. What did remember about that?
A. She recalls being in the massage room undressing;
Maxwell complimented her body and then asked if her breasts
were real, at which point, she touched her breasts.

Q. And when you say "she touched her breasts," do you
mean Maxwell touched
A. Yes.
breasts?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000316
03/29/2021 0,5

Q. And on those occasions, just to be clear,
according to why was she getting undressed in the
massage room when Maxwell was present?

A. For getting prepared for the massage with
Jeffrey Epstein.
Q. Other than during her first visit or two with
did ever participate in massages with
Epstein during which another female was in the room?

A. Yes.
4• In particular does she recall two occasions when
Epstein brought another girl into the room?

A. Yes.
Q. Would you please describe for the grand jury what
recalled about one such occasion?
A. She recalled that the girl looked like a model.
She recalls at one point during the massage Jeffrey Epstein
attempted to have sex with her; he slightly penetrated her
at least once or twice, that she can recall; she told him
no, at which point he began to have sex with the other
female and at the same time she was performing oral on

Q. Now just to clarify some of the pronouns there.
You said that Epstein attempted to penetrate, or have sexual
intercourse, with her; do you mean that recalls that
Epstein attempted to penetrate vagina with his
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000317
03/29/2021 q6
penis?

A. Yes.
Q. Does recall Epstein attempting to do that
and actually inserting his penis into her vagina on one or
two occasions?

A. Yes.
Q. And in response, did say no?
A. Yes.
Q. And in response to that did Epstein then engage in
sexual intercourse with the other girl?

A. Yes.
4• And at the same time was the other girl performing
oral sex on
A. Yes.
Q. Was there another instance where Epstein brought a
different girl into the room?

A. Yes.
Q. What did remember happening during that
other instance?
A. Similar instance where Epstein would have sex with
the other female at the same time while she was performing
oral on

Q. So Epstein would have intercourse with the other
girl and the other girl would perform oral sex on
A. Yes.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0O00O318
03/29/2021 97

Q. Did ever bring other girls to massage
Epstein?
A. Yes.
Q. Why did she do that?
A. She was told she could earn more money.

Q. Who told her, or asked her, to bring other girls?
A. Both Jeffrey and Maxwell.
Q. What, in particular, did they ask her to do?

A. They asked if she could bring younger girls.
Q. Did in fact, bring multiple girls over to
Epstein's house?

A. Yes.
Q. Can she remember the name of every girl that she
brought over?
A. No.
4• Are there some examples of names that she
remembers of girls that brought over?

A. Yes.
4• What are some examples?
A. (ph) and
Q. According to
A. Yes.
Q.
older than
And according to

was younger than
was about a year
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000319
03/29/2021 OR

A. Yes.
Q. When brought these girls would Epstein
engage in sex acts, in the presence of both and the
girls she had brought, during the massage?

A. Yes.
Q. After each massage would both and the girl
get paid?
A. Yes.
Q. How much did remember them getting paid?

A. Three hundred dollars.
Q. So did each, and the girl, get $300?
A. Yes.
Q. Did receive any gifts from Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. What's an example of some gifts that she remembers
receiving from Epstein?
A. Flowers, a book called "Massage for Dummies," and
Victoria's Secret underwear.

Q. Does she recall receiving multiple packages of
Victoria's Secret lingerie?
A. Yes.
Q. Before she first received Victoria's Secret
lingerie, did Maxwell ask her for her address and her bra
size?

A. Yes.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000320
03/29/2021 99

Q. How does remember receiving packages
Victoria's Secret underwear?
A. She recalls receiving them at her house in West
Palm Beach.

Q. And how would they get to her house?
A. Either FedEx or UPS.
Q. What, if anything, does remember about the
return address on those packages?

A. She recalls that they stated they were from New
York.
Q. Does she remember whose name was on the return
address?

A. She recalls Jeffrey's and Maxwell's name.
Q. What did do with the money she made
massaging Epstein?
A. She used it to purchase drugs.

Q. Did she and her boyfriend then use those drugs?
A. Yes.
Q. Did continue going to school after she met
Jeffrey Epstein?

A. No.
Q. About how old was she when she dropped out?
A. About 14.
Q. Was she in middle school when she dropped out?

A. Yes.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNYJMONB21
03/29/2021 100

Q. So did ever attend high school?
A. No.
Q. In or about 2003 did become pregnant with
her boyfriend
A. Yes.

Q. Did continue to massage Epstein after she
became pregnant, until she began showing her pregnancy?
A. Yes.

Q. Did give birth to her son in 2004, when
was about 17 years old?
A. Yes.
Q. After the birth of her son did
massage Epstein on a small number of occasions?

A. Yes.
Q. What did tell you about that?
A. She was doing it to -- excuse me -- support her
baby.
Q. Was that because she needed the money?

A. Yes.
Q. Have you reviewed the proposed superseding
indictment marked Grand Jury Exhibit 6?
A. It's not in front of me right now, but I have
reviewed it.

Q. Have you reviewed the proposed superseding
indictment or would you like me to provide you with a copy?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000322
03/29/2021

A. Yes, I reviewed it.
Q. Is the individual referred to as
Minor Victim 4 in the proposed superseding indictment?

A. Yes.
Q. Before you began investigating Epstein and his
associates was there a prior investigation by a different
FBI office in Florida into Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. During that investigation was interviewer
in 2007?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you reviewed a report from that interview?

A. Yes.
Q. During that interview did describe
providing numerous paid sexualized massages to Epstein at
his Palm Beach residence when she was underage?

A. Yes.
Q. Did mention Maxwell at all during that
interview?
A. No.
Q. During your more recent interviews with her in
2021 did explain why she did not mention Maxwell
during her 2007 interview?

A. Yes.
Q. What did she say about that?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000323
03/29/2021

A. She was not asked.
Q. She was not asked about Maxwell?
A. Correct.
Q. Did she think that Maxwell was important to the
interview in 2007?

A. No.
Q. Did sue Jeffrey Epstein in approximately
2008?
A. Yes.
Q.
2009?
Was she deposed, as part of that law suit, in

A. Yes.
Q. Have you reviewed a transcript of that deposition?
A. Yes.
Q. During that deposition in 2009 did state
that Maxwell was one of the people who would call her to
schedule massage appointments with Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. Was asked any other questions about
Maxwell, or any follow-up questions about Maxwell, during
that 2009 deposition?

A. No.
Q. After that deposition did the law suit settle?
A. Yes.
Q. During her more recent interviews did
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000324
03/29/2021 103
admit that she lied during her 2009 deposition?

A. Yes.
Q. And in particular, in her 2021 interviews did
tell you that after she stopped seeing Epstein she
began working for an escort service?

A. Yes.
Q. During her 2021 interviews did admit that,
as part of that escort service, she engaged in paid sex acts
with men?

A. Yes.
Q. Now, during her 2009 deposition was asked
about her time working for an escort service?
A. Yes.

Q. Did she lie and claim that she had engaged in no
sex acts and only non-sexual dates as part of that escort
service?

A. Yes.
Q. Did she explain why she lied during her
deposition?
A. Yes.
Q. What did she say about that?
A. She was embarrassed.

Q. Was she ashamed to admit that she had worked as a
prostitute, during her deposition?
A. Yes.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000325
03/29/2021 104

Q. Has struggled with drug addiction in the
years since her time with Epstein?
A. Yes.
Q. Did she, in particular, become addicted to cocaine
and crack cocaine?

A. Yes.
Q. Was she also in a car crash after which she was
prescribed opioids?
A. Yes.
Q. And did she become addicted to opioids?

A. Yes.
Q. Between the ages of 18 and 26 was arrested
and convicted, on multiple times including misdemeanors and
felonies, for crimes arising out of her drug use, such as
drug possession and traffic violations?

A. Yes.
Q. Was her last felony an incident involving stolen
property when she pawned an Xbox that belonged to one of
's friends?

A. Yes.
Q. As a result of that conviction did spend
several weeks in jail?
A. Yes.
Q. And was that the longest jail sentence she had
ever served?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000326
03/29/2021
1 A. Yes.

Q. After was released from that jail sentence
did she go into drug treatment and obtain mental health
treatment?

A. Yes.
Q. Was that several years ago?
A. Yes.
Q. What does do now?
A. She's a stay-at-home mother.
Q. Is she married?

A. Yes.
Q. To someone other than
A. Yes.
Q. Does she have three young children with her
current husband?

A. Yes.
Q. Does he work while she takes care of the kids?
A. Yes.
Q. Has received treatment for depression,
anxiety, PTSD, and schizophrenia, among other mental health
issues?

A. Yes.
Q. As for her schizophrenia, does that manifest in
hearing voices telling her that someone's going to
take her children away and hurt her children?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000327
03/29/2021

A. Yes.
Q. Does believe that that comes from a fear
that what happened to her as a child could happen to her
children?

A. Yes.
Q. Is able to tell the difference between
those voices and reality?
A. Yes.
Q. Does she take medication to help her not hear
those voices?

A. Yes.
Q. Does currently take multiple medications
to help her manage her drug addiction and her mental health
issues?

A. Yes.
Q. Do those include Methadone, Xanax, and medical
marijuana?
A. Yes.
Q. Is currently, or has she ever, sued
Maxwell?

A. No.
Q. Does she have any plans to do so?
A. No.
Q. Have you identified evidence that corroborates
account of her time interacting with Epstein and
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000328
03/29/2021 107
Maxwell?

A. Yes.
Q. Did you interview
A. Yes.
Q. What is the current nature of
ex-boyfriend,
and
relationship?
A. They have a child in common, and they talk very
minimally just because they have a child in common.

Q. So do they only speak when necessary to discuss
their teenage son?
A. Yes.
Q. According to were he and
dating when was about 14 years old and was
about 17 years old?

A. Yes.
Q. Did remember that he, and
and would hang out around
that time?
A. Yes.
Q. What di' recall about how came to
meet Jeffrey Epstein?

A. He recalls that the four of them were hanging out,
and they had mentioned --
Lo them that
and had mentioned
could go to massage an old man and she
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000329
03/29/2021 108
would be paid money in return for that.

Q. After that what does remember happening?
A. He recalls that went to Epstein's house,
with to do the massage.

Q. Did recall bringing to Epstein's
Palm Beach residence on multiple occasions?
A. Yes.
Q. Did remember receiving phone calls to
schedule appointments for to massage Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. What, if anything, did remember about
meeting Jeffrey Epstein?
A. He recalls meeting him at his house Epstein's
house; he recalls that Epstein was there with his car, and
he was showing off his car; he recalls that Epstein was
flashy.

Q. What, if anything, did remember
saying about Maxwell?
A. He recalls that said Maxwell was rude and
nasty and that she was supposed to be teaching her how to do
massages.

Q. What did remember doing with the money that
received from Epstein?
A. They purchased drugs; and
Q. and would purchase drugs?
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000330
03/29/2021 109

A. Yes.
Q. What did understand was happening when
was at Epstein's Palm Beach residence?
A. He understood that she was going in there to give
massages to Epstein but felt that there may have also been
something else going on.

Q. What did remember about bringing
other girls to Epstein's residence?
A. He recalls that she had brought other girls.

Q. Did he remember that both and the other
girls would get paid for going to Epstein's house?
A. Yes.
Q. Turning to the next slide. During the prior
investigation into Epstein did the other FBI office obtain
certain Federal Express records regarding Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. Was there one in particular from October of 2002
that is up on the slide right now?
A. Yes.
Q. Would you please walk the grand jury through what
we see on this slide?

A. Sure. On the left-hand side it says, picked up
October 7th of 2002. The sender's address is on the bottom.
In the middle it says, Jeffrey E. Epstein; his address is
457 Madison Avenue, New York, New York. It was sent
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0000033 I
03/29/2021
to -- the recipient being --

Q. And is name spelled instead CL
in the recipient column?
A. Yes.
Q. And the 457 Madison Avenue address, is that in
Manhattan?

A. Yes.
Q. How old was on October 7, 2002?
A. Fifteen.
Q. Have you interviewed a man named
A. Yes.
Q. Is that the same man about whom we read back
testimony from Special Agent earlier today?

A. Yes.
Q. To remind the grand jury, did work for
Epstein in the 1990s and early 2000s at Epstein's Palm Beach
residence?

A. Yes.
Q. Did recall meeting
A. Yes.
Q. What did remember about how he first met
A. He recalls driving Maxwell to a massage
appointment at Mar-a-Lago. He was told to wait in the car
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000332
03/29/2021 111
while she got her massage. When she was done she got in the
car and they started leaving the property. At some point
during that drive, while still on the property, she was --
asked him to stop. She got out of the car and approached a
female who was wearing a uniform at the time. Maxwell spoke
to that female for about 20 minutes, and Mr. could
not hear the conversation. Maxwell then got back in the car
and drove back to Epstein's house. Shortly thereafter,
later that day, that same girl arrived at the house. She
soon became a regular at the house, and learned --
later learned -- her name to be

Q. And when said that became
a regular at the house, what was understanding of
why was coming to Epstein's Palm Beach
residence?

A. To give Epstein massages.
Q. Turning to the next slide. Have you reviewed
flight records for Jeffrey Epstein's private jet?

A. Yes.
Q. Do those show multiple flights that
was on when she was under the age of 18?
A. Yes.
Q. Was Maxwell present for some of those flights with

A. Yes.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000333
03/29/2021 112

Q. Are two such flights reflected on this slide?
A. Yes.
Q. I'd like to ask you to please walk the grand jury
through those two flight records.

A. On December 11th and December 14th of 2000, you
can see all the way at the bottom of the page, on the
left-hand side it's marked 11 and 14; the first flight goes
from PBI to Teterboro, which is Palm Beach in Florida and
Teterboro is in New Jersey. On that flight was Epstein,
Maxwell, and among others. The next
flight, on the 14th, goes from Teterboro to the
Virgin Islands. On that flight is Epstein, Maxwell,
among others.

Q. Based on your understanding of
date of birth, how old was on these two flights?
A. Seventeen.
Q. Turning to the next slide. Does this slide show
three additional flights that took with
Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell when she was 17 years
old?

A. Yes.
Q. Would you please walk the grand jury through these
three flights?
A. Sure. The first flight is January 26, 2001. On
that flight is Jeffrey Epstein, Maxwell, and
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0O00O334
03/29/2021 113
among others. That was from Teterboro to
Palm Beach.
Down a little bit further there's another date
that appears to be January 28th of 2001, although the 8
seems like it's a little faded, but does appear to be late
January 2001. On that flight is Jeffrey Epstein,
Ghislaine Maxwell, and among others.
And the last flight is the 30th of January, also
2001; this flight's had Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell,
and on that flight.

Q. Based on your review of flight records for
Jeffrey Epstein's private jet have you found multiple
additional flights in 2001 that took with
Epstein and Maxwell when she was still 17 years old?

A. Yes.
Q. Have you reviewed certain phone records from the
year 2004?
A. Yes.
Q. Did those phone records show that on at least two
occasions in April and May of 2004 an employee of Epstein'.
called phone number?

A. Yes.
Q. Turning to the next slide. During the prior
investigation of Epstein was there a search executed at
Epstein's Palm Beach residence in 2005 by the Palm Beach
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000335
03/29/2021
Police Department?

A. Yes.
Q• During that search did the police recover message
pads from the residence?
A. Yes.
Q. Would you please explain to the grand jury what
message pads are?

A. Sure. So message pads, in this particular
instance, were pads that Epstein kept next to each of his
phones in his residence. If someone was to call, whoever
would answer that phone would jot down a note as to who the
person was that was calling, who they were asking for, the
time and date, and their phone numbers, and any specific
message they wanted to leave.

Q. Have you reviewed the message pads that were
recovered from Jeffrey Epstein's Palm Beach residence in
2005?
with

A. Yes.
Q. Do those message pads include several messages
name and/or phone number on them?
A. Yes.
Q. Do those message-pad excerpts date between the
years 2003 and 2005?

A. Yes.
Q. Up on this slide right now, are those two examples
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000336
03/29/2021
of message-pad excerpts that reference

A. Yes.
Q. Would you please walk the grand jury through these
message pad excerpts?
A. Sure. The first one says the message is for

Mr. Epstein. The date is 3/1/2003.
3/11?
Q. I'm sorry, I think you said 3/1, did you mean
A. I'm sorry. It's a little faded. 3/11/2003. The
message is from and the phone number -- also a
little faded here -- but says, . The second message
says it's for JE, Jeffrey Epstein; the date is March 16,
2003; the message is from ; same number as the
previous message is . The message on the bottom
says she wants to work.

Q. And just to remind the grand jury, did
tell you that there were times when she would call to ask to
massage Epstein so that she could get more money for drugs?

A. Yes.
Q. Turning to the next slide. Are these additional
message pad excerpts seized from Jeffrey Epstein's
Palm Beach residence in 2005?

A. Yes.
Q.
these?
Would you please walk the grand jury through
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000337
03/29/2021 116

A. Sure. The first one on the left says the message
is for JE, Jeffrey Epstein. It's from
There's -- the date is missing on this one, but it says the
time is 12:30. The phone number is . The one
on the right says the message is also, again, JE for
Jeffrey Epstein. There's no date; the time is 3:15
It's from
p.m.
, phone number The
message states, ■ wants to work.

Q. During the search in 2005 of Epstein's Palm Beach
residence were additional messages recovered that are nor
included on these slides?

A. Yes.
Q. Additionally, were multiple massage tables seize°
from the residence in 2005?
A. Yes.
Q• Was at least one of those tables manufactured
outside of the state of Florida?

A. Yes.
Q. Have you reviewed photographs and a video
recording from that 2005 search of the Palm Beach residence?

A. Yes.
Q. Would you please describe for the grand jury,
based on those photographs and that video, what the massage
room in the Palm Beach residence looked like?

A. Sure. It was basically a master bathroom. There
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000338
03/29/2021 117
was glass doors which appear to go back into a shower.
There's a sink in the room; there is a couch in the room;
there's several door in the room, one of which leads into a
closet. Inside of the closet on the walls, also on the
walls of the massage room, there were multiple photographs,
some of them being of nude women.

Q. Was there also a massage table in that closet?
A. Yes. Photographed was a massage table inside of
the closet.

Q. Have you told the grand jury everything you know
about this case, or have you merely answered the questions
that I've asked you?

A. I've merely answered the questions.
Q. When you testified about conversations you had
with others, or documents you reviewed, did you testify to
the exact words or just the substance?

A. Just the substance.
Q. And are you willing to return to the grand jury if
the grand jurors have additional questions for you?

A. Of course.
MS. Then with the Foreperson's permission
I'll ask that the witness please be excused.
FOREPERSON. Yes, he may.

MS. Thank you.
(Witness Excused)
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000339
03/29/2021
(Time Noted: 12:15 p.m.)
(Colloquy Follows)
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_00000340
CERTIFICATE
I hereby certify that the foregoing is a true and
accurate transcription, to the best of my skill and ability,
from my electronic notes of this proceeding.
April 5, 2021
Date
Reporter
Free State Reporting, Inc.
FREE STATE REPORTING, INC.
Court Reporting Transcription
D.C. Area 301-261-1902
Balt. & Annap. 410-974-0947
GM_GLSDNY_0000034I
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                Ross Ulbricht [crypto] founder of infamous online drug market Silk Road, pardoned by Trump 
 Halkbank [mideast] Turkish bank charged with evading sanctions on Iran, "pardoned" by Trump in 2026 [alj] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00039421 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2021-03-29)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
x
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
S 120 Cr. 330 (AJN)
GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
Defendant.
x
THE GOVERNMENT'S OMNIBUS MEMORANDUM IN OPPOSITION
TO THE DEFENDANT'S PRE-TRIAL MOTIONS
AUDREY STRAUSS
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
Attorney for the United States of America
Assistant United States Attorneys
- Of Counsel -
TABLE OF CONTENTS
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT 1
BACKGROUND 2
ARGUMENT 3

I. Jeffrey Epstein's Non-Prosecution Agreement Is Irrelevant to This Case 3
A. The NPA Does Not Bind the Southern District of New York 4

1. The Text of the Agreement Does Not Contain a Promise to Bind Other Districts 5
2. The Defendant Has Offered No Evidence That the NPA Binds Other Districts  9

B. The NPA Does Not Immunize Maxwell from Prosecution 15
1. The NPA Is Limited to Particular Crimes Between 2001 and 2007 15

2. The NPA Does Not Confer Enforceable Rights on Maxwell 17
C. The Defendant Has Offered No Basis for Additional Discovery or a Hearing 21

II. The Indictment Is Timely 23
A. Statutory Background 24
B. The 2003 Amendment to Section 3283 Applies Retroactively 26

1. The 2003 Amendment Satisfies Step One of Landgraf 28
2. The 2003 Amendment Satisfies Step Two of Landgraf 32

C. The Defendant's Crimes Involved the Sexual Abuse of Minors 36
III. The Defendant's Motion to Dismiss the Indictment Based on Alleged Improper Pre-
Trial Delay Should Be Denied 41

A. The Defendant Has Failed to Demonstrate Actual and Substantial Prejudice 42
1. Applicable Law 42
2. Discussion 44

B. The Defendant Has Failed to Establish That the Government Delayed the Indictment for
An Improper Purpose 52

1. Applicable Law 52
2. Discussion 54
IV. The Court Should Deny the Defendant's Motions to Suppress 59
A. Factual Background 61

1. The Civil Lawsuit against Maxwell 61
2. February 2016 Meeting 62
3. The April and July 2016 Depositions of Maxwell 64

4. The USAO-SDNY Commences the Instant Investigation in 2018 65
5. The USAO-SDNY's Subpoenas and Ex Pane Applications for Materials 66

6. Proceedings before Chief Judge McMahon 68
a. March 26, 2019 Hearing 68
b. April 9, 2019 Hearing 70
c. Chief Judge McMahon's Memorandum and Order 71

7. Magistrate Judge Netbum's Order 74
8. Unsealing of Maxwell's Depositions 74
9. The New York Daily News Article 75

B. The Defendant's Suppression Motion Should Be Denied 76
1. Martindell Provides No Basis to Grant the Relief the Defendant Seeks 76

a. Applicable Law 76
b. Discussion 79
2. Maxwell's Fourth Amendment Claim Fails 82
a. Maxwell Has Not Established Standing 82

i. Applicable Law 82
ii. Discussion 84
b. The Government Acted in Good Faith 86
i. Applicable Law 86
ii. Discussion 88

c. Suppression of Certain Materials Would Be Improper Under the Inevitable Discovery
Doctrine 93
i. Applicable Law 93

ii. Discussion 94
3. The Defendant's Motion to Suppress Evidence Obtained Pursuant to the Subpoena
Under the Fifth Amendment Is Without Merit 96

a. Applicable Law 96
i. The Fifth Amendment — Generally 96
ii. The Fifth Amendment — Act of Production Privilege 97
iii. The Fifth Amendment — When Private Action Is Deemed Government Action 98

b. Discussion 99
4. The Government Did Not Violate Maxwell's Due Process Rights 103
a. Applicable Law 104

b. Discussion 107
5. The Court Should Not Exercise Its Inherent Authority to Order Suppression 109
a. Applicable Law 109

b. Discussion 110
6. The Defendant Is Not Entitled to a Hearing 111
a. Applicable Law 112
b. Discussion 115

V. The Jury Should Decide Whether the Defendant Committed Perjury 116
A. Factual Background 117
B. Applicable Law 119

C. Discussion 122
1. April 2016 Deposition 123
2. July 2016 Deposition 129
3. Materiality 135
VI. Counts Five and Six Are Properly Joined and Should Not Be Severed 138

A. Applicable Law 138
B. Discussion 141
VII. The Indictment Contains the Elements of Each Offense and Provides the Defendant
More Than Adequate Notice of the Charges Against Her 150

A. Applicable Law 150
B. Discussion 152
VIII. There Is No Basis to Strike Any Portion of the Indictment 157

A. Relevant Facts 158
B. Applicable Law 159
C. Discussion 161
IX. The Defendant's Motion to Dismiss Count One or Count Three as Multiplicitous Is
Premature 169

A. Relevant Facts 169
B. Applicable Law 170
C. Discussion 172
X. The Defendant's Various Disclosure Motions Should be Denied 174

A. Bill of Particulars Is Not Warranted 174
1. Applicable Law 174
2. Discussion 178
B. The Defendant's Requests for Early Production of a Witness List and Jencks Act Material
Should Be Denied 182

1. Applicable Law 182
2. Discussion 184
C. The Defendant's Additional Requests for Disclosure Should Be Denied 185

XI. The Use of a Grand Jury Siting in White Plains Was Entirely Proper 193
A. Background 194
1. The SDNY and Local Rules for the Division of Business 194

2. The SDNY Jury Plan 195
B. Applicable Law 197
C. Discussion 198
1. The Defendant Was Properly Indicted by a Grand Jury Sitting in White Plains 198

2. The Defendant's Fair Cross-Section Claim Is Meritless 205
a. The Defendant Has Not Established that Blacks or Hispanics Are Unfairly
Represented 205

b. Any Potential Underrepresentation Is Not Due to Systematic Exclusion 210
CONCLUSION 212
iii
EXHIBIT LIST
Exhibit 1: Notes from the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York
Exhibit 2: June 14, 2007 Email
Exhibit 3: November 2020 Report, U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Professional
Responsibility
Exhibit 4: Notes from February 11, 2021 Call
Exhibit 5: Notes from February 29, 2016 Meeting
Exhibit 6: November 30, 2018 Email
Exhibit 7: December 6, 2018 Email
Exhibit 8: February 28, 2019 Government Letter to Judge Sweet
Exhibit 9: February 28, 2019 Government Letter to Judge Netburn
Exhibit 10: Transcript of April 22, 2016 Deposition
Exhibit 11: Transcript of July 22, 2016 Deposition
Exhibit 12: Affidavit of Dr. Bernard R. Siskin
iv
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases
Albright v. Oliver,
510 U.S. 266 (1993)
Andover Data Servs., a Div. of Players Computer, Inc. v. Statistical Tabulating Corp.,
Page(s)
876 F.2d 1080 (2d Cir. 1989) 106, 119, 149
Arizona v. Youngblood,
488 U.S. 51 (1988) 76
Aronson v. K. Arakelian, Inc.,
154 F.2d 231 (7th Cir. 1946) 19
Berghuis v. Smith,
559 U.S. 314 (2010) 299, 302
Blaszczak,
17 Cr. 357 (LAK) 275
Blissett v. Lefevre,
924 F.2d 434 (2d Cir. 1991) 158
Blum v. Yaretsky,
457 U.S. 991 (1982) 143
Bochese v. Town of Ponce Inlet,
405 F.3d 964 (11th Cir. 2005) 24
Botha v. Don King Productions, Inc.,

No. 97 Civ. 7587 (JGK), 1998 WL 88745 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 27, 1998) 148
Boyd v. United States,
116 U.S. 616 (1886) 145
Branzburg v. Hayes,
408 U.S. 665 (1972) 110
Bridges v. United States,
346 U.S. 209 (1953) 53
Bronston v. United States,
409 U.S. 352 (1973) 181
Bryson v. United States,
396 U.S. 64 (1969) 147
Burgess v. United States,
552 U.S. 124 (2008) 51
Caplin & Drysdale, Chartered v. United States,
491 U.S. 617 (1989) 159
Carpenter v. United States,
138 S. Ct. 2206 passim
Chambers v. Mississippi,
410 U.S. 284 (1973) 159
Chemical Bank v. Affiliated FM Ins. Co.,
154 F.R.D. 91 (S.D.N.Y. 1994) passim
Christopher v. SmithKline Beecham Corp.,
567 U.S. 142 (2012)
Colorado v. Connelly,
479 U.S. 157 (1986) 139, 141, 142
Colorado v. Spring,
479 U.S. 564 (1987) 138
County of Sacramento v. Lewis,
523 U.S. 833 (1998) 152
Cruz v. Maypa,
773 F.3d 138 (4th Cir. 2014) 43
Davis v. United States,
564 U.S. 229 (2011) 122
Doe 1 v. United States,
359 F. Supp. 3d 1201 (S.D. Fla. 2019) 14
Doe No. 1. v. United States,
749 F.3d 999 (11th Cir. 2014) 173, 174, 176
Dowling v. United States,
493 U.S. 342 (1990) 76
Duren v. Missouri,
439 U.S. 357 (1979) 289, 296
Edwards v. Mazzuca,

No. 00 Civ. 2290 (US), 2007 WL 2994449 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 15, 2007) 234
Falter v. United States,
23 F.2d 420 (2d Cir. 1928) 45
Fisher v. United States,
425 U.S. 391 (1976) 140, 146
Flagg v. Yonkers Say. & Loan Ass 'n,
396 F.3d 178 (2d Cir. 2005) 143
Franks v. Delaware,
438 U.S. 154 (1978) 166, 169, 170, 171
Gatto,
17 Cr. 686 (LAK) 275
Golino v. City of New Haven,
950 F.2d 864 (2d Cir. 1991) 125
Graham v. Connor,
490 U.S. 386 (1989) 151
Grant v. United States,
282 F.2d 165 (2d Cir. 1960) 164
Greer v. Miller,
483 U.S. 756 (1987) 158
Grunewald v. United States,
353 U.S. 391 (1957) 248
Hamling v. United States,
418 U.S. 87 (1974) 225, 227
vi
Hemphill v. United States,
392 F.2d 45 (8th Cir. 1968) 268
Herring v. United States,
555 U.S. 135 (2009) 123
Howell v. Superintendent Rockview SCI,
939 F.3d 260 (2d Cir. 2019) 302
Huddleston v. United States,
485 U.S. 681 (1988) 254
In re Enter. Mort. Acceptance Co. Sec. Litig. ("Enterprise",
), 391 F.3d 401 (2d Cir. 2004) 36,43,44
In re Grand Jury Subpoena Duces Tecum Dated Apr. 19, 1991,
945 F.2d 1221 (2d Cir. 1991) 108, 113
In re Grand Jury Subpoena Duces Tecum Dated Oct 29, 1992,
1 F.3d 87 (2d Cir. 1993) 140, 145
In re Grand Jury Subpoena,
826 F.2d 1166 (1987) 136
In re Grand Jury Subpoena,
836 F.2d 1468 (4th Cir. 1988) 149
In re Three Grand Jury Subpoenas Duces Tecum Dated Jan. 29,
1999, 191 F.3d 173 (2d Cir. 1999) 139
In Re Three Grand Jury Subpoenas Jan. 5,
1988, 847 F.2d 1024 (2d Cir. 1988) 136
In re U.S.,
834 F.2d 283 (2d Cir. 1987) 284
In re Various Grand Jury Subpoenas,
924 F. Supp. 2d 549 (S.D.N.Y. 2013), aff'd, 579 F. App'x 37 (2d Cir. 2014) 140
Int'l Equity !nvs., Inc. v. Opportunity Equity Partners Ltd.,

No. 05 Civ. 2745 (JGK) (RLE), 2010 WL 779314 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 2, 2010) 111
Johnson v. United States,
520 U.S. 461 (1997) 200
Kungys v. United States,
485 U.S. 759 (1988) 222
Landgraf v. USI Film Products,
511 U.S. 244 (1994) 35,36, 41, 42
Leocal v. Ashcroft,
543 U.S. 1 (2004) 56, 57
Madanes v. Madanes,
186 F.R.D. 279 (S.D.N.Y. 1999) 141
Martindell v. Intl Tel. and Tel. Corp.,
594 F.2d 291 (2d Cir. 1979) passim
Martinez v. McAleenan,
385 F. Supp. 3d 349 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) 150, 151
Michigan v. Tucker,
417 U.S. 433 (1974) 137
vii
Miller v. Pate,
386 U.S. 1 (1967) 157, 174, 175
Mills v. Scully,
826 F.2d 1192 (2d Cir. 1987) 158
Minnesota v. Mwphy,
465 U.S. 420 (1984) 144
Murray v. Met. Life Ins. Co.,
583 F.3d 173 (2d Cir. 2009) 223
Nyhawan v. Holder,
557 U.S. 29 (2009) 56
Nix v. Williams,
467 U.S. 431 (1984) 132, 133
North Carolina v. Pearce,
395 U.S. 711 (1969) 259
Oregon v. Elstad,
470 U.S. 298 (1985) 139, 141
Palmieri v. State of N.Y.,
779 F.2d 861 (2d Cir. 1985) 108, 112, 114
Rakas v. Illinois,
439 U.S. 128 (1978) 115, 116, 118
Ratzlaf v. United States,
510 U.S. 135 (1994) 165
Rawlings v. Kentucky,
448 U.S. 98 (1980) 116
Richardson v. Marsh,
481 U.S. 200 (1987) 212
Rivera v. United States,
928 F.2d 592 (2d Cir. 1991) 168, 172
Rochin,
342 U.S., 72 S. Ct. 205 153
Rosencrans v. United States,
165 U.S. 257 (1897) 296
Russell v. United States,
369 U.S. 749 (1962) 229
Rutenberg v. United States,
245 U.S. 480 (1918) 292
Salinas v. United States,
522 U.S. 52 (1997) 245
Santobello v. United States,

No. 94 Cr. (RPP), 1998 WL 113950 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 13, 1998) 21
Sch. Dist. No. 7,
167 F.3d 784 (2d Cir. 1999) 61
SEC v. 71eStreetcom,
273 F.3d 222 (2d Cir. 2001) 109, 113
viii
Silver,
15 Cr. 93 (VEC) 275
Skelos,
15 Cr. 317 (KMW) 275
Smith v. Maryland,
442 U.S. 735 (1979) 117, 118
Stogner v. California,
539 U.S. 607 (2003) 45
Swain v. Alabama,
380 U.S. 202 (1965) 300
Taylor v. Louisiana,
419 U.S. 522 (1975) 299, 300
Taylor v. United States,
495 U.S. 575 (1990) 56
Thom v. Ashcroft,
369 F.3d 158 (2d Cir. 2004) 47
Toussie v. United States,
397 U.S. 112 (1970) 48
United State v. Nader,
425 F. Supp. 3d 619 (E.D. Va. 2019) passim
United States v. Ahmed,
992 F. Supp. 682 (S.D.N.Y. 1998) 166
United States v. Ahmed,
No. 10 Cr. 131 (PKC), 2011 WL 5041456 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 21, 2011) 243
United States v. Al Kassar,
660 F.3d 108 (2d Cir. 2011) 154
United States v. Alameh,
341 F.3d 167 (2d Cir. 2003) 77, 78, 81
United States v. Alberti,
568 F.2d 617 (2d Cir. 1977) 187
United States v. Aleman,
286 F.3d 86 (2d Cir. 2002) 27
United States v. Alfonso,
143 F.3d 772 (2d. Cir. 1998) 226
United States v. Amato,
15 F.3d 230 (2d Cir. 1994) 209
United States v. An Antique Platter of Gold,
184 F.3d 131 (2d Cir. 1999) 222
United States v. Anderson,
747 F.3d 51 (2d Cir. 2014) 212
United States v. Anderson,
772 F.3d 969 (2d Cir. 2014) 162
United States v. Annabi,
10 Cr. 07 (CM) 286
ix
United States v. Annabi,
771 F.2d 670 (2d Cir. 1985) 5, 7, 8
United States v. Annabi,
771 F.2d 670 (2d Cir. 1985), aff'd, 867 F.2d 1425 (2d Cir. 1988) 5
United States v. Arid,
12 Cr. 24 (LAP) 286
United States v. Arzberger,
592 F. Supp. 2d 590 (S.D.N.Y. 2008) 151
United States v. Ash,
464 F. Supp. 3d 621 (S.D.N.Y. 2020) 145
United States v. Ashburn,
76 F. Supp. 3d 401 (E.D.N.Y. 2014) 126
United States v. Awadallah,
349 F.3d 42 (2d Cir. 2003) 166, 168
United States v. Bahna,
68 F.3d 19 (2d Cir. 1995) passim
United States v. Balde,
20 Cr. 281 (KPF) 298
United States v. Barlow,
732 F. Supp. 2d 1 (E.D.N.Y. 2010) 300
United States v. Barlow,
732 F. Supp. 2d 1 (E.D.N.Y. 2010), aff'd, 479 F. App'x 372 (2d Cir. 2012) 300, 302
United States v. Barnes,
520 F. Supp. 2d 510 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) 300
United States v. Batchelder,
442 U.S. 114 (1979) 265
United States v. Bejasa,
904 F.2d 137 (2d Cir. 1990) 274
United States v. Bellomo,
263 F. Supp. 2d 561 (E.D.N.Y. 2003) 268
United States v. Ben Zvi,
242 F.3d 89 (2d Cir. 2001) 41
United States v. Benussi,
216 F. Supp. 2d 299 (S.D.N.Y. 2002) 248, 250
United States v. Biaggi,
675 F. Supp. 790 (S.D.N.Y. 1987) 268
United States v. Biaggi,
909 F.2d 662 (2d Cir. 1990) 298, 300
United States v. Bin Laden,
91 F. Supp. 2d 600 (S.D.N.Y. 2000) 240
United States v. Bfrney,
686 F.2d 102 (2d Cir. 1982) 61, 65
United States v. Buren,
470 F.2d 113 (2d Cir. 1972) 183
United States v. Blakney,
941 F.2d 114 (2d Cir. 1991) 205, 219
United States v. Blaszczak,
308 F. Supp. 3d 736 (S.D.N.Y. 2018) 279
United States v. Block,

No. 16 Cr. 595 (JPO), 2017 WL 1608905 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 28, 2017) 267
United States v. Bonacorsa,
528 F.2d 1218 (2d Cir. 1976) 180, 190, 197, 199
United States v. Bonventre,
646 F App'x 73 (2d Cir. 2016) 271
United States v. Bortnovsky,
820 F.2d 572 (2d Cir. 1987) 266, 267, 274
United States v. Botti,

No. 08 Cr. 230 (CSH), 2009 WL 3157582 (D. Conn. Sept. 25, 2009) 218
United States v. Brand,
467 F.3d 179 (2d Cir. 2006) 236
United States v. Brand,
556 F.2d 1312 (5th Cir. 1977) 75
United States v. Brand,

No. 04 Cr. 194 (PKL), 2005 WL 77055 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 12, 2005) 257
United States v. Broccolo,
797 F. Supp. 1185 (S.D.N.Y. 1992) 207, 214, 217
United States v. Brown,
744 F. Supp. 558 (S.D.N.Y. 1990) 170
United States v. Brown,
800 F. App'x 455 (9th Cir. 2020), cert denied, No. 20-5064, S.Ct. , 2021 WL 78235 (Jan.
11, 2021)
United States v. Brown,
34, 39

No. 07-0296, 2008 WL 161146 (E.D. Pa. Jan. 16, 2008) 216
United States v. Brown,
No. 99-1230, 2002 WL 34244994, at (2d Cir. Apr. 26, 2002) 6
United States v. Bruno,
159 F. Supp. 3d 311 (E.D.N.Y. 2016) 7
United States v. Bunn,
154 F. App'x 227 (2d Cir. 2005) 237
United States v. Burke,

No. 09 Cr. 135 (SJ), 2011 WL 2609837 (E.D.N.Y. July I, 2011) 82
United States v. Butler,
351 F. Supp. 121 (S.D.N.Y. 2004) 243
United States v. Butler,

No. 04 Cr. 340, 2004 WL 2274751 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 7, 2004) 208, 211
United States v. Calandra,
414 U.S. 338 (1974) 110
United States v. Caming,
968 F.2d 232 (2d Cir. 1992) 165
xi
United States v. Campo Flores,

No. 15 Cr. 765 (PAC), 2016 WL 5946472 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 12, 2016) 281, 282
United States v. Canfield,
212 F.3d 713 (2d Cir. 2000) 167
United States v. Canter,
338 F. Supp. 2d 460 (S.D.N.Y. 2004) 283
United States v. Carbonaro,

No. 02 Cr. 743 (RCC), 2004 WL 2222145 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 30, 2004) 83
United States v. Carpenter,
680 F.3d 1101 (9th Cir. 2012) 50
United States v. Carson,
464 F.2d 424 (2d Cir. 1972) 217, 219
United States v. CFW Const. Co.,
583 F. Supp. 197 (D. S.C. 1984) 23
United States v. Chacko,
169 F.3d 140 (2d Cir. 1999) 259
United States v. Chalmers,
474 F. Supp. 2d 555 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) 225, 226
United States v. Chambers,
800 F. App'x 43 (2d Cir. 2020) 69
United States v. Chan Lo,

No. 14 Cr. 491 (VSB), 2016 WL 9076234 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 4, 2016), aff'd. 679 F. App'x 79 (2d
Cir. 2017)
United States v. Chen,
378 F.3d 151 (2d Cir. 2004)
United States v. Cheung Kin Ping,
555 F.2d 1069 (2d Cir. 1977)
United States v. Chuang,
68, 81
897 F.2d 646 (2d Cir. 1990) 115, 116
United States v. Coffey,
361 F. Supp. 2d 102 (E.D.N.Y. 2005) 228
United States v. Coke,

No. 07 Cr. 971 (RPP), 2011 WL 3738969 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 22, 2011) 153, 160, 163
United States v. Collins,
409 F. Supp. 3d 228 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) 278
United States v. Concepcion,
983 F.2d 369 (2d Cir. 1992) 252
United States v. Coppa,
267 F.3d 132 (2d Cir. 2001) 274
United States v. Corbett,
750 F.3d 245 (2d Cir. 2014) 137
United States v. Cornielle,
171 F.3d 748 (2d Cir. 1999) 60, 77, 78, 85
United States v. Corr,
543 F.2d 1042 (2d Cir. 1976) 181
xii
United States v. Countentos,
651 F.3d 809 (8th Cir. 2011) 57, 58
United States v. Cromitie,
727 F.3d 194 (2d Cir. 2019) 154
United States v. Cromitie, et al.,
09 Cr. 558 (CM) 286
United States v. Crouch,
84 F.3d 1497 (5th Cir. 1996) 75
United States v. D'Amico,
734 F. Supp. 2d 321 (S.D.N.Y. 2010) 268
United States v. Davis,
702 F.2d 418 (2d Cir. 1983) passim
United States v. DeFilippo,

No. 17 Cr. 585 (WHP), 2018 WL 740727 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 31, 2018) 169
United States v. Delacruz,
970 F. Supp. 2d 199 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) 77
United States v. DePalma,
461 F. Supp. 778 (S.D.N.Y. 1978) 241, 250
United States v. Dewar,
489 F. Supp. 2d 351 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) 165
United States v. Diaz,
176 F.3d 52 (2d Cir. 1999) 251, 253
United States v. DiGregorio,
795 F. Supp. 630 (S.D.N.Y. 1992) 155
United States v. Dodge,
597 F.3d 1347 (11th Cir. 2010) (en banc) 54
United States v. Dornau,
356 F. Supp. 1091 (S.D.N.Y. 1973) 73
United States v. Dorvee,
616 F.3d 174 (2d Cir. 2010) 236
United States v. Drago,

No. 18 Cr. 0394 (SW) (AYS), 2019 WL 3072288 (E.D.N.Y. July 15, 2019) 86
United States v. Dumitru,
No. 18 Cr. 243 (LAK), 2018 WL 3407703 (S.D.N.Y. June 26, 2018) 261
United States v. Eldred,
933 F.3d 110 (2d Cir. 2019) 123
United States v. E!-Sadig,
133 F. Supp. 2d 600 (N.D. Ohio 2001) 23
United States v. Elsbery,
602 F.2d 1054 (2d Cir. 1979) 62, 72
United States v. Estrada,
320 F.3d 173 (2d Cir. 2003) 259
United States v. Ewell,
383 U.S. 116 (1966) 80
United States v. Falso,
544 F.3d 110 (2d Cir. 2008)
United States v. Fanner,
137 F.3d 1265 (10th Cir. 1998)
United States v. Feldman,
939 F.3d 182 (2d Cir. 2019)
United States v. Fennell,
166, 169
179, 180
8, 20, 27
496 F. Supp. 2d 279 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) 284, 286
United States v. Figueroa,
618 F.2d 934 (2d Cir. 1980) 255
United States v. Fiumano,

No. 14 Cr. 518 (JFK), 2016 WL 1629356 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 25, 2016) 70
United States v. Florence,
456 F.2d 46 (4th Cir. 1972) 293
United States v. Florida West Int'l Airways, Inc.,
853 F. Supp. 2d 1209 (S.D. Fla. 2012) 23, 24
United States v. Forde,
740 F. Supp. 2d 406 (S.D.N.Y. 2010) passim
United States v. Gallo,

No. 98 Cr. (JGK), 1999 WL 9848 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. II, 1999) 275, 281
United States v. Gambino,
838 F. Supp. 744 (S.D.N.Y. 1993) 70
United States v. Gaudin,
515 U.S. 506 (1995) 182, 184, 200, 222
United States v. Geaney,
417 F.2d 1116 (2d Cir. 1969) 284
United States v. Gentile,
235 F. Supp. 3d 649 (D.N.J. 2017) 48
United States v. Ghailani,
751 F. Supp. 2d 502 (S.D.N.Y. 2010) 155
United States v. Ghavami,

No. 10 Cr. 1217 (KMW), 2012 WL 2878126 (S.D.N.Y. July 13, 2012) 262
United States v. Gibson,
175 F. Supp. 2d 532 (S.D.N.Y. 2001) 268
United States v. Gilbert,
266 F.3d 1180 (9th Cir. 2001) 62
United States v. Gillette,
383 F.2d 843 (2d Cir. 1967) 165
United States v. Gonzalez,

No. 00 Cr. 447, 2000 WL 1721171 85
United States v. Gottfried,
165 F.2d 360 (2d Cir. 1948) 292
United States v. Gracesqui,

No. 10 Cr. 74 (PKC), 2015 WL 5231168 n.2 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 8, 2015), aff'd, 730 F. App'x 25
(2d Cir. 2018) 209
xiv
United States v. Green,
981 F.3d 945 (11th Cir. 2020) 124
United States v. Greer,
956 F. Supp. 525 (D. Vt. 1997) 72
United States v. GrWith,

No. 99 Cr. (HB), 2000 WL 1253265 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 5, 2000) 264
United States v. Guerrier,
18 Cr. 284 (JSR) 286
United States v. Guzman,
337 F. Supp. 140 (S.D.N.Y. 1972) 300
United States v. Halkbank,

No. 15 Cr. 867 (RMB), 2020 WL 5849512 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. I, 2020) 261
United States v. Hallahan,
756 F.3d 962 (7th Cir. 2014) 19
United States v. Halper,
590 F.2d 422 (2d Cir. 1978) 216
United States v. Haqq,
278 F.3d 44 (2d Cir. 2002) 115
United States v. Harrison,
764 F. Supp. 29 (S.D.N.Y. 1991) 72
United States v. Hastings,
461 U.S. 499 (1983) 160
United States v. Heath,
455 F.3d 52 (2d Cir. 2006) 132, 133
United States v. Henderson,
337 F.3d 914 (7th Cir. 2003) 61, 62
United States v. Henry,
861 F. Supp. 1190 (S.D.N.Y. 1994) 269
United States v. Herbert,
698 F.2d 981 (9th Cir. 1983) 293
United States v. Hernandez,
85 F.3d 1023 (2d Cir. 1996) 242
United States v. Hester,

No. 19 Cr. 324 (NSR), 2020 WL 3483702 (S.D.N.Y. June 26, 2020) 211
United States v. Heyward,
No. 10 Cr. 84 (LTS), 2010 WL 4484642 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 9, 2010) 154
United States v. Hillegas,
578 F.2d 453 (2d Cir. 1978) 79
United States v. Hoo,
825 F.2d 667 (2d Cir. 1987) 78
United States v. Hsia,
24 F. Supp. 2d 14 (D.D.C. 1998) 249
United States v. lannelli,
461 F.2d 483 (2d Cir. 1972) 64
xv
United States v. Israel,
05 Cr. 1039 (CM) 286
United States v. Jackman,
46 F.3d 1240 (2d Cir. 1995) 300, 301
United States v. Jeffries,
405 F.3d 682 (8th Cir. 2005) 33, 37, 38, 46
United States v. Jenkins,
727 F. App'x 732 (2d Cir. 2018) 194
United States v. Jennings,
960 F.2d 1488 (9th Cir. 1992) 162
United States v. Jimenez,
824 F. Supp. 351 (S.D.N.Y. 1993) 240, 268
United States v. Johns,
15 F.3d 740 (8th Cir. 1994) 37
United States v. Johnson,
21 F. Supp. 2d 329 (S.D.N.Y. 1998) 294
United States v. Jones,
482 F.3d 60 (2d Cir. 2006) 259
United States v. Josephberg,
459 F.3d 350 (2d Cir. 2006) passim
United States v. Kaplan,
758 F. App'x 34 (2d Cir. 2018) 182
United States v. Kenny,
883 F. Supp. 869 (E.D.N.Y. 1995) 294
United States v. Kidd,
386 F. Supp.3d 364 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) 231, 232
United States v. King,
560 F.2d 122 (2d Cir. 1977) 64
United States v. Kozel,

No. 19 Cr. 460 (KMW), 2020 WL 4751498 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 17, 2020) 236
United States v. Kross,
14 F.3d 751 (2d Cir. 1994) 183, 221, 222
United States v. LaFlam,
369 F.3d 153 (2d Cir. 2004) 254
United States v. Lahey,
967 F. Supp. 2d 698 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) 168
United States v. Lambus,
897 F.3d 368 (2d Cir. 2018) passim
United States v. Laskow,
688 F. Supp. 851 (E.D.N.Y. 1988) 8
United States v. Laskow,
688 F. Supp. 851 (E.D.N.Y. 1988) (tbl.) 5
United States v. Laurenti,
581 F.2d 37 (2d Cir. 1978) 79
xvi
United States v. Lawson,
683 F.2d 688 (2d Cir. 1982)
United States v. Leo Sure Chief
438 F.3d 920 (9th Cir. 2006)
United States v. Leon,
468 U.S. 897 (1984)
60, 78
33, 38, 46
124, 125
United States v. Leonelli,
428 F. Supp. 880 (S.D.N.Y. 1977) 268
United States v. Levy,

No. II Cr. 62 (PAC), 2013 WL 664712 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 25, 2013) 267
United States v. Lighte,
782 F.2d 367 (2d Cir. 1986) passim
United States v. Loera,
333 F. Supp. 3d 172 (E.D.N.Y. 2018) 152
United States v. Long,
697 F. Supp. 651 (S.D.N.Y. 1988) 65
United States v. Lopez,
944 F.2d 33 (1st Cir. 1991) 21, 26
United States v. Lovasco,
431 U.S. 783 (1977) 76, 79, 80, 82
United States v. Mahabub,

No. 13 Cr. 908 (MN), 2014 WL 4243657 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 26, 2014) 266, 268, 269
United States v. Mandell,
710 F. Supp. 2d 368 (S.D.N.Y. 2010) 267
United States v. Marcus,
628 F.3d 36 (2d Cir. 2010) 248
United States v. Mariamma Vijua,

No. 15 Cr. 240, 2016 WL 107841 (N.D. Tex. Jan. 11, 2016) 22
United States v. Marion,
404 U.S. 307 (1971) 59, 63, 72
United States v. Markiewicz,
978 F.2d 786 (2d Cir. 1992) 178, 180, 187, 198
United States v. Martin,
426 F.3d 68 (2d Cir. 2005) 167
United States v. Martinez,

No. 92 Cr. (SWK), 1993 WL 322768 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 19, 1993) 216
United States v. Martinez,
No. 94 Cr. (RPP), 1995 WL 10849 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 12, 1995) 77
United States v. Mason,
479 F. App'x 397 (2d Cir. 2012) 248
United States v. Mast,
735 F.2d 745 (2d Cir. 1984) 144
United States v. McCourty,
562 F.3d 458 (2d Cir. 2009) 260
xvii
United States v. McDarrah,
351 F. App'x 558 (2d Cir. 2009) 257
United States v. Medina,

No. 13 Cr. 272 (PGG), 2014 WL 3057917 (S.D.N.Y. July 7, 2014) 261
United States v. Miller,
116 F.3d 641 (2d Cir. 1997) 252, 292
United States v. Miller,
425 U.S. 435 (1976) 116, 117, 119
United States v. Miller,
911 F.3d 638 (1st Cir. 2018) 44
United States v. Ming He,
94 F.3d 782 (2d Cir. 1996) 161
United States v. Mitan,

No. 08-760, 2009 WL 2328870 (E.D. Pa. July 28, 2009) 218
United States v. Mitchell,
966 F.2d 92 (2d Cir. 1992) 144
United States v. Mitlof,
165 F. Supp. 2d 558 (S.D.N.Y. 2001) 268
United States v. Monserrate,

No. 10 Cr. 965 (CM), 2011 WL 3480957 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 4, 2011) 267
United States v. Montoya-Eschevarria,
892 F. Supp. 104 (S.D.N.Y. 1995) 118
United States v. Moore,
968 F.2d 216 (2d Cir. 1992) 125
United States v. Morgan,
113 F.3d 1230, 1997 WL 268712 (2d Cir. 1997) (unpublished opinion) 45
United States v. Mostafa,
965 F. Supp. 2d 451 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) 242, 243, 247, 262
United States v. Mulder,
273 F.3d 91 (2d Cir. 2001) 241, 242
United States v. Mullens,
536 F.2d 997 (2d Cir. 1976) 139
United States v. Murgio,
209 F. Supp. 3d 698 (S.D.N.Y. 2016) 231, 241, 247
United States v. Muric,

No. 10 Cr. 112 (LTS), 2010 WL 2891178 (S.D.N.Y. July 13, 2010) 86
United States v. Myers,
692 F.2d 823 (2d Cir. 1982) 153, 161
United States v. Napolitano,
552 F. Supp. 465 (S.D.N.Y. 1982) 241
United States v. Nejad,

No. 18 Cr. 224 (MN), 2019 WL 6702361 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 9, 2019) 225
United States v. Nemesian,
824 F.2d 1294 (2d Cir. 1987) 233
xviii
United States v. Nitsche,
843 F. Supp. 2d 4 (D.D.C. 2011) 201, 202
United States v. Nixon,
418 U.S. 683 (1974) 282
United States v. Noble,

No. 07 Cr. 284 (RJS), 2008 WL 140966 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 11, 2008) 164
United States v. Okwumabua,
828 F.2d 950 (2d Cir. 1987) 138
United States v. Olivieri,
740 F. Supp. 2d 423 (S.D.N.Y. 2010) 146
United States v. Oshatz,
700 F. Supp. 696 (S.D.N.Y. 1988) 147, 148
United States v. Page,
657 F.3d 126 (2d Cir. 2011) 205, 209, 210, 220
United States v. Pascarella,
84 F.3d 61 (2d Cir. 1996) 252
United States v. Paulin,
445 F.3d 211 (2d Cir. 2006) 253
United States v. Payner,
447 U.S. 727 (1980) 115, 161, 162
United States v. Pena,
932 F. Supp. 2d 464 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) 221
United States v. Perez,
940 F. Supp. 540 (S.D.N.Y.I996) 281
United States v. Pierre -Louis,

No. 16 Cr. 541 (CM), 2018 WL 4043140 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 9, 2018) passim
United States v. Pipola,
83 F.3d 556 (2d Cir. 1996) 253
United States v. Pirro,
212 F.3d 86 (2d Cir. 2000) 229
United States v. Pizarro,

No. 17 Cr. 151 (MN), 2018 WL 1737236 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 10, 2018) passim
United States v. Plaza-Andrades,
507 F. App'x 22 (2d Cir. 2013) 291
United States v. Polos,
723 F. App'x 64 (2d Cir. 2018) 195
United States v. Post,
950 F. Supp. 2d 519 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) 226
United States v. Potamitis,
739 F.2d 784 (2d Cir. 1984) passim
United States v. Prisco,
391 F. App'x 920 (2d Cir. 2010) 4
United States v. Quinones,
511 F.3d 289 (2d Cir. 2007) 251
xix
United States v. Rahimi,

No. 16 Cr. 760 (RMB), 2017 WL 2984169 (S.D.N.Y. June 22, 2017) 225
United States v. Rahman,
189 F.3d 88 (2d Cir. 1999) 154
United States v. Rajaratnam,

No. 09 Cr. 1184 (RJH), 2010 WL 4867402 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 24, 2010) 172
United States v. Ramnath,
131 F.3d 132 (2d Cir. 1997) 300
United States v. Raymonda,
780 F.3d 105 (2d Cir. 2015) 124
United States v. Reeves, et al.,
16 Cr. 372 (VEC) 286
United States v. Remington,
208 F.2d 567 (2d Cir. 1953) 146
United States v. Resendiz-Ponce,
549 U.S. 102 (2007) 227, 235
United States v. Ricco,
549 F.2d 264 (2d Cir. 1977) 61
United States v. Richardson,
512 F.2d 105 (3d Cir. 1975) 49
United States v. Richardson,
537 F.3d 951 (8th Cir. 2008) 293
United States v. Rioux,
930 F. Supp. 1558 (D. Conn. 1995) 297, 298
United States v. Rioux,
97 F.3d 648 (2d Cir. 1996) passim
United States v. Rittweger,
259 F. Supp. 2d 275 (S.D.N.Y. 2003) 268
United States v. Rivera,
546 F.3d 245 (2d Cir. 2008) 204, 220, 224
United States v. Rivera,

No. 09 Cr. 619 (SJF), 2011 WL 1429125, at (E.D.N.Y. Apr. 13, 2011) 262
United States v. Rivera,
No. 16 Cr. 175 (LGS), 2017 WL 1843302 (S.D.N.Y. May 8, 2017) 274
United States v. Roberts,
660 F.3d 149 (2d Cir. 2011) 138
United States v. Roberts,
852 F.2d 671 (2d Cir. 1988) 132
United States v. Rolan-Zapata,
916 F.2d 795 (2d Cir. 1990) 256
United States v. Rosa,
11 F.3d 315 (2d Cir. 1993) 253
United States v. Rosa,
626 F.3d 56 (2d Cir. 2010) 123
xx
United States v. Rubin,
609 F.2d 51 (2d Cir. 1979) 61
United States v. Rubinson,
543 F.2d 951 (2d Cir. 1976) 81
United States v. Ruiz,
702 F. Supp. 1066 (S.D.N.Y. 1989) 214
United States v. Ruiz,
894 F.2d 501 (2d Cir. 1990) 207, 213, 214, 217
United States v. Russo,
483 F. Supp. 2d 301 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) 274, 282
United States v. Russo,
801 F.2d 624 (2d Cir. 1986) 5, 11
United States v. Rutkoske,
506 F.3d 170 (2d Cir. 2007) 248
United States v. Salameh,
152 F.3d 88 (2d Cir. 1998) 5, 6, 245
United States v. Salerno,
481 U.S. 739 (1987) 151
United States v. Salmonese,
352 F.3d 608 (2d Cir. 2003) 247, 249
United States v. Sampson,
385 F.3d 183 (2d Cir. 2004) 208
United States v. Sampson,
898 F.3d 270 (2d Cir. 2018) 200, 201
United States v. Sampson,
898 F.3d 287 (2d Cir. 2018) 177, 178, 188
United States v. Samsonov,

No. 07 Cr. 1198 (CM), 2009 WL 176721 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 23, 2009) 269
United States v. Santiago,
987 F. Supp. 2d 465 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) 75
United States v. Sarwari,
669 F.3d 401 (4th Cir. 2012) 179, 180
United States v. Sattar,
272 F. Supp. 2d 348 (S.D.N.Y. 2003) 27
United States v. Savage,
970 F.3d 217 (3d Cir. 2020) 302
United States v. Scala,
388 F. Supp. 2d 396 (S.D.N.Y. 2005) 67, 68, 71
United States v. Scaipa,
897 F.2d 63 (2d Cir. 1990) 69
United States v. Scaipa,
913 F.2d 993 (2d Cir. 1990) passim
United States v. Schaefer,

No. 17 Cr. 400 (HZ), 2019 WL 267711 (D. Or. Jan. 17. 2019) 121
xxi
United States v. Schafrick,
871 F.2d 300 (2d Cir. 1989) 182
United States v. Schmidt,
105 F.3d 82 (2d Cir. 1997) 153, 154
United States v. Schneider,
801 F.3d 186 (3d Cir. 2015) 51,52,54,57
United States v. Seabrook,

No. 10 Cr. 87 (DAB), 2010 WL 5174353 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 14, 2010) 282
United States v. Sensi,
No. 08 Cr. 253, 2010 WL 2351484 (D. Conn. June 7, 2010) 34, 52
United States v. Sergentakis,

No. 05 Cr. 230 (JFK), 2005 WL 1994014 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 17, 2005) 275
United States v. Serrano,
No. 13 Cr. 58 (KBF), 2014 WL 2696569 (S.D.N.Y. June 10, 2014) 126
United States v. Shaw,
260 F. Supp. 2d 567 (E.D.N.Y. 2003) 165, 171
United States v. Sliker,
751 F.2d 477 (2d Cir. 1984) 255
United States v. Smith,
985 F. Supp. 2d 547 (S.D.N.Y. 2014) 241, 243, 247
United States v. Smith,

No. 05 Cr. 922 (DLC), 2007 WL 980431 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 3, 2007), affd, F. App'x 636 (2d Cir.
2009)
United States v. Snyder,
668 F.2d 686 (2d Cir. 1982)
United States v. Soares,
66 F. Supp. 2d 391 (E.D.N.Y. 1999)
United States v. Spears,
63, 78
159 F.3d 1081 (7th Cir. 1999) 62, 66, 67
United States v. Sprouts,
282 F.3d 1037 (8th Cir. 2002) 63
United States v. Stavroulakis,
952 F.2d 686 (2d Cir. 1992) 225, 233
United States v. Stein,
456 F.2d 844 (2d Cir. 1972) 68
United States v. Stein,
541 F.3d 130 (2d Cir. 2008) 142, 143
United States v. Stokes,
733 F.3d 438 (2d Cir. 2013) 124, 132
United States v. Stringer,
730 E 3d 120 (2d Cir. 2013) 228, 229, 231
United States v. Strohm,
671 F.3d 1173 (10th Cir. 2011) 180, 190
United States v. Swanson,
210 F.3d 788 (7th Cir. 2000) 170
United States v. Sweig,
441 F.2d 114 (2d Cir. 1971) 207, 211, 217
United States v. Tanu,
589 F.2d 82 (2d Cir. 1978) 79
United States v. Thai,
29 F.3d 785 (2d Cir. 1994) 252
United States v. Thompson,
13 Cr. 378 (AJN), 2013 WL 6246489 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 3, 2013) 281, 284
United States v. Thompson,
896 F.3d 155 (2d Cir. 2018) 236
United States v. Thompson,

No. 13 Cr. 378 (MN), 2013 WL 6246489 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 3, 2013) 274
United States v. Torres,
901 F.2d 205 (2d Cir. 1990) 266, 268, 271
United States v. Towne,
870 F.2d 880 (2d Cir. 1989) 251
United States v. Tracy,
12 F.3d 1186 (2d Cir. 1993) 283
United States v. Tram :::: ti,
513 F.2d 1087 (2d Cir. 1975) 225, 233
United States v. Tranquillo,
606 F. Supp. 2d 370 (S.D.N.Y. 2009) 284
United States v. Trippe,
171 F. Supp. 2d 230 (S.D.N.Y. 2001) 267
United States v. Triumph Capital Group, Inc.,
237 F. App'x 625 (2d Cir. 2007) 184, 187
United States v. Turoff,
853 F.2d 1037 (2d Cir. 1988) 204
United States v. Ulbricht,

No. 14 Cr. 68 (KBF), 2014 WL 5090039 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 10, 2014) 118, 275
United States v. Urena,
989 F. Supp. 2d 253 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) 28, 171
United States v. Valentine,
820 F.2d 565 (2d Cir. 1987) 156, 157, 158
United States v. Valona,
834 F.2d 1334 (7th Cir. 1987) 66
United States v. Vickers,
708 F. App'x 732 (2d Cir. 2017) 256
United States v. Vickers,

No. 13 Cr. 128 (RJA) (HKS), 2014 WL 1838255 (W.D.N.Y. May 8, 2014) passim
United States v. Vilar,
No. 05 Cr. 621 (KMK), 2007 WL 1075041 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 4, 2007) 169
United States v. Villegas,
899 F.2d 1324 (2d Cir. 1990) 115
United States v. Walker,
191 F.3d 326 (2d Cir. 1999) 70
United States v. Walsh,
194 F.3d. 37 (2d Cir. 1999) 228, 266, 271
United States v. Walters,
910 F.3d 11 (2d Cir. 2018) 152
United States v. Washington,
431 U.S. 181 (1977) 136, 137, 138
United States v. Watson,
599 F.2d 1149 (2d Cir. 1979) 78
United States v. Wedd,

No. 15 Cr. 616 (KBF), 2016 WL 1055737 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 10, 2016) 271
United States v. Weiner,
479 F.2d 923 (2d Cir. 1973) 187
United States v. Werner,
620 F.2d 922 (2d Cir. 1980) 205, 206, 208, 223
United States v. Wey,

No. 15 Cr. 611 (MN), 2017 WL 237651 n.8 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 18, 2017) 85, 227, 229
United States v. Williams,
205 F.3d 23 (2d Cir. 2000) 70
United States v. Williams,

No. 10 Cr. 622 (ADS), 2018 WL 4623017 (E.D.N.Y. Sept. 26, 2018) 123
United States v. Winter,
348 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1965) 146
United States v. Wong,
431 U.S. 174 (1977) 146
United States v. Wright,
343 F.3d 849 (6th Cir. 2003) 62
United States v. Ying Lin,

No. 15 Cr. 601 (DLI), 2018 WL 5113139 (E.D.N.Y. Oct. 19, 2018) 206
United States v. Yonkers Contracting Co., Inc.,
682 F. Supp. 757 (S.D.N.Y. 1988) 291
United States v. Young,
08 Cr. 285 (KMK), 2008 WL 4178190 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 4, 2008) 235
United States v. Young,
No. 08 Cr. 285 (KMK), 2008 WL 4178190 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 4, 2008) 234
United States v. Zackson,
12 F.3d 1178 (2d Cir. 1993) 253
United States v. Zodhiates,
901 F.3d 137 (2d Cir. 2018) 122, 126, 131
Valentine v. Konteh,
395 F.3d 626 (6th Cir. 2005) 235
Vernon v. Cassadaga Valley Cent. School Dist.,
49 F.3d 886 (2d Cir. 1995) 42, 43
xxiv
Washington v. Glucksberg,
521 U.S. 702 (1997)
Weingarten v. United States,
865 F.3d 48 (2d Cir. 2017)
Zafiro v. United States,
506 U.S. 534 (1993) 209,
passim
210, 220
Zicarelli v. Dietz,
633 F.2d 312 (3d Cir. 1980) 293
Zietzke v. United States,
426 F. Supp. 3d 758 (W.D. Wash. 2019) 121
Statutes
18 U.S.C. §I623(a) 118
18 U.S.C. § 1591 152
18 U.S.C. § 1623 3, 115
18 U.S.C. § 2 2, 3
18 U.S.C. § 2243 155
18 U.S.C. § 2422 passim
18 U.S.C. § 2422(a) 17
18 U.S.C. § 2422(b) 17
18 U.S.C. § 2423 3, 151
18 U.S.C. § 2423(a) passim
18 U.S.C. § 2423(b) 17, 37
18 U.S.C. § 2423(e) 17
18 U.S.C. § 2703(c)(2) 87
18 U.S.C. § 2703(d) 88
18 U.S.C. § 3282 24, 35
18 U.S.C. § 3283 passim
18 U.S.C. § 3299 25
18 U.S.C. § 3500 181, 184
18 U.S.C. § 3500(a) 181
18 U.S.C. § 3500(b) 182
18 U.S.C. § 3509(a) 37
18 U.S.C. § 3509(a)(8)  36
18 U.S.C. § 3509(d) 152
18 U.S.C. § 3509(k) 24, 36
18 U.S.C. § 371 2, 151, 155, 168
18 U.S.C. § 3771 116
28 U.S.C.§ 112 192
28 U.S.C. § 112(b) 192, 200
28 U.S.C. § 1861 et seq.  193, 194
28 U.S.C. § 1863(a) 194
28 U.S.C. § I863(bX6) 195
28 U.S.C. § 1865(b) 194
xxv
28 U.S.C. § 1869(e) 198, 200
28 U.S.C. § 81 192
New York Penal Law § 130.55 155
Pub. L. No. 101-647 24
Pub. L. No. 103-322 24
Pub. L. No. 108-21  25
Pub. L. No. 109-162 25
Pub. L. No. 109-248 25
Rules
Fed. R. App. P. 4(a)(6) 99
Fed. R. Civ. P 56 153
Fed. R. Crim. P. 14(a) 157
Fed. R. Crim. P. 16 200
Fed. R. Crim. P. 21  221
Fed. R. Crim. P. 5(f) 206
Fed. R. Crim. P. 6(e) 88
Fed. R. Crim. P. 7 168
Fed. R. Crim. P. 7(c)(1) 168
Fed. R. Crim. P. 7(d) 177
Fed. R. Crim. P. 7(f) 192
Fed. R. Crim. P. 8(a) 156
Fed. R. Crim. P. 8(a) 156
Fed. R. Evid. 402 183
Fed. R. Evid. 403 183, 185
Fed. R. Evid. 404(b)(2) 184
Fed. R. Evid. 801  210
N.Y. R.P.C. 3.7(b) 166
Rule 14 157
Rule 404(b) 186
Other Authorities
149 Cong. Rec. S 5137 30
149 Cong. Rec. S 5147 30
H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 108-66 29
Positivism and the Separation of Law and Morals,
71 Harv. L. Rev. 593 (1958) 130
Sexual Abuse Prosecutions,
77 J. Crim. L. & Criminology 1 (1986) 24
xxvi
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
x
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
S 1 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
Defendant.
x
PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
The Government respectfully submits this memorandum in opposition to the defendant's
twelve pre-trial motions, dated January 25,2021 (the "Defense Motions"). In her pretrial motions,
the defendant seeks to throw everything but the proverbial kitchen sink at the Indictment, raising
myriad arguments that find little support in fact or law. For the reasons that follow, the motions
should be denied in their entirety.
First, the non-prosecution agreement between Jeffrey Epstein and the U.S. Attorney's
Office for the Southern District of Florida is entirely irrelevant to this case, and the defendant's
motion fails as a matter of law. Second, the indictment is timely under 18 U.S.C. § 3283, which
provides an extended statute of limitations for crimes involving the sexual abuse of minors. The
defendant's statute of limitations arguments run contrary to the text of the statute, the intent of
Congress, and the weight of authority. Third, the defendant's claim that the Government delayed
in bringing the indictment fails as a matter of law and fact. Fourth, both of the defendant's motions
to suppress evidence obtained through a judicially approved subpoena are meritless, and her
allegations of Government misconduct are baseless. Fifth, Counts Five and Six—which charge
the defendant with committing perjury—are properly pleaded, and the defendant's motion to
dismiss those charges improperly asks the Court to adjudicate her guilt. It is for the jury to decide
whether the defendant committed perjury, and the motion should be denied. Sixth, the crimes in
the indictment should be tried together, as all six counts of the indictment are logically connected
and provable through overlapping evidence. The Court should not sever this case, and thereby
require victims of child sexual abuse to testify at multiple trials. Seventh, the Indictment
indisputably alleges each element of every offense charged and provides the defendant with ample
notice of the charges against her. Eighth, the Indictment is properly pled and there is no basis to
strike any portion of it as surplusage. Ninth, the defense motion to dismiss one of the conspiracy
charges as multiplicitous is premature. Tenth, the defendant is not entitled to a bill of particulars
or any of the other early disclosures she seeks. Finally, the use of a grand jury sitting in White
Plains to return the Indictment in this case was entirely proper.
BACKGROUND
On June 29, 2020, a grand jury sitting in this District returned an indictment charging the
defendant in six counts. On July 2, 2020, the Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBP") arrested the
defendant. On July 8, 2020, a grand jury sitting in this District returned a superseding indictment
(the "Indictment") containing the same charges, with ministerial corrections. (Dkt. No. 17). Count
One of the Indictment charges the defendant with conspiring with Jeffrey Epstein and others to
entice minors to travel to engage in illegal sex acts, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371. Count Two
charges the defendant with enticing a minor to travel to engage in illegal sex acts, and aiding and
abetting the same, in violation 18 U.S.C. §§ 2422 and 2. Count Three charges the defendant with
conspiring with Epstein and others to transport minors to participate in illegal sex acts, in violation
of 18 U.S.C. § 371. Count Four charges the defendant with transporting minors to participate in
illegal sex acts, and aiding and abetting the same, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2423 and 2. Counts
Five and Six charge the defendant with perjury, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1623. 1
ARGUMENT
I. Jeffrey Epstein's Non-Prosecution Agreement Is Irrelevant to This Case
The defendant seeks to dismiss the Indictment based on a 2007 non-prosecution agreement
("NPA") between Jeffrey Epstein and the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of
Florida (the "USAO-SDFL"). (Def. Mot. I). She does so despite the fact that: (1) she did not
negotiate the NPA, was not a party to the NPA, and her name is not contained anywhere in the
document; and (2) her crimes are not identified or named in any way in the NPA. Essentially, the
defendant claims she is immune from prosecution for any federal crime, during any time period,
anywhere, in the United States, based on the language of a document that does not name her and
which she did not sign. Moreover, she seeks to enforce the NPA against a U.S. Attorney's Office
that did not negotiate the NPA and is not bound by it.
The defendant's arguments are meritless, and the Court should reject them. As a threshold
matter, under the well-settled law of this Circuit, the NPA is not enforceable in this District,
because the USAO-SDFL's agreement with Jeffrey Epstein is not binding on the U.S. Attorney's
Office for the Southern District of New York (the "USAO-SDNY"). Moreover, even if the NPA
applied to this District —which it does not—the NPA does not immunize the defendant from
prosecution for the crimes charged in the Indictment. Finally, because the defendant has failed to
1 As the Government has repeatedly indicated, the investigation into Jeffrey Epstein's co-
conspirators remains ongoing. (See, e.g., Gov't Letter dated Aug. 21, 2020, Dkt. No. 46; Gov't
Letter dated Oct. 6, 2020, Dkt. No. 60; Gov't Letter dated Oct. 20, 2020, Dkt. No. 65). To the
extent that investigation results in additional charges against the defendant, the Government
intends to seek any superseding indictment at least three months in advance of trial. The
Government does not anticipate that any new charges would require the production of any
additional discovery.
offer any evidence to support her claim that the NPA applies to this District, to the defendant, or
to the crimes in the Indictment, the Court should deny the defendant's request for discovery and
an evidentiary hearing.

A. The NPA Does Not Bind the Southern District of New York
As an initial matter, the NPA is not enforceable in this District. To the contrary, it is black-
letter law in this Circuit that a plea agreement in one district does not apply elsewhere, in the
absence of express indications not present here. Indeed, the Second Circuit has considered and
rejected the exact arguments the defendant advances in her motion. The defendant's motion is
without any basis in the law and should be denied.
It is well settled in the Second Circuit that "a plea agreement in one U.S. Attorney's office
does not, unless otherwise stated, bind another." United States v. Prisco, 391 F. App'x 920, 921
(2d Cir. 2010) (citing United States v. Annabi, 771 F.2d 670, 672 (2d Cir. 1985) (per curiam) ("A
plea agreement binds only the office of the United States Attorney for the district in which the plea
is entered unless it affirmatively appears that the agreement contemplates a broader restriction."));
United States v. Salamelz, 152 F.3d 88, 120 (2d Cir. 1998). This Circuit "presumes a narrow
reading of the boundaries of a plea agreement unless a defendant can affirmatively establish that a
more expansive interpretation was contemplated." United States v. Laskow, 688 F. Supp. 851, 854
(E.D.N.Y. 1988) (citing Annabi, 771 F.2d at 672), aff'd, 867 F.2d 1425 (2d Cir. 1988)(tbl.). To
meet this burden, a defendant must establish that either the text of the agreement or the
"negotiations between defendant and prosecutor" indicate a promise to bind other districts. United
States v. Russo, 801 F.2d 624, 626 (2d Cir. 1986). For the reasons set forth below, the defendant
has failed to establish that the USAO-SDFL promised Epstein that the NPA would bind other
districts.

1. The Text of the Agreement Does Not Contain a Promise to Bind Other
Districts
Turning first to the text of the NPA, the terms of the agreement do not contain an
"affirmative appearance" that the parties who signed the NPA intended to bind any other U.S.
Attorney's Office. To begin with, there can be no dispute that only representatives of the USAO-
SDFL signed the agreement. There is no signature block for, nor specific mention of, any other
district or component of the Department of Justice.
In her motion, the defendant argues that the words "United States" in the NPA evince an
intent to bind the entire United States Government. (Def. Mot. 1 at 18). But the Second Circuit
has rejected this very argument: "[t]he mere use of the term `government' in the plea agreement
does not create an affirmative appearance that the agreement contemplated barring districts other
than the particular district entering into the agreement." Salameh, 152 F.3d at 120 (citations and
internal quotation marks omitted). This rule also extends to plea agreements that use the term
"United States." See United States v. Brown, No. 99-1230, 2002 WL 34244994, at *2 (2d Cir.
Apr. 26, 2002) (summary order) (plea agreement does not bind other districts "even if the plea
agreement purports to bind `the Government' or the "United States"); United States v. Bruno, 159
F. Supp. 3d 311, 321 (E.D.N.Y. 2016) ("The Court disagrees with Defendant's argument that the
phrase `United States' shows an intent to bind all United States Attorney's Offices. Rather, the
plea agreement covers only Defendant's liability in the SDFL.").
As the Second Circuit first explained in Annabi, plea agreements apply only in the district
in which they are executed, absent evidence that the parties agreed to broader restrictions:
As an original proposition, a plea agreement whereby a federal
prosecutor agrees that `the Government' will dismiss counts of an
indictment . . . might be thought to bar the United States from
reprosecuting the dismissed charges in any judicial district unless
the agreement expressly limits the scope of the agreement to the
district in which the dismissed charges are initially brought.
However, the law has evolved to the contrary. A plea agreement
binds only the office of the United States Attorney for the district in
which the plea is entered unless it affirmatively appears that the
agreement contemplates a broader restriction.
Annabi, 771 F.2d at 672 (citations omitted). Thus, under Annabi and its progeny, a plea agreement
only binds the U.S. Attorney's Office that executes the agreement, even if, as here, the agreement
references "the Government" or "the United States" and even if the agreement lacks a provision
that "expressly limits the scope of the agreement to the district" in which the agreement was
entered. 2
Confronted with this clear and controlling authority, the defendant's motion attempts to
limit the rule of Annabi by noting that some decisions applying Annabi concerned plea agreements
that also included express provisions limiting the enforceability of the agreements to the districts
in which they were entered. (Def. Mot. 1 at 22). Essentially, the defendant argues that without an
express provision limiting the scope of the agreement, every plea agreement should be interpreted
to bind the entire federal government. But the law in this Circuit holds the opposite: the
presumption is that a plea agreement in one district does not bind another, absent an affirmative
appearance that the agreement extends more broadly. See Laskow, 688 F. Supp. at 854
("Defendant's argument, in effect, is that unless there is an explicit statement to the contrary, it is
presumed that a non-prosecution agreement binds offices of the United States Attorney that are
2 The defendant's motion emphasizes that the Second Circuit has held, as a general matter, that
plea agreements are construed against the Government. (Def. Mot. 1. at 13). That does not carry
the day here, as Annabi provides a specific mode of analysis for determining whether a plea
agreement applies to other districts, and the defendant's motion fails under Annabi. More broadly,
the authorities the defendant cites for this general principle arise from circumstances in which a
defendant has sought to enforce his own a plea agreement against the Government. (See, e.g., Del
Mot. 1 at 13 (citing United States v. Feldman, 939 F.3d 182, 189 (2d Cir. 2019) (analyzing claim
by defendant seeking to enforce promises he claimed prosecutors had made to him)). Notably, the
defendant has cited no authority for the proposition that plea agreements are to be construed in
favor of a third party who was not involved in plea negotiations.
not parties to the agreement. This position is at odds with the law in this Circuit, which presumes
a narrow reading of the boundaries of a plea agreement unless a defendant can affirmatively
establish that a more expansive interpretation was contemplated.") (citing Annabi, 771 F.2d at
672). To hold otherwise would turn Annabi on its head.
The defendant next argues that the following provision of the NPA evinces an intent to bind
the entire federal government:
In consideration of Epstein's agreement to plead guilty and to
provide compensation in the manner described above, if Epstein
successfully fulfills all of the terms and conditions of this
agreement, the United States also agrees that it will not institute any
criminal charges against any potential co-conspirators of Epstein,
including but not limited to Sarah Kellen, Adriana Ross, Lesley
Groff, or Nadia Marcinkova.
NPA at 5; Def. Mot. 1 at 20-21. Aside from the reference to "United States" which, as noted
above, is insufficient, the defendant does not point to any language in this provision that
purportedly binds other districts. Instead, she argues that the absence of language specifically
limiting this provision to the USAO-SDFL demonstrates an intent to bind the entire federal
government. This argument fails, for at least three reasons. First, the defendant's argument inverts
the holding of Annabi: in this Circuit, the presumption is that plea agreements bind only the district
in which they are entered, absent affirmative indications otherwise. Put differently, the absence
of express limiting language in this provision is not an affirmative indication of a broader
application. Accordingly, under Second Circuit law, the absence of limiting language in this
specific provision provides no support for the defendant's motion.
Second, the defendant's argument acknowledges that the plain terms of the NPA
immunized Epstein from prosecution in "this District," that is, the Southern District of Florida.
See NPA at 2 ("After timely fulfilling all the terms and conditions of the Agreement, no
prosecution . . . will be instituted in this District"). In other words, the NPA was expressly limited
to the USAO-SDFL. 3 Given this provision, it would be unnatural to read a broader application to
other districts —based on no textual indicia—into the provision relating to co-conspirators.
Moreover, the defendant's reading of the NPA would require the Court to adopt the view that,
where a plea agreement contains limiting terms, they must be repeated in every paragraph in order
to have their natural and common-sense effects.
Third, and perhaps most importantly, the defendant's interpretation strains common sense.
In order to accept the defendant's arguments, the Court would have to reach the counterintuitive
conclusion that Epstein expressly bargained for broader immunity for his co-conspirators than he
did for himself. That is, under the defendant's reading of the agreement, Epstein bargained to
protect co-conspirators nationally for crimes they committed with Epstein, but Epstein only sought
protection for himself in the Southern District of Florida. The text of the agreement does not
support such a puzzling interpretation. Instead, the more natural reading of the NPA is that its
repeated references to the U.S. Attorney's Office and "this District" reflect a universal limitation
on the NPA: it applies only to the USAO-SDFL.
Finally, at several points in her motion, the defendant emphasizes that the NPA contains the
word "global," but she does not appear to argue that this creates an affirmative appearance that the
NPA binds other districts. (Def. Mot. 1 at 9, 12). Nor could she. The phrase "Epstein seeks to
resolve globally his state and federal liability," by its terms, refers to Epstein's liability alone. See
NPA at 2. Moreover, this language appears directly after several paragraphs describing
investigations conducted by the Florida State Attorney's Office and the USAO-SDFL. See id. at
1-2. Thus, in this context, the terms "global" and "state and federal liability" plainly refer to
3 In fact, the NPA states that it was executed "on the authority of R. Alexander Acosta, United
States Attorney for the Southern District of Florida." NPA at 2.
prosecutions by those two offices, and only those two offices. 4 The defendant therefore cannot
argue that the word "global" in this provision means that the NPA binds the entire federal
government.
In sum, the defendant points to nothing in the text of the NPA that could possibly be
construed to bind other districts. To the contrary, there are affirmative indications in the text that
the NPA applies only to the USAO-SDFL. Accordingly, under Annahi, the NPA is only binding
on the USAO-SDFL, and the defendant's motion fails as a matter of law.
2. The Defendant Has Offered No Evidence That the NPA Binds Other
Districts
Although a defendant may offer evidence that the negotiations between the prosecutor and
defendant contained a promise to bind other districts, Russo, 801 F.2d at 626, the defendant has
failed to do so here. The defendant's motion is replete with bare assertions and conclusory
allegations, but it fails to point to any evidence that the NPA binds the USAO-SDNY.
The lone document the defendant offers in support of her motion is a privilege log filed by
the USAO-SDFL in connection with a lawsuit filed by Epstein's victims. (Def. Mot. 1 at 22). The
log reflects that the FBI agents working with the USAO-SDFL interviewed witnesses in other
states —including New York—during their investigation. That is entirely unremarkable, since
federal investigations frequently involve gathering evidence in other states. This does not in any
way establish the substantive involvement of any other districts in the prior investigation, let alone
that the USAO-SDFL promised Epstein that the U.S. Attorney's offices in those states would be
bound by the NPA.
4 Interpreting the term "federal liability" in this provision could not be read to encompass all U.S.
Attorney's offices without also interpreting its neighboring term, "state . . liability," to refer to
every state prosecutor's office in all fifty states. The USAO-SDFL clearly did not—and could
not—make such a broad promise.
The privilege log also does not establish that the USAO-SDFL involved other U.S.
Attorney's Offices in plea negotiations with Epstein. Grasping at straws, the defendant points to
a notation in the privilege log, which contains an entry for handwritten notes, reflecting that the
prosecutor in the USAO-SDFL spoke with an Assistant U.S. Attorney in New York. (Def. Mot. 1
at 22). The notes referenced in the privilege log are attached hereto as Exhibit 1. As the notes
reflect, the prosecutor at the USAO-SDFL reached out to an Assistant U.S. Attorney at the USAO-
SDNY to ask about a civil lawsuit relating to Epstein that was handled by the Civil Division of
this Office in the 1990s. The Government is producing to defense counsel today emails that
confirm that this was the nature of the contact. 5 One of those emails is attached hereto as Exhibit
2 for the Court's reference. Put simply, those communications provide no indication that the
USAO-SDNY was involved in plea negotiations with Epstein. Rather, the USAO-SDFL asked
about an old civil case involving Epstein that an AUSA at the USAO-SDNY happened to handle
years earlier. In sum, the privilege log in no way establishes that other districts were involved in
negotiating the NPA, much less that Epstein was promised that the NPA would bind other districts.
The defendant proffers no other documentary evidence beyond the privilege log. Instead,
without any citation, she broadly alleges that "senior levels of Main Justice were directly involved
in the negotiation and approval of the NPA." (Def. Mot. 1. at 22). This vague and unsworn
allegation is not evidence. Moreover, any contacts between the USAO-SDFL and Main Justice
5 In response to the allegations raised by the defense's motion, the Government identified the
underlying notes referenced in the privilege log. The Government is producing those underlying
notes, as well as the relevant emails, to defense counsel today. The Government has also been
informed by a human resources representative that payroll records reflect that the Assistant U.S.
Attorney referenced in the privilege log left the USAO-SDNY on or about April 29, 2007, months
before the NPA was executed. Although the Government has been informed that Human
Resources records do not contain information regarding a division transfer, the Government
understands from colleagues that the Assistant U.S. Attorney worked in the Civil Division in the
1990s and worked in the Criminal Division in the 2000s.
would not, without more, establish that the USAO-SDFL intended to bind other districts, much
less that the USAO-SDFL communicated a promise to Epstein that the NPA would extend beyond
the USAO-SDFL. The defendant's failure to offer any evidence is fatal to her claim.
Although it is not the Government's burden to address and rebut every innuendo or
conclusory statement in the defendant's motion, it is significant here that the circumstances of the
NPA have been extensively litigated in a civil lawsuit, and have also been investigated by the
Department of Justice's Office of Professional Responsibility ("OPR"), resulting in a report of
OPR's findings (the "OPR Report).6 The records of both matters provide no support for the
defendant's claims.
The OPR Report notes that the USAO-SDFL periodically consulted with the Chief of the
Department of Justice Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section ("CEOS"), Andrew Oosterbaan,
during the investigation and plea discussions, and that the CEOS Chief attended a meeting with
defense counsel, during which defense counsel made a pitch that Epstein should not be prosecuted.
November 2020 Report, United States Department of Justice, Office of Professional
Responsibility, at 61-62. However, although the line prosecutor, Maria Villafaiia, subsequently
sent the CEOS Chief a draft of the NPA, the OPR Report reflects that the CEOS Chief reported to
6 The defendant's motion cites to the executive summary of the OPR Report. However, the entire
report is publicly available, is attached as Exhibit 3 hereto, and has been widely reported on and
published by the media. See, e.g., "Read the report: Investigation into the U.S. Attorney's Office
for the Southern District of Florida's Resolution of Its 2006-2008 Federal Criminal Investigation
of Jeffrey Epstein and Its Interactions with Victims during the Investigation," Wash. Post (Nov.
12, 2020), hups://www.washingtonpost.com/context/read-the-report-investigation-into-the-u-s-
attomey-s-office-for-the-southem-district-of-florida-s-resolution-of-its-2006-2008-federal-
criminal-investigation-of-jeffrey-epstein-and-its-interactions-with-victims-during-the-
investigation/db9373e8-22f8-4712-b4a7-be844d162de0/.
OPR that "he did not recall having read the NPA at this juncture and `had no involvement with it.'
OPR Report at 64 n. 105.7
Beyond this, the OPR Report and the record in the civil case note contacts with Main
Justice about the NPA, but only after the NPA was negotiated, drafted, and signed. In the civil
case, the district court detailed the history of the plea negotiations —and noted that, after the NPA
was signed, Epstein's counsel appealed to officials in Washington, D.C., hoping to avoid
enforcement of the NPA's requirement that Epstein plead guilty to state offenses, as the agreement
required. Doe I v. United States, 359 F. Supp. 3d 1201, 1212-13 (S.D. Fla. 2019). As the district
court noted, that appeal was rejected. Id. at 1213.
In particular, and following the execution of the NPA, the report reflects that the USAO-
SDFL contacted the CEOS Chief in connection with a letter from Epstein's counsel, Kenneth Starr,
protesting about complying with certain parts of the NPA. OPR Report at 95. According to the
report:
At the same time, at [USAO-SDFL supervisor] Lourie's request,
Villafafta sent the NPA and its addendum to Lourie and Oosterbaan.
Oosterbaan responded to Lourie that he was "not thrilled" about the
NPA; described Epstein's conduct as unusually "egregious,"
particularly because of its serial nature; and observed that the NPA
was "pretty advantageous for the defendant and not all that helpful
to the victims." He opined, however, that the Assistant Attorney
General would not and should not consider or address the NPA
"other than to say that she agrees with it." During her OPR
interview, [Assistant Attorney General] Fisher did not recall reading
Starr's letter or discussing it with Oosterbaan, but believed the
comment about her "agree[ing] with it" referred to a federal
prosecution of Epstein, which she believed was appropriate. She
told OPR, however, that she "played no role in" the NPA and did
not review or approve the agreement either before or after it was
signed.
The OPR Report further reflects that, at the time, a supervisor at the USAO-SDFL noted the
CEOS had "no approval authority." OPR Report at 60.
OPR Report at 95. The OPR Report further notes that, thereafter, Epstein sought to avoid
complying with the NPA entirely, and his attorneys appealed to Main Justice in the hopes of
voiding the agreement. OPR Report at 94-108. That appeal was not successful. Id. In any event,
the involvement of Main Justice alone would not begin to establish the very different proposition
that Main Justice viewed the NPA as binding any district other than USAO-SDFL, let alone
specifically considered and approved such an outcome, or communicated such a promise to
Epstein.
Further still, the record in the civil case makes clear that the USAO-SDFL's position was
that the NPA did not bind other districts. In a July 5, 2013 brief, the USAO-SDFL stated:
[T]he Non-Prosecution agreement simply obligated the government
not to prosecute Epstein in the Southern District of Florida for the
offenses set forth in the Non-Prosecution Agreement. The Non-
Prosecution Agreement does not bar the United States from bringing
federal criminal charges against Epstein for the offenses set forth in
the Non-Prosecution Agreement in any other district in the
nation. Neither does the Non-Prosecution Agreement bar
prosecution in any district for offenses not identified in the
agreement.
Government Brief, 08 Civ. 80736 (KAM), Dkt. No. 205-2, at 10-11 (S.D. Fla.) (emphasis in
original); see also OPR Report at 81, n.125 (observing that a supervisor at the USAO-SDFL
"pointed out that the NPA was not a `global resolution' and other co-conspirators could have been
prosecuted `by any other [U.S. Attorney's] office in the country.").
As the USAO-SDFL has explained, the NPA did not bind other districts, and could not.
That is because the USAO-SDFL lacked the authority to do so under applicable Department of
Justice guidelines:
Significantly, under the governing provision of the United States
Attorney's Manual, the USAO-SDFL did not have the authority to
unilaterally bar Epstein's prosecution in any other district in the
country: `No district or division shall make any agreement,
including any agreement not to prosecute, which purports to bind
any other district(s) or division without the express written approval
of the United States Attomey(s) in each affected district and/or the
Assistant Attorney General of the Criminal Division.'
Government Brief, 08 Civ. 80736 (KAM), Dkt. No. 205-2, at 11 n. I I (S.D. Fla.) (quoting United
States Attorney's Manual, 9-27.641 (Multi -District (Global) Agreement Requests)). Significantly,
this brief was signed by the same prosecutor who negotiated and signed the NPA. Id. Although
the defendant makes the sweeping, self-serving, and unsupported allegation that "the government
had every reason to foresee a potential prosecution of Epstein's co-conspirators in this District
and, after multiple layers of review within the Department of Justice, intended to agree to preclude
it," the USAO-SDFL's brief says otherwise. (Def. Mot. 1 at 22). Further still, the record
developed in both civil litigation and OPR's investigation does not support this claim.
at
As the foregoing makes clear, the defendant has failed to produce any evidence that the USAO-
SDFL promised Epstein that other districts would be bound by the NPA. There is no "affirmative
appearance" that the NPA binds other districts, and the motion should be denied. Under Annabi
and its progeny, the defendant has failed to establish that the NPA binds other districts. For this
reason alone, the defendant's motion should be dismissed, in keeping with the well-established
law in this Circuit. 8
8 In her motion, the defendant asks this Court to apply a bizarre and unprecedented choice-of-
federal-law doctrine, under which the defendant asks the Court to apply non-existent rulings from
the Eleventh Circuit on an issue that Court does not appear to have reached. (Def. Mot. 1 at 23-
25). This argument has no legal foundation, and the defendant offers no authority for the
proposition that federal plea agreements are governed by the choice of law principles that apply to
conflicting state laws. Annabi is the binding law of this Circuit, and this Court must apply it.

B. The NPA Does Not Immunize Maxwell from Prosecution
Even if the NPA bound this District —which it does not—the NPA provides no basis for
dismissing the Indictment. The NPA does not protect the defendant for at least two reasons. First,
the text of the NPA specifically limits the scope of the NPA to certain federal crimes committed
between 2001 and 2007, and thus the NPA does not apply to the distinct offenses and time periods
charged in the Indictment. Second, the NPA does not protect the defendant at all, because the
mere use of the word "co-conspirator" does not establish that the defendant was among the class
of persons contemplated by the agreement, much less that the defendant has standing to enforce it.
1. The NPA Is Limited to Particular Crimes Between 2001 and 2007
Contrary to the defendant's assertions, the NPA did not provide carte blanche immunity to
Epstein or his "co-conspirators." In fact, the NPA contains detailed provisions that limit the scope
of the crimes immunized in the agreement.
The NPA begins by outlining the scope of the USAO-SDFL investigation. delineating the
timeframe of the offense conduct under investigation ("from in or around 2001 through in or
around September 2007"), and listing each and every statutory offense under investigation. NPA
at 1. The NPA does this for a reason, because these terms are later used in the agreement to set
the boundaries of immunity. In particular, the agreement provides:
[N]o prosecution for the offenses set out on pages 1 and 2 of this
agreement, nor any other offenses that have been the subject of the
joint investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the
United States Attorney's Office, nor any offenses that arose from
the Federal Grand Jury investigation will be instituted in this
District, and the charges against Epstein if any, will be dismissed.
NPA at 2. Thus, the NPA barred the USAO-SDFL from prosecuting Epstein for the specific
offenses enumerated in the NPA.9 While these same limitations are not repeated in the provision
that purports to immunize "co-conspirators," these limitations apply with equal force across the
agreement, because that is the only common-sense way to read the NPA. Indeed, and as noted
above in a related context, it would be exceedingly strange to interpret the "co-conspirator"
provision to extend broader immunity than Epstein negotiated for himself.
The defendant may assert that the "co-conspirator" provision has absolutely no limitations,
but such an argument would lead to absurd results. In particular, in arguing that the "co-
conspirator" provision lacks any temporal or statutory limitations whatsoever, the defendant seems
to claim that the NPA immunized her for future crimes including, for example, perjury offenses
that she is charged with committing almost a decade after the NPA was executed. (Def. Mot. 1 at
32 ("For the foregoing reasons, Ms. Maxwell respectfully requests that the Court dismiss the
indictment.")). Although the defendant does not highlight this point in her motion —perhaps
recognizing how absurd it would be—that is the natural consequence of her illogical interpretation
of the NPA. Despite advancing an argument that strains common sense, the defendant cites no
case in which a court has interpreted a plea agreement to bar prosecution for crimes that pre- or
post-dated the period covered by the agreement. The Government is aware of no such authority.
See United States v. Hallahan, 756 F.3d 962, 974 (7th Cir. 2014) (rejecting defense argument that
plea agreement barred prosecution for subsequent bail jumping, and, in interpreting the
9 By its plain terms, the NPA did not immunize Epstein for his "background," as the defendant
suggests. (Def. Mot. 1 at 27). This provision refers, instead, to a list of "offenses" under federal
law. Indeed, it is unclear how any plea agreement could immunize a defendant's "background."
Similarly, the fact that the USAO-SDFL interviewed Minor Victim-2 does not mean that this case
"arose out of" the USAO-SDFL investigation, an assertion the defendant's motion does not explain
or support with evidence. As the Indictment makes clear, the events underpinning the Indictment
involve multiple victims and specific legal charges that were not within the scope of the USAO-
SDFL investigation. As discussed in greater detail below, Minor Victim- I and Minor Victim -3
were never interviewed by the USAO-SDFL, and they did not agree to speak with law enforcement
until 2019.
Government's promises in the plea agreement to only cover past crimes, observing that "not
limiting the prohibition to past crimes would make it absurd and probably illegal") (citing Aronson

v. K. Arakelian, Inc., 154 F.2d 231, 233 (7th Cir. 1946) ("[A] contract will not be presumed to
have imposed an absurd or impossible condition on one of the parties, but will be interpreted as
the parties must be supposed to have understood the conditions at the time.")).
Finally, the defendant claims that the NPA covers all violations of the Mann Act. (Def.
Mot. 1 at 26 n.4). Not so. The NPA lists specific statutory provisions within the Mann Act, but
none of the provisions contained in the Indictment. In particular, the NPA expressly covers
violations of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2422(b), 2423(b), and 2423(e), but it does not include the particular
provisions charged in the Indictment against Maxwell, which alleges violations of §§ 2422(a) and
2423(a). These are plainly not the same crimes, and a plea agreement cannot be read to immunize
unnamed crimes in the general ballpark of the specific crimes enumerated in the agreement. The
defendant cites no authority that supports her overbroad reading of this provision.
Accordingly, the NPA immunizes only certain, specific offenses, none of which are
contained in the Indictment. As a result, the defendant cannot invoke the NPA to seek the dismissal
of the Indictment.
2. The NPA Does Not Confer Enforceable Rights on Maxwell
Even if this Court were to construe the NPA beyond its plain terms to preclude prosecutions
for the crimes contained in the Indictment, the defendant has established neither that those
protections extend to Maxwell specifically, nor that she has standing to pursue those protections.
The defendant asks this Court to interpret the NPA according to contract principles, and
accord the defendant standing to enforce the NPA as a third party beneficiary. As a general matter,
plea agreements are interpreted using principles from contract law, but that maxim is not without
limitations. As the defendant's motion recognizes, the Second Circuit has emphasized that plea
agreements differ from commercial contracts in meaningful respects. (Def. Mot. 1 at 30 (citing
United States v. Feldman, 939 F.3d 182, 189 (2d Cir. 2019) ("[W]hile the district court's analysis
might have been compelling with respect to a contract arising out of commercial negotiations
among private parties, we believe the court did not correctly apply the standards that govern the
interpretation of plea agreements with the government. We have long recognized that plea
agreements are significantly different from commercial contracts."))). Accordingly, although the
third party beneficiary doctrine is a tenet of contract law, its application to plea agreements under
federal law is a separate question.
The defendant correctly notes that plea agreements may address leniency for third parties.
(Def. Mot. 1 at 15). However, it does not necessarily follow that a third party may enforce such a
promise. Indeed, it is far from clear that, under federal law, a third party may enforce a plea
agreement. At least one court in this Circuit has noted the absence of authority that a third party
has standing to enforce another individual's plea agreement. See Santobello v. United States, No.
94 Cr. 119 (RPP), 1998 WL 113950, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 13, 1998) ("Even if Santobello could
establish the existence of plea agreements between the Government and his co-defendants, there
is little known authority that would allow him to enforce the agreements as a third party
beneficiary.") (citing United States v. Lopez, 944 F.2d 33, 36-37 (1st Cir. 1991)).
Following this logic, at least one court has concluded that third parties lack standing to
enforce plea agreements. In United States v. Mariamma Viju, the defendant claimed that the
Government had entered into a plea agreement with her husband, under which the Government
had promised not to prosecute her. No. 15 Cr. 240, 2016 WL 107841, at *1 (N.D. Tex. Jan. 11,
2016). Observing that the principles governing interpretation of plea agreements diverge in many
respects from those underlying contract law, the district court concluded that "third -party
beneficiaries have no contractual right to enforce plea agreements." Id. at '3-4. The court
reasoned, "[t]he right to enforce a plea deal does not exist for its own sake; rather, it is a means to
achieve fairness in plea bargaining." Id. at '4. That is because a defendant has the right to enforce
his plea agreement, and "enforcement by third parties adds nothing to protecting the defendant's
right." Id. The same holds true here.
In support of her claim that she has standing to enforce the NPA, the defendant relies upon
three district court decisions, none of which analyzed the threshold question of whether third party
standing concepts from contract law apply to plea agreements. In United States v. Florida West
Int 'I Airways, Inc., 853 F. Supp. 2d 1209, 1228 (S.D. Fla. 2012), the district court applied the third
party beneficiary doctrine to a former airline employee based on a prior plea agreement with the
airline that immunized, among others, current and former employees of the airline and its
subsidiaries. In its analysis, however, the court applied the doctrine without analyzing the question
of whether third party beneficiary standing principles apply to plea agreements. Id. For similar
reasons, the defendant's reliance on United States v. El-Sadig, 133 F. Supp. 2d 600, 608-09 (N.D.
Ohio 2001) is misplaced. In that case, the court permitted a third party to invoke a plea agreement,
but it did not analyze or address whether third party standing rules apply to plea agreements. Id.
Likewise, in United States v. CFW Const. Co., 583 F. Supp. 197, 203 (D.S.C. 1984), the court
applied the third party beneficiary doctrine, but relied solely on contracts treatises for support, and
did not analyze whether that doctrine should be applied to plea agreements.
In any event, even if third party beneficiaries had standing to enforce federal plea
agreements, the defendant has failed to establish that she is a third party beneficiary of the NPA.
In order to establish that she has enforceable rights under the NPA, the defendant must show that
"a direct and primary object of the contracting parties was to confer a benefit on the third party."
Fla. W. Intl Ainvays, Inc., 853 F. Supp. 2d at 1228 (quoting Boclzese v. Town of Ponce Inlet, 405
F.3d 964, 982 (11th Cir. 2005)). In other words, "the intent of the parties is the key" to evaluating
whether an individual is a third party beneficiary. Id.
Here, the defendant has offered no evidence that the parties intended to confer a benefit on
her in particular, or that her crimes in the 1990s make her a member of the class of "co-
conspirators" the parties had in mind when they negotiated the NPA. To the contrary, the OPR's
investigation of the circumstances surrounding the inclusion of this provision in the NPA strongly
undercuts any such argument, and OPR's findings demonstrate that the parties did not intend to
confer a benefit on the defendant. With respect to the "co-conspirator" provision, the OPR Report
concluded, in relevant part:
Other than various drafts of the NPA and of a federal plea
agreement, OPR found little in the contemporaneous records
mentioning the provision and nothing indicating that the subjects
discussed or debated it—or even gave it much consideration. Drafts
of the NPA and of the federal plea agreement show that the final
broad language promising not to prosecute "any potential co-
conspirators of Epstein" evolved from a more narrow provision
sought by the defense. The provision expanded as [USAO-SDFL
prosecutor Maria] Villafafia and defense counsel exchanged drafts
of, first, a proposed federal plea agreement and, then, of the NPA,
with apparently little analysis and no substantive discussion within
the USAO about the Provision.
OPR Report at 166. With respect to Maxwell in particular, OPR interviewed Maria Villafaiia, the
lead prosecutor on the case, and noted:
Villafafia acknowledged that investigators were aware of Epstein's
longtime relationship with a close female friend who was a well-
known socialite, but, according to Villafafia, in 2007, they "didn't
have any specific evidence against her." Accordingly, Villafaiia
believed that the only "co-conspirators" of Epstein who would
benefit from the provision were the four female assistants identified
by name.
OPR Report at 167.1° After reviewing the facts and circumstances of the negotiation, OPR
concluded that "the evidence does not show that [Former USAO-SDFL U.S. Attorney Alex]
Acosta, [Former USAO-SDFL supervisor Andrew] Lourie, or Villafafia agreed to the
nonprosecution provision to protect any of Epstein's political, celebrity, or other influential
associates." OPR Report at 168."
In view of OPR's conclusions —and in the absence of any evidence to the contrary
proffered by the defendant —the defendant has failed to establish that that she was an intended
third party beneficiary of the NPA. Accordingly, the defendant lacks standing to enforce the NPA.
C. The Defendant Has Offered No Basis for Additional Discovery or a Hearing
The defendant's motion for discovery and a hearing fares no better. Lacking any
evidence —much less any legal authority —that the NPA applies to this District or the crimes in
the Indictment, the defendant asks the Court to order discovery and conduct a hearing. In short,
10 The OPR Report further reflects that in OPR's interview of Villafafia, she reported that she did
not have anyone in mind aside from the four individuals named in the "co-conspirator" provision:
"Villafafia told OPR that she was willing to include a non-prosecution provision for Epstein's co-
conspirators, who at the time she understood to be the four women named in the proposed
agreement, because the USAO was not interested in prosecuting those individuals if Epstein
entered a plea. Villafafia told OPR, `[W]e considered Epstein to be the top of the food chain, and
we wouldn't have been interested in prosecuting anyone else.' She did not consider the possibility
that Epstein might be trying to protect other, unnamed individuals, and no one, including the FBI
case agents, raised that concern." OPR Report at 70. Further, the OPR Report notes that:
"Villafafia told OPR that, apart from the women named in the NPA, the investigation had not
developed evidence of `any other potential co-conspirators.'" Id. at 81. Similarly, the report
reflects that a supervisor at USAO-SDFL told OPR "that it never occurred to him that the reference
to potential co-conspirators was directed toward any of the high-profile individuals who were at
the time or subsequently linked with Epstein." OPR Report at 80-81.
" Although the defendant correctly notes that the OPR Report reflects that the prosecutor remarked
that Epstein "wanted to make sure that he's the only one who takes the blame for what happened,"
OPR Report at 167, that desire explains the existence of the "co-conspirator" provision, but it does
not inform its meaning or scope.
the defendant asks this Court to authorize an extensive and burdensome fishing expedition,
premised on the defendant's pure conjecture. The Court should deny the motion.
Although the defendant asserts that the Court is obligated to conduct a hearing, she has
failed to establish that any hearing is warranted. The defendant argues that courts conduct
evidentiary hearings "where the existence or scope of a plea agreement or non-prosecution
agreement is in genuine dispute." (Def. Mot. 1 at 29). But the defendant has not established any
genuine factual dispute in this case that a hearing would be required to resolve. The defendant has
offered bare conclusions in support of her motion, which are refuted by governing law, record
evidence, and the four corners of the agreement itself. That is not a basis for a hearing.
As the Second Circuit explained in United States v. Aleman, 286 F.3d 86 (2d Cir. 2002), "a
district court need not conduct a hearing every time a defendant summarily accuses the government
of failing to live up to an alleged bargain." Id. at 91. In that case, the court held that a hearing
was required because the defendant had submitted affidavits from his attorney, as well as
corroborating affidavits from other attorneys, and the Government had not submitted any evidence.
Id.; see also United States v. Sattar, 272 F. Supp. 2d 348, 383 (S.D.N.Y. 2003) (applying Aleman,
and ordering an evidentiary hearing based upon the defendant's submission of an affidavit from
an attorney with knowledge of the alleged oral agreement). Similarly, in United States v. Feldman,
939 F.3d 182 (2d Cir. 2019), the Second Circuit held that a hearing was required based on the
defendant's uncontested assertions about specific representations made to him by a prosecutor. Id.
at 184, 190. Here, by contrast, the defendant has offered no evidence in support of her allegations.
The defendant cannot seriously argue that she has made the type of showing that requires a
hearing. For example, she has not offered any affidavits from Epstein's former defense attorneys
claiming that the USAO-SDFL made promises that were not contained in the NPA. Nor has she
pointed to anything in the extensive record of either the OPR investigation or the civil litigation
surrounding the NPA that would suggest that the NPA applies to this District, or to the crimes in
the Indictment, or to Maxwell. In the absence of any such evidence —and in the face of substantial
contrary evidence gathered in the civil litigation and OPR investigation —the Court has no
obligation to conduct a hearing.
For similar reasons, the defendant's motion for discovery should be denied. To the extent
the defendant seeks discovery under Rule 16, she has failed to meet her burden. A defendant
seeking discovery under Rule 16 "must make a prima fade showing of materiality and must offer
more than the conclusory allegation that the requested evidence is material." United States v.
Urena, 989 F. Supp. 2d 253, 261 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) (citations omitted). Here, the defendant has
offered nothing more than her conjecture that some unspecified evidence might exist. The motion
should be denied.

II. The Indictment Is Timely
Counts One through Four are timely charged because the applicable limitations period, 18
U.S.C. § 3283 (2003), permits prosecution for offenses "involving the sexual or physical abuse...
of a child" at any time "during the life of the child," and each of the victims identified in the
Indictment remains alive. Maxwell contends that Section 3283 should not be applied to conduct
that predated its amendment in 2003 (Def. Mot. 2), but that argument is contrary to the text of the
statute, Congress's clear intent when extending the statute of limitations, and the decisions of other
circuits and district courts in this Circuit. In effect, the defendant's motion asks this Court to break
new ground, and become the first court to hold that Section 3283 applies only prospectively.
In the alternative, Maxwell argues that Section 3283 is inapplicable because the offenses
charged in the Indictment do not "involv[e] the sexual or physical abuse . . . of a child." (Def.
Mot. 2 at 12-14). Yet her argument runs contrary to the weight of authority that has adopted the
common-sense view that crimes that necessarily entail the sexual or physical abuse of children
"involv[e] the sexual or physical abuse of a child." This Court should do the same and deny the
motion.
A. Statutory Background
Between 1990 and 2006, Congress passed a series of laws that expanded the statute of
limitations for prosecutions of crimes against minors, ultimately extending the statute of
limitations to the lifetime of the minor victim and, for certain offenses, eliminating the statute of
limitations entirely. These laws reflect a virtually unbroken congressional policy that the default
five-year statute of limitations for federal crimes, 18 U.S.C. § 3282, is inadequate for such
offenses. An extended statute of limitations is necessary because "child sex abuse offenses . . .
may be difficult to detect quickly," in part because children often first report their abuse long after
it occurs. Weingarten v. United States, 865 F.3d 48, 54 (2d Cir. 2017) (citing, e.g., David McCord,
Expert Psychological Testimony About Child Complainants in Sexual Abuse Prosecutions, 77 J.
Crim. L. & Criminology I, 60-61 (1986)).
In 1990, Congress enacted a new statute of limitation for certain crimes against children,
which stated: "No statute of limitation that would otherwise preclude prosecution for an offense
involving the sexual or physical abuse of a child under the age of 18 years shall preclude such a
prosecution before the child reaches the age of 25 years." Crime Control Act of 1990, Pub. L. No.
101-647, tit. II, § 225(a), 104 Stat. 4789, 4798 (codified at 18 U.S.C. § 3509(k) (1990)). In 1994,
Congress re-codified this provision, moving it to 18 U.S.C. § 3283 with identical language.
Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994, Pub. L. No. 103-322, tit. XXXIII,
§ 330018(a), 108 Stat. 1796, 2149 (codified at 18 U.S.C. § 3283 (1994)) ("No statute of limitations
that would otherwise preclude prosecution for an offense involving the sexual or physical abuse
of a child under the age of 18 years shall preclude such prosecution before the child reaches the
age of 25.").
As the Second Circuit has recognized, "after nearly a decade, Congress began to view even
the extended statute of limitations period in the 1994 version of § 3283 as `inadequate in many
cases' because it released from criminal liability sex abusers whose crimes were not brought to the
attention of federal authorities until after their victims turned twenty-five." Weingarten, 865 F.3d
at 54 (citing H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 108-66, at 54 (2003)). Accordingly, in April 2003, Congress
amended Section 3283 to permit the prosecution of sex offenses against minors at any time during
the lifetime of the minor victim. Prosecutorial Remedies and Tools Against the Exploitation of
Children Today Act ("PROTECT Act") of 2003, Pub. L. No. 108-21, tit. II, § 202, 117 Stat. 650,
660 (codified at 18 U.S.C. § 3283 (2003)) ("No statute of limitations that would otherwise preclude
prosecution for an offense involving the sexual or physical abuse, or kidnaping, of a child under
the age of 18 years shall preclude such prosecution during the life of the child.").
In January 2006, Congress further amended Section 3283 to its current form to permit the
prosecution of such offenses during the lifetime of the victim or ten years after the offense,
whichever is longer. Violence Against Women and Department of Justice Reauthorization Act of
2006, Pub. L. No. 109-162, tit. XI, § 1182(c), 119 Stat. 2960, 3126 (codified at 18 U.S.C. § 3283
(2006)) ("No statute of limitations that would otherwise preclude prosecution for an offense
involving the sexual or physical abuse, or kidnaping, of a child under the age of 18 years shall
preclude such prosecution during the life of the child, or for ten years after the offense, whichever
is longer.").
Finally, later that same year, Congress enacted a new statute as part of the Adam Walsh
Child Protection and Safety Act of 2006, Pub. L. No. 109-248, 120 Stat. 587. That statute
eliminated the statute of limitations entirely for certain crimes involving the sexual exploitation of
minors. Id. tit. II, § 211(1), 120 Stat. at 616 (codified at 18 U.S.C. § 3299).
B. The 2003 Amendment to Section 3283 Applies Retroactively
Counts One through Four of the Indictment charge crimes that occurred between 1994
and 1997. At the time of the offense conduct, the applicable statute of limitations, 18 U.S.C.
§ 3283 (1994), ran until "the child reaches the age of 25." However, in 2003, while the statute of
limitations had not yet run for the crimes charged in the Indictment, 12 Congress amended the
statute, extending the limitations period to permit a prosecution at any time "during the life of the
child." 18 U.S.C. § 3283 (2003). Because the victims are all alive, the Indictment is timely under
the 2003 amendment.
Put simply, the 2003 amendment applies to any conduct that could have been charged at
the time of its enactment. The legislative purpose behind Section 3283 and a plain reading of the
statute compel this conclusion, and courts have repeatedly held that the 2003 amendment applies
retroactively, provided that the statute of limitations had not run for the offense at the time of the
amendment. See, e.g., United States v. Leo Sure Chief, 438 F.3d 920, 922-25 (9th Cir. 2006)
("Because Congress evinced a clear intent to extend, rather than shorten, the statute of limitations
applicable to sexual abuse crimes, and because there is no ex post facto problem here, the
prosecution was timely.") (citing United States v. Jeffries, 405 F.3d 682, 685 (8th Cir. 2005), cert.
denied, 546 U.S. 1007 (2005)); United States v. Brown, 800 F. App'x 455, 461 (9th Cir. 2020)
("Because Congress evinced a clear intent to extend the statute of limitations for these types of
12 The timeliness of the charges in the Indictment in 2003 is discussed in greater detail below.
crimes in its amendments, and because there is no ex post facto problem here, the prosecution was
timely."), cert. denied, No. 20-5064, S.Ct. , 2021 WL 78235 (Jan. 11, 2021); United States v.
Pierre -Louis, No. 16 Cr. 541 (CM), 2018 WL 4043140, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 9, 2018) (denying
motion to dismiss child exploitation charges as time-barred) ("Defendant's argument rests on the
erroneous premise that the law requires the defendant to have committed the charged offense after
the effective date of the extension of the statute of limitations for the charge to not be time-barred.
As long as the original statute of limitations had not lapsed when the extension went into effect,
the prosecution is not time-barred."); United States v. Sensi, No. 08 Cr. 253, 2010 WL 2351484,
at *2 (D. Conn. June 7, 2010) (holding that the 2003 amendment of Section 3283 applies to pre-
enactment conduct, and rejecting the argument "that the lack of a savings clause in the 2003
version of section 3283 is fatal to extending the statute of limitations."); United State v. Nader,
425 F. Supp. 3d 619, 624-30 (E.D. Va. 2019) (holding that the 2003 amendment of Section 3283
applies to pre-enactment conduct).
In Landgraf v. USI Film Products, 511 U.S. 244 (1994), the Supreme Court set forth a
two-part framework for determining whether a statute applies retroactively. At step one of the
analysis, "if Congress `expressly prescribed' that a statute applies retroactively to antecedent
conduct, `the inquiry ends[] and the court enforces the statute as it is written,' save for
constitutional concerns." Weingarten, 865 F.3d at 54-55 (quoting In re Enter. Mon. Acceptance

Co. Sec. Litig. ("Enterprise'), 391 F.3d 401, 405-06 (2d Cir. 2004)). However, "when a statute
`is ambiguous or contains no express command' regarding retroactivity, a reviewing court must
determine whether applying the statute to antecedent conduct would create presumptively
impermissible retroactive effects." Id. For the reasons set forth below, the 2003 amendment of
18 U.S.C. § 3283 satisfies both steps of Landgraf, and should be applied to pre-enactment conduct.
1. The 2003 Amendment Satisfies Step One of Landgraf
At step one of the Landgraf analysis, the question is whether Congress has "expressly
prescribed the statute's proper reach." Landgraf, 511 U.S. at 280. When evaluating Congress's
intent at step one of the Landgraf inquiry, the Second Circuit has considered both the text of the
statute and the legislative history. Enterprise, 391 F.3d at 406-08. In this case, the amended
versions of Section 3283 evince Congress's express intent to extend the statute of limitations. The
text and history of Section 3283 firmly establish that, with each amendment of the statute of
limitations, Congress intended to repeal and replace the prior version of the statute and thereby
extend the time to bring live charges of child sexual abuse.
The 2003 amendment, like the 1994 version of the statute, specifically states that "[n]o
statute of limitations that would otherwise preclude prosecution" of a child sexual offense "shall
preclude" prosecution of such offense during the life of the victim. 18 U.S.C. § 3283 (2003).
Claims that were live in 2003 were, at the time, subject to the then-existing statute of limitations,
which ran until the victims reached the age of 25. Whenever that statute of limitations ran, it would
"otherwise preclude prosecution." Instead, that statute of limitations was replaced by the 2003
amendment.
The Eighth and Ninth Circuits have both held that Congress intended to extend the statute
of limitations for live claims of sexual abuse. In United States v. Jef•ies, 405 F.3d 682 (8th Cir.
2005), the Eighth Circuit reasoned that "both the title and wording of § 3509(k) indicate that
Congress intended by it to extend the general statute of limitations. . § 3509(k) was later
recodified at § 3283 and continued to extend the statute of limitations in child abuse cases." Id. at
684 (citing United States v. Johns, 15 F.3d 740, 743 (8th Cir. 1994) (holding that an earlier version
of § 3509(k) applied to conduct predating its enactment in 1990)). The Eighth Circuit's
reasoning —which addressed earlier versions of the statute —applies with equal, if not greater,
force to the 2003 amendment, which established an even broader statute of limitations. Following
Jqffries, the Ninth Circuit has similarly held that Section 3283 applies retroactively, because
"Congress evinced a clear intent to extend" the statute of limitations. Leo Sure Chief, 438 F.3d at
924 (citing Jeffries, 405 F.3d at 685).
Not only does the wording of the statute clearly express that Congress intended for the 2003
amendment to be the only governing statute of limitations for live claims of child sexual abuse,
but the legislative history also supports this conclusion. The Joint Report accompanying the 2003
amendment explains that Congress wanted to expand the statute of limitations out of concern that
the 1994 amendment did not go far enough to ensure that perpetrators of child sexual abuse were
held to account:
While [the statute of limitations allowing for prosecution until the
victim reaches age 25] is better than a flat five-year rule [under

Section 3282], it remains inadequate in many cases. For example, a
person who abducted and raped a child could not be prosecuted
beyond this extended limit — even if DNA matching conclusively
identified him as the perpetrator one day after the victim turned 25.
H.R. Conf. Rep. No. 108-66, at 54 (2003). Congress's express intention was to prevent
perpetrators of crimes against children from escaping justice based on a timing technicality.
Moreover, since the 2003 amendment extended the statute of limitations throughout the lifetime
of the victim, it is clear that Congress expressly authorized prosecutions to occur decades after
crimes had been committed.13
13 Although the defendant claims that prosecuting her crimes now presents unique fairness
concerns, there is nothing unusual about prosecuting sex crimes long after they have occurred.
See, e.g., United States v. Brown, 800 F. App'x 455, 461 (9th Cir. 2020) (2014 indictment charging,
among other crimes, sex trafficking offenses dating to 2000 and 2001), cert. denied, No. 20-5064,
-- S. Ct. -- , 2021 WL 78235 (Jan. 11, 2021); United States v. Pierre -Louis, No. 16 Cr. 541 (CM),
2018 WL 4043140, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 9, 2018) (2016 indictment covering conduct going back
to 1998); United State v. Nader, 425 F. Supp. 3d 619, 622 (E.D. Va. 2019) (2019 indictment for
The defendant argues that Congress did not intend for Section 3283 to apply to pre-
enactment conduct, and asserts that the legislative history supports this interpretation. Specifically,
the defendant points to an earlier version of the bill, which contained an express retroactivity
provision that was not included in the final version of the statute. (Def. Mot. 2 at 6-7). The
defendant's argument on this point is both misleading and unpersuasive. The defendant quotes
Senator Patrick Leahy's comments on the 2003 conference committee report to the effect that "the
conference agreed to drop language from the original House-passed bill that would have extended
the limitations period retroactively." (Def. Mot. 2 at 7). This is a selective quotation; the full
statement regarding retroactivity is as follows:
A final point on section 202: I am pleased that the conference agreed
to drop language from the original House-passed bill that would
have extended the limitations period retroactively. That language,
which would have revived the government's authority to prosecute
crimes that were previously time-barred, is of doubtful
constitutionality. We are already pushing the constitutional
envelope with respect to several of the "virtual porn" provisions in
this bill. I am pleased that we are not doing so in section 202 as
well.
149 Cong. Rec. 55137, S5147 (Apr. 10, 2003) (statement of Sen. Leahy) (emphasis added). As
the full quotation makes clear, the legislative history does not support the conclusion that when
Congress amended Section 3283, it declined to adopt the language in the House-passed bill
because it wanted the lengthened statute of limitations to apply only prospectively. Instead,
Senator Leahy's comments indicate that Congress declined to add language that would allow for
the resurrection of time-barred prosecutions, in violation of the Ex Post Facto Clause. 14 But that
conduct in 2000). Indeed, that is precisely what Congress authorized when it extended the statute
of limitations for such crimes through the lifetime of the victim.
14 Moreover, the fact that Congress considered, but ultimately omitted, retroactivity language does
not end the Landgraf inquiry, as the defendant suggests. Indeed, Landgraf itself makes this clear.
In that case, the statute at issue had a predecessor, which contained a retroactivity provision. That
concern is entirely separate from extending the statute of limitations for live claims, which is what
Congress did here. Critically —and as discussed in greater detail below —there is no Ex Post Facto
Clause issue in this case, because the statute of limitations for Counts One through Four had not
yet expired when the limitations period was extended in 2003.15
Accepting the defendant's argument would undermine Congress's plain purpose in
extending the limitations period. In 1990, 2003, and 2006, Congress extended —and ultimately
abolished —the statute of limitations to ensure that prosecutors could seek justice for child sex
abuse victims who come forward or identify their abusers after a delay. Applying the 2003 statute
only prospectively subverts that purpose by exempting all past offenders. According to the
defendant, in 2003, Congress wanted to ensure that every perpetrator who abused a minor in the
future was subject to prosecution for the lifetime of the minor, but Congress simultaneously was
version was vetoed by the President, and the final version of the statute omitted the retroactivity
provision. As the Supreme Court explained, "[t]he omission of the elaborate retroactivity
provision of the 1990 bill—which was by no means the only source of political controversy over
that legislation —is not dispositive because it does not tell us precisely where the compromise was
struck in the 1991 Act." Landgraf, 511 U.S. at 256. Indeed, "[i]t [was] entirely possible —indeed,
highly probable —that, because it was unable to resolve the retroactivity issue with the clarity of
the 1990 legislation, Congress viewed the matter as an open issue to be resolved by the courts."

Id. at 261.
15 Minor Victim-1 and Minor Victim-2 were both younger than 25 in 2003, when Congress
extended the limitations period. Minor Victim-3 was not, but this does not alter the inquiry,
because the Indictment does not contain any counts that relate to Minor Victim-3 alone. Instead,
she is one of multiple victims of the conspiracies charged in Counts One and Three. The inclusion
of the overt acts relating to Minor Victim-3 in an otherwise timely conspiracy count does not
render that count untimely. To the contrary, for conspiracy counts, the Government is only
required to prove that one overt act in furtherance of the conspiracy occurred within the limitations
period. United States v. Ben Zvi, 242 F.3d 89, 97 (2d Cir. 2001). Thus, the defendant is incorrect
to assert that the government is "barred" from prosecuting the defendant for any offense against
Minor Victim-3. (Def. Mot. 2 at 10, n.3). Instead, there is no statute of limitations issue here so
long as the jury is properly instructed at trial that it must find at least one overt act within the
limitations period—Le., one overt act that does not relate to Minor Victim -3.
content to let all previous perpetrators avoid prosecution whenever their victims turned twenty-
five. No such intent is manifest in either the text or in Senator Leahy's statement.
The reach of Section 3283 is clear. Because Congress has expressly extended the statute of
limitations to pre-enactment conduct, the Court should resolve its analysis at Landgraf step one
and apply the statute as Congress intended. In the alternative, however, the statute is—at worst—
ambiguous. If the Court takes that view, it should proceed to Landgraf step two.
2. The 2003 Amendment Satisfies Step Two of Landgraf
If the Court were to determine that the legislative intent behind Section 3283 is ambiguous,
the inquiry then extends to the second step of the Landgraf analysis, which examines the
retroactive effects of the statute. As the Supreme Court explained in Landgraf, "[a] statute does
not operate `retrospectively' merely because it is applied in a case arising from conduct antedating
the statute's enactment, or upsets expectations based in prior law." 511 U.S. at 269. Instead, the
question is whether the statute "would impair rights a party possessed when he acted, increase a
party's liability for past conduct, or impose new duties with respect to transactions already
completed." Vernon v. Cassadaga Valley Cent. School Dist, 49 F.3d 886, 890 (2d Cir. 1995)
(quoting Landgraf, 511 U.S. at 280). Applying Section 3283 here would have none of those
effects. Maxwell's rights, liabilities, and duties were governed by the substantive criminal statutes
governing her conduct. Until the statute of limitations expired, Maxwell had the same legal
liability, the same rights, and the same incentives to retain evidence. A statute extending that
period attaches no new legal consequences; rather, it preserves the status quo. Therefore, the
statute does not operate "retrospectively" within the meaning of Landgraf. See Cruz v. Maypa,
773 F.3d 138, 145 (4th Cir. 2014) ("[A]pplying [an] extended limitations period to claims that
were unexpired at the time of its enactment does not give rise to an impermissible retroactive effect
under Landgraf.").
The Second Circuit has considered in three cases whether retroactive statutes of limitation
are permissible under Landgraf. In Vernon v. Cassadaga Valley Cent. School Dist, the Second
Circuit held that a new statute shortening the filing period for a civil claim applied retroactively.
In reaching that conclusion, the Court noted that "Landgraf and other cases countenance treating
statutes of limitations differently from statutory provisions that affect substantive rights," because
statutes of limitations regulate secondary, and not primary conduct. Vernon, 49 F.3d. at 890-91.
In In re Enterprise Mortgage Acceptance Co., 391 F.3d 401 (2d Cir. 2004), the Second Circuit
held that applying an extended statute of limitations retroactively created impermissible retroactive
effects. Yet in that case, it was critical to the Court's analysis that—unlike here—the statute
revived claims that were previously time-barred. Id. at 410 ("In our view, the resurrection of
previously time-barred claims has an impermissible retroactive effect.").
In Weingarten, the Second Circuit considered, but did not ultimately reach, the issue of
whether Section 3283 applies retroactively.16 In discussing the second step of Landgraf, the Court
observed: "Courts have routinely recognized a difference between revoking a vested statute of
limitations defense and extending a filing period for live claims." Id. at 57 (collecting cases).
Moreover, in an opinion by Judge Learned Hand, the Second Circuit explained why extending an
active criminal statute of limitations does not offend any concept of fairness:
Certainly it is one thing to revive a prosecution already dead, and
another to give it a longer lease of life. The question turns upon how
much violence is done to our instinctive feelings of justice and fair
play. For the state to assure a man that he has become safe from its
16 The First Circuit has similarly considered this issue in the context of an ineffective assistance of
counsel claim and declined to reach the issue of whether Section 3283 applies retroactively. United
States v. Miller, 911 F.3d 638, 644 (1st Cir. 2018).
pursuit, and thereafter to withdraw its assurance, seems to most of
us unfair and dishonest. But, while the chase is on, it does not shock
us to have it extended beyond the time first set, or, if it does, the
stake forgives it.
Faker v. United States, 23 F.2d 420, 425-26 (2d Cir. 1928). The distinction between statutes that
revive expired prosecutions and those that extend existing limitations periods has deep roots in
established jurisprudence. It is well-settled that the Ex Post Facto Clause prohibits laws that revive
time-barred prosecutions, but permits laws that retroactively extend limitations periods. Stogner
v. California, 539 U.S. 607, 632 (2003) (holding that the Ex Post Facto Clause does not "prevent
the State from extending time limits for . . . prosecutions not yet time barred."); United States v.
Morgan, 113 F.3d 1230, 1997 WL 268712, at *7 (2d Cir. 1997) (unpublished opinion) ("The long-
standing rule in this circuit is that Congress has the power to extend the period of limitations
without running afoul of the ex post facto clause, provided the original period has not already
run.") (citing Faker, 23 F.3d at 425-26). And other circuits have emphasized this distinction in
the context of Section 3283. Leo Sure Chief 438 F.3d, at 922-25; Jeffries, 405 F.3d 685.
Read together, the Second Circuit's decisions in Weingarten, Vernon, Enterprise, and
Faker establish that Congress may retroactively extend the limitations period for still-viable
prosecutions. That is precisely what has occurred here, because the charges in the Indictment were
still timely when the 2003 amendment extended the limitations period. As a result, applying

Section 3283 in this case does not create impermissible retroactive effects. Therefore, step two of
Landgraf is satisfied, and Section 3283 applies retroactively.
Resisting this conclusion, the defendant asserts that, in the criminal context, Landgraf s
second step provides protections beyond the Ex Post Facto Clause. But that is not the law. See
Nader, 425 F. Supp. 3d at 630 (rejecting the argument that "there is `daylight' between the Ex Post
Facto Clause and Landgraf s second step."). Maxwell cites no precedent for the proposition that,
in the criminal context, much less in the context of criminal statutes of limitations, Landgraf
forecloses prosecutions permitted by the Constitution. Maxwell instead cites dictum by a single
judge in a non-criminal case that, "pp' [he] were judging on a clean slate," he would read Landgraf
to prohibit some retroactive application of statutes that, "while not the equivalent of criminal ex
post facto, nevertheless would run afoul of Landgraf s considerations, and that he "expect[ed]
that the Supreme Court's future decisions" would confirm such a reading. Thom v. Ashcroft, 369
F.3d 158, 163 n.6 (2d Cir. 2004) (Calabresi, J., "[s]peaking only for [him]self'). That footnote is
too slender a reed to support Maxwell's entire motion to dismiss the Indictment as untimely.
Moreover, Maxwell has identified no case in the intervening seventeen years in which the Supreme
Court has embraced Judge Calabresi's view. See Nader, 425 F. Supp. 3d at 631 (finding arguments
relating to Judge Calabresi's footnote unpersuasive, and concluding that Section 3283 applies
retroactively under Landgraf). As Weingarten recognized, any court to hold that "retroactively
extending a filing period for live charges is a presumptively impermissible retroactive effect under
Landgraf' will be the first to do so. 865 F.3d at 58.
The defendant also argues that "criminal limitations statutes are to be liberally interpreted
in favor of repose," relying on the Supreme Court's decision in Toussie v. United States, 397 U.S.
112, 115 (1970). Toussie considered whether a person's failure to register for the draft was a
continuing offense subjecting him to prosecution eight years later, notwithstanding the five-year
limitations period in Section 3282. Id. at 114. In that context, the Court invoked a presumption
in favor of repose when determining whether the underlying conduct was time-barred. But that
presumption says nothing about whether Congress intended an extension of a statute of limitations
to apply purely prospectively, a question governed by Landgraf Only one case has applied
Toussie to the Landgraf analysis, see United States v. Gentile, 235 F. Supp. 3d 649, 655 (D.N.J.
2017), and that case, which did not concern Section 3283, relied extensively on a pre-Landgraf
opinion requiring a clear statement of congressional intent in favor of retroactivity. See id. at 655
(citing United States v. Richardson, 512 F.2d 105 (3d Cir. 1975)). That clear-statement rule is
inconsistent with the analysis required by Landgraf step two. See Nader, 425 F. Supp. 3d at 631
(rejecting an identical argument relying on Toussie and Gentile).
***
The defendant asks this Court to break new ground and become the first court to hold that

Section 3283 applies only prospectively. The Court should reject this invitation. For the reasons
set forth above, the weight of authority holds that Section 3283 applies retroactively, in keeping
with Congress's express intent to expand prosecutions of individuals who sexually exploit
children. The Indictment is timely, and the motion should be denied.

C. The Defendant's Crimes Involved the Sexual Abuse of Minors
The defendant next argues that Section 3283 does not apply at all, and she asks the Court to
conclude that the crimes of sexual abuse alleged in the Indictment did not involve sexual abuse.
Her argument runs contrary to both the case law and common sense. Her motion is meritless and
should be denied.
By its terms, Section 3283 applies to any "offense involving the sexual or physical abuse,
or kidnaping, of a child under the age of 18 years." 18 U.S.C. § 3283. As discussed above, when
the statute was first enacted, it was located at 18 U.S.C. § 3509(k). The definition of the term
"sexual abuse" is located in a neighboring provision within that same section:
For purposes of this section ... the term `sexual abuse' includes the
employment, use, persuasion, inducement, enticement, or coercion
of a child to engage in, or assist another person to engage in, sexually
explicit conduct or the rape, molestation, prostitution, or other form
of sexual exploitation of children, or incest with children.
18 U.S.C. § 3509(a)(8). The term "sexually explicit conduct" is in turn defined to mean, among
other things, "sexual intercourse, including sexual contact"; and the term "sexual contact" means
"the intentional touching, either directly or through clothing, of the genitalia, anus, groin, breast,
inner thigh, or buttocks of any person with an intent to abuse, humiliate, harass, degrade, or arouse
or gratify sexual desire of any person." Id. § 3509(a)(9)(A). Courts have looked to the definition
of "sexual abuse" set forth in Section 3509(a) to determine whether the statute of limitations of

Section 3283 applies to an offense. United States v. Carpenter, 680 F.3d 1101, 1103-04 (9th Cir.
2012) ("We join our sister circuits in looking to subsection 3509(a) for a definition of `sexual
abuse' under federal law, and find it the appropriate definition to use in applying section 3283's
extended statute of limitations."); United States v. Vickers, No. 13 Cr. 128 (RJA) (HKS), 2014 WL
1838255, at ■10 (W.D.N.Y. May 8, 2014) (applying the definition of "sexual abuse" set forth in

Section 3509(a)).
As is evident from its plain text, the definition of "sexual abuse" set forth in Section 3509(a)
includes not only actual "sexual contact," but also the "the employment, use, persuasion,
inducement, enticement, or coercion of a child to engage in, or assist another person to engage in,"
sexual contact. 18 U.S.C. § 3509(a). The breadth of this definition is underscored by Congress's
use of the word "includes." The Supreme Court has held that Congress's choice of the word
"includes" is "significant because it "makes clear that the examples enumerated in the text are
intended to be illustrative, not exhaustive." Christopher v. SmithKline Beecham Corp., 567 U.S.
142, 162 (2012) (citing Burgess v. United States, 552 U.S. 124, 131 n.3 (2008)). Thus, sexual
abuse "as defined here encompasses a wider set of behavior than just rape or other unwanted sexual
touching." United States v. Schneider, 801 F.3d 186, 197 (3d Cir. 2015). In keeping with that
broad definition, courts have held that Section 3283 "does not require that an offense consist of a
sexual act between a defendant and a specific child," Vickers, 2014 WL 1838255, at *11, but
instead reaches offenses involving the transportation of minors to engage in illegal sexual activity.
See Sensi, 2010 WL 2351484, at *2-3 (collecting cases interpreting the term "sexual abuse" to
encompass "all crimes that would logically relate to the common understanding of sexual abuse
even when found in chapters 110 (`Sexual Exploitation and Other Abuse of Children') and 117
(`Transportation of Illegal Sexual Activity and Related Crimes') of title 18"); Schneider, 801 F.3d
at 196-97 (holding that Section 3283 applied to defendant convicted of traveling with the purpose
of engaging in sex with a minor victim, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2423(b)); Vickers, 2014 WL
1838255, at *11-12 (holding that violations of 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a) were crimes involving sexual
abuse under Section 3283).
The defendant's motion does not engage with these authorities at all. Instead, the defendant
asks the Court to apply an "essential ingredients" test, relying heavily upon the Supreme Court's
decision in Bridges v. United States, 346 U.S. 209 (1953), which concerned the Wartime
Suspension of Limitations Act ("WSLA"). (Def. Mot. 2 at 12-14). But Bridges is inapposite,
since it concerned a statute "[t]he legislative history of [which] emphasize[d] the propriety of its
conservative interpretation" and "indicate[d] a purpose to suspend the general statute of limitations
only as to" certain narrowly defined offenses. Bridges, 346 U.S. at 216. There is no corresponding
indication that Congress intended the "essential ingredients" test to apply to Section 3283. As the
Third Circuit has explained in rejecting an identical argument:
While Bridges did adopt an "essential ingredient" test, the
limitations -extending statute at issue was a narrowly drafted
exception specifically intended to target frauds related to war
procurement. Unlike the WSLA, § 3283 has no such restrictive
language or legislative history suggesting congressional intent to
limit its application to a specific subset of circumstances. Congress,
rather, has evinced a general intention to "cast a wide net to ensnare
as many offenses against children as possible."
Schneider, 801 F.3d at 197 (quoting United States v. Dodge, 597 F.3d 1347, 1355 (11th Cir. 2010)
(en bane)); see Weingarten, 865 F.3d at 59 n.I0 (distinguishing Bridges because the "essential
ingredient" test there "effectuated Congress's specific intent to limit the WSLA's extended
limitations period to only a few offenses," while "Congress had the opposite intention for Section
3283"); see also Vickers, 2014 WL 1838255, at *11-12 ("[T]he defendant argues that the charged
offense does not "involve" the sexual abuse of a child, as reflected in the elements of the offense.
Defendant's argument is illogical and clearly misinterprets the use of the term `involving' in
section 3283.").
Although the Second Circuit has not yet reached this issue, it examined this question in
Weingarten v. United States, in the context of a claim for ineffective assistance of counsel.
Weingarten, 865 F.3d at 58-60. Rejecting the claim, the Second Circuit observed that none of the
criteria for applying the categorical approach are met in the context of Section 3283. Id. The
categorical approach—which focuses on the elements of the offense-is generally only used in
settings like sentencing and immigration, where a court is asked to evaluate the conduct from a
prior conviction. Id. at 59. In such a context, a court attempting to examine the facts of the prior
conviction to determine the present punishment or immigration consequences would encounter
logistical and constitutional obstacles. Id. (noting an Apprendi problem and "daunting practical
difficulties and potential unfairness"). None of those concerns is present here, where the relevant
facts will be proved at trial.
The Weingarten court also specifically rejected the argument Maxwell now asserts: that
the words "offense involving" require a categorical approach. "[T]hat Congress used the word
`involving' in § 3283 does not necessarily mean it intended to trigger the categorical approach.
'Involving' . is equally consistent with applying a fact-based approach." 865 F.3d at 60 n.11
(citing Nijhawan v. Holder, 557 U.S. 29, 38 (2009) (applying the circumstances-specific approach
to a statute containing the word "involves")). Moreover, as the Weingarten court observed, the
Supreme Court has applied the categorical approach to statutes containing the word "involving"
where the statutes at issue also referenced "elements" of offenses, or specific prior "convictions,"
in a manner that referred to specific convictions, as opposed to particular offense conduct. 865
F.3d at 59 (citing Taylor v. United States, 495 U.S. 575 (1990); Leocal v. Ashcroft, 543 U.S. 1
(2004)). By contrast, the phrase "sexual abuse" in Section 3283 refers to specific conduct, and not
the statutory offenses charged in the Indictment.
In Weingarten, the Second Circuit further noted that applying the categorical approach to

Section 3283 would run contrary to Congress's intention to "cast a wide net to ensnare as many
offenses against children as possible." 865 F.3d at 60 (quoting Schneider, 801 F.3d at 196). On
this point, it bears emphasizing that the interpretation the defendant advances would lead to absurd
outcomes, as many federal crimes involving the sexual abuse of minors do not contain, as an
element, a requirement that the defendant commit a sex act with a minor. It would run contrary to
Congress's intent to interpret Section 3283 in a manner that would exclude many—if not most-
sexual offenses against children.
The lone Section 3283 case the defendant cites, United States v. Countentos, 651 F.3d 809
(8th Cir. 2011), is easily distinguishable on its facts. In that case, the Eighth Circuit considered,
among other issues, whether the crime of possessing child pornography involved sexual abuse
within the meaning of Section 3283. Id. at 816-18. In analyzing that question, the court discussed,
among a variety of factors, the elements of the crime. But it did not consider the categorical
approach, or purport to apply an "essential ingredients" test, as the defendant implies. Instead, the
court resolved the issue by answering a common sense question: "Does someone who merely
possesses child pornography sexually abuse the child portrayed in the images?" Id. at 817. This
inquiry has no relevance here, as this case does not involve the possession of child pornography.
The crimes charged in the Indictment plainly involved the sexual abuse of minors. First,
the Indictment clearly alleges that the minor victims were subjected to actual, physical sexual
contact as part of the defendant's crimes. See Indictment at ¶¶ 4 (alleging that conduct toward
minor victims involved sexual abuse), 5 (alleging that "Epstein's resulting abuse of minor victims
included, among other things, touching a victim's breast, touching a victim's genitals, placing a
sex toy such as a vibrator on a victim's genitals, directing a victim to touch Epstein while he
masturbated, and directing a victim to touch Epstein's genitals."), 7 (describing patterns of sexual
abuse). Moreover, the Indictment alleges that the defendant persuaded, induced, enticed, and
transported minors for purposes of engaging in criminal sexual activity, and that she conspired to
do the same. As discussed above, the offenses charged in the Indictment accordingly involved the
sexual abuse of minors as defined in Section 3509(a) and incorporated into Section 3283.
Because the defendant's crimes involved sexual abuse, the expanded statute of limitations
set forth in Section 3283 applies to the crimes charged in Counts One through Four of the
Indictment and her motion should be denied.
III. The Defendant's Motion to Dismiss the Indictment Based on Alleged Improper Pre -
Trial Delay Should Be Denied
The defendant contends that the Indictment should be dismissed because the Government's
delay in bringing the charges violates the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment. (Def. Mot.
7). The defendant has not and cannot successfully establish such a violation. First, the defendant
has not established that any alleged pre-indictment delay caused actual prejudice to the defense.
Her speculative assertions about lost witnesses and records are hardly the sort of evidence that she
can use to carry her heavy burden. Without proof of actual prejudice, the motion fails. Second,
even if the Court finds actual prejudice to the defense, the defendant has not established that the
Government's purpose in any alleged pre-indictment delay was improper or designed to gain any
sort of tactical advantage. The Government obtained an indictment charging the defendant on
June 29, 2020, less than two years after opening its investigation and less than a year after victims
with information critical to the pending charges came forward. The defendant thus cannot
establish an undue delay, much less a delay caused by the Government for an improper purpose.
Because the defendant cannot establish either element, let alone both, her due process claim
is meritless and should be denied.
A. The Defendant Has Failed to Demonstrate Actual and Substantial Prejudice
1. Applicable Law
It is well-settled that the statute of limitations is "the primary guarantee against bringing
overly stale criminal charges." United States v. Marion, 404 U.S. 307, 322 (1971) (internal
quotation marks and citations omitted). Thus, when a case has been brought within the statute of
limitations, it is "only rarely dismissed," and carries a "strong presumption of validity." United
States v. ConiesIle, 171 F.3d 748, 752 (2d Cir. 1999); see also United States v. Lawson, 683 F.2d
688, 694 (2d Cir. 1982).
The Second Circuit standard for pit -indictment delay is clear, and it imposes a heavy
burden on the defendant to show that: (i) "he suffered actual prejudice because of the alleged pre-
indictment delay," and (ii) "that such delay was a course intentionally pursued by the government
for an improper purpose." Conzielle, 171 F.3d at 752 (citations omitted). The burden for proving
both prongs of the standard rests squarely on the defendant. United States v. Scarpa, 913 F.3d
993, 1014 (2d Cir. 1990); United States v. Rubin, 609 F.2d 51, 66 (2d Cir. 1979); United States v.
Ricco, 549 F.2d 264, 272 (2d Cir. 1977). The burden is so heavy that it is rarely met by a defendant.
See DeMichele v. Greenburgh Centr. Sch. Dist No. 7, 167 F.3d 784, 790-91 (2d Cir. 1999)
("[W]hile the [Supreme] Court may not have shut the door firmly on a contention that at some
point the Due Process Clause forecloses prosecution of a claim because it is too old, at most the
door is barely ajar.").
Substantial prejudice is just that—substantial, actual, non-speculative prejudice. See
United States v. Birney, 686 F.2d 102, 105-06 (2d Cir. 1982) (a defendant's "proof of prejudice
must be definite and not speculative"); see also United States v. Henderson, 337 F.3d 914, 920
(7th Cir. 2003) (prejudice sufficient to warrant dismissal for pre-indictment delay must be "actual
and substantial" and "specific, concrete, and supported by evidence"). Prejudice in this context
refers to "actual prejudice to the defendant's right to a fair trial." United States v. Elsbety, 602
F.2d 1054, 1059 (2d Cir. 1979). The mere loss of witnesses or evidence, without more, is
insufficient. Claims of loss of memory resulting from the passage of time have been held to be
insufficient to warrant dismissal of an indictment on due process grounds. See United States v.
Wright, 343 F.3d 849, 860 (6th Cir. 2003); Henderson, 337 F.3d at 919-20. Moreover, even when
a claim of prejudice is based upon the complete loss of a witness's testimony or other evidence, a
defendant nevertheless must show how that testimony or evidence would have affected the
outcome or otherwise have assisted the case. See United States v. Gilbert, 266 F.3d 1180, 1187
(9th Cir. 2001) (defendant's pre-indictment delay claim rejected due to failure to show "how the
testimony from [three absent] witnesses would have benefitted his case"); United States v. Spears,
159 F.3d 1081, 1085 (7th Cir. 1999) ("[A] defendant must do more than show that a particular
witness is unavailable and that the witness' testimony would have helped the defense. He must
also show that the witness would have testified, withstood cross-examination, and that the jury
would have found the witness credible" (citations omitted)). "Courts have held that `the defendant
also has the burden of showing that the lost testimony or information was not available through
other means.'" Pieire-Louis, 2018 WL 4043140, at *4 (quoting United States v. Sprouts, 282 F.3d
1037, 1041 (8th Cir. 2002)).
The vast majority of pre-indictment delay cases fail on the first prong. See, e.g., Marion,
404 U.S. at 324-25 (fading witness memories insufficient; "no one suggests that every delay-
caused detriment to a defendant's case should abort a criminal prosecution"); United States v.
Snyder, 668 F.2d 686, 689 (2d Cir. 1982) (death of a defense witness three years before indictment
insufficient prejudice); United States v. lannelli, 461 F.2d 483, 485 (2d Cir. 1972) (unavailability
of witnesses insufficient prejudice); United States v. King, 560 F.2d 122, 130-31 (2d Cir. 1977)
(death of witness and missing documents insufficient prejudice); Pieire-Louis, 2018 WL 4043140,
at *4-5 (death of a defense witness and defendant's own memory issues insufficient prejudice).
2. Discussion
The defendant points to at least four ways in which she claims the passage of time
prejudiced her defense, but none of her hypothetical claims of prejudice withstand scrutiny. In
particular, she contends that, as a result of the passage of time, four witnesses have died, unnamed
Epstein employees have been "lost," unspecified witnesses now have "failed or corrupted"
memories, and records have been lost or destroyed. She further contends that these collectively
demonstrate actual prejudice. (Def. Mot. 7 at 8-14). None has merit, individually or collectively.
With respect to the first three arguments, the fact that certain witnesses cannot testify
because of their deaths or failed memories does not compel a finding of actual prejudice. "Faded
memories or unavailable witnesses are inherent in any delay, even if justifiable. To merit dismissal
a defendant must demonstrate a substantial, actual prejudice to his ability to defend himself."
United States v. Long, 697 F. Supp. 651, 657 (S.D.N.Y. 1988). The defendant has not made such
a showing. Her speculative assertions simply do not rise to that level.
The defendant first claims she has suffered substantial prejudice as a result of pre-
indictment delay due to the unavailability of Jeffrey Epstein, Epstein's mother, Michael Casey (the
alleged agent of Minor Victim -1), and Palm Beach Police Department Detective Joseph Recarey.
She contends that the loss of Epstein demonstrates actual prejudice because Epstein "would have"
testified that the defendant did not engage in the criminal activity with which she is charged. (Def.
Mot. 7 at 8). That assertion is speculative at best, and the law is clear that "proof of prejudice must
be definite and not speculative." Birney, 686 F.2d at 105-06; see also Long, 697 F. Supp. at 657
(finding that "perceived prejudice is speculative" where there was "no way of knowing what [the
unavailable witness's] testimony would have been"). To credit Maxwell's argument is to assume
that Epstein, after being indicted with federal sex trafficking charges, would have taken the stand,
would not have invoked his Fifth Amendment rights, and would have provided testimony that
exculpated Maxwell, which a jury would have credited in the face of contradictory trial evidence.
This is an exercise in chain upon chain of conjecture that comes nowhere close to meeting the
burden of demonstrating actual prejudice. See Spears, 159 F.3d at 1085 ("[A] defendant must do
more than show that a particular witness is unavailable and that the witness' testimony would have
helped the defense. He must also show that the witness would have testified, withstood cross-
examination, and that the jury would have found the witness credible." (citations omitted)); see
also United States v. Valona, 834 F.2d 1334, 1339 (7th Cir. 1987) (noting that prejudice analysis
must consider whether the missing witness "would have withstood cross-examination," whether
the jury would have found him a "credible witness," and whether the testimony, when compared
to other trial evidence "would affect the trial outcome" (internal quotation marks and citations
omitted)). The defendant has not and cannot establish that Epstein would have been available to
testify in the first instance, much less that he would have voluntarily agreed to testify at her trial
in a way that would help, rather than hurt, the defendant.
As to Epstein's mother, who died in April 2004, the defendant contends that she "would
have testified that she did not observe Ms. Maxwell with any Accusers between 1994 and 1997."
(Def. Mot. 7 at 9). "Counsel's unworn assertions as to vague generalities" that witnesses, "if
alive, would give testimony helpful to [the defendant] do not show that [the defendant's] ability to
present a defense has been substantially and actually prejudiced." United States v. Scala, 388 F.
Supp. 2d 396, 399-400 (S.D.N.Y. 2005). Here, "there is no evidence before the Court as to what
[the deceased witness] would have testified, much less specific evidence of how losing that
testimony has caused [the defendant] actual prejudice." Id. at 400. Further, unless Epstein's
mother was with the defendant "every moment" between 1994 and 1997, "it would be impossible
for [her] to testify that [the] defendant did not commit the charged crimes, so whatever helpful
testimony [she] might have offered (the details of which are sparse in the motion) would be easily
undermined on cross-examination." Pierre -Louis, 2018 WL 4043140, at '4 (citing Spears, 159
F.3d at 1081-1085). Moreover, Epstein's mother died "sufficiently prior to `any realistic trial
date,' to make it improbable that any prejudice it may have caused [the defendant] was the result
of government delay." United States v. Cheung Kin Ping, 555 F.2d 1069, 1073 (2d Cir. 1977)
(quoting United States v. Stein, 456 F.2d 844, 848 (2d Cir. 1972)). Indeed, Epstein's mother passed
away before the Palm Beach Police Department even began investigating Epstein in 2005. (Def.
Mot. 7, Ex. D at i).
The defendant's claims relating to Michael Casey and Detective Recarey fare no better.
She again speculates that Casey and Detective Recarey, who passed away in August 2017 and May
2018 respectively, would have testified, and that such testimony would have been exculpatory and
would have materially helped the defense. (Def. Mot. 7 at 9-11). The defendant cannot establish
that Casey and Detective Recarey would have testified in a way that would help, rather than hurt,
the defendant.
In particular, the defendant contends that Michael Casey, the purported agent of Minor
Victim-1, "would be able to testify" about Minor Victim-I's behavior during the "relevant time
period" and the "lack of any 'outcry' or `grooming.'" (Id. at 10). The defense suggests that Casey
not having related any complaints about Maxwell to "any authority, Ms. Maxwell, or any other
known witness" means that he knew of no complaints. (Id. at 9-10). As an initial matter, "there
is no evidence before the Court as to what [Casey] would have testified." Scala, 388 F. Supp. 2d
at 400. Even assuming that Casey would have testified as the defendant now contends, such
testimony (which would be purely speculative and unsubstantiated) would also have no bearing
on whether the abuse, in fact, occurred.
The defendant argues that Detective Recarey would have testified that none of the
witnesses with whom he spoke in connection with a prior investigation told him about the
defendant participating in sex trafficking activities. (Def. Mot. 7 at 10-11). As a threshold matter,
the defendant has not established how such testimony, which would consist entirely of hearsay,
could even be admissible at the defendant's trial. Moreover, the fact that Epstein may have abused
victims without the defendant's participation is not exculpatory as to charges alleging the
defendant assisted in the grooming and abuse of other victims. The well-established law of this
Circuit generally precludes a defendant from offering evidence that a defendant did not participate
in criminal conduct on a particular occasion —or of her law-abiding conduct during uncharged
periods or uncharged events —to rebut the Government's evidence with respect to the charged
crimes or events. See, e.g., United States v. Scarpa, 897 F.2d 63, 70 (2d Cir. 1990) ("A defendant
may not seek to establish h[er] innocence . . . through proof of the absence of criminal acts on
specific occasions."); United States v. Chambers, 800 F. App'x 43, 46 (2d Cir. 2020) ("A single
occurrence of lawful conduct is `simply irrelevant' to other occurrences of lawful conduct."
(quoting United States v. Walker, 191 F.3d 326, 336 (2d Cir. 1999)); United States v. Williams,
205 F.3d 23, 34 (2d Cir. 2000) ("We reject Williams's assertion that the evidence of innocent
travel was necessary to rebut the government's allegation that Williams had been involved in other
cocaine importations from Jamaica. Although the government did argue that Williams had been
involved in other importations, it did not allege that Williams had engaged in drug activity during
these particular trips."); United States v. Fiwnano, No. 14 Cr. 518 (JFK), 2016 WL 1629356, at
*7 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 25, 2016) ("The principle is rather elementary. A defendant charged with
robbing a bank in Manhattan on April 22 cannot offer as evidence to disprove the charged crime
that he did not rob the bank's branches in Brooklyn or the Bronx on April 22 or that he did not rob
the Manhattan branch on April 20, 21, 23, and 24, because this evidence is irrelevant to the charge
that he robbed the Manhattan bank on April 22."); United States v. Gambino, 838 F. Supp. 744,
748 (S.D.N.Y. 1993).
Inadmissibility aside, the Indictment specifically charges conduct between 1994 and 1997.
That a different investigative team focused on Epstein's conduct in the early 2000s may not have
uncovered evidence about the defendant's conduct in the 1990s has no bearing on the charges in
this case, which was brought entirely independent of the prior SDFL investigation. Moreover, and
as detailed further below, two of the victims referenced in the Indictment, Minor Victim -1 and
Minor Victim-3, were never interviewed by the USAO-SDFL, and had never spoken to law
enforcement until they met with this Office in late August and September 2019, after Epstein's
death." As such, it is neither surprising nor terribly probative of any issue in dispute in this case
that Detective Recarey might have testified to a lack of knowledge as to what the victims identified
in this Indictment have told the USAO-SDNY. In sum, the defendant has not put "specific
evidence" before this Court demonstrating that the loss of Detective Recarey's testimony, even if
admissible, has caused her actual prejudice. Scala, 388 F. Supp. 2d at 400.
The defendant next contends that had the Government brought the charges earlier, she
would have interviewed and subpoenaed as witnesses "the many Epstein employees that were
present at the different locations during that three-year period." (Def. Mot. 7 at 11). She does not
specify which employees she would have called as witnesses, the grounds for contending they are
"lost" or "missing," whether they would have been willing to testify, or what admissible evidence
they would have provided. She merely speculates that the evidence could have helped her defense.
This is far from the definite proof of prejudice required to state a due process claim. See United
States v. Greer, 956 F. Supp. 525, 528 (D. Vt. 1997) ("In the context of unavailable witnesses, the
defendant must offer some grounds for his belief that the absent witness would have helped his
case in a material way." (internal quotation marks and citation omitted)).
The defendant also argues that "[m]any potential witnesses have been contacted in relation
to this matter and other related litigations," noting that "[s]ignificant numbers of potential
witnesses no longer remember when events may have occurred" or "who was present." (Def. Mot.
7 at 12). Dimming or fading memories over the passage of time are not in themselves sufficient
to "demonstrate that [defendants] cannot receive a fair trial" or "justify the dismissal of the
indictment." Marion, 404 U.S. at 326; Elsbery, 602 F.2d at 1059. Indeed, the fact that the defense
described the witnesses as "potential witnesses" suggests that she might still call them. Further,
17 The third victim, Minor Victim -2, was interviewed previously by the FBI. The Government is
not aware of Detective Recarey having participated in an interview of Minor Victim-2.
to the extent the passage of time affects the memories of witnesses who testify at trial, the
defendant will have an opportunity to cross-examine such witnesses. See United States v.
Harrison, 764 F. Supp. 29, 32 (S.D.N.Y. 1991) (noting that "the passage of time does affect
witnesses' memories and it may be relevant to the credibility of their testimony" and that the
Government also faces potential harms from the passage of time). 18 Accordingly, the defendant's
bald assertions regarding diminished memories of potential witnesses are speculative and, thus,
fall short of the proof of actual prejudice required by the Supreme Court's standard in Marion.
The defendant also claims that because of the delay in the prosecution, she does not have
access to certain exculpatory documentary evidence. (Def. Mot. 7 at 12-14). Once again, this
argument is entirely speculative. The defendant hypothesizes that if she had access to certain
documentary evidence (some of which, such as travel records, has been produced in discovery),
or evidence which she herself should have access to (e.g., her own emails from 1994 to 1997, her
own phone records from 1994 to 1997, and her own travel records from 1994 to 1997), this
evidence would have helped her. She offers no proof or basis for concluding that the records
would be helpful. Even if such records were helpful, dismissal of the Indictment would be too
extreme a measure in light of the relative significance of this form of evidence to other proof in
the case. Thus, the defendant's claim that she no longer has access to certain evidence is not a
proper basis to dismiss the Indictment. See United States v. Donau, 356 F. Supp. 1091, 1094
(S.D.N.Y. 1973) ("A bare allegation that records have been lost or destroyed, which might relate
Ig The Government notes that it faces the same potential harms from the passage of time as does
any party, including loss of witnesses through death or disappearance, diminishment of memories
over the passage of time, and loss of evidence. The Government, of course, bears the burden of
proof at trial, and as such, prosecutors have every incentive to bring cases as promptly as possible,
when memories are fresh and when it is possible to identify corroborating witnesses and records.
Any suggestion that the Government delayed bringing the instant case for over two decades for its
own benefit or a tactical advantage borders on the absurd.
to the instant prosecution, is insufficient to show actual prejudice. .. . The fact that evidence may
be lost or destroyed during the pre-indictment stage is inherent in any delay, no matter what the
duration. Furthermore, there has been no allegation in this case that the destruction of the records
was deliberate on the part of either the government or trustee." (internal citations omitted)).
Lastly, the defendant contends that prejudicial media reporting and inappropriate pm-trial
publicity from at least 2011 through the present has resulted in prejudice to the defendant. (Def.
Mot. at 14). She claims that had the Government brought charges against her between 1996 and
2011, the Government "would have not prevailed," noting that the defendant's accusers would not
have been "able to conform their `memories' to the often republished 'obvious lies.'" (Id. at 15).
This argument, like the others contained in this motion, is steeped in speculation. The defendant
cites not one case in support of her argument that pre-trial publicity can ever establish actual
prejudice, nor does she point to any evidence that the Government fomented such publicity dating
back to 2011. To the extent the defendant is concerned about pretrial publicity, she will have the
opportunity to propose an appropriate examination of potential jurors during voir dire to identify
a panel of impartial jurors who have not been prejudiced by any publicity this case may have
garnered.
In short, the defendant's complaints are nothing more than the type of self-serving, vague,
speculative, and conclusory claims of prejudice that courts have consistently rejected as
insufficient to warrant dismissal of charges based upon pm-indictment delay. 19 The motion should
therefore be denied.
19 The defendant also complains about the Government's failure to "provide discovery adequate
to fully investigate the extent of the prejudice to Ms. Maxwell." (Def. Mot. 7 at 7). Among the
items the defense complains about not receiving in discovery are the names and dates of birth of
the Minor Victims, the specific location of any overt act, the date of any overt act, any witness
statements, or any corroboration of any allegation in the Indictment. (Id.). As described herein,
see Section X, infra, the Government has made substantial discovery productions pursuant to Rule

B. The Defendant Has Failed to Establish That the Government Delayed the
Indictment for An Improper Purpose
1. Applicable Law
If, and only if, a defendant has established significant, actual prejudice does the inquiry
turn to the reason for the delay.20 See, e.g., Pierre -Louis, 2018 WL 4043140, at *5 ("Because
Defendant failed to show prejudice, the Court need not even address the second prong."). The
reason for delay violates due process only if it is so extreme that it departs from fundamental
notions of "fair play."' United States v. Lovasco, 431 U.S. 783, 795 (1977). The Supreme Court
has "defined the category of infractions that violate `fundamental fairness' very narrowly,"
Dowling v. United States, 493 U.S. 342, 352 (1990), and the Supreme Court has "stressed the
importance for constitutional purposes of good or bad faith on the part of the Government when
the claim is based on loss of evidence attributable to the Government," Arizona v. Youngblood,
488 U.S. 51, 57 (1988).
16 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, which provides ample information about the
charged crimes and the victims referenced in the Indictment. Additionally, many of the
defendant's requests fall within the scope of the Government's Giglio and Jencks Act obligations,
which the Government intends to produce at the appropriate stage in the litigation, well in advance
of trial.
20 The defendant invites the Court to engage in a balancing test that weighs the prejudice to the
defendant against the Government's reasons for delay. (Def. Mot. 7 at 5, 6 n.4). This Court should
reject the defendant's invitation. The defendant cites United States v. Brand, 556 F.2d 1312, 1317
n.7 (5th Cir. 1977), for the proposition that a showing of prejudice triggers such balancing. (Def.
Mot. 7 at 5). However, the Fifth Circuit subsequently rejected such a balancing test, finding that
the "Brand footnote is pure dicta" and instead requiring that defendants demonstrate that the
prosecution intentionally caused the delay to gain a tactical advantage over the defendant or "for
some other bad faith purpose." United States v. Crouch, 84 F.3d 1497, 1509, 1512 (5th Cir. 1996).
The defendant also cites that several Circuit courts, namely the Fourth, Seventh, and Ninth
Circuits, require such a balancing test. (Def. Mot. 7 at 6 n.4). The Second Circuit, however, "has
not adopted any balancing test, as the Fourth, Seventh and Ninth Circuits have, and its
jurisprudence suggests that it would not do so." United States v. Santiago, 987 F. Supp. 2d 465,
490 (S.D.N.Y. 2013). Several other Circuits have also "refused to adopt a balancing test." Id.
(collecting cases). This Court should follow that example.
The Second Circuit has clearly held that a defendant seeking the dismissal of an indictment
filed within the statute of limitations must establish that the Government acted intentionally,
deliberately, or with some strategy, and that the Government used that delay to gain a tactical
advantage over the defendant. See, e.g., Cornielle, 171 F.3d at 752 (delay must be "intentional
device to gain [a] tactical advantage over the accused"); see also United States v. Alameh, 341
F.3d 167, 176 (2d Cir. 2003) ("To show unjustifiable conduct, a defendant must demonstrate that
the government has intentionally used delay to gain unfair tactical advantage."); see also United
States v. Delacruz, 970 F. Supp. 2d 199, 203 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) ("Delacruz's motion to dismiss
would nevertheless fail for the independent reason that he has not made any showing that the
preindictment delay was an intentional device designed by the Government to gain a tactical
advantage."); United States v. Martinez, No. 94 Cr. 219 (RPP), 1995 WL 10849, at ■4 (S.D.N.Y.
Jan. 12, 1995) ("In order to establish improper delay by the Government in filing an indictment, a
defendant must show that the delay was the result of an intentional device of the Government to
gain tactical advantage over the accused." (internal quotation marks and alterations omitted) (citing
United States v. Hoo, 825 F.2d 667, 671 (2d Cir. 1987))). Indeed, some version of the phrase
"deliberate device" and "tactical advantage" is found in nearly every Second Circuit decision on
the issue. See, e.g., Alameh, 341 F.3d at 176 ("intentionally used delay to gain unfair tactical
advantage"); Cornielle, 171 F.3d at 752 (requiring "intentional device" to gain "tactical
advantage"); Lawson, 683 F.2d at 694 (delay not "engineered by the government for an improper
purpose, such as gaining a tactical advantage"); Snyder, 668 F.2d at 689; United States v. Watson,
599 F.2d 1149, 1157 n.5 (2d Cir. 1979); United States v. Tanu, 589 F.2d 82, 89 (2d Cir. 1978);
United States v. Laurenti, 581 F.2d 37, 40 n.11 (2d Cir. 1978); United States v. Hillegas, 578 F.2d
453, 460 (2d Cir. 1978).
2. Discussion
Even if the defendant could establish any actual prejudice—which she cannot—such
prejudice would be "necessary but not sufficient" to establish a due process claim. Lovasco, 431
U.S. at 790. The defendant's motion fails because she has not demonstrated the other necessary
element to prevail: that the claimed delay by the Government was intentional and deliberate to
gain a strategic advantage. Here, as in Lovasco, any pre-indictment delay was the result of the
Government's continuing investigation of the case. The Lovasco Court held that the investigative
delay did not deprive the defendant of his due process rights and noted that imposing a duty upon
prosecutors to file charges as soon as probable cause exists "'would have a deleterious effect both
upon the rights of the accused and upon the ability of society to protect itself."' Id. at 791 (quoting
United States v. Ewell, 383 U.S. 116, 120 (1966)).
The same is true in the present case. The defendant has not shown—and cannot show—
that the Government caused any pre-indictment delay in this case to gain a tactical advantage. The
defendant argues that "[t]actical, reckless, and bad faith motives can reasonably be inferred from
the way the government has ignored evidence, delayed any prosecution, enlisted partisan lawyers
to do its bidding, circumvented established precedent to illegally obtain evidence, and
misleadingly quoting banal testimony so that it could be labeled `perjury."' (Def. Mot. 7 at 15).
But rhetoric aside, the defendant offers nothing beyond baseless speculation in support of her
claims.
The defendant claims a twenty-six-year delay on the part of the Government in bringing
Counts One through Four and a four-year delay as to Counts Five and Six. (Def. Mot. 7 at 4).
That is not so. The USAO-SDNY opened its investigation into Epstein and his co-conspirators in
late November 2018. See Section IV, infra. Epstein was charged by indictment on July 2, 2019.
Thereafter, the Government continued its investigation, which included interviewing two victims
(Minor Victim-1 and Minor Victim-3) for the first time. In particular, Minor Victim -1 first agreed
to be interviewed in September 2019, and Minor Victim -3 first agreed to be interviewed in August
2019.21 The Government conducted multiple additional interviews of both victims, as well as other
witnesses, and took additional investigative steps over the next several months before it was
prepared to seek an indictment charging the defendant. Those two victims were critical to the
investigation, as they helped form the basis of the charges in the Indictment, which the Government
sought on June 29, 2020, less than a year after the victims came forward. That period of time—
and, in particular, less than one year between when key victims came forward and the Indictment
was obtained —cannot possibly give rise to a colorable due process violation.11 See Cheung Kin
Ping, 555 F.2d at 1072 (finding that "the government is not responsible for a period of delay during
which an important witness is unavailable to it" and describing the delay as the period between the
witness's cooperation and the date of indictment); United States v. Rubinson, 543 F.2d 951, 961
(2d Cir. 1976) ("If there was any intentional delay in returning the instant indictment, it was due
in significant measure to the refusal of critical witnesses until 1973 to reveal what they knew.").
Cf. Lovasco, 431 U.S. at 796 ("Rather than deviating from elementary standards of fair play and
decency, a prosecutor abides by them if he refuses to seek indictments until he is completely
21 While the Government is proffering these facts for purposes of this Motion, the underlying
information, which is contained in the FBI 302 reports of interviews with the victims, will be
produced to the defense as 3500 material in advance of trial.
n In this respect, the Government notes that significant aspects of the defendant's argument rest
on a faulty premise: i.e., that the Government could have indicted the defendant at any time
between 1994 and 2020, but simply chose not to do so for tactical reasons. As noted above, two
key witnesses who helped give rise to the instant charges did not agree to speak law enforcement
until 2019, facts that significantly undercut the notion that the Government was intentionally
sitting on a criminal case against the defendant for any meaningful period of time. Cf. Ex. 3 (OPR
Report) at 81 ("Villafafia told OPR that, apart from the women named in the NPA, the investigation
had not developed evidence of `any other potential co-conspirators.'"); id. at 167 (with respect to
Maxwell, "according to Villafafia, in 2007, they `didn't have any specific evidence against her.").
satisfied that he should prosecute and will be able promptly to establish guilt beyond a reasonable
doubt." (internal quotation marks and citations omitted)).
Moreover, even if the Court were to determine that a twenty-six-year period of delay were
applicable here, the defendant's motion should be dismissed because she failed to show that the
Government acted improperly to obtain a tactical advantage. See, e.g., Pierre -Louis, 2018 WL
4043140 (denying motion to dismiss for pre-indictment delay as to conduct charged in 2016
involving sexual abuse of minors from 1998 to 2007 as defendant failed to satisfy both prongs of
pre-indictment delay standard); United States v. Burke, No. 09 Cr. 135 (SO, 2011 WL 2609837,
at *7 (E.D.N.Y. July 1, 2011) (denying motion to dismiss indictment based on thirty-year pre-
indictment delay because even if unavailability of alibi witnesses were prejudicial, defendant failed
to show that government delayed for its own benefit); United States v. Carbonaro, No. 02 Cr. 743
(RCC), 2004 WL 2222145 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 30, 2004) (in a racketeering conspiracy case in which
a 14-year-old murder was alleged as a predicate act, finding that, even assuming defendant had
shown actual prejudice, defendant's motion to dismiss based on pre-indictment delay failed
because defendant supplied no evidence that government's conduct was for an improper purpose).
The defendant claims that the Government intentionally delayed the indictment in this case
with a prescient view towards capitalizing on civil litigation. For instance, Maxwell asserts that it
"has been advantageous to the government to have aggressive lawyers collecting information from
Ms. Maxwell as part of civil discovery and disseminating that information to the public, as part of
an ongoing campaign to vilify Ms. Maxwell." (Def. Mot. 7 at 16). She again cites the subpoena
the Government issued to Boies Schiller & Flexner LLP ("Boles Schiller") to obtain materials
from the Giuffre civil litigation. (Id.). Leaving aside the fact that, as set forth in Section IV, the
Government obtained such materials through a judicially approved and entirely appropriate
process, the inference that the defendant urges this Court to draw—that the Government delayed
seeking an indictment to gain a tactical advantage and did so through strategy in the pending civil
litigation —is both unsupported by the record and illogical.
The defendant makes much of the Government having moved to intervene and stay the
proceedings in Doe v. Indyke, No. 20 Civ. 484 (JGK), while the Government has not moved to
stay Giuf•e v. Maxwell. (Def. Mot. 7 at 16-19). She suggests that there is some "sharp contrast"
between the Government's actions in the various civil matters, which "establish a strong inference
that as long as the government stood to gain a tactical advantage by delaying the indictment .. ., it
would not move to intervene." (Id. at 19). Setting the defendant's conspiracy theories aside, the
civil matters were in completely different procedural postures, which implicate different concerns
regarding a pending criminal case. The Giuffre v. Maxwell litigation was settled and complete
well before the Government even opened its investigation in this case. By contrast, the Doe v.
Indyke case was initiated after the Government opened its investigation and remained ongoing
after the Indictment in this case was filed.23 The defendant quotes the Government's letter to Judge
Freeman requesting permission to intervene and stay Doe v. Indyke (see id.), but omits the portion
of that letter in which the Government explained that, as far as it was aware, Doe v. Indyke was
the "lone case in this District that has not yet been either resolved or stayed at this point. . . In
23 In particular, Giuffre v. Maxwell was resolved in 2017 and the determination of what material
should remain sealed remains the only open issue. Accordingly, there is no more discovery to be
conducted in the Giuffre case and no possible concern to the Government that, for example, its
trial witnesses in the criminal case might be deposed in that civil case. In Doe v. Indyke, on the
other hand, discovery was just beginning, and if discovery were to have proceeded, multiple
witnesses or potential witnesses at the criminal trial would likely have been subject to deposition.
That concern, among others, raised a significant risk that proceeding with the civil matter would
adversely affect the ongoing criminal prosecution against the defendant. Moreover, the interests
of judicial economy and the public interest in enforcement of the criminal law were served by a
stay in the Doe case because the outcome of the criminal case could resolve disputed issues in the
Doe case. Such concerns are not present in Giuffre v. Maxwell.
particular, this matter appears to be the only remaining active civil case in this District in which
claims against Ghislaine Maxwell have been asserted." (20 Civ. 484 (DCF) (JGK), Dkt. No. 80
at 2). The defendant's baseless conjecture about the Government's supposedly nefarious reasons
for delaying her prosecution are not sufficient to support a dismissal of the Indictment. The
defendant ignores the fact that cases such as this one take time to investigate and indict.
The defendant also suggests that the Government engaged in reckless disregard of
circumstances that would likely impede her ability to mount an effective defense. (Def. Mot. 7 at
5-6, 15). As an initial matter, this argument falls short of "a standard that requires a showing of
intentionality." United States v. Wey, No. 15 Cr. 611 (AJN), 2017 WL 237651, at *13 n.8
(S.D.N.Y. Jan. 18, 2017).24 While this Court in Wey did not foreclose the possibility of
recklessness sufficing under certain circumstances, much as in Wey, "the instant case does not
require this Court to pass on the issue," id., because there is no evidence of recklessness in this
case. To the contrary, as detailed above, the Government acted promptly in bringing criminal
charges shortly after two key victims whose testimony helped give rise to those charges first agreed
to speak with law enforcement. Baseless speculation aside, the defendant offers no argument or
evidence as to how or why the Government acted recklessly here.
In sum, not only does the defendant fail to demonstrate actual, non-speculative prejudice
owing to pre-indictment delay, but she also fails to establish that the Government intentionally
24 This Court has noted "some disagreement among the district courts in this Circuit as to whether
reckless —as opposed to intentional —disregard of circumstances . . . may support a due process
challenge based on pre-indictment delay," but concluded that "the pertinent decisions [], on
balance, more plainly comport with a standard that requires a showing of intentionality." Wey,
2017 WL 237651, at *13 n.8 (citing Cornielle, 171 F.3d at 752 (defendant bears burden of showing
that "delay was a course intentionally pursued by the government for an improper purpose")
(emphasis added)); see also United States v. Gonzalez, No. 00 Cr. 447, 2000 WL 1721171, at *1
& n.1 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 17, 2000) ("Neither the Supreme Court nor the Second Circuit . . . has
adopted this alternative [recklessness] standard.").
manufactured any alleged delay to gain a tactical advantage over her. She has "offered no credible
evidence to suggest that the Government tarried in bringing charges against [her] solely to gain
some prosecutorial advantage." Pierre -Louis, 2018 WL 4043140, at *5. As such, because the
defendant cannot meet her "heavy burden" of showing both actual prejudice and unjustifiable
Government conduct, her motion to dismiss the Indictment for pre-indictment delay should be
denied. 25
IV. The Court Should Deny the Defendant's Motions to Suppress
The defendant moves to suppress evidence the Government obtained pursuant to a grand
jury subpoena issued to Boies Schiller and to dismiss Counts Five and Six under the Due Process
Clause, the Fourth Amendment, the Fifth Amendment, and the Second Circuit's decision in
Martindell v. Intl Tel. and Tel. Corp., 594 F.2d 291 (2d Cir. 1979). (Def. Mots. 3 & 11). In
particular, the defendant contends that the Government violated the Second Circuit's decision in
Martindell and misled Chief Judge McMahon in obtaining the modification of a protective order.
She also contends the subpoena was overly broad and amounted to an unlawful search of materials
in which she had a reasonable expectation of privacy, as well as an infringement of her privilege
against self-incrimination. Although the defendant styles her request for relief as two separate
25 The defendant asks the Court for leave to supplement her motion "after the government provides
her with meaningful discovery" and notes that "after the disclosure of meaningful discovery, [she]
may request that the Court defer ruling on this motion until after any trial if the indictment has not
been dismissed on other grounds." (Def. Mot. 7 at 1). As noted above and discussed further in
Section X, infra, the Government has complied with its Rule 16 obligations and will produce
Giglio and Jencks Act materials well in advance of trial. The Court should reject the defendant's
invitation to defer ruling on this motion. See, e.g., United States v. Muric, No. 10 Cr. 112 (LTS),
2010 WL 2891178, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. July 13, 2010) ("The motion to dismiss the Indictment as the
result of pre-indictment delay is therefore denied, without prejudice to appropriately supported
later motion practice."); United States v. Drago, No. 18 Cr. 0394 (SJF) (AYS), 2019 WL 3072288,
at *2 (E.D.N.Y. July 15, 2019) (denying motion to dismiss on the ground of pre-indictment delay
without prejudice to renewal).
motions, the suppression motions overlap in fact and argument, and accordingly, the Government
responds to both motions in this section.
As set forth herein, the defendant's suppression motions challenging a judicially approved
grand jury subpoena should be denied without a hearing for multiple reasons. As an initial matter,
the defendant's claim that the Government "circumvented" Martindell fails because the
Government issued a valid grand jury subpoena, sought judicial authorization to permit
compliance with the subpoena, and obtained materials from Boies Schiller that otherwise would
have been covered by the relevant protective order only after receiving such authorization. In any
event, even if the Government's motion did not satisfy Martindell, Martindell provides no basis
to suppress evidence, and the defendant cites no authority in support of that request. Second, the
defendant's claim that the subpoena was a warrantless search in violation of the Fourth
Amendment fails because she has not established standing to challenge a judicially approved grand
jury subpoena issued to a third party, and because the subpoena was entirely lawful. Even if she
had standing, her claim still fails because suppression would be improper under the good faith
exception and the inevitable discovery doctrine. Third, the defendant's claim that the subpoena
violated her Fifth Amendment rights fails because, among other things, such a violation requires
coercion and state action. Fourth, the defendant's claim that the Government violated the Due
Process Clause is meritless, as the Government's conduct was not, by any reasonable definition,
outrageous or conscience shocking. And finally, the defendant's request for a hearing should be
denied because she has proffered no admissible evidence to support her accusations of Government
misconduct; instead, she relies entirely on an anonymously sourced article that, as detailed herein,
she cites to describe certain events that simply did not occur.
Accordingly, the defendant's suppression motions should be denied.

A. Factual Background
The defendant's motion is, at its core, premised on a false factual narrative. The defendant
alleges, based on a New York Daily News article, that Boies Schiller and the Government colluded
starting in at least early 2016 with the "precise[] design[]" of having the defendant "charged with
perjury." (Def. Mot. 3 at 10). In particular, she claims that Boies Schiller met with the
Government in February 2016, urged the Government to open an investigation of Epstein and
Maxwell, told the Government what was in its files, and met with the Government again in the
summer of 2016 to ask if it would consider charging the defendant with perjury after her two
depositions. (Id. at 2, 8).
That is not so. While a now former Assistant United States Attorney ("AUSA-1") met
with a lawyer from Boies Schiller and two other attorneys about Epstein in February 2016, that
meeting was not focused on the defendant, and AUSA-1 did not participate in a second meeting
with those attorneys. Moreover, that February 2016 meeting pre -dated the depositions that gave
rise to the perjury counts in the Indictment, which itself was obtained more than four years
thereafter.26 The Indictment was instead the product of an investigation that was not opened until
late 2018 and that had nothing to do with a meeting that had taken place nearly three years earlier
with an AUSA who played no part in the decision to open the 2018 investigation and similarly
played no part in the 2018 investigation itself.

1. The Civil Lawsuit against Maxwell
In or about September 2015, Giuffre, represented by Boies Schiller, filed a civil defamation
lawsuit against Maxwell in the Southern District of New York. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt.
26 While, as discussed herein, the Government has uncovered evidence of a phone call from one
of the attorneys, Stan Pottinger, to AUSA-1 in early May 2016, AUSA-1 has no specific memory
of that call, nor did AUSA-1 provide any notes or records of that call to the team working on the
instant investigation.

No. 1). In short, Giuffre alleged that Maxwell had defamed her when Maxwell stated that Giuffre
was not the victim of sex crimes perpetrated by Epstein and Maxwell. Giuffre alleged that
Maxwell had made those false statements for the "malicious purpose of further damaging a sexual
abuse and sexual trafficking victim; to destroy Giuffre's reputation and credibility; to cause the
world to disbelieve Giuffre; and to destroy Giuffre's efforts to use her experience to help others
suffering as sex trafficking victims." (Id. at 8).

2. February 2016 Meeting
Attorney Peter Skinner of Boies Schiller contacted AUSA-1, who was at that time the
Human Trafficking and Project Safe Childhood Coordinator of the USAO-SDNY, to request an
opportunity for him and other attorneys to meet with AUSA-1 to present on a potential case. (See
Ex. 4 at 1). 22 AUSA-1 agreed to the meeting, and on or about February 29, 2016, AUSA-1 met
with three attorneys —Peter Skinner of Boies Schiller, Brad Edwards, and Stan Pottinger—
regarding Jeffrey Epstein. (See Ex. 4 at 1). Edwards and Pottinger were also attorneys for Virginia
Roberts Giuffre, who had alleged that she is a victim of sex crimes perpetrated by Epstein and
Maxwell. 28 (Ex. 5 at 1).29
At the meeting, Edwards provided AUSA-1 with details about, among other things, the
USAO-SDFL's prior investigation of Epstein, as well as Giuffre's personal history and experience
with Epstein. (See Ex. 5). The focus of the meeting was on Epstein, and AUSA-1 understood that
the attorneys were advocating that the USAO-SDNY open an investigation into Epstein. (See Ex.
22 On February 11, 2021, to help gather facts relevant to the reporting contained in the New York
Daily News article, the USAO-SDNY and the FBI conducted a telephonic interview of AUSA-1.
Notes of that interview are attached as Exhibit 4.
28 Peter Skinner of Boies Schiller is not listed on the docket as an attorney representing Giuffre.
" AUSA-1's notes from the February 29, 2016 meeting are attached as Exhibit 5.
4 at 1, 4). During the meeting, the attorneys referenced multiple individuals who worked for and/or
helped Epstein, including Maxwell, but the attorneys primarily focused their presentation on
Epstein. (See id. at 1-2, 4). The attorneys did not present particular criminal statutes that might
be pursued by the USAO-SDNY or make suggestions about investigative steps, nor did they
suggest the use of civil lawsuits as a means to conduct a criminal investigation. (Id. at 2-3).
AUSA-1 did not tell the attorneys whether or not an investigation would be opened, consistent
with her standard practice. (Id. at 3). After the meeting, AUSA-1 received a limited number of
emails from the attorneys (see Exs. 6 & 7).30 AUSA-1 did not participate in a second meeting with
those attorneys and has never met David Boies. (See Ex. 4 at 4).
AUSA-1 recalls being aware of depositions as a general matter, but she does not recall
having knowledge of who had been deposed or the substance of the depositions. (Id. at 5). AUSA-
1 does recall thinking through the challenges of a potential perjury investigation, but she does not
recall who specifically would have been he target of such an investigation. (Id.). AUSA-1 does
not recall being asked if the USAO-SDNY would consider charging Maxwell with perjury. (Id.).
Moreover, and critically for present purposes, the meeting described above pre -dated the
depositions which give rise to the perjury counts in the instant Indictment, making it all but
impossible that the attorneys suggested, during that February 2016 meeting, that Maxwell had
committed perjury in depositions that, as detailed below, had yet to occur.
The Government has also conducted a review of AUSA-1's emails in an effort to determine
whether any further contacts occurred. One email dated May 3, 2016 from Pottinger to AUSA-1
appears to suggest that AUSA-1 spoke with Pottinger on or about May 2, 2016 by telephone (see
3° AUSA-1 left the USAO-SDNY in 2019. Since receiving the Defense Motions, the Government
has searched AUSA-1's archived emails for any email communications with attorneys from Boies
Schiller or the other attorneys who participated in the February 2016 meeting. The Government
is producing all identified emails to defense counsel today.

Ex. 7), but AUSA-1 does not recall the details of that conversation (see Ex. 4 at 4), nor is the
Government aware of any notes or other records documenting the substance of the call. The
Government has not identified any records that suggest AUSA-1 ever communicated via email
with Pottinger, Edwards, Skinner, or any other attorney at Boies Schiller regarding this matter after
May 3, 2016.
The USAO-SDNY did not open an investigation into Epstein or Maxwell in 2016. (Id. at
4).

3. The April and .luly 2016 Depositions of Maxwell
On March 2, 2016, Maxwell moved for entry of a protective order for materials produced
in discovery and submitted a proposed order for the consideration of the Honorable Robert W.
Sweet, the United States District Judge who was then overseeing the Giuffre v. Maxwell civil
litigation. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. Nos. 38 & 39-1). On or about March 4, 2016, Boies
Schiller represented that Giuffre did not oppose the entry of a protective order, but opposed the
form proposed by Maxwell out of concern that it was overly broad and could lead to over-
designation of material as confidential. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 40 at 2). Boies Schiller
submitted a redline of Maxwell's proposed protective order, deleting some provisions and adding
language that confidential material could be disclosed to law enforcement. (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. B).
On March 18, 2016, Judge Sweet entered a protective order governing the discovery and
dissemination of confidential information after the parties agreed to the form of the order originally
proposed by Maxwell. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 62; see also Def. Mot. 3, Ex. G at 2-3).
The protective order, among other things, restricted the parties from disclosing discovery materials
marked confidential to third parties, absent express permission from the Court.
In connection with the defamation suit, Maxwell was deposed by Boies Schiller, counsel
for Giuffre, on April 22, 2016 and July 22, 2016.
On or about May 24, 2017, the parties entered into a settlement agreement and voluntarily
dismissed the civil action. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 916). Boies Schiller has continued
to represent Giuffre in post-settlement litigation. Giuffre v. Maxwell, No. 18-2868 (2d Cir.);
Giuffre v. Maxwell, No. 20-2413 (2d Cir.).

4. The USAO-SDNY Commences the Instant Investigation in 2018
On or about November 29, 2018, the USAO-SDNY initiated its investigation into Epstein
and possible co-conspirators, and formally opened the investigation by completing the requisite
paperwork to open an investigation on or about November 30, 2018. The investigation was
prompted by a series of articles published by the Miami Herald earlier that same week relating to
Epstein, his conduct, and the circumstances of his prior conviction. See Julie K. Brown, "Even
from Jail, Sex Abuser Manipulated the System. His Victims Were Kept in the Dark," Miami
Herald (Nov. 28, 2018). 31 AUSA-1 was not involved in the decision to open the investigation or
in the investigation itself. (See Ex. 4 at 6). Indeed, AUSA-1 stopped serving as the Office's
Human Trafficking and Project Safe Childhood Coordinator as of April 2017.
Shortly after initiating the investigation, the prosecutors involved in the investigation
learned of the prior February 2016 meeting and requested copies of AUSA-1's notes and records
31 Indeed, on July 8, 2019, at the press conference following the arrest of Epstein, Geoffrey S.
Berman, then United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, stated that while he
was not "going to go into any aspects of how our investigation originated[,] I will say that we were
assisted from some excellent investigative journalism."
from that meeting. On or about December 6, 2018, AUSA-1 provided the prosecutors with her
notes from the February 2016 meeting (which are attached as Exhibit 5) and documents the
attorneys provided. 32
5. The USAO-SDNY's Subpoenas and Ex Pane Applications for
Materials
Shortly after opening the investigation in late November 2018, the Government identified
possible victims and their counsel through public filings or media reports, which included Boies
Schiller. (Def. Mem. 3, Ex. E at 2-3). The USAO-SDNY first contacted Boies Schiller about its
investigation on or about December 18, 2018. Shortly thereafter, in or about December or January
2018, the Government indicated to Boies Schiller that it intended to make document requests.
Boies Schiller generally advised the Government that a protective order would govern some of the
materials. (Id. at 3).
In or about February 2019, approximately two months after the USAO-SDNY opened its
investigation (and almost three years after the February 29, 2016 meeting described above), the
USAO-SDNY issued two criminal grand jury subpoenas to Boies Schiller. One of the subpoenas
requested non-privileged documents relating to Giuffre v. Maxwell, 15 Civ. 7433 (RWS); the other
32 The Government has reviewed the file that AUSA-1 provided to the prosecution team on or
about December 6, 2018 and understands, based on a review of that file, that at the February 2016
meeting, AUSA-1 received copies of Epstein's black book, flight records, and Palm Beach Police
Department reports. Although AUSA-1 does not now recall the attorneys providing her with any
documents at the meeting (Ex. 4 at 2), an email she sent to the prosecution team on December 6,
2018 refers to these documents as materials that the attorneys provided at the meeting.
The Government notes that as of March 7, 2016, one week after AUSA-1's February 29,
2016 meeting with the attorneys when she received these documents, Maxwell had only produced
two emails in response to Giuffre's discovery requests. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 43 at
1-2). None of the documents apparently provided to AUSA-1 during the February 2016 meeting
was an email. Accordingly, the Government has no reason to believe that Giuffre's counsel
provided AUSA-1 with any discovery materials from the Giu&•e v. Maxwell civil case. AUSA-1
also does not believe she ever received any such discovery materials. (Ex. 4 at 6).
requested the same relating to Jane Doe 43 v. Epstein, et al., 17 Civ. 0616 (JGK) (SN). Because
of the ongoing and covert nature of the grand jury investigation, and consistent with its standard
practice under such circumstances, the Government did not notify the defendant or her counsel
that it had issued the subpoenas.
In response to receiving the subpoenas, Boies Schiller began producing materials not
covered by the protective orders in the relevant civil cases. However, Boies Schiller also had
advised the Government that although it would not otherwise contest compliance with the
subpoenas, it believed that the protective orders precluded full compliance. 33 (Exs. 8 & 9).
Accordingly, the Government applied a pate and under seal to each relevant court (Judge Sweet
and Magistrate Judge Sarah Netbum, respectively) to request that each court modify the respective
protective orders to permit compliance with the subpoenas. (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. C).
Following a request by Judge Sweet for briefing supporting the Government's initial
application, see Del Mot. 3, Ex. D at 4, 20; Ex. G at 6, the Government submitted a pane and
sealed letters in support of its applications to each court on or about February 28, 2019. (Exs. 8 &
9). The Government wrote, "Where, as here, a grand jury subpoena has validly issued, and the
recipient of the subpoena is not contesting compliance —but rather seeking authorization to comply
with the subpoena —a court should grant such permission through limited modification of an
applicable protective order, absent countervailing interests not present in this case." (Id. at 2). The
Government submitted that the court was "best guided" by Chemical Bank v. Affiliated FM Ins.
Co., 154 F.R.D. 91, 93 (S.D.N.Y. 1994), in which the court rejected an application for a party in
civil litigation to be held in contempt for complying with a grand jury subpoena by producing
33 Significantly, and as detailed herein, Boies Schiller did not produce to the Government any
materials subject to the protective orders until, as further described below, it received an order
granting it the ability to do so in one of the civil cases.
materials in violation of a protective order, without first obtaining authorization from the court,
because the court would have granted such authorization had it been sought. (Id.). The court also
stated that such formal judicial approval could be obtained ex pane if sufficient reason was
provided. (Id.). In its letters, the Government noted that its "specific knowledge of the subject
matter of discovery materials is relatively limited, due to the confidential nature" of the litigation.

(Id. at 2 n.1). The Government also submitted that the court need not employ the Martindell
balancing test to evaluate the Government's ability to obtain access to materials covered by a
protective order because (1) the Martindell balancing test generally relates to "instances where the
Government sought protected information without [ ] grand jury process" and (2) "any
presumption against modification of a protective order is unreasonable where, as here, the
protective order is on its face temporary or limited." (Id. at 3-4).
6. Proceedings before Chief Judge McMahon
a. March 26, 2019 Hearing
Judge Sweet passed away in March 2019 before ruling on the Government's application.
After Judge Sweet's death, but before the civil case was reassigned to a new judge, Chief Judge
McMahon took up the Government's application. Chief Judge McMahon subsequently inquired
about the Government's application in two transcribed ex pane and sealed hearings. (Def. Mot.
3, Exs. D & E). At the first hearing, on March 26, 2019, Chief Judge McMahon inquired as to
why Boies Schiller did not make an application for permission to be relieved from the protective
order, to which the Government replied that it could not "speak to why Boies Schiller in particular
didn't make their own application." (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. D at 3). The Government further noted that
Boies Schiller "simply isn't in a position to be able to describe the investigation in the way that
we have in our submission." (Id. at 11-12). Chief Judge McMahon noted that she believed that
Martindell was applicable. (Id. at 3). She stated that were the Government's application disclosed
to the parties, "Maxwell would protest" and argue that the Government lacked standing as it was
not a party to the protective order. (Id. at 8). In response to questions from Chief Judge McMahon,
the Government explained that the protective order, on its face, did not implicate the types of
confidential business information or trade secrets ordinarily considered by courts in conducting
the Martindell balancing test. (Id. at 13).
Chief Judge McMahon stated that the protective order did not contain a provision allowing
a party to the order to disclose materials requested by law enforcement without permission of the
court, noting her understanding that "it may have been negotiated out." (Id. at 14-15). The court
inquired whether the Government's position was that "reliance on the nondisclosure of
confidential materials to law enforcement in connection with a grand jury subpoena that has been
duly authorized would be unreasonable." (Id. at 14). The Government responded in the
affirmative, stating that the Government believed a provision precluding compliance with a law
enforcement request would be void for public policy. (Id. at 15). The Government further cited
Chemical Bank in support of the proposition that it would be unreasonable to rely on a protective
order provision that barred the disclosure of information to law enforcement. (Id. at 15-16).
In response to questions about the breadth of the subpoena, the Government explained that
it was "essentially unable to significantly narrow the request for information . . We have either
little or no additional information than the Court does in terms of what materials there are [and]
who was deposed." (Id. at 17). In response to Chief Judge McMahon's question about the privacy
interests implicated by the protective order, (id. at 16-17), the Government also noted that it was
dissimilar to an ordinary third-party intervenor in that it would be "extremely restricted" in its use
of the materials in light of the "extraordinary protections" of Federal Rule of Criminal Procedue
6(e). (Id. at 17-18).
Finally, Chief Judge McMahon also inquired whether the materials sought by the
Government might be used to commence criminal proceedings against either of the parties to the
libel case, i.e., including Maxwell. (Id. at 18). The Government acknowledged that possibility as
a general matter. (Id.). Chief Judge McMahon noted that the parties to the protective order relied
on that order "in order to give whatever in discovery they gave, whether it was deposition
testimony they gave or — then again, I can't fathom why anybody who has any criminal exposure
would not have taken the Fifth Amendment in response to questions in a civil deposition, but I
don't know." (Id. at 18-19). The Government stated, "I do not know, but I think it is entirely
possible that what we are seeking is page after page of people taking the Fifth. That is entirely
possible. But to the extent that it is not or there are other materials -- and this may be bad for our
argument, but in all transparency and candor, I think there may be other individuals who also relied
on the protective order." (Id.). The Government further explained that it "want[ed] to have a
formal application" for the relevant materials and took that approach to "avoid the types of
problems" created by other less formal government requests in other cited cases. (Id. at 20).

b. April 9, 2019 Hearing
Chief Judge McMahon held another conference on April 9, 2019. She stated that she
wanted "to make sure I'm not in a Chemical Bank kind of situation, so I would like to know about
contacts between [the USAO-SDNY and Boies Schiller] prior to the issuance of the subpoena on
the subject of your investigation." (Del Mot. 3, Ex. E at 2 (emphasis added)). 34 In Chemical
34 Tellingly, Maxwell omits the italicized portion of this question from her motion, thereby
stripping important context from the nature of Chief Judge McMahon's question which, as asked,
was focused on "your investigation." (See Def. Mot. 3 at 7).
Bank, of course, as noted above, the subpoena recipient produced materials to a prosecutor in
direct violation of the relevant protective order, without seeking a modification of the protective
order and without any court authorization to do so. 154 F.R.D. at 93. Moreover, in that case, the
District Attorney seemingly opened its investigation and issued the subpoena in direct response to
information provided by the subpoena recipient who was then a party to civil litigation. Id.
The Government responded to Chief Judge McMahon by explaining its contacts with Boies
Schiller in connection with the instant (and only) investigation it had opened on Epstein, that is,
the investigation prompted by, and opened following, public reporting on Epstein in November

2018. In particular, the Government explained that the USAO-SDNY opened an investigation
first, on either November 30, 2018 or December 3, 2018, and then made contact with Boies Schiller
shortly thereafter. (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. E at 2-3). In this respect, the Government further explained
that the USAO-SDNY, after opening the investigation, had endeavored to identify counsel who
represented victims or witnesses in public filings or media reports, which included Boies Schiller,
noting that "[w]ith respect to Boies Schiller in particular, we quickly came to learn during the
investigation that they had at the time either active or recently completed civil litigation" and
indicated that the USAO-SDNY intended to make document requests. (Id.). The Government
also noted that, unlike in Chemical Bank, here Boies Schiller had informed the Government that it
would be unable to comply with the subpoena in light of the protective order. (Id. (noting that
Boies Schiller "generally advised us that they believed there was a protective order that would
govern at least some of the materials, and that is why we ultimately made the application to the
Court.")).
c. Chief Judge McMahon's Memorandum and Order
On or about April 9, 2019, Chief Judge McMahon granted the Government's application
and issued a memorandum and order. (Def. Mot. 3, Exs. F & G). The Court noted that while the
Government's application was procedurally "[i]rregular," there was precedent for granting the
Government's request and, therefore, the Court would consider the application. (De£ Mot. 3, Ex.
G at 6, 8-9). The Court found that, contrary to the Government's arguments, it was appropriate
for the Court to analyze the Government's application in light of the Martindell factors. (Id. at 9-
12).
In so doing, Chief Judge McMahon considered, among other things, "the degree to which
. . . the party who could be expected to oppose unsealing[] reasonably relied on the protective
order." (Id. at 16). She concluded that such reliance was unreasonable. (Id. at 22). She evaluated
the factors under Second Circuit case law that are relevant to assessing whether a party's reliance
on the protective order was reasonable, namely the scope of the protective order, the language of
the order itself, the court's level of inquiry before granting the order, and the nature of reliance on
the order. (Id. at 17). She concluded that first three factors favored granting the Government's
application for modification. (Id. at 17-20). Chief Judge McMahon noted that, as the order
"plainly gives the court the power to enter an order compelling disclosure to anyone —law
enforcement included —Maxwell could not reasonably have relied on the absence of automatic
permission for such disclosure to shield anything she said or produced from a grand jury's
scrutiny." (Id. at 18-19).
As to the last factor, Chief Judge McMahon found that "the nature of the parties' reliance
on the order does seem to weigh against modification." (Id. at 20). She noted that the record
indicated that "Giuffre likely could not have secured Maxwell's deposition —at least in the absence
of substantial court involvement —without" the protective order. (Id.). "However, the only thing
on which Maxwell or anyone else might reasonably have relied is that Giuffre or her lawyers would
not do what the defendant in Chemical Bank did—that is, forward discovery materials in their
possession to prosecutors for the purpose of fomenting an investigation. But I am not faced with
that situation." (Id. at 21). Chief Judge McMahon further stated, "Nothing in this record suggests
to me that Giuffre or Boies Schiller had anything to do with the Government's decision to convene
a grand jury to look into the matters that were the subject of the [civil lawsuit]." (Id.). Instead,
she explained that the Government informed the Court that it had "contacted Boies Schiller as part
of its search for parties who might have been victims in its investigation; and that Boies Schiller
told the Government that it could not consensually produce at least some documents in its files
because of the existence of the Protective Order." (Id.). Chief Judge McMahon concluded that it
was "quite clear that Boies Schiller did not foment the Government's investigation." (Id.).
Among other conclusions, Chief Judge McMahon found that because Maxwell's reliance
on the protective order in that case as a "shield [. . .] from the court-ordered disclosure of
Confidential Materials pursuant to a grand jury subpoena was unreasonable, the Court may
exercise its discretion to grant the Government's application." (Id. at 22). The Court further
concluded that "[t]he Government has persuasively demonstrated extraordinary circumstances,
which would entitle it to modification in any event." (Id.). She also noted that "while in other
circumstances the breadth of the subpoena might be troubling, here the Government is in no
position to narrow its request, because [the civil case] was litigated almost entirely under seal."

(Id. at 25).
Chief Judge McMahon permitted that the Government share the order—and only that
order, which itself prohibited further dissemination, and not including any other materials
associated with the Government's application —with Boies Schiller. The relevant order was
provided to Boies Schiller shortly after it was issued. The materials provided by Boies Schiller
included, in addition to deposition transcripts of Maxwell and other individuals, materials
produced by Giuffre, Maxwell, and non-parties, and court-related pleadings in the civil case.

7. Magistrate Judge Netburn's Order
On or about April 9, 2019, the Government advised Judge Netbum, who had not yet ruled
on the Government's other application in Jane Doe 43 v. Epstein, et at, 17 Civ. 0616 (JGK) (SN),
of Chief Judge McMahon's decision via a pane and sealed letter. (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. I).
Subsequently, on April 16, 2019, Judge Netburn denied the Government's application. (Def. Mot.
3, Ex. H). Judge Netburn found that she was authorized under the All Writs Act to modify the
protective order, but declined to do so as the Government had not established exceptional
circumstances or a compelling need. (Id. at 3). She concluded that on the record before her, the
parties' reliance on the protective order was reasonable and the presumption of confidentiality
should apply. (Id. at 5-6). The court rejected the Government's arguments for exceptional
circumstances and compelling need as relying on "the general desire for secrecy" and
"unpersuasive" under the Martindell standard. (Id. at 6). Judge Netbum concluded that "the
Government must demonstrate not that this investigation is an extraordinary circumstance, but that
the reason for seeking the documents is so extraordinary or compelling that there is a need to
modify the Protective Order. The Government has not met that standard." (Id. at 7) (emphasis in
original).

8. Unsealing of Maxwell's Depositions
Three months after Chief Judge McMahon issued her Order, Giuffre v. Maxwell was
reassigned to the Honorable Loretta A. Preska on July 9, 2019. On or about July 23, 2020, Judge
Preska ordered unsealed certain litigation materials, including, and related to, Maxwell's April
2016 deposition transcript. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1077). Maxwell appealed Judge
Preska's order, arguing that the court abused its discretion in ordering the unsealing of the
deposition materials and that Maxwell's interests outweighed the public's interests in access to the
materials. Giuffre v. Maxwell, No. 20-2413 (2d Cir.), (Dkt. No. 140-1 at 2). On October 19, 2020,
the Second Circuit found that Judge Preska "correctly held that the deposition materials are judicial
documents to which the presumption of public access attaches, and did not abuse its discretion in
rejecting Maxwell's meritless arguments that her interests superseded the presumption of access."

(Id. at 3).
On October 22, 2020, Maxwell's April 2016 deposition was publicly filed. (See 15 Civ.
7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1137-13).
On January 27, 2021, a redacted version of Maxwell's July 2016 deposition was publicly
filed. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1201-14). On February 11, 2021, another version of the
July 2016 deposition was publicly filed with fewer redactions. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No.
1212-1).

9. The New York Daily News Article
On October 13, 2020, the New York Daily News published an article describing the
February 29, 2016 meeting (the "Daily News Article" or the "Article"). 35 The Article stated,
among other things, that defense attorneys representing victims of Epstein and Maxwell "urged"
the USAO-SDNY to "open an investigation of the duo" during that meeting. Citing two
anonymous sources, the Article described the defense attorneys' alleged efforts to "pique" the
Government's interest "in a second meeting in the summer of 2016 after Maxwell allegedly
35 See Stephen Rex Brown, Manhattan federal prosecutors declined to pursue Jeffrey Epstein and
Ghislaine Maxwell case in 2016: sources, New York Daily News, Oct. 13, 2020,
https://wwvv.nydailynews.corninew-yorlc/ny-jeffity-epstein-maxwell-case-20201013-
jrnzhl7zdrzdgrbbs7yc6bfnszu-story.html.
committed perjury." According to two anonymous sources, "a second meeting occurred."
However, the Article cites another anonymous source as "insist[ing] [a second meeting] never
happened."

B. The Defendant's Suppression Motion Should Be Denied
Maxwell seeks suppression of the evidence the Government obtained via a judicially
authorized subpoena to Boies Schiller under Martindell, the Fourth Amendment, Fifth
Amendment, the Due Process clause, and the Court's inherent authority. However, Maxwell's
motion turns on erroneous facts, runs afoul of controlling law, and should be denied.

1. Martindell Provides No Basis to Grant the Relief the Defendant Seeks
Maxwell argues that the Government "circumvented" the Second Circuit's decision in
Martindell and "violated Maxwell's rights," which requires suppression of the evidence the
Government obtained from the subpoena. (Def. Mot. 11 at 11-12). Even assuming that to be
true—which, of course, as detailed above and herein, it is not—there is no basis in law to suppress
evidence as a result of a Martindell violation, and Maxwell cites none in support of her claim.
Setting that fatal flaw aside, however, her claim is wrong on both the facts and the law. The
Government issued a valid grand jury subpoena for the materials, applied for judicial authorization
to modify the protective order to permit compliance with the subpoena, and a district court judge,
who evaluated the Government's application under Martindell, properly exercised her discretion
in modifying the protective order. Only after receiving that court order did the Government obtain
any protected materials from Boies Schiller. Maxwell's motion should be denied.
a. Applicable Law
"[T]here is no question that a Rule 26(c) protective order is subject to modification," and
a decision to modify such an order is "committed to the sound discretion of the trial court." In re
"Agent Orange" Prod. Liab. Litig., 821 F.2d 139, 147 (2d Cir. 1987); see also Andover Data
Sows., a Div. of Players Computer, Inc. v. Statistical Tabulating Corp., 876 F.2d 1080, 1083 (2d
Cir. 1989) ("It is well-settled here and elsewhere, for instance, that a Rule 26(c) protective order
may be overturned or modified based on a finding of improvidence, extraordinary circumstances
or compelling need.").
In Martindell, the Government informally—and without use of a grand jury subpoena—
sought access to discovery materials from a civil litigation that were subject to a protective order.
594 F.2d at 294. The Second Circuit found that the "deponents [had] testified in reliance upon [a]
Rule 26(c) protective order, absent which they may have refused to testify." Id. at 296. In so
ruling, the Second Circuit reasoned that the interest in the enforcement of Rule 26(c) protective
orders—which included securing just and speedy determination of civil disputes—was sufficient
to outweigh the Government's interest in obtaining information by means of an informal document
request. Id. at 295-96. The Second Circuit held that "absent a showing of improvidence in the
grant of a Rule 26(c) protective order or some extraordinary circumstance or compelling need, ..
. a witness should be entitled to rely upon the enforceability of a protective order against any third
parties, including the Government." Id.; see also In re Grand Jury Subpoena Duces Tecum Dated
Apr. 19, 1991, 945 F.2d 1221, 1224-25 (2d Cir. 1991) ("The Martindell test [ ] does not transform
a protective order into a grant of immunity because the test allows a protective order to be
overcome by a showing of improvidence in the grant of the order, extraordinary circumstances or
compelling need."); Palmieri v. State of N.Y., 779 F.2d 861, 862 (2d Cir. 1985) (holding that
"absent an express finding by the district court of improvidence in the magistrate's initial grant of
the protective orders or of extraordinary circumstances or compelling need by the State for the
information protected thereunder, it was error for the district court to modify the magistrate's
orders").
At the same time, in Martindell, the court noted that "[t]he reliance of a private party upon
protection of pre-existing documents from disclosure to the Government would normally be more
difficult to justify than that of a witness who would, absent the protective order, have invoked his
privilege and given no testimony at all." Id. at 297 n.8; see also United States v. Davis, 702 F.2d
418, 422-23 (2d Cir. 1983) (finding Martindell inapplicable and affirming enforcement of a grand
jury subpoena where "there [was] no indication that [a witness] agreed to testify only in reliance
on [an] 'understanding"' of confidentiality and where many records sought "existed prior to the
advent of the litigation"). In subsequent cases, the Second Circuit has clarified that the Martindell
presumption comes into play only when a party reasonably relies on a protective order in providing
deposition testimony. See, e.g., Davis, 702 F.2d 418; SEC v. TheStreet.com, 273 F.3d 222, 230-
31 (2d Cir. 2001) (stating that "some protective orders may not merit a strong presumption against
modification," as the nature of some orders "may not justify reliance by the parties").
In United States v. Davis, the Second Circuit explained that "[r]anged against these
considerations [relating to the policy in favor of enforcing Rule 26(c) protective orders] are the
reasons for permitting the grand jury broad subpoena power in a criminal investigation." 702 F.2d
at 421. The Second Circuit noted the grand jury's "wide ranging authority to inquire into suspected
violations of the criminal law; and to effectuate such investigations it may compel the production
of documentary evidence or the testimony of witnesses, as it deems necessary." Id. at 421-22
(citing United States v. Calandra, 414 U.S. 338, 343 (1974)). "Wide latitude in gathering evidence
is vital to the grand jury's investigative function." Id. at 422; see Branzburg v. Hayes, 408 U.S.
665, 688 (1972) ("Although the powers of the grand jury are not unlimited and are subject to the
supervision of a judge, the longstanding principle that 'the public . . . has a right to every man's
evidence,' except for those persons protected by a constitutional, common-law, or statutory
privilege is particularly applicable to grand jury proceedings." (internal citations omitted)).
b. Discussion
The Government did not, in any way, attempt to circumvent Matthaei!. To the contrary,
the Government presented Martindell squarely to the relevant courts, first arguing that its test was
not applicable, and then, in the alternative, that the requested relief should be granted even if the
courts applied the Martindell standard. It cannot possibly be the case that the Government was
attempting to "circumvent" a case that it cited 11 times in its argument to both relevant courts.
(See (Exs. 8 & 9). Instead, the Government issued a subpoena to Boies Schiller in connection with
its investigation and made an application to two judges to modify Rule 26(c) protective orders that
precluded full compliance with those subpoenas. While the Government argued that the court
need not employ the Manindell balancing test for several reasons, it also made arguments under
Martindell in the alternative. Ultimately, both Chief Judge McMahon and Judge Netburn found
that Martindell applied and analyzed the Government's application under that framework.
As Chief Judge McMahon found, even under the Martindell approach, testimony provided
pursuant to a protective order can be divulged to a grand jury if the government establishes "some
extraordinary circumstance or compelling need." Martindell, 594 F.2d at 296. After concluding
that reliance on the protective order was unreasonable, 36 Chief Judge McMahon found that the
"Government [ ] persuasively demonstrated extraordinary circumstances," citing "significant
36 See, e.g., hit'! Equity Ines., Inc. v. Opportunity Equity Partners Ltd., No. 05 Civ. 2745 (JGK)
(RLE), 2010 WL 779314, at *8 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 2, 2010) (finding that the parties' reliance on a
civil protective order "was not unreasonable given the nature of the litigation," but "not so
overwhelming as to warrant the indefinite application of Martindell's strong presumption against
modification because the order's broad scope and express language, and the minimal level of court
inquiry outweigh the Parties' reliance.").
public interest" which resulted in the Government convening a grand jury to investigate a serious
crime. (Del. Mot. 3, Ex. G at 22-23). The Court also noted that because the investigation was not
publicly known, "the ordinary exercise of grand jury power [Le., to subpoena witnesses to testify
and to produce documents] . . . would implicate and invite the very risk of disclosure —and the
possibility of alerting potential criminal targets that they are under investigation, causing them to
destroy evidence, flee from prosecution, or otherwise seriously jeopardize the Investigation —that
caused the Government to proceed via subpoena [to Boies Schiller] and its related Application."

(Id. at 23-24). The Court further noted that the "Government's interest is bolstered" as the request
was made by a grand jury that had issued a "subpoena for the production of documents as part of
an ongoing investigation." (Id. at 25). In support of her argument, the defendant cites Palmieri
where the Second Circuit, applying Martindell, reversed the district court's decision granting the
state Attorney General's motion to intervene to modify sealing orders. (Def. Mot. 11 at 14).
Maxwell's reliance on Palmieri is of no avail. There, the Second Circuit held that the district court
erred by not expressly finding that the state had shown improvidence, extraordinary circumstances,
or compelling need before modifying the sealing orders in a civil case. Palmieri, 779 F.2d at 862,
866. By contrast, here Chief Judge McMahon made this explicit finding.
Judge Netbum, on the other hand, rejected the Government's arguments for exceptional
circumstances and compelling need as "unpersuasive" under the Martindell standard. (Def. Mot.
3, Ex. H at 6). Maxwell argues that Judge Netbum was "exactly right" in her analysis of whether
exceptional circumstances existed, but ignores the fact that Chief Judge McMahon made contrary
findings on this point. That two neutral judicial officers were presented with the facts, analyzed
the law, and reached varying conclusions based on different findings shows that there are
guardrails in place to ensure compliance with Martindell. In other words, the Government in no
way circumvented Martindell; rather, the Government sought court approval to enforce a subpoena
and then followed the directives it received. 37
Most critically, however, even if the Government's motion did not satisfy Martindell,
Maxwell offers no legal authority for the proposition that suppression is the proper remedy. 38
Indeed, none of the Second Circuit cases applying Martindell contemplate suppression as a
remedy. See, e.g., In re Grand Jury Subpoena Duces Tecum Dated Apr. 19, 1991, 945 F.2d at
1224 (remanding for findings "on whether the protective order was improvidently granted or
whether the government had made a showing of exceptional circumstances or a compelling need");
Palmieri, 779 F.2d at 862 (reversing district court's modification of protective orders where district
court did not make an "express finding" of improvidence, extraordinary circumstances, or
compelling need and "remand[ing] for further proceedings consistent with this opinion").
37 Maxwell asks this Court to review and reverse Chief Judge McMahon's exercise of her
discretion in modifying the protective order, because she disagrees with Chief Judge McMahon's
analysis of the Martindell factors. Although Chief Judge McMahon's order modifying the civil
protective order was not entered on the civil docket, that order, along with the Government's
application and related materials, were produced to the defense on or about August 12, 2020. As
a result, Maxwell could have sought review of Chief Judge McMahon's order in the Second
Circuit. See Fed. R. App. P. 4(a)(6). Maxwell asks this Court to second-guess a coequal district
court's decision to modify a protective order. Putting aside the question of whether this Court
even has the authority to do so, it should in any event decline Maxwell's invitation to act as a
reviewing court to Chief Judge McMahon's decision, which was made in her "sound discretion."
In re "Agent Orange" Prod. Liab. Litig., 821 F.2d at 147.
38 To the extent that Maxwell seeks suppression of documents created prior to the entry of the
protective order (or created after its entry but not subject to its protections), that aspect of her
motion should be denied. A significant amount of the materials provided in response to the
subpoena included such pre-existing documents not created in reliance on a protective order, which
do not trigger the Martindell presumption in the Second Circuit, see 77zeStreet.com, 273 F.3d at
234-235; Davis, 702 F.2d at 422. Maxwell's arguments also do not extend to transcripts of other
individuals' depositions, who were not parties to the protective order.

2. Maxwell's Fourth Amendment Claim Fails
Maxwell's Fourth Amendment motion is premised on a wholly unsupported expansion of
the law. Because Maxwell lacked a privacy interest in the files of a third party law firm who
represented her adversary in civil litigation, and because the subpoena was entirely lawful, she
cannot make out a Fourth Amendment violation. Moreover, even if Maxwell had standing to assert
this claim, it would nonetheless fail because the Government relied in good faith on a judicial order
permitting compliance with its subpoena.

a. Maxwell Has Not Established Standing
i. Applicable Law
The Fourth Amendment protects the "right of the people to be secure in their persons,
houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures." U.S. Const. amend IV.
"The basic purpose of this Amendment ... is to safeguard the privacy and security of individuals
against arbitrary invasions by governmental officials." Carpenter v. United States, 138 S. Ct.
2206, 2213 (internal quotation marks and citation omitted). "It has been clear for a generation that
`Fourth Amendment rights are personal rights ... [that] may not be vicariously asserted."' United
States v. Haqq, 278 F.3d 44, 47 (2d Cir. 2002) (quoting Rakas v. Illinois, 439 U.S. 128, 133-34
(1978)). Accordingly, a defendant's Fourth Amendment rights "are violated only when the
challenged conduct invaded his legitimate expectation of privacy rather than that of a third party."
United States v. Payner, 447 U.S. 727, 731 (1980) (emphasis in original); see also United States
v. Villegas, 899 F.2d 1324, 1333 (2d Cir. 1990). Ultimately, the Fourth Amendment inquiry is
"whether [a] defendant has established a legitimate expectation of privacy in the area searched."
United States v. Chuang, 897 F.2d 646, 649 (2d Cir. 1990) (citations omitted). This threshold
question involves two separate inquiries: (1) whether a defendant has demonstrated a subjective
expectation of privacy in the places and items that were searched; and (2) whether that expectation
was one that society accepts as reasonable. Id. It is axiomatic that "[t]he proponent of a motion
to suppress has the burden of establishing that his own Fourth Amendment rights were violated by
the challenged search or seizure." Rakas, 439 U.S. at 130, n.1; see also Rawlings v. Kentucky, 448
U.S. 98, 104 (1980).
Under the third party doctrine, the Fourth Amendment "does not prohibit the obtaining of
information revealed to a third party and conveyed by [the third party] to Government authorities."
United States v. Miller, 425 U.S. 435, 443 (1976). The Supreme Court has long held that "a person
has no legitimate expectation of privacy in information he voluntarily turns over to third parties,"
Smith v. Maryland, 442 U.S. 735, 743-44 (1979), "even if the information is revealed on the
assumption that it will be used only for a limited purpose," Miller, 425 U.S. 435, at 443.
Exceptions to the applicability of the third party doctrine are narrow. For example, in Carpenter,
138 S. Ct. at 2220, the Supreme Court declined to extend the third party doctrine to cell site
location information, holding that "a warrant is required in the rare case where the suspect has a
legitimate privacy interest in records held by a third party." 138 S. Ct. at 2222. However, the
Court stressed that its holding was "a narrow one," with specific consideration given to "the unique
nature of cell phone location information," id. at 2220, which "provides an intimate window into
a person's life," id. at 2217.
"The law is clear that the burden on the defendant to establish [Fourth Amendment]
standing is met only by sworn evidence, in the form of affidavit or testimony, from the defendant
or someone with personal knowledge." United States v. Montoya-Eschevarria, 892 F. Supp. 104,
106 (S.D.N.Y. 1995) (citations omitted); see also United States v. Ulbricht, No. 14 Cr. 68 (KBF),
2014 WL 5090039, at *6 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 10, 2014); Rakas, 439 U.S. at 130 n.1.
ii. Discussion
Maxwell cannot assert a Fourth Amendment claim because she had no legitimate
expectation of privacy in the deposition transcripts or other materials she designated as confidential
under the protective order. The materials were held by a third party law firm that represented her
adversary in the civil suit. See Smith, 442 U.S. at 743-44 ("a person has no legitimate expectation
of privacy in information he voluntarily turns over to third parties"); Miller, 425 U.S. at 443 (no
legitimate expectation of privacy in materials held by a third party "even if the information is
revealed on the assumption that it will be used only for a limited purpose"); Carpenter, 138 S. Ct.
at 2220 ("We do not disturb the application of Smith and Miller ."). Maxwell cites no authority
for the proposition that she has standing to challenge a judicially approved grand jury subpoena
directed at a third party law firm, because there is none.
Maxwell points to the fact that the materials were designated as confidential under the
protective order, but that reliance is misplaced. (Def. Mot. 11 at 6-8). Martindell by its own terms
contemplates the modification of a protective order in a civil action. See, e.g., Andover Data
Sews., 876 F.2d at 1083 ("It is well-settled here and elsewhere . . . that a Rule 26(c) protective
order may be overturned or modified based on a finding of improvidence, extraordinary
circumstances or compelling need."). And with respect to the specific protective order at issue,
Chief Judge McMahon found that because the order "plainly gives the court the power to enter an
order compelling disclosure to anyone —law enforcement included —Maxwell could not
reasonably have relied on the absence of automatic permission for such disclosure to shield
anything she said or produced from a grand jury's scrutiny." (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. Gat 18-19); see
also Def. Mot. 3, Ex. A at ¶ 5 ("CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION[] shall not, without the
consent of the party producing it or further Order of the Court, be disclosed[.]") (internal quotation
marks omitted) (emphasis added)); In re "Agent Orange" Prod. Liab. Litig., 821 F.2d at 145 ("It
is undisputed that a district court retains the power to modify or lift protective orders that it has
entered."). It also bears noting that Martindell and its progeny do not discuss law enforcement
applications in Fourth Amendment terms.
In an effort to avoid the application of the third party doctrine, Maxwell contends that she
did not in fact voluntarily share anything in the civil suit, and that "every other circumstance"
supported her "expectation that her deposition transcripts would be private." (Def. Mot. 11 at 9).
Neither argument withstands scrutiny. As an initial matter, the facts of this case are far removed
from the "narrow" circumstances in which the Supreme Court has found an exception to the third
party doctrine. For example, the Carpenter Court, while stressing that its holding was a "narrow
one," 138 S. Ct. at 2220, held that "[g]iven the unique nature of cell phone location records," which
provide a "intimate window into a person's life," "the fact that the information is held by a third
party does not by itself overcome the user's claim to Fourth Amendment protection." Id. at 2217;
see also Zietzke v. United States, 426 F. Supp. 3d 758, 768 (W.D. Wash. 2019) ("The Court . . .
will extend Carpenter to new circumstances only if they directly implicate the privacy concerns
that animated the majority. [T]he majority was overwhelmingly concerned with `Carpenter's
anticipation of privacy in his physical location.' In other words, Carpenter was about
surveillance." (internal citation omitted)).
There can be no serious argument that the facts of this case, or the materials obtained
pursuant to the subpoena issued here, revealed Maxwell's physical location over a period of time
or are otherwise in any way analogous to the narrow category of information contemplated by the
majority in Carpenter. To the extent the defendant argues that her deposition transcripts implicate
such interests because she "did not `voluntarily convey' her testimony to Giuffre," (Def. Mot. II
at 10), the Court should reject the defendant's efforts to twist Carpenter's exception to the third
party rule beyond recognition. The defendant was not compelled to participate in the deposition
or to answer questions without invoking her Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination; she
voluntarily chose to do so. Even if she chose to do so in reliance on the protective order, that
protective order was subject to modification under well-settled case law and by its own terms.
Contrary to the defendant's claims (Def. Mot. 11 at 10), she assumed the risk that the deposition
transcripts would divulged to the Government. See, e.g., United States v. Schaefer, No. 17 Cr. 400
(HZ), 2019 WL 267711, at *5 (D. Or. Jan. 17, 2019) (declining to apply Carpenter where
government obtained defendant's eBay transactions without a warrant as defendant "assumed the
risk that [eBay] would reveal to police the purchases he made" and defendant "did not have a
reasonable expectation of privacy in the records of his purchases").
Because Maxwell had no legitimate Fourth Amendment privacy interest in the materials in
Boies Schiller's possession, she has no standing to challenge their seizure, and no warrant was
required to obtain those materials. Her motion should be rejected on this ground alone.

b. The Government Acted in Good Faith
Even if the defendant had standing to bring this motion, it still fails because the
Government only obtained these materials after obtaining a court order authorizing it to do so. The
Government accordingly acted in good faith when it acted pursuant to that judicial order.

i. Applicable Law
Under the so-called "good faith" exception, the exclusionary rule and its remedy of
suppression do not apply "when the Government `act[s] with an "objectively reasonable good-
faith belief that their conduct is lawful."' United States v. Zodhiates, 901 F.3d 137, 143 (2d Cir.
2018) (quoting Davis v. United States, 564 U.S. 229, 238 (2011) (internal quotation marks
omitted)). "As the rule seeks to deter future Fourth Amendment violations, the Supreme Court
advises district courts to only suppress evidence where it serves such a purpose." United States v.
Williams, No. 10 Cr. 622 (ADS), 2018 WL 4623017, at *4 (E.D.N.Y. Sept. 26, 2018) (internal
quotation marks and citations omitted). "`[T]he exclusionary rule is not an individual right and
applies only where it results in appreciable deterrence." United States v. Eldred, 933 F.3d 110,
118 (2d Cir. 2019) (quoting Herring v. United States, 555 U.S. 135, 141 (2009)); see also Herring,
555 U.S. at 144 (concluding that "[t]o trigger the exclusionary rule, police conduct must be
sufficiently deliberate that exclusion can meaningfully deter it, and sufficiently culpable that such
deterrence is worth the price paid by the justice system."). As a result, exclusion should be a "last
resort" rather than a "first impulse." United States v. Rosa, 626 F.3d 56, 64 (2d Cir. 2010) (internal
quotation marks and citation omitted). The exclusionary rule should be used only where law
enforcement "`exhibit[s] deliberate, reckless, or grossly negligent disregard for Fourth
Amendment rights."' United States v. Raymonda, 780 F.3d 105, 117-18 (2d Cir. 2015) (quoting
United States v. Stokes, 733 F.3d 438, 443 (2d Cir. 2013)); see also United States v. Green, 981
F.3d 945, 957 (11th Cir. 2020) ("It follows that when officers act with `an objectively reasonable
good-faith belief that their conduct is lawful'—i.e., by acting in reasonable reliance on a warrant,
statute, or court order—the exclusionary rule does not apply because there is little, if any,
deterrence benefit in such circumstances." (citations omitted)).
In the context of search warrants, suppression will generally not be warranted where the
evidence at issue was "obtained in objectively reasonable reliance on a subsequently invalidated
search warrant." United States v. Leon, 468 U.S. 897, 922 (1984). As a result, although the burden
is on the Government to establish good faith, "[s]earches pursuant to a warrant will rarely require
any deep inquiry into reasonableness, for a warrant issued by a magistrate normally suffices to
establish that a law enforcement officer has acted in good faith in conducting the search." Id.
(internal quotation marks and citations omitted); see also Golino v. City of New Haven, 950 F.2d
864, 870 (2d Cir. 1991) (noting that the "issuance of a warrant by a neutral magistrate, which
depends on a finding of probable cause, creates a presumption that it was objectively reasonable
for the officers to believe that there was probable cause"). Indeed, the good faith exception does
not apply only in four narrow circumstances:

(1) where the issuing magistrate has been knowingly misled; (2)
where the issuing magistrate wholly abandoned his or her judicial
role; (3) where the application is so lacking in indicia of probable
cause as to render reliance upon it unreasonable; and (4) where the
warrant is so facially deficient that reliance upon it is unreasonable.
United States v. Moore, 968 F.2d 216, 222 (2d Cir. 1992) (citing Leon, 468 U.S. at 923). The good
faith exception analysis applies in the context of court orders. See, e.g., Zodhiates, 901 F.3d at
143 (applying good faith analysis in Fourth Amendment challenge to cell phone location
information obtained by subpoena issued pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2703(c)(2)); United States v.
Serrano, No. 13 Cr. 58 (KBF), 2014 WL 2696569, at *7 (S.D.N.Y. June 10, 2014) (finding good
faith exception would apply to cell site information obtained pursuant to a subpoena authorized by
magistrate judge pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2703(d)); United States v. Ashburn, 76 F. Supp. 3d 401,
406, 414-18 (E.D.N.Y. 2014) (applying Leon to § 2703(d) orders for historical cell-site data
obtained and finding that the good faith exception applied).
ii. Discussion
The exclusionary rule and its remedy of suppression should not apply here, as the
Government issued a grand jury subpoena; sought the materials after applying to the district court
for an order to modify the civil protective order; and only obtained the materials after the district
court modified the protective order and issued a 26-page decision. The Government acted in
reasonable reliance on the district court's decision.
The defendant argues that the Government misled the Court when it "claimed not to know
what was in Boies Schiller's file and that Boies Schiller had no role in instigating the investigation
of Maxwell." (Del. Mot. 11 at 1). The defendant's claims are both factually inaccurate and
meritless.
First, the Government did not mislead Chief Judge McMahon about its contacts with Boies
Schiller. As an initial matter, Maxwell's argument is premised solely on her use of selective
snippets from a lone Daily News Article that is premised, in meaningful part, on anonymous
sources and hearsay. As the factual background set forth above —which is corroborated by notes
and correspondence produced alongside this brief—makes clear, David Boies and Boies Schiller
played no role in initiating, let alone "fomenting" the Government's investigation. That
investigation was opened more than two and a half years after the last known contact between any
lawyer associated with any civil counsel for Giuffre and, in any event, was initially focused on
Epstein, not this defendant. As detailed above, the USAO-SDNY opened the instant investigation
in late November 2018 shortly after the Miami Herald published a series of articles about Epstein.
AUSA-1 was not involved in that decision, which in any event had nothing to do with a meeting
that had taken place nearly three years prior.39 (Ex. 4 at 6).
39 Maxwell repeatedly claims that Boies Schiller urged AUSA-1 to open an investigation of
Epstein and Maxwell, (Def. Mot. 3 at 8), but that allegation, which is supported by nothing aside
from the above-referenced media report, is incorrect. While AUSA-1 did meet with the three
attorneys in February 2016, she understood the attorneys to be focused on Epstein, and not on
Epstein and Maxwell as a "duo." (Ex. 4 at I, 4). The presentation to AUSA-1 focused on urging
an investigation into Epstein with only passing references to Maxwell. Simply put, the pitch was
to investigate Epstein, not Maxwell.
The defendant repeatedly argues that the Government's failure to mention AUSA-1's prior
contact with Boies Schiller in 2016 was a misrepresentation that led to the modification of the
protective order. The argument, which relies principally on hyperbolic rhetoric, is simply
incorrect. As an initial matter, the Government did not insist, contrary to Maxwell's twisted
reading of the transcript, that "there had been no contact whatsoever" between Boies Schiller and
the Government at any time prior to the Government opening its investigation. (Def. Mot. 3 at 1).
Instead, Chief Judge McMahon's question was more specific: referencing Chemical Bank and the
desire to avoid "a Chemical Bank kind of situation," Chief Judge McMahon asked about contacts
between the two parties "prior to the issuance of the subpoena on the subject ofyour investigation."
(Def. Mot. 3, Ex. E at 2 (emphasis added); see also Def. Mot. 3 at 7 (omitting the italicized portion
of the question)). In response, the Government described accurately its communications with
Boies Schiller that had occurred in the time period surrounding the opening of its investigation and
the issuance of the subpoena. Additionally, and in light of the Government's prior arguments to
Chief Judge McMahon relating to Chemical Bank,4° the Government attempted to address the
misconduct at issue in that case: namely the production of confidential documents without seeking
modification of a protective order by confirming that, here, no such production had yet occurred.
(Def. Mot. 3, Ex. E at 2) (noting that Boies Schiller "generally advised us that they believed there
40 See, e.g., Exs. 8 & 9 at 2-3 (discussing Chemical Bank as rejecting a contempt request where a
party "compl[ied] with a grand jury subpoena despite the existence of a protective order" and
focusing arguments on the nature of the production of documents); (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. D at 15) (the
Government describing Chemical Bank as "essentially say[ing]: You should have asked, but of
course this is fine for you to disclose this information to the government based on the validly issued
grand jury subpoena"); cf (id. at 4 (Chief Judge McMahon describing Chemical Bank as saying
"the proper procedure [for the production of documents] is for somebody to make a motion to be
relieved from the terms of the protective order"), 20 (Chief Judge McMahon stating that "in the
Chemical Bank case, it all was ex post facto and it all happened")).
was a protective order that would govern at least some of the materials, and that is why we
ultimately made the application to the Court.")).
While the Government appreciates, with the benefit of hindsight, that an answer that had
also referenced the February 2016 meeting (and the fact that USAO-SDNY took no action as a
result of that meeting) would have provided additional context —and would have further reinforced
that this was not a "Chemical Bank situation" —as noted above, the Government's response
accurately described its contacts with Boies Schiller as relevant to "your investigation" and the
issuance of the subpoena at hand. Indeed, there is no reason to believe that a description of the
February 2016 meeting would have been material to Chief Judge McMahon's analysis of whether
she was facing a "Chemical Bank kind of situation." (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. E at 2).
In Chemical Bank, counsel for a civil party approached the Manhattan District Attorney's
Office "suggesting that it had evidence of criminal violations relating to the case." 154 F.R.D. at
93. In response, a grand jury subpoena was issued and "confidential documents were produced by
the defendant without complying with any of the specific procedures or exceptions provided in the
[confidentiality] orders." Id. Here, by contrast, the Government accurately conveyed to Chief
Judge McMahon the opening of its investigation in late 2018, the reason it made contact with Boies
Schiller shortly thereafter and served a subpoena in February 2019, and that no documents
governed by the protective order had yet been produced. Aside from rank speculation loosely
premised on an anonymously sourced news report, the defendant offers nothing to support her
assertion that "Boies Schiller was instrumental in fomenting the Maxwell prosecution" (Def. Mot.
3 at 2) (emphasis in original), or that AUSA-1 's February 2016 meeting with Boies Schiller (as it
actually occurred) undercut the accuracy of the Government's representations to Chief Judge
McMahon, or played any role in the Government opening its investigation in November 2018.
Second, the Government did not misrepresent the extent of its knowledge of the contents
of Boies Schiller's files. As the Government correctly represented to the court, the Government
had "either little or no additional information than the Court does in terms of what materials there
are [and] who was deposed." (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. D at 17). In support of her argument, Maxwell
cites again to the Daily News Article, which reports that "after Maxwell's two depositions, David
Boies himself apparently approached the government in the summer of 2016, asking if the
Southern District would consider charging Maxwell with perjury"' (Def. Mot. 3 at 8). But the
Government has uncovered no evidence that such a meeting ever occurred. AUSA-1 does not
recall ever speaking with or meeting David Boies in her life. (Ex. 4 at 4). Moreover, AUSA-1
does not recall being asked if the USAO-SDNY would consider charging Maxwell with perjury

(id. at 5), and while notes of the February 2016 meeting refer to the existence of depositions
generally, there can be no question Chief Judge McMahon appreciated the Government's general
understanding that such transcripts would be part of the civil litigation file. (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. G at
21). Simply put, there is no evidence that the Government had any significant knowledge of the
contents of Boies Schiller's files, or that the Government's representations to Chief Judge
McMahon were incorrect.
In sum, Maxwell has failed to put forth any evidence that the Government misled Chief
Judge McMahon, and as such, the good faith exception applies. To the contrary, the record before
the Court demonstrates that the Government directly responded to Chief Judge McMahon's
question and accurately described the contacts between Boies Schiller and the USAO-SDNY in
connection with the investigation, the Government's lack of knowledge of the contents of that file,
and the fact that no protected materials had been produced in violation of the protective order.
Upon receiving a court order issued by a Chief United States District Judge who had carefully
considered the Government's application and then issued a lengthy opinion ruling on that
application, the Government was entirely reasonable in its understanding that the order was lawful.
It was therefore similarly reasonable for the Government to obtain materials from Boies Schiller
in response to the subpoena that had been analyzed and blessed by a court order. The Government
acted with an 'objectively reasonable good-faith belief' that its conduct was lawful and in
reasonable reliance on the district court's order. Zodhiates, 901 F.3d at 143 (internal quotation
marks and citations omitted).

c. Suppression of Certain Materials Would Be Improper Under
the Inevitable Discovery Doctrine
To the extent materials the Government obtained from Boies Schiller have now been
unsealed and posted on the public docket, there is no basis to suppress such materials because the
Government would have inevitably been able to access them upon unsealing.

i. Applicable Law
Under the inevitable discovery doctrine, "evidence that was illegally obtained will not be
suppressed `if the government can prove that the evidence would have been obtained inevitably'
even if there had been no statutory or constitutional violation." United States v. Roberts, 852 F.2d
671, 675-76 (2d Cir. 1988) (quoting Nix v. Williams, 467 U.S. 431, 447 (1984)). When a claim of
inevitable discovery is raised, the court must "determine, viewing affairs as they existed at the
instant before the unlawful search occurred, what would have happened had the unlawful search
never occurred." Stokes, 733 F.3d at 444 (citation omitted) (emphasis in original); see also United
States v. Heath, 455 F.3d 52, 55 (2d Cir. 2006) (The application of the inevitable discovery
doctrine "turns on a central question: Would the disputed evidence inevitably have been found
through legal means `but for' the constitutional violation? If the answer is `yes,' the evidence
seized will not be excluded.").
"The government bears the burden of proving inevitable discovery by a preponderance of
the evidence." Stokes, 733 F.3d at 444 (citing Mr, 467 U.S. at 444). This requires establishing,
"'with a high level of confidence, that each of the contingencies necessary to the legal discovery
of the contested evidence would be resolved in the government's favor." Id. (quoting Heath, 455
F.3d at 60). As the Supreme Court has explained, if the Government can establish that the evidence
inevitably would have been discovered by lawful means, "then the deterrence rationale [for the
exclusionary rule] has so little basis that the evidence should be received." Nix, 467 U.S. at 444.
ii. Discussion
Even if the Court were to find that there had been some constitutional violation in the
Government obtaining a modification of the protective order—which it should not—the question
in an inevitable discovery analysis is whether the Government would inevitably have found the
disputed evidence. The answer is yes, at least as to some of the evidence, including the April 2016
deposition that forms the basis of Count Five and part of the July 2016 deposition that forms the
basis of Count Six.41
41 In January 2021, the defendant asked Judge Preska to reconsider her order unsealing certain
portions of her testimony on the basis that, among other things, public release of the section would
make it more difficult for Maxwell to suppress the testimony as evidence against her at her criminal
trial. On February 8, 2021, Judge Preska "decline[d] Ms. Maxwell's invitation to reconsider its
order" and noted that the defendant had both filed a suppression motion and available tools under
the Federal Rules of Evidence and Procedure. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1211 at 3, 5).
The portion of the July 2016 deposition transcript that forms the basis of Count Six that has been
unsealed relates to the defendant denying that she has given a massage to anyone, including Epstein
or Minor Victim-2. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1212-1 at 113). The fact that the defendant
argued against unsealing the transcript by pointing to her suppression argument is irrelevant. Judge
Preska determined that the public's First Amendment right of access outweighed the defendant's
interests. If the Government had not modified the protective order and charged the defendant with
perjury based on the deposition transcript, that argument would have been unavailable and the
balance would have tipped still more in favor of public access, leading to the transcript's inevitable
discovery.
The defendant asks the Court for a drastic remedy, namely suppression of all evidence the
Government obtained pursuant to the subpoena, as well as the dismissal of Counts Five and Six.
In so doing, the defendant seeks a windfall to which she is not entitled based on unprecedented
claims that ignore the facts and the law. Suppression of all materials the Government obtained
pursuant to the subpoena is unwarranted here, particularly where certain of the materials have been
subsequently unsealed by Judge Preska in the underlying civil litigation, including Maxwell's
April 2016 deposition transcript. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1077). The Second Circuit
affirmed Judge Preska's ruling in October 2020, finding that the Court "correctly held that the
deposition materials are judicial documents to which the presumption of public access attaches,
and did not abuse its discretion in rejecting Maxwell's meritless arguments that her interests
superseded the presumption of access." Giuffre v. Maxwell, No. 20-2413 (2d Cir.), (Dkt. No. 140-
1 at 3).42 On October 22, 2020, the defendant's April 2016 deposition was publicly filed. (See 15
Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1137-13). In February 2021, a redacted version of the defendant's July
2016 deposition was publicly filed. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1212-1). In other words,
had the Government not obtained an order modifying the protective order, the Government
inevitably would have discovered and obtained, at a minimum, the defendant's April 2016
deposition transcript and a portion of the July 2016 transcript that form the basis of the charges in
Counts Five and Six.
42 Relatedly, the defendant moved to modify the criminal protective order in order to use
confidential criminal discovery materials in filings she intended to submit in civil litigation. The
defendant raised this precise point—that if the Court ultimately decided that it was inappropriate
for the Government to proceed by subpoena, the Government would claim inevitable discovery.
(Dkt. No. 54 at 3). The defendant offered no coherent explanation of how the criminal discovery
materials could have any conceivable impact on the issues pending in civil litigation. She cited no
case law suggesting that, for example, the possibility of an inevitable discovery argument by the
Government should foreclose unsealing in a civil case. This Court rejected the defendant's motion
to modify the criminal protective order. (Dkt. No. 51). The Second Circuit also dismissed the
defendant's appeal for want of jurisdiction. (Dkt. No. 71).

3. The Defendant's Motion to Suppress Evidence Obtained Pursuant to
the Subpoena Under the Fifth Amendment Is Without Merit
The defendant's motion to suppress all evidence obtained pursuant to the subpoena on Fifth
Amendment grounds fails for multiple, independent reasons. As an initial matter, Boies Schiller
is not the Government and was not acting as an agent of the Government when it deposed the
defendant or otherwise litigated the civil case against her. That the defendant may regret her choice
to respond to Boies Schiller's questions during two depositions instead of invoking her privilege
against self-incrimination does not transform that choice into a Fifth Amendment violation.

a. Applicable Law
i. The Fifth Amendment — Generally
The Fifth Amendment provides in pertinent part: "No person .. . shall be compelled in any
criminal case to be a witness against himself." U.S. Const. amend. V. To establish a Fifth
Amendment violation, an individual must "demonstrate the existence of three elements:
1) compulsion, 2) a testimonial communication, and 3) the incriminating nature of that
communication." In re Grand Jwy Subpoena, 826 F.2d 1166, 1168 (1987); see also, e.g., In Re
Three Grand Jut) , Subpoenas Jan. 5, 1988, 847 F.2d 1024, 1028 (2d Cir. 1988).
It is "axiomatic that the Amendment does not automatically preclude self-incrimination,
whether spontaneous or in response to questions put by government officials." United States v.
Washington, 431 U.S. 181, 186 (1977). "Indeed, far from being prohibited by the Constitution,
admissions of guilt by wrongdoers, if not coerced, are inherently desirable." Id. at 187. "[T]he
Fifth Amendment proscribes only self-incrimination obtained by a `genuine compulsion of
testimony.'" Id. (quoting Michigan v. Tucker, 417 U.S. 433, 440 (1974)); see also Washington,
431 U.S. at 187 ("Absent some officially coerced self-accusation, the Fifth Amendment privilege
is not violated by even the most damning admissions."). Nor does the Constitution "prohibit every
element which influences a criminal suspect to make incriminating admissions." Id. The question
is not whether a witness was encouraged to speak, but whether his "free will," when he spoke,
"was overborne." Id. at 188; see also, e.g., United States v. Corbett, 750 F.3d 245, 253 (2d Cir.
2014).
It follows that the Government need not inform a witness of the nature of its investigation,
see United States v. Olovumabua, 828 F.2d 950, 953 (2d Cir. 1987), much less his individual status
in the investigation, see Washington, 431 U.S. at 189 & 190 n.6. The Constitution does not
"require that the police supply a suspect with a flow of information to help him calibrate his self-
interest in deciding whether to speak or stand by his rights." Colorado v. Spring, 479 U.S. 564,
576-77 (1987) (internal quotation marks omitted); see also, e.g., id. at 577 (there is no requirement
that law enforcement give information that might affect "the wisdom" of speaking). Nor does the
Constitution require that someone be questioned only in the manner most likely to ensure that he
gives the decision whether to speak careful thought. See, e.g., United States v. Roberts, 660 F.3d
149, 157 (2d Cir. 2011) ("the Fifth Amendment does not protect against hard choices" (internal
quotation marks omitted)); United States v. Mullens, 536 F.2d 997, 1000 (2d Cir. 1976) (there is a
difference between "those choices which are physically or psychologically coerced and those
which are merely difficult").
In short, the Fifth Amendment is only violated by "government misconduct" that is
"coercive." Colorado v. Connelly, 479 U.S. 157, 163 (1986); see also Oregon v. Elstad, 470 U.S.
298, 312 (1985) (Fifth Amendment prohibits "coercion" effected "by physical violence or other
deliberate means calculated to break the suspect's will").
ii. The Fifth Amendment — Act of Production Privilege
The act of production privilege is a form of the Fifth Amendment privilege pertaining to
the production of materials. "[Ain individual may claim an act of production privilege to decline
to produce documents, the contents of which are not privileged, where the act of production is,
itself, (1) compelled, (2) testimonial, and (3) incriminating." In re Three Grand Jury Subpoenas
Duces Tecwn Dated Jan. 29, 1999, 191 F.3d 173, 178 (2d Cir. 1999).
Consistent with these requirements, the privilege only "prohibits the compelled disclosure
of documents when the act of production has independent communicative aspects -such as an
admission that the documents exist, that the subject possesses or controls the documents, that the
documents are authentic, or that the subject believes the documents are responsive to the
subpoena." In re Various Grand Jury Subpoenas, 924 F. Supp. 2d 549, 552 (S.D.N.Y. 2013),
aff'd, 579 F. App's 37 (2d Cir. 2014); see also Fisher v. United States, 425 U.S. 391, 408 (1976).
It follows that the privilege does not apply when "[t]he existence and location of the [sought]
papers are a foregone conclusion and the [compelled individual] adds little or nothing to the sum
total of the Government's information by conceding that he in fact has the papers." Id. at 411; see
also In re Grand Jury Subpoena Duces Tecum Dated Oct. 29, 1992, 1 F.3d 87, 93 (2d Cir. 1993);
Madanes v. Madanes, 186 F.R.D. 279, 284 (S.D.N.Y. 1999) ("[E]ven if documents contain
incriminating information, requiring a person to produce them does not implicate the Fifth
Amendment unless the act of production is itself testimonial in nature and incriminating to the
person making the disclosure.").
iii. The Fifth Amendment — When Private Action Is Deemed
Government Action
As discussed above, "[t]he sole concern of the Fifth Amendment . . is governmental
coercion." Connelly, 479 U.S. at 170. "[T]he Fifth Amendment privilege is not concerned `with
moral and psychological pressures to confess emanating from sources other than official
coercion.'" Id. (quoting Elsiad, 470 U.S. at 305). For this reason, even "[t]he most outrageous
behavior by a private party seeking to secure evidence against a defendant does not make that
evidence inadmissible." Connelly, 479 U.S. at 166.
This does not mean that only action undertaken directly by the Government may violate
the Fifth Amendment (or another right). In certain circumstances, a private entity may be deemed
to be acting as a government agent. See United States v. Stein, 541 F.3d 130, 146 (2d Cir. 2008)
("Actions of a private entity are attributable to the State if there is a sufficiently close nexus
between the State and the challenged action of the entity so that the action of the latter may be
fairly treated as that of the State itself." (internal quotation marks and ellipsis omitted)).
However, this standard "is not satisfied when the state merely approves of or acquiesces in
the initiatives of the private entity, or when an entity is merely subject to governmental regulation."

Id. (internal quotations marks and citations omitted; alterations incorporated)). Nor is it sufficient
that a non-government entity chooses to cooperate with a government investigation or has its own
parallel investigation. See id. at 150. Non-government action is attributable to the government
"only when it can be said that the State is responsible for the specific conduct of which the
[defendant] complains." Blum v. Yaretsky, 457 U.S. 991, 1004 (1982) (emphasis in original).
"Such responsibility is normally found when the State `has exercised coercive power or has
provided such significant encouragement, either overt or covert, that the choice must in law be
deemed to be that of the State."' Stein, 541 F.3d at 147 (quoting Blum, 457 U.S. at 1004); see also
Flagg v. Yonkers Say. & Loan Ass 'n, 396 F.3d 178, 187 (2d Cir. 2005).
b. Discussion
As an initial matter, the defendant's Fifth Amendment claim fails because she has not
demonstrated state action. Boies Schiller is not an agent of the Government and has not been at
any time during the course of the Government's investigation, including when it initiated the civil
lawsuit against the defendant or took her deposition years before the Government initiated its own
investigation. The defendant offers no evidence to the contrary, and there is no reason to believe,
on this record, that the Government in any way controlled Boies Schiller when it litigated a civil
case against the defendant. As such, the Fifth Amendment does not apply.
The defendant's claim further fails because without coercion or compulsion, there is no
Fifth Amendment violation. See Minnesota v. Murphy, 465 U.S. 420, 431 (1984) (rejecting claim
that a "failure to inform [the defendant] of the Fifth Amendment privilege barred use of his
confession at trial"); United States v. Mitchell, 966 F.2d 92, 100 (2d Cir. 1992) ("Inculpatory
statements are not involuntary when they result from a desire to cooperate, or from a defendant's
ignorance of, or inattention to, his right to remain silent."); United States v. Mast, 735 F.2d 745,
750 (2d Cir. 1984) (same). The defendant implicitly argues that she only testified under oath in
the civil matter because she thought she would not be held to that oath. In other words, had she
known that she would be subject to the penalties of perjury, she would have invoked her Fifth
Amendment right. But the defendant's misguided expectation that she would face no
consequences cannot be said to coerce speech. The defendant, represented by able counsel,
voluntarily chose to waive her Fifth Amendment rights and testify under oath. And she chose to
do so in connection with civil depositions that occurred over two years before the Government
opened its investigation. The circumstances surrounding that decision come nowhere near the type
of coercion that rises to the level of a Fifth Amendment violation. See, e.g., United States v. Ash,
464 F. Supp. 3d 621, 627-30 (S.D.N.Y. 2020) (finding suppression of defendant's phone
unwarranted where defendant complied with former employer's request to return the phone
because defendant was not coerced into doing so, and rejecting defendant's argument that the
employer was required to warn her that it might produce the phone to the government, even
assuming arguendo that that employer's actions were attributable to the government).
The defendant's claim that her act of production privilege was somehow violated similarly
fails. Counsel cites Boyd v. United States, 116 U.S. 616 (1886) for the proposition that "a
compulsory production of the private books and papers . . . [also] is compelling . . . him to be a
witness against himself, within the meaning of the fifth amendment." (Det. Mot. 11 at 15) (quoting
Boyd, 116 U.S. at 634-35). In In re Grand Jury Subpoena Duces Tecum Dated Oct 29, 1992, the
Second Circuit ruled that the Fifth Amendment does not protect the contents of private papers that
are not business documents, and also noted that "[s]everal aspects of the Boyd decision did not
endure." 1 F.3d at 90 (citing Fisher v. United States, 425 U.S. 391 (1976)).
Further, the Fifth Amendment does not protect against being compelled to speak and then
speaking falsely. "[E]ven if an individual's perjured testimony is improperly procured because of
government misconduct, that testimony may still be used to prosecute that defendant for perjury."
United States v. Olivieri, 740 F. Supp. 2d 423, 425 (S.D.N.Y. 2010) (citing United States v.
Remington, 208 F.2d 567 (2d Cir. 1953); United States v. Winter, 348 F.2d 204 (2d Cir. 1965));
see also United States v. Wong, 431 U.S. 174, 180 (1977) ("[P]erjury is not a permissible way of
objecting to the Government's questions. . . . Indeed, even if the Government could, on pain of
criminal sanctions, compel an answer to its incriminating questions, a citizen is not at liberty to
answer falsely."); Bryson v. United States, 396 U.S. 64, 72, 90 (1969) (rejecting challenge to false
statement prosecution; "[I]t cannot be thought that as a general principle of our law a citizen has a
privilege to answer fraudulently a question that the Government should not have asked. . . . A
citizen may decline to answer the question, or answer it honestly, but he cannot with impunity
knowingly and willfully answer with a falsehood.").
Contrary to the defendant's argument (Def. Mot. 11 at 16), this case is distinguishable from
United States v. Oshatz, 700 F. Supp. 696 (S.D.N.Y. 1988). There, the defendant had already been
indicted at the time of his deposition in a civil case, "was reluctant to be deposed because of the
pending indictment, and he agreed only after the parties in the civil case stipulated that the
deposition would be sealed." Id. at 699-700. The court found that the subpoenas for the deposition
transcript were "unenforceable" because the "government has not argued that the protective order
was improvidently granted or that there are some extraordinary circumstances or compelling need,
in view of the holding in Martindell." 43 Id. at 701. The court found that the protective order served
the "'vital function" described in Martindell, as the defendant had already been indicted at the
time of his deposition in a civil case for almost seven months; the defendant "consistently resisted
the use of his testimony in the criminal action against him"; and the Government did not seek the
deposition "to aid it in a criminal investigation or grand jury proceeding." Id. at 700; see also
Botha v. Don King Productions, Inc., No. 97 Civ. 7587 (JGK), 1998 WL 88745 (S.D.N.Y. Feb.
27, 1998) (noting importance of policy concerns of Martindell where Government obtained an
indictment against witness "long before his deposition in the civil action" and where federal
criminal case remains pending after civil action is resolved). Here, by contrast, Chief Judge
McMahon found that the "Government has persuasively demonstrated extraordinary
circumstances, which would entitle it to modification in any event." (Def. Mot. 3, Ex. G at 22).
As she noted in her opinion, the situation was distinct from Oshatz "where the Government was
trolling for evidence to use at a trial, rather than seeking information as part of a criminal
investigation or grand jury proceeding." (Id. at 24-25). As Chief Judge McMahon already
concluded, Oshatz does not warrant a different result here.
43 In Martindell, the Second Circuit explicitly deemed it "unnecessary for us to decide the Fifth
Amendment issues raised by the parties." Martindell, 594 F.2d at 297.
The defendant argues that Martindell "authorized her to give deposition testimony under
the shield of the Protective Order without worrying whether the government could `insinuate itself'
into the case and use her own words against her." (Def. Mot. 11 at 15-16). That is not the law,
and the defendant cannot use the protective order to cloak her testimony. The Second Circuit has
recognized that because "[i]t is well-settled here and elsewhere . . . that a Rule 26(c) protective
order may be overturned or modified based on a finding of improvidence, extraordinary
circumstances or compelling need[,]" "as a practical matter it is clear that the protections afforded
by a Rule 26(c) order are not as extensive as those afforded by the fifth amendment, or by a
statutory grant of use immunity, and that a protective order therefore cannot be used to abridge a
witness' fifth amendment rights." Andover Data Servs., 876 F.2d at 1083 (emphasis in original);
see id. at 1084 ("Uncertainty about the ultimate outcome of a protective order will mean that no
deponent may always effectively rely on a protective order to secure his right against self-
incrimination.") (quoting In re Grand Jury Subpoena, 836 F.2d 1468, 1478 (4th Cir. 1988)));
Davis, 702 F.2d at 421-22 ("Absent applicable grounds for exception, such as a previously asserted
Fifth Amendment privilege, no shield protects the civil evidence [ ] from compellable production
before the grand jury which subpoenaed it").

4. The Government Did Not Violate Maxwell's Due Process Rights
The defendant also claims that the Government's conduct "cannot be squared with
elemental due process." (Def. Mot. 3 at 14 (citing U.S. Const. amend. V)). This claim is meritless.
Because there was no Government misconduct—let alone the type of outrageous Government
misconduct that would justify the extraordinary remedy the defendant seeks —the motion must be
denied.

a. Applicable Law
The Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment provides that "[n]o person . . . shall be
deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law . ." The Due Process Clause
"protects individuals against two types of government action." Martinez v. McAleenan, 385 F.
Supp. 3d 349, 356 (S.D.N.Y. 2019). Procedural due process "ensures that government cannot
unfairly and without meaningful process deprive a person of life, liberty, or property," while
substantive due process "prevents the government from engaging in conduct that shocks the
conscience, or interferes with rights implicit in the concept of ordered liberty." Id. (internal
quotation marks and citations omitted; alteration omitted).
Procedural due process analysis focuses on whether government action depriving a person
of life, liberty, or property. . . [is] implemented in a fair manner," United States v. Salerno, 481
U.S. 739, 746 (1987). "Courts examine procedural due process questions in two steps: the first
asks whether there exists a liberty or property interest which has been interfered with by the
[Government]; the second examines whether the procedures attendant upon that deprivation were
constitutionally sufficient." United States v. Arzberger, 592 F. Supp. 2d 590, 599 (S.D.N.Y. 2008)
(internal quotation marks and citations omitted).
As to substantive due process, the Supreme Court is "always . . . reluctant to expand the
concept of substantive due process because guideposts for responsible decisionmaking in this
unchartered area are scarce and open-ended." Washington v. Glucksberg, 521 U.S. 702, 720
(1997) (internal quotation marks and citation omitted). Because of this reluctance, the Supreme
Court held in Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (1989), "that where a particular Amendment
provides an explicit textual source of constitutional protection against a particular sort of
government behavior, that Amendment, not the more generalized notion of substantive due
process, must be the guide for analyzing these claims." County of Sacramento v. Lewis, 523 U.S.
833, 842 (1998) (internal quotation marks omitted); Albright v. Oliver, 510 U.S. 266, 272 (1993)
("[t]he protections of substantive due process have for the most part been accorded to matters
relating to marriage, family, procreation, and the right to bodily integrity.").
The defendant bears the "'very heavy' burden of establishing a due process violation."
United States v. Walters, 910 F.3d 11, 27 (2d Cir. 2018). "To succeed on a claim that the
government's conduct in pursuit of evidence violates a defendant's Fifth Amendment due process
rights, the government's method of acquiring the evidence must be so egregious that it 'shocks the
conscience.'" United States v. Loera, 333 F. Supp. 3d 172, 184 (E.D.N.Y. 2018) (internal
quotation marks and citations omitted). "The concept of fairness embodied in the Fifth
Amendment due process guarantee is violated by government action that is fundamentally unfair
or shocking to our traditional sense of justice, or conduct that is `so outrageous' that common
notions of fairness and decency would be offended were judicial processes invoked to obtain a
conviction against the accused." United States v. Schmidt, 105 F.3d 82, 91 (2d Cir. 1997) (internal
quotation marks and citations omitted). "Such outrageous or conscience shocking behavior
involves egregious invasions of individual rights, or coercion." United States v. Coke, No. 07 Cr.
971 (RPP), 2011 WL 3738969, at *5 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 22, 2011) (internal quotation marks and
citations omitted). The Second Circuit has explained:
The paradigm examples of conscience-shocking conduct are
egregious invasions of individual rights. See, e.g., Rochin, 342 U.S.
at 172, 72 S. Ct. 205 (breaking into suspect's bedroom, forcibly
attempting to pull capsules from his throat, and pumping his
stomach without his consent). Especially in view of the courts'
well-established deference to the Government's choice of
investigatory methods, see United States v. Myers, 692 F.2d 823,
843 (2d Cir. 1982), the burden of establishing outrageous
investigatory conduct is very heavy, see United States v. Schmidt,
105 F.3d 82, 91 (2d Cir. 1997).
United States v. Rahman, 189 F.3d 88, 131 (2d Cir. 1999); United States v. Al Kassar, 660 F.3d
108, 121 (2d Cir. 2011) ("Generally, to be `outrageous,' the government's involvement in a crime
must involve either coercion or a violation of the defendant's person. It does not suffice to show
that the government created the opportunity for the offense, even if the government's ploy is
elaborate and the engagement with the defendant is extensive." (internal citations omitted)). The
Second Circuit has "yet to identify a particular set of circumstances in which government
investigative conduct was so egregious that it shocked the conscience and violated fundamental
guarantees of due process." United States v. Heyward, No. 10 Cr. 84 (LTS), 2010 WL 4484642,
at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 9, 2010); see also United States v. Cromitie, 727 F.3d 194, 218 (2d Cir.
2019).
There also "must be a causal connection between the violation and the deprivation of the
defendant's life or liberty threatened by the prosecution." United States v. Ghailani, 751 F. Supp.
2d 502, 505 (S.D.N.Y. 2010). "That is to say, relief against the government in a criminal case is
appropriate if, and only if, a conviction otherwise would be a product of the government
misconduct that violated the Due Process Clause." Id.
Even where Government misconduct meets the outrageousness test, dismissal of an
indictment is warranted only where the Government's behavior "resulted in [] prejudice to the
[defendant's] defense or legal representation." United States v. DiGregorio, 795 F. Supp. 630,
635 (S.D.N.Y. 1992). Absent a showing of prejudice, the appropriate remedy for conduct violating
the test for outrageousness is suppression of the evidence obtained as the result of the
Government's outrageous misconduct. Id.
b. Discussion
The defendant argues that the Due Process Clause requires the suppression of the evidence
the Government obtained pursuant to subpoena, including the April and July 2016 depositions,
and the dismissal of Counts Five and Six. The defendant falls far short of carrying the very heavy
burden of establishing a due process violation to warrant the extraordinary relief she seeks. The
Government's conduct did not, by any reasonable definition, "shock the conscience."
The defendant has not identified explicitly the component of her due process rights that the
Government allegedly violated. As she does not seem to allege that the Government deprived her
of life, liberty, or property in an unfair manner (nor could she), it seems that the defendant is
claiming that the Government's supposed misrepresentation of facts to the Court violated her
substantive due process rights. As set forth above, the Government did not mislead Chief Judge
McMahon in connection with its ex pane application. The Government did not violate the law,
much less participate in any violation that so "shocks the conscience" as to require suppression as
a matter of substantive due process.
The defendant has neither specified what "fundamental right" the Government allegedly
violated nor provided legal authority supporting her claim. She cites United States v. Valentine,
820 F.2d 565, 570 (2d Cir. 1987), seemingly to argue that her right to a fair trial has been implicated
because of the same alleged prosecutorial misconduct in connection with the modification of the
protective order described above. However, the defendant cites no authority for the proposition
that such misconduct (assuming, of course, it occurred, which it did not) would warrant the relief
she now seeks, and the primary case she relies upon is readily distinguishable. In Valentine, the
defendant was convicted of perjury based upon grand jury testimony in which he denied that he
was given a loan to make a political contribution. 820 F.2d at 570. The Second Circuit reversed
and held that it was a due process violation for the prosecutor to suggest that certain witnesses,
who had not testified at trial but who had testified before the grand jury, supported the
Government's theory of the case, when in fact their testimony before the grand jury did not. Id.
The Second Circuit stated that this action "violated the due process prohibition against a
prosecutor's making `knowing use of false evidence,' including by misrepresenting the nature of
nontestimonial evidence." Id. at 570-71 (quoting Miller v. Pate, 386 U.S. 1, 6-7 (1967)). The
Second Circuit further noted that reversal of a criminal conviction is a "drastic remedy that courts
are generally reluctant to implement," and that the court would only do so "when a prosecutor's
tactics cause substantial prejudice to the defendant and thereby serve to deprive him of his right to
a fair trial." Id.
The instant case is easily distinguishable from Valentine, as it does not involve any of the
same facts, including any alleged mischaracterization of grand jury testimony at trial or any
prosecutor making "knowing use of false evidence." Id. at 570-71; see also Mills v. Scully, 826
F.2d 1192, 1195 (2d Cir. 1987) (citing Valentine for the proposition that "[e]ven where defense
counsel is aware of the falsity, there may be a deprivation of due process if the prosecutor
reinforces the deception by capitalizing on it in closing argument, or by posing misleading
questions to the witnesses" (citations omitted)). "Prosecutorial misconduct denies a defendant due
process only when it is `of sufficient significance to result in the denial of the defendant's right to
a fair trial!" Blissett v. Lefevre, 924 F.2d 434, 440 (2d Cir. 1991) (quoting Greer v. Miller, 483
U.S. 756, 765 (1987)).
The defendant has otherwise failed to identify how she has been deprived of the right to a
fair trial. A jury will hear testimony about the defendant's statements during her April and July
2016 depositions, along with other evidence, and determine if her statements were perjurious.
"While the Constitution guarantees a fair trial through the Due Process Clauses . . it defines the
basic elements of a fair trial largely through the several provisions of the Sixth Amendment."
Cap/in & Drysdale, Chartered v. United States, 491 U.S. 617,633 (1989) (citations omitted). "The
right of an accused in a criminal trial to due process is, in essence, the right to a fair opportunity
to defend against the State's accusations. The rights to confront and cross-examine witnesses and
to call witnesses in one's own behalf have long been recognized as essential to due process."
Chambers v. Mississippi, 410 U.S. 284,294 (1973). And as noted, the defendant cites no legal
authority supporting the proposition that the Government's actions during its investigation have
somehow deprived her of a fair trial or otherwise violated her due process rights. In short, none
of Maxwell's allegations of misconduct rises to the level of a due process violation.
Dismissal of Counts Five and Six of the Indictment would be all the more unwarranted
here, where there was no outrageous Government misconduct and where the defendant cannot
show that the Government's behavior prejudiced her defense or legal representation. Similarly,
because there was no misconduct by the Government, there is no basis to suppress the evidence
obtained pursuant to the subpoena. The defendant's motion—unsupported by the law and the
facts-must be denied.

5. The Court Should Not Exercise Its Inherent Authority to Order
Suppression
The defendant urges the Court to exercise its inherent authority to order suppression. This
Court should decline the defendant's invitation to exercise this sparingly used power.

a. Applicable Law
"[T]he Supreme Court has recognized three purposes for the supervisory powers, `to
implement a remedy for violation of recognized rights, to preserve judicial integrity by ensuring
that a conviction rests on appropriate considerations validly before a jury, and finally, as a remedy
designed to deter illegal conduct.' Coke, 2011 WL 3738969, at '6 (quoting United States v.
Hastings, 461 U.S. 499, 505 (1983)). "However, while there are times when a district court may
properly find it absolutely necessary[, in order] to preserve the integrity of the criminal justice
system, to suppress evidence under its inherent or supervisory authority, 'the Supreme Court has
explained that a court's inherent power to refuse to receive material evidence is a power that must
be sparingly exercised [only in cases of] manifestly improper conduct by federal officials." United
States v. Lambus, 897 F.3d 368, 401 (2d Cir. 2018) (alterations and emphasis in original) (internal
quotations and citations omitted). The Second Circuit has "'recognized that courts cannot fashion
their own sub-constitutional limitations on the conduct of law enforcement agents." Id. (quoting
United States v. Ming He, 94 F.3d 782, 792 (2d Cir. 1996)); see also United States v. Myers, 692
F.2d 823, 847 (2d Cir. 1982). "Accordingly, the court should not exercise its inherent or
supervisory power `as a substitute for Fourth Amendment jurisprudence, which adequately
safeguards against unlawful searches and seizures.' Lambus, 897 F.3d at 401 (quoting Ming He,
94 F.3d at 792); see also United States v. Payner, 447 U.S. 727, 737 (1980) ("the supervisory
power does not extend so far" as to "confer on the judiciary discretionary power to disregard the
considered limitations of the law it is charged with enforcing").
b. Discussion
By asking the Court to exercise its inherent authority, the defendant apparently means to
suggest that the Court should grant the relief she seeks, even if she has failed to establish a violation
of the Constitution or other governing law. The defendant fails to provide justification for the
extraordinary remedy of suppression or to cite persuasive case law in favor of such an
extraordinary use of the Court's inherent authority.
The law is clear that a district court's supervisory authority does not extend to suppressing
evidence absent some violation of the Constitution or other governing law. See Payner, 447 U.S.
at 737 (holding that "the supervisory power does not extend" to "disregard[ing] the considered
limitations of the law it is charged with enforcing"); United States v. Anderson, 772 F.3d 969, 976
(2d Cir. 2014) (same); United States v. Jennings, 960 F.2d 1488, 1491 (9th Cir. 1992) ("Absent a
violation of a recognized right under the Constitution, a statute, or a procedural rule, a district court
is not entitled to exclude evidence as a sanction against government practices disapproved of by
the court."). The requirements established by the Supreme Court and the Second Circuit for
suppressing evidence would have little effect if district courts were free to disregard them and
suppress evidence by invoking their supervisory authority. Consistent with that principle, and
given that this power is "sparingly exercised," Lambus, 897 F.3d at 401, (emphasis in original),
this Court should not elect to do so here where the defendant has not established a violation of her
Fourth Amendment, Fifth Amendment, or due process rights. See, e.g., id. at 401-02 ("We can
appreciate the district court's frustration at careless government representations that may impact
the integrity of judicial decisions, especially proffers in support of ex parte applications that an
adversary has no opportunity to dispute[,]" but finding that the district court erred in suppressing
evidence by invoking its inherent authority); Coke, 2011 WL 3738969, at *6 (declining to exercise
its supervisory powers to suppress wiretap evidence and finding defendant "has no Fourth
Amendment right, and the novel substantive due process right he asks this Court to create cannot
be described as a recognized right." (internal citations omitted)).

6. The Defendant Is Not Entitled to a Hearing
The defendant argues that if the Court is "disinclined" to grant the extraordinary relief of
suppression she seeks, she is entitled to an evidentiary hearing to probe the Government's
"misstatements" to Chief Judge McMahon and the extent of coordination between the USAO-
SDNY and Boies Schiller prior to the issuance of the subpoena. (Def. Mot. 3 at 16). With respect
to that alleged "misconduct," the defendant appears to makes two general accusations: first, that
in 2016 Boies Schiller encouraged the USAO-SDNY to investigate the defendant for perjury, and
second, that the Government's statement to Chief Judge McMahon as to whether she was facing a
"Chemical Bank kind of situation" was false. Neither is correct, for the reasons described above.
Because the defendant has proffered no reliable evidence to support any of the accusations
contained in her motion papers, and because the Government has responded to those accusations
with AUSA-1's contemporaneous notes of the February 29, 2016 meeting and notes from an
interview of AUSA-1 conducted by the USAO-SDNY and the FBI (see Exs. 4 & 5), as well as
relevant AUSA-1 emails (Exs. 6 & 7), such a hearing is not warranted.

a. Applicable Law
"[E]videntiary hearings should not be set as a matter of course, but only when the petition
alleges facts which if proved would require the grant of relief." Grant v. United States, 282 F.2d
165, 170 (2d Cir. 1960). "In order to make the requisite showing in sufficient detail, the defendant
must submit an affidavit by someone with personal knowledge that disputed facts exist." United
States v. Noble, No. 07 Cr. 284 (RJS), 2008 WL 140966, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 11, 2008). "In the
absence of such an affidavit, or when the allegations contained in such an affidavit are general and
conclusory, an evidentiary hearing is unnecessary." United States v. Dewar, 489 F. Supp. 2d 351,
359 (S.D.N.Y. 2007). A district court may decide the motion without a hearing if the moving
papers do not create a genuine issue as to any material fact. United States v. Carving, 968 F.2d
232, 236 (2d Cir. 1992), abrogated on other grounds by Ratzlaf v. United States, 510 U.S. 135
(1994. Moreover, it is well settled that a material issue of fact sufficient to justify an evidentiary
hearing requires "an affidavit of someone with personal knowledge of the underlying facts."
United States v. Shaw, 260 F. Supp. 2d 567, 570 (E.D.N.Y. 2003); see also United States v. Gillette,
383 F.2d 843, 848 (2d Cir. 1967); United States v. Ahmad, 992 F. Supp. 682, 685 (S.D.N.Y. 1998)
("ordinarily [a factual issue must be] raised by an affidavit of a person with personal knowledge
of the facts;" otherwise "there is no basis for holding an evidentiary hearing or suppressing the
evidence").
The defendant's allegations are analogous to those raised when evaluating defendants'
claims of Government Franks violations. To obtain a Franks hearing, a defendant must make a
"substantial preliminary showing," United States v. Falso, 544 F.3d 110, 125 (2d Cir. 2008)
(quoting Franks v. Delaware, 438 U.S. 154, 155-56 (1978)), that (i) there were "inaccuracies or
omissions" in the affidavit, (ii) "the alleged falsehoods or omissions were necessary to the issuing
judge's probable cause or necessity finding," and (iii) "the claimed inaccuracies or omissions
[were] the result of the affiant's deliberate falsehood or reckless disregard for the truth." Lambus,
897 F.3d at 397; see also United States v. Awadallah, 349 F.3d 42, 64 (2d Cir. 2003). Even if a
defendant clears the first Franks hurdle with a substantial preliminary showing of a false statement
or omission, the defendant is not entitled to a Franks hearing unless a reviewing court makes the
legal determination that the false statement or omission was "necessary to the [issuing] judge's
probable cause finding." United States v. Canfield, 212 F.3d 713, 718 (2d Cir. 2000).
To determine whether alleged errors and omissions are material, a court should revise the
affidavit (adding alleged omissions and correcting alleged errors), and determine whether the
revised affidavit supports a finding of probable cause. See, e.g., Canfield, 212 F.3d at 719. If the
revised affidavit supports a probable cause finding, then "the inaccuracies were not material to the
probable cause determination and suppression is inappropriate." Id. at 718. After adding the
alleged omissions and correcting the alleged errors, the "ultimate inquiry" is whether "there
remains a residue of independent and lawful information sufficient to support probable cause."
United States v. Martin, 426 F.3d 68, 74 (2d Cir. 2005) (internal quotation marks and citations
omitted).
"[E]ven if the misrepresented or omitted information was material, a motion to suppress is
to be denied unless the misrepresentations or omissions were intentional or deliberate, or were
made in reckless disregard for the truth." Lambus, 897 F.3d at 399. The standard to demonstrate
material false statements and omissions in an agent's affidavit is a "high one." Rivera v. United
States, 928 F.2d 592, 604 (2d Cir. 1991). The intent prong of Franks is particularly demanding
with respect to omissions. "Franks protects against omissions that are designed to mislead, or that
are made in reckless disregard of whether they would mislead." Awadallah, 349 F.3d at 68
(emphasis in original). After all, "la]ll storytelling involves an element of selectivity,' and it is
therefore not necessarily constitutionally significant that an affidavit `omit[s] facts which, in
retrospect, seem significant.'" United States v. Lahey, 967 F. Supp. 2d 698, 708 (S.D.N.Y. 2013)
(quoting United States v. Vilar, No. 05 Cr. 621 (KMK), 2007 WL 1075041, at *27 (S.D.N.Y. Apr.
4, 2007)); see also United States v. DeFilippo, No. 17 Cr. 585 (WHP), 2018 WL 740727, at *2
(S.D.N.Y. Jan. 31, 2018) ("As courts in this Circuit have recognized, it is not shocking that every
affidavit will omit facts which, in retrospect, seem significant." (internal quotation marks and
citations omitted)).
The "substantial preliminary showing" requirement explained above exists to "avoid
fishing expeditions into affidavits that are otherwise presumed truthful." Falso, 544 F.3d at 125.
"[C]onclusory allegations cannot support a Franks challenge as a matter of law." United States v.
Pizarro, No. 17 Cr. 151 (AJN), 2018 WL 1737236, at *10 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 10, 2018); see also
Franks, 438 U.S. at 171 ("To mandate an evidentiary hearing, the challenger's attack must be more
than conclusory and must be supported by more than a mere desire to cross-examine."). Instead,
to warrant a Franks hearing:
[t]here must be allegations of deliberate falsehood or of reckless
disregard for the truth, and those allegations must be accompanied
by an offer of proof . . . Affidavits or sworn or otherwise reliable
statements of witnesses should be furnished, or their absence
satisfactorily explained. Allegations of negligence or innocent
mistake are insufficient. The deliberate falsity or reckless disregard
whose impeachment is permitted today is only that of the affiant,
not of any nongovernmental informant.
Id.
The burden to even obtain a Franks hearing is a heavy one, and such hearings are thus
exceedingly rare. See United States v. Brown, 744 F. Supp. 558, 567 (S.D.N.Y. 1990) ("A
defendant seeking to have the Court hold a Franks hearing bears a substantial burden."); United
States v. Swanson, 210 F.3d 788, 790 (7th Cir. 2000) ("These elements are hard to prove, and thus
Franks hearings are rarely held.").
b. Discussion
In an alternative effort to suppress the materials obtained pursuant to the subpoena, the
defendant argues that an evidentiary hearing is warranted to inquire into the Government's
"misrepresentations" to Chief Judge McMahon. (Def. Mot. 3 at 16). However, as discussed
extensively above, Maxwell's motion is little more than speculation and innuendo, itself rooted in
a lone news article that, as described above, is not fully accurate. She otherwise presents no
admissible evidence, affidavits, or other materials supporting the breathless accusations contained
in her motion papers. As such, because the defendant does not include "an affidavit of someone
with personal knowledge of the underlying facts," Shaw, 260 F. Supp. 2d at 570, and because the
Government has responded with reliable information directly rebutting the defendant's allegations,
there is no material issue of fact sufficient to justify an evidentiary hearing.4*
The defendant cites Franks, to suggest that a hearing is somehow warranted, but her motion
falls far short of the standard required to obtain a hearing. "While the Franks analysis discussed
above is typically employed to evaluate misstatements and omissions relating to probable cause,
the Second Circuit has extended the Franks analysis to other Title III requirements for obtaining a
warrant." United States v. Rajaratnam, No. 09 Cr. 1184 (RJH), 2010 WL 4867402, at *18
(S.D.N.Y. Nov. 24, 2010). The defendant fails to identify the standard that would govern such a
hearing. In light of the interests implicated by a Title III wiretap, the USAO-SDNY submits that
the defendant's depositions in a civil matter, even with a protective order, are no more significant
than the interests implicated by a Title III wiretap. As such, the exacting standard of Franks should
apply. On this record, the defendant has not made a threshold showing that the Government acted
with the intent to mislead or in reckless disregard for the truth. The Franks standard is rightly a
"high one," Rivera, 928 F.2d at 604, and one the defendant has failed to meet here.
The defendant's bald assertions alone do not entitle her to a fishing expedition in the form
of a hearing.

V. The Jury Should Decide Whether the Defendant Committed Perjury
Counts Five and Six of the Indictment allege that, during the course of two depositions, the
defendant knowingly made false material declarations, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1623. The
defendant moves to dismiss those Counts, arguing that the Court can determine now—on a pre-
44 For similar reasons, the defendant's request for discovery regarding this matter should be denied.
The defendant has failed to meet her burden under Rule 16 of making "a prima fade showing of
materiality and must offer more than the conclusory allegation that the requested evidence is
material." Urena, 989 F. Supp. 2d at 261 (citations omitted). Because the defendant has offered
nothing more than her conjecture, based on an inaccurate and hearsay-ridden article, that some
unspecified evidence might exist, her request for discovery should be denied.
trial record—that the questions were fundamentally ambiguous, and the defendant's answers were
truthful and immaterial. (Def. Mot. 5). To the contrary, the Government expects to prove at trial
that the defendant understood the questions and that her answers were both false and materially

so. This case does not present the narrow circumstances in which a court can and should dismiss
perjury counts, let alone do so before trial.

A. Factual Background
On July 7, 2008, following the USAO-SDFL entering into the non-prosecution agreement
with Epstein, two minors filed a petition under the Crime Victims' Rights Act (CVRA), 18 U.S.C.
§ 3771, alleging that the prosecutors violated their rights under that statute. See Doe v. United
States, 08 Civ. 80736 (S.D.F.L). See generally Doe No. 1. v. United States, 749 F.3d 999, 1002
(11th Cir. 2014) (describing the background of the suit). On December 30, 2014, Virginia Roberts
Giuffre moved to join the petition, alleging that the USAO-SDFL had also violated her CVRA
rights. See Doe, No. 08 Civ. 80736, Dkt. No. 279.45 In her motion for joinder, Giuffre described
the defendant as "'one of the main women' Epstein used to `procure under-aged girls for sexual
activities,"' and as a "'primary co-conspirator' with Epstein in his scheme. See Giuffre v. Maxwell,

No. 18-2868 (2d Cir. 2019), Dkt. No. 287 at 10 (containing the unsealed summary judgment
opinion from 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP)). Among other allegations, Giuffre alleged that the defendant
"'persuaded' [her] to go to Epstein's mansion," and, "when Giuffre began giving Epstein a
massage, [he] and [the defendant] 'turned it into a sexual encounter.'" Id. at 11. Giuffre alleged
that the defendant also "`participat[ed] in the sexual abuse" of others. Id. A few days later, the
press reported a statement by a spokesman for the defendant, Ross Gow. Among other things,
45 Giuffre filed a corrected motion on January 2, 2015. See Doe, No. 08 Civ. 80736, Dkt. No. 280.
The court later struck the original motion, sealed the corrected motion, and ordered filing of a
redacted version of the corrected motion. See id., Dkt. No. 325 (Apr. 7, 2015).
Gow stated that Giuffre's claims were "untrue" and "obvious lies." (15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt.
No. 1 at 6).
As described in the preceding section, in the fall of 2015, Giuffre sued the defendant for
defamation." (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1). Giuffre alleged that Epstein sexually abused
her, "with the assistance and participation of Maxwell" at "numerous locations" between 1999 and
2002, and that Epstein abused more than thirty minors between 2001 and 2007 "with the assistance
of numerous co-conspirators." (Id. at 3).
During the defendant's first deposition on April 22, 2016, the defendant refused to answer
questions that she deemed related to consensual adult sexual interactions. (See, e.g., Ex. 10 at
92:20-93:6). Giuffre moved to compel the defendant to answer, explaining that "[a]t the core of
[her] allegations is the allegation that [the] Defendant lured her into a sexual situation with the
offer of a job making money as a massage therapist; that Epstein always habitually tried to turn
massages into sex . . . and that Maxwell recruited other females for an ostensibly proper position,
such as therapeutic masseuse, with knowledge that the intent was for that person would be
pressured to provide sexual gratification to Epstein." (15 Civ. 7443 (LAP), Dkt. No. 1137-1 at 5-
6). Giuffre also explained that the defendant's refusal to answer questions about adult consensual
sex prevented Giuffre "from seeking legitimate discovery," such as the identity of people the
defendant presently deemed adults. (id. at 6).
The Court granted Giuffre's motion. "[N]otwithstanding" the intrusiveness of the
questions and the fact that the defendant had not put her private affairs at issue, "the questions are
directed to reveal relevant answers regarding Defendant's knowledge of Plaintiff's allegations."
" The below discussion is provided as context for the Court's consideration of the motion. As
discussed further in the Government's opposition to the defendant's motion for severance, the
Government expects to provide a more streamlined presentation regarding the Giuffre suit at trial.
(Def. Mot. 4, Ex. H at 9). "That knowledge," the Court explained, "goes directly to the truth or
falsity of the alleged defamation, a key element of Plaintiff's claim." (Id.). The Court therefore
ordered the defendant to answer the questions related to her sexual activity with or involving (1)
Epstein, (2) Giuffre, (3) underage girls known to Epstein or who she thought might become known
to Epstein, or (4) involving massage with individuals the defendant "knew to be, or believed might
be, known to Epstein." (Id. at 10). The Court further ordered the defendant to answer questions
about her knowledge of the sexual activities of others in the same four categories. The Court added
that the "scope of Defendant's answers are not bound by time period, though Defendant need not
answer questions that relate to none of these subjects or that is clearly not relevant." (Id.). The
defendant sat for a second deposition on July 22, 2016, before the case settled.
As discussed more fully below, the Indictment charges the defendant with two counts of
perjury, one arising from statements made during the April 2016 deposition and one arising from
statements made during the July 2016 deposition. Indictment ¶y 21, 23. (Ex. 10 at 253:25-254:8,
384:15-20; Ex. 11 at 88:9-89:13, 91:22-92:16, 113:2-12). The defendant now moves to dismiss
both counts, arguing that the Court can effectively decide now, as a matter of law, that the questions
were fundamentally ambiguous, her answers were true, and her answers were immaterial to the
case.
B. Applicable Law

Section 1623(a) imposes criminal penalties on anyone who "in any proceeding before or
ancillary to any court ... knowingly makes any false material declaration." 18 U.S.C. § 1623(a).
In perjury prosecutions, "whether the witness believes that an answer is true or false generally
turns on the declarant's understanding of the question." United States v. Lighte, 782 F.2d 367, 372
(2d Cir. 1986). Accordingly, and as is true of virtually all factual issues, "[a] jury is best equipped
to determine the meaning that a defendant assigns to a specific question." Id.; see, e.g. United
States v. Sampson, 898 F.3d 287, 307 (2d Cir. 2018).47
A narrow exception arises when language in a question is so "fundamentally ambiguous"
that a Court can conclude, as a matter of law, that a perjury count cannot stand. Lighte, 782 F.2d
at 375. A question is "fundamentally ambiguous" when "it is not a phrase with a meaning about
which [people] of ordinary intellect could agree, nor one which could be used with mutual
understanding by a questioner and answerer unless it were defined at the time it were sought and
offered as testimony." Id. at 375 (internal quotation marks omitted). In such a case, the "answers
associated with the questions posed may be insufficient as a matter of law to support the perjury
conviction." United States v. Markiewicz, 978 F.2d 786, 808 (2d Cir. 1992) (quoting Lighte, 782
F.2d at 375). For instance, in Lighte, a case involving post-conviction appellate review, the Court
found that a question was fundamentally ambiguous because it used the word "'you' without
indication that, unlike the prior two questions, the appellant was now being questioned in his role
as trustee." 782 F.2d at 376. "[F]undamental ambiguity," however, "is the exception, not the
rule." United States v. Sarwari, 669 F.3d 401, 407 (4th Cir. 2012) (quoting United States v.
Fanner, 137 F.3d 1265, 1269 (10th Cir. 1998)). A defendant cannot demonstrate fundamental
ambiguity simply by showing that words used in a question are amenable to multiple meanings,
or that an answer "might generate a number of different interpretations." Lighte, 782 F.2d at 375;
United States v. Strohm, 671 F.3d 1173, 1178 (10th Cir. 2011) ("Simply plumbing a question for
post hoc ambiguity will not defeat a perjury conviction where the evidence demonstrates the
defendant understood the question in context and gave a knowingly false answer."). "If, in the
47 The Second Circuit analyzes general principles of perjury similarly under 18 U.S.C. § 1623 and
another perjury statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1621, see Lighte, 782 F.3d at 372, and it has assumed without
deciding that those standards also apply to offenses under 18 U.S.C. § 1001(a)(2), see United States
v. Sampson, 898 F.3d 287, 307 n.15 (2d Cir. 2018).
natural meaning in the context in which words were used they were materially untrue, perjury was
established." United States v. Bonacorsa, 528 F.2d 1218, 1221 (2d Cir. 1976). Critically, and as
noted with respect to Lighte above, courts generally evaluate whether a challenge to a perjury
count on the basis that a question was fundamentally ambiguous after trial and following the
development of a full factual record. See, e.g., Strohm, 671 at 1175 (appeal following conviction);
SanvaH, 669 F.3d at 406 (same); Farmer, 137 F.3d at 1269 (appeal following conviction and
partial Rule 29 dismissal) Marldewicz, 978 F.2d at 808 (appeal following conviction); cf. United
States v. Forde, 740 F. Supp. 2d 406, 413 (S.D.N.Y. 2010) (denying a motion to dismiss a perjury
count). Indeed, the defendant cites no case in which a court has dismissed a perjury count on the
basis of "fundamental ambiguity" before trial.
Because perjury requires a knowing false statement, the law does not permit conviction
based on answers that are literally true. See Lighte, 782 F.2d at 374. Nor can a conviction rest on
answers that are literally true but unresponsive, and therefore "arguably misleading by negative
implication." Id.; see Bronston v. United States, 409 U.S. 352, 362 (1973). But when "the answer
is false, the fact that it is unresponsive is immaterial." United States v. Corr, 543 F.2d 1042, 1049
(2d Cir. 1976). Even statements that "could be literally true in isolation" can support a perjury
conviction if they are "materially untrue" in "the context in which the statements were made."
United States v. Schaftick, 871 F.2d 300, 304 (2d Cir. 1989). "[U]nless the questioning is
fundamentally ambiguous or imprecise, the truthfulness of [the defendant's] answers is an issue
for the jury." Id. at 304; see United States v. Kaplan, 758 F. App'x 34, 39 (2d Cir. 2018) (same);

cf. Lighte, 782 F.2d at 374 (finding the evidence insufficient where some answers "were literally
true under any conceivable interpretation of the questions").
Finally, even if a defendant makes a knowing false statement, a perjury conviction requires
that the statement be material. A false statement is material if it has "a natural tendency to
influence, or [be] capable of influencing, the decision of the decisionmaking body to which it was
addressed." United States v. Gaudin, 515 U.S. 506, 509 (1995) (alteration in original) (quotation
marks omitted). A statement made in a civil deposition is also material if "a truthful answer might
reasonably be calculated to lead to the discovery of evidence admissible at the trial of the
underlying suit." United States v. Kross, 14 F.3d 751, 754 (2d Cir. 1994)); see United States v.
Birrell, 470 F.2d 113, 115 n.1 (2d Cir. 1972) (explaining, in the context of a motion to proceed in
forma pauperis and for appointment of counsel, that "it must be shown that a truthful answer would
have been of sufficient probative importance to the inquiry so that, as a minimum, further fruitful
investigation would have occurred." (citation and internal quotation marks omitted)). "The
testimony need not have actually influenced, misled, or impeded the proceeding." United States

v. Chan Lo, No. 14 Cr. 491 (VSB), 2016 WL 9076234, at ■8 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 4, 2016), aff'd 679 F.
App'x 79 (2d Cir. 2017); see Forde, 740 F. Supp. 2d at 412. Since materiality is an element of the
offense, it is a question for the jury "except in the most extraordinary circumstances." Forde, 740

F. Supp. 2d at 412 (citing Gaudin, 515 U.S. at 522-23).
C. Discussion
The Government expects to prove at trial that the defendant's deposition statements were
knowingly false. The defendant's strained efforts to inject ambiguity into the questioning and to
justify her answers as truthful are in significant part, arguments that are properly put to the jury
and not a basis to dismiss the counts pretrial and without the benefit of a complete record. See
United States v. Triumph Capital Group, Inc., 237 F. App'x 625, 627-28 (2d Cir. 2007)
("Generally, the meaning and truthfulness of a defendant's statement is a question of fact for the
jury."). At this stage, the defendant must identify defects so fundamental that the charged
statements cannot, as a matter of law, support a perjury conviction. She has failed to do so, and
her motion should be denied.

1. April 2016 Deposition
At the April 2016 deposition, Giuffre's counsel asked the defendant about how Giuffre
came to Epstein's home (Ex. 10 at 14:9-17:4), whether hired massage therapists engaged in sexual
activity with Epstein (id. at 51:13-55:16), and the defendant's knowledge of Epstein's Florida
criminal case (id. at 171:25-173:12, 183:25-186:21), among other topics. The transcript makes
clear that when the defendant did not understand a question, she said so. (See, e.g., id. at 9:4-9
("[C]an you please clarify the question. I don't understand what you mean by female, I don't
understand what you mean by recruit."), 39:23-24 ("I don't understand what your question is
asking."), 94:18-95:4 ("You don't ask me questions like that. First of all, you are trying to trap
me, I will not be trapped."), 138:6 ("Define relationship."), 244:22-23 ("You are not asking me a
good question, sorry.").
Count Five charges the defendant with perjury arising from two colloquies at this
deposition. First, Giuffre's counsel asked the defendant a series of questions about whether the
defendant brought women to Epstein, which the defendant resisted by observing that she hired
"people across the board" to "work for Jeffrey." (Id. at 245:7-18). Giuffre's counsel asked
whether any minors worked as exercise instructors or masseuses at Epstein's home, and the
defendant testified that they were all adults except for Giuffre, who she acknowledged at least
claimed to have been seventeen. (Id. at 246:18-251:12). Giuffre's counsel then asked questions
about whether Epstein had a "sexual preference for underage minors," which drew objections from
defense counsel and which the defendant ultimately answered by saying "I cannot tell you what
Jeffrey's story is. I'm not able to." (Id. at 251:13-253:12). This colloquy followed:

Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein have a scheme to recruit underage girls to
use them for purposes of sexual massages?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Objection to the form and foundation.
A. Can you ask me again, please?
Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein have a scheme to recruit underage girls to
recruit them for sexual massages?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Objection to the form and foundation.
A. Can you ask it a different way?
Q. Did Jeffrey Epstein have a scheme to recruit underage girls for
sexual massages?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Objection to the form and foundation.
Q. If you know.
A. I don't know what you are talking about. 48
(Ex. 10 at 253:13-254:8).
The defendant argues that the question was ambiguous, as shown by her requests for the
questioner to rephrase the question. (Def. Mot. 4 at 9-10, 18). A properly instructed jury could
readily conclude otherwise in light of the evidence the Government expects to introduce at trial.
The defamation case involved allegations that Giuffre was a victim of that scheme: Giuffre had
alleged that Epstein and the defendant had sexualized a massage that Giuffre gave Epstein. The
preceding questions focused on (I) whether the defendant brought underage masseuses to work
for Epstein, and (2) whether Epstein had a sexual preference for underage girls. Moreover, at trial
and as discussed further below, the Government expects to elicit testimony from one or more of
48 Underlined sentences are charged as false statements in the Indictment.
the victims specified in the Indictment about sexualized massages the victims provided to Epstein,
conduct that obviously predated the deposition. See Indictment ¶ 7(a), (c). In context, and with an
understanding of the Government's other evidence, a rational juror could readily conclude that the
question "did Jeffrey Epstein have a scheme to recruit underage girls for sexual massages . . . [i]f
you know?" had a clear meaning, and more important for purposes of the instant motion, any
ambiguity was not "fundamental." Cl Triumph Capital Grp., Inc., 237 F. App'x at 628
(concluding that an answer about "this arrangement" was not fundamentally ambiguous).
Nor is there any basis to dismiss the count now based on the defendant's professed
confusion or denial of knowledge of the scheme's existence. A defendant may commit perjury by
falsely denying memory or knowledge of an event. See, e.g., United States v. Alberti, 568 F.2d
617, 625 (2d Cir. 1977); United States v. Weiner, 479 F.2d 923, 926, 929 (2d Cir. 1973); Forde,
740 F. Supp. 2d at 410-11. Viewing the question and answer "in the context of the line of
questioning as a whole," the defendant "consistently denied" knowledge of Epstein's scheme,
Markiewicz, 978 F.2d at 810, and a jury could conclude that the "question was not fundamentally
ambiguous—and thus that [the defendant], understanding the question, lied." See Sampson, 898
F.3d at 307; cf. Indictment ¶¶ 4(e) 11(c)-(d), 17(c)-(d) (discussing use of massage as part of the
sexual abuse scheme).
Second, later in the deposition, Giuffre's counsel asked the defendant a series of questions
in an attempt to identify other underage girls that the defendant met and brought to Epstein.
Specifically:

Q. Can you list for me all the girls that you have met and brought to
Jeffrey Epstein's house that were under the age of 18?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Objection to the form and foundation.
A. I could only recall my family members that were there and I could
not make a list of anyone else because that list -- it never happened
that I can think of.

Q. I'm talking about the time you were working for Jeffrey Epstein,
can you list all girls that you found for Jeffrey Epstein that were
under the age of 18 to come work for him in any capacity?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Objection to the form and foundation.
A. I didn't find the girls.
Q. You choose the word.
MR. PAGLIUCA: If you have a question ask it, you don't choose
the word.

Q. List all of the girls you met and brought to Jeffrey Epstein's home
for the purposes of employment that were under the age of 18?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Objection to the form and foundation.
A. I've already characterized my job was to find people, adults,
professional people to do the jobs I listed before; pool person,
secretary, house person, chef, pilot, architect.

Q. Pm asking about individuals under the age of 18, not adult
persons, people under the age of 18.
A. I looked for people or tried to find people to fill professional jobs
in professional situations.

Q. So Virginia Roberts was under the age of 18, correct?
A. I think we've established that Virginia was 17.

Q. Is she the -- sorry, go ahead. Is she the only individual that you
met for purposes of hiring someone for Jeffrey that was under the
age of 18?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Objection to form and foundation.
Mischaracterizes her testimony.
A. I didn't hire people.

Q. I said met.
A. I interviewed people for jobs for professional things and I am not
aware of anyone aside from now Virginia who clearly was a
masseuse aged 17 but that's, at least that's how far we know that I
can think of that fulfilled any professional capacity for Jeffrey.

Q. List all the people under the age of 18 that you interacted with at
any of Jeffrey's properties?
A. I'm not aware of anybody that I interacted with, other than
obviously Virginia who was 17 at this point?
(Ex. 10 at 382:4-384:20).
The defendant argues that this question was "grossly ambiguous: who was `Jeffrey'; what
were 'Jeffrey's properties;' to what time frame did the question apply; what was the basis for Ms.
Maxwell to determine who may or may not have been `under the age of 18'; and what did `interact
with' mean?" (Def. Mot. 4 at 11). These arguments only underscore the principle that perjury
prosecutions are an inquiry into "the natural meaning in the context in which words were used,"
Bonacorsa, 528 F.2d at 1221, and not an opportunity for defense counsel to "plumb[] a question
for post hoc ambiguity," Strohm, 671 F.3d at 1178. A reasonable jury, after hearing the evidence,
could readily conclude that the natural meaning of those words in context is abundantly clear. For
instance, at the end of trial, a jury could conclude that "Jeffrey" is Jeffrey Epstein; "Jeffrey's
properties" are Jeffrey Epstein's properties, including his houses in Palm Beach, New York, New
Mexico, and the United States Virgin Islands (see, e.g., Ex. 10 at 248:17-20 (naming those
properties)); and "interact" is an expansive word aimed at capturing any encounter, that was used
after the defendant resisted words like "met," "found," and "hired" in the prior questions, see
Interact, Oxford English Dictionary Online, https://oed.corniview/Entry/97518 (last visited
February 25, 2021) ("To act reciprocally, to act on each other."). Such inferences will be
particularly easy for a jury to reach after hearing multiple victims testify about their own
interactions with the defendant and Epstein at Epstein's various properties. See, e.g., Indictment
1 7(a) ("MAXWELL subsequently interacted with Minor Victim-1 on multiple occasions at
Epstein's residences."). Accordingly, a rational juror, after hearing the evidence, could find that
the question called for the names of minors that the defendant interacted with at any of Jeffrey
Epstein's properties, that the defendant answered that she was aware of no such minors other than
Giuffre, and therefore that her answer was false. And even if the defendant identifies some
plausible ambiguity —and she has not—the terms in this question are ones "with a meaning about
which [people] of ordinary intellect could agree," and therefore are not fundamentally ambiguous.
Lighte, 782 F.2d at 375 (internal quotation marks omitted).
The defendant points out that, in response to an earlier question asking her to list the
underage girls she "met and brought" to Epstein's house, she said that she could not do so. (Del.
Mot. 4 at 12-13). She argues that the charged question was "improper" because it asked her to
generate a list "from events that had happened nearly two decades previously." (Id.). Her
unpersuasive after-the-fact efforts to justify her answer provide no basis to keep this question from
the jury. As noted above, the transcript makes clear (and a jury could find) that when the defendant
did not understand or could not answer a question, she said so. To the extent the defendant is
arguing that her answer was literally true, a reasonable July could find otherwise. In this respect,
the Government notes, among other things, that in response to the earlier question, the defendant
said that she could not make a list not because she could not remember events from that long ago
but "because that list -- it never happened that I can think of." (Ex. 10 at 382:4-13) (emphasis
added). And in response to the charged question, the defendant said that she "was not aware of
anybody" under 18—that is, the list would be empty. See Forde, 740 F. Supp. 2d at 413 ("Olivieri,
if truly confused, could also have asked for clarification. Instead he replied with a strong
denial..."). A properly instructed jury could conclude after hearing all of the evidence at trial
that the defendant intended the natural meaning of the words she used, not the allegedly truthful
answer she suggests now, and therefore that she lied. In sum, the defendant's post-hoc efforts to
inject confusion into clear questioning are unavailing and should be rejected, and the jury should
decide whether the defendant's answers were false.

2. July 2016 Deposition
Count Six charges the defendant with perjury arising from three colloquies at the second
deposition.
ans thaelMr. EPalBea
at 544 Although she didiathe names of any of aomen,,
"bloand llirrwyera
tiefenari lTaWarl irt/d. Following that line of questioning, the following
colloquy occurred:

Er. When you and Mr. Epstein were engaged in sexual activity that
included these other women, were any devices or sex toys used as
part of the sexual activity?

A. No.
Q. Were you ever involved in sexual activities in Mr. Epstein's Palm
Beach house that included the use of sex toys or any kind of
mechanical or other device?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Objection to form and foundation.
A. No.
Q. Were you ever involved in sexual activities in any of Mr.
Epstein's properties other than Palm Beach that included the use of
sex toys or any kind of mechanical or other device?

Q. Were you aware of the presence of sex toys or devices used in
sexual activities in Mr. Epstein's Palm Beach house?

A. No. not that I recall.
other pi
question:
Giuffre's lawyer asked the following
Q. Do you know whether Mr. Epstein possessed sex toys or devices
used in sexual activities?
Ir -ionl n and foundation.
A. Ng,
The defendant now argues that these questions are ambiguous because they contain
"numerous undefined terms," such as "sex toy or device" and "sexual activities." (Def. Mot. 4 at
14). She asks, for instance, whether "bath oil" would count as a sex toy or device. (Id.). Yet this
argument is simply another attempt to imbue ambiguity after the fact into commonly used words
with common sense meanings. The mere fact that a term could apply equally to several different
objects does not automatically mean that the question is impermissibly vague and can never form
the basis of a perjury charge. See, e.g., H.L.A. Hart, Positivism and the Separation of Law and
Morals, 71 Harv. L. Rev. 593, 607 (1958) ("A legal rule forbids you to take a vehicle into the
public park. Plainly this forbids an automobile, but what about bicycles . ?"). Instead, it is well-
settled that "[t]he jury should determine whether the question—as the declarant must have
understood it, giving it a reasonable reading—was falsely answered." Lighte, 782 F.2d at 372. So
long as the question involves a phrase "which could be used with mutual understanding by a
questioner and answerer," it is not fundamentally ambiguous. Id. at 375 (internal quotation marks
omitted); see United States v. Jenkins, 727 F. App'x 732, 735 (2d Cir. 2018) ("An individual of
ordinary intelligence would not think that a question asking for information regarding `real estate,
stocks, bonds, ... or other valuable property' would allow omission of information regarding
money market funds ....").
The use of broad or inclusive terms does not render the question fundamentally ambiguous.
As the Second Circuit explained in the context of the term "employment activities," "[t]he broad
language of the question is not fundamentally ambiguous; it is instead designed to capture all
employment activities in an applicant's recent history." United States v. Polos, 723 F. App'x 64,
65-66 (2d Cir. 2018). So too here. A "sex toy or device" is an intelligible phrase with an
understood meaning. See Sex Toy, Oxford English Dictionary Online,
https://www.oed.com/view/Entry/176989 (last visited February 12, 2021) ("[A] device or object
designed for sexual stimulation (as a dildo, vibrator, etc.) or to enhance sexual pleasure or
performance."). To the? al ac ins a , it was de t
earlier in the depositimardniyities" to include "Kissing,
touchinpwith hands ox mouths or otaa.1.=
The defendant's objections to the next colloquy in the indictment are similarly unavailing.
Shortly after the above exchange, the following conversation occurred:
17.11 atrme tiittany circri=r itsprcWres, taialyou engage in
lexual activities with any woman other than when you had three-
'ray sexual activities with Mr. Epstein?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Object to the form.
A. Can you repeat the question?
At any time, in  Mr. Epstein's properties, did you engage
in sexual activities any woman other than when you had thrill
way sexual activities with Mr. Epstein?

MR. PAGLIUCA: Same objection.
A. No.
Q. Other than yourself and the blond and brunette that you have
identified as having been involved in three-way sexual activities,
with whom did Mr. Epstein have sexual activities?
r -Objection to form

A. I wasn't aware that he was having sexual activities with anyone
when I was with him other than myself.

Q. I want to be sure that I'm clear. Is it your testimony that in the
1990s and 2000s, you were not aware that Mr. Epstein was having
sexual activities with anyone other than yourself and the blond and
brunette on those few occasions when they were involved with you?
A. That is my testimony, that is correct.
The defendant primarily argues that her answers were literally true. In the defendant's
telling, the phrase "[w]hen I was with him," refers not to the duration of the defendant's
relationship with Epstein, but instead to only those moments when she was in the act of having sex
with Epstein and either the blond or brunette identified above. (Def. Mot. 4 at 16).
as the de gi rigimppuiggiggrEkred wh Mile"
three-perir encas inn a fourth person, the answer 631‘firfi is no, she argil
beca I activities by defi cannot involve four people. And in any event,
she further argues, because the question asked the defendant about the 1990s and 2000s, it
therefore covered any 'sexual activities' spanning more than a millennium." (Id. at 16-17).
The defendant, therefore, argues that the questioner asked whether a logically impossible
event occurred or will occur at some point over the course of a millennium. But the defendant's
professed confusion—which again was not raised during the deposition itself—ignores the plain
and obvious context of the question, which did not refer to a time period far exceeding the human
life span, and was not limited to only the times in which the defendant was in the act of having sex
with Epstein. Plainly, a jury could find that the defendant correctly understood the question when
she answered it in July 2016, and that she ascribed a natural meaning to the words used in the
questions, and not the tortured illogical meaning she now assigns to those questions: whether,
during the course of her relationship with Epstein, she was aware of anyone other than herself
having sexual relations with Epstein. The Government expects its evidence to show that she was.
See, e.g., Indictment ¶ 1 (stating that the defendant "assisted, facilitated, and contributed to"
Epstein's sexual abuse of minors). At a minimum, the defendant's answers were not "literally true
under any conceivable interpretation of the questions." Lighte, 782 F.2d at 374. And the
defendant's professed confusion now and proposed illogical reading of the questions in the instant
motion does not render them fundamentally ambiguous. See Bonacorsa, 528 F.2d at 1221 ("A
defense to a charge of perjury may not be established by isolating a statement from context, giving
it in this manner a meaning entirely different from that which it has when the testimony is
considered as a whole."). Accordingly, a jury should be permitted to determine what meaning the
defendant ascribed to those questions and whether her answers were in fact false.
Finally, the defendant answered the following questions:

Q. Did you ever give a massage to anyone other than Mr. Epstein at
any of Mr. Epstein's properties?
A. First of all, I never said I gave Mr. Epstein a massage.

Q. I will ask that question if you want, but I was focusing on people
other than Mr. Epstein right now.

A. I don't give massages.
Q. Let's just tie that down. It is your testimony that you've never
given anybody a massage?

A. I have not given anyone a massage.
Q. You never gave Mr. Epstein a massage, is that your testimony?
A. That is my testimony.

Q. You never gave [Minor Victim-2] a massage is your testimony?
A. I never gave [Minor Victim-21 a massage.

(Ex. II at 112:17-113:12).
The defendant argues that these questions were fundamentally ambiguous because the
deposition elsewhere discussed both sexual and professional massages. It was unclear, she
explains, what kind of massage the questioner meant. (Def. Mot. 4 at 17.) The defendant's
argument is, yet again, misguided. This line of questioning used broad language, and at no point
during this set of questions did Giuffre's counsel suggest that the questions were limited to sexual
or professional massages. Cf. Lighte, 782 F.2d at 376 (concluding that the word "you" was
ambiguous when the prior two questions asked about the defendant "as an individual" and then
switched "without indication" to the defendant "as trustee"). The defendant's answers were
unequivocal, with no expressions of confusion or internal contradictions. Cf. Markiewicz, 978
F.2d at 809 (explaining that a question was ambiguous as to whether it asked about the deponent's
personal or professional capacities, in light of the deponent's confusion in the next questions). A
properly instructed jury could conclude that the defendant meant what she said: she never gave
anyone a massage, including Epstein and Minor Victim-2.
The defendant is, of course, free to testify on her own behalf to her professed confusion or
otherwise argue to the jury that the questions were ambiguous or the answers truthful. The issue
before the Court is whether the questions were so fundamentally ambiguous that a jury, after
hearing the trial evidence, could not conclude that the "response given was false as the defendant
understood the question." Lighte, 782 F.2d at 375 (internal quotation marks omitted). The
defendant has failed to establish such a fundamental defect.°
3. Materiality
Finally, the defendant argues that none of these answers was material to the defamation
action. As a threshold issue, however, materiality is also not appropriate for resolution on a motion
to dismiss the indictment. As noted above, materiality is a jury question "except in the most
extraordinary circumstances." Forde, 740 F.Supp.2d at 412 (citing Gaudin, 515 U.S. at 522-23).
As the Supreme Court explained in Johnson v. United States, 520 U.S. 461 (1997), "there is no
doubt that materiality is an element of perjury under § 1623," and its precedent "therefore dictates
that materiality be decided by the jury, not the court." Id. at 465.
The Second Circuit has explained that it is inappropriate for courts to resolve questions
relating to the sufficiency of the evidence on a motion to dismiss the indictment. The Federal
Rules of Criminal Procedure contain no "analogue for summary judgment under Federal Rule of
Civil Procedure 56" for several reasons. United States v. Sampson, 898 F.3d 270, 280 (2d Cir.
2018). First, "[p]ermitting civil `summary judgment' -like motions . . . would enable an end-run
around the calibrated framework for discovery in criminal cases," and thereby "upset the policy
49 Even if the Court concludes that any of the individual statements charged in the Indictment
cannot sustain a perjury conviction, the count survives so long as some statement can properly be
presented to the jury. See Bonacorsa, 528 F.2d at 1221 ("It is customary, and ordinarily not
improper, to include more than one allegedly false statement in a single count. . . . Where there
are several such specifications of falsity in a single count, proof of any of the specifications is
sufficient to support a verdict of guilty." (citations omitted)).
choices reflected in the criminal discovery rules." Id. Second, doing so "risks invading 'the
inviolable function of the jury' in our criminal justice system."' Id. at 281 (citation omitted).
Accordingly, if the "defense raises a factual dispute that is inextricably intertwined with a
defendant's potential culpability, a judge cannot resolve that dispute on a Rule 12(b) motion." Id.
The exception to this rule is "extraordinarily narrow" because, in the normal course, the
"government must make a detailed presentation of the entirety of the evidence before a district
court can dismiss an indictment on sufficiency grounds," which the Government is not required to
do at the motion-to-dismiss stage. Id. at 282 (internal quotation marks and citation omitted). That
point is underscored by United States v. Nitsche, 843 F. Supp. 2d 4 (D.D.C. 2011), on which the
defendant relies. There, the district court dismissed an indictment in a child enticement case for
insufficiency of the evidence. First, however, the court explained that the question was ripe
because "(1) Defendant has stipulated to the entire record that is relevant to Count I; (2) the
Government has had several opportunities to make a proffer of any additional facts, to conduct
any subsequent investigation, and to ask the Court for further delay to seek more evidence; and (3)
because the record is limited to the chat." Id. at 9. Accordingly, "[t]he transcripts themselves
provide the Court with all of the relevant undisputed facts to decide the motion." Id. Here, of
course, that is simply not the case and, in particular, there is no stipulation as to the entire relevant
record.
Under the relevant legal standard, the defendant's statements were material if they could
have led to the discovery of other evidence or could influence the factfinder in the defendant's
civil case. Evaluating that standard necessarily implicates facts beyond the deposition testimony
itself and Judge Preska's unsealing order,5° such as identification of the allegedly defamatory
5° The defendant observes that Judge Preska redacted some of the statements that form the basis
of Count Six, stating that the "testimony is . . . far afield from the sex trafficking and sexual abuse
statements at the heart of that case and the evidence that might have been uncovered had the
defendant answered the questions truthfully. A jury should be allowed to hear the questions in
context to evaluate their materiality, which cannot be done at this stage.51 The Court therefore
should deny the motion.
In any event, the perjurious statements were material in both senses of the definition. First,
the questions were aimed at developing a record in the civil suit that Epstein and the defendant
recruited Giuffre to Epstein's Palm Beach property in the guise of hiring her as a masseuse, and
then sexualized that massage. Honest answers to those questions-for instance that Epstein in fact
had a scheme to recruit underaged girls for sexual massages —would have been corroborative of
some of Giuffre's claims. Second, had the defendant honestly answered the deposition questions,
Giuffre could have located other victims or witnesses who may have corroborated her testimony.
But in any event, the question of materiality should be put to the jury and is inappropriate for the
Court to resolve on a motion to dismiss without the benefit of the full factual record. The motion
should be denied.
allegations that were central to the dispute in Giuffre v. Maxwell." (Def. Mot. 4, Ex. I at 7:3-6.)
(The last colloquy has been unsealed except for Minor Victim-2's name. (See 15 Civ. 7433 (LAP),
Dkt. No. 1212-1).) Yet Judge Preska's opinion as to the propriety of certain redactions in a civil
case is not controlling as to whether the Government can meet the elements of a criminal perjury
charge here. First, before Judge Preska were the defendant's denials of various sexual activities,
not honest answers that would have been quite different. In part for that reason, Judge Sweet
authorized the deposition at the outset. Second, the Government was not a party to the civil
unsealing litigation and did not have an opportunity to be heard on this issue before Judge Preska.
5I While the Government is open to crafting a stipulation on the background of the Giuffre lawsuit
to streamline presentation of these issues to the jury, it notes that the defendant's summary of that
suit as set forth in her motion is incorrect. (E.g., Def. Mot. 4 at 20 (erroneously asserting that the
defamation claims at issue turned on Giuffre's ability to prove salacious allegations about public
officials)).
In sum, the defendant asks this Court to dismiss Counts Five and Six by stretching to read
ambiguity into clear questions and encouraging the Court to resolve questions committed to the
jury. The Court should reject those arguments and permit the jury to resolve these issues of fact.

VI. Counts Five and Six Are Properly Joined and Should Not Be Severed
The Indictment charges the defendant with participating in a scheme to sexually abuse
minors, and with committing perjury to conceal her crimes. All six counts of the Indictment are
properly joined: they are logically connected, subject to overlapping proof, and connected by a
common scheme or plan. To sever the counts and justify holding a second trial at which a second
jury will be convened and the same witnesses —including victims of sexual abuse —will testify a
second time, the defendant must carry a heavy burden by showing substantial prejudice from the
joinder. She has not done so, and the severance motion should be denied.

A. Applicable Law
Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 8(a) permits the joinder of offenses that "are of the
same or similar character, or are based on the same act or transaction, or are connected with or
constitute parts of a common scheme or plan." Fed. R. Crim. P. 8(a). This rule establishes three
tests for joinder, each "reflect[ing] a policy determination that gains in trial efficiency outweigh
the recognized prejudice that accrues to the accused." United States v. Turoff, 853 F.2d 1037,
1042 (2d Cir. 1988).
Charges are "similar" if they are "somewhat alike" or "hav[e] a general likeness to each
other." United States v. Rivera, 546 F.3d 245, 253 (2d Cir. 2008) (quoting United States v. Werner,
620 F.2d 922, 926 (2d Cir. 1980) (internal quotation marks omitted). "Rule 8(a) does not require
`too precise an identity between the character of the offenses!" United States v. Pizarro, No. 17
Cr. 151, 2018 WL 1737236, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 10, 2018) (Nathan, J.) (quoting Werner, 620
F.2d at 929). Offenses may be joined "where the same evidence may be used to prove each count
or if the counts have a sufficient logical connection." United States v. Page, 657 F.3d 126, 129
(2d Cir. 2011) (internal quotation marks and citations omitted). "For purposes of analysis under
Rule 8(a)," however, "no one characteristic is always sufficient to establish `similarity' of offenses,
and each case depends largely on its own facts." United States v. Blakney, 941 F.2d 114, 116 (2d
Cir. 1991) (internal quotations and citations omitted). For instance, in United States v. Werner,
620 F.2d 922 (2d Cir. 1980), the "Second Circuit found sufficient similarity between two cargo
thefts that occurred two years apart and only one of which was violent in nature," because "'both
offenses arose out of [defendant's] scheme to use his position as an insider ... to obtain money or
property carried by it."' United States v. Smith, No. 05 Cr. 922 (DLC), 2007 WL 980431, at *2
(S.D.N.Y. Apr. 3, 2007), aff'd, 348 F. App'x 636, 638 (2d Cir. 2009) (first alteration in original)
(quoting Werner, 620 F2d at 927).
Joinder is also proper for "distinct criminal acts where they originated from a common
scheme." United States v. Ying Lin, No. 15 Cr. 601 (DLI), 2018 WL 5113139, at *2 (E.D.N.Y.
Oct. 19, 2018) (citing Werner, 620 F.2d at 927). Specifically in the context of perjury, "[t]he law
in this circuit clearly supports the joinder of underlying substantive crimes with perjury counts
where, as here, the false declarations concern the substantive offenses." United States v. Potamitis,
739 F.2d 784, 791 (2d Cir. 1984); see United States v. Sweig, 441 F.2d 114, 118 (2d Cir. 1971).
False statements can "concern" or be connected with substantive offenses even if they were not
made as part of an investigation into the specific substantive conduct. See United States v. Ruiz,
894 F.2d 501, 505 (2d Cir. 1990) (joining false statements on loan applications with perjury about
"attempts to secure Senate Ethics Committee approval" of "consulting fees'); United States v.
Broccolo, 797 F. Supp. 1185, 1190-91 (S.D.N.Y. 1992) (joining fraud counts with a false statement
in a bankruptcy proceeding). Similarly, "[c]ourts have repeatedly recognized the appropriateness
of trying perjury or obstruction charges together with the underlying crimes to which the perjury
relates, where proof of the alleged perjury requires proof of knowledge of the underlying crime."
United States v. Butler, No. 04 Cr. 340, 2004 WL 2274751, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 7, 2004) (Lynch,
J.) (permitting joinder of defendants under Rule 8(b)).
In the event that properly joined counts "appear[] to prejudice a defendant or the
government," Rule 14(a) permits a court to "order separate trials of counts . . . or provide any other
relief that justice requires." Fed. R. Crim. P. 14(a). "[I]n order to prevail" on a Rule 14 motion,
"the defendant must show not simply some prejudice but substantial prejudice." United States v.
Sampson, 385 F.3d 183, 190 (2d Cir. 2004) (quoting Werner, 620 F.2d at 928). The defendant
carries this "heavy burden" because Rule 8(a) already strikes a "balance" between "considerations
of economy and speed" and "possible unfairness" to the defendant. United States v. Amato, 15
F.3d 230, 237 (2d Cir. 1994). Accordingly, "the principles that guide the district court's
consideration of a motion for severance usually counsel denial," Pizarro, 2018 WL 1737236, at
*5 (alteration, internal quotation marks, and citation omitted), and severance should be granted
"only if there is a serious risk that a joint trial would compromise a specific trial right of one of the
defendants, or prevent the jury from making a reliable judgment about guilt or innocence," Zafiro

v. United States, 506 U.S. 534, 539 (1993). 52 But "Rule 14 does not require severance even if
prejudice is shown; rather, it leaves the tailoring of the relief to be granted, if any, to the district
court's sound discretion." Id. at 538-39. "[L]ess drastic measures . .. such as limiting instructions,
52 While Zafiro involved a motion to sever defendants, rather than counts, the Supreme Court's
construction of Rule 14(a) applies in either case. See Page, 657 F.3d at 129 (relying on Zafiro);
United States v. Gracesqui, No. 10 Cr. 74 (PKC), 2015 WL 5231168, at *4 n.2 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 8,
2015), aff'd, 730 F. App'x 25 (2d Cir. 2018) (citing Page for the proposition that Zafiro applies
both to motions to sever counts and motions to sever defendants).
often will suffice to cure any risk of prejudice and permit joinder." Page, 657 F.3d at 129 (internal
quotation marks omitted).

B. Discussion
The perjury counts should be tried jointly with Counts One through Four. The offenses are
of similar character, are logically connected and will be proved through much of the same evidence
because the perjury counts concern at least some of the same conduct relevant to the crimes
charged in Counts One through Four and, as such, are properly joined. See generally Potamitis,
739 F.2d at 791. Severing the counts would waste judicial resources by requiring a second trial at
which the Government would offer similar proof, including by calling the same victims of sexual
abuse to testify again at a second trial. The defendant has identified no prejudice sufficient to
justify imposing that burden on the victims, the Court, and the Government.
First, the Government expects to prove the offenses charged in Counts One through Four
and those charged in Counts Five and Six with much of the same evidence. See United States v.
Hester, No. 19 Cr. 324 (NSR), 2020 WL 3483702, at *21 (S.D.N.Y. June 26, 2020) ("Notably, the
fact that evidence of the crime charged in one count may be admissible in the Government's direct
case in the trial of the other will typically defeat the need to severe the counts."). At trial, some of
the most critical evidence that the defendant committed the offenses charged in Counts One
through Four will also form the crux of the Government's proof of the falsity of the defendant's
deposition testimony. In particular, victim testimony and related evidence offered to prove the
existence of Epstein's scheme to abuse underage girls, and Maxwell's participation therein, will
also provide much of the evidence demonstrating the falsity of the statements charged in Count
Five. Compare, e.g., Indictment ¶ 4(c), (e) (discussing massages resulting in sexual abuse), with
id. ¶ 21 (denying interacting with underage girls and a denying a "scheme to recruit underage girls
for sexual massages"). Similarly, aspects of that proof, such as testimony regarding the sexualized
massages that were part of the scheme, will also prove the falsity of the statements charged in
Count Six. Indeed, were severance to be granted, the facts involving Counts One through Four
"would be central to a separate trial" on Counts Five and Six. Butler, 2004 WL 2274751, at *4;
see Sweig, 441 F.2d at 118-19 ("Virtually every overt act alleged in the conspiracy count formed
the subject matter of one of the eight perjury counts, and would therefore be admissible in a perjury
trial to show the falsity of Sweig's denial before the grand jury.").
Critically, the Government expects that proof to include testimony from victims of sexual
abuse. For instance, the Government anticipates that Minor Victim-2 will testify that the defendant
gave her an unsolicited massage during which Minor Victim-2 was topless. Indictment 7(b).
That is an overt act charged in Counts One and Three. Id. ¶¶ 11(c), 17(c). It is also strong evidence
that the defendant's statement "I never gave [Minor Victim-2] a massage" was false, as charged
in Count Six. Id. ¶ 23. If the Court severs the Indictment into two trials, it will require Minor
Victim-2 to testify about her abuse twice. Cf. Richardson v. Marsh, 481 U.S. 200, 210 (1987)
(recognizing that joint trials of multiple defendants avoid "requiring victims and witnesses to
repeat the inconvenience (and sometimes trauma) of testifying").
Similarly, the defendant's efforts to conceal her crimes by lying in a deposition is itself
compelling evidence of her consciousness of guilt as to the offenses charged in Counts One
through Four and indeed would almost certainly be relevant and admissible at a trial as to those
counts even if severance were granted. In particular, and among other examples, the defendant's
false denial of the existence of a scheme to recruit underage girls for sexual massages, and her
specific (and equally false) denials as to Minor Victim-2, would be admissible as evidence of the
defendant's consciousness of guilt, even at a trial focused exclusively on Counts One through Four.
See, e.g., United States v. Anderson, 747 F.3d 51, 60 (2d Cir. 2014) ("[A]cts that exhibit a
consciousness of guilt, such as false exculpatory statements, may also tend to prove knowledge
and intent of a conspiracy's purpose ...." (internal quotation marks and citations omitted)).
Second, the offenses are logically connected and are part of the same common plan or
scheme. It is settled law in this Circuit that joinder of "underlying substantive crimes with perjury
counts" is appropriate "where, as here, the false declarations concern the substantive offenses."
Potamitis, 739 F.2d at 791; see also United States v. Ruiz, 894 F.2d 501 (2d Cir. 1992) (same). In
Ruiz, the defendant was a New York state senator who founded a nonprofit that was developing a
mall in the Bronx, and for which he provided consulting services. In 1984 and 1985, he made two
loan applications for funds to invest in the project, on which he made false statements. Id. at 503-

04. In 1986, the defendant also lied about his possession of a letter from the Senate Ethics
Committee to a grand jury that was investigating his consulting activities for the nonprofit. Id. at
503. He was charged with two counts of false statements on the loan applications and one count
of perjury, and he moved to sever the perjury charge. The district court denied the motion,
explaining that, although the "alleged perjury did not occur during a specific investigation by the
grand jury into the alleged bank fraud," the statements nonetheless "'concerned the defendant's
scheme to maximize his personal gain from the [project], as well to cover any improprieties that
scheme might involve."' Broccolo, 797 F. Supp. at 1190 (quoting United States v. Ruiz, 702 F.
Supp. 1066, 1076-77 (S.D.N.Y. 1989)) (emphasis omitted). And the Second Circuit affirmed,
explaining that the counts had "sufficient logical connection" because they all "relate to [the
defendant's] extra-senatorial activities through the [nonprofit]," and therefore were "part of a
common scheme or plan." Ruiz, 894 F.2d at 505. So too here: the defendant's perjury did not
occur in the context of a grand jury investigation into the same sexual offenses charged in the
Indictment, but the statements concerned those offenses and sought to conceal the defendant's role
therein. See Broccolo, 797 F. Supp. at 1190-91 (joining counts involving use of businesses to
commit fraud with a count of falsely swearing in bankruptcy court that the defendant "had not
engaged in any business activity during the preceding six years"). 53 Accordingly, and consistent
with the holdings in Ruiz and Broccolo, this Court should deny the severance motion.
The defendant argues that the offenses are not connected because they involve different
time periods. To be sure, Counts One through Four charge conduct involving certain victims from
1994 to 1997, while the perjury counts charge statements made in 2016 in a case concerning
Giuffre's abuse from 1999 to 2002. However, the specific statements charged in Count Five and
Count Six directly relate to the conduct charged in Counts One through Four, including, in one
instance, a specific victim identified as relevant to those counts. And those statements were not
time-bound or restricted to Giuffre. For instance, the defendant denied the existence of any scheme
to recruit underage girls for sexual massages, not the existence of such a scheme between 1999
and 2002, or a scheme specifically focused on Giuffre. The defendant also denied ever giving
anyone a massage, specifically including Epstein and Minor Victim-2. She did not limit her denial
to Giuffre or to a particular time period. There is, accordingly, a strong connection between the
truth or falsity of the defendant's broad denials and her acts in the period at issue in the substantive
counts. The cases on which the defendant relies are factually inapposite and do not support her
argument, because they involve wholly unrelated events. See, e.g., United States v. Halper, 590
F.2d 422, 431 (2d Cir. 1978) (severing a Medicaid fraud indictment from a tax evasion indictment
where the only similarly was the defendant's manipulation of people he had employed —different
53 While the defendant may argue that the fact that her deposition, unlike Ruiz, did not involve
criminal authorities counsels in favor of a different outcome, as discussed further below, the
prospect of a criminal prosecution was nonetheless plainly on her mind at the time of the
depositions, as evidenced by the myriad arguments she herself makes in support of her motions to
suppress the fruits of the grand jury subpoena to Boies Schiller. (See, e.g., Def. Mot. 3 at 3-4, Def.
Mot. 11 at 2).
in each indictment —to his personal profit); United States v. Brown, No. 07-0296, 2008 WL
161146, at *5 (E.D. Pa. Jan. 16, 2008) (severing an "isolated" firearms possession charge on a
certain day from other narcotics and firearms charges); United States v. Martinez, No. 92 Cr. 839
(SWK), 1993 WL 322768, at *8-9 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 19, 1993) (similar).
The defendant also contends that her false statements were not connected to the substantive
offenses because they were made in a civil deposition, rather than "to the grand jury or the FBI to
derail its investigation." (Def. Mot. 5 at 8). As an initial matter, and as evidenced by the
defendant's own motions to suppress the fruits of the grand jury subpoena issued to Boies Schiller,
the defendant herself professes to have been concerned about the prospect of a criminal
investigation at the time of her depositions, which strongly suggests that, on these facts, the
distinction is of little moment. (See, e.g., Def. Mot. 3 at 3-4 (explaining that the defendant "flatly
rejected" a law enforcement exception to the civil protective order); Def. Mot. 11 at 2 (arguing
that the defendant "declined to invoke" her Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination
at the deposition after negotiating the protective order)). More important, and whatever moment
that distinction may have in other contexts, it has little bearing on the severance analysis which
turns instead on whether the substance of the false statement relates to the substantive offense, and
is thereby provable through overlapping evidence and part of the speaker's effort to conceal the
offense. See Ruiz, 894 F.2d at 505; Potamitis, 739 F.2d at 791 (citing United States v. Carson,
464 F.2d 424, 436 (2d Cir. 1972); Sweig, 441 F.2d at 118-19) (affirming denial of a severance
motion where the false statements "concern the substantive offenses" and citing cases where the
perjury count's proof overlapped with the evidence on the substantive counts). With respect to
that analysis, the defendant cites no case for the proposition that the setting in which the statement
is made is significant, much less determinative. Cl Broccolo, 797 F. Supp. at 1190 (false statement
in bankruptcy proceeding). And the cases the defendant cites in which a perjury or false statements
count was severed only underscore this point. In both cases, the statement itself concerned an
entirely different subject matter, provable through largely if not entirely different evidence. See
United States v. Botti, No. 08 Cr. 230 (CSH), 2009 WL 3157582, at *1, *5 (D. Conn. Sept. 25,
2009) (severing a structuring conspiracy and false statements related to that conspiracy from a
"separate" corruption conspiracy); United States v. Milan, No. 08-760, 2009 WL 2328870, at *3
(E.D. Pa. July 28, 2009) (severing counts charging a fraud scheme from perjury count for an
affidavit submitted as part of a bail motion, which "was not as an attempt to cover up the scheme
to defraud, but rather an attempt to show that Court had erred" in its bail decision).
Finally, the defendant argues that the counts are unrelated because the defendant's
testimony was given in response to questions "tangential to the defamation action," and her
answers "concealed" no crimes because they were "true and reflective of the poor questioning by
the plaintiffs lawyers." (Def. Mot. 5 at 8-9). The defendant is free to make at least some of these
arguments to the jury, but these assertions are not a lawful basis for severing Counts Five and Six.
This is merely an attempt to refashion the defendant's claim that she gave truthful, immaterial
answers to ambiguous questions. But, as discussed in detail in Section V, those arguments have
no merit.
Third, the defendant has failed to carry her heavy burden under Rule 14(a) to show
prejudice. At the outset, "[t]he contention that there is some inherent prejudice in joining perjury
and related counts with substantive charges has been widely rejected." Potamitis, 739 F.2d at 791.
And courts routinely hold that there is no prejudice where the evidence in support of the two counts
is "interconnected." Blakney, 941 F.2d at 116; see Carson, 464 F.2d at 436 ("[T]he commonality
of proof of the conspiracy and perjury crimes permitted joinder of the offenses . . . and denial of
appellant's Rule 14 pretrial motion for severance."); Pizarro, 2018 WL 1737236, at *6-*7.
The defendant argues that the trial on the perjury counts will require a "full-blown re-
litigation of the defamation action." (Def. Mot. 5 at 9). That is a significant exaggeration. To
litigate the perjury counts, the parties will need to present evidence about the basic substance of
the civil suit—in particular, Giuffre's allegations and the defendant's denials-such that the jury
will be able to assess materiality and the statements' context. This can be done briefly —as stated
in Section V, the Government is amenable to presenting that information through a stipulation —
and, in any event, through minimal additional evidence. The stipulation or other evidence could
be crafted to minimize the risk of spillover prejudice, for instance by referring to Giuffre by a
pseudonym to avoid any connection she might have to testimony on the substantive counts. And
any remaining prejudice could be vitiated by a limiting instruction that the jury should not consider
Giuffre's allegations as evidence of the substantive counts. See Page, 657 F.3d at 130-31
(approving of similar precautions when introducing evidence of a defendant's prior felony
conviction); Pizarro, 2018 WL 1737236, at *7; see also Zafiro, 506 U.S. at 540 ("[J]uries are
presumed to follow their instructions." (citation and internal quotation marks omitted)). There is
every reason to think a jury could and would follow such an instruction. See, e.g., Rivera, 546
F.3d at 254 (using a limiting instruction to prevent spillover prejudice for counts involving the
sexual exploitation of different children, especially in light of admissibility across counts); United
States v. Pena, 932 F. Supp. 2d 464, 467 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) (using a limiting instruction to address
spillover prejudice from two murder for hire conspiracies). Indeed, even if the counts were
severed, as noted above, the Government would still seek to offer evidence of the defendant's false
denials of conduct relevant to Counts One through Four as evidence of her consciousness of guilt
as to those counts, and would consent to a similar limiting instruction, which a jury would be
presumed to follow. And, of course, in a severed trial exclusively on the perjury counts, the
defendant would surely argue that a limiting instruction is necessary to prevent the jury from
concluding that the defendant's statements were false based in part on the substance of Giuffre's
unproven allegations. Just as a jury would set aside the substance of Giuffre's allegations for that
purpose, so can the jury set aside the substance of Giuffre's allegations for Counts One through
Four.
The defendant contends instead that the perjury counts require a "collateral trial" on the
truth of Giuffre's statements and resolution of "more than 50 substantive motions . . . pending
before the District Court." (De£ Mot. 5 at 9-10). As described in Section V, a false statement in
a civil deposition is material ( 1) if a "truthful answer might reasonably be calculated to lead to the
discovery of evidence admissible at the trial of the underlying suit," United States v. Kross, 14
F.3d 751, 753 (2d Cir. 1994), or (2) if it has "a natural tendency to influence, or [be] capable of
influencing, the decision of the decisionmaking body to which it was addressed," United States v.
Gaudin, 515 U.S. 506, 509 (1995) (alteration in original) (internal quotation marks omitted).
Neither of these standards requires the jury to determine whether the defendant's statements would
have tipped the scales in the defamation suit or would likely have led to the discovery of evidence.
See Kungys v. United States, 485 U.S. 759, 771 (1988) ("It has never been the test of materiality
that the misrepresentation or concealment would more likely than not have produced an erroneous
decision, or even that it would more likely than not have triggered an investigation."); United States
v. An Antique Platter of Gold, 184 F.3d 131, 135-36 (2d Cir. 1999) (distinguishing the "natural
tendency test" from a but-for test); Kross, 14 F.3d at 754 (rejecting, in a civil forfeiture case, the
argument that the defendant's true testimony would not itself have justified a forfeiture because
"such evidence might lead to evidence . . . which would justify forfeiture"). The jury need not
decide the outcome of the defamation case in order to evaluate whether truthful answers were
capable of influencing the decisionmaker or could reasonably have led to the discovery of
admissible evidence. 54
Finally, the defendant argues that severance is appropriate because including the perjury
counts "will necessarily introduce into the trial the issue of Ms. Maxwell's credibility." (Def. Mot.
5 at 13). That is true anytime perjury or false statements counts are joined with other offenses, yet
joining perjury or false statements counts to the substantive crimes they concern is the rule, not
the exception. And more generally, the "adverse effect of being tried for two crimes rather than
one" is not prejudice. Werner, 620 F.2d at 929.
Trying the perjury counts with the Mann Act counts they concern makes eminent sense.
Doing so greatly advances judicial efficiency by avoiding the need for two trials at which the same
evidence would be presented, including testimony from the same victims. Just as the counts are
similar in character, the trial would not be unwieldy. Against these efficiencies, endorsed by the
liberal joinder principles behind Rule 8, the defendant identifies at most only "generalized claim[s]
of prejudice," Rivera, 546 F.3d at 254, that can be cured by an appropriate limiting instruction.
She thus falls far short of meeting her heavy burden, and her motion should be denied.
54 The defendant relatedly suggests that her counsel from the defamation suit may have to testify
regarding the perjury counts, denying her counsel of her choice. She has not identified what factual
issue they might testify to and why it must come from one of the lawyers who represented her on
both that case and this one. The Government notes, in this respect, that three of the defendant's
attorneys in this case had no involvement in the civil suit. Even if such testimony were necessary
by one of the defendant's lawyers, it would only disqualify the firm if that lawyer is called "on a
significant issue other than on behalf of the client, and it is apparent that the testimony may be
prejudicial to the client." N.Y. R.P.C. 3.7(b); see generally Murray v. Met. Life Ins. Co., 583 F.3d
173, 177-80 (2d Cir. 2009) (discussing the advocate -witness rule).
VII. The Indictment Contains the Elements of Each Offense and Provides the Defendant
More Than Adequate Notice of the Charges Against Her
The defendant also moves to dismiss Counts One through Four on the grounds that the
Indictment lacks specificity because it does not name minor victims, does not include specific
dates, and uses language that the defendant claims not to understand. (Del. Mot. 12). The motion
is meritless and should be denied. The plain language of the Indictment clearly and sufficiently
sets forth every element of each crime charged, and the extensive details contained in the
Indictment as further amplified through the voluminous discovery and the Government's various
pit -trial filing describing the case and its anticipated proof at trial provide the defendant with more
than sufficient notice of the charges against her.
A. Applicable Law
It is well-established that "[a]n indictment is sufficient if it contains the elements of the
offense(s) charged and fairly informs a defendant of the charge(s) against which he must
defend." United States v. Rahimi, No. 16 Cr. 760 (RMB), 2017 WL 2984169, at ■1 (S.D.N.Y.
June 22, 2017) (citing United States v. Chalmers, 474 F. Supp. 2d 555, 559 (S.D.N.Y. 2007);
Hamling v. United States, 418 U.S. 87, 117 (1974)). As a result, "'an indictment need do little
more than to track the language of the statute charged and state the time and place (in approximate
terms) of the alleged crime" in order to be sufficient. United States v. Stavroulakis, 952 F.2d 686,
693 (2d Cir. 1992) (quoting United States v. Tramunti, 513 F.2d 1087, 1113 (2d Cir. 1975)). As
such, "[a] defendant faces a high standard in seeking to dismiss an indictment." United States v.
Nejad, No. 18 Cr. 224 (MN), 2019 WL 6702361, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 9, 2019) (internal quotation
marks omitted) (quoting United States v. Post, 950 F. Supp. 2d 519, 527 (S.D.N.Y. 2013)).
Additionally, "when deciding a motion to dismiss, a court must accept all factual allegations in the
indictment as true." Chalmers, 474 F. Supp. 2d at 559. "A court should not look beyond the face
of the indictment and draw inferences as to proof to be adduced at trial, for `the sufficiency of the
evidence is not appropriately addressed on a pretrial motion to dismiss an indictment.' Id.
(quoting United States v. Alfonso, 143 F.3d 772, 776-77 (2d. Cir. 1998)).
Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 7 states in part that an indictment "must be a plain,
concise, and definite written statement of the essential facts constituting the offense charged . . . ."
Fed. R. Crim. P. 7(c)(1). There are two constitutional requirements an indictment must satisfy in
order to be sufficient: first, it must "contain[] the elements of the offense charged and fairly
inform[] a defendant of the charge against which [s]he must defend," and second, it must
"enable[]" a defendant "to plead an acquittal or conviction in bar of future prosecutions for the
same offense." United States v. Resendiz-Ponce, 549 U.S. 102, 108 (2007) (internal quotation
mark omitted) (quoting Handing, 418 U.S. at 117). "[A]n indictment parroting the language of a
federal criminal statute is often sufficient . .." Id. at 109. As a general matter, "[a]n indictment
does not . . `have to specify evidence or details of how the offence was committed.' United
States v. Wey, No. 15 Cr. 611 (MN), 2017 WL 237651, at *5 (S.D.N.Y. Jan, 18, 2017) (emphasis
in original) (quoting United States v. Coffey, 361 F. Supp. 2d 102, 111 (E.D.N.Y. 2005)). "When
the charges in an indictment have stated the elements of the offense and provided even minimal
protection against double jeopardy," the Second Circuit "has repeatedly refused, in the absence of
any showing of prejudice, to dismiss ... charges for lack of specificity." United States v. Stringer;
730 F.3d 120, 124 (2d Cir. 2013) (ellipses in original) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting
United States v. Walsh, 194 F.3d. 37, 45 (2d Cir. 1999)).
Although courts have identified certain crimes for which an indictment may require greater
specificity beyond tracking the language of the statute, such cases are "very rare." Stringer, 730
F.3d at 125. For example, the Second Circuit has clarified that within this "less -common category"
is the "specification of what statements are alleged to be false, and in what respect they are false,
in charges of criminal falsity," as well as "the subject matter of the congressional inquiry" for
charges of "refusal to answer questions in a congressional inquiry." Id. at 125-26 (citing, inter
alia, Russell v. United States, 369 U.S. 749 (1962)). Similarly, "where an indictment charges a
crime that depends in turn on violation of another statute, the indictment must identify the
underlying offense." United States v. PilTO, 212 F.3d 86, 93 (2d Cir. 2000). When delineating the
contours of this narrow category of crimes requiring additional specificity in an indictment, the
Second Circuit has previously found that the failure to name a specific victim of fraud does not
render an indictment inadequate under this standard. See Stringer, 730 F.3d at 127. In other words,
absent some affirmative indication that additional specificity is required when charging a particular
statute, there is no basis to conclude that an indictment need contain more than the elements of the
offense and the approximate time and place of the alleged violation. See Wey, 2017 WL 237651
at *5 (declining to "depart from the usual sufficiency framework" where defendant "cites no
authority" suggesting that the statutes at issue fall into the narrow exception to the general rule
when considering motion to dismiss for lack of specificity).
B. Discussion
Because each of the four counts at issue—Counts One, Two, Three, and Four—clearly lays
out each element of the charged offense and adequately informs the defendant of the accusations
against her, the Indictment easily satisfies the standard for sufficiency. Tellingly, the defendant
does not claim that any of these counts fails to allege an essential element or to track the language
of the relevant statute. Nor could she, as the face of the Indictment not only contains each and
every essential element of the crimes charged, but also goes beyond the basic requirements for
pleading each charge by providing additional factual background. Instead, the defendant baldly
asserts that the crimes charged in Counts One through Four require additional specificity without
citing any authority in support of such a broad claim. (See Def. Mot. 12 at 2). In particular, the
defendant suggests that the failure to identify each minor victim by name, the presence of a date
range rather than specific dates, and the use of certain language that the defendant claims not to
understand render Counts One through Four so deficient that they must be dismissed. Because the
defendant cites no authority indicating that violations of 18 U.S.C. §§ 371, 2422, or 2423 fall into
the rare exception to "the rule that `an indictment need do little more than to track the language of
the statute charged,'" her motion should be denied. United States v. Murgio, 209 F. Supp. 3d 698,
716 (S.D.N.Y. 2016) (Nathan, J.) (quoting Stringer, 730 F.3d at 124).
First, the use of pseudonyms to refer to minor victims of the charged conduct does not
warrant dismissal of the Indictment. See Stringer, 730 F.3d at 124 (affirming sufficiency of fraud
indictment InJotwithstanding its failure to specify the names of persons whose identifying
documents were used" in scheme where prosecution provided victims' names in advance of trial).
The identity of a victim is not required to be included on the face of a charging instrument, and the
"lack of any identity or date of birth information of the alleged victims does not warrant dismissal"
of charges alleging sexual abuse. United States v. Kidd, 386 F. Supp.3d 364, 369 (S.D.N.Y. 2019).
The defendant cites no law to the contrary and has not identified a single indictment in this District
that includes the full names of minor victims of sexual abuse. Indeed, it makes good sense that a
charging instrument alleging sexual abuse of minors would not include the full names of minor
victims, whose privacy Congress has emphasized should be protected. See 18 U.S.C. § 3509(d)
(delineating privacy protections for child victims and witnesses).
Judge Marrero's decision in Kidd, which denied a motion to dismiss a sex trafficking
charges in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591 where the indictment referred to victims by pseudonyms,
is particularly instructive here. See 386 F. Supp.3d at 366. In denying the motion to dismiss,
Judge Marrero found Stringer's holding "that the identity of a victim was not required to be
contained in an indictment, despite the centrality of the victim's identity to the charge" to be
equally applicable in a case involving sex trafficking charges. Id. at 369. The same logic follows
here. The use of pseudonyms to refer to the minor victims of sexual abuse in Counts One through
Four is no more prejudicial to the defendant here than the absence of victim identities was to the
defendants in Kidd or Stringer. This is especially so when the Government has already provided
the defendant with the birth month and year of each victim, provided discovery regarding each
victim, and has repeatedly indicated that it will provide the defendant with the names of its
witnesses, including the minor victims referenced in the Indictment, four weeks in advance of trial.
Such disclosure will ensure that the defendant is readily able to bar future prosecutions for the
same offense, and together with the elements of each crime and additional details contained in in
the Indictment, is more than sufficient to survive a motion to dismiss.
Second, the Indictment "state[s] the time and place (in approximate terms)" of the conduct
alleged in Counts One through Four. Stavroulakis, 952 F.2d at 693 (quoting Tramunti, 513 F.2d
at 1113). In particular, Counts One through Four each allege that the defendant engaged in a
continuing course of conduct involving the enticement and transportation of minors with intent to
commit illegal sex acts, as well as conspiracies to do so, between in or about 1994 and in or about
1997. See Indictment ¶¶ 1, 6, 7, 9-11, 13, 15-17, 19. Courts in the Second Circuit have consistently
upheld indictments containing a range of time rather than a specific date. See, e.g., Kidd, 386. F.
Supp. 3d at 369 ("[Th]e Second Circuit routinely upholds the 'on or about' language used to
describe the window of when a violation occurred." (citing United States v. Nersesian, 824 F.2d
1294, 1323 (2d Cir. 1987)); United States v. Vickers, No. 13 Cr. 128 (RJA) (HKS), 2014 WL
1838255, at *1, 4-6 (W.D.N.Y. May 8, 2014) (denying motion to dismiss indictment charging
enticement of a minor, in violation of 18 U.S.C. 2423(a), "between in or about 2000 to in or about
2004," because "the Indictment states all the elements of the crime charged by tracking the
statutory language," as well as "the nature of the criminal activity" and "the underlying facts").
"This is especially true in cases of sexual abuse of children: allegations of sexual abuse of
underage victims often proceed without specific dates of offenses," including "[i]n cases of
continuing sexual abuse," for which "it is sufficient for the indictment to specify a period of time—
rather than a specific date—in which defendant committed the acts at issue . ..." United States v.
Young, No. 08 Cr. 285 (KMK), 2008 WL 4178190, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 4, 2008) (internal
quotation mark omitted) (quoting Edwards v. Mazzuca, No. 00 Civ. 2290 (US), 2007 WL
2994449, at *5 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 15, 2007)). Indeed, lbJecause minors often are not capable of
remembering the exact dates when the alleged acts occurred, 'fairly large time windows in the
context of child abuse prosecutions are not in conflict with constitutional notice requirements!"
Young, 2008 WL 4178190, at *2 (quoting Valentine v. Konteh, 395 F.3d 626, 632 (6th Cir. 2005)).
The same is true here. The minor victims in this case cannot reasonably be expected to recall the
exact dates when particular instances of abuse took place during their adolescence. This is
especially so for Minor Victim-1, who experienced numerous instances of abuse over multiple
years of her youth. Providing the approximate ranges of dates during which the offenses took
place fully satisfies the requirements of an adequately pled charging instrument. The defendant
cites no authority to the contrary, and her motion to dismiss should accordingly be denied.
Third, the Indictment lists in clear detail the allegations relevant to each element of every
criminal statute for which she is charged. Beyond simply "parroting the language of a federal
criminal statute," Resendiz-Ponce, 549 U.S. at 108, the Indictment provides extensive detail
regarding how the defendant is alleged to have committed the crimes charged in Counts One
through Four. See Indictment ¶¶ 1-11. Indeed, "by providing Defendant with a narrative of the
manner in which Defendant is alleged to have committed the charged offenses, the Indictment
provides Defendant with more detail than is strictly necessary" under the governing law. United
States v. Kozel, No. 19 Cr. 460 (ICMW), 2020 WL 4751498, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 17, 2020).
Although the defendant complains that some of the terms used in the speaking portions of
the Indictment are somehow vague, she cites no authority to suggest that her difficulty
comprehending basic language in portions of a charging instrument that do not speak to the
elements of the offense requires dismissal. 55 Counts One and Three, charging the defendant with
violations of 18 U.S.0 § 371, "clearly contain[] the elements of the offense charged, fairly inform[]
[her] of the charge[s] against [her], and enable[] [her] to plead an acquittal or conviction in bar of
future prosecution for the same offense." United States v. Born, 154 F. App'x 227, 229 (2d Cir.
2005). Counts Two and Four, charging violations of 18 U.S.0 §2422 and § 2243, respectively,
similarly contain the elements of those offenses and adequately inform the defendant of the charges
55 Alternatively, the defendant claims that the acts listed throughout the Indictment do not
constitute illegal behavior. In this vein, the defendant makes specific reference to "grooming" as
conduct that is not illegal. (Def. Mot. 12 at 4). The defendant cites no authority for this argument,
which is contrary to Second Circuit law. In particular, the Second Circuit has for many years
found grooming behavior to be a means to "persuade, induce, or entice" minors to engage in illegal
sexual activity. See, e.g., United States v. Thompson, 896 F.3d 155, 173 (2d Cir. 2018) ("Our
precedent, however, supports applying a broad definition of enticement in this context: that
definition would reasonably include Thompson's grooming of the minor victims to act as he
desired with regard to many matters over the months before he made the video."); United States v.
Dorvee, 616 F.3d 174, 180 (2d Cir. 2010) ("We do not believe that the district court was clearly
erroneous in finding, as a matter of fact, that these images were sent as part of a grooming process
to persuade the agent to engage in the type of sexual conduct depicted in the images." (internal
quotation marks and citation omitted)); United States v. Brand, 467 F.3d 179, 203 (2d Cir. 2006)
("Brand's sexual advances and grooming behavior provide additional evidence in support of the
jury's finding that Brand attempted to entice a minor."). In any event, whether grooming alone
constitutes a crime is immaterial to the instant motion, and it will be for the jury to decide whether
the evidence at trial, as a whole, establishes the elements of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt.
against her. The Indictment also cites the relevant state criminal statute under which the defendant
is charged constituting "sexual activity" within the language of both § 2422 and § 2243,
specifically, violations of New York Penal Law § 130.55. Indictment ¶¶ 11(b), 13, 17(b), 19. The
defendant cites no authority for her suggestion that by providing additional detail regarding how
the defendant committed the charged crimes, the Government is somehow required to provide
even more specificity beyond the basic elements of the crimes charged. Absent any such authority,
and where there is no suggestion that the Indictment fails to allege the essential elements of each
crime charged, there is no basis to dismiss any of the counts in the Indictment.
For the foregoing reasons, the defendant's sufficiency challenges to the Indictment fail as
a matter of law, and her motion to dismiss Counts One through Four should be denied.
VIII. There Is No Basis to Strike Any Portion of the Indictment
The defendant moves to strike any reference to Minor Victim-3 from the Indictment,
claiming that—contrary to the plain terms of the Indictment —the events involving Minor Victim -
3 are unrelated to the conspiracies charged in Counts One and Three and that some of that the
allegations regarding Minor Victim-3 are unduly prejudicial. (Def. Mot. 6). The motion is
baseless. First, as the Indictment itself makes clear, the defendant's and Epstein's interactions
with Minor Victim -3 were part of a broader scheme and agreement to entice and transport minor
victims with intent to commit illegal sex acts. Even if Minor Victim-3 was not ultimately
transported as a minor, the core of a conspiracy is an agreement to engage in criminal conduct;
there is no legal requirement that the agreed upon crime be completed. Although Minor Victim -
3's experiences cannot alone form the basis of a timely substantive charge, both charged
conspiracies include timely overt acts, and it is well established that a charged conspiracy can
encompass otherwise time-barred acts so long as at least one overt act in furtherance of the
conspiracy is timely. Second, the description of Minor Victim -3's experiences in the Indictment
is no more inflammatory or prejudicial than those regarding Minor Victim -1 and Minor Victim -2.
Finally, even if evidence regarding Minor Victim-3 were not admissible as direct evidence of the
charged conspiracies —which it is—that evidence will be admissible under Federal Rule of
Evidence 404(b) to prove the defendant's knowledge, intent, and modus operandi. Accordingly,
the motion to strike references to Minor Victim-3 as surplusage should be denied.
A. Relevant Facts
As alleged in the Indictment, Minor Victim-3 was one of the minor girls whom the
defendant groomed to engage in sexual activity with Jeffrey Epstein. Minor Victim-3 was born in
. At trial, the Government expects that Minor Victim-3 will testify,se in substance
and in part, that when she was , she met the defendant. After meeting Minor Victim -
3, the defendant befriended Minor Victim-3 by, among other things, discussing Minor Victim-3's
life and family with Minor Victim -3. As a result, the defendant came to know Minor Victim-3's
age.
Minor—Victim-3 to meet Epstein. At some-Rairm 19
Minor Victim-3, who was still 17 years old, to the defendant's home in L where _II
defendant introduced Minor Victim-3 to Epstein. During that first visit, the defendant encouraged
Minor Victim-3 to provide Epstein with a massage. During the ensuing massage, Epstein engaged
in at least one sex act with Minor Victim-3. Subsequently, the defendant invited Minor Victim-3,
who was still 17 years old, to return to the defendant's home in London and massage Epstein again.
56 While the Government is proffering these facts for purposes of this Motion, the underlying
information, which is contained in the FBI 302 reports of interviews with Minor Victim-3, will be
produced to the defense as 3500 material in advance of trial.
Once again, the defendant encouraged Minor Victim-3 to provide a massage to Epstein. During
the ensuing massage, Epstein engaged in at least one sex act with Minor Victim-3.
Following those two encounters, the defendant and Epstein invited Minor Victim-3 to
travel with them to Florida, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and New York. Minor Victim-3 eventually
accepted these invitations, but she does not recall whether she was 17 or 18 when she took her first
trip at Epstein and the defendant's invitation. When Minor Victim-3 traveled with Epstein and the
defendant, she provided additional massages to Epstein, during which he engaged in multiple sex
acts with Minor Victim-3. Over the course of their interactions, the defendant made multiple
statements to Minor Via the defendant's awareness that Epstein engaged in sex
acts with Minor Victim-3. _On at-acne occasion, the defendant asked Minor Victim-3 if she
knew any otboviOunga  acts with Epstein.

B. Applicable Law
"Although the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure grant the Court authority to strike
surplusage from an indictment, see Fed. R. Crim. P. 7(d), li]t has long been the policy of courts
within the Southern District to refrain from tampering with indictments."' United States v. Bin
Laden, 91 F. Supp. 2d 600, 621 (S.D.N.Y. 2000) (quoting United States v. Jimenez, 824 F. Supp.
351, 369 (S.D.N.Y. 1993)). "Motions to strike surplusage from an indictment will be granted only
where the challenged allegations are 'not relevant to the crime charged and are inflammatory or
prejudicial.'" United States v. Scarpa, 913 F.2d 993, 1013 (2d Cir. 1990) (quoting United States
v. Napolitano, 552 F. Supp. 465, 480 (S.D.N.Y. 1982)). "'Ulf evidence of the allegation is
admissible and relevant to the charge, then regardless of how prejudicial the language is, it may
not be stricken."' Id. (brackets in original) (quoting United States v. DePalma, 461 F. Supp. 778,
797 (S.D.N.Y. 1978)); see also United States v. Mulder, 273 F.3d 91, 99 (2d Cir. 2001). "This
standard is an exacting one, and only rarely is alleged surplusage stricken from an indictment."
Murgio, 209 F. Supp. 3d at 724 (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting United States v. Smith,
985 F. Supp. 2d 547, 610 (S.D.N.Y. 2014)).
In setting forth allegations in an indictment, the Government is not limited to description
of only the bare elements of a crime; rather, an indictment may be used to provide background to
the charged criminal conduct, to describe the circumstances, means, and methods of an offense,
and to describe evidence that is otherwise admissible at trial. Simply put, "[s]tatements providing
background are relevant and need not be struck." United States v. Mostafa, 965 F. Supp. 2d 451,
466 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) (citing Mulder, 273 F.3d at 100). Allegations also will not be stricken where
they elucidate the circumstances, means, and methods of a charged scheme or would be admissible,
in the alternative, under Rule 404(b) of the Federal Rules of Evidence. See United States v.
Hernandez, 85 F.3d 1023, 1030 (2d Cir. 1996) (affirming denial of motion to strike surplusage
where "[defendants' cocaine -related activity was clearly relevant evidence of the organizational
structure and method of operation of their heroin conspiracy, and it also tended to establish the
nature of the relationship between Defendants and their supplier of heroin, defendant Jose Antonio
Hernandez," and citing Rule 404(b)).
In terms of timing, "[c]ourts in this district routinely await presentation of the
Government's evidence at trial before ruling on a motion to strike." Mostafa, 965 F. Supp. 2d at
467 (citing, inter alia, Scarpa, 913 F.2d at 1012); see also United States v. Ahmed, No. 10 Cr. 131
(PKC), 2011 WL 5041456, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 21, 2011). As multiple courts have concluded,
"'[t]here is little or no purpose in attempting to predict in advance of trial what evidence will prove
admissible or how specific allegations relate to the overall charges." Smith, 985 F. Supp. 2d at
612 (brackets in original) (quoting United States v. Butler, 351 F. Supp. 121, 124 (S.D.N.Y. 2004)).
C. Discussion
The defendant's motion to strike should be denied —or at a minimum deferred until after
the conclusion of the Government's direct case—because all of the challenged allegations pertain
to evidence that will be relevant and admissible at trial, and are not unduly prejudicial.
First, the allegations regarding Minor Victim-3 are properly included in the Indictment's
description of the conspiracies charged in Counts One and Three because evidence of those
incidents is relevant and admissible at trial as direct evidence of the crimes charged. Counts One
and Three allege that the defendant participated in conspiracies with Epstein both to transport
minor victims and to entice minor victims to travel with the intent to commit illegal sex acts.
Indictment¶¶ 9-11, 15-17. In the course and as part of those conspiracies, the defendant groomed
multiple minor victims for sexual abuse by Epstein through multiple methods, including
befriending victims and encouraging minor victims to provide massages to Epstein knowing he
would engage in sex acts with them. Id. ¶¶ I, 4, 7, 14. As detailed in the Indictment, that grooming
was a fundamental part of both conspiracies because it encouraged minor victims to be alone with
and to engage in sex acts with Epstein. 1, 4, 14. It follows that the defendant's role grooming
Minor Victim-3 to engage in sex acts with Epstein was a part of and therefore constitutes evidence
of these conspiracies. Id. ¶¶ 7(c), 11(d), 17(d).
The defense claims that because the Indictment does not allege that each element of
substantive violations of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2422 and 2423(a) was met as to Minor Victim-3, her
experiences cannot be direct evidence of the conspiracies to violate those statutes charged in
Counts One and Three. But that argument ignores a fundamental tenet of conspiracy law. It is
axiomatic that a conspiracy does not require a completed substantive crime. See Salinas v. United
States, 522 U.S. 52, 65 (1997) ("It is elementary that a conspiracy may exist and be punished
whether or not the substantive crime ensures, for the conspiracy is a distinct evil, dangerous to the
public, and so punishable in itself."). Indeed, "[i]t is well settled that the essential elements of
the crime of conspiracy are: (1) that the defendant agreed with at least one other person to commit
an offense; (2) the defendant knowingly participated in the conspiracy with the specific intent to
commit the offenses that were the objects of the conspiracy; and (3) that during the existence of
the conspiracy, at least one of the overt acts set forth in the indictment was committed by one or
more of the members of the conspiracy in furtherance of the objectives of the conspiracy." United
States v. Salarneh, 152 F.3d 88, 145-46 (2d Cir. 1998).
Because a conspiracy does not require the completion of a substantive crime, it does not
matter whether Minor Victim -3 was ever in fact transported as a minor, or whether the elements
of the substantive crimes of transportation an enticement are satisfied as to her. See Salinas, 522
U.S. at 65. What matters is whether the Indictment properly alleges that the defendant agreed to
participate in schemes to transport and entice minors to travel with the intent that an illegal sex act
would be committed, and whether the allegations at issue are relevant and admissible evidence of
that conspiracy. Here, that is plainly the case. As alleged, the defendant's participation in
recruiting and grooming Minor Victim-3 to engage in sex acts as a minor with Epstein during the
period charged in the Indictment, is itself evidence of the defendant's agreements with Epstein to
identify minor girls to entice and transport for purposes of illegal sex acts.57 Moreover, the
57 The defendant takes issue with the Indictment's reference to these sex acts as "abuse" because,
she asserts, Minor Victim-3 was above the age of consent in the United Kingdom at the time they
occurred. The description in the Indictment is factually accurate, however, because Minor Victim -
3 will testify to her subjective experience of these acts with a much older man as traumatic,
exploitative, and abusive at trial. While the Government will be careful to avoid suggesting to the
jury that any consensual act committed after Minor Victim-3 was at or above the age of consent
was itself criminal (as opposed to evidence of the charged conspiracies), to the extent defense
counsel wishes to request a particular limiting instruction or to seek authorization for a particular
line of cross-examination regarding the legality of any sex acts that took place in London, the
appropriate forum to do so is in a motion in litnine.
Government further expects Minor Victim -3 will testify that
, which is probative of the
defendant's intent, in her initial interactions with Minor Victim -3, to entice Minor Victim-3 to
travel and be transported for the purpose of engaging in sexual acts.58 Thus, even if Minor Victim -
3 did not travel as a minor, the events involving Minor Victim-3 outlined in the Indictment
constitute direct and admissible evidence of the agreements between and the relationship of the
defendant and Epstein. Because evidence regarding Minor Vitim-3 is therefore relevant and
admissible at trial, there is no basis to strike these allegations from the Indictment. See Scarpa,
913 F.2d at 1013. Given the relevance of these allegations, the defendant has not satisfied the
"exacting" standard required to justify striking portions of an Indictment. Murgio, 209 F. Supp.
3d at 724 (quoting Smith, 985 F. Supp. 2d at 610). Accordingly, the motion should be denied, or,
at the very least, deferred until "presentation of the Government's evidence at trial" after which
the Court will have a full understanding of how Minor Victim-3's experiences fit into the charged
conspiracies. Mostafa, 965 F. Supp. 2d at 467.
The fact that the Government would be precluded, by virtue of the statute of limitations,
from bringing a charge based exclusively on the experience of Minor Victim -3 is immaterial. It is
well-established that a prosecution for a conspiracy is timely so long as the conspiracy exists and
at least one timely overt act is committed in furtherance of the conspiracy within the applicable
statute of limitations. See United States v. Sahnonese, 352 F.3d 608, 614 (2d Cir. 2003) (citing
Grunewald v. United States, 353 U.S. 391, 396-97 (1957)); United States v. Rutkoske, 506 F.3d
170, 174-75 (2d Cir. 2007); United States v. Mason, 479 F. App'x 397, 398 (2d Cir. 2012).
5S Minor Victim-3 has been a she was invitedil
when she was 18 years old. Regardless, the subsequent invitation demonstrates that the grooming
and sex acts in London were part of conspiracies to entice and transport minors.
Accordingly, overt acts that may, on their own, be untimely can nevertheless serve as direct
evidence of the existence of a charged conspiracy. See, e.g., United States v. Benussi, 216 F. Supp.
2d 299, 301-07, 309 (S.D.N.Y. 2002) (admitting evidence of otherwise untimely acts during
conspiracy trial); cf. United States v. Marcus, 628 F.3d 36, 43 (2d Cir. 2010) (declining to vacate
a conviction on a statute with only prospective application when "the Government presented post-
enactment evidence sufficient to satisfy the elements" in addition to evidence of relevant pre-
enactment conduct). Evidence regarding Minor Victim -3 is thus admissible to prove the existence
of the conspiracy, even if a conviction could not be supported based on her experiences alone.S9
The Government agrees with the defendant that Minor Victim-3 turned 25 before 2003
and, as a result, a substantive count based exclusively on conduct involving Minor Victim-3 is
time-barred. As discussed above, however, the conduct involving Minor Victim-1 and Minor
Victim-2 alleged in the Indictment is timely. Thus, if the jury concludes that the conspiracies
existed, involved either Minor Victim -1 or Minor Victim-2, and included at least one overt act as
to either Minor Victim-1 or Minor Victim-2, then Counts One and Three are not time-barred. See
Salmonese, 352 F.3d at 614. Moreover, and so as to ensure that any count of conviction is based
on timely conduct, the Government would have no objection to an appropriate instruction from
" As a fallback argument, the defense cites United States v. Hsia, 24 F. Supp. 2d 14 (D.D.C. 1998),
in which a District Judge concluded that alleged overt acts involving concealment or "cover-ups"
were not obviously within the scope of the charged conspiracy to defraud the United States by
impairing and impeding the Immigration and Naturalization Service. Id. at 20, 24-26. Although
the Court denied the motion to strike the alleged surplusage, it ordered the prosecution to provide
a bill of particulars regarding the alleged acts of concealment. Id. at 26, 33. The case is readily
distinguishable because the alleged surplusage in Hsia involved a completely different type of
conduct —obstruction —than that charged in the indictment —fraud. Here, by contrast, the
allegations regarding Minor Victim -3 involve conduct that falls within the heartland of the
conspiracy: grooming a minor girl to engage in sex acts with Jeffrey Epstein. Moreover, in both
the Indictment and in this memorandum, the Government has provided extensive detail regarding
Minor Victim -3's anticipated testimony, which avoids any concern that the defendant will be
surprised at trial, which was the animating concern in Hsia. See id. at 33. As such, this motion
does not offer a basis for a bill of particulars.
the Court informing the jury that, to convict on any conspiracy count, it must find at least one overt
act in furtherance of the conspiracy that occurred within the statute of limitations. See Benussi,
216 F. Supp. 2d at 309 (describing a similar jury instruction provided fora conspiracy containing
some allegations that were time-barred and others that were timely).
Second, the allegations regarding Minor Victim-3 in the Indictment are no more
inflammatory or prejudicial than those describing the experiences of Minor Victim-1 and Minor
Victim-2. The references to "sexual abuse" accurately describe Minor Victim-3's experience of
sex acts with Epstein as traumatic, exploitative, and abusive, and she will testify to that effect at
trial. Moreover, because these acts were committed in furtherance of the criminal conspiracies
charged in the Indictment, it is neither misleading nor prejudicial to imply that this activity
involved illegal conduct. More to the point, because evidence regarding Minor Victim-3 "is
admissible and relevant to the charge[s]" contained in Counts One and Three of the Indictment,
the language describing Minor Victim-3's experiences in the Indictment "may not be stricken"
"regardless of how prejudicial the language is .. ." Scarpa, 913 F.2d at 1013 (quoting DePahna,
461 F. Supp. at 797).
Finally, even if Minor Victim-3's experiences did not constitute direct evidence of the
crimes charged—which they do—this same evidence will also be admissible pursuant to Rule
404(b) to prove the defendant's knowledge, intent, and modus operandi. Federal Rule of Evidence
404(b) provides, in pertinent part:
Evidence of any other crime, wrong, or act is not admissible to prove
a person's character in order to show that on a particular occasion
the person acted in accordance with the character. This evidence
may be admissible for another purpose, such as proving motive,
opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, absence
of mistake, or lack of accident.
"[E]vidence of uncharged criminal conduct is not evidence of `other crimes, wrongs, or acts' under
Rule 404(b) if that conduct is `inextricably intertwined with the evidence regarding the charged
offense.'" United States v. Quinones, 511 F.3d 289, 309 (2d Cir. 2007) (quoting United States v.
Towne, 870 F.2d 880, 886 (2d Cir. 1989)). Where "the indictment contains a conspiracy charge,
uncharged acts may be admissible as direct evidence of the conspiracy itself." United States v.
Diaz, 176 F.3d 52, 79 (2d Cir. 1999) (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting United States v.
Miller, 116 F.3d 641, 682 (2d Cir. 1997)); see also United States v. Thai, 29 F.3d 785, 812 (2d Cir.
1994). "An act that is alleged to have been done in furtherance of the alleged conspiracy . is not
an `other' act within the meaning of Rule 404(b); rather, it is part of the very act charged." United
States v. Concepcion, 983 F.2d 369, 392 (2d Cir. 1992).
The Second Circuit "follows the `inclusionary' approach to `other crimes, wrongs, or acts'
evidence, under which such evidence is admissible unless it is introduced for the sole purpose of
showing the defendant's bad character, or unless it is overly prejudicial under Fed. R. Evid. 403
or not relevant under Fed. R. Evid. 402." United States v. Pascarella, 84 F.3d 61, 69 (2d Cir.
1996) (internal citation omitted); see also United States v. Paulino, 445 F.3d 211, 221 (2d Cir.
2006); United States v. Zackson, 12 F.3d 1178, 1182 (2d Cir. 1993). Under this approach,
uncharged acts are admissible in a conspiracy case where they are used to (i) explain the
development of the illegal relationship between coconspirators; (ii) explain the mutual criminal
trust that existed between coconspirators; and/or (iii) complete the story of the crime charged. See
Diaz, 176 F.3d at 80; United States v. Pipola, 83 F.3d 556, 566 (2d Cir. 1996); United States v.
Rosa, 11 F.3d 315, 334 (2d Cir. 1993). In addition, evidence of "other acts" is admissible under
Rule 404(b) if it (i) is advanced for a proper purpose, "such as proving motive, opportunity, intent,
preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, absence of mistake, or lack of accident," Fed. R. Evid.
404(b)(2); (ii) is relevant to the crime for which the defendant is on trial; (iii) has probative value
that is not substantially outweighed by any unfair prejudicial effect; and (iv) is admitted with a
limiting instruction to the July, if requested. See Huddleston v. United States, 485 U.S. 681, 691-
92 (1988); United States v. LaFlam, 369 F.3d 153, 156 (2d Cir. 2004).
Here, evidence regarding the defendant's interactions with Minor Victim-3 is admissible
to prove the defendant's knowledge, intent, and modus operandi, all of which are permissible
purposes under Rule 404(b). Testimony regarding the defendant's efforts to recruit and encourage
Minor Victim -3 to engage in sex acts with Epstein in the context of massages establishes that the
defendant knew of Epstein's attraction to minor girls and knew that Epstein used massage to
initiate sexual contact with minor girls. Similarly, testimony regarding the defendant's interactions
with Minor Victim -3, including how the defendant befriended Minor Victim -3 and then
encouraged her to engage in sex acts with Epstein, establishes that the defendant intended for
minor girls to engage in sex acts with Epstein when she befriended them, invited them to travel,
and arranged for their travel.60 Finally, the details of how the defendant interacted with Minor
Victim-3 demonstrates that the defendant had a specific modus operandi when grooming minor
girls to engage in sexual activity with Epstein. As with Minor Victim-1 and Minor Victim-2, the
defendant asked minor girls details about their lives, normalized sexual topics and activity, and
used her presence as an adult woman to convince minor girls that the sexual activity Epstein
initiated was normal and acceptable. "The similarity sufficient to admit evidence of past acts to
establish a recurring modus operandi need not be complete; it is enough that the characteristics
relied upon are sufficiently idiosyncratic to permit a fair inference of a pattern's existence." United
60 Such evidence is particularly probative when it seems apparent from defense filings that the
defendant plans to argue that even if she were somehow involved in transporting or traveling with
minors, she had no knowledge or intent that they engage in sexual conduct with Epstein.
States v. Sliker, 751 F.2d 477, 487 (2d Cir. 1984). Here, the defendant's specific and unique
approach to preparing minor girls to engage in sex acts with Epstein demonstrate the existence of
such an idiosyncratic pattern warranting admission.
Other acts evidence is, like all other evidence, inadmissible under Rule 403 if its probative
value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice. See Fed. R. Evid. 403.
Evidence is unfairly prejudicial, however, "only when it tends to have some adverse effect upon a
defendant beyond tending to prove the fact or issue that justified its admission into evidence."
United States v. Figueroa, 618 F.2d 934, 943 (2d Cir. 1980). Other acts evidence is typically not
unfairly prejudicial where it is not "any more sensational or disturbing than the crimes" with which
the defendant has been charged. United States v. Rolan-Zapata, 916 F.2d 795, 804 (2d Cir. 1990).
Here, as already discussed, evidence regarding Minor Victim-3's experiences with the defendant
and Epstein are no more inflammatory or upsetting than those of Minor Victim-1 and Minor
Victim-2. Those experiences include a wide range of abuse at the hands of Epstein, including
abuse that the defendant witnessed and participated in herself. Evidence regarding similar events
involving Minor Victim-3, who was of a similar age and experienced similar types of sexual
contact, is no more "sensational or disturbing" than the other acts detailed in the Indictment. Id.
Evidence of other acts involving the grooming or abuse of minor victims is regularly admitted for
similar purposes in cases where charges allege sexual activity with minors. See, e.g., United States

v. Vickers, 708 F. App'x 732, 737 (2d Cir. 2017) ("As to the testimony concerning Vickers'
`grooming' of his victims, we conclude that such evidence was admissible even under Rule 404(b),
because it was probative of Vickers' knowledge of how to secure adolescent boys' trust so that he
could sexually abuse them. We identify no abuse of discretion in the district court's decision to
admit all of the challenged testimony [regarding uncharged acts of sexual abuse] under Rule
403."); United States v. McDarrah, 351 F. App'x 558, 563 (2d Cir. 2009) (affirming admission
pursuant to Rule 404(b) of defendant's "e-mail responses to the Craigslist advertisements" for
erotic services because the e-mails "were relevant to his knowledge and intent, because he wrote
those emails to girls he knew could be minors (he enthusiastically indicated that girls younger than
18 are acceptable) and his e-mails showed his interest in actual sexual conduct"); United States v.
Brand, No. 04 Cr. 194 (PKL), 2005 WL 77055, at *5 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 12, 2005) (admitting
"evidence that Brand exhibited an interest in child erotica and child pornography on the intemet
in the period leading up to the charged conduct" under Rule 404(b) because evidence was
"pertinent to whether he used the intemet in an attempt to engage in sexual conduct with" victim).
Accordingly, Rule 403 does not bar the admission of evidence regarding Minor Victim -3,
especially given its probative value in demonstrating the defendant's knowledge, intent, and modus
operandi.
In sum, because evidence regarding Minor Victim -3's experience is admissible both as
direct evidence of the conspiracies charged in Counts One and Three and pursuant to Rule 404(b),
there is no basis to strike the allegations regarding Minor Victim -3 from the Indictment.

IX. The Defendant's Motion to Dismiss Count One or Count Three as Multiplicitous Is
Premature
The defendant moves to dismiss Counts One or Three on the ground that they are
multiplicitous. (Def. Mot. 8). Because the Second Circuit has made clear that a multiplicity
challenge does not become timely until after trial, this motion should be denied as premature.

A. Relevant Facts
Count One charges the defendant with participating in a conspiracy, in violation of 18
U.S.C. § 371, to transport minors with the intent to commit an illegal sex act, in violation of 18
U.S.C. § 2422. See Indictment ¶¶ 9-11. Count Three charges the defendant with participating in
a conspiracy, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371, to entice minors to travel with the intent to commit
an illegal sex act, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a). See Indictment ¶t 15-17. In other words,
Count One and Count Three charge the defendant with agreeing to commit two separate and
distinct federal crimes.
B. Applicable Law
The Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution "protects against
multiple punishments for the same offense." North Carolina v. Pearce, 395 U.S. 711, 717 (1969).
Accordingly, a defendant cannot be sentenced for multiplicitous charges covering the same crime.
"An indictment is multiplicitous when it charges a single offense as an offense multiple times, in
separate counts, when, in law and fact, only one crime has been committed." United States v.
Chacko, 169 F.3d 140, 145 (2d Cir. 1999); see also United States v. Jones, 482 F.3d 60, 72 (2d
Cir. 2006) ("A claim of multiplicity cannot succeed, however, 'unless the charged offenses are the
same in fact and in law."' (quoting United States v. Estrada, 320 F.3d 173, 180 (2d Cir. 2003)).
Although the Double Jeopardy Clause does not protect against simultaneous prosecutions for the
same offense, a defendant does have a right not to be punished twice for the same crime. United
States v. Joseplzberg, 459 F.3d 350, 355 (2d Cir. 2006) (per curiam). Accordingly, "[i]f the jury
convicts on more than one multiplicitous count, the defendant's right not to suffer multiple
punishments for the same offense will be protected by having the court enter judgment on only
one of the multiplicitous counts." Id. Similarly, where the judgment of conviction has already
been entered on multiplicitous counts, that right is protected by vacating the convictions on all but
one count. Id.
The Second Circuit has clarified that District Courts should not rule on a motion to dismiss
a charge on multiplicity grounds until the time of sentencing. See id. (vacating district court's
dismissal of count as multiplicitous prior to trial, as such a determination before trial is "at best
premature"). Among other reasons, courts look to "the record as a whole in determining whether
an indictment is in fact multiplicitous," and the record cannot be fully established until trial is
complete. United States v. McCouny, 562 F.3d 458, 469 (2d Cir. 2009). Additionally, because
double jeopardy is meant to protect a defendant from successive punishments for the same offense,
a multiplicitous count does not violate the Clause unless and until sentence is imposed. See
Josephberg, 459 F.3d at 355 ("Where there has been no prior conviction or acquittal, the Double
Jeopardy Clause does not protect against simultaneous prosecutions for the same offense, so long
as no more than one punishment is eventually imposed.").
Following the Second Circuit's directive, courts in this Circuit regularly defer ruling on a
multiplicity motion until after the conclusion of trial. See, e.g., United States v. Halkbank,No. 15

Cr. 867 (RMB), 2020 WL 5849512, at *9 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. I, 2020) (denying pretrial motion to
dismiss multiplicitous count and noting that "lc]ourts in this Circuit have routinely denied pre-
trial motions to dismiss potentially multiplicitous counts as premature." (quoting United States v.
Medina, No. 13 Cr. 272 (PGG), 2014 WL 3057917, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. July 7, 2014)1); United States

v. Dwnitru, No. 18 Cr. 243 (LAK), 2018 WL 3407703, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. June 26, 2018) (denying
pretrial motion to dismiss multiplicitous count in light of "the Circuit's controlling view that the
question of multiplicitousness is properly considered only at a later point in the proceedings");
United States v. Mostafa, 965 F. Supp. 2d 451, 464 (S.D.N.Y. 2013) ("[M]ultiplicity is properly
addressed by the trial court at the sentencing stage."); United States v. Ghavami, No. 10 Cr. 1217
(KMW), 2012 WL 2878126, at *11 (S.D.N.Y. July 13, 2012) ("To the extent that the Indictment
alleges more than one conspiracy . . ., Defendants' multiplicity challenge is premature. Should
the jury convict Defendants on what the Court ultimately determines to be multiplicitous counts,
the Court will enter judgment on only one of the multiplicitous convictions." (citations omitted));
United States v. Rivera, No. 09 Cr. 619 (SJF), 2011 WL 1429125, at *4 (E.D.N.Y. Apr. 13, 2011)
("Since it is possible that the jury will convict defendants on only one (1) of the respective counts
that they allege are multiplicitous, and acquit defendants on all of the counts with which they allege
that count is multiplicitous, the issue of whether the counts are multiplicitous in violation of the
Double Jeopardy Clause is premature at the pretrial stage.").
C. Discussion
The defendant's motion to dismiss Counts One or Three of the Indictment as multiplicitous
is, at best, premature. Consistent with the directive of the Second Circuit, this Court should defer
ruling on this motion until after the completion of trial. The additional time will ensure that the
full factual record is developed before the Court conducts the multiplicity analysis, and the motion
may become moot depending on the jury's verdict.
First, the Court cannot conduct the multiplicity analysis before hearing all of the evidence
regarding the charges contained in the Indictment. Prior to trial, the record will not be fully
developed, and the Court cannot conduct the necessary analysis to determine whether the counts
are in fact multiplicitous. Consistent with the directive of the Second Circuit and the consistent
practice in this District, the Court should defer conducting any multiplicity analysis until after
hearing all of the evidence at trial. See Josepliberg, 459 F.3d at 355.
Second, the motion may become moot because it is possible that the jury could conclude
that the defendant is guilty of one of the charged conspiracies but not guilty of the other. That is
because each charged conspiracy alleges that the defendant agreed to violate a different criminal
statute. Count One alleges that the defendant agreed to transport minors with the intent that they
engage in illegal sex acts. Count Three alleges that the defendant agreed to entice minors to travel
with the intent that they engage in illegal sex acts. In other words, Count One requires proof of an
agreement to transport, while Count Three requires proof of an agreement to entice. Transportation
does not necessarily require enticement, and likewise enticement to travel does not necessarily
require transportation. See United States v. Griffith, No. 99 Cr. 786 (HB), 2000 WL 1253265, at
*4 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 5, 2000) (denying post-trial motion to dismiss as multiplicitous 18 U.S.C.
§ 2422 transportation charge and 18 U.S.C. § 2423(a) enticement charge involving same alleged
conduct and noting "[t]hat persuasion and transportation involve proof of different facts is hardly
contentious").
Here, it is possible that the jury could conclude, after hearing all the evidence, that the
defendant agreed to transport one or more minors interstate, but that she did not agree to entice
minors to travel. For example, the jury could theoretically conclude that although the defendant
agreed to arrange transportation for a minor victim, the defendant herself did not agree to persuade
or entice a minor victim to travel. Likewise, the jury could theoretically conclude that the
defendant agreed to entice, or encourage, one or more minors to travel interstate, but she did not
agree to actually transport or assist in the transportation itself. Although the Government expects
to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant in fact agreed both to entice and to transport
one or more minor victims, it is possible that the jury may reach a different conclusion. Depending
on the inferences the jury draws from the evidence presented at trial, it could convict on one
conspiracy count while acquitting on the other, or it could conclude that the defendant agreed both
to transport and to entice, in which case it could convict on both counts. That possibility means
that a motion to dismiss counts as multiplicitous is premature. Because the Government has the
discretion to present to the jury both the theory that the defendant agreed to transport and the theory
that the defendant agreed to entice, the defense motion is premature. See Josephberg, 459 F.3d at
355 ("It is well established that '[w]hether to prosecute and what charge to file or bring before a
grand jury are decisions that generally rest in the prosecutor's discretion,' and 'a defendant has no
constitutional right to elect which of two applicable federal statutes shall be the basis of his
indictment and prosecution . . .'" (brackets and ellipses in original) (quoting United States v.
Batchelder, 442 U.S. 114, 124 (1979)).
Only after the Court has heard all of the evidence at trial and received the jury's verdict
will the defense motion be ripe. Accordingly, the motion should be denied as premature.

X. The Defendant's Various Disclosure Motions Should be Denied
Maxwell's motions also include an assortment of requests for orders requiring the
Government to make various disclosures, all of which are meritless or, at best, premature.

A. Bill of Particulars Is Not Warranted
First, the defendant moves for a bill of particulars, demanding the Government set out an
array of details regarding the Government's theory of its case and anticipated witness testimony.
The defendant, like all defendants, is entitled to sufficient information to understand the charges
against her, to prepare a defense, and to protect against double jeopardy. However, the
Government has provided such information, and much more, in the Indictment, extensive
discovery, and various pretrial filings, including this memorandum. The defendant will also
receive trial exhibits, a witness list, and Jencks Act material reasonably in advance of trial. As
such, she has not established an entitlement to a bill of particulars under well-established governing
law.

1. Applicable Law
The proper purpose of a bill of particulars under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 7(f) is
"to provide defendant with information about the details of the charge against him if this is
necessary to the preparation of his defense, and to avoid prejudicial surprise at trial." United States
v. Torres, 901 F.2d 205, 234 (2d Cir. 1990), abrogated on other grounds by United States v.
Marcus, 628 F.3d 36, 41 (2d Cir.2010) (emphasis added) (internal quotation mark omitted).
Accordingly, "[a] bill of particulars is required 'only where the charges of the indictment are so
general that they do not advise the defendant of the specific acts of which he is accused!" United
States v. Walsh, 194 F.3d 37, 47 (2d Cir. 1999) (quoting Torres, 901 F.2d at 234); see United
States v. Mahabub, No. 13 Cr. 908 (AJN), 2014 WL 4243657, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 26, 2014).
In exercising its broad discretion to determine whether the charges are so general that they
require supplementation through a bill of particulars, the Court should consider not just the text of
the Indictment, but also discovery and other information supplied to the defendant to date. See
United States v. Bortnovsky, 820 F.2d 572, 574 (2d Cir. 1987); see also, e.g., Pierre -Louis, 2018
WL 4043140, at *7 (denying request for bill of particulars where indictment charged sex
trafficking conspiracy spanning two decades because indictment and discovery "would suggest
that defendant has enough information to apprise him of the charges with enough precision to
enable him to prepare a defense, avoid unfair surprise at trial, and preclude a second prosecution
for the same offense"); United States v. Block, No. 16 Cr. 595 (JPO), 2017 WL 1608905, at *6-7
(S.D.N.Y. Apr. 28, 2017) (denying request for bill of particulars as to alleged fraud and unindicted
co-conspirators where indictment sufficiently advised defendant of nature of charges against him
and described with specificity acts he allegedly committed, nature of conspiracy, and explained in
language closely tracking statute crimes alleged); United States v. Monserrate, No. 10 Cr. 965
(CM), 2011 WL 3480957, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 4, 2011) (denying request for bill of particulars
where discovery and indictment was "sufficient to apprise the defendant of the charge" and to
allow him to prepare for trial); United States v. Trippe, 171 F. Supp. 2d 230, 240 (S.D.N.Y. 2001)
(denying bill of particulars request in stock fraud case where indictment was fifteen pages long
and substantial discovery had been provided).
Although the Government cannot provide "mountains of documents to defense counsel"
as a substitute for a bill of particulars where one would otherwise be required, see Bortnovsky, 820
F.2d at 575, the provision of voluminous discovery in combination with some guidance about what
is most relevant can vitiate a need for further particulars, see, e.g., United States v. Mandell, 710
F. Supp. 2d 368, 385 (S.D.N.Y. 2010) (denying request for particularization of alleged
misrepresentations where the indictment was thirty-four pages long and Government had provided
voluminous, organized discovery). In no event should volume of discovery alone warrant a bill of
particulars; "[w]hile [a] [c]ourt may sympathize with counsel's task of reviewing a large quantity
of materials that continue to be produced," that concern is addressed by granting the defense
sufficient time in which to conduct the review in advance of trial. See United States v. Levy, No.
11 Cr. 62 (PAC), 2013 WL 664712, at *13 (S.D.N.Y. Feb. 25, 2013).
A bill of particulars would undoubtedly be helpful to the defense in any case. But "the law
does not impose upon the Government an obligation to preview its case or expose its legal
theories," United States v. Leonelli, 428 F. Supp. 880, 882 (S.D.N.Y. 1977), and therefore "[t]tle
ultimate test must be whether the information sought is necessary, not whether it is helpful."
United States v. Maio! 165 F. Supp. 2d 558, 569 (S.D.N.Y. 2001) (emphasis added); Mahabub,
2014 WL 4243657, at *2 ("The purpose of a bill of particulars is to ensure that a defendant has the
information necessary to prepare a defense, not to turn over all information that would aid the
defendant."); United States v. Rittweger, 259 F. Supp. 2d 275, 292-93 (S.D.N.Y. 2003) (denying
bill of particulars request as "'an impermissible attempt to compel the Government to provide the
evidentiary details of its case' (quoting United States v. Biaggi, 675 F. Supp. 790, 810 (S.D.N.Y.
1987)).
A bill of particulars should not be misused to compel the Government to disclose "the
manner in which it will attempt to prove the charges, the precise manner in which the defendant
committed the crime charged, or a preview of the Government's evidence or legal theories."
Mitlof, 165 F. Supp. 2d at 569; see also Torres, 901 F.2d at 234 ("Acquis i t ion of evidentiary detail
is not the function of the bill of particulars.' (quoting Hemphill v. United States, 392 F.2d 45, 49
(8th Cir. 1968))). The "wheres, whens and with whoms"' are "beyond the scope of a bill of
particulars." Mitlof, 165 F. Supp. 2d at 569 (citing Torres, 901 F.2d at 233-34; Jimenez, 824 F.
Supp. 351, 363 (S.D.N.Y. 1993)); see also, e.g., United States v. D 'Amico, 734 F. Supp. 2d 321,
335 (S.D.N.Y. 2010) ("A bill of particulars is not a general investigative tool, a discovery device
or a means to compel the government to disclose evidence or witnesses to be offered prior to trial.'
(quoting United States v. Gibson, 175 F. Supp. 2d 532, 537 (S.D.N.Y. 2001))); United States v.
Bellomo, 263 F. Supp. 2d 561, 580 (E.D.N.Y. 2003) ("A bill of particulars is not designed to:
obtain the government's evidence; restrict the government's evidence prior to trial; assist the
defendant's investigation; obtain the precise way in which the government intends to prove its
case; interpret its evidence for the defendant, or disclose its legal theory."); United States v. Henry,
861 F. Supp. 1190, 1197 (S.D.N.Y. 1994) ("This instrument should not function to disclose
evidence, witnesses, and legal theories to be offered by the Government at trial or as a general
investigative tool for the defense.").
There are good reasons why bills of particulars are warranted only where the allegations in
the indictment, as supplemented by discovery and other disclosures, are so general as to render it
impossible to prepare a defense. Because "a bill of particulars confines the Government's proof
to particulars furnished," it can "restrict unduly the Government's ability to present its case."
Henry, 861 F. Supp. at 1197; see also Mit(of, 2014 WL 4243657, at *2 (recognizing that "care
must be taken" because "[t]he government's presentation of evidence at trial is limited to the
particulars contained in the bill"); United States v. Samsonov, No. 07 Cr. 1198 (CM), 2009 WL
176721, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 23, 2009) ("The vehicle of a bill of particulars serves to inform a
defendant of the nature of the charge, when he is otherwise insufficiently informed, and must not
be misused to compel disclosure of how much the Government can prove, nor to foreclose the
Government from using proof it may develop as the trial approaches."). Moreover, where the
Government's provision of particulars is tantamount to an itemized preview of its proof, it creates
the very real danger that a defendant will "tailor her testimony to explain away the Government's
case." Henry, 861 F. Supp. at 1197. These concerns animate the rule that "if the defendant has
been given adequate notice of the charges against her and can prepare fully for trial with reasonably
diligent efforts, the Government cannot be required to disclose additional details about its case."
Id.
2. Discussion
There is no basis for a bill of particulars in this case. The charges against the defendant
are clear from the face of the Indictment, which provides significant detail regarding the charged
crimes. As is apparent from the 18-page Indictment, the charges concern the defendant's
participation in conspiracies to transport and entice minor girls to travel with the intent that they
engage in illegal sex acts with Jeffrey Epstein from 1994 through 1997, and the defendant's attempt
to cover up that conduct during her civil deposition testimony in 2016. Specifically, the Indictment
makes plain that the defendant is charged with engaging in a conspiracy to transport minor girls
with intent that they engage in sexual activity with Epstein, engaging in a conspiracy to entice
minor girls to travel with the intent that they engage in sexual activity with Epstein, aiding and
abetting the transportation and enticement of a particular minor girl interstate for the purpose of
engaging in sex acts with Epstein, and lying about those same crimes during her 2016 civil
deposition testimony. The charged time periods are made plain in each count, as is the statute she
is accused of violating.
The speaking Indictment in this case goes above and beyond a mere recitation of the
elements of each offense by detailing the defendant's specific role in the crimes charged. Among
other things, it specifies three minor victims in particular and describes the steps the defendant
took with respect to each as part of the charged crimes. See, e.g., Indictment ¶ 7. Additionally,
the Indictment details the types of sex acts that Epstein committed with the minor victims as part
of the charged crimes and the locations where those acts occurred. See, e.g., id.1 5-6. In this way,
the Indictment makes clear the Government's theory that the defendant groomed three minor girls
to engage in sex acts in Florida, New Mexico, New York, and London with Epstein between 1994
and 1997. The Indictment further specifies during which portion of that period each of those three
victims interacted with the defendant and Epstein as minors. See id. 17. Additionally, the
Indictment identifies the precise answers that the Government alleges constituted perjury, and
alleges facts, in the earlier portions of the Indictment, that indicate how and why the Government
will seek to prove the answers were false. Compare id. ¶¶ 21, 23 with id. ¶¶ 1-11. Simply put,
this is not a case in which the allegations in the Indictment "are so general that they do not advise
the defendant of the specific acts of which he is accused." Walsh, 194 F.3d at 47 (internal quotation
mark omitted) (quoting Torres, 901 F.2d at 234). Thus, the Indictment itself provides a sufficient
basis to deny the defendant's motion in its entirety. See, e.g., United States v. Bonventre, 646 F
App'x 73, 79 (2d Cir. 2016) ("c[E]videntiary detail is not the function of the bill of particulars.'
Particulars are necessary only where indictment charges are `so general that they do not advise the
defendant of the specific acts of which he is accused.'" (internal citation omitted) (quoting Torres,
901 F.2d at 234; United States v. Chen, 378 F.3d 151, 163 (2d Cir. 2004))); United States v. Wedd,
No. 15 Cr. 616 (KBF), 2016 WL 1055737, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 10, 2016) (denying motion for
bill of particulars where "the Indictment is a `speaking' Indictment that provides a significant
amount of detail as to the Government's theory of the case and the nature of the proof that will
underlie the charges at trial").
Additional particularity relating to the details of the counts in the Indictment might be
helpful for the defendant, but that is both true in every case and not the appropriate standard.
Instead, the inquiry is properly focused on whether the information already available to her is so
general that a bill of particulars is necessary to the preparation of her defense. Plainly it is not. In
addition to the speaking Indictment, the defendant has received over 2.7 million pages of discovery
in this case. Although that is a high volume of discovery, it is clear from the defense's own motion
that the defense has apparently already reviewed that material (at least in significant part),
identified relevant materials therein, and is aware of their relevance to the allegations in the
Indictment. (See, e.g., Def. Mot. 10 at 6). Indeed, much of the discovery is text searchable, and
the time period that each document relates to is readily ascertainable.
In this vein, the defendant has received
ctment, w
=IMIIMIPItiding flights with the defendant and flightsMill
n 61 flect instawhen one of the inif
61 Records of commercial flights were unavailable by the time the Government opened its
investigation in this case. Accordingly, the Government has no records of commercial flights that
the defendant, Epstein, or any victims may have taken during the relevant period.
Indictment traveled on the private plane during the period alleged in the Indictment. Business
records from a particular educational institution reflect instances when Epstein and the defendant
were present at a summer camp that same minor victim attended, which line up with flight records
confirming they were in the same summer the victim attended the camp
in 1994. Diary entries identify the perioan a different minor victim identified in the
Indictment first met Epstein, and customs a indicate times in 1994 whendiostein and tS
defendant traveled internationally cma another minor victim'  11
discovery also incleontemporary phar of each of the three villINVege in
Indialfrom th antj and the Government has provided the defense with the
birth month and year of each minor victim. 62
In other words, as the Government has previously indicated, the discovery provides the
defendant with more than sufficient information about the three minor victims to permit her to
prepare for trial. The discovery also provides the defense the ability to identify specific private
plane flights that are relevant to the Indictment. Any remaining detail regarding the specifics of
abuse, particular interactions, and additional trips will come from witness testimony. As is to be
expected when describing events more than two decades in the past, that testimony will provide
approximate time periods when events occurred, rather than specific dates. Given the information
the defendant already has from the discovery, the Indictment, and the Government's court filings
(including this memorandum), any additional detail would essentially serve as early Jencks Act
production, allowing the defendant to tailor any testimony to the Government's case. The
discovery gives the defense ample information to assist in its investigation, and given the defense's
62 In this memorandum, the Government has also clarified that Minor Victim -3 was 17 years old
at the time of the events described in the Indictment involving her. See Section VIII, supra.
apparent ability to understand who the three victims are from the productions, there is no real
concern that the defense will waste efforts conducting any such investigation before receiving
Jencks Act material 63
Moreover, with respect to the perjury counts, to the extent there could plausibly be any
remaining ambiguity about the nature of the charges, the Government has addressed and resolved
such ambiguity in responding to the instant motions. In this memorandum, the Government has
summarized how the defendant's false statements during her deposition were material to the
pending civil litigation. See Section V, supra. Perhaps more importantly, the defendant personally
participated in that civil litigation, and she is undoubtedly quite familiar with it.
Together, the discovery productions, briefing in which the Government has described
aspects of its evidence and theory (see, e.g., Government Memorandum in Opposition to Renewed
Bail Motion, Dec. 18, 2020, Dkt. No. 100, at 8-12), the contents of this memorandum, and the
details contained in the Indictment more than adequately inform the defendant of the charges
against her. This is simply not a case where the "relevance of key events [are] shrouded in
mystery." See Bortnovsky, 820 F.2d at 574. Accordingly, the Court should deny the motion for a
bill of particulars.

B. The Defendant's Requests for Early Production of a Witness List and Jencks
Act Material Should Be Denied
1. Applicable Law
Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 16 "does not require the Government to furnish the
names and addresses of its witnesses in general." United States v. Bejasa, 904 F.2d 137, 139 (2d
63 Although the victims' identities are clear from the discovery, and the defendant's motion makes
clear that she strongly suspects their identities, there is no basis to require the Government to turn
over the names of its witnesses, including its victim-witnesses in advance of its Jencks Act
production, which is customary in this District. See Section X.B., infra.
Cir. 1990). Thus, "Iiin the absence of a specific showing that disclosure [of a witness list] [is]
both material to the preparation of [the] defense and reasonable in light of the circumstances
surrounding [the] case,' the request for a witness list should be denied." United States v. Russo,
483 F. Supp. 2d 301, 309 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) (quoting Bejasa, 904 F.2d at 139-40). "Courts in the
Second Circuit typically deny motions for the early disclosure of witness lists where, as here,
Defendants have not made a specific showing of need." United States v. Rivera, No. 16 Cr. 175
(LGS), 2017 WL 1843302, at *2 (S.D.N.Y. May 8, 2017). The claim that "given the complexity
of the case, disclosure of the government witness list will level the playing field" amounts to an
"abstract statement of need" that does not justify provision of a witness list. Russo, 483 F. Supp.
2d at 309.
The Jencks Act, 18 U.S.C. § 3500, covers disclosure of statements or reports made by
Government witnesses, and the rule mandates that such materials not be the subject of discovery
or inspection "until said witness has testified on direct examination in the trial of the case." 18
U.S.C. § 3500(a); see also United States v. Coppa, 267 F.3d 132, 145 (2d Cir. 2001) ("[T]he Jencks
Act prohibits a District Court from ordering the pretrial disclosure of witness statements."); United
States v. Thompson, No. 13 Cr. 378 (AJN), 2013 WL 6246489, at *9 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 3, 2013)
(denying request for early production of Jencks Act material in light of Coppa).
Typically in this District, and as is the case here, the Government confirms that it will
produce 3500 material and Giglio (or impeachment) material reasonably in advance of trial, and
will engage in good faith discussions with the defense regarding a schedule for pretrial disclosures.
See United States v. Sergentakis, No. 05 Cr. 230 (JFK), 2005 WL 1994014, at *1-2 (S.D.N.Y.
Aug. 17, 2005) C' 18 U.S.C. § 3500(b) calls for production of Government witness statements after
the witness `has testified on direct examination.' The Government response . .. that '[c]onsistent
with the regular practice in this District, the Government intends to make Section 3500 material
available to the defense at the same time as impeachment material, [and that] in order to avoid any
delay in the trial, the Government will produce such material sufficiently in advance of each
Government witness's testimony' ... is more than adequate."); United States v. Gallo, No. 98 Cr.
338 (JGK), 1999 WL 9848, at *8 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 11, 1999) ("[T]he Government has indicated that
it is aware of its obligations under Giglio .. . and the Jencks Act and that it will provide the required
information to the defendants in accordance with its responsibilities under Giglio and the Jencks
Act sufficiently in advance of each witness's testimony to allow adequate time to prepare for cross-
examination. These representations are sufficient.").

2. Discussion
Trial is still more than four months away. The degree of complexity to this case, and the
volume of discovery, is on par with other recent high-profile trials in this District, and in those
cases witnesses have typically been disclosed approximately three to four weeks before trial. E.g.,
Gallo, 17 Cr. 686 (LAK); Blaszczak, 17 Cr. 357 (LAK); Skelos, 15 Cr. 317 (KMW); Silver, 15 Cr.
93 (VEC); Uthricht, 14 Cr. 68 (KBF). As the Government has noted for some time now, the
Government intends to match or even go above and beyond that practice in this case. Specifically,
the Government has offered repeatedly to provide non-testifying witness statements to the defense
as much as eight weeks before trial, thereby allowing extra time for the defense to determine
whether it wishes to call any of the witnesses the Government does not intend to present at trial,
and to provide testifying witness statements and Giglio material as much as four weeks in advance
of trial. Given that the defense has already been able to initiate its investigation of the charges,
and given that the discovery makes clear who the three minor victims are, eight weeks should be
ample time to review non-testifying witness statements, and four weeks is more than enough time
to review the statements of testifying witnesses. The Government remains open to engaging in
good faith discussions with the defense to mutually agree on a schedule for reciprocal pretrial
disclosures. 64 Accordingly, the motion for a witness list and early production of Jencks Act
material should be denied.
C. The Defendant's Additional Requests for Disclosure Should Be Denied
The defendant also makes a variety of motions seeking disclosures to which she is not
entitled, all of which should be denied.
First, the defendant requests denti fled as "A"
Fin a 2 e to a
buash subpoenas , which the defense attached to their motion as Exhibit B. (Def. Mot.
10 at 7-8). The defense assumes that because asposiasaily_ MAIM
thereby, according to the defense, rendering any record of
those interviews exculpatory. But that defense theory rests on a faulty premise. The Government
has reviewed the document memorializing and
confirmed that it inculpates the defendant and contains nothing exculpatory. The Government has
also reviewed l it,±I I! iii and
confirmed that it also inculpates the defendant. The Government has, however, identified a single
line in that could arguably be considered helpful to
the defense. 65 With the possible exception of that one line, there is nothing exculpatory contained
64 The Government has requested reciprocal discovery from the defendant and, to date, she has
produced nothing.
65  In articular, Mr/Wf2 of the notes from this 206g linMew, a single line
ted, "rumor is that JE is gay," an apparent reference to Jeffrey Epstein's rumored sexual
in made by ss "M" in 2006. Accordingly, the records of
these interviews constitute witness statements covered by the Jencks Act and are not subject to
disclosure by statute until after each witness has completed direct examination at trial. See 18
U.S.C. § 3500. As noted above, however, the Government fully intends to provide all Jencks Act
material of both testifying and non-testifying witnesses, which will of course include the records
relating to these interviews, to the defense multiple weeks in advance of trial. The Government
respectfully submits that is sufficient to meet its obligations with respect to these documents, and
the defendant's motion for their immediate disclosure should be denied.
Second, the defendant's request for an unredacted copy of the FBI report attached to the
Defense Motion as Exhibit C should be denied as moot because the Government has already
produced an unredacted copy of that report to the defense. (Def. Mot. 10 at 8-9). Specifically, the
document was produced without redactions under bates numbers SDNY_GM_00380550 through
SDNY_ GM_ 00380554 as part of the Government's discovery production dated November 9,
2020." This motion should accordingly be denied as moot.
Third, the defendant's request for unredacted copies of the FBI report regarding
is based purely on her speculation that the redacted portions
of those materials contain exculpatory information. (Def. Mot. 10 at 8-9). Once again, the
61.1.  Out of an abundance of caution, today the Government has informed defense counsel
of witness "M." of this single line
" Notably, the unredacted report does not contain
demonstrating that defense counsel's speculation about
supposed Brady material lurking beneath redactions is inaccurate. The redacted copy defense
counsel attached as Exhibit C was recovered during the execution of a search warrant for one of
Epstein's devices and was produced to defense counsel in the form in which it was recovered from
the device. In other words, defense counsel has received two copies of this same document: the
redacted version that Epstein had on one of his devices, and the unredacted version from the FBI's
files.
angwilmnaiiiiipiesses
Government has reviewed the full report and confirmed that there is nothing exculpatory contained
therein. To the contrary, the report inculpates the defendant. Accordingly, the defendant is not
entitled to its immediate disclosure. The Government will produce an unredacted version of this
document together with all other witness statements in advance of tria1.67
Fourth, the defense requests production of pages from a personal diary that is in the custody
of a civilian third party and is not in the custody or control of the Government. (Def. Mot. 10 at
10). Leaving aside the fact that the defense cites no authority for the proposition that the
Government has an obligation to obtain the personal papers of a third party, see United States v.
Collins, 409 F. Supp. 3d 228, 239 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) ("The Government's `Brady obligations extend
only to materials within prosecutors' possession, custody or control or, in appropriate cases, that
of the Department of Justice, perhaps another part of the Executive Branch, or a comparable state
authority involved in the federal prosecution.'" (quoting United States v. Blaszczak, 308 F. Supp.
3d 736, 742 (S.D.N.Y. 2018))), the Government has already represented that it has asked the third
party at issue about the materials the defendant purports to seek and that no such materials exist.
In particular, to the extent the defense is concerned with whether there are diary entries from the
spring of 1996, the Government has already indicated in response to the defendant's second bail
motion that it is aware of none. (See Dkt. No. 100 at 11 n. 2 ("Because this victim stopped writing
in her journal about a month after that first meeting with Epstein, there are no entries regarding the
subsequent trip she took months later to visit Epstein, during which she met the defendant. This
victim provided the Government with copies of her journal entries relating to Epstein and informed
the Government that the remaining entries are personal in nature and have nothing to do with
67 As is the case with the other redacted document referenced in this motion, the redacted copy
defense counsel attached as Exhibit D was recovered during the execution of a search warrant for
one of Epstein's devices and was produced to defense counsel in the form in which it was
recovered from the device.
Epstein or the defendant.")). In other words, the defendant again seeks supposedly exculpatory
evidence that does not exist. The defendant offers no basis on which to conclude that this
representation is false or that any such evidence does in fact exist. As such, this motion should be
denied.
Fifth, the defendant asks this Court, again without citing any legal authority, to order the
Government to produce copies of all subpoenas it has issued for the defendant's records as part of
its investigation in this case. (Def. Mot. 10 at 11). This incredibly broad request is nothing more
than a fishing expedition inappropriately seeking the details of investigative requests made through
the grand jury process. The defense has cited no legal basis for the Court to direct the Government
to provide the defense with copies of the subpoenas themselves (as opposed to records or other
materials received in response to such subpoenas), let alone every subpoena issued for the
defendant's records during a multi-year and ongoing grand jury investigation. The types of
requests issued by the grand jury have no conceivable bearing on the defense or on any motion the
defense may seek to bring. The Government has already produced to the defense all discoverable
material that it has received in response to subpoenas issued to date during this investigation. In
the absence of any legal authority justifying this request, it should be denied. Additionally, for the
reasons discussed above in Sections I and IV, the defendant is not entitled to discovery or a hearing
relating to her motion to dismiss the Indictment based on the NPA or her motion to suppress
subpoena returns.
Sixth, the defendant asks the Court to direct the Government to immediately disclose any
Brady and Giglio material. (Def. Mot. 10 at 11-13). The motion for disclosure of Brady material
should be denied as moot because the Government has conducted a search for any such material
and has already disclosed any potentially exculpatory information in its possession of which it is
aware, consistent with the Rule 5(0 Brady order previously issued by the Court in this case. See
Fed. R. Crim. P. 5(0; Dkt. No. 68. The Government recognizes its continuing obligation to
disclose any Brady material, and to make a diligent search for any relevant material that may be
in the possession of the prosecution team, including investigating agents and officers. As the
Government has already emphasized in this case, the Government takes its disclosure obligations
very seriously and has committed to being transparent with the Court and the defense regarding its
approach to obtaining and reviewing files, including other agency files, that may be relevant to
this case. (See, e.g., Gov't Letter dated October 7, 2020, Dkt. No. 63). Consistent with that
commitment, the Government has completed an initial review of its files for Brady material and
Rule 16 material and has produced more than 2.7 million pages of discovery as a result of that
review. These productions have included specific disclosures of certain witness statements that
may arguably be exculpatory. The Government also intends to produce all statements and potential
impeachment material in its possession regarding any potential witness identified during its
investigation, including those individuals whom the Government does not intend to call at trial.
As discussed below, the Government is in the process of reviewing all files in its possession for
potential impeachment material. The Government remains cognizant of its Brady obligations and
will promptly produce any potentially exculpatory material if any is identified during that review.
The Government is not currently aware of any undisclosed Brady material in its possession,
but it will certainly provide timely disclosure of any additional Brady material if any such material
comes to light. Courts in this Circuit routinely deny specific requests for Brady material where,
as here, the Government has made a good-faith representation to the court and defense counsel
that it recognizes and has complied with its disclosure obligations under Brady. See, e.g.,
Thompson, 2013 WL 6246489 at *9 ("In light of the Government's 'good -faith representation to
the court and defense counsel that it recognizes and has complied with its disclosure obligations
under Brady,' defendants' request for immediate or otherwise early
production of Brady materials is denied." (internal citation omitted) (quoting United States v.
Perez, 940 F. Supp. 540, 553 (S.D.N.Y.1996))); Gallo, 1999 WL 9848, at *8 (denying defendant's
motion to compel production of purported Brady material based on Government's representations
that "it is aware of its obligations under Brady . . . and will produce any Brady material to the
defense well before trial"); United States v. Campo Flores, No. 15 Cr. 765 (PAC), 2016 WL
5946472, at *11 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 12, 2016) ("The Government represents that it is aware of its
obligation under Brady; that it has complied; and will continue to comply. That is sufficient to
deny Defendants' motion for Brady relief." (internal citations omitted)). Given the Government's
extensive efforts to review its files for any material warranting disclosure, and its commitment to
continue meeting its disclosure obligations, the motion should be denied.
For similar reasons, the motion for disclosure of Giglio material should be denied as
premature. The Government is fully aware of its obligation to disclose impeachment material, is
in the process of reviewing all files in its possession for any such material, and will produce any
such material several weeks in advance of trial. As noted above, that is consistent with governing
law in this Circuit, and the defendant cites no authority for the proposition that she is entitled to
such material as much as four months in advance of trial. Courts in this Circuit have repeatedly
refused to compel disclosure of impeachment or Giglio material well in advance of trial, and the
defense has provided no particularized basis for even earlier disclosure here. See United States v.
Nixon, 418 U.S. 683, 701 (1974) ("Generally, the need for evidence to impeach witnesses is
insufficient to require its production in advance of trial."); Campo Flores, 2016 WL 5946472, at
*II ("The Government has represented that it will make impeachment material relating to its
anticipated witnesses available . . . ten days before trial. There is no need to depart from the
customary rule in this district of disclosure shortly before trial."); United States v. Seabrook, No.
10 Cr. 87 (DAB), 2010 WL 5174353, at *4 (S.D.N.Y. Dec. 14, 2010) ("The Government represents
to the Court that it is aware of its Brady, Giglio, Jencks Act, and 404(b) obligations and will
comply with them in a timely fashion, as appropriate. Based on the Government's representations,
and on the current posture of this case, the Court expects that the Government will comply timely
with all of its obligations under Brady, Giglio, the Jencks Act, and Rule 404(3), and does not find
a need to order compliance at this time." (internal citation omitted)); Russo, 483 F. Supp. 2d at 308
("Here the government has represented that it intends to produce Giglio material no later than the
Friday of the week before a witness is scheduled to testify at trial, in accordance with its usual
practice. To the extent that the government's disclosure in this case proves unusually voluminous
or complex, the government has in good-faith represented that it intends to
produce Giglio material sufficiently in advance of their witnesses' testimony so as to avoid any
delay in trial. At the time of those disclosures, to the extent that Defendants feel that additional
time is necessary given the volume or complexity of the materials provided, the Court will
consider applications to continue or recall witnesses. It is unnecessary, however, to
order early disclosure at this time."); United States v. Canter, 338 F. Supp. 2d 460, 461-62
(S.D.N.Y. 2004) (denying analogous motion and noting that "[i]t has been the practice of this
Court and of other courts in this district to require that the Government produce these materials a
few days before the start of trial"). Because the Government has committed to providing the
defense with Giglio material multiple weeks in advance of trial, which is ample time for the
defense to prepare its cross-examination of the Government's witnesses, this motion should be
denied.
Seventh, the defendant seeks a proffer of all co-conspirator statements that the Government
intends to offer at trial pursuant to Federal Rule of Evidence 801(d)(2)(E). (Def. Mot. 10 at 13-
14). In making this motion, the defense cites authority confirming that co-conspirator statements
may be admitted at trial on a conditional basis without the need for any pretrial consideration of
their admissibility. See United States v. Tracy, 12 F.3d 1186, 1199 (2d Cir. 1993) ("The decision
as to whether the four prerequisites have been met, like all other preliminary questions of
admissibility, is to be made by the court. If the government succeeds in persuading the court that
the conditionally admitted coconspirator statements were made during and in furtherance of a
conspiracy of which both the declarant and the defendant were members, the statements are
allowed to go to the jury. If the court is not so persuaded, it either should instruct the jury to
disregard the statements, or, if those statements were `so large a proportion of the proof as to render
a cautionary instruction of doubtful utility,' should declare a mistrial." (internal citations omitted)
(quoting United States v. Geaney, 417 F.2d 1116, 1120 (2d Cir. 1969))). Indeed, the Second
Circuit has rejected the suggestion that non-exculpatory co-conspirator statements are discoverable
under Rule 16 or by any means other than the Jencks Act. See In re U.S., 834 F.2d 283, 284-87
(2d Cir. 1987) (issuing a writ of mandamus reversing District Court's order directing the
Government "to produce all oral statement made by the defendants and coconspirators that the
Government planned to offer at trial as admissions of a defendant" under Fed. R. Evid. 801).
Consistent with the Government's intention to produce Jencks Act material several weeks in
advance of trial, the defense will receive notice of any co-conspirator statements that the
Government may seek to introduce through witness statements with sufficient time to raise any
objections with the Court. Accordingly, this motion should be denied
Finally, the defendant requests early disclosure of Rule 404(b) material that the
Government may seek to introduce at trial. (Def. Mot. 10 at 17). As is customary in this district,
the Government will provide notice to the defense of its intent to use any such evidence at least 45
days in advance of trial, which will leave sufficient time for the defense may file any motions in
limine to be considered at the final pretrial conference. See Thompson, 2013 WL 6246489 at *9
("The Government has represented that it will disclose the substance of [the 404(b) evidence it
intends to introduce at trial] ... in a timely fashion in order to permit the defendants the opportunity
to challenge admission and to permit the Court to make an appropriate finding. This is all that Rule
404(b) requires." (alterations in original) (internal citation omitted)); United States v. Tranquillo,
606 F. Supp. 2d 370, 383 (S.D.N.Y. 2009) ("The Government has indicated that it will make the
required disclosure two weeks prior to trial, a practice that typically comports with Rule 404(6));
United States v. Fennell, 496 F. Supp. 2d 279, 284 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) ("The government has in good
faith noted its obligations under Rule 404(b), and indicated that it intends to provide notice of the
404(b) evidence it intends to introduce two weeks before the beginning of trial. There is therefore
no need to issue the order Defendant seeks."). Accordingly, this motion should be denied.

XI. The Use of a Grand Jury Siting in White Plains Was Entirely Proper
On June 29, 2020, amidst a global pandemic that suspended grand juries across the country,
the Government sought and obtained an indictment from a grand jury of the Southern District of
New York (the "Southern District" or "SDNY") sifting in White Plains. The defendant now
challenges the pool from which that grand jury was drawn, alleging that it does not reflect a "fair-
cross section of the community," and moves to dismiss the Indictment under the Sixth
Amendment. (Def. Mot. 9 at 1). As set forth below, the defendant's arguments rely on faulty
premises, and at any rate fail to meet the elements of a claim under the Sixth Amendment.
Therefore, the defendant's motion must be denied.
A. Background
1. The SDNY and Local Rules for the Division of Business
The defendant's brief repeatedly uses the term "Division" to describe a "White Plains
Division" and a "Manhattan Division." (See, e.g., Def. Mot. 9 at 2 ("On June 29, 2020, the
government filed a sealed indictment of Ms. Maxwell in the Manhattan Division of this Court. The
government has conceded that Ms. Maxwell's indictment was obtained using a grand jury seated
in White Plains, apparently with jurors drawn exclusively from the White Plains Division.")). Her
use of the term "division" is imprecise and attributes legal significance where there is none.
Understanding how that is so requires some background.
District courts in each state in the United States are prescribed by statute. United States
district courts in New York State are divided between four districts: Northern, Southern, Eastern
and Western. 28 U.S.C. § 112. While certain districts in other states are further divided into
"divisions" by statute, see, e.g., id. § 81 (dividing Alabama into three "districts" and multiple
"divisions" within each district), the federal districts in New York State are not so divided. That
is, in the Southern District, no "divisions" have been created by statute. Id. § 112(b). The statute
provides only that "Court for the Southern District shall be held at New York, White Plains, and
in the Middletown -Wallkill area of Orange County or such nearby location as may be deemed
appropriate." Id.
In the Southern District, the only authority determining whether particular cases are heard
in the Manhattan or White Plains courthouse is the SDNY Business Division Rules. These rules
begin with an important preface: they "shall not be deemed to vest any rights in litigants . ."
SDNY Business Division Rules, available at httpsillwww.nysd.uscourts.govisitesidefaultifiles/
local_rules/rules-2018-10-29.pdf. Moreover, the Rules do not describe —much less limit—what
matters may be heard by what grand jury. Cf. SDNY Business Division Rule 6 (describing
proceedings after an indictment has been returned). Rather, the Rules provide only that once an
indictment is returned, "[t]he U.S. attorney designates on the criminal cover sheet that the case is
to be assigned to White Plains if the crime was allegedly committed in whole or in predominant
part in the Northern Counties." SDNY Business Division Rule 18(b)). Furthermore, the Rules
specifically contemplate that cases may be reassigned from one courthouse to another. SDNY
Business Division Rule 19. Consistent with these Rules, it is common for cases to be indicted by
grand juries sitting in the White Plains courthouse and tried in the Manhattan courthouse. See,
e.g., United States v. Israel, 05 Cr. 1039 (CM), Dkt. No. 25; United States v. Cromitie, et at, 09

Cr. 558 (CM), Dkt. No. 183, 200; United States v. Annabi, 10 Cr. 07 (CM), Dkt. No. 45; United
States v. Arici, 12 Cr. 24 (LAP), Dkt. No. 115, 117; United States v. Reeves, et at, 16 Cr. 372
(VEC), Dkt. No. 51; United States v. Guerrier, 18 Cr. 284 (JSR), Dkt. No. 98.
2. The SDNY Jury Plan
The Jury Selection and Service Act of 1968, 28 U.S.C. § 1861 et seq. (the "JSSA"),
provides the structure for the selection of juries in federal district courts. The JSSA requires each
district to "devise and place into operation a written plan for random selection of grand and petit
jurors .. .." 28 U.S.C. § 1863(a). Each district in New York selects grand and petit juries pursuant
to a plan adopted by the judges of the district and approved by the Judicial Conference of the
Second Circuit. Id.; see also United States v. Bahna, 68 F.3d 19, 23 (2d Cir. 1995). The plan for
the Southern District has been in place since February 2009. See Amended Plan for the Random
Selection of Grand and Petit Jurors in the Southern District of New York, available at
https://www.nysd.uscourts.govisitesidefauItalles/pdgiutypIatfeb_2009.pdf (the "SDNY Jury
Plan," or the "Plan").
Under the terms of the SDNY Jury Plan, the initial selection of persons to be considered
for service as grand and petit jurors are made at random from voter registration lists. SDNY Jury
Plan at Art. III.A. Two Master Jury Wheels are constructed from these lists: one for the Manhattan
courthouse and one for the White Plains courthouse. Id. at Art. III.B. The Manhattan Master Jury
Wheel draws from voter lists from the following counties: New York, Bronx, Westchester,
Putnam, and Rockland. See id. at Art. III.C. The White Plains Master Jury Wheel draws from
voter lists from the following counties: Westchester, Putnam, Rockland, Orange, Sullivan, and
Dutchess. See id. Both Master Jury Wheels are emptied and refilled no later than September 1
following the date of each Presidential Election. Id. at Art. III.B.
To meet anticipated demand for jurors, names are drawn randomly from the Master Jury
Wheels. Id. at Art. III.D. These individuals are sent a questionnaire to examine their qualifications
and availability for jury service. Id. Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1865(b), all persons are qualified for
jury service unless he or she:

(1) Is not a citizen of the United States at least eighteen years old who has resided for a
period of one year within the judicial district;

(2) Is unable to read, write, and understand English with a degree of proficiency sufficient
to fill out the juror qualification questionnaire;

(3) Is unable to speak English;
(4) Is incapable, by mental or physical infirmity, to render satisfactory jury service; or

(5) Has a charge pending for the commission of, or has been convicted in a State or Federal
court, of a felony and his or her civil rights have not been restored.

Id. at Art. VII. Additionally, certain persons are declared exempt from jury service, including
active service members in the Armed Forces of the United States, members of fire or police
departments, and public officers in the executive, legislative, or judicial branches of the State or
Federal Government who are actively engaged in the performance of official duties. Id. at Art. V;
28 U.S.C. § 1863(b)(6). Finally, because jury service for certain groups of individuals would
"entail undue hardship or extreme inconvenience," those individuals are excused or deferred upon
individual request. SDNY Jury Plan at Art. VI. These groups include:

(1) Persons over 70 years of age;
(2) Persons having legal custody and active daily care of a child under the age of 12, or who
are essential to the daily care of aged or infirm persons;

(3) Persons who have satisfactorily served as grand or petit jurors in a State or Federal court
within the last four years;

(4) Volunteer safety personnel; and
(5) Persons as to whom a judge finds, for any other reason, that jury service would
constitute an undue hardship and extreme inconvenience.
Id.
The names of individuals who are determined to be qualified to serve as jurors, and are not
"exempt, excused, or deferred," comprise the Qualified Jury Wheels—one for service at the
Manhattan courthouse and one for service at the White Plains courthouse. Id., Art. IV.A-B. When
jurors are needed, names are drawn randomly from the Qualified Jury Wheels, and summonses are
sent to those whose names are drawn. Id., Art. IV.C. After being summoned, these individuals
are randomly assigned to jury panels as needed, for individual trials and grand juries at the
courthouse corresponding to the Qualified Wheel from which they were drawn. Id.

B. Applicable Law
"The Sixth Amendment guarantees a criminal defendant a jury selected from a fair cross
section of the community." United States v. Rioux, 97 F.3d 648, 654 (2d Cir. 1996). In Duren v.
Missouri, the Supreme Court articulated a three part test that defendants must meet in order to
establish a prima facie violation of the fair cross-section requirement: (1) the excluded group is
"distinctive"; (2) "representation of this group in venires from which juries are selected is not fair
and reasonable in relation to the number of such persons in the community;" and (3) the
"underrepresentation is due to systematic exclusion of the group in the jury-selection process."
439 U.S. 357, 364 (1979).

C. Discussion
The Government's decision to seek an indictment of the defendant from a grand jury sitting
in White Plains was entirely appropriate and consistent with the Constitution, the JSSA, and the
SDNY local rules. The defendant's claims to the contrary rest on a faulty premise: That a
defendant who is likely to be tried in the Manhattan courthouse must be indicted by a grand jury
sitting in that same courthouse. That is not the law. See Section XI.C.1, infra.
That foundational error is fatal to the defendant's fair cross-section claim. When the proper
comparators are considered—the White Plains Master (or Qualified) Wheels to the voting age
population of the counties from which juries in White Plains are drawn, rather than the defendant's
apples-to-oranges comparison of the White Plains Qualified Jury Wheel to the population of the
Manhattan "Division"—the defendant fails to establish unfair underrepresentation under the
second prong of the Duren test. Moreover, the defendant has not established that any disparity
resulted from systemic exclusion of a particular group. Accordingly, the motion should be denied.
1. The Defendant Was Properly Indicted by a Grand Jury Sifting in
White Plains
At the heart of the defendant's fair cross-section claim is her contention that the
Government seeking an indictment from a grand jury sitting in White Plains—which was the only
available grand jury that day, due to the global pandemic 68—"was a deviation from the established
practice of indicting defendants in the division where the offense is alleged to have occurred and
where the case will be tried." (Def. Mot. 9 at 2). Because the offense is alleged to have occurred
in the "Manhattan Division" and the defendant assumes that her jury trial will occur there too, she
argues that the "appropriate comparison," for the purpose of her fair cross-section claim, "is
therefore between the Manhattan Division and the qualified wheel for White Plains." (Def. Mot.
9 at 6). This premise is faulty.
"It is well-settled that neither the jury selection statute nor the Constitution requires that
jurors be drawn from an entire district." Bahna, 68 F.3d at 24 (collecting cases); see also United
States v. Plaza-Andrades, 507 F. App'x 22, 26 (2d Cir. 2013) ("[O]ur precedent makes clear that
the Sixth Amendment does not entitle a defendant to be tried in a geographic location any more
68 This case was indicted on June 29, 2020, on which date the grand jury sitting in White Plains
was the only available grand jury in the District. Beginning on or about June 25, 2020, grand jury
quorums returned in Manhattan, but with substantially less availability than before the pandemic.
As a result, the Government has sought indictments from grand juries sitting in White Plains and
Manhattan, as availability permits. In this instance, the Government was prepared to indict on
June 29, 2020, and the only grand jury available in this District on that day sat in White Plains.
The global pandemic's effect on grand jury availability continues to evolve, but at no point have
grand juries in White Plains or Manhattan resumed normal activity.
The defendant speculates that the Government sought an indictment on June 29, 2020
because of some arbitrary desire to arrest the defendant on July 2, 2020, one year to the day after
a grand jury returned a sealed indictment charging Jeffrey Epstein with federal crimes on July 2,

2019. (See, e.g., Def. Mot. 9 at 1, 8). Setting aside the silliness of marking the anniversary of an
indictment's return, as opposed to the anniversary of the arrest itself, which took place on July 6,
2019, there is no reality in the defense's conspiracy theories. As the defense knows full well, the
Government attempted to locate and arrest the defendant on July 1, 2020 but was unable to confirm
her location until obtaining cellphone location data identifying her location and enabling her arrest
on July 2, 2020. The defense knows this because they have the warrant application that the
Government submitted on July I, 2020 for the defendant's cellphone location information, in
which the Government stated that it had been unable to confirm the defendant's location. In other
words, the Government indicted the defendant as soon as it was prepared to present the evidence
it had gathered to a grand jury, and the Government arrested the defendant as soon as it was able
to locate her after obtaining that indictment.
specific than the District where the offense was allegedly committed."). Rather, "[c]ourts have
broad latitude in defining the geographic area from which juries will be selected." United States
v. Yonkers Contracting Co., Inc., 682 F. Supp. 757, 768 (S.D.N.Y. 1988). Consistent with the
foregoing, the SDNY Jury Plan creates two separate Master Wheels —one for the White Plains
courthouse and one for the Manhattan courthouse, each of which draws from certain counties, with
some overlapping counties. SDNY Jury Plan Art. III.B, III.C. This is perfectly consistent with
the JSSA, see 28 U.S.C. § 1869(e), and with longstanding precedent, as Judge Hand has explained:
[T]he district and circuit courts have had power since the first
Judiciary Act of 1789 to divide a district territorially in the interest
of an impartial trial, of economy, and of lessening the burden of
attendance. There cannot be the faintest question of the
constitutionality of this statute; the courts have again and again
recognized its validity. Furthermore, it would be impossible in
practice to administer it, if it were a condition that that the divisions
made must be so homogeneous that they showed an equal
percentage of all possible groups. There are probably no districts in
the Union, which can be divided without disclosing in the sections
different racial, religious, political, social or economic percentages.
To demand that they shall not, would be a fantastic pedantry which
would serve no purpose and would put an end to the statute.
United States v. GotOied, 165 F.2d 360, 364 (2d Cir. 1948); accord Bahna, 68 F.3d at 24-25.
There is accordingly no constitutional or statutory basis for the defendant's claimed
entitlement to a grand July drawn from the population of the same "division" in which the offense
occurred and she assumes she will ultimately be tried. To the contrary, the Second Circuit has
rejected a similar claim. In Bahna, a defendant in the Eastern District of New York was initially
convicted at a trial held at the Brooklyn courthouse; after that conviction was vacated, he was
again convicted, this time at a trial held at the Uniondale courthouse. 68 F.3d at 20. Under the
relevant jury plan, jurors for trials held in Brooklyn were drawn from the entire Eastern District,
while jurors for trials held in the "Long Island Division," which included the Uniondale
courthouse, were drawn from Nassau and Suffolk Counties. Id. at 24. The defendant argued that
the district court erred by selecting the jury from the "Long Island Division" wheel because there
was under-representation of Blacks and Hispanics in that "division" as compared to the Eastern
District as a whole. Id. at 23-24. The Second Circuit rejected the argument, finding that it "[wa]s
based upon an improper premise." Id. at 24. Contrary to the defendant's claims, "[w]here a jury
venire is drawn from a properly designated division, we look to that division to see whether there
has been any unlawful or unconstitutional treatment of minorities." Id. (emphasis added).
Consistent with Bahna, courts have repeatedly found that defendants in criminal cases have
no constitutional or statutory right to a jury drawn from the entire district or from a particular
geographic area within a district, such as the county or "division" where the offense was
committed. See, e.g., Rutenberg v. United States, 245 U.S. 480, 482 (1918) (rejecting claim that
defendant had Sixth Amendment right to jury drawn from entire district); United States v. Miller,
116 F.3d 641, 659 (2d Cir. 1997) ("Th[e] [Sixth] Amendment's guarantees of an impartial jury `of
the State and district' in which the crime was committed does not require a narrower geographical
focus than the district itself."); United States v. Richardson, 537 F.3d 951, 959 (8th Cir. 2008) (a
criminal defendant "does not have a right to have his trial in or jurors summoned from a particular
division of the state and district where the crime was committed"); United States v. Herbert, 698
F.2d 981, 984 (9th Cir. 1983) (finding that "[a] petit jury may be drawn constitutionally from only
one division and not the whole district"); Zicarelli v. Dietz, 633 F.2d 312, 318 (3d Cir. 1980)
("[T]there is no constitutional right to a jury chosen from the division where the offense was
committed or from the entire district which includes that division."); United States v. Florence,
456 F.2d 46, 49-50 (4th Cir. 1972) (holding that a defendant has no constitutional or statutory right
to a jury selected from the entire district or from a particular division).
Because the defendant has no right to insist that either the grand or petit jury be drawn from
any particular geographic area within the Southern District, she is wrong to assert that her fair
cross-section claim must be analyzed against the geographic location in which the offense was
committed or the trial is expected to occur. Rather, "[w]here a jury venire is drawn from a properly
designated division, we look to that division to see whether there has been any unlawful or
unconstitutional treatment of minorities." Bahna, 68 F.3d at 24 (emphasis added). Here,
consistent with the SDNY Grand Jury Plan, the venire for the grand jury that indicted the defendant
was drawn from the voter lists of the following counties: Westchester, Putnam, Rockland, Orange,
Sullivan, and Dutchess. That is undoubtedly a "properly designated division" pursuant to the
JSSA. As noted, the Southern District is not divided into "divisions" by statute. See 28 U.S.C.
§ 112(b). For purposes of the JSSA, district courts in such undivided districts have the authority
to determine "divisions" comprised of "counties, parishes, or similar political subdivisions
surrounding the places where court is held." 28 U.S.C. § 1869(e). Accordingly, while the SDNY
Jury Plan neither creates nor ever uses the term "White Plains Division" or "Manhattan Division,"
it contemplates Master Jury Wheels drawn from two geographic areas that satisfy the definition of
"division" under the JSSA. Thus, in evaluating the defendant's fair cross-section claim, this Court
must "look to that division"—the counties from which the White Plains Master Wheel is drawn—
"to see whether there has been any unlawful or unconstitutional treatment of minorities." Bahna,
68 F.3d at 24 (emphasis added).
In the face of this authority, the defendant cites only two district court cases for the
proposition that "community" for purposes of a fair cross-section claim is "widely understood to
mean the district or division where the trial will be held." (Def. Mot. 9 at 5 (emphasis added)
(internal quotation marks and citation omitted)). Not only is the authority cited non-binding, but
it is inapposite as well: both cases appear to concern instances in which the grand jury and trial
jury sat in the same courthouse, and thus there was no cause to consider whether the same
"community" was relevant to separate challenges to the grand and petit juries. See United States
v. Johnson, 21 F. Supp. 2d 329, 334-35 (S.D.N.Y. 1998); United States v. Kenny, 883 F. Supp.
869, 874-75 (E.D.N.Y. 1995). As such, neither case supports the proposition that where a
defendant is challenging the selection of the grand jury, the relevant "community" is the
population of the location in which her trial will be held. Such a comparison is unjustified, as
Bahna makes clear: That case appears to involve conduct that occurred in Brooklyn, appears to
have been indicted in Brooklyn, was originally tried in Brooklyn, and was later transferred to
Uniondale, where it was tried with a jury drawn from the "Long Island Division." Yet the Second
Circuit rejected the defendant's claimed entitlement to a jury drawn from Kings, Queens and
Richmond counties, or the entire Eastern District, because that argument —like the defendant's
here—was based on a flawed premise.
The defendant's proposed rule—comparing the composition of the grand jury venire to the
population of the expected trial location—makes little legal or practical sense. Where, as here,
the defendant's challenge is to the indictment, the proceeding for which the defendant is entitled
to expect a jury drawn from a fair cross-section of the community is not the trial, but the grand
jury proceeding itself. Indeed, that must be the case, as it is not yet determined where the trial in
this matter will in fact occur. The defendant assumes that her trial will ultimately be held at the
Manhattan courthouse. While that is likely to be the case, it is not necessarily so. Bahna again
illustrates the point, as a case originally tried in Brooklyn was reassigned to Uniondale for the
retrial "to accommodate trial congestion in the court's calendar during a period of judicial
emergency . . . ." United States v. Soares, 66 F. Supp. 2d 391, 397 n.2 (E.D.N.Y. 1999). In the
Southern District, cases are commonly transferred from one courthouse to another, including cases
that are indicted in White Plains but tried in Manhattan. See Section XLA.1, supra (collecting
examples). That is entirely consistent not just with the foregoing authority, but also with the
Southern District's Local Rules for the Division of Business. See SDNY Business Division Rules
18, 19. Criminal cases are also sometimes transferred to other Districts for trial. See Fed. R. Crim.

P. 21. Under the defendant's approach, it would be impossible for prosecutors to determine ex
ante that that they were seeking an indictment from a grand jury drawn from a representative cross-
section of the relevant community, because they would not yet know with certainty in which
community the case will be tried.
The defendant's argument therefore boils down to an unfounded complaint that it is "a
deviation from the established practice" to seek an indictment in a courthouse other than the one
in which the case will likely be tried. (Def. Mot. 9 at 2). This argument is inconsistent with the
foregoing law that the defendant has no right to jurors drawn from any particular geographic area
within the district. See also Rosencrans v. United States, 165 U.S. 257, 260-63 (1897) (finding no
error in grand July returning indictment in a division different from the division in which the trial
proceeded). It also finds no succor in the SDNY Business Division Rules, which vest no rights in
any parties and, in any event, contemplate that judges may reassign cases from one courthouse to
another. And it falls exceedingly flat on the facts of this case. The Government did not forum
shop to achieve some perceived advantage. Rather, it sought a timely indictment from a grand
jury in White Plains because it was the only grand jury with a quorum sitting in the Southern
District on that date (a relatively rare situation created by an unprecedented public health crisis).
In sum, the decision to indict the defendant in White Plains was entirely proper, and the
lack of any constitutional or statutory basis for the defendant's contrary argument is fatal to her
fair cross-section claims, as described below.

2. The Defendant's Fair Cross -Section Claim Is Meritless
The defendant's fair cross-section claim is based on the assertion that Black or African -
American and Hispanic or Latino individuals are unfairly underrepresented in the relevant jury
pool. (Def. Mot. 9 at 5). While these are "distinctive" groups, satisfying Duren's first prong, the
defendant's claim fails on each of the other two prongs.
a. The Defendant Has Not Established that Blacks or Hispanics
Are Unfairly Represented
The second prong of the Duren test requires the Court to determine whether representation
of either or both of the "distinctive" groups in venires from which juries are selected is not fair and
reasonable in relation to the number of such persons in the community. Duren, 439 U.S. at 364.
This requires determining the relevant comparators —Le., what is the "relevant jury pool" and what
is the community "population" against which it is compared —as well as the appropriate method
of statistical comparison. See Rioux, 97 F.3d at 656.
Here, the defendant contends that the relevant jury pool is the White Plains Qualified
Wheel. (Def. Mot. 9 at 5-6). The Government believes that the relevant jury pool is the White
Plains Master Wheel, but, as set forth below, the defendant's claim fails even using the White
Plains Qualified Wheel.
"Neither the Supreme Court nor the Second Circuit has defined the `relevant jury pool'
with any specificity." United States V. Rioux 930 F. Supp. 1558, 1565 (D. Conn. 1995). In a
detailed survey of the case law, the district court in Rioux found that cases have examined different
relevant pools, including the master wheel, the qualified wheel over a period of time, the venires
appearing around the time of the defendant's trial, or some combination thereof. Id. Ultimately,
the district court in Rioux found that the teaching of Duren and the Second Circuit's subsequent
cases is that "the court must assess representativeness in the context of the systematic defect
identified by the defendant." Id. at 1568. In that case, the claimed defects were in the construction
of the qualified wheel and, therefore, the "relevant jury pool" was the "qualified wheel over the
life of the wheel." Id. at 1575.
Affirming that decision, the Second Circuit did not hold that the qualified wheel is
necessarily the "relevant jury pool." Rather, after stating that the relevant jury pool "may be
defined by: (1) the master list; (2) the qualified wheel; (3) the venires; or (4) a combination of the
three," the Circuit noted that the parties had agreed that the district court properly used the qualified
wheel over the life of the wheel as the "relevant jury pool." Rioux, 97 F.3d at 657. The court's
acceptance of the qualified jury wheel as the "relevant jury pool" for that case—an issue which
was not in dispute —does not mean it necessarily must be applied in all cases. Id. Indeed, in other
cases where the claim of error was not focused on the construction of the qualified wheel, different
"relevant jury pools" have been used by the Second Circuit. Most notably, in Biaggi, the main
thrust of the defendant's fair cross-section claim was that reliance on voter registration lists
systemically excluded African-Americans and Hispanics from jury service —a claim which is
directed at the composition of the master wheel —and the Second Circuit identified the district's
master wheel as the relevant jury pool. United States v. Biaggi, 909 F.2d 662, 677 (2d Cir. 1990).
Here, the defendant claims that "the primary reason" for the alleged underrepresentation is
the Government's "choice to pursue an indictment from a grand jury drawn from the White Plains
Division, as opposed to the Manhattan Division .. . ." (Def. Mot. 9 at 7). Even if this argument
described a function of the jury selection process — though it does not — it would be directed at the
how the particular Master Wheel is selected. It says nothing about the process by which a Master
Wheel is reduced to the subset of qualified jurors contained in the Qualified Wheel. Because the
"systematic defect" alleged by the defendant relates to the Master Jury Wheel, the White Plains
Master Jury Wheel is the appropriate "relevant jury pool." Rioux, 930 F. Supp. at 1566-68.
Although the Master Jury Wheel does not include reliable information regarding the race
and ethnicity of the individuals selected from voter registration lists, the racial and ethnic makeup
of the White Plains Master Jury Wheel can be estimated using geocoding and Bayesian Improved
Surname Geocoding ("BISG"). 69 Taking into account those estimates, the White Plains Master
Wheel is 11.20% Black or African-American and 12.97% Hispanic or Latino. (Siskin Aff. at ¶
28). By contrast, the White Plains Qualified Wheel is 8.76% Black or African-American and
10.48% Hispanic or Latino. (Id. at ¶ 17).
The community population for purposes of assessing representativeness is the population
eligible for jury service in the community. See, e.g., Taylor v. Louisiana, 419 U.S. 522, 524 (1975)
(focusing on population eligible for jury service); Rioux, 97 F.3d at 657 ("We conclude that the
appropriate measure in this case is the eighteen and older subset of the population ...."). But how
should the relevant "community" be defined? The defendant contends that it is the jury eligible
population of the "Manhattan Division," because that is where the offense occurred and where she
assumes she will be tried. (Def. Mot. 9 at 6). As set forth above, she is wrong. The relevant
69 The defense motion references the expert report of an expert witness named Jeffrey O'Neal
Martin ("Martin Aft"), which was prepared for the defense in United States v. Balde, No. 20 Cr.
281 (KPF), where a similar motion is currently pending before Judge Failla. The Government is
likewise attaching the expert report of Dr. Bernard R. Siskin, which was prepared for the
Government in Balde. As detailed Dr. Skiskin's report, geocoding is based on estimating the
proportion of persons who are of a given race or ethnicity based on the racial and ethnic area in
which they live. (See Affidavit of Dr. Bernard R. Siskin ("Siskin Aff."), attached hereto as Exhibit
12, at ¶ 26). BISG enhances the accuracy of geocoding for Hispanic or Latino persons by using
information about persons' last names. (Id.).
comparator is the jury eligible population of the five counties from which the White Plains Master
Wheel is drawn.
The American Community Survey ("ACS") 2018 data indicate that the jury eligible
population for the White Plains counties in 2018 was 12.45% Black or African-American and
14.12% Hispanic or Latino.70 (See Siskin Aff. at ¶ 19; see also Martin Aff. at ¶ 21).
Once the relevant comparators are defined, an additional threshold question is the statistical
method by which to compare them. Courts have applied different approaches over time, such as
the statistical decision theory, the comparative disparity theory, and the absolute disparity theory.
See Biota, 97 F.3d at 655. Although no method is perfect, see Berghuis v. Smith, 559 U.S. 314,
329 (2010), the Second Circuit has made clear that the comparative disparity theory is disfavored
and strongly suggested that the absolute disparity theory is generally appropriate, see Rioux, 97
F.3d at 655-56; see also United States v. Barnes, 520 F. Supp. 2d 510, 514 (S.D.N.Y. 2007) ("[T]he
absolute disparity approach is the primary approach used in this Circuit.").
The "absolute disparity" approach measures the absolute numerical difference between the
distinctive group's representation in the community population and the group's representation in
the relevant jury pool. See Rioux, 97 F.3d at 655; United States v. Barlow, 732 F. Supp. 2d 1, 30-
31 (E.D.N.Y. 2010), gird 479 F. App'x 372, 373 (2d Cir. 2012). For example, if Blacks
represented 10% of the community population but only 2% of the relevant jury pool, the "absolute
disparity" would be 8%.
There is no specific numerical threshold that constitutes unacceptable disparity under the
"absolute disparity" method. "[P]erfectly proportional representation is not required, since no
70 The American Community Survey gathers demographic information in between the decennial
census, and is published by the United States Census Bureau. (See Siskin Aff. at ¶ 18). The latest
available data is the 2018 five-year survey combining the 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, and 2018 survey
data. (Id.).
source list will be an exact statistical mirror of the community." United States v. Guzman, 337 F.
Supp. 140, 143 (S.D.N.Y. 1972); see also Taylor, 419 U.S. at 538. The mere fact that a jury
selection system is imperfect does not make it invalid. Swain v. Alabama, 380 U.S. 202, 209
(1965) (overruled on other grounds). Accordingly, the Second Circuit has found that absolute
disparities as high as nearly 5% fail to establish a prima facie case of underrepresentation. See,
e.g., Biaggi, 909 F.2d at 677-78 (3.6% for Blacks and 4.7% for Hispanics); United States v.
Ramnath, 131 F.3d 132, 132 (2d Cir. 1997) (3.45% for African -Americans and 4.87% for
Hispanics); see also Barlow, 732 F. Supp. 2d at 34-35 (collecting out-of-circuit cases rejecting
claims presenting similar and even higher disparities). 71
Properly calculated, the "absolute disparity" in this case falls comfortably within the range
deemed acceptable by the Second Circuit and other courts. As noted, the "relevant jury pool" is
the White Plains Master Wheel, which is comprised of 11.20% Black or African -American persons
and 12.97% Latino or Hispanic persons. (Siskin Aff. at ¶ 28). The "community population" is the
jury eligible population for the five counties from which the White Plains Master Wheel is drawn,
which was comprised of 12.45% Black or African-American persons and 14.12% Hispanic or
Latino persons in 2018. (Id. at ¶ 19). This yields an "absolute disparity" of 1.25% for Black or
African-American persons and 1.15% for Latino or Hispanic persons. (Id. at ¶ 28). That disparity
does not rise to the level of satisfying the second prong of the Duren test.
71 In United States v. Jackman, the Second Circuit held that an absolute disparity of 2.5% for Black
or African -American persons and 3.4% for Hispanic or Latino persons was sufficient to satisfy the
second prong of the Duren test. 46 F.3d 1240 (2d Cir. 1995). The unique facts of Jackman make
it readily distinguishable. The jury clerk in Jaclanan relied on a qualified jury wheel that was
mostly drawn from a master jury wheel that completely excluded potential jurors from two cities
in the Division —cities that accounted for 62.93% of the voting-age Black population and 68.09%
of the voting-age Hispanic population in the division. See id. at 1242-44. This resulted in a venire
comprised of no Black or African-American persons and one Hispanic or Latino person. Id. at

1244. See also id. at 1252 (Walker, J., dissenting) (stating that the majority's decision was "at
odds with every decision in every circuit applying the Duren test").
The result is the same even if the defendant's preferred relevant jury pool is used. The
White Plains Qualified Wheel is comprised of 8.76% Black or African -American persons and
10.48% Latino or Hispanic persons. (Id. at ¶ 17; see also Martin Aff. at ¶ 55). This results in
absolute disparities of 3.69% and 3.64%, respectively. These figures are also comfortably within
the range that the Second Circuit has determined does not satisfy the second prong of the Duren
test. Moreover, as discussed below, the factors that cause the disparity between the White Plains
Qualified Wheel and the White Plains Master Jury Wheel, as well as the voting age population,
are not the result of systematic exclusion.
It is only by employing an apples-and-oranges method of comparing the White Plains
Qualified Wheel to the jury eligible populations of the "Manhattan Division" or the entire Southern
District that the defendant is able to identify disparities that might arguably satisfy the second
prong of Duren. Because that method has no basis in the law, the defendant's claim fails at the
second prong.

b. Any Potential Underrepresentation Is Not Due to Systematic
Exclusion
Even assuming the defendant had satisfied the second prong of the Duren test—which she
has not—she most certainly has not demonstrated that any underrepresentation is "due to
systematic exclusion of the group in the fray -selection process." Rioux, 97 F.3d at 654 (emphasis
added). That is, she cannot establish that the exclusion is the product of "the system of jury
selection itself, rather than external forces." Id. at 658 (emphasis added). She therefore cannot
satisfy the third prong of Duren.
As then-District Judge Bianco explained, "systematic exclusion does not occur simply
because a facially neutral disqualification criterion disproportionately impacts a particular group."
Barlow, 732 F. Supp. 2d at 40; see also United States v. Barlow, 479 F. App'x 372, 373 (2d Cir.

2012) (affirming Judge Bianco's "thorough and well-reasoned" opinion). Indeed, "la] selection
process that is facially neutral is unlikely to demonstrate systematic exclusion."' United States v.
Savage, 970 F.3d 217, 259 (3d Cir. 2020) (brackets in original) (quoting Howell v. Superintendent
Rockview SCI, 939 F.3d 260, 269 (2d Cir. 2019)). Moreover, a defendant cannot "make out a
prima facie case merely by pointing to a host of factors that, individually or in combination, might
contribute to a group's underrepresentation." Berghuis, 559 U.S. at 332 (emphasis in original).
Insofar as the underrepresentation here is measured by a comparison of the White Plains
Qualified Wheel to the July eligible population of the "Manhattan Division" or entire Southern
District, the defendant's argument rests entirely on the prosecution's decision to pursue an
indictment in White Plains rather than Manhattan. (Def. Mot. 9 at 7). That decision was entirely
proper, as set forth above. See Section XI.C.1, supra. And even if it were the case that this decision
resulted in substantial underrepresentation, it nevertheless does not amount to "systematic
exclusion . . . in the jwy-selection process." The prosecution's decision as to where to seek an
indictment was based entirely on the availability of grand juries during a pandemic, which has
nothing to do with the process by which the grand jury is selected. The defendant points to no
other source of any supposed systemic exclusion of any identified group. Accordingly, the
defendant's claim also fails at the third prong of Duren.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, the Court should deny all twelve of the defendant's pre-trial
motions.
Dated: New York, New York
February 26, 2021
Respectfully submitted,
AUDREY STRAUSS
United States Attorney
By: Is
Assistant United States Attorneys
(212) 637-2225
EFTA00025091 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ arrest warrant and other discovery materials
(inferred date: 2021-04-14)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Silvio .1 Mono Building
April 14, 2021
BY USAfx
Jason E. Foy
Foy & Seplowitz LLC
105 Main Street
Hackensack, NJ 07601
Re: United States v. Tom Noel No. 19 Cr. 830
Dear Counsel:
This letter provides additional discovery pursuant to Rule 16(a) of the Federal Rules of
Criminal Procedure. This letter and the materials identified herein are subject to the protective
order entered in this case on December 16, 2019, and have been designated as "Protected
Materials" as defined in the order where noted below. Accordingly, the materials and information
'dentified herein shall not be disclosed to any third party or referenced publicly except as set forth
in the protective order.
Description Bates Numbers Classification Pursuant
to Protective Order
Arrest documentation and signed
warrants
SDNY 00017773 —
SDNY 00017775
Confidential
Documents from the MCC including
quarters, maps, and rosters
SDNY 00017776 —
SDNY 00017782
Confidential
FBI import forms
SDNY 00017783 —
SDNY 00017822
Confidential
FBI Laboratory examination requests
SDNY 00017823 —
SDNY_000 17825
Confidential
FBI process reports
SDNY 00017826 —
SDNY 00017991
Confidential
Witness statements
SDNY 00017992 —
SDNY 00018024
Confidential
Anonymized index SDNY_00018025 Attorney's Eyes Only
Additionally, the Government is producing the following matenals only to your client:
06.20.2018
Page 2
Description Bates Numbers Classification Pursuant
to Protective Order
US Marshals Service Intake and Personal
History
SDNY TN 00020912
SDNY TN 00020924
—
Finally, while we do not agree these materials are required to be produced pursuant to Rule
16, based on your prior request for information, the Government is providing the following
information from the Bureau of Prisons ("BOP"):

• Since approximately January 1, 2019, in BOP matters that resulted in sustained
administrative charges of falsification with regard to log entries, the following disciplinary
actions were taken: 2 letters of reprimand; 50 suspensions; 1 demotion; 3 terminations; and
6 resignations/retirements prior to discipline.

• The BOP has records of the following, inmate deaths over the last ten years at the MCC and
MDC:
Inmate Name Register Num DOD Institution 'Death Location Cause of Death
Tony McClam 79490-054
enneth Houck 06743-015
ric Manson 01558-112
effre E. stein 6318-054
Oscar Re oso 0240-019
Fang Xin He '/9018-053
9+24/2020 MCC
5/19/2020 MDC
10/23/2019 MCC
8/10/2019 MCC
10/23/2015 MDC
7/19/2012 MDC
Housing Unit
Special Housing Unit
Community Hospital
C'ommunit Hos • ital
Community  Hos
Mental Health Unit
Cardiac
Hanging
Dru Overdose
The foregoing information is subject to the protective order. Please contact us with any questions.
By:
Very truly yours,
AUDREY STRAUSS
United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New York
/5/
Assistant United States Attorneys
06.20.2018
EFTA00039817 (Jmail)
 [legal] notice of hearing
EFTA00039826 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2021-04-21)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Sihlo J. Mollo Building
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York, New York 10007
April 23, 2021
BY ECF
The Honorable Alison J. Nathan
United States District Court
Southern District of New York
United States Courthouse
40 Foley Square
New York, New York 10007
Re: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
Dear Judge Nathan:
The Government respectfully submits this letter in response to the Court's Order dated
April 21, 2021, which directed the Government to submit any requests for redaction of information
contained in filings regarding the defense's proposed Rule 17(c) subpoena. (Dkt. No. 226). After
reviewing the relevant filings, the Government seeks a limited number of redactions, which are
narrowly tailored to protect the privacy interests of third parties. In particular, the Government
respectfully requests that the Court permit the redaction of the names and identifying information
of particular third parties referenced in the defense's response to the objections of Boies Schiller
Flexner LLP ("BSF") to the defense's proposed Rule 17(c) subpoena, BSF's reply, and the April
19, 2021 joint letter addressing the redactions to those same documents. Today the Government
is submitting to the Court by email its proposed redactions to those documents, which the
Government respectfully requests be filed under seal.
These proposed redactions are consistent with the three-part test articulated by the Second
Circuit in Lugosch v. Pyramid Co. of Onondaga, 435 F.3d 110 (2d Cir. 2006). Although these
documents are judicial documents that are subject to the common law presumption of access, the
Page 2
proposed redactions are narrowly tailored to protect the privacy interests of third parties referenced
in the documents. These redactions are thus consistent with similar, tailored redactions permitted
by the Court in this case to protect the privacy interests of third parties. Accordingly, the
Government respectfully requests that the Court adopt the proposed redactions.
The Government has conferred with defense counsel and counsel from BSF, both of whom
indicated that they take no position on the Government's redaction requests.
Respectfully submitted,
AUDREY STRAUSS
United States Attorney
By:
Assistant United States Attorneys
Southern District of New York
Cc: All Counsel of Record (By ECF)
EFTA01249210 (Jmail)
 [crypto] FBI tip linking American commerce secretary and Tether asset custodian Howard Lutnick to Ponzi schemes and Russian money
(inferred timestamp: 2021-04-23 13:26:00)
50D-NY-3027571 Serial 595
FIT 1036 (Rev. 10.16.2009) UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Import Form

Form Type: FD-71A - Guardian Complaint Form Date: 04/23/2021
Title:U NTOC2020 288hmb01 Alleged Money Laundering by Howard Lutnick via BGC Financial and Cantor Fitzgerald
Approved By: <REDACTED>
Drafted By: <REDACTED>
Case ID #: 272-NY-0 (U) MONEY LAUNDERING -ZERO FILE
50D-NY-3027571 (U) EPSTEIN, JEFFREY; CHILD SEX TRAFFICKING

Synopsis: U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 04-23-2021 01:26 PM--SEE
GUARDIAN 681124 NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA.

On 10/14/2020, at 9:16:24 AM Eastern Time, <REDACTED>, date of birth
<REDACTED>, Home telephone number <REDACTED>, called the FBI National
Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to report alleged money laundering by
Howard Lutnick via BGC Financial and Cantor Fitzgerald.

Note: This information is being sent to your field office based on the
possible location of Lutnick within the United States.

<REDACTED> provided the following information:

<REDACTED>, calling from the <REDACTED> previously worked for <REDACTED>
and Cantor Fitzgerald (CF) in the financial market.
<REDACTED> was responsible for reviewing, reporting, and compliance for all
of North America. uncovered fraud, money laundering, Ponzi
schemes, and regulatory breaches by III and CF, so he became a
whistleblower. III and CF received large fines and there are "live cases"
still occurring in the United Kingdom.
Further investigation by <REDACTED> linked Howard Lutnick to illegal
activities with JP Morgan, Russian Hedge 1; and other senior
executives in the financial business. <REDACTED> has documented proof
3501.238-005
Page I of 3

50D-NY-3027571 Serial 595
Title: U NT0C2020 288hmb01 Alleged Money Laundering by Howard Lutnick via BGC Financial and Cantor Fitzgerald
Re: 272-NY-0, 04/23/2021
showing money laundering and Ponzi schemes by Lutnick via offshore shell
companies, liquid funding, and real estate brokerage firms. is
using a "global Ponzi share" scheme involving over 3,500 BGC employees
who are forced to contribute 10% of their earnings into the scheme.
Lutnick is deeply rooted to the royal family and has multiple high
profile and celebrity connections. Lutnick claims to be a philanthropist,
but is merely using his charities as a "smokescreen" for his illegal
activity. Many of the individual involved in Lutnick's charities have
criminal breaches against them.

<REDACTED> believes he has supporting documents which could link Lutnick to
Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. Maxwell and Sarah Ferguson, a
royal family member, host events called La Dolce Vita Parties, where high
profile celebrities and executives contribute large donations to attend.
The donations are linked to causes involving children. Lutnick made "huge
donations" to these events. Epstein also sold Lutnick a house for $10
dollars through a trust fund, which was then sold for millions shortly
after prior to the money going overseas.

<REDACTED> stated he has multiple regulatory reporting documents he can
provide to an agent to substantiate his claims. would like to
speak to an agent to better and more thoroughly outline and tie
everything together.

In addition, believes its suspicious Lutnick's contributed over
65 million dollars to Haverford College in New York, although he cannot
prove any illegal activity concerning this aspect.

Database Queries

Sentinel and Guardian queries for Howard Lutnick revealed 26 results in
the NY division case files including restricted closed case no.:272D-NY-
306108, Serial 204, concerning money laundering and control file case
no.:194-NY-C277070-B, Serial 392, concerning a RICO violations/real
estate scheme.

3501.238-005
Pagc2of3

50D-NY-3027571 Serial 595
Title: U NTOC2020 288hmb01 Alleged Money Laundering by Howard Lutnick via BGC Financial and Cantor Fitzgerald
Re: 272-NY-0, 04/23/2021

A DIVS query for Howard Lutnick revealed 34 results, including three
SAR's, in addition to the aforementioned case files.
Sentinel and Guardian queries for <REDACTED> revealed a single
results for case no.:62F-NY-A29O116-USPS_Mail, Serial 991, concerning a
complaint of illegal billing practices made by <REDACTED>

A DIVS query for <REDACTED> revealed no additional derogatory
information.

**Note: Queries were not conducted on Epstein and Maxwell due to the
sensitive nature of the case.

The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions
of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. Department of the Treasury
regulations implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C. 5311, et seq.; 31
CFR...CONTENT TRUNCATED --SEE GUARDIAN 681124 NY FOR COMPLETE TEXT
Enclosure(s): Enclosed are the following items:
1. U Contents of Submission
.•
3501.238-005
Pagc 3 of 3
╔════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Citrix [tech] address book software used by Epstein 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00159380 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of <REDACTED> former Epstein employee
(date: 2021-05-14)
FD•302 (Rev S•&10)
50D-NY-3027571 Serial 637
-1 of 8-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of Enty  04/17/2021

<REDACTED> date of birth (DOB) was interviewed pursuant
to a proffer agreement via video conference. Present for the interview was
<REDACTED> attorney <REDACTED>, along with Assistant United States
Attorneys , Special Agent
, and Detective IIII . After being advised of the identity of the
above listed individuals and the nature of the interview, <REDACTED> provided
the following information:

<REDACTED> was managed by <REDACTED>; <REDACTED> was <REDACTED> assistant.
<REDACTED> was a "runner" who ran errands. <REDACTED> <REDACTED> and <REDACTED>
worked out of GHISLAINE MAXWELL's home. When <REDACTED> was first hired by
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, she was given more informal tasks while she was modeling.
One of her first tasks was to go to MAXWELL's house, where MAXWELL gave her
a list of items, like toiletries to pick up for the 301 66th Street address.

<REDACTED> was EPSTEIN's assistant. <REDACTED> saw <REDACTED> working with MAXWELL
as well. Some relationships were more formal and "office like", but
<REDACTED> and MAXWELL's relationship was more friendly.

Tasks that MAXWELL gave to <REDACTED> were errands like buying shampoo and
shirts for her and wanting to clean the office. In New York, the
office inside MAXWELL's house was small with three desks. <REDACTED> shared a
desk with MAXWELL. MAXWELL spent time at EPSTEIN's other residents.
<REDACTED> recalled the strange message she received from JEAN LUC BRUNEL.
<REDACTED> English was not great at the time. MAXWELL thought the message
was funny. MAXWELL either assisted or directed <REDACTED> in how to write the
message.

<REDACTED> had always felt a bit intimidated by MAXWELL. MAXWELL's attitude
came across that she was better than everyone else. <REDACTED> was
uncomfortable around MAXWELL and limited her time around her.

Investigation on 05/14/2021
Filer S00-NY-3027571
g New York, New York, United States (, Other (Video))
Ihwdmea 05/14/2021

3524-013
Page loll
FD.302a (Rev 54.10) 50D-NY-3027571 Serial 637
50D-NY-3027571
CominumionofM3Mla  (U1 Proffer of On 05/14/2021 p,s, 2 of 8

MAXWELL overlooked everything with EPSTEIN. MAXWELL and EPSTEIN seemed
to have a family like relationship. <REDACTED> was aware that MAXWELL and
EPSTEIN used to date. <REDACTED> was also aware that the house MAXWELL lived
in in New York used to belong to EPSTEIN. In EPSTEIN's houses, MAXWELL had
a bedroom and an office. In Palm Beach, MAXWELL's office was a small room
above the kitchen. In EPSTEIN's master bedroom, he had two bathrooms where
the one to the left was where the massages took place, and the other room
had a large closet where saw MAXWELL's clothes hanging. <REDACTED>
recalled that in New Mexico MAXWELL had a bedroom. thought it may
have been who mentioned MAXWELL's bedroom because she was assigning
bedrooms. recalled had stayed in MAXWELL's bedroom in New
Mexico. At every one of EPSTEIN's properties, MAXWELL acted almost like an
owner; people treated her like an owner.

<REDACTED> spent approximately 15-20% of the time around MAXWELL. While in
Palm Beach, <REDACTED> home was in proximity so she would get time off; she
would not always be around EPSTEIN's house. was mostly there at the
Palm Beach residence. <REDACTED> recalled traveling with MAXWELL approximately
15-20% of the time. recalled traveling to New Mexico with MAXWELL
twice. recalled traveling to Aspen with EPSTEIN and MAXWELL.
and EPSTEIN went to see LES WEXNER. <REDACTED> recalled MAXWELL being
there with a group of women and chewing them out.

<REDACTED> recalled when a new house manager, JANUSZ BANASIAK, started in
Palm Beach and brought in fresh flowers, MAXWELL was impressed. <REDACTED>
remembered a time where MAXWELL questioned her on the ice in the water she
was taking to EPSTEIN, asking if the ice was made from Evian.

While in Palm Beach, EPSTEIN received two massages a day. If <REDACTED>
traveled with EPSTEIN, sometimes <REDACTED> would call from New York to set up
the massages. <REDACTED> job was to reconfirm with them. <REDACTED> would
sometimes send the initial schedule and <REDACTED> would call . EPSTEIN then
wanted to confirm and reconfirm with them; she would have to call in
the evening and then the next morning.

<REDACTED> did not recall MAXWELL confirming massages. ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
may have confirmed massages.

When <REDACTED> was asked if she was aware of MAXWELL's knowledge of EPSTEIN
3524-013
Page 2 of 8
FD402a (Rev 54.10) 50D-NY-3027571 Serial 637
50D-NY-3027571
Continuahon ofFD-302 of (0) Proffer of on 05/14/2021 p 3 of 8

getting massages, she replied yes. In general, it was common knowledge
EPSTEIN had two massages a day. talked about a time in New Mexico
where EPSTEIN treated them to an outside location spa facility. MAXWELL
told they needed to find a pretty masseuse for EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN
sent MAXWELL, and possibly to a spa facility where each of
them were to be treated to a massage. MAXWELL said the masseuse for EPSTEIN
must be pretty and must be good at massage. MAXWELL said this to the group.

The phone books were contact address books. The pastel colored books
were EPSTEIN's books while the black small books were MAXWELL's books.
There was a section for massage contacts in them.

EPSTEIN noted once that when he and MAXWELL dated that MAXWELL would
bring more girls for threesomes, saying they were sexual relationships.
did not recall when or where EPSTEIN said this to her. EPSTEIN told
that MAXWELL brought him girls. As of the date of this interview,
impression was that this was for sexual activities. It surprised
that MAXWELL would bring other girls in for sex. When EPSTEIN told
this she did not think that was something MAXWELL would do. <REDACTED>
recalled MAXWELL dating other men. <REDACTED> described MAXWELL as "high end
and sophisticated" and did not think "those types" of people would do that.

EPSTEIN's expectations were when he had girlfriends they would have to
bring other girls in. When <REDACTED><REDACTED> dated EPSTEIN they brought
<REDACTED> in for sex and she told <REDACTED> that she <REDACTED> had to find
other girls for EPSTEIN.

When <REDACTED> was asked about what she said in a prior interview about
MAXWELL participating in threesomes, replied that she was talking
about what she just referenced in regards to EPSTEIN telling <REDACTED> that
MAXWELL participated in threesomes.

At the time <REDACTED> worked for EPSTEIN from 2004-2006 she did not get a
sense that he and MAXWELL were still in a romantic relationship. <REDACTED>
thought they were in a relationship years prior to working for them.

<REDACTED> took a lot of photographs, some of them of <REDACTED>. <REDACTED>
described them as "model type" photographs possibly for Victoria's Secret.
<REDACTED> was in jeans and a tank top on the island along the beach. <REDACTED> was
asked her to take off her top and bra, telling <REDACTED> that EPSTEIN said it
was ok. These types of photographs of other girls were on display all over
EPSTEIN's houses. These photographs were kept in large binders at MAXWELL's
house. They were in thumbnail form with Compact Disk's (CD) attached.
There was a large commercial printer at MAXWELL's New York house where the
thumbnails were printed; thought this was possibly why the binders
were kept there. described the binders as large with packets and
the photographs were burned onto CDs. There were contact sheets with
thumbnails, so they knew which photographs were on which CD. These binders
were stored in a large cabinet located past the three desks in MAXWELL's
office in her New York home. , and worked
there. There were approximately 8-10 binders of photographs. There were
other photographs as well. described a time in Palm Beach where she
was on the couch with IIII and stripped, took off her top, and
danced. EPSTEIN nudged to get the camera to take photographs.
Either or put together the binders. Everything was at the
request of EPSTEIN. enjoyed taking photographs; she had a nice
camera. MAXWELL asked them to clean the office once. felt MAXWELL
must have observed the printer and binders were there. They were intimate
photographs so they would not have been printed commercially. The intimate
photographs were of different women in binders that were mainly topless with
modal like poses. Some photographs were in EPSTEIN's gym along the whole
wall - they were all topless photographs. described the photographs
as women with an unknown age range. When asked if the age range was
18-20 years old, replied that the women were maybe younger but it
was hard to tell because of make-up and the model style photographs.
did not recall if MAXWELL took nude photographs. was not
sure if anyone other than took photographs. At the time<REDACTED> had
stopped working for them, the binders were still at MAXWELL's house.
MAXWELL sold the New York house at one point and thought the real
estate agent had possibly taken photographs of MAXWELL'S office.

In regards to the storage of contact information, <REDACTED> would get the
phone numbers for <REDACTED>. <REDACTED> made her own contact list that she typed
up. <REDACTED> printed a few copies and put them in a desk. When <REDACTED> came
back to New York, these were sometimes missing.

The notebooks had massage sections, but <REDACTED> never called from there.
3524-013
Page 4 of 8
FIT.302a (Rev 54.10) 50D-NY-3027571 Serial 637
SOD-NY-3027571
Continuahon of FD-302 of (U) Proffer of 0, 05/14/2021 pist 5 of 8
<REDACTED> only called people from the contact information given to her by
<REDACTED> and the contact list had made from contacts given to her by
<REDACTED> gave phone numbers. <REDACTED> was not sure where
<REDACTED> got the information from. contact list was created by hand
then typed up in a word document in Palm Beach. typed up and
printed a few and stored them in a drawer. recalled the list was
missing one time or had thrown it out because it was crumpled in the
trash can. was at a computer in Palm Beach at a desk near the
living room that she and used for work. created a digital
copy for herself. was not sure if anyone else had a digital contact
list for massages. thought the contact books for massages seemed
outdated.

(Agent note: <REDACTED> was shown a document titled "Masseusses". This
document is attached in a 1A.) did not recognize this document.
did not format her document how this one was formatted;
underlined the names. thought there were approximately 10 names on
the document she created but thought there may have been more than one
person on each line like having referrals listed.

<REDACTED> described there being message books around the house that had a
page that copied itself, notepads, and contact numbers and information.
Some of these were kept in the pantry behind the kitchen. There were white
notepads throughout EPSTEIN's home that had "Jeffrey Epstein" and "Ghislaine
Maxwell" written on them. Messages were kept on these notepads.

Phone numbers were kept in a system they used called Citrix. People's
numbers were also kept in books. MAXWELL had books with a black cover
throughout the house and EPSTEIN had books with a colorful cover throughout
the house. There were multiple copies of the books throughout the house.
believed that both sets of books had contact information for
massages. The contact information for massages was organized by location.
remembered skimming through the books and seeing this. MAXWELL's
black books were very simple as they were just black and white with simple
font. believed EPSTEIN's colorful books were black and white inside
and simple as well, but the font was slightly larger. advised she
may be able to recognize the books if she saw them; she has a photographic
memory. [Agent note: At this point in the interview, was shown a
document.] recalled this document to be one of MAXWELL's contact
3524-013
Page 5 of 8
FIT.302a (Rev 54.10) 50D-NY-3027571 Serial 637
50D -NY -3027571
ContinualionofFD-302 of (U) Proffer of On 05/14/2021 par 6 of 8
books. also recalled that the font for EPSTEIN would have been
larger. The contact books were printed and not updated. was given
a project to update EPSTEIN's books; she used the Citrix system to gather
the numbers from in order to update the books. did not recall being
asked to update MAXWELL'S contact books. During the time that
worked for EPSTEIN she did not recall anyone switching the books out.
When was asked if she recalled someone asking her to gather items
from the Palm Beach house, she stated yes. and EPSTEIN told her to
go to Palm Beach to meet someone to hand over the contact books and
computers. EPSTEIN, ) and flew into
Miami. was told to stay with while EPSTEIN and had a
meeting. thought the meeting was held at what is now called the
SOHO HOUSE HOTEL. thought EPSTEIN was involved in the construction
of the hotel. recalled telling her to meet a gentleman and
may have called before she met him. recalled the
conversation she had with EPSTEIN was where he told her that something
happened to his detriment and she needed to gather the stuff from the
house. thought she was meeting with a police officer or
investigator.
to the island. When arrived at the Palm Beach house, JANUSZ was
there and he helped her gather items. gathered the contact books.
recalled definitely gathering EPSTEIN's books, but she could not
recall if she grabbed all of MAXWELL's books. thought she gave both
sets to the gentleman. When the gentleman left, JANUSZ called and said that
he found a book, so called the gentleman back to hand it over.
recalled the gentleman to be thought this
was around October 6, because it was the day before her birthday.
also recalled stopping at a gas station and found a record of the stop on
her bank statement. had anxiety and stress while working for
EPSTEIN.
drove to Palm Beach, while and EPSTEIN flew on
recalled telling her to do the same thing on the island.
told to remove the contact books from the island and take
them to New York. thought she may have asked where all the
books were stored because there were so many buildings. This was possibly a
couple weeks after had already removed the books and computers from
Palm Beach.
3524-013
Page6of8
FIT.302a (Rev 54.10) 50D-NY-3027571 Serial 637
50D-NY-3027571
Continuahon of FD-302 of (U) Proffer of 0, 05/14/2021 p,s, 7 of 8
In Palm Beach, each desk had a computer. removed the computer
from EPSTEIN's office (the cabana by the pool), along with the computer that
she and used and the computer from MAXWELL's office. There was a
stationary computer that security used that did not remove from the
house.
removed the books from the island and took them to New York.
When returned to New York, she gave the books to
thought left the office with the books. This was around the time
that had been given the assignment to update the books.
asked what to do with the printouts of the contact numbers.
told to shred it. did not recall why told her to
shred it. just recalled EPSTEIN mentioning that something was
stolen or compromised. remembered EPSTEIN referring to visas and
immigration. did not remember if she discussed this with anyone
afterwards.
recalled an individual named MARK who was the IT person they
would call if they had computer issues. did not know if MARK worked
for WEXNER. thought MARK may have knowledge about the database they
used.
recalled MAXWELL being somewhat intimately involved in EPSTEIN's
life. MAXWELL was "very much present". MAXWELL had two assistants and she
was "Sort of like a boss". MAXWELL was one of EPSTEIN's friends and ex-
girlfriends. EPSTEIN kept certain people around his life, including MAXWELL
and EVA DUBIN, who was an ex-girlfriend. was also very close to
EPSTEIN. thought and MAXWELL were close as MAXWELL took
to some events. recalled that EPSTEIN bought a nice
fur for Christmas and it was to be kept at MAXWELL's home. MAXWELL was in
every detail. MAXWELL questioned the staff in New York. When MAXWELL
visited EPSTEIN's different homes, she seemed more like an owner. EPSTEIN
and MAXWELL were close. recalled EPSTEIN telling her that he
delivered the news of MAXWELL's father's death to her. MAXWELL had drivers
and staff who thought she was not nice. recalled a couple that
worked for EPSTEIN and saw the woman crying when she came in because
MAXWELL said something mean to her. MAXWELL seemed like EPSTEIN's person.
recalled that there was a couch on display at a store and the store
did not want to sell it. EPSTEIN said to have MAXWELL deal with it.
3524-013
Page7a13
FIT.302a (Rev 54.10) 50D-NY-3027571 Serial 637
50D-NY-3027571
ContinualionofFD-302 of (U) Proffer of On 05/14/2021 p,s, 8 of 8
There was a masseuse in Palm Beach, , who stayed at the New York
apartment. EPSTEIN helped get an internship with a teenage
magazine. MAXWELL was in charge of managing the apartment.
recalled that when left the apartment, there was something missing
from the apartment and MAXWELL said that must have took it.
(Agent note: At this point in the interview was shown a document.
This document is attached in a IA.] recognized the document as
being a printed copy from the Citrix database. was not sure which
of the books this would have come from. This would have been managed by
believed MAXWELL would have had knowledge of the massages.
MAXWELL managed EPSTEIN's houses and was very much present. Any person that
was in the houses would have knowledge of EPSTEIN's schedule and massages.
People spoke freely; someone may have said that EPSTEIN was getting a
massage. People walked through the kitchen and sometimes there was a girl
with another girl there. One girl went upstairs while another stayed in the
kitchen. recalled there was a chiropractor at the house and gave an
appointment to a girl that was there.
did not know what MAXWELL got out of staying with EPSTEIN. To
it seemed that EPSTEIN and MAXWELL shared assets. recalled
a time where EPSTEIN bought a new helicopter and became upset because it was
shaking. He blamed it on MAXWELL. MAXWELL seemed like family to EPSTEIN.
EVA was also like family
MAXWELL and EPSTEIN seemed to have a family like relationship.
3524-013
Page 8 of 8
EFTA00157613 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ witness prep of Juan Alessi (Epstein's former house manager in Palm Beach), describes Trump's visits
(date: 2021-06-08)
June 8, 2021 Juan Alessi prep
AUSA
SA
Det
Attorney Reynolds
•

• JA provided a copy of his separation agreement with JE
• Prior testimony
o
o Testified three times regarding Epstein

• Approximately 2004 or 2005, provided sworn statement to Detective from
PBPD
• After that, next time was a deposition in a civil case against Epstein

• After that, third time was a deposition in a civil case against Maxwell
•
• Shortly after JA left working for Epstein,
JA went back to Epstein's house and took
$6,400.
o JA was able to get into the house because JA had a key and no one was in the
house. JA knew the code to the safe.
o After JA stole the money, Epstein called JA, asked to meet up. When they met,
Epstein showed JA a picture from surveillance video of JA (at the time JA didn't
know there was a surveillance video in the house). Epstein told JA he wouldn't
press charges, but JA had to pay Epstein back.
o JA paid Epstein back approximately a couple months after that.
o JA made a statement at the PBPD about the theft.
o [JA provided AUSA with a copy of the receipt he received from the check he
wrote to Epstein to pay back the money]
o Epstein told JA never to go back to Epstein's house again, and JA never went
back.
•

• JA recalls seeing Epstein had a big silver gun, believes Epstein said it was a .45
o Near the end of JA employment with JE, JE bought a bunch of rifles
o JA never took or borrowed any of JE's guns
•
3504-039
Page 1 of 13
o Job for Epstein was basically like slavery. JA stayed there because he needed to
pay for his kids to get through college.
o Was awful because JA was blamed if anything was wrong at all. Epstein's home
was supposed to be run like a 5-star hotel.
0

• JA has read news about the criminal case involving Maxwell and Epstein
o JA has read about the charges in this case
o JA has read about civil cases making accusations against Maxwell
Preparation for Direct Testimony

• In the early 1990s, JA was doing maintenance for a lot of properties in Palm Beach. JA
met Epstein because JA was working on Lesley Wexner's mother's house. Lesley
Wexner recommended JA to JE because JE worked for Wexner's mother.

• JE hired JA to work maintenance on a property that Epstein had just purchased in or
about 1990. JA continued working for JE until about December 2002
o At first, JA's duties involved just maintenance and repairs
o At some point, JE asked if JA wanted to work fulltime just on JE's house, and JA
agreed
o JA's job responsibilities evolved from taking care of the house to running the
house. Running the house included taking phone calls, making appointments,
doing the shopping, preparing the food, cleaning, buy newspapers in the morning,
prepare breakfast
o JA would work from 5am until 10pm each day when JE was in Palm Beach
o When JE was in Palm Beach, JA slept in his quarters upstairs in the second floor
of JE's house.
o JA's wife started working for JE about 3 years after JA started, and she would
help JA with his responsibilities.
o When JE was not in Palm Beach, JA would sleep in his own home.

• JE's Palm Beach house was at 358 El Brillo Way
o 2-story home, 11 bathrooms, 8 bedrooms, pool house with a bathroom, large
home, three car garage, two stairways, two entrances (one front and one by
kitchen), large pool
2
3504-039
Page 2 of 13
o JA's room was in the second floor Southeast corner, far away from JE's bedroom
at the other end of the house

• Other than JE, Ghislaine Maxwell also gave JA instructions regarding how to do his job
o JA met GM about 6 or 7 months after JA started working for JE
o GM was a regular at JE's Palm Beach house the whole time JA worked for JE
after that
o GM had dark short hair, was tall, thin, had dark eyes, and was pretty
o After GM came into the picture, JE spoke with JA very little, and GM would give
JA instructions. For example, GM would instruct JA about what to buy.
Occasionally, JA would speak with JA, but mostly spoke with GM. GM would
tell JA what to cook, what to buy, when to schedule a massage. Sometimes JE
would tell JA he wanted a massage as well.
o JA understood that GM was JE's girlfriend
o When GM moved in, in the early 1990s, GM told JA that she would be handling
all the homes as an employee of JE's. GM told JA and his wife that GM was the
lady of the house. JA found GM & JE's relationship strange because he did not
see much love between them.
o JA had a very good relationship with JE before GM came into the picture
o After JE began dating GM, JA was no longer allowed to speak directly to JE. GM
told JA not to talk to JE directly. GM told JA not to ask questions and not to talk
to other people who were in the house.
o Closer to the end of JA's employment with JE, the rules changed.
■ About two years before JA stopped working for JE, GM told JA not to
look JE in his eyes.
■ About five years before JA stopped working for JE, GM told JA not to
engage in any conversations.

• At some point, JA received a booklet with instructions about how to run
the house. GM gave JA the manual and said it was made by a very
important person in England, and that's the way they wanted the
household to be run.

• While JA was working for JE, JE would come to Palm Beach about twice a week, and
sometimes for a full week.
o When JA learned JE was coming into town, he would have to rush and get the
house ready. There was never a set day or schedule far in advance for when JE
would come to Palm Beach.
o GM would often come with JE to Palm Beach. Sometimes GM would come to
Palm Beach by herself before JE arrived. But there were also many times when
JE would be at the Palm Beach residence without GM there.
o 99110 of the time in GM slept in JE's room. The room was at the other end of the
house from JA's room, towards the intercoastal, on second floor. Huge bedroom
with an attached bathroom for GM, and a second bathroom that was bigger for JE.
JE's bathroom had a steam room, a shower, a large closet. There was a sofa in
JE's bathroom.
3
3504-039
Page 3 of 13

• Over JA's years working for JE, females would come to the house very often.
o Sometimes with GM, sometimes with JE
o Sometimes JE had to pick them up at the airport
o The majority of these females appeared to be in their 20s
o They would hang around the pool, have meals, and go to the movies with JE &
GM
o Most of the girls would be topless by the pool. Most were European. JA
observed JE kiss the girls and pat them on the back.

• Over JA's years working for JE, many famous people came to the house.
o For example, Mr. Trump, Senator George Mitchell, John Kennedy Jr., Alan
Dershowitz, Frederick Fecai, Alberto Pinto, a general, Mr. Wexner, Nobel prize
winner, Prince Andrew and his wife

• JA and his wife took trips to JE's other properties
o One trip with JA wife to the ranch was for a session to teach them how to clean
and maintain JE's homes. JA and his wife were invited by GM and JE. Ranch
was in Santa Fe, NM. Was in or around the mid-1990s.
■ Ranch was very large with multiple cabins, JE's home way up in the
mountains. Home was incredibly big, Spanish style with a patio in the
center. Underground pool.
■ JA and his wife stayed in separate quarters, not at the house. House was
built but under construction.
■ Flew there on commercial air.
o JA once flew on JE's small private plane with GM to Miami and then back
o JA visited JE's private island during a vacation with his wife in St. Thomas.
Visited for a couple hours. This was about later 1990s.
■ JE's island was a paradise, small island with house with different pavilions
and different buildings. Main house was separate from the quarters,
multiple cabins. Pool. Very impressive property.
o JE would send JA and his wife on vacation every year. One time was a trip to
England.
■ Trip to England was sometime in the 1990s.
■ Went to Maxwell's house in London briefly, was a small townhouse.
Believe it was two floors, and only saw it for a few minutes. Living room
and kitchen on the first floor, her bedroom upstairs.

• During JA's time working for JE, JA recalls additional employees
o was an assistant for GM who traveled with GM and JE
o was an assistant who would travel with JE and GM
o JE had multiple chefs of the years. Included one named Rupert from England,
one named Didier from France, one named Andy from New York, one named
Adam from New York. Chefs would occasionally travel with JE and GM. Often,
though JE and GM would not come with chefs, so JE would have to cook.
started working for JE a few months before JA left. • took over
the phones when she came.
4
3504-039
Page 4 of 13
■ U answered phone calls and made appointments for massage therapists.
■ U would travel with GM and JE
o Larry Visoski and David Rodgers were JE's pilots
o Other than GM, JA recalls that JE had a girlfriend named
(unsure of spelling) who was . JE dated her when he was
still with GM.

• JA remembers seeing two young females at JE's Palm Beach residence during the time
JA worked for JE
• First was
o came to JE's house with her mother, where they met with JE and GM
•
o JA knew was because she was in high school. JE told JA to pick
up from
o IS and her mother came over about two more times for dinner with GM, JE, and
maybe
o After that, JA recalls seeing IS at JE's Palm Beach house about twice per week
o When SI came over to the house by herself, JE and GM were there. JA does not
recall if any other guests were around when SI visited.
■ JA observed talking with JE and GM during these visits

• JA recalls once time when
• JA recalls that U was a beautiful girl
■ JA observed JE kiss U hello. JA may have seen JE pat bottom.
■ JA does not recall any time when U visited the house but GM was not
present. It is possible that there were times when came over and JE
was not there.
o Sometimes JA would have to pick U up to bring her to JE's home.
■ JA picked U up from her home
■ JA also picked U up from her school
■ JA would pick s up in a black Mercedes
■ SI could not drive because she did not have a license. JA believes
was about 14 or 15 years old when he was picking her up and taking her to
JE's house
■ Either JE or GM would instructed JA to pick U up
■ U would sit in the back of the car when he picked her up. JA was not
allowed to talk with SI because GM told JA not to
o • would go to the movies with JE and/or GM
o When would visit JE's house, there would be times when JA would not see
and would not see what she was doing.
■ JA would be in the kitchen, and U would be on the other side of the
house with JE and GM.
■ JA was not watching where U went when she visited the house
5
3504-039
Page 5 of 13
o JA remembers one time came to JE's house with a suitcase
o JA does not recall the exact timeframe when was coming over to JE's house
■ JA believes it was approximately the late 1990s, but he does not remember
for sure
■ It was definitely when U was a student

• Second was --
o JA first saw when he was driving a convertible Mercedes to Mar-a-Lago spa
with GM.
■ That day, JA drove GM to many other spas and massage places in the
area. GM made me make a list of spas and addresses to visit them so that
she could see and meet massage therapists. JA made a list from the
telephone book. Was a hot day in the middle of summer. Last stop was
Mar-a-Lago.
■ After GM went in, as they were driving out, GM saw this girl in a white
uniform (JA later learned her name was a) and told JA to
stop. GM went and talked to the girl.
GM talked to her, then GM and JA went home.
■ Later that afternoon, was at JE's Palm Beach residence, and JA
learned name
o After that first visit, came to JE's house very often. Not every day, but two or
three times per week.
■ JA understood that was a massage therapist
■ JA observed GM and JE interact with at the house, but JA would not
hear their conversations
o JA knew that was very young because she didn't drive.
■ That first afternoon her father drove her to JE's residence.
■ Otherwise, she drove with her boyfriend.
■ Twice, JA picked up from her house where she
lived with the boyfriend.
o At the very end of JA's time working for JE, JA saw bringing two girls to
JE's Palm Beach residence.
■ JA doesn't remember their names, but they were young. They looked the
same age as a.
o JA observed El go to the airport with JE and GM and then get on JE's plane with
them multiple times.
■ Those trips were either to New York or the island
■ GM would make the travel arrangements
o JA does not recall exactly when he met and interacted with but he believes it
was approximately the early 2000s.
• Near the end of JA's time working for JE, JE would receive three massages per day. One
in the morning, one in the afternoon, and one in the evening.
6
3504-039
Page 6 of 13
o GM would either tell JA to call particular girls to schedule massages, or she
would make the calls herself
■ GM would tell JA who to call, and if that girl was not available, GM
would tell JA to call someone else
■ would also call girls to schedule massages
o JA had a rolodex in which he had the masseuses' contact information
■ Massage therapists would sometimes leave a card with JA
■ Sometimes JE would give JA the masseuse's phone number
■ Sometimes GM would give JA the masseuse's phone number
■ JA kept the rolodex in his office next to the kitchen
o JE got massages throughout JA's time working for him, but the frequency of
massages increased closer to the end of JA's employment
o There would be a different girl for each massage appointment. There were some
who were repeats, and others who only came once and never came back.
o Either JE or GM would tell JA when massage appointments needed to be
scheduled
o GM and JE would bring oils from overseas for use during massages.
■ The labels said they were made overseas, e.g., England, Paris, Tahiti.
■ JA would put them in JE's bathroom set of drawers
o JA was never present for any of JE's massages. The doors were never open when
JE received a massage.
o After massages, JA would go upstairs and prepare JE's room for the night.
■ JA would put away the massage table.
■ JA sometimes had to remake the bed after massages.
■ Most of the time JA had to clean up towels and oils.
■ Sometimes, JA would find vibrators. Some looked like a man's penis.
Others looked like neck and back massagers. JA would put gloves on,
wash the vibrators off, and then dump them in the basket in GM's
bathroom. GM had a wicker basket with those sex toys, a black vinyl
costume, adult pornographic videos in her bathroom.
■ JA did not see sex toys anywhere else in JE's house other than the basket
in GM's bathroom.
o Most of JE's visitors to the Palm Beach house received massages, but Mr. Trump
did not.
■ Either GM or JE would tell JA that a guest was going to receive a massage
and would tell JA to set up the massage table wherever the massage was
going to take place.
o JE received most of his massages in his bathroom
■ Sometimes, JE received massages in the pool house, very rarely by the
pool

• The majority of JE's massages were in JE's bathroom
• JA only found used sex toys in JE's bathroom
7
3504-039
Page 7 of 13

• Whenever JE & GM flew out of Palm Beach, they were either going to the island or to
NY
o JA was not involved in arranging travel
o When JE & GM were on the way to Palm Beach, either the pilot or GM would
call JA to say they were coming
o Either GM or JE would tell JA when they were leaving Palm Beach

• When someone would call JE's Palm Beach house and leave a message for JE, if JA
answered the phone, he would write the message down in a message book.
o The message book created a carbon copy. JA would give the top original to JA,
and the copy would stay in the book.
o The message books were by the kitchen phone or in JA's office off the kitchen

• JA recalls many photographs throughout JE's Palm Beach residence
o JA recalls photos of JE with the pope and with GM, photos with Prince Andrew
and important people on the tables on the first floor.
o JA also saw nude pictures on GM's desk close to the pantry. The photos were
unframed and contained nude females. The photos appeared to have been taken
by JE's pool in Palm Beach. GM had a camera and was often taking pictures.

• JA stopped working for JE in or about December 2002
o JA left because the job was terrible. JA was treated badly, and
the job was stressful. Closer to the end there were crazy rules coming up, and
asking JA to do stupid things like waiting with a tray of cool towels by the door
for JE when he came in from a jog. JA had to wear a tuxedo, wear a tie all the
time.
o JA also learned that JE and GM were interviewing other people to take JA's job.
o Closer to the end of his employment, JA told JE one of those girls is going to get
you in trouble. JE responded they only want money.
o JA signed an agreement when he left JE's employment. JA understood that we
was not supposed to talk with anyone about his time working for JE.
o After JA stopped working for JE, he never saw GM in person again.
• Since leaving JE's employment, many reporters have tries to speak with JA
o Some reporters have offered JA money to speak to them. One offered JA
$250,000 for an interview. JA always said no, never took any money.
o JA did not want to be a part of anything to do with JE.
8
3504-039
Page 8 of 13
SEPARATION AGREEMENT
SEPARATION AGREEMENT effective as of January 2, 2003 (the "Effective Date)
by and between JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN ("Epstein") and JUAN ALESSI ("Mr. Alessi") and
MARIA ALESSI ("Ms. Alessi").
WHEREAS, Epstein, Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi desire to memorialize their agreements
in connection with the cessation of employment of Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi by Epstein, upon
the terms, conditions and other provisions contained in this Agreement;
NOW, THEREFORE, Epstein. Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi, each intending to be legally
bound hereby, agree as follows:

I. CESSATION OP  Effective as of the Effective Date, each
of Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi ceased to be employed by Epstein.

2. BENEFITS. Epstein shall provide Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi with the
following:
(a) Upon the execution and delivery by each of the panics hereto of this
Agreement, Epstein shall pay, as severance to each, the sum of Thirty Thousand (530,000)
Dollars to Mr. Alessi and the sum of Twenty Thousand ($20,000) Dollars to Ms. Alessi. Each of

Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi acknowledges and agrees that the payment of such severance by
Epstein shall be subject to usual and customary payroll deductions for withholding taxes, social
security, disability, unemployment insurance and other items ordinarily deducted, in all cases in
accordance with Epstein's payroll practices currently in effect.

(b) Health insurance benefits coverage heretofore provided to each of Mr.
Alessi and Ms. Alessi in connection with his or her former employment by Epstein shall continue
through and until January 31, 2003. Epstein shall pay the costs to each of Mr. Alessi and Ms.
Alessi of continuing health insurance coverage under the applicable provisions of COBRA for the
period commencing February I. 2003 and ending on December 31, 2003.

3. PAYMENT FOR OBLIGATIONS.  Each of Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi
understands, acknowledges and agrees that: (a) the payments and benefits to be provided by
Epstein pursuant to the provisions of Section 2 are not required as a result of any pre-existing
legal or equitable obligation of Epstein or any agreement, arrangement or understanding between

Mr. Alessi or Ms. Alessi, on the one hand. and Epstein. on the other hand, and (b) such payments
arc to be made solely for, and in full and complete consideration of. the releases provided by Mr.
Alessi and Ms. Alessi, and Mr. Akssi's and Ms. Alessi's performance or, and compliance with.
their respective obligations, under the provisions of this Agreement.

4. PROPRIETARY INFORMATION.  All confidentiality and non-disclosure
obligations of Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi in respect of Epstein and any and all affiliates of Epstein
which were in effect prior to the Effective Date shall remain in full forte and effect and survive
the execution of this Agreement by the panics hereto.

5. RELEASE. Except with respect to Epstein's performance of his express
obligations under the provisions of this Agreement, each of Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi,
individually, as well as both of them collectively, and each in his or her capacity as the spouse or
the other, hereby releases, acquits and forever discharge (a) Epstein. (h) Ghislainc Maxwell. and
3504-039
Page 9 of 13

(c) all entities in which Epstein and/or Ms. Maxwell is either an officer, director, significant
shareholder, partner, manager, member or owner, either directly or indirectly (collectively, the
"Released Parties"), from any and all claims, liabilities, promises, controversies, damages,
actions, causes of action, suits, charges, demands, costs, losses, debts and expenses which either

Mr. Alessi or Ms. Alessi, or both of them, ever had or may now have, whether known or
unknown, whether specifically mentioned herein or not, which may exist or might be claimed to
exist by reason of any act, promise, allegation, utterance, writing, representation, rumor,
omission, thing, cause or matter whatsoever, including, without limitation, any aspects of Mr.
Alessi's or Ms. Alessi's employment by. or the cessation of his or her employment with, Epstein
and any other association or relationship between Mr. Alessi or Ms. Alessi with any of the
Released Parties, from the beginning of time through the date on which this Agreement has been
executed and delivered by both Mr. Alessi and Ms. Alessi.

6. GOVERNING LAW.  This Agreement shall be governed by, and construed,
interpreted, performed and enforced under, the laws of the State of Florida, applicable to
contracts executed and to be fully performed therein, without giving effect to conflicts of law
principles thereof.
7. ENTIRE AGREEMENT. This Agreement contains the entire agreement of
the parties hereto concerning the subject matter hereof, and, except as provided in Section 4 hereof,
supersedes any and all prior agreements between the parties hereto concerning the subject matter
hereof, which prior agreements are hereby canceled. This Agreement may only be changed,
modified or amended by an agreement in writing, signed by the parties hereto.
WHEREFORE, the parties hereto have read all of the foregoing, understand the same,
and have executed this Agreement on the date set forth below.
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN Date
JUAN ALESSI Date
MARIA ALESSI Date
2
3504-039
Page 10 of 13
STATE OF
COUNTY OF
)
)ss.:
)
On January 2003, before me, the undersigned, personally appeared
Jeffrey Epstein, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory
evidence to be the individual whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and he
acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his own capacity, and that by his
signature on the instrument, he executed the instrument.
STATE OF
COUNTY OF
) ) ss.:
)
Notary Public
On January 2003, before me, the undersigned, personally appeared
Juan Alessi, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory
evidence to be the individual whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and he
acknowledged to me that he executed the same in his own capacity, and that by his
signature on the instrument, he executed the instrument.
STATE OF
COUNTY OF
)
)ss.:
)
Notary Public
On January 2003, before me, the undersigned, personally appeared
Maria Alessi, personally known to me or proved to me on the basis of satisfactory
evidence to be the individual whose name is subscribed to the within instrument and she
acknowledged to me that she executed the same in her own capacity, and that by her
signature on the instrument, she executed the instrument.
Notary Public
3
3504-039
Page 11 of 13
INN WADHova
, Pay To The
Order Of  •-•11
OFFICIAL CHECK 2242
1020
1.1 0 .
of THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED DOLLARS AND DO CENTS  Milers
Nt ;
any 11100101 bosky.
Regt s
by MV Pigment Swans Inc rgEarwooci. Colorado CUSTOMER COPY , Aft Ora 16 Crace•20
John Alesaa
3504-039
Page 12 of 13
%WI° Western Surety Company LOST INSTRUMENT BOND
KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: Bond No. 69610804
of J r 9  , as Principal, and
WESTERN SURETY COMPANY, a corporation of Sioux Falls, South Dakota, as Surety, are held and firmly
bound unto  Neehavl a Bank
of
, and successors and assigns, as Obligee, in the sum of
Six Thousand Four Hundred and 00/100  DonArts (  $6,400.00  ),
lawful money of the United States, to be paid to the Obligee or lawftd representatives, for which payment, well
and truly to be made, the said Principal and Surety bind themselves, jointly and severally, by these presents.
WHEREAS, the aforesaid Principal is the owner or is entitled to the possession of
Cashier's Check No. dated October 17, 2003
and has lost, mislaid or destroyed said instrument or instruments, so that the same cannot be found or
produced, and
WHEREAS, the Obligee has agreed with the Principal on Principal's promise of indemnity, to duplicate
said instrument or instruments so lost, mislaid or destroyed, or to pay to said Principal or credit to said
PrincisalndesittV, the value thereof.
!sr.' „JO , The condition of this obligation is such that if the Obligee shall issue or cause to be
or Principal's order, new or duplicate instrument or instruments in place of the
'd or destroyed instrument or instruments, or if the Obligee shall pay to Principal or
' %runt the value thereof; and if the Principal shall in case the lost, mislaid or destroyed
is be found or come into the hands or power of the Principal, or to the hands, custody
or O , deliver or cause the same to be delivered unto the Obligee in order to be cancelled and
also s ittihes indemnify and save harmless the Obligee from and against any and all costs, actions,
suits, damages, charges or expenses, by reason of said lost, mislaid or destroyed instrument or instruments,
then this obligation to be void, otherwise to remain in fhll force and effect
Dated this  nth  day of  November  2003
Countersigned
By
Form 23541-2002
Resident Agent
WESTE
By
Paul T. Brufla , or Vice President
3504-039
Page 13 of 13
EFTA00008474 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2021-06-21)
PCCIONFISZ/OIMINON01/0 irmayserie
3990a
990 LL •ON
03ZINTORO AOA ON My
aV 31^ IS
ontioduted onv unoothontra tur-pu•r , •
FBI-NY Computer Analysis Response Team
90A -NY -31512 27
(Mundtion Two 1) Ultrwm t TO 0 lap'. tent)) ming the CART
Artwork archive ed video images taken horn MCC NY video
Rtnorde/ hard Oren, , as of 06/21/2021 Master Copy
FOR Of Mal USE ONLY - ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
ACKLSI13 E NIVH3 3.3N3WA3 NO11V'JI133A.\'130 IlV3IIFIR11(8303.1
///
Frozii,uoi

╭─────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────╮
│ 2209702                       │
│                               │
│ $5"                           │
│                               │
│ 6                             │
│ ean                           │
│ a qisten                      │
│                               │
│ wees                          │
│                               │
│ NIVED aoNaaIAa                │
│ NOLLVOLISZANT 40 nVauina Tata │
│                               │
│ roor-ad                       │
╰───────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00040083 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2021-07-15)
Materials Provided for Review:
Documents/Audio/Video:

I. Epstein Plea documents (SDNY_GM_00078754-00078773)
2. PBPD r orts 2005-2006 (SDNY_GM_00101088-00101174)

3. Day Planner (Native)
4. Diary Scrapbook (Native)
5. diary excerpts (AFARMER00010471-10477)
6. e mg excerpt re George Rush interview of JE (SDNY_GM_00131943)

7. Affidavit of George Rush (4.6.10) (SDNY_GM_00555837)
8. Supp Affidavit of George Rush (4.30.10) (SDNY_GM_00555849)

9. Affidavit of Michael Fisten (4.26.10) (SDNY_GM00133755)
10. JE Comprehensive report (12.6.18) (SDNY_GM_00171822)

11. Property Details report — NYC (SDNY_GM_00172151)
12. Property Details report — Florida (SDNY_GM_00172183)

13. Psych evaluation notes (SDNY_GM_00367309)
14. JE report card 1966 (SDNY_GM_00469627)
15. Photo — JE & 2 DNY_GM_00491334)

16. Email between & JE (5.5.10) (SDNY_GM_00717520)
17. Email between & JE (5.5.10) (SDNY_GM_02014856)
18. List of "Thoughts" from JE to Graydon SDNY GM_02735352)

19. Typed note from JE to Graydon re (SDNY_GM_02735353)
20. Email (9.12.02) (SDNY_GM_027
21. Trilateral Commission member 2003 (SDNY_GM_00080493)

22. Summons and Complaint (CMA v. JE/SK 2.25.08)
23. First Amended Complaint (CMA v. JE/SK 29.09)
24. Affidavit of Dr. Hall 8.18.09 (SDNY_GM_01986418)

25. GX-106
26. GX-107
27. GX-108
28. Government kr re disclosure of Expert Lisa Rocchio (4.23.21)
29. Government kr re disclosure of 3502 materials (4.23.21)

30. SDNY_GM_00789445
31. SDNY_GM_00970541
32. SDNY_GM_01005056
33. SDNY_GM_O 1674683
34. SDNY_GM_O 1674923

35. SDNY_GM_01906777-780
36. SDNY_GM_01915472
37. SDNY_GM_O 1937083
EXHIBIT C
38. SDNY_GM_00467727
39. SDNY_GM_00469609

40. SDNY_GM_00471694
41. SDNY_GM_00491238
42. SDNY_GM_00491263
43. SDNY_GM_00491290
44. SDNY_GM_00491303

45. SDNY_GM_00491927
46. SDNY_GM_00502151
47. SDNY_GM_00502694
48. SDNY_GM_00505588
49. SDNY_GM_00506534

50. SDNY_GM_SUPP_000 16748
51. Epstein Indictment (7.2.19)
52. Maxwell Superseding Indictment (7.20.20)
53. Maxwell Second Superseding Indictment (3.29.21)

54. JE and the Myth of the Underage Woman_The Atlantic (8.15.19)
55. Inside Woody Allen's Close Friendship w/ JE_Daily Beast (3.14.21)

56. Bill Gates Hoped Epstein Would Help him win a Nobel_NYPost (5.18.21)
57. Jeffrey had a Way of Making these People Materialize_VanityFair (10.01.19)

58. We Found JE's other little Black Book_Insider (7.6.21)
59. A story of power_podcast on Epstein_The Guardian (7.11.21)

60. De Georgiou article_Night & Day (7.25.04)
61. De eorgiou article_Tatler (8.28.19)
62. depo, Vol. I (11.10.09)

63. depo, Vol. II (11.10.09)
64. Epstein SORA Hearin 1.18.11)
65. Det. transcript (10.11.05) (SDNY_GM_00119201)
66.
Det.■ & t
depo v. axwell) (6.21.16) (SDNY_GM_00145214)

67. (SDNY_GM_SUPP_00219000-219005; 00122767)
68. (SDNY_GM_SUPP_00201375-201380)
69. (SDNY_GM_SUPP_00086948)

70. (SDNY_GM_SUPP_00086961)
71. (SDNY_GM_SUPP_00108247-108254)
72. DOC000000028277
73. DOC000000028230
74. Defiance Podcast - Epstein's Mentor — Episode 62 (10.12.20)

75. Chasing Ghislaine - Episode 5 (7.15.21)
76. Chasing Ghislaine - Episode 6 (7.15.21)
77. Chasing Ghislaine - Episode 7 (7.15.21)
2
3500 Materials:
3501-008-001
3501-019-001
3501-021-003
3501-022-001
3501-028-001
3501-053-006
3501-054-002
3501-102-001
3501-137-001
3501-142-004
3501-144-032
3501-104-001
3502-001 thru 3502-025
3505-001
3505-026
3505-100
3505-027
3505-030
3505-031
3505-034
3505-036
3505-035
3505-043
3505-044
3505-058
3505-028
3505-076
3505-079
3505-081
3505-059
3505-068
3505-074
3505-005
3505-090
3505-091
3505-088
3505-089
3505-092
3505-097
3
3509-003
3509-005
3509-008
3509-020
3509-001
3509-023
3509-028
3509-011
3513-009
3513-031
3513-002
3513-037
3513-005
3513-041
3513-045
3513-059
3514-001
3514-019
3514-023
3514-026
3514-006
3514-012
4
EFTA00276977 (Jmail)
 [girls] notes from Emma Sergeant interview describing being introduced to Trump by Epstein & Maxwell, see quote: "I have fear around her (Gm) Gm is 
extremely dangerous person behavior I’ve seen sociopathic"
(date: 2021-07-21)
7/21/21

Got Msg from Guy Louthan that he got subpoena but hadn’t heard from other people gave

<REDACTED> Lives in Portugal
<REDACTED>

Testified in court?
- Custody & child support hearing w daughter father ~2014/2015
She 7 now About 2 at time
Daughter father had substance abuse prob &
Had been negligent abusive
I awarded full legal custody
- Suggestion He did thought
- Judge find untruthful. No

Deposed?
No

GJ?
No

Recently settled lawsuit against
News Corp found to be Phone hacking tapping phones
myself & <REDACTED>
Paid amt money 95,000 pounds
Public apology in courtroom
England  2/3 months ago

not been sued

public reporting read, watched, etc ?
halfway thru Netflix 1st ep - most could get thru
1st ep GM doc on Peacock
no podcasts
read couple articles bout GM & JE some time ago
b4 charges periodically google JE see what happening
article 2019 Sunday Times
conola long
something like "naked ambition Sorry <REDACTED> don't believe you are a victim"
pretty scathing article practical attacking
me - it was nasty

She had reached out - we had worked  something separate prior
guess she doesnt like me

-> Dateline - I did - not compensated
piece about my organiz
I travel to do interview
think they covered flight
no they didnt

flight/hotel  FBI paid for travel to speak at hotel hearing
found out about (Dateline) when come out cohet

therapy sessions covered - think 8 maybe
Covered by FBI bout 1 1/2 yr ago may been 12
think some paid back bout 1/2 y ago

money paid back Ny ovs after settlement victim claim prog.

JE comp. fund - 3.25 million
not paid direct to me not in full
went law firm St 1st
fees

vic updates attend?
I meeting Regarding invest into (OPR Report)
invest.
Covered by govt flight/hotel

time of hearing charges, dismissed
Spoke w/<REDACTED>
limited way
cant remember last name
She outlined her experience limited way
couple phone convos & Whats app msgs w/ V
usually just think bout you, hope ok
after hearing   when you saw things in news

other than detail in Dateline I havent talked Much

V quite keen to have me cooborate her on
island - said couldnt do that cuz not sure
people on Dateline most shared their story
I shared the least talked as group
more so feelings associated less details

<REDACTED> put 2gether text group
I removed myself fun

1 vic older than me connected thru Brad &
<REDACTED> more so telling me her
experience

Im in AA
2 sponsors over 16/17yRS
been sober 18 yrs
<REDACTED> knows GM quite well
her fam connected to Gm fam

one of 1st people I told - not in detail
2006 Prob talked her bout it

Jay Westbrook- let him know about both JE & Gm
prob 5 yes ago talked

<REDACTED> When came back from island
I 22/23 - She repeatedly asked me
what was wrong/going on & why GM
kept calling me

T was my bestf
Spent 60/70% time 2gether   would been around when GM call
that age tell of everything
notice Shift in Charactere

Robert Hanson
he introduced me to GM
we still in contact
believe he at oxford w GM

dont think he aware what going on
think he privileged enough not to see what
he didnt want See
R is part of system in England that allows behavior to continue
not responsible for it
abuse of power by wealthy & powerful men kept England going some Time
making jokes about it /making light
when JE 1st arrested talked R
thought it was very funny
R & I dated on/off many yes
I would say I went along w it
didnt feel I could challenge it
I had email comm w/ JE when he in prison that seemed like comfort
Im fearful it be presented in bad light
1st he (R) knew bout my experience was after Ny hearing
I was in lot press in UK
he called me $ said oh youre quite famous

arrested-no
drugs periodic addict
cocaine (around 16 last: May 1, 2003
2-3 day then
ble if take last
(around 17 R introduce mc) break Sleeping pills
never abstinate think smoked pot 2x (proble, prob early 20s)
Toger than couple WKS
2-3x wk
cocaine cant sleep 2-3x wk
on or b4 5/1/03

no substances now
never sold drugs
prob given drugs other people
- cocaine
wasnt common thing bc wasnt my cocaine
Flat - Notting Hill when got divorced
23-27 most likely shared

Shoplifred
Stole bra from dept Store in teens
gum from gas station 2x late teens

mail
no

credit card w permission
I married - my card but he mad - joint account w/ my husband

fraud scheme
no

broke into house /store no

robbery no

applied public assistance
EDD - when on maternity leave
mat comp in us so can stay home
application did not lie

lied on taxes - no
fake id - no
give fake name to LE - no
.    lie       "  "  - no
false police report - no
involve physical altercation/fight -
* crazy woman who stalked me
Jasmine Leonard - created fake
social med pages pretend be me
She pushed me over into Road

she preg. 7/8 mo - she attacked me
I obvi did not attack back
I went to police about fake media / stalking / hit me
around 10 yrs ago

• Vic of dv w/ relationship daughter father
-2 dv restraining orders I filed
-2014/2015
- quire a few in varying severity
- had take daughter to hospital b/ce she
had bruising around eyes
- he was high
- his story she had allergies in eyes
- he Sucked on her eyes like animal
she in her care
I went pick her up

Id take friend b/c he sometimes verbal/ physical abuse to me

CPS called on you - no
possess CP - no
sex for money-no
gang assoc. -no
possess gun - no
diagnose mb - no
meds- no

anythingal media /internet could be used
I have one IG account private
not in my my name & not my photo
pics of dog & me my kid

Ive had slighty risque photos taken of me btw 18-20
I wasnt paid for them
theyre not pornographic
breasts ( nude top up)

Stuff I did hurt me not something done someone. else
Ive had abortions
not something excited or pleased about

When Je Thing took off
Jasmine attacked me social media
twitter <- <REDACTED> nonsense accusations

late teens /early 20s height of addiction
Tom Parkables. Camilla son
Story about drug abuse & I in it
bout me drug seeking.

alcohol 1st abuse b/w 16-18
I grew up South of France we given wine/champagne  13/14

use varied over time
binge
Short periods sobriety followed by binges

articles about
apart from Robert stories are gossip-not true

Stories I playboy model not true

I was on tv reality show w/ Hasselhoff
I help him w/ alcohol & his daughters
he said could you be coach to my daughters
show was to help them

producers wanted something more

Staged me jump up kiss him
me thank him for
reveal never took place
I never dated him

Trump - no

GM brought me to party in NY
She seemed very excited s there be
lots of great men for me to meet there
she like presented me
run down of my accolades - my CV kind of thing

she present me to Donald
We have convo for like 20 min
I invited to Mar A Lago
given tour by DT w JE/GM
nothing happen btw me & DT

but made clear I be available
by GM things say

“Oh I think he likes you. Arent you lucky. This is great”
article 1997 20 yr  <-  I think I 22

I was given suggestions things to wear
“oh he’ll like that. He doesnt like that”
my role

queue set up very much w JE

GM introduce me to Harlan Peltz in NY
[ she said someone reached out ]
def w/ pretex this is guy for you
he & friends - dated much later
he good guy

another man Gm introduced me to
he lived next door to Gm
he passed away due to alcoholism
Michael Garland
I helped raise his children - we're very close
he much older than me
his eldest child remembers living next door to Gm
7 at time

Gm fam was very much like my moms fam
her father like my moms father
connected in that way - deep connection
think that's why she recognize me as
suitable for that role she needed

I have fear around her (Gm)
Gm is extremely dangerous person
behavior I’ve seen sociopathic
fear if she not convicted
EFTA01249911 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Interlochen Center for the Arts vice president
(date: 2021-09-17)
FD•302(Iter.54.10)
50D-NY-3027571 Serial 642
-1 of 5 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
nmeofewn  09/17/2021
was interviewed over video conference. Present for the
interview was Assistant United States Attorneys and
along with Special Agent
After being advised of the identity
of the above listed individuals and the nature of the interview,
provided the following information:
was contacted by private investigators from the defense team;
they sat on his porch for a bit and talked.
As of the date of this interview, was retired and living in North
Carolina. Prior to his retirement was a fundraiser.
worked in theatre in Baltimore. has worked in DC for Academic
Travel Abroad and for the Mountain Institution.
(Agent Note: At this point in the interview, the interviewing team was
made aware that AMBROSE's wife was present in the room.)
pent
National Parks.
his whole career in fundraising. worked with
worked at INTERLOCHEN. From 1990-1999, AMBROSE was the Vice
President of Advancement. His duties included public relations,
fundraising, marketing, and alumni relations. was based in Michigan
at the time. There was a staff of about 20 people in which managed
the department, including senior fundraiser, secretaries, and employees.
interacted with major donors. Major donors gave a gift of
approximately $5000 or $10,000. interacted with JEFFREY EPSTEIN.
Around 1991 or 1992 AMBROSE was contacted by an alumna that lived in New
York and was involved in a dance organization in New York. AMBROSE did not
remember her name. This alumna had met EPSTEIN and he was interested in
invomptiomon 06/02/2021 New York, New York, United States (, Other (Video))
File" 500 -NY-3027571 Datedrafted 09/08/2021
by
This tkicument contains neither recommendations nor COCICiUNI011$ of the FBI. II is the property of the FBI and IM1 
loaned to your agency. II and its contents
are not
to be distributed outside your agency.
3501.478-001
Page 1 of5
FD•302a (Rev. 5-8-10) SOD-NY-3027571 Serial 642
500-NY-3027571
Communion of FD•302 of CU) Interview of On 06/02/2021 ,per  2 of 5
supporting INTERLOCHEN. EPSTEIN offered to host an event at his office
and/or his house in Manhattan. met EPSTEIN to talk about this event
in New York in the winter time; there was snow on the ground. and
EPSTEIN talked; EPSTEIN wanted to host an event and said he would cover all
costs for the event, including food, etc. EPSTEIN and would be in
touch about setting up a date.
met EPSTEIN on the INTERLOCHEN campus once.
EPSTEIN was interested in knowing where INTERLOCHEN was going
financially.
recalled EPSTEIN hosting another event at his office.
MIKE WALLACE was an alumani. They wanted to recognize him as an
alumnai. EPSTEIN hosted an event for him.
There was a phone conversation that had with EPSTEIN set up
through MAXWELL to build a log cabin on INTERLOCHEN's property. It would be
to have guests and parents stay at the property. They upgraded for visitors
who performed.
EPSTEIN says he is interested in supporting and asked how he could help.
INTERLOCHEN wanted a 2-4 family facility. EPSTEIN sent his
architect plans. MAXWELL calls on multiple occasions telling them
what EPSTEIN wanted to do. EPSTEIN wanted to build a log cabin. MAXWELL
tells them details of what he wants and says it has to be
handicap accessible. EPSTEIN flew in a performer that was handicap.
MAXWELL was the gate keeper for EPSTEIN. You had to go through MAXWELL
to make an appointment or to visit EPSTEIN.
There were phone calls back and forth between and MAXWELL then
EPSTEIN would eventually agree on the plans. EPSTEIN sends a check and they
build the cabin. meets with EPSTEIN prior to building the cabin
then about once or twice after that.
EPSTEIN stayed in the cabin a few times. MAXWELL gave
instructions on what he needed to eat and what to have ready on the
property. would get flower for the cabin. would wait for
his arrival but sometimes he would be late and would not see him.
3501.478-001
Pgge2of5
F0.302a (Rev. 5-8-10) SOD-NY-3027571 Serial 642
500-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (0) Interview of ,On 06/02/2021 ,per  3 of 5
MAXWELL was there at least 2 times. does no specifically remember
the first occasion. MAXWELL was his right hand man always taking care of
his accommodations.
The campus was open all year long but summer time was the popular time to
visit. MAXWELL and EPSTEIN had to visit between June 1 - August 15.
They let EPSTEIN come and stay 2 weeks a year at his request because of
his donations. MAXWELL calls and requests a time and date to come.
would arrange his arrival and his food for the cabin. MAXWELL and
EPSTEIN would come and stay.
There are about 100 buildings on the campus and its an open campus.
There was always a music performance going on and very much a public place.
EPSTEIN's cabin was segregated away from the main campus.
The main campus consisted of classrooms, a small hotel, a cafeteria,
student housing and a performance site.
The junior boys camp is across the street.
About a quarter to half a mile down the road are more visitors lodges
where EPSTEIN's lodge was located.
***Agent note: At this point prosecutors share their screen with to
show him several documents. These documents are attached in a 1A.
states the following after reviewing each document. ****
Page 1 (11/12/1993): "That's me and that's my signature". does
not remember sending this letter and says he sent a lot of letters to their
donors. This letter is agreeing that the lodge will be handicap
accessible. states that's probably the first gift.
Page 2 (7/27/1993): PEARLMAN coming to campus. Corresponds to
EPSTEIN's interest in the place being barrier free. did see him
this summer and remembers meeting with him but is not sure if MAXWELL was
there.
Page 3 (12/29/1993): Memorandum, don't remember but possibly because they
received a check. That $15K+$185K would round up to $200K sounds like a
3501.478-001
Pgge3of5
F0.3022 (Rev. 5-8-10) SOD-NY-3027571 Serial 642
500-NY-3027571
Convention of FD•302 (U) Interview of 06/02/2021 ,r age 4 of 5
wonderful gift.
Page 4 (11/10/1993): does not recognize.
looked at the document and filed.
would have just
Page 5-6 (2/9/1994): $200K for the new lodge (the 15K + 185K).
does not remember this letter. does not have a memory of when the
lodge was created. notes the 2 weeks of use paragraph). They were
going to make a scholarship from the income that they received from the
lodge called "The Jeffrey E. Epstein Scholarshi ". had invited
EPSTEIN to stay at the cabin that summer. references a concert.
PEARLMAN would have performance a concert in August. EPSTEIN flew him in
prior to the lodge being built and then again after.
Page 7 (12/23/1994): remembered something about that. There was a
financial envelope with a bank or Wall Street thing there and included in
the package. invited EPSTEIN back to campus. did not
recall whose financial information. Most of the communication was through
MAXWELL. Many times MAXWELL was the gatekeeper. This was probably why
AMBROSE sent this to her.
d id not recall EPSTEIN scholarship students. The private
investigator that contacted AMBROSE showed him documents and then AMBROSE
remembered. 'I'll'. recalled a young lady they acknowledged that was
receiving a gift - receiving the Jeffrey Epstein scholarship.
People approached saying they were sponsoring a certain
individual. INTERLOCHEN would not accept gifts to offset someone
attending. This was so INTERLOCHEN was not put at risk.
EPSTEIN approached to put money towards a student.
position was to always say no.
hought
read that EPSTEIN had sponsored students. The scholarship office
was a separate office; this was not through office. The business
office would handle EPSTEIN's payments for students. PAT KESSEL was the one
who would have handled this. When grandparents would want to make
contributions to go towards a student,
IIIIIII
told them they had to go to
the business office.
AMBROSE's conversations with EPSTEIN were very business like; EPSTEIN was
3501.478-001
Page 4 of 5
FD•302a (Rev. 54-10) SOD-NY-3027571 Serial 642
500 —NY-3027571
Continuation of FD•302 of CU) Interview of On 06/02/2021 ,p age 5 of 5
a very abrupt individual.
IIIIIIIIwas sure there were records at INTERLOCHEN for the timeframe
regarding EPSTEIN's lodge.
In retrospect, recalled asking about their (EPSTEIN and MAXWELL)
visit regarding how much bread, cheese, etcetera to get. MAXWELL told him
that she, EPSTEIN, and their personal masseuse was coming.
remembered getting a big bouquet of flowers to put in the lodge.
remembered looking for a vase to put them in and had to run out to get one.
This was the summer time. EPSTEIN's lodge was separate from campus; people
would not see others coming and going.
3501.478-001
Page 5 of 5
╔════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Eric Gainey [employee] Epstein's accountant 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01246216 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Lesley Groff, see quote: "he did not have the number of a trader. GROFF had anxiety trying to get a trader. EPSTEIN did
a lot with politics"
(date: 2021-09-24)
FD.302 (Rev. 5.8.10) -1 of 9 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  09/24/2021

LESLEY GROFF, date of birth (DOB) was interviewed pursuant
to a proffer agreement at 39 Broadway Suite 1610, New York, New York.
Present for the proffer was GROFF's attorney Michael Bachner. Also present
for the proffer was Assistant United States Attorneys and
, along with Special Agent . After being advised of
the identity of the above listed individuals and the nature of the
interview, GROFF provided the following information:

GROFF is in retirement along with her husband. GROFF has a
son. GROFF enjoys exercising and listening to books on tape. GROFF
resigned in July 2019 from working for JEFFREY EPSTEIN (EPSTEIN). GROFF had
started working for EPSTEIN in February 2001.

GROFF attended college in North Texas and is a UTD graduate. GROFF lived
in Texas then met a man who lived in New Jersey which caused her to move to
the area. GROFF worked for nine years at an office supply company. GROFF
then divorced. GROFF then worked at Nordstrom. GROFF met her current
husband at a triathlon; GROFF was still working at Nordstrom at the time.
GROFF wanted to be an event planner and thought Wall Street would be a great
place to work.

A headhunter, RUSSELL, found her resume on Monster. GROFF was looking at
a job to work for the Knicks, but it was taken. GROFF met with RUSSELL and
he told her that there was a job to organize one man's life. This man was
EPSTEIN, a Manhattan socialite. GROFF had never heard of EPSTEIN before
this. GROFF interviewed for the position. GROFF interviewed with
, who was GHISLAINE MAXWELL's (MAXWELL) assistant at the
time. Then GROFF interviewed with MAXWELL before interviewing with EPSTEIN
the next day when he was in town. GROFF interviewed at 457 Madison on the 4
th floor; this location was part of a palace. GROFF was in the front office
before going to EPSTEIN's office. GROFF met with all three people on the
Investigmionm 07/23/2021
Filen SOD-NY-3027571
at New York, New York, United States I, Other (Video))
Date drafted 08/03/2021
by
This document comairn neither reo.mimendations nor conclusions of the FBI. It is the property of the Fill and is loaned 
to your agency; m and its content., are
not
to be distnbuted outside your agency.
3501.098.015
Page 1 of 9
FD.3022 (Rev. 5•&10)
50D-NY-3027571
Contumation of FD.302 of (U) Proffer of LESLEY GROFF 07/23/2021 page 2 of 9

same day; it was a normal interview about being an executive assistant.
During the interview, the phone kept ringing. EPSTEIN would talk then hang
up. It seemed to be a very vibrant office.

GROFF had to sign a non-disclosure agreement. If GROFF spoke about
business people, which GROFF thought included LES WEXNER (WEXNER), she would
owe him $100,000. GROFF had never seen anything like the non-disclosure
agreement before working for EPSTEIN.

GROFF had her own office in the back. Others that worked at the office
were two attorneys, an assistant, a trader, a travel assistant IIII
, and MAXWELL came in and out of the office.

EPSTEIN did not work a 9-5 schedule. EPSTEIN gave GROFF pages including a
call list, who he wanted to see, and appointments. GROFF had to reorganize
and shift things. At the time, GROFF made all phone calls, including
calling the driver, chef, and other people. GROFF had two phones on her
desk; it was hectic. GROFF was told that mistakes were not tolerated. It
was challenging; GROFF liked that. Sometimes, GROFF went home in tears;
sometimes for messing up his day. GROFF felt it was pretty incredible to
see all the people EPSTEIN dealt with in politics, television, etcetera.
GROFF felt "wow"; prior to working for EPSTEIN, she never knew people who
owned a plane, etcetera. GROFF found out about MAXWELL's father and life.
GROFF felt like their (EPSTEIN and MAXWELL) lives were the lifestyle of the
rich and famous.

GROFF described getting into the office she would have to go in through
the palace and go straight through the hotel portion. The left side was
where EPSTEIN's office was located. GROFF thought on the fourth floor was
where the office was located. There were other businesses in the building.
They had a view of the 5th Avenue Cathedral. Once off of the elevator, there
was a desk for the receptionist - GROFF could not remember if this was there
the day she left. After going straight, there would be a large office for
two accountants and the trader. The accountant was ERIC GAINEY (GAINEY),
who had an assistant accountant BELLA KLEIN (BELLA). The trader was HARRY
BELLER (SELLER) . The person who was EPSTEIN's assistant would be at the
receptionist desk; someone was always there and it changed over time. There
was ), an'
). The controller was EMAD HANNA (HANNA) . When GAINEY
left, he was replaced by RICH KAHN (KAHN) . To the right of the office were
3501.098-015
Page 2 of 9
FD.302a(tev.54-4°)
50D-NY-3027571
Conti:notional I' D402 of ( U ) Proffer of LESLEY GROFF 07/23/2021 .page 3 of 9
the attorneys, DARREN INDYKE (INDYKE) and JEFF SCHANTZ (SCHANTZ). Straight
back was GROFF's office. Towards the left was EPSTEIN's office and towards
the right was a desk for MAXWELL and her assistant LAUREN
QUITNER (QUITNER) was an assistant to the attorneys. There was a desk for
which changed to ) when left.

EPSTEIN wanted an estate manager, which kept turning over. There were a
lot of people in the office. They first started building MAXWELL's house.
After her house was built, she moved her and her assistant to her house.
MAXWELL was maybe at the office once a week and brought her dog Max.
Full-time employees included the attorneys, QUITNER, , and the
people in the front office. GROFF worked 9-S Monday through Friday for the
first couple years. GROFF then became pregnant and had a son and was off
for about 3-4 months. took over while GROFF was on maternity leave.
Approximately a year and a half later, MAXWELL's assistant left and
moved back to being her assistant.

GROFF started a job share where she worked Tuesday, Wednesday, and
Thursday and III worked Monday and Friday. EPSTEIN would leave New York
Friday and return Monday night. EPSTEIN wanted GROFF there to do the call
list. EPSTEIN called in the morning to schedule business meetings,
architects, designers. When GROFF would think he was done, he'd decide he'd
want to do it all over again. GROFF remembered seeing an invoice of a
carpet for an airplane that was more than she made.

Back then, GROFF did not use email. EPSTEIN called constantly. EPSTEIN
told her to call a certain individual then he would want an immediate call
back. GROFF relayed messages, make and break appointments, and contact
houses. GROFF would have JOJO sit outside certain locations. GROFF made
appointments for lunch dates, but he did not like; people would come eat but
he would not eat. EPSTEIN did not like wasting time.

The first time EPSTEIN laid into GROFF was when she moved an appointment
and forgot to tell the other person. EPSTEIN did not let it go; GROFF
ruined his whole day saying he can't get that time back.

GROFF would tell the pilot when EPSTEIN wanted to leave. For example,
GROFF would tell the pilot he would want to "leave tomorrow at 4pm to Palm
Beach". GROFF did not make airline reservations at the time; made
3501.098-015
Page 3 of 9
FO.302a(tev.54-40)
50D-NY-3027571
Conti:notional:D.3020f (U) Proffer of LESLEY GROFF .on 07/23/2021 .page 4 of 9
those reservations then. EPSTEIN told GROFF to tell to make the
reservations. A lot of people traveled on EPSTEIN's plane. EPSTEIN might
tell GROFF. The lingo he used was "do you need a ride". GROFF would call
and ask if he wanted friends then GROFF would call them. The pilot, LARRY,
needed to know. GROFF would ask EPSTEIN then she would relay that
information to LARRY. Sometimes, EPSTEIN told GROFF who was traveling with
him and other times he told LARRY himself. GROFF talked with EPSTEIN when
he was away. EPSTEIN often traveled with MAXWELL. The first year
traveled often with them as well then traveled with them. The
assistants traveled with EPSTEIN. TED MEISTER (MEISTER) was on the plane a
lot; he liked to go to Palm Beach. MAXWELL and were usually on the
plane with EPSTEIN.

MAXWELL traveled quite a bit. GROFF thought MAXWELL did her own things
as well. GROFF was not MAXWELL's assistant and did not see her as much.
MAXWELL was a big part of EPSTEIN's life. MAXWELL introduced EPSTEIN to a
lot of people in her circle. This was GROFF's perception because GROFF knew
her background. GROFF's impression was that she knew that was how EPSTEIN
met royalty - through MAXWELL. MAXWELL did not talk to GROFF. GROFF never
had normal conversations with MAXWELL or EPSTEIN. MAXWELL told GROFF she
was not to engage in frivolous conversation with EPSTEIN. If GROFF bought
movie tickets for EPSTEIN, she was not allowed to ask if he liked the movie
the next day.

GROFF did not have a lot to do with the CLINTON trip. MAXWELL dealt with
the details. GROFF's perception was that MAXWELL knew CLINTON first but
GROFF did not know for sure.

GROFF recalled a conversation with MAXWELL in the very beginning,
probably around GROFF's first week. MAXWELL told her, "You're here to
work." MAXWELL told her that EPSTEIN did not need extra conversation and
that she was not allowed to fraternize on the phone, that the people she
spoke to were EPSTEIN's friends not GROFF's friends. GROFF found this
similar to Wall Street in that she could not fraternize.
GROFF was asked to go to a party. This was probably within the first
month of working for EPSTEIN. GROFF went to the party with her husband, who
knew other Wall Street people. EPSTEIN found out and "torched" her the
following Monday. EPSTEIN told GROFF he was going to fire her but put her
3501.098-015
Pagc 4 of 9
FO402a(kv.54-10)
50D-NY-3027571
Continwflionof FD-30201 (U) Proffer of LESLEY GROFF ,On 07/23/2021 .page 5 of 9
on probation instead. GROFF had to keep herself totally separate. It made
sense to GROFF, so she never did it again.
From the beginning, massage was a part of EPSTEIN's day; they were normal
appointments. GROFF thought MAXWELL told her EPSTEIN had to have a massage
every day. and III trained GROFF too, but GROFF thought MAXWELL
told her that. It was presented like it was totally normal. and
III had been there prior to GROFF and no one seemed like it was out of the
ordinary. GROFF's job was to make appointments. To GROFF, making massage
appointments was just another appointment she had to make for EPSTEIN.
EPSTEIN would call GROFF in the morning and say something like, "Call
and see if she can do a massage at 4." EPSTEIN would then call GROFF every
15 minutes. If GROFF told EPSTEIN she could not get " ' he would tell
GROFF to call someone else instead.
There was a directory of contacts, not just massage people. Anyone could
go in and update the list; everyone had access. It was kept on the computer
in an old antiquated system. GROFF thought it was just a file on the
computer; they used PCs not Apple computers. They had a message sheet and
directory. There was an IT guy who came every so often if they had computer
problems. When GROFF was told to call someone, she would pull the phone
number from the directory. EPSTEIN gave GROFF a name and phone number, but
if the person had been around for a while, the number would be in the
computer.

For massages in New York at EPSTEIN's residence, GROFF scheduled for New
York. GROFF thought she may have scheduled massages for EPSTEIN's Palm
Beach residence, but it was not as much. When EPSTEIN left New York and
took an assistant with him, the assistant took over the daily things in Palm
Beach, New Mexico, and Paris.

GROFF had a call list everyday of people she had to call for EPSTEIN.
Outside New York, GROFF did not know who scheduled the massage
appointments. GROFF did not recall specifically making appointments outside
of New York, but stated that it was possible. GROFF definitely made
appointments in New York.

GROFF thought MAXWELL made an extra book. GROFF described the book as
super thick that was printed in a larger type to see. It was a little black
3501.098-015
Page 5 of 9
FD.3022 (Rev. 5•&10)
50D-NY-3027571
Conti:notional FD402 of (U) Proffer of LESLEY GROFF _0,, 07/23/2021 ,page 6 of 9
book. MAXWELL had them printed and bound. GROFF thought she wanted to have
them on the plane or next to the phones. GROFF recalled seeing one on her
(GROFF) desk. The black books were around. There was one on GROFF's desk
when she first started working there. They were next to EPSTEIN's phones on
the desk. GROFF did not know why she associated the books to MAXWELL; they
were there before GROFF worked there. GROFF thought the books had been
updated. GROFF did not know where they were printed. GROFF did not use the
books; she used the computer. GROFF thought the books were everywhere, but
maybe not in the accounting office. The books were at his homes. They were
on the desk in rooms. There were a lot of important people in the books
with their phone numbers, including politicians, actors, Wall Street
individuals, and royalty. GROFF was not supposed to take the book home.
GROFF thought the book fizzled out. It made sense that EPSTEIN wanted them
next to the phone. It was just a tool for contacts. The book went away, but
GROFF did not know when this happened. They changed over to Mac Computers.
EPSTEIN wanted to keep things simple. EPSTEIN wanted a list of dentists,
scientists, etcetera. GROFF did not think she was there when the directory
was first made, but was not sure. MAXWELL was an office manager and had
stationary made. MAXWELL may have asked to have them made. GROFF
thought maybe she was assuming that MAXWELL made them.

[Agent note: At this point in the interview, GROFF was shown a document with
a list of names and contact information. This document is attached in a 1A.]
GROFF advised, "This looks like people he'd contact." GROFF did not
recognize this specific document, but it looked like something GROFF could
have typed up. GROFF recognized the names on the document. It seemed
typical of when EPSTEIN would travel. A word document possibly could have
been GROFF who copied and pasted from the directory to word. Using a Mac
computer GROFF could copy and paste but she did not think she could copy and
paste to word using the older computers. The list of people's names and
numbers was constant.

[Agent note: GROFF was shown a document titled "Masseuses". This document
is attached in a 1A. ] GROFF advised that this document looked like
something that would definitely be in the office that EPSTEIN asked to be
put together. There were other documents made for architects, etcetera.
GROFF advised this document did not look familiar. GROFF did not recall
making this document but stated she was not saying she did not create it.
3501.098-015
Pagc 6 of 9
FD.3022 (Rev. 5•&10)
50D-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD.302 of (U) Proffer of LESLEY GROFF 07/23/2021 .page 7 of 9
GROFF advised the document looked old. GROFF recognized the names. To
GROFF, this was just another list. GROFF recalled having to make a list of
all the Ted speakers when she started. The lists printed out would be more
for EPSTEIN to take with him. GROFF used the directory more.

[Agent note: GROFF was shown a document with title "Masseuses from JAN".
This document is attached in a 1A.] GROFF's first thought was that "JAN"
meant January. "New user" on the document was not significant to GROFF.
The document stated, "Last saved by Lesley Groff". GROFF advised this
looked like a list she could have put together. This was definitely
something EPSTEIN would have wanted. It looks like something GROFF could
have done but she could not recall this specific list. GROFF made a lot of
lists.

If EPSTEIN traveled out of town he would want to see people. Sometimes,
he would tell GROFF to add new people. If he went to Harvard, he would want
a list of professors he would want to talk with while there.

When GROFF would call to schedule massage appointments, she would say
something like, "Hi how are you? Mr. Epstein is in New York and he's
wanting to know if you can give him a massage at 4." The phone calls were
short and to the point. A lot of times when GROFF called, the females were
at casting calls and they would not know how long they would be there so
they would have to call GROFF back. When EPSTEIN would call back for his
messages, he would tell GROFF to forget that one and call % ". GROFF
would call someone else and sometimes have to leave a message. Sometimes
GROFF heard street noises in the background. GROFF called females and one
male masseuse. GROFF distinctly remembered females being on casting calls
because it was annoying because she wanted to get on with her day and could
not because she had to schedule a massage appointment. Scheduling massage
appointments was around 1% of GROFF's job. GROFF left a lot of messages;
people would not answer their phones. Sometimes, people called GROFF asking
to see EPSTEIN for a massage. Everyone wanted to see him. Anytime GROFF
called someone, not just massage people, people just jumped to meet with
EPSTEIN.

GROFF thought EPSTEIN was a money manager. His biggest client was
WEXNER. GROFF knew this from the beginning because of the non-disclosure
agreement she had to sign. GROFF thought EPSTEIN had other clients. GROFF
3501.098-015
Page 7 of 9
FD.3022 (Rev. 5.8.101
SOD-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Proffer of LESLEY GROFF .on 07/23/2O21 .page 8 of 9
thought EPSTEIN was doing some trades. EPSTEIN would tell GROFF to get
someone - he did not have the number of a trader. GROFF had anxiety trying
to get a trader. EPSTEIN did a lot with politics. EPSTEIN was a generous
person, who gave to charity tables and wanted to be anonymous. EPSTEIN
seemed very busy. EPSTEIN had an interest in decorating. GROFF was floored
by the contacts he had all over the world; GROFF was impressed by that.
GROFF had to learn how to dial overseas numbers.

MAXWELL was an office manager. This was how GROFF was introduced to
MAXWELL. MAXWELL was EPSTEIN's best friend. GROFF saw EPSTEIN torch
MAXWELL at times; he was angry with her. EPSTEIN got mad at his attorneys
in the office. Sometimes MAXWELL left with her head down. GROFF did not
like hearing EPSTEIN yell at SCHANTZ; but he did not walk out defeated.
EPSTEIN and MAXWELL were confidants. GROFF knew EPSTEIN built MAXWELL her
house; GROFF thought told her this. It was just bought and under
construction. GROFF thought EPSTEIN and MAXWELL were boyfriend/girlfriend.
They were very carefree. They did not spend every moment together. GROFF
thought EPSTEIN cared for MAXWELL and she cared for him. EPSTEIN and
MAXWELL did not live together. GROFF did not know where MAXWELL was living
while her house was being built.

When GROFF first started, MAXWELL helped with the rules. MAXWELL told
her that when EPSTEIN calls GROFF to give requirements, if GROFF did not
understand something, to stop him then and do not wait until the end because
it will make EPSTEIN mad. EPSTEIN was famous for talking under his breath
and mumbling. GROFF did not have normal conversations with MAXWELL. GROFF
did not talk to MAXWELL about her wedding or when she was pregnant. MAXWELL
would come and go from the office and bring her dog into the office.
MAXWELL had her own driver. There was a guy who was the driver and a girl
who was the maid. Looking back, GROFF did not know how much managing
MAXWELL actually did. When MAXWELL's house was being built, that was her
priority. MAXWELL was in the office next to GROFF.

[Agent note: At this point in the interview, GROFF was shown a black book.
This book is 1A-9 in case file 72-MM-113327.]
GROFF advised this book did
not look like the one she saw. The one GROFF saw had larger writing. It
was the same size but the one she remembered had a thicker binding. GROFF
thought it was probably the same information inside. This information would
have been in the directory. To GROFF's recollection, it looked the same.
3501.098-015
Pageliof9
FD.3022(Rev.5.8-10)
50D-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD402of (U) Proffer of LESLEY GROFF
GROFF recalled the directory was alphabetical.
,o n 07/23/2021 page 9 of 9

GROFF did not have conversations with MAXWELL about massages. GROFF
worked 9-5; EPSTEIN did not contact GROFF on the weekends.

GROFF remembered MAXWELL called BELLA, who was from Russia, about the
KGB. MAXWELL had to check every invoice. MAXWELL smiled and was happy,
except when EPSTEIN got upset with her. MAXWELL talked to everybody; it
seemed business related. traveled with MAXWELL on EPSTEIN's plane.
EPSTEIN and MAXWELL were volatile. One moment EPSTEIN would be screaming
and the next he was down to business. MAXWELL tended to carry it and leave.
GROFF thought the whole office seemed happy, like the employees were
happy, and it was a nice place to work.

Sometimes GROFF was asked to messenger money for massages and sometimes
JOJO took money for the massages to give to people. EPSTEIN sent everything
by messenger. EPSTEIN sent things FedEx. GROFF got the money from
accounting and would pay someone around $100. GROFF would type a message to
BELLA; GROFF thought BELLA had the petty cash box. BELLA put money in an
envelope. Then it would be put in a messenger box. JOJO or a messenger
would pick it up. This did not happen all of the time, but rather some of
the time. No one ever came to the office to pick up money, except JOJO or a
messenger.
GROFF never went to EPSTEIN's house until 2013. GROFF went to EPSTEIN's
island. GROFF was at a wedding on Tortola. EPSTEIN told GROFF she should
go to the island. EPSTEIN was not on the island when she went. MILES
ALEXANDER and KATHY ALEXANDER fed GROFF and her husband lunch then they went
back. GROFF went on a trip with her husband to London. EPSTEIN said they
could stay at his guest room in Paris. They stayed there a couple of nights
then went back to London. GROFF did not go to the New Mexico Ranch. GROFF
did not travel with EPSTEIN.
3501.098-015
Pagc 9 of 9
EFTA00063136 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ Office of the Inspector General interview of BOP employee Hughwon <REDACTED>, about cameras at MCC
(date: 2021-09-29)
DIGITALLY RECORDED
SWORN STATEMENT
OF
<REDACTED>

OIG CASE #:
2019-010614

DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL
SEPTEMBER 29, 2021

RESOLUTE DOCUMENTATION SERVICES
28632 Roadside Drive, Suite 285
Agoura Hills, CA 91301
Phone:
APPEARANCES:
OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL
BY:
BY:
BY:
WITNESS:
OTHER APPEARANCES:
NONE
1 : The recorder has started.
2 My name is and I am a Senior
3 Special Agent with the U.S. Department of
4 Justice, Office of the Inspector General, New
5 York Field Office, and these are my
6 credentials.
7 : Okay. I see them.
8 : This interview with
9 Federal Bureau of Prisons employee, Hughwon
10 , is being conducted as part of an
11 official U.S. Department of Justice, Office of
12 the Inspector General, or DOJ/OIG
13 investigation. Today's date is September 29th,
14 2021. And the time is 8:16 a.m. This
15 interview is being conducted at the OIG New
16 York Field Office, located at 1 Battery Park
17 Plaza, New York, New York. Also present is
18 DOJ/OIG ASAC, or Assistant Special Agent-in-
19 Charge, . He is in person. And
20 Special Agent is joining us by
21 telephone. He is also with the DOJ/OIG. This
22 interview will be recorded by me, Senior
23 Special Agent . Could
24 everyone please identify themselves for the
25 record, and spell their last name? To start,
1 again, I am DOJ/OIG Senior Special Agent Dennis
2 Matulewicz.
3 : I am Assistant Special Agent-
4 in-Charge
6 Electronics tech. Bureau of Prisons.
7 D-A-N-I-E-L.
8 : This is Special Agent
9 . D-A-N-I-E-L.
10 : All right. Thank you.
11 This is an official DOJ/OIG investigation into
12 the death of inmate Jeffrey Epstein, and the
13 surrounding circumstances, and you are being
14 asked to voluntarily provide answers to our
15 questions. Will you agree to a voluntary
16 interview with the DOJ/OIG?
17 : Yes.
18 : Thank you, sir. So, this
19 is the official Warnings and Assurances to
20 Employees Requested to Provide Information on a
21 Voluntary Basis. And in this line, I'm going
22 to say, this investigation pertains to,
23 it's job performance failure and security
24 failure, correct?
25 : Yes.
1 : Job performance failure.
2 All right. So, it says, United States
3 Department of Justice, Office of the Inspector
4 General, Warnings and Assurances to Employees
5 Requested to Provide Information on a Voluntary
6 Basis. "You are being asked to provide
7 information as part of an investigation being
8 conducted by the Office of the Inspector
9 General. This investigation is being conducted
10 pursuant to the Inspector General Act of 1978,
11 as amended. This investigation pertains to job
12 performance failure and security failure. This
13 is a voluntary interview.
14 Accordingly, you do not have to answer
15 questions. No disciplinary action will be
16 taken against you if you choose not to answer
17 questions. Any statement you furnish may be
18 used as evidence in any future criminal
19 proceedings, or agency disciplinary
20 proceedings, or both." And there is a waiver
21 section. And it says, "I understand the
22 Warnings and Assurances stated above and I am
23 willing to make a statement and answer
24 questions. No promises or threats have been
25 made to me, and no pressure or coercion of any
1 kind has been used against me."
2 So, take a look. If you understand it,
3 and are agreeing, and are willing to continue,
4 can you just please sign where it says employee
5 signature? Thank you very much for signing.
6 DO you understand the form?
7 : Mm-hmm. Yes, I do.
8 : Okay. Do you understand
9 this is a voluntary interview?
10 : Yes.
11 : Perfect. Thank you.
12 Okay. Today's date, again, is September 29th.
13 So, I'm writing 09/29/21. The place is OIG,
14 NYFO. And the time is 8:19 a.m. And I am
15 signing my name as the Special Agent. ASAC
16 , can you sign as a witness, please?
17 : Mm-hmm.
18 : Thank you, sir.
19 : Thank you.
20 : All right. Before
21 starting the interview, I would like to place
22 you under oath. , can you please
23 raise your right hand? Do you swear to tell
24 the truth and nothing but the truth --
25 : Yes.
: -- during this interview?
: Yes.
: Thank you, sir. Again,
4 it's a voluntary interview, if you don't
5 understand any of my questions, please ask me
6 to rephrase.
7 : Yeah.
8 : Or ask for any
9 clarification. I would be happy to provide it.
10 Were you previously interviewed by the OIG at
11 the MCC on July 15th, 2021?
12 : Yes.
13 : Great. And that was by
14 me and Special Agent Correct?
15 : Yes.
16 : Great. Is it correct
17 that the MCC camera -. Or sorry. Before I go
18 on that, are you still at the MCC?
19 : Yes, I am.
20 : Are you still the
21 electronics technician?
22 : Yes, I am.
23 : Great. Has anything
24 changed since we spoke on July 15th, 2021?
25 : No.
1 : No. Great. Is it
2 correct that the MCC cameras were not working
3 properly in August 2019?
4 : Yeah. Well, the recorders
5 wasn't working. The cameras were working. The
6 recorders weren't working.
7 : So, the live feed was
8 working, but the recordings were not.
9 : Yes.
10 : Correct. When did you
11 first learn that the MCC cameras were not
12 working properly?
13 : That day. This was, I
14 believe, that day. Towards the end of my
15 shift. I'm not sure what time.
16 : So, you still think it
17 was August 9th, 2019, that you learned?
18 : Yes.
19 : After giving it some
20 thought, do you think maybe it happened the day
21 before, on August 8th, 2019?
22 : I don't know if I spoke to
23 somebody. I don't know why it would be the
24 8th.
25 : All right. When we go
over the reports, we will see if that can help
freshen, you know, help you recall. First,
we're just going to ask you some questions for,
like, you know, so you can, from memory, recall
5 exactly --
6 : What happened.
7 : -- when it was, and then
8 we will go over the reports, and see if that
9 helps jog anything. But to your recollection,
10 it was on August 9th, 2019?
11 : Yes.
12 : And what is --
13 : It was that Friday.
14 : -- what is it that makes
15 you think that it was on that Friday?
16 : Because that's when I went
17 to the room. That's the only thing I really
18 remember. Because it was a lot of hours after
19 that.
20 : Okay.
21 : That day.
22 : So, it was just
23 : Yeah.
24 : -- it was a lot of things
25 going on.
1 : Yeah. There was a lot of
2 things going on. But I remember the 9th
3 because everything happened the next day.
4 : Okay.
5 : On Saturday.
6 : And are you aware, now,
7 after the fact, that the cameras stopped
8 recording on July 29th, 2019?
9 : No.
10 : So, you're not aware of
11 that?
12 : No. Nobody. It's the
13 first time somebody has told me that.
14 : Okay. So, by reviewing
15 the recording system, or anything like that,
16 you didn't learn that they stopped on July
17 29th?
18 : No. The recorders were
19 still working. Because the recorders were
20 still working for the building. All the -.
21 Not all the cameras were working, but some of
22 the recorders were working. (Indiscernible
23 *00:06:26) .
24 : So, when we spoke last
25 time, you explained to us that on, like, August
1 9th, is when you first noticed it, and that
2 half of the cameras, or --
: Half of them was on --
: -- half the cameras on
: DVR-1.
: DVR-1, and half were
7 on DVR-2.
8 : DVR-2.
9 : And one of the, one of
10 those DVRs, which included half of the cameras
11 --
12 : Cameras.
13 : -- they stopped --
14 : Yeah. Stopped working.
15 : -- working.
16 : Yeah.
17 : So, what is your
18 knowledge or recollection of when those half of
19 cameras -?
20 : I don't know when those
21 half the cameras stopped working?
22 : So, when you were trying
23 to obtain video after the fact, you never
24 learned, like, when they're
25 : This is the first time --
1 : -- the last video?
2 : -- yeah, this is the first
3 time I heard that, was July.
4 : Okay.
5 : Yeah.
6 : So, when is the first
7 time you found out, then, that the recordings
8 were, in fact, not working?
9 : When I went to go try to
10 fix it on that Friday.
11 : Okay. On the 9th?
12 : Yeah.
13 : Okay. But on the 9th,
14 did you -. I thought you had told us you
15 couldn't gain access to it on the 9th. So,
16 when did you actually gain access to the room,
17 to be able to --
18 : I went up there --
19 : -- determine -?
20 : -- in the afternoon, to go
21 do work. They said I couldn't stay because
22 had to leave, so the video room.
23 : Okay.
24 : Yeah.
25 So, III had to leave, so
1 you couldn't stay to do the work?
2 : Yeah. I couldn't stay to
3 do the work, because I don't have a key, I
4 don't have access to the room. Because it's
5 the property room.
6 : And when you say "they,"
7 who was it that told you this?
8 : I was talking to Officer
9 III. But it's no -. Everybody knows that SIS,
10 that's their room, and I don't have access to
11 go in the room. At the time, I didn't have
12 access to fix the recorders.
13 : Okay. Did you ever talk
14 to a
15 : That day?
16 : Any day, about these
17 recordings.
18 : Yeah. I've talked to
19 people numerous times about me getting access
20 to the room, that I should have access to the
21 room.
22 : No, I'm talking about,
23 like, on August 8th or August 9th, about the
24 cameras. Do you recall having a conversation -
25 -
1 : I don't recall.
2 : -- with lieutenant
4 : No.
5 : No. Or ? The
6 Associate Warden.
7 : I don't remember.
8 : No. Okay. So, you don't
9 remember learning that, on July 29th, 2019, the
10 cameras stopped recording?
11 : This is the first time
12 : From (Indiscernible
13 *00:08:19) .
14 : I heard it.
15 : That's the very first
16 time you heard?
17 : That it was July. Yeah.
18 : Okay.
19 : Because that's, like, two
20 weeks out, I wouldn't - not know it was
21 recording for two weeks. That doesn't make any
22 sense.
23 : Okay. So, you don't
24 think that that would be accurate?
25 : No.
1 : All right. Do you know
2 what stopped them from recording?
3 : I just know that the
4 system was old, and it had a lot of problems.
5 : Okay. Do you know if
6 someone did, like, an improper shutdown, or
7 that power surge created it to shut off?
8 : They were on UPSs, and no
9 power surge that would have created it. It
10 would have just been mechanical.
11 : Okay.
12 : Or, yeah, yeah.
13 : Just from age?
14 : Just from age, and wear
15 and tear. Yes.
16 : Okay. And again, on
17 August 8th, you don't recall ever having
18 conversations with anybody regarding these
19 cameras, or first learning on August 8th that
20 the cameras went down?
21 : August 8th? The day
22 before? I don't really recall (Indiscernible
23 *00:09:09) .
24 : And you don't recall
25 having the conversation with SIS Lieutenant
1 and about the cameras not
2 recording on August 8th, 2019? On Thursday?
3 : No. I don't recall.
4 : You don't. Do you
5 remember them, towards the end of your shift,
6 bringing you in the office because they
7 couldn't get the recordings to rewind, and
8 asked you to fix the problem?
9 : On the 8th?
10 : On the 8th.
11 : Hmm. I don't recall that.
12 No.
13 : Do you remember having -
14 at any time - a conversation prior to Epstein's
15 death, with lieutenant, with SIS Lieutenant
16 and
17 : Together? At the same
18 time? No. I don't recall it. Yeah.
19 : What about separately?
20 : Separately, probably. We
21 probably talked about it. But not together.
22 At the same time.
23 : Well, do you recall the
24 conversations that you had, then, prior to
25 Epstein dying on the - or being found - on the
1 10th. What conversations did you have with
2 each of those individuals?
3 : Right. I was just busy
4 working. On the 10th, the day it happened, or
5 -?
6 : No. Prior to the 10th.
7 So, the 8th, the 9th, or anywhere back to the
8 July 29th, really.
9 : Oh. That we were working
10 on the problem, trying to figure out what was
11 causing it, and that's when I ordered new hard
12 drives to replace all the drives. That was my
13 next step. That's what I was going to do that
14 day. But I couldn't.
15 : And what made you do
16 that, though? Who told you to replace the hard
17 drives?
18 : Talking through SigNet,
19 and the former com tech, he's the
20 computer services manager and we talked about
21 buying hard drives. I actually got a purchase
22 order, too. Yeah.
23 : So, who was the computer
24 service manager?
2 and last name?
4 M.
S
6 1?
8 L. Yeah.
: Can you spell the first
. And
: And did you say
. III Yes. That's an
or -?
Yeah. III
So, no..
Noll.
: Okay.
And that's an-
15 : And that was the CSM?
16 : Yup.
17 I'm sorry. And it's All Not will At the
18 end.
19 : All right. So,
20 -M?
21 : Yes.
22 : Okay. Great. And who
23 was that person?
24 : He was the previous com
25 tech before I got there, and now, he was - at
1 that present time - he was the computer
2 services manager.
3 : He was?
4 : Yes.
5 : Okay. So, he was
6 actually working at the MCC?
: Yes.
: And he was your boss?
: No. It's just, I talked
10 to him about computer stuff, because he knows a
11 little bit more than I do. That's his
12 specialty.
13 : Okay. What was his kind
14 of, like, job role at the time?
15 : His job role was to take
16 care of the computers. Infrastructure of the
17 building.
18 : Okay.
19 : Yeah.
20 : And what was the
21 conversation you had with him, and where?
22 : I think, that's when we
23 were talking about actually just replacing all
24 of the hard drives because they keep failing
25 all the time. So, the next step was to replace
1 all the hard drives.
2 : And do you remember when
3 you had that conversation?
4 : A few days before this
5 happened. And we've had numerous conversations
6 about this for weeks because - and probably
7 months - because of the way the hard drives
8 kept failing. The drives would, the recorders
9 would stop working.
10 : So, did you know, then, a
11 few days before this? I'm assuming, when you
12 say "this," August 9th, 2019, that the hard
13 drives had failed?
14 : I knew it was a
15 possibility they failed. At the time, or the
16 before I left, I knew everything was working.
17 : Before you left when?
18 : I'm not too sure, but I'm
19 just saying, like, overall, as far as, like, as
20 far as everything recording, because I've
21 checked the recorders. It looked like
22 everything was recording.
23 : What day are you speaking
24 about, though?
25 : Oh, specifically, before
1 the incident happened, on the 9th.
2 : So, on the 9th,
3 everything was recording?
4 : Well, when I checked it,
5 of course it wasn't recording. That's why I
6 went up there to check.
7 : It was not?
8 : It was not recording.
9 : Okay. So, when is the
10 first time you found out that it was not
11 recording?
12 : Oh. I guess the 9th.
13 Everybody keep saying the 8th, but I don't
14 really remember the 8th.
15 : Okay. So, the 9th, and
16 is that when you --
17 : Because I -.
18 : -- are saying you had the
19 conversation with
20 : Yes. Well, I had the
21 conversation before, with , about what I
22 was going to do next.
23 : Okay.
24 : Because it happened
25 before, so the next step was just to replace
1 all the hard drives.
2 : Like, it happened long
3 before, or when are you talking about --
4 : It happened --
5 : -- it happened?
6 : -- multiple times before,
7 where the recorders would stop working.
8 : Okay.
9 : Yes.
10 : So, you were trying to
11 preemptively stop that from happening?
12 : Happening again, yes.
13 : Okay. So --
14 : So -.
15 : -- you didn't talk to
16 him based upon the system stopping recording.
17 You were talking about it --
18 : Mm-hmm.
19 : -- doing preventative
20 maintenance?
21 : Maintenance. Yes.
22 : Is that correct?
23 : Yes.
24 : Okay. But you don't
25 remember exactly when you spoke with him?
1 : No. Some time around that
2 time, because I have to get the purchase, I
3 have to get the parts to make the repairs, or
4 change the drives out.
5 : All right. So, until we
6 go over this, I'm going to run through these,
7 just so we keep on track. But it sounds like
8 I'm going to have to show you these documents,
9 to help maybe clarify some things.
10 : Mm-hmm.
11 : Do you know, did you know
12 that the recorders - that the cameras weren't
13 recording prior to August 9th, 2019?
14 : Yeah. I know there was
15 failures in the system. Yes.
16 : So, you knew that they
17 were not recording?
18 : Not that day. But I know
19 that, overall, there was going to be system
20 failures.
21 : And did you know that it
22 was half of them, all on DVR-1 or 2?
23 : I wasn't too sure what it
24 was.
25 : Okay.
1 : But I know there was a
2 failure. I didn't check to see exactly where
3 they were.
4 : So, you knew there was a
5 failure with the system, prior to August 9th.
6 You just didn't know what the failure was?
7 : Yes.
8 : And how did you know
9 that?
10 : Well, I would have to go
11 check if there was video, there was no recorder
12 videos, live videos, but there was no recorder
13 video.
14 : So, you personally had
15 checked to see if there were recorded video?
16 : Yes.
17 : And when did you do that?
18 : I had, well, I had checked
19 that day, before I had to go upstairs to look
20 at everything.
21 : August 9th?
22 : August 9th. Yes.
23 : So, that's where I'm
24 saying. So, when you say, prior to the time,
25 you're talking about the same day, August 9th,
1 is when you checked the --
2 : Checked the recording.
3 : -- the recording.
4 : Yeah.
5 : Prior to August 9th, did
6 you check the recording to see if it was
7 recording?
8 : Multiple times before.
9 Yes.
10 : And were they recorded?
11 : From what I believe, yes.
12 I'm not too sure.
13 : Okay. Would you check
14 that system to check on the recordings, every
15 day?
16 : No. There was nothing
17 that says I have to check it.
18 : Sure.
19 : The thing with the
20 recorders is, I'm not really supposed to, like,
21 mess with the system. I just, I'm maintenance.
22 I'm not really supposed to, like, oh, today,
23 SIS, that's their job to tell me, hey,
24 there is no video, or something, there is a
25 problem.
: So, how did you know that
the recording wasn't being able to rewind, and
check recording? Why were you in there
checking that?
5 : I just, I guess I spoke to
6 somebody, or maybe I checked it. I'm not too
7 sure.
8 : But it would have been
9 based upon someone requesting you to do so?
10 : Yes.
11 : And you believe that
12 happened on the 9th?
13 : Yes.
14 : Okay.
15 : And just, and the call
16 dropped. Let me get back on.
17 : Absolutely.
18 : Agent
19 : Hey, . You hear us fine
20 now?
21 : Yes. I apologize. I
22 don't know why the call dropped.
23 : Mm-hmm.
24 : Okay.
25 : All right. So, we were
1 just talking about the recording and how Mr.
2 would not go in and review a recording
3 without someone requesting him to do so. He
4 doesn't recall specifically who made that
5 request for him to review the recording, but he
6 believes that he reviewed the recording on the
7 9th, and that's when he determined that it
8 wasn't recording properly. Is that correct?
9 : Yes.
10 : All right. And you - and
11 again - you don't remember why you were
12 reviewing that recording?
13 : No. Because we're in the
14 middle of a -. Well, no, this -. Before
15 Epstein happened, we were in the middle of a
16 camera project, we had people TDY. So, I was,
17 like, the lead in the building, trying to tell
18 everybody what needs to get done. And I think
19 the day before, I was on 10 South, I was
20 putting in a rack or something, so I was busy
21 that day, and I had a TDY guy on me.
22 : And when you - on the
23 8th?
24 : Yeah.
25 : You got a TDY guy with
1 you.
4 With you?
: Yeah.
: And who was that TDY guy?
. His last name was
6 , and I don't remember his first name.
7 He was an electrician.
8 : An electrician. Do you
9 know which facility he came from?
12 name?
: No. I'm not too sure.
: You don't know the first
: I forgot his first name.
14 We just call everybody by their last name.
15 : But he's not from MCC?
16 : No. He's not in from MCC.
17 : After the interview, can
18 you just see if you can identify who that
19 person is, and then send me an email?
20 : Okay.
21 : Of the person's name.
22 But the August 8th, 2019, you believe this --
23 : Yeah.
24 : -- this TDY employee,
25 , was with you?

╭────────────── Page 28, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ 1 you.                                       │
│ 2 a:                                         │
│ MEE «826 ho va                               │
│ 4 with you?                                  │
│                                              │
│ MEE: M.'s ast name was                       │
│ 6 MBM, and I don                             │
│ 7 He was an elec                             │
│ 8 WENN: electrician. Do you                  │
│ 9 know which facility he came from?          │
│ 10 HE: X0. tim not                           │
│ i WES «ou don’t know the first               │
│                                              │
│ hat TDY guy?                                 │
│                                              │
│ remember irst name.                          │
│                                              │
│ rician.                                      │
│                                              │
│ 13 (NN: = forgot his first name.             │
│                                              │
│ call everybody by their last name.           │
│                                              │
│ ter the interview, can                       │
│                                              │
│ 18 you just see if you can identify who that │
│                                              │
│ 19 person is, and then send me an email      │
│                                              │
│ 20 Ln                                        │
│                                              │
│ th                                           │
│                                              │
│ name.                                        │
│                                              │
│ perso’                                       │
│                                              │
│ 2019, you believe this --                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────╯

1 : Yeah. He was with me. We
2 were together all day because we were doing the
3 piping, and trying to put the rack in.
4 : And what is a rack?
5 : Where the Well, for
6 the new camera system, that's where the power
7 supply, the switch would go, the camera feed,
8 the cat five cables would go. Everything will
9 go on the rack.
10 : So, it had to do with the
11 camera system?
12 : The upgrading the new
13 camera system. Yes.
14 : Is that anything that
15 could have possibly caused the cameras to stop
16 recording?
17 : No. That's -. Nothing
18 was hooked up. It was just the hardware.
19 There was no wiring or nothing.
20 : Okay. So, that could not
21 have affected the camera?
22 : The cameras? No.
23 : All right. And do you
24 remember, prior to August 9th, checking on the
25 camera system, though, to make sure it was
1 recording?
2 : Yes. After we had the
3 problem, yes.
4 : No, no, no. Prior to the
5 9th.
6 : Yes. Prior to the 9th.
7 : And when did you check
8 on, prior, like, how many days before? Do you
9 remember?
10 : I don't really remember.
11 : Are you talking about,
12 like, a few days leading up, a day leading up,
13 or are you talking about, like, a month or two?
14 : Maybe, like, weeks. Not
15 months. It wouldn't have been a month.
16 : Like, a few weeks?
17 : Yeah, because I had to
18 order the parts. I don't know when I ordered
19 the parts. But I had to know that they weren't
20 working.
21 : But I thought you just
22 said that they were working, and you only
23 ordered them as preventative maintenance?
24 : Well, I - yeah -. Well,
25 they weren't working before. So, I had to
1 rebuild one of the drives. I had to change one
2 of the drives out.
3 : Okay.
4 : That's when I went to say,
5 let me order a whole bunch of drives, to
6 replace all the drives together, at once.
7 : And are you able to
8 determine when you made that order?
9 : Yes. We have a purchase
10 order. Yes.
11 : All right. So, those two
12 things so far. Can you give me the name of
13 , and the second thing is the purchase
14 order, with regard to --
15 : Yeah.
16 : -- when you made that
17 order --
18 : Yeah.
19 • -- for the new drives?
20 : Mm-hmm.
21 : I'll send you an email
22 after this.
23 : Okay.
24 : Just kind of reminding
25 you of what it is we're hoping to get. And
1 there, but again, you ordered that because
2 there was a problem with the --
3 : Recorders.
4 : -- with the recorders --
5 : Yes.
6 : -- you fixed that
7 problem.
8 : Temporarily. But I knew
9 it was going to happen again. And the best
10 thing to do was replace all the drives.
11 : Okay. So, you knew that
12 it would stop recording again?
13 : I knew there was going to
14 be a problem again. Yes.
15 : Okay. And what made you
16 know that
17 : Talking to the vendor, and
18 talking to , and the age of the unit,
19 because it was, like, 15 years old. And the
20 fact that it's on 365, 24 days, and on 24 hours
21 a day, like, it just constantly goes on. And
22 then, when you try to do maintenance, something
23 as simple as changing the time, the recording
24 would stop for, like, a whole day, day and a
25 half. Because for the drives rebuilding, you
1 have to change the time.
2 : Okay.
3 : And before all of this
4 happened, I actually put in a camera project.
5 That's why I was in the middle of a camera
6 project, to replace everything.
7 : Now, when you say that
8 the people you spoke to, you mentioned
9 and then, you said the customer service people
10 --
11 : Yeah. SigNet.
12 : -- Signet.
13 : Yeah. Mainly
14 , and I would talk to him.
15 •
•
16 main point of contact?
was your
17 : Yes.
18 : What about a
19 ? Would you recall -?
20 was the one that came
21 after Epstein. That's the guy that showed up
22 when we had to put in the new drives. Because
23 we ordered the new We ordered the new
24 recorders. But everything was downstairs in
25 the basement. And we weren't really a priority
1 on the list until, of course, Epstein happened.
2 That's when SigNet came the next day, and put
3 the new recorders in.
4 : Okay. So, prior to
5 August 10th, 2019, your main point of contact
6 was SigNet, with
8 : I mean, -.
9 Yes.
10 : And what was his role and
11 responsibility with SigNet?
12 : He is just, like, the guy
13 we will call if there is a problem, or if
14 training, or if I don't know the system.
15 Because, like, this system, I never had
16 training on it. So, like, when I saw it,
17 because the last institution I was, was, like,
18 maybe two versions ahead of this one. So, when
19 I saw this recording, I was, like, this stuff
20 is old, like, I don't know anything about it.
21 Like, what should I do? So, I called
22 and , like, pretty much would walk me
23 through trouble shooting, if there is a
24 problem.
25 : And what was the system
1 again?
2 : Raid (Phonetic Sp.
3 *00:21:08) .
4 : Nice Pro, or something
5 like that?
6 : I don't -. I know it was
7 a raid system. A raid array. I remember
8 that's what he kept saying. Raid array.
9 : Okay.
10 : It was raid.
11 : And do you know what that
12 means? Raid array?
13 : Just the way the drives
14 would go. So, if, the way he explained that to
15 me, if one drive would go bad, that's not so
16 bad. But as soon as two drives go bad, that's
17 when all the recordings pretty much stops.
18 : So --
19 : Because it was a redundant
20 system.
21 -- okay. So, when one
22 drive goes bad, does any, do any recordings
23 stop?
24 : No. It will keep
25 recording.
1 : So, it will automatically
2 shift over to the other drive?
3 : To the other slot. Yes.
4 : Okay.
5 : And then, when two drives
6 go bad, that's when all the recordings stop.
7 : So, what is the
8 difference between ours, where is one -. Is
9 what you're talking about a DVR-1 and a DVR-2?
10 : No. That's the drive in
11 the DVRs, because there's 16 drives. That's
12 what - I think - that's what it was. So, out
13 of the 16 like, in DVR-1, if one goes bad,
14 that's not a problem. As soon as the second
15 drive goes bad, then that's when you have a
16 problem. And that's when the recording would
17 stop.
18 : Okay. So, what is your
19 understanding of what happened here?
20 : Oh. The drive went bad.
21 : One of them?
22 : Two of them. Yeah.
23 : Two of them
24 : I believe.
25 • -- did go bad?
2 -
: Yes. Because that's why -
3 : And is it two of 16, or
4 is it two out of two?
5 : Two out of 16.
6 : So, if two out of 16 go
7 bad --
8 : Go bad.
9 : -- then --
10 : Mm-hmm.
11 they all.
12 : The recordings stop. Yes.
13 : For all of them?
14 : Yes.
15 : Okay.
16 : On that drive. All the
17 recording stops.
18 : And the DVR-1 and DVR-2,
19 that's simply the recording system?
20 : Yes.
21 : That's not the, anything
22 to do with the -. The drives are what's making
23 --
24 : Mm Hmm.
25 : -- the recording, but
1 they're saving it to DVR-1 --
2 : Yes.
3 : -- and DVR-2.
4 : Yes.
5 : So, what is the
6 difference between if a DVR-1 goes bad, but not
7 DVR-2? Is that just -?
8 : The physical location over
9 it. Because everything on the old system was
10 analog. So, like, cameras one through whatever
11 are on this drive, on DVR-1, and our other
12 cameras are on DVR-2.
13 : So, does each DVR have 16
14 drives?
15 : Yes.
16 : All right. So --
17 : So -.
18 : DVR-1 has 16 drives.
19 DVR-2 has 16 drives.
20 : Yes.
21 : And either DVR-1 or DVR-
22 2, two of those drives went bad?
23 : Yes.
24 : And stopped that DVR-2
25 from recording.
1 : From recording. Yes.
2 : But the drives on DVR-1
3 were all good?
4 : All good. Yes.
5 : Okay.
6 : And another thing I've
7 learned also, through my time, is that SigNet
8 replied to me this, you could look at the
9 camera software, until you physically look at
10 the drives, you would think that everything is
11 recording. That's something we went over
12 recently.
13 : Well, what about a -. I
14 was told that there was an application that you
15 would have, that was called Supervision.
16 : Yeah. I don't look at
17 Supervision.
18 : You don't.
19 : You can. I have access to
20 look at it, but I didn't get trained on it, so
21 I don't really look at Supervision. I would
22 just go in the regular Nice Vision, and look at
23 it that way.
24 : Yeah. We were told that,
25 in order to determine if there were problems
with the drives --
have to --
:
The drives. You would
-- that's through --
5 : -- yes.
6 -- yeah, you go into
7 Supervision, and that would, in fact, tell you?
8 : And which, I have no
9 training on.
10 : So, you've never --
11 : Obviously.
12 : -- looked at that?
13 : No.
14 : Did anyone else have
15 health --
16 : At the time, no.
17 : -- did anyone else have
18 access?
19 : No.
20 : So, you were the only
21 person with access to Supervision?
22 : Yes. Pretty much. Yes.
23 : All right. And do you
24 know if someone accessed the application
25 Supervision, they could have taken the drives
1 offline, or the recordings offline?
2 : Hmm, yeah. But yeah,
3 nobody would have that access.
4 : Would they be able to do
it from there, though?
6 : Yes. They probably would,
7 yes.
8 : But you are confident no
9 one had access to it?
10 : No.
11 : Okay. So, you would be
12 the one and only person with access to
13 Supervision?
14 : Yes.
15 : And there is no, like, if
16 you're not there, somebody else has
17 : There is nobody --
18 : -- a way to --
19 : -- there is nobody. Yeah.
20 : -- how would they do
21 that? From SigNet? To get access again.
22 : Oh, no. They would just
23 have to know the password, to log in.
24 : Well, that's what I mean.
25 So, if you ended up not being able to show up,
1 or you left, or something like that, how would
2 someone gain access to that?
3 : That's something they
4 would have to try to figure out, but yeah. I
5 don't
6 : But to your knowledge,
7 you're the only person that had the password to
8 access Supervision?
9 : Yes.
10 : Okay. And SigNet
11 wouldn't be able to remote in?
12 : No. They have no access
13 to remote in. That's BOP. They don't want
14 them to be able to backdoor remote into
15 anything.
16 : Okay. And when did you -
17 -
18 : Oh. Well, they -. The
19 old system, they were able to, if you had a 56K
20 (Phonetic Sp. *00:25:06) modem, they were able
21 to do maintenance, and tell me, like, the
22 status of the drives. But I would have to
23 physically hook up 56k modem. But at the time,
24 that wasn't hooked up. Because we did some
25 repairs before, when I was trying to figure
1 stuff out, and I couldn't figure it out, where
2 they would - through a modem - they would
3 remote into the -. Well, I would have to grant
4 them access to look at the drives, to help with
5 the drives.
6 : So, how --
7 : And we've done that
8 before. Yes.
9 so, you had to grant
10 them access. They couldn't go in there
11 : No
12 -- without your
13 : Physically. And
14 physically, you have to put a cable in.
15 : Okay.
16 : Yeah.
17 : So, you are the one and
18 only person with access, remotely, that could
19 have accessed those servers?
20 : Yes.
21 : Okay. And do you
22 remember the last time you would have accessed
23 that application?
24 : I have no idea.
25 : No? Would it have been
1 leading up to August 9th, 2019?
2 : Probably. Yeah.
3 : And do you know around
4 how long before that?
5 : No.
6 : Is there a way to
7 determine? Do they have, like, some thing that
8 you can see when your last log ons were, or
9 anything like that?
10 : You could call computer
11 services, then they could tell you my
12 keystrokes or whatever, whatever I logged into.
13 But that's, like, the only time. Yeah.
14 : Okay.
15 : But there is really
16 nothing to say when I logged in.
17 : But to your recollection,
18 you were not accessing Supervision at all?
19 : Hmm. I mean, they showed
20 me how to do some stuff on it, but I don't
21 really even think I remembered how to - at that
22 time - I don't really remember.
23 : But the point being, in
24 this case, you didn't find out the recordings
25 had stopped because of that application,
1 Supervision. Correct?
2 : I don't believe so. No.
3 : Okay. And you did not
4 take the cameras, or recordings, offline from
5 Supervision. Correct?
6 : No. I can't. Yeah. No.
7 I've never been able to do that. So, no.
8 : So, you don't even -.
9 Sorry. I thought you told me before you could
10 do it. DO you think --
11 : You have access to do it,
12 yes, if you are in Supervision. Yeah. There
13 is stuff you can do on Supervision to stop the
14 recordings. Yes.
15 : Now, if you weren't
16 really familiar with the application, is it
17 possible that you were in there, and you
18 accidentally knocked them offline?
19 : No.
20 : Okay.
21 : I wouldn't knock anything
22 offline.
23 : No. You don't believe
24 so?
25 : No.
1 : Okay. And what would be
2 a reason for you to go into the application,
3 Supervision?
4 : Just to see what was going
5 on, who's logging on, or just to, if something
6 looks funky to me, or just doesn't feel right,
7 to see what was going on.
8 : Okay.
9 : Yeah.
10 : And do you have any
11 examples, prior to August 9th, 2019, when you
12 would have done that?
13 : I know there was one time,
14 like, when they remoted in, they were showing
15 me stuff on the drives. And I was talking to
16 SigNet over the phone, and they were showing me
17 how to fix the drives before.
18 : Okay.
19 : But other than that, like,
20 I don't really remember me using Supervision
21 that much.
22 : And that would have been,
23 they would have had a log of when that
24 happened?
25 : Yeah. Supervision has a -
1 . Every time you log into Supervision, you see
2 a username and who logged in. That's always
3 kept on Supervision.
4 : Okay. And do you have
5 access to that now, to be able to
6 : Yes.
7 : -- determine?
8 : Yes.
9 : So, it shows that
10 : Well, that --
11 : -- it shows -.
12 : -- well, whatever system
13 you have, you can log into it, and see what you
14 have on it, in Supervision.
15 : And when you logged in,
16 and when you logged out?
17 : Yeah.
18 : So, would you still have
19 the ability now, to go back to see when you
20 logged in and logged out?
21 : For the old system, no.
22 : No? Not for the old
23 system.
24 : Old system, no.
25 : Okay. But SigNet would
probably have a call log of you --
: Of who's on.
: -- talking with them?
: Yes.
5 : Going over --
6 : Supervision.
7 : -- Supervision?
8 : -- yes.
9 : All right. So, SigNet
10 should be able to provide us something, with
11 regard to
12 : Supervision. Yes.
13 : -- when they had you in
14 there.
15 : Yeah.
16 : And do you think that you
17 went in there, though, aside from them showing
18 you?
19 : Maybe to check some stuff
20 out. But not really.
21 : Okay. All right. So,
22 again, August 9th is the first time you think
23 that you knew that the cameras weren't
24 recording.
25 : Mm-hmm.
1 : If we were to tell you
2 that the cameras actually stopped the recording
3 on July 29th, 2019, you said that's news to
4 you?
5 : Yes. That's kind of a
6 long time for me not to notice that the cameras
7 That's, like, a week and a half.
8 : Something like that.
9 : Yeah.
10 : Yeah.
11 : For me not to notice that
12 they stopped recording.
13 : So -.
14 : But I could see where, if
15 I didn't do it, because we were busy with a
16 project, maybe I didn't check it. But that's
17 kind of hard. And for SIS, or nobody to tell
18 me, like, hey, the cameras weren't recording,
19 or we've tried to pull video and it wasn't
20 working. That's kind of weird, too.
21 : All right. All right.
22 So, since you don't remember these, we're going
23 to start going into --
24 : Sure.
25 : -- some of these -. I'm
1 just, again, because I assumed you were going
2 to remember this stuff, I'm going to cover
3 these questions to make sure that I don't miss
4 anything.
5 : Mm-hmm.
6 : And then, we will have
7 to, maybe, refresh with some of them. So, did
8 , Associate Warden , or
9 tell you to fix the cameras on
10 August 9th, 2019? On August 8th --
11 : 8th.
12 : -- or 9th, 2019.
13 : Yes. The 8th or 9th.
14 Yes.
15 : Okay.
16 : Somebody did tell me about
17 the drives.
18 : And who was it that told
19 you?
20 : I think it was SIS.
21 Somebody in SIS. It might have been
22 But I'm pretty sure it's somebody from SIS that
23 told me, hey, the cameras stopped working. Or
24 here, there is a problem.
25 : And can you just recall
1 that conversation, of what they told you, and
2 what happened, and where it was?
3 : It's pretty simple. Like,
4 hey, , the camera is not working, this
5 and that, it's not really elaborate. Like, I
6 just go and do my thing.
7 : And did they tell you,
8 fix it immediately?
9 : No.
10 : Did they tell you that
11 they were informing the captain?
12 : No.
13 : And you don't recallill
14 being involved?
15 : Pfft. This is news to me,
16 she doesn't really get involved, as far as I
17 know.
18 : Well -.
19 : I mean, after the fact,
20 everybody is involved, but
21 : So, the information we
22 have is and were
23 attempting to review video on August 8th --
24 : Oh, okay. 2019.
25 : -- 2019.
2 at video --
: Okay. They were looking
And --
: -- for some reason.
5 : -- and they were looking
6 at video. So, they called you.
7 : Okay.
8 : And had you come up. And
9 had you determine what was going on.
10 : Okay.
11 said,
12 on August 8th, she said, make sure that you get
13 this thing fixed.
14 : Mm-hmm.
15 : She, then, she said she
16 didn't work on August 9th, and the schedule for
17 August 9th reflects that.
18 : Okay. So, if that
19 happened, I'm not saying this happened, but if
20 it that did happen, I probably noticed that the
21 drive went back and probably was trying to
22 rebuild the drive. But I'm not sure if that's
23 exactly -. Honestly, I don't remember the day
24 before what happened.
25 : And that's what I'm
1 trying to, you know --
2 : Mm-hmm.
3 -- refresh your
4 recollection. So, on August 8th, 2019, she
5 said it happened some time before 2:00 p.m.,
6 that's when she spoke to you about this.
7 : So, I would have went in
8 there.
9 : And she said -.
10 : And if I was upstairs, I
11 would have went right in the room.
12 : And she - yeah - she said
13 that --
14 : But I don't remember.
15 : -- she was under the
16 understanding that, on August 8th, you were
17 fixing it.
18 : Yeah.
19 : She said, she didn't work
20 on August 9th, and she hadn't planned on
21 working on August 10th --
22 : Mm-hmm.
23 : -- but she got called in.
24 : Mm-hmm.
25 : On August 10th --
: August 10th.
: -- because of what --
: Yeah. Epstein.
: -- happened with Epstein.
: Yes.
6 : She said, when she saw
7 you on August 10th, she had learned that the
8 camera system wasn't fixed
11 recording.
: Yeah.
: -- and they weren't
: Yeah.
: And she said, , why
14 didn't this get fixed? And your response to
15 her was, I came in today to do that.
16 : Yeah.
17 : Does that all help you
18 : Yes.
19 : -- recollect what's going
20 on?
21 : Yes.
22 : Does that sound accurate?
23 : It sounds accurate, but -.
24 So, if something happened on the 8th, I don't
25 think I would wait until the 9th to fix it.
1 So, if it did happen on the 8th, I don't really
2 remember the 8th. I remember the 9th more
3 specifically. But it did happen on the 8th. I
4 would have went to the room, and just replaced
5 the drives, because that's the only thing I
6 would do.
7 : All right. I'm going to
8 skip ahead and do, I'm going to read you - and
9 I'll continue on with this - I'm going to
10 : Yeah.
11 : -- read you the FBI
12 interview report from when you
13 : Mm-hmm.
14 : -- do you remember, you
15 said that you were interviewed by the FBI?
16 : Yes. I was.
17 : All right. So, this says
18 you were interviewed by the FBI on March 12th,
19 2020. Is that correct?
20 : Yes.
21 : All right. So, I'm going
22 to just read, I'll just read the whole thing,
23 so that we're not missing anything. It says,
24 "On March 12, 2020, ," it says
25 your date of birth and telephone number, "was
1 interviewed by Assistant United States
2 Attorney, (Phonetic Sp.
3 *00:32:42), Task Force Officer Detective
4 (Phonetic Sp. *00:32:45), and
5 Special Agent-, at the United
6 States Attorney's Office, Southern District of
7 New York, 1 St. Andrew Plaza, New York, New
8 York. During the interview, provided
9 the following details." Does that all sound
10 correct so far?
11 : Yes.
12 : And we're just going to
13 stop after each paragraph, to have you --
14 : Mm-hmm.
15 : -- to check in with you.
16 " started working for the Bureau of
17 Prisons in_, and worked in both New York
18 and Indiana. had some college
19 education, was in the United States Marine
20 Corps for four years, and had ten years'
21 experience in electronics." Correct?
22 : Yes.
23 : "In 2016, was put
24 in charge of all the cameras at the
25 Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC).
1 advised that the cameras at MCC were out of
2 date. The recorders frequently went bad, and
3 the cameras were all analog, and not maintained
4 properly."
5 : Yes.
6 "The camera system was
7 over 20 years old. Sometimes, the screen would
8 be active, indicating that the camera was
9 working. However, the video would not be
10 recording."
11 : Yes.
12 • advised that only
13 one hard drive of the camera system was
14 working, at the time of the incident, on August
15 10th, 2019. When a DVR went bad, none of the
16 cameras recorded. There was a system failure
17 of DVR-2 on July 29th, 2019, and the
18 motherboard failed on DVR-2 on August 8th,
19 2019. The hard drive failure occurred on
20 August 10th, 2019." Is that something that you
21 provided to them?
22 : Yeah. I probably did.
23 Yes.
24 : So, can you just explain
25 to me what we're talking about here, because it
says -?
: That was -.
: It says, specifically,
there was a system failure --
5 : Yes.
6 : -- of DVR-2, on July 29th
8 : 29th.
9 : -- 2019.
10 : That was a month before.
11 Well, yeah.
12 : That's that week and a
13 half.
14 (Indiscernible *00:34:34).
15 : That's the July 29th,
16 2019 --
17 : Yes.
18 : -- that we were talking
19 about. So, what would have happened with the
20 system failure?
21 : That's when I had to
22 replace the motherboard on the DVR-2.
23 : And what does that mean?
24 : DVR-2 was really old, and
25 SigNet didn't have the parts to replace it, so

╭──────────── Page 58, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ Ea                                       │
│                                          │
│ specifically,                            │
│                                          │
│ 4 there was a                            │
│                                          │
│ 10 ; was a month before.                 │
│ 11 Well, yeah.                           │
│                                          │
│ 12 (IN: hat’s that week and a            │
│ 13 half.                                 │
│                                          │
│ 14 be                                    │
│                                          │
│ 16 2019 --                               │
│                                          │
│ 18 WMS, «| === we wore talking           │
│ 19 So, what would have happened with the │
│ 20 em failure?                           │
│                                          │
│ Th                                       │
│                                          │
│ hen I had                                │
│                                          │
│ 22 replace the motherboard on the DVR-2. │
│                                          │
│ and what                                 │
│                                          │
│ does                                     │
│                                          │
│ -2 was really old, and                   │
│                                          │
│ to replace so                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────╯

1 I had to call with , I contacted another
2 BOP facility, and then, I took the computer
3 apart, and he just pretty much replaced the
4 motherboard, and got the DVR-2 to start
5 working.
6 : On the 29th?
7 : If that's what it says,
8 yes.
9 : Well, it just says -. It
10 doesn't say when you got it to stop working.
11 It just says there was a system failure of DVR-
12 2 on July 29th, 2019.
13 : I believe they probably
14 spoke to Signet then. I'm not too sure with
15 the dates because everything is I've been
16 super busy. The dates, I'm not really good
17 with.
18 : Okay. But on July 29th,
19 2019, with the system failure, would have that
20 stopped the recordings?
21 : Yes. A system failure
22 would have stopped the recordings.
23 : Okay. And is it your
24 understanding that, after July 29th, the
25 recordings were working?
1 : Yes.
2 : All right.
3 : Because he would have
4 logged into Nice Vision, and he would have seen
5 things was working.
6 : But I thought you said
7 that --
8 : And that's, well --
9 : -- you'll only see if it
10 was working, if it was live feed. I thought
11 you said you wouldn't see recording.
12 : No. If you log into the
13 Nice Vision, with the live feed, you would
14 think everything is still recording because
15 everything looks green. It's when you try to
16 play back the video and, like, oh, wow, there's
17 nothing being recorded. That's when you would
18 know there is a problem.
19 : Okay. So --
20 : So, if somebody has
21 the way you check --
22 -- to pull the video.
23 Yeah.
24 : -- like, the way you
25 checked was to try to rewind video?
1 : Yeah. That's the only way
2 you could check it, is try to pull video from
3 the days prior.
4 : All right. So, you are
5 aware, though, on July 29th, 2019, it stopped
6 recording, but your understanding was that you
7 got it to work again?
8 : Yes. Everything started
9 working again.
10 : All right. And do you
11 know if you checked on it for say, let's say
12 the 30th of July, or -?
13 : I was in the middle of a
14 project, so I can't say I was just focused on
15 that, because there was a lot going on.
16 : So, you only recall that
17 you would have checked on the 29th?
18 : Yeah.
19 : Of July.
20 : Yeah. I don't think I
21 would have had reason to check, unless somebody
22 told me it wasn't working.
23 : Okay. And it says, "And
24 the motherboard failed on DVR-2, on August 8th,
25 2019." What does that mean?
1 : So, the motherboard,
2 that's the one I had to get replaced on August
3 8th, 2019.
4 : Right. So, this says
5 August 8th. And you've been saying that you
6 first learned on August 9th. So, where does
7 this come into play? How do we know that the
8 motherboard failed on DVR-2 on August 8th,
9 2019?
10 : August 8th. That's the
11 motherboard I wrote, I must have replaced.
12 Because I remember replacing a motherboard.
13 : And what does a
14 motherboard do? What is that?
15 : When did this happen?
16 Everything happened on the Epstein, that was --
17 : Epstein was the 10t .
18 : 10th.
19 : And just to help
20 : So, that's --
21 : -- so, just so we're not
22 running in circles --
: -- yeah, that -.
: -- let me just read you
25 the SigNet service call, as well.
1 : Yeah.
2 : So, this is the SigNet
3 service request, number 24975.
4 : Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
5 : It says, assigned to
7 : Mm-hmm.
9 : Mm-hmm. (Indiscernible
10 *00:37:33) .
11 : -- and
12 Date created, August 8th, 2019.
13 : Okay.
14 : And then, if we go down
15 and we look at the, well, we'll read the
16 comment section.
17 : Okay.
18 : So, there is a comment by
19 on August 8th, 2019, at 3:38 p.m.
20 It says, "Hi, . Unable to locate anything
21 official. The basic steps are as follows.
22 One, set the raid level to none and save. It
23 will restart it with all drives being J.
24 Replace any faulty drives. Two, set the raid
25 level to five, and save. It will restart and
1 being an initialization." And obviously, these
2 words seem to be wrong. I'm sure --
3 : Mm-hmm.
4 : -- it's supposed to say,
5 it will restart and begin initialization.
6 : Mm-hmm.
7 : It talks about the
8 password. And it talks about different
9 directions to go forward --
10 : Mm-hmm.
11 -- with. And then, there
12 is a comment by on August 14,
13 2019, at 8:02 p.m. This says, "
14 called us on Thursday, August 8th, stating that
15 he had two bad drives on his raid unit."
16 : Mm-hmm.
17 : "Of the Nice Vision Pro
18 Unit NVR. We advised him to get replacement
19 drives."
20 : Mm-hmm.
21 : Once they are replaced,
22 they should start to --
: Initialize.
: -- initialize --
: Yes.
1 : -- to become available
2 for the raid array. Hughwon did not have
3 drives readily available."
4 : Mm-hmm.
5 : "He checked with his
6 local CSM," which again --
7 : Mm-hmm.
8 : -- you said was --
10 okay. "To see if they
11 had any spare replacement drives. Once he
12 located replacement drives on Friday, August
13 9th, he did not have access to the DVR room to
14 replace them. He called SigNet for phone
15 support, on Saturday, August 10th --
16 : Mm-hmm.
17 : -- when he gained access
18 to the DVR room.
19 : Mm-hmm.
20 "He attempted to replace
21 the drives, and they started to rebuild.
22 During the rebuild process of the drives, the
23 drives were required to be taken out of the
24 raid on DVR-2."
25 : Yeah.
: "Once the drives are
removed without proper shutdown of the
recorder, the video database becomes corrupted.
Typically, any time the raid on a raid five
5 configuration loses two drives
6 : Mm-hmm.
7 : -- the raid needs to be
8 rebuilt, and all data is wiped from the raid."
9 : Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
10 : Do you want to just
11 review that yourself?
12 : Uh-huh.
13 : So that I'm not just
14 reading it to you, and tell me if that sounds
15 accurate to you.
16 : Yes. That sounds a little
17 bit better, like, what happened.
18 : So, is this now
19 refreshing your recollection that, actually, on
20 August 8th, is when you found out?
21 : Yes. Okay. It was the
22 8th,
23 : It was the 8th?
24 : The 8th. Yes.
25 : All right. And it was
1 the 8th that someone told you that the
2 recorders --
3 : (Indiscernible *00:40:04),
4 and I probably went to go look at the room.
5 Yes. And then, I probably went back the next
6 day, on the 9th, because the Thursday, when he
7 told me to put the drives in, I probably went
8 to put the drives in, and replace them. And
9 then, Friday, is when I'm stopped to see if the
10 drives finished that rebuilding.
11 : I'm sorry. Can you
12 repeat this again? What happened?
13 : Okay. Okay. Now, it's
14 making more sense.
15 : So, on the 8th, was it -
16 can you recall - was it that
17 told -?
18 : Somebody told me what was
19 going on, on the 8th.
20 : At the time, was there
21 only two SIS people working there, Lieutenant
22 , and SIS Tech
: -- is it -?
2 : Yes.
3 : Were they -? I think
4 they were the only two
5 : Two working.
6 : -- at the time.
7 : Yes.
8 : So, would it have been
9 one of the two of them?
10 : Two of them. Yes.
11 : Okay. And they told you
12 that the recording --
: Recorders went bad.
: -- was -.
: Yes.
: Okay. So -.
17 : And then, and that's
18 probably when I called SigNet, okay, two
19 drives, two bad drives. So, I probably got the
20 drives. I started to rebuild it. And then,
21 the next day, that's when I checked.
22 : But it sounds like, from
23 this, you didn't have the drives on the 8th.
24 Is that correct?
25 : I probably - because there

╭───────────── Page 68, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ 4 they were the only two --                 │
│                                             │
│ Two working.                                │
│                                             │
│ he time.                                    │
│                                             │
│ So, would it have been                      │
│                                             │
│ Two of them. ¥                              │
│                                             │
│ Okay. And they told you                     │
│                                             │
│ Recorders went bad.                         │
│                                             │
│ -- was                                      │
│                                             │
│ Okay. So -.                                 │
│                                             │
│ And then, and that’s                        │
│                                             │
│ 18 probably when I called SigNet, okay, two │
│                                             │
│ 19 dri                                      │
│                                             │
│ , two bad drives. So, I probably got the    │
│                                             │
│ I started to rebuild i And then,            │
│                                             │
│ hat’s when I checked.                       │
│                                             │
│ next day,                                   │
│                                             │
│ 22 MM. @= i= sounds Like, from              │
│                                             │
│ s, you didn't have the drives on the 8t     │
│                                             │
│ correc                                      │
│                                             │
│ 25 (:_— {probably - because ther            │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯

1 was spare drives on the room - so, I probably
2 started to rebuild on the 8th. I'm not too
3 sure. Honestly.
4 : All right. Well, this is
5 really important for us to get you to try to
6 remember.
7 : I know.
8 : Because this is, like, a
9 big piece of this, the fact that the cameras
10 were down when Epstein --
11 : Yeah, I know, but I
12 : -- and
13 : I was doing, like, a
14 million things, and I've been doing a million
15 things after, like --
16 : Sure.
17 : -- this happened.
18 : So, on the 8th, you
19 actually believe that, from reading this --
20 : This. Yes.
21 : -- you believe that you
22 actually did try to rebuild on the 8th --
23 : Yes.
24 : -- and not on the 10th?
25 : Not on the 10th. Yes.
1 : All right. Because that
2 way that it reads, I thought was that, you
3 didn't have them on the 8th. On the 9th, you
4 didn't have access, "And then, on the 10th,
5 when he gained access to the DVR room, he
6 attempted to replace the drives, and they
7 started to rebuild." That's how this reads.
8 : That sounds about -. That
9 sounds right. Yeah.
10 : So, now you're thinking,
11 you actually did it on the 10th, and not the
12 8th?
13 : Yeah, I know I replaced
14 the drives on the 10th, because that's when
15 they told me, like, not to do it, and it got
16 crazy.
17 : All right. So, now
18 you're thinking that actually you didn't do
19 anything on the 8th.
20 : Hmm. I probably know
21 about those drives being bad, and I went to go
22 get drives.
23 : So --
24 : Yes.
25 : -- so, on the 8th, you
1 went to look for drives?
2 : Yes.
3 : Do you think you located
4 them on the 8th?
5 : Hmm. I came back the next
6 day, and that's when I replaced them.
7 : Well, the next day was
8 the 9th --
9 : The 9th.
10 : -- and it says that you
11 didn't have access to
12 : Just to replace
13 : -- replace.
14 : -- yeah, I can't go in the
15 room.
16 : So then, it sounds like,
17 so, you didn't do anything on the 8th --
18 : Or the 9th.
19 : -- or the 9th.
20 : Mm-hmm.
21 : You obtained the
22 hardware, but then, on the 10th --
23 : That's when I got access
24 to the room.
25 : -- and previously, what
1 you told us that, is that you found out on the
2 9th, and then on the 10th, you didn't have
3 access to the room, so on the 10th, you did
4 overtime so that you could do it then.
5 : I was going to be doing
6 overtime anyway. So, I was going to be there
7 regardless.
8 : You were going to be
9 there on the 10th, regardless?
10 : Yeah, because we had TDY
11 people there.
12 : Okay. So, you were going
13 to be working on the 10th, overtime, regardless
14 of this camera issue?
15 : Yeah. Regardless. I was
16 -. Because this had nothing to do with my
17 overtime. I was doing a project.
18 : All right. Because we
19 talked in pretty detail, in July, when
20 and I spoke with you about, like, how someone
21 approved your overtime to work on the 10th,
22 specifically to work on this camera issue.
23 : No. This was not for
24 that.
25 : And you --
1 : No. And that's --
2 : -- and then, you went on
3 where, like, on, in detail about --
4 : No. That's --
5 : -- like, who would have
6 approved it --
7 : No. What --
8 -- would it have been
9 ? Would it have been one of the AWs?
10 The captain?
11 : I don't know who approved
12 it, but we were already working on the camera
13 project. So, that's what I was doing.
14 : Okay.
15 : I was already --
16 : So, you weren't --
17 : -- this had nothing to do
18 with anything.
19 : -- so, you weren't there
20 on --
21 : So, specifically, to just
22 deal with this. And if I said, okay, I'll deal
23 with it tomorrow, I probably, said, okay, I
24 don't have time today, I could deal with it
25 first thing in the morning tomorrow.
1 : Okay. So, if you didn't
2 deal with it on the 9th, because you couldn't
3 gain access to --
4 : Yes.
5 : -- the SIS room?
6 : Yeah.
7 : How were you going to get
8 access to the SIS room
9 : Somebody was there
10 : -- (Indiscernible
11 *00:43:42) .
12 : -- on Saturday.
13 : Now, someone is always
14 there from SIS on Saturday?
15 : Not always, but there was
16 going to be somebody there on Saturday --
17 : Okay.
18 : -- because I think I asked
19 • if he was going to be there Saturday.
23 employee, correct?
All right. And III --
And there was -.
: -- wasn't actually an SIS
: Yes. He was an SIS. He
25 was just in the video room.
1 : He was a telephone
2 monitor --
3 : Monitor.
4 : -- guy.
5 : Yes.
6 : But he didn't actually
7 work for SIS. Correct?
8 : No. But there would have
9 been a reason why I said I'm coming back
10 tomorrow because somebody would have been in
11 the office tomorrow for me to get access.
12 : So, you believe either
13 III, or one of the SIS -. So, III could gain
14 access without an SIS employee letting him in?
15 : He has the key for the
16 room.
17 : He did?
18 : Yes.
19 : All right. So, you
20 believe III, then, was going to be there on
21 Saturday, and he was going to grant you access?
22 : Somebody was going to be
23 there to grant me access.
24 : And previously, when you
25 said that III was You said III was there on
1 the 9th, or he was there on the 8th?
2 : That's his main post.
3 So, he is always, like, there.
4 : So, he is always in the
5 SIS room?
6 : So, for the week, yeah.
7 That's what he's -. He's just in the room.
8 : Okay. . As in,
10 : Yes. I have a couple of
11 questions.
12 : Oh, yeah. But what I --
13 (Indiscernible *00:44:50).
14 -- was going to ask is
15 if, can you check the roster for the 10th, and
16 see if III was scheduled, or , or
17 SIS
18 : Okay. Hold on a minute.
19 : Yeah. (Indiscernible
20 *00:45:01) .
21 III is listed for August
22 10th. At 7:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. on OSP number
23 one.
24 : Oh. Is that OSP number
25 one, is that the -?
1 : No. That's OSP-1. That's
2 outside perimeter. But he still had, would
3 have the key. So, he probably would have given
4 me access to the room.
5 : And do you believe that
6 you actually spoke with him about any of this?
7 : Yeah. We spoke about it,
8 like
12 spoken with him?
13 : When I went in the room,
14 like, because he was leaving for the day, he
15 was, like, well, you can't have access. I'll
16 be back tomorrow. And then, I would have came
17 --
18 : Well, and what day did he
19 tell you that? On the 8th or the 9th?
20 : That was that Friday.
24 check, was
•
: Prior to the 10th?
-- yeah.
: When would have you
: So, the 9th?
: Yeah.
: All right. Can you just
in on that Friday?
: Yeah. Let me -. 1 don't
1 see his name on the first couple of pages.
2 However, you want to go through the rest.
3 : All right. So, again,
4 the way that this reads is -.
5 : I think you said,
6 : Excuse me?
7 is listed for phone
8 monitor.
9 So, is there?
10 : Yeah. It looks like he
11 was assigned to phone monitor.
12 : All right. And phone
13 monitor would have been in the SIS room?
14 : Yes.
15 : All right. And --
16 : In the SIS room.
-- and how do they
(Indiscernible *00:47:43).
-- is that
: It's
21 : Okay. Great. All right.
22 So, he would have been the phone monitor. So,
23 your understanding, then, is on the 8th, that's
24 when it was noticed that this thing wasn't --
25 : Right.
1 : -- recording.
2 : Yes.
3 : And that was by an SIS
4 official?
5 : Mm-hmm.
6 : Somebody, either a
8 : Mm-hmm.
9 : -- or a
10 : Yeah.
11 : On the 9th, you went in
12 to go fix it?
13 : Yes.
14 : But you went towards the
15 end of your shift, when III was leaving?
16 : I started doing something
17 before then, but it was going to be too late
18 for the drives to rebuild, so even if I
19 replaced them, it wasn't going to be, like,
20 right away. The drives were going to start
21 working.
22 : Well, didn't you say that
23 it took about eight hours for the drives to -?
24 : A whole day. 24 hours.
25 : So --
1 : Not eight hours. Not
2 eight hours. A whole 24 hours.
3 : -- so, why wouldn't you
4 have rebuilt them --
5 : Mm-hmm.
6 -- during the day, on the
7 9th, so that you could check back in on the
: Probably --
: 10th?
: -- well, like I said, I
11 didn't have drives, or I was trying to get the
12 drives.
13 : Well, this says that, on
14 the 8th, you didn't have the drives. On the
15 9th --
16 : Mm-hmm.
17 : -- he had --
18 : Yeah.
19 : -- he did not access to
20 the DVR
: Mm-hmm.
: DVR room.
: Mm-hmm.
: -- to replace them.
: To replace the drives.
1 Yeah. So, it was probably later, in the end of
2 the day, I had all the drives, and I went to go
3 replace them. And that's when I couldn't go in
4 the room.
5 : Okay. And then, you
6 talked to III at that time, and said you would
7 be back on Saturday to do it?
8 : Yeah. Yeah.
9 : All right. Now, in
10 talking to , she explained
11 that this was an extremely urgent matter, and
12 that she spoke to - she wrote a memo on it.
13 And she talked to the captain, and they said,
14 make sure you get this done today. And that --
15 : Yeah.
16 •• -- on the 10th, when she
17 saw you --
18 : That sounds like --
19 •• -- she said --
20 : -- a lot of B.S. I'm
21 sorry to say like --
22 : -- okay.
23 : -- that doesn't -.
24 Because this thing happened so many times, as
25 I've been there. Like, why would this day be
1 different from the months leading up to it,
2 where this kept happening? Like, why would -.
3 I know Epstein happened. Everybody is trying
4 to say --
5 : Yeah.
6 : -- okay, this is what
7 happened, but before that, nobody even cared.
8 To be honest with you.
9 : So
10 : I'm just going to be
11 honest. Nobody cared that the drives were bad,
12 or the recordings aren't working. Oh, those
13 recorders weren't working. Okay. Fix it,
14 And then, we will go from there. But
15 nobody, before Epstein. This was, like, a known
16 thing.
17 : Okay.
18 : Like, the drives would go
19 bad. There would be no video. It was no big
20 deal to anybody in that building.
21 : Because you said, in
22 every other institution, within the BOP --
23 : Yeah.
24 : -- this would have been
25 very (Indiscernible *00:49:57) .
1 : This is a big deal. This
2 is, like, you can't leave. You've got to stay
3 here.
4 : Well, that's what she
5 says, she said she actually wrote a memo,
6 provided it to the captain, both said, yes,
7 this has got to get done on the 8th.
8 : Well, if that was the
9 case, they would have gave me access and I
10 would have stayed in the building. I would
11 never get to go home. And that's what I've
12 done before in my other institution. Any time
13 anything fails, or if there is a big failure,
14 you stay until it's fixed.
15 : Right. And that's where
17 : And that's what they are
18 doing now.
19 : -- what we're trying to
20 reconcile.
21 : Yeah.
22 : Because the memo was
23 written on the 8th, provided to the captain.
24 They said, "Make sure it's fixed." She's
25 saying that the next time she saw you, on the
1 10th, and finds out that the video wasn't
2 recorded, she says to you, why didn't you fix
3 this on the 8th?
4 : Yeah. Good luck. Yeah.
5 And because it doesn't even take me a day to
6 fix -. Those problems, it takes me a couple of
7 days, because I have to rebuild drives. Even
8 when I rebuild the drive, the next day it's not
9 going to work.
10 : Right.
11 : It's going to take a
12 couple of days. And after I rebuild the
13 drives, you have no video from the days prior.
14 I don't even know what video you have after the
15 drives start working. You have to go look to
16 see what video you have.
17 : Okay. So, again, I guess
18 that's the question of, why didn't you start
19 working on it immediately, on the 8th?
20 : Because I have no idea.
21 : Well --
22 : Well, I was working on it,
23 but yeah.
24 : -- it was -.
25 : But, like, it looks like,
1 it was a pattern of, okay, , it's a
2 priority, but it's not a priority.
3 : Okay.
4 : And for somebody to say
5 they wrote a memo to the captain, like, where
6 is there a memos before when this happened?
7 : And then, we'll have to
8 ask, I guess
9 : Yeah.
10 : -- (Indiscernible
11 *00:51:16) about previous memos.
12 : Yeah. There's got to be
13 previous memos.
14 : Okay.
15 : Yeah. This is - yeah,
16 that right there.
17 : So, you don't think that
18 that's accurate?
19 : No. I would not say that
20 that's accurate. I'm not trying to throw
21 anybody under the bus, but to say, like, this,
22 this day, like, it's bigger than any other time
23 it happened, like, come on, this has been
24 happening for months now.
25 : Okay.
1 : It's been happening since
2 I got in that building. And I was at a
3 previous institution and like I said, if this
4 was a big deal, I wouldn't even go home.
5 , you've got to stay for overtime.
6 You've got to call SigNet. I'm going to give
7 you the key for the room.
8 : Well, that's what they
9 said that they did. Or at least Lieutenant
10 is saying that she told you that this is
11 a big deal, you've got to do it.
: Pfft.
: Right now. And --
: Oh, yeah. Everybody is
15 trying to cover their tracks. No. This is not
16 the case. I could honestly say this is not the
17 case.
18 : All right.
19 : And it has never been
20 previous practice before. I had a facility
21 manager, (Phonetic Sp.
22 *00:52:05) ,my previous facility manager, I'm,
23 like, hey, the first time this happened, I
24 remember it because it was so weird to me that
25 they told me to go home. I was, like, well, at
1 my other jail, if something wasn't working, I
2 couldn't leave. Like, if he radios go down, I
3 have to stay there until the radios are fixed.
4 Like, two months ago, the radios failed, and -
5 oh, three months ago - they failed in Brooklyn.
6 They called me from MCC New York, to go to
7 Brooklyn to help them with their radio system.
8 : Right.
9 : Their console. So, if
10 that was the case, they would have called MCC
11 to come, if I couldn't stay to fix the problem.
12 So, that's never been previous practice over
13 there. No.
i4 : Okay.
15 : That's, like, that's news
16 to me.
17 : Now, are you aware that
18 the captain was notified?
19 : He probably - he should
20 have been notified. It's the captain's
21 equipment every time the camera is not
22 recording.
23 : All right. So, but you
24 do recall, you did speak on the 8th with the
25 lieutenant, with an --
1 : Yes.
2 : -- one of the two --
3 : (Indiscernible *00:53:00).
4 : SIS.
5 : I talked to somebody on
6 the 8th. Yes.
7 : And you just can't
8 specifically even kind of put yourself back
9 into that?
10 : No.
11 : Do you remember, though,
12 on the 10th, saying, why
13 didn't you fix this?
14 : I was so busy with
15 everything else. Like, I don't even remember
16 that.
17 : So, you don't remember
18 that.
19 : No. I don't.
20 : Do you have any reason to
21 believe it wasn't that you
22 spoke with on the 8th?
23 : No. I don't believe so.
24 : You don't believe you
25 spoke with her, or you don't -.
1 : No. I believe I spoke to
2 somebody from SIS. Because that's when who
3 If they were trying to pull video, and they
4 couldn't pull the video, that's when they would
5 tell me, hey,
6 : Right.
7 : -- there is a problem.
8 But other than that
9 : So --
10 : -- there is no reason for
11 me to talk to anybody from SIS.
12 : So, it's a likely that it
13 was
14 : Yes.
15 : And is it likely that, on
16 the 10th, asked you why
17 wasn't this fixed?
If she was there, yeah.
: Okay.
: Yeah.
: And is it likely that you
22 told her, on the 10th, that's why I'm here
23 today, to fix it?
24 : Yes.
25 : Okay. Is there anything
that I read to you, from this, on the, you
know, on the 8th is when you determined; on the
9th you couldn't gain access; and on the 10th
is when you gained access to the DVR room --
5 : Mm-hmm.
6 -- and you attempted to
7 replace the drives. Does that all sound
8 accurate?
9 : That sounds accurate.
10 Yes.
11 : All right. So, it is
12 that, on the 8th, you found out; the 9th, you
13 couldn't gain access --
14 : (Indiscernible *00:54:11).
15 Yeah.
16 : -- and the 10th -.
17 : It was all (Indiscernible
18 *00:54:15) . Yeah.
19 : Okay. So, now going
20 forward, though, we can at least have a
21 (Indiscernible *00:54:18).
22 a story of --
23 : For what happened --
24 : for what it is
25 : -- yes. Happened.
1 : -- that happened. So
2 now, these questions might make a little more
3 sense.
4 : Okay.
5 : And -.
6 : Hey, can I ask him
7 something?
8 : Yeah.
9 : Before we go.
10 : Please.
11 : Okay.
12 : Please do.
13 : So, there is something
14 contradictory in between the 302 and the
15 SigNet. On the 302, it states that there was a
16 motherboard failed on DVR-2, on August 8th.
17 : Mm-hmm.
18 : It doesn't say that the
19 hard drives failed. It says the hard drives
20 failed on August 10th.
21 : Yeah. Could you -.
22 : That's two different
23 things.
24 : Mm-hmm.
25 : So, yeah. So --
1 : So, as --
2 : -- according -.
3 : -- Agent
4 asked, what happened, and when did it happen?
5 : That, you would have to
6 call. I'm not too sure the dates of
7 everything.
8 : But this is, so, this was
9 the, this is the interview of you.
10 : Mm-hmm. Yes.
11 : So, the assumption is,
12 that you are the one who provided them this
13 information. Correct?
14 : Yes. I am.
15 : So, with you telling them
16 that a system failure of DVR-2 occurred on July
17 29th, 2019 -?
18 : I don't think I would have
19 given them exact dates because I don't remember
20 when all that stuff happened, to tell you the
21 truth. Me giving exact dates, that's, I can't
22 give exact dates.
23 : Okay.
24 : Yeah.
25 : And then, so you think
1 that they actually located these dates on
2 themselves?
3 : Yeah. They probably would
4 have to call SigNet to get the exact dates.
5 : So, you don't think that
6 this is actually the information you provided
7 them during the interview?
8 : No. Because I wouldn't
9 have gave them -. There is no way I would have
10 had that, or remembered this. No.
11 : Okay. And then, saying
12 that the motherboard failed on DVR-2, on August
13 8th, 2019.
14 : That's something -. Yeah.
15 That's information they would have got from
16 SigNet.
17 : So, you don't believe
18 that this, you actually - this paragraph right
19 here - that you told them? You think that they
20 got that information
21 : Yeah. They probably --
22 : -- outside of your
23 interview?
24 : -- collaborated it with
25 SigNet. Yes. Because me and - I don't even
1 remember exact dates today. So, like, there's
2 no way I could remember exact dates.
3 : All right. , did
4 you want to follow up on that?
5 : No. I mean, yeah, it
6 comes from -. So, you're saying that the
7 statement in the 302 is inaccurate?
8 : No.
9 : No.
10 : No. He's not saying
11 that's inaccurate.
12 : I'm saying it's accurate,
13 but they probably found out dates.
14 : He's saying that he
15 thinks that they got this information based
16 upon another source, not from him.
17 : Not from me.
18 : Okay.
19 : Because I can't give you
20 exact dates. That's all.
21 : All right. So, there is
22 - just while we're on this 302 - there is
23 another part that says, "After the incident,"
24 and that's the Epstein incident.
25 : I know.
1 was asked about
2 the cameras."
3 : Mm-hmm.
4 : Who asked you about the
5 cameras? Do you recall?
6 : Pfft. The warden.
7 Everybody. Anybody that could think about
8 asking me questions asked.
9 : All right. "There were
10 two new hard drives to install."
11 : Yeah.
12 : "But installing the new
13 hard drives would mean that all prior data --
14 : Yeah.
15 -- would be lost.
16 : Lost. Yeah. You would
17 lose all video.
18 : Oh. Lose all video or
19 lose all recording?
22 the old video?
: All the old video. Yes.
: Oh, so, the recording of
: Yes. Yeah.
24 : So, when you install
25 these new hard drives --
1 : The two new drives, and
2 everything would be gone.
3 everything is wiped.
4 : So, whatever video they
5 were looking for, it would be gone. So,
6 whatever they were trying to, it would be gone.
7 : Okay. It says, "The
8 Warden wanted video, and so was told to
9 start working on the system."
10 : Yes.
11 : So, at this time, was it
12 prior to replacing the new, the two new drives?
13 : Well, this time, that's
14 when I probably started replacing the drives.
15 : But if --
16 : Yeah.
17 : -- if you replaced them
18 and all recording gets --
19 : Wiped.
20 : -- wiped.
21 : Yeah.
22 : Then how would you be
23 able to obtain the video?
24 : Yeah, there is no video
25 obtained.
1 : So, that's what I'm just
2 trying to make sense of what this states. So,
3 "The Warden wanted video, so
They wanted me to start --
: -- was told -."
-- they wanted me to start
7 that day recording video. We will get the
8 recorder to work, though --
9 : Oh.
10 : -- (Indiscernible
11 *00:57:52) .
12 : Well, he didn't want
13 video of the incident --
14 : Incident.
15 : -- he wanted video to
16 (Indiscernible *00:57:56) .
17 : And then, he was trying to
18 see if there was video from the incident, and
19 I'm, like, there is no video. And that's when,
20 the next day, I find out there was a video on
21 the other recorder --
22 : Okay.
23 : -- that, yeah, that other
24 camera.
25 : So, that helped explain
1 it. When you were saying the warden wanted
2 video, you're talking about from that point
3 forward, the video
4 : The video. Yeah.
5 : -- he wanted the
6 recording to be working --
7 : Yeah. He
8 : -- not the video of the
9 incident.
10 -- well, they wanted a
11 video of the incident, and the recorder to
12 start working. I'm, like, there's no video,
13 there's nothing I could do. I can't find any
14 video.
15 : Okay.
16 : That recorder is gone.
17 : I gotcha.
18 : So then, it was at that
19 point, okay, we'll get the recorder working,
20 and do whatever you got to do to get the
21 recorder working.
22 : Okay. So, it says,
23 " started removing the bad drives in
24 order to rebuild the DVR."
25 : Yeah.
1 : Is that correct?
2 : Yes.
3 : So, are you the one that
4 actually removed the two --
5 : The drives.
6 : -- drives?
7 : Yeah.
8 : And you --
9 : And I labeled everything.
10 Yeah.
11 : -- and you put the new,
12 two new drives in?
13 : Yes.
14 : All right.
15 : And then, the FBI came and
16 stopped me in the middle of everything.
17 : It says, " advised
18 that the FBI agent was the one who pulled out
19 the DVR."
20 Yeah. Because I told
21 them, if you pull out the drives, that you're
22 going to have problems, there's going to be
23 corruption, because like I, like I told you
24 before, you pull out two drives, like,
25 everything is wiped. Even if there is a video
1 from before. You just, you're, like, out of
2 luck. Because it's going to --
3 : Now, can you just explain
4 that? What is it that they pulled?
5 : Two of the drives.
6 : They pulled the two
7 drives?
8 : Yeah. Yeah. Because I
9 was See, what happened was, I was going to
10 start rebuilding the drives, so I labeled
11 everything. It was, it was a mess. So, they
12 wanted me to -. Let me if I can think about
13 it. So, everything stopped working. I go in
14 the room, , you've got to get the
15 recorder working. Well, I got to pull the
16 drives out to get the recorder working. So,
17 the two drives that I pulled out. And so, the
18 two old drives, and the two new drives, I
19 labeled them, because I knew that it was going
20 to be a big thing. So, I got to pay attention
21 to what I'm doing. And then, in the midst of
22 all that, that's when they took the drives, and
23 said, hey, we need to stop doing everything.
24 : So, who is it that
25 actually pulled the bad drives out? You or the
1 FBI?
2 : I pulled the bad drives
3 out to replace them with good drives. Yes.
4 : And you put the two new
5 drives in?
6 : Drives in. Yes.
7 : So, what is it that the
8 FBI pulled?
9 : They pulled all the
10 drives.
11 : So, you were rebuilding
12 it. And when you rebuilt it, they came in and
13 they just pulled them all out?
14 : Yeah. They would pull
15 them all.
16 : So, it was never able to
17 rebuild?
18 : Yes.
19 : All right. So, they
20 pulled all the drives. And so, when they said
21 the DVR. Is that different from -?
22 : Yeah. The DVR because
23 they pulled everything from DVR-1, and that was
24 the one that wasn't working. And then, DVR-2,
25 the one that was working, the next day, I had
1 to get all the - well, the same day - I could
2 get all the important parts of the prison on
3 DVR-1, that wasn't working, on DVR-2, which I
4 probably should have done the day before, but
6 : So, it's DVR-2 that we're
7 speaking about. Correct?
8 : Yes. That was the good
9 drive.
10 : Oh, DVR-2 was the good
11 drive?
12 : Yes.
13 : But DVR-1 wasn't. Okay.
14 So, DVR.
15 : And what does this say?
16 DVR. DVR-2 is the good drive. DVR-1 is the
17 bad drive.
18 : Okay. So, DVR-1 --
19 : That's not - no - that's
20 not what you said before. You said DVR-1 was
21 all good. DVR-2 went bad.
22 : Yes.
23 : Okay. So, DVR-2 was the
24 bad drive.
25 : Yes.
1 : So, as far as DVR-2 being
2 the bad drive, is the DVR, is that the 16
3 drives, or is there a separate box --
4 : No. It's the 16 drives,
5 and then, you have, like, the brain, some
6 motherboard, you know, the other computer on
7 the bottom, but -.
8 : So, when you say, when
9 they say that the FBI agent was the one who
10 pulled out the DVR, you're talking about all 16
11 --
12 : All the, they probably
13 pulled the --
14 : -- drives and
15 motherboard.
16 : -- they probably pulled -.
17 Yeah. They probably took all of the
18 recordings. But they had to take -. When I'm
19 talking about that the next day, because we
20 already had the new set, when all this
21 happened, SigNet came the next day, and we had
22 the new system up and running. Everything was
23 in boxes. So, he had to just come in and
24 install it.
25 : Okay. So --
: So, the next day, the FBI
took both drives, DVR-1 and 2.
: So, on the 11th, the FBI
came and just took it all?
5 : They took it all. Yes.
6 : Everything?
7 : Everything.
8 : All right. Okay. So, it
9 says that, " also advised that he knew
10 that, by replacing both hard drives, the system
11 would be wiped.
12 : Mm-hmm.
13 : And that he had advised
14 personnel at MCC of that."
15 : Yes.
16 : Now, when you say,
17 "Wiped," it means just everything --
18 : It means --
19 : -- that was on it before?
20 : -- everything is gone.
21 Yes. There is no video. There's nothing.
22 : And do you know how far
23 that would have gone back to?
24 : No.
25 : No?
1 : No.
2 : So, was that the case,
3 could have we obtained video off of those -?
4 : Other drives? Yes, before
5 I started rebuilding. Yes. But that's what I
6 was told to do. So, that's what I was
7 (Indiscernible *01:02:17) .
8 : So, just explain that.
9 What could have we got off of it? And you're
10 talking about DVR-2 now, the bad drive. Right?
11 : DVR-1 is the bad drive.
12 : So, this is where I'm
13 getting confused. I thought we just said that
14 DVR-2 is the bad drive. I've got to get this
15 straight. , you just - I thought we
16 said, we did say that, but then you just chimed
17 in and said it was DVR-2 that was bad. Which
18 one was it? DVR-1 or 2 that was bad?
19 : DVR-1 is bad.
20 : In the initial part of the
21 interview, he stated that DVR-2 went bad, and
22 DVR-1 drives were all good.
23 : All right. Because yeah,
24 on the thing, it says --
25 : Yeah, because everything
1 was on DVR-2.
2 : -- "He attempted to
3 replace the drives, and he started to rebuild.
4 During the rebuild process of the drives, the
5 drives were required to be taken out of raid on
6 DVR-2."
7 : Yeah. I would say on DVR-
8 2. I'm sorry. I got confused.
9 : All right. So, DVR-2 is
10 the bad drive --
11 : The bad drive. Yes.
12 : All right. So, on DVR-2,
13 the bad drive --
14 : Yeah.
15 : -- could video have been
16 obtained?
17 : Yes, before I started
18 doing anything. Yes.
19 : So, prior to you pulling
20 them out, we may have been able to obtain video
21 from the 9th?
25 recording.
: Hmm. No.
: August 9th?
: No. Because it wasn't
1 •
2 •
3 drives.
4 ■
: All right.
: Because you had two bad
: So, what video are you
5 talking about when we said we could have
6 obtained video?
7 : Oh, well, saying that
8 stuff there is a possibility in the background,
9 even if you have two bad drives that stuff
10 could have been recording over it, but that's
11 their technical jazz. Like, I don't know
12 anything about that.
13 : So, in saying that
14 : But saying that -.
15 it sounds like, okay,
16 it is possible that we could have gotten video
17 --
18 : Video.
19 : -- for August 9th and
20 10th.
21 : Yes. It is a possibility.
22 Not a strong possibility, but yeah.
23 : So, it is possible, but
24 once the two drives
25 : Yes.
1 : -- were pulled --
2 : Pulled. Yes. That was a
3 --
4 : -- that possibility
5 became
6 : Yeah.
7 : -- impossible.
8 : It was gone. Yes.
9 : All right. Now, are
10 those two drives, are you -? When the SIS
11 official told you on the 8th that they weren't
12 able to go back --
13 : To do.
14 : -- and review the video -
15 -
16 : Mm-hmm.
17 : -- if something was
18 recording in the background, would you have
19 been - you know, like you were talking about,
20 there is a possibility - would you have been
21 able to tell at that time?
22 : No. I wouldn't have been
23 able to tell. That's something SigNet would
24 have, or some expert, video expert, would have
25 -.
: All right.
: That's nothing above me.
: Was your only course of
4 action to replace those two bad drives?
5 : Yes.
6 : So, would, regardless,
7 that video have been, at some point, deleted?
8 : Yes.
9 : And you were -. Who
10 instructed you to actually pull out those two
11 bad drives?
12 : I would just have to - I
13 probably talked to SigNet, or -. Well, and I
14 told SIS this before, like, if I pulled two
15 drives, there is no video, especially if it was
16 bad.
17 : Did you talk to anybody
18 on August 10th, prior to pulling them, that
19 there was a possibility that video of the
20 Epstein incident could have been retrieved?
21 : No.
22 : So, you didn't tell
23 anybody that?
24 : I'm not saying I didn't
25 tell anybody that, but that was -. I think
1 that's something I found out later. Because
2 that's when SigNet was talking to me. But
3 that's not something I would have known before
4 Epstein.
5 : All right.
6 : Because that was something
7 we talked about, like, the days after that
8 happened.
9 : Because this 302 says,
10 %•%
advised that an FBI agent was the one
11 who pulled out the DVR. also advised
12 that he knew that, by replacing both hard
13 drives, the system would be wiped, and that he
14 had advised personnel at MCC of that."
15 : Mm-hmm. There would be no
16 video.
17 : When did you do that?
18 : Before I started doing
19 anything. If I'm going to change drives,
20 you're going to know, like, it's -. Because I
21 know this was going to be bigger than just me
22 fixing the recorders. Like, there is other
23 things that are going to happen, but I'm going
24 to tell you, hey, if I do this, this is what's
25 going to happen.
1 : But I thought you just
2 said that that's something you found out later.
3 : Later. But no, as far as
4 there being video on the background.
5 : Oh.
6 : Yeah. As far as --
7 : So -.
8 : -- me pulling out the
9 drives, I already knew that before because
10 that's what happened the last time, when I
11 replaced two drives, that there was no old
12 video. It was just the new video.
13 : So, on the 10th, your
14 understanding, that there was no video from the
15 9th --
16 : Or the 10th.
i7 -- or 10th.
18 : Yes. That was my
19 understanding.
20 : So, therefore, yeah, and
21 at that time, you didn't know that there was a
22 possibility --
23 : Possibility --
24 : If things were recording
25 --
1 : -- going in the
2 background.
3 : -- in the background.
4 : Yes.
5 : And once the DVR, that
6 the two drives were pulled, that possibility
7 became --
8 : Became an impossibility.
9 : -- an impossibility.
10 : Yes.
11 : Okay. Before we move on
12 from that, did anybody want to clarify any of
13 that?
14 : Yeah.
15 : What --
16 : Go ahead.
17 technically, when you pull
18 a drive --
19 : Mm-hmm.
20 : -- like, what happens? It
21 might be a technical question.
22 : Yeah.
23 : Like, how does everything
24 wipe? Is that -?
25 : Oh, well, it's, like,
1 looking for ones and zeros, and if nothing is
2 lined up, from what the SigNet explained to me,
3 is one drive being bad is not really a problem,
4 because the other drives are going to -. It's
5 the redundant. So, it's the backup, it's going
6 to take over for that drive that's not working.
7 : Okay.
8 : But now, since this drive
9 is not working, and this one that's working is
10 taking, any drive is taking over for this
11 drive, and that drive goes bad, that means we
12 have two bad drives. That means nothing is
13 going to be recording.
14 : So, they work in conjunction
15 -
16 : Yeah.
17 : -- with the other one?
18 : Yeah.
19 : But the death of --
20 : The redundant.
21 the death of one
22 : (Indiscernible *01:07:27).
23 is (Indiscernible
24 *01:07:25) . Gotcha.
25 : And then, when they both
1 die, you're done.
2 : Gotcha. And there's no way to
3 recover anything?
4 : Well, at the time, they
5 told me no, and then they said, well, there is
6 a possibility that it could have been recording
8 : Yeah.
9 : -- in the background,
10 after the fact.
11 : Okay.
12 : But that was something
13 more technical than my understanding, because
14 at the time, if something goes bad, just, you
15 know, take the drives out, put it in. And
16 then, this became a bigger thing. So now,
17 we're, like, well, there was still kind of a
18 possibility that more things would have been
19 happening. From my understanding. That's what
20 SigNet told me.
21 : Okay.
22 : All right. And then, for
23 clarity purposes, when - again, on the 8th, you
24 found out that this was an issue, and that you
25 had to replace the drives --
1 : Mm-hmm.
2 : -- when did you obtain
3 the new drives?
4 : It had to be some time
5 during that day or the next day. I probably
6 was looking for drives, because if I --
7 : Because you said --
8 : -- if I knew --
9 you got them, and you
10 got them from the CSM?
11 : Yeah.
12 : Okay. And you just don't
13 know if that, you got them from CSM on the 8th
14 or the 9th?
15 : The 9th. Yeah. I know I
16 got some drives from him before because we've
17 gotten, I've gotten old drives from him before.
18 And I know we've ordered drives. I'm not too
19 sure if I ordered a whole bunch of drives to
20 just replace all 16, or whatever, how many are
21 in the raid. But we were, that was going to be
22 the next step, to just rebuild everything.
23 : Now, if it was your
24 project, and you are the camera guy, why did he
25 have the drives and not you?
1 : Because he has all the
2 hard drives in the building. Like, me having
3 the hard drives is not part of my job
4 description. But --
5 : All right. So --
6 -- I could have them, but
7 he's got more, like, readily available ones.
8 And everything that I had was from the old
9 stuff that wasn't working from before.
10 : Okay.
11 : So, if I pulled something
12 from that, something that wasn't working
13 before, I don't know if it was bad. That's why
14 it's on the shelf. Because nothing was labeled
15 bad. It was just on the shelf. That's, it was
16 a mess, that whole area was a mess.
17 : Okay. Where was his
18 equipment stored?
19 : Oh, the CSM?
20 : Yes.
23 near the -?
25 the first floor.
: His is in the server room.
: Is that within the SIS,
: No. That's downstairs, in
1 : Okay. So, the server
2 room is in the computer server room?
3 : Yes. Yeah.
4 : Nothing to do with the
5 cameras?
6 : No.
7 : All right. So, you would
8 have had to have gone to him
9 : Gone up to him --
10 -- within the -?
11 -- with the, yeah, at the
12 time, like, hey, , you got some drives? I
13 don't have any drives.
14 : Okay. So, what -? Can
15 you just explain what steps it is? You found
16 out on the 8th. What steps did you take in
17 order to resolve this issue? Do you know if
18 you -? Did you call SigNet on the 8th, or did
19 you call them on the 10th? Because the way
20 that this -. The way that this reads, just
21 look at these comments. It says this comment
22 was made on the 8th, at 3:38 p.m. --
23 : Mm-hmm.
24 : -- and where it says, "Hi
25 Unable to locate anything official --
1 : Mm-hmm.
2 : -- the basic steps are as
3 follows. Set the raid level --
4 : Uh-huh.
5 : -- it none and save. It
6 will So, what is going on here? What are
7 these instructions? This is supposed to be
8 specific to this incident.
9 : Mm-hmm.
10 : Do you follow what's
11 going on there?
12 : Yeah. Oh, so, I called
13 them on Thursday. And I probably started to
14 rebuild on Friday. But I couldn't do the
15 rebuild on Friday.
16 : So, you called them on
17 Thursday? What, to obtain the instructions?
18 : I already knew what I had
19 to do. I always just call them to make sure
20 I'm doing everything right.
21 : All right. So, on
22 Thursday, you called them.
23 : Mm-hmm.
24 : And are these
25 instructions that I'm looking at, though, on
1 this comment from August 8th, 2019, at 3:38
2 p.m.?
3 : Yeah. It looks like
4 that's right. When I - that's where I do the
5 rebuild, probably. Those are probably the
6 instructions to do the rebuild.
7 : Yeah.
8 : For two drives.
9 : And do you understand who
10 it's - when it says, "Hi Unable to
11 locate anything official." - do you know who it
12 is that is talking there?
13 : It could be
14 or
15 : Hey. Can I --
16 : That was
17 can I clarify that?
18 Because I didn't -. We know that that comment
19 right there is by (Phonetic Sp.
20 *01:11:18) . He's a Qognify support engineer.
21 : Okay.
22 : And that's the
23 instructions that he provided to give you.
24 : Okay.
25 : Okay.
1 : All right. And do you
2 know when you would have received those
3 instructions? Would it have been on the 8th?
4 : Yes.
5 : Okay. And you're saying,
6 the reason why you didn't do it on the 8th is
7 because --
8 : I didn't have the drives.
9 : -- you didn't have the
10 drives
11 : Uh-huh.
12 : -- to do it?
13 : Yeah.
14 : All right. So then, on
15 the 9th, you got --
16 : The drives.
17 : -- the drives?
18 : Yes.
19 : But you got them later in
20 the day
21 : Late.
22 • -- is what you're saying?
23 : Yes. And I didn't have
24 access to go in the room.
25 : And III told you that you

╭──────────── Page 120, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ 1 MNS) «822 ight. and do you              │
│                                           │
│ 2 know when you would have received those │
│                                           │
│ ructions? Would it have been on the 8th?  │
│                                           │
│ idn't do it on the                        │
│                                           │
│ have                                      │
│                                           │
│ and I didn                                │
│                                           │
│ to go in the room.                        │
│                                           │
│ 25 RS: MM coe you that you                │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────╯

1 --
2 : Can't go in there.
3 : -- couldn't be in there?
4 : Yes.
5 : And do you specifically
6 recall being the one who said you can't
7 come in here?
8 : Well, he's just, like, if
9 I'm gone for the day, there was nobody else
10 there. He was the only one with the key.
11 : So, again, if we speak to
12 him, is he going to say, yeah, I told him he
13 can't come in?
14 : Yeah. Yeah. He knows I
15 can't come in. Because it's the evidence room,
16 too. So, yeah.
17 : Yeah. We talked to SIS
18 about that. She said there was not an
19 evidence room in there.
20 : It's still an evidence
21 room right now. If you go there.
22 : Mm-hmm.
23 : That's where I
24 : Well, maybe now, but what
25 is it on the 9th?
2 evidence room.
: -- it's always been the
: Because she said, yeah
: It's not going to be --
5 : -- she said there were
6 files in there, but there's no evidence.
7 : Yeah. Every contraband
8 they get from inmates, that's where they store
9 everything.
14 --
16 *01:12:28) .
18 still, there's junk
19 video room. That's
20 had with this whole
: In that area?
: In that area. Yes.
: Where the -?
: Yes. And if you go there
: Where (Indiscernible
-- right now, there's
in there. It's not just a
the biggest problem that I
thing, was that at other
21 institutions, when you have a video room, you
22 just have a video room. There is nothing else
23 in there. There's just the com techs. You go
24 in, you do whatever you got to do, you come
25 out. There should not be anything else mixed
1 with the room.
: Okay.
: And up to this day, there
4 is still evidence and garbage in that room.
5 : Okay.
6 : So, it is not a video
7 room.
8 : Can you just look on the
9 9th, what time did III work until?
10 : Hold on.
11 : Did you say 7:00 to
12 : On the 9th. Bear with me.
13 Nine. So, this falls under either 7:00 to
14 3:00, or 8:00 to 4:00.
15 : Okay.
16 : So, it was later than me
17 staying for And you could just check my
18 overtime, too, to see what time I stayed. So,
19 if I did overtime that day.
20 : All right. But point
21 being, is you didn't go in and fix them on that
22 day?
23 : No.
24 : All right. So, when you
25 say you didn't have access to the room, you are
1 saying you didn't have access to the room after
2 3:00 p.m.?
3 : Yes.
4 : And you
5 : Or whatever time.
6 : -- because usually --
7 : Yeah.
8 : -- your shift was from
9 6:00 a.m. to --
10 : 6:00 --
11 : -- 2:00 p.m.
12 : -- 2:00 --
13 : Correct?
14 : -- yeah, but I was doing a
15 project. So, I don't know what overtime. I
16 was probably doing overtime. So, I was working
17 maybe 12 hours, 16 hours.
18 : And this is just one of
19 those things we're going to have really
20 reconcile here, because
21 : Mm-hmm.
22 : -- as you know, this is
23 such a big part of this thing --
24 : Mm-hmm.
25 : -- that we don't have a
1 video. Why didn't you, from 6:00 to 2:00, fix
2 this thing?
3 : Because I was doing other
4 things. This wasn't -. This was a priority,
5 but, and the fact, like I said, this was not,
6 like, the main priority in the building. Oh,
7 the recorders aren't working? Okay. Well, all
8 right, it's not, like, oh, not, this is what
9 you have to make. Now, after Epstein, like,
10 oh, this is the main thing you have to focus on
11 for the day.
12 : Okay. So, you didn't get
13 to it until after you took care of a bunch of -
15 : Other stuff.
16 : -- other stuff.
17 : Yes.
18 : And by the time you got
19 to it, at the end of your shift, basically, it
20 sounds like?
21 : Yes.
22 : That there wasn't enough
23 time to do it?
24 : To do it. Yeah. Yeah.
25 : But you could have gained
1 access between --
: 6:00.
: -- at least when he was
4 working there, 7:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m.
5 : Yes.
6 : But you just didn't?
7 : No.
8 : Okay. When you
9 : I have a few questions.
10 : yup. Go ahead.
11 : I have a question. I know
12 you might have actually answered this question,
13 but just I, I probably didn't hear it. But you
14 said that you spoke to MCC personnel about the
15 date of being wiped. Who specifically did you
16 speak to?
17 : It would be somebody in
18 SIS.
19 : It would be somebody
20 where?
21 : Or I'm pretty sure I told
22 the warden, too, because this was a big deal.
23 That on the, on that Saturday, when everything
24 happened, like, you know, if I pulled these,
25 there's going to be no video at all.
1 : And is this the
2 conversation you had directly with the captain?
3 : No. This would have been
4 the warden, or SIS. I really didn't see the
5 captain that day. I don't remember seeing the
6 captain or talking to the captain.
7 : Was this a big --
8 : I would just --
9 -- sorry.
10 -- that day --
11 : -- this was a big
12 conversation.
13 : -- yeah, when
14 : Yeah.
15 : -- everybody was asking me
16 questions. It was mainly SIS and the warden I
17 was dealing with. I wasn't really dealing with
18 anybody else.
19 : But you don't recall
20 exactly who you told, hey, I'm about to pull
21 the drives, but everything will be wiped?
22 : I'm not too sure. But
23 either the SIS or the warden. I'm pretty sure
24 of that.
25 : But again, he explained -
1 -
2 : And do you -.
3 : -- that it was his
4 understanding that there was nothing on there,
5 anyway. He didn't find out until later that
6 there could have been some background.
7 : Okay. And then, the final
8 question is, when the FBI agent that came in,
9 do you remember who that FBI agent was that you
10 spoke to?
11 : No. I don't remember his
12 name.
13 : Okay.
14 : Okay.
15 : And you told him
16 specifically that, hey, listen, I pulled two
17 drives --
18 : Two drives. Yeah.
19 -- and it's in the process
20 of being rebuilt?
21 : Yes.
22 : And you advised him that,
23 if they pulled the drives, at that point.
24 : That they were going to be
25 - yes. And I was on the phone with SigNet when
1 this was going on. So, I could tell them
2 exactly what was going on.
3 : Well, let me clarify
4 that, then, because you said that you pulled
5 the two drives, and that would have wiped the
6 system, but you said the FBI came in and just
7 took everything.
8 : Yeah, they took --
9 : So --
10 : -- took everything. Yes.
11 : -- so, they didn't pull
12 the two drives.
13 : Drives.
14 : They pulled it all?
15 : All. Yes.
16 : You said the -. They
17 took all --
18 : Yes.
19 : DVR-2 on the 10th --
20 : Well, all the --
21 : -- and they came back on
22 the 11th, took the rest --
23 : The rest of it.
25 : Yes.
of it.
1 : Is that correct?
4 clarify that,
: Yes.
: So, does that help
: Yeah. Now, the last part
6 to this, I emailed you guys a snippet. Based
7 on the FBI's analysis, it looks like, they
8 indicated that there was a catastrophic disc
9 failures in their raid. And no reportings
10 would have been available after 7/29.
11 : Mm-hmm.
12 : You mentioned earlier in
13 the interview that there was a motherboard
14 failure.
15 : Yes. That was another
16 time.
17 : But that happened around
18 July. That's what you initially mentioned.
19 : I have If that's what
20 I said, then yes. But
21 : So, and you said the only
22 way you could have corrected that situation
23 would have been that, you went in, and you
24 verified that by reviewing, going back and
25 reviewing old footage, to see that the cameras
1 were working.
: Yes.
: And are you sure that you
4 did that? Because according to the FBI, based
5 on their analysis, it looks like there was a
6 catastrophic disc failures, and there is
7 nowhere, recordings in there since 7/29 anyway.
8 : I'm going to read you
9 what this says.
10 : Okay.
11 : It says, "On," it looks
12 like it would have been in September 18th,
13 2019, "A meeting was conducted with DVR vendor,
14 technical support representative,
15 , of SigNet Technologies.
16 provided an overview of the operation of the
17 system. A review of the DVR-2 controller logs
18 by and Senior Advisor
19 "indicated that there had been
20 catastrophic disc failures in the array, and no
21 recordings would have been available after
22 7/29/2019."
: So, on the --
: It says, "
: -- (Indiscernible
1 *01:18:31) .
3 : Go ahead.
4 : -- and Computer Scientist
5 , "were provided
6 access to the beginning sectors of the 16
7 drives, to see if the structure would indicate
8 clues of a possible rebuild. None were
9 apparent." So, what it is saying is that, and
10 you could read the specific language, this
11 would be, like, but what it is saying is that -
12 -
13 : Yeah.
14 : -- on the 29th, nothing -
15 -
16 : Had been recorded.
17 : -- had recorded.
18 : Yes.
19 : Prior to that, it sounded
20 like you were, like, there is no possibility
21 that that could have happened. I would have
22 known.
23 : Mm-hmm.
24 : So --
25 : Yeah.
1 : -- now, when you're
2 seeing them, and did they go in and they look
3 at this, does that seem like they would be
4 right, and nothing recorded after 7/29?
5 : Yes. They're the experts.
6 So, they would know that nothing recorded.
7 : All right. So, from 7/29
8 to 2019, nothing recorded, but this is the
9 first time you are hearing of it?
10 : Yes. That is the first
11 time I'm hearing about that.
12 : And during the FBI
13 interview, that's not something they discussed
14 with you?
15 : No. Nobody told me that
16 was on the 29th. That that's the first time.
17 That's the first time I've heard that.
18 : Okay. Sorry, . Do
19 you want to go ahead?
20 : Yeah. You mentioned that,
21 earlier in the interview, I might have - based
22 on my notes here - that you did a motherboard
23 rebuild, and there was (Indiscernible
24 *01:19:44) could have happened around July
25 29th. And if this happened around July 29th,
1 are you sure that you went in and you verified
2 that the cameras were actually operating? It
3 was actually recording?
4 : Yes. I would have to
5 verify everything was recording.
6 : Now, if it was recording,
7 how was it that, based on their analysis of
8 this stuff, that there is no recordings in the
9 system after 7/29/2019?
10 : The way I was taught to
11 look at the system, was to look at the Nice
12 Vision, and if I saw the red lights, like, the
13 system is recording. But then, I found out
14 later, the red lights on the system recording,
15 the way I was looking at it, it doesn't mean
16 that there was actual video recording. That's
17 something that SigNet told me later.
18 : All right. But then, that
19 contradicts what you stated earlier. Earlier,
20 you stated that you actually went back in, and
21 you reviewed --
22 : Yeah.
23 : -- older footage.
24 : I would have to look for
25 video. Yes.
1 : But now, it's different.
2 Now, you're stating that you went back in, and
3 you just looked to see if there was, like, a
4 dot --
5 : No, no.
6 : -- to see if it was
7 recording.
8 : I'm saying, I did both. I
9 would have looked to see if there was video,
10 and then I would have looked to see that I got
11 the red lights, that everything was recording.
12 The initial thing to do is to look to see a red
13 lights, that those are working. And then, the
14 next thing was to do was to pull back to see if
15 there was video. Now, SigNet told me later,
16 after all of this happened, even on the new
17 recorder that we have, the red lights that
18 show, it don't mean that anything is recording.
19 The system is not recording. You would have to
20 go pull video from, like, a week before, or two
21 weeks before, to see if there was a failure.
22 But you would not know, like, looking at it,
23 that there was a problem.
24 : Okay. But you had said
25 based upon this comment by the FBI report --
1 : Yes.
2 : -- there was no recording
3 for you to go back and pull back --
4 : Back. Yes.
5 : -- (Indiscernible
6 *01:21:21) .
7 : Because it happened on the
8 29th. So, there must have been video that I
9 pulled back from maybe before the 29th. When I
10 was looking at it.
11 : So, what you're saying is
12 that, you reviewed the, you fixed the
13 motherboard, but when you checked to see the
14 video was recording, you didn't check to see if
15 video was recording from the time you checked
16 the --
17 : No.
18 : -- fixed the motherboard
19 --
20 : No.
21 : -- to the time that you
22 checked it,
23 you fixed --
24 : Yes.
25 : -- the motherboard.
you checked previous to the time
:
:
wouldn't have known
:
Yes.
So, therefore, you
--
Known that.
5 : -- that it wasn't --
6 : Yeah.
7 -- recording --
8 : It wasn't recording.
9 -- at that point.
10 : Yeah. I wouldn't have
11 known that. I was just under the assumption
12 that everything, because I saw the video from
13 before.
14 : So, you saw --
15 : That it was working.
16 -- the video from before,
17 but you would have seen that anyway --
18 : Mm-hmm.
19 : -- what you needed to do,
20 actually, was check --
21 : Check.
22 : -- from the point that
23 you fixed it --
24 : To -.
25 : -- to the time --
1 : That I checked.
2 : -- that you checked.
3 : Yeah.
4 : Needed to be that
5 recording.
6 : Yes.
7 : And you didn't do that?
8 : There was no video. So.
9 : But are we certain --
10 : There was no.
11 : -- that July 29th, 2019
12 would have been the day that you fixed the
13 motherboard? That's what this information
14 says, but it says the motherboard failed on
15 that day, at least, but we don't know that
16 specifically, that that's the day that you
17 tried to fix it, or do we?
18 : No.
19 : Because the only other
20 service request I have for 2019 is this one on
21 February 28th, 2019. Would have they put in a
22 service request if you were fixing the
23 motherboard?
24 : I would have -. I had the
25 emails before, maybe with , with the
I motherboard.
2 : You do?
3 : Yeah.
4 : Could that
5 : Because I have the
6 : -- can that be the third
7 thing we ask you for
8 : -- because I had --
9 : -- if you could get us
10 those emails?
11 : -- we have to get it from
12 another jail, because they didn't have it. And
13 he was the one that walked me through because I
14 had to -. He walked me through and I'm, like,
15 one of their engineers had to walk me through
16 how to pull that thing out. The motherboard.
17 : All right. Can you give
18 me all your emails from and
19 and
20 : Mm-hmm.
21 : That will be the third
22 thing I'm going to ask. Is that okay?
23 : Yes.
24 : Can you tell me, this
25 service request number, 22855, it says, date
1 created February 28th, 2019. It was a
2 , and
3 again. By looking at this, can you tell me
4 what it was -? This is the only other one we
5 could, we've received with that --
6 : (Indiscernible *01:23:38).
7 : -- from that calendar
8 year. Can you tell me what that would have had
9 to do with?
10 : Hmm. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
11 Okay. Rebuilt the raid. So, there was a -.
12 It doesn't say what drive or anything. Right?
13 : I don't know. I'm asking
14 you. Because it's not as detailed as this
15 other one, it kind of looks like more
16 instruction type things.
17 : Yeah, yeah. Hmm.
18 : Because you said that the
19 drives had gone bad in the past --
20 : Yes.
21 : -- and you knew that they
22 would do it again.
23 : Again.
24 : Is this what you're
25 talking about? Is this February 20 --
1 : Yes.
2 : 28th, would that have
3 been when the drives went bad last time?
4 : The last time. Yes. And
5 it probably went bad a time before that, also.
6 : But on this date, is that
7 when you said that you had previously ordered
8 the new drives --
9 : Yeah.
10 : -- based upn
11 : No. This would have been
12 --
13 : -- (Indiscernible
14 *01:24:23) .
15 -- it would have been a
16 little bit later on, I ordered the drives. It
17 would have been before all of this happened,
18 that I ordered -.
19 : But point being, is, you
20 told us that the reason why you ordered them is
21 because that it had gone bad in the past --
22 : Mm-hmm.
23 : -- and they told you it
24 would go bad --
25 : Bad again.
1 : -- again in the future.
2 : Yes.
3 : Is this the last event
4 that, when they went bad? And the reason why
5 they would have told you that information.
6 : If that's when I called
7 them. That probably would have been the last
8 event.
9 : Okay.
10 : Yeah.
11 : So, earlier that year.
12 : Yeah.
13 : Okay. So, approximately
14 six months before. Okay. And that's why you
15 would have ordered the new drives, though, and
16 had them on hand?
17 : Yes.
18 : Okay. Just before we -.
19 Can you just initial and date these before we
20 continue moving on? I just -. Wait. We have
21 -. As you know, we have everyone initial and
22 date these things.
23 : Mm-hmm.
24 : So we know what it is
25 that we're talking about, for the future.
: Mm-hmm.
: I mean, the date is
: Mm-hmm.
: -- again, September 29th,
5 2021. And I'm making sure, making sure we have
6 those. Let me see what else. All right. So,
7 when you realized that you could not resolve
8 the recording issue on August 8th, 2019, did
9 you notify anyone that you needed more time?
10 : No.
11 : No. And why didn't you?
12 So, if the SIS told you, hey, we need this
13 fixed, why didn't you notify him that it --
14 : past --
15 : -- could (Indiscernible
16 *01:26:14) .
17 -- practice, so just go
18 home, . It's not that important. You
19 will come back tomorrow, and deal with it
20 tomorrow.
21 : That was past practice.
22 But not --
23 : Yes.
24 : -- that didn't actually
25 occur on August 8th. That was just your --
1 : Mm-hmm.
2 : -- your experience had
3 taught you that you could fix it the next day?
4 : The next day. Just come
5 in the next day.
6 : Okay. But no one
7 actually told you to come in the next day?
8 : Hmm-mm. No.
9 : Okay. Was it your
10 understanding about how important it was that
11 the camera issue was resolved before you went
12 home?
13 : Pfft. At that
14 institution? No.
15 : No?
16 : It was never made clear to
17 me, like, this was important. Because this
18 happened, like I said, numerous times before.
19 : Okay.
20 : Yes.
21 : So, when SIS Lieutenant
22 says that it was her understanding that
23 she told you that it was not only important,
24 but it had to be fixed on the 8th, you
25 : Yeah, because --
1 : -- (Indiscernible
2 *01:26:56) .
3 : -- if this happened before
4 and I was fixing stuff, it wasn't like I fixed
5 it that day, and it works that day. It takes a
6 couple of days. It's not going to -. And me
7 magically snap my fingers. Like, I go in the
8 room and I just fix it, and it starts
9 recording. That's not the case.
10 : All right. Would have
11 you, then, told her, though, I will get on it
12 immediately --
13 : Yeah.
14 • -- but in your mind, you
15 knew it would take a few days, but she didn't
16 know that? Would that be a possible scenario
17 to that?
18 : That's a possibility.
19 They might not know how long it would take me
20 to fix stuff.
21 : Did you tell them how
22 long it would take?
23 : They just would see me
24 back there working. They wouldn't really know
25 how intense, or what I was doing.
1 : All right. So, she would
2 have said, make sure --
: Mm-hmm.
you fix this
: Fix this.
and you would have
7 : And I --
8 : -- started --
9 : -- fixing it --
10 : -- working on it
11 : -- yeah, but it wouldn't
12 have been fixed that day. No.
13 : Gotcha. And what
14 instructions did you receive from Lieutenant
15 , or regarding
16 the cameras, the camera issue being resolved
17 ASAP?
18 : I can't recall, but I
19 don't really ever believe anybody tells me
20 anything. That it has to be resolved ASAP.
21 With the recordings. I've never -.
22 : Hmm. Okay. So, what we
23 have is, it says, you know, "
24 spoke with the Captain and wrote a memo
25 regarding cameras not working.
1 told her the issue must be resolved ASAP. She
2 relayed that to , and agreed to
3 work overtime to resolve that." Does that -?
4 : The same day?
5 : Well, she said that she
6 thought it was going to be resolved the same
7 day, but she said that you agreed to work
8 overtime. So, it sounds like there was some
9 miscommunication --
10 : Miscommunication. Yeah.
11 It was a miscommunication. They already knew I
12 was working on the project. I was going to be
13 there. So.
14 : So, were you already -.
15 And you said you were already working overtime.
16 : Yes.
17 : On other things.
18 : On things. Yes.
: And you had TDY people
: People with me.
: -- with you?
: Yes.
: So, does it sound to you
24 that she did tell you that it needed to be
25 resolved ASAP. You did say, I'll work overtime
1 to fix it. But you just weren't meaning that
2 you were going to fix it that same day?
3 : Hmm. No. That --
4 : Is it --
5 : -- yeah. I won't.
6 : -- is that correct, the
7 way I said that?
8 : It wouldn't have been
9 fixed that same day. So --
10 : That's what I mean.
11 : -- yeah. Yeah. It
12 wouldn't have -. There is no way it would have
13 been fixed that same day.
14 : So, she would have
15 understood you're staying that same day,
16 overtime, to fix it.
17 : But I, how would I stay if
18 I don't have access to the room? That's my
19 question.
20 : Well, she said that she
21 spoke with you in the room.
22 : In the room. Yeah. But
23 after she leaves, after they leave, I don't
24 have access to the room. So, how could I stay
25 in the room when I don't have access to it?
1 : Right. And then, the
2 following day, when you did come back, and you
3 did have access, you actually just didn't go
4 until the very end --
5 : End of the day.
6 : -- of the day.
7 : Yes.
8 : And then, you no longer
9 had access.
10 : Access. Yes.
11 : And then, you said you
12 were going to go back on Saturday, in the
13 morning --
14 : Morning. I had, because I
15 had the drives. I got the drives from the
16 Because I remember carrying the drives
17 to the room.
18 : All right. And did you
19 agree to work overtime on August 8th, 2019, to
20 resolve the issue before you went home on
21 August 8th, 2019?
22 : No. No. Somebody would
23 have had to -. My supervisor would have had to
24 tell me, whoever was in charge, would hey,
25 like, this is, you need to stay and,
1 you know, I couldn't just, like, I'm going to
2 stay. Like, no.
3 : Okay.
4 : Somebody's got to say,
5 well, you have to stay, or we have to, you
6 know, talk about what's going on with me
7 staying.
8 : Well, she told, well, she
9 said that she was with , and her, and
10 they said you've got to stay to work overtime.
11 : Pfft. That's the -.
12 She's not my supervisor. So, that
13 : Right.
14 : -- doesn't work. It's
15 whoever is in charge of main facilities, and AW
16 is my, like, supervisor, but there is
17 still somebody --
18 : So, who would have --
19 : -- before her.
20 • -- been your supervisor?
21 : It would have been the
22 general foreman of facility managers, whoever
23 is assigned, and they would have had to say,
24 hey, , you have to stay.
25 : All right. So --
1 : Like, I work for , but
2 I don't work for —.
3 : -- but so --
4 : Mm-hmm.
5 • was out, and
6 this is something we discussed in our last
7 interview.
8 : Mm-hmm.
9 : He wasn't there.
10 : Yeah, there.
11 : And here has an out of
12 office assistant that we have from you. You
13 sent an email on Friday, August 9th, 2019, at
14 6:51 a.m.
15 : Mm-hmm.
16 : To . It says, "I
17 will be out," and his automatic response --
18 : Mm-hmm.
19 was, "I will be out of
20 the office on Monday, August 5th through
21 Friday, August 9th."
22 : Mm-hmm.
23 : "I will have limited
24 phone and email access. Acting for me is
25 on Monday 8/5, and Tuesday 8/6."
1 : Mm-hmm.
2 : "She will be reached at,"
3 and then, it says --
4 : The number.
5 : -- the number.
6 : Mm-hmm.
7 : "And/or via radio track
8 four. Wednesday through Friday,
9 will be Acting, and he will be reached
10 at" --
11 : Track four.
: -- the phone number.
: Yeah.
: Or track four radio. So,
15 would have you, so, the last time we spoke, you
16 were certain that you requested overtime on
17 that Saturday --
18 : Yeah.
19 : -- and that your boss
20 approved it.
21 : Approved it. Yeah.
22 : Is that still your
23 recollection? Because now it sounds like you
24 had, like, a blanket over, a blanket --
25 : We were in the middle of a
1 project. So, it was probably just a blanket
2 overtime.
3 : So, there wouldn't have
4 been somebody that you specifically requested?
5 : No.
6 : All right. Because,
7 yeah, that was something we talked about --
8 (Indiscernible *01:31:36).
9 : -- for a long time --
10 : Yeah.
11 : -- last time.
12 : Yeah.
13 : So, when you're thinking
14 of it, there is not someone that you went to?
15 : If he wasn't actually
16 there, they were just acting, it was probably
17 just a blanket overtime.
18 : Yeah, and we spoke to all
19 three of them, and they said --
20 : Yeah.
21 : -- he never talked to us.
22 We didn't even know anything about the camera
23 issue. They all - all three of them said you
24 never talked to them about overtime. And no
25 idea anything about the camera issue.
1 : Yeah.
2 : Does that sound right?
3 : Well --
4 : They knew about it after
5 August 10th --
6 : Yes.
7 : -- but they said they
8 didn't know about it on the 8th or the 9th.
9 : Well, because they're not
10 really in charge. So, that's, like, you can't
11 tell them, because they're not -. I would have
12 to tell , or whoever is in charge of it.
13 : But he was out. So, who
14 --
15 : Yes.
16 : -- would have you spoken
17 with?
18 : Whoever was in charge, but
19 there, obviously, there is nobody in charge.
20 That doesn't even make sense.
21 : Well, the acting, and
22 during that time, says, you know --
23 : It was
24 : -- right.
25 : Said I didn't talk to him.
1 : So, you didn't actually
2 speak with anybody about these camera issues,
3 prior to going home on the 8th? You just were
4 working on it?
5 : I was working on it.
6 Yeah.
7 : Okay. So, you didn't
8 notify anybody, though, hey, these cameras are
9 out, and they're not, it's not resolved?
10 : They would have known
11 that, before I left, like, they still - I'm
12 still working on it. It was not, like, I'm
13 going to do fix it right away.
14 : Okay. Now, this actually
15 is, this email from you to your boss --
16 : Mm-hmm.
17 : -- it looks like these
18 are, like, your priority for things that you
19 were working on at the time. Is that correct?
20 : Yes.
21 : Why aren't the cameras
22 listed on there, if that was on August 9th?
23 : I have no idea. Mm-hmm.
24 : So, if you found out on
25 the 8th, which we have clarified that you did,
this is what you're telling
: Is going on --
3 : -- is going on in the
4 institution --
5 : -- in the institution.
6 : -- and what you need to
7 work on.
8 : On. Well, the --
9 : Wouldn't you have put
10 that
11 : -- that --
12 : -- on there?
13 : -- yeah. I would have put
14 that on there. But the camera thing was, like,
15 a constant thing. It wasn't, like, it wasn't
16 anything new. Like, they were having problems
17 with the cameras.
18 : But it wasn't new, but it
19 wasn't new that the recordings weren't
20 : Working.
21 : -- weren't recording.
22 : Yeah.
23 : So, should have that been
24 on there?
25 : It should have been on
1 there. Yes. It should have been on there.
2 : So, being that it wasn't
3 on there, does that make you re-think, huh,
4 maybe I didn't even work on it on the 9th, or
5 try to work on it on the 9th?
6 : I did work on it, if
7 that's what I said before.
: Okay.
: But yeah.
: Because they were writing
11 that, it sounds like, based upon a conversation
12 with you on the 9th, they don't know that you
13 don't have access to do them on the 9th.
14 That's what they're writing, based upon what
15 you told them.
16 : Mm-hmm.
17 : Like, oh, yeah, I'm doing
18 it today because on the 9th, I couldn't gain
19 access --
20 : Yes.
21 : -- to the room.
22 : Mm-hmm.
23 : So, looking at this, and
24 what you were working on, it looks like you
25 sent them an email of what you were working on
1 that day. And now that you're seeing what you
2 were working on that day, and the fact that the
3 cameras weren't listed on there, were you
4 actually working on it on the 9th?
5 : Yes.
6 : And you are positive you
7 went on the 9th and tried to gain access
8 : Because I had --
9 : -- to that room?
10 : -- and I had to get the
11 drives from I did get the drives from
13 : Okay. But you are
14 positive you actually tried to access that
15 room, and III told you -?
16 : After I leave, that's it,
17 you can't stay.
18 : All right. And that's,
19 your positive about, on the 9th, even though
20 it's not listed on your to-do list, on the 8th
22 : Yeah, because that was
23 probably something in -. This is probably all
24 the stuff that I fixed during that week, or
25 stuff I was looking at.
1 : Okay.
2 : Mm-hmm.
3 : Just, but the reason why
4 the camera issue isn't on there is why?
5 : It's a recurring thing.
6 Like, it's not something -. Like --
7 : Okay.
8 : -- after I fixed it,
9 that's where I would give them the stuff I
10 worked on. It's not if I'm working on, this is
11 the stuff, like, I've been working on or fixed
12 before. This is the stuff that is pending, or
13 has to get done. Because those are work
14 orders.
15 : So, from your
16 understanding, the camera issue wouldn't be
17 listed on this?
18 : It wouldn't be listed on
19 here. No.
20 : And you wouldn't have
21 notified that the cameras were down, and
22 not recording?
23 : Mmm, no. That would have
24 been up to whoever was in charge. Like, I'm
25 not -. I'm just the guy that fixes stuff.
1 : Oh, I thought you said
2 you tell This is your supervisor --
3 : Direct supervisor.
4 : -- direct supervisor.
5 : Yeah.
6 : I thought you said you
7 would always tell your direct --
8 : Supervisor.
9 : -- supervisor.
10 : Yeah.
11 : But you didn't?
12 : No.
13 : So, this is just the
14 things we need to reconcile.
15 : Reconcile. Okay.
16 : Is this something that
17 you should have told him?
18 : If he wasn't in charge,
19 then I didn't tell him. No.
20 : Well, you didn't tell
21 We know that. But he is still your
22 - you said that he is not my real boss.
23 : Yeah. I can't tell --
24 : But
25 : -- and I can't tell him
1 about cameras, anyway. So, if it was , and
2 and , that's probably the only
3 people that would know about the camera
4 situation.
: So, from the 8th?
: From the 8th. Yes.
: And -. Okay. So, from
8 looking at this, though, you don't see anything
9 wrong with not telling him that, when you're
10 talking about your to-do list?
11 : Hmm. He's not in the
12 institution. That's, like, yeah.
13 : Okay. So, the camera,
14 the camera issue should not have been listed on
15 here?
16 : Hmm.
17 : And when we go back --
18 : This is --
19 : -- to , or talk to
20 the warden
21 : -- this is --
22 • -- will they say the same
23 thing?
24 : -- this is everything that
25 I've closed out over the --
:
outs?
:
that I've done. Yes.
Oh, these are your close
-- yeah, this is stuff
5 : All right. So --
6 : For the week.
7 -- and that's why there's
8 not much --
9 : (Indiscernible *01:36:10).
10 : -- there's nothing, other
11 than your things.
12 : No.
13 : So, this is the things
14 that you've completed?
15 : Completed. Yes.
16 : These aren't things that
17 you're working on.
18 : Working on. No.
19 : Okay. And you are sure
20 of that?
21 : Yes.
22 : Perfect. All right. Can
23 you initial and date that?
24 : Mm-hmm.
25 : In retrospect, should
1 have you notified that the camera issues
2 weren't working? The cameras weren't
3 recording.
4 : The thing about that, if
5 you're not in the building, and there is an AW,
6 and an SIS told me the cameras are not working,
7 like, why should I call you at home to tell you
8 the cameras aren't working?
9 : Yeah, yeah.
10 : It's not -. You're not in
11 the building.
: Okay.
: So.
: So, is it your
15 understanding that, after III left, there was
16 no way for you to access that room?
17 : I would have to break
18 glass, and write a memo, and all this other
19 stuff. So, why I have to stay in the room?
20 And it's the evidence room. So, I can't really
21 just willy-nilly go in there by myself where I
22 shouldn't be, you know?
23 : Okay. And how serious it
24 is if you have to break the glass, to obtain
25 those keys?
1 : I just have to write a
2 memo and tell the lieutenant why I would have
3 to stay behind. But I was coming back the next
4 day. So, and I was probably working overtime
5 all week. And it was just time for me to go.
6 : Okay.
7 : I've been doing some long
8 hours.
9 : Okay. So, because you
10 had worked the hours, you made it, you made
11 that decision based upon your own experience
12 that I'm going to work it on the next day, I'm
13 not going to fix it today?
14 : Mm-hmm. Yeah.
15 : So, you --
16 : And the past practice of
17 just deal with it tomorrow. But I've been told
18 by my other supervisors, hey, just deal with it
19 tomorrow.
20 : Okay. But you weren't
21 told, in this situation --
22 : No.
23 : -- you made that
24 independent decision on your own, though.
25 Correct?
1 : Yes. From what I've been
2 experienced from before. Yes.
3 : Okay. But you could have
4 broken the glass, wrote a memo, and stayed to
5 fix it?
6 : Yes.
7 : Okay. And you did not
8 ask the captain, and any AWs, or the warden if
9 you could come back the following day to fix
10 it?
11 : I was already coming back
12 for overtime. So.
13 : Right. Point being is to
14 notify them, hey, these cameras, the recordings
15 are still down?
16 : The recordings were down
17 months at a time. I'm sorry. Like --
18 : Whoa, whoa, whoa. Tell
19 us more about that.
20 : -- you -.
21 : So, there were
: I'm sorry.
: -- there were --
: I'm sorry.
: -- no, no, no. We need
1 to know this stuff. So --
: I'm sorry.
: -- this is --
: Like, this is not, like,
5 everybody -. It looks like I'm the fall guy,
6 or, like, something isn't working, like, you
7 keep asking me the same question. The thing
8 about these cameras, these cameras weren't
9 working for, like, weeks at a time. Like, this
10 hasn't been the first time where these
11 recordings weren't working, and nobody checked
12 them.
13 : Well, that's what we need
14 to know.
15 : Yes.
16 : And we didn't -. So,
17 this is the first we're hearing that there was
18 weeks at a time that the --
19 _: Yes. Of course --
21 working.
23 time.
24 : Well then --
25 : This happened before.
-- recordings weren't
: -- there were weeks at a
1 : -- well then, tell us.
2 So, here. Open, open discussion. Tell us
3 exactly what was going on with these
4 recordings, and when they weren't working.
5 : Well, when I fist got to
6 the institution, that's why I started a
7 project. I would look for video, and they
8 would tell me there is a problem, and I'm,
9 like, oh, you can't keep running the
10 institution like this. If there is no video,
11 you have to fix the system. You have to get an
12 upgrade. I've called SigNet about the problem.
13 And I informed everybody, hey, this is a
14 problem. You can't have a jail where you can't
15 find video whenever you need video. Or the
16 recorder is always failing.
17 I was in Terre for a year and a half. I
18 don't remember, maybe a couple times where
19 something - as far as video, pulling back
20 video, you would always find a video. There
21 was never a time where you couldn't find a
22 video. Maybe some cameras weren't working, but
23 as far as pulling back video for a jail, there
24 is no time where you can't find video. And my
25 experience, when I got there, was, like, oh,
1 it's not a big deal, it's not a big deal.
2 And I'm, like, well, this is a jail, with
3 funding and whatever else problems they had.
4 Nobody considered anything here a priority or
5 an emergency. So, after Epstein, that's when
6 it was, like, oh, well, now you've got to stay,
7 now you have to do everything. And I've been
8 screaming at the hilltop when I got there.
9 Like, hey, you have a problem, you've got to
10 fix it. That's why I did the money for a
11 project, hey, you need to get new recorders in,
12 you've got to put the -. You've got to
13 upgrades. Like, you haven't done anything at
14 all. Like, you have to spend money. Like,
15 this stuff is old.
16 : But tell us specifically
17 about times where there were weeks at a time
18 that the recorders --
19 : Well, not weeks --
20 : -- were down.
21 : -- at a time, but I'm just
22 saying, like, if this happened at this time,
23 right, and I replaced the drives the other
24 time, weren't they looking for video, and
25 another time they couldn't find video, and I
1 fixed it, and then, they were, like, oh, well,
2 everything is fine now. And then, a month
3 later, or two months later, we have the same
4 problem again. Oh, can't find video. They
5 were just concerned about video they could find
6 for that specific time. They were never
7 concerned about finding a video for the whole
8 time.
9 : Okay. So, it - from what
10 we have, from our records - it suggests that,
11 in February, was the last time --
12 : No.
13 : -- (Indiscernible
14 *01:40:26) .
15 : This happened before.
16 That's why I --
22 February --
: This was the last time?
-- yes.
: Okay. It may --
: The last time.
: -- have happened before
: Yeah. Yeah. But there
24 was more times where it happened before
25 February. Since I touched down and got to MCC,
1 New York, this was a problem.
2 : So, it was a constant
3 reoccurring problem --
4 : Yes.
5 : -- where this was
6 happening?
7 : Yes.
8 : And what have you been
9 telling them all along was that we need to fix
10 --
11 : The problem.
12 : -- recurring --
13 : Yes.
14 : -- problem.
15 : Yes. So, that's why I had
16 a brand-new hard drive downstairs. And it
17 wasn't a priority.
18 : Right.
19 : Because you've got other
20 things to worry about.
21 : But when the -. And
22 correct me if I'm wrong, though. I understand
23 what they're saying that, like, you're saying
24 that it wasn't a priority for them to install a
25 whole new system, but it did sound like it was
1 a priority, once the recordings went down --
2 : Down. Yes.
3 : -- that they need to be
4 fixed.
5 : Fixed. Yeah. They need
6 to be fixed. Yes.
7 : Right. So, that's where
8 I want to make sure we're clarifying, when you
9 make a statement such as, it would be weeks at
10 a time that there is no recordings.
11 : I'm just, not weeks at a
12 time, but there would be days where there is no
13 video.
14 : Okay.
15 : Like, they always try to
16 get video, there is no video. This isn't the
17 first time --
18 : Right.
19 : -- this happened.
20 : And that was what
21 happened, it looks like, back in February
22 : Yes.
23 : -- it would have been
24 about six months before
25 : And this happened --
2 *01:41:23) .
: -- (Indiscernible
: -- before then, and it
4 happened a couple times before then --
5 : Right.
6 : -- because that's when I
7 started Whenever I started working at that
8 prison, I probably noticed it within the next,
9 the first three to four months I was there.
10 Like, hey, what's going on with the recorders?
11 Why is there no video?
12 : Right.
13 : And then, especially when
14 I had to do the time change, because we had to
15 do a time change in October, on the year
16 changes, and I'm, like, why is it taking a
17 whole day and a half for them, for the
18 recordings to start to rebuild and change the
19 time on the recordings. It shouldn't take a
20 whole day to do that.
21 : And --
22 : Because you have to stop
23 and start stuff, and it's, like, well, why is
24 the system so old? Like, what are you guys
25 doing?
: And did you already have
a new system to install at this point?
: No, I didn't.
: It wasn't on there?
5 : No. I had to submit a
6 project. I went with the engineering tech --
7 : No, no, no. Prior to
8 August 10th, 2019.
9 : Yeah.
10 : Did you already have a
11 new system --
12 : Yes.
13 : -- at that time?
14 : At the time. At the
15 location. Yes.
16 : So, you did have a new
17 system --
18 : System.
19 : -- you just hadn't
20 installed --
21 : Installed it.
22 : -- it yet.
23 : Yes.
24 : And why didn't you
25 install it, prior?
1 : Because it wasn't a
2 priority. Like I said before.
3 : Okay. But your priority,
4 or whose priority?
5 : Whoever - Signet - or
6 whoever is on the list for them to install the
7 new, our recorders.
8 : Okay. So, you don't
9 : They have a list.
10 : -- install it?
11 : No. I do not install it.
12 I help the --
13 : Signet would have --
14 : -- technician who will
15 come and install it. Yes.
16 : -- and when was SigNet
17 scheduled to install this?
18 : I have no idea.
19 : Whose job would it be to
20 call SigNet and to schedule them to install the
21 new recorders?
22 : That's not my --
23 : That's not you?
24 : -- that's not me.
25 : As the camera guy, you
1 wouldn't have anything to do with it?
2 : No. That's upper
3 management, and SigNet.
4 : So -.
5 : Or . Like, hey,
6 when is this thing -? But that's not my call.
7 It's here. Like, you know, they have to
8 schedule it and work that out.
9 : So, if it's on the
10 premises, and you have the new system at the
11 MCC, how long was it actually at the MCC prior
12 to this time?
13 : It was a few months.
14 : So, the new system --
15 : Yes.
16 : -- probably was ordered
17 after the February timeframe.
18 : No. It was ordered way
19 before then.
20 : So, maybe --
21 : It was ordered because it
22 was This happened in 2019. The new system
23 was here, and the money from 2018.
24 : So, you've had this new
25 camera system on hand for almost a year, if not
--
: Not a year, but a few
months. Yeah. We had --
: So, a few months.
5 : -- it for a few months.
6 Yeah.
7 : And it obviously can't be
8 SigNet's decision
9 : Decision.
10 : -- to put it in.
11 : It's --
12 : Is it?
13 : -- no, it's not SigNet's.
14 The facility. Who is in charge of the
15 facility?
16 : So, who is the person
17 that was in charge of getting that new camera
18 system installed?
19 : Whoever was in charge.
20 : Who?
21 : That would be the facility
22 manager. Whoever was --
23 : So,
24 : -- well, he just got
25 there. We were at limbo. There was nobody in
1 charge.
2 : So, there was no one to
3 actually schedule this thing to get --
4 : Installed. Yeah.
5 : -- and --
6 : Nobody to take charge and
7 say, hey, I can't call Signet, hey, I need you
8 to come I'm -. What am I?
9 : Who knew that the new
10 camera system was there?
11 : I did. I think I did, and
12 that was probably about it. Because --
13 : Okay. Was that anyone's
14 --
15 : -- it was too much -.
16 Like, at the time, we didn't have a general
17 foreman or a facility manager. There was
18 nobody that really -. We started a project.
19 It was just, like, a whole big mess of
20 confusion.
21 : All right.
24 *01:44:12) .
There was really nobody --
Because (Indiscernible
-- to say, hey, this is,
1 you know -.
2 : So, you always say that
3 the cameras are the captain's baby. Would it
4 have been the captain that should have taken
5 responsibility for that, to say, like, hey, get
6 these --
7 : These cameras --
8 : -- these new cameras -?
9 -- you got the new
10 recorders, hey, get them in. Yeah. But
11 Yeah.
12 : Because you keep on
13 saying, hey, this has been an ongoing problem.
14 Well, it looks like the problem - the solution
15 was there.
16 : Yes. But nobody --
17 : But it was never actually
19 : -- (Indiscernible
20 *01:44:33) .
21 : -- implemented.
22 : No. It was never
23 implemented.
24 : So, I know you said,
25 like, oh, it looks like you're saying, well,
1 you know, I'm the fall guy. Well, I'm asking
2 you, who is? Who is the guy that should have
3 made sure that that was fixed?
4 : I'm just the maintainer of
5 the system.
6 : Right, right, right.
7 : I'm not the installer of
8 the system.
9 : And I'm not saying that
10 you are the guy.
11 : Yeah.
12 : I'm asking you the
13 question.
14 : I helped install
15 : Who -?
16 : -- the system.
17 : So -.
18 : I maintained the system.
19 I fixed the problem when you tell me, hey,
20 , there is a problem. I go check it out.
21 I call SigNet. And we work on the issue.
22 : And -.
23 : That's it. That's all I
24 do.
25 : And I'm asking questions.
1 I'm not making accusations.
4 responsible --
: Accusations.
: Not once did I say you're
: You're responsible.
6 : -- what I'm asking is,
7 who is responsible?
8 : It would be, probably be,
9 the facility manager, or the general foreman,
10 or -,
11 : And because there was no
12 one there --
13 : Yeah.
14 : -- who, then, would
15 become responsible?
16 : Well, then it would be the
17 AW. Whoever is in charge.
18 : And who was the AW in
19 charge at that time?
20 , probably.
21 : So, it would be , not
24 yeah.
: Oh. Oh. She was -. Oh,
was there, too. Yeah.
: So, one of the two?
1 : One of the two. Oh, well,
2 , and was. Before them, it was
3 (Phonetic Sp. *01:45:34), because I remember, I
4 had to talk to him about this whole camera
5 thing.
6 : And who is
7 : He was another AW, before
8 took over. This is, like, before
9 all this got started, it was -. Back with my
10 old manager and , when I was telling
11 them, hey, you need to upgrade your camera
12 system.
13 : Okay. All right. And
14 there was nothing on -. Nothing scheduled to
15 actually get the new system installed?
16 : No. And from what I know,
17 we weren't on the list to get anything
18 installed.
19 : And the reason why you
20 were able to install it, you said on the 11th?
21 : It's because of whatever
22 happened with Epstein.
23 : So, Epstein happened.
24 You had this
25 : Everything (Indiscernible
*01:46:06)
there.
: -- new system already
4 : Yes.
5 : So, on the 11th, you were
6 able to immediately --
7 : Immediately.
8 : -- install it.
9 : Install it no problem.
10 : So then, the day after
11 (Indiscernible *01:46:11).
12 : -- Epstein's found, there
13 is a new camera system there?
14 : There is a new camera
15 there.
16 : Who installed it?
17 : It was and
18 myself.
19 : So, he flew in?
20 : Yes.
21 : And installed it --
22 : With me.
23 : -- with you?
24 : Yeah. Well, I put the
25 rack in, and helped him. Well, he pretty much
1 did everything. But get the rack and the UPS
2 in.
3 : All right. And who
4 contacted to make sure he came
5 down?
6 : I was on the phone with
7 SigNet after all this happened. I was on the
8 phone the whole time with SigNet.
9 : So, who made the ultimate
10 decision to, hey, it's time now to get this new
11 system installed?
12 : Probably , when he
13 got a hold of what was going on.
14 : Okay. So, would
15 have
16 : Yeah.
17 : -- been able to make that
18 decision?
19 : Make that decision. Or
20 maybe when I was Because I think I, when I
21 was on the phone with that they were,
22 like, well, we got to get out there right away,
23 because whatever is going on.
24 : Now, was , was he,
25 did he have knowledge that this camera system
1 was old and needed to be replaced?
2 : Yes.
3 : So, should have he had
4 the -. He should have made this a priority, to
5 make sure that the new camera system was put in
6 place, since he had been there for, I think, a
7 few months?
8 : Well, we already started
9 the project. I don't think anybody knew the
10 gravity of the recorders at the time. Like, if
11 I knew how important the recording was.
12 Everybody else, they were just, like, oh, it's
13 just, it's broken again. And I'm, like, well,
14 you know, it's not just broken again, it
15 shouldn't be broken at all.
16 : Okay. And then, did you
17 tell people that?
18 : Yes.
19 : And who did you tell
20 that?
21 : I've talked to my co-
22 workers, and I've talked to my facility manager
23 about the problem. And I even talked to the
24 regional com tech, because we have a regional
25 guy in charge of the cameras, and that work
1 stuff, like, like, this stuff is unacceptable.
2 Like, when I came and, like, the way the
3 building was laid out, and some of the wiring
4 issues in the building, this was just not
5 acceptable.
6 : Okay. But knew,
7 prior to August 10th, how important this was to
8 get this new camera system in?
9 : It was. That's why we
10 started the project. Yeah.
11 : And when you say you
12 stared the project, what did you start on the
13 project?
14 : Trying to figure out how
15 we were going to upgrade, like, because not
16 only did the recorder was bad, it was also the
17 housing units, there was only one camera in the
18 housing unit. So, if anything was to happen on
19 the housing unit, you would see no video.
20 : Okay.
21 : It would just be a blanket
22 camera footage of the common area. There would
23 be no additional video.
24 : And you said the new system
25 was purchased with year-ends '18 --
1 : Mm-hmm.
2 money?
3 : Yeah.
4 : So then, how long was this
5 system sitting around? You said a couple
6 months, but that's more than a couple of
7 months.
8 : A few. It's a few months.
9 I'm not too sure when everything got ordered,
10 or when it was sitting around. Because even if
11 we ordered it, I think everything was on back
12 order. That's why it didn't come right away,
13 the recorder.
14 : Oh, okay.
15 : The recorder.
16 : Okay.
17 : Yeah.
18 : But it was post that February
19 date?
20 : Before the -. I'm sorry.
21 Can you repeat that, please?
22 : Yeah. So, I mean, it was, it
23 was, if it was on back order, it probably
24 arrived some time in, what, '19 versus '18?
25 : I am not too sure when it
1 arrived.
2 : Okay.
3 : So, because
4 : Can I ask a question?
5 : -- yeah. Go ahead.
6 Please.
7 based on your
8 understanding, how important is it that the
9 cameras are recording on a day to day basis?
10 : It's very important. And
11 it should be checked on a day to day basis.
12 And the way, at my last institution, that I was
13 aware that anything wasn't working, was I would
14 actually get a report from SIS, this camera is
15 bad, that camera is out. This camera is not
16 working. Now, after Epstein happened, they
17 wanted to task me with that job. I refused
18 because I can't be the same person cooking the
19 food, telling you that the cameras are bad, or
20 the food is good. So then, it became up to
21 somebody else to check the cameras. Daily.
22 Now, they check it every day. There is a
23 report that's sent up. But before Epstein,
24 there was never a daily report of the cameras
25 are recording, or we have an issue. There was
1 never anything set up at MCC, as far as that
2 goes.
3 : So, you think before
4 Epstein had happened, no one had a day to day
5 responsibility to make sure the cameras were
6 working?
7 : No.
8 : Who would have been the
9 next - if no one had the day to day
10 responsibility - who could have checked?
11 : That would have been SIS's
12 responsibility, because my
13 : Okay.
14 : -- my previous jail, SIS
15 would be the one telling me, hey, , there
16 is a camera out, or there is other issues,
17 because I don't just work on cameras. I work
18 on all the communications in the building. So,
19 cameras are, yes, that is, like, one my main
20 things, but if there is other issues in the
21 building, like, I can't just focus on cameras.
22 And at the time, I was by myself. I was the
23 only electronics technician in the building for
24 a while.
25 : What other types of things do
1 you do? I know you fix the (Indiscernible
2 *01:50:45) .
3 : Fire alarm. Cameras.
4 Radios. And I install the network. Like, if
5 you need a cat five (Phonetic Sp. *01:50:50)
6 cable, or anything communication lines --
7 : Mm-hmm.
8 : -- in the building. The
9 fire alarm for the building. The doors.
10 : All right. I'm just
11 going to --
12 : I'll get back on again.
13 : -- oh, he dropped again?
14 : Looks like he dropped. Yeah.
15 : Hey. Hey. Can you hear
16 me?
17 : Yeah.
18 : Yeah.
19 : Hey. I apologize. A call
20 reception is going in and out. I apologize for
21 that.
22 : Okay.
23 : Based on the question I
24 was asking, if, you said there was a few
25 instances where the cameras went down, it
1 wasn't working for a few days.
2 : Yes.
3 : How bad do you think that
4 the situation is, where the camera is not
5 recording for a few days?
6 : I think it's pretty bad
7 when you're in a prison, and, you know, like,
8 in my experience, because I was custody
9 (Indiscernible *01:51:52) before, like, there
10 has been assaults on inmate on inmate, among
11 our staff, or somebody possibly bringing
12 contraband in the building. And you have no
13 recording to see what was going on. Then you
14 have pretty bad video at that, that it was a
15 priority.
16 : Okay.
17 : Yeah. All that stuff
18 should be fixed.
19 : And based on those
20 instances, did you ever write up any reports --
21 : Yes, I did.
22 -- did you send it to -?
23 : I did. Before I got the
24 money approved for the new camera system, I got
25 together with the engineering tech, and I wrote
1 -. I also, I wrote a work order over $10,000,
2 because the camera system as an asset is worth
3 over $10,000. To get that fixed. Because I
4 had that problem, I had also the fire alarm
5 was, I had a problem with that. I had a
6 problem with that. I had a problem with the
7 voicemail system. Everything. When I got to
8 the building, everything was just at a pretty
9 bad state. That wasn't the only thing that was
10 looked over as, like, oh, we need to get this
11 fixed. The whole building was, as far as
12 communication wise, it was pretty bad.
13 : Yeah. But the question I
14 had was, did you write any reports or
15 : I -.
16 : -- any emails to upper
17 management --
18 : Yes.
19 : -- saying, hey, listen -?
20 : Yes.
21 : Okay. Do you recall who
22 you sent it to?
23 : I would have sent it to
24 and he was my first facility
25 manager.
4 name?
6 know.
7 : Is it
•
: Can you spell that last
-. I don't
: -- or
: So, it would be
12 : No. He spells it weird.
13 . Oh,
14 : All right. So, can that
15 be the fourth request, then? So, we talked
16 about the emails between SigNet --
17 : And then, my --
18 (Indiscernible
19 *01:53:53), but also --
20 : -- and then,
21 . He's the engineering tech. He's the
22 one that actually wrote up the report to get
23 sent to the regional office, as far as the
24 money for the camera project.
25 : All right. So, those
1 emails. And any other emails --
2 : And then --
3 : -- you can find.
4 . He was
5 also the general foreman when this happened,
6 too.
7 : All right. So, can you,
8 at least those three people, as well as anybody
9 else.
10 : Mm-hmm.
11 : So, all the emails from
12 SigNet, and any, really, emails with regard to
14 : Okay.
15 : -- the cameras issue --
16 : Camera issue,
i7 : -- that you can provide
18 to us. That would be greatly beneficial for
19 us, that we know who was notified, when --
20 : Mm-hmm.
21 : -- who, you know --
22 : That's fine.
23 : -- what actions should
24 have been taken, and when they should have been
25 taken.
1 : Mm-hmm.
2 : I just want to real
3 quickly follow up on these things, to make sure
4 what we have is accurate. Specifically, with
5 regard to the FBI report that said, "There was
6 a system failure of DVR-2 on July 29th, 2019,
7 and a motherboard failed on DVR-2 on August
8 8th, 2019. The hard drive failure occurred on
9 August 10th, 2019." Again, is that information
10 that you provided to them, or did they obtain
11 that themselves?
12 : I think they obtained that
13 themselves. They would have --
14 : All right. And do you
15 know --
16 : -- the exact dates.
17 : -- do you know the
18 difference between, like, a system failure, a
19 motherboard failure, and a hard drive failure?
20 : Yes.
21 : All right. So, I'm going
22 to read you what we have obtained regarding
23 this, and I want you to tell me if it's
24 accurate or not.
25 : Okay.
1 : So, it says, "Per
2 from SigNet," regarding, this is still
3 regarding a system failure, "this looks to be
4 an error coming from the video management
5 server.
6 : Mm-hmm.
7 : There is an application
8 within the video management system software
9 called Supervision. This application monitors
10 connection between the main application server,
11 which manages authentication --
12 : Authentication.
13 : -- for users to access
14 live recorded video, and an ability to export
15 video, along with many other customizable
16 features. And system devices, such as DVRs,
17 cameras, video encoders, or video decoders. If
18 this is the case, then this would have been the
19 message from the Supervision application,
20 showing that there was a lost connection to
21 DVR-2."
22 : DVR-2. Right.
23 : Does that sound accurate
24 to you?
25 : Yes. It's -. Yeah.
1 : So, they would have
2 obtained this information, it sounds like, from
3 that application, Supervision?
4 : Yes.
5 : Okay. But you didn't
6 check that. Correct?
7 : No.
8 : All right. So, do you
9 know what caused that system failure on July
10 : No. I have --
11 : 29th?
12 : I have -. No.
13 : But you said you were
14 working on the mother -. Or you were --
15 : Yeah.
16 you were working on
17 the system right around that time?
18 : Yes.
19 : All right. So, likely,
20 it was whenever you were working on the system
21 around July 29th, 2019, that caused the DVR,
22 the recorders to stop recording?
23 : No. I checked everything
24 before I -.
25 : Well, we just talked
1 about previously, is that you checked
2 everything when you were working on it, for the
3 time prior --
4 : Prior to me --
5 : -- to when you worked on
6 it.
7 : -- to me working on it.
8 Yeah.
9 : So, likely, that's when
10 the --
11 : When the --
12 : -- recorders stopped?
13 : -- yeah.
14 : Okay. So, whatever,
15 whatever work you were doing on it, likely
16 stopped the recordings, but no one presented
17 the issue to you until August 8th, 2019?
18 : Yeah, but I always check
19 everything after I'm done. That's very strange
20 that I --
21 : Well, again, we think you
22 checked it, but it looks like, it sounds like
23 you checked it for the time
24 : Yeah.
25 : -- period prior to when
1 you fixed, you thought you fixed it.
2 : I fixed it. Yeah.
3 : So -.
4 : But that doesn't sound
5 like me. I'm sorry. Just how I am
6 : Well, no, no, no, this is
7 what you told us.
8 : -- yeah.
9 : So --
10 : Yes, yes. But I would
11 have checked to make sure, like, a couple days
12 later, okay, it's still working. Or --
13 : And do you recall
14 (Indiscernible *01:57:17) .
15 : -- because I'm pretty sure
16 I looked at the Nice Vision, and the Nice
17 Vision looked like it was fine. But there
18 could have been another problem. But I don't
19 pull video. Like, I don't go back to pull
20 video for, I told you, I don't.
21 : So, you just don't recall
22 if you ever went back and checked?
23 : I'm pretty sure I checked.
24 I'm more than definite. After I fixed it, I
25 would have checked to make sure it was working.
1 : Because the information
2 we have is that there is no video from July
3 29th --
4 : 29th.
5 : -- on.
6 : On. Yes.
7 : So -.
8 : And that's the last time I
9 worked on it. That's what it says, right?
10 : No, it doesn't. It just
11 says that there was a system failure of DVR-2
12 on July 29th, 2019.
13 : Yeah.
14 : And just from talking
15 with you, it sounded like you knew that there
16 was a system failure, prior to that time, and
17 that's when you worked on it, and thought you
18 resolved the issue.
19 : I probably -. Hmm. Can
20 you - I'm sorry - can you repeat that one more
21 time for me?
22 : We spoke an hour or so
23 ago --
24 : Uh-huh.
25 : -- about how, prior to

╭─────────────── Page 199, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ ion                                              │
│                                                  │
│ 1 WMS. 2-c2se che intorn:                        │
│                                                  │
│ here is no video from July                       │
│                                                  │
│ 2 we have is                                     │
│                                                  │
│ 3 29th --                                        │
│                                                  │
│ == on                                            │
│ on. Yes.                                         │
│ So -.                                            │
│                                                  │
│ No, it doesn't. It just                          │
│                                                  │
│ 11 says that there was a system failure of DVR-2 │
│                                                  │
│ 12                                               │
│ 13                                               │
│                                                  │
│ 14 J; And just from talking                      │
│ 15 with you, it sounded like you knew that there │
│ 16 was a system failure, prior to t ime, and     │
│                                                  │
│ 17 that’s when you worked on it, and thought you │
│ 18 resolved the issue.                           │
│                                                  │
│ one more                                         │
│                                                  │
│ 20 you - I'm sorry - can you rep                 │
│                                                  │
│ 1 time for me?                                   │
│                                                  │
│ 23 ago --                                        │
│                                                  │
│ 24 Le                                            │
│ 25 MES. == 2500: how, prior to                   │
│                                                  │
│ 6                                                │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

1 this issue, you knew about a system failure
2 : Failure.
3 : -- and you went in and
4 you fixed
5 : Fixed the issue --
6 : -- the issue --
7 : -- yeah.
8 : -- or you thought --
9 : That I fixed the issue.
10 : -- you fixed the issue.
11 : Okay.
12 : So, what this is saying,
13 that there was a system failure on July 29th,
14 2019. And the information that we have is,
15 there was no --
16 : Follow ups.
17 • -- recordings --
18 : For after that.
19 • from the 29th
20 : Yeah.
21 : -- so, the 29th on.
22 : On. Yes.
23 : So, it sounds like you
24 thought you fixed the issue
25 : The issue --
2 didn't.
3 ■
: -- but you actually
: -- didn't. Yeah.
4 : So, does that sound
5 right?
6 : That sounds right. Yes.
7 : Okay. And you don't know
8 Did you know - and I can't recall, at this
9 point - what would have caused it? You said it
10 was of old age? Because it says, "Per
11 the situation could have been caused
12 by a power outage, or improper shut down of the
13 DVR."
14 : I have no reason to shut
15 it down, and it had an UPS on it. So.
16 : So, you don't think
17 either it would have been a power outage, or
18 improper shut down?
19 : I think the way
20 everything, the old system was wired up, it
21 probably wasn't wired up correctly. I would
22 have to say that he is probably right about
23 there being a power issue.
24 : There would be a what?
25 : A power issue.
1 : So, even though you're
2 saying that there was some kind of serge
3 protector type of thing on there -?
4 : There is a UPS on it. But
5 I don't think everything was maintained the way
6 it should have been maintained.
7 : So, you think it was
8 likely caused by a power, some kind of power
9 outage?
10 : If it was a power outage,
11 that would explain what the problem is.
12 : But you don't know
13 anything about it, there a power outage?
14 : No. I didn't know
15 anything about power outages.
16 : And you don't Do you
17 remember ever shutting down the DVR system,
18 prior, when you were working on it?
19 : Hmm. No. Can you find
20 out if there was a generator test on the 20 -.
21 When was -? You said the 29th of July, right?
22 : Well, it looks like the
23 reason why you found this out is he went into
24 the application, Supervision.
25 : Yeah. I know. Okay. I'm
1 going to read that now. And July 29th, that
2 would have been -. Because we do do our
3 generator test monthly, but I don't know if it
4 was the 29th of July.
5 : Mm-hmm. I'll add that as
6 the fifth request, find, provide any
7 information with regard to the system failure
8 issue.
9 : That's - no, the time
10 : (Indiscernible
11 *02:00:23) .
12 : -- do they know what time,
13 or they just have the thing?
14 : No. It just says July
15 29th.
16 : Yeah.
17 : All right. And do you
18 know when - the system failure - do you know
19 when you found out about that, and how?
20 : Hmm. As far as what now?
21 : The system failure was
22 the July 29th issue, not August 9th, or 8th,
23 9th, or 10th.
24 : Oh. Not until you guys
25 told me there was a system failure. The only
thing I knew about was the, oh, that was the --
: This is the thing you
said you worked on.
: -- oh. The AMS. I had to
5 restart the AMS. Yeah. That was --
6 : So, you did restart it?
7 : -- yeah.
8 : So, you did shut it down?
9 : Yeah. I shut it down and
10 restarted it. That simple.
11 : So, when it says that it
12 could have been caused by an improper
13 : Shut down.
14 : -- shut down.
15 : Yes.
17 too?
: Could have that been it,
18 : No. Once you restart it,
19 it's, like, it's a pretty small thing, like,
restarting the AMS doesn't mess anything up,
really.
23 you did restart it?
: Okay. All right. But
24 : Yeah. After the shutdown.
25 : So, technically, it is a
1 possibility, then, because it says you --
2 : No.
3 : -- no?
4 : No.
5 : You don't think that --
6 : Hey, once you do the AMS,
7 that's just the communication thing, like, if -
8 . And not everything is talking, that's when
9 everything would start working.
10 : Okay. And you said you
11 never would access Supervision.
12 : Mm-hmm.
13 : We talked about all of
14 this. So, it says, this is the issues, "The
15 motherboard failed on DVR-2. Per
16 , in the case of a motherboard failure,
17 this would cause the operating system, such as
18 Windows, to shut down or fail. When this
19 happens, it would stop recording to the hard
20 drive, because the recorder software requires
21 Windows Operating System to be operational, to
22 record data to the hard drives."
23 : Mm-hmm.
24 : "Also, when the
25 motherboard fails, the network connectivity is
2O6
1 lost because the network card is dependent on
2 the motherboard to be functioning. And Windows
3 to be running, for the network card driver to
4 be operational. If and when the motherboard
5 failed, this would have caused the network card
6 to shut off, thus triggering the above message
7 of a system failure, of DVR-2. Because it can
8 no longer communicate with the DVR." Does this
9 sound accurate?
10 : Yes.
11 : All right. Do you know
12 what caused the motherboard failure?
13 : No.
14 : Do you remember, do you
15 know what affect it had?
16 : I just remember I did the
17 electronics thing, I just did a smell test, and
18 I knew something on the motherboard burned up.
19 You could smell that. Because I, when I took
20 the motherboard out, you could tell it was a
21 problem. Something on the motherboard burned
22 up. Or failure power. Or something. But it
23 was the motherboard. Because I do remember
24 doing that.
25 : All right. And do you
1 know if this would have been caused by a power
2 outage or an improper shut down, or anything?
3 : Hmm. No.
4 : No.
5 : Huh-uh.
6 : Now, this is just
7 something I'm thinking out loud. Being that
8 you told us that you fixed this issue on the
9 29th, but you also pulled the drives on the
10 10th, is what it would have deleted at that
11 point, back to the 29th, when you had last
12 worked on the system?
13 : Hmm.
14 : Do you follow what I'm
15 asking?
16 : I -.
18 everything?
20 I don't know.
: Or it just deleted
: I -. I don't -. I mean,
: Because you said that,
22 you pulled the two bad drives, it's going to
23 wipe
24 : The system.
25 : -- you're not going to be
able to get --
:
:
(Indiscernible *02:03:41).
-- recordings.
4 : Yes.
5 : So, I guess what I'm
6 asking is
7 : But there was --
8 : -- wouldn't that wipe it
9 back to the last time you worked on it?
10 : -- no. It would have
11 wiped out everything before that. Not the last
12 --
13 : So --
14 : -- time I would have
15 worked on it.
16 : -- it would have just
17 wiped it all out?
18 : Yeah.
19 : All right.
20 : So, there was video after
21 I left. I fixed it. Because there was video.
22 : All right.
23 : It looked like it was
24 recording, but it wasn't recording.
25 : All right. So, if it
1 wipes everything, how --
2 : How does it -?
3 : -- how would the FBI be
4 able to obtain knowledge that there was no
5 recordings, prior to -? Because in the more
6 detailed report, doesn't it say that
7 there is no recordings prior to July 29th?
8 : Bear with me. I'm just
9 pulling up the report.
10 : Yeah, but the point
11 being, you're not sure?
12 : As far as -?
13 : As far as the recordings
14 not working, between July 29th, 2019, and
15 August 8th, 2019.
16 : No.
17 : You know that they
18 weren't recording on August 8th.
19 : Yeah, because I had to
20 : But you didn't
21 : -- check it, yeah.
22 : -- know anything prior --
23 : About it.
24 : to that.
25 : Yeah.
2 is news to you?
: And the July 29th issue
: Yes.
4 : Okay. Well, we'll look
5 into that.
6 : It doesn't state clearly
7 if they -. Was anything was retrieved, but
8 prior to 29th, that's something we have to
9 clarify with the FBI.
10 : Okay. All right. Now,
11 regarding the hard drive failure. It says,
12 "Per if there was a message that
13 stated this is in the Supervision application
14 of the video management system, this would
15 indicate that the failed motherboard had been
16 either recovered, repaired, or replaced, and
17 now functioning because this would allow
18 Windows Operating System to run, allowing the
19 recording to be in operation, and communication
20 to the application management server restored.
21 If there is one hard drive failure, the
22 system is recoverable by replacing the drive
23 and letting it rebuild. If there were two
24 drives simultaneously failed, then the recorded
25 video data is lost, and unrecoverable due to
1 the raid array needing a new configuration as
2 new drives are added." Does this sound
3 accurate?
4 : Yes.
5 : Does this sound like what
6 happened?
7 : That's -. Yes.
8 : Okay. Is
9 really the person to explain this versus you?
10 He's the expert on this, correct?
11 and . Yes.
12 : They are the two. So -.
13 : And then, if you don't,
14 knows the engineer, the engineer of
15 Those are the guys that would know.
18 else.
: So --
would know somebody
: -- more so than you? You
20 get your information from them. Correct?
21 : Yes.
22 : Okay. So, when they
23 provide us with this information, we can rely
24 on it to be accurate?
25 : Yes. That is accurate.
Yes.
: Okay. And what, do you
know what caused the hard drive failure?
: No. I just think it's
5 wear and tear because everything is so old.
6 : Okay. But that occurred
7 on August 10th. So, it sounded like the hard
8 drive failure occurred because the two drives -
10 : Yes.
11 : -- were pulled?
12 Oh. I don't know.
13 : Okay. But it says, "Per
14 this could have been caused by
15 normal wear and tear --
16 : Tear.
17 : -- and age of the hard
18 drives."
19 : Uh-huh. Yes.
20 : Is that accurate?
21 : Yes.
22 : And you believe that's
23 what happened?
24 : Yes.
25 : And do you know what
1 affect the hard drive failure had?
2 : I just know there would be
3 no video, or, you know, the drives would be
4 bad. You can't take anything off the drives.
5 : Okay. And again, you are
6 the one who replaced the two drives. The FBI
7 just came and took everything.
8 : They took everything.
9 Yes.
10 : Okay. All right. We
11 covered everything else earlier in the
12 interview. Is there anything else, or
13 , that we want to cover?
14 : I've got a couple of
15 follow up questions.
16 : Please.
17 , the two hard
18 drives that you pulled on August 10th, to
19 replace it, where those two the two drives you
20 had previously replaced, or are those the
21 different ones?
22 : Those are new drives.
23 : New drives meaning that it
24 wasn't previously replaced by you?
25 : Mm-hmm.
1 : I'm sorry. I didn't hear
2 you.
: I'm sorry?
: I don't know if you said
5 yes or no. That's why. I couldn't hear you.
6 : Oh, the two new drives
7 were from the computer services. The drives
8 that I had replaced.
9 : No, no, no. The question
10 was, do you know the two drives that you said
11 went bad, that you had to replace, right?
12 : Yes.
13 : Were those two drives
14 previously replaced by you?
15 : I have no idea. There is
16 no way of me knowing what was replaced, or
17 there was no system --
18 : Okay.
19 : -- in place to see if I
20 wrote down a list, like, one through 16, I
21 replaced on this date, and one through 16,
22 replaced on this other date. There's -. I
23 can't tell you what was fixed, or when, how it
24 was fixed. There was no maintenance log of
25 what was changed, or repaired.
1 : Okay. And we were told by
2 that, previously, when you
3 had to stay and work in the camera room
4 : Yes.
5 : -- there were situations
6 where you had to do work in the camera room,
7 and if she or had to leave, she would
8 leave the keys with the captain, and you could
9 continue doing the work
10 : Yes.
11 : -- in the captain's room.
12 : That is correct. Yes.
13 : How come, on August 8th,
14 you couldn't do that?
15 : There was no captain.
16 : There was no captain on
17 August 8th?
18 : No. There was an acting
19 captain. I don't think there was a captain.
20 There was nobody --
21 •
22 : -- yeah, there was no -.
23 But he wasn't there.
24 : So, we know, on August
25 9th, he was there until at least 7:00 p.m.
1 : 7:00. Oh. Oh, he's
2 probably not -. He was probably not in his
3 office, then. Because the office is right next
4 to the room.
5 : Yeah. "On August 8th,
6 SIS went right next to him,
7 in his office, and provided him the memo
8 regarding the issue." On August 9th is when
9 you said that you couldn't gain access to the
10 room, but we do, in fact, know that Darden was
11 there until at least 7:00 p.m.
12 : The thing about this memo
13 part, that I don't get it, is that there could
14 have been memos from before, like, that
15 decision make any sense to me. Because this is
16 not the only time the recorder failed. So, to
17 have a memo this one time, when Epstein
18 happens, like, that just doesn't make sense to
19 me.
20 : Okay. So --
21 : Is it --
22 : -- and the fact that --
23 : -- sorry.
24 : -- there is this memo
25 : Yeah.
2 suggests?
: -- what do you think that
: Somebody is trying to say
4 they did their job where they didn't do their
5 job.
6 : So, you think that the
7 memo was, in fact, created on the 10th, instead
8 of the 8th?
9 : I don't know when it was
10 created. I'm just saying, people are trying to
11 cover their tracks. To say they were notified,
12 and they told this person, and that person.
13 When I got there, and I was trying to explain
14 to everybody how important most of the systems
15 were, everybody just looked at me like I'm
16 spinning two heads. Like, I'm not telling you
17 I'm, like, I came from a compound. There
18 was a medium. There is a high. There is a
19 low. There is a death row. If something
20 doesn't work, it's a jail, you have to stay.
21 Now, after Epstein happens, everybody wants to
22 do their job. So, that's the long and short of
23 it.
24 : Okay.
25 : I'm not trying to say that
1 anybody did anything. But I'm just saying,
2 like, now everybody wants to write memos, and
3 have statements, when all this stuff was
4 happening before, is there records of you
5 calling and saying there was a problem? I have
6 records of me saying there was a problem, and
7 I'm trying to fix the problem. And I stayed
8 and fixed the problem. But these other people
9 that are saying stuff, man.
12 me.
: Yeah. So, in any --
: That doesn't make sense to
: -- any of those records,
14 you can give us, again, that's going to be
15 greatly appreciated. I'm going to follow up
16 with an email, asking what we talked about, but
17 anything else that you think will be helpful,
18 to help us?
19 : Yeah. I just, I'm sorry
20 you guys have to go through this, because I, I
21 mean, I'm still going through it.
22 : Right, right, right.
23 : But I'm pretty sure you
24 guys want to get it over with yourself. So.
25 : Anything else,
4 :
: No. That's it.
: No.
Nothing from me.
5 : Okay. We're going to end
6 this, then.
7 : Yeah.
8 : Anything you want to add?
9 : No. Just send me the
10 emails, and I will try to get you some
11 information.
12 : Okay.
13 : Yeah. Thank you, guys. I
14 know this is not easy for you guys
15 : No.
16 : -- to go over the same
17 thing.
18 : And we appreciate your
19 cooperation. Thank you.
20 : Yeah.
21 : It is -.
22 : Oh, and the job failure.
23 Was that on my part? Like, not doing my job,
24 or not notifying anybody, or what -?
25 : Well, when we're talking
to people, we're telling everybody the same
thing.
: Thing, yeah.
: It's not our decision,
5 really, to make, you know
6 : Mm-hmm.
7 : -- to say
8 : What --
9 : -- we're going to
10 basically
11 : -- (Indiscernible
12 *02:11:18) .
13 : -- provide the
14 information
15 : Information.
16 • -- to the BOP.
17 : Yeah.
18 : They determine
19 : Determine --
20 : -- you know, the actions
21 --
22 : -- oh, he should have said
23 this. Yeah.
24 : -- you know, and all that
25 kind of stuff --

╭────────────── Page 220, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ 1 to people, we’re telling everybody the same │
│                                               │
│ 2 thing.                                      │
│                                               │
│ Thing,                                        │
│                                               │
│ ah                                            │
│                                               │
│ It’s not our decision,                        │
│                                               │
│ ally, to make, know ==                        │
│ ° EE: on.                                     │
│ 7 MS: -- => say --                            │
│ a st -                                        │
│ ° MNS» —— 2" re going to                      │
│                                               │
│ rnible                                        │
│                                               │
│ -- provide the                                │
│                                               │
│ formation -~                                  │
│                                               │
│ Information.                                  │
│                                               │
│ -- to the BO                                  │
│                                               │
│ They determine --                             │
│                                               │
│ De                                            │
│                                               │
│ rmine --                                      │
│                                               │
│ -- you know, the ac                           │
│                                               │
│ ons                                           │
│                                               │
│ -- oh, he should have said                    │
│                                               │
│ this. Yeah.                                   │
│                                               │
│ -- you know, and all                          │
│                                               │
│ 25 kind of stuff --                           │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────╯

1 : But look --
2 : I mean, we will have our,
3 you know --
4 : -- the thing about this
5 whole thing, I'm just going to add my part,
6 because I came from another institution. If
7 there is a problem, and, like, especially the
8 cameras, somebody should be notified. Okay.
9 I'm the guy that fixes it. Okay. what
10 are you doing? Have you fixed it? Now, after
11 Epstein happens, and we've had recorder issues
12 now, and that was what I sent the email, okay,
13 I fixed this, I did this, I did that. But
14 before that, it was not happening.
15 : Right.
16 : That's the only part I
17 want to add. That's Now, everybody covers
18 their tracks. But before this, sad to say this
19 had to cause the whole Bureau to wake up. But
20 -.
21 : Right.
22 : Yeah.
23 : All right. So, if that's
24 it?
25 : That's it.
1 : All right.
2 : That's my last piece.
3 : It is currently 10:27
4 a.m. on September 29th, 2021. This is Senior
5 Special Agent , and I'm
6 turning off the recorder. Thank you.
CERTIFICATE
I hereby certify that the foregoing pages
represent an accurate transcript of the
electronic sound recording of the proceedings
before the Department of Justice, Office of the
Inspector General in the matter of:
Interview of
Transcriber
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Peter Thomas Roth [friend] student of Epstein at Dalton, skincare company founder 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00159394 (Jmail)
 [misc] notes from interview with employee and copy of 2005 household manual for Palm Beach residence
(date: 2021-09-30)
<REDACTED>                                              9/30/2021
<REDACTED>
<REDACTED>
[barely legible handwritten notes]

Wanted to apologize to us because she felt that she
may have minimized [something] during last meeting the she
knew the girls were under age . wanted to be clear that she
knew at the time that the girls were less than underage.
wanted to be clear that she wrong and [something].

<REDACTED>: Context from modeling world, when she saw as a model
underage girls, red flag didn't go up, because she used to be
didn't have the C underage girl to step [something] at the time
[something] and S. [something] all we want to is as be concerned
about and do not have say anything in her the truth want to be clear that
the truth. Please do not apologize or be concerned about us,
we just want to hear the truth and do not have any expectations
that you know or any anything in particular

<REDACTED>: she does not feel any pressure at all, she is learning to
accept responsibility

<REDACTED>: I am telling the truth, I do not feel any pressure from
you to [something] say anything. it has been a  process for me to came
to accept
3524-018
Page 1 of 66
EFFA_00009546

Shared household manual. has never seen this before.
- recalls at some point <REDACTED> typed a list of
what to do when JE travelled - packing, etc.
- does not recall ever seeing household manual

Shown setbook

1) no
2) no
3) no
4) no
5) almost at first thought this was almost a young version of her
6) no
7) Jeffrey Epstein

8) no
9) no
10) no
11) no
12) no
13) recognizes from the media that this is <REDACTED>
14) no
15) no
16) Ghislaine Maxwell

17) do not recognize
18) no
19) no
20) no

Shown Ex. A:
this is me. i do not remember this photo being taken.
do not recognize location. from 2004-2006 because that was when
[something] [something] [something] [something] [something]
[something] [something] [something] [something] [something]

Ex. B - this is me & JE at USVI little st. janes
at entrance to the island. don't recall this
being taken.

[witness prep]
<REDACTED> was assistant who wind from Eis home her assisht
Last seen GM 05-06
would recognize [something]

Wall of Photos
"uc se link trophies plates in PB"
"Not sure if femes peuple"
"Not sure if there were photos in PB bedroom
10-15 nosa assoned in person, muy have been in contact w/ were prople
that one. wot see. This is the grup that woe runny.

might have been masseusses who con Soneve ese she and not have contact
with layer gremp of mosusses thor the reing gramp.

Around 15-20 propre are for appontunts dung the PB
"Renberg busk, does not recull Wehr twe , the

"Je hed astrand Jun seatve for massage on Leen in his bedroom it made her"

HOUSEHOLD MANUAL
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
3524-018
Page 7 of 66
LIST O1: CONTENTS

• Introduction
• Grooming & Guest Relations
• Proper Language
• Answering the telephone
• Pre-arrival information gathering

• Guest pick-up and drop-off
• Escorting guests to their room
• Pre-arrival preparations
- Master Bedroom
- Master Bathroom
- Master Bathroom Toiletries
- Ms Maxwell's Bathroom
- Ms Maxwell's Bathroom Toiletries
- Guestrooms
- Guest Bathrooms
- Guest Bathrooms Toiletries
- All Bathrooms
- Exterior
- The Cabana
Vehicles and Bicycles
- Interior
- Prepare and Purchase Shopping List (Sec pp. 30-32 for lists)

• Daily duties while Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell, and guests are in residence
Morning preparation
- Pool Area
- Cabana
- Kitchen
- Downstairs Areas
- Master Bedroom
- Master Bathroom
- Ms Maxwell's Bathroom
- Gucstrooms
Early evening
Before you leave at night

• Shopping Lists
- Pre-Arrival
- On-hand at all times
2/14/2005
3524-018
Page 8 of 66
• Cleaning Schedule
- Daily
- Weekly
Monthly (Week I, Week 2, Week 3)
- Every six months (April, October)

• Maintenance Schedule
Check every month
Check every three months (March, June, September, December)
Check every six months (April, October)

• Bedroom cleaning
• Bathroom cleaning
• Laundry and dry cleaning
• Office Supplies
• Mail and Deliveries •

• Resetting the Telephone
Serving Breakfast
Standby duties
• Emergency procedures
Supplement: Contact Telephone Numbers
2/14/2005
3524-018
Page 9 of 66
INTRODUCTION
This manual is designed to give you the proper guidance and assistance to nett)
your duties to the best of your ability, while ensuring a consistently high level of service.
Gathering as much information as possible will help you with the day to day running of the home.
By using your communications skills - listening and observing, you will be
able to anticipate the needs of Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests.
Checklists will assist you in making sure that all tasks have been completed and that not even the smallest details have
been overlooked.
2/14/2005 3
3524-018
Page 10 of 66
GROOMING & GUEST• RELATIONS
Appearance is extremely important if high standards are to be maintained. A favorable
first impression goes a long way. Personal cleanliness, good presentation, and a genuine
and polite "aim to please" approach arc very important.

• Try and anticipate the needs of Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests.
• Make guests feel pampered and welcome.

• Always address guest by their name, (eg: Mr Smith or Ms Smith)
• Do not discuss personal problems with guests.

• Be cautious of voice levels and noise while working in rooms, kitchen and
hallways.
• Unobtrusive is the key.

• Remember that you see nothing, hear nothing, say nothing, except to answer a
question directed at you. Respect their privacy.

• Use your judgment when conveying information to Mr Epstein. If the matter is
not urgent, leave a note for him, clearly stating what it is you need to know.
Wear the appropriate clothing while Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests arc in residence. Dark blue trousers with 
white golf shirts to be worn daily, long
sleeve white shirts for dinner service.

• Items in pockets must not create a bulge or be visible.
• Do not address Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests with your hands in your
pockets.

• Do not cat or drink in front of Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests. D o not
chew gum.
• When you are attending to Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests, cellular
phones must be placed on "vibrate." At no time should these phones "ring."

• Avoid using strong perfume or aftershave lotion. This could cause an allergic
reaction.
• Channel all questions and concerns through the Estate Manager.

• SMILE!
2/14/2005 4
3524-018
Page II of 66
PROPER IAN( UACE
What you say is as important as what you do. Your language must include good diction and exclude
swear words and slang. Pay attention to how you speak to Mr Epstein. Ms Maxwell and their guests.
You do not say:
"Yeah"
"Sure"
"No problem"
"You bet"
"Gotcha"
"Right"
"I dunno"
You do say:
"Yes, Mr
"Of course, Ms
"My pleasure"
"It is no trouble at all"
"With pleasure"
"I would be very pleased to"
"You arc quite right"
"I have no idea, but I will find out immediately"
To a compliment you say:
"You are very kind"
"Thank, you, Ms  . I enjoy doing it."
To a justified criticism or mistake you say:
"1 am very sorry; it will not happen again."
"It was completely my fault; I will make the changes immediately."
To a guest you say:
"If I can be of any additional assistance, please let me know."
"Is there anything else that you might need."
"I am very pleased that you enjoyed your stay, Mr
"It was lovely to see you again, Mrs
2114/2005 5
35241-0113
Page 12 of 66
What to say when entering a room:
"May I come in"
What to say after entering the room:
Greet Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell, and /or their guests, "Good Morning, Mr
You do not expound on the weather or any other subject, unless asked. You have no idea how they are feeling.
You provide your service, then ask, "Is there anything else I might do for you," and if not, leave the room.
2/14/2005 6
3524-018
Page 13 of 66
ANSWERING 'ME TELEPHONE
How you answer the telephone will leave a long-lasting impression on all those who call. it
immediately tells the caller the service standard. When you answer the phone, the quality of
your voice is of utmost importance. The person on the other end of the line cannot see your
expression or gestures, so any impression that person receives depends entirely on your
voice. Speak clearly and distinctly. Do not slam down the receiver at any time!

• All calls should be answered in three rings or less.
• If the incoming line is one of Mr Epstein's or Ms Maxwell's. answer as follows:
"Good morning / afternoon / evening. Epstein / Maxwell residence.

• If Mr Epstein or Ms Maxwell have advised that they do not wish to receive any calls,
you are to reply as follows:
"Mr Epstein / Ms Maxwell is not available. May I take a message?"
Complete a phone message slip with the following information: Name (spelt
correctly), date and time of call, telephone number including the area code.
Place the message on the pantry countertop if it is for Mr Epstein, and for Ms
Maxwell, on her desk.

• If Mr Epstein and Ms Maxwell choose to receive a call, you are to reply as follows:
"May I ask who is calling? Just a moment please."
Ring the extension where they are located and advise them who is calling.

• There is a "Do Not Disturb" setting on the telephone system. This option is to be set
as directed in the pre-arrival check off list.

• Telephone directories are to be updated every six months, or as the new tel ephone
directories are available.
A copy of Mr Epstein and Ms Maxwell's telephone directories must be placed to the
right of each telephone (except for the Guestrooms).

• Always check that there arc notepads and pens. These must be placed to the right of
each telephone.
A pair of reading glasses must be placed in front of each telephone (except for the
Guestrooms).

• An extension card must be placed under the front of each telephone.
2/14/2005 7
3524-018
Page 14 of 66
▪ Unless otherwise instructed. NEVER disclose Mi Epstein or Ms Maxwell\ :me% Hies
or whereabouts to anyone. lithe caller is insistent. you simply ask to take a message.
a time and a number, where the caller can be reached. Do not be bullied and do not show any reaction or impatience, 
simply he firm.

• Advise Ms Maxwell of any strange telephone calls or enquiries.
• Advise Ms Maxwell of any unusual behavior, such as strangers lurking around the
vicinity of the property.
Entrance gates to the property must remain closed when Mr Epstein is not in
residence.

• The security of the house and of Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests, is your first consideration and should be 
uppermost in your consciousness.
2/14/2005
3524-018
Page 15 of 66
PRE,-ARRIVAI, INFORMATION GATHERING
This is all the information necessary to meet the needs of Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests. If possible, this 
should be done 24 hours prior to arrival.

• Obtain a list of all guests who will be joining Mr Epstein and Ms Maxwell. • Confirm travel itinerary.

• Ask about any special requests or dietary requirements. • Ask about any gifts that Mr Epstein may want placed in the 
guestrooms.
GUEST PICK-UP AND DROP-OFF
All guests should have a staff member waiting for them at the appropriate terminal gate.

• Double check arrival information.
Always have a written copy of the guest's travel itinerary (flight arrival times, etc) on •
hand.

• Chock the number of people in the party to insure that the vehicle can accommodate all arriving guests.

• If you are unfamiliar with the guest, prepare a sign clearly stating the guest's name. • Welcome guest by name.

• Advise guest of your name.
• Offer to carry any luggage that guest may have with them. Escort guest to luggage pickup area if necessary, gather 
luggage and escort guest to •
vehicle.

• Advise guest on travel time. Provide demographics on the area. • Keep conversation to a minimum.
• When you are driving Mr Epstein or Ms Maxwell, keep your hands on the wheel. Your cellular phones should be placed on 
"vibrate." At no time should you answer
private calls.
ESCORTING GUESTS TO THEIR ROOM

• Upon arrival, gather guest's belongings and escort to pre-assigned room. • Inquire from guest where they would like 
their luggage and place it appropriately.

• Offer to unpack luggage.
• Show guest how to use the telephone.
• Show guest how to use the remote control for the television. • Ask guest to complete "Emergency contact information" 
form and return to you. • Ask guest if
they have any food allergies.

• Ask guest what they would like to be served for breakfast and at what time. • Tell guest to enjoy their stay and let 
them know how you can be reached.
2/14/2005
9
3524-018
Page 16 of 66
PRE -ARRIVAL PREPARATIONS
CHECK OFF LIST
MASTER BEDROOM
D A/C is set at 6O degrees.
J All light fixtures arc working.
O Shutters must be closed.
O Remote controls for the television arc working.
9 Telephones are on "Do not disturb."

• JE and GMtelephone directories placed to right of telephone.
• Telephone extension card placed under front of telephone.
9 Alarm clock must be set to the correct time and date.
O Two lighted pens on both bedside tables.

• Regular pens on both bedside tables.
• Jeffrey Eµstein large and small notepads on both bedside tables.
J Reading glasses on both bedside tables.
D Eye masks on both bedside tables.
3 Box of tissues on each bedside table (Replace if less than 1/3).
O Flashlight with new batteries.
J Bottled water and drinking glasses on both bedside tables.
D Gun placed in beside table drawer.
DATE:
2/14/2005
SIGNATURE:
10
3524-018
Page 17 of 66
MASTER BATHROOM

• Check that water is hot and runs clear.
• Fresh bar of soap placed to the right of the washbasin.
3 Two fresh facecloths on the washbasin and Iwo in the shower.
O Electric toothbrush (Replace head every 4 weeks).
D New toothbrush placed in a clean drinking glass to the left of the washbasin.
❑ Toothpaste is more than 1/4  full.
O Mouthwash.
❑ Razor and shaving cream (more than 'A full).
3 Electric razor plugged in and charged.

• Tissues (replace if less than 1/4 ).
O Q-Tips.
❑ Round cotton pads.
O Clean all fixtures, shower and steam room.
❑ New pair of exfoliating gloves in the shower.

• Tidy and replace any toiletries which are running low.
O Three large blue towels and one hand towel to be ready for massage in towel room.
J Shutters must be open.
DATE: SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005
3524-018
Page 18 of 66
MASTER BATHROOM '1OII,ETRI ES
CHECK OEE I,IST
❑ Gillette MACH 3 Razor with extra blades (change blade after every use)
J Shaving Cream (Kiehl'' Close Shavers Squadron)
9 Secret Original Solid Deodorant

• Lever 2000 soap
J term Plus Face Wash
• Facial moisturizers (Kiehl's Ultra Facial Maisiurizer, Bahor)
❑ Aquaphor Hand Cream
California❑  Mango Lotion
3 Bubble bath and shower gels (variety)
3 Shampoo / Conditioner (White Rain Coconut Essence, Biolage, Nexxus Simply Silver)

• Hair finishing cream (Paul Mitchell Stickworks)
• Peter Thomas Roth Sunscreen (face and body)
• Kiehl's Lip Balm with SPF
9 Q-Tips

• Round cotton pads
• Toothpaste (Arm & Hammer Dental Care and Mentadent)
Toothbrush (Oral B / Hard)
J Electric Toothbrush (Braun Ultra Plaque Remover)
J Scope mouthwash

• Dental Floss (Johnson & Johnson Reach /Mint waxed)
• Baby Powder (Johnson & Johnson)
Mason Pearson Hairbrush
3 Hair Comb
Tweezers

• Fingernail clippers and file
DATE: SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 I2
3524-018
Page 19 of 66
MS MAXWELL'S BM I ROMI
D Two big white towels placed next to the bath.
O Soap, shampoo and bubble bath by the side of the tub.
9 Check that water is hot and running clear.
O Water must be directed to the faucet and not the sprayer on the tub.
9 Two fresh washcloths on the washbasin and two next to the bathtub.
O Fresh bar of soap placed to the right of the washbasin.
9 Electric toothbrush (Replace head every 4 weeks).
9 New toothbrush placed in a clean drinking glass to the left of the washbasin.
O Toothpaste is more than 1/4 full.
9 Mouthwash.

• Q-Tips.
9 Round cotton pads.
3 Tidy and replace any toiletries which are running low.
9 Tissues (replace if less than 1/4 ).
9 Unlock the closets.
al Photographs to be placed.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 1$
3524-018
Page 20 of 66
MS MA X \VEIL'S BATHROOM TOILF:FRIES
CHECK (WlLIST
Facial Moisturizer (La Mer)
❑ Bober 'Foam Mask
3 Kiehl's Cucumber Toner
0' Kiehl's Washable Cleansing Milk

• La Mer Eye Balm
❑ Evian Face Mist
❑ Clarins Creme Masvelt Body Shaping Creme
❑ Bober Natural Body Peeling
3 Lancome afoliance Gel
❑ Body Lotion (Frederic Fekkat Clinique Deep Comfort Body Moisture)
1 Aquaphor Hand Cream
❑ Secret Original Solid Deodorant
D Round cotton pads
J Q-Tips

• Toothbrush (Oral B / Hard)
3 Electric Toothbrush (Braun Ultra Plaque Remover)
Toothpaste (Ann & Hammer Dental Care and Mentadent)
J Dental Floss (Johnson & Johnson Reach /Mint waxed)

• Scope mouthwash
3 Sunscreen (Lancome Soleil SPF 30 Face Creme)
0 Kiehl's Lip Balm with SPF
2/14/2005
3524-0113
Page 21 of 66
Lever 2000 soap
J Bubble Bath, Bath Gel, Bath Salts (variety)

• Razor and shaving gel
J Shampoo / Conditioner (Frederic ream' Technical cf Apple Cider)
• Aquis Hair Towel

• Mason Pearson Bair Brush
❑ Babor Hand & Nail Repair
J Nail polish remover (Curer)
9 Fingernail clippers and file
Ti Tweezers
J OB tampons (light & heavy)
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/ 14/2005 15
3524-018
Page 22 of 66
GUESTROOM S
Hint: All guestrooms must appear as though the arriving guest is the first to ever stay in
the room.

• Bed linen must be fresh.
O All light fixtures are working.
O Remote controls for the television are working.
O Instructions on "How to work the television" placed next to the television.
O Alarm clock must be set to the correct time and date.
O Telephones are on "Do not disturb."
J Telephone extension card placed under front of telephone.
O Pens and Jeffrey Epstein large and small notepads on bedside table.

• Eye masks on both bedside tables.
• Small bouquet of fresh flowers.
• Gifts if indicated by Mr Epstein.
J Bottled water and drinking glasses on bedside table.
J Selection of fresh fruit.
D Side plate, fruit knife, napkin.
▪ Flashlight with new batteries.
J Closets must be cleared. Check that there arc sufficient wooden hangers that are
hung evenly.
DATE:
2/14/2005
SIGNATURE:
16
3524-018
Page 23 of 66
GUEST BATHROOMS
O Towels and bathrobes arc fresh.
O Fresh bar of soap and shampoo in bathtub and shower stall.
O Two fresh washcloths on the washbasin and two next to the bathtub.

• Fresh bar of soap placed to the right of the washbasin.
O New toothbrush and toothpaste on the counter to the lell of the washbasin.
9 Clean drinking glass.

• Tissues (replace if less than''/.,).
• Check guest supplies and replace what is needed.
O Hairdryer is working.
3 Replace toilet paper with new roll. Fold end into a "V."
DATE: SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 17
13524-018
Page 24 of 66
GUEST BATHROONiti TOILE I RI 1.ti
CHECK OFF LIST
O Toothbrush (Oral 13 / Hard)
❑ Toothpaste (Ann & Hammer Dental Care. Mentadent)
3 Dental Floss (Johnson & Johnson Reach /Mint waxed)
O Scope mouthwash
❑ Shaving Cream (Kiehl's, Gillette)
❑ Schick Trib/ade Disposable Razors (Men & Ladies)
O Aquaphor Hand Cream
❑ Facial cleansers and moisturizers (variety)
3 Round cotton pads
3 Body Lotion (The Body Shop Body Butter, California Mango)
J Secret Original Solid Deodorant
▪ Sunscreen (Clinique Body & Face SPF IS & 30)

• Lip Balm (Kiehl's with SPF)
• Hawaiian Tropic After Sun
▪ Tweezers
Fingernail kit
3 Hairbrush
Comb
Shampoo / Conditioner (Biolage, The Body Shop Coconut, Frederic Fekkai)
J Lever 2000 soap
Q Tips
O Bath / Shower Gel
❑ Tampax and OB tampons (regular), Always pads (with wings)
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 18
3524-018
Page 25 of 66
ALL BATHROOMS
CHECK 1,1ST
All bathrooms must contain the following extra items
O Toilet paper (white two-ply)
3 Bath towel
O Hand towel
9 Washcloth
O Hand soap
D Bath soap (Lever 2000)
3 Kleenex tissue

• 9 Tylenol
3 Turns
3 Sudafod
• Halls cough sweets
• Box of matches
• Toilet brush
3 Toilet plunger
DATE: SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 19
3524-018
Page 26 of 66
EXTERIOR
J Pressure wash pool deck, sidewalks, terrace and patios.
3 Pressure wash outdoor fiirniture.
Place cushions on pool and terrace furniture.

• Have the pool cleaned.
3 Check that pool water temperature is between 82 — ftlIT
O Float in the pool is properly inflated.

• Pool "toys" arc clean and in working order.
3 Pool lights working.
• Towels are in the wooden basket.
O Telephone is connected and in working order.
O Landscape lights working.
O Wash windows.
O Check fence for holes where Max can get out.

• Awnings arc clean and working.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 20
35241-0 I 8
Page 27 of 66
THE CABANA
❑ Check that computer will access the Internet and Bloomberg.
J Place paper in the copier.

• Plenty of pens and paper.
9 Two pairs of reading glasses on the desk.
O Telephone directory placed to the right of the telephone.
O Tissues (replace if less than 1/4 ).

• Tidy the desk, but do not throw any papers away.
3 Stereo in working condition.
O Two bathrobes and towels in the bathroom.
9 Fresh bar of soap placed to the right of the washbasin.
3 New toothbrush and toothpaste placed to the left of the washbasin.
3 Clean drinking glass.
❑ Replace toilet paper with new roll. Fold end into a "V."

• Suntan oil and insect repellent.
DATE:
2/1412005
SIGNATURE:
21
3524-018
Page 28 of 66
EFFA_00009573
VEHICLES AND 131(.:YCLES
D Drive all vehicles to make sure that they are in good running condition. No flat
batteries.
O Check that cars are full of petrol (never below'/.).
O Place $100 in the glove compartment or center console of each car.
O Two bottles of water.

• JE and GM telephone directories.
O Reading glasses.
O Jeffrey Epstein large and small notepads with pens.
O Box of tissues.
O Two pairs of sunglasses.

• Check that bicycles are clean and tire pressure is correct.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 22
3524-018
Page 29 of 66
INTERIOR
Living Room
Plump the cushions.
0 Check that stereo system and headphones arc working.
J Clean and tidy all table top surfaces.
Tidy up the magazines. Throw out fashion magazines over two months old.
3 Place books that are lying around hack on bookshelves.
Ms Maxwell's Desk
3 Check that the DSL computer line is working.
3 Place paper in the copier.
3 Plenty of pens and notepads.
0 JE & GM telephone directories placed to the right of the telephone.
3 Tissues (replace if less than %).
Kitchen
Polish marble counter tops in kitchen.
3 Empty dishwasher.
J Check all expiration dates on food in refrigerator and pantry.
J Dish pantry must be organized.
7, Napkins cleaned and pressed for trays.
2/14/2005 23
3524-018
Page 30 of 66
General
3 Buy The N)' Tim c. The Wall SNIT! Animal, Palm &web Post and place in the
pantry. Buy the Daily Mail and place on Ms Maxwell's desk.
3 Current TV Guide next to television.

• "I -low to work the TV" instructions next to television.
• Check that all light bulbs are working. Dust and straighten lampshades.

• Check that the water is hot and running clear.
3 Check that all air conditioners arc in working order.

• Check that all telephones arc working.
O Flashlights on each desk and in the kitchen. Check batteries.

• Reading glasses, pens and notepads at every telephone.
• All clocks are set at the correct time and date. (See p. 55 for instructions.)

• All electrical appliances and stereo systems are working.
• Place box of matches next to all candles.
—I Dust and straighten paintings.

• Straighten the fringe on all rugs. Check for stains.
2 Check that all smoke detectors are working. Check fire extinguishers.
3 Clean all air vents.

• Make sure that all drapes are hanging neatly with hooks in place.
Stationary
2 Three sizes of Jetty Epstein notepads.
▪ Two sizes of Ghislaine Maxwell and Lady Ghislaine notepads.
Letterhead stationary and envelopes. One pack from each of Mr Epstcin's
residences and business. Mr Epstein's personal stationary (writing paper,
notepads. envelopes, compliment slips).
9 JeffieyEpstein and Ghislaine Maxwell cards and envelopes.
DATE:
2/14/2005 14
3524-018
Page 31 of 66
DAILY DUTIES (IN RESIDENCE)
CHECK OFF LIST
Morning preparation
J Buy newspapers.

• Check that the petrol in all vehicles is more than full.
3 $100 in glove compartment or center console of each vehicle.

• Replace empty water bottles.
• Check that there are pens, notepads, telephone directories and tissues.
3 Any CD's lying around should be placed back in the correct covers.
Pool Area

• Check that pool temperature is between 82 - 88'F
3 Wipe down all outside tables and chairs.
D Place reading glasses, pens, notepads and a telephone on the pool table outside.
7 JE and GM telephone directories placed to the right of the telephone.

• Replenish and place towel basket next to pool.
• Check that pool "toys" arc clean.
Cabana
D All exercise equipment is put away.
3 Stereo is switched off.
Empty dustbin.
9 Pens, notepads and reading glasses on desk.

• Check that there is enough paper in the printer.
3 Tidy desk and place books neatly to one side. Do not throw away any papers.
D Replace soiled hand towels and bathrobes.

• Check soap, toothbrush, toothpaste and clean drinking glass.
3 Clean the toilet and check toilet paper.
9 Replace tissues if less than 1/3.
2/14/2005 25
3524-018
Page 32 of 66
Kitchen
3 Make the coffee.
3 Wipe down the counter tops and cupboard doors.
3 Take out the trash.

• Check that Max has food and water.
Downstairs Areas
• Plump the cushions.
• Remove any trash and dirty glasses.
❑ Tidy magazines and replace any books on bookshelves.
3 Any CD's lying around should be placed back in the correct covers.

• Check that there are pens, notepads and reading glasses next to each telephone.
• Check that the telephone extension card is placed under the front of the telephone.
J Replace hand towel in powder room. Clean sink and toilet. Replenish toilet paper.

• Check that the printers have enough paper.
Once Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and guests come downstairs
Make breakfast.
Master Bedroom
15 Make up the bed with fresh bed linen.
J Check the phones are on "Do not disturb."

• Tidy bedside tables and remove any trash and dirty glasses.
2/14/2005 26
3524-018
Page 33 of 66
Master Bathroom
J Replace used towels.
O Two clean hand towels by the sink.
J Two facecloths by the sink and in the shower.

• Three large blue towels and one hand towel on the chair for massage.
O Clean all fixtures including shower and steam room.
D Replace tissues if less than V3.

• Check that there is enough toothpaste.
J Clean the drinking glass.
J Tidy all toiletries and replace any that are running low.
O Remove clothes from the hamper and launder.
J All other clothes and shoes should be put back in the closet.
Ms Maxwell's. Bathroom
J Replace used towels.
7 Clean bathtub and all fixtures.

• Replace tissues if less than V,.
• Check that there is enough toothpaste.
7 Clean the drinking glass.
D Tidy all toiletries and replace any that are running low.
7 Remove clothes from the hamper and launder.

• All other clothes and shoes should be put back in the closet.
2/14/2005 27
3524-018
Page 34 of 66
Guestrooms

• Make the beds (change linen every other day).
D Remove any trash and dirty glasses.
• Straighten any out of place clothing, private belongings, newspapers and magazines.
3 Remove dirty clothing and launder.
▪ Replace used towels.

• Clean bathtub and all fixtures.
3 Replace tissues if less than X.
J Clean the drinking glass.
3 Tidy vanity and toiletries.
Early evening
3 Check if there are any incoming faxes. Replenish fax paper.
3 Walk through the house and tidy.
9 Turn on all lights inside and out.
3 Turn down bed in Master Bedroom.
3 Check the phones arc on "Do not disturb."
Tidy Master Bedroom and replace any soiled towels and bathrobes.
Turn down beds in Guestrooms.
J Tidy Guestrooms and replace any soiled towels and bathrobes.
J Place bottles of water and drinking glasses by each bedside.
Before you leave at night
3 Make sure that Max is inside.
▪ Check that all doors to the outside arc shut and locked.
Check that the garage doors are closed.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 28
3524-018
Page 35 of 66
Mar 03 OS 01:02p
PRE -ARRIVAL SHOPPING LIST
Dairy Products
J 1/2  gallon regular milk
I quart skim milk
J I quart half and half
- 4 Lurpak European butter
I I large container Dannon regular plain yogurt
J I Philadelphia cream cheese
I tub plain cottage cheese
J Ya pint heavy cream
.1 I dozen eggs
J % pound Boar's Head Swiss cheese
3 Haagen Dazs ice cream - coffee, chocolate, vanilla, strawberry
Fresh produce
J 2 green vegetables of choice (such as French green beans, broccoli)
3" Cleaned baby spinach and medium greens
- 8 ripe tomatoes
3 Grape tomatoes
3 3 avoeadoes
.3 European cucumber

• I Iceberg lettuce (not in a packet)
3 I regular lettuce (not in a packet)
3 6 endive
2 Fresh baby carrots
▪ Fresh Rosemary
7 Fresh Thyme
J Dill

• Fresh Mint
Italian parsley
3 Olives
7 Scallions
▪ Garlic
J 2 Sweet onions
7/ 2 Red onions
• 2 Sweet potatoes
6 Baking potatoes
3 Ginger
3 1 bag juice oranges
Cl 6 eating oranges

• Small bunch red and green grapes
O 2 Mango
- 6 ripe bananas
3 Berries (strawberries, raspberries, blueberries — whatever is in season)
D 4 Fugi apples
D 1/2  Watermelon
3 4 Lemons
Figs
3/3/2005 29
P-I
Page 36 of 66
Mar O3 O5 01:03p
Fresh meat, poultry & fish
'A pound Boar's (lead black form ham
% pound cracked pepper turkey breast
3 Ms Maxwell or David will advise any additional meat, poultry or fish to purchase.
Beverages 1.11jUUJUIJI.1
Apple Juice
Cranberry juice
4 Diet Coke (place in refrigerator)
4 Cokc (place in refrigerator)
Gatorade
Large bottle Perrier water (place in refrigerator)
Vitamin water (place in refrigerator)
Tonic Water
Breads, Cereals and baked goods
Cheerios
Kix
6 assorted bagels
1 pack Tortilla wraps

• I pack Pita bread
Treats
• Chocolate
• Cheetos
Other
• "Skippy" Chunky Peanut Butler
Carmine Giardini's Market
I.! t t.1 t.. Homemade mozzarella
I inch wedge parmesan cheese
Smoked salmon
6 Laughing Cow mini cheese
6 Baby Bell Cheeses
Brie cheese
' pound Cheddar cheese
I fresh salmon
DATE:
3/3/2005 30
3524-018
Page 37 of 66
Woos
Canned goods
Tomato paste
Pomi tomatoes chopped and strained
31
SIIOPPING 1.IST
The following items should be in stock al all limes
** Regardless of quantity used, all open packets must he replaced after each visit ••
Beverages
Fiji water (large and small)
3 Maxwell House coffee
J Starbucks ground Colombian coffee
J Diet Coke
O Coke
O Sprite
O Diet Sprite
O Pepsi
i Diet Pepsi
O Tonic Water
J Club Soda
O Perrier Water
O Vitamin Water
O Cranberry juice
3 English breakfast tea (packets and tea leaves)
O Earl Grcy tea (packets and tea leaves)
O Mint tea
O Chamomile tea
3 White wine - Chablis Premier Cm (6 bottles)
O Red wine — Snottily (6 bottles)
O Veuve-Clicquot champagne (4 bottles)
O Absolut Vodka

• Tanqueray Gin
O Whiskey
3 Heineken Beer (6 pack)
3 Corona Beer (6 pack)
Spices and condiments
Hellmann's mayonnaise
Dijon mustard
6 Low sodium chicken stock
Colivita extra virgin olive oil
Sea salt
Sugar (White, Brown)
Sweet & Low
Equal
3524-018
Page 38 of 66
Miscellaneous
Assortment of Barilla Pasta
.3 Rice
❑ Assorted LU cookies
❑ Oreos
3 Eukanuba dog food
Household products
❑ Paper towels
J Toilet paper (white two-ply)
3 Kleenex tissues
O Tide with Bleach
3 Downy fabric softener
3 Bounce dryer sheets
❑ Palmolive Dish soap
❑ Murphy's oil soap
3 Soft scrub
3 Windex
3 Clorox Bleach
❑ Fantastik All purpose cleaner
❑ Cascade Dishwasher detergent
❑ Glad zipper storage bags (Large)
3 Glad zipper storage bags (Small)
3 Garbage bags
O Sponges
O Latex Gloves
O O111 Insect repellent
3 Air freshener
3 Formula 409 bathroom cleaner

• Lysol toilet bowl cleaner
• Brasso
• Liquid drain opener
71 Oven /Grill cleaner
3 Silverware cleaning product
Light bulbs
❑ Batteries

• Lenscraftcrs Pre-Moistened Disposable Towelettes
2/14/2005 32
3524-018
Page 39 of 66
Pharmaceuticals

• 2 bottles Bayer aspirin
D Tylenol
❑ 2 Alava
Cl 2 Robitussin cough medicine
3 Nyquil
3 Robitussin cough sweets

• Halls cough sweets
D Bandages
3 Antiseptic for cuts
DATE:
2/I4/2005
Ncosporin
lichinacca
Zinc loxengcrs
Vitamin C
Vitamin B
Vitamin E
Folic Acid
Multi vitamin twin tab I a day
D Calcium twin tab
SIGNATURE: 33
3524-018
Page 40 of 66
0,EANING Stift:MLE
The most important aspect of household cleaning and maintenance is routine. Certain tasks have to be completed every day
to keep things at a high standard. A
home that is properly cleaned stays "in place" much longer than those that have been only surface cleaned. Always 
remember to clean from the top down and from
the inside out. Always vacuum last. When leaving a room, turn to check it after you complete it.
2/14/2005 34
3524-018
Page 41 of 66
DAILY
O Dishes, dishwasher —wash dishes, use dishwasher if needed. Remember: crystal,
fine china, silver, cutlery knives, hand-painted bowls or serving platters and pots and
pans do not normally go in the dishwasher.

• Kitchen — Clean counter tops, clean sinks, move items on the counter top and clean
under them. Clean smudges and finger prints from cabinets, doors and light
switches, clean microwave oven, clean and shine inside and out. Clean refrigerators.
2 Kitchen appliances — Shine toaster, coffee maker. Note: appliances not left out
should be cleaned before putting away.

• Sink — Remove any deposits, clean and shine.
Garbage— Empty trash, replace bag, wipe off.
3 Floors — Remove chairs and small items, sweep well. Mop with warm water.

• Glass — Clean glass doors and tables as needed.
-1 Furniture — Clean, dust, shine tables, chairs, plump cushions.
D Bedrooms — Make beds as needed, neaten personal belongings, clean all the mirrors,
look for streaks.

• Bathrooms— Shine faucets, toilet paper holder, make-up mirrors, towel rack,
toothbrush holder. Clean and re fill vanity items, check for tissue and toilet paper,
wipe bath, sink, mirror, shower walls, place fresh towels.
1 Clocks — Check time and date.
Phones — Clean with disinfectant.

• Vacuum — Heavy traffic areas as needed. Comb tassels on carpets.
DATE:
2/14/2005
SIGNATURE:
35
3524-018
Page 42 of 66
WEEKLY
J Baseboards — Dust with a soil cloth.
D Wood furniture — Dust and polish tables, chairs, shelves, frames, cabinets.
J Sofas and chain - Vacuum all cushions, fluff pillows, spot-clean as needed.
Lamps - Dust lampshades. Check light bulbs. Straighten shades.
Computers and desks — Clean and wipe screen, dust, replace objects exactly where you found them.
3 Dust and polish — All glass tables, mirrors, pictures, porcelain and art objects.
3 Walls — Remove fingerprints from walls, switches, doors.
D Cabinets and drawers — Clean thoroughly inside and out. Straighten or repack.
3 Shelving — Clean thoroughly. Rotate areas requiring fresh shelf paper.
D Massage Tables — Wipe and sanitize.
3 Carpets — Vacuum. Be sure you get the stairs, get behind doors, under furniture, spot-clean as needed.
3 Bathrooms - Shine faucets, mirrors, towel racks. Wipe and clean bath and shower tiles, doors and walls. Remove mold 
with mildew remover. Remove soap build up.
3 Toilet — Clean bowl, seat, lid, base, tank top. Check toilet paper.
3 Marble — Polish marble in bathrooms.
3 Refrigerator — Clean thoroughly. Throw out spoiled food. To eliminate odors, place a bowl of cotton balls soaked in 
plain vanilla extract in the fresh food
section.
-1 Windows — Clean all windows inside and out, clean window ledges.
! Blinds - Dust quickly over each blind. If necessary, clean with ammonia and water.
2/14/2005 36
3524-018
Page 43 of 66
D Front Entrance — Sweep and imp. clean door mats.
O Outdoor furniture— Pressure wash.
3 Pool — Clean. Check that water temperature is between 82 -88'F.
3 Exercise equipment — Wipe all equipment, sides and fronts, vacuum behind. check.

• Garage — Vacuum / sweep out as needed.
• Cars — Wash and wax exterior, clean and vacuum inside.
DATE: SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 37
3524-018
Page 44 of 66
MONTHLY
Divide your list of monthly duties into weekly cleaning schedules. This will make it
easier for you to deep-clean each area properly. This does not mean that you do not need
to perform your daily and weekly duties.
WEEK I
9 Clean windows — wash the insides, clean sills.

• Clean blinds.
9 Clean light fixtures.
O Clean ceilings, walls, doors, baseboards and air vents.
9 Clean ceiling fans.
3 Clean /vacuum air conditioners and humidifiers.

• Air all rooms. Open the windows and doors to allow fresh air into the room.
WEEK 2
• Clean and organize closets in bathrooms and bedrooms.
O Clean drawers and shelves in bathrooms and bedrooms.
9 Turn mattresses.
O Re-fold linen closets and order as needed.
Re-stock utility closets.

• Wipe books.
• Discard old magazines.
7 Polish wood furniture.
• Clean bed frames, vacuum under beds and bedroom furniture.
9 Wash bath mats.
Clean steam room walls and floor thoroughly to prevent scum and mildew from
forming and avoid bad odors.
WEEK 3

• Clean and organize crockery and glassware in butler's pantry.
J Clean kitchen floors thoroughly.
• Clean refrigerator and freezer.
9 Clean pots and pans.

• Clean kitchen cabinets inside and out.
3 Clean and organize kitchen drawers.
3 Clean and check pantry supplies.
9 Clean silverware.
•• Chipped and broken items must be removed and reported to the Estate Manager.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 38
3524-018
Page 45 of 66
EVERY SIX MONTHS
APRIL
(Check list to be completed and signed by 28th April)
❑ Rotate seasonal clothing. Dry clean items if necessary.
❑ Wash mattress covers and launder any blankets.
❑ Take all books down from shelves and clean.
❑ Clean upholstery and throw cushions.
J Dry clean drapes.
❑ Check for pests throughout property.
3 Inventory all crockery, glassware, linens, etc.
❑ Steam clean all carpets.
❑ Car maintenance if necessary.

• Drain and clean pool.
DATE: SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 39
3524-018
Page 46 of 66
OCTOBER
(Check list to be completed and si gned by 28th ()cipher)
O Rotate seasonal clothing. Dry clean sweaters and other items if necessary. 3 Wash mattress covers and launder any 
blankets.

• Take all books down from shelves and clean.
3 Clean upholstery and throw cushions.
3 Dry clean drapes.
O Check for pests throughout property.
J Inventory all crockery, glassware, linens, etc.

• Steam clean all carpets.
❑ Car maintenance if necessary.
9 Drain and clean pool.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/I4/2005 40
3524-018
Page 47 of 66
MAINTENANCE Stift:IAWE
Preventive maintenance is the best way to keep your home and grounds in good
condition. Maintenance that is carried out on a regular basis, will ward off major repairs.
21 14/2005 i i
3524-0I8
Page 48 of 66
CHECK EVERY MONTH
(Check list to be completed and signed by the 28"' of each month)
J Fire Extinguisher — Check to make sure that it is fully charged.
0 Security alarm — Test system.
J Sink stoppers — Clean out debris, soak stoppers in vinegar and water to clean.
J Garbage disposal — Flush with hot water and baking soda, put ice cubes through t❑
sharpen.
0 Hot water heating system — Test relief valve and replace if necessary; check
pressure gauge and drain expansion tank if necessary.
Steam heating system — Check safety valve and steam-pressure gauge and have
replaced if necessary; chock water-level gauge and add water if needed; drain water
until clear to eliminate sediment.
1 Air conditioners / heaters — Clean or replace filter; clean condenser, evaporator
coils and condensation drain.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 42
3524-0) 8
Page 49 of 66
BEDROOM CLEANING

• If weather permits, open windows to air the room.
• Strip the bed.
• Place pillows, duvet, bedspreads and blankets on a chair. Never on the floor.

• Empty trash containers and pick up any other trash. Check under the bed.
Make die bed with fresh linen.

• Make sure that the closets are empty. Check that the hangers arc not broken and
are hung evenly.
• Dust all furniture and picture frames.

• Dust and straighten lamp shades. Scams must face the wall. Replace the light
bulb if necessary.
Spot clean all mirrors and glass.

• Wipe all walls, doors, and light switches.
• Telephone must be free of dust. No sticky spots. Cord must hang properly.

• Make sure that the television, remote control and radio are in working order and
free of dust.
• Alarm clock must be set to the correct time and date.

• Close the windows.
• Make sure that the drapes hang evenly and all hooks are in place.
• Vacuum the carpet.
2/14/2005 49
3524-018
Page 50 of 66
EFFA_00009595
BATHROOM (TEANING

• Empty trash containers and pick up any other trash.
Replace soiled towels. All towels to be even in width and hung evenly lengthwise.
No seams exposed.

• Replace soiled bathrobes. Robes must be washed after each visit.
• Check guest supplies and replace what is needed.

• Replace toilet paper with new roll. Fold end into a "V"
• Replace soap with new bar.
• Clean mirrors using glass cleaner. Stan at the top and work down to the bottom.

• Clean vanity and sink using all-purpose cleaner.
Clean toilet using toilet bowl cleaner. Squirt under rim of bowl and let stand a
few minutes. Clean the rim, seat, hinges, base, all porcelain and hardware. Flush.

• Clean the shower stall and walls. Place the dirty hathinat in the tub or shower
stall and stand on the mat while cleaning. Use all-purpose cleaner and wipe down
the walls and glass door. Clean marble with damp cloth. Clean the shower head
and soap dishes. Rinse shower stall with hot water after removing the bathmat.
Dry shower walls, floor and door. Wipe down shower curtain. Place bottom of
curtain outside of tub. Arrange curtain in pleats.

• Clean the bathtub. Kneel on dirty bathmat. Using tissue, remove all hair and
foreign material from tub and drain. Using all-purpose cleaner, scrub thoroughly,
paying attention to sides of the tub. Rinse with hot water. Dry the entire surface.
Polish fixtures with a dry, clean cloth.
NOTE:
All surfaces must be clean of hair, smudges, debris, fingerprints, soap build-up and scum. No dripping faucets.
No clogged drains.
If guests are in residence, clean under toiletries left on the vanity and put back in a neat, orderly manner.
2/14/2005 50
3524-018
Page 51 of 66
LAUNDRY AND DRY CLEANING

• The first rule in laundry is read the label. Determine if you can wash an item, or if you must take it to be 
dry-cleaned.

• Sort clothes — white in one pile, colored in another, delicate in yet another.
• Check pockets!
• Wash towels separately.

• Wash all new towels and linen before use.
• Rotate your towels and sheets so as not to wear them out.
Worn towels should be transferred to staff quarters for staff use.

• Bed linens are taken to Snow White Laundry.
Clothes that require dry cleaning are taken to Spartan Cleaners. If the garment is stained, be sure to show the cleaner 
where it is soiled, mentioning what you
think the stain is. When you collect the clothes, check that the garment is properly cleaned and the stains have been 
removed.

• Detergents — Tide with Bleach; Downy fabric softener; Bounce dryer sheets.
• Organize the linen closet. All sheets, pillow cases and towels identically folded. The folded end should face outward.
Separate stacks according to which
bedroom they belong in.
2/14/2005 5l
3524-018
Page 52 of 66
CIIECK EVERY THREE MONTHS
MARCH
(Check list to be completed and signed by 28th March)
3 Faucets - Check for leaking faucets. Replace washers if necessary.
9 Bathtub drain assembly — Clean out debris; inspect rubber seal; replace if
necessary.
❑ Shower drain assembly — Clean out debris and scrub strainer.
❑ Range hood fan — Clean grease filter.
3 Dishwasher - Run the unit with a quart of white vinegar added to the tank. This
removes an y deposits left behind in the tub and helps keep the drain clear.
❑ Hinges and locks — Lubricate as needed.
❑ Awnings — Lower and clean. Check motor.
DATE:
2/14/2005
SIGNATURE:
43
3524-018
Page 53 of 66
CHECK EVERN' SIX MONTHS
APRIL
(Check list to be completed and signed by 28th April)
3 Toilets — Check for leaks in flushing mechanism; repair if necessary.
'J Interior caulking — Inspect caulking around bathtubs, showers and sinks; replace if deteriorating.
3 Washing machines — Clean water inlet filters; check hoses for leaks and replace if necessary.
O Clothes dryers — Vacuum lint from ducts and surrounding areas.
O Refrigerator — Wash and check door gasket; clean condenser coils with a gentle brush.
D Range hood fan — Wash fan blades and housing.
3 Hot water heating system — Lubricate circulating pump and motor.
LI Wiring — Check for frayed cords and wires; repair if necessary.
3 Foundation — Check for cracks and moisture, repair if necessary.

• Roof — Inspect roof surface; repair if necessary.
3 Gutters and downspout — Clean out, inspect and repair weaknesses; check for proper drainage and adjust if necessary.
O Exterior caulking — Inspect caulking and replace if deteriorating.
O Window sills, door sills and thresholds - Fill cracks, caulk edges and repaint; replace if necessary

• Drain -waste and vent system — Flush out system.
• Irrigation system — Check, drain and repair if necessary.
3 Fences — Inspect and repair if necessary.
Garage doors - Clean and lubricate hinges, rollers and tracks; tighten screws.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005
47
3524-018
Page 54 of 66
JUNE
(Check list to be completed and signed by 28th June)
• Faucets - Check for leaking faucets. Replace washers if necessary.
❑ Bathtub drain assembly— Clean out debris; inspect rubber seal; replace if
necessary.
O Shower drain assembly — Clean out debris and scrub strainer.
O Range hood fan — Clean grease filter.
❑ Dishwasher - Run the unit with a quart of white vinegar added to the tank. This
removes any deposits left behind in the tub and helps keep the drain clear.
❑ Hinges and locks — Lubricate as needed.
❑ Awnings — Lower and clean. Check motor.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 44
3524-018
Page 55 of 66
SEPTEMBER
(Check list to be completed and signed by 28th September)
3 Faucets - Check for leaking faucets. Replace washers if necessary.
3 Bathtub drain assembly — Clean out debris; inspect rubber seal; replace if
necessary.
3 Shower drain assembly — Clean out debris and scrub strainer.
Range hood fan — Clean grease filter.
3 Dishwasher - Run the unit with a quart of white vinegar added to the tank. This
removes any deposits left behind in the tub and helps keep the drain clear.
1 Hinges and locks — Lubricate as needed.
0 Awnings — Lower and clean. Check motor.
DATE: SIGNATURE:
2/14/2005 45
3524-018
Page 56 of 66
OCTOBER
(Check list to be completed and signed by 28°' October)
J Toilets — Check for leaks in flushing mechanism; repair if necessary.
Interior caulking — Inspect caulking around bathtubs, showers and sinks; replace if
deteriorating.
Washing machines — Clean water inlet filters; check hoses for leaks and replace if
necessary.
Clothes dryers — Vacuum lint from ducts and surrounding areas.
D Refrigerator — Wash and check door gasket; clean condenser coils with a gentle
brush.
D Range hood fan — Wash fan blades and housing.
11 lint water heating system — Lubricate circulating pump and motor.
1.1 Wiring — Check for frayed cords and wires; repair if necessary.
0 Foundation — Check for cracks and moisture, repair if necessary.
D Roof — Inspect roof surface; repair if necessary.
Cutters and downspout — Clean out, inspect and repair weaknesses; check for
proper drainage and adjust if necessary.
D Exterior caulking — Inspect caulking and replace if deteriorating.
Window sills, door sills and thresholds - Fill cracks, caulk edges and repaint;
replace if necessary
Drain -waste and vent system — Flush out system.
-Li Irrigation system — Check, drain and repair if necessary.
Fences — Inspect and repair if necessary.
J Garage doors — Clean and lubricate hinges, rollers and tracks; tighten screws.
DATE:  SIGNATURE:
2!1 4/2005 48
3524-018
Page 57 of 66
DECEMBER
(Check list to be corrmkted and signed by 2)t* December)

• Faucets - Check for leaking faucets. Replace washers if necessary.
• Bathtub drain assembly — Clean out debris; inspect rubber seal; replace if
necessary.
:11 Shower drain assembly- Clean out debris and semb strainer.
73 Range hood fan - Clean grease filter.
I Dishwasher - Run the unit with a quart of white vinegar added to the tank. This
removes any deposits left behind in the tub and helps keep the drain clear.
"I Hinges and locks — Lubricate as needed.
- Awnings — Lower and clean. Check motor.
DATE:
2/1O2005
SIGNATURE:
46
3524-018
Page 58 of 66
OFFICE SU PPI A ES
The following supplies should be in inventory at all times:

• Copy / printer paper.
• Toner and ink cartridges for printers and fax machine — a minimum of 2 per unit

• Pens and pencils.
• Red and green markers.
• Black markers.
• Rulers.
• Pair of scissors.
• Scotch tape.

• Shipping tape.
• Photographic print paper.
• Personalized notepads, cards, envelopes (Call Cecilia Steen to order).

• FeclEx and parcel slips.
• Disposable cameras.
• Film for cameras.
2/1412005 52
3524-018
Page 59 of 66
MAIL AND DELIVERIES
When Mr Epstein and Ms Maxwell arc in residence:

• Personal cards, notes and invitations arc to be placed on the pantry countertop.
• Correspondence for Ms Maxwell is to be placed on her desk.
When Mr Epstein and Ms Maxwell arc not in residence:

• Mr Epstein or Ms Maxwell's assistant must be notified if any packages arc
delivered.
General mail, including invoices and bank statements, are to be sent via FedEx to
Eric Gany in New York, twice a week.

• Include all personal mail in a separate envelope addressed to either Mr Epstein or
Ms Maxwell.
2/14/2005 53
3524-018
Page 60 of 66
RESKrl'ING TIIE TELEPHONE
Assure that the telephones arc always set to the proper date and time. The household
phones may be reset by performing the following:
Without picking up the receiver, dial 692 on the kitchen phone.

• Follow by dialing 2 digits for the year, 2 digits for the day. 2 digits for the month
and finally, dial 4 digits for the military time.
The phone should display the new date and time as well as make a noise to
indicate that it has been reset.

• Pick up the receiver and then hang-up. This will return the phone to its normal
mode.
2/14/2005 54
3524-018
Page 61 of 66
SERVING BREA K FAST
Mr Epstein's breakfast preferences:
Glass of water
Coffee

• I Sweet and Low or Equal
Creamer filled with Half & Half, wanned in the microwave for 25 seconds.
• Mr Epstein will indicate what food he would like to eat.
Ms Maxwell's breakfast preferences:

• Maxwell House coffee served with milk
Freshly squeezed orange juice
Glass of water
• I Weetabix with sliced banana. Milk and sugar on the side.
When service breakfast to guests:

• Pre-set table or breakfast trays for the number of guests present.
• As guests arrive, inquire whether they would like coffee, tea, or fruit juice.

• Always make sure that coffee is fresh.
Reconfirm that guests have no allergic reaction to any specific foods.

• Take the breakfast order. Inquire whether they would like to wait for any
remaining guests (if applicable), before you begin preparation.

• Always serve from the left, and clear from the right if possible.
Clean breakfast area as soon as guests have departed.
2/14/2005 55
3524-018
Page 62 of 66
STANDBY nun ES
When necessary, you will be required to be on "standby" duty. During this lime. you are to make yourself available for 
any duties dial need to he carried out,
or respond to an emergency that may arise.
In order for you to be able to respond promptly, you should not travel more than one hour from your home base. This 
means that if you arc called, the maximum
time it will take you to return, is one hour.
To properly perform this duty, you should know the following:
You could be called upon at any time, day or night.

• Have the necessary contact details for Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell, the Estate Manager and other relevant staff members.

• Call the Estate Manager and other relevant staff members and advise them of an
emergency. This should be done immediately.

• When speaking to the Estate Manager or other relevant staff members, provide accurate and detailed information.
• The security of the house, Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell and their guests arc your first
consideration. Always handle a crisis in a calm and professional manner.
2/14/2005 56
3524-018
Page 63 of 66
EMERGENCY PRO( 'ED I. NESS
In the event of an emergency, you may be required to decide on a course of action to
protect Mr Epstein, Ms Maxwell, their guests, other staff members and yourself.
REMEMBER TO STAY CALM AND DO NOT PANIC
FIRE
Call the Fire Department or 911 as soon as possible. Tell them the exact location and
nature of the fire.
Ask all guests to leave their rooms.
Never use the elevator. It could stop between floors.
When you exit the building during a fire, close all doors as you exit to confine the fire.
Make sure that everyone leaves with you.
Heat, smoke and gases emitted by burning materials can quickly choke you. If you are
caught in heavy smoke, get down on the floor and crawl. Take short breaths, breathing
through your nose.
If your clothes catch fire, don't run. Stop where you are, drop to the ground, cover your
face with your hands to protect your face and lungs and roll over to smother the flames.
Do not overestimate your ability to put out a fire. Most fires cannot be easily or safely extinguished. Do not attempt 
to put the fire out once it begins to
quickly spread.
HURRICANE SEASON
The season generally runs from June through November with the peak period being in
August and September.
During this time, it is necessary to monitor all weather systems on a daily basis, either via the television, Internet 
or radio. Guests must be advised of the
situation.
All outdoor furniture and loose items must be stored inside. Potted plants are moved into
areas with the least wind or placed indoors.
All shutters arc closed.
2/14/2005 57
3524-018
Page 64 of 66
MEDICAL EMERGENCY
Call 911 as soon as possible. Give them as much inlbrmation us you can. Tell them what
happened and the current condition of the patient.
If you arc unable to get help, drive the patient to the Good Samaritan Hospital,
1309 North Flagler Drive, West Palm Beach. Call the hospital on route and tell them that
you are on your way.
EMERGENCY CONTACT INFORMATION
GUEST NAME:
ALLERGIES:
CONTACT NAME:
CONTACT TELEPHONE:
HOME
WORK
PORTABLE
THANK YOU!
2/14/2005 .5f;
3524-018
Page 65 of 66
3524-018
Page 66 of 66
EFTA00156204 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Ghislaine Maxwell's receptionist
(date: 2021-10-08)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 5-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Dateactury  10/08/2021
), date of birth (DOB) DATE, was interviewed over
video conference. Present via video was Assistant United States Attorneys
and , along with Special Agent Young. After
being advised of the identities of the above listed individuals and the
nature of the interview, provided the following information:
met GHISLAINE MAXWELL (MAXWELL) at JEFFREY EPSTEIN's (EPSTEIN) house
in Palm Beach, Florida. was offered a receptionist job by MAXWELL.
MAXWELL asked to bring a couple of friends with her.
recalled EPSTEIN's home was along the intercostal. was under
the impression that MAXWELL and EPSTEIN both lived there.
was attending the PALM BEACH ATLANTIC UNIVERSITY when MAXWELL first
approached her. was by herself when MAXWELL approached her out of the
blue and asked if was interested in secretary work. told her no.
MAXWELL asked if she would be interested if it was for $200 an hour.
told her "sure". asked MAXWELL where she had to go. MAXWELL
wrote down directions and gave her phone number.
recalled she went to EPSTEIN's home around 2001, sometime around
9/11 because recalled watching TV together with them in the kitchen
when anthrax was found in West Palm Beach.
MAXWELL told she would be answering phones and helping with
paperwork. MAXWELL did not say who would be working for.
described EPSTEIN's house. The driveway had taller hedges. When
she walked in there was a black and white photograph of a topless woman.
was from the midwest and had never been around rich people like that.
In the room to the left was where MAXWELL had asked to shred books. In
the room to the right was an open area that had doors to the pool. There
Investigationon 10/08/2021  at New York, New York, United States (In Person)
File# SOD-NY-3027571
by Nicole Young
Date drafted 10/08/2021

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
SOD-NY -3027571
continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of a 10/08/2021 ,page 2 of 5
was a room that was MAXWELL's office that had doors with glass. There was a
kitchen and bedrooms upstairs.
worked there for approximately six to nine months. explained
that she was doing drugs at the time so it was hard to say how long she
stayed there.
went to the house when they called her. At first, she went quite a
bit, a couple times a week. It was inconsistent. She would go weeks
without being there.
MAXWELL had told to bring friends that were interested in work.
MAXWELL did not explain what her friends would be doing. When first
went, she took her two college roommates, and did not
recall their last names. described as a tall blonde and
was heavier set. MAXWELL did not like or MAXWELL
did not like because she was heavier set.
EPSTEIN, MAXWELL, and another girl lived at the house. The girl lived in
one of the upstairs bedrooms. described the girl as thinner with light
brown or dirty blonde hair. met the girl at the house. MAXWELL
introduced the girl and to each other. The girl showed around the
house. They went upstairs and got naked on the massage tables. There was a
guy there when and the girl got massages. This guy taught them to give
massages. described the guy as having dark hair and being a couple of
inches taller than is 5'4". only saw the guy 2 to 3 times.
The girl was the one who showed things there. The girl worked for
them. was 20 years old at the time and thought the girl was around her
age. assumed the girl was around her age. thought the girl could
have been a year younger or older than her.
actual age.
was not sure of the girl's
MAXWELL asked to call a ballet school in West Palm Beach. MAXWELL
wanted to ask girls to come over. MAXWELL said she had done ballet
when she was younger and wanted to get her ballet skills back. MAXWELL
wanted younger people who were more limber. MAXWELL wanted to make sure the
massage table was set up. thought she may have assumed MAXWELL wanted
the guy there because he gave massages but was not sure. called
the ballet school but did not remember if she scheduled anyone. did
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
50D-NY -3027571
Comthwdion of FD-302 of (U) Interview of
not see them.
MAXWELL asked
answer the phones.
lines. MAXWELL told
a 10/08/2021 ,page 3 of 5
to give EPSTEIN massages. MAXWELL asked to
was only allowed to answer 2-3 of the 8 phone
how to answer the phones. thought she
remembered her telling her how to transfer and how to make the calls.
MAXWELL gave a lot of cash to get movie tickets for them from the
theater at City Place.
MAXWELL had shred phone books that MAXWELL had made. described
the phone books as being "not quite half a page" and being bound. The phone
books were cloth like and had a hard back and hard binding that was black
almost like a sketch book. When they updated the books, had to take
the pages out and shred them. described the room where she shredded
the books being on the first floor down the hallway that looked like an
office but did not look used. The room was pretty empty with not much
decor.
only gave massages to EPSTEIN. MAXWELL told to just remember
what she learned from the massage therapist. The first massage gave
EPSTEIN was out by the pool. recalled EPSTEIN having a chart of gray
colors and told her to come help him pick out a color gray for his jet.
started massaging EPSTEIN's feet and legs.
recalled she did not wear much back then. She wore short shorts and
was skinny so she hardly wore anything to cover her stomach.
EPSTEIN was "handsy" and "touchy feely". EPSTEIN was not afraid to say
what he liked or did not like. When massaged EPSTEIN it would only be
the two of them. described that they could be seen from the living
room area but the doors were shut. EPSTEIN touched "all over",
including on her breasts, waste, thighs, and probably grabbed her "ass".
When EPSTEIN touched her breasts, had a shirt on. EPSTEIN touched her
breasts over and under her shirt. At the time, had never had sex
before. gave EPSTEIN massages in the lawn chair by the pool.
thought EPSTEIN was wearing a shirt and shorts. also gave
EPSTEIN a massage in the kitchen, but it was not a fully body massage.
Upstairs massages were more intimate. felt that the upstairs seemed
more intimate. knew the downstairs area; she did not feel free to roam
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
50D-NY -3027571
Comthwdion of FD-302 of (U) Interview of a 10/08/2021 ,page 4 of 5
upstairs. There were massages done upstairs. The girl had a room
upstairs. The girl shared with that they had guests that stayed
upstairs. The girl took care of those guests. understanding was
that by the girl taking care of those guests that was how she was able to
live there. The girl said they were visitors. thought the girl had
told her she lived there but did not remember.
When
photograph.
first went to EPSTEIN's home, she saw the black and white
also saw a woman who had on only bikini bottoms and a
towel walk through. thought that was how rich people lived by having
beautiful naked people around.
understanding was that EPSTEIN and MAXWELL were boyfriend and
girlfriend; they lived together. It was made clear to that it was
their house. The phone lines were for them. Now that has thought
back, she did not recall seeing them kissing or being intimate. saw
that they lived and worked there together. did not care to understand
and did not ask questions. assumed they lived there or it was their
second home. EPSTEIN and MAXWELL were always there when was there.
was never at their home without them.
thought she remembered all men calling the phone lines. did
not remember what they called about. did not remember if there were
women calling.
MAXWELL paid $200 an hour in 100 dollar bills.
stopped working for them around the time she got kicked out of
school. recalled she flew home for Christmas in 2001 and then flew
back. stopped working for them around 2002. was more into
partying and snorting cocaine than working. recalled she was staying
with a family with the last name TUNIS. slept on their couch for a
while. recalled coming in to the home and seeing the mom, SUE TUNIS,
sitting at the table with two officers. The officers, who were a man and
woman, told they were investigating a prostitution ring. thought
they were from the VICE squad. They asked if she would continue to go
back to the house to get more information. said no and left Palm
Beach. This interaction with law enforcement stuck out to because she
had never got in trouble or talked with the police prior to that.
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
50D-NY-3027571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of on 10/08/2021 " cc 5 of 5
recalled when she first started going to EPSTEIN's home, she told
her mom that she was going to rich people's home and making a lot of money.
mom called the university and said something was wrong. The school
told her mom that everything was fine.
had not thought about this in years until seeing EPSTEIN's arrest.
husband knows that she worked there but does not know everything.
felt like MAXWELL recruited her "off the bat" and felt like MAXWELL
was going to use her to recruit other girls.
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Pam Bondi [trump] Florida District Attorney during Epstein's crime spree, current Attorney General, lobbyist for Qatar 
                                                                         Sean J. Lancaster [employee] airplane reseller 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00095751 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ 63 page evidence list from Ghislaine Maxwell trial, removed from DOJ site by Pam Bondi DOJ
(inferred date: 2021-10-11)
United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell
20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
Non-Testifying Witness Material
11/6/2021

3501.000
General     Date    Descriptban     Attorney    Produced to Defense
3501.000001 2021.08.31 voicemail from unknown caller 2021.1031
3501.000002 Records of 911 calls 2021.10.11
3501.000003 2006.02.17 Palm Beach Police Department Widen( report 2021.10.11
3501.000003 2006.07.25 Palm Beach Police Department Widen( moon 2021.10.11
3501.000005 2007.09.13 Palm Beach Polito Department Midget moon 202L10.11
3501.000006 2006.09.01 Palm Beach Police Department Widen( report 2021.10.11
3501.000007 2007.0223 Letter from Gerald Lefcourt to <REDACTED> with draft transcript excerpts 2021.10.11
3501.000008 INTENTIONAL GAP
3501.000009 Palm Beach Police Department property receipt 202L10.11
3501.000010 Hotline notes 2021.10.11
3501.000011 Hotline notes 2021.10.11
3501.000012 Hotline notes 2021.10.11
3501.000013 Hotline notes 2021.10.11
3501.000014 20200843 Me intake repot an us) 2021.10.11
3501.000015 2020.0606 RI intake report 2021.10.11
3501.000016 2020.05.10 MI intake report an us) 2021.10.11
3501.000017 2020.0811 MI intake report 2021.10.11
3501.000018 2019.07.01 MI intake report lancoymous) 2021.10.11
3501.000019 2019.07.06 Mti intake report 'anonymous) 2021.10.11
3501.000020 2019.07.06 Mti intake report fan s) 202L10.11
3501.000421 2019.02.8 Mil Intake report 2021.10.11
3501.000022 2019.02.8 FBI Intake report 'anonymous) 2021.10.11
3501.000023 2019.07.09 FBI Intake report 'anonymous) 2021.10.11
3501.000024 2019.07.09 FBI Intake report 'anonymous) 2021.10.11
3501.000025 2019.07.09 MI Intake report (anonymous) 2021.1031
3501.000026 2019.07.03 MI Intake report 'anonymous) 2021.10.11
3501.000027 2019.07.10 MI Intake repot 'anonymous) 2021.10.11
3501.000023 2019.07.10 1W Intake repat 'Numinous) 2021.10.11
3501.000029 2019.07.10 FBI Intake repat lancemnous) 202L10.11
3501.000030 2019.07.09 FBI Intake report lanoromous) 202L10.11
3501.000031 2019.07.10 Mti intake report lanoromous) 202L10.11
3501.000032 2019.07.10 Ma intake report lanoromous) 202L10.11
3501.000033 2019.07.12 Ma intake report lanoromous) 202L10.11
3501.000034 2019.07.11 Ma intake report lemsal [kat 202L10.11
3501.000035 Attachment to FBILMake radon 3501.000034 202L10.11
3501.000036 Attachment to FBILMake radon 3501.000034 202L10.11
3501.000037 2019.07.12 RI intato report lanommous) 2021.10.11
3501.000038 2019.07.13 MI Intake report lanconnous) 2021.10.11
3501.000039 2019.07.11 FBI Intake report lanconnous) 2021.10.11
3501.000010 2019.07.14 FBI Intake repat temail isp) 2021.10.11
3501.000011 2019.07.17 FBI Intake report Illvinerpostl 2021.10.11
3501.000012 Attachment to FBI Intake radon 3501.006032 2021.10.11
3501.000013 2019.07.17 FBI intake report 'hinter oast' 2021.10.11
3501.000044 Attachment to FBI intake radon 3501.200033 202L10.11
3501.000015 Attachment to FBI intake radon 3501.200033 202L10.11
3501.000016 2019.07.31 Ma intake report !anomalous) 202L10.11
3501.000017 2019.0401 Ma intake report !Adrian Addeo) 202L10.11
3501.000418 2019.0601 Ma intake report lanommous) 202L10.11
3501.000419 2019.07.27 Ma intake report lanommous) 202L10.11
3501.000050 2019.08.11 Ma intake report fanconnous) 2021.1011
3501.000051 2019.08.11 Me intake report WY B.) 2021.1031
3501.000052 2019.06.10 He intake repat jancemnous) 2021.10.11
3501.000053 2019.06.17 1W Intake repat lancemnous) 2021.10.11
3501.000054 2019.06.17 1W Intake report lanommous) 2021.10.11
3501.000056 2019.0612 FBI Intake report lanommous) 2021.10.11
3501.000056 2019.06.25 FBI Intake report lanornmous) 2021.10.11
3501.000057 2019.06.28 FBI Intake report lanommous) 202L10.11
3501.000058 2019.06.30 1W Intake report lanommous) 202L10.11
3501.000059 2019.09.10 FBI Intake report lanommous) 2021.10.11
3501.000030 2019.09.11 FBI Inlet* report !anomalous) 2021.10.11
3501.000061 2020.07.02 f IIII Intake report lanommous) 2021.10.11
3501.000062 2020.07.06 FBI Intake report lanornmous) 2021.10.11
3501.000.063 2020.07.06 FBI Intake report lemaa twl 2021.10.11
3501.000.064 Attachment to FBI make report 3501.BOO63 2021.10.11
3501.000.065 2020.07.03 FBI intake report lanen,mous) 2021.10.11
3501.000066 2020.07.10 Ma intake repot lancenmous) 2021.10.11
3501.000.067 Attachment to FBI intake report 3501.000066 202L10.11
3501.000038 Attachment to FBI intake recoil 3501.000066 202L10.11
3501.000039 Attachment to FBI intake repan 3501.000066 202L10.11
3501.000.070 2020.07.10 Ma intake report !anomalous) 202L10.11
3501.000071 Attachment to FBI intake radon 3501.000070 202L10.11
3501.000.072 Attachment to FBI intake radon 3501.000070 2021.10.11
3501.000073 Attachment to FBIintake radon 3501.000070 2021.10.11
3501.000074 2020.07.11 Ma intake report !anonymous) 2021.10.11
3501.000.075 Attachment to FBI /Make report 3501.010074 2021.1011
3501.000076 2020.07.12 illti intake report 'anonymous) 2021.1011
3501.000077 2020.07.15 FBI Intake roped 'email tip) 2021.10.11
3501.000078 2020.07.17 1W Intake repat )anonymous) 2021.10.11
3501.000079 2020.07.16 Me intake repat fans) 2021.10.11
3501.000080 2020.07.26 MI intake report 202L10.11
3501.000481 2020.07.27 Ma intake report 'anonymous) 202L10.11
3501.000022 Attachment to FBIintake radon 3501.BOO81 202L10.11
3501000083 Attachment to FBI intake radon 3501.BOO81 202L10.11
3501000034 Attachment to FBI intake moon 3501.00D-031
WA
202910.11
3501.0000/5 2020.07.29 FMintake report 'anonymous) 202910.11
3501.000036 2020.07.29 FMintake report 'anonymous) 202910.11
3501.000037 2020.01503 FMintake report 'anonymous) 202910.11
3501.000093 2019.07.044 Memo to filt regarding Todd LNU 202910.11
3501.000093 2020.11.10 tenet from 2021.10.11
3501.000090 thew& 3501000126 Anommous Hotline TOs 2021.lOll
3501.000127 FAySpxo oroNe 2021.10.11
350140-0123 2019.07.01 Handmitten rotes 2021.10.11
350140-0129 2021.0.23 Not  from call 2021.10.11
3501.000-130 2021.09.27 Emal then 2021.10.11
3501.000.131 elancheritten rotes 202910.11
3501.000.132 Widen( report 202910.11
3501.000.133 Handwritten rotes 2021.10.11
3501.000434 Handwritten rotes 2021.10.11
3501.000435 2020.07.13 volcano' 2021.1-025
3501.000436 2020.07.29 Email do 2021.1-025
3501.00013) 2021.06.01 Volcano' 2021.1-025
3501.000.133 21121.06.13 Voicemal 2021.1-025
3501.000139 20211-003 1W treaterepof lanantwiou0 2021.1-025
3501.000.140 20211-003 1W report 'anonymous) 2021.1-025
3501400-141 letter 2021.1-025
3501400-142 Nandmitten rotes 2021.1-025
3501.000143 eUndmitten rotes 2021.1-025
3501.000144 elanclanitten rotes 20291-025
3501.000-145 2021.10.111 1W report Ian s) 2021.11.06
3501.001 Data Desatirnoa Attorney Produced to Defense
350100/001 2007.09.15
Florida Dopanment et eighway Safety & motet Vehides
(DAV.I.D)Inciondoal Summary P* 0 for N/A 2021 0411
3501.002 Data Data Attorney ProducedtoDarns
3501402 031 2035.11.17
Florida Dopanment of hwa Safety & Motor Vehicles IndlyCluat
Sunman Page for
WA
2021.04.12
3501402 002 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Pence Department Incident Report 2021.04.12
3501.002 CO3 2006.09.01 Palm Beach PanmDap30 IIncidentReport 2021.04.12
3501402.001 201907 13 tervieur 302 2021.04.12
3501402 CCG 2019.07.13 nteryiew No es 2021.04.12
3501.002 005 IOOS.li21 Not  from ate eel 2021.07.23
35014,02-007 2019.07.13 Intenders/ 300 2021.07.23
3509003 Date DesatPtIon Attorney Produced to Delores
3501.003-001 2008.06.06
Florida OnearIntent of WAIrsavSaftcv & Moto.- Vehides lectveual
Summary Page for 2021.04.12
1501403 002 2009.06.06 Search Record 2021.04.12
3501403 003 2009.07.21 tenet from 2021.04.12
3501403-010 Search Record 202110.11
3501403-005 2000.02.04 Emat frees 202110.11
3501403 006 2009.07.10 Letter from 202910.11
3501403-007 200909.02 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501.003-003 2008.12.05 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501.006 Data Description Attorney Produced to Deform
3501004 001 2007.0227 Testinwerr of
WA
202101 12
3501404 002 2007.10.04 Law Enforcement Report Regarding 2021.0912
3501.004.033 2007 10.10 intaYleor 302 2021.04.12
3501404-001 2007.10.10 Intavenv Steen 2021.41912
3501404-005 2007.10.12 Panetta to 2021.01.12
3501404-006 2009.02.25 Palm Beach PolcaDtpartment Inteligencelteoon 2021.01.12
3501404-007 200903.24 VklIrn Us( 2021.01.12
3501.004-003 2006.04.29
Florida Department of Ferny Safety & Motor Yehkles Inevidual
Aallreary rage for 2021.04.12
3501404.009 2006.04.29 Search Record for 2021.04.12
3501404-010 2009.04.29
Florida Department of isehvay Safety & Motor Vehicles Inevidual
Summary Page for 2021.04.12
3501004-011 2009.04.29 Search Record for 2021.04.12
35014304012 2000.07.03 VkIlm Us( 2021.01.12
35014304013 2009.07.21 Letter from to 2021.01.12
35014304014 2000.12.04 FW report re: Victim Assistance Program 2021.01.12
35014304-015 2000.12.10 1W report dooamentIng infcanatlor 2021.01.12
35014304016 2019.07.23 1W report documenting caeca with 2021.0912
3501430.017 Photographs aflame Does 1.19 2021.04.12
35014304013 2007.10.10 1W report dooimentIng intetvwe 2021.07.23
3501404-019 2007.10.12 1W repot documenting -letter 2021.07.23
350100.020 2019.07.10 1W report dooamenting (Watt 2021.07.23
3501.009021 2004.03.11 PBPO supplemental report 2021.lOll
3501404022 2007.10.10 302 from Interview 2021.10.11
3501.004.023 2003.07.10 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501404-024 2009.09.02 Loner from 2021.10.11
3501404 025 2008 12 05 Loner from 2021.10.11
3501004 026 2019.06.13 Memorandum from call mth 2021.10.11
3501.004 02/ elandmitten notes 2021.10.11
3501.005
Randy 4npar0 Date OfeCliptiell Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.005.001 2019.08.13 Randy Ampaeo Interview 302
WA
2021.01.12
3501405.002 2019.08.13 Randy Amato IMerveye Naos 2021.01.12
1866 Data Dinalplion Mornay Produced to Defense
3501406001 2006.03.09 Florida DAV.I.D.Indhidual Summary Page for
Tatiana Martins
2021.01.12
3501006 002 21106.03.09 Florida DAVID. ..steeled Darer Memo AelMty bra 2021.04.12
35011307 Date Desalption Attorney Produced tog/Sense
3501.00? 031 2019.0613 Internee 302
WA
2021.04.12
3501.00? 0)2 2019.0613 Internee Notes 2021.04.12
3501.007033 2019.0313 Rec of Internee 2021.06.12
3501.007 023 2019.08.22 FM cancel documenting recording of interview 2021.01.12
3501.007 036 2019.08.27 FM cancel regarding 2021.01.12
3501407406 2019.08.27 Widen( Summary Report 2021.01.12
3501407.007 2019.0817 Widen( Summary Report 2021.04.12
3501.007-00B 2019.0817 RecorOeg of phone call to F81 2021.04.12
3501007-009 2019.0627 Text fiercer/See statement 2021.07.23
350100)010 21119.0627 FBI report document Mamoru 2022.07.23
3501.006 Date DesalptIon Attorney Produced to Defense
3501408-001 2019.0613 AWN**. 302
Daniel Caw ,
2021.04.12
3501408 002 2019.0613 AWN**. Notes 2021.04.12
3501408.003 2019.0613 FBI report regarding 2021.04.12
3501008-004 2019.07.12 nterview 302 2021.07.23
3501.009
Mark WI
Date DesalptIon Attorney Produced to Defame
3591 009 0)1 2006.0).13 Palm Beach Ponce Department Incident men WA 2021 64.11
3506010 Date DesalptIon Attorney ProducedtoDraw
3501 010 031 2006 07 13 Palm Beach Ponce Department incident report N/A 2021.04.12
Janusz Dana's/at Date Dawle. Atbdney Produced to Defense
3501.011 0)1 2005.10.18 Florida DAY.I.D. indindial Summary page for Janusz Banaslat
WA
2021.04.12
3301011032 2006.05.01 Probabe Cause Alhdavn Regarding fencer Epstein 2021.04.12
3501411.003 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Police Oepartment Incident Report 2021.04.12
3501.011.001 2006.12.04 Law Enforcement Retort Regarding Janusz Banana 2021.04.12
3501011-00.5 _2006.12.04 Florida DAVID. Indhokial Summary page for Janusz Banaslat 2021.04.12
3501411.006 200612.01
Florida DAV.I.D.Mtranet Records Information System page for
Janusz Banasialc 2021.01.12
3501011.007 2006.12.04 Research report regards" g Janusz Banasiak 2021.01.12
3501011-00B 2007.01.11 lanum Sanas,* Interview 302 and notes 2021.06.12
3501.011409 2007.01.22 Janusz Banastik Interview report 2021.01.12
3501011.010 2007.01.24 tenet from e ll. to Mk Kiel Sdnck 2021.116.12
3501011.011 2007.02.02 Petty cash records for Janusz Ban.rak 2021.01.12
3501011.012 2007.0102 Janusz Sanas,* Interview 302 2021.06.12
3501011.013 2007.01.02 Janusz BariasUlc Interview Notes 2021.06.12
1501411414 2007.01.01 FBI report regarding Janusz Banasiat interview 2021.04.12
3501411-015 2007.01.06 Transcnpl of estimony 2021.04.12
3501411-016 2007.05.30 Transcript of tesWnony 2021.04.12
3501411-017 2007.07.30 -Declaration 2021.04.12
3501411-013 2008.03.13 Court Order from Palm Beath County Coun to Januu Banasiak 2021.01.12
3501411-019 2008.04.29 Testimony of 2021.01.12
3501411-020 2010.01.16 Deposition of Janusz Banailat 2021.01.12
3501.011-021 Janusz Banaslak drovers kens. 2021.06.12
3501411-022 2005.10.28 Florida DAV.I.D. Mdinckra1 Summary page for Janusz Banasia 2021.07.23
3501411-023 2005.12.23 Car rental receipt 2021.07.23
3501411-024 2006.01.11 Memo from Michael sanct to DaIah Weiss re; Janusz Banasiat 2021.07.23
3501.011-025 2006.01.30 Car rental records 2021.07.23
3501411-026 2007.01.22 FBI report dooimentIng Manion with Janusz Banarsak 2021.07.23
3501411-027 2007.02.01 Fea tepee documenting intervssa with Janusz Banarsak 2021.07.23
3501411-023 2010.01.10 Decosibon exhibit 1 2021.07.23
3501411-029 2010.0116 Oen exhibit 2 2021.07.23
3501411-030 2010.02.16 Deposition exhibit 3 2021.07.23
3501411 031 2010.02.16 Deposition exhibit 4 2021.07.23
3501411 032 201620.19 Deposition exhibit 5 2021.07.23
3501.012
Illdiard gamete
Date Dwaine. Attorney Produced to Debase
3501.012 031 2019.07.29 Richard Barnett Interview 302
N/A
2021.01.12
1501.012-002 2019 07 29 Richard Barnett Interview notes 2021.01.12
3501412 033 2019.09.16 Richard Barnett interview 302 2021.04.12
3501012004 2019.09.16 Richard Barnett Interview notes 2021.04.12
3501412 036 2019.09.16 Richard Barnett proffer ageernent 2021.04.12
3506013 Date Description Mangy ProducedtoDefense
3501.013.031 2007.06.04 ir!en NZVI 1 2021.04.12
3501413-002 2007.06.04 Jr. c . c Z 2021.01.12
3501.013-003 2007.06.12 Repot on IIIIONIOIV Of
3501.014 Date Delalplinn
3501114 C01 2004.0124 Victim list
3501.014 002 20060312 Florida DAV.I.D.Indisidui Summary PC 10,
3501414 003 2006.05.01 Pro0able Cause Affl0ave Regarding Milroy Epstein
3501.014O01 2006.07.13 Peen Beach Police Department incident Report
3501.014005 2006.0727 Florida DAVID. Individual Summary P br
3501.014006 2006.08.02 Law enforcement report for
3501.014007 2006.08.02 Search recall for
3501414O18 2006.08.08 FBI roped dooamenting Halm Information
3501414-009 2006.03.11 Letter from to
3501414-010 2006 08.16 ass, went Mttory
3501.014011 2006.08.26 Palm Beach Police Department 04dence./Property Trxkiret Report
3501014011 2006.08.28 Palm Beach Police Department Property Retool
3501.014013 2006 0831 interview 302
3501.014014 2006.08.31 internew notes
3501.014015 2006 09.31-InteMew
3501.014.016 2006.09.01 FBI long to
3501.014017 2006.10.03 1.116034*0 38*
3501.014018 2006 10.03 MY51,340 Page
3501414019 2007.02.016 Transcript of -testimony
3501.014 020 2007.0212 Florida DAV.1.D. mdMdual Summary Page lot
3501414'021 2007.02.27 Transcript of estimony
3501.014'022 2007.03.15 Letter from to
3501.014 023 2007.03.15 intend** 302
3501414'024 200703.15 inteiview notes
3501414'025 2007.03.16 interview report
3501414'026 2007.03.21 FS late to
3501.014 027 2007.05.01 Transcript of estimony
3501.014 028 2007.05.22 Transcript of *steno
3501.014 029 2007.05.31 MySpace Page
3501.014030 2007.06.11 FBI child exploitation imestietion notes/anal is
3501.014031 2007.06.11
Flonda DAV.1.D. Motor Vete,. Status fee lute 12..
3501.014'032 2007.06.12 Rectal search for
3501414 033 2007.06.12 National Comprehensive Report 0
3501414 034 200707.20 Florida DAVID indindal Summary Pao" lot
3501414'035 2007.11.28 FS chit, caplottationlowestIgation notes/analysis
3501414'036 2007.11.12 FS reot.c-4 for travel to conduct intervsom
3501414'037 2008.03.17 Notice ol depanion of o
3501.014 038 2008.03.18 transcnp: of estimony
3501414039 2008.04 29 Transcnpt of
3501414010 2008.07.03 Victim List
3501.014011 2008.0311 Letter from to
3501.014012 2008.21.09 Later from to
3501414-043 2008.12.04 FB, memorandum rear 01 idden aWHanceprowam
3501414014 2008.12.04 FS memorandum regarding Movie., offer
3501.014045 2000.12.04 FS memorandum regarding communication %WM
3501.014016 201907.23
ES OOCUMentatIO0 reganlng attempted contact voth
3501.014017 2019.10.15 InteMew 302
3501.014 018 2019.10.15 InteMew notes
3501.014 019 birth certificate
3501.014 050 Prestos of lane Does 1-19
3501.014 051 Idenlifymg information
3501414052 Flsotographs of victims
3501414053 2006.02.14 Ando f 114 (full Upe recorcirc side Al
3501014054 2006.02.14 Ando filo (clip of tape wonting!
3501.014055 2006.02.14 Ando ON (06e B of lap) recording:
3501.014 056 2006.08.01 FBI report documeoting victim information
3501.014 057 2006.08.31 FEti report dowmenting 80ervlew with Ill
3501.014058 2006.09.01 PS repot dooamenting letter to
3501.014059 200703.16 FEti report dooamenting vectors with
3501.014.060 200703.21 FBI report dooamenting loner to
3501.014.061 2007.11.28 FBI report dooamenting Haim information
3501414062 2019.12.04 FBI report dooamentingvictIm information
3501414.063 201907.10 FBI report dooamenting attempted contact with
3501.014.064 varlets Venous search results and records rogardin
3501414.065 200703.15 Letter from
3501.014056 2008.05.19 (mat from lay leikavitz
3501.014'067 2009.06.19 Stbmission to the DAG
3501.014'068 2008.07.10 toiler from
3501014 059 2008.09.02 toiler from
3501414 070 2019.06.13 Memorandum from call loth
3501414'071 Money transfer record
3501414'072 2008.05.19 Letter fromiPen Starr anti Joe Whitley
3501.014 073 Handesitten notes
3501.015 Date Descriptlea
3501.015.001 2006.07.13 Pad Beach Pence Department incident Report
3501415.002 2006.07.27 Florida DAVID. clover Icense tranwaten page Ice
3501415003 2006.08.02 Search retool fo
35014315011 2006.0601 Law enforcement report Ice
WA 2021.04.12
ProducedtoDefense
2021 0.1 11
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.0422
2021.0422
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202304.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202304.12
202304.12
2021.0812
2021.0812
2021.0812
2021.0812
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.0422
2021.0422
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202304.12
2021.41812
2021.0412
202304.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202304.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.0422
2021.0422
2021.0422
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10 15
Produced toDefense
2021.04.12
2021.41812
2021.41812
2021.41812
Attorney
WA
Attorney
3501015.005 2006.08.08 lea memorandum to cbconent victim informabon
3501015.006 200608.11 Letter from to
3501015407 2006.08.16 Assignment NUNN for
3501015.008 2006.0818 Palm Beach Pence Department Property newel
3501015.009 2007.02.01 totter Item Gould Lefeourt to and
3501.015010 2007.12.11 letter to Alnander Acosta
3501015011 2006.02.03 Video Op of intervbsa
3501015012 2006.02.03 Video dip of i nzervbra
3501015013 2006.02.03 Video dip of inzervbre
3501015014 2006.02.03 Video dip of inter./We
3501015015 2006.02.03 Video dip ohntervem
35010.15016 2007.02.01 Latter from Geoid Lelcourt
3501016 Date Desolation
3501.016001 2020.06.19 nOniew notes
35010164302 2020.10.15 nOniew rotes
3501016003 2020 06.19 302
3501016024 21/21/10.15 302
3501.016.005 Voieernal
3501.017 Date Desolation
3501 017 CO1 2020 1023 interview 302
350/017002 202010.23 interview notes
350L032 Date Desolate
3501.018 031 2007.02.27 Sallower, of
3501 018.032 2007 10.05 intone:se 302
3501018003 2007.1009 solo solophme intense,.
3501.01803.
3501018.005
21:00_._an.t o
2008.01.08 search and Imartas
3501.018 0)5 2008.01.08 Law enforcement repot rtgardina
3501018007 2008.02.06 rEd memorandum regarding investigation leads
3501018078 2008.02.06 SW memorandum for interview of
3501.018 009 2008.03.20 interview notes
3501.018 010 2008.03 20 interview 302
3501.018 011 2008.03.21 Email reptdog
3501.018 012 2008.03.21 SW memorandum regarding Movies of
3501.018 013 2008.03.25 intercom notes
3501.018 014 2008.03.25 interview 302
3501018.015 2008.03.26
1W memorandum regarding telephone conmuNcazion with
3501.018.016 2008 03.27 RI memorandum to cover load set Oy Miami division
3501.018.017 2008.03.27 Hill memorandum totems lead set to lAlarni &Neon
3501018018 2008.00.02 lea memorandum to document intenose of
3501.018 019 2019.01.30 intercom 302
3501.018.020 201901 30 intercom notes
3501018.021 intercom notes
3501.018.022 note-
3501018.023 2007.10.09 1W memorandum to doeuNent intercew of
3501018.024 2007.10.09 NU memorandum to doctment imenteye or
3501018.025 2008.02.06 Ka memorandum to Oxurnent lead set
3501018026 2008.03.24 Ka memorandum to do anent Linen...v. of
3501.018.027 2008.03.24 Ka memorandum to do anent Linen...v. of
3501018.022 2008.03.26 Hill memoranda., to document Lntercem of
3501018029 2008.03.26 He memoranda., to document Lntercam of
3501.018023 2007.10.05 302 from InteMew
3501.018.031 2008.03.20 302 from InteMew
3501418.032 2008.03.25 302 from InteMew
3501.019 Date Decolption
3501.019001 2020.11.OJ nternew 302
3501019002 2020.11.04 ',Mlle.?. MOWS
3501.019.033 Nato: regarding
3501.019.001 teach
3501.019.005 2008.05.06 Law enforcement repot regardin
3501019.005 2019.07.11 Text messages with agent
3501.021) Dote Oescrip0on
3501 020 001 2020.07.30 SW memoraneken regarding subpoena sonice to
3501.020 OO2 2020.08.03 Notes from phone call with Alan Goelman
350/020073 2020.08.12 Interview 302
3501020004 2020.08.12 Interview notes
3501.001 Date Disolptlen
3501021001 20203/1.08 interview 302
3501022002 202001.08 ..=. interview notes
3501022003 202002.06 M=. interview 302
35010230/1 202002.06 WiterdOW ra tes
3501022 Date Desolate
35010.21001 2019.10.23 -Interview 302
N/A
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
ProducedtoDefense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.25
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202101.12
202101.12
202101.12
2021.0612
2021.0612
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.0612
2021.0612
202101.12
202101.12
202101.12
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202101.12
2021.09.12
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
202104.12
2021.01.12
2021.0112
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
Attorney
NIA
NIA
Attorney
N/A
Attorney
N/A
Attorney
Atan Geeleran
AttOffi•V
N/A
Atterniry
3503.022402 2019.10.23 -Intervnwnote 2021.04.12
Gre•Illarbei
Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3503.023.003 2019.0722 Greg Bledsoe Into 2
Wa
2021 03 12
35/1023002 3019.0E 22 Greg Bledsoe Interne not 2021 C4 12
3501.020
16 buds Date Description Attorney ProducedtoOdense
3.024.001 3008.00.30 National ccowrehenslv¢RePOM fa iri Bosons Wa 2021.04.12
350LCOS Date DesalptIon Attorney Producedto0e3ense
3501.02504 through 062 Various sans records for
WA
2021 C4 12
3501025053 2006 07 13 Pan Beach Police Meant incident Report 2021.01 12
3503.025.064 2007.06.02 Search result for 2021.04.12
3501 25.065 2006 06.08 10 memorandum to document Nalm inlomiation 2023 04.12
3501025-066 2006.06.01 Letter from to 2021.04.12
3501.025067 2006.0226 Palm Beach Pence Department Evidence/Properly Tracking Report 2023.04.32
3501025068 2006.06.06 Pam Beach PoIceDepartrn n Property Rtecpt 2021 04.32
3501.025069 2007.12.11 Letter to AleroneW Kota 2023.04.12
3501.025070 Notre abou 2021.04.12
3501025071 Inrious Boirjaphkeal Dia for 2021.04.12
3501025072 2005.03.36 Audio flit (side A of tape recorang: 2021.07.23
3501025073 2005.03.16 Oudot et (side II of tape recording: 202107.23
3503.025074 2005.30.21 Florida DAV.I.D. eidnielual Summary Pate to 202107.23
3501026075 2005.1113 National Comprehensive Report for 2021.07.23
3501025076 2005.1115 Audoteafull tape recordt61 2021.07.23
3503.025077 2005.13.35 Audio tik. (clip of tape wording! 2021.07.23
3501025073 2006.08.02 National Comprehensive pen for 2021.07.23
3501026079 2006.0604 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501.025@0 2005.13.35 NW* 3lnupldenuIcatlor 2021.10.11
3501.016 Date Description Attorney Produced to Odense
1. 2019.09.18 ntavnw 302
Gem Al1-ed
2021.04.12
3503.026-002 2019 09 18 mtervMwnotet 2021 04 12
3503026003 2019.11.19 WI complaint 2021.04.12
3501.026-004 2019 09 0 (mad 2021 10.25
3501.027 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3503.027 031 2019 09 18 ntoMew 302
6taria All•ed
2021 04 12
3501 27.032 2039.09.18 InteMew notes 2021.04.12
3501.020 Date Daalption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.028.001 2020.08.17 I inlemew302
WA
2021 04.12
3501.028-002 2020.08.17 Interview note: 2021 04 12
3501.028.003 2020.07.13
(mai Iran to the UnitedStatesAttorneys Ottke for
the Southern District cf Now York 20210112
3503.028 003 2020.07.17 Email Nan 2021.10.25
3503.029 Data DesalptIon Attorney Produced to Defense
1.029 C01 2007.07.11 Flaka DAV.I.D. Endive:1w, Summary Page for
WA
2021.03.12
3503 29.002 2007.07.11 Gong Senthillf 2021.0432
3501.029-003 2007 07 11 Lawenforce/rant report regarding 2021 04 12
3501030 Date DescriPtion Attorney Produced to Defense
3503 030-031 2019 1016 interview 302
WA
2021.04.12
3503.030002 2019.10.16 lifitervICW flOtt”, 2021.04.12
3503 0003 203905.37 regarding cal IT and 2021.07 23
3 030 CO4 2019.06.13 Memorandum regardox call wrh and 2021.07 23
1.030 035 2008.32.06 Letter 2021.10.11
3501 030 COS 2019 I 16 Text s ith new 2021 1 II
3501.031 Date DetatPtion Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3503031002 2007. 04 InteMew rates
WA
2021.0212
3503031002 2007.06.04 in Mew JOI 2021.04.12
3503031403 2007.06.33 ID ndosn ol into." 2023.04.32
3501.031.001 2008.03.24 Court order from Palm Beath COUIMV Court to 2021.04.12
3501.032
Jean Luc anal
Date DescriPtion Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501032.001 007.08.15 Law enforcenwit repot regarding lean Luc &Uhl
Wa
2021.04.12
3503.032 032 007.0215 El a DAV.I.D ySial s Pats rc gafel Jean We Brunel 2023.01.32
3503.032 CO3 3019.07.08 terv - .. 302 2021.04.12
3501.083 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3503.033.001 2019.10.23 Menus?. 302
WA
3503.033402 2019.10.23 Interview notes 2021 OA 12
3501.034
Tacktry Bryan Ate Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501034001 2007.02.27 Tenemerged
WA
2021.04.12
3501.034002 21)07.05.01 Florida DAV.I.D.Indincea Summa P for Zachary Bryan 21)21.04.12
3501.035
Michael
Date DiescrilMon Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501 035 COI 201907 C6 MiCiael intense.. 302 WA 2021 C4 :2
3501.036
Linos Ca0oaay Date DeS01 01510 Attar! ity Produced to Odense
3501.036001 2020.09 10 Lance Holloway internee 302
N/A
2021.04.12
3501036.002 2020 09 10 tame Holloway InteMew notes 2021.01.12
3501.036 003 2020.09 03 Emals with agents 2021.10.11
3501.037 Date Dasalplien Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.032001 2019.0826 intonate/ 302 2021.04.12
3501.0374302 2019.08.26 nIerview nolo. 2021.01.12
3501037003 oholograohs 2021.03.12
350L038 Date Descriptioa Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.038 COI 2007.07.02 Imorwcw males
N/A
2021.04.12
3501.038 002 2007.07.02 imerwee 302 2021.01.12
3501.038 0)3 2007.0702 183 memotandtm notes roaming- interview 2021.04.12
3501 038 004 2007.07 02 Florida DAVID. Individual Summary Page for 2021.04.12
3501.039
Gullherme Castellano Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
35)1039 NI 2008.05.20 National Comprehensive Report for Gullherme Castelar4 WA 2021.04.12
3501.040
Data Ossalptke Attorney Produced to Dakar
3501.040001 21)07.02.27 iestinwny of
Sleld MoCaeley
2021.03.12
3501.040002 2007.06.25 Florida DAV.I.D.Indhickiii Surornaiy Page br 21)21.0412
3501.040003 2007.06.25 Florida DAV.I.D. mdMdual Summary Page lot 2021.04.12
3501.040011 2007.06.25 Florida DAV.I.D. Photo tine Up for 2021.01.12
3501.040005 2007.06.25 Flores DAV.I.D.A0cIrr-s ?Motivation for 2021.04.12
3501.040.005 2007 10.19 ireermew notes 2021.01.12
3501.040037 2007.10.19 iroternew 302 2021.01.12
3501.040038 2007.11123 IMOPMVI notes 2021.04.12
3501440039 2008.01.10 FBI lotto' to 2021.04.12
3501440010 2008.03.24 Victim list 2021.04.12
3501.040011 2008.0410 letter from to Jeffrey Herman 2021.04.12
35014340012 2008.04.21 letter from Stuart Mermelstein to lack Goldberger 2021.04.12
2008.04.29
&
2008.03.38 intim:my of 2021.01.12
3501.040014 2008.07.03 Victim lest 2021.04.12
3501.040015 2008.07.10 from Jeffrey Merman 2021.01.12 letter to
Fil!memorandten id
3501.040016 2018.12.03 2021.04.12
regarding entavet,
'Mot/nation
3501.040017 Various ktogta0hocal file 2021.04.12
3501.040018 tient informabon 2021.04.12
3501040019 2007.11123 MI report documenting interview with 2021.07.23
3501.040020 2008.01.30 FBI report documenting letters to victms 2023.07.23
3501440021 2008.07.30 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501440022 2008.1)9.02 Letter from 2021.1011
3501440023 2008.12.05 Letter from 2021.1011
35011111 Date Description Attorney Producod to Debase
3501041-031 2019.1)&13 intervLev. 302
WA.
2021.0.1.12
3501.041 022 2019.08.13 ,n, 41%.4'. metes 2021 03 12
3501.042 Date DiesalPtIrm Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.042.001 2019.07.10 Crisis intake report regaiding
Stria McCaMev
2021.04.12
3501.042002 2019.08.28 intemew 302 2021.04.12
3501.042403 2019.08.28 Illtenotev. notes 2023.0412
3501.042011 2019.07.14 Emal Iran- 2021.1011
3501.042005 2019.07.23 Emal re re 2021.10.11
3501.042406 2019.09.11 Emal regarding 2021.10.11
3501.042037 2019.09.11 Final from 2021.10.11
3501.042038 2019.09.12 Final from 202L10.11
3501.042039 2019.09.26 Final from 202L10.11
3501.042010 2019.09.28 Emal from 202L10.11
3501.042011 2021.09.13 Emal than 202L10.11
3501.042012 2021.09.13 Emal than 2021.10.11
3501042013 2021.09.13 Emal than 2021.1011
3501.043 Date Ossalplfan Attorney Produced to  WORM
3501043031 2019.07.31 Internee 302
WA
2021.04.12
3501.043402 2019.07.31 Internee notes 2021.04.12
3501.0.4 Data Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501 044 0)1 2007.1009
Florida DAY.I.D. InclitiO4.1 Summary page for
WA 2023.04.32
3508045 One Ossolpdan Attorney Produced to Del ens*
3501.045 033 2019.0724 Waylay 302 2021.64.12
3501.045 002 2019.07.14 interview Notes 2021.04.12
3501.045033 2019.0607 Movies/ 301 2023.04.32
35014346004 2019.0507 Movies/ Notes 2023.04.32
3501.045-005 2019.0820 Movies/ 301 2023.04.32
3501.045-006 2019.0820 Movie./ Notes 2023.04.12
3501.045-007 2019.10.16 interview 301 202804.12
3501-045-008 Photograph 202L04.12
3501.045039 Photograph 20280812
35011345010 Photograph 2021.0812
35011345011 2019.07.31 FBI intake report 202L07.23
35011345012 2019.10.29 FBI intake report 202807.23
3501045013 2019.07.10 FW report 2021.10.11
3501445 014 2019.07.10 Law enforcement report 2021.10.11
3501.045 015 2019.07.19 License toroth 2021.10.11
3503.O4 Date Description Attorney Produced to Odense
3501 046 031 2007.1009 Florida DAN.I.D.iodntdual tunmon 048u lot WA 2021 03 12
3501.047 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.047 003 2006.01.01 bi raohical information
N/A
2021.-01.12
3501.047 002 2006.07.31 Palm Beach PoliceDepartment material *mutts statement 2021.04.12
3501.047033 2006.07.31 Photo Inc upinstructions 20280812
3501.0470n 2006.08-01 Palms ScroontSregarckg 2021.04.12
3501.017-005 2006.0501 Florida DAVI.D.Indhi0.-01 &oniony Ono regarding 2023.04.32
3501.017-005 2006.06.07 Pan Beach Ponce Otparrtnent !olden report 2023.04.32
3501.047-007 2006.0608 FW mammoths" documenting victim Information 2023.04.32
3501.047-008 2006.08.08 r unite inforination 2021.04.12
3501.047.039 2006.0331 Letter from from Alogancler Acosta 202804.12
3501047010 2007.04.24 Cad Cal information 202801.12
3501047011 2006.01.10 Fla Into to 202804.12
3501047012 20011.01.10 vkarn rghts 302 2023.04.12
3501047013 2006.03.24 Maim list 202804.12
3501047014 2008.07.03 Maim list 2021.04.12
3501.042015 2008.07.23 Letter from Alearao Aco;:a to 2021.04.12
3501.042016 2006.12.12 vX0rn nlormation 302 2021.04.12
3501.047.017 Binh cern, tate 2023.04.32
3501017.018 Various 2023.04.32 Biographical fib co
3501447-019 2001.0608 1113 CAD Cal Information 2023.07.23
3501047020 2006.07.28 Florida DAtI.D.Incliticlual 2021.07.23 gonna or.. 'I
3501.047 021 2006.06.02 Florida DAY.I.D. Indlyiclual 2021-07.23 unmoor page regarding
Report regarding 3501.047 022 2006.01106 National comprehensive 202807.23
3501.047 023 2006.01.10 FW report doo.rmenting inters to Warns 202807.23
3501.047 02,1 2006.07.33 Pugs° file 2021.07.23
350104702$ 2006.07.31 Notc-: from mooting with_ 2021.10.11
3501.047 026 2006.01104 toner from 2021.10.11
3501.047 027 2007.06.07 toner from 2021.10.11
3501.047 028 2007.06.07 letter fr om 2021.10.11
3501.047 029 2008.07.30 letter from 2021.10.11
3501.047 030 2008.09.02 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501.047 031 2008.12.03 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501.046 Date DesaVBen Attorney Produced so Defies*
3501.048 033 2007.07.23 People search foe
WA
2021.0.12
3501048-00 2007.07.23 Florida DAVID. indedthsal summary pa e r rd
regarding
2021.04.12
3501 48033 21307.06.66 Law onforoment report 20281)812
3501.049 Date Desofption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.049 033 2007.07.23
W
2021 01.12 Person search for
3501 049 002 2007.0806 Law enforcement report regarding- 2021 0/ 12
3501.050 Data Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
1501.050033 2007 1 09 Florida DA1/ I D. wdMdual tunmant page for Wa 2021 04 12
3501.051 Data Desolation Attorney ProducedtoDebase
3501.051 033 2019 07 17 offer eement 2021 0.1 12
3501 51032 2019.07.17 interview 302 2021.04.12
3501 51-003 21319.07.17 interview notes 2021.04.12
3501.051.004 21119.07.30 CMN Intake report regarding 2023.07.23
3503.052 Date Desolation Money Produced to Defense
1501.052-033 2006.1 18 Florida DAVID dtal tunmary pa efa
WA
2021 04 12
3501 52 002 2006.10.18 Florida DAVID. dual tunrnan, page for 2023.04.32
3501.052-003 2020.12.04 Search mood re 202811812
3501.063 Date DesertPtIon Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.053031 2019.07.01 ,n:trvrtd. WOCCart
WA
2021.04.12
3501453.002 2019.07.01 .rtItiVrt" ieroc0re 2021.04.12
3501.053403 2019.07.01 interVero record 2021.04.12
3501.0530M 2019.07.01 unervew recordne 2021.04.12
3501453035 2019.07.24 OIG initial repan 2021.04.12
3501453.006 2019.0817 interview 302 2021.04.12
3501453.007 2019.08.27 1.11001101011101“ 2021.04.12
3501453.008 2019.06.19 Business Lint Report for 2021.07.23
3501453039 2019.06.19 Law Enforcement Report regarded 2021.07.23
3501453-010 2019.06.19 Contact Card Report regardn; 2021.07.23
3501453-011 2019.07.02 Typed notes from interview 2021.07.23
3501.053 022 2019.06.26 Text Message:with agent 2021.1011
3502054 Date Desatpaan Attorney Produced to 0eiense
3501.054 001 2006.09.01 Palm Beach Pa3m0eparm¢nt Incident Report
Grit Alko
2021.04.12
3501.054.032 2019.07.31 witorview 302 2021.04.12
3501454.033 2019.07.31 intonecw notes 2021.04.12
3501.054.034 2019.07.31 =photos pecreded during interview 2021.04.12
3501.051.035 2019.08.27 witensme 302 2021.04.12
3501451.006 2019.06.27 Marley notes 2021.04.12
3501.051007 2019.11.21 MU complaint 2021.04.12
3501.051.038 2019.11.21 Inte rv iew 302 2021.04.12
3501.054.039 2019 11 22 Interview notes 2021.04.12
3501.054 010 2020.0014 Documentation of smices 2021.04.12
3501.054 011 202170010 Documentation of smices 2022.04.12
3501.065
Date Desalptlen Attorney ProducedtoDefies*
3501.055.031throuth3501055•068 Various School records for 2022.04.12
3501.065059 2005.04.23 Appantinent notes 2021.04,12
3501455-070 2005.05.21 Incident not >1 2021.04.12
3501455-071 2005.11.09 Palm Beach Pace De cement pro arca 2021.04.12
3501.055-072 2005.11.14 MySpace bt 2021.04.12
3501.056073 2005.11.14 PArSpace bt 2021.04.12
3501.056074 2006.05.01 Pr.:tut/00th* Affidave Regarding fencer Epstein 2021.04.12
3501.055075 2006.07.13 Palm Beach PoliceDepartment Incident Report 2021.04.12
3501.055076 2006.07.13
ketSpace information from Palm Beach Police
Department 2021.04.12
3501.055.077 2006.07.19 Transcnpt of Interview 2021.04.12
3501.055078 2007.07.27 Florida DAVID. indnichal summary pale for 2021.04,12
3501.055.079 2007.06.04 Letter from to 2021.0412
3501.056080 2006.08.05 FBI memorandum to docament Warm information 2021.0412
3501455-061 2006.07'26 Pali Beach Pace °apartment Evidence/Property Trackers Reran 2021.04.12
3501455.062 2006.06.25 Pan Beach Police Department property receipt 2021.04.12
35010554383 2006.09.29 Grand JAN1021101 2021.04.12
3501055W 2006.10.10 interview 302 2021.0412
3501.055.085 2006.10.11 FS memorandum for InteMew of 2021.0412
3501.055066 2007.01.24 Letter Born Gerald Lolcoart to 2021.0412
3501.056067 2007.0227 Tedimenyol 2021.01.12
3501.0560U 2007.03.20 TedImeery ol 2021.0412
3501.0560N 2007.04.06 ES lefief to 2021.0412
3501.055090 2007.05.22 Toslimeeryol 2021.0412
3501455-091 2007.06.11 FBI detailed marsh related to Medication 2021.01.12
3501.055092 2007.06.12 Record search for 2021.0412
3501.056093 2007.07.20 Falional Comprehensive Report for 2021.01.12
3501.055481 2007.11.28 Florida DAVID. indnicksal sunmary page for 2021.04.12
3501.055095 2008.03.20 FBI detailed analysis related to imesligalion 2021.04.12
3501455 096 2008.03.14 Victim lest 2021.0412
3501455 097 2008.03.10 Court Order to 2021.04,12
3501.055.098
2008.04.29
&
2008.03.18 Testimony of 2021.04.12
3501055099 2008.07.03 Victim let 2021.04.12
3501.055403 2008.10.24 Pan Beach County Sheriffs OfficeWarm notification confirmation 2021.0412
3501.055401 2008.10.24
Pro Tech Monitoring. Inc.offender details report regardless Jeffrey
Epstein 2021.01.12
3501.055102 2008.10.24 Notification letter to 2021.01.12
3501455.103 2008.10.24
Pro Tech Monitonng. Inc. offender details report recordersJeffrey
Epstein 2021.0412
3501.055101 2008.11.09 Letter from to 2021.01.12
3501.055405 2018.11.04 FBI memorandum doomentin interueve of 2021.01.12
3501.055406 2018.11.04 FO memorandum doomentin lotto/eve of 2021.04.12
3501.055407 2018.11.04 FID memorandum doomentinewitervbre of 2021.04.12
3501.055408 2018.11.04 Child victim information 2021.04.12
3501455.109 2018.12.04 notional information 2021.04.12
3501455.110 2005.12.06 interyleernotes 2021.04.12
3501455.111 Lin and pnOtO, °flame Dees 1.19 2021.04.12
3501455.112 Various B 'cal fik. co 2021.04.12
3501455.113 Fila Identifying infamation for 2021.04.12
3501.055.114 FID identifying infanution for 2021.04.12
3501.055.115 PhOtOS of victims 2021.04.12
3501.055.116 biograohicaliedonnation 2021.01.12
3501.055.117 2005.11.06 Video MC !full recordin I 2021.07.23

╭──────────────────────── Page 9, Image 1 ─────────────────────────╮
│ EES ae peorer Pediat oben                                        │
│                                                                  │
│ ae meomer edit tobe                                              │
│                                                                  │
│ Ses ae peorey Pediat oben                                        │
│ salto 7.08 paar                                                  │
│ ssoass one pao ny pont                                           │
│                                                                  │
│ SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER PARAGRAPHS 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, and 17 9 │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

3501055118 2005.11.03 Video record Iraardry lclnof tOCOed
3501055119 2005.09.23 Search repo-Vs regarding
3501.055220 2006.05.01 PBPD probable oust anidn regarding MIMI
3501.055221 2006.05.01 PBPD probable oust afficlent regarding
3501.055222 2006.07.20 Letter to -from PBPD
3501055123 2006.10.11 FBI report regarding interview with
3501.055224 2007.13.23 FBI report regarding imestigation and victim informatior
3501055125 2018.12.00 1W repot regarding -Information
3501055126 2018.12.04 FBI repot regarding- information
3501.055227 2018.12.04 F& repot regarding -Information
3501655228 Various Various knySpace pages
3501055129 Various Various search records re al
3501.055.130 Isaac/mitten notes
3501.055.131 Notes regarding Myhre Mkonation
3501055132 2007.05.33 Mv5Dace Doges
3501055133 2008.07.10 letter from
3501.055.134 2008.09.02 Leiter from
3501.055.135 2019.06.13 Memorandum from oil Mth
3501.055.136 Hand...Mien notes
3501.055.137 /image old
3501.55.B31 SroJM___,
Hand mitten rotes 3501055139 200611.08
3501.066
Yea DaLaDui Date Duelptlen
3501.056 001 2019.0731 Merwin DelaCruz interview 302
3501.056 002 2019.0711 Merwin DelaCruz InteMew cowl' shoat
3501056003 2019.07.11 Merwin DelaCruz Interview notes
3501.057 Date Dualptlen
3501.057 C01 CDB Office Pilau nurrixes
3501.057402 20200610 tmsl wsth
3501.0614 Date Desalption
3501.058 003023 Various School records for
3501.058 024 2005.11.15 Palm Beach Police amen( Int*, ONE notes on
3501.058 025 2006.05.01 Wettable Cause Aftdavn Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
3501.058 02,5 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Police Department incident Report
3501.058 027 2006.07.27
Florida DAVID. I ncIntdual sunmary page regarding
IMMII
3501058028 2006.0604 Letter from to
3501.058 029 2006.06.08 Fifa Memorandum to document ‘..ct.m.nfoimation
3501058030 006 0616 ass, wren: history
3501.058 032 2006 011.33 inteniew 302
3501.058 032 2006.08.22 internew 302
3501.058 033 2006.06.26 Pall Beach Peace Department ENdencePropmtylrackslg &von
3501.058 034 2006.06.28 FBI letter to
3501.058 OIS 2006.06.28 Palm Beach Pe00e Department Property Receipt
3501.058 036 2007.02.27 Testimony of
3501.058 037 2007.06.11 FBI detailed analysis pertaining to investigation
3501.058 038 2007.06.32 Recad search for
3501.058 039 2007.06.32 Nitional Canprehenslee Report for
3501.058 OW 2007.07.20 Florida DAS/10.060M leero for
3501.058 041 2002.13.28 FBI detailed ameisis pertaining to extstigation
3501.058 012 2007.12.11 Letter to Aleranckf 8COSta
3501.058013 2008.03.20 Victim list
2008.04.29
&
2008.03.38 Testirricery of
3501.058015 2008.07.03 Victim list
3501.058016 2008.12.00 FBI memoranda." to docarnent mtentee of
3501.058017 2008.12.04 Child victim informatico
3501.058018 2008.12.04 IdentlNlnRWormrbn
3501058049 2019.07.12 Intendew 302
3501058050 2019.07.12 Intendew notes
3 5010 5 8 0 51 Intendew notes
3501.058 052 Lill and photograph ot lane Does 1.19
3501.058 053 Various Biographr.al f ID on
3501.058 054 I:4 Neal Information
3501058-05$ 1110101ot vktims
3501058-056 2005.11.15 Audio f ilt(full tape recording. ideal
_3501058-06) 2005.11.15 Audofiktlip of tape recording:
3501.058 058 2005.11.15 Audo f no (side 11 of tape recordings
3501058-069 2005.11.10
Florida DAVA.D.indrOdual summary page regarding
-
3501058060 2005.11.13 National Comprehensive Report for
3501.058 051 2006.02.09 MyStaace pa n
3501.058 052 2006 05.01 PBPD probable oust affidavit rdin
3501.058 053 2006.05.01 PBPD probable oust affidavit NM
3501.058 054 2006.06.22 FBI report regarding Interview with
3501.058 065 2007.11.211 F. repot regarding imestigalico and victim infomu0or
3501.058 056 2012.12.00 1W report regarding Vdorma0on
3501.05806) Various Various search records regards.'
3501.058068 Handmitten notes
3501.058069 2007.05.33 Atv5pace pates
3501058070 2008.07.30 Letter from
N/A
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2022.07.23
2022.07.23
2023.07.23
2023.07.23
2023.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2022.1011
2021.1015
Produiad toDebase
2023.04.32
2022.04.22
202101.12
Produced to Defense
2021.03.12
2023.0432
ProducedtoDetente
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2023.04.12
2023.0432
2023.0432
2023.04.32
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2023.04.32
2023.04.32
2023.04.32
2023.04.32
2023.04.32
2023.04.32
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202L111.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
2021.07.23
2023.07.23
2023.07.23
2023.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.1011
2022.20.11
Paternal,
X/A
Attorney
Lisa Bloom
Attorney
3501 58.071 2008.09.02 Letter from
3501 58.072 2008 12 08 Letter from
3501 58.073 2019.0613 emorandum from oil With
3501 58.074 Image of
350=59
EMIDebbi Data Ossalplice
3501.059.031 2009.11.16 Emal Iran Eva Dubin to Carmen Sloane
3501.059002 2021.01.19 Notelo Da
3501459403 20210121 Motet* Da
3501059401 20210122 introductory conu¢roaan wet Era Dubin and her casual
3501 59.00S 20210122 Motet* Da
3501.060 ■ Date 11080 108 ,1
3501 031 2001.01.01 -bton Information 302
350106/5002 2 .07. 1 Palm Beach Ponce Department material Wanes, IInament
3501 60003 2006.06.08 FW me orandwn regarding documenting Naim Information
3501 60033 2006.06.0 llm info Val 302
3501 60035 2006.06.31 Letter from to
3501 60005 2006.06.16 nt hal
3501 60007 2007.1 28 encore 302
3501.060038 2007.11.28 efYLCY notes
3501460009 2007.11.29 ocarina as
3501060010 20190709 terater 02
350106/5011 2019.07.12 iroteraver 302
3501060012 201907 12 Wirefahlic ote
3501.060013 bath otetifote
350106/5014 Varlou le
350106/5015 2007.11.29 1W report r rdln ntiwlawwllh
350106150/6 2019 0709 contact 302
350106/5017 202002.10 Toil stage: Rh agent
3501 60.013 2019 07 12 Toil sager. Rh want
3501 60019 W ndr wIto, notes
3501061 Date OssalptIon
061 01 1 2007 20
Florida DAV.I.D.udmdual summary page redarthf,
....
3501.062
Mark 1 eatan Date Desolation
MI 06 031 2009.09.21 Depositional Mark EMten
3501.063 Date Description
1501 6 031 2020.10.27 NMm from call asth
3501.06 .032 2020.1028 m:entcw 302
350146 403 2020.10.28 m:entcw Cote
3509064 Date DesolptIon ■
3501.064 001056 VarIOUt records lot
3501.064.057 2004 12 2 Western Union record
3501 64058 2006.0).13 Pao Beach PoliteDepartment Incident Report
3501 64.059 2006 013.02 RecordtteagN for
3501 64.060 2006.08.08 1W Memorandum to document actin information
3501 64.061 2006.08.11 Letter from -to-
3501.064 2006.08.26 Palm Beath Police Department Evidence/PropertyTrackIng Report
3501.064.053 2006.08.28 Palm Beach Ponce Department Properly Receipt
3501 64.054 2006.09.29 Grand hoe transcripts
3501064065 2007.02.01 letter from Gerald Lefcourt 1
3501064066 2007.02.27 Testi
3501064067 2007.04.25 InMMew 302
3501064068 2007.04.26 InMMew notes
3501.064059 2007.0426 ntenlowarcl FBI Florida materials
3501 64.070 20070430 FW momoandun regarding victim asUstance program
3501 64.071 2007.04.30 FW letter to
3501 64072 2007 04.30 InMMew 302
3501.064.073 2007.04.30 FBI rt mos 1 received from
3501.064074 2007.05.641 Veal of
1464075 2007.05.21 FW memorandum of eftorMw
3501464076 200705.21 Interview 302
3301.064077 2007.05.22 Testinwew of
1.064.0/3 2007 06.11 F81 detailed anrtysis penairenst to anat9gallon
1.064.079 2007.06.12 RecordsuwN for
1501.064.080 2007 04.12 Fl a DAV.I.D.m or ',status foe
1501.064.081 2007.04.12 Florida DAV.I.D.Inforinat n for
1501.064.082 2007 06.12 oral comprthe moan Of
3501464.083 2007.07.20 Floda DAV.I.D.ind dual om ary page foe
o lineup 3501064.084 200707 20 Floda DAV.I.D.oh
3501.064.085 2007.11.28 FBI detailed analysisperla W rr to Ynesligallon
3501 64.086 2007 12.11 Letter tOMPZIlltAf ACOSta
3501 64087 2001.01.31 InMMew 302
3501004488 3001.0101 1W momorandlm docu entin rnetIng
3501464.089 3001.0101 1W document detailing eh
Interview 302 3501.064093 3001.0201
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
AMMO/ ProducedtoDakar
TatianaMartini
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
Attorney ProducedtoDefense
WA
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
Attorney ProducedtoDefense
WA 2021.04.12
Attorney
WA
Produced to Defense
2021 02 :2
Attorney Produced to Detente
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
Attorney Produced to Deltas*
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2023.0112
2023.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2023.04.12
2023.04.12
2023.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
501064 091
501064 092
200802.11 Interview notes
200803.24 Vklim list
2008.04.29
501064 093
3501064 094
501.064 095
501.064096
501.064097
501.064.098
501064.099
2008.03.18
2008.07.03 Vktim list
2008.07.21 letter from to
2008 12 14  SW memorandum  doamenting ntervlsw of
2019.0320 interview 302
2019.03.20
Testimony of
Interview notes
ntmlew notes
.064
501064.101
1064 102
501.064.103
3501464 101
501064.105
501.064.107
501.064.108
501.064.109
50106/110
50106/111
50106/112
50106/113
501.064.114
501.064.115
501.064.116
501.064.117
3501.064.118
3501.064.119
3501064.120
501.064.121
501.064.122
501.064.123
501.064.124
501064.125
List and ca$Otograged of Jane Does 319
Various Biosraphicalfik. for
mteryiew notes
Ftrotos of vknms
Ical Informal'
.1L14 Audo flte(Jull tape recording)
.1L14 Audo fa clip °flape rev dine
.1110 Florida DAVID. dual summary page for
.1L14 IWO 'ten motes
.12.13 Search recce& or
02.09 Space
2006.05.01 Mit probable oust alfdav4 roil
OS.01 NM probable Qutealfdant regarding
2007.04.26 PBS report regarding Mervaw of
2007.04.30 PBS report regarding letter to
2007. 21 RS report regarding ntervaw of
2007 11 28
2008.02.31
2018.12.04
2019.03.20
'Euro
FBI re rdin interview of
SW re r rdin
rd rats, non and aim infortna or
Various
I (nation
Interview 302
Vanout search records re Arcing
stand am not
Various notes and search r cecis
Audo f Ile (tape rotor/leg side Al
Audo fI (tape recorcarg side 81
Audo f1 1064116
1064427 2004.12.23 Money transfer mord
206.0.04 Letter from
2007 02.01 Loner fr om Gerald lalcoist
2003.0531 MySpace pasts
2007.12.11 letter from lay lei
2008.07.10 toner from
2008.09.02 letter from
2008.12.05 Letter
2019.06.13 Memorandum from call 'nth
3501064.128
501.064 129
501.064.130
501.064.131
501.064.1
501064.1
501064.134
501064.1
501064.1 Hanchinitten notes
Western Unice', records 1066137 N/A
3501.015 Data DealP 1100 Atterrirt
501.065 001
2019.07.09 ea...mall message
email message
2019.07.09 ycaemall message WA
3501.060
Date Descrattloa
006,03. 31 palm Falco °apartment material %toots statement
Attorney
WA
501.057 Date Description Attorney
1.067001
501.067 002
501.062033
501.067.005
501067.036
501.067.007
501067.008
501067.009
2007.01.01 bagtaphIcal info 'bon 302
2037.02 27
2007.09.22 Rental a cation
2007 1026
2007.1026
2007.1029
2008.01.10 FBI letter to data January ID, 2008
2008.01.10 v Um rghts 302
2008.03 24 Vialm list
2008.04.29
Testimony of
Intomew not
IMoMew 302
IMoMew 302
501.062010
501.062011
501.062012
501.067014
3501067-015
3501067.016
501067.017
501.067018
501.067019
501.067020
501067 022
501067 023
501.067 024
2008.03.18 Testimay of
2008.07.03 Vklim lel
2000.07.21 letter ern A rar4.a . Mata to
2018.12.0$ teem, nformation
2018.12.0$ Loomptorn in formation
2018.12.0$ um information 302
201907.09 interview attempt
List and photographs*, 1Jne Doe,  1.19
Various Biographical file on
Idea: n nforma•.Im
2003.02.28 NM CAD Cal Inforrnatio
2007 11129 NU report regarding intav
20011.01.10 15 report regarding letters to v Urn
2010 12 01 103 report regarding infotmati
2007.1026 302from interview
200807 10
2008.0902 letter Iron
1063025 letter Iron
202L0Al2
202L0Al2
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.0412
2021.0412
2021.0412
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
202110.11
202110.11
21121.1031
2021.1031
2021.1031
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
armload to Dakota
2021.03.12
2021.10.11
2021.1025
Produced to Defense
202: 04 :2
Produced to Defense
2021.03.12
2021.04.12
202103.12
2021.01.12
2021.0112
2021.04,12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202L0Al2
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202L07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
3501.067.027 2008.12.05 Letter from
3501.067.0221 2019.06.13 Memorandum from oil MSII
350100 Date Desaiption
3501.068 CO1 1996.07.11 HYPO r coon
3501.06882 1996.09.03 FBI report
301.068.08 2006.11.13 Law enforcement report foe
3501.068.003 208.11.14 intervws notes
3501.068 018 2006.11.14 ntervkor 302
301.068.08 2006.11.14 intervxvo notes
301.06882 201707 30 Ixation
3501.068038 2019.0417 affidavit
3501069009 201908.17 interview 302
3501069010 2019.11.12 cIW complaint
3501.068.011 1996 0903 Complaint form
3501.068.012 2018.12.01 FBI report regarding travel to interview
3501069013 2019.05.20 Asset Report regarding
3501.068.014 2019.05.20 Law Enforcement Rcoon regareArg
3501.068.015 2019.05.20 Contact Can! Report regarding
3501.068.016 2019.08.16 300 regarding Sigrid McCauley phone cad
3501.068.017 2019.08.17 302 regarding nonacid
3501069018 Screemhot of [rebook page
3501069019 Sereemriot of latebook page
3501068020 50ton:hot of Totterpage
3501 068.021 2019 1004 Freud Nan with
3501.069 Date Des 0'iption
350146%001 2002.1003 Florida DAY.I.D.Indindual stenmarr page of
350L070
Date DmaiPthm
3501 070-001 2019 09 12 intervWw 302
3501.070002 2019.09.12 IntervWw notes
3508071 Date Description
3501.071401 2006.09.28 Florida DAVID. indendual summary page tor
3501.071402 2006.09.28 Florida DAY.I.D.motor reticle status for
3501.072 Date Dulaiption
3501.072.001 2006.12.14
Honda DAV.I.D.Indhidoal summary Page for
JIMEN
3501073 Date Description
3501.073.001 2006.12 14 Florida 0 A.Y.I.D. indmdual sunmary P48. fir
3501074 Date DescriP004
3501 074 WI 2006.12.14 Florida DAVID. individual summon( page lor
3501.075
Deb Desalptioe
3501.075401 2005.11.08 Palm Beach Peace °apartment property receipt
3501.075402 2006.05.01 Probable Cause Affidavit Regarding leHrey Epstein
3501.075403 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Ponce Department Incidern report
3501.075401 2006.08.08 FBI memorandum regarding Nairn notification
3501.075405 2006.08.11 letter tram to
3501.075406 2006 0816 am id history
3501075407 2007.02.27 Temlnwery of
3501075409 2007.0808 Temlnwery of
3501.075409 2017.12.11 Letter to Almancler Mosta
3501.075010 Notes on
3501.075011 Various Biogragnical tile cm
3501.075012 2005.11.07 Audo tile (side A of tape rezoning
3501.075013 2005.11.07 Audo Mt (side 8 °flap. recording!
3501075011 2005.108 Florida DAV.I.D.indrAdual summarypage for
3501075015 2005.11.02 National Comprehensive Report for
3501075016 2006.02.09 Igy5p.xe Oars
3501.075017 2006.05.01 PBPD probable cause angina Min
35010750W 2006.05.01 PBPD probable oust angina Nen
3501075.019 monde...Mtn notes
3501.079020 2005.10.18 Palm Beach County search warrant and application
3501.075 021 2006.08.01 Letter tram
3501.075 012 2007.02.01 Letter home:laid Leforst
3501.075 023 2007.12.11 Longhorn lay Lelkaailz
3501.075 021 2005.11.07 Handmitten rotes
3501.076
Tony 110100. Date 0 • 101 0808
3501.076.001 2006.0501 Palm Beach Mee Department Probable Cause Affidavit
3501.076002 2006.12.14 Florida DAVID. indrildual sunmary page for Tony F.gueroa
3501.076033 2006.12.14 Florida DAY.I.D.$4dress information for To0y lteudoa
3501.076005 2006.12.14 Florida DAVID. inciMchaal summary page for Tony Figueroa
202L10.11
2021.10.11
ProducedtoDefense
2021.03.12
2021.04.12
2021.04,12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
Produced to Defense
202:03 :2
Produced to Defense
202101.12
202101.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
ProducedtoDefense
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
202101 12
Produced to Defense
202 C4 :1
Produced to Defense
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.25
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Attorney
Sigrid McCaeley
Attorney
WA
Attorney
Gbh AWOCI
Mann
N/A
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
Attorney
WA
Attorney
3501.076005 2006.12.14 Florida DAVID. historical &Nor Ikons. activity for Tony fl ounce
3501.076.006 2006.12.14 Florida ACCH response regarding Tony Figueroa
3501.076007 2006.12.14 CadCal information regarding suspiocus .ehele
3501.076038 2006.12.14 Palm Beach Police Department citation tracbmg report
3501.076009 2006.12.14 Florida DAV.I.D.photo line up for Tony FeLeroa
3501.076010 2006.12.14 Research regarding Tony Figueroa
3501.076011 2006.12.14 Research regarding Tony Figueroa
3501076012 2006.12.14 0001 Information and citation tracking report
3501.076013 2007.01.04 Record search regarding Tony Figueroa
3501476014 2007.01.06 Research regarding Tony Figueroa
3501476015 2007.01.06 National comprehensive mpan resin:m.7am Figueroa
3501.076016 2007.01.10 Fns memorandum regarding intavieerof Tony Figueroa
3501.076017 2007.01.10 Tony Figueroa Miamian notes
1501.0760113 2007.01.10 Tony Figueroa Intense* 302
3501.076019 2007.05.01 Testimony of
3501.076020 2007.06.20 Florida DAV.I.D.ciriyer license transaction page for Tony Figueroa
3501.076021
2008.04.29
&
2008.03.18 TeSihnonyol
3501476022 2008.05.15 Lay/enforcement report regarding Tony Figueroa
3501.076023 2011.03.12 FEU travel request tocond.-et ,memews
3501.076024 2011.03.12 FS request to laolitate interview
3501.076025 2016.06.14 Depositional Tony Figueroa
3501.076026 2016.06.14 Depositional Tony Figueroa
3501.076027 2018.12.04 Tony Ftoaeroa 16mtifying information
3501.02600E 2020.0603 FBI MeMOranOall regarding attempted contact with Tony Figueroa
3501.076029 2020.08.03 Tony Figueroa internaw 302
3501476030 2020.0619 Tony Figueroa Interview notes
3501.076.031 202/.01.27 Tony Figueroa Interview 302
3501.076.032 2021.01.27 Tony Figueroa Interview notes
3501.076.033 2021.01.27 Anthony Flipp:103 proem eovement
3501.076.034 Anthony Figurfoa trograPhirallnicinnotir
3501476.035 2007.01.10 FEU report regarding Wavier( of entlxerrFiveroa
3501.076.036 2018.12.04 FIN report regarding interview of enthcerrFiveroa
3501.076 037 2021.01.27 Ugned goner agreement
3501.077 Date Description
3501.07? 031 2007.10.05 Phone nurnber Starch molts
3501.078
loam Fontandla Date Desalp6on
1531 013 0)1 tuelan0 Fontaine driver license
3501.079 Date Description
3501.079.001 2005.12.08
NitiOnli oxnprenensive report regarding
3501.079.032 2005.11.01 Florida DAV.I.D.Indnithal summary page regarding
3501479 033 2007 10.02 Interview 302
3501.0/9 OK 2007.10.04 Fill memorandum regarding
3501.079 035 Various lhographical fik. for
3501.0/9 016 Notes for <alto& members
3503.060 Date Desalption
3501.080 031 2005.11.21 Plink Beach Police Department incident report
3501.080 002 2006.09.01 Patin Beach rgi<e0eganmgnt incident report
3501080003 2019.08.22 Cnus Intake report regarding
3501.061 Date Dueled=
3501 081 OM 2005.11.21 Palm Beach Peace Department Incident MOM
3503 081 0)1 2026.09 01 Palm Beach Ponce Department Incident Wien
3501082 Date Descried=
3501481001 2008.01.10 SW lento' to
3501082002 2008.03,24 Victim lot
3501082003 200807.03 Victim let
3501.082.004 2008.12.19 Letter trent tO
3301.082.005 2008.06.25 intervew 302
3501.082.005 Variant itiOgripille-li St tOr
3501.082407 Notes on
3501.082.038 Notes on
3501482.009 2008.01.10 FBI report regarding letters to vktims
3501482.010 2007.1[01 Email regarOng IMMO
3501.082.011 2008.07.10 Letter from
3501.082.012 2008.09.02 Letter from
3501.082.013 2019.06.13 Memorandum from call 'nth
1.50L063
Martin Gannon Date Denalption
3501 083 0)1 2019.08.27 Marbn Gannon Interview 302
3501 083 032 2019.08.27 M., run Damon Interview cover Net:
3501 083 0)3 2019.08.27 "art, Gannon interview notes
Metan °met:
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.111.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.1:IA12
2021.1:IA12
2021.1:IA12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021 07 23
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
Produced to Detente
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202301.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1011
2021.1031
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
Attorney
WA
Attorney
NIA
Attained
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
3501083001 2019.07.12 Email Iran
3501.083.005 2019.06.27 Notes on Gannon tam*, members
3501.083.005 2019.08.27 MarberGannon @Justice workup
3501.083.037 2019.09.04
FIN memorandum documenting inquiries pertaining to Martin
Gannon
3501.083.038 2019.09.04 Cramton Police Department incident report
3501.083.039 2019.09.04 10 cancel
3501083.010 2019.06.28 Fax retardertniartin Gannon
3501083011 2019.09.03 Menlo Gannon olustite records
3501.064
Padres Garcia Date DescaPthla
350106001 2007.10.19 Law enforcemmt report regarding Andres Gar0a
3501.065
Nor ZlowAsy Data Description
3501.085 021 2006.12.05 Person search of lgor Zirroxev
3501.085 0)2 2006.12.06 Law enforcement report retarding tor Zinovitv
3501.085003 Nor Zinovicy Other license
3501.086
Oscar Garcia Date Description
3501086001 2007.04.24 CAD call infammion
3501.087 Mtn DescriPtion
3501.087.031 2020 07 27 interview 302
3501.087 002 202170727 Interview cover thee:
3501.087 003 202170727 Markopa Palm Department report
3501.0116 Data Decalption
3501488.001 2008.04.23 Law enforcement tepee for
3501.089 Date DescilMial
3501 089 0)1 2019.07.06 Intervew 302
3501.090 Data Description
3501.0900)1 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Polce Oeparynent Incident Report
3501090002 2006.06.28 MIIOW to
3501090003 2006.07.24 tenet to Mr. and Mrs. from PBPD
3501.090011 2006.08.25 MI report documenting Attain
3501090005 2006.12.20 Memorandum retantleglinpeathenent material
3501090005 2006 03.31 Police report
3501090037 2006.04.04 Palm Beach County Shirai's Office tooter%
3501.090 0)3 206.04.06 Police report
3501.090 CM 2007.01.01 Letter fromGerald Lefton<
3501 090 010 2007 12.11 Letter from laylefkoNO
3501.091 AY . Description
3501.0910)1 2006.04.26 Palm Beach Police Department Properly receipt
3501.093002 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Mee Department Incident Report
3501.093033 2006.04126 pan Beach Police Department Properly receipt
3501091.001 2006.09.27 Facto
3501091-006 2005.03.14 Mao file Dull tape recorant Ude Al
3501091-005 2005.03.14 nodef Ile (clip of tape meordlnit:
3501.091-007 2005.03.14 Audo fileDid. B of tape wording
3501093008 2006.04.17 Au/oft*
3501491-009 2006.07.24 tenet to Mr. and Mrs. from PBPD
3501093010 2006.11.20 Memorandum regardim Impeachment material
3501093011 Harr/mitten notes
3501.091012 2006.04.04 Palm Beach County Sherd? s Office search result
3501191 013 2007.01.01 Letter from Gerald Lelcourt
3501091 014 2007.11.11 Letter from lay Lefkomu
3501.092 Data DesaiPthla
3501.092-0M 2006.01.05 Notes on
3501.092032 2005.03.15 Photo array
3501.092033 2005.11.24 Cnerokoe County Shares Office report
3501.092011 2006.01.26 Palm Beach Police Department [Pollen),  receipt
3501092005 2006 0404 Palm Beach County Sher' s Offense Report
3501492-006 2006.05.01 Probable Cause Affidavn Retarding leHrey Epstein
3501092007 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Police rtrnent Incident Report
3501.092-008 200607.19 Notes on Grand key test
3501492-009 2006.07.19 Trantcrtpt of testimony
3501.092010 2006.07.25 Victim Identification Wmregarding
3501092.011 200607.26 Palm Beach Pence Department proportY receipt
3501092-012 2006.07.17 Florida DAY.I.D.IndMdual suanmarypage for
3501092-013 2006.0304 letter from to
3501092-014 2006.08.08 Victim notification form regarding I l_
3501092.015 2006 08.16 ass ant history
3501092.016 2006.06.26 Palm Beach Polite Department Evidence/Property TrackingReport
3501092.017 2006.06.26 Palrn Beach Police Department properly receipt
3501092018 2006.0328 FBI memoranda." I etittlIntvICIIT asallancoproitram
3501092019 2006.09.29 Grand Jury transolpts
WA
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.10.11
2021.1011
2021.10.11
ProducedtoDeena*
2021.01.12
ProducedtoBelem*
2021.04.12
2021.03.12
2021.0111
ProducedtoDelmar.
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.0112
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Debra
202103.12
Produced to Odense
2021 0111
Produced to Defense
2021.0112
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202107.23
202107.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1011
Produced to Debra
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
202101.12
202101.12
202101.12
202101.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.0412
2021.04.12
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
attorney
WA
Marnry
WA
Marnry
WA
Attorney
WA
AttOrnfly
3501092030 2007.01.24 letter from Gerald lefcoart to and
3501,092.00.1 2007.0201 latter from Gerald Ofeoart to and
3501.091022 2007.02.26 'Maroc." 302
3501.091013 2007.0126 Photographs shown to -
3501092A24 2007.02.27 interview noes
3501492 025 2007.01.27 Testimony of
3501092 026 2007.03.20 Testimony of
3501192 027 2002.05.06 Testimony of
3501492 028 2007.06.08 Barad request regarding
3501092 029 2007.06.11 FBI detailed analysis pertaining to investigation
3501092030 2007.06.22 Recent search repaid/rig
3501492-031 2007.06.12 National Comprehensive Report for
3501092032 2007.07.20
Florida DAVID. Individual summary page regarding
„MM.
2007.11.28 RI detailed analysis pertain% to Investigation
3501092034 2007.12.11 Letter to Aleonclar Acosta
3501092-035 photos
3501092036 2008.02.01 MKpace photos
3501.092437 2008 0113 Myspace photos
3501092038 2008.0120 Depositional
3501.092039 2008.0120 Vktim list
3501492-010 2008.07.03 Vktim lilt
3501.092011 2008.07.10 Letter to Theodore Leopold
3501491042 2008.10.14 Pam Beach County 5herdes Office victim notification ecrifirmatian
3501491043 2008.10.14 Vartness letter regxdrµ Jeffrey rpstan
3501092044 2008.10.14
Pro Tech Mangano& Inc.offender details repon regardingJaffrey
Epstein
3501 092 015 2008.10.10 Pro Tech Monitoring. Inc.offender ektails report regarchkg Jeff ref
Epstein
3501.092 046 birth ecnificate
3501092 017 ttarelan Information
35010920th IliallITIa
3501.092 019 MySpace Wag
3501.092 010 1450ace coenartalkons
3501.092 051 1450ace coenartatians
3501492 052 Various Bsographical f de on
3501092 053 MyiDxe pr ofile
3501092014 IMI p.1 ace profile information
3501492 066 gj-MysDace WOMo
3501092-052 Photograph of
3501.092058 Photographed
3.5 .4 pace.059 photapraPh
3501492.060 MySioce page
3501092.061 Myspace page
3501092.052 Photos of uktims
isa .i oace.ora ptotagraphs
3501092.064 United Stales v. inactrnent
3501092.066 200503.15 Amigo f Ile (full taparecordAt side Al
3501492466 2005.03.15 Sono f de (dip of tape wording!
3501492.067 200503.15 Aucio f de (lull tape reeordet& Pd. 8)
3501492838 2005.03.15 Audo f de tfull tape recordeig, side Al
3501092839 2005.03.15 Audio f lie (dip of tape recording!
3501091070 2005.03.15 Mao f go (full tape recording. sides)
3501092071 2005.03.18 Aue1ofdafull tape recording. side Al
3501092072 2005.03.16 Patio tilt (clip of tape recording!
3501092073 200503.18 Aue1ofdafull tape recording. side 81
3501.092-074 200503.30 Aue1ofdafull tape recording. side Al
3501.091075 2005.03.30 Pogo f dacha of tape wording!
3501092076 200503.30 Auctofdafull tap:. reeonagig. Worn
3501092077 200503.30 Nandi...OM notes
3501491078 200303.31 Audofile
3501491079 2005.0331 AucIofile
3501492080 2006.00.04 MySpace paces
3501.092-081 2006.00.04 Palm Beach County Shorn/Ps Off lee Offense Report
3501091062 2006.00.04 Pato Beach County Shernfts Office search row& f or M and
3501492.033 2006.05.01 PIM probable oust affidavit regarding
3501092.084 2006.05.01 P810 probable oust affidavit reprding
3501.092.085 2006.05.01 IWO probable oust affidant regading Jeffrey Epstein
3501091086 2006.05.01 P8P0 probable oust affidant regardin
3501.091087 2006.05.01 P8P0 Probable oust affidavg regarding
3501.092433 2006.0633 MySpace pages
35014910ES 2006.07.24 Letter to Mr. and Mrs. nrom P8P0
3501492090 2006.08.25 ES report regarding Inter to
3501492491 2006.08.28 IWO property receipt
3501092092 2006.12.20 Memorandum re rd I achment material
3501492-093 2007.02.27 ES report regarding interview yetth
35014924394 2007.05.31 MvSawe Dago
3501.092495 2007.11.28 FIN repot regarding bwestigatica and victim Informance
3501492-096 2004.0220 Deposition transalpt
3501.092-097 2004.0220 Depostton ha [canto notes
3501.092 098 2008.0210 oopostton handwritten notes
3501.092099 MyStaace paces
Florida Department of children and 'miles Information re =
AM.
3501092101 MySixxe pages
3501492.102 MySpace Pates
3501492.103 Cherokee County Sheriff's Once incident report
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021-01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.00.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.00.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
3501.092.101
Florida Department of children and Fanilles information re:Ell
WA
2021.07.23
3501.092.105 MyS0.xe Dates 2021.07.23
3501.092.106 Cherokee county Sheriffs office offense region 2021.07.23
3501.092407 Cherokee county sheriff's office offense region 2021.07.23
3501.092.108 20090380 ItandmItten notes 2021.07.23
3501092109 Typed roles tten ta 2021.07.23
3501.092.110 Various Various search records mood.* 2023.07.23
3301092111 Pude fikitull tam recordInt. Ode Al 2021.07.23
3501.092.111 Awl* f At (clip of tape reeordIngl 2021.07.23
3501.092.113 Pude f i1t(tull taperer🔛lint On/ 2021.07.23
3301092.114 2006.06.06 Lett er from 0enld Lefcourt to 2021.07.23
3301.092.116 2006.0331 Police report 2021.10.11
3301092.116 2006.0601 Letter regarding Epstein PahlraDh eamnxion 2021.10.11
3501.092.117 2007.02.01 Letter frame:old Lelcourt 2021.10.11
3501.092118 2007.0931 MySiaace Oates 2021.10.11
3501.092.119 2007.12.11 Lena from lay Lelkeentz 2021.10.11
3501092.120 2007.12.21 Letter from lay Lelkowela 2021.10.11
3501092.121 2008.05.27 St minion to the DAG 2021.10.11
3501.092.122 2008.0619 Ski:mission to the DAG 2021.10.11
3501.092123 2008.07.10 letter from 2021.10.11
3501092.124 2008.09.02 letter from 2021.10.11
3501.092325 2006.12.06 letter from 2021.10.11
3501.092126 2008.12.08 letter from 2021.10.11
3501.092127 imam of 2021.10.11
3501.092125 FAySoxe Dag,: 2021.10.11
Brle•Gordert Date Datalption Attorney ProducedtoMIN=
3501.093 C01 2006.12.04 Anon search for Beim Canon
WA
2011.04.12
3501.093.002 2007.02.03 Brice Gordon Interview notes 1021.04.12
3501093001 2007.02.05 enc. Gordon interview 302 2021.04.12
3501.093.034 2007.02.13 Memorandum of Eck. Gorden intentne 2021.04.12
3501.093006 2007.02.25 Memorandum doeumenerg Interview of Once Gordon 2021.04.12
3501.0934305 2017.02.15 enc. Gordon InteMew cover sheet 2021.01.12
3501.099007 200702.13 Mill report documenting interuienv with She* Gordon 2021.07.23
3501093.008 2017.02.15 FBI report doo.imenting IntepoWerwith ghee Gordon 2021.07.23
3501.093039 2019.04.0B Asset Report regarding Brice Gordon 2021.07.23
3501.093010 2019.04.08 Law Enforcement Amon regareIrg Balm Gordon 2021.07.23
3501.099011 2019.04.08 Contact Card Report regarding BnceGordon 2021.07.23
3501099012 2019.04.08 Diva's History Accord regarding Once Gordon 2021.07.23
3501.099013 2019.04.08 Comprehensive Address Report reigareing Sam Gordon 2021.07.23
3301493.014 Scretoshot of Facebook page 2021.07.23
35013&0 Date Desalption Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.094 C01 2019.08.13 =InteMew 302
WA
2021.04.12
3501.094032 2019.08.13 ntemew notes 2021.04.12
MOUES Date Ossakition Attorney Produced to Defense
3501098031 2019 07 12 ema4 corm fine WA 2021 P2.12
alfIlta Date OssoloGeo Attorney producedtoDefense
3501.096001 2007.07.23 Person search for
1 A
2021.124.12
3501.096032 2007.01106 1.=.
Florida DAY.I.D.IndMdual summary page regarding l l
2021.04.12
3501096.003 2007.08.06 taw enforcement re rdln 2021.04.12
3501.097
Daniel Groff Date Desialptloa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 097 0)1 2007.08.15 Law enforcement report rcsatclina Donp6 Groff WA 202: Ca :2
3501.098
Groff Date DienalPtlom Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.098 C01 2007.0815 Law enforcement report regarding Lesley Groff
Michael Bachner
2021.04.12
3501098.002 2007.08.21 Letter regarding Interview of Wiley Groff 2021.111.12
3501098.003 2007.08.21 Lesley Groff interview 302 2021.01.12
3501098.031 2007.0821 Lesley Groff Interview/notes 2021.01.12
2006.04.29
&
200603.18 Teslinworof 2021.01.12
3301.098.005 201907.06 Lesley Graft Interview 302 2021.01.12
3301.098037 201907.06 Lesley Croft interview notes 2021.01.12
3501.098.035 20200113 Lesley Groff attorney Droller notes 2021.01.12
3501098009 202002.21 Lesley Groff attorney Droller follow., 2021.111.12
3501099010 200601.09 FM report documenting interview with Leslie Croft 2021.07.23
3301098011 2021.07.23 Signed proffer agreement 2021.10.11
3501098012 2006.06.19 Starr submission to DAG 2021.10.11
3501098013 201902.06 Lesley Groff internee/302 2021.10.11
3501.098.014 2019.07.06 Lesley Groff interview notes 2021.10.11
3501098.015 2021.07.23 Lesley Groff interview 302 2021.10.11
3501098.016 2021.07.23 Lesley Groff interview/notes 2023.10.11
3501.099
Michael Guerrero Date DaatptIon Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501099001 2006.08.02 CAD all infamationregardnit Michael Guerrero WA 2021124.12
3501.100
Eileen G 0 nhcem Date Description Attorney Produce/Ito Wens* I
3501.100 031 2007.0815 Law enforcemmt repot roam ditIR bicen Gaggenteun
NIA
2021.04.12
3501.100002 2007.09.06 Eileen Guggenheim internew notes 2021.04.12
3501.100003 2007.09.06 Eileen Guggenheim internew 302 2021.04.12
3501.100016 2007.09.11 Memorandum of (leen Gutgenhom interview 2021.04.12
3501.100035 200709.06 itancinvitteo notes 2021.10.11
3501101 Data DesatptIon Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.101-002 2020.04.10 Menges 302
WA
2021,0112
3501.1014302 2020.04.10 intervws notes 2021.04.12
3501.101403 2020.09.09 intervws noes 2021.04.12
3501.101404 2021.05.18 ntervxw notes 2024.1011
3501.101.005 2021.05 18 intetYkOW 302 2021.1031
3501.102 Dale Desalpthan Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.102 001 2020.07.15 interview 302
N/A
2021,04,12
3501.102.032 2020.07.15 interview notes 2021.01.12
3501.103 Date Desalpthan Attorney Produced to Delenee
3501.103001 throu h 031 Various School words for 2021.04.12
3501.103 032 2002.04,29 Recut search regarding 2021.04.12
3501.103 033 2002.12 FROM reservation 2021.04.12
3501.103 034 2005.0604 Victoria Secret 'potation 2021.04.12
3501.103.035 2005.09.11 Juvenile arrest notice for 2021.01.12
3501.103.066 2005.09.12 Probable Cause Affidavit of 2021.04.12
3501.103-067 200509 16 Defendant Activity report for 2021.04.12
3501.103-038 2005.09.16 Defendant Activity report for 2021.04.12
3501.103-069 2005.10.13 Palm Beath Police cement ro rent 2021.04.12
3501.106060 2005.10.25 Mernork"durn from the Court of Palm Beach Country regarding
2021.04.12
3501.106061 2005.1025 Nob* Prase form reganing 2021.04.12
3501.106062 2005.11.14 MyS0ace profile 2021.04.12
3501.103063 2005.11.18 Palm Beach Police Department Oxidant report 2021.01.12
3501.103064 2006.02.16 Limitedbrands Mcident report 2021.01.12
3501.103445 2006.02.20 hlySoace blogconversaticm 2021.01.12
3501.106066 2006.02.20 MySoace profile pictures 2021.04.12
3501.103447 2006.05.01 Probable Cause Affidavit Regarding Jeffrey Epstein 2021.04,12
3501.103046 2006.07.13 Pakn Beach Peace Department Incident Report 2021.04,12
3501.103.019 2006.07.27 Florida DAVID. indMdual summarypage for 2021.04,12
3501.103-050 2006.0602 ReCuds search for 2021.04.12
3501.103451 2006.08,01 Letter from to 2021.04.12
3501.103452 2006.08.08 FBI Memorandum to document Hcbm information 2021.04.12
3501.103-053 2006.08.18 Photo Int.up 2021.04.12
3501.103-054 2006.08.18 Inteview 302 2021.04.12
3501.103-055 2006.08.22 FW memorandum regarding movies of 2021.04.12
3501.103-056 2006.0626 Pain Beach Po3ce Department Evidence/Property7rackirg Ripon 2021.04.12
3501.103-057 2006.0626 Palm Beach Polce Department Evidence/Property7racking Report 2021.04.12
3501.106058 2006.08,28 FBI letter to 2021.04.12
3501.103-059 2006.0628 Palm Beach Pale* Department Dridence/Pro T rackirg Report 2021.04.12
3501.103.050 2006.09.16 Defendant Acioily report for 2021.04.12
3501.103.051 2006.09.29 Grand fury transcripts 2021.04.12
3501.103062 2006.10.03 HMI Tucker MISPX0 Page 2021.01.12
3501.103 053 2007.01.24 Letter Prom Gerald Lefcust to 2021.04.12
3501.103 066 2007.02.27 intim:ego! 2021.01.12
3501.103 065 2007.04.24 COD call information 2021.01.12
3501.103 056 2007.05.22 Testimonyof 2021.01.12
3501.1113.057 2007.06.12 National Comprehensive Repenter 2021.04.12
3501.103.059 2007.06.12 Record request kr 2021.04.12
3501.103.059 2007.07.20 Florida DAV.I.D.IndMdual summary page for 2021.04.12
3501.106070 2007.11.28 FW detailed analysis conducted 2021.04.12
3501.103071 2007.12.11 Letter toMeander Acosta from RADS & Erne LLP 2021.04.12
3501.106072 2007.12.11 Letter to Meander Acoga from RADS & Ens UP 2021.04.12
3501.103073 2008.03.24 Victim list 2021.04.12
3501.103-074
2008.04.29
&
2006.03.18 testimony of 2021.01.12
3501.103.075 2000.07.03 Victim at 2021.04.12
3501.103076 2001112.09 totter from to 2021.01.12
3501.103.077 20161104 F$31 memorandum regarding Movies of 2021.04.12
3501.103-07S 2019.03.19 intent** 302 2021.04.12
3501.103-079 2019.03.19 IntellieW notes 2021.04.12
3501.103-080 2019.07.06 FBI MeMOrandlall Crisis Mtake moon 2021.04.12
3501.103-061 2019.09.12 interview 302 2021.04.12
3501.106062 2019.09.12 Interview notes 2021.04.12
3501.103-063 birth cendkate 2021.04.12
3501.103-084 Voter icleolificatiortreturn SOMCONCROSted 2021.04.12
3501.103-086 course schedule 2021.04.12
3501.103-096 Myra. account 2021.04.12
3501.103-067 Biographicalfatecm 2021.04.12
3501.1060U Various MvSoxe profile regarding 2021.01.12
3501.106093 SAySoxe profile regarding 2021.04.12
3501.103-050 F81 Wen:dying information for 2021.04.12
3501.103091 Photos of victims 2021.04.12
3501.103092 Omega,:Mic Mfamation for
3501 103-093 Juvenile arrest record for
3501.100091
3501.103095
3501.103-096
3501.103097
3501.103-098
3501.103-099
3501.103.100
3501.103.101
3301.103102
3301.103103
3301.103104 2006.08.22 Memorandum doeumentirg Interview of
3501 103.105 2006 08.22 FBI report documenting MmHg,: of
3501.103.106
3501.103.107
3501.103103
3501.103109
3501.103110
3301.103111
3301.103112
3301.103113
3301.103114
3301.103115
3501 103.116
3501.103.117
3301.103118
3501.103119
3501.103420
3501.103121
3501.103122
3501.103123
3501.103424
3501.103125
3501.103126
3501.103127
3301.10313E
3501.103429
3501.103.130
3501.103131
3501.103132
3501.103133
2005.10.11 gado file (full tam recording. tide Al
2005.10.11 Auclo (clip of tape recording!
2005.10.11 Auclo f tape recording. side Al
2005.1011 gado file (elle of tap. recording!
20(6.1031 gado fax (full tap, recorc% 110. 01
2005.11.04 Victoria Secret store Indent report
2006.02.17 Letter to -from Guy Fronstln
2006.05.01 IWO probable muse affidavit regarding
2006.03.01 IWO probable muse affidavit regarding
2006.07.20 Letter to from P640
2006.12.20 Memorandum regardng impeachment material
2007.01 Letter regarding
2007.11.28 F81 report regarding Mvesligation and victim Infonnatior
2018.12.64 HU report doo.ementing information
2019.03.19 nternow 302
Victoria Sean store mockat report
Various search records regarcingf
Various search records regarciog
Various search records repecIngl
Various search records repecIngl
Various search records refratOnt
manchMtten notes
Various search records refraectnt
Letter from Alan DOKhOVIAZ to
MySoare Pages
MySoare Pages
Alt fame (full tap:qt.:Omra 1104 Al
Alt f ale Hull tape recorder&  side M
Pude file tape reeordmAl
Auelofiklelip of tape recording!
Audo ma
2005.10.24 Community:entre docsenenta0en
2005.11.07 MySpore pages
2005.11.18 IWO incident report
2005.11.21 Riley Kiraly approach olM
2007.02.01 Letter from Gemld Wear(
2007.05.31 My5Dare Pages
2007.06.25 Letter from Gemld Lereourt
2002.11.19&
2007.11.29 Letters from
2007.12.11 letter from In Lelkornt
2006.00.19 St.:mission so the DAG
2008.07.10 letter Item
2008.09.15 Letter from
2019.06.13 Memorandum from call srAth
2019 06.24 Text messakrx1th a gent
3501.103134
3501.103135
3501.103136
3501.103437
3501.103.133
3301.103139
1501 103.140
3501.103441 Drawn& tri
3301 103.142 Fbotos or
1501.103443
3501.103144
3501.103.145
3501.103146
3501.103.147
3501.103.148
3501.103.149
ktociena retwns regard/19M
Transcript request
14y5Dace Pares
waste
2006.04.06 *Sudo file
2005.1030 Handwritten notes
Glory ADed
Rase
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2022.07.23
2022.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2022.07.23
2022.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.2031
2021.20.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.2031
2021.1025
3501.100
0 Attorney Produced to Defense
3503104 002
3501.104002
3501.104.003
3501.104.001
3501.104.005
3501.109006
3501.104.007
3501.104.008
3501.104.009
3501.104-010
3501.104011
3501.104012
3501.104013
3501.104014
3501.104015
3501.104016
2019.08.01
2019.08.01
2019.09.18 Screemhot of Right recent from
2019.09.18
2019.09.18
2019.09.18
2019.09.13
2006.11.16 saccre.not of flight recent
2006.03.01 Sactreznt of email to
2006.11.16 Sr/core-Mt of flightht recebt
2005.07.26 Sactreznt of email from
2006.01.27 Sr/core-not of email from
2006.04.06 Sercerehot of email from
2006.03.01 Scree hot of email to
2019.11.20
202001.01
interHew 302
Interview notes
email regarding flight
email containing teats
Intenlew 302
Intenlew notes
CeAlcomiplaIM
Intenlew notes Gloria Ailed
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.0432
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202301.12
2021.0012
202301.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.0432
2021.0432
MUDS
VANED Hammond Description AttOrney ProducedMD*1ms*
3501.105.001
3501.1(6032
3501.1(6033
3501.11:6-001
3501.11:6035
3501.116-006
2006.11.27 NAlbam Hammond interview 302
2006.11.27 Flight records arcl Dotes
2006.12.01 Memorandum of Wiliam Hammond interdew
2007.02.06 Testimonyof
2019.07.06 Wtham Hammond Interview 302
2019.07 31 773,c:from phone can with
2021 0/.12
2021.03.12
2021.0432
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
3501.106
Robert H.1150.1 Date DesalptIon Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.106401 2021.01.12 Robert Hanson intavbw 302
David Lancaster
2021.01.12
3501.106002 2021.01.12 Handwritten notes 2021.07.23
3501.105-003 2021.01.06 Emits Rh agents 2021.10.11
3301.105-004 2021.01.11 1mali wtth agents 2021.10.11
3501.107 Date Data Pdbarillity Produced to Defense
3501.107 001 2005.04.18
Florida DAVID. mdMdual sunmarY page re840,900
....
NIA
2021.08.12
3501.107 002 2006.07.13 Pam Beach Pollee Department InOdem Report 2021.04.12
3501.107403 2006.0606 FEN memorandun dacumonlln¢ victim Information 2021.01.12
3501.107404 3005.0811 Letter from to 2021.01.12
1.107405 3005.0836 asignment history 2021.01.12
3501.107406 08. 26 Palm Beach PgiceDtpanment Evidence/Property TrackedRaven 2021.01.12
3501.107407 3005.0828 Palm Beach Police Department Mindy Receipt 2021.01.12
3501.1074308 birth cannot. 2021.01.12
1.1074309 Various Biographical f ik. co 2021.01.12
3501.107-010 2005 12.13 Audotdo(taperoorOre Ode Al 2021.07 23
3501.107-011 2005.12.13 gu0oti (tap, reconSeg Ode B) 2021.07.23
3501.107-012 2006.0131 MASA (full tape recordWIJ 2021.07 23
3501.107013 MOfi.0131 Auctori (clID from tape recording! 2021.07.23
3501.107014 2006.02.00 Video We 2021.07 23
3501.107015 20060107 Video We 2021.07.23
3501.107416 2006.02.03 Video We 2021.07 .23
3501.107.017 2005.02.03 Video Wo 2021.07.23
3501.107018 2005.02.03 Video Welfull deo reeordost 2021.07.23
3501.107419 2006.02.03 Video No lcblrem video ice dl 2021.07.23
3501.107.020 Aodofa, 2021.07 .23
3501.107421 2007.02.01 letter from Gerald Waxy( 2021.10.11
3501.107022 2007.12.11 Letter homier LefkoMh 2021.10.11
3501.10,
lames Hatt Date Desalpdon Attorney ProducedtoDefense
1 108 031 2020.11.11 Notes 1 rem *all Mils Cor60 chat r regarders lames Hatt
N/A
2021.04,12
39)1 108 0) 2020.11.30 lames Hatt Interview notes 2021.01.12
1501308003 2020.11.30 lama HattlnteMow 302 2021.1 11
3501.100 Date Descdptlea Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.109 031 2019.07.17 IM=MI ntervie.e 302 W0. 2021 IN 12
3501110 Date Detatiatirm Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.110001 2006.0802
Florida DAVID. vidMdug summary pa8Ft to44,00 8 'MI
iMM
dMcCa,eley
2021.01.12
3501 110002 2006.08.02 Sa °env report regarding 2021.0112
3501.110003 2006.0804 letter from to 2021.01.12
3501.110004 2006.0.06 FIN memorandum docu online Halm infomiaton 2021.04.12
3501.110005 2007.01.27 Testimeerfol 2021.04.12
3501.110006 2007.10.86 Law eriorcemmt report regarding 2021.04.12
3501.110007 2007.10.25 Law enforcemmt report regarding 2021.04.12
3501.110008 2007.1805 internew 302 2021.04.12
3501.110009 2007.1826 irgerriave notes 2021.01.12
3501.110010 2008.01.10 Ka kites to 2021.01.12
3501.110011 2008.03.18 Testimony of 2021.01.12
3501.110012 2008.04.29 Testimony col 2021.04.12
3501.110013 2008 1 07 National Cemprehenslve Repa resardina 2021 04 12
3501.110014 2008.11.14 Letter from to 2021.04.12
3501.110015 2019 0705 Interview attempts 300 2021 01.12
3501.110016 Victim ha 2021.01.12
3501.110017 Various Bidgrspheal Ida on 2021.01.12
3501.110018 0301.10 MVeclrotlo0 notes 2021.01.12
3501.110.019 2005.0805 National Comorehensiv¢ R¢Oa regarding 2021.07 23
3501.110020 2007.1826 FEll report regarding interview 2021.07.23
3501.110021 2006.01.10 1W report regarding letters to ti s 2021 07 23
3501.110.021 2007.1805 302 from InteMew 2021.10.11
3501.110021 2006 07 10 Letter hem 2021 10.11
3501.110024 2009.09.02 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501.110025 2008 11 10 Letter from 2021 10.11
3501.110026 2008.11.05 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501.110023 2019. 13 Memorandum from oll wth 2021.1 11
3501.111 Otte 0014,1kel Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 111 031 2019.0828 aids in a n
s6nd M*caal.r
2021.04 12
3501.111.002 2019.08.28 Inlay 302 2021.04.12
3501.111.003 2019.08.28 Interview notes 2021.01.12
3501.112 Date Deealptlen Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.112401 2007.02.27 Testimony of 2021 04 12
3501.112.002 2007.10.03 -intoM4w 302 2021.04,12
3501112-005 2007 10.29 InteMew 302 2021.04.12
3501.112404 3005.01.10 MI letter to 2021.01.12
3501.112405 2008.0125 Palm Bexh Poke Department Inteagenee Report 2021.0112
3501.112.006 2001104.09 Search record for 2021.01.12
1.112407 200.07.21 letter from 10 2021.01.12
350 2019.07.10 1.112408 194 memorandum documenting contact made web Florida victims 2021.01.12
3501.1124309 Victim list
3501.112410 Various Eficeraphical file tor
3501.112411 2007.1029 FM report regarding interneewith
3501.112412 2008.01.10 FM report regarding letters to victims
3501.112413 2008.07.10 Letter from
3501.112414 2008.09.02 Letter from
3501.112.015 2008.12.05 Letter from
3501.112416 2019.06.13 Memorandum from call enth
3501213 Date Desorption
3501.113 COI 2008.06.08
Florida DAY.I.D.indrildual summary048e kir
3501216 Date Desorption
3501.1140)1 2007.0808 Florida DAY.I.D.Inclendual summary page toe
3501.114.002 2007.06.08 Florida DAVID. ohoto lineup for
3.50L1LS Date Mated=
3501.115 001 2019.07.13 Palm Beach Pence Department Yielding Noon
3501.115
IMP
Date Desorption
2006.0815 Florida DAVID. indnidual summary page for
3501.116002 2006.0815 Florida DAVID. indnidoal summary pa
3501.118003 2006.0815 Florida DAVID. address Vitcenution to
3501.116004 2006.08.15 Florida DAY.I.D.0 venkle bloc
3501.118005 2006.0815 Florida DAY.I.D. Ford ve810e information
3501 116.006 21306 0815 Florida DAY I D hoto lere I
era w 302 3501.116007 2006.08.17
3501.116038 2006.0817 m re for
3501.116009 2006.0822 FIEll memorand
3501.116010 2006.08.22 EN memoranthen W4h notes
3501.116011 on
3501.118012
Noto..jr nii  toirriai
3501117 Data Deserot.on
3501.117401 2019.07.31 internew 302
3501 117402 2019 07 31 internew notes
3501.07 Date Descrisition
3501.118001 2020.07.06 (mat regard
3501119 Date Description
1501.11%001 2020.07.02 interview 302
3501 119032 202007 02 in erYleiVraOteS
3501.119.003 2020.07.15 FB'report
3501320 Dote Mated=
3501.120001 2020.08.21 Interview 302
3501120032 2020.08.21 Internee rotes
3501.121 Data Malptlen
3501.121-001 202007.13 interview 302
3501.121.002 2020.07.13 interview notes
3501.121403 2020.07.14
Notes romrallwe
IM=MI
and
1501112 Date Description
3501.121001 2007.10.09 Honda DAVID. indledual summary page lee
3501123 Date Mad=
3501.123.001 2019.07.11 interview not
3501.123012 2019.07.11 InterneW notes
3501.123.033 2019.07.04 =a intake roped pones)
3501.123.004 2019.07.10 Text messages with agent
350un Deb Mealptke
350/224401 2019.08.12 interview 302
3501.12403E 2019.08.12 VoterVieVe notes
3501.175
Mni
Date Descried=
3501.128001 2004.04.09 Memorandum COVIY3II oi and
3501.125.002 2005.10.13 National ccenprehensiverepon regarding
3501.125403 2005.11.21 PM Beach Pence Department Widen report
3501.128004 2006.05.01 Probable Cause ffidav t leer E eln
3501.1254305 2006.08.01
r egarian
Lee/ enletreMent re mgaMin
3501.1254306 2006.08.01 searchreconi re anI
Robert
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1011
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
Predated to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
Predated to Meese
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.0412
2021.04,12
2021.04,12
2021.04.12
202101.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Deems*
202104 12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.10.11
ProducedtoDetente
2021.04.12
2021.0412
Produced 38 Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
202104.12
hothead to Defense
2021.01.12
2021.01,12
2021.10%11
2021.1011
Produced38MM=
2021.0412
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.03.12
2021.04.12
2021.0412
2021.0412
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
ettOrney
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
ettOrney
WA
Attorney
WA
/atom=
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Ottflitey
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
3501.125007 2006.09.01 Palm Beach Police Department Incident Noon
3501.126008 2003.01.06 Testimony&
3501.126009 2007.01.27 Testimony&
3501.125010 2007.03.20 Testimony ol
3501.125011 2003.05.08 Testimony&
3501.126012 2007.05.10 Law enforcammt renal regarding MMI
3501.125.013 2007.05.10 Law enforcement report rcsardiee
3501.125014 2007.05.15 Tettimcnyol
3501.125015 2007.05.11 Tettimaty of
3501.125016 2007.08.15 letter from to
3501.125017 2007.08.16 taw enforcement roped regarding
3501.125018 2007.08.28 Suppon of Gcnonvnent's response
3501.125019 2008.02.06 FIN memorandum tarot leads for captioned ,nastigation
3501.125020 2008.03.18 Testimony&
3501.125.021 2008.04.29 Testimony&
3501.125.022 2009.06.09 National comprehenUve aeon regarrInR=IMI
3501.125023 2009.06.09 Person search forM
1501.125024 2009.06.11 Lens Nexis colon moon regande6
1501.125025 2010.03.24 Deposition,"
3501.125026 201003.24 Depositonol
3501.125.027 2010.03.24 Depositonol
,nteryLew 302 3501.125022 2019.07.06
3501.125029 2019.11.26 ,nteryew 302
3501.125020 2019.11.26 ,nteryey, octet
3501 125.031 2019 11 26 Ce &for agreement
3501.125032 2019.11.27 attorney potter
3501 125.033 2019 12 04 ,iveryaw 302
3501.125034 2019.12.04 urAcmcw notes
3501 125.035 202003.17 ant complain.
3501.125036 driver owns*
3501.125.037 klentlicatico of
3501.129038 2015.1004 Purloins.
3501.125.039 2006.06.01 FBI report regarding case opognsl
3501.125060 2006.07.24 FBI ro ped regarding case opennsl
3501.125061 2006.08.01 FBI re port regarding case manna
3501.125062 2006.09.18 FBI report di se tting lead
3501.125013 2007.0612 FBI (opal regarding case Deering
3501.125064 2007.08.27 FBI report regarding watch list
3501.125045 2007.11.22 FBI report regarding inver4igation ar4 riven informatior
3501.125066 2019.03.25 Compowhenshe Address Report i estareir4g MIMI
3501.125067 2019.03.25 Asset Report regarding MEI
3501.125018 2019.03.25 Law Enforcement Report regontst
3501.125069 2019.03.25 Contact Card Report regarding M
3501.125050 Ftrotograph
3501.125051 Various search records and photographs
3501.126052 Flotogralf ,
3501.126053 2005.10.18 yam Beach County *arch warrant and apMlotin
3501 125054 2006 05 01 Letter from React to Barry Krneher
3501.125056 2007.05.23 Pay stubs
3501.125036 2008.06.19 SutenIssion to the DAG
3501.125057 2019.07.16 Text messages with agent
3501.125058 2019.07.31 Attorney proffer notes
3501.125059 20 19.09.06 Attorney proffer notes
3501.125030 2019.10.18 Attorney proffer notes
3501.126061 2021.1011 Letter re:Mend
3501.125052 Rental car records
3501.125.053 Rents car records
3501.125.064 Employment search records
3501.125.055 Search reowds
3501.126056 Wesemlunico records
3501.126067 2005.12.13 Handwritten rotes
1501126 Date Desolation
3501.126001 2006.1104 Law enforcemmt report regarding
Conk Kraal Date Description
3501.123.001 2006.07.13 Palm Beach PokeDepartment ncident Noon
3501.128
Date Description
1501.128 031 20051006 Palm Beach PoliceDepartment property report
1501.128 0)2 2019.07.13 Pan Beach PolceDtpartment incident recoil
3501.128 0)3 2006.07.27 Florida DAVID. individual summary page for
3501.128 OM 2006.0604 Letter from to
3501.128 COS 2006.0608 FBI ro ped dooamenting victim Information
3501.128 005 2006.0609 Notes abou
3501.1280)7 2006.01116 as signment history
3501.128.0)8 2006.06.26 PST Beach Police Department Property receipt
3501.128 009 2006.01126 Palm Beach Pole* De partment midence/property traclarg report
3501.128 010 2007.02.01 Letter frame:old Lelcoral to
3501.128 011 2007.12.11 Letter to Aleonekl Acosta from RADS Ells LLP
3501.128 012 2007.12.11 Letter to Aloaruckf Acosta from Kirkbrd Ohs LLP
3501128.013 2008.01.10 FBI letter to
3501.128.014 2008.03.24 Victim lost
3501.128015 2008.07.03 Victim lost
3501.128016 2008.07.21 Letter from to
Susan Meditates, Kathleen Cassidy,
SalnalGuha
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.0412
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.616.12
2021.616.12
2021.06.12
2021.06.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.0412
2021.0412
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.06.12
2021.06.12
2021.06.12
2021.06.12
2021.06.12
2021.0612
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1011
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202610.11
2021.10.11
2021.1011
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1015
Produced Be Dahill*
20210/.12
ProducedtoDefense
202101 12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.06.12
2021.01.12
2021.0612
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
3501.128017 2008.11.09 Lotter from to
3501 128018 birth cerlif tate
3501.128019 Various Eaccacautal file co
3501.128 020 2005.10.05 Audofdafull tap, recorded, side Al
3501.128 021 2005.10.05 /Sudo fib (clip herniae. recording:
3501.128 022 2005.10.05 /Sudo f dafull tape recording. side IN
3501.128 023 2005.10.05 Florida DAV.I.D.indnidual summary page for
3501.128 024 2005.11.13 Caw Instory search results
3501.128 025 2006.05.01 PBPO probable muse 2Mo...I regarding
3501.128 026 2006.05.01 PBPO probable oust affident regarding
3501.128 027 2008.01.10 PBS report dooamenting letters to victims
3501.128028 2019.06.21 Memorandum documenteg telephone comemnior
3501.128029 2019.06.27 Memorandum documenting contact vatn
3501.128030 Hanchollten notes
3501.128 031 Harschollten notes
3501.128 032 Sowerethot of tea message
3501.128 033 Sowerethot of ten message
3501.128 034 Sowerethot often message
3501.128 035 Samnshot of test message
3501.128 036 Sadeftd101 of test message
3501.128 037 Saeenthot of test message
3501.128038 Screen shot of test message
3501.128039 Screen shot of test message
3501.1280W Saeenshot of test message
3501.128.011 Saddr41101 of test message
3501.128 012 SOW00101 of test message
3501.128013 SOW00101 of test message
3501.128 044 SOW00101 of test message
3501.128 015 SOW00101 of test message
3501.128 016 SOCCCOM1 of test message
3501.128 017 2035.10.18 Palm Beach County *arch warrant and apNBalba
3501.128 065 2007.01.01 letter from Gerald LOICOul
3501.128 049 2007.06.15 Letter 11001G2tald Leicatal
3501.128060 2008.05.19 Email from Leftcemla
3501.128 011 2008.05.17 &Logsdon to the DAG
3501.128 032 2008.06.19 aeolssion to the PSG
3501.128 013 2008.07.10 Letter from
3501.128 07.1 2008.09.02 Letter from
3501.118 OSS 2005.10.05 HaAdmineft notes
3501.129
Adam Perry Lane
Date DenalptIon
3501.119 031 2006.11.04 law enforcement report regarding Adam Perry bog
3501.129002 2006.12.04 Search results for Adam Perry Lang
3501.129033 2006.12.04 Results from search...ew byname for Adorn Perry Lang
3501.129401 2007.0815 Ow enforcement MICR MgatdiAgAdIM Perry bog
3501.129.005 2020.09.22 Notes from call mth Larry Lustberg (tearing Adam Petry Lang
3501.129.006 2020.0915 AdaMPCITy LIM WMINICW 302
3501.129007 2020.09.15 AdamPerry Lang intentew notes
3501.130 Data Denalptlen
3501.130001 2006.01.10 PAM Beach Police Department property tOOMPt
3501.130002 2006.07.13 PAM Beach PolceDepartment Widen( report
3501.130-033 2006.07.17 Florida DAY.I.D.Inclonclual SUMMary PIO fora
3501.130034 2006.0801 Record search regard/
3501.130006 2006.08.02 Nall0041conprehonaverecon rogueing
3501.130 COS 2006.0202 -Resod of
3501.130007 204.084 letter from to
3501.130036 2006.0208 FBI memorandum tO dOCuMent slain, Information
3501131 .1009 006.08.16 ass ent history
3501.130010 2006.0226 Pam Beach Pole* Department eddencelpropertylraclog report
3501.130011 2006.0228 PaIM Beach Polce Department property receipt
3501.130012 2006.10 30 intentkow 302
3501 130013 2006 1030 intervbror notes
3501.130014 2006.11.01 Mtendow 302
3501.130015 2006.12.01 bio al information
3501.130016 2007.01.27 Tallowy of
3501.130417 2007.04.06 FBI late, to
3501.130418 2007.06.11 FBI details Is conducted
3501.130019 2017.06.11 Florida DAY.I.D.01010, veNclt status for
3501.130020 2007.06.11 Reccedssearchregarchrg
3501.130021 2007.06.12 Na00(111CCCADMACASIVOMpart regazdeg
3501.130022 2007.08.14 ritetview 302
3501 130023 2007 11 06 inen.ttw 302
3501.130024 2007.11.28 RI Ottani artatytiS conducted
3501.130025 2008.03.24 Maim lest
3501.130026 2008.04.29 Testimony of
3501.130027 2008.07.03 Victim list
3501.130028 2008.12.09 Loner from to
3501.130029 2018.12.04 -PS memorandum regarding Interview of
3501.130.030 2018.12.04 PS memorandum regarding MOM assistance program
3501.130 031 2018.11.04 PS memorandum retarding Movie., of a_ ,
3501.130 032 2019.11.04 personal information 302
3501.130033 -bbgrx RN rmatinfo on
3501.130034 VaflOuS EliOraFtdC3111/301
NJA
202L4.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
202L07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1025
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
202LOS.12
202LOS.12
202LOS.12
2021.06.12
202104.12
Pre Sad to Wass
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.4.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202L04.12
202L04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202L04.12
202LCM.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202L04.12
202L04.12
Attorney
Liar COCO LuttbOtA
Atternry
3501.130035 2006.01.09 Au0o filo (full tape retorting side Al
3501.130036 2006 01 09 IWO* f I cllp from lade recording!
3501.130033 2006.01.09 Au0o f I full tape recording. side Ell
3501.130038 2005.12.12 Florida DAVID. irclkidual summarypage for
3501 I 0039 2006.05.01 PIM) probable oust anident rdin
3501.1 POLO 2006.05.01 PIM) probable oust anident (dine I=IMI
35011 0011 2006.07 20 Lelia to torn PBPO
3501.130012 2006.07.31 Cicada DAV.I.D.Indeddual summa +a for
3501.130013 11.01 FEWroped regarding intavIent of
3501.130044 2003.00.06 FEU report regarding lector to
1.1 003 2007.IL28 FM (opal regarding exestigalicn and victim Info
3501.130046 2018.12.01 FEW report regarding Information
3501.130013 2019.06.25 Memorandum (064,0,404mo  oil pith
3501.130048 2019.07.10 FM report regarding contact with victims
3501.130019 2019.07.10 Memorandum regarding phone call vdth
3501.1 0050 2019.07.13 Memorandum rogafthrte phone call pith
3501.1 051 2019.07.19 mandmitten notes
3501.130052 Various search records relating to -
Soren:Mot of teat message 3501.130053
3501.130034 SaeeMal of tea message
3501.130055 Sa mnot of tea message
3501.1 0016 Sa eclat of tea message
3501 I 0067 Satomnot of test message
3501.1 0 CGS 2008.07.10 Leiter horn
I I 0 039 2008.09 02 Leiter from
3501.1 0 060 2003.0531 No 1.4.50xe pate retort ,
3501.130061 2006 01 09 NandnlNen note,
3501.131
Ken lamina Date Description
3501 1 1 COI 2007 05 08 Testimony of
3501.132 Date DeSaf0808
350E  COI 2007 07 Florida DAV.I.D.ind d um ary pa e loe
3501.1 2 032 2007.07.11 Fl a DAV.I.D. photo I up for
I 132403 2007 10.03 Interview 302
3501.132-001 200710.04 Fill memorandum of inteniew aitli
3501.132-005 2008 01.10 Ma letter to
3501.1 2406 2008.0 20 Vialm list
3501.132-037 2038.07.03 Vialm list
3501.132-008 2019.05.28 Emal conlalnrl scraansmts of texts
3501.1 2409 Sown:Mot ofd to
3501.1 2410 Sammtiot of M toin
3501.1 2.011 2019 28 Email coaxed,' screanshots of M teas
3501.1 2.012 SateMal of Mt.
3501.1 2.013 VarIous 8 kraphical f Ile forges
3501.1 2.014 2007.12.01 FBI report regarding phone cSI well mother
3501.1 2.015 2008.01.10 FIN report regarding letters tovNbms
3501.1 2.016 2019.05.28 Text stages vilth agent
3501.133 Date Daalistloa
3>v 133 (CU 2007.1 27 Florida DAV.I.D.Ind 0 sum el' oa lor
3501.134
Paul Andrew Lavery (Lowy)
Date Descriptaon
3501 134 COI 2005 11 16 Florida DAV I D indnidual summa f et Paul Lavwy
3501.07-037 2005.11.16 Florida DAVID. minsdual summary page for Paul Lavery
3501.134 033 3005.11.22 Leah Noels business report rout for Do Yotrutlf a Favor Inc
3501 I OM 3005.1.22 Leah Nexis person moon results for Paul Andrew Loewy
3501.134 036 2005.11.22 Curisian of Licensing agency search for Paul Lawry and associates
3501.1 005 2005.11.22 Coastal of Licensing agencysearch for Paul A. Lavery
3501.134.037 2005.11.22 PALMS sunning for Paul Andrew Lynam
3501.131006 1075.1.1 Records scotch for Paul Lawny
3501.1 009 IOM.I3.23 Nwitteatiane., Paul Lawry
3501.131010 3Wfi.07.33 Pape Beach Po1coOtpartmont oxidant report
3501.1 011 2007.06.15 Paul Lavery Interview notes
3501.131012 2007.07.30 Support of Go one response
3501.131013 Names of private Invertigato
3501.131014 Notoi regardirp Paul Lavery
3501.131015 TC with Paul tawry
3501.131016 2005.04.20 Business records
1501.134013 Vernon Records
3501.135 Date DesafiatIoa
3501.13 5 0 01-06 3 Mlsc SNOM related records fo
3501.1 5038 2005 12 10 Palm Beach Ponce 0epanment p(opeM receipt
3501.1 5069 20006.05.01 Probable Cause Affidavn rogueing Epstein
3501.135010 20006.07.33 PaMi Beach Polito Department wicident report
3501.135.071 2006.07.27 Florida DAV.I.D.Onver license transaction page
3501.135072 2006.0842 Record search reRardnx-
3501.135073 2006.08.02 NNiaai corner hen rccort et
1.135074 2006.08.02 Record of
WA
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2023.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1425
ProducedtoDefense
2021 C4 12
ProducedtoDefense
2021.0012
2021.04.12
202L01.12
2021.0812
202L01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
2021.01.12
2023.04.32
2023.04.32
2023.0412
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
ProducedtoDefense
2021N 11
ProducedtoDefense
2021.04.12
2023.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2023.0412
2023.0632
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
ProducedtoWOMB
2021.04,12
2023.0412
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
Attorney
WA
attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
3501.136075 2006.08.01 Lotter from to
3501.135076 2006.0808 FBI memorantrn to document victim Information
3501.135071 ass meat history
3501.135.0E 2006.08.16 ass meat Mstory
3501.135.079 2006.08.26 Palm Beach Polce Department andencelpropertytrackat report
3501.135.080 2006.08.28 Palm Beach Police Department property receipt
3501.136081 2006.1101 inttnits 302
3501.136062 2006.1301 intenneernotes
3501.135083 2007.02.01 Letter from Gerald Lelcourt to
3501.135034 2007.04.06 FBI tette.' to
3501.135085 2007.06.12 Record search regarding
3501.135036 2007.06.12 National ccenprehensive /non of
3501.135087 2007.06.12 Florida DAV.I.D.motor oaNclo status
3501.135033 2007.06.12 Person search fee
3501.135039 2007.07.20 Florida BAWD. indrndual summarypage
3501.135.090 2007.07.20 Florida BAWD. photo Inoue
3501.135091 2007.12.11 Letter to Aleondo Acacia from Kittens:la Ellis LIP
3501.135092 2008.03.20 Letter to lack Goldberger from Maim Kennon
3501.135093 2008.03.24 Victim list
3501.135.094 2008.07.03 Victim list
3501.135095 2008.07.10 Lefler told,/ Herman freer
3501.135096 2008.07.10 Letter to Jeffrey Herman freer
3501.135097 2018.12.0$ -FBI memorandten dooymenting 'Mame* of
3501.135098 2018 12.01 FM memorandum %eh notes of intorno/. of
3501.135099 identiywR iriormatkon
3501 135.103 Tinos of uktims
3501.135101
3501.135102 various
rNer kens.
Biograpencalf ik . co
3501.135.103 2005.12.13 /ludo fib (full tarn recording. side Al
3501.135.101 2005.12.13 Aar.° fik. (clip from tape recording:
3501.135105 2005.12.13 Aar.° fib (full tape recording. side BI
3501.135.106 2005.12.07 Various search records regatta
3501.135.107 2006.05.01 PBPD probable cause affidant repaint
350/.135106 2006.05.01 PBPD probable oust af I idea rogardin(
3501.135.109 2006.07.24 Letter to from Fin°
3501.135110 2006.11.03 FBI report regarding interview vain
3501.135.111 2018.12.01 FM report regarding information
3501.135112 Various search records regardme
3501.135.113 itandseitten notes
3501.135114 2007.02.01 Letter from Gerald Lelcourt
3501.135115 2007.05.31 My5Oace Palos
3501.135116 2007.12.11 Loner from lay Leakostu
3501.135.117 2008.07.10 Letter from
3501.135.1n 2008.09.02 Letter from
3501.135119 2008.12.05 Letter from
3501.135.120 2019.08.22 Text messages nab ;gent
3501.135.121 Handoonten notes
3501.L36 Date Desalption
3501 136031 2007 1009 Florida DAV I D Ind/nasal summary page feces
3501.137 Date Description
3931 137 031 2020 1009 interdew 302
3501.137 CO2 2020.10.09 internew rotes
3501.138 Date Desatinloa
3501.133 001.087 Mist Strad related records fo
3501.138 0313 2005.10.06 Parrn ritxh Police Department property receipt
3501.138 039 2006.05.01 ProbabIe Cause Affidayn regarding X•ffrey Cotton
3501.138 093 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Polite Department incident report
3501.138 092 2006.07.27 Florida DAY.I.D.driver license trona -Manage foe
3501.138 092 2006.08.02 National ccenprehensiverecon of
3501.138 093 2006.08.02 Record of
3501.138091 2006.08.02 identification index search of
3501.138 095 2006.06.08 FBI memoranda., to dournent victim Information
3501.138 096 2006.08.11 Loner from to
3501.138 097 2006.08.16 assignment history
3501.138 098 2006.08.38 assignment history
3501.138 099 2006.08.26 Palm Beach Polite Department midence/propeny leaden. report
3501.138100 2006.06.28 Palm Beach Police Department property receipt
3501.138101 2007.04.24 CAD Call information
3501.138.102 2007.05.18 ritenriew 302
3501.138 103 2007.05.21 ntennew 302
3501.138 104 2007.06.12 identification index search of
3501.138 105 2007.06.22 National comprehensive report of -
3501.138.106 2007.09.07 Florida DA.V.I.D.InciMdtsal summary Page for
3501.138.107 2007.09.07 Record search for
3501.138.106 2007.09.07 Record search for
3501.138409 2007.09.07 National comprehensive report of
3501.138.110 2007.13.28 FBI memorandisn regarding dotal a na)ois conducted
3501.138.111 2008.03.30 FW letter to
3501.138.112 2008.03.20 Letter to lack Goldberger from %ahoy Kerma"
3501.138.113 2008.03.24 Victim list
3501.138.114 2008.07.03 Victim list
202301.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2023.01.12
2023.01.32
2023.04.32
2023.04.32
2023.01.32
2023.01.32
2023.01.12
2021.01.12
202301.12
202301.12
202301.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2023.01.12
2023.01.12
2023.01.12
2023.01.12
2023.01.12
202301.12
202301.12
202301.11
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2022.07.23
2021.01.23
2023.07.23
2023.07.23
2023.07.23
2023.07.23
2023.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
202310.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2023.10.31
2023.20.31
2023.10.31
2023.10.31
Produced to Degtit“
20214 12
Produced to Defense
2021C4 12
20210 12
Produced20006MM
2022.04.22
2023.04.12
2023.04.32
2023.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2023.01.32
2023.01.32
2023.01.32
2023.01.32
2021.01.12
202301.12
202301.11
202301.11
202301.11
2021.01.11
2021.01.12
2023.01.32
2023.01.32
2023.01.32
2023.01.32
2023.01.32
2021.01.12
202301.12
202301.12
Attorney
WA
Attorney
NIA
Attorney
3501.138115 2008.07.10 Letter to Jeffrey Herman from
3501.138.116 2008.07.10 Letter tole of/Herman frcm
3501.138117 2019.07.23 PIN me orandwn retarding contact wall victm
3501.138118 Notes on
-n4
:55:HH:11.HHOO
X51
birth rend icatc
3501138121 2005.10.03 Florida DAV.I.D.indkidual wn ary page toe
3501.138122 2006.02.10 MySiliace pat*
3501.138123 2006.05.01 PBPD probable cause afMartt hatardln
3501.138.124 2006.05.01 PBPD probable oust afManit retardin
3501.138.125 2007.05.21 PIN report regarding Mervlevvwlh
3501.138126 2009.01.10 PIN report retarding *nets tovitlms
3501.138127 2019.07.10 PIN report retarding contact wih vice s
3501.138.122 Melon (full tact recordm4. side Al
3501.138.129 Motor, full tact record**. side B1
3501.138.130 Ando f I full tact recording)
3501.138131 Aucloti clip from tape recording;
3501.138132 Handmitten notes
3501.138133 FA So.x 0 pap
3501.138.134 Various searth roods Mara
3501.138135 Various search rCtords (nada
3501.138.136 2005.10.04 coma's
3501.138-137 2005.10.18 Palm Beach County search wamnea application
3501.138.138 2006.0804 *tier Rom
3501.138119 2007.05.31 Mysoaco DWI
3501.138140 20011.07.10 Letter from
3501.138.141 20011.09.02 titer from
3501.138142 20011.12.05 Mier fr
3501.138143 2005.10.04 Mod Pon notes
3501.138.144 2005.10.05 NandsOltm notes
3501J33
Guy Louthan Date Diesatption
3501339 001 2021.01.14 Guy Louthan ntovusv 302
3501.139 032 2021.01.14 Handonittm notes
3501340 Date
3501.140 ,032 2007.04.23 CAD Call Inkeniation
3501.141 Date Description
3501.141 031 2007.0531 Mysoace naive
350L16 Date Des0101100
3501.142.031 2017.01.26 oil complaint
3501.142-002 2019.12.24 Votc.r. from call wth Joff Pco ectaiding
3501.142.003 2020.01.03 ArtomoypraHer ion i
3501.142401 2020.02.28 lnenmw 332
- lnemtw nuts
3501.143 Date Dasalption
:5500HHIIHHOOH :101:11HH..79/ lntervlew 302
:55:HHHHH0022 :1111..793 ntOVVIeWnOteS
3501.144 Date Description
3501.144.031 2005.1030
2005.12.13
National comprehensive report for
Plod a DAVID. ubMduA summary page for 3501.144.032
3501.144.033 2006.05.01 Probable Cause AHldavi rotartIngae4frey tostc.n
3501.144.011 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Police Department Ridden( Noon
3501.144.005 2006.08.01 LW/ efiONCTOM repot tor
3501.144.006 2006.08.01 Ploda DAV.I.D.Indhid summary page for
3501.144.037 2006.08.01 Research regarding
3501.1M.038 2006.0838 Moto Yaw
3501.144.009 2006.08.26 Pain Beach Police elegoalmant e4clance/traching report
3501.144.010 2006.0828 Pain Beach Peace 91.artMent pro . receipt
3501.144011 2006.09.01 Pain Beach Po3cellepartment Mldme ripen
3501.144012 2007.02.26 Tunmeny of
3501.144013 2007.03.20 Testlmeny of
3501.144014 2007.05.07 Ploda DAV.1.D. information resarcing
3501.144015 2007.05.07 Ploda DAV.1.D. int mation matting
3501.144016 2007.05.07 I a DAV.1.D.oa port catenation tor
3501.144017 2007.05.08 Tesslmonv of
3501.144018 2007.05.15 Tesslmeny of
3501.144019 2007.05.22 m:Imeny of
3501.144020 2007.0815 Lester from to
3501.144021 2007.08.17 Law enforcemmt report tel
3501.144022 20011.02.26 PIN memoranda." totot leads to Ron
3501.144023 2009.03.18 Tetlimeny of
3501.144.024 20011.04.29 Teslimenyof
3501.144.025 2009.06.09 National can rehensiv¢r n for
3501.144 026 2009.06.09 Person search retarding
3501.144.027 2009.06.11 WA% person MOM on
3501.144023 2010.04.13 soon
WA
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
2021.10.25
2021.10.25
Produced to Odense
2021.0723
Produced to Doane
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021 04 12
Produced to Odense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2022.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Diem
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Attorney
,r/A
Attorney
NM
Attorney
'WA
Attorney
)(Ahoy Pop
Attorney
Na
Attorney
3501.144029 2018.12.04
FEU memorandtm regarding pronging information to Miami
clMsloo
3501.144030 2018.12.04
Ka memorandwa regarding forwarders photographs of =
3501.144031 2018.12.04 1E4 memorandum regarding contact mill
3501.144032 2019.08.11 EN cnsis intake report
3501 144033 2019 10.11 ntennew 302
3501.144.034 2019.10.11 nternew notes
3501.144.035 2019.10.15 ntennew 302
3501.144036 2019.10.15 interview notes
3501.144.037 2019.10.25 ntennew 302
3501.144038 2019.10.25 -internew notes
3501.144039 Document provided by
3501.144010 Document provided by
3501.144.011 Document provided by
3501.144.012 Document provided by
3501.144.013 2005.10.10 National ccomarehensive Report regarding
3501.144.044 2007.08.27 RI report regarding watch list
3501.144015 2007.11.28 RI report regarding Mesligation and victim informatior
3501.144016 2010.11.34 RI report regarding tat ligation
3501.144017 2010.11.26 EN repot retarder,
3501.144048 2010.11.26 EN report regrading
3501.144019  2010.12.10 F6 report regarding
3501.144050 2010.12.10 Fl3, report regarding =_
3501.144051 2005.01.19 IPME statcment
3501.144052 2005.03.03 Eve's Garden recetA
3501.144053 2005.10.18 Pam Beach County search warrant and applkation
3501.144%4 2007.0306 Letter from Geoid takeoff
3501.144055 2008.06.19 Sktrnission to the DAG
3501.144.056 2019.10.07 Attorney proffer notes
3501.144057 2020.01.08 Mae (rem
3501.144058 2020.01.08 Email regarding threats
3501.144.059 2020.06.04 gm* rflardirtvea
3501.144.060 2020.07.14 Text mosukc=with cm
3501.144.061 2020.07.15 (mai frorn
3501.144.052 2020.07.19 (mai Iran
3501.144%3 2020.07.28 Emal Iran
3501 144.054 202008.03 Emal to
3501.144%5 2021.04.21 Emal Iran
3501.144%6 2021.10.11 totter regarding= and
3501.144%7 Employment search records
3501.144068 I-MS*50M label
ISOILIAS
Date DesalP1loa
3501.145%1 2021 02 03 Email from to TA
3501.145402 20230303 V01.00Mi I message
3501.145403 20230301 VOICOTIA I mevsag0
3501.145034 2021.0306 emew 302
3501 145405 2021 02 11 inmemew 302
3501.145.006 2021.03.03 Ftotrographs from
3501 145.007 2021 03 03 intentew 302
3501.145038 2021.03.03 intemm notes
3501.145.009 through 049 2021.03.03 Ftotrogractrs from
3501.145450 2021.02.01 Email fran Vend McCawky
3501.145051 2021.02.01 Email Irma
3501.145052 2021.02.08 Email frcen
3501.145053 2021.02.11 (mai frota
3501.145.054 202/.02.13 (mai frota
3501.145 055 2021.02.11 (mai from -
3501.145 036 2021.02.11 (mai Iron
3501.145 037 2021.02.11 Attachment to email
3501.145338 2021.03.02 (mai Iron
3501 145059 2021 03 03 (mai Iron
3501.145.050 2021.03.03 (mai Iron
3501 145.051 2021 03 03 (mai Iron
3501.145.052 2021.03.03 (mai Iron
3501.145.063 2021.03.03 (mai Iron
3501.145.064 2021.03.03 (mai Iran
3501.145465 2021.113.03 (mat from
3501.145466 2021.03.03 illlaa from
3501.145.067 2021.03.03 Email frcen
3501.145058 2021.03.03 (mat frcm
3501.145019 2021.03.03 (mai Iron
3501 145070 2021 0303 (mai Iron
3931.145071 2021.03.03 (mai Iron
3501 145.072 2021 03 03 (mai Iron
3501.145.073 2021.03.03 (mai Iron
3501 145074 2021 03 03 (mai Iron
3501.145075 2021.03.03 (mai Iron
3501.145076 2021.03.03 (mat Iron
3501.145077 2021.03.03 (mad frcen
3501.145073 2021.113.03 Email from
3501.145079 2021.03.03 Email (rem
3501.145080 2021.03.03 Email hem
3501.145081 2021.03.03 Email frcen
3501.145%2 2021 03 03 (mat from
3501.145083 2021.03.03 (mat from
3501 145484 2021 03 01 (mai Iron
3501.145485 2021.03 01 (mai Irorn-
AaroiM sitmcc
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
Produced to Delano
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202L10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
Attorney
3501.145MS 2021.03.04 Email frown
3501 145 087 2021 03.04 Email frown d-
3501.145088 2021.03.04 Email frown
3501 145 099 2021 0304 Email frown
3501145 090 2021.0304 (mat frown
3501145 091 2021.03.04 Email Irons
3501.145 092 2021.03.04 Email Irons
3501.145093 2021.03.04 Email ftwa
3501.145.09S 2021.03.04 Email trans
3501.145.095 2021.03.04 Email from
3501.145096 2021.03.04 Email Iron
3501.145.097 2021.03.04 final frown
3501.145096 2021.03.04 final frown
3501.145099 2021.03.04 Gnat frown
3501.145400 2021.03.04 Gnat Irons
3501.145101 2021.03.04 Attachment to email
3501.145102 2021.03.04 (mai Irons
3501.145103 2021.03.05 (mai Irons
3501.145104 202/.03.05 (mai Irona
3501145.105 2021.02.06 ia,tonigsv notes
3501145.106 20210111 I intoMow notes
3501.106 Date Doscilptke
3501.146 001 2006.08.02 Florida DAVID. indhidual summary page for
3501.146 ON 2006.08.02 PALMS Screen
3501.146-01 2006.08.02 CAD Call vitoanation for house check
3501.1460:4 2006.08.02 CAD Call vitoanation for susoklous vehicle
3501.146,0)5 2006.0801 lolonbt Nation arida search of
3501.146,035 2006.0301 Florida DAY.I.D.driver license transaction page
3501.146,007 2006.0805 letter llama to
3501.144038 2006.0608 National comprehensive resort tor
3501.146,009 2006.0808 1W memorandum to document victim informatom
3501.146-010 2006.08.10 memos 302
3501.146-011 2006.06.10 inter...Kw notes
3501.146-012 2018.12.04 FBI memoranda n documenting interviva of
3501.146-013 2018.11.00 FBI nolo: of Merv**. with
3501.146-014 tl enOMM lnformayon
3501.146 015 Various Biographical Moon
3501.146 016 2003.02.22 112E CAD Cal Information
3501.146 017 2004.0618 IITE CAD Cal Information
3501.146 018 2006.07.31 Florida DAV.I.D.Iodhiclual summary page for
records cepa 3501.146 019 2006.06.01 Various search
3501.146 020 2006.06.11 FBI moat regarding intoruscw of
3501146 021 201811.04 FBI repot regardin inforanatiw
3503-147 Date Drialption
350E 2020.07.15 Monism/ 302
3501.142-01 2020.0x15 nternew notes
3501.10-01 2019.11.01 Intones" 301
3501.10-000 2019.11.01 Intoning Notes
3501.148
eatrkk McKenna DM Dosciptkes
39)1 148 0)1 2006.11.11 Florida DAVID. indnidual summary page for Patoct McKenna
3501148 032 2006.11.11 Florida DAY.I.D.IndhIdual summary page f of Panel McKenna
3501.143 Data Brettlptkes
350E 2005.12.02 Florida DAV.I.D.Iodhiclual summary page foa
3501.149.002 2005.12.11 National comprehensive ropan for
3501.149.003 2005.12.13 PALMS Screening regarding
3501.149.0M 2006.0601 Pramble Cause Affidavn re/arcing X.frev Cotten
3501.149.035 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Palo Department Widen( moon
3501.149.036 2006.07.25 5uteelsslon of matatak locate Ide
3501.149.037 2006.07.17 Florida DAY.I.D.dnver license transaction page forte
moon fof 3501.149.038 2006.08.02 Malawi comprehensive
3501.149.009 2006.01302 Record en due
3501.149010 2006.08.02 Record search regarding
3501.149011 2006.06.11 Letter from to
3501.149012 2006.0616 %%Moment Nstory
3501.149013 2006.0631 AutorrackgP 0:lutist*
3501.149014 2006.06.31 AutorrackX3 0:lutist*
3501.149015 2006.09.03 Mecical tercet for
3501.149016 2006.09.01 Certificate of bath fa
3501.149017 2006.09.15 Mecical recceds for
3501.149 Old 2007.01.20 letter from to lames Members
3501.149 019 2007.01.C6 Testimony of
3501.149 020 2007.01.11 Loner Bun Samos Eisenberg to
3501.149 021 2007.00.23 CAD Call information
3501.149 022 2007.00.20 Draft notes of Inteniew
3501.149 023 2007.04.24 Notes of intarvIciv
3501.149 024 2007.04.24 Record,/ of intenders !part II
3501.149 026 2007.04.24 Rooming of 'Monier, 21 limn
N/A
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
2021.10.11
2021.1011
2021.10.11
2021.1011
2021.1011
2021.1011
2021.10.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1011
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.0412
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
Produced to Proms
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.1011
1021.10.11
Produced to Please
2021.0412
2021.04.12
Produced Be Odense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202106.12
2021.0612
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.0412
2021.0412
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.0612
2021.0612
Attorney
N/A
Attorney
WA
Attorney
N/A
Attorney
3501.149026 2007.05.08 Testimony of
3501.149027 2007.09.07 Florida DAVID. indMdtsal swnmary page for
3501.149.02g 2007.09.07 National comprehensive report for
3501.14%029 2007.09.07 Record search regardec
3501.149.030 2018.01.10 Fill letter to James Eisenberg
3501.149031 2006.02.25 Palm Beach Pak* Department intelligence moon
3501.149032 2006.03.18 Testimony of
3501.149.033 2008.03.24 Victim let
3501.149034 2006.04.29 Testimony of
3501.149.035 2006.07.03 Victim lest
3501.149036 2019.07.14 niondem 302
3501.149037 2019.07.14 nteniew notes
3501.149038 birth certdicate
3501.149039 Notes on
3501.149.010 Research regarding
3501.149.061 Florida DAV.I.D.driver kerne transaction page Ice
3501.149.062 Various Ellographical tilt co
3501.149.063 Several video tiles
3501.11904 2007.0424 Au00 tilt
3501.149.015 2007.0%324 /Sudo tilt
3501.149016 2005.12.12 Various search records roma
3501.149047 2007.12.17 Letter to Mery ckf Acosta from Kenneth Starr
3501.149.018 2006.01.10 FW re rMardln8 Inters to uktims
3501.149.069 Various search records regarchtt
3501.149.050 2006.01.09 Sulastriber records
3501.149.051 2006.0801 Letter to
3501.149.052 2006.09.14 Letter regarding
3501.149.053 2006.09.21 Letter regarding IM M
3501.149.06A 2006.11124 Letter regarding
3501.149.055 2007.04.27 Transcript
3501.14%066 2007.12.21 Letter from letkowilz
3501.149.057 2006.0539 Email
3501.149.054 2006.0627 Starr AA:mission to D40
3501.149.059 2006.06.19 Starr sal:mission to D40
3501.149050 2006.12.06 Email and letter
3501.149061 Materials reptcloggranchury appearance
3501.14%062 SM. materials
3501.14%063 Materials regarang grandjury testrnony
3501.149. 64 Texts Ann men:
3501.149.055 Attachment to tens with ageM
3501.149.056 Attachment to tens with ageM
3501.149.067 Attachment to tens with ageM
3501.149 063 Voicernal
3501.150 Date Desalplion
3501.156031 2006.07.13 Palm Beath PelicoDepanment Kaden( repori
3501.156002 2009.10.06 Deposition o
3501151 Date Dasalptlon
3501.151 CO1 2020.03.04 interview 302
3501 151032 2020 03 04 interview notes
350/.151003 2020.03.04 Documents provide." lay
Date DeratptIon
3501.151001 2006.12.04 Amon search tor
3501.151032 2006.12.06 Law enforcemmt repot regarding
3501.153 Date Dosalplion
350E 2006.12.04 Person search for
3501.153002 2006.12.06 Law enforcemmt repcet warding
350L154 Date Ossalption
3501.154 031 2006.12.01 Penon search toe
1501.154.002 2006.12.06 U., enforcement report ritardlnil
MALIN Date DeralptIon
3501.156001 2006.12.13 nterviewnott:
3501 155.002 2006 12 13 Aterview 302
3501.155.003 2018.12.04 FS! memerandt",mth nolet of = Itorvie..
3501.155.006 2018.12.04 Fr3i memorandum documenting interview of
interview 302 3501.155035 2020.1009
3501 155.006 2020.1a29 bgaview notes
3501.155.00 ide tion
3501.155.038 2006.12.13 FW report regarding intelvA 9fl uirti
3501.155009 2018.12.04 FW moat regarding informarmr
3501.156 Date DeralptIon
3501.156 001 2005.10.13 Palm Beach Odic. Department properly receipt
3501.156002 2006.05.01 Probable Cause Aftdavn retanling Jeffrey Cotton
3501.156003 2036.07.13 Pain Beach Police Department Widen( report
202L01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.06.12
2021.04.12
2021.06.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202L01.12
202LO4.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202L07.23
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1031
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
2021.10.11
Produced to Debase
2021.04.12
202L01.12
Produced to Defense
2021 04 12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Producedto Miss
2021 04.12
2021 0/.12
Produced to Delano
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Delano
20210.11
2021.04.12
202L01.12
202LO4.12
202L04.12
202L0t12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202LCIA12
Patent..
N/A
Attorney
Attorney
NIA
Attorney
NIA
Attorney
Attorney
NIA
Attorney
3501.1560M 2006.08C6 FBI memorandum to document victim Information
3501 156005 2006 0811 letter areal to
3501.15600 2006 0816 nt history
3501.1560)7 2006.0626 PaM Beach Poke Department eAdenceftracting report
3501.1560)8 2007.01.01 letter from Gerald Lefrourt to
3501.156009 2007.01.12 Letter from lames Eisenberg to
3501.156010 20(17.03.13 interneve notes
3501.156011 200703.13 intennew 302
3501.156012 20)7.03.20 Tenn of
3501.156013 2007.03.20
Cal) Call irdconation
bleenAcer 302
3501.156014 2007.04.24 reefers suspicious person
3501.156015 2007.04.24 CAD Call morn atioe regarding traffic stop
3501.156016 2007.1211 Letter tenter:mom Acosta from Incident:I & Ellis LIP
3501156017 2019.12.04 Jaen Inkrmatico
3501.156018 birth certificate
3501.156019 idmttrr lnfamaten
3501.156020 Various elejjacettal PM CO
3501.156021 2005.10.12 Auclo filafull taps. recordett, sine Al
3501.156022 2005.10.12 Patio file (clip from tape recording:
3501.156023 2005.10.12 Alga° flit (full tape recording, side Et)
3501.156024 2005.10.11
Florida DAV.I.D. individual summary page regarding_
IMMI
3501.156425 2006.0801 KIM probable oust affident regarding
3501.156406 2006.0801 MPG probable oust anident regarding
3501.156427 20)7.03.20 FBIreport regarding intennew of
3501.156423 2018.1204 FBI report regarding intennew of
3501.156409 Nandemitten rotes
3501.156030 My50.140 races
3501.156031 2006.0804 letter from
3501.156032 2007.02.01 letter frame:old Went
3501.156033 2007.12.11 Letter from lay Lefkorniz
3501.156034 2009.12.)7
Palm Beach County complaint (Epstein sr. Scott Rothstei ,=M
and LAI) ...M.
3501.157 Date Desolation
3501.157 001 2008.04.23 National canprehenshve moon for
3501.157 002 2008.04.30 Lserenforcemcnt report regarding
3501.157 003 2008.04.30 Person search retarding
3503.153 Date Description
3591 158 0)1 2020.12.15 in.enore 302
3591 158 0)2 2020.12 15 P rile( Neve notes
3503-199 Data Deal.=
3501.159 031 2006.07.28 EMINI inatenal witness statement efficient
3501.1594302 2006.07.28 Palm Beath Felice Department property receipt
3501.159.003 200807.28 Photo roe .0 into...tons
3501.159401 200807.28 Moto Iry co
3501.159405 2006.0801 Dater from  to
3501.159.006 2006.0807 Pages from Pa,. Beach Voice )apartment Incident Noon
3501.159.007 2006.0807 Pages from Palm Beach Voice Department Indent Rcoort
3501.159.0)8 2006.08.07 Pages from Faro Beach Voice Department incident Report
3501 159.009 2006.08.07 Pages from Palm Beach Voice Department Indent Report
3501.159010 2006.08.07 Pages from Pan, Beath Poke Department Indent Report
3501.159011 2006.0808 FBI memorandion to document Nairn Information
3501.159012 2006.10.23 Menlo,. notes
3501.159013 2006.10.24 InteMew 302
3501.159.014 2006.10.24 ntereger notes
3501.159.015 2006.10.24 FBI memorandum Mils notes of IMennew
3501.159.016 2007.0227 Testimony°,
3501.159.017 2007.04.06 ND letta to
3501.159.013 2007.06.08 Records search of
3501.159019 2007.06.12 Florida DAY.I.D.OlOtor NAM! Mann for
3501.159.020 2007.06.12 Rotate search of
3501.159.021 2007.06.12 Meerut oxnprehonsive report for
3501.159.022 2008.01.31 Marten notes
3501.159023 2008.01.31 Mennen notes
3501.159024 2008.01.31 intent** 302
3301.159025 2008.02.01 IMOMew 302
3301.159026 2008.07.21 Letter from to
3301.159027 2008.12.09 letter tram to
3501.159023 2008.12.09 Letter from to
3501.159029 2018.12.04 113 memorandum to Oacument intemen of
3501 159.030 2019 04 11 Mernew 302
3301.159031 2019.04.11 nternew Pearl
3501 159.032 2019 05 29 tverotw 302
3501.159033 2019.05.29 Meninx notes
3501.159034 2019.06.19 Tranteniat reterenern
3501.159035 2021.01.03 Phone call from
3501.159036 brth certificate
3501.159037 2004 notC000kpaROS
3301.15901E 2004.08.30 Federal Credit uNco ckposit sips
3301.159039 2004.10.31 Federal Credit uNon statement
3301.159010 tos
3301.159041 school planon
3301.15900 2006.07.28 Video We
3301.159013 2006.07.28 Video file
N/A
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202110.11
202110.11
2021.10.11
2021.1011
Produced to Debase
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
Produced to Odense
2021 Oa 12
2021 10 11
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney

╭──────────────────────── Page 30, Image 1 ─────────────────────────╮
│ a Date ‘Attorney Produced to Defense:                             │
│                                                                   │
│ SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER PARAGRAPHS 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, and 17 30 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

3501.159014 2006.0602 Florida DAVID. indendual stenmary page foe
Wind Mer-anley
202L07.23
3501.159 016 2516.0.8.16 National cceoprehensiverecon for 202L07.23
3501.159 016 2006.1104 181 report regarding interview with 2021.07.23
3501.159 017 2537.13.23 FEti report regarding investigation and victim Infomutior 2021.02.23
3501.159 048 2008.01.31 FBI report regarding interview with- 2021.07.23
3501.159 019 2018.12.04 Fill repot regarding information 2021.0}.23
3501.159060 Various search records regardag 2021.0}.23
3501.159051 Various search records resarclest 2021.07.23
3501.1 9062 2006.0104 Florida DAV I I) driver license transaction pate 2021 30.31
3501.1 9.063 2037.05. 31 MVSpace p 2021.30.11
3501.159-05 2001.07.10 Letter from 2021 30.11
3501.159055 2001.07.21 Letter from 2023.30.11
3501 159056 2008.09.02 Letter from 2021.10.11
3501.159057 2019.04.51 Teat Messages with agent 202L10.11
3501.1 9.068 2020.07.01 Vgttmal Iran= 2021.10.11
3501.159059 2020.07.16 Email w8h 2023.10.11
3501 159.050 202007 16 Email with 2023.10.11
3501.159051 2021.07.16 Email with= 2023.10.11
3501.1 9.052 202017.36 Email ith= 2021 30.11
3501.159053 2020.07.16 Email FM= 2023.30.11
3501.159061 2020 D7 36 FmailwFM= 2023 10.11
3501.159-065 2020.17.36 Email with= 2023.30.31
3501.159-001 Hanchotten note. 2021 30.31
3501.159467 Flandmitten notes 2021.30.31
3501.159-068 2019.06.01 FBI Report 2023.10.11
3501.159059 2021.03.13 FBIReport 2023.10.11
3501.159070 Biographical file en 2021.10.11
3501.160 Date Dosalpeen Attorney Produced to Defense
501.160001 tivoA91038 Misr ol documents for
N.P.
2021.14.12
3501.1612084 006 07 Palm Police Department Mldmt reoon 2021.04.12
3501.160085 birth con to 2021.0132
3608161 Date Dosalption Attorney Produced to bl ew
3501.161 003 5020.0821 weenie 302
5VA
3501,161001 2020 08.21 weeMew notes 2021 04 12
3501.162 Date Desalpifee Attorney Produced to Odense
1. 2001.01.30 National conprehenuvernon For
Almandra Colton
Roberta Kaplan
2023.01.12
3501.162402 200110929 114 memorandum to dournent interaction with 2021.01.12
3501.162403 2008 29 'subpoena served on 2021 0612
3501.162401 2008. 29 interview301 2021.01.12
3501.162036 21/08.06.31
FS memorandwo to document service of subpoena to
2021.01.12
3501.162-006 200806.31
FS memorandwo to document service of subpoena to
IME 2021.01.12
3501.162-007 2008.06.09 Lens Heals Person report for 2021 01 12
3501.168008 2001.06.09 National conprehonsive report for 2021.01.32
3501.162-009 2518 06.09 TEM passenger actMty report for 2121 01.12
3501.162-010 3001.0618 National comprehensive report for 2021.01.32
3501.162-011 3001.0619 T.Mobile subscribe detaled for 2023.01.12
3501.162-012 2001.0620 Record search for- 2023.01.12
3501.162-013 2019.03.01 nternew notes 2023.01.12
3501.162.014 2019.03.01 ntendow 302 2023.01.12
3501.162-015 2019.04.06 nterriew notes 2023.01.12
3501.162.016 2019.61.20 ntendow 302 2023.01.12
3501.162.017 2019.04.24 nterriew notes 2021.01.12
3501.162.018 2019.05.02 nteMow photo Sub/ 2021.01.12
3501.162019 2019.06.02 - InteMew photo cute 2121.01.12
3501.162020 2019 DS.02 photo tuba
nteMow photo ellotet
2021 04 12 -InteMow
3501.162 023 2019.05.02 2021.01.12
3501.162022 2019.05.02 nteMow photo ellotet 2021 01.12
3501.162023 2019.05.02 nteMow photo ellotet 2021.01.12
3501 162 024 2019.05.02 ntendew 302 2023.01.12
3501.162 026 2019.05.02 nterview notes 2023.01.12
3501 162-026 201909.16 ntendow 302 2023.01.12
3501.162 027 2019.0601 nteMow notes( 3) 2023.01.12
3501 162 028 5)19 DS OS nteMew notes( 2) 2021.01.12
3501.162 029 2019.05 08
'InteMew
prone( ayeemmt 2023.01.12
3501.162030 2019.05 23
21)19.06.23
notes
2021 0612
3501.162 011 -InteMow 2123. 12
3501.162 032 21)19 19 Transcript tenon 2021 01.32
3501.162-033 2019.07.19 Transcript r trendy 2021.01.32
3501.162-03 photos 1 19 2121 01.12
3501.162.03S Varous BagraphealBloon- 2021.01.12
3501.162-036 Nxional compiehensiverecon for 2023.01.12
3501.162-037 Mazeuse nu 2023.01.12
3501.162-016 Jeffrey Epstein metsaget 2023.01.12
3501.162-039 2008.134.30 National comprehensive moan for 2023.07.23
3501.162010 2008.0929 Memorandum regardhiinteniew toth 2023.07.23
3501.162011 2008.06.29 15 report regarding interview with 2021.07.23
3501.162012 2008.06.31 Memorandum aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa 2023.07.23
3501.162013 2008.06.31 531 report regarding Mery 2021.07.23
3501.162014 through 3501.162.168 2019.06.02 Photo suNbits from 2019.05.02 interview 2023.30.11
3501.163 Date DeusIplian
3501 163 0)1 2006.07 31 material witness statement
3501,163002 2006.07.31 photo We ay Instructions
3501.163003 2006 .05.02 Florida DAVID. Ind/Moat summary page for
for 3501.163034 2006 0602 PALMS Screen
3501.166005 200fi.0602 CAD Call 'germane° rooming suspicious vehicle
3501.163-006 206.0607 Pages Iran Palm BeachPoke Department Inciant report
3501.163037 266.086 Pages from Palm Beach Poke Department Indekrit report
3501.163408 IWfi.0602 FBI memorandum to document vl0lm lnforma0an
3501.163-009 Various BiogyaphiCal f de co
1.163-010 2001.0808 111E CAD Cal Iorltution t
3501.163-011 206.07.31 Nio
3501.163-012 2036.02.01 Florida DAV.I.D.sdMdualsummarypagefar-
records re gx44e3501.163-013 Va us Various search
3501163-014 2006.07 1 Notes from inteMew
3501.166015 2006.0604 letter from
3501.163016 2006 0611 letter from
3501.163-017 2007.06.07 letter from
3501.163013 2007.06.07 Letter from
3501.163019 2001.07.10 Letter from
1 163020 200.09.02 Letter from
1.163021 200 .12.05 letter from
3501 163-022 2019 06.13 Memorandum from oil web
3501.164 Date Desatptioa
3501 164 0)1 2005 08.17 Notes ardl s of marr landscapers
3501.164.002 2006.10.15
Florida DAV.I.D.indhichaal summary page foe
AM.
3501.164.036 206.12.04 Law enforcement report regarding
3501.164001 2006.12.00 ced search for
3501.164.005 2006.12.00 Search Index by name of
3501.145 Date Description
3501.165 0)1 20200826 IMeMaw 302
3501,165002 2020.0826 MeMaw notes
3501.166 Date Description
3501166 0)1 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Pole* Department ncldent raven
3501 166 0)2 2007 11 02 agen5aw n os
3502166 0)3 2007.11.02 -YNOMaw 02
3501.166 ON 206.05.01 PBPO probable ouse an aM regarding
3501.166 005 206.0601 PBPO probable ouse anent regarding
1 166 CO6 2007 11 C6 POI re echo interviewynth
3501.167 Dee Descelptlee
3501167.031 2005 10.05 Pam Beach PcdceDtpanme 1 property receipt
3501.167402 206.07.13 Palm Beach Police Department Mcident noon
3501.167-06 206.086 Record arch re tdrig
3501.167.001 2006060 National comprehend recon for
3501.167-005 206.066 FBI memorandwn to dorument vlalm lnfotmaon
3501.167405 206.0616 tom nt history
3501.167.007 306.0826 Palm Beach Ponce Department midenceipropartytrackeg report
3501.167 2006.6.28 Palm Beach Peace Department pro real
3501.167409 2006.10.03 EdyStaxe profile for
3501.167.010 2007.02.01 Letter from Gerald Lefrourt to
3501.167.011 2007.03.21 FBI memorandum to recntst travel inteMew a
3501.167-012 2007.03.22 Mtervieve 302
3501.167-013 2007.03.22 interview 302
3501.167-014 2007.03.22 interview notes
3501.167-015 2007.05.6 Testinwry of
3501.167.016 2007.05.15 Testimony of
3501.167417 2007.05.18 ntaavle notes
3501.167018 2007.05.18 mtervNw 36
3501.167-019 2007.05. 31 WO
3501.167420 2007.06.02 Record re east r 0
3501 167401 200706.12 Record 'ratchet rd
3501.167422 2007.06.12 Fialional rcemarehenUve n for
3501.167423 2007.06.22 FBI memorandum documenting amnion of subpoena
3501.167@! 2007.07.20 Flor a DAVID. dual summary page for
3501.167-025 2007.126 ntery1N 36
3501.167026
.00.29
&
206.03.18 Testinwrirof
3501.167-027 cerbf atem of immunizadon
3501.162.00E ntervww 302
3501.167029 Palen Baxh Police 0 p rim nt property receipt
3501.167-020 record
3501.167031 14K5traphiC01100 on
3501.167032 2005.10.03 Florida DAV.I.D..ndnidual si.mmarr pa efor
3501.167033 2005.10.01 *ado aio I WI lope retordoAl
3501.167434 2005.1001 AudioMeWin from tape imordin '
Produced to Detente
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202607.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202610.11
202610.11
2021.10.11
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2022.00.22
2022.00.22
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
Produced to Defense
202:0 :2
202:04 :2
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
Produced (*Odense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2023.04.32
2023.04.32
2021.0612
202601.12
202601.12
202601.12
2021.0612
202601.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
202604.12
2021.0612
202601.12
202601.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
Anomie
Skeen
Attorney
WA
Attorney
Attorney
Attorney
3501.167035 2005.10.04 MaoriBOJO Urn recordhg side AI
3501.167036 2005.10.04 Ando file (clip from tape recording!
3501.167037 2005.10.04 Ando filafull tape retardate. LOON
3501.167036 2006.0110 My5pare pages
3501.167039 2006.0901 PEW° probable °ottani/13.ot r rdin
3501.167410 2006.0901 PBPD probable oust affidavit regarding
3501.167411 2007.03.21 FBI report regarding travel to interview
3501.167442 2007.03.23 FBI rep0rt regardlne interview with
3501.167.043 20117.0925 FBI report regardin8 intaview with
3501.1674Y 2007.11.28 FBI re port regarding byresligalica and victim Infomu0or
3501.167445 2012.12.04 FBI report regarding Mar iewwith
3501.167416 2005.10.05 Florida DAVID. indhldual summary page for
3501.167417 Various search records regardmg
3501.167418 Handornten notes
3501.167419 2005.10.18 Pan Beach County search warrant and application
3501.167050 2006.0804 Letter from
3501.167051 2006.0811 Letter from
3501.167052 2007.02.01 Lent( from Gerald Waxy(
3501.167053 2007.06.25 letter from Gerald Lelcowl
3501.167054 2007.12.11 letter from lay 144104,44
3501.167055 20011.07.10 letter from
3501.167056 20011.07.21 letter from
3501.167057 20011.09.02 letter from
3501.167058 20011.09.15 letter from
3501.167059 2008.12.05 tenet from
3501.167030 Search records
3501.167061 Ted records and
3501.167062 Submission to the DAG
3921.167063 2005.10.03.01 Nandontten notes
Deft Descdptloa
3501.168.021 2007.02.27 Tesilmcny of
3501.168.032 2007.1002 interva nolet
3501.168.033 2007.1002 interktew 302
3501.168.001
2006.04.29
&
2008.03.18 Testimony of
3501.168 COS 2019.09.18 in.entees 302
3501.168 0:6 2019.09.18 katentevi notes
3501.168007 identitsing information
3501.168008 2007.10.18 FBI report, rdin ntmwwwdh
3501.168009 2018.12.04 FBI report regarding int Ith
3501.168 010 202007.08 intake report (gardens
3501.168 011 2008.07.10 totter from
3501.168 012 2008.0902 letter Nom
3501.168 013 2008.12.09 letter Nom
3501.168 014 2019.0643 Memorandum from call *nth
3501.168 015 2019.08.26 Text message-n.10+ agent
3501.168 016 2019.10.01 (mat
3501.168 017 2019.10.23 (mat
3503.16/9 Data DralptIon
3501.169031 2007.08.23 internew notes
3501.16%002 2007.08.23 interview 302
1501.16%001 2007.09.04 FW repal regarding interview with
350L170 Date ones
3501.170-031 2020.10.09 interview307
3501.170 002 2020.10.09 interview handwritten note:
3501.170003 2021.03.01 Notes from all with counsel
3501.171 Date Dmalptlen
39)1 171 031 2006.12.14 Florida DAY.I.D.Indrndull swernerr page for
3501.172 Date Desorption
3501.172-001 2009.1020 Deposition of Volume I. West Pan Beach, FL
3501.172032 2009.1020 Depositicm of Volume II West Pan Beach, Ft
3501.172033 2006.1104 taw enforcement re r rdin;
3501.172004 emailaddress
3501172.005 2005.1006 Search records
3501.173 Dells Desorption
3501.1730311 3501.173.042 Various set031 records
3501.17343 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Police MINIM Incident gear.
3501.17344 2006.06.02 Dwell/WO:Med repCet regarding
3501.173.45 200806.06 FIN memorandum doo/menting victim infonmatico
3501.173.46 2006.08.16 ass meat 111510
3501.17347 2006.08.26 Palm Beach Police Department Dridence/Property Tracking Rayon
3501.17348 2006.06.28 Pam Beach Police Department Property Receipt
3501.17349 2019.03.22 Intmkw300
3501.173.50 2019.03.22 interview handovittal notes
Biographtal I de 3501.173.51 Various on
WA
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
2021.10.11
2021.1025
Produced to Defame
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2022.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.1025
2021.10.25
ProducedtoDam
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.10.12
Produced to Mimosa
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021 03 12
Produced to Defense
2021.0612
Produced to Odense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.07.23
2021.0723
2021.10.11
Produced to Defame
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.0612
2021.0612
2021.06.12
2021.06.12
2021.06.12
2021.06.12
2021.116.12
Attorney
Robert
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
hammy
N/A
Attorney
3501.173.52 2006.04 OS Audotilafull tap, recordirli
Sigrid McCauley
2021.07.23
3501173.53 2006.04 OS Pude f ik. Cello of tape worth 2021.07.23
3501173.54 2006.09 11 letter from 2021.10.11
3501174 Date Desatplion Mornay ProducedtoMeanie
350E 2019.07.17 meeting and pood“bon of protcgsaons 302
Sigrid McCauley
2021.04.12
350/.174002 2019.07.17 Photograitis produced by 2021.0412_
3501.174.003 2019.07.17 Photographs Produced by 2021.04.12
3501.174.004 2019.07.17 Photographs produced by 2021.04.12
3501.174.005 2019.0528 i intentmv 302 2021.04.12
3501.1744306 2019.08.28 in:endive hanelm Men notes 2021.04.12
3501.174.007 2019.06.13 Typed intenlew notes 2021.07.23
3501.174.008 2019.06.13 HanOnrittcn ,nternew notes 2021.07.23
3501.174.009 2019.06.13 itanc/writtco internew notes 2021.07.23
3501.174 010 2020.01.31 Email web 2021.10.11
3501.175 Date Omelettes Attorney Produced toDeems*
3101.175401 2008.01.06 Law eNoreament report regarding
krA
2021.04.12
3501.175032 2008.01.01 FOYSPace Page 2021.04.12
1501.175003 2008.01.06 Paton search for 2021.04.12
3501.175.004 2008.03.17 internee 302 2021.04.12
3501.175405 2008.03.22 internee 302 2021.04.12
3501 1754306 2008 C4.22 intenimv record 202L0Al2
3501.175.007 2008.0422 intenimv record 2021.01.12
3501 175.008 201902 10 interview 302 2021.04.12
3501.175.009 2019.02.10 interview 302 2021.04.12
3501.175.010 Various Page from biological file cm 2021.04.12
3501.175.011 Various Etiological Ideal 2021.04.12
3501.175.012 2008.03.22 Memorandum regarden. internee *nth 2021.07.23
3501.175.013 2008./3.22 FBI report regarding interview with 2021.07.23
3501.175.014 2008.04.22 FBI report regarding interview with 2021.07.23
3501.175.015 2019.01.31 FBI report 2021.10.11
3501176 Date D44019906 Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.176 031 2007.06 29 Florida DAVID. individual summary page foe WA 2021 03 12
3501.177 Date DeS040040 Attorney Produced to Odense
3501.177031 2004.03.20 Student progress and de re tort for
N/4
2021.04.12
3501 177.002 2007 09 26 Florida DAY I D WI/Actual stoma 0 fa 2021.04.12
3501.177.003 2005.11104 Pude filafull tap, recording) 2021.07.23
3501.177.004 2035.10.04 Pude lilt (clip °Wee recording! 2021.07.23
3501.171005 2005.10.04 Voicanats from 2021.10.11
3501.177.036 2006.0111 Victim reds letter 2021.10.11
350L179 Data Owatonna Atbarney Producedto0efense
3501.178.001 through 3501.178.047 Various school records
WA
2021.04.12
3501.178.01 6 . de aphic inforri o0C6 n 202L04.12
3501.178.00 20(6.10.06 Florida DAV.I.D. indrildual summary page for 2021.04.12
3501.178.050 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Poke Department Incident Report 2021.04.12
3501.178.011 Various Pages from biographical liken 2021.04.12
3501.178.052 2006.0502 National Comprehensive Report for 2021.04.12
2006.0602 NCIC Interstate Identification Indexsearch for 2021.0412 _3501.178.033
3501.178.014 2006.06.02 Information Nedra 2021.0412
3501.178.055 2006.01602 NCIC Interstate Identification Indexsearch for
FW memorandten doodmenting victim Infortnabon
2021.04.12
3501.178.056 2006.0103 2021.04.12
3501.178.057 2007.09.26 Florida DAVID. individual summary page for 2021.04.12
3501.178.058 2007.10.02 interview 302 2021.04.12
3501.178.059 2007.10.02 integylave handwritten notes 202L0Al2
3501.178060 Various Biographical flit cm 2021.04.12
3501.178 061 2007.10.05 Fes report rmarding interview h 2021.07.23
3501.139 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.179 001 driver keens. N/A 2021.04.12
3501130 Date Desallatioe Attorney ProducedtoDonnie
3501.180 031 2005.11.22 Rile., Kiraly home page
I4/4
2021 01.11
3501.180 032 2005.11.22 Gil &ley bxlatroon0 infamy:ler 2021.04.12
3501.180003 2005.11.22 Rik" Kiraly company 'M elees 2021.04.12
3501.180003 2005.11.22 Rik" Kiraly homing* 202104.12
3501.180016 2005.11.22 Riley Kiraly case managers 2021.411.12
3501.180005 2005.11.22 Riley Kiraly FACIA 2021.01.12
3501.180007 2005.11.22 Riley Kiraly history 2021.04.12
3501.180002 2007.0514 Florida DAV.I.D.indhicksal unwary page for 2023.04.12
3501.180009 2007.07.30 Riley Kiraly FADS 2021.01.12
3501.180010 2007.07.30 Rase Rineycase managers 2021.01,12
3501.180022 Mon* recce& 2023.0412
3501.180012 2005.11.21 Riley Kir* approach of MM 2021.10.11
3501.180013 2005.12.06 subscriber history 2021.10.11
3501.180014 2007.07.30 Riley Kiraly mesa* pages 2021.10.11
3501.180015 Riley subpoena quashing materials 2021.10.11
3501.131 Date Desa t tiw i Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.181 031 Various ihographical file on
NJA
2021.04.12
3501.181032 2007.09.26 Palm Beach County Sheriffs OfficeBookirwBbtter Search for
2021.01.12
3501.183033 2007.09.26
Palm Beach County Sheriffs OfficeBoolong Natter Search for
2021.01.12
3501.181.001 2007.1-002 Sormation manna 2021.01.12
3501.181 035 2007.10.02 Interview 302 2021.01.12
3501.181006 2008.05.27 NCIC Interstate
r
IdenUfloUon Index search let
interview 302
2021.01.12
3501.181 007 2001105.28 2021.01.12
3501.181 036 2008.0828 Interview handwritten notes 2021.01.12
3501.183009 2019.03.20 Interview 302 2021.01.12
3501.181-010 2019.03.20 Interview handwritten notes 2021.01.12
3501.181.011 2007 10.0$ FBI report regarding interview with 2021.07.23
3501.181-012 2008.05.30 RI report regarding letter to 2021.07.23
3501.181-013 2008 05.30 FBI report regarding Waviest with 2021.07.23
3501.181.014 2008.09.03 Letter to rom 2021.07.23
3501.181.015 2007.1002 FIN re port regarding contact wgh 2021.10.11
3501.181.016 2008.0530 letter regarding FBI's Victim Ankslance Program 2021.10.11
3501.181-017 2008.07.09 Nottication of Identified Wawa 2021.10.11
3501.181-013 2008.07.10 letter from VItafana 2021.10.11
3501.181.019 2008.09.03 letter regarding amended n°31'1[2[10101 Identified viobrr 2021.10.11
3501.181020 2008.12.05 Emal and letter 2021.10.11
3501.181 022 2019.04.11 Text conversation with agent 2021.10.11
3501.181 022 2019.07.29 Text conversation with agent 2021.10.11
350L112 Data Desolation Attorney ProducedtoDe/aim
3501.182 001 2005.03.15 Florida DAY.I.D.Indnidual summary pa e lee 2021.01.12
3501.182 002 2005.03.15 Report generated regarding 2021.04.12
3501.182 003 2005.03.31 Cal to 2021.04.12
3501.182.034 2005.03.31 Cal to 2021.04.12
3501.182 005 2005.05.27 Interstate lowilifieallop index search (crowds fob
Mangy/ handwritten notes
2021.01.12
3501.182 0:6 2005.10.03 2021.01.12
3501.182 037 2005.10.03 IntervWw handwritten notes 2021.01.12
3501.182 036 2005.1001 Palm Beach Police Department Property Receipt 2021.01.12
3501.182-009 mar4mitten rotes 2021.01.12
3501.182010 2006.05.09 Palm Beach County Shordrs Office Vim:* Report regarding=
2021.01.12
3501.182.011 2006.05.09 Palm Beach County Shordrs Office Offense Report regarding=
MI 2021.01.12
3501.182012 20066723 Palm Beach PoliceDepartment Incident Report 2021.01.12
3501.182013 2006.06.01 Florida DA.V.I D.indmdtal sisnmary page for 2021.01.12
3501.182014 2006.03.01 i.theN information 2021.01.12
3501.182015 2006.06.01 Record motet: rogueing 2021.01.12
3501.182-016 2006.06.01 Law enforeerneM report regarding
NCIC Interstate Identification Indexsearch for
2021.01.12
3501.182-017 2006.03.01 2021.01.12
3501.182-013 2006.08.26 Palm Beath Police Department Evidence/PropenyTrackIng Report 2021.01.12
3501.182 019 2006.08.26 Palm Beath Polio Department EvIdence/PropenyTrackIng Report 2021.01.12
3501.182 020 2006.06.28 Palm Beach Police Department Property Receipt 2021.01.12
3501.182 021 2006.06.23 Palm Beach Police Department Propeny Receipt 2021.01.12
3501.182 022 2006.10.03 1.1.4PaCe Page 2021.01.12
3501.182 021 Notes and inderrnation regarding 2021.01.12
3501.182 02A 2007.01.11 Search remedy areling 2021.01.12
3501.182 02S 2007.02.01
Pages of a letter (rem Gerald LefroJrt to and
2021.01.12
3501.182026 2007.0227 -I orierom o 2021.01.12
3501.182027 Retort reeirdog 2021.01.12
3501.18200E 2007.03.20 'le::imorco 2021.01.12
3501.182 029 2007.03.27 Letter from to MIcloal Outto 2021.01.12
3501.182 030 2007.04.24 testimonyo 2021.01.12
3501.182 031 2007.04.24
,E=MI
'testimony 2021.01.12
3501.182032 B reptile.' fib on 2021.01.12
3501.182033 2007.05.15 'testimony 2021.01.12
3501.182 034 2007.05.32 1.41 0• 02 Pa ge 2021.01.12
3501.182 035 2007.05.31 heopace Page 2021.01.12
3501.182 036 2007.05.31 ...Apace Pals 2021.01.12
3501.182 037 2007.06.03 Record (count regaling 2021.01.12
3501.182038 2007.06.12 National Comprehensive Report regarding 2021.01.12
3501.1824339 2007.06.12 NCIC Interstate Identification Indexsearch for 2021.01.12
3501.182410 2007.06.13 Ma oast drecticos 2021.01.12
3501.182011 2007.09.07 Florida DAV.I.D. indnIdual mama e for 2021.01.12
3501.182012 2007.09.07 NCIC Interstate Ident.lication Indexsearch for 2021.01.12
3501.182 013 2007.09.07 Recoil request (*Luang 2021.01.12
3501.182 Ca 2007.09.07 Ma uest direction 2021.01.12
3501.182 015 2007.09.07 National Comprehensive Report ardin 2021.01.12
3501.182 016 2007.12.11 Pages of a letter frown Kirkland & Ella lo Aletandet kosta 2021.01.12
3501.182047 2019.07.07 interview 302 2021.01.12
3501.182013 2006D42941
200603.13 IMMItostlenony of 2022.01.12
3501.182 019 2008.07.22 Cowlorder from Palm BeachCountyC*0n to 2021.01.12
3501.182 050 2009.03.26 Notice of dep:onion to 2021.01.12
3501.182 061 2019.11.01 interwes 302 2021.01.12
3501.182 062 2009.0300 Menner handwritten notes 2021.01.12
3501.182 053 2005.03.13 Moto file (full tape recorchu. T.4W Al 2021.07.23
3501.182-051 2005.03.13 Auclo file (dip from tape recordin ; 2021.07.23
3501.182 055 2005.03.18 Palo fib (full own] side ID
3503182 056 2005.09.19 LW/ calory:malt starchmord' regarding
3501.182 057 2005.10.03 Video f4e
3503182 05.5 2005.10.03 Video f4e
3503182 059 2005.10.03 Video f4e
3501.182 050 2035.10.03 Video face 'full video tape recording'
3501.182 051 21105.10.03 Video f4e Icloof ..oleo lap* reccning:
3501.182 062 20060101 PBPD probable cause affidavit
rcgarding 350/182063 266.0101 PBPD probable cause affidavit regardin
3501.182 054 2006.06.01 fel report regarding caw opening
3501.182 055 2006.0724 FBI re port rdin case opens
3501.182 056 2006.06.01 FBI report regarding case opening
3501.182 067 2006.628 PBPD property rootlet
3501.182 068 2006.09.13 FBI re port regarding set lead
3501.182 059 2006.10.24 My50.xe Pages
3501.182 070 2007.06.22 1 Ea report regarding case opening
3501.182 071 2007.11.23 FBI report regarding imesligation 'NJ victim infomutior
3501.182 072 Various search records regard**
3501.182073 Hanclaitten notes
3501.182074 Audio fat (clip herniae* recording'
3501.182075 Audio fik.Dull tap" recordng, Weal
3501.182-076 Audofik.(ull tap" recordeig, odes)
3501.182077 Puebla*
3501.182073 Audio fi*Wlip from tape recording:
3501.182079 Audio filalull tap" ratan:Int s.60 Al
3501.182 093 Audio filalull tap" recording, s.60 Ell
3501.182 081 Audo f Mich° from tape recording'.
3501.182032 Audio f de lull tap" recordnit ode Al
3501.182083 Arad° 'donut' tap" recoil:Wt.  tides)
3501.182-084 2005.10.13 Application and search warrant
3501.182.06 2006.05.01 letter from /Ached Rater to Parry (niche(
3501.182036 2007.02.01 letter from Gerald lacourt to
3501.182057 2007.02.15 Hanclentten notes
3501.1824363 2007.02.26 Letter re:
3501.18269 2007.04.02 letter re:
3501.182490 2007.04.16 letter re.
3501.182031 2007.0103 letter from to Mahal Dutto
3501.182092 2007.05.31 MySoxe palm.
3501.182093 2007.06.14 teller from to Michael Durk.
3501.182094 2007.06.25 Letter IromGetald letwat to
3501.182095 2007.11.11 Letter from lelkowiu to Acosta
3501.182096 2008.06.19 Starr sttenission to DAG
3501.182 097 20080710 final noldkanan letter of identified vniens
3501.182 096 20080710 final notification letter of identified vnims
3501.182 099 2008.09.02 Amended notification letter of Identified victim
3501.182.103 2008.1108 Later Otnolifkallca for Wit release
3501.182.101 AT&T R«ords
3501.182.102 2009.11.10 Deposition transcript
350116 Data Description
3503183 001 2004.11.23 Police call response regarding
3501.183 002 2004.11.23 Palm Beach Police Department Intelligence Retort
3501.183003 2005.11.10 Palm Beach Police Department Property Receipt
3501.1830M 2006.01.05 Pan Beach Police Department Properly Receipt
3501.183-005 2006.07.13 PSI Beach Police Department Incident Report
3501.183-006 2006.615 Pan Beach Pace Department Property ReCoOt
3501.183-007 2006.06.26 Palm Beach Police Department Evidence/ProptelyTrackire Report
3501.183038 2006.06.26 Pay, Beach Police Department hirionce/Property Tracking Report
3501.183 009 2006.06.23 vay, Beach Police Department Properly Receipt
3501.183 010 2006.11.09 Apptcation for Employment tri
3501.183011 2006.11.09 Authorization for Release of information
3501.183012 2006.11.09 employment dotal, vent' lc fatal one
3501.183013 2006.11.09 rename
3501.183014 2006.11.09 - Idembinryl docummD
3501.183015 2007.01.18 Menage 302
3501.183016 2007.02.01 Pages of a letter from Gerald Lelcoun to and
3501.183017 Transcnot Index
3501.183018 20060429& 2008.03.111 testimony of
3501.183 019 2009.07.29
,M=Ill
Deposition o
3501.183 020 2009.06.07 Continued deposnionol
3501.183 021 2004.11.28 PBPD Inteligence Report
3501.183 022 2006.11.03 Florida DAVID. individual summary page for
3501.183 023 2005.11.10 Puebla"
3501.183 014 2005.11.10 Ando fat
3501 183 025 2006 01 04 1460119(full tap" recce
3501.183 026 2006.01.04 Ando fat (clip of tape recording.
3501.183 027 2006.01.04 Hardaitten notes
3501.183 022 2006.05.01 PBPD probable cause anidant regardin
3501.183 029 2006.05.01 PBPD probable cause anidant regardin
3501.183 030 2007.01.23 FBI report regarding interview with
3501.183 031 Mao faalull taperer:010nd. ode Al
3501.183032 liactofilalull tap" recording. side IN
3501.183-033 Audo file
3501.183-034 Puebla*
Rita Glavin
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
Producedto66m
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.111.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01,12
2021.0432
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
Attamely
3501.183035 Puebla*
3501183036 Puebla*
3501183037 Angola*
3501183038 AucIota,
3501.183039 Antecede
3501.183.010 Video No
3501183.011 Video No
3501183.012 Video No
3501183063 Video No
3501.123044 Auto N*
3501183015 2005.02.02 Rent A Car Statement
3501.183016 2007.01.01 Letter from Leto:pun to !Malone
3501.183.017 2009.11.03 Advice of nghts form
3501.183.048 2009.11.03 302
3501 183039 2009 11 03 Content to search farm
3501.183030 2009.11.0 302
3501.1834:G1 2009.11.06 Advice of nghts form
3501.183 037 2009.11.01 US y criminal complaint
3501.183053 20111111.17 Florida criminal history record
3501.183.054 21/10.06.18 US v. se ntenoeg packet
3501.183055 -records
3501.183456 Debar Car Rental subpoena mean
3501.183057 - 3025 regarding obstruction th rees
3501.183058 l l 3025 regarding obstruction charges
3501.183059 3025 regarding obstruction charges
3501.183060 2009.08.07 Continued dominion of
3501.183061 2006.01.04 Handwilltthnoto:
3501.183 062 2006.01.06 Handwilltthnoto:
3501.134 Date Descended
1501.184001 2007.11106 Marylon 302
3501.184.002 2007.1/3,07 FBI report regarding Mery Ice
3501.135 Date Description
3501.185 COI 2009.06.11 lthisNexis Report regarding
3501.136 Date DeterlptIon
330E  031 2020.08.21 ntennew 302
3501.186002 2020.08.11 ntenriewhandwntten notes
3501.186003 2020.08.23 InteMewhadwntten notes
3501.327 Date DesalptIon
3501 187.001
3501.187.002
2019 07 11
2019.07.11
uventos 302
ift.COAC". hanOsritien notes
3501.183003 2019.06.13 Memorandum regard% phone call with
3501.187.011 2019.07.01 Memorandum regarthn g phone Call with
3501.187 OM Hanchwittth rotes
3501.187006 Hanchwittth rotes
3501.18700] SCrOthitiOt of test message
3501.187003 Soren:hot of test message
3501.187003 manchwittm notes on article
3501.187010 2019.07.09 Emal reword
350L1S3 Date Descendent
3501.183001 2019.07.15 FBI memo tetra to CK al NI
3501.188.032 2019.07.26 Manic.: 301
3501.188.003 2019.07.26 littOrvICY handwritten notes
3501.188.001 Screen:hot of Facebook male for
3501.188.M SCreertitiOt of FaC03004 Orate foe
3501.188.006 SCretreitiOt of Facebook profile foe
1501.188.007 SOWthitiOt of Facebook profile foe
3501.188008 2019.07.14.
2019.07.31 Text conversation with agent
3501.1E Date DetalptIon
3501.189001 2006.07.31 Material Witness Statement Affidavit of Prosecution Palm 8.0.101
Police Department
3501.189.002 2006.07.33 Photo lec-up Instructions for
3501.183003 2006.08.01 Florida DAV.I.D.Widindual summary pa la fort
3501.189-001 2006.0301 Ott.C., WOOS° TraMaCtIOn Pak° foe
3501 189 CO3 21/06 08.07 Palm Beach Police Department Incident Report
3501.189 036 2006.0808 National Comprehensive Report for
3501.189 CO7 2006.08.08 f 3 memorandum deCuMentineviCIIM infonnabon
3501.189 033 2007.01.17 c...tier-orn of
3501.189 009 2007.06.08 Record moues: egarang
3501.189010 2007.06.31 NCIC Interstate Identification Indexstanch forte
National Comprehensive Report for 3501.189011 2007.06.31
3501.189012 2007.06.31 Florida DAV.I.D. indnidual summary page foe
3501.189013 Intentionally omitted
3501.189014 2007.06.33 Ma Jest deettions
3501.183015 2007.0615 VitOfv1Vir 301
WA
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2023.07.13
2023.07.23
2023.07.23
2021.10.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.25
101110.15
ProducedtoDefense
2021.0112
2023.07.23
Produced to Define*
20210 12
Produced to Defense
2021.0112
2021.04.12
2021.10.11
ProducedtoOdense
2021.04.12
2023.04.32
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202110.11
2021.1011
ProducedtoOdense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.06.12
202106.12
202106.12
202106.12
202106.12
202110.11
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.06.12
202106.12
202106.12
202106.12
202106.12
202106.12
202106.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.06.12
202106.12
202106.12
2021.116.12
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
GlOtia Allred
Attorney
WA
Attorney
WA
Attorney
3501.189-016 2007.06.25 interview handwritten notes
3501.189017
501 189013
501.189 019
3501.189020
3501.189 021
3501.189022
501.189 023
501.189024
2007.07.20 Florida DAV.I.D.Indhichal summary page for
200707 20 Florda DAV.I.D. photo lwue up for
2019.07.10 FBI memorandum regarding dctim contact
2019.1x16 Interview 302
2019.1036 interview handwritten notes
3501.189025
3501.189 02,5
544,3 ""ot t eReW eiMMEMMEMO
Information reganIng
Biographical f ile regardwg
2006.07.26 Fl a DAV.I.D.IndMdual summary page foe
07.31 Maori
1.189 027
1.189 023
1.189029
1.189 030
2007.06.25 FBI report regarding Ftervle of
2007.06.27 Ando file (full tape  recorOnt rde Al
2007.06.27 Ando Nk WA tape recorelrit rde Ell
2007.11.25 FBI report rm., ding imese anon and vialm Info not
2008.02.20
2008.12 04 Fa report regarding ntervlcr of
2019.07.10 Fa report regarding mmart weh victims
501.189011
501.189032
501.189 011
501.189 014
501.189 015
3501 189036
3501.189037
3501.189038
FBI report reptatne letters to  victim
Hancleritten notes
Vanous search records re
07.33
.011.0$ totter to
.011.11 Leiter to
Notes
1.189 019
1.189040
501.189 031
2007.06.07 totter regarding victims' (lets
2007 06.07 totter regarding %loan' fleets
2008.07.30
2008.0721 testa
2008.09.02 totter to
008 12 09
2019. 06.13 Memorandum to We
mat notdiaction letter of Identified viams
1.189032
1.189 033
501.189044
501.189 035
lie
WA
3501130 Date Desalting' Attorney
501.190001 2007.04.24 MI CAD Cal Inf nation A
3501191 Date Desallfon Attogney
3501.191 002
3501.192002
3501.191-003
3501.1910M
501.192005
501.191-006
501.191.007
501.191006
2019.08.09
2019.08.09
2019.06.13 interview 302
2019.06.13 learn* handwritten notes
2019.06.1
2019.0613 Paotohooi and Ind
2019.0813 Text converutlon wih agent
errervpw 302
interview handwritten notes
Photobook Ind
Voicernal
350L192
501.192031
Date DesaltIon
2006.12.14 Florida DA.V.I.D. indhidual sanmary page foe
Attorney
3501.192-002 2006.12 14 nen!) DAVI D. <maven:contact nlornution for
501.193 Date Desallfon Attorney
3501.193-001 tlycugh 3501193 060
3501.193051
501.193052
501.19
501.193098
Various school records
2006.06.01 FBI Cava sheet for biographical file foe
2006.07.33 Pages frown Palm Beach Poke Department Incident Report
200fi.07.33 Palm Beach Police Department incident Report
2006.07.27 Flor ida DAVID. dove, none transaction page for
501.193055
501.19
501.193-06]
2006.06.02 National Comprehensive Port regarding
2006.06.02 adsregard/re
2006.06.02 IC Interstate Identification Index search for
501.19 063
501 19 -069
1.193-070
2006.06.06
2006 0325 Palm Beach Pane Department Property Receipt
FBI memorandum dowmenting viola Inforreaton
.0326 Palm Beach Police De anent Dad Pro me
I 19 -072
3301.193073
3301.193074
3301.193075
I 19 -076
ace
MOfi.10.03  ace
2007.0101 Pages of a letter from Gerald Lelcoun to and
2007.04.26 Interview 302
2007.06.12 Florida DAV.I.D.Inderldual summary page foe
2007 06.12 Florida DAV.I.D.motor mmNclestalusP
2007.06.12 Search necadsregardirtit
2007 06.12
2007.06.12 NNlocalCoComprehensive Re Repor regarding
3301.193-077
I 19 .073
1.193-079
Search re ds re garding
3501.193-030
1.193-031
1.19 032
1.19 033
1.193-064
1.192035
2007.09.07 Florida DAVID. widMdual summary page fa
2007.09.07 Record request waning
2007.09.07 Search recce& regarding
2007.09.07 NatlaW Comprehensive port regarding
2007.09.07 Search recordsregarding
2007.06.03 Florida DAV.I.D.IndMilual 'Lemur page for
202101.12
202101.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2023.00.12
2021.07.23
202107.23
202107.23
202107.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
202110.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
Produced to Deltas*
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021 0412
2022.04.22
2023.04.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.1011
2021.10.11
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
202104 12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2023.04.32
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202101.12
202101.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202101.12
202101.12
202101.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202101.12
202101.12
3501.193-0% 2007.06.12 rlorida DAY.I.Dan or seNclestatus Date
3501.19 .087 2005 10.01 Palm Beach Ponce Department Property Rectot
350119 0313 tl enttona informahor
I 19 MI Palm Beach Police Department Properly FleCtill
3501.193 090 2003.10.05 Palm Beach Police Department Properly Recool
I 19 091 Handwritten notes regareing
3501.193092 Search racoons regarding
350119 09 alandenitten notes Agana
3501.19 .094 Various geographical fib rcgardt
3501.19 .095 2003.10.03 Put% file cull tape reCOrdalg, Ude AI
3501.193-0% 2003.10.03 Pude file (clip of tape recording;
3501.193 097 2003.10.03 ludo faltnvil tape recorded. warn
3501.1934% 2003.10.01 Pude Sahli tape recording. side Al
3501.19 .099 2003.10.01 Audio larch/Iof tape recording;
3501.19 100 2003.10.01 Puebla:41,AI tape recording. ant
3%1.193301 2005.10.05 Florida DAVID. dual summary page for
3501.19 102 2Wfi.02.10 At Saxe Daggs
3501.19 103 200609.01 PBPO Dm% e Ouse aHMawt regarding
1.19 101 0901 PBPO probable muse aHMant regarding
I 19 105 2007.04.26 FBI report weedier/ Ken. an
1.19 106 2007.04.30 FBI report regarding later to
I 19 107 200706.08 Person search regarding
3301.193108 2019.12.01 PBS report regarding rem 4: iln
3301.193109 201907 C6 Memorandum regardept interne *WI
1.19 .110 Audo tilt cull tape recording. tide Al
3501.19 .111 Pude tilt (dip of tape recording;
3501.19 .112 Pude tilt (lull tape recordrat, de BI
3501.19 .113 Nandentten notes
3501.19 .114 ArySince D
3501 19 115 Various search records rcgadng-
3501.193116 2025.10.04 Yet Is
3501.19 117 2005 10.18 App i abort and search warrari
3501.19 .118 2001.0801 Lotter to
3501.19 .119 2006.04.11 letter to
3501.19 110 2007.02.01 letter from lefoaun to Wlafana
3501.19 121 2007.06.29 tonee from lefoaun to Wlafana
3301.193122 200.07.10 i al ocedkat n kdorof Identified braoms
3301.193123 2016.09.12 totter to
3501.19 .124 2008.12.08 letterto-
3501.193.12$ 2005.1 04 Handnnttennotei
3501.1% Date Molina
3501.194.001 2006.08.02 MI CAD Cat Information
3501-195 Date DefolptIon
3503195 001 2008.02 woe ]taw death record r ,...ocirg
3501 195 CO2 Note re and *oath et
3501.1% Date Desolptlea
1501 156 001 2007.10.09 Florida DAV.I.D.indtricksal summary page for
3501.197 Date Description
3501.197 001 2020.07.13 Victim nal itatOn form
3501.197.002 2020.07.14 mderilew 302
3501.197.003 2020.11.09 intake moon
3501199 Date De
saigeloa
3501 198 0)1 2007.05 03 6mal reaming emalt a6dress
3501 t980)2 te from
501.199 Date Description
3501.199.001 2005.04.18 31 a DAVID. indhidual summary029ra
Cove roe *graphical file on 1.19g002 2006.01.01
1 199.003 07.13 Page from Pan Beach Pam Deparlmea In dent Reneri
3301.199404 01.11 Fier a medial Ikense search,*
1 199405 2008.01 Palm Beach Police Department Property Rama
3301.199406 2006.07.13 Pages from Pan Beach Poke Detairtmem I ocient Report
3301.1%407 2006.07 13 Palm Beach PoliceDepartment Incident Report
330 CI 1.199408 2006.07.27 a DAVID. cleft( license transaction page tor
3501.199.009 20060802 Law ericircenwit repeal regarding
3501.199010 2006.0802 NCIC Interstate Identification Index search for
3501.199411 2006.08.26 Palm Beach Pace Department Pndence/PropertyTrkking Repon
3301.1%412 2007.05.03 Non to David Copperliek
1.199013 2007.05.03 ma
(mad
(*tatting email address
1.199014 2007.05 08 mai kern Ora Comerbeld to
1.199015 2007.05 10 imal from to David Copoediek
3301.1%416 2007.05 .30 imal from to David Copoediele
1.199017 2007.05.15 ma from to David Copoediek
WA
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.0112
2021.0112
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
202110.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
202110.11
2021.10.25
Attorney Produced to Defense
NIA 2021.04.12
Attorney Produced to Deleon
WA
2021 DS 12
202107 :2
Attorney Produced to Defense
WA 2021.04.12
Attorney Produced to Defense
gain
2021.04.12
2021.0112
2021.07.23
Attorney ProducedtoDefense
WA
202100 :1
201: C•I .
Attorney Produced to Defense
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
3501.199015 2007.05.04 Email frown David Cooperfield to
A
2021.04.12
3501.199019 2007.12.11 Pages ofa letter from Kirkland & Ella to Almada Acosta 2021.04.12
3501.199 020 2007.12.11 Ta us search results ardin 2021.04.12
3501.199021 2007.12.11 National Comprehensive Report regarding 2021.04.12
3501.199022 2007.12.12 Fea memorandum regarding request for travel 2021.04.12
3501.199023 2008.01.15 lad. DAS/ADAM/Adult summary page foe 2021.04.12
3501.199024 2008 15 Florda DAV.1.D.moorwNsbitaluspa4e 2021.04.12
3501.199025 2000 05.35 Ow enforcement report regarding
Palm Beach Mice cement Pro e
2021 04.12
3501.199026 200fi.0625 2021.04.12
3501.199022 20190709 302 report regarding attempted contact with 2021 04.12
3501.199028 Note fro 2021.04.12
3501.199029 Vadou Biog Aorta* co 2021.04.12
3501.199030 200601.19 Audio flte(full tape recordinA vde Al 2021.07.23
3501.199031 200fi.0119 Patti (clip of tape recording! 2021.07 23
3501.199.032 2001.01.19 Amble (fill tape record**.  toe  85 2021.07.23
3501.199033 Arid° f I null tape reran:AV 2021.07 23
3501.199034 *ado f I (clip °flape recording! 2021.07.23
3501.199035 Nandeellten rotes 2021.02 .23
3501.199036 Florida kens* records 2021.10.11
3591.199032 ilanchuretco notes 2021 10.11
3501.200 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.200001 2007.01.10 Roodsearch regard
WA
2011 04 11
3501366E 2017.01.10 Florida DAVID. individual summary put lcc 2021 0411
1.200003 2007.01.10 Road search meardrut 2011 Pt 12
35(11.201 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoI/dense
3501.201031 2002.0611 Person search regarding
V,rA
2021.03.12
350/.201002 2007. 11 Goo& Map data 2021.04.12
3501102 Dote DescriPtion Money Produced to Defense
3501.201001 2017.05.01 Ws merge
Robert
2021.04.12
3501 202 001 2017 06.05 Florida DAV I D search for driers Weft° number 2021 04 12
3501.202 0)3 2007.06.11 NCIC Interstate Identification Index search for 2021.04.12
3501.202004 2007 06.11 Recadsregardng 2021.04.12
3501.202.CC6 2007.06.11 Law {decrement repot regarding 2021.04.12
3501 202.006 2017 06.11 NCIC Interstate Identifiotion Index search for 2021.04.12
3501.2020)7 2007.06.12 interview 302 2021.04.12
3501.202408 2007 06.12 interview neonates 2021 04.12
3501.2020)9 2007.06.12 Florida DAV.I.D.incliOdual summary page for 2021. 12
3501.202010 2007 06.12 Florida DAV I D or eeNcItMatus Dade 2021 12
3501.202011 2007.06.12 National Comprehensive port regarding 2021.04.12
3501.202012 2008.10.07 National Canprehenslve Report regarding 2021 04.12
3501.202013 Juvenile arrest inormationr I 2021.04.12
3501.202014 26).66 Recent request (*prang 2021.04.12
3501.202.015 ilancholltm notes 2021.04.12
3501302016 Various BbgraphItalfdeon 2021.0112
3501.202.017 2007.06.32 FEa report regarding intav 2021.07.23
3501.202018 2008.01.10 FEa report regarding lotors far Maims 2021.07.23
3501.202019 2006.10.15 Appllratim and search arraM 202110.11
3501.202020 2007.06.07 Letter Born VIIIana 2021.1011
3501.202021 2007.06.07 letter to 2021.10.11
3501.201022 2008.07.10 loner ImenVilaf ana 2021.10.11
3501.202023 2008 11.14 tenor from Vilafana 2021 10.11
3501.202.024 2008.12.05 Letter from Miro 2021.10.11
3501 202.02S 2019 06.13 Memorandum to No 2021 10.11
1501103 Date DesaiPtica Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 2030)1 2007 06.11 Person search r In N/A 202' Pt 12
3501204 Date Dualption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.204.031 2020.0822 inteniew haI
WA
202101 12
3501.204032 020.08.22 interview hand Art n notes 2021.01.12
3503105 Date Desalption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.209001 2019.0814 Memorandum regarding contxt with WA 2021.01.12
3501.206 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.206 0)1 2019.0809 F0 letter to US Embassy in London
WA
2021 C4.12
3501 206 CO2 2019.08.19 1W memorandum r rdin contact Aith 2021.01.12
3,01 206 0)3 2019.08.19 Email reorcang contact with 2021.04.12
3501.207
Date Desalption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 2070)1 2020.03.10 Nopa regarding phone call with A/A 2021.0(12
3901201 Date Desalpifen Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 208.031 2019 0806 iiverivear 302
WA
2021.01 12
3501 208 CO2 2019.0806 in.erstme handwritten notes 2021.04.12
3501.209 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 209 0)1 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Police Department leaden: Recon WA 202: 14 :1
3501.210 Date DeScrIP000 Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.210001 201104.11 Email from off and 6 1.4ax
fill Greenfield. Mirk Manley
2021.04.12
3501.2113002 2011.04.12 Email from Jeffrey Epstein to M 2021.0112_
3501210.003 2011.04.28 Erna. frown WM 2021.04.12
3501210004 2011.04.29 Erma from Greene, AE 2021.04.12
3501210.0CG 2017.02.23 Decbration of 2021.04.12
3501210406 2020.1006 Notes from call web all Greenfield regarding 2021.04.12
3501210007 2020.10.14 Interview 302 2021.04.12
3501210038 2020.10.14 intonimv handwritten notes 2021.04.12
3501210009 Statement regarding unsealed deponents 2021.07.23
3501.210010 Statement regarding February 23. 2017 declaration 2021.07.23
3501.210011 2021.07.21 Email 202110.11
3501.210012 Notes 2021.1011
3501.210 013 Notes on 2017 declaration 2021.10.11
3501.211 Date De10101103 Attorney Produced to Odense
3501.211031 2005.11.07 Pate Beach Police Department Properly Romp
NIA
2021.04.12
35012114302 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Police Department leaden% Retort 2021.04.12
35012114303 2006.07.27 Florida DAVID. dnver license transaction was foe 2021.04.12
3501.211034 2006.08.02 Law enforcemNit report warding 2021.01.12
35012114305 2006.08.02 NCIC Interstate Identifiotion Index starch for 2021.01.12
35012114306 2006.08.08 FBI memorandum dooamentingvictim Information 2021.01.12
3501.211007 2006.03.16 Assignment Woo/for 2021.01.12
3501.211408 2006.08.28 Palm Beach Police Department PropeM Report 2021.04.12
3501.211009 2007.02.01 Pages of a tense from Gerald Lalcoun to and
2021.04.12
350/.211010 2007.12.11 Pages Na kik.' Iran Kiiiland & Elk to Alan, Acosta 2011.0/12
20060129&3501.211.011 2008.03.13 testimony of 2021.04.12
3501211012 various ilhograprocal f Otto 2021.04.12
3501211013 Various search records regarclng 2021.07.23
3501211014 2005.11.04 Video Ne If ull video recent,* 2021.07.23
3501.211015 2005.11.04 Video Ne Klett %lcerrecordinel 2021.07.23
3501.211016 2006.05.01 PBPD probable oust affidavit regarding- 2021.07.23
3501.211017 2006.05.01 PBPD probable oust affidavit regarding 2021.07.23
3501.211018 Ando f IN (full tap, reCOrding side Al 2021.07.23
3501.211019 Audofilt(clip of tape wording! 2021.07.23
3501.211020 Audo f Oa (full tape recordivg sake) 2021.07.23
3501.211021 kandwrittor notes 2021.07.23
3501211022 2005.11.04 Puebla,* 2021.07.23
3501211023 2006.08.04 Letter from Vitalana 2021.10.11
3501211024 2007.02.01 Letter from tekoun 2021.10.11
3501.211025 2007.12.11 letter born lelkowni 2021.1011
3501.211 025 2005.11.04 Handwritten notes 2021.1025
3503.232 Date DesatiatIon Attorney ProducedtoDentist
3501212031 2006.12.05 Person search tom
N/A
2021.04.12
3501.212002 2006.12.07 Person search kw 2021.04.12
3501.213 Date 13esab0pn Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.213 031 2019.08.12 interview hanchwithm notes
N/A
2021.04.12
3501.213 002 2019.08.12 interview 302 2021.01.12
3501.214 Date Desalptke Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.214 031 2010.06.15 Sworn strement of WA 202: 03 :2
3501.19 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 215 001 2019 07 17 intontew h03 2021 04.12
3501.215 002 2019.07.17 interview handwritten notes 202101.12
3501.214 Date Desalption MOT( ly Produced to Defense
3501.216 031 2007.1009 Florida DA.V.I.D.indhsdual sunmary page lot VIA 2021 0212
3501.217 Date Descr10000 Attorney Produced to Defense
3501217 0: M7.07.11 ei algorc Law enwitt re r Mine WA 202: N. :2
3501.213 Date DesolptIon Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.218 0)1 :Node 3 5 012 18 03 3 Various school records 2021.04.12
3501.218034 2006.07.13 Pages from Palm Mad% POlte Depart ce nt Mocknt Report 2021.01.12
3501.218.035 2005.11.09 Palm Beach PoliceDepartment Property ReCtspt 2021.01.12
3501.218.036 2006.07.27 Florkla DAY.I.D.Ariver license transactIto par tam 2021.01.12
3501.218037 2006.06.02 Law enforottreot repot regardIng 2021.01.12
3501.218038 2006.08.02 NCIC Interstate IdentifIcatIon Index search tot 2021.01.12
3501.218039 2006.0808 (SI memotandten dooamentIng victim information 2021.0112
3501.218010 2006.0826 Palm Beach Police Department bridence./Propertr Trackir8 &von
3501.218011 2006.08.28 Palm Beach Police Department Property Receipt
3501.218 012 2006.1003 pace pa
3501.218 013 2006.10.03 pace pa
3501.218 044 2007.02.01 Pages of a letter keen Gerald Lelcoun to and
3501.218 015 2007.05.22 testimony of
3501.218016
...=.
2007.0808 Record regtvl (*Ana
3501.218.017 2007.06.12 NCIC Interstate Identification Index se arch tor
3501.218083 2007.06.12 National Ccenprehensive Report retarding
3501.218 039 Palm Beath Police amen( Pro e Rectal
3501.218030 Various Bicgraphical File co
3501.218 051 2005.10.13 Florida DAV.I.D.indMdual summary page for
3501.218 052 2005.11.06 Video No !full video recoedne
3501.218 053 2005.11.041 Video NoIdeal Mck, 3 recording'
3501.218053 2006.05.01 PBPO probable oust atlidaAt Min
3501.218035 2006.05.01 PBPO probable oust atfidav regarding
3501.218 036 2008.07.23 FBI report ntgarding letter sat to ALAI Palero
3501.218 037 2008.07.25 FBI report regarding delorety of wet" nob, 'cation letter
3501.218 068 2008.100.7 FBI repot regarding delitery of tutor notification letter
3501.218 069 2008.10.19 FBI rope., regarding deBeery of ‘tcbm notification letter
3501.218 050 2008.11.25 FBI report regarding del/poor:4 ‘tcbm notification letter
3501.218 051 Audo fate
3501.218 052 Video We
3501.218 053 2005.10.18 Application and search warrant
3501.218 054 2006.06.01 letter tromVitafaria
3501.218 055 2007.02.01 letter from Letcourt
3501.218 056 2007.12.11 letter from lelkowni
3501.218 057 2008.07.10 Letter from Matsu
3501.218 058 21108.0803 Letter from Maria
3501.218 059 2008.12.12 Letter from VIlafana
3501.218 070 94:mistion to the ODAG
3501.218 071 2005.10.11 Handwrittm notes
3501.218 072 Handwrittm notes
3501.219 Data Desa 106,0
3501.219001 1997.05.20 Santa Monica Police Department Crime Report
3501.219 002 2019.1023 Ventage 302
3501.219 003 2019.1023 intentave handwritten notes
3501= Data Desolation
3501.2200.01 2006.07.13 Palm Beach Police Department incident Report
3501.220002 2006.08.26 Palm Beach Police Department Evidence/ProPertylrxkog 8fl ort
3501520003 2006.08.28 Palm Beach Police A Prooettv Race,
3301.22000! 2007.12.11 Pages Iron letter from tarMand& VIA to Alexander Acosta
3501520005 Pocket dettull tape recordhg side Al
3501.220 0:6 Audi> fdt (clip of tape recording!
3501.220-037 Audio file (All tape recording. Ade M
3501.220036 Audo File
3501.220009 2006.01.09 Florida DAAP.I.D.Indhidual summary page regarding
MEI
3501.220010 Notes
3501221 Data Dualptlee
3501.221001 2019.08.29 Interview 302
35012214302 2019.0829 latervIewhandavatm notes
3501.= Date Dualplfan
3501.222 001 2006.08.16 Magoon:fa history for
35012224302 2006.01.09 Florida DAY.I.D.tattoncal diver license adivny rvarding
3501222403 2006.01.09 Palm Beach Peace Department inkonation (twang
MI
3501.222404 2006.01.09 Florida DAVID. indMdual summarypage regarding
3501.222405 2006.01.11 National Comprehensive Report regarding
3501222406 2006.07.13 Pages Awn Palm Beach Pole* Department Incident Report
3501.222407 2006.07.27 Florida DAVID. driver keine Volta/Mal page tegatary
3501222008 2006.0802 Roror0ire rd
3501222009 2006.0802 NCIC Interstate Identification Indexsearch tor
3501222410 2006.0802 National Comprehensive Report ard10
3501222011 2006.0803 FBI memorandwn documenting victim intonnabon
3501.222012 2007.01.16 Florida DAAP.I.D.indMdual summary page retarding
3501.222413 2007.02.27 of
3501.222.014
.1.=Etesilmony
2007.07.02 taw eNorcemmt report ratarding
3501.222.015 20(17.07.02 Florida DAV.I.D.InclMdual summary page artfi'a
3501.222416 2007.07.02 Florida DAV.I.D. hoto line u r (din
3501.222417 2007.07.02 Florida DAV.I.D. search for drives license number
3501222018 2007.011.07 interview 302
3501222019 2007.011.07 interview handwntten notes
N/A
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
202310.11
202310.11
202310.11
202310.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.11125
2021.10.25
Produced to Defense
2021 OA 12
2021.124.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Debase
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
202L0112
202L01.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.01.23
2021.10.11
Produced to Deltas*
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202L0112
202L01.12
202L01.12
202 LOA 12
202L01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2021.0112
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202 LOA 12
Atteinee
Attentay
NIA
Attorney
Attorney
3501222.020 2007.09.07 Florida DAV.I.D.IndMdtsal summary page re aerS
3501222.C-01 2007.09.07 NCIC Interstate Identification Index search for
3501222.022 2007.09.07 Record rams, regarc1ng
35012224323 2007.09.07 National Comprehensive Report regarding
3501.222-024 2007.09.07 Florida DAVID. indMdual summarypage regarding
3501.222.025 2007.09.07 Interstate Identification Index search for -
3501.222026 2007.09.07
_HOC
Worth ref:4,a
3501.222.C-07 2009.01.31 interview 302
3501322W 2008.01.31 InteMewtbandaMbn notes
3501222W 2008.01.31 nteiview handwetten notes
3501222.030 2009.03.22 Notice of Depoution to -
3501222031 2019.03.22 ntendew 302
3501.222-032 2019.03.22 InteMowhandwMNn notes
3501.222-033 2019.05.29 ntennew 302
3501.222-034 2019.05.29 ntennew handwntten notes
3501.222.035 2019.06.18 Fx<mpt from testimony of
3501.222-036 2006.02..06 Awl° NNlen tape recorchrli
3501.222-037 2006.0206 Mich, file (clip of tape wording!
3501.222-038 2007.06.M Law enforcement report regardina
3501.222-039 2007.08.14 19 report regarding inteprime of
3501222-040 2007.11.28 FIP report regarding rreostiganen and victim Informant."
3501222-041 2008.01.10 18!report regarding letters tovictims
3501222-042 2008.01.31 11Preport regarding Mimicryof
3501222-043 2008.09.03 letter to from
3501222-044 Various search records retarders/
3501.222015 2006.00.11 letter to
3501.222016 2007.06.07 letter from Vlearana
3501.222.017 2007.10.31 Final from agent toMilian.
3501.222048 2000.01.10 Letter from Tatter SmIth
3501.22200 2000.03.26 (mad From *en: toMilian.
3501.222-050 2000.03.27 Fmad from *en: toMllafana
3501.222-051 2008.03.31 (mat from *ent to VIllalana
3501.222-052 2008.07.09 letter from Valeria
3501222-053 2008.07.10 letter from Sniafaria
3501222-054 2008.08.01 (mat From %neaten.
3501222-055 2008.09.03 letter from Medan'
3501222-056 2008.12.05 (mad and letter fromMR.11one
3501.222-057 Text conversation with agent
3501.222-058 Text conversation with agent
3501.222-059 Various words for
3501.222050 Hanchwitten notes
3503223 Date DesalptIon
350E  001 202aoTo7 ntennew 302
3501.223 002 2020.07.07 nterview handwritten notes
390920.6 Date Omuta.
3501.224001 2007.08.15 Law enforrewnt regal regarding
36=5 Date Desalinize
3501.225.001 through 3501225 078 Various —school records
3501.225 079 2006.06.01 104 memorandum documenting victim information
3501.225 093 2006.06.09 Juvenile arrest information retard,
3501.x2563 2006.08.09
Florida DAV.I.D.driver tr eble transaction page *prang
-
3501.22562 2006.08.09 Florida DAY.I.D.search for dawn Ikea* number
3501.225033 2006.08.18 nteMew 302
3501.225 084 2006.08.18 inteMewhadWMten notes
3501.2254335 2006.08.28 Palm Beach Police Department Property Recent
3501.225.086 2006.06.26 Palm Beech Poll eDepartment Deldence/Procortv Tiximg Ronan
3501.225.087 2007.06.12 Records relating to
3501 225.0P3 2006.1a03 M e
3501.225.099 2007.02.06
3501.225-090 2007.02.27
3501.225-091 2007.03.20
nteMew 302 3501.225-092 2007.03.24
3501225-093 2007.03.24 nteMewhandivntten notes
3501.225094 2007.05.06 temimony of
3501.225 095 2007.05.15 testimony of I__ ,
3501.225 096 2007.06.08 Record reo,.ett cozening
3501.225 027 2007.06.12 National Comprehensive Report regarding
3501.225 093 2007.06.12 Juvenilearrest information regarding
3501.225099 2007.06.12 Reccaltrelating to
3501.225400 2007.07.20 Florida DAVID. indmetal sommarrlaaSe regarding
3501.225401 2007.07.20 Florida DAVID. photo Inv up relardinf
3501.225.102 2008.01.31 nteMew 302
3501.225.103 2008.02.01 -record of interview
3501.225.101 2008.02.08 axed of contact
3501225.105 it ical fatal
3501.225406 2008.03.18 MMII testimony of
3501.225407 2008.03.20 Letter from Jeffrey Herman to lack Goldberger
3501.x35108 2008.04.29 ton, of
202LOAl2
202LOAl2
202LOAl2
202LOAl2
2021.01.12
2021.01,12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
2020.00.12
2020.00.12
202101.12
2020.01.12
202101.12
2021.01.12
2020.00.12
2020.00.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
Produced to Defense
2021 0.1 12
Produced to Defense
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2023.0432
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202L04.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
2021.06.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202L01.12
202LO4.12
202D:14.12
202L04.12
202L04.12
2021.01.12
2023.0432
2023.0432
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.01.12
202L01.12
202LO4.12
202D:14.12
Attorney
N/A
Attorney
Attorney
3501.225.109 2008.03.22 Note**, Deemtion to
3501.225.110 2009.09.29 toner from Adam Norowit: to Judge leffrevColbath
3501225.111 2009.10.09 Fmal from to hlichaN McAuliffe and Paul lacks
3501225.112 2008.07.10 letter from to Jeffrey Norman
3501 225 113 2019 0709 302 report rNpeding attempted contact with
3501225.1/4 Palm 90x8 Pence Department Properly newel
3501.225115 Flardmitten notes retardne
3501225.116 leardwritten notes INtaNIOS
3501225.117 PPM* of
3501225.1113 2005.10.03 Florida DAV I D indhiclual summary e r rOlo
3501225.119 2005.10.06 Trio fik. (full tam recording)
3501225.120 2005.10.06 Audio file NT of tape recording!
3501225.121 2005.10.06 Tete file (full tape recording)
3501225.122 2005.10.06 Audio file (clip of tape recording!
3501225.123 2006.01.30 MyStaxe pages
3501.225124 2006.02.09 FAGOace Pkges
3501.225.125 2006.0901 FIPD probable oust affidavit regarding
3501225.126 2006.05.01 Pero probable muse anident regarding
3501225.127 2006.09.13 FB1 report regarding interview with
3501225.122 2006.12.08 FEtirepcel regarding letter ton to
3501225.129 2007.03.26 FM repcel regarding intorvwee wtth
3501229130 2007.11.28 FBI repot rprOing rrecciganon and victim Informatior
3501225.131 2008.02.01 Fu report rgordinp ntervinvwnh
3501.225.132 2008.02.08 FEtl repot regarding call with
3501225.133 2009.0929 Letter from Adam Horowitz to lud e leffrevColbath
3501225.134 2018.12.04 FS report regarding information
3501225.135 2019.0109 302 regarding attemµed contact
3501225.136 Various search records regardng
3501.225.137 My50.xe Pages
3501225.138 20053018 Appication and search warned
3501.225139 2006.06.04 Letter from VIlafaria
3501225.140 2006.06.11 Letter to
3501.225.141 2008.03.18 (marls between agent and Wlafana
3501.225142 2008.07.10 letter from Vitafana
3501225.143 200809.02 tenet from Vitafana
3501225.144 200809.02 letter from Vitafana
3501225.145 2008.12.05 teller from Vitafana
3501225.146 2008.12.05 letter loom Vitafaro
3501.225147 Photograph of
3501 225.148 Florida DAV I D records rHDeding
3501.229149 20053006 Handwritten rotes
3501226 Date Dueled=
3501.226 001 2007.01.19 Person search for SSN
3501226.002 2007.01.11 Florida DAV.I.D.Indtridual suhmary page regarding
3501226-003 2007.01.11 NCIC Interstate Identifiotion Index search for
1501226.001 2007.01.11 Florida DAV.I.D.historical 01Yer Ikenleadhlgy regarding
MM
3501.226006 2007.01.11 taw enforcemmt repcel regarding
3501.226 036 2007.01.11 National Comprehensive Report regarding
3501.226 CO7 2007.0127 1.MMtestimonyof
3501.226 032 Vegan Manors Police Department Endence/Propertr INN*101
3501.226009 200004.n&
2008.03.18 IMME testimony of
3501.226010 2008.0815 FEN memorandum regarding contact weth
3501226011 2008.0815 Letter from Scott Cruse to Adam Reeve
3501.226012 2008.10.07 FBI memorandum regarding victim nonficallco
3501.226013 2008.10.07 FEU memorandum regarding netim nonficallco
3501.226014 2008.11.25 Letter from George Nichals to Manila'', WM
3501.226015 2008.12.03 F8I memorandum regarding debating letter to
3501.226016 2008.12.03 Letter from5cort Cruse tow Sulkewsia
3501.226017 2008.12.06 FEU memorandum regarding deneming tatter to
3501226018 2008.12.C11 FEll memorandum regarding delivering baler to
3501.226019 2009.01.15 acknowled m nt of sciv e
3501.226020 2009.02.17 FS memorandum regarding aclrroMedgemont ot
WYK*
3501.226021 2009.02.17 Fga memorandum regarding aerosiedgemcnt of
service
3501.226022 2011.03.07 FIN memoranatn regarding phoneinterview weber
3501.226.023 2011.03.12 FIN memorandum regarding travel to Interview
3501.226.024 2011.03.12 FBI memoranaan regarding =finance of Australian Federal Pollee
3501.226025 2011.03.12 Fga memoranda regarding travel to interview
3501.226026 2011.03.14 Fga memorandum regarding tra‘c4 to interview
3501226027 2011.03.14 Fga memorandum regarding favor to interview
3501.226022 2011.03.17 Cover street for notes from interview
3501.226 029 2011.03.17 Telegraphs provided by
N/A
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.00.12
2021.0012
2021.0012
2021.00.12
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.07.23
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2021.10.11
2011.10.11
2011.10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
202L10.11
2021.1025
Allonity ProducedtoOdense
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.01.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04,12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
2021.04.12
3501.226030 2011.03.17 Interview 302
Stoic' McCauley
2021.04.12
3501.226031 2011.03.17 Cowl sheet for rotes from intent 2021.01.12
3501.226032 2011.03.17 Cover sheet fee photo way thaw, to 2021.01.12
3501.226033 IOI1.03.18 Cony shoat for 20 pbntgUaptdcm:eared horn 2021.01.12
3501.226034 2011.03.18
Cover sheet fee 'TM Massage school certilkation for
MEI 2021.04.12
3501.226035 2015.02.25 Authorizatian to release infumalion to another person tom 2021.0432
3501.226036 20110322 FBI memorandum documenting immstIcalion 2021.04.12
3501.226-037 2014.09.06 Mlam case 6x ummts 2021.04.12
3501.226038 2015.02.26 FM request regarding materials relating to 2021.04.12
3501.226039 2015.03.11 FBI memorandum regarding FOa request letter 2021.01.12
3501.226010 2016.02.29 Hanchienttth notes 2021.41312
3501.226011 2019.09.09 interview 302 2021.41312
3501.226012 2019.09.09 interview handwaten notes 2021.41312
3501.226013 Hancholltth notes 2021.01.12
3501.226044 Wa0se11ten notes 2021.01.12
3501.226045 Biographical Meth 2021.01.12
3501.2264346 2007.0310 Almon search for social security number 2021.07.23
3501226047 2008.0807 FBI re port retarding debrering victim notification knee 2021.07.23
3501.226048 2008.0308 RI repot regarding debrering victim notification letter 2021.07.23
3501.226019 2008.0325
Letter to Mr. Adam Reeve regarding clelverng victim notification
batter 2021.07.23
3501.226030 2008.10.07 RI report regarding delarering victim notification letter 2021.07.23
3501.226051 2008.12.03 FW report regarding delarering victim notification letter 2021.07.23
3501.226052 2008.12.01 FW report regarding delarering victim notification letter 2021.07.23
3501.226053 2009.03.17 FW report regarding delarering victim notification letter 2021.07.23
3501.226054 2011.0312 Ka report regarding <tethering victim notification letter 2021.07.23
3501.226056 2011.03.12 1W report regarding deluering victim notification letter 2021.07.23
3501.226056 2011.03.14 CBI report regarding delsrering victim notification letter 2021.07.23
3501.226057 2011.03.14 419 report regarding &ducting victim notification letter 2021.07.23
3501.226-058 2011.03.22 FBI report regarding <tethering victim notification tette. 2021.07.23
3501.226-059 2011.07.17 302 from vitervien 2021.07.23
3501.226050 2015.03.11 RI re port regarding FOIAregavni 2021.07.23
3501.226061 2018.12.04 RI re port regarding latter to 2021.07.23
3501.226062 2018.12.04 RI report regarding delivering victim notify -anion letter 2021.07.23
3501.226053 2019.06.03 Typed notes from Interview 2021.07.23
3501.226064 2019.06.03 Handwritten notes 2021.07.23
3501.226065 kindrenttth notes 2021.07.23
3501.226056 BrOwarel County. FL mfdencefproPertyrecetd 2021.07.23
3501.226057 2010.06.11 Emal than 2021.07.23
3501.226 068 2011.03.11 (mai than 2021.07.23
3501.226059 2011.03.30 (Mil th an 2021.07.23
3501.226070 20110435 Emal than 2021.07.23
3501.226071 2011.04.20 (mai than 2021.07.23
3501.226072 2011.07.04 (mai th an 2021.07.23
3501.226073 2011.07.04 Nobee of Fling [attachment to preplan anal) 2021.07.23
3501.226074 2014.04.29 fin>1 th an 2021.07.23
3501.226075 2014.07.18 (mai than 2021.07.23
3501.226076 2014.08.11 (mai th an 2021.07.23
3501.226077 2014.08.22 (mai th an 2021.07.23
3501.226078 2014.08.22 (mai th an 2021.07.23
3501.226079 2015.01.14 (mai th an 2021.07.23
3501.226M 2016.05.10 (mat th an 2021.07.23
3501.226-061 2019.04.01 (mat th an 2021.07.23
3501.226032 2020.1027 (mat than 2021.07.23
3501.226063 2020.1027 Scarmeel (Mdence/progorty recant 'attachment to previous mai) 2021.07.23
3501.226 064 Narrative continuation rotating Wilton Minor PC 202130.11
3501.226 08S 1999.06.11 302 2021.10.11
3501.226 0.36 2008.07.10 Letter nOinVitalana 2021.10.11
3501.226087 2008.09.03 Letter from Vitafana 2021.10.11
3501.226 OM 2008.09.03 Letter from Vitalana 202310.11
3501.226 089 2011.03.07 (mai than 202310.11
3501.226 093 2011.0307 (mai than 202310.11
3501.226091 2011.03.09 (mai than 202310.11
3501.226092 2011.03.10 (mai Nato 202310.11
3501.226093 2011.03.11 Cm>, chain 202310.11
3501.226094 2011.03.11 (mat chain 2021.10.11
3501.226095 2011.03.15 Emal 2021.10.11
3501.226096 2011.03.15 Email chain 202130.11
3501.226097 2011.03.15 LOW chain 2021.10.11
3501.226098 2011.03.15 Erna' th an 202310.11
3501226039 2011.0315 Emal th aw. 2021.10.11
3501.226-103 2011.03.15 (mai th an 2021.10.11
3501.226-101 2011.03.15 (mai than 202310.11
3501.226.102 2011.03.17 302 202310.11
3501.226.103 2011.05.17 Notce of Fling 202310.11
3501.226101 2014.04.15 (mai than 202310.11
3501.226105 2015.01.26 Declaration byagent 202310.11
3501.226106 2019.06.13 Memorandum to filet 202310.11
3501.226-107 2020.1027 Notes anclaccomciamsrceexuments 2021.10.11
3501.226106 2021.1020 Notes 2021.102
3501X0
DesalPtlea Attorney Producsd to Debora
3501227.001 2019.07.08 FRI record • th us intake report WA 2021.07.23
35012E Date DesalPtlea AttOrneY PrOdUCed to MOOS*
3591 228 0)1 2020.07.17 F8Irecord • intake report
WA
202L07.23
3591 228 0)2 20x0,071) 98!record •I intake report 2023.0723
3501229 Date Desap0on Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 229 0)1 2019.07 12 98!record . olds inuke report WA 202: 07 )3
3501.230 Date Descr10000 Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.}3POOl 2019.07.08 lea town] • crisis intake repo< WA }OL.W.23
3501231 Data Desolation Attorney Produced to Phase
3501.231.001 2020,07.07 1W record • In intake room, WA 2021 07 23
3501232 Date Descadeloa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.232 0)1 2019.0809 1W record • crisis intake rerun
WA
2021 07 23
3501.232 002 2019.0809 rap sneet 2021 07 23
3501233 Date Desatiation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.233.031 2019.07.11 1W record . ealsis intnie repen WA 2021.07.23
3501399 Date Detestation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.230.001 2019.07.16 1W record , axis intake re0ot WA 202: 07 23
3501236 Date DesatPtioa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.235.001 2020.07.21 1W record . • intake retort
$/A
2021.07.23
3501.235002 2020.07.21 Screenshot of Reddy post 2021.07.23
3501.235.003 2020.07.21 Screensnot of Redde post 2021.07.23
3501.235.001 2020.0121 Saterectiot of Redde post 2021.07.23
3501.235006 2020.07.21 Scretoshot of Redde post 2021,07,23
3501235 Data Desolates Attorney Produced to Debase
3501.236001 2019.07.03 asset Noon
N/A
2021.07.23
3501.236.002 2019.07.03 law enforoament 2021.07.23
3501.236.003 2019.07.03 contact card report 2021.07.23
3501.236001 Rgto r of ct card 2021.07.23
3501.236.0)5 Toto r of and Donald Tnsn• 2021.07.23
3501.236.005 Samandwat of Facetoak 2021.07.23
3501.236.007 FinatoraC 410f OK 2021.07.23
3501.236.038 Finatoprac.of bilis 2021.07.23
3501.ZI7 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.237 0)1 2019.07.08 flu re cord , _ crisis intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501.238 Date DesalPtIon Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.238 001 20201019 18I record . make report
WA
2021.07.23
3501.238.002 2021.02.16 Inteniew 302 2021.1011
3501.238.003 2021.02.16 Interwiev• notes 2021.10.11
3501.238.0:4 incident request 2021.1011
3501.238.035 2021.01.23 1W Import form 2021.1011
3501.238605 2021.04.23 1W incident summary 2021.10.11
3501239 Date Detestation Attorney Produced to Defense
350! 239 0)1 2019.07.11 1W record. crisis nuke rcy, ri WA 202: 01 23
3501.200 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defence
3501.240 0)1 2021.04.28 Notes of Interview with FIFO Captar WA 2021.07.23
3501.201
Data Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.305001 2019.08.13 Sea record . ens. inale report WA 2021.07.23
3503242 Date Descriptnan Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.242 001 2020.07.09 1W record.- intake re cce WA 2021 07 23
3501243 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.203.001 2019.07.18 Hew Mexico driver's license reccea
WA
2021.07.23
3501.243.002 2019.07.18 riot r 2021.07.23
3501.243003 2019.07.18 contact card report 2021.07.23
3501.243.0:4 2019.07.18 finder report 2021.07.23
3501.203-003 2019.07.18 law enforcement report 2021.07.23
3501.2•0 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Deter.
3501.20COOl 2019.05.15 Hew Mexico 'Jamey's license (*cord: WA 2021.07.23
nova Date Desa1Ption Attorney Produced to Defense
:55HH.:11:00 :11:1200.88 War mato te$:Oft S•Larlial
3501246 Date DesaiPtioa Attorney Produced to Detente
3501.246 003 2019.09.14 FBI record • 'MI calls Intake report
WA
2021 07 23
3501.246 022 2019.09.14 Saeenshot of YourutevWee 2021 07 23
3501.247 Date Descrialon Attorney Produced to Odom
3501247.031 2019.07.09 FS record . M crisis intake report
WA
2023.07.23
3501247.002 2019.07.18 F 6 record • M crisis intake ripen 2021.07.23
3501.208 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
39)1 248 031 2019.07 08 96 record.- cnus intake renal WA 202: 07 23
3501.249 Date Description Attorney Produced to  Detente
39)1 249 0)1 2007.08 05 p‘Cric records search WA 202: 07 )3
3501250 Date DesaiPtioa Attorney Produced to Odense
3501.250031 2019.08.10 rearmed • crisis intake rcpert WA 2021.07.23
3501251 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.252021 2019.07.12 FBI record • crisis intake rayon WA 2011 07 23
3501Za Date DesaiPtioa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.252 0)1 2019.0708 Fm record. CICG matt roport N/A 2021 07 23
3501253 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.353001 2019.0703 FW record - crisis intWte report WA 2021 07 23
3501754 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.254.001 2019.07.08 181 record =0118 Intake spat WA 2021.0723
3501255 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.255 0)1 2019.07.12 FBI record.- crisis intake report N/A 2021 07 23
3501256 Date Moine^ Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.256.021 2019.07.11 RI record •MMOUs intake report
N/A
2021.07.23
3501.256.002 2019.07.11 Saetristoot of arntter Kelik.and reply 2021.07.23
3501.257 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.257.0M 2019.0708 FBI record . = crisis intake rcoon N/A 2021 07 23
350Lra Date Dews Attorney Produced to Defense
350E  0)1 2020.08.17 FBI record . intake rayon
N/A
2021.07.23
3501.258.022 2020.08.17 Feirecord . MM intake rnaon 2021.07.23
3501.258000 2020.10.09 FW record. intake ream 2021.07.23
3501.M3 Date DesatOthla Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.259 021 2019.09.25 FW record. ate LnZalt report WA 2021.07.23
3501260 Date DesatOthla Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.260 COI 2019.07.11 FW record. M tree 'mato report WA. 202: 07 13
3501.261
1- Date Descrialoa Attorney Produced to Defense
350136/001 2020.07.02 Fm record. ntake renen WA 2021.07.23
3501262 Date Description Attorney Produced to Dame
3501.262 0)1 2019.0708 FSIrecord ....leis intake report N/A 2021 07 23
3501.263 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.263 0)1 2019.0708 90 record . l l [Ails intake report WA 202: 07 23
381.}60 Date Desolptloa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.264 0)1 2019,11.:3 90 record . crta nuke report WA 202: 07 )3
3501.266 Date Desolptloa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.265 021 2007.07.23 WA 2021.07.23
3501.266 Date Descrialon Attorney Produced to Dame
:55:HHHH.:103H MISSOMM.13 Fear MK intake moon a Ninj 11111(a
3507.267 Date lisaldP 1800 Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.267.001 2019.08.02 lm record erI0slnlaIe roped WA 202L07.23
350120/ Dela Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.268.001 2019.0510 compre0msnv address tenon
WA
2021.0723
3501.268002
....
2019 0910 IMMI law en forcement report 2021.0 .23
3501.2680O3 2019.05.10 contact card 2021.07.23
3501 268 COS 2019 0910 New Mexicodcwers license records 2021 07 23
3501.269 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 269 COI 2020 1019 ins record mtakl report WA 202 07 2
3507.3]0 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3591 T70 031 2019 07 09 Ins record.- crlib ntake revert WA 202' 07 I
3501.2)1 Date DescriPtion Attorney Produced to Odense
3501.271.001 3019.0833 ins record MI c Intake raped N/ }03.013
3501.272 Date Desailithia Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.272.001 2006.08.17 DAVID records WA 202: 07 23
350L273 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.273 C01 2019.07.23 Ins record crisis nl4ke report WA 202:.0]13
1274 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.274 001 3019.0. 34 FS' record crisis intake report 4154 2021 07 2
3501275 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.275.001 2019.11.29 F 6 report rciurdin ails N/A 2021.07.23
3501271 Date Description Attorney Produced to Donne
3501. 2021.03.29 194 rose rd'—YNako report
WA
2021 07.23
3501 276 032 302,0312 FM neat. form 2021 10 11
3501.277 Date DesalP800 Attorney Produced to  Defense
3501 2019.07.13 194 record olds nntast repent
N/A
2021.07.23
3501277.002 2019.08.22 Ins record ells!nest report 2027.0.23
3501278 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
39)1 278 031 2019.05.10 New laniard et -.c. e or % 102:.0113
350L279 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.279 031 3019.1130 18I record crisis intake report VA 2021 07 23
350L280 Date Descrilithia Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 280-001 2020 0 03 NM record At** report WA 2021.013
350L2Il Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 281.001 2019 07 12 1m record S-°Ias intake tenon
WA
2021.0]13
3501.281.002 2019.07.21 NM record • alas intake Neon 202:.013
3501.82 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to  Defense
3501382001 019.07.10 FM record ell Make report N/A 2021.07.13
3501110 Date Description Attorney Produced toDebase
3501.283001 2020,0 6, 34 Fm record Wake roper WA 2021.0.13
35012114 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
350E 2020.07.03 1m record ake report
WA
2021.07.23
3501 284 CO2 2020.07.03 NU reVard intake report 2021.0].23
39)1 284 0)3 2020.07.15 194 record intake eport 2021.013
3501.285 Date Description Attorney Produced to  Defense
3501 285001 2019.07.23 1m record . rise mate report N/A 2021.07.13
350L2111 Date Dentinal^ Attorney Produced toDeanne
3501 286 001 2019 07 15 1m record mss intake report
VA
2021.0].23
3501.286.002 2019.07.15 entree🔛I M. cnus Intake repCel 2021.0].23
3501.287 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3931 287 0)1 2019.0708 181 record • crisis incr. reran NIA 20E 07 23
3501.2311 Date Desattioe Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.288 0)1 2019.0707 lm record •EM crisis intake report WA 2021.0723
350L2•9 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Odense
3501.389001 2019.07.15 flu record -crisis intake moot NIA 2021 07 23
3501.290 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.290 col 2020.10.27 norecord. intake repot WA 2021 07 23
3501.291 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.291 001 2020.0717 Fm record • intake report
N/A
2021.07.23
3501.291402 202007.18 Ha record .f -Intake report 2021.07.23
350L292 Date pasattble Attorney ProducedtoDelano
3501.292 COI 2019.07 08 FP record • ate nzate report N/A 2021 07 23
3501293 one pasattble Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501 293 0)1 2019.07 08 FP record • mss intake (sport NIA 202: 07 23
3501.294 Date Desalption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.29a 0)1 2009.09.21 Transcript of the depaubonol WA 2021.07.23
MMMM
Data Desolation Attorney Prod ri d to Warne
3501.295401 2020.07.07 FBI record • Mining report
N/A
2021.07.23
3501.295032 2020.07.07 Fm record • M intake report 2021.07.23
3501.295 033 2020.07.08 Ka record • M intake region 2021.07.23
_-
Dote Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501396001 2019.07.13 F 5 record. cnsa Intake cepa( N/A 2021.07.23
Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Dakota
3501.297401 2019.05.20 law enforcement repot
N/A
2021.07.23
3501.297.002 2019.05.20 contact card report 2021.07.23
3501.297 003 2019.05.20 Pipl search 2021.07.23
3501.297007 Pnot 2021.07.23
3501.297005 criminal noon 2021.07.23
3501.297406 Saeerdol of Factlaccit 2021.07.23
3501297407 Sacco:hot 2021.07.23
350L2SS Date Desolation attorney ProducedtoDelano
3501.298 001 2020.1027 intake repan WA 2021 01 23
3501.729 Date Desolation attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.299 001 2007.08.15 Law enforcemmt repot revokes N/A 2021.07.23
350L300 Date peozilltble Attorney Produced to Deleon
3501300 0)1 2020.03.19 intake Noon WA 2021.07.23
350L301 Date Desolation Attorney ProducedtoDefame
3501.301001 2020.07.08 intake resort NJA 202: 07 23
350L302 Data Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.302 031 2019.07.08 eras intake re on N/A 2021 07 23
=
Date Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.303 0)1 2019.07 08 crisis intake mon WA 202: 01 13
3501.304 Date pasalption Attorney Produced to Defense
350130e001 2019.09.11 crisis intate report WA 2021.07.23
3501.305
Date pasattion Attorney Produced to Defense
3501305001 2019.07.M Mcrae Mlac tepee N/A 2021.07.23
3501.306 Date palatable Attorney Produced to Delano
3501.306 0)1 2020.07.08 intake report
WA
2021.07.23
3501.306032 2021.06.21 intake f013011 2021.10.11
3503307 Date Desaiption Atorney Defense
3501 307 0)1 019.03 cr into % 2023.0223
3501.309 Date Desabtbn Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 308 0)1 2020.08.02 MI neat* report W 2021.07.2
3501.309 Date DewOptloa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501309 0)1 201907.08 I Minato repot WA 2021.0].23
3501-310 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense

3501. 10 0)1 2019.0 .08 FM In ale report WA 21 07 2
3501.311 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense

I. 11033 3019.0633 SW ate repot
WA
2021 0 .23
3591.311002 2019.0533 SW ineatc report 2021.0.23
3503.312 Date Desalpeon Attorney Produced to Odense
3501312 0)1 2019.07 08 Fm lnato report WA 2021.0].23
3503-313 Date DesaiPthia Attorney Produced to Defense
1 I .033 2019.04.08 Addeo% port roy
WA
2021.07.23
3501 I .032 2019.04.08 law*Hortemen1 report rouadLne 20210713

3501. I .003 2019.04.08 Contact card earning 2021.07.23
3501. I al 2019 DO 08 Diva's history records rtlurdln6 2021.0 .23

3501. I .035 Fiwtooraph 2021.07.23
3501. I 006 2007.112.08 FINrecords c ecii 2021.1031
3501.314 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3»1.310001 3019,050 18I IcealCrepat W 20}1.013
350UIS Date Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501315 0)1 Twiner sueenshot V, 2023 .0)13
3501-316 Date Dewblbn Attorney Produced to Defense

I. 14003 2019.09.17 13a ntal o report W }03.0.23
3507.313 Date Dew ton Attorney Produced to Detente
3501.317031 2019.0.20 SW lnate report
W
2021 07 23
3»1.317001 3019.0.50 SW nate report 202..0] 13
3591.310 Date Description Attorney Produced to Orions*
1 NI 2020 11 02 FM a report W 7
3503.319
Date Desoiption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.31%033 2020,01.02 FM intake report WA 2021.07.23
3507.320 Date DescaptIon Attorney Produced to Detente
3501.320033 2019.05.10 Other's history records for WA 2021.07.23
3501-372 Date Desalption Attorney Produced to Defense
3591321 031 2020.02.05 18iintake report WA 202. 07 13
3501.322 Date Descripifon Attorney Produced to Defense
I 3020.0611 SW ineatc report WA 2021.07.23
3501.323 Date Attorney Produced to Defense
3»1.3}3001 2019.07.08 FmI Aake report W 2021 07 23
3503.324 Date Desalptke Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.324003 2019.0 .14 Motorr ydMCe blorrtotbn searthreWts
WA
2021 07.23
3501. 24002 2019.0 .14 Motor yobke blorrtotbn searthresSts 2023.0.23
3501. 24003 2019.0 14 LW COMNOTalt re port reprdIns 2021.07.23
3591.320001 2019.0 14 Rol search br 2021.0 .23
3501.324.035 2019.0 14 Contact canton:on for 2021.07.23
3591.320006 2019 0 34 Asset report for 2021.0 .23
3501.324.007 2019.03.34 Ceiva's history morels for 2021.07.23
3501.324.038 2019.04.08 Con:air:entre address report 2023.0.23
3501.315 Date Desoto*. Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.325001 2019.07.10 Fm intake report WA 2021.07.23
Is LI Pue 'SI 'OT '6 18 'L SHdVHDV2:1Vd 2:1102:10 1A1_011.0dd Ol1J31SfS
'WINE Val yodetaleni rat 9010'810Z [00'914'106£
eimPo 0; PEMPOM &Bosom ucelatosaa Ma 9ITIOSE
ft./0'110Z VRI Locionieffis if tOltrGIOZ KO Srf IChf
*sung° Oa Imonpoid AsVIOIN emetic's/a Ilea SirrIOSE
ft 10 :tot VIN In.:p.tai spioNai kiNeos $noutA ICO nl'IOSf
mooliao2PlooPold Miming uoadinsafi *Ica mien
ft 10 :lel CPI yodanieTil if 1101'6102 10) fef'1051
moolea01PlooPold Aeutomf voattfona gra IttIOSE
Et £0t i0i VP, Ixrdo,oles.” rili 911,0'6102 [Cant TOSE
ofuelea of PotoPold Amoy/ uoattiosea *Pa ZniOSE
ft10120/ Chi yodzoole/ul Wu fill'810Z 10) WE' 10S0
1001601P1nP1d Asoinly ucettliona Kea OVIOSE
it'LO't tat VPI Wisaaa Auxiom 1110'8102 10) Ott IC5f
£rLO'I000 lifftooisiolui woffsoieN I1101102 NO Ott 1GSf
f C20102 VIM maimilul umi ZOE 1110'810Z 10) Ott tent
1110 oa PciiPoid Asumay Deationa Ma alrEIOSE
EilfrtiOt VRI Lodstolen, rat Stt0.6102 10) 60010S0
ofenloa 01PotePold AousoaV Deatfinfaa flea MINE
Et £0 trot VPI yotlaniexil 181 03 tO610Z 100 90£'1050
ofenlea ea P1OP0M MUMMY Deattiosea flea ntiOSE
ft £0 trot VPI yodanielui NJ 1,010.810Z 1001frIOSE
osuorecoPlooPold AsuPOUV Deattosea Ilea (EVIOST
f rt0.1 tat yin ioxionielus en 9010.010Z IC0100'1050
mitre ollnoopold &mow utelasosaa otea 9E£'105f
f/ 10 :tee VP, ioadeniew el 9380'6100 10)5ff 105f
0,00.10 04 Potopotd Miming uoadv>soa plea SWINE
ft 10 :lel VP, yodonielul el 60 10'6100 10) rff'1051
1V1/1Q 0>PlooPold Mwouy uoraosea ma 1EEIM£
ft tO 110Z VAI Lode' arm en fa tO 610Z ICO.EfElOst
ankaPaca Willow Asusowt ucetainsea *Iva MIME
1 ridattat FM fof spacoof manly sfrofita £1'L0'610Z 50,000.1051
f C10102 io; mato ye' ucluo) 2110'810Z 100tEVIOSI
f ZIOTZOr )Q1 a itconnopo MI 8110'610Z f00.ZECIOSI
fC201Z02 Jo; uoianiull ssoulinfl £lL0'610Z 00,010105f
ft'LOICOZ io; L01 1111y 8110.6100 ICOZ1V1051
eso•NO1P111POId Atonally uoattossa Ilea MIME
Ettatrot VP, Pod), olem r3i St LOVZOt 1CO 1ff' ii)S0
olooPaot PotePotd housollif uoattiosea flea !MOSS
1101.1r02 Val 1.)ou human unliesOuni Tf10.610t ZCOOft1051
Et LO ICOC tint" 1^S^Jalul tuoi1ZOf If tO GIOZ 10) Off 1051
wo *NO 01 P1OnPOM AevioUV uoagossa Ilea
OfflOSE
ft 10 :tot VP, poillonievi en 80.L0'6102 1036Zf Vhf
muRPROMPRopPokl Atonally utiadiosea pea REIN£
1010 trot VP, Ledo' rielv, oil fl't0.6102 KO Rif Vhf
olooPao1PotePold Antony voaatosoa flea SWINE
ItITICOZ VP, uodeniezus of P1130'6100 1C0100'1051
maPao1PlooPold Anomaly uciUkosefi ma [MDSE
ft 10 ;tat ,,,;>, vocb, 01eivl of St't0.610Z 10) Rif IOS£
/1011004 0040P:0d ADILIOUV equi:deo ofea 9ZEIOSE
3501.347 Date DesalAtIoa Attorney ProducedtoDeb=
3501.347.031 2019.09.10 FBI intake report WA 202L07.23
3501.343 Date Desolation Attorney eroduind to Delease
3501.348.002 2021.03.08 MI intake report WA 2021.07.23
3.50L349 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.349.001 2007.07.02
Florida DAVID. odindual summary page rogarthng
WA
2021.07.23
3501.349.= 2007.07.02 Consion *likening Agency search regardhe 2021.07.23
3501.349.003 2007.07.02 CoAsion or Licensing Agency search reeardreRNMInvestleations 2021.07.23
3501.349.003 2007.07.02 Law enforcem= repot r Min 2021.07.23
3501.350 Date Descriptice Attorney Produced to Defense
3501350001 3019.8.C8 13a intake report WA 2021.07.23
3501.351 Date Description Attorney Produced to Deena
3501.351.001 2019.0710 1m intake report
WA
2021.07.23
3501.351.002 2019.0713 HP intake re 2021.07.23
3501352 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.352.001 2019.07.11 181 intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501.353 Date °ascription Attorney Produced to Deltas*
1501.353 002 2020.07.09 FM intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501.354 Data Descrkitioa Atto rn ey Produced to Debase
3501.35.001 2020.07.13 FBI intake report WA 2021.07.23
3501.355 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.355 COI 2020.0810 SW intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501.356 Date DesaiPtioa Attorney Produced to Defense
1501.356 031 2020.0805 FM intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501.357 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.357.001 2019.07.25 1m intake report
WA
2021.07.23
3501.357.002 2019.07.25 Fla intake report 2021.07.23
3501.353 Date Descriptioa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.358 COI 2020.07.13 1m intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501.359 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.359 COI 2019.0709 1m intake report WA 2021.07.23
3501360 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.360 031 2020.07.09 FBI intake report WA 2021.07.23
350L361 Date Description Atto rn ey Produced to Drama
3501.361031 2019.08.14 13I intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501.3C Date Dascription Altos= Produced to Defense
3501.362 031 2019.07.29 HD intake re WA 2021 07 23
3501.363 Data DeSCIIPUOn Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.563 0)1 2019.07 08 RIintake report WA 202: 07 23
3501.364 Data DesaiPtioa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 364 COI 2019.08.06 SW intake report WA 2021.07.21
3501.365 Date Dot sate Attorney Produced to Wane
3501.365001 2020.07.13 101 intake report
WA
2021.07.23
3501.365002 2020.07.13 Screenthot attached to intake report 2021.07.21
3501366 Date Desolation Mane/ Produced to MOM&
-IIIIIIIIF 2020.07.22 131 Intake re WA 2021.07.23
3501367 Date Desoiption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501367 001 2019.05 10 Cover's history records r !ding WA 202: 02 23
3501369 Date Desatption Attorney ProducedtoOdense
3501.368031 2019.0722 Banta-otter@Pen regarding
N/A
2021.07.23
3501.368.002 2019.07.22 Law enforcemxit report regarding 2021.07.23
3501.368 033 2019.07.22 Contact card report retAretng 2021.07.23
3501,368 OO4 2019.07.22 Finder report regardire 2023.07.23
3501.368 0)5 2019.07.22 COvees history:geoids regarding 2021.07.23
3501.368 0:6 2019.07.07 1W crisis Mao form 2021.10.11
3501.369 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 369 0)1 2020.07.06 1W intake report WA 2021 01 23
3501370 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.370001 2019.10.08 F81 intake report WA 2021.07.23
3501.371 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoOdense
3501.3710)1 2019.07 19 MI intake report WA 2021 01 23
3501.372 Date Desoiption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.372 031 2019.07 08 1W intake retort IPA 2021 02 23
3501.373 Date Desoiption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.373.001 2020.08.20 1W intake report
NIA
2021.07.23
3501.373.002 2020.08.24 Filli intake report 2021.07.23
Date DescriPthla Attorney ProducedtoDakota
3501.374 001 2019.07.11 1W intake report
WA
2021.07.23
3501.374.002 2019.07.11 1W intake report 2021.07.23
3501.374.003 2019.07.11 FBI intake report 2021.07.23
350L375 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoOdense
3501.375 001 2021.05.17 Typed notes from call WA 2021 01 23
3501376 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.376 0)1 2019.0811 RI intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501377 Date DescriPticia Attorney Produced to Miens*
3501.377001 2019.09.10 SW intake report
WA
2021.07.23
3501.377002 2021.03.19 ntemew 302 202L10.11
3501.377003 intennew tlenes 2021.1011
3501.373 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.378 0)1 2019.09.13 1W intake report WA 2021 0) )3
3501.379 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoOdense
3501.379.001 2021.03.22 1W intake report WA 2021.07.23
350130 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoOdense
3501.380001 2019.07.12 1W intake report WA 2021 01 23
a
Date Maple ton Atterney Produced to Defense D
2019.0828 SW intake report WA 2021 01 23
Sia m Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.382031 2019.07.12 1W 'plate report
WA
2021.07.23
3501.337002 2019.07.12 FEll intake report 2021.07.23
3501333 Date DesatptIon Attorney ProducedtoDeltas*
3501.3890)1 2020.07.09 1W Intake report
WA
2021.07.23
3501.389032 2020.07.09 Screen at at tached to intake report 2021.07.23
3501.389003 20200709 Se/etre-hot attothed to intake report 2021.07.23
301.383001 2020.07.09 Saterez)ot attached to intake report 2021.07.23
3501.383.036 2020.07.09 Settere.not attached to intake report 2021.07.23
3501.383.036 2020.07.09 Sacerrtiot attached to intake report 2021.07.23
3501.389007 2020.07.09 Screenthot attached to intake r rt 2021.07.23
3501.383.038 2020.07.09 Sercenthot attached to intake report 2021.07.23
3501.381039 2020.07.09 Sercerr.Pot attxhed to intake report 2021.07.23
3501.381010 2020.07.09 Sactre.hot attached to intake report 2021.07.23
3501.381011 2020.07.09 Screerrlot attached to intake report 2021.07.23
3501.383012 2020.07.09 Screendtiot attached to intake report 2021.07.23
3501.384 Data DnaIrks Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.384 0)1 202007.02 181 neat* report
WA
2021.07.2
3501.384.802 2021.10.08 r4eIttm .mernew noes 202L10.11
3501.384.033 2005.10.18 Um Beach Police reixet 202L10.11
3501.384.011 2021.10.11 Haccleittm oat 2021.1805
3501.384.035 2021.10.11 1E4 302 2021.11.86
3301.384006 2021.1 08 1m 302 2021.11.06
3% Date Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.385 031 2019.12.09 i81i ate report 1trA 2011.0].23
3501.3K Date Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 86 CO1 2020.07.17 FM hale report 1trA 2021.0].23
Date Deeablfen Attorney Produced to Oedema
3501.387.001 2020,12.06 RI ware report WA 2021.0].23
3501.310 Date Descriptioa Attorney Produced to pedant*
3931388 031 2019.04.09 Law enfoitemmt report 'natal 30210723
WA
3501.388002 2019.04.09 Contact card rem, repecir 2021 07 2
3503.388 003 2019.04.09 Diva's hittory records rapardlnc 2021 07 23
3501.389 Date Descri0000 Attorney produced to Detente
3501.389.001 2019.04.09 Compretc.nsn't address report
WA
20}1,0].}3
3501.389.032 2019.04.09 Asset retail regarding 2021.0].}3
3501.389.033 2019.04.09 Law enforcemm1 (coat regarding }0}1.07,}3
3501.389.004 2019.04.09 Contact tardier:oil reSarcana 2021.07.23
501.390 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defines
3501 390 CO1 020.07 06 FBI lrtalcropat WA 2021.0].23
3501.391 Date Description Attorney ereCtuteel to Detente
3501 391 CO1 202030.12 RI intake report WA 2021.0123
Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.391001 020.07.06 FM intate report
WA
2021.07.2

3501. 91002 202007.86 Sdee  attached to 1 repoit 2021.07 .23
3501.391003 202007.86 Screened attached tolntakereport 2021.07.23
3501. 92.00S 20200706 Scremhot attached to Intake report 2021.07 .23
3501.393 Date Description eAtOtney Produced to Defense
3501.391001 2019.07.24 1m loratereport WA 2021.0].23
3501 Date Desalption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.394 031 2019.0 09 RI Intake report WA 2021.0].23
Date Dewlplen Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.395 031 2020.09 14 1W neatereport WA 2021.07.23
350L396 Date Detablfen Attorney Produced to Odense
1 6 CO1 2006.08.17 0weolik WA 2021.07.23
3501.397 Date Dmabtlon Attorney Produced to Define
2019.07.27 1m intatereporl WA 2. 07 2
%3 D Produced Date Description Attorney to Defense
3501.398 031 2%].0].10 Law OftrOrCefilalt report rcgarclindll WA 2021 07 23
350L399 Date Desalption Money Produced to Defense
3591.399 0)1 2019.07 10 FM intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501.000 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501400 COI 2019.08.21 FM intake report WA 2021.07.23
3501.001 Date Descriptioa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501401031 2019 1018
2019.1018
3021d MCrvMw
WA
20}3.0723
3501401.002 Notmlrom Intemew 2021.07.2
3501.002 Date Description Mangy Produced to Defense
3501.002001 2020.01.23 lmintakereport WA 2021.07.23
3501.003 Date , Darwinian Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.003 031 201%0709 , 6 ircalc eepC•1 WA ion 02 23
3501404 Date Desolption Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501404.001 2019.08.18 Notes from tekohene can
Stew. Miller
2021.07.23
35014114.0N 2021.05.13 Notes from Webfx 2021.07.23
3501.405 Date Descaption Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501405001 2019.07.08 1m intake report WA 2011 07 23
3501.406 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.000001 2020.07.22 fill intake report
WA .
2021.07.23
3501.000032 2020.07.29 FM intake report 2021.07.23
3501A01 Date Dewip0on Attornrd ProducedtoDefense
3501.407.001 2019.07.11 1m ]Nate re A 202107.23
3501 406 Date Deter eon Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.408 0)1 2019.08 12 181intale report WA 2021 07 23
3501.409 Data Desolption Attorney Produced to Defense
3YJ1 809 0)1 2021.04.07 302 from intennew with NJA 2021.07.23
3501-410 Date DescriPtion Attorney ProducedtoDefense
35014113001 2020.08.06 Fifa 'neat. (spat WA 202307.23
3501411 Date DescriPtion Attorney ProducedtoDefter.
3501411001 2008.04.01 Nate change petition
WA
2021.07.23
3501411.002 2008.06.04 Order for change of name 2021.07.23
3501411.003 2019.05.10 Repsier of actions 2021.07.23
35014110CM 2019.05.10 Repster of actions 2021.07.23
3501411.035 2019.05.10 C.ion's history records regardin 2021.07.23
3501.411 Date ons 0 Attorney Produced to Defense
3501412-001 2019.05.10 Asset report regardev
WA
2021.07.23
3501412.002 2019.05.10 Lay/enforcement report regarding 2021.07.23
3501412023 2019.05.10 Contact card fecon rogueing 2021.07.23
3501412.004 2019 10 Ddwls hiss records d 2021.07.23
350L413 Date Matt= Attorney Produced to Debase
3501413.001 2019.05.10 Diva's history reoards I'' Win NIA 2021 07 23
3501.014 Data Dascaption Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.414 CO1 2020.08.24 1m intake report WA 2021 07 23
3501.015 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3 501415 0 01 2019.0831 101 Meat/newt WA 2021 07 23
3501.01f Date DesatP 1Ma AMMO,' Produced to MOM*
3501416 001 Various Cherokee. County Sheriffs Office incident moons
WA
2021.07.23
3501.416 002 2005.05.05 ).Mobile records 2021.10.11
3501416003 2005.08.02 ).Mobile records 2021.10.11
3501A17 Data Desat01km Attorney Produced to Defense
3501417.001 21119.07.08 RI intake report WA 2021.07.23
a
3501.013 Date DescrIP044 Attorney ProducedtoDeems*
3501.418 CO1 2010.00.17 Ems] from egarding contact from
I mad than
2021.07.23
3501.418 0)2 2010.06.17 2021.07.23
3501418 033 2010.07.23 (mat th an 2021.0.23
3501418005 2010.07.23 Ertiad from regarding 40640  frcer . 2021.0.23
3501416005 2010.08.2) 2021.07.23 Mid from retarding centact frog. WA
3501.01.1 Date Detalptize Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501419 001 2019.08.14 1m intake report
WA
2021.07.23
3501419002 2019.08.14 FEll intake report 2021.07.23
3501.420 Date DescriPtio0 Attorney Produced to Wan=
, • • 2019.08.30 Fill intake report WA 2021.07.23
350 421 Date Deta tea Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.421.031 2019.0108 FBI Intake report Wa 202L07.23
3504124 Data Attorney andood to Defense
3501421001 006.05.17 Car rental Neon*
N/A
2021.07.23
3501.42}.002 itandesitten not 2021.0].23
3501473 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 23 C01 2020 0709 194 intake report WA 2021 07 23
350/.07 Data Description Attorney Produced to Debase
3301.424 001 2019 1012 RI lntakCrcpM WA }0}1.0713
3501.025 Data DakabDon Attorney Produced to Defense
307907.V RI Inlets( A }0}1.0]33
3501425 Date Dawbibn Attorney Produced to Odense
3501.420001 2019.07 08 1mlntatC report WA 2011.0].23
3503.017 Data D tabDou Attorney Produced to Defense
3301 427 031 2019.0 07 1m intake report WA 2021.07.23
35pi1}8 Data Desci Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.4}BOO/ 020.07.02 FBI intake report WA 2021.012
3501.423 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501  001 2008.0610 National comp( henssvo report I 0 A a earn NJA 2021 07
350/430 Date Desolation Attorney ProducedtoDefense
39)1 130001 2019.07 24 Fm lntakCrcpat F(/a 1011.0213
3501.431 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
35014 31-001 3079.0711 C.1 s histoorrecords for
W
2021.07.2
3501.431-007 Con:nixed report ardine- }0}1.07.}3
3504132 Data Desolation Attorney Produced to Odense
3501432 0)1 2019.07.09 1m intake report WA 2021.0].23
3501.033 Data Desolation Attorney Produced to Cleanse
3501433001 2019.00.10 Comprelx•nnt address report
WA
2021.0].23
3501433402 2019.00.10 Asset retort regarelnit 2021.07.23
1501433403 2019.04.10 Law enforcemcot repot regarding 2021.07.23
3501433401 2019.00.10 Contact card report refacing 2021.07.23
3501433.005 2019.04.10 Driwg's history records regarding 2023.07.23
3501A34 Data Desolation Attorney Produced to Phase
3501.434.001 2019.04.10 ComaeMntrrt address report
WA
2021.0].23
3501434.032 2019.04.10 Asset report rennin/ 2021.0] .23
3501434003 2019.00.10 Law eriorcement report regardine 2021.07.23
3501434.001 2019 04 10 Contact card report Ion/0r 2021.07 .23
3501.434 003 2019.04.10 Diva's history records rotaiding 2021.07.23
3501.433 Data Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.439001 21119.07.12 RI I ate report W 2021012
3501.431 Date Deralatlon Attorney Produced to Oedema
3501430001 2019.07.09 Fla i AM., report FUi 2021.0].23
3501.437 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 2019.0 08 194 Intake report Wi 2021.0]13
3501.438 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501438 001 30}0,0 3.10 Fm lntakenpart FUi 2021 07 )3
3501-439 Date Desalatico Attorney Produced to Defense
3501439.001 2019 07 19 1 III nta repot
V,
2021 07 2
IA 9.002 2019.07.22 Toner *Justice records 202L10.11
IA 9403 2019 07 22 Toner law enl orcement repot 202L10.11
14 9401 2019.10.19 FBI repot 202L10.11
LS
LI Pue 'ST '0I '6 '8 'L. SHdVHDVHVd 2:1102:1O 1ALLMOdd O1.1Thons
no:Wan itionpoy Leona. unittianoa Kea "nen
ItEn 1 TOT anti sawn ape° 1010100Z ICOLO9rIOSE
swop oa papiod anot£Y clop
OMNI
ft to trot V vip i tv4wonopOicci ft ea 8001 ti:0 66,10St
*Nom oapioopou aunty troactiona Ilea
GSVIOSE
ft CO : ZOt VP, can nem mi CO LOSTOZ 10) 859 WU
mono° otPcollital Mona oceanic° ;Plea inVIOSE
1 HAVOC Val Annum, nem, 9t1OSTOZ fOOISVIOSt
frarTZOZ oilcanpante pews 9t10.6101 ZOnSVIOSI
traCTZOZ tooth+ new, cal 9110'610T TOO LSrlOSt
cosuomoapioopoid anca atainna alto ZSYTOSE
ft 10 :COS VP. adoinezul ml BO LO'STOZ ICO 95V IOSE
MONO 0* Plonpoki anca tatitiona olea fndEOSE
ft 10 :TOT VPi atoniens mi SI10'610Z ICO SStriOSE
omen 0* wand anca oceans° nea SIVIOSE
f rarTZOZ VPi cotici neon m 1110.6101 ICO DEVIOSI
fan 0* wand aunty ucquasoa yep
ft 10 trot VP, Ind') aleX,/ ?Eli 8010.STOZ 10) ES> Wif
none° cOPTOninod Atonally UCiaOSOCI WO ESC:TOSE
ft 10 :tot VP. vol.. , tr,,, Si 60 LO'STOZ 103 tSV ILSE
OVU110001POW•POM AsatOUV vacant.° 0100
ZWEOSE
ft 10 IZOI VP. Dan cica ali El ItO'STOT WO ISVIOSE
num° aa pompom ancia ucgdoona ne.:1 !MOSE
front& Lia In tuon nay ZOIO'ItOt ICOLOSIVIOSt
MONO C4 PIOPPOM AaVJOIN oceans° otea OSVIOSE
ft CO :tot VP. Loa new, MT 6: tOOTOT 1(061t Vhf
*Ana° 01 Pinolial concord vacant.° nea 6WTOSE
ft 10 trot VP, Lan new mi 93 L0'020Z 100 814 tent
swap oa papaw Cana ocitiasoa WEI MIME
I TOTITOZ undone 7 asnASCpa relItlin or hien loads. on 0//01102 DOCFLKIDSt
tf'011Z0Z sows unild•Wei. SrLOITOZ ZOO zWIOSE
Et101 COT a flavour Vim *pew unuo551Tpieeat tot OrLOITOZ TOJerVIOSE
MONO 02 POWWW.1 &molly iscadinwa MO ZirYTOSE
ft 10 :TOT VPi can nem al COLO'STOZ 1039tt TOSE
omen 0* pompom MAMA. uoadansm all 9ndlOSE
trLOIZOZ VPi unilci new ml 9T10.0tOt TCOSTrIOSt
omen 0* pompom Moony 1101:1401,0 Kea SWITISE
ft 10 :tot VP. 1)0505 °Lem MT 6010%101 ICO VC> Vhf
*Ana° 01 moons,' aunty uccaosoa all fit TOSE
ft 10 :tee VPl va05 clew, mi et 10.6TOZ 1004C> IC64
mow° ea poonpoki Aswan, tontazsca Nea EWTOSE
ft 10 trot VPi sodEnea mi et10'6101 100 too TOSE
map at pompom MAMA. uoadiosaa all
ZWIOSE
ft10-TTOZ VP. Lan neon el trLOITOZ IOO Itt WU
MOP° 01IMPPOM Amain uclidiOSea 0200
IV. 10SE
ft CO : alt VP. 1)0505 clew, mi Of10.6TOZ 10) Ot,IC5f
*SWING 01940090/4 AsiumniV uclukOSOCI 4404:1 OWIOSE
3501.461.001 2019.07.08 Ilea crisis intake form WA 2021.10.11
3501.462 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
35'.)1 467 001 2019.07 08 14i onus Inlet:40cm WA 2021 10 11
3501.463 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.463001 2019.07 08 Fla anus mint. form WA 2021 10 11
3501.469
SIPINIIIIIIM
Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.407001 Handraiticn nett: WA 2021.10.11
350L465 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3591 165 0)1 2019.07.07 14i onus Intake form N/A 2021.10.11
3503.444 Date Desolation Attorney ProducedtoDolma
3501466 021 Voiconats
N/4
2021.10.11
3501466 002 Voiconals 2021.10.11
3503.417 Date Desolation Attorney ProducedtoDolma
3501.467001 2019.08 Text comer -non won agent
V/A
2021.10.11
3501.467.002 2019 08.07 Ca ,n4cm.uson tex4rairg 2021 10.11
3503.40
f- Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.468001 2021.10.11 Letter re-poles ni‘coIxCtan. Nicola; 8oulat 2021 10 11
1.501-449 Data Desoiption Ilttorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.469 031 2005.11.21 r,Amou notes
07 4
2021.1 11
3501.469 0)2 2005.11.06 Yello w Par. retorts 2021.10.11
3501.469 033 2005.11.22 Public records seatch 2D}3.30.31
3501470 One Desolation Attorney Produced to Detente
3591470 COI 2019.07 CO SW crisis inlet* form WA 202: :0 :I
3501.471 One Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501471 001 2019.07.08 lW onus intake form NJ (A 2021.10.11
3503472 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501472.001 H.1r.O.WIttC11 nate.
WA
2021 10 11
3501472.002 2021.07.26 Fla intake form 2021.10.11
3501472.003 2021.09.20 iflefulfte 302 2021.10.11
3501472.004 2021.09.20 (mai Nan 2021.10.11
35014724305 2021.09.20 (mai Nan 2021.10.11
35014724306 2021.09.20 (mai Nan 202L10.11
3501472.007 2021.09.20 (mai Nan 202L10.11
3501472.008 2021.09.20 (mai Nan 2021.10.11
3501472.009 2021.09.20 (mai Nan 2021.10.11
3501472.010 2021.09.25 (mai Nan 2021.1031
_MS 3501473 001
Date Attorney ProducedtoDebora
2005.12.06 Stir.triber hnioey N/A 2021 10.11
3503.479 Date Daliana Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.4e.001 2021.05.20 Handsnilm ro ta
.A.0011 Willams
2021 10 11
3501.474002 2021.05.20 inzennew 302 2021.10.11
3503.473 Date Description AttornO Predation° Mesa
3501.475401 2019.07.08 Mai th an
WA
2021.10.11
3501475-007 2019.07.08 (mai th an 2021.1025
3501.476 One DeS0100011 Money Produced to Defense
3591 476 0)1 2006 01 77 T-Mobile response WA 202: :0 II
3501.077 Date DescriPtIon Attorney Produced to Defense
3501477 031 2021.05.14 302 from interview WA 2021.10.11
3501.473
DINIODIMMIIII• Data Desolation Attorney ProducedtoDolma
3501.478 001 2021.0602 300 from InteMew
WA
2021.10.11
3501.478 002 2021.06.02 Handwritten rotes from Interview 2021.1031
3501.478 003 2021.06.02 Document shown at interview 2021.10.11
3501473 Date Madan Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.479 001 2021.01.18 Text mestasex with as ont 2021.10.11
3501479.002 2021.04.27 302 Nom Interview 202110.11
3501479.003 2021.04.27 Hanchwitten notes from InteMew 202110.11
3501479004 2021.04.27 Signed proffer agreement 202110.11
3501479 035 2021.01119 Continuation of proffer agreemd0 202110.11
3501479 036 2021.01119 302 from interview 202110.11
35014 79 037 2021.08.19 manthwitten notes from InteMew 2021.10.11
1501479 036 2021.08.23 Attorneyproffer notes lennifct Seidel 2021.10.11
3501.480 Date Desatptioe Attorney ProducedtoWane
3501480031 2021.02.01 302 from InteMew
Donald Ovtoulay
2021.10.11
3501480002 2021.02.01 Nandiwitten notes from Interview 2021.10.11
3501480033 2021.04.26 Attorney tall notes 2021.10.11
3501480CW 2021.0804 Signed prate( agreement 202110.11
3501480-CCG 2021.0804 302 from Interview 2021.10.11
3501480-005 2021.08.03 Document from interview 2021.10.11
3501480-037 2021.0804 Document from Interview 2021.10.11
3501480.000 20210803 Handwritten notes 2021.10.25
3501.481 Date Desalptlee Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.481 031 20200116 302 from Interview
N/A
2021.10.11
3501481 002 2020.01.16 Handwritten rotes from Interview 2021.10.11
Data Desalt Attorney Produced to Defense
3501482 031 2017.04.10 SIC complaint
WA
2021.10.11
3501482 002 2021201.08 SEC judgnwrit 2021.10.11
3501482 033 2020.02.16 Text messages with agent 2021.10.11
35014820OS 202002.26 302 Nom Interview 202110.11
3501.482 COS 202002.26 ilanchwitten notes from Interview 2021.1011
3501.483 Date Desolate Attorney Produced to Defense
3501483 001 2005.07.25 MI CAD Cal Information
WA
2021.10.11
3501483 032 2006.07.13 Vain Beach Ponce Department Incident report 2021.10.11
3501483003 2020.06.03 PSI re port from imemew 2021.10.11
3501483001 2020.06.13 302 Dom interview 2021.10.11
3501483005 2020.08.13 Nandi...11Rn notes from interview 2021.10.11
3501483006 2020.08.19 Notes from all wait attorney 2021.10.11
3501.483 037 Elate oll 2021.10.11
3501.483 C0S lhographr.al I IN 2021.10.11
3503.484 on Desolellon Manley Produced to  Defense
3501.484.031 2019.07.10 FBI MIA* repot 2021.10.11
3501484 002 2019.0820 CrAl tampion: 2021.10.11
3501484 033 2019.10.24 302 horn Interview 2021.10.11
3501424004 2019.10.20 Nanderitton notes from Interview 2021.10.11
3501424033 Ftwolograph 2021.10.11
3501491006 2021.0L27 302 from InteMew 2021.10.11
3501.484 0)7 2021.0L27 Nandientten notes trom Interview 2021.10.11
3501484 03S 2021.07.22 Notes from tall with attorney 2021.10.11
350148A009 2021.08.11 302 Nom Interview 2021.10.11
3501484010 2021.08.11 Handwritten notes from interview 2021.10.11
3501.485 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501485 021 2020.07.17 Text messages with agent
N/A
2021.10.11
3501485 032 2021.0012 302 from Interview 2021.10.11
3501485 033 2021.08.12 Handwritten notes from Interview 2021.10.11
3501.499 Date Dralptlen Attorney Produced to Defense
3501486.001 2021.01.06 302 born InteMew
WA
2021.10.11
3501489002 2021.01.06 Handwritten notes from Interview 2021.1011
3501486.003 2021.08.19 302 Nom Interview 2021. 10.11
3501486.011 20220819 I4andrentten notes from Interview 2021 10.11
3503.0,/ Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.487 0)1 2021.07.13 1Ea Intake report WA 2021 10 11
3501.406 Date Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3591 488 0)1 2011.04 78 Typed now: WA 207::0.:I
3501489 Date MA016.1011 Attorney Produced to Defense
3501489 0)1 2019.07.11 Voictenall WA 2021.10.11
3501.090 Data Desolation Attorney Produced to  Defense
3501490 0)1 2021.04 26 104 repot 2021.10.11
3501490 ,602 Attachment to report 2021.10.11
3501490 ,033 Attachment to report 2021.10.11
3501490001 Attachment to report 2021.1011
3501490005 Attachment to report 2021.1011
3501490.005 Attachment to report 202110.11
3501490007 Attachment to report 202110.11
3501.490008 Attachment to moon 202L10.11
3501490009 Attachment to Noon 2021.10.11
3531 490 010 Attachment to moan WA 2023.30.11
3501.491 Date Des0 Attorney Produced to Debase
350149/001 202106.10 161 intake renal WA 2023.10.31
150102 Date Des0 Attorney ProducedtoDefies*
3501.492401 2019.08.26 Text messages with agents 2021.10.11
3501M2.031 202/.0328 302 from all with attorney 2021.10.11
3501492.0)3 2021.02.20 302 from Interview 2021.10.11
350149290/ 2021.02.20 Handwritten notes from Interview 202L10.11
3501492.005 2021.04.13 302 from InteMew 202L10.11
3501492006 2021.04.13 Handwritten notes from Interview 202L10.11
35014929)7 Ftrotograph 202L10.11
3501492008 Veto:mall 2021.10.11
Date Detatiffro Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.493 031 2019.07.15 Voiternal WA 2021 10 11
3501.0ff Data Oatafr211oa Attorney Produced to Oedema
3531.494 COI 2019.10.09 181 report
WA
2021.10.11
3501 494 032 Attachment to moon 2021.10.11
350) 04 CO3 2019.07.29 Comprehensive moon 2021.10.11
3501.495 Data 0039100w Attorney Produced to Defense
39)1 495 031 Columba County Sheriffs Office report VA 2021.10.11
3.50L096 Data 0039100w Attorney ProducedtoDebase
1501.496 0)1 2021.06.30 Notes from Interview
WA
2023.10.31
3501496903 2021.07.02 Notes from Interview 2021.10.11
3501496 013 2021.07.32 Notes from Interview 2021.10.11
3501.097
MniMi
Date Desorption Attorney ProducedtoMeanie
3501 497 0)1 2016.06.10 Cep:onion transept
WA
2021.10.11
3531.497 032 2019.07.11 Email from ME 2021.10.11
3501.497 031 2019.07.25 Email from attorney 2021.10.11
3501497004 21119.13.03 302 horn InteMew 2021.10.11
3501492906 2019.13.01 IlindwrItten rotes from InteMew 2021.10.11
3501.096 Data Desorption Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501.498 031 2021.08.09 rm intake report WA 2021 10 11
3501.099 Date Desorption Attorney produced to Defense I
3501499 031 2005.10.20 Palm Beach Police Department properly receipt
WA
2021.10.11
3501.499 002 2005.10.20 Palma  Police Dof artment Incident Noon 202210.11
3501.499 003 2011.12.29 Florida Department of Law Enforcement complaint 2021.10.11
3501.499 003 2021.05.32 Note: from interview 2021.10.11
3501499 005 2021.06.09 Notes from InteMew 2023.30.31
3501499 005 Text motives with agent 2023.30.31
3501.500 Data Ditral$100 Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.500 COI 2021.03.30 302 from interview WA 2021.10.11
3501.500902 2021.03.30 Notes from InteMew 2023.10.11
3501.501 Date DesolP 000 Attorney Produced to Defense
35013019)1 2020.07.14 lm repot
2VA
2023.10.31
3501.501002 Attachment to Noon 2023.10.31
3501.501003 Audo recordwl 2021.10.11
Date Desorption Attorney Produced to Debase
35013020)1 2021.09.09 190 Intake report
WA
2021.10.11
3501302932 2021.09.23 MI Intake report 2021.10.11
3501.502903 2021.10.12 Emal 2023.10.25
3501.502.00{ Volcmal 202210.25
3501.502 035 2021.10.26 Notes 2021.11.05
IIIIIIIII Data Des atPtion Attorney Produced to Defense D
2021.04.01 302 from interview
N/A
2021.10.11
3501303032 2021.04.01 Notes from interview 2021.10.11
3501.504 Data Desaffflon Attorney Produced to Oedema
3501.504 001 2021.04.01 302 from interview
WA
2021.10.11
3501.504 002 2021.04.01 Note: from interview 2021.10.11
3501.505 Date DescrIPtloo Attorney Producedto Defense I
,--IIIIMIIIN=
3501.505 021 2019.03.19 Contact card report
N/A
3501.505 002 2019.03.19 Diva's Napo/record 202310.11
3501.505403 2019.03.19 Law enlorcemmit repcet 202110.11
3501.505401 2019.04.09 Lintechn Dade 2021.10.11
3501.505.03S 2019.04.09 therapist web Dago 2021.10.11
3501.505 005 2019.07.19 Notes 2021.10.11
3501.505 007 2019.07.19 Comprehensive report 2021.10.11
3501.505 033 2019.07.19 Mato recordire 2021.10.11
3501.505009 20 19.06.12 9.8pIcenentalrepcet 2021.10.11
3501.505 010 Ynate 2021.1011
3501.506 Date Descriptloa Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.506 001 2021.09.03 Email chain
Patricia Nage
2021.10.11
3501.506 002 2021.09.24 Email th an 2021.1011
Date DesalptIon Attorney Produiad to Defense
3501.507-001 Manch...lite° notes NIA 2021.1025
3501.107 Date Dwalption Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.508 0)1 2019.0813 Handwritten notes WA 2021 10 25
3501509 Date DesalptIon Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.509 031 2014.08.20 Letter regarding Crime Victims' reghts Act N/A 21121.10.25
Sam Data Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.510-031 2019.08.13 Handmittconote-s N/A 20211025
3501313 Date Description Attorney ProducedtoM*011Se
3501 513 001 :02 2021.1a25
3501324 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.514401 2010.10.12 r02
VIA
2021 10 25
1501.514 032 2019.07.08 1W cnss intake form 202: :0 25
3501.515 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
2010.10.26 McCoikey 302 2cZ: :02S
DescriPtion Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.516 001 Julio Suarez 302 N/A 2021.1025
3501517 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.517-001 2019.11.25 (mat than
WA
2021. /0.25
3501.517 032 2021.10.08 FM intake form 202: 10 25
3301318 Date Desoiption Attorney Produced to Del on
3501.513.001 2021.10.08 1W irroon form
WA
2021.10.25
3501.513.002 Attachment to Import form 2021.10.25
3501.518.003 Attachment to bnpon form 2021.11125
3501.513.004 Attachment to en on form 2071.10.25
3301.519
f .
Date DescriPtion Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.519 0)1 2020.07.17 Voicernal WA 2021 1025
3502.520 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.520 0)1 2020.07.06 Email th an WA 202: :0 25
3501.521 Date Desoiption Atto rney Produced to Defense
3501 521 0)1 2021 02 :8 letter WA 202: :0 25
3501.511 Date Desoiption Attorney Produced to Defense
350E 2021.10.08 1W import form
N/A
2021.10.25
35013224302 2021.1003 Letter 2(121.10.25
3.301.9n Dote Desception Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.523.001 I 2021.10.07 PIA 'croon form WA 2021.10.25
MA I
Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 524 0)1 2019.07.09 (mai th an WA 2021 10 25
Sr Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3931.525 031 2019.0709 (mai than WA 2021 10 25
3501.52I6 Date DatcSton Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.526 C01 2020.07.06 Email than WA 2021.10.25
3501523 Date Description Attorney Produced to Odense
2020,06.23 Letter WA 2021.10.25
3501522 Data Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.528 001 2020.10.12 (mai than WA 2021.1025
3501 529 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3591.529 0)1 2021.08.18 Owl Nan WA 2021 10 25
3501 530 Date Data Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.530 0)1 202007.13 (mai than WA 2021.10.25
Date Desalption Attorney I Produced b Defense
3501 531 001 2020 07 06 (mail th an WA 2021 1025
3508533 Date Desailithia Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.532 0)1 2020.07.27 ivoicema I WA 2021 1025
3501.533 Date Descriptlon Attorney ProducedtoDefense
3501 533 031 2020.09.24 (mai th an WA 202: :0 25
3501.534 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
1501334 C01 2020.07.07 Email than WA 2021.1025
a Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501535.001 2020.07 06 Voicornal WA 2021 10 25
3501530 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.536 001 2020.10.06 than WA 2021.1025
3501.537 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
IIRIFIF 2020.07.27 (mai than
WA
2021.10.25
3501.537001 2020.1008 Emai than 2021.10.25
3501.537.001 2020.1008 Emai than 2021.1025
3501538 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3501 538 0)1 2020.07.06 (mai th an WA 202: :0 25
3501.539 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
3531 539 031 2020.09.24 (mai than WA 2021.1025
3501340 Data Desolation Attorney Produced to Defense
3501.540001 202110109 Voiceenal
WA
2021.10.25
3501.540.001 2020.0609 Voiceenat 2021.1025
3501.540001 2020.0809 Volterra& 2021.10.25
3501541 Date Description Attorney Produced to Debase
3501.541 001 2020.07.21 (mid th an WA 202110.25
3503342 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
gillifli 2020,0801 OW Nan WA 2021 10 25
3501.543 Date Description Attorney Produced to Defense
1501.543 031 2021.10.08 Finirrpon form
WA
2021.1025
2021.10.03 Attachment to import lone 2021.10.25
3503544 Date Dela 101140 Atoms, Predated to Defense
3501.544 001 volumes WA 2021.1025
3501545 Date Deter ton Attorney Produced to Detente
3501 545 031 2021.10.05 FILII lemon form
WA
2021.1025
39)1 545 0)1 2021.1008 Attachment to Vnpon form 2021.1025
3501 545 0)3 2021.100€ Attichmen: to moon form 2021.1025
3501-546
.Ma Date DesatptIon Attorney Produced to Delano'
15015460)1 202007.29 Emal than WA 2023/025
╔═══════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Zlatá Rybářová [girls] Czech recruiter 
╚════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00512483 (Jmail)
 [tech] Karyna Shuliak personal address book
(inferred date: 2021-10-16)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYCO24329.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024329.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Notes
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case Data: Contacts (18301-18400 of 19830)
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/9/Messages/95525.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First YOUR TRAVEL CONSULTANT
Email
(Email)
ID 1444182
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxa
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/8/Messages/83489.emlx
Mac Mail
YouTube
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxa
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/8/Messages/85668.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
YouTube
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/8/Messages/83737.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
YouTube Space NY Connect
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/itaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/9/0/1/Messages/109573.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/9/Messages/91641.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
ysmichar - Amazon Marketplace
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/katyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxa
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/8/9/Messages/98579.emlx
Mac Mail
Ytad
ID 1374924
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Alsers/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/6/8/Messages/86657.emlx
Mac Mail
Yuko Inamasu
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number (VOIP)
Phone Number (Work Phone)
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
Phone Number (Home Phone)
ID
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skvae
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Ftecents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 9324727
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
hS e
Last
Phone Number (VOIP)
Phone Number (Work Phone)
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
Phone Number (Home Phone)
ID 9402
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Userilkaryna/Library/Containerskom.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Containerskom.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 9241400
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Containerskom.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First
Email (Email)
ID 3892502
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
Last
Phone Number (VOIP)
Phone Number (Work Phone)
Phone Number (Mobile Phone)
Phone Number (Home Phone)
ID 9402
Contact
Source NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Userilkaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-41386-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/1/1/Messages/113945.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1410266
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/0/1/Messages/101621.emlx
Mac Mail
Yuliya Kanunikova
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/9/Messages/94058.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1401381
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/0/1/1/Messages/110414.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email) Bella
ID 1335736
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/3/1/Messages/135299.emlx
Mac Mail
Email
la >(Email)
ID 1448165
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/3/9/Messages/93787.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
a> (Email)
ID 1407681
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/Mai UV6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/0/1/Messages/107252.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
a> (Email)
ID 1339002
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path Alsers/lcatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/4/8/Messages/84280.emix
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1403483
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
Path Alsers/lcatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/1/9/Messages/91403.emix
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
a> (Email) Lesley
ID 1370018
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
fUsers/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/0/1/Messages/107646.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1339383
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsersikaryna/Libraty/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType R n
First
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Alsers/Icaryna/Library/Mai IN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mboxa
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/1/9/Messages/91594.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
fUsers/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/0/1/Messages/104397.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Yumi lida
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxi4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/2/1/Messages/128941.emlx
Mac Mail
First YvesDelorme
Email
(Email)
ID 1379898
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users~ (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Yveta Masarova
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Containerskom.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Yvonne Berger
Email (Email)
Email (Email)
ID 9324727
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Containerskom.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Yvonne Berger
Email (Email)
Email (Email)
ID 9241400
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Containerskom.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Yvonne Berger
Email (Email)
Email (Email)
ID 3892502
Contact
Source
Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users~ (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Macnunk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-97
7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/1/6/1/Message.s/161267.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Yvonne Burch
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
AJsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac
7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/1/6/1/Messages/161136.emlx
Mac Mail
Yvonne Sampson
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
Junk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-97
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/2/9/Messages/92645.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Z Gallerie
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C I A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/2/9/Messages/92641.emlx
Mac Mail
Z Gallerie Customer Service
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MaiVV6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/4/1/Messages/147271.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/9/Messages/99457.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Zach
Contact
NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/1/9/Messages/91217.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zachary Herbst
Email
(Email)
ID 1369947
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zagat Announcements
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4lMacintosh HD
Path /UsersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zagat NYC
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-056 I -4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C 1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B 1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/5/0/1/Messagesl105516.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zagat Survey
Email
(Email)
ID 1444311
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zagat Survey Voting
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/0/1/Messages/109951.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Zara
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/lcaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/5/9/Messages/95550.emlx
Mac Mail
Zara Home
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/Icatyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/0/1/Messages/108888.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Zara Home
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Zaven
Yaralian
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Zaven
Yaralian
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Zaven
Yaralian
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/Icatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/9/Messages/92987.emlx
Mac Mail
zavvi.com
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/9/Messages/92985.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
zavvi.com
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Path Alsers/Icaryna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxa
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/5/9/Messages/95645.emlx
Mac Mail
7-anle Digitize Review
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/Icatyna/Library/MailN6/1890A3EB-0561-4D86-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxa
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/3/9/Messages/93668.emlx
Mac Mail
7-anle Inc.
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Contact
/Users/Icaryna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxict
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/0/1/Messages/104265.emlx
Mac Mail
Zazzle Inc.
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/karyna/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecentssecentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Zazzle Support
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Macaunk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-97
7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/3/6/1/Messages/163948.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zclgcv
Email
(Email)
ID 1020173
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/11sersM (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Mac-nunk.mbox/5184DD6D-098A-4810-97
7E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/8/5/1/Messages/158653.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zcoh Cqagtgbii
Email
(Email)
ID 1020035
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B0
22-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
ZDC
Gordon
2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2015-01-22 07:41:52 (UTC)
Organization Brice
ID 578
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B0
22-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
ZDC
Gordon
2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2015-01-22 07:41:52 (UTC)
Organization Brice
ID 578
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/1/0/1/Messages/101305.emlx
Mac Mail
First ZDC
Email Larry (Email)
ID 1370584
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date
Modification Date
Organization
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B0
22-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
ZDC
Gordon
2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
2015-01-22 07:41:52 (UTC)
Brice
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INB0X.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/5/0/1/Messages/105942.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Lesley Grof
Contact
Source Device NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zelin
Email (Email) Zelin
ID 1082149
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INB0X.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/2/1/1/Messages/112378.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Zenthea
ID 1437781
Contact
Source
Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/karyna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F I 3-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/2/1/Messages/128033.partial.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First ZERO HALLIBURTON
Email ZERO HALLIBURTON (Email)
ID 1379923
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
fUsers/Icaryna/Library/Mai IN6/1B90A3EB-056 I -4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/Junk.mbox/423
B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/8/4/1/Messages/148315.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First ZespA
Email Zespl (Email)
ID 1327256
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zhana
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
ID 1528
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zhana
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:45 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
ID 6375
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zhana
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:45 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
ID 6375
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zhana
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2017-11-09 02:38:45 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
ID 6375
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zhana
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
ID 1528
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zhana
Phone Number (Mobile
Creation Date 2012-02-01 16:53:55 (UTC)
Modification Date 2017-11-09 02:38:46 (UTC)
ID 1528
Contact
Source NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD Device
Path /Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F I 3C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/1/3/1/Messages/131354.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email
(Email)
ID 1373758
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mboxi4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/4/3/1/Messages/134072.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zimmerli of Switzerland
Email
(Email)
ID 1406270
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/MailData/Envelope Index
SourceType Mac Mail
First
Email (Email)
ID 1082149
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Zlata
Rybafova
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
Skype
Zlata
Rybafova
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Usersljee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Zlata
Last Rybafova
ID 90618
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zlatka
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2015-11-16 15:27:56 (UTC)
ID 715
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zlatka
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2015-11-16 15:27:56 (UTC)
ID 715
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Libraty/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B02
2-F709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zlatka
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(iPhone)
Email (Home)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:15 (UTC)
Modification Date 2015-11-16 15:27:56 (UTC)
ID 715
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/9/9/Messages/99771.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Zmicer Maslau
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/3/1/Messages/137048.emlx
Mac Mail
ZO Skin Health
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/karyna/Libraty/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13CIA/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F70BCF7860AF/Data/7/3/1/Messages/137050.emlx
Mac Mail
ZO Skin Health
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Zoe
Tennant
2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Zoe
Tennant
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 307
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Zoe
Tennant
2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 307
Source
Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email
(Email)
ID
Contact
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Usergicaryna/Library/MailN6/1B90A3EB-0561-4DB6-A847-27A656F13C1A/INBOX.mbox/4
23B1948-4823-4372-8F13-F7OBCF7860AF/Data/7/8/Messages/87403.partial.emlx
Mac Mail
Zoe
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-8022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Zoe
Tennant
2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC)
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/01634A06-3F78-47EC-B022-F
709788093C8/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zoe
Last Tennant
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
Modification 2017-11-09 02:38:48 (UTC) Date
ID 960
Contact
Source Device NYCO24353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Zoe
Last Tennant
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-04 18:00:10 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-11-06 18:07:17 (UTC)
ID 307
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First ZORRO
Last OFFICE
ID 90951
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First ZORRO
Last OFFICE
ID 90951
Contact
Source
Device
Path
NYCO24329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users, (Deleted)/Library/MaiIN2/Mac-_'Sent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/4/4/Messages/44706.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zorro
Email
(Email)
ID 1059000
Contact
Source Device NYC024353.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/jee/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First ZORRO
Last OFFICE
ID 90951
Contact
Source Device NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
Path fUsers/karyna/Library/Containers/com.apple.corerecents.recentsd/Data/Library/Recents/Recents
SourceType Recents
First Zorro
Email (Email)
ID 1568949
Source
Device
Path
Contact
NYC024329.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users, (Deleted)/Library/MailN2/Maceent Messages.mbox/5184DD6D-098A
-4810-977E-8613A4F7EC65/Data/4/5/Messages/54589.emlx
SourceType Mac Mail
First Zorro
Email
(Email)
ID 1059989
> Zorro
Case Data: Contacts (18201-18300 of 19830) Case Data: Contacts (18401-18500 of 19830)
EFTA00040087 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2021-10-20)
Exhibit A

e) at&t
MATTER ID# 448193
National Court Order Compliance
11760 US HIGHWAY 1, SUITE 600
NORTH PALM BEACH, FL 33408-
3029
VERIFICATION OF AUTHENTICITY OF AT&T RECORDS
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared
says:
who being duly sworn, deposes and
My name is I am over the age of 18 and qualified to make this affidavit I am employed by AT&T
as a Legal Comp lance na yst and serve as the Custodian of Records for AT&T. I have been employed by AT&T
since 06/23/2006. Attached to this Affidavit are copies of AT&T subscriber and call detail records for:
Number(s):
The attached copies of billing records were originally provided without certification by an analyst at the AT&T
GLDC. The records have been purged and are unable to be created in the same format as originally provided.
Christian R. Everdell mailed them to the National Compliance Center on 10/14/2021. The attached copies of usage
records appear to be in the same format as records that were maintained and produced by AT&T. These
documents are in the same format and contain call data consistent with AT&T records and do not appear to have
been modified or altered in any way. I routinely rely on these types of documents in the course of my duties as
Custodian of Records and Legal Compliance Analyst for AT&T.
Based on the regular practices of AT&T in 2008, the records were:

a. Made at or near the time of each act, event, condition, opinion, or diagnosis set forth in the records.

b. Made by or from information transmitted by AT&T systems.
c. Would have been kept in the course of regularly conducted business activity.
It was the regular practice of the business activity to make these records.
10/20/2021
The foregoing affidavit was sworn to and subscribed before me by ho is personally known to me.
Notary Public, State of Florida
Printed Name
Serial Number (if any)
National Court Order Compliance
1
t 1MI,..1 t Notary Putax • Sta. of Fonds
‘<aj\eV I  CWimiSSI" ! I I24 . _. Mr COWL Exams Au; .
Bonded thrash National Notary Ass".
EFTA00040119 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2021-11-08)
HADDON
M OR C A N
FOREMAN
November 8, 2021
VIA EMAIL
United States Attorney's Office
Southern District of New York
I St. Andrew's Plaza
New York, NY 10007
Haddon, Morgan and Foreman, P.0
Jeffrey S. Pagliuca
150 Eost lath Avenue
Denver, Co
PH
FX
www hmflaw corn
Re: United States v. Ghisiaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
Defendant's Good Faith, Non-Frivolous Objections to Proffered Co-Conspirator
Hearsay Statements
Dear Counsel,
Pursuant to the Court's November 1, 2021 Order we write to note our good faith
objections to certain categories of alleged co-conspirator hearsay statements, and representative
examples:
Regarding the first, third, and fourth' designated categories, there are two issues for
conferral. First, we assume that these proffered statements are limited to those individuals
specifically identified by the government as "minor victims" in the indictment or correspondence
to defense counsel dated October 11, 2021. There were many alleged minor victims in the
Southern Florida state and federal investigations. To the extent that the government intends to
include statements made to other alleged "minor victims" not specifically identified, Ms.
"Statements made by Epstein to friends and Family of Minor Victims," "Statements
made by CC-2 to friends and Family of Minor Victims," and "Statements made by Jeffrey
Epstein to the Minor Victims or in their presence."
November 8, 2021
Page 2
Maxwell objects. In addition, these categories do not contain any temporal limitations and we
object to any statements allegedly made outside the dates of the alleged conspiracy.
Category 2, "Statements made by Jeffrey Epstein to his employees" appears to, primarily,
relate to statements that post-date any alleged conspiracy. The first exemplar is a statement
allegedly from Epstein to CC-1 claiming that Ms. Maxwell "used to find girls for him." This
statement, or statements like it, cannot have been made either in the course of or in furtherance
of any conspiracy at issue here and are no more than "idle chatter." United States v. Lieberman,
637 F.2d 95, 102 (2d Cir.1980) (challenged testimony "smack[ed] of nothing more than casual
conversation about past events. It is difficult to envision how it would have furthered the
conspiracy"). Similarly, the second example concerns direction from Epstein and CC-2 to CC-1
to "help someone who was coming to take the computers...." Again, this statement does not
appear to be during or in furtherance of any conspiracy alleged in the indictment. See Lutwak v.
United States, 344 U.S. 604 (1953); Kruleivitch v. United States, 336 U.S. 440 (1949). We
assume the third example relates to the time period alleged in the indictment. To the extent it
does not we object.
Best Regards,
Jeffrey S. Pagliuca
EFTA00040107 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2021-11-11 20:00:00)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
United States of America,
—v—
Ghislaine Maxwell,
Defendant.
USDC SONY
DOCUMENT
ELECTRONICALLY FILED
DOC 0:
DATE FILED: 11/11/21
20-CR-330 (MN)
OPINION & ORDER
ALISON J. NATHAN, District Judge:
Before the Court is the Defense's motion to exclude the Government's expert witness,

Dr. Lisa Rocchio, pursuant to Federal Rule of Evidence 702 and the standard in Daubert v.
Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993). Dkt. No. 386. The Government filed
a response brief, Dkt. No. 397, and Defendant filed a reply, Dkt. No. 398. The Court conducted
a Daubert hearing on November 10, 2021, at which both parties examined Dr. Rocchio. Dkt.

No. 431. The Court stated its oral opinion at that hearing that it would deny and grant in part
Defendant's motion, to be followed by this opinion.

I. Legal standard
Federal Rule of Evidence 702 governs the admissibility of expert testimony. That rule
states:
A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or
education may testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise if:

(a) the expert's scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the trier
of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue;
I

(b) the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data;
(c) the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods; and
(d) the expert has reliably applied the principles and methods to the facts of the case.
The Court exercises a "gatekeeper function" in assessing the admissibility of expert
testimony. Restivo v. Hessernann, 846 F.3d 547, 575 (2d Cir. 2017). To determine whether an
expert's method is reliable, the Court considers the non-exhaustive list provided by the Supreme
Court in Daubers, including whether the expert's method has been tested, whether it has been
subjected to peer review, the rate of error, standards controlling the method's operation, and
whether the method is accepted by the expert community. United States v. Kidd, 385 F. Supp. 3d
259, 263 (S.D.N.Y. 2019) (citing Daubers, 509 U.S. at 593-94).
But Rule 702 ultimately sets a "liberal" and "permissive" standard of admissibility.
Nimely v. City of New York, 414 F.3d 381, 395-96 (2d Cir. 2005). In particular, not every expert
admissible under Daubers need rely on a method that conforms with "the exactness of hard
science methodologies." E.E.O.C. v. Bloomberg L.P., No. 07-CV-8383 (LAP), 2010 WL
3466370, at *13-14 (S.D.N.Y. Aug. 31, 2010) (quoting United States v. Simmons, 470 F.3d
1115, 1123 (5th Cir. 2006)).
IL Discussion
As a preliminary matter, the Defense argues that the additional materials filed by the
Government in support of Dr. Rocchio's expertise should be excluded as failing to comply with
the Court's order that the Government make all expert witness disclosures by April 23, 2021.
Dkt. No. 250. But that Order, made pursuant to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 16(a)(1)(G),
required only that the Government provide an adequate summary of the intended topics and
opinions of Dr. Rocchio's testimony, which the Government did here in a timely manner. See
2
Kidd, 385 F. Supp. 3d at 262. The Defense cites only one case, United States v. Lewis, which
involved the distinct situation where a district court excluded expert testimony because the notice
itself was untimely. 818 F. App'x 74, 79 (2d Cir. 2020). The Court concludes that the
Government's supplemental materials in further response to the Defense's motion are timely and
may be considered in resolving the Daubert motion.
Turning to the proffered expert opinions, as articulated in the Government's disclosure
and at the Daubert hearing, Dr. Rocchio would offer five expert opinions. First, that perpetrators
of sexual abuse of minors frequently use manipulation or coercion short of physical force as part
of a strategic pattern, often referred to as grooming, to make the minor vulnerable to abuse.
Second, that manipulation and grooming can prevent the minor from understanding their
experience as abuse and so prevent disclosure. Third, that abuse can cause long-term traumatic
and psychological consequences. Fourth, that the presence of another individual can facilitate
sexual abuse of minors. And fifth, that nondisclosure, incremental disclosure, and secrecy are
common among victims of sexual abuse and that memory can be affected by a variety of factors,
including the effects of trauma.
The Defense does not contest that Dr. Rocchio has the qualifications to express opinions
on these subjects. Dr. Rocchio has a PhD in clinical psychology and is a clinical instructor at the
Alpert Medical School of Brown University. She has more than two decades of experience
treating hundreds of victims of trauma, many of which were minor victims of sexual abuse. She
has published peer-reviewed articles on trauma and sexual abuse and has given numerous talks in
addition to her teaching. Given these papers, and her credible and extensive hearing testimony,
the Court therefore finds Dr. Rocchio qualified as an expert.
3
The Defense instead argues that Dr. Rocchio's method is unreliable, that it is not relevant
to the jury's determination, and that its prejudicial effect would substantially outweigh its
probative value. These arguments rely heavily on a district court opinion from outside this
circuit, United States v. Raymond, 700 F. Supp. 2d 142 (D. Me. 2010). After careful
consideration of the Defense's arguments and the thorough reasoning in Raymond, the Court
concludes that Dr. Rocchio's anticipated testimony is admissible with one exception. The Court
will address first why Dr. Rocchio's testimony is admissible and then address the one opinion
that it will exclude.
First, Dr. Rocchio's method is reliable and well-accepted in her profession. It is for this
reason that several courts in this circuit have admitted the testimony of similar experts, such as
testimony on so-called trauma bonding to explain why prostitutes may not flee from their pimps
even when not physically restrained. In United States v. Kidd, the court admitted the testimony,
finding it to be "quite common[ ]" and accepted in the academic literature. 385 F. Supp. 3d at
263. Identical testimony was admitted by Judge Furman in United States v. Dupigny, No. 18-
Cr.-528 (JMF) (S.D.N.Y. 2019), Dkt. No. 198 at 27, by Judge Engelmayer in United States v.
Randall, 19 Cr. 131 (PAE) (S.D.N.Y. 2020), Dkt. No. 335 at 24-30, and by Judge Cote in United
States v. Torres, No. 20-CR-608 (DLC), 2021 WL 1947503, at *7 (S.D.N.Y. May 13, 2021).
Their decisions are consistent with the vast majority of courts to consider the admission
of such experts. A number of courts have admitted experts on the particular topic of grooming at
issue here, a sample of which include the Seventh Circuit in United States v. Romero, 189 F.3d
576, 585 (7th Cir. 1999), the Fifth Circuit in United States v. Hitt, 473 F.3d 146, 158 (5th Cir.
2006), the Ninth Circuit in United States v. Halamek, 5 F.4th 1081, 1087-89 (9th Cir. 2021), the
Tenth Circuit in United States v. Batton, 602 F.3d 1191, 1201-02 (10th Cir. 2010), the Eighth
4
Circuit in United States v. Johnson, 860 F.3d 1133, 1141 (8th Cir. 2017), and the District of
Massachusetts in Doe ex rel. Pike v. Pike, 405 F. Supp. 3d 243, 249 (D. Mass. 2019).
Here, Dr. Rocchio has extensive experience treating minors who have been sexually
abused, and those decades of relevant experience, combined with her formal training, are an
adequate basis for her to testify on methods that perpetrators of sexual abuse often use to build
trust with their victims, whether that be grooming or other forms of manipulation and coercion.
The Government has also provided several articles on the subject of grooming that convince the
Court that it is a well-accepted theory in Dr. Rocchio's field. Though the Second Circuit has not
ruled on the admissibility of a grooming expert, it has previously recognized the academic
literature on grooming to facilitate sexual abuse of minors. See United States v. Brand, 467 F.3d
179, 203 (2d Cir. 2006). The Defense cites to several contrary articles that suggest experts
disagree on the kinds of behaviors that define grooming. But if experts disagree on the proper
interpretation of evidence, "it is not the Court's role to resolve the dispute through exclusion of
one of the expert's opinions." In re Digital Musk Antitrust Litig., 321 F.R.D. 64, 80 (S.D.N.Y.
2017).
Moreover, Dr. Rocchio addressed these contrary articles during the Daubert hearing,
identifying points of agreement and disagreement. Based on her testimony, the parties'
submission and accompanying exhibits, the Court concludes that the core concept of grooming is
well-accepted in the relevant literature, even if experts continue to debate the details.
The Defense's primary argument is that Dr. Rocchio's method is unreliable because it is
based on her personal experience with the clients she has treated, that Dr. Rocchio did not verify
whether those clients were truthful, and that Dr. Rocchio has not and cannot identify an error
rate. The Court finds that these objections are misplaced in the field of clinical psychology,
5
particularly when studying the causes and effects of sexual abuse of minors. The Court agrees
with Judge Engelmayer's response to this argument:
The absence of large quantity statistical studies is explained by a practical reason
that should be obvious to all. Studying the circumstances and psychological
drivers of trafficked women is not like studying diseases or potential cures in
laboratory animals. In those studies, laboratory conditions literally can be
achieved.. . .
That strictly quantitative mode of inquiry is not realistic or even ethical in the
context of studying sex trafficking. The causes and contributors to sex trafficking
by their nature must be studied retrospectively. They cannot ethically be studied
otherwise. Subjects cannot be tested to see under what circumstances they would
and would not, on a going forward basis, fall prey to the predations of sex
traffickers. Given the necessarily retrospective nature of such a study, given the
small size of the populations under review, and given the inherently
individualized circumstances presented by different perpetrators, victims, and
contexts in this tumultuous and emotionally fraught area of criminal conduct, the
vocabulary of error rates and statistical significance is an unusually poor fit.
Tr. at 29-30, United States v. Randall, 19-Cr.-131 (PAE) (S.D.N.Y. 2020), Dkt. No. 335.
For the reasons Judge Engelmayer gave—which Dr. Rocchio echoed in her testimony —
the Court finds that the error-rate factor listed by Daubert is not determinative as to the reliability
of Dr. Rocchio's method.
For similar reasons, the Court rejects the Defense's argument that Dr. Rocchio's method
is unreliable because she relied on the reports of her clients. Given the realities of studying
sensitive criminal acts like sexual abuse, a researcher can only rarely verify reports with absolute
certainty. Yet that does not mean a clinical or forensic psychologist accepts all statements at
face value. Rather, as the Government notes, part of Dr. Rocchio's profession is to examine and
diagnose her patients consistent with her significant training and specialized knowledge.
Further, on the forensic side of her practice, Dr. Rocchio regularly investigates and verifies
sexual abuse. She reports "remarkable consistency" between the reports of her clinical patients
6
and her forensic findings. Nov. 10 Tr. at 40. That said, the Defense is of course free to cross-
examine Dr. Rocchio about how she evaluates her patients.
The Defense also suggests that Dr. Rocchio's experience is based on an unrepresentative
sample of alleged victims because her patients self-selected seeking treatment with her. Yet the
Defense does not explain why Dr. Rocchio's experience with a large number of patients would
not be applicable to the alleged victims in this case. To the extent the Defense wishes to argue
that Dr. Rocchio's experience is under-representative, that is a topic for cross-examination.
Further, the Defense argues that Dr. Rocchio's experience treating victims of sexual
abuse does not make her an expert on grooming, which would require experience with
perpetrators themselves. This argument overlooks the fact that, as she testified, Dr. Rocchio also
relied on literature that includes studies of sexual abusers' reported behaviors. But more
importantly, the Court concludes, as other courts like the Ninth Circuit have, that extensive
experience with victims can be used to study perpetrators' process of victimization. See
Halamek, 5 F.4th at 1088. That is especially so here where the crux of Dr. Rocchio's expected
testimony is the effect that grooming behaviors have on the minor, not the perpetrator's mental
state when performing the behaviors.
Second, the Court finds that Dr. Rocchio's opinions are relevant to the Government's
case against Ms. Maxwell. Two points of law bear mention here. For one, as the Second Circuit
has explained, expert testimony cannot "constitute evaluations of witness credibility" —that is,
expert testimony is inadmissible if it "comment[s] directly, under the guise of expert opinion, on
the credibility of trial testimony from" specific fact witnesses. Nimely, 414 F.3d at 398.
Additionally, if the expert's "opinion is one that the jury could reach with their own `common
knowledge and common sense,' no expert testimony is warranted." Edmondson v. RCI Hosp.
7
Holdings, Inc., No. 16-CV-2242 (VEC), 2020 WL 1503452, at *6 (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 30, 2020)
(quoting 4 Weinstein's Federal Evidence § 702.03 (2019)); see also United States v. Mulder, 273
F.3d 91, 101 (2d Cir. 2001) (explaining that "the district court should not admit testimony that is
'directed solely to lay matters which a jury is capable of understanding and deciding without the
expert's help' (quoting United States v. Castillo, 924 F.2d 1227, 1232 (2d Cir. 1991))). Dr.
Rocchio's first and second opinions may assist the jury in understanding how a minor may be
enticed, induced, or coerced into illegal sexual activity without physical force. These opinions
may also assist a jury in assessing evidence that some alleged victims repeatedly interacted with
Jeffrey Epstein, seemingly voluntarily, even after they suffered abuse. Dr. Rocchio's fourth
opinion is similarly relevant to the charges that require proving intentional enticement or
inducement.
Dr. Rocchio's third and fifth opinions pertain to issues that will arise in the case based on
anticipated cross-examination by the Defense. Specifically, the third opinion becomes relevant if
the Defense impeaches an alleged victim based on their substance abuse. And the fifth opinion
may become relevant if the Defense impeaches an alleged victim based on an ostensible delay in
fully disclosing sexual abuse. At the Daubert hearing, the Defense stated that they intended to
pursue both lines of impeachment at trial. Nov. 10 Tr. at 156-57. The Court therefore finds
these elements of Dr. Rocchio's testimony relevant to matters the Defense intends to put in issue
during anticipated cross-examination. The Court also concludes that these opinions satisfy the
other relevant Daubert requirements. Namely, they would assist the jury in understanding
concepts that require expert knowledge without directing the jury to reach any conclusion as to a
witness's credibility. Additionally, both Dr. Rocchio's opinion about sexual abuse's connection
to substance abuse and her opinion about delayed disclosure are "are outside the ken of the
8
average person," and so appropriate for expert testimony. United States v. Felder, 993 F.3d 57,
72 (2d Cir. 2021). Nor would admission of these opinions cause unfair Rule 403 prejudice since
they are relevant rebuttal to impeachment points that the Defense will put in issue.
The Defense argues that Dr. Rocchio's testimony is not relevant because the Government
represents that she will testify only to general principles and not offer "testimony regarding any
specific victim." Dkt. No. 386 at 3. The Defense has the law backwards on this point. As
explained above regarding the Second Circuit's Nimely decision, an expert may not testify as to a
specific witness's credibility. 414 F.3d at 398. And as other courts have explained in admitting
similar testimony, Dr. Rocchio's testimony is appropriate because she does not testify as to any
specific witness's credibility. See, e.g., Torres, No. 20-CR-608 (DLC), 2021 WL 1947503, at
*7; Johnson, 860 F.3d at 1140 (8th Cir. 2017) (explaining that an expert may testify "regarding
the general characteristics that sexually abused children exhibit" but may not usurp the jury's
role of assessing the credibility of any specific victim); United States v. Telles, 6 F.4th 1086,
1097-98 (9th Cir. 2021) (same).
This analysis is referred to in the case relied upon by the Defense, United States v.
Raymond, and in portions of the Defense's briefing, as a question of "fit." 700 F. Supp. 2d at

149. But Daubert's "fit" requirement is really just a specialized relevance inquiry that asks
"whether expert testimony proffered in the case is sufficiently tied to the facts of the case that it
will aid the jury in resolving a factual dispute." Alto v. Sun Pharm. Indus., Inc., No. 1:19-CV-
09758 (GHW), 2021 WL 4803582, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 13, 2021) (quoting Daubert, 509 U.S. at
591). Fit is satisfied if the expert's opinion would assist the jury's decision on a relevant
question of fact without "usurp[ing] either the role of the trial judge in instructing the jury as to
the applicable law or the role of the jury in applying that law to the facts before it." Id. (quoting
9
United States v. Duncan, 42 F.3d 97, 101 (2d Cir. 1994)). For the reasons already provided, the
Court finds that fit is satisfied here.
Third, the probative value of Dr. Rocchio's testimony is not substantially outweighed by
403 prejudice to Ms. Maxwell. The Court finds that Dr. Rocchio's testimony would not unduly
"'simplify' an otherwise complex case" or mislead jurors by a supposedly infallible expert. Dkt.
No. 386 at II. Dr. Rocchio's opinions speak only to concepts and will not (and indeed may not)
suggest that the jury find any alleged victim witness to be credible or to find Ms. Maxwell guilty.
The more general nature of Dr. Rocchio's opinions, which the Court heard in detail at the
Daubert hearing, therefore mitigates its prejudicial effect. Telles, 6 F.4th at 1097. It is the jury's
role to determine whether and how Dr. Rocchio's opinions apply to the facts of this case and the
credibility of the witnesses.
Last, as previously mentioned, the Court will grant in part the Defense's Daubert motion.
The Defense argues that Dr. Rocchio's opinion that grooming can be done to facilitate sexual
abuse by a third party or that the presence of a third party can otherwise facilitate grooming is
unreliable. The Defense calls this "grooming -by-proxy." E.g., Dkt. No. 386 at 9. Terminology
aside, the Court agrees with this narrower objection to Dr. Rocchio's testimony. As discussed at
the hearing, this phenomenon is not identified in the relevant literature regarding child sexual
abuse and has not been subjected to peer review. Instead, the Court understands this opinion to
be an extrapolation of the broader principle of how grooming functions through the development
of trust. That extrapolation may be logical and follow common sense, but it is for the jury to
make on the facts of this case. The Court therefore excludes Dr. Rocchio's opinion that the
presence of a third party can facilitate grooming. Dr. Rocchio's core opinions about grooming,
however, remain admissible under the Rule 702 and Daubert standard and remain relevant
10
pursuant to Rule 401 and not unduly prejudicial. As discussed, the jury may extrapolate from the
opinions that the presence of a third party creates the atmosphere of trust that can facilitate
grooming. Moreover, as the Government explains, Dr. Rocchio's testimony is still relevant
because the Government alleges both that Ms. Maxwell "in fact participated in sexual abuse of
minors" and that she "conspired with a predator who groomed and sexually abused minors."
Dkt. No. 397 at 27.
The Court therefore denies the Defense's motion to exclude Dr. Rocchio's testimony
except as to the opinion that the presence of a third party can facilitate grooming.
This resolves docket number 386.
SO ORDERED.
Dated: November 11, 2021
New York, New York
11
ALISON J. NATHAN
United States District Judge
EFTA00014648 (Jmail)
 [girls] former employee "understood that all the girls were school girls"
(inferred date: 2021-11-19)
November 19, 2021 WebEx Meeting

• Asked whether he wants counsel, told could have an attorney appointed if he could
not afford one; said he did not feel he needed or wanted a lawyerJE received between 2 and 4 massages every day when he was in Palm BeachJE's massage appointments were set up through his assistants

• received phone call from assistants that people were coming at certain time to give JE
massages; when person rang doorbell, let her in; most of time, they waited in kitchen;
waited until or showed up and took person up to massage room

• did not recall answering phone calls where people said they wanted to give a massage
• People who came to give JE massages did not wear uniforms; they wore casual clothes
(jeans, t-shirts, sneakers, sweatpants)

• People giving massages were female; they were not professional, trained masseuses; they
did not show up with equipment to give massages

• saw some females waiting outside house, In thought they were waiting for someone to
pick them up after massage

• sometimes saw females walking to ring doorbell; most of the time heard doorbell and let
females in
• Sometimes more than one female came at a time; remembers one time when two girls
came, one girl waited in the kitchen and one went upstairs; doesn't remember what the
girls looked like; the two girls seemed like friends; came together and left together after
certain period of time; they were young girls (high school age)

• Impression was they were young; under 20 years old
• understood that all the girls coming to give massages were "school girls"

• impression was that all the girls coming for appointments were high school girls
• U sometimes heard the girls talk about school; does not know what grade they were in

• overheard the girls talk about soccer games, time to go to classes; doesn't remember
which classes
• started seeing school girls at the PB house within a few days of when started working
there
EFTA00040143 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2021-11-19 19:02:05)
Event: Accepted: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
Start Date: 2021-11-22 23:00:00 +0000
End Date: 2021-11-23 00:00:00 +0000
Location: Zoom Meeting - Meeting ID Below
Class: X-PERSONAL
Comment:
Date Created: 2021-11-19 19:02:05 +0000
Date Modified: 2021-11-19 19:02:05 +0000
Priority: 5
DTSTAMP: 2021-11-19 17:32:24 +0000
Attendee: Stoddart, Allison < I
EFTA00009654 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2021-11-24)
case 62033DASJI4 Illocorreat59/51 PaSIMI/flint Rae1.2)642
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
Defendant.
IMDCSIMI
DOCUMDM
ELLCTADMICALIAFMLU
DOC':
am nun:  11/24/21
(PROPOSED].
PROTECTIVE ORDER
20 Cr. 330 (A.711)
ALISON J. NATHAN, United States District Judge:
WHEREAS the Court has ordered production of materials
from the Epstein Victims' Compensation Fund to the Court
pursuant to Fed. R. Crim. P. 17(c) (the "Rule 17 Materials")
(see Dkt. No. 496);
WHEREAS those materials are likely to contain
information that would (:) affect the privacy and
confidentiality of individuals, (Li) would risk prejudicial
pretrial publicity if publicly disseminated, and (iii) are not
authorized to be disclosed to the public or disclosed beyond
that which is necessary for the trial in this action;
WHEREAS the Court has directed the parties to
negotiate and submit a proposed protective order;
IT HEREBY IS ORDERED:

1. Any and all Rule 17 Materials disclosed to the
Government, the defendant ("Defendant"), and/or to the
defendant's criminal defense attorneys ("Defense Counsel,' and
1
(
(
(
Mutcal I waniOO338a420N 1 RIMS111224111 Re4p23:672
collectively with the Government, "the Parties") shall be
treated as "Confidential Infsrmation" within the meaning of the
Protective Order (Dkt. No. 36 4 7) and shall be subject  to the
provisions thereof.

2. At the discretion of the Court, the Court nay
des:gnate certain materials as "Highly Confidential" within the
meaning :I the Protective Order (Dkt. No. 36 4 1:1 and subject
to the provisions thereof.
SO ORDERED:
Dated: New York, New York
November 24_, 202:
HONORABLE ALISOH J. NAI.HAN
United States District Judge
(
(
(
EFTA00005967 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2021-11-26 09:15:00)
╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

FecK;.< Of fice_
Addres:.:
NEW YORK
NV 10007
location: FIDKK
Device I0: -BICO2
.dEx Express Package(s1 - Drooped Oft
0.45 lb (S)
Pieces: 1
lo See Feat, JtIVILt uman
ar fidex.coi far retails. All nercharicisf se =s finl
Visit us at: tedex.beei
Or call 1.800.6nEedEx
1.800.463.3335
Nov 24, 'Mil 4:34:15 PM
*44#4***4$ WE tislut ssassasst4
lell us now we're doing
le,:eive a discount on youl next order!
fecKwtecue/welisten
Redimplion Code:
44$ Thank you ***

╭──────── Page 2, Image 1 ────────╮
│ af                              │
│                                 │
│ Fed Office.                     │
│                                 │
│ seeeeeeees HE LISTEN HeReEEE ES │
│ ii e're doing                   │
│                                 │
│ fedex, com/welisten             │
│                                 │
│ +++ Thank you +44               │
╰─────────────────────────────────╯

te 1112621, 1:24 PM Detailed Tracking
FedEx.
TRACK ANOTHER SHIPMENT
796271883447
ADD NICKNAME
Delivered
Friday, 11/26/2021 at 9:15 am
FROM
New York NY US
MANAGE DELIVERY
Travel History
TIME ZONE
Local Scan Time
Friday, November 26,
2021
DELIVERED
Signed for by: A.ALEX
GET STATUS UPDATES
OBTAIN PROOF OF DELIVERY
TO
Novato, CA US
9:15 AM Novato, CA Delivered
8:31 AM SAN RAFAEL, CA On FedEx vehicle for delivery
828 AM SAN RAFAEL, CA At local FedEx facility
625AM QNCANO, CA Departed FedEx hub
4:59 AM OAKLAND, CA Arrived at FedEx hub
3:52 AM INDIANAPOLIS, IN Departed FedEx hub
Thursday, November 25,
2021
1:00 AM INDIANAPOLIS IN Arrived at FedEx hub
Wednesday, November 24,
2021
Cr 0
O
httpslAwewledex.conWedextrackThrknbankqua X 1,2
11,2f$21, 1:24 PM
1122PM
9:28 PM
8:49 PM
6:39 PM
434PM
2:20PM
Shipment Facts
TRACKING NUMBER
DIMENSIONS
12x9x3 in.
TOTAL SHIPMENT WEIGHT
1 ibs / 0.45 kgs
PACKAGING
Your Packaging
STANDARD TRANSIT
11/26/21 before 11:30 am 0
Detailed Tracking
NEWARK NJ Departed FedEx hub
NEWARK NJ Arrived at FedEx hub
NEW YORK NY Left FedEx origin facility
NEW YORK NY Picked Up
NEW YORK NY Picked up
Tendered at FedEx Office
Shipment Informa0on sent to FedEx
Collapse History
SERVICE
FedEx Priority Overnight
DELIVERED TO
Shipping/Receiving
TERMS
Shipper
SPECIAL HANDLING SECTION
Deliver Weekday
ACTUAL DELIVERY
11/26/21 at 9:15 am
WEIGHT
1 lbs / 0.45 kgs
TOTAL PIECES
1
RMA
642371
SHIP DATE
11/24/210
https://www.fedexconVfedextracW?ftknbr-MItrkgual FX 22
EFTA00040138 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2021-11-29)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
United States of America,
—v—
Ghislaine Maxwell,
Defendant.
20-CR-330 (AJN)
Jurors for Peremptory
11/29/21
Jurors for the exercise of peremptory strikes (11/29 at 8:30 a.m., 58 jurors total)
Courtroom 506
Courtroom 110
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 David Ross [arts] head of School of Visual Arts MFA program, director of Whitney Museum 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00157634 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ witness prep of Juan Alessi (Epstein's Palm Beach house manager)
(date: 2021-12-01)
December 1, 2021 Alessi prep
AUSA
SA
Showed JA GX-52 and asked if he recognized it.

• JA immediately said he believes GX-52 is one of the directories he remembers from JE's
PB home. GX-52 is a bit smaller than he remembered the directories being, but the
names in GX-52 are familiar. The type face is all the same, but JA remembers the letters
being a bit larger and the book being a bit thicker. The format looks the same to JA. JA
also recognizes that this book, like the one he remembers, has different names in the
same page, some with a lot of numbers and some only one or two numbers. The book JA
remembers also had the same binding and same cover as GX-52.

• JA believes that this must be a newer version of the book he remembers that post-dates
his employment because his name and his wife's name is no longer in it.

• JA specifically remembered seeing many entries in GX-52 the book he saw when he
worked for JE, such as the following: Alan Paul, Duchess and Duke of York, Mandy and
Ralph Ellison, Dimitri Goulandris, Bobby Kennedy, Ethel Kennedy, Dr. Kissinger, Philip
Levine, Peter Mandelson, all of the Maxwell entries, Robert Murdoch, John Newman,
Joel Paschow, Thomas Pritzker, Jane Rosenthal, Rothchild, Elizabeth Saltzman, Peter
Sorros, Jeffrey Steiner,, Mike Wallace, Robert Walter, Bob Weinstein, Prince
Michel of Yugoslavia, Mark Zeff, Mr. & Mrs. Miele, Alberto Pinto, Paul Hoffman, Eva
Anderson, Bill Archer, Anthony Barrett, Jonathan Barrett, , Leon Black,
David Borden, Alan Dershowitz, Dr. Elderman, Mark
Epstein, Paula Epstein, Andrew Farkas, Jonathan Farkas, Kenneth Gilman,
Eric Gany, Bob Gold, Bob Goodman, Darren Indyke, Henry Jarecki Pamela Johananoff,
Elizabeth Johnson, Jack Kessler, Henry Kravis, Adam Perry Lang, Mark Lundberg,
Marvin Minsky, Robert Meister, Mark Middelton, David Mitchell,
Senator George Mitchell, Myhrvold Nathan, NA Property Inc., New Alban Country Club,
Bob Oatman, Gary Newman, Ovitz Michael, Joe Pagano, Pilots, Thomas Quinn, Lewis
Reniere, Ed Razek, David Rochafeller, David Rodgers, Henry Rosovsky, David Ross,
Jeffrey Schantz, Douglas Schoettle, Warren Spector, Jes Staley,
Stroll Lawrence, Craig Tafoya, Donald Trump, Steve Tuckerman, Ugland Peg,
Larry Visoski, Vera Wang, Wexners, White House, Mort Zuckerman, Richard Barnett,
Fontanella, Ghislaine Maxwell, Esther Sternberg, Dawn DeVito, Gerald Goldsmith,
Allen Stopeck, Mike Pezulo, John Kelly, Gary Kerney, Ken Bruce, Bill Richardson,
Santa Fe Institute, airlines, all the hotels.

• JA specifically remembers that the book he saw has the same masseuse lists as GX-52,
including the list of masseuses in CA, the list of masseuses for the island, list of
masseuses for UK, list of masseuses for FL, list of masseuses for NM.

• JA remembers there being more numbers for JE in the book he saw than he sees in GX-
52.
3504-047
Page 1 of 4

• JA noted that there were entries in GX-52 he did not remember from when he worked for
JE (did not see in the book he had when he worked for JE because • came
weeks before he left), doesn't recall seeing big lettering for headings like "BRAZIL" or
"FINANCE". Recalls many more entries for Donald Trump.

• JA doesn't know the process for updating the book, but he received it from the office in
New York, and the books were replaced every year.

• Re massage in FL page, there are several entries JA remembers from the book he saw,
but some that appear to be new because there are more numbers there now than he
remembers. JA recalls all of the entries on the left column, but doesn't remember the
names on the right, except

• There were no markings and no post-its in the version of the book that he remembers.
Prepared for trial testimony. JA new/corrected/clarified statements below:

• Cabana at JE's PB house was there when JA first started working for JE. Renovations
were all done by 1992. JE had to move out of the house in 1992 for the renovations.
Then moved back into the house 4-6 months later. JE was in a rental house during that
time.

• Between about 1993 and 1995, JA thinks there were designers changing the rooms in the
PB house, but those alterations didn't require moving out or staying elsewhere.

• In or about 2001, JE built huge wall between pool and barracks, finished just before
2002.
• When JA visited the NM ranch, even though the main house was under construction, it
was still habitable, and JE could still stay there while the construction finished.

• JA remembers getting the booklet/Handbook closer to the end of his time working at
JE's, closer to 2000s.

• JA remembers that GM gave the booklet/manual to him
• JE would sometimes call JA and said to remove all of GM's photographs because he was
bringing someone else who he was interested in.

• Re GX-606:
o Page 13, JA does not remember the photographs referenced on this page in the
version of the manual he received
o JA does not recall the portion of page 16 that references fresh fruit, but otherwise
identical to the version he received
o JA does not recall seeing the medicines on page 19 being in the manual he
received
o JA does not remember part of page 30. The entry in the manual JA received
listed Evian water, not Perrier. The manual JA received didn't list Cheerios, or a
few other entries that are in this page of GX-606.
o On page 31, everything other than the alcohol, JA remembers being in the manual
he received.
3504-047
Page 2 of 4
o Upon closer review, JA does not remember page 33 being part of the manual he
received

• JA recalls that GM got Max around 1993 or 1994, and that Max was still alive when JA
left.
• GM got very little mail at PB. Mostly was JE's mail coming to that house.

• JA believes was about 14 or 15 when met her, and thinks he met her in 1994 or 1995.
JE recalls II with mother about 3 to 4 times.

• JA remembers that he picked U up from
• JA recalls his wife picking El up too
• JA recalls other females were present at JE's house when U was there. Can't recall all
their names, but includes and

• JA recalls that went to the movies sometimes with JE & GM. Sometimes I
or 6 people went to the movies.

• [AUSA showed JA the attached affidavit.] After reviewing, JA explained that at the time
he signed this affidavit, he believed it was true. But has he has thought more about this
time period in preparation for his testimony, JA has remembered more times he picked

up. JA is confident he picked more than twice. JA is also confident that his wife
picked up. JA recalls bringing to JE's plane, but is not sure how many times. JA
drove many people for JE & GM, so it is possible he drove more times that he cannot
remember.
•
3504-047
Page 3 of 4
Is
DECLARATION OF JUAN P. ALESSI
I, JUAN P. ALESSI, declare as follows:

1. My name is Juan P. Alessi. I have personal knowledge of the facts set forth herein,
except as to those stated on information and belief and, as to those, lam informed and believe
them to be true. If called as a witness, my testimony would be as follows:

2. I worked for Jeffrey E. Epstein between the years of 1991 and 2002. As Mr.
Epstein's employee, my job duties included managing his estate in Palm Beach, Florida.

3. During the course of my employment for Mr. Epstein, I personally observe
along with her mother on three occasions at Mr. Epstein's home in Palm Beach located at
358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida 33480 I don't recall the year and I don't know how old
was at that time. During those occasions, I would observe Mr. Epstein and.
and her mother talking. I never observed anything that I considered unusual or that caused
me any concern.

4. In addition to seeing at Mr. Epstein's home, I was also instructed on
one occasion by Mr. Epstein to pick-up from what I presumed was her home address
in and drive her to Mr. Epstein's home. On this occasion
was alone when I picked her up and drove her to Mr. Epstein's home.
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States that the foregoing is
true and correct.
Executed on it L21..y tSCIS22  , at West Palm Beach, Florida.
TM3Q-W2NJ - 25
3504-047
Page 4 of 4
╔═════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Emmy Tayler [epstein] assistant to Ghislaine Maxwell 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00068582 (Jmail)
 [legal] U.S. v. Ghislaine Maxwell: trial transcript
EFTA02730477 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI Research and Key Findings for Roderic Alexander, defense witness for Ghislaine Maxwell
(date: 2022-01-19)
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
Template Elleetire 10-1-2021
Tactical Intelli ence Report
FBI New York, ID -13
19 January 2022
50D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS

(U) LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE: The information marked (U//LES) in this document is the property of the
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and is for internal use within the FBI only. Distribution outside the FBI
without FBI New York's authorization is prohibited. Precautions should be taken to ensure this information is stored
and/or destroyed in a manner that precludes unauthorized access. Information bearing the LES caveat may not be
used in legal proceedings without first receiving authorization from the originating office. Recipients are prohibited
from subsequently posting the information marked LES on a website on an unclassified network.

(U) This document is classified [insert overall classification level].
(U) This document is only for FBI internal use. Do not externally disseminate this product.

(U) Tactical Intelligence Report template approved for fiscal year 2022, as of I October 2021.
(U//FOUO) Research and Key Findings for Roderic Alexander In Hamilton, a
Person of Interest for Alleged Defense Witnesses in the Ghislaine Maxwell
Th al

(U) Executive Summary
(U//LES) FBI New York C-20 is investigating Ghislaine Maxwell in a child sex trafficking
investigation based on information regarding several victims reportedly sexually abused by
Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell in the mid-late 1990s to the early 2000s. Trial started for
Ghislaine Maxwell on 29 November 2021 and FBI C-20 received a potential list of defense
witnesses on 11 December 2021. FBI New York conducted research on suspected defense
witnesses in order to identify the individuals and any derogatory information related to the
individuals. This TIR addresses FBI New York Criminal Division Band II Threat — Crimes
Against Children.

• (U//FOUO) Hamilton's last known INBOUND US travel occurred on 5 February 2016
• (U//FOUO) Hamilton's last known OUTBOUND US travel occurred on 7 February 2016

• (U//FOUO) Hamilton is associated to the company, Releev Limited in the United
Kingdom.

(U) Substantiation
(U//LES) Travel records reviewed for Roderic Alexander In Hamilton between 13 December
2021 to 16 December 2021 identified his last known international travel to the United States.

• (U//LES) According to TECS travel records matching the subject, Hamilton last traveled
INBOUND on 5 February 2016 from London/Heathrow Intl to John F Kennedy Intl.
Hamilton used United Kingdom Passport# and traveled on a Visa waiver:
Border Patro TECS I "Encounter Records of
Roderic Hamilton"113 December 2021-16 December 2021).
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

• (U//LES) According to TECS travel records matching the subject, Hamilton last traveled
OUTBOUND on 7 February 2016 from Newark Intl to London/Heathrow Intl. Hamilton
used United Kingdom Passport# (US Customs and Border Patrol I TECS
"Encounter Records of Roderic Hamilton" 113 December 2021-16 December 2021).

(U) Open Source Research for Roderic Alexander In Hamilton on 13 December 2021 identified
two websites matching the subject to a business in the United Kingdom.

• (U) Website
o (U) According to CheckCompany, a UK based website providing free information
about companies, company directors and officers in the United Kingdom, Roderic
Hamilton was listed as being located in London and is associated to the business,
Releev Limited. (Checkcompany.co.uk I "Roderic Alexander Innes Hamilton —
London, 22 January 2015" I Accessed 13 December 2021 1 RODERIC
ALEXANDER INNES HAMILTON - LONDON (checkcompany.co.uk).

• (U) Website
o (U) According to company-inforamtion.service.gov.uk, a UK based website
providing company information, Roderic Alexander Innes Hamilton is the
Director of Releev Limited, located at Flat 11 Southside Quarter, 38 Burns Rd
London, England, SW115GY. Hamilton's birthday is listed as being
and the company status is listed as dissolved. (Gov.UK I "Company -
Information Service, No Date" I Accessed 13 December 2021 IRoderic Alexander
Innes HAMILTON personal appointments - Find and update company
information - GOV.UK (company-inforrnation.service.gov.uk).
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
2
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Biographical Information

• (U//LES) Name: Roderic Alexander In Hamilton (US
Customs and Border Patrol I TECS I "Encounter
Records of Roderic Hamilton" 113 December 2021-
16 December 2021).

• (U//LES) (US Customs and Border
Patrol I TECS I "Encounter Records of Roderic
Hamilton" 113 December 2021-16 December 2021).

• (U//LES) Passport: issued in GBR-United
Kingdom and expires on (US Customs and
Border Patrol I TECS I "Encounter Records of
Roderic Hamilton" 113 December 2021-16 December
2021).

(U) Investigative/Intelligence Caps
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U) Roderic Hamilton
Non•US Passport (P )
Last Name: HAMILTON
First Name: RODERIC
DOB:
Gender: M - Male

(U) Source: TECS I Photo I UNCLASSIFIED//FOUR
OFFICIAL USE ONLY I UNCLASSIFIED//FOUR
OFFICIAL USE ONLY I Search Criteria: Roderic Hamilton;
DOB

• (U) What is the relationship between Roderic Hamilton and Ghislaine Maxwell
and/or Jeffrey Epstein?
• (U) Does Roderic Hamilton know any of the victims referenced in the
Epstein/Maxwell investigation?
UNCLASSIFIED// FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

(U) Source Summary Statement
(U) Reporting in this Tactical Intelligence Report was derived primarily from TECS (Treasury
Enforcement Communications System). All the secured information was collected between 13
December 2021 and 16 December 2021. The reporting was current as of 19 January 2022.
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
3
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Consumers:
(U) Approval:
=
(U) FBI New York Field Office prepared this Tactical  Intelligence Report. Please direct comments and queries to
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
4
EFTA02730271 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI Research and Key Findings for (unknown), defense witness for Ghislaine Maxwell
(date: 2022-03-22)
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
Template Ellector 111-1.211!1
FBI New York, ID -13
21 March 2022
SOD-NY-3027571-INTELPROUS

(U) This document is classified UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY.
(U) This document is only for FBI internal use. Do not externally disseminate this product.

(U) Tactical Intelligence Report template approved for fiscal year 2022, as of 1 October 2021.
(UHFOUO) Research and Key Findings for a Person of
Interest for Alleged Defense Witnesses in the Ghislaine Maxwell Trial

(U) Executive Summary
(U//FOLIO) FBI New York Intelligence Division conducted research on suspected defense
witnesses for the Ghislaine Maxwell trial in order to identify the individuals and any related
derogatory information. FBI New York Criminal Division squad C-20 is investigating Ghislainc
Maxwell in a child sex trafficking investigation based on information regarding several victims
reportedly sexually abused by Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell in the mid-late 1990s to
the early 2000s. Trial started for Ghislaine Maxwell on 29 November 2021 and C-20 received a
potential list of defense witnesses on 11 December 2021, listing This Tactical
Intelligence Report (TIR) addresses FBI New York Criminal Division Band II Threat — Crimes
Against Children.

(U) Key Findings

• (U//FOLIO)
• (U//FOLIO)
(U) Opportunities
was employed by Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.
had three prior addresses associated with Jeffrey Epstein.
(U//FOLIO) Interviewing may reveal more information regarding her knowledge
of victims and the relationship between Ghislaine Maxwell's and Jeffrey Epstein.
(U//FOUO) Interviewing other witnesses may reveal more information regarding
Healy's relationship with Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein.
(U) Substantiation
(U//FOUO) was employed by Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.

• (U///FOUO) As of October 2020, according to an FBI interview of an individual with
direct access, worked as a receptionist at the New York Office for
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
1
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
Epstein's company located of (FBI I FD-302 50D-NY-3027571, serial 5801
24 February 2021).'

• (U//FOUO) As of October 2020 according an FBI New York interview of an individual
with direct access, I  was hired as a receptionist at
for Epstein's compan in 1996 when worked as a receptionist. When
Espinosa worked at for Maxwell, it was understood Maxwell to be
the office manager o (FBI I FD-302 50O-NY-3027571, serial 568
I 9 February 2021).

• (U) As of December 2021, according to https://jeffreyepsteinpodcast.com, an online
website and podcast providing information about both Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine
Maxwell, was referenced as working for Jeffrey Epstein after her sister,
began working for Epstein during the 1990s. (The Prince and the Pervert
PodcastI"Epstein Sisters 14 October 2020
(1.1//FOUO) had three prior addresses associated with Jeffrey Epstein.

• (U//FOLIO) As of December 2021, according to address records referenced in Accurint,
had three addresses listed as a residence that were associated with Jeffrey
Epstein: 1) Epstein's Office located at
Epstein's island located a
00802; and 3) Epstcin's Ncw York residence located at
(Accurint I Advanced Search I Accessed 12 December 2021 1 "Comprehensive Search").

• (U) As of December 2021, according to hups://leffreyepsteinpodeast.com, an online
website and podcast providing information about both Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine
Maxwell, worked for Jeffrey Epstein and was listed as a witness on an
Epstein property transaction in 1998. (The Prince and the Pervert Podcast I "Epstein
Sisters 114 October 2020 I

(U) Biographical Information

• (U//FOLIO) Name: (Accurint I Advanced Search I Accessed 12 December
2021I"Name Search").
• (U//FOLIO) DOB: (Accurint I Advanced Search (Accessed 12 December 2021 1
"Name Search").

• (U//FOLIO) SSN: (Accurint I Advanced Search I Accessed 12 December
2021I"Name Search).
• (U//FOLIO) Analyst Note: Epstein's New York office was located at 457 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10022.
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
2
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

• (U//FOU0) Address: (Accurint I Advanced Search I
Accessed 12 December 2021 I "Name Search").
• (U//FOLIO) Phones:
(Accurint I Advanced Search I Accessed 12 December 2021I"Comprehensive Search").

(U) Investigative/Intelligence Gaps

• (U//FOLIO) To what extent waste
Maxwell's illicit activities?
• (U//FOU0) What does-
the Epstein/Maxwell investigation?
aware of Epstein's and
know about the victims referenced in
UNCLASSIFIED// FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY

(U) Source Summary Statement
(U//FOUO) Reporting in this TIR was derived primarily from FBI interviews of individuals with
direct access and open source information. All the information was collected between 14 October
2021 and 16 December 2021. The reporting was current as of 19 January 2022.

(U) Consumers:
(U) Approval:
(U) FBI New York Field Office prepared this Tactical Intelligence Report. Please direct comments and queries to
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY — DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
3
EFTA02730267 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI Research and Key Findings for Malcolm Grumbridge, defense witness for Ghislaine Maxwell
(date: 2022-04-14)
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
Template !attire 10.1.2021
FBI New York, ID -13
14 February 2022
50D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS

(U) LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE: The information marked (U//LES) in this document is the property of the
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and is for internal use within the FBI only. Distribution outside the FBI
without FBI New York's authorization is prohibited. Precautions should be taken to ensure this information is stored
and/or destroyed in a manner that precludes unauthorized access. Information bearing the LES caveat may not be
used in legal proceedings without first receiving authorization from the originating office. Recipients are prohibited
from subsequently posting the information marked LES on a website on an unclassified network.

(U) This document is classified Unclassified//Law Enforcement Sensitive.
(U) This document is only for FBI internal use. Do not externally disseminate this product.

(U) Tactical Intelligence Report template approved for fiscal year 2022, as of I October 2021.
(U//FOUO) Research and Key Findings for Malcolm Grumbridge, a Person of
Interest for Alleged Defense Witnesses in the Ghislaine Maxwell Trial

(U) Executive Summary
(U//LES) FBI New York Intelligence Division conducted research on suspected defense
witnesses for the Ghislaine Maxwell trial in order to identify the individuals and any related
derogatory information. FBI New York Criminal Division squad C-20 is investigating Ghislaine
Maxwell in a child sex trafficking investigation based on information regarding several victims
reportedly sexually abused by Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell in the mid-late 1990s to
the early 2000s. Trial started for Ghislaine Maxwell on 29 November 2021 and C-20 received a
potential list of defense witnesses on 11 December 2021. This Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR)
addresses FBI New York Criminal Division Band II Threat — Crimes Against Children.

(U) Key Findings

• (U//FOUO) Grumbridge last traveled to the United States on a four day trip in 2019.
• (U//FOUO) Grumbridge is referred to as a Maxwell family associate in open source
articles.

• (U//FOUO) Grumbridge is referenced in open source articles for being removed as a
Solicitor from the Solicitors Regulation Authority due to several rule breaches.

(U) Substantiation
(U//LES) Grumbridge's last traveled to the United States on a four day trip in 2019.

• (U//LES) As of December 2021, according to TECS travel records matching the subject,
Grumbridge last traveled INBOUND on 24 October 2019 from London/Heathrow Intl to
John F Kennedy Intl. GBR-United Kingdom issued Passportlinith an
expiration date of 31 August 2021. (US Customs and Border Patrol I TECS I "Encounter
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
1
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
Records of Malcolm Grumbridge" 114 December 2021).

• (U//LES) As of December 2021, according to TECS travel records matching the subject,
Grumbridge last traveled OUTBOUND on 27 October 2019 from John F Kennedy Intl to
London/Heathrow Intl. (US Customs and Border Patrol I TECS I "Encounter Records of
Malcolm Grumbridge" 114 December 2021).

(U) Grumbridge is referenced in open source articles as being a Maxwell family associate.

• (U) As of December 2021, according to the Steeple Times, an online magazine based in
the UK, Malcolm Grumbridge was found guilty in 2020 "of a string of rule breaches"
after more than four decades of having a legal and business career. The article states
Grumbridge has been at the heart of the Maxwell's finances to include acted as the
custodian of 44 Kinnerton St in Belgravia, London.' The article also states Grumbridge
established over 150 companies in total. (Steeple Times I "Grubby Malcolm Grumbridge
& Mucky Ghislaine Maxwell" I 5 August 2021 1 www.thesteepletimes.com/movers-
shakershnalcolm-grumbridge-maxwel10.

• (U) As of December 2021, according to dailymail.com, an online news website, Malcolm
Grumbridge is referenced as a Maxwell family associate and has involvement in the
Hogarth Group, a company that runs health clubs in West London. (DailyMail I
"Ghislaine Maxwell still has connections despite link to Prince Andrew and Jeffery
Epstein" 12 July 20201 www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2904115/Ghislaine-Maxwell-
s-link-ssex-scandal-court-papers-involving-Prince-Andrew-Jeffery-Epstein-don-t-stop-
having-amazing-social-connections.html).

• (U) As of December 2021, according to This is Money, a UK based financial website,
Malcolm Grumbridge is listed as having involvement with two companies with Kevin
Maxwell. The article notes Kevin Maxwell had a "mystery benefactor over payments due
on his home." Grumbridge is listed as a Maxwell family friend and lawyer. (This is
Money I "Maxwell firms to be struck off register" I 5 August 2005 I
www.thisismonev.co.uk/money/news/article-1592483/Maxwell-firms-to-be-struck-off-
register.html).
(U) Grumbridge is referenced in open source articles for being removed as a Solicitor from the
Solicitors Regulation Authority due to several rule breaches.

• (U) According to the Tatler, a British magazine that focuses on fashion, lifestyle, high
society and politics, Malcolm Grumbridge is listed as a legal advisor to the Hogarth
Health Club in Chiswich and is referenced as a lawyer. (Tatler I "Where on earth was the
British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell? At last, we know" I 3 July 2020 I

• (U//FOUO) (Analyst Note: The address 44 Kinnerton St in Belgravia, London is a known residence of Ghislaine
Maxwell).
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
2
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
www.tatler.com/article/where-on-earth-is-ghislaine-maxwell).

• (U) According to The Times, a UK based daily newspaper, Malcolm Grumbridge quit the
legal profession in 2020 after admitting to reckless conduct. Grumbridge set up several
companies registered to the The Hogarth Group with several linked to Kevin and Ian
Maxwell.' (The Times I "Disgraced solicitor Malcolm Grumbridge's links to the
Maxwells" I 2 August 2021 1 www.thetimes.co.uk/article/disgraced-solicitor-malcolm-
grumbridges-links-to-the-maxwells-tst265t2t).

• (U) According to https://chiswickcalandar.co.uk, a UK based website, Malcolm
Grumbridge was removed from the Roll of Solicitors after an investigation by the
Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) because they identified several ears of concern
such as: Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing, The SRA Accounts Rules 2011, the
Solicitors" Accounts Rules 1998 and the SRA Code of Conduct. Grumbridge was
accused of failing to check the source of where money was coming from and failing to
verify the identity of clients. The SRA stated Grumbridge "failed to behave in a way that
maintain the trust the public places in him." (https://chiswickcalandar.co.uk I "Financial
dealings of Hogarth Club director Malcolm Grumbridge in the spotlight" I 2 August 2021
https://chiswickcalandar.co.uk/financial-dealings-of-hogarth-club-director-malcolm-
grumbridge-in-the-spotlight/).

(U) Biographical Information

• (U//LES) Name: Malcolm Grumbridge (US Customs
and Border Patrol I TECS I "Encounter Records of
Malcolm Grumbrid e" 14 December 2021).

• (U//LES) DOB: S Customs and Border
Patrol I TECS I "Encounter Records of Malcolm
Grumbridge"I 14 D t • (U//LES) Passport: ssued in GBR-United
Kingdom and expires on 31 August 2021. (US
Customs and Border Patrol I TECS I "Encounter
Records of Malcolm Grumbridge" 114 December
2021).
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE
ONLY

(U) Malcolm Grumbridge
Last Name: GRUMBRIDGE
First Name
Birth Dale
Encnti Date: 10.27/2019
MALCOLM
CHRISTOPHER

(U) Source: TECS I Photo I UNCLASSIFIED/!FOUR
OFFICIAL USE ONLY I UNCLASSIFIED//FOUR
OFFICIAL USE ONLY Search Criteria: Malcolm
Gnm*ddae: Do
b (U) (Analyst Note: Kevin Maxwell and Ian Maxwell are Ghislaine Maxwell's brothers).
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
3
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY

(U) Investigative/Intelligence Gaps
UNCLASSIFIED// FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U) Source Summary Statement
(U) Reporting in this Tactical Intelligence Report was derived primarily from TECS (Treasury
Enforcement Communications System). All the secured information was collected between 13
December 2021 and 16 December 2021. The reporting was current as of 19 January 2022.

(U) Consumers:
(U) Approval:
(U) FBI New York Field Office oreoared this Tactical Intelligence Report. Please direct comments and queries to
FBI INTERNAL USE ONLY - DO NOT DISSEMINATE EXTERNALLY
UNCLASSIFIED//LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
4
EFTA00143433 (Jmail)
 [girls] victim impact statement
(approximate date: 2022-06-01)
INFORMATION RELATED TO ELIGIBILITY AND COMPENSATION

Please complete the questions below to the best of your ability. You may use additional
space to describe your experiences.

1. Do you consider yourself a Victim -Survivor of sexual abuse and/or trafficking by
Jeffrey Epstein?

Yes, I consider myself a Victim-Survivor of sexual abuse and trafficking by Jeffrey Epstein.
When I arrived in New York I was escaping a physically and
mentally abusive relationship. I was a vulnerable young woman who was new to a foreign
country and knew no one. I was carefully selected as the perfect victim to be sex trafficked
by Epstein.

Once selected by my predator she quickly gathered my information whilst
coercing me into a false friendship. Most importantly, she discovered my true ambition was
to study at <REDACTED>.

Like all sex trafficking groominga Epstein quickly met my needs to achieve my
dreams. This was all an illusion. <REDACTED> told me she knew a wealthy philanthropist who
could help me g<REDACTED> Epstein quickly established those credentials by promising to
send me to my dream school under certain conditions, which began to increase in time.
Once befriended by I was coerced to visit Epstein Island, St. Little James, on my
first visit. She said it was purely a girl's trip, and once on the island, Epstein's sexual abuse
started and continued until May 2007. My passport was taken away and I could not leave and
he always promised to find me if I left. Epstein had complete control over every aspect of my
life, including medication, shelter, food and basic human living necessities. He delighted in
torturing me by dangling rewards for being raped that were never entirely within reach with
the help of an extensive network of enablers, including <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED> located at their Headquarters in New York in 2007.

He found out my biggest fear was anything happening to my family, and he used that till, to
my core, I was convinced my family would be murdered. I lived in a permanent state of
"Flight or Fright" and still do.
1
Most importantly, at no time did I ever consent to being raped and raped repeatedly. The fact
that my predator was paid money for my delivery to Epstein means I was sold into sex
slavery. Pm assuming the payment made on my behalf came from Epstein's JP Morgan
account.

To the best of your ability, please describe the circumstances under which you first met
Jeffrey Epstein and/or anyone associated with him (including the approximate date).

<REDACTED> - I met <REDACTED> one of Epstein's recruiters, in a <REDACTED>
around two weeks after arriving in <REDACTED><REDACTED>. She soon introduced
me to Epstein.

Jeffrey Epstein — I agreed with <REDACTED> to meet Epstein at the cinemas around a week after
meeting her. I, Epstein, and several other girls, including <REDACTED>, went to the movies. The
third time I met, Epstein was on his plane to the island to be raped in early <REDACTED>

<REDACTED> - On the first plane to the island in late October <REDACTED> I met <REDACTED>. She
was Epstein's "girlfriend". I saw her often throughout my trafficking as she was often with
Epstein. She also sexually assaulted me in early 2007.

<REDACTED> - On one of Epstein's plane rides to St Little James, I met <REDACTED>. We
first flew together on Epstein's plane on the 10th of December 2006 along with
was an employee and best friend of my recruiter.

I saw <REDACTED> on many occasions in the USVI and New York.

Ghislaine Maxwell - I met Ghislaine roughly after the second trip on the island in USVI
after I started being sex trafficked by Epstein in late 2006. I met her frequently until May
2007. She was Epstein's right-hand lady who controlled everything, including me. Without
Ghislaine, there would be no Epstein.

<REDACTED> - I first met in St Little James USVI early in my sex trafficking in 2006.
I saw <REDACTED> multiple times as she was Epstein's PA, including in New York.

Lesley Groff — Lesley was also a top lieutenant PA Sif stein. I never met Lesly personally;
however, we were in permanent contact as she and <REDACTED> were constantly making
arrangements for me on behalf of Epstein. Our correspondence increased when she helped
with my <REDACTED> application for Epstein.

Jean Luc Brunel - I met Brunel when I met Ghislaine at St Little James. I saw him on
multiple trips to the island. He was a top employee of Epstein's.

Cathy & Miles Alexander- I first met Epstein's Island Managers when I first visited the
island in early October 2006. I saw them every time I went to Epstein's Island.

Igor - I met Igor generally every time I saw Epstein from early October 2006 — May 2007, as
he was Epstein's bodyguard.

<REDACTED> - I first met when she was new to being trafficked by Epstein late December 2006.

<REDACTED> - I first met <REDACTED> another survivor, in late December 2006.

Sergey Brin and Ann Wojcicki — I met the pair on Epstein's Island, St. Little James when
they spent the day with Epstein, Maxwell, and Jean- Luc on 01/01/2007.

Alan Dershowitz — I first met Dershowitz at the beginning of 2007 at Epstein's office in NY
for legal representation. The second time I met him was at a restaurant with Epstein, and the
thirst time at Epstein's Mansion.

<REDACTED> — I met in January 2007. When I first arrived, I shared a room in an
apartment on <REDACTED> I was in the neighbourhood where I met <REDACTED> in the corner
shop by the apartment. When walking out, a homeless man I knew through being a regular at
the store introduced me to <REDACTED> out of the blue. He was adamant that we had to meet each
other.

2. Provide the approximate time period during which you interacted with Jeffrey
Epstein and/or anyone associated with him.

I regularly interacted with <REDACTED>, Jeffrey Epstein, <REDACTED> (we both
also stayed at Epstein's apartments <REDACTED> NY and interacted there, too),
<REDACTED> Ghislaine Maxwell, Lesley Groff, Jean Luc Brunel, Cathy & Miles
Alexander, Igor during the duration of my trafficking which was from late
September/October 2006 to May 2007

<REDACTED> — I saw initially saw her regularly after the New Year's Trip.

<REDACTED> - I spent the New Year's trip with her for a few days, and I think I'm sure I saw her
on more trips after.

Sergey Brin and Ann Wojcicki - One day — 01/01/2007

Alan Dershowitz — On three occasions in early 2007
<REDACTED> - January 2007 —16 August 2008

3. List the location(s) where you were sexually abused and/or trafficked by Jeffrey
Epstein and/or anyone associated with him.

I was trafficked in the following locations:
1.) Jeffery's New York Mansion - 9 East 7 ls' Street
2.) US Virgin Islands — St. Little James
3.) Epstein's Apartment — 301E. 661h Street NY
4.) <REDACTED> NY apartment —He lived just off <REDACTED> Across the
road from my old room share and in the only neighbourhood, I felt any form of safety.
5.) <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

4. When did the sexual abuse and/or trafficking occur? (Please identify the
approximate date(s) that the sexual abuse and/or trafficking happened, to the
best of your knowledge)

Jeffrey Epstein and Co — Early October 2006 — May 2007
<REDACTED> - January 2007 — 16 August 2008
Alan Dershowitz and <REDACTED> — Early 2007

5. On approximately how many separate occasions were you sexually abused
and/or trafficked by Jeffrey Epstein and/or anyone associated with him?

Jeffrey Epstein - During the first visit to the island, I was raped repeatedly by Epstein.
After the first visit, Epstein raped me regularly until I managed to "escape" from him in
May 2007 and sometimes up to thrice a day.

<REDACTED>- I was repeatedly abused sexually, mentally, and emotionally from
when I first met <REDACTED> in January 2007 to 16th August 2008.

Alan Dershowitz and — I was sexually assaulted on one occasion.

6. To the best of your ability, describe the nature and circumstances of the sexual
abuse and/or trafficking.

Epstein controlled my life for almost a year, abusing me regularly in New York and on the
Island of St Little James. The abuse was both physical and emotional. Epstein housed me in
one of his many apartments on He bought my food, paid for my medication, and
even controlled how I wore my hair.

I was put on a low-calorie diet and starved because Epstein insisted that I reach an
unachievable weight as a prerequisite to "helping" me with myMadmission. However, he
sent me to a psychiatrist to prescribe me medication whose main side effect was weight gain.
Epstein never intended to send me toMand enjoyed tormenting me. Epstein even got his
assistant Lesley Groff to monitor my weight loss and had to send her nude pictures of myself.

On the 6'h February 2007 I wrote to Lesley " ou also let him know that I am
now 57kg and that everything is going well in <REDACTED>

On the 8'h of February 2007, I wrote to Lesley "Could you please tell Jeffrey to ,1  me on
the number I have asap as I'm not prepared to go under 56kg in order to study at <REDACTED>

On the 16'h of Febuary Lesly writes to me "Hi ...Jeffery is awaiting your picture!...and
why were you hoping to hear from me before going to bed??
;)Les"

As soon as I stepped on Epstein's plane for the first time, I was captured on Epstein's web.
My passport was taken away and the sexual abuse began. Epstein caused significant physical
damage to my insides, vaginal area and rectum. Epstein raped me daily and sometimes up to
three times a day.

One day I was in severe distress and afraid; I tried to escape Epstein and the others by trying
to swim off St Little James. Epstein and Maxwell, after spending the day being raped,
bullied, and belittled, brought me back as if nothing happened. Epstein and Maxwell
maintained control by constantly alternating between sticks of abuse and false carrots as
praise. When I was raped, I was made a cup of tea by Cathy and met with smiles. Epstein
Maxwell and others made threats and offered bribes, and everyone around normalised this
behaviour, from my recruiter, her best friend <REDACTED> Epstein's "girlfriend" <REDACTED>.
Epstein's employees to the border control that ignored hundreds of children and young
women like me being trafficked.

Once Jeffrey was tired of me, he sent me to <REDACTED> to recruit another victim. Upon
return I purposely failed to bring him a victim to sexually abuse, and I failed to lose yet more
<REDACTED> For this, I was severely punished by Epstein, a memory that will forever be in my
mind.

Epstein had me carry a Blackberry, and if I did not answer immediately, Epstein would come
and find me. One day I was walking in New York and did not answer Epstein. Within
minutes Epstein's driver pulled up beside me. He made it clear not to disobey him.

Beyond Epstein's abuse, he also forced me to have sex with others a ainst my will. One day
ign summoned me to his mansion. When I arrived, <REDACTED> was waiting for me.
led me to the upstairs bedroom, where Epstein forced me to perform sexual acts with
<REDACTED> his lawyer friend, Alan Dershowitz, and <REDACTED>. This event traumatised me.

In early January 2007, I met randomly in my old neighbourhood. <REDACTED> worked as
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> and I quickly fell for his charming
disposition.

Early in the relationship, I told him about Jeffrey. On the 26th of January, I wrote to <REDACTED> at
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> "I am off to eat some celery. Oh, I almost forgot to
tell you. I spoke to Jeffrey this morning snd everything is fine. He told me not to worry."

<REDACTED> knew Epstein put me on an unrealistic extreme diet and that I suffered from intense
%kidney pain, headaches, exhaustion, and starvation to get into <REDACTED> supported my
weight loss and bought expensive gifts to celebrate my wei t goals. even helped me
with my <REDACTED> application. On the 9th of February 2007, <REDACTED> wrote, "Good Morning
Beautiful!! Made a few additions -it's now up to 602 words. We need to get it up to about
675-725. Have attached the document and copied the text below."

<REDACTED> knew that Epstein was controlling me chemically. Epstein's psychiatrist prescribed me
<REDACTED><REDACTED>. Due to the nature of the medication, I couldn't go one day
withoutiknedication and the financial assistance of Epstein to pay for my prescription. I
begged <REDACTED> to put me on his health insurance so I could break free from Epstein and him
raping me.

<REDACTED> strung me along with false carrots like Epstein, and, on the 12th of March, <REDACTED> wrote
"Here's a link for you to use to compare plans. We can discuss when I get home — does not
look too bad..."

Epstein kicked me out of his apartments when I refused to be raped and <REDACTED> suggested I
move in with him. Whilst living with <REDACTED I was regularly raped by Epstein knew
this but did not help me or protect me.

On multiple occasions, I told <REDACTED> that I would go to the authorities, and each time he
stopped me. He convinced me that moving on was best. Instead, he used Epstein's methods
and sent me to therapy. On 10 July 2007, <REDACTED> wrote, "Here are the forms and the location
as well. I am so happy for you to start this... and proud of your resolve to be happy and have
a better life. Xxx"

After I escaped Epstein to <REDACTED> <REDACTED>soon followed, where he quickly integrated himself
into my life and moved into my home, which resulted in me becoming financially entrapped
by him.

Over the months, whilst Epstein's plea bargain was being finalised, <REDACTED> became angry and
distant. He would have a violent burst and, on two occasions kicked my dog so hard she hit
the wall. My Mom witnessed this as she was living with <REDACTED> and me then. He also
threatened to slit my mom and my throat twice unprovoked. My mom and I were afraid and
did not doubt his threat.

Once Epstein's jail sentence started, <REDACTED> wrote on the P' of July 2008, "Finally", and sent
me a link to an article. I find it odd that he never offered to console me in any way.
On the 16'h of August, my time with ended. His job was completed. He arranged for
my Mum and me to be at the cinemas whilst he "bought my birthday present". Instead, he
took my house keys and cleared out m house and I had to find out via m mom he never
wanted to see me again. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> arrived at the
<REDACTED> saw me, threw the newspaper on my bed, and left.

Because abuse of all natures had become so normalised for me, I didn't see the bright neon
red flags when I met <REDACTED> or throughout our relationship, nor did I question why <REDACTED>
wanted to be my friend. I was tricked into being in a relationship with <REDACTED> to monitor,
control, silence and ultimately destroy. Epstein and <REDACTED> almost completed their mission.
Not only did Epstein, and others sexually violate me, but they also exploited me
and gaslighted me to extremes where I suffer severely from anxiety, depression, and isolation
with psychological trauma.

7. Did anyone witness the sexual abuse and/or trafficking or circumstances
surrounding the abuse and/or trafficking? If yes, please provide the name(s) of
each witness and date(s) of the incident(s) the person witnessed. Anyone's name
who you provide will be kept confidential. The Claims Administrator will not
reach out to this person / these people.

Miles and Cathy Alexander -
Miles and Cathy were always around on St Little James as they were the island managers. It
was their job to observe everything, and they were highly paid to do so. They were always in
and out of bungalows, shepherding us around and serving us. Making sure everything ran
smoothly.

When I first arrived, they greeted me with warmth and friendliness. Their smiles were white
and bright. They used the same friendly, warm smiles to comfort me after Epstein raped me,
and I fled, bleeding and crying.

Igor Zinoviev -
Igor was always there when I was on the island. He regularly saw me in distress. On one
occasion, after being raped three times that day and being bullied, belittled, and starved, I
tried to swim off the island to escape my worst nightmare.

Before I started, I was stopped. I was returned to my hell hole. During a meeting, Igor
confirmed to Brad Edwards that he had witnessed the traumatic event. He told Brad that my
"attempt showed no greater level of distress than he'd seen in other girls throughout the
years".

Again, Igor's job as Epstein's bodyguard was to observe everything. Brad confirmed this in
his book Relentless Pursuit, page 305, which I have included.
9

<REDACTED> -
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>, witnessed me being raped. When I first
met her, she was more distressed the I was. By then, I had found a way to block the rapes in
my mind when they were happening. It was the only way to survive and keep living one more
day. On more than one occasion, I took her turn to be raped by Epstein to preserve what little
she had left.

<REDACTED>
was on the same trip New Year's Eve trip, and she, too, was raped. We all witnessed
each other's rapes, fear, and trauma.

Sergey Brin and Ann Wojcicki —
I met Sergey and Anna when they came for the day to EF in's Island on 01/01/2007 to visit
Epstein, Maxwell, and Jean-Luc Brunel. I, and were with them for most of
the duration. They observed that we did not speak and that we remained mute. They
witnessed the trauma on our faces and in our eyes. Sergey and Anne witnessed our souls and
bodies riddled with fear. They said nothing. They did nothing. They just continued to laugh
and joke around us as if we were nothing like I didn't even exist.

My Mum - <REDACTED>
Mum witnessed roughly three months of my abusive relationship with <REDACTED>. She has
included her written statement of what she witnessed, including threatening to slit our
throats twice, his angry, aggressive disposition toward me, kicking my dogl.twice and
how he deviously orchestrated his exit strate once his 'ob was done. She also witnesses
how he threw a newspaper on her <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>.

8. To the best of your ability, please describe the impact (emotional, psychological,
physical, financial, etc.) you believe the sexual abuse and/or trafficking by
Jeffrey Epstein and/or anyone associated with him had on you.
Epstein, and others have broken me unfathomably.

Whilst with Epstein, I suffered severe depression, anxiety, and physical damage due to his
daily rapes. I was sometimes raped up to three times a day. The psychological damage and
trauma that Epstein caused by his continuous sexual assault is irreparable, and I will forever
live with deep emotional scars. No amount of time can truly heal those wounds.

When Epstein put me on the extreme diet, I became dangerously thin and suffered severe
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>. Since then, I have engaged in extreme dieting
an oun rt c a enging to maintain a ea t y weight. Psychologically what Epstein did by
starving me into an extreme weight loss that was never achievable for education and using it
as an excuse to assault me sexually repeatedly has been profound and is a daily struggle.
Since Epstein's psychiatrist prescribed me, I have been on various medications and will
continue for the foreseeable future. I have been referred to a psychiatrist in the to
oversee continued medication and trauma treatment.

The deceit, extreme gaslighting, coercion, manipulation and sexual abuse suffered by
have caused tremendous trauma, which recently manifested in significant mental
and physical health issues, some of which may never be resolved.

Whilst was living with me, I began to see media reports on Epstein and his plea
deal with Alex Acosta. The reports triggered me enormously, and with the help of the abusive
relationship with <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>.

I was in <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED>. Due to recovery and the financial turmoil left me in, I lost my home in
<REDACTED>. It took me several years to recover financially.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> due to
overwhelming fear of what Epstein would do to my family and me and reliving the trauma of
the dail rapes. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

Since then, I have been coping with the all-consuming fear that someday one of Epstein's
associates would harm me, my loved ones, and my family.

Epstein, <REDACTED>, and others have soiled my soul as a human being. I pray that the severe
emotional distress and anxiety will someday subside. My privacy has been breached, and my
reputation has been damaged. Worse of all, Epstein, <REDACTED> and others have taken what
should be the best years of my life away from me. No monetary compensation in the world
can replace time stolen from me. Time is priceless, something that not even the wealthiest
man in the world can purchase.

I frequently experience flashbacks and wake up in cold sweats from nightmares reliving the
traumatic experience. I'm hypervigilant, experience dramatic mood changes, and avoid
certain places, situations, and people, especially men. I will sometimes start to c
uncontrollably and without apparent reason. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED> due to the current litigation with JP Morgan and
the trauma o re wing my sex tra w mg and abusive relationship with <REDACTED>. The
external trauma stress has and is profoundly affecting my body.

In addition, I shy away from strangers and have difficulty making new friends because they
could be associated with Epstein, and others. Something which will forever be a
probable threat for the rest of my life.

Since coming forward, I have lived in hiding, <REDACTED> and struggled to cope with
years of fighting for justice and the truth. The ongoing Epstein saga has had catastrophic
consequences on my mental health, and I have been unable to earn a living throughout the
years apart from my memoir.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

Due to the nature and duration of my treatment and the severity of my trauma, it will be
unlikely that I will be able to return to employment in the foreseeable future, if ever.

9. Have you received any treatment or services (medical, counseling, addiction,
etc.) related to the sexual abuse and/or trafficking by Jeffrey Epstein and/or
anyone associated with him? If yes, please describe and provide the name of the
service provider, the date(s) of the services provided, and a description of the
services.

Yes, I have.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

I again had to stop therapy due to a lack of finances. Therapy was also tricky because I have
been in the thick of trying to achieve justice for myself and others who were sexually
trafficked. <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> have been horrific. It has
been challenging to get into a space to achieve even the slightest of healing.

10. Did you attempt to contact law enforcement or were otherwise prevented from
contacting law enforcement or seeking help by Jeffery Epstein and/or anyone
associated with him? If so, please explain the efforts you took to contact law
enforcement or seek help and how you were prevented from doing so.

Jeffrey Epstein —
Whilst I Was being trafficked, I was repeatedly told by Epstein that if I ever told anyone or
went to the FBI or any authorities, my family and I would get killed. I also could not escape
from Epstein.

Epstein had me carry a Blackberry given to me by him, and if I did not answer immediately,
he would come and find me. One day I was walking in New York and did not answer Epstein
as I knew he wanted to weigh, berate, and then rape me afterwards as punishment for not
weighing his unachievable weight loss goals. Undoubtedly, the Blackberry Epstein gave me
was always tracking me.

Within minutes Epstein's driver pulled up beside me. Epstein then demanded that I get in the
car, took me back to his mansion, and made it very clear that I had to obey him.
When I came forward in 2016 I was also located and followed in
live in hiding in
two years which was mcre
which led me to
for
y cu t an iso atmg. I nce again, pstein, and
others had imprisoned me once again. While I was hiding, Jef‘fti demonstrated that he could
locate me again by emailing another victim to locate me after I
came forward.
After my case was settled, the US Government discovered that Epstein attempted to
sabotage my case by paying off fact witnesses before their scheduled depositions when my
case was pending.
During my time with = he discovered Epstein was sexually trafficking me early in our
relationship. At not one point did he suggest I should go to the FBI or authorities in fear that
I and my family would be harmed. Instead, when I was most distressed and just about to
come forward, he would pacify me, then manipulate me not to and, to deter me, send me to
therapy and overindulge me with expensive gifts and dinners.
HE ARRANGED THERAPY FOR ME when I was just on the brink of going to the
authorities on two separate occasions. One during the Epstein investigation and the second
during the plea bargain. Epstein used this exact strategy. normalised and aided my
sex trafficking with Epstein and others.
He first sent me to therapy when he worked at whilst Epstein was
their client.
16
Please see below an example corresponding to therapy. On the 10th of July, wrote from
his Email account
"Here are the forms and the locations as well.
I am so happy for you to start this... and proud of your resolve to be happy and have a better
life.
Xxx"
Forwarded by pn 07/10/2007 11:29 AM
MI 607/06/2007 10:58
AM
Subject
1pm Wed 11 July
To
CC
Dear =,
I look forward to meeting you 1pm Wednesday 11 July at the l
for an initial consultation. (I have also provisionally reserved
11am Saturday 14th July).
Address: It is located next t
The fee i 120 - you can pay after the session by cash or cheque. I am
aware that will settle payment for the first consultation, and
alternate sessions if we agree to work together.
Please note that the cancellation policy is 48 hours notice for any changes
to the appointment to avoid being charged the full fee.
I am attaching a consultation form - it will save time if you can fill it
out and bring it to our session. I am also attaching our terms and
17
conditions for you to read.
Kind wishes,
Between and the therapist that chose, controlled, and paid for, theyight me
into believing it was best to move on. I also had no choice, as I was beholden to
financially. I did what he told me. I was afraid of becoming homeless again.
was and is an enabler on behalf of for Epstein. Epstein was one of their
most profitable clients, and Sergey Brin whom I interacted on the island before I met =,
was the no. 1 top client ati lEfor many years. was deliberate) ut there to
silence me. He almost succeeded when he threw the newspaper on
walked out when I
I thou
and the therapist he arranged for me were right and tried to move on until

* VS Jeffrey istein Ghislaine Maxwell, <REDACTED><REDACTED> and <REDACTED>

I came forward <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED>. Since then, I have been in hiding several times. Epstein demonstrated that he could
locate me after he hired individuals to follow me while I lived in when I first came
forward. I promptly moved into remote hiding for two years. Once in hiding, he also emailed
another fellow survivor looking for me. I have included the email.

During my litigation, specific witnesses cooperating with my counsel during my discovery
suddenly stopped doing so when Epstein made two payments of $250.000 and $100,000
(made from Deutsche Bank?) to one of his long-time friends and one of his employees.

Again, the US Government discovered that Epstein attempted to sabotage my case by
paying off fact witnesses before their scheduled depositions when my case was pending.

I received a s<REDACTED> which was not a product of fair circumstances and was
corrupted by Epstein's witness tampering. I could have filed a motion to vacate the settlement
agreement. See Interspace Inc. v Morris, 650 F. Supp. 107, 110 (S.N.D.Y.1986) (settlement
agreement will be set aside if there is "cause sufficient to invalidate a contact, such as fraud,
collusion, mistake or accident").

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>. Please see a letter written by my ex-partner <REDACTED><REDACTED>
to <REDACTED> that I couldn't travel due <REDACTED><REDACTED>.

<REDACTED> wrote,
<REDACTED> cannot sit for any significant length of time due <REDACTED><REDACTED>

It is estimated at this time that <REDACTED> will not be able to travel until at least one month
following <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>. <REDACTED> has a meeting with <REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> to determine when that will happen. "

My case against Epstein, Maxwell, <REDACTED>, and <REDACTED> was a great miscarriage of
justice whereby it's affected me deeply on multiple levels, including beliefs in the world
around me which will stay with me forever.

US Government / FBI -

I have fully cooperated with the government as part of its investigation into Epstein and
his co—conspirators.

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

11. Please provide any additional information that you wish to share with the Claims
Administrator. You may also schedule a meeting with the Claims Administrator
to share more information directly with her. Please provide any additional
information you which to share with the Claims Administrator including any
additional information about the harm you suffered as a result of Epstein's
conduct if not already described in your prior answers.

Over the last seven years, it would have been easier to draw a drop of blood out of the centre
of Ayers Rock than achieve true justice where all those responsible are held accountable. I
realise that true justice is a mere fantasy, for I and hundreds of other women (some of whom
were children when trafficked).

My life has been shattered seeking the truth and I have made many personal sacrifices along
the journey. One is privacy.

The world needed to hear my and others' stories of how we were trafficked and implicate
those in a quest for justice. The woman whom Epstein and others sexually assaulted needed
to know they were not alone and to offer comfort to those suffering like me.

<REDACTED> to my detriment, which massively impacted my mental health. I
want to point out that I have not received payment for an interview, nor have I asked.

I have included several links for your viewing:

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
EFTA02731018 (Jmail)
 [politics] letter from Senator Ron Wyden to Marc Rowan
(inferred date: 2022-06-22)
Kt. Wel3f, I. MOON . °AIRMAN
CROW STARENOw. MICHIGAN PARE C WO. 0A10
MARIA EmowELL wASNINGTON Ewa GASMEN ,. OWA
RostRT NE HI Not/ taw JEMMY JOHN CORWN Tint
CARMRCIIAWMM JOHN MUNE. SOUTH DM(OTA
dtHJAMIN t (AHERN. MPWLAND
SHOOLOO MOAN. Cm0
MOAN. R BENNET.COICAMLO
MAWR P CASEY. 1. .. PERINSYLVAVA
MARK A WARNER. MAGMA
SHELDON ANITIHOUSE. ANODE GLAND
MAGGIE LASSAN, MW RAMPSNME
CATHERINE CORTEZ AUTO. NEVADA
ELIZAKTN WARREN. MASSACHUSETTS
ROAM SUM. NORTH GAROWLA
ROt 'CAIMAN. OHIO
PATRCR J TOOMEY. PCNNSNERAMA
I'M SCOTT. SOUTH CAROLINA
Bll CASSIOY. MUMMA
JAMES t ARKFORD. OCLAHOMA
STEW DAMES. MONTANA
Too° voJNG miaow
BEN SASSE NE liAASKA
JOHN IJAPRAS50.AVOMMG
JOSHUA SNOWMAN SEAM DIRECTOR
GREGG SUCHARD. IttPuBILCAN STALE DLRECTCA
Marc Rowan
Chief Executive Officer
Apollo Global Management, Inc.
9 West 57th Street, 43rd Floor
New York, NY 10019
Dear Mr. Rowan,
United *tams *coati
June 22, 2022
COMMITTEE ON FINANCE
WASHINGTON, OC 20510-6200
I write seeking information regarding a business arrangement between Leon Black and
Jeffrey Epstein. A report commissioned by the Conflicts Committee of Apollo Global
Management ("Apollo") stated Epstein was paid $158 million by Black between 2012 and 2017
for services related to a variety of tax and estate planning matters, an amount that appears to far
exceed that paid by Black to his other professional advisors.' This compensation scheme, which
ranged between $23 million and $26 million for a number of years appears to have far exceeded
the median CEO pay for Fortune 500 CEOs, which Fortune calculated at $15.9 million for 2021.2
This amount also appears well in excess of the expected compensation for estate planning
services—particularly in a case where Epstein's work was required to be vetted by other legal
and accounting professionals, at times was viewed as not useful, and included instances of
substantial misrepresentations of applicable tax laws!
'Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation Of Epstein/Black Relationship And Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/ 14[1494/0001 I 93 I 2521016405/d118102dex99 .htm
2 The top 10 highest paid CEOs of the Fortune 500, Fortune, May 28, 2022 https://fortune.com/2022/05/28/highest.
paithceos-in-america-202 I/
3 Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation Of Epstein/Black Relationship And Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
https://www.see.gov/Archivestedgar/data/14 11494/000 I 19312521016405/d I 18102dex99l.htm (At page 3, "not all
of Epstein's advice was useful"; at page 4, "such advice was vetted consistently by Blacks' other advisors, including
Family Office employees, Paul Weiss, and other outside legal, accounting, and tax professionals"; at page I1, "[Mr.
Epstein's] ideas would appear plausible at face value, but did not hold up under scrutiny"; at page 17, "Black was
under the misconception that his payments to Epstein would be tax deductible ('sixty cent dollars') because this is
what Epstein had told Black." )
As you are aware, Jeffrey Epstein was arrested and indicted in federal court on July 8,
2019 on sex trafficking charges involving the exploitation and abuse of dozens of underage
girls.' In the aftermath of these charges, Apollo hired law firm Dechert LLP to conduct an
investigation into Epstein's ties to Black, Apollo's Chairman and Chief Executive Officer at the
time. Mr. Black for decades maintained longstanding personal and professional ties to Epstein
and engaged Mr. Epstein for his advice related to tax strategy, estate planning and philanthropy.
The investigation, according to a filing published by Apollo with the Securities and
Exchange Commission on January 22, 2021 ("the report"), identified several tax matters where
Black paid Epstein $158 million for his advice.' According to the report, Epstein advised Black
on tax strategy for complex transactions and trusts designed to avoid paying as much as $2
billion in taxes.' This includes advice related to a "proprietary" solution Epstein developed for
Black to resolve issues with a trust Black created in 2006 in order to transfer assets to his
beneficiaries while avoiding roughly $1 billion in gift and estate taxes.' According to the report,
Epstein also advised Black on a "step -up-basis transaction" designed to save Black's children
approximately $600 million in taxes as well as other tax planning and compliance issues,
including responding to audit inquiries from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).s
As Chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, which has oversight jurisdiction of matters
pertaining to federal taxation, I seek more information related to the extraordinary compensation
Black paid Epstein for a so-called "proprietary" tax avoidance solution Epstein developed for
Black. Despite not being a certified public accountant or licensed tax attorney, it appears that
Epstein was paid an amount that far exceeded what Black paid other professional advisors,
including some of the most high-priced legal counsel in the nation.' In light of Epstein's role in a
sprawling human trafficking scheme, it is important to understand why Epstein's compensation
arrangement was substantially different than that typically afforded to professional advisors
involved in trust, estate and tax planning. Accordingly, please provide answers to the following
questions no later than July 9, 2022:

1. Has Apollo retained all documents related to the memorandum titled "Investigation Of
Epstein/Black Relationship And Any Relationship Between Epstein and Apollo Global
Management, Inc." prepared by Dechert LLP for the Apollo Conflicts Committee? If not,
what individual or entity currently has custody of those documents? Has Apollo
'Jeffrey Epstein Charged In Manhattan Federal Court With Sex Trafficking Of Minors, U.S. Department of Justice,
Jul. 8, 2019, httus:/Avwwjustice.gov/usao-sdnv/pr/jeffrev-enstein-charged-manhattan-federal-court-sex-trafficking-
minors
Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation Of Epstein/Black Relationship And Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1411494/0001 I 93 I 2521016405/d118102dex99 .htm

Id. at pg. 3: "As a result of Epstein's work, Black believed, and witnesses generally agreed, that Epstein provided
advice that conferred more than $1 billion and as much as $2 billion or more in value to Black."
7 Id. at pg. 10: "Epstein approached Black with his solution — which Epstein asserted was proprietary — and Black
agreed to pay Epstein to implement this solution. Outside legal counsel described the solution as a 'grand slam' and
one that met all of Black's financial and estate planning goals."
Id.

Id. at pg. 17: "It is clear that the compensation paid by Black to Epstein far exceeded any amounts Black paid to
his other professional advisors."
transferred control of these documents to Leon Black, his family office (Elysium
Management, LLC) or any other individuals or entities operating on Mr. Black's behalf?

2. The report claims that "Many witnesses believed that Epstein had creative ideas that no
other advisor had proposed." Please elaborate on how this conclusion was reached and
describe in detail the "creative ideas" proposed by Epstein. Please also describe how
solutions developed by Epstein related to tax matters differed from those offered by
licensed tax attorneys, certified public accountants or other professional advisors engaged
by Black for his estate and family office.

3. The report claims that "As a result of Epstein's work, Black believed, and witnesses
generally agreed, that Epstein provided advice that conferred more than $1 billion and as
much as $2 billion or more in value to Black." Please describe how this conclusion was
reached, including a detailed description of any taxes avoided by Black or his heirs and
beneficiaries that were included as part of this valuation. Please also provide any
documents supporting the claim that Epstein provided value between $1 - $2 billion to
Black, including as they relate to Mr. Black's taxes.

4. The report claims that "in 2013, payments (to Epstein) were memorialized in signed and
unsigned agreements." Please provide copies of any compensation agreements signed
between Mr. Black and Mr. Epstein. Please also describe any "unsigned agreements"
between Mr. Black and Mr. Epstein where Mr. Epstein was compensated for work related
to trust and estate planning, tax issues, issues relating to artwork, Black's airplane,
Black's yacht, and other similar matters.

5. The report claims that Epstein and Black negotiated a "written service agreement" that
was signed on February 13, 2013. Please provide a copy of this agreement, as well as any
documents related to payments made by Black to Epstein as a result of this agreement.
These documents should include any statements of work or descriptions of the services
rendered by Epstein for Black related to payments made under the agreement.

6. The report claims that Black paid Epstein $56.5 million in five installment payments over
2013 and 2014 as part of an agreement that was never signed. The agreement was
apparently renegotiated and the total amount paid was apparently $50 million. Please
provide all documents related to payments made by Black to Epstein resulting from this
unsigned agreement, including any statements of work or descriptions of the services
rendered by Epstein as part of the agreement.

7. The report claims that starting in 2014, Black began to pay Epstein for his ongoing
services on an ad hoc basis, without negotiating written service agreements. As part of
this, Black paid Epstein $70 million in 2014 and $30 million in 2015. Please provide all
documents related to payments made by Black to Epstein in 2014 and 2015, including
any statements of work or descriptions of services rendered by Epstein related to his work
on the step-up-basis transaction and estate, tax planning, tax audits and filings, or any
other advice provided by Epstein to Black.

8. The report claims that "it is clear the compensation paid by Black to Epstein far
exceeded any amounts Black paid to his other professional advisors." Please explain how
Dechert LLP made this assessment. Please also provide documents showing how
Epstein's compensation compared to other professional advisors, including attorneys
providing tax, trust and estate planning services and certified public accountants who
assisted Black with tax matters.

9. The report claims that "after 2013 payments were made by Mr. Black to Mr. Epstein on
an ad hoc basis based on Black's perceived value of Epstein's work." Please provide a
detailed description of how Black decided compensation amounts for Epstein, including
any documentation of trust and estate planning and tax consulting services rendered by
Epstein for Black.

10. The report claims that from 2013 through 2017, Black was under the misconception that
his payments to Epstein would be tax-deductible, based on advice from Epstein. Please
describe whether Black claimed income tax deductions for Epstein's compensation for
any taxable year during this period, and why it was determined that such payments were
nondeductible. Please also describe whether Black amended his tax returns after learning
that the payments to Epstein were not tax-deductible. Please also include all
substantiation documents with respect to any income tax deductions previously claimed
by Black. Please also describe whether any payments from Black to Epstein were
characterized as gifts for tax purposes, and please provide any documents, including tax
returns, related to any reportable gifts made to Epstein.

11. The report claims that Epstein provided Black with a "proprietary" solution that would
resolve a "problem" with a Grantor Retained Annuity Trust established in 2006 ("2006
GRAT") by Black in order to transfer assets to his beneficiaries without paying estate
taxes. The report also indicates that the value of the estate tax liability if this issue had not
been resolved could have been $1 billion or more. While GRATs are a tax avoidance
technique that raise serious public policy concerns, they are routinely used by estate tax
planners and have been upheld by federal courts and IRS guidance. Please describe the
solution to this 2006 GRAT issue proposed by Jeffrey Epstein and the work done by
Epstein for the family office to resolve the matter. Please also provide all documents
obtained by Dechert LLP as part of its investigation in relation to Epstein's work related
to the 2006 GRAT.

12. The report claims that Epstein provided "significant value" related to a transaction that
addressed certain loans between Black and certain family trusts for the purpose of
achieving a potential tax benefit for Black's children. It appears Epstein estimated that
this transaction saved Black $600 million in taxes. Please provide a detailed description
of the role Epstein played in planning and executing this transaction, including the advice
Epstein provided Black related to the transaction. Please also provide a detailed
description and documentation supporting the estimate of $600 million in value of the
transaction for Mr. Black.

13. The report claims that Epstein provided "ongoing advice on a variety of issues to Black's
estate." This included establishing additional GRATs and tax planning. Please provided a
detailed description of the "tax planning" advice Epstein provided Black, including as
they relate to the following matters:

a. Addressing an IRS audit letter relating to the 2013 tax year;
b. Addressing an IRS audit letter regarding Black's 2012 tax filings, including
interfacing with the IRS to achieve a positive resolution; and

c. Planning and coordinating the submission of statements of reasonable cause for a
series of tax years to address an apparent failure to file certain tax forms,
including IRS Forms 8865, relating to Black's interests in BRH Holdings L.P., a
partnership through which Black and the other Apollo co-founders hold their
ownership interests in Apollo and related foreign partnerships.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
Ron Wyden
United States Senator
Chairman, Committee on
Finance
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Dan Dubno [journalist] producer and technologist for CBS News in New York [edge] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01653121 (Jmail)
 [government] letter from FBI to USCIS regarding an individual's cooperation in the investigation of Epstein and Maxwell
(inferred date: 2022-06-28)
U.S. Department ofJustice
Federal Bureau of Investigation
In Reply, Please Refer to 26 Federal Plaza
File No. 50D-NY-3027571
USCIS
38 River Road
Essex Junction, Vermont 05479
Attention: Humanitarian Division
New York, New York 10278
August 9, 2022
RE: : Continuous physical presence in the United States for criminal investigation
Dear USCIS:
cooperated in a federal investigation regarding Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.
In or about February of 2021, counsel, Erica Dubno, informed our office of intent to
depart briefly from the United States solely in connection with an E-2 visa, which had been issued
bearing a March 25, 2021 expiration date. was in lawful E-2 status at the time and eligible to extend that
status. She did not require our direct sponsorship to return to the United States by lawful means.
We informed that she was required to return after the departure and that she was expected to be available
and physically present in the United States in connection with our ongoing investigation. She assured us of her
continued participation in the investigation upon her return. did in fact return on February 15, 2021,
resuming her cooperation in the investigation of Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.
Elm Assistant Special Agent in Charge
Supplement B, Delaration of Law Enforcement Officer for
Victim of Trafficking in Persons
Department of Homeland Security
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
USCIS
Form 1-914
OMB No. 1615-0099
Expires 12/3112023
START HERE - Type or print in ink. This form should be completed by Federal, state,
local, or tribal law enforcement agencies for victims under the Victims of Trafficking and
Violence Protection Act (VTVPA), Public Law 106-386, as amended.
PART 1. Victim Information

I. Full Legal Namc
Family Name (Last Name) Given Name (First Name) Middle Name (if any)
2. Other Names Used
Provide any other names you have used since birth, including aliases, maiden names,
and nicknames. If you need extra space to complete this section, use the space
provided in Part 9. Additional Information.
Family Name (Last Name) Given Namc (First Name) Middle Name (if any)
3.
5.
6.
Date of Birth (dd/mm/yyyy) 4. Gender or Sex
❑ Male ❑X Female ❑ Other
Alien Registration Number (A-Number) (if any)
► A-
U.S. Social Security Number (SSN) (if any)
Part 2. Agency Information

I. Name of Certifying Agency
Federal Bureau of Investigations
2. Namc of Certifying Official
'Amanda Young

3. Title of Certifying Official
Special Agent
4. Division/Office of Certifying Official
'New York Field Office

5. Agency Mailing Address
Street Number and Name
For USCIS Use Only
Returned
Date
Date
Resubmitted
Date
Date
Reloc Sent
Date
Date
Reloc Rec'd
Date
Date
Receipt
Remarks
26 Federal Plaza
City or Town
New York
IMPS ZIP Co* Loging2
Apt. Ste. Flr.
State
NY

6. Daytime Telephone Number 7. Fax Number
Number
ZIP Code
10278
Form 1-914. Supplement B Edition 12/02/21 Page
Part 2. Agency Information (continued)

8. Agency Type
0 Federal
9. Case Status
0 On-going
D State
0 Completed
D Local 0 Tribal
10. Certifying Agency Category
❑ Judge 0 Law Enforcement O Prosecutor 0 Other

II. Case Number 12. FBI or SID Number
Part 3. Statement of Claim
1. The applicant is or has been a victim of a severe form of trafficking in persons. Specifically, he or she is a victim
of: (Select all
that apply. Base your analysis on the victimization the applicant experienced rather than on the specific violations 
charged, the
counts on which convictions were obtained, or whether any prosecution resulted in convictions. Note that the definitions
that
control this analysis are not the elements of criminal offenses, but arc those set forth at 8 CFR 214.11(a).)
Sex trafficking in which a commercial sex act was induced by force, fraud, or coercion. Sex trafficking means the
0 recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, obtaining, patronizing, or soliciting of a person for the purpose 
of a
commercial sex act.
0 Sex trafficking and the victim is under 18 years of age.
RA The recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, or obtaining of a person for labor or services through the use
of force,
r=  fraud, or coercion for subjection to involuntary servitude, peonage, debt bondage, or slavery.
0 Other, specify on attached additional sheets.

2. Please describe the victimization the applicant's claim is based on and identify the relationship between that 
victimization and
the crime investigated or prosecuted. Attach the results of any name or database inquiry performed in the investigation 
of the
case, as well as any relevant reports and findings. Include relevant dates, etc. Attach additional sheets, if necessary.
Applicant was recruited, harbored, and obtained by Jeffrey Epstein and others for
purposes of a coercive sexual relationship. On numerous occasions, Jeffrey Epstein
coerced, threatened, and forced Applicant into submission for purposes of him
committing sex acts with or unto her. Applicant shared pictures of injuries she
sustained as a result of physical abuse/encounters with Mr. Epstein.

3. las the applicant expressed any fear of retaliation or revenge if removed from the United States? If yes, explain. 
Attach
additional sheets, if necessary.
Applicant informed us that she and some of her family members in their native
Slovakia, directly and indirectly, have received threats during Applicant's
participation in the investigation and prosecution of criminal charges against
suspects/defendants Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. Applicant expressed fear
of retaliation or revenge by individuals connected to or implicated in the alleged
criminal acts of Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell. Applicant has expressed fear of serious
harm by such individuals if she were to be removed from the United States.
Form 1-914, Supplement B Edition 12/02/21 Page 2
Part 3. Statement of Claim (Continued)

4. Provide the date(s) on which the acts of trafficking occurred.
Date (mm/dd/yyyy)
Not. X03-2018 Date (mm/dd/yyyy)  Date (mm/dd/yyyy) Date (mm/dd/yyyy)

5. List the statutory citation(s) for the acts of trafficking being investigated or prosecuted, or that were 
investigated or prosecuted.
18 USC 371; 18 USC 1591(a), (b); 18 USC 1623; USC 2423(a) ; NYPL 130.55

6. Provide the date on which the investigation or prosecution was initiated.
Date (mm/dd/yyyy)
12/06/2018

7. Provide the date on which the investigation or prosecution was completed.
Date (mm/dd/yyyy)
06/28/2022
Part 4. Cooperation of Victim
The applicant:
RA Has complied with requests for assistance in the investigation/prosecution of the crime of trafficking. (If you 
select
' .I Item A., provide an explanation below in Item Number 2.)
B u .—. Has failed to comply with requests to assist in the investigation/prosecution of the crime of trafficking. (If 
you select
Item B., provide an explanation below in Item Number 2.)

C. El Has not been requested to assist in the investigation/prosecution of any crime of trafficking.
D. ❑ Has not yet attained the age of 18.
A.

E. El Other, specify on attached additional sheets.
2. If you selected Item A. or Item B. above, provide an explanation for your selection.
participated in several telephonic and in person meetings with our
office concerning our investigation of criminal charges against Jeffrey Epstein and
Ghislaine Maxwell. responded to questions asked of her about alleged
criminal activities by Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell.
Part 5. Family Members Implicated In Trafficking
Arc any of the applicant's family members believed to have been involved in his or her trafficking to the United States?
❑yes El No
If you answered "Yes" to Item Number I., list the relative(s) and describe the involvement. Attach additional sheets if
necessary.
Full Name Relationship Involvement
N/A N/A N/A
N/A N/A N/A
N/A N/A N/A
N/A N/A N/A
Fonn 1414, Supplement B Edition 12/02/21 Page 3
Part 6. Attestation
Based upon investigation of the facts, I certify, under penalty of perjury, that the above noted individual is or has 
been a victim of a
severe form of trafficking in persons as defined by the VTVPA. I certify that the above information is true and correct 
to the best of
my knowledge, and that I have made, and will make, no promises regarding the above victim's ability to obtain a visa 
from U.S.
Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), based upon this certification. I further certify that if the victim 
refuses to comply with
reasonable requests for assistance in the investigation or prosecution of the acts of trafficking of which he/she is a 
victim, I will notify
USCIS.

I. Sjgnature of Law Enforcement Officer (identified in Part 2.)
0
2. i of Supervisor of Certifying Officer S

3. Printed Name of Supervisor
(rice
Date of Si ture (mm/ddlyyyy)
Oa re la-o9 Date of Si ture (mm/dd/yyyy)
cZro IQ a
Form I-914. Supplement 8 Edition 12102/21 Page 4
EFTA00128750 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip from Reynaldo Clark about Epstein bribing USVI elected officials
(date: 2022-10-24)
OFFICIAL RECORD FD-1057 (Rcv. 5-8-10)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Electronic Communication

Title: (U) Guardian 872616_SJ Date: 10/24/2022
From: SAN JUAN
.       SJ-ST THOMAS RA
.       Contact:
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 1948-SJ-3673194 (U) Public Corruption and Money Laundering in St Thomas
.                          SENSITIVE INVESTIGATIVE MATTER
Synopsis: (U) Public Corruption and Money Laundering in St Thomas

Details: REYNALDO CLARK, date of birt telephone
came to the FBI St Thomas RA to report public corruption involving
members of the VI Legislature, Governor ALBERT BRYAN, Port Authority
Director CARLTON DOWE, Attorney ARTURO WATLINGTON, and former governor
JOHN DEJONGH.

Title: (U) Guardian 872616_5J
Re: 194E-SJ-3673194, 10/24/2022
JEFFREY EPSTEIN paid off CARLTON DOWE in order to push through the
construction of the new STANDARD AVIATION hanger on St Thomas. EPSTEIN
wanted to be able to park his private jet inside of a hanger when he and
his guests would arrive and depart.
╔═══════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 OCC [government] Office of the Comptroller of the Currency 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00161836 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in US Virgin Islands v. JPMorgan Chase
EFTA00151754 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about declaration of Law Enforcement Officer for Victim of Trafficking
(inferred date: 2023-01-31)
Supplement 8, Delaration of Law Enforcement Officer for
Victim of Trafficking in Persons
Department of Homeland Security
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
USCIS
Form 1-914
OMBNo.1615-0099
Expires 1//31/2023
START HERE - Type or print in ink. This form should be completed by Federal, state.
local, or tribal law enforcement agencies for victims under the Victims of Trafficking and
Violence Protection Act (VTVPA). Public Law 106-386, as amended.
PART 1. Victim Information

I. Full Legal Name
Family Name (Last Name) Given Maine (Pint Name)  Middle Name (if any)
2. Other Names Used
Provide any other names you have used since birth, including aliases. maiden names.
and nicknames. If you need extra space to complete this section. use the space
provided in Part 9. Additional Information.
Family Name (Last Name) Given Name (First Name) Middle Name (if any)

3. Date of Binh (dd/mm/yyyy) 4. Gender or Sex
02/21/1985 ❑ Male Female ❑ Other
5. Alien Registration
lo• A-
Number (A-Number) (if any)

6. U.S. Social Security Number (SSN) (if any)
Part 2. Agency Information
I.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Name of Certifying Agency
Federal Bureau of Investigations
Name of Cenifying Of ficial
Title of Certifying Official
Special Agent
Division/Office of Certifying Official
New York Field Office
Agency Mailing Address
Street Number and Name
26 Federal Plaza
City or Town
New York
Daytime Telephone Number 7. Fax Number
For USCIS Use Only
Returned
Date
Date
Resubmitted
Date
Date
Reloc Sent
Date
Date
Reloe Rec'd
Date
Date
Receipt
Remarks
amszitssies
Apt. Ste. Flr. Number
El
State ZIP Code
NY 10278
Form 1-914. Supplement B Edition 12/0281 Page I
Part 2. Agency Information (continued)

8. Agency Type
Federal O State O Local O Tribal
9. Case Status
O On-going El Completed
10. Certifying Agency Category
O Judge Law Enforcement O Prosecutor O Other

11. Case Number 12. FBI or SID Number
Part 3. Statement of Claim
The applicant is or has been a victim of a severe form of trafficking in persons. Specifically, he or she is a victim 
of: (Select all
that apply. Base your analysis on the victimization the applicant experienced rather than on the specific violations 
charged, the
counts on which convictions were obtained, or whether any prosecution resulted in convictions. Note that the definitions
that
control this analysis are not the elements of criminal offenses, but are those set forth at 8 CFR 214.11(a).)
Sex trafficking in which a commercial sex act was induced by force, fraud, or coercion. Sex trafficking means the
O recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, obtaining, patronizing, or soliciting of a person for the purpose 
of a
commercial sex act.
O Sex trafficking and the victim is under 18 years of age.
iv  The recruitment, harboring, transportation, provision, or obtaining of a person for labor or services through the 
use of force,
fraud, or coercion for subjection to involuntary servitude, peonage, debt bondage, or slavery.
O Other, specify on attached additional sheets.

2. Please describe the victimization the applicant's claim is based on and identify the relationship between that 
victimization and
the crime investigated or prosecuted. Attach the results of any name or database inquiry performed in the investigation 
of the
case, as well as any relevant reports and findings. Include relevant dates, etc. Attach additional sheets, if necessary.
Applicant was recruited, harbored, and obtained by Jeffrey Epstein and others for
purposes of a coercive sexual relationship. On numerous occasions, Jeffrey Epstein
coerced, threatened, and forced Applicant into submission for purposes of him
committing sex acts with or unto her. Applicant shared pictures of injuries she
sustained as a result of physical abuse/encounters with Mr. Epstein.

3. Has the applicant expressed any fear of retaliation or revenge if removed from the United States? If yes, explain. 
Attach
additional sheets, if necessary.
Applicant informed us that she and some of her family members in their native
directly and indirectly, have received threats during Applicant's
participation in the investigation and prosecution of criminal charges against
suspects/defendants Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. Applicant expressed fear
of retaliation or revenge by individuals connected to or implicated in the alleged
criminal acts of Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell. Applicant has expressed fear of serious
harm by such individuals if she were to be removed from the United States.
Form I-914, Supplement El Edition 12/02/21 Page 2
Part 3. Statement of Claim (Continued)

4. Provide the date(s) on which the acts of trafficking occurred.
Date (mm/dd/yyyy)  Date (mm/dd/yyyy)
jApput- 2003-20(8

5. List the statutory citation(s) for the acts of trafficking being investigated or prosecuted, or that were 
investigated or prosecuted.
Date (mm/dd/yyyy) Date (mm/ddlyyyy)
18 USC 371; 18 USC 1591(a) , (b) ; 18 USC 1623; USC 2423(a) ; NYPL 130.55

6. Provide the date on which the investigation or prosecution was initiated.
Date (mm/dd/yyyy)
12/06/2018

7. Provide the date on which the investigation or prosecution was completed.
Date (mm/dd/yyyy)
06/28/2022
Part 4. Cooperation of Victim

I. The applicant:
Has complied with requests for assistance in the investigation/prosecution of the crime of trafficking. (If you select 
A. 2 7j Item A., provide an explanation
below in Item Number 2.)
B ri  Has failed to comply with requests to assist in the invcstigation/prosecution of the crime of trafficking. (If you
select
Item B., provide an explanation below in Item Number 2.)

C. ❑ Has not been requested to assist in the investigation/prosecution of any crime of trafficking.
D. 0 Has not yet attained the age of 18.

E. ❑ Other, specify on attached additional sheets.
2. If you selected Item A. or Item B. above, provide an explanation for your selection.
participated in several telephonic and in person meetings with our
office concerning our investigation of criminal charges against Jeffrey Epstein and
Ghislaine Maxwell. III responded to questions asked of her about alleged
criminal activities by Mr. Epstein and Ms. Maxwell.
Part 5. Family Members Implicated In Trafficking

1. Are any of the applicant's family members believed to have been involved in his or her trafficking to the United 
States?
El yes No
If you answered "Yes" to Item Number I., list the relative(s) and describe the involvement. Attach additional sheets if
necessary.
Full Name Relationship Involvement
N/A N/A N/A
N/A N/A N/A
N/A N/A N/A
N/A N/A N/A
Form 1.914, Supplement B Edition 12/02/21 Pagc 3
Part 6. Attestation
Based upon investigation of the facts, I certify, under penalty of perjury, that the above noted individual is or has 
been a victim of a
severe form of trafficking in persons as defined by the VTVPA. I certify that the above information is true and correct 
to the best of
my knowledge, and that I have made, and will make, no promises regarding the above victim's ability to obtain a visa 
from U.S.
Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), based upon this certification. I further certify that if the victim 
refuses to comply with
reasonable requests for assistance in the investigation or prosecution of the acts of trafficking of which he/she is a 
victim, I will notify
USCIS.
ntified in Part 2.)
Cr
Date of Signature (mm/dcliyyyy)
og ro
Date of Si nature (mmiddiyyyY)
CZ( O/a?,
Form 1-914, Supplement B Edition 12/02/21 Page 4
EFTA00145666 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in US Virgin Islands v. JPMorgan Chase
EFTA00129013 (Jmail)
 [legal] Virgin Islands Daily News JP Morgan calls Cecile de Jongh Epstein's local fixer
EFTA00129016 (Jmail)
 [article] Virgin Islands Daily News
(inferred date: 2023-05-26)
Friday,
May
26,
2023
very
projects

f. . John
is
currently
mitigated
with
a steel
plate.
The
!king
to
rehabilitate
sections
of
the
road.
heard
on
onal
Park
ehabilitatc mon
Bay
of
Honey-
;outhwest. House,
an
t between !aches. nent
fail-
s threaten suit
in
a
sections construe
-
aid
Kim
second
area
of
erosion.
The
project
will
involve
instal-
lation
of
a
mechanically
stabilized
earth
retaining
wall
at
one
site,
and
installation
of
a rock
face
trapezoi-
dal
rockery
wall
at
the
second
site.
In
response
to
questioning
from
St.
John
CZM
Committee
member
Rafe
Boulon,
Campo
-Allen
said
native
stone
will
be
used,
and
the
rockery
wall's
facade
was
chosen
with
the
viewshed
in
mind.
Campo
-Allen
said
there
are
known
archaeological
sites
close
to,
but
not
at,
the
two
failing
sections
of
road
-
Friday,
May
26,
2023
VIRGIN
ISLANDS
The
Virgin
Islands
Daily
News
3

44

Epstein's
primary
conduit
for
spreading
money
and
influence
throughout
the
USVI
government
was
First
Lady
deJongh.
—
Court
documents
filed
by
JPMorgan
Chase
lawyers
Court
filing
claims
ex-first
lady
was
Epstein's
local
fixer
By
SUZANNE
CARLSON
Daily
News
Staff
A
court
filing
by
lawyers
for
JPMorgan
Chase
accuses
former
Vir-
gin
Islands
first
lady
Cecile
deJongh
of
facilitating
Jeffrey
Epstein's
abuse
of
women
and
girls
by
helping
him
influence
local
politicians,
and
says
deJongh
even
asked
Epstein
to
suggest
changes
to
the
territory's
sex
offender
"Epstein's
primary
conduit
for
spreading
money
and
influence
throughout
the
USVI
government
was
First
Lady
deJongh"
who
worked
as
Epuein's
local
fixer
for
two
decades.
including
throughout
her
husband
John
deJongh
1cs
tenure
as
V.I.
gover-
nor
from
2007
to
2015.
according
to
the
filing. DeJongh
told
Epstein
which
govern-
ment
officials
to
pay
oft',
and
devised
ways
to
jlaify
his
victims'
presence
in
the
territory
by
enrolling
them
at
the
University
of
the
Virgin
Islands
so
they
could
obtain
student
visas,
according
to
the
filing.
In
a statement
to
The
Daily
News
on
Th
ursday,
UVI
President
David
Hall
denied
all
allegations
in
the
bank's
filing. Attorneys
for
the
bank
say
docu-
ments
obtained
during
the
discovery
process,
which
is
still
ongoing,
show
that
deiongh
asked
Epstein
—
a
registered
sex
offender
- to
suggest
tr.
duo
territory%
sex
offender
Former
first
lady
Cecile
deJongh
and
her
husband,
former
Gov.
John
deJongh
Jr.
!cording
to
the
tiling.
"Lest
there
be
doubt
that
Epstein's
goal
was
to
gain
influence,
First
Lady
deJongh
explicitly
advised
Epstein
on
how
to
buy
control
of
the
USVI
political
class:"
according
to
the
filing.
telling
him
"how
to
vote
and
whom
to
he
would
'support
[then-USVI
sena-
tor]
Carlton
Dome's
bid
to
go
hick
to
VIPA'
who
would
be
a 'good
person
for
us'
there."
Prior
to
his
election,
Go'
Albert
Bryan
Jr.,
in
2018.
also
"facilitated
do-
nations
by
Epstein
to
USVI's
schools
little
le:woes:sand
Epstein
also
lawsuit
filed
by
the
V.I.
Justice
Depart-
ment
in
the
U.S.
District
Court
for
the
Southern
District
of
New
York.
The
government
has
accused
the
bank
of
facilitating
and
profiting
from
Epsteins
crimes.
But
attorneys
for
the
bank
say
the
government
provided
a
safe
haven
for
Epstein
and
allowed
Who
knew
what,
when?
In
the
ongoing
civil
case,
the
bank
has
asserted
several
affirmative
de-
fenses.
including
that
the
VI.
govern-
ment
has
"unclean
hands"
because
of
officials'
dealings
with
Epstein.
The
V.I.
government
has
asked
the
court
to
deny
certain
affirmative
defenses.
Rut
Ellsworth
responded
in
the
bank's
latest
filing
that
it's
the
V.I.
government
that
bears
responsibility
for
enabling
Epstein's
crimes.
"To
grant
USVI
immunity
from
these
defenses
would
be
to
allow
it to
profit
from
Epstein
twice:
first
directly,
then
again
in
a civil
suit
which
it could
just
as
easily
see
reflected
in
a inimx,"
according
to
the
filing.
A judge
has
not
yet
ruled
on
the
dispute
over
affirmative
defenses.
Meanwhile,
the
bank's
lawyers
are
naming
Cecile
de
Jongh
and
other
Virgin
Islanders
as
key
parties
respon-
sible
for
helping
Epstein
thrive
in
the
territory,
despite
his
status
as
a sex
of-
fender
convicted
of
procuring
children
for
prostitution
in
Florida
in
2008.
The
V.I.
Justice
Department
is
re-
sponsible
for
monitoring
sex
offenders
in
the
territory,
including
Epstein.
who
claimed
Little
St.
James
island
off
St.
Thomas
as
his
primary
residence
for
tuo
decades
before
his
August
2019
suicide.
Several
sections
of
Ellsworth's
filing
that
remain
partially
redacted
refer
to
the
territory's
lack
of
enforcement
of
EFTA00039025 (Jmail)
 [government] Bureau of Prisons report on death of Jeffrey Epstein
(date: 2023-06-22)
Investigation and Review of the Federal Bureau of
Prisons' Custody, Care, and Supervision of Jeffrey
Epstein at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in
New York, New York
* * *
INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
23-085
JUNE 2023
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Investigation and Review of the Federal Bureau of
Prisons' Custody, Care, and Supervision of Jeffrey
Epstein at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in
New York, New York
Introduction and Background
According to its website, the Federal Bureau of Prisons
(BOPys current mission statement is "Corrections
professionals who foster a humane and secure
environment and ensure public safety by preparing
individuals for successful reentry into our
communities? However, the Department ofJustice
(DOJ) Office of the Inspector General (OIG) has
repeatedly identified long-standing operational
challenges that negatively affect the BOP's ability to
operate its institutions safely and securely. Many of
those same operational challenges, including staffing
shortages, managing inmates at risk for suicide,
functional security camera systems, and management
failures and widespread disregard of BOP policies and
procedures, were again identified by the OIG during
this investigation and review into the custody, care, and
supervision of one of the BOP's most notorious
inmates, Jeffrey Epstein.
The OIG initiated this investigation upon receipt of
information from the BOP that on August 10, 2019, in
the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York,
New York (MCC New York), Epstein was found hanged
in his assigned cell within the Special Housing Unit
(SHU). The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner,
City of New York, determined that Epstein had died
by suicide.
The OIG conducted this investigation jointly with the
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), with the OIG's
investigative focus being the conduct of BOP personnel.
Among other things, the FBI investigated the cause of
Epstein's death and determined there was no
criminality pertaining to how Epstein had died.
This report concerns the OIG's findings regarding MCC
New York personnel's custody, care, and supervision of
Epstein while detained at the facility from his arrest on
federal sex trafficking charges on July 6, 2019, until his
death on August 10.
Epstein is Assigned to the SHU on July 7
Epstein was assigned to a cell in the SHU on July 7 due
to media coverage of his case and inmate awareness of
his notoriety. SHU inmates are securely separated
from general population inmates and kept locked in
their cells for approximately 23 hours a day.
BOP policy requires SHU staff to observe all inmates at
least twice an hour and that Lieutenants conduct at
least one round in the SHU each shift. BOP policy also
requires multiple inmate counts during every 24-hour
period. Among other things, inmate counts and rounds
enable BOP staff to observe inmates and ensure they
are secure in their cells and in good health. Further, to
eliminate safety hazards, MCC New York requires SHU
staff to search SHU common areas and at least five cells
daily, and to search the entire SHU every week.
On July 18, the court refused to set bail for Epstein and
ordered him detained pending trial on the
criminal charges.
Incident Involving Epstein on July 23
While in MCC New York, Epstein was screened on
numerous occasions by psychological staff, including a
formal suicide assessment on July 9. In the evaluations
he denied having thoughts or a history of attempted
suicide. Psychological staff determined Epstein did not
meet the criteria for a psychological diagnosis.
On July 23, at 1:27 a.m., correctional officers (CO)
responded to Epstein's SHU cell where they found
Epstein with an orange cloth around his neck. Epstein's
cellmate told officers Epstein tried to hang himself.
Medical staff examined Epstein, observed friction
marks and superficial reddening around his neck and
on his knee, and placed him on suicide watch. BOP
policy requires that inmates identified as suicide risks
be placed on suicide watch until no longer at imminent
risk. The BOP uses a less restrictive monitoring form,
psychological observation, for Inmates who are
stabilizing but not yet ready to return to a housing unit.
Epstein was removed from suicide watch on July 24 but
remained under psychological observation until July 30.
Epstein first told MCC New York staff he thought his
cellmate had tried to kill him, but later said he did not
know what occurred and did not want to talk about
how he had sustained his injuries. Epstein also later
asked if he could be housed with the same cellmate.
Mother inmate housed on the same SHU tier told the
016 that he heard Epstein's cellmate call for assistance,
and that Epstein's cellmate told him that Epstein tried
to hang himself from the bunkbed ladder. Disciplinary
charges against Epstein for alleged self-mutilation were
not sustained due to insufficient evidence.
Following the July 23 incident, the Psychology
Department determined Epstein needed to be housed
with an appropriate cellmate, and on July 30 it sent an
email to over 70 MCC New York employees informing
them of this requirement. The Warden at the time told
the OIG that he selected a new cellmate for Epstein in
consultation with BOP executive leadership. That
inmate remained Epstein's cellmate until August 9.
Events of August 8-10, 2019, and
Epstein's Death
On August 8, the U.S. Marshals Service sent two emails
notifying numerous MCC New York staff that Epstein's
cellmate was being transferred to another facility on
August 9. However, no action was taken to ensure
Epstein was assigned another cellmate.
Also on August 8, Epstein met with his attorneys at the
prison, as he had on prior occasions, and signed a new
Last Will and Testament. MCC New York officials did
not learn about the new Will until after Epstein's death.
The following day, August 9, Epstein's cellmate was
transferred to another facility and he was not assigned
a new cellmate. Additionally, on that date, the
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit unsealed
approximately 2,000 pages of documents in civil
litigation involving Ghislaine Maxwell, who was later
convicted in December 2021 of conspiring with Epstein
to sexually abuse minors over the course of a decade.
The documents contain substantial derogatory
Information about Epstein and there is extensive media
coverage of information in the unsealed documents.
Also on August 9, after meeting at the prison with his
lawyers, MCC New York staff allowed Epstein to make,
in violation of BOP policy, an unrecorded, unmonitored
telephone call before he was returned to his SHU cell.
Although Epstein said he was calling his mother, in
actuality he called someone with whom he allegedly
had a personal relationship.
At approximately 8 p.m. on August 9, SHU inmates
were locked in their cells for the night, including Epstein
who was without a cellmate. A search of Epstein's cell
following his death revealed Epstein had excess prison
blankets, linens, and clothing in his cell, and that some
had been ripped to create nooses. Only one SHU cell
search was documented on August 9, and it was not of
Epstein's cell. BOP records did not Indicate when
Epstein's cell was last searched. The 016 also found
that SHU staff did not conduct any 30-minute rounds
after about 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and that none of the
required SHU Inmate counts were conducted after
4 p.m. on August 9. Count slips and round sheets were
falsified to show that they had been performed.
On August 10, at approximately 6:30 a.m., the two SHU
staff on duty, CO Tova Noel and Material Handler
Michael Thomas, began delivering breakfast to SHU
Inmates. Noel unlocked the door to Epstein's SHU tier.
When Thomas attempted to deliver breakfast to
Epstein through the food slot in his locked cell door,
Epstein did not respond to Thomas's verbal commands.
Thomas unlocked the cell door and saw Epstein
hanged. Thomas immediately yelled for Noel to get
help and call for a medical emergency.
Thomas told the OIG that when he entered Epstein's
cell, Epstein had an orange string, presumably from a
sheet or a shirt, around his neck that was tied to the
top portion of the bunkbed. Epstein was suspended
from the top bunk in a near-seated position, with his
buttocks approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half off
the floor. Thomas said he immediately ripped the
orange string from the bunkbed, and Epstein's buttocks
dropped to the ground. Thomas then lowered Epstein's
body to the floor and began chest compressions until
responding MCC New York staff members arrived
approximately 1 minute later. Shortly thereafter,
outside medical personnel arrived and took over the
emergency response, eventually removing Epstein to a
local hospital where he was pronounced dead.
On August 11, 2019, the Office of the Chief Medical
Examiner performed an autopsy and determined the
ii
cause of death was hanging and the manner of death
was suicide. Blood toxicology tests did not reveal any
medications or illegal substances in Epstein's system.
The Medical Examiner who performed the autopsy told
the OIG that Epstein's injuries were consistent with
suicide by hanging and that there was no evidence of
defensive wounds that would be expected if his death
had been a homicide. Epstein did not have marks on
his hands, broken fingernails or debris under them,
contusions to his knuckles that would have evidenced a
fight, or, other than an abrasion on his arm likely due to
convulsing from hanging, bruising on his body.
The Limited Available Video Evidence
Recorded video evidence for August 9 and 10 for the
SHU area where Epstein was housed was only available
from one prison security camera due to a malfunction
of MCC New York's Digital Video Recorder system that
occurred on July 29, 2019. While the prison's cameras
continued to provide live video feeds, recordings were
made for only about half the cameras. MCC New York
personnel discovered this failure on August 8, 2019, but
it was not repaired until after Epstein's death. As
detailed in this report, like many other BOP facilities,
MCC New York had a history of security
camera problems.
The available recorded video footage from the one SHU
camera captured a large pan of the common area of
the SHU and portions of the stairways leading to the
different SHU tiers, Including Epstein's cell tier. Thus,
anyone entering or attempting to enter Epstein's SHU
tier from the SHU common area would have been
picked up by that video camera. Epstein's cell door,
however, was not in the camera's field of view. The OIG
reviewed the video and found that, between
approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and about
6:30 a.m. on August 10, no one was seen entering
Epstein's cell tier from the SHU common area. The OIG
determined that movements captured on video before
and after those times were generally consistent with
employee actions as described by witnesses and
documented in BOP records.
Results of the OIG's Investigation and Review
The OIG's investigation and review identified numerous
and serious failures by MCC New York staff, Including
multiple violations of ma New York and BOP policies
and procedures. The OIG found that MCC New York
staff failed on August 9 to carry out the Psychology
Department's directive that Epstein be assigned a
cellmate, and that an MCC New York supervisor allowed
Epstein to make an unmonitored telephone call the
evening before his death. Additionally, we found that
staff failed to undertake required measures designed
to make sure that Epstein and other SHU inmates were
accounted for and safe, such as conducting inmate
counts and 30-minute rounds, searching inmate cells,
and ensuring adequate supervision of the SHU and the
functionality of the video camera surveillance system.
The 016 also found that several staff falsified BOP
records relating to inmate counts and rounds and
lacked candor during their OIG Interviews. Two MCC
New York employees, Noel and Thomas, were charged
criminally with falsifying BOP records. The charges
were later dismissed after they successfully fulfilled
deferred prosecution agreements. The U.S. Attorneys
Office for the Southern District of New York declined
prosecution for other MCC New York employees who
the OIG found created false documentation.
The combination of these and other failures led to
Epstein being unmonitored and alone in his cell, which
contained an excessive amount of bed linens, from
approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 until he was
discovered hanged in his locked cell the following day.
While the 016 determined MCC New York staff engaged
in significant misconduct, we did not uncover evidence
contradicting the FBI's determination regarding the
absence of criminality in connection with how Epstein
died. We did not find, for example, evidence that
anyone was present in the SHU area where Epstein was
housed during the relevant timeframe other than the
Inmates who were locked in their assigned cells. The
SHU housing unit was securely separated from the
general inmate population and Inmates were kept
locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day.
Access to the SHU was controlled by multiple locked
doors. Within the SHU, the entrance to each tier could
be accessed only via a single locked door at the top or
bottom of the staircase leading to the individual tier.
Keys to open the locked tier doors were available to a
limited number of COs while on duty. Each tier had
eight cells and each individual cell, which was made of
cement and metal, could be accessed only through a
single locked door, to which a limited number of COs
had keys while on duty. The SHU cell doors were made
of solid metal with a small glass window and small
locked slots that correctional staff used to handcuff
Inmates and provide food and toiletries to inmates. As
a further security measure, during each shift a limited
number of the COs had keys while on duty.
iii
SHU staff told the OIG that at approximately 8 p.m. on
August 9, all SHU inmates, including Epstein, were
locked in their cells for the evening and we found no
evidence to the contrary. The prison's recorded video
did not identify any staff or other individuals
approaching Epstein's SHU tier from the SHU common
area between approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9
and about 6:30 a.m. on August 10. Additionally, the
O16 did not observe on the recorded video that Noel
and Thomas, who were seated at the desk at the SHU
Officers' Station immediately outside the area where
Epstein was housed, at any time during the time period
rose from their seats or approached the cell block. We
additionally found that Thomas's and Noel's reaction on
the morning of August 10 upon finding Epstein hanging
in his cell, as described to us by Thomas, Noel, the
responding Lieutenant, and inmates, was consistent
with their being unaware of any potential harm to
Epstein prior to Thomas entering Epstein's cell at about
6:30 a.m. on August 10.
None of the MCC New York staff members we
interviewed were aware of any information suggesting
Epstein's cause of death was something other than
suicide. Additionally, none of the inmates we
interviewed had any credible information suggesting
Epstein's cause of death was something other than
suicide. Further, the SHU staff and three interviewed
inmates with a direct line of sight to Epstein's cell door
on the night of his death stated that no one entered or
exited Epstein's cell after the SHU staff returned Epstein
to his cell on August 9.
As noted, the surveillance camera in the SHU area
where Epstein was housed was live streaming
movement in the hallway outside of Epstein's cell.
Although the camera was not recording the captured
video, the camera was in plain view of the inmates and
therefore inmates would have been aware that any
hallway movements, including into or out of Epstein's
cell, could be monitored by BOP staff, even if,
unbeknownst to them, the DVR system was not
recording the live stream at that time. As the OIG has
noted in numerous prior reports, BOP staff and
inmates are aware of where prison cameras are located
and often engage in wrongdoing in locations where
they know cameras are not located.
We noted as well that Epstein had previously been
placed on suicide watch and psychological observation
due to the events of July 23, 2019; that numerous
nooses made from the excess prison sheets were
found in his cell on the morning of August 10; that no
weapons were recovered from his cell after his death;
and that he signed a new Last Will and Testament on
August 8, 2 days before he died. We found that the
staffs failure to assign Epstein a cellmate on August 9;
failure to conduct rounds and counts that evening; and
to allow him to have excess linens in his cell, left
Epstein unmonitored and locked alone in his cell for
hours, which provided him an opportunity to
commit suicide.
Finally, the Medical Examiner who performed the
autopsy detailed for the O16 why Epstein's injuries were
more consistent with, and indicative of, a suicide by
hanging rather than a homicide by strangulation. The
Medical Examiner also cited the absence of debris
under Epstein's fingernails, marks on his hands,
contusions to his knuckles, or bruises on his body
evidencing a struggle, which would be expected if
Epstein's death had been a homicide by strangulation.
Conclusion and Recommendations
This is not the first time the O16 has found significant
Job performance and management failures on the part
of BOP personnel and widespread disregard of BOP
policies that are designed to ensure that inmates are
safe, secure, and in good health. The combination of
negligence, misconduct, and outright job performance
failures documented in this report all contributed to an
environment in which arguably one of the BOP's most
notorious inmates was provided with the opportunity
to take his own life, resulting in significant questions
being asked about the circumstances of his death, how
it could have been allowed to happen, and most
importantly, depriving his numerous victims, many of
whom were underage girls at the time of the alleged
crimes, of their ability to seek Justice through the
criminal justice process. The fact that these failures
have been recurring ones at the BOP does not excuse
them and gives additional urgency to the need for DOJ
and BOP leadership to address the chronic staffing,
surveillance, safety and security, and related problems
plaguing the BOP.
The O16 made eight recommendations to the BOP to
address the numerous issues identified during our
Investigation and review. Finally, we recommended
that the BOP review the conduct and performance of
the BOP personnel as described in this report and
determine whether discipline or other administrative
action with regard to each of them is appropriate.
iv
Table of Contents
Chapter 1: Introduction 1
Chapter 2: Background 5

I. Significant Entities and Individuals 5
IL Methodology 6
III. Applicable Law, Regulations, and BOP Policies  7

A. Standards of Conduct 7
B. False Statements and Lack of Candor 8
C. Relevant BOP Policies Regarding the Operation of Correctional Facilities 8
Chapter 3: Timeline of Key Events 14
Chapter 4: Custody and Care of Epstein Prior to His Death 21

I. Epstein's Arrest and Detention on July 6  21
II. MCC New York's Special Housing Unit 22
III. Epstein's Initial Cell and Cellmate Assignment from July 7 to July 23 28

IV. Events of July 23 and the Placement of Epstein on Suicide Watch and Psychological Observation
from July 23 to July 30 29

V. The Psychology Department's Post-July 23 Determination that Epstein Needed to Have an
Appropriate Cellmate 32

VI. Selection of Epstein's Cellmate After Psychological Observation 33
VII. Epstein's Cell Assignment from July 30 to August 10 33
VIII. Psychological Evaluations of Epstein from July 6 to August 9 41
Chapter 5: The Events of August 8-10, 2019, and Epstein's Death 50

I. Epstein Signs a New Last Will and Testament on August 8 50
II. Court Order on August 9 Releasing Epstein-Related Documents in Pending Civil Litigation 50
III. Transfer of Epstein's Cellmate on August 9 to Another Institution and Failure to Replace Him with
Another Inmate 51

A. Notice on August 8 of the Impending Transfer of Epstein's Cellmate on August 9 51
B. MCC New York Staff Reject Epstein Attorney's Request that Epstein be Housed Without a
Cellmate  51

C. Removal on August 9 of Epstein's Cellmate from MCC New York 52
D. Failure to Assign Epstein a New Cellmate on August 9 53

IV. Epstein is Allowed to Make an Unmonitored Telephone Call on August 9 58
V. Failure to Conduct SHU Inmate Counts and Staff Rounds on August 9--10 61

A. SHU Inmate Counts 61
B. Staff Rounds in the SHU 67
VI. Epstein's Death on August 10 70
A. Discovery of Epstein Hanged in Cell and Emergency Response 70

B. Items Found in Epstein's Cell on August 10 Following His Death 76
C. Autopsy Results 79
Chapter 6: The Availability of Limited Recorded Video Evidence Due to the Security Camera
Recording System Failure 81

I. Background on the Security Camera System at MCC New York 81
II. Discovery of Security Camera System Recording Issues in August 2019 82

A. Discovery on August 8 of the DVR 2 Failure that Occurred on July 29 82
B. Response on August 8 and 9 to Discovery of the Recording Failure 83

C. SHU Camera Locations and Operational Status on August 10 84
D. FBI Forensic Analysis of the DVR System 92
Chapter 7: Conclusions and Recommendations 94

I. Conclusions 94
A. MCC New York Staff Failed to Ensure that Epstein Had a Cellmate on August 9 as Instructed by
the Psychology Department on July 30 98

B. MCC New York Staff Failed to Conduct Mandatory Rounds and Inmate Counts Resulting in
Epstein Being Unobserved for Hours Before His Death 102

C. MCC New York Staff Allowed Epstein to Place an Unmonitored Telephone Call on August 9 107
D. MCC New York Staff Failed to Conduct and Document Cell Searches and Eliminate Safety
Hazards in Epstein's Cell on August 9 Leaving Epstein with Excessive Linens in His Cell  108

E. MCC New York Staff Failed to Ensure that the Institution's Security Camera System was Fully
Functional Resulting in Limited Recorded Video Evidence 109
II. Recommendations 110
Appendix A: The BOP's Response to the Draft Report 115
Appendix B: OM Analysis of the BOP's Response 118
Chapter 1: Introduction
The Federal Bureau of Prisons (13OP) is a component of the Department of Justice (DOJ) that operates
122 institutions across the United States. According to its website, the BOP's current mission statement is
"Corrections professionals who foster a humane and secure environment and ensure public safety by
preparing individuals for successful reentry into our communities." However, the DOJ Office of the
Inspector General (OIG) has issued numerous reports over more than a decade identifying long-standing
operational challenges facing the BOP that have negatively affected its ability to operate its institutions
safely and securely. Those reports have contained dozens of recommendations to the BOP. As we detail in
this report, many of those same operational challenges and systemic issues, including significant staffing
shortages, providing appropriate custody and care of inmates at risk for suicide, the absence of functional
security camera systems, and management failures and widespread disregard of BOP policies and
procedures, were once again identified by the OIG during the course of this investigation and review into
the custody, care, and supervision of one of the SOP's most notorious inmates, Jeffrey Epstein. We
therefore make further recommendations to the BOP in the conclusion of this report to help it address
these recurring issues.

The OIG initiated this investigation upon the receipt of information from the BOP that on the morning of
August 10, 2019, in the Metropolitan Correctional Center located in New York, New York (MCC New York),
inmate Jeffery Epstein was found hanged in his assigned cell within the Special Housing Unit (SHU). The SHU
is a housing unit where inmates are securely separated from the general inmate population and kept locked
in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day, to ensure their own safety as well as the safety of staff and
other inmates. Epstein had been placed in the SHU on July 7, 2019, the day after his arrest, due to the
significant media coverage of his case and awareness of his notoriety among MCC New York inmates.
According to information obtained by the OIG during the investigation, at approximately 8 p.m. on August 9,
all SHU inmates, including Epstein, were locked in their cells for the evening. Additionally, the six separate
tiers or groups of cells within the SHU were also securely locked. At approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10,
2019, SHU staff unlocked the door to the SHU tier in which Epstein's cell was located in order to deliver
breakfast to inmates through the food slots in the locked cell doors. When SHU staff entered the tier to
deliver breakfast to Epstein, SHU staff knocked on the locked door to Epstein's cell. Epstein, who was
housed alone in the cell, did not respond to SHU staff. SHU staff unlocked the cell door and found Epstein
hanged in his cell, with one end of a piece of orange cloth around his neck and the other end tied to the top
portion of a bunkbed in Epstein's cell. Epstein was suspended from the top bunk in a near-seated position
with his buttocks approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half off the floor and his legs extended straight out on
the floor in front of him. Epstein's cell contained an excess amount of prison linens, as well as multiple
nooses that had been made from torn prison linens.

SHU staff immediately activated a body alarm, which notified all MCC New York staff of a medical emergency
and prompted MCC New York staff assigned to the Control Center to call for 911 emergency services. SHU
staff then ripped the orange cloth away from the bunkbed, which caused Epstein's buttocks to drop to the
ground. SHU staff laid Epstein on the ground and immediately initiated cardiopulmonary resuscitation
(CPR). At approximately 6:33 a.m., other MCC New York employees responded to the SHU. A responding
MCC New York Lieutenant took over administering CPR and asked SHU staff to retrieve an automated
external defibrillator and call for the duty nurse. A Clinical Nurse responded and continued to perform CPR
on Epstein in the place of the Lieutenant. At approximately 6:39 a.m., Epstein was placed on a stretcher and
moved by medical staff to the MCC New York Health Service Unit., The Clinical Nurse continuously
administered CPR until he was relieved by outside Emergency Medical Technicians (EMT) when they arrived
at the Health Services Area minutes later. The EMTs continued CPR, intubated Epstein, and administered
medication and fluids in their efforts to revive him. At approximately 7:10 a.m., Epstein was transported by
the EMTs in an ambulance to New York Presbyterian Lower Manhattan Hospital, where he was pronounced
dead by an emergency room physician at 7:36 a.m. On August 11, 2019, the Office of the Chief Medical
Examiner, City of New York, performed an autopsy on Epstein and determined that the cause of death was
hanging and the manner of death was suicide.

The OIG conducted this investigation jointly with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), with the OIG's
investigative focus being the conduct of BOP personnel. Among other things, the FBI investigated the cause
of Epstein's death. The FBI determined that there was no criminality pertaining to how Epstein had died.
This report concerns the OIG's findings regarding MCC New York personnel's custody, care, and supervision
of Epstein during his detention at the facility from his arrest on July 6, 2019, until his death on
August 10, 2019.

The OIG investigation and review identified numerous and serious failures by MCC New York staff, as well as
multiple violations of MCC New York and BOP policies and procedures. Among the most significant was the
failure to assign Epstein a new cellmate on August 9, 2019, after Epstein's cellmate was transferred out of
MCC New York that day. Epstein was required to have a cellmate at all times pursuant to a written direction
that the MCC New York Psychology Department issued on July 30 after Epstein was removed from suicide
watch and psychological observation following a possible attempted suicide by him on July 23. As a result of
the failure to assign him a new cellmate, Epstein was housed alone in his cell from the night of August 9
until he was found hanged in his cell by SHU staff at approximately 6:30 a.m. the following morning. In
addition, we determined that SHU staff failed to conduct required inmate counts and rounds, including
overnight on August 9-10, and allowed Epstein to have an excess of blankets, linens, and clothing in his cell.
These failures compromised Epstein's safety, the safety of other inmates, and the security of the institution,
and provided Epstein an opportunity to commit suicide while locked alone in his cell on the morning of
August 10 without having been subject to overnight observation or supervision by SHU staff.
The OIG also found that an MCC New York supervisor had allowed Epstein, in violation of BOP policy, to
make an unrecorded, unmonitored telephone call the evening before his death to an individual with whom
he allegedly had a personal relationship. Further, 2 days before his death, during a meeting with his lawyers
in a private room at the MCC New York, Epstein signed a new Last Will and Testament, which MCC New York
officials did not learn about until after his death.

Additionally, the OIG determined that MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU, including the two SHU staff
on duty the night of August 9-10, 2019, who were stationed at a desk that was directly outside the SHU tier
in which Epstein was housed and diagonally across from Epstein's cell, had falsified BOP records to claim
Moving an inmate requiring outside emergency medical care to the Health Services Unit provides health care staff and
Emergency Medical Technicians (EMT) with immediate access to any necessary medical equipment and supplies and
allows EMTs faster access to the inmate when they arrive at MCC New York because Correctional Officers (CO) can
directly escort EMTs to the Health Services Unit to begin emergency treatment immediately. If EMTs had to be escorted
to the housing unit, they would first need to be thoroughly screened, which would delay medical attention.
that they had conducted all of the required counts of inmates and 30-minute rounds during their shifts
within the SHU. As described in greater detail in Chapter 2, inmate counts and 30-minute rounds are two
means by which the BOP accounts for inmates and assesses their safety, security, and well-being. BOP and
MCC New York policies require that staff members count all inmates in each housing unit within the facility
at designated times each day. Additionally, SOP and MCC New York policies require that a staff member
observe all SHU inmates at least once during the first 30 minutes of each hour (e.g., 12 a.m. to 12:30 a.m.)
and again during the second 30 minutes of the hour (e.g., 12:30 a.m. to 1 a.m.), thus ensuring that inmates
are observed at least twice per hour. SOP staff are required to document inmate counts and 30-minute
rounds on official BOP forms, which are often referred to as "count slips" and "round sheets."2
During the OIG's investigation, the OIG obtained information that the staff assigned to the MCC New York
SHU did not conduct any counts of inmates within the SHU from August 9, 2019, at approximately 4 p.m.,
until Epstein was found hanged in his cell on the morning of August 10, 2019. However, in documentation
completed by the SHU staff on duty during that period, staff members falsely certified in the count slips that
they had conducted the required counts. Additionally, the OIG investigation revealed that the staff assigned
to the MCC New York SHU did not conduct any required 30-minute rounds of inmates after approximately
10:40 p.m. on August 9, 2019. Again, however, SHU staff on duty during that period had falsely certified in
the round sheet that the required rounds were conducted. The combination of these and other failures led
to Epstein being unmonitored and locked alone in his cell, which the OIG found contained an excessive
amount of bed linens, from approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 until he was discovered hanged in his cell
at approximately 6:30 a.m. the following day.

While the OIG determined that MCC New York staff committed significant violations of BOP and MCC
New York policies and falsified records related to their conducting inmate counts and rounds, the OIG did
not uncover evidence that contradicted the Fars determination regarding the absence of criminality in
connection with how Epstein died. All MCC New York staff members who were interviewed by the OIG said
they did not know of any information suggesting that Epstein's cause of death was something other than
suicide. Additionally, none of the 15 inmates who agreed to be interviewed in connection with this
investigation, 10 of whom were housed in the SHU on August 9 and 10, had any credible information
suggesting that Epstein's cause of death was something other than suicide. Further, the SHU staff and the
three interviewed inmates with a direct line of sight to the door of Epstein's cell from their cells stated that
no one entered or exited Epstein's cell after the SHU staff returned Epstein to his cell on the evening of
August 9, which is consistent with the security measures in place within the MCC New York SHU. SHU staff
told the OIG that at approximately 8 p.m. on August 9, all SHU inmates were locked in their cells for the
evening and that there was no indication that any of the other inmates could have gotten out of their cells.
Additionally, the OIG analyzed the available recorded video of the SHU, which was limited to the common
area of the SHU, including the SHU Officers' Station, due to the MCC New York security camera system's
recording issues that we detail in this report.' The OIG's analysis of the recorded video did not identify any
Correctional Officers (CO) or other individuals approaching any of the SHU tiers, including the L Tier where
2 These BOP forms are officially entitled "Official Count Slip" and "MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute
Check Sheer
For reasons we describe below, while the camera inside the L Tier was working and transmitting live video, the video
was not being recorded.

Epstein was housed, from the common area of the SHU between approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and
approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10.

Finally, the Medical Examiner who performed the autopsy detailed for the OIG why Epstein's injuries were
more consistent with, and indicative of, a suicide by hanging rather than a homicide by strangulation. The
Medical Examiner also cited to the absence of debris under Epstein's fingernails, marks on his hands,
contusions to his knuckles, or bruises on his body that evidenced Epstein had been in a struggle, which
would be expected if Epstein's death had been a homicide by strangulation.

As discussed in greater detail in the Conclusions and Recommendations chapter of this report, this is not
the first time that the OIG has found significant job performance and management failures on the part of
BOP personnel and widespread disregard of SOP policies that are designed to ensure that inmates are safe,
secure, and in good health. The OIG has investigated numerous allegations related to the falsification of
official SOP documentation concerning inmate counts and rounds and has repeatedly found deficiencies
with the BOP's staffing levels, the custody and care of inmates at risk for suicide, and security camera
systems at BOP institutions. The combination of negligence, misconduct, and outright job performance
failures documented in this report all contributed to an environment in which arguably one of the most
notorious inmates in BOP's custody was provided with the opportunity to take his own life. The BOP's
failures are troubling not only because the BOP did not adequately safeguard an individual in its custody,
but also because they led to questions about the circumstances surrounding Epstein's death and effectively
deprived Epstein's numerous victims of the opportunity to seek justice through the criminal justice process.
The fact that these failures have been recurring ones at the BOP does not excuse them and gives additional
urgency to the need for DOJ and BOP leadership to address the chronic problems plaguing the BOP.
Unless otherwise noted, the OIG applies the preponderance of the evidence standard in determining
whether DOJ personnel have committed misconduct. The U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board applies this
same standard when reviewing a federal agency's decision to take adverse action against an employee
based on such misconduct. See 5 U.S.C. § 7701(cX1)(B) and 5 C.F.R. § 1201.56(bX1)(ii).
In Chapter 2 of this report, we provide background information, including identification and a description of
significant entities and individuals; a summary of our methodology; and the applicable laws, federal
regulations, and BOP policies. In Chapter 3, we outline a timeline of key events. In Chapter 4, we set forth
our findings of fact relating to the BOP's custody and care of Epstein before his death. In Chapter 5, we set
forth our findings of fact related to the events of August 8-10, 2019, including Epstein's death. In Chapter 6,
we set forth our findings of fact related to the BOP's failure to ensure that there was a functional security
camera system at MCC New York, which resulted in limited recorded video evidence relevant to Epstein's
death. Finally, Chapter 7 contains our conclusions and recommendations.
Chapter 2: Background
I. Significant Entities and Individuals
Jeffrey Epsteinwas born in 1953 and, prior to his arrest, worked at various jobs in the financial industry and
ultimately developed considerable wealth. On July 2, 2019, a federal grand jury of the U.S. District Court for
the Southern District of New York returned an indictment that charged Epstein with engaging in sex
trafficking and a sex trafficking conspiracy, in violation of 18 U.S.C. 44 371, 1591(a), (b)(2), and 2. These
charges were based on allegations that between 2002 and 2005, Epstein paid girls as young as 14 years old
hundreds of dollars in cash each for engaging in sex acts with him at his Florida and New York residences.
The indictment further alleged that Epstein also paid each of these minor victims hundreds of dollars in cash
to recruit other girls to engage in sex acts with Epstein.

On July 6, 2019, Epstein was arrested at Teterboro Airport in New Jersey upon his return to the United States
from France and was transported to the Federal Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) Metropolitan Correctional Center,
located at 150 Park Row in New York, New York (MCC New York). Following a detention hearing on July 15,
2019, the court ordered that Epstein be detained pending trial based on the court's finding that he was a
danger to the community and a flight risk.

MCC New York is a federal administrative detention facility operated by the BOP that primarily provides
pretrial detention services for the U.S. District Courts for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York.
The BOP temporarily closed MCC New York in October 2021 due to substandard conditions that are
unrelated to this investigation. When it was operational, MCC New York housed approximately 750 inmates
at any given time. Prior to its closure, the majority of MCC New York's inmate residents were individuals
with pending criminal charges (as opposed to individuals who had been convicted of offenses and were
serving a sentence of imprisonment), but whom the court had determined under applicable law should
remain in custody pending trial either because they represent a danger to the community, a substantial
flight risk, or both. MCC New York has several different housing units. Epstein was initially assigned to MCC
New York's general inmate population, but on July 7, 2019, he was moved to the Special Housing Unit (SHU)
pending reclassification due to the significant increase in media coverage and awareness of his notoriety
among the other inmates. The SHU is a housing unit within MCC New York where inmates are securely
separated from the general inmate population and kept locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours per
day, to ensure their own safety as well as the safety of staff and other inmates.

Correctional Officer (CO) Tova Noel and Material Handler Michael Thomas began working together in MCC
New York SHU at 12 a.m. on August 10, 2019.4 During their shift, they each created and submitted falsified
official BOP forms documenting inmate counts (often referred to as 'count slips"), and Noel completed and
signed more than 75 separate entries on an official BOP form documenting 30-minute rounds (often
4 Noel worked her regular shift in the SHU from 4 p.m. to 12 a.m. on August 9, 2019, followed by an overtime shift in 
the
SHU from 12 a.m. to 8 a.m. on August 10, 2019. Thomas did not work his regular shift as a Material Handler in a
different location of MCC New York and instead worked an overtime shift in the SHU from 12 a.m. to 8 a.m. on
August 10, 2019.
S
referred to as a "round sheet") falsely stating that she and Thomas had conducted such rounds when, in
fact, they had not.5
On November 19, 2019, a federal grand jury of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York
returned an indictment that charged Noel and Thomas with one count each of conspiracy and multiple
counts each of falsification of records, in violation of 18 U.S.C. 4§ 371, 1001(a)(3), and 2. The indictment
alleged that on August 9, 2019, Noel failed to conduct the mandatory 4 p.m. and 10 p.m. counts of inmates
in the MCC New York SHU, and that on August 10, 2019, both she and Thomas failed to conduct the
mandatory 12 a.m., 3 a.m., and 5 a.m. counts and mandatory 30-minute rounds within the MCC New York
SHU. The indictment further alleged that Noel and Thomas created, certified, and submitted false
documentation indicating that the counts and rounds had been done as required to conceal their failure to
perform their assigned duties. As a result, it appeared from documentation that prisoners in the SHU,
including Epstein, were being regularly monitored when, in fact, no CO had checked on Epstein from
approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9, 2019, until approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10, 2019, when
Epstein was found hanged in his cell.

On May 25, 2021, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York entered into deferred
prosecution agreements with Noel and Thomas. Their respective agreements, which are part of the court
record in their cases, included admissions by Noel and Thomas that they falsely certified that they had
conducted counts and rounds. The agreements also required each of them to truthfully and completely
disclose all information related to their activities and employment with the BOP; be interviewed by the
U.S. Attorney's Office of the Southern District of New York, the FBI, and the OIG; complete 100 hours of
community service; refrain from violating the law; and fulfill other conditions related to pretrial supervision
and their establishment of good behavior. On December 13, 2021, after Noel and Thomas successfully
fulfilled the terms of their deferred prosecution agreements as determined by the prosecutors, the
U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York entered a nolle prosequi order and dismissed all
charges pending against them. Prosecution was declined by the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern
District of New York for other BOP employees assigned to the SHU who also falsely certified inmate count
slips and round sheets on the day before and the day of Epstein's death.

As discussed in greater detail in Chapter 7 of this report, the OIG found that, in addition to Noel and
Thomas, many other MCC New York staff members engaged in administrative misconduct, exercised poor
judgment, and/or failed to adequately perform their assigned duties.
II. Methodology
During the course of this investigation, the OIG interviewed 54 witnesses, several on more than one
occasion. The witnesses interviewed included Noel, Thomas, and other MCC New York staff assigned to the
SHU on August 9-10, 2019; MCC New York supervisors at the time of Epstein's death, including the Warden,
Associate Wardens, Captain, and Lieutenants; medical staff; staff members responsible for the MCC
New York security camera system; other BOP staff and contractors; and a relative of Epstein, who had
5 These BOP forms are officially entitled "Official Count Slip" and "MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute Check
Sheet." Each of the 6 tiers in the SHU had a separate round sheet, each of which had 13 entries reflecting 30-minute
rounds were conducted, when they were not, in fact, completed.

requested to provide information.' The BOP employees and contractors we interviewed included
employees involved in various aspects of the emergency response, who worked at MCC New York in the
days leading up to the response and following the response, as well as other individuals with information
pertinent to our investigation. Additionally, the OIG participated in interviews of 15 inmates who had been
housed at MCC New York during time periods relevant to our investigation, including three who were
housed in the L Tier of the SHU on the day Epstein died.' Those three L-Tier inmates were housed in cells
opposite Epstein's cell and therefore had a direct line of sight to Epstein's cell on the night of August 9-10.
The OIG also reached out to one of Epstein's attorneys to discuss the possibility of providing information,
but ultimately the attorney declined to be interviewed, citing attorney -client privilege (the attorney -client
privilege survives a client's death) and issues related to ongoing litigation involving Epstein's estate.
The OIG also collected over 127,000 documents, as well as MCC New York video and photographs. Among
these were BOP documents, including staff rosters; daily logs and reports; investigative and incident reports;
documentation regarding inmate counts and 30-minute rounds; inmate housing assignment
documentation; inmate transfer documents; Psychology Department reports and medical records relating
to Epstein; Epstein's institutional phone call records; MCC New York records of Epstein's visits with his
attorneys; electronic communications, including text messages and emails of BOP employees and
contractors; MCC New York security camera surveillance video; records from contractors regarding the MCC
New York security camera system; service records for MCC New York's security camera system; MCC
New York photographs, including photographs taken of efforts to revive Epstein on the morning of
August 10, 2019; BOP policies and program statements; MCC New York Post Orders; and financial records.
The OIG also conducted forensic analysis of the computers located in the SHU and BOP cellular telephones.
In addition, the OIG reviewed FBI investigative records, including interview reports (FD-302), notes from
witness interviews and other meetings, and electronic communications. The OIG also reviewed Epstein's
autopsy report and interviewed the Medical Examiner who performed the autopsy on Epstein.
Ill. Applicable Law, Regulations, and BOP Policies
A. Standards of Conduct
The Standards of Ethical Conduct for Employees of the Executive Branch sets out general principles that are
designed to "ensure that every citizen can have complete confidence in the integrity of the Federal
Government."8 Among other things, these standards require that every federal employee "use official time
' On a separate occasion, the relative contacted the OIG to say that the relative had "photographic proof' that the door
to Epstein's cell was left open the night Epstein died. When the OIG followed up with the relative to request copies of
the photographs and any information regarding this allegation, the relative stated that upon further review, the
photographs did not show what the relative previously communicated to the OIG.

/ The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York sought interviews from inmates housed in the L Tier 
of
the SHU on the night that Epstein died, each of whom was represented by counsel. Three inmates agreed to be
interviewed. The OIG does not have the authority to compel or subpoena testimony from individuals who are not
DOJ employees.
8 C.F.R. § 2635.101(a).

in an honest effort to perform official duties.", The ethical regulations also mandate that federal employees
not use federal property "for other than authorized activities." ,
BOP policy (Program Statement 3420.11, Standards of Employee Conduct) imposes several additional
standards of conduct on its employees. At all times, BOP employees must "[c]onduct themselves in a
manner that fosters respect for the Bureau of Prisons, the Department of Justice, and the U.S. Government."
Because "[i]nattention to duty in a correctional environment can result in escapes, assaults, and other
incidents," BOP employees "are required to remain fully alert and attentive during duty hours." BOP policy
provides that employees can use government property for authorized purposes only, and further specifies
that personal use of government office equipment, such as computers, "will not take place during official
working hours." BOP policy requires that employees "obey the orders of their superiors at all times."

B. False Statements and Lack of Candor
Under federal law, "whoever, in any matter within the jurisdiction of the executive...branch of the
Government of the United States, knowingly and willfully...makes or uses any false writing or document
knowing the same to contain any materially false, fictitious, or fraudulent statement or entry" has violated
18 U.S.C. § 1001(a)(3). The terms "knowingly and willfully" mean that the subject acted with knowledge that
the conduct was, in a general sense, prohibited by law. It is not required that the subject was aware of the
existence of Section 1001.

Under BOP standards of conduct discussed above, employees are required to cooperate fully with official
investigations, which includes providing "all pertinent information they may have" and "truthfully responding
to questions."
C. Relevant BOP Policies Regarding the Operation of Correctional Facilities
1. Special Housing Units
SHUs within BOP facilities are governed by federal regulations, 28 C.F.R. §§ 541.21-541.33. These
regulations provide that the BOP may establish SHUs "where inmates are securely separated from the
general inmate population." These regulations and BOP policy (Program Statement 5270.11, Special
Housing Units) explain that inmates in the SHU are either on administrative detention or disciplinary
segregation status. Administrative segregation status is a non-punitive designation that removes an inmate
"from the general population when necessary to ensure the safety, security, and orderly operation of
correctional facilities, or protect the public." There are several reasons an inmate can be placed in
administrative detention status, including when an inmate's presence in the general inmate population
presents a threat to self or others, or when administrative detention status is necessary for the protection of
the inmate. Assignment to the SHU for protection reasons can be based on being a victim of an assault,
acting (or being perceived) as an informant, refusing to enter general population, or because of staff
concerns about the inmate's safety.
S C.F.R. § 2635.705(a); see also S C.F.R. § 2635.101(b)(5).
10 5 C.F.R. § 2635.101(b)(9); see also S C.F.R. § 2635.704(a).

Inmates in the SHU are securely separated from general population inmates and are kept locked in their cell
when in their assigned tier within the SHU. As discussed in greater detail in Chapter 4, witnesses told the
OIG that SHU inmates are locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day. BOP policy provides that,
weather and resources permitting, SHU inmates will have the opportunity to exercise outside their quarters
S hours per calendar week. Under federal regulations and BOP policy, SHU inmates ordinarily have the
opportunity to shower at least 3 times a week, typically on different days in 1-hour periods. SHU inmates
may also be escorted from their cells by MCC New York staff for visits, including legal visits, court
appearances, medical and psychological attention. The MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that all
visitors to the SHU be documented in a visitor log, and that any inmate visiting the SHU, such as inmates on
work details, be searched visually and with a hand-held metal detector, without exception. The MCC
New York SHU Post Orders also require that food carts be searched inside and out before being brought
into a SHU cellblock and that all meals be delivered to each inmate's cell through the food slot in the
inmate's locked cell door.

BOP policy provides that inmates housed in the SHU for 30 continuous calendar days are to be examined
and interviewed by a mental health staff member to assess the inmate's adjustment and the threat
presented to self or others.

BOP policy also requires that all staff assigned to the SHU participate in quarterly training on, among other
things, orderly supervision, suicide prevention, and security procedures relating to the unit. When a staff
member is assigned to the SHU at the last-minute and has not completed the quarterly training, the staff
member must be advised of the general requirements of a SHU post and be permitted to ask questions
about the duties.
2 Inmate Accountability ,'
a. Counts
Inmate counts serve an important security function, as they enable COs to ensure that all inmates are
accounted for and present at the appropriate location within the facility. BOP policy requires that each
institution "conduct, at a minimum, five official inmate counts during every 24-hour period," and that on
"weekends and holidays an additional count will be conducted at 10:00 a.m." At least 1 count a day during
the week and 2 counts a day on weekends and holidays must be "stand-up counts," which means that
inmates are required to stand when they are counted. MCC New York SHU Post Orders designate that
counts must occur at 12 a.m., 3 a.m., 5 a.m., 4 p.m., and that stand-up counts are to be conducted at 10 p.m.
daily and also at 10 a.m. on weekends and federal holidays.

The BOP requires that each count be conducted by at least two officers, one of whom will count the inmates
while the other observes the unit for any unauthorized movement from the end of the tier. This
requirement is also set out in the MCC New York SHU Post Orders. The two officers will then switch roles
and compare the count numbers. If the totals do not match, then the officers must conduct another count
in the same manner. When conducting the count, officers are required to observe each inmate's body and
not rely solely on movement or sound. Officers conducting the count relay the count verbally to the Control
" This section describes inmate accountability measures that are most relevant to this investigation and review. The
BOP utilizes a variety of other security and inmate accountability tools in addition to those discussed in this section,
which are described in BOP Program Statement 5500.14, Correctional Services Procedures Manual.
Center, which maintains the master count of all inmates, and then remain in the unit until the Control
Center accepts the count. If a count reported verbally does not match the master count, then the Control
Center must notify the Operations Lieutenant and the staff members must recount the inmates. If the
second count does not match the master count, then the Operations Lieutenant will order a bed-book
count, that is, when inmates are counted using their picture cards, which are on file in the Control Center. A
Lieutenant must take at least 1 count in the morning and one in the evening.

Correctional staff prepare count slips for each count, which must be prepared in ink, signed by both officers,
and retained for 30 days. Count slips may not be altered. BOP policy provides that the "official count will
not be cleared until all count slips are received and verified in the Control Center."

b. 30-Minute Rounds
The BOP uses additional accountability measures for inmates who are in administrative detention or
disciplinary segregation, i.e., for those detained in a SHU. In such cases, a correctional staff member must
observe all inmates at least twice an hour, once during the first 30 minutes (e.g., 12 a.m. to 12:30 a.m.) and
again during the second 30 minutes (e.g., 12:30 a.m. to 1 a.m.). BOP policy provides that these 'rounds are
to be conducted on an irregular schedule and no more than 40 minutes apart." These same requirements
for rounds are also described in the Post Orders for the MCC New York's SHU.

c. Documentation Regarding Inmate Status and Confinement
BOP policy also provides that each institution must prepare a daily change/transfer sheet, which indicates
changes to an inmate's status, including housing and job assignments and medical convalescence. The MCC
New York SHU Post Orders require that correctional staff assigned to the SHU create a SHU file for each
inmate housed in that unit and that morning watch officers audit the inmate files every night. The MCC
New York SHU Post Orders further specify that all pertinent information about an inmate's confinement
should be noted on a Special Housing Unit Record Form (BP-292), and that SHU officers must maintain a log
of pertinent information regarding inmate activity and enter such information into the BOP computer
system TRUSCOPE, which provides institution staff with detailed inmate and institution security-related
information and provides unit officers an electronic event log.

d. Cell Searches
BOP policy requires that BOP staff routinely and irregularly search housing units to, among other things,
maintain sanitary standards and eliminate safety hazards.0 The MCC New York SHU Post Orders require
that officers assigned to the SHU conduct searches of the SHU common areas and cells, and that the entire
SHU be searched every week. BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders require written
documentation of each housing unit search.

3. Psychological Screening
a. Initial Screening
Pursuant to BOP policy governing inmates in pretrial detention status (Program Statement 7331.04, Pretrial
Inmates), all pretrial inmates must have an initial risk/needs assessment screening within 48 hours of
' 2 BOP Program Statement 5521.06, Searches of Housing Units, Inmates, and Inmate Work Areas.
admission to the institution. The goal of this screening is to determine "the inmate's security, medical,
psychological, and/or other special needs." The BOP also requires that institutions screen pretrial inmates
"returning from court, as events at court may alter the inmate's separation and/or security needs." SOP
policy further recognizes that there are often "high security, high profile inmates" who may present a
significant threat to themselves or others, and that the "need to identify and monitor these inmates
regularly is paramount."
b. Suicide Prevention
The BOP's suicide prevention program is governed by federal regulations, 28 C.F.R. §§ 552.40-552.42, which
require the BOP to establish a suicide prevention program to identify and manage potentially suicidal
inmates. Pursuant to these regulations, when an inmate is identified as being at-risk for committing suicide,
BOP staff must place the inmate on suicide watch until the inmate is no longer an imminent risk.
BOP policy (Program Statement 5324.08, Suicide Prevention Program) requires that medical staff screen all
new inmates, ordinarily within 24 hours, for signs of suicidality. However, at MCCs, among other facilities
with high rates of admissions and short lengths of stays, "comprehensive psychological intake conducted by
Psychology Services ordinarily will be performed only on inmates who are suspected of being suicidal or
appear psychologically unstable? Inmates in the SHU are monitored more closely, and inmates exhibiting
signs of potential suicide risk are referred to the shift Lieutenant. BOP policy recognizes that inmates who
are placed in the SHU due to a request for protective custody are at greater risk of committing suicide and
should therefore be screened for suicidal ideation within 72 hours of arriving in the SHU. BOP policy
explicitly states that "staff must never take lightly any inmate suicide threats." Any staff member who has
reason to believe that an inmate may be suicidal should "ordinarily maintain the inmate under direct,
continuous observation."
Every BOP institution must have one or more rooms, ordinarily in the health services area, dedicated to
inmates placed on suicide watch. Suicide watch may be conducted by specially trained staff or inmates. For
inmates placed on suicide watch, the specially trained staff or inmate maintains continuous observation of
the inmate believed to be at risk of committing suicide. Following suicide watch and based on clinical
findings following a face-to-face evaluation, the inmate will be removed from suicide watch or transferred to
a medical referral or health care facility. Psychological observation is a less restrictive form of individual
monitoring that is used for inmates who are stabilizing and not yet prepared for placement in general
population or restrictive housing. While on suicide watch, the inmate is normally required to wear a suicide
watch gown and will be allowed a suicide watch blanket.

As discussed in greater detail in Chapter 4, witnesses told the OIG that an inmate is placed on suicide watch
when the inmate is believed to be imminently suicidal. During suicide watch, the inmate is under constant
observation by staff; the cell lights are on 24 hours a day; and the inmate is given a special mattress,
blanket, and smock to wear. Although psychological observation is a lower classification, witnesses told the
OIG that at MCC New York the psychological observations was the same as suicide watch except that
inmates were allowed to have their clothing and some materials, such as books, as determined by the
Psychology Department. At MCC New York, psychological observation was used to see how an inmate was
doing before releasing the inmate to a housing unit.

4. Suicide Response
Recognizing that failure to appropriately respond to an emergency can jeopardize the safety of staff and
inmates and the security of the institution, the BOP's Standards of Employee Conduct require that
"employees respond immediately, effectively, and appropriately during all emergency situations." The MCC
New York General Housing Unit Post Orders outline the required response to a suspected inmate suicide.
These orders require that MCC New York staff notify the Operations Lieutenant and Control Center of the
situation. The orders further provide that, once there is adequate staff present, immediate action must be
taken to open the inmate's airway and initiate cardiopulmonary resuscitation, even if MCC New York staff
believe that the inmate "has been dead for a period of time." MCC New York staff are to continue
cardiopulmonary resuscitation until they are relieved by medical staff or another rescuer. The SOP policy
governing crime scenes and the collection of evidence provides that the need to immediately attend to an
apparent suicide victim, undertake lifesaving measures, and ensure inmate and staff safety take precedence
over efforts to preserve a crime scene.13
S. Inmate Discipline
Federal regulations, 28 C.F.R. 99 541.1-541.8, and BOP policy (Program Statement 5270.09, Inmate Discipline
Program) establish an inmate discipline program, which is designed to ensure the safety, security, and
orderly operation of correctional facilities, as well as the protection of the public. The inmate discipline
program applies to all inmates in BOP custody, including inmates with pending criminal charges. One of the
guiding principles of this program is that BOP staff are to take disciplinary action when and to such a degree
as necessary to regulate the behavior of inmates to promote a safe and orderly institution. "Tattooing or
self-mutilation" is among the prohibited acts sanctioned through the inmate discipline program. This
prohibited act falls within the second most severe category of offenses on a 4-tier scale. The BOP defines
"tattooing or self-mutilation" as "Rio put indelible patterns on the skin; to injure, disfigure or make imperfect
by removing or irreparably damaging parts of the body (wrist cutting falls within this offense)."14 The
definition does not make an explicit reference to suicide attempts other than inclusion of "wrist cutting."
Among other things, BOP policy addressing the inmate discipline program identifies the prohibited acts,
describes the process for adjudicating violations, and lists applicable penalties for each category of offense.
As relevant to this matter, the discipline process begins when a staff member observes an inmate commit a
prohibited act and issues a report documenting the incident. A BOP supervisor then investigates the alleged
inmate misconduct, which includes taking a statement from the inmate regarding the incident. If an inmate
appears to be mentally ill at any stage of the disciplinary process, a mental health staff member will
examine the inmate and assess the inmate's competency to participate in the disciplinary process. If the
inmate is found to be competent and the prohibited act falls into the first or second most severe category,
the matter is referred to a discipline hearing officer, who will hold a hearing and make a determination as to
whether the inmate committed the prohibited act and, if so, impose any of the sanctions that correspond to
the severity of the prohibited act. At the hearing, the inmate is advised of his or her rights and permitted to
13 BOP Program Statement 5510.14, Crime Scene Management and Evidence Control, is a restricted policy that is not
released to the public in its entirety.
14 BOP Elements of Prohibited Acts.

choose a staff representative, make a statement, and call witnesses. The inmate is also allowed to appeal
the outcome through the BOP's administrative remedy program.

6. Conditions of Confinement
a. Telephone Calls
The federal regulations, 28 C.F.R. H 540.100-540.106, that govern telephone calls for inmates require that
the Warden of each BOP institution establish procedures to monitor inmate telephone conversations, which
is "done to preserve the security and orderly management of the institution and to protect the public." For
safety and security reasons, SOP policy (Program Statement P5264.08, Inmate Telephone Regulations)
requires that all inmate telephone calls be made through the Inmate Telephone System. BOP policy
recognizes that "on rare occasion, during times of crisis," inmates may be permitted to make a telephone
call outside of the Inmate Telephone System. In such circumstances, the telephone "must be placed in a
secure area (e.g., a locked office)," and "must be set to record telephone calls." Additionally, the staff
member coordinating the call must notify the BOP's Special Investigative Services via email, providing the
inmate's name and register number, the date and time of the call, the number and name of the individual
called, and the reason for the call. The Special Investigative Services must enter this information into the
telephone recording system within 7 days.
b. Personal Effects, Medication, and Linens
Federal regulations governing BOP SHUs provide that inmates in administrative detention status ordinarily
may have a reasonable amount of personal property." Under SOP policy regarding SHUs, the personal
property of SHU inmates "may be limited or withheld for reasons of security, fire safety, or housekeeping."16
The BOP Chief Pharmacist issues medication each workday for inmates in the SHU. Restricted medications
are administered to inmates during daily SHU rounds. Each institution determines "the medication(s) and
amount (number of days) an inmate in SHU may maintain in their cell." Inmates may also purchase pre-
approved over-the-counter medications at the commissary. MCC New York General Housing Units Post
Orders provide that when an inmate is released or transferred out of a housing unit, the inmate will remove
all limited and government -issued clothing from the cell in which the inmate was previously housed. These
Post Orders further specify that all cells are to be cleaned daily by inmates occupying the cell, and that
blankets, towels, and other linens will not be used as rugs or hung over inmate bunk beds at anytime.
Pursuant to these Post Orders, MCC New York housing unit officers on all three shifts are responsible for
maintaining "a high level of sanitation" and a "safe and clean environment."
15 28 C.F.R. § 541.31(h)(1).
16 BOP Program Statement 5270.11, Special Housing Units.
Chapter 3: Timeline of Key Events
Except as otherwise noted, the following information is derived from the Federal Bureau of
Prisons (BOP) records and the Office of the Inspector General's interviews.
September 21-24,
March 17, 2019
July 2, 2019
July 6, 2019
July 7, 2019
The BOP awards contracts to two companies (Company 1 and 2) to
upgrade the security camera system at Metropolitan Correctional Center
in New York, New York (MCC New York). At the time, images from the
MCC New York's analog video cameras are recorded to a Digital Video
Recorder (DVR) system, which is divided into two DVR systems. Cameras
assigned to the DVR 1 system record only to the DVR 1 hard drives, and
cameras assigned to DVR 2 system record only to the DVR 2 hard drives.
In connection with MCC New York's upgrade of its security camera
system, the BOP's Northeast Regional Office begins arranging for
technicians from other BOP institutions to perform temporary duty (TDY)
assignments to MCC New York to perform necessary mechanical,
electrical, plumbing, and wiring work. However, during the course of the
TDY rotations, work is not consistently conducted on the camera upgrade
because TDY personnel are sometimes used to cover shortages at MCC
New York's custody posts.
According to court records, a federal grand jury of the U.S. District Court
for the Southern District of New York returns an indictment charging
Epstein with sex trafficking and conspiracy to commit sex trafficking.
Epstein is arrested at an airport in New Jersey and is transported for
detention pending his initial court appearance to the MCC New York as a
pretrial detainee. Epstein is placed in the general inmate population and
medically screened.
An MCC New York Facilities Assistant asks the Psychology Department to
evaluate Epstein because he appears "distraught, sad, and a little
confused." Epstein is assigned to the MCC New York's Special Housing
Unit (SHU) because of significant media attention and his notoriety
among other MCC New York inmates."
" The SHU is a housing unit within MCC New York where inmates are securely separated from the general inmate
population and kept locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day, to ensure their own safety as well as the
safety of staff and other inmates.
July 8, 2019
July 9, 2019
July 10, 2019
July 11, 2019
July 15, 2019
July 16, 2019
July 18, 2019
According to court records, Epstein is arraigned in federal court and
enters a plea of not guilty to all charges. The court sets a detention
hearing for July 15, 2019.
MCC New York staff conducts a routine intake screening of Epstein, the
records of which indicate that Epstein denies a history of any mental
health problems. After the Chief Psychologist consults with the National
Suicide Prevention Coordinator from BOP's Central Office, the Psychology
Department conducts a further evaluation of Epstein after his return from
court. Records show that Epstein denies any suicidal thoughts but was
placed on psychological observation due to the presence of risk factors
(high-profile case, nature of the charges, pre-trial status, and
ongoing proceedings).
The Psychology Department administers a formal, in-person suicide risk
assessment for Epstein. The Psychology Department continues
psychological observation for another day pending a suitable
housing placement.
The Psychology Department removes Epstein from psychological
observation and returns him to the SHU with a recommendation that he
have a cellmate. Epstein is housed with another inmate (Inmate 1).
An MCC New York psychologist meets with Epstein briefly and
recommends follow-up visit to occur the next week.
According to court records, Epstein appears in court for his
detention hearing.
At Epstein's request, an MCC New York psychologist meets with him
during a legal visit.
According to court records, Epstein appears in court for a ruling on the
issue of detention. The court orders that Epstein be detained pending
trial because he presents a danger to the community and he is a
flight risk.
The Psychology Department conducts 30-day psychology reviews for the
entire SHU population. Epstein is not in the SHU at the time and
therefore his review is not conducted.

July 22, 2019 According to court records, Epstein files an appeal of the court's order
denying Epstein pretrial release.
July 23, 2019
July 24, 2019
July 25-29, 2019
At approximately 1:27 a.m., SHU staff hears noises coming from Epstein's
cell. Epstein's cellmate (Inmate 1) says that Epstein has attempted to
hang himself. SHU staff observes Epstein lying on the floor with a piece of
orange cloth around his neck. Epstein initially tells MCC New York staff
that his cellmate tried to kill him. Epstein's cellmate (Inmate 1) tells MCC
New York staff that while he was asleep, he felt something hit his legs and
when he turned on the light, he saw Epstein with a string around his neck
and called the guards.fe
Epstein is transferred out of the SHU and placed on suicide watch in a cell
near the Psychology Department and Health Services Unit.
Later that morning, Health Services Unit personnel conduct a medical
assessment and observe that Epstein has a red mark two-thirds of the
way around the front and sides of his neck. The BOP assesses Epstein for
risk of suicide and determines that he should remain on suicide watch.
At approximately 8:45 a.m., Epstein is removed from suicide watch but
remains under psychological observation in the same cell near the
Psychology Department and Health Services Unit. Medical staff examine
Epstein at 1:08 p.m. and Psychological Services staff complete a Post
Suicide Watch Report. In contrast to his prior statement that his cellmate
tried to kill him, Epstein says he does not remember how he sustained
the injuries to his neck.
Epstein is seen by the Psychology Department daily and on each date
adamantly denies suicidality or having any memory of what occurred on
July 23, 2019.
July 29, 2019 Psychology Department staff determine that Epstein can be released
from psychological observation and transferred back to the SHU.19
le  When interviewed by the OIG, another inmate housed in the same SHU tier (Inmate 2) at the time of the July 23
incident said he heard Inmate 1 call for assistance, and that Inmate 1 later told him that Epstein had tried to kill 
himself
by hanging himself from the bunkbed ladder.

19 The investigation revealed that Epstein was originally scheduled to return to the SHU on July 29, 2019, but at his
request he remained on psychological observation until July 30, 2019. The BOP's SENTRY database, which is a BOP
Continued
Disk failures occur in DVR 2 of MCC New York's security camera system,
which results in the system being unable to record, although the cameras
continue to work and broadcast live video feed. MCC New York personnel
do not learn of the DVR 2 recording failure until August 8, 2 days before
Epstein's death. Roughly half of MCC New York's security cameras,
including those located in the SHU, are assigned to record to the
DVR 2 system.
July 30, 2019 Epstein is transferred back to the SHU.2°
An MCC New York Staff Psychologist from the Psychology Department
sends an email to over 70 BOP staff members stating that Epstein 'needs
to be housed with an appropriate cellmate." Epstein and his new cellmate
(Inmate 3) are placed in a cell within the SHU that can accommodate the
electrical needs of Epstein's medical device.
MCC New York conducts disciplinary proceedings against Epstein for
alleged self-mutilation and ultimately concludes that there is insufficient
evidence to find that Epstein engaged in a prohibited act.2' When Epstein
is psychologically evaluated in connection with the disciplinary
proceedings, he says he does not remember how he sustained the marks
around his neck.
MCC New York personnel attempt to obtain an estimate from Company 1
to run the wiring and conduit for the new camera system, which would
eliminate the need for BOP technicians to perform the work.
July 31, 2019 According to court records, Epstein appears in court for a status
conference, at which time the court sets deadlines for motions and
responses. Upon his return to MCC New York, the U.S. Marshals Service
provide paperwork to BOP that indicates Epstein had
"suicidal tendencies."
database that contains information relating to the care, classification, subsistence, protection, discipline, and 
programs
of federal inmates, was not updated to reflect this change because it indicated that Epstein was transferred back to the
SHU on July 29, 2019.

20 The OIG's investigation revealed that at some point after he returned to the SHU from suicide watch and
psychological observation, Epstein asked two different MCC New York staff members if he can be housed with the same
cellmate Epstein initially said tried to kill him.

21 The BOP's inmate discipline program and the offense with which Epstein was charged is further described in
Chapter 2.
The Psychology Department conducts a clinical visit with Epstein, who
denies any suicidal ideation.
August 1, 2019
August 2, 2019
MCC New York Receiving and Discharge staff notify the Psychology
Department of the notation of "suicidal tendencies" on U.S. Marshals
Service paperwork relating to Epstein. The Psychology Department
conducts a suicide risk assessment of Epstein, who denies that he is
suicidal, and determines that suicide watch is not warranted.
Psychological staff recommend a follow-up in 1 week.
MCC New York Special Investigative Services complete its investigation
into the incident on July 23, 2019, and finds that there is insufficient
evidence to determine that Epstein harmed himself or that he was
harmed by his cellmate.
August 8, 2019 Epstein is seen by the Psychology Department and denies suicidal
ideation, intention, or plan.
August 9, 2019
Epstein meets with his attorneys and, unbeknownst to MCC New York
personnel, changes his Last Will and Testament during the meeting.
MCC New York staff receive notice that Epstein's cellmate will be
transferred out of the institution the following day, August 9.
MCC New York staff discover the disk failures that occurred in the DVR 2
system on July 29 and that resulted in approximately one half of the
institution's security cameras not recording, although the cameras
continued to broadcast a live video feed. MCC New York staff do not
perform the work necessary to restore recording functionality of the
DVR 2 system or address long-standing performance failures with the
institution's camera system.
At approximately 8:30 a.m., Epstein's cellmate (Inmate 3) is transferred
out of MCC New York. Two MCC New York SHU staff members said they
notified supervisory staff of Epstein's cellmate's transfer and Epstein's
need for a new cellmate. Other witnesses did not corroborate these
statements. Epstein is not assigned a new cellmate as required by the
Psychology Department.
Sometime between 8 a.m. and 9 a.m., Epstein meets with his attorneys in
the SHU attorney conference room. Sometime prior to 1 p.m., Epstein's
attorneys ask MCC New York staff members if Epstein could be moved to
a different housing unit or housed without a cellmate.
MCC New York staff obtain the replacement hard drives to repair the
institution's security camera system but do not complete the repairs
necessary to restore recording functionality and address long-standing
performance failures with the institution's DVR 2 system.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit unseals approximately
2,000 pages of documents in civil litigation involving Ghislaine Maxwell,
who is later convicted in December 2021 of conspiring with Epstein to
sexually abuse minors over the course of a decade. Some of these
documents contain information that may relate to the criminal charges
pending against Epstein. There is extensive media coverage of
information in the unsealed documents.
At approximately 6:45 p.m., Epstein leaves the attorney conference room.
At approximately 7 p.m., contrary to BOP policy but with the permission
of a Unit Manager, Epstein is permitted to place an unmonitored
telephone call to a number with a New York City area code, purportedly
to speak with his mother. In actuality, Epstein speaks with someone with
whom he allegedly has a personal relationship. After the call, Epstein is
returned to his cell, where he remains without a cellmate.
MCC New York SHU staff members do not conduct the 4 p.m. or 10 p.m.
inmate counts. After approximately 10:40 p.m., SHU staff members do
not conduct the required 30-minute rounds.
August 10, 2019 MCC New York SHU staff members do not conduct the 12 a.m., 3 a.m., or
5 a.m. inmate counts or any of the 30-minute rounds from 12 a.m. until
approximately 6:30 a.m.
At approximately 6:30 a.m., SHU staff begin to deliver breakfast to
inmates in the SHU through the food slots in the locked cell doors. When
SHU staff attempt to deliver breakfast to Epstein, SHU staff unlock the
door to the tier in which Epstein's cell was located and then knock on the
door to Epstein's cell. Epstein, who is housed alone in the cell, does not
respond to SHU staff. SHU staff unlock the cell door and find Epstein
hanged in his cell, with one end of a piece of orange cloth around his neck
and the other end tied to the top portion of a bunkbed in Epstein's cell.
Epstein is suspended from the top bunk in a near-seated position with his
buttocks approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half off the floor and his
legs extended straight out on the floor in front of him.
SHU staff immediately activate a body alarm, which notified all MCC
New York staff of a medical emergency and prompted MCC New York
staff in the Control Center to call for 911 emergency services. SHU staff
then rip the orange cloth away from the bunkbed, which causes Epstein's
buttocks to drop to the ground. SHU staff lay Epstein on the ground and
immediately initiate cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). At
approximately 6:33 a.m., BOP medical staff respond to the SHU, continue
CPR, apply the automated external defibrillator, and move Epstein to MCC
New York's Health Services Unit. Minutes after arriving in the Health
Services Unit, an ambulance arrives and paramedics continue CPR,
incubate Epstein, and administer medications and fluids. At
approximately 7:10 a.m., the ambulance takes Epstein to New York
Presbyterian Lower Manhattan Hospital, where he is pronounced dead at
7:36 a.m. by the emergency room physician.
MCC New York staff unsuccessfully attempts to recover video from the
DVR 2 system of the SHU and the BOP begins repairing the DVR 2 system.
The FBI seizes all hard drives contained in the DVR 2 system as evidence.

August 11, 2019 The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, City of New York, conducts an
autopsy of Epstein.
August 14-15, 2019
August 16, 2019
The FBI returns to MCC New York and seizes additional components of
the DVR 2 system and the entire DVR 1 system. The FBI's Digital Forensics
Analysis Unit in Quantico, Virginia, begins to conduct a forensic analysis of
MCC New York's DVR systems and determines that there were
catastrophic disk failures in the DVR 2 system disk array and no
recordings were available on the DVR 2 system after July 29, 2019.
The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, City of New York, releases its
findings publicly that the cause of Epstein's death was hanging and that
the manner of death was suicide.
Chapter 4: Custody and Care of Epstein Prior to His Death
I. Epstein's Arrest and Detention on July 6
On July 2, 2019, a grand jury of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York returned a two-
count indictment that charged Epstein with committing sex trafficking and a sex trafficking conspiracy, in
violation of 18 U.S.C. H 371, 1591(a), (bX2), and 2, based on allegations that he sexually exploited and
abused dozens of minor girls, some as young as 14 years old, at his homes in New York and Florida. The
indictment alleged that from at least 2002 through 2005, Epstein enticed and recruited girls, many of whom
he knew were underage, to visit his homes and perform sex acts in exchange for paying each girl hundreds
of dollars in cash. The indictment further alleged that Epstein, working with employees and associates,
created a vast network of underage victims to sexually exploit in New York and Florida by paying some
victims hundreds of dollars in cash each to recruit other minor girls to be similarly abused by Epstein. In
addition to the two criminal charges, the indictment also contained forfeiture allegations, which sought to
forfeit to the United States any property that was either used to commit or was a proceed of the charged
sex trafficking offense, including Epstein's New York residence.

On Saturday, July 6, 2019, Epstein was arrested at Teterboro Airport in New Jersey upon his return to the
United States from France. He was transported to the Metropolitan Correctional Center located in
New York, New York (MCC New York), where he was initially placed in the general inmate population. MCC
New York is a federal administrative detention facility operated by the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP). The
BOP temporarily closed MCC New York in October 2021 due to substandard conditions that are unrelated to
this investigation. When it was operational, MCC New York housed primarily pretrial detainees who had not
yet been convicted of any offense, but whom the court had determined under applicable law should remain
in custody pending trial either because they represent a danger to the community, a substantial flight risk,
or both. Due to the significant media attention surrounding his arrest and his notoriety among other MCC
New York inmates, the following day Epstein was moved to MCC New York's Special Housing Unit (SHU), a
housing unit within MCC New York where inmates are securely separated from the general inmate
population and kept locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours per day, to ensure their own safety as
well as the safety of staff and other inmates. On Monday, July 8, 2019, Epstein appeared in federal court
and pleaded not guilty to the charges. The court ordered that Epstein remain in custody pending a
detention hearing scheduled for July 15, 2019.

At the detention hearing, Epstein sought to be placed in home detention at his New York residence with
electronic monitoring and other conditions. The prosecutors sought to have Epstein detained at MCC
New York pending trial. The court reviewed the parties' filings and heard argument on the matter of pre-
trial release on July 15, 2019. On July 18, 2019, the court ordered that Epstein be detained pending trial. In
its ruling, the court noted that because Epstein had been indicted for a violation of the federal sex trafficking
statute that involved minor victims, there was a presumption in favor of detention under federal law. The
court found that the United States had shown by clear and convincing evidence that Epstein threatened the
safety of another person and of the community based on testimony from two victims, the allegations of
repeated sexual abuse of minors, and the lewd photographs of young-looking women or girls that were
found during an authorized search of Epstein's New York residence in July 2019. The court also relied on the
recommendation of U.S. Pretrial Services, the seriousness of the offenses with which Epstein had been
charged, evidence reflecting Epstein's harassment and intimidation of and tampering with witnesses
involved in a prior Florida state criminal investigation, and Epstein's lack of compliance with his legal
obligations as a registered sex offender. The court found that the United States had also shown by a
preponderance of the evidence that Epstein was a flight risk based on the severity of the criminal charges
and severity of the potential punishment; the strength of the evidence against Epstein; and Epstein's
criminal history, sex offender registration, vast wealth and substantial liquid assets, multiple residences, a
foreign residence, limited family ties in the United States, private plane(s), extensive overseas travel, and
possession of a foreign passport bearing Epstein's photograph but not his name. Finally, the court found
that Epstein's pretrial release proposal was inadequate because, among other things, it did not contain
sworn, accurate, or comprehensive financial statements; it required excessive court involvement in routine
aspects of the proposed home confinement; the proposed consent to extradition was unenforceable; and
the proposed appointment of a trustee to monitor Epstein's compliance with release conditions was
unacceptably vague and problematic due to the potential conflict of interest presented by monitoring the
conduct of a person who paid the trustee's salary, and allegations that Epstein engaged in unlawful acts with
his employees during the sex trafficking conspiracy. Epstein appealed the court's order on July 22, 2019.
This appeal remained pending at the time of Epstein's death.
II. MCC New York's Special Housing Unit
Epstein was initially assigned to MCC New York's general inmate population, but on July 7, 2019, at
approximately 7:20 p.m., he was moved to the SHU pending reclassification due to the significant increase in
media coverage and awareness of his notoriety among other MCC New York inmate residents. The SHU is a
housing unit within MCC New York where inmates are securely separated from the general inmate
population and kept locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day, to ensure their own safety as well
as the safety of staff and other inmates. Inmates in the SHU are either on administrative detention or
disciplinary segregation status. Administrative segregation status is a non-punitive designation that
removes an inmate from the general population when it is necessary to do so to ensure the safety, security,
and orderly operation of the correctional facility or to protect the public. The MCC New York employee who
was the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant on August 9, 2019, told the Office of the Inspector
General (OIG) that most inmates housed in the SHU are "locked down" in their cells for most of the day.
Other witnesses told the OIG that SHU inmates are locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day.
The Warden of MCC New York during Epstein's period of detention at that facility, along with Associate
Warden 1 and the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant, explained that this was one of the reasons
that conducting rounds in the SHU was so important. Unlike inmates in general population housing, SHU
inmates could not physically approach a staff member; therefore, the staff member had to go to each
inmate's cell.

Witnesses told the OIG that Epstein's daily routine in the SHU was to meet with his attorneys in the attorney
conference room all day until approximately 8 p.m.n MCC New York attorney logs confirmed that Epstein
had daily visits with attorneys from several different law practices throughout the period of his detention at
MCC New York. This is consistent with the information available in SENTRY, a BOP database that contains
information relating to the care, classification, subsistence, protection, discipline, and programs of federal
inmates, which indicates that Epstein had one to two attorney visits on all but 1 day he was detained at MCC
New York. BOP emails reflect that other attorneys expressed frustration to a Supervisory Staff Attorney with
the BOP's Consolidated Legal Center for New York because attorneys had to wait hours or were unable to
22 As discussed in Chapter 1, BOP policy provides that SHU Inmates may be escorted from their cells by MCC New York
staff for visits, including legal visits, court appearances, medical and psychological attention, showers, and 
recreation.
meet with their clients because Epstein and his attorneys were occupying the attorney conference room,
even at times when Epstein had to leave the conference room for a medical visit.

At MCC New York, the SHU was located on the south side of the institution's ninth floor and was often
referred to as "9 South." Primary access to the SHU was controlled by a locked door (Main Exterior Entry
Door). That door was opened remotely by a staff member in MCC New York's centralized Control Center.
Access into the SHU was further controlled by a second locked door (Main Interior Entry Door), to which a
limited number of Correctional Officers (CO) had keys while on duty.

Secondary access to the SHU was controlled by a locked door. That door was opened remotely by a staff
member in the centralized Control Center. Entry into the SHU from the secondary access point was further
controlled by three additional locked doors, to which a limited number of the COs had keys while on duty.
The secondary access doors were used only by staff when facilitating visits between the SHU inmates and
their outside visitors.

Within the SHU, inmates were assigned to six separate tiers or groups of cells, three of which were
accessible via stairs leading up from the common area on the ninth floor (Upper Tiers—G, J, and L Tiers) and
three of which were accessible via stairs leading down from the common area on the ninth floor (Lower
Tiers—H, K, and M Tiers). The entrance to each tier could be accessed only via a single locked door at the
top or bottom of the staircase leading to the individual tier. A limited number of keys to open the locked tier
doors were available only to a limited number of COs while on duty. Each tier had eight cells, each of which
could house either one or two inmates. Each individual cell, which was made of cement and metal, could be
accessed only through a single locked door, to which only a limited number of COs had keys while on duty.
The SHU cell doors were made of solid metal with a small glass window and small locked slots that
correctional staff used to handcuff inmates and provide food or toiletries to inmates. As a further security
measure, during each shift the keys to the SHU tier doors and SHU cell doors were carried by different COs.
As noted above, inmates in the SHU are securely separated from the general inmate population and are
kept locked in their cell when in their assigned tier within the SHU. Witnesses told the OIG that SHU inmates
are locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day. BOP policy provides that, weather and resources
permitting, SHU inmates will have the opportunity to exercise outside of their quarters 5 hours per calendar
week. Under federal regulations and BOP policy, SHU inmates ordinarily have the opportunity to shower at
least 3 times a week, typically on different days in 1-hour periods. SHU inmates may also be escorted from
their cells by MCC New York staff for visits, including legal visits, court appearances, medical and
psychological attention. The MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that all visitors to the SHU be
documented in the SHU visitor log, and that any inmate visiting the SHU, such as inmates on work details,
be searched visually and with a hand-held metal detector, without exception. The MCC New York SHU Post
Orders also require that food carts be searched inside and out before being brought into a SHU cellblock
and that all meals be delivered through the cell door food slot of the locked cell door.
Figure 4.1
Primary SHU Entrance (Ninth Floor)
Note: The photograph on the right has been modified for security reasons.

Source: DOJ OIG photographs and DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
Figure 4.2
Secondary SHU Entrance (Ninth Floor)
Note: The photograph on the right has been modified for security reasons.

Source: DOJ OIG photographs and DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
Figure 4.3
Tiered Structure of SHU (2-Dimensional)
Upper Tiers
Source: DOJ OIG schematic drawings depicting the MCC New York SHU
lower Tiers
Figure 4.4
Tiered Structure of SHU (3-Dimensional)
Source: DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
Figure 4.5
Stairways Leading to SHU Upper and Lower Tiers
Note: The photograph on the right has been modified for privacy reasons.

Source: DOJ OIG photographs and DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
Ill. Epstein's Initial Cell and Cellmate Assignment from July 7 to July 23
According to the Warden, MCC New York typically housed inmates in the SHU with a cellmate. Upon
Epstein's initial transfer to the SHU on July 7, 2019, he was assigned a cell in the M Tier of the SHU with
Inmate 1. The Warden explained that Epstein was a high-profile inmate and that he initially selected
Inmate 1 to be Epstein's cellmate because Inmate 1 was another high-profile inmate, and the Warden
believed Inmate 1 to be the least likely SHU inmate to harm Epstein!' Epstein and Inmate 1 were housed
together in cell Z05-124.

23 In 2008, Epstein pleaded guilty in a Florida state court to a felony charge of procurement of minors to engage in
prostitution in violation of Florida Statute § 796.03. As a result of this conviction, Epstein was required to register 
as a
sex offender.
IV. Events of July 23 and the Placement of Epstein on Suicide Watch and
Psychological Observation from July 23 to July 30
According to BOP documents, at approximately 1:27 a.m. on July 23, 2019, Senior Officer Specialists 1 and 2
heard noise coming from the M Tier in the SHU, the tier where Epstein was housed. Senior Officer
Specialist 2 documented in a BOP report that upon checking cell Z05-124, he saw Epstein laying down near
his bunk with "a piece of handmade orange cloth" around his neck, and Senior Officer Specialist 1 wrote in a
BOP report that Epstein's cellmate (Inmate 1) said Epstein had attempted to hang himself. In his interview
with the OIG, Senior Officer Specialist 1 said that Inmate 1, who appeared shaken up, told him that he had
been asleep on the floor of the cell and was awoken when he felt Epstein land on him. Senior Officer
Specialist 2 reported that after he had been alerted by the noise, he grabbed the door keys, called the
Control Center for assistance, and then he and Senior Officer Specialist 1 entered the cell, where they
secured and removed Epstein's cellmate. Senior Officer Specialist 1 reported that he then reentered the
cell, placed Epstein on his side, and removed "an orange homemade rope" from his neck. In his interview
with the OIG, Senior Officer Specialist 1 said Epstein had a sheet around his neck, which was attached to the
bunkbed ladder in the cell. Senior Officer Specialist 1 said that Epstein was sitting on the floor of the cell
with his back against the bunkbed ladder. Senior Officer Specialist l's report said that Epstein was
breathing, but unresponsive, so he began chest compressions, at which time the Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant and other staff arrived. Senior Officer Specialist 1 confirmed in his OIG interview that they
started cardiopulmonary resuscitation but stopped when they realized that Epstein was already breathing.
The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant documented in a BOP report that when she arrived at the SHU,
she saw Epstein lying in the fetal position in his cell, breathing heavily and snoring, wearing only a t-shirt and
boxers. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant observed that Epstein's neck was red, but she saw no
further injuries. She called out to Epstein, who flickered his eyes and continued snoring. The COs
unsuccessfully tried to get Epstein to stand on his own, and then placed him on a stretcher and took him to
the Health Services Unit.

According to BOP records, at approximately 1:40 a.m., Epstein was transferred out of the SHU and placed on
suicide watch. As previously noted in Chapter 2, inmates on suicide watch are housed in a dedicated room,
typically in the health services area, where they are continuously monitored by specially trained staff
or inmates.

Senior Officer Specialist 3 documented in a BOP report that when he and others responded to the call for
assistance and gained access to the SHU, he saw Epstein lying on the floor of his cell snoring. He and the
other officers verbally instructed Epstein to stand up, but Epstein did not. He and other officers then lifted
Epstein onto a stretcher to remove him from the cell.

Senior Officer Specialist 4 wrote in a BOP report that he responded to a body alarm in the SHU and helped
remove Epstein from his cell, placed him on a stretcher, and took him to the second floor for a medical
assessment. Senior Officer Specialist 4 further reported that, while he was observing Epstein in the Health
Services Unit, Epstein told Senior Officer Specialist 4 that he thought his cellmate had tried to kill him.
Epstein further stated that his cellmate had tried to extort him and that for the last week his cellmate had
threatened to beat him if he did not pay him. Epstein told Senior Officer Specialist 4 he had not reported
this to MCC New York staff, but that he had told his lawyers.

The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant documented in a BOP report that when she returned to the
Health Services Unit, Senior Officer Specialist 4 informed her that Epstein had said that his cellmate had
tried to kill Epstein and had been harassing him. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant then spoke
with the cellmate (Inmate 1), who said he was wearing headphones and was asleep when he felt something
hit his legs. Inmate 1 said he called out to Epstein and when Epstein did not answer, he got up, turned on
the light, and saw Epstein sitting on the floor, leaning to the side with a string around his neck. Inmate 1
told the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant that he then called the guards. Inmate 1 provided a similar
statement to BOP officials at approximately 2:50 p.m. on July 23, 2019.

The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant's report notes that she also spoke with Epstein, who told her that
he had returned to his cell after an attorney visit at approximately 8 p.m. the previous day, at which time his
cellmate was reading the Daily News newspaper. Epstein's said his cellmate turned to a page of the
newspaper that had Epstein's picture and reported that Epstein was worth $77 million. Epstein told the
Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant that he looked at his picture, balled it up, and threw it in the garbage.
Epstein further stated that he woke up at approximately 1 a.m. to get a drink of water, returned to his bunk,
and the next thing he remembered was that he was snoring and MCC New York staff were inside his cell.
When asked about the allegations against his cellmate, Epstein said he had been told that if his cellmate
hurt him, MCC New York staff would not care.

Inmate 2, who was housed in the same SHU tier as Epstein on July 23, told the FBI about an incident that
occurred in the SHU around 1:20 a.m. to 1:30 a.m. on an unspecified date. Inmate 2 said he was reading a
book when he heard an inmate scream and bang on the cell door to get the SHU officers' attention.
Inmate 2 said he could only see the cell door and not inside. According to Inmate 2, Senior Officer
Specialist 2 responded to the cell and then left and returned with additional officers. The FBI was further
told by Inmate 2 that the officers opened the cell door, removed an inmate, placed the inmate in handcuffs,
and put the inmate in the shower area. Inmate 2 stated that the officers reentered the cell and Inmate 2
heard a thump as if something had hit the floor. The officers then pulled the other inmate out of the cell,
placed him on a stretcher, and took him away. Inmate 2 also told the FBI that, later in the evening, around
2:10 a.m. to 2:15 a.m., the COs returned to the cell where the incident had occurred earlier. He said he
further observed the officers clean out the cell and use a video camera to record the inside of the cell.
Inmate 2 said he saw the officers remove from the cell orange clothing items that had been tied together.
Inmate 2 also said that the first inmate to be removed from the cell later told Inmate 2 that he was sleeping
when his cellmate had tried to kill himself by hanging himself from the ladder of the bed.
According to BOP records, medical staff evaluated Epstein at approximately 6:20 a.m. on July 23, 2019, and
observed friction marks and superficial reddening of his neck and one knee. The red mark spanned two-
thirds of Epstein's neck (front and sides) and was 2 inches wide. Epstein told the medical staff that he did
not know what had caused his injuries, and that he went to drink a little water and woke up snoring.
Later that morning, the MCC New York Staff Psychologist conducted a suicide risk assessment and
determined that Epstein should remain on suicide watch. During the assessment, Epstein denied any
knowledge of how he sustained the marks on his neck. The Staff Psychologist noted in the assessment
report that it was unclear whether Epstein had placed the string around his neck or if someone else did.
Medical staff examined Epstein at approximately 1:08 p.m. the following day, July 24, 2019, and observed
that the central part of the red mark on Epstein's neck had some abrasion. According to BOP records,
Epstein told the medical staff that he still did not want to talk about how he sustained his injuries, but he
believed that his cellmate had something to do with it. BOP's Special Investigative Services (SIS) opened an
investigation into this incident but was unable to determine whether Epstein harmed himself or had
been assaulted.

On July 24, 2019, at approximately 8:45 a.m., Epstein was removed from suicide watch. However, Epstein
remained in the same cell that he was placed in the previous day and was under psychological observation
until July 30, 2019.2'
The MCC New York Chief Psychologist told the OIG that an inmate is placed on suicide watch when the
inmate is believed to be imminently suicidal. During suicide watch, the inmate is under constant
observation by staff; the cell lights are on 24 hours a day; and the inmate is given a special mattress,
blanket, and smock to wear. The Chief Psychologist explained that although psychological observation is a
lower classification, at MCC New York the psychological observations were the same as suicide watch except
that inmates were allowed to have their clothing and some materials, such as books, as determined by
Psychology Department. At MCC New York, psychological observation was used to see how an inmate was
doing before releasing the inmate to a housing unit.

The Chief Psychologist told the OIG that the Psychology Department independently makes the decision who
goes on and off suicide watch. The Chief Psychologist also stated that the Psychology Department makes
recommendations to the institution's management about where inmates are housed when they come off of
suicide watch. According to her, the Psychology Department always recommends that inmates coming off
of suicide watch be housed with other inmates; however, she said the recommendations cannot always be
carried out due to other security factors. When that occurs, the Psychology Department recommends
conducting increased rounds and keeping an eye on those inmates.

The Chief Psychologist further told the OIG that, based on a conversation with the BOP's National Suicide
Prevention Coordinator from the BOP's Central Office, she passed along to the MCC New York executive
staff the recommendation that Epstein be housed with an alleged sex offender in the SHU.'s The Chief
Psychologist stated that the MCC New York Warden and Associate Wardens decided who Epstein would be
housed with and the Psychology Department was not involved in that decision.

According to BOP records, as a result of the July 23 incident, MCC New York subsequently conducted
disciplinary proceedings against Epstein for alleged self-mutilation, but ultimately found that there was
insufficient evidence to find that Epstein engaged in a prohibited act. When Epstein was psychologically
evaluated on July 30, 2019, in connection with disciplinary proceedings, Epstein said he did not remember
how he obtained the marks around his neck. On August 2, 2019, the SIS investigation into the July 23, 2019,
incident was completed and found insufficient evidence to support either that Epstein had harmed himself
or that he had been harmed by his cellmate.

24 Epstein's BOP medical records reflect that he was removed from psychological observation and returned to the SHU
on July 30, 2019.
25 Neither of Epstein's cellmates at MCC New York were alleged to be sex offenders.

Senior Officer Specialist 1 told the OIG that after Epstein came off of suicide watch, Epstein asked if he could
be paired up with Inmate 1 again. Senior Officer Specialist 1 told Epstein that his request was something he
would need to raise with the Operations Lieutenant. Senior Officer Specialist 1 told the OIG that Epstein
replied, "Yeah, but I don't understand, you know, we were bunkies, everything was cool." The Chief
Psychologist also told the OIG that Epstein mentioned to her that he wanted Inmate 1 to continue to be
his cellmate.
V. The Psychology Department's Post-July 23 Determination that Epstein Needed
to Have an Appropriate Cellmate
Following the events of July 23, the MCC New York Psychology Department determined that Epstein needed
to be housed with an appropriate cellmate. To ensure Epstein's cellmate requirement was disseminated to
MCC New York staff, on July 30, 2019, at 12:30 p.m., the Staff Psychologist sent an email to over 70 MCC
New York staff members which read, "Inmate Epstein #76318-054 is being taken off Psych Observation and
needs to be housed with an appropriate cellmate." A review of the email recipients showed that the email
was sent to, among others, the Warden, Associate Warden 2, the Captain, the SHU Lieutenant, the SIS
Lieutenant, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Morning
Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, and CO 1. The Staff Psychologist also
completed a "Post-Watch Report," which stated that the "SHU L[ieutenant] informed inmate Epstein needs
to be housed with an appropriate cellmate."
The Warden told the OIG that the Chief Psychologist had advised him that Epstein was not suicidal and was
ready to return to the SHU. According to the Warden, when he spoke with the Chief Psychologist regarding
Epstein, she told him to assign Epstein a cellmate. He added that MCC New York would typically house an
inmate who was previously on suicide watch with a cellmate. The Warden stated there was no BOP policy
mandating that an inmate coming off of suicide watch have a cellmate, but they usually housed such an
inmate with a cellmate.

During their interviews with the OIG, Associate Warden 1, the Captain, and the SHU Lieutenant each said
they had verbally informed the SHU staff of Epstein's cellmate requirement and were confident that all SHU
staff members knew of Epstein's cellmate requirement. Additionally, the Captain said he visited the SHU on
multiple occasions and directed his staff to be alert and attentive about Epstein's special needs.
According to Associate Warden 1, the Captain was in charge of correctional services, including the SHU.
Associate Warden 1 said the Captain should have told the SHU Lieutenant, and that the SHU Lieutenant
should have told the SHU staff about the cellmate requirement. Associate Warden 1 further told the OIG
that the SHU Lieutenant was responsible for ensuring that everything within the SHU was in compliance.
Associate Warden 1 told the OIG that the SHU staff knew that Epstein was required to have a cellmate, and
said she personally heard it being discussed on more than one occasion when she would visit the SHU while
performing her rounds.

The Captain, who supervised all of the Lieutenants and COs working in MCC New York, said that after the
cellmate requirement was issued for Epstein, he spoke with the SHU Lieutenant and directed him to ensure
that Epstein had a cellmate. Similar to the Warden, the SHU Lieutenant told the OIG that while there is no
BOP policy addressing the necessity of assigning cellmates to individuals coming off of suicide watch, it was
common practice in the BOP for prisoners coming off of suicide watch to be assigned a cellmate. The SHU
Lieutenant confirmed that a BOP psychologist told him that Epstein had to be housed with a cellmate when
Epstein returned to the SHU and said that he passed the directive down to the SHU staff.
Additionally, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge on August 9, 2019, said he and all other SHU staff were
aware of Epstein's cellmate requirement. MCC New York Psychology Department personnel told the 016
that MCC New York staff members knew of Epstein's cellmate requirement because it was discussed during
staff meetings, department head meetings, SHU meetings, morning meetings, and during required
staff training.

Forensic Psychologist 1 told the 016 that on August 9, 2019, she was present during a meeting in which one
of Epstein's attorneys opposed Epstein having a cellmate. Forensic Psychologist 1 said she explained to the
attorney that Epstein needed to have a cellmate because he was housed in the SHU and he was a
sex offender.
VI. Selection of Epstein's Cellmate After Psychological Observation
The Captain told the OIG that he compiled a list of possible cellmates for Epstein, vetted those inmates, and
provided the list of names to the MCC New York Warden. The Warden told the 016 that he identified two
potential cellmates and tentatively decided on Inmate 3. The Warden said he passed this information on to
the BOP Director's Chief of Staff and later received word that he should assign Inmate 3 to be
Epstein's cellmate.

The Warden told the OIG that no inmates were pre-vetted to replace Inmate 3 if he left MCC New York. The
Warden and the Captain told the OIG that if Inmate 3 had been removed as Epstein's cellmate, they would
have had to review a new list of potential cellmate candidates to ensure that Epstein was housed with an
appropriate inmate. According to the Warden and the Captain, if Inmate 3 was no longer detained at MCC
New York, SHU staff should have informed a Lieutenant on duty, who should have informed the Captain,
who would have ensured that the process of selecting a new cellmate for Epstein would begin.
VII. Epstein's Cell Assignment from July 30 to August 10
As a result of Epstein's cellmate requirement, on July 30, 2019, following his release from psychological
observation, Epstein was initially assigned to cell Z04-206 with Inmate 3 in the J Tier of the SHU.26 A BOP
26 SENTRY, which is BOP's database of information relating to the care, classification, subsistence, protection, 
discipline,
and programs of inmates, inaccurately reflected that this move from his psychological observation cell to the SHU
occurred the previous day Oily 29, 2019). The investigation revealed that Epstein was originally scheduled to return to
the SHU on July 29, 2019, but, at his request, he remained on psychological observation until July 30, 2019.
SENTRY was not updated to reflect either the actual date of Epstein's transfer back into the SHU or the cell to which he
and Inmate 3 were assigned after the initial cell change necessitated by the electrical needs of Epstein's medical 
device.
The administrative error in BOP's SENTRY records regarding Epstein's cell assignment had no effect on the events the
016 investigated and reviewed.

According to 016 interviews with MCC New York staff members, it does not appear that there were any checks to ensure
Continued
medical record note reflected that, on this same date, Epstein was provided with his personally-owned
medical device. BOP witnesses told the OIG that on that same date, Epstein and Inmate 3 were moved to
cell Z06-220 in the L Tier of the SHU to accommodate the electrical needs of Epstein's medical device. Of all
the cells in the SHU, cell Z06-220 was the closest cell with a direct line of sight to the SHU Officers' Station in
the common area of the SHU, which was approximately 15 feet away.

Inmate 3 told the OIG that when he and Epstein were first assigned as cellmates in cell Z06-220 in the L Tier,
the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant told Inmate 3 that he had a "cool bunkie" for him, an "old guy" who
would not bother Inmate 3. Inmate 3 said he told the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant that he slept on the
bottom bunk, and the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant said that would not be a problem because his new
cellmate slept on the floor. Inmate 3 said he was surprised by this response because he understood that
sleeping on the floor was not allowed and he had previously been disciplined for doing so.
When Epstein arrived in the cell, Inmate 3 recognized him and said he (Inmate 3) told the Day Watch
Operations Lieutenant that the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant had "jammed up" Inmate 3. Inmate 3 said
he knew Epstein had tried to hang himself and had just come from suicide watch. According to Inmate 3,
the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant told Inmate 3 not to worry, that Epstein was okay, and that Inmate 3
should keep an eye on him. Inmate 3 asked the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant if he was supposed to
serve as a suicide prevention advocate, that is, an inmate who is assigned to the suicide watch area.
Inmate 3 said the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant laughed and brushed off Inmate 3's comment.
According to Inmate 3, COs brought two mattresses to the cell for Epstein and placed them on the floor.
Epstein put the mattresses on the right side of the cell, which is only partially visible through the cell door
window when the cell door is closed. Inmate 3 noted that Epstein also had two extra blankets, which Inmate
3 said was also unusual because none of the inmates had extra blankets.

Inmate 3 said he asked Epstein to please not kill himself or hang himself while Inmate 3 was his cellmate
because Inmate 3 had a chance to go home soon. Epstein told Inmate 3 not to worry and that he was not
going to cause Inmate 3 any trouble.

that inmates were physically located in the cells to which they were assigned in SENTRY. Associate Warden 1 told the
OIG that the error would have been identified if SHU staff members had conducted a bed-book count, but there was no
requirement to do a bed-book count every certain number of days. Associate Warden 1 explained that during a bed-
book count, the staff members have a roster with them while conducting the count of inmates assigned to their housing
unit to ensure all inmates are accounted for and in their assigned cells. The OIG's investigation revealed that these 
and
other cell assignment and recordkeeping errors would have been uncovered had MCC New York SHU staff been
undertaking inmate accountability measures, such as rounds, counts, census checks, and bed-book checks.
Figure 4.6
SHU L Tier
Sources: DOJ OIG schematic d awing depicting the MCC New York SHU; and photograph taken by the Office of the Chief
Medical Examiner. City of New York (OCME)
Figure 4.7
Exterior Views of Epstein's Cell
Note: Both photographs have been modified for security reasons and the left photograph has been modified for privacy
reasons.
Sources: DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU; OCME photographs
Figure 4.8
The Door to the Cell Occupied by Epstein and Inmate 3 from July 30 to August 9
Note: The photograph has been modified for privacy reasons.
Source: OCME
Figure 4.9
View of Epstein's Empty Cell from Cell Door Window
Source: DOJ OIG photograph and DO OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
Figure 4.10
Interior View of Epstein's Empty Cell from Just Inside the Cell Door
Source: DOJ OIG photograph and DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
Figure 4.11
View of Epstein's Cell Door from the SHU Officers' Station
Epstein's Cell Door
Note: The photograph has been modified for security and privacy reasons.

Source: D0J 0IG photograph and D0J 0IG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
Figure 4.12
View of the SHU Officers' Station from Epstein's cell
Note: The photograph has been modified for security reasons.

Source: DOJ OIG photograph and DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
VIII. Psychological Evaluations of Epstein from July 6 to August 9
During Epstein's detention at MCC New York, a variety of medical professionals, including a Medical Doctor,
a Clinical Nurse, and Physician Assistant 1, who is a Mid-Level Practitioner, conducted multiple medical
appointments with Epstein, and Epstein was prescribed a variety of medications for various ailments and
health needs. Epstein was also given an eye and dental exam, as well as a blood panel screening. This
section details Epstein's psychological evaluations while he was in MCC New York custody prior to his death.
On Saturday, July 6, 2019, at 9:38 p.m., upon Epstein's intake into MCC New York, he was medically screened
by Physician Assistant 2. The screening included taking vital signs and asking various medical history
questions, including questions related to Epstein's mental health. Among other things, Physician Assistant 2
annotated that Epstein did not have current suicidal ideation and had denied having a history of suicide
attempts. Physician Assistant 2 instructed Epstein how he could obtain medical, dental, and mental
health care.

At 2:58 a.m. on Sunday, July 7, 2019, a Facilities Assistant emailed the Psychology Department asking that
someone evaluate Epstein because he appeared "distraught, sad, and a little confused."
On July 8, 2019, Forensic Psychologist 1 of the Psychology Department conducted an Intake Screening of
Epstein that included a self-report, staff observation, and a review of information in SENTRY. Forensic
Psychologist 1 noted that during Physician Assistant l's initial intake evaluation, on the intake questionnaire,
Epstein denied having a history of mental health treatment and any history of mental health symptoms.
Additionally, Forensic Psychologist 1 noted no suicidal ideations, attempts, or self-harm; no history of
substance abuse or treatment; and no sexual offense convictions.

During the evaluation, Epstein stated he had been previously incarcerated for 3 months for "prostitution,"
and that he was currently charged with sex trafficking. Epstein denied recent or present morbid thoughts
and denied passive or active suicidal ideation. It was noted in BOP records that Epstein's verbalizations
were future -oriented and did not have indications of helpless or hopeless thinking.

According to Forensic Psychologist 1, Epstein did not meet the criteria for any psychological diagnosis and
was designated as Mental Health Care Code 1. This is indicative of an inmate who does not show any
significant level of functional impairment associated with a mental illness and does not demonstrate a need
for regular mental health intervention. Epstein was educated on emergency procedures for contacting the
Psychology Department staff, and Epstein agreed to contact staff if he needed Psychology Department
services in the future.

The MCC New York Chief Psychologist told the OIG that based on the Psychological Services Intake
Questionnaire, inmates have four different Care Code ratings.27 Code 1 means there are no concerns about
the inmate's mental health status; they have no needs and will not be followed up with unless requested by
staff or the inmates. Code 2 means there is some history of mental health issues, but the inmate has them
under control and the Psychology Department will follow up monthly. Code 3 is more severe, requiring
weekly visits by the Psychology Department to ensure the inmate is stable and if unstable would be moved
to observation. Code 4 inmates are seen daily by the Psychology Department and are under constant
psychological observation. The Chief Psychologist stated that a Code 1 inmate can be on suicide watch.
Suicide watch is for inmates who are showing immediate and exigent signs of being suicidal.
Subsequent to the intake screening, on July 8, 2019, the Chief Psychologist consulted with the National
Suicide Prevention Coordinator from the BOP's Central Office, regarding the various risk factors associated
with Epstein for suicidality. These risk factors were that Epstein was involved in a high-profile case with
media attention, had been charged with sex offenses, was on pretrial status, and there was the potential for
bad news from a court proceeding that day. A determination was made that upon Epstein's return from
court, staff were to notify the psychologist and place Epstein on a "watch status" until a thorough suicide risk
assessment could be conducted.

When Epstein returned from court on July 8, 2019, it was after duty hours and MCC New York staff contacted
the Psychology Department and informed them that Epstein denied suicidality. However, for precautionary
reasons, Epstein was placed on psychological observation status until Psychology Department staff could
conduct a suicide risk assessment the following day. During Epstein's period of psychological observation,
inmate companions continuously observed him and kept a log that detailed Epstein's activities in 15-minute
increments. Under BOP policy, on a case-by-case basis, the Warden may authorize such an inmate
27 Upon reviewing a draft of this report, the Chief Psychologist noted that mental health care is classified into 
"levels,"
not "codes."
companion program at an institution to utilize inmate observers, who are selected, trained, and supervised
by the institution's Suicide Prevention Program Coordinator.

On July 9, 2019, the Chief Psychologist conducted a suicide assessment of Epstein. She reviewed Epstein's
medical record and interviewed him, which revealed that he possessed some risk factors for suicidality.
Epstein denied having any past or present suicidal ideation, intention, or plan, and also denied having any
history of mental health treatment or any current mental health symptoms. The Chief Psychologists
assessment was that Epstein had "protective" factors present that could decrease his risk of suicide. The
Chief Psychologist assessed factors that included his willingness to engage in treatment, view of death as
negative, future orientation, and the fact that he adamantly denied any suicidal ideation, intention, or plan.
The Chief Psychologist's assessment was that Epstein had numerous protective factors that outweighed his
risk factors for suicidality and that he had a positive outlook regarding his legal case. Epstein remained on
psychological observation pending a suitable cell assignment, and the Chief Psychologist noted that a
suicide watch was not warranted at the time of her report.

On July 10, 2019, the Chief Psychologist met with Epstein for a psychological observation and noted that,
according to the psychological observation logbook, Epstein had been eating his meals, sleeping, and
interacting with other inmates. During this meeting with the Chief Psychologist, Epstein voiced concerns
over being housed in the SHU. Epstein asked the Chief Psychologist to be "single-celled" if he were to be
housed in the SHU and had also requested a shower, his property, pen, and paper. The Chief Psychologist
stated Epstein had been provided a shower on this date. She provided Epstein with coping skills strategies,
to which he was receptive. Epstein continued to deny any suicidal ideation, intention, or plan; and Epstein
stated he was looking forward to his upcoming court hearing regarding pretrial release. The Chief
Psychologists assessment was that Epstein was psychologically stable at the time and that he could be
released from the psychological observation area. She noted that Epstein would be housed in the SHU with
a cellmate and would be seen the following morning to evaluate his mental status and stability. Following
this July 10 assessment, Epstein was taken off of psychological observation and returned to the SHU with
documented recommendations for a cellmate and next-day contact by the Psychology Department.
The following day, July 11, 2019, the Staff Psychologist attempted to see Epstein in the morning and
afternoon, but he was meeting with his attorneys. Since the Staff Psychologist was unable to meet with
Epstein, the Chief Psychologist met with Epstein in the attorney conference area for a psychological
observation follow-up. During this meeting, Epstein expressed concerns about a number of issues,
including not yet receiving his property, not having enough water during his attorney conference, and a
desire to attend recreation. Epstein was upset about having to wear an orange uniform and the Chief
Psychologist explained the orange uniform was because he was being housed in the SHU. During this
clinical contact, the Chief Psychologist provided Epstein with additional coping strategies, to which he was
receptive. Additionally, Epstein was educated about routine and emergency procedures for contacting the
Psychology Department staff and reminded of self-help books and audiotapes available through the
Psychology Department. Epstein continued to deny any suicidal ideation, intention, or plan and was
scheduled to be seen again the following week. The Chief Psychologist told the DIG that Epstein and his
attorney mocked her for thinking Epstein was suicidal.n
On July 16, 2019, at Epstein's request, the Chief Psychologist met with Epstein during his attorney
conference. The Chief Psychologist noted that Epstein did not have any psychological concerns and denied
suicidality. The Chief Psychologist noted that she provided Epstein with psychoeducation regarding
additional coping strategies. Epstein was educated about routine and emergency procedures to contact
Psychology Department staff and reminded of self-help books and audiotapes that are available to him. The
Chief Psychologist noted in her clinical contact report that there was no need for follow-up and that Epstein
would be seen in the SHU for rounds and monthly SHU reviews.

According to the SOP After Action Review submitted by the Southeast Regional Director, the Chief
Psychologist's meeting with Epstein on July 16, 2019, at Epstein's request during his attorney conference was
inappropriate. The Southeast Regional Director wrote in the report that Epstein attempted to "bring his
attorneys into the fray regarding the mental hearth treatment being provided by the institution." In the
After Action Review, the Southeast Regional Director wrote that it was not typical for the BOP to provide
psychological intervention in the presence of others, nor was it appropriate for a BOP psychologist to meet
with an inmate's attorney. When asked by the OIG about these findings, the Chief Psychologist stated that
the intention was to check on Epstein, not to breach any security.

On July 18, 2019, the Chief Psychologist conducted a monthly SHU review and noted that Epstein was
unavailable due to a meeting with his legal team and that she would attempt to interview Epstein in the near
future to complete his monthly review.

As noted previously, at approximately 1:27 a.m. on July 23, 2019, Epstein was found lying on the floor of his
cell with a piece of homemade orange cloth around his neck. The Chief Psychologist made a general
administrative note in Epstein's file that she was contacted by the Operations Lieutenant at approximately
2 a.m., and informed that Epstein was being placed on suicide watch after he was found with a string loosely
hanging around his neck. That morning, Physician Assistant 1 assessed Epstein for injuries and noted in
BOP records that Epstein was cooperative, alert, and oriented. According to BOP's medical records, Epstein
did not appear distressed and was smiling during the clinical assessment. Epstein said he did not know
what had happened and could not explain the mark on his neck. Physician Assistant 1 noted that Epstein
had a circular line of erythema, i.e., superficial redness on the skin, that was 2 inches wide and spanned two-
thirds of the way around the front and sides of the base of his neck. According to the BOP report, one
section of the erythema (or redness) in the front of his neck had marks of friction, and there was no
inflammation, deformities, hematomas, lacerations, or tenderness. The SOP report stated that Epstein was
able to move his neck without any restriction and denied having any pain, discomfort, or respiratory
problems. Physician Assistant 1 further noted there was another small erythema (or redness) on Epstein's
left knee about 2 centimeters in diameter, which was noted as mild. Physician Assistant l's assessment was
that the injury was unspecified and was self-inflicted.

21 upon reviewing a draft of this report, the Chief Psychologist noted that Epstein's attorneys were not "mocking" her;
the attorneys and Epstein were simply laughing at the fact that she was inquiring as to whether Epstein was suicidal and
dismissing the possibility that Epstein could be suicidal.

Also on July 23, 2019, the Staff Psychologist conducted a suicide risk assessment that included a clinical
interview of Epstein and a review of Epstein's medical record, the psychology data system, and a review of
the SENTRY database. According to the Staff Psychologist's report, Epstein denied knowing why he was
placed on suicide watch. BOP records state that Epstein recalled getting a drink of water the night prior and
then went back to bed. Epstein's next recollection was hearing himself snoring. The BOP assessment
records reflect that Epstein wanted to know why he was on suicide watch and he was informed that he had
been found with a string on his neck. The Staff Psychologist noted that it was unclear whether Epstein had
placed the string around his neck or if someone else did. Epstein denied current suicidal or self-harm
thoughts or ever having these thoughts; denied a history of self-harm and suicide attempts; and denied
feeling hopeless and fearing for his safety. Epstein told the Staff Psychologist that he lived to enjoy life and
that his future plans included fighting his criminal case and getting back to his normal life. The Staff
Psychologist noted that Epstein was to remain on suicide watch for further observation. The Staff
Psychologist told the OIG she had advised BOP staff that Epstein would need a cellmate.
The Chief Psychologist said she considered three possibilities to explain the July 23 incident: (1) Epstein
and/or Inmate 1 were gaming the system to get something they wanted that they were not getting
(2) Epstein, who really was suicidal, had conducted a rehearsal; or (3) Inmate 1 had assaulted Epstein. The
Chief Psychologist told the OIG that after Epstein told her he wanted to be housed with the same cellmate
he originally said had assaulted him, she began to think that the third possibility (assault by Inmate 1) was
less plausible than the other two possibilities, although she did not know for certain.
The following day, July 24, medical staff examined Epstein at approximately 1:08 p.m., and observed that the
central part of the red mark on Epstein's neck had some abrasion. Epstein told the medical staff that he still
did not want to talk about how he sustained his injuries, but he believed that his cellmate had something to
do with it. GOP's SIS opened an investigation into this incident but was unable to determine whether
Epstein had harmed himself or had been assaulted.

On July 24, 2019, after 31 hours and 5 minutes, Epstein was removed from suicide watch. Epstein remained
in the same cell that he was in under suicide watch and was under psychological observation until July 30,
2019.29 Also on July 24, 2019, Forensic Psychologist 2 completed a Post Suicide Watch Report. According to
Forensic Psychologist 2's report, Epstein continued to claim a lack of memory regarding how he sustained
the scar around his neck. The SOP report further stated that Epstein adamantly denied suicidal ideation,
intentions, and plans, that Epstein identified reasons to live and was future -oriented, and that Epstein was
assessed for a willingness to engage in treatment. The BOP report reflected that Forensic Psychologist 2
inquired further if Epstein could recall the previous days incident and Epstein stated that he had been trying
to remember. Forensic Psychologist 2 asked Epstein why he told another inmate that Epstein's cellmate had
tried to kill him but was now claiming he has no memory of the incident Epstein told Forensic
Psychologist 2 that he did not recall himself or his cellmate tying a string or rope around his neck.
Following Forensic Psychologist 2's examination of Epstein, she determined that he should be removed from
suicide watch. Forensic Psychologist 2 told the FBI that she discussed the decision to step Epstein down to
psychological observation from suicide watch with the Chief Psychologist and Associate Warden 2, who both
" Epstein's BOP medical records reflect that he was removed from psychological observation and returned to the SHU
on July 30, 2019; however, SENTRY inaccurately reflects that Epstein was transferred back to the SHU on July 29, 2019.
concurred with her determination. Epstein was therefore taken off suicide watch and placed on
psychological observation, during which time BOP records reflect that he was continuously observed by
inmate companions and seen daily by Psychology Department staff. Forensic Psychologist 2 annotated in
the Post Suicide Watch Report that the reason for removing Epstein from suicide watch was due to Epstein
stating he had no interest in killing himself; he had described having a wonderful life; and Epstein had said it
would be crazy to take his own life and he would not do that to himself. Forensic Psychologist 2 told the FBI
that following her clinical visit with Epstein on July 24, 2019, she was cautious with Epstein's case and his
self-reporting of what had occurred the previous day. Forensic Psychologist 2 stated that she observed
signs of positivity and that Epstein "adamantly denied suicide." Nevertheless, she was not comfortable
taking Epstein off suicide watch and instead opted to place Epstein on psychological observation, which was
a step down from suicide watch. Forensic Psychologist 2 told the FBI that"! made the decision with the
consent" of the Chief Psychologist and Associate Warden 2, with whom she had consulted. Forensic
Psychologist 2 told the FBI that placing Epstein on psychological observation allowed him to possess hygiene
products, two novels, attend legal visits, and take showers. It also allowed him to have standard inmate
clothing, a flex pen, a toothbrush and toothpaste, soap, and deodorant. However, Forensic Psychologist 2
explained that it was not healthy for inmates to stay on suicide watch for extended periods of time and they
are re-evaluated on a day-to-day basis.

According to Forensic Psychologist 2's Post Suicide Watch Report, Epstein expressed a feeling of safety being
housed in the psychological observation area rather than the SHU and asked if there was a safer unit for
him to be housed. Forensic Psychologist 2 informed Epstein that he would remain on psychological
observation for the near future, but his long-term housing would need to be revisited because it is not ideal
to remain in psychological observation for extended periods of time. The BOP report states that Epstein
was again educated on routine and emergency procedures for contacting Psychology Department staff.
According to BOP records, between July 25-29, 2019, Epstein was seen daily by the Chief Psychologist or the
Staff Psychologist while he was on psychological observation. On each of these dates, according to BOP
reports, Epstein adamantly denied any suicidality and denied having any memory of what occurred on
July 23, 2019, which resulted in him being placed on suicide watch. Additionally, on each date, Epstein was
provided with supportive and coping skill interventions to which he was receptive. SOP records state that
Epstein expressed concerns about being housed again in the SHU because he felt it was dangerous; he
could not sleep well due to noise from other inmates; and it was difficult for him to work on his legal case.
The Chief Psychologist told the FBI and the OIG that she met with Epstein on July 25, 2019, and he was in
good spirits. She said that during this clinical visit, Epstein said he was baffled over the July 23, 2019 incident
and asked the Chief Psychologist to give him some cues to help him remember. The Chief Psychologist told
the OIG that she kept Epstein on psychological observation because he had not answered her questions
regarding the possible suicide attempt. The Chief Psychologist told the OIG that she coordinated with the
BOP's National Suicide Prevention Coordinator, who recommended that Epstein be housed with a sex
offender in the SHU. The Chief Psychologist notified Associate Warden 2 of this recommendation via email.
BOP records further reflect that, during his clinical visit on July 28, 2019, Epstein told the Staff Psychologist
that he was agitated for hours the previous night because of a non-stop toilet flushing and that the noise
was similar to when he was housed in the SHU. The Staff Psychologist informed Epstein that he would be
moving to a different cell.

On July 29, 2019, according to BOP records, Epstein reported to the Chief Psychologist that his memory of
the July 23, 2019 incident may be impaired because of his sleep apnea. On this date, Epstein was to receive
his personally owned medical device. BOP records state that Epstein was aware he would be returning to
the SHU but reported that he did not feel well due to lack of sleep and other medical concerns. Epstein
asked to stay on psychological observation, where he felt safe, for one more night to get some sleep and
then return to the SHU with a cellmate the following day. According to SOP records, the Chief Psychologist
informed Epstein that he could stay 1 more night and explained that there were no mental health issues
precluding him from returning to the SHU the following day. The Chief Psychologist explained to Epstein
that he would be placed in a safe situation in the SHU. Epstein again was provided supportive interventions
and psychoeducation regarding additional coping strategies. BOP records state that Epstein was somewhat
receptive but more concerned with getting phone calls, recreation, and housing placement concerns.
On July 30, 2019, according to SOP records, Epstein reported to the Staff Psychologist that he had not slept
well, and Epstein discussed how he did not think he would be able to sleep well in the SHU because of the
noise. The Staff Psychologist annotated in the clinical contact summary that documentation revealed
Epstein had eaten and taken a shower the day prior (July 29) and also had eaten breakfast on July 30. The
Staff Psychologist annotated, Epstein did not display indications of disturbed thought process or content
and denied current suicidal or self-harm ideation. BOP records further stated that Epstein agreed to
immediately report to staff if he began to have suicidal or self-harm thoughts and that Epstein was future -
oriented and did not appear to be a danger to himself. The Staff Psychologist noted in her clinical contact
report that she had consulted with the Chief Psychologist and that psychological observation of Epstein
would be discontinued. According to her clinical contact report, the Staff Psychologist educated Epstein
about routine and emergency procedures for contacting Psychology Department staff and noted that
Epstein would be seen the following day to monitor his mental status and provide further intervention if
needed. The Staff Psychologist also noted in her report that the SHU Lieutenant was informed that Epstein
needed to be housed with an appropriate cellmate.

Also on July 30, 2019, the Staff Psychologist completed an evaluation of competency related to Epstein being
able to proceed with the disciplinary process. Epstein had been charged by BOP with a prohibited act,
specifically tattooing or self-mutilation, for the incident that occurred on July 23, 2019. In conducting the
evaluation of competency, the Staff Psychologist reviewed the suicide risk assessment completed by the
Chief Psychologist on July 9, 2019, in which Epstein had denied a history of mental health treatment and
having any past or present suicidal ideation, intention, or plan. The Staff Psychologist also reviewed the
suicide risk assessment that she herself completed, dated July 23, 2019, which stated that it was unclear at
the time if Epstein had placed the string around his neck or if it was done by someone else. According to
the Staff Psychologist's notes from her competency evaluation on July 30, the determination of an inmate's
competency to proceed with the disciplinary process was based on a clinical assessment of the inmate's
ability to understand the nature of the proceedings and his or her ability to assist in his or her own defense.
After a review of available psychological and psychiatric records and information related to the offense, the
Staff Psychologist found that Epstein was competent to proceed with the disciplinary process.
That same day, July 30, Epstein was removed from psychological observation and transferred back to the
SHU, consistent with what he had been told by the Chief Psychologist the prior day.

On July 31, 2019, according to SOP records, Forensic Psychologist 3 conducted a clinical visit with Epstein
and noted that he was in a pleasant mood, generally slept well, and was getting readjusted to being in the
SHU. Epstein told Forensic Psychologist 3 that he was getting along with his cellmate. According to her
report, Epstein explicitly denied recent and current suicidal ideation or intent and denied having thoughts of
harming others. Epstein also agreed to contact staff immediately if he experienced any suicidal thoughts or
psychological distress. Forensic Psychologist 3's report further stated that Epstein was receptive to her
utilization of cognitive behavioral therapeutic techniques. She wrote that there did not appear to be a need
for follow-up at the time and Epstein expressed a willingness to self-refer to Psychology Department staff if
needed. According to the report, Epstein would continue to be seen during routine SHU rounds and
SHU reviews.

On August 1, 2019, according to BOP records, BOP Receiving and Discharge staff, who are responsible for
processing inmates who enter or leave the facility, notified the Staff Psychologist that the previous day when
the U.S. Marshals Service (USMS) had brought Epstein back to MCC New York from court, they had provided
a form on which it was noted that Epstein had "suicidal tendencies." The OIG reviewed the USMS Prisoner
Schedule Report for July 31, 2019, as well as the USMS Prisoner Custody Alert Notice that had annotated in
the remarks that Epstein had "Mental Concerns: Suicidal Tendencies." The Chief Psychologist told the OIG
that the USMS annotates suicidal tendencies for many inmates if the USMS was aware the inmate was
previously on suicide watch. Therefore, the Chief Psychologist said the annotation was not abnormal since
Epstein had just come off suicide watch and Epstein may have told the USMS that he had been on
suicide watch.

Following receipt of this information from the Receiving and Discharge staff, the Staff Psychologist
conducted a suicide risk assessment on August 1 that included a review of Epstein's previous clinical
encounters, medical records, and data in the Psychology Department and SENTRY systems. According to
the Staff Psychologist's assessment, Epstein denied stating he was suicidal and was surprised that the form
noted that he had suicidal tendencies. The Staff Psychologist said that Epstein told her that the incident
report he received for the marks on his neck arising from the July 23 event had been expunged. The OIG
confirmed that the incident report was expunged. Epstein also said his cellmate talked at night and kept
Epstein awake but that Epstein wanted to give it 3 to 4 more days before determining if he wanted another
cellmate. The Staff Psychologist concluded in her report that Epstein did not appear to be a danger to
himself and denied current suicidal or self-harm ideation and agreed to immediately inform staff if he had
any of these thoughts. Epstein told her that he had social supports in the community and that he had
reasons to live and positive future plans. The Staff Psychologist noted that Epstein was currently
psychologically stable and that suicide watch was not indicated at the time. The Staff Psychologist
concluded that Epstein's overall acute suicide risk was low, and the overall chronic suicide risk was absent.
Epstein was again provided supportive and educative interventions and educated about routine and
emergency procedures for contacting Psychology Department staff. The Staff Psychologists report noted
that Epstein would continue to be seen during routine SHU rounds and SHU reviews and that he would be
seen by Psychology Department staff the following week to monitor his mental status and provide further
intervention, if needed.

On August 8, 2019, the Chief Psychologist conducted a clinical follow-up session with Epstein. According to
her report, Epstein described his sleep as fair and requested that he be placed in general population. The
report further stated that Epstein denied feelings of depression, anxiety, and any suicidal ideation,
intention, or plan. Epstein told the Chief Psychologist that he received the necessary documentation to
make phone calls and asked if his previous phone calls over the speaker phone counted as his monthly
phone contact. The Chief Psychologist stated in her report that Epstein had no mental health concerns and
did not appear to be in any distress. The Chief Psychologist wrote that SHU staff had not reported any
unusual behaviors related to Epstein. She provided Epstein with supportive interventions and
psychoeducation regarding additional coping strategies, to which Epstein was receptive. Epstein was
educated on routine and emergency procedures for contacting Psychology Department staff and also
reminded of self-help books and audiotapes that are available to him. The Chief Psychologist wrote that
Epstein would be seen in weekly SHU rounds and monthly for SHU reviews. The Chief Psychologist told the
OIG that the fact that Epstein underwent three suicide risk assessments was unusual. 3°
Upon reviewing a draft of this report, the Chief Psychologist noted that it was not unusual for someone with static risk
factors like Epstein to have received multiple suicide risk assessments. According to the Chief Psychologist upon
reviewing a draft of this report, what was unusual was the fact that Epstein was in attomey conference "day and night
on a daily basis due to his financial resources." She noted that It was difficult for Psychology Department staff to
interview Epstein because he had a right to his attorney visits, which would last throughout the working day.
Chapter 5: The Events of August 8-10, 2019, and Epstein's Death

I. Epstein Signs a New Last Will and Testament on August 8
In the weeks following Epstein's death, multiple media outlets reported that Epstein signed a new Last Will
and Testament on August 8, 2019. At least one media organization published a copy of the notarized
document showing that it was signed by Epstein and two of his attorneys and notarized on August 8, 2019.
Attorney visitor logs from the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York, New York (MCC New York)
confirmed that those attorneys and the notary public visited Epstein on that date. The Office of the
Inspector General (OIG) confirmed via court records that the August 8, 2019 will and other probate -related
documents were filed in the Superior Court of the Virgin Islands on August 15, 2019. Among the court filings
was an affidavit from another attorney who stated that she received the August 8, 2019 will from Epstein.
The OIG confirmed via attorney visitor logs that this attorney also visited Epstein at MCC New York on
August 8, 2019. The OIG's investigation and review revealed that MCC New York personnel were unaware
that Epstein had changed his will 2 days before he died.

The Chief Psychologist said she had heard that Epstein had changed his will from media reporting following
his death. The Chief Psychologist did not know if the media reporting was accurate, but she thought that if
it were true, it would have been useful information to know because it would have been a red flag. The Staff
Psychologist and the Chief Psychologist told the OIG that if Epstein's attorneys had notified them or the
Psychology Department that Epstein had changed his will, such information would have been a factor
warranting a review of Epstein's mental state and Epstein probably would have been placed back on suicide
watch or some type of observation.

II. Court Order on August 9 Releasing Epstein -Related Documents in Pending
Civil Litigation
On August 9, 2019, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ordered the unsealing of the summary
judgment filings from a defamation lawsuit filed b  a woman who alleged that
Epstein had victimized her when she was a teenager, against Ghislaine Maxwell.3' As a result of the court's
order, that same day approximately 2,000 pages of documents were released into the public domain, which
contained considerable derogatory information about Epstein and some may have related to the criminal
charges pending against him. Additional high-profile public figures were also named in the released
documents. There was significant media coverage of information contained within the unsealed
court filings.

31 Maxwell was subsequently indicted and, in December 2021, convicted of conspiring with Epstein to sexually
abuse minors.
III. Transfer of Epstein's Cellmate on August 9 to Another Institution and Failure
to Replace Him with Another Inmate

A. Notice on August 8 of the Impending Transfer of Epstein's Cellmate on August 9
As noted above, since July 30, consistent with the Psychology Department's determination that Epstein
needed to have a cellmate, Epstein had been housed with Inmate 3, whom the Warden and the Federal
Bureau of Prisons (BOP) executive leadership had selected as an appropriate cellmate. At 10:33 a.m. on
August 8, 2019, the U.S. Marshals Service (USMS) sent an email to MCC New York personnel assigned to
Receiving and Discharge, the area within the Correctional Services Department that is responsible for
processing inmates who enter or leave the facility, with the subject "Transfer of Prisoners from NYM [MCC
New York] to GEO."32 The body of the email identified Inmate 3 as one of the prisoners to be transferred
and further stated, "Please schedule the transfer for Friday 8/9/19."
At 3:36 p.m. on the same day, the USMS sent a second email to a number of MCC New York personnel,
including Associate Warden 2, the Captain, the SHU Lieutenant, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, the
Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, another Lieutenant, and the
Special Investigative Services Lieutenant, with the subject "Prisoner Production 08-09-2019." This email
contained two attachments, one of which was the Prisoner Schedule Report for MCC New York for August 9,

2019. The first page of this attachment reflects that Inmate 3 was scheduled to be transferred from MCC
New York to GEO (Queens Detention Facility) on August 9, 2019. This attachment also includes the acronym
"WAB" within the Destination/Description portion of the document, which MCC New York personnel told the
OIG means "with all belongings." During their OIG interviews, MCC New York staff members further
explained that the 'WAB" notation meant that Inmate 3 was being permanently removed from MCC
New York on August 9, 2019. Notwithstanding this email, as detailed below, several of the email recipients
identified above, including the Captain, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, and the Day Watch Activities
Lieutenant told the OIG that they believed Inmate 3 had gone to court on August 9, and they did not know
he had been transferred to another facility.

B. MCC New York Staff Reject Epstein Attorney's Request that Epstein be Housed
Without a Cellmate
Forensic Psychologist 1 told the OIG that on August 9, 2019, she was present during a meeting in which one
of Epstein's attorneys opposed Epstein having a cellmate. Forensic Psychologist 1 explained to the attorney
that because Epstein was housed in the SHU and he was a sex offender, he needed to have a cellmate.
Additionally, the OIG investigation revealed that on the day of Epstein's death, a Supervisory Staff Attorney
with the BOP's Consolidated Legal Center for New York, sent an email to the Warden to inform him that on
the previous day (August 9, 2019), two of Epstein's attorneys separately contacted him. One of the attorneys
asked for Epstein to be moved to a different, specific housing unit within MCC New York; the other attorney
asked for Epstein to be housed without a cellmate in the SHU. The Supervisory Staff Attorney said he
informed the first attorney that the suggested housing unit was not available for pretrial detainees such as
32 GEO refers to the Queens Detention Facility, a contract detention facility located in Queens, New York, that is
managed by The GEO Group, Inc.

Epstein, and he said he told the second attorney that Epstein could not be housed without a cellmate
because of his prior suicide attempt.
C. Removal on August 9 of Epstein's Cellmate from MCC New York
According to MCC New York reports, including the Daily Log and the Lieutenant's Log, on August 9, 2019, at
approximately 8:38 a.m., Epstein's cellmate, Inmate 3, was "pre-removed" and transferred out of MCC
New York in a routine, pre-arranged transfer. The Daily Log tracks inmate movements throughout MCC
New York each day, while MCC New York Lieutenants utilize the Lieutenant's Log to document the daily
activities that took place within the institution during their respective shifts.

The Supervisory Correctional Systems Specialist was the supervisor of Receiving and Discharge on August 9,
2019, and was responsible for overseeing all inmate movements in and out of the institution that day. The
Supervisory Correctional Systems Specialist verified that Receiving and Discharge would have used the
USMS emails sent on August 8, 2019, to coordinate Inmate 3's transfer out MCC New York, and since
Inmate 3 was listed as 'WAB" on the USMS emails, that meant he was being transferred from the facility and
not coming back. She explained to the OIG that if Inmate 3 had been going to court, as many pretrial
inmates held at MCC New York often did, the Daily Log would have reflected "court," rather than "pre-
remove." Since the Daily Log listed Inmate 3 as "pre-remove," the Receiving and Discharge personnel who
entered the information into the report were made aware that Inmate 3 was being transferred from MCC
New York on or before the morning of August 9, 2019. The Supervisory Correctional Systems Specialist told
the OIG that the language in the USMS emails ("WAB," i.e., "with all belongings") and MCC New York reports
("pre-removed") made it clear that Inmate 3 would not be returning to the SHU or MCC New York.
The OIG also interviewed the Correctional Systems Officer, who was the Receiving and Discharge officer who
handled inmate movement in and out of MCC New York on August 9, 2019. The Correctional Systems
Officer confirmed that the Daily Log reflected that Inmate 3 was "pre-removed" on August 9, 2019, at
8:38 a.m., because he was being officially moved from the institution to another prison. She explained to
the OIG that the ordinary process was that Receiving and Discharge personnel would enter the information
regarding Inmate 3 into SENTRY, along with information pertaining to other inmates who would be leaving
their MCC New York housing units. Receiving and Discharge used this information to create the daily call
out list, which had all of the inmates' names and times that they were to be moved. The Correctional
Systems Officer told the OIG that the call out list from August 9, 2019, was no longer available because the
call out lists were printed and hand-delivered to the housing units each day, and then discarded by the units
at the end of the day. She also said each day's call out list was only maintained electronically for a 24-hour
period, and then it was updated (overwritten) with the next day's list. In her OIG interview, the Correctional
Systems Officer explained what would have occurred on this date based on her experience. Receiving and
Discharge personnel would have printed copies of the call out list for August 9, 2019, which the MCC
New York internal officer would distribute to the various housing units within the facility. Based on the
other records reflecting Inmate 3's transfer, the Correctional Systems Officer said the call out list created for
August 9, 2019, would have listed 'WAB" next to Inmate 3's name, which meant that he was departing from
the institution and not returning.

Correctional Officer (CO) 1 told the OIG that on the morning of August 9, 2019, he and Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge escorted Inmate 3 to Receiving and Discharge and Epstein to his legal visit.
D. Failure to Assign Epstein a New Cellmate on August 9
1. Day Watch Staff Actions on August 9
The SHU Lieutenant told the OIG that he worked at MCC New York on August 8, 2019, from approximately
6 a.m. until approximately 2 p.m., and that he was off on August 9, 2019. The SHU Lieutenant, whose shift
ended over an hour before the USMS sent the second email regarding Inmate 3's impending transfer, told
the OIG he was not aware that Inmate 3 was scheduled to be transferred out of MCC New York, and
therefore he did not notify the Captain that Epstein would require a new cellmate. According to the SHU
Lieutenant, as soon as the SHU staff learned that Inmate 3 would be transferred, they should have notified a
Lieutenant on duty. The Day Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant told the
OIG that on August 9, 2019, they had oversight of the SHU from approximately 6 a.m. until 2 p.m. due to
their position descriptions and because of the SHU Lieutenant's absence.

According to the MCC New York Staff Roster, on August 9, 2019, SHU Officer #1 was listed as Senior Officer
Specialist 5. Although SHU Officer #1 is typically the Officer in Charge, another Senior Officer Specialist told
the OIG that, in actuality, he was the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge on August 9 from approximately
6 a.m. until 2 p.m. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that since he had the most experience and
seniority, he was considered by everyone to be the SHU Officer in Charge, which the SHU Lieutenant
confirmed. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he knew that Epstein had to have a
cellmate. He said that, as a general practice, every inmate who is transferred from suicide watch and/or
psychological observation to the SHU is placed with a cellmate. He also confirmed that the SHU Lieutenant
had instructed him that Epstein was to be housed with a cellmate at all times. According to the Day Watch
SHU Officer in Charge, between July 30 and August 9, 2019, he told all other MCC New York staff members
who worked in the SHU of Epstein's cellmate requirement and further stated that everyone who worked in
the SHU should have known that Epstein was required to have a cellmate due to their knowledge, training,
and experience.

The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge confirmed that on the morning of August 9, 2019, the SHU staff
received an inmate call out list that listed Inmate 3 as "WAB," which he explained meant that Inmate 3 was
being removed from MCC New York. He told the OIG that sometime between 8 a.m. and 9 a.m., he escorted
Epstein from the SHU to the attorney conference room for Epstein's daily legal visit, during which time
Epstein joked around with him. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that he and Epstein were
accompanied by CO 1, who was escorting Inmate 3 to Receiving and Discharge. The Day Watch SHU Officer
in Charge and CO 1 both told the OIG that Inmate 3 was escorted to Receiving and Discharge with all of his
belongings, and both said that during the escort the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge informed Epstein that
he would be assigned a new cellmate due to Inmate 3's departure and the requirement that Epstein have a
cellmate. In his interview with the OIG, CO 1 confirmed this conversation between the Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge and Epstein, but he did not provide any additional information regarding notifications
made either by him or the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the
OIG that when he and CO 1 left the SHU with Epstein and Inmate 3, both the Day Watch Operations
Lieutenant and the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant should have been physically present in the Lieutenants'
Office and should have seen that Inmate 3 was departing the institution when they passed the office.
The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that while he did not expect Inmate 3 to return to MCC New York,
there had been times when inmates had been escorted to Receiving and Discharge as an expected removal,
only to be returned to the SHU later that same day due to unforeseen circumstances. According to the Day
Watch SHU Officer in Charge, he did not select a new cellmate for Epstein because he was not certain that
Inmate 3 had been discharged from the institution, although he assumed that Inmate 3 would not return to
the SHU. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that when his shift ended at approximately
2 p.m., he informed the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Senior Officer Specialist 5 that, if Inmate 3
did not return to the SHU, Epstein would need a new cellmate upon Epstein's return from his attorney visit.
The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said he specifically recalled telling the Evening Watch SHU Officer in
Charge, in the presence of Senior Officer Specialist 5, "Make sure this guy gets a bunkie," to which the
Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge replied, "All right." The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that, at
some point that day, it was likely that he also informed the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, but he could
not specifically recall if he had done so.

The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that a replacement cellmate should have been identified
as soon as it was confirmed that Inmate 3 had left the institution. He said a new cellmate could have been
reassigned before the 4 p.m. SHU count if it was known that Inmate 3 was not coming back, but the SHU
staff members had until Epstein returned from his attorney visit to assign Epstein a new cellmate.
According to the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, SHU staff definitely should have realized that Inmate 3
was not returning both during the 4 p.m. count and when Epstein returned from his attorney visit later that
evening. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that Epstein's daily routine was that he would
be with his attorneys in the attorney conference room until approximately 8 p.m., so SHU personnel had
time to make a new cellmate assignment. He said all SHU staff members shared the responsibility to find a
replacement cellmate and that anyone assigned to the SHU could have found another inmate to replace
Inmate 3. However, he also said that due to Epstein's high profile, the SHU personnel should have asked a
Lieutenant to contact the Psychology Department to see which inmate should be placed with Epstein.
On August 12, 2019, following Epstein's death, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge wrote a memorandum
to the Warden stating, "On Friday August 9, 2019 at approximately 1:50 p.m., I 5/O/S [the Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge] passed on to oncoming staff member (the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge] and
present shift staff [Senior Officer Specialist 5] and [CO 2] that Inmate [3] was going WAB [i.e., with all of his
belongings] and possibly may not return. Also that Inmate Epstein #76318-054 will be needing a cell mate
upon arrival from his attorney visit." The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge departed the SHU at
approximately 2 p.m. and worked an overtime shift as a driver for MCC New York. He stated that he did not
follow up with the SHU staff to verify that Epstein had been assigned another cellmate.
MCC New York staff with responsibility for oversight and staffing of the SHU during the Day Watch, including
the Warden, Associate Warden 1, the Captain, the SHU Lieutenant, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant,
the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, and the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, told the OIG that they all
knew Epstein was required to have a cellmate pursuant to the Psychology Departments determination.
They also confirmed that everyone who regularly worked in the SHU knew of this requirement, and that it
was the responsibility of all SHU staff to notify a supervisor upon learning that Epstein needed to be
assigned a new cellmate due to Inmate 3's transfer to another prison. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge
and CO 1, however, were the only two MCC New York staff members working the Day Watch on August 9,
2019, who told the OIG that they were aware of Inmate 3's transfer and the need to assign Epstein a new
cellmate. CO l's immediate superior (the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge) was already aware of the need
to assign Epstein a new cellmate. While the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he made a
number of notifications, other witnesses could not confirm that he had passed on information regarding
Epstein's need for a new cellmate.

The Day Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant both told the OIG that they
did not know Inmate 3 had been transferred out of the facility, despite the fact that both were recipients of
the second email the USMS sent on August 8 that included the information about Inmate 3's impending
transfer out of MCC New York on August 9. Rather, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Day
Watch Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that they believed Inmate 3 had been removed from MCC New York
for a court appearance.

The Day Watch Activities Lieutenant did not recall Inmate 3 departing the institution with all of his
belongings or having any conversations with the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge or anyone else regarding
Inmate 3's departure from MCC New York. According to the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, he did not
know that Epstein was without a cellmate. Other senior officials, including the Warden, Associate Warden 1,
and the Captain, were also unaware of Inmate 3's transfer and the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate.
These officials concurred that while all SHU staff and supervisors were responsible for notifying a supervisor
in the chain-of-command of the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge
bore primary responsibility for the notification because he was the SHU Officer in Charge and one of two
people who saw Inmate 3 leave the facility with all of his belongings. The Captain told the OIG that since
Epstein was in the attorney conference room all day, no one may have even thought about it, and may have
only become aware when they put Epstein back in his cell after his attorney visit that evening. The Captain
said as soon as the SHU staff became aware that Epstein was without a cellmate, they should have notified
the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant. The Captain said that if he had been informed, he would have
taken immediate action to ensure that Epstein was either assigned a new cellmate or monitored until that
assignment occurred. The Captain, however, was one of the recipients of the USMS August 8 email that
notified members of MCC New York supervisory staff of Inmate 3's transfer to another facility. The Warden
and Associate Warden 1 did not receive this email.

The Warden told the OIG that he was off duty on August 9, 2019. The Warden said that in the event Epstein
was without a cellmate, the plan was to review the situation and decide who should replace Inmate 3, but
that no inmate in the SHU was preselected to replace Inmate 3 if this event occurred.
2 Evening Watch Staff Actions on August 9
The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he was the SHU Officer in Charge on August 9
from approximately 2 p.m. until 10 p.m. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge said he relieved the Day
Watch SHU Officer in Charge from his duties and worked in the SHU with Senior Officer Specialist 5, a
Material Handler, CO 2, and CO Tova Noel. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge stated that when he
began his shift, Epstein was visiting with his attorneys in the attorney conference room. The Evening Watch
SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he did not recall having a conversation with the Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge about Epstein needing a cellmate. When advised that the Day Watch SHU Officer in
Charge was confident about their conversation, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge stated, "I don't
necessarily want to call anyone a liar[] per se, but I don't remember him speaking to me about this. So,
maybe he spoke to [Senior Officer Specialist 5], and maybe I was standing there, and he thought I heard
him." The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge said if Inmate 3 had left MCC New York with all of his
belongings, then someone should have found another inmate to replace him because Epstein was required
to have a cellmate.

The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he eventually learned later that evening that
Epstein did not have a cellmate. According to the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, after Epstein
returned from his attorney visit and placed a telephone call, he escorted Epstein to his cell and saw that
Inmate 3 was not there. According to the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, after he realized that
Epstein did not have a cellmate, he, Noel, and the Material Handler, all of whom were working in the SHU
that evening, talked about Epstein needing a new cellmate. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge said
SHU staff could not just put anyone in the cell with Epstein. In his interview with the OIG, the Evening Watch
SHU Officer in Charge stated that he called someone (he could not recall who) and notified that person that
Epstein did not have a cellmate. OIG interviews did not identify an individual who received such a call or
who witnessed the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge making it.

Senior Officer Specialist 5 told the OIG that on August 9, he worked in the SHU from approximately 8:45 a.m.
until 4 p.m. Senior Officer Specialist 5 said when he reported for duty, Epstein was already with his
attorneys, Inmate 3 had already left the SHU, and neither inmate returned to the SHU prior to his departure.
Senior Officer Specialist 5 told the OIG that he did not know Inmate 3 had been released from MCC
New York and that no one told him Epstein would need a new cellmate, including the Day Watch SHU Officer
in Charge, the Captain, the SHU Lieutenant, or anyone from the Psychology Department.
CO 2 told the OIG that on August 9, he worked in the SHU from 8 a.m. until 4 p.m. CO 2 said he did not
recall Inmate 3 departing the SHU that day, and that he was unaware that Epstein needed a new cellmate.
The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that he was the Operations Lieutenant at the MCC
on August 9 from approximately 2 p.m. until 10 p.m. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant said he was
aware that Epstein was required to have a cellmate due to a mass email that was sent to all of the MCC
New York Lieutenants. According to the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, everyone who regularly
worked in the SHU should have known that Epstein was required to have a cellmate. The Evening Watch
Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that he did not know Inmate 3 had left MCC New York earlier that day
and was unaware that Epstein did not have a cellmate. He said that if Inmate 3 had been transported to
Receiving and Discharge as 'WAB" and the SHU Lieutenant was off, then another supervisor should have
been notified. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that SHU personnel assigned to his
shift should have notified him that Epstein was without a cellmate, but he had not been informed. The OIG's
investigation revealed, however, that the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant was one of the recipients of
the USMS email notifying MCC New York supervisory staff of Inmate 3's scheduled transfer out of MCC
New York on August 9. According to the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Acting Evening Watch
Activities Lieutenant conducted the Lieutenant round in the SHU on August 9, and she only would have
known that Epstein was without a cellmate if someone from the SHU told her or if she walked through the
SHU tiers during the round. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant said he believed that if the Evening
Watch Acting Activities Lieutenant knew that Epstein did not have a cellmate, she would have notified him.
Both the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant and the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the
OIG that they were unaware that Epstein needed to have a cellmate. The Acting Evening Watch Activities
Lieutenant, who was serving in this position on August 9 from approximately 4 p.m. until 10 p.m., told the
OIG that because her ordinary position was a Senior Officer Specialist, she was not aware that Epstein was
required to have a cellmate. The Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant recalled hearing that Epstein
had been placed on suicide watch, but said she never received specific instructions regarding Epstein. She
said the SHU staff did not tell her about the requirement that Epstein have a cellmate or that his cellmate
had left MCC New York. The Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant did not receive the August 8 USMS
email regarding Inmate 3's transfer. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant, who was the Operations
Lieutenant from approximately 10 p.m. on August 9 until 6 a.m. on August 10, told the OIG that she did not
know that Epstein was required to have a cellmate, and that the Captain never spoke with her about this
issue. The Captain confirmed that he did not specifically tell the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant that
Epstein needed a cellmate; however, the Captain said he believed that the Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant should have known of the requirement, and she was one of the recipients of the email from the
Psychology Department on July 30, 2019, that informed MCC New York staff that Epstein needed to have an
appropriate cellmate. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant also received the August 8 USMS email
notifying MCC New York supervisory staff of Inmate 3's scheduled transfer out of MCC New York. The
Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that if SHU staff knew that Epstein required a cellmate
and did not have one, they should have informed her when she visited the SHU at approximately 4 a.m. on
August 10, as part of her Lieutenant rounds.

The Material Handler said the SHU was not his regular post and he had not attended SHU training, but he
had worked in the SHU approximately 10 to 20 times. According to the Material Handler, on August 9 he
reported for a voluntary overtime shift from 12 a.m. to 8 a.m. and then worked his regular 8 a.m. to 4 p.m.
shift in the warehouse. At some point during the day shift, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant called and
asked the Material Handler if he could work overtime in the SHU, and he agreed. The Material Handler said
he worked the 4 p.m. to 12 a.m. shift in the SHU with the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Noel.
The Material Handler told the OIG that he felt pressured to work the third shift, which resulted in him
working 24 hours straight, from 12 a.m. on August 9 through 12 a.m. on August 10. After the Evening Watch
SHU Officer in Charge left at 10 p.m., the Material Handler and Noel were the only employees working in the
SHU from 10 p.m. to 12 a.m. The Material Handler recalled that Epstein came back to the SHU from meeting
with his attorneys at approximately 8 p.m., which was later than the rest of the inmates, and was returned
to his cell on L Tier. After the Material Handler and Noel gave Epstein his food, the Material Handler said
they left the L Tier area. The Material Handler said Epstein was alone in his cell, but he was unaware that
Epstein needed a cellmate.

Noel told the OIG that she worked in the SHU from approximately 4 p.m. on August 9 until 8 a.m. on
August 10, which was a double shift of 16 hours. Noel said the SHU was her regular post during the time
that Epstein was housed within the SHU. According to Noel, inmates housed within the MCC New York SHU
were typically assigned cellmates, but she did not know if they were required to have cellmates. Noel said
Epstein was assigned a cellmate while he was housed within the SHU but said that no one spoke with her
about a requirement that Epstein have a cellmate. Noel said she did not know that Inmate 3 had been
removed from MCC New York on August 9, and stated she was not aware that Epstein should have been
assigned a new cellmate if Inmate 3 had been removed from MCC New York.

Material Handler Michael Thomas told the OIG that he worked a shift in the SHU on August 10 from 12 a.m.
until 8 a.m. Thomas said the SHU was not his normal post, but he had worked in the SHU on numerous
previous occasions and was familiar with the SHU protocols and procedures. Thomas said he knew that if
an inmate came off suicide watch or psychological observation, they should be assigned a cellmate, and he
said he was aware that Epstein had previously been on suicide watch and psychological observation.
Therefore, Thomas assumed that Epstein was required to have a cellmate but said no one had spoken with
him about that requirement. Thomas said the SHU staff should have notified the Operations Lieutenant as
soon as they knew that Epstein's cellmate had departed MCC New York on August 9. However, Thomas said
he did not know that Inmate 3 was removed from MCC New York on August 9, and that Epstein was without
a cellmate during his shift on August 10.
IV. Epstein is Allowed to Make an Unmonitored Telephone Call on August 9
For safety and security reasons, BOP policy requires that all inmate telephone calls be made through the
Inmate Telephone System. BOP records reflect that Epstein placed an unrecorded, unmonitored telephone
call to a telephone number in the local 646 area code using a non-Inmate Telephone System line on
August 9, 2019, from 6:58 p.m. to 7:19 p.m. No other BOP records exist regarding the unmonitored call,
including identity of the person called or a summary of the conversation. The OIG found no evidence that
Epstein signed an Acknowledgement of Inmate form, as required by BOP policy and necessary for him to
use a non-Inmate Telephone System line. The Acknowledgement of Inmate form provides, among other
things, that the BOP reserves the authority to monitor and record non-attorney conversations on any
telephone located within the institution to preserve the security and orderly management of the institution
and to protect the public. The OIG did not find that any notification was made to the MCC New York's
Special Investigative Services staff advising the telephone call had been made, the date and time of the
telephone call, the name of the person being called, Epstein's name and register number, or a brief
statement explaining the purpose of Epstein's telephone call, as BOP policy requires.
The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that when he was preparing to escort Epstein back
to the SHU from the attorney conference room on August 9, 2019, a Unit Manager said to the Evening Watch
Operations Lieutenant that he was going to escort Epstein, so he could provide Epstein with the opportunity
to place a telephone call using an unrecorded legal telephone line that is utilized by inmates to call their
attorneys. The Unit Manager was the Institutional Duty Officer the week of Epstein's death. The Northeast
Regional Director told the OIG that an Institutional Duty Officer is a supervisor who monitors the facility on
non-duty hours on behalf of the Warden when the Warden is not present.

The Captain told the OIG that he had authorized the Unit Manager to provide Epstein with a telephone call
from the SHU on August 9, 2019, because he wanted to accommodate Epstein's request for a telephone call
since Epstein was assigned to the SHU and had limited ability to place telephone calls. The Captain
explained that when the Unit Manager was escorting Epstein from his attorney visit back to the SHU, he told
the Unit Manager in the elevator that Epstein could place a telephone call from the SHU, but it had to be
monitored and logged.

The Unit Manager told the OIG that he worked on August 9 from approximately 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. The Unit
Manager explained that on August 9, Epstein asked to call his mother and that it was his understanding that
Epstein had not been able to obtain the necessary documentation to use the Inmate Telephone System for
various reasons, including the fact that Epstein was with his attorneys during normal working hours. As
described below, Epstein had, in fact, completed the requisite BOP paperwork that allowed him to place
calls through the Inmate Telephone System. The Unit Manager said the decision to allow Epstein to place
the call was his alone as the Unit Manager and because, as the Institutional Duty Officer, he was
representing the Warden, who was not physically within MCC New York at that time. The Unit Manager said
he did not recall having a conversation with the Captain about permitting Epstein to make the call, and he
would have allowed the call even if the Captain did not want him to, given it was his decision to make as the
Unit Manager. The Unit Manager explained that he viewed ensuring that inmates had family socialization as
a part of his job, and he would allow inmates to place telephone calls if they were unable to make calls
under ordinary circumstances.

The Unit Manager told the OIG that at approximately 6:45 p.m., he and Senior Officer Specialist 1 escorted
Epstein from the attorney conference room to the SHU so that Epstein could place a telephone call. The
Unit Manager said he put Epstein in the shower area to make the telephone call because COs were present
in that area. The Unit Manager explained that he also chose the shower area because that location ensured
Epstein would not be able to pull the phone cord into his cell and use it to harm himself. The Unit Manager
said he plugged the telephone line into the legal line, which was not recorded, and dialed the telephone
number that Epstein provided. As noted above, the number that was dialed was in the local 646 area code.
The Unit Manager said he allowed Epstein to place the telephone call on the unrecorded legal line because
he believed that Epstein had not set up his Inmate Telephone System account that would have allowed him
to call on the institutions recorded lines. According to the Unit Manager, a male answered, and the Unit
Manager handed the receiver to Epstein. The Unit Manager heard Epstein say, "Hey, how are you doing?
How's everything?' The Unit Manager admitted that he should have verified who was on the line, as Epstein
had requested to make a telephone call to speak with his mother, and it was a male who answered the
phone. The Unit Manager said he could not verify the phone number because he believed that Epstein did
not have his Inmate Telephone System account set up, and he did not have any phone numbers associated
with his account. The Unit Manager told the OIG that after he handed the telephone to Epstein, his shift
ended so he left the SHU and left MCC New York for the day.

The Unit Manager said that when he left the SHU, Epstein was still on the call and the Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge and Noel were at the officers' desk, and that Senior Officer Specialist 1 was also present.
According to the Unit Manager, when he was leaving, he told the officers, "Hey, make sure he gets his 15-
minutes, and after that, he's done." The Unit Manager said he did not provide the SHU staff with
instructions to monitor the call. He said that after he left, he contacted Noel on the SHU telephone and
asked her to make sure that Epstein's call had ended because his time was up.

The Unit Manager acknowledged that he did not stay and monitor the call as he should have done. The Unit
Manager said the proper way to have an inmate place a telephone call on an unmonitored line would be to
bring the inmate out and place him in a belly chain because then he would be handcuffed in the front. The
Unit Manager said he should have provided Epstein with the phone, with a counselor or unit team member
present, and placed the call on speaker so the call was monitored.

The OIG investigation determined that Epstein did not, in fact, speak with his mother, who, according to
public records, died in 2004. The OIG found that Epstein actually spoke with Individual 1, who declined to be
interviewed by the OIG.33 Individual l's lawyer told the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of
New York during an attorney proffer that Individual 1 spoke with Epstein on August 9, 2019, at about 7 p.m.,
for approximately 20 minutes. Individual l's attorney proffer was that Individual 1 was in the country of
Belarus at the time of the call.34 Individual l's attorney told the U.S. Attorney's Office that during the
43 The OIG does not have the authority to compel or subpoena testimony from individuals who are not Department of
Justice employees.

34 The OIG did not investigate the factual accuracy of this proffer. We note that there are methods by which a call to 
the
646 area code could connect to a telephone in Belarus.

telephone call, Epstein told Individual 1 that the press had gotten crazy, and they discussed personal things
such as books, music, and hygiene while incarcerated. According to the representations by Individual l's
counsel, Epstein told Individual 1, 'They are trying to keep me safe," and that his case would take a little
longer than he originally thought. He told Individual 1 he loved her, to be strong, and that he would not be
able to call her again for another month.

Senior Officer Specialist 1 told the OIG that he was not a witness to Epstein's August 9 call, but he had
previously discussed telephone calls with Epstein and knew that Epstein had the requisite paperwork that
allowed him to place calls through the Inmate Telephone System. Senior Officer Specialist 1 told the OIG
that Epstein was issued the necessary documentation to make telephone calls when Inmate 1 was his
cellmate. Senior Officer Specialist 1 also advised the OIG about an interaction that he had with one of
Epstein's attorneys prior to August 9 when he was on an elevator with Epstein and the attorney. According
to Senior Officer Specialist 1, Epstein's attorney asked him about getting Epstein the necessary
documentation to make calls. Senior Officer Specialist 1 said he then verified that Epstein was able to make
calls through the Inmate Telephone System. When Senior Officer Specialist 1 asked Epstein why he had said
he was unable to make calls, Epstein responded, "[T]hey said they monitor those phone calls." Senior
Officer Specialist 1 said that in a subsequent conversation with Epstein's attorney, the attorney asked how
Epstein could get an unmonitored call. Senior Officer Specialist 1 told Epstein's attorney that decision had to
be made by a Lieutenant or Unit Manager.

Noel told the OIG that after Epstein's attorney conference on August 9, the Unit Manager plugged a
telephone line in the legal line, and placed Epstein in a shower area within the SHU where he was afforded a
telephone call. The OIG investigation determined that the legal line is an unrecorded telephone line outside
of the Inmate Telephone System, which is designed for inmates to use when speaking with their counsel and
therefore is not recorded. Noel said that after the Unit Manager set Epstein up with the call, he left the SHU
and did not instruct Noel, or anyone else to Noel's knowledge, to monitor Epstein's call. According to Noel,
the call was not monitored or logged. Noel said that approximately 15 to 20 minutes later, while Epstein
was still using the telephone, the Unit Manager called the SHU staff via telephone, told Noel that Epstein's
time was up, and asked that Noel retrieve the telephone from Epstein. Noel estimated that Epstein's call
lasted for 20 minutes and said the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and the Material Handler were also
present in the SHU during Epstein's phone call. Noel reported that she took the phone back from Epstein,
left Epstein alone in the shower, and went to use the bathroom on 10 South. Noel said that upon her
return, Epstein was already placed back in his cell.

The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he was present in the SHU on August 9 during
the time of Epstein's telephone call but did not overhear Epstein's conversation. The Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge also said that while Epstein was having his telephone call, the officers were distracted by
the actions of another inmate. The Material Handler said he did not recall seeing the Unit Manager or
Epstein in the shower area on the night of August 9, and did not have any knowledge or information
regarding a phone call made by Epstein that night.

The Northeast Regional Director told the OIG that if Epstein's call was authorized by an MCC New York
official, then it should have been done on a speaker phone while being monitored by a staff member, and
the call should have been logged and a record of the call should have been created. The Northeast Regional
Director said Epstein's unmonitored telephone call was extremely concerning because "[w]e don't know
what happened on that phone call. It could have potentially led to the incident [Epstein's death], but we
don't, we will never know."
V. Failure to Conduct SHU Inmate Counts and Staff Rounds on August 9--10
A. SHU Inmate Counts
As detailed in the BOP policies section of Chapter 2, the BOP requires COs assigned to guard inmates to
conduct institution -wide counts of inmates at regularly scheduled intervals each day to ensure that all
inmates are present and accounted for at the appropriate location within the facility. Performing an
institutional count is one of the basic and essential aspects of a CO's job, and the count was one of the basic
and essential components of the daily operation of MCC New York. The Captain told the OIG that counts are
a core responsibility of COs and ensure accountability of the inmates. The Evening Watch Operations
Lieutenant said that it is very important that the institutional count is accurate because that is how staff
members know if all inmates are present and if anyone has escaped.

On weekdays, MCC New York conducted institutional counts at 12 a.m., 3 a.m., 5 a.m., 4 p.m., and 10 p.m.
The 10 p.m. count was a stand-up count, which meant that inmates were required to stand when they were
counted. Pursuant to BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders, two COs were required to perform
the institutional count for each housing unit, including the SHU. To perform the institutional count in the
SHU, BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders required two officers to walk from tier to tier to
observe and count each individual inmate. During each count, one CO would count the inmates while the
other officer observed the inmates. The two officers would then switch roles and compare the count
numbers. If the totals did not match, then the officers had to conduct another count in the same manner.
COs had to document their performance of inmate counts on an official MCC New York form often referred
to as a count slip.35
On the count slip, COs were required to fill in the date and time the count had been performed, write the
total number of inmates physically present in the unit counted, and then both COs printed their name and
signed the count slip. Once the COs had completed and signed the count slip, the count slips were then
collected and delivered to the Control Center. Officers assigned to the Control Center were responsible for
comparing the count slips from each housing unit to the institution's inmate roster to ensure that each
inmate was accounted for. Only after all the count slips had been collected from each housing unit, and the
numbers on the slips had been matched to the institution's inmate roster, could the institutional count be
deemed "cleared" or completed. If a housing unit's count slip was incomplete or did not match the number
of inmates that were supposed to be in the unit, then the count had to be redone in that housing unit via a
more intensive version of the institutional count, called a bed-book count, which is when inmates are
counted using their picture cards. Records of each institutional count, including the count slips, were
provided to a supervising official and retained by MCC New York.

The OIG's investigation found that none of the required SHU inmate counts were conducted from 4 p.m. on
August 9, 2019, until Epstein was discovered hanged in his cell at approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10,

2019. Further, the OIG determined that SHU staff did not conduct any 30-minute rounds after
approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9, and that the count slips and round sheets had been falsified. As a
35 This BOP form is officially entitled "Metropolitan Correctional Center; New York, New York; Official Count Slip."
result, many SHU staff and supervisors were unaware that Epstein did not have a cellmate as the Psychology
Department had determined was necessary, and Epstein was alone and unobserved in his cell for an
extended period of time.
1. The 4 p.m. SHU Count on August 9
The OIG's investigation determined that the 4 p.m. SHU inmate count on August 9, 2019, was inaccurate
because SHU staff did not physically count the inmates as required by BOP policy and instead relied upon a
predetermined number of inmates believed to be in the SHU at that time. However, Epstein, who was in the
SHU attorney visitation room, was correctly accounted for during the 4 p.m. and subsequent SHU counts.
The OIG determined that the error in the 4 p.m. SHU count was carried over into the next inmate count at
10 p.m. that counted an inmate who had been transferred out of the SHU. The SHU inmate count was not
corrected until 12 a.m. when the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant reviewed the master institutional
count and housing unit count slips and informed SHU staff of the correct number of inmates in the SHU at
that time.

Senior Officer Specialist 5 told the OIG that prior to his departure from the SHU at approximately 4 p.m., he
told the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge what the SHU count should be. In addition, the Day Watch
SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that SHU staff maintain a "cheat sheet," which lists the number of
inmates believed to be in the SHU at any given time.

When interviewed by the OIG, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge reviewed the 4 p.m. SHU count slip from
August 9, 2019, which was signed by the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and CO Noel. Based on his
review, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and
Noel probably did not count the inmates in the SHU. He said they likely wrote down the numbers they
thought should have been entered for the count because the count slip inaccurately included an inmate
(Inmate 4) among the number of inmates in the SHU after that inmate had been transferred to another
housing unit. According to what he told the OIG and wrote in an email on August 9, earlier that afternoon
the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge observed Inmate 4 attempt to retrieve an unknown item from his
visitor in the MCC New York SHU visiting room. The Lieutenant's Log from August 9, 2019, reflected that
following this incident, Inmate 4 was removed from the SHU at 3:15 p.m. and transferred to the Receiving
and Discharge dry cell, which is a secure location where inmates are taken for observation when they are
believed to have ingested or secreted contraband on their person. According to the Day Watch SHU Officer
in Charge, the inaccurate 4 p.m. count slip told him 'that the count was not done and they just assumed and
went by the cheat sheet because the body wasn't even there," referring to Inmate 4, who was transferred
from the SHU to Receiving and Discharge. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that if the
4 p.m. SHU count had been accurately conducted, then the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and the
SHU staff should have realized that Inmate 4 was no longer in the SHU.

In his interview with the OIG, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge acknowledged that neither he nor
any other SHU staff member conducted the 4 p.m. SHU count on August 9. The Evening Watch SHU Officer
in Charge verified that it was his handwriting and signature on the 4 p.m. SHU count slip and said he had
prepared the count slip ahead of time because "[t]here was so much going on" in the SHU that day. The
Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge confirmed that Noel's name and signature also appeared on the 4 p.m.
count slip.36 During his OIG interview, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge reviewed BOP documents
regarding the inmate's transfer from the SHU and acknowledged further that based on that transfer, the
number of inmates listed on the SHU count slip he and Noel submitted for the 4 p.m. count, the count slip
was incorrect.

Noel admitted in the deferred prosecution agreement she entered into with the U.S. Attorney's Office for
the Southern District of New York that she completed false count slips on August 9 and 10. Noel initially told
the OIG that she did not conduct the 4 p.m. count on August 9, but after acknowledging that she signed the
4 p.m. SHU count slip, Noel said she did not recall if she conducted the count. According to Noel, she and
other SHU staff filled out the count slip before conducting the counts because they knew the number of
inmates they were supposed to report.
2. The 10 p.m. SHU Count on August 9
At the time of the 10 p.m. count, all inmates in the MCC New York SHU, including Epstein, were locked in
their cells for the night. At or around that time, the two officers assigned to the SHU were responsible for
conducting the 10 p.m. stand up count. At 10 p.m. on August 9, the two assigned SHU officers were Noel
and the Material Handler. Through review and analysis of the SHU security camera video, witness
statements, and SOP records, the OIG determined that MCC New York staff did not perform the 10 p.m.
count in the SHU.37 Nonetheless, Noel and the Material Handler completed and signed the 10 p.m. SHU
count slip. The 10 p.m. SHU count slip listed the total number of inmates as /3 + 1." According to the MCC
New York master count sheet for the 10 p.m. count on August 9, 2019, all units had verbally reported their
inmate counts to the Control Center by 10:30 p.m.33 At approximately 10:36 p.m., the Control Center
completed all paperwork and officially cleared the 10 p.m. institutional count.

The Material Handler said he was present at the time of the 10 p.m. count, but that the count was not
conducted because everyone was tired. The Material Handler noted that on August 9, he had worked an
overtime shift from 12 a.m. until 8 a.m., his regular shift from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m., followed by his SHU overtime
shift from 4 p.m. to midnight. Thus, at the time of the 10 p.m. count, he had worked 22 consecutive hours at
MCC New York. The Material Handler verified that he and Noel signed the 10 p.m. count slip and believed
that Noel called the Control Center with their count numbers. He did not know why the count slip listed
"73 + 1".

Noel told the OIG that she had conducted the SHU count alone at 10 p.m. and that the Material Handler
signed the count slip even though he did not conduct the count with her. However, the OIG's review and
analysis of the SHU security camera video conflicts with Noel's statement that she conducted the 10 p.m.
count. Specifically, the video reflects that it was not until between 10:29 p.m. and 10:36 p.m. when Noel
walked to different tiers inside the SHU. Yet, as described above, MCC New York records reflect that counts
from all MCC New York housing units were reported to the Control Center by 10:30 p.m., as the count
36 Prosecution was declined for BOP employees (other than Noel and Thomas) who falsely certified inmate counts and
rounds on the day before and the day of Epstein's death.

37 The quality of the SHU video footage was poor. Therefore, in conjunction with reviewing the video, the OIG analyzed
witness statements and BOP records to better determine what the video depicted.

38 The official name for the document used to record an institutional count is "Bureau of Prisons Count Sheet?
documentation shows the count was verbally cleared by the Control Center at 10:30 p.m. It therefore
appears that the video depicts Noel conducting a later round in the SHU, as she was required to do every
30 minutes during her shift, and not the 10 p.m. SHU count.

Noel said she wrote the 73 on the count slip but she did not remember if she or someone else had written
"+ 1" on the count slip and she did not know why "+1" was on the count slip. Noel claimed that, unlike the
4 p.m. count slip, which the Evening Watch Officer in Charge pre-filled, she did not prepare the 10 p.m.
count slip in advance of the count. Noel said she did not know that the 10 p.m. SHU count slip, which listed
73 inmates, was inaccurate, and she could not explain why the 12 a.m. count also inaccurately listed that
73 inmates were physically present in the SHU, whereas the 3 a.m. and 5 a.m. count slips accurately listed
72 inmates in the SHU.

Senior Officer Specialist 6 told the OIG that on August 9, 2019, he worked in the Control Center from
approximately 4 p.m. until 12 a.m., and then he worked as an Internal Officer from 12 a.m. until 8 a.m. on
August 10. According to Senior Officer Specialist 6, he took the August 9 10 p.m. institutional count by
himself in the Control Center, and assisted with the 12 a.m., 3 a.m., and 5 a.m. counts on August 10 as an
Internal Officer. Senior Officer Specialist 6 confirmed to the OIG, as MCC New York records reflect, that he
had received verbal counts from all units by 10:30 p.m., and further stated that he had cleared the
institutional count at 10:36 p.m., which was when paperwork was complete and the count was
officially complete.

Senior Officer Specialist 6 reviewed the MCC New York 10 p.m. institutional count, which showed that the
SHU had 73 inmates assigned, whereas the Receiving and Discharge Department had zero inmates assigned
to the unit. When questioned by the OIG about the 10 p.m. SHU count slip that listed '73 + 1" inmates and
was signed by the Material Handler and Noel, Senior Officer Specialist 6 told the OIG that he believed that
the "+ 1" on the count slip was in his handwriting. Senior Officer Specialist 6 also reviewed the 10 p.m.
Receiving and Discharge count slip, which listed "9S + 1" on the count slip and told the OIG that it was his
handwriting. 39 Senior Officer Specialist 6 explained that the "9S + 1" on the SHU count slip meant that he
was "ghost counting" the inmate (Inmate 4) who had been moved from the SHU, located in the 9 South area,
to the Receiving and Discharge area earlier that day. Senior Officer Specialist 6 said that because there
were, in actuality, only 72 inmates in the SHU during the 10 p.m. count, he should have written "73 - 1" on
the SHU count slip rather than "73 + 1".

39 According to BOP records and witness interviews, "95" refers to the SHU, which was located in 9th Floor South section
of MCC New York.
Figure 5.1
10 p.m. Count Slips from the SHU and Receiving and Delivery on August 9
Metropolitan Correctional Center
New York, New York
+ I Official Count Slip
Unit:
Count:

1. Print Name:
I. Signature:
2. Print Name:
2. Signature:
Date:
Time:
Note: The images have been modified for privacy reasons.
Source: BOP
Metropolitan Correctional Center
Official Coant Slip
Unit: ZA  Date: (••2? • C t
Count: 14:L± I
Print Name:
Signature:
Print Name: _
Signature:
Time:
Senior Officer Specialist 6 did not recall if he wrote on the count slips at the time of the 10 p.m. count or
during the 12 a.m. count when Inmate 4 was transferred in SENTRY from the SHU to Receiving and
Discharge. Senior Officer Specialist 6 told the OIG that if he had made the notations at the time of the
10 p.m. count, he should not have cleared the count. Instead, he should have created a new master count
sheet and requested that the SHU staff conduct a new count, provide a new count slip, and discard the
inaccurate SHU count slip. Senior Officer Specialist 6 told the OIG that an Operations Lieutenant would have
needed to authorize him to do the "ghost count" and write on the count slips, although he could not recall
precisely who gave him the authorization or when he had done so. The OIG investigation and review
determined that the only Operations Lieutenant on duty at the time was the Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant, who started her shift at 10 p.m. on August 9. When questioned by the OIG, the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant adamantly denied having authorized a "ghost count' and the OIG identified no
record or witness (other than Senior Officer Specialist 6) to indicate that she had done so. The OIG
interviewed other MCC New York personnel, who said "ghost counting" was not permitted, and stressed the
importance of an accurate physical count of inmates.
3. The 12 a.m., 3 a.m., and 5 a.m. SHU Counts on August 10
The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that she supervised the August 10 12 a.m.
institutional count from the Control Center. During the count, the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant
said she identified the issue with the inaccuracy of the SHU count slip because it counted Inmate 4 as
present in the SHU, when in actuality he had been removed from the SHU and placed in the Receiving and
Discharge dry cell the previous day (August 9, 2019). The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant said that
after learning of the discrepancy, she made the appropriate update reflecting the inmate transfer in
SENTRY. This update is reflected in Inmate 4's Inmate History Quarters, which states that Inmate 4 was
transferred out of the SHU into a different housing unit on August 10, 2019, at 12:35 a.m. The Morning
Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that she believed she told the SHU staff to conduct a new count
and create a new count slip, but she did not know if they had actually done so.

During his interview with the OIG, Senior Officer Specialist 6 reviewed BOP records relating to the inmate
transfer, the 12 a.m. institutional count, and the housing unit count slips. Based on his review of this
material, Senior Officer Specialist 6 said the 12 a.m. SHU count slip was inaccurate because it continued to
list 73 inmates instead of the 72 inmates who were physically present in the SHU at that time. Senior Officer
Specialist 6 reviewed the institutional counts and SHU count slips for the 3 a.m. and 5 a.m. counts and told
the OIG that they were accurate because they listed the SHU as having 72 inmates.

At approximately 12 a.m. on August 10, 2019, Material Handler Thomas replaced the other Material
Handler, and he and Noel were the only two staff members on duty in the SHU. Noel and Thomas were
responsible for conducting the 12 a.m., 3 a.m., and 5 a.m. counts in the SHU. Through review and analysis
of the SHU security camera video, witness statements, and BOP records, the OIG determined that Noel and
Thomas did not perform any of these counts. Nonetheless, Noel and Thomas completed and signed SHU
count slips for each of the three counts, and in reliance on the count slips, the Control Center cleared the
12 a.m., 3 a.m., and 5 a.m. institutional counts at approximately 12:49 a.m., 3:24 a.m., and 5:30 a.m.,
respectively. Noel and Thomas both admitted to the OIG that they did not conduct the 12 a.m., 3 a.m., and
5 a.m. counts on August 10, and that they had falsified the respective count slips.

Noel told the OIG that she signed the August 10 12 a.m., 3 a.m., and 5 a.m. count slips that Thomas had
prefilled. Noel said she did not know why the 12 a.m. count slip documented that there were 73 inmates in
the SHU, whereas the 3 a.m. and 5 a.m. slips documented there were only 72 inmates. Noel recalled that
Thomas had spoken with someone and then they changed the count slips.

Noel told the OIG that she and CO 3 conducted the 3 a.m. and 5 a.m. counts in MCC New York's 10 South
Unit, which is the single-celled secure unit adjacent to the SHU. Noel said that when she left the SHU to
assist CO 3, she took the SHU keys with her and that no one could have accessed the SHU while she was
gone because she had to physically open the door for anyone who came into the SHU. Noel also told the
OIG that when the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant arrived to conduct a round at approximately
4 a.m., Noel let her into the SHU. The OIG's review and analysis of the SHU video shows that the Morning
Watch Operations Lieutenant arrived in the SHU at approximately 4 a.m., visited the 10 South Unit at
4:04 a.m., returned to SHU at 4:11 a.m., and left the SHU at 4:14 a.m. According to Noel, no one other than
the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant and CO 3, as detailed later below, entered the SHU during
her shift.

Thomas told the OIG that since he had begun working with the BOP in 2007, he had worked in the SHU fairly
regularly and he was familiar with how to work in the SHU and how the SHU operated. Thomas described
his responsibilities while working in the SHU as to maintain the count of inmates, make sure the inmates are
fed, and, depending on the shift, make sure they get their showers. Thomas's Overtime Schedule showed
that he worked 21 shifts in the SHU during morning watch from May through August 2019. The overtime
schedule also showed that Thomas worked 12 overtime shifts in the SHU when Epstein was assigned to the
SHU in July and August 2019.

Thomas acknowledged that neither he nor Noel conducted any rounds or counts in the SHU during their
shift between approximately 12 a.m. and approximately 6:30 a.m. Thomas said the August 10, 2019 round
sheets were signed, but the rounds were not conducted because he was tired that day. Thomas recalled
'dozing off from here and there" during his shift, but he did not know if Noel slept.
Thomas did not recall having a conversation with anyone concerning the discrepancy between the 12 a.m.
SHU count slip, which listed 73 inmates, and the institutional count, which listed 72 inmates in the SHU.
Thomas said he had filled out and signed the 3 a.m. SHU count slip, which listed 72 inmates in the SHU.
Thomas did not know why the number of inmates was different on the 12 a.m. and 3 a.m. count slips and
did not recall speaking with the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant about the 12 a.m. count. Thomas
told the OIG that he knew he was falsely certifying the count slips when he signed them on August 10, 2019.
B. Staff Rounds in the SHU
1. CO Rounds
As detailed in the BOP Policies section of Chapter 2, in addition to inmate counts, BOP policy and MCC
New York SHU Post Orders required that COs assigned to the SHU conduct rounds to observe all inmates at
least twice an hour. As part of their assigned duties, MCC New York SHU officers had to walk each of the
tiers of the SHU twice an hour on an irregular schedule, once during the first 30 minutes and again during
the second 30 minutes, with both rounds occurring no more than 40 minutes apart. COs working in the
SHU were required to complete and initial an official MCC New York form, often referred to as a "round
sheet," which was reviewed and signed by a supervisor, documenting the date and time of each 30-minute
round in each tier of the SHU.4°
The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that SHU staff spoke about conducting rounds on Epstein
every day. He said that the Warden, Lieutenants, and other MCC New York staff members frequently told
the SHU staff to conduct rounds and to keep an eye on Epstein. To reinforce this message, the Day Watch
SHU Officer in Charge created a sign on orange paper that he hung on a computer in the SHU officer's area
that said, "MANADATORY (sic] ROUNDS MUST BE CONDUCTED EVERY 30 MINUTES ON EPSTEIN # 76318-054
AS PER GOD!!!!" The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said the sign was hanging on the computer on
August 9 and 10, 2019, and it was clearly visible to everyone who worked in the SHU. The Acting Evening
Watch Activities Lieutenant confirmed that written instructions to conduct rounds on Epstein were posted
on the SHU computer.

This BOP form is officially entitled "MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute Check Sheet."
Figure 5.2
Sign Created by the Day Watch
SHU Officer in Charge
LW
MANADATOR4OUNDS MUST
BE CONDUCTED EVERY 30
MINUTES ON
EPSTEIN #76318-054 AS PER
GOD!!!!
Note: The image has been modified for
privacy reasons.
Source: BOP
The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that
Noel filled out the round sheet on behalf of everyone who was
working in the SHU during his shift. The Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge was not certain if all of the rounds were
actually conducted. The Material Handler said he believed the
rounds listed on the round sheet as having occurred between
4:01 p.m. to 7:36 p.m. probably had been done, but he was
uncertain about the remaining rounds. The Material Handler
said he had seen officers "blow off" 30-minute rounds in the
past. Noel told the OIG that, as a general practice, when the
COs went to the various SHU tiers to distribute food or
supplies, they counted that as a round. Noel said she was
aware that she was supposed to conduct two rounds every
hour during their shift, but that she had never actually
completed rounds every 30 minutes while working in the SHU.
When asked which rounds she conducted on August 9, 2019,
Noel responded, "That's hard for me to tell because I didn't
conduct it every 30 minutes. It was give out food, pick up the
trays, give out toilet paper, go down. So those were the rounds
I conducted." Noel verified that her initials were on the round
sheets for August 9 and 10, 2019, and said, consistent with her
usual practice, she filled out the round sheets and initialed the
round sheets at the start of the 4 p.m. and the 12 a.m. shifts.

Noel and Thomas both admitted to the OIG that they did not conduct any of the rounds reflected on the
SHU Round Sheet on August 10, 2019, from 12 a.m. until Epstein was found hanged in his cell at
approximately 6:30 a.m. Nonetheless, Noel completed and signed more than 75 separate 30-minute entries
stating that she and Thomas had, in fact, conducted such rounds.'" Through review and analysis of the SHU
video footage, witness statements, and BOP records, the OIG determined that Noel and Thomas did not
enter the tiers in the SHU to conduct any of the rounds and counts between 12 a.m. and approximately
6:30 a.m. on August 10. Noel and Thomas can be seen at the SHU Officers' Station, moving in the SHU
common area, and in the SHU laundry and entrance/exit area throughout the morning of August 10.
Additionally, from approximately 1 a.m. to 3 a.m., Noel and Thomas were seated at the SHU Officers' Station
without moving and appeared to be sleeping. OIG analysis of the activity on the SHU computers revealed
that Noel used the computer periodically throughout the night, including to search the Internet for furniture
sales and benefit websites and to read a news article about Epstein. Thomas used the computer briefly
around 1 a.m. and 6 a.m. to search for motorcycle sales and sports news.

Noel told the OIG that she went through each tier in the SHU at approximately 10 p.m., and at the time she
went to Epstein's cell and saw him laying on a mattress on the floor, which she said was typical for him.
Epstein asked Noel for his medical device, so she plugged it in for him. Noel saw that Epstein was in the cell
by himself and without a cellmate, but she maintained that she did not know that Epstein was required to
have a cellmate. Noel told the OIG that Epstein's cell was approximately 15 feet away from the SHU Officers'
41 Each of the 6 tiers In the SHU had a separate round sheet, each of which had 13 entries reflecting 30-minute rounds
were conducted, when they were not, in fact, completed.

Station. Noel said that during her shift on August 10, 2019, no one went to Epstein's cell and no one other
than the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant and CO 3 came into the SHU.

Through review and analysis of the SHU video footage, witness statements, and BOP records, the OIG
determined that at approximately 10:40 p.m. a CO, believed to be Noel, carried linen or inmate clothing up
to the L Tier, which was the last time any CO approached the only entrance to the SHU tier in which Epstein
was housed.
2. Lieutenant Rounds
BOP policy requires that a Lieutenant visit the SHU during each shift to ensure that all procedures are being
followed. BOP training for new Lieutenants instructs that the Operations Lieutenant must visit the SHU at
least once per shift and n(t)his visit will be substantially more than just entering the unit, signing the log
book, and talking with staff." Additionally, when the SHU Lieutenant is unavailable, the Operations
Lieutenant should make rounds in the SHU on each shift. The training instructs that while in the SHU the
Operations Lieutenant must walk each range (tier), inspect logs and records, observe activities, and
periodically observe SHU inmate counts. The training further outlines that the SHU Lieutenant is
responsible for the direct supervision of the unit, including enforcement of rules, review of paperwork,
coordination of activities, movement of inmates, and cell searches. The SHU Lieutenant should make
rounds on the ranges (tiers) each day.

The statements of multiple witnesses were consistent with BOP training materials. The Northeast Regional
Director, the Warden, Associate Warden 1, the Captain, and the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge all told the
OIG that Lieutenants should have walked down all of the SHU tiers when conducting a Lieutenant round in
the SHU. Noel said the SHU Lieutenant walked the tiers all the time, however, other Lieutenants did not
always walk down the tiers. Multiple witnesses also told the OIG that it was standard practice for the BOP to
store the SHU round sheets at the end of each tier in the SHU. This practice was designed to ensure that
the assigned COs and Lieutenants walked down each tier when conducting rounds to observe every cell and
inmate during the round before initialing the round sheet. On August 9 and 10, 2019, however, the MCC
New York SHU round sheets were kept at the SHU Officers' Station in the common area of the SHU rather
than at the end of each tier.

None of the Lieutenant rounds conducted on August 9 and 10 alerted the supervisory staff to the fact that
Epstein lacked a cellmate. According to MCC New York records, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant
conducted a round in the SHU at 11:27 a.m. on August 9. The Day Watch Activities Lieutenant said he did
not specifically recall if he conducted a round in the SHU, but he believed that he did conduct the round. As
discussed in greater detail above, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that he did not know that
Epstein's cellmate had been removed from MCC New York or that Epstein was without a cellmate during his
shift on August 9. The Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that she conducted a
Lieutenant round in the SHU on August 9 sometime between 5 p.m. and 8 p.m. The Acting Evening Watch
Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that she did not know that Epstein's cellmate had departed from MCC New
York or that Epstein required a cellmate because she was only the Acting Activities Lieutenant and had not
attended SHU or department head meetings. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant reviewed the
August 9 round sheets and said that although his signature is on one of the forms as if he conducted a
round in the SHU, it was actually the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant who had conducted the
round. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant said he did not know why his signature was on the form
because he did not conduct any rounds within the SHU on August 9 and he did not recall signing the form.
The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant confirmed that she conducted her round in the SHU at
approximately 4 a.m. on August 10. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant said she went up to the
10 South Unit and then back down to the SHU because she needed to sign the round sheets. Contrary to
BOP training for new Lieutenants, which she attended in 2011, the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant
told the OIG, 'We are not required to go to each individual cell and look at the inmates. When we make
rounds, we get with the officers." The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant said she did not conduct a
round to observe the inmates when she visited the SHU. Noel confirmed that the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant visited the SHU but did not walk down the tiers.

Through review and analysis of the SHU security camera video, witness statements, and BOP records, the
OIG determined that at approximately 4 a.m. on August 10, 2019, the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant
briefly visited the SHU as part of her supervisory duties and conferred with Noel and Thomas, who were
seated at and around the SHU Officers' Station in the common area of the SHU. Noel told the OIG that at
approximately 5:30 a.m., Thomas went to the 10 South Unit, which was adjacent to the SHU, to relieve CO 3,
and that CO 3 briefly walked through the SHU common area as he left and returned from his break. The
OIG's review and analysis of the video footage revealed that, aside from those two officers, no one entered
the SHU and no one conducted any counts or rounds.
VI. Epstein's Death on August 10
A. Discovery of Epstein Hanged in Cell and Emergency Response
On August 10, 2019, shortly after 6 a.m., the doorbell to the SHU rang, indicating that a delivery of breakfast
carts had arrived at the SHU. Noel and Thomas retrieved the breakfast carts from the double-locked
entrance to the SHU and brought them inside the SHU. At the time, Thomas and Noel were the only officers
in the SHU. At approximately 6:30 a.m., MCC New York security camera video recordings show Noel and
Thomas walking toward the L Tier. Noel and Thomas told the OIG that at this time they were entering the
L Tier, in which Epstein was housed, to deliver breakfast to the inmates. As discussed previously, between
approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10, the OIG did not observe
on the available recorded video any COs or other individuals approach the L Tier where Epstein was housed
from the common area of the SHU.

Noel told the OIG that she unlocked the door to the L Tier so Thomas could deliver the breakfast trays.
Thomas told the OIG that he knocked on Epstein's cell door, saw a portion of Epstein through the window
but could not make out what he saw, so he said to Epstein, "Come to the door, come to the door." Thomas
said he did not observe any movement or hear a response, so he unlocked the cell door, entered the cell,
and saw Epstein hanged as described further below. Thomas said he immediately yelled for Noel to get
help, and that Noel activated a body alarm, signaling a medical emergency, and began taking the steps
described below.
Figure 5.3
Photograph of a Piece of Orange Cloth
Hanging from the Bunkbed in
Epstein's Cell Following His Death
Thomas explained that when he first entered Epstein's cell,
Epstein had an orange string, presumably from a sheet or a
shirt, around his neck. The end of the string was tied to the
top portion of the bunkbed. Epstein was suspended from the
top bunk in a near-seated position, with his buttocks
approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half off the floor and his
legs extended out straight on the floor. Thomas said Epstein
did not look discolored or very different from when he last
saw Epstein alive. Thomas said he immediately ripped the
orange sheet or shirt away from the bunkbed, and Epstein's
buttocks dropped approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half to
the ground. Thomas then lowered Epstein's entire body to
the floor and, because he did not believe Epstein was
breathing, Thomas immediately began providing chest
compressions until responding MCC New York staff members
arrived approximately 1 minute later. Thomas said he did not
provide rescue breaths and was unaware if Epstein was dead
or alive because he never checked for a pulse before initiating
chest compressions. Thomas said medical personnel took
over the emergency response, including chest compressions
and use of an automated external defibrillator (AED), when
they arrived. Thomas said he assisted with bringing Epstein
down to the Health Services Unit on the second floor, and
that he left MCC New York at approximately 8 a.m. Thomas
said he had received cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR)
training during MCC New York annual refresher training and
had responded to medical emergencies in the past, but this
was the first time he was the first responder.

Source: Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, Thomas said he was present in the SHU for his entire shift on
August 10, 2019, from 12 a.m. until the time he attempted to
deliver breakfast to Epstein at approximately 6:30 a.m. and
did not see anyone go inside Epstein's cell during his shift. Thomas said that he would have known if
someone went in or out of Epstein's cell and said no one did. Thomas told the OIG that he could see
Epstein's cell door from the SHU Officers' Station, but he could not see inside the cell from that vantage
point. Thomas said that it was not possible for anyone to have entered the SHU without his knowledge
because he or Noel would have had to open the SHU door for anyone to gain entry. The only other key to
the SHU was located elsewhere in the institution; no other MCC New York staff members had the keys
required to gain access to the SHU. Moreover, Thomas said that anyone attempting to access the L Tier
where Epstein was located would have had to walk directly in front of the SHU Officers' Station where
Thomas was seated, and no one did. Thomas denied that he or Noel had any role in Epstein's death.
City of New York
Noel told the OIG that on the morning on August 10, when it was time to deliver food to the inmates, she
unlocked the door to the L Tier and stood by it while Thomas took the food to the inmates. Noel said that
when Thomas knocked on Epstein's door, there was no response. Noel said Epstein's cell door was locked,
so Thomas used a key to open it and went inside. Noel heard Thomas call out for her to retrieve the cutter
and then she heard Thomas rip something. Noel said she observed Thomas lifting Epstein from under his
arms and dragging him back out of the corner of the cell and laid him down on the ground to perform CPR.
According to Noel, within seconds of Thomas calling out for the cutter she hit the body alarm, which is a
button on an MCC staff member's radio that is used to signal distress or an emergency. Noel recalled
hearing Thomas say, "Breathe, Epstein, breathe," and 'We're going to be in so much trouble." Noel said she
stood at the door about a foot away from Epstein's cell and never went in. Noel said Thomas only
performed chest compressions and said she did not see Thomas checking for breath or pulse. Noel said
that when she saw Epstein, he looked blue and did not have a shirt on or anything around his neck. Noel
said she did not get the cutter because Thomas did not need it based upon the ripping sound she heard.
Noel said an MCC New York Lieutenant who responded to the alarm asked her what happened, and before
she got the chance to answer, Thomas stated, "Oh, it's not her fault, we fucked up." Noel did not recall
making any comments or statements to the Lieutenant. Other than the Lieutenant, Noel did not recall
which COs responded to the alarm and she did not know what happened in the cell after MCC New York
staff arrived because she was waiting at the bottom of the steps outside the L Tier. Noel said she was alone
in the SHU for 20 minutes after they left with Epstein and she kept calling the Control Center to get
status updates.

Noel told the OIG that Epstein's cell was approximately 15 feet from the SHU Officers' Station. Noel said she
would have known if someone went in or out of Epstein's cell overnight and no one did. She also said that
there was no indication that any of the inmates could have gotten out of their cells. Noel said she never
slept during her shift on August 9-10, 2019. Noel said that when she is seen on the camera at the desk not
moving, she was on the computer. Noel then clarified by saying that she worked 5 days of overtime leading
up to her shift, so she would begin to doze off; however, she caught herself and never slept.
The Lieutenant told the OIG that he was the Operations Lieutenant who relieved the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant on August 10, 2019, at approximately 5:30 a.m. The Lieutenant said that at
approximately 6:33 a.m., he heard a call for a medical emergency in the SHU and immediately responded to
the alarm. When he arrived, Noel told him, "Epstein hung himself." Once inside, the Lieutenant observed
that Thomas was performing CPR on Epstein. The Lieutenant stated that he asked, "Where's his bunkie at?"
and that Noel responded, in substance, that Epstein did not have a cellmate. Noel also told the Lieutenant,
"We didn't do rounds at 3 a.m. and 5 a.m." Thomas stated, 'We didn't do the rounds. We messed up." The
Lieutenant took over administering CPR and asked SHU staff to retrieve an AED and call for the duty nurse.
The MCC New York Electronics Technician told the OIG that he responded to the emergency call at 6:33 a.m.
When the Electronics Technician first arrived in the SHU, Thomas and other MCC New York staff members
were picking Epstein up and placing him on a stretcher. The Electronics Technician said he and Senior
Officer Specialist 6 performed chest compressions on Epstein while he was on the stretcher and being
transported to the Health Services Unit on the second floor. 42 The Electronics Technician stated that he
42  Moving an inmate requiring outside emergency medical care to the Health Services Unit provides health care staff
and Emergency Medical Technicians (EMT) with immediate access to any necessary medical equipment and supplies,
and allows EMTs faster access to the inmate when they arrive at MCC New York because COs can directly escort EMTs to
the Health Services Unit to begin emergency treatment immediately. If EMTs had to be escorted to the housing unit,
they would first need to be thoroughly screened, which would delay medical attention.
then returned to the SHU and worked there for approximately 1 hour, along with the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant and Noel. The Electronics Technician believed he was in the SHU prior to 7 a.m. and
until approximately 8 a.m., but he was not positive with regard to the times. The Electronics Technician said
he delivered food to the inmates on one tier while the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant did the same
on another tier while Noel unlocked the doors outside of the tiers for the Electronics Technician and the
Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant. The Electronics Technician said that when they were delivering food
to the inmates, he heard the inmates saying, "You killed him. You weren't making rounds. You killed him."
The Electronics Technician told the OIG that the inmates also said Thomas and Noel just sat at the SHU
Officers' Station and never checked on the inmates. The Electronics Technician told the OIG he understood
the inmates to be saying that Thomas and Noel were responsible for Epstein's death because they had not
conducted rounds during their shift. The Electronics Technician said he believed that Epstein took his own
life and said he had no reason to believe otherwise.

Senior Officer Specialist 6 said he responded to the emergency call at 6:33 a.m. and when he arrived, staff
members were already performing CPR on Epstein. Senior Officer Specialist 6 said he assisted with
transporting Epstein to the Health Services Unit, taking Epstein to the ambulance, and then followed the
ambulance to the hospital in another vehicle, and stayed at the hospital until he was relieved from duty.
The OIG also reviewed photographs that were taken in the MCC New York Health Services Unit of EMTs
attempting to resuscitate Epstein. The photographs show, among other things, Epstein on his back with an
intravenous line in his arm, his orange BOP-issued shirt ripped open and laying around his arms, and him
wearing orange BOP-issued boxer shorts. None of the photographs taken at MCC New York show Epstein in
a hospital gown, although the OIG did review photographs taken at New York Presbyterian Lower
Manhattan Hospital which show Epstein in a hospital gown.

Additionally, the OIG participated in interviews of three inmates assigned to the same SHU tier as Epstein at
the time of his death and who were housed in cells opposite Epstein's cell and therefore had a direct line of
sight to Epstein's cell.o3 One such inmate was Inmate 5, who was assigned to a cell directly across from
Epstein's cell on the left side of the tier and who told the OIG that he could see all the cells on the right side
of L Tier, where Epstein was housed. Inmate 5 believed a count was last conducted within the SHU on
August 9, 2019, a little before 12 a.m., and said that no additional count was conducted after that time.
Inmate 5 did not see anyone, or hear anyone, go into Epstein's cell on the night of August 9 or the morning
of August 10 prior to a male CO discovering Epstein on the morning of August 10. Inmate S said the male
CO knocked on Epstein's assigned cell, looked in, and then opened the door. Inmate 5 could only see
Epstein's legs from the knee down but could tell that Epstein was laying down on his back because his feet
were pointed upward. The male CO bent down to shake Epstein and was saying, "Epstein, Epstein." The
male CO then tried to pick up Epstein from behind, with his arms wrapped around Epstein. Inmate 5 said
both the officer and Epstein fell back to the floor, with Epstein falling to the side of the officer. Inmate 5 said
that once the two fell, he could then see that it was Epstein. The CO then started giving Epstein chest
compressions and mouth-to-mouth resuscitation. At this point, the officer said, 'Fuck!" and asked the
female CO, who was standing near the L Tier gate, if she has pressed the button. The female officer said,
"Yeah, a long time ago." A Lieutenant then arrived at Epstein's cell along with a male nurse who tried to
43  As noted previously, the U.S. Attorneys Office for the Southern District of New York sought interviews from all of 
the
inmates housed in the L Tier of the SHU on the night that Epstein died.

revive Epstein. Epstein was not responsive. Inmate S said Epstein looked dead when the male CO tried to
pick him up and they both fell. Inmate 5 said officers had trouble getting Epstein onto the stretcher because
Epstein was basically dead weight. When the officers did get Epstein on the stretcher, Epstein still had on
headphones." Inmate 5 did not see any marks around Epstein's neck, and he did not see a rope around
Epstein's neck. However, Inmate S saw a male CO come out of Epstein's cell with a sheet that had a loop
and knot.
Figure 5.4
Location of the Cells Assigned to Inmates 5-7 in Relation to Epstein's Cell in the L Tier
Source: DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting
the MCC New York SHU
Inmate 6 told the OIG that on August 9 and 10, 2019, he was housed within the SHU on L Tier in a cell
directly across from Epstein's cell. Inmate 6 last saw Epstein's cellmate, Inmate 3, on August 9 when
Inmate 3 said, "See you later. I'm going to court." Inmate 6 said Inmate 3 did not return that night and said
the SHU officers never conducted their required 30-minute rounds. Inmate 6 believed the COs last checked
on the inmates in the SHU on August 10 between 12:30 a.m. and 1 a.m. Inmate 6 did not observe anyone
entering Epstein's cell after Epstein returned from his legal visit on August 9, 2019; did not hear noise that
night; and said Epstein's door was not opened during the night. Inmate 6 said a male officer discovered
Epstein dead during breakfast delivery on August 10. Inmate 6 said he observed the male CO entered
Epstein's cell and began performing CPR, while the female CO, who appeared panicked, stayed outside of
the cell. Inmate 6 said he observed Epstein on the floor but did not see a rope over Epstein's head.
However, when Epstein was removed from his cell, Inmate 6 observed the COs holding a rope and a
44  An MP3 player with headphones was obtained as evidence by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).
defibrillator. Inmate 6 did not see marks on Epstein's neck but did see bruising on his face and observed
earphones that were still in place on Epstein's ears.

Inmate 7, who was two cells down from Epstein's cell and on the other side of the tier, told the OIG that he
could not see into Epstein's cell but he could see the cell door. Inmate 7 said that after dinner was brought
to Epstein's cell on the evening of August 9, 2019, Inmate 7 did not recall seeing anyone going in or out of
Epstein's cell until the following morning at around 6 a.m. He further stated that he did not hear any door
"pop open" that evening. Inmate 7 said he remembered waking up around 6 a.m. on August 10, 2019, and
hearing a voice, possibly male, saying "Breathe." Inmate 7 said he saw Epstein removed from his cell on
a stretcher.

In addition, the OIG and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) interviewed seven inmates assigned to
other tiers in the SHU, none of whom had any direct knowledge of how Epstein died. These inmates
consistently reported that the SHU officers did not systematically conduct the counts and rounds as
required on the evening Epstein died and that the last round was either between 9:30-10 p.m. or 12:30-
1 a.m. Several inmates told the OIG that before Epstein died the SHU staff never conducted rounds at night.
According to the SOP Form 583 Report of Incident, on August 10, 2019, at approximately 6:33 a.m., while
delivering the breakfast meal, Epstein was found unresponsive in his cell. Consistent with the required
response to a suspected suicide outlined in the MCC New York General Housing Unit Post Orders that are
described in Chapter 2, staff called for assistance and began life-saving measures." At 6:39 a.m., Epstein
was taken to the MCC New York Health Services Unit, and Emergency Medical Services (EMS) arrived to MCC
New York at 6:43 a.m. Epstein was transported to the local hospital, New York Presbyterian Lower
Manhattan Hospital, at 7:10 a.m., and was pronounced deceased at 7:36 a.m.

According to a memorandum attached to the Form 583 from the Clinical Nurse dated August 10, 2019, when
the medical emergency involving Epstein was called over the radio, the Clinical Nurse immediately
responded to the call and upon arrival, saw Epstein on the floor within his cell unresponsive with CPR in
progress by COs. The Clinical Nurse's memorandum reads that Epstein was cold, with circumferential
bruising around his neck and posterior mottling, pupils fixes and dilatated, and no palpable pulses were felt.
According to the memorandum, at 6:35 a.m., a call was placed for EMS, CPR continued, and an AED was
utilized and indicated "No Shock Advised," so CPR continued. Epstein was then transported to the MCC
New York Health Services Unit treatment room with CPR in progress. Upon arrival, Epstein's pulse was
checked, and the AED indicated "No Shock Advised." EMS and paramedics arrived on the scene, intubated
Epstein, and gave him medications and fluids." Epstein was transported to the local emergency room with
CPR in progress at approximately 7:10 a.m.

45 As noted in Chapter 2, BOP policy provides that the need to immediately attend to an apparent suicide victim,
undertake lifesaving measures, and ensure inmate and staff safety take precedence over efforts to preserve a
crime scene.

46 The EMS arrival time on the Clinical Nurse's memorandum is listed as 6:56 a.m. Based on the OIG's review of other
documentation and interviews, we believe the arrival time reflected on those other documents (6:43 a.m.) is more likely
the time of EMS's arrival. We noted that the Clinical Nurse, at the time of EMS's arrival, was actively engaged in
administering CPR to Epstein and responding to the health emergency.

According to a memorandum attached to the Form 583 from the Correctional Systems Officer dated
August 10, 2019, after Noel called the medical emergency, the Correctional Systems Officer received a call
from staff in the SHU instructing her to call 911 for an ambulance. The Correctional Systems Officer notified
the New York Police Department (NYPD) via the MCC New York institutional NYPD telephone. The
Correctional Systems Officer then informed NYPD that MCC New York needed an ambulance and medical
assistance for one of the inmates. The New York City Fire Department and EMS arrived at MCC New York at
6:43 a.m. and were escorted to the second-floor medical area. EMS departed MCC New York with Epstein
and a BOP escort via ambulance and chase car to the local hospital at 7:10 a.m.

The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that she was relieved as the Operations Lieutenant
prior to 6 a.m. on August 10, 2019, but was still working on things like the Daily Activity Reports and
Lieutenant Logs that she did not get to finish during her shift. At some point, the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant heard that there was a medical emergency in SHU, so she went to assist because she
knew that inmates would need to be given food and other things would need to be done. The Morning
Watch Operations Lieutenant estimated that she went to the SHU around 7 a.m. to help with the inmate
meals, and believed the Electronics Technician was also helping out. Noel was there, but she was not
helping with delivering food to the inmates. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant said that after the
meals were delivered, she finished up and went home.

All MCC New York staff members who were interviewed by the OIG said they did not know of any
information suggesting that Epstein's cause of death was something other than suicide. Additionally, no
inmate provided the OIG with information suggesting that anyone assisted Epstein with taking his own life
or had any credible information suggesting that Epstein's cause of death was something other than suicide.
Some MCC New York staff told the OIG that Epstein's death could have been prevented if, among other
things, Epstein had been assigned a new cellmate after Inmate 3's departure and rounds and counts had
been conducted in the SHU as required. Some witnesses also faulted MCC New York staffing shortages,
which resulted in excessive overtime and meant that MCC New York staff members were often overtired
during their shifts. Other MCC New York staff members told the OIG that even if inmate safety and
accountability measures had been property executed, an inmate who wanted to take his life would have
found a way to do so.
B. Items Found in Epstein's Cell on August 10 Following His Death
Following Epstein's death, the BOP and FBI collected many of the items found inside Epstein's cell. The FBI
inspected the cell and retrieved what it believed to be relevant to its investigation into the cause of Epstein's
death, which included one torn sheet, miscellaneous papers, and an MP3 player. The FBI did not recover
any weapons inside of the cell. After the FBI's inspection, the BOP recycled the linens from Epstein's cell and
collected the remaining items, which included various over-the-counter medications, books (including
religious books), BOP pamphlets, toiletries, batteries, headphones, glasses, mail and envelopes, a brown
paper bag, an orange homemade rope, AED pads, and a medical device.
Figure 5.5
Photograph of a Piece of Orange Cloth Tied into
a Noose Recovered from Epstein's Cell
After His Death ."
Source: Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, City of
New York
The photographs of Epstein's cell on August 10, 2019,
show an excess of blankets, linens, and clothing.
Some of the linens had been ripped into thin strips,
which were tied to the desk and bunkbed inside the
cell. Some of the strips were tied like a noose. When
shown a picture of Epstein's cell, Noel verified that it
contained a lot of linen and extra clothing. Noel said
the mattress on the floor was Epstein's, as he always
slept on the mattress on the floor. As detailed in the
BOP policies section of Chapter 2, MCC New York
SHU Post Orders required that COs assigned to the
SHU during the daytime tours of duty conduct at
least five cell searches each day, and that the entire
SHU, including all common areas and cells, be
searched every week. The OIG investigation
revealed, however, that on August 9, 2019, the SHU
staff logged only one cell search in TRUSCOPE, and
the search was not of Epstein's cell." BOP records
did not indicate when Epstein's cell was last searched.
The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that
at least five cell searches should be conducted on the
day and night watch shifts within the SHU, and that
cell searches are conducted in cells every time the
inmate departs the cell. He said the SHU Officer in Charge was responsible for making sure the searches
were conducted and logged into the BOP TRUSCOPE database. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said
that only one cell search was entered into TRUSCOPE on August 9, 2019, because cell searches were tedious
to enter, and he was busy. He did not believe that it was a problem that only one cell search was logged on
August 9 because he said the SHU staff would have gone into every cell when the inmates took their
showers. He said that during the period of Epstein's custody, SHU inmates showered on Mondays,
Wednesdays, and Fridays. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that during showers, SHU staff
searched every cell. He explained that all of the SHU cells should have been searched on Friday, August 9
because it was a shower day. He said SHU staff should also conduct cell searches when inmates go to the
recreation area or for attorney visits. According to the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, Epstein's cell
should have been searched because both Epstein and Inmate 3 left the cell on the morning of August 9. He
further stated that he believed that the majority of cells in the SHU were searched although, as noted above,
the SHU staff logged only one cell search in TRUSCOPE on August 9 and the search was not of Epstein's cell.
41 As noted previously, Epstein's cell contained an excessive amount of linens, some of which had been ripped into thin
strips and tied like a noose. Figure 6.5 depicts one such noose, which is illustrative of the types of linens found in
Epstein's cell; the noose depicted is not the ligature Epstein used to kill himself.

" TRUSCOPE is a BOP database that provides institution staff with detailed inmate and institution security-related
information and provides unit officers an electronic event log.
Figure 5.6
Photograph of Epstein's Cell After
His Death
Source: Office of the Chief Medical Examiner,
City of New York
The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that in
August 2019, each inmate would have been authorized to
have two sheets and one blanket. He said that in the winter,
inmates are allowed to have an additional blanket. When
interviewed by the OIG, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge
reviewed a picture of Epstein's cell from August 10, 2019,
after Epstein had been removed from the cell. The Day
Watch SHU Officer in Charge said there appeared to be an
excess number of linens and blankets in the cell, which he
believed were for both Epstein and Inmate 3, and that there
were possibly a couple of extra sheets as well. He noted that
there were two mattresses in the cell and deduced that
Inmate 3's assigned items had not yet been removed even
though he had departed MCC New York earlier that day.
According to the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge,
Inmate 3's items should have been removed as soon as the
SHU staff knew Inmate 3 was not returning. He told the OIG
that any extra linens or blankets should be removed when
the inmates take showers and their cells are searched. He
told the OIG that he believed the purpose of limiting the
linens provided to the inmates was to ensure there was
enough to go around and that it was more of an
administrative matter rather than a security matter.
The Captain also reviewed the picture of Epstein's cell from
August 10, 2019, when interviewed by the OIG. He said
Epstein had too many linens, t-shirts, and blankets in his cell.
The Captain said the SHU staff were responsible for
removing those items because they did not want to hear the
other inmates complain that they were not issued the same
number of items. The Captain stated that it is also a security
issue because it "gives the inmates the materials to be able to make homemade fashioned and improvised
nooses" or "use it as escape paraphernalia," such as a rope that inmates had used to escape from another
facility in Chicago.

Inmate 3 told the OIG that Epstein was allowed to sleep on the floor, which he said was unusual for the SHU
where that was not normally allowed. Inmate 3 said Epstein also had two extra blankets, which no other
inmate had, as well as two pens, which inmates were not allowed to have. Epstein would ask for things, and
if the COs said no, Epstein would tell them he was writing down their name and providing the information to
his lawyer. According to Inmate 3, the COs were on "eggshells" around Epstein. Inmate 3 said that when he
left the SHU on August 9, 2019, there was an orange cloth twisted around the ladder, strings on the side of
the ladder, and a string tied across the bed. Inmate 3 explained that the string tied across the bed served as
a clothesline, and that the strings were part of a sheet they had ripped. According to Inmate 3, one night he
woke up, saw Epstein fidgeting with the clothesline, and asked Epstein what he was doing. Epstein said he
was trying to fix the clothesline, but Inmate 3 told him no and flushed the clothesline down the toilet. As
discussed in Chapter 4, when Inmate 3 and Epstein first became cellmates upon Epstein's return to the SHU
following suicide watch and psychological observation, Inmate 3 asked Epstein not to kill himself while
Inmate 3 was his cellmate because Inmate 3 had a chance to go home soon. In response, Epstein told
Inmate 3 not to worry and that he was not going to cause him any trouble.

When Inmate 3 left on August 9, he told Epstein that he would leave the clothesline in the cell so that
Epstein could wash his clothes. Inmate 3 did not say anything about a noose having been in the cell, but he
said there were five blankets in their cell when he left.
C. Autopsy Results
On August 11, 2019, the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, City of New York, performed an autopsy on
Epstein and determined that the cause of death was hanging and the manner of death a suicide. One of the
office's Medical Examiners performed the autopsy, and the autopsy report was reviewed by the First Deputy
Chief Medical Examiner. In connection with this investigation, the OIG interviewed the Medical Examiner
who performed the Epstein autopsy (hereinafter the "Medical Examiner"). The Medical Examiner told the
OIG that the pattern of Epstein's neck bone fractures was consistent with a hanging. The Medical Examiner
explained that a different fracture pattern is present if there has been a manual compression of the neck
versus a sustained pressure like in a hanging, and the pattern of Epstein's neck fractures was that of a
hanging. The Medical Examiner also said Epstein had petechial hemorrhages, which are pinpoint bleeds in
skin, on his face and mouth. These hemorrhages are caused when the blood flow is obstructed and the
small skin capillaries burst. The Medical Examiner additionally identified plethora, which is purple
discoloration of the skin, and stated that both petechial hemorrhages and plethora are consistent with
suicide by hanging. The Medical Examiner stated that Epstein's petechia and plethora were identified from
his neck up. In homicidal strangulations, according to the Medical Examiner, these conditions are normally
found only in the eyes and mouth, and in a different pattern. Epstein also had, the Medical Examiner
explained, a marked and obvious ligature furrow that peaked upward which is consistent with suicide as
opposed to a ligature strangulation.

The Medical Examiner further stated that there was no evidence of defensive wounds consistent with what
is seen in victims of strangulation. The Medical Examiner told the OIG that in strangulation cases there is
invariably some signs of a struggle, even if the victim is impaired. The Medical Examiner noted that the
autopsy did not identify any signs of a struggle. Epstein did not have any marks on his hands (no broken
fingernails, no debris under the fingernails, no contusions to his knuckles) that would have evidenced a
fight, and, other than an abrasion on his arm likely due to convulsing from hanging, no bruising on his body.
We also were told by the Medical Examiner that Epstein did not have strap muscle hemorrhages of the neck,
which is bleeding in the lung muscles in the front of the neck. Nor did he have, the Medical Examiner told
the OIG, hemorrhaging in the muscles in the back of his neck. The Medical Examiner explained that you
would expect to see that hemorrhaging when there has been an incomplete compression as opposed to a
sustained compression like a hanging.

In addition, the Medical Examiner determined that the cloth material of the ligature (noose) found in
Epstein's cell could have caused the fractures and superficial injuries the Medical Examiner identified during
the autopsy. The Medical Examiner also told the OIG that the ligature furrow was too broad to have been
caused by the electrical cord of the medical device in Epstein's cell. The Medical Examiner said blood
toxicology tests were conducted and no medications or illegal substances were identified in Epstein's
system. The Medical Examiner stated that the ruling of Epstein's death a suicide was the Medical Examinees
independent medical judgment and that the Medical Examiner was not pressured or otherwise subjected to
any attempt to influence her ruling.
Chapter 6: The Availability of Limited Recorded Video Evidence
Due to the Security Camera Recording System Failure
In August 2019, the Metropolitan Correctional Center located in New York, New York (MCC New York) had
approximately 150 video security cameras (no audio) placed throughout the institution. The Office of the
Inspector General (OIG) found that approximately 11 cameras were located in and around the Special
Housing Unit (SHU) where Epstein was confined at the time of his death on August 10, 2019, including one at
the end of the L Tier where Epstein was housed that showed any movement in or out of inmate cells and in
the Tier's hallway. In addition to broadcasting live video, MCC New York had a system that recorded the live
video feeds. Following Epstein's death, MCC New York officials and Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
investigators attempted to review video recordings related to the incident and discovered that, although the
security cameras were working and transmitting live video, recorded video from most of the cameras in the
SHU area was not available due to a malfunction of the video recording system that had occurred on July 29,
2019, including video from the camera at the end of the L Tier. As a result, while the L Tier video camera
was transmitting a live video feed on the night of August 9, 2019, and morning of August 10, 2019, the video
was not being recorded. One of the cameras that had available recordings from August 9 and 10 was a
camera located outside a housing unit adjacent to the SHU. That camera captured video of a large part of
the common area of the SHU, including the SHU Officers' Station and portions of the stairways leading to
the different SHU tiers, including the L Tier. Thus, anyone entering or attempting to enter the L Tier from
the common area of the SHU, including on August 9 and 10, would have been picked up by the video
recorded by that camera. In addition, the recordings showed the SHU Officers' Station where the two SHU
staff were seated at a desk immediately outside the entrance to the L Tier and diagonally across from
Epstein's cell, which was the first cell on the righthand side of the L Tier.
I. Background on the Security Camera System at MCC New York
All video surveillance from MCC New York's cameras was connected to a Digital Video Recorder (DVR)
system. The DVR system had two data storage systems that were labeled "DVR 1" and "DVR 2," and each
consisted of 16 hard drives used for storing digital recordings. Roughly half of MCC New York's security
cameras were assigned to record to DVR 1, and the other half were assigned to record to DVR 2. Cameras
assigned to DVR 1 only recorded to the DVR 1 hard drives, and cameras assigned to DVR 2 only recorded to
the DVR 2 hard drives. Therefore, if DVR 2 crashed, no video from the DVR 2-assigned cameras could be
retrieved from DVR 1, and vice versa.

The OIG's investigation revealed a history of camera problems at MCC New York. In August 2019, the
Electronics Technician was the only such technician at MCC New York. The Electronics Technician told the
OIG that when he began work at MCC New York in 2016, he found that the facility's security camera system
needed to be upgraded. According to the Electronics Technician, the system had not been properly
maintained prior to his arrival, the hard drives in the DVRs frequently malfunctioned and needed to be
replaced, and the overall system was outdated, in part because the cameras were analog and not digital.
The Electronics Technician told the OIG that, throughout his tenure at MCC New York, the camera system
was subject to frequently recurring failures, particularly with respect to the DVR hard drives.a9
The Warden, who assumed his responsibilities at MCC New York in May 2018, told the OIG he was generally
aware that there were problems with the security camera system throughout the institution. He further
stated that efforts were undertaken to determine which cameras were working and which needed to be
fixed, and that MCC New York officials intended to ultimately seek funding to replace the entire system.
Federal Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) records reflect that on September 6, 2018, the Warden submitted a
memorandum to the BOP's Northeast Regional Director to request $800,000 in funding to replace the entire
camera system. The memorandum identified an estimated project start date of December 1, 2018, and an
estimated completion date of February 9, 2019. The BOP approved the funding request, and on
September 21, 2018, a contract in the amount of $698,108.99 was awarded to Company 1 to provide various
equipment for the project and associated labor. On September 24, 2018, a separate contract in the amount
of $34,089.28 was awarded to Company 2 to provide assorted networking equipment and wiring needed to
install the camera system.

As the camera upgrade project was beginning, BOP officials recognized that MCC New York's mechanical,
electrical, and plumbing systems were also in need of major repairs. MCC New York did not have enough
qualified technicians on staff to complete both the camera installation and other repairs needed at the
facility, so beginning the week of March 17, 2019, the BOP's Northeast Regional Office arranged for
technicians from other BOP institutions to conduct temporary duty (TDY) assignments at MCC New York to
perform the work. During the course of the TDY rotations, work was not consistently conducted on the
camera upgrade because sometimes TDY staff assigned to the project were used to cover shortages at MCC
New York's custody posts, and sometimes there were not enough TDY volunteers who possessed the skills
required to do the camera work.

At the time of Epstein's death on August 10, 2019, the camera system upgrade had not been completed.
Immediately following Epstein's death, Company 1 officials arrived at MCC New York and installed the new
recording system within a couple of days, and recording functionality was restored using the existing
cameras. The majority of the new cameras did not arrive at the facility until October 2019, and they were
installed in stages as the wiring work was conducted. According to the Electronics Technician, as of
August 2021, when the MCC closed, the wiring work had still not been fully completed.
II. Discovery of Security Camera System Recording Issues in August 2019
A. Discovery on August 8 of the DVR 2 Failure that Occurred on July 29
According to forensic analysis conducted by the FBI after Epstein's death, disk failures occurred in MCC
New York's DVR 2 system on July 29, 2019, which resulted in the system being unable to record. According
to BOP records and OIG interviews, the BOP did not learn about the failure until August 8, 2019, when the
Special Investigative Services (SIS) Lieutenant and Associate Warden 1 attempted to review recorded
surveillance video for a matter unrelated to Epstein. The SIS Lieutenant told the OIG she discovered that no
49 The Electronics Technician provided the OIG with copies of email messages and work orders that documented nine
instances between June 2017 and July 2019, in which actions were taken to address a problem with either the MCC
New York's cameras or the hard drives used to record video from the cameras.

recorded video was available for several of the institution's cameras, so she reported the matter to the
Communications Office, and the Electronics Technician arrived to assess the problem sometime before his
shift was scheduled to end. The Electronics Technician told the OIG that he found that roughly half of the
institution's approximately 150 cameras, which were assigned to record to DVR 2, were displaying a live
video feed but were not recording.

The Electronics Technician told the OIG that, before Epstein's death, no one was specifically tasked with
ensuring that video from the cameras was being recorded. The Electronics Technician said he therefore did
not perform any daily checks to ensure that video was being recorded. The Warden indicated that SIS staff
are usually responsible for checking the system for recording functionality and reporting any problems to
the Communications Office. However, the SIS Lieutenant told the OIG that it was her belief that the
Electronics Technician should have been checking the system daily to ensure it was recording. The OIG
found that there are no BOP policies that specifically state that institutional staff must perform periodic
checks to ensure the camera system is fully functional or that security camera systems have the capacity to
record. 50 The Facility Manager told the OIG that since Epstein's death, he now checks to ensure that all
cameras and the recording system are working on a daily basis, and he subsequently provides a report
about the status of the system to the facility's executive staff, the SIS, and the electronics technicians.
B. Response on August 8 and 9 to Discovery of the Recording Failure
On August 8, following discovery of the recording failure, Company 1 service request records reflect that the
Electronics Technician contacted a Company 1 technical support representative, who ultimately determined
that two hard drives within DVR 2 had failed. According to the Electronics Technician and the Company 1
service request record, the Company 1 representative informed the Electronics Technician that the two
drives needed to be replaced and DVR 2 needed to be rebuilt in order for the cameras to record again. The
Electronics Technician told the OIG that he informed a Company 1 Technician that he had to obtain the
drives from MCC New York's Computer Services Manager. The Electronics Technician further stated that he
left the institution at the end of his shift and did not obtain the hard drives and did not continue to work on
the matter. The Electronics Technician told the OIG he had "no idea" why he did not stay at the facility to
resolve the problem that day, but he noted for the OIG that he had not historically been required to stay
after his shift ended to work on such matters, and even if he had begun working on the DVR that day, he
would not have completed the work on August 8 due to the time the rebuilding process takes.s'
The OIG found that the Electronics Technician's immediate supervisor, the Facility Manager, was on leave
that week and therefore was not told on August 8 about the DVR recording failure. The Facility Manager
confirmed that he did not learn about the camera problem until days after Epstein's death. The Electronics
Technician told the OIG that he did not report the problem to the Lock and Security Supervisor, who was the
Acting Facility Manager in the Facility Manager's absence. The SIS Lieutenant told the OIG that after the
Electronics Technician had examined the system on August 8, the Electronics Technician informed her that
cameras were not recording and said, "I'm going to stay and do overtime tonight." Based on his comment,
so For example, BOP Program Statement 5500.15, Correctional Services Manual, states generally that the Warden must
establish a security inspection system that involves all departments but does not specifically address security camera
systems. This program statement is a restricted policy that is not released to the public in its entirety.
Si According to open source information on digital data storage system rebuilds, the rebuilding process can take up to
several days to complete depending on the number of hard drives that were damaged and the storage capacity of each.
the SIS Lieutenant assumed that the Electronics Technician would remain at the institution after his shift
ended that day to correct the issue. The Electronics Technician told the OIG there must have been some
miscommunication because he did not say he was going to work overtime and resolve the problem that
same evening since he knew the problem could not be fixed in one evening. The Electronics Technician told
the OIG that, in hindsight, he should have stayed at the institution to begin work on the problem that
same day.

The SIS Lieutenant told the OIG that she verbally informed the Captain on August 8 that the cameras were
down, but BOP records reflect that the Captain left the institution before the malfunction was discovered.
The Captain told the OIG that he did not learn about the DVR recording issue until after Epstein's death on
August 10 when he asked to see video related to the Epstein incident. Associate Warden 1 confirmed she
was with the SIS Lieutenant on August 8 when the camera problem was discovered, but she told the OIG she
only knew video could not be replayed. She did not know the recording system for certain cameras was
down. She could see live video from the cameras on that date, and therefore assumed they were recording.
According to the Electronics Technician, after he reported to work on August 9, 2019, and attended to other
matters throughout the day, the Electronics Technician obtained the replacement hard drives and
attempted to perform the repair sometime late in the day. However, the Electronics Technician told the OIG
that no SIS staff were present at that time to give him access to the room in which the DVR room was
located, so he requested access from the only other individual who had a key to the space, Correctional
Officer (CO) 4.52 According to the Electronics Technician, CO 4 denied him access to the room because CO
4's shift was ending at 4 p.m., and CO 4 was unable to stay and accompany him in the space while the
Electronics Technician performed the work. According to the Electronics Technician, CO 4 said he would be
at the institution the following day to provide the Electronics Technician access to the room, so the
Electronics Technician decided to postpone the repair until the following day. The Electronics Technician
said his decision was influenced by the fact that he had historically been told by MCC New York supervisors
that such matters did not have to be attended to until the following day, and even if he had replaced the
hard drives that day, the rebuilding process would have taken 24 hours to complete and would therefore
not have finished until the following day anyway.
C. SHU Camera Locations and Operational Status on August 10
The Electronics Technician arrived at the institution around 6 a.m. on August 10, 2019, and shortly
thereafter, before he could begin working on the DVR system, he heard the staff body alarm sound and he
reported to the SHU to assist. Later that day he was asked to pull potential video from cameras located in
and around the SHU. The Electronics Technician eventually determined that most of the cameras in the
SHU area were assigned to record to DVR 2. While the cameras assigned to DVR 2 were providing live video
streams on August 9 and 10, 2019, no recordings from those cameras were available due to the DVR 2 hard
drive issue, which the FBI later determined had occurred on July 29, 2019. Among the cameras whose video
was not recorded was the camera at the end of L Tier, the SHU tier in which Epstein was housed.
52 The DVR system was located in a locked room, and access to the room was limited to the institution's SIS unit, staff
assigned to inmate phone monitoring, and the Electronics Technicians.

Only two cameras in the vicinity of the SHU area were recording to DVR 1 at the time of Epstein's death.s3
One camera was located on the upper-level entrance to the 10 South Unit, a housing unit adjacent to the
SHU, near the door MCC New York staff referred to as the "46 door." That camera captured video of a large
part of the common area of the SHU, including the SHU Officers' Station and portions of the stairways
leading to the different SHU tiers, including the tier containing Epstein's cell. Thus, anyone entering or
attempting to enter the L Tier from the common area of the SHU on August 9 and 10 would have been
picked up by the video recorded by that camera. Epstein's cell door, however, was not in that camera's field
of view. The other camera that was recording was located in one of the ninth floors two elevator bays and
provided video of the ninth -floor fire exit and two of the floors four elevators.

The available video showed that at approximately 7:49 p.m. on August 9, Epstein was escorted toward the
L Tier stairway by an individual believed to be the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge.54 At approximately
10:39 p.m., an unidentified CO appeared to walk up the L Tier stairway, and then reappeared within view of
the camera at 10:41 p.m. This is believed to be the last time anyone entered L Tier before approximately
6:30 a.m. on August 10. Between approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and just before 6:30 a.m. on
August 10, the OIG did not observe on the recorded video any CO or other individual enter any of the SHU
tiers, which is consistent with CO Tova Noel and Material Handler Michael Thomas's admissions to the OIG
that the SHU rounds and counts were not conducted during that time frame. At approximately 6:28 a.m., an
unidentified officer was observed on the L Tier stairway, presumably to deliver breakfast food trays.
Between 6:28 a.m. and 6:32 a.m., an unidentified officer, believed to be Noel, moved back and forth several
times between the L Tier stairway and the SHU Officers' Station. At approximately 6:33 a.m., additional
officers entered the SHU and ascended the L Tier stairway, presumably after Noel activated her body alarm
when Epstein was discovered hanged in his cell.

As noted above, the camera at the end of the L Tier was providing a live video feed at the time of Epstein's
death but the video was not being recorded. The Electronics Technician told the OIG that certain MCC
New York personnel, including the Control Center, SIS personnel, the Warden, most Lieutenants, and the
Electronics Technician, had access to the live video feed of the institution's security cameras. He explained
that to view the live feed of a particular camera an employee with access would need to key in the specific
camera into the security camera system to call up the live feed. The Correctional Systems Officer, who was
working in the Control Center on August 10 from 12 a.m. to 8 a.m., and the Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant both told the OIG that the only live feed from the SHU on their screens was video from the
camera showing the SHU common area, and they did not perceive a need to take the necessary steps to see
the live feed from the SHU L Tier from either of their duty stations on the evening Epstein died.
S3 One additional camera located at the 10 South Officers' Station was recording on August 10, 2019. That camera is not
depicted in Figure 4.12 because neither the SHU nor the SHU entrances were within the field of view of that camera.
54 The OIG found the video captured by the camera at the entrance to the 10 South Unit to be of low quality. Due to the
video's low quality and the distance between the camera and the SHU common area, the OIG was able to observe
movement of individuals within the SHU but was not always able to conclusively identify the individuals. The OIG was
also not always able to determine the specific destinations of the individuals seen in the video given that the camera
only captured partial views of the stairways to the various SHU tiers. The OIG found that movements captured on the
video were generally consistent with employee actions described by multiple witnesses and certain actions documented
In BOP records.
Figure 6.1
SHU Camera Locations and Recording Status on August 10, 2019
Upper rs Tiers
0 Streaming and Recording
Camera
El Streaming but not Recording
Camera
Source: DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
Figure 6.2
Location of Recording SHU Camera at 10th Floor -South entrance
Note: The photograph has been modified for privacy reasons.

Source: DOJ OIG photograph and DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU
Figure 6.3
Field of View of the SHU Camera at 10th Floor -South Entrance
Source: DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU and the BOP
Figure 6.4
Partial View of L Tier Stairway, from the SHU Camera at 10th Floor -South Entrance
Source: DOJ OIG and the BOP
Figure 6.5
View of SHU Officers' Station from the SHU Camera at 10th Floor -South Entrance
Source: 00J 0IG and the BOP
Figure 6.6
Field of View of the Recording 9th Floor Elevator Bay Camera
Source: DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SW and the BOP
Figure 6.7
Location of Non -Recording Camera in the L Tier of the SHU
Source: DOJ OIG schematic drawing depicting the MCC New York SHU and the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner,
City of New York
The Warden, who was not scheduled to work on August 10, 2019, arrived at the institution later that
morning after being notified of Epstein's death and was informed that most of the cameras in the SHU were
not recording. He told the OIG that when the SIS Lieutenant arrived at the facility that morning, he informed
her that the SHU cameras had not been recording, and the SIS Lieutenant explained that the hard drive
issue had been detected on August 8. He told the OIG that prior to August 10, he was unaware that the
DVR 2 issue had been detected on August 8, and that approximately half of the facility's cameras, and in
particular the cameras in the SHU, were found to not be recording on that date.

The Electronics Technician told the OIG that the Warden had instructed Electronics Technician to try and
recover any potential SHU video that may have been recorded by the cameras assigned to the
malfunctioning DVR 2 system, but the Electronics Technician was unable to find anything. The Electronics
Technician further said that the Warden wanted to have all the facility's cameras recording again as soon as
possible, so he instructed the Electronics Technician to begin repairing DVR 2.

D. FBI Forensic Analysis of the DVR System
FBI evidence documents revealed that on August 10, 2019, the FBI seized all hard drives contained within
the DVR 2 system. On August 14, 2019, the FBI returned to MCC New York and seized additional DVR 2
components. On August 15, 2019, the FBI seized the entire DVR 1 system.

The FBI's Digital Forensics Analysis Unit in Quantico, Virginia, received MCC New York's DVR system on
August 16, 2019, and began to conduct a forensic analysis of the system. According to FBI forensic reports,
DVR 2 did not start successfully. The Digital Forensics Analysis Unit found that the system contained three
faulty hard drives. The FBI forensic reports state that the three drives were repaired by an FBI Advanced
Data Recovery Specialist, but the DVR was never able to be assembled successfully. The forensic reports
further state that an FBI computer scientist and the Company 1 Technician reviewed the DVR 2 controller
logs and found that there had previously been "catastrophic disk failures" and no recordings would have
been available after July 29, 2019.

When the OIG asked the Electronics Technician about this finding by the FBI, he told the OIG he was
unaware that cameras were not recording to DVR 2 between July 29 and August 8, 2019. Neither the
Warden nor the SIS Lieutenant was aware the cameras assigned to DVR 2 had not been recording since
July 29, 2019. The Company 1 Technician could not recall working with the Electronics Technician on any
DVR issues prior to August 8, 2019, but he said that if the entire DVR 2 server went down on July 29, 2019, no
video would have been able to have been retrieved from that point forward from any of the cameras
recording to DVR 2.
Chapter 7: Conclusions and Recommendations
I. Conclusions
Our investigation and review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) custody, care, and supervision of
Jeffrey Epstein identified numerous and serious failures by employees of the Metropolitan Correctional
Center located in New York, New York (MCC New York), including falsifying BOP records relating to inmate
counts and rounds and multiple violations of MCC New York and BOP policies and procedures, which
compromised Epstein's safety, the safety of other inmates, and the security of the institution. Specifically,
we found that MCC New York staff failed to undertake required measures designed to make sure that,
among other things, Epstein and other inmates were accounted for and safe, such as conducting inmate
counts and 30-minute rounds, searching inmate cells, and ensuring adequate supervision of the Special
Housing Unit (SHU) and the functionality of MCC New York's security camera system.

We further found that multiple BOP employees submitted false documents claiming that they had
performed the required counts and rounds and that several MCC New York staff members lacked candor
when questioned by the Office of the Inspector General (OIG) about their actions. Two MCC New York
employees, Tova Noel and Michael Thomas, were charged criminally with falsifying BOP records relating to
their conducting inmate counts and rounds. The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York
subsequently entered into deferred prosecution agreements with Noel and Thomas and the court
dismissed all charges against them after Noel and Thomas successfully fulfilled the terms of their
agreements. Prosecution was declined by the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York for
other MCC New York employees assigned to the SHU on August 9-10, 2019, who the OIG found also
created, certified, and submitted false documentation regarding inmate counts and rounds on the day
before and the day of Epstein's death.

The OIG also found that the MCC New York staff failed to carry out the Psychology Department's directive
that Epstein be assigned a cellmate and that an MCC New York supervisor allowed Epstein to make an
unmonitored telephone call the evening before his death.

The OIG determined that the combination of these and other failures led to Epstein being alone and
unmonitored in his cell, with an excessive amount of bed linens, from approximately 10:40 p.m. on
August 9, until he was discovered hanged in his cell at approximately 6:30 a.m. the following day.
Additionally, the OIG found that staffing shortages, a persistent issue for the BOP, compromised the ability
of MCC New York staff to adequately supervise inmates. As detailed below, we make a number of
recommendations to the BOP to address the serious issues we identified during our investigation
and review.

While the OIG determined that MCC New York staff committed significant violations of BOP and MCC
New York policies and falsified records relating to their conducting inmate counts and rounds, the OIG did
not uncover evidence that contradicted the Federal Bureau of Investigation's (FBI) determination regarding
the absence of criminality in connection with how Epstein died. All MCC New York staff members who were
interviewed by the OIG said they did not know of any information suggesting that Epstein's cause of death
was something other than suicide. Likewise, none of the interviewed inmates provided any credible
information that Epstein's cause of death was something other than suicide.

As detailed in Chapter 4 of this report, the SHU was a housing unit within MCC New York where inmates
were securely separated from the general inmate population and kept locked in their cells for
approximately 23 hours a day, to ensure their own safety as well as the safety of staff and other inmates.
Access to the SHU was controlled by multiple locked doors. The primary entrance to the SHU (Main Exterior
Entry Door) was opened remotely by a staff member in MCC New York's centralized Control Center.
Additionally, there was a second locked door at the main entrance (Main Interior Entry Door), which could
be opened only with a key held by a limited number of Correctional Officers (CO) while on duty.0 Within the
SHU, the entrance to each tier could be accessed only via a single locked door at the top or bottom of the
staircase leading to the individual tier. Keys to open the locked tier doors were available only to a limited
number of COs while on duty. Each tier had eight cells, each of which could house either one or two
inmates. Each individual cell, which was made of cement and metal, could be accessed only through a
single locked door, to which only a limited number of COs had keys while on duty. The SHU cell doors were
made of solid metal with a small glass window and small locked slots that correctional staff used to handcuff
inmates and provide food and toiletries to inmates. As a further security measure, during each shift a
limited number of the COs had keys while on duty.

BOP policy and practice require that all SHU inmates be locked in their cells overnight. The OIG found no
evidence indicating that the door to Epstein's cell or any other cell in the SHU tier in which Epstein was
housed was unlocked on the evening of August 9-10, 2019, after SHU staff locked Epstein in his cell at
approximately 8 p.m. SHU staff told the OIG that at approximately 8 p.m. on August 9, all SHU inmates were
locked in their cells for the evening and that there was no indication that any of the other inmates could
have gotten out of their cells. Epstein did not have a cellmate after Inmate 3 was transferred out of MCC
New York on August 9, and therefore Epstein was alone in his cell the evening of August 9-10. The door to
Epstein's cell was visible from the SHU Officers' Station, and CO Tova Noel and Material Handler
Michael Thomas told the OIG that no one entered or exited Epstein's cell during their shift on August 10.
Both of them further described delivering breakfast to the L Tier at about 6:30 a.m. on August 10, and how
Noel unlocked the door to the L Tier, Thomas entered the L Tier and called for Epstein, and then Thomas
unlocked his cell door when Epstein failed to respond. Additionally, the three inmates who were housed in
the same SHU tier as Epstein on August 9 and 10, and who had a direct line of sight to the door of Epstein's
cell from their cells, stated that no one entered or exited Epstein's cell after the SHU staff returned Epstein
to his cell on the evening of August 9, which is consistent with the security measures in place within the MCC
New York SHU.

Further, the OIG analyzed the available recorded video of the SHU, which was limited to the common area of
the SHU, including the SHU Officers' Station, due to the MCC New York security camera system's video
recording issues that we detailed in Chapter 6. The OIG's analysis of the recorded video did not identify any
COs (other than those assigned to the SHU during that timeframe or had a specific reason for visiting the
SHU) or other individuals present in the common area of the SHU approach any of the SHU tiers, including
the L Tier where Epstein was housed, between approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and approximately
6:30 a.m. on August 10. In sum, the OIG's investigation did not find any evidence that anyone was present in
5 The primary entrance doors to the MCC New York SHU are shown in Figure 4.1. Access to the secondary entrance to
the SHU, which was adjacent to the elevator bay on the south side of the floor, was also controlled by an exterior entry
door opened by the Control Center and an interior door opened only with a key held by one of the COs assigned to the
SHU while on duty. The secondary entrance doors to the SHU are shown in Figure 4.2.

the L Tier during that timeframe other than the inmates who were locked in their assigned cells on that tier
of the SHU.

We also noted that the surveillance camera in the L Tier, as shown in the photograph in Figure 6.7, was in
plain view of the inmates and therefore inmates would have been aware that any hallway movements,
including into or out of Epstein's cell, were being live streamed and could be monitored, even if,
unbeknownst to them, the Digital Video Recorder (DVR) system was not recording the live stream at that
time. As the OIG has noted in numerous prior reports regarding the BOP's camera system, BOP staff and
inmates are aware of where prison cameras are located and often engage in wrongdoing in locations where
they know cameras are not located.56 Additionally, the OIG did not observe on the recorded video of the
SHU common area that Noel and Thomas, who were seated at the desk at the SHU Officers' Station
immediately outside the L tier during that time period, at any time rose from their seats or approached the
L Tier. We additionally found that Thomas's and Noel's reaction on the morning of August 10 upon finding
Epstein hanging in his cell, as described to us by Thomas, Noel, the responding Lieutenant, and inmates,
was consistent with their being unaware of any potential harm to Epstein prior to Thomas entering Epstein's
cell at about 6:30 a.m. on August 10.

We further noted that Epstein had previously been placed on suicide watch and psychological observation
due to the events of July 23, 2019; that numerous nooses made from prison bed sheets were found in his
cell on the morning of August 10; and that he had signed a new Last Will and Testament on August 8, 2 days
before he died. No weapons were recovered from Epstein's cell after his death. Additionally, the inmates
who were interviewed consistently reported that on the evening Epstein died the SHU staff did not
systematically conduct the required rounds and counts, which was one of the primary mechanisms for the
SHU staff to ensure the safety and security of inmates housed in the SHU. As a result, Epstein was
unmonitored and locked alone in his cell for hours with an excess amount of linens, which provided an
opportunity for him to commit suicide.

Finally, the Medical Examiner who performed the autopsy detailed for the OIG why Epstein's injuries were
more consistent with, and indicative of, a suicide by hanging rather than a homicide by strangulation. The
Medical Examiner also told the OIG that the ligature furrow was too broad to have been caused by the
electrical cord of the medical device in Epstein's cell and that blood toxicology tests revealed no medications
or illegal substances were in Epstein's system. The Medical Examiner also noted the absence of debris
under Epstein's fingernails, marks on his hands, contusions to his knuckles, or bruises on his body that
would have indicated Epstein had been a struggle, which would be expected if Epstein's death had been a
homicide by strangulation.

This is not the first time that the OIG has found significant job performance and management failures on
the part of SOP personnel and widespread disregard of SOP policies that are designed to ensure that
inmates are safe, secure, and in good health. For instance, the OIG's December 2022 investigation and
review of the BOP's handling of the transfer of James 'Whiter Bulger identified serious job performance and
56 U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) OIG, Notification of Needed Upgrades to the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Securiaty 
nera
System, Management Advisory Memorandum 22-001 (October 2021); U.S. DOJ OIG, Audit of the Federal Bureau of Pitons'
Management and Oversight of its Chaplaincy Services Program, 21-091 (July 2021); U.S. DOJ OIG, Review of the Federal
Bureau of Prisons' Contraband Interdiction Efforts, Evaluation and Inspections Report 16-05 (June 2016).
management failures at multiple levels within the BOP.,' Similar to the Bulger report, the numerous and
serious transgressions that occurred in this matter came to light largely because they involved a high-profile
inmate. The fact that serious deficiencies occurred in connection with high-profile inmates like Epstein and
Bulger is especially concerning given that the BOP would presumably take particular care in handling the
custody and care of such inmates.

Regrettably, the OIG has encountered similar issues on many other occasions. For example, the OIG has
investigated numerous allegations related to the falsification of official BOP documentation concerning
inmate counts and rounds, several of which have resulted in criminal prosecution. The OIG currently has
two open investigations into allegations of falsified inmate count and round documentation, each involving
an inmate death (by suicide and homicide) or escape from a BOP facility.

This investigation and review also revealed the direct impact of insufficient staffing levels on inmate safety.
Witnesses repeatedly told the OIG that counts, rounds, cell searches, and other methods of inmate
accountability were not undertaken because correctional staff were working multiple shifts —including one
staff member who worked 24-hours straight —and were tired and overwhelmed with other duties. As
discussed in greater detail in our recommendations, the OIG has repeatedly found the need for BOP to
address staffing shortages. Most recently, in March 2023, the OIG found that the coronavirus disease 2019
(COVID-19) pandemic exacerbated the effects of preexisting BOP medical and nonmedical staffing
shortages, an issue the OIG has identified as a concern for the BOP since at least 2015.58
Further, the OIG has repeatedly found that BOP personnel have not consistently been attentive to the needs
of inmates at risk for suicide. In this investigation, that inattention manifested in the failure of MCC
New York staff and supervisors to ensure that Epstein was assigned a cellmate as required by the MCC
New York Psychology Department directive issued after the July 23, 2019 incident in which Epstein was
discovered in his cell with an orange cloth around his neck. In a March 2023 report, the OIG found that BOP
psychology staff did not assess the suitability of single-cell assignments for five of the seven inmates who
died by suicide while in COVID-19 quarantine units between March 2020 and April 2021.59 The OIG's 2017
report on the BOP's use of restrictive housing for inmates with mental illness also noted that single-ceiling
may present risks to inmate mental health, and both of the recommendations from that report regarding
the use and oversight of single-ceiling remain open as of March 2023.60
Lastly, as discussed in greater detail in the conclusions and recommendations that follow, the persistent
deficiencies of the BOP's security camera systems are well documented and long-standing.
6°  U.S. DOJ OIG, Investigation and Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Handling of the Transfer of Inmate James 
'Whitey'
Bulger, 23-007 (December 2022).

" U.S. DOJ OIG, Capstone Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Response to the Coronovirus Disease 2019 Pandemic,
Evaluation and Inspections Division A-2020-011 (March 2023) (Capstone Report).
" Capstone Report.

60 U.S. DOJ OIG, Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Use of Restrictive Housing for Inmates with Mental Illness, 
Evaluation
and Inspections Report 17-OS (July 2017).

The combination of negligence, misconduct, and outright job performance failures documented in this
report all contributed to an environment in which arguably one of the most notorious inmates in BOP's
custody was provided with the opportunity to take his own life, resulting in significant questions being asked
about the circumstances of his death, how it could have been allowed to have happen, and most
importantly, depriving his numerous victims, many of whom were underage girls at the time of the alleged
crimes, of their ability to seek justice through the criminal justice process. The fact that these failures have
been recurring ones at the BOP does not excuse them and gives additional urgency to the need for
Department of Justice (DOJ) and BOP leadership to address the chronic staffing, surveillance, security, and
related problems plaguing the BOP.

The OIG has completed its investigation and is providing this report to the BOP for appropriate action.
Unless otherwise noted, the OIG applies the preponderance of the evidence standard in determining
whether DOJ personnel have committed misconduct. The U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board applies this
same standard when reviewing a federal agency's decision to take adverse action against an employee
based on such misconduct. See 5 U.S.C. § 7701(c)(1)(B) and 5 C.F.R. § 1201.56(b)(1)(ii).

A. MCC New York Staff Failed to Ensure that Epstein Had a Cellmate on August 9 as
Instructed by the Psychology Department on July 30
On July 30, 2019, the MCC New York Psychology Department sent an email to over 70 BOP staff members
stating that Epstein "needs to be housed with an appropriate cellmate." The Psychology Department's
directive that Epstein have an appropriate cellmate arose out of the events that occurred on July 23, 2019,
when Epstein was found lying on the floor of his cell with a piece of orange cloth around his neck. Epstein's
cellmate at the time (Inmate 1) told MCC New York staff that Epstein had tried to hang himself, and another
inmate housed on the same SHU tier at the time (Inmate 2) corroborated several aspects of Inmate l's
account. Epstein's accounts of what had occurred varied. Epstein initially told MCC New York staff that he
thought his cellmate had tried to kill him, but thereafter he repeatedly said he did not know what had
occurred. Epstein later asked two different MCC New York staff members if he could be housed with the
same cellmate Epstein initially accused of having tried to harm him.

As a result of this incident, Epstein was placed on suicide watch and then psychological observation.
Consistent with the Psychology Department's directive, the Captain and the SHU Lieutenant each told the
OIG that they verbally informed SHU staff of Epstein's cellmate requirement. These and other witnesses
said staff members regularly assigned to the SHU knew that Epstein needed to have a cellmate. However,
despite the Psychology Department's widely disseminated July 30 email instruction and the subsequent
verbal direction provided by the Captain and the SHU Lieutenant, Epstein was left without a cellmate on
August 9 and, less than 24 hours later, Epstein died by suicide.
1. Failure to Make Required Notifications Regarding the Need to Assign Epstein a
New Cellmate
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that on August 9, 2019, MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU
failed to notify their superiors that Epstein's cellmate, Inmate 3, had been transferred out of MCC New York
and therefore Epstein needed to be assigned a new cellmate. The failure to make these required
notifications —and the supervisors' failure to properly supervise the SHU staff, discussed further below-
resulted in Epstein being housed without a cellmate at the time of his death, which was contrary to the
Psychology Department's directive issued just 10 days earlier.

BOP standards of conduct require that employees "obey the orders of their superiors at all times."" MCC
New York Post Orders for the SHU require, among other things, that all SHU officers "maintain a log of
pertinent information regarding inmate activity, detailing time, persons involved (if pertinent) and the event,
which must be logged into TRUSCOPE."62 Importantly, the SHU Post Orders clarify that they 'are not
intended to describe in detail all the officers responsibilities. Good judgment and common sense are
expected in all situations not covered in these post orders."
On August 9, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, and CO
Tova Noel were each assigned to the MCC New York SHU as their permanent quarterly assigned post and
served as the SHU Officer in Charge during their respective shifts.63 The OIG investigation found that each
of these employees knew that Epstein was required to have a cellmate at all times per the Psychology
Department's directive.

The OIG further found that on August 9 the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge, and Noel each became aware at various times during their respective shifts that Epstein's
cellmate, Inmate 3, had been transferred from the institution with all of his belongings, a status known to all
MCC New York staff members as meaning the inmate was being permanently transferred out of the
institution. Specifically, the OIG investigation found that on the morning of August 9, the Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge and CO 1, who was also assigned to the SHU, reviewed the MCC New York daily call out list,
a document that identifies all inmates who were leaving their housing units each day, which listed Inmate 3
as being scheduled to depart MCC New York with all of his belongings. At approximately 8:30 a.m., CO 1
escorted Inmate 3 from the SHU to Receiving and Discharge to be transferred out of the institution, and the
Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge escorted Epstein from the SHU to the attorney conference room for his
daily meeting with his attorneys." During the escort, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge and CO 1
discussed the need to assign Epstein with a new cellmate due to Inmate 3's transfer. 65 The Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge told the OIG, and stated in a memorandum that he prepared following Epstein's death,
that he notified his relief, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, of the need to assign Epstein a new
cellmate, and that he likely notified an unspecified Lieutenant. However, the OIG did not credit the Day
Watch SHU Officer in Charge's account because no other witnesses or evidence confirmed that he had in
fact passed on information regarding Epstein's need for a new cellmate, either to a supervisor or his relief.
6I  BOP Program Statement 3420.11.

62 TRUSCOPE is a BOP database that provides institution staff with detailed inmate and institution security-related
information and provides unit officers an electronic event log.

63 Noel served as the SHU Officer in Charge after the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge's shift ended at 10 p.m. on
August 9, 2019.

64 Receiving and Discharge is the area of MCC New York that is responsible for processing inmates who enter or leave
the facility.

65 The OIG did not find that CO 1 failed to make appropriate notifications because his immediate superior in his chain-
of-command, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, was aware of the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate.
The OIG investigation also found that during the next shift in the MCC New York SHU, both the Evening
Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Noel became aware that Epstein was without a cellmate. The Evening
Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that when he escorted Epstein back to his cell after Epstein's
telephone call, he saw that Inmate 3 was not there and then he, Noel, and the Material Handler discussed
the need for Epstein to have a new cellmate. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge also told the OIG
that he notified an unspecified supervisor. However, other witnesses did not corroborate his account. Noel
told the OIG that she was unaware both that Epstein needed to have a cellmate and that Inmate 3 had been
removed from the institution. Noel also told the OIG that she went to Epstein's cell at approximately
10 p.m.—a time of day when all inmates were secured in their cells—and may have plugged in Epstein's
medical device for him. The OIG did not credit Noel's statements that she did not know that Epstein needed
a cellmate or that Inmate 3 had been removed from the SHU based on contradictory witness statements
(including her own) regarding SHU staffs knowledge of Epstein's cellmate requirement and Inmate 3's
transfer out of the SHU.66
The OIG investigation concluded that on August 9, 2019, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Evening
Watch SHU Officer in Charge, and Noel failed to notify a supervisor as required after Epstein's cellmate was
permanently removed from the MCC New York SHU, which constituted a violation of BOP standards of
conduct. Additionally, their inaction violated MCC New York SHU Post Orders because none of these
individuals documented the fact the Epstein needed a new cellmate as required. Finally, all of these officers
failed to exercise good judgment and common sense, as required by the SHU Post Orders, by not
immediately undertaking steps through their chain-of-command to ensure that a high-profile inmate who
had been released from suicide watch and psychological observation 10 days earlier had an
appropriate cellmate.
2. Failure to Adequately Supervise SHU Staff
The OIG also found that MCC New York supervisory personnel failed to effectively perform their duties,
which contributed to the fact that Epstein was housed without a cellmate at the time of his death. Rather
than passively relying on a notification from subordinates, supervisory personnel also had an obligation
under federal regulations to "put forth honest effort in the performance of their duties," which included
supervision of SHU personnel. 67 The OIG's investigation revealed that the Captain and the Day Watch
Operations Lieutenant, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, and
the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant, among other MCC New York staff, received an email from the
U.S. Marshals Service (USMS) on August 8, 2019, notifying them that Inmate 3 was scheduled to be
transferred to another facility the following day. If any of these supervisors had read the email attachment,
they would have known of the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate. Instead, many of these individuals
told the OIG that they believed that Inmate 3 had gone to court on August 9 and they were unaware that he
would not return and Epstein needed a new cellmate. The SHU Lieutenant's shift on August 8 ended over
an hour before the USMS sent the email notification and he was not working on August 9. In his absence,
the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, the Evening Watch Operations
Lieutenant, and the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant had oversight of the SHU during their respective
46 Noel reviewed a draft of the report and we considered her comments but made no changes as a result.
67 5 C.F.R. § 2635.101(b)(5): see also S C.F.R. § 2635.705(a).

shifts, and the Captain had oversight over all of the Lieutenants." The OIG found that the failure of these
individuals to adequately supervise SHU staff and ensure that a high-profile inmate who had recently been
on suicide watch and psychological observation had an appropriate cellmate constituted a job performance
failure.

3. Failure to Have a Contingency Plan for Assigning Epstein a Cellmate
Additionally, the OIG found that the Warden's failure to have a back-up cellmate assignment for Epstein
constituted poor judgment. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that although he knew
that Epstein needed to be assigned another cellmate, SHU staff could not just put anyone in the cell with
Epstein. The Warden confirmed this in his OIG interview, when he explained that he and BOP executive
leadership selected Inmate 3 as Epstein's cellmate following the events of July 23, 2019. The Warden told
the OIG that no inmates were pre-vetted to serve as Epstein's cellmate if Inmate 3 left MCC New York." The
Northeast Regional Director, the Warden, and the Captain all told the OIG that if Inmate 3 had been
removed as Epstein's cellmate, they would have had to review a new list of potential cellmate candidates to
ensure that Epstein was housed with an appropriate inmate. This selection process, which involved multiple
steps undertaken by high-level BOP management, would be difficult to accomplish in a short period of time
and ultimately may have impeded SHU officers' ability to house Epstein with a cellmate on August 9, 2019.
4. Lack of Candor
BOP policy requires that "[c]uring the course of an official investigation, employees are to cooperate fully by
providing all pertinent information they may have. Full cooperation requires truthfully responding
to questions."
As discussed above, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge and the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told
the OIG that they notified supervisory personnel regarding the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate.
Based on a lack of corroborating evidence for these assertions, the OIG found that they lacked candor in
their OIG interviews in violation of BOP policy. Similarly, the OIG found that Noel lacked candor in violation
of BOP policy when she said she did not know that Epstein needed a cellmate or that his then-cellmate
Inmate 3 had been transferred out of the SHU.

The OIG also found that the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant lacked candor in her interview with the
OIG in violation of BOP policy when she said she was not aware that Epstein was required to be housed with
a cellmate. Her statement is contradicted by the fact that she was one of the MCC New York staff members
who responded to the July 23, 2019 incident involving Epstein, which resulted in him being placed on suicide
watch and psychological observation; she was a recipient of the Psychology Department's July 30, 2019
(>3 The Senior Officer Specialist who served as the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant from 4 p.m. to 10 p.m. on
August 9, 2019, told the OIG that she was not aware of Epstein's cellmate requirement. The OIG credited her account
because she did not ordinarily work in or supervise the SHU and did not receive the Psychology Department's July 30,
2019 email regarding the need for Epstein to have an appropriate cellmate or the USMS August 8, 2019 email notifying
that Inmate 3 would be transferred to another facility the following day.

49 Upon reviewing a draft of this report, the Warden told the OIG that there were no suitable backup cellmates
for Epstein.
J°  BOP Program Statement 3420.11.

email identifying the cellmate requirement; and the statements of multiple witnesses who told the OIG that
Epstein's cellmate requirement was widely disseminated verbally by MCC New York leadership.

B. MCC New York Staff Failed to Conduct Mandatory Rounds and Inmate Counts
Resulting in Epstein Being Unobserved for Hours Before His Death
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that on August 9 and 10, 2019, MCC New York SHU staff did not
conduct the mandatory rounds and inmate counts during their shift in the SHU. The failure to undertake
these required measures to account for inmate whereabouts and wellbeing—and the supervisors' failure to
properly supervise the SHU staff, as discussed further below—resulted in Epstein being unobserved for
hours before his death, which compounded the failure of MCC New York staff to ensure that Epstein had an
appropriate cellmate.
1. Failure to Conduct Rounds and Inmate Counts in the SHU
Federal regulations require that employees "use official time in an honest effort to perform official duties."'
Additionally, BOP standards of conduct required that employees "[c]onduct themselves in a manner that
fosters respect for the Bureau of Prisons, the Department of Justice, and the U.S. Government: 1n Because
"[i]nattention to duty in a correctional environment can result in escapes, assaults, and other incidents,"
BOP standards of conduct also require employees "to remain fully alert and attentive during duty hours."
BOP policy also requires "[c]ontinuous inmate accountability," which is accomplished through rounds and
inmate counts!' Among other things, rounds and inmate counts enable staff to observe inmates and
ensure that they are safe and secure in their cells and are in good health.

BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders set out the requirements for these inmate accountability
measures, specifying that correctional staff must conduct rounds on an irregular schedule at least twice
each hour, no more than 40 minutes apart. BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders further specify
that at least two MCC New York SHU staff members must conduct inmate counts at 12 a.m., 3 a.m., 5 a.m.,
4 p.m., and 10 p.m. daily, and also at 10 a.m. on weekends and federal holidays.

The OIG's investigation and review revealed that an inmate (Inmate 4) was internally transferred from the
SHU to Receiving and Discharge at approximately 3:15 p.m. on August 9, 2019; however, this inmate transfer
was not documented until approximately 12:35 a.m. on August 10, 2019. Based on this internal transfer,
BOP records, and witness statements, the OIG determined that the 4 p.m. and 10 p.m. SHU inmate counts
on August 9 were erroneous. In addition, the OIG reviewed the available SHU security camera video, which
did not show COs walking up or down the stairs leading to the various SHU tiers during the count times, a
process that is necessary to conduct an accurate count of inmates.J4 During their OIG interviews, the
Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, CO Tova Noel, and Material Handler Michael
Thomas each admitted that they did not conduct all of the mandatory rounds and inmate counts in the SHU
J1 S C.F.R. § 2635.705(a); see also S C.F.R. § 2635.101(b)(5).
77 BOP Program Statement 3420.11.
73 BOP Program Statement 5500.14.

J4 As discussed in Chapter 5, the OIG found that the security camera video was of low quality. Therefore, the OIG
analyzed the video in conjunction with BOP records and witness statements regarding the personnel in the SHU and
their activities.

on the evening of August 9 and the morning of August 10. Noel told the OIG that she conducted the 10 p.m.
count on August 9. The OIG did not credit her statement based on: (1) its review of the SHU security
camera video, which reflects Noel walking up and down the stairs leading to some, but not all, of the tiers
several minutes after the SHU inmate count had been called into the Control Center; (2) the 10 p.m. count
slip, which erroneously included the SHU Inmate 4, who had been internally transferred to Receiving and
Delivery; (3) other BOP records; and (4) the Material Handler's statement to the OIG that no one conducted
the 10 p.m. count because everyone was tired.

Instead of performing the required duties to account for inmate whereabouts and wellbeing, the OIG found
that officers assigned to the SHU on August 9 and 10, including the Material Handler, Noel, and Thomas
primarily remained seated in the SHU Officers' Station—sometimes without moving for a period of time,
suggesting that they were asleep—and conducted a variety of Internet searches on MCC New York
computers. Thomas also admitted to the OIG that he "dozed off' for periods of time during his shift. The
OIG's analysis of the SHU security camera video revealed that after approximately 10:40 p.m., no CO
entered Epstein's tier in the SHU until just before 6:30 a.m. when Noel and Thomas began to serve breakfast
to the inmates.

The OIG investigation and review concluded that the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material
Handler, Noel, and Thomas failed to conduct the mandatory rounds and inmate counts during their
respective shifts in the MCC New York SHU on August 9 and 10, 2019, and that their actions constituted
violations of S C.F.R. §§ 2635.101(b)(5) and 2635.705(a), BOP Program Statements 3420.11 and 5500.14, and
MCC New York SHU Post Orders.
2 False Statements and Lack of Candor
The OIG's investigation and review found that on August 9 and 10, 2019, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in
Charge, the Material Handler, Noel, and Thomas made false statements when they falsified BOP records by
attesting that they had completed the mandatory rounds and inmate counts when, in fact, they had not.
Federal law provides that "whoever, in any matter within the jurisdiction of the executive...branch of the
Government of the United States, knowingly and willfully...makes or uses any false writing or document
knowing the same to contain any materially false, fictitious, or fraudulent statement or entry" has violated
18 U.S.C. § 1001(a)(3).

As discussed above, the OIG found that the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler,
Noel, and Thomas failed to conduct all of the mandatory rounds and inmate counts. As part of each
institutional inmate count, BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders require two COs to conduct each
count and memorialize the number of inmates in the SHU on an official MCC New York form, often called a
count slip) , On the count slip, both COs are required to fill in the date and time the count had been
performed, write the total number of inmates physically present in the unit counted, and then sign the
count slip. Once the COs complete and sign the count slips, the count slips are then collected and delivered
to the MCC New York Control Center. Officers assigned to the Control Center are responsible for comparing
the count slips from each housing unit to the institution's overall inmate count sheet to ensure that each
75 This BOP form is officially entitled "Metropolitan Correctional Center; New York, New York; Official Count Slip."
inmate was accounted for.76 Only after all the count slips have been collected from each housing unit, and
the numbers on the count slips had been matched to the institution's overall inmate count sheet, could the
institutional count be deemed "cleared" or completed.

The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, Noel, and Thomas each prepared and/or
signed a false count slip to create the impression that they had fulfilled their inmate accountability
responsibilities when, in fact, they had not.J7 These individuals admitted to the OIG that instead of
performing their assigned duties, they pre-filled the count slips with the number of inmates they believed
were in the SHU based on what officers from the previous shift had told them and signed off on the
documents knowing that they falsely attested to having completed the counts. Additionally, Noel admitted
to the OIG that she had prefilled the official MCC New York forms documenting the times of the 30-minute
rounds, often referred to as round sheets, and falsely attested to having completed the rounds!'
Noel and Thomas were indicted by a grand jury for their false certifications of having conducted counts and
rounds. Subsequently, each entered into a deferred prosecution agreement with the U.S. Attorney's Office
for the Southern District of New York. The U.S. Attorney's Office of the Southern District of New York
declined prosecution for the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and the Material Handler.
The OIG investigation has found that the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, Noel,
and Thomas knowingly and willingly falsified BOP records in violation of federal law by attesting that they
had completed the mandatory rounds and inmate counts on the evening of August 9, 2019, and morning of
August 10, 2019.

Additionally, as noted above, BOP policy requires employees to cooperate fully with an official investigation
and truthfully respond to questions. The OIG found that Noel lacked candor when she told the OIG that she
had conducted the 10 p.m. count when the weight of evidence indicates that, at most, she may have
conducted a round at the time.
3. Poor Judgment Regarding the Use of Overtime
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that on August 9, 2019, MCC New York supervisory staff
requested that a staff member fill an overtime position within the SHU, which resulted in that staff member
working three shifts back-to-back, that is, 24 hours straight.

The collective bargaining agreement between the BOP and unions representing BOP employees provides
that "[o]rdinarily, the minimum time off between shifts will be seven and one-half (73/2) hours, and the
76 The official name for the document used to record an institutional count is "Bureau of Prisons Count Sheet."
77 The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Noel signed the 4 p.m. count slip; Noel and the Material Handler signed
the 10 p.m. count slip; and Noel and Thomas signed the 12 a.m., 3 a.m., and S a.m. count slips.
78 This BOP form is officially entitled "MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute Check Sheet."
minimum elapsed time of on 'days off will be fifty-six (56) hours, except when the employee requests
the change."
The Material Handler told the OIG that on August 9 he reported for a voluntary overtime shift from 12 a.m.
to 8 a.m. and then worked his regular 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. shift in the warehouse. At some point during the day
shift, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, a higher ranking official, called and asked the Material Handler
if he could work overtime in the SHU and he agreed. The Material Handler told the OIG that he felt
pressured to work the third shift, which resulted in him working 24 hours straight, from 12 a.m. on August 9
through 12 a.m. on August 10. As discussed previously, the Material Handler admitted to the OIG that on
the evening of August 9, during his third shift which he worked in the SHU, he did not conduct the
mandatory inmate counts and rounds because he was too tired.

The OIG investigation and review concluded that the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant exercised poor
judgment when he requested that the Material Handler work a third consecutive shift. As the Day Watch
Operations Lieutenant, he had access to the staff roster and schedule and therefore he should have known
that the Material Handler had already worked 16 straight hours. Additionally, the Day Watch Operations
Lieutenant's action was inconsistent with the collective bargaining agreement and did not reflect sound
correctional judgment, as it would have been extremely difficult for the Material Handler to have effectively
performed his duties during his third shift.
4. Clearing the 10 p.m. Institutional Count Knowing that It Was Inaccurate
The OIG's investigation and review determined that on August 9, 2019, MCC New York staff cleared the
10 p.m. institutional count knowing that the inmate counts from two housing units were inaccurate.
BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that COs conducting an institutional count relay the
count verbally to the Control Center, which maintains the master count of all inmates.8° If a count reported
verbally does not match the master count, the Control Center must notify the Operations Lieutenant and
the staff members must recount the inmates. MCC New York SHU Post Orders further provide that "[c]ount
slips which appear to be altered will not be accepted."
As discussed previously, the OIG determined that an internal transfer of an inmate (Inmate 4) from the SHU
to Receiving and Discharge on August 9 was not documented appropriately at the time of the transfer. The
failure to document the transfer, along with the SHU staff not conducting the required inmate counts,
resulted in the MCC New York Control Center receiving a count slip from the SHU with an incorrect number
of inmates identified as being present within the SHU at the 10 p.m. institutional count.
During his OIG interview, Senior Officer Specialist 6, who was assigned to the Control Center, admitted that
he amended the 10 p.m. count slips he received from the SHU and Receiving and Discharge in an attempt to
reflect the correct number of inmates in the SHU following the internal inmate transfer that resulted in a
SHU inmate (Inmate 4) being moved to Receiving and Discharge earlier in the day. Senior Officer Specialist 6
acknowledged that he should have requested a recount from the SHU, but instead he cleared the 10 p.m.
" BOP and Council of Prison Locals, Master Agreement, July 21, 2014-July 20, 2021 (extended until 2026).
so BOP Program Statement 5270.11.

count. Senior Officer Specialist 6 explained that the action he took was known as "ghost counting,"
something he said he would not have done without authorization from the Operations Lieutenant or
someone of a higher rank than himself. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant denied having
authorized a "ghost count" and we found no evidence to corroborate Senior Officer Specialist 6's claim that
the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant knew of and approved the false count.

The OIG found that Senior Officer Specialist 6 modified the count slips received from the SHU and Receiving
and Discharge, failed to request a recount of the SHU inmates, and cleared the 10 p.m. institutional count
knowing that it was inaccurate in violation of BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders.
5. Failure to Adequately Supervise SHU Staff and Conduct Lieutenant Rounds
The OIG also found that MCC New York supervisory personnel failed to effectively perform their duties,
which contributed to the fact that Epstein was unobserved for many hours before his death. As discussed
above, federal regulations require that MCC New York supervisory personnel "put forth honest effort in the
performance of their duties," which includes appropriate supervision of SHU personnel. 81 Additionally, BOP
policy requires that a Lieutenant visit the SHU during each shift to ensure that all procedures are
being followed. 82
The OIG's investigation revealed that the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant had oversight of the SHU during their respective shifts.83 The Evening Watch
Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that on August 9, 2019, he did not supervise the 4 p.m. count or conduct
any rounds in the SHU. He acknowledged that he signed some of the pages of the 4 p.m. count, but he did
not sign all of the pages as he should have. Beginning at 10 p.m. on August 9, the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant was the sole supervisor overseeing the SHU. The Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant told the OIG that she noticed an error in the 12 a.m. count on August 10, which was due to SHU
staff including Inmate 4, who had been internally transferred to Receiving and Discharge, among the
inmates in the SHU. According to the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant, the SHU staff should have
conducted another count and submitted a new count slip, but she did not know if they actually did so.
During her shift, the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant conducted one round in the SHU at
approximately 4 a.m. on August 10. The OIG's review of the available SHU security camera video revealed
that the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant was present in the SHU for approximately 7 minutes, during
which time she conferred with Noel and Thomas, who were seated at and around the SHU Officers' Station
in the common area of the SHU. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that she was not
required to visit each tier or go to each individual cell during a lieutenant round, but rather the purpose of
the Lieutenant round was for her to speak with the officers on duty. This description of a Lieutenant round
$1 5 C.F.R. § 2635.101(b)(5): see also S C.F.R. § 2635.705(a).
82 BOP Program Statement 5270.11.

83 The Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant also had oversight over the SHU during her overtime shift (4 p.m. to
10 p.m. on August 9, 2019) in an acting capacity. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Acting Evening
Watch Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant did not supervise any
institutional counts, which was due to the start and end time of her overtime shift. The Acting Evening Watch Activities
Lieutenant also told the OIG that she conducted one round in the SHU sometime between 5 p.m. to 8 p.m., during which
time she walked down all of the tiers.

is inconsistent with the statements of many other supervisors and BOP Lieutenant training, all of which
emphasized the need for Lieutenants to walk down all of the SHU tiers during a round. During their
interviews with the OIG, the Northeast Regional Director, the Warden, Associate Warden 1, and the Captain
clarified that they expected a Lieutenant conducting a round in the SHU to check in with the officers, walk
down each of the tiers in the SHU, speak with inmates, and address inmate concerns. They explained that
the Lieutenants did not act responsibly if they did not walk down each of the tiers to check on the inmates in
the SHU. As the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant explained, unlike inmates in general population,
SHU inmates cannot approach a supervisor because they are confined within a cell. Further, the BOP
Lieutenant training, which the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant attended in 2011, taught that
Operations Lieutenants were required to visit the SHU at least once during each shift and that "[t]his visit
will be substantially more than just entering the unit, signing the log book, and talking with staff." Instead,
Operations Lieutenants were trained to, among other things, walk through each range (or tier), inspect logs
and reports, observe activities, and periodically observe counts within the SHU.

The OIG found that the failure of the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant to adequately supervise SHU staff, and of the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant
to adequately conduct a Lieutenant round in the SHU, which contributed to the SHU staff's failure to
conduct mandatory rounds and counts, constituted a job performance failure.
C. MCC New York Staff Allowed Epstein to Place an Unmonitored Telephone Call on
August 9
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that on the night before his death, Epstein placed an
unrecorded, unmonitored telephone call using a non-Inmate Telephone System line from 6:58 p.m. to
7:19 p.m. Other than an MCC New York call log, no other BOP records exist regarding this unmonitored call,
including the identity of the person Epstein called or a summary of the conversation.
Federal regulations require that the Warden of each BOP institution establish procedures to monitor inmate
telephone conversations, which is "done to preserve the security and orderly management of the institution
and to protect the public." e' For safety and security reasons, BOP policy requires that all inmate telephone
calls be made through the Inmate Telephone System.85 BOP policy recognizes that "on rare occasion, in
times of crisis," inmates may be permitted to make a telephone call outside of the Inmate Telephone
System. In such circumstances, the telephone "must be placed in a secure area (e.g., a locked office), and
"must be set to record telephone calls." Additionally, the staff member coordinating the call must notify the
BOP's Special Investigative Services via email, providing the inmate's name and register number, the date
and time of the call, the number and name of the individual called, and the reason for the call. The Special
Investigative Services must enter this information into the telephone recording system within 7 days.
The OIG's investigation determined that on August 9, 2019, Epstein asked to call his mother. The Unit
Manager told the OIG that after Epstein's attorney visit had concluded, he agreed to allow Epstein to place a
telephone call on an unrecorded legal line. The Unit Manager explained that it was his understanding that
Epstein did not have the ability to place a telephone call through the Inmate Telephone System. The OIG's
84 28 U.S.C. 4 540.102.
85 BOP Program Statement P5264.08.

investigation established both that Epstein's mother was deceased at the time he asked to telephone her
and that Epstein had been assigned the necessary documentation that would have allowed him to place
calls through the Inmate Telephone System, although he did not take the necessary steps to complete the
setup process that would have given him the ability to place calls through that system. The Captain told the
OIG that when the Unit Manager was escorting Epstein from his attorney visit back to the SHU and Epstein's
requested call was discussed, he told the Unit Manager that Epstein's telephone call had to be monitored
and logged.

The Unit Manager told the OIG that he escorted Epstein from his attorney visit to the shower area of the
SHU, where he connected a telephone into an unrecorded legal line and dialed the phone number provided
by Epstein. The Unit Manager said that when a male answered the call, he handed the telephone to Epstein,
and then left MCC New York for the day because his shift had ended. Before leaving the SHU, the Unit
Manager said he told the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, and Noel, who were at
the SHU Officers' Station, to make sure Epstein got his 15 minutes on the telephone, but he did not instruct
them to monitor the telephone call. The Unit Manager admitted that he did not verify the recipient of the
telephone call, and that neither he nor anyone monitored or logged the telephone call as required.
The OIG found that the Unit Manager violated BOP policy by allowing Epstein to make an unrecorded and
unmonitored telephone call, and by failing to verify the telephone call recipient, monitor, and log the call.
We further found that the Unit Manager exercised poor judgment when he left MCC New York while Epstein
was still on the telephone call that the Unit Manager had arranged and failed to instruct the Evening Watch
SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, or Noel to monitor the call.
D. MCC New York Staff Failed to Conduct and Document Cell Searches and Eliminate
Safety Hazards in Epstein's Cell on August 9 Leaving Epstein with Excessive Linens
in His Cell
The OIG's investigation and review determined that MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU on August 9,
2019, failed to conduct and document searches of Epstein's cell in the SHU. BOP policy requires that BOP
staff routinely and irregularly search housing units.&6 MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that SHU staff
conduct at least five cell searches each shift during daytime and evening hours (7:45 a.m. to 12 a.m.), in
addition to other searches of SHU cells and common areas, and BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post
Orders require written documentation of cell searches. BOP policy explains that the purpose of cell
searches is to, among other things, maintain sanitary conditions and eliminate safety hazards. To that end,
MCC New York General Housing Unit Post Orders provide that when an inmate is transferred out of a
facility, all of the inmate's linens should be taken to Receiving and Discharge.

The OIG reviewed MCC New York SHU TRUSCOPE entries for August 9, and identified only one cell search
entered by MCC New York SHU staff for the entire day. During his interview with the OIG, the Day Watch
SHU Officer in Charge stated that multiple cell searches were conducted in the MCC New York SHU on
August 9; however, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge stated that he failed to document the cell searches
within the TRUSCOPE system as required because he was too busy with other duties. The Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge further stated that any of the SHU staff could have logged the cell searches into
86 BOP Program Statement 5521.06.

TRUSCOPE, but that it was primarily the SHU Officer in Charge's responsibility to do so. The Evening Watch
SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he and other staff members did not conduct any cell searches
during his shift in the SHU on August 9. Additionally, the OIG determined that there was an excessive
amount of bed linen within Epstein's cell. The Captain reviewed photographs of Epstein's cell and told the
OIG that the excessive linens were a security issue because they could give inmates materials to fashion an
improvised noose or use as escape paraphernalia.

The OIG found that on August 9, 2019, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge either failed to conduct the
required cell searches or failed to document the cell searches that he conducted in the SHU, and that the
Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge failed to ensure that MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU
conducted cell searches and himself failed to log cell searches in violation of BOP policy and MCC New York
SHU Post Orders. Additionally, the OIG found that it was a performance failure for the Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, and Noel, who served as the SHU Officer in
Charge during their respective shifts on August 9 and 10, 2019, to have permitted Epstein to have an
excessive amount of linens in his cell.
E. MCC New York Staff Failed to Ensure that the Institution's Security Camera
System was Fully Functional Resulting in Limited Recorded Video Evidence
This investigation and review revealed longstanding deficiencies with MCC New York's security camera
system. These deficiencies resulted in nearly all of the cameras in and around the SHU where Epstein was
being housed to not record video starting in late July 2019 and continuing through the date of Epstein's
death on August 10, 2019. According to forensic analysis conducted by the FBI after Epstein's death, on
July 29, 2019, a disk failure in MCC New York's DVR 2 system caused approximately half of the institution's
cameras—including nearly all of the cameras in and around the SHU—to display only a live video feed with
no video recording. MCC New York personnel did not learn of this system failure until 11 days later on
August 8, 2019. MCC New York personnel determined that the DVR 2 system needed to be rebuilt to restore
recording functionality. Despite the lack of recording functionality, this repair was not completed until after
Epstein's death.

The Warden told the OIG that he was generally aware that there were problems with the camera system.
The Warden sought and received approval from BOP to replace the entire camera system and in
September 2018, BOP entered into contracts totaling over $730,000 to purchase new equipment for the
camera replacement project. Although MCC New York management procured new DVR components
approximately 9 months prior to Epstein's death, the new system was not installed in a timely manner. The
new cameras required new conduit and wiring to be installed before the camera installation. Management
faced staffing shortages, temporary rotating facility managers, and other competing priorities that did not
allow for completion of the installation of the wiring or the new camera system. The OIG determined that as
of August 2021—nearly 3 years after MCC New York contracted for replacement camera equipment —the
system upgrade still had not been completed. 8,
$1 The BOP temporarily closed MCC New York in October 2021 due to substandard conditions that are unrelated to this
investigation and review.

MCC New York's failure to ensure that its security camera system was fully functional and make timely
repairs is consistent with the OIG's previous observations regarding weaknesses in the BOP's overall system
of security cameras. Dating back to at least 2013, the OIG has repeatedly observed inadequacies in the
BOP's overall system of security cameras, including inoperable cameras, an insufficient number of cameras,
poor video quality, and inadequate video storage. In a 2016 report on the BOP's contraband interdiction
efforts, the OIG identified specific deficiencies with the camera system, and recommended that the BOP
evaluate the system to determine needed upgrades.88 In response to the 2016 recommendation, the BOP
assessed the camera systems at each institution over the next several years and determined that 45 of its
122 institutions, including MCC New York, required camera system upgrades. The BOP worked to upgrade
the systems at those 45 institutions between 2019 and 2021. In June 2021, the BOP reported that it had
updated all cameras at the 45 institutions with the latest software and equipment, and that it had installed
additional cameras to bolster surveillance. However, as reported in an October 2021 Management Advisory
Memorandum issued to the BOP, the OIG analyzed the reported upgrades at the 45 institutions and found
that the BOP had addressed some but not all of the deficiencies described in the 2016 OIG report. In its
2021 Management Advisory Memorandum, the OIG recommended that the BOP develop a comprehensive
strategic plan for transitioning to a fully digital security camera system. The BOP has provided the OIG with
a strategic plan that includes estimated cost projections and timelines for addressing the camera system
concerns and completing the system upgrades.89 As of 2023, the OIG's 2021 recommendation
remains open.

The BOP's failure to address the issue of functional security camera systems across the agency and at
individual institutions presents an ongoing risk to the safety of BOP staff and inmates and has the potential
to impair the investigation of and accountability for staff and inmate misconduct. It is imperative that the
BOP prioritize the expeditious expansion and modernization of its security camera system to mitigate
security risks.

II. Recommendations
The OIG investigation identified multiple shortcomings in BOP policies that should be further assessed to
ensure the BOP can more effectively handle issues that arise in connection with the custody and care of
inmates. The recommendations address issues related to and the custody and care of inmates at risk for
suicide; measures designed to increase safety, such as staff rounds, inmate counts, and cell searches; and
institutional security camera systems and staffing shortages, two longstanding issues for the BOP.
1. The BOP should implement a process for assigning a cellmate following suicide watch
or psychological observation, with criteria for exceptions based on the particular
individual or security considerations.

According to the MCC New York Institution Supplement policy to the Suicide Prevention Program Policy
Statement 5324.08, inmates discharged from suicide watch will be assigned a cellmate. The supplemental
88 U.S. DOJ OIG, Review of the Federal Bureau of Prison? Contraband Interdiction Efforts, Evaluation and Inspections 
Report
16-05 dune 2016).

89 U.S. DOJ OIG, Notification of Needed Upgrades to the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Security Camera System, Management
Advisory Memorandum 22-001 (October 2021).

policy does not, however, describe how long the cellmate requirement should last or if any staff must
approve the removal of the cellmate requirement. The Suicide Prevention Program Policy Statement
5324.08 does not describe any process or procedure that requires cellmate assignments for inmates coming
off of suicide watch. The Warden stated there was no BOP policy mandating that an inmate coming off of
suicide watch have a cellmate, but that doing so was "sound correctional judgment."
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that there were knowledge gaps among MCC New York staff
regarding Epstein's cellmate requirement, indicating that improved communication with institutional staff
would be beneficial. The OIG therefore recommends that the BOP implement a requirement that all
inmates coming off of suicide watch or psychological observation to be assigned cellmates with criteria for
exceptions based on the particular individual or security considerations, provide guidance for determining
when a cellmate is no longer required, and implement a process for approving, documenting, and
communicating to institutional staff the assignment and removal of cellmates for these inmates.

2. The BOP should establish procedures to ensure inmates at high risk for suicide and for
whom a cellmate is recommended will continue to have a cellmate until the
recommendation is changed or rescinded, including establishing a contingency plan
for cellmate re-assignment, with criteria for exceptions based on the particular
individual or security considerations.

The OIG's investigation and review found that there was no contingency plan in place to assign Epstein a
new cellmate when his then-cellmate was transferred out of MCC New York. Although the failure to assign a
new cellmate was due, in part, to SHU staff failing to make required notifications and supervisory staff
failing to adequate supervise SHU staff, the gap in cellmate assignment was also due to the lack of a
contingency plan. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that although he knew that Epstein
needed a new cellmate, he said that SHU staff did not have the authority to assign a new cellmate, which
was consistent with what MCC New York supervisory personnel told the OIG. A contingency plan, such as a
list of alternate cellmates, would have increased the likelihood that Epstein would not have been housed
alone at the time of his death. The OIG therefore recommends that the BOP develop contingency plans for
cellmate assignment for high-risk inmates with criteria for exceptions based on the particular individual or
security considerations.
3. The BOP should evaluate its current process for obtaining and documenting approval
for social or legal visits while an inmate is on suicide watch or
psychological observation, which allows for institution -specific variations in the
process, and provide guidance on standard components that each institution should
include in its process to mitigate security issues that can arise when an inmate is on
suicide watch or psychological observation.

According to the BOP's Suicide Prevention Program Policy Statement 5324.08 and the MCC New York
Institution Supplement to the suicide prevention policy, inmates on suicide watch must be under constant
observation by staff or trained inmate observers. The MCC New York Institution Supplement policy states
that only with rare exceptions that are approved by the Captain as well by the Associate Warden of
Programs will visitation either social or legal be permitted for inmates on suicide watch. Additionally, the
MCC New York Procedural Memorandum for Psychological Observation states that inmates on psychological
observation will be continuously monitored by either an inmate companion or a staff member.
A review of the Suicide Watch Chronological Logs for July 23, 2019, revealed Epstein was allowed to leave the
suicide watch room to visit with his attorneys for more than 6 hours. According to the Psychological
Reconstruction conducted by the Assistant Director of the Reentry Services Division, during Epstein's
psychological observation on July 24 through July 30, 2019, Epstein was also allowed to visit with his
attorneys between 8-11 hours each day without direct observation. Although the MCC New York
supplemental policy described an approval process for social and legal visits while an inmate is on suicide
watch or psychological observation, the OIG found no evidence that Epstein's legal visits were approved by
the Captain or an Associate Warden. Additionally, the BOP Suicide Prevention Program Policy Statement
5324.08 does not describe any process or procedures that allows an inmate to have legal or social visits
while on suicide watch or psychological observation. The OIG therefore recommends that the BOP evaluate
its current process for such visits to be approved and documented.

4. The BOP should evaluate its methods of accounting for inmate whereabouts and
wellbeing and make changes as may be appropriate to improve those methods
through policy, training, or other measures.

The OIG's investigation and review revealed many inmate accountability deficiencies. Most fundamentally,
MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU on August 9 and 10, 2019, did not conduct many of the required
rounds and inmate counts. Additionally, there was lacking or delayed documentation regarding inmates,
including cell assignments and internal inmate transfers. Internal reports, such as the daily call out list and
the Lieutenant log, are either not retained or subject to continuous modification, which reduces their utility
as accountability tools. Therefore, the OIG recommends that the BOP evaluate its methods of accounting
for inmate whereabouts and wellbeing and make changes as appropriate to improve those methods
through policy, training, or other measures.

5. BOP policy should clarify what is required of a Lieutenant when conducting a round.
The OIG's investigation and review revealed significant gaps in the supervision of MCC New York staff
assigned to the SHU. Although BOP policy requires MCC New York Lieutenants to conduct at least one
round in the SHU during each shift, what was required of a Lieutenant during the round is not specified.
During their interviews with the OIG, experienced MCC New York supervisory personnel described what
should be done during a round, which is also reflected in BOP Lieutenant training, but this expectation was
not memorialized in any BOP or MCC New York policy or Post Order. The OIG recommends that the BOP
develop a policy, either at an agency-wide or institution -specific level, to define what is expected of
supervisory personnel during a round in the SHU to better ensure that BOP staff are
appropriately supervised.

6. The BOP should continue to develop and implement plans to address staffing
shortages at its prisons.

Since at least 2015, the OIG has repeatedly found the need for BOP to address staffing shortages, including
medical staffing shortages.90 This investigation and review revealed the direct impact of staffing deficiencies
on inmate safety. For example, the Material Handler worked three consecutive shifts-24 hours straight —
on August 9, 2019, which was certainly a contributory cause to the lack of adequate means of accounting for
inmate location and wellbeing in the SHU. The Material Handler told the OIG that no one did the 10 p.m.
SHU inmate count because they were tired. Additionally, the OIG's investigation and review found that in
connection with MCC New York's upgrade of its security camera system, the BOP's Northeast Regional Office
arranged for technicians from other BOP institutions to perform temporary duty (TDY) assignments to MCC
New York to perform necessary mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and wiring work. Yet, during the course of
the TDY rotations, work was not consistently conducted on the camera upgrade because sometimes TDY
staff were used to cover shortages at MCC New York's custody posts. Without adequate staffing, the BOP
cannot fulfill its mandate to ensure safe and secure correctional facilities. The OIG therefore recommends
that the BOP continue to develop and implement plans to address staffing shortages at its institutions.
7. The BOP should evaluate its cell search procedures and make changes as may be
appropriate to improve those procedures through policy, training, or other measures.

The OIG's investigation and review found that there was an excessive amount of linens in Epstein's cell at
the time of his death. BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that SHU cells be searched,
but they do not specifically address the issue of excessive bed linens, which the Captain told the OIG
present a safety hazard because an inmate can use them to harm themselves or escape from the
institution. Therefore, the OIG recommends that the BOP evaluate its cell search procedures and make
changes as may be appropriate to improve those procedures through policy, training, or other measures.
90 U.S. DOJ OIG, Analysis of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Fecal! Year 2019 Overtime Noun and Cogs Management Advisory
Memorandum 21-011 (December 2020); U.S. DOJ OIG, Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisoncs lice of Restrictive Rousing
for Inmates with Mental Illness Evaluation and Inspections Division Report 17-05 (July 2017); U.S. DOJ OIG Audit of the
Federal Bureau of Prisons' Contract No DJBP0616BPA12004 Awarded to Spectrum Services Inc Victotville. Colifotilia Audit
Division Report 17-20 (March 2017); U.S. DOJ OIG, Audit of the Federal Ruremt of Prisons' Contract with Corerivic Inc to
Operate the Adams County Correctional Center in Natchez, Mississippi, Audit Division Report 17-08 (December 2016); U.S.
DOJ OIG, 8 iew ' ' Medical Stomnp Challenges Evaluation and Inspections Division Report
16-02 (March 2016); U.S. DOJ OIG, Review oftheimport of an Aging Inmate Population on the Federal Bureau of Pricons
Evaluation and Inspections Division Report 15-05 (May 2015). Additionally, multiple remote inspections the OIG
conducted as part of its pandemic response oversight work revealed that staffing shortages impacted the BOP's ability
to respond to inmates' medical needs during the Coronavirus Disease 2019 pandemic. These findings are summarized
in the OIG's Capstone report.
8. The BOP should enhance existing policies regarding institutional security camera
systems to ensure they specifically state that such systems must have the capacity to
record video and that BOP institutions must conduct regular security camera system
functionality checks.

As discussed in the Conclusions section of this chapter, the OIG found that, even though the highest levels
of leadership knew of the MCC New York security camera system's recurring deficiencies, prior to Epstein's
death, no one was tasked with the responsibility of checking the security camera system on a routine basis
to ensure that the system was functional. As a result, when on July 29, 2019, video from approximately half
of the institution's security cameras was no longer being recorded, the problem went undetected for
11 days. The OIG also found that there are no BOP policies that specifically state that security camera
systems must have the capacity to record or that institutional staff must perform periodic checks to ensure
the camera system is fully functional. Cameras that are failing to provide good quality or any live video
streams put the safety of BOP staff members and inmates at risk, and the lack of video recordings can
potentially hinder investigations of wrongdoing by staff and inmates. The GIG therefore recommends that
the BOP enhance existing policies and protocols so they specifically state that all institutional security
camera systems must have the capacity to record, and that specified staff at each institution must conduct
periodic checks of the security camera system to determine its operational status and take corrective action
as soon as possible when the system is found to be inoperable. Such routine checks would help ensure that
camera system malfunctions are detected and corrective actions are initiated in a timely manner.
Appendix A: The BOP's Response to the Draft Report
U. S. Department ofJustice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Central Office
Office oldie Director
MEMORANDUM FOR
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Washington. DC 20534
June 22,2023
ASSISTANT INSPECTOR GENERAL
INVESTIGATIONS DIVISION
Response to the Office of Inspector General's (O1G) Draft Report:
Investigation and Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Custody, Care.
and Supervision of Jeffrey Epstein at the Metropolitan Correctional Center
in New York, New Yodc
The Bureau of Prisons (BOP) appreciates the opportunity to formally respond to the Office of the
Inspector General's (O1G) above-referenced draft report. BOP values OIG's careful review of the
facts and circumstances surrounding the death of Jeffrey Epstein and concurs with the
recommendations resulting from this engagement. The lessons learned during the course of this
engagement will be applied to the broader BOP correctional landscape.

The facts and circumstances related to those few BOP employees at MCC New York in this
report reflect a failure to follow BOP's longstanding policies, regulations, and/or laws. While
this misconduct described in this report is troubling, those who took part in it represent a very
small percentage of the approximately 35.000 employees across more than 120 institutions who
continue to strive for correctional excellence every day.

In the Report, CrIG makes recommendations to enhance BOP policies and practices and improve
accountability. In response to this and previous OIG and Government Accountability Office
(GAO) engagements, 13O13 has already begun to evaluate nationwide trends and strengthen
employee accountability.

O1O Official Draft Report: BOP's Care. Custody. and Supervision of Jeffrey Epstein at MCC New Yak,
New York
June 22, 2023
Page 2 of 3
In April of this year, BOP's leadership announced its new mission as "corrections professionals
who foster a humane and secure environment and ensure public safety by preparing individuals
for successful reentry into our communities." BOP's new core values include accountability,
integrity, respect, compassion, and correctional excellence. Of note, our core value of
accountability requires 13O13 employees to be responsible and transparent to the public,
ourselves, and to those in our care and custody by the standards we establish, the actions we take,
and the duties we perform. As reflected in our mission and core values, BOP is committed to
providing a safe environment for both employees and adults in our custody.
Recommendation One: The BOP should implement a process for assigning a cellmate
following suicide watch or psychological observation, with criteria for exceptions based on the
particular individual or security considerations.
BOP's Response: The BOP recognizes the importance of careful monitoring of adults in
custody who face mental health challenges and therefore concurs with this recommendation.
Our practice is to carefidly consider both the well-being and safety of the individual involved
and overarching safety and security concerns. In the years since Mr. Epstein's death, the BOP
has updated its process related to suicide watch and psychological observation. Under BOP's
revised process, upon removal from suicide watch or psychological observation, psychologists
make individualized care recommendations about clinical follow-up and other custodial
concerns, including housing and cellmates. Mental health, custody, and unit team employees
work collaboratively to ensure that each individual removed from suicide watch is housed
appropriately.

Recommendation Two: The BOP should establish procedures to ensure inmates at high risk for
suicide and for whom a cellmate is recommended will continue to have a ccllmatc until the
recommendation is changed or rescinded, including establishing a contingency plan for cellmate
re-assignment. with criteria for exceptions based on the particular individual or security
considerations.

BOP's Response: The BOP concurs with this recommendation. As described in its response to
Recommendation 1, BOP's current process related to suicide watch and psychological
observation applies an individualized approach to the care and custody of adults in custody.
Upon removal from suicide watch or psychological observation, individualized care
recommendations are made by psychologists, custody. and unit team for each individual. BOP
thoroughly evaluates each ceiling assignment on an individual basis for persons deemed to be at
moderate to high risk for suicide.
Recommendation Three: The BOP should evaluate its current process for obtaining and
documenting approval for social or legal visits while an inmate is on suicide watch or
psychological observation, which allows for institution-specific variations in the process, and
provide guidance on standard components that each institution should include in its process to
mitigate security issues that can arise when an inmate is on suicide watch or psychological
observation.

OIG Official Draft Report: BOP's Care, Custody, and Supervision of Jeffrey Epstein at MCC New York,
New York
June 22, 2023
Page 3 of 3
BOP's Response: The BOP concurs with this recommendation.
Recommendation Four: The BOP should evaluate its methods of accounting for innate
whereabouts and wellbeing and make changes as may be appropriate to improve those methods
through policy, training, or other measures.
BOP's Response: The BOP concurs with this recommendation.
Recommendation Five: BOP policy should clarify what is required of a lieutenant when
conducting a round.
BOP's Response: The BOP concurs with this recommendation.
Recommendation Six: The BOP should continue to develop and implement plans to address
stalling shortages at its prisons.

BOP's Response: The BOP concurs with this recommendation. Hiring and retaining qualified
personnel is a key priority and BOP has developed and implemented a multi-pronged approach
that involves enhanced recruitment efforts and appropriate incentives. While the issues raised in
the OIG's report were the result of employees failing to adhere to their duties, as opposed to a
staffing shortage, the BOP welcomes the opportunity to continue the significant work that has
already been undertaken and that is ongoing regarding staffing.

Recommendation Seven: The BOP should evaluate its cell search procedures and make changes
as may be appropriate to improve those procedures through policy, training, or other measures.
BOP's Response: The BOP concurs with this recommendation.

Recommendation Eight: The BOP should enhance existing policies regarding institutional
security camera systems to ensure they specifically state that such systems must have the
capacity to record video and that BOP institutions must conduct regular security camera system
functionality checks.
BOP's Response: The BOP concurs with this recommendation.

The BOP appreciates OIG's careful attention to this engagement, and its willingness to provide
specific. feasible recommendations that address the root causes of issues raised in the incident
described. Thank you for the opportunity to comment on this report. We look forward to
working with OIG to close these recommendations.
Appendix B: OIG Analysis of the BOP's Response
The Office of the Inspector General (OIG) provided a draft of this report to the Federal Bureau of Prisons
(BOP), and the BOP's response is incorporated as Appendix A. The BOP indicated in its response that it
agreed with all eight recommendations.

The following provides the OIG's analysis of the BOP's response and a summary of the actions necessary to
close the recommendations. The OIG requests that the BOP provide an update on the status of its response
to the recommendations within 90 days of the issuance of this report.

Recommendation 1: The BOP should implement a process for assigning a cellmate following suicide
watch or psychological observation, with criteria for exceptions based on the particular individual or
security considerations.
Status: Resolved.
BOP Response: The BOP reported the following:
The BOP recognizes the importance of careful monitoring of adults in custody who face mental
health challenges and therefore concurs with this recommendation. Our practice is to
carefully consider both the well-being and safety of the individual involved and overarching
safety and security concerns. In the years since Mr. Epstein's death, the BOP has updated its
process related to suicide watch and psychological observation. Under BOP's revised process,
upon removal from suicide watch or psychological observation, psychologists make
individualized care recommendations about clinical follow-up and other custodial concerns,
including housing and cellmates. Mental health, custody, and unit team employees work
collaboratively to ensure that each individual removed from suicide watch is housed
appropriately.

OIG Analysis: The BOP's response is responsive to this recommendation. The OIG will consider whether to
close this recommendation after the BOP (1) provides for the OIG's review a proposed process for assigning
a cellmate following suicide watch or psychological observation, with criteria for exceptions based on the
particular individual or security considerations, that addresses issues identified in the OIG's report; and (2)
implements the process.

Recommendation 2: The BOP should establish procedures to ensure inmates at high risk for suicide
and for whom a cellmate is recommended will continue to have a cellmate until the
recommendation is changed or rescinded, including establishing a contingency plan for cellmate re-
assignment, with criteria for exceptions based on the particular individual or security
considerations.
Status: Resolved.
BOP Response: The BOP reported the following:
The BOP concurs with this recommendation. As described in its response to Recommendation
1. BOP's current process related to suicide watch and psychological observation applies an
individualized approach to the care and custody of adults in custody. Upon removal from
suicide watch or psychological observation, individualized care recommendations are made
by psychologists, custody, and unit team for each individual. BOP thoroughly evaluates each
ceiling assignment on an individual basis for persons deemed to be at moderate to high risk
for suicide.

OIG Analysis: The BOP's response is not fully responsive to this recommendation. Recommendation 1
focuses on the process for assigning a cellmate following suicide watch and psychological observation.
Recommendation 2, on the other hand, focuses on procedures to ensure that inmates at high risk for
suicide and for whom a cellmate is recommended continue to have a cellmate until the recommendation is
changed or rescinded. Our investigation and review determined that BOP employees did not take steps to
ensure that Jeffrey Epstein continuously had a cellmate in response to Psychology Department personnel
having determined that he needed to have an appropriate cellmate, and absent any indication that security
or other considerations relating to Epstein warranted his not having a cellmate.

The OIG will consider whether to close this recommendation after the BOP (1) develops the recommended
procedures; (2) provides the procedures to the OIG; and (3) implements the procedures.
Recommendation 3: The BOP should evaluate its current process for obtaining and documenting
approval for social or legal visits while an inmate is on suicide watch or psychological observation,
which allows for institution -specific variations in the process, and provide guidance on standard
components that each institution should include in its process to mitigate security issues that can
arise when an inmate is on suicide watch or psychological observation.
Status: Resolved.
BOP Response: The BOP reported the following:
The BOP concurs with this recommendation.

OIG Analysis: The BOP concurred with this recommendation but did not provide any additional
information. The OIG will consider whether to close this recommendation after the BOP (1) evaluates the
current process for obtaining and documenting approval for social or legal visits while an inmate is on
suicide watch or psychological observation; (2) provides guidance on standard components that each
institution should include it is process; and (3) provides to the OIG documentation of the evaluation and the
guidance forwarded to institutions for inclusion in their institution -specific processes.
Recommendation 4: The BOP should evaluate its methods of accounting for inmate whereabouts
and wellbeing and make changes as may be appropriate to improve those methods through policy,
training, or other measures.
Status: Resolved.
BOP Response: The BOP reported the following:
The BOP concurs with this recommendation.

OIG Analysis: The BOP concurred with this recommendation but did not provide any additional
information. The OIG will consider whether to close this recommendation after the BOP (1) evaluates its
methods of accounting for inmate whereabouts and wellbeing; (2) makes any appropriate changes to
improve those methods through policy, training, or other measures; and (3) provides documentation of
evaluation and any appropriate changes to the OIG.

Recommendation 5: BOP policy should clarify what is required of a Lieutenant when conducting a
round.
Status: Resolved.
BOP Response: The BOP reported the following:
The BOP concurs with this recommendation.

OIG Analysis: The BOP concurred with this recommendation but did not provide any additional
information. The OIG will consider whether to close this recommendation after the BOP (1) updates its
policy to clarify what is required of a Lieutenant when conducting a round; (2) communicates the policy
update to all relevant BOP employees; and (3) provides documentation of the policy update and
communication to the OIG.

Recommendation 6: The BOP should continue to develop and implement plans to address staffing
shortages at its prisons.
Status: Resolved.
BOP Response: The BOP reported the following:
The BOP concurs with this recommendation. Hiring and retaining qualified personnel is a key
priority and BOP has developed and implemented a multi -pronged approach that involves
enhanced recruitment efforts and appropriate incentives. While the issues raised in the OIG's
report were the result of employees failing to adhere to their duties, as opposed to a staffing
shortage, the BOP welcomes the opportunity to continue the significant work that has already
been undertaken and that is ongoing regarding staffing.

OIG Analysis: The BOP's response is responsive to the recommendation. The OIG will consider whether to
close this recommendation after the BOP (1) develops and implements plans to address staffing shortages
at its prisons and (2) provides documentation of such efforts to the OIG.

Recommendation 7: The BOP should evaluate its cell search procedures and make changes as may
be appropriate to improve those procedures through policy, training, or other measures.
Status: Resolved.
BOP Response: The BOP reported the following:
The BOP concurs with this recommendation.

OIG Analysis: The BOP concurred with this recommendation but did not provide any additional
information. The OIG will consider whether to close this recommendation after the BOP (1) evaluates its cell
search procedures; (2) makes any appropriate changes to those procedures through policy, training, or
other measures; and (3) provides documentation of evaluation and any appropriate changes to the OIG.
Recommendation 8: The BOP should enhance existing policies regarding institutional security
camera systems to ensure they specifically state that such systems must have the capacity to record
video and that BOP institutions must conduct regular security camera system functionality checks.
Status: Resolved.
BOP Response: The BOP reported the following:
The BOP concurs with this recommendation.

OIG Analysis: The BOP concurred with this recommendation but did not provide any additional
information. The OIG will consider whether to close this recommendation after the BOP (1) enhances
existing policies regarding institutional camera systems to include the recommended language update; (2)
communicates the policy update to all relevant BOP employees; and (3) provides documentation of the
policy update and communication to the OIG.
╔═══════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
          Generation Now [usvi] political group in USVI 
 Southland Gaming [usvi] gambling company (???) in USVI 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00129035 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Denise George
(date: 2023-10-02)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 4-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Camp
Date of entry  10/06/2023

On October 2, 2023, Denise George (GEORGE) date of birth
phone-, requested to file a complaint. After being made aware of
the identity of the interviewing agent, GEORGE provided the following
statement:

EPSTEIN WAIVER
GEORGE became the United State Virgin Islands Attorney General (AG) in 2019.
Within the first two weeks of GEORGE becoming Attorney General, Albert Bryan
(BRYAN), the newly elected Governor of the Virgin Islands, informed her that
Jeffrey Epstein (EPSTEIN) wanted a waiver for a 21 day reporting
requirement.

Erika Kellerhals (KELLERHALS), legal representative for EPSTEIN, submitted a
request letter to GEORGE. In KELLERHALS request she provided examples of
other waivers being granted (Truck Drivers and other individuals where short
notice travel was part of their daily job duties) . The waiver being granted
was at the sole discretion of the AG. A previous AG, Vincent Franklin Frazer
(FRAZER) granted EPSTEIN the waiver but it was later rescinded by acting AG
Carol Thomas -Jacobs (JACOBS) after EPSTEIN was detained in the Dominican
Republic. BRYAN informed GEORGE via text message that "you need to make a
decision on the Epstein matter". GEORGE did not grant EPSTEIN the waiver.
The same day she informed KELLERHALS via a letter and BRYAN via an email.
BRYAN responded with "Thank you for your work on this".

In July, 2019, KELLERHALS emailed GEORGE asking for a meeting. GEORGE
replied asking her to bring documents that justified waiver. The meeting was
scheduled for a Wednesday. EPSTEIN was arrested the prior Saturday in New
York and would later die in custody.

GEORGE stated that she believed FRAZER initially stated that EPSTEIN must
report like everyone else, but he later authorized the waiver. GEORGE
believed that FRAZER was pressured by then Governor John De Jongh (DeJONGH).
EPSTEIN updated his will and estate planning with KELLERHALS. GEORGE
Investigation on 10/02/2023
Facts 272L—SJ-377S806
at St Thomas, Virgin Islands, United States (In Person)
by Christopher J. Sebero
Date drafted 10/02/2023

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
272L-S3-3775806
Continuation of FD-302 of (U//FOUO) Interview of Denise George ,on 10/02/2023 ,p age 2 of 4
believed EPSTEIN moved his assets under the United States Virgin Islands
(USVI) due to his relationship with DeJONGH.

After being briefed by the outgoing acting AG, EPSTEIN requesting a waiver,
and EPSTEIN's death, GEORGE believed EPSTEIN was involved in Economic
Development Commission (EDC) fraud and proceeds from criminal acts
pertaining to Criminally Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (C/CO) .

MOTLEY RICE CICO

BRYAN told GEORGE "He's dead go for it". GEORGE contacted Motley Rice
(MOTLEY RICE) to assist with CICO and recovering funds from EPSTEIN's estate
received due to criminal activity. MOTLEY RICE investigated with forensic
accountants discovered several companies and LLCs with relationships to
EPSTEIN's Southern Trust Company (SOUTHERN TRUST).

In approximately January of 2020 GEORGE with MOTLEY RICE filed a CICO
against the EPSTEIN estate. Approximately a few days after EPSTEIN died
KELLERHALS filed a probate petition in Superior Court USVI with Judge
Carolyn P. Hermon-Percell (PERCELL).

Agent Note: [PERCELL was appointed by BRYAN on March 23, 2022 to a five year
term as the Commissioner to Casino Control.]

During the investigation into the EPSTEIN estate it was discovered that
Richard Kahn (KAHN) and Darren Indyke (INDYKE) were participants in the
human trafficking operation. INDYKE was in charge of coordinating female to
female marriages to gain immigration status in the United States. The
females would be threatened if they attempted divorce. The victims were
housed on EPSTEIN properties and moved from Palm Beach, Florida, New York
and Little St. James Island.

A second amended complaint added INDYKE and KAHN as co-conspirators. The
estate settled for 105 million dollars in civil court. The estate denied all
wrong doing. MOTLEY RICE maintained a copy of the case file. Point of
contact for MOTELY RICE was Linda Singer phone 202-340-7163.

BRYAN original tone of "Go for it" changed to "End it quickly". BRYAN would
message GEORGE with questions on why she was interviewing certain people,
requesting documents, or filing certain items. BRYAN told GEORGE that
`originally when I said go ahead I didn't think it was going to go this far.
I can't get you to let this go?'.

GEORGE attempted to interview or request information from EPSTEIN estate
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
272L-SJ-3775806
Continuation of FD-302 of (U//FOUO) Interview of Denise George ,on 10/02/2023 ,p age 3 of 4

employees. All EPSTEIN employees had nondisclosure agreements and were
informed if questioned by law enforcement to say nothing and alert
KELLERHALS.

BRYAN's Chief of Security Anderson Poleon.

On a separate case not related to EPSTEIN, BRYAN showed interest. A VIPD
officer sued the VI government for false arrest and imprisonment. The former
officer who was fired became BRYAN's chief of security. BRYAN asked for
updates frequently and inside information while the case was pending. The
officer's lawyer has close ties to BRYAN. BRYAN called GEORGE on speaker
phone with the officer in the room and offer amounts for settlement.
[Agent Note: Agent latter learned the officer was Anderson Poleon (POLEON) .]

Generation Now

GEORGE opined that SOUTHLAND GAMING was being helped by the VI government
because Jason CHARLES is part of Generation Now (GENERATION NOW). Another
member of GENERATION NOW was John Engerman (ENGERMAN), BRYAN's campaign
manager, David Bornn (BORNN) a former KELLERHALS employee and current Chief
of Legal for BRYAN, and another KELLERHALS lawyer.

Southland Gaming

Southland Gaming (SOUTHLAND GAMING) sued the VI government for breach of contract.

On morning at approximately 07:30 BRYAN called GEORGE extremely angry
stating "I am hearing you are going after people who are members of our
team." BRYAN continued first it was Joseph, then EPSTEIN, and you are going
after SOUTHLAND GAMING. GEORGE replied she was representing the VI and
SOUTHAND GAMING sued the VI. In the paper was a headline that day `AG states
Southland Gaming contract illegal'. GEORGE later learned from Jenifer O'neal
(ONEAL) that ONEAL called the governor to complain. GEORGE opined that ONEAL
and SOUTHLAND GAMING's liaison to the VI government, Jason Charles (CHARLES)
are good friends and are often seen dinning together. USVI and SOUTHLAND
GAMING mediation fell through. The VI government offered SOUTHLAND GAMING
rights at the new Racetrack on St. Thomas in exchange for a withdrawal of
the lawsuit.

[Agent Note: An article by the Virgin Island's Daily News from May 12, 2020
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
272L-SJ-3775806
CominuationolFO-30.2of (U//FOUO) Interview of Denise George jm 10/02/2023 .page 4 of 4
by Susanne Carlson was titled "AG: 17-year -old VLT contract was never
legal".]

MOTLEY RICE started interviewing employees of the EPSTEIN estate. BORNN
called GEORGE and stated I am getting calls from KELLERHALS and asked what
GEORGE was investigating. GEORGE replied that it was none of KELLERHALS
business.

BRYAN informed GEORGE to settle with the EPSTEIN estate for 80 million
dollars and to pursue mediation and select Henry Smock (SMOCK) as the
mediator. BRYAN told GEORGE that the EPSTEIN estate just wanted to clear
people. BRYAN later told GEORGE that he was sick of her not doing what she
was told to do.

GEORGE believe BRYAN sent Carlton Dome (DOWE) to talk with GEORGE to
convince her. DOWE stated that he knew GEORGE would only do things if they
are right, but stated that he (DOWE) does things for BRYAN too but has a
line he won't cross. When GEORGE stated that BRYAN would have to fire her to
get what he wants. DOWE stated that it would be political suicide to fire
her at least before the election. After this meeting DOWE stopped talking to
GEORGE.

The EPSTEIN estate and USVI settled on 105 million.

JP MORGAN
Approximately December 27, 2022, GEORGE filed action against JP MORGAN. On
December 31, 2022 GEORGE was informed that she was terminated. Several
reasons were provided to the press but a listed reason was that no attorney
general was going to file anything without notifying the Governor.

UK TIMES
GEORGE was interviewed by two papers in reference to her time as the AG for
the USVI. After the article was publish a cease and desist letter was
emailed to her along with an unknown man arriving at her home. GEORGE took
the use of an unknown man to convey a message that we can reach you at your
home.
[Agent Note: GEORGE was open to future contact.]
EFTA00005191 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00173481 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about statement of Aaron E. Spivack re: investigation into missing evidence and cyber intrusion, see quote: "Special Agent 
Aaron E. Spivack improperly handled, documented, and stored digital evidence and failed to secure CSAM within policy, resulting in a cyber intrusion" 
[wired]
(date: 2024-01-26)
I, Aaron E. Spivack, having been duly sworn by Supervisory
Special Agent (SSA) Dannie W. Price, Jr., hereby make the
following statement to SSA Price and SSA Matthew A. Zavala on
01/26/2024 and SSA Price and SSA Claudia Dubravetz on
08/08/2024, whom I know to be SSAs of the Federal Bureau of
Investigation (FBI), assigned to the Inspection Division (INSD)
at the time of my statement. My attorney, Richard J. Roberson,
Jr., was present during my statement on both occasions, via
telephone . This statement took place over a two-day period. The
statement initiated on 01/26/2024, and again on 08/08/2024,
after additional allegations were added:

I entered on duty (EOD) on 02/21/2006, as an Intelligence
Analyst (IA). I EOD on 10/08/2008, as a Special Agent (SA) and I
am currently assigned to the New York Field Office (HYPO)
that capacity.

I understand that this is an internal investigation
regarding an allegation that Special Agent Aaron E. Spivack
improperly stored digital evidence at his residence in violation
of 1.6- Investigative Deficiency- Improper Handling of Property
in the Care, Custody, or Control of the Government. On
10/30/2023 the following expanded allegations were added:
Special Agent Aaron E. Spivack improperly handled, documented,
and stored digital evidence and failed to secure CSAM within
policy, resulting in a cyber intrusion in violation of 1.6-
Investigative Deficiency- Improper Handling of Property in the
Care, Custody, or Control of the Government and 5.17- security
Violation- Failure to Secure sensitive Equipment/ Materials. On
02/07/2024 the following expanded allegations were added:
Special Agent Aaron E. Spivack exceeded the limits of his
authority by contracting an outside company to develop computer
software on behalf of the FBI in violation of 2.8 Misuse of
Position and 5.23 Violation of Miscellaneous Rules/Regulations.

I have been further advised of my rights and
responsibilities in connection with this inquiry as set forth on
a "Warning and Assurance to Employee Required to Provide
Information" form FD-645 which I have read and signed. I
understand from my review of the FD-645 that should : refuse to
answer or fail to reply fully and truthfully during this
interview, I can expect to be dismissed from the rolls of the
FBI.
this here
E (EM)
e issues I
occur. I
ement
ere
st of
but th ral
0 n
I am currently assigned to CT-25, a Domestic Terrorism
squad, but assigned to an Enterprise Investigation that is a
hybrid of Domestic Terrorism and Child Exploitation violations.
I was assigned to squad CY-3 in May 2010 and officially named on
the squad in July 2010. This was when the FBI's child
exploitation program was referred to as "Innocent Images" and
fell under the Cyber Division, while Squad C-20 was the Human
Trafficking (HT) squad at the time. I believe it was 2015 when
Violent Crimes Against Children (VCAC) and HT programs were
combined under the FBI's Criminal Division, which led to the
merger of the violations in the NYFO under squad C-20. The Squad
is split and has the HT side and the VCAC side, and I was a VCAC
Agent. Agents primarily work their assigned violations, but we
come together as a squad for operations.
I have been with the FBI for over 18 years, having spend
the last 16 years as an Agent. I have been one of the FBI's
leading Agents in Child Exploitation investigations and to this
day, I believe that I am one of, if not the only, Court-
certified expert witness for the entire FBI for child
exploitation. I have  personally  accounted for aniseem4mately over
60 arrests, 150 search warrants, and have been responsible for
rescuing several hundreds of children.
cud to INSD and
ardect
Head•uarters (
ssistant Director in
Char •e
(AD) (DD)
ce
Assistant United States Attorney's Officc-c (U(AUSA's)I
des•it-
AUSAs.
Last month
Eoordinator
I believe Digital Extraction Technician (DExT) training was
opened to VCAC Agents in 2012. Scott Ledford was my instructor
for DExT. As of 2023, I knew Ledford was a Unit Chief (DC) and
led the Cyber Action Team (CAT). I believe at least three or
four of us initially received DExT training in approximately
2012, but I think all of us working Innocent Images/VCAC on the
squad were eventually trained. However, once the child
exploitation program moved from the Cyber Division to the
Criminal Division, that changed. The funding we received through
the Criminal Division was significantly less than what we
received through Cyber Division , so the DExT program was no
longer able to put on as many classes and certify as many people
as it had before. By the time of the intrusion that forms the
basis of this internal inquiry, only about half of the "child
exploitation" Agents on my Squad were DExT certified. This is
whilc vc wcrc still with CY 3.
We got certified because the Computer Analysis Response
Team (CART) was long overburdened and not familiar with the
nuances of the child exploitation violation, such as the types
of programs used by offenders, the vernaculars, etc. It was also
known, and something I witnessed personally, that due to the
reliance on CART and how long it would take for them to prepare
a case for review, "hands-on" offenders were not being arrested
in a timely manner. This resulted in the continuation of child
victimization at the hands of the offenders the FBI was actively
investigating. This was around the same time Agents working
other violations began to also see an increase in the collection
and reliance upon digital evidence in their cases. As DExTs, we
were encouraged, and in some cases I believe required, to assist
CART with their backlog by conducting DExT extractions for other
squads. The other reason was to eliminate the lag time in
searching evidence and identifying contact offenders (offenders
who physically exploited or physically assaulted children)
sooner.
VCAC investigations are different than most other FBI
investigations since, in VCAC investigations, a search warrant
is generally executed in the early stages of an investigation,
and the evidence needed to arrest and charge an offender is
usually derived from the materials seized during the execution
of a search warrant. Whereas other squads, generally speaking,
execute search warrants at the culmination of their
investigations.
Mike Osborn was a UC of the Crimes Against Children Human
Trafficking Unit (CACHTU) at FBI HQ  Headquarters  (HQ) and
eventually an Assistant Special Agent in Charge (ASAC) at NYFO.
He was a huge proponent of DExT. Being DExT trained allowed us
to conduct our own data extractions faster, but more
importantly, it allowed for a faster and more efficient way of
identifying "contact", or "hands-on", offenders and, thus, rescue
child victims of sexual abuse before they could be further
victimized.
After becoming DExT certified, we received DExT equipment
that allowed us to image, process, and better review the digital
files. The DExT training allowed us to better use FBI analytical
programs to review digital evidence. Being DExT certified
allowed us to assist CART by offering an alternative for other
squads to use for data extractions. At the time, CART was not
located in NYFO Headquarters City (HQC). CART was located in
Moonachie, New Jersey. It could take an hour to get to the CART
lab from the NYFO. CART evidence reviews needed to take place
there and it could take all day. CART eventually moved to NYFO,
HQC.
The volume of data extractions we took on lessened the
burden on CART. At least in New York, CART only had one or two
examiners who could handle data extractions immediately, and
almost certainly none who could respond after hours or on
weekends.
Since we dealt with child victims, it was, and is,
imperative that the digital evidence be processed immediately.
In nearly every child exploitation investigation the digital
evidence is quite literally the evidence to prove the crime and
without a prompt review, there is no probable cause to effect an
arrest, putting the lives of child victims in continued danger.
it is that very risk, the risk of continued abuse, that has
prompted the FBI to enact new policies requiring expeditious
investigation into allegations of child exploitation. This
includes the expeditious review of evidence.
Prior to the DExT training, onsite forensics,
was not really a practice. We had to take digital evidence back
to the office to view it and we relied more on the post-search
interview. After a search, we had to go back and arrest an
offender once we found the evidence. This made for a
significantly more dangerous arrest because the offenders knew
we were coming. There was also the potential for offender
suicide. We had three offender suicides that I can recall.
NYFO SAS Linh Phung, Thomas "Tommy" Thompson, Mitch
Thompson, and I were DExT trained. SA Cindy Wolff (aka Cindy
Dye) was also DExT trained. Cindy was the last to be trained
while our squad fell under Cyber Division. At the time, I was
the most junior Agent on the squad. Before being DExT trained,
all of our digital evidence was submitted to CART for data
extractions, imaging, and processing. We did have access to the
Case Agent Investigative Review (CAIR) system, a forensic tool
for data review, but the program was slow, not capable of
handling large evidence reviews, did not work all that well, and
did not do what we in the child exploitation program needed it
to do. As a result, rather than using CAIR, Agents on the squad
opted to travel to Moonachie, , where CART was
located, to conduct their reviews on site versus over the CAIR
network. The ineffectiveness of CAIR was no secret and was
widely known, and one of the reasons for the creation of the
autonomous DExT labs.
After collecting digital evidence, I would enter the
digital evidence into the Evidence Control Unit (ECU) and get a
1B evidence number assigned. I would then enter a CART request
with a description of what forensic examinations I needed to be
performed and information on the device that needed to be
extracted. Then I would submit it to CART. It could take a day
or two to get the evidence to CART and the amount of time it
would take CART to process the evidence varied. It could take
weeks or months. Once it was extracted, CART would process it in
the Forensic Tool Kit (FTK). We could review the data on CAIR or
go to Moonachie to review it. Everyone on the squad, for the
most part, chose to go to Moonachie. CART Digital Forensic
Examiners Stephen Flatley and Carlos Koo eventually set up a
spot in NYFO, HQC to do data extractions.
Even after receiving DExT training, we used CART for things
like very large media dumps/extractions and encrypted files. We
also used them to help us with understanding what some of the
digital evidence was. I believe CART may have provided us
digital copies of the data extraction and I think it may have
been on DVDs. They would have been accessible on Operational
Wide Area Network (OPWAN) aS well
. I do not recall
what we did with the copies on DVD. CART may have checked them
into evidence and provided a working copy. The DExT trained
Agents would do data dumps on everything we could like hard
drives, loose media, and thumb drives.
In 2015, generally if it was a device we could image, we
would follow this process. We would use write blockers to assure
we did not accidentally manipulate the original data. We would
create an image of our evidence; sometimes we would use another
hard drive. We imaged and processed the data. We had some hard
dr4yetdrivesl but I am not sure where they came from. I believe
HQ sent us a box of hard drives. I also believe CART may have
given us some as well.
We used a forensic duplicator called a TD3, and later a TX-
1 as well as FTK Imager, to image a device onto a hard drive and
make the derivative evidence. We would then make a working copy
image off of the derivative evidence. We would then work off of
the working copy.
I
placed
am pretty sure the
in the NYFO ECU if
derivative evidence was cataloged and
that was the policy, but if that was
not the policy we would not have done that. The DExT Program
provided us with Redundant Array of Independent Disks (RAIDS).
These RAIDs were to be used to house our working copy evidence
images. I initially advised the interviewing SSAs, once we ran
out of hard drives for derivative evidence, we were instructed
to use the RAIDs and that these instructions came from either a
r my supervisor. This is true, as it was the SSA and
the case Agent for our squad's whose responsibility it
was to request and receive funding and equipment. Any requests
that we needed were routed through them, and the case
Agent was also one of our DExT Agents who also faced the same
issues of not having the hard drives to create derivative
evidence. However, I also recall these instructions were
provided by HQ, either our Program Manager (PM), the DExT PM, or
both. This may have occurred in 2012 when I went through the
DExT program and continued over the years. As there has been a
revolving door of PMs, I do not recall the names of the people I
spoke with at the can provide as many names of PMs who
I can recall had been there over the years.
Typically, the person running a Group I or Group II
Undercover Operation (UCO) investigation and the squad SSA would
be the people who communicated with HQ for resources. As an
example, I recall in 2015, I sent an email to SA Tommy Thompson,
who was the case agent of our squad's Group II, asking for some
large capacity hard drives with our remaining Group II funds.
This was one of many requests I made, which were generally
verbal, for equipment/resources. At the time we were still
merged with Cyber. When we moved to the Criminal Division, our
funds were nearly wiped out.  Sometime thereafter,
tinh Phung left NYFO and became a DExT PM at FBI HQ. Shl
would often  complain about a lack of funding.
When we first became DExT trained, it was much easier to
comply with the policy since the size of the data was
significantly smaller than it is today. For example, telephone
dumps then often fit on a DVD, or worst case a Blu-ray DVD.
Today, DVDs are nearly obsolete as the size of data collections
has become enormous, requiring large capacity hard drives which
are more expensive and harder to get.
To be 100% compliant with the existing policy in—o—etiveri
pliieach year, it would likely require C-20 alone to purchase
over a hundred hard drives, and this is just one squad in one
office. To ensure that everyone in the FBI is compliant 4e—it
elven ycareach year,  the  FBI would likely have to purchase
thousands of hard drives, then do this year after year. But the
FBI does not do this and the policy it created to cover search
warrants decades ago has not changed, despite the fact the
environment the policy applies to has.
This is one of the several fundamental flaws that I have
and continue to voice. If creating derivative igvidence is a
requirement, then why does the FBI not automatically rovide the
hard drives? How can the FBI enforce a policy without providing
the filed with the ability to comply? If, in nearly every search
warrant executed FBI-wide electronic media is seized, resulting
in the need for derivative evidence hard drives, why is it then
incumbent upon each individual squad, in each office, under each
program and division, to figure out a way to obtain the funding
to purchase them? If the FBI knows hard drives cannot easily be
purchased in bulk, and that there are security requirements on
where the drives must be manufactured, why does the FBI not just
purchase them for us rather than place that nearly impossible
burden on us?
In approximately 2017 I took over as case Agent for our
squad's Group -II. As the case Agent I was able to use Group- II
funds to make purchases, which were obligated to us .through
CACHTU.
-I was running out of hard drive space for derivative
evidence and of storage space in general. The PMs told us buying
hard drives in bulk was a problem. The stores had a capacity
limit, but I was advised to try anyway but was not successful. I
would purchase the drives on Amazon, like I was instructed to do
by HQ, until my covert account was shut down by Amazon since the
purchasing of large quantities of hard drives was flagged as
suspicious. We were also purchasing hard drives from New Egg,
like we were instructed to do by HQ, specifically SSA Heath
Graves who was the DExT PM, because they could sell bulk (10 or
more) hard drives, but I was later told by someone in the
Procurement Unit we could not use New Egg. This left us with
very few options for buying hard drives and despite voicing
these issues, no one at HQ offered a solution. In speaking with
other Agents across the FBI, I learned this was a common
problem. I went to CART who gave us what hard drives they could
spare.
In 2017 I began to gain a voice among many FBI Child
Exploitation circles. I took over our squad's Group II UCO, and
almost immediately converted it into a Group I. This conversion,
which allows for the use of sensitive techniques, was done due
to my desire to enhance our undercover capabilities and increase
our effectiveness by using some of the most robust undercover
techniques available at the time. While every undercover
operation must be approved every six months in front of the
Criminal Undercover Operations Review Committee (CUORC), because
ours was now a Group I, it also had to be presented up through
CACHTU and approved by the AD. Assistant Director (AD). During
the CUORC, I brought up the funding issues. In the funding
section we discussed what we spent and what we anticipated to
spend. During my time as the case Agent for my squad's Group I,
my squad's statistical accomplishments increased exponentially.
The number of undercover sessions conducted by my squad
increased by 198% in the four years after I took over the NYFO
child exploitation program compared to the four years prior.
This meant an increase of approximately 2000 undercover sessions
in the same four-year span. More significantly, however, was how
I tasked undercovers and provided direction to ensure the
program worked to identify the most vulnerable of the exploited
children; and set out to rescue them. The results cannot be
overstated in that the lives of hundreds of children were saved.
While I am personally responsible for saving the lives of
hundreds, many hundreds, if not thousands more were saved
because of how I managed and directed the child exploitation
program.
In 2018 I did a five-week temporary duty assignment (TDY)
at CACHTU. My former SSA, Sean Watson, was the UC there. My job
was to call every VCAC Group I and Group II UC0 Case Agent and
ask questions about the issues they were having and to provide
recommendations on how to better the program, how CACHTU could
better assist the field, things that needed improvement, etc. I
learned a lot about the issues affecting the entire child
exploitation program and, while there were some differences in
the issues facing some offices over others, there were a number
of common issues that impacted every office. These issues
largely dealt with lack of guidance, direction, training,
equipment, DExT support, funding, and personnel. I drafted a
summary of the calls I made and created a section for complaints
from the field in reference to provided my assessment
to CACHTU leadership. One of the many takeaways was that nearly
every office haUe different
complying with policy and guidance.
a—and
EMIS  This summary was also provided to
the interviewing Agents and I can make it available to whomever
needs it.
This same assessment, as well as additional details were
also provided to Bryan Vorndran, who was the Deputy Assistant
Director (DAD) who covered child exploitation, as well as to my
immediate supervisor and to the supervisors/PMs at CACHTU. This
came as DAD Vorndran separately requested a working group of
Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) to address the needs of the VCAC
program. I explained to him how we had equipment
provided my assessment both orally and in
several documents.
Also in 2018, CACHTU PMs SSAs Michael Deizlak and Matthew
Chicantek were presenting to EdeeettEive—Managemen#II on the
issues facing child exploitation investigations. SSA Deizlak and
SSA Chicantek requested information from me that they wanted to
present. I emailed SSA Deizlak and SSA Chicantek, along with UC
Sean Watson of CACHTU, the write-up I sent after my TDY as well
as a separate, even more detailed summary of the issues. In this
three-page summary I talked about the need to appropriate money
for equipment, as well as details regarding issues affecting the
program, including the DExT, guidance, support, and more.
hers nd I m it very Clear to HO that we did not have
hard drives Every now and then they would send us COMP and
eitertJELAuwtIenthey would send funds, but nothing was
consistent. I also informed my SSA of the need for hard drives.
I was aware he knew we needed them and there were no funds.
Other Agents were dealing with the Same issues. It has been, and
continues to be, the  p ti 0fl g/CACAents to create
derivative copies of original evidence if derivative hard drives
are available. However, given  the long toryofpotreogiving
either the hard drives or the  funds to purnhAse them, war
leftwithAgra:ts have aa t_t_g_n   no alternative store their
derivative evidence on local storage. I would sometimes create
derivative copy of the evidence on the RAID tower, as well as  a
working copy. If the evidence was a large collection of
different computer  it was not   practical_to store twn
Copies (a working copy and derivative cois or the R11.M)mar
an. I would only create one. However, I very_plitaft a efl
riPriVAtiVP evidence rOpiOC onto either internal nr Pvternal hard
drives that were maintained in our lab either as having been
resiced i gp pseth aggl r wro or uired. Since as discussed we did
not have a surplus of hard drives nor did we often have the
funds to purchase them I used ones I was able to get or hard
drives that had been repurpOSed. However, it often was the case
where I  maintained the derivative evidence of several
investigations on a single hard drive. This was due to the
, and the fart that I did not
want to waste the extra space that was free if a
particular case only took up a portion of the hard drive. As
reeourree were hard to come by I maximized the resources I did
have. These derivative evidence hard drives were separate and
apart from the evidence copies maintained on our RAIDS or
servers. I was not able to do this for every investigation, due
to the limitations discussed, but when feasible it was done.
This was my way of going out of my way to create dDerivative
eEvidence as often as I could, despite not having the resources.
I have located some of these hard drives that are still
maintained in the r-20 lab, and phntng A hs of them have been
provided o h in rvi wing S$AS.
When I was unable to create true derivative evidence to be
checked into ECU or the derivative evidence described above, I
ropidered the working_cOpy of the evidence on my RAID or lerver
as the derivative copy. Regardless. III the evidence copies had
"hash -verification" logs to ensure the coot' was a bit-for-bi
used were designed to prevent changes to the vi n so there
was never a possibility that the evidence copies could be
Petered
I have various correspondence with HQ advising there was a
lack of funding. This not only affected us getting hard drives,
but also various other things. Phung provided us with more RAID
towers for instructed us to use the storage to meet
our needs. I do not recall her exact words, but I understood her
directions to mean I could use the RAID towers for the creation
of derivative and working copy evidence.
I also learned funds were available, but not designated for
the purchase of the hard drives. Money was either not there or
was allocated to something else. I spoke with Heath Graves who
was the DExT PM and then Jim Harrison who iS the current DExT
PM.
In June 2023, I proposed an idea to SSA Seamus Clarke and
ASAC Spencer  Horn re ardin  how to address  the issue of handling
derivativeevidenre  cinre the long -etanding prnrecs of tieing
external  media to store derivative evidence was no longer
Commented (DWI]: I movcd this up
DW
2024.10.19 13:34:00
Commented (IDW2J: I movcd this up
DW
2024.10.19 13:36:00
practical. SSA. Clarke and ASAC Horn liked my idea and encouraged
me to reach out to the ECU to find a way to pitch the idea.
T reached  011t to Supervisory administrative Specialist
(SAS) Arlene McKenna, who the NYFO ECU. SAS McKenna
also liked  my idea and stated any changes in the evidence
guidelines or polity would have to come From the Field Kvidenre
Eliggrem (FEP) of the FBI's Laboratory Division (LD). SAS McKenna
provided the name of the FEP's Supervisory Management and
Erogram_AnalystAIMPAL Adeline Josephi_and_Suggested  I  rear))
out to her.
On 06 07 2023 I spoke with MAPA Joseph via FBINET Skype
mall. I discussed  with MAPA Joseph the issue with the current
process, which was feasible years ago when the size  of
electronic evidence  was significantly 'mailer  In_those days,
derivative evidence was stored
blue-ray DVD or thumb drive. However, in recent years the size
Of electronic evidence sei,uros has increased dramatically &
requiring hard drives to be able to accommodate  the data,
;sp_ sidthlat l„ 0xlair ahil I personally have never had an issue
Obtaining DVDS, I could not Say the same about  hard drives. I
PKPleined that while the technical environment the ECU
policy/guidance is based cn  alachanged, the FBI'S
guldrgice/p_ocyndnli r n i h not. This has created the very
issue which  is part this  inability t.4
amide by the guidance/policy T stated that it has become
increasing ly difficult for the field to be in compliance with
the existing guidance/policy since the field no longer has the
resources to be compliant.
I offered  to help figure out another  process fox
maintaining  derivative evidence, as I believed it was a waste of
money and resources to purchase expensive hard drives for
derivative evidence which will jnet he checked into evidence
until the conclusion of an investigation, just to then be
destroyed. I spoke with MAPA Joseph  about creating reusable
virtual derivative storage that was Brand-alone. I suggested the
virtual evidence locker could be a server, which could be
controlled by the evidence units and that 1g numbers could still
be used and assigned to the folders of the derivative evidence
aosed the use of an electronic chain of custody
procoe.e to docnment the Arreq.e of the electronically  stored
derivative evidence. I further suggested that since the
derivative evidence copies were maintained electronically, there
would be no need to waste fnnde on hard drivee that would jnet
end up being destroyed anywav4 and that at the conclusion of an
investigation when the evidence iS to be "destroyed", the media
would be deleted, thereby freeing up space for new derivative
evidence. MAPA Joseph liked th suggestion  and stated list2oA.4 would
discuss it with her team, s•-cifically her UC whose name I
cannot recall. My SSA and ASAC, SSA Clarke  and ASAC Horn, were
both aware of my idea and conversations and encouraged me to
follow-up with MAPA Joseph, which I did via email nn 06/27/2021
This  email,  which has  since been provided to the interviewing
SSAs, stated in part:
"Hey Adeline,
A couple  eeks_ago  we had a disrussion,about
authorizing  our lab to store DE on our servers, rather than
the repeated, costly, an4 wasteful  process purchasing tons
hard drives to store TIF The Center, which would he seeflre,
CSmainacceSSIcagasandatili—seggirea15fOrthe
electronically_stored  DE, would take the  place of the
physieal hard drives whir")) would lave money_time,  and
eliminate the need to waste tons and tons of hard drives.
I _was wondering h and if there is
anything we can do to get something like this goingl
Thanks so much!
Aaron"
MAPA Joseph responded on 06/30/2023 with the following_
"Good Morning Aaron,
Moo All ie well
Apolog for tly i  delayedresponse.  Jea lw in in-
person training this week for evidence tech's. For your
awareness, we are working on wrapping up several projects
for this fi c ar. I am adding DE idea to our
whiteboard to discuss thi amongst the team to include all
key stakeholders that  wo yow d involved. don't min,
I'll send you a calendar invite So that it's on my calendar
to cirri.. back with you to discuss what the team decided
Kind regards,
Since this emaill I have not heard back
from MAPA Joseph or anyone in her chain of command regarding
this issue-
I have provided a recent example to the interviewing
Agents. In this example, which took place II November 2023,
after the intrusion and   inquiry, C-20
requested funds for derivative evidence hard drives and were
denied. After requesting $2,155.62 for derivative evidence hard
drives, CACHTU responded to "Please utilize cart for a resource
for this. We are under a CR and are very restrictive on what we
can approve". C-20 then went to CART, as directed, who in turn
stated they did not have any hard drives to spare and
recommended C-20 request funds from CACHTU.
This example further illustrates that even despite the
intrusion and the negative attention we received regarding
derivative evidence hard drives, the squad was again put in the
position of being unable to comply with policy because the FBI
would not provide the requisite hard drives or funding needed to
be compliant.
Sometime later C-20 would eventually receive some hard
ere then advised by the NYFO Information System
Security Officer (ISSO) their hard drives were out of policy and
that they could not use them since the hard drives were not
manufactured in the United States. This, again, put the squad in
an impossible situation with no alternatives being offered. It
was also quite ridiculous as it is likely that none of our
computer equipment is manufactured in the United States.
almost immediately converted it into a Croup I. This conversion,
to my desire to enhance our undercover capabilities and increase
our effectiveness by using some of the m st robust undercover
operati n must be approved every nix moatha in fr nt of the
Criminal Undercover Operations Review Committee (CUORC), because
^ACWTU  and approved by the Assistant Director (AD). During the
During my time as the cacc Agent for my squad's Cr up I, my cqual
•
number of undercover sections conducted by my squad increased by
198% in the f ur years after I took vcr the WYFO chill
compa.ed  to the Co.- seas Thls
meant an increase of approximately 2000 undcrc vcr sc-si no in
the same f ur  year span. M rc significantly, h 'fever, was h w I
worked t identify the m ct vulnerable of the cx1 .tsii
that the 11.t.s of 4 Leda of child-ee 4e-e eased.
While I am personally responsible for saving the lives of
I
bccaucc of how I mana cd and directed thc child exploitation
Agite-gre*ee rege'rdeltrit3/4 -be-seleireee- he-4 aet9e-e4-4tafteR4411
lie 1-.01 ele-J   -4--ttedet,
CC.\ Cla-k- a..J .ICAC lik-J 1-1-e -d en
"lebe"reetal - etit - be - Ste - €13/4 - £4 6- ire riteh - t41e- Mee'r
ICAC) A-1- - m llL CY70 CCU. CAC ti-X--au
lik.A ft, LhS
titti.debittee-er-Debberwent441-hemme-ba-ceme-bram-bite-Fielni-Demialemee
to•leffi-4•Fis'P.-0.&-sle—r-a•i-s—eberetese seee-4-fr&i- 6.k6—meicea4te
1 •-•
Peeerem - Avelts 4- 14441,11M- r ikeiel'ime - geeePhra terYeek•eel - I-- reseet
k--
r - rmemr,
11.
-11. I d' 3-J -1th Will J---rh '  --tb tb-  .eh
reeeeee7 . 04Seit". 04" 4rnett 4leb 4'e'lea. 61 1319^-00iteri - Ste -041 Pe- e'fi
earaebistas-embiaiwboasia-M 4rwiamosblet-assaaaw—lor-Okess-eartss
e„18---- -ea ste-ed ea DVD- and
f scie---s k-s 1-e--e-aLd d-d-at-eally,
-in 1.43 b- Si.. Le d-ta.

╭──── Page 25, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

I tlai-J4 -Lac I pc„ce..ell) Le.t had a-
Jht----.1 DV a,
III'
‘ eette.r4 th'44a--i-f e t‚ir li —t4te-42 e494444e r t..
ab.d- be -t-ted th-t .1 Le- h-----

• C It • C • C • 1 e.
.1 I
the e-latl-e I-.J-n--/p-I.e, el-e- tkt f.-Id h-- 1h-
le b._ cemplleht.
4 ee
elettiapee••••-esaieiefeeer-wiei-ele-•44-1-jeee-kee-Sieekeel-ieete-e•idenee
le -Le. ee..1d L. a -hl-h L-
be-eseekerwheeeitee#  te th- feld--e e£ th deeieetiere—ewieleneee
th- -se of e.. ele-t-ealt ei. -1- -f
• s 1-...S 4 a> ••••• y
I (-rat- nhety-et-4 th-t J1L-t thz
*
L- n-_d te -e-t_ lanai- en hee.d ,h-t ,ea,d 'ant
.p h-Lon eLaf...f.A e.t.a -t t6.. e-ttlea.a- sf —
A-14 L- d-lel-J, th-i-b, fieela./ -p fai
. ih- -J -t-e ,,,,
•Ninti-t -11. ?1, Jed AC:.47
1...-th nee-- my Id-- -ed   me.J 'm
4.el-lem-tte-iereit-tertaire-deeeember-iditere-1-diek-e4e-emmeld-en-46424+242-3m
Tela h-a h-„ia th-
Ad-l-e-,
e -r leL te ete._ DC o
eemetriee-seeeete-keer eteed-s't444- eset?u4"Pe'e-4e-fee-ehe
▪ -1 L- J
linri -etc thc -c-d te -aete le -es a -d U.rs af heid 4.14-a
- , 2 , ;$ ,)
▪ .- es- de te 9-1. 11L- thl- e-1-y?
zilleserlee-eee-emielele
Ameeid:
HIZA Jesa,iph -e OC/30/2023 -ith th- felle-1-,
arzottertie44meerieety-Pereemer
W- ei- eetri-eti-ey In
t- d' a tLin amenvo1 th- le :..el-d- all
4terstatekel"ele're-Stet-weal aii".94" 41 I4' eeLt""4"freir
te-eMeele-rneed-mriee-pett-to-deepettee-whae-eive-heatn-deeededv
Eind
Jaya
mitea  LEL,
f.em RAN. Ja:A.ph a.
444441 901441.•
2018 : did a fi.e tcmposeet—doey—aaeOgnme.t. ITDY)
at CACHTU. My former  SSA, Scan Watson, was the UC there. My joie
tettetell 4+—everrVeAe —e'rentr÷—ewtei—Erretr±+ —Uee—ene —helent— Arnti
er -INere
recommendations  on how to better the program, how CACHTU  could
ednict (die field, things that d,ed,d Inp.evement, etc. :
learned  a lot about the issues affecting  the entire  child
cxpl itati n program  and, while there were some differences  in
of common issues that impacted  every  office. These issues
largely dealt with lack f guidance, direction,  training,
equipment., DC P dayea.t, I J-adled e
summary  of the calls I made and created  a section  for complaints
:rem th, field in refe.e,e, to
et, CACHTU lcadcrohip. This summary wan aloe provided to the

╭──── Page 28, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

itterviewitragertest-enel-4--eeterritaite-it--aveiaat-le-ltithemever
nccds it.
e4w4e-perweidad-tre-Drywn-Veehdrehr-whe-wee-the-Depehy-Awleisteet
Director  (DAD) wh c vcrcd child cupl itati n, as well as t my
i-ntmeel-i-atesuperviser-arrel-fre-t+te-strperv+ser-s4-Pi4s-at-C-A ris
came an DAD Vorndran  oeparately  rcqucoted  a working  group of
-ubjcct Matter Experts (SMEs) to address the nccds of the VCAC
provided  my assessment  both rally and in several
d cumcnts.
Alm, I- 2018, CACHTU PH- CSAa Mlehe-1 D-Irlek e.d Matthew
rhicantck  were presenting  to Executive  Management  on the issued
4.-atiltg-t+ael--erri-eitte-ieri-rr.vest-i-eset-i-ert-SSA-Bei-r-1-erk-entel-3534
Clekeettsek r-gae-Led -e that th-f
present. I entailed SEA Dcizlak  and SEA Chi antek, al ng with Ur
Geo.. W,.taea of CACHTU, the writ- .p I 9,Lt after my TDY an well
as a separate, even more detailed  summary  of the issues. In this
three page summary  I talked  about the need to appropriate  money
program, including the DExT, guidance, supp rt, and m re. Ge4eee
C.ei, -e- and th-.1 Lh-, -e-ld
eL..J L-t ...Ahiaq .40
jerreerrneel-for-reSA-e4-tite-Freed-ier-itted-elereee"—I-"rere-essere-ite-4mew
wit.hrtt-ite,  hew-Pews  .  refl..- 4.-

╭──── Page 29, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

p-attl-t ef VCAC 7.g-..te te e-eat- de,....-t...--eepeee-ed
Hawevers-erevem-thm---le_ merheemarred-teet-seeme-v-erreatieter-the-head
4- +Petrl'''S- e'ente€ 41melg- eceate - s- ekkei~i'v'e - eeere 4- t4 te
-e RAID t-e..., ae -ell as a -4.1.14 . :C
"Pee- q‚e~et"ieerlehe - see're - bwe - etries - ki - weekkPrerectri - efltS
t- T.)y) ar. tke AA:D le-e- and : -8-1J emly e -e-te  .
•- -å J • •.1
:ILL- --It...el e- --I--mal La-d d-1.es th-t -e-- -a--te-./eJ I.
egie -4 •14"7- e'itiTe riar erstal 14‘ gmbrniPeersins•
Sel" .i'PeST i'neerneeeeeee d f" 4 " .fe eed
' efl ha .e  Ile  f-md le  p...J..1e- tk , I --Lå
:t ette- -ae tIe e-e- -Le-- I th-
it- ef- ebiet34-e- nered - elei've• -;24 Tie
lb 44SI II.kii . et" ‚ Paet"be —. 1'eate —Ste —egebt's~
t-e- :f a pa.LIe-la. t --k ..p a -C II.- 1.--J
i • i br. - • -1>e
e -e --t-9 T J
FkAtee-er-earmare ems-net-elmla-t-e-ée-tha-e-See-evemy
-etlep.tlen, d-e Le Ih- :tal' Ltt -h-.

╭─ Page 30, Image 1 ─╮
│ a                  │
│                    │
│ 4                  │
│                    │
│ (Kt                │
╰────────────────────╯

rwrflmn Pe --A • 9 "%
>9...•rni ital. to*
th -t a ht.I1 - th- C 20 1 b, --J ph-t-g.a r L, I
k  “q CCha.
Scu er the dc.le:Ale- -N.d--e- d-J—ells-ei sissy-, I
abseb-reerfrembre ttm•emenee-Mte-eeprwee-e-hrb-fer-irrt
paa.:..k.
orlimeredm
201' : t_ e- it: Child
.1-eet 1--ediet-1„ -e-.e.ted .t 2-te a 0.e -p I. ?Lie e--. dr
alle-e is.. th- -e- ef e--eiti.e te-h-lq-es e ..as d -d- d-e
eff-eti.--e-e b) sal-, e -m_ ef th- m-et .eL-et -d---e.-r
the ti--. WL1I- e.e., -ade.ea.e-
'L- • 44- e-COMI SIIII •
CUORC, 1 b.e-qht ..p th- las -e-. I- th- f-Rdi-q e-ctie.
iretilipeterreeehmeratt-tre-eperet-ermr-whert-we rrear-re-eperm4
etteigirm esee-Alenb-fier-my-eper ntr-1- 7-my-epertetei
-Létlistisl

╭─ Page 31, Image 1 ─╮
│ -                  │
╰────────────────────╯

the Ce-.. aft-- I Leek NY: child
mentor ~n
we -Led 1.. C.- --et ,-1----L1- ..f
th11.1--.., -es-lts
r) A A.) 1
W411- I am Ce- the li--- et
-c.e ou„(-1
b. • s 1 u T ft 1 /1 • 1 1
When interviewed by INSD, I was asked when the standard
practice for C-20 members changed to not adding derivative
copies to the ECU. According to INSD, I stated I did not know,
but the change did happen. INSD then asserted that I now believe
the practice of creating derivative evidence copies onto
separate hard drives to be checked into evidence was dependent
upon we were provided funds to purchase the drives or
the drives themselves.
This is not entirely correct and lacks context. The
"change" that occurred as somewhat two-fold and started when
the FBI moved VCAC from the Cyber Division to the Criminal
Division and the funding we received was dramatically reduced.
The other contributing factor was, as discussed earlier, the
increase in the size of the electronic media seized during
search warrants and the subsequent need for significantly larger

╭─────── Page 32, Image 1 ────────╮
│ rent teck een the               │
│                                 │
│ enpleitationprogremcompaned tot │
│                                 │
│ path tone                       │
│                                 │
│ ‘                               │
│                                 │
│ a                               │
│                                 │
│ _                               │
│                                 │
│ +                               │
│                                 │
│ sneany henner                   │
╰─────────────────────────────────╯

and more expensive media to house the "Derivative 'Evidence.
This affected many things, including our ability to purchase
hard drives. Sol the "change" that led to our inability to
regularly comply with the derivative evidence practice was out
of our control. Despite that, I personally voiced this concern
numerous times over the years, but it was not an issue many were
willing to care about. Early on, when VCAC fell under the Cyber
Division, we had regular access to these drives, but when the
program was moved into the Criminal Division that changed.
Despite repeated requests, as well as having alerted everyone
within the chain of command, we were told to figure it out.
We had been advised that if derivative hard drives were not
available, to store the derivative evidence on our local
storage, which is what we did. It may have been in 2016 or 2017
and possibly happened because we did not have hard drives. I
believe we were initially getting some hard drives from DExT
after completing the certification course. DExT slowly went to
no longer providing hard drives to new DExT certified Agents at
all. I do not know what they are teaching about digital evidence
storage in DExT or how to get drives, but I know from other
Agents who have attended the DExT training more recently that
guidance has still been to seek funding from CACHTU, who again
has been stating they do
Until approximately
designated ISSO. This is
not have the funds.
February 2023, the NYFO did not have a
a required position, and I think it
being left unfilled exacerbated many of the problems that are
discussed herein.
retired Special Agent in Charge (SAC) Nicholas Bouchears who
created a timeline and report of his years-long request for an
ISSO, which was a requirement that the FBI left unfilled in the
NYFO until January or February 2023.
The situation was in essence entrapment. We were
by policy to create derivative evidence, but we were not
the ability to comply. Despite repeated
acknowledgements from FBI HQ about the conundrum, solutions were
never provided. We were told to adapt and to figure things out,
and we did. The result is that we got punished for it, which is
quite insane. We should not be held accountable for a problem we
could not fix and were not responsible for fixing,
When derivative hard drives were not available, we did as
we had been instructed by imaging t he original evidence onto the
RAID Storage or Network Attached Storage (NAS), and as
previously discussed, I even went above and beyond given our
limitations by creating derivative evidence copies of multiple
cases onto larger internal hard drives so I could ensure I was
doing everything within my power to comply with the
times I would create a second copy. If I made a second copy, I
would use one as the main copy and the other was the working
copy. If I did one copy, that one would be used as the working
copy. At times I would make multiple working copies
According to INSD, I advised I had not been making
derivative copies of digital evidence and that I now believe I
personally made derivative copies and did whenever I was
afforded with the requisite hard drives.
This is incorrect. From the beginning I have never wavered
and have always been adamant that I had been making derivative
evidence copies whenever preet4eelpossible. As I have also
stated, this was an FBI-wide issue that affected many 'gents,
including many in supervisory positions. The issue • not that
derivative evidence copies were not always created, the issue is
why the field was not always provided with the ability to create
derivative evidence copies.
The issue regarding derivative evidence that I and other'
faced was well known to our supervisors and specifically to our
substantive desk at HQ. The question for us in the field was
what do we do? Do we stop investigating our cases because wail'
hi  have a sufficient process for creating and storing
derivative evidence? Of course not. Just because I, and others,
did not always receive the drives did not mean our VCAC
lalglagps till had to adapt and
overcome and felt that while II may not have been able to create
derivative copies for III the evidence, the reasons for that
were well documented and out of III control. Had we, or I,
decided not to work cases due to the lack of derivative evidence
hard drives or funding for them, we would have been punished for
that as well. Aside from neglecting work being itself an
offense, there are other policies governing the child
exploitation program that explicitly require child exploitation
Agents to expeditiously conduct their investigations. It is like
being stuck between a rock and a hard place, and I, and others,
were told by FBI leadership over the years to make do, as long
as the cases were being properly investigated, and that is what
we did.
At no point in time have I ever IMI=Iistored digital
evidence at my residence. After the intrusion when the FBI's INSD
conducted their interviews, I had been asked about "evidence" and
reviewing materials from home. I acknowledged that I, like
everyone else, had done some work from home. However, the "
evidence" being referred to has always been "working copies" and
items that are absolutely covered under policy. At no time had I
taken original or derivative evidence home.
I believed that I had cleared up any misunderstanding or
ainantics over the word "evidence", because tom—that word used
without a descriptor  is  just a generic term for evidence. The
word has types,  not cmcluaivc  to "original"  r "derivative"
evidence. like a classification to distinguish what the evidence
is such as "original", "derivative", and "working copy". Then,
there are caveats to the category of evidence such as "digital",
"general", "drug", "valuablefinaLciii",  etc.  For example, when I
review subpoena returns, 4B-4e—oppirte—prespeo4B4/I am reviewing  "
evidence", but that does not mean the evidence is "original" or
"derivative", and unless those subpoena returns are in paper
form, they are categorized  as "digital evidence". Nevertheless,
I am authorized to review those from home.  that I am reviewing.
The same applies to  Or—chat messages derived_from a devicer or
having been included in a lead or Guardian
When discussing this with the Inspectors, I was clear that
anything I reviewed outside appropriate facilities was working
copies. At no point had I ever discussed with anyone that I have
taken original and/or derivative evidence home or in any way in
violation of policy. Any assertion to the contrary is
categorically false.
I have recently found a folder that I created on my FBINET
computer called "to Take home for baby leave". This folder
contained items I planned to take home to work on while still
under the work-from-home guidance we received during the
pandemic, which is also during the time my wife gave birth to
our twin boys. The items in this folder are generally indicative
of other files I had reviewed from home, none of which are
original evidence, derivative evidence, or CSAM.
Other examples that have also been provided to INSD include
an email from CACHTU SSA Jordan Hadfield which was sent to all
VCAC OCEs. The email was sent during the pandemic when OCEs were
working from home and is requesting to know if OCEs were aware
of a website contained in the email. SSA Hadfield instructed the
OCEs to not use their "HOME COMPUTER" to access the link because
it contained CSAM, however SSA Hadfield knew OCEs had their own
FBI-issued misattributed laptops and phones that they could
access the link on from home.
Another example is from my supervisor at the time, SSA Sean
Watson, who stated in an email dated 03/25/2020:
"I will be assigning Guardian lead(s) which can be worked
from home or an alternate location. Reminder for 305 leads,
do NOT use personal networks to vet out 305 leads. Use
covert equipment with an aircard or covert cell phones."
Throughout most of its existence the C-20 lab was Internet
connected. However, and for clarification, the C-20 lab existed
long before the DExT program and the misattributed Internet was
connected to our misattributed computers. At the time,
work was primarily conducted on
computer -based Internet platforms whereas today, the majority of
OCE work is on mobile-based platforms.
Back then, we used misattributed FBI-issues desktop
computers to conduct OCE sessions from the lab and adjusted
eutour work hours accordingly. As offenders began using mobile-
based applications, OCEs were required to do the same. With the
use of mobile applications offenders were now online and
chatting throughout the day, versus just when they were on their
home computers. Thus, the expectation of OCEs changed to emulate
that of the offenders. I do not know exactly when we received
FBI-issuede misattributed cellular telephones, but when we did,
we also received the authority to take them with us wherever we
went if we were engaging with CSAM offenders. In fact, OCEs have
long been encouraged to communicate with offenders at random
hours of the days and on weekends, to send offenders benign
photographs while on vacation, at events, etc.; all to better
legitimize the OCEs and help to dispel any fear offenders masi
have that the OCEs are law enforcement.,
When we became DExT certified, our computers were not
connected to the Internet except when we needed to update
software' or some other Internet required task. As the years
went on, the need for our DExT computers to be connected to the
Internet grew. As discussed, HQ was aware of this and at times
even promoted programs that required this. Additionally, two
agents from C-20 and our SSA had all gone down to CACHTU to
become SSAs and the UC respectively, and they were aware of this
practice and need both from having worked on C-20 as well as
from their positions at CACHTU. Lastly, as previously discussed,
at the time of the intrusion our squad had been participating in
a CACHTU pilot program, which included several other VCAC squads
from across the FBI and required the computers to be connected
to the Internet.
Regardless, our lab has always been "stand-alone", meaning
none of our computers to any FBI systems.
Additionally, our lab was "misattr buted" and able to be used in
covert capacities and to access websites that could contain
Child Sexual Abuse Material (CSAM) .
Initially, in approximately 2012, the C-20 lab was not
connected to the Internet, but at the time we had little reason
outside of software updates to be connected to the Internet.
Several years later that changed as the advancement in our
software and capabilities grew, requiring our computers to be
Internet -connected. The only guidance or direction we received
at the time was that our Internet -connected DExT computers not
be connected to a FBI network and as far as I have always been
aware that is the only policy on the matter as well. Even FBI HQ
implemented investigative steps that required DExT labs to be
Internet -connected, such as the method that was used to transmit
CSAM to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children
(NCMEC), whereas previously it had been to do so via a storage
media. Later, the FBI created the "SIFTS" program which was an
online portal for CSAM transmission. As an example, the FBI'i
SIFTS has been provided to INSD which includes
IIMMIF Anes must be connected to the Internet
In approximately 2022, CACHTU advised the field that the
licensing method for one of our most used programs, "Axiom", was
moving from dongle-based to cloud-based. CACHTU wanted to pilot
the cloud-based method and elicited the assistance of five or
six VCAC squads from across the FBI to do so, one of which was
our squad. —This pilot program, which began prior to our
intrusion and continued well after, required the DExT computers
to be connected to the Internet. It allowed us to check out a
license when we needed to, but t,—II do so, we needed to stay on
the Internet . There was some level of security
provided by the switch box and some on the NAS itself.
The computers, NAS and RAID tower storage that contained
CSAM were then all connected to the Internet. We received
guidance from CACHTU, specifically from the DExT PMs, to disable
Commented (CT3): Chat about this lore
C20 Tedaeam
202410.08 12:46:00
the antivirus to use the Axiom since the antivirus would flag
the program. I believe this came from Tommy, Heath, and CART,
and others . Squad C-20 did not know how to set up the Internet
and the switch box. We reached out to Computer Scientists (CSs)
and CART and received some help, and I have numerous emails that
I can provide to support this if requested. I do not know
anything about networking and how to set up networks,
. The CSs also did not know. I believe someone
from the Operational Technology Division (OTD) told me to Google
it were AN, the
Would 6MIIIIr weeillecoulat
use OPWAN Since did
not have an OPWAillrection, plus the size on
have been too m OPWAN to handle
Networking is not a DExT function and is not in my skill
set, so I did not even know what questions to ask. "T "RS®'
stated naringSMINWWWWWWWWWWWWWWininriny squad,li
Systems Administrator. Despite the INSD having labeled us this
in their post-intrusion report, we are not. We have never
received any training or instrulliton on systems administration,
and labeling urs.miaatimealedge we did not possess.
The off-the-shelf security that was in place was what we
were using. I and the squad asked everyone we could think of for
help - CART, the CSs, OTD, the office of the Chief Information
Officer (ooio), Management Information Systems (MIS), etc.
however, all were of no help.
CS Jim Walsh  and ITS Steven Flatley  helped us set up some
of the equipment. Christian Idsola from CART also helped, as did
another CART employee whose name I cannot recall. I ME  asked
FO CART s•uad, foci,
M in_moony Broderick ,
191.,., 1., the
These
communications, along with many others, occurred in writing via
email and them can  pr vide them to
investigatorSI.
In our desperation to find someone with a networking/system
administrator background to help us, we put out a Confidential
Human Source (CHS) canvass for assistance with our network
through our CHS Coordinator.
We also
reached out to OTD, Counterterrorism Division (CTD), and Cyber
Division (CyD) for help, but none were able to. An Agent on a CT
squad suggested that they had a Counterterrorism (CT) CHS who
could come over and look at the network, however the CHS advised
networking was not his/her specialty. The CHS was a former
contractor for the FBI and had a Top Secret (TS) clearance and
was not able to assist.
Commented (in]: Plate do in. Provide them to INSD.
Jim Roberson
2024.10.22 12:54:00
Our request was simple - to network the few standalone
computers in our lab. However, no responsible entity within the
FBI would assist, so we had to reach out to friends and
colleagues to help on their own. While their help was valuable,
none of our volunteered help came from anyone who was a network
or systems administrator, and the FBI's network or system
administrators would not assist. The various networking and
system administrative units in the FBI handle FBI networks, and
the few that handle covert/misattributed networks do not handle
CSAM networks. Despite the irrelevance of the latter from a
technical perspective, CSAM is offz—putting and no one wanted to
assist and CACHTU did not know what to do. In fact, CACHTU was
aware that networking VCAC computers was an issue affecting so
many other FBI Offices that PMs Stacie Kane, BrIndln Roth and
James Harrison encouraged us to find the solution so that it
could be emulated across the other VCAC DExT labs.  fact, our
mid the improvements we had been making on behalf of the
VCAC program, contributed to several end-of-year "gold" ratings
by CACHTUJ
As an example, in September 2022, SSA Brendan Roth, who was
the PM for the Northeast region for CACHTU, requested IIII I
the VCAC squad who needed to enhance
their . FBI Albany was trying to figure out how to
receive funds for their upgrades, and SSA Roth knew that I in
the NYFO had been this process and asked that I assist.
After SSA Roth and I spoke over the phone, he sent an email to
myself and SA Brian Seymore from the Albany stating
in part the following:
"Aaron
Per our convo about Group I UCO funds for CSAM review
stations - CC'ing Brian from Albany.
Maybe you guys can talk and answer questions he had about
the process and questions you were asked about it from
legal/procurement.
SSA Brendan Roth Criminal Investigative Division I Violent Crime
Section Crimes Against Children and Human Trafficking Unit
(CACHTU)"
Ii e with a
administrat  r background  to help uc, we put out a Confidential
fitmen-raarretrese-4er-assietenee--wi-t4t-etrr-netwark
th-e-qh-e ehad e-t t., OTD,
untcrtcrr  rirm Divisi n (CTD), and Cybcr Divici n (CyD) f r
c me over and look at the nctw rk and he/she advised  networking
vac Rot his/her specialty. The CBE was a f rmcr c ntract r for
the rni a“d il“el a T.4) See—t (TS) ela.a.et. Thls whwa
the lab wa:: on the 9th floor prior to it getting  fl ded.
In 2017, ounIIMB flooded after the temperatureillerthe lab
got so hot they triggered the sprinkler system. This devastated
our lab and ruined thousands  of
DExT equiPmarrbaudigiar this flan   Ott flee leb "wwel—I, some of
the equipment was replaced by CACHTU and CART was able to
salvage some of the equipment. We moved the C-20 lab to the 10th
floor in December 2020. I received approval on 12/22/2020 to
purchase switches, NASs, cables and hard drives. This equipment
was purchased with $34,000 in CACHTU funding, which also
supplied the Long Island Resident Agency (RA) with similar
equipment._
for the lost
upgrades.
CACHTU PM Leslie Adamczyk was a former NYFO Agent and
member of C-20 and knew about these issues. SSA Adamczyk
similarly had her DExT computer connected to the Internet and
similarly did not always create derivative evidence.
During the COVID pandemic there were three of us from my
squad who came to the office on a regular basis; myself, SA Matt
Deragon, and SA Brian Gander. The guidance, however, was to work
from home. The C-20 SSA at the time was Sean Watson. SSA Watson
provided guidance to work from home, in addition to the guidance
pushed by the FBI Director, our AD, and others in FBI
management. This guidance included conducting limited forensics
from home, and CACHTU pushed out to the field temporary AXIOM
licenses for
reviews from
the sole purpose
home. This meant
of conducting limited forensic
that literally the FBI was
encouraging Agents to conduct forensic reviews, of evidence,
from home. e of this
NewevesTriCe fEi bulk of my faTiEire -reviews meant reviewing
CSAM. Due to this reason,- I came into the officeliamignm dally fn
00 CSAM  reviewS ‘ This is a fact and can be corroborated by SAs
Deragon and Gander, as well as by checking the building access
logs which will show I used my access badge to enter the
building and the frequency I accessed the building. Other work
was done from home. I looked at subpoena returns and reviewed
working copy material that did not include CSAM. Anything I took
home was covered under was covered under the guidance
being disseminated. I have a Bureau -issued laptop computer that
I utilized for these purposes. It is categorically false that I
violated policy by taking home CSAM, original, or derivative
evidence.
FB
SSA about r f
exa les to !gab and
requeitted..,
At the time, I was working on three cases primarily: Robert
Hadden, Darnel Feagins, and Jacob Daskal. Only one of these
cases, Feagins, was a CSAM investigation. The Feagins
investigation was the reason for my having to come to the office
during the pandemic, which eventually changed when, after
indicting him, Feagins fled, turning the investigation into a
fugitive matter. The Daskal and Hadden investigations were
contact offense, or "hands-on" offense, cases that did not
involve CSAM.
To conduct the investigation for Hadden I was doing web-
based interviews from home and writing FD-302s and subpoena
returns which were all non-CSAM-related. For the Daskal case I
completed a 68-page DExT review FD-302. I took metadata-related
information. Some of it was exported from Daskal's computer, but
none of it was CSAM; rather it was data to prove he and the
victim of the investigation were together in various locations
and certain dates and times. For the Darnel Feagins case I was
splitting the work. I did not do CSAM-related work from home. I
did not take any storage devices home that were original or
derivative evidence. Any copies or data I took home would have
been working copies. It would have been impossible for me to
take derivative copies home in general.
I was coming IIII the office every day to do my CSAM
reviews. I do not believe I was doing any OCE work at the time
since we were instructed not to. We were trying NOT to create a
need for Agents to have to run out on warrants or to conduct
Knock and Talks (KTs) due to COVID unless it was an emergency -
and other OCEs would do OCE work from everywhere,
including home, but all of that was covered under our Group I
authority.
According to INSD, during my original interview I advised
that Agents believed they were authorized to conduct OCE work
outside FBI space and that we now have
uthority to conduct OCE work outside FBI space. This is a
slight of my statement as to this day it is
our belief that we always had authorization to conduct OCE work
outside FBI space. The reference to now having an EC was in
response to additional questioning by INSD  and did not change
the fact we had appropriate authorization prior to the EC. For
one, how we functioned as OCEs, to include when and where we
conducted OCE sessions, had been directed to us through FBI
trainings, FBI HQ, and our supervisors. Second, the authority
was written in our bi-annual renewals, which
are reviewed and approved by the entire chain of command and
include the and
Regarding anything I took home to work on, I have always
been certain what I knew I was authorized to take home and
what I was not. As , I would take home removable
storage devices like a hard drive or thumb drive that contained
working -copy data and/or other material that would allow me to
work from home. Some of my devices, including my FBI-issued OCE
telephone and my FBI-issued and encrypted laptop, may have had
CSAM on them, but as an OCE who was authorized to conduct OCE
sessions from outside FBI space, which included my home and
elsewhere, taking these devices home was covered by policy as
these devices were used in authorized and capacities. The OCE
and UCE polices allow for these things since communicating as an
OCE with VCAC offenders can require around -the-clock
communication. here is absolutely zero truth to any notion that
i violated any of these policies. I was quite literally doing my
job, which as a VCAC OCE, meant taking my OCE laptop and
telephone with me outside FBI space to communicate with CSAM
offenders. The communications with these offenders and any CSAM
I collected as a result, were maimed in accordance oll
olicy and that is lust a fact.
As for any evidence review I did from home, all was done in
accordance with policy and guidance. Despite a semantical
difference of opinion with INSD, I know that any evidence I did
take home was authorized under policy - it was not original or
derivative and was only working copies. Even as a matter of
logistics I would not have been able to take home original or
derivative evidence as I did not have the technical equipment at
home to review them on my laptop. I would have required write
blockers and/or other equipment to access original or derivative
evidence so despite the notion being outrageous anyway, it would
have been a nearly logistically L.r.,ssiblimpossibilitye.
Anything I took home to review was a sub-set of working -copy
data all authorized to review from home. All original and
derivative evidence were either checked into the NYFO ECU or on
the C-20 lab server.
The lab server had to be connected to the Internet II send
CSAM to NCMEC. As mentioned previously, the official way to send
CSAM to NCMEC is to use the SIFTS online portal. They will
accept hard drives. but it is not what they want, and NCMEC has
been moving to eliminate the use of hard drives altogether.
There are conflicting policies, and I brought this up while
assisting in revising the policy. I am one of, if not the only,
Court -certified expert witness for the entire FBI for child
exploitation.
During COVID, the concept of remote working was becoming a
thing. The idea came up during COVID to be able to do remote
work since that is what the FBI was beginning to promote. The
idea was continued by hearing from other members of law
enforcement, including some within the FBI, that they were
of remote computing to access their forensic labs while
away, such as on TDY or at a conference. The intention was not
to work from home, per se, but rather to increase the efficiency
of the forensic review process`
. The steps of imaging and
processing evidence before it is ready for review can sometimes
take days. During this time there is little for the DExT Agent
to do while the computer is doing its processing work. What
little there is for the DExT Agent to do is often what separates
one stage of this process from the next. Sc4 if a stage is
completed on a Saturday, it will not move to the next stage
until the DExT Agent does the very few things needed to proceed,
which may not happen until the following Monday. This may then
kick the process off to the next stage, but now the Agent may
have to wait several hours or longer for the next step. In order
to be more efficient and to allow this process to begin on a
Friday, for example, and be ready for review on a Monday, I
believed the idea of remote computing was a reasonable solution.
Remote computing would have allowed for a the DExT Agent to
remote in over a weekend to initiate the next stage of a process
so that the process took advantage of the weekend to conduct the
lengthy steps so that by Monday it was ready for review. The
downloading process could take a while, but the steps between
the process were three or four clicks. If I knew a hard drive
was going to take a day or so to process, and the next process
would also take a day or so,
to go into the office just to click a button.
Especially in a densely populated area like New York City during
COVID. The idea was to be able to remote in to the server and
tell the computer to move on to the next step of the process.
The idea of using remote computing was reinforced a few
years ago when I attended training provided by the International
Association of Computer Investigative Specialists (IACIS) during
which we went through basic computer forensics. I heard about
law enforcement use of Microsoft Remote Desktop Protocol (RDP)
there. I believe RDP was being used in the Bureau' but I am not
sure for what purpose or on what devices. I spoke with several
others in the FBI about RDP, including the DExT PM at the time,
SSA Heath Graves, who mentioned he had either been using it or
toyed around with the idea. SSA Graves mentioned to me that
setting it up and using it was fairly easy, and that all I
needed to do was follow Microsoft's directions as they were
pretty easy to follow. SSA Graves knew what my intentions were
and thought it was a great idea to be able to remote in to cut
the lag time of our processing.
I thought the C-20 system was secure. I attempted to access
the C-20 computer lab through RDP. I believed the lab's security
prevented me from remoting in. I had no idea that in so doing I
had opened the lab's RDP port and that it had worked. I could
access the port from in the lab, but once outside the lab, I was
unable to gain access to the network. I thought the security was
doing what it was supposed to. I was later advised that the RDP
configuration was mostly correct and that I was a step or two
away from having set it up successfully and securely. I was not
trying to be lazy or silly, I wanted to be more efficient in the
download process. Sometimes I would start a process on a Friday
only to come in on Monday and see it crashed and needed to be
restarted. RDP access would have allowed me to see the crash and
restart the process remotely.
I believe enabling remote access to the C-20 computer lab
was a good initiative, but it was not executed properly. It was
all about improving our abilities to protect children. I had
asked for help, b I. did not get it, but I did get
encouragement,  I was going off the guidance I received from the
DExT PM and CACHTU supervisor, SSA Heath Graves, who advised me
to follow the instructions off the Microsoft website. While I
cannot recall verbatim what he said, I am positive it was in the
realm of the Microsoft instructions regarding RDP to be "very
good" and "easy to follow" or something to that affect. My heart
and mind were in the right place, but I lacked the knowledge for
networking and was not a system administrator. Yet I was tasked
with setting up a network I did not know how to set up, and
despite repeated requests for help, I was denied. I should not
be held accountable for the FBI's systemic failure, especially
when the FBI encouraged me and approved me to enhance our lab. I
thought my attempt to remote into the C-20 lab did not work
because the security settings were effective. I asked for help,
even help with RDP, from nearly every unit in the FBI that had
anything to do with networking, DExT, etc., including CACHTU and
the DExT PMs. All I got in response was encouragement in what I
was doing, but no form of technical assistance.  IIIRFBI cannot
FBI did
attempted to set the RDP up in either the Fall/winter of
2022 or early 2023. The intrusion happened on Super Bowl Sunday
of 2023, and I discovered it the very next day, on Monday.
I provided the interviewing SSAs with an outline I drafted
on 02/13/2024 of the intrusion situation which I read out loud.
I signed the copy of the outline and provided it to the
interviewing SSAs to add to my statement. The following is from
my outline. This portion of my statement is written as it
appears in the physical outline:
Seamus, below is a timeline of what transpired today,
noting that we had no idea this was a potential hack until late
this afternoon. Given the potential that someone accessed our
lab to do this, and that the issue may have been with the way we
setup our network, below is also a little insight to the many
attempts we've made to get the FBI to assist in both physical
security to the lab and to help with networking:
Today's events (approx times)
-7:30am - I arrived at the office and noticed my Talino computer
had restarted.
-7:40am - I logged in to my Talino and a txt file popped up that
said in part my network has been compromised and provided an
email address to contact. This file was in the "startup" folder
so when logging in it opened automatically. I ran my computer's
anti-virus software, which was up to date and active, and it
identified one potential threat which I attempted to remove.
While this is not common, it is also not unusual given the data
we recover from 305 subject devices.
-I attempted to remove the potential threat, but my
administrative privileges had been removed, and despite many
attempts to gain access, I could not
-8:30am - I reached out to Christian Idsola at CART for help,
but he was going to be tied up for a couple of hours
-9:00am, I reached out to Talino for help and they walked me
through some steps, but nothing worked. They then advised me of
a process to take to run antivirus software against my Talinos
Operating System hard drive, which took some time but identified
the likely source of the threat, which was attributed to a
forensic program we use called Axiom. The threat was determined
to possibly be a "booby -trap" left by a subject (who is a
hacker) that was tripped when the Axiom forensic program ran
across it. After this discussion it was believed that was the
reason for the issues and we then began working on a solution,
which seemed likely to fix my issue.
-Around this time I also noticed our main server was down, but I
didn't think too much of it since we just added a new switch and
tried to configure some ports to run at different settings to
increase our bandwidth. I assumed at the time the lack of access
was a result of incorrectly applying the settings to
the "LAG" and "BOND" configurations of the switch. I was able to
see that according to the switch, the server seemed to be
connected just fine, so I spent some time troubleshooting it.
-Around 11:00am or so I was finally on instant message chat with
the makers of the server, synology, who had us conduct some
tests and they ultimately concluded that a possible issue was a
defective hard drive in the server. This was a problem sine the
server is "raided" and finding the defective hard drive was a
time-consuming and difficult task, but several of us began our
attempts.
-3:00pm - Is when Christian Idsola and Lewis LNU from CART came
over to help. After a bunch of triage and testing we could not
figure out why we could not connect to the server, since by all
accounts it was working.
-we then noticed that our other servers (NAS1 and NAS2) were
also not working properly, although we were able to access their
control windows, unlike with the Synology server. After some
digging around we noticed the folders that contain our data was
missing. Initially we thought this was due to a firmware
issue since Christian and I had dealt with that in the past and
resembled the same issue.
-Around 3:30pm or so we located the log files and began combing
through, which is when we noticed strange IP activity that took
place yesterday from two IP addresses. The activity included
combing through certain files pertaining to the Epstein
investigation. I reached out to one of the case agents to see if
they were in the office yesterday, thinking that maybe they
inadvertently changed a setting on the NAS or if they noticed
anything strange about them.
-Around 4/4:30pm we dove into the IPs and checked all of our
computers to see which had the IPs in question. One computer,
our discovery computer, matched one of them and is located in a
room next to the lab, The other IP is one we don't recognize,
but is the same address as the IPson our network, leading us to
believe it was a computer that accessed our network somehow. We
were not able to identify the computer, but it had to have
accessed our network either by being plugged into the network,
or possibly by telnetting in virtually.
-5:00pm - we realized we were hacked and discussed what we
needed to do to ensure its contained.
-5:15pm, we immediately saved our logs and shut everything down.
We disconnected the Internet and ensured anything containing a
log file was preserved.
-5:30pm - I began calling my SSA, Bob Whelp in Security, Jessica
Cardenas at CART, Amit Patel in Cyber. Physical Security
-Dec, 2021 - Moved into the 10th floor lab
-Dec, 2021 - made numerous requests for an electronic keypad
lock on the door only to be told by the locksmith there is no
funding for a lock. These requests have been made numerous times
from Dec, 2021 until a couple months ago, when the response was
to make numerous copies of the key we have to the lab
Networking/Network Security
-Since approx 2017 we have elicited help from CART and Cyber in
networking our lab, all to no avail. Some CART and Cyber folks
have come over on their good graces, but they were not network
savvy and just tried to do what they could. Some months ago (I
can look up the exact date) we again requested help from CART,
but were told their networking person was too busy to help. This
meant no one with networking experience or ability was willing
to help, so we had to figure it out on our own.
- End of the Outline -
Once I realized there had been an intrusion, I called SSA
Clarke, and Bob Welp with Security. I also called CART and
Cyber. This all occurred the same day I found out about the
intrusion.
The switch box was for the internal network. We had a
server rack and a server. We had a switch box l and we just added
a second switch box. We also had a misattributed Internet that
was connected to the OCE computers. The switch boxes were never
connected together. The Internet entered through a router that
was connected to the DExT computer and connected to the switch
box. I believed all were secure.
I believed, since we had a revolving door of CSs and CART
members, and since CACHTU was aware and having other offices
emulate the C-20 computer lab, I thought we were good.
edr we—were—i-n—t-hemiddle—ed
piloting Axiom. Ith  Light falt f different things t all w
' ,g—edge tre&
think utsidc the b x. We have a large act f hash files that we
etnt t N-MEC. A hash is a rand m ctring of text used t verify
the-4 rteejr'i+Y—oi f4ltrHtshes —frre—elst-4ilte--t—f4-rt9errri-rrtl—i-n
that they arc unique and can be eatal ged. Regarding CSAM, all
files arc "hashed", and th cc hash valucc arc distributed
th. e.14,O
these hashes, C-AM can be detected  since if a files hash
wetheeti—even—i'llswilig—ter—dtde—id-i—We—wemded—be—newkre—whet—we—hetel
with the Rhcl. 500 tcralaytcs  of ata gone
Commented (DWSJ: I think we should delete this. II
doesn't really make seine and is a bit redundant...what do
you think?
D W
2024.10.2007:1100
Commented (JR6R5p Agreed. Take it out. We can
articulate that to INSD if they ask, and am always put it had
in if necessary.
Jim Roberson
2024.10.22 13:38:CIO
ft,-4-loos-eble-be-oeeeveo-abeet-440-opeobybee-e4-obet
data, h bravos, I was told to C ogle h w to rec vcr the data. No
one—e-l-se--t-treel—terhalp—srs
The OCIO Section Chief (SC), Matt Smith, was pissed because
he found an email I had sent prior to the intrusion requesting
assistance that no one had responded to. I spoke with SC Smith
who believed this was part of systemic failures. We asked for
help, and our requests fell on deaf ears. We were always
referred to someone else. I understand I opened the C-20 lab's
RDP ports, Bit the FBI knew
FBI had told me to follow the instructions on Microsoft
website on how to open the gotta I was trying to make things
better, and moreover CACHTU and other HQ and management entities
knew what I was doing and supported me. The policies are not
easy to find, are simply not available on the FBI's site, and
often .  In fact, I have examples I can
share of attempts to access policy just to find it isn't there.
FBI HQ Criminal Investigative Division (CID) DAD Jose Perez
has since acknowledged the policy for the lab was vague or non-
existent, which is something he advised  II  Ccc trt-r'ite
of in an email that I provided to the interviewing Agents.
Additionally, a few weeks after the intrusion, DAD Perez,
with others from FBI HQ, were visiting the NYFO on un-related
matters, however there was a meeting to discuss the status of
the intrusion which I was present for. Prior to the meeting, DAD
Perez, whom I have known for years, approached me and informed
me that he knew I was not responsible for the intrusion. DAD
Perez further advised me that our lab was one of many across the
FBI that had similar configurations. DAD Perez assured me that
he knew the FBI had systemic failures, that we in the NYFO were
not alone, that I should not worry, and that FBI HQ would help
get our lab back up and running. DAD Perez also acknowledged me
for my work and stated he knew I was the kind of hard-working
Agent that the FBI needs.
I was not part of the conversations to conduct a Security
Incident Reporting System (SIRS) report.
, that if I
did not have the initiative, we would not have had our
successes, Which r Ei7i tesultedgE nanarom dr eteiammi
IMUed and their offenders being brought to_dambdidl
continued to receive praise for my work, and CACHTU has
continued to ask me to review policy before it is sent out to
the field. I took over the Group I UCO and doubled its
statistical accomplishments. I have rescued more exploited
children than anyone in the NYFO and in most of the Bureau. All
I wanted to do was to better the Bureau. I did not know how to
do everything right, but I always did the right thing and
everything I did was with good intentions. I love this job. I
was not reckless. There was no self-interest involved. I was
always trying to do the right thing. I also want to point out
that I was twice awarded the Medal of Excellence for my work,
among other accolades.
Prior to the intrusion the squad was seen as the gold
standard for child exploitation programs. Our end-of-year
ratings were consistently "gold", and we were often touted as
being amongst the highest performing squads in the Bureau. Our
squad was responsible for hundreds of child victims being
rescued and dozens of offenders being brought to justice. These
impacts are directly correlated to our DExT lab and the work we
did to enhance it.
intrusion,
Quesada
overturned
After the intrusion we were directed to completely stand
our lab down. We were directed to submit III our electronic
evidence to CART for imaging and processing. A few months into
this process, I and others on my squad compiled statistics
comparing our effectiveness before and after the intrusion. II
,-videdi
By comparison, after the
intrusion our squad suffered a 95.52% reduction in productivity.
During this time frame, my squad had 281 electronic evidence
items that needed to be imaged and processed, and all but 12 of
these devices had been taken to CART. Prior to the intrusion
Agents on the squad could begin imaging evidence they seized the
same day and were generally done imaging all their evidence
within a few days. However, the average completion time for CART
to image devices was approximately 30.5 days. This is a
staggering number and is a prime example of why the DExT program
is so important and how much of an impact the DExT lab had on my
squad's ability to swiftly and effectively conduct child
exploitation investigations.
Additionally, this summary highlighted one very unfortunate
instance in which, because of the lag time at CART and the
amount of time it took CART to image and process devices, an
offender who was a citizen of another country managed to pee'
the United States before the CART review could be completed. It
is almost certain this would not have happened if the DExT
review could have taken place in the squad's lab. However, it did
happen, and again illustrates the significance of the lab and
why the enhancements I made over the years, and the numerous
pleas I made for help, were so important.
This summary has been turned over to the interviewing
Agents, and I can make it available again if requested.
Completely separate and apart from the intrusion, but
occurring simultaneously, ApostleX is both the name of a
software company and their product. I had no previous
relationship with the company prior to a representative from
ApostleX visiting the FBI, NYF0 to provide a presentation on
their software. They were touring the United states, and
approaching law enforcement and agencies promoting
their product. They are a startup company. Apostlex reached out
to several entities within the IIIII not just the NYF0. One of
the Apostlex employees is a retired agent from NYFO named Chris
Braga. I knew Braga from NYFO as a polygrapher. In October 2021
Braga reached out to me and several other individuals in the
NYFO about ApostleX. I initially did not care much about the
product. They were pitching a preservation tool that was geared
towards CUSS. It initially did not sound relevant to what we in
C-20 were working. Braga worked it out with others in the NYFO
and set up a few information sessions for different NYFO
Divisions. Our Gang squad, C-30 had an information session. On
10/20/2021, the C-30 SSA sent out an email to my SSA who sent
the invite for the presentation to our squad. Another Agent from
my squad and I decided to attend. I attended what I believed was
a Bureau-sanctioned information session.
I want to be very clear that I had no previous relationship
whatsoever with ApostleX. They approached the FBI, and I
initially declined to even attend an information session. It
wasn't until my supervisor sent an email to our squad advising
of the information session that I decided to attend. All of this
is very provable from the many smalls and correspondences that I
have provided as well as others I can provide.
I showed up late to the NYFO ApostleX information session
and left early. The portion I did sit in on talked about how
ApostleX helped with CUSS' use of 3rd party apps. The lack of
technology available to preserve encrypted apps, or self-
communications, was a widely known issue. Self-destruct
apps cannot be recovered, which makes them very popular with
VCAC offenders. There were nol good methods to capture the
information. We voiced concerns about this for years,  WM
notably during the CACHTU •olic but there
was no fix. There is a VCAC email in which
CACHTU supervisors are participants, and there have been
hundreds of emails over the years of Agents voicing concern*2
asking questions, identifying issues etc.; which imolai'
concerns about this very issue . We did not have the ability to
go after VCAC offenders who used self-destruct apps like Wicker.
There were, and remain, no ways for us to preserve those types
of communications. When conducting chat operations, depending on
the application being used, the OCEs are unable to preserve the
chats with the offenders. Some applications allow for as short
as a one second self-destruct period, meaning that after one
second of viewing the chat, it is deleted and gone forever.
There is no forensic program in existence within the FBI to
preserve that chat. Furthermore, these self-destruct apps are
designed in such a way that if an OCE attempts to screen record
or use a screen shot to preserve a chat they either alert the
person on the other end or do not allow the screenshot to be
taken. The Bureau's answer to this problem was not really an
answer. Some responses to this problem were to use another
device to photograph the chats, which is problematic for a
variety of reasons, while other responses were for our issue to
be passed around.
I similismd that a solution would be to use my "Bbu-phone" to
take photographs of these chats. I asked what to do with the
CSAM that I would inevitably be taking photographs of, and the
INSD interviewer had no answer.
Once ApostleX came along and I heard what their product did
for CHSs, I asked if it would work for encrypted chats and self-
destruct chats. They said it would. I left the meeting and met
with ApostleX after the presentation was over. When we met. we
discussed if their technology would do what I described. They
advised they would check and get back with me. They got back to
us in early November 2021 and advised they believed they had the
ability to incorporate what I was asking for. I led the effort
with ApostleX, but my squad was involved. I spoke with SSA
Seamus Clark and ASAC John Penza (retired). We saw the benefit
of it for VCAC purposes. My bosses wanted me to explore it. It
was early on and we needed to do everything right.
I believe there were a ton of Agents, throughout the
Bureau, simultaneously engaged in similar conversations with the
ApostleX company, discussing how to purchase the tool. The
ApostleX company has been to multiple FBI offices and ...ay Laye
had conversations with Safe Streets t_tVber Division squads, etc:
ents who were
I believe the
ApostleX company pitched OTD and other ADs. At one point I even
had an Executive Assistant Director (EAD) reach out to me
personally about ApostleX.
On 11/08/2021, ApostleX requested I sign a nondisclosure
agreement. I reached out to NYFO III Tara Semos and we may have
also spoken with an Associate Division Counsel (ADC). The
decision was that we would not sign anything. We did not have
the position or authority. I told this to ApostleX, but I also
told them that we were not going to steal their intellectual
property.
People liked the ApostleX program. The consensus was that
it was not a fully developed program, but that it could be
developed.
I know there are currently programs that are used
in the FBI that were  made through Agent input, -TO
_acme tl.at created c"t1..c1„ L, Ave.A.1 th-nes-lec)  or created
e some pro.rams
d via
Axiom is a CART-approved tool that the Bureau uses. I was
asked to work with Axiom on how it was useful for us and what
changes could be made to make it better for the case Agent. With
respect to ApostleX, my understanding was that we were talking
to a company that was brought in to us to fix a problem Agents
throughout the Bureau were routinely encountering when dealing
with a CHS or an OCE, namely the undetected real time
preservation of their text chats.
We communicated with CACHTU who liked Apostick, but said
they would not commit funding.
In November 2021 ApostleX was still conceptual. It was in
the right direction but needed to be refined. They knew from a
big picture standpoint what the problems were. From a technical
standpoint the product was a home run.
Just as was the case with the lack of funding for hard
drives we discussed previously, nothing I or my squad did with
respect to ApostleX was done in a vacuum. We briefed all the way
up to the ASAC (Penza) level. He did not want us to go to the
contract
III  E2peera-1-Agent—in-Gitarle (SAGY-or the In_
in Charge (ADIC) with a problem. He wanted us to also have a
solution before we briefed the ADIC. He wanted the product to be
more developed. He did not want an on-paper solution.
At no point did anyone on my squad or I sign a contract
with ApostleX, or with anyone else for that matter._ We follia
the of the CDC, OGC, FFD, and otherin nag
retire  r.. - Mark Gerber,rm I All
several calls with and who was very
suppurative of ApostglIIMBd my involvement with it. We spent
months We were going through the Privacy Threshold Analysis
(PTA) steps to get the Bureau to sign a contract LMINIMI
IMPAIMENIIIIIIIierprocesses we were dir
also never orally or verbally agreed to a
. It was our goal to have the FBI take on
pursuing a contract, not us.
At this point ApostleX was a concept and not a product. My
chain of command had no issue with me working with ApostleX to
develop the concept into a product. We were briefing our chain
of command regularly and we even brought in our Intel
supervisors. We wanted to make the product useful, not only to
us, but to other people throughout the Bureau as well. We
brought in CHS Coordinators, people from Intel, and people from
the VC program. We did not want to think singularly about our
violation.
It is required by FBI policy that we preserve OCE sessions,
but even to this does not exist to do that. I saw
it, and still see it, almost as an entrapment for OCEs, in that
we are required by FBI policy to preserve chats, yet the FBI has
not provided us with a means to do so. i realized lust how bad
IIIIMINEMWErrEBErFBI Hommorrewormild was when someone in al
Cnccutivc Manlqcfl2n*.  told me he thought OCE chats were
automatically preserved. This blew me away as this 4t-could not
have been -further from reality and shows how bad the
disconnect is from what FBI HQ perCIANSMAIIMbiEteality  in al
fielch
We saw ApostleX as an opportunity to address this and other
concerns, follow policy, and follow the law. Current methods
include all or nothing solutions, which result in "over-
collection" and create potential First Amendment issues, in that
they may record the communications of people who are not
involved in child exploitation crimes or violating the law.
ApostleX addressed this. The support we got from the onset of
that vision was incredible.
FBI HQ knew what we were doing because I discussed with
them the problems we were having with apps like Wicker. Apostlex
was already successful with apps like were
working on Signal and a few others. Apostlex engineers figured
out how to make their program work with Signal while we were
working with them. They were going in the right direction, we
just needed to guide them towards a total solution to our actual
needs. They were already working on trying to fix the problem
OCEs were having in 2021. We just needed to work on how to
preserve apps that created secret and self-destructing chats.
The Apostlex company was never given access to FBI
information. They did not come into FBI space. 'lc would FaccTime
t+.-em e never gave them anything that belonged to the FBI. The
ApostleX program was installed on a completely standalone
computer that was connected to a misattributed Internet line. It
was never attached to any FBI networks, storage containers, or
covert networks, very specifically including the compromised
covert c-20 computer lab network that was previously discussed.
The computer with the Apostlex program was in FBI space. It
was an old computer that was going to be thrown away. It was a
covert computer. I cannot recall if we had a CS wipe the drive
of the computer or if it was provided to us with no drives and
we installed wiped drives. Either way, we had to install
operating systems. The CS was Jim Walsh. The computers were
given to us to use at our discretion
I do not remember if I told
him what the computers were going to be used for. I am not sure
if we got the computers before or after we heard the Apostlex
sales pitch. One event did not trigger the other, and it did not
matter as the computers were for covert --use anyway.
ApostleX ran on a main computer. In our case it was the one
we set up. The Apostlex database resideds on the computer and
the computer's sole function was to run the Apostlex server.
ApostleX allowed undercover phones to connect to it. Apostlex is
a server that sits on a computer and runs in the background.
There is a web-based computer interface. It only workeds from
this one particular computer which sits behind a Virtual Private
Network (VPN). If I am an OCE using the Telegram app I would
connect my Telegram account to Apostlex. There is an
authentication process. We had the company add an icon that let
the OCE know ApostleX was working in the background preserving
the chats. The ApostleX company added a small icon that showed
ApostleX was active. ApostleX's integration was chat application
specific, so we were only preserving what needed to be
preserved. It started with Telegram. Around the time we were
told to shut down, it worked with Signal. We were getting close
with What's App.
Any Telegram account we wanted to preserve would be added
to the ApostleX account. We had the ability to select what was
relevant and what was not. With appropriate authorization, we
could do an account takeover of a Subject's account. With
ApostleX there is an ability to avoid overcollection.
ApostleX was initially grabbing everything, and we would
need to check what to preserve. We wanted to make a parameter
for how long to keep information that was not checked, which
would then be purged. The accounts would be taken over through
consent or with a warrant. We were testing the capability of
Apostlex to preserve self-destructing chats. Initially, in the
testing environment, the disappearing chats were preserved on
both the sender and the receiver's telephones, which obviously
would not work for us. We worked with the company to address
that.
The ApostleX company did not have the ability to access the
data we collected from chat applications. The only data ApostleX
had access to was the telemetry. I believe OCIO looked at that
and III happy with it. SC Matt Smith from OCIO was also involved
and sent Requests for Information (RBIs) to our local ISSO, Jim
Eckel, who reviewed Apostlex, the code, and had at least one
call with them that I was a part of. I believe he also had
additional communications with them that I was not a part of. In
the end, I know that OCIO's questions were sufficiently answered.
We never went live with the Apostlex program and only
operated it in a testing environment. We did not use active
cases. We used dummy phones and OCEs chatting on the Telegram
application. We added a bunch of older OCE Telegram accounts to
test it out. accounts we used were real covert accounts.
Some of the accounts were historical. When we synced Apostlex to
chat application accounts, the entire history of the chat
application account would be pulled. The information was
exclusively stored on the local hard drive of the computer
,.....1..4—that ran Apostlex. One of the Telegram accounts I used
for testing was about 12 years old. The test accounts I used
were not involved in any chat groups that were pertinent. I am
not sure about the other folks who were testing Apostlex. I do
not believe anyone cared about the accounts we used. I believe
the historical data attached to the accounts had already been
adjudicated but it is possible some of the information may not
have been. I cannot say there was no evidentiary data put on the
standalone Apostlex computer, which is routine. Many undercover
Agents use multiple devices to access their accounts, including
both computer and cellular devices. Since the account originates
on their FBI-issued undercover phones, any ancillary devices
have no impact. I do not bclicvoam positive  having information
on the ApostleX computer was ater—no different than having it on
any other computer. I did use a historic case to demonstrate how
we could export from Apostlex for discovery purposes. The case
was not fully adjudicated at that point. I am certain the
accounts we were using had no impact on any ongoing
investigation. There was likely CSAM from the historical
accounts that was extracted and uploaded onto the Apostlex
computer when the historic accounts were synced with the
ApostleX program. The Apostlex company or anyone else could not
see it, however,_
It took a while to set the standalone ApostleX computer up.
We may have hooked the computer up in December 2021 or January
2022. We tested it intermittently for a couple of months. It
would be a long process to reconfigure things. We would
give feedback to the Apostlex engineers who monitored the
telemetry data and could see the issues with the Apostlex
program from their end as we tested it. Sometimes the fixes took
a few hours or a day or two. Once they had a fix, Apostlex
engineers would send me a document with instructions on how to
fix the issues. Any message that was sent from the company was
done through Bureau email. The instructions would be written in
the email itself or provided verbally. Though it is possible I
may have used my personal telephone to communicate with Apostlex
engineers using the video teleconferencing application, zoom, I
do not recall for sure. I do believe I may have used my FBI
laptop and possibly my OCE telephone for the Zoom calls with
ApostleX engineers, however.
Sometimes the ApostleX engineer could see me during our
Zoom calls and sometimes not, however we also sanitized the FBI
space. We would input the instructions sent by the Apostlex
company into the computer with the ApostleX program on it. There
were a couple of times I had "tech people", SA Robert Depresco,
SA Martin Nachman, and others, look at the ApostleX computer and
to review the code. I also provided the code and entire system
to the NYFO ISSO, Jim Eckle, and others from OCIO to review the
code and system. Additionally, I advised OTD and FBI HQ that
they could review it as well. It is possible I forwarded the
codes to other people to look at it.
There was no formalized process set up for updating the
standalone ApostleX computer. The updates consisted mostly of
updating a configuration file and if I needed to change code it
was due to the configuration file. I made the deliberate
decision not to let the ApostleX company remote access into the
standalone AposlteX computer. During this process, I felt like
the ApostleX company was a verified entity and I was working
with someone the Bureau invited in,
we ran the security process through OCIO and the NYFO ISSO,
Jim Eckle, and Certified Information Systems Security Officer
(CISSO) Robert Cavallo who were all satisfied with the setup.
The NYFO did not have either the ISS0 or the CISSO positions
staffed until February 2023, however. My squad SSA, branch ASAC,
CDC, and CACHTU were all aware of ApoStleX and of what we were
doing with them from the very earliest stages. There were others
in the office who knew as well. As we progressed with our
testing and development of the program, others were involved to
include III, the General Counsel himself, the Procurement
Office, Several Illi t Cpecial Agents in Charge (SACn), the NYFO
ADIC, and various other leaders in FBI management. At a minimum,
my squad SSA, branch ASAC and NYFO CDC all knew what we were
doing. OTD was involved but not at this stage. CACHTU
was aware and the Child Exploitation Operational Unit (CEOU) was
also aware. I had gone back and forth with them a bit. There was
communication on 11/08/2021.
I was passionate about this product as a force multiplier.
I can assure you there was nothing done in a
when I started working with
ApostleX on this product, my chain of command knew. My chain
gave me the thumbs -up to proceed and my guidance was to get to a
point where it was functional before we briefed the ADIC. From
the very beginning I had the approval of my SSA, ASAC and CDC. I
advised my supervisor on a regular basis on what we were doing,
why, and how, but he did not micro -manage me and did not know
every little detail that was involved.
I reached out to CACHTU to see who I needed to work with to
get it approved. They said if I could develop the tech, it would
be great. We also discussed funding, and CACHTU was not sure who
would fund ApostleX. They said that perhaps they could fund the
VCAC portion of it, but that for an enterprise -wide use funding
would have to come from OTD or elsewhere. At the request of
I have included some email correspondence to support this. I
also have hundreds of pages of documents that cover nearly
everything that involved ApostleX, from the first instance I
ever heard of them through the PTAs, the correspondences with
CACHTU, CDC, OGC, FBI ®£x::::W.icc , etc. These
documents show that everything I did with ApostleX was above
board, and any notion to the contrary is unfounded.
As I mentioned previously, in April or May 2022, I went to
an IACIS conference and the Apostlex program was working. Leslie
Adamczyk, who was a former squad mate and a VCAC PM, was also in
attendance. Leslie already knew about ApsotleX since we were
good friends, and I was her former training Agent when she was
in the NYFO. We spoke regularly and she knew about ApsotleX, but
at this conference I showed her some  c-sf t. c-eenshots of
it. Leslie was amazed -‘:.t-and thought the greater FBI needed to
have this, and she said  4-t-e-lei-her-alaeut-t-he-preetuet-r&he-era444
it needed to be briefed at the Program Coordinators (PCOR)
conference,  and that when she got back to CACHTU after the
conference, she would talk to the other PMs to see about adding
me to the list of presenters. —That was the perfect venue since
it would be attended by VCAC PCORs from every Field Office. I
was added to the list of presenters. I had conversations with
the PMs and UC who the conference, and I was added to
the agenda. I worked on a presentation and showed it to SSA
Adamczyk. She loved it. SSA Adamczyk was a PM for CACHTU at the
time and was coordinating with the person who put the conference
together. I submitted a summary of what ApostleX was and what I
was presenting on. I submitted a draft of my presentation prior
to the conference. SSA Clarke was present during my
presentation.
The PCOR conference presentation went well. There were
numerous questions' and I had people who called me to talk more
about it later. I heard from an Agent in Las Vegas whose SSA,
Matt Schaeffer, was on an 18-month TDY to CACHTU as an Assistant
Section Chief (ASC)• ASC Schaeffer did not like the ApostleX
program. The feedback was all positive except what I heard
second-hand from ASC Schaeffer. During my presentation I made it
clear ApostleX was technology that we were developing but that
we did not have yet. If I made comments during the presentation
about not following policy in my work with the ApostleX company,
it was done as a joke. I was briefing a room full of supervisors
as well as CACHTU about a program designed to help III their
Agents. In no way, shape, or form did I ever say, in any serious
fashion, that I violated policy and/or that I paid anything for
Apostlex. There is a possibility that I may have made jokes
about paying the ApostleX company a dollar for the program, but
I did not pay them a dollar, nor any amount for that matter.
That would have obviously been beyond my authority as a GS-13
case Agent. At some point early on there may have been a
conversation with ApostleX about if we should pay the company a
dollar. We were concerned that we were using a product for free.
I took the question to Legal or maybe even my bosses. The
decision was made not to pay them. I remember this conversation
occurring, but I do not recall the details since no monetary
exchange ever took place. I began hearing rumors in March or
April of 2023 about things I said during my ApostleX
presentation at the VCAC PCOR conference being taken out of
context. There was never a contract between the FBI and
Apostlex, either orally or in writing, and if there had been it
would have been through approved channels and not with me.
During the PCOR conference, Apostlex was still soliciting
the FBI about their product. Around that time, ASAC Penza
retired and at some point, Spencer Horn became ASAC. The
ApostleX program was not active; there was no contract, and my
chain of command was aware of what I was doing. The guidance to
get the concept to a place where it was a better solution before
it was briefed higher up the chain of command continued after
ASAC Penza retired and ASAC Horn came in. The SAC was eventually
briefed.
A few days after the VCAC PCOR conference I heard from
Joanna Pasquarelli who is an
Ccncral Att rncy (Ct) for OGC. `GA—Pasquarelli attended the
VCAC PCOR conference and saw my presentation. IIILGA—Pas  quarelli
informed me we needed to stop testing Apostlex immediately. She
did not say we needed to stop working with the Apostlex company,
but to shut down the computer with the ApostleX program. We did
so immediately. She also informed me we needed a PTA
She also had concerns
about the Fair Act and the procurement process in relation to
how we worked with the company. We discussed the laws about
companies bidding on the chance to work with the FBI on a
product as opposed to a single source product. This process
eventually included a lot of people from OGC. Kfter sending Is
@A—Pasquarelli my first draft of the PTA, she responded with,
among other things, "I read through your draft PTA and you did
an excellawiES
I spoke with CDC Semos about my conversation with `GA
Pasquarelli. I was sent a "pony" of the PTA which I filled out
and returned. III_GA—Pasquarelli was very pleased with what I
turned in. Both she and CDC Semos mentioned orally and over
email how pleased they were with the work I had done, and both
expressed their eagerness to help. Pasquarelli, CDC
Semos, and later numerous others including people in FBI
management all reviewed the entire process I had been engaged in
and not a single person expressed concern. To the contrary, all
were eager to be involved in the project and to help get the
needed approvals to develop and use ApostleX. There were a lot
of email communications and Microsoft Teams calls. We had to
IIII some comparisons to see if there were other companies that
offered products IIII Apostlex.
I had spoken with OTD about the issues OCEs were having
capturing chats on encrypted applications and capturing
disappearing chats in the past. We had tried, unsuccessfully, to
get OTD involved prior to this process. After OGC was involved,
they required us to check with OTD on what they had to address
the issue, or if they could come up with a solution in house. We
also asked if OTD would work with the ApostleX company to
develop the ApostleX product. We learned there was a product
called Eagle Claw available which I believe is so bad that it
should be taken off the approved list of tools to use. There was
only one guy at the time working on Eagle Claw, and he said what
I described of Apostlex was a homerun. Eagle Claw had a lot of
limitations. We spoke with a lot of people about existing
programs and external products as part of the procurement
process. Nothing could do what ApostleX could do. ilhave and can
provide extrrde  other
programs, inPriding test ials, siliel-by-elarENEParisons, and
more. Some of these products were created by the HQ desk tor
Safe-Streets, where UC Matthew Cobo was overseeing theii
attempts to use ApostleX.I
I also know that even as of October 2022, CACHTU
supervisors, including ASC Schaeffer and then SC Jose Perez,
were aware of Apostlex. I know this because I have email
communications between them and PMs at CACHTU who were helping
to try and arrange a meeting about ApostleX. Never had there
been any issues or reservations expressed to me or to the PMs
helping to facilitate our meetings.
I continued to work through my chain of command, CACHTU,
OGC, Safe Streets, OCIO, NYFO ISSO, Finance and Facilities
Division (FFD), OTD and various units within OTD. We were moving
along up and through the holidays of 2022. There were a lot of
revisions to the PTA. We even worked through an emergency in
which the Boston Field Office had a hands-on offender, and they
needed to preserve their chat information. Despite initially
receiving support, emergency use authority was never granted in
that case. I worked with OGC GA Christopher Dearing on PTA
revisions. I was delayed getting back to him due to a trial.
Once I got back to him, the cyber intrusion of the C-20 computer
lab happened.
The standalone computer containing the Apostlex program had
been turned off in our testing environment since July 2022,
roughly six months before the C-20 computer lab intrusion took
place. We were not using it at all. I am not sure if it was even
plugged in. I heard there was a rumor that some people believed
ApostleX had to do with the C-20 lab computer intrusion. I
received an email from CDC Semos theta
Apostlex was going to be shut down due to the belief it was
involved in the intrusion. This was completely untrue, of
course, as two completely separate networks were involved, and
the Apostlex network was not even running when the C-20 computer
lab intrusion took place. ApostleX had nothing whatsoever to do
with the intrusion. I believe CDC Semos cleared this rumor up
with OGC. My chain of command wanted ApostleX to continue to
move forward because they saw value in it. Before and after the
intrusion I had been tasked with providing briefings and
information to upper management including SAC Michael Brodack,
SAC Robert Kissane, and ADIC Michael Driscoll. None were
deterred by the intrusion and knew one had nothing to do with
the other. These executives, along with the NYFO CDC, Tara
Semos, and ADC Dane Christensen, were supportive of the pursuit
of ApostleX and had no issue with anything I or anyone else had
done. We saw that NYFO Criminal Division and CACHTU were being a
roadblock. We had a meeting with SAC Brodack prior to the C-20
lab intrusion to get the ADIC involved in the ApostleX project
to push the needle forward. We wanted to be able to pilot the
program. Some of the questions from OGC asked who was supporting
the ApostleX project. The intrusion happened before a formal
briefing could take place, however.
There was a meeting about ApostleX with NYFO CT Division
SAC Robert Nissans in August 2023. CDC Semos, ASAC Horn, the
ISSO, SSA of the Tech squad, Eddie Pennetta, SA Depresco, and SA
Nachman. The meeting was about trying to use a Domestic
Terrorism (DT) case as a pilot case for ApostleX. There were
still conversations about ApostleX taking place until I was
of this INSD internal investigation.
I was working with CTD's International Terrorism Operations
Section (ITOS) and some high-tech unit. They were asking for
information to push up to EAD Larissa Knapp, who reached out to
me personally. I had my ASAC respond to her on my behalf.
After the C-20 lab intrusion, CACHTU wanted nothing to do
with ApostleX. NYFO wanted to see if they could do something
with ApostleX on their own. They also got CT involved to see if
they could push ApostleX through their networks. There were
conference calls with the ApostleX company to field questions.
Representatives from the ApostleX company may have also gone to
Huntsville, Alabama and spoken with the AD of OTD.
There was confusion on getting the Authority to Operate
(ATO) . It was a situation. We did not know which
one we needed first, the ATO or the PTA. We were working on the
ATO process as well.
CACHTU funded the equipment for the C-20 lab. I believe
Group I UCOS were exempt from needing an ATO. ASAC Horn was
trying to see if we could get approval to use Apostlex under the
Group I because he believed we would not need an ATO. I believe
this was discussed with CDC Semos, because I was present when
they argued about it. When I was putting together the
information for the C-20 lab, I did not know about an ATO
requirement. I later found out we did not need an ATO for covert
purchases. I think they may have tried to change that after -the-
fact.
There was a financial threshold for the lab purchases. This
was approved by Jack Cordes in OGC. It outlined what was needed
for the C-20 lab and how we were going to use the equipment. I
believe everything that needed an F number received one.
No one ever told me of the requirement for an ATO for the
C-20 lab. It came up after ASAC Horn and CDC Semos had their
discussions. TEIVIIIIIPMFRAMMEWITIMInif anyVilfrollfritnfla
have been up to one of the dozen or so entities overseeing o
Group- I renewals whose job it is to know what is and what il
not required from an administrative perspea
Some of the ApostleX company sits in Ireland and some in
the United States (US). They are registered in the US to receive
government contracts.
Our squad's end-of-year review for fiscal year 2022
mentioned ApostleX as one of the reasons to give us a "gold"
rating. However, Apostlex was also referenced as the reason for
a lower program rating for fiscal year 2023. CACHTU initially
rated our squad "gold", the highest rating, but DD Dcputy
Paul Abbate later changed our rating to "red", the worst
rating, and included the reference to Apostlex and its direct
involvement in the intrusion as the reason, which, as discussed
previously in greater detail, is categorically false and both
physically and digitally 4-impes4b4eimpossible. Ely ASAC attempted
to fight this false narrative but was told it could not be
changed.
I never understood that just working with ApostleX in
general could cause procurement issues, and even to this day as
much as I have learned from all of this, I know that my
involvement did not and would not cause procurement issues. I
have learned that nothing I did was improper and that many
programs used by the FBI originate in much the same manner. OGC
was trying to figure out how to make it work.
As mentioned previously, I think it is also important to
note that WED did not have an ISSO or a CISSO when the C-20 lab
was set up.
Under no circumstances whatsoever did I exceed my authority
by contracting an outside company. There was no contract. My
chain of command, including our CDC and later OGC, to include
the General Counsel himself, knew I was speaking with Apostlex
and creating a solution to a problem. I c..1,,,-.1-ngaged in the
Commented (CT7J: I did not highlight Mix. SSA Pnce did
C20 TechTeam
2024.10.11 13:19:00
Commented PR8R71: OK. Just remove the highlighting
that Weird.
Jun Roberson
2024.10.17 09:19:00
PTA process as instructed, working for months with many FBI
lawyers, procurement officers, and management, all ensuring our
pursuit of this much-needed program was done correctly. Any
notion that I violated any policy, rule, or regulation is
categorically false.
For perspective, ApostleX first came to the NYFO in October
2D21, and despite the vast amount of people, entities, and
oversight my work on ApostleX received, not once had I been
advised anything I did was inappropriate until I received notice
of this inquiry in March 2024. Among the many documents and
correspondences I have provided INSD include many with OGC, CDC,
and CACHTU. Specific to CACHTU, I know that ASC Schaeffer did
not like ApostleX, and after the intrusion he used it as an
excuse to punish me. ASC Schaeffer banned me from being an
instructor at the VCAC OCE course, of which I am a founding
instructor. ASC Schaeffer accused me of lying when I presented
on ApostleX at the PCOR conference. ASC Schaeffer stated that he
believed I was supposed to present at the PCOR conference on a
case update, but that at the last minute I switched my
presentations to present on ApeostleX and that no one in CACHTU
was aware. ASC Schaeffer says he believed this, but it was
dcspitc the months after the PCOR conference before he would
eventually make this accusation. Additionally, after the PCOR
conference, in approximately October 2022, I was an instructor
at a VCAC OCE training and even discussed ApostleX. In advance
of  this teeie4eltraining, I attempted to secure a meeting with
then SC Jose Perez to discuss ApostleX since I was going to be
at HQ for the training. I have correspondence between CACHTU
supervisors/PMs, some of which what include include ASC
Schaeffer, about thSsmy proposed meeting with SC Perez, and at
no time was this "lie" ever mentioned. After ASC Schaeffer
accused me of this lie, I immediately sent him proof that the
allegation was false. ASC Schaeffer responded with
acknowledgment that I was in fact telling the truth]
h wcvcrhowever, he suspended me from the training anAny
communications with ASC Schaeffer e.e as fellews.have been
provided to INSD and additional communications are available
upon request.
As I repeatedly stated, I attempted to solicit help from
every appropriate entity, to include the NYFO "Security
Officer", Robert Help. However, until just weeks before the
intrusion this position was only temporarily staffed, and the
ISSO and CISSO positions were not staffed at all. I have
provided a document to the interviewing Agents that originated
from former NYFO SAC Nicholas Bouchears in which he outlines the
issue of not having these positions filled and the steps he took
to fill them. If these positions had been filled there is little
doubt that I would have received the assistance I needed to
ensure our network was secure. However, these positions were not
filled, and I was nevertheless encouraged to enhance our lab by
all levels of management and received the necessary approvals
along the way. I should not be punished for failures in
hindsight that were out of my control. While I take
responsibility for er14—efall • my actions, I am confident that
nothing I did was without approval' and everything was done in
the interest of improvement.
Lastly, it should be noted that, since the intrusion, my
squad mates and I have been referenced as having been "System
Administrators", which we absolutely are not. The INSD report
identifies me, and others on my squad, as having been System
Administrators despite the fact we were not, have never been
trained in system administration, and were never qualified to be
system administrators. Despite myself and my chain of command
bringing this to the attention of INSD we continued to be
referred to in this manner. This is a critical fact since I
cannot, nor can my squad mates, be held to the same standard of
knowledge as an actual system administrator. The title implies a
level of knowledge, and thus a level of responsibility, that I
did not and do not possess. None of us on my squad do or ever
have.
In my defense I possess hundreds, if not thousands, of
pages of supporting documentation. I have provided a large
number of these documents to the interviewing Agents and am
happy to provide more if requested.  This includes, but is not
limited to, the NYFO's opposition to the post-intrusion INSD
findings, many of which are provable as categorically false and
misleading.

• •
a
•oH a
an
to
I am willing to voluntarily take a polygraph examination
concerning the truthfulness of the information contained in this
signed, sworn statement. I have no other pertinent information
regarding the aforementioned allegations. I have been advised
that I should submit any additional information of which I may
become aware, regarding this inquiry, to the Internal Affairs
Section (IAS)/Inspection Division (INSD) or to the Office of
Professional Responsibility (OPR).
I have been given the opportunity to review this statement
and make any changes prior to signing it.
I was instructed on 01/26/2024 not to discuss this matter
with anyone other than the person(s) conducting this interview,
representatives from IAS/INSD, Security Division - Clearance
Referral Evaluations Unit, OPR, the FBI Ombudsman, and/or an FBI
Employee Assistance Program (EAP) Counselor. I have been told
that should I decide to discuss this matter with anyone else, I
must first obtain authorization from the interviewer(s).
I have read this statement, consisting of this and 36 other
pages and it is true and correct.
Aaron E. Spivack
Sworn to and subscribed before me on the Xnd day of
September, 2024, in New York, NY.
Dannie W. Price, Jr.
Witness:
witness
EFTA01242527 (Jmail)
 [misc] 3,000 pages of Epstein phone logs, call to Scott Shay at Hyperion Partners, see link for call counts [michelcrypt4d4mus.github]
(inferred timestamp: 2024-03-01 12:26:00)
3,000 pages of Epstein phone logs, call to Scott Shay at Hyperion Partners, see link for call counts
╔════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Anthony Cuti [finance] accountant at Rothstein Kass 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01684300 (Jmail)
 [crypto] FBI evidence list w/tip about Howard Lutnick, Cantor Fitzgerald, and BGC from an employee who had already blown the whistle successfully
(inferred date: 2024-08-01)
Serial Repc SOD-NY-3027571
Serial # Date Type Author Title Synopsis
M ######## FD-302 U) Intervi: (U) On August 01, 2024, ANALEA O'LEARY (A.l
701 #4444444
########
Crisis Intak
FD-71A

U) On 09/
M U Potentia U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 08-28-:
699 ####$##$# Crisis Intak U//FOUO
698 ########
########
Letter Inc°
Crisis Intak

(U) Corres . (U) Correspondence to Director Wray, AG Me
697 (U)
(U//FOUO
On OS/
696 ######## FD-302 (U//FOUO) ROBERT NEUMANN, Chief, Univer
695 ######## FD-1057 (U) Senten (U) To document the sentencing of Ghislaine
694 ########
########
Collectedlt
Crisis Intak
(U)
(U)
(U)
(U)
Deriva . (U) Derivative evidence created
693 On 06/
Q ######## FD-1057 Mail R = (U) An envelope containing a letter from the i
¢_9j, ######## FD-1057 FD1 i i . (U) The original chain of custody for 50D-NY-
690 UMW Collectedlt (U) Deriva . (U) Derivative evidence created
689 ######## Collectedlt (U)
(U)
(U)
(U)
Deriva . (U) Derivative evidence created
688 ######## Crisis Intak On 05/
687 ######## FD-302 Phon
686 #######4 FD-1057 Defen (U) Notes received from Defense after goverr
685 ########
########
IPTacticallr
FD-1023
(U//FOUO)
(5)
(U//FOUO) This Tactical Intelligence Report (1
e S-0010 (5) Former FB BOD member's possible links w
02 ######## FD-1057 (U) Convi (U) To document the conviction of Ghislaine I
682 #4444444 LEIMFDR (U//REL T 4 I I I
681 ######## FDR (U) Reque •
Teleph

(U) Request to obtain information regarding t
(U) Request NY ECU to transfer evidence to D
cag_Q ######## FD-302 (U)
679 ########
NUM=
FD-302
FD-1057
(U)
(U)
Teleph
Reque
Intervi
On 11/
677 ########
########
FD-302
Crisis Intak
(U)

(U) 676
ca ########
########
Crisis Intak
FD-302
(U)
(U)
On 11/
Intervi
U) On 11/
U) intervi
U) Phone
e
673 ########
Crisis Intak
FD-302

(U) To request
ontacted De • n
the reimbursement of trial wit
e
671 ######## FD-302
670 ######## FD-302
U//FOUO

U) Call wi
U) Reimb
U) Intervi
669 ########
########
FD-794
FD-302 668
a  #4444444 FD-71A U//FOUO DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON
666 ######## Collectedlt
U//FOUO

U) Collect
U) Materi
(U) Collect evidence
(U) On Friday 10/8/202 as i 665 ######## FD-302
FD-71A
FD-71A
e ######## U//FOUO DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON
Q l #4444444 U NTOC20 U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 10-08-:
662 ######## FD-71A U//FOUO U//FOUO DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON
661 ######## FD-71A U USPS M U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 10-08-:
660 ######## FD-71A U NTOC20 U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 10-08-:
659 ######## FD-71A U Email re: U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 10-08-:
658 ritffrit#888 FD-71A
657 rIttirttititfl FD-1057
fiu ######## FD-1057
55 ######## FD-71A
654,####0#110 FD-1057
02 ######## FD-302
##0#0##0 FD-302
######## FD-302
650 8181188818 FD-302
####1111## FD-302
MINIM FD-302
####0#######0###FD-302
646 ####0110# FD-302
UMW* FD-302
######## Crisis Intak
643 ######## FD-302
642 NNW* FD-302
1111######1111######FD-302
tiNtffitilt8 FD-302
######## FD-302
638 ######## FD-302
4.3_€
88888888 FD-302
######## FD-302
*WM FD-302
UMW, FD-302
000#0###000#0###FD-1057
632 ######## FD-302
63.1 8181188818 FD-302
630 ######## FD-302
629 MINIM FD-302
M MUM FD-302
627 stattatusatt FD-302
626 #01111011110 FD-302
fin
814811$1.188 Crisis Intak
§2Q
#######0#######0
1818#18,88
tffiniffittlt
tilt#11#81t8
888#0ti#0
FD-302
FD-302
FD-302
Crisis Intak
OTHER
88#88888 FD-302
#01111111100 FD-302
fill
######## Crisis Intak
Matt FD-1057
MIN IUM FD-1057
Crisis Intak 614
#11####lt0
#lt###tilt0 FD-302
612 Iffffriffrifitt. FD-1057
U//FOUO U//FOUO DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED O

U) Reimb (U) To request the reimbursement of trial wit
U) Fed-Ex (U) Fed-Ex Delivery Confirmation for items sh
U Victim o U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 10-07

U) Reque (U) Request Transfer of Evidence Item 1B139
U) Intervi
U) Meetin
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi

U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Proffer (U) LESLEY GROFF, date of birth (DOB)
U) Service (U) On Tuesday, September 21, 2021, writer

U) On 9/2
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Proffer
U) Intervi
U) Intervi

U) Intervi
U) Reque
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) On 9/9

U) GWEN
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U)
(U) Request to serve three trial subpoenas
hereto referred to as
as interviewed ove
as interviewed o
On 08/
U)Docum (U) Documentation of Services by VS

U) TRIAL (U) On 07/30/2021
U) Trial S (U) On Wednesday, July 28, 2021,
U) On 7/2
U) Locate (U) To locate and serve

U) Missou (U) Missouri birth record identified and obta
U) On 07/
U) Device (U) On February 14, 2020, in response to MD

(U) Reque • (U) Background of Epstein/Maxwell case wit
served
611 411444444 EvidenceE U) Collect
U//FOUO
(U) Collection of Evidence,
(U//FOUO) At the request
Austin, TX
610 44444444
FD-302
Crisis [nu
of
gia U) On 06/
44444444 Crisis Inta U) On 6/1
607 4441144114 FD-1057 U) lA Lab (U) 1A Lab Report Material Upload
4444$1.144 FD-71A U Implied 1U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 05-19
fg)1 MOWN FD-302 U) Intervi
604 44444444 FD-302 U) Intervi
603 44444444 FD-302 U) Introd
602 44444444 LABRPT U) 2021-0I(U) 2021-00585-2 Questioned Documents
601 444410144 FD-302 U) Intervie (U) District Judge (retired),
600 ######## FD-1057 U) Reques (U) Request item be picked up from victim/w
599 ######## LHMFDR U//REL TO
52.4 ######## FDR U) Reques (U) Request to obtain inbound and outbound
5.91 ######## OTHER U) Docum (U) Documentation of Services b
596 44444444 FD-302 U) Intervi
595 44444444 FD-71A U NTOC20: U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 04-23
44444444 LHMFDR tll/REL TO
593 Nana FD-302 U) SIMON
592 44444444 FDR U) Reques (U) Request to obtain inbound and outbound
591 44444444 Crisis Inta U) On 03/
5Z2 44444444 Crisis Inta U) On 3/2
5.6.2 44444444 Crisis Inta U) On 03/
588 444114444 FD-302 U) Intervi (U) date of bi
587 44444444 Crisis Inta U) On 03/
51LE 44444444 FD-302 U) Intervi
585 44444444 FD-302 U) Intervi
584 44444444 FD-302 U) Intervi
583 ######## FD-302 U) Intervi
582 4441/4444 FD-302 U) Virtua ate of birth (DOB
44444444 FD-302 U) Teleph date of birth (DOB
5A) Hammitt FD-302 U) Intervi
579 M44444 FD-302 U) Intervie
21 1$4411$11144 FD-302 U) Introd u as given an introdu
577 WNW FD-302 U) Introd as given an introductory m
576 441$44444 FD-302 U) Inform; (U) On or about 1/28/21, Attorney
575 44444444 FD-1121 U) Reques (U) The Laboratory Division is requested to p
574 4441/4444 FD-302 U) Phone (U) On or about January 13, 2021,
21 44444444 FD-302 (U) Intervie date of birth (DOB)
572 ######## FD-302 (U) Intervie date of birth
571 444444194 FD-302 (U) Intervie was interviewed ove
22 ######## FD-302 U) Intervi
5_61 444114444 FD-302 (U)Intervi
568 MOWN FD-302 U) Intervie
567 ######## FD-302 U) Proffer
566 44444444 FD-302 (U) Intervie (U) LARRY VISOSKI (VISOSKI), was interviewe
565 UMW* FD-302 U) Intervi
564 flgaliftrIgg FD-302
563 agarfitifftg FD-302
5§2 ggagriggg LHMFDR
§1. ########
560 MINNUN
FD-302
Collectedlt
5a9 ########
558 Ittfflittrtfiffi
FDR
FD-1023
557 fltiflattflit
556 flggifffiffta
FD-302
FD-302
555 ######## FD-302
554 flirititifftflfl FD-302
553 flitrUfitfirtfi Collectedlt
552 Ifififirtrififir FD-302
511, ##M### FD-302
Q ######## FD-302
549 ########
548 tattitttfirtt# FD-302
FD-302
547 ######## FD-302
inttrattrtatt FD-302
ffil#44444 FD-302
Crisis Intak 544
afraflifintt.
#####N*
Iffigrfififitg
Iffigififttlfg
FD-302
OTHER
FD-302
Crisis Intak 540 g*fftgrfrifitt
538 ######## FD-1023
gligiffittrtg FD-1057
537 flaitifffitifiti Crisis Intak
5ttl  NUMMI
533 ###IIIMII#
532 tItt######
Crisis Intak
FD-794
FD-1057
FD-794
FD-1023
1$14$111#411W I Crisis Intak
######## Crisis Intak
######## Crisis Intak
figgiffigati Crisis Intak
527 IFINNIFUM FD-1057
NUNN LHMFDR
NUMMI FDR
#444#44# FD-302
aagaltatta Court
#gafffigati Court
521 ######## Court
520 UMW, Court
519 ittiflflirtfitit Court
MMUS* I Court 518

U) Intervie
U) Intervie
U//RE L TO
U//FOLIO) (U//FOUO) A digital review of evidence proce
U//FOUO) (U//FOUO) Highly confidential responsive ma

U) Reques (U) Request for foreign assistance from LEGA'
U) 5-0009 (U) Chabad's involvement in U.S. Presidential

(U) Intervie
(U) Call rec
U) Intervie
U) Intervi
(U) Ten yea (U) Ten yearbooks received from FBI West Pa

(U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intery
U) Intery
U) Intery
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) On 12/
U) Intervi

(U) Victim  (U) To document victim outreach support eff
(U) Intervie (U) date of birth
U) On 11/(
S//NF)

5) 5-00099 (5) More information on
U) On 11/
U) On 10/
U) Fund R (U) To document a request for a reimbursem

U) Fund R (U) To document two serials associated with
U) Fund R (U) To document a request for a reimbursem

U) S-0009 (U) Foreign influence on U.S. officials by Israe
U) On 10/
U) On 10/
U) On 10/
U) On 10/
U) Intern (U) To request country clearance and travel a
U//REL T

U) Notifl
U) Intervi
U) Cell Ph
U) Cell Ph (U) On or about June 29, 2020, a wa
U) Search
U) Search
U) Search

U) Search
elephone num
as interviewed via vide
(U) <di
SO (S//NF) SO-18 Jeffery Epstein Special.
(U) Notification and concurrence to Legat Lo
ate of birth

(U) On or about June 29, 2020, a wa
(U) On or about September 12, 2019, a searc
(U) On or about September 12, 2019, a searc

(U) On or about July 15, 2019, a search warra
(U) On July 7, 2019, a search warrant was sw
517 littlfifiteHtfi Court (U) Search (U) On July 6, 2019, a search warrant was sw.
516 uttifitiMette
########

(U) On 09/
ik (U) On 09/1
14 ######## OTHER
FD-302
FD-302
(U) Docum (U) Documentation of Services by
513 ######## (U) Intervie
02 ######## (U) Intervi
511 ######## FD-302 (U) Intervie

(U) On 08/ 510 ########
########
########
Crisis Inta
Crisis Inta
Crisis Intl
509 (U) On 08/
508 (U) On 08/
507 MUM= Collected) (U) SOD-NY (U) SOD-NY-3027571
506 ######## Crisis Inta (U) On 08/
505 ########
########
Crisis Inta
Crisis Inta

(U) On 08/
50 (U) On 08/
5.O ######## Crisis Inta
OTHER
(U) Date St
502 SMOKNett (U) Docum (U) To document the provision of victim servi
501 ######## Crisis Intl
FD-302
FD-302

(U) On 08/
500 ######## (U) Intervi:
(U) Intervi:
(U) Federa
as interviewed over SKY 499 ########
498 ######## FD-1057 (U) To document FGJS service to
497 ########
########
Crisis Intl i
FD-302

(U) On 08/
12¢ (U) Intervie
191 ########
KIIIMSMIM
FD-302
LHMFDR
(U) Intervie
(LWREL TO 494
493 ########
########
FD-302
Crisis Inta

(U) Attem .
(U) On 08/
(U) Contact wit as atm
19_z
491 ######## Crisis Inta (U) On 08/i
490 ######## FDR (U) Notifica (U) Notification to Legat London to conduct L
489 ########
KIMINMIN
tfft$SNKKU
########
########
ttetKaMM
ifittUtniM
Crisis inta
FD-302
E=
El=
rani=
Collected)
FD-1057

(U) On 08/
(U//FOU0)
(U) On 08/
(U) On 08/
(U) On 08/
488 (U//FOUO) On July 27, 2020, Starla Waggner,
..IE
OS (U) Aerial S (U) Aerial Surveillance
483 (U) Grand j (U) To document grand jury subpoena service
482 ########
########
Crisis Inta
Crisis Inta

(U) On 07/
481 (U) On 07/I
480 teNtMffiN Crisis Inta (U) On 07/
4/2 ######## Crisis Inta
FD-1057
FD-1057
FD-1057
Crisis Inta .

(U) On 07/
(U) Lead Re (U) Request assistance in serving grand jury si 478 ########
######## 477 (U) Lead Re

(U) Lead Re
(U) Request assistance in serving grand
(U) Request assistance in serving grand
jury si
jury si gli ########
ita ######## (U) Date St
474 ######## Crisis Inta (U) On 07/
473 ######## FD-1023 (U) S-00095 (U) CHS provided information about Jeffrey EI
472 ######## Crisis inta (U) On 07/
471 ######## Crisis [nth (U) On 07/ I I
470 murmur Crisis Intak U) On 07/
469 ######## Crisis Intak U) On 07/
468 'MUNN* FD-302 U//FOUO)

U) Arrest 467 ######## FD-302 (U) Pursuant to an arrest warrant issued in th
466 lltMattlt8 Crisis Intak U) On 07/

U) On 07/
U) On 07/
U) NTOC21
4g 4444410/1* Crisis Intak
464 88#88#118 Crisis Intak
463 0011##### Crisis Intak
462 88811M8 Crisis Intak U//FOUO)

U) On 07/ 461 Int it tiff 88# Crisis Intak
460 88 8# tiff Crisis Intak U) (U) On
459 ####000# FD-1023 U)  S-00011(U)

U) On 07/
U) Informs
U//FOUO)
CHS report on female who went to Jeffrey
458 ######00 Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
42 ########
########
455 MIMI** FD-1057 U//FOU 0) (U//FOUO) Contacts o
454 IffitHifffiN Crisis Intak U) On 07/
453 OFD -712 U) Pen Rei (U) To document the pen register on Ghisla
452 #8888#88 FD-712 U) Pen Re (U) To document the renewal of a pen registe
451 88888888 OTHER U) Docum (U) To document victim services I-
450 88888888 FD-1057 U//FOUO) (U//FOU0) UNUB calling Bradford (NH) Police
442 BIBBNIBB
########
FD-302
FD-1057
U//FOUO)
44a U) Ghislair (U) Mail cover of Ghislaine Maxwell, using 30:
447 m FD-712 U) Pen Rei (U) To document the renewal of a pen registe
446 ######## Crisis Intak U) On 07/I
ME #8 fit $ I It Crisis Intak U) On 07/
444 ##ti###tiff Crisis Intak U) NTOC21
443 ######tiff Crisis Intak U) On 07/:
442 88 ft 88 888 Crisis Intak U) On 07/I
441 NUNN Crisis Intak U) On 07/
4_42 88888888 Crisis Intak U) On 07/
42 NUNN Crisis Intak U) On 07/
438 #####1111# Crisis Intak U) (U)On
It ft St It $ fftlf Crisis Intak U) On 07/
436 fifitt#100/8 FD-794 U) Fund R (U) To document a request for a reimbursemi
435 tifft if if tit ft FD-712 U) Pen Reg

U) On 07/I
(U) To document the pen register on Ghisla
434 t ISIS ill I * Crisis Intak
433 Int t 1 f I 1N Crisis Intak U) On 07
Ail 88 8118 888 Crisis Intak U) On 07/I
431 88888888 Crisis Intak U) On 07/i
430 NUNN Crisis Intak U) On 07/i
422 88888888 Crisis Intak U) On 07/i
428 ft *OW ft( ft, FD-302 U//FOLIO) (U//FOLIO) On June 25 2020 Special AgentII
427 SW (NUN
_
Crisis Intak U) On 07/
426 #11####tiff
t tItt till tilt
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

U) On 07/
425 U) On 07/i
424 88 ft Stitt* Crisis Intak U) On 07/
423 ######## Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak 422
ar Q
########
MUUMUU
########
########
########
########
########
########
#########
########
########
MINIUM*.
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
FD-302
Crisis Intak
UMOU0

U) On 07/
U) On 07/ .
(U) On 07/
(U) NTOC2(
(U) On 07/
(U//FOLIO)
(U) NTOC2(
(U) On 07/I
U) (U)On
(U) On 07/l
U//FOUO) (U//FOLIO)

(U) NTOC2(
(U) On 06/:
U) On 06/
U) FD1 (U) USPS Criminal Investigation Mail Cover Re
U) Inform (U) On or about July 17, 2019, Agents met MI

U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) FD1
U) 50D-N (U) SOD-NY-3027571
U) On 03/
U) Intery
(U) Intervie (U) DAVID RODGERS,

(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie

(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Intervie
(U) Proffer
(U) Proffer
(U) Intervie
(U) SOD-NY (U) SOD-NY-3027571

(U) Pass in
U) Intervi
U) Share I (U) Share information relating to interview o
U) interviel
(U) Intervie

(U) Intervi
4Q
########
########
WINNOW
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
FD-1064
405 ######## FD-302
404 ######## FD-302
Itg###### FD-302
RiftMind FD-1064
######## Collectedlt
######## Crisis Intak
3.22
######## FD-302
Nana FD-302
itiffifiddRd FD-302
######## FD-302
######## FD-302
394 ######## FD-302
######## FD-302
Rintrffirtdd FD-302
M##### FD-302
390 muumuu FD-302
3-91.
389 ######## FD-302
######## FD-302
WNW FD-302
######## FD-302
######## FD-302
NNW* FD-302
2.22
######Ifit FD-302
######## FD-302
######## Collectedit
2.6..Q
######## LH MFDR
FD-302
######## FDR
######## FD-302
######## FD-302
######## FD-302

(U) REQUEST FOR MAIL COVER - CRIMINAL IN
374 NUNN FD-302
M ######## FD-302
72 ######## FD-302
######## EMAIL
370 (MtBMW  Crisis Intak
######## FD-302
368 ######## FD-1057
367 ######## Crisis Intak
366 ######## FD-302
365 ######## FD-302
3t4 ######## Crisis Intak
######## Collectedlt
362 ######## OTHER
######## FD-1057
3_0 ######## FDR
359 ######## FD-302
358 ######## OTHER
357 ######## Crisis Intak
356 ######## FD-1057
355 ######## FD-302
354 ######## FD-302
352 ######## FD-302
252 ######## FD-302
351 ######## FD-302
350 ######## FD-302
112 ######## FD-302
348 ######## FD-302
347 BMW= FD-302
346 ######## FD-302
345 IMMO
3,L4  MUM
343 Mittatittatt
342 ########
FD-302
FD-302
FD-1057
OTHER
IMBIffttlita Crisis Intak
######## FD-302

U) Intervi
U) Proffer
U) Intervi
U) Non-Tr (U) Non-Transitory/For Record
U) On 03/
U) Intervi
U) Califon

U) On 02/
I I • • • ti , ce p ne num
(U) Request approval for NY agent and TFO
######## FD-1057
######## FD-1057
337 ifftniffUt# F D-302
tfftnifftn FD-1057
######## FD-302
##$##### FD-302
3.31
3_31
######## FD-302
######## FD-302
######## Crisis Intak
UMW F D-302
######## FD-302
328 ########

(U) Intervie
(U) Intervi
(U) NTOC2
(U) SOD-NY (U) SOD-NY-3027571
(U) Daum (U) Documentation of Services by

(U) Reques (U) To request country clearance and FBIHQ
(U) Legat C (U) Legat Copenhagen - Pass information and

(U) VS0 D.
(U) On 01/
(U) Epstei
(U) Phone
(U) Intervi
(U) Intervi
(U) Intervi
(U) Intervi
(U) Phone
(U) Intervi

(U) Intervi
(U) Intervi
(U) Epstei
(U) Docum
(U) On 01/
(U) Intervi
(U) Emerg
(U) Emerg
(U) Intervi
(U) Califo

(U) To document that the VSO Documentatio
I I I
(U) To document Emergency Victim Assistanc
(U//FOUO) On or about January 8, 2020, writ

(U) Attorney BRAD EDWARDS was interviewe
(U) Intervi
(U) Intervi
(U) To document Emergency Victim Assistanc

(U) Documentation of Services by VS
(U) To document expenditure of Federal Eme
(U) To document expenditures of Federal Em

(U) Request approval for NY agent and TFO t
FD-1057 (U) To doc (U) To document call with journalist Caroline
327 ########
########
########
########
FD-302
FD-302
FD-302
FD-302
Crisis Inta
OTHER

(U) Intervi
(U) Intervi
(U) Intervi
(U) Proffer
(U) On 11/
of th
(U) To document outreach and records
M
ati
321 44444444 FD-1057 (U) Terror' (U) A request for FEVAF assistance by PM Am
320 ######## FD-1057 (U) The BI • (U) The Bloom Firm contact with FBI Seattle r
319 44444444
########
######## FD-1057

(U) NT0C2
(U) On 11/
(U) Holida (U) To request holiday pay during the week o
316 ######## FD-302 (U) Intervi
315 ######## FD-302 (U) Chaunt (U) <di
2.14 44444444
########
mows
MIMS*
MOM
FD-1057
FD-1035
FD-302
12=
EnITD
IPTacticall

(U) Terror: (U) U) To document approval and expenditur
Sub• M
(U) Admini
(U) On 08/
(U) On 10/
(U//FOUO)

(U) Document FD-1035:
I
(U//FOUO) This Tactical
Administrative
3n
Intelligence Report309
308 ######## IPTacticall (U//FOUO (U//FOUO) This Tactical Intelligence Report
307 ######## Crisis Intl (U) On 10/

(U) Lead F • (U) This Lead was generated to follow-up on i 3.16 ######## FD-1057
igi ########
441$114444
Crisis Inta
FD-302

(U) On 10/
(U) Intervi (U) <di 304
303 FD-1057 (U) Emerg (U) To document expenditure of Federal Eme
12 mow IPTacticall (U//FOUO) (U//FOUO) This Tactical Intelligence Report
(UHFOU0) This Tactical Intelligence Report301 ######## IPTacticall (U//FOUO)
300 44444444
########
FD-302
FD-302
FD-302

(U) Intervie
(U) Christin 299
298 (U) <di
/92
########
########
FD-302
FD-302
FD-302
FD-302
(U) Intervi
(U) Intervi

(U) On 09/
(U) Intervi
I 295
23A
293 se 4 4 4 (U) )000000000(
292 ######## FD-1035 (U) Admini (U) Document FD-1035: Administrative Sub ..
291 ######## FD-1035 (U) Admini (U) Document FD-1035: Administrative Sub ..
290 44444444*
######## FD-302 212 (U) Intervi
288 ######## FD-1035 (U) Admini (U) Document FD-1035: Administrative Sub
287 ########
########
Crisis Inta
FD-302

(U) On 09/
(U) Intervi (U) <di zu
285 Mani* FD-302 (U) Device (U) On Sepetember 05 2019, ITS/Forensic Ex
284 FD-1057 (U) Califo (U) Request approval for NY agent and TFO t
283 ######## FD-302 (U) Device (U) On Sepetember 05, 2019, ITS/Forensic E
282 ########
Crisis Inta (U) On 09/

(U) On 09/ 281
280 NUNN
279 ISM:BM*
278 #ttilifititIN
277 Pattitat.
276 tntStMttNI
2Z  *WOMB
274 ########
273 ########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
FD-302
FD-302
FD-634
NUM= FD-1057
271 ################FD-1057
270 ########
269 ########
262 ########
FD-302
FD-302
FD-302
FD-302
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
FD-302
EMAIL
Crisis Intak
261 ######## FD-302
Crisis Intak 260 ########
112 ########
111 I########nnni########
257 Nana
Crisis Intak
FD-71A
FD-71A
Crisis Intak 256 /####M###
111 ################Crisis Intak
252 ######## FD-302
########Crisis Intak
######## Crisis Intak
251 ######## Collectedit
112 ######## FD-302
249 Xa##a#####Collectedlt
248 ######## FD-302
2A/ ######## Crisis Intak
246 ######## FD-302
245 ######## EMAIL
244 ######## FD-1057
243 ittNtitiflti F D-302
242 #######$t Crisis Intak
########Crisis Intak
########Crisis Intak
112 ########
238 ########################
237 /NUMB
236 ########
235 ########
234 ########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 09/
(U) On 09/
(U) On 09/
(U) On 09/
U) On 09/,
U) Intervie
U//FOUO) (U//FOUO) (U//FOUO) On August 12, 2019 in

(U) New Criminal Case: 31E-NY-3027571-FF;
(U) Case Enhancement; AM #190904-175728
(U) Thsi report documents inquiries to the Cr

U) New Cr (
U) FBI Nev (
U) Follow. (
U) intervie
U) VANES'
U) Search (U) On August 12, 2019, at approximately 8:5

U) Suppler (U) On Saturday July 6,2019,  the author,
U) On 8/3'
U) On 08/
(U//FOUO)
(U) Late su
(U) An ano

(U) Phone
(U) On 081
(U) On 081
U WEXNER
U NTOC20:
(U) On 08f
(U) (U) On
(U) On 08/
(U) (U)Datf
(U//FOUO)

(U) Search
(U) Late submission of evidence
I I I U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 08-28-:
U DOCUMENT SYNOPSIS CREATED ON 08-27-:
U)

U) Record
(U) Sigrid h
(U) On 08/
(U) Inventc
(U) Cecilia I
(U) Transfe
(U) Amend
(U) On 08/
(U) On 08/

(U) On 08/
(U) On 08/
(U) On 8/1,
(U) On 08/
(U) On 08/
(U) On 08/
(U) On 08/
(U) Search warrant executed on Little St Jame

(U) Recorded Interview (Non-Custodial - Over
(U) SIGRID MCCAWLEY (MCCAWLEY), attorne
(U) A search warrant, issued in the United Sta

(U) On August 19, 2019, LEGAT London notifh
(U) To document/request the transfer of evid
(U) On July 31st, 2019, at approximately 6:30
233 81M88888 Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
232 810888888 Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
all 8#88#888
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
(U) On 08/
2Q U) Saulen
229 NUM* Crisis Intak (U) NTOC2
2ZE 88888.018 Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
227 UMW Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
226 MOM/ Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
225 trIMIHMIM Crisis Intak (U) On 8/1
224 #ittMtritirtt Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
223 81Htiffinit Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
222 88#88888 FD-1057 (U) Reporti (U) To submit reporting from S-00017284 (0c
221 11888$MIM Crisis Intak U) On 08/
224 88$018#88 Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
m MUUMUU Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
218 #88888,18 Crisis Intak (U) NTOC2
217 NUNN Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
216 Mr:WM FD-302 (U//FOUO)
215 MMUS* LHMFDR (U) Cedilla
214 88888$M8 Crisis Intak (U) On 08/I
213 810881.888 Crisis Intak (U) On 08/i
212 8888#888 FD-302 (U) Intervie
211 8888881,8 Crisis Intak (U) On 08/i
210 ISIMISMIM FD-302 (U) Device (U) On July 18, 2019, ITS/Forensic Examiner (I
209 rttitrartiM FDR U) Reques (U) Request for Foreign Assistance from LEGA
IN ###$Mittirt FD-302 (U) Intervie
207 frilittitaMit FD-302 (U) Inters/ha
206 ######## FD-302 (U) Return (U) On August 2nd, 2019, Special Agent (SA) It
205 88#88888 Collected It (U) Seizure (U) Seizure of items from safe of 9 East 71st S
204 81Mititnit Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
2Q UMW* FD-302 (U) Intervie (U) A search warrant issued in the United Stal
202 ####$$##$# FD-302 (U) Intervie was interviewed k
201 NUNN Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
202 IMOMSMIM Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
199 WNW FDR (U) FDR to (U) To provide information to Legat Canberra
198 tHritiffintr Crisis Intak (U) On 8/14
197 #8818MIM Crisis Intak (U) NTOC2
196 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 08/
AI #19MSHMIS Crisis Intak (U) On 7/3:
194 ######## FD-302 (U) Post Ar (U) No Synopsis Available.
193 #888#88# FD-888 (U) Op Play (U) To document the search op plan on 7/11/
122 ######## EMAIL (U) Late su (U) Late submission of evidence
191 iffirlattrItt FD-888 (U) Arrest! (U) To document the arrest/search operation
190 UMW/ FD-302 U) Intervie as
189 WHIIM#118 Crisis Intak U) On 07/
188 ######## FD-302 U) Intervie as interviewed at
187 88#88#118 FD-302 U) Intervie was interviewed a
176 NMINM
FD-302
FD-302
Crisis Intak
FD-302
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
CreateCa
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
####000# OTHER
Iff/XXXXXX Crisis lntak
#44114444 Crisis Intak
tt#444444 FD-1057
StXXxxxxx FD-302
tfft#00000 FD-302
in
in
169 ##1100000 FD-302
#000140X FD-302
tffIXXXXXP FD-302
166 BBBNIANS FD-302
MUMMA
BMINBIM
Collectedlt
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak 162 It#######
1§1
160 ######## Crisis Intak
Mffittiffttitt Crisis Intak
159 ######## FD-1057
158 NUMB Crisis Intak
157 MUNN= Crisis Intak
156 41#######  Crisis Intak
155 notxXXXX Crisis Intak
154 XXXXXXO FD-302
151 #4XXUBB Crisis Intak
152 /WNW Crisis lntak
151 MINN*
150 Wfftlinitit
FD-302
FD-302
149 XXX##### FD-302
148 XXXIMBStB Crisis Intak
147 001100000 FD-302
146 44xxxxxx Collectedlt
;45  *MINIM Collectedlt
144 XXXXNXX Crisis Intak
143 ######## Crisis Intak
142 ########
141 ########
140 ####0###
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

U) Intervi
U) Intervi
U) On 07/
U) Arrest
U) On 07/
U) On 07/
U) On 07/
U) On 07/
U) Openin
U) On 07/
was interviewed at 600 0
as in

(U) Pursuant to an arrest warrant issued in th
(U) To request a full investigation be opened
(U) On 07/
(U) Jeffrey (U) Arrest paperwork, search warrant, photo

(U) On 07/
(U) On 07/
(U) EC to di (U) Between 7/10-12
(U) Intervii
(U) Interive
(U) Seizure
(U) On 07/
(U) NTOC2

(U) On 07/
(U) On 07/
(U) On 07/
(U) Provid -
(U) On 07/
(U) On 07/
(U) On 07/
(U) On 07/
ME=
nd the
(U) JEAN LUC BRUNEL, date of birth (DOB)

(U) From 07/09/2019 through 07/11/2019, Ss
(U) Seizure of items from safe of 9 East 71st, I
(U) Provide information for a request to the !

U) On 07/
U) On 07/
U) Search
U) Interive
U) Attemp (U) On July 7, 2019, ar
U) On 07/
U) WILLIA
U) Items s

U) Search
U) On 07/
U) On 07/
U) On 07/
U) On 07/
U) On 07/
(U) A search warrant, Issued In the United Sta

(U) <di
(U) Items seized from JEFFREY EPSTEIN during
(U) Search Warrant Executed at 9 East 71st St
139 ######## Crisis Intak (U)
(U)
On 07/
On 07/ 138 ######## Crisis Intak
az ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
Is& ########
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/
135 (U) On 07/
194 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
133 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
132 ########
########
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/
131 (U) On 07/
130 (U) On 07/
129 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
128 ######## Crisis Intak (U)
(U//FOUO)
(U)
(U)
On 07/.
On 07/:
On 07/:
127 ########
########
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
124 ########
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/
123 (U)
(U)
On 07/
On 07/ 122 ######## Crisis Intak
121 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
120 ######## Crisis Intak (U)
(U)
On 07/
On 07/ 119 ######## Crisis Intak
.111 ########
########
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/
(U) On 07/
116 (U) On 07/
115 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
114 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
113 ########
########
########
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) NTOC2
112 (U) On 07/
111 (U) NTOC2I
110 (U) On 07/
109 ########
Mikktnnat
########
ismidststim
########
Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
108 Crisis Intak (U) (U)On
107 FD-302
FD-302
Crisis Intak
(U)
(U)
NOEMI
Intery
U <di
la
105 (U) On 07/I
104 ########
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/
103 (U) NTOC21
102 ######## (U) On 07/
121 ######## Crisis Intak (U)
(U)
(U)
On 07/
On 7/11
On 07/
100 ########
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak 99
91 ########
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/1
91 (U) On 07/i
96 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
95 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
94 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/I
93 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/
92 NitititinHtit Crisis Intak (U) NTOC2
91 rIttettiteee Crisis Intak (U) NTOC2I
90 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
89 etterteette Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
88 tteeetterld Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/
AZ eireffitfle
MOWN
(U) On 07/i
$I (U) NTOC2
85 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
########
ettettettiffl
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/1
(U) On 07/1
82 Melilla Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
81 ####000# Crisis Intak (U) On 07
80 etterteette Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
Z2 MIMS Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
/4 ######## Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/1
77 ######## (U) NTOC2i
76 ######## (U) On 07/1
75 NUNN Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
####000#
########
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/1
(U) On 07/1
72 ########
########
########
rillettett#e
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/1
71 (U) On 07/1
IQ (U) On 07/i
69 (U) On 07/
68 MOM/ Crisis Intak (U) On 07/i
Ez ######## Crisis Intak (U) NTOC2
66 direddita Crisis Intak (U) On 07
ifittliferUte
########
MINIM
etteettelte
etteturette
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/1
(U) NTOC2i
(U) On 07/1
(U) On 07/1
61 Crisis Intak (U) On 07
60 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
51 etterfeette Crisis Intak (U) On 07/i
58 ettedertrie Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak

(U) On 07/1
UMW*
Mane
#####$IIN
(U) On 07/I
(U) On 07/1
55 (U) On 07/1
M tteeiffirtne Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
53 ########
NUM*
Crisis Intak
FD-302

(U) On 07/
(U) A search warrant, issued 52 (U) Search in the United Sta
51 ########
moms
Crisis Intak
Crisis Intak
(U) On 07/1
5Q (U) On 07/i
49 dritrderifitt Crisis Intak (U//FOUO)
48 UMW Crisis Intak (U) On 07/I
47 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
46 ######## Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
45 MISM111841 Crisis Intak U) On 07/
44 ######## Crisis Intak U) NTOC2
43 ######## Crisis Intak U) On 07/
42 uttrift8888 Crisis Intak U) On 07/
41 tt#88M8 Crisis Intak U) On 07/
4.4 88888888 Crisis Intak U) NTOC2
32 #11#8n#8 Crisis Intak U) On 07/
38 10110018101 Crisis Intak U) On 07/1
37 88811101118 Crisis Intak U) On 07/
36 #88##### Crisis Intak U) Ono 07
35 NUNN Crisis Intak U) On 07/1
34 8101111$88# Collectedlt (U) Search (U) Search Warrant Executed at 9 East 71st St
33 8881018.01 Crisis Intak (U) On 07/1
32 8118$11188# Crisis Intak (U) On 07/i
31 88$1118888 Crisis Intak U) On 07/
30 1111100091# FD-1057 U) 31E-NY (U) Fed-EX signature confirmation page.
29 #118#11888 Crisis Intak U) (U)On
######## Crisis Intak U) (U) On
27 ftt01#8#88 FD-1035 U) Admini (U) Document FD-1035: Administrative Subpc
26 ######## FD-302 U) Intervi
25 ######## FD-302 U) Intervi
24 ######## FD-302 U) Intervi
a ######## CollectedIt U) Items t (U) Items turned over to the FBI during
22 Nana FD-1057 U) Florida (U) Request approval for NY agent and TFO t
21 8#118flfrit FD-302 U) Intervi ereto ref
14 MUM FD-302 U) Intervi s Intervi
19 1011108101 FD-1057 U//FOUO (U//FOUO) To document the Issuance of a sil
18 88811101118 FD-1057 U) Reque (U) To request evidence items in 31E-MM-10
17 8810188811 FD-302 U) Intervi
16 IMMO FD-302 U) Intervi
15 ######## FD-1057 U) Florida (U) Request approval for NY agent and TFO t.
14 Stamm FD-302 U) Intervi
13 #####$$## FD-302 U) Intervi
2,2 stasuttim FD-302 U) Intervi
11 8#$##### FD-302 U) Intervi
10 8811#11#1* FD-302 U) Intervi
9 #888101118 FD-1057 U) Florida (U) Request approval for NY agent and TFO t •
8 8#81ffitIftri FD-302 U) Intervi
7 8.91#1181fit FD-302 U) Phone
6 81111#1111## FD-302 (U) Intervi- (U) On 02/14/2019,
5 1.8814#### FD-302 U) intervie
4 8811811118# FD-1057 U) Trip to (U) To document travel to West Palm Beach,
3 #8881188# FD-1057 U) NY req (U) NY requests LA assistance to confirm vial
2 ######## FD-1057 U) Florida (U) Request approval for NY agent and TFO
1 810111101118 CreateCase (U) Openin (U) To request case be opened and assigned.

J. birth nam
023 05:54 PM—SEE GUARDIAN 978710 JR FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. On 08/28/2023, Arkansa
I 1 1 1 I I I I
rick B. Garland and DOJ lOG Michael E. Horowitz, dated 5/2/2023, from Jennifer Freeman, Esq. of the P
;lty of Mich gan Police Department(UMPD) email contacted writer to provide th
nanager of the Epstein Residence at 9 East 71st Street, NY, NY 10021 containing a NY ID for an individus
027571 1826 was inadvertently misplaced. E iscovered this and started a contint
as interviewed telep
IR) details tactical analysis regarding travel information for Jeffrey Epstein, a sub ect in a child exploitati
th Epstein; BOD member plans to leave due to lack of sufficient USG engagement; China tech acquisitio
s nterviewed telephonically by Spec
After being advised of the identity of
as interviewed telephonically by Spec
=was interviewed pursuant to a proffer agreement via video conference Present for the inten
as interviewed at
On this
West Palm
call ULF spoke with
Beach FL. Present for this interm
egarding his concerns fo
as interviewed telephonically. After being advis
10-18-202101:07
email addre as interviewed over video conference. Present vii
PM—SEE GUARDIAN 762214 NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT
1---
Police Department.
DATA. An attorney sery
I I I I I
resent with Sgt t the Town of Palm Beach s currently a
DATA. On 7/25/2021, a 10-08-202105:15 PM—SEE GUARDIAN 755162_NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT
021 05:11 PM—SEE GUARDIAN 696289_NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. On 12/17/2020, at 4:01:
10-08-202105:09 PM—SEE GUARDIAN 708478 NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. On 01/11/2021,
021 05:07 PM—SEE GUARDIAN 664501 NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. NYOC receives a LISPS le
021 05:05 PM—SEE GUARDIAN 658904 NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. On 07/13/2020, at 2:23:
02105:03 PM—SEE GUARDIAN 603998_NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. (U) On 11/25/2019, Edv,
10-08-202104:59 PM-SEE GUARDIAN 751864 NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. On 7/12/2021, a
02112:51 PM—SEE GUARDIAN 668064_NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. On 08/20/2020, NELL FE
as
ed at
interviewed a •
•
Chatsworth, California. Present for the it
as interviewed a New York, New York. Present for the Inter
New York NY.Present for the interview was -s  attorney Geanne Christense
interviewing Agent a
Agen
nd De
New Yo
New York, New Yor
as interviewed telephonically. After
Mewed over video conference by AU
being advised of the identity of the
Special
proffer agreement at SDNY
ewed at over
as interviewed
WEBEX audio on by AU
as interviewed pursuant to a
pursuant to a proffer agreement at
SHELLING and SANDRA
I
erved trial subpoenas to SUSAN
at
interview
ILENE
was Assistant
WEBB TOWNSEND at
video conference.
as
Present
interviewed
for the
Pasadena, California. Present for the inte
h
Detective
United States Attorney
was interviewed pursuant to a proffer agreement at
at SDNY
FiC and
and Detective
SKI) was interviewed
as interviewed pursuant to a proffer agreement
US
over video conference by AUS
terviewed over video conference by AU
_was interviewed pursuant to a proffer agreement via video conference. Present for the inter%
wed at the
' AU
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION,
Detectiv
Detectiv
Los Angeles Field Office. Present
and
and
for the interview w
After being adv
'AU After being adv
I in person on 9/2/2021. Present for this interview wa -
r -

• attorneys Brad Edwards and Brit
of birth
Ned over video
i. . - •mi •• •• - 1. M' r, s attorneys
Also I
• US/
Di
• Is
Ager
conference by AU • • U • and Detective
interview was AUS •
and Special
IlE, was interviewed over video conference. Present for this
as interviewed over video conference
video conference by AU Detectiv
by AUSA
and
Detective
AUS
Special Agent
er video conference by AU • US
as interviewed at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York(room&#35;645). Present for thi
Detective nd Dee
and Also p
B:as interviewed at y AUS
Detective as interviewed telephonically by AU
I I I
Records,
located
trial subpoena to the Rhode Island Department of Health, Office of Vital located at
a
3 Capitol I
BURKE served a trial subpoena on witness CYNTHIA HOPKINS at her residence
S request &#35;13768, a full file system extraction was performed on the following device using GrayK
O went to Austin, Texas 78721 to retrieve evidence from
021 04:38 PM-SEE GUARDIAN 739010_NY FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. BackgroundOn April 26,
nterviewed at The Federal Bureau of Investigation in Farmington, New Mexico. P
s if
as given an introductory meet with the case team over video conference. Present via video was As
as interviewed at her residence, I
Meryl
021 01:26 PM—SEE GUARDIAN 681124 NY FOR
as
CURRENT ASSESSMENT
interviewed
DATA. On
telephonically.
10/14/2020,
After
at 9:16:
was interviewed telephonically by FBI Specia
as interviewed over video conference by AU
cellular telephone
Assistant
numbe
Jupiter, FL 334
birth (DOB) mail address
as interviewed at the
for this interview was
as interviewed at the Jupiter, FL 334
as interviewed over video conference. Present United States Attorne
as interviewed over video conference. After being advised of the identity of the interview
as interviewed telephonically. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Age
as interviewed in person in London, England over the course of 3 days spanning from 10/14/2020 to 3
as interviewed over video conference. Present on the video call were -s  attorneys B
ory meet with the case team over video conference. Present via video was Assistant United States Mb
t with the case team over video conference. Present via video was s attorney Tatiana Martins. AI:
ds contacted writer and expressed that one of his clients would be willing to speak w
I I I I I I I
'A contacted writer to ask about the
as interviewed at the
as interviewed over video conference
return of
by AU
•
her photographs
US
AUS
she provided to the FBI. NIDA also expr
Jupiter, FL 334
AU
US Detective
nd Detective Also pres
gliE Di
= MEM USA AU D
hos attorneys Glen McGorty, Daniel Zelenk
video conference by AU
was interviewed over the phone by Special Agent
rviewed over video conference by AU
as interviewed over video conference by
erviewed over video conference by AU
with pursuant to a proffer agreement via video conference
as interviewed over video conference. Present on the video call was attorney John
as interviewed over video conference IlL - 1 SpedalSA=, Agent
DOB) wasinterviewed via video conference with her attorneys Gloria Allred, Mariann Want
I I I I I I
rsed by CART for images and videos related to the captioned case was conducted. Images and videos tP
I I I I I I
' London to locate
3ardon petitions and influences from
to ascertain her willingness to meet with US authorities.
Russia and Israel on President Trump and Jared Kushner
er
contacted
vas interviewed
was interviewed telephonically. After being advised of the identity of the Intervie
o discuss the information she provided from her prior interview.
at the FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION at 290 Broadway, New York, New
and
York. Pr
conference. Present on the video call was Assistant United States Attorney
on the video
I I I
Present
video call as via
as interviewed via video conference. call wasMs  attorney Ayani
telephonically. After being ac cellular telephone numbe was interviewed
was video conference. Present on the s legal team including Gloria Allre
was interviewed via video conference. Present on the video call was s legal team Ind
s lega as interviewed via video conference. Present on the video was
mall address cellular numbe
interview was
as interviewed at tel
s leg as interviewed via video conference. Present for the
as interviewed
as
over video
interviewed
conference
over video
by AU
conference by AU US
Special Agen
M I
nt of funds spent to purchase five external hard drives for digital evidence for discovery associated for o
nt of funds spent to purchase an external hard drive for digital evidence associated with captioned case
on the call was AU
out in the Southern
A
District of P
ras interviewed over video conference on 8/26/2020. Present
:ell phone location information and pen register information was sworn
:ell phone location information and pen register informafon was sworn out in the Southern District of P
warrant was sworn out in the Southern District of New York by the Honorable James L Cott for six bine
warrant was sworn out in the Southern District of New York by the Honorable James L Cott for electra
it was sworn out in the Southern District of New York by the Honorable Kevin Nathaniel Fox for items so
m out in the Southern District of New York by the Honorable Barbara Moses for items seized from 9 Ea
m out in the Southern District of New York by the Honorable Barbara Moses for the residence of 9 East
as interviewed via video conference on 8/19/2020 by Detective
as interviewed over video conference by AU
as interviewed over the phone by AU
birth (DOB
E video call on 7/7/2020 by Special Agen
and Specia Agen
Detective
Detective
s intery ewed via video conference with her attorneys Jack Scarola and Mich;
nd Detective After being advise
as interviewed telephonically on 7/15/2020. Present on the call wa
as interviewed telephonically on 7/15/2020. Also present on the call wa s attorneys Brad
pted on August 3, 2020. Based on a Florida Driver and Vehicle Information Database (DAVID) search, it
previous name cellular telephone numbe wa:
'on July 14th,2020, was interviewed by telephone via -After being advised of the i
e Southern District of New York, Special Agents and Task Force Officers of the Federal Bureau of Investie
m, security personnel for Ghislaine Maxwell at the time of her arrest at 338 East Washington Road, Brai
)B)
;nt of funds spent to purchase an external hard drive for digital evidence associated with SOD-NY-30275
atthew C. Knight took aerial photographs of 301 Summer Street Manchester by the Sea, Massachusetts
irth (DOB) • f Greenville, SC, cell phon mail address n
h Attorney BRAD EDWARDS. EDWARDS provided a USB with photographs that was given to him b
in as date of birth
Plaza, New
as interviewed at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New
rs interviewed at One Saint Andrews York, New York. Present for the interview was MUECKE
numbs
as interviewed
mber
iewed a
iewed at 6300
as intery ewed telephonically on April 10, 2020. After being advised of the ide
at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present for the interview was
was interviewed telephonically. Present on the call was AU and Spe
attorney
Wilshire
New York, New York. Present for the interview was s
Blvd, Suite 1500, Los Angeles, California. Present for the interview was
was interviewed at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present for the interview w
interviewed at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present for the interview was-
) as interviewed
interviewed at One Saint
was interviewed at
at
Andrews Plaza, New
New York, New York. Present for the interview I
York, New York. Present for the interview was
West Palm Beach, Florida. Present for this interview was I
✓iewed a .
was interviewed at
New York. Present for the interview was s attorney Glc
Beverly Hills, California. Present for the interview was MA
vas interviewed
as interviewed
)B)
at New York,
Plaza,
to a
New York. Present for the interview was -s attomi
as interviewed at
at One Saint Andrews
as Interviewed pursuant
Beverly Hills, California. Present for the interview
New York, New York. Present for the interview was.
proffer agreement at New York, New `I
)B) as interviewed at
as interviewed at One St. Andrews
New
Plaza, New
York, New York. Present for the interview w
York, New York. Present for the interview was
as interviewed at est Palm Beach Florida. Present for this interview was
as interviewed at
as interviewed at the Federal Bureau
Los Angeles, California. Present for the interview was AUSi
of Investigation St. Thomas Resident Agency in the Virgin Islands b
was interviewed at THE SWEDISH POLICE AUTHORITY in Stockholm, Sweden. Present for the inte
erviewed at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present for the interview was AUSA
th (DOB)
was interviewed
was interviewed pursuant to a proffer agreement at West F
at Pensacola, Florida. Present for the interview was AUSA
■uvas interviewed at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present for the interview was A
as interviewed at
email address
Los Angeles, California. Present for the interview was AUSi
was interviewed at New York, New Yo
)B) as interviewed at the Federal Bureau of Investigation in Los Angeles, California. Presen
? Fund expenditures for the travel and lodging of victims/attendees of the Miami and New York Epstein
tr contacted
viewed at One Saint Andrews
date of birth .t
New York. Present for
The purpose of the call was t<
Plaza, New York, the interview wars attorru
8)
, interviewed
was interviewed at 6300 Wilshire Blvd, Suite 1500, Los Angeles, California. Present for th
at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present for the interview was BRUNO's
_was interviewed at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present for the interview
order to relay informatio l over the phone on 11/1/2019. EDWARDS reached out to in
Los Angeles, California. Present vas interviewed at 6300 Wilshire Blvd, for the interview was AUSA
as interviewed at the Federal Bureau of Investigation St. Thomas Resident Agency in the Virgin Islands b
elephone
as interviewed
numbe as interviewed
Plaza,
on the island of Little St. James. After being a
elephone number as interviewed on the island of Little St. James. After be
at One Saint Andrews New York, New York. Present for the interview was RAP
Fund expenditures
was interviewed at 455 Madison Avenue, New York, New York. Present for the interview
(including reimbursements) for the travel and lodging of victims/attendees of the P
7 ti as interviewed at 1St Andrews Plaza New York NY. Present for the interview was AUSA Ma
? of birth (DOB) was interviewed at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present f
as interviewed
as interviewed
as interviewed at
at
at
Santa
West
Monica, California.
Beach, Florida.
Present for this interview was De
West Palm Present for the interview was
Palm Beach, Florida. Present for the interview was FBI V
as interviewed at Miramar, Florida. Present for the interview was AUSA
=was interviewed at
Los
Los Angeles, California. Present for the interview was A
as Interviewed at Angeles, California. Present for the interview was
I I I I I I
as interviewed at
was interviewed
Los Angeles, California. Present for the interview was
date of birth at One Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present
A, date of birth (DOB)
th (DOB)
cellular telephone numbe as
at
interviewed at
as interviewed pursuant to a proffer agreement
I I as was approved by • n 10/11/19. Approval was granted for water and
was interviewed at 1 Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York. Present for the interview was A
, hereinafter., date of birth cial security account numbe urrent
1R) details tactical analysis regarding travel information for Ghislaine Maxwell a subject in a child sex tra

IR) details tactical analysis regarding the identity of Ghislaine Maxwell a subject in a child sex trafficking
dormation that a USC is in custody in Mexico,MX, regarding a child sex ring inve
IR) details tactical analysis regarding travel information for a subject in a child sex t
IR) details tactical analysis regarding the Went ty of ubject in a child sex trafficklr
birth (DOB) as interviewed in the vicinity of
inside
New York, New York. Also r
terviewed via Skype while agents and prosecutors were present of 1 St Andrews Plaza. Present I<
I I I I
as
fil)
interviewed at West Palm Beach, Florida. Present for the interview
cellular numbe as interviewed at her residence at
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, phone numbe mail address
e Southern District of New York United States District Attorney's Offices located at 1 Saint Andrews Plaz
miner (SFE John Chan in response to MDUS request &#35;10398, initiated an unlock on the following
miner (SFE John Chan, In response to MDUS request &#35;10399, initiated an unlock on the following
as interviewed by phone on
conjunction with the execution of a search warrant,
fter being advised of the identity
Spec al Agent
Pendens flied on 9 East 71st Street,
of the interviev
Operation: nd Staff
elzure: 3540-19-F-474; Asset ID: 19-FBI.006034Us New York, New)
11 complaints; $785 loss; Providing IC3 complaints in relation to captioned investigation pertaining to J
I r I I I I I
of birth uesday August 27,2019,
ellular telephone
was interviewed
as interviewed
executed
at New York, NY. After be
being advised of tt
warrant signed and aul
telephonically. After
a search pursuant to a a.m., the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
- nd SA were assigned to take custody and transport case subject/def
SOURCE, hereinafter , date of birth • dal security account numbe
was interviewed at telephonically a i After being advised of the identity of the i
019 07:29 AM—SEE GUARDIAN 579223_CV FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. On, 26 August 2019, the
1019 10:24 AM—SEE GUARDIAN 566318_PH FOR CURRENT ASSESSMENT DATA. On 07/16/2019 at 4:42 I
URCE, hereinafter date of birth ial security account numbe ui
I
Fort Lauderdale, Florida, telephone numbe
tes District Court for the Southern District of New York on 07/11/2019 at 12:50 pm, was executed at 9 E
id SA hat declined to be Interviewed by Agents. The full response from
Id m, Special Agent (SA and SA ompleted a thorough review a amender
URCE, hereinafte date of birth
as interviewed at his residence, located a
ial security account numbe Ul
E) Victoria Tenpenny, in response to MDUS request &#35;10126, a file system extraction was performe
llOrwwas interviewed at the New York Police Department's 13th Precinct located at 4707 Pearso
as interviewed at Lenwich located at 613 9th Avenue, New York, NY. After being advised
met with FRANK SENERCHIA (SENERCHIA) in the lobby of the Federal Bureau of Investigatii
I I I I I I I es District Court for the Southern District of New York on 07/11/2019, was executed at 9 East 71st Strei
y phone on 07/11/2019 during the execution of a search warrant at 9 East 71st Street, New York, New'
interviewed a Florida. Present for the interview was Ta
West Palm Beach, Florida. Present for the interview were AU ask Force
West Palm Beach, Florida. Present for the interview was AU ask Force
I I I I I I
erviewed a
West Palm Beach, Florida. Present for the interview was AU ask Force
West Palm Beach, Florida. Present for the interview were AU
Southern District of New York, Special Agents and Task Force Officers of the Federal Bureau of Investi
signing agent traveled to West Pa m Beach, Florida to contact victim's in the Jeffrey Epstein case.
07/26/1989, was interviewed at the Southern District of New York United States District Attorney's O
residence address
business addres
residence addres
was interviewed at her plac
was
was interviewed
1949, residence address telephone numbe
es District Court for the Southern District of New York on 07/11/2019 at 12:50 pm, was executed at 9 •
esidence address was interviewed at her re
attempted to interview GHISLAINE MAXWELL, date of birth
as interviewed at West Palm Beach, Florida. Present for the interview was.
tes District Court for the Southern District of New York on 07/06/2019 at 10:14am, was executed at 9 E
as
rred to a
interviewed a
was interviewed pursuant to a proffer
West Palm Beach, Florida.
agreement at
Present for the in
New York,
New York, rred to a was interviewed pursuant to a proffer agreement at
Present for
rred to a
wed pursuant to a proffer
was interviewed pursuant to a proffer agreement at New York,
the intervie agreement at New York, New York.
as interviewed
as
a
at the Law offices of
West Palm Beach, Florida. Present for the interview we
interviewed Boies Schiller Flexner at 401 E Las Olas Blvd, Fort Lauder(
he Law offices of Boies Schiller Flexner at 401 E Las Olas Blvd, Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Present for the
cellular telephone numbe as interviewed at her residence
South C
being ad
Ilular telephone numbe as interviewed
was
in the vicinity of North and
After
interviewed at her residence
as interviewed at her residence
Ilular telephone numbe
email address date of birth (DOB)
home address
residing at
ellular telephone
cellular telephone number
cellular
ith telephone
her residence
telephone numb
numbe
numbe was interviewed at
r travel to West Palm Beach, FL to confer with FBI PBCRA regarding caption case and conduct witness int
I I I I
11 0,as interviewed by writer and Palm Beach County Sheriffs Office Victim Advocate
s State Police referred a complaint received on 08/25/2023 from date of birth
larsh Law Firm, New York City, setting out concerns regarding alleged improper handling of the Jeffrey
tonically. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview
al Agen .
the interviewing Agent
and Detective
and the nature of the
fter being advised of the identity of the interviewir
Interview, 'rovided the following information:
al Agen and Detective fter being advised of the identity of the interviewir
ew wa 's attorney Joseph Nascimento, along with Assistant United States Attorney
ew was Assistant United States Attome along with Special Agen nd
ed of the identity of the interviewing Agent and the nature of the interview provided the followin
video was Assistant United States Attorneys and along with Special Agent
ng as outside counsel for the Attorney General of Virgin Islands in a civil matter against the Jeffrey Epsft
I
Organized
I
Crime,
telephone
ssigned to and supervises the Palm Beach Police Department's Vice &amp;
numbe
Narcotics I
Re
st
RICHAR
t 9:36 AM Eastern Time,
29 AM Eastern Time,
date of birth Ilular
date of birth ell telephone numbe
at 12:13 p.m. Eastern Time, address
New York, United States District Judge ter from United States Distrcit Court Southern District of
16 PM Eastern Time, FNU LNU (ANON), Home
DOB SSAN
telephone numbe I other identifieres r
to
terview was
new was
Assistant United States Attom and Special Agent After bein
Attorne
fter being advised o
s attorney Sigrid McCawley. Also present was Assistant United States
0 nd Detective n, along with AUSA
nd Detective
After being advised
fter being advised of the identity of the above listed individuals and the n
of the identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview,
t NY. Present for the interview was s attorney Jennifer Beidel (remotely over video conference),

k. Present for the proffer was 's attorney Michael Bachner. Also present for the proffer was Ass
each of there residences. They were advised to contact the Assistant United States Attorney (AUSA) lis
view was
ew York NY.
After being
s attorneys
along with
Ridgewood,
Brad Edwards and Brittany
Special
Henderson.
Agent
was
Also present was Assistant
and Detective
Uni
Beidel,
AU
New Jersey. Present for the interview s attorney Jennifer
along with Present for the interview
fter being  advised of the
advised of the identity
s attorney Joseph
US
of the interviewing
wa
identity
of the above
attorney Joseph Nascimento,
of the above listed individuals and the nature of the inte
listed individualsand the nature of the interview
ew was
*s AUS
Nascimento, along with Assistant United States Attorneys
Detectiv and fter being ad
sed of the identity Agents and the nature of the interview provided the follow
sed of the Identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview, rovided the follow
tany Henderson. Also present for this interview was Assistant United StatesAttorney M
Attorney
being a
Brad Edwards and Brittany Henderson. Also present on the call was Assistant United States
attorneys Britney Henderson and Brad Edwards. After (resent for this interview was -s
tective
o present for
Detective and Special
and lso
Agen
present for
David Schertler
of the
Also present for this interview w.
this interview wa s legal team
this interview wa s attorneys
fter being advised of the identity
and Paola Pinto. After being advised
above listed individuals and the nature of th
interview wer s attorney Donald Duboulay, along with AU
After being
After
the idenf
Also present in part for this interview was Investigator
s attorney ROBERT GLASSMAN. advised of tsent for this interview wa
a birth ce
advised
The Office of Vital Records
cell
provided a certified copy of
Before was cell: alternate

ER. She provided the evidence consisting of one pair of black women's cowboy boots, size 8, and was is!
2021, the Counter Terrorism Unit (CTU) was made aware that an individual by the name of
esent for the interview was Assistant United States Attorney along with Special Agen •
al team including
sistant United
Gloria
States Attorne
Alfred, Mariann Wang, and Heather Gregorio.
and
Also present on the
long with
call was As
Detective

nd. Also present during the interview was Maryland State Police After being adv
being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agent and the nature of the interview, • rov
of thi
24 AM Eastern Time, Simon Andriesz, date of birth'Home telephone
advised
number
of the identities Agen L' After being
=lams
ME Detective and Special Agen After being advised of the id
interviewed telephonically. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents i

77. Present in person was s attorneys Jack Scarola and M ke Danchuk. Also present in persc
77. Present
ing Agent and
in person
Detective
was s attorneys Jack Scarola, Chris Rodgers, and Mike Danchuk. Also
Special Agen • nd FBI Victim Specialist
of the interview, rovided the following information: Analyst and the nature
I I I I I
0/16/2020. Present for this interview was Assistant United States Attorne Detective
rad Edwards and Brittany Henderson. Also present
me 2:: long
via video was Assistant United States Attorne
with Detective and Special Agent
Attorneys Mt
MA
o present via
th the FBI.
video was Assistant United States
• rovided information regarding
I
to include that she recalled GHISLAINE
I I I
Rssed her upset over identifying herself as a victim when she knew what was going on.
77. Present in person was
Detective and Special
nd Special Agen
s attorneys Chris Rodgers
Agent
and Mike Danchuk. Also present in per
Also present for this Interview
was -s  attorneys
was_
Also present for this interview
Brittany Henderson.
Lar
ant on this
tective
Detective
tective
an •
Also
phone call was s attorney
and Special Agen •
and Special Agent
After being advised of the identity
fter
Also
being advised of the identity of the interviei
Also present for this interview
present for this interview was
was E
s e
and
and Special Agen •
present. Also present via video was Assistant United States Attorney
present on the call was Assistant United States Attorne
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents and the natu
and John Cuti present. Also present via video was Assistant United States Attorney D 7Kent for the Interview was s 
attorneys Brad Edwards and Brittany
Henderson. Also present fo
After
is Neal. Also present on the video call was Assistant United States Attome
vised of the identity of the interviewing Agent and the nature of the interview, provided
1, Mariann Wang, and Mice Reiter. Also on the video call was Assistant United States Attorneys
Kling Gloria Allred, Mariann Wang, and Eric Hecker. After being advised of the identity of the interview
team, including Gloria Allred, Mariann Wang, and Alice Reiter. Also on video was Assistant United Stat
1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ephonically After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agent and the nature of the intervie
al team Gloria Allred and Mariann Wang. Also present via video was Assistant United States Attorneys
and Detective
UW th e and Special Agent
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents
nd Detect After being advised of the identil
fter b
ized from Jeffrey Epstein at the time of his arrest, along with items seized from 9 East 71st Street
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the intervh
and Special Agent Also present for this video conference was at
Ind Special Agent Also on this call was s attorney AITAN GOELMANA. After bell
Also present via video was Assistant United States Attorneys
d of the identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview rovided the folic
s attorneys Brad Edwards and Brittany Henderson. After being advised of the identity of the interviewir
Edwards and Brittany Henderson. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agent and Am
vas determined tha s most recent p ace of residency was
Interviewed at her res dence, was intend
I1Mdentity of the interviewing Task Force Officer and the nature of the interview, provided the
ation's New York Child Exploitation and Human Trafficking Task Force and Boston Divisions' New Hamp
ellphonE email address was interviewed at the Bradfc
as interviewed at
ork, New York. Present for the interview wer
s attorney Sigrid McCawley along with
After being
s attorneys, Erica Dubno and Aaron Mysliw
AU and Special Agen
ltity of the 'nterviewing Agent and the nature of the interview, provided the following informati
Assistant United States Attorneys
ial Agen
oria Allred and paralegal SAMMY WONG, along with AU
ttorney Gloria Allred. Also present for the Interview was AUSA AUS
s SZANKAY's attorneys Brad Edwards and Brittany Henderson. Also present for the interview was AUSs
Z' attorneys Brad Edwards and Brittany Henderson. Also present for the interview was AU
as attorney Gloria Allred, along with AUSA
S' attorney Ted Gibbs. Also present for the interview was AUS
ietective
ria Allred, along with AU
s attorney Jeffrey Pop, along with AU
y Gloria Allred, along with AU
was AU
cial Ager
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agent and the nature
Detecti'
and Special Agent
U
Prior to beginning this interview,
Special Agen
U •
s s attorneys/legal team including Suzanne Bloom, Cristina Calva
s attorneys Erica Dubno and Aaron Mysliwiec, along with AUSA
s attorney Rita GLAVIN, along with Detective
Detectiv
AUS
Deteci
De
as se
and Detec
and Detective
Special Agen
Special Agent
MO's legal team, including attorneys Brittany Henderson and Brad Edwards. Also present for the intery
ork. Present for the Interview was s attorneys/legal team including Suzanne Bloom, Cristina Cal
along witl
USA-
Detective Special Agen ,
and Special Agen After being advised of the identities of the in'
iew was Assistant United States Attorne FBI Special Agen NYPD Detect
der
aim Beach,
USA
AUSA-AU
Florida. Present for the interview was
Detective'and Special Agent.'
Joseph Nascimento, along with A s attorney
and Special Agen i fter being advised of the identi
J Special Agen nd Detectiv •
rk. Present for the interview
Detective
was
Special
AU
Agen
and
attorney
Special Agen
Robi
for the interview was AU ZE and Special Agen ft
Victim Briefings. This documentat on reflects a GTA charge as well as a refund for the October GTA Stai
ascertain s availability in scheduling an in-person interview. was willing to meet 'n person tc
y Sigrid McCawley, along with AUSSAUS Detective-and Spe
Marianne Wong, along with Dan Mullkoff via telephon e interview were her attorneys Gloria Allred and
legal team, including attorneys Brittany Henderson and Brad Edwards.
va l.nA
Also present for the interview w
Detective
.1 about this investigation that he had deemed relevant. After being advised of the identity of the intery
USA
Detective and Special
Detective pecial Agen
Agen After being advised of
nd
the identities
s att
of the in
wised of the identities of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview,
of the interview,
provided the
ing advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature
U

• rovic
pecial Agen
and paralegal Sammy
• attorney
was
Sigrid McCawley, along with AU
s legal team, including attorneys Gloria Allred and Mariann Wang,
Keen US ands Attorneys Erica Dubno and Aaron MySliviec. After b
r the interview was Assistant United States Attome and Special Agen
:Wive Special Agent
Detectiv
AUS
nd
and AUSA
and Special Agent
After
Agen
Aft
After bein FBI Victim Specialist
ctim Specialist Detective
der FBI Victim Specialist
Special Agen •
nd Special
being adv
A
Alexandel
Detective
JS •
attorneys,
EMI Detective nd Special Agen u
Glassman and Nathan Werksman, along with AU USA Robert
for this interview was AUS
• USA
for the
interview
Detective Special Agen
AU Detective and Special Agent
dison Ave, New York, New York. Present interview
wa
was _s
s attorney
attorney Gloria Allred, along wit
alm Beach, Florida. Present for the Joseph Nascimento, along with A
leenex utilized by attendees of victim briefings that took place in Miami on 10/15/19 and in New York
. AUSAI DeteCtSallilSpecial Agen nd CHART
ce
tigation by the Mexican authorities, that is purported to include video evidence, held by Mexican law e
resent for the interview was s husband ). After being advised of the ide
r the interview was Task Force Offcers, Detective Detectiv a along with AUSAI
was AU U • pedal Agen nd
Florida. Present for the interview was AU US
Detective
pecial Ag ail, Jupiter,
mail.com, date of birth (DOB) was interviewed by Special Agen
3, New York, NY. Also in attendance for the interview was s attorney, Sanford Talcon and AUS
OftlMIring task force officer and  the nature of the interview, rovided the following information:
f the FBI New York Field ce v ence Response Team (ERT) conducted a tl
ing advised of the identity of the interviewing Agent and Task Force Officer as the nature of the intervie
e identities of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview, INTERVIEWEE provided the folio
horized by the Honorable Ruth Miller, United States District Court for the District of Virgin Is ands, at a .
endant JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN to 26 Federal Plaza, Manhattan, NY, incidental to his arrest at TETERBORO A
-urrent addre
nterviewing Agent and the nature of the interview,MIMprovided the following information:
Cleveland Field Office received an email from
p.m. Eastern Time,
telephone
, email address
living in
rent address
ast 71st Street, New York, New York 10021 at 2:35pm on 07/11/2019. During the search, Agents obsen
the Inventory related to two suitcases that were received by SA  . 107/11/2019 during the ext
rent address
SSAU COUNTY). After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agent and the nature of the inter
riend, I 1 Place, Long Island City - Queens, New York. Also present during the interview was
of the identity of the interviewing Agent and the nature of the interview, 'rovided the foil
on (FBI) office at 290 Broadway, New York, New York 10007. Also present during the meeting was SAl
ht, New York, New York 10021 at approximate y 2:35pm on 07/11/2019. Upon initial review of the prep
via telephc 'ork 10021. =was contacted by the property manage
Ricer Detective nd Special Agen fter being advised of the identity of the i
fter bein advised of the identity of the
ices located at 1 Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, NY. Also in attendance for the interview was
Officer, Detective Special Agen nd S Attorney Brad Edwards. After
ask Force Officer, Detective and Special Agent
z of employment. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agent and the nature of the Iry
nterviewed via telephone at his place of business. After being advised of the identity of the interviewir
at her residence. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agent, Task Force Officer and tl.
gyring individuals: RRY VISOK,
at 1 Saint Andrews Plaza, New York, New York 10007. Also present for the interview was Assistant Unity
vas contacted via telephone. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agent and the natu
ast 71st Steet, New York, New York 10021 at 2:35pm on 07/11/2019 The warrant signed by the Honor.
dence. After being advised of the dentity of the interviewing Agent and the nature of the interview, GI
he address listed was a postal box at a UPS Store. Agt
DA's attorney Sid Garcia, along with AU Detective and
ist 71st Steet, New York, New York 10021 at 6 15pm on 07/06/2019. The warrant signed by the Honora
:erview were AUSA U
the interview wa
ask
ttorney
ttorneys
Force Off ce
Alex Conlon along
and Jenna
and Special Agen
New York. Present for with AUSA
Dabbs along with New York. Present for the interview wer
New York.
N v.faattomeys,
Present for the interview wer ttorneys Alex Conlon and Alex Elonowitz-Hess
Alexandra Conlon, Alexandra Elonowitz Hess, and Jenna Dabbs, along witl
re AU
ale, Florida. Present for
U
the interview were AU
ask Force Office nd Special
U
Agen
ask Force Office
interview were AUS
Florida. After
USA
being advised of the
ask Force Office and Special Age
identity of the interviewing Agents and the na
ematis Street. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the inte
used of the identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview, rovided the fo
and the nature of t Riviera Beach, Florida. After being advised of the identity of the Interviewing Agents
iail.com, was
was interviewed
interviewed at her home residence f
erbeing a v se o t e i entity of ti was interviewed
by SA
telephonically on
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Ager
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing Agents a
regarding interstate threats and witness tampering/retaliation by (
In estate contacted S regarding information obtained in the course of her inyestigadi
residential addre • Internet Protocol (IP) address
adential addre called the FBI National Threat Opera
bmitted an online tip to the FBI National Threat Operations Center (NTOC), via tips.f ti.goy, to report poi
) M. BERMAN dated 07/23/2020 addressed to the NYO FBI nd includes a le
efused, called the FBI National Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to report possible sex trafficking by Gre
lephone numbs came to the Albuquerque office of the FBI to report an email he receive
her addres called the FBI National Threat Operations
d she wanted to provide information on GHISLAINE MAXWELLMM was willing to testify and shi
e entered MCC Brooklyn via the West Lobby and advised that he wished to visit inmate Ghislaine Mani
D2, called the FBI National Threat Operations Center (NTOC) to report alleged money laundering by Hou
iforcement officials, of JEFFREY EPSTEIN engaging in sex acts with minors. The said minors were report(
Israel; the email is attached. ted that the WEXNER FOUNDATION in Cleveland, OH had appoi
gmail.com, phone numbs ate of birthaubmitted a tip to the FBI National
eorge Tonks. (also on the telephone call), date of birth
in.Two women, one located in New York City and one located elsewhere, have made accusations again&
M3.58.212, which resolves to Cass Street, Florida, submitted an online tip to the FBI National Threat Opt
Sons Center (NTOC) to report Information on a possible accountant of Jeffrey Epstein in Los Angeles, Cal
sible human trafficking in New York, NY.Lee provided the following Information:Date Submitted: 01/11/;
ter he received from repeat complainant/Five Points Correctional Facility inmate
g Horvath and Jana Jaffe In New York, NY.ANON provided the following information:ANON believes Greg
:I offering 7 videos of sexual abuse and the location of two foreign girls buried on Zorro Ranch. (U) On 1
O
:enter (NTOC) to report NOTE: This Guardian is being forwarded to the New York Field Office, where Col
requested if the FBI could provide her with a 1998 flight record from St. Thomas to Newark
ell, Reg. No 02879-509. The Special Investigative Lieutenant that was on duty at the time reported to tt
and Lutnick via BGC Financial and Cantor Fitzgerald.Note: This Information is being sent to your field offl,
tted JEFFREY EPSTEIN as a trustee, EPSTEIN gave the WEXNER FOUNDATION approximately 9 Million USI
Threat Operations Center (NTOC) Unit to report in 1988 she was taken by criminals who have connectior
re the first two people to report sexual abuse by Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell in approxin
Jes Staley, the CEO of Barclays Bank, of violent rape. One of the women believes that she spoke to the I
•radon Center (NTOC) via tipsiblgov, regarding her being victimized trafficked) as a child by Gislaine M
fornia.NOTE: The following information is being forwarded for your situational awareness and any ado
021 12:13:13 PM ETTransaction Number: 4A0F6D0C-4F27-4206-81C7-C8146AA80DA8Threat To Life: Fa
DIN# 19A3320 -s letter which is dated 07/12/2020, provides detail
Horvath and Jana Jaffe, owners of Villa Arabesque in Acapulco, MX, were involved in drug and/or sex tr
1/21/2019, received an email from rdin 7 videos of sexual abu
nplainant is currently staying, for domain awareness and any other actions deemed necessary. Thomas f
) was seeking for victim assistance program and flight records would be helpful to her.
e front lobby and explained visiting procedures. It was reported tha sked if he could "ring
e based on the possible location of Lutnick within the United StatesAndriesz provided the following id
also stated that the WEXNER FOUNDATION transferred at least 2.3 Million USD to Israeli forme
with Jeffrey Epstein she was then taking and placed in a escort business Date Submitted: 07/16/2019 0
iately 2006 Approximately two years ago, Maxwell hired Lady Victoria Hervey, a resident in the United k
81 with these accusations previously. Attorney Singer wanted to be sure that the FBI was aware of these
axwell.NOTE: Per SMAPA 59394, This Guardian is provided to the Tampa Field Office for domain awaren
) deemed appropriate.•rovided the following information:She used to date the son of an account
seSubmitted Text:IC3 Complaint ID:12101111249530222 Date: 01/11/2021 12:49:53 Filed from: 158.1(
; on an unnamed JEWISH GIRL who he reports was raped by her father (no name provided) since the age
fficking in the early 2000's. Horvath and Jaffe currently live in Olympic Tower in New York, but they usec
ie by Jeffrey Epstein and the location of two foreign girls buried on Zorro Ranch for sale for one bitcoin.
rovided the following information eported her grandfather, name not obtained, whose care TI
her bell and ask her can she please see me." The Lieutenant advised of the visiting procedi
wmation:Andriesz, call ng from the United Kingdom, previously worked for BGC Financial (BGC) and Can
r Prime Minister Ehud Barak; EPSTEIN allegedly signed some of these transfer documents.
1:42:13 PM ESTTransaction Number: F10869E9-0789-4CA9-899F-9424FC383B73Threat To Life: FalseSub
ingdom, to stalk and harass victims of Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein. Hervey hired two men, one of whor
accusations. In addition, during the course of their investigation they have seen information showing tl.
ss, dissemination to local authorities or for whatever action deemed appropriate.Date Submitted: 07/2
int named Drew Bernstein who she believes was an accountant for Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwe
6.223.134 Victim Information Name: Business Name: Age: 30 - i
of 8 years old. dvises that she then became pregnant as a result. At the age of 14 years old, l
Villa Arabesqu Henry Kissinger and other high profile individuals who had ties to Epstein. Ha
The email had a valid wallet (3Cr9TpVeRcgeg4zGhPEdzhC94HzuUScbHN) for the funds. The email had a
‘omas was in since she was a baby, had a house a few doors down from the sat'
res, again, and he stated he would write inmate Maxwell and request to be placed on her visiting list. IV
for Fitzgera d (CF) in the financial market. Andriesz was responsible for reviewing reporting, and comp!)
mined Text I was trafficked from Nashville, TN to NYC in 1988 when I was 19 by the ring of criminals con
I was George Tonks, a conman on probation in Chicago, IL Tonks made contact with about two
at Epstein's attorney and accountant were aware of the activities occurring and were helping in perpetu
5/2021 09:36:45 AM ESTTransaction Number: 1k2576jrViolation: Human-Traffick ngThreat To Life: False!

I. She was around this man between 2005 and 2007, but has not been in contact with him since 2009. S
ddress (condnuedaSulte/Apt/Mall Stop City: New Yr
aims the unnamed JEWISH GIRL visited JEFFREY EPSTEIN'S mansion and became highly favorer
vath and Jaffe owned multiple private jets which they used to fly people to Villa Arabesque, Including Al
deadline of 11/22/2019. The author states that the information was insurance against future litigation a
ve, an as taken by boat to Epstein's Island said it was complicated and involved Jefl
eft without incident; however, the Lieutenant was aware that Sas frequently w
once for all of North America. Andriesz uncovered fraud, money laundering, Ponzl schemes, and regulat
nected to Jeffrey Epstein. I was taken by van and exchanged for an Australian girl my age who wer
rears ago and befriended her through stories of abuse he had suffered as well. Tonics was able to get Fai
ubmitted Text:Alot and years of trauma and threats. Reported Agency Name: I was a childReport Numb
he believes he was their accountant because Epstein was mentioned as a good friend and she met MaX%
rk County: NY State: New York Country: United States of America Zip Code/Route: 10001 Phone Numbe
in their website seeking arrangements. further alleges that this unnamed JEWISH GIRL is respc

ON. In college, ANON was  friends with Jaffe's nephew, Doug Jaffe III (Doug), who invited ANON to sper
igainst Epstein. (Uflelieves the email could be valid since he uses his full first name and thinks I
ery Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell Thomas also reported a meeting that took place at Rio Rancho Midd
riling inmate Maxwell and notified CTU of the incident. On April 29, 2021, CTU was notified that
xy breaches by BGC and CF, so he became a whistleblower. BGC and CF received large fines and there a
t back to Nashville. A woman named Mary Reddish drove and she was paid by people in the music busk
er: Date of Report: 2021-07-25Phone Type: CellPhone Number: 8
r: mail Address:
nsible for approximate y 3 homicides including one where she injected Fentanyl into
Business IT POC: su
I
ess I can identify. I was handed over to put me to work at an escort service on E
EFTA00172546 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2024-09-21)
LIMITED
OFFICIAL
USE
The attached information
must be protected and not
released to unauthorized
individuals. Use of this
cover sheet is in accordance
with the Department of
Justice regulation on the
control of Limited Official
Use information.
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE ONLY-NOT FOR PUBLIC RELEASE
IN SPEC
DRAFT
Investigation and Review of the Federal Bureau
of Prisons' Custody, Care, and Supervision of
Jeffrey Epstein at the Metropolitan Correctional
Center in New York, New York
* *
March 202-:;
Notice: This Draft Is Restricted to Limited Official Use.

This document is a WORKING DRAFT prepared by the U.S. Department of Justice Office of the
Inspector General. It has not been fully reviewed within the Department and is, therefore, subject
to revision. This report may contain sensitive law-enforcement or privacy-protected information
and is for authorized recipients only. Recipients of this draft must not, under any circumstances,
show or release its contents for purposes other than official review and comment. It must be
safeguarded in accordance with Department of Justice Order 2620.7 to prevent publication or
other improper disclosure of the information it contains.

If you have received this draft report in error, please contact (202) 768-2643 to arrange its return.
LIMITED OFFICIAL USE ONLY—NOT FOR PUBLIC RELEASE
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Investigation and Review of the Federal Bureau of
Prisons' Custody, Care, and Supervision of Jeffrey
Epstein at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in
New York, New York
Introduction and Background
The Department of Justice (OOJ) Office of the Inspector
General (OIG) initiated this investigation upon receipt of
information from the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP)
that on August 10, 2019, in the Metropolitan
Correctional Center in New York, New York (MCC New
York), inmate Jeffery Epstein was found hanged in his
assigned cell within the Special Housing Unit (SHU).
The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, City of New
York, determined that Epstein had died by suicide.
The OIG conducted this investigation jointly with the
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), with the OIG's
investigative focus being the conduct of BOP personnel.
Among other things, the FBI investigated the cause of
Epstein's death and determined there was no
criminality pertaining to how Epstein had died.
This report concerns the OIG's findings regarding MCC
New York personnel's custody, care, and supervision of
Epstein while detained at the facility from his arrest on
federal sex trafficking charges on July 6, 2019, until his
death on August 10. Epstein was assigned to the SHU
on July 7 due to media coverage of his case and inmate
awareness of his notoriety. SHU inmates are securely
separated from general population inmates and kept
locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day.
While in MCC New York, Epstein was screened on
numerous occasions by psychological staff and in all of
the evaluations he denied having thoughts or a history
of suicide. Psychological staff determined Epstein did
not meet the criteria for a psychological diagnosis.
Relevant BOP Policies
BOP policy requires SHU staff to observe all inmates at
least twice an hour and that lieutenants conduct at
least one round in the SHU each shift. BOP policy also
requires multiple inmate counts during every 24-hour
period. Among other things, inmate counts and rounds
enable BOP staff to observe inmates and ensure they
are secure in their cells and in good health. Further, to
eliminate safety hazards, MCC New York requires SHU
staff to search SHU common areas and at least five
cells daily, and to search the entire SHU every week.
For inmates identified as suicide risks, the BOP requires
they be placed on suicide watch until no longer at
imminent risk. A less restrictive monitoring form,
psychological observation, is used for inmates who are
stabilizing but not yet ready to return to a housing unit.
Additionally, BOP policy requires that all inmate
telephone calls be made through BOP's Inmate
Telephone System. On rare occasions, BOP policy
permits inmates to make a call outside of this system,
but the call must be recorded and documented.
Incident Involving Epstein on July 23, 2019
On July 23 at 1:27 a.m., correctional officers responded
to Epstein's SHU cell where they found Epstein with a
handmade orange cloth around his neck. Epstein's
cellmate told officers Epstein tried to hang himself.
Medical staff examined Epstein, observed friction
marks and superficial reddening around his neck and
on his knee, and placed him on suicide watch. Epstein
was removed from suicide watch on July 24 but
remained under psychological observation until July 30.
Epstein first told MCC New York staff he thought his
cellmate had tried to kill him, but later said he did not
know what occurred and did not want to talk about
how he had sustained his injuries. Epstein also later
asked if he could be housed with the same cellmate.
Another inmate housed on the same SHU tier told the
OIG that he heard Epstein's cellmate call for assistance,
and that Epstein's cellmate told him that Epstein tried
to hang himself from the bunkbed ladder. Disciplinary
charges against Epstein for alleged self-mutilation were
not sustained due to insufficient evidence.
Following the July 23 incident, the Psychology
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Department determined Epstein needed to be housed
with an appropriate cellmate, and on July 30 it sent an
email to over 70 MCC New York employees informing
them of this requirement. The Warden at the time told
the OIG that he selected a new cellmate for Epstein in
consultation with BOP executive leadership. That
inmate remained Epstein's cellmate until August 9.
Events of August 8-10, 2019, and Epstein's Death
On August 8, the U.S. Marshals Service sent two emails
notifying numerous MCC New York staff that Epstein's
cellmate was being transferred to another facility on
August 9. However, no action was taken to ensure
Epstein was assigned another cellmate.
Also on August 8, Epstein met with his attorneys at the
prison, as he had on prior occasions, and signed a new
Last Will and Testament. MCC New York officials did
not learn about the new Will until after Epstein's death.
The following day, August 9, Epstein's cellmate was
transferred to another facility and he was not assigned -
a new cellmate. Also on August 9, after meeting at the
prison with his lawyers, staff allowed Epstein to make
an unrecorded, unmonitored telephone call before he
was returned to his SHU cell. Although Epstein said he
was calling his mother, he actually called an individual
with whom he allegedly had a personal relationship.
At approximately 8:00 p.m. on August 9, SHU inmates
were locked in their cells for the night, including Epstein
who was without a cellmate. A search of Epstein's cell
following his death revealed Epstein had excess prison
blankets, linens, and clothing in his cell, and that some
had been ripped to create nooses. Only one SHU cell
search was documented on August 9, and it was not of
Epstein's cell. BOP records did not indicate when
Epstein's cell was last searched. The OIG also found
that SHU staff did not conduct any 30-minute rounds
after about 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and that none of the
required SHU inmate counts were conducted after 4:00
p.m. on August 9. Count slips and round sheets were
falsified to show that they had been performed.
On August 10, at approximately 6:30 a.m., the two SHU
staff on duty, Correctional Officer Tova Noel and
Material Handler Michael Thomas, began delivering
breakfast to SHU inmates. Tova unlocked the door to
Epsteln's SHU tier. When Thomas attempted to deliver
I As detailed in the report, MCC New York had a history
breakfast to Epstein through the food slot in his locked
cell door, Epstein did not respond to Thomas's verbal
commands. Thomas unlocked the cell door and saw
Epstein hanged. Thomas immediately yelled for Noel
to get help and call for a medical emergency.
Thomas told the OIG that when he entered Epstein's
cell, Epstein had an orange string, presumably from a
sheet or a shirt, around his neck that was tied to the
top portion of the bunkbed. Epstein was suspended
from the top bunk in a near-seated position, with his
buttocks approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half off
the floor. Thomas said he immediately ripped the
orange string from the bunkbed, and Epstein's buttocks
dropped to the ground. Thomas then lowered Epstein's
body to the floor and began chest compressions until
responding MCC New York staff members arrived
approximately 1 minute later. Shortly thereafter,
outside medical personnel arrived and took over the
emergency response, eventually removing Epstein to a
local hospital where he was pronounced dead.
On August 11, 2019, the Office of the Chief Medical
Examiner performed an autopsy and determined the
cause of death was hanging and the manner of death
was suicide. Blood toxicology tests did not reveal any
medications or illegal substances in Epstein's system.
The Medical Examiner who performed the autopsy told
the OIG that Epstein's injuries were consistent with
suicide by hanging and that there was no evidence of
defensive wounds that would be expected if his death
had been a homicide. Epstein did not have marks on
his hands, broken fingernails or debris under them,
contusions to his knuckles that would have evidenced a
fight, or, other than an abrasion on his arm likely due to
convulsing from hanging, bruising on his body.
The Limited Available Video Evidence
Recorded video evidence for August 9 and 10 for the
SHU area where Epstein was housed was only available
from one prison security camera due to a malfunction
of MCC New York's Digital Video Recorder system that
occurred on July 29, 2019. While the prison's cameras
continued to provide live video feeds, recordings were
made for only about half the cameras. MCC New York
personnel discovered this failure on August 8, 2019, but
it was not repaired until after Epstein's death.'
of security camera problems.
ii
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
The available video from the one SHU camera captured
a large part of the common area of the SHU and
portions of the stairways leading to the different SHU
tiers, including Epstein's cell tier. Thus, anyone entering
or attempting to enter Epstein's SHU tier from the SHU
common area would have been picked up by that video
camera. Epstein's cell door, however, was not in the
camera's field of view. The OIG reviewed the video and
found that, between approximately 10:40 p.m. on
August 9 and about 6:30 a.m. on August 10, no one was
seen entering Epstein's cell tier from the SHU common
area. The OIG determined that movements captured
on video before and after those times were generally
consistent with employee actions as described by
witnesses and documented in BOP records.
Results of the OIG's Investigation and Review
The OIG's investigation and review identified numerous
and serious failures by MCC New York staff, including
multiple violations of MCC New York and BOP policies
and procedures. The 016 found that MCC New York
staff failed on August 9 to carry out the Psychology
Departments directive that Epstein be assigned a
cellmate, and that an MCC New York supervisor allowed
Epstein to make an unmonitored telephone call the
evening before his death. Additionally, we found that
staff failed to undertake required measures designed
to make sure that Epstein and other SHU inmates were
accounted for and safe, such as conducting inmate
counts and 30-minute rounds, searching inmate cells,
and ensuring adequate supervision of the SHU and the
functionality of the video camera surveillance system.
The OIG also found that several staff falsified BOP
records relating to inmate counts and rounds and
lacked candor during their OIG interviews. Two MCC
New York employees, Noel and Thomas, were charged
criminally with falsifying BOP records. The charges
were later dismissed after they successfully fulfilled
deferred prosecution agreements. The U.S. Attorney's
Office for the Southern District of New York declined
prosecution for other MCC New York employees who
the OIG found created false documentation.
The combination of these and other failures led to
Epstein being unmonitored and alone in his cell, which
contained an excessive amount of bed linens, from
approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 until he was
discovered hanged in his locked cell the following day.
While the 016 determined MCC New York staff engaged
in significant misconduct, we did not uncover evidence
contradicting the FBI's determination regarding the
absence of criminality in connection with how Epstein
died. SHU staff told the OIG that at approximately 8:00
p.m. on August 9, all SHU inmates, including Epstein,
were locked in their cells for the evening and we found
no evidence to the contrary. The prison's recorded
video did not identify any staff or other individuals
approaching Epstein's SHU tier from the SHU common
area between approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9
and about 6:30 a.m. on August 10. Further, none of the
MCC New York staff members we interviewed were
aware of any information suggesting Epstein's cause of
death was something other than suicide. Additionally,
none of the inmates we interviewed had any credible
information suggesting Epstein's cause of death was
something other than suicide. Further, the SHU staff
and three interviewed inmates with a direct line of sight
to Epstein's cell door on the night of his death stated
that no one entered or exited Epstein's cell after the
SHU staff returned Epstein to his cell on August 9.
We further noted that Epstein had previously been
placed on suicide watch and psychological observation
due to the events of July 23, 2019; that numerous
nooses made from the excess prison sheets were
found in his cell on the morning of August 10; and that
he signed a new Last Will and Testament on August 8, 2
days before he died. We found that the staffs failure to
assign Epstein a cellmate on August 9, to conduct
rounds and counts that evening, and to allow him to
have excess linens in his cell, left Epstein unmonitored
and locked alone in his cell for hours, which provided
him an opportunity to commit suicide.
Finally, the Medical Examiner who performed the
autopsy detailed for the 016 why Epstein's injuries were
more consistent with, and indicative of, a suicide by
hanging rather than a homicide by strangulation. The
Medical Examiner also cited the absence of debris
under Epstein's fingernails, marks on his hands,
contusions to his knuckles, or bruises on his body
evidencing a struggle, which would be expected if
Epstein's death had been a homicide by strangulation.
The OIG made nine recommendations to the BOP to
address the numerous issues identified during our
investigation and review. Finally, we recommend that
the BOP review the conduct and performance of the
BOP personnel as described in this report and
determine whether discipline or other administrative
action with regard to each of them is appropriate.
iii
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Table of Contents
Chapter 1: Introduction 1
Chapter 2: Background 5

I. Significant Entities and Individuals 5
II. Methodology 6
III. Applicable Law, Regulations, and BOP Policies  7

A. Standards of Conduct 7
B. False Statements and Lack of Candor 8
C. Relevant BOP Policies Regarding the Operation of Correctional Facilities  8

1. Special Housing Units 8
2. Inmate Accountability 9
3. Psychological Screening  10
4. Suicide Response  11

5. Inmate Discipline   12
6. Conditions of Confinement 12
Chapter 3: Timeline of Key Events 14
Chapter 4: Custody and Care of Epstein Prior to His Death 21

I. Epstein's Arrest and Detention on July 6  21
II. MCC New York's Special Housing Unit (SHU) 22
III. Epstein's Initial Cell and Cellmate Assignment from July 7 to July 23 26

IV. Events of July 23 and the Placement of Epstein on Suicide Watch and Psychological Observation
from July 23 to July 30 26

V. The Psychology Department's Post-July 23 Determination that Epstein Needed to Have an
Appropriate Cellmate 30

VI. Selection of Epstein's Cellmate After Psychological Observation 31
VII. Epstein's Cell Assignment from July 30 to August 10 31
VIII. Psychological Evaluations of Epstein from July 6 to August 9 37
Chapter 5: The Events of August 8-10, 2019, and Epstein's Death 45

I. Epstein Signs a New Last Will and Testament on August 8 45
II. Court Order on August 9 Releasing Epstein-Related Documents in Pending Civil Litigation 45
III. Transfer of Epstein's Cellmate on August 9 to Another Institution and Failure to Replace Him with
Another Inmate 45

A. Notice on August 8 of the Impending Transfer of Epstein's Cellmate on August 9 45
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release

B. MCC New York Staff Reject Epstein Attorney's Request that Epstein be Housed Without a
Cellmate 46
C. Removal on August 9 of Epstein's Cellmate from MCC New York 46

D. Failure to Assign Epstein a New Cellmate on August 9 47
1. Day Watch Staff Actions on August 9 47
2. Evening Watch Staff Actions on August 9 50

IV. Epstein is Allowed to Make an Unmonitored Telephone Call on August 9 52
V. Failure to Conduct SHU Inmate Counts and Staff Rounds on August 9-10 55

A. SHU Inmate Counts 55
1. The 4:00 p.m. SHU Count on August 9 56
2. The 10:00 p.m. SHU Count on August 9 58

3. The 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. SHU Counts on August 10 60
B. Staff Rounds in the SHU 61
1. Correctional Officer Rounds 61

2. Lieutenant Rounds 63
VI. Epstein's Death on August 10 64
A. Discovery of Epstein Hanged in Cell and Emergency Response 64

B. Items Found in Epstein's Cell on August 10 Following His Death 70
C. Autopsy Results 72
Chapter 6: The Availability of Limited Recorded Video Evidence Due to the Security Camera Recording
System Failure 74

I. Background on the Security Camera System at MCC New York 74
II. Discovery of Security Camera System Recording Issues in August 2019 75

A. Discovery on August 8 of the DVR 2 Failure that Occurred on July 29 75
B. Response on August 8 and 9 to Discovery of the Recording Failure 76

C. SHU Camera Locations and Operational Status on August 10 77
D. FBI Forensic Analysis of the DVR System 82
Chapter 7: Conclusions and Recommendations 84

I. Conclusions 84
A. MCC New York Staff Failed to Ensure that Epstein Had a Cellmate on August 9 as Instructed by
the Psychology Department on July 30 88

1. Failure to Make Required Notifications Regarding the Need to Assign Epstein a New
Cellmate 88
2. Failure to Adequately Supervise SHU Staff 90
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release

3. Failure to Have a Contingency Plan for Assigning Epstein a Cellmate  91
4. Lack of Candor 91
B. MCC New York Staff Failed to Conduct Mandatory Rounds and Inmate Counts Resulting in
Epstein Being Unobserved for Hours Before His Death 92

1. Failure to Conduct Rounds and Inmate Counts in the SHU 92
2. False Statements and Lack of Candor 93
3. Poor Judgment Regarding the Use of Overtime 94

4. Clearing the 10:00 p.m. Institutional Count Knowing that It Was Inaccurate 95
5. Failure to Adequately Supervise SHU Staff and Conduct Lieutenant Rounds 96

C. MCC New York Staff Allowed Epstein to Place an Unmonitored Telephone Call on August 9 97
D. MCC New York Staff Failed to Conduct and Document Cell Searches and Eliminate Safety
Hazards in Epstein's Cell on August 9 Leaving Epstein with Excessive Linens in His Cell 98

E. MCC New York Staff Failed to Ensure that the Institution's Security Camera System was Fully
Functional Resulting in Limited Recorded Video Evidence 99
II. Recommendations 100
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Chapter 1: Introduction
The Department of Justice (DOJ) Office of the Inspector General (OIG) initiated this investigation upon the
receipt of information from the Federal Bureau of Prisons (SOP) that on the morning of August 10, 2019, in
the Metropolitan Correctional Center located in New York, New York (MCC New York), inmate Jeffery Epstein
was found hanged in his assigned cell within the Special Housing Unit (SHU). The SHU is a housing unit
where inmates are securely separated from the general inmate population and kept locked in their cells for
approximately 23 hours a day, to ensure their own safety as well as the safety of staff and other inmates.
Epstein had been placed in the SHU on July 7, 2019, the day after his arrest, due to the significant media
coverage of his case and awareness of his notoriety among MCC New York inmates.

According to information obtained by the OIG during the investigation, at approximately 8:00 p.m. on
August 9, all SHU inmates, including Epstein, were locked in their cells for the evening. Additionally, the six
separate tiers or groups of cells within the SHU were also securely locked. At approximately 6:30 a.m. on
August 10, 2019, SHU staff unlocked the door to the SHU tier in which Epstein's cell was located in order to
deliver breakfast to inmates through the food slots in the locked cell doors. When SHU staff entered the tier
to deliver breakfast to Epstein, SHU staff knocked on the locked door to Epstein's cell. Epstein, who was
housed alone in the cell, did not respond to SHU staff. SHU staff unlocked the cell door and found Epstein
hanged in his cell, with one end of a piece of orange cloth around his neck and the other end tied to the top
portion of a bunkbed in Epstein's cell. Epstein was suspended from the top bunk in a near-seated position
with his buttocks approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half off the floor and his legs extended straight out on
the floor in front of him. Epstein's cell contained an excess amount of prison linens, as well as multiple
nooses that had been made from torn prison linens.

SHU staff immediately activated a body alarm, which notified all MCC New York staff of a medical
emergency and prompted MCC New York staff assigned to the Control Center to call for 911 emergency
services. SHU staff then ripped the orange cloth away from the bunkbed, which caused Epstein's buttocks
to drop to the ground. SHU staff laid Epstein on the ground and immediately initiated cardiopulmonary
resuscitation (CPR). At approximately 6:33 a.m., other MCC New York employees responded to the SHU. A
responding MCC New York Lieutenant took over administering CPR and asked SHU staff to retrieve an
automated external defibrillator and call for the duty nurse. A Clinical Nurse responded and continued to
perform CPR on Epstein in the place of the Lieutenant. At approximately 6:39 a.m., Epstein was placed on a
stretcher and moved by medical staff to the MCC New York Health Service Unit.2 The Clinical Nurse
continuously administered CPR until he was relieved by outside Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs)
when they arrived at the Health Services Area minutes later. The EMTs continued CPR, incubated Epstein,
and administered medication and fluids in their efforts to revive him. At approximately 7:10 a.m., Epstein
was transported by the EMTs in an ambulance to New York Presbyterian Lower Manhattan Hospital, where
he was pronounced dead by an emergency room physician at 7:36 a.m. On August 11, 2019, the Office of
the Chief Medical Examiner, City of New York, performed an autopsy on Epstein and determined that the
2 Moving an inmate requiring outside emergency medical care to the Health Services Unit provides health care staff and
Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs) with immediate access to any necessary medical equipment and supplies, and
allows EMTs faster access to the inmate when they arrive at MCC New York because correctional officers can directly
escort EMTs to the Health Services Unit to begin emergency treatment immediately. If EMTs had to be escorted to the
housing unit, they would first need to be thoroughly screened, which would delay medical attention.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
cause of death was hanging and the manner of death was suicide.

The OIG conducted this investigation jointly with the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), with the OIG's
investigative focus being the conduct of BOP personnel. Among other things, the FBI investigated the cause
of Epstein's death. The FBI determined that there was no criminality pertaining to how Epstein had died.
This report concerns the OIG's findings regarding MCC New York personnel's custody, care, and supervision
of Epstein during his detention at the facility from his arrest on July 6, 2019, until his death on August 10,
2019.

The OIG investigation and review identified numerous and serious failures by MCC New York staff, as well as
multiple violations of MCC New York and BOP policies and procedures. Among the most significant was the
failure to assign Epstein a new cellmate on August 9, 2019, after Epstein's cellmate was transferred out of
MCC New York that day. Epstein was required to have a cellmate at all times pursuant to a written direction
that the MCC New York Psychology Department issued on July 30 after Epstein was removed from suicide
watch and psychological observation following a possible attempted suicide by him on July 23. As a result of
the failure to assign him a new cellmate, Epstein was housed alone in his cell from the night of August 9
until he was found hanged in his cell by SHU staff at approximately 6:30 a.m. the following morning. In
addition, we determined that SHU staff failed to conduct required inmate counts and rounds, including
overnight on August 9-10, and allowed Epstein to have an excess of blankets, linens, and clothing in his cell.
These failures compromised Epstein's safety, the safety of other inmates, and the security of the institution,
and provided Epstein an opportunity to commit suicide while locked alone in his cell on the morning of
August 10 without having been subject to overnight observation or supervision by SHU staff.
The OIG also found that an MCC New York supervisor had allowed Epstein, in violation of BOP policy, to
make an unrecorded, unmonitored telephone call the evening before his death to an individual with whom
he allegedly had a personal relationship. Further, 2 days before his death, during a meeting with his lawyers
in a private room at the MCC New York, Epstein signed a new Last Will and Testament, which MCC New York
officials did not learn about until after his death.

Additionally, the OIG determined that MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU, including the two SHU staff
on duty the night of August 9-10, 2019, who were stationed at a desk that was directly outside the SHU tier
in which Epstein was housed and diagonally across from Epstein's cell, had falsified BOP records to claim
that they had conducted all of the required counts of inmates and 30-minute rounds during their shifts
within the SHU. As described in greater detail in Chapter 2, inmate counts and 30-minute rounds are two
means by which the BOP accounts for inmates and assesses their safety, security, and well-being. BOP and
MCC New York policies require that staff members count all inmates in each housing unit within the facility
at designated times each day. Additionally, SOP and MCC New York policies require that a staff member
observe all SHU inmates at least once during the first 30 minutes of each hour (e.g., 12:00 a.m. to 12:30
a.m.) and again during the second 30 minutes of the hour (e.g., 12:30 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.), thus ensuring that
inmates are observed at least twice per hour. BOP staff are required to document inmate counts and 30-
minute rounds on official BOP forms, which are often referred to as "count slips" and "round sheets."3
3 These BOP forms are officially entitled "Official Count Slip" and "MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute Check
Sheet."
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
During the OIG's investigation, the OIG obtained information that the staff assigned to the MCC New York
SHU did not conduct any counts of inmates within the SHU from August 9, 2019, at approximately 4:00 p.m.,
until Epstein was found hanged in his cell on the morning of August 10, 2019. However, in documentation
completed by the SHU staff on duty during that period, staff members falsely certified in the count slips that
they had conducted the required counts. Additionally, the OIG investigation revealed that the staff assigned
to the MCC New York SHU did not conduct any required 30-minute rounds of inmates after approximately
10:40 p.m. on August 9, 2019. Again, however, SHU staff on duty during that period had falsely certified in
the round sheet that the required rounds were conducted. The combination of these and other failures led
to Epstein being unmonitored and locked alone in his cell, which the OIG found contained an excessive
amount of bed linens, from approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 until he was discovered hanged in his cell
at approximately 6:30 a.m. the following day.
While the OIG determined that MCC New York staff committed significant violatio
York policies and falsified records related to their conducting inmate counts and rou
uncover evidence that contradicted the FBI's determination regarding the absence of cr
connection with how Epstein died. All MCC New York staff members who were interviewe
they did not know of any information suggesting that Epstein's cause of death was something other than
suicide. Additionally, none of the 15 inmates who agreed to be interviewed in connection with this
investigation, 10 of whom were housed in the SHU on August 9 and 10, had any credible information
suggesting that Epstein's cause of death was something other than suicide. Further, the SHU staff and the
three interviewed inmates with a direct line of sight to the door of Epstein's cell from their cells stated that
no one entered or exited Epstein's cell after the SHU staff returned Epstein to his cell on the evening of
August 9, which is consistent with the security measures in place within the MCC New York SHU. SHU staff
told the OIG that at approximately 8:00 p.m. on August 9, all SHU inmates were locked in their cells for the
evening and that there was no indication that any of the other inmates could have gotten out of their cells.
Additionally, the OIG analyzed the available recorded video of the SHU, which was limited to the common
area of the SHU, including the SHU Officers' Station, due to the MCC New York security camera system's
recording issues that we detail in this report. 4 The OIG's analysis of the recorded video did not identify any
correctional officers or other individuals approaching any of the SHU tiers, including the L Tier where
Epstein was housed, from the common area of the SHU between approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and
approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10.
OP and MCC New
e OIG did not
ity in
the OIG said
Finally, the Medical Examiner who performed the autopsy detailed for the OIG why Epstein's injuries were
more consistent with, and indicative of, a suicide by hanging rather than a homicide by strangulation. The
Medical Examiner also cited to the absence of debris under Epstein's fingernails, marks on his hands,
contusions to his knuckles, or bruises on his body that evidenced Epstein had been in a struggle, which
would be expected if Epstein's death had been a homicide by strangulation.

As discussed in greater detail in Conclusions and Recommendations chapter of this report, this is not the
first time that the OIG has found significant job performance and management failures on the part of BOP
personnel and widespread disregard of SOP policies that are designed to ensure that inmates are safe,
secure, and in good health. The OIG has investigated numerous allegations related to the falsification of
official SOP documentation concerning inmate counts and rounds, and has repeatedly found deficiencies
4 For reasons we describe below, while the camera inside the L Tier was working and transmitting live video, the video
was not being recorded.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
with the BOP's staffing levels, the custody and care of inmates at risk for suicide, and security camera
systems at BOP institutions. The combination of negligence, misconduct, and outright job performance
failures documented in this report all contributed to an environment in which arguably one of the most
notorious inmates in SON custody was provided with the opportunity to take his own life. The BOP's
failures are troubling not only because the BOP did not adequately safeguard an individual in its custody,
but also because they led to questions about the circumstances surrounding Epstein's death and effectively
deprived Epstein's numerous victims of the opportunity to seek justice through the criminal justice process.
The fact that these failures have been recurring ones at the SOP does not excuse them, and gives additional
urgency to the need for DOJ and BOP leadership to address the chronic problerlaguing the SOP.
Unless otherwise noted, the OIG applies the preponderance of the evidence standard in determining
whether DOJ personnel have committed misconduct. The U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board applies this
same standard when reviewing a federal agency's decision to take adverse action against an employee
based on such misconduct. See 5 U.S.C. § 7701(c)(1)(8) and 5 C.F.R. § 1201.56(b)(1)(ii).
11In Chapter 2 of this report, we provide background information, including identification an description of
significant entities and individuals; a summary of our methodology; and the applicable laws, federal
regulations, and BOP policies. In Chapter 3, we outline a timeline of key events. In Chapter 4, we set forth
our findings of fact relating to the SON custody and care of Epstein before his death. In Chapter 5, we set
forth our findings of fact related to the events of August 8-10, 2019, including Epstein's death. In Chapter 6,
we set forth our findings of fact related to the BOP's failure to ensure that there was a functional security
camera system at MCC New York, which resulted in limited recorded video evidence relevant to Epstein's
death. Finally, Chapter 7 contains our conclusions and recommendations.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Chapter 2: Background
I. Significant Entities and Individuals
Jeffrey Epsteinwas born in 1953 and, prior to his arrest, worked at various jobs in the financial industry and
ultimately developed considerable wealth. On July 2, 2019, a federal grand jury of the U.S. District Court for
the Southern District of New York returned an indictment that charged Epstein with engaging in sex
trafficking and a sex trafficking conspiracy, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 371, 1591(a), (b)(2), and 2. These
charges were based on allegations that between 2002 and 2005, Epstein paid girls as young as 14 years old
hundreds of dollars in cash each for engaging in sex acts with him at his Florida and New York residences.
The indictment further alleged that Epstein also paid each of these minor victims hundreds of dollars in
cash to recruit other girls to engage in sex acts with Epstein.

On July 6, 2019, Epstein was arrested at Teterboro Airport in New jersey upon his return to the United States
from France and was transported to the Federal Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) Metropolitan Correctional Center,
located at 150 Park Row in New York, New York (MCC New York). Following a detention hearing on July 15,
2019, the court ordered that Epstein be detained pending trial based on the court's finding that he was a
danger to the community and a flight risk.

MCC New York is a federal administrative detention facility operated by the BOP that primarily provides
pretrial detention services for the U.S. District Courts for the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York.
The BOP temporarily closed MCC New York in October 2021 due to substandard conditions that are
unrelated to this investigation. When it was operational, MCC New York housed approximately 750 inmates
at any given time. Prior to its closure, the majority of MCC New York's inmate residents were individuals
with pending criminal charges (as opposed to individuals who had been convicted of offenses and were
serving a sentence of imprisonment), but whom the court had determined under applicable law should
remain in custody pending trial either because they represent a danger to the community, a substantial
flight risk, or both. MCC New York has several different housing units. Epstein was initially assigned to MCC
New York's general inmate population, but on July 7, 2019, he was moved to the Special Housing Unit (SHU)
pending reclassification due to the significant increase in media coverage and awareness of his notoriety
among the other inmates. The SHU is a housing unit within MCC New York where inmates are securely
separated from the general inmate population, and kept locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours per
day, to ensure their own safety as well as the safety of staff and other inmates.

Correctional Officer Tova Noel and Material Handler Michael Thomas began working together in MCC New
York SHU at 12:00 a.m. on August 10, 2019.5 During their shift, they each created and submitted falsified
official BOP forms documenting inmate counts (often referred to as "count slips"), and Noel completed and
signed more than 75 separate entries on an official BOP form documenting 30-minute rounds (often
referred to as a "round sheet") falsely stating that she and Thomas had conducted such rounds when, in
5 Noel worked her regular shift in the SHU from 4:00 p.m. to 12:00 a.m. on August 9, 2019, followed by an overtime shift
in the SHU from 12:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. on August 10, 2019. Thomas did not work his regular 4:00 p.m. to 12: 00 a.m.
shift as a Material Handler in a different location of MCC New York and instead worked an overtime shift in the SHU
from 12:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. on August 10, 2019.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
fact, they had not. 6
On November 19, 2019, a federal grand jury of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York
returned an indictment that charged Noel and Thomas with one count each of conspiracy and multiple
counts each of falsification of records, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 371, 1001(a)(3), and 2. The indictment
alleged that on August 9, 2019, Noel failed to conduct the mandatory 4:00 p.m. and 10:00 p.m. counts of
inmates in the MCC New York SHU, and that on August 10, 2019, both she and Thomas failed to conduct the
mandatory 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. counts and mandatory 30-minute rounds within the MCC
New York SHU. The indictment further alleged that Noel and Thomas created, certified, and submitted false
documentation indicating that the counts and rounds had been done as required to conceal their failure to
perform their assigned duties. As a result, it appeared from documentation that prisoners in the SHU,
including Epstein, were being regularly monitored when, in fact, no correctional officer had checked on
Epstein from approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9, 2019, until approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10, 2019,
when Epstein was found hanged in his cell.

On May 25, 2021, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York entered into deferred
prosecution agreements with Noel and Thomas. Their respective agreements, which are part of the court
record in their cases, included admissions by Noel and Thomas that they falsely certified that they had
conducted counts and rounds. The agreements also required each of them to truthfully and completely
disclose all information related to their activities and employment with the BOP; be interviewed by the U.S.
Attorney's Office of the Southern District of New York, the FBI, and the OIG; complete 100 hours of
community service; refrain from violating the law; and fulfill other conditions related to pretrial supervision
and their establishment of good behavior. On December 13, 2021, after Noel and Thomas successfully
fulfilled the terms of their deferred prosecution agreements as determined by the prosecutors, the U.S.
District Court for the Southern District of New York entered a nolle prosequi order and dismissed all charges
pending against them. Prosecution was declined by the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of
New York for other BOP employees assigned to the SHU who also falsely certified inmate count slips and
round sheets on the day before and the day of Epstein's death.

As discussed in greater detail in Chapter 7 of this report, the OIG found that, in addition to Noel and
Thomas, many other MCC New York staff members engaged in administrative misconduct, exercised poor
judgment, and/or failed to adequately perform their assigned duties.
II. Methodology
During the course of this investigation, the OIG interviewed 54 witnesses, several on more than one
occasion. The witnesses interviewed included Noel, Thomas, and other MCC New York staff assigned to the
SHU on August 9-10, 2019; MCC New York supervisors at the time of Epstein's death, including the Warden,
Associate Wardens, Captain, and Lieutenants; medical staff; staff members responsible for the MCC New
York security camera system; other BOP staff and contractors; and a relative of Epstein, who contacted the
OIG through his attorney and requested to provide information. The BOP employees and contractors we
interviewed included employees involved in various aspects of the emergency response, who worked at
6 These SOP forms are officially entitled " Official Count Slip" and "MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute
Check Sheet: Each of the six tiers in the SHU had a separate round sheet, each of which had 13 entries reflecting 30-
minute rounds were conducted, when they were not, in fact, completed.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
MCC New York in the days leading up to the response and following the response, as well as other
individuals with information pertinent to our investigation. Additionally, the OIG participated in interviews
of 15 inmates who had been housed at MCC New York during time periods relevant to our investigation,
including three who were housed in the L Tier of the SHU on the day Epstein died.' Those three L-Tier
inmates were housed in cells opposite Epstein's cell and therefore had a direct line of sight to Epstein's cell
on the night of August 9-10. The OIG also reached out to one of Epstein's attorneys to discuss the possibility
of providing information, but ultimately the attorney declined to be interviewed, citing attorney -client
privilege and issues related to ongoing litigation involving Epstein's estate.

The OIG also collected over 127,000 documents, as well as MCC New York video and photographs. Among
these were BOP documents, including staff rosters; daily logs and reports; investigative and incident
reports; documentation regarding inmate counts and 30-minute rounds; inmate housing assignment
documentation; inmate transfer documents; Psychology Department reports and medical records relating
to Epstein; Epstein's institutional phone call records; MCC New York records of Epstein's visits with his
attorneys; electronic communications, including text messages and emails of BOP employees and
contractors; MCC New York security camera surveillance video; records from contractors regarding the MCC
New York security camera system; service records for MCC New York's security camera system; MCC New
York photographs, including photographs taken of efforts to revive Epstein on the morning of August 10,
2019; BOP policies and program statements; MCC New York Post Orders; and financial records. The OIG
also conducted forensic analysis of the computers located in the SHU and BOP cellular telephones. In
addition, the OIG reviewed FBI investigative records, including interview reports (FD-3025), notes from
witness interviews and other meetings, and electronic communications. The OIG also reviewed Epstein's
autopsy report and interviewed the Medical Examiner who performed the autopsy on Epstein.
Ill. Applicable Law, Regulations, and BOP Policies
A. Standards of Conduct
I
The Standards of Ethical Conduct for Employees of the Executive Branch sets out general principles that are
designed to "ensure that every citizen can have complete confidence in the integrity of the Federal
Government." 8 Among other things, these standards require that every federal employee "use official time
in an honest effort to perform official duties."9 The ethical regulations also mandate that federal employees
not use federal property "for other than authorized activities."10
BOP policy (Program Statement 3420.11, Standards of Employee Conduct) imposes several additional
standards of conduct on its employees. At all times BOP employees must "[Conduct themselves in a
manner that fosters respect for the Bureau of Prisons, the Department of Justice, and the U.S. Government."
Because "Mnattention to duty in a correctional environment can result in escapes, assaults, and other
incidents," BOP employees "are required to remain fully alert and attentive during duty hours." BOP policy
The U.S. Attorneys Office for the Southern District of New York sought Interviews from inmates housed in the L Tier of
the SHU on the night that Epstein died, each of whom was represented by counsel. Three inmates agreed to be
Interviewed. The OIG does not have the authority to compel or subpoena testimony from individuals who are not
Department employees.
a 5 C.F.R. § 2635.101(a).
g 5 C.F.R. § 2635.705(a); see also 5 C.F.R. § 2635.101(b)(5).
70 5 C.F.R. § 2635.101(b)(9); see also 5 C.F.R. § 2635.704(a).
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
provides that employees can use government property for authorized purposes only, and further specifies
that personal use of government office equipment, such as computers, "will not take place during official
working hours." BOP policy requires that employees "obey the orders of their superiors at all times."

B. False Statements and Lack of Candor
Under federal law, "whoever, in any matter within the jurisdiction of the executive...branch of the
Government of the United States, knowingly and willfully...makes or uses any false writing or document
knowing the same to contain any materially false, fictitious, or fraudulent statement or entry" has violated
18 U.S.C. § 1001(a)(3). The terms "knowingly and willfully' mean that the subject acted with knowledge that
the conduct was, in a general sense, prohibited by law. It is not required that the subject was aware of the
existence of Section 1001.

Under BOP standards of conduct discussed above, employees are required to cooperate fully with official
investigations, which includes providing "all pertinent information they may have" and "truthfully responding
to questions."
C. Relevant BOP Policies Regarding the Operation of Correctional Facilities
1. Special Housing Units
Special Housing Units within BOP facilities are governed by federal regulations, 28 C.F.R. §§ 541.21-541.33.
These regulations provide that the BOP may establish Special Housing Units (SHU) "where inmates are
securely separated from the general inmate population." These regulations and BOP policy (Program
Statement 5270.11, Special Housing Units) explain that inmates in the SHU are either on administrative
detention or disciplinary segregation status. Administrative segregation status is a non-punitive designation
that removes an inmate "from the general population when necessary to ensure the safety, security, and
orderly operation of correctional facilities, or protect the public." There are several reasons an inmate can
be placed in administrative detention status, including when an inmate's presence in the general inmate
population presents a threat to self or others, or when administrative detention status is necessary for the
protection of the inmate. Assignment to the SHU for protection reasons can be based on being a victim of
an assault, acting (or being perceived) as an informant, refusing to enter general population, or because of
staff concerns about the inmate's safety.

Inmates in the SHU are securely separated from general population inmates and are kept locked in their cell
when in their assigned tier within the SHU. As discussed in greater detail in Chapter 4, witnesses told the
OIG that SHU inmates are locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day. BOP policy provides that,
weather and resources permitting, SHU inmates will have the opportunity to exercise outside their quarters
5 hours per calendar week. Under federal regulations and BOP policy, SHU inmates ordinarily have the
opportunity to shower at least three times a week, typically on different days in 1-hour periods. SHU
inmates may also be escorted from their cells by MCC New York staff for visits, including legal visits, court
appearances, medical and psychological attention. The MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that all
visitors to the SHU be documented in a visitor log, and that any inmate visiting the SHU, such as inmates on
work details, be searched visually and with a hand-held metal detector, without exception. The MCC New
York SHU Post Orders also require that food carts be searched inside and out before being brought into a
SHU cellblock and that all meals be delivered to each inmate's cell through the food slot in the inmate's
locked cell door.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
BOP policy provides that inmates housed in the SHU for 30 continuous calendar days are to be examined
and interviewed by a mental health staff member to assess the inmate's adjustment and the threat
presented to self or others.

BOP policy also requires that all staff assigned to the SHU participate in quarterly training on, among other
things, orderly supervision, suicide prevention, and security procedures relating to the unit. When a staff
member is assigned to the SHU at the last-minute and has not completed the quarterly training, the staff
member must be advised of the general requirements of a SHU post and be permitted to ask questions
about the duties.
2. Inmate Accountabilityll
a. Counts
Inmate counts serve an important security function, as they enable correctional officials to ensure that all
inmates are accounted for and present at the appropriate location within the facility. BOP policy requires
that each institution "conduct, at a minimum, five official inmate counts during every 24-hour period," and
that on "weekends and holidays an additional count will be conducted at 10:00 a.m." At least one count a
day during the week and two counts a day on weekends and holidays must be "stand-up counts," which
means that inmates are required to stand when they are counted. MCC New York SHU Post Orders
designate that counts must occur at 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., 5:00 a.m., 4:00 p.m., and that stand-up counts are
to be conducted at 10:00 p.m. daily and also at 10:00 a.m. on weekends and federal holidays.
The BOP requires that each count be conducted by at least two officers, one of whom will count the inmates
while the other observes the unit for any unauthorized movement from the end of the tier. This
requirement is also set out in the MCC New York SHU Post Orders. The two officers will then switch roles
and compare the count numbers. If the totals do not match, then the officers must conduct another count
in the same manner. When conducting the count, officers are required to observe each inmate's body and
not rely solely on movement or sound. Officers conducting the count relay the count verbally to the Control
Center, which maintains the master count of all inmates, and then remain in the unit until the Control
Center accepts the count. If a count reported verbally does not match the master count, then the Control
Center must notify the Operations Lieutenant and the staff members must recount the inmates. If the
second count does not match the master count, then the Operations Lieutenant will order a bed-book
count, that is, when inmates are counted using their picture cards, which are on file in the Control Center. A
lieutenant must conduct at least one count in the morning and one in the evening.

Correctional staff prepare count slips for each count, which must be prepared in ink, signed by both officers,
and retained for 30 days. Count slips may not be altered. BOP policy provides that the "official count will
not be cleared until all count slips are received and verified in the Control Center."

b. 30-Minute Rounds
The BOP uses additional accountability measures for inmates who are in administrative detention or
11 This section describes inmate accountability measures that are most relevant to this investigation and review. The
BOP utilizes a variety of other security and inmate accountability tools in addition to those discussed in this section,
which are described in BOP Program Statement 5500.14, Correctional Services Procedures Manual.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
disciplinary segregation, i.e., for those detained in a SHU. In such cases, a correctional staff member must
observe all inmates at least twice an hour, once during the first 30 minutes (e.g., 12:00 a.m. to 12:30 a.m.)
and again during the second 30 minutes (e.g., 12:30 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.). BOP policy provides that these
"rounds are to be conducted on an irregular schedule and no more than 40 minutes apart." These same
requirements for rounds are also described in the Post Orders for the MCC New York's SHU.

c. Documentation Regarding Inmate Status and Confinement
BOP policy also provides that each institution must prepare a daily change/transfer sheet, which indicates
changes to an inmate's status, including housing and job assignments and medical convalescence. The MCC
New York SHU Post Orders require that correctional staff assigned to the SHU create a SHU file for each
inmate housed in that unit and that morning watch officers audit the inmate files every night. The MCC New
York SHU Post Orders further specify that all pertinent information about an inmate's confinement should
be noted on a Special Housing Unit Record Form (BP-292), and that SHU officers must maintain a log of
pertinent information regarding inmate activity and enter such information into the BOP computer system
TRUSCOPE, which provides institution staff with detailed inmate and institution security-related information
and provides unit officers an electronic event log.

d. Cell Searches
BOP policy requires that BOP staff routinely and irregularly search housing units to, among other things,
maintain sanitary standards and eliminate safety hazards.12 The MCC New York SHU Post Orders require
that officers assigned to the SHU conduct searches of the SHU common areas and cells. During the
morning watch (12:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m.), SHU staff are required to search the common areas; during the day
watch (8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m.), SHU staff are required to search every inmate's cell who attends recreation;
and during the evening watch (4:00 p.m. to 12:00 a.m.), SHU staff are required to conduct at least five cell
searches. The Post Orders further require that the entire SHU be searched every week. BOP policy and
MCC New York SHU Post Orders require written documentation of each housing unit search.

3. Psychological Screening
a. Initial Screening
Pursuant to BOP policy governing inmates in pretrial detention status (Program Statement 7331.04, Pretrial
Inmates), all pretrial inmates must have an initial risk/needs assessment screening within 48 hours of
admission to the institution. The goal of this screening is to determine "the inmate's security, medical,
psychological, and/or other special needs." The BOP also requires that institutions screen pretrial inmates
"returning from court, as events at court may alter the inmate's separation and/or security needs." BOP
policy further recognizes that there are often "high security, high profile inmates" who may present a
significant threat to themselves or others, and that the "need to identify and monitor these inmates
regularly is paramount."
b. Suicide Prevention
The BOP's suicide prevention program is governed by federal regulations, 28 C.F.R. §§ 552.40-552.42, which
require the BOP to establish a suicide prevention program to identify and manage potentially suicidal
inmates. Pursuant to these regulations, when an inmate is identified as being at-risk for committing suicide,
12 BOP Program Statement 5521.06, Searches of Housing Units, Inmates, and Inmate Work Areas.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
BOP staff must place the inmate on suicide watch until the inmate is no longer an imminent risk.
BOP policy (Program Statement 5324.08, Suicide Prevention Program) requires that medical staff screen all
new inmates, ordinarily within 24 hours, for signs of suicidality. However, at MCCs, among other facilities
with high rates of admissions and short lengths of stays, "comprehensive psychological intake conducted by
Psychology Services ordinarily will be performed only on inmates who are suspected of being suicidal or
appear psychologically unstable." Inmates in the SHU are monitored more closely, and inmates exhibiting
signs of potential suicide risk are referred to the shift lieutenant. BOP policy recognizes that inmates who
are placed in the SHU due to a request for protective custody are at greater risk of committing suicide and
should therefore be screened for suicidal ideation within 72 hours of arriving in the SHU. SOP policy
explicitly states that "staff must never take lightly any inmate suicide threats." Any staff member who has
reason to believe that an inmate may be suicidal should "ordinarily maintain the inmate under direct,
continuous observation."
Every SOP institution must have one or more rooms, ordinarily in the health services area, dedicated to
inmates placed on suicide watch. Suicide watch may be conducted by specially trained staff or inmates. For
inmates placed on suicide watch, the specially trained staff or inmate maintains continuous observation of
the inmate believed to be at risk of committing suicide. Following suicide watch and based on clinical
findings following a face-to-face evaluation, the inmate will be removed from suicide watch or transferred to
a medical referral or health care facility. Psychological observation is a less restrictive form of individual
monitoring that is used for inmates who are stabilizing and not yet prepared for placement in general
population or restrictive housing. While on suicide watch, the inmate is normally required to wear a suicide
watch gown and will be allowed a suicide watch blanket.

As discussed in greater detail in Chapter 4, witnesses told the OIG that an inmate is placed on suicide watch
when the inmate is believed to be imminently suicidal. During suicide watch, the inmate is under constant
observation by staff; the cell lights are on 24 hours a day; and the inmate is given a special mattress,
blanket, and smock to wear. Although psychological observation is a lower classification, witnesses told the
OIG that at MCC New York the psychological observations was the same as suicide watch except that
inmates were allowed to have their clothing and some materials, such as books, as determined by the
Psychology Department. At MCC New York, psychological observation was used to see how an inmate was
doing before releasing the inmate to a housing unit

4. Suicide Response
Recognizing that failure to appropriately respond to an emergency can jeopardize the safety of staff and
inmates and the security of the institution, the BON Standards of Employee Conduct require that
"employees respond immediately, effectively, and appropriately during all emergency situations." The MCC
New York General Housing Unit Post Orders outline the required response to a suspected inmate suicide.
These orders require that MCC New York staff notify the Operations Lieutenant and Control Center of the
situation. The orders further provide that, once there is adequate staff present, immediate action must be
taken to open the inmate's airway and initiate cardiopulmonary resuscitation, even if MCC New York staff
believe that that the inmate "has been dead for a period of time." MCC New York staff are to continue
cardiopulmonary resuscitation until they are relieved by medical staff or another rescuer. The SOP policy
governing crime scenes and the collection of evidence provides that the need to immediately attend to an
apparent suicide victim, undertake lifesaving measures, and ensure inmate and staff safety take precedence
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
over efforts to preserve a crime scene.13
5. Inmate Discipline
Federal regulations, 28 C.F.R. §§ 541.1-541.8, and BOP policy (Program Statement 5270.09, Inmate Discipline
Program) establish an inmate discipline program, which is designed to ensure the safety, security, and
orderly operation of correctional facilities, as well as the protection of the public. The inmate discipline
program applies to all inmates in BOP custody, including inmates with pending criminal charges. One of the
guiding principles of this program is that BOP staff are to take disciplinary action when and to such a degree
as necessary to regulate the behavior of inmates to promote a safe and orderly institution. "Tattooing or
self-mutilation" is among the prohibited acts sanctioned through the inmate discipline program. This
prohibited act falls within the second most severe category of offenses on a 4-tier scale. The SOP defines
"tattooing or self-mutilation" as "No put indelible patterns on the skin; to injure, disfigure or make imperfect
by removing or irreparably damaging parts of the body (wrist cutting falls within this offense)."16 The
definition does not make an explicit reference to suicide attempts other than inclusion of "wrist cutting."
Among other things, BOP policy addressing the inmate discipline program identifies the prohibited acts,
describes the process for adjudicating violations, and lists applicable penalties for each category of offense.
As relevant to this matter, the discipline process begins when a staff member observes an inmate commit a
prohibited act and issues a report documenting the incident. A BOP supervisor then investigates the alleged
inmate misconduct, which includes taking a statement from the inmate regarding the incident. If an inmate
appears to be mentally ill at any stage of the disciplinary process, a mental health staff member will
examine the inmate and assess the inmate's competency to participate in the disciplinary process. If the
inmate is found to be competent and the prohibited act falls into the first or second most severe category,
the matter is referred to a discipline hearing officer, who will hold a hearing and make a determination as to
whether the inmate committed the prohibited act and, if so, impose any of the sanctions that correspond to
the severity of the prohibited act. At the hearing, the inmate is advised of his or her rights and permitted to
choose a staff representative, make a statement, and call witnesses. The inmate is also allowed to appeal
the outcome through the BOP's administrative remedy program.

6. Conditions of Confinement
a. Telephone Calls
The federal regulations, 28 G.F.R. §§ 54O.1OO-54O.1O6, that govern telephone calls for inmates require that
the Warden of each BOP institution establish procedures to monitor inmate telephone conversations, which
is "done to preserve the security and orderly management of the institution and to protect the public." For
safety and security reasons, BOP policy (Program Statement P5264.O8, Inmate Telephone Regulations)
requires that all inmate telephone calls be made through the Inmate Telephone System. BOP policy
recognizes that "on rare occasion, during times of crisis," inmates may be permitted to make a telephone
call outside of the Inmate Telephone System. In such circumstances, the telephone "must be placed in a
secure area (e.g., a locked office)," and "must be set to record telephone calls." Additionally, the staff
member coordinating the call must notify the BOP's Special Investigative Services via email, providing the
inmate's name and register number, the date and time of the call, the number and name of the individual
13 BOP Program Statement 551O.14, Crime Scene Management and Evidence Control, is a restricted policy that is not
released to the public in its entirety.
74 BOP Elements of Prohibited Acts.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
called, and the reason for the call. The Special Investigative Services must enter this information into the
telephone recording system within 7 days.
b. Personal Effects, Medication, and Linens
Federal regulations governing BOP Special Housing Units provide that inmates in administrative detention
status ordinarily may have a reasonable amount of personal property. 15 Under SOP policy regarding
Special Housing Units, the personal property of SHU inmates "may be limited or withheld for reasons of
security, fire safety, or housekeeping."16 The SOP Chief Pharmacist issues medication each workday for
inmates in the SHU. Restricted medications are administered to inmates during daily SHU rounds. Each
institution determines "the medication(s) and amount (number of days) an inmate in SHU may maintain in
their cell." Inmates may also purchase pre-approved over-the-counter medications at the commissary. MCC
New York General Housing Units Post Orders provide that when an inmate is released or transferred out of
a housing unit, the inmate will remove all limited and government -issued clothing from the cell in which the
inmate was previously housed. These Post Orders further specify that all cells are to be cleaned daily by
inmates occupying the cell, and that blankets, towels, and other linens will not be used as rugs or hung over
inmate bunk beds at any time. Pursuant to these Post Orders, MCC New York housing unit officers on all
three shifts are responsible for maintaining "a high level of sanitation" and a "safe and clean environment"
O
is 28 C.F.R. § S41.31(hX1).
76 BOP Program Statement 5270.11, Special Housing Units.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Chapter 3: Timeline of Key Events
Except as otherwise noted, the following information is derived from the Federal Bureau of
Prisons (SOP) records and OIG interviews.
September 21-24, The BOP awards contracts to two companies (Company 1 and 2) to
2018 upgrade the security camera system at Metropolitan Correctional Center
in New York, New York (MCC New York). At the time, images from the
MCC New York's analog video cameras are recorded to a Digital Video
Recorder (DVR) system, which is divided into two DVR systems. Cameras
assigned to the DVR 1 system record only to the DVR 1 hard drives, and
cameras assigned to DVR 2 system record onIC the DVR 2 hard drives.
March 17, 2019 In connection with MCC New York's upgrade of its security ca
system, the BOP's Northeast Regional Office begins arranging fo
technicians from other BOP institutions to perform temporary duty (TDY)
assignments to MCC New York to perform necessary mechanical,
electrical, plumbing, and wiring work. However, during the course of the
TDY rotations, work is not consistently conducted on the camera upgrade
because sometimes TDY staff are used to cover shortages at MCC New
York's custody posts. S
July 2, 2019 According to court records, a federal grand jury of the U.S. District Court
for the Southern District of New York returns an indictment charging
Epstein with sex trafficking and conspiracy to commit sex trafficking.
July 6, 2019 Epstein is arrested at an airport in New Jersey and is transported for
detention pending his initial court appearance to the MCC New York as a
pretrial detainee. Epstein is placed in the general inmate population and
medically screened.
July 7, 2019 An MCC New York Facilities Assistant asks the Psychology Department to
evaluate Epstein because he appears "distraught, sad, and a little
confused." Epstein is assigned to the MCC New York's Special Housing
Unit (SHU) because of significant media attention and his notoriety
among other MCC New York inmates."
77 The SHU is a housing unit within MCC New York where inmates are securely separated from the general inmate
population and kept locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day, to ensure their own safety as well as the
safety of staff and other inmates.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
July 8, 2019 According to court records, Epstein is arraigned in federal court and
enters a plea of not guilty to all charges. The court sets a detention
hearing for July 15, 2019.
MCC New York staff conducts a routine intake screening of Epstein, the
records of which indicate that Epstein denies a history of any mental
health problems. After the Chief Psychologist consults with the National
Suicide Prevention Coordinator from BOP's Central Office, the Psychology
Department conducts a further evaluation of Epstein after his return from
court. Records show that Epstein denies any suicidal thoughts but was
placed on psychological observation due to the presence of risk factors
(high-profile case, nature of the charges, pre-trial status, and ongoing
proceedings).
July 9, 2019 The Psychology Department administers a formal, in-person suicide risk
assessment for Epstein. The Psychology Department continues
psychological observation for another day pending a suitable housing
placement.
July 10, 2019
July 11, 2019
July 15, 2019
July 16, 2019
July 18, 2019
The Psychology Department removes Epstein from psychological
observation and returns him to the SHU with a recommendation that he
have a cellmate. Epstein is housed with another inmate (Inmate 1).
An MCC New York psychologist meets with Epstein briefly and
recommends an additional follow-up visit the following week.
According to court records, Epstein appears in court for his detention
hearing.
At Epstein's request, an MCC New York psychologist meets with him
during a legal visit.
According to court records, Epstein appears in court for a ruling on the
issue of detention. The court orders that Epstein be detained pending
trial because he presents a danger to the community and he is a flight
risk.
The Psychology Department conducts 30-day psychology reviews for the
entire SHU population. Epstein is not in the SHU at the time and
therefore is not reviewed.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
July 22, 2019 According to court records, Epstein files an appeal of the courts order
denying Epstein pretrial release.
July 23, 2019
July 24, 2019
July 25-29, 2019
At approximately 1:27 a.m., SHU staff hears noises coming from Epstein's
cell. Epstein's cellmate (Inmate 1) says that Epstein has attempted to
hang himself. SHU staff observes Epstein lying on the floor with a piece
of orange cloth around his neck. Epstein initially tells MCC New York staff
that his cellmate tried to kill him. Epstein's cellmate (Inmate 1) tells MCC
New York staff that while he was asleep, he felt something hit his legs and
when he turned on the light, he saw Epstein with a string around his neck
and called the guards.16
Epstein is transferred out of the SHU and placed on suicide watch.
Later that morning, Health Services Unit personnel conduct a medical
assessment and observes that Epstein has a red mark two-thirds of the
way around the front and sides of his neck. The BOP assesses Epstein for
risk of suicide and determines that he should remain on suicide watch.
At approximately 8:45 a.m., Epstein is removed from suicide watch but
remains in the same cell and is under psychological observation. Medical
staff examines Epstein at 1:08 p.m. and Psychological Services staff
completes a Post Suicide Watch Report. In contrast to his statement the
previous day, Epstein says he does not remember how he sustained the
injuries to his neck.
Epstein is seen by the Psychology Department daily and on each date
adamantly denies suicidality or having any memory of what occurred on
July 23, 2019.
July 29, 2019 Psychology Department staff determined that Epstein may be released
from psychological observation and return to the SHU.19
Disk failures occur in DVR 2 of MCC New York's security camera system,
la  When interviewed by the OIG, another inmate housed in the same SHU tier (Inmate 2) at the time of the July 23
incident said he heard Inmate 1 call for assistance, and that Inmate 1 later told him that Epstein had tried to kill 
himself
by hanging himself from the bunkbed ladder.

19 The investigation revealed that Epstein was originally scheduled to return to the SHU on July 29, 2019, but at his
request he remained on psychological observation until July 30, 2019. The GOP's SENTRY database, which is a BOP
database that contains information relating to the care, classification, subsistence, protection, discipline, and 
programs
of federal inmates, was not updated to reflect this change because it indicated that Epstein was transferred back to the
SHU on July 29, 2019.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
which results in the system being unable to record, although the cameras
continue to work and broadcast live video feed. MCC New York personnel
do not learn of the DVR 2 recording failure until August 8, 2 days before
Epstein's death. Roughly half of MCC New York's security cameras,
including those located in the SHU, are assigned to record to the DVR 2
system.
July 30, 2019 Epstein is transferred back to the SHU.20
An MCC New York Staff Psychologist from the Psychology Department
sends an email to over 70 BOP staff members stating that Epstein "needs
to be housed with an appropriate cellmate." Epstein and his new cellmate
(Inmate 3) are placed in a cell within the SHU that can accommodate the
electrical needs of Epstein's medical device.
MCC New York conducts disciplinary proceedings against Epstein for
alleged self-mutilation and ultimately concludes that there is insufficient
evidence to find that Epstein engaged in a prohibited act.21 When Epstein
is psychologically evaluated in connection with the disciplinary
proceedings, he says he does not remember how he sustained the marks
around his neck.
MCC New York personnel attempt to obtain an estimate from Company 1
to run the wiring and conduit for the new camera system, which would
eliminate the need for BOP technicians to perform the work.
July 31, 2019 According to court records, Epstein appears in court for a status
conference, at which time the court sets deadlines for motions and
responses. Upon his return to MCC New York, the U.S. Marshals Service
provide paperwork to BOP that indicates Epstein had "suicidal
tendencies."
The Psychology Department conducts a clinical visit with Epstein, who
denies any suicidal ideation.
August 1, 2019 MCC New York Receiving and Discharge staff notify the Psychology
Department of the notation of "suicidal tendencies" on U.S. Marshals
20 The OIG's investigation revealed that at some point after he returned to the SHU from suicide watch and
psychological observation, Epstein asked two different MCC New York staff members if he can be housed with the same
cellmate Epstein initially said tried to kill him.

21 The SOP's inmate discipline program and the offense with which Epstein was charged is further described in Chapter
2.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Service paperwork relating to Epstein. The Psychology Department
conducts a suicide risk assessment of Epstein, who denies that he is
suicidal, and determines that suicide watch is not warranted. Follow-up is
recommended in 1 week.
August 2, 2019 MCC New York Special Investigative Services complete its investigation
into the incident on July 23, 2019, and finds that there is insufficient
evidence to determine that Epstein harmed himself or that he was
harmed by his cellmate.
August 8, 2019 Epstein is seen by the Psychology Department and denies suicidal
ideation, intention, or plan.
August 9, 2019
Epstein meets with his attorneys and, unbeknownst to MCC New York
personnel, changes his Last Will and Testament during the meeting.
MCC New York staff receive notice that Epstein's cellmate will be
transferred out of the institution the following day, August 9.
MCC New York staff discover the disk failures that occurred in the DVR 2
system on July 29 and that resulted in approximately one half of the
institution's security cameras not recording, although the cameras
continued to broadcast a live video feed. MCC New York staff do not
perform the work necessary to restore recording functionality of the DVR
2 system or address long-standing performance failures with the
institution's camera system.
At approximately 8:30 a.m., Epstein's cellmate (Inmate 3) is transferred
out of MCC New York. Two MCC New York SHU staff members said they
notified supervisory staff of Epstein's cellmate's transfer and Epstein's
need for a new cellmate. Other witnesses did not corroborate these
statements. Epstein is not assigned a new cellmate as required by the
Psychology Department.
Sometime between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 a.m., Epstein meets with his
attorneys in the attorney conference room. Epstein's attorneys ask MCC
New York staff members if Epstein could be moved to a different housing
unit or housed without a cellmate.
MCC New York staff obtain the replacement hard drives to repair the
institution's security camera system but do not complete the repairs
necessary to restore recording functionality and address long-standing
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
performance failures with the institution's DVR 2 system.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit unseals approximately
2,000 pages of documents in civil litigation involving Ghislaine Maxwell,
who is later convicted in December 2021 of conspiring with Epstein to
sexually abuse minors over the course of a decade. Some of these
documents contain information that may relate to the criminal charges
pending against Epstein. There is extensive media coverage of
information in the unsealed documents.
At approximately 6:45 p.m., Epstein leaves the attorney conference room.
At approximately 7:00 p.m., contrary to BOP policy but with the
permission of a Unit Manager, Epstein is permitted to place an
unmonitored telephone call to a number in the New York City area,
purportedly to speak with his mother. In actuality, Epstein speaks with
someone with whom he allegedly has a personal relationship. After the
call, Epstein is returned to his cell, where he remains without a cellmate.
MCC New York SHU staff members do not conduct the 4:00 p.m. or 10:00
p.m. inmate counts. After approximately 10:40 p.m., SHU staff members
do not conduct the required 30-minute rounds.
August 10, 2019 MCC New York SHU staff members do not conduct the 12:00 a.m., 3:00
a.m., or 5:00 a.m. inmate counts or any of the 30-minute rounds from
12:00 a.m. until approximately 6:30 a.m.
At approximately 6:30 a.m., SHU staff begin to deliver breakfast to
inmates in the SHU through the food slots in the locked cell doors. When
SHU staff attempt to deliver breakfast to Epstein, SHU staff unlock the
door to the tier in which Epstein's cell was located and then knock on the
door to Epstein's cell. Epstein, who is housed alone in the cell, does not
respond to SHU staff. SHU staff unlock the cell door and find Epstein
hanged in his cell, with one end of a piece of orange cloth around his neck
and the other end tied to the top portion of a bunkbed in Epstein's cell.
Epstein is suspended from the top bunk in a near-seated position with his
buttocks approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half off the floor and his
legs extended straight out on the floor in front of him.
SHU staff immediately activate a body alarm, which notifies all MCC New
York staff of a medical emergency and prompts MCC New York staff in the
Control Center to call for 911 emergency services. SHU staff then rip the
orange cloth away from the bunkbed, which causes Epstein's buttocks to
drop to the ground. SHU staff lay Epstein on the ground and immediately
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
initiate cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). At approximately 6:33 a.m.,
BOP medical staff respond to the SHU, continue CPR, apply the
automated external defibrillator, and move Epstein to MCC New York's
Health Services Unit. Minutes after arriving in the Health Services Unit, an
ambulance arrives and paramedics continue CPR, incubate Epstein, and
administer medications and fluids. At approximately 7:10 a.m., the
ambulance takes Epstein to New York Presbyterian Lower Manhattan
Hospital, where he is pronounced dead at 7:36 a.m. by the emergency
room physician.
MCC New York staff unsuccessfully attempts to recover video from the
DVR 2 system of the SHU and the FBI seizes all hard drives contained in
the DVR 2 system as evidence. The BOP begins repairing the DVR 2
system.

August 11, 2019 The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, City of New York, performs an
autopsy on Epstein.
August 14-15, 2019
August 16, 2019
The FBI returns to MCC New York and seizes additional components of
the DVR 2 system and the entire DVR 1 system. The FBI's Digital Forensics
Analysis Unit in Quantico, Virginia, subsequently begins to conduct a
forensic analysis of MCC New York's DVR systems and determines that
there was catastrophic disk failures in the DVR 2 system disk array, and
no recordings were available on the DVR 2 system after July 29, 2019.
The Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, City of New York, releases its
findings publicly that the cause of death was hanging and that the
manner of death was suicide.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Chapter 4: Custody and Care of Epstein Prior to His Death
I. Epstein's Arrest and Detention on July 6
On July 2, 2019, a grand jury of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York returned a two-
count indictment that charged Epstein with committing sex trafficking and a sex trafficking conspiracy, in
violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 371, 1591(a), (b)(2), and 2, based on allegations that he sexually exploited and
abused dozens of minor girls, some as young as 14 years old, at his homes in New York and Florida. The
indictment alleged that from at least 2002 through 2005, Epstein enticed and recruited girls, many of whom
he knew were underage, to visit his homes and perform sex acts in exchange for paying each girl hundreds
of dollars in cash. The indictment further alleged that Epstein, working with employees and associates,
created a vast network of underage victims to sexually exploit in New York and Florida by paying some
victims hundreds of dollars in cash each to recruit other minor girls to be similarly abused by Epstein. In
addition to the two criminal charges, the indictment also contained forfeiture allegations, which sought to
forfeit to the United States any property that was either used to commit or was a proceed of the charged
sex trafficking offense, including Epstein's New York residence.

On Saturday, July 6, 2019, Epstein was arrested at Teterboro Airport in New Jersey upon his return to the
United States from France. He was transported to the Metropolitan Correctional Center located in New
York, New York (MCC New York), where he was initially placed in the general inmate population. MCC New
York is a federal administrative detention facility operated by the Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP). The BOP
temporarily closed MCC New York in October 2021 due to substandard conditions that are unrelated to this
investigation. When it was operational, MCC New York housed primarily pretrial detainees who had not yet
been convicted of any offense, but whom the court had determined under applicable law should remain in
custody pending trial either because they represent a danger to the community, a substantial flight risk, or
both. Due to the significant media attention surrounding his arrest and his notoriety among other MCC
New York inmates, the following day Epstein was moved to MCC New York's Special Housing Unit (SHU), a
housing until within MCC New York where inmates are securely separated from the general inmate
population, and kept locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours per day, to ensure their own safety as
well as the safety of staff and other inmates. On Monday, July 8, 2019, Epstein appeared in federal court
and pleaded not guilty to the charges. The court ordered that Epstein remain in custody pending a
detention hearing scheduled for July 15, 2019.

At the detention hearing, Epstein sought to be placed in home detention at his New York residence with
electronic monitoring and other conditions. The prosecutors sought to have Epstein detained at MCC New
York pending trial. The court reviewed the parties' filings and heard argument on the matter of pre-trial
release on July 15, 2019. On July 18, 2019, the court ordered that Epstein be detained pending trial. In its
ruling, the court noted that because Epstein had been indicted for a violation of the federal sex trafficking
statute that involved minor victims, there was a presumption in favor of detention under federal law. The
court found that the United States had shown by clear and convincing evidence that Epstein threatened the
safety of another person and of the community based on testimony from two victims, the allegations of
repeated sexual abuse of minors, and the lewd photographs of young-looking women or girls that were
found during an authorized search of Epstein's New York residence in July 2019. The court also relied on the
recommendation of U.S. Pretrial Services, the seriousness of the offenses with which Epstein had been
charged, evidence reflecting Epstein's harassment and intimidation of and tampering with witnesses
involved in a prior Florida state criminal investigation, and Epstein's lack of compliance with his legal
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
obligations as a registered sex offender. The court found that the United States had also shown by a
preponderance of the evidence that Epstein was a flight risk based on the severity of the criminal charges
and severity of the potential punishment the strength of the evidence against Epstein; and Epstein's
criminal history, sex offender registration, vast wealth and substantial liquid assets, multiple residences, a
foreign residence, limited family ties in the United States, private plane(s), extensive overseas travel, and
possession of a foreign passport bearing Epstein's photograph but not his name. Finally, the court found
that Epstein's pretrial release proposal was inadequate because, among other things, it did not contain
sworn, accurate, or comprehensive financial statements; it required excessive court involvement in routine
aspects of the proposed home confinement the proposed consent to extradition was unenforceable; and
the proposed appointment of a trustee to monitor Epstein's compliance with release conditions was
unacceptably vague and problematic due to the potential conflict of interest presented by monitoring the
conduct of a person who paid the trustee's salary, and allegations that Epstein engaged in unlawful acts with
his employees during the sex trafficking conspiracy. Epstein appealed the court's order on July 22, 2019.
This appeal remained pending at the time of Epstein's death.

II. MCC New York's Special Housing Unit (SHU) ‘Nk Epstein was initially assigned to MCC New York's general inmate 
population, but on July 7, 2019, at
approximately 7:20 p.m., he was moved to the SHU pending reclassification due to the significant increase in
media coverage and awareness of his notoriety among other MCC New York inmate residents. The SHU is a
housing unit within MCC New York where inmates are securely separated from the general inmate
population, and kept locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day, to ensure their own safety as
well as the safety of staff and other inmates. Inmates in the SHU are either on administrative detention or
disciplinary segregation status. Administrative segregation status is a non-punitive designation that
removes an inmate from the general population when it is necessary to do so to ensure the safety, security,
and orderly operation of the correctional facility or to protect the public. The MCC New York employee who
was the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant on August 9, 2019, told the OIG that most inmates
housed in the SHU are "locked down" in their cells for most of the day. Other witnesses told the GIG that
SHU inmates are locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day. The Warden of MCC New York
during Epstein's period of detention at that facility, along with Associate Warden 1 and the Acting Evening
Watch Activities Lieutenant, explained that this was one of the reasons that conducting rounds in the SHU
was so important. Unlike inmates in general population housing, SHU inmates could not physically
approach a staff member; therefore, the staff member had to go to each inmate's cell.
Witnesses told the OIG that Epstein's daily routine in the SHU was to meet with his attorneys in the attorney
conference room all day until approximately 8:00 p.m.22 MCC New York attorney logs confirmed that
Epstein had daily visits with attorneys from several different law practices throughout the period of his
detention at MCC New York. This is consistent with the information available in SENTRY, a BOP database
that contains information relating to the care, classification, subsistence, protection, discipline, and
programs of federal inmates, which indicates that Epstein had 1-2 attorney visits on all but 1 day he was
detained at MCC New York. SOP emails reflect that other attorneys expressed frustration to a Supervisory
Staff Attorney with the BOP's Consolidated Legal Center for New York because attorneys had to wait hours
or were unable to meet with their clients because Epstein and his attorneys were occupying the attorney
22 As discussed in Chapter 1, BOP policy provides that SHU inmates may be escorted from their cells by MCC New York
staff for visits, including legal visits, court appearances, medical and psychological attention, showers, and 
recreation.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
conference room, even at times when Epstein had to leave the conference room for a medical visit
At MCC New York, the SHU was located on the south side of the institution's ninth floor and was often
referred to as "9 South." Primary access to the SHU was controlled by a locked door adjacent to the elevator
bay on the north side of the floor (Main Exterior Entry Door). That door was opened remotely by a staff
member in MCC New York's centralized Control Center, which is located on the first floor of the institution.
Access into the SHU from the primary elevator bay was further controlled by a second locked door (Main
Interior Entry Door), to which only one of the correctional officers assigned to the SHU had keys, while on
duty.
Ax .

Secondary access to the SHU was controlled by a locked door adjacent to the elevator bay on the south side
of the floor. That door was opened remotely by a staff member in the centralized Control Center. Access
into the SHU from the secondary elevator bay was further controlled by three additional locked doors, to
which only one of the correctional officers assigned to the SHU had keys, while on duty. The secondary
elevators and access doors were used only by staff when facilitating visits between the SHU inmates and
their outside visitors.

4IL. Within the SHU, inmates were assigned to six separate tiers or groups of cells, three of which were
accessible via stairs leading up from the common area on the ninth floor (Upper Tiers—G, J, and L Tiers) and
three of which were accessible via stairs leading down from the common area on the ninth floor (Lower
Tiers—H, K, and M Tiers). The entrance to each tier could be accessed only via a single locked door at the
top or bottom of the staircase leading to the individual tier. Keys to open the locked tier doors were
available only to one of the correctional officers assigned to the SHU, while on duty. Each tier had eight
cells, each of which could house either one or two inmates. Each individual cell, which was made of cement
and metal, could be accessed only through a single locked door, to which only one of the correctional
officers assigned to the SHU had keys, while on duty. The SHU cell doors were made of solid metal with a
small glass window and small locked slots that correctional staff used to handcuff inmates and provide food
or toiletries to inmates. As a further security measure, during each shift the keys to the SHU tier doors and
SHU cell doors were carried by different officers assigned to the SHU.

As noted above, inmates in the SHU are securely separated from the general inmate population and are
kept locked in their cell when in their assigned tier within the SHU. Witnesses told the OIG that SHU inmates
are locked in their cells for approximately 23 hours a day. SOP policy provides that, weather and resources
permitting, SHU inmates will have the opportunity to exercise outside of their quarters 5 hours per calendar
week. Under federal regulations and BOP policy, SHU inmates ordinarily have the opportunity to shower at
least three times a week, typically on different days in 1-hour periods. SHU inmates may also be escorted
from their cells by MCC New York staff for visits, including legal visits, court appearances, medical and
psychological attention. The MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that all visitors to the SHU be
documented in the SHU visitor log, and that any inmate visiting the SHU, such as inmates on work details, be
searched visually and with a hand-held metal detector, without exception. The MCC New York SHU Post
Orders also require that food carts be searched inside and out before being brought into a SHU cellblock
and that all meals be delivered through the cell door food slot of the locked cell door.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 4.1: Primary SHU Entrance (Ninth Floor)
Main Interior
Entry Door
Figure 4.2: Secondary SHU Entrance (Ninth Floor)
South
Elevato,
I
i i

ej
-1 _ I /
Ie
e
Main Entry Door
(not pictured)
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 4.3: Tiered Structure of SHU (2-Dimensional)
Upper Tiers
Figure 4.4: Tiered Structure of SHU (3-Dimensional)
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 4.5: Stairways Leading to SHU Upper and Lower Tiers
Ill. Epstein's Initial Cell and Cellmate Assignment from July 7 to July 23
According to the Warden, MCC New York typically housed inmates in the SHU with a cellmate. Upon
Epstein's initial transfer to the SHU on July 7, 2019, he was assigned a cell in the M Tier of the SHU with
Inmate 1. The Warden explained that Epstein was a high-profile inmate and that he initially selected Inmate
1 to be Epstein's cellmate because Inmate 1 was another high-profile inmate, and the Warden believed
Inmate 1 to be the least likely SHU inmate to harm Epstein.23 Epstein and Inmate 1 were housed together in
cell Z05-124.
IV. Events of July 23 and the Placement of Epstein on Suicide Watch and Psychological
Observation from July 23 to July 30
According to BOP documents, at approximately 1:27 a.m. on July 23, 2019, Senior Officer Specialists 1 and 2
heard noise coming from the M Tier in the SHU, the tier where Epstein was housed. Senior Officer Specialist
2 documented in a BOP report that upon checking cell Z05-124, he saw Epstein laying down near his bunk
with 'a piece of handmade orange cloth" around his neck, and Senior Officer Specialist 1 wrote in a BOP
report that Epstein's cellmate (Inmate 1) said Epstein had attempted to hang himself. In his interview with
the OIG, Senior Officer Specialist 1 said that Inmate 1, who appeared shaken up, told him that he had been
23 In 2008, Epstein pleaded guilty in a Florida state court to a felony charge of procurement of minors to engage in
prostitution in violation of Florida Statute § 796.03. As a result of this conviction, Epstein was required to register 
as a
sex offender.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
asleep on the floor of the cell and was awoken when he felt Epstein land on him. Senior Officer Specialist 2
reported that after he had been alerted by the noise, he grabbed the door keys, called the Control Center
for assistance, and then he and Senior Officer Specialist 1 entered the cell, where they secured and removed
Epstein's cellmate. Senior Officer Specialist 1 reported that he then reentered the cell, placed Epstein on his
side, and removed an orange homemade rope" from his neck. In his interview with the OIG, Senior Officer
Specialist 1 said Epstein had a sheet around his neck, which was attached to the bunkbed ladder in the cell.
Senior Officer Specialist 1 said that Epstein was sifting on the floor of the cell with his back against the
bunkbed ladder. Senior Officer Specialist l's report said that Epstein was breathing, but unresponsive, so he
began chest compressions, at which time the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant and other staff arrived.
Senior Officer Specialist 1 confirmed in his OIG interview that they started cardiopulmonary resuscitation
but stopped when they realized that Epstein was already breathing. The Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant documented in a BOP report that when she arrived at the SHU, she saw Epstein lying in the fetal
position in his cell, breathing heavily and snoring, wearing only a t-shirt and boxers. The Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant observed that Epstein's neck was red, but she saw no further injuries. She called out
to Epstein, who flickered his eyes and continued snoring. The correctional officers unsuccessfully tried to
get Epstein to stand on his own, and then placed him on a stretcher and took him to the Health Services
Unit.

According to BOP records, at approximately 1:40 a.m., Epstein was transferred out of the SHU and placed on
suicide watch. As previously noted in Chapter 2, inmates on suicide watch are housed in a dedicated room,
typically in the health services area, where they are continuously monitored by specially trained staff or
inmates.

Senior Officer Specialist 3 documented in a BOP report that when he and others responded to the call for
assistance and gained access to the SHU, he saw Epstein lying on the floor of his cell snoring. He and the
other officers verbally instructed Epstein to stand up, but Epstein did not. He and other officers then lifted
Epstein onto a stretcher to remove him from the cell. lip
Senior Officer Specialist 4 wrote in a BOP report that he responded to a body alarm in the SHU and helped
remove Epstein from his cell, placed him on a stretcher, and took him to the second floor for a medical
assessment. Senior Officer Specialist 4 further reported that, while he was observing Epstein in the Health
Services Unit, Epstein told Senior Officer Specialist 4 that he thought his cellmate had tried to kill him.
Epstein further stated that his cellmate had tried to extort him, and that for the last week his cellmate had
threatened to beat him if he did not pay him. Epstein told Senior Officer Specialist 4 he had not reported
this to MCC New York staff, but that he had told his lawyers.

The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant documented in a BOP report that when she returned to the
Health Services Unit, Senior Officer Specialist 4 informed her that Epstein had said that his cellmate had
tried to kill Epstein and had been harassing him. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant then spoke
with the cellmate (Inmate 1), who said he was wearing headphones and was asleep when he felt something
hit his legs. Inmate 1 said he called out to Epstein and when Epstein did not answer, he got up, turned on
the light, and saw Epstein sitting on the floor, leaning to the side with a string around his neck. Inmate 1
told the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant that he then called the guards. Inmate 1 provided a similar
statement to BOP officials at approximately 2:50 p.m. on July 23, 2019.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant's report notes that she also spoke with Epstein, who told her that
he had returned to his cell after an attorney visit at approximately 8:00 p.m. the previous day, at which time
his cellmate was reading the Daily News newspaper. Epstein's said his cellmate turned to a page of the
newspaper that had Epstein's picture and reported that Epstein was worth $77 million. Epstein told the
Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant that he looked at his picture, balled it up, and threw it in the garbage.
Epstein further stated that he woke up at approximately 1:00 a.m. to get a drink of water, returned to his
bunk, and the next thing he remembered was that he was snoring and MCC New York staff were inside his
cell. When asked about the allegations against his cellmate, Epstein said he had been told that if his
cellmate hurt him, MCC New York staff would not care.

Inmate 2, who was housed in the same SHU tier as Epstein on July 23, told the FBI about an incident that
occurred in the SHU around 1:20 a.m. to 1:30 a.m. on an unspecified date. Inmate 2 said he was reading a
book when he heard an inmate scream and bang on the cell door to get the SHU officers' attention. Inmate
2 said he could only see the cell door and not inside. According to Inmate 2, Senior Officer Specialist 2
responded to the cell and then left and returned with additional officers. The FBI was further told by Inmate
2 that the officers opened the cell door, removed an inmate, placed the inmate in handcuffs, and put the
inmate in the shower area. Inmate 2 stated that the officers reentered the cell and Inmate 2 heard a thump
as if something had hit the floor. The officers then pulled the other inmate out of the cell, placed him on a
stretcher, and took him away. Inmate 2 also told the FBI that, later in the evening, around 2:10 a.m. to 2:15
a.m., the correctional officers returned to the cell where the incident had occurred earlier. He said he
further observed the officers clean out the cell and use a video camera to record the inside of the cell.
Inmate 2 said he saw the officers remove from the cell orange clothing items that had been tied together.
Inmate 2 also said that the first inmate to be removed from the cell later told Inmate 2 that he was sleeping
when his cellmate had tried to kill himself by hanging himself from the ladder of the bed.
According to BOP records, medical staff evaluated Epstein at approximately 6:20 a.m. on July 23, 2019, and
observed friction marks and superficial reddening of his neck and one knee. The red mark spanned two-
thirds of Epstein's neck (front and sides) and was 2 inches wide. Epstein told the medical staff that he did
not know what had caused his injuries, and that he went to drink a little water and woke up snoring.
Later that morning, the MCC New York Staff Psychologist conducted a suicide risk assessment and
determined that Epstein should remain on suicide watch. During the assessment, Epstein denied any
knowledge of how he sustained the marks on his neck. The Staff Psychologist noted in the assessment
report that it was unclear whether Epstein had placed the string around his neck or if someone else did.
Medical staff examined Epstein at approximately 1:08 p.m. the following day, July 24, 2019, and observed
that the central part of the red mark on Epstein's neck had some abrasion. According to BOP records,
Epstein told the medical staff that he still did not want to talk about how he sustained his injuries, but he
believed that his cellmate had something to do with it. BOP's Special Investigative Services (SIS) opened an
investigation into this incident but was unable to determine whether Epstein harmed himself or had been
assaulted.

On July 24, 2019, at approximately 8:45 a.m., Epstein was removed from suicide watch. However, Epstein
remained in the same cell that he was placed in the previous day and was under psychological observation
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
until July 30, 2019.24
The MCC New York Chief Psychologist told the OIG that an inmate is placed on suicide watch when the
inmate is believed to be imminently suicidal. During suicide watch, the inmate is under constant
observation by staff; the cell lights are on 24 hours a day; and the inmate is given a special mattress,
blanket, and smock to wear. The Chief Psychologist explained that although psychological observation is a
lower classification, at MCC New York the psychological observations was the same as suicide watch except
that inmates were allowed to have their clothing and some materials, such as books, as determined by
Psychology Department. At MCC New York, psychological observation was used to see how an inmate was
doing before releasing the inmate to a housing unit.

The Chief Psychologist told the OIG that the Psychology Department independently makes the decision who
goes on and off suicide watch. The Chief Psychologist also stated that the Psychology Department makes
recommendations to the institution's management about where inmates are housed when they come off of
suicide watch. According to her, the Psychology Department always recommends that inmates coming off
of suicide watch be housed with other inmates; however, she said the recommendations cannot always be
carried out due to other security factors. When that occurs, the Psychology Department recommends
conducting increased rounds and keeping an eye on those inmates.

The Chief Psychologist further told the OIG that, based on a conversation with the Psychiatrist with the
BOP's Central Office who was the BOP's National Suicide Prevention Coordinator, she passed along to the
MCC New York executive staff the recommendation that Epstein be housed with an alleged sex offender in
the SHU.25 The Chief Psychologist stated that the MCC New York Warden and Associate Wardens decided
who Epstein would be housed with and the Psychology Department was not involved in that decision.
According to BOP records, as a result of the July 23 incident, MCC New York subsequently conducted
disciplinary proceedings against Epstein for alleged self-mutilation, but ultimately found that there was
insufficient evidence to find that Epstein engaged in a prohibited act. When Epstein was psychologically
evaluated on July 30, 2019, in connection with disciplinary proceedings, Epstein said he did not remember
how he obtained the marks around his neck. On August 2, 2019, the SIS investigation into the July 23, 2019,
incident was completed and found insufficient evidence to support either that Epstein had harmed himself
or that he had been harmed by his cellmate.

Senior Officer Specialist 1 told the OIG that after Epstein came off of suicide watch, Epstein asked if he could
be paired up with Inmate 1 again. Senior Officer Specialist 1 told Epstein that his request was something he
would need to raise with the Operations Lieutenant. Senior Officer Specialist 1 told the OIG that Epstein
replied, "Yeah, but I don't understand, you know, we were bunkies, everything was cool." The Chief
Psychologist also told the OIG that Epstein mentioned to her that he wanted Inmate 1 to continue to be his
cellmate.

24 Epstein's BOP medical records reflect that he was removed from psychological observation and returned to the SHU
on July 30, 2019.
25 Neither of Epstein's cellmates at MCC New York were alleged to be sex offenders.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
V. The Psychology Departments Post-July 23 Determination that Epstein Needed to
Have an Appropriate Cellmate
Following the events of July 23, the MCC New York Psychology Department determined that Epstein needed
to be housed with an appropriate cellmate. To ensure Epstein's cellmate requirement was disseminated to
MCC New York staff, on July 30, 2019, at 12:30 p.m., the Staff Psychologist sent an email to over 70 MCC New
York staff members which read, "Inmate Epstein #76318-054 is being taken off Psych Observation and
needs to be housed with an appropriate cellmate." A review of the email recipients showed that the email
was sent to, among others, the Warden, Associate Warden 2, the Captain, the SHU Lieutenant, the SIS
Lieutenant, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Morning
Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, and Correctional Officer 1. The Staff
Psychologist also completed a "Post-Watch Report," which stated that the "SHU L[ieutenant] informed
inmate Epstein needs to be housed with an appropriate cellmate."
The Warden told the OIG that the Chief Psychologist had advised him that Epstein was not suicidal and was
ready to return to the SHU. According to the Warden, when he spoke with the Chief Psychologist regarding
Epstein, she told him to assign Epstein a cellmate. He added that MCC New York would typically house an
inmate who was previously on suicide watch with a cellmate. The Warden stated there was no BOP policy
mandating that an inmate coming off of suicide watch have a cellmate, but they usually housed such an
inmate with a cellmate.

During their interviews with the OIG, Associate Warden 1, the Captain, and the SHU Lieutenant each said
they had verbally informed the SHU staff of Epstein's cellmate requirement and were confident that all SHU
staff members knew of Epstein's cellmate requirement. Additionally, the Captain said he visited the SHU on
multiple occasions and directed his staff to be alert and attentive about Epstein's special needs.
According to Associate Warden 1, the Captain was in charge of correctional services, including the SHU.
Associate Warden 1 said the Captain should have told the SHU Lieutenant, and that the SHU Lieutenant
should have told the SHU staff about the cellmate requirement. Associate Warden 1 further told the OIG
that the SHU Lieutenant was responsible for ensuring that everything within the SHU was in compliance.
Associate Warden 1 told the OIG that the SHU staff knew that Epstein was required to have a cellmate, and
said she personally heard it being discussed on more than one occasion when she would visit the SHU while
performing her rounds.

The Captain, who supervised all of the lieutenants and correctional officers working in MCC New York, said
that after the cellmate requirement was issued for Epstein, he spoke with the SHU Lieutenant and directed
him to ensure that Epstein had a cellmate. Similar to the Warden, the SHU Lieutenant told the OIG that
while there is no BOP policy addressing the necessity of assigning cellmates to individuals coming off of
suicide watch, it was common practice in the BOP for prisoners coming off of suicide watch to be assigned a
cellmate. The SHU Lieutenant confirmed that a BOP psychologist told him that Epstein had to be housed
with a cellmate when Epstein returned to the SHU, and said that he passed the directive down to the SHU
staff.

Additionally, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge on August 9, 2019, said he and all other SHU staff were
aware of Epstein's cellmate requirement. MCC New York Psychology Department personnel told the OIG
Limited Official Use Only-Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
that MCC New York staff members knew of Epstein's cellmate requirement because it was discussed during
staff meetings, department head meetings, SHU meetings, morning meetings, and during required staff
training.

Forensic Psychologist 1 told the O16 that on August 9, 2019, she was present during a meeting in which one
of Epstein's attorneys opposed Epstein having a cellmate. Forensic Psychologist 1 said she explained to the
attorney that Epstein needed to have a cellmate because he was housed in the SHU and he was a sex
offender.
VI. Selection of Epstein's Cellmate After Psychological Observation
The Captain told the OIG that he compiled a list of possible cellmates for Epstein, vetted those inmates, and
provided the list of names to the MCC New York Warden. The Warden told the OIG that he identified two
potential cellmates and tentatively decided on Inmate 3. The Warden said he passed this information on to
the BOP Director's Chief of Staff and later received word that Mould assign Inmate 3 to be Epstein's
cellmate.

The Warden told the O16 that no inmates were pre-vetted to replace Inmate 3 if he left MCC New York. The
Warden and the Captain told the OIG that if Inmate 3 had been removed as Epstein's cellmate, they would
have had to review a new list of potential cellmate candidates to ensure that Epstein was housed with an
appropriate inmate. According to the Warden and the Captain, if Inmate 3 were no longer detained at MCC
New York, SHU staff should have informed a lieutenant on duty, who should have informed the Captain,
who would have ensured that the process of selecting a new cellmate for Epstein would begin.
VII. Epstein's Cell Assignment from July 30 to August 10
As a result of Epstein's cellmate requirement, on July 30, 2019, following his release from psychological
observation, Epstein was initially assigned to cell Z04-206 with Inmate 3 in the J Tier of the SHU.36 A BOP
medical record note reflected that, on this same date, Epstein was provided with his personally -owned
a  \IL
"ur
36 SENTRY, which is BOP's database of information relating to the care, classification, subsistence, protection, 
discipline,
and programs of inmates, inaccurately reflected that this move from his psychological observation cell to the SHU
occurred the previous day (July 29, 2019). The investigation revealed that Epstein was originally scheduled to return to
the SHU on July 29, 2019, but, at his request, he remained on psychological observation until July 30, 2019.
SENTRY was not updated to reflect either the actual date of Epstein's transfer back into the SHU or the cell to which he
and Inmate 3 were assigned after the initial cell change necessitated by the electrical needs of Epstein's medical 
device.
The administrative error in BOP's SENTRY records regarding Epstein's cell assignment had no effect on the events the
OIG investigated and reviewed.

According to OIG interviews with MCC New York staff members, it does not appear that there were any checks to ensure
that inmates were physically located in the cells to which they were assigned in SENTRY. Associate Warden 1 told the
OIG that the error would have been identified if SHU staff members had conducted a bed-book count, but there was no
requirement to do a bed-book count every certain number of days. Associate Warden 1 explained that during a bed-
book count, the staff members have a roster with them while conducting the count of inmates assigned to their housing
unit to ensure all inmates are accounted for and in their assigned cells. The O16's investigation revealed that these 
and
other cell assignment and recordkeeping errors would have been uncovered had MCC New York SHU staff been
undertaking inmate accountability measures, such as rounds, counts, census checks, and bed-book checks.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
medical device. SOP witnesses told the OIG that on that same date, Epstein and Inmate 3 were moved to
cell 206-220 in the L Tier of the SHU to accommodate the electrical needs of Epstein's medical device. Of all
the cells in the SHU, cell Z06-220 was the closest cell with a direct line of sight to the SHU Officers' Station in
the common area of the SHU, which was approximately 15 feet away.

Inmate 3 told the OIG that when he and Epstein were first assigned as cellmates in cell Z06-220 in the L Tier,
the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant told Inmate 3 that he had a "cool bunkie" for him, an "old guy" who
would not bother Inmate 3. Inmate 3 said he told the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant that he slept on the
bottom bunk, and the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant said that would not be a problem because his new
cellmate slept on the floor. Inmate 3 said he was surprised by this response because he understood that
sleeping on the floor was not allowed and he had previously been disciplined for doing so.
When Epstein arrived in the cell, Inmate 3 recognized him and said he (Inmate 3) told the Day Watch
Operations Lieutenant that the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant had "jammed up" Inmate 3. Inmate 3 said
he knew Epstein had tried to hang himself and had just come from suicide watch. According to Inmate 3,
the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant told Inmate 3 not to worry, that Epstein was okay, and that Inmate 3
should keep an eye on him. Inmate 3 asked the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant if he was supposed to
serve as a suicide prevention advocate, that is, an inmate who is assigned to the suicide watch area. Inmate
3 said the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant laughed and brushed off Inmate 3's comment.
According to Inmate 3, correctional officers brought two mattresses to the cell for Epstein and placed them
on the floor. Epstein put the mattresses on the right side of the cell, which is only partially visible through
the cell door window when the cell door is closed. Inmate 3 noted that Epstein also had two extra blankets,
which Inmate 3 said was also unusual because none of the inmates had extra blankets.

Inmate 3 said he asked Epstein to please not kill himself or hang himself while Inmate 3 was his cellmate
because Inmate 3 had a chance to go home soon. Epstein told Inmate 3 not to worry and that he was not
going to cause Inmate 3 any trouble.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 4.6: SHU L Tier
Figure 4.7: Exterior Views of Epstein's Cell
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 4.8: The Door to the Cell Occupied by Epstein and Inmate 3 from July 30 to August 9
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 4.9: View of Epstein's Empty Cell from Cell Door Window
fir
Figure 4.10: Interior View of Epstein's Empty Cell from Just Inside the Cell Door
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release

╭─────────────────────────── Page 44, Image 1 ────────────────────────────╮
│ Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release                        │
│                                                                         │
│ Figure 4.11: View of Epstein’s Cell Door from the SHU Officers’ Station │
│                                                                         │
│ 36                                                                      │
│                                                                         │
│ Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release                        │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
VIII. Psychological Evaluations of Epstein from July 6 to August 9
During Epstein's detention at MCC New York, a variety of medical professionals, including a Medical Doctor,
a Clinical Nurse, and Physician Assistant 1, who is a Mid-Level Practitioner, conducted multiple medical
appointments with Epstein, and Epstein was prescribed a variety of medications for various ailments and
health needs. Epstein was also given an eye and dental exam, as well as a blood panel screening. This
section details Epstein's psychological evaluations while he was in MCC New York custody prior to his death.
On Saturday, July 6, 2019, at 9:38 p.m., upon Epstein's intake into MCC New York, he was medically screened
by Physician Assistant 2. The screening included taking vital signs and asking various medical history
questions, including questions related to Epstein's mental health. Among other things, Physician Assistant 2
annotated that Epstein did not have current suicidal ideation and had denied having a history of suicide
attempts. Physician Assistant 2 instructed Epstein how he could obtain medical, dental, and mental health
care.

At 2:58 a.m. on Sunday, July 7, 2019, a Facilities Assistant emailed the Psychology Department asking that
someone evaluate Epstein because he appeared 'distraught, sad, and a little confused."
On July 8, 2019, Forensic Psychologist 1 of the Psychology Department conducted an Intake Screening of
Epstein that included a self-report, staff observation, and a review of information in SENTRY. Forensic
Psychologist 1 noted that during Physician Assistant l's initial intake evaluation, on the intake questionnaire,
Epstein denied having a history of mental health treatment and any history of mental health symptoms.
Additionally, Forensic Psychologist 1 noted no suicidal ideations, attempts, or self-harm; no history of
substance abuse or treatment; and no sexual offense convictions.

During the evaluation, Epstein stated he had been previously incarcerated for 3 months for "prostitution,"
and that he was currently charged with sex trafficking. Epstein denied recent or present morbid thoughts
and denied passive or active suicidal ideation. It was noted in BOP records that Epstein's verbalizations
were future -oriented and did not have indications of helpless or hopeless thinking.

According to Forensic Psychologist 1, Epstein did not meet the criteria for any psychological diagnosis and
was designated as Mental Health Care Code 1. This is indicative of an inmate who does not show any
significant level of functional impairment associated with a mental illness and does not demonstrate a need
for regular mental health intervention. Epstein was educated on emergency procedures for contacting the
Psychology Department staff, and Epstein agreed to contact staff if he needed Psychology Department
services in the future.

The MCC New York Chief Psychologist told the OIG that based on the Psychological Services Intake
Questionnaire, inmates have four different Care Code ratings. Code 1 means there are no concerns about
the inmate's mental health status; they have no needs and will not be followed up with unless requested by
staff or the inmates. Code 2 means there is some history of mental health issues, but the inmate has them
under control and the Psychology Department will follow up monthly. Code 3 is more severe, requiring
weekly visits by the Psychology Department to ensure the inmate is stable and if unstable would be moved
to observation. Code 4 inmates are seen daily by the Psychology Department and are under constant
psychological observation. The Chief Psychologist stated that a Code 1 inmate can be on suicide watch.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Suicide watch is for inmates who are showing immediate and exigent signs of being suicidal.
Subsequent to the intake screening, on July 8, 2019, the Chief Psychologist consulted with the Psychiatrist
who was the National Suicide Prevention Coordinator from the BOP's Central Office, regarding the various
risk factors associated with Epstein for suicidality. These risk factors were that Epstein was involved in a
high-profile case with media attention, had been charged with sex offenses, was on pretrial status, and
there was the potential for bad news from a court proceeding that day. A determination was made that
upon Epstein's return from court, staff were to notify the psychologist and place Epstein on a "watch status"
until a thorough suicide risk assessment could be conducted.

When Epstein returned from court on July 8, 2019, it was after duty hours and MCC New York staff contacted
the Psychology Department and informed them that Epstein denied suicidality. However, for precautionary
reasons, Epstein was placed on psychological observation status until Psychology Department staff could
conduct a suicide risk assessment the following day. During Epstein's period of psychological observation,
inmate companions continuously observed him and kept a log that detailed Epstein's activities in 15-minute
increments. Under BOP policy, on a case-by-case basis, the Warden may authorize such an inmate
companion program at an institution to utilize inmate observers, who are selected, trained, and supervised
by the institution's Suicide Prevention Program Coordinator.

On July 9, 2019, the Chief Psychologist conducted a suicide assessment of Epstein. She reviewed Epstein's
medical record and interviewed him, which revealed that he possessed some risk factors for suicidality.
Epstein denied having any past or present suicidal ideation, intention, or plan, and also denied having any
history of mental health treatment or any current mental health symptoms. The Chief Psychologist's
assessment was that Epstein had "protective" factors present that could decrease his risk of suicide. The
Chief Psychologist assessed factors that included his willingness to engage in treatment, view of death as
negative, future orientation, and the fact that he adamantly denied any suicidal ideation, intention, or plan.
The Chief Psychologist's assessment was that Epstein had numerous protective factors that outweighed his
risk factors for suicidality and that he had a positive outlook regarding his legal case. Epstein remained on
psychological observation pending a suitable cell assignment, and the Chief Psychologist noted that a
suicide watch was not warranted at the time of her report.

On July 10, 2019, the Chief Psychologist met with Epstein for a psychological observation and noted that,
according to the psychological observation logbook, Epstein had been eating his meals, sleeping, and
interacting with other inmates. During this meeting with the Chief Psychologist, Epstein voiced concerns
over being housed in the SHU. Epstein asked the Chief Psychologist to be "single-celled" if he were to be
housed in the SHU and had also requested a shower, his property, pen, and paper. The Chief Psychologist
stated Epstein had been provided a shower on this date. She provided Epstein with coping skills strategies,
to which he was receptive. Epstein continued to deny any suicidal ideation, intention, or plan; and Epstein
stated he was looking forward to his upcoming court hearing regarding pretrial release. The Chief
Psychologists assessment was that Epstein was psychologically stable at the time and that he could be
released from the psychological observation area. She noted that Epstein would be housed in the SHU with
a cellmate and would be seen the following morning to evaluate his mental status and stability. Following
this July 10 assessment, Epstein was taken off of psychological observation and returned to the SHU with
documented recommendations for a cellmate and next-day contact by the Psychology Department.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
The following day, July 11, 2019, the Staff Psychologist attempted to see Epstein in the morning and
afternoon, but he was meeting with his attorneys. Since the Staff Psychologist was unable to meet with
Epstein, the Chief Psychologist met with Epstein in the attorney conference area for a psychological
observation follow-up. During this meeting, Epstein expressed concerns about a number of issues,
including not yet receiving his property, not having enough water during his attorney conference, and a
desire to attend recreation. Epstein was upset about having to wear an orange uniform and the Chief
Psychologist explained the orange uniform was because he was being housed in the SHU. During this
clinical contact, the Chief Psychologist provided Epstein with additional coping strategies, to which he was
receptive. Additionally, Epstein was educated about routine and emergency procedures for contacting the
Psychology Department staff and reminded of self-help books/audiotapes available through the Psychology
Department Epstein continued to deny any suicidal ideation, intention, or plan and was scheduled to be
seen again the following week. The Chief Psychologist told the OIG that Epstein and his attorney mocked
her for thinking Epstein was suicidal.
S
On July 16, 2019, at Epstein's request, the Chief Psychologist met with Epstein during his torney
conference. The Chief Psychologist noted that Epstein did not have any psychological concerns and denied
suicidality. The Chief Psychologist noted that she provided Epstein with psychoeducation regarding
additional coping strategies. Epstein was educated about routine and emergency procedures to contact
Psychology Department staff and reminded of self-help books and audiotapes that are available to him.
The Chief Psychologist noted in her clinical contact report that there was no need for follow-up and that
Epstein would be seen in the SHU for rounds and monthly SHU reviews.
Ill
11,7
According to the SOP After Action Review submitt hee by t Southeast gional Director, the Chief
Psychologists meeting with Epstein on July 16, 2019, at Epstein's request during his attorney conference was
inappropriate. The Southeast Regional Director wrote in the report that Epstein attempted to "bring his
attorneys into the fray regarding the mental health treatment being provided by the institution." In the
After Action Review, the Southeast Regional Director wrote that it was not typical for the BOP to provide
psychological intervention in the presence of others, nor was it appropriate for a BOP psychologist to meet
with an inmate's attorney. When asked by the OIG about these findings, the Chief Psychologist stated that
the intention was to check on Epstein, not to breach any security.

On July 18, 2019, the Chief Psychologist conducted a monthly SHU review and noted that Epstein was
unavailable due to a meeting with his legal team and that she would attempt to interview Epstein in the near
future to complete his monthly review.

As noted previously, at approximately 1:27 a.m. on July 23, 2019, Epstein was found lying on the floor of his
cell with a piece of homemade orange cloth around his neck. The Chief Psychologist made a general
administrative note in Epstein's file that she was contacted by the Operations Lieutenant at approximately
2:00 a.m., and informed that Epstein was being placed on suicide watch after he was found with a string
loosely hanging around his neck. That morning, Physician Assistant 1 assessed Epstein for injuries and
noted in BOP records that Epstein was cooperative, alert, and oriented. According to BOP's medical records,
Epstein did not appear distressed and was smiling during the clinical assessment Epstein said he did not
know what had happened and could not explain the mark on his neck. Physician Assistant 1 noted that
Epstein had a circular line of erythema, i.e., superficial redness on the skin, that was 2 inches wide and
spanned two-thirds of the way around the front and sides of the base of his neck. According to the BOP
report, one section of the erythema (or redness) in the front of his neck had marks of friction, and there was
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
no inflammation, deformities, hematomas, lacerations, or tenderness. The BOP report stated that Epstein
was able to move his neck without any restriction and denied having any pain, discomfort, or respiratory
problems. Physician Assistant 1 further noted there was another small erythema (or redness) on Epstein's
left knee about 2 centimeters in diameter, which was noted as mild. Physician Assistant l's assessment was
that the injury was unspecified and was self-inflicted.

Also on July 23, 2019, the Staff Psychologist conducted a suicide risk assessment that included a clinical
interview of Epstein and a review of Epstein's medical record, the psychology data system, and a review of
the SENTRY database. According to the Staff Psychologist's report, Epstein denied knowing why he was
placed on suicide watch. SOP records state that Epstein recalled getting a drink of water the night prior and
then went back to bed. Epstein's next recollection was hearing himself snoring. The BOP assessment
records reflect that Epstein wanted to know why he was on suicide watch and he was informed that he had
been found with a string on his neck. The Staff Psychologist noted that it was unclear whether Epstein had
placed the string around his neck or if someone else did. Epstein denied current suicidal or self-harm
thoughts or ever having these thoughts; denied a history of self-harm and suicide attempts; and denied
feeling hopeless and fearing for his safety. Epstein told the Staff Psychologist that he lived to enjoy life and
that his future plans included fighting his criminal case and getting back to his normal life. The Staff
Psychologist noted that Epstein was to remain on suicide watch for further observation. The Staff
Psychologist told the OIG she had advised BOP staff that Epstein would need a cellmate.
The Chief Psychologist said she considered three possibilities to explain the July 23 incident (1) Epstein
and/or Inmate 1 were gaming the system to get something they wanted that they were not getting
(2) Epstein, who really was suicidal, had conducted a rehearsal; (3) Inmate 1 had assaulted Epstein. The
Chief Psychologist told the OIG that after Epstein told her he wanted to be housed with the same cellmate
he originally said had assaulted him, she began to think that the third possibility (assault by Inmate 1) was
less plausible than the other two possibilities, although she did not know for certain.
The following day, July 24, medical staff examined Epstein at approximately 1:08 p.m., and observed that the
central part of the red mark on Epstein's neck had some abrasion. Epstein told the medical staff that he still
did not want to talk about how he sustained his injuries, but he believed that his cellmate had something to
do with it. BOP's Special Investigative Services (SIS) opened an investigation into this incident but was
unable to determine whether Epstein had harmed himself or had been assaulted.

On July 24, 2019, after 31 hours and 5 minutes, Epstein was removed from suicide watch. Epstein remained
in the same cell that he was in under suicide watch and was under psychological observation until July 30,
2019.27 Also on July 24, 2019, Forensic Psychologist 2 completed a Post Suicide Watch Report. According to
Forensic Psychologist 2's report, Epstein continued to claim a lack of memory regarding how he sustained
the scar around his neck. The BOP report further stated that Epstein adamantly denied suicidal ideation,
intentions, and plans, that Epstein identified reasons to live and was future -oriented, and that Epstein was
assessed for a willingness to engage in treatment. The BOP report reflected that Forensic Psychologist 2
inquired further if Epstein could recall the previous days incident and Epstein stated that he had been trying
to remember. Forensic Psychologist 2 asked Epstein why he told another inmate that Epstein's cellmate had
tried to kill him but was now claiming he has no memory of the incident. Epstein told Forensic Psychologist
27 Epstein's BOP medical records reflect that he was removed from psychological observation and returned to the SHU
on July 30, 2019; however, SENTRY inaccurately reflects that Epstein was transferred back to the SHU on July 29, 2019.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
2 that he did not recall himself or his cellmate tying a string or rope around his neck.
Following Forensic Psychologist 2's examination of Epstein, she determined that he should be removed from
suicide watch. Forensic Psychologist 2 told the FBI that she discussed the decision to step Epstein down to
psychological observation from suicide watch with the Chief Psychologist and Associate Warden 2, who both
concurred with her determination. Epstein was therefore taken off suicide watch and placed on
psychological observation, during which time BOP records reflect that he was continuously observed by
inmate companions and seen daily by Psychology Department staff. Forensic Psychologist 2 annotated in
the Post Suicide Watch Report that the reason for removing Epstein from suicide watch was due to Epstein
stating he had no interest in killing himself; he had described having a wonderful life; and Epstein had said it
would be crazy to take his own life and he would not do that to himself. Forensic Psychologist 2 told the FBI
that following her clinical visit with Epstein on July 24, 2019, she was cautious with Epstein's case and his
self-reporting of what had occurred the previous day. Forensic Psychologist 2 stated that she observed
signs of positivity and that Epstein "adamantly denied suicide." Nevertheless, she was not comfortable
taking Epstein off suicide watch and instead opted to place Epstein on psychological observation, which was
a step down from suicide watch. Forensic Psychologist 2 told the FBI that "I made the decision with the
consent" of the Chief Psychologist and Associate Warden 2, with whom she had consulted. Forensic
Psychologist 2 told the FBI that placing Epstein on psychological observation allowed him to possess hygiene
products, two novels, attend legal visits, and take showers. It also allowed him to have standard inmate
clothing, a flex pen, a toothbrush and toothpaste, soap, and deodorant. However, Forensic Psychologist 2
explained that it was not healthy for inmates to stay on suicide watch for extended periods of time and they
are re-evaluated on a day-to-day basis.
Nv/
According to Forensic Psychologist 2's Post Suicide Watch Report, Epstein expressed a feeling of safety being
housed in the psychological observation area rather than the SHU and asked if there was a safer unit for
him to be housed. Forensic Psychologist 2 informed Epstein that he would remain on psychological
observation for the near future, but his long-term housing would need to be revisited because it is not ideal
to remain in psychological observation for extended periods of time. The BOP report states that Epstein
was again educated on routine and emergency procedures for contacting Psychology Department staff.
According to BOP records, between July 25-29, 2019, Epstein was seen daily by the Chief Psychologist or the
Staff Psychologist while he was on psychological observation. On each of these dates, according to BOP
reports, Epstein adamantly denied any suicidality and denied having any memory of what occurred on July
23, 2019, which resulted in him being placed on suicide watch. Additionally, on each date, Epstein was
provided with supportive and coping skill interventions to which he was receptive. BOP records state that
Epstein expressed concerns about being housed again in the SHU because he felt it was dangerous; he
could not sleep well due to noise from other inmates; and it was difficult for him to work on his legal case.
The Chief Psychologist told the FBI and OIG that she met with Epstein on July 25, 2019, and he was in good
spirits. She said that during this clinical visit, Epstein said he was baffled over the July 23, 2019 incident and
asked the Chief Psychologist to give him some cues to help him remember. The Chief Psychologist told the
OIG that she kept Epstein on psychological observation because he had not answered her questions
regarding the possible suicide attempt. The Chief Psychologist told the OIG that she coordinated with the
RCP's National Suicide Prevention Coordinator, who recommended that Epstein be housed with a sex
offender in the SHU. The Chief Psychologist notified Associate Warden 2 of this recommendation via email.
BOP records further reflect that, during his clinical visit on July 28, 2019, Epstein told the Staff Psychologist
that he was agitated for hours the previous night because of a non-stop toilet flushing and that the noise
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
was similar to when he was housed in the SHU. The Staff Psychologist informed Epstein that he would be
moving to a different cell.

On July 29, 2019, according to BOP records, Epstein reported to the Chief Psychologist that his memory of
the July 23, 2019 incident may be impaired because of his sleep apnea. On this date, Epstein was to receive
his personally owned medical device. SOP records state that Epstein was aware he would be returning to
the SHU but reported that he did not feel well due to lack of sleep and other medical concerns. Epstein
asked to stay on psychological observation, where he felt safe, for one more night to get some sleep and
then return to the SHU with a cellmate the following day. According to BOP records, the Chief Psychologist
informed Epstein that he could stay 1 more night and explained that there were no mental health issues
precluding him from returning to the SHU the following day. The Chief Psychologist explained to Epstein
that he would be placed in a safe situation in the SHU. Epstein again was provided supportive interventions
and psychoeducation regarding additional coping strategies. BOP records state that Epstein was somewhat
receptive but more concerned with getting phone calls, recreation, and housing placement concerns.
On July 30, 2019, according to BOP records, Epstein reported to the Staff Psychologist that he had not slept
well, and Epstein discussed how he did not think he would be able to sleep well in the SHU because of the
noise. The Staff Psychologist annotated in the clinical contact summary that documentation revealed
Epstein had eaten and taken a shower the day prior (July 29) and also had eaten breakfast on July 30. The
Staff Psychologist annotated, Epstein did not display indications of disturbed thought process or content
and denied current suicidal or self-harm ideation. BOP records further stated that Epstein agreed to
immediately report to staff if he began to have suicidal or self-harm thoughts, and that Epstein was future -
oriented and did not appear to be a danger to himself. The Staff Psychologist noted in her clinical contact
report that she had consulted with the Chief Psychologist and that psychological observation of Epstein
would be discontinued. According to her clinical contact report, the Staff Psychologist educated Epstein
about routine and emergency procedures for contacting Psychology Department staff and noted that
Epstein would be seen the following day. The Staff Psychologist also noted in her report that the SHU
lieutenant was informed that Epstein needed to be housed with an appropriate cellmate.
Also on July 30, 2019, the Staff Psychologist completed an evaluation of competency related to Epstein being
able to proceed with the disciplinary process. Epstein had been charged by BOP with a prohibited act,
specifically tattooing or self-mutilation, for the incident that occurred on July 23, 2019. In conducting the
evaluation of competency, the Staff Psychologist reviewed the suicide risk assessment completed by the
Chief Psychologist on July 9, 2019, in which Epstein had denied a history of mental health treatment and
having any past or present suicidal ideation, intention, or plan. The Staff Psychologist also reviewed the
suicide risk assessment that she herself completed, dated July 23, 2019, which stated that it was unclear at
the time if Epstein had placed the string around his neck or if it was done by someone else. According to
the Staff Psychologist's notes from her competency evaluation on July 30, the determination of an inmate's
competency to proceed with the disciplinary process was based on a clinical assessment of the inmate's
ability to understand the nature of the proceedings and his or her ability to assist in his or her own defense.
After a review of available psychological and psychiatric records and information related to the offense, the
Staff Psychologist found that Epstein was competent to proceed with the disciplinary process.
That same day, July 30, Epstein was removed from psychological observation and transferred back to the
SHU, consistent with what he had been told by the Chief Psychologist the prior day.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
On July 31, 2019, according to BOP records, Forensic Psychologist 3 conducted a clinical visit with Epstein
and noted that he was in a pleasant mood, generally slept well, and was getting readjusted to being in the
SHU. Epstein told Forensic Psychologist 3 that he was getting along with his cellmate. According to her
report, Epstein explicitly denied recent and current suicidal ideation or intent and denied having thoughts of
harming others. Epstein also agreed to contact staff immediately if he experienced any suicidal thoughts or
psychological distress. Forensic Psychologist 3's report further stated that Epstein was receptive to her
utilization of cognitive behavioral therapeutic techniques. She wrote that there did not appear to be a need
for follow-up at the time and Epstein expressed a willingness to self-refer to Psychology Department staff if
needed. According to the report, Epstein would continue to be seen during routi HU rounds and SHU
reviews.

On August 1, 2019, according to BOP records, SOP Receiving and Discharge staff, who are responsible for
processing inmates who enter or leave the facility, notified the Staff Psychologist that the previous day when
the U.S. Marshals Service (USMS) had brought Epstein back to MCC New York from court, they had provided
a form on which it was noted that Epstein had "suicidal tendencies: The OIG reviewed the USMS Prisoner
Schedule Report for July 31, 2019, as well as the USMS Prisoner Custody Alert Notice that had annotated in
the remarks that Epstein had "Mental Concerns: Suicidal Tendencies". The Chief Psychologist told the OIG
that the USMS annotates suicidal tendencies for many inmates if the USMS was aware the inmate was
previously on suicide watch. Therefore, the Chief Psychologist said the annotation was not abnormal since
Epstein had just come off suicide watch and Epstein may have told the USMS that he had been on suicide
watch.

Following receipt of this information from the Receiving and Discharge staff, the Staff Psychologist
conducted a suicide risk assessment on August 1 that included a review of Epstein's previous clinical
encounters, medical records, and data in the Psychology Department and SENTRY systems. According to
the Staff Psychologist's assessment Epstein denied stating he was suicidal and was surprised that the form
noted that he had suicidal tendencies. The Staff Psychologist said that Epstein told her that the incident
report he received for the marks on his neck arising from the July 23 event had been expunged. The OIG
confirmed that the incident report was expunged. Epstein also said his cellmate talked at night and kept
Epstein awake but that Epstein wanted to give it 3 to 4 more days before determining if he wanted another
cellmate. The Staff Psychologist concluded in her report that Epstein did not appear to be a danger to
himself and denied current suicidal or self-harm ideation and agreed to immediately inform staff if he had
any of these thoughts. Epstein told her that he had social supports in the community and that he had
reasons to live and positive future plans. The Staff Psychologist noted that Epstein was currently
psychologically stable, and that suicide watch was not indicated at the time. The Staff Psychologist
concluded that Epstein's overall acute suicide risk was low, and the overall chronic suicide risk was absent.
Epstein was again provided supportive and educative interventions and educated about routine and
emergency procedures for contacting Psychology Department staff. The Staff Psychologist's report noted
that Epstein would continue to be seen during routine SHU rounds and SHU reviews.

On August 8, 2019, the Chief Psychologist conducted a clinical follow-up session with Epstein. According to
her report, Epstein described his sleep as fair and requested that he be placed in general population. The
report further stated that Epstein denied feelings of depression, anxiety, and any suicidal ideation, intention,
or plan. Epstein told the Chief Psychologist that he received the necessary documentation to make phone
calls and asked if his previous phone calls over the speaker phone counted as his monthly phone contact.
The Chief Psychologist stated in her report that Epstein had no mental health concerns and did not appear
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
to be in any distress. The Chief Psychologist wrote that SHU staff had not reported any unusual behaviors
related to Epstein. She provided Epstein with supportive interventions and psychoeducation regarding
additional coping strategies, to which Epstein was receptive. Epstein was educated on routine and
emergency procedures for contacting Psychology Department staff and also reminded of self-help books
and audiotapes that are available to him. The Chief Psychologist wrote that Epstein would be seen in weekly
SHU rounds and monthly for SHU reviews. The Chief Psychologist told the OIG that the fact that Epstein
underwent three suicide risk assessments was unusual.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Chapter 5: The Events of August 8-10, 2019, and Epstein's Death

I. Epstein Signs a New Last Will and Testament on August 8
In the weeks following Epstein's death, multiple media outlets reported that Epstein signed a new Last Will
and Testament on August 8, 2019. At least one media organization published a copy of the notarized
document showing that it was signed by Epstein and two of his attorneys and notarized on August 8, 2019.
Attorney visitor logs from the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York, New York (MCC New York)
confirmed that those attorneys and the notary public visited Epstein on that date. The OIG confirmed via
court records that the August 8, 2019 will and other probate-related documents were filed in the Superior
Court of the Virgin Islands on August 15, 2019. Among the court filings was an affidavit from another
attorney who stated that she received the August 8, 2019 will from Epstein. The OIG confirmed via attorney
visitor logs that this attorney also visited Epstein at MCC New York on August 8, 2019. The OIG's
investigation and review revealed that MCC New York personnel were unaware that Epstein had changed
his will 2 days before he died.

The Chief Psychologist said she had heard that Epstein had changed his will from media reporting following
his death. The Chief Psychologist did not know if the media reporting was accurate, but she thought that if
it were true, it would have been useful information to know because it would have been a red flag. The Staff
Psychologist and the Chief Psychologist told the OIG that if Epstein's attorneys had notified them or the
Psychology Department that Epstein had changed his will, such information would have been a factor
warranting a review of Epstein's mental state and Epstein probably would have been placed back on suicide
watch or some type of observation.

II. Court Order on August 9 Releasing Epstein-Related Documents in Pending Civil
Litigation
On August 9, 2019, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ordered the unsealing of the summary
judgment filings from a defamation lawsuit filed by a woman who alleged that
Epstein had victimized her when she was a teenager, against Ghislaine Maxwell.28 As a result of the court's
order, that same day approximately 2,000 pages of documents were released into the public domain, some
of which contained information that may have related to the criminal charges pending against Epstein.
Additional high-profile public figures were also named in the released documents. There was significant
media coverage of information contained within the unsealed court filings.
III. Transfer of Epstein's Cellmate on August 9 to Another Institution and Failure to
Replace Him with Another Inmate
A. Notice on August 8 of the Impending Transfer of Epstein's Cellmate on August 9
As noted above, since July 30, consistent with the Psychology Department's determination that Epstein
needed to have a cellmate, Epstein had been housed with Inmate 3, whom the Warden and the Federal
Bureau of Prisons (BOP) executive leadership had selected as an appropriate cellmate. At 10:33 a.m. on
28 Maxwell was subsequently indicted and, in December 2021, convicted of conspiring with Epstein to sexually abuse
minors.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
August 8, 2019, the U.S. Marshals Service (USMS) sent an email to MCC New York personnel assigned to
Receiving and Discharge, the area within the Correctional Services Department that is responsible for
processing inmates who enter or leave the facility, with the subject 'Transfer of Prisoners from NYM [MCC
New York] to GEO."29 The body of the email identified Inmate 3 as one of the prisoners to be transferred
and further stated, "Please schedule the transfer for Friday 8/9/19."
At 3:36 p.m. on the same day, the USMS sent a second email to a number of MCC New York personnel,
including Associate Warden 2, the Captain, the SHU Lieutenant, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, the
Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, another Lieutenant, and the SIS
Lieutenant, with the subject "Prisoner Production 08-09-2019." This email contained two attachments, one
of which was the Prisoner Schedule Report for MCC New York for August 9, 2019. The first page of this
attachment reflects that Inmate 3 was scheduled to be transferred from MCC New York to GEO (Queens
Detention Facility) on August 9, 2019. This attachment also includes the acronym 'WAB" within the
Destination/Description portion of the document, which MCC New York personnel told the OIG means "with
all belongings." During their OIG interviews, MCC New York staff members further explained that the 'WAB"
notation meant that Inmate 3 was being permanently removed from MCC New York on August 9, 2019.
Notwithstanding this email, as detailed below, several of the email recipients identified above, including the
Captain, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, and the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that
they believed Inmate 3 had gone to court on August 9, and they did not know he had been transferred to
another facility.

B. MCC New York Staff Reject Epstein Attorney's Request that Epstein be Housed
Without a Cellmate
Forensic Psychologist 1 told the OIG that on August 9, 2019, she was present during a meeting in which one
of Epstein's attorneys opposed Epstein having a cellmate. Forensic Psychologist 1 explained to the attorney
that because Epstein was housed in the SHU and he was a sex offender, he needed to have a cellmate.
Additionally, the OIG investigation revealed that on the day of Epstein's death, a Supervisory Staff Attorney
with the BOP's Consolidated Legal Center for New York, sent an email to the Warden to inform him that on
the previous day (August 9, 2019), two of Epstein's attorneys separately contacted him. One of the attorneys
asked for Epstein to be moved to a different, specific housing unit within MCC New York; the other attorney
asked for Epstein to be housed without a cellmate in the SHU. The Supervisory Staff Attorney said he
informed the first attorney that the suggested housing unit was not available for pretrial detainees such as
Epstein, and he said he told the second attorney that Epstein could not be housed without a cellmate
because of his prior suicide attempt.
C. Removal on August 9 of Epstein's Cellmate from MCC New York
According to MCC New York reports, including the Daily Log and the Lieutenant's Log, on August 9, 2019, at
approximately 8:38 a.m., Epstein's cellmate, Inmate 3, was 'pre -removed" and transferred out of MCC New
York in a routine, pre-arranged transfer. The Daily Log tracks inmate movements throughout MCC New
York each day, while MCC New York lieutenants utilize the Lieutenant's Log to document the daily activities
29 GEO refers to the Queens Detention Facility, a contract detention facility located in Queens, New York, that is
managed by The GEO Group, Inc.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
that took place within the institution during their respective shifts.

The Supervisory Correctional Systems Specialist was the supervisor of Receiving and Discharge on August 9,
2019, and was responsible for overseeing all inmate movements in and out of the institution that day. The
Supervisory Correctional Systems Specialist verified that Receiving and Discharge would have used the
USMS emails sent on August 8, 2019, to coordinate Inmate 3's transfer out MCC New York, and since Inmate
3 was listed as 'WAB" on the USMS emails, that meant he was being transferred from the facility and not
coming back. She explained to the OIG that if Inmate 3 had been going to court, as many pretrial inmates
held at MCC New York often did, the Daily Log would have reflected "court" rather than "pre-remove." Since
the Daily Log listed Inmate 3 as "pre-remove," the Receiving and Discharge personnel who entered the
information into the report were made aware that Inmate 3 was being transferred from MCC New York on
or before the morning of August 9, 2019. The Supervisory Correctional Systems Specialist told the OIG that
the language in the USMS emails ("WAIL" i.e., "with all belongings") and MCC New York reports ("pre-
removed") made it clear that Inmate 3 would not be returning to the SHU or MCC New York.
The OIG also interviewed the Correctional Systems Officer, who was the Receiving and Discharge officer who
handled inmate movement in and out of MCC New York on August 9, 2019. The Correctional Systems
Officer confirmed that the Daily Log reflected that Inmate 3 was "pre-removed" on August 9, 2019, at 8:38
a.m., because he was being officially moved from the institution to another prison. She explained to the
OIG that the ordinary process was that Receiving and Discharge personnel would enter the information
regarding Inmate 3 into SENTRY, along with information pertaining to other inmates who would be leaving
their MCC New York housing units. Receiving and Discharge used this information to create the daily call
out list, which had all of the inmates' names and times that they were to be moved. The Correctional
Systems Officer told the OIG that the call out list from August 9, 2019, was no longer available because the
call out lists were printed and hand-delivered to the housing units each day, and then discarded by the units
at the end of the day. She also said each days call out list was only maintained electronically for a 24-hour
period, and then it was updated (overwritten) with the next day's list. In her OIG interview, the Correctional
Systems Officer explained what would have occurred on this date based on her experience. Receiving and
Discharge personnel would have printed copies of the call out list for August 9, 2019, which the MCC New
York internal officer would distribute to the various housing units within the facility. Based on the other
records reflecting Inmate 3's transfer, the Correctional Systems Officer said the call out list created for
August 9, 2019, would have listed 'WAG" next to Inmate 3's name, which meant that he was departing from
the institution and not returning.

Correctional Officer 1 told the OIG that on the morning of August 9, 2019, he and Day Watch SHU Officer in
Charge escorted Inmate 3 to Receiving and Discharge and Epstein to his legal visit.
D. Failure to Assign Epstein a New Cellmate on August 9
1. Day Watch Staff Actions on August 9
The SHU Lieutenant told the OIG that he worked at MCC New York on August 8, 2019, from approximately
6:00 a.m. until approximately 2:00 p.m., and that he was off on August 9, 2019. The SHU Lieutenant, whose
shift ended over an hour before the USMS sent the second email regarding Inmate 3's impending transfer,
told the OIG he was not aware that Inmate 3 was scheduled to be transferred out of MCC New York, and
therefore he did not notify the Captain that Epstein would require a new cellmate. According to the SHU
Lieutenant, as soon as the SHU staff learned that Inmate 3 would be transferred, they should have notified a
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Lieutenant on duty. The Day Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant told the
OIG that on August 9, 2019, they had oversight of the SHU from approximately 6:00 a.m. until 2:00 p.m. due
to their position descriptions and because of the SHU Lieutenants absence.

According to the MCC New York Staff Roster, on August 9, 2019, SHU Officer #1 was listed as Senior Officer
Specialist 5. Although SHU Officer #1 is typically the Officer in Charge, another Senior Officer Specialist told
the OIG that, in actuality, he was the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge on August 9 from approximately 6:00
a.m. until 2:00 p.m. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that since he had the most experience and
seniority, he was considered by everyone to be the SHU Officer in Charge, which the SHU Lieutenant
confirmed. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he knew that Epstein had to have a
cellmate. He said that, as a general practice, every inmate who is transferred from suicide watch and/or
psychological observation to the SHU is placed with a cellmate. He also confirmed that the SHU Lieutenant
had instructed him that Epstein was to be housed with a cellmate at all times. According to the Day Watch
SHU Officer in Charge, between July 30 and August 9, 2019, he told all other MCC New York staff members
who worked in the SHU of Epstein's cellmate requirement and further stated that everyone who worked in
the SHU should have known that Epstein was required to have a cellmate due to their knowledge, training,
and experience.

The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge confirmed that on the morning of August 9, 2019, the SHU staff
received an inmate call out list that listed Inmate 3 as "WAB," which he explained meant that Inmate 3 was
being removed from MCC New York. He told the OIG that sometime between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 a.m., he
escorted Epstein from the SHU to the attorney conference room for Epstein's daily legal visit, during which
time Epstein joked around with him. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that he and Epstein were
accompanied by Correctional Officer 1, who was escorting Inmate 3 to Receiving and Discharge. The Day
Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Correctional Officer 1 both told the OIG that Inmate 3 was escorted to
Receiving and Discharge with all of his belongings, and both said that during the escort the Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge informed Epstein that he would be assigned a new cellmate due to Inmate 3's departure
and the requirement that Epstein have a cellmate. In his interview with the OIG, Correctional Officer 1
confirmed this conversation between the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Epstein, but he did not
provide any additional information regarding notifications made either by him or the Day Watch SHU Officer
in Charge. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that when he and Correctional Officer 1 left
the SHU with Epstein and Inmate 3, both the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Day Watch Activities
Lieutenant should have been physically present in the Lieutenants' Office and should have seen that Inmate
3 was departing the institution when they passed the office.

The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that while he did not expect Inmate 3 to return to MCC New York,
there had been times when inmates had been escorted to Receiving and Discharge as an expected removal,
only to be returned to the SHU later that same day due to unforeseen circumstances. According to the Day
Watch SHU Officer in Charge, he did not select a new cellmate for Epstein because he was not certain that
Inmate 3 had been discharged from the institution, although he assumed that Inmate 3 would not return to
the SHU. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that when his shift ended at approximately 2:00
p.m., he informed the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Senior Officer Specialist 5 that, if Inmate 3
did not return to the SHU, Epstein would need a new cellmate upon Epstein's return from his attorney visit.
The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said he specifically recalled telling the Evening Watch SHU Officer in
Charge, in the presence of Senior Officer Specialist 5, "Make sure this guy gets a bunkie," to which the
Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge replied, "All right." The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that, at
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
some point that day, it was likely that he also informed the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, but he could
not specifically recall if he had done so.

The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that a replacement cellmate should have been identified
as soon as it was confirmed that Inmate 3 had left the institution. He said a new cellmate could have been
reassigned before the 4:00 p.m. SHU count if it was known that Inmate 3 was not coming back, but the SHU
staff members had until Epstein returned from his attorney visit to assign Epstein a new cellmate.
According to the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, SHU staff definitely should have realized that Inmate 3
was not returning both during the 4:00 p.m. count and when Epstein returned from his attorney visit later
that evening. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that Epstein's daily routine was that he
would be with his attorneys in the attorney conference room until approximately 8:00 p.m., so SHU
personnel had time to make a new cellmate assignment. He said all SHU staff members shared the
responsibility to find a replacement cellmate and that anyone assigned to the SHU could have found
another inmate to replace Inmate 3. However, he also said that due to Epstein's high profile, the SHU
personnel should have asked a lieutenant to contact the Psychology Department to see which inmate
should be placed with Epstein.

On August 12, 2019, following Epstein's death, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge wrote a memorandum
to the Warden stating, "On Friday August 9, 2019 at approximately 1:50 p.m., I 5/O/S [the Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge] passed on to oncoming staff member [the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge] and
present shift staff [Senior Officer Specialist 5] and [Correctional Officer 2] that Inmate [3] was going WAS
[i.e., with all of his belongings] and possibly may not return. Also that Inmate Epstein #76318-054 will be
needing a cell mate upon arrival from his attorney visit." The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge departed the
SHU at approximately 2:00 p.m. and worked an overtime shift as a driver for MCC New York. He stated that
he did not follow up with the SHU staff to verify that Epstein had been assigned another cellmate.
MCC New York staff with responsibility for oversight and staffing of the SHU during the Day Watch, including
the Warden, Associate Warden 1, the Captain, the SHU Lieutenant, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant,
the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, and the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, told the OIG that they all
knew Epstein was required to have a cellmate pursuant to the Psychology Departments determination.
They also confirmed that everyone who regularly worked in the SHU knew of this requirement, and that it
was the responsibility of all SHU staff to notify a supervisor upon learning that Epstein needed to be
assigned a new cellmate due to Inmate 3's transfer to another prison. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge
and Correctional Officer 1, however, were the only two MCC New York staff members working the Day
Watch on August 9, 2019, who told the OIG that they were aware of Inmate 3's transfer and the need to
assign Epstein a new cellmate. Correctional Officer l's immediate superior (the Day Watch SHU Officer in
Charge) was already aware of the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate. While the Day Watch SHU Officer
in Charge told the OIG that he made a number of notifications, other witnesses could not confirm that he
had passed on information regarding Epstein's need for a new cellmate.

The Day Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant both told the OIG that they
did not know Inmate 3 had been transferred out of the facility, despite the fact that both were recipients of
the second email USMS sent on August 8 that included the information about Inmate 3's impending transfer
out of MCC New York on August 9. Rather, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Day Watch
Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that they believed Inmate 3 had been removed from MCC New York for a
court appearance.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
The Day Watch Activities Lieutenant did not recall Inmate 3 departing the institution with all of his
belongings or having any conversations with the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge or anyone else regarding
Inmate 3's departure from MCC New York. According to the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, he did not
know that Epstein was without a cellmate. Other senior officials, including the Warden, Associate Warden 1,
and the Captain, were also unaware of Inmate 3's transfer and the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate.
These officials concurred that while all SHU staff and supervisors were responsible for notifying a supervisor
in the chain-of-command of the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge
bore primary responsibility for the notification because he was the SHU Officer in Charge and one of two
people who saw Inmate 3 leave the facility with all of his belongings. The Captain told the OIG that since
Epstein was in the attorney conference room all day, no one may have even thought about it, and may have
only become aware when they put Epstein back in his cell after his attorney visit that evening. The Captain
said as soon as the SHU staff became aware that Epstein was without a cellmate, they should have notified
the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant. The Captain said that if he had been informed, he would have
taken immediate action to ensure that Epstein was either assigned a new cellmate or monitored until that
assignment occurred. The Captain, however, was one of the recipients of the USMS August 8 email that
notified members of MCC New York supervisory staff of Inmate 3's transfer to another facility. The Warden
and Associate Warden 1 did not receive this email.

The Warden told the OIG that he was off duty on August 9, 2019. The Warden said that in the event Epstein
was without a cellmate, the plan was to review the situation and decide who should replace Inmate 3, but
that no inmate in the SHU was preselected to replace Inmate 3 if this event occurred.
- Oh\ \ /
2. Evening Watch Staff Actions on August 9
The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he was the SHU Officer in Charge on August 9
from approximately 2:00 p.m. until 10:00 p.m. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge said he relieved
the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge from his duties and worked in the SHU with Senior Officer Specialist 5,
a Material Handler, Correctional Officer 2, and Correctional Officer Tova Noel. The Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge stated that when he began his shift, Epstein was visiting with his attorneys in the attorney
conference room. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he did not recall having a
conversation with the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge about Epstein needing a cellmate. When advised
that the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge was confident about their conversation, the Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge stated, "I don't necessarily want to call anyone a lima per se, but I don't remember him
speaking to me about this. So, maybe he spoke to [Senior Officer Specialist 5], and maybe I was standing
there, and he thought I heard him." The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge said if Inmate 3 had left MCC
New York with all of his belongings, then someone should have found another inmate to replace him
because Epstein was required to have a cellmate.

The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he eventually learned later that evening that
Epstein did not have a cellmate. According to the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, after Epstein
returned from his attorney visit and placed a telephone call, he escorted Epstein to his cell and saw that
Inmate 3 was not there. According to the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, after he realized that
Epstein did not have a cellmate, he, Noel, and the Material Handler, all of whom were working in the SHU
that evening, talked about Epstein needing a new cellmate. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge said
SHU staff could not just put anyone in the cell with Epstein. In his interview with the OIG, the Evening Watch
SHU Officer in Charge stated that he called someone (he could not recall who) and notified that person that
Epstein did not have a cellmate. OIG interviews did not identify an individual who received such a call or
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
who witnessed the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge making it.

Senior Officer Specialist 5 told the OIG that on August 9, he worked in the SHU from approximately 8:45 a.m.
until 4:00 p.m. Senior Officer Specialist 5 said when he reported for duty, Epstein was already with his
attorneys, Inmate 3 had already left the SHU, and neither inmate returned to the SHU prior to his departure.
Senior Officer Specialist 5 told the OIG that he did not know Inmate 3 had been released from MCC New
York and that no one told him Epstein would need a new cellmate, including the Day Watch SHU Officer in
Charge, the Captain, the SHU Lieutenant, or anyone from the Psychology Department.

Correctional Officer 2 told the OIG that on August 9, he worked in the SHU from 8:00 a.m. until 4:00 p.m.
Correctional Officer 2 said he did not recall Inmate 3 departing the SHU that day, and that he was unaware
that Epstein needed a new cellmate.

The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that he was the Operations Lieutenant at the MCC
on August 9 from approximately 2:00 p.m. until 10:00 p.m. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant said
he was aware that Epstein was required to have a cellmate due to a mass email that was sent to all of the
MCC New York Lieutenants. According to the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, everyone who regularly
worked in the SHU should have known that Epstein was required to have a cellmate. The Evening Watch
Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that he did not know Inmate 3 had left MCC New York earlier that day
and was unaware that Epstein did not have a cellmate. He said that if Inmate 3 had been transported to
Receiving and Discharge as 'WAB" and the SHU Lieutenant was off, then another supervisor should have
been notified. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that SHU personnel assigned to his
shift should have notified him that Epstein was without a cellmate, but he had not been informed. The OIG's
investigation revealed, however, that the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant was one of the recipients of
the USMS email notifying MCC New York supervisory staff of Inmate 3's scheduled transfer out of MCC New
York on August 9. According to the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Acting Evening Watch
Activities Lieutenant conducted the lieutenant round in the SHU on August 9, and she only would have
known that Epstein was without a cellmate if someone from the SHU told her or if she walked through the
SHU tiers during the round. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant said he believed that if the Evening
Watch Acting Activities Lieutenant knew that Epstein did not have a cellmate, she would have notified him.
Both the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant and the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the
OIG that they were unaware that Epstein needed to have a cellmate. The Acting Evening Watch Activities
Lieutenant, who was serving in this position on August 9 from approximately 4:00 p.m. until 10:00 p.m., told
the OIG that because her ordinary position was a Senior Officer Specialist, she was not aware that Epstein
was required to have a cellmate. The Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant recalled hearing that
Epstein had been placed on suicide watch, but said she never received specific instructions regarding
Epstein. She said the SHU staff did not tell her about the requirement that Epstein have a cellmate or that
his cellmate had left MCC New York. The Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant did not receive the
August 8 USMS email regarding Inmate 3's transfer. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant, who was
the Operations Lieutenant from approximately 10:00 p.m. on August 9 until 6:00 a.m. on August 10, told the
OIG that she did not know that Epstein was required to have a cellmate, and that the Captain never spoke
with her about this issue. The Captain confirmed that he did not specifically tell the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant that Epstein needed a cellmate; however, the Captain said he believed that the
Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant should have known of the requirement, and she was one of the
recipients of the email from the Psychology Department on July 30, 2019, that informed MCC New York staff
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
that Epstein needed to have an appropriate cellmate. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant also
received the August 8 USMS email notifying MCC New York supervisory staff of Inmate 3's scheduled
transfer out of MCC New York. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that if SHU staff
knew that Epstein required a cellmate and did not have one, they should have informed her when she
visited the SHU at approximately 4:00 a.m. on August 10, as part of her lieutenant rounds.
The Material Handler said the SHU was not his regular post and he had not attended SHU training, but he
had worked in the SHU approximately 10 to 20 times. According to the Material Handler, on August 9 he
reported for a voluntary overtime shift from 12:00 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. and then worked his regular 8:00 a.m.
to 4:00 p.m. shift in the warehouse. At some point during the day shift, the Day Watch Operations
Lieutenant called and asked the Material Handler if he could work overtime in the SHU, and he agreed. The
Material Handler said he worked the 4:00 p.m. to 12:00 a.m. shift in the SHU with the Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge and Noel. The Material Handler told the OIG that he felt pressured to work the third shift,
which resulted in him working 24 hours straight, from 12:00 a.m. on August 9 through 12:00 a.m. on August
10. After the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge left at 10:00 p.m., the Material Handler and Noel were
the only employees working in the SHU from 10:00 p.m. to 12:00 a.m. The Material Handler recalled that
Epstein came back to the SHU from meeting with his attorneys at approximately 8:00 p.m., which was later
than the rest of the inmates, and was returned to his cell on L Tier. After the Material Handler and Noel
gave Epstein his food, the Material Handler said they left the L Tier area. The Material Handler said Epstein
was alone in his cell, but he was unaware that Epstein needed a cellmate.

Noel told the OIG that she worked in the SHU from approximately 4:00 p.m. on August 9 until 8:00 a.m. on
August 10, which was a double shift of 16 hours. Noel said the SHU was her regular post during the time
that Epstein was housed within the SHU. According to Noel, inmates housed within the MCC New York SHU
were typically assigned cellmates, but she did not know if they were required to have cellmates. Noel said
Epstein was assigned a cellmate while he was housed within the SHU but said that no one spoke with her
about a requirement that Epstein have a cellmate. Noel said she did not know that Inmate 3 had been
removed from MCC New York on August 9, and stated she was not aware that Epstein should have been
assigned a new cellmate if Inmate 3 had been removed from MCC New York.

Material Handler Michael Thomas told the OIG that he worked a shift in the SHU on August 10 from 12:00
a.m. until 8:00 a.m. Thomas said the SHU was not his normal post, but he had worked in the SHU on
numerous previous occasions and was familiar with the SHU protocols and procedures. Thomas said he
knew that if an inmate came off suicide watch or psychological observation, they should be assigned a
cellmate, and said he was aware that Epstein had previously been on suicide watch and psychological
observation. Therefore, Thomas assumed that Epstein was required to have a cellmate, but said no one had
spoken with him about that requirement. Thomas said the SHU staff should have notified the Operations
Lieutenant as soon as they knew that Epstein's cellmate had departed MCC New York on August 9.
However, Thomas said he did not know that Inmate 3 was removed from MCC New York on August 9, and
that Epstein was without a cellmate during his shift on August 10.
IV. Epstein is Allowed to Make an Unmonitored Telephone Call on August 9
For safety and security reasons, BOP policy requires that all inmate telephone calls be made through the
Inmate Telephone System. BOP records reflect that Epstein placed an unrecorded, unmonitored telephone
call to a telephone number in the local 646 area code using a non-Inmate Telephone System line on August
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
9, 2019, from 6:58 p.m. to 7:19 p.m. No other BOP records exist regarding the unmonitored call, including
identity of the person called or a summary of the conversation. The OIG found no evidence that Epstein
signed an Acknowledgement of Inmate form, as required by SOP policy and necessary for him to use a non-
Inmate Telephone System line. The Acknowledgement of Inmate form provides, among other things, that
the BOP reserves the authority to monitor and record non-attorney conversations on any telephone located
within the institution to preserve the security and orderly management of the institution and to protect the
public. The OIG did not find that any notification was made to the MCC New York's Special Investigative
Services (SIS) staff advising the telephone call had been made, the date and time of the telephone call, the
name of the person being called, Epstein's name and register number, or a brief7 ment explaining the
purpose of Epstein's telephone call, as SOP policy requires.

The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that when he was preparing to escort Epstein back
to the SHU from the attorney conference room on August 9, 2019, a Unit Manager said to the Evening Watch
Operations Lieutenant that he was going to escort Epstein so he could provide Epstein with the opportunity
to place a telephone call using an unrecorded legal telephone line that is utilized by inmates to call their
attorneys. The Unit Manager was the Institutional Duty Officer the week of Epstein's death. The Northeast
Regional Director told the OIG that an Institutional Duty Officer is a supervisor who monitors the facility on
non-duty hours on behalf of the Warden when the Warden is not present.

The Captain told the OIG that he had authorized the Unit Manager to provide Epstein with a telephone call
from the SHU on August 9, 2019, because he wanted to accommodate Epstein's request for a telephone call
since Epstein was assigned to the SHU and had limited ability to place telephone calls. The Captain
explained that when the Unit Manager was escorting Epstein from his attorney visit back to the SHU, he told
the Unit Manager in the elevator that Epstein could place a telephone call from the SHU, but it had to be
monitored and logged.

The Unit Manager told the OIG that he worked on August 9 from approximately 11:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. The
Unit Manager explained that on August 9, Epstein asked to call his mother and that it was his understanding
that Epstein had not been able to obtain the necessary documentation to use the Inmate Telephone System
for various reasons, including the fact that Epstein was with his attorneys during normal working hours. As
described below, Epstein had, in fact, completed the requisite BOP paperwork that allowed him to place
calls through the Inmate Telephone System. The Unit Manager said the decision to allow Epstein to place
the call was his alone as the Unit Manager and because, as the Institutional Duty Officer, he was
representing the Warden who was not physically within MCC New York at that time. The Unit Manager said
he did not recall having a conversation with the Captain about permitting Epstein to make the call, and he
would have allowed the call even if the Captain did not want him to, given it was his decision to make as the
Unit Manager. The Unit Manager explained that he viewed ensuring that inmates had family socialization as
a part of his job, and he would allow inmates to place telephone calls if they were unable to make calls
under ordinary circumstances.

The Unit Manager told the OIG that at approximately 6:45 p.m., he and Senior Officer Specialist 1 escorted
Epstein from the attorney conference room to the SHU so that Epstein could place a telephone call. The
Unit Manager said he put Epstein in the shower area to make the telephone call because correctional
officers were present in that area. The Unit Manager explained that he also chose the shower area because
that location ensured Epstein would not be able to pull the phone cord into his cell and use it to harm
himself. The Unit Manager said he plugged the telephone line into the legal line, which was not recorded,
Limited Official Use Only-Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
and dialed the telephone number that Epstein provided. As noted above, the number that was dialed was
in the local 646 area code. The Unit Manager said he allowed Epstein to place the telephone call on the
unrecorded legal line because he believed that Epstein had not set up his Inmate Telephone System account
that would have allowed him to call on the institutions recorded lines. According to the Unit Manager, a
male answered, and the Unit Manager handed the receiver to Epstein. Bullock heard Epstein say, "Hey, how
are you doing? How's everything?" The Unit Manager admitted that he should have verified who was on the
line, as Epstein had requested to make a telephone call to speak with his mother, and it was a male who
answered the phone. The Unit Manager said he could not verify the phone number because he believed
that Epstein did not have his Inmate Telephone System account set up, and he did not have any phone
numbers associated with his account. The Unit Manager told the OIG that after he handed the telephone to
Epstein, his shift ended so he left the SHU and left MCC New York for the day.

The Unit Manager said that when he left the SHU, Epstein was still on the call and the Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge and Noel were at the officers' desk, and that Senior Officer Specialist 1 was also present.
According to the Unit Manager, when he was leaving, he told the officers, 'Hey, make sure he gets his 15-
minutes, and after that, he's done." The Unit Manager said he did not provide the SHU staff with
instructions to monitor the call. He said that after he left, he contacted Noel on the SHU telephone and
asked her to make sure that Epstein's call had ended because his time was up.

The Unit Manager acknowledged that he did not stay and monitor the call as he should have done. The Unit
Manager said the proper way to have an inmate place a telephone call on an unmonitored line would be to
bring the inmate out and place him in a belly chain because then he would be handcuffed in the front. The
Unit Manager said he should have provided Epstein with the phone, with a counselor or unit team member
present, and placed the call on speaker so the call was monitored.

The OIG investigation determined that Epstein did not, in fact, speak with his mother, who, according to
public records, died in 2004. The OIG found that Epstein actually spoke with Individual 1, who declined to be
interviewed by the OIG.3° Individual l's lawyer told the U.S. Attorneys Office for the Southern District of
New York during an attorney proffer that Individual 1 spoke with Epstein on August 9, 2019, at about 7:00
p.m., for approximately 20 minutes. Individual 1's attorney proffer was that Individual 1 was in the country
of Belarus at the time of the call.31 Individual l's attorney told the U.S. Attorney's Office that during the
telephone call, Epstein told Individual 1 that the press had gotten crazy, and they discussed personal things
such as books, music, and hygiene while incarcerated. According to the representations by Individual l's
counsel, Epstein told Individual 1, 'They are trying to keep me safe;' and that his case would take a little
longer that he originally thought. He told Individual 1 he loved her, to be strong, and that he would not be
able to call her again for another month.

Senior Officer Specialist 1 told the OIG that he was not a witness to Epstein's August 9 call, but he had
previously discussed telephone calls with Epstein and knew that Epstein had the requisite paperwork that
allowed him to place calls through the Inmate Telephone System. Senior Officer Specialist 1 told the OIG
30 The OIG does not have the authority to compel or subpoena testimony from individuals who are not Department
employees.

31 The OIG did not investigate the factual accuracy of this proffer. We note that there are methods by which a call to 
the
646 area code could connect to a telephone in Belarus.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
that Epstein was issued the necessary documentation to make telephone calls when Inmate 1 was his
cellmate. Senior Officer Specialist 1 also advised the OIG about an interaction that he had with one of
Epstein's attorneys prior to August 9 when he was on an elevator with Epstein and the attorney. According
to Senior Officer Specialist 1, Epstein's attorney asked him about getting Epstein the necessary
documentation to make calls. Senior Officer Specialist 1 said he then verified that Epstein was able to make
calls through the Inmate Telephone System. When Senior Officer Specialist 1 asked Epstein why he had said
he was unable to make calls, Epstein responded, "[T]hey said they monitor those phone calls." Senior
Officer Specialist 1 said that in a subsequent conversation with Epstein's attorney, the attorney asked how
Epstein could get an unmonitored call. Senior Officer Specialist 1 told Epstein's attorney that decision had to
be made by a lieutenant or unit Manager.

Noel told the OIG that after Epstein's attorney conference on August 9, the Unit Manager plugged a
telephone line in the legal line, and placed Epstein in a shower area within the SHU where he was afforded a
telephone call. The OIG investigation determined that the legal line is an unrecorded telephone line outside
of the Inmate Telephone System, which is designed for inmates to use when speaking with their counsel
and therefore is not recorded. Noel said that after the Unit Manager set Epstein up with the call, he left the
SHU and did not instruct Noel, or anyone else to Noel's knowledge, to monitor Epstein's call. According to
Noel, the call was not monitored or logged. Noel said that approximately 15 to 20 minutes later, while
Epstein was still using the telephone, the Unit Manager called the SHU staff via telephone, told Noel that
Epstein's time was up, and asked that Noel retrieve the telephone from Epstein. Noel estimated that
Epstein's call lasted for 20 minutes and said the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and the Material
Handler were also present in the SHU during Epstein's phone call. Noel reported that she took the phone
back from Epstein, left Epstein alone in the shower, and went to use the bathroom on 10 South. Noel said
that upon her return, Epstein was already placed back in his cell.

The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he was present in the SHU on August 9 during
the time of Epstein's telephone call but did not overhear Epstein's conversation. The Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge also said that while Epstein was having his telephone call, the officers were distracted by
the actions of another inmate. The Material Handler said he did not recall seeing the Unit Manager or
Epstein in the shower area on the night of August 9, and did not have any knowledge or information
regarding a phone call made by Epstein that night.

The Northeast Regional Director told the OIG that if Epstein's call was authorized by an MCC New York
official, then it should have been done on a speaker phone while being monitored by a staff member, and
the call should have been logged and a record of the call should have been created. The Northeast Regional
Director said Epstein's unmonitored telephone call was extremely concerning because "[w]e don't know
what happened on that phone call. It could have potentially led to the incident [Epstein's death], but we
don't, we will never know."
V. Failure to Conduct SHU Inmate Counts and Staff Rounds on August 9-10
A. SHU Inmate Counts
As detailed in the BOP policies section of Chapter 2, the BOP requires correctional officers assigned to guard
inmates to conduct institution -wide counts of inmates at regularly scheduled intervals each day to ensure
that all inmates are present and accounted for at the appropriate location within the facility. Performing an
Limited Official Use Only-Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
institutional count is one of the basic and essential aspects of a correctional officers job, and the count was
one of the basic and essential components of the daily operation of MCC New York. The Captain told the
OIG that counts are a core responsibility of correctional officers and ensure accountability of the inmates.
The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant said that it is very important that the institutional count is
accurate because that is how staff members know if all inmates are present and if anyone has escaped.
On weekdays, MCC New York conducted institutional counts at 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., 5:00 a.m., 4:00 p.m.,
and 10:00 p.m. The 10:00 p.m. count was a stand-up count, which meant that inmates were required to
stand when they were counted. Pursuant to BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders, two
correctional officers were required to perform the institutional count for each housing unit, including the
SHU. To perform the institutional count in the SHU, BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders
required two officers to walk from tier to tier to observe and count each individual inmate. During each
count, one correctional officer would count the inmates while the other officer observed the inmates. The
two officers would then switch roles and compare the count numbers. If the totals did not match, then the
officers had to conduct another count in the same manner. Correctional officers had to document their
performance of inmate counts on an official MCC New York form often referred to as a count slip.32
On the count slip, correctional officers were required to fill in the date and time the count had been
performed, write the total number of inmates physically present in the unit counted, and then both
correctional officers printed their name and signed the count slip. Once the correctional officers had
completed and signed the count slip, the count slips were then collected and delivered to the Control
Center. Officers assigned to the Control Center were responsible for comparing the count slips from each
housing unit to the institution's inmate roster to ensure that each inmate was accounted for. Only after all
the count slips had been collected from each housing unit, and the numbers on the slips had been matched
to the institution's inmate roster, could the institutional count be deemed "cleared" or completed. If a
housing unit's count slip was incomplete or did not match the number of inmates that were supposed to be
in the unit, then the count had to be redone in that housing unit via a more intensive version of the
institutional count, called a bed-book count, which is when inmates are counted using their picture cards.
Records of each institutional count, including the count slips, were provided to a supervising official and
retained by MCC New York.

The OIG's investigation found that none of the required SHU inmate counts were conducted from 4:00 p.m.
on August 9, 2019, until Epstein was discovered hanged in his cell at approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10,

2019. Further, the OIG determined that SHU staff did not conduct any 30-minute rounds after
approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9, and that the count slips and round sheets had been falsified. As a
result, many SHU staff and supervisors were unaware that Epstein did not have a cellmate as the
Psychology Department had determined was necessary, and Epstein was alone and unobserved in his cell
for an extended period of time.
1. The 4:00 p.m. SHU Count on August 9
The OIG's investigation determined that the 4:00 p.m. SHU inmate count on August 9, 2019, was inaccurate
because SHU staff did not physically count the inmates as required by BOP policy and instead relied upon a
predetermined number of inmates believed to be in the SHU at that time. However, Epstein, who was in the
32 This BOP forms is officially entitled "Metropolitan Correctional Center; New York, New York; Official Count Slip."
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
SHU attorney visitation room, was correctly accounted for during the 4:00 p.m. and subsequent SHU counts.
The OIG determined that the error in the 4:00 p.m. SHU count was carried over into the next inmate count
at 10:00 p.m. that counted an inmate who had been transferred out of the SHU. The SHU inmate count was
not corrected until 12:00 a.m. when the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant reviewed the master
institutional count and housing unit count slips and informed SHU staff of the correct number of inmates in
the SHU at that time.

Senior Officer Specialist 5 told the OIG that prior to his departure from the SHU at approximately 4:00 p.m.,
he told the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge what the SHU count should be. In addition, the Day Watch
SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that SHU staff maintain a "cheat sheet" which lists the number of
inmates believed to be in the SHU at any given time.

When interviewed by the OIG, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge reviewed the 4:00 p.m. SHU count slip
from August 9, 2019, which was signed by the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Correctional Officer
Noel. Based on his review, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that the Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge and Noel probably did not count the inmates in the SHU. He said they likely wrote down
the numbers they thought should have been entered for the count because the count slip inaccurately
included an inmate (Inmate 4) among the number of inmates in the SHU after that inmate had been
transferred to another housing unit. According to what he told the OIG and wrote in an email on August 9,
earlier that afternoon the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge observed Inmate 4 attempt to retrieve an
unknown item from his visitor in the MCC New York SHU visiting room. The Lieutenants Log from August 9,
2019, reflected that following this incident Inmate 4 was removed from the SHU at 3:15 p.m. and
transferred to the Receiving and Discharge dry cell, which is a secure location where inmates are taken for
observation when they are believed to have ingested or secreted contraband on their person. According to
the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the inaccurate 4:00 p.m. count slip told him "that the count was not
done and they just assumed and went by the cheat sheet because the body wasn't even there;' referring to
Inmate 4, who was transferred from the SHU to Receiving and Discharge. The Day Watch SHU Officer in
Charge told the OIG that if the 4:00 p.m. SHU count had been accurately conducted, then the Evening Watch
SHU Officer in Charge and the SHU staff should have realized that Inmate 4 was no longer in the SHU.
In his interview with the OIG, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge acknowledged that neither he nor
any other SHU staff member conducted the 4:00 p.m. SHU count on August 9. The Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge verified that it was his handwriting and signature on the 4:00 p.m. SHU count slip and said
he had prepared the count slip ahead of time because "[t]here was so much going on" in the SHU that day.
The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge confirmed that Noel's name and signature also appeared on the
4:00 p.m. count slip.33 During his OIG interview, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge reviewed BOP
documents regarding the inmate's transfer from the SHU and acknowledged further that based on that
transfer, the number of inmates listed on the SHU count slip he and Noel submitted for the 4:00 p.m. count,
the count slip was incorrect.

Noel admitted in the deferred prosecution agreement she entered into with the U.S. Attorney's Office for
the Southern District of New York that she completed false count slips on August 9 and 10. Noel initially told
the OIG that she did not conduct the 4:00 p.m. count on August 9, but after acknowledging that she signed
33 Prosecution was declined for BOP employees (other than Noel and Thomas) who falsely certified inmate counts and
rounds on the day before and the day of Epstein's death.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
the 4:00 pm SHU count slip, Noel said she did not recall if she conducted the count. According to Noel, she
and other SHU staff filled out the count slip before conducting the counts because they knew the number of
inmates they were supposed to report.
2. The 10:00 p.m. SHU Count on August 9
At the time of the 10:00 p.m. count, all inmates in the MCC New York SHU, including Epstein, were locked in
their cells for the night. At or around that time, the two officers assigned to the SHU were responsible for
conducting the 10:00 p.m. stand up count. At 10:00 p.m. on August 9, the two assigned SHU officers were
Noel and the Material Handler. Through review and analysis of the SHU security camera video, witness
statements, and BOP records, the OIG determined that MCC New York staff did not perform the 10:00 p.m.
count in the SHU.34 Nonetheless, Noel and the Material Handler completed and signed the 10:00 p.m. SHU
count slip. The 10:00 p.m. SHU count slip listed the total number of inmates as "73 + 1." According to the
MCC New York master count sheet for the 10:00 p.m. count on August 9, 2019, all units had verbally
reported their inmate counts to the Control Center by 10:30 p.m.35 At approximately 10:36 p.m., the Control
Center completed all paperwork and officially cleared the 10:00 p.m. institutional count.
The Material Handler said he was present at the time of the 10:00 p.m. count, but that the count was not
conducted because everyone was tired. The Material Handler noted that on August 9, he had worked an
overtime shift from 12:00 a.m. until 8:00 a.m., his regular shift from 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m., followed by his
SHU overtime shift from 4:00 p.m. to midnight. Thus, at the time of the 10:00 p.m. count, he had worked 22
consecutive hours at MCC New York. The Material Handler verified that he and Noel signed the 10:00 p.m.
count slip, and believed that Noel called the Control Center with their count numbers. He did not know why
the count slip listed "73 + 1".

Noel told the OIG that she had conducted the SHU count alone at 10:00 p.m. and that the Material Handler
signed the count slip even though he did not conduct the count with her. However, the OIG's review and
analysis of the SHU security camera video conflicts with Noel's statement that she conducted the 10:00 p.m.
count. Specifically, the video reflects that it was not until between 10:29 p.m. and 10:36 p.m. when Noel
walked to different tiers inside the SHU. Yet, as described above, MCC New York records reflect that counts
from all MCC New York housing units were reported to the Control Center by 10:30 p.m., as the count
documentation shows the count was verbally cleared by the Control Center at 10:30 p.m. It therefore
appears that the video depicts Noel conducting a later round in the SHU, as she was required to do every 30
minutes during her shift, and not the 10:00 p.m. SHU count.

Noel said she wrote the 73 on the count slip but she did not remember if she or someone else had written
"+ 1" on the count slip and she did not know why "+1" was on the count slip. Noel claimed that, unlike the
4:00 p.m. count slip, which the Evening Watch Officer in Charge pre-filled, she did not prepare the 10:00
p.m. count slip in advance of the count. Noel said she did not know that the 10:00 p.m. SHU count slip,
which listed 73 inmates, was inaccurate, and she could not explain why the 12:00 a.m. count also
inaccurately listed that 73 inmates were physically present in the SHU, whereas the 3:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m.
34 The quality of the SHU video footage was poor. Therefore, in conjunction with reviewing the video, the OIG analyzed
witness statements and BOP records to better determine what the video depicted.

35 The official name for the document used to record an institutional count is "Bureau of Prisons Count Sheet."
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
counts slips accurately listed 72 inmates in the SHU.

Senior Officer Specialist 6 told the OIG that on August 9, 2019, he worked in the Control Center from
approximately 4:00 p.m. until 12:00 a.m., and then he worked as an Internal Officer from 12:00 a.m. until
8:00 a.m. on August 10. According to Senior Officer Specialist 6, he took the August 9 10:00 p.m.
institutional count by himself in the Control Center, and assisted with the 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., and 5:00
a.m. counts on August 10 as an internal officer. Senior Officer Specialist 6 confirmed to the OIG, as MCC
New York records reflect, that he had received verbal counts from all units by 10:30 p.m., and further stated
that he had cleared the institutional count at 10:36 p.m., which was when paperwork was complete and the
count was officially complete.

Senior Officer Specialist 6 reviewed the MCC New York 10:00 p.m. institutional count, which showed that the
SHU had 73 inmates assigned, whereas the Receiving and Discharge Department had zero inmates assigned
to the unit. When questioned by the OIG about the 10:00 p.m. SHU count slip that listed "73 + 1" inmates
and was signed by the Material Handler and Noel, Senior Officer Specialist 6 told the OIG that he believed
that the "+ 1" on the count slip was in his handwriting. Senior Officer Specialist 6 also reviewed the 10:00
p.m. Receiving and Discharge count slip, which listed "9S + 1" on the count slip, and told the OIG that it was
his handwriting.TM Senior Officer Specialist 6 explained that the "9S + 1" on the SHU count slip meant that he
was "ghost counting" the inmate (Inmate 4) who had been moved from the SHU, located in the 9 South area,
to the Receiving and Discharge area earlier that day. Senior Officer Specialist 6 said that because there
were, in actuality, only 72 inmates in the SHU during the 10:00 p.m. count, he should have written /3 - 1" on
the SHU count slip rather than "73 + 1".

Figure 5.1: 10:00 p.m. Count Slips from the SHU and Receiving and Delivery on August 9
Metropolitan Correctional Center
New York, New York
Simi opulitan Correctional Center
Official Count Slip
"IS 4- i Official Count Slip
Unit: ZA Wm eaaja
W --n Unit: Date: Comm _ Time: ( 0 "
COMA: i Time: O.OG

I. Print Name:
Print Nam
Signature:
1. Signature: Print Name:
2. Print Name: Sign aaaaa :
2. Signature:
Senior Officer Specialist 6 did not recall if he wrote on the count slips at the time of the 10:00 p.m. count or
during the 12:00 a.m. count when Inmate 4 was transferred in SENTRY from the SHU to Receiving and
Discharge. Senior Officer Specialist 6 told the OIG that if he had made the notations at the time of the 10:00
p.m. count, he should not have cleared the count. Instead, he should have created a new master count
sheet and requested that the SHU staff conduct a new count, provide a new count slip, and discard the
inaccurate SHU count slip. Senior Officer Specialist 6 told the OIG that an Operations Lieutenant would have
36 According to BOP records and witness interviews, "9S" refers to the SHU, which was located in 9th Floor South section
of MCC New York.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
needed to authorize him to do the "ghost count" and write on the count slips, although he could not recall
precisely who gave him the authorization or when he had done so. The OIG investigation and review
determined that the only Operations Lieutenant on duty at the time was the Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant, who started her shift at 10:00 p.m. on August 9. When questioned by the OIG, the Morning
Watch Operations Lieutenant adamantly denied having authorized a "ghost count" and the OIG identified no
record or witness (other than Senior Officer Specialist 6) to indicate that she had done so. The OIG
interviewed other MCC New York personnel, who said 'ghost counting" was not permitted, and stressed the
importance of an accurate physical count of inmates.
3. The 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. SHU Counts on August 10
The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that she supervised the August 10 12:00 a.m.
institutional count from the Control Center. During the count, the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant
said she identified the issue with the inaccuracy of the SHU count slip because it counted Inmate 4 as
present in the SHU, when in actuality he had been removed from the SHU and placed in the Receiving and
Discharge dry cell the previous day (August 9, 2019). The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant said that
after learning of the discrepancy, she made the appropriate update reflecting the inmate transfer in
SENTRY. This update is reflected in Inmate 4's Inmate History Quarters, which states that Inmate 4 was
transferred out of the SHU into a different housing unit on August 10, 2019, at 12:35 a.m. The Morning
Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that she believed she told the SHU staff to conduct a new count
and create a new count slip, but she did not know if they had actually done so.

During his interview with the OIG, Senior Officer Specialist 6 reviewed BOP records relating to the inmate
transfer, the 12:00 a.m. institutional count, and the housing unit count slips. Based on his review of this
material, Senior Officer Specialist 6 said the 12:00 a.m. SHU count slip was inaccurate because it continued
to list 73 inmates instead of the 72 inmates who were physically present in the SHU at that time. Senior
Officer Specialist 6 reviewed the institutional counts and SHU count slips for the 3:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m.
counts and told the OIG that they were accurate because they listed the SHU as having 72 inmates.
At approximately 12:00 a.m. on August 10, 2019, Material Handler Thomas replaced the other Material
Handler, and he and Noel were the only two staff members on duty in the SHU. Noel and Thomas were
responsible for conducting the 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. counts in the SHU. Through review and
analysis of the SHU security camera video, witness statements, and BOP records, the OIG determined that
Noel and Thomas did not perform any of these counts. Nonetheless, Noel and Thomas completed and
signed SHU count slips for each of the three counts, and in reliance on the count slips, the Control Center
cleared the 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. institutional counts at approximately 12:49 a.m., 3:24 a.m.,
and 5:30 a.m., respectively. Noel and Thomas both admitted to the OIG that they did not conduct the 12:00
a.m., 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. counts on August 10, and that they had falsified the respective count slips.
Noel told the OIG that she signed the August 1012:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. count slips that Thomas
had prefilled. Noel said she did not know why the 12:00 a.m. count slip documented that there were 73
inmates in the SHU, whereas the 3:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m. slips documented there were only 72 inmates.
Noel recalled that Thomas had spoken with someone and then they changed the count slips.
Noel told the OIG that she and Correctional Officer 3 conducted the 3:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m. counts in MCC
New York's 10 South Unit, which is the single-celled secure unit adjacent to the SHU. Noel said that when
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
she left the SHU to assist Correctional Officer 3, she took the SHU keys with her and that no one could have
accessed the SHU while she was gone because she had to physically open the door for anyone who came
into the SHU. Noel also told the OIG that when the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant arrived to
conduct a round at approximately 4:00 a.m., Noel let her into the SHU. The OIG's review and analysis of the
SHU video shows that the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant arrived in the SHU at approximately 4:00
a.m., visited the 10 South Unit at 4:04 a.m., returned to SHU at 4:11 a.m., and left the SHU at 4:14 a.m.
According to Noel, no one other than the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant and Correctional Officer 3,
as detailed later below, entered the SHU during her shift.

Thomas told the OIG that since he had begun working with the BOP in 2007, he had worked in the SHU fairly
regularly and he was familiar with how to work in the SHU and how the SHU operated. Thomas described
his responsibilities while working in the SHU as to maintain the count of inmates, make sure the inmates are
fed, and, depending on the shift, make sure they get their showers. Thomas's Overtime Schedule showed
that he worked 21 shifts in the SHU during morning watch from May through August 2019. The overtime
schedule also showed that Thomas worked 12 overtime shifts in the SHU when Epstein was assigned to the
SHU in July and August 2019.

Thomas acknowledged that neither he nor Noel conducted any rounds or counts in the SHU during their
shift between approximately 12:00 a.m. and approximately 6:30 a.m. Thomas said the August 10, 2019
round sheets were signed, but the rounds were not conducted because he was tired that day. Thomas
recalled "dozing off from here and there" during his shift, but he did not know if Noel slept.
Thomas did not recall having a conversation with anyone concerning the discrepancy between the 12:00
a.m. SHU count slip, which listed 73 inmates, and the institutional count, which listed 72 inmates in the SHU.
Thomas said he had filled out and signed the 3:00 a.m. SHU count slip, which listed 72 inmates in the SHU.
Thomas did not know why the number of inmates was different on the 12:00 a.m. and 3:00 a.m. count slips
and did not recall speaking with the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant about the 12:00 a.m. count.
Thomas told the OIG that he knew he was falsely certifying the count slips when he signed them on August
10, 2019.
B. Staff Rounds in the SHU
1. Correctional Officer Rounds
As detailed in the BOP Policies section of Chapter 2, in addition to inmate counts, BOP policy and MCC New
York SHU Post Orders required that correctional officers assigned to the SHU conduct rounds to observe all
inmates at least twice an hour. As part of their assigned duties, MCC New York SHU officers had to walk
each of the tiers of the SHU twice an hour on an irregular schedule, once during the first 30 minutes and
again during the second 30 minutes, with both rounds occurring no more than 40 minutes apart.
Correctional officers working in the SHU were required to complete and initial an official MCC New York
form, often referred to as a "round sheet" which was reviewed and signed by a supervisor, documenting the
date and time of each 30-minute round in each tier of the SHU.37
The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that SHU staff spoke about conducting rounds on Epstein
37 This BOP form is officially entitled "MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute Check Sheet."
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
every day. He said that the Warden, lieutenants, and other MCC New York staff members frequently told
the SHU staff to conduct rounds and to keep an eye on Epstein. To reinforce this message, the Day Watch
SHU Officer in Charge created a sign on orange paper that he hung on a computer in the SHU officers area
that said, "MANADATORY [sic] ROUNDS MUST BE CONDUCTED EVERY 30 MINUTES ON EPSTEIN # 76318-054
AS PER GOD!!!!" The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said the sign was hanging on the computer on August
9 and 10, 2019, and it was clearly visible to everyone who worked in the SHU. The Acting Evening Watch
Activities Lieutenant confirmed that written instructions to conduct rounds on Epstein were posted on the
SHU computer.
Figure 5.2: Sign Created by the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge
MANADATORY)ROUN DS MUST '■
BE CONDUCTED EVERY 30
MINUTES ON
EPSTEIN #76318-054 AS PER
GOD!!!!
The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that
Noel filled out the round sheet on behalf of everyone who was
working in the SHU during his shift. The Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge was not certain if all of the rounds were
actually conducted. The Material Handler said he believed the
rounds listed on the round sheet as having occurred between
4:01 p.m. to 7:36 p.m. probably had been done, but he was
uncertain about the remaining rounds. The Material Handler
said he had seen officers "blow off" 30-minute rounds in the
past. Noel told the OIG that, as a general practice, when the
correctional officers went to the various SHU tiers to distribute
food or supplies, they counted that as a round. Noel said she was aware that she was supposed to conduct
two rounds every hour during their shift, but that she had never actually completed rounds every 30
minutes while working in the SHU. When asked which rounds she conducted on August 9, 2019, Noel
responded, "That's hard for me to tell because I didn't conduct it every 30 minutes. It was give out food, pick
up the trays, give out toilet paper, go down. So those were the rounds I conducted." Noel verified that her
initials were on the round sheets for August 9 and 10, 2019, and said, consistent with her usual practice, she
filled out the round sheets and initialed the round sheets at the start of the 4:00 p.m. and the 12:00 a.m.
shifts.

Noel and Thomas both admitted to the OIG that they did not conduct any of the rounds reflected on the
SHU Round Sheet on August 10, 2019, from 12:00 a.m. until Epstein was found hanged in his cell at
approximately 6:30 a.m. Nonetheless, Noel completed and signed more than 75 separate 30-minute entries
stating that she and Thomas had, in fact, conducted such rounds.38 Through review and analysis of the SHU
video footage, witness statements, and BOP records, the OIG determined that Noel and Thomas did not
enter the tiers in the SHU to conduct any of the rounds and counts between 12:00 a.m. and approximately
6:30 a.m. on August 10. Noel and Thomas can be seen at the SHU Officers' Station, moving in the SHU
common area, and the SHU laundry and entrance/exit area throughout the morning of August 10.
Additionally, from approximately 1:00 a.m. to 3:00 a.m., Noel and Thomas were seated at the SHU Officers'
Station without moving and appeared to be sleeping. OIG analysis of the activity on the SHU computers
revealed that Noel used the computer periodically throughout the night, including to search the internet for
furniture sales and benefit websites and to read a news article about Epstein. Thomas used the computer
38 Each of the 6 tiers in the SHU had a separate round sheet, each of which had 13 entries reflecting 30-minute rounds
were conducted, when they were not, in fact, completed.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
briefly around 1:00 a.m. and 6:00 a.m. to search for motorcycle sales and sports news.
Noel told the OIG that she went through each tier in the SHU at approximately 10:00 p.m., and at the time
she went to Epstein's cell and saw him laying on a mattress on the floor, which she said was typical for him.
Epstein asked Noel for his medical device, so she plugged it in for him. Noel saw that Epstein was in the cell
by himself and without a cellmate, but she maintained that she did not know that Epstein was required to
have a cellmate. Noel told the OIG that Epstein's cell was approximately 15 feet away from the SHU Officers'
Station. Noel said that during her shift on August 10, 2019, no one went to Epstein's cell and no one other
than the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant and Correctional Officer 3 came into the SHU.
Through review and analysis of the SHU video footage, witness statements, and BOP records, the OIG
determined that at approximately 10:40 p.m. a correctional officer, believed to be Noel, carried linen or
inmate clothing up to the L Tier, which was the last time any correctional officer approached the only
entrance to the SHU tier in which Epstein was housed.
2. Lieutenant Rounds
At
BOP policy requires that a lieutenant visit the SHU during each shift to ensure that all procedures are being
followed. BOP training for new lieutenants instructs that the Operations Lieutenant must visit the SHU at
least once per shift and "[t]his visit will be substantially more than just entering the unit, signing the log
book, and talking with staff." Additionally, when the SHU Lieutenant is unavailable, the Operations
Lieutenant should make rounds in the SHU on each shift. The training instructs that while in the SHU the
Operations Lieutenant must walk each range (tier), inspect logs and records, observe activities, and
periodically observe SHU inmate counts. The training further outlines that the SHU Lieutenant is
responsible for the direct supervision of the unit, including enforcement of rules, review of paperwork,
coordination of activities, movement of inmates, and cell searches. The SHU Lieutenant should make
rounds on the ranges (tiers) each day.

The statements of multiple witnesses were consistent with BOP training materials. The Northeast Regional
Director, the Warden, Associate Warden 1, the Captain, and the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge all told the
OIG that lieutenants should have walked down all of the SHU tiers when conducting a lieutenant round in
the SHU. Noel said the SHU Lieutenant walked the tiers all the time, however, other lieutenants did not
always walk down the tiers. Multiple witnesses also told the OIG that it was standard practice for the BOP to
store the SHU round sheets at the end of each tier in the SHU. This practice was designed to ensure that
the assigned correctional officers and lieutenants walked down each tier when conducting rounds to
observe every cell and inmate during the round before initialing the round sheet. On August 9 and 10, 2019,
however, the MCC New York SHU round sheets were kept at the SHU Officers' Station in the common area
of the SHU rather than at the end of each tier.

None of the lieutenant rounds conducted on August 9 and 10 alerted the supervisory staff to the fact that
Epstein lacked a cellmate. According to MCC New York records, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant
conducted a round in the SHU at 11:27 a.m. on August 9. The Day Watch Activities Lieutenant said he did
not specifically recall if he conducted a round in the SHU, but he believed that he did conduct the round. As
discussed in greater detail above, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that he did not know that
Epstein's cellmate had been removed from MCC New York or that Epstein was without a cellmate during his
shift on August 9. The Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that she conducted a
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
lieutenant round in the SHU on August 9 sometime between 5:00 p.m. and 8:00 p.m. The Acting Evening
Watch Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that she did not know that that Epstein's cellmate had departed
from MCC New York or that Epstein required a cellmate because she was only the Acting Activities
Lieutenant and had not attended SHU or department head meetings. The Evening Watch Operations
Lieutenant reviewed the August 9 round sheets and said that although his signature is on one of the forms
as if he conducted a round in the SHU, it was actually the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant who
had conducted the round. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant said he did not know why his signature
was on the form because he did not conduct any rounds within the SHU on August 9 and he did not recall
signing the form. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant confirmed that she conducted her round in
the SHU at approximately 4:00 a.m. on August 10. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant said she went
up to the 10 South Unit and then back down to the SHU because she needed to sign the round sheets.
Contrary to BOP training for new lieutenants, which she attended in 2011, the Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant told the OIG, 'We are not required to go to each individual cell and look at the inmates. When
we make rounds, we get with the officers." The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant said she did not
conduct a round to observe the inmates when she visited the SHU. Noel confirmed that the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant visited the SHU but did not walk down the tiers.
a
Through review and analysis of the SHU security camera video, witness statements, and BOP records, the
OIG determined that at approximately 4:00 a.m. on August 10, 2019, the Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant briefly visited the SHU as part of her supervisory duties and conferred with Noel and Thomas,
who were seated at and around the SHU Officers' Station in the common area of the SHU. Noel told the OIG
that at approximately 5:30 a.m., Thomas went to the 10 South Unit, which was adjacent to the SHU, to
relieve Correctional Officer 3, and that Correctional Officer 3 briefly walked through the SHU common area
as he left and returned from his break. The OIG's review and analysis of the video footage revealed that,
aside from those two officers, no one entered the SHU and no one conducted any counts or rounds.
VI. Epstein's Death on August 10
A. Discovery of Epstein Hanged in Cell and Emergency Response
On August 10, 2019, shortly after 6:00 a.m., the doorbell to the SHU rang, indicating that a delivery of
breakfast carts had arrived at the SHU. Noel and Thomas retrieved the breakfast carts from the double-
locked entrance to the SHU and brought them inside the SHU. At the time, Thomas and Noel were the only
officers in the SHU. At approximately 6:30 a.m., MCC New York security camera video recordings show Noel
and Thomas walking toward the L Tier. Noel and Thomas told the OIG that at this time they were entering
the L Tier, in which Epstein was housed, to deliver breakfast to the inmates. As discussed previously,
between approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10, the OIG did not
observe on the available recorded video any correctional officers or other individuals approach the L Tier
where Epstein was housed from the common area of the SHU.

Noel told the OIG that she unlocked the door to the L Tier so Thomas could deliver the breakfast trays.
Thomas told the OIG that he knocked on Epstein's cell door, saw a portion of Epstein through the window
but could not make out what he saw, so he said to Epstein, "Come to the door, come to the door." Thomas
said he did not observe any movement or hear a response, so he unlocked the cell door, entered the cell,
and saw Epstein hanged as described further below. Thomas said he immediately yelled for Noel to get
help, and that Noel activated a body alarm, signaling a medical emergency, and began taking the steps
described below.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 5.3: Photograph of a Piece of Orange Cloth Hanging from the Bunkbed in Epstein's Cell
Following His Death
Thomas explained that when he first entered Epstein's cell,
Epstein had an orange string, presumably from a sheet or a
shirt, around his neck. The end of the string was tied to the
top portion of the bunkbed. Epstein was suspended from the
top bunk in a near-seated position, with his buttocks
approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half off the floor and his
legs extended out straight on the floor. Thomas said Epstein
did not look discolored or very different from when he last
saw Epstein alive. Thomas said he immediately ripped the
orange sheet or shirt away from the bunkbed, and Epstein's
buttocks dropped approximately 1 inch to 1 inch and a half to
the ground. Thomas then lowered Epstein's entire body to
the floor and, because he did not believe Epstein was
breathing, Thomas immediately began providing chest
compressions until responding MCC New York staff members
arrived approximately 1 minute later. Thomas said he did not
provide rescue breaths and was unaware if Epstein was dead
or alive because he never checked for a pulse before initiating
chest compressions. Thomas said medical personnel took
over the emergency response, including chest compressions
and use of an automated external defibrillator (AED), when they arrived. Thomas said he assisted with
bringing Epstein down to the Health Services Unit on the second floor, and that he left MCC New York at
approximately 8:00 a.m. Thomas said he had received cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) training during
MCC New York annual refresher training and had responded to medical emergencies in the past, but this
was the first time he was the first responder.

Thomas said he was present in the SHU for his entire shift on August 10, 2019, from 12:00 a.m. until the
time he attempted to deliver breakfast to Epstein at approximately 6:30 a.m., and did not see anyone go
inside Epstein's cell during his shift. Thomas said that he would have known if someone went in or out of
Epstein's cell, and said no one did. Thomas told the OIG that he could see Epstein's cell door from the SHU
Officers' Station, but he could not see inside the cell from that vantage point Thomas said that it was not
possible for anyone to have entered the SHU without his knowledge because he or Noel would have had to
open the SHU door for anyone to gain entry. The only other key to the SHU was located in the Control
Center; no other MCC New York staff members had the keys required to gain access to the SHU. Moreover,
Thomas said that anyone attempting to access the L Tier where Epstein was located would have had to walk
directly in front of the SHU Officers' Station where Thomas was seated, and no one did. Thomas denied that
he or Noel had any role in Epstein's death.

Noel told the OIG that on the morning on August 10, when it was time to deliver food to the inmates, she
unlocked the door to the L Tier and stood by it while Thomas took the food to the inmates. Noel said that
when Thomas knocked on Epstein's door, there was no response. Noel said Epstein's cell door was locked,
so Thomas used a key to open it and went inside. Noel heard Thomas call out for her to retrieve the cutter
and then she heard Thomas rip something. Noel said she observed Thomas lifting Epstein from under his
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
arms and dragging him back out of the corner of the cell and laid him down on the ground to perform CPR.
According to Noel, within seconds of Thomas calling out for the cutter she hit the body alarm, which is a
button on an MCC staff members radio that is used to signal distress or an emergency. Noel recalled
hearing Thomas say, "Breathe, Epstein, breathe," and 'We're going to be in so much trouble." Noel said she
stood at the door about a foot away from Epstein's cell and never went in. Noel said Thomas only
performed chest compressions and said she did not see Thomas checking for breath or pulse. Noel said
that when she saw Epstein, he looked blue and did not have a shirt on or anything around his neck. Noel
said she did not get the cutter because Thomas did not need it based upon the ripping sound she heard.
Noel said an MCC New York Lieutenant who responded to the alarm asked her what happened, and before
she got the chance to answer, Thomas stated, "Oh, its not her fault, we fucked up." Noel did not recall
making any comments or statements to the Lieutenant. Other than the Lieutenant, Noel did not recall
which correctional officers responded to the alarm and she did not know what happened in the cell after
MCC New York staff arrived because she was waiting at the bottom of the steps outside the L Tier. Noel said
she was alone in the SHU for 20 minutes after they left with Epstein and she kept calling the Control Center
to get status updates.

Noel told the OIG that Epstein's cell was approximately 15 feet from the SHU Officers' Station. Noel said she
would have known if someone went in or out of Epstein's cell overnight and no one did. She also said that
there was no indication that any of the inmates could have gotten out of their cells. Noel said she never
slept during her shift on August 9-10, 2019. Noel said that when she is seen on the camera at the desk not
moving, she was on the computer. Noel then clarified by saying that she worked 5 days of overtime leading
up to her shift, so she would begin to doze off; however, she caught herself and never slept.
The Lieutenant told the OIG that he was the Operations Lieutenant who relieved the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant on August 10, 2019, at approximately 5:30 a.m. The Lieutenant said that at
approximately 6:33 a.m., he heard a call for a medical emergency in the SHU and immediately responded to
the alarm. When he arrived, Noel told him, "Epstein hung himself." Once inside, the Lieutenant observed
that Thomas was performing CPR on Epstein. The Lieutenant stated that he asked, 'Where's his bunkie at?"
and that Noel responded, in substance, that Epstein did not have a cellmate. Noel also told the Lieutenant,
'We didn't do rounds at 3:00 a.m. and 5:00 a.m." Thomas stated, 'We didn't do the rounds. We messed up."
The Lieutenant took over administering CPR and asked SHU staff to retrieve an automated external
defibrillator (AED) and call for the duty nurse.

The MCC New York Electronics Technician told the OIG that he responded to the emergency call at 6:33 a.m.
When the Electronics Technician first arrived in the SHU, Thomas and other MCC New York staff members
were picking Epstein up and placing him on a stretcher. The Electronics Technician said he and Senior
Officer Specialist 6 performed chest compressions on Epstein while he was on the stretcher and being
transported to the Health Services Unit on the second floor.39 The Electronics Technician stated that he
then returned to the SHU and worked there for approximately 1 hour, along with the Morning Watch
39 Moving an inmate requiring outside emergency medical care to the Health Services Unit provides health care staff
and Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs) with immediate access to any necessary medical equipment and supplies,
and allows EMTs faster access to the inmate when they arrive at MCC New York because correctional officers can
directly escort EMTs to the Health Services Unit to begin emergency treatment immediately. If EMTs had to be escorted
to the housing unit, they would first need to be thoroughly screened, which would delay medical attention.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Operations Lieutenant and Noel. The Electronics Technician believed he was in the SHU prior to 7:00 a.m.
and until approximately 8:00 a.m., but was not positive with regard to the times. The Electronics Technician
said he delivered food to the inmates on one tier while the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant did the
same on another tier while Noel unlocked the doors outside of the tiers for the Electronics Technician and
the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant. The Electronics Technician said that when they were delivering
food to the inmates, he heard the inmates saying, "You killed him. You weren't making rounds. You killed
him." The Electronics Technician told the OIG that the inmates also said Thomas and Noel just sat at the
SHU Officers' Station and never checked on the inmates. The Electronics Technician told the OIG he
understood the inmates to be saying that Thomas and Noel were responsible for Epstein's death because
they had not conducted rounds during their shift. The Electronics Technician he believed that Epstein
took his own life and said he had no reason to believe otherwise.

Senior Officer Specialist 6 said he responded to the emergency call at 6:33 a.m. and when he arrived, staff
members were already performing CPR on Epstein. Senior Officer Specialist 6 said he assisted with
transporting Epstein to the Health Services Unit, taking Epstein to the ambulance, and then followed the
ambulance to the hospital in another vehicle, and stayed at the hospital until he was relieved from duty.
4'
The OIG also reviewed photographs that were taken in the MCC New York Health Services Unit of EMTs
attempting to resuscitate Epstein. The photographs show, among other things, Epstein on his back with an
intravenous line in his arm, his orange BOP-issued shirt ripped open and laying around his arms, and him
wearing orange BOP-issued boxer shorts. None of the photographs taken at MCC New York show Epstein in
a hospital gown; although the OIG did review photographs taken at New York Presbyterian Lower
Manhattan Hospital which show Epstein in a hospital gown.

Additionally, the OIG participated in interviews of three inmates assigned to the same SHU tier as Epstein at
the time of his death and who were housed in cells opposite Epstein's cell and therefore had a direct line of
sight to Epstein's cell.4° One such inmate was Inmate 5, who was assigned to a cell directly across from
Epstein's cell on the left side of the tier and who told the OIG that he could see all the cells on the right side
of L Tier, where Epstein was housed. Inmate 5 believed a count was last conducted within the SHU on
August 9, 2019, a little before 12:00 a.m., and said that no additional count was conducted after that time.
Inmate 5 did not see anyone, or hear anyone, go into Epstein's cell on the night of August 9 or the morning
of August 10 prior to a male correctional officer discovering Epstein on the morning of August 10. Inmate 5
said the male correctional officer knocked on Epstein's assigned cell, looked in, and then opened the door.
Inmate 5 could only see Epstein's legs from the knee down, but could tell that Epstein was laying down on
his back because his feet were pointed upward. The male correctional officer bent down to shake Epstein
and was saying, "Epstein, Epstein." The male correctional officer then tried to pick up Epstein from behind,
with his arms wrapped around Epstein. Inmate 5 said both the officer and Epstein fell back to the floor, with
Epstein falling to the side of the officer. Inmate 5 said that once the two fell, he could then see that it was
Epstein. The correctional officer then started giving Epstein chest compressions and mouth-to-mouth
resuscitation. At this point, the officer said, "Fuck!" and asked the female correctional officer, who was
standing near the L Tier gate, if she has pressed the button. The female officer said, "Yeah, a long time ago."
A lieutenant then arrived at Epstein's cell along with a male nurse who tried to revive Epstein. Epstein was
not responsive. Inmate 5 said Epstein looked dead when the male correctional officer tried to pick him up
4° As noted previously, the U.S. Attorneys Office for the Southern District of New York sought interviews from all of 
the
inmates housed in the L Tier of the SHU on the night that Epstein died.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
and they both fell. Inmate S said officers had trouble getting Epstein onto the stretcher because Epstein
was basically dead weight. When the officers did get Epstein on the stretcher, Epstein still had on
headphones.d1 Inmate S did not see any marks around Epstein's neck, and he did not see a rope around
Epstein's neck. However, Inmate 5 saw a male correctional officer come out of Epstein's cell with a sheet
that had a loop and knot.

Figure 5.4: Location of the Cells Assigned to Inmates 5-7 in Relation to Epstein's Cell in the L Tier
Inmate 6 told the OIG that on August 9 and 10, 2019, he was housed within the SHU on L Tier in a cell
directly across from Epstein's cell. Inmate 6 last saw Epstein's cellmate, Inmate 3, on August 9 when Inmate
3 said, "See you later. I'm going to court." Inmate 6 said Inmate 3 did not return that night, and said the
SHU officers never conducted their required 30-minute rounds. Inmate 6 believed the correctional officers
last checked on the inmates in the SHU on August 10 between 12:30 a.m. and 1:00 a.m. Inmate 6 did not
observe anyone entering Epstein's cell after Epstein returned from his legal visit on August 9, 2019, did not
hear noise that night, and said Epstein's door was not opened during the night. Inmate 6 said a male officer
discovered Epstein dead during breakfast delivery on August 10. Inmate 6 said he observed the male
correctional officer entered Epstein's cell and began performing CPR, while the female correctional officer,
who appeared panicked, stayed outside of the cell. Inmate 6 said he observed Epstein on the floor, but did
not see a rope over Epstein's head. However, when Epstein was removed from his cell, Inmate 6 observed
the correctional officers holding a rope and a defibrillator. Inmate 6 did not see marks on Epstein's neck but
did see bruising on his face and observed earphones that were still in place on Epstein's ears.
Inmate 7, who was two cells down from Epstein's cell and on the other side of the tier, told the OIG that he
could not see into Epstein's cell but he could see the cell door. Inmate 7 said that after dinner was brought
4' An MP3 player with headphones was obtained as evidence by the FBI.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
to Epstein's cell on the evening of August 9, 2019, Inmate 7 did not recall seeing anyone going in or out of
Epstein's cell until the following morning at around 6:00 a.m. He further stated that he did not hear any
door "pop open" that evening. Inmate 7 said he remembered waking up around 6:00 a.m. on August 10,
2019, and hearing a voice, possibly male, saying "Breathe." Inmate 7 said he saw Epstein removed from his
cell on a stretcher.

In addition, the OIG and the FBI interviewed seven inmates assigned to other tiers in the SHU, none of
whom had any direct knowledge of how Epstein died. These inmates consistently reported that the SHU
officers did not systematically conduct the counts and rounds as required on the evening Epstein died and
that the last round was either between 9:30-10:00 p.m. or 12:30-1:00 a.m. Several inmates told the OIG that
before Epstein died the SHU staff never conducted rounds at night.

According to the BOP Form 583 Report of Incident, on August 10, 2019, at approximately 6:33 a.m., while
delivering the breakfast meal, Epstein was found unresponsive in his cell. Consistent with the required
response to a suspected suicide outlined in the MCC New York General Housing Unit Post Orders that are
described in Chapter 2, staff called for assistance and began life-saving measures.d2 At 6:39 a.m., Epstein
was taken to the MCC New York Health Services Unit, and Emergency Medical Services (EMS) arrived to MCC
New York at 6:43 a.m. Epstein was transported to the local hospital, New York Presbyterian Lower
Manhattan Hospital, at 7:10 a.m., and was pronounced deceased at 7:36 a.m.

According to a memorandum attached to the Form 583 from the Clinical Nurse dated August 10, 2019, when
the medical emergency involving Epstein was called over the radio, the Clinical Nurse immediately
responded to the call and upon arrival, saw Epstein on the floor within his cell unresponsive with CPR in
progress by Correctional Officers. The Clinical Nurse's memorandum reads that Epstein was cold, with
circumferential bruising around his neck and posterior mottling, pupils fixes and dilatated, and no palpable
pulses were felt. According to the memorandum, at 6:35 a.m., a call was placed for EMS, CPR continued,
and an AED was utilized and indicated "No Shock Advised," so CPR continued. Epstein was then transported
to the MCC New York Health Services Unit treatment room with CPR in progress. Upon arrival, Epstein's
pulse was checked, and the AED indicated "No Shock Advised." EMS and paramedics arrived on the scene,
intubated Epstein, and gave him medications and fluids." Epstein was transported to the local emergency
room with CPR in progress at approximately 7:10 a.m.

According to a memorandum attached to the Form 583 from the Correctional Systems Officer dated August
10, 2019, after Noel called the medical emergency, the Correctional Systems Officer received a call from staff
in the SHU instructing her to call 911 for an ambulance. The Correctional Systems Officer notified the New
York Police Department (NYPD) via the MCC New York institutional NYPD telephone. The Correctional
Systems Officer then informed NYPD that MCC New York needed an ambulance and medical assistance for
one of the inmates. The New York City Fire Department and EMS arrived at MCC New York at 6:43 a.m. and
42  As noted in Chapter 2, BOP policy provides that the need to immediately attend to an apparent suicide victim,
undertake lifesaving measures, and ensure inmate and staff safety take precedence over efforts to preserve a crime
scene.

a3  The EMS arrival time on the Clinical Nurse's memorandum is listed as 6:56 a.m. Based on the OIG's review of other
documentation and interviews, we believe the arrival time reflected on those other documents (6:43 a.m.) is more likely
the time of EMS's arrival. We noted that the Clinical Nurse, at the time of EMS's arrival, was actively engaged in
administering CRP to Epstein and responding to the health emergency.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
were escorted to the second-floor medical area. EMS departed MCC New York with Epstein and a BOP
escort via ambulance and chase car to the local hospital at 7:10 a.m.

The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that she was relieved as the Operations Lieutenant
prior to 6:00 a.m. on August 10, 2019, but was still working on things like the Daily Activity Reports and
Lieutenant Logs that she did not get to finish during her shift. At some point, the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant heard that there was a medical emergency in SHU, so she went to assist because she
knew that inmates would need to be given food and other things would need to be done. The Morning
Watch Operations Lieutenant estimated that she went to the SHU around 7:00 a.m. to help with the inmate
meals, and believed the Electronics Technician was also helping out. Noel was there, but she was not
helping with delivering food to the inmates. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant said that after the
meals were delivered, she finished up and went home.

All MCC New York staff members who were interviewed by the OIG said they did not know of any
information suggesting that Epstein's cause of death was something other than suicide. Additionally, no
inmate provided the OIG with information suggesting that anyone assisted Epstein with taking his own life,
or had any credible information suggesting that Epstein's cause of death was something other than suicide.
Some MCC New York staff told the OIG that Epstein's death could have been prevented if, among other
things, Epstein had been assigned a new cellmate after Inmate 3's departure and rounds and counts had
been conducted in the SHU as required. Some witnesses also faulted MCC New York staffing shortages,
which resulted in excessive overtime and meant that MCC New York staff members were often overtired
during their shifts. Other MCC New York staff members told the OIG that even if inmate safety and
accountability measures had been property executed, an inmate who wanted to take his life would have
found a way to do so.
B. Items Found in Epstein's Cell on August 10 Following His Death
Following Epstein's death, the BOP and FBI collected many of the items found inside Epstein's cell. The FBI
inspected the cell and retrieved what it believed to be relevant to its investigation into the cause of Epstein's
death, which included one torn sheet, miscellaneous papers, and an MP3 player. The FBI did not recover
any weapons inside of the cell. After the FBI's inspection, the BOP recycled the linens from Epstein's cell and
collected the remaining items, which included various over-the-counter medications, books (including
religious books), BOP pamphlets, toiletries, batteries, headphones, glasses, mail and envelopes, a brown
paper bag, an orange homemade rope, AED pads, and a medical device.

The photographs of Epstein's cell on August 10, 2019, show an excess of blankets, linens, and clothing.
Some of the linens had been ripped into thin strips, which were tied to the desk and bunkbed inside the cell.
Some of the strips were tied like a noose. When shown a picture of Epstein's cell, Noel verified that it
contained a lot of linen and extra clothing. Noel said the mattress on the floor was Epstein's, as he always
slept on the mattress on the floor. As detailed in the BOP policies section of Chapter 2, MCC New York SHU
Post Orders required that correctional officers assigned to the SHU during the daytime tours of duty
conduct at least five cell searches each day, and that the entire SHU, including all common areas and cells,
be searched every week. The OIG investigation revealed, however, that on August 9, 2019, the SHU staff
Limited Official Use Only-Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
logged only one cell search in TRUSCOPE, and the search was not of Epstein's cell.40 BOP records did not
indicate when Epstein's cell was last searched.

The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that at least five cell searches should be conducted on
the day and night watch shifts within the SHU, and that cell searches are conducted in cells every time the
inmate departs the cell. He said the SHU Officer in Charge was responsible for making sure the searches
were conducted and logged into the SOP TRUSCOPE database. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said
that only one cell search was entered into TRUSCOPE on August 9, 2019, because cell searches were tedious
to enter, and he was busy. He did not believe that it was a problem that only one cell search was logged on
August 9, because he said the SHU staff would have gone into every cell when the inmates took their
showers. He said that during the period of Epstein's custody, SHU inmates showered on Mondays,
Wednesdays, and Fridays. The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said that during showers, SHU staff
searched every cell. He explained that all of the SHU cells should have been searched on Friday, August 9
because it was a shower day. He said SHU staff should also conduct cell searches when inmates go to the
recreation area or for attorney visits. According to the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, Epstein's cell
should have been searched because both Epstein and Inmate 3 left the cell on the morning of August 9. He
further stated that he believed that the majority of cells in the SHU were searched although, as noted above,
the SHU staff logged only one cell search in TRUSCOPE on August 9 and the search was not of Epstein's cell.
Figure 5.5: Photograph of Epstein's Cell After His Death
The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that in
August 2019, each inmate would have been authorized to
have two sheets and one blanket. He said that in the winter,
inmates are allowed to have an additional blanket. When
interviewed by the OIG, the Day Watch SHU Officer in
Charge reviewed a picture of Epstein's cell from August 10,
2019, after Epstein had been removed from the cell. The
Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge said there appeared to be
an excess number of linens and blankets in the cell, which
he believed were for both Epstein and Inmate 3, and that
there were possibly a couple of extra sheets as well. He
noted that there were two mattresses in the cell and
deduced that Inmate 3's assigned items had not yet been
removed even though he had departed MCC New York
earlier that day. According to the Day Watch SHU Officer in
Charge, Inmate 3's items should have been removed as
soon as the SHU staff knew Inmate 3 was not returning. He
told the OIG that any extra linens or blankets should be
removed when the inmates take showers and their cells are
searched. He told the OIG that he believed the purpose of
limiting the linens provided to the inmates was to ensure
there was enough to go around and that it was more of an administrative matter rather than a security
44 TRUSCOPE Is a BOP database that provides institution staff with detailed Inmate and Institution security-related
Information and provides unit officers an electronic event log.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
matter.

Figure 5.6: Photograph of a Piece of Orange Cloth Tied into a Noose Recovered from Epstein's Cell
After His Death'
The Captain also reviewed the picture of Epstein's cell
from August 10, 2019, when interviewed by the OIG.
He said Epstein had too many linens, t-shirts, and
blankets in his cell. The Captain said the SHU staff
were responsible for removing those items because
they did not want to hear the other inmates complain
that they were not issued the same number of items.
The Captain stated that it is also a security issue
because it "gives the inmates the materials to be able
to make homemade fashioned and improvised
nooses" or "use it as escape paraphernalia7 such as a
rope that inmates had used to escape from another
facility in Chicago.

Inmate 3 told the OIG that Epstein was allowed to sleep on the floor, which he said was unusual for the SHU
where that was not normally allowed. Inmate 3 said Epstein also had two extra blankets, which no other
inmate had, as well as two pens, which inmates were not allowed to have. Epstein would ask for things, and
if the correctional officers said no, Epstein would tell them he was writing down their name and providing
the information to his lawyer. According to Inmate 3, the correctional officers were on "eggshells" around
Epstein. Inmate 3 said that when he left the SHU on August 9, 2019, there was an orange cloth twisted
around the ladder, strings on the side of the ladder, and a string tied across the bed. Inmate 3 explained
that the string tied across the bed served as a clothesline, and that the strings were part of a sheet they had
ripped. According to Inmate 3, one night he woke up, saw Epstein fidgeting with the clothesline, and asked
Epstein what he was doing. Epstein said he was trying to fix the clothesline, but Inmate 3 told him no and
flushed the clothesline down the toilet. As discussed in Chapter 4, when Inmate 3 and Epstein first became
cellmates upon Epstein's return to the SHU following suicide watch and psychological observation, Inmate 3
asked Epstein not to kill himself while Inmate 3 was his cellmate because Inmate 3 had a chance to go home
soon. In response, Epstein told Inmate 3 not to worry and that he was not going to cause him any trouble.
When Inmate 3 left on August 9 he told Epstein that he would leave the clothesline in the cell so that Epstein
could wash his clothes. Inmate 3 did not say anything about a noose having been in the cell, but he said
there were five blankets in their cell when he left.
C. Autopsy Results
On August 11, 2019, the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner, City of New York, performed an autopsy on
Epstein and determined that the cause of death was hanging and the manner of death a suicide. One of the
4S As noted previously, Epstein's cell contained an excessive amount of linens, some of which had been ripped into thin
strips and tied like a noose. Figure 6.5 depicts one such noose, which is illustrative of the types of linens found in
Epstein's cell; the noose depicted is not the ligature Epstein used to kill himself.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
office's Medical Examiners performed the autopsy, and the autopsy report was reviewed by the First Deputy
Chief Medical Examiner. In connection with this investigation, the OIG interviewed the Medical Examiner
who performed the Epstein autopsy (hereinafter the "Medical Examiner"). The Medical Examiner told the
OIG that the pattern of Epstein's neck bone fractures was consistent with a hanging. The Medical Examiner
explained that a different fracture pattern is present if there has been a manual compression of the neck
versus a sustained pressure like in a hanging, and the pattern of Epstein's neck fractures was that of a
hanging. The Medical Examiner also said Epstein had petechial hemorrhages, which are pinpoint bleeds in
skin, on his face and mouth. These hemorrhages are caused when the blood flow is obstructed and the
small skin capillaries burst. The Medical Examiner additionally identified plethora, which is purple
discoloration of the skin, and stated that both petechial hemorrhages and plethora are consistent with
suicide by hanging. The Medical Examiner stated that Epstein's petechia and plethora were identified from
his neck up. In homicidal strangulations, according to the Medical Examiner, these conditions are normally
found only in the eyes and mouth, and in a different pattern. Epstein also had, the Medical Examiner
explained, a marked and obvious ligature furrow that peaked upward which is consistent with suicide as
opposed to a ligature strangulation.

The Medical Examiner further stated that there was no evidence of defensive wounds consistent with what
is seen in victims of strangulation. The Medical Examiner told the OIG that in strangulation cases there is
invariably some signs of a struggle, even if the victim is impaired. The Medical Examiner noted that the
autopsy did not identify any signs of a struggle. Epstein did not have any marks on his hands, no broken
fingernails, no debris under the fingernails, no contusions to his knuckles that would have evidenced a fight,
and, other than an abrasion on his arm likely due to convulsing from hanging, no bruising on his body. We
also were told by the Medical Examiner that Epstein did not have strap muscle hemorrhages of the neck,
which is bleeding in the lung muscles in the front of your neck. Nor did he have, the Medical Examiner told
the OIG, hemorrhaging in the muscles in the back of his neck. The Medical Examiner explained that you
would expect to see that hemorrhaging when there has been an incomplete compression as opposed to a
sustained compression like a hanging.

In addition, the Medical Examiner determined that the cloth material of the ligature (noose) found in
Epstein's cell could have caused the fractures and superficial injuries the Medical Examiner identified during
the autopsy. The Medical Examiner also told the OIG that the ligature furrow was too broad to have been
caused by the electrical cord of the medical device in Epstein's cell. The Medical Examiner said blood
toxicology tests were conducted and no medications or illegal substances were identified in Epstein's
system. The Medical Examiner stated that the ruling of Epstein's death a suicide was the Medical Examiners
independent medical judgment, and that the Medical Examiner was not pressured or otherwise subjected to
any attempt to influence her ruling.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Chapter 6: The Availability of Limited Recorded Video Evidence
Due to the Security Camera Recording System Failure
In August 2019, the Metropolitan Correctional Center located in New York, New York (MCC New York) had
approximately 150 video security cameras (no audio) placed throughout the institution. The OIG found that
approximately 11 cameras were located in and around the Special Housing Unit (SHU) where Epstein was
confined at the time of his death on August 10, 2019, including one at the end of the L Tier where Epstein
was housed that showed any movement in or out of inmate cells and in the Tier's hallway. In addition to
broadcasting live video, MCC New York had a system that recorded the live video feeds. Following Epstein's
death, MCC New York officials and FBI investigators attempted to review video recordings related to the
incident and discovered that, although the security cameras were working and transmitting live video,
recorded video from most of the cameras in the SHU area was not available due to a malfunction of the
video recording system that had occurred on July 29, 2019, including video from the camera at the end of
the L Tier. As a result, while the L Tier video camera was transmitting a live video feed on the night of
August 9, 2019, and morning of August 10, 2019, the video was not being recorded. One of the cameras
that had available recordings from August 9 and 10 was a camera located outside a housing unit adjacent to
the SHU. That camera captured video of a large part of the common area of the SHU, including the SHU
Officers' Station and portions of the stairways leading to the different SHU tiers, including the L Tier. Thus,
anyone entering or attempting to enter the L Tier from the common area of the SHU, including on August 9
and 10, would have been picked up by the video recorded by that camera. In addition, the recordings
showed the SHU Officers' Station where the two SHU staff were seated at a desk immediately outside the
entrance to the L Tier and diagonally across from Epstein's cell, which was the first cell on the righthand side
of the L Tier.
I. Background on the Security Camera System at MCC New York
All video surveillance from MCC New York's cameras was connected to a Digital Video Recorder (DVR)
system. The DVR system had two data storage systems that were labeled "DVR 1" and "DVR 2," and each
consisted of 16 hard drives used for storing digital recordings. Roughly half of MCC New York's security
cameras were assigned to record to DVR 1, and the other half were assigned to record to DVR 2. Cameras
assigned to DVR 1 only recorded to the DVR 1 hard drives, and cameras assigned to DVR 2 only recorded to
the DVR 2 hard drives. Therefore, if DVR 2 crashed, no video from the DVR 2-assigned cameras could be
retrieved from DVR 1, and vice versa.

The OIG's investigation revealed a history of camera problems at MCC New York. In August 2019, the
Electronics Technician was the only such technician at MCC New York. The Electronics Technician told the
OIG that when he began work at MCC New York in 2016, he found that the facility's security camera system
needed to be upgraded. According to the Electronics Technician, the system had not been properly
maintained prior to his arrival, the hard drives in the DVRs frequently malfunctioned and needed to be
replaced, and the overall system was outdated, in part because the cameras were analog and not digital.
The Electronics Technician told the OIG that, throughout his tenure at MCC New York, the camera system
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
was subject to frequently recurring failures, particularly with respect to the DVR hard drives.d6
The Warden, who assumed his responsibilities at MCC New York in May 2018, told the OIG he was generally
aware that there were problems with the security camera system throughout the institution. He further
stated that efforts were undertaken to determine which cameras were working and which needed to be
fixed, and that MCC New York officials intended to ultimately seek funding to replace the entire system.
BOP records reflect that on September 6, 2018, the Warden submitted a memorandum to the Federal
Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) Northeast Regional Director to request $800,000 in funding to replace the entire
camera system. The memorandum identified an estimated project start date of December 1, 2018, and an
estimated completion date of February 9, 2019. The BOP approved the funding request, and on September
21, 2018, a contract in the amount of $698,108.99 was awarded to Company 1 to provide various equipment
for the project and associated labor. On September 24, 2018, a separate contract in the amount of
$34,089.28 was awarded to Company 2 to provide assorted networking equipment and wiring needed to
install the camera system.

As the camera upgrade project was beginning, BOP officials recognized that MCC New York's mechanical,
electrical, and plumbing systems were also in need of major repairs. MCC New York did not have enough
qualified technicians on staff to complete both the camera installation and other repairs needed at the
facility, so beginning the week of March 17, 2019, the BOP's Northeast Regional Office arranged for
technicians from other BOP institutions to conduct temporary duty (TDY) assignments at MCC New York to
perform the work. During the course of the TDY rotations, work was not consistently conducted on the
camera upgrade because sometimes TDY staff assigned to the project were used to cover shortages at MCC
New York's custody posts, and sometimes there were not enough TDY volunteers who possessed the skills
required to do the camera work.

At the time of Epstein's death on August 10, 2019, the camera system upgrade had not been completed.
Immediately following Epstein's death, Company 1 officials arrived at MCC New York and installed the new
recording system within a couple of days, and recording functionality was restored using the existing
cameras. The majority of the new cameras did not arrive at the facility until October 2019, and they were
installed in stages as the wiring work was conducted. According to the Electronics Technician, as of August
2021, when the MCC closed, the wiring work had still not been fully completed.
II. Discovery of Security Camera System Recording Issues in August 2019
A. Discovery on August 8 of the DVR 2 Failure that Occurred on July 29
According to forensic analysis conducted by the FBI after Epstein's death, disk failures occurred in MCC New
York's DVR 2 system on July 29, 2019, which resulted in the system being unable to record. According to
BOP records and OIG interviews, the BOP did not learn about the failure until August 8, 2019, when the
Special Investigative Services (SIS) Lieutenant and Associate Warden 1 attempted to review recorded
surveillance video for a matter unrelated to Epstein. The SIS Lieutenant told the OIG she discovered that no
recorded video was available for several of the institution's cameras, so she reported the matter to the
a6  The Electronics Technician provided the OIG with copies of email messages and work orders that documented nine
instances between June 2017 and July 2019, in which actions were taken to address a problem with either the MCC New
York's cameras or the hard drives used to record video from the cameras.
Limited Official Use Only-Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Communications Office, and the Electronics Technician arrived to assess the problem sometime before his
shift was scheduled to end. The Electronics Technician told the OIG that he found that roughly half of the
institution's approximately 150 cameras, which were assigned to record to DVR 2, were displaying a live
video feed but were not recording.

The Electronics Technician told the OIG that, before Epstein's death, no one was specifically tasked with
ensuring that video from the cameras was being recorded. The Electronics Technician said he therefore did
not perform any daily checks to ensure that video was being recorded. The Warden indicated that SIS staff
are usually responsible for checking the system for recording functionality and reporting any problems to
the Communications Office. However, the SIS Lieutenant told the OIG that it was her belief that the
Electronics Technician should have been checking the system daily to ensure it was recording. The OIG
found that there are no SOP policies that require institutional staff to perform periodic checks to ensure the
camera system is fully functional or that security camera systems have the capacity to record. The Facility
Manager told the OIG that since Epstein's death, he now checks to ensure that all cameras and the
recording system are working on a daily basis, and he subsequently provides a report about the status of
the system to the facility's executive staff, the SIS, and the electronics technicians.
B. Response on August 8 and 9 to Discovery of the Recording Failure
On August 8, following discovery of the recording failure, Company 1 service request records reflect that the
Electronics Technician contacted a Company 1 technical support representative, who ultimately determined
that two hard drives within DVR 2 had failed. According to the Electronics Technician and the Company 1
service request record, the Company 1 representative informed the Electronics Technician that the two
drives needed to be replaced and DVR 2 needed to be rebuilt in order for the cameras to record again. The
Electronics Technician told the OIG that he informed a Company 1 Technician that he had to obtain the
drives from MCC New York's Computer Services Manager. The Electronics Technician further stated that he
left the institution at the end of his shift and did not obtain the hard drives and did not continue to work on
the matter. The Electronics Technician told the OIG he had "no idea" why he did not stay at the facility to
resolve the problem that day, but he noted for the OIG that he had not historically been required to stay
after his shift ended to work on such matters, and even if he had begun working on the DVR that day, he
would not have completed the work on August 8 due to the time the rebuilding process takes.'"
The OIG found that the Electronics Technician's immediate supervisor, the Facility Manager, was on leave
that week and therefore was not told on August 8 about the DVR recording failure. The Facility Manager
confirmed that he did not learn about the camera problem until days after Epstein's death. The Electronics
Technician told the OIG that he did not report the problem to the Lock and Security Supervisor, who was the
Acting Facility Manager in the Facility Managers absence. The SIS Lieutenant told the OIG that after the
Electronics Technician had examined the system on August 8, the Electronics Technician informed her that
cameras were not recording and said, "I'm going to stay and do overtime tonight." Based on his comment,
the SIS Lieutenant assumed that the Electronics Technician would remain at the institution after his shift
ended that day to correct the issue. The Electronics Technician told the OIG there must have been some
miscommunication because he did not say he was going to work overtime and resolve the problem that
same evening since he knew the problem could not be fixed in one evening. The Electronics Technician told
47 According to open source information on digital data storage system rebuilds, the rebuilding process can take up to
several days to complete depending on the number of hard drives that were damaged and the storage capacity of each.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
the GIG that, in hindsight, he should have stayed at the institution to begin work on the problem that same
day.

The 515 Lieutenant told the GIG that she verbally informed the Captain on August 8 that the cameras were
down, but BOP records reflect that the Captain left the institution before the malfunction was discovered.
The Captain told the GIG that he did not learn about the DVR recording issue until after Epstein's death on
August 10 when he asked to see video related to the Epstein incident Associate Warden 1 confirmed she
was with the SIS Lieutenant on August 8 when the camera problem was discovered, but she told the OIG she
only knew video could not be replayed. She did not know the recording system for certain cameras was
down. She could see live video from the cameras on that date, and therefore assumed they were recording.
According to the Electronics Technician, after he reported to work on August 9, 2019, and attended to other
matters throughout the day, the Electronics Technician obtained the replacement hard drives and
attempted to perform the repair sometime late in the day. However, the Electronics Technician told the GIG
that no SIS staff were present at that time to give him access to the room in which the DVR room was
located, so he requested access from the only other individual who had a key to the space, Correctional
Officer 4." According to the Electronics Technician, Correctional Officer 4 denied him access to the room
because Correctional Officer 4's shift was ending at 4:00 p.m., and Correctional Officer 4 was unable to stay
and accompany him in the space while the Electronics Technician performed the work. According to the
Electronics Technician, Correctional Officer 4 said he would be at the institution the following day to provide
the Electronics Technician access to the room, so the Electronics Technician decided to postpone the repair
until the following day. The Electronics Technician said his decision was influenced by the fact that he had
historically been told by MCC New York supervisors that such matters did not have to be attended to until
the following day, and even if he had replaced the hard drives that day, the rebuilding process would have
taken 24 hours to complete and would therefore not have finished until the following day anyway.
C. SHU Camera Locations and Operational Status on August 10
The Electronics Technician arrived at the institution around 6:00 a.m. on August 10, 2019, and shortly
thereafter, before he could begin working on the DVR system, he heard the staff body alarm sound and he
reported to the SHU to assist. Later that day he was asked to pull potential video from cameras located in
and around the SHU. The Electronics Technician eventually determined that most of the cameras in the
SHU area were assigned to record to DVR 2. While the cameras assigned to DVR 2 were providing live video
streams on August 9 and 10, 2019, no recordings from those cameras were available due to the DVR 2 hard
drive issue, which the FBI later determined had occurred on July 29, 2019. Among the cameras whose video
was not recorded was the camera at the end of L Tier, the SHU tier in which Epstein was housed.
Only two cameras in the vicinity of the SHU area were recording to DVR 1 at the time of Epstein's death."
One camera was located on the upper-level entrance to the 10 South Unit, a housing unit adjacent to the
SHU, near the door MCC New York staff referred to as the "46 door." That camera captured video of a large
part of the common area of the SHU, including the SHU Officers' Station and portions of the stairways
" The DVR system was located in a locked room, and access to the room was limited to the institution's SIS unit, staff
assigned to inmate phone monitoring, and the Electronics Technicians.

One additional camera located at the 10 South Officers' Station was recording on August 10, 2019. That camera is not
depicted in Figure 4.12 because neither the SHU nor the SHU entrances were within the field of view of that camera.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
leading to the different SHU tiers, including the tier containing Epstein's cell. Thus, anyone entering or
attempting to enter the L Tier from the common area of the SHU on August 9 and 10 would have been
picked up by the video recorded by that camera. Epstein's cell door, however, was not in that camera's field
of view. The other camera that was recording was located in one of the ninth floors two elevator bays and
provided video of the ninth -floor fire exit and two of the floors four elevators.

The available video showed that at approximately 7:49 p.m. on August 9, Epstein was escorted toward the L
Tier stairway by an individual believed to be the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge.50 At approximately
10:39 p.m., an unidentified Correctional Officer appeared to walk up the L Tier stairway, and then
reappeared within view of the camera at 10:41 p.m. This is believed to be the last time anyone entered L
Tier before approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10. Between approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and just
before 6:30 a.m. on August 10, the OIG did not observe on the recorded video any Correctional Officer or
other individual enter any of the SHU tiers, which is consistent with Correctional Officer Tova Noel and
Material Handler Michael Thomas' admissions to the OIG that the SHU rounds and counts were not
conducted during that time frame. At approximately 6:28 a.m., an unidentified officer was observed on the
L Tier stairway, presumably to deliver breakfast food trays. Between 6:28 a.m. and 6:32 a.m./an
unidentified officer, believed to be Noel, moved back and forth several times between the L Tier stairway
and the SHU Officers' Station. At approximately 6:33 a.m., additional officers entered the SHU and ascended
the L Tier stairway, presumably after Noel activated her body alarm when Epstein was discovered hanged in
his cell.

As noted above, the camera at the end of the L Tier was providing a live video feed at the time of Epstein's
death but the video was not being recorded. The Electronics Technician told the OIG that certain MCC New
York personnel, including the Control Center, SIS personnel, the Warden, most lieutenants, and the
Electronics Technician, had access to the live video feed of the institution's security cameras. He explained
that to view the live feed of a particular camera, including the SHU L Tier camera, an employee with access
would need to key in the specific camera into the security camera system to call up the live feed. The
Correctional Systems Officer, who was working in the Control Center on August 10 from 12:00 a.m. to 8:00
a.m., and the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant both told the OIG that the only live feed from the SHU
on their screens was video from the camera showing the SHU common area, and they did not perceive a
need to take the necessary steps to see the live feed from the SHU L Tier from either of their duty stations
on the evening Epstein died.

5° The OIG found the video captured by the camera at the entrance to the 10 South Unit to be of low quality. Due to the
video's low quality and the distance between the camera and the SHU common area, the OIG was able to observe
movement of individuals within the SHU but was not always able to conclusively identify the individuals. The OIG was
also not always able to determine the specific destinations of the individuals seen in the video given that the camera
only captured partial views of the stairways to the various SHU tiers. The OIG found that movements captured on the
video were generally consistent with employee actions described by multiple witnesses and certain actions documented
in BOP records.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only —Not for Public Release
Figure 6.1: SHU Camera Locations and Recording Status on August 10, 2019
upper I on. r, Tie
Recording Camera (i) Non-recording Camera
Figure 6.2: Location of Recording SHU Camera at 10th Floor-South entrance
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 6.3: Field of View of the SHU Camera at 10th Floor-South Entrance
Figure 6.4: Partial View of L Tier Stairway, from the SHU Camera at 10th Floor-South Entrance
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 6.5: View of SHU Officers' Station from the SHU Camera at 10th Floor-South Entrance
Figure 6.6: Field of View of the Recording 9th Floor Elevator Bay Camera
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Figure 6.7: Location of Non -Recording Camera in the L Tier of the SHU
The Warden, who was not scheduled to work on August 10, 2019, arrived at the institution later that
morning after being notified of Epstein's death, and was informed that most of the cameras in the SHU were
not recording. He told the OIG that when the SIS Lieutenant arrived at the facility that morning, he informed
her that the SHU cameras had not been recording, and the SIS Lieutenant explained that the hard drive
issue had been detected on August 8. He told the OIG that prior to August 10, he was unaware that the DVR
2 issue had been detected on August 8, and that approximately half of the facility's cameras, and in
particular the cameras in the SHU, were found to not be recording on that date.

The Electronics Technician told the OIG that the Warden had instructed Electronics Technician to try and
recover any potential SHU video that may have been recorded by the cameras assigned to the
malfunctioning DVR 2 system, but the Electronics Technician was unable to find anything. The Electronics
Technician further said that the Warden wanted to have all the facilitys cameras recording again as soon as
possible, so he instructed the Electronics Technician to begin repairing DVR 2.
D. FBI Forensic Analysis of the DVR System
FBI evidence documents revealed that on August 10, 2019, the FBI seized all hard drives contained within
the DVR 2 system. On August 14, 2019, the FBI returned to MCC New York and seized additional DVR 2
components. On August 15, 2019, the FBI seized the entire DVR 1 system.

The FBI's Digital Forensics Analysis Unit in Quantico, Virginia, received MCC New York's DVR system on
August 16, 2019, and began to conduct a forensic analysis of the system. According to FBI forensic reports,
DVR 2 did not start successfully. The Digital Forensics Analysis Unit found that the system contained three
faulty hard drives. The FBI forensic reports state that the three drives were repaired by an FBI Advanced
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Data Recovery Specialist, but the DVR was never able to be assembled successfully. The forensic reports
further state that an FBI computer scientist and the Company 1 Technician reviewed the DVR 2 controller
logs and found that there had previously been "catastrophic disk failures," and no recordings would have
been available after July 29, 2019.

When the OIG asked the Electronics Technician about this finding by the FBI, he told the OIG he was
unaware that cameras were not recording to DVR 2 between July 29 and August 8, 2019. Neither the
Warden nor the SIS Lieutenant was aware the cameras assigned to DVR 2 had not been recording since July
29, 2019. The Company 1 Technician could not recall working with the Electronics Technician on any DVR
issues prior to August 8, 2019, but he said that if the entire DVR 2 server went down on July 29, 2019, no
video would have been able to have been retrieved from that point forward from any of the cameras
recording to DVR 2.
O
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Chapter 7: Conclusions and Recommendations
I. Conclusions
Our investigation and review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) custody, care, and supervision of
Jeffrey Epstein identified numerous and serious failures by employees of the Metropolitan Correctional
Center located in New York, New York (MCC New York), including falsifying BOP records relating to inmate
counts and rounds and multiple violations of MCC New York and BOP policies and procedures, which
compromised Epstein's safety, the safety of other inmates, and the security of the institution. Specifically,
we found that MCC New York staff failed to undertake required measures designed to make sure that,
among other things, Epstein and other inmates were accounted for and safe, such as conducting inmate
counts and 30-minute rounds, searching inmate cells, and ensuring adequate supervision of the Special
Housing Unit (SHU) and the functionality of MCC New York's security camera system.

We further found that multiple BOP employees submitted false documents claiming that they had
performed the required counts and rounds and that several MCC New York staff members lacked candor
when questioned by the OIG about their actions. Two MCC New York employees, Tova Noel and Michael
Thomas, were charged criminally with falsifying BOP records relating to their conducting inmate counts and
rounds. The U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York subsequently entered into deferred
prosecution agreements with Noel and Thomas and the court dismissed all charges against them after Noel
and Thomas successfully fulfilled the terms of their agreements. Prosecution was declined by the U.S.
Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York for other MCC New York employees assigned to the
SHU on August 9-10, 2019, who the OIG found also created, certified, and submitted false documentation
regarding inmate counts and rounds on the day before and the day of Epstein's death.

The OIG also found that the MCC New York staff failed to carry out the Psychology Department's directive
that Epstein be assigned a cellmate and that an MCC New York supervisor allowed Epstein to make an
unmonitored telephone call the evening before his death.

The OIG determined that the combination of these and other failures led to Epstein being alone and
unmonitored in his cell, with an excessive amount of bed linens, from approximately 10:40 p.m. on August
9, until he was discovered hanged in his cell at approximately 6:30 a.m. the following day. Additionally, the
OIG found that staffing shortages, a persistent issue for the BOP, compromised the ability of MCC New York
staff to adequately supervise inmates. As detailed below, we make a number of recommendations to the
BOP to address the serious issues we identified during our investigation and review.

While the OIG determined that MCC New York staff committed significant violations of BOP and MCC New
York policies and falsified records relating to their conducting inmate counts and rounds, the OIG did not
uncover evidence that contradicted the FBI's determination regarding the absence of criminality in
connection with how Epstein died. All MCC New York staff members who were interviewed by the OIG said
they did not know of any information suggesting that Epstein's cause of death was something other than
suicide. Likewise, none of the interviewed inmates provided any credible information that Epstein's cause of
death was something other than suicide.

As detailed in Chapter 4 of this report, the SHU was a housing unit within MCC New York where inmates
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
were securely separated from the general inmate population and kept locked in their cells for
approximately 23 hours a day, to ensure their own safety as well as the safety of staff and other inmates.
Access to the SHU was controlled by multiple locked doors. The primary entrance to the SHU (Main Exterior
Entry Door) was opened remotely by a staff member in MCC New York's centralized Control Center.
Additionally, there was a second locked door at the main entrance (Main Interior Entry Door), which could
be opened only with a key held by one of the correctional officers assigned to the SHU, while on duty."
Within the SHU, the entrance to each tier could be accessed only via a single locked door at the top or
bottom of the staircase leading to the individual tier. Keys to open the locked tier doors were available only
to one of the correctional officers assigned to the SHU, while on duty. Each tier had eight cells, each of
which could house either one or two inmates. Each individual cell, which was made of cement and metal,
could be accessed only through a single locked door, to which only one of the correctional officers assigned
to the SHU had keys, while on duty. The SHU cell doors were made of solid metal with a small glass window
and small locked slots that correctional staff used to handcuff inmates and provide food and toiletries to
inmates. Asa further security measure, during each shift one officer carried the keys to the second SHU
entrance doors and the SHU tier doors while another officer carries the keys to the SHU cell doors.
BOP policy and practice require that all SHU inmates be locked in their cells overnight. The OIG found no
evidence indicating that the door to Epstein's cell or any other cell in the SHU tier in which Epstein was
housed was unlocked on the evening of August 9-10, 2019, after SHU staff locked Epstein in his cell at
approximately 8:00 p.m. SHU staff told the OIG that at approximately 8:00 p.m. on August 9, all SHU
inmates were locked in their cells for the evening and that there was no indication that any of the other
inmates could have gotten out of their cells. Epstein did not have a cellmate after Inmate 3 was transferred
out of MCC New York on August 9, and therefore Epstein was alone in his cell the evening of August 9-10.
The door to Epstein's cell was visible from the SHU Officers' Station, and Correctional Officer Tova Noel and
Material Handler Michael Thomas told the OIG that no one entered or exited Epstein's cell during their shift
on August 10. Both of them further described delivering breakfast to the L Tier at about 6:30 a.m. on August
10, and how Noel unlocked the door to the L Tier, Thomas entered the L Tier and called for Epstein, and
then Thomas unlocked his cell door when Epstein failed to respond. Additionally, the three inmates who
were housed in the same SHU tier as Epstein on August 9 and 10, and who had a direct line of sight to the
door of Epstein's cell from their cells, stated that no one entered or exited Epstein's cell after the SHU staff
returned Epstein to his cell on the evening of August 9, which is consistent with the security measures in
place within the MCC New York SHU.

Further, the OIG analyzed the available recorded video of the SHU, which was limited to the common area of
the SHU, including the SHU Officers' Station, due to the MCC New York security camera system's video
recording issues that we detailed in Chapter 6. The OIG's analysis of the recorded video did not identify any
correctional officers (other than those assigned to the SHU during that timeframe or had a specific reason
for visiting the SHU) or other individuals present in the common area of the SHU approach any of the SHU
tiers, including the L Tier where Epstein was housed, between approximately 10:40 p.m. on August 9 and
approximately 6:30 a.m. on August 10. In sum, the OIG's investigation did not find any evidence that anyone
was present in the L Tier during that timeframe other than the inmates who were locked in their assigned
" The primary entrance doors to the MCC New York SHU are shown in Figure 4.1. Access to the secondary entrance to
the SHU, which was adjacent to the elevator bay on the south side of the floor, was also controlled by an exterior entry
door opened by the Control Center and an Interior door opened only with a key held by one of the correctional officers
assigned to the SHU, while on duty. The secondary entrance doors to the SHU are shown in Figure 4.2.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
cells on that tier of the SHU.

We also noted that the surveillance camera in the L Tier, as shown in the photograph in Figure 6.7, was in
plain view of the inmates and therefore inmates would have been aware that any hallway movements,
including into or out of Epstein's cell, were being live streamed and could be monitored, even if,
unbeknownst to them, the DVR system was not recording the live stream at that time. As the OIG has noted
in numerous prior reports regarding the BOP's camera system, SOP staff and inmates are aware of where
prison cameras are located and often engage in wrongdoing in locations where they know cameras are not
located.52 Additionally, the OIG did not observe on the recorded video of the SHU common area that Noel
and Thomas, who were seated at the desk at the SHU Officers' Station immediately outside the L tier during
that time period, at any time rose from their seats or approached the L Tier. We additionally found that
Thomas' and Noel's reaction on the morning of August 10 upon finding Epstein hanging in his cell, as
described to us by Thomas, Noel, the responding Lieutenant, and inmates, was consistent with their being
unaware of any potential harm to Epstein prior to Thomas entering Epstein's cell at about 6:30 a.m. on
August 10.

We further noted that Epstein had previously been placed on suicide watch and psychological observation
due to the events of July 23, 2019; that numerous nooses made from prison bed sheets were found in his
cell on the morning of August 10; and that he had signed a new Last Will and Testament on August 8, 2 days
before he died. No weapons were recovered from Epstein's cell after his death. Additionally, the inmates
who were interviewed consistently reported that on the evening Epstein died the SHU staff did not
systematically conduct the required rounds and counts, which was one of the primary mechanisms for the
SHU staff to ensure the safety and security of inmates housed in the SHU. Asa result, Epstein was
unmonitored and locked alone in his cell for hours with an excess amount of linens, which provided an
opportunity for him to commit suicide.

Finally, the Medical Examiner who performed the autopsy detailed for the OIG why Epstein's injuries were
more consistent with, and indicative of, a suicide by hanging rather than a homicide by strangulation. The
Medical Examiner also told the OIG that the ligature furrow was too broad to have been caused by the
electrical cord of the medical device in Epstein's cell and that blood toxicology tests revealed no medications
or illegal substances were in Epstein's system. The Medical Examiner also noted the absence of debris
under Epstein's fingernails, marks on his hands, contusions to his knuckles, or bruises on his body that
would have indicated Epstein had been a struggle, which would be expected if Epstein's death had been a
homicide by strangulation.

This is not the first time that the OIG has found significant job performance and management failures on
the part of BOP personnel and widespread disregard of BOP policies that are designed to ensure that
inmates are safe, secure, and in good health. For instance, the OIG's December 2022 investigation and
review of the BOP's handling of the transfer of James "Whitey" Bulger identified serious job performance
52 U.S. DOJ OIG Notification of Needed Uogrades to the Federal Bureau of Prisons'Securitv Camera System
Management Advisory Memorandum 22-001 (October 2021); U.S. DOJ OIG, Audit of the Federal Bureau of Prisons'
Management and Oversight of its Chaplaincy Services Program 21-091 (July 2021); U.S. DOJ OIG Review of the Federal
Bureau of Prisons' Contraband Interdiction Fffortc Evaluation and Inspections Report 16-05 (June 2016).
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
and management failures at multiple levels within the BOP.53 Similar to the Bulger report, the numerous
and serious transgressions that occurred in this matter came to light largely because they involved a high-
profile inmate. The fact that serious deficiencies occurred in connection with high-profile inmates like
Epstein and Bulger is especially concerning given that the SOP would presumably take particular care in
handling the custody and care of such inmates.

Regrettably, the OIG has encountered similar issues on many other occasions. For example, the OIG has
investigated numerous allegations related to the falsification of official SOP documentation concerning
inmate counts and rounds, several of which have resulted in criminal prosecution. The OIG currently has
five open investigations into allegations of falsified inmate count and round documentation, each involving
an inmate death (by suicide and homicide) or escape from a BOP facility.

This investigation and review also revealed the direct impact of insufficient staffing levels on inmate safety.
Witnesses repeatedly told the OIG that counts, rounds, cell searches, and other methods of inmate
accountability were not undertaken because correctional staff were working multiple shifts —including one
staff member who worked 24-hours straight —and were tired and overwhelmed with other duties. As
discussed in greater detail in our recommendations, the OIG has repeatedly found the need for SOP to
address staffing shortages. Most recently, in March 2023, the OIG found that the coronavirus disease 2019
(COVID-19) pandemic exacerbated the effects of preexisting BOP medical and nonmedical staffing
shortages, an issue the OIG has identified as a concern for the BOP since at least 2015.50
Further, the OIG has repeatedly found that BOP personnel have not consistently been attentive to the needs
of inmates at risk for suicide. In this investigation, that inattention manifested in the failure of MCC New
York staff and supervisors to ensure that Epstein was assigned a cellmate as required by the MCC New York
Psychology Department directive issued after the July 23, 2019 incident in which Epstein was discovered in
his cell with a handmade orange cloth around his neck. In a March 2023 report the OIG found that BOP
psychology staff did not assess the suitability of single-cell assignments for five of the seven inmates who
died by suicide while in COVID-19 quarantine units between March 2020 and April 2021.55 The OIG's 2017
report on the BOP's use of restrictive housing for inmates with mental illness also noted that single-ceiling
may present risks to inmate mental health, and both of the recommendations from that report regarding
the use and oversight of single-telling remain open as of March 2023.56
Lastly, as discussed in greater detail in the conclusions and recommendations that follow, the persistent
deficiencies of the BOP's security camera systems are well documented and long-standing.
The combination of negligence, misconduct, and outright job performance failures documented in this
53 U.S. DOJ OIG Investigation and Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Handling of the Transfer of Inmatejames
White, Bulger, 23-007 (December 2022).

54 U.S. DOJ OIG, Capstone Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Response to the Coronavirus Disease 2019
Pandemic Evaluation and Inspections Division A-2020.011 (March 2023) (Capstone Report).
ss Capstone Report.

56 U.S. DOJ OIG Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Use of Restrictive Housing for Inmates with Mental Illness
Evaluation and Inspections Report 17-OS (lull/ 2017).
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
report all contributed to an environment in which arguably one of the most notorious inmates in BOP's
custody was provided with the opportunity to take his own life, resulting in significant questions being asked
about the circumstances of his death, how it could have been allowed to have happen, and most
importantly, depriving his numerous victims, many of whom were underage girls at the time of the alleged
crimes, of their ability to seek justice through the criminal justice process. The fact that these failures have
been recurring ones at the BOP does not excuse them, and gives additional urgency to the need for DOJ and
BOP leadership to address the chronic staffing, surveillance, security, and related problems plaguing the
BOP.

The OIG has completed its investigation and is providing this report to the BOP for appropriate action.
Unless otherwise noted, the OIG applies the preponderance of the evidence standard in determining
whether DOJ personnel have committed misconduct. The U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board applies this
same standard when reviewing a federal agencys decision to take adverse action against an employee
based on such misconduct. See 5 U.S.C. § 7701(c)(1)(B) and S C.F.R. § 1201.56(b)(1)(ii).

A. MCC New York Staff Failed to Ensure that Epstein Had a Cellmate on August 9 as
Instructed by the Psychology Department on July 30
On July 30, 2019, the MCC New York Psychology Department sent an email to over 70 BOP staff members
stating that Epstein 'needs to be housed with an appropriate cellmate." The Psychology Department's
directive that Epstein have an appropriate cellmate arose out of the events that occurred on July 23, 2019,
when Epstein was found lying on the floor of his cell with a piece of orange cloth around his neck. Epstein's
cellmate at the time (Inmate 1) told MCC New York staff that Epstein had tried to hang himself, and another
inmate housed on the same SHU tier at the time (Inmate 2) corroborated several aspects of Inmate 1's
account. Epstein's accounts of what had occurred varied. Epstein initially told MCC New York staff that he
thought his cellmate had tried to kill him, but thereafter he repeatedly said he did not know what had
occurred. Epstein later asked two different MCC New York staff members if he could be housed with the
same cellmate Epstein initially accused of having tried to harm him.

As a result of this incident, Epstein was placed on suicide watch and then psychological observation.
Consistent with the Psychology Department's directive, the Captain and the SHU Lieutenant each told the
OIG that they verbally informed SHU staff of Epstein's cellmate requirement. These and other witnesses
said staff members regularly assigned to the SHU knew that Epstein needed to have a cellmate. However,
despite the Psychology Department's widely disseminated July 30 email instruction and the subsequent
verbal direction provided by the Captain and the SHU Lieutenant, Epstein was left without a cellmate on
August 9 and, less than 24 hours later, Epstein died by suicide.
1. Failure to Make Required Notifications Regarding the Need to Assign Epstein a
New Cellmate
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that on August 9, 2019, MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU
failed to notify their superiors that Epstein's cellmate, Inmate 3, had been transferred out of MCC New York
and therefore Epstein needed to be assigned a new cellmate. The failure to make these required
notifications —and the supervisors' failure to properly supervise the SHU staff, discussed further below—
resulted in Epstein being housed without a cellmate at the time of his death, which was contrary to the
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Psychology Department's directive issued just 10 days earlier.

BOP standards of conduct require that employees "obey the orders of their superiors at all times."57 MCC
New York Post Orders for the SHU require, among other things, that all SHU officers "maintain a log of
pertinent information regarding inmate activity, detailing time, persons involved (if pertinent) and the event,
which must be logged into TRUSCOPE."58 Importantly, the SHU Post Orders clarify that they "are not
intended to describe in detail all the officer's responsibilities. Good judgment and common sense are
expected in all situations not covered in these post orders."
On August 9, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, and
Correctional Officer Tova Noel were each assigned to the MCC New York SHU as their permanent quarterly
assigned post and served as the SHU Officer in Charge during their respective shifts.59 The OIG
investigation found that each of these employees knew that Epstein was required to have a cellmate at all
times per the Psychology Department's directive.

The OIG further found that on August 9 the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge, and Noel each became aware at various times during their respective shifts that Epstein's
cellmate, Inmate 3, had been transferred from the institution with all of his belongings, a status known to all
MCC New York staff members as meaning the inmate was being permanently transferred out of the
institution. Specifically, the OIG investigation found that on the morning of August 9, the Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge and Correctional Officer 1, who was also assigned to the SHU, reviewed the MCC New York
daily call out list, a document that identifies all inmates who were leaving their housing units each day,
which listed Inmate 3 as being scheduled to depart MCC New York with all of his belongings. At
approximately 8:30 a.m., Correctional Officer 1 escorted Inmate 3 from the SHU to Receiving and Discharge
to be transferred out of the institution, and the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge escorted Epstein from the
SHU to the attorney conference room for his daily meeting with his attorneys. 60 During the escort, the Day
Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Correctional Officer 1 discussed the need to assign Epstein with a new
cellmate due to Inmate 3's transfer. 61 The Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG, and stated in a
memorandum that he prepared following Epstein's death, that he notified his relief, the Evening Watch SHU
Officer in Charge, of the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate, and that he likely notified an unspecified
lieutenant. However, the OIG did not credit the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge's account because no
other witnesses or evidence confirmed that he had in fact passed on information regarding Epstein's need
for a new cellmate, either to a supervisor or his relief.
59 BOP Program Statement 3420.11.

58 TRUSCOPE is a BOP database that provides institution staff with detailed inmate and institution security-related
information and provides unit officers an electronic event log.

59 Noel served as the SHU Officer in Charge after the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge's shift ended at 10:00 p.m.
on August 9, 2019.

60 Receiving and Discharge is the area of MCC New York that is responsible for processing inmates who enter or leave
the facility.

61 The OIG did not find that Correctional Officer 1 failed to make appropriate notifications because his immediate
superior in his chain-of-command, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, was aware of the need to assign Epstein a new
cellmate.
Limited Official Use Only-Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
The OIG investigation also found that during the next shift in the MCC New York SHU, both the Evening
Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Noel became aware that Epstein was without a cellmate. The Evening
Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that when he escorted Epstein back to his cell after Epstein's
telephone call, he saw that Inmate 3 was not there and then he, Noel, and the Material Handler discussed
the need for Epstein to have a new cellmate. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge also told the OIG
that he notified an unspecified supervisor. However, other witnesses did not corroborate his account Noel
told the OIG that she was unaware both that Epstein needed to have a cellmate and that Inmate 3 had been
removed from the institution. Noel also told the OIG that she went to Epstein's cell at approximately 10:00
p.m., a time of day when all inmates were secured in their cells, and may have plugged in Epstein's medical
device for him. The OIG did not credit Noel's statements that she did not know that Epstein needed a
cellmate or that Inmate 3 had been removed from the SHU based on contradictory witness statements
(including her own) regarding SHU staffs knowledge of Epstein's cellmate requirement and Inmate 3's
transfer out of the SHU. 4f,V
The OIG investigation concluded that on August 9, 2019, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Evening
Watch SHU Officer in Charge, and Noel failed to notify a supervisor as required after Epstein's cellmate was
permanently removed from the MCC New York SHU, which constituted a violation of BOP standards of
conduct. Additionally, their inaction violated MCC New York SHU Post Orders because none of these
individuals documented the fact the Epstein needed a new cellmate as required. Finally, all of these officers
failed to exercise good judgment and common sense, as required by the SHU Post Orders, by not
immediately undertaking steps through their chain-of-command to ensure that a high-profile inmate who
had been released from suicide watch and psychological observation 10 days earlier had an appropriate
cellmate.
2. Failure to Adequately Supervise SHU Staff
The OIG also found that MCC New York supervisory personnel failed to effectively perform their duties,
which contributed to the fact that Epstein was housed without a cellmate at the time of his death. Rather
than passively relying on a notification from subordinates, supervisory personnel also had an obligation
under federal regulations to "put forth honest effort in the performance of their duties," which included
supervision of SHU personnel. 62 The OIG's investigation revealed that the Captain and the Day Watch
Operations Lieutenant, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant, and
the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant, among other MCC New York staff, received an email from the
U.S. Marshals Service (USMS) on August 8, 2019, notifying them that Inmate 3 was scheduled to be
transferred to another facility the following day. If any of these supervisors had read the email attachment,
they would have known of the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate. Instead, many of these individuals
told the OIG that they believed that Inmate 3 had gone to court on August 9 and they were unaware that he
would not return and Epstein needed a new cellmate. The SHU Lieutenant's shift on August 8 ended over
an hour before the USMS sent the email notification and he was not working on August 9. In his absence,
and the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, the Day Watch Activities Lieutenant, the Evening Watch
Operations Lieutenant, and the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant had oversight of the SHU during their
respective shifts, and the Captain had oversight over all of the lieutenants. 63 The OIG found that the failure
62 5 C.F.R. § 2635.101(b)(5); see also 5 C.F.R. § 2635.705(a).

63 The Senior Officer Specialist who served as the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant from 4:00 p.m. to 10:00
Continued
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
of these individuals to adequately supervise SHU staff and ensure that a high-profile inmate who had
recently been on suicide watch and psychological observation had an appropriate cellmate constituted a job
performance failure.

3. Failure to Have a Contingency Plan for Assigning Epstein a Cellmate
Additionally, the OIG found that the Warden's failure to have a back-up cellmate assignment for Epstein
constituted poor judgment. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that although he knew
that Epstein needed to be assigned another cellmate, SHU staff could not just put anyone in the cell with
Epstein. The Warden confirmed this in his OIG interview, when he explained that he and BOP executive
leadership selected Inmate 3 as Epstein's cellmate following the events of July 23, 2019. The Warden told
the OIG that no inmates were pre-vetted to serve as Epstein's cellmate if Inmate 3 left MCC New York. The
Northeast Regional Director, the Warden, and the Captain all told the OIG that if Inmate 3 had been
removed as Epstein's cellmate, they would have had to review a new list of potential cellmate candidates to
ensure that Epstein was housed with an appropriate inmate. This selection process, which involved multiple
steps undertaken by high-level BOP management, would be difficult to accomplish in a short period of time
and ultimately may have impeded SHU officers' ability to house Epstein with a cellmate on August 9, 2019.
4. Lack of Candor
BOP policy requires that h[d]uring the course of an official investigation, employees are to cooperate fully by
providing all pertinent information they may have. Full cooperation requires truthfully responding to
questions."
As discussed above, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge and the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told
the OIG that they notified supervisory personnel regarding the need to assign Epstein a new cellmate.
Based on a lack of corroborating evidence for these assertions, the OIG found that they lacked candor in
their OIG interviews in violation of BOP policy. Similarly, the OIG found that Noel lacked candor in violation
of BOP policy when she said she did not know that Epstein needed a cellmate or that his then-cellmate
Inmate 3 had been transferred out of the SHU.

The OIG also found that the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant lacked candor in her interview with the
OIG in violation of BOP policy when she said she was not aware that Epstein was required to be housed with
a cellmate. Her statement is contradicted by the fact that she was one of the MCC New York staff members
who responded to the July 23, 2019 incident involving Epstein, which resulted in him being placed on suicide
watch and psychological observation; she was a recipient of the Psychology Department's July 30, 2019
email identifying the cellmate requirement; and the statements of multiple witnesses who told the OIG that
Epstein's cellmate requirement was widely disseminated verbally by MCC New York leadership.
p.m. on August 9, 2019, told the OIG that she was not aware of Epstein's cellmate requirement. The OIG credited her
account because she did not ordinarily work in or supervise the SHU and did not receive the Psychology Department's
July 30, 2019 email regarding the need for Epstein to have an appropriate cellmate or the USMS August 8, 2019 email
notifying that Inmate 3 would be transferred to another facility the following day.
64 BOP Program Statement 3420.11.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release

B. MCC New York Staff Failed to Conduct Mandatory Rounds and Inmate Counts
Resulting in Epstein Being Unobserved for Hours Before His Death
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that on August 9 and 10, 2019, MCC New York SHU staff did not
conduct the mandatory rounds and inmate counts during their shift in the SHU. The failure to undertake
these required measures to account for inmate whereabouts and wellbeing—and the supervisors' failure to
properly supervise the SHU staff, as discussed further below—resulted in Epstein being unobserved for
hours before his death, which compounded the failure of MCC New York staff to ensure that Epstein had an
appropriate cellmate.
1. Failure to Conduct Rounds and Inmate Counts in the SHU
Federal regulations require that employees "use official time in an honest effort to perform official duties."65
Additionally, BOP standards of conduct required that employees "[Conduct themselves in a manner that
fosters respect for the Bureau of Prisons, the Department of Justice, and the U.S. Government." 66 Because
"[0nattention to duty in a correctional environment can result in escapes, assaults, and other incidents," BOP
standards of conduct also require employees 'to remain fully alert and attentive during duty hours." BOP
policy also requires "[Continuous inmate accountability," which is accomplished through rounds and inmate
counts.67 Among other things, rounds and inmate counts enable staff to observe inmates and ensure that
they are safe and secure in their cells and are in good health.

BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders set out the requirements for these inmate accountability
measures, specifying that correctional staff must conduct rounds on an irregular schedule at least twice
each hour, no more than 40 minutes apart. BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders further specify
that at least two MCC New York SHU staff members must conduct inmate counts at 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m.,
5:00 a.m., 4:00 p.m., and 10:00 p.m. daily, and also at 10:00 a.m. on weekends and federal holidays.
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that an inmate (Inmate 4) was internally transferred from the
SHU to Receiving and Discharge at approximately 3:15 p.m. on August 9, 2019; however, this inmate transfer
was not documented until approximately 12:35 a.m. on August 10, 2019. Based on this internal transfer,
BOP records, and witness statements, the OIG determined that the 4:00 p.m. and 10:00 p.m. SHU inmate
counts on August 9 were erroneous. In addition, the OIG reviewed the available SHU security camera video,
which did not show correctional officers walking up or down the stairs leading to the various SHU tiers
during the count times, a process that is necessary to conduct an accurate count of inmates. 68 During their
OIG interviews, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, Correctional Officer Tova
Noel, and Material Handler Michael Thomas each admitted that they did not conduct all of the mandatory
rounds and inmate counts in the SHU on the evening of August 9 and the morning of August 10. Noel told
the OIG that she conducted the 10:00 p.m. count on August 9. The OIG did not credit her statement based
on: (1) its review of the SHU security camera video, which reflects Noel walking up and down the stairs
65 5 C.F.R. § 2635.705(a); see also S C.F.R. 5 2635.101(b0).
66 BOP Program Statement 3420.11.
67 BOP Program Statement 5500.14.

68 As discussed in Chapter 5, OIG found that the security camera video was of low quality. Therefore, the OIG analyzed
the video in conjunction with BOP records and witness statements regarding the personnel in the SHU and their
activities.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
leading to some, but not all, of the tiers several minutes after the SHU inmate count had been called into the
Control Center; (2) the 10:00 p.m. count slip, which erroneously included the SHU Inmate 4, who had been
internally transferred to Receiving and Delivery; (3) other BOP records; and (4) the Material Handlers
statement to the OIG that no one conducted the 10:00 p.m. count because everyone was tired.
Instead of performing the required duties to account for inmate whereabouts and wellbeing, the OIG found
that officers assigned to the SHU on August 9 and 10, including the Material Handler, Noel, and Thomas,
primarily remained seated in the SHU Officers' Station—sometimes without moving for a period of time,
suggesting that they were asleep—and conducted a variety of internet searches on MCC New York
computers. Thomas also admitted to the OIG that he "dozed off' for periods of time during his shift. The
OIG's analysis of the SHU security camera video revealed that after approximately 10:40 p.m., no
Correctional Officer entered Epstein's tier in the SHU until just before 6:30 a.m. when Noel and Thomas
began to serve breakfast to the inmates.

The OIG investigation and review concluded that the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material
Handler, Noel, and Thomas failed to conduct the mandatory rounds and inmate counts during their
respective shifts in the MCC New York SHU on August 9 and 10, 2019, and that their actions constituted
violations of S C.F.R. §§ 2635.101(b)(5) and 2635.705(a), BOP Program Statements 3420.11 and 5500.14, and
MCC New York SHU Post Orders.
2. False False Statements and Lack of Candor
The OIG's investigation and review found that on August 9 and 10, 2019, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in
Charge, the Material Handler, Noel, and Thomas made false statements when they falsified BOP records by
attesting that they had completed the mandatory rounds and inmate counts when, in fact, they had not.
Federal law provides that "whoever, in any matter within the jurisdiction of the executive...branch of the
Government of the United States, knowingly and willfully...makes or uses any false writing or document
knowing the same to contain any materially false, fictitious, or fraudulent statement or entry" has violated
18 U.S.C. § 1001(a)(3).

As discussed above, the OIG found that the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler,
Noel, and Thomas failed to conduct all of the mandatory rounds and inmate counts. As part of each
institutional inmate count, BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders require two correctional officers
to conduct each count and memorialize the number of inmates in the SHU on an official MCC New York
form, often called a count slip.69 On the count slip, both correctional officers are required to fill in the date
and time the count had been performed, write the total number of inmates physically present in the unit
counted, and then sign the count slip. Once the correctional officers complete and sign the count slips, the
count slips are then collected and delivered to the MCC New York Control Center. Officers assigned to the
Control Center are responsible for comparing the count slips from each housing unit to the institution's
overall inmate count sheet to ensure that each inmate was accounted for. 7° Only after all the count slips
have been collected from each housing unit, and the numbers on the count slips had been matched to the
69 This BOP form is officially entitled "Metropolitan Correctional Center; New York, New York; Official Count Slip."
70 The official name for the document used to record an institutional count is "Bureau of Prisons Count Sheet:
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
institution's overall inmate count sheet, could the institutional count be deemed 'cleared" or completed.
The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, Noel, and Thomas each prepared and/or
signed a false count slip to create the impression that they had fulfilled their inmate accountability
responsibilities when, in fact, they had not!' These individuals admitted to the OIG that instead of
performing their assigned duties, they pre-filled the count slips with the number of inmates they believed
were in the SHU based on what officers from the previous shift had told them and signed off on the
documents knowing that they falsely attested to having completed the counts. Additionally, Noel admitted
to the OIG that she had prefilled the official MCC New York forms documenting the times of the 30-minute
rounds, often referred to as round sheets, and falsely attested to having completed the rounds.0
Noel and Thomas were indicted by a grand jury for their false certifications of having conducted counts and
rounds. Subsequently, each entered into a deferred prosecution agreement with the U.S. Attorney's Office
for the Southern District of New York. The U.S. Attorney's Office of the Southern District of New York
declined prosecution for the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and the Material Handler.
The OIG investigation has found that the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, Noel,
and Thomas knowingly and willingly falsified BOP records in violation of federal law by attesting that they
had completed the mandatory rounds and inmate counts on the evening of August 9, 2019, and morning of
August 10, 2019.

Additionally, as noted above, BOP policy requires employees to cooperate fully with an official investigation
and truthfully respond to questions. The OIG found that Noel lacked candor when she told the OIG that she
had conducted the 10:00 p.m. count when the weight of evidence indicates that, at most, she may have
conducted a round at the time.
3. Poor Judgment Regarding the Use of Overtime
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that on August 9, 2019, MCC New York supervisory staff
requested that a staff member fill an overtime position within the SHU, which resulted in that staff member
working three shifts back-to-back, that is, 24 hours straight.

The collective bargaining agreement between the BOP and unions representing BOP employees provides
that "[o]rdinarily, the minimum time off between shifts will be seven and one-half (7/) hours, and the
minimum elapsed time of on 'days off will be fifty-six (56) hours, except when the employee requests the
change.""
The Material Handler told the OIG that on August 9 he reported for a voluntary overtime shift from 12:00
a.m. to 8:00 a.m. and then worked his regular 8:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. shift in the warehouse. At some point
71 The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge and Noel signed the 4:00 p.m. count slip; Noel and the Material Handler
signed the 10:00 p.m. count slip; and Noel and Thomas signed the 12:00 a.m., 3:00 a.m., and 5:00 a.m. count slips.
77 This BOP form is officially entitled "MCC New York, Special Housing Unit, 30 Minute Check Sheet."
77 BOP and Council of Prison Locals, Master Agreement, July 21, 2014-July 20, 2021 (extended until 2026).
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
during the day shift, the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant, a higher ranking official, called and asked the
Material Handler if he could work overtime in the SHU and he agreed. The Material Handler told the OIG
that he felt pressured to work the third shift, which resulted in him working 24 hours straight, from 12:00
a.m. on August 9 through 12:00 a.m. on August 10. As discussed previously, the Material Handler admitted
to the OIG that on the evening of August 9, during his third shift which he worked in the SHU, he did not
conduct the mandatory inmate counts and rounds because he was too tired.

The OIG investigation and review concluded that the Day Watch Operations Lieutenant exercised poor
judgment when he requested that the Material Handler work a third consecutive shift. As the Day Watch
Operations Lieutenant, he had access to the staff roster and schedule and therefore he should have known
that the Material Handler had already worked 16 straight hours. Additionally, the Day Watch Operations
Lieutenant's action was inconsistent with the collective bargaining agreement and did not reflect sound
correctional judgment, as it would have been extremely difficult for the Material Handler to have effectively
performed his duties during his third shift.
4. Clearing the 10:00 p.m. Institutional Count Knowing that It Was Inaccurate
The OIG's investigation and review determined that on August 9, 2019, MCC New York staff cleared the
10:00 p.m. institutional count knowing that the inmate counts from two housing units were inaccurate.
BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that correctional officers conducting an institutional
count relay the count verbally to the Control Center, which maintains the master count of all inmates!' If a
count reported verbally does not match the master count, the Control Center must notify the Operations
Lieutenant and the staff members must recount the inmates. MCC New York SHU Post Orders further
provide that "[c]ount slips which appear to be altered will not be accepted."
As discussed previously, the OIG determined that an internal transfer of an inmate (Inmate 4) from the SHU
to Receiving and Discharge on August 9 was not documented appropriately at the time of the transfer. The
failure to document the transfer, along with the SHU staff not conducting the required inmate counts,
resulted in the MCC New York Control Center receiving a count slip from the SHU with an incorrect number
of inmates identified as being present within the SHU at the 10:00 p.m. institutional count.
During his OIG interview, Senior Officer Specialist 6, who was assigned to the Control Center, admitted that
he amended the 10:00 p.m. count slips he received from the SHU and Receiving and Discharge in an
attempt to reflect the correct number of inmates in the SHU following the internal inmate transfer that
resulted in a SHU inmate (Inmate 4) being moved to Receiving and Discharge earlier in the day. Senior
Officer Specialist 6 acknowledged that he should have requested a recount from the SHU, but instead he
cleared the 10:00 p.m. count. Senior Officer Specialist 6 explained that the action he took was known as
"ghost counting," something he said he would not have done without authorization from the Operations
Lieutenant or someone of a higher rank than himself. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant denied
having authorized a "ghost count" and we found no evidence to corroborate Senior Officer Specialist 6's
claim that the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant knew of and approved the false count.
74 BOP Program Statement 5270.11.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
The OIG found that Senior Officer Specialist 6 modified the count slips received from the SHU and Receiving
and Discharge, failed to request a recount of the SHU inmates, and cleared the 10:00 p.m. institutional
count knowing that it was inaccurate in violation of BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders.
5. Failure to Adequately Supervise SHU Staff and Conduct Lieutenant Rounds
The OIG also found that MCC New York supervisory personnel failed to effectively perform their duties,
which contributed to the fact that Epstein was unobserved for many hours before his death. As discussed
above, federal regulations require that MCC New York supervisory personnel "put forth honest effort in the
performance of their duties," which includes appropriate supervision of SHU personnel. 75 Additionally, BOP
policy requires that a lieutenant visit the SHU during each shift to ensure that all procedures are being
followed. 76
The OIG's investigation revealed that the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant had oversight of the SHU during their respective shifts." The Evening Watch
Operations Lieutenant told the OIG that on August 9, 2019, he did not supervise the 4:00 p.m. count or
conduct any rounds in the SHU. He acknowledged that he Igned some of the pages of the 4:00 p.m. count,
but he did not sign all of the pages as he should have. Beginning at 10:00 p.m. on August 9, the Morning
Watch Operations Lieutenant was the sole supervisor overseeing the SHU. The Morning Watch Operations
Lieutenant told the OIG that she noticed an error in the 12:00 a.m. count on August 10, which was due to
SHU staff including Inmate 4, who had been internally transferred to Receiving and Discharge, among the
inmates in the SHU. According to the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant, the SHU staff should have
conducted another count and submitted a new count slip, but she did not know if they actually did so.
,A•7 7
During her shift, the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant conducted one round in the SHU at
approximately 4:00 a.m. on August 10. The OIG's review of the available SHU security camera video
revealed that the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant was present in the SHU for approximately 7
minutes, during which time she conferred with Noel and Thomas, who were seated at and around the SHU
Officers' Station in the common area of the SHU. The Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant told the OIG
that she was not required to visit each tier or go to each individual cell during a lieutenant round, but rather
the purpose of the lieutenant round was for her to speak with the officers on duty. This description of a
lieutenant round is inconsistent with the &tements of many other supervisors and BOP lieutenant training,
all of which emphasized the need for lieilrants to walk down all of the SHU tiers during a round. During
their interviews with the OIG, the Northeast Regional Director, the Warden, Associate Warden 1, and the
Captain clarified that they expected a lieutenant conducting a round in the SHU to check in with the officers,
walk down each of the tiers in the SHU, speak with inmates, and address inmate concerns. They explained
that the lieutenants did not act responsibly if they did not walk down each of the tiers to check on the
76 5 C.F.R. § 2635.101(6)(5); see also 5 C.F.R. § 2635.705(a).
76 BOP Program Statement 5270.11.

77 The Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant also had oversight over the SHU during her overtime shift (4:00 p.m.
to 10:00 p.m. on August 9, 2019) in an acting capacity. The Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Acting Evening
Watch Activities Lieutenant told the OIG that the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant did not supervise any
institutional counts, which was due to the start and end time of her overtime shift. The Acting Evening Watch Activities
Lieutenant also told the OIG that she conducted one round in the SHU sometime between 5:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m., during
which time she walked down all of the tiers.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
inmates in the SHU. As the Acting Evening Watch Activities Lieutenant explained, unlike inmates in general
population, SHU inmates cannot approach a supervisor because they are confined within a cell. Further, the
BOP lieutenant training, which the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant attended in 2011, taught that
Operations Lieutenants were required to visit the SHU at least once during each shift and that "[t]his visit
will be substantially more than just entering the unit, signing the log book, and talking with staff." Instead,
Operations Lieutenants were trained to, among other things, walk through each range (or tier), inspect logs
and reports, observe activities, and periodically observe counts within the SHU.

The OIG found that the failure of the Evening Watch Operations Lieutenant and the Morning Watch
Operations Lieutenant to adequately supervise SHU staff, and of the Morning Watch Operations Lieutenant
to adequately conduct a lieutenant round in the SHU, which contributed to the SHU staffs failure to conduct
mandatory rounds and counts, constituted a job performance failure.
C. MCC New York Staff Allowed Epstein to Place an Unmonitored Telephone Call on
August 9
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that on the night before his death, Epstein placed an
unrecorded, unmonitored telephone call using a non-Inmate Telephone System line from 6:58 p.m. to 7:19
p.m. Other than an MCC New York call log, no other BOP records exist regarding this unmonitored call,
including the identity of the person Epstein called or a summary of the conversation.
Federal regulations require that the Warden of each BOP institution establish procedures to monitor inmate
telephone conversations, which is "done to preserve the security and orderly management of the institution
and to protect the public."78 For safety and security reasons, BOP policy requires that all inmate telephone
calls be made through the Inmate Telephone System.19 BOP policy recognizes that "on rare occasion, in
times of crisis," inmates may be permitted to make a telephone call outside of the Inmate Telephone
System. In such circumstances, the telephone "must be placed in a secure area (e.g., a locked office), and
"must be set to record telephone calls." Additionally, the staff member coordinating the call must notify the
BOP's Special Investigative Services via email, providing the inmate's name and register number, the date
and time of the call, the number and name of the individual called, and the reason for the call. The Special
Investigative Services must enter this information into the telephone recording system within 7 days.
The OIG's investigation determined that on August 9, 2019, Epstein asked to call his mother. The Unit
Manager told the OIG that after Epstein's attorney visit had concluded, he agreed to allow Epstein to place a
telephone call on an unrecorded legal line. The Unit Manager explained that it was his understanding that
Epstein did not have the ability to place a telephone call through the Inmate Telephone System. The OIG's
investigation established both that Epstein's mother was deceased at the time he asked to telephone her
and that Epstein had been assigned the necessary documentation that would have allowed him to place
calls through the Inmate Telephone System, although he did not take the necessary steps to complete the
setup process that would have given him the ability to place calls through that system. The Captain told the
OIG that when the Unit Manager was escorting Epstein from his attorney visit back to the SHU and Epstein's
requested call was discussed, he told the Unit Manager that Epstein's telephone call had to be monitored
78 28 U.S.C. § 540.102.
79 BOP Program Statement P5264.08.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
and logged.

The Unit Manager told the OIG that he escorted Epstein from his attorney visit to the shower area of the
SHU, where he connected a telephone into an unrecorded legal line, and dialed the phone number provided
by Epstein. The Unit Manager said that when a male answered the call, he handed the telephone to Epstein,
and then left MCC New York for the day because his shift had ended. Before leaving the SHU, the Unit
Manager said he told the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, and Noel, who were at
the SHU Officers' Station, to make sure Epstein got his 15 minutes on the telephone, but he did not instruct
them to monitor the telephone call. The Unit Manager admitted that he did not verify the recipient of the
telephone call, and that neither he nor anyone monitored or logged the telephone call as required.
The OIG found that the Unit Manager violated BOP policy by allowing Epstein to make an unrecorded and
unmonitored telephone call, and by failing to verify the telephone call recipient, monitor, and log the call.
We further found that the Unit Manager exercised poor judgment when he left MCC New York while Epstein
was still on the telephone call that the Unit Manager had arranged and failed to instruct the Evening Watch
SHU Officer in Charge, the Material Handler, or Noel to monitor the call.
D. MCC New York Staff Failed to Conduct and Document Cell Searches and Eliminate
Safety Hazards in Epstein's Cell on August 9 Leaving Epstein with Excessive Linens
in His Cell
The OIG's investigation and review determined that MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU on August 9,
2019, failed to conduct and document searches of Epstein's cell in the SHU. BOP policy requires that BOP
staff routinely and irregularly search housing units.w MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that SHU
staff conduct at least five cell searches each shift during daytime and evening hours (7:45 a.m. to 12:00
a.m.), in addition to other searches of SHU cells and common areas, and BOP policy and MCC New York SHU
Post Orders require written documentation of cell searches. BOP policy explains that the purpose of cell
searches are to, among other things, maintain sanitary conditions and eliminate safety hazards. To that
end, MCC New York General Housing Unit Post Orders provide that when an inmate is transferred out of a
facility, all of the inmate's linens should be taken to Receiving and Discharge.

The OIG reviewed MCC New York SHU TRUSCOPE entries for August 9, and identified only one cell search
entered by MCC New York SHU staff for the entire day. During his interview with the OIG, the Day Watch
SHU Officer in Charge stated that multiple cell searches were conducted in the MCC New York SHU on
August 9; however, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge stated that he failed to document the cell searches
within the TRUSCOPE system as required because he was too busy with other duties. The Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge further stated that any of the SHU staff could have logged the cell searches into
TRUSCOPE, but that it was primarily the SHU Officer in Charge's responsibility to do so. The Evening Watch
SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that he and other staff members did not conduct any cell searches
during his shift in the SHU on August 9. Additionally, the OIG determined that there was an excessive
amount of bed linen within Epstein's cell. The Captain reviewed photographs of Epstein's cell and told the
OIG that that the excessive linens were a security issue because they could give inmates materials to fashion
80 BOP Program Statement 5521.06.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
an improvised noose or use as escape paraphernalia.

The OIG found that on August 9, 2019, the Day Watch SHU Officer in Charge either failed to conduct the
required cell searches or failed to document the cell searches that he conducted in the SHU, and that the
Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge failed to ensure that MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU
conducted cell searches and himself failed to log cell searches in violation of BOP policy and MCC New York
SHU Post Orders. Additionally, the OIG found that it was a performance failure for the Day Watch SHU
Officer in Charge, the Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge, and Noel, who served as the SHU Officer in
Charge during their respective shifts on August 9 and 10, 2019, to have permitted Epstein to have an
excessive amount of linens in his cell.
E. MCC New York Staff Failed to Ensure that the Institution's Security Camera
System was Fully Functional Resulting in Limited Recorded Video Evidence
This investigation and review revealed longstanding deficiencies with MCC New York's security camera
system. These deficiencies resulted in nearly all of the cameras in and around the SHU where Epstein was
being housed to not record video starting in late July 2019 and continuing through the date of Epstein's
death on August 10, 2019. According to forensic analysis conducted by the FBI after Epstein's death, on July
29, 2019, a disk failure in MCC New York's Digital Video Recorder (DVR) 2 system caused approximately half
of the institution's cameras—including nearly all of the cameras in and around the SHU—to display only a
live video feed with no video recording. MCC New York personnel did not learn of this system failure until
11 days later on August 8, 2019. MCC New York personnel determined that the DVR 2 system needed to be
rebuilt to restore recording functionality. Despite the lack of recording functionality, this repair was not
completed until after Epstein's death.

The Warden told the OIG that he was generally aware that there were problems with the camera system.
The Warden sought and received approval from BOP to replace the entire camera system and in September
2018, BOP entered into contracts totaling over $730,000 to purchase new equipment for the camera
replacement project. Although MCC New York management procured new DVR components approximately
9 months prior to Epstein's death, the new system was not installed in a timely manner. The new cameras
required new conduit and wiring to be installed before the camera installation. Management faced staffing
shortages, temporary rotating facility managers, and other competing priorities that did not allow for
completion of the installation of the wiring or the new camera system. The OIG determined that as of
August 2021—nearly 3 years after MCC New York contracted for replacement camera equipment —the
system upgrade still had not been completed. 81
MCC New York's failure to ensure that its security camera system was fully functional and make timely
repairs is consistent with the OIG's previous observations regarding weaknesses in the BOP's overall system
of security cameras. Dating back to at least 2013, the OIG has repeatedly observed inadequacies in the
BOP's overall system of security cameras, including inoperable cameras, an insufficient number of cameras,
poor video quality, and inadequate video storage. In a 2016 report on the BOP's contraband interdiction
efforts, the OIG identified specific deficiencies with the camera system, and recommended that the BOP
81 The BOP temporarily closed MCC New York in October 2021 due to substandard conditions that are unrelated to this
investigation and review.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
evaluate the system to determine needed upgrades. 82 In response to the 2016 recommendation, the BOP
assessed the camera systems at each institution over the next several years and determined that 45 of its
122 institutions, including MCC New York, required camera system upgrades. The SOP worked to upgrade
the systems at those 45 institutions between 2019 and 2021. In June 2021, the BOP reported that it had
updated all cameras at the 45 institutions with the latest software and equipment, and that it had installed
additional cameras to bolster surveillance. However, as reported in an October 2021 Management Advisory
Memorandum issued to the BOP, the OIG analyzed the reported upgrades at the 45 institutions and found
that the SOP had addressed some but not all of the deficiencies described in the 2016 OIG report. In its
2021 Management Advisory Memorandum, the OIG recommended that the BOP develop a comprehensive
strategic plan for transitioning to a fully digital security camera system. The BOP has provided the OIG with
a strategic plan that includes estimated cost projections and timelines for addressing the camera system
concerns and completing the system upgrades 83 As of 2023, the OIG's 2021 recommendation remains
open. Jg''
The BOP's failure to address the issue of functional security camera systems across t ncy  and at
individual institutions presents an ongoing risk to the safety of BOP staff and inmates and hal the potential
to impair the investigation of and accountability for staff and inmate misconduct. It is imperative that the
BOP prioritize the expeditious expansion and modernization of its security camera system to mitigate
security risks.
id\ II. Recommendations
The OIG investigation identified multiple shortcomings in BOP policies that should be further assessed to
ensure the BOP can more effectively handle issues that arise in connection with the custody and care of
inmates. The recommendations address issues related to and the custody and care of inmates at risk for
suicide; measures designed to increase safety, such as staff rounds, inmate counts, and cell searches; and
institutional security camera systems and staffing shortages, two longstanding issues for the BOP.

1. The BOP should implement a proce r assigning a cellmate following suicide watch or
psychological observation.

According to the MCC New York Institution Supplement policy to the Suicide Prevention Program Policy
Statement 5324.08, inmates discharged from suicide watch will be assigned a cellmate. The supplemental
policy does not, however, describe how long the cellmate requirement should last or if any staff must
approve the removal of the cellmate requirement. The Suicide Prevention Program Policy Statement
5324.08 does not describe any process or procedure that requires cellmate assignments for inmates coming
off of suicide watch. The Warden stated there was no SOP policy mandating that an inmate coming off of
suicide watch have a cellmate, but that doing so was "sound correctional judgment."
The OIG's investigation and review revealed that there were knowledge gaps among MCC New York staff
regarding Epstein's cellmate requirement, indicating that improved communication with institutional staff
82 U.S. DOJ OIG Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Contraband Interdiction Efforts Evaluation and Inspections
Report 16-05 (June 2016).

83 U.S. DOJ OIG Notification of Needed Upgrades to the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Security Camera System
Management Advisory Memorandum 22-001 (October 2021).
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
would be beneficial. The OIG therefore recommends that the BOP implement a requirement that all
inmates coming off of suicide watch or psychological observation to be assigned cellmates, provide
guidance for determining when a cellmate is no longer required, and implement a process for approving,
documenting, and communicating to institutional staff the assignment and removal of cellmates for these
inmates.

2. The BOP should establish a contingency plan for cellmate assignment for high-risk inmates,
ensuring that another cellmate can be assigned efficiently.

The OIG's investigation and review found that there was no contingency plan in place to assign Epstein a
new cellmate when his then-cellmate was transferred out of MCC New York. Although the failure to assign a
new cellmate was due, in part, to SHU staff failing to make required notifications and supervisory staff
failing to adequate supervise SHU staff, the gap in cellmate assignment was also due to the lack of a
contingency plan. The Evening Watch SHU Officer in Charge told the OIG that although he knew that Epstein
needed a new cellmate, he said that SHU staff did not have the authority to assign a new cellmate, which
was consistent with what MCC New York supervisory personnel told the OIG. A contingency plan, such as a
list of alternate cellmates, would have increased the likelihood that Epstein would not have been housed
alone at the time of his death. The OIG therefore recommends that the BOP develop contingency plans for
cellmate assignment for high-risk inmates.
Aa- \a,
3. The BOP should implement a process that requires approval to be obtained and
documented for social or legal visits while an inmate is on suicide watch or psychological
observation.

According to the BOP's Suicide Prevention Program Policy Statement 5324.08 and the MCC New York
Institution Supplement to the suicide prevention policy, inmates on suicide watch must be under constant
observation by staff or trained inmate observers. The MCC New York Institution Supplement policy states
that only with rare exceptions that are approved by the Captain as well by the Associate Warden of
Programs will visitation either social or legal be permitted for inmates on suicide watch. Additionally, the
MCC New York Procedural Memorandum for Psychological Observation states that inmates on
psychological observation will be continuously monitored by either an inmate companion or a staff
member.

A review of the Suicide Watch Chronological Logs for July 23, 2019, revealed Epstein was allowed to leave the
suicide watch room to visit with his attorneys for more than 6 hours. According to the Psychological
Reconstruction conducted by the Assistant Director of the Reentry Services Division, during Epstein's
psychological observation on July 24 through July 30, 2019, Epstein was also allowed to visit with his
attorneys between 8-11 hours each day without direct observation. Although the MCC New York
supplemental policy described an approval process for social and legal visits while an inmate is on suicide
watch or psychological observation, the OIG found no evidence that Epstein's legal visits were approved by
the Captain or an Associate Warden. Additionally, the BOP Suicide Prevention Program Policy Statement
5324.08 does not describe any process or procedures that allows inmate to have legal or social visits while
on suicide watch or psychological observation. The OIG therefore recommends that the BOP develop and
implement a process for such visits to be approved and documented.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release

4. The BOP should improve its methods of accounting for inmate whereabouts and wellbeing
by expanding institutional controls and documentation.

The OIG's investigation and review revealed many inmate accountability deficiencies. Most fundamentally,
MCC New York staff assigned to the SHU on August 9 and 10, 2019, did not conduct many of the required
rounds and inmate counts. Additionally, there was lacking or delayed documentation regarding inmates,
including cell assignments and internal inmate transfers. Internal reports, such as the daily call out list and
the lieutenant log, are either not retained or subject to continuous modification, which reduces their utility
as accountability tools. Therefore, the OIG recommends that the BOP develop a plan to improve its
methods of accounting for inmate whereabouts and wellbeing, institutional controls, and documentation.

5. BOP policy should clarify what is required of a lieutenant when conducting a round.
The OIG's investigation and review revealed significant gaps in the supervision of MCC New York staff
assigned to the SHU. Although BOP policy requires MCC New York lieutenants to conduct at least one
round in the SHU during each shift, what was required of a lieutenant during the round is not specified.
During their interviews with the OIG, experienced MCC New York supervisory personnel described what
should be done during a round, which is also reflected in BOP lieutenant training, but this expectation was
not memorialized in any BOP or MCC New York policy or Post Order. The OIG recommends that the BOP
develop a policy, either at an agency-wide or institution -specific level, to define what is expected of
supervisory personnel during a round in the SHU to better ensure that BOP staff are appropriately
supervised.

6. The BOP should develop and implement a plan to address staffing shortages at its prisons.
Since at least 2015, the OIG has repeatedly found the need for BOP to address staffing shortages, including
medical staffing shortages,' This investigation and review revealed the direct impact of staffing deficiencies
on inmate safety. For example, the Material Handler worked three consecutive shifts-24 hours straight —
on August 9, 2019, which was certainly a contributory cause to the lack of adequate means of accounting for
inmate location and wellbeing in the SHU. The Material Handler told the OIG that no one did the 10:00 p.m.
SHU inmate count because they were tired. Additionally, the OIG's investigation and review found that in
connection with MCC New York's upgrade of its security camera system, the BOP's Northeast Regional Office
arranged for technicians from other BOP institutions to perform temporary duty (TDY) assignments to MCC
84 U.S. DOJ 016, Analytic of  the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Fiscal Year 2019 Overtime Hours and Cogs Management
Advisory Memorandum 21.011 (December 2020); U.S. DOJ OIG, Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Use of
Restrictive Housing for Inmates with Mentallllnecc Evaluation and Inspections Division Report 17-05 (July 2017); U.S.
DOJ OIG, Audit of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' ContrarrNo. DIBP0616BPA 12004 Awardod to Soertrum Sorviros, Inc..
Vic-torville, California Audit Division Report 17-20 (March 2017); U.S. DOJ OIG, Audit of the Federal Bureau of Prisons'
Contract with Coreavic Inc. to Operate the Adams County Correctional Center in Natchez Mississipp4 Audit Division
Report 17-08 (December 2016); U.S. DOJ 01G, Review of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Mediral Staffing (hallows
Evaluation and Inspections Division Report 16-02 (March 2016); U.D. DOJ OIG, Review of the Impact of an Aging Inmate
Population on the Federal Bureau of Prisons Evaluation and Inspections Division Report 15.05 (May 2015). Additionally,
multiple remote inspections the 016 conducted as part of its pandemic response oversight work revealed that staffing
shortages impacted the BOP's ability to respond to Inmates' medical needs during the Coronavirus disease 2019
pandemic. These findings are summarized in the OIG's Capstone report.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
New York to perform necessary mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and wiring work. Yet, during the course of
the TDY rotations, work was not consistently conducted on the camera upgrade because sometimes TDY
staff were used to cover shortages at MCC New York's custody posts. Without adequate staffing, the BOP
cannot fulfill its mandate to ensure safe and secure correctional facilities. The OIG therefore recommends
that the SOP develop and implement a plan to address staffing shortages at its institutions.

7. The BOP should clarify and improve the cell search policy.

The OIG's investigation and review found that there were an excessive amount of linens in Epstein's cell at
the time of his death. BOP policy and MCC New York SHU Post Orders require that SHU cells be searched,
but they do not specifically address the issue of excessive bed linens, which the Captain told the OIG
present a safety hazard because an inmate can use them to harm him/herself or escape from the
institution. Therefore, the OIG recommends that the SOP clarify, either at an agency-wide or institution -
specific level, what materials should be seized during a cell search.

8. The BOP should develop policies requiring that institutional security camera systems have
the capacity to record video and that BOP institutions conduct regular security camera
system functionality checks.

As discussed in the Conclusions section of this chapter, the OIG found that, even though the highest levels
of leadership knew of the MCC New York security camera system's recurring deficiencies, prior to Epstein's
death, no one at MCC New York was tasked with the responsibility of checking the security camera system
on a routine basis to ensure that the system was functional. As a result, when on July 29, 2019, video from
approximately half of the institution's security cameras was no longer being recorded, the problem went
undetected for 11 days. The OIG also found that there are no BOP policies that require that security camera
systems have the capacity to record or that institutional staff perform periodic checks to ensure the camera
system is fully functional. Cameras that are failing to provide good quality or any live video streams put the
safety of BOP staff members and inmates at risk, and the lack of video recordings can potentially hinder
investigations of wrongdoing by staff and inmates. The OIG therefore recommends that the BOP develop
policies and protocols that require that all institutional security camera systems have the capacity to record,
and that specified staff at each institution conduct periodic checks of the security camera system to
determine its operational status and take corrective action as soon as possible when the system is found to
be inoperable. Such routine checks would help ensure that camera system malfunctions are detected and
corrective actions are initiated in a timely manner.
Limited Official Use Only—Not for Public Release
EFTA02731082 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ memo about investigation into Epstein's co-conspirators
(inferred timestamp: 2024-10-04 20:19:00)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
MEMORANDUM
TO: Geoffrey S. Berman. U.S. Attorn
FROM: AUSAs
DATE: December 19, 2019
RE: Investigation into Potential Co-Conspirators of Jeffrey Epstein
This memorandum details the investigative steps taken since the indictment of Jeffrey
Epstein in this District on July 2, 2019 and analyzes the extent to which certain of Epstein's
associates and employees may or may not be criminally liable for their conduct during their
employment with Epstein.
I. Background
On July 2, 2019, a federal grand jury in the Southern District of New York returned a
sealed indictment (the "Indictment") charging Jeffrey Epstein with one count of sex trafficking
of minors, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591, and one count of conspiracy to commit sex
trafficking of minors, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371.
The prosecution memorandum in support of that indictment detailed the evidence
gathered regarding Epstein and his associates during our Office's pre-indictment investigation.
That evidence revealed that beginning in at least 2002, Epstein enticed and recruited dozens of
minor girls to engage in sex acts with him, for which he paid the victims hundreds of dollars in
cash. He undertook this activity in at least two different locations, including his mansion in
Manhattan, New York (the "New York Residence") and his estate in Palm Beach, Florida (the
"Palm Beach Residence"). In both New York and Florida. Epstein perpetuated this abuse in
similar ways. Victims were initially recruited to provide "massages" to Epstein, which would be
performed nude or partially nude, would become increasingly sexual in nature, and would
typically include one or more sex acts, including groping and direct or indirect contact with
victims' genitals. Epstein paid his victims hundreds of dollars in cash for each separate
encounter.
Moreover, Epstein actively encouraged certain of his victims to recruit additional girls to
be similarly sexually abused. He incentivized his victims to become recruiters by paying these
victim-recruiters hundreds of dollars for each additional girl they brought to him. In this fashion.
Epstein created a vast network of underage victims — as young as 14 — in locations including
New York and Palm Beach. In creating and maintaining a network of minor victims whom he
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
abused, Epstein worked with others, including employees and associates who facilitated his
exploitation of minors by, among other things, contacting victims and scheduling their sexual
encounters with Epstein, both in New Yorlc and in Florida.
Epstein was arrested on July 6, 2019, and the Indictment against him was unsealed on
July 8, 2019. That same day, our Office held a press conference asking anyone with information,
including any victims, to come forward and meet with investigators. In the wake of the press
conference, numerous victims and witnesses came forward and were interviewed by the FBI and
ow Office.
On or about August 10, 2019, Epstein committed suicide while in custody at the
Metropolitan Correctional Center. Since his death, we have continued the investigation that
remained ongoing following the return of the Indictment against Epstein into tential co-
conspirators. In particular, that investigation focused on Ghislaine Maxwell,
and Leslie Groff. This memo details the steps taken in this
investigation since July 2019, summarizes the potential charges for the conduct at issue, and
analyzes the evidence against certain of Epstein's associates and employees:
Leslie Groff, and Ghislaine Maxwell. The potential charges
against Maxwell will be further analyzed in a separate prosecution memorandum, which is
expected to seek authorization to charge Maxwell with federal offenses for her role in facilitating
the transport of minors for illegal sex acts.
II. Investigative Steps Taken
Since the Indictment was unsealed on July 5, 2019, our Office and the FBI have been
contacted by numerous potential witnesses—both directly and through their attorneys. Every
unrepresented person who contacted the investigative team—either through the FBI tip line or by
calling our Office—was contacted in the first instance by an FBI agent for an initial screening
interview. The FBI then provided our Office with the names and contact information of individuals
who appeared to have information pertinent to our investigation. The AUSAs and case agents then
conducted follow up interviews of those identified individuals. In addition, the investigative team
initiated contact with numerous witnesses about whom we learned both through our investigation
and through press reporting. Although some individuals declined to be interviewed, we ultimately
conducted dozens of witness interviews and proffers. At the same time, following the unsealing of
the Indictment, ow Office and the FBI took numerous additional investigative steps, including the
execution of search warrants, the review of financial records and other documents, and meetings
with attorneys for numerous subjects of the investigation.
This section walks through the information gathered during our continuing investigation
since Epstein's arrest in July 2019. First, we summarize interviews conducted with victims who
were abused as minors. Second, we summarize interviews conducted with victims who were
abused as adults. Third, we summarize interviews conducted with victims who were not abused.
Fourth, we summarize interviews with individuals who are subjects of the investigation. Fifth, we
summarize ow interview with one victim,
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Finally, we walk through other investigative steps, such as attorney proffers,
search warrants, and document review.
A. Interviews of Victims Who Were Abused As Minors
1.
Since the unsealing of the Indictment, we have been in regular contact with attorneys
who represent
Over the course of multiple proffers, all conducted between March 2019 and July
2019, has described how she was recruited to engage in sexual contact with Epstein in
approximately , at the age of approximately 14. While at a New York City club,
met another teenager who described having worked for a rich man, giving topless massages—
and recruiting other girls to do the same—and invited to make money this way. At the
time, was living by herself and supporting herself financially, having moved away
from a difficult home life.
ultimately visited Epstein's New York residence to engage in sexual massages
and other sex acts at least dozens of times between approximately , all while she
was a minor.' During these visits, performed erotic massages on Epstein, including
being partially or fully nude while she massaged him. Most or all of the massages performed by
would end with Epstein masturbating and ejaculating; during some of the massages,
Epstein touched the genitals o with his hand or with a vibrator or sex toy.
also reported a hazy memory of participating in an incident in which
was nude with Epstein in his bed. could not recall the details of any sex
acts that occurred during that interaction with Epstein ordinarily paid
$300 in cash after a massage was completed. During an earlier visit, recalls Epstein
asking her how old she was and her truthfully telling Epstein that she was 14 years old.
After initial meetings with Epstein, he asked her, in sum and substance, to
recruit other girls for the same activity. Over approximately the next two years,
estimates that she brought dozens of girls to Epstein to provide massages at his New York
residence, starting with girls she knew from her community and eventually strangers whom
met at bars, clubs, or other locations. would describe to the girls what was
expected, i.e., that they would provide erotic massages to Epstein, while nude, and that Epstein
might touch them or ask them to touch him. would schedule appointments for the
provided a detailed description of Epstein's New York residence, which was
corroborated by photographs taken by the FBI during the execution of a search warrant there in
July 2019.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
girls by phone with Leslie Groff.2 Although recalls meeting Groff on at least one
occasion at her office to pick up some money, she did not have extensive interactions with Groff
and did not tell Groff her age.
Each time brought a girl to Epstein, was paid $300. and the other
girl would also receive $300, alwa in cash. After brought a girl to Epstein, he
would sometimes either tell to bring the girl again, if he liked her, or tell
not to bring the girl again. noticed that the girls Epstein liked were generally younger
and more petite. Epstein would tell "you know what I like." which she took to mean
underage, petite girls. Epstein would occasionally indicate his displeasure with for
bringing a particular irl, including expressing to that he did not like dark-skinned
girls. Later on, as grew older and knew fewer oung girls to bring, she brought older
girls, which Epstein expressed displeasure about. recalls at least one occasion when
she saw a girl show Epstein an ID to prove she was under 18.
2.
During  interviews conducted between March and July 2019,
described how she was recruited to provide Epstein with sexualized massages at
his Palm Beach residence when she was approximately 14 years old. estimates that she
herself performed more than ten sexualized massages and that she also recruited approximately
20 to 30 additional girls who were similarly abused by Epstein in Florida.
When first encountered Epstein, she was a high school dropout, living away from
home and supporting  herself financial) . She recalls being recruited b a young girl named
at a party who told and her friend that they could make
agreed to go to Epstein's Palm Beach $200 by giving a massage to an older man.
residence, and she ultimately participated in at least ten massages, which became increasingly
sexual over time. She recalled that Epstein would instruct her to pinch his nipples while he
masturbated, and that she was often instructed to take her clothes off and perform the massage
while nude. During the massages, Epstein would touch her genitals with a vibrator or his hand.
She recounted that Epstein would frequently push thin further to see how far he could go. On
at least one occasion, Epstein brought another woman, into a sexualized
massage with During this encounter, who was an adult at the time, engaged
in sex acts with at Epstein's direction.
2 A message slip recovered from a trash pull from E tein's Palm Beach residence during the
first Florida investigation included a message from' The phone number associated
with that message appears on toll records for one o friends from the same period.
I
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Epstein asked to bring other girls for massages, which she did. Initially, Epstein
simply asked her to "bring a friend" and told her he would pay her to bring other girls. Later,
after a few experiences of  bringing victims who balked at the sexual nature of the
massages, Epstein told her not to bring girls unless they knew what to expect. understood
this to mean she should warn girls to expect they would need to take off their clothes, and that
Epstein would touch them and masturbate. She then conveyed as much in recruiting new
victims.
estimates that over the course of several years, she recruited approximately 20 to 30
girls for Epstein, all of whom were approximately 15 to 20 years old.4 believes that most
of the girls she recruited were minors. Epstein would occasionally indicate to which girls
he liked and which girls he disliked, and she noticed he preferred the younger minors she
brought, and that he referred petite blonde girls. usually coordinated these appointments
with or specifically recalls that would occasionally
call and say that she was in New York, that Epstein would be arriving in Florida soon, and
that she wanted to know it  could "work" when he arrived.. also recalled -
personally taking her to the massage room on some occasions, where she would set up the
massage table. also recalls paying her after some of these encounters.
When'. first met Epstein, she told him she was 18 because her friend had told her to
lie about her age. In truth, she was approximately 14 or 15 at the time, and was wearing braces,
and recalls that it would have been obvious that she was very young. Initially, similarly
told other girls she brought to Epstein to say they were older because her friend had given her
that instruction. Over time, however, based on her observations of the girls that Epstein seemed
to prefer—and the sheer number of minors she brought to the house without issue—M came
to believe that Epstein wanted younger girls and did not care if the girls told him their true ages.
For this reason, stopped telling the girls she recruited to lie about their ages. She stated that
the girls she recruited looked very young, and she believes it would have been obvious to anyone
that they were underage.
When the Florida investigations became public, after had stopped visiting Epstein,
she recalls having a phone conversation with in which stated, in sum and
substance, that would be taken care of if she didn't say anything.
4 Message pads recovered from Epstein's Palm Beach residence during the first Florida
I.investigation include messages with full name and phone number. The messages appear
to refer to scheduling appointments an recruiting other girls, e.g.: "She has a female friend for
you, please call back as soon as possible." Additionally, the message pads include messages
with names of individuals- identified as other victims.
5 Contemporaneous phone records reflect numerous calls between- and
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
On August 27, 2019, we met with in New York.
3.
During During prior interviews conducted between April and July 2019 • described how between approximately-, she went to
Epstein's
Florida residence approximately 20 times to participate in sexualized massages. receiving
ayments of $200 for each visit. recalled that she told Epstein her true age, which was 17.
Specifically,
explained that she would typically deposit cash from Epstein in her bank account right away.
provided a notebook in which she noted sits she made: based on her dates of deposits.
it appears the abuse began in approximately , weeks past her sixteenth birthday. The
records also appear to show that cash payments from Epstein continued through -
several months before her eighteenth birthday.
Similar to other victims.. was recruited by a high school friend, who told her she
could make money by giving a massage. She recalls Epstein telling her that they could travel
together after she turned 18, and that once she turned 18 he would be able to help her with a
modeling career. She ultimately stopped going to Epstein's residence because she felt disgusted
by her interactions with him.
. generally scheduled the massages through . recalled that would
sometimes call from New York to schedule massages in advance of Epstein's arrival in Florida.
and ifically rec mentioning on calls that was in New York at the
time. also recalled pe rsonally taking her to the massage room on some occasions.
. specifically recalled telling that she was in high school and could not provide
massages at certain times due to school conflicts. She also reported that Epstein asked her to
bring girls who looked like her, which she took to mean blonde girls her age.. brought two
seventeen-year-old girls to Epstein's house for massages, for which. was also paid..
has reported that the massages became increasingly sexual over time, and included Epstein
6 Contemporaneous phone records reflect numerous contacts between and A
comparison of call records against logs of Epstein's flights on his private Jet reflects several sets
of calls during times when
example, on
afternoon: later t t
West Palm Beach.
appears to have been in New York City with Epstein. For
and
recc.reflect at
had three calls spread throughout the
and Epstein flew from -
to
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
touching her genitals and using a vibrator on her genital area, including under her underwear.
also recalled that Epstein asked her for intercourse, but she refused.
On Au t 27, 2019, we met with in New York.
4.
We have interviewed on three occasions. First, on S tember 19, 2019,
was interviewed in During this interview, described how she
met Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell and described in general terms how her relationship with
them evolved. She did not want to discuss specific incidents of abuse in detail during this
interview.
In When was about 13 years old
Maxwell and Epstehaoached her while she was sitting
outside at apicnic table with her friends.' ifiin told
asked about back ound. When told Epstein that she live
that he gives scholarships and
Epstein asked for her phone number so that they could connect. About six weeks later,
after had returned home and had turned 14, someone called from
Epstein's office askin to have tea with Epstein. They accepted the
invitation, and both had tea with Epstein at his Palm Beach residence,
during which he explained that he likes to mentor and give scholarships.°
After that meetin be an spending more time with Epstein and Maxwell.
, Maxwell or an assistant would regularly call
house phone to invite to visit with Epstein. recalls Epstein having a number of
different assistants, including Leslie Groff and When she was still 14 years old,
travelled to New York to visit with Epstein and Maxwell. During that trip, Epstein and
Maxwell took shopping and picked out clothing for her, including white underwear.
does not recall any sexual contact occurring until after that trip to New York. After that
tri frequently went to Epstein's Palm Beach residence. While there. Epstein would
Between approximatel
I
I
9 worked as Maxwell's assistant in
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
have rub his feet, and he often gave her cash, which he claimed was for her to use for
voice lessons.
Epstein first sexually abused when she was 14 years old at his Palm Beach
residence. The two were discussing desire to be , and Epstein told
that she needed to be comfortable in her underwear. Epstein then pulled his pants down,
pulledi into his lap and began masturbating. Epstein told a photographer might do
this to her, so she needed to be prepared. After that first incident, Epstein increasingly sexually
abused After a few months of abusing on his own, Epstein began abusing
with Maxwell present. Eventually, Epstein also had other young girls or women
participate in sex acts with-could not recall the names of all of these other
females, but she vaguely remembers meeting once. She also recalled Epstein's
assistant, being involved in sexual contact. Many of these instances occurred in
the context of massages, during which would be present when other girls would provide
sexualized massages to Epstein.
For the next approximately two years, Epstein continued sexually abusing by,
among other things, fondling her genitals and using vibrators to touch her genitals. During that
period, Epstein also photographed while wearing only underwear.' recalled
travelling to New York and New Mexico with both Epstein and Maxwell during this period. She
indicated that both Epstein and Maxwell participated in sexual encounters with her during this
period, but she was not at that point prepared to go into more details regarding the specifics of
the contact. recalled that either Groff or Maxwell would arrange her travel.
When was a senior in high school, Epstein paid for her to move to
continued abusing there, and eventually raped her in his New York residence.
recalled meeting famous friends of Epstein's, including Prince Andrew, but she never had any
sexual encounters with any of Epstein's friends. remained in contact with Epstein until
, when she was 21 years old.
e
Second, on November 14, 2019, was re-interviewed in During this
interview, clarified her memory of the timing of her interactions with Epstein and
Maxwell. She recalled when she was 13
years old, shortly before she turned 14 . She recalled first travelling on
Epstein's private jet when she was 14 years old, when she travelled to New York. Epstein first
engaged in sexual contact with when she was 14 years old. began her senior year
in New York in., so she moved to New York in when she was about 17
years old, then began attending school in New York in the fall after turning 18 years old. Given
that timing, she believes she may have been 18 when Epstein raped her in New York.
10 Multiple photographs of  were recovered from Epstein's Palm Beach residence during
the first Florida investigation.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e)
recalled travelling to New Mexico with Epstein approximately three times.
Maxwell was present for each of those trips. She went more frequently to New York, but
Maxwell was not around as often during the New York trips because Epstein and Maxwell did
not live in the same residence in New York. could not recall whether Maxwell would
call her to make appointments to see Epstein while in New York. She generally recalled
assistants calling to invite her to see Epstein. recalled that Maxwell was much more
present when she first met Epstein and that Maxwell made travel arrangements for during
her earlier trips with Epstein. also recalled at least one incident of sexual abuse in New
York when she was a minor during which Maxwell was present, but she explained that Maxwell
was present for more instances of abuse in Florida. did not wish to discuss the details of
incidents of abuse during this meeting.
Third, on December 17, 2019, was interviewed for a third time in
She
recalled that when she was still living in (before she moved to when she
was 17 years old), she would speak with Maxwell on the phone about plans to travel with
Epstein. She also recalled flying on Epstein's private et with Maxwell. When asked to describe
specific instances of abuse before she moved to described sexual assaults
ranging from Epstein masturbating in her presence to Epstein touching her genitals with a
vibrator to Epstein engaging in oral sex with her to  raping her. When asked which
specific acts Maxwell was physically present for, indicated that she was not entirely sure.
She could only specifically recall instances in which Maxwell was in the room while Epstein
masturbated and directed to touch hisinis. She could not recall specifically whether
Maxwell was resent when Epstein touched genitals or engaged in other sexual contact
with her. did not recall Maxwell ever touching her during an instance of sexual abuse
with Epstein.
5.
We have interviewed on three occasions.
First. on August 27, 2019, met  with us in New York. During that interview.
described meeting Ghislaine Maxwell lived at the
time, when
and how much he was oin to like
was about 17 ears old. Maxwell talked about her bo end. Jeffrey,
One day when Epstein was
Maxwell invited to come to Maxwell's residence, where she was introduced to
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e)
Epstein. During that fust meeting, Maxwell told that Epstein needed a massage
every day and asked to give Epstein a massage. Maxwell then brought-
up to a bedroom where Epstein was in a robe. While Maxwell waited outside the room, Epstein
removed the robe and got onto the bed.
massage. Epstein rolled over, touched
then massaged Epstein. During the
and put her hand on his penis.
After that first sexual assault. Maxwell repeatedl called who was still 17,
and invited her to see Epstein at Maxwell's residence During these visits, Epstein
engaged in sexual contact with At the time, was not in school but still
lived with .11 is confident Maxwell knew her age because Maxwell got
her an expensive gift for her 18 birthday.
Eventually, Maxwell and Epstein invited to travel with them to Palm Beach,
Paris, the Virgin Islands, and New York. Every time travelled with Epstein, he
engaged in sexual contact with her. This included sexualized massages during which Epstein
used a vibrator to touch her genitals. recalled times that she resisted Epstein's
advances, and Maxwell encouraged her to do what Epstein wanted, sayin_•thi ike "don't be
silly" to minimize the conduct. On one occasion, Maxwell encouraged to wear a
schoolgirl uniform for Epstein. When resisted. Maxwell responded. "don't be so
frigid." On one occasion, Maxwell asked if she knew someone who could give
Epstein "a blow job" because Maxwell did not feel like doing so that day.
Maxwell also made comments about Epstein's sexual preferences, notin that he
preferred younger looking females and wanted to constantly have sex. understood
that Maxwell was Epstein's girlfriend, but she came to understand that Maxwell allowed Epstein
to engage in sexual contact with other ple, as long as it did not include intercourse.
Nevertheless, Epstein raped on multiple occasions, and he told not to
tell Maxwell about the rapes because it violated their understanding. Maxwell also asked
to bring other girls to engage in sex with Epstein and repeatedly asked to
engage in sex acts with Epstein. Maxwell continued to ask to enga e in sexualized
massages with Epstein into her 20s. Over the years, Leslie Groff would contact to
invite her to meet Epstein and would make her travel arrangements.
Second. on September 19, 2019. met with us in New York. During this
interview, she a ' described meeting Maxwell when she was 17 years old. Maxwell then
introduced  to Epstein, and during that first meeting, Maxwell encouraged.
■ to give Epstein a full body massage. Maxwell then waited outside the room while.
gave Epstein a massage, during which Epstein put her hand on his penis. After the
massage was over. Maxwell asked how it went,  whether had nu'. and whether
Epstein liked it. Maxwell then paid for the massage.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
When turned 18, Maxwell gave her a gift with a card signed by both
Epstein and Maxwell. also recalled Maxwell telling someone else at a later date that
Maxwell met when she was 17 years old. was not certain whether she
began travelling with Epstein and Maxwell before or after her 18 birthday. After she was 18 or
19 years old, recalls Maxwell saying she was getting too old to have a child with
Epstein. Maxwell also told that Epstein needed sex three to four times per day.
Third, on December 15, 2019, we met with
still could not recall whether she first traveled with Epstein and Maxwell
when she was 17 or when she was 18. She was certain, however, that she was 17 years old
during at least the first two instances when Epstein sexually assaulted her . Both
instances occurred at Maxwell's residence had previously described the
first instance, which involved Maxwell encouraging her to provide Epstein a massage and
waiting outside the bedroom while massaged Epstein, and Epstein first sexually
abused -
Sometime after leaving Maxwell's residence following that first incident of abuse,.
received a call from Maxwell. On the call, Maxwell said was a "clever
girl" and that "Jeffrey was very impressed," so Maxwell wanted to schedule a return visit.
agreed and sometime later, she returned to Maxwell's London residence. When
arrived, Maxwell told her, in substance, that Maxwell was relieved was
there because otherwise "it falls to me," which understood to mean that Maxwell had
to provide Epstein with sexualized massages if no one else was available. After this
conversation, Maxwell walked to a bedroom and opened the door. Inside the room,
Epstein was fully nude and standing facing Maxwell and Maxwell said "I'll leave
you to it," and left. did not wish to discuss the details of the sexual abuse that
occurred during this second massage at this time. After the massage, Maxwell asked if. had a nice time, and then changed
the subject to chat about upcoming
plans.
6.
On September 28, 2019, was interviewed in New York. explained
at the outset of the interview that her recollection had been refreshed by reviewing the journal
she kept while in high school which we are in the process of obtaining. met Epstein in.
and worked in some capacity
for Epstein. Between , when was 16 years old and a junior in high school
, she took two trips to meet with Epstein.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e)
First. told that Epstein was interested in meeting her
and hel • in her with college. Epstein then paid for to fly out
to New York . While in New York, stayed
saw Epstein twice during this New York trip.
During the first meeting, Epstein bought tickets to see the Phantom of the Opera and
met with them before the show at his New York residence. During that meeting. Epstein asked
about her life and offered to help her with her education. During the second meet'
Epstein took
,
to see the movie 12 Monkeys. Epstein sat between
during the movie and touched inappropriately throughout the movie. In particular,
Epstein touched leg, stroked her arm, and held her hand.
Second,
with Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell.
phone about this trip.
which made them feel more comfortable about
to fly to New Mexico and arranged for a driver to take her to Epstein's New Mexico ranch.
background and lifil especifically remembers telling Maxwell that she was a junior in high
Once at the ranch, nt time with Maxwell, who expressed interest in
school because they discussed her homework, her plans for the upcoming senior year, and her
desire to attend college.
flew alone to New Mexico, where she spent a weekend
recalls that spoke with Epstein on the
all knew that Maxwell would be on the trip,
traveling alone.' Epstein paid for
During this trip to New Mexico, recalls several instances of conduct that made her
feel uncomfortable. First, Maxwell encouraged to masse ipstein's feet with her and
showed how he liked to have his feet rubbed. Second,
i
went to the movies with
Epstein and Maxwell to see Primal Fear, and outside the theater, Maxwell aiu down Epstein's
sweatpants a bit in a joking manner. During the movie. Epstein again held hand and
stroked her arm, but he did not  to be trying to hide this contact from Maxwell. Third,
Maxwell insisted on giving a massage during which was either partially or fully
nude. The massage took place in a room with an open door leading to the next room where
Epstein was located, such that E stein may have been able to observe- "  During the
massage. Maxwell rubbed chest, touching the sides of her breasts. Finally, one morning.
Epstein came into room, got into bed with her, and said he wanted to cuddle. said
she needed to go to the bathroom, and left the room. does not recall having any other
contact with Epstein or Maxwell after the New Mexico trip.
EFI'A_00022472
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
7.
was interviewed on July 31, 2019, August 27, 2019 and
November 21, 2019. all in New York.
Epstein sexuall assaulted her in New Mexico, Florida, and Paris."
said that when she was 17 ears old,
first
First, during the July 31. 2019 interview,
met Epstein through who worked as a masseuse
for Epstein and introduced Epstein as someone who could help
was on the verge of homelessness and had nowhere
else to go. first introduced to Epstein at a hotel-. During that first
meeting, Epstein expressed interest in background and offered to pay for her to travel
and attend school.
After that first meetin , Epstein invited to his  home in New Mexico. During that
first trip. Epstein asked to 'ye him a massage. was present in the massage
room, and both and were in swimsuits. At first, Epstein asked to remove
her top and began fondling froze as Epstein turned to her and began to fondle her
genitals. During this first interview, was too distressed to describe any other details
regarding this assault. She explained, however, that after that first incident, when she was still
17, she travelled with Epstein to other residences where he sexually assaulted her. In particular,
recalled during this interview that Epstein assaulted her in New Mexico, Florida, and
Paris on four occasions when she was 17 years old. Two of the assaults involved Epstein
sneaking into her room at night and raping her. asked not to discuss the details of those
assaults during this first interview.
E stein aid for to travel to for school. In
turned 18 . After turning 18, continued to spend time
with E stein for approximately two more years. During that two-year period, Epstein paid for
to attend school  for three months-long periods." When she was
not in school, either travelled with Epstein or resided at an apartment he provided for her
in New York. During that same period, Epstein continued to engage in sexual
Eventually the stress of continued abuse led to develop an eating
10 As indicated below, during a subsequent interview, clarified that she was in fact
assaulted in New Mexico, New York, Florida, and the Virgin Islands when she was 17 years old.
Although Epstein engaged in sexual contact with her in other locations, including Paris, she was
18 years old when those incidents took place.
15 We have identified message pads recovered during the first Florida investigation referencing
instances in which = called for Epstein during this period.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
disorder. When confided in Epstein about her eating disorder
for her to fly to Arizona and then essentially disowned her, cutting off contact.
he paid
While travelling with Epstein, became familiar with the people in his world,
including  Leslie Groff Ghislaine Maxwell. and Jean Luc Brunel.
provided us with copies of photoirahe  still had from her time with Epstein,
including photographs featuring Epstein. Maxwell. and Brunel.
recalled that was
Epstein's assistant. In that capacity, arranged the scheduling for Epstein's flights on his
roximately five years older than and acted as
private jet and coordinated with his pilots and house staff to arrange for E stein's travel. As
described above, was present when Epstein sexually assaulted in a massage room
at Epstein's New Mexico residence. could not recall, however, whether she ever
expressly discussed her age with During this first interview, was too distressed to
discuss instances of sexual assault in detail, but she indicated that was present for and
participated in two assaults before turned 18, and believed that during these assaults.
touched 16 also recalled that took photographs of= while at
Epstein's Virgin Islands residence. Although could not be completely sure, she believed
that those photographs were taken when she was 17 years old. did not recall whether she
was clothed in the photos or if anyone else was in the photos.17
As travelled with Epstein . she noticed a lot of ' is
coining and going to and from Epstein's residences in New York and Palm Beach.
recalled that these girls would stay for about an hour or so. They appear.oung, but but
did not know whether any were under the age of 18. recalled saying generally
that the girls were there to see Epstein.
recalled that became E stein's girlfriend
after returning from her first trip
knows that was 18 years old when they met. For about two years,
was roommate when the travelled with Epstein, and they shared an
apartment in New York. As a result, the two became
friends. referred to herself as Epstein's girlfriend, but in general, she and did
not discuss the details of their sexual activity with Epstein.
16 As descried below, during a subsequent interview, clarified that she onl recalled one
instance of sexual abuse when she was a minor for w lc was present. also
clarified that she does not have a memory of= touching er during any instances of abuse.
17 When execut search warrant at Epstein's New York residence, the FBI recovered multiple
photographs o in which she is nude or partially nude and appears to be in a tropical
location.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
understood Ghislaine Maxwell to be Epstein's "partner," who also handled
scheduling along with Her impression was that Maxwell's relationship with Epstein was
more focused on business than personal matters.
explained that Leslie Groff arranged payments for schooling and also
coordinated her commercial flights. did not see Groff as often as she saw
and Maxwell because Groff did not travel with Epstein.
Second, during the August 27, 2019 interview, provided additional details
regarding her interactions with other people in Epstein's circle during her time travelling with
Epstein. First, explained that she understood to be Epstein's assistant.
responsibilities included shopping, travel arrangements, and coordinating with Epstein's
pilots. During the time was travelling with Epstein went
wherever Epstein did. During this same period, when Epstein was in New York,
,
resided
in the same building as did, though in a different apartment. When in New
York, would sometimes call and instruct her to come to Epstein's New York
residence.
again indicated that was present for the first time Epstein assaulted her and
was somehow involved in the second time Epstein assaulted her, but she was not emotionally
prepared to describe the details of the assaults during this interview. does not recall
speaking explicitly with about her age, but she does recall that was present with
Epstein and others for 19ih and 20th birthdays. When asked who else attended those
birthdays, recalled that Epstein and were present as well.
When asked who else she recalled being associated with Epstein
mentioned that a female named whose last name could not recall, was
present during an instance when Epstein sexually assaulted in Virgin Islands.
recalled that was older than Again, though, was not emotionally
prepared to describe the details of that assault. recalled that Leslie Groff booked
travel for school. also recalled that Ghislaine Maxwell often travelled
with Epstein and would sleep in Epstein's room when they travelled. More generally,
explained that she did not discuss Epstein's sexual abuse with anyone, including
Maxwell, Groff, and because she felt that it was taboo and not something she
should mention.
recalled two instances when Epstein asked her to provide massages to other men,
both of which took place after turned 18. First, massaged Jean Luc Brunel, but
the massage did not involve any sexual contact. Second, when was at Epstein's Paris
residence, Epstein instructed her to massage Harvey Weinstein there. When went into
the massage room, Weinstein directed to remove her shirt. refused, and in
response, Weinstein became angry and told to tell or Weinstein's assistant Bonnie
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
to come instead. left and told Epstein what happened. Epstein apologized to for
putting her in that position.
Third, during the November 21, 2019 interview, provided additional details
regarding certain instances of abuse and clarified her memories of her interactions with Epstein
before turning 18. recalled that when she was about 17 years old
introduced her to a man named Joseph Alvarez, a/k/a "Gypsy," , who
taught both sisters how to give massages. Alvarez then introduced to Epstein, and she
began travelling with him. Later introduced to Epstein. That first
meeting took place at a hotel , where met both Maxwell and Epstein. During
the meeting, massaged Epstein's feet while he asked about her life and
background. told him she wanted to go back to school, and Epstein offered to pay for her
to attend school . Following that meeting, Epstein called on multiple occasions,
sometimes with Leslie Groff connecting the calls. Eventually, Epstein committed to paying for
to attend school . In response, gave up the room in the apartment where
she was living, gave notice to her job, and prepared to travelME.
A few weeks before left
she accepted the invitation. then travelled to Epstein's New Mexico residence in
when she was still 17 years old. She recalls Epstein, Maxwell, and other females whose
names she does not remember being at the residence when she arrived. remained at the
New Mexico residence for a couple of days before returning . Early on in the visit,
Maxwell took horseback riding, and told Maxwell about her life and background.
Although does not specifically recall saying her age, she believes Maxwell would have
had strong indications of her age based on that conversation. Later during that same trip,
went swimming in the pool with As they got out of the pool in their swimsuits, Epstein
called them over to give him a massage in a nearby massage room. Once inside the massage
room, Epstein removed top, began masturbating, and touched breasts and
genitals. Epstein then touched genitals. froze and began crying, but Epstein
continued to touch her genitals and masturbate until he ejaculated. recalled that-
seemed at ease, as though this was a normal occurrence. never spoke about the incident
with
Epstein invited to New Mexico, and
After returned , Epstein called her multiple times, both to discuss her
plans to attend school and to invite her on another trip. agreed to go on another trip with
Epstein , when she was still 17. In or arounc , she flew
o New York, where she visited Epstein at his New York residence. Once there,
Epstein brought alone into the dining room where he reached down her pants and fondled
her. From New York, flew with Epstein, Maxwell, and another female to Palm
Beach, where the group stayed at Epstein's Palm Beach residence for a few days. One of the
nights in Palm Beach, Epstein came into the room where was sleeping and raped her.
The same group then flew from Palm Beach to the Virgin Islands, where they stayed on at
Epstein's Virgin Islands residence. One of the nights on the island, Epstein again came into the
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
room where was sleeping and raped her. The same group then flew back to Palm
Beach.' From there. believes she flew back to
After that trip. Epstein paid for to travel to Spain in approximately
and attend school there. While in Spain, turned 18 in . At the end of the
semester in the spring ofM, Epstein paid for her to fly back to the Virgin Islands and rejoin
him at his Virgin Islands residence." Over the next approximately two years. Epstein
periodically paid for to travel to attend school for months at a time. When-
was not attending school, she travelled with Epstein to his various residences. During the
periods she was with Epstein, her understanding was that either or Maxwell scheduled
Epstein's massages. She recalled thinking that the masseuses she saw were about her age (18 or
19 years old).
8.
On Se tember 10. 2019. we met with
when
On November 4, 2019, we interviewed in Mlin or around ,
was approximately 16 years old, a friend of hers named asked if
1° We have identified flight records for E stein'sprivate 'et corroborating account of this
trip. In particular, flight records
19 The metadata for some of the nude photogra hs o recovered from Epstein's New York
residence suggest that the photos were created , w ch would be consistent with
1 I
second trip to the Virgin Islands.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
she wanted to make money by giving a massage to a billionaire. said yes, and
connected her with a your man named 21 who gave a ride to Epstein's
Palm Beach residence. told to lie and say she was 18 years old. Once at the
residence, met then brought to the massage room while
waited downstairs. then gave Epstein a massage, during which Epstein
masturbated and o ed genitals and buttocks. At the end of the massage, Epstein
offered to a if she brought other girls to engage in similar acts. During that initial
meeting, lied and said she was 18 years old and in college. then went
her phone number. downstairs and gave
After that first encounter, be an bringing other girls to massage E stein. To
coordinate the massage appointments, spoke on the phone with
continued bringing girls to Epstein's Palm Beach residence for approximately two more years
until she was 18 years old and the police began investigating Epstein. In total, estimates
she went to Epstein's Palm Beach residence once or twice a month. She recalled that Epstein
often went weeks without coming to Florida. When brought a new girl. Epstein always
paid 5200 himself. Sometimes would bring girls up to the massage room, and
down, then would go up to talk with Epstein and get paid by him. d not recall
would wait downstairs for about an hour until the  came back
di
sometimes did.
any of the is she brought being upset after a massage, as she always warned them what to
expect. only recalls dealing with and never met or spoke with Maxwell, or
Groff.
In total, brought about six different girls to give sexualized massages to E stein.
All except one were minors. At one time, brought someone in her 20s, and told
not to bring her again, though he did not say why. All the other girls brought
were oun er looking, thinner girls. told everyone she brought to say they were 18 years
old. did not recall having any personal conversations with and does not know
whether knew how old she or any of the girls she recruited were. recalled that
occasionally asked to bring a specific girl. recalls referring to the girls
she recruited as her "friends" to Eventually, some of the girls brought began
recruiting other girls themselves. recalled walking into the massage room with a recruit
at some point and seeing and Epstein leaving the shower/steam room together, which led
her to believe they had a sexual relationship. The police approached in 2006, after
which she never spoke with Epstein or again.
9.
was interviewed on July 14, 2019 in
When she was
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
approximately 13 or 14, a friend of hers named recruited to
give massages to Epstein at his Palm Beach residence. Over a period of approximately two
years, frequently went to his residence and engaged in massage sessions with Epstein,
during which he touched her breasts and genitals, used a vibrator on her genital area, and
masturbated in front of her. also became a prolific recruiter and estimates that she may
have brought as many as one hundred underage girls to Epstein's Palm Beach residence for
massages massa became pregnant at the age of 15, after which Epstein no longer wanted to
see her, but he allowed to continue recruiting other girls for massages. received
$200 for each massage she performed and for each massage performed by a girl she brought to
Epstein's Palm Beach residence.
recalled that the first time a new girl gave Epstein a massage, Epstein would often
ask to stay in the massage room with the new girl. remembered that
would sometimes bring girls up to the massage room, but would then leave before the
massage began. would sometimes pay following massages. also provided
with gifts from Epstein, including a bikini, and baby shower gifts when became
pregnant.
recalled that she primarily scheduled massages through over the phone.
When scheduling an appointment for a new girl, would call, say she had "someone" for
Epstein and would describe what the girl looked like. Occasionally would pick up
and drive her to Epstein's Palm Beach residence. recalled saying things like, "you
know what Jeffrey likes." also believed that knew was in high school, but
she could not recall a specific conversation in which told her age or that she was in
high school.
recalled lying and telling Epstein that she was 16 years old when they met. She
also told Epstein that the girls she recruited were all 16 or older. recalled one incident,
however, when Epstein was angry with her for bringing an older girl who was about 18. As a
result, understood that Epstein wanted younger girls. recalled bringing girls to
Epstein's residence approximately twice per week, most of whom were between the ages of 14
and 16.
ultimately stopped recruiting girls to massage Epstein after she was approached by
the FB During the initial Florida investigation, spoke with Epstein's attorneys.
Although could not recall the names of any of these attorneys, she recalled that they
pressured her to lie and tell investigators that she had told Epstein she was 18 years old.
recalled Epstein's lawyers suggesting that if she told the truth, her child would be taken away
22 We have identified message pads recovered during the first Florida investigation referencing
'M At least one of these messages indicates that is bringing another female to
Epstein's residence.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e)
from her because she engaged in recruiting activities.
10. • . was interviewed on September 12, 2019 in New York. regularly
visited Epstein's Palm Beach residence from approximate' , when she
between 16 and 18 ears old. When■ was about 16 years old and a sophomore in hi school
, she was recruited by a friend named 23
explained that could make money by giving nude massages to an older man.
and went with to Epstein's Palm Beach residence, where she believes she met
While waited in the kitchen.. went up to the massage room, where she
engaged in a paid sexualized massage with Epstein. Over the ensuing months,. returned to
Epstein's Palm Beach residence many times to engage in paid sexualized massages. The sexual
abuse escalated to include oral sex and rape. . stopped going to Epstein's residence
when she was in college and the police approached her.
■ described Epstein giving her cash and gifts, includin a rental car. She also recalled
that Epstein helped with her college essays. Epstein also sent flowers in connection with
her performance in a high school p
lay—.24 ■ indicated that Epstein took multiple nude
photographs of her in his Palm Beach residence.
. generally described as being frequently present at the Palm Beach house.
would frequently call to tell her when Epstein would be in town and to schedule
massages. Durin at least some of these conversations, told■ that she was callin
from New York. also recalled being paid primarily by Epstein. but sometimes b
or someone named Alfredo.' . indicated that she believes knew
she was unc.a e: however, did not recall any specific conversations or discussions of her
age with Nor could remember any discussions she had with
I
of details of her
life that would have been suggestive of age, such as high school classes or extracurricular
activities. . explained, though, that she openly talked with Epstein about taking the SATs and
applying for college and would work on her college application essays at Epstein's home. She
23 was interviewed during the Florida investigation and reported engaging in multiple
ai sexualized massages with Epstein at his Palm Beach residence when she was a minor.
also admitted to bringing two other minor girls, including. to provide Epstein with
sex 'zed massages.
24 We have identified messages recovered from Epstein's Palm Beach residence during the first
Florida investigation referencing'- which appear to corroborates contact with
Epstein.
zs The FBI has identified this individual as a housekeeper who is now deceased.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e)
also recalled that organized drivers to pick■ up from
lived.
where she
. also recalled instances in which walked to the massage room and set up
the table while there were sex toys visible in the room. also recalled one instance in which
came into the massage room when■ was still naked after a sexualized massage.
However, did not recall any specific conversations she had with about sex.
remember asking her to bring other girls that looked like over to Epstein's home.
■ recalled seeing Maxwell at the house only a few times, and did not have any
substantive conversations or interactions with her.
referred to as Epstein's "sex slave" and believed that Epstein had
"bought" told that was one of Epstein's girlfriends. When
■ was 16 years old, engaged in sex acts with. at Epstein's direction.
After the police began investigating Epstein in 2005,■ received a call from a • I
named who also went to Epstein's Palm Beach residence for massages. asked
if■ if she had spoken with law enforcement and added that■ would be "taken care of if
she did not talk.
11.
On September 18, 2019 ■ was interviewed in
was either 16 or 17 years old, a friend of hers named
could make $200 by giving a massage in her underwear to an older man.
to Epstein's Palm Beach residence with on one occasion. When
arrived at Epstein's Palm Beach residence, a woman named greeted
had them wait downstairs. At some point said Epstein was ready. and both girls went up
to the massage room. Both girls got undressed, Epstein came into the room, both girls started
massaging him, and then Epstein told to leave. E stein then masturbated and touched
enitals with a vibrator. At the end of the massage, went back downstairs to where
was waiting. E stein came down and paid both and Sometime later,
told. that reached out to ask whether would come back. refused
and never saw Epstein again.
When■
told■ she
agreed and went
and
and and
26 We have identified this individual as
summarized below.
' 7 The FBI is still trying to identify this individual.
who participated in an interview, which is
EF1A_00022481
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
12.
On October 15, 2019, was interviewed in
when was approximately 16 years old and living in Palm Beach, her friend
her to give a back massage to a nice older  for $200. agreed and went with
Epstein's Palm Beach residence, where engaged in a sexualized massage with E
For about the next two years. until she was about 18 years old
paid sexualized massages to E stein approximately once per week. At some point, Epstein
began bringing his girlfriend
with at Epstein's direction.
show for her 18th birthday.
friend only went to Epstein's Palm Beach residence once.
invited
to
stein.
provided
into the room during these massages to engage in sex acts
recalled that Epstein sent her to a David Copperfield
also brought one of her friends to massage Epstein, but the
Epstein's assistant would often call to schedule massage appointments.
Althou discussed her a e with Epstein, she does not recall explicitly discussing her age
with Occasionally, walked to
after each massage. Around the time
to the massage room, but she was never involved
abi nr sexual contact. Either Epstein or
turned 18, she stopped receiving calls inviting her to massage Epstein.
was contacted by the FBI and interviewed. did not recall
or anyone else connected to Epstein contacting her during that investigation.
13.
On October 16, 2019, was interviewed in When
was about 15 or 16 years old and living in Florida, a girl from her hi i school named
r
asked if she wanted to give a man a massage for $200. a eed and went with
to Epstein's Palm Beach residence. Once there, Epstein met in the kitchen and
brought her to the macsage room while waited downstairs. While in the massage room,
Epstein asked to remove her clothes. then massaged Epstein while
undressed. Epstein then paid and she left.
When returned for a second massage, Epstein used a vibrator to touch her
genitals, after which he paid her $200. Over the next few months, returned to
Epstein's Palm Beach residence about ten more times toprovide Epstein with paid sexualized
massages. After that first massage, called to schedule each of her
subsequent massages. also brought a friend of hers to massage Epstein once and was
paid $200 for bringing her. never told Epstein or her age, but she did recall
telling Epstein that she was in high school and a cheerleader.
211 We believe this individual to be
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)

14. =
On October 16, 2019, was interviewed in When was
about 15 years old , her friends and
asked if she wanted to give a man a massage for money. agreed and later
went with to Epstein's Palm Beach residence. Upon arriving, an Asian woman
directed and to go up to the massage room. When they got to the room, a tall
woman with short brown hair, whom now believes to be Maxwell, walked out of the
shower in a towel, handed lotion, and said "I think you'll be needing this more than me,"
then left. Epstein then entered in a robe and got on the massage table. and
began massaging Epstein, then left, at which point, removed her clothes, and
Epstein touched her genitals. During the massage, told Epstein that she was 16 because
had told her to lie and say she was 16, when she was in fact 15 years old. After the
massage, gave $200 and said that she was also paid $150. They
then left together. never returned and never saw Epstein again.

15. M
was interviewed on July 11, 2019 in Florida. when was
14 years old, some of her friends, including recruited her to give Epstein a
massage at his Palm Beach residence, during which Epstein touched breasts and
genitals. recalled a "lady" with black hair meeting her and in Epstein's kitchen
before the massage, but did not speak with the lady or learn her name. Rather,
spoke exclusively with the lady. did not participate in any other massages with Epstein,
but she subsequently recruited one other minor girl to give Epstein a paid sexualized massage.
16.
was interviewed on July 11, 2019 in , when
was about 16 years old, her friend recruited her to give Epstein
massages at his Palm Beach house. provided Epstein with two massages and was
sexually abused during both. During the first, Epstein touched breasts and
genitals. The second involved more extensive abuse, which did not want to describe
during our interview. recalled that a petite blonde woman named who appeared
to be in her early 20s, took upstairs to the massage room before both massages. After
both massages, paid $200. After the first massage, took phone
number, and, subsequently, called to invite her back. After the second massage,
did not want to return, but called four or five times and pressured her to return.
ultimately did not return.
29 We have identified these individuals as ME and whose interviews are
described above.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e)
17.
was interviewed on July 12, 2019 in
was 17 years old and working as a model her friend
, when
invited her to
Epstein's Palm Beach residence.
Epstein's girlfriend. Epstein gave
was Aiear-old model and told that she was
and cash to go shopping, and they purchased
underwear together at the mall. They returned to Epstein's house, and Epstein asked to try
on the underwear for him. felt as though she could not say no, and complied. That same
weekend, invited to come to Epstein's Palm Beach residence to receive a massage
from a masseuse. She was told Epstein would not be present, and so she agreed. Shortly after
undressed for the massage, the masseuse left the room, and Epstein entered. He insisted
that flip onto her back (thereby exposing her breasts). so that he could show her what he
had learned from a chiropractor about "adjustments." E•nthen rotated her shoulders and
hips, but did not touch her chest. After this experience, refused to return to the house and
never saw or spoke with Epstein again.
18.
was interviewed on July 12, 2019 in
when was about 16 years old, a friend of hers named recruited
ivrie Epstein a sexualized masse e at his Palm Beach residence. Durin the first massage,
was in the room with Approximately one month later, told that
"they" asked for to come back. returned for a second massage, this time by
herself. During both massages, Epstein instructed to remove her clothes and used a
vibrator to touch genitals while he masturbated. recalled telling Epstein that
she was in high school. She recalled another woman inside the house when she arrived, but she
did not recall the woman's name or appearance.
19.
was interviewed on July 13, 2019, in New York. , when
was approximately 14 years old, another young woman befriended outside her school
described the young woman as white and slim with mid-length
brown hair, but could not recall the young woman's name or any other identifying
details 3r After woman invited to and the young woman became friends, the your
Epstein's Manhattan residence. Over approximately the next year,
i
provided Epstein with
30 was interviewed during the Florida investigation and reported engaging in multiple paid
sexualized massages with Epstein at his Palm Beach residence when she was a minor.
also admitted to bringing two other minor girls, including to provide Epstein with
sexualized massages.
31 We have not identified this individual.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
nude massages at the Manhattan residence, during which Epstein touched her breasts and
masturbated. was paid $300 in cash following each massage. • while
was massaging Epstein, he asked her to get on, him, which she did, and he then
raped her despite her protests to stop. After the rape, stopped going to Epstein's residence
and did not see him again.
recalled that either Epstein himself or a secretary would schedule massage
appointments. also recalled that the secretary would be near the entrance to the house
when arrived for massages and sometimes paid after the massages. cannot
recall the secretary's name or appearance. also remembered that a maid would sometimes
bring her to the massage room, but again she did not recall the name or appearance of any
particular maid.
20.
was interviewed on Jul 17, 2019 in , when -
was 16 years old, a friend of hers named recruited to give Epstein a massage
at his New York residence. went to Epstein's New York residence and provided him
with massages on two occasions. During both masse es, Epstein masturbated, touched
and used a vibrator on her genitals. recalled Epstein telling her: "you look
so young." brought a 19-year-old friend to E stein's New York residence to give
Epstein a massage, after which Epstein paid her $200. recalls that she was given the
phone number of a woman to call to schedule massage appointments. That same woman
contacted to tell her not to bring that friend again because she was too old, but
could not recall the woman's name and could not provide a description of the woman.
21.
was interviewed on July 26, 2019 in New York. was recruited by
three of her friends—named and to perform a massage fialtein
at his New York residence , when was about 17 years old. only
met E stein once and was accompanied by on that visit. When and
arrived at Epstein's New York residence, an older woman in her 40s or 50s, who
appeared to be a secretary, answered the door, but does not recall the woman's name or
any other identifying characteristics. The secretary directed and to the
massage room, where they met Epstein. During the massage, Epstein touched enitals
and directed her to touch his genitals. After the massage. the same secretary provided
32 We have identified as Mr who, together with
recruited minor girls ed massages wit stein in New York
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
and with a white envelope containing cash. never saw or spoke with Epstein
again.
22.
was first interviewed on August 1, 2019 in New York.
M , when was 16 and working as a model in New York, she was introduced to
Epstein. On multiple occasions went to Epstein's Manhattan
residence to engage in sexualized massages in exchange for money. During these sessions,
Epstein masturbated and touched genitals with a vibrator. The abuse escalated over
time to include oral sex, and during her last meeting with Epstein, he raped her. Epstein knew
age, because she told him during their first meeting that she was 16.
Shortly after met Epstein, he offered her an apartment in his building
Mind accepted. Upon moving into the building, met a woman named
(whom we believe to be who lived in a different apartment in the same
building. recalled asking when they first met whether she i should be
scared or concerned about Epstein. In response, brushed the concerns off, saying
something like "you're fine." They did not otherwise interact much.
recalled that on one occasion, purchased white lace underwear for
at Epstein's direction. Epstein subsequently took pictures of wearing the
underwear. On another occasions, recalled Epstein telling that was his
"best little cocksucker." Additionally, was
and wired money so that she and could travel to Paris and stay at
Epstein's home there (though Epstein was not in Paris at the time they visited). also
recalled at least one instance when called her to schedule a massage appointment with
Epstein.
After Epstein raped she decided to return home, and Epstein agreed to pay for
her flight home. recalled that someone named Ghislaine, whom believed to be
Epstein's assistant, emailed the plane ticket to her.
On September 18, 2019, was re-interviewed
addition to confirming the information she provided during her prior interview,
provided additional details regarding her interactions with Epstein's employees.
again stated that worked for Epstein as an assistant. At some point,
Epstein said something about having put on his schedule. Both Epstein and
would call and/or text to schedule massages with Epstein at his New York
residence. also sent money via Western Union from Epstein when was
travelling in Europe. In addition, recalled an instance in which Epstein forced her to
perform oral sex on him while he sat on a cushion in a hallway inside his New York residence.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
As pulled away from Epstein's crotch, she saw standing the hallway.
said "oh." then laughed. and walked away. Following that incident. Epstein bra ed to in
front ofM that was his "best little cocksucker." In response, said
something like. "oh, good to know." recalled hearing Epstein make this comment
about her to on more than one occasion. She also recalled that Epstein would refer to her
as "one of my girls" to
On a separate occasion, Epstein directed to purchase new underwear for
He specified that should go to Victoria's Secret and buy white underwear. Sometime
later, gave a pair of white underwear. Epstein later photo phed in
the underwear, but was not present for those hotographs. could not recall
whether ever paid her for massages. did not recall ever talking about her own
life, background, or age with
After moved away from New York and stopped seeing Epstein, an assistant
named reached out to her on E stein's behalf to schedule a return trip to visit

Sn. Following that call, sent
recalled that Ghislaine Maxwell was the name associated with the Expedia account that
a round-trip plane ticket to visit Epstein.
booked the ticket. did not end up using the tickets. never met or
Maxwell in person.
explained that her only interaction with was when first
moved into theient building on East 66th Street. knocked on door to
check on her. asked whether she • was safe here, and reassured her that
she was fine and safe.
23.
was interviewed on August 6, 2019 in New York.
when was about 14 years old and attend hi shhschool
named invited her to give a rich guy a massage.
to Epstein's New York residence. Upon arriving.
massage room, where the massaged Epstein together. During the massage, Epstein masturbated
and touched genitals with a vibrator. Afterwards. Epstein paid both
and
, a friend
agreed and accompanied
went with to the
" We have identified as who, together with recruited
minor ' is for sexuahz massa es wt E stein in New York.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Epstein subsequently invited to return, and over the next month,
engaged in paid sexual massages with Epstein at his New York residence approximately twice
per week. also knew that a girl named was
bringing girls to Epstein. After about a month, began bringing other minor girls to
massage Epstein, and Epstein paid for each girl she brought. She recalled bringing
as many as three or four minor girls to Epstein in a single week. continued bringing
girls to Epstein until she was 17 years old-Sometimes would
participate in the massages, and sometimes she would wait outside the massage room.
also recalled a few occasions when Epstein directed her to engage in sex acts with a
tall blonde girl, whose name she did not recall, but who we believe to be
did not recall whether she explicitly discussed her age or the ages of the girls she
brought with Epstein. She stopped seeing Epstein after learning from the news that he was in
trouble with law enforcement.
Other than Epstein, recalled speaking with Leslie Groff on the phone when
scheduling massages. Primarily, though, recalled that Groff would answer the
phone and then transfer her call to Epstein.
24.
On September 18, 2019,
about 15 years old
New York, where
Epstein's New York residence, and went there to visit her. While there, an assistant,
whose name does not recall, showed her around the mansion and took a clothed
photograph of At some point, mentioned to the assistant that she was on a high
school field trip. The assistant took down contact information, and then-
left to go shopping.
was interviewed in . When was
she was living and went on a field trip to
was living at the time. was staying at
A few weeks after returned to from the field trip, Epstein's assistant
called her to say that Epstein wanted to meet her and invited to see a
David Copperfield show in Las Vegas. accepted the invitation, and her mother
coordinated with Epstein's assistant to arrange the logistics. met up with
Epstein, and a few other females whose names she does not recall in Las Vegas, where they all
saw the show. From there, the group went to Epstein's private jet and flew to New Mexico.
During the flight, Epstein asked her age, and she truthfully said she was 15 years old.
and then stayed on Epstein's New Mexico ranch for a few days. One
day, a redheaded female on the trip asked to give a massage.' believes she saw
a camera in the corner of the massage room. The redhead directed to take off her clothes
and then massaged her genital area. The next day, a middle-aged woman whose name
35 We have not been able to identify this individual.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
does not recall (but who is not Ghislaine Maxwell), told that Epstein wanted to see her.
Epstein then took up to his bedroom, where he asked her to give him a massage. Epstein
then used a vibrator to touch genitals. The next day, Epstein gave anal
cash to go shopping. Later in the trip, Epstein bought white underwear from
Victoria's Secret and photographed her wearing them.
At some point during this trip, Ghislaine Maxwell arrived on the property, but
did not interact with her. At the end of the trip, Epstein asked what she wanted for her
future. said she wanted to go to college, and Epstein wrote her a $5,000 check, which
did eventually use to help pay for college. After returned home, someone
reached out and invited her to Epstein's island, but declined and never saw Epstein
again.

B. Interviews of Victims Who Were Abused As Adults
was interviewed on August 27, 2019 in New York. reported
being sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. is . When
was over the age of 18, she met Ghislaine Maxwell in California through a man named
Gypsy, who was teaching to be a professional masseuse. Maxwell eventuall recruited
to fly to Palm Beach to provide massages both Maxwell and Epstein. When
first arrived at Epstein's Palm Beach residence, Maxwell told her she would be fine and just to
do whatever Epstein likes.
Over the next approximately three years, travelled with Epstein and Maxwell as
their masseuse, including on their trip to Africa with President Clinton. provided
normal massages to Maxwell multiple times. also massaged Epstein, who forced her
to engage in an escalating series of sexual acts with him. recalled that Epstein raped
her approximately a dozen times over the three years she travelled with him. She never
discussed the abuse with anyone else in Epstein's circle, including Maxwell.
recalled that Leslie Groff and Maxwell coordinated the travel logistics for her
and Epstein. She recalls that Groff was right outside the closed door to Epstein's office on one
occasion when Epstein forced to perform oral sex on him, but she does not know
whether Groff knew what was happening inside the office. believed Epstein was going
behind Maxwell's back when he abused her and did not think Maxwell knew anything about
Epstein's sexual advances toward her. Throughout her time with Epstein, felt very
isolated and was not aware that Epstein was abusing any other victims, including
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRAM. P. 6(e)
2. n
On September 18, 2019, was interviewed in reported
at sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. When was about 18 years old in or around
she travelled to New York to work as a model. While in New York, met David
Blau at a nightclub. Blane subsequently introduced to Epstein and brought her to
Epstein's New York residence for a dinner arty, where gave Epstein her phone number.
Subsequently, contacted to invite her to E stein's private island.
accepted the invitation, and arranged her travel. subsequently had dozens of
interactions with Epstein over the next year, during which she travelled to both the Vii islands
and Palm Beach with him. During these tri s, met and
Ghislaine Maxwell. understood that was Epstein's girlfriend.
At some point, Epstein offered to pay $200 if she massaged him. agreed, and
ended up giving Epstein multiple massages, during which Epstein engaged in sexual contact with
her. did not feel comfortable discussing the details of the sexual contact during this
interview. recalled telling her that Epstein wanted a massage on at least some
occasions, and noticed that there were often numerous girls around Epstein's residences.
did not know if any of those girls were minors. Epstein told though. that everyone.
including was over the age of 18.
also recalled taking one trip with during which they travelled to
Las Vegas and then to New Mexico with Epstein. Before the trip, told Epstein that.
E r was underage, and Epstein said that was fine. During that trip, recalled Maxwell
engaging in sexual conversations, such as discussions of masturbation, but she did not recall
Epstein being discussed during those conversations.
3 .=
. was interviewed on Jul 17, 2019 in New York. reported being
sexually abused b E stein as an adult. knew and interacted with Epstein between
a oximatel In , when was 17 years old, she met Epstein through
who had been previous) introduced to Epstein by a mutual .
friend. At their first meeting, Epstein specifically asked her age and told her, in
substance, that the could not interact until she turned 18. Atter her 18th birthday, Epstein
began having give him masse es, Burin  he used a vibrator to touch her genitals.
A short time later, Epstein took and on a trip to his Virgin Islands residence.
During  directed
Between, Epstein had intercourse with
to give him a masse e, during which he raped her.
on multiple occasions.
30 By 2007, Epstein knew he was under investigation for sexualized massages with minors. He
pled guilty to a state solicitation of a minor charge in 2008.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
described the first few of these instances as forcible and explained that eventually she stopped
resisting.
recalled that Leslie Groff would schedule her massage appointments with Epstein
and make her travel arrangements. Groff worked in an office inside Epstein's New York
residence during the times visited, and met her many times. also recalled
that an assistant named would sometimes cover for Groff and run errands for
Epstein. also knew that worked as Epstein's assistant until she got married
in or around 2011, and that was Epstein's girlfriend.
When Epstein was serving his jail sentence, visited him while he was on work
release at his office and engaged in sexual conduct with him there. After Epstein completed his
sentence, did not have any other sexual encounters with him, but she occasionally
worked for him by running errands or cleaning his house. In or around , Epstein paid
$10,000 to many a young woman who was a foreign national and whom Epstein wanted
to be able to stay in the United Sates. The two were married for about four years, then divorced
in-. ceased all communication with Epstein after the divorce in-.
4.
On October 24, 2019, was interviewed in New York. reported
being sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. is met
Epstein in New York in approximately when she was about 20 years old. At the time,
was and had limited financial resources. A friend of
from named suggested that could provide massages to a
man who paid really well. agreed and began providing Epstein with paid massages at his
New York Residence. During either the first or second massage, Epstein engaged in sexual
contact with After that, began providing Epstein with paid sexualized massages
multiple times per week. The appointments were scheduled at first by and then by
either Leslie Groff or recalls being paid for the massages by Epstein,
Groff, and Bella Klein. Within a few months of meeting Epstein, moved into
Epstein's apartment building on 66th Street in New York.
In or around travelled with Epstein to his residences in the Virgin Islands,
New Mexico, and Palm Beach. At some point, Epstein escalated his sexual contact with
by raping her. As she spent more time with Epstein, he became more controlling about her
appearance. For example, Epstein limited food intake, bought her white underwear to
wear, and made cut her hair short and die it blonde. During this same period, Maxwell
was present for trips took with Epstein to the Virgin Islands. specifically recalls
participating in conversations during which Maxwell provided and others, including
with tips on how to please Epstein sexually. She recalled Maxwell describing
Epstein as needing a lot of sex, and Maxwell encouraged and other girls to engage in
sexual activity with Epstein.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Eventually, became aware that Epstein's actual girlfriend was
On different occasions, Epstein directed to engage in sexual activity with other women
in the contexts of masse es, including and as well as women named
". and■ also recalled introducing to stein, but she was
not present when Epstein sexually abused. also recalled seeing Jean Luc
Brunel. and at Epstein U.S. Virgin Islands home during 2007. On at least one occasion,
took shopping and mentioned Burin the  trip that Epstein liked white
underwear. When travelling to the Virgin Islands, would collect everyone's passports
and hold them until the end of the trip.
At some point, heard about a news article saying Epstein was a child molester.
confronted Epstein about the article, and he denied any knowing contact with minors.
Epstein explained the situation by claiming that someone had shown him a fake ID suggesting
she was 18 years old.
About a year after meeting Epstein, during a trip to the Virgin Islands. posted a
message on her MySpace a e co laining about being stuck on an island with a horrible girl
named referencing Epstein learned of the post and became enraged. He
sent back to New York and directed her to move out of the 66th Street building.
Following this incident, continued to have contact with Epstein, but she spent less time
with him.lpaein subsequently paid for to attend massage school, which she completed
in around=
Eipistein and Maxwell both asked to find other young women to massage Epstein,
but= never actual( recruited anyone to do so. Epstein in particular said the younger a girl
looked the better. recalled a conversation during which Epstein referred to Maxwell as
too old, and Maxwell responded that Epstein liked girls too young. also recalled that
would go to night clubs to pick up new girls to provide sexualized massages.
recalled girls bringing other girls to massage Epstein. never asked how old these girls
were, but they looked young. recalled that Brunel would bring girls to meet Epstein, but
she does not know whether any engaged in sexual activity. She does recall, however. Brunel
commenting that Epstein liked "them young."
Around the time Epstein went to jail, asked to meet her at Epstein's New
York Residence to go through stuff in the basement. Once arrived, directed her
to throw away vibrators and nude photographs of young women. then paid for
37 We believe this woman to be who recruited other adult victims for Epstein
in New York. The FBI made contact with in earlier this month. She
provided contact information for an attorney w o represents er, and we are attempting to
contact the attorney to request an interview.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
%helping with that task. also recalled and Epstein both telling her that if anyone in
the press approached her, should not say anything.
recalled two instances in which Epstein directed her to provide massages to other
men, both of which occurred in or around 2011 or 2012. First, Epstein instructed to
massage Leon Black at Epstein's New York residence. attempted to give Black an
ordinary massage, but Black began initiating sexual contact, at which point ran out of the
room. complained to Epstein, who laughed it off as a funny incident. also
recalled a woman named being directed to massage Black, and afterwards,
told that she had provided Black with oral sex during the massage. Second, Epstein
instructed to provide a massage to Jes Staley in E stein's New York residence.
attem tecSve him an ordinary massage, but he forced
raped Afterwards, complained to Epstein, who said he left it to
to touch his genitals and then
and
Staley to decide whether to engage in sex. After this incident, began to distance herself
from Epstein. Epstein did not pay for providing these massages to Black or Staley, but
Epstein was paying for to finish her massage school at the time, so she felt indebted to
him.
5.
On August 26, 2019, was interviewed in New York.
reported being sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. When was 19 years old in
she was working at a coffee shop where a blonde Eastern European woman named
approached her and recruited her to give a wealthy man a massage. told
that she made money for each woman she recruited and assured that it would
just be a massage and nothing more. agreed and later went to Epstein's New York
residence to perform a massage. During the massage, Epstein directed to remove her
clothes, and after she complied, he masturbated and touched her breasts and genitals.
asked Epstein to stop, but he continued to assault her until he ejaculated. Aftenvards, Epstein
paid in cash. recalled that a maid walked her up to the massage room and
walked her out of the residence after the massage, but she did not know the maid's name or
recall any identifying characteristics. attempted to get to return for another
massage with Epstein, but never returned.
6.
On August 28, 2019, was interviewed in New York.
sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. In approximately when
old, she met a woman named who appeared to be in her mid-20s, in
time, was studying to be a massage therapist, and
Maxwell, was looking for someone to replace was interested, so took a
picture of  face to show to her bosses. Shortly thereafter, someone called and
arranged to fly her from to New York. Once in New York, provided a massage
reported being
was about 22 years
At the
said that her boss, Ghislaine
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
to Maxwell at her residence. At the end of the massage, Maxwell told to give her partner,
Jeffrey, "what he wants" and added "Jeffrey always gets what he wants." Maxwell then paid
$100. Later that same day, went to Epstein's New York residence to massage him.
He asked for a foot massage, and during the massage, he used his foot to touch her breasts and
crotch through her clothing. At the end of the massage, Epstein fondled her genitals and
buttocks through her clothing as was leaving. then left and never heard from Epstein
or Maxwell again.

7. •=1
On August 28, 2019, was interviewed in New York.
reported being sexually abused by E stem as an adult. explained that she previously
did not recall who recruited her, but helped her remember that it was a woman
named who was a woman with long dark hair.38 When was about 20
years' old living in New York in or around 2000, she met at a club. eventually invited
her to meet a friend on the Upper East Side, and agreed.. then brought
to Epstein's New York Residence. Once there, a woman who appeared to be Epstein's personal
assistant, but whose name cannot recall, greeted them and had them wait. Epstein
then invited. and into the massage room, where and gave Epstein
a massage. During the massage, Epstein directed. and to engage in sexual contact
with each other and also engaged in sexual contact with The encounter ended when
someone knocked on the door and called for Epstein, who left in a rush.. and
then left. The next day,. invited to return, but declined and never saw
Epstein again.
8.
On August 28, 2019, was interviewed in New York. generally
reported being "sexually trafficked" by Epstein as an adult; however, was emotional
throughout the meeting and unable to provide details regarding her experiences. She stated
generally that Epstein, Maxwell, and Groff all mined her life, but she was
too distressed to answer questions about what each of those individuals did. We have repeatedly
contacted attorney (she is represented by ) to schedule a follow-up
interview, but to date her attorney has not been able to coordinate another interview.
9.
was interviewed via VTC on August 29,

2019. reported being sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. In or around when
38 The FBI has tentatively identified this individual as . We believe she resides in
, and the FBI is attempting to contact her.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
was about 20 years old and living in New York, a young woman named
approached her at a coffee shop where she worked. hung out with le times
and then asked if she wanted to make money by giving a massage to her boss. said
she had done it before and it was easy. agreed and accompanied to Epstein's New
York residence. Once there, a maid whose name does not recall let the two into the house
and took to the massage room while waited in the kitchen. Once was in the
massage room. Epstein entered the room in a towel and laid on the massage table. During the
massage, Epstein touched breasts and genitals while masturbating. After the assault,
Epstein left, and the maid returned to bring= down to the kitchen, where gave
S400. Afterwards, asked it  wanted to return, but declined. then told
that she made $600 per recruit and asked if she wanted to help recruit. again
declined.
10.
was interviewed on September 12, 2019 in New York.
rsted being sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. When was in her early 20.
she was living in New York and working as a model. A booker recommended that
she meet with Epstein because he could help her modeling career. ended up visiting
Epstein's New York residence on one • easion. Upon arrival, she was greeted by a female
assistant whose name she does not know. then met with Epstein alone in a room with a
massage table. At first. Epstein told he could help her find modellithork with
Victoria's Secret. Eventually, though, Epstein  approached and attempted
to touch her genitals. Epstein offered to pay money, but she refused to take anything
from him. saw a large vibrator in the room, which she picked up and threw at Epstein
before leaving. She never saw him again.
11.
On October 23, 2019, was interviewed in New York. reported
being sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. In when was 27 years old and
working as a model in Los Angeles. a friend of hers introduced her to Epstein as someone who
worked for Victoria's Secret and could help with her modeling career. Epstein then wane.
meet with in his hotel room in Los Angeles. An assistant named Kimberly called
to tell her the time and place of the meeting. During the meeting, Epstein told to undress
and then groped her buttocks. resisted and decided to leave. Before left, Epstein
handed her $100. never saw Epstein again.
" We believe this individual to be
described above.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
12.
On October 23, 2019, was interviewed in New York. reported being
sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. In or about when was about 22 years old,
she was working as a model in New York and met a young woman named (believed to
be at a club. told about a man who liked to help people and
had connections in the modelling world. asked if would be willing to give him a
massage while only in her undenvear, and agreed. subsequently went with
to Epstein's New York residence. Upon arriving, took to the massage room, had
her undress, and then left. then provided Epstein a massage during which he attempted to
touch her and began masturbating. After the massage, Epstein paid $300, after which
went down to the kitchen where was waiting for her. never returned and
never saw Epstein again.
13.
On October 23, 2019, was interviewed in New York.
reported being sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. In or about when =was
about 26 years old, she was working as professional masseuse Another
professional masseuse connected with Epstein, who hired to massage him
and others at his New Mexico ranch for about the next three years. recalls that
Epstein would come to his ranch approximately three or four times per year, and during most of
those visits, she would be asked to come to the ranch to provide massages. While at the ranch,
provided massages to Ghislaine Maxwell and multiple young women who appeared
to be models. also provided Epstein with massages, during which he would engage in
sexual contact with her. Around saw whom-
, at the ranch in Maxwell's office, but did not speak with
understood that Maxwell was Epstein's girlfriend and ran the house.
Maxwell encouraged to bring friends out to the ranch to provide massages, and
emphasized that she wanted pretty, young women. brought one professional
masseuse her own age once to the ranch.
14.
On October 23, 2019, was interviewed in New York.
reported being sexually abused by Epstein as an adult. In when was 18 years old
and modeling in New York, she met a young woman named (believed to be
massage in her underwear.
at a night club. add that she could make easy money by giving a
agreed and ended up giving Epstein paid sexualized
massages on several occasions at his New York residence. Each massage was scheduled by
and a maid whose name does not know would show to the massage
room and pay her after each massage. At some point, Epstein connected with Jean Luc
Brunel for a modeling interview. also went on one trip to the Virgin Islands with
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Epstein and other young women. While on the island, provided Epstein with a
massage during which he attempted to force her into more sexual activity than she was
comfortable with. became upset, and she was sent home. She never saw Epstein
again.

C. Interviews of Witnesses Who Were Not Sexually Abused
1. Juan Alessi
Juan Alessi was interviewed on July 13, 2019 in Florida. Juan Alessi ("Mr. Alessi")
worked for Epstein as the house manager at his Palm Beach residence from the early 1990s until
the end of 2002. Additionally, his wife, Maria Alessi, ("Ms. Alessi") also worked at Epstein's
Palm Beach residence. Mr. Alessi recalled that in or about 1993, Ghislaine Maxwell took charge
of managing Epstein's residences in Palm Beach, New York, New Mexico, the Virgin Islands,
and Ohio. Around that time, Epstein specifically instructed Mr. Alessi to go to Maxwell for
orders. Mr. Alessi described Maxwell as extremely demanding and compared working under her
to "slavery."
Mr. Alessi recalled that his relationship with Epstein began to deteriorate beginning in
approximately 2000, when Maxwell instructed Mr. Alessi and other house staff not to make eye
contact or be in the same room with Epstein. Around this same period, Mr. Alessi recalled that
Epstein received approximately three massages per day when he was staying at his Palm Beach
residence. Mr. Alessi understood most of the masseuses to be professional massage therapists
from around the Palm Beach area, several of whom provided massages for Epstein's guests,
including business partners and prominent people, at the Palm Beach residence. At first, Mr.
Alessi was responsible for scheduling Epstein's frequent massage appointments, but during the
last several weeks of his employment, was hired as Epstein's personal assistant and
began scheduling the appointments instead.
Closer to the end of his tenure, Maxwell asked Mr. Alessi to compile a list of all hotels
and spas around the area of Palm Beach. After Mr. Alessi compiled the list, Maxwell instructed
him to drive her around to each location. Maxwell would enter each location, then return with
business cards of massage therapists. Mr. Alessi recalls one such incident in or around the
summer of 2002 when he drove Maxwell to Mar-a-Lago and waited for her to receive a massage
there. After Maxwell returned to the car, she observed a young girl, whom Mr. Alessi later
learned was named and instructed Mr. Alessi to stop the car. Maxwell got out
of the car and went to speak with for about 20 to 25 minutes before returning. Later that
same day, Mr. Alessi saw come to Epstein's Palm Beach residence. Over the next
several months, returned just about every day to the Palm Beach residence to give
Epstein massages. Mr. Alessi recalls learning that was also traveling with Epstein to
other locations, and he recalls bringing other girls about her age to the Palm Beach
residence to massa ge Epstein. Mr. Alessi understood that was under the age of 18 but
did not know what was doing in the "massages" with Epstein.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)

Mr. Alessi also recalled that a young girl named used to come to the Palm
Beach residence regularly. He recalled that was and that
she and her mother visited Epstein's Palm Beach residence multiple times. Mr. Alessi and his
wife both picked up and understood that was a friend of Epstein's.

Mr. Alessi recalled that travelled with Epstein at least one time and eventually moved to
with Epstein's help. Mr. Alessi observed Epstein kiss on the cheek and pat her
on the bottom.
In total, Mr. Alessi saw "hundreds" of girls at Epstein's Palm Beach residence, but he
believed the majority to be in their 20s. Toward the last few months of his employment, Mr.
Alessi began seeing younger girls, most of whom were brought to the residence by
Maxwell instructed Mr. Alessi not to ask these girls their ages or speak to them. Mr. Alessi
recalls that Maxwell hired younger girls to come to the Palm Beach residence, including two
girls whom Mr. Alessi knew to be in high school, but whose names he could not recall. Mr.
Alessi believed most of the young women who came to the house to be professional masseuses,
but he also recalled cleaning up after massages and finding sex toys in the room, which he then
washed. Mr. Alessi also recalled that Maxwell kept a basket filled with sex toys in her room and
that Maxwell was occasionally inside the massage room with the young women who came to the
house.

Mr. Alessi also recalled more generally that many young women would be topless or
naked by the pool. At the very end of his tenure, Mr. Alessi told Epstein that he should slow
down, that "these girls" would get him in trouble. Epstein remarked that it was fine, and that
"these girls only care about money." When Mr. Alessi left Epstein's employment, Epstein told
him: "I hope you keep your mouth shut."

2. Maria Alessi
Maria Alessi was interviewed on July 13, 2019 in Florida. Ms. Alessi worked for Epstein
at his Palm Beach residence from the mid 1990s until the end of 2002. Ms. Alessi primarily
worked outside of the house, often shopping and running errands, so she was not able to observe
most of the visitors to the house. When asked who, if anyone, she specifically recalls coming to
the Palm Beach residence, Ms. Alessi recalled Ghislaine Maxwell frequently visiting the
residence with Epstein. Ms. Alessi believed that Maxwell was Epstein's personal assistant. She
also recalled seeing at the Palm Beach residence. She also recalled seeing girls
in their 20s or 30s around the house.

3. Gregory Bledsoe
Dr. Gregory Bledsoe was interviewed by telephone on July 22, 2019. Bledsoe is a doctor
who was hired by the Secret Service to provide backup medical services for Bill Clinton during a
trip to Africa in 2002 on Epstein's private jet. Bledsoe recalled that Ghislaine Maxwell and four
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e)
young women. including a masseuse named and a model named
accompanied Epstein on the trip.40 Bledsoe stated that there were no minors on the
flight. He did remark, though, that he found it odd that Epstein would bring four women on the
itiiind he witnessed Epstein grabbing buttocks on the plane. Bledsoe also noticed that
appeared to be intentionally positioning herself in front of the bedroom door so that no
one other than Epstein and his entourage could go inside the bedroom on the plane. Otherwise.
though. Bledsoe did not recall any suspicious or inappropriate behavior during the trip.

4. Richard Barnett
Richard Bamett was interviewed on September 16, 2019 in New York. Barnett was the
chief engineer and property manager for Epstein's New York residence from approximately
1995 through approximately 2014. Barnett had never been interviewed previously, and he was
fully cooperative in the interview. He explained that he was hired by Maxwell and his job was
primarily to keep the property in full working order, which included maintenance of mechanical
operations including the elevators, HVAC operations, electrical work, and other structural
aspects of the house. He also occasionally visited other Epstein properties for similar purposes.
Barnett has formal training as an engineer. He had little day-to-day interaction with Epstein, and
primarily reported to Maxwell until around 2007 or 2008. and then to He described
having seen many young women at the property, but none with whom he interacted directly; he
was instructed not to speak to guests at the house. During the initial Florida investigation, he
was told by Epstein's attorneys that Epstein had inadvertently patronized an underage prostitute,
and as a result, he did not know the scope of Epstein's misconduct until his arrest in 2019.
D. Interviews of Subjects of the Investigation
1.
• was first interviewed with her attorney present and pursuant to a proffer
agreement on July 12, 2019 in was born in and spent her childhood in
graduated high school in and when she was about 18 or 19 years old, she
left to travel as a model. , who connected her with a
modeling agency in In or around late moved to where she
married her first husband in . They ultimately divorced . Before she
began workua.br Epstein  in
husband' and obtainin her
continued modeling while also workin her
associate's degree from After
obtained her bachelor's degree in and
. She is currently employed
leaving Epstein's employ in early
her master's degree in
4° Flight logs for this trip confirm that these individuals were all on E stein's private jet. The
FBI has not yet been able to identify contact information for
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
In or around
community. Around
assistant. Around early
his employee until early
Maxwell.
was in her early 20s, she met Epstein through the modeling
, Epstein offered a job working as an
began working as an assistant for Epstein, and she remained
reported to who reported to Ghislaine
responsibilities included running errands and scheduling appointments. As a
result, scheduled numerous massages for Epstein. According to Epstein expected to
have two massages every day: one in the morning and one in the afternoon. and-
were responsible for ensuring that these massages were confirmed when Epstein was in Palm
Beach. Leslie Groff was responsible for scheduling the massages when Epstein was in New
York.
At some point, Epstein began forcingM to engage in sexual encounters, which were
coercive and nonconsensual. was very distressed when discussing these incidents and did
not want to describe them in detail during our first meeting. At least some of these encounters
involved providing Epstein with his massages while at his Virgin Islands residence. As a
result, was aware that Epstein's massages were usually sexual. described how Epstein
had two groups of girls who provided massages in his Palm Beach and New York homes: one
group was of professional masseuses who gave actual massages to Epstein's friends, and the
second group consisted of younger girls who were not professional masseuses and who only
gave massages to Epstein.. explained that she implicitly understood at the time, and now
realizes fully that Epstein was engaging in sexual contact with the second group of girls.
When scheduling massage appointments, either or Epstein would provide
with the names of girls to call for massages, but for the most part called to confirm
massage appointments. • also recalled that would sometimes ask to call some of
the masseuses and ask if they have another girl to bring.. would occasionally show girls to
the massage room and set up the massage table. • believed it was possible Epstein had asked
to pay the girls, but she cannot recall for certain. typed up a list of girls to call in
Palm Beach and printed copies.
recalled certain details that signaled to her, in retrospect, that girls in this second
group were minors. For example, she was asked to help find SAT prep courses for one girl, and
she recalled girls mentioning school and their parents. That said,M was-
was not at the time familiar with the SAT or the fact
that it is typically taken by high school students. explained that, at the time of the relevant
conduct, she never consciously realized that any of the girls involved in sexualized massages
were underage. She now realizes in retrospect, that she should have known that at least some of
these girls were minors.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
also recalled frequently photographing other women, including taking nude
photos of understood that Maxwell kept binders of those nude photos in her home in
New York.
In 2005, Epstein directed. to collect all contact books and computers from his Palm
Beach residence and provide them to a man who met. at the residence. was present
for the conversation in which Epstein gave. these instructions. Sometime later in 2005,
also asked. to take the contact books from the Virgin Islands and shred them.
Epstein was under investigation at the time.
On September 10, 2019, we met in with_- and her attorney for a
second proffer, during which we further discussed her year working for Epstein. During
employment for Epstein, she, and all had apartments in Epstein's 66 Street
building in New York.. recalled times when photographed. and recalled that
Maxwell had binders of nude photos of women posing in Epstein's different residences.'
Generally, during her year working for Epstein,M noticed that Epstein received two massages
per day. Leslie Groff scheduled the massages in New York, while and. scheduled
the massages in Palm Beach.
understood that Maxwell was Epstein's ex-girlfriend. Maxwell would give.
directions about tasks to carry out, such as errands for the houses. also recalled one
instance in New Mexico when Maxwell told. that if she found a pretty girl, she should get
the girl's number so that the girl can massage Epstein.
Also during this proffer, we reviewed certain documents, such as message pads,
recovered from Epstein's Palm Beach residence during the first Florida investigation, with-
She confirmed that she wrote one message for Epstein from Jean Luc Brunel that referenced
having a teenage girl for Epstein to meet. distinctly recalled Maxwell commenting on how
funny that particular message was. also confirmed that at least one message referenced
someone who was being scheduled to massage Epstein being in high school. also recalled
at least one girl
recalls
wantin, about college, and another girl named. discussing the SAT.
discussing SAT classes with Maxwell at some point and also recalls ordering
SAT prep books for her.
knew that shared an apartment in New York with
She recalls left the apartment and stopped spending time with Epstein after developing an
eating disorder. also met believed was over the
age of 18 when she met her. also knew that recruited girls for Epstein in
41 description of these binders is consistent with the binders of photographs recovered
from Epstein's New York residence during the execution of a search warrant there in July 2019.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
New York and shared an apartment with 42 who also helped find girls
to massage Epstein.. also recalled a young woman named travelling with Epstein.
provided. with training regarding how to make scheduling calls and was
direct supervisor. During the year. worked for Epstein, would primarily take
responsibility for calling to confirm massage appointments when she was in New York and
planning to travel to Palm Beach.. recalls Epstein wanted his massages confirmed either the
night before or morning of each appointment.
recalled that there were certain girls, such as and who
would come to the Palm Beach residence with other girls and wait in the kitchen while the girls
they brought massaged Epstein. In those circumstances both the girl who gave the massage and
the girl who waited in the kitchen would be paid. stated that although in retrospect she
believes there were indications that some of the individuals providing massages to Epstein were
especially young or in high school, she did not know at the time that certain individuals were
underage. She did understand generally, though, that at least some massages involved sex acts
because she was required to perform such acts in the context of massages for Epstein.
At some point when she was in Miami with Epstein and was directed to
drive to Palm Beach to meet someone there. Both and Epstein told to drive to Palm
Beach.. did not understand what was going on, but she recalls Epstein saying something
happened with a visa. Epstein and directed. to gather computers and directories from
the Palm Beach house and give them to a man who would meet there. gave.
the phone number of the person. was to meet in Palm Beach. followed these
instructions and gave the computers and directories from Palm Beach to a man who met her at
Epstein's Palm Beach residence.43
After. completed that task in Palm Beach, asked. to gather the
directories from Epstein's Virgin Islands residence and bring them back to New York.
reminded. to check every building on Epstein's island for the directories. followed
this instruction and brought the directories to Maxwell's house in New York, where she gave
them to then told. to shred the directories in Maxwell's house. also
recalled an instance when Darren Indyke met with her and told her that if she ever needed help
she should not talk to the police.
42 appears on a number of logs for Epstein's private jet. The FBI has identified two
potential addresses for and is attempting to contact her.
43 Materials from the search warrant executed by the Palm Beach Police Department in 2005
confirm that computers appeared to have been removed from Epstein's Palm Beach residence
prior to the search.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
advised that she was also extensively sexually abused by Epstein during her year as
his employee. Although we did not delve into specific detail about all of those events, she
described having been requiredarovide sexual massages, similar to many other victims we
have interviewed in this case. was primarily required to provide Epstein with sexualized
massages at his residences in the Virgin Islands and New Mexico, though she recalls one such
massage in Palm Beach. Epstein cone ed to that her job responsibilities included
providing sexual masse es to him. recalled having about five sexual encounters with both
Epstein and who was Epstein's girlfriend at the time. did not feel that she
could decline to engage in sexual activity with Epstein. Her job depended on relenting to his
advances, and she knew that he had guns, some of which he kept in his bedroom. After about a
year, was finally able to quit and return to living with her husband.
2.
On October 7, 2019, attorneys provided us with an attorney proffer, during
which they explained how met Epstein and how Epstein abused her over several
years, be innin when she was 18 years old. It was during the course of this abuse that Epstein
brought into some of his massages to participate in sex acts with other girls. The
attorney proffer detailed how Epstein controlled every aspect ofl life—including
her physical appearance, her weight, and her clothing—for years. This controlling behavior took
multiple abusive forms, including forcing to have multiple plastic surgeries, forcing
her to engage in BDSM, referring to her as his "sex slave," insulting her, and physically abusing
her, including by choking her and throwing her down a set of stairs. Additionally. her attorneys
provided us with a photograph o and who both appear very thin—
together wearing t-shirts that read "Don't Feed the Pig."
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
First, on October 11, 2019, participated in an interview during which she
walked us through her back ound, how she met E stein, and the general contours of her
relationship with him. was and began modeling in Europe in her
early teens. In approximately , when was IS years old, she received a visa to
travel to New York to work as a model for Karin Models, which was owned by Jean Luc Brunel.
was in New York for a few weeks before she met Epstein. During that time,
employees of the agency told that she owed the company money for her travel and
housing, but she also needed to lose weight before she could go on any castings. did
not end up going on any castings because in-she met Epstein at Jean Luc
Brunet's birthday party. Afteiegd
45 a few days later, inviting her to Palm Beach.
briefly with Epstein at the party. received a
call from E rein's assistant,
eventually agreed to travel to E stein's Palm Beach residence, and during that first
trip, Epstein engaged in sexual contact with
flew with Epstein.
in a massage room. A few days later,
and to the Virgin Islands.
She remained there for a few days before flying back to New York.
In October 2003,E stein aid for to fly back to so that she could
finish high school there. then returned t in or around
at which int E stein offered to let her stay in an apartment in his building on 6 Street
in New York. agreed. and after that, she travelled everywhere Epstein went.
including his residences in New York, Palm Beach, the Virgin Islands, New Mexico, and Paris.
Eventually. began travelling with Epstein less and less over the ensuing years.
remained in a relationship with Epstein until August 2010.
Earlier on. travelled often with Epstein and
was roommate and close friend.
and Ghislaine Maxwell also travelled with Epstein, and Jean Luc Brunel
was also close friends of Epstein. Earlier on, Maxwell slept in Epstein's room when the
traveled together, but eventually. began sleeping in Epstein's room.
recalled that other assistants who worked for Maxwell and/or Epstein were
and was unsure whether
as The FBI has been unable to obtain contact information for
46 The FBI is attempting to identify contact information for
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
assistant as well. recalled that Epstein would pit the women in his circle against
each other and encouraged a lot of secrecy. also recalled that a woman named
introduced some young women to Epstein in New York.
In or around 2006, Epstein told that had been arrested for a drug
charge, and to save herself, she set up Epstein to be investigated. was familiar with
■ as someone who gave Epstein sexualized massages. At some point later,
learned that the charges against Epstein related to prostitution. recalls that her
general sense at the time was that Epstein was being treated unfairly and that the women were
setting him up to get money. emphasized that she now realizes that narrative was
not true, but she accepted Epstein's version of events at the time. To reinforce this narrative,
Epstein repeatedly provided with examples of women he claimed were blackmailing
him. Epstein also told that if she was ever approached, she should not talk and
should either tell Epstein or find a lawyer. recalled being interviewed by Epstein's
attorneys around the time of the first investigation, and she remembers going into the interview
with the goal of being on Epstein's "side." During the interview, she described sex acts she had
with other women together with Epstein in Florida.
Eventually, Epstein told and that he was going to jail for soliciting a
prostitute. Epstein told them that the women he had engaged in sex acts with had lied to him
about their ages. When Epstein went to jail in 2008, became closer with and
they remained good friends for years until Epstein was arrested in 2019, at which point
attorneys advised her to stop speaking with
While Epstein was serving his first jail sentence in Florida, frequently visit
him. She also recalled that and Brunel often visited Epstein. During that same period,
began . After Epstein was
released from jail, in or around 2009, Epstein became increasingly aggressive and irritable with
At one point in 2009, Epstein became particularly violent with so she
left. He then convinced her to return, but again in 2010, he was violent with her, and she ended
the relationship. Until about 2012, Epstein's plane, and he would
have sex with her on some of those trips. In 2012, began working as at her
own company, and she stopped having sex with Epstein.
In the last year or so before Epstein's 2019 arrest, he would check in with-
whenever a news article that referenced her was published. explained that because
of her association with Epstein, she has not been able to maintain steady employment or build
new relationships. told Epstein about these difficulties, and they came to an
agreement that Epstein would double whatever money she was able to make through her work as
He also covered medical expenses for her and paid for her attorneys when she was
deposed in 2015. also noticed that whenever negative articles were published,
Epstein would wire her money. This included a $100,000 wire shortly after the Miami Herald
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
series was published in November 2018. believed Epstein sent her this money
because he felt guilty for the trouble the articles caused her.
Second, on October 15, 2019, we met with for another proffer, during which
she reviewed in more detail certain aspects of her experiences with Epstein.
recalled that before the first investigation into Epstein, he had a number of nude photos of
women in his residences, but at some point after the investigation, there were far fewer of those
photographs in his Florida and Paris residences. Once Epstein was in jail, would
visit him frequently. When he was in jail, Epstein would have his lawyer Darren Indyke and a
paralegal bring him a computer, which he used to have video sex with While
Epstein was on work release, a number of women visited him at his office and would watch
movies with him on a couch. At some point when Epstein was on work release, was
put on his approved driver list and would drive him back to jail at night in a suburban with a
mattress in the back. Most nights, she and Epstein would park near the jail and have sex in the
back of the car. Epstein seemed friendly with the guards at the jail, but she does not know why
he was permitted these freedoms.
Shortly after met Epstein, he pushed her to have a threesome with another
woman. ultimately agreed, and Epstein subsequently brought into the
massage room with other young women to engage in sex acts. The first time this took place was
in Epstein's Palm Beach residence with who was a minor at the time. During that
massage, Epstein directed and to massage him and then engage in sexual
contact with each other and with him. had a few such experiences with. At the
end of each sexual encounter, Epstein would send out of the massage room.
recalled that or another member of the household staff would sometimes set
up the massage room. does not recall seeing receive money. Epstein did not
pay for engaging in sex acts, but he would give $100 bills as pocket
money when they went on new trips together.
Although knew■ was a senior in high school, she believed■ was at
least 18 because of an instance when Epstein sent the two of them to an adult store where they
were carded before entering. produced an ID and was permitted to enter the store, so
assumed that was at least 18 years old. also recalls bringing a
explained that
was 17 at the
friend to massage Epstein and talking about wanting to go to college.
in most high school seniors are 18 or 19, but she now knows that
time.
In additional to. recalled having sexual encounters at Epstein's direction
with a young woman named and a young woman named in the Palm Beach
residence. Each took place in the massage room. Both and the other girl would
massage Epstein, then Epstein would direct the girls to engage in sexual activity with each other
and with him. Each encounter ended with Epstein ejaculating, at which point he would direct
to leave the room, while the other girl stayed in the room and got dressed.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
More generally, understood that Epstein received one to two massages per
day from women in Palm Beach. All of the young women appeared to be age, but
she did not know for sure how old they were. In addition to the three girls with whom she had
sexual contact, recalled masseuses named and One of
or would walk the girls up to the massage Epstein's assistants—either
room prior to each massage. also recalled that some of these girls would bring
friends and wait in the kitchen while the friends ave Epstein a massage. heard the
assistants scheduling massage appointments, but was not generally involved in
scheduling. She believes she may have reached out to at some point to schedule a massage,
though she is not certain. may have occasionally answered the phone in Epstein's
Palm Beach residence and taken messages, but that was not her primary responsibility, so she did
not do so frequently.
knew that some masseuses, who were older than the other masseuses who
only massaged Epstein, provided traditional, non-sexual massages to herself, Maxwell, and
was not initially sure what was going on in the massage room with Epstein.
Although she learned from her own experience that he engaged in sexual activity during
massages, she was unsure whether every massage appointment involved sexual activity, or just
some. Before Epstein went to jail, the frequency of his massages slowed and eventually stopped
entirely.
When was in New York, she did not stay in Epstein's New York residence,
so she was not as familiar with his massage routine there as she was with his routine in Palm
Beach. She did recall, however, multiple occasions when Epstein brought her into the massage
room in his New York residence for sexual encounters with him and other women.
also recalled some such experiences at Epstein's Virgin Islands residence, including at least one
encounter with and a woman named did not recall
encounters with other women in New Mexico, but she recalls some sexual encounters with
Epstein and an older woman at Epstein's Paris residence.
Third, on October 25, 2019, we conducted our final proffer with during
which she provided additional details regarding her time with Epstein. When asked about
Epstein's massage routine at his New York residence, recalled that he would usually
have a morning and afternoon massage, both of which were ordinarily scheduled by Leslie Groff.
The women coming over to give these massages appeared similar in age and general appearance
to the young women who came for massages in Florida. Again, did not know the
ages of these young women, though she believed they were around her age. Epstein stopped
getting regular massages after he completed his jail sentence.
did not recall people coming for regular massages in the New Mexico
residence, but there was a massage room at that residence. In the Virgin Islands, one or two
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
women came to give Epstein massages, but believes they were licensed masseuses.
They would go into the massage room with Epstein.
As to the young women who gave massages in Florida and New York, does
not expressly recall seeing anyone pay those girls, but she acknowledged that it was reasonable
to think that they were getting paid. Looking back, realizes that Epstein probably
had her leave the room after each sexual encounter with another girl so that he could pay the girl.
recalled that Epstein made her believe that and. were attracted to
her and wanted to engage in sex with her. In retrospect, she realizes that was not true, and she is
embarrassed that she believed him.
was also aware that Epstein's assistants gave Epstein massages, and she
believed and were each sexually involved with Epstein at some
point. Epstein would refer to the group of assistants and girlfriends who traveled regularly with
him as his "family." impression was that the only person Epstein saw as his equal
was Maxwell. Epstein and Maxwell talked openly about sex. recalled one instance
when Maxwell was with a group of girls at Epstein's Virgin Islands property and discussed oral
sex and erotic books to read.
and  were all dependent on Epstein, which was in contrast to
Maxwell, who was much older than those three. remarked that the longer a woman
was around Epstein, the harder it was to get out, and she has no idea how managed to leave.
She remarked that only "got out" by getting married, and "got out" by
becoming
also reviewed the details of her interactions with Brunel. She recalled that
Brunel would encourage her to be good to Epstein and massage his feet for him.
believed that Brunel and Epstein had a close relationship, and she heard them talk about women
and sex in front of her. In or around early Brunel brought a young girl, who was about 15
years old, to Epstein's Virgin Islands residence. assumed as much because Epstein
commented that the girl was 10 years younger than but does not know her
exact age, nor does she know whether anyone engaged in sexual contact with the girl and does
not recall the girl's name. During her years with Epstein, visa was sponsored by
Brunel's modeling agency, even though she was not working. Epstein told that he
paid Brunel $1 million to keep her in the country. As a result, felt that Epstein could
have her deported with a single phone call to Brunel. In 2011, Epstein and Brunel refused to
help renew visa, but she was able to obtain one through her work as
explained that for years she and both thought that Epstein was the
victim of a witch hunt targeting a wealthy man. She now realizes that Epstein was abusive, and
she is embarrassed that she believed his manipulative narrative for so long. More recently,
told about some of the physically abusive behavior Epstein engaged in
toward her, and expressed surprise, saying she did not have similar experiences.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRAM. P. 6(e)
3.
attorneys provided attorney proffers to us on July 31, 2019, September 6,
2019, and October 18, 2019. These proffers covered personal background, introduction
to Epstein, sexual abuse she experienced at Epstein's hands, and job Tsi sibilities for Epstein.
Her attorneys said that scheduling massages was just one small part o job. They also
asserted that did not know that the massages involved sexual contact or that any
masseuses were minors. Following these meetings, proffered with us, pursuant to a
proffer apeement, on two occasions. The information she provided in those proffers closely
tracked the information provided by her attorneys in their proffers and accordingly do we not
separately summarize the attorney proffers below. We a with her attorneys, however, that
for purposes of these two proffers, we would not discuss obstructive conduct during the
first investigation.
On November 26, 2019, we interviewed in New York.
While there,
some modeling jobs.
As a result, was extremel isolated and alone
to live with her husband and his family.
and atte ' ted to find
to support herself. After about a year. in or around a coworker mentioned a wealth
couple who was looking for a personal assistant and invited to meet them in
agreed and flew to where she met Epstein, Maxwell. and
flew with that same group to New York. During this trip, there,
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
herself as an ideal personal assistant for Epstein and Maxwell. flew back
was back in for about a month before Maxwell called her and asked her to
fly out to Palm Beach. agreed and was on a plane the next day. She then spent a few
days at Epstein's Palm Beach residence, during which she was formally hired as Maxwell's
personal assistant. She then continued travelling with Epstein and Maxwell and never returned
. Shortly after was hired, Epstein instructed her to take a bath with him, during
which he told her "you go the job, now you just have to keep it." Epstein then engaged in sexual
contact with and understood that her job was dependent on her willingness to
submit to Epstein's sexual demands.
responsibilities included coordinating travel for Epstein and his entourage,
managing his houses, completing shopping, organizing schedules and binders for each house,
digitizing photographs, and running errands. For her first few years of employment,
reported directly to Maxwell, and she worked out of Maxwell's house when they were in New
York. When in New York, would occasionally stay at Epstein's New York residence, but
she primarily resided in an apartment in Epstein's building on 66th Street. When Epstein got out
of jail, no longer reported to Maxwell and instead worked out of Epstein's residence
when they were in New York.
During the time she worked for Epstein, travelled with him wherever he went.
Each morning, either Epstein or Maxwell would give a list of tasks to complete for the
day. When Epstein was in Palm Beach, was responsible for scheduling his daily
massages. Typically in Palm Beach, Epstein would receive a morning massage and an afternoon
massage. Maxwell and taught how to schedule massages using a directory that
was kept in Maxwell's office. Maxwell or Epstein would tell who from the directory to
call for a particular massage. Typically, would call to schedule massages a day ahead of
time. believed that the people she was calling were experienced masseuses. If one
masseuse could not make an appointment, she would either tell Maxwell or Epstein, or she
would ask the masseuse whether they could refer anyone else. Eventually, was shown
how to edit the directory on the computer,' and she would update the directory with new contact
information for new masseuses when told to do so.
recalled that some of the masseuses were regulars, while others came less
frequently. Maxwell and other guests would sometimes get massages as well, and those
' This appears to be the directory that. was instructed to remove from Epstein's Palm Beach
and Virgin Islands residences. As discussed above, was also instructed to remove the • computers from Epstein's Palm 
Beach residence, whit appears to have included the computer
on which edited the directory. As result, law enforcement has not recovered a copy of
this directory.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
massages were provided by people on the same directory list as the people who massaged
Epstein. When asked what types of reasons these people gave when they could not make
appointments, said she recalled some saying they had to work and one referencing soccer
practice.
When a masseuse arrived at the Palm Beach residence, generally someone would meet
her in the kitchen. would then take her up to the massage room. If it was a masseuse's
first time, would show her the table, lotions, and towels. would then leave and tell
Epstein that his massage was ready. would typically then go run errands while Epstein
received his massage, and she was sometimes present when a masse e finished. Sometimes
multiple girls would give Epstein massages at the same time, but did not recall anyone
bringing a girl for a massage and then waiting for that girl inside the house. did not really
talk with any of the masseuses or learn about
, and she recalls another who was pregnant.
At  ri ersonal lives. She did recall, though, one girl
sa that she was on break from college
believed that Epstein usually paid the masseuses, but a couple of times he asked her to
pay them. recalled paying the masseuses around $200 per massage.
When asked to name the masseuses she remembered, listed several names,
including
recalled that
M and She
was attendm cone e and that had a baby at some point, but she
did not know much about or remembered one time when
called and asked how much Epstein would pay to have sex with one of the masseuses.
was shocked and told that Epstein "doesn't do that." did not mention the
conversation to Epstein because she worried he would get mad at her and she felt uncomfortable
bringing it up.
also did not think that sexual abuse was taking place during the massages for
several reasons. She explained that some massages were provided b men,49 and that no one
ever acted like anything was wrong. The masseuses would also call and ask to come
back, so did not believe anything abusive was taking place. also walked in on
some of Epstein's massages, and the masseuses she saw in the massage room on those occasions
were clothed. Epstein also asked to rovide him massages on a couple occasions, but
they never turned sexual. As a result, did not connect massages with sexual activity.
48 was interviewed during the first Florida investigation. During that interview
smil.vhen=1 was 23 years old, Maxwell recruited her to work as an assistant at
Epstein's Palm Beac residence. She eventually gave massages to Epstein,
and Her massages with Epstein included sexual contact.
" No other witness has described any male masseurs providing massages to Epstein or anyone
else in Epstein's circle.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
viewed the masseuses as her peers — i.e., young adults in their early 20s — and it
never her mind that any of them were minors. In view. Epstein was the head of
the household, and everyone did what he said. did recall Epstein telling her that he was
for an SAT tutor for but never took the SATs because
so she did not know what that test was or what it meant. She
has recently learned that it is a test that someone would ordinarily take in high school, but she
did not know that at the time.
only learned that Epstein was sexually abusing minors when news articles started
coming out about it. She recalled being shocked, angry, and disappointed. She was particularly
angry with Epstein for manipulating her to help orchestrate the abuse of other women. During
the first investigation, Epstein showed some of the masseuse's MySpace pages in which
they claimed to be 18 or referenced drug use. felt that she had nowhere to mnd her
reputation was ruined in the press, so she did not think she could get another job. said
that she still feels awful and wishes she could apologize to the victims. She also said that she
wishes she had been interviewed during the first investigation so that she could have told
someone that she was being abused and explained that she did not recruit or procure girls—she
just met them when they came to the house."
On December 4. 2019, we conducted a second proffer with in New York. This
proffer focused on the 5250.000 payment she received from Epstein in late 2018 and on the
sexual abuse she experienced while working for Epstein.
With tcsyect to the 2018 payment, explained that between approximately 2016
and 2018, she and her husband experienced fmancial difficulties.
was still in touch with Epstein and saw him every other month or
so. During those meetings. told Epstein about her financial troubles. Then one day in
early December 2018, Leslie Groff emailed inviting her to visit with Epstein at his
residence in New York. accepted the invitation and once again told Epstein about her
financial difficulties. In r e. Epstein made a call to his accountant, Rich Kahn. and directed
Kahn to wire 5250,000 to Epstein told not to tell anyone about the payment, but
he did not say why. assumed Epstein did not want her husband to feel badly about
accepting such a gift. The last time Erarnrovided with money before that transaction
was a $100,000 gift for her wedding
Notwithstanding Epstein's instruction to the contrary, told her husband about the
$250,000 payment, and they used it to deal with their financial problems. mentioned the
payment she received to who responded that she had recently received a payment of
5° We did not discuss the end of her relationship with Epstein durin this roffer. As discussed
below, we covered that time period during our second proffer with
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
$100,000 from Epstein. said that Epstein called her one day and asked if she could
use money, and when she said yes, he sent her the money. believed Epstein was being
generous because during their prior conversations about her financial difficulties, Epstein had
told that she would always be safe and he would always take care of her.
When asked about the Miami Herald series, said she was aware as early as April
2018 that a reporter for the Miami Herald was working on a story about Epstein. was
aware of the series the day it was published in November 2018, and she recalls that she received
the email from Groff inviting her to meet with Epstein within a day or two of the series'
publication. Although recalled mentioning the series when she met with Epstein in early
December, she does not recall the details of what they discussed and did not believe the payment
and articles were related.
With respect to Epstein's sexual abuse, reiterated that Epstein first engaged in
sexual contact with her shortly after she was hired when he directed her to take a bath with him
and indicated that her job depended on engaging in sex acts with him. explained that she
did not feel that she had a choice because she did not want to lose her job, which had finally
helped her feel financially secure. Epstein paid for housing, travel, clothing, and food,
in addition to paying her a salary, which began at approximately $35,000 per year, then increased
annually until she was earning a bit over $100,000 per year. When Epstein went to jail, she took
a pay cut to $75,000, which remained her salary until she left her job when she married her
husband . Epstein also paid for attorney when she was deposed in
lawsuit.
For approximately the next several years, from approximately until around the time
Epstein went to jail in 2008, Epstein engaged in frequent sexual contact with Over that
period, could only recall a small number of trips she took with Epstein during which he
did not engage in some sort of sexual contact with her. Usually this contact involved Epstein
bringing to a bedroom and giving her explicit instructions regarding how to touch him
and how to position herself while he masturbated on the bed. Additionally, Epstein frequently
snuck into room while she was sleeping and woke her up by fondling her.
insisted that she had no memory of any sexual contact taking place in any massage room with
Epstein or in the context of any massage at all. During this period, had a small number of
serious boyfriends, and Epstein knew about those boyfriends but still engaged in sexual contact
with did not want to engage in any sexual contact with Epstein but felt obligated
to do so in order to keep her job.
The sexual contact slowed sometime before Epstein went to jail and evolved into Epstein
just asking to sleep in his bed but not engaging in sexual contact. As this contact slowed,
believes Epstein was spending more of his time with who was his
girlfriend. After Epstein was released from jail, no longer slept in his bed, and they no
longer had any sexual contact.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
explained that she did not quit her job because she did not know where else she
could go and was completely dependent on Epstein. She had no friends outside of Epstein's
world, no education, and no family to support her. Epstein was also controlling in other aspects
of_ life. He would become enraged if she made a mistake or did not follow his
instructions about travel plans precisely. Epstein also controlled physical appearance.
He made her cut her hair short and dye it blonde. He also selected her clothes and would
comment on her body and encourage her to lose weight. was aware that Epstein was
similarly controlling of Epstein also controlled whe
t
re lived, as she travelled
with him wherever he went and was required to be on call 24/7. so recalled that Epstein
and Maxwell had sign a healthcare proxy assigning them responsibility if anything
happened to her. was also required to sign a confidentiality agreement.
recalled three instances during which Epstein directed to engage in sexual
activity while another woman was present. First, shortly after she took the job, was
directed by Maxwell and Epstein to engage in sexual contact with them at Epstein's Virgin
Islands residence. does not remember how this incident began or ended, but she
remembers Maxwell being naked in the bedroom with her and Epstein and directing-
regarding how to sexually touch E stein. Second, in or around-, Epstein directed
and a woman named 51 who was in her 20s, to engage in sexual contact with
each other and with him at his Virgin Islands residence. Third, in or around
Epstein directed and a woman named who was in college, to engage in
sexual contact with each other and him at his New York residence.
The most violent form of sexual abuse experienced occurred when she and
Epstein were alone in the gym at Epstein's Palm Beach residence. While was doing sit-
ups, Epstein closed the blinds to the windows and then roughly pulled pants down and
aggressively raped her. That is the only time
her.
recalled Epstein having intercourse with
did not tell Maxwell about the other incidents of sexual contact with Epstein
because she was afraid Maxwell would become angry and that would lose her job.
understood that Maxwell was Epstein's girlfriend and that she viewed the other girls
Epstein had sex with as trash that should be quickly disposed of. did not want Maxwell
to think of her that way. She recalled, though, one instance on Epstein's birthday in or around
2002 at Epstein's Virgin Islands residence when Maxwell directed and other young
women to get naked, wrap themselves in saran wrap and take photographs while posing around
Epstein as he sat on a massage table. Maxwell also directed and the other young women
to put paint on their breasts and press them on a canvass to give to Epstein as a birthday present.
also recalled a time when Maxwell discussed techniques for giving oral sex in
presence. does not know, though, whether Maxwell engaged in any sexual contact with
any other women.
51 The FBI has not yet identified this individual.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e)
After Epstein came out of jail, responsibilities increased as she stepped into the
role that Maxwell previously held running all of his homes. did not recall scheduling
massa es for E s stein an ore after he came back from 'ail. separated from Epstein in
2012 . At first tried to
restructure her job responsibilities so that she would not have to travel so much with Epstein, but
Epstein rejected that plan and encoura ed to leave her position and move in with her
husbanc, the time she got married
there, was managing
was no longer Epstein's employee. From
was ashamed of the sexual abuse she experienced and did not tell anyone about it
for years. including her husband. The first people disclosed this abuse to were the
attorneys who currently represent her. Because her husband did not know about Epstein's sexual
abuse, he viewed Epstein as father-figure and encouraged her to remain in touch with
him after they were married.
At the end of the interview, said that she wished she could tell the victims that she
would never knowingly facilitate their abuse. She emphasized that she would not knowingly
help put someone through what she went through.
E. Interview of
On September 9, 2019. we interviewed in New York.
. During this interview, we discussed with the process of her recruitment and her
interactions with Maxwell. We also discussed at a high level her allegations that she was "lent
out" to other individuals by Epstein to engage in sex acts with them.'
At the be i of the interview. hasized that
When asked to describe how she first came into contact with Epstein,
referenced what she called her "training period" with Epstein and Maxwell, which began
in or around also indicated that she previously believed she was 15 when she first
met Maxwell, but the "records"  showed that she was in fact 16 years old. She explained that she
met Maxwell at Mar-a-Lago,
and where Maxwell recruited her to come to Epstein's Palm Beach residence to massage Epstein.
At the residence, Maxwell and Epstein both interviewed and then began
" As described in more detail below, we have been unable to corroborate . haccounts of
being "lent our' to other men for sex. We have, however, been able to corro rate er account
of being recruited by Maxwell, being sexually abused by Epstein, and recruiting other minor
girls to provide paid sexualized massages to Epstein at his Palm Beach residence.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
massaging Epstein. During the massage, Epstein and Maxwell asked questions about
her background and difficult family life, and she told them truthfully how old she was. Epstein
and Maxwell then directed to take off her clothes, and the massage became sexual.
During what refers to as her "training period," Maxwell and Epstein taught
about how to engage in sex acts. For example, Maxwell and Epstein taught how
to perform oral sex and how to engage in anal stimulation. During this same period, also
recalls many conversations during which Maxwell and Epstein would tell to look for and
recruit young females. They directed to find young females who looked like the girl
next door. explicitly remembered Epstein saying the "younger the better" and that he
did not want "black girls." understood that these recruits would give paid sexualized
massages to Epstein at his Palm Beach residence.
Maxwell taught how to recruit younger girls for Epstein by taking on
shopping trips, during which Maxwell would demonstrate how to recruit girls and would make
practice doing so. Maxwell taught to recruit young girls by saying, "I know this
really nice guy who likes to help people out," adding "you can make some money," and noting
that the man could help the girl with her education or being a model. Maxwell criticized
for being "bad" at recruiting girls and would show how easily Maxwell could recruit
girls.
followed these instructions and told the girls she recruited that they would have
to give massages, but not normal massages. When girls agreed to the proposition, would
exchange numbers with them. would then describe the girl to Epstein, who would
decide whether he wanted to meet with them. If the girl was acceptable, then Maxwell would
schedule the girl to come to the Palm Beach residence at a particular date and time.
recalledgetting in trouble for not bringing enough girls and for not bringing the "right" girls for
Epstein. was usually paid $200 for each girl she brought. If Epstein liked a girl
brought in, he would give her $300 as an extra incentive. Usually Epstein paid but
sometimes he told her to get money from Juan Alessi. Epstein would occasionally take the
phone number of a girl himself after a massage if he liked her.
vividly recalled a conversation with Maxwell and during which
they were all smoking cigarettes inside Epstein's Palm Beach residence. During this
conversation, asked Maxwell how she handled Epstein being with so many girls.
Maxwell responded that it took the "pressure off" Maxwell having "to do it." added that
the more girls they recruited the less they would "have to do" themselves. understood
that Epstein had a sex addiction.
When recruited girls, she would have them meet her at her home, and then she
would get a ride. Sometimes would give her rides, and sometimes Juan Alessi
would give her rides. Upon arriving at Epstein's Palm Beach residence, either Juan Alessi,
Maria Alessi, Maxwell, or would answer the door. would then bring the girl up
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
to the massage room and would stay in the room for the massage with them. did not
recall recruiting anyone in New York and believes she only recruited girls in Florida. In total,
believe that she brought no more than 20 girls to Epstein. She expressed sincere
remorse for having recruited girls to be abused by Epstein.
described herself  as subservient durin her  with Epstein and recalled
quitting her Job at Epstein's direction. said that she initially believed she
started travelling with Epstein about six months after her "training period," but upon reviewing
Mar-a-Lago records and flight records, she realized she took her first trip with Epstein only three
months after being recruited. recalled travelling very frequently, either weekly or every
other week, with Epstein. When she travelled to New York, she would stay in an apartment in
Epstein's building on 66th Street. During one such trip. left for a walk and was gone for
a few hours, after which Maxwell and Epstein were angry that she had not stayed in the
a artment and waited for them to contact her. In response to that incident, Maxwell bought
a cellphone and told to stay in Epstein's New York residence and only leave
when Epstein directed her to go to a sex store or go recruit girls though, as mentioned above,
never successfully recruited any girls in New York). never slept over in
Epstein's Palm Beach residence, but she recalled that eventually Epstein gave her money to pay
for her own apartment in Florida, which enabled her to move out of her parents' home.
Durin herperiod travelling with Epstein, spend most of her time with Epstein,
Maxwell, and When that group spent time watching television or movies together.
Maxwell would sometimes initiate sexual contact by taking off her clothes and telling to
give her oral sex. Maxwell would also involve in the sexual contact, all while Epstein
was present. On one such occasion, Maxwell used a sex toy on in a way that was
physically painful to As spent more time with E stem, though. Maxwell
became less directly involved in sexual contact. At some point, began using drugs so
heavily that Epstein said he did not want her around anymore. She still maintained some contact
with him, though. and when she turned 19 Epstein and Maxwell paid for to
travel to for massage therapy school.
%also mentioned someone named who was who was also good at
recruiting girls. She also said that someone named would recruit girls for
Epstein.
initially described
claimed that she had personally watched recruit girls, but she did not provide additional
details. recalled meeting after her "training" was complete and she
had already "proven" herself. Shortly before that first meeting. Epstein described as one
of his "favorites." Epstein then brought to house in , where
" The FBI has not yet identified this individual.
as a "mastermind" at finding girls. first
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
. Epstein, and all engaged in sexual contact with each other. recalled that
already knew exactly what to do and what Epstein liked sexually. recalled
Epstein saying that other than Maxwell, was the best for picking up girls. When asked to
describe specific instances in which personally observed recruit someone,
E l
said she did not recall actually seeing recruiting anyone, and added that she and
did not really get along, and did not see her much. When asked whether-
had other sexual experiences with she said there were "tons" and "too many to count."
generally described Maxwell and Epstein directing her to engage in sex acts with
other men. Although we did not delve into the details of this topic, volunteered some
information about it,
used the term "lent out" to describe instances in which Maxwell or
Epstein directed her to have sexual contact with other men. Her first memory of being "lent out"
was after Epstein paid for her to get an apartment in Florida and after Maxwell had gotten her a
cellphone. One day, Maxwell told to massage Glen and Eva Dubin and explicitly told
that she had to do to Glen what did for Epstein, which understood to
mean engage in sex acts. added that at some point, Maxwell and Epstein told
that they were going to "test me out" with other people, which she needed to do in order to be a
"real" massage therapist. With respect to Prince Andrew,' recalled that Maxwell told
that she was going to meet a prince and should make him happy and do the exact same
things for him that she did for Epstein because the prince was a good friend of Maxwell's.
explained that she was "lent out" so many times that she began using drugs, and
she cannot estimate how many times she was "lent out" to other people. She recalls being "lent
out" to some people multiple times, and some people just once. Sometimes Maxwell would
direct to engage in sex acts with other men, and sometimes Epstein would do so. When
in New York, either Maxwell or Epstein would call to the massage room and direct her
to engage in sex with a man there. said that she was never paid by any of these other
men for the sexualized massages she provided. does not recall any conversations about
money taking place in front of any of the men to whom she was "lent out." also
mentioned Alan Dershowitz, but we did not fully explore the details of her interactions with him.
When asked whether she was aware of any other girls who were "lent out" like
she said that was a participant in sex acts with "lots" of third parties. She also said
that was "lent out" and that and were "lent out" together.'
54 We are in the process of obtaining the name of a lawyer who represents Prince Andrew. Once
we have this contact information, we plan to request an interview.
55 This is inconsistent with account. does not recall ever being told to have sex
with any men other than Epstein. This is also inconsistent with account.
described being sexually abused by Epstein, but she did not describe ever being told to have sex
with any men other than Epstein.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
also recalled being "lent our with a woman named and with -
added that there were more girls whose names she could not think of at the time.
noted that came into the picture toward the end of
time with Epstein, so she did not know much about her.
account of being recruited by Maxwell, abused by Maxwell
and Epstein, engaging in paid sexualized massages with Epstein as a minor, recruiting other
minors to engage in paid sexualized massages with Epstein, and travelling to other locations with
Epstein are all consistent with other evidence and corroborated, in significant part, by
employment records at Mar-a-Lego, fli t records for Epstein's private jet, and other witnesses.
In particular. Juan Alessi confirms that frequently visited Epstein's Palm Beach
residence to provide Epstein with masse es and often brought other your irls to the residence
to massage Epstein. Alessi knew that was a minor and knew that travelled with
Epstein. In addition, Maria Alessi and both recalled seeing with Epstein.
Moreover, her account of theseiiiences remarkabimisistent with the experiences of
other victim-recruiters. such as and
number
of the men has publicly identified as people to whom she was "lent out" have
vociferously denied her allegations. No other victim has described being expressly directed b
either Maxwell or Epstein to engage in sexual activitsithinither men.
and
recalled E stein asking her to massage Harve
directed to remove her shirt. When
not ask her to massage any other men again.
Leon Black and Jes Staley, both of whom engaged in sexual contact with her against her will
during the massages. Moreover, according to when she complained to Epstein about the
sexual contact, he laughed and told that it was up to her whether to engage in sex during
those massages.
Weinstein and that during the massage Weinstein
refused and left, Epstein apologized and did
recalled Epstein asking her to massage
I
" The FBI has not yet identified this individual.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
In
the memoir, described a number of incidents that she has since admitted did not in fact
wrotairtially fictionalized account of her experienced with Epstein and Maxwell. In
take place. These include descriptions of a sexual encounter with a Nobel Prize winning scientist
and a scene in which is caught with cocaine in her room and fired. The memoir
also mentions Alan Dershowitz, but does not claim that engaged in sex acts with him.
She did not raise those claims until 2014.
Also in when was still writing her memoir, she exchanged emails with
Sharon Churcher, a reporter for the Mail on Sunday. In one email.Misked Churcher to
help her put together a list of Epstein's well-known associates so that could include them
in her memoir. In response. Churcher wrote, "Don't forget Alan Dershowitz. JE's buddy and
lawyer. Good name for your pitch... We all suspect Alan is a pedo and tho no proof of that, you
probably met him when he was hanging with JE."
As for
well as
account of her interactions with Prince Andrew
a photograph of= with Prince Andrew and Maxwell. as
recollection that Maxwell also introduced her to Prince Andrew.
Prince Andrew. who has publicly denied the allegations
we asked
whether she recalled any other females who ma have been present with her during these sexual
interactions. In response, said that
and more girls whose names should could not recall, had all participated with
sexual encounters with other men at the direction of either Epstein or Maxwell. However,
and have very different memories. who as noted above, did recall
meeting on one occasion, did not recall Epstein or Maxwell ever asking her to have sex
with any other men. Nor did she recall ever being present when engaged in sex acts
with other men. Similarly, although described numerous instances of sexual abuse, she
did not describe ever being directed by Epstein or Maxwell to engage in sex acts with another
man. She, too, did not recall ever being present when engaged in sex acts with other
men.
also described visiting residence in and engaging in sexual
activity with and Epstein there. However, we have been unable to gather any evidence to
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
suggest that ever resided in Rather, the information provided by other
witnesses and corroborated by travel records, suggests that resided in Epstein's building
on 66th Street in New York and otherwise travelled with Epstein wherever he went.
Of particular si cance in evaluatin account of_ participation in
sexual abuse, description o conduct was internally inconsistent within our
single interview with her. At first, stated that was a "mastermind" recruiter and
said that she had personally witnessed recruit minor girls to engage in paid sexualized
massages with E stein. When asked to describe specific instances in which she observed -
recruiting girls, said that she had never seen recruit anyone and had not actually
spent much time with By contrast, when asked whether she recalled any other instances
in which was present for sexual activity._ said there were "tons" and "too many to
count."
Additionally, in or around 2016, was deposed
admitted to lying about her
employment history on her resume, admitted to burning handwritten notes that she had made
about her experiences with Epstein and Maxwell, and admitted that she inaccurately told a
reporter that she was abused by Epstein for four years when she was only with him for about two
years. She also confirmed that she was paid a total of nearly $200,000 for the statements and
photo of Prince Andrew that she provided to Sharon Churcher, and she admitted to exchanging
emails with Churcher about how "big headlines" would help sell her memoir.
also admitted that she had previously claimed that the FBI told her they were aware of 40 other
Epstein victims, when in fact the FBI never told her how many victims they had identified. She
further claimed that the FBI told her that Epstein had cameras watching her at all times,
including while in the bathroom (we are not aware of any such cameras). At one point during
her deposition, became particularly combative when pressed to describe in detail any
specific times she recalled when Maxwell directed her to have sex with another person.
Eventually, cursed in her response, saying, "She's the one who brought me to be
trafficked by Jeffrey Epstein in the flicking first place."
Substantially all of the individuals accused by of engaging in misconduct have
publicly denied the allegations. These denials include public statements made by Dershowitz
and Prince Andrew, who both deny engaging in any sexual contact with And as noted
below, Maxwell, through counsel, has similarly disputed substantial aspects o account.
Finally, has engaged in a continuous stream of public interviews about her
allegations, many of which have included sensationalized if not demonstrably inaccurate
characterizations of her experiences. The most recent example arose this month when
publicly claimed that the FBI had warned her of a "credible" death threat. In fact, both the FBI
and our Office have repeatedly told that there are no credible threats to her safety.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Nevertheless, has stated both publicly and during a meeting of victims at the FBI's New
York office that the FBI has identified a credible threat against her.

F. Additional Investigative Steps
In addition to conducting numerous witness interviews, we have met with attorneys for
other subjects of the investigation, executed search warrants, reviewed financial records, and
reviewed numerous documents in an effort to evaluate and corroborate witness accounts.
1. Attorney Meetings
a. Counsel for Ghislaine Maxwell
On October 8, 2019, Maxwell's attorneys provided us with an attorney proffer. During
the meeting. her attorneys described Maxwell's background and upbringing. She was born in
France in 1961 and raised in Paris. In the early 1990s, she began traveling to the United States
more often as her father expanded his business there, and she met Epstein through a friend of her
father's while in the United States. In 1991, he father died, and his company collapsed, leaving
Maxwell with limited financial resources. Epstein supported Maxwell both emotionally and
financially after her father's death, and they began a romantic relationship in 1992. Early on in
the relationship, Epstein was very secretive and kept Maxwell in the dark about other parts of his
life, including other girlfriends he had. During the earlier period of their relationship. Maxwell
was not allowed to look at Epstein's message sheets or answer his phones.
By around the mid-1990s. Maxwell only saw Epstein about half the days in any given
month, and they were physically intimate less often. Around that same time, Maxwell began
managing Epstein's properties. Epstein paid Maxwell a salary. and she would give him weekly
its regarding his various properties. In 1996, they hired Kimberly Galindo57 and
as assistants to help with Maxwell's management responsibilities. By the late 1990s.
Maxwell wanted to many and have a child with Epstein. Although Epstein refused to many her,
he told Maxwell that he would have a child with her, which was why Maxwell decided to stay
with him.
57 The FBI has not yet identified this individual.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Around the late 1990s, Epstein began using testosterone patches, which made him more
aggressive. Their relationship began to deteriorate, and Maxwell stopped sleeping in the same
room as Epstein. In or around 1999 or 2000, Maxwell stopped having sex with Epstein. At that
time, Epstein was dating a woman named-. 513 In or around Maxwell ended her
romantic relationship with Epstein and began dating other men. Around the same time, Maxwell
met in Hawaii and ended up hiring her to be Maxwell's personal assistant to
replace Shortly after was hired, though, Epstein made clear that would be
his assistant instead. Maxwell trained regarding how to manage Epstein's houses, and
eventually took over Maxwell's responsibilities.
Between about 2001 and 2003, Maxwell continued travelling with Epstein, even though
they fought frequently, because Epstein wanted her to continue managing his properties. It was
during this period that Maxwell met Maxwell does not recall meeting
and she primarily recalls speaking with Leslie Groff on the phone.
In 2003, Maxwell began a long-term relationship with Ted Wight, and she remained in a
committed relationship with him until 2010. As a result of that relationship, Maxwell spent less
and less time with Epstein. She was not present in 2005 when the Palm Beach Police
Department searched Epstein's Palm Beach residence, and she was not contacted or interviewed
during that investigation. Maxwell understood that Epstein pled guilty to having sex with an
"underage prostitute," and she did not visit him in jail.
Throughout their relationship, Epstein asked Maxwell to connect him with massage
therapists, but she insists that she only hired adults for that role. She recalled Epstein getting one
massage per day, and she believed that the massages were not sexual in nature. Maxwell did
engage in sex acts with Epstein and other adult women, but she denies ever doing so with
minors. Maxwell categorically denies any involvement in recruiting minors for sex with Epstein.
Maxwell's attorneys claimed that she has a medical condition making some of the public
allegations regarding certain sex acts involving Maxwell physically impossible. They did not
provide any additional details regarding the nature of the condition or which acts it impacted.
They added that she could be intimate with Epstein, but not every day because of this condition.
At the conclusion of the proffer, Maxwell's attorneys walked through the public
allegations against their client and explained their views of why the individuals making those
claims were not credible. In doing so, they emphasized that Maxwell had not invoked her Fifth
Amendment privilege against self-incrimination when she was deposed as a part of
lawsuit.59 Although they discussed several witnesses during this portion of the
ss The FBI has not yet identified this individual.
" We have reviewed the transcripts of Maxwell's two-part deposition in 2016, which was taken
in connection with defamation suit against Maxwell. During the deposition,
Maxwell admitted to being in a romantic relationship with Epstein from the early 1990s through
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
meeting. they primarily focused on three victims: and
First, they highlighted a number of inconsistencies within account, including
prior accounts of abuse that has since admitted to fabricating in her memoir. They also
pointed out that account of being forced to have sex with other men differs
dramatically from that of other victims of Epstein's abuse. Second, they noted that
was an adult when she met Epstein and that she had admitted to lying and saying that
she had video evidence of her abuse, when she did not. Finally, they noted that flight lo show
that Maxwell was "never" in New Mexico in , which is when says
Maxwell engaged in inappropriate behavior with her. Maxwell denies allegations.
b. Counsel for Leslie Groff
Leslie Groff worked as Epstein's primary New York-based assistant from at least in or
about 2001 through the summer of 2019. Her responsibilities included, among other things,
scheduling Epstein's massages at the New York residence. Generally, Groff would call victims
to schedule massage appointments, but she had limited interactions with the victims beyond
scheduling. In addition to scheduling massage appointments, Groff would also book flights for
girls who travelled to meet Epstein at his various residences. Groff made these arrangements by
phone from the New York office where she worked for Epstein. She spent little time in
Epstein's residence and thus had few in-person interactions with victims.
in or around 2000. She also described acting as his employee and being tasked with running his
various properties. She claimed to have spent very little time with Epstein in the 2000s.
Throughout the deposition. Maxwell took virtually every opportunity she could to call'. a
liar and to accuse both and her attorneys of feeding "vicious lies" to the press. e
denied any awareness that any minors other than ever massaged Epstein, and she denied
any knowledge of any sexual contact between Epstein and any minors. She also denied knowing
that Epstein engaged in sexual activity durin the course of massages. Maxwell admitted during
herd eposition to meeting both and but denied any awareness that
Epstein had sexual contact with t em. S e claim not to reca 1 age and claimed that
she only saw at Epstein's Palm Beach residence and that was with her mother on
all of those visits. Maxwell also claimed that she had never given anyone. including Epstein, a
massage, though she admitted to showing people where "pressure points" are located on a hand
and foot. She denied ever showing anyone how to massage Epstein. She also denied ever
having sexual contact with -
60It is true that the flight lo s for Epstein's private jet do not show Maxwell flying on his plane
to New Mexico in ; however, it is still possible that Maxwell took a commercial
flight to New Mexico. Given e passage of time, it has not been possible to obtain records of
such travel.
In any event, Maxwell admitted during her 2016 deposition that she met at
Epstein's New Mexico residence. Although that admission does not inc. te, s e has
admitted under oath to meeting
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
On July 18, 2019, we gave a reverse proffer to Leslie Groff, during which we explained
that numerous victims had indicated that she was responsible for scheduling massages during
which they were sexually abused. We encouraged Groff to meet with us for a proffer so that she
could share her story and explain her role. Subsequently, on August 7, 2019, we had a phone
call with Groff's attorney during which he indicated that he would not bring Groff in for a
proffer and had advised her to invoke her Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination
if she is subpoenaed to testify. In recent weeks, we have reached back out to Groff's attorney to
convey that we will not be able to provide her with any sort of agreement if she does not proffer
with us. He appeared to understand our position and is considering whether to bring Groff in for
a proffer.

c. Counsel for Jean Luc Brunel
In August and September of 2019, we had multiple phone calls with an attorney for Jean
Luc Brunel. On our last call, the attorney indicated that Brunel was not willing to meet with us
for a proffer and would invoke his Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination if
subpoenaed to testify in the grand jury.
d. Counsel for Leslie Wexner
On July 25, 2019, counsel for Wexner provided us with an attorney proffer. Wexner is
the billionaire founder and CEO of L Brands (formerly Limited Brands) corporation, which
controls Victoria's Secret, among other retail brands. It has been publicly reported that Wexner
and Epstein had a close relationship and that Epstein managed Wexner's finances from the 1990s
through the 2000s.
During our meeting, Wexner's attorneys indicated that Wexner had no knowledge of any
inappropriate or unlawful activity with young women by Epstein. The attorneys emphasized
Wexner's relationship with Epstein was more professional than social. The attorneys also
explained that over his years handling Wexner's finances, Epstein stole or otherwise
misappropriated several hundred million dollars from Wexner. That misconduct, together with
fees that Epstein paid himself for his services to Wexner, appears to account for virtually all of
Epstein's wealth.
Wexner first met Epstein in the 1980s through a mutual friend who recommended
Epstein as a financial adviser. After a couple other acquaintances recommended Epstein as well,
Wexner brought Epstein on to help with his investments. Over time, Epstein became more
involved in Wexner's finances until Epstein controlled all of Wexner's personal finances with
virtually no oversight. In 1991, Epstein obtained a power of attorney from Wexner, which
enabled Epstein to handle the purchase and sale of real estate and other assets on Wexner's
behalf. At some point in 1998, Epstein sold himself the New York residence in which he resided
until his arrest in 2019 at a deeply discounted price. The New York residence had previously
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
belonged to Wexner, but the Wexners had moved out of it in 1995. Epstein also sold himself a
private plane that previously belonged to Wexner at a deeply discounted price.
In the 1990s, Epstein told Wexner that he had other clients and that Wexner did not need
to pay Epstein because Epstein was having fun and they would settle up later. Epstein
introduced Wexner to a number of other people as his clients, and Wexner interacted with other
prominent people who knew Epstein, such as Prince Andrew, professors at Harvard, and a sultan
in Dubai. Epstein had no formal role in L Brands or Victoria's Secret. At some point, Wexner
heard a rumor that Epstein might be holding himself out as connected to Victoria's Secret, but
when Wexner asked Epstein about it, Epstein denied doing so.
Epstein handled Wexner's personal business affairs until 2007, when Wexner learned that
Epstein had stolen or otherwise misappropriated several hundred million dollars from Wexner.
Around that time, Epstein told Wexner that he was having legal problems involving an overly
aggressive police chief and some sort of massage. Epstein said he was being blackmailed and it
could get messy, so it would be best for Wexner's wife to take over the family finances. In
response, Wexner's wife looked into the state of their finances and discovered that Epstein had
misappropriated a significant amount of the family's funds. For example, Epstein frequently
bought property on behalf of the Wexners and then sold it to himself for a fraction of the cost.
The Wexners then decided to cut off Epstein. When confronted, Epstein tried to convince
Wexner's wife that she did not understand the financials and insisted that he had the Wexners'
best interests at heart. The Wexners did not want to bring unnecessary public attention to the
issue, so they withdrew the power of attorney, and hired counsel to negotiate a private settlement
with Epstein. As a result of those negotiations, Epstein agreed to return $100 million to the
Wexners, which he did in January of 2008. At that point, Wexner severed all ties with Epstein,
and he has not seen or spoken to Epstein since.
Wexner knows nothing about the claim from and explained that at the
time, Epstein owned a property adjacent to the Wexners about a half mile way from the
Wexners's property. The Wexners's security team is not aware of any inappropriate incident
taking place on the Wexners's property, and the Wexners first heard about
allegations from public reporting this year.

2. Search Warrants
In July and August 2019, we obtained and the FBI executed search warrants for Epstein's
residences in New York and the Virgin Islands. We subsequently obtained warrants to search all
electronic devices, drives, and discs seized from those residences. The FBI is continuing to
review the extraordinarily large amount of data contained on those devices and is working with
our filter team to complete a privilege review of that data. In addition, we have reviewed the
materials obtained during the Palm Beach Police Department's October 2005 search of Epstein's
Palm Beach residence.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Based on our review of these materials thus far, we have identified some victims who
appear in photographs maintained in Epstein's residences. Of particular note, we have identified
photographs of and at Epstein's residences. It bears noting that,
contrary to some news reports, these searches did not reveal any cameras in any of the bedrooms
or massage rooms.
3. Financial Records
Together with the FBI, we have reviewed a number of financial documents regarding
Epstein's, Maxwell's, and finances. We have also been in touch for
counsel representing JP Morgan, Deutsche Bank, and TD Bank, each of which have held
accounts related to Epstein or his associates.
Epstein held the bulk of his finances at JP Morgan from the early 2000s until 2013, when
he opened multiple accounts at Deutsche Bank and transferred his funds from JP Morgan to
Deutsche Bank. In 2019, Deutsche Bank closed Epstein's accounts, and his funds from those
accounts were primarily transferred to the Bank of Puerto Rico. Epstein's accounts appeared to
be exclusively for the purpose of holding his own money. His Deutsche Bank accounts included
checking accounts, money market accounts, and brokerage accounts for his charities, his
consulting company Southern Trust Company, Inc., and several trusts, most of which appear to
have been established to handle payments for Epstein's various expenses in connection with his
properties and planes. We have not identified any accounts that are consistent with Epstein
handling or investing other people's money.
Additionally, in the fall of 2019, counsel for TD Bank reached out and informed us that
several individuals and entities associated with Epstein held accounts at TD Bank, including
accounts held by Epstein was not a signatory on any of the accounts, and TD Bank
is in the process of closing all of the accounts.
On September 12, 2019, we met for several hours with counsel for Deutsche Bank, which
held the majority of Epstein's finances from 2013 through 2019. Their presentation was
extremely thorough, including a 50-page summary of their analysis. The presentation broke
down Epstein's finances into a number of useful categories, including listing various types of
transactions by type and recipient. At a high level, there was no immediate indication of
financial criminal activity or misconduct, including based on our analysis and the internal
investigation that continues to be in progress at Deutsche. Additionally, as referenced above,
there do not appear to be any signs that Epstein was trading on behalf of any clients in Deutsche
accounts during the period when he was a client, between 2013 and 2019.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
We are continuing to receive additional documents from JP Morgan.61 and the FBI is
continuing to review financial records for any evidence of potential misconduct or potential
obstruction.

4. Additional Document Review
Finally, as we have met with new witnesses, we have re-evaluated documents and records
obtained pre-indictment for any corroborating information of new victim accounts. In particular,
we have found numerous message pads featuring the names of victims who have spoken with us,
which were found either in trash pulls or during the search of Epstein's Palm Beach residence
during the 2005 Florida investigation. Additionally, we have identified some flight logs within
the records obtained from one of Epstein's pilots that reflect instances during which certain
victims flew on Epstein's private jet.
III. Legal Landscape
We have considered the applicability of three different criminal charges to the conduct
revealed during the course of our investigation. This section walks through the elements and
basic contours of each statute and summarizes the applicable statutes of limitations.

A. Sex Trafficking of Minors
In the original Indictment, we charged Epstein with sex trafficking of minors, in violation
of Title 18, United States Code, Section 1591. This statute has the following elements:

(1) That the defendant knowingly recruited, enticed, harbored, transported, provided, or
obtained by any means a person, or aided and abetted the same;

(2) In or affecting commerce:
(3) Knowing the fact that the victim had not yet attained the age of 18 years old;

(4) Knowing the victim would be caused to engage in a commercial sex act; and
(5) That venue is proper in the Southern District of New York.
61 These productions include messages exchanged between Jes Staley and Epstein around the
period when recalled being d by Staley during e at Epstein's New
York residence.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
I•1
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)

B. Transportation of Minors
Title 18, United States Code, Section 2423 makes it a crime to transport minors with the
intent to engage in criminal sexual activity. That crime has the following elements:

(I) That the defendant knowingly transported a victim, or aided and abetted the same;
(2) Across state lines;

(3) At the time of the transportation, the victim was less than 18 years old;
(4) The defendant transported the victim with the intent that the victim engage in "sexual
activity for which any person can be charged with a criminal offense;" and

(5) That venue is proper in the Southern District of New York.
Title 18, United States Code, Section 2423(a) provides:
A person who knowingly transports any individual under the age of 18 years in
interstate or foreign commerce, or in any Territory or Possession of the United
States, with intent that such individual engage in prostitution, or in any sexual
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
activity for which any person can be charged with a criminal offense, shall be
fined under this title or imprisoned not more than ten years, or both.
"To secure a conviction under § 2423(a), the government ... must prove beyond a reasonable
doubt that the defendant: (1) knowingly transported a minor across state lines and (2) with the
intent that the minor engage in sexual activity for which some person could be criminally
charged." United States v. Vargas-Cordon, 733 F.3d 366, 375 (2d Cir. 2013).
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)

C. Enticement of Minors
We have also considered Title IS, United States Code, Section 2422(b), which makes it a
crime to entice a minor to engage in illegal sexual activity. The enticement statute was enacted
in February 1996, and the version of the statute in effect at that time provided: "Whoever, using
any facility or means of interstate or foreign commerce, including the mail, or within the special
maritime and territorial jurisdiction of the United States, knowingly persuades, induces, entices,
or coerces any individual who has not attained the age of 18 years to engage in prostitution or
any sexual act for which any person may be criminally prosecuted, or attempts to do so, shall be
fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 10 years, or both."
To prove a violation of the enticement statute, the Government must prove four elements:
"that an individual (i) used a facility of interstate commerce; (ii) to knowingly persuade, induce
or entice, or to attempt to persuade, induce or entice; (iii) any individual who is younger than
eighteen-years old; (iv) to engage in sexual activity of a criminal nature." United States v.
Brand, 467 F.3d 179, 201-02 (2d Cir. 2006).

D. Statute of Limitations
The conduct revealed during our investigation spanned from approximately 1994 through
approximately 2005.
" As discussed below, we anticipate recommending transportation of minors charges against
Maxwell and will prepare a separate prosecution memorandum regarding those charges. That
prosecution memo will detail the applicable state statutes for the conduct relevant to the
proposed charges against Maxwell.
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)

IV. Analysis
In light of the evidence gathered during our investigation, as well as the  tools
available, in this section, we evaluate whether there is sufficient evidence to charge
69 The term "sexual abuse" is defined as including "the employment, use, persuasion,
inducement, or coercion of a child to engage in, or assist or another person to engage in, sexually
explicit conduct or the rape. molestation, prostitution, or other form of sexual exploitation of
children, or incest with children." 18 U.S.C. § 3509(8). The term "sexually explicit conduct"
means "actual or simulated (A) sexual intercourse [. ..] (C) masturbation: [or] (D) lascivious
exhibition of the genitals or pubic area of a person[.]"
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK' PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
Leslie Groff and/or Ghislaine Maxwell with a federal crime
and, if so. whether such charges would be in the interests of justice.
A.

I. Evidence That Conspired to Sex Traffic Minors
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)

a. Knowledge of Sex Acts
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)

b. Knowledge of Age
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)

B. •
=_00022544
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
PRIVILEGED - ATTORNEY WORK PRODUCT/DELIBERATIVE PROCESS
CONFIDENTIAL - SUBJECT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e)
D. Leslie Groff
E. Ghislaine Maxwell
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Kash Patel [trump] FBI Director, former employee of Chinese crypto money laundering cult Falun Gong 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00173333 (Jmail)
 [article] article about destruction of evidence at FBI
(inferred timestamp: 2025-02-27 15:28:00)
FBI withheld `thousands of pages' of  Jeffrey Epstein docs, Pam Bondi says —
and she's demanding they be turned over

By Josh Christenson
Published Feb. 27, 2025, 3:28 p.m. ET

WASHINGTONAttorney General Pam Bondi revealed Thursday that "thousands of
pages" of documents in the FBI's investigation into the sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein
were withheld from her.

And she's demanding that they be turned over by Friday morning.
Bondi 59 disclosed in a letter to FBI Director Kash Patel a tipster said that all but
"approximately 200 pages of documents" were still being kept secret at the FBI's office
in New York — despite her repeated requests for the "full" Epstein files.

Attorney General Pam Bondi revealed that the New York FBI office withheld thousands
of pages in documents about the Jeffrey Epstein investigation from her.
AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana
The initial batch included flight logs, phone numbers and the names of victims, but a
source in the FBI's New York office reached out and said that hundreds additional
documents were not included.
AdChoices [I=.
The video player is currently playing an ad. You can skip the ad in 5 sec with a mouse or
keyboard
"By 8:00 a.m. tomorrow, February 28, the FBI will deliver the full and complete Epstein
files to my office, including all records, documents, audio and video recordings, and
materials related to Jeffrey Epstein and his clients, regardless of how such information
was obtained," Bondi said.
"There will be no withholdings or limitations to my or your access," she vowed to Patel.
Rep. Andy Ogles (R-Tenn.) has floated a bill to prevent non-public records on Epstein
housed at the Department of Justice from being destroyed, according to a copy of a
letter obtained by The Post.
7
Bondi said in a letter to FBI Director Kash Patel that all but 200 documents on Epstein
are being kept in secret files in New York.
REUTERS
7
The Jacob K. Javits Federal Building in Manhattan — where Bondi claims additional
Epstein documents are being kept.
SeanPavonePhoto — stock.adobe.com
Ogles, 53, wrote to Bondi on Wednesday, announcing that he was "drafting legislation
entitle the Preventing Epstein Documentation Obliteration Act, or the PEDO Act"
following "reports that certain FBI agents are allegedly attempting to destroy critical
records."
"Should you encounter any statutory barriers to the expeditious public release of Jeffrey
Epstein's client list or other pertinent information related to his activities — to include
circumstances in which any such documentation is housed in other federal agencies -
I stand ready to assist," he said.
"Our constituents deserve nothing less than radical transparency in matters implicating
the integrity of our justice system," he added in the missive, which was first reported by
Fox News.
7
Rep. Andy Ogles (R-Tenn.) has floated a bill to prevent non-public records on sex
trafficker Jeffrey Epstein housed at the Department of Justice from being destroyed,
according to a copy of a letter obtained by The Post.
CQ-Roll Call, Inc via Getty Images
A former FBI special agent had suggested the Epstein files could be among documents
during a recent interview on the conservative influencer Benny Johnson's podcast.
"There are FBI servers," said ex-agent-turned-whistleblower Garret O'Boyle "and
people inside the FBI have been working night and day to destroy files on these
servers."
"No idea on what it is — I can only speculate — but you mentioned the Epstein list," he
added. "I'd imagine it's cases like that."
The FBI currently has hundreds of Epstein files available to the public on its website, but
The Post previously scooped that the Justice Department was preparing to release 100
pages of the notorious criminal's personal address book on Thursday, according to a
source who reviewed the files.
7
The DOJ is preparing the release Epstein's pesonal address book.
Patrick McMullan via Getty Images
Bondi had hinted on Fox News "Jesse Wafters Primetime" that the DOJ was going to
release "some Epstein information," while adding the fact that details of the financier's
abuse of more than 250 victims "will make you sick."
Conservative influencers were received at the White House and presented with "Phase
1" of the Epstein files release, emerging from the West Wing Thursday afternoon to
brandish the binders at the press without immediately disclosing any details.
The Mon Transparent filminS-- at t.
stestator of Or, ,
Ihnsald r !pop
The Justice Department is releasing 100 pages of Epstein's personal address book on
Thursday, according to a source who reviewed the files.
AFP via Getty Images
Ogles in his letter to Bondi also claimed a "decades-long obfuscation campaign" had
withheld full details on investigations into the assassinations of President John F.
Kennedy, Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy.
The effect of that "has clearly marginalized trust in our institutions and has contributed
to all sorts of alternative theories and motivations regarding the deaths of these men,"
he said.
Another Tennessee lawmaker has also pushed for the full release of the Epstein files.
7
Conservative influencers were received at the White House and presented with "Phase
1" of the Epstein files release.
REUTERS
"For years, my efforts to crack the Epstein trafficking ring wide open have been
stonewalled by Democrats at every turn," Sen. Marsha Blackburn (R-Tenn.) posted
Monday on X.
"This will change under [FBI Director Kash Patel]. I just sent him a letter asking for the
complete & unredacted Epstein files."
476
What do you think? Post a comment.
In his confirmation hearing, Patel committed to Blackburn that he would "do everything"
to reveal the "full weight" of "what happened" in Epstein's child sex trafficking ring.
The FBI did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
EFTA00129637 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about return of property / case closed / transfer files
(inferred timestamp: 2025-03-05 03:25:00)
72-MM-113327 Serial 62
FD-1057 (12cv. 5-8-10)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Electronic Communication
Title: (U) Closing EC
From: MIAMI
MM-PB2
Contact:
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 72-MM-113327
Date: 12/20/2012

(U) RODRIGUEZ, ALFREDO - SEE SUB
Synopsis: (U) Request captioned case be closed.
Full Investigation Initiated: 10/28/2009
Details:
Request captioned case be closed. The defendant/subject in this case
has been sentenced and all prosecutorial matters have been resolved.
Request case be closed.
.•
72-MM-113327 Serial 63
FD-1057 (12cv. 5-8-10)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Electronic Communication
Title: (U) EC return of property to Alfredo Date: 06/17/2013
Rodriguez
From: MIAMI
MM-PB2
Contact:
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 72-MM-113327 (U) RODRIGUEZ, ALFREDO - SEE SUB
Synopsis: (U) Document return of property to ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ.
Full Investigation Initiated: 10/28/2009
Enclosure(s): Enclosed are the following items:

1. (U) FD 597 return of property to ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ.
Details:
Document return of property to ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ.
••
FD -597 (Rev 8-11-94) Page V of
File #
On (date)
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Receipt for Property Received/Returned/Released/Seized
- AP - 37x7
(Name)
(Street Address)
(City)
item(s) listed below were:

• Received From
• Returned To
AReleased To
Seized
Description of Item(s):D  A lir60/0 AOCIfi c, Ut SOC/G/ Se6lAn"11
AStAilf 4// . 6P1 C-C•rd /hOdd flak . ex-
p Di- A birch A tis utt e7a C2-
rT)pGet C39O I re. /001700,--1 41
Received By: Received From:
igna ure (Signature)
72-MM-113327 Serial 64
FD-1057 (Rcv. 5-8-10) UNCLASSIFIED
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Electronic Communication
Title: (U) Transfer of case files Date: 03/07/2025
From: MIAMI
Contact:
Approved By: A/SSA
Drafted By:
Case ID *: 72-MM-I13327 (U) RODRIGUEZ, ALFREDO - SEE SUB
Synopsis: (U) To document the transfer of case files
Enclosure(s): Enclosed are the following items:

1. (U) Itemized list of files
2. (U) FEDEX Tracking
Details:
The purpose of this electronic communication is to document the transfer
of case files in the captioned investigation, to include IA files. On
3/4/2025, the items were shipped via Fedex to the Washington Field Office
Evidence room. The following are attached to this document digitally in
the IA section:
1. Itemized list of contents
2. Fedex tracking receipt
••
The Below is a list of the content sent Via FedEx, tracking #
Items are listed per titles solely on original folders in box.
Main Case File Vol #1
RA sub File Vol #1 contain 2 1As in the back
0
Red Wallet #1 containing: CD and large folder labeled: 72-MM -113327 Phone Records, Virgin
Island

• Red wallet #2 containing: 6 lose disk: 3 labeled Disk 2 and 3 labeled disk 4, In addition to 2 white
disks in one envelope and stick
Red Wallet #3 Contain:

• Loose Document File with sticky labeled Disco Conf: Stolen Globe on Disco "Original"
Manila Folders Labeled:
C• Cell data
Phone subscriber info

• 72-MM-113327 and Alfredo Rodriguez PPI
:• Order to seal documents
:• Plea agreement
• Loose court doc

• Written/ Email correspondence
• Alfredo Rodrigues (Court documents)
• Jail Property Receipts
• FD-302

• Phonebook/ handwritten Docs
• Red Wallet #4 Label 72-MM -13327 Alfredo Rodriguez; Epstein Pone book Documents, DL,
Reports Photos, Contain:
Manila Folders labeled

• Epstein Phone Book
❖ FL Photos
:• Epstein phone book Docs
• Epstein phone book Docs
• Epstein phone book Docs
> Open top Red Wallet #5: Folder labeled Miscellaneous for both cases 31E-MM -113327 and 72-
MM -113327 containing:
Manila Folders Labeled

• Magazines page and articles
• Steven Hoffenberg/ BOP records etc.
+ Phonebook working records
• New Orleans Docs
+ Non-Prosecution agreement

• Australia /Travel Documents
• Breakers Condos
•
•
• Photo Arrayaia
+ Rodriguez & Epstein/ Robert Courtier,

• Subpoenas/Invoice
• Leslie Wexner
• Delray beach PD Reports NCIC Missing Person
• Miles & Cathy Alexander

• Eppinger and on file list 245H-MM -88743
•
• Baleen Sweep — Disk issues
• / Aviation photos
+ MC2 Models/ Sergio Cordero Khalid Monroe

• Julian Barbosa
• Email/Brad Edwards & Mike Fisten
• David Kelmanson
• 2 Steno Note book
> Red wallet #6 Containing
❖ CCPR /AT&T / Virgin Island

• Disk
:4- Red Wallet #7 Red wallet: Labeled Phone records/ Subpoena Returns Florida numbers
Manila Folders labeled

• Subpoenas Faxed
+ Epstein Phone Numbers
+ AT& tolls
• USA Mobility
• Phone book isce aneous
• Verizon GTE CA

• Vitel Comm
Pacific Bell
C.. Sprint Spectrum
Phone records/Subpoena Returns; 72-MM-113327 Florida numbers
Manila Folders Labeled:
Cellco Partnership/DBA Verizon
Red Wallet # 8
Manila Folders Labeled

• Loose Plea agreement
4- Consent to Search
<• Advice of rights
Tuesday, 3/4/25 2:25 PM Shipment information sent to FedEx
6:09 PM Picked up RIVIERA BEACH, FL
6:10PM Shipment arriving On-Time RIVIERA BEACH, FL
8:12 PM Left FedEx origin facility RIVIERA BEACH, FL
11:49 PM Arrived at FedEx hub MEMPHIS, TN
Wednesday, 3/5/25 3:25 AM Departed FedEx hub MEMPHIS, TN
6:03 AM At destination sort facility DULLES. VA
8:10AM At local FedEx facility WASHINGTON. DC
8:17AM Ready for recipient pickup WASHINGTON, DC
Package available for pickup at: 1501 ECKINGTON PLACE
NORTHEAST
8:17 AM Delivery exception WASHINGTON, DC
Rerouted to revised delivery address
EFTA00163964 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ summary of Epstein and Maxwell Related Investigations
(inferred date: 2025-03-12)
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Epstein and Maxwell Related Investigations
Summaries provided from Case Indexes email from NY sent on March 12, 2025
Case Number Case Summary
50D-NY-3027571 Child Sex Trafficking investigation into
Epstein, opened 12/06/2018. Epstein was
indicted on 07/02/2019 and arrested on
07/06/2019. On 08/10/2019, FBI NY was
notified Epstein committed suicide in his
jail cell. Maxwell was indicted on
06/29/2020 and arrested on 07/02/2020.
The Maxwell trial began on 11/28/2021.
Maxwell was convicted on 12/29/2021 on
5 out of 6 counts. Maxwell was sentenced
on 06/28/2022 to 20 years. In November
2024, the U.S. appeals court rejected
Maxwell's request for en banc review.
This investigation remains in Pending
Inactive status.
72-MM-113327 Obstruction of justice case with subject
, a former employee of
Epstein, opened 10/28/2009 b FBI
Miami Palm Beach RA. was
arrested for obstruction on 12/08/2009,
convicted, and sentenced in 2010. This
investigation was closed on 03/13/2013.
The 1B items have been incorporated into
the 50D case with new 1B numbers. The
1As were sent to NY in 2019 and were
housed in a physical format until we sent
them to WFO. One box containing the 72-
MM physical case file was located at FBI
Miami Palm Beach RA and coordinated
for transport to WFO on 03/03/2025. The
item of evidentiary use out of the 72-MM
case was the black contact book.
31E-MM-108062 Child Prostitution case against Epstein
brought by Palm Beach County Police
Department (PBPD), opened 07/25/2006
by FBI Miami Palm Beach RA, resulting in
a guilty plea in State Court. This case has
remained in Pending Inactive status since
07/25/2017 and case materials have
been preserved for a civil litigation hold.
The 1B items have been incorporated into
the 50D case with new 18 numbers. The
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
remaining 31E-MM file was sent to NY in
2019 in boxes and was housed both in a
physical and digital format (DVDs), until
we sent it to WFO.
90A-NY-3151227 FBI-NYO opened case 90A-NY-3151227,
a death investigation case on 08/12/2019
after JEFFERY EPSTEIN was discovered
unresponsive in his jail cell at MCC on
08/10/2019. Two Correctional Officers
were indicted for false records and
conspiracy and subsequently self-
surrendered to the FBI on 11/19/2019. In
May 2021, SDNY entered a deferred
prosecution agreement with the two
Correctional Officers for a period of 6
months and the terms were satisfied.
Closed in December 2022.
90C-NY-3154599 On 8/17/2019, the FBI opened an
investigation into contraband being
brought into Metropolitan Correctional
Center. Epstein was referenced in this
case. Case closed in October 2023.
9A-NY-3144791 Threats against victim of Epstein were
anonymously posted online. The case
was opened on 7/26/2019 and closed on
5/12/2020. Attempts to make contact with
the individual who posted the threats
were unanswered.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Search Terms
50D-NY-3027571
72-MM-113327
31E-MM-108062
90A-NY-3151227
90C-NY-3154599
9A-NY-3144791
Jeffrey Epstein
Epstein
Jeffrey Edward Epstein
Jeffrey E Epstein
Jefferey Epstein
Jeffrey Epstein Island
Epstein Island
(passport)
(SSN)
Ghislaine Maxwell
Ghislaine
Maxwell
(SSN)
David Rodgers (pilot and employee for over 25 years)
Epstein's private jet
Epstein's helicopter
Epstein's flight logs
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Opening ECs Case Agent
Case Number Case Opening SA and SSA
50D-NY-3027571
72-MM-113327
31E-MM-108062
90A-NY-3151227
90C-NY-3154599
9A-NY-3144791
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
EFTA01649103 (Jmail)
 [government] "MCC Corruption Case" is about guards on duty when Epstein died
(timestamp: 2025-03-17 22:33:37)
Date: Mon, 17 Mar 2025 22:33:37 +0000
Importance: Normal
50D-NY-3027571- the main Epstein case file.
31E-MM-108062- Miami Epstein Investigative file.
90A-NY-3151227- Epstein death investigation
90C-NY-3154599- Possible- MCC corruption case.
EFTA00161465 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about evidence inventory including, see quote: "List of Absent Items"
(date: 2025-03-25)
FD-597 (Rev. 06/26/2023) Page  I
UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Receipt for Property
Case ID: 50D-NY-3027571
on (date) 03/25/2025 item (s) listed below were:
❑ Collected/Seized
❑ Received From
❑ Returned To
p Released To
(Name) Coreen Mao
(Street Address) 950 Pennsylvania Avenue NW
(City) Washington, D.C.
Description of Item (s):

I. Inventory Sheet w/ page counts and red lines showing classified material (x2)
2. Epstein Transparency Project — Classified Material

3. Epstein Redactions Final Page Count
4. Epstein Transparency Project — Sample
a. 050D-NY-3027571 - Serials 1.26 (213 see-through pages)

5. Thumb drives (x2)
6. CDs w/ classified material (x2)
7. Flagged items — 31E
8. Flagged items — 50D
9. Adobe Redaction Guide — Sealing Final Redactions

10. Adobe Redaction Guide — Adding/Editing See-Through
II. How to Redact a PDF in 7 steps
12. Epstein IA Media Out Part I of 2 and Part 2 of 2 contains possible CSAM (2 Samsung drives)

13. ID Evidence for 50D-NY-3027571 (I D 1-1D6) and 31E-MM -I08062 (I DI) with cover sheet (4 CDs total)
14. Photographs of I B evidence for SOD-NY-3027571 and 31E-MM -I08062 (1 CD)
I5. Memorandum for the Attorney General and the Deputy Attorney General

16. List of Absent Items
Received By:
Printed Name/ Title:
Received From:
(Signature) (Signature)
Printed NamefFitle: !Darren Cox  / Acting Assistant Director
EFTA00004105 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2025-03-29)
05- (02_,/-
4' 0-0

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ O5- 7024          │
│ A Qo              │
│                   │
│ Mic. Photos       │
│                   │
│ C sees            │
╰───────────────────╯

II

╭──── Page 3, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

i
nolelPittat ORLANDO. FL 32440
>rOrrY l,*
‘TYIF NO. 310
Pi14: 171 4: !.-3):
ri ‘tThIA
ea.
I 5a. !''-rflass„
tte--
\ nTh fi
rang -
-
I♦ wwww••••••

• ..sessin
i :MS1INIreisrvpuilicorplos
'‘....- — 1
r
■
r.. 1
_rabba.  _

╭──── Page 10, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

i
r-

╭──── Page 14, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

I

╭──── Page 17, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 18, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 20, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭─ Page 22, Image 1 ─╮
│ ~<4 =~             │
│ 76 Dc YOOO         │
╰────────────────────╯

-
.

╭──── Page 29, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

r
_
S
I
i
,-
i
; , • 4 - •
1.-
n'ttelIVZ, lid-. 7

• 10".
i
I.-

╭──── Page 37, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

-

╭──── Page 38, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

is
ilOPO6 -grieNg;
_ 4

• S.

╭──── Page 40, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

S

╭──── Page 41, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

1
r
•

╭──── Page 46, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 47, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 48, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

4;fait i&itilt

╭──── Page 49, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

A
CSAM
NOT
SCANNED
33 ,,,,•t-5

╭──────────────────── Page 52, Image 1 ────────────────────╮
│ CSAM                                                     │
│ NOT                                                      │
│ SCANNED                                                  │
│                                                          │
│ 33 images                                                │
│                                                          │
│ Official DocLab Instruction(s) — Revised March 10", 2025 │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA02711825 (Jmail)
 [article] Techonomy (???) article titled "Artificial Intelligence Ignites in Ethiopia"
(inferred date: 2025-03-29)
Artificial Intelligence Ignites in Ethiopia
B
Ethiopia has come a long way from its nightmare past of famine and war. Today it's well known that it has one of
the highest GDP's in Africa. is Africa's largest recipient of developmental aid and the 3'd largest recipient of
foreign investment. Little is known however about the computer science thriving from its capital, Addis Ababa.
and of course nothing of the fact that its artificial intelligence is on fire.

The foundation for artificial intelligence (Al) in bandwidth-barren Ethiopia comes not so much commercial growth
where less than 2% have access to the Internet, but from the despotic government's fervent development of higher
education, makeshift emblems to support its massive multi-billion dollar industrial plans. Today, there arc over 30
official universities and 130 or so polytechnics or institutes, most of them emphasizing technology. Many of them
are in the capital. and in 2012, the Ministry of Science and Technology established its own university resulting in
two major science and tech universities in and near Addis Ababa. Behind all the tech glitz however and the
government's plans for a S250 million dollar tech park in Addis Ababa. only 34% of Ethiopian children enroll into
the equivalent of 9th grade according to world indexes, early adult literacy is approximately 35%. child labor at
27%, girl marriage at an appalling 41%, and the country still ranks near the bottom of the UNDP's World Index
for quality of life. But in the capital, education rates are warpedly improved and with 70% of the population under
the age of 29, what's emerging is an urban sub-culture of keen young, English speaking software engineers with
few private sector opportunities but to program for the outside world. And program they do at a fraction of the cost:
today, the Ministry of Trade and Industry 'affirms' more than 700 licensed companies in computer technology and
95 software businesses serving customers worldwide.
At the hub of this tech growth is an Al group, called iCog Labs co-founded in 2012 by a young Ethiopian
roboticist, Getnet Assefa Gezaw, and a Californian AI pioneer from Hong Kong called Ben Goertzel. With a team
of • Ethiopian software engineers, iCog practices full on 'Strong Intelligence', the belief that computers
can potentially simulate the human brain, not just aspects of it. The resolute lab has a bold mission: to create
software that not only simulates the brain, but pushes the envelope of what the brain can do. The lab also focuses
on a host of practical applications such as SLAM mapping: mobile robots that construct maps of unknown
environments based on its experiences in its physical environment. (useful for mineral exploration or agricultural
optimization). iCog also delves into 'deep learning' algorithms for vision processing and object recognition (used
in drones, satellites or security systems), machine learning data algorithms to predict patterns in everything from
agriculture to electricity consumption: and algorithms that react to English and a host of African languages.
iCog is self-supporting, with projects around the world including, Al-driven automated pill dispensers and elderly-
care products for Telehealth, a Chinese company, humanoid robotics for Hanson Robotics, makers of the famous
Robot Einstein and other lifelike humanoid robots, mapping the genomics of longevity for two California
corporations and machine learning algorithms to optimize production of the sweetener, Stevia, for Stevia First in
California. iCog's humanitarian work includes making AI teaching tablets for children—distributed to
villages—with games teaching coding, mathematics and English. The effort builds on One Laptop per Child's
program which has given thousands of rural Ethiopian children tablets to write computer programs in the language
Squeak. iCog is soon expanding to a second branch in Hawassa. a smaller city near the capital and has
collaborated with Addis Ababa Institute of Technology to form the first post-doctorate Al program in the country.
Finally, iCog is a major contributor to the OpenCog foundation, the =open -source AI programming provider
in the world and founded by Goenzel in Hong Kong. Open source means they share coding with Al developers
worldwide and particularly to advance labs across Ethiopia.

Other labs are laying a foundation for AI developers to work in their native Amharic language. EthioCloud,
created the first advanced Amharic code programming language which runs on Microsoft's all-purpose .NET and
C# platforms. The company also offers the first standard optical character recognition program to convert Amharic
paper documents into editable text and the first Amharic text-to-speech conversion software.
Fast on their heels, the Ethiopian government is rabidly eager to put robotics and advanced algorithmic
intelligence into its mega-industrial projects, pan of its massive, Big Brother sounding, 5 year Growth and
Transformation Plan (morphing now into the Vision 2025 plan). Its motivations range from likely megalomania to
maintaining the multi-billion dollar flood of foreign investment which it relies on to stay in power. And given that
it can't keep leasing out its land to foreigners, and that it sits on a goldmine of minerals and clean energy potential
from geothermal to hydraulics, it is zealously enticing the most sophisticated technology partnerships from
countries like China, India and Saudi Arabia to become a major honcho exporter (the 2nd biggest after South Africa
according World Bank estimates). Current AI ventures and supporting infrastructure projects include a $1.4 billion
mobile phone deal for Ethiotelecom to install network quality assessing robots in moving vehicles for mobile calls,
advanced Chinese-built QoS (quality of service) ambient intelligence into the communication networks for its
massive $4 billion electric Light Rail project. the largest in East Africa, US/French machine-learning self-
diagnostic intelligence software into the power grids to support the Blue Nile's S5 billion Grand Renaissance Dam,
the largest hydroelectric power plant in Africa (which will also have its own tech park), cement loading robots and
quality assessment robot technology for Dangote Cement, the largest cement plant in East Africa, self-diagnostic
intelligence into the electric grids for the Ashegoda Wind Farm, the largest wind farm in Africa and self-
diagnostic intelligence into the smart grids serviced by Ethiopian Electric Power Corporation.

The stage is also ripe for Al to be put into many more of its mammoth projects, including a S4 billion US-Icelandic
geothermal plant, one of the world's largest, two deep space telescope observatories coupled with multi-billion
dollar satellite plans, integration of intelligence into its own fleet of locally manufactured drones and factory
robotics into a rapidly growing $10 billion dollar industrial tax free zone, primarily for the Chinese to outsourcc
their own labor from $30 a day per worker in China to $1 per day in Ethiopia.

Technological leapfrogging is a term that is proudly buzzing around the ministries and tech community of Addis
Ababa. not to mention Africa: the notion that technology in developing nations can bypass the bureaucracy of older
systems. The concept is hugely attractive but if basic human conditions such as nutrition, health, education.
representation, labor rights, private sector GDP growth, which is the 6th lowest in the world, forced mass relocation
of entire communities, with little to no compensation, due to Big Brother's mega-plans; if these don't improve at
equally considerable rates, then all this artificial intelligent leapfrogging, all this high-tech, motherboard
economics, will seem just well, artificial, colonial and circuitry hubris.

Ethiopia nevertheless has a rich history of pioneers. It is the estimated birthplace of Homo sapiens, Africa's oldest
independent country, perhaps the oldest in the world, the cradle of culturally advanced, fiercely independent
kingdoms, dating to the 8ib century BC, one of first 24 members of the United Nations, the first African country to
join the League of Nations, the protector of some of the most important heritage sites and a multitude of record
breaking scientists, Olympians and marathoners. If the Ethiopian people can progressively claim their country, it
might be fitting for them to carry the torch again for mankind: from homo sapien to homo cyborg and beyond.
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Secure Technologies Exploitation Unit aka STXU [government] password crackers 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00172473 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about executive summary of Epstein cases
(approximate date: 2025-05-01)
Executive Summary

FBI New York provided to Headquarters and DOJ all material in the Epstein investigation and reviewed evidentiary
items as requested.

IMD worked with CID and NY agents to confirm completeness of the file inventory at the onset of the project,
identifying any potentially missing' serials or documents and processing those serials/documents throughout the
review process.

All physical paper and physical 1A media, delivered to IMD for scanning and processing, as well as all Sentinel
documents associated with the six Epstein cases identified was downloaded by IMD to SSD external drives, and
provided to CID for delivery to DOJ. IMD redacted all pages, digitalized physical copies as well as Sentinel
documents, consistent with direction provided by DOJ.

Prior to exporting materials for DOJ delivery, IMD, CID, and NY verified that all documents were present, and no
pages were inadvertently removed from IMD's digital inventory prior to it being downloaded to a thumb drive and
provided to BD and CID on 3/25/25.

I. Cases
FBI New York advised there were six Epstein-related case files:
• 50D-NY-3027571*
• 72-MM-113327
• 31E-MM-108062*
• 90A-NY-3151227
• 90C-NY-3154599
• 9A-NY-3144791
*Based on the direction provided in DM scoping guidance, cases SOD-NY-3027571 and 37E-MM-108062 were
the focuses of the Epstein Transparency Project.
II. Efforts to Identify Case Materials
Request for Collection Overview
On 2/27/2025, at approximately 9:00 a.m., FBI NY squad C-20 received a request to send all evidence and
documents related to Epstein in C-20's possession to Washington, DC by 8:00 a.m. the following day. FBI NY
confirmed the serials in Sentinel were accurate, coordinated with Evidence Control to prepare chains of
custody, and loaded physical items for shipment. On 2/28/2025, at approximately 7:45 a.m., C-20 delivered
these items to DOJ with chains of custody ready for turn-over. The shipment included 84 digital items, 70
general items, 2 valuables, 2 ELSUR items, 3 red wells, and one disc containing all three Sentinel case files (50D-
NY-3027571, 72-MM-113327, 31E-MM-108062).
On 2/28/2024, FBI NY squad C-19 received a request to send all evidence and documents related to 90A-NY-
3151227 in C-19's possession to Washington, DC. On 3/3/2025, C-19 delivered these items to FBI WFO at
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO 1
Epstein Overview: FBI Response
approximately 7:30 a.m. Discs containing the following Sentinel case files were also provided: 90A-NY-3151227,
9A-NY-3144791, 90C-NY-3154599, and 282B-NY-3156749.
Digital Queries
C-20 conducted Sentinel and Guardian searches (i.e. NY searched Sentinel with keyword "Epstein"). C-20
identified 50D-NY-3027571, 72-MM-113327, and 31E-MM-108062 responsive to this request.
C-20 coordinated with NY ECR, NY ELSUR, NY CART, NY ERT, NY CMP, and NY TTAs for all items related to
these cases being held with these units.
IMD conducted a search of the FBI's Central Records System (CRS) to ensure all materials within each
responsive case file (serials and sub-files) were accounted for. The CRS indices provide a listing of the related
main file and sub-file materials for each case file reflected above.
For additional fidelity to ensure all files were accounted for, IMD conducted an index search of the subject term
"Jeffrey Epstein" in Sentinel, ACS, and the Pre-UCFN' Manual Index Cards (NY, HQ and MM offices of origin) of
the CRS. The specific offices of origin searched correlated to the offices of the initial set of case files found at
the start of the project and was consistent with guidance provided by NY and CID.
Physical Search
C-20 physically searched squad area to include locked cabinets, desks, closets, meeting rooms, and anywhere
else documents/items may have been stored. All squad members, former case agents, and former SSA were
requested to search their workspace for any physical or digital documents/files responsive to this request. Hard
drives and network drives were also searched. An additional quality control search was conducted throughout
the squad area and one box of case items (non-evidentiary, to include several 1As containing interview notes
and photo logs, GJ material, and trial exhibits) was located on 2/28/2025 and delivered to WFO on 3/3/2025.
External Entities Notified
Miami field office and Palm Beach RA, including MM ECR and ELSUR, were contacted to locate all
documents/items responsive to this request and ship them to WFO.
OTD/STXU was contacted for 50D ELSUR items 1D2, 1D3, 1D4, and 1D6. A disc containing these items was sent
to WFO ELSUR.
SDNY and SDFL were contacted for any evidentiary items responsive to this request.
Pre-UCFN (Universal Case File Number) refers to case numbers used before the FBI switched to a UCFN system in the
1990$. These cases were kept in hard copy in the originating office and not maintained in ACS or Sentinel; however. IMD
maintains a copy of the indexing for pre-UCFN cases.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO 2
• • %,
• vit.r..? Epstein Overview: FBI Response
III. Timeline
FEBRUARY 2025
2/18/2025: Black book, flight logs, masseuse list
2/25/2025:
o Response to ODAG questions regarding black book, flight logs, masseuse list
o Response to Senator Blackburn letter to Director Patel regarding "recordings", included 50D case
evidence report
2/27/2025: Rescanned copy of 72-MM 1A9 and handwritten document
2/28/2025:
o Evidence and documents from 50D-NY-3027571, 72-MM-113327, and 31E-MM-108062; Disc
containing Sentinel case files (50D-NY-3027571, 72-MM-113327, and 31E-MM-108062)
o Epstein and Maxwell case background including government exhibit list
MARCH 2025
3/3/2025: Evidence and documents from 90A-NY-3151227; Discs containing Sentinel case files (90A-NY-
3151227, 9A-NY-3144791, 90C-NY-3154599, and 282B-NY-3156749)
3/4/2025:
o Response to request for any documents at a higher classification (50D serials 538, 539, 684)
o FBI suggestions for ODAG review of case files, including an exported list of all Epstein evidence/1A/1Cs
3/7/2025: Epstein evidence summary (SOD, 72, 31E, 90A, 90C, 282A)
3/11/2025: Evidence transport from WFO to IMD; NY onsite at IMD
3/12/2025:
o Redacted and Unredacted index of Epstein case files (50D, 72, 31E, 90A, 90C, 9A)
o Response to questions regarding CSAM, timeline production, video summary, digital evidence
summary, OTD status for electronic data upload, and clarifying Miami cases
o Epstein evidence photos from IMD/RIDS intake
o Summary of all Epstein cases to
3/14/2025: CID binders containing Epstein case information
3/16/2025:
o Daily sitrep for review of 1B136, 16144, 16145, 1B146 (continued through 4/1)
o 18136 Highly Confidential Responsive Material one-pager
o Redacted documents, 50D serials 1-240
3/18/2025: Victims lists (multiple)
3/19/2025:
o The following DOJ users were added to DCAP for review of 16136:
and Kashyap Patel.
o Residential Search Warrant affidavits from 50D case
o IMD extracted digital files from the non-evidentiary media (1A media items from 31E-MM-108062, 50D-
NY-3027571, 72-MM-113327, 90A-NY-3151227) and exported all contents to two SSDs (external
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO 3
for delivery to DOJ via CID. drives). A copy of the 1A media on SSD was provided to CID SC
DAD delivered to DOJ on the afternoon of 3/19/25.
3/21/2025:
o Review of all ELSUR (1Ds)
o List of all Agents/AUSAs that testified or names were made public regarding Epstein cases
3/22/2025: IMD, with assistance from HQ-based ITID personnel, provided victim' name-only redactions for all
six cases identified above. This victim-only guidance was consistent with initial processing guidance provided
by DOJ. ITID downloaded files and provided an SSD to DAD Totaling pages across all six cases
delivered: 116,792 pages.
3/23/2025: IMD provided direct to DOJ ( and all Epstein-related training materials
("Transparency Project Processing Guidance.pdf), developed by FBI based on DOJ's scoping guidance. This
training material was provided to all FBI personnel participating in the redaction project.
3/24/2025: Sentinel final discrepancy results
3/25/2025:
o 16 Epstein items to ODAG: FD-597 Release of Property signed by AAD

1. Inventory sheet with page counts and red lines showing classified material (x2)
2. Epstein Transparency Project - Classified Material

3. Epstein Redactions Final Page Count
4. Epstein Transparency Project — Sample
5. Thumb drives (x2)
6. CDs with classified materials (x2)

7. Flagged items — 31E
8. Flagged items — 50D
9. Adobe Redactions Guide — Sealing Final Redactions
10. Adobe Redactions Guide — Adding/Editing See-Through

11. How to Redact a PDF in 7 steps
12. Epstein 1A Media Out Part 1 of 2 and Part 2 of 2, contains possible CSAM (2 Samsung drives)

13. 1D Evidence for 50D-NY-3027571 (1D1-1D6) and 31E-MM-108062 (1D1) with cover sheet (4
CDs total)
14. Photographs of 16 evidence for 50D-NY-3027571 and 31E-MM-108062 (1 CD0
15. Memorandum for the Attorney General and the Deputy Attorney General

16. List of Absent Items
o IMD delivered to BD and CID SC four (4) thumb drives containing DOJ redaction
processing on cases 50D-NY-3027571 and 31E-MM-108062. Per instruction from DOJ on 03/22/25, DOJ
requested the scoping expand greater than victim names to include witnesses, law enforcement, AUSAs
(e.g., SDNY redaction list + SDFL list received), and focused efforts on the 50D (SDNY) and 31E (SDFL)
cases, excluding the Grand Jury (GJ) subfiles'. Total pages across the two requested cases delivered:
84,246 pages.
2 Total victim list = 1,114 names. The list included victims and victim families, per SDNY/SDFL.
3 GJ subfiles were excluded per DOJ scoping guidance, which stated Grand Jury Material, per statute, are exempt from 
public
disclosure. Therefore, IMD was instructed not to include al subfiles in the redaction project. Any al material present 
in other
parts of the investigative case were redacted in accordance with DOJ's scoping guidance.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO 4
Epstein Overview: FBI Response
3/26/2025:
o 16136 stats and summary for 3/26/2025 ODAG meeting
o Response to questions from 3/26/2025 ODAG meeting
o Sentinel serial match to Government sealed trial exhibits
3/27/2025: Sentinel serial match to Defense sealed trial exhibits
APRIL 2025
4/1/2025: 16136 review of photos and videos
4/5/2025: 1B136 review summary
4/11/2025: Digital 1As review
4/15/2025: Digital 1As review summary; status completion for all digital evidence/items
4/30/2025:
o 40 photos (20 Highly confidential responsive material, 10 Gov sealed exhibits, 10 Gov unsealed exhibits)
in hard copy and USB
o Additional photos (6 Highly confidential responsive material, 8 physical 1Bs) in hard copy and USB, plus
digital copy of all physical 1Bs which were re-photographed on 3/21/2025
o C-20 shared drive link to IMD to support investigation into unauthorized destruction
IV. Material Processed
Paper Document, Physical Photos, Non-evidentiary Media
On 3/11/25, IMD received delivery of material from WFO/NY related to the following cases: 31E-MM-108062,
50D-NY-3027571, 72-MM-113327, and 90A-NY-3151227. IMD's scanned the paper document and physical
photos received and these pages were included in the processing and redacted for DOJ deliver. IMD performed
media extraction from non-evidentiary media (1A media).
All files extracted by IMD from the non-evidentiary media (1A media) were provided via external drive to CID
SC on 3/19/25 for delivery to HQ.
On 3/20/25, IMD received an additional delivery of material from WFO/NY related to the following cases: 72-
MM-113327 and 90C-NY-3154599. IMD scanned the paper documents and physical photos received and these
pages were included in the processing and redacted for DOJ deliver. IMD performed media extraction from
non-evidentiary media (1A media). All new 1A media was added to the previous inventory, and new SSDs with
the updated inventory (previous 1A media from 3/11 and 3/12, plus new 1A media from 3/20) were provided
to CID on 3/25/25 for delivery to DOJ.
Audio/Video
IMD, per discussion and direction from CID and NY, did not review any audio or videos. IMD personnel are not
trained in the review of sensitive Child Sexual Abuse Material (CSAM).
IMD's processing of audio/video was limited to the extraction of files from 1A digital media items. IMD
provided copies of the 1A video files from the non-evidentiary media (1A media) to NY on 04/04/25 via
teleporter and on 04/09/25 via FedEx.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO 5
Epstein Overview: FBI Response
1D/ELSUR
C-20 received the 1D ELSUR from the OTD extraction via DCAP and reported on 04/01/2025.
IMD did not process, scan, redact or review 1D/ELSUR material, as ELSUR material is managed by OTD. IMD
created AudioNideo summary tables and a Digital Media Processing Estimate white paper to document the
1D/ELSUR data and how long it would take IMD to process and review.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO 6
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION I INFORMATION MANAGEMENT DIVISION
Epstein Follow-Up IMD

• Total number of pages processed/redacted? (mixed scoping criteria) 116,792 pages
o Does this include all 6 cases? Yes.

• Total number of pages processed/redacted under the final DOJ scoping criteria? 84,246 pages
o Which files does this include? The 50 and 31 case files only.

• Please confirm that ISS scanned all 1A material. Is the total for the 1A paper material, included
in the total pages redacted?
ISS scanned all IA paper material that was received. All paper 1 A material that was scanned
was included in the materials redacted.
o Please confirm 1A media was provided to DOJ.
Confirmed. IMD/DCU placed the media onto an SSD (external  drive), and a copy of the
cont A media were provided to SC for delivery to DOJ via CID.
DAD delivered to DOJ.
o Please confirm 1A videos were provided to NY for review.
1 A videos were delivered digitally to NY via teleporter and physically via thumb drive
shipped through Fed Ex.

• The 1B shows entries for only 2 cases. Does this mean there was no 1B for the other 4 cases?
IMD tasked to OTD and CID, as IMD's role regarding the 1B was scanning any paper materials
in the 1B boxes. OTD was only involved in cases 50D-NY-302751 and 90A-NY-3151227. OTD has
no visibility into other cases of which we were not involved. CID defers to NY as the case
owners.

• The 1D shows entries for 4 cases, but not the 2 main cases. Does this mean there was no 1D
with the two mains?
IMD tasked to OTD and CID, IMD had no role in the 1D materials. OTD cannot answer this
question since DFAU does not handle ELSUR data. CID defers to NY as the case owners.

• Finally, is this digital inventory the totality of what was received by IMD the day the truck
arrived from NY/WFO?
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIEDI/FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
During the process, WFO continued to deliver additional paper and media to include digital
serials for inclusion. All 1A media IMD received in ISS is reflected and was extracted, copied to
SSD, and provided to DOJ via HQ. This includes:

• ALL of the 1 A material received by truck on March 11, 2025, with five case files;
• A delivery from WFO the morning of March 20, 2025, which included a 1 A envelope
with paper and media for case number 90C-NY-3154599; and,

• A delivery from WFO on the evening of March 20, 2025, which included a box of nine
red wallets with paper and media. This tumed out to be related to one case file
originally received on the truck (case number 72-MM-113327)

• Is the evidence still in IMD EC R? If not, when are where was it transported? If so, when and
where will it be transported?
WFO/NY removed all evidence from the IMD Evidence Storage Room (ESR) when they
departed the CRC on March 25, 2025. The agents advised they were taking the evidence to
DC.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 SPIEF [russia] St. Petersburg International Economic Forum, Sergey Belyakov conference, attended by Svetlana Pozhidaeva 
                                   Edward Jay Epstein [journalist] no relation, wrote books about spies [godofthedesert] 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02730486 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ Evidence list for 50D-NY-3027571 Filtering On '1A'
(approximate date: 2025-05-01)
Case Number:
Case Summary:
SOD-NY-3027571
Child Sex Trafficking investigation into Epstein, opened 12/08/2018. Epstein was indicted on
07/02/2019 and arrested on 07/06/2019. On 08/10/2019, FBI NY was notified Epstein committed
suicide in his jail cell. Maxwell was indicted on 06/29/2020 and arrested on 07/02/2020. The
Maxwell trial began on 11/28/2021. Maxwell was convicted on 12/29/2021 on S out of 6 counts.
Maxwell was sentenced on 06/28/2022 to 20 years. In November 2024, the U.S. appeals court
rejected Maxwell's request for en banc review. Maxwell requested an appeals extension to
04/10/2025. This investigation remains in Pending Inactive status.
Evidence Report for Case: 50D-NY-3027571
Filtering on: 1A
Type g Acquired On Serial g
1A 317 2025-03-10 706
1A ilfi 2025-03-10 225
1A al 2025-03-10 706
1A 314 2025-02-27 704
1A 313 2024-08-01 702
1A 312 2022-11-02 696
1A 311 2022-05-26 692
1A 310 2022-03-07 687
1A 309 2021-12-11 686
1A Eli 2021-11-24 Q14
1A Igi 2021-11-22 ila
1A 306 2021-11.23 677
1A 305 2021-11-05 674
1A 304 2021-10-19 672
1A 303 2021-11-02 671
1A 302 2021-10-11 670
lA 301 2021-10-14 669
1A 3Q2 2021-06-23 02
lA Z9.2 2021-10-08 01
lA 298 2021-10-08 665
1A 297 2021-10-08 665
lA 336 2021-10-08 §61
lA 295 2021-10-08 665
1A 294 2021-10-08 664
lA 293 2021-10-08 663
1A 292 2021-10-08 662
lA Z91. 2021-10-08 01
1A 290 2021-10-08 660
lA 289 2021-10-08 659
lA 221 2021-10-08 552
1A 287 2021-06-23 657
lA 286 2021-10-07 657
Lk 285 2021-10-07 656
lA 294 2021-09-02 653
Lk 214 2021-09-17 ga
lA 282 2021-05-18 651
1A 281 2021-09-20 650
lA 224 2021-09-20 552
1A Z7_2 2021-05-20 M./
1A 278 2021-09-27 6413
1A 277 2021-08-19 647
1A 276 2021-07-23 646
1A 275 2021-07-23 646
LA 274 2021-09-21 645
IA 273 2021-09-01 643
m M 2021-09-01 a
IA M 2021-06-02 442
1A 270 2021-06-02 642
lA 2.62 2021-04-27 al
1A M 2021-08-20 aQ
1A 267 2021-08-12 639
LA 266 2021-08-19 638
1A 265 2021-05-14 637
LA 264 2021-05-14 637
lA 263 2021-09-02 636
lA 262 2021-08-30 635
lA ai 2021-08-31 04
1A 102 2021-09-15 01
1A 259 2021-09-02 632
1A 258 2021-09-02 632
1A M 2021-09-02 632
1A 256 2021-09-08 632
1A 255 2021-07-27 631
1A 254 2021-08-11 630
lA 334 2021-09-14 412
lA M 2021-04-01 421
lA 251 2020-11-30 627
1A 250 2021-06-30 626
lA 242 2021-06-30 42k
lA 248 2021-08-04 624
LA 247 2021-06-28 623
lA 246 2021-06-23 623
LA 245 2021-06-23 623
lA 244 2021-03-23 M
1A 243 2021-07-06 616
lA 242 2021-07-14 615
1A 241 2021-07-14 41E
1A 240 2020-02-14 613
lA 239 2021-06-29 610
LA 238 2021-05-20 607
IA 237 2021-04-13 605
LA 231 2021-04-13 445
lA 235 2021-04-01 604
1A 234 2021-03-30 603
lA M 2021-05-17 W.2
1A M 2021-03-19 596
1A 231 2021-01-29 588
1A 230 2021-03-03 586
1A 229 2021-03-03 586
1A 228 2021-01-21 585
IA 227 2021-01-21 585
IA 226 2021-01-19 584
M 22.1 2021-02-24 al
IA 224 2021-02-11 53/
1A 223 2021-02-08 581
lA 222 2020-10-14 514
1A 221 2020-10-15 512
1A 220 2020-10-14 580
Lk 219 2021-01-27 579
1A 218 2021-02-01 578
Lk 217 2021-01-20 573
lA 216 2021-01-14 M
1A 215 2020-09-25 571
lA 2,14 2021-02-02 57.4
1A all 2021-01-12 522
lA 212 2020-10-28 568
1A 211 2021-01-27 567
1A 210 2020-02-07 566
lA 209 2020-10-07 566
Lk 208 2021-01-13 565
1A 207 2020-09-10 564
lA 2 2020-10-09 522
1A 205 2021-01-19 558
lA 204 2020-10-15 556
lA lca 2020-11-04 555
1A 202 2020-10-29 554
Lk 201 2020-08-13 552
M 200 2020-06-19 551
LA 199 2020-08-21 550
lA ag 2020-08-22 itia
1A Di 2020-08-21 .5
lA 196 2020-10-09 547
lA 125 2020-08-17 24_6
IA ISA 2020-10-09 545
lA 193 2020-08-21 543
LA 192 2020-11-18 542
IA 191 2020-08-24 541
1A 192 2020-10-21 525
lA 189 2020-10-22 535
1A 188 2020-10-09 535
lA 16/ 2020-06-19 522
1A 1.4¢ 2020-08-26 5_2A
lA 185 2020-08-19 513
1A 184 2020-08-11 512
lA 183 2020-08-12 511
1A 182 2020-07-17 500
LA 181 2020-07-07 499
lA 180 2020-07-15 496
1A n2 2020-07-15 1.81
lA al 4 2020-07-27 MA
1A in 2020-08-04 488
1A 1.7.fi 2020-07-28 VI
1A iza 2020-07-28 4Z
1A 174 2020-07-28 477
1A 173 2020-07-28 477
1A 172 2020-07-28 476
lA M 2020-07-28 476
lA n_Q 2020-07-27 171
lA 1O 2020-07-21 01
lA 168 2020-07-14 468
1A 167 2020-07-02 467
1A 1.61 2020-07-02 4Z
1A 165 2020-07-08 450
1A 164 2020-07-13 449
1A 163 2020-07-13 445
LA 162 2020-07-11 443
lA 101. 2020-07-10 g_42
1A 160 2020-07-10
IA 159 2020-07-10 439
1A 15A 2020-06-19 OA
lA 157 2020-07-06 433
lA 156 2020-06-25 428
LA 155 2020-07-07 422
lA 154 2020-07-02 412
lA 151 2019-07-17 O.5
lA 152 2019-10-25 404
1A 151 2020-03-04 403
1A 152 2020-04-10 222
1A 2,42 2020-02-07 22A
1A 148 2020-02-07 398
1A 147 2019-07-22 397
1A 146 2019-11-21 396
1A 145 2019-09-18 395
1A 144 2019-10-23 394
IA 143 2019-10-23 393
1A 142 2019-09-12 ila
IA 141 2019-08-26 331.
1A 140 2019-10-18 390
1A 122 2019-10-18 39.2
1A al 2019.09-12 222
1A 137 2020-02-28 388
1A 136 2019-10-23 387
IA 135 2020-02-26 386
Lk 134 2019-10-24 385
lA 133 2019-10-24 385
1A 132 2019-12-04 384
2019-11-26 222
1A 1 2019-10-11 27
1A 129 2020-02-05 380
1A 128 2019-11-04 379
1A 127 2020-02-05 378
1A 126 2020-02-27 377
Lk 125 2019-08-13 376
lA 124 2019.08-13 376
m al 2020-02-05 ill
IA 122 2020-01-14 M
IA 121 2019.09-10 373
1A 120 2020-02-19 372
1A 112 2020-01-16 222
1A 118 2019-12-17 366
1A 117 2019-07-26 365
1A 116 2019-07-26 365
Lk 115 2019-12-15 359
IA 114 2019-12-15 252
1A 113 2019-12-15 359
lA 112 2020-01-17 356
1A 111 2020-01-08 3.55
IA 110 2019.08-28 54
IA 109 2019-09-18 353
Lk 108 2019-10-23 352
IA 107 2019-09-09 351
IA 1.9.¢ 2019-11-01 ESQ
IA 105 2019-09-18 349
IA 104 2019-08-09 348
IA isl 2019.08-12 liz
1A 12Z 2019.08-12 II&
1A 101 2019.08-28 345
1A 100 2019-08-01 344
1A 99 2020-01-08 343
1A 98 2019-12-30 343
LA 97 2019-12-30 343
IA 96 2019-12-02 343
1A 21 2019-10-01 al
IA a 2019-10-15 3a
1A 93 2019-12-17 339
1A 22 2019-12-17 laa
1A a 2019.09-19 331
1A 90 2019-10-16 334
1A 89 2019-10-16 333
1A 88 2019-10-15 332
1A 87 2019-09-18 330
1A 86 2019.09-19 329
1A 85 2019-11-14 327
1A M 2019-09-28 321
1A $.5 2019-07-31 315
1A 82 2019-07-12 324
1A 81 2019-11-13 322
1A N 2019.08-28 316
1A n 2019-08-27 315
Lk 78 2019-08-29 306
lA 77 2019-08-29 306
m 16 2019-08-06 30
IA Z5 2019.09-24
IA 74 2019-07-05 300
1A 73 2019.08-27 298
1A 22 2019-07-11 22Z
1A 71 2019-07-12 296
1A 70 2019-08-13 294
1A 69 2019-09-16 289
LA 68 2019-07-12 286
lA §.2 2019-09-05 /8.5
1A a 2019-09-05 283
lA 65 2019.09-14 281
1A 0 2019-08-13 2Z/
IA 63 2019.08-24 272
IA 62 2019-08-28 271
LA 61 2019-08-27 270
IA 60 2019-08-13 269
LA 52 2019-08-12 2.0
IA 58 2019-08-12 268
IA 57 2019-08-12 268
LA a 2019.08-12 211
1A II 2019.08-12 268
1A sit 2019.08-11 268
1A 53 2019-08-20 264
1A 52 2019-08-13 261
1A 91 2019-08-28 258
1A 50 2019-08-27 257
IA 49 2019-08-07 252
1A g 2019-07-11 2g
1A 47 2019.08-16 /31
1A 46 2019-07-24 216
1A 4.5. 2019-08-09 214
1A 44 2019-07-29 212
1A 43 2019-07-31 208
1A 42 2019-07-31 207
1A 41 2019-08-02 206
1A 40 2019-07-11 203
1A 39 2019-07-11 202
1A 38 2019-07-06 194
1A az 2019-07-17 M
1A 3..¢ 2019-07-13 MI
1A 35 2019-07-13 187
1A 34 2019-07-14 186
1A 33 2019-07-11 185
1A 32 2019-07-02 183
1A 31 2019-07-16 175
ia 30 2019-07-17 171
m as 2019-07-06 MI
IA a 2019-07-12 16_¢
IA 27 2019-07-19 159
IA 26 2019-07-17 153
IA 22 2019-07-17 M
IA 24 2019-07-11 151
1A 23 2019-07-06 150
ia 22 2019-07-07 14/
1A 21 2019-07-12 127
1 A 20 2019-07-11 116
1A 12 2019-05-29 142
IA 18 2019-07-06 2
IA 17 2019-07-08 49
IA 16 2019-06-24 30
IA 15 2019-05-29 26
IA 14 2019-05-08 25 ia 13 2019-05-23 24
1A 12 2019-05-02 21
1A fl 2019-04-24 2Q
1A 14 2019.04-26 12
1A 9 2019.04-11 17
1A 8 2019-03-22 16
1A 7 2019-03-22 14
1A 6 2019-03-20 13
LA 5 2019-03-19 12
IA 4 2019-03-25 11
m A 2019-03-19 12
IA 2 2019-03-04 I
IA 1 2019-01-30 5
Serial Title

(U) Transport of Evidence Items 16136, 16144, 16145, and 1B146
(U) Transport of Evidence Items 1B136, 16144, 16145, and 16146

(U) Transport of Evidence Items 16136, 16144, 16145, and 1B146
(U) Transfer of Case Documents from the New York Field Office to the Washington Field Office

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) Identification of [REDACTED] as a possible associate of JEFFREY EPSTEIN

(U) Mail Received from Epstein Residence
(U) Phone Interview with [REDACTED]
(U) Defense Notes for [REDACTED]

(U) Telephonic Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Telephonic interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Phone conversation with [REDACTED]
(U) Call with [REDACTED]

(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial
(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department
(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department
(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department

(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department
U//FOUO NTOC2021 E-Tip Additional Victim Reports Being Human Trafficked By Gislaine Maxwell M A Child (7
U NTOC2020 352mtr01 Information on a Possible Accountant of Jeffrey Epstein. (NY)
U//FOUO NTOC2020 024srm01 E-Tip: Possible Human Trafficking in New York, NY. (NY)
U USPS Mail Tipster - Information Related to Jeffrey Epstein/Unnamed 29 YOA Jewish Female
U NTOC2020 195hmb02 Potential Sex Trafficking by [REDACTED] and [REDACTED) in New York, NY (NY)
U Email regarding information for sale about the Epstein Zorro Ranch
U//FOUO NTOC2021Conceming Comments by (REDACTED]. (NY)

(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial
(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial
(U) Fed-Ex Delivery Confirmation

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]- September 2, 2021
(U) Meeting with [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)

(U) Proffer of [REDACTED]
(U) Proffer of [REDACTED]
(U) Service of subpoena.
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] - September 1, 2021

(U) Interview of [REDACTED) - September 1, 2021
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview/Proffer of [REDACTED)

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Proffer of [REDACTED)

(U) Proffer of [REDACTED)
(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] - August 30, 2021
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] - August 31, 2021

(U) Request to serve three trial subpoenas
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED) - July 27, 2021
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) [REDACTED] Interview 8/4/2021
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Locate and Serve witness (REDACTED)
(U) Missouri Birth Certificate Identified and obtained

(U) Missouri Birth Certificate Identified and obtained
(U) Device Extraction - MDUS 13768
(U//FOUO) Collection of evidence in Austin, Texas

(U) lA Lab Report Material: Lab it (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Introductory conversation with [REDACTED)
(U) 2021-00585-2 Questioned Documents
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] - Day 3

(U) Interview of [REDACTED) - Day 3
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] - Day 1
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Virtual Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Telephonic Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of[REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Introductory Conversation with [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] - Day 2

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Proffer of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview/Proffer of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview/Proffer of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
( -013.pdf
(U) Call received from [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Victim Services Division - Case Support Unit Assistance

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Fund Reimbursement - Five 2TB Hard drives
(U) Fund Reimbursement - Five 2TB Hard drives

(U) Fund Reimbursement - Five 2TB Hard drives
(U) Fund Reimbursement - 12 TB External Hard Drive
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Lead Request to Serve grand Jury subpoena [REDACTED]
(U) Lead Request to Serve grand jury subpoena [REDACTED]

(U) Lead Request to Serve grand jury subpoena [REDACTED]
(U) Lead Request to Serve grand Jury subpoena [REDACTED]

(U) Lead Request to Serve grand jury subpoena [REDACTED]
(U) Lead Request to Serve grand jury subpoena [REDACTED]

(U) Date Submitted: 07/25/2020 10:08:31 AM ET Transaction Number: 4D291278-35FF-489A-A26C
(U) On 07/21/2020, at 2:17 a.m. Eastern Time, [REDACTED], date of birth [REDACTED],
(U//FOUO) Telephone Interview Of [REDACTED]

(U) Arrest of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U) Arrest of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U//FOUO) Impersonation of FBI Agent
(U//FOUO) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) On 07/12/2020, at 3:12:08 PM Eastern Time, [REDACTED], date of birth [REDACTED],
(U) On 07/11/2020, at 10:02 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol

(U) On 07/09/2020, at 9:47 p.m. Eastern Time, [REDACTED], email address [REDACTED]
(U) On 07/10/2020, at 9:44 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP

(U) On 07/10/2020, at 9:22 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP
(U) Fund Reimbursement

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 10:19 AM Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U//FOUO) Aerial photos of [REDACTED]

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 12:33:51 PM Eastern Time, an anonymous complainant, Email account
(U//FOUO) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Information provided by [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] on 10/25/19
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED] on 11.21.19
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Proffer of [REDACTED] interview #2
(U) Proffer of [REDACTED] Interview B1

(U) interview of[REDACTED] on 10/11/2019
(U) Pass information to Swedish authorities for informational purposes.

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Share information with Swedish Authorities
(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Proffer of[REDACTEDI

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Phone conversation with [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Phone call with Attomey[REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U)[REDACTED] interview
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Epstein Breiflng EVAF Expenditures
(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures

(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director
(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director
(U)[REDACTED] interview

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED] on 9/19/2019
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] on 11/14/2019
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED] on 7/31/19
(U) Proffer of (REDACTED) Interview #1
(U) Victim Services Division - Victim Meeting

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) (REDACTED] Interview
(U) Lead Forwared to Legat Mexico City, Mexico
(U) Lead Forwared to Legat Mexico City, Mexico

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U)(REDACTED] interview

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Device Unlock and Extraction - MDUS 10398
(U) Device Unlock and Extraction - MDUS 10399

(U) On 09/14/2019, at 2:58 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED], date of birth (REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) FBI New York - Jeffrey Epstein - Child Sex Trafficking - 190904-175728
(U) Follow-Up Law Enforcement Inquiries Pertaining to [REDACTED]

(U) Interview Of [REDACTED]
(U) (REDACTED]
(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James
(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James

(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James
(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James
(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James

(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] (PROTECT SOURCE) Interview #3
(U) Phone interview of (REDACTED]
U (REDACTED] - financial connection to JEFFREY EPSTEIN
U NTOC2019 1971(103 E-Tip: Information Regarding Multiple Criminal Allegations such as Human Sex Traffi
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] (PROTECT SOURCE) Interview 42

(U) Inventory of Two Suite Cases (black/blue) for JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U) On 8/15/19, at 11:15 a.m. Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] (PROTECT SOURCE) Interview One

(U) On 08/08/2019, at 9:02 a.m. Eastern Time, [REDACTED], date of birth [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Return of Property to [REDACTED] on 08/02/2019

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED) on 07/11/2019
(U) Post Arrest Spontaneous Utterances made by Defendant JFFREY E. EPSTEIN

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Arrest of JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U) Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interivew of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] on 07/15/2019
(U) Provide information to SEATTLE FO for conducting interview

(U) On 07/17/2019, at 3:43 p.m. Eastern Time, the FBI's Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) On 07/17/2019, at 3:51 p.m. Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)

(U) Search Warrant Executed- 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021
(U) Interivew of [REDACTED]
(U) Attempted Interview of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U//FOUO) On 07/11/2019, at 10:56 p.m. Eastern Time, tipster email address [REDACTED]

(U) On 07/11/2019, at 2:31 a.m., Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED) on 5/29/2019

(U) Search Warrant Executed- 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021
(U//FOUO) On 07/08/2019, at 1:10 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, the Office of Public Affairs

(U) 31E-NY-3027571
(U) Interview of [REDACTED] on 5/29/2019
(U) Interview of [REDACTED) on 5/8/2019
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED] on 5/2/2019
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) TECS Silent Hit Notification

(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED)
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Interview of [REDACTED]

(U) Interview of [REDACTED]
Summary
(U) Chains of Custody
(U) Ending Transport Photographs
(U) Starting Transport Photographs

(U) Photos and Photo Logs
(U) Agent Notes
(U//FOUO) Email from [REDACTED] and attachments from Null
(U) letter from former Epstein Estate; fake NY State Driver's license

(U) [REDACTED) interview notes
(U//FOUO) Defense notes for [REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes

(U) interview notes
(U) digital notes
(U) Digital notes, household manual
(U) Notes
(U) [REDACTED] notes

(U) 794
(U) Receipt
(U) [REDACTED) interview notes
(U) Property receipt
(U) Trash pull
(U) Digital case files

(U) Subpoena
U
U
U
U
U
U
U
(U) Receipt
(U) FD-794
(U) Fed-Ex Delivery Confirmation, 41864 0967 1500
(U) [REDACTED] Interview notes - 9.2.21 & Scan shown to NB

(U) Notes - [REDACTED]
(U) notes & doncuments
(U) Emails from [REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Notes

(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Documents shown to [REDACTED)
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Drivers license information for each individual.

(U) News article shown to [REDACTED]
(U) Notes
(U) Documents shown to [REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes

(U) [REDACTED) Interview notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Documents shown to [REDACTED]

(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Trial Subpoenas
(U) photobook
(U) Nude photo of [REDACTED]
(U) Items shown to [REDACTED) during interview

(U) Notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Notes
(U) notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Messages pads
(U) notes

(U) Notes
(U) Transcript
(U) Epstein phone contact
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Trial Subpoena - [REDACTED]
(U) Copy of FedEx shipment with tracking number 774263190664
(U)[REDACTED] Farmer Certified Birth Certificate

(U) Legal Authority for Device
(U//FOUO) FD-597
(U) Lab # [REDACTED): 1 disk
(U) Photo provided by [REDACTED]

(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED) Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] notes
(U) 2021-00585-2 QUESTIONED DOCUMENTS

(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Photographs provided via email by [REDACTED)

(U) Photo from Myspace account
(U) Interview notes day 3
(U) Interview notes day 1
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Emails
(U) Statement referenced in interview
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Notes
(U) Interview notes day 2
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] flight log
(U) interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] involvement in U.S. Presidential pardon petitions and influences
from Russia and Israel on [REDACTED] and [REDACTED]

(U) notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] Interview notes

(U) Latest contact information tracked and updated by ODAG partners.
(U) Interview notes
(U) 10.21 HD Receipt

(U) 10.22 HD Receipt
(U) 10.9 HD Receipt
(U) Receipt
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U//FOUO) Notes Re: Interview of [REDACTED] on July 27, 2020.
(U//FOUO) City of Maricopa Police Department Officer Report for D.R. 200722037

(U) Subpoena
(U) Accurint
(U) Subpoena
(U) Accurint
(U) Subpeona
(U) Accurint
(U) (U//FOUO) THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN HAS BEEN DETERMINED BY
THE FBI TO BE PERTINENT TO & WITHIN THE SCOPE OF AN AUTHORIZED LAW
ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY & SHOULD BE CONSIDERED IN THE CONTEXT OF THE
ASSESSMENT OR PREDICATED INVESTIGATION TO WHICH THE INFORMATION
RELATES. PARTICULAR ATTENTION SHOULD BE GIVEN TO THE AUTHORIZED
PURPOSE FOR COLLECTING & RECORDING THIS INFORMATION PURSUANT TO THE
ATTORNEY GENERAL'S GUIDELINES FOR DOMESTIC FBI OPERATIONS & THE
DOMESTIC INVESTIGATION & OPERATIONS GUIDE. THAT PURPOSE MAY BE SET
FORTH IN THE FILE'S OPENING ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATION OR OTHER RELATED
DOCUMENTS.

(U) Screenshot of Reddit post by user [REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) NYPD SVD Hotline Worksheet
(U) Photo
(U) Arrest warrant, arrest paperwork, notes
(U//FOUO) Document and audio recording from Bradford (NH) Police
(U//FOUO) Interview notes of [REDACTED]

(U) Graphic Capture of Viral Video.
(U) screenshot of [REDACTED] Quora page
(U) Screenshots of Epstein's alleged employee's confession on YouTube and 4chan

(U) Website [REDACTED]
(U) Screenshots from [REDACTED]
(U) Receipt
(U) Reported Tweets to NTOC
(U//FOUO) Aerial photos of [REDACTED]

(U) Screen shot of Imgur capture of the comment made by[REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) Notes from [REDACTED]
(U) Photographs provided by [REDACTED]

(U) (REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Interview notes & documents provided by [REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes

(U) Flight logs
(U) [REDACTED] Interview notes
(U) (REDACTED] interview notes
(U) (REDACTED) interview notes

(U) (REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes

(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Two boxes of papers and media from PBPD
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes & police report
(U) Interview notes
(U) Photo provided by [REDACTED] and [REDACTED] attorneys

(U) Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] 302

(U) Interview Notes
(U) [REDACTED] 302
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Photo Book
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Interview notes and Message pad copies shown
(U) [REDACTED] Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Facebook Profile Screenshots
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Photos

(U) Emails
(U) Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] W Hotel charges, approval to accept charge, and proof of refund.

(U) [REDACTED] phone call notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Interview Notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) (REDACTED] Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes

(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] Lodging

(U) [REDACTED] Lodging
(U) [REDACTED] Lodging
(U) [REDACTED] Reimbursement
(U) Receipts of EVAF Expenditures for Epstein Victims

(U) Interview Notes
(U) Receipts
(U) Receipts
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes

(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes and photos provided by [REDACTED]
(U) Interview notes
(U) RSVP/potential victim list, templates, reminders and overviews

(U) interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) VA DMV image of [REDACTED)
(U) DMV images of [REDACTED], [REDACTED) and [REDACTED], [REDACTED).110 reports concerning [REDA

(U) Interview notes
(U) Receipts
(U)[REDACTED] Grand Jury Subpoena
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Administrative Documents

(U) Administrative Documents
(U) Screenshot of YouTube Video, [REDACTED]
(U) Interview notes
(U) Enclosed are the IC3 complaints

(U) Police Records from Cranston RI Police Department
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Receipt for Property (FD-597)

(U) Charlie and Delta Zone, with Bravo's Building 6, Search Paperwork
(U) Bravo Zone Search Paperwork
(U) Alpha Zone Search Paperwork

(U) Evidence Log, Sign•in Log, map, notes
(U) Search Warrant Little Saint James
(U//FOUO) Interview Notes

(U) Interview Notes
U S79223_CV
U 566318_PH
(U//FOUO) Interview Notes, images provided
(U) two (2) property receipts, one (1) inventory log, 1 (one) ERT photographic log and one CD with photogral

(U) Twitter screenshots of the links provided.
(U//FOUO) Interview Notes and photograph of (REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED] NCIC

(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) (1) DVD of photos, (2) original signed receipt for property forms FD-597, (1) business card

(U) original handwritten notes of [REDACTED] interview on 07/11/2019
(U) copy of Handwritten contact information for [REDACTED), his attorney [REDACTED], and property manal

(U) Photocopy of working folder pertaining to arrest paperwork of JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Epstein arrest warrant

(U) Arrest paperwork, search warrant, photographs disc
(U//FOUO) Interview Notes [REDACTED] 7/17/2019
(U) [REDACTED] Florida Identification

(U) Original Handwritten Interview Notes of [REDACTED] on 07/12/2019
(U) TLO report and WASHINGTON STATE DL image of potential victim to be interviewed.

(U) Twitter screenshots - [REDACTED]
(U) Twitter Post.
(U) Search warrant execution log, FBI Sign in log, Evidence Collected item log, copy
of search warrant, (1) FD-597 Forms, (1) DVD disk of Search photos

(U) [REDACTED] Notes
(U) Documents from UPS
(U) Attachments from tipster.
(U) twitter screenshot
(U) [REDACTED] Interview notes

(U) original search logs, copy of search warrant, (1) signed FD-597, (1) DVD disk of Search photos
(U//FOUO) Twitter Username [REDACTED]

(U) Fed-EX signature confirmation page.
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes 5.29.19
(U) Interview notes 5/8/19

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes 5.2.19, Photos 1 through 19 and A through F
(U) [REDACTED] Interview Notes
(U//FOUO) TECS silent hit entered

(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) (REDACTED] Interview notes
(U) (REDACTED). Interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] Interview notes

(U) [REDACTED] Interview Notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) [REDACTED] interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
p 2021-00585-2 IA.4 CASE COMMUNICATION LOG: Con

╭───── Page 28, Image 1 ──────╮
│ eesanneeeseee©*7071-00585-2 │
│                             │
│ 1A.zip CASE COMMUNI         │
│                             │
│ IICATION LO‘                │
│                             │
│ Cor                         │
╰─────────────────────────────╯

tmunicadonLog2021-00585.pdf CASE NOTE INTERFACE REPORT: CNI Questioned Documents (AF)
ase Note (143683).p CASE FILES: 2021-00585 #1, Lead 17.pdf 2021-00585 Shipping Invoice C
ntainer C.pdf 2021-00585 #1 LER, Seria 575.pdf 2021-00585 Shipping Invoice Container B.p
if 2021-00585 Al Check-In Notes.rtf CASE CHAIN OF CUSTODY: Chain0Kustody2021-005854
df CASE RECORD REPORT: CaseReport2021-00585 Record #2.pdf CASE COMMUNICATION LOG FIL
S: 2021-00585_UNCLASS.pdf CASE REPORT: CaseReport2021-00S8S.pdf CASE RECORD FILES
2021-00585 Item 3 Matchmaker Images.pdf
Evidence Report for Case: 50D-NY-3027571
Filtering on: Type(s):1B
Item # Collected On
1B146 7/22/2022 10:00
1B145 5/25/202214:00
1B144 5/25/2022 14:00
1B143 7/7/2019 3:00
1B142 10/8/202113:00
1B141 10/8/202113:00
1B140 10/8/202113:00
1B139 6/29/2021 16:15
18138 8/12/2019 19:20
1B137 8/28/2006 11:50
1B136 1/26/202116:00
1B135 6/6/2019 12:00
1B134 8/28/2006 11:00
1B133 8/28/2006 11:00
1B132 8/28/2006 11:50
18131 8/28/2006 11:50
1B130 8/28/2006 11:50
1B129 8/28/2006 11:50
1B128 8/28/200611:50
18127 8/28/2006 11:50
18126 8/12/2019 19:20
1B125 8/12/2019 19:20
1B124 8/12/2019 19:20
1B123 8/12/2019 19:20
1B122 8/12/2019 19:20
1B121 8/12/2019 19:20
1B120 8/12/2019 19:20
1B119 8/12/2019 19:20
1B118 8/12/2019 19:20
1B117 8/12/2019 19:20
1B116 8/12/2019 19:20
1B115 8/12/2019 19:20
1B114 8/12/2019 19:20
1B113 8/12/2019 19:20
18112 8/12/2019 19:20
1B111 8/12/2019 19:20
1B110 8/12/2019 19:20
1B109 8/12/2019 19:20
1B108 8/12/2019 19:20
1B107 8/12/2019 19:20
18106 8/12/2019 19:20
11105 8/12/2019 19:20
1B104 8/12/2019 19:20
18103 8/12/2019 19:20
1B102 8/12/2019 19:20
18101 8/12/2019 19:20
1B100 8/12/2019 19:20
1B99 8/12/2019 19:20
1898 8/12/2019 19:20
1B97 8/12/2019 19:20
1B96 8/12/2019 19:20
1B95 8/12/2019 19:20
1B94 8/12/2019 19:20
1893 8/12/2019 19:20
1B92 8/12/2019 19:20
1691 8/12/2019 19:20
1690 8/12/2019 19:20
1889 8/12/2019 19:20
1888 8/12/2019 19:20
1887 8/12/2019 19:20
1886 8/12/2019 19:20
1685 8/12/2019 19:20
1884 8/12/2019 19:20
1683 8/12/2019 19:20
1682 8/12/2019 19:20
1881 8/12/2019 19:20
1680 8/12/2019 19:20
1679 7/11/2019 15:35
1B78 7/11/2019 15:35
1B77 7/11/2019 15:35
1B76 7/11/2019 15:35
1B75 7/11/2019 15:35
1B74 7/11/2019 15:35
1B73 7/11/2019 15:35
1872 7/6/2019 18:15
1871 7/6/2018 18:15
1870 7/11/2019 19:28
1869 7/11/2019 19:28
1B68 7/11/2019 19:28
1867 7/11/2019 19:28
1B66 7/11/2019 19:28
1865 7/11/2019 19:28
1B64 7/11/2019 19:28
1B63 7/11/2019 19:28
1862 7/11/2019 19:28
1B61 7/11/2019 19:28
1860 7/11/2019 19:28
1B59 7/11/2019 19:28
1658 7/11/2019 19:28
1857 7/11/2019 19:28
1856 7/11/2019 19:28
1B55 7/11/2019 19:28
1B54 7/11/2019 19:28
1653 7/11/2019 19:28
1B52 7/11/2019 16:28
1B51 7/11/2019 16:28
1B50 7/11/2019 16:28
1849 7/11/2019 16:28
1848 7/11/2019 16:28
1847 7/11/2019 16:28
1846 7/11/2019 16:28
1845 7/11/2019 19:28
1844 7/11/2019 19:28
1843 7/11/2019 19:28
1842 7/11/2019 19:28
1841 7/11/2019 19:28
1840 7/11/2019 19:28
1B39 7/11/2019 19:28
1B38 7/11/2019 19:28
1837 7/11/2019 19:28
1B36 7/11/2019 19:28
1835 7/11/2019 19:28
1B34 7/11/2019 19:28
1833 7/11/2019 19:28
1B32 7/11/2019 19:28
1B31 7/11/2019 19:28
1B30 7/11/2019 19:28
1B29 7/11/2019 19:28
1B28 7/11/2019 19:28
1827 7/7/2019 3:00
1826 7/7/2019 3:00
1825 7/7/2019 3:00
1824 7/7/2019 3:00
1823 7/7/2019 3:00
1822 7/7/2019 3:00
1821 7/7/2019 3:00
1B20 7/7/2019 3:00
1819 7/7/2019 3:00
1818 7/7/2019 3:00
1817 7/7/2019 3:00
1816 7/7/2019 3:00
1815 7/7/2019 3:00
1B14 7/7/2019 3:00
1813 7/7/2019 3:00
1812 7/7/2019 3:00
1811 7/7/2019 3:00
1810 7/7/2019 3:00
1B9 7/7/2019 3:00
188 7/7/2019 3:00
1B7 7/7/2019 3:00
1B6 7/7/2019 3:00
1B5 7/6/2019 0:00
1B4 5/29/201918:00
1B3 5/29/201918:00
1B2 5/29/2019 18:00
1B1 5/29/201918:00
Description

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE containing: NYC032395 - One (1)DVD-R containing image log files and FTK reports for systel

(U) Red Rope Containing;NYC032391 - Three (3) LTD 6 tape cartridges containing an Arcserve backup of all digital

(U) Red Rope Containing;NYC032392 - Two(2) LTO 6 tape cartridges containing an Arcserve backup of all digital evi

(U) one (1) CD labelled "girl plcs nude book 4"
(U) ONE REDROPE CONTAINING: (1) Envelope containing 1 VHS tape, 2 cassette tapes & 4 micro cassette tapes

(U) ONE REDROPE CONTAINING: (1) Envelope containing 4 CD's
(U) (2) Bankers box containing various EPSTEIN related case materials

(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: One pair of black women's cowboy boots, size 8
(U) ONE CELLOPHANE containing: Disk containing images of Matchmaker shred reconstruction

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING: (1) un-framed photo.
(U//FOUO) ONE RED ROPE containing: Highly confidential responsive material to include nude and semi nude ima

(U) Box containing Ten yearbooks collected by FBI West Palm Beach Resident Agency
(U) One (1) peach massage table.

(U) One (1) green massage table (PBPD0S-1024).
(U) One (1) beige massage table.
(U) One (1) brown massage table.

(U) One flat box containing one (1) large framed photo.
(U) One box containing four (4) framed photos.
(U) One box containing twelve (12) framed photos.

(U) One box containing five (5) framed photos
(U) One red rope containing: LSJ logbook
(U) One red rope containing:Daily Vessel Trip logs Feb 2, 2017 - Feb 16, 2017

(U) HP Tower S/N: CNV74213M3 Model: 570-p056
(U) Lenovo Tower S/N: 153306G2USAIXEKGX
(U) Lenovo Tower S/N: M107YG6U Machine type: 90J0

(U) Mac DesktopS/N: W89524C2SPJ model A1312
(U) HP TowerS/N: CNV716004YModel #: 260-a010
(U) HP Desktop TowerS/N: CNV7160050Model #: 260-a010

(U) Silver Mac desktop
(U) 6 Bay with 146GB drivesS/N: MXQ824A1R
(U) One box containing Panasonic KX-TDE100S/N: KX-TDA01049LCCD005398

(U) HP server with (4) 500 GB drivesS/N: MXQ3220187
(U) Blue prints
(U) One cellophane containing:Boat trip log & employee lists

(U) Unifi serverMacID: 1735K788A20463234-8uuu9FFCCID: SWX-UASPRO
(U) Unifi videoM/N: UVC-NVR-2TBMacID: 1829FB4FBE426EA90

(U) One cellophane containing:Paper with passwords on both sides
(U) Unifi Cloud keyM/N: UN-CKFCCID: SWX-UCCKIC 6545A-UCCKMac ID: 1843KB4FBE4D30C69-dcRgm9

(U) CELLOPHANE containing Olympus Digital Voice Recorder
(U) Silver Mac desktopModel #: A1311S/N: W804736DDA5

(U) Dell Inspiron tower with power cordReg Model: D19MQCHFA335
(U) One red rope contalning:LSJ & GSI Boat Log 2019

(U) Box containing Shredded paper
(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING; Apple iPod shuffle on watch band
(U) Silver Macbook Desktop with keyboard

(U) One cellophane containing:Photograph
(U) One cellophane containing:Employee contact list
(U) One red rope containing:Red Nikon Camera

(U) One box containing: Silver Desktop Mac with keyboard
(U) HP Laptop with chargerS/N: CND81368V5
(U) Toshiba Laptop with charger

(U) One red rope containing:Remodeling documents for Island
(U) One cellophane containing:Handwritten notes on LSJ notepad

(U) One flat FedEx box containing: Photos, Photo negatives, letter
(U) One red rope containing:lsland blueprints, island photos, and documents

(U) One red rope containing:photo album of girl & Epstein
(U) One red rope containing:letter, photo album of girls, photos of island

(U) One cellophane containing:Document with names
(U) One cellophane containing:Employee contact list
(U) Silver Mac Desktop

(U) One red rope containing: Notepads with notes - LSJ stationary with handwritten notes
(U) Silver Mac Desktop with mouse & keyboardS/N: C02NM1MOFY14

(U) Silver iPad Model A15675/N: DMPQL1RMG5Yin case
(U) CELLOPHANE containing Silver iPad Model A15675/N: DMPQL25NGSYPYin case

(U) RED ROPE containing Silver MacBook ProS/N: C02QMOGUGWDP
(U) Silver Mac Laptop labeled "JE BIG LAPTOP" "BLACK BAG" in black bag S/N: W89111772QT

(U) Mac Desktop labeled "Kitchen Mac" - grey
(U) One heat-sealed bag containing one yellow envelope marked "SK" dated 08/27/08 containing multiple smaller

(U) RED ROPE CONTAINING: 4 binders with 68 discs inside
(U) One heat-sealed bag containing one small white envelope with writing "2000-SK" containing $4,400 USC (44 x

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING; Austrian Passport with Epstein photograph
(U) RED ROPE CONTAINING: Two blue binders with 58 discs inside

(U) CELLOPHANE containing Black hard drive
(U) CELLOPHANE containing Black hard drive
(U) One (1) silver IPad with serial number DLXQGM3KGMW3.

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING :One (1) black iPhone with IMEI number 357201093322785.
(U) One box containing: 1 Apple Desktop computer

(U) 1 Silver IPAD - 64GB
(U) 1 Space Gray Apple IPAD
(U) 1 Space Gray Apple IPAD
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Black Radioshack recorder

(U) One cellophane containing 1 Silver Olympus recorder
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Sony BM-560 Recorder

(U) Box containing 45 Assorted Cd's
(U) One red rope containing 1 Sony Vaio Laptop
(U) 1 Dell Precision Tower 5810

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Barracuda 7200 harddrive 80GB
(U) 1 MSI PC Computer IN A BROWN BOX

(U) One red rope containing:1 Sony Camera with black case
(U) 1 Gray Apple Desktop Computer with keyboard and mouse

(U) One cellophane containing 1 Seagate Backup Plus Portable Drive - 1TB
(U) One cellophane containing one (1) White Apple (Phone 5, 64GB.

(U) 1 Apple Desktop Computer with keyboard and mouse
(U) 1 Apple Desktop Computer with keyboard and mouse

(U) One cellophane containing:1 SPIEF 2014 Silver USB
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Cruzer Guide 32GB USB

(U) One cellophane containing 1 Cruzer Guide 32GB USB
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Cruzer Guide 32GB USB

(U) One cellophane containing 1 Cruzer Guide 32GB USB
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Blue EMTEC 16 GB USB

(U) One cellophane containing 1 EMTEC 16 GB USB
(U) One red rope containing:10 assorted cd's
(U) One cellophane containing 3. Silicone Power Micro SD Adapter with 16GB SD Card

(U) 1 DELL Machine
(U) 1 Cube 9000 Siteserver, (BLACK/SILVER)
(U) 1 HP Compaq Machine
(U) One cellophane containing one (1) Mentor Media 32GB USB.

(U) One cellophane containing one (1) Data Traveler 4GB USB.
(U) One cellophane containing one (1) Data Traveler 4GB USB.

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) Silver Apple Desktop Computer with keyboard and mouse

(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: 1 stuffed dog
(U) Box containing 2-1 inch black binders containing CD's and 13 loose CD's

(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: 2 white in color busts of female torsos
(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: 1 brown bust sculpture of female breasts

(U) One red rope containing: 2 photos and 1 album page with additional 2 photos
(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: 1 blue box containing various Cd's

(U) Red rope containing 12 polaroid photos, 1 folder labeled "Sue" containing various photos/cd's
(U) ONE BANKERS BOX CONTAINING: bundled photos and cd's from "Women Old Photos Box"

(U) 10 black binders containing photos, cd's etc.
(U) 1 blue in color bust of a female torso
(U) One red rope containing: 2 photos of female buttocks

(U) One box containing: 5 costumes and 1 wig
(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINI1 vibrator, 3 buttplugs, 1 set of cuffs, 1 dad°, 1 leash, i box of condoms, i nurse cap

(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING; (1) butt plug
(U) One box containing four (4) framed photos of naked females.

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING: 1 set of copper handcuffs and whip
(U) One (1) green massage table.
(U) One cellophane containing:3 sheets of paper- (1) photo depicting two girls, (2) cash disbursements

(U) One cellophane containing:3 pages- (1) handwritten note Epstein letterhead, (2) page typed letter
(U) One flat FedEx box containing: 3 photographs- (2) depicting Epstein with two females, (1) photo depicting two

(U) One red rope containing: 3 sheets of paper depicting photographs of a living room
(U) One cellophane containing: 2-page handwritten len

(U) Box containing one (1) set of Blueprints for residence 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York Stamped receive

(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING: 1 Red Notebook
(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING: 10 Photographs
(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING: 17 Miscellaneous Financial Documents

(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING: 1 Premier Day Planner
envelopes containing $17,115 UK (152 x $100, 35 x $50 4 x $20, 6 x $10, 5 x $5).
Evidence Report for Case: SOD-NY-3027571
Filtering on: 1C
Type b Acquired O Serial #
2 2019-08-11 274
1 2019.08-11 274
Serial Title
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Little Saint James Island
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Little Saint James Island
Summary

(U) - One (1) CD of WORKING COPY of RAW scan data for "Main Structure"
- One (1) CD of WORKING COPY of RAW scan data for "Grotto"
- One (1) CD of Scene2Go products for both "Main Structure" and "Grotto"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for "Main Structure"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for "Grotto"
- Copy of each sketch showing locations of scans

(U) ORIGINAL FARO LASER SCAN DATA and Notes
- Two (2) CDs of ORIGINAL RAW scan data for "Main Structure"
- Two (2) CDs of ORIGINAL RAW scan data for "Grotto"
- One (1) CD of Scene2Go products for both "Main Structure" and "Grotto"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for "Main Structure"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for "Grotto"
- Copy of each Error Report for both area projects
- Copy of each sketch showing locations of scans
Evidence Report for Case: 1500-NY-3027571
Filtering on: Type(s): 1D
Item # Collected On
1D6 8/24/2020 7:00
IDS 8/3/2020 9:25
1D4 5/7/2020 7:00
1D3 4/18/2020 7:00
1D2 2/4/2020 7:00
1D1 8/20/2019 17:00
Description

(U) (NY-ERF#19236) Court Authorized Intercept Doc# 20-CRIM-1281832Facility : u-Ray Disc# 7446!
(U) 07/02/2020; One (1) original SD card and one (1) Blu Ray containing FLIR aerial surveillance footage of Bradfoi

(U) (NY-ERF#18399) Court Authorized Intercept-Doc#20-CRIM-2134OFacility isc#690612-R1
(U) (NY-ERF# 18727) Court Authorized Intercept Doc#20-CRIM-81211Fadlity- lu-Ray Disc#694397
(U) (NY-ERRS 18309) Court Authorized Intercept Doc# 19-CRIM-29845156Facility- *sc# 671455
(U) Recorded Interview (Non-Custodial - Overt) DM 8/13/2019 with {REDACTED} - Philadelphia
d, NH on the aforementioned date.
Serial Rem] 50D-NY-3027571
Serial * Date
LQ¢ 3/12/2025 10:37
705 3/5/2025 13:34
ja 2/28/2025 18:10
Ma 2/27/2025 14:55
702 8/13/2024 16:54
701 9/26/2023 15:29
700 8/28/2023 17:54
699 6/17/2023 7:41
698 6/8/2023 8:38
697 5/28/2023 14:52
On 11/4/2022 12:02
¢91 7/27/2022 15:10
694 7/22/2022 12:10
693 6/30/2022 19:53
692 6/3/2022 12:05
691 5/26/2022 9:36
690 5/25/2022 15:44
689 5/25/2022 15:44
¢1% 5/24/2022 21:40
§3/ 3/15/2022 9:06
686 2/11/2022 12:16
685 1/31/2022 13:20
§1U 1/20/202214:13
683 1/18/2022 16:26
682 12/15/2021 9:33
681 12/14/2021 14:29
680 12/14/2021 10:30
§12 12/6/2021 11:09
01 12/2/2021 12:13
677 11/29/2021 11:13
§1¢ 11/16/2021 16:13
E71 11/16/2021 13:09
674 11/15/2021 11:22
673 11/14/2021 16:56
672 11/11/2021 9:31
El 11/8/2021 12:33
670 10/26/2021 9:42
669 10/25/2021 7:35
gl 10/21/2021 15:23
§§/ 10/18/2021 13:07
666 10/15/2021 9:43
665 10/15/2021 9:40
664 10/8/2021 17:15
663 10/8/2021 17:11
662 10/8/2021 17:09
661 10/8/2021 17:07
§E2 10/8/2021 17:05
§.52 10/8/2021 17:03
658 10/8/2021 16:59
01 10/8/202112:44
656 10/7/2021 18:27
655 10/7/2021 12:51
654 10/6/2021 14:02
653 9/30/2021 18:44
652 9/30/2021 18:44
651 9/30/2021 13:20
650 9/30/2021 13:19
42 9/30/2021 13:19
M 9/30/2021 13:19
647 9/29/2021 10:14
646 9/24/2021 14:52
645 9/23/2021 13:41
644 9/23/2021 10:44
643 9/17/2021 12:55
642 9/17/2021 12:54
01 9/17/2021 12:54
fa 9/17/2021 10:57
639 9/17/2021 10:57
638 9/17/2021 10:56
13Z 9/17/2021 10:54
636 9/16/2021 16:21
635 9/16/2021 16:21
634 9/16/2021 16:21
633 9/16/2021 16:21
§3/ 9/16/2021 10:53
631 9/16/2021 10:53
630 9/16/2021 10:53
§22 9/15/2021 11:30
628 9/14/2021 17:04
627 9/14/2021 17:03
626 9/14/2021 17:03
625 9/9/2021 11:16
ka 8/9/2021 14:46
623 8/9/2021 14:04
622 8/9/2021 14:04
fial 8/9/2021 13:08
620 8/9/2021 11:47
619 8/2/2021 11:15
618 7/29/2021 17:57
617 7/26/2021 12:09
616 7/21/2021 17:06
615 7/19/2021 12:21
614 7/13/2021 9:22
al 7/12/2021 12:46
ll  7/6/2021 11:30
611 7/2/2021 13:19
ila 7/1/2021 11:45
609 6/21/2021 17:46
608 6/11/2021 14:45
607 5/24/2021 12:50
606 5/19/2021 16:38
C05. 5/19/2021 16:28
604 5/19/2021 16:27
603 5/19/2021 16:12
02 5/17/2021 14:12
10.1 5/17/2021 10:37
600 5/11/2021 12:27
599 5/11/20215:21
598 5/7/2021 15:30
597 5/3/2021 16:47
596 4/27/2021 12:07
595 4/23/2021 13:26
la 4/7/2021 9:37
al 4/5/2021 10:19
592 3/31/2021 12:04
591 3/29/2021 20:03
5%2 3/22/202121:08
SN 3/22/2021 12:04
588 3/8/2021 14:18
587 3/8/202113:32
586 3/8/2021 11:09
5.41 3/4/2021 12:59
5M. 3/3/2021 10:35
583 3/2/202110:37
5.12. 2/26/2021 11:14
an 2/26/2021 11:13
580 2/24/2021 15:21
579 2/24/2021 14:48
578 2/23/2021 20:21
fl 2/23/2021 17:06
576 2/23/2021 14:00
575 2/23/2021 13:59
514 2/23/2021 13:58
511 2/23/2021 12:47
572 2/9/2021 9:46
571 2/9/2021 9:46
570 2/9/2021 9:46
569 2/9/2021 9:42
568 2/9/2021 9:40
567 2/9/2021 8:59
50 2/9/2021 8:58
Ma 2/5/2021 14:56
564 2/3/2021 10:28
if22 2/3/2021 10:28
562 1/28/20216:49
561 1/27/2021 17:16
560 1/27/2021 15:44
559 1/25/2021 15:32
558 1/19/2021 15:24
557 1/14/20219:25
556 1/13/2021 12:28
551 1/13/2021 10:35
54 1/13/2021 10:33
553 1/13/2021 10:28
552 1/12/2021 14:04
551 1/12/2021 13:59
550 1/4/2021 13:14
549 1/4/202113:11
548 1/4/2021 12:43
12/29/2020 13:13
AE 12/9/2020 11:49
545 12/8/2020 16:39
544 12/6/2020 10:08
al 12/2/2020 10:23
542 11/24/2020 12:21
541 11/10/2020 17:15
540 11/10/2020 7:47
539 11/9/2020 12:31
531 11/4/2020 18:58
531 11/2/2020 8:49
536 10/27/2020 17:03
10/27/2020 12:16
534 10/27/2020 10:36
533 10/23/2020 13:53
532 10/19/2020 18:28
531 10/19/2020 15:03
53.Q 10/19/2020 12:52
529 10/13/2020 16:30
528 10/9/2020 20:06
Z 10/7/2020 18:24
526 10/6/2020 5:20
525 10/1/2020 13:50
524 9/30/2020 12:30
523 9/24/2020 15:48
522 9/24/2020 15:48
521 9/24/2020 15:48
520 9/24/2020 15:48
la 9/24/2020 15:47
NI 9/24/202015:47
517 9/18/2020 13:14
51¢ 9/14/2020 13:52
515 9/8/2020 23:10
S14 9/4/202016:04
513 8/27/2020 11:56
512 8/27/2020 11:55
511 8/27/2020 11:53
510 8/25/2020 18:34
509 8/24/2020 17:59
59.1 8/24/2020 17:14
0/ 8/24/2020 14:08
506 8/20/2020 11:37
505 8/18/2020 15:56
504 8/17/2020 16:21
503 8/15/2020 8:08
502 8/14/2020 18:03
501 8/11/2020 17:54
5182 8/11/2020 15:12
4 8/11/2020 15:10
498 8/11/2020 9:48
497 8/11/2020 0:13
12¢ 8/7/2020 11:56
495 8/7/2020 11:55
494 8/7/2020 10:30
493 8/7/2020 9:02
492 8/6/2020 15:29
191 8/6/2020 11:07
490 8/6/2020 7:47
489 8/5/2020 19:23
AM 8/5/2020 12:55
487 8/4/2020 14:50
486 8/3/2020 18:25
485 8/3/202013:14
484 8/3/2020 9:36
gl 7/30/2020 19:56
482 7/30/2020 15:25
481 7/30/2020 14:54
4Q 7/30/202012:22
412 7/29/2020 20:34
476 7/28/2020 15:47
477 7/28/2020 15:47
476 7/28/2020 15:47
475 7/27/2020 8:10
474 7/26/2020 19:13
473 7/22/2020 18:31
472 7/22/2020 11:45
471 7/22/2020 11:23
470 7/22/2020 9:23
AU 7/22/2020 8:48
40 7/21/2020 15:42
467 7/21/2020 15:41
466 7/20/2020 11:21
465 7/19/2020 4:02
464 7/19/2020 3:57
463 7/18/2020 1:36
462 7/17/2020 19:21
442 7/17/2020 16:46
4Q 7/17/2020 16:12
459 7/17/2020 12:58
458 7/17/2020 1:56
457 7/16/2020 11:26
456 7/15/2020 23:00
455 7/15/2020 14:57
454 7/15/2020 14:26
15.1 7/15/2020 13:42
152 7/14/2020 14:07
451 7/14/2020 14:06
450 7/14/2020 13:39
M2 7/14/2020 13:36
448 7/13/2020 15:45
447 7/13/2020 15:43
446 7/13/2020 10:52
445 7/13/2020 10:19
444 7/12/2020 12:09
..kil 7/11/2020 11:08
442 7/11/2020 0:10
441 7/10/2020 19:05
440 7/10/2020 13:34
439 7/10/2020 13:06
438 7/9/2020 22:47
437 7/9/2020 21:32
426 7/9/202015:09
435 7/9/202015:08
434 7/9/2020 13:01
432 7/9/202013:00
432 7/9/2020 11:12
431 7/9/2020 2:28
430 7/8/202018:00
429 7/8/2020 15:21
428 7/8/202013:09
427 7/8/2020 13:01
426 7/7/2020 18:14
1.ZI 7/7/2020 17:56
424 7/7/2020 17:48
423 7/7/2020 14:37
422 7/7/2020 13:33
421 7/7/2020 11:50
420 7/7/2020 11:36
419 7/6/2020 12:51
418 7/3/2020 20:07
417 7/3/2020 18:48
416 7/3/2020 18:12
415 7/2/2020 19:18
414 7/2/2020 17:11
ill 7/2/2020 16:07
412 7/2/2020 12:44
410 6/19/2020 7:19
409 6/18/2020 10:42
408 6/15/2020 17:44
406 5/21/2020 18:59
405 5/20/2020 13:12
le 5/14/2020 12:54
NI 5/14/2020 12:54
402 5/14/2020 11:32
401 5/7/2020 11:20
02 5/6/2020 11:28
399 4/23/2020 15:43
398 4/23/2020 15:42
397 4/23/2020 14:07
396 4/23/2020 14:05
121 4/23/202014:05
am 4/23/2020 14:04
393 4/23/2020 14:03
19.2. 4/23/2020 14:03
391 4/23/2020 13:59
390 4/23/2020 13:58
389 4/23/2020 13:57
388 4/23/2020 13:56
KZ 4/23/2020 13:56
386 4/23/2020 13:55
385 4/23/2020 13:54
le 4/23/2020 13:53
313. 4/23/2020 13:52
382 4/23/2020 13:49
381 4/18/2020 11:02
380 4/15/2020 8:10
379 4/9/2020 14:34
378 4/7/202010:53
377 3/31/2020 10:35
VA 3/31/2020 10:21
321 3/31/2020 10:20
374 3/31/2020 10:09
222 3/31/2020 10:08
3.22 3/26/2020 13:52
371 3/26/2020 13:50
370 3/19/2020 12:47
369 3/16/2020 17:07
368 2/27/2020 9:17
367 2/19/2020 12:44
366 2/13/2020 17:28
3121 2/13/2020 17:16
3..4 2/6/202010:41
363 2/4/2020 12:21
362 2/3/202010:29
361 1/31/2020 15:50
360 1/24/2020 15:38
359 1/24/2020 9:36
358 1/23/2020 18:45
5/ 1/23/2020 2:08
¢ 1/22/2020 16:58
355 1/21/2020 10:37
354 1/17/2020 14:17
152 1/17/2020 14:13
352 1/15/2020 10:17
351 1/15/2020 10:13
350 1/14/2020 14:30
349 1/14/2020 14:17
ig 1/14/2020 14:03
MZ 1/10/2020 15:29
346 1/10/2020 15:28
3A1 1/10/2020 15:28
344 1/10/2020 15:27
343 1/8/2020 17:43
342 1/6/2020 17:47
341 1/2/2020 9:42
Iv 1/2/2020 7:12
339 12/18/2019 17:32
338 12/18/2019 17:32
231 12/13/2019 14:06
¢ 12/13/2019 12:18
335 12/13/2019 10:28
334 12/13/2019 10:28
333 12/11/2019 5:53
332 12/11/2019 5:52
331 12/10/2019 18:11
330 12/4/2019 11:19
la 12/4/2019 10:36
121 12/4/2019 5:21
327 11/26/2019 12:10
32¢ 11/26/2019 12:08
325 11/26/2019 12:05
324 11/26/2019 12:03
323 11/23/2019 22:07
322 11/19/2019 15:27
321 11/14/2019 11:52
320 11/13/2019 21:00
319 11/13/2019 12:30
ilk 11/10/2019 16:20
31/ 10/24/2019 17:48
316 10/23/2019 15:53
315 10/23/2019 15:46
314 10/23/2019 13:55
313 10/23/2019 9:40
312 10/22/2019 20:39
311 10/22/2019 17:37
31Q 10/21/2019 7:04
Q2 10/18/2019 16:22
308 10/18/2019 13:41
307 10/12/2019 18:23
3.Q¢ 10/9/2019 11:20
305 10/8/2019 21:13
304 10/3/2019 16:39
303 10/3/2019 15:04
302 10/2/2019 13:53
Q1 10/1/2019 16:40
300 9/27/2019 16:31
299 9/27/2019 16:31
221 9/26/2019 8:59
122 9/26/2019 8:59
296 9/26/2019 8:58
295 9/25/2019 17:00
294 9/25/2019 15:23
221 9/24/2019 10:49
292 9/19/2019 14:28
291 9/19/2019 14:28
2Z2 9/19/2019 10:05
182 9/17/2019 17:33
288 9/17/2019 15:43
287 9/17/2019 13:39
286 9/17/2019 10:47
285 9/16/2019 14:46
284 9/16/2019 13:13
283 9/16/2019 10:42
822 9/14/2019 19:24
a$1. 9/14/2019 17:01
280 9/12/2019 21:31
222 9/12/2019 11:04
VI 9/11/2019 14:42
277 9/10/2019 20:08
276 9/10/2019 17:23
275 9/10/2019 16:47
274 9/9/2019 11:16
273 9/6/2019 12:41
272 9/6/2019 9:34
ZU 9/4/2019 17:36
ZZQ 9/4/2019 17:35
269 9/4/2019 17:32
268 9/4/2019 17:31
267 9/4/2019 17:30
266 9/3/2019 7:35
265 8/30/2019 17:29
264 8/30/2019 16:46
MI 8/30/2019 10:10
/62 8/30/2019 5:12
261 8/29/2019 15:13
260 8/29/2019 8:22
2.52 8/28/2019 10:58
258 8/28/2019 7:29
257 8/27/2019 10:24
256 8/25/2019 10:10
255 8/23/2019 17:22
524 8/23/2019 7:44
253 8/23/2019 7:41
252 8/22/2019 20:10
251 8/22/2019 11:52
250 8/22/2019 11:16
249 8/22/2019 10:50
248 8/21/2019 12:09
247 8/21/2019 10:36
341 8/20/2019 13:25
245 8/20/2019 13:03
244 8/20/2019 13:01
2.11 8/20/2019 13:00
242 8/20/2019 12:29
241 8/17/2019 22:12
240 8/17/2019 20:04
239 8/16/2019 19:45
238 8/16/2019 12:45
237 8/16/2019 11:45
236 8/16/2019 8:41
2.41 8/15/2019 18:28
IM 8/15/2019 16:58
233 8/15/2019 13:01
232 8/15/2019 12:25
231 8/15/2019 12:05
230 8/15/2019 8:33
229 8/15/2019 7:59
228 8/14/2019 17:53
227 8/14/2019 10:34
226 8/14/2019 8:43
225 8/14/2019 8:20
224 8/13/2019 21:54
221 8/13/2019 17:09
222 8/13/2019 15:57
221 8/12/2019 22:23
220 8/11/2019 22:57
219 8/11/2019 14:32
218 8/11/2019 9:21
217 8/10/2019 15:36
a.6 8/9/2019 19:42
al 8/9/2019 11:11
214 8/9/2019 11:07

213. 8/8/2019 17:44
2.12 8/8/2019 16:09
211 8/8/2019 9:32
210 8/8/2019 8:42
209 8/7/2019 16:54
208 8/7/2019 15:37
Di 8/7/2019 15:36
206 8/7/2019 15:35
205 8/7/2019 15:35
la 8/7/2019 15:09
203 8/7/2019 13:26
202 8/7/2019 13:26
201 8/7/2019 0:47
200 8/6/2019 19:16
122 8/2/2019 15:24
198 8/2/2019 13:11
197 8/2/2019 10:22
344 8/1/2019 9:05
195 7/31/2019 16:43
194 7/31/2019 14:53
193 7/31/2019 14:49
192 7/31/2019 14:49
191 7/31/2019 14:48
190 7/31/2019 14:48
189 7/31/2019 4:13
UM 7/30/2019 18:01
1.81 7/30/2019 18:00
186 7/30/2019 17:59

215. 7/30/2019 17:59
184 7/30/2019 15:26
183 7/29/2019 13:22
182 7/29/2019 9:38
181 7/28/2019 15:12
al  7/27/2019 4:39
179 7/26/2019 19:52
178 7/26/2019 9:43
222 7/25/2019 18:09
ILE 7/25/2019 15:29
175 7/24/2019 12:02
174 7/24/2019 3:09
173 7/23/2019 18:13
172 7/23/2019 17:28
171 7/23/2019 17:26
170 7/23/2019 17:20
le 7/23/2019 17:19
al 7/23/2019 17:18
167 7/23/2019 17:18
166 7/23/2019 17:17
1¢2 7/23/2019 17:09
164 7/23/2019 12:25
163 7/22/2019 10:08
162 7/21/2019 10:37
161 7/20/2019 3:21
1.C2 7/19/2019 20:46
159 7/19/2019 14:59
158 7/19/2019 14:07
15Z 7/18/2019 16:46
156 7/18/2019 8:37
155 7/17/2019 17:03
154 7/17/2019 16:50
153 7/17/2019 16:42
152 7/17/2019 16:36
151 7/17/2019 12:23
150 7/17/2019 12:03
142 7/17/2019 12:01
148 7/17/2019 8:33
147 7/16/2019 14:44
146 7/16/2019 14:36
145 7/16/2019 14:35
144 7/16/2019 13:59
143 7/15/2019 22:25
142 7/15/2019 17:52
141 7/15/2019 15:59
14Q 7/15/2019 12:02
139 7/15/2019 11:53
DI 7/15/2019 11:06
137 7/15/2019 8:53
136 7/15/2019 3:15
135 7/15/2019 1:07
134 7/14/2019 18:03
133 7/13/2019 20:25
132 7/13/2019 18:05
131 7/13/2019 15:26
13Q 7/13/2019 15:04
119 7/13/2019 11:24
128 7/12/2019 22:55
127 7/12/2019 20:31
126 7/12/2019 19:44
125 7/12/2019 19:44
124 7/12/2019 18:58
123 7/12/2019 15:11
122 7/12/2019 13:40
al, 7/12/2019 13:27
120 7/12/2019 12:48
119 7/12/2019 12:37
118 7/12/2019 11:38
117 7/12/2019 9:46
116 7/12/2019 7:13
115 7/11/2019 22:51
114 7/11/2019 19:59
a. 1 7/11/2019 16:07
112 7/11/2019 12:32
111 7/11/2019 12:12
11Q 7/11/2019 11:09
109 7/11/2019 10:34
108 7/10/2019 23:43
107 7/10/2019 17:06
106 7/10/2019 17:05
1Qa 7/10/2019 17:05
104 7/10/2019 15:48
103 7/10/2019 15:42
12 7/10/2019 15:03
1Q1 7/10/2019 14:42
100 7/10/2019 12:10
99 7/10/2019 12:05
98 7/10/2019 10:39
97 7/10/2019 10:22
96 7/10/2019 9:46
95 7/10/2019 6:25
a 7/10/2019 0:26
22 7/9/2019 22:27
92 7/9/2019 20:49
21 7/9/2019 19:33
2Q 7/9/2019 19:10
89 7/9/2019 17:40
88 7/9/2019 17:35
87 7/9/2019 17:23
86 7/9/2019 16:44
85 7/9/2019 16:42
84 7/9/2019 16:36
82 7/9/2019 16:30
82 7/9/2019 16:17
81 7/9/2019 16:12
80 7/9/2019 15:10
22 7/9/2019 13:28
78 7/9/2019 12:43
77 7/9/2019 11:32
76 7/9/2019 10:58
22 7/9/2019 7:51
22 7/8/2019 23:09
73 7/8/2019 22:30
72 7/8/2019 22:10
21 7/8/2019 21:44
70 7/8/2019 21:01
69 7/8/2019 20:43
68 7/8/2019 20:24
67 7/8/2019 20:12
22 7/8/2019 19:41
65 7/8/2019 19:37
64 7/8/2019 19:25
82 7/8/2019 18:53
62 7/8/2019 18:24
61 7/8/2019 18:23
60 7/8/2019 17:52
59 7/8/2019 17:47
M 7/8/2019 17:11
57 7/8/2019 16:28
56 7/8/2019 16:14
a 7/8/2019 16:00
a 7/8/2019 15:57
53 7/8/2019 15:50
52 7/8/2019 15:37
51 7/8/2019 15:10
50 7/8/2019 14:28
49 7/8/2019 14:27
48 7/8/2019 14:19
47 7/8/2019 14:09
lk 7/8/2019 13:58
45 7/8/2019 13:53
44 7/8/2019 13:51
41 7/8/2019 13:43
42 7/8/2019 13:36
41 7/8/2019 13:17
40 7/8/2019 13:05
39 7/8/2019 12:39
38 7/8/2019 12:38
37 7/8/2019 12:30
al 7/8/2019 12:26
24 7/8/2019 12:18
34 7/8/2019 12:17
33 7/8/2019 12:12
32 7/8/2019 12:05
31 7/8/2019 12:02
30 7/8/2019 9:21
29 7/7/2019 20:22
a 7/7/2019 6:44
22 7/1/2019 11:30
26 7/1/2019 10:58
25 7/1/2019 10:12
24 6/24/2019 14:25
23 6/4/2019 11:06
22 5/28/2019 12:47
21 5/22/2019 15:57
20 5/6/2019 16:59
12 5/6/2019 16:59
18 4/30/2019 13:57
17 4/23/2019 11:20
j& 4/17/2019 14:49
15 4/5/2019 13:17
14 4/4/2019 10:57
13 4/4/2019 10:51
12 3/27/2019 16:52
11 3/27/2019 16:51
10 3/27/2019 16:50
9 3/15/2019 11:18
I 3/8/2019 17:47
Z 3/6/2019 13:50
6 2/14/2019 18:46
5 2/12/2019 11:41
4 1/31/2019 12:08
3 1/31/2019 10:46
1/15/2019 9:11
12/6/2018 18:33
Title

(U) Transport of Evidence Items 1B136, 1B144, 1B145, and 18146
(U) Rule 6(e) Letters
(U) Transfer of Case Documents from the New York Field Office to the Washington Field Office

(U) Valuables Charge Out
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) On 09/26/2023, at 2:44 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, called the FBI National Threat
U Potential witness tampering/retaliation and interstate threats of {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) On 06/16/2023, at 3:39 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) Correspondence to Director Wray from {REDACTED}, Esq.
(U) On 05/18/2023, at 10:26 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}), date of birth (REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) Identification of {REDACTED} as a possible associate of JEFFREY EPSTEIN

(U) Sentencing of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U) Derivative evidence created
(U) On 06/30/2022, at 6:33 PM Eastern Time,(REDACTED), date of birth(REDACTED)

(U) Mail Received from Epstein Residence
(U) FD1004
(U) Derivative evidence created
(U) Derivative evidence created

(U) On 05/24/2022, at 8:21 p.m. Eastern lime, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), with
(U) Phone Interview with {REDACTED}

(U) Defense Notes for (REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records for Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Conviction of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Request to obtain information regarding UK solicitor (REDACTED)

(U) Request to obtain information regarding UK citizen
(U) Telephonic Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Telephonic interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Request NY ECU to transfer evidence to Denver FO
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) On 11/16/2021, at 1:52 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} [PROTECT IDENTITY),

(U) On 11/16/2021, at 11:35 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) On 11/14/2021, at 4:24 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} [PROTECT IDENTITY), cellular
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Phone conversation with {REDACTED}
(U) Call with {REDACTED}
(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
U//FOUO Accusations of Rape and human trafficking
(U) Collect evidence
(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department
U//FOUO NTOC2021 E-Tip Additional Victim Reports Being Human Trafficked By Gislaine Maxwell As A Child (TP)
U NTOC2020 352mtr01 Information on a Possible Accountant of Jeffrey Epstein. (NY)
U//FOUO NTOC2020 024srm01 E-Tip: Possible Human Trafficking in New York, NY. (NY)
U USPS Mail Tipster - Information Related to Jeffrey Epstein/Unnamed 29 YOA Jewish Female
U NTOC2020 19Shmb02 Potential Sex Trafficking by {REDACTED} and {REDACTED} in New York, NY (NY)
U Email regarding information for sale about the Epstein Zorro Ranch
U//FOUO NTOC2021Conceming Comments by {REDACTED}. (NY)

(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial
(U) Fed-Ex Delivery Confirmation
U Victim of Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Request Transfer of Evidence Item 1B139 to FBI NY ECR
(U) Interview of (REDACTED) - September 2, 2021

(U) Meeting with {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Proffer of {REDACTED}
(U) Service of subpoena.

(U) On 9/23/2021, at 9:S8 AM Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED),
(U) Interview of (REDACTED) - September 1, 2021

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview/Proffer of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Proffer of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED} August 30, 2021

(U) Interview of (REDACTED).- August 31, 2021
(U) Request to serve three trial subpoenas
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)- July 27, 2021
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) On 9/9/2021, at 10:S1 AM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) {REDACTED}interview 8/4/2021
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) On 08/09/2021, at 12:09 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) Documentation of Services by VS {REDACTED} 04/01/2021-06/30/2021
(U) TRIAL SUBPOENA SERVED ON RI OFFICE OF {REDACTED}

(U) Trial Subpoena Served on (REDACTED) on 07/28/2021
(U) On 7/26/2021, at 11:16 AM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, Email account {REDACTED}

(U) Locate and Serve witness (REDACTED)
(U) Missouri Birth Certificate Identified and obtained
(U) On 07/13/2021, at 8:36 AM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}, home

(U) Device Extraction - MDUS 13768
(U) Request for Birth Certificate
(U) Collection of Evidence, Austin, TX
(U//FOUO) Collection of evidence in Austin, Texas

(U) On 06/21/2021 at 04:07 p.m. {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}, cellular
(U) On 6/10/2021, at 10:07 AM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of {REDACTED},

(U) 1A Lab Report Material: Lab # {REDACTED}
U Implied Threats Via Communication
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Introductory conversation with {REDACTED}
(U) 2021-00585-2 Questioned Documents

(U) Interview of Judge {REDACTED} - Maryland
(U) Request assistance to pick up evidence from victim/witness
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Request to obtain inbound and outbound travel records from the UK

(U) Request to obtain inbound and outbound travel records from the UK
(U) Documentation of Services by VS {REDACTED} 01/01/2021-03/31/2021

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
U NTOC2020 288hmb01 Alleged Money Laundering by {REDACTED} via {REDACTED}I and {REDACTED}
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Request to obtain inbound and outbound travel records from the UK

(U) {REDACTED} 02.16.2021
(U) Request to obtain inbound and outbound travel records from the UK
(U) On 03/29/2021, at 7:21 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 3/22/2021, at 7:51 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 03/22/2021, at 10:43 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) On 03/08/2021, at 10:55a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED} - Day 3
(U) Interview of {REDACTED} - Day 1
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Virtual Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Telephonic Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Introductory Conversation with {REDACTED}
(U) Introductory Conversation with {REDACTED} and her counsel

(U) Information provided by {REDACTED}
(U) Request for Laboratory Examinations
(U) Phone Call from {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED} Day 2
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Proffer of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview/Proffer of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Request coordination of witness interview of {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Responsiveness Review of Digital Evidence processed by CART
(U//FOUO) Highly confidential responsive material from digital evidence processed by CART

(U) Request to locate UK citizen {REDACTED}
S4-013.pdf
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Call received from {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Ten yearbooks received from FBI West Palm Beach Resident Agency

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) On 12/06/2020, at 9:32 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Victim Services Division - Case Support Unit Assistance
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) On 11/09/2020, at 5:16 p.m. Eastern time,{REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On 11/02/2020 at 5:58 AM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 10/27/2020, at 3:20 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) Fund Reimbursement - Five 2TB Hard drives
(U) Fund Reimbursement EC
(U) Fund Reimbursement -12 TB External Hard Drive
(U -011.pdf

(U) On 10/19/2020, at 2:00 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 10/19/2020, at 11:43 AM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 10/12/2020, at 3:14 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 10/09/2020, at 7:22:58 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) International Travel Request and Country Clearance to London, UK
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Notification and concurrence to conduct interview of UK citizen

(U) Notification and concurrence of UK citizen interview
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Cell Phone Location Information Warrant for {REDACTED}

(U) Cell Phone Location Information Warrant for {REDACTED}
(U) Search Warrant for six binders seized from(REDACTED)

(U) Search Warrant for items seized from Little St James
(U) Search Warrant for items seized from Jeffrey Epstein & (REDACTED)

(U) Search Warrant for items seized from (REDACTED)
(U) Search Warrant for {REDACTED}, New York, New York

(U) On 09/14/2020, at 12:12 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth(REDACTED},
(U) On 09/08/2020, at 10:29 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) Documentation of Services by VS (REDACTED) 04/01/2020-06/30/2020
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) On 08/24/2020, at 12:06:59 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}
(U) On 08/24/2020, at 11:34:48 AM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), Home telephone number

(U) On 08/24/2020, at 4:31 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},
(U) 50D-NY-3027571
(U) On 08/20/2020, at 10:31:12 AM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) On 08/17/2020, at 3:03 PM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth(REDACTED},
(U) On 08/17/2020, at 3:32 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) Date Submitted: 07/12/202007:06:53 PM ET Transaction Number: 07A23145-D0C9-438C-
(U) Documentation of services

(U) On 08/11/2020, at 7:26 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), email
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoena Service- (REDACTED)
(U) On 08/10/2020, at 08/10/2020 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (Anonymous

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Notification of intent to conduct a voluntary witness interview of a UK citizen

(U) Attempted Contact with (REDACTED)
(U) On 08/06/2020, at 02:27 PM, (REDACTED), Cell Telephone {REDACTED}, Called the FBI

(U) On 08/06/2020, at 10:12 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED),
(U) Notification of UK citizen interview

(U) On 08/05/2020, at 5:48 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, email address (REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) On 08/03/2020, at 12:28 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), IP
(U) On 08/03/2020, at 5:11 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time, (REDACTED), date of birth

(U) On 08/02/2020, at 11:54 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, cell phone number(REDACTED)
(U) Aerial Surveillance

(U) Grand jury subpoena service to (REDACTED); coverage for Lead 14.
(U) On 07/29/2020, at 2:46:26 PM Eastern Time, Anonymous, Internet Protocol (IP) address

(U) On 07/09/2020, at 8:52:54 AM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},
(U) On 07/29/2020, at 2:14:24 PM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On 07/29/2020, at 7:45 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), Internet
(U) Lead Request to Serve grand Jury subpoena (REDACTED)

(U) Lead Request to Serve grand Jury subpoena (REDACTED)
(U) Lead Request to Serve grand jury subpoena (REDACTED)

(U) Date Submitted: 07/25/202010:08:31 AM ET Transaction Number: 4D291278-35FF-489A-A26C
(U) On 07/26/2020, at 4:44 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED}, home
a( -008.pdf

(U) On 07/22/2020, at 9:28:05 AM Eastern Time, {REDACTED), date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 07/22/2020, at 10:07 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 07/18/2020, at 5:45 p.m. Eastern Time, an ANONYMOUS (hereafter ANON), Internet
(U) On 07/21/2020, at 2:17 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U//FOUO) Telephone Interview Of (REDACTED)

(U) Arrest of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U) On 07/17/2020 at 5:20 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On 07/18/2020, at 2:22 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, cell telephone number +
(U) On 07/17/2020, at 4:03 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, cell telephone number +

(U) NTOC2020 200ko1 Information Regarding Jeffery Epstein Human Trafficking case.: SOD-NY
(U//FOUO) On 07/17/2020, at 6:37:42 PM Eastern Time, An anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol

(U) On 07/17/2020, at 3:03 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},
(U) (U) On 07/17/2020, at 02:53 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth
at-216.pdf

(U) On 07/16/2020, at 10:27 PM, Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) Information Regarding Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. On 07/15/2020, at 8:45
(U//FOUO) NTOC2020 197ab02 On 07/15/2020 at 9:45p.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of
(U//FOUO) Contacts of {REDACTED}, security personnel for Ghislaine Maxwell

(U) On 07/15/2020, at 1:41:32 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED},
(U) Pen Register on Ghislaine Maxwell's phone number

(U) Pen Register renewal on Ghislaine Maxwell's phone number
(U) Documentation of Services
(U//FOUO) Impersonation of FBI Agent
(U//FOUO) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Ghislaine Maxwell, Mall Cover Information
(U) Pen Register renewal on Ghislaine Maxwell's phone number

(U) On 07/08/2020, at 10:49 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},
(U) On 07/12/2020, at 3:12:08 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED},

(U) NTOC2020 194jcc01 E-TIP: Anonymous User Reporting (REDACTED) Possess Videos of
(U) On 07/11/2020, at 10:02 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol

(U) On 07/09/2020, at 9:47 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, email address{REDACTED}
(U) On 07/09/2020, at 5:46:58 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED},

(U) On 07/10/2020, at 9:44 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP
(U) On 07/10/2020, at 9:22 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP

(U) (U)On 07/09/2020 at 8:29 p.m. {REDACTED)(PROTECT IDENTITY), date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 07/08/2020 at 6:01 P.M. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), email address

(U) Fund Reimbursement
(U) Pen Register on Ghislaine Maxwell's phone number
(U) On 07/07/2020, at 8:03:18 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, Internet Protocol (IP) address

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 10:19 AM Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) On 07/09/2020, at 9:51 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} (PROTECT IDENITITY), date of

(U) On 07/08/2020, at 11:50 PM, Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),
(U) On 07/08/2020, at 4:42 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 3:39:20 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U//FOUO) Aerial photos of 301 Summer Street Manchester by the Sea, Massachusetts 01944.

(U) On 07/08/2020, at 12:00 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous (Anonymous) tipster, using
(U) On 07/07/2020, at 5:59 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}(PROTECT IDENTITY), date of

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 5:03:34 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTEDI,
(U) On 07/07/2020, at 5:27 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},
(U//FOUO) On 07/06/2020, at 12:59 p.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 12:33:51 PM Eastern Time, an anonymous complainant, Email account
(U) On 07/07/2020, at 10:57 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 10:49:04 AM Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (
(U) NTOC2020 188ahm01 Information Regarding Ghislaine Maxwell. (NY) On 07/06/2020, at

(U) On 07/03/2020, at 5:21:13 PM Eastern Time, (REDACITD}[PROTECT IDENTITY), date of
(U//FOUO) On 07/02/2020, at 5:57:18 PM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth{REDACTED},

(U) NTOC2020-MC3 185vkavOl On 07/03/2020, at 4:44 p.m. EST, international
(U) On 07/02/202, at 5:52:20 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) (U)On 07/02/2020, at 2:52:51 PM Eastern Time, ANONYMOUS, Cellular telephone number
(U) On 07/02/2020, at 1:28:41 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},
(U//FOUO) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 192vmd01 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/11/2019, at 11:06
(U) On 06/11/2020, at 11:03:51 AM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth{REDACTED},

(U) On 06/14/2020, at 4:50:33 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED),
(U) FD1064 - 2020-05-21T12-59-59.xml

(U) Information provided by {REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED} on 10/25/19
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}

(U) F01064 - 2020-05-13T04-35-32.xml
(U) SOD-NY-3027571
(U) On 03/10/2020, at 12:24 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED} on 11.21.19

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED)
(U) interview of {REDACTED)
(U) Proffer of (REDACTED} Interview #2

(U) Proffer of (REDACTED} Interview #1
(U) Interview of (REDACTED) on 10/11/2019
(U) SOD-NY-3027571
(U) Pass Information to Swedish authorities for informational purposes.

(U) interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Share information with Swedish Authorities
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Proffer of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Non-Transitory/For Record
(U) On 03/19/2020, at 11:13:52 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) California Trip Request
(U) On 02/19/2020, at 12:11 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) Interview of (REDACTED) 12/17/2019 ____
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) NTOC2020 37ch01 E-Tip: Involvement with Jeffrey Epstein, Sex Trafficking, and Murder

(U) 50D-NY-3027571
(U) Documentation of Services by VS (REDACTED)10/1/19-12/31/19
(U) Request Country Clearance and FBIHQ travel authority to Stockholm, Sweden

(U) Legat Copenhagen - Pass information and concurrence to Interview Swedish citizen
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) VSD Documentation of Services
(U) On 01/23/2020 at 12:10 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Phone conversation with (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Phone call with Attorney (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) (REDACTED) Interview
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Documentation of Services by VS (REDACTED) 7/1/19-9/30/19

(U) On 01/02/2020, at 3:46 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED}3,
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director
(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) California Trip Request
(U) (REDACTED) Interview
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) On 12/09/2019, at 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED) on 9/19/2019
(U) To document call with (REDACTED).

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)on 11/14/2019
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED) on 7/31/19

(U) Proffer of (REDACTED) Interview #1
(U) On 11/23/2019, at 8:33 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED)

(U) Victim Services Division - Victim Meeting
(U) Terrorism Victim Assistance Fund and Budget Matters, Victim Services Division

(U) (REDACTED) contact with FBI Seattle re: (REDACTED)
(U) NTOC2019 317bmm01 Knowledge of Two Women Working For Epstein On 11/13/2019 at 9:40

(U) On 11/10/2019, at 2:43 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),
(U) Holiday Pay Request

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) (REDACTED) Interview
(U) Terrorism Victim Assistance Fund and Budget Matters, Victim Services Division

(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)
(U) (REDACTED) (PROTECT SOURCE) Interview #4
(U) On 08/11/2019, at 8:09:38 PM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) On 10/21/2019, at 5:58 am Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED), home
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records for Ghislaine Maxwell
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Ghislaine Maxwell

(U) On 10/11/2019, at 1:37:25 PM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),
(U) Lead Forwared to Legat Mexico City, Mexico

(U) On 10/08/2019, at 8:40 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records for (REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) (REDACTED) Interview
(U) (REDACTED) Interview
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) On 09/25/2019, at 2:08 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) )000000000(
(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)
(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)

(U) Date Submitted: 09/14/2019 03:33:55 AM EST Transaction Number: 1DBC5395-3782461D-
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)
(U) On 09/17/2019, at 12:40 pm Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Device Unlock and Extraction - MDUS 10398
(U) California Trip Request
(U) Device Unlock and Extraction - MDUS 10399

(U) On 09/13/2019, at 6:30 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED)
(U) On 09/14/2019, at 2:58 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) On 09/11/2019, at 7:53 p.m. Eastern lime, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), Internet
(U) On 09/10/2019, at 08:45 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol

(U) On 09/11/2019, at 1:42:18 PM Eastern Time, the Law Office of (REDACTED),
(U) On 09/10/2019, at 5:44 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}[PROTECT

(U) On 09/10/2019, at 12:36:56 PM Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Little Saint James Island

(U) New Criminal Case: 31E-NY-3027571-FF; Seizure: 3540-19-F-474; Asset ID: 19-FBI-006034
(U) FBI New York - Jeffrey Epstein - Child Sex Trafficking - 190904-175728

(U) Follow-Up Law Enforcement Inquiries Pertaining to (REDACTED)
(U) Interview Of (REDACTED)
(U) (REDACTED)

(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James
(U) Supplemental To Jeffrey E Epstein Arrest on July 06, 2019

(U) On 8/31/2019 at 8:50 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), cell number (REDACTED)
(U) On 08/30/2019, at 4:56 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of
(U//FOUO) (REDACTED) (PROTECT SOURCE) Interview #3

(U) Late submission of evidence
(U) An anonymous caller, international telephone number (REDACTED), stated that she

(U) Phone interview of (REDACTED)
(U) On 08/28/2019, at 10:55:42 AM Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol

(U) On 08/28/2019, at 09:48 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED)
U (REDACTED) - financial connection to JEFFREY EPSTEIN
U NTOC2019 1971(103 E-Tip: Information Regarding Multiple Criminal Allegations such as Human Sex Traffi

(U) On 08/25/2019, at 9:03 A.M. Eastern Time, an Anonymous female caller (Anonymous),
(U) (U) On 08/22/2019, at 4:34 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED}, email address (REDACTED)

(U) On 08/22/2019, at 4:55 P.M. Eastern Time, (REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) (U)Date Submitted: 08/12/201910:41:15 PM EST Transaction Number: 6AC08539-244A-4664-
(U//FOU0) (REDACTED} (PROTECT SOURCE) Interview #2

(U) Search warrant executed on Little St James
(U) {REDACTED} Phone Interview
(U) Recorded Interview (Non-Custodial - Overt) DTD 8/13/2019 with (REDACTED) - Philadelphia

(U) {REDACTED} Interview
(U) On 08/21/2019 at 10:05 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) Inventory of Two Suite Cases (black/blue) for JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U) {REDACTED}- Legat London
(U) Transfer of Evidence from Miami case file to NY case file

(U) Amended Suitcase Inventory on 07/31/2019
(U) On 08/12/2019, at 12:27 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} [PROTECT IDENTITY], cellular

(U) On 08/17/2019 at 8:29 p.m. Eastern time, Anonymous female contacted the FBI National
(U) On 08/17/2019, at 6:38 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female (Anonymous), age 32

(U) On 08/16/2019, at 6:28 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED),
(U) On 8/15/19, at 11:15 a.m. Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)

(U) On 08/16/2019, at 10:12 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}
(U) On 08/15/2019, at 8:00 p.m. Eastern Time, Psychologist {REDACTED},

(U) On 08/15/2019, at 5:12 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}
(U) On 08/14/2019, at 3:43 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED},

(U) On 08/10/2019, at 11:01 a.m. Eastern Time, Anonymous [PROTECT IDENTITY], date of
(U) On 08/10/2019, at 3:46 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},

(U) On 08/11/2019, at 7:38 a.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}, who
(U) {REDACTED} stated that her son recruited not only young girls, but young boys as well

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 227jcc01 E-TIP: Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 08/13/2019
(U) On 08/14/2019, at 4:15 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}(PROTECT IDENTITY', date of

(U) On 08/14/2013, 10:04 a.m., Eastern Time, (REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED},
(U) On 08/11/2019, at 9:01 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},

(U) On 8/11/2019, at 11:28:04 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, Other telephone number +
(U) On 08/13/2019 at 5:49 p.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},

(U) On 08/13/2019, at 4:06:17 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) Reporting from{REDACTED} (Closed)

(U) On 08/12/2019, at 8:35 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}
(U) On 08/11/2019, at 10:36 p.m. Eastern time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 08/11/2019, at 1:40 P.M. Eastern Time, an anonymous caller (Anonymous), telephone
(U) NTOC2019-MC3 223fas01 E-Tip: Crisis Intake Regarding Jeffrey Epstein Human Traffickin

(U) On 07/27/2019, at 6:06 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP
(U//FOUO) (REDACTEDRPROTECT SOURCE) Interview One

(U) {REDACTED}
(U) On 08/08/2019, at 9:02 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 08/08/2019, at 5:19 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) On 08/07/2019, at 2:08 p.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}[PROTECT IDENTITY], date of

(U) Device Extraction - MDUS 10126
(U) Request to Interview{REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}

(U) Return of Property to (REDACTED} on 08/02/2019
(U) Seizure of items from safe of 9 East 71st St, NY, NY

(U) On 08/07/2019, at 1:37 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of (REDACTED} on 07/11/2019
(U) On 08/06/2019, at 10:55 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 08/06/2019, at 4:50:59 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) FDR to Legat Canberra

(U) On 8/1/2019, at 12:29:31 PM Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP
(U) NTOC2019 214mka01 Suspicious Activity by Epstein Associate(REDACTED}. (NY) On 08/02/2019

(U) On 08/01/2019, at 8:19 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, which is an alias provided
(U) On 7/31/2019, at 04:07:50 PM Eastern Time, Attorney (REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) Post Arrest Spontaneous Utterances made by Defendant JFFREY E. EPSTEIN
(U) Op Plan 7/11/2019
(U) Late submission of evidence

(U) Arrest/Search Op Plan 7/6/2019
(U) Interview offREDACTED}
(U) On 07/31/2019, at 3:20 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (Anonymous),

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}

(U) On 07/30/2019, at 02:26:42 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED),
(U) Arrest of JEFFREY EPSTEIN

(U) On 07/29/2019, at 6:48 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED},
(U) On 07/27/2019 at 02:44:33 PM EST, (REDACTED), email address (REDACTED)

(U) On 07/20/2019, at 1:51 a.m. Eastern Time (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),
(U) On 07/24/2019, at 4:23 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED)

(U) Opening EC
(U) On 07/25/2019, at 4:45 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED)
(U) On 07/25/2019, at 1:29 p.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}

(U) Jeffrey Epstein
(U) On 07/24/2019, at 2:50 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 07/23/2019, at 10:17 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth

(U) EC to document contact made with Florida victims
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interivew of (REDACTED)

(U) Interivew of (REDACTED}
(U) Interivew of (REDACTED)
(U) Interviews (or attempted) of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of(REDACTED) on 07/15/2019

(U) Seizure of items from safe of 9 East 71st, NY, NY
(U) On 07/23/2019, at 11:22 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 192vmd01 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/11/2019, at 11:06
(U) On 07/21/2019 at 10:15 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED}

(U) On 07/20/2019, at 1:51 a.m. Eastern Time (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),
(U) On 07/19/2019, at 7:48 p.m. Eastern Time, Retired New Mexico State Police Officer,

(U) Provide information to SEATTLE FO for conducting interview
(U) On 07/19/2019, at 11:36 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of

(U) On 07/18/2019 at 4:11 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED), home
(U) On 07/18/2019, at 8:14 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth(REDACTED},

(U) On 07/17/2019 at 2:54 p.m., Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED),
(U) Interivew of (REDACTED)

(U) On 07/17/2019, at 3:43 p.m. Eastern Time, the FBI's Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) On 07/17/2019, at 3:51 p.m. Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)

(U) Search Warrant Executed- 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021
(U) Interivew of (REDACTED)
(U) Attempted Interview of GHISLAINE MAXWELL

(U) On 07/12/2019, 3:33 p.m., Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED},
(U) {REDACTED}
(U) Items seized from JEFFREY EPSTEIN during his arrest

(U) Search Warrant Executed at 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021
(U) On 07/16/2019, at 12:56 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED), date of birth (REDACTED),

(U) On 07/14/2019, at 11:44 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), email
(U) On 07/15/2019, at 5:01 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 07/15/2019, at 2:51 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 07/15/2019, at 11:34 p.m. Eastern TimeAREDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED}

(U) On 07/15/2019, at 10:06 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 07/15/2019, at 10:06 a.m. Eastern TimeAREDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On 07/11/2019, at 10:48 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous (Anonymous) tipster, Internet
(U) On 07/15/2019, at 2:35 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED}

(U) On 07/013/2019 at 7:44 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 07/14/2019, at 5:24 p.m Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On 07/13/2019, at 8:04 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 1:44 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},

(U) On 07/13/2019, at 2:57 p.m. Eastern Time, an Anonymous female caller, telephone
(U) On 07/13/2019, at 2:19 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On 07/13/2019, at 10:31 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 07/12/2019 02:35:56 AM EST, an anonymous individual, email address not provided,
(U//FOUO) On 07/11/2019, at 10:56 p.m. Eastern Time, tipster email address{REDACTED}

(U) On 07/12/2019, at 6:21 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 6:30 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth

(U) On 07/12/2019, at 5:17 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 2:33 p.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},

(U) On 07/12/2019, at 12:29p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 11:48 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On 07/12/2019, at 10:31 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth
(U) On 07/11/2019, at 2:40 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth

(U) On 07/12/2019, at 1:22 a.m. Eastern Time an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), Internet
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 8:11 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} [PROTECT IDENTITY),

(U) On 07/11/2019, at 2:31 a.m., Eastern lime, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) On 07/10/2019, at 7:45 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous complainant, email address

(U) On 07/11/2019, at 7:13 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED)
(U) NTOC2019-MC1 192cdr03 Information Concerning Jeffrey Epstein, case no.: 31E-NY-

(U) On 07/11/2019, at 12:00 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) NTOC2019-MC3 192vmd01 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/11/2019, at 11:06

(U) On 07/11/2019, 10:13 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date
(U) On 07/10/2019 at 10:57 A.M Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster with an Internet

(U) (U)On 07/10/2019 at 8:59 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} [PROTECT IDENTITY],
(U) {REDACTED} and {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of{REDACTED} on 5/29/2019
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 4:32 p.m. Eastern Time, Anonymous Tipster, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On 07/10/2019, at 2:50 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (Anonymous),
(U) NTOC2019-MC3 191vmd03 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/10/2019, at 3:08

(U) On 07/10/2019, at 2:35 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (Anonymous),
(U) On 07/10/2019, at 1:28 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},

(U) On 7/10/2019, at 11:59 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 07/10/2019, at 11:28 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (ANONYMOUS),

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 4:47 A.M. {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}, home address {REDACTED}
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 6:S6 A.M. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, email address(REDACTED)

(U) On 07/10/2019, at 8:20 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth
(U) On 07/10/2019, at 5:03 a.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 10:49 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 8:44 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 190vmd05 Jaffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/09/2019, at 7:34
(U) NTOC2019-MC3 190vmd04 Jaffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/09/2019, at 6:43

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 6:37 p.m. Eastern Time, anonymous male caller (Anonymous), called
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 4:10 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 4:27 p.m. Eastern lime, an anonymous female in her 60's (Anonymous)
(U) On 07/09/2019 at 4:34 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 190vmd03 Jaffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/09/2019, at 3:28
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 2:34 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 3:55 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}[PROTECT IDENTITY
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 3:47 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 3:27 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, DOB{REDACTED}, phone{REDACTED},
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 3:33 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED)), cellular telephone

(U) On 07/09/2019 at 2:09 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 12:34 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous male caller (Anonymous),

(U) On 07/08/2019 at 12:45 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},
(U) NTOC2019 190bmm01 Possible Pimp (REDACTED) for Epstein On 07/08/2019 at 12:02 p.m.

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 5:50 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:40 a.m. Eastern Time, Anonymous, Internet Protocol (IP) address

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 10:18 p.m. Eastern Time,(REDACTED), date of birth{REDACTED}
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 9:00 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 8:14 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 4:31 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} [PROTECT IDENTITY), date of

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 8:25 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED), home
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 7:52 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 8:11 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} date of birth{REDACTED},
(U) NTOC2019 189jeg02 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/08/2019, at 6:23 p.m.

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 7:02 p.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED}
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 07:01 p.m. Eastern Time, an Anonymous male caller called the

(U) NTOC2019 189vmd04 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/08/2019, at 4:44 p.m.
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 5:16 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED)), date of birth{REDACTED}

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 4:12 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED}
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 5:11 p.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 5:17 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 3:34 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 07/08/2019 at 07/08/2019 at 4:51 p.m. Eastern Time,(REDACTED), date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 3:55 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 03:08 PM Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 3:03 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED}, phone

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:25 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 2:07 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},

(U) Search Warrant Executed- 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 1:20 p.m. Eastern Time, an Anonymous caller, cellular telephone

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:16 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED),
(U//FOUO) On 07/08/2019, at 1:10 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, the Office of Public Affairs

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 1:43 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 1:28 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:29 p.m. Eastern Time,{REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED},
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 11:31 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 189dec01 Possible Connection between YouTuber, (REDACTED},
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:10 p.m. Eastern Time, Anonymous, telephone number {REDACTED},

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:49 p.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED} [PROTECT IDENTITY], date of
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 11:31 a.m. Eastern lime, (REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) NTOC2019 189vmd02 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/08/2019, at 12:34 p.m
(U) On 07/07/2019 at 11:51 a.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED}, date of birth(REDACTED}

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:55 a.m. Eastern Time,(REDACTED}, date of birth (REDACTED}
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:57 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On() 07/08/2019, at 11:50 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:44 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) Search Warrant Executed at 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:28 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:34 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:27 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth{REDACTED},

(U) 31E-NY-3027571
(U) (U)On 07/07/2019 at 4:31 p.m. Eastern Time, (REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED},

(U) (U) On 07/07/2019 at 6:06 a.m. Eastern Time, {REDACTED}, date of birth {REDACTED}
(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)

(U) Interview of {REDACTED} on 5/29/2019
(U) Interview of {REDACTED} on 5/8/2019
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Items turned over to the FBI during {REDACTED} Interview on 5/29/19
(U) Florida Trip Request
(U) Interview of (REDACTED} on 5/2/2019

(U) Interview offREDACTED}
(U//FOUO) TECS Silent Hit Notification
(U) Request Miami Evidence to transfer items in 31E-MM-108062 to New York Evidence

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Florida Trip Request
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}

(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}

(U) Florida Trip Request
(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Phone interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview with {REDACTED} on 02/14/2019

(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Trip to Florida
(U) NY requests LA assistance to confirm victim address and initial notification/interview

(U) Florida Trip Request
(U) Opening EC
Serial Repel SOD-Nle-3027571-EIA
Serial U Date Title
2 7/1/2019 13:39 (U) Consensual Monitoring Authorization
1 7/1/2019 9:53 (U) Subfile Opening Document
Serial Report for Case: SOD-NY-3027571-FA
Serial U Date Title
¢ 4/1/2022 14:26 (U) )00000000(
5 11/13/2019 13:06 (U) )000000000C
4 11/4/2019 14:33 (U) lOCCOUCOON
2 11/4/2019 14:33 (U) )000000000C
2 9/30/2019 7:45 (U) )000000000(
1 8/30/2019 10:10 (U) FA Subfile Opening Document
Serial Report for Case: 50D-NY-3027571-FF
Serial* Date
17 4/14/2022 16:02
16 4/13/2022 11:52
.1.5. 9/13/2019 12:13
14 9/6/2019 12:41
13 8/22/201916:03
12 8/21/201916:03
11 8/13/2019 16:01
10 8/12/2019 11:43
9 8/12/2019 11:43
8 8/7/2019 13:10
Z 8/7/2019 9:08
A 7/29/201913:38
5 7/24/2019 13:26
4 7/24/2019 13:25
2 7/22/2019 13:20
2 7/8/2019 14:28
1 6/24/2019 14:38
Title

(U) Request is withdrawn as to title and appraisal for
(U) Request for Title and Appraisal reports for
(U) LSJsubpoena

(U) New Criminal Case: 31E-NY-3027571-FF; Seizure:
(U) Jade Data Research Inc, Title Report and Documen •

(U) Two Deeds for Great St James Island purchased by
(U) Request for a Title re • ort and an A .. raisal for

(U) Certified Appraisal $13,000,000.00, dated 07/24/2019.
(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoena for State of Delaware, Div. of Corporations records for L.SJ, LLC.

(U) Grand Jury Subpoena to serve on
(U) Filed Notice of Penden for
(U) Certified Appraisal fo
(U) Title Report and Title D ocuments • r

(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoena for records for USVI corporations.
(U) Request for a Title Report and an Appraisal for

(U) Request for a title search and an appraisal fo
(U) Forfeiture Subfile Opening Document
Serial Report for Case: I 50D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS
Serial # Date
12 3/31/2022 9:51
11 3/31/2022 6:58
12 3/24/2022 12:10
2 3/2/2022 21:04
8 3/2/2022 21:02
7 1/31/2022 13:20
6 10/24/2019 11:14
5 10/18/2019 16:22
4 10/18/2019 13:41
3 10/2/2019 13:53
2 10/1/2019 16:40
1 8/29/2019 9:43
Title
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) for {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) for {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) for {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) for {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) for {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of {REDACTED}

(U) Key Findings Pursuant to {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of (REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of {REDACTED}

(U) Subfile Opening Document
Case Number 72-MM -113327
Case Summary:
Obstruction of justice case with subject Alfredo Rodriguez, a
former employee of Epstein, opened 10/28/2009 by FBI
Miami Palm Beach RA. Rodriguez was arrested for obstruction
on 12/08/2009, convicted, and sentenced in 2010. This
investigation was closed on 03/13/2013. The 1B items have
been incorporated into the 50D case with new 1B numbers.
The lAs were sent to NY in 2019 and were housed in a
physical format until we sent them to WFO. One box
containing the 72•MM physical case file was located at FBI
Miami Palm Beach RA and coordinated for transport to WFO
on 03/03/2025. The only item of evidentiary use out of the 72
MM case was the black contact book.
Serial Report for Case: 72-MM-113327
Serial * Date
M 3/7/2025 9:16
63 6/18/2013 10:18
41 1/2/2013 13:18
a 8/29/20110:00
60 1/18/20110:00
59 11/9/2010 0:00
58 10/26/2010 0:00
57 10/26/2010 0:00
56 9/17/2010 0:00
a 11/18/2010 0:00
M 11/18/2010 0:00
53 11/16/2010 0:00
52 10/26/2010 0:00

R. 10/13/2010 0:00
50 10/13/2010 0:00
49 8/9/2010 0:00
48 8/9/2010 0:00
47 9/2/2010 0:00
46 9/2/2010 0:00
45 7/1/2010 0:00
44 6/21/2010 0:00
43 6/23/2010 0:00
42 6/23/2010 0:00
41 6/23/2010 0:00
4Q 6/23/2010 0:00
39 6/23/2010 0:00
38 6/23/2010 0:00
31 6/23/2010 0:00
36 6/23/2010 0:00
35 6/23/2010 0:00
34 6/23/2010 0:00
33 6/23/2010 0:00
22 6/23/2010 0:00
31 6/23/2010 0:00
30 6/23/2010 0:00
22 6/23/2010 0:00
22 6/7/2010 0:00
27 5/25/2010 0:00
26 4/23/2010 0:00
25 3/18/2010 0:00
24 3/18/2010 0:00
23 2/4/2010 0:00
22 11/3/2009 0:00
21 11/9/2009 0:00
2Q 11/5/2009 0:00
12 12/8/2009 0:00
la 12/8/2009 0:00
17 12/22/2009 0:00
16 12/9/2009 0:00
15 12/1/2009 0:00
14 12/2/2009 0:00
13 11/6/2009 0:00
12 11/6/2009 0:00
U
10/29/2009 0:00
1Q 11/5/2009 0:00
9 10/28/2009 0:00
8 10/28/2009 0:00
7 11/5/2009 0:00
6 11/3/2009 0:00
5 11/3/2009 0:00
4 11/2/2009 0:00
1 10/28/2009 0:00
2 10/28/2009 0:00
1 10/28/2009 0:00
Title

(U) Transfer of case files
(U) EC return of property to Alfredo Rodriguez
(U) Closing EC
(U//FOUO) REQUEST ADMINISTRATIVE CLOSURE OF CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST LEAD BE COVERED FOR PALM SPRINGS RA TO
(U//FOUO) CONSOLIDATED LEGAL CENTER PROVIDED BOP RECORDS RE:IREDACTEDJ
(U//FOLIO) INTERVIEW RE;IREDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED] RE:(REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW RE;(REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING PALM SPRINGS RA TO INTERVIEW (REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) TO COVER LEAD FOR THE MIAMI DIVISION REGARDING THE
(U//FOLIO) [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) REQUESTIN INFO RE:IREDACTED1 AND [REDACTED]
(U) TO NOTIFY PALM BEACH RA THAT LEAD HAS BEEN COVERED.
(U) [REDACTED] INTERVIEW; 10/12/2010
(U//FOUO) An' FEE: $50.00
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THIRD PARTY DRAFT ISSUE FUNDS IN THE AMOUNT
(U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING NEW YORK DIVISION TO CONDUCT INTERVIEW
(U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING TRENTON RA TO CONDUCT INTERVIEW OF FEDERAL
(U//FOUO) SENTENCE DATE RE:ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOLIO) EPSTEIN'S EX BUTLER SENTENCED TO 18 MONTHS FOR TRYING TO SEL
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) OBTAINED CALIFORNIA DRIVERS LICENSE (CDL) PHOTOGRAPHS
(U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING COPY OF CAUFORNIA DRIVERS LICENSE OF
(U//FOUO) CONVICTION RE:ALFREDO RODRIQUEZ
(U//FOUO) FEES/WIRE TRANSFER OF "SHOW MONEY":$275.00
(U//FOUO) REQUEST CASE FUNDING IN THE AMOUNT OF $275.00 FOR
(U//FOUO) EC REGARDING LATE SUBMISSION OF RECORDINGS TO ELSUR.
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW RE:ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) UC HOTEL ROOM IN THE AMOUNT OF $177.30
(U//FOUO) REQUEST CASE FUNDING IN THE AMOUNT OF $177.30 FOR
(U//FOUO) ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ PLACED UNDER ARREST AND TRANSPORTED
(U//FOUO) ARREST RE:ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) ARREST RE:ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) TO DOCUMENT BUSINESS INFORMATION.
(U//FOUO) ARREST WARRRANT RE:ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) COMPLAINT RE:ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW RE ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ

(U) XXKO(XXXXX
(U//FOUO) FGJ SUBSCRIBER AND BILUNG INFO REIREDACTED]
(U//FOUO) FGJ SUBPOENA FOR [REDACTED]

(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009, [REDACTED], DATE OF B
(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009, [REDACTED], DATE OF 8
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR SAC AUTHORITY TO UTILIZE NON BUREAU
(U//FOUO) PURSUANT TO SEARCH:PROVIDED BY ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) OPERATION PLAN RE:ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR $50,000.00 OF "SHOW MONEY" FROM FBIHQ
(U//FOUO) NCIC CCH RE:ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
1A/1C Rep 72-MM-113327
Type # Serial # Acquired On
lA 21 24 2025-03.04
lA 20 64 2025-03-03
1A as ¢1, 2013-06-17
lA 14 12010.06-23
1A 17 1 2010-11-16
1A 16 1 2010-12-19
1A 15 1 2010-09-28
1A 14 12010-11-09
1A 13 1 2010-03-19
1A 12 1 2009-11-18
1A 11 12010-02-01
1A .12 12009-11-06
1A 9 12009-11-03
1A 8 12009-11-03
1A 7 1 2009-11-02
1A 6 1 2009-08-06
IA 5 1 2009-11-18
lA 4 1 2009-11-06
lA 1 12009-11-06
lA 2 12009-11-03
lA 1 12009-11-06
Serial Title

(U) Transfer of case files
(U) Transfer of case files
(U) EC return of property to Alfredo Rodriguez
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOLIO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOLIO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOLIO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOLIO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOLIO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
Summary

(U) Copy of Fedex Tracking
(U) Itemized list of files
(U) FD 597 return of property to ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ.
(U//FOUO) VARIOUS TELEPHONE CD'S AND SUBPOENA FOR ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ CASE; SENT OUT TO HQ FOR Bi
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF 1) [REDACTED] ON 11/16/2010 2) CONTACT INFORMATION FOR E
(U//FOUO) BOP INMATE RECORD RE:[REDACTED] AND [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) (2) BALEEN SWEEP CD'S FOR TOLL RECORD
(UHFOUO) BOP RECORDS REJREDACTED] AND [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ATT PHONE RECORDS FOR SUBJ ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ, JULY 1,2009 11/2009,
(U//FOUO) INVOICE FOR PAYMENT OF STAGEHAND FEES/MONEY WIRE FEE AND COPY OF CASHIERS CHECK FOR F
(U//FOUO) FOUR (4) DVDS OF DEPOSITION OF ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ AUG 2009
(U//FOUO) 1)ADVICE OF RIGHTS FORM 2)ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ,11/6/2009 INTERROGATION
(U//FOUO) 1 BOUND BLACK ADDRESS BOOK AND 2 STAPLED HANDWRITTEN SET OF DOCUMENTS ON YELLOW LE
(U//FOUO) ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ 2 PASSPORTS;FL DRIVER LICENSE,RESIDENT ALIEN CARD;SOCIAL SECURITY CARC
(U//FOUO) DVD/CD'S OF CONSENSUALLY MONITORED PHONE CALLS WITH ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ (7 DISCS)
(U//FOUO) LEETER AND EMAIL CORRESPONDENCE BETWEEN ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ AND [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) FGJ SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR PHONE NUMBER [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) 1)FD-26 CONSENT TO SEARCH SIGNED BY ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ 2)FD-395 SIGNED BY ALFREDO RODRN
(U//FOUO) 1)FD-597 SIGNED BY ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) FD-395-[REDACTED]
PSTEIN'S ASSOCIATES AND EMPLOYEES WRITTEN OUT BY COUTERIER S ASSISTANT
Evidence Report for Case: 72-MM-113327
Filtering on: Type(s):1B, 1D, 1E
Item # Collected On
1D6 10/28/2009 8:00
1D5 10/29/2009 8:00
1D4 11/3/2009 7:00
1D3 11/2/2009 7:00
1D2 11/3/2009 7:00
1D1 11/3/2009 7:00
Description

(U) ONE ORIGINAL TELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 10/28/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE
(U) ONE ORIGINAL TELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 10/29/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE

(U) ONE ORIGINAL TELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 11/3/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE
(U) ONE ORIGINAL TELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 11/02/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE

(U) ONE ORIGINAL NONTELEPHONE RECORDING (CCTV) MADE ON 11/3/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE
(U) ONE ORIGINAL NONTELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 11/3/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE
Serial Repc 72-MM-113327-ELA
Serial # Date
2 2/4/2010 0:00
2 10/28/2009 0:00
1 10/28/2009 0:00
Title
(U//FOUO) EC REGARDING LATE SUBMISSION OF RECORDINGS TO ELSUR.

(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009, (REDACTED], DATE OF B
(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009, [REDACTED], DATE OF B
1A/1C Rep 72-MM-113327-ELA
Type tt Acquired On Serial #
lA 2 2009-10-28 1
lA 1 2009-10-28 1
Serial Title
(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009,(REDACTEDJ, DATE OF B
(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009, (REDACTED), DATE OF B
Summary
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL I
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL I
D•472 CONSENT FORM REF/[REDACTED] DATED 10/28/2009
Case Number: 31E-MM-108062
Case Summary:
Child Prostitution case against Epstein brought by PBPD, opened 07/25/2006 by FBI Miami
Palm Beach RA, resulting In a guilty plea in State Court. This case has remained in Pending
Inactive status since 07/25/2017 and case materials have been preserved for a civil litigation
hold. The 18 items have been incorporated into the SOD case with new 1B numbers. The
remaining 31E-MM file was sent to NY in 2019 in boxes and was housed both in a physical
and digital format (DVDs), until we sent it to WFO.
Serial Re 31E-MM-108062
Serial * Date
al 5/12/2023 8:17
262 4/28/2023 13:46
al 7/8/2022 13:53
260 6/6/2019 13:40
259 6/6/2019 13:40
258 12/6/2018 18:33
257 10/13/2017 9:28
256 9/29/2015 11:16
255 3/11/2015 12:22
254 7/12/2013 14:47
251 7/12/2013 11:32
al 7/8/2013 13:19
251 7/8/2013 13:16
250 8/12/20110:00
249 7/1/2011 0:00
248 3/23/2011 0:00
247 3/22/2011 0:00
246 3/2/20110:00
aa 1/31/2008 0:00
244 1/31/2008 0:00
243 1/31/2008 0:00
242 1/31/2008 0:00
2g1 1/31/2008 0:00
240 4/7/2011 0:00
239 4/7/20110:00
238 3/22/20110:00
237 3/14/20110:00
afi 3/14/2011 0:00
235 3/12/2011 0:00
234 3/12/20110:00
al 3/1/2011 0:00
al 12/10/2010 0:00
231 12/10/2010 0:00
230 11/24/2010 0:00
229 11/26/2010 0:00
al 11/26/20100:00
227 4/16/2010 0:00
226 7/20/2010 0:00
m 7/22/2010 0:00
224 5/28/2008 0:00
223 1/27/2010 0:00
222 1/26/2010 0:00
221 1/8/2010 0:00
220 6/11/2009 0:00
219 6/17/2009 0:00
218 6/10/2009 0:00
217 4/10/2009 0:00
ak 2/17/2009 0:00
215 11/25/2008 0:00
214 10/17/2007 0:00
213 12/11/2008 0:00
212 12/8/2008 0:00
211 12/3/2008 0:00
210 11/25/2008 0:00
209 9/29/2008 0:00
208 9/29/2008 0:00
207 9/29/2008 0:00
2.4.6 9/29/2008 0:00
20 9/29/2008 0:00
204 9/29/2008 0:00
203 9/29/2008 0:00
202 9/29/2008 0:00
201 9/29/2008 0:00
200 9/29/2008 0:00
199 9/29/2008 0:00
In 9/29/2008 0:00
19/ 9/29/2008 0:00
196 9/29/2008 0:00
195 9/29/2008 0:00
94 9/29/2008 0:00
193 9/29/2008 0:00
192 9/29/2008 0:00
191 9/29/2008 0:00
190 9/29/2008 0:00
18.2 9/29/2008 0:00
188 9/29/2008 0:00
187 9/29/2008 0:00
IgE 9/29/2008 0:00
185 9/29/2008 0:00
184 9/29/2008 0:00
183 9/29/2008 0:00
182 9/29/2008 0:00
AI 9/29/2008 0:00
180 9/29/2008 0:00
179 9/29/2008 0:00
Iza 9/29/2008 0:00
177 9/29/2008 0:00
176 9/29/2008 0:00
175 10/19/2008 0:00
174 10/7/2008 0:00
173 8/25/2008 0:00
172 8/8/2008 0:00
171 8/7/2008 0:00
nQ 7/25/2008 0:00
16.2 7/23/2008 0:00
168 7/23/2008 0:00
AZ 7/21/2008 0:00
1§§ 7/7/2008 0:00
165 7/1/2008 0:00
164 5/30/2008 0:00
163 5/29/2008 0:00
162 5/31/2008 0:00
161 3/18/2008 0:00
160 3/17/2008 0:00
152 3/17/2008 0:00
152 4/22/2008 0:00
157 4/22/2008 0:00
156 3/27/2008 0:00
155 3/25/2008 0:00
154 3/20/2008 0:00
153 4/2/2008 0:00
152 4/2/2008 0:00
151 3/6/2008 0:00
152 2/27/2008 0:00
149 2/1/2008 0:00
148 1/25/2008 0:00
24/ 11/28/2007 0:00
146 11/2/2007 0:00
145 10/26/2007 0:00
144 10/26/2007 0:00
143 10/26/2007 0:00
M 10/19/2007 0:00
141 10/19/2007 0:00
140 10/2/2007 0:00
13.2 10/2/2007 0:00
138 9/6/2007 0:00
137 8/23/2007 0:00
136 3/5/2008 0:00
135 3/5/2008 0:00
la 2/6/2008 0:00
133 11/7/2007 0:00
132 11/7/2007 0:00
ili 1/10/2008 0:00
14Q 8/21/2007 0:00
129 10/25/2007 0:00
128 10/3/2007 0:00
127 8/7/2007 0:00
126 10/3/2007 0:00
125 10/9/2007 0:00
124 10/10/2007 0:00
121 10/2/2007 0:00
122 10/2/2007 0:00
121 3/22/2007 0:00
lag 11/1/2007 0:00
119 8/7/2007 0:00
118 12/4/2007 0:00
117 11/7/2007 0:00
116 6/25/2007 0:00
115 6/20/2007 0:00
114 6/12/2007 0:00
113 6/4/2007 0:00
112 6/4/2007 0:00
111 5/18/2007 0:00
110 5/10/2007 0:00
109 4/25/2007 0:00
108 4/26/2007 0:00
107 3/18/2007 0:00
106 3/19/2007 0:00
105 2/26/2007 0:00
10 1/10/2007 0:00
al 7/2/2007 0:00
102 10/12/2007 0:00
101 8/27/2007 0:00
UM 8/27/2007 0:00
99 8/17/2007 0:00
98 6/22/2007 0:00
97 6/11/2007 0:00
96 5/25/2007 0:00
21 5/29/2007 0:00
M 5/18/2007 0:00
93 4/30/2007 0:00
22 4/15/2007 0:00
91 4/30/2007 0:00
90 4/26/2007 0:00
89 2/14/2008 0:00
88 5/17/2007 0:00
17_ 5/2/2007 0:00
86 4/30/2007 0:00
85 4/30/2007 0:00
M 4/20/2007 0:00

al. 3/24/2007 0:00
82 3/15/2007 0:00
81 3/13/2007 0:00
80 4/6/2007 0:00
79 3/21/2007 0:00
78 3/13/2007 0:00
77 1/11/2007 0:00
16 2/2/2007 0:00
1/18/2007 0:00
74 3/21/2007 0:00
21 3/12/2007 0:00
22 3/6/2007 0:00
71 3/6/2007 0:00
70 2/13/2007 0:00
69 1/23/2007 0:00
68 1/23/2007 0:00
67 2/15/2007 0:00
66 2/6/2007 0:00
55 2/6/2007 0:00
64 2/6/2007 0:00
63 2/6/2007 0:00
62 1/18/2007 0:00
51 12/8/2006 0:00
60 10/30/2006 0:00
59 11/27/2006 0:00
58 8/15/2006 0:00
52 1/25/2007 0:00
a 6/21/2007 0:00
55 6/21/2007 0:00
54 6/21/2007 0:00
52 12/18/2006 0:00
52 12/13/2006 0:00
51 8/17/2006 0:00
50 12/20/2006 0:00
49 12/6/2006 0:00
4.4 12/18/2006 0:00
47 11/27/2006 0:00
46 11/15/2006 0:00
4.1 11/13/2006 0:00
44 11/1/2006 0:00
43 10/24/2006 0:00
42 10/24/2006 0:00
41 10/24/2006 0:00
N 10/24/2006 0:00
39 12/8/2006 0:00
38 12/5/2006 0:00
32 7/13/2006 0:00
25 10/10/2006 0:00
35 10/11/2006 0:00
34 8/31/2006 0:00
33 11/9/2006 0:00
32 11/14/2006 0:00
31 8/18/2006 0:00
30 10/14/2006 0:00
42 10/14/2006 0:00
n 8/18/2006 0:00
27 8/10/2006 0:00
22 8/18/2006 0:00
25 10/17/2006 0:00
24 10/16/2006 0:00
23 10/16/2006 0:00
22 10/16/2006 0:00
21 10/16/2006 0:00
20 6/21/2007 0:00
19 9/18/2006 0:00
12 7/30/2006 0:00
11 9/13/2006 0:00
16 8/8/2006 0:00
15 9/1/2006 0:00
14 8/28/2006 0:00
13 8/14/2006 0:00
12 8/14/2006 0:00
11 8/5/2006 0:00
.1.4 8/8/2006 0:00
2 8/4/2006 0:00
8 8/1/2006 0:00
7 7/29/2006 0:00
¢ 7/26/2006 0:00
5 7/25/2006 0:00
4 7/24/2006 0:00
3 5/1/2006 0:00
2 5/1/2006 0:00
1 7/24/2006 0:00
Title

(U) 31-MM-108062-1A SEC 001 SER 1A89 ONLY
(U) Case update and reassignment request.
(U) Missing chain of custody

(U) FedEx Shipment Receipt.
(U) FedEx Shipment Receipt.
(U) Opening EC
(U) FY 2018 Name Check Summary File

(U) Request for ELSUR shipment
(U) FOIA REQUEST LETTER
(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) Items received from [REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SIDES ARGUE WHETHER JEFFREY EPSTEIN'S NONPROSECUTION DEAL VI
(U//FOUO) CURRENCY TRANSACTION REPORT
(U//FOUO) PROSTITUTION RING LEADER SENTENCED TO 21 MONTHS
(U//FOUO) THE EVIDENCE PERSON WAS UNABLE TO LOOK TO SEE IF ANYTHING WA
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED]AND THE 17-YEAR OLD GIRL HIS SEX OFFENDER FRIEN
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW RE:[REDACTEDI
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] MET WITH SA'S AND AUSA
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] CONTACTED SAS AND PROVIDED INFO
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] MET WITH SA'S AND AUSA
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] MET WITH SAS AND AUSA
(U//FOUO) FUNDS REQUEST $90.09
(U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING REIMBURSEMENT FROM CASE FUNDS FOR

(U) TO DOCUMENT LIAISON AND INVESTIGATION IN AUSTRALIA
(U) INTERVIEW OF U.S. CITIZEN [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) TO ADVISE MIAMI DIVISION OF CACU CONCURRENCE OF THE TRAVEL
(U//FOUO) REQUEST LEGAT CANBERRA FACILITATE INTERVIEW OF VICTIM,
(U//FOUO) REQUEST COUNTRY CLEARANCE AND TRAVEL AUTHORITY FOR TWO
(U//FOUO) JANE DOE#1 AND JANE DOE#2 VS US, NO 09-80736

(U) DELTA SERIAL -012
(U) FORWARDING CURRENT PHOTOGRAPHS OF [REDACTED].
(U) PROVIDING INFORMATION TO THE MIAMI DIVISION RE CO-

(U) DELTA SERIAL -012
(U) DELTA SERIA -011
(U//FOUO) FOIPA REQUEST
(U//FOUO) BILLIONAIRE PEDOPHILE GOES FREE
(U//FOUO) THE BILLIONAIRE PEDOPHILES SEX DEN
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) JUDSGE RULES EPSTEIN ATTORNEYS CAN SUBPOENA ABORTION RECORDS
(U//FOUO) EX-EPSTEIN WORKER FACES OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE

(U) TO REQUEST TRANSFER OF ABOVE CAPTIONED CASE DUE TO
(U//FOUO) DRIVER LICENSE'S INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INMATE PHONE CALLS LOG
(U//FOUO) WOMEN WANT SEX PLEA DEAL UNSEALED
(U//FOUO) SUIT ACCUSES JAILED TYCOON OF SEX CRIME

(U) LEAD SET TO LEGAT CANBERRA COVERED BY THE SYDNEY SUB
(U) LETTER TO MS [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) WOMAN SUES BILLIONAIRE INVESTOR, SAYS THEY HAD SEX WHEN SHE
(U//FOUO) BILLIONAIRE SEX OFFENDER LEAVES JAIL SIX DAYS A WEEK FOR WOR

(U) LEAD SET TO LEGAT CANBERRA COVERED BY THE SYDNEY SUB
(U) REQUEST AFP DELIVER USAO LETTER TO [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) VICTIM [REDACTED] PROVIDED WITH USAO LETTER.
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO:
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFO: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CHILD VICTIM INFORMATION: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ARREST: JEFFREY ESPTEIN
(U//FOUO) VICTIM [REDACTED] PROVIDED WITH VICTIM
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST HAND DELIVERY OF VICTIM NOTIFICATION
(U) REQUEST AFP'S ASSISTANCE IN DELIVERING A VICTIM NOTIFICATION
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) TO DOCUMENT REQUEST FOR DELIVERY OF VICTIM
(U//FOUO) TO DELIVER VICTIM NOTIFICATION LETTER AND BROCHURES.
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) YOUR NAME WAS REFERRED TO FBI'S VICTIM NOTIFICATION PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) BID TO BURN EPSTEIN PLEA
(U//FOUO) RICH MAN FOUGHT THE LAW AND HE MOSTLY WON
(U//FOUO) PALM BEACHER PLEADS IN SEX CASE
(U//FOLIO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED]
(U//FOLIO) TO DOCUMENT SERVICE OF GRAND JURY SUBPOENA TO [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) GIRL SUES EPSTEIN, TWO OTHERS SHE SAYS CONSPIRED IN MASSAGES
(UHFOUO) SEARCH WARRANT
(UHFOUO) SEARCH WARRANT
(U//FOUO) RESPONSE TO LEAD AT MASTIC, NEW YORK, TO INTERVIEW
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) TO COVER LEAD SET BY THE MIAMI DIVISION, SERIAL 134
(U//FOUO) IREDACTENTELEPHONICALLY CONTACTED SA [REDACTED]
(U//FOLIO) [REDACTED] WAS INTERVIEWED AT THE NEW YORK OFFIC
(U//FOLIO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) ANOTHER SUIT ALLEGES SEX DURING MASSAGE
(U//FOUO) GIRL DROPS LAWSUIT AGAINST PALM BEACH MAN
(U//FOUO) PART-TIME PALM BEACHER FACES ANOTHER SEX SUIT
(U//FOUO) PALM BEACH MAN FACES LAWSUIT IN TEEN SEX CASE
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOLIO) [REDACTED] IDENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] IDENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(UHFOUO) [REDACTED] IDENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) THIS EC WAS ORIGINALLY SUBMITTED ON 5/1/07 BUT NOT
(U//FOUO) THIS EC WAS ORIGINALLY SUBMITTED ON 5/1/07 BUT NOT
(U//FOUO) TO SET LEADS FOR CAPTIONED INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOUO) DRAFT REQUEST $ 306.50
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST FUNDS FOR EXPENSES ASSOCIATED TO THE
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM RIGHTS
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(11//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF (REDACTED)
(W/FOuO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERIVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] IDENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) NOTICE OF HEARING
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RE: INTELLIGENCE REQUEST RE: [REDACTED]
(UHFOU0) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED)
(UHFOU0) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RE: EXPLOITATION OF MINORS [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) PLACING OF [REDACTED]& [REDACTED)ON WATCH LIST
(U//FOUO) ATTEMPT TO SERVE TARGET LETTER ON TWO FEMALES BY SA [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED MATTER.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB-FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED MATTER.
(U//FOUO) RE: LIST OF NATIONS THAT HAVE EXTRADITION TREATIES
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) INTERIVEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] IDENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) [REDACTED] IDENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED MATTER.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST SUPERVISORY SPECIAL AGENT (SSA) [REDACTED]
(U//FOLIO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOLIO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST INTELLIGENCE ANALYST (IA) [REDACTED]
(U//FOLIO) INTERVIEW OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U//FOLIO) RE: MEETING WITH [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST ASSIGNMENT OF CO-CASE AGENT.
(U//FOLIO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) RE: UPDATE TO THE CASE
(U//FOUO) DELAYS IN EPSTEIN CASE UNUSUAL LAWYERS SAY
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED MATTER.
(U//FOUO) TO REMOVE WRITER AS CO-CASE AGENT.
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) DRAFT REQUEST FOR $205.00
(U//FOUO) DRAFT REQUEST FOR $18.25
(U//FOUO) TO REPORT RESULTS OF COVERED LEAD.
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(UHFOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(UHFOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST FUNDS FOR EXPENSES ASSOCIATED TO THE ABOVE
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) TO DOCUMENT ASSISTANCE PROVIDED TO INTELLIGENCE
(U//FOUO) TO SET LEADS FOR CAPTIONED INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(W/FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIER OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(UHFOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST ASSIGNMENT OF CO-CASE AGENT AND SUBMIT
(U//FOUO) INCIDENT REPORT
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(UHFOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) REQUEST THAT SA [REDACTED] WITH SOU 263-
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) LEAD COVERED FOR CAPTIONED INVESTIGATION; GRAND JURY
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) TO SET LEAD FOR CAPTIONED INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOUO) BILLIONAIRE FACES CHARGE OF SOUCITATION OF MINORS
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST ANALYTICAL ASSISTANCE REGARDING
(U//FOUO) EPSTEIN CAMP CALLS FEMALE ACCUSERS LIARS
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) THE MAN WHO HAD EVERYTHING
(U//FOUO) PALM BEACH CHIEF FOCUS OF FIRE IN EPSTEIN CASE
(U//FOUO) EXPERT: IGNORANCE OF AGE ISN'T DEFENSE IN SEX CHARGES
(U//FOUO) TO DOCUMENT VICTIM INFORMATION. PLEASE REFER TO THE
(U//FOUO) HE WAS 50. AND THEY WERE GIRLS
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB-FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) POLICE SAY LAWYER TRIED TO DISCREDIT TEENAGE GIRLS
(U//FOUO) AFTER LONG PROBE BILLIONARE FACES SOUCITATION CHARGE
(U//FOUO) INDICTMENT: BILLIONAIRE SOLICITED 3 TIMES
(U//FOUO) MYSTERY MONEY MAN FACES SOLICITING CHARGE
(U//FOUO) PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT/ [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT\JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
1A/1C Rep 31E-MM-108062
Type # Acquired On Serial #
lA Al k 2008-06-20 ISA
lA 145 2008-03-06 254
lA MA 2007-08-15 251
1A 143 2007-08-24 254
1A 142 2006-09-01 254
IA 141 2008-01-01 253
1A 140 2006-01-01 253
IA DI 2006-01-01 253
lA DI 2006-01-01 253
lA 137 2006-01-01 253
lA ilk 2007-01-01 25.1
1A }al 2006-01-01 2.5.2
lA 134 2006-01-01 253
1A 133 2006-01-01 253
lA 132 2006-01-01 253
SA 131 2007-01-01 253
lA 130 2007-01-01 253
1A 129 2006-01-01 253
M aa 2006-01-01 252
lA 127 2006-01-01 152
lA 126 2007-01-01 253
lA 125 2006-01-01 253
lA 124 2006-01-01 252
1A 123 2006-01-01 253
1A 122 2006-01-01 253
1A 121 2006-01-01 253
1A 120 2006-01-01 253
lA na 2007-01-01 al
lA 118 2006-01-01 253
lA 117 2006-01-01 253
1A 11 2008-01-01 252
lA 115 2007-01-01 253
lA 114 2007-01-01 253
lA 113 2006-01-01 253
lA 112 2006-01-01 253
lA 111 2006-01-01 252
IA 110 2006-01-01 253
lA 109 2006-01-01 253
I.A 1Q1 2007-01-01 251
1A 107 2007-01-01 151
lA 106 2006-01-01 253
1A 10S 2006-01-01 2S3
lA 104 2006-01-01 253
1A 103 2006-01-01 253
LA 102 2006-01-01 253
1A 101 2007-01-01 253
1A 144 2007-01-01 251
IA 92 2006-01-01 al
1A 98 2006-01-01 253
lA 92 2008-01-01 251
1A 9 2006-01-01 192
1A 95 2006-01-01 253
LA 94 2007-01-01 253
1A 93 2007-01-01 253
LA 92 2008-01-01 253
lA 91 2011-03-09 252
1A 90 2011-03-18 251
lA 12 2011-03-18 251
1A 9.2 2011-03-17 Z51
lA 87 2011-03-17 251
lA 86 2011-04-26 1
lA 15 2010-05-28 1
lA 84 2008-05-29 1
LA 83 2008-03-24 1
1A 82 2007-09-28 1
1A al 2008-01-15 1
lA 14 2008-04-22 1
lA 79 2009-06-10 1
lA 78 2008-04-07 1
lA ZZ 2008-03-17 1
lA 76 2008-03-20 1
LA 75 2008-03-25 1
lA 74 2008-04-21 1
LA n 2008-03-19 1
lA 21 2008-02-06 1
lA 71 2008-02-25 1
lA 70 2008-02-25 1
1A §.2 2007-12-03 1
lA 68 2007-11-28 1
LA 67 2007-11-02 1
LA 66 2007-11-02 1
LA 65 2007-10-19 1
1A 2007-10-02 1
LA 63 2007-10-02 1
1A 62 2007-09-06 1
1A §.1 2007-08-23 1
1A EQ 2007-08-07 1
lA 59 2007-08-07 1
1A 58 2007-08-07 1
lA 57 2007-03-22 1
1A 56 2007-06-25 1
1A 55 2007-06-04 1
1A 54 2007-06-04 1
1A 51 2007-03-19 1
IA 5/ 2007-07-02 1
1A 51 2007-07-10 1
14 3,Q 2007-06-27 1
1A la 2007-06-14 1
IA 48 2007-06-05 1
IA 47 2007-05-29 1
IA 4.6 2007-05-23 1
IA 45 2007-05-18 1
14 44 2007-05-08 1
14 43 2007-05-04 1
IA 42 2007-05-04 1
1A 41 2007-04-30 1
14 ao 2007-04-19 1
1A 39 2007-04-19 1
lA 34 2007-04-19 1
14 37 2007-04-17 1
lA 36 2007-04-07 1
1A 35 2007-04-10 1
IA 34, 2007-04-10 1
14 11 2007-04-09 1
14 32 2007-04-05 1
lA 31 2007-04-05 _1
IA 32 2007-04-04
m 29 2007-04-03 1
m 28 2007-04-03 1
14 27 2007-03-28 1
1A 26 2007-03-26 1
14 5 2007-03-23 1
14 24 2007-03-21 1
14 23 2007-02-26 1
14 34 2007-02-22 1
lA 21 2007-02-09 1
14 20 2007-01-24 1
1A 19 2007-01-24 1
lA 18 2007-01-16 1
14 17 2007-01-10 1
14 16 2007-01-10 1
14 15 2007-01-03 1
IA 1.4 2006-11-17 1
14 1,1 2006-10-23 1
lA 12 2006-08-31 1
14 11 2006-08-30 1
1A 10 2006-08-08 1
14 9 2006-08-08 1
LA 8 2007-02-28 1
1A 7 2007-02-22 1
1A i 2007-03-05 1
IA a 2007-03-02 1
LA 4 2007-02-08 1
lA 2 2007-03-01 1
lA 2 2006-12-13 1
IA 1 2006-08-18 1
Serial Title

(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.
(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.

(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.
(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.

(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) Items received from [REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED]
(U) [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(W/FOU0) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
Summary

(U) T-Mobile USA, Inc. [REDACTED]/[REDACTED]/(REDACTED) - Subscriber Information
(U) At&t [REDACTED] - Subscriber and Toll Information

(U) Bell South[REDACiED]- Subscriber and Toll Information
(U) Metro PCS [REDACTED] - Subscriber Information

(U) Palm Beach County Health Department - Certificate of Birth for [REDACTED], dob[REDACTED]
(U) Biographical files for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED] and [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED], and [REDACTED], dob

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information, and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information, and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information, and original notes for [REDACTED], dob[REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file and MySpace information for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for (REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file, and MySpace information for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob[REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information, and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file and MySpace information for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file and MySpace information for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for[REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file, and original notes for [REDACTED], dob[REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file, and MySpace information for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for[REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical files and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED] and [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file, and MySpace information for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for[REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file, MySpace Information and original notes for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]
(U) Biographical file for [REDACTED], dob [REDACTED]

(U) Biographical file for[REDACTED], dob[REDACTED]
(U) Items received from attorney [REDACTED]
(U) ITM Massage school certification for [REDACTED] and FD-597
(U) 20 photographs received from [REDACTED] and FD-597.
(U) Original notes re interview of [REDACTED]
(U) Photo array shown to [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) A COPY OF NON-PROSECUTION AGREEMENT
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL GI SUBPOENA SERVED ON [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CELLULAR RECORDS FOR [REDACTEDHREDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RESULTS OF ADMIN SUB FORIREDACTEDY[REDACTED] AND [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CELLULAR RECORDS FOR [REDACTED] [REDACTED]/[REDACTED] AND [REDACTEDI[REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CELLULAR RECORDS FROM AT&T FOR [REDACTED] [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN RESULTS: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR TELEPHONE # [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR [REDACTED] [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED] DATED 03/20/2008
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED] DATED 3/25/08
(U//FOUO) SUPBOENA RESULTS FOR [REDACTED], (REDACTED] ANDIREDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ONE 597 RECEIPT FOR 2 YEAR BOULES FROM [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) 2 597 PROPERTY RECEIPTS DOCUMENTARY PROPERTY RELEASE AND RECEIPT OF HARD DRIVE
(U//FOUO) POUCE REPORT FROM PBPD RE: [REDACTED] AND[REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL PB POLICE INTELLIGENCE REPORT DATED 03/05/2004
(U//FOUO) A COPY OF BILL AND PAYMENT TO AMERICAN EXPRESS FOR FINANCIALRECORDS
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) FD-597 MASSAGE FOR DUMMIES - BOOK
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF[REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF 1) [REDACTED]; 2) [REDACTED] AND ATTACH PHOTOS FROM [RE[
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RESULTS FROM ADIN SUBPOENA FOR CINGULAR [REDACTED], [REDACTED], [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ADMINSTRATIVE SUBPOENA RESULTS FROM CINGULAR RE [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) JETBLUE RECORDS REGARDING [REDACTED] TRAVEL
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FROM JETBLUE RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CORPORATE RECORD RE: [REDACTED] AND [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE: [REDACTED] AND [REDACTED]
(UHFOUO) RECORDING (AUDIO) [REDACTED] [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CERTIFIED COPIES OF TECS RECORDS
(U//FOUO) F0597 RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO AND CD-R RE: [REDACTED]; [REDACTED]; [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) CINGULAR RECORDS FOR [REDACTED], [REDACTED], AND [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE: IREDACTED];[REDACTED]; [REDACTED];[REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE: [REDACTED]; [REDACTED]; [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN INFORMATION RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) A COPY OF SPRINT EMAIL SENT TO [REDACTED]PHONE RECORDS
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS NEGATIVE FROM TIME WARNER
(U//FOUO) ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA RESULTS FROM TIME WARNER
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE: [REDACTED]; 2) ADDITIONAL FAXES REC- E(VED ON 02-27-007, 02-28-2007, ANC
(U//FOUO) ADMIN SUBPOENA RETURN MATERIALS RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ADMIN SUBPOENA RETURN MATERIALS RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ADMIN SUBPOENA RETURN RESULTS RE: [REDACTED] AND [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR [REDACTED', JEFFREY EPSTEINAREDACTEDIr ((REDACTED]) AND OTHERS
(U//FOUO) ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA FOR CINGULAR/ATT RE: [REDACTED][REDACTED] AND RESULTS
(U//FOUO) JETBLUE SUBPOENA RESULTS
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO AND TELL RECORDS RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) PHOTOGRAPH SHOWN TO [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR INFORMATION ON[REDACTED] CELL ULAR TELEPHONE-SPRINT/NEXTEL [REC
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR EPSTEIN AND COMPANY [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA REGARDING CINGULAR # [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RESULT OF SUBPOENA DATED 12-22-2006
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR [REDACTED] (SUBSCRIBER INFO ONLY)
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR[REDACTED] AND [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) ADMIN SUBPOENA FOR CINGULAR RE KREDACTED) AND RESULTS
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR [REDACTED!
(U//FOUO) 1 CD CONTAINING TOLL RECORDS FROM (REDACTED]/[REDACTED]/[REDACTED] AND DOCUMENTATI
(U//FOUO) ADMIN SUBPOENA RESULTS FROM CINGULAR RE [REDACTED];[REDACTED], [REDACTED],[REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) RUSULTS FROM CINGULAR RE #S [REDACTED]; [REDACTED], [REDACTED];[REDACTED]ADMINISTRATII
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR [REDACTED] AND [REDACTED] [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR [REDACTED] AND [REDACTED] TELEPHONE[REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN MATERIALS RE: [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESUTIS RE: MYSPACE.COM USER ID [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) 1) HARD COPY AND CD-ROM SUBPOENA RETURN RESULTS FOR MYSPACE ID WS [REDACTED], [REDAC
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN MATERIALS RE: FRIEDN ID NUMBERS [REDACTED], [REDACTED], [REDACTED], [RI
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) PHOTO LINE UP POSITIVE ID OF [REDACTED]
ACTED] 6-4-07; 3) PHOTOCOPIESOF [REDACTED] SCRAPBOOK ITEMS
Serial Rep; 31E-MM-108062-FF
Serial # Date
IQ 10/20/2022 14:26
9 9/18/2008 0:00
a 2/11/2008 0:00
Z 5/1/2007 0:00
6 5/1/2007 0:00
5 4/4/2007 0:00
4 4/5/2007 0:00
A 3/23/2007 0:00
2 11/6/2006 0:00
1 8/1/2006 0:00
Title
(U) Request Closure of FF subfile
(U//FOUO) REQUEST CLOSING OF FORFEITURE SUBFILE FF.
(U//FOUO) REPORT STATUS OF FORFEITURE INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOUO) DRAFT $340.00 CERTIFIED COPY OF CORPORATE RECORDS
(U//FOUO) DRAFT $946.00 CERTIFIED COPY OF CORPORATE RECORDS
(U//FOLIO) UPDATED OWNERSHIP/ENCUMBRANCE REPORT FOR [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) DRAFT $150.00 TITLE SEARCH
(U//FOLIO) TO UPDATE STATUS OF FORFEITURE INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOLIO) TO UPDATE STATUS OF FORFEITURE INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB-FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
Sedalitept_31E-MM-108062-61
Serial* Date Title Synopsis
a ######## (U)XXXXX)0000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
45 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (J))000000000(
44 ######## (U))000000(XX (1))000000000(
42 ######## (U)XXXXX)0000( (U))0000000OCK
42 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
41 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
40 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
39 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
38 ######## (U)XXXXXX)000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
37 ######## (U)XXXX)000(XX (U)XXXXXXXXXX
lfi ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
31 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
34 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
33 ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
31 ######## (U))000000(X00( (U))000000000(
31 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
30 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
29 ######## (U))00000000( (U)XXXXX)D000(
22 ######## (u))000000000( (U))000000000(
27 ######## (U)XXXX)000(XX (U)XXXXXXXXXX
26 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
25 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
24 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXX)000(
23 ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
22 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
21 ########
########
Mitt tlittt tin
tt$$#$$####
#0#0014##
(U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
20 (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
19 (U)XXXXXXXXXX (U) XXXXXXXXXX
18 (U) XXXXXXXXMC (U) XXXXXXXXXX
17 (U)X00000000( (U) XXXXXXXX)0(
lfi########04)00000000( (U)XXXX)00000(
15 ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
14 ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
13 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
12 ######## (U))000000)00( (U))000000000(
11 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
10 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
9 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
I ######## (U)XXXX)C0000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
7 ######## (U)XXXXX)0000( (U)XXXX)00000(
6 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
5 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
4 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
3 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(

╭───────────────────────────────────────────────────── Page 196, Image 1 
──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ [Serial Repe 31£-MM-108062-G)                                                                                         
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ Serial# Date _—‘Title                                                                                                 
│
│ AHHHHHE(U) XXX                                                                                                        
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ HHH (U) XXX                                                                                                           
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXNX                                                                                                   
│
│ HAHAH (UL) XXX                                                                                                        
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXHK                                                                                                   
│
│ AHHHAAHE (UL) XXX                                                                                                     
│
│ AIEEE (U) XXXXXXXXXX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHHH (U0) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXXYX                                                                                                  
│
│ HAE (U) XXXOXXXHK                                                                                                     
│
│ AHHHHAEHE (UL) XXXXXXXXYX                                                                                             
│
│ HRHAHAHE (UL) XXX                                                                                                     
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXKAX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXNX                                                                                                    
│
│ HHH (U) XXX                                                                                                           
│
│ AHRHHHHE (UL) XXXXXXXXHK                                                                                              
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AIEEE (U) XXXXXXXXXK                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHR (U) XXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                    
│
│ sna (U) XXXXXXXXYX                                                                                                    
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXHXXXOX                                                                                                  
│
│ HAHAH (U) XXX                                                                                                         
│
│ AIEEE (U) XXXXXXXXXK                                                                                                  
│
│ HAHAH (U) XXX                                                                                                         
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHR (U) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                    
│
│ AnH (U) XXX                                                                                                           
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ fs fe ier ton iss fom yo FS TS US 1S DS en Pon IS Ut JR3 IPS IS P03 ISR IER USS Ube IB PS Ue US IS eh IS es 8 IS IA IS
IB NG │
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ Synopsis                                                                                                              
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAK                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX000XX                                                                                                          
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXXX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X9000000XX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) 9000000KX                                                                                                         
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X900000KKX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXXX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X900000KXX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X9000000XX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) X20                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAK                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAK                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X000000KX                                                                                                         
│
│ (U) X9000000XX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) 0000000KX                                                                                                         
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXXK                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X9000000KX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X900000KX                                                                                                         
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXXX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX0000X                                                                                                          
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
───────╯

#,MMIMIN
NUNN
(U) X)00000000(
(U) XXXXXXXXXX
(U))00000000M
(U) XXXXXXXXXX
SA/1C Rep 31E-MM-108062-0
Type Acquired On Serial # Serial Title
1C 2 2007-07-18 M (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1C 1 2006-08-18 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 41 2008-07-26 42 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 42 2008-05.14 IQ (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 41 2008-06-05 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 40 2008-03-12 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 39 2008-03-12 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 38 2007-09-25 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 37 2007-09-10 IM (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 36 2007-07-16 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A ii 2007-07-22 42 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 34 2007-08-09 .1¢ (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 33 2007-06-08 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 32 2007-06-13 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A n 2007-05-29 IN (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
a 30 2008-05-29 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
a 29 2006-08-31 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 28 2007-11-30 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 27 2007-07-10 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
m a 2007-06-27 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 25 2007-06-25 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 24 2007-06-22 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
IA 21 2006-08-01 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 22 2007-05-03 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 21 2007-04-30 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 20 2007-04-25 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 19 2007-04-16 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M a 2007-04-09 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 17 2007-04-03 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 16 2007-03-16 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A a 2007-02-02 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 14 2007-01-23 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
a 13 2006-11-27 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 12 2006-11-09 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
a 11 2006-11-07 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 12 2006-09-29 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 9 2006-09-15 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 8 2006-09-04 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M Z 2006-08-30 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A A 2006-08-18 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 5 2006-08-24 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 4 2006-08-17 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 3 2006-08-15 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 2 2006-08-15 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 1 2006-08-11 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
Serial Re • 31E-MM-108062-SBP
Serial # Date
E 6/9/2009 0:00
86 6/9/2009 0:00
$.4 4/11/2008 0:00
M 4/1/2008 0:00
83 2/25/2008 0:00
82 2/25/2008 0:00
81 2/22/2008 0:00
N 12/22/2006 0:00
79 5/17/2007 0:00
0:00
0:00
78 8/1/2006
ZZ 8/1/2006
Zfi 8/8/2007 0:00
75 8/5/2007 0:00
74 8/8/2007 0:00
LI 8/14/2007 0:00
72 8/14/2007 0:00
71 5/17/2007 0:00
70 5/17/2007 0:00
i2 6/22/2007 0:00
4.1 6/22/2007 0:00
67 6/22/2007 0:00
66 6/22/2007 0:00
il 6/22/2007 0:00
64 6/22/2007 0:00
63 6/22/2007 0:00
62 6/22/2007 0:00
61 6/22/2007 0:00
0 6/22/2007 0:00
59 1/15/2007 0:00
58 1/15/2007 0:00
51 1/4/2007 0:00
56 3/28/2007 0:00
55 3/28/2007 0:00
54 3/28/2007 0:00
53 3/28/2007 0:00
52 3/28/2007 0:00
51 4/10/2007 0:00
50 4/10/2007 0:00
42 4/10/2007 0:00
M 4/10/2007 0:00
47 4/10/2007 0:00
46 3/28/2007 0:00
45 3/28/2007 0:00
44 6/22/2007 0:00
43 6/22/2007 0:00
42 2/16/2007 0:00
,ll 12/22/2006 0:00
N 12/22/2006 0:00
39 12/22/2006 0:00
la 8/1/2006 0:00
31 8/1/2006 0:00
36 8/1/2006 0:00
35 3/28/2007 0:00
34 6/22/2007 0:00
33 6/22/2007 0:00
32 6/22/2007 0:00
31 6/22/2007 0:00
IQ 6/22/2007 0:00
22 6/22/2007 0:00
28 6/22/2007 0:00
27 6/22/2007 0:00
LO. 3/7/2007 0:00
25 2/26/2007 0:00
24 2/21/2007 0:00
23 3/1/2007 0:00
22 3/2/2007 0:00
al 3/1/2007 0:00
20 2/21/2007 0:00
19 2/21/2007 0:00
la 6/22/2007 0:00
17 6/22/2007 0:00
16 6/22/2007 0:00
15 6/22/2007 0:00
14 6/22/2007 0:00
ti 6/22/2007 0:00
12 6/22/2007 0:00
11 6/22/2007 0:00
12 6/22/2007 0:00
9 6/22/2007 0:00
8 6/22/2007 0:00
7 6/22/2007 0:00
6 6/22/2007 0:00
a 6/22/2007 0:00
4 6/22/2007 0:00
3 6/22/2007 0:00
2 9/1/2006 0:00
1 8/1/2006 0:00
Title
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE PHONE AND TOLL RECORDS
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE TOLL RECORDS AND SUBSCRIBER INFORMATION ON [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE BILLING AND TOLL INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION FOR [REDACTED]
(U//FOLIO) SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION FOR [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION FOR [REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOLIO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) RE:SUBPOENA
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNTING AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB•FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
Case Number.
Case Summary:
90A-NY-3151227
On 02/28/2025, FBI-NYO opened case 90A-NY-3151227, a death investigation case on 08/12/2019
after JEFFERY EPSTEIN was discovered unresponsive in his jail cell at MCC on 08/10/2019. Two
Correctional Officers were indicted for false records and conspiracy and subsequently self-
surrendered to the FBI on 11/19/2019. In May 2021, SDNY entered a deferred prosecution
agreement with the two Correctional Officers for a period of 6 months and the terms were satisfied.
90C-NY-3154599 is a contraband at MCC case in which EPSTEIN is referenced. 9A-NY-3144791 is a
threat to victim case in which EPSTEIN is referenced.
Serial Repc90A-NY-3151227
Serial * Date
211 2/28/2025 18:02
210 2/28/2025 18:02
2Q2 2/28/2025 17:14
VI 2/28/2025 15:32
207 7/2/2024 5:11
206 6/25/2024 13:19
205 5/31/2024 13:16
204 12/5/2022 15:25
203 9/21/2022 11:54
202 9/19/2022 14:25
241 8/1/2022 7:40
2.(V 7/8/2022 7:55
199 6/6/202210:25
198 5/10/2022 9:49
197 5/3/202216:07
196 2/3/2022 13:22
195 1/31/2022 14:31
194 11/22/2021 13:01
i1,₹ 9/2/20219:22
1.9.7, 7/26/2021 12:18
191 5/25/2021 16:15
190 3/4/202113:29
2,12 3/4/202113:28
188 10/14/2020 13:35
187 9/17/202015:39
186 9/10/2020 16:00
185 9/4/2020 13:12
1M 7/31/2020 10:41
183 7/31/2020 8:51
182 2/4/202010:49
111, 12/23/2019 15:14
180 12/23/2019 15:12
179 12/23/2019 15:10
178 12/20/2019 12:49
177 12/20/2019 12:48
rfi 12/20/2019 11:22
175 12/20/2019 11:22
174 12/19/2019 14:58
171 12/19/2019 14:57
212 12/19/2019 14:55
171 12/19/2019 14:48
170 12/19/2019 14:48
169 12/19/2019 14:47
168 12/13/2019 14:25
167 12/13/2019 14:25
166 12/13/2019 14:24
IQ 12/13/2019 14:24
4 12/13/2019 14:24
163 12/13/2019 14:08
1.62 12/13/2019 14:07
161 12/11/2019 13:39
160 8/29/2019 11:20
159 12/5/2019 12:36
158 12/4/2019 12:03
157 11/22/2019 9:15
156 11/22/2019 9:15
155 11/21/2019 14:27
&I 11/20/2019 13:37
2.5.1 11/19/2019 8:32
152 10/29/2019 10:09
151 10/15/2019 12:43
150 10/10/2019 16:16
149 2/5/2020 9:46
148 10/9/2019 9:14
147 10/9/2019 9:13
IA 10/3/2019 9:08
10/3/2019 9:02
144 10/3/2019 9:02
143 10/2/2019 11:57
112. 9/26/2019 15:45
141 9/26/2019 14:34
140 9/25/2019 10:18
139 9/25/2019 10:17
138 9/25/2019 10:17
13/ 9/25/2019 10:16
136 9/25/2019 10:15
135 9/25/2019 10:12
14 9/25/2019 10:12
133 9/25/2019 10:11
132 9/24/2019 16:01
131 9/24/2019 15:31
130 9/24/2019 14:15
la 9/24/2019 14:12
128 9/24/2019 10:06
127 9/24/2019 10:06
332 9/24/201910:03
M 9/24/2019 9:34
124 9/23/2019 16:15
123 9/23/2019 16:15
122 9/23/2019 15:41
121 9/18/2019 12:54
120 9/18/2019 12:46
119 9/18/2019 12:28
.1a 9/13/2019 14:08
117 9/13/2019 12:46
116 9/11/2019 11:24
jaa 9/10/2019 13:41
114 9/10/2019 11:23
113 9/10/2019 9:02
112 9/10/2019 9:02
in 9/9/201916:28
110 9/9/2019 16:24
109 9/9/2019 16:23
108 9/9/2019 16:23
122 9/9/201916:23
122 9/9/2019 16:22
105 9/9/2019 16:21
104 9/9/2019 16:19
103 9/9/2019 16:06
102 9/9/2019 16:02
101 9/9/201915:59
100 9/9/2019 15:58
22 9/4/2019 17:30
22 9/6/2019 10:08
97 9/6/201910:08
96 9/6/201910:08
22 9/6/201910:07
94 9/6/2019 10:07
93 9/6/2019 10:07
92 9/6/2019 10:07
91 9/6/201910:06
22 9/6/2019 10:06
22 9/6/2019 10:06
88 9/6/201910:05
22 9/6/2019 10:05
86 9/6/201910:05
85 9/6/201910:04
84 9/6/201910:04
83 9/6/201910:04
21 9/6/2019 10:04
81 9/6/2019 8:42
80 9/6/2019 8:42
Z2 9/6/2019 8:41
22 9/6/2019 8:41
77 9/6/2019 8:40
76 9/5/201916:25
75 9/5/2019 9:28
74 9/5/2019 9:28
73 9/4/201914:53
72 9/4/2019 14:51
71 9/3/2019 9:31
LQ 9/3/2019 9:30
69 8/30/2019 13:50
§1 8/29/2019 9:28
§1 8/29/2019 9:23
66 8/29/2019 9:19
65 8/29/2019 8:19
64 8/28/2019 16:51
e 8/28/201916:50
62 8/28/2019 16:47
61 8/27/2019 17:04
22 8/27/2019 14:20
a 8/27/2019 14:19
58 8/26/2019 16:18
57 8/26/201914:04
56 8/26/2019 13:55
55 8/26/2019 12:31
M 8/22/2019 11:08
53 8/22/2019 11:07
5/ 8/22/2019 7:00
5.1. 8/22/2019 6:59
50 8/21/2019 9:54
49 8/21/2019 9:40
g 8/21/2019 9:18
47 8/20/2019 14:11
46 8/20/2019 13:37
45 8/19/2019 16:05
44 8/19/201915:00
AI 8/19/2019 14:32
42 8/16/2019 16:25
41 8/16/201916:20
41 8/16/2019 16:02
39 8/16/2019 15:54
38 8/16/201915:44
37 8/16/2019 15:37
36 8/16/2019 15:31
g 8/16/2019 14:50
34 8/16/2019 14:50
33 8/16/2019 14:49
12 8/16/2019 14:49

3. 8/16/2019 12:18
30 8/16/2019 11:47
29 8/16/2019 11:45
28 8/16/2019 11:17
27 8/16/2019 10:46
26 8/16/201910:45
25 8/15/2019 17:05
24 8/15/2019 14:46
a 8/15/2019 14:45
22 8/15/2019 13:26
21 8/14/2019 14:22
20 8/14/2019 14:21
19 8/14/201914:20
18 8/14/2019 14:19
17 8/14/2019 14:18
16 8/14/2019 14:18
15 8/14/2019 14:17
14 8/14/2019 14:15
U 8/14/2019 14:14
12 8/14/2019 14:14
11 8/14/2019 14:14
10 8/14/2019 14:13
2 8/14/2019 14:13
8 8/14/2019 14:12
7 8/14/2019 14:11
6 8/14/2019 14:11
5 8/14/2019 14:10
4 8/14/2019 14:10
3 8/14/2019 9:09
2 8/14/2019 9:08
i 8/12/2019 10:26
Title

(U) Evidence Control Unit (ECU) Policy Note
(U) Item returned from OIG
(U) Restart chain of custody
(U) OIG return of evidence

(U) F0-1004
(U) UNSUB(S); JEFFREY EPSTEIN - VICTIM; DEATH INVESTIGATION
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC033797

(U) Closing Communication
(U) Evidence Chain of Custody for Items 1637 and 1B38
(U) Release of Evidence to the Office of the Inspector General (OIG)

(U) FW:
(U) Name check response - (REDACTED)
(U) 1A Import
(U) AUSA Evidence Email - Concurrence
(U) Release of Evidence to the Office of the Inspector General (OIG)

(U) Deferred Prosecution Agreement
(U) FW: Charged Out Evidence Coming Due
(U) FW: Evidence Recharge
(U) Request# HQQ190816001 TB

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO26022
(U) Email threat to (REDACTED)
(U) Intake Screening Phone Log

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) 90A-NY-3151227182 through 1618 Continuation chain use
(U) 2020-01577-1 Questioned Documents

(U) Response from FBI Laboratory Forensic Document Examiner
(U) Name check response - (REDACTED)
(U) Request to send Evidence to Laboratory for Handwriting Analysis

(U) Request for Laboratory Examinations
(U) Psychology report and interview notes
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Proffer of (REDACTED)
(U) Proffer of (REDACTED)

(U) Proffer of (REDACTED)
(U) Proffer of (REDACTED)
(U) interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) (REDACTED) Interview
(U) (REDACTED}Interview
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Daily Assignment Log for (REDACTED)
(U) Work Schedules for (REDACTED)
(U) Letter to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner Regarding the Autopsy of Jeffrey Epstein

(U) OIG Forms Provided by OIG (REDACTED)
(U) 016 Forms Provided by 016 (REDACTED)
(U) Transcription of Recorded Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Memorandum of Investigation Regarding the Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) 90A-NY-3151227 SID 223558 Process Report

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Suspicious Activity Report Received from JP Morgan Chase Regarding(REDACTED)

(U) Email Documenting Call with (REDACTED)
(U) Arrest of (REDACTED) and (REDACTED)
(U) Indictment of (REDACTED) and (REDACTED)

(U) CART Process Report for CART Submission ID:218509
(U) CART Archive designated as NYF01278
(U) Email Summarizing Conversation with Medical Examiner on November 14, 2019

(U) Jeffrey Epstein's Probate Petition and Will
(U) Suicide Training Documents for Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoenas Served to Metropolitan Correctional Center Employees
(U) Serial Moved - See Details for Justification

(U) Job Descriptions for Control Post at Metropolitan Correctional Center
(U) Letter Received from Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Form 583 Report of Incident Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC) Special Housing Unit (SHU) Video Review

(U) Email to OCME Requesting Documents and Photographs Pertaining to this Investigation
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Metropolitan Correctional Center Staff Rosters for July 23 - August 8, 2019
(U) Computer Analysis Provided by OIG

(U) MCC Suicide Watch 2nd Floor Drawing
(U) MCC 10th Floor Drawing
(U) MCC 9th and 10th Floor Drawing
(U) Picture of (REDACTED)

(U) Picture of (REDACTED)
(U) MCC Annual Refresher Training
(U) MCC Bed Assignments for Epstein
(U) SHU Inmate Log for August 9 and 10

(U) MCC Documents Regarding Epstein
(U) Counts and Count Slips for August 10, 2019
(U) Photograph of Homemade Rope from July 23, 2019 Incident

(U) TruView Documents Provided by Office of the Inspector General
(U) Phone Records for MCC Caller Station 6385

(U) Phone Records for MCC Caller Station 6317
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Evidence Return
(U) MCC Duty Officer Supplement

(U) OIG Referral - OIA-2019-05324
(U) Proffer of (REDACTED)
(U) NDA with SigNet Technologies Inc
(U) MCC Count Slips for July 23, 2019 to August 9, 2019

(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Documentation of MCC Special Housing Unit
(U) Email Provided by {REDACTED} Regarding Epstein Needing a Cellmate

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) 90A-NY-3151227 Process Report
(U) Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of the City of New York Autopsy Report

(U) 30 Minute Round Sheet for MCC ZB on July 27 and 29, 2019
(U) information Provided by Office of the Inspector General Regarding Job Descriptions at MCC

(U) Memorandum from {REDACTED} Regarding Jeffrey Epstein's Celimate
(U) EmaBs from MCC Regarding Suicide Watch and Psychological Observation of Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Memorandum by {REDACTED}regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) MCC Count Slips for August 10, 2019
(U) Document Provided Regarding MCC 30 Minute Rounds on August 10, 2019

(U) Document Provided Regarding MCC 30 Minute Rounds for August 6, 2019.
(U) Document Provided Regarding MCC 30 Minute Rounds on August 5, 2019.

(U) Email Regarding MCC Staff Assignments on August 10, 2019
(U) Documents Provided Regarding 30 Minute Rounds at Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Photographs of Jeffrey Epstein provided by BOP
(U) Proffer of {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Supplemental To Jeffrey E Epstein Arrest on July 06, 2019
(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Psychology Notes from July 8, 2019 Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Psychology Notes from July 9, 2019 Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Psychology Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Sentry Documentation for Jeffrey Epstein
(U) MCC Staff Emergency Contacts
(U) Staff Roster for MCC on 8/10/2019

(U) Staff Roster for MCC on 8/9/2019
(U) TRU-SCOPE Logs Provided by BOP
(U) Documents provided by {REDACTED} regarding 30 Minute Rounds

(U) Documents provided by {REDACTED} regarding 30 Minute Rounds
(U) Documents provided by {REDACTED} regarding 30 Minute Rounds

(U) Additional Psychology Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Jeffrey Epstein Investigative Reports
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of Corrections Officer {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Evidence return concurrence
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Return of Property belonging to (REDACTED)

(U) Proffer of (REDACTED)
(U) Office of Inspector General (OIG) Forms Provided by (REDACTED)
(U) CART Master Copy designated as NYCO25654

(U) (REDACTED) Interview
(U) Photo Log for Photos 41-67 of METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Documentation of FedEx shipment for original OIG waiver signed by (REDACTED)
(U) 90A-NY-3151227 MDUS #10754

(U) Device Extraction - MOUS 10754
(U) Request for Laboratory Examinations
(U) Receipt of Apple iPhone XS, 'MEW: 357208091738649

(U) Receipt of Apple iPhone XS
(U) Proffer Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Database Checks - (REDACTED)
(U) Database Checks - Persons of Interest

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO23596
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO23597

(U) Proffer Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Chain of Custody- Digital Evidence Laboratory - Items 1620, 1B21

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) F0-597/ Items 1820, 1821
(U) INTERVIEW OF MCC INMATE (REDACTED)
(U) Submission of Video Evidence from Metropolitan Correctional Center, NY NY

(U) Items 1837, 1838 transfer to NY OCME
(U) 08/10/2019 Evidence from MCC and (REDACTED)
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27715

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27714
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27713

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27712
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27711

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27710
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27709

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27708
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27707

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27706
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27705

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27704
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Search - Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC), Special Housing Unit, L-Tier, Cell 220

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27703
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27702

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27701
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Seizure of DVR Controller and DVR System #1

(U) Seizure of hard Drives Associated with DVR #2
(U) Seizure of DVR System #2
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23595

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23594
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23593
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23592

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23591
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23590
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23589

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23588
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23587
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23586

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23585
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23584
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23583

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23582
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23581
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23580

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23579
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23578
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Initial Review of EPSTEIN Inmate Records with Lieutenant Doctor (BOP)
(U) Opening EC
1A/1C Report for Case: 90A-NY-3151227
Type # Acquired On Serial #
lA 100 2024-06-25 2Q2
lA 99 2024-05-31 205
1A 11 2022.09-21 241
1A 91 2022-09-14 242
1A 96 2022-05-03 199
1A 95 2022-05-03 197
1A 94 2022-01-12 196
1A a 2021-06-16 193
1A U 2021-07-23 192
1A 91 2021-05-24 191
lA IQ 2021-05-24 121
1A 2020-03-12
lA AI 2020-09-17 187
Ilk
1A 9/ 2020-09-02
lA 86 2019-09-11
lA 85 2019-08-21 181
1A 94 2019-08-23 1Q
LA 83 2019-08-26 179
la 82 2019-12-19 178
1A a 2019-12-19 177
LA 14 2019-12-19 1171
1A 79 2019-12-19 175
1A 21 2019-08-20 124
1A ZZ 2019-08-21 1Z1
1A 76 2019-08-19 172
LA 75 2019-08-14 171
1A 74 2019-08-20 170
1A ZA 2019-09-25 169
1A 72 2019-12-11 163
1A 71 2019-12-11 162
1A ZQ 2019-11-19 15Z
1A 12 2019-11-19 151
1A 68 2019-09-18 151
1A 67 2019-08-15 150
1A §fi 2019-08-15 148
1A 65 2019-09-26 147
1A 64 2019-09-26 147
1A 63 2019-09-30 145
1A 02 2019-09-30 AI1
LA 4.1 2019-09-25 142
la 60 2019-08-13 131
1A 59 2019-08-13 129
LA 54 2019-08-30 111
IA 57 2019-09-24 125
LA 56 2019-08-28 122
lA 55 2019-09-11 119
LA 54 2019-08-17 118
ia 52 2019-09-06 .113.
1A 52 2019-08-28 114
1A 51 2019-08-12 112
1A 5Q 2019-08-11 143
la 49 2019-08-10 102
la as 2019-08-26 101
AZ 2019-08-17 122
1A slE 2019-08-12 100
1A 45 2019-08-28 80
1A 44 2019-08-23 80
1A 43 2019-08-20 79
1A 42 2019-08-15 78
1A 41 2019-08-28 77
1A 40 2019-08-16 77
1A 22 2019-08-16 ZZ
1A 21 2019-08-30 /¢
1A 37 2019-08-30 76
1A 36 2019-09-03 74
1A 25 2019-08-29 a
IA 34 2019-08-29 73
1A 33 2019-08-29 73
1A 32 2019-08-29 73
1A 23 2019-08-29 72
LA 44 2019-08-29 72
1A 29 2019-08-29 72
1A 28 2019-08-29 71
1A 2Z 2019-08-29 24
IA 26 2019-08-21 69
1A 25 2019-08-28 68
1A 24 2019-08-16 67
1A 23 2019-08-16 64
1A 22 2019-08-14 ¢2
1A 21 2019-08-12 2
1A 20 2019-08-12 62
1A 12 2019-08-23 4.1
1A a 2019-08-27 59
IA 17 2019-08-26 56
LA 16 2019-08-26 56
IA 15 2019-08-26 55
LA 14 2019-08-22 ,H
ia 13 2019-08-19 53
IA 12 2019-08-19 53
LA 11 2019-08-19 44
1A 34 2019-08-16 14
1A 9 2019-08-16 48
1A 8 2019-08-15 47
1A 7 2019-08-16 46
1A 6 2019-08-12 44
LA 5 2019-08-12 30
IA 4 2019-08-10 29
m 1 2019-08-12 21
IA 2 2019-08-12 2E
IA 1 2019-08-10 23
Serial Title

(U) FD-1004
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC033797
(U) Evidence Chain of Custody for Items 1637 and 1838

(U) Release of Evidence to the Office of the Inspector General (OIG)
(U) lA Import
(U) Release of Evidence to the Office of the Inspector General (OIG)

(U) Deferred Prosecution Agreement
(U) Request,* HQQ190816001 TB
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO26022

(U) Email threat to (REDACTED)
(U) Email threat to (REDACTED}
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) 2020-01577-1 Questioned Documents

(U) Response from FBI Laboratory Forensic Document Examiner
(U) Psychology report and interview notes
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of {REDACTED)
(U) Proffer of {REDACTED)
(U) Proffer of {REDACTED)

(U) Proffer of {REDACTED}
(U) Proffer of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED)
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED)
(U) (REDACTED)Interview
(U) (REDACTED)Interview
(U) Interview of {REDACTED)
(U) Transcription of Recorded Interview of(REDACTED)

(U) Memorandum of Investigation Regarding the interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Arrest of (REDACTED)and {REDACTED)

(U) Indictment of {REDACTED}and {REDACTED}
(U) Suicide Training Documents for Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoenas Served to Metropolitan Correctional Center Employees
(U) Job Descriptions for Control Post at Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Letter Received from Metropolitan Correctional Center
(U) Letter Received from Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC) Special Housing Unit (SHU) Video Review
(U) Interview of {REDACTED)

(U) Metropolitan Correctional Center Staff Rosters for July 23 - August 8, 2019
(U) Counts and Count Slips for August 10, 2019

(U) TruView Documents Provided by Office of the Inspector General
(U) Interview of BOP LT. Carlos Perez
(U) Evidence Return

(U) Proffer of {REDACTED)
(U) Interview of {REDACTED)
(U) Documentation of MCC Special Housing Unit
(U) Interview of {REDACTED)

(U) Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of the City of New York Autopsy Report
(U) Information Provided by Office of the Inspector General Regarding Job Descriptions at MCC

(U) Documents Provided Regarding 30 Minute Rounds at Metropolitan Correctional Center
(U) Photographs of Jeffrey Epstein provided by BOP

(U) Proffer of {REDACTED}
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Metropolitan Correctional Center
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of(REDACTED)
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of Corrections Officer {REDACTED}
(U) interview of Corrections Officer {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of Corrections Officer {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Return of Property belonging to {REDACTED}
(U) Proffer of {REDACTED}
(U) {REDACTED} Interview

(U) Photo Log for Photos 41-67 of METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Documentation of FedEx shipment for original OIG waiver signed by {REDACTED}
(U) Device Extraction - MDUS 10754

(U) Receipt of Apple iPhone XS
(U) Receipt of Apple iPhone XS
(U) Proffer Interview of
(U) Database Checks - {REDACTED}

(U) Database Checks - Persons of Interest
(U) Database Checks - Persons of Interest
(U) Proffer Interview of(REDACTED}

(U) Chain of Custody- Digital Evidence Laboratory - Items 1820, 1821
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) FD-S97/ Items 1820, 1821

(U) INTERVIEW OF MCC INMATE {REDACTED}
(U) Items 1837, 1838 transfer to NY OCME
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Search - Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC), Special Housing Unit, 1-Tier, Cell 220
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED}
(U) Seizure of hard Drives Associated with DVR #2
Summary
(U) CHAIN OF CUSTODY OF 1660

(U) NY-3151227 SID 112048 Admin Documents
(U) FD-1004 for Evidence Items 1837 and 1838
(U) Emails, OCME Letter, FD-1004 Chain of Custody Forms

(U) FD-1004 package copies for evidence items permanently released to OIG: 181-1836, 1840, 1842, 1843, 1845,

(U) FD-597 Receipt of Property Forms and FD-1004 Evidence Chain of Custody Forms
(U) Deferred Prosecution Agreements for (REDACTED) and (REDACTED}

(U) 2 Lab Report, 16 CoC, 2 Shipping invoice, 1 CD-R (logs), 1 DEMS disc
(U) Tape Information
(U) Open source and database information on (REDACTED)

(U) Email threat to {REDACTED} from (REDACTED)
(U) Interview Notes taken by (REDACTED)
2020-01577-1 QUESTIONED DOCUMENTS
2020-01577-1 1A.zip
CASE NOTE INTERFACE REPORT:
CNI Questioned Documents (AF) Case Note (128072).p
CASE COMMUNICATION LOG FILES:
2020-01577 email attachment (16 110).pdf
2020-01577 #1 Reply to acknowledgment.pdf
2020-01577 email attachment (16 89).pdf
2020-01577 #2_UNCLASS.pdf
2020-01577 email attachment (18 92).pdf
2020-01577 emails with {REDACTED}.pdf
CASE REPORT:
CaseReport2020-01577.pdf
CASE RECORD FILES:
2020-01577 #1 Record Images (i3).pdf
2020-01577 Enclosures.pdf
2020-01577 #1 Record Images (i6).pdf
2020-01577 #2 Record Images (i4-iS).pdf
2020-1577-1 Archived Record Images of items 1 and
2020-01577 #1 Notes.pdf

(U) Email from FBI Lab
(U) Psychology report and interview notes
(U) (REDACTED) interview notes
(U) (REDACTED) interview notes

(U) (REDACTED) interview notes
(U) (REDACTED) Notes
(U) (REDACTED) Notes
(U) Notes (REDACTED)
(U) Notes (REDACTED)

(U) Interview Notes (REDACTED)
(U) Interview notes (REDACTED)
(U) Interview notes (REDACTED)
(U) (REDACTED) interview notes

(U) (REDACTED) interview notes
(U) (REDACTED) interview notes
(U) Transcripts of Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) MOI regarding the interview of (REDACTED}
(U) USMS Arrest Paperwork and Copy of Arrest Warrants
(U) Indictment of (REDACTED) and (REDACTED)

(U) MCC Suicide Prevention Material
(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoenas to MCC Employees
(U) Post Orders for Control

(U) Letter
(U) Letter and Chain of Custody from MCC
(U) MCC SHU Video Reviews
(U) Notes from (REDACTED) Second Interview

(U) MCC Staff Rosters
(U) 5 AM Count 3 AM Count, and Count Slips for August 10, 2019
(U) Epstein's TruView

(U) AGENT NOTES
(U) Package copy for 1B44. Evidence was returned to (REDACTED) on 8/28/19 by (REDACTED) per EC 8/29/19 Se

(U) Proffer Notes - (REDACTED)
(U) Notes from (REDACTED) interview, Copy of MCC Count Slip, Copy of MCC 30 Minute Round Sheet

(U) Administrative Worksheet, Sign-In Log, Total Station Data, Schematic with measurements, and Sketch.
(U) Bureau of Prisons Psychology Services Post Suicide Watch report dated 7/24/2019 at 09:23 for inmate Jeffrey

(U) Autopsy Report of Epstein
(U) Job Descriptions of General Housing Unites and SHU at MCC
(U) 30 Minute Round Sheets for MCC

(U) Photographs of Epstein
(U) Notes by (REDACTED} for (REDACTED)
(U//FOUO) Working Copy of LASER Scan Data and Field Projects
- One (1) CD of WORKING COPY of RAW scan data for "Main Area"
- One (1) CD of WORKING COPY of RAW scan data for "Cell"
- One (1) CD of Scene2Go products for both "Main Area" and "Cell"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for both "Main Area" and "Cell"
- Copy of each sketch showing locations of scans

(U) Original LASER Scan Data and Field Office products
- Two (2) CDs of ORIGINAL RAW scan data for "Main Area"
- Two (2) CDs of ORIGINAL RAW scan data for "Cell"
- One (1) CD of Scene2Go products for both "Main Area" and "Cell"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for both "Main Area" and "Cell"
- Copy of each Error Report for both area projects
- Copy of each sketch showing locations of scans

(U) OIG Form signed by (REDACTED)
(U) Notes from (REDACTED) interview
(U) Interview Notes (REDACTED)
(U) Notes from interview of (REDACTED) and Pictures of (REDACTED) and (REDACTED} shown to (REDACTED)

(U) OIG Form - (REDACTED)
(U) FD-597 and SDNY Receipt for Property
(U) Interview Notes and Picture of {REDACTED}

(U) EPSTEIN July 8, 2019 Intake Screening
(U) Interview Notes (REDACTED)
(U) Notes from interview of Contreras

(U) MCC SHU lime Sheet
(U) MCC Head Count Sheet
(U) MCC Memorandum
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Reference Documents #3, #6, #7, #8, #9

(U) Reference Documents #1, #2, #4, #5
(U) (REDACTED} Notes from (REDACTED)
(U) (REDACTED} Notes
(U) (REDACTED} NOTES

(U) Interview notes
(U) Evidence retum documents
(U) Proffer Notes taken by (REDACTED}
(U) Notes
(U) One CD labeled "Working Copy," one CD labeled "original copy," Maps: 2nd Floor Psych, 2nd Floor Psych, 9 SH

(U) OIG warning
(U) (REDACTED} interview notes
(U) FedEx tracking documentation
(U) Legal Authority
(U) FD-597 receipt for property

(U) Consent to search Computer/Electronic Equipment form (OIG-Form 233/4)
(U)(REDACTED)proffer notes
(U) Database checks and a work-up on (REDACTED).

(U) Database checks and work-up for (REDACTED).
(U) Database checks and work-up for (REDACTED).
(U) Proffer Notes

(U) Chain of Custody- Digital Evidence Laboratory - Items 1820, 1821
(U) 08/16/2019 (REDACTED} Interview Notes

(U) FD-S97/ Items 1820, 1821
(U) INTERVIEW NOTES OF INMATE
(U) OCME Evidence Receipt
(U) Interview documents

(U) BOP chain of custody logs and Photos of search
(U) Copy of signed OIG waiver
(U) Original Interview Notes

(U) FD•597 Receipt for property
Edward Epstein registration number 76318-054 and Interview Notes of (REDACTED)
Evidence Report for Case:
Filtering on:
Item 4
1B37
90A-NY-3151227
Type(s):1B, 1D, 1E
Description

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO23578: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, STSOODM002, S/N Z3T6CJJA,
(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23579: One (1) Hitachi 500GB HDD, HDS721050CLA662, S/N JP1572JE36A13K

(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23580: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, STSOODM002, S/N Z3T6CF5X,
(U) One red rope contalning:NYCO23581: One (1) Seagate Barracuda SOOGB HDD, ST350032ONS, S/N

(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23582: One (1) Hitachi 50008 HDD, HDS721050CLA662, S/N
(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23583: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST3500320NS, S/N 9QM8EC75,

(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23584: One (1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N
(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23585: One (1) Western Digital 50068 HDD, WD5000AVDS-63U7B1, S/N

(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23586: One (1) Western Digital 500GB HDD, WD5000AAIOC- 60U6AAO, S/N
(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23587: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST350032ONS, S/N

(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23588: One (1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HOD, STSOONM0011, S/N
(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23589: One (1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N

(U) One red rope contalning:NYCO23590: One (1) Western Digital 500GB HDD, WDS000AVDS- 63U7B1, S/N
(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23591: One (1) Western Digital 50068 HDD, WDS000AAKX-60U6AA0, S/N

(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23592: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST350032ONS, S/N
(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23593: One (1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N

(U) NYCO23594: One (1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N Z1M1LOYG, from MCC Nice
(U) One red rope containing:NYCO23595: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST350032ONS, S/N

(U) Two boxes containing: DVR System #2 consisting of the following items:
1. Disk Array Chassis; Model#: SA-66405, SN: F96168201-004

2. Disk Array Controller; Model#: NP-2000, SN: 43144902
(U) Dell Powerridge R420 DVR Controller, Barcode# SBMQZ12, Express service Code #: 11587249622,

(U) ONE LARGE BROWN BOX CONTAINING: DVR System #1 consists of the following items:
1. Disk Array Chassis containing 16 hard Drives; Model#: Premium 8600, SN: 232476

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27701: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB Hard Drive, model ST10000M003,
S/N S1D85PLA, containing the Clone Copy of 1B1 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, STSOODM002, S/N

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27702: One (1) Hitachi 1TB Hard Drive, HUA722010CLA330, S/N
JPW9KON039EZLL, containing the Clone Copy of 182 hard drive (Hitachi 500GB HOD, HDS721050CLA662, S/N

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27703: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB Hard Drive, model ST1000DM003,
S/N Z1D3ZSSO, containing the Clone Copy of 1B3 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, STSOODM002, S/N

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27704: One (1) Seagate Desktop 1TB hard drive, model ST1000DM003, S/N
24YDRIT, containing the Clone Copy of 1B4 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB Hard Drive, 513500320N5, S/N

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27705: One (1) Seagate Desktop 1TB hard drive, model ST1000DM003, S/N
Z4YDHX5M, containing the Clone Copy of 1B6 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST350032ONS, S/N

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27706: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB Hard Drive, model ST10000M003,
S/N W1D4LIYH6, containing the Clone Copy of 187 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 500GB, STSOONM0011,

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27707: One (1) Western Digital 1TB hard drive, WD10EADS-00L5B1, S/N
WCAU45803950, containing the Clone Copy of 188 hard drive (Western Digital 500GB HDD, WD5000AVDS-

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27708: One (1) Seagate Desktop 1000GB HDD, ST100DM003, S/N Z4Y00Q48,
containing the Clone Copy of 1B9 hard drive (Western Digital 500GB HDD, WDS000AAKX- 60U6AAO, S/N

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27709: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N
W1D496N0, containing the Clone Copy of 1610 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda SOOGB HOD, ST3S0032ONS, S/N

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27710: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N
Z1DB25CT, containing the Clone Copy of 1B11 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011,

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27711: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N
W1D48Z6E, containing the Clone Copy of 1812 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 50008 HDD, STSOONM0011,

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27712: One (1) Western Digital 1000GB HDD, WD1003FZEX-00MK2A0, S/N
WCC3F2783519, containing the Clone Copy of 1815 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, 5T3500320NS,

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27713: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N
S1D9GK9P, containing the Clone Copy of 1816 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, ST500NM0011,

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27714: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N
S1D9DETC, containing the Clone Copy of 1B17 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011,

(U) One red rope containing: NYCO27715: One (1) Seagate Barracuda, 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N
W1D06T5L, containing the Clone Copy of 1B18 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST3500320NS, S/N

(U) One (1) torn sheet.
(U) Clothing released from New York Presbyterian Hospital
(U) One red rope containing papers.

(U) One red rope containing: One (1) Seagate 500gb hard drive, serial number W2AEXSIV, containing video
downloaded from DVR1 at MCC contained in 4 folders. Folders as follows: all video available for download for

(U) One cellophane containing one (1) MP-3 Player.
(U) One red rope containing: One (1) Hitachi 2TB Hard Drive, OF10311JPK3EAOP09, S/N B9GMGTYF, containing

(U) One red rope containing: One (1) WD Black 3TB hard drive, WD3003FZEX-00Z4SAO, S/N WCC13LZR579P,
containing the verified E01 images NYCO23578 (1B1), NYCO23579 (182), NYCO23580 (183), NYCO23581 (184),

(U) One (1) Apple iPhone XS, IMEl#: 357208091738649
(U) One red rope containing: NYCO25654- One (1) Western Digital 250 GB Hard Drive (Model: WD2500JD S/N:

(U) One red rope containing:NYF01278- One (1) IBM LTO5 Data Cartridge containing Archive of Case Volume in

(U) One red rope said to contain: Hard Drive, Seagate, ST500NM0011, S/N: Z1M16CMQ, Clone of repaired 1B5,

(U) One red rope said to contain: Hard Drive, Seagate, ST3500630AS, S/N: 9QG4FNAD, Clone of repaired 1817,

(U) One red rope said to contain: Hard Drive, Toshiba, DT01ACA050, S/N: 74J2z3GAS, Clone of repaired 1818,

(U) One red rope said to contain: Hard Drive, Seagate, STSOONM0011, S/N: Z1M116000, Clone of 1813,
(U) One red rope said to contain: Hard Drive, Seagate, ST3500410SV, S/N: 6VM5VRFN, Clone of 1B14, derivative

(U) One red rope said to contain the following: Hard Drive, Seagate, ST3500630A, S?N: 9qg23rDP, Clone of

(U) ONE REDROPE CONTAINING: Two (2) Ultrium LT0-6 tapes containing the CART network archive of video
(U) ONE REDROPE CONTAINING: Archive of DVR 2 Controller images, DVR 2 repaired drive images, and Video

(U) ONE REDROPE CONTAINING: 1 10TB SEAGATE HARD DRIVE CONTAINING ARCHIVE OF DVR 1 IMAGES
(U) ONE REDROPE CONTAINING: 12.0 TB WD HARD DRIVE CONTAINING ARCHIVE OF DVR MAIN CONTROLLER

(U) ONE LARGE BROWN BOX CONTAINING: DVR SYSTEM 1:
2. Disk Array Controller; Model#: NP-2000, SN: 43144901

(U) RED ROPE containing HQQ019335 Hard Drive, Western Digital WD1001FALS-41Y6A1, S/N:WCATR7962678,
(U) BOX CONTAINING: eighteen (18) hard drives

(U) (1) Red rope containing: Two (2) Ultrium LTO6 tapes containing the archive of MCC video images and work
Case Number.
Case Summary:
90C-NY-3154599
On 8/17/2019, the FBI opened an investigation into contraband being brought into Metropolitan Correctional
Center. Epstein was referenced in this case.
Serial Report for Case: I90C-NY-3154599
Serial # Date
g 9/6/2024 5:53
60 10/21/2023 12:13
52 9/8/2023 14:19
51 5/3/2023 12:37
57 1/13/2023 13:20
56 1/11/202316:55
55 12/2/2021 14:41
54 9/30/2020 9:26
53 3/16/2020 11:02
52 3/10/2020 12:53
51 2/20/2020 16:24
5.Q 2/20/2020 16:24
49 8/15/2019 13:26
48 8/15/2019 14:45
47 8/15/2019 14:46
46 8/20/2019 13:37
45 8/19/2019 16:05
44 2/4/2020 11:23
4 2/3/2020 11:35
IZ 2/3/2020 11:32
41 2/3/2020 11:13
40 2/3/202011:08
32 2/3/2020 9:39
38 2/3/2020 9:22
37 2/3/2020 9:11
36 2/3/2020 9:07
35 1/29/2020 15:27
24 1/29/202015:06
11 12/3/2019 9:05
32 11/7/2019 11:33
31 10/30/201910:10
30 10/30/201910:11
29 10/29/2019 15:17
28 10/29/2019 15:16
27 10/23/2019 11:02
22 10/23/2019 10:59
25 10/18/2019 11:35
24 10/11/2019 15:13
22 10/11/2019 15:11
10/11/2019 15:04
21 10/4/2019 11:32
20 10/3/2019 13:19
19 9/19/2019 12:56
18 9/19/2019 11:03
17 9/6/2019 8:40
16 9/5/2019 16:24
15 8/23/2019 12:27
14 8/23/2019 12:10
13 8/23/2019 9:11
12 8/23/2019 9:11

AI. 8/23/2019 9:08
10 8/23/2019 9:07
9 8/22/2019 11:08
8 8/22/2019 9:00
7 8/22/2019 8:55
6 8/21/2019 16:16
5 8/21/2019 15:49
4 8/21/2019 15:47
1 8/21/2019 9:50
2 8/20/2019 14:09
1 8/17/2019 9:10
Title

(U) 1A Upload- 1B3
(U) Closing EC
(U) Evidence disposal
(U) Evidence disposal
(U) Late Justification EC
(U) Recorded interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Return of Evidence to (REDACTED)
(U) Review of Cell Site data related to Search Warrant Returns
(U) Proffer of (REDACTED) - 02/12/2020

(U) Evidence Disposition Destruction
(U) )000000000(
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Seizure of DVR System #2

(U) Seizure of hard Drives Associated with DVR #2
(U) Seizure of DVR Controller and DVR System #1
(U) INTERVIEW OF MCC INMATE (REDACTED)

(U) Submission of Video Evidence from Metropolitan Correctional Center, NY NY
(U) Search warrant application and affidavit and warrants with proof of service

(U) SW Application, SW
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Notes, Subpoena service
(U) Recorder interviews rendered on 8/14/19

(U) FD-26 and FD-597 for (REDACTED)
(U) Optlal Dish w/ 85 digital photographs of {REDACTED} cell phones
(U) FD597

(U) FD-597, Receipt for e-property
(U) FD-26 and FD597 for (REDACTED)
(U) Receipt for electronic property

(U) Interview Notes
(U) T-Mobile Search Warrant -(REDACTED) Cell Site Data
(U) Photographing of (REDACTED) Cellular Telephone

(U) )000030000(
(U) Trasfer of Custody of (REDACTED) Telephones from SDNY USAO
(U) )000000000C
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED) - 10/16/2019
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}; MCC
(U) Interview of {REDACTED} on 9/18/2019

(U) Proffer with (REDACTED)
(U) Proffer of (REDACTED) - 08/22/2019
(U) Interview of (REDACTED) - 09/27/2019

(U) Interview of (REDACTED) -09/27/2019
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Canvass for Surveillance Cameras in the Vicinity of MCC

(U) Interview of Corrections Officer (REDACTED)
(U) Search Warrant Executed on (REDACTED}' Cell Phones number (REDACTED}

(U) )000000000C
(U) )000000000(
(U) Transfer of Cellular Telephones for Processing
(U) Reciept of Documents

(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Database Checks - (REDACTED)
(U) Reciept of Documents

(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Search Warrant Execution for Cellular Phones belong to (REDACTED) and (REDACTED)

(U) Search Warrant Execution for Cellular Phones belong to(REDACTED) and (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Opening Communication
1A/1C Report for Case: i 90C-NY-3154599
Type # Acquired On Serial *
1A '12 2024-08-14 g
lA 48 2023-05-01 58
1A 4.2 2021-12-02 a 1A IN  2020-09-21 5.4
1A 45 2019-09-18 51
1A 44 2019-09-18 SO
1A 43 2019-09-18 so
1A 42 2019-09-18 50
1A 41 2020-02-20 50
1A ao 2020-02-20 50
1A 22 2019-09-26 IQ
1A a 2019-09-18 52
1A 37 2019-08-22 44
1A 36 2019-08-16 43
1A 35 2019-08-23 42
1A 34 2019-09-09 41
1A 33 2019-08-14 40
1A 32 2019-08-14 39
1A 31 2019-08-23 3$
lA N 2019-08-16 3/
lA 29 2019-08-19 36
1A 28 2019-08-22 34
1A 21 2019-10-18 22
1A 26 2019-08-23 31
1A 25 2019-09-09 30
1A 24 2019-08-23 30
1A 23 2019-08-23 29
1A 22 2019-09-09 a 1A 21 2019-10-18 25
lA 20 2019-08-23 19
1A a 2019-08-19 25
lA a 2019-08-19 15
lA 17 2019-08-19 14
1A 16 2019-08-19 13
lA 15 2019-08-22 12
1A 14 2019-08-19 11
lA 13 2019-08-14 11
lA 12 2019-08-20 10
lA 11 2019-08-19 4
1A 33 2019-08-19 7
1A 9 2019-08-16 6
1A 8 2019-08-16 5
1A 7 2019-08-16 4
1A 6 2019-08-14 I.
1A 5 2019-08-14 2
IA 4 2019-08-15 2
IA 2 2019-08-14 2
1A 2 2019-08-14 2
IA 1 2019-08-14 1
Serial Title

(U) lA Upload- 1B3
(U) Evidence disposal
(U) Return of Evidence to (REDACTED)
(U) Review of Cell Site data related to Search Warrant Returns

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents

(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents

(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Search warrant application and affidavit and warrants with proof of service

(U) SW Application, SW
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Notes, Subpoena service
(U) Recorder interviews rendered on 8/14/19

(U) FD-26 and FD-597 for {REDACTED}
(U) Optial Dish w/ 85 digital photographs of (REDACTED) cell phones
(U) FD597

(U) FD-597, Receipt for e-property
(U) Receipt for electronic property
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Photographing of (REDACTED). Cellular Telephone

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) Trasfer of Custody of {REDACTED} Cellular Telephones from SDNY USAO

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) Interview of (REDACTED); MCC
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}
(U) Search Warrant Executed on (REDACTED) Cell Phones number (REDACTED)

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) Transfer of Cellular Telephones for Processing

(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents

(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Search Warrant Execution for Cellular Phones belong to (REDACTED) and (REDACTED)

(U) Search Warrant Execution for Cellular Phones belong to (REDACTED) and (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of(REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)
(U) Interview of (REDACTED)

(U) Opening Communication
Summary
(U) FD1087,1004- 183
(U) Email Attachments
(U) Signed FD-597 and FD-1004s.

(U) Historical Cell site returns
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) {REDACTED}Employee Records at MCC
(U) {REDACTED}Work Schedule at MCC for 8/18/19 to 8/23/19

(U) {REDACTED} Inmate Profile
(U) Case Notes
(U) Cadre inmates released to include halfway house. May-August 2019

(U) Unit Rosters
(U) MCC 3 AM Count Slips for 8/10/2019 including a hand Writing exemplar for {REDACTED}

(U) Search warrant application and affidavit and warrants with proof of service
(U) SW Application, SW
(U) Interview of {REDACTED}

(U) Notes, Subpoena service
(U) Recorder interviews rendered on 8/14/19
(U) FD-26 and FD-597 for {REDACTED}

(U) Optial Dish w/ 85 digital photographs of {REDACTED}s cell phones
(U) FD597
(U) F0-597, Receipt for e-property

(U) Receipt for electronic property
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Photographs of content on (REDACTED) cellular telephone

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) property receipts
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied

(U) Interview Notes (REDACTED)
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Property Receipts Related to Evidence Processing
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) Property Receipts
(U) (REDACTED}schedule and Assignments 5/31/2019
(U) Metro Card Database Check Reports

(U) Metro Card Photos
(U) (REDACTED) Housing Assignment
(U) (REDACTED) Communications Report
(U) (REDACTED) schedule and Assignments 6/1/19 to 8/19/2019

(U) Visitors Log from MCC
(U) Search Warrant Documents
(U) Search Warrant Documents
(U) email from (REDACTED)

(U) Photos taken at time of interview of (REDACTED} identification, metro cards and call history
(U) MCC incident report with photos, memo by (REDACTED}, memo by (REDACTED}, BOP Notification to Visitor, i

(U) {REDACTED} FD 26 and FD 597 Consent to Search
(U) Recorded Interview Video
(U) MCC Incident Report
lidmin detention order, Roster, medical report,
Evidence Report for Case: 90C-NY-3154599
Filtering on: Type(s):1B, 1D, 1E
Item It Collected On Description
1B3 8/22/201916:30 (U) ONE CELLOPHA
1B2 8/16/201916:30 (U) ONE CELLOPHA
1B1 8/14/2019 17:30 (U) ONE CELLOPHA
1D1 12/1/2022 12:25 (U) NYEM489294Ri
Description

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING: Flash drive serial number 0002586 containing data obtained from (phone Xr

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING: (phone 7 Serial Number FYQVT0J4HFY0
(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING: (phone Xr Serial Number F2LYX56VKKKQ

(U) NYEM#89294
Recorded non-custodial interview of {REDACTED}
ierial Number F2LYX56VKXKQ and phone 7 Serial Number FYQVT0J4HFY0
Case Number 9A-NY-3144791
Case Summary:
Threats against victim of Epstein were anymously posted online. The case was opened on
7/26/2019 and closed on 5/12/2020. Attempts to make contact with the individual who
posted the threats were unanswered.
Serial Repc:9A-NY-3144791
Serial # Date
7 5/12/2020 14:56
6 5/4/2020 9:00
I 9/5/2019 4:23
4 8/8/2019 13:46
3 8/2/2019 15:24
2 8/1/2019 8:34
1 7/26/2019 9:43
Title

(U) Closing EC
(U) Updated OCE activity
(U) Anonymous threat against (REDATED}
(U) Attempted Contact To Threat to Life Posting on (REDATED).

(U) FDR to Legat Canberra
(U) Request for OCE
(U) Opening EC

╭────────────────────────── Page 255, Image 1 ──────────────────────────╮
│ [A/C Rep 9A-NY-3144791                                                │
│                                                                       │
│ lType it Serial # Serial Title                                        │
│ 1A 2 4 (U) Attempted Contact To Threat to Life Posting on {REDACTED}. │
│ JA i 1 (U) Opening EC                                                 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA02730741 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ Evidence list for 50D-NY-3027571 Filtering On 'Type(s): 1B'
(approximate date: 2025-05-01)
Case Number:
Case Summary:
50D-NY-3027571
Child Sex Trafficking investigation into Epstein, opened 12/08/2018. Epstein was
indicted on 07/02/2019 and arrested on 07/06/2019. On 08/10/2019, FBI NY was
notified Epstein committed suicide in his jail cell. Maxwell was indicted on
06/29/2020 and arrested on 07/02/2020. The Maxwell trial began on 11/28/2021.
Maxwell was convicted on 12/29/2021 on S out of 6 counts. Maxwell was sentenced
on 06/28/2022 to 20 years. In November 2024, the U.S. appeals court rejected
Maxwell's request for en banc review. Maxwell requested an appeals extension to
04/10/2025. This investigation remains in Pending Inactive status.
Evidence Report for Case: 50D-NY-3027571
Filtering on: Type(s):1B
Item # Collected On
1B146 7/22/2022 10:00
1B145 5/25/202214:00
1B144 5/25/2022 14:00
1B143 7/7/2019 3:00
1B142 10/8/202113:00
1B141 10/8/202113:00
1B140 10/8/202113:00
1B139 6/29/2021 16:15
18138 8/12/2019 19:20
1B137 8/28/2006 11:50
1B136 1/26/202116:00
1B135 6/6/2019 12:00
1B134 8/28/2006 11:00
1B133 8/28/2006 11:00
1B132 8/28/2006 11:50
18131 8/28/2006 11:50
1B130 8/28/2006 11:50
1B129 8/28/2006 11:50
1B128 8/28/200611:50
18127 8/28/2006 11:50
18126 8/12/2019 19:20
1B125 8/12/2019 19:20
1B124 8/12/2019 19:20
1B123 8/12/2019 19:20
1B122 8/12/2019 19:20
1B121 8/12/2019 19:20
1B120 8/12/2019 19:20
1B119 8/12/2019 19:20
1B118 8/12/2019 19:20
1B117 8/12/2019 19:20
1B116 8/12/2019 19:20
1B115 8/12/2019 19:20
1B114 8/12/2019 19:20
1B113 8/12/2019 19:20
18112 8/12/2019 19:20
1B111 8/12/2019 19:20
1B110 8/12/2019 19:20
1B109 8/12/2019 19:20
1B108 8/12/2019 19:20
1B107 8/12/2019 19:20
18106 8/12/2019 19:20
11105 8/12/2019 19:20
1B104 8/12/2019 19:20
18103 8/12/2019 19:20
1B102 8/12/2019 19:20
18101 8/12/2019 19:20
1B100 8/12/2019 19:20
1B99 8/12/2019 19:20
1898 8/12/2019 19:20
1B97 8/12/2019 19:20
1B96 8/12/2019 19:20
1B95 8/12/2019 19:20
1B94 8/12/2019 19:20
1893 8/12/2019 19:20
1B92 8/12/2019 19:20
1691 8/12/2019 19:20
1690 8/12/2019 19:20
1889 8/12/2019 19:20
1888 8/12/2019 19:20
1887 8/12/2019 19:20
1886 8/12/2019 19:20
1685 8/12/2019 19:20
1884 8/12/2019 19:20
1683 8/12/2019 19:20
1682 8/12/2019 19:20
1881 8/12/2019 19:20
1680 8/12/2019 19:20
1679 7/11/2019 15:35
1B78 7/11/2019 15:35
1B77 7/11/2019 15:35
1B76 7/11/2019 15:35
1B75 7/11/2019 15:35
1B74 7/11/2019 15:35
1B73 7/11/2019 15:35
1872 7/6/2019 18:15
1871 7/6/2018 18:15
1870 7/11/2019 19:28
1869 7/11/2019 19:28
1B68 7/11/2019 19:28
1867 7/11/2019 19:28
1B66 7/11/2019 19:28
1865 7/11/2019 19:28
1B64 7/11/2019 19:28
1B63 7/11/2019 19:28
1862 7/11/2019 19:28
1B61 7/11/2019 19:28
1860 7/11/2019 19:28
1B59 7/11/2019 19:28
1658 7/11/2019 19:28
1857 7/11/2019 19:28
1856 7/11/2019 19:28
1B55 7/11/2019 19:28
1B54 7/11/2019 19:28
1653 7/11/2019 19:28
1B52 7/11/2019 16:28
1B51 7/11/2019 16:28
1B50 7/11/2019 16:28
1849 7/11/2019 16:28
1848 7/11/2019 16:28
1847 7/11/2019 16:28
1846 7/11/2019 16:28
1845 7/11/2019 19:28
1844 7/11/2019 19:28
1843 7/11/2019 19:28
1842 7/11/2019 19:28
1841 7/11/2019 19:28
1840 7/11/2019 19:28
1B39 7/11/2019 19:28
1B38 7/11/2019 19:28
1837 7/11/2019 19:28
1B36 7/11/2019 19:28
1835 7/11/2019 19:28
1B34 7/11/2019 19:28
1833 7/11/2019 19:28
1B32 7/11/2019 19:28
1B31 7/11/2019 19:28
1B30 7/11/2019 19:28
1B29 7/11/2019 19:28
1B28 7/11/2019 19:28
1827 7/7/2019 3:00
1826 7/7/2019 3:00
1825 7/7/2019 3:00
1824 7/7/2019 3:00
1823 7/7/2019 3:00
1822 7/7/2019 3:00
1821 7/7/2019 3:00
1B20 7/7/2019 3:00
1819 7/7/2019 3:00
1818 7/7/2019 3:00
1817 7/7/2019 3:00
1816 7/7/2019 3:00
1815 7/7/2019 3:00
1B14 7/7/2019 3:00
1813 7/7/2019 3:00
1812 7/7/2019 3:00
1811 7/7/2019 3:00
1810 7/7/2019 3:00
1B9 7/7/2019 3:00
188 7/7/2019 3:00
1B7 7/7/2019 3:00
1B6 7/7/2019 3:00
1B5 7/6/2019 0:00
1B4 5/29/201918:00
1B3 5/29/201918:00
1B2 5/29/2019 18:00
1B1 5/29/201918:00
Description

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE containing: NYC032395 - One (1)DVD-R containing image log files and FTK reports for systel

(U) Red Rope Containing;NYC032391 - Three (3) LTD 6 tape cartridges containing an Arcserve backup of all digital

(U) Red Rope Containing;NYC032392 - Two(2) LTO 6 tape cartridges containing an Arcserve backup of all digital evi

(U) one (1) CD labelled "girl plcs nude book 4"
(U) ONE REDROPE CONTAINING: (1) Envelope containing 1 VHS tape, 2 cassette tapes & 4 micro cassette tapes

(U) ONE REDROPE CONTAINING: (1) Envelope containing 4 CD's
(U) (2) Bankers box containing various EPSTEIN related case materials

(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: One pair of black women's cowboy boots, size 8
(U) ONE CELLOPHANE containing: Disk containing images of Matchmaker shred reconstruction

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING: (1) un-framed photo.
(U//FOUO) ONE RED ROPE containing: Highly confidential responsive material to include nude and semi nude ima

(U) Box containing Ten yearbooks collected by FBI West Palm Beach Resident Agency
(U) One (1) peach massage table.

(U) One (1) green massage table (PBPD0S-1024).
(U) One (1) beige massage table.
(U) One (1) brown massage table.

(U) One flat box containing one (1) large framed photo.
(U) One box containing four (4) framed photos.
(U) One box containing twelve (12) framed photos.

(U) One box containing five (5) framed photos
(U) One red rope containing: LSJ logbook
(U) One red rope containing:Daily Vessel Trip logs Feb 2, 2017 - Feb 16, 2017

(U) HP Tower S/N: CNV74213M3 Model: 570-p056
(U) Lenovo Tower S/N: 153306G2USAIXEKGX
(U) Lenovo Tower S/N: M107YG6U Machine type: 90J0

(U) Mac DesktopS/N: W89524C2SPJ model A1312
(U) HP TowerS/N: CNV716004YModel #: 260-a010
(U) HP Desktop TowerS/N: CNV7160050Model #: 260-a010

(U) Silver Mac desktop
(U) 6 Bay with 146GB drivesS/N: MXQ824A1R
(U) One box containing Panasonic KX-TDE100S/N: KX-TDA01049LCCD005398

(U) HP server with (4) 500 GB drivesS/N: MXQ3220187
(U) Blue prints
(U) One cellophane containing:Boat trip log & employee lists

(U) Unifi serverMacID: 1735K788A20463234-8uuu9FFCCID: SWX-UASPRO
(U) Unifi videoM/N: UVC-NVR-2TBMacID: 1829FB4FBE426EA90

(U) One cellophane containing:Paper with passwords on both sides
(U) Unifi Cloud keyM/N: UN-CKFCCID: SWX-UCCKIC 6545A-UCCKMac ID: 1843KB4FBE4D30C69-dcRgm9

(U) CELLOPHANE containing Olympus Digital Voice Recorder
(U) Silver Mac desktopModel #: A1311S/N: W804736DDA5

(U) Dell Inspiron tower with power cordReg Model: D19MQCHFA335
(U) One red rope contalning:LSJ & GSI Boat Log 2019

(U) Box containing Shredded paper
(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING; Apple iPod shuffle on watch band
(U) Silver Macbook Desktop with keyboard

(U) One cellophane containing:Photograph
(U) One cellophane containing:Employee contact list
(U) One red rope containing:Red Nikon Camera

(U) One box containing: Silver Desktop Mac with keyboard
(U) HP Laptop with chargerS/N: CND81368V5
(U) Toshiba Laptop with charger

(U) One red rope containing:Remodeling documents for Island
(U) One cellophane containing:Handwritten notes on LSJ notepad

(U) One flat FedEx box containing: Photos, Photo negatives, letter
(U) One red rope containing:lsland blueprints, island photos, and documents

(U) One red rope containing:photo album of girl & Epstein
(U) One red rope containing:letter, photo album of girls, photos of island

(U) One cellophane containing:Document with names
(U) One cellophane containing:Employee contact list
(U) Silver Mac Desktop

(U) One red rope containing: Notepads with notes - LSJ stationary with handwritten notes
(U) Silver Mac Desktop with mouse & keyboardS/N: C02NM1MOFY14

(U) Silver iPad Model A15675/N: DMPQL1RMG5Yin case
(U) CELLOPHANE containing Silver iPad Model A15675/N: DMPQL25NGSYPYin case

(U) RED ROPE containing Silver MacBook ProS/N: C02QMOGUGWDP
(U) Silver Mac Laptop labeled "JE BIG LAPTOP" "BLACK BAG" in black bag S/N: W89111772QT

(U) Mac Desktop labeled "Kitchen Mac" - grey
(U) One heat-sealed bag containing one yellow envelope marked "SK" dated 08/27/08 containing multiple smaller

(U) RED ROPE CONTAINING: 4 binders with 68 discs inside
(U) One heat-sealed bag containing one small white envelope with writing "2000-SK" containing $4,400 USC (44 x

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING; Austrian Passport with Epstein photograph
(U) RED ROPE CONTAINING: Two blue binders with 58 discs inside

(U) CELLOPHANE containing Black hard drive
(U) CELLOPHANE containing Black hard drive
(U) One (1) silver IPad with serial number DLXQGM3KGMW3.

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING :One (1) black iPhone with IMEI number 357201093322785.
(U) One box containing: 1 Apple Desktop computer

(U) 1 Silver IPAD - 64GB
(U) 1 Space Gray Apple IPAD
(U) 1 Space Gray Apple IPAD
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Black Radioshack recorder

(U) One cellophane containing 1 Silver Olympus recorder
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Sony BM-560 Recorder

(U) Box containing 45 Assorted Cd's
(U) One red rope containing 1 Sony Vaio Laptop
(U) 1 Dell Precision Tower 5810

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Barracuda 7200 harddrive 80GB
(U) 1 MSI PC Computer IN A BROWN BOX

(U) One red rope containing:1 Sony Camera with black case
(U) 1 Gray Apple Desktop Computer with keyboard and mouse

(U) One cellophane containing 1 Seagate Backup Plus Portable Drive - 1TB
(U) One cellophane containing one (1) White Apple (Phone 5, 64GB.

(U) 1 Apple Desktop Computer with keyboard and mouse
(U) 1 Apple Desktop Computer with keyboard and mouse

(U) One cellophane containing:1 SPIEF 2014 Silver USB
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Cruzer Guide 32GB USB

(U) One cellophane containing 1 Cruzer Guide 32GB USB
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Cruzer Guide 32GB USB

(U) One cellophane containing 1 Cruzer Guide 32GB USB
(U) One cellophane containing 1 Blue EMTEC 16 GB USB

(U) One cellophane containing 1 EMTEC 16 GB USB
(U) One red rope containing:10 assorted cd's
(U) One cellophane containing 3. Silicone Power Micro SD Adapter with 16GB SD Card

(U) 1 DELL Machine
(U) 1 Cube 9000 Siteserver, (BLACK/SILVER)
(U) 1 HP Compaq Machine
(U) One cellophane containing one (1) Mentor Media 32GB USB.

(U) One cellophane containing one (1) Data Traveler 4GB USB.
(U) One cellophane containing one (1) Data Traveler 4GB USB.

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives

(U) One red rope containing:1 Seagate Path/100 Hard Drives
(U) Silver Apple Desktop Computer with keyboard and mouse

(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: 1 stuffed dog
(U) Box containing 2-1 inch black binders containing CD's and 13 loose CD's

(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: 2 white in color busts of female torsos
(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: 1 brown bust sculpture of female breasts

(U) One red rope containing: 2 photos and 1 album page with additional 2 photos
(U) ONE BOX CONTAINING: 1 blue box containing various Cd's

(U) Red rope containing 12 polaroid photos, 1 folder labeled "Sue" containing various photos/cd's
(U) ONE BANKERS BOX CONTAINING: bundled photos and cd's from "Women Old Photos Box"

(U) 10 black binders containing photos, cd's etc.
(U) 1 blue in color bust of a female torso
(U) One red rope containing: 2 photos of female buttocks

(U) One box containing: 5 costumes and 1 wig
(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINI1 vibrator, 3 buttplugs, 1 set of cuffs, 1 dad°, 1 leash, i box of condoms, i nurse cap

(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING; (1) butt plug
(U) One box containing four (4) framed photos of naked females.

(U) ONE CELLOPHANE CONTAINING: 1 set of copper handcuffs and whip
(U) One (1) green massage table.
(U) One cellophane containing:3 sheets of paper- (1) photo depicting two girls, (2) cash disbursements

(U) One cellophane containing:3 pages- (1) handwritten note Epstein letterhead, (2) page typed letter
(U) One flat FedEx box containing: 3 photographs- (2) depicting Epstein with two females, (1) photo depicting by(

(U) One red rope containing: 3 sheets of paper depicting photographs of a living room
(U) One cellophane containing: 2-page handwritten letterSteven D. Small

(U) Box containing one (1) set of Blueprints for residence 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York Stamped receive

(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING: 1 Red Notebook
(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING: 10 Photographs
(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING: 17 Miscellaneous Financial Documents

(U) ONE RED ROPE CONTAINING: 1 Premier Day Planner
envelopes containing $17,115 UK (152 x $100, 35 x $50 4 x $20, 6 x $10, 5 x $5).
Evidence Report for Case: 1500-NY-3027571
Filtering on: Type(s): 1D
Item # Collected On
1D6 8/24/2020 7:00
IDS 8/3/2020 9:25
1D4 5/7/2020 7:00
1D3 4/18/2020 7:00
1D2 2/4/2020 7:00
1D1 8/20/2019 17:00
Description

(U) (NY-ERF#19236) Court Authorized Intercept Doc# 20-CRIM-1281832Facility : lu-Ray Disci/ 7446!
(U) 07/02/2020; One (1) original SD card and one (1) Blu Ray containing FLIR aerial surveillance footage of Bradfoi

(U) (NY-ERF#18399) Court Authorized Intercept-Doc#20-CRIM-2134OFacil Disc#690612-R1
(U) (NY-ERF# 18727) Court Authorized Intercept Doc#20-CRIM-81211Fad Blu-Ray Disc#694397
(U) (NY-ERF# 18309) Court Authorized Intercept Doc# 19-CRIM-29845156Facility *sc# 671455
(U) Recorded Interview (Non•Custodial - Overt) DTD 8/13/2019 wit Philadel • hia
5
d, NH on the aforementioned date.
Evidence Report for Case: 50D-NY-3027571
Filtering on: 1A
Type g Acquired On Serial g
1A 317 2025-03-10 706
1A ilfi 2025-03-10 225
1A al 2025-03-10 706
1A 314 2025-02-27 704
1A 313 2024-08-01 702
1A 312 2022-11-02 696
1A 311 2022-05-26 692
1A 310 2022-03-07 687
1A 309 2021-12-11 686
1A Eli 2021-11-24 Q14
1A Igi 2021-11-22 ila
1A 306 2021-11.23 677
1A 305 2021-11-05 674
1A 304 2021-10-19 672
1A 303 2021-11-02 671
1A 302 2021-10-11 670
lA 301 2021-10-14 669
1A 3Q2 2021-06-23 02
lA Z9.2 2021-10-08 01
lA 298 2021-10-08 665
1A 297 2021-10-08 665
lA 336 2021-10-08 §61
lA 295 2021-10-08 665
1A 294 2021-10-08 664
lA 293 2021-10-08 663
1A 292 2021-10-08 662
lA Z91. 2021-10-08 01
1A 290 2021-10-08 660
lA 289 2021-10-08 659
lA 221 2021-10-08 552
1A 287 2021-06-23 657
lA 286 2021-10-07 657
Lk 285 2021-10-07 656
lA 294 2021-09-02 653
Lk 214 2021-09-17 ga
lA 282 2021-05-18 651
1A 281 2021-09-20 650
lA 224 2021-09-20 552
1A Z7_2 2021-05-20 M./
1A 278 2021-09-27 6413
1A 277 2021-08-19 647
1A 276 2021-07-23 646
1A 275 2021-07-23 646
LA 274 2021-09-21 645
IA 273 2021-09-01 643
m M 2021-09-01 a
IA M 2021-06-02 442
1A 270 2021-06-02 642
lA 2.62 2021-04-27 al
1A M 2021-08-20 aQ
1A 267 2021-08-12 639
LA 266 2021-08-19 638
1A 265 2021-05-14 637
LA 264 2021-05-14 637
lA 263 2021-09-02 636
lA 262 2021-08-30 635
lA ai 2021-08-31 04
1A 102 2021-09-15 01
1A 259 2021-09-02 632
1A 258 2021-09-02 632
1A M 2021-09-02 632
1A 256 2021-09-08 632
1A 255 2021-07-27 631
1A 254 2021-08-11 630
lA 334 2021-09-14 412
lA M 2021-04-01 421
lA 251 2020-11-30 627
1A 250 2021-06-30 626
lA 242 2021-06-30 42k
lA 248 2021-08-04 624
LA 247 2021-06-28 623
lA 246 2021-06-23 623
LA 245 2021-06-23 623
lA 244 2021-03-23 M
1A 243 2021-07-06 616
lA 242 2021-07-14 615
1A 241 2021-07-14 41E
1A 240 2020-02-14 613
lA 239 2021-06-29 610
LA 238 2021-05-20 607
IA 237 2021-04-13 605
LA 231 2021-04-13 445
lA 235 2021-04-01 604
1A 234 2021-03-30 603
lA M 2021-05-17 W.2
1A M 2021-03-19 596
1A 231 2021-01-29 588
1A 230 2021-03-03 586
1A 229 2021-03-03 586
1A 228 2021-01-21 585
1A 227 2021-01-21 585
lA 226 2021-01-19 584
1A al 2021-02-24 512
IA 224 2021-02-11 522
1A 223 2021-02-08 581
lA 222 2020-10-14 514
1A 221 2020-10-15 551)
1A 220 2020-10-14 580
Lk 219 2021-01-27 579
1A 218 2021-02-01 578
Lk 217 2021-01-20 573
lA 216 2021-01-14 M
lA 215 2020-09-25 571
lA j4 2021-02-02 5Z4
1A 211 2021-01-12 55.2
1A 212 2020-10-28 568
1A 211 2021-01-27 567
1A 210 2020-02-07 566
1A 209 2020-10-07 566
Lk 208 2021-01-13 565
1A 207 2020-09-10 564
M 20 2020-10-09 511
m na 2021-01-19 55.4
lA 204 2020-10-15 556
1A 203 2020-11-04 555
1A zu 2020-10-29 54
1A 201 2020-08-13 552
Lk 200 2020-06-19 551
lA 199 2020-08-21 550
Lk 198 2020-08-22 549
lA 122 2020-08-21 54
1A 191 2020-10-09 522
1A 195 2020-08-17 546
1A 191 2020-10-09 5_41 IA al 2020-08-21 543
lA 192 2020-11-18 542
Lk 191 2020-08-24 541
lA 190 2020-10-21 535
lA 182 2020-10-22 1.1E
lA 188 2020-10-09 535
1A 187 2020-06-19 533
lA iik 2020-08-26 521
1A 111 2020-08-19 513
1A 184 2020-08-11 512
1A 183 2020-08-12 511
1A 182 2020-07-17 500
1A 181 2020-07-07 499
IA 180 2020-07-15 496
IA 179 2020-07-15 495
IA 01 2020-07-27 al
IA 177 2020-08-04 ga
1A 176 2020-07-28 478
1A iza 2020-07-28 AZ1
1A Ili 2020-07-28 171
1A M 2020-07-28 477
1A 172 2020-07-28 476
1A 171 2020-07-28 476
Lk 170 2020-07-27 475
1A 169 2020-07-21 469
1A 168 2020-07-14 468
1A ifiZ 2020-07-02 422
1A 10 2020-07-02 0/
1A 165 2020-07-08 450
1A 164 2020-07-13 449
1A .aa 2020-07-13 445
1A 162 2020-07-11 443
1A 161 2020-07-10 442
ia 160 2020-07-10 440
m 152 2020-07-10 02
IA 154 2020-06-19 0¢
IA 157 2020-07-06 433
1A 156 2020-06-25 428
1A 1 2020-07-07 422
1A 154 2020-07-02 412
1A 153 2019-07-17 405
1A 152 2019-10-25 404
Lk 151 2020-03-04 403
IA IN 2020-04-10 222
1A a2 2020-02-07 398
IA 148 2020-02-07 398
1A 142 2019-07-22 222
IA 146 2019-11-21 221
IA 145 2019-09-18 395
Lk 144 2019-10-23 394
IA 143 2019-10-23 393
Lk 142 2019-09-12 Ra
IA 141 2019.08-26 391
1A 140 2019-10-18 390
IA 122 2019-10-18 222
1A 121 2019-09-12 212
1A 137 2020-02-28 388
1A 136 2019-10-23 387
1A 135 2020-02-26 386
1A 134 2019-10-24 385
LA 133 2019-10-24 385
IA 132 2019-12-04 384
1A at 2019-11-26 iga
IA 1.12 2019-10-11 18/
1A 3.29 2020-02-05 380
1A 12 2019-11-04 222
1A 127 2020-02-05 221
1A 126 2020-02-27 377
LA 125 2019-08-13 376
1A 124 2019.08-13 376
1A 123 2020-02-05 375
1A 122 2020-01-14 M
1A 121 2019-09-10 373
1A ii& 2020-02-19 2Z2
1A 112 2020-01-16 212
1A 118 2019-12-17 366
1A 117 2019-07-26 365
1A 116 2019-07-26 311
1A lis 2019-12-15 359
1A 114 2019-12-15 359
lA 113 2019-12-15 359
1A 112 2020-01-17 35fi
IA M 2020-01-08 255
la 110 2019-08-28 354
1A 109 2019.09-18 353
lA 141 2019-10-23 252
IA 107 2019.09-09 351
LA 106 2019-11-01 350
lA 105 2019-09-18 349
LA 104 2019-08-09 241
lA 142 2019-08-12 342
1A 102 2019-08-12 3_
lA 101 2019.08-28 345
1A LW 2019-08-01 294
IA 99 2020-01-08
IA 98 2019-12-30 343
LA 97 2019-12-30 343
IA 96 2019-12-02 343
LA 25 2019-10-01 ma
lA 94 2019-10-15 340
1A 93 2019-12-17 339
LA 22 2019-12-17 221
1A a 2019.09-19 225
1A 90 2019-10-16 334
1A 89 2019-10-16 333
1A 88 2019-10-15 332
1A 87 2019-09-18 330
LA 86 2019-09-19 329
IA 85 2019-11-14 327
1A m 2019-09-28 la
LA 12 2019-07-31 3_U
1A 82 2019-07-12 324
1A Al 2019-11-13 222
1A a 2019.08-28 316
1A 79 2019.08-27 315
1A 78 2019-08-29 306
1A 77 2019.08-29 306
LA 76 2019-08-06 304
1A 75 2019.09-24 303
1A 74 2019-07-05 300
1A Z2 2019-08-27 22A
1A 3 2019-07-11 2E
1A 71 2019-07-12 296
1A 70 2019-08-13 294
1A 4.2 2019.09-16 289
1A 68 2019-07-12 286
1A 67 2019-09-05 285
1A 66 2019.09-05 283
1A c..a 2019.09-14 /$1.
1A 14 2019.08-13 M
1A 63 2019.08-24 272
1A 62 2019.08-28 271
1A 11 2019.08-27 222
1A 60 2019.08-13 269
1A 59 2019-08-12 268
1A 58 2019.08-12 268
1A 57 2019-08-12 268
lA a 2019-08-12 ag
1A 55 2019-08-12 268
lA 54 2019.08-11 268
1A 42 2019-08-20 214
IA 52 2019.08-13 261
IA 51 2019-08-28 258
LA 50 2019-08-27 257
IA 49 2019-08-07 252
LA 4O 2019-07-11 241
lA 47 2019.08-16 238
1A 46 2019-07-24 216
1A 41 2019-08-09 224
1A 44 2019-07-29 212
1A 43 2019-07-31 208
1A 42 2019-07-31 207
1A 41 2019.08-02 206
1A 40 2019-07-11 203
IA 39 2019-07-11 202
IA 38 2019-07-06 194
1A n 2019-07-17 1N
IA 33 2019-07-13 MA
1A 35 2019-07-13 187
1A 24 2019-07-14 IN
1A 22 2019-07-11 185
1A 32 2019-07-02 183
1A 31 2019-07-16 175
IA 30 2019-07-17 171
1A 29 2019-07-06 168
1A 22 2019-07-12 166
1A 27 2019-07-19 159
1A a 2019-07-17 155
1A 25 2019-07-17 2.51
1A 24 2019-07-11 151
1A 23 2019-07-06 150
1A 22 2019-07-07 149
1A 21 2019-07-12 127
1A 20 2019-07-11 116
ia 19 2019-05-29 106
m La 2019-07-06 5/
IA 17 2019-07-08 /2
IA 16 2019.06-24 30
1A 15 2019-05-29 26
1A 14 2019-05-08 251A 13 2019-05-23 24
1A 12 2019-05-02 21
1A 11 2019.04-24 20
1A 14 2019-04-26 19
IA 2 2019-04-11 17
1A 3 2019-03-22 16
lA 7 2019-03-22 14
1A 3 2019-03-20 13
1A 5 2019-03-19 12
IA 4 2019-03-25 11
IA 3 2019-03-19 10
IA 2 2019-03-04 8
IA 1 2019-01-30 5
Serial Title

(U) Transport of Evidence Items 16136, 16144, 16145, and 1B146
(U) Transport of Evidence Items 1B136, 16144, 16145, and 16146

(U) Transport of Evidence Items 16136, 16144, 16145, and 1B146
(U) Transfer of Case Documents from the New York Field Office to the Washington Field Office

(U) Interview o
(U//FOUO) Identification of as a possible associate of JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U) Mail Received from Epstein Residence

(U) Phone Interview wit
(U) Defense Notes fo
(U) Telephonic Interview o
(U) Telephonic interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Phone conversation wit
(U) Call wit
(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial

(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial
(U) Interview o
(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department

(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department
(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department
(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department
U//FOUO NTOC2021 E-Tip Additional Victim Reports Being Human Trafficked By Gislaine Maxwell M A Child (7
U NTOC2020 352mtr01 Information on a Possible Accountant of Jeffrey Epstein. (NY)
U//FOUO NTOC2020 024srm01 E-Tip: Possible Human Trafficking in New York, NY. (NY)
U USPS Mail Tipster - Information Related to Jeffrey Epstein/Unnamed 29 YOA Jewish Female
U NTOC2020 195hmb02 Potential Sex Trafficking by in New York, NY (NY)
U Email regarding information for sale about the Epstein Zorro Ranch
U//FOUO NTOC2021Conceming Comments NY)

(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial
(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial
(U) Fed-Ex Delivery Confirmation

(U) Interview o September 2, 2021
(U) Meeting wit
(U) Interview o
(U) interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) interview o
(U) Proffer o
(U) Proffer o
(U) Service of subpoena.
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview/Proffer o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Proffer o

(U) Proffer o
(U) Interview o
(U) Intervie
(U) Interview o fkugust 31, 2021
(U) Request to serve three trial subpoenas

(U) Interview o
September 1, 2021
September 1, 2021
August 30, 2021
July 27, 2021
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U nterview 8/4/2021
(U) Interview o
(U) Locate and Serve witness
(U) Missouri Birth Certificate Identified and obtained

(U) Missouri Birth Certificate Identified and obtained
(U) Device Extraction - MDUS 13768
(U//FOUO) Collection of evidence in Austin, Texas

(U) IA Lab Report Material: Lab # 2021-00585
(U) Interview o
(U) Introductory conversation wit
(U) 2021-00585-2 Questioned Documents

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o Day 3
(U) Interview o Day 3

(U) Interview o Day 1
(U) Interview o
(U) Virtual Interview o
(U) Telephonic Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Introductory Conversation wit
(U) Interview o Day 2
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Proffer o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) interview o
df
(U) Call received fro
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Victim Services Division - Case Support Unit Assistance
(U) Interview o
(U) Fund Reimbursement - Five 2TB Hard drives

(U) Fund Reimbursement - Five 2TB Hard drives
(U) Fund Reimbursement - Five 2TB Hard drives
(U) Fund Reimbursement - 12 TB External Hard Drive

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U//FOUO) Interview of
(U//FOUO) Interview of
(U) Date Submitted: 07/25/2020 10:08:31 AM ET Transaction Number: 4D291278-3SFF-489A-A26C

(U) On 07/21/2020, at 2:17 a.m. Eastern Time
(U//FOUO) Telephone Interview O
(U) Arrest of GHISLAINE MAXWELL

(U) Arrest of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U//FOUO) Impersonation of FBI Agent
(U//FOUO) Interview o
(U) On 07/12/2020, at 3:12:08 PM Eastern Time

(U) On 07/11/2020, at 10:02 a.m. Eastern lime, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol
(U) On 07/09/2020, at 9:47 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/10/2020, at 9:44 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP
(U) On 07/10/2020, at 9:22 a.m. Eastern lime, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP

(U) Fund Reimbursement
(U) On 07/06/2020, at 10:19 AM Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U//FOUO) Aerial photos of 301 Summer Street Manchester by the Sea, Massachusetts 01944.

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 12:33:51 PM Eastern Time, an anonymous complainant, Email account
(U//FOUO) Interview o

(U) Information provided b
(U) Interview o • n 10/25/19
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o n 11.21.19

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Proffer o nterview #2

(U) Proffer o nterview #1
(U) Interview o • n 10/11/2019
(U) Pass information to Swedish authorities for informational purposes.

(U) Interview o
(U) Share information with Swedish Authorities
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Proffer o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o 7/2019
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Phone conversation wit
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Phone call with Attornet
(U) Interview o
U nterview
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Epstein Brelfing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures

(U) Epstein Brelfing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Interview o
(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director

(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director
(U nterview
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o n 9/19/2019
(U) Interview o n 11/14/2019
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o • n 7/31/19
(U) Proffer o terview #1
(U) Victim Services Division - Victim Meeting
(U) Interview o
(U nterview

(U) Lead Forwared to Legat Mexico City, Mexico
(U) Lead Forwared to Legat Mexico City, Mexico
(U) Interview o

(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director
(U) Interview o
(U nterview
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Device Unlock and Extraction - MDUS 10398

(U) Device Unlock and Extraction - MDUS 10399
(U) On 09/14/2019, at 2:58 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) Interview o

(U) FBI New York - Jeffrey Epstein - Child Sex Trafficking
(U) Follow-Up Law Enforcement Inquiries Pertaining t.

(U) Interview 0
(U
(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James
(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James

(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James
(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James
(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James

(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James
(U//FOUO PROTECT SOURCE) Interview #3
(U) Phone Interview o
U WEXNER FOUNDATION - financial connection to JEFFREY EPSTEIN
U NTOC2019 1971(103 E-Tip: Information Regarding Multiple Criminal Allegations such as Human Sex Traffi
(U//FOUO PROTECT SOURCE) interview #2

(U) Inventory of Two Suite Cases (black/blue) for JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U) On 8/15/19, at 11:15 a.m. Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U//FOUO PROTECT SOURCE) Interview One

(U) On 08/08/2019, at 9:02 a.m. Eastern lime date of bin
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) interview o

(U) Return of Property t . on 08/02/2019
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o • n 07/11/2019
(U) Post Arrest Spontaneous Utterances made by Defendant JFFREY E. EPSTEIN

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Arrest of JEFFREY EPSTEIN

(U) Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Interview o
(U) Interivew o
(U) Interview o • n 07/15/2019
(U) Provide information to SEATTLE FO for conducting interview

(U) On 07/17/2019, at 3:43 p.m. Eastern Time, the FBI's Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) On 07/17/2019, at 3:51 p.m. Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)

(U) Search Warrant Executed- 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021
(U) Interivew o
(U) Attempted Interview of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U//FOUO) On 07/11/2019, at 10:56 p.m. Eastern Time, tipster email address zephyr_daleth@

(U) On 07/11/2019, at 2:31 a.m., Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) Interview o • n 5/29/2019

(U) Search Warrant Executed- 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021
(U//FOUO) On 07/08/2019, at 1:10 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, the Office of Public Affairs

(U) 31E-NY-3027571
(U) Interview o • n 5/29/2019
(U) Interview o • n 5/8/2019
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o • n 5/2/2019

(U) Interview o
(U//FOUO) TECS Silent Hit Notification
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
Summary
(U) Chains of Custody

(U) Ending Transport Photographs
(U) Starting Transport Photographs
(U) Photos and Photo Logs
(U) Agent Notes
(U//FOUO) Email from Neumann and attachments from Null

(U) letter from former Epstein Estate; fake NY State Driver's license
(U nterview notes
(U//fOUO) Defense notes fo
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes

(U) interview notes
(U) digital notes
(U) Digital notes, household manual
(U) Notes
(U em otes
(U) 794
(U) Receipt
(U nterview notes

(U) Property receipt
(U) Trash pull
(U) Digital case files
(U) Subpoena
U 755162_NY
U 696289_NY
U 708478_NY
U 664501_NY
U 658904_NY
U 603998_NY
U 751864_NY

(U) Receipt
(U) FD-794
(U) Fed-Ex Delivery Confirmation, #1864 0967 1500
(U) NB Interview notes - 9.2.21 & Scan shown to NB

(U) Notes
(U) notes & doncuments
(U) Emails fro
(U nterview notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Documents shown t.
(U nterview notes

(U) Drivers license information for each individual.
(U) News article shown t.
(U) Notes
(U) Documents shown t.
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes

(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U nterview notes
(U) Documents shown t.
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Trial Subpoenas

(U) photobook
(U) Nude photo o
(U) Items shown touring Interview
(U) Notes
(U nterview notes
(U) Notes
(U) notes

(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Messages pads
(U) notes
(U) Notes
(U) Transcript
(U) Epstein phone contact
(U) Notes

(U) Notes
(U) Trial Subpoena - Cynthia Hopkins
(U) Copy of FedEx shipment with tracking numbe
(U ertified Birth Certificate

(U) Legal Authority for Device
(U//FOUO) FD-597
(U) Lab # 2021-00585:1 disk
(U) Photo provided be
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U otes

(U) 2021-00585-2 QUESTIONED DOCUMENTS
(U nterview notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Photographs provided via email b

(U) Photo from Myspace account
(U) Interview notes day 3
(U) Interview notes day 1
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Emails
(U) Statement referenced in interview
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Notes
(U) Interview notes day 2
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U light log
(U) interview notes
(U nterview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Chabad's involvement in U.S. Presidential pardon petitions and influences from Russia and Israel on Pres

(U) notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U nterview notes

(U) Latest contact Information tracked and updated by ODAG partners.
(U) Interview notes
(U) 10.21 HD Receipt

(U) 10.22 HD Receipt
(U) 10.9 HD Receipt
(U) Receipt
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) interview notes
(U nterview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U//FOUO) Notes Re: Interview • on July 27, 2020.
(U//FOUO) City of Maricopa Police Department Officer Report for D.R.

(U) Subpoena
(U) Accurint
(U) Subpoena
(U) Accurint
(U) Subpeona
(U) Accurint
(U) (U//FOUO) THE INFORMATION CONTAINED HEREIN HAS BEEN DETERMINED BY THE FBI TO BE PERTINEN

(U) Screenshot of Reddit post by user r/maxwellhill
(U//FOUO) NYPD SVD Hotline Worksheet
(U) Photo
(U) Arrest warrant, arrest paperwork, notes
(U//FOUO) Document and audio recording from Bradford (NH) Police
(U//FOUO) Interview notes o

(U) Graphic Capture of Viral Video.
(U) screenshot of David McPhee's Quora page
(U) Screenshots of Epstein's alleged employee's confession on YouTube and 4chan

(U) Website www.kidsquest.com
(U) Screenshots from kidsquest.com
(U) Receipt
(U) Reported Tweets to NTOC
(U//FOUO) Aerial photos of 301 Summer Street Manchester by the Sea, Massachusetts 01944.

(U) Screen shot of lmgur capture of the comment made b
(U//FOUO) Notes from
(U) Photographs provided bt
(U nterview notes

(U) Interview notes & documents provided al
(U nterview notes
(U) Flight logs
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U_nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes

(U) Two boxes of papers and media from PBPD
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes & police report

(U) Interview notes
(U) Photo provided b nd her attorneys
(U) Interview notes
(U) SK interview notes
(U) interview notes
(U nterview notes
(U :02

(U) Interview Notes
(U 02
(U ntervlew notes
(U) Photo Book
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Ulf interview notes

(U) Interview notes and Message pad copies shown
(U nterview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Facebook Profile Screenshots
(U ntervlew notes
(U) Photos
(U) Emails
(U) Interview notes
(U  Hotel charges, approval to accept charge, and proof of refund.
(U •hone call notes
(U nterview notes
(U ntervlew notes

(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U .odging
(U odging
adging
aeimbursement

(U) Receipts of EVAF Expenditures for Epstein Victims
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Receipts
(U) Receipts
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U nterview notes
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes and photos provided la
(U) Interview notes
(U) RSVP/potential victim list, templates, reminders and overviews

(U) interview notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) VA DMV image o
(U) DMV Images o A an' IA. TLO reports concemin: n'

(U) Interview notes
(U) Receipts
(U rand Jury Subpoena
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) interview notes
(U

(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Administrative Documents
(U) Administrative Documents
(U) Screenshot of YouTube Video

(U) Interview notes
(U) Enclosed are the IC3 complaints
(U) Police Records from Cranston RI Police Department

(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview notes
(U) Receipt for Property (FD-597)
(U) Charlie and Delta Zone, with Bravo's Building 6, Search Paperwork

(U) Bravo Zone Search Paperwork
(U) Alpha Zone Search Paperwork
(U) Evidence Log, Sign-In Log, map, notes

(U) Search Warrant Little Saint James
(U//FOUO) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes
U 579223_CV
U 566318 PH
(U//FOUO) Interview Notes, images provided

(U) two (2) property receipts, one (1) inventory log, 1 (one) ERT photographic log and one CD with photograi

(U) Twitter screenshots of the links provided.
(U//FOUO) Interview Notes and photograph of "Jeff"
(U) Douglas Metzger NCIC

(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) Notes
(U) (1) DVD of photos, (2) original signed receipt for property forms FD-597, (1) business card

(U) ori inal handwritten notes o nterview on 07/11/2019
(U) copy of Handwritten contact information fo his attorney and property

(U) Photocopy of working folder pertaining to arrest paperwork of JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Epstein arrest warrant

(U) Arrest paperwork, search warrant, photographs disc
(U//FOUO) Interview Note /17/2019
(U orida Identification

(U) Original Handwritten Interview Notes o '7/12/2019
(U) TLO report and WASHINGTON STATE DL image of potential victim to be interviewed.

(U) Twitter screenshots - Jamocan
(U) Twitter Post.
(U) Search warrant execution log, FBI Sign in log, Evidence Collected item log, copy of search warrant, (1) FD
(U dotes

(U) Documents from UPS
(U) Attachments from tipster.
(U) twitter screenshot
(U nterview notes
(U) original search logs, copy of search warrant 1) signed FD-597, (1) DVD disk of Search photos
(U//FOLIO) Twitter Username

(U) Fed-EX signature confirms ion page.
(U nterview notes 5.29.19
(U) Interview notes 5/8/19
(U) Interview notes

(U) Interview notes 5.2.19, Photos 1 through 19 and A through F
(U nterview Notes
(U//FOUO) TEES silent hit entered
(U nterview notes
(U interview notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview Notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes

(U) Interview notes
(U) Interview notes
p 2021-00585-2 IA.4 CASE COMMUNICATION LOG: Con

╭───── Page 39, Image 1 ──────╮
│ eesanneeeseee©*7071-00585-2 │
│                             │
│ 1A.zip CASE COMMUNI         │
│                             │
│ IICATION LO‘                │
│                             │
│ Cor                         │
╰─────────────────────────────╯

1TO & WITHIN THE SCOPE OF AN AUTHORIZED LAW ENFORCEMENT ACTIVITY & SHOULD BE CONSIDERI
tmunicadonLog2021-00585.pdf CASE NOTE INTERFACE REPORT: CNI Questioned Documents (AF)
,ED IN THE CONTEXT OF THE ASSESSMENT OR PREDICATED INVESTIGATION TO WHICH THE INFORMATI0
ase Note (143683).p CASE FILES: 2021-00585 #1, Lead 17.pdf 2021-00585 Shipping Invoice C
N RELATES. PARTICULAR ATTENTION SHOULD BE GIVEN TO THE AUTHORIZED PURPOSE FOR COLLECTIN
ntainer C.pdf 2021-00585 #1 LER, Seria 575.pdf 2021-00585 Shipping Invoice Container B.p
5 & RECORDING THIS INFORMATION PURSUANT TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S GUIDELINES FOR DOME
if 2021-00585 Al Check-In Notes.rtf CASE CHAIN OF CUSTODY: Chain0Kustody2021-005854
'TIC FBI OPERATIONS & THE DOMESTIC INVESTIGATION & OPERATIONS GUIDE. THAT PURPOSE MAY BE

╭──── Page 71, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

df CASE RECORD REPORT: CaseReport2021-00585 Record #2.pdf CASE COMMUNICATION LOG FIL
SET FORTH IN THE FILE'S OPENING ELECTRONIC COMMUNICATION OR OTHER RELATED DOCUMENTS.
S: 2021-00585_UNCLASS.pdf CASE REPORT: CaseReport2021-00S8S.pdf CASE RECORD FILES
2021-00585 Item 3 Matchmaker Images.pdf
Evidence Report for Case: SOD-NY-3027571
Filtering on: 1C
Type b Acquired O Serial #
2 2019-08-11 274
1 2019.08-11 274
Serial Title
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Little Saint James Island
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Little Saint James Island
Summary

(U) - One (1) CD of WORKING COPY of RAW scan data for "Main Structure"
- One (1) CD of WORKING COPY of RAW scan data for "Grotto"
- One (1) CD of Scene2Go products for both "Main Structure" and "Grotto"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for "Main Structure"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for "Grotto"
- Copy of each sketch showing locations of scans
(U) ORIGINAL FARO LASER SCAN DATA and Notes
- Two (2) CDs of ORIGINAL RAW scan data for "Main Structure"
- Two (2) CDs of ORIGINAL RAW scan data for "Grotto"
- One (1) CD of Scene2Go products for both "Main Structure" and "Grotto"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for "Main Structure"
- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for "Grotto"
- Copy of each Error Report for both area projects
- Copy of each sketch showing locations of scans
Serial Rem] 50D-NY-3027571
Serial * Date
LQ¢ 3/12/2025 10:37
705 3/5/2025 13:34
ja 2/28/2025 18:10
Ma 2/27/2025 14:55
702 8/13/2024 16:54
701 9/26/2023 15:29
700 8/28/2023 17:54
699 6/17/2023 7:41
698 6/8/2023 8:38
697 5/28/2023 14:52
On 11/4/2022 12:02
¢91 7/27/2022 15:10
694 7/22/2022 12:10
693 6/30/2022 19:53
692 6/3/2022 12:05
691 5/26/2022 9:36
690 5/25/2022 15:44
689 5/25/2022 15:44
¢1% 5/24/2022 21:40
§3/ 3/15/2022 9:06
686 2/11/2022 12:16
685 1/31/2022 13:20
§1U 1/20/202214:13
683 1/18/2022 16:26
682 12/15/2021 9:33
681 12/14/2021 14:29
680 12/14/2021 10:30
§12 12/6/2021 11:09
01 12/2/2021 12:13
677 11/29/2021 11:13
§1¢ 11/16/2021 16:13
E71 11/16/2021 13:09
674 11/15/2021 11:22
673 11/14/2021 16:56
672 11/11/2021 9:31
El 11/8/2021 12:33
670 10/26/2021 9:42
669 10/25/2021 7:35
gl 10/21/2021 15:23
§§/ 10/18/2021 13:07
666 10/15/2021 9:43
665 10/15/2021 9:40
664 10/8/2021 17:15
663 10/8/2021 17:11
662 10/8/2021 17:09
661 10/8/2021 17:07
§E2 10/8/2021 17:05
§.52 10/8/2021 17:03
658 10/8/2021 16:59
01 10/8/202112:44
656 10/7/2021 18:27
655 10/7/2021 12:51
654 10/6/2021 14:02
653 9/30/2021 18:44
652 9/30/2021 18:44
651 9/30/2021 13:20
650 9/30/2021 13:19
42 9/30/2021 13:19
M 9/30/2021 13:19
647 9/29/2021 10:14
646 9/24/2021 14:52
645 9/23/2021 13:41
644 9/23/2021 10:44
643 9/17/2021 12:55
642 9/17/2021 12:54
01 9/17/2021 12:54
fa 9/17/2021 10:57
639 9/17/2021 10:57
638 9/17/2021 10:56
13Z 9/17/2021 10:54
636 9/16/2021 16:21
635 9/16/2021 16:21
634 9/16/2021 16:21
633 9/16/2021 16:21
§3/ 9/16/2021 10:53
631 9/16/2021 10:53
630 9/16/2021 10:53
§22 9/15/2021 11:30
628 9/14/2021 17:04
627 9/14/2021 17:03
626 9/14/2021 17:03
625 9/9/2021 11:16
ka 8/9/2021 14:46
623 8/9/2021 14:04
622 8/9/2021 14:04
fial 8/9/2021 13:08
620 8/9/2021 11:47
619 8/2/2021 11:15
618 7/29/2021 17:57
617 7/26/2021 12:09
616 7/21/2021 17:06
615 7/19/2021 12:21
614 7/13/2021 9:22
al 7/12/2021 12:46
ll  7/6/2021 11:30
611 7/2/2021 13:19
ila 7/1/2021 11:45
609 6/21/2021 17:46
608 6/11/2021 14:45
607 5/24/2021 12:50
606 5/19/2021 16:38
C05. 5/19/2021 16:28
604 5/19/2021 16:27
603 5/19/2021 16:12
02 5/17/2021 14:12
10.1 5/17/2021 10:37
600 5/11/2021 12:27
599 5/11/20215:21
598 5/7/2021 15:30
597 5/3/2021 16:47
596 4/27/2021 12:07
595 4/23/2021 13:26
la 4/7/2021 9:37
al 4/5/2021 10:19
592 3/31/2021 12:04
591 3/29/2021 20:03
5%2 3/22/202121:08
SN 3/22/2021 12:04
588 3/8/2021 14:18
587 3/8/202113:32
586 3/8/2021 11:09
5.41 3/4/2021 12:59
5M. 3/3/2021 10:35
583 3/2/202110:37
5.12. 2/26/2021 11:14
an 2/26/2021 11:13
580 2/24/2021 15:21
579 2/24/2021 14:48
578 2/23/2021 20:21
fl 2/23/2021 17:06
576 2/23/2021 14:00
575 2/23/2021 13:59
514 2/23/2021 13:58
511 2/23/2021 12:47
572 2/9/2021 9:46
571 2/9/2021 9:46
570 2/9/2021 9:46
569 2/9/2021 9:42
568 2/9/2021 9:40
567 2/9/2021 8:59
50 2/9/2021 8:58
Ma 2/5/2021 14:56
564 2/3/2021 10:28
if22 2/3/2021 10:28
562 1/28/20216:49
561 1/27/2021 17:16
560 1/27/2021 15:44
559 1/25/2021 15:32
558 1/19/2021 15:24
557 1/14/20219:25
556 1/13/2021 12:28
551 1/13/2021 10:35
54 1/13/2021 10:33
553 1/13/2021 10:28
552 1/12/2021 14:04
551 1/12/2021 13:59
550 1/4/2021 13:14
549 1/4/202113:11
548 1/4/2021 12:43
12/29/2020 13:13
AE 12/9/2020 11:49
545 12/8/2020 16:39
544 12/6/2020 10:08
al 12/2/2020 10:23
542 11/24/2020 12:21
541 11/10/2020 17:15
540 11/10/2020 7:47
539 11/9/2020 12:31
531 11/4/2020 18:58
531 11/2/2020 8:49
536 10/27/2020 17:03
10/27/2020 12:16
534 10/27/2020 10:36
533 10/23/2020 13:53
532 10/19/2020 18:28
531 10/19/2020 15:03
53.Q 10/19/2020 12:52
529 10/13/2020 16:30
528 10/9/2020 20:06
Z 10/7/2020 18:24
526 10/6/2020 5:20
525 10/1/2020 13:50
524 9/30/2020 12:30
523 9/24/2020 15:48
522 9/24/2020 15:48
521 9/24/2020 15:48
520 9/24/2020 15:48
la 9/24/2020 15:47
NI 9/24/202015:47
517 9/18/2020 13:14
51¢ 9/14/2020 13:52
515 9/8/2020 23:10
S14 9/4/202016:04
513 8/27/2020 11:56
512 8/27/2020 11:55
511 8/27/2020 11:53
510 8/25/2020 18:34
509 8/24/2020 17:59
59.1 8/24/2020 17:14
0/ 8/24/2020 14:08
506 8/20/2020 11:37
505 8/18/2020 15:56
504 8/17/2020 16:21
503 8/15/2020 8:08
502 8/14/2020 18:03
501 8/11/2020 17:54
5182 8/11/2020 15:12
4 8/11/2020 15:10
498 8/11/2020 9:48
497 8/11/2020 0:13
12¢ 8/7/2020 11:56
495 8/7/2020 11:55
494 8/7/2020 10:30
493 8/7/2020 9:02
492 8/6/2020 15:29
191 8/6/2020 11:07
490 8/6/2020 7:47
489 8/5/2020 19:23
AM 8/5/2020 12:55
487 8/4/2020 14:50
486 8/3/2020 18:25
485 8/3/202013:14
484 8/3/2020 9:36
gl 7/30/2020 19:56
482 7/30/2020 15:25
481 7/30/2020 14:54
4Q 7/30/202012:22
412 7/29/2020 20:34
476 7/28/2020 15:47
477 7/28/2020 15:47
476 7/28/2020 15:47
475 7/27/2020 8:10
474 7/26/2020 19:13
473 7/22/2020 18:31
472 7/22/2020 11:45
471 7/22/2020 11:23
470 7/22/2020 9:23
AU 7/22/2020 8:48
40 7/21/2020 15:42
467 7/21/2020 15:41
466 7/20/2020 11:21
465 7/19/2020 4:02
464 7/19/2020 3:57
463 7/18/2020 1:36
462 7/17/2020 19:21
442 7/17/2020 16:46
4Q 7/17/2020 16:12
459 7/17/2020 12:58
458 7/17/2020 1:56
457 7/16/2020 11:26
456 7/15/2020 23:00
455 7/15/2020 14:57
454 7/15/2020 14:26
15.1 7/15/2020 13:42
152 7/14/2020 14:07
451 7/14/2020 14:06
450 7/14/2020 13:39
M2 7/14/2020 13:36
448 7/13/2020 15:45
447 7/13/2020 15:43
446 7/13/2020 10:52
445 7/13/2020 10:19
444 7/12/2020 12:09
..kil 7/11/2020 11:08
442 7/11/2020 0:10
441 7/10/2020 19:05
440 7/10/2020 13:34
439 7/10/2020 13:06
438 7/9/2020 22:47
437 7/9/2020 21:32
426 7/9/202015:09
435 7/9/202015:08
434 7/9/2020 13:01
432 7/9/202013:00
432 7/9/2020 11:12
431 7/9/2020 2:28
430 7/8/202018:00
429 7/8/2020 15:21
428 7/8/202013:09
427 7/8/2020 13:01
426 7/7/2020 18:14
1.ZI 7/7/2020 17:56
424 7/7/2020 17:48
423 7/7/2020 14:37
422 7/7/2020 13:33
421 7/7/2020 11:50
420 7/7/2020 11:36
419 7/6/2020 12:51
418 7/3/2020 20:07
417 7/3/2020 18:48
416 7/3/2020 18:12
415 7/2/2020 19:18
414 7/2/2020 17:11
ill 7/2/2020 16:07
412 7/2/2020 12:44
410 6/19/2020 7:19
409 6/18/2020 10:42
408 6/15/2020 17:44
406 5/21/2020 18:59
405 5/20/2020 13:12
le 5/14/2020 12:54
NI 5/14/2020 12:54
402 5/14/2020 11:32
401 5/7/2020 11:20
02 5/6/2020 11:28
399 4/23/2020 15:43
398 4/23/2020 15:42
397 4/23/2020 14:07
396 4/23/2020 14:05
121 4/23/202014:05
am 4/23/2020 14:04
393 4/23/2020 14:03
19.2. 4/23/2020 14:03
391 4/23/2020 13:59
390 4/23/2020 13:58
389 4/23/2020 13:57
388 4/23/2020 13:56
KZ 4/23/2020 13:56
386 4/23/2020 13:55
385 4/23/2020 13:54
le 4/23/2020 13:53
313. 4/23/2020 13:52
382 4/23/2020 13:49
381 4/18/2020 11:02
380 4/15/2020 8:10
379 4/9/2020 14:34
378 4/7/202010:53
377 3/31/2020 10:35
VA 3/31/2020 10:21
321 3/31/2020 10:20
374 3/31/2020 10:09
222 3/31/2020 10:08
3.22 3/26/2020 13:52
371 3/26/2020 13:50
370 3/19/2020 12:47
369 3/16/2020 17:07
368 2/27/2020 9:17
367 2/19/2020 12:44
366 2/13/2020 17:28
3121 2/13/2020 17:16
3..4 2/6/202010:41
363 2/4/2020 12:21
362 2/3/202010:29
361 1/31/2020 15:50
360 1/24/2020 15:38
359 1/24/2020 9:36
358 1/23/2020 18:45
5/ 1/23/2020 2:08
¢ 1/22/2020 16:58
355 1/21/2020 10:37
354 1/17/2020 14:17
152 1/17/2020 14:13
352 1/15/2020 10:17
351 1/15/2020 10:13
350 1/14/2020 14:30
349 1/14/2020 14:17
ig 1/14/2020 14:03
MZ 1/10/2020 15:29
346 1/10/2020 15:28
3A1 1/10/2020 15:28
344 1/10/2020 15:27
343 1/8/2020 17:43
342 1/6/2020 17:47
341 1/2/2020 9:42
Iv 1/2/2020 7:12
339 12/18/2019 17:32
338 12/18/2019 17:32
231 12/13/2019 14:06
¢ 12/13/2019 12:18
335 12/13/2019 10:28
334 12/13/2019 10:28
333 12/11/2019 5:53
332 12/11/2019 5:52
331 12/10/2019 18:11
330 12/4/2019 11:19
la 12/4/2019 10:36
121 12/4/2019 5:21
327 11/26/2019 12:10
32¢ 11/26/2019 12:08
325 11/26/2019 12:05
324 11/26/2019 12:03
323 11/23/2019 22:07
322 11/19/2019 15:27
321 11/14/2019 11:52
320 11/13/2019 21:00
319 11/13/2019 12:30
ilk 11/10/2019 16:20
31/ 10/24/2019 17:48
316 10/23/2019 15:53
315 10/23/2019 15:46
314 10/23/2019 13:55
313 10/23/2019 9:40
312 10/22/2019 20:39
311 10/22/2019 17:37
31Q 10/21/2019 7:04
Q2 10/18/2019 16:22
308 10/18/2019 13:41
307 10/12/2019 18:23
3.Q¢ 10/9/2019 11:20
305 10/8/2019 21:13
304 10/3/2019 16:39
303 10/3/2019 15:04
302 10/2/2019 13:53
Q1 10/1/2019 16:40
300 9/27/2019 16:31
299 9/27/2019 16:31
221 9/26/2019 8:59
122 9/26/2019 8:59
296 9/26/2019 8:58
295 9/25/2019 17:00
294 9/25/2019 15:23
221 9/24/2019 10:49
292 9/19/2019 14:28
291 9/19/2019 14:28
2Z2 9/19/2019 10:05
182 9/17/2019 17:33
288 9/17/2019 15:43
287 9/17/2019 13:39
286 9/17/2019 10:47
285 9/16/2019 14:46
284 9/16/2019 13:13
283 9/16/2019 10:42
822 9/14/2019 19:24
a$1. 9/14/2019 17:01
280 9/12/2019 21:31
222 9/12/2019 11:04
VI 9/11/2019 14:42
277 9/10/2019 20:08
276 9/10/2019 17:23
275 9/10/2019 16:47
274 9/9/2019 11:16
273 9/6/2019 12:41
272 9/6/2019 9:34
ZU 9/4/2019 17:36
ZZQ 9/4/2019 17:35
269 9/4/2019 17:32
268 9/4/2019 17:31
267 9/4/2019 17:30
266 9/3/2019 7:35
265 8/30/2019 17:29
264 8/30/2019 16:46
MI 8/30/2019 10:10
/62 8/30/2019 5:12
261 8/29/2019 15:13
260 8/29/2019 8:22
2.52 8/28/2019 10:58
258 8/28/2019 7:29
257 8/27/2019 10:24
256 8/25/2019 10:10
255 8/23/2019 17:22
524 8/23/2019 7:44
253 8/23/2019 7:41
252 8/22/2019 20:10
251 8/22/2019 11:52
250 8/22/2019 11:16
249 8/22/2019 10:50
248 8/21/2019 12:09
247 8/21/2019 10:36
341 8/20/2019 13:25
245 8/20/2019 13:03
244 8/20/2019 13:01
2.11 8/20/2019 13:00
242 8/20/2019 12:29
241 8/17/2019 22:12
240 8/17/2019 20:04
239 8/16/2019 19:45
238 8/16/2019 12:45
237 8/16/2019 11:45
236 8/16/2019 8:41
2.41 8/15/2019 18:28
IM 8/15/2019 16:58
233 8/15/2019 13:01
232 8/15/2019 12:25
231 8/15/2019 12:05
230 8/15/2019 8:33
229 8/15/2019 7:59
228 8/14/2019 17:53
227 8/14/2019 10:34
226 8/14/2019 8:43
225 8/14/2019 8:20
224 8/13/2019 21:54
221 8/13/2019 17:09
222 8/13/2019 15:57
221 8/12/2019 22:23
220 8/11/2019 22:57
219 8/11/2019 14:32
218 8/11/2019 9:21
217 8/10/2019 15:36
a.6 8/9/2019 19:42
al 8/9/2019 11:11
214 8/9/2019 11:07

213. 8/8/2019 17:44
2.12 8/8/2019 16:09
211 8/8/2019 9:32
210 8/8/2019 8:42
209 8/7/2019 16:54
208 8/7/2019 15:37
Di 8/7/2019 15:36
206 8/7/2019 15:35
205 8/7/2019 15:35
la 8/7/2019 15:09
203 8/7/2019 13:26
202 8/7/2019 13:26
201 8/7/2019 0:47
200 8/6/2019 19:16
122 8/2/2019 15:24
198 8/2/2019 13:11
197 8/2/2019 10:22
344 8/1/2019 9:05
195 7/31/2019 16:43
194 7/31/2019 14:53
193 7/31/2019 14:49
192 7/31/2019 14:49
191 7/31/2019 14:48
190 7/31/2019 14:48
189 7/31/2019 4:13
UM 7/30/2019 18:01
1.81 7/30/2019 18:00
186 7/30/2019 17:59

215. 7/30/2019 17:59
184 7/30/2019 15:26
183 7/29/2019 13:22
182 7/29/2019 9:38
181 7/28/2019 15:12
al  7/27/2019 4:39
179 7/26/2019 19:52
178 7/26/2019 9:43
222 7/25/2019 18:09
ILE 7/25/2019 15:29
175 7/24/2019 12:02
174 7/24/2019 3:09
173 7/23/2019 18:13
172 7/23/2019 17:28
171 7/23/2019 17:26
170 7/23/2019 17:20
le 7/23/2019 17:19
al 7/23/2019 17:18
167 7/23/2019 17:18
166 7/23/2019 17:17
1¢2 7/23/2019 17:09
164 7/23/2019 12:25
163 7/22/2019 10:08
162 7/21/2019 10:37
161 7/20/2019 3:21
1.C2 7/19/2019 20:46
159 7/19/2019 14:59
158 7/19/2019 14:07
15Z 7/18/2019 16:46
156 7/18/2019 8:37
155 7/17/2019 17:03
154 7/17/2019 16:50
153 7/17/2019 16:42
152 7/17/2019 16:36
151 7/17/2019 12:23
150 7/17/2019 12:03
142 7/17/2019 12:01
148 7/17/2019 8:33
147 7/16/2019 14:44
146 7/16/2019 14:36
145 7/16/2019 14:35
144 7/16/2019 13:59
143 7/15/2019 22:25
142 7/15/2019 17:52
141 7/15/2019 15:59
14Q 7/15/2019 12:02
139 7/15/2019 11:53
DI 7/15/2019 11:06
137 7/15/2019 8:53
136 7/15/2019 3:15
135 7/15/2019 1:07
134 7/14/2019 18:03
133 7/13/2019 20:25
132 7/13/2019 18:05
131 7/13/2019 15:26
13Q 7/13/2019 15:04
119 7/13/2019 11:24
128 7/12/2019 22:55
127 7/12/2019 20:31
126 7/12/2019 19:44
125 7/12/2019 19:44
124 7/12/2019 18:58
123 7/12/2019 15:11
122 7/12/2019 13:40
al, 7/12/2019 13:27
120 7/12/2019 12:48
119 7/12/2019 12:37
118 7/12/2019 11:38
117 7/12/2019 9:46
116 7/12/2019 7:13
115 7/11/2019 22:51
114 7/11/2019 19:59
a. 1 7/11/2019 16:07
112 7/11/2019 12:32
111 7/11/2019 12:12
11Q 7/11/2019 11:09
109 7/11/2019 10:34
108 7/10/2019 23:43
107 7/10/2019 17:06
106 7/10/2019 17:05
1Qa 7/10/2019 17:05
104 7/10/2019 15:48
103 7/10/2019 15:42
12 7/10/2019 15:03
1Q1 7/10/2019 14:42
100 7/10/2019 12:10
99 7/10/2019 12:05
98 7/10/2019 10:39
97 7/10/2019 10:22
96 7/10/2019 9:46
95 7/10/2019 6:25
a 7/10/2019 0:26
22 7/9/2019 22:27
92 7/9/2019 20:49
21 7/9/2019 19:33
2Q 7/9/2019 19:10
89 7/9/2019 17:40
88 7/9/2019 17:35
87 7/9/2019 17:23
86 7/9/2019 16:44
85 7/9/2019 16:42
84 7/9/2019 16:36
82 7/9/2019 16:30
82 7/9/2019 16:17
81 7/9/2019 16:12
80 7/9/2019 15:10
22 7/9/2019 13:28
78 7/9/2019 12:43
77 7/9/2019 11:32
76 7/9/2019 10:58
22 7/9/2019 7:51
22 7/8/2019 23:09
73 7/8/2019 22:30
72 7/8/2019 22:10
21 7/8/2019 21:44
70 7/8/2019 21:01
69 7/8/2019 20:43
68 7/8/2019 20:24
67 7/8/2019 20:12
22 7/8/2019 19:41
65 7/8/2019 19:37
64 7/8/2019 19:25
82 7/8/2019 18:53
62 7/8/2019 18:24
61 7/8/2019 18:23
60 7/8/2019 17:52
59 7/8/2019 17:47
M 7/8/2019 17:11
57 7/8/2019 16:28
56 7/8/2019 16:14
a 7/8/2019 16:00
a 7/8/2019 15:57
53 7/8/2019 15:50
52 7/8/2019 15:37
51 7/8/2019 15:10
50 7/8/2019 14:28
49 7/8/2019 14:27
48 7/8/2019 14:19
47 7/8/2019 14:09
lk 7/8/2019 13:58
45 7/8/2019 13:53
44 7/8/2019 13:51
41 7/8/2019 13:43
42 7/8/2019 13:36
41 7/8/2019 13:17
40 7/8/2019 13:05
39 7/8/2019 12:39
38 7/8/2019 12:38
37 7/8/2019 12:30
al 7/8/2019 12:26
24 7/8/2019 12:18
34 7/8/2019 12:17
33 7/8/2019 12:12
32 7/8/2019 12:05
31 7/8/2019 12:02
30 7/8/2019 9:21
29 7/7/2019 20:22
a 7/7/2019 6:44
22 7/1/2019 11:30
26 7/1/2019 10:58
25 7/1/2019 10:12
24 6/24/2019 14:25
23 6/4/2019 11:06
22 5/28/2019 12:47
21 5/22/2019 15:57
20 5/6/2019 16:59
12 5/6/2019 16:59
18 4/30/2019 13:57
17 4/23/2019 11:20
j& 4/17/2019 14:49
15 4/5/2019 13:17
14 4/4/2019 10:57
13 4/4/2019 10:51
12 3/27/2019 16:52
11 3/27/2019 16:51
10 3/27/2019 16:50
9 3/15/2019 11:18
I 3/8/2019 17:47
Z 3/6/2019 13:50
6 2/14/2019 18:46
5 2/12/2019 11:41
4 1/31/2019 12:08
3 1/31/2019 10:46
2
1
1/15/2019 9:11
12/6/2018 18:33
Title

(U) Transport of Evidence Items
(U) Rule 6(e) Letters
(U) Transfer of Case Documents from the New York Field Office to the Washington Field Office

(U) Valuables C
(U) Interview o
(U) On 09/26/2 stern lime, Leran Elbaz, called the FBI National Threat
U Potential witness tampering/retaliation and interstate threats o
(U//FOUO) On 06/16/2023, at 3:39 p.m. Eastern Time t, date of bid

(U) Correspondence to Director Wray fro i
(U) On 05/18/2023, at 10:26 a.m. Eastern Time George Ton Ton ), date of birth
(U//FOUO) Identification of as a possible associate of JEFFREY EPSTEIN

(U) Sentencing of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U) Derivative evidence created
(U) On 06/30/2022, at 6:33 PM Eastern Time

(U) Mail Received from Epstein Residence
(U) FD1004
(U) Derivative evidence created
(U) Derivative evidence created

(U) On 05/24/2022, at 8:21 p.m. Eastern lime, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), with
(U) Phone Interview wit

(U) Defense Notes fo
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records for Jeffrey Epstein
df

(U) Conviction of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Request to obtain information regarding UK solicito

(U) Request to obtain information regarding UK citizen
(U) Telephonic Interview o
(U) Telephonic interview o

(U) Request NY ECU to transfer evidence to Denver FO
(U) Interview o
(U) On 11/16/2021, at 1:52 p.m. Eastern Time PROTECT IDENTITY],

(U) On 11/16/2021, at 11:35 a.m. Eastern Time • ate of birth
(U) Interview o
(U) On 11/14/2021, at 4:24 p.m. Eastern Time NU [PROTECT IDENTITY), cellular

(U) Interview o
(U) Phone conversation witl
(U) Call witl
(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial

(U) Interview o
U//FOUO Accusations of Rape and human trafficking
(U) Collect evidence
(U) Materials from Palm Beach Police Department
U//FOUO NTOC2021 E-Tip Additional Victim Reports Being Human Trafficked By Gislaine Maxwell As A Child C
U NTOC2020 352mtr01 Information on a Possible Accountant of Jeffrey Epstein. (NY)
U//FOUO NTOC2020 024srm01 E-Tip: Possible Human Trafficking in New York, NY. (NY)
U USPS Mail Tipster - Information Related to Jeffrey Epstein/Unnamed 29 YOA Jewish Female
U NTOC2020 19Shmb02 Potential Sex Trafficking by Greg Horvath and Jana Jaffe in New York, NY (NY)
U Email regarding information for sale about the Epstein Zorro Ranch
U//FOUO NTOC2021Conceming Comments bt NY)

(U) Reimbursement of expenses incurred for trial
(U) Fed-Ex Delivery Confirmation
U Victim of Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Request Transfer of Evidence Item 16139 to FBI NY ECR
(U) Interview o September 2, 2021
(U) Meeting witl

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Proffer o
(U) Service of subpoena.

(U) On 9/23/2021, at 9:58 AM Eastern Time
(U) Interview o September 1, 2021
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview/Proffer o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Proffer o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o August 30, 2021

(U) Interview o August 31, 2021
(U) Request to serve three trial subpoenas
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o July 27, 2021

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) On 9/9/2021, at 10:51 AM Eastern Time
(U terview 8/4/2021

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) On 08/09/2021, at 12:09 p.m. Eastern lime
(U) Documentation of Services 1)1a/01/2021-06/30/2021

(U) TRIAL SUBPOENA SERVED ON RI OFFICE OF VITAL RECORDS
(U) Trial Subpoena Served o . n 07/28/2021
(U) On 7/26/2021, at 11:16 AM Eastern Time mall accou

(U) Locate and Serve witness
(U) Missouri Birth Certificate Identified and obtained
(U) On 07/13/2021, at 8:36 AM Eastern Time home

(U) Device Extraction - MDUS 13768
(U) Request for Birth Certificate
(U) Collection of Evidence, Austin, TX
(U//FOUO) Collection of evidence in Austin, Texas

(U) On 06/21/2021 at 04:07 p.m cellular
(U) On 6/10/2021, at 10:07 AM Eastern Time
(U) 1A Lab Report Material: Lab 8 2021-00585
U Implied Threats Via Communication

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Introductory conversation wit
(U) 2021-00585-2 Questioned Documents
(U) Interview ofludg= Maryland

(U) Request assistance to pick up evidence from victim/witness
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Request to obtain inbound and outbound travel records from the UK

(U) Request to obtain inbound and outbound travel records from the UK
(U) Documentation of Services b 01/01/2021-03/31/2021

(U) Interview o
U NTOC2020 288hmb01 Alleged Money Laundering by Howard Lutnick via BGC Financial and Cantor Fitzgerak
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Request to obtain inbound and outbound travel records from the UK
(U '2.16.2021

(U) Request to obtain inbound and outbound travel records from the UK
(U) On 03/29/2021, at 7:21 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 3/22/2021, at 7:51 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 03/22/2021, at 10:43 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) Interview o

(U) On 03/08/2021, at 10:55a.m. Eastern Time
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Virtual Interview o
(U) Telephonic Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Introductory Conversation wit
(U) Introductory Conversation wit nd her counsel

(U) Information provided b
(U) Request for Laboratory Examinations
(U) Phone Call froze
(U) Interview o Day 2

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Proffer o
(U) Interview/Proffer o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Request coordination of witness interview o
(U//FOUO) Responsiveness Review of Digital Evidence processed by CART
(U//FOUO) Highly confidential responsive material from digital evidence processed by CART

(U) Request to locate UK citize
(U ..f
(U) Interview o
(U) Call received fro
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Ten yearbooks received from FBI West Palm Beach Resident Agency
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) On 12/06/2020, at 9:32 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) Interview o
(U) Victim Services Division - Case Support Unit Assistance
(U) Interview o
(U) On 11/09/2020, at 5:16 p.m. Eastern time
effery Epstein Special.

(U) On 11/02/2020 at 5:58 AM Eastern Time
(U) On 10/27/2020, at 3:20 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) Fund Reimbursement - Five 2TB Hard drives

(U) Fund Reimbursement EC
(U) Fund Reimbursement -12 TB External Hard Drive
anif
(U) On 10/19/2020, at 2:00 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 10/19/2020, at 11:43 AM Eastern Time
(U) On 10/12/2020, at 3:14 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 10/09/2020, at 7:22:58 PM Eastern Time

(U) International Travel Request and Country Clearance to London, UK
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Notification and concurrence to conduct interview of UK citizen

(U) Notification and concurrence of UK citizen interview
(U) Interview o
(U) Cell Phone Location Information Warrant for

(U) Cell Phone Location Information Warrant for
(U) Search Warrant for six binders seized from
(U) Search Warrant for items seized from Little St James

(U) Search Warrant for items seized from Jeffre E stein
(U) Search Warrant for items seized fro
IIII: SSHHHHII HINVHHHHHH ffH

(U) On 09/14/2020, at 12:12 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 09/08/2020, at 10:29 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) Documentation of Services b /01/2020-06/30/2020

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) On 08/24/2020, at 12:06:59 PM Eastern Timeest Name Unknown (LNU), date of

(U) On 08/24/2020, at 11:34:48 AM Eastern Time Home telephone number
(U) On 08/24/2020, at 4:31 p.m. Eastern Time date of birt

(U) 50D-NY-3027571
(U) On 08/20/2020, at 10:31:12 AM Eastern Time date of birtl
(U) On 08/17/2020, at 3:03 PM Eastern Time

• i: i i .

(U) Date Submitted: 07/12/2020 07:06:53 PM ET Transaction Number: 07A23145-D0C9-438C-
(U) Documentation of services

(U) On 08/11/2020, at 7:26 a.m. Eastern Time .ast Name Unknown (LNU), email
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoena Service
(U) On 08/10/2020, at 08/10/2020 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (Anonymous

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U//REL TO USA, GBR) Notification of intent to conduct a voluntary witness interview of a UK citizen

(U) Attempted Contact witl
(U) On 08/06/2020, at 02:27 PM NU, Cell Telephon Called the FBI
(U) On 08/06/2020, at 10:12 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) Notification of UK citizen interview
(U) On 08/05/2020, at 5:48 p.m. Eastern Time mail address
(U//FOUO) Interview of

(U) On 08/03/2020, at 1 : p.m. as m ime, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), IP
(U) On 08/03/2020, at 5:11 P.M. Eastern Daylight Time date of birth

(U) On 08/02/2020, at 11:54 a.m. Eastern Time cell phone numbe
(U) Aerial Surveillance
(U) Grand jury subpoena service t coverage for Lead 14.

(U) On 07/29/2020, at 2:46:26 PM Eastern Time, Anonymous, Internet Protocol (IP) address
(U) On 07/09/2020, at 8:52:54 AM Eastern Time

(U) On 07/29/2020, at 2:14:24 PM Eastern Time
(U) On 07/29/2020, at 7:45 p.m. Eastern lime, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), Internet

(U) Lead Request to Serve grand Jury subpoen
HJJ: LLHHII HHHHHHHtt HH SSHAvrH HHHHHIJ HiHrrH HiillHppHHH

(U) Lead Request to Serve grand jury subpoen
(U) Date Submitted: 07/25/2020 10:08:31 AM ET Transaction Number

(U) On 07/26/2020, at 4:44 p.m. Eastern Time NU, date of birt home
• If
(U) On 07/18/2020, at 5:45 p.m. Eastern Time, an ANONYMOUS (hereafter ANON), Internet

(U) On 07/21/2020, at 2:17 a.m. Eastern Time
(U//FOUO) Telephone Interview 0
(U) Arrest of GHISLAINE MAXWELL

(U) On 07/17/2020 at 5:20 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/18/2020, at 2:22 a.m. Eastern Time cell telephone number +

(U) On 07/17/2020, at 4:03 a.m. Eastern Time cell telephone number +
(U) NTOC2020 200ko1 Information Regarding Jeffery Epstein Human Trafficking case.: 50D-NY
(U//FOUO) On 07/17/2020, at 6:37:42 PM Eastern Time, An anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol

(U) On 07/17/2020, at 3:03 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) (U) On 07/17/2020, at 02:53 p.m. Eastern Time
adf
(U) On 07/16/2020, at 10:27 PM, Eastern Time

(U) Information Regarding Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. On 07/15/2020, at 8:45
(U//FOUO) NTOC2020 197ab02 On 07/15/2020 at 9:45p.m. Eastern Time
(U//FOUO) Contacts o security personnel for Ghislaine Maxwell

(U) On 07/15/2020, at 1:41:32 PM Eastern Time
(U) Pen Register on Ghislaine Maxwell's phone number
(U) Pen Register renewal on Ghislaine Maxwell's phone number

(U) Documentation of Services
(U//FOUO) Impersonation of FBI Agent
(U//FOUO) Interview o
(U) Ghlslaine Maxwell, Mail Cover Information

(U) Pen Register renewal on Ghislaine Maxwell's phone num
(U) On 07/08/2020, at 10:49 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/12/2020, at 3:12:08 PM Eastern Time

(U) NTOC2020 194jcc01 E-TIP: Anonymous User Reportin ossess Videos of
(U) On 07/11/2020, at 10:02 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol

(U) On 07/09/2020, at 9:47 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/09/2020, at 5:46:58 PM Eastern Time
(U) On 07/10/2020, at 9:44 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP

(U) On 07/10/2020, at 9:22 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP
(U) (U)On 07/09/2020 at 8:29 p.m PROTECT IDENTITY]

(U) On 07/08/2020 at 6:01 P.M. Eastern Time email address
(U) Fund Reimbursement
(U) Pen Register on Ghislaine Maxwell's phone number

(U) On 07/07/2020, at 8:03:18 PM Eastern Time Internet Protocol (IP) address
(U) On 07/06/2020, at 10:19 AM Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)

(U) On 07/09/2020, at 9:51 a.m. Eastern Time PROTECT IDENITITY], date of
(U) On 07/08/2020, at 11:50 PM, Eastern Time

(U) On 07/08/2020, at 4:42 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/06/2020, at 3:39:20 PM Eastern Time
(U//FOUO) Aerial photos of 301 Summer Street Manchester by the Sea, Massachusetts 01944.

(U) On 07/08/2020, at 12:00 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous (Anonymous) tipster, using
(U) On 07/07/2020, at 5:59 p.m. Eastern Time PROTECT IDENTITY], date of

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 5:03:34 PM Eastern Time
(U) On 07/07/2020, at 5:27 p.m. Eastern Time date of bin
(U//FOUO) On 07/06/2020, at 12:59 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 12:33:51 PM Eastern Time, an anonymous complainant, Email account
(U) On 07/07/2020, at 10:57 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/06/2020, at 10:49:04 AM Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (
(U) NTOC2020 188ahm01 Information Regarding Ghislaine Maxwell. (NY) On 07/06/2020, at

(U) On 07/03/2020, at 5:21:13 PM Eastern Time PROTECT IDENTITY], date of
(U//FOUO) On 07/02/2020, at 5:57:18 PM Eastern Time

(U) NTOC2020-MC3 185vkav01 On 07/03/2020, at 4:44 p.m. EST international
(U) On 07/02/202, at 5:52:20 PM Eastern Time

(U) (U)On 07/02/2020, at 2:52:51 PM Eastern Time, ANONYMOUS, Cellular telephone number
(U) On 07/02/2020, at 1:28:41 PM Eastern Time
(U//FOUO) Interview o

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 192vmd01 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/11/2019, at 11:06
(U) On 06/11/2020, at 11:03:51 AM Eastern Time

(U) On 06/14/2020, at 4:50:33 PM Eastern Time
(U) FD1064 - 2020-05-21T12-59-59.xml
(U) Information provided bi

(U) Interview o • n 10/25/19
(U) Interview o
(U) F01064 - 2020-05-13T04-35-32.xml
(U) SOD-NY-3027571
(U) On 03/10/2020, at 12:24 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o • n 11.21.19
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Proffer o terview #2
(U) Proffer o nterview #1
(U) Interview o • n 10/11/2019

(U) SOD-NY-3027571
(U) Pass Information to Swedish authorities for informational purposes.
(U) Interview o

(U) Share information with Swedish Authorities
(U) Interview o
(U) interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Proffer o
(U) Interview o
(U) Non-Transitory/For Record
(U) On 03/19/2020, at 11:13:52 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) Interview o
(U) California Trip Request
(U) On 02/19/2020, at 12:11 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) interview o 2/17/2019

(U) Interview o
(U) NTOC2020 37ch01 Elip: involvement with Jeffrey Epstein, Sex Trafficking, and Murder
(U) 50D-NY-3027571

(U) Documentation of Services by V'0/1/19-12/31/19
(U) Request Country Clearance and FBIHQ travel authority to Stockholm, Sweden

(U) Legat Copenhagen - Pass information and concurrence to Interview Swedish citizen
(U) interview o
(U) VSD Documentation of Services

(U) On 01/23/2020 at 12:10 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Phone conversation wit

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) interview o
(U) Phone call with Attorn
(U) interview o
(U •terview

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Epstein Breifing EVAF Expenditures
(U) Documentation of Services by V • r /1/19-9/30/19

(U) On 01/02/2020, at 3:46 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) interview o
(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director

(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director
(U) interview o
(U) California Trip Request
(U terview

(U) interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) interview o
(U) On 12/09/2019, at 5:00 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o • n 9/19/2019
(U) To document call wit
(U) Interview o 11/14/2019
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o 7/31/19

(U) Proffer o terview #1
(U) On 11/23/2019, at 8:33 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) Victim Services Division - Victim Meeting

(U) Terrorism Victim Assistance Fund and Budget Matters, Victim Services Division
(U) The Bloom Firm contact with FBI Seattle re

(U) NTOC2019 317bmm01 Knowledge of Two Women Working For Epstein On 11/13/2019 at 9:40
(U) On 11/10/2019, at 2:43 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) Holiday Pay Request
(U) Interview o
(U nterview
(U) Terrorism Victim Assistance Fund and Budget Matters, Victim Services Division

(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)
(U PROTECT SOURCE) Interview #4
(U) On 08/11/2019, at 8:09:38 PM Eastern Time
home (U) On 10/21/2019, at 5:58 am Eastern Time
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records for Ghislaine Maxwell
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Ghislaine Maxwell

(U) On 10/11/2019, at 1:37:25 PM Eastern Time
(U) Lead Forwared to Legat Mexico City, Mexico
(U) On 10/08/2019, at 8:40 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) Interview o
(U) Emergency Victim Funds and Budget Matters, Office of the Director
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records fo
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) o

(U) Interview o
(U nterview
(U nterview
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) On 09/25/2019, at 2:08 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) Interview o
(U) )000000000(
(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)
(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)

(U) Date Submitted: 09/14/2019 03:33:55 AM EST Transaction Number: 1DBC5395-3782-461D-
(U) Interview o
(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)

(U) On 09/17/2019, at 12:40 pm Eastern Time
(U) Interview o
(U) Device Unlock and Extraction - MDUS 10398

(U) California Trip Request
(U) Device Unlock and Extraction - MDUS 10399
(U) On 09/13/2019, at 6:30 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 09/14/2019, at 2:58 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 09/11/2019, at 7:53 p.m. Eastern lime, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), Internet

(U) On 09/10/2019, at 08:45 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol
(U) On 09/11/2019, at 1:42:18 PM Eastern Time, the Law Office o

(U) On 09/10/2019, at 5:44 p.m. Eastern Time ROTECT
(U) On 09/10/2019, at 12:36:56 PM Eastern Time
(U) Interview o
(UHFOU0) Laser Scans conducted of Little Saint James Island

(U) New Criminal Case: 31E-NY-3027571-FF; Seizure: 3540-19-F-474; Asset ID: 19-F8I-006034
(U) FBI New York - Jeffrey Epstein - Child Sex Trafficking - 190904-175728

(U) Follow-Up Law Enforcement Inquiries Pertaining t •
(U) Interview 0
(U
(U) Search Warrant Execution - Little Saint James

(U) Supplemental To Jeffrey E Epstein Arrest on July 06, 2019
(U) On 8/31/2019 at 8:50 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 08/30/2019, at 4:56 p.m. Eastern Time ate of
(U//FOUO PROTECT SOURCE) Interview #3
(U) Late submission of evidence

(U) An anonymous caller, international telephone numbe tated that she
(U) Phone interview o
(U) On 08/28/2019, at 10:55:42 AM Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol

(U) On 08/28/2019, at 09:48 a.m. Eastern Time
U WEXNER FOUNDATION - financial connection to JEFFREY EPSTEIN
U NTOC2019 1971(103 E-Tip: Information Regarding Multiple Criminal Allegations such as Human Sex Traffi

(U) On 08/25/2019, at 9:03 A.M. Eastern Time, an Anonymous female caller (Anonymous),
(U) (U) On 08/22/2019, at 4:34 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 08/22/2019, at 4:55 P.M. Eastern Time
(U) (U)Date Submitted: 08/12/2019 10:41:15 PM EST Transaction Number: 6AC08539-244A-4664-
(U//FOU0 PROTECT SOURCE) Interview #2

(U) Search warrant executed on Little St James
(U hone Interview
(U) Recorded Interview (Non-Custodial - Overt) DTD 8/13/2019 wit Philadelphia

(U) Sigrid McCawley Interview
(U) On 08/21/2019 at 10:05 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) Inventory of Two Suite Cases (black/blue) for JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U Legat London

(U) Transfer of Evidence from Miami case file to NY case file
(U) Amended Suitcase Inventory on 07/31/2019

(U) On 08/12/2019, at 12:27 p.m. Eastern Time ROTECT IDENTITY], cel ular
(U) On 08/17/2019 at 8:29 p.m. Eastern time, Anonymous female contacted the FBI National

(U) On 08/17/2019, at 6:38 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female (Anonymous), age 32
(U) On 08/16/2019, at 6:28 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 8/15/19, at 11:15 a.m. Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) On 08/16/2019, at 10:12 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 08/15/2019, at 8:00 p.m. Eastern Time, Psychologis
(U) On 08/15/2019, at 5:12 p.m. Eastern Time
of

(U) On 08/14/2019, at 3:43 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 08/10/2019, at 11:01 a.m. Eastern Time, Anonymous [PROTECT IDENTITY], date

(U) On 08/10/2019, at 3:46 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 08/11/2019, at 7:38 a.m. Eastern Time, Jay B., date of birth 05/01/1957, who
(U tated that her son recruited not only young girls, but young boys as well

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 227jcc01 E-TIP: Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 08/13/2019
(U) On 08/14/2019, at 4:15 p.m. Eastern Time PROTECT IDENTITY], date of

(U) On 08/14/2013, 10:04 a.m., Eastern Time
(U) On 08/11/2019, at 9:01 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 8/11/2019, at 11:28:04 PM Eastern Time Other telephone number +

(U) On 08/13/2019 at 5:49 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 08/13/2019, at 4:06:17 PM Eastern Time
(U) Reporting from Closed)

(U) On 08/12/2019, at 8:35 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 08/11/2019, at 10:36 p.m. Eastern time
(U) On 08/11/2019, at 1:40 P.M. Eastern Time, an anonymous caller (Anonymous), telephone

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 223fas01 E-Tip: Crisis Intake Regarding Jeffrey Epstein Human Traffickin
(U) On 07/27/2019, at 6:06 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP
(U//FOUO PROTECT SOURCE) Interview One
(U

(U) On 08/08/2019, at 9:02 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 08/08/2019, at 5:19 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) Interview o

(U) On 08/07/2019, at 2:08 p.m. Eastern Time PROTECT IDENTITY], date of
(U) Device Extraction - MDUS 10126

(U) Request to Intervi
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview •
(U) Return of Property to • n 08/02/2019
(U) Seizure of items from safe of 9 East 71st St, NY, NY

(U) On 08/07/2019, at 1:37 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o 'n  07/11/2019
(U) On 08/06/2019, at 10:55 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 08/06/2019, at 4:50:59 PM Eastern Time
(U) FDR to Legat Canberra
(U) On 8/1/2019, at 12:29:31 PM Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster, Internet Protocol (IP

(U) NTOC2019 214mka01 Suspicious Activity by Epstein Associate. (NY) On 08/02/2019
(U) On 08/01/2019, at 8:19 a.m. Eastern lime, which is an alias provided

(U) On 7/31/2019, at 04:07:50 PM Eastern Time, date of birth
(U) Post Arrest Spontaneous Utterances made by Defendant JFFREY E. EPSTEIN

(U) Op Plan 7/11/2019
(U) Late submission of evidence
(U) Arrest/Search Op Plan 7/6/2019
(U) Interview o

(U) On 07/31/2019, at 3:20 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (Anonymous),
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) On 07/30/2019, at 02:26:42 PM Eastern Time
(U) Arrest of JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U) On 07/29/2019, at 6:48 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/27/2019 at 02:44:33 PM EST
(U) On 07/20/2019, at 1:51 a.m. Eastern Tim
(U) On 07/24/2019, at 4:23 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) Opening EC
(U) On 07/25/2019, at 4:45 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/25/2019, at 1:29 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) Jeffrey Epstein
(U) On 07/24/2019, at 2:50 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/23/2019, at 10:17 a.m. Eastern Time ate of birth

(U) EC to document contact made with Florida victims
(U) Interview o
(U) Interivew o
(U) Interivew of Jean Brunel

(U) Interivew o
(U) Interviews (or attempted) o flsoki 'alia, an•
(U) Interview o • n 07/15/2019
(U) Seizure of items from safe of 9 East 71st, NY, NY

(U) On 07/23/2019, at 11:22 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) NTOC2019-MC3 192vmd01 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/11/2019, at 11:06

(U) On 07/21/2019 at 10:15 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/20/2019, at 1:51 a.m. Eastern Tim
(U) On 07/19/2019, at 7:48 p.m. Eastern Time, Retired New Mexico State Police Officer,

(U) Provide information to SEATTLE FO for conducting interview I
(U) On 07/19/2019, at 11:36 a.m. Eastern Time date of

(U) On 07/18/2019 at 4:11 p.m. Eastern Time home
(U) On 07/18/2019, at 8:14 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/17/2019 at 2:54 p.m., Eastern Time

(U) Interivew o
(U) On 07/17/2019, at 3:43 p.m. Eastern Time, the FBI's Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) On 07/17/2019, at 3:51 p.m. Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)

(U) Search Warrant Executed-
(U) Interivew o
(U) Attempted Interview of GHISLAINE MAXWELL
(U) On 07/12/2019, 3:33 p.m., Eastern Time
(U

(U) Items seized from JEFFREY EPSTEIN during his arrest
(U) Search Warrant Executed .
U) On 07/16/2019, at 12:56 p.m as ern ime

(U) On 07/14/2019, at 11:44 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), email
(U) On 07/15/2019, at 5:01 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/15/2019, at 2:51 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/15/2019, at 11:34 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/15/2019, at 10:06 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/15/2019, at 10:06 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/11/2019, at 10:48 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous (Anonymous) tipster, Internet

(U) On 07/15/2019, at 2:35 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/013/2019 at 7:44 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/14/2019, at 5:24 p.m Eastern Time

(U) On 07/13/2019, at 8:04 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 1:44 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/13/2019, at 2:57 p.m. Eastern Time, an Anonymous female caller, telephone

(U) On 07/13/2019, at 2:19 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/13/2019, at 10:31 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/12/2019 02:35:56 AM EST, an anonymous individual, email address not provided,
(U//FOUO) On 07/11/2019, at 10:56 p.m. Eastern Time, tipster email address

(U) On 07/12/2019, at 6:21 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 6:30 p.m. Eastern Time date of birth
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 5:17 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/12/2019, at 2:33 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 12:29p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 11:48 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/12/2019, at 10:31 a.m. Eastern Time date of birth
(U) On 07/11/2019, at 2:40 p.m. Eastern Time • ate of birth

(U) On 07/12/2019, at 1:22 a.m. Eastern Time an anonymous tipster (Anonymous), Internet
(U) On 07/12/2019, at 8:11 a.m. Eastern Time [PROTECT IDENTITY],

(U) On 07/11/2019, at 2:31 a.m., Eastern Time, the FBI Office of Public Affairs (OPA)
(U) On 07/10/2019, at 7:45 p.m. Eastern lime, an anonymous complainant, email address

(U) On 07/11/2019, at 7:13 p.m. Eastern Time date o
(U) NTOC2019-MC1 192cdr03 Information Concerning Jeffrey Epstein, case no.: 31E-NY-

(U) On 07/11/2019, at 12:00 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) NTOC2019-MC3 192vmd01 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/11/2019, at 11:06

(U) On 07/11/2019, 10:13 a.m. Eastern Time • ate
(U) On 07/10/2019 at 10:57 A.M Eastern Time, an anonymous tipster with an Internet

(U) (U)On 07/10/2019 at 8:59 p.m. Eastern Time PROTECT IDENTITY],
(U) NOEMI GOICO an.
(U) Interview o • n 5/29/2019

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 4:32 p.m. Eastern Time, Anonymous Tipster, date of birth 01/17/2002
(U) On 07/10/2019, at 2:50 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (Anonymous),

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 191vmd03 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/10/2019, at 3:08
(U) On 07/10/2019, at 2:35 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (Anonymous),

(U) On 07/10/2019, at 1:28 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 7/10/2019, at 11:59 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/10/2019, at 11:28 a.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female caller (ANONYMOUS),

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 4:47 A.M
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 6:56 A.M. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/10/2019, at 8:20 a.m. Eastern Time date of birth

(U) On 07/10/2019, at 5:03 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 10:49 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 8:44 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 190vmd05 Jaffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/09/2019, at 7:34
(U) NTOC2019-MC3 190vmd04 Jaffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/09/2019, at 6:43

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 6:37 p.m. Eastern Time, anonymous male caller (Anonymous), called
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 4:10 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 4:27 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous female in her 60's (Anonymous)
(U) On 07/09/2019 at 4:34 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) NTOC2019-MC3 190vmd03 Jaffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/09/2019, at 3:28
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 2:34 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/09/2019, at 3:55 p.m. Eastern Time PROTECT IDENTITY
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 3:47 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 3:27 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 3:33 p.m. Eastern Times cellular telephone

(U) On 07/09/2019 at 2:09 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/09/2019, at 12:34 p.m. Eastern Time, an anonymous male caller (Anonymous),

(U) On 07/08/2019 at 12:45 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) NTOC2019 190bmm01 Possible Pim • or Epstein On 07/08/2019 at 12:02 p.m.

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 5:50 p.m. Eastern Time date of birth
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:40 a.m. Eastern Time, Anonymous, Internet Protocol (IP) address

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 10:18 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 9:00 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 8:14 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 4:31 p.m. Eastern Time PROTECT IDENTITY], date of
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 8:25 p.m. Eastern Time home

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 7:52 p.m. Eastern Tim
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 8:11 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) NTOC2019 189jeg02 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/08/2019, at 6:23 p.m.

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 7:02 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 07:01 p.m. Eastern Time, an Anonymous male caller called the

(U) NTOC2019 189vmd04 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/08/2019, at 4:44 p.m.
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 5:16 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 4:12 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 5:11 p.m. Eastern Time date of birth
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 5:17 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/08/2019 at 3:34 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 07/08/2019 at 4:51 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 3:55 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 03:08 PM Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 3:03 p.m. Eastern Time hone
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:25 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 2:07 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) Search Warrant Executed- 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 1:20 p.m. Eastern Time, an Anonymous caller, cellular telephone
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:16 p.m. Eastern Time
(U//FOUO) On 07/08/2019, at 1:10 P.M. Eastern Standard Time, the Office of Public Affairs

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 1:43 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019 at 1:28 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:29 p.m. Eastern Time

(U) On 07/08/2019 at 11:31 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) NTOC2019-MC3 189dec01 Possible Connection between YouTuber, Jean Francois Gariepy,

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:10 p.m. Eastern Time, Anonymous, telephone numbe
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 12:49 p.m. Eastern Time PROTECT IDENTITY), date of

(U) On 07/08/2019 at 11:31 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) NTOC2019 189vmd02 Jeffrey Epstein Human Trafficking (NY) On 07/08/2019, at 12:34 p.m

(U) On 07/07/2019 at 11:51 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:55 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:57 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) Ono 07/08/2019, at 11:50 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:44 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) Search Warrant Executed at 9 East 71st Street, New York, New York 10021

(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:28 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:34 a.m. Eastern Time
(U) On 07/08/2019, at 11:27 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) 31E-NY-3027571
(U) (U)On 07/07/2019 at 4:31 p.m. Eastern Time
(U) (U) On 07/07/2019 at 6:06 a.m. Eastern Time

(U) Administrative Subpoena (FD-1035)
(U) Interview o • n 5/29/2019
(U) Interview o 5/8/2019
(U) Interview o

(U) Items turned over to the FBI duri nterview on 5/29/19
(U) Florida Trip Request
(U) Interview o 5/2/2019

(U) Interview o
(U//FOUO) TECS Silent Hit Notification
(U) Request Miami Evidence to transfer items in 31E-MM-108062 to New York Evidence

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Florida Trip Request
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o

(U) Interview o
(U) Interview o
(U) Florida Trip Request
(U) Interview o
(U) Phone interview o
(U) Interview wit • n 02/14/2019

(U) Interview o
(U) Trip to Florida
(U) NY requests LA assistance to confirm victim address and initial notification/interview

(U) Florida Trip Request
(U) Opening EC
P)
Serial Repel SOD-Nle-3027571-EIA
Serial U Date Title
2 7/1/2019 13:39 (U) Consensual Monitoring Authorization
1 7/1/2019 9:53 (U) Subfile Opening Document
Serial Report for Case: SOD-NY-3027571-FA
Serial U Date Title
¢ 4/1/2022 14:26 (U) )00000000(
5 11/13/2019 13:06 (U) )000000000C
4 11/4/2019 14:33 (U) lOCCOUCOON
2 11/4/2019 14:33 (U) )000000000C
2 9/30/2019 7:45 (U) )000000000(
1 8/30/2019 10:10 (U) FA Subfile Opening Document
Serial Report for Case: 50D-NY-3027571-FF
Serial* Date
17 4/14/2022 16:02
16 4/13/2022 11:52
.1.5. 9/13/2019 12:13
14 9/6/2019 12:41
13 8/22/201916:03
12 8/21/201916:03
11 8/13/2019 16:01
10 8/12/2019 11:43
9 8/12/2019 11:43
8 8/7/2019 13:10
Z 8/7/2019 9:08
A 7/29/201913:38
5 7/24/2019 13:26
4 7/24/2019 13:25
2 7/22/2019 13:20
2 7/8/2019 14:28
1 6/24/2019 14:38
Title

(U) Request is withdrawn as to title and appraisal for 338 E Washington Rd, Bradford, NH property.
(U) Request for Title and Appraisal reports for 338 E Washington Rd, Bradford, Merrimack County, NH
(1 ubpoena

(U) New Criminal Case: 31E-NY-3027571-FF; Seizure: 3540-19-F-474; Asset ID: 19-FBI.006034
(U) Jade Data Research Inc, Title Report and Documents for 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, FL33480.

(U) Two Deeds for Great St James Island purchased by GREAT ST JIM LLC in January 2016.
(U) Request for a Title report and an Appraisal for Little St James Island, U.S.V.I.

(U) Certified Appraisal 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, FL 33480, $13,000,000.00, dated 07/24/2019.
(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoena fo

(U) Grand Jury Subpoena to serve o
(U) Filed Notice of Pendency for 9 East 71st Street, New York, NY 10021.

(U) Certified Appraisal for 9 E 71st Street, New York, NY 10021, dated 07/13/2019.
(U) Title Report and Title Documents for 9 East 71st Street, New York, NY 10021.

(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoena for records fo
(U) Request for a Title Report and an Appraisal for 358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida 33480.

(U) Request for a title search and an appraisal for 9 E 71st St, New York, NY 10021.
(U) Forfeiture Subfile Opening Document
Serial Report for Case: I 50D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS
Serial # Date
12 3/31/2022 9:51
11 3/31/2022 6:58
12 3/24/2022 12:10
2 3/2/2022 21:04
8 3/2/2022 21:02
7 1/31/2022 13:20
6 10/24/2019 11:14
5 10/18/2019 16:22
4 10/18/2019 13:41
3 10/2/2019 13:53
2 10/1/2019 16:40
1 8/29/2019 9:43
Title
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) fo
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) fo
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) fo
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) for
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) fo
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records for Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Key Findings Pursuant to the Review of Toll Records Regarding Target Telephone Number
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records for Ghislaine Maxwell
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Ghislaine Maxwell
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) of Travel Records fo
(U//FOUO) Tactical Intelligence Report (TIR) o

(U) Subfile Opening Document
Case Number 72-MM -113327
Case Summary:
Obstruction of justice case with subject Alfredo Rodriguez, a
former employee of Epstein, opened 10/28/2009 by FBI
Miami Palm Beach RA. Rodriguez was arrested for obstruction
on 12/08/2009, convicted, and sentenced in 2010. This
investigation was closed on 03/13/2013. The 1B items have
been incorporated into the 50D case with new 1B numbers.
The lAs were sent to NY in 2019 and were housed in a
physical format until we sent them to WFO. One box
containing the 72•MM physical case file was located at FBI
Miami Palm Beach RA and coordinated for transport to WFO
on 03/03/2025. The only item of evidentiary use out of the 72
MM case was the black contact book.
Serial Report for Case: 72-MM-113327
Serial * Date
64 3/7/2025 9:16
63 6/18/2013 10:18
5.2 1/2/2013 13:18
42 8/29/20110:00
60 1/18/20110:00
59 11/9/2010 0:00
58 10/26/2010 0:00
57 10/26/2010 0:00
56 9/17/2010 0:00
a 11/18/2010 0:00
511 11/18/2010 0:00
53 11/16/2010 0:00

N. 10/26/2010 0:00
51 10/13/2010 0:00
SO 10/13/2010 0:00
49 8/9/2010 0:00
a 8/9/2010 0:00
47 9/2/2010 0:00
46 9/2/2010 0:00
a 7/1/2010 0:00
44 6/21/2010 0:00
43 6/23/2010 0:00
42 6/23/2010 0:00
41 6/23/2010 0:00
IQ 6/23/2010 0:00
39 6/23/2010 0:00
31 6/23/2010 0:00
E 6/23/2010 0:00
36 6/23/2010 0:00
35 6/23/2010 0:00
34 6/23/2010 0:00
3.2 6/23/2010 0:00
32 6/23/2010 0:00
31 6/23/2010 0:00
22 6/23/2010 0:00
n 6/23/2010 0:00
28 6/7/2010 0:00
27 5/25/2010 0:00
26 4/23/2010 0:00
25 3/18/2010 0:00
24 3/18/2010 0:00
23 2/4/2010 0:00
22 11/3/2009 0:00
21 11/9/2009 0:00
20 11/5/2009 0:00
14 12/8/2009 0:00
18 12/8/2009 0:00
17 12/22/2009 0:00
16 12/9/2009 0:00
15 12/1/2009 0:00
14 12/2/2009 0:00
13 11/6/2009 0:00
12 11/6/2009 0:00
11 10/29/2009 0:00
10 11/5/2009 0:00
9 10/28/2009 0:00
8 10/28/2009 0:00
7 11/5/2009 0:00
6 11/3/2009 0:00
5 11/3/2009 0:00
4 11/2/2009 0:00
2 10/28/2009 0:00
2 10/28/2009 0:00
1 10/28/2009 0:00
Title

(U) Transfer of case files
(U) EC return of property t.
(U) Closing EC
(U//FOUO) REQUEST ADMINISTRATIVE CLOSURE OF CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST LEAD BE COVERED FOR PALM SPRINGS RA TO
(U//FOUO) CONSOLIDATED LEGAL CENTER PROVIDED BOP RECORDS R:
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW RE;AUSP ____
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF D E:ARTHUR SHAPIRO
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW R:
(U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING PALM SPRINGS RA TO INTERVIE \A ll
(U//FOUO) TO COVER LEAD FOR THE MIAMI DIVISION REGARDING THE
(U//FOUO
(U//FOUO) REQUESTIN INFO R ND BERRY LESTER KESSLER _

(U) TO NOTIFY PALM BEACH RA THAT LEAD HAS BEEN COVERED.
(U NTERVIEW; 10/12/2010
(U//FOUO) ATT FEE: $50.00
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THIRD PARTY DRAFT ISSUE FUNDS IN THE AMOUNT
(U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING NEW YORK DIVISION TO CONDUCT INTERVIEW
(U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING TRENTON RA TO CONDUCT INTERVIEW OF FEDERAL
(U//FOUO) SENTENCE DATE R
(U//FOUO) EPSTEIN'S EX BUTLER SENTENCED TO 18 MONTHS FOR TRYING TO SEL
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE DOCUMENT CONVERSION LABORATORY
(U//FOUO) OBTAINED CALIFORNIA DRIVERS LICENSE (CDL) PHOTOGRAPHS
(U//FOLIO) EC REQUESTING COPY OF CAUFORNIA DRIVER'S LICENSE OF
(U//FOUO) CONVICTION R:
(U//FOLIO) FEES/WIRE TRANSFER OF "SHOW MONEY":$275.00
(U//FOUO) REQUEST CASE FUNDING IN THE AMOUNT OF $275.00 FOR
(U//FOUO) EC REGARDING LATE SUBMISSION OF RECORDINGS TO ELSUR.
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW R
(UHFOU0 MOTEL ROOM IN THE AMOUNT OF $177.30
(U//FOUO) REQUEST CASE FUNDING IN THE AMOUNT OF $177.30 FOR
(U//FOUO • LACED UNDER ARREST AND TRANSPORTED
(U//FOUO) ARREST R:
(U//FOUO) ARREST R
(U//FOUO) TO DOCUMENT BUSINESS INFORMATION.
(U//FOUO) ARREST WARRRANT R:
(U//FOUO) COMPLAINT R:
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW R

(U) )0(>0000000(
(U//FOUO
(U//FOUO
(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009 DATE OF B
(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009 DATE OF B
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR SAC AUTHORITY TO UTILIZE NON BUREAU
(U//FOUO) PURSUANT TO SEARCH:PROVIDED B
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW R
(U//FOUO) OPERATION PLAN R:
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR $50,000.00 OF "SHOW MONEY" FROM FBIHQ
(U//FOUO) NCIC CCH R 2
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
1A/1C Rep 72-MM-113327
Type # Serial # Acquired On
lA 21 24 2025-03.04
lA 20 64 2025-03-03
1A as ¢1, 2013-06-17
lA 14 12010.06-23
1A 17 1 2010-11-16
1A 16 1 2010-12-19
1A 15 1 2010-09-28
1A 14 12010-11-09
1A 13 1 2010-03-19
1A 12 1 2009-11-18
1A 11 12010-02-01
1A .12 12009-11-06
1A 9 12009-11-03
1A 8 12009-11-03
1A 7 1 2009-11-02
1A 6 1 2009-08-06
IA 5 1 2009-11-18
lA 4 1 2009-11-06
lA 1 12009-11-06
lA 2 12009-11-03
lA 1 12009-11-06
Serial Title

(U) Transfer of case files
(U) Transfer of case files
(U) EC return of property to Alfredo Rodriguez
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOLIO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOLIO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
(U//FOUO) OPEN AND ASSIGN A NEW 72 (OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE)
Summary

(U) Copy of Fedex Tracking
(U) Itemized list of files
(U) FD 597 return of property t •
(U//FOUO) VARIOUS TELEPHONE CD'S AND SUBPOENA FO E; SENT OUT TO HQ FOR B1
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF 1 N 11/16/2010 2) CONTACT INFORMATIO
(U//FOUO) BOP INMATE RECORD RE:BERRY KESSLER AN,
(U//FOUO) (2) BALEEN SWEEP CD'S FOR TOLL RECORD
(U//FOUO) BOP RECORDS R: ND BERRY KESSLER
(U//FOUO) ATT PHONE RECORDS FOR SUB JULY 1,2009 11/2009
(U//FOU0) INVOICE FOR PAYMENT OF STAGEHAND FEES/MONEY WIRE FEE AND COPY OF CASHIERS CHECK FOR F
(U//FOUO) FOUR (4) DVDS OF DEPOSITION 0 UG 2009
(W/FOU0) /ADVICE OF RIGHTS FORk.o ./6/2 009INTERROGATION
(U//FOUO) 1 BOUND BLACK ADDRESS BOOK AND 2 STAPLED HANDWRITTEN SET OF DOCUMENTS ON YELLOW LE
(U//FOUO , PASSPORTS;FL DRIVER LICENSE,RESIDENT ALIEN CARD;SOCIAL SECURITY CARC
(U//FOUO) DVD/CD'S OF CONSENSUALLY MONITORED PHONE CALLS W 7 DISCS)
(U//FOUO) LEETER AND EMAIL CORRESPONDENCE BETWEE N .
(U//FOUO
(U//FOUO) 1)FD-26 CONSENT TO SEARCH SIGNED B )FD-395 SIGNED B
(U//FOUO) FD 395
4 FOR EPSTEIN'S ASSOCIATES AND EMPLOYEES WRITTEN OUT BY COUTERIER'S ASSISTANT
Evidence Report for Case: 72-MM-113327
Filtering on: Type(s):1B, 1D, 1E
Item # Collected On
1D6 10/28/2009 8:00
1D5 10/29/2009 8:00
1D4 11/3/2009 7:00
1D3 11/2/2009 7:00
1D2 11/3/2009 7:00
1D1 11/3/2009 7:00
Description

(U) ONE ORIGINAL TELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 10/28/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE
(U) ONE ORIGINAL TELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 10/29/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE

(U) ONE ORIGINAL TELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 11/3/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE
(U) ONE ORIGINAL TELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 11/02/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE

(U) ONE ORIGINAL NONTELEPHONE RECORDING (CCTV) MADE ON 11/3/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE
(U) ONE ORIGINAL NONTELEPHONE RECORDING MADE ON 11/3/2009 SEE SAC LATE EC SERIAL 3 ELA FILE
Serial Repc 72-MM-113327-ELA
Serial # Date
2 2/4/2010 0:00
2 10/28/2009 0:00
1 10/28/2009 0:00
Title
(U//FOUO) EC REGARDING LATE SUBMISSION OF RECORDINGS TO ELSUR.

(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009
(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009
DATE OF B
DATE OF B
1A/1C Rep 72-MM-113327-ELA
Type tt Acquired On Serial #
lA 2 2009-10-28 1
lA 1 2009-10-28 1
Serial Title Summary
(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009 DATE OF B (U//FOUO) ORIGINAL I
(U) ON OR ABOUT AUGUST OF 2009 DATE OF B (U//FOUO) ORIGINAL I
D•472 CONSENT FORM REF FATED 10/28/2009
Case Number: 31E-MM-108062
Case Summary:
Child Prostitution case against Epstein brought by PBPD, opened 07/25/2006 by FBI Miami
Palm Beach RA, resulting In a guilty plea in State Court. This case has remained in Pending
Inactive status since 07/25/2017 and case materials have been preserved for a civil litigation
hold. The 18 items have been incorporated into the SOD case with new 1B numbers. The
remaining 31E-MM file was sent to NY in 2019 in boxes and was housed both in a physical
and digital format (DVDs), until we sent it to WFO.
Serial Re 31E-MM-108062
Serial * Date
al 5/12/2023 8:17
262 4/28/2023 13:46
al 7/8/2022 13:53
260 6/6/2019 13:40
259 6/6/2019 13:40
258 12/6/2018 18:33
257 10/13/2017 9:28
256 9/29/2015 11:16
255 3/11/2015 12:22
254 7/12/2013 14:47
251 7/12/2013 11:32
al 7/8/2013 13:19
251 7/8/2013 13:16
250 8/12/20110:00
249 7/1/2011 0:00
248 3/23/2011 0:00
247 3/22/2011 0:00
246 3/2/20110:00
aa 1/31/2008 0:00
244 1/31/2008 0:00
243 1/31/2008 0:00
242 1/31/2008 0:00
2g1 1/31/2008 0:00
240 4/7/2011 0:00
239 4/7/20110:00
238 3/22/20110:00
237 3/14/20110:00
afi 3/14/2011 0:00
235 3/12/2011 0:00
234 3/12/20110:00
al 3/1/2011 0:00
al 12/10/2010 0:00
231 12/10/2010 0:00
230 11/24/2010 0:00
229 11/26/2010 0:00
al 11/26/20100:00
227 4/16/2010 0:00
226 7/20/2010 0:00
m 7/22/2010 0:00
224 5/28/2008 0:00
223 1/27/2010 0:00
222 1/26/2010 0:00
221 1/8/2010 0:00
220 6/11/2009 0:00
219 6/17/2009 0:00
218 6/10/2009 0:00
217 4/10/2009 0:00
ak 2/17/2009 0:00
215 11/25/2008 0:00
214 10/17/2007 0:00
213 12/11/2008 0:00
212 12/8/2008 0:00
211 12/3/2008 0:00
210 11/25/2008 0:00
209 9/29/2008 0:00
208 9/29/2008 0:00
207 9/29/2008 0:00
2.4.6 9/29/2008 0:00
20 9/29/2008 0:00
204 9/29/2008 0:00
203 9/29/2008 0:00
202 9/29/2008 0:00
201 9/29/2008 0:00
200 9/29/2008 0:00
199 9/29/2008 0:00
In 9/29/2008 0:00
19/ 9/29/2008 0:00
196 9/29/2008 0:00
195 9/29/2008 0:00
94 9/29/2008 0:00
193 9/29/2008 0:00
192 9/29/2008 0:00
191 9/29/2008 0:00
190 9/29/2008 0:00
18.2 9/29/2008 0:00
188 9/29/2008 0:00
187 9/29/2008 0:00
IgE 9/29/2008 0:00
185 9/29/2008 0:00
184 9/29/2008 0:00
183 9/29/2008 0:00
182 9/29/2008 0:00
AI 9/29/2008 0:00
180 9/29/2008 0:00
179 9/29/2008 0:00
Iza 9/29/2008 0:00
177 9/29/2008 0:00
176 9/29/2008 0:00
175 10/19/2008 0:00
174 10/7/2008 0:00
173 8/25/2008 0:00
172 8/8/2008 0:00
171 8/7/2008 0:00
nQ 7/25/2008 0:00
16.2 7/23/2008 0:00
168 7/23/2008 0:00
AZ 7/21/2008 0:00
1§§ 7/7/2008 0:00
165 7/1/2008 0:00
164 5/30/2008 0:00
163 5/29/2008 0:00
162 5/31/2008 0:00
161 3/18/2008 0:00
160 3/17/2008 0:00
152 3/17/2008 0:00
152 4/22/2008 0:00
157 4/22/2008 0:00
156 3/27/2008 0:00
155 3/25/2008 0:00
154 3/20/2008 0:00
153 4/2/2008 0:00
152 4/2/2008 0:00
151 3/6/2008 0:00
152 2/27/2008 0:00
149 2/1/2008 0:00
148 1/25/2008 0:00
24/ 11/28/2007 0:00
146 11/2/2007 0:00
145 10/26/2007 0:00
144 10/26/2007 0:00
143 10/26/2007 0:00
M 10/19/2007 0:00
141 10/19/2007 0:00
140 10/2/2007 0:00
13.2 10/2/2007 0:00
138 9/6/2007 0:00
137 8/23/2007 0:00
136 3/5/2008 0:00
135 3/5/2008 0:00
la 2/6/2008 0:00
133 11/7/2007 0:00
132 11/7/2007 0:00
ili 1/10/2008 0:00
14Q 8/21/2007 0:00
129 10/25/2007 0:00
128 10/3/2007 0:00
127 8/7/2007 0:00
126 10/3/2007 0:00
125 10/9/2007 0:00
124 10/10/2007 0:00
121 10/2/2007 0:00
122 10/2/2007 0:00
121 3/22/2007 0:00
lag 11/1/2007 0:00
119 8/7/2007 0:00
118 12/4/2007 0:00
117 11/7/2007 0:00
116 6/25/2007 0:00
115 6/20/2007 0:00
114 6/12/2007 0:00
113 6/4/2007 0:00
112 6/4/2007 0:00
111 5/18/2007 0:00
110 5/10/2007 0:00
109 4/25/2007 0:00
108 4/26/2007 0:00
107 3/18/2007 0:00
106 3/19/2007 0:00
105 2/26/2007 0:00
10 1/10/2007 0:00
al 7/2/2007 0:00
102 10/12/2007 0:00
101 8/27/2007 0:00
UM 8/27/2007 0:00
99 8/17/2007 0:00
98 6/22/2007 0:00
97 6/11/2007 0:00
96 5/25/2007 0:00
21 5/29/2007 0:00
M 5/18/2007 0:00
93 4/30/2007 0:00
22 4/15/2007 0:00
91 4/30/2007 0:00
90 4/26/2007 0:00
89 2/14/2008 0:00
88 5/17/2007 0:00
17_ 5/2/2007 0:00
86 4/30/2007 0:00
85 4/30/2007 0:00
M 4/20/2007 0:00

al. 3/24/2007 0:00
82 3/15/2007 0:00
81 3/13/2007 0:00
80 4/6/2007 0:00
79 3/21/2007 0:00
78 3/13/2007 0:00
77 1/11/2007 0:00
16 2/2/2007 0:00
1/18/2007 0:00
74 3/21/2007 0:00
21 3/12/2007 0:00
22 3/6/2007 0:00
71 3/6/2007 0:00
70 2/13/2007 0:00
69 1/23/2007 0:00
68 1/23/2007 0:00
67 2/15/2007 0:00
66 2/6/2007 0:00
55 2/6/2007 0:00
64 2/6/2007 0:00
63 2/6/2007 0:00
62 1/18/2007 0:00
51 12/8/2006 0:00
60 10/30/2006 0:00
59 11/27/2006 0:00
58 8/15/2006 0:00
52 1/25/2007 0:00
a 6/21/2007 0:00
55 6/21/2007 0:00
54 6/21/2007 0:00
52 12/18/2006 0:00
52 12/13/2006 0:00
51 8/17/2006 0:00
50 12/20/2006 0:00
49 12/6/2006 0:00
4.4 12/18/2006 0:00
47 11/27/2006 0:00
46 11/15/2006 0:00
4.1 11/13/2006 0:00
44 11/1/2006 0:00
43 10/24/2006 0:00
42 10/24/2006 0:00
41 10/24/2006 0:00
N 10/24/2006 0:00
39 12/8/2006 0:00
38 12/5/2006 0:00
32 7/13/2006 0:00
25 10/10/2006 0:00
35 10/11/2006 0:00
34 8/31/2006 0:00
33 11/9/2006 0:00
32 11/14/2006 0:00
31 8/18/2006 0:00
30 10/14/2006 0:00
42 10/14/2006 0:00
n 8/18/2006 0:00
27 8/10/2006 0:00
22 8/18/2006 0:00
25 10/17/2006 0:00
24 10/16/2006 0:00
23 10/16/2006 0:00
22 10/16/2006 0:00
21 10/16/2006 0:00
20 6/21/2007 0:00
19 9/18/2006 0:00
12 7/30/2006 0:00
11 9/13/2006 0:00
16 8/8/2006 0:00
15 9/1/2006 0:00
14 8/28/2006 0:00
13 8/14/2006 0:00
12 8/14/2006 0:00
11 8/5/2006 0:00
.1.4 8/8/2006 0:00
2 8/4/2006 0:00
8 8/1/2006 0:00
7 7/29/2006 0:00
¢ 7/26/2006 0:00
5 7/25/2006 0:00
4 7/24/2006 0:00
3 5/1/2006 0:00
2 5/1/2006 0:00
1 7/24/2006 0:00
Title

(U) 31-MM-108062-1A SEC 001 SER 1A89 ONLY
(U) Case update and reassignment request.
(U) Missing chain of custody

(U) FedEx Shipment Receipt.
(U) FedEx Shipment Receipt.
(U) Opening EC
(U) FY 2018 Name Check Summary File

(U) Request for ELSUR shipment
(U) FOIA REQUEST LETTER
(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) Items received fro,,
(U
(U//FOUO) SIDES ARGUE WHETHER JEFFREY EPSTEIN'S NONPROSECUTION DEAL VI
(U//FOUO) CURRENCY TRANSACTION REPORT
(U//FOUO) PROSTITUTION RING LEADER SENTENCED TO 21 MONTHS
(U//FOUO) THE EVIDENCE PERSON WAS UNABLE TO LOOK TO SEE IF ANYTHING WA
(U//FOUO) PRICE ANDREW AND THE 17-YEAR OLD GIRL HIS SEX OFFENDER FRIEN
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW R
(U//FOUO iET WITH SA'S AND AUSA
(U//FOUO ONTACTED SA'S AND PROVIDED INFO
(U//FOUO AET WITH SAS AND AUSA
(U//FOUO ET WITH SA'S AND AUSA
(U//FOUO) FUNDS REQUEST $90.09
(U//FOUO) EC REQUESTING REIMBURSEMENT FROM CASE FUNDS FOR

(U) TO DOCUMENT LIAISON AND INVESTIGATION IN AUSTRALIA
(U) INTERVIEW OF U.S. CITIZE
(U//FOUO) TO ADVISE MIAMI DIVISION OF CACU CONCURRENCE OF THE TRAVEL
(U//FOUO) REQUEST LEGAT CANBERRA FACILITATE INTERVIEW OF VICTIM,
(U//FOUO) REQUEST COUNTRY CLEARANCE AND TRAVEL AUTHORITY FOR TWO
(U//FOUO) JANE DOE#1 AND JANE DOE#2 VS US, NO 09-80736
(U

(U) FORWARDING CURRENT PHOTOGRAPHS O
(U) PROVIDING INFORMATION TO THE MIAMI DIVISION RE CO-
(U//FOUO) FOIPA REQUEST
(U//FOUO) BILLIONAIRE PEDOPHILE GOES FREE
(U//FOUO) THE BILLIONAIRE PEDOPHILES SEX DEN
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O
(U//FOUO) JUDSGE RULES EPSTEIN ATTORNEYS CAN SUBPOENA ABORTION RECORDS
(U//FOUO) EX-EPSTEIN WORKER FACES OBSTRUCTION OF JUSTICE

(U) TO REQUEST TRANSFER OF ABOVE CAPTIONED CASE DUE TO
(U//FOUO) DRIVER LICENSE'S INFO
(U//FOUO) INMATE PHONE CALLS LOG
(U//FOUO) WOMEN WANT SEX PLEA DEAL UNSEALED
(U//FOUO) SUIT ACCUSES JAILED TYCOON OF SEX CRIME

(U) LEAD SET TO LEGAT CANBERRA COVERED BY THE SYDNEY SUB
(U) LETTER TOM'
(U//FOUO) WOMAN SUES BILLIONAIRE INVESTOR, SAYS THEY HAD SEX WHEN SHE
(U//FOUO) BILLIONAIRE SEX OFFENDER LEAVES JAIL SIX DAYS A WEEK FOR WOR

(U) LEAD SET TO LEGAT CANBERRA COVERED BY THE SYDNEY SUB
(U) REQUEST AFP DELIVER USAO LETTER TO MS
(W/FOU0) VICTI • ROVIDED WITH USAO LETTER.
(U//FOUO) ARREST: JEFFREY ESPTEIN
(U//FOUO) VICTI • ROVIDED WITH VICTIM
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST HAND DELIVERY OF VICTIM NOTIFICATION
(U) REQUEST AFP'S ASSISTANCE IN DELIVERING A VICTIM NOTIFICATION
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) TO DOCUMENT REQUEST FOR DELIVERY OF VICTIM
(U//FOUO) TO DELIVER VICTIM NOTIFICATION LETTER AND BROCHURES.
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) YOUR NAME WAS REFERRED TO FBI'S VICTIM NOTIFICATION PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) BID TO BURN EPSTEIN PLEA
(U//FOUO) RICH MAN FOUGHT THE LAW AND HE MOSTLY WON
(U//FOUO) PALM BEACHER PLEADS IN SEX CASE
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO
(U//FOUO
(U//FOUO) GIRL SUES EPSTEIN, TWO OTHERS SHE SAYS CONSPIRED IN MASSAGES
(U//FOUO) SEARCH WARRANT
(U//FOUO) SEARCH WARRANT
(U//FOUO) RESPONSE TO LEAD AT MASTIC, NEW YORK, TO INTERVIEW
(U//FOUO
(U//FOUO) TO COVER LEAD SET BY THE MIAMI DIVISION, SERIAL 134
(U//FOUO ELEPHONICALLY CONTACTE,
(U//FOUO AS INTERVIEWED AT THE NEW YORK OFFIC
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) ANOTHER SUIT ALLEGES SEX DURING MASSAGE
(U//FOUO) GIRL DROPS LAWSUIT AGAINST PALM BEACH MAN
(U//FOUO) PART-TIME PALM BEACHER FACES ANOTHER SEX SUIT
(U//FOUO) PALM BEACH MAN FACES LAWSUIT IN TEEN SEX CASE
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O.
(U//FOUO IDENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO DENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O •
(U//FOUO DENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O
(U//FOUO) THIS EC WAS ORIGINALLY SUBMITTED ON 5/1/07 BUT NOT
(U//FOUO) THIS EC WAS ORIGINALLY SUBMITTED ON 5/1/07 BUT NOT
(U//FOUO) TO SET LEADS FOR CAPTIONED INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOUO) DRAFT REQUEST $ 306.50
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST FUNDS FOR EXPENSES ASSOCIATED TO THE
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM RIGHTS
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O1
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O •
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O •
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O •
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O •
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW 0 •
(U//FOUO) INTERIVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW 0 •
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO DENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) NOTICE OF HEARING
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) RE: ANTHON
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) RE: INTELLIGENCE REQUEST RE
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) RE: EXPLOITATION OF MINOR •
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) PLACING 0 0 N WATCH LIST
(U//FOUO) ATTEMPT TO SERVE TARGET LETTER ON TWO FEMALES BY S
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED MATTER.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB-FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED MATTER.
(U//FOUO) RE: LIST OF NATIONS THAT HAVE EXTRADITION TREATIES
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERIVEW 0
(U//FOU0 DENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOU0 DENTIFYING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED MATTER.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST SUPERVISORY SPECIAL AGENT (SSA
(UHFOU0) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST INTELLIGENCE ANALYST (IA
(U//FOU0) INTERVIEW OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U//FOUO) RE: MEETING WIT
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST ASSIGNMENT OF CO-CASE AGENT.
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) RE: UPDATE TO THE CASE
(U//FOUO) DELAYS IN EPSTEIN CASE UNUSUAL LAWYERS SAY
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW Oi
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED MATTER.
(U//FOUO) TO REMOVE WRITER AS CO-CASE AGENT.
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF D'
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O •
(U//FOUO) DRAFT REQUEST FOR $205.00
(U//FOUO) DRAFT REQUEST FOR $18.25
(U//FOUO) TO REPORT RESULTS OF COVERED LEAD.
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O •
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW OF DAVID ROGERS
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST FUNDS FOR EXPENSES ASSOCIATED TO THE ABOVE
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O •
(U//FOUO) TO DOCUMENT ASSISTANCE PROVIDED TO INTELLIGENCE
(U//FOUO) TO SET LEADS FOR CAPTIONED INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW Oi
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIER O1
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O
(UHFOUO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) RE
(UHFOUO) RE
(W/FOUO) RE
(UHFOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST ASSIGNMENT OF CO-CASE AGENT AND SUBMIT
(U//FOUO) INCIDENT REPORT
(U//FOLIO) INTERVIEW O
(U//FOLIO) INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) INTERVIEW O •
(U//FOLIO) REQUEST THAT SP ENIT
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST TRAVEL REFERENCE CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) LEAD COVERED FOR CAPTIONED INVESTIGATION; GRAND JURY
(U//FOUO) TO
(U//FOUO) BILLIONAIRE FACES CHARGE OF SOUCITATION OF MINORS
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST ANALYTICAL ASSISTANCE REGARDING
(U//FOUO) EPSTEIN CAMP CALLS FEMALE ACCUSERS UARS
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) RE: VICTIM ASSISTANCE PROGRAM
(U//FOUO) THE MAN WHO HAD EVERYTHING
(U//FOUO) PALM BEACH CHIEF FOCUS OF FIRE IN EPSTEIN CASE
(U//FOUO) EXPERT: IGNORANCE OF AGE ISN'T DEFENSE IN SEX CHARGES
(U//FOUO) TO DOCUMENT VICTIM INFORMATION. PLEASE REFER TO THE
(U//FOUO) HE WAS 50. AND THEY WERE GIRLS
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB-FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
(U//FOUO) POLICE SAY LAWYER TRIED TO DISCREDIT TEENAGE GIRLS
(U//FOUO) AFTER LONG PROBE BILLIONARE FACES SOUCITATION CHARGE
(U//FOUO) INDICTMENT: BILLIONAIRE SOLICITED 3 TIMES
(U//FOUO) MYSTERY MONEY MAN FACES SOLICITING CHARGE
(U//FOUO) PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAV
(UHFOUO) PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT\JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
SET LEAD FOR CAPTIONED
UT
INVESTIGATION.
1A/1C Rep 31E-MM-108062
Type # Acquired On Serial #
lA Al k 2008-06-20 ISA
lA 145 2008-03-06 254
lA MA 2007-08-15 251
1A 143 2007-08-24 254
1A 142 2006-09-01 254
IA 141 2008-01-01 253
1A 140 2006-01-01 253
IA DI 2006-01-01 253
lA DI 2006-01-01 253
lA 137 2006-01-01 253
lA ilk 2007-01-01 25.1
1A }al 2006-01-01 2.5.2
lA 134 2006-01-01 253
1A 133 2006-01-01 253
lA 132 2006-01-01 253
SA 131 2007-01-01 253
lA 130 2007-01-01 253
1A 129 2006-01-01 253
M aa 2006-01-01 252
lA 127 2006-01-01 152
lA 126 2007-01-01 253
lA 125 2006-01-01 253
lA 124 2006-01-01 252
1A 123 2006-01-01 253
1A 122 2006-01-01 253
1A 121 2006-01-01 253
1A 120 2006-01-01 253
lA na 2007-01-01 al
lA 118 2006-01-01 253
lA 117 2006-01-01 253
1A 11 2008-01-01 252
lA 115 2007-01-01 253
lA 114 2007-01-01 253
lA 113 2006-01-01 253
lA 112 2006-01-01 253
lA 111 2006-01-01 252
IA 110 2006-01-01 253
lA 109 2006-01-01 253
I.A 1Q1 2007-01-01 251
1A 107 2007-01-01 151
lA 106 2006-01-01 253
1A 10S 2006-01-01 2S3
lA 104 2006-01-01 253
1A 103 2006-01-01 253
LA 102 2006-01-01 253
1A 101 2007-01-01 253
1A 144 2007-01-01 251
IA 92 2006-01-01 al
1A 98 2006-01-01 253
lA 92 2008-01-01 251
1A 9 2006-01-01 192
1A 95 2006-01-01 253
LA 94 2007-01-01 253
1A 93 2007-01-01 253
LA 92 2008-01-01 253
lA 91 2011-03-09 252
1A 90 2011-03-18 251
lA 12 2011-03-18 251
1A 9.2 2011-03-17 Z51
lA 87 2011-03-17 251
lA 86 2011-04-26 1
lA 15 2010-05-28 1
lA 84 2008-05-29 1
LA 83 2008-03-24 1
1A 82 2007-09-28 1
1A al 2008-01-15 1
lA 14 2008-04-22 1
lA 79 2009-06-10 1
lA 78 2008-04-07 1
lA ZZ 2008-03-17 1
lA 76 2008-03-20 1
LA 75 2008-03-25 1
lA 74 2008-04-21 1
LA n 2008-03-19 1
lA 21 2008-02-06 1
lA 71 2008-02-25 1
lA 70 2008-02-25 1
1A §.2 2007-12-03 1
lA 68 2007-11-28 1
LA 67 2007-11-02 1
LA 66 2007-11-02 1
LA 65 2007-10-19 1
1A 2007-10-02 1
LA 63 2007-10-02 1
1A 62 2007-09-06 1
1A §.1 2007-08-23 1
1A EQ 2007-08-07 1
lA 59 2007-08-07 1
1A 58 2007-08-07 1
lA 57 2007-03-22 1
1A 56 2007-06-25 1
1A 55 2007-06-04 1
1A 54 2007-06-04 1
1A 51 2007-03-19 1
IA 5/ 2007-07-02 1
1A 51 2007-07-10 1
14 3,Q 2007-06-27 1
1A la 2007-06-14 1
IA 48 2007-06-05 1
IA 47 2007-05-29 1
IA 4.6 2007-05-23 1
IA 45 2007-05-18 1
14 44 2007-05-08 1
14 43 2007-05-04 1
IA 42 2007-05-04 1
1A 41 2007-04-30 1
14 ao 2007-04-19 1
1A 39 2007-04-19 1
lA 34 2007-04-19 1
14 37 2007-04-17 1
lA 36 2007-04-07 1
1A 35 2007-04-10 1
IA 34, 2007-04-10 1
14 11 2007-04-09 1
14 32 2007-04-05 1
lA 31 2007-04-05 _1
IA 32 2007-04-04
m 29 2007-04-03 1
m 28 2007-04-03 1
14 27 2007-03-28 1
1A 26 2007-03-26 1
14 5 2007-03-23 1
14 24 2007-03-21 1
14 23 2007-02-26 1
14 34 2007-02-22 1
lA 21 2007-02-09 1
14 20 2007-01-24 1
1A 19 2007-01-24 1
lA 18 2007-01-16 1
14 17 2007-01-10 1
14 16 2007-01-10 1
14 15 2007-01-03 1
IA 1.4 2006-11-17 1
14 1,1 2006-10-23 1
lA 12 2006-08-31 1
14 11 2006-08-30 1
1A 10 2006-08-08 1
14 9 2006-08-08 1
LA 8 2007-02-28 1
1A 7 2007-02-22 1
1A i 2007-03-05 1
IA a 2007-03-02 1
LA 4 2007-02-08 1
lA 2 2007-03-01 1
lA 2 2006-12-13 1
IA 1 2006-08-18 1
Serial Title

(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.
(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.

(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.
(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.

(U) EC for submission of Administrative Subpoena returns to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.

(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) EC for submission of victim/witness work files to case file.
(U) Items received fro
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(W/FOU0) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOLIO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST CASE BE OPENED AND ASSIGNED.
Summary

(U) T-Mobile USA, Inc Subscriber Information
(U) At& Subscriber and Toll Information
(U) Bell South Subscriber and Toll Information

(U) Metro P. Subscriber Information
(U) Palm Beach County Health Department - Certificate of Birth fo
do• : • (U) Biographical files fo • o • n •

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information, and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information, and original notes fo

(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file fo do •
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information, and original notes fo

(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file and MySpace information fo
(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file fo

(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file, and MySpace information fo
(U) Biographical file fo

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information, and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file and MySpace information fo

(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file and MySpace information fo

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file and original notes fo

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file and original notes fo

(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file, and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file, and MySpace information fo

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes fo

(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical files and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file and original notes fo

(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file, and MySpace information fo

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes fo

(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file fo

(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes fo
(U) Biographical file fo do
(U) Biographical file, MySpace information and original notes fo

(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Biographical file fo
(U) Items received from attorne

(U) ITM Massage school certification fo nd FD-597
(U) 20 photographs received fro^ nd FD-597.
(U) Original notes re interview o
(U) Photo array shown t .
(U//FOUO) A COPY OF NON-PROSECUTION AGREEMENT
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL GJ SUBPOENA SERVED ON MARIA LACORDA
(U//FOUO) CELLULAR RECORDS FOR JENNIFER ARNOLD
(U//FOU0) RESULTS OF ADMIN SUB FO' , N,
(U//FOUO) CELLULAR RECORDS FO • 003 AN
(U//FOUO) CELLULAR RECORDS FROM AT&T FO
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN RESULTS
(U//FOU0) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR TELEPHONE
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FO
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0 ATED 03/20/2008
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0 ATED 3/25/08
(U//FOUO) SUPBOENA RESULTS FOR GANN MURRAY, KITTY BENSKY AN
(U//FOUO) ONE 597 RECEIPT FOR 2 YEAR BOULES FROM WELUNGTON HS
(U//FOUO) 2 597 PROPERTY RECEIPTS DOCUMENTARY PROPERTY RELEASE AND RECEIPT OF HARD DRIVE
(U//FOUO) POUCE REPORT FROM PBPD RE: JENNIFER AMEROLD AN
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL PB POLICE INTELLIGENCE REPORT DATED 03/05/2004
(U//FOUO) A COPY OF BILL AND PAYMENT TO AMERICAN EXPRESS FOR FINANCIALRECORDS
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW Oi
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW Oi
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 01
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 01
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 01
(U//FOUO) FD-597 MASSAGE FOR DUMMIES - BOOK
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0.
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW OF 1 2) EMAIL AND ATTACH PHOTOS FRO
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0'
(U//FOUO) RESULTS FROM ADIN SUBPOENA FOR CINGULAR I
(U//FOUO) ADMINSTRATIVE SUBPOENA RESULTS FROM CINGULAR RE
(U//FOUO) JETBLUE RECORDS REGARDIN c RAVEL
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FROM JETBLUE RE
(W/FOU0) CORPORATE RECORD RE: JEGE INC AND HYPERION AIR INS
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE:
(UHFOU0) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0 •
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE: AND
(U//FOUO) RECORDING (AUDIO I 24-2007
(U//FOUO) CERTIFIED COPIES OF TECS RECORDS
(U//FOUO) F0597 RE
. •(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO AND CD-R RE:
(U//FOUO) CINGULAR RECORDS FOF Isl 0
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE: 561 656-1947; 561 333-0225; 561 655-2779;
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE:
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN INFORMATION RE:
(U//FOUO) A COPY OF SPRINT EMAIL SENT TO RENTE RE ZADIS PHONE RECORDS
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS NEGATIVE FROM TIME WARNER
(U//FOUO) ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA RESULTS FROM TIME WARNER
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE:
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO RE: 2) ADDITIONAL FAXES REC- EIVED ON 02-27-007, 02-28-2007, AN
(U//FOUO) ADMIN SUBPOENA RETURN MATERIALS RE:
(U//FOUO) ADMIN SUBPOENA RETURN MATERIALS RE:
(U//FOLIO) ADMIN SUBPOENA RETURN RESULTS RE: AND 561 333- 0225
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FO JEFFREY EPSTEIN
(U//FOUO) ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA FOR CINGULAR/ATT RE ND RESULTS
(UHFOU0) JETBLUE SUBPOENA RESULTS
-(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER INFO AND TELL RECORDS RE:
(U//FOLIO) PHOTOGRAPH SHOWN T•
(U//FOLIO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR INFORMATION O ELL ULAR TELEPHONE-SPRINT/NEX1
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOR EPSTEIN AND COMPANY
(U//FOLIO) ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA REGARDING CINGULAR #
(U//FOUO) RESULT OF SUBPOENA DATED 12-22-2006
(U//FOLIO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FO • SUBSCRIBER INFO ONLY)
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FO • N 0
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW 0
(U//FOUO) ADMIN SUBPOENA FOR CINGULAR RE AND RESULTS
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FO •
(U//FOUO) 1 CD CONTAINING TOLL RECORDS FRO ND DOCUMENTATION
(U//FOUO) ADMIN SUBPOENA RESULTS FROM CINGULAR RE 561 32
(U//FOLIO) RUSULTS FROM CINGULAR RE #S I ADMINIS
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FO. 0 • 61 596-4700
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESULTS FOi N , ELEPHONE
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN RE:
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN MATERIALS RE:
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RESUTIS RE: MYSPACE.COM USER ID 20425696
(U//FOUO) 1) HARD COPY AND CD-ROM SUBPOENA RETURN RESULTS FOR MYSPACE ID WS 60688973, 65739018,
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW O1
(U//FOUO) SUBPOENA RETURN MATERIALS RE: FRIEDN ID NUMBERS 60688973, 65739018, 65739759, 2042596,1
(U//FOUO) ORIGINAL NOTES RE INTERVIEW O'
(U//FOUO) PHOTO LINE UP POSITIVE ID O
-4-07; 3) PHOTOCOPIESOi .CRAPBOOK ITEMS
Serial Rep; 31E-MM-108062-FF
Serial # Date
IQ 10/20/2022 14:26
9 9/18/2008 0:00
a 2/11/2008 0:00
Z 5/1/2007 0:00
6 5/1/2007 0:00
5 4/4/2007 0:00
4 4/5/2007 0:00
A 3/23/2007 0:00
2 11/6/2006 0:00
1 8/1/2006 0:00
Title
(U) Request Closure of FF subfile
(U//FOUO) REQUEST CLOSING OF FORFEITURE SUBFILE FF.
(U//FOUO) REPORT STATUS OF FORFEITURE INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOUO) DRAFT $340.00 CERTIFIED COPY OF CORPORATE RECORDS
(U//FOUO) DRAFT $946.00 CERTIFIED COPY OF CORPORATE RECORDS
(U//FOUO) UPDATED OWNERSHIP/ENCUMBRANCE REPORT FOR 358 EL BRILLO WAY
(U//FOUO) DRAFT $150.00 TITLE SEARCH
(U//FOLIO) TO UPDATE STATUS OF FORFEITURE INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOLIO) TO UPDATE STATUS OF FORFEITURE INVESTIGATION.
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB-FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
Sedalitept_31E-MM-108062-61
Serial* Date Title Synopsis
a ######## (U)XXXXX)0000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
45 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (J))000000000(
44 ######## (U))000000(XX (1))000000000(
42 ######## (U)XXXXX)0000( (U))0000000OCK
42 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
41 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
40 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
39 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
38 ######## (U)XXXXXX)000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
37 ######## (U)XXXX)000(XX (U)XXXXXXXXXX
lfi ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
31 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
34 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
33 ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
31 ######## (U))000000(X00( (U))000000000(
31 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
30 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
29 ######## (U))00000000( (U)XXXXX)D000(
22 ######## (u))000000000( (U))000000000(
27 ######## (U)XXXX)000(XX (U)XXXXXXXXXX
26 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
25 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
24 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXX)000(
23 ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
22 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
21 ########
########
Mitt tlittt tin
tt$$#$$####
#0#0014##
(U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
20 (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
19 (U)XXXXXXXXXX (U) XXXXXXXXXX
18 (U) XXXXXXXXMC (U) XXXXXXXXXX
17 (U)X00000000( (U) XXXXXXXX)0(
lfi########04)00000000( (U)XXXX)00000(
15 ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
14 ######## (U))000000000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
13 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
12 ######## (U))000000)00( (U))000000000(
11 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
10 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
9 ######## (U)XXXX)00000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
I ######## (U)XXXX)C0000( (U)XXXXXXXXXX
7 ######## (U)XXXXX)0000( (U)XXXX)00000(
6 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
5 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
4 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(
3 ######## (U))000000000( (U))000000000(

╭───────────────────────────────────────────────────── Page 187, Image 1 
──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ [Serial Repe 31£-MM-108062-G)                                                                                         
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ Serial# Date _—‘Title                                                                                                 
│
│ AHHHHHE(U) XXX                                                                                                        
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ HHH (U) XXX                                                                                                           
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXNX                                                                                                   
│
│ HAHAH (UL) XXX                                                                                                        
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXHK                                                                                                   
│
│ AHHHAAHE (UL) XXX                                                                                                     
│
│ AIEEE (U) XXXXXXXXXX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHHH (U0) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXXYX                                                                                                  
│
│ HAE (U) XXXOXXXHK                                                                                                     
│
│ AHHHHAEHE (UL) XXXXXXXXYX                                                                                             
│
│ HRHAHAHE (UL) XXX                                                                                                     
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXKAX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXNX                                                                                                    
│
│ HHH (U) XXX                                                                                                           
│
│ AHRHHHHE (UL) XXXXXXXXHK                                                                                              
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AIEEE (U) XXXXXXXXXK                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHR (U) XXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                    
│
│ sna (U) XXXXXXXXYX                                                                                                    
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (UL) XXXXHXXXOX                                                                                                  
│
│ HAHAH (U) XXX                                                                                                         
│
│ AIEEE (U) XXXXXXXXXK                                                                                                  
│
│ HAHAH (U) XXX                                                                                                         
│
│ AHHH (U) XXX                                                                                                          
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                  
│
│ AHHH (U) XXXXXXXKHX                                                                                                   
│
│ AHR (U) XXXXXXXXHX                                                                                                    
│
│ AnH (U) XXX                                                                                                           
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ fs fe ier ton iss fom yo FS TS US 1S DS en Pon IS Ut JR3 IPS IS P03 ISR IER USS Ube IB PS Ue US IS eh IS es 8 IS IA IS
IB NG │
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ Synopsis                                                                                                              
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAK                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX000XX                                                                                                          
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXXX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X9000000XX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) 9000000KX                                                                                                         
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X900000KKX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXXX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X900000KXX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X9000000XX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) X20                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAK                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAK                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X000000KX                                                                                                         
│
│ (U) X9000000XX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) 0000000KX                                                                                                         
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXXK                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X9000000KX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) X900000KX                                                                                                         
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXXX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX0000X                                                                                                          
│
│ (U) XXXXXXXXAX                                                                                                        
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
│ (U) XXX                                                                                                               
│
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
───────╯

1
#,MMIMIN
NUNN
(U) X)00000000(
(U) XXXXXXXXXX
(U))00000000M
(U) XXXXXXXXXX
SA/1C Rep 31E-MM-108062-0
Type Acquired On Serial # Serial Title
1C 2 2007-07-18 M (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1C 1 2006-08-18 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 41 2008-07-26 42 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 42 2008-05.14 IQ (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 41 2008-06-05 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 40 2008-03-12 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 39 2008-03-12 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 38 2007-09-25 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 37 2007-09-10 IM (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 36 2007-07-16 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A ii 2007-07-22 42 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 34 2007-08-09 .1¢ (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 33 2007-06-08 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 32 2007-06-13 46 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A n 2007-05-29 IN (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
a 30 2008-05-29 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
a 29 2006-08-31 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 28 2007-11-30 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 27 2007-07-10 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
m a 2007-06-27 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 25 2007-06-25 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 24 2007-06-22 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
IA 21 2006-08-01 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 22 2007-05-03 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 21 2007-04-30 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 20 2007-04-25 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 19 2007-04-16 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M a 2007-04-09 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 17 2007-04-03 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 16 2007-03-16 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A a 2007-02-02 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
lA 14 2007-01-23 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
a 13 2006-11-27 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 12 2006-11-09 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
a 11 2006-11-07 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 12 2006-09-29 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 9 2006-09-15 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M 8 2006-09-04 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
M Z 2006-08-30 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A A 2006-08-18 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 5 2006-08-24 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 4 2006-08-17 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 3 2006-08-15 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 2 2006-08-15 1 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
1A 1 2006-08-11 (U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
Serial Re • 31E-MM-108062-SBP
Serial # Date
E 6/9/2009 0:00
86 6/9/2009 0:00
$.4 4/11/2008 0:00
M 4/1/2008 0:00
83 2/25/2008 0:00
82 2/25/2008 0:00
81 2/22/2008 0:00
N 12/22/2006 0:00
79 5/17/2007 0:00
0:00
0:00
78 8/1/2006
ZZ 8/1/2006
Zfi 8/8/2007 0:00
75 8/5/2007 0:00
74 8/8/2007 0:00
LI 8/14/2007 0:00
72 8/14/2007 0:00
71 5/17/2007 0:00
70 5/17/2007 0:00
i2 6/22/2007 0:00
4.1 6/22/2007 0:00
67 6/22/2007 0:00
66 6/22/2007 0:00
il 6/22/2007 0:00
64 6/22/2007 0:00
63 6/22/2007 0:00
62 6/22/2007 0:00
61 6/22/2007 0:00
0 6/22/2007 0:00
59 1/15/2007 0:00
58 1/15/2007 0:00
51 1/4/2007 0:00
56 3/28/2007 0:00
55 3/28/2007 0:00
54 3/28/2007 0:00
53 3/28/2007 0:00
52 3/28/2007 0:00
51 4/10/2007 0:00
50 4/10/2007 0:00
42 4/10/2007 0:00
M 4/10/2007 0:00
47 4/10/2007 0:00
46 3/28/2007 0:00
45 3/28/2007 0:00
44 6/22/2007 0:00
43 6/22/2007 0:00
42 2/16/2007 0:00
,ll 12/22/2006 0:00
N 12/22/2006 0:00
39 12/22/2006 0:00
la 8/1/2006 0:00
31 8/1/2006 0:00
36 8/1/2006 0:00
35 3/28/2007 0:00
34 6/22/2007 0:00
33 6/22/2007 0:00
32 6/22/2007 0:00
31 6/22/2007 0:00
IQ 6/22/2007 0:00
22 6/22/2007 0:00
28 6/22/2007 0:00
27 6/22/2007 0:00
LO. 3/7/2007 0:00
25 2/26/2007 0:00
24 2/21/2007 0:00
23 3/1/2007 0:00
22 3/2/2007 0:00
al 3/1/2007 0:00
20 2/21/2007 0:00
19 2/21/2007 0:00
la 6/22/2007 0:00
17 6/22/2007 0:00
16 6/22/2007 0:00
15 6/22/2007 0:00
14 6/22/2007 0:00
ti 6/22/2007 0:00
12 6/22/2007 0:00
11 6/22/2007 0:00
12 6/22/2007 0:00
9 6/22/2007 0:00
8 6/22/2007 0:00
7 6/22/2007 0:00
6 6/22/2007 0:00
a 6/22/2007 0:00
4 6/22/2007 0:00
3 6/22/2007 0:00
2 9/1/2006 0:00
1 8/1/2006 0:00
Title
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE PHONE AND TOLL RECORDS
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE TOLL RECORDS AND SUBSCRIBER INFORMATION ON 917-855-3
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE BILLING AND TOLL INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION FOR
(U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION FOR
(U//FOUO) PROVIDE SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION FOR
(U//FOLIO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) RE:SUBPOENA
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNTING AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
(U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR AU. ACCOUNT AND BIWNG INFORMATION
(U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB•FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
Case Number.
Case Summary:
90A-NY-3151227
On 02/28/2025, FBI-NYO opened case 90A-NY-3151227, a death investigation case on 08/12/2019 after
JEFFERY EPSTEIN was discovered unresponsive in his jail cell at MCC on 08/10/2019. Two Correctional
Officers were indicted for false records and conspiracy and subsequently self-surrendered to the FBI on
11/19/2019. In May 2021, SDNY entered a deferred prosecution agreement with the two Correctional
Officers for a period of 6 months and the terms were satisfied. 90C-NY-3154599 is a contraband at MCC
case in which EPSTEIN is referenced. 9A-NY-3144791 is a threat to victim case in which EPSTEIN is
referenced.
Serial Repc90A-NY-3151227
Serial * Date
211 2/28/2025 18:02
210 2/28/2025 18:02
2Q2 2/28/2025 17:14
VI 2/28/2025 15:32
207 7/2/2024 5:11
206 6/25/2024 13:19
205 5/31/2024 13:16
204 12/5/2022 15:25
203 9/21/2022 11:54
202 9/19/2022 14:25
241 8/1/2022 7:40
2.(V 7/8/2022 7:55
199 6/6/202210:25
198 5/10/2022 9:49
197 5/3/202216:07
196 2/3/2022 13:22
195 1/31/2022 14:31
194 11/22/2021 13:01
i1,₹ 9/2/20219:22
1.9.7, 7/26/2021 12:18
191 5/25/2021 16:15
190 3/4/202113:29
2,12 3/4/202113:28
188 10/14/2020 13:35
187 9/17/202015:39
186 9/10/2020 16:00
185 9/4/2020 13:12
1M 7/31/2020 10:41
183 7/31/2020 8:51
182 2/4/202010:49
111, 12/23/2019 15:14
180 12/23/2019 15:12
179 12/23/2019 15:10
178 12/20/2019 12:49
177 12/20/2019 12:48
rfi 12/20/2019 11:22
175 12/20/2019 11:22
174 12/19/2019 14:58
171 12/19/2019 14:57
212 12/19/2019 14:55
171 12/19/2019 14:48
170 12/19/2019 14:48
169 12/19/2019 14:47
168 12/13/2019 14:25
167 12/13/2019 14:25
166 12/13/2019 14:24
IQ 12/13/2019 14:24
4 12/13/2019 14:24
163 12/13/2019 14:08
1.62 12/13/2019 14:07
161 12/11/2019 13:39
160 8/29/2019 11:20
159 12/5/2019 12:36
158 12/4/2019 12:03
157 11/22/2019 9:15
156 11/22/2019 9:15
155 11/21/2019 14:27
&I 11/20/2019 13:37
2.5.1 11/19/2019 8:32
152 10/29/2019 10:09
151 10/15/2019 12:43
150 10/10/2019 16:16
149 2/5/2020 9:46
148 10/9/2019 9:14
147 10/9/2019 9:13
IA 10/3/2019 9:08
10/3/2019 9:02
144 10/3/2019 9:02
143 10/2/2019 11:57
112. 9/26/2019 15:45
141 9/26/2019 14:34
140 9/25/2019 10:18
139 9/25/2019 10:17
138 9/25/2019 10:17
13/ 9/25/2019 10:16
136 9/25/2019 10:15
135 9/25/2019 10:12
14 9/25/2019 10:12
133 9/25/2019 10:11
132 9/24/2019 16:01
131 9/24/2019 15:31
130 9/24/2019 14:15
la 9/24/2019 14:12
128 9/24/2019 10:06
127 9/24/2019 10:06
332 9/24/201910:03
M 9/24/2019 9:34
124 9/23/2019 16:15
123 9/23/2019 16:15
122 9/23/2019 15:41
121 9/18/2019 12:54
120 9/18/2019 12:46
119 9/18/2019 12:28
.1a 9/13/2019 14:08
117 9/13/2019 12:46
116 9/11/2019 11:24
jaa 9/10/2019 13:41
114 9/10/2019 11:23
113 9/10/2019 9:02
112 9/10/2019 9:02
in 9/9/201916:28
110 9/9/2019 16:24
109 9/9/2019 16:23
108 9/9/2019 16:23
122 9/9/201916:23
122 9/9/2019 16:22
105 9/9/2019 16:21
104 9/9/2019 16:19
103 9/9/2019 16:06
102 9/9/2019 16:02
101 9/9/201915:59
100 9/9/2019 15:58
22 9/4/2019 17:30
22 9/6/2019 10:08
97 9/6/201910:08
96 9/6/201910:08
22 9/6/201910:07
94 9/6/2019 10:07
93 9/6/2019 10:07
92 9/6/2019 10:07
91 9/6/201910:06
22 9/6/2019 10:06
22 9/6/2019 10:06
88 9/6/201910:05
22 9/6/2019 10:05
86 9/6/201910:05
85 9/6/201910:04
84 9/6/201910:04
83 9/6/201910:04
21 9/6/2019 10:04
81 9/6/2019 8:42
80 9/6/2019 8:42
Z2 9/6/2019 8:41
22 9/6/2019 8:41
77 9/6/2019 8:40
76 9/5/201916:25
75 9/5/2019 9:28
74 9/5/2019 9:28
73 9/4/201914:53
72 9/4/2019 14:51
71 9/3/2019 9:31
LQ 9/3/2019 9:30
69 8/30/2019 13:50
§1 8/29/2019 9:28
§1 8/29/2019 9:23
66 8/29/2019 9:19
65 8/29/2019 8:19
64 8/28/2019 16:51
e 8/28/201916:50
62 8/28/2019 16:47
61 8/27/2019 17:04
22 8/27/2019 14:20
a 8/27/2019 14:19
58 8/26/2019 16:18
57 8/26/201914:04
56 8/26/2019 13:55
55 8/26/2019 12:31
M 8/22/2019 11:08
53 8/22/2019 11:07
5/ 8/22/2019 7:00
5.1. 8/22/2019 6:59
50 8/21/2019 9:54
49 8/21/2019 9:40
g 8/21/2019 9:18
47 8/20/2019 14:11
46 8/20/2019 13:37
45 8/19/2019 16:05
44 8/19/201915:00
AI 8/19/2019 14:32
42 8/16/2019 16:25
41 8/16/201916:20
41 8/16/2019 16:02
39 8/16/2019 15:54
38 8/16/201915:44
37 8/16/2019 15:37
36 8/16/2019 15:31
g 8/16/2019 14:50
34 8/16/2019 14:50
33 8/16/2019 14:49
12 8/16/2019 14:49

3. 8/16/2019 12:18
30 8/16/2019 11:47
29 8/16/2019 11:45
28 8/16/2019 11:17
27 8/16/2019 10:46
26 8/16/201910:45
25 8/15/2019 17:05
24 8/15/2019 14:46
a 8/15/2019 14:45
22 8/15/2019 13:26
21 8/14/2019 14:22
20 8/14/2019 14:21
19 8/14/201914:20
18 8/14/2019 14:19
17 8/14/2019 14:18
16 8/14/2019 14:18
15 8/14/2019 14:17
14 8/14/2019 14:15
U 8/14/2019 14:14
12 8/14/2019 14:14
11 8/14/2019 14:14
10 8/14/2019 14:13
2 8/14/2019 14:13
8 8/14/2019 14:12
7 8/14/2019 14:11
6 8/14/2019 14:11
5 8/14/2019 14:10
4 8/14/2019 14:10
3 8/14/2019 9:09
2 8/14/2019 9:08
i 8/12/2019 10:26
Title

(U) Evidence Control Unit (ECU) Policy Note
(U) Item returned from OIG
(U) Restart chain of custody
(U) OIG return of evidence

(U) FO-1004
(U) UNSUB(S); JEFFREY EPSTEIN - VICTIM; DEATH INVESTIGATION
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC033797

(U) Closing Communication
(U) Evidence Chain of Custody for Items 1637 and 1B38
(U) Release of Evidence to the Office of the Inspector General (OIG)

(U) FW:
(U) Name check response - SAMAR CHANTELE ANDREA
(U) 1A Import
(U) AUSA Evidence Email - Concurrence

(U) Release of Evidence to the Office of the Inspector General (OIG)
(U) Deferred Prosecution Agreement
(U) FW: Charged Out Evidence Coming Due

(U) FW: Evidence Recharge
(U) Request# HQQ190816001 TB
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC026022

(U) Email threat to TOVA NOEL
(U) Intake Screening Phone Log
(U) Interview of Hughwon Daniel
(U) 90A-NY-3151227 1B2 through 1618 Continuation chain use

(U) 2020-01577-1 Questioned Documents
(U) Response from FBI Laboratory Forensic Document Examiner
(U) Name check response - CARLOS MANUEL PEREZ

(U) Request to send Evidence to Laboratory for Handwriting Analysis
(U) Request for Laboratory Examinations

(U) Psychology report and interview notes
(U) Interview of Miguel Monge
(U) Interview of Darrius Dupree
(U) Interview oflohn MARRUGO

(U) Proffer of Jason Mojica
(U) Proffer of Christian Perez
(U) Proffer of Freddy Caraballo
(U) Proffer of Carlos Sanchez-Galan

(U) Interview of Roberto Grijalva
(U) Interview of Dr. Imeri
(U) Interview of Clyde Washington
(U) Glenda ANDERSON-LAYNE Interview

(U) Steven LOPEZ Interview
(U) Interview o
(U) Daily Assignment Log for Tova Noel
(U) Work Schedules for Michael Thomas

(U) Letter to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner Regarding the Autopsy of Jeffrey Epstein
(U) OIG Forms Provided by OIG

(U) 016 Forms Provided by 016 SAS
(U) Transcription of Recorded Interview of Lamine N'Diaye
(U) Memorandum of Investigation Regarding the Interview of Saadiq Shakir
—

(U) 90A-NY-3151227 SID 223558 Process Report
(U) Interview o
(U) Suspicious Activity Report Received from JP Morgan Chase Regarding Tova Noel

(U) Email Documenting Call with Warden James Petrucci
(U) Arrest of TOVA NOEL and MICHAEL THOMAS
(U) Indictment of TOVA NOEL and MICHAEL THOMAS

(U) CART Process Report for CART Submission ID:218509
(U) CART Archive designated as NYF01278
(U) Email Summarizing Conversation with Medical Examiner on November 14, 2019

(U) Jeffrey Epstein's Probate Petition and Will
(U) Suicide Training Documents for Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoenas Served t
(U) Serial Moved - See Details for Justification
(U) Job Descriptions for Control Post at Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Letter Received from Metropolitan Correctional Center
(U) Form 583 Report of Incident Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC) Special Housing Unit (SHU) Video Review II
(U) Email to OCME Requesting Documents and Photographs Pertaining to this Investigation

(U) Interview of GHITTO BONHOMME
(U) Metropolitan Correctional Center Staff Rosters for July 23 - August 8, 2019

(U) Computer Analysis Provided by OIG
(U) MCC Suicide Watch 2nd Floor Drawing
(U) MCC 10th Floor Drawing

(U) MCC 9th and 10th Floor Drawing
(U) Picture of Tova Noel
(U) Picture of Michael Thomas
(U) MCC Annual Refresher Training

(U) MCC Bed Assignments for Epstein
(U) SHU Inmate Log for August 9 and 10
(U) MCC Documents Regarding Epstein

(U) Counts and Count Slips for August 10, 2019
(U) Photograph of Homemade Rope from July 23, 2019 Incident

(U) TruView Documents Provided by Office of the Inspector General
(U) Phone Records for MCC Caller Station 6385

(U) Phone Records for MCC Caller Station 6317
(U) Interview of BO
(U) Evidence Return
(U) MCC Duty Officer Supplement

(U) 016 Referral - OIA-2019-05324
(U) Proffer of RAYSHAUN JONES
(U) NDA with SigNet Technologies Inc
(U) MCC Count Slips for July 23, 2019 to August 9, 2019

(U) Interview of GHITTO BONHOMME
(U) Documentation of MCC Special Housing Unit
(U) Email Provided by Dr. lmeri Regarding Epstein Needing a Cellmate

(U) Interview of Samantha DiMisa
(U) 90A-NY-3151227 Process Report
(U) Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of the City of New York Autopsy Report

(U) 30 Minute Round Sheet for MCC ZB on July 27 and 29, 2019
(U) Information Provided by Office of the Inspector General Regarding Job Descriptions at MCC

(U) Memorandum from SO egarding Jeffrey Epstein's Celimate
(U) Emails from MCC Regarding Suicide Watch and Psychological Observation of Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Memorandum by Lt egarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) MCC Count Slips for August 10, 2019
(U) Document Provided Regarding MCC 30 Minute Rounds on August 10, 2019

(U) Document Provided Regarding MCC 30 Minute Rounds for August 6, 2019.
(U) Document Provided Regarding MCC 30 Minute Rounds on August 5, 2019.

(U) Email Regarding MCC Staff Assignments on August 10, 2019
(U) Documents Provided Regarding 30 Minute Rounds at Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Photographs of Jeffrey Epstein provided by BOP
(U) Proffer of ANGEL ARROYO
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Supplemental To Jeffrey E Epstein Arrest on July 06, 2019
(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Medical Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Psychology Notes from July 8, 2019 Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Psychology Notes from July 9, 2019 Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Psychology Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein

(U) Sentry Documentation for Jeffrey Epstein
(U) MCC Staff Emergency Contacts
(U) Staff Roster for MCC on 8/10/2019

(U) Staff Roster for MCC on 8/9/2019
(U) TRU-SCOPE Logs Provided by BOP
(U) Documents provided by 8OP SIS Lt. Doctor regarding 30 Minute Rounds

(U) Documents provided by BOP SIS Lt. Doctor regarding 30 Minute Rounds
(U) Documents provided by BOP SIS Lt. Doctor regarding 30 Minute Rounds

(U) Additional Psychology Notes Regarding Jeffrey Epstein
(U) Jeffrey Epstein Investigative Reports
(U) Interview of KIMANA CALE

(U) Interview of ROSALIND SILVIA
(U) Interview of FREDERICO RANCIER-MEDRANO
(U) Interview of Corrections Office

(U) Interview of DR. KARI SCHLESSINGER
(U) Evidence return concurrence
(U) Interview of JOHNNY CONTRERAS

(U) Interview of S'amar C. Andrea
(U) Interview of DR. ELISSA MILLER
(U) Interview of MARQUEA RICE
(U) Interview of PERRY JOYNER

(U) Interview of Michael Cannata
(U) Return of Property belonging to MICHAEL THOMAS
(U) Proffer of EFRAIN REYES

(U) Office of Inspector General (OIG) Forms Provided by OIG Special Agent (SA
(U) CART Master Copy designated as NYC025654

(U) LEONARDO FERNANDEZ Interview
(U) Photo Log for Photos 41-67 of METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
(U) Interview of STANLEY JEAN

(U) Documentation of FedEx shipment for original OIG waiver signed by James Darden
(U) 90A-NY-3151227 MDUS #10754

(U) Device Extraction - MDUS 10754
(U) Request for Laboratory Examinations
(U) Receipt of Apple iPhone XS, IMEI#: 357208091738649

(U) Receipt of Apple iPhone XS
(U) Proffer Interview of
(U) Database Checks - Robert Charles Adams
(U) Database Checks - Persons of Interest

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC023596
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC023597

(U) Proffer Interview of COREY LATIMER
(U) Chain of Custody- Digital Evidence Laboratory - Items 1B20, 1B21

(U) Interview of Edward Jimenez (79466-054)
(U) FD-597/ Items 1B20, 1B21
(U) INTERVIEW OF MCC INMATE CHRISTOPHER SANTOS FEUX

(U) Submission of Video Evidence from Metropolitan Correctional Center, NY NY
(U) Items 1837, 1838 transfer to NY OCME

(U) 08/10/2019 Evidence from MCC and Lt. Doctor
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027715
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027714

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027713
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027712

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027711
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027710

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027709
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027708

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027707
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027706

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027705
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027704

(U) Interview of NATHANIEL BULLOCK
(U) Search - Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC), Special Housing Unit, L-Tier, Cell 220

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027703
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC027702

(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO27701
(U) Interview ofiermaine Darden
(U) Seizure of DVR Controller and DVR System #1

(U) Seizure of hard Drives Associated with DVR #2
(U) Seizure of DVR System #2
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23595

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23594
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23593
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23592

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23591
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23590
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23589

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23588
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23587
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23586

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23585
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23584
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23583

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23582
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23581
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23580

(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23579
(U) Submission of CART Evidence NYCO23578
(U) Interview of BOP Med .
(U) Initial Review of EPSTEIN Inmate Records with Lieutenant Doctor (BOP)
(U) Opening EC
1A/1C Report for Case: 90A-NY-3151227
Type # Acquired On Serial #
lA 100 2024-06-25 2Q2
lA 99 2024-05-31 205
1A 11 2022.09-21 241
1A 91 2022-09-14 242
1A 96 2022-05-03 199
1A 95 2022-05-03 197
1A 94 2022-01-12 196
1A a 2021-06-16 193
1A U 2021-07-23 192
1A 91 2021-05-24 191
lA IQ 2021-05-24 121
1A 2020-03-12
lA AI 2020-09-17 187
Ilk
182
1A 9/ 2020-09-02
lA 86 2019-09-11
lA 85 2019-08-21 181
1A 94 2019-08-23 1Q
LA 83 2019-08-26 179
IA 82 2019-12-19 178
1A a 2019-12-19 177
LA AQ 2019-12-19 a¢
1A 79 2019-12-19 175
1A 31 2019-08-20 124
1A ZZ 2019-08-21 123
1A 76 2019-08-19 172
LA 75 2019-08-14 171
1A 74 2019-08-20 170
1A Z1 2019-09-25 169
1A 72 2019-12-11 163
1A 71 2019-12-11 162
1A ZQ 2019-11-19 152
1A AA 2019-11-19 15E
1A 68 2019-09-18 151
1A 67 2019-08-15 150
1A 33 2019-08-15 148
1A 65 2019-09-26 147
1A 64 2019-09-26 147
1A 63 2019-09-30 145
1A 32 2019-09-30 Al a
LA 31 2019-09-25 142
la 60 2019-08-13 131
1A 59 2019-08-13 129
1A 51 2019-08-30 123
1A 57 2019-09-24 125
1A 56 2019-08-28 122
1A 55 2019-09-11 119
LA 54 2019-08-17 118
lA 52 2019-09-06 113
1A 52 2019-08-28 114
lA 51 2019-08-12 112
1A 52 2019-08-11 1Q2
la 41 2019-08-10 102
la 48 2019-08-26 101
LA 47 2019-08-17 100
la 46 2019-08-12 100
LA 45 2019-08-28 33
lA 44 2019-08-23 80
la 43 2019-08-20 79
la 43 2019-08-15 21
1A 41 2019-08-28 LZ
1A 48 2019-08-16 77
1A 39 2019-08-16 77
1A 38 2019-08-30 76
1A 37 2019-08-30 76
IA 36 2019-09-03 74
IA 35 2019-08-29 73
1A M 2019-08-29 Za
IA 55 2019-08-29 231A 32 2019-08-29 73
1A 3.1 2019-08-29 22
1A IQ 2019-08-29 22
1A 29 2019-08-29 72
1A 28 2019-08-29 71
1A 27 2019-08-29 70
1A 26 2019-08-21 69
1A 25 2019-08-28 68
1A 24 2019-08-16 67
1A 21 2019-08-16 fA
1A 22 2019-08-14 51
1A 21 2019-08-12 62
1A 20 2019-08-12 62
1A 19 2019-08-23 61
1A 18 2019-08-27 59
IA 17 2019-08-26 56
1A 16 2019-08-26 56
IA 11 2019-08-26 35
IA 14 2019-08-22 5A
IA 13 2019-08-19 53
1A 12 2019-08-19 53
1A 11 2019-08-19 53
1A 10 2019-08-16 49
IA 9 2019-08-16 48
IA 8 2019-08-15 47
IA 7 2019-08-16 46
IA 3 2019-08-12 44
lA 5. 2019-08-12 32
IA 4 2019-08-10 29
1A 3 2019-08-12 2k
1A 2 2019-08-12 11
IA 1 2019-08-10 23
Serial Title

(U) FD-1004
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYC033797
(U) Evidence Chain of Custody for Items 1637 and 1838

(U) Release of Evidence to the Office of the Inspector General (OIG)
(U) lA Import
(U) Release of Evidence to the Office of the Inspector General (OIG)

(U) Deferred Prosecution Agreement
(U) Request,* HQQ190816001 TB
(U) Submission of CART Derivative Evidence NYCO26022

(U) Email threat to TOVA NOEL
(U) Email threat to TOVA NOEL
(U) Interview of Hughwon Daniel
(U) 2020-01577-1 Questioned Documents

(U) Response from FBI Laboratory Forensic Document Examiner
(U) Psychology report and interview notes
(U) Interview of Miguel Monge

(U) Interview of Darrius Dupree
(U) Interview of John MARRUGO
(U) Proffer of Jason Mojica
(U) Proffer of Christian Perez

(U) Proffer of Freddy Caraballo
(U) Proffer of Carlos Sanchez-Galan
(U) Interview of Roberto Grijalva
(U) Interview of Dr. Imeri

(U) Interview of Clyde Washington
(U) Glenda ANDERSON-LAYNE Interview
(U) Steven LOPEZ Interview
(U) Interview o

(U) Transcription of Recorded Interview of (amine N'Diaye
(U) Memorandum of Investigation Regarding the Interview of Saadiq Shakir

(U) Arrest of TOVA NOEL and MICHAEL THOMAS
(U) Indictment of TOVA NOEL and MICHAEL THOMAS
(U) Suicide Training Documents for Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoenas Served t.
(U) Job Descriptions for Control Post at Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Letter Received from Metropolitan Correctional Center
(U) Letter Received from Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC) Special Housing Unit (SHU) Video Review
(U) Interview of GHITTO BONHOMME

(U) Metropolitan Correctional Center Staff Rosters for July 23 - August 8, 2019
(U) Counts and Count Slips for August 10, 2019

(U) TruView Documents Provided by Office of the Inspector General
(U) Interview of BO
(U) Evidence Return

(U) Proffer of RAYSHAUN JONES
(U) Interview of GHITTO BONHOMME
(U) Documentation of MCC Special Housing Unit

(U) Interview of Samantha DiMisa
(U) Office of the Chief Medical Examiner of the City of New York Autopsy Report

(U) Information Provided by Office of the Inspector General Regarding Job Descriptions at MCC
(U) Documents Provided Regarding 30 Minute Rounds at Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Photographs of Jeffrey Epstein provided by BOP
(U) Proffer of ANGEL ARROYO
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Metropolitan Correctional Center
(U//FOUO) Laser Scans conducted of Metropolitan Correctional Center

(U) Interview of KIMANA CALE
(U) Interview of KIMANA CALE
(U) Interview of ROSALIND SILVIA
(U) Interview of FREDERICO RANCIER-MEDRANO

(U) Interview of Corrections Office
(U) Interview of Corrections Office
(U) Interview of Corrections Office

(U) Interview of DR. KARI SCHLESSINGER
(U) Interview of DR. KARI SCHLESSINGER
(U) Interview ofJOHNNY CONTRERAS

(U) Interview of S'amar C. Andrea
(U) Interview of S'amar C. Andrea
(U) Interview of S'amar C. Andrea
(U) Interview of Samar C. Andrea

(U) Interview of DR. ELISSA MILLER
(U) Interview of DR. ELISSA MILLER
(U) Interview of DR. ELISSA MILLER

(U) Interview of MARQUEA RICE
(U) Interview of PERRY JOYNER
(U) Interview of Michael Cannata
(U) Return of Property belonging to MICHAEL THOMAS

(U) Proffer of EFRAIN REYES
(U) LEONARDO FERNANDEZ Interview
(U) Photo Log for Photos 41-67 of METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER

(U) Interview of STANLEY JEAN
(U) Interview of STANLEY JEAN
(U) Documentation of FedEx shipment for original OIG waiver signed by James Darden

(U) Device Extraction - MDUS 10754
(U) Receipt of Apple iPhone XS
(U) Receipt of Apple iPhone XS
(U) Proffer Interview of

(U) Database Checks - Robert Charles Adams
(U) Database Checks - Persons of Interest
(U) Database Checks - Persons of Interest

(U) Proffer Interview of COREY LATIMER
(U) Chain of Custody- Digital Evidence Laboratory - Items 1B20, 1B21

(U) Interview of Edward Jimenez (79466-054)
(U) FD-597/ Items 1B20, 1B21
(U) INTERVIEW OF MCC INMATE CHRISTOPHER SANTOS FEUX

(U) Items 1837, 1B38 transfer to NY OCME
(U) Interview of NATHANIEL BULLOCK
(U) Search - Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC), Special Housing Unit, L-Tier, Cell 220

(U) Interview ofJermaine Darden
(U) Interview ofJermaine Darden
(U) Seizure of hard Drives Associated with DVR #2
Summary

(U) CHAIN OF CUSTODY OF 1660
(U) NY-3151227 SID 112048 Admin Documents
(U) FD-1004 for Evidence Items 1837 and 1838

(U) Emails, OCME Letter, FD-1004 Chain of Custody Forms
(U) FD-1004 package copies for evidence Items permanently released to OIG: 181-1836, 1840, 1842, 1843, 1845,

(U) FD-597 Receipt of Property Forms and FD-1004 Evidence Chain of Custody Forms
(U) Deferred Prosecution Agreements for Noel and Thomas

(U) 2 Lab Report, 16 CoC, 2 Shipping invoice, 1 CD-R (logs), 1 DEMS disc
(U) Tape Information
(U) Open source and database information on SHAWN CHRISTOPHER CONE

(U) Email threat to TOVA NOEL from shawncone@gmail.com
(U) Interview Notes taken by TF II
2020-01577-1 QUESTIONED DOCUMENTS
2020-01577-1 1A.zip
CASE NOTE INTERFACE REPORT:
CNI Questioned Documents (AF) Case Note (128072).p
CASE COMMUNICATION LOG FILES:
2020-01577 email attachment (18 110).pdf
2020-01577 #1 Reply to acknowledgment.pdf
2020-01577 email attachment (18 89).pdf
2020-01577 #2_UNCLASS.pdf
2020-01577 email attachment (18 92).pdf
2020-01577 emails with Sftedf
CASE REPORT:
CaseReport2020-01577.pdf
CASE RECORD FILES:
2020-01577 #1 Record Images (i3).pdf
2020-01577 Enclosures.pdf
2020-01577 #1 Record Images (i6).pdf
2020-01577 #2 Record Images (i4-i5).pdf
2020-1577-1 Archived Record Images of Items 1 and
2020-01577 #1 Notes.pdf

(U) Email from FBI Lab
(U) Psychology report and interview notes
(U) Monge Interview notes
(U) Dupree interview notes

(U) Marrugo interview notes
(U) Mojica Notes
(U) Perez Notes
(U) Notes CARABALLO
(U) Notes SANCHEZ-GALAN

(U) Interview Notes Grijalva
(U) Interview notes Imeri
(U) Interview notes Washington
(U) ANDERSON-LAYNE interview notes
(U nterview notes
(U nterview notes

(U) Transcripts of Interview of N'Diaye
(U) MOI regarding the interview of Saadiq Shaker
(U) USMS Arrest Paperwork and Copy of Arrest Warrants

(U) Indictment of Noel and Thomas
(U) MCC Suicide Prevention Material
(U) Federal Grand Jury Subpoenas t -

(U) Post Orders for Control
(U) Letter
(U) Letter and Chain of Custody from MCC
(U) MCC SHU Video Reviews

(U) Notes from GB Second interview
(U) MCC Staff Rosters
(U) 5 AM Count 3 AM Count, and Count Slips for August 10, 2019

(U) Epstein's TruView
(U) AGENT NOTES
(U) Package copy for 1B44. Evidence was returned to Shannon Farrar on 8/28/19 by Sta

(U) Proffer Notes
(U) Notes from Bonhomme interview, Copy of MCC Count Slip, Copy of MCC 30 Minute Round Sheet

(U) Administrative Worksheet, Sign-In Log, Total Station Data, Schematic with measurements, and Sketch.
(U) Bureau of Prisons Psychology Services Post Suicide Watch report dated 7/24/2019 at 09:23 for inmate Jeffrey

(U) Autopsy Report of Epstein
(U) Job Descriptions of General Housing Unites and SHU at MCC
(U) 30 Minute Round Sheets for MCC

(U) Photographs of Epstein
(U) Notes by AUSti or Arroyo
(U//FOUO) Working Copy of LASER Scan Data and Field Projects- One (1) CD of WORKING COPY of RAW scan data

(U) Original LASER Scan Data and Field Office products- Two (2) CDs of ORIGINAL RAW scan data for "Main Area" -

(U) OIG Form signed by Cale
(U) Notes from Cale interview
(U) Interview Notes Silvia
(U) Notes from interview of Medrano and Pictures of Noel and Thomas shown to Medrano

(U) OIG Form
(U) FD-597 and SDNY Receipt for Property
(U) Interview Notes and Picture o
(U) EPSTEIN July 8, 2019 Intake Screening

(U) Interview Notes DR. KARI SCHLESSINGER
(U) Notes from interview of Contreras
(U) MCC SHU Time Sheet
(U) MCC Head Count Sheet

(U) MCC Memorandum
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Reference Documents #3, #6, #7, #8, #9
(U) Reference Documents #1, #2, #4, #5

(U) &notes from Dr. Miller Interview
(U) RICE Notes
(U) JOYNER NOTES
(U) Interview notes
(U) Evidence return documents

(U) Proffer Notes t 41all)yAU Reyes
(U) Notes
(U) One CD labeled "Working Copy," one CD labeled "original copy," Maps: 2nd Floor Psych, 2nd Floor Psych, 9 Sli

(U) OIG warning
(U) JEAN interview notes
(U) FedEx tracking documentation
(U) Legal Authority
(U) FD-597 receipt for property

(U) Consent to search Computer/Electronic Equipment form (OIG-Form 233/4)
MALSeLeon proffer notes
(U) Database checks and a work-up o.

(U) Database checks and work-up for Michael Thomas.
(U) Database checks and work-up for Tova Noel.
(U) Proffer Notes

(U) Chain of Custody- Digital Evidence Laboratory - Items 1B20, 1B21
(U) 08/16/2019 Jimenez interview Notes

(U) FD-597/ Items 1B20, 1B21
(U) INTERVIEW NOTES OF INMATE
(U) OCME Evidence Receipt
(U) Interview documents

(U) BOP chain of custody logs and Photos of search
(U) Copy of signed CIIG waiver
(U) Original Interview Notes
(U) FD-597 Receipt for property
for "Main Area"- One (1) CD of WORKING COPY of RAW scan data for "Cell"- One (1) CD of Scene2Go pn
Two (2) CDs of ORIGINAL RAW scan data for "Cell"- One (1) CD of Scene2Go products for both "Main Ar
ducts for both "Main Area" and "Cell"- One (1 CD containing the PROJECT FILE for both "Main Area" an
ba" and "Cell"- One (1) CD containing the PROJECT FILE for both "Main Area" and "Cell"- Copy of each Er
ror Report for both area projects- Copy of each sketch showing locations of scans
Evidence Report for Case: 90A-NY-3151227
Filtering on: Type(s):1B, 1D, lE
Item It Description
161 (U) One red rope cot
162 (U) One red rope cot
163 (U) One red rope cot
164 (U) One red rope cot
165 (U) One red rope cot
166 (U) One red rope cot
187 (U) One red rope cot
168 (U) One red rope col
169 (U) One red rope col
1610 (U) One red rope cot
1611 (U) One red rope cot
1612 (U) One red rope col
1613 (U) One red rope cot
1614 (U) One red rope col
1615 (U) One red rope cot
1616 (U) One red rope cot
1617 (U) NYCO23594: One
1618 (U) One red rope cot
1619 (U) Two boxes conta
1620 (U) Dell Powerridge
1821 (U) ONE LARGE BRO'
1622 (U) One red rope cot
1623 (U) One red rope cot
1624 (U) One red rope cot
1625 (U) One red rope cot
1826 (U) One red rope cot
1627 (U) One red rope cot
1628 (U) One red rope cot
1629 (U) One red rope cot
1830 (U) One red rope cot
1631 (U) One red rope cot
1632 (U) One red rope cot
1633 (U) One red rope cot
1634 (U) One red rope cot
1635 (U) One red rope cot
1636 (U) One red rope cot
1637 (U) One (1) torn shet
1638 (U) Clothing releasec
1639 (U) One red rope cot
1640 (U) One red rope cot
1641 (U) One cellophane (
1842 (U) One red rope cot
1843 (U) One red rope cot
1B44 (U) One (1) Apple iP1
1B45 (U) One red rope col
1B46 (U) One red rope col
1B47 (U) One red rope sai
1B48 (U) One red rope sal
1B49 (U) One red rope sai
1B50 (U) One red rope sal
1B51 (U) One red rope sai
1B52 (U) One red rope sai
1B53 (U) ONE REDROPE C
1854 (U) ONE REDROPE O
1B55 (U) ONE REDROPE O
1856 (U) ONE REDROPE O
1B57 (U) ONE LARGE BROl
1858 (U) RED ROPE contai
1B59 (U) BOX CONTAININI
1B60 (U) (1) Red rope con
taining: NYCO23578: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST500DM002, S/N Z3T6CJJA, from MCC Nice Vision
taining:NYCO23579: One (1) Hitachi 500GB HDD, HDS721050CLA662, S/N JP1572JE36A13K from MCC Nice Vision
taining:NYCO23580: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, STSOODM002, S/N 2316CF5X, from MCC Nice Vision
taining:NYCO23581: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST3500320NS, S/N 9QM8MT9P, from MCC Nice Visic
taining:NYCO23582: One (1) Hitachi 500GB HDD, HDS721050CLA662, S/N JP1S72JE36MWNK, from MCC Nice Visit
taining:NYCO23583: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST3S00320NS, S/N 9QM8EC75, from MCC Nice Visio
taining:NYCO23584: One (1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, ST500NM0011, S/N Z1M1PZPE, from MCC Nice
taining:NYCO23585: One (1) Western Digital 500GB HDD, WDS000AVDS-63U7B1, S/N WCAV92911026, from MCC
taining:NYC023586: One (1) Western Digital 500GB HOD, WD5000AAKX- 60U6AAO, S/N WCC2EJUC34CJ, from MC
taining:NYCO23587: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST3500320NS, S/N 9QM8MSEZ, from MCC Nice Visi •
taining:NYCO23588: One (1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N Z1M1PX26, from MCC Nice
taining:NYCO23589: One (1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N Z1M1Q1FX, from MCC Nic
taining:NYCO23590: One (1) Western Digital 500GB HDD, WDSOOOAVDS- 63U7B1, S/N WCAV91870016, from MC(
taining:NYCO23591: One (1) Western Digital 500GB HDD, WD5000AAI0(-60U6AAO, S/N WCC2E0DE83YK, from MC
taining:NYCO23592: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST3500320NS, S/N 9QM8MT6D, from MCC Nice Visit
taining:NYCO23593: One (1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, ST500NM0011, S/N Z1M1P207, from MCC Nia
(1) Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N Z1M1LOYG, from MCC Nice Vision DVR2 Surveillant
taining:NYCO23595: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST3500320NS, S/N 9QM8MSRR, from MCC Nice Visic
rung: DVR System #2 consisting of the following items: 1. Disk Array Chassis; Model#: SA-66405, SN: F96168201 I i
N BOX CONTAINING: DVR System #1 consists of the following items:1. Disk Array Chassis containing 16 hard Drive
taining: NYCO27701: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB Hard Drive, model ST1000DM003, S/N S1D85PLA, contai
taining: NYCO27702: One (1) Hitachi 1TB Hard Drive, HUA722010CIA330, S/N JPW9KON039EZLL, containing the C
taining: NYCO27703: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB Hard Drive, model ST1000DM003, S/N Z1D3ZSSO, contaii
taining: NYCO27704: One (1) Seagate Desktop 118 hard drive, model ST1000DM003, S/N Z4YDJL1T, containing thi
taining: NYCO27705: One (1) Seagate Desktop 118 hard drive, model ST1000DM003, S/N Z4YDHX5M, containing
taining: NYCO27706: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB Hard Drive, model ST1000DM003, S/N W1D48YH6, con
taining: NYCO27707: One (1) Western Digital 1TB hard drive, WD10EADS-00L5B1, S/N WCAU45803950, containini
taining: NYCO27708: One (1) Seagate Desktop 1000GB HDD, ST100DM003, S/N 24100Q48, containing the Clone
taining: NYCO27709: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST10000M003, S/N W1D496N0, containing the Cl.
taining: NYCO27710: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N Z1DB25CT, containing the Clon
taining: NYCO27711: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N W1D4826E, containing the Clo
taining: NYCO27712: One (1) Western Digital 1000GB HDD, WD1003FZEX-00MK2A0, S/N WCC3F2783519, contain
taining: NYCO27713: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N S1D9GK9P, containing the Clor
taining: NYCO27714: One (1) Seagate Barracuda 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N S1D9DETC, containing the Clo
taining: NYC027715: One (1) Seagate Barracuda, 1000GB HDD, ST1000DM003, S/N W1D06TSL, containing the Cl
taining: One (1) Seagate 500gb hard drive, serial number W2AEXSJV, containing video downloaded from DVR1 at
taining: One (1) Hitachi 2TB Hard Drive, OF10311JPK3EAOP09, S/N B9GMGTYF, containing the verified E01 Images
taining: One (1) WD Black 318 hard drive, WD3003FZE)(-00Z4SAO, S/N WCC13LZR579P, containing the verified EC)
taining: NYCO25654- One (1) Western Digital 250 GB Hard Drive (Model: WD2SOOJD S/N: WMAEP1322402) conta
itaining:NYF01278- One (1) IBM LTOS Data Cartridge containing Archive of Case Volume in regards to CART Reque
I to contain: Hard Drive, Seagate, ST500NM0011, S/N: Z1M116CCO, Clone of 1B13, derivative evidence from FBI E
I to contain: Hard Drive, Seagate, ST3500410SV, S/N: 6VMSVRFN, Clone of 1B14, derivative evidence from FBI ERF
I to contain the following: Hard Drive, Seagate, ST3S00630A, S?N: 9qg23rDP, Clone of HqQ019331 (top bay of DVI
)NTAINING: Two (2) Ukrium LT0-6 tapes containing the CART network archive of video images taken from MCC-N
piing HQQ019335 Hard Drive, Western Digital WD1001FALS-41Y6A1, S/N:WCATR7962678, Clone of HQQ019333 al
wining: Two (2) Ultrium LTO6 tapes containing the archive of MCC video images and work product under CART Sul
ling the Clone Copy of 1B1 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, STSOODM002, S/N Z3T6CJJA), co
one Copy of 1B2 hard drive (Hitachi 500GB HDD, HDS721050CLA662, S/N JP1572JE36A13K), collected v
iing the Clone Copy of 183 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda SOOGB HDD, STSOODM002, S/N Z3T6CFSX), cc
Clone Copy of 184 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 50068 Hard Drive, ST3500320NS, S/N 9QM8MT9P), i
he Clone Copy of 186 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST350032ONS, S/N 9QM8EC75), collet
ining the Clone Copy of 167 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 500GB, ST500NM0011, S/N Z1M1PZPI
; the Clone Copy of 168 hard drive (Western Digital 500GB HDD, WD5000AVDS-63U761, S/N WCAV9Z91
opy of 1B9 hard drive (Western Digital 500GB HDD, WD5000AAKX- 60U6AAO, S/N WCC2EJUC34CJ), coil'
ne Copy of 1610 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HOD, ST3500320K S/N 9QM8MSEZ), collected
e Copy of 1B11 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N Z1M1PX26), collei
le Copy of 1612 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N Z1M1Q1FX), collt
ing the Clone Copy of 1815 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, 513500320N% S/N 9QM8MT6())
e Copy of 1816 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N Z1M1P207), colle
e Copy of 1817 hard drive (Seagate Constellation ES 500GB HDD, STSOONM0011, S/N Z1M1LOYG), collei
ne Copy of 1818 hard drive (Seagate Barracuda 500GB HDD, ST350032ONS, S/N 9QM8MSRR), collected
kACC contained in 4 folders. Folders as follows: all video available for download for 8/10/2019, All relev
NYCO23589 (1812), NYCO23593 (1816), NYCO23594 (1817), and NYCO23595 (1618). Master Copy.
I images NYCO23578 (1B1), NYCO23579 (182), NYCO23580 (1B3), NYCO23581 (164), NYCO23583 (186), l'i
ning generated reports and data extractions of 1B44_NYCO25647 in regards to CART Request #218509:
id HQQ019336 Hard Drive, Western Digital WD15EVDS-73V9B1, S/N:WMAVU4005952, Clone of HQQO3
lected via Tableau TX-1, S/N 000ECC58017139 (F2882257). Request ID 112048. Derivative Copy.
1026), collected via Tableau T03-8, S/N 01D34O7C-1222. Request ID 112048. Derivative Copy.
nt video from Special Housing Unit floor 9 and Attorney Visit area floor 3 from 7/23 to 8/10 2019, All v
YC023584 (1B7), NYC023585 (188 , NYC023586 (1B9), NYC023587 (1810), NYC0235138 (1B11), and NYC
deo available to download for 8/9 (THIS DOWNLOAD FAILED) and video downloaded by tech, (that is th
e wrong camera).
Case Number.
Case Summary:
90C-NY-3154599
On 8/17/2019, the FBI opened an investigation into contraband being brought into Metropolitan
Correctional Center. Epstein was referenced in this case.
Serial Report for Case: I90C-NY-3154599
Serial # Date
g 9/6/2024 5:53
60 10/21/2023 12:13
52 9/8/2023 14:19
51 5/3/2023 12:37
57 1/13/2023 13:20
56 1/11/202316:55
55 12/2/2021 14:41
54 9/30/2020 9:26
53 3/16/2020 11:02
52 3/10/2020 12:53
51 2/20/2020 16:24
5.Q 2/20/2020 16:24
49 8/15/2019 13:26
48 8/15/2019 14:45
47 8/15/2019 14:46
46 8/20/2019 13:37
45 8/19/2019 16:05
44 2/4/2020 11:23
4 2/3/2020 11:35
IZ 2/3/2020 11:32
41 2/3/2020 11:13
40 2/3/202011:08
32 2/3/2020 9:39
38 2/3/2020 9:22
37 2/3/2020 9:11
36 2/3/2020 9:07
35 1/29/2020 15:27
24 1/29/202015:06
11 12/3/2019 9:05
32 11/7/2019 11:33
31 10/30/201910:10
30 10/30/201910:11
29 10/29/2019 15:17
28 10/29/2019 15:16
27 10/23/2019 11:02
22 10/23/2019 10:59
25 10/18/2019 11:35
24 10/11/2019 15:13
22 10/11/2019 15:11
10/11/2019 15:04
21 10/4/2019 11:32
20 10/3/2019 13:19
19 9/19/2019 12:56
18 9/19/2019 11:03
17 9/6/2019 8:40
16 9/5/2019 16:24
15 8/23/2019 12:27
14 8/23/2019 12:10
13 8/23/2019 9:11
12 8/23/2019 9:11

AI. 8/23/2019 9:08
10 8/23/2019 9:07
9 8/22/2019 11:08
8 8/22/2019 9:00
7 8/22/2019 8:55
6 8/21/2019 16:16
5 8/21/2019 15:49
4 8/21/2019 15:47
1 8/21/2019 9:50
2 8/20/2019 14:09
1 8/17/2019 9:10
Title

(U) lA Upload- 1B3
(U) Closing EC
(U) Evidence disposal
(U) Evidence disposal
(U) Late Justification EC
(U) Recorded interview of Shahada Harris

(U) Return of Evidence to Shahada Harris
(U) Review of Cell Site data related to Search Warrant Returns
(U) Proffer of SHAHADA HARRIS - 02/12/2020

(U) Evidence Disposition Destruction
(U) XX)O(XX)0(XX
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Seizure of DVR System #2

(U) Seizure of hard Drives Associated with DVR #2
(U) Seizure of DVR Controller and DVR System #1
(U) INTERVIEW OF MCC INMATE CHRISTOPHER SANTOS FELIX

(U) Submission of Video Evidence from Metropolitan Correctional Center, NY NY
(U) Search warrant application and affidavit and warrants with proof of service

(U) SW Application, SW
(U) Interview of Joy Aassiddaa
(U) Notes, Subpoena service
(U) Recorder interviews rendered on 8/14/19

(U) FD-26 and FD-597 for Harris
(U) Optial Dish w/ 85 digital photographs of Shahada Harris cell phones
(U) FD597

(U) FD-597, Receipt for e-property
(U) F0-26 and FD597 for Harris
(U) Receipt for electronic property
(U) Interview Notes

(U) T-Mobile Search Warrant - MICHELLE RODRIGUEZ Cell Site Data
(U) Photographing of Shahada Harris' Cellular Telephone

(U) )000000000(
(U) Trasfer of Custody of Harris Cellular Telephones from SDNY USAO
(U) )000000000(
(U) Interview of RICHARD FLETCHER

(U) Interview of LESUE ANDERSON - 10/16/2019
(U) Interview ofJabraddrick Durant; Lieutenant; MCC
(U) Interview of CASANOVA MADISON on 9/18/2019

(U) Proffer with SHAHADA HARRIS
(U) Proffer of SHAHADA HARRIS - 08/22/2019
(U) Interview of RAMEL LOGAN - 09/27/2019

(U) Interview of MICHELLE RODRIGUEZ -09/27/2019
(U) Interview of Joy Aassiddaa (DOB 10/17/1978)
(U) Canvass for Surveillance Cameras in the Vicinity of MCC

(U) Interview of Corrections Office
(U) Search Warrant Executed on Shahada Harris' Cell Phones numbe
(U) )O0OOOOOOOC

(U) )O0CO0OO0O(
(U) Transfer of Cellular Telephones for Processing
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents

(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Database Checks - Robert Charles Adams
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents

(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Search Warrant Execution for Cellular Phones belong to Shadda Harris an.
(U) Search Warrant Execution for Cellular Phones belong to Shadda Harris an •

(U) Interview of Shahada Harri
(U) Interview of Shahada Harris
(U) Opening Communication
1A/1C Report for Case: i 90C-NY-3154599
Type # Acquired On Serial *
1A '12 2024-08-14 g
lA 48 2023-05-01 58
1A 4.2 2021-12-02 a 1A IN  2020-09-21 5.4
1A 45 2019-09-18 51
1A 44 2019-09-18 SO
1A 43 2019-09-18 so
1A 42 2019-09-18 50
1A 41 2020-02-20 50
1A ao 2020-02-20 50
1A 22 2019-09-26 IQ
1A a 2019-09-18 52
1A 37 2019-08-22 44
1A 36 2019-08-16 43
1A 35 2019-08-23 42
1A 34 2019-09-09 41
1A 33 2019-08-14 40
1A 32 2019-08-14 39
1A 31 2019-08-23 3$
lA N 2019-08-16 3/
lA 29 2019-08-19 36
1A 28 2019-08-22 34
1A 21 2019-10-18 22
1A 26 2019-08-23 31
1A 25 2019-09-09 30
1A 24 2019-08-23 30
1A 23 2019-08-23 29
1A 22 2019-09-09 a 1A 21 2019-10-18 25
lA 20 2019-08-23 19
1A a 2019-08-19 25
lA a 2019-08-19 15
lA 17 2019-08-19 14
1A 16 2019-08-19 13
lA 15 2019-08-22 12
1A 14 2019-08-19 11
lA 13 2019-08-14 11
lA 12 2019-08-20 10
lA 11 2019-08-19 4
1A 33 2019-08-19 7
1A 9 2019-08-16 6
1A 8 2019-08-16 5
1A 7 2019-08-16 4
1A 6 2019-08-14 I.
1A 5 2019-08-14 2
IA 4 2019-08-15 2
IA 2 2019-08-14 2
1A 2 2019-08-14 2
IA 1 2019-08-14 1
Serial Title

(U) IA Upload- 1B3
(U) Evidence disposal
(U) Return of Evidence to Shahada Harris
(U) Review of Cell Site data related to Search Warrant Returns

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents

(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents

(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Document Review for Multiple Documents
(U) Search warrant application and affidavit and warrants with proof of service

(U) SW Application, SW
(U) Interview of Joy Aassiddaa
(U) Notes, Subpoena service
(U) Recorder interviews rendered on 8/14/19

(U) FD-26 and FD-597 for Harris
(U) Optial Dish w/ 85 digital photographs of Shahada Harris cell phones
(U) FD597

(U) FD-597, Receipt for e-property
(U) Receipt for electronic property
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Photographing of Shahada Harris' Cellular Telephone

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) Trasfer of Custody of Harris Cellular Telephones from SDNY USAO

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) Interview ofJabraddrick Durant; Lieutenant; MCC
(U) Interview of Joy Aassiddaa

(U) Search Warrant Executed on Shahada Harris' Cell Phones numbe
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied

(U) Transfer of Cellular Telephones for Processing
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents

(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Reciept of Documents
(U) Search Warrant Execution for Cellular Phones belong to Shadda Harris an

(U) Search Warrant Execution for Cellular Phones belong to Shadda Harris an .
(U) Interview of Shahada Harris

(U) Interview of Shahada Harris
(U) Interview of Shahada Hard
(U) Interview of Shahada Harris
(U) Interview of Shahada Harris

(U) Opening Communication
Summary
(U) FD1087,1004- 1B3
(U) Email Attachments
(U) Signed FD-597 and FD-1004s.

(U) Historical Cell site returns
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U mployee Records at MCC
(U -York Schedule at MCC for 8/18/19 to 8/23/19

(U) Ramel Logan Inmate Profile
(U) Case Notes
(U) Cadre inmates released to include halfway house. May-August 2019

(U) Unit Rosters
(U) MCC 3 AM Count Slips for 8/10/2019 including a hand Writing exemplar fo
(U) Search warrant application and affidavit and warrants with proof of service

(U) SW Application, SW
(U) Interview of Joy Aassiddaa
(U) Notes, Subpoena service
(U) Recorder interviews rendered on 8/14/19

(U) FD-26 and FD-597 for Harris
(U) Optial Dish w/ 85 digital photographs of Shahada Harris cell phones
(U) FD597

(U) FD-597, Receipt for e-property
(U) Receipt for electronic property
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Photographs of content on Shahadda Harris' cellular telephone

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) property receipts
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied

(U) Interview Notes.' DURANT
(U) Interview Notes
(U) Property Receipts Related to Evidence Processing
(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied

(U) RESTRICTED - Access Denied
(U) Property Receipts
(U chedule and Assignments 5/31/2019
(U) Metro Card Database Check Reports

(U) Metro Card Photos
(U) Keith Outlaw Housing Assignment
(U) Keith Outlaw Communications Report
(U chedule and Assignments 6/1/19 to 8/19/2019

(U) Visitors Log from MCC
(U) Search Warrant Documents
(U) Search Warrant Documents
(U) email from Shahada Harris

(U) Photos taken at time of interview of Harris' identification, metro cards and call history
(U) MCC incident report with photos, memo by CO Fletcher, memo by LT Durant, BOP Notification to Visitor, Ad

(U) Shahadda Harris FD 26 and FD 597 Consent to Search
(U) Recorded Interview Video
(U) MCC Incident Report
In detention order, Roster, medical report,
90C-NY-3154599
Type(s):18, 1D, 1E
Collected On Description
8/22/2019 16:30 (U) ONE CELLOPHA
8/16/2019 16:30 (U) ONE CELLOPHA
8/14/2019 17:30 (U) ONE CELLOPHA
12/1/2022 12:25 (U) NYEM88929484
NE CONTAINING: Flash drive serial number 0002586 containing data obtained from (phone Xr Serial Number F2LY'
NE CONTAINING: (phone 7 Serial Number FYQVT0J4HFY0
NE CONTAINING: (phone Xr Serial Number F2LY)(56VKXKQ
corded non-custodial interview of Shahada Harris
56VKXKQ and (phone 7 Serial Number FYQVT0J4HFY0
Case Number: 9A-NY-3144791
Case Summary:
Threats against victim of Epstein were anymously posted online. The case was
opened on 7/26/2019 and closed on 5/12/2020. Attempts to make contact with
the individual who posted the threats were unanswered.
Serial Repc:9A-NY-3144791
Serial # Date
7 5/12/2020 14:56
6 5/4/2020 9:00
I 9/5/2019 4:23
4 8/8/2019 13:46
3 8/2/2019 15:24
2 8/1/2019 8:34
1 7/26/2019 9:43
Title

(U) Closing EC
(U) Updated OCE activity
(U) Anonymous threat against VIRGINIA ROBERTS GUIFFRE
(U) Attempted Contact To Threat to Life Posting on Deep Paste.

(U) FDR to Legat Canberra
(U) Request for OCE
(U) Opening EC

╭────────────────────────── Page 255, Image 1 ───────────────────────────╮
│ [A/C Rep 9A-NY-3144791                                                 │
│                                                                        │
│ lType Serial # Serial Title                                            │
│ FLY 2 4 (U) Attempted Contact To Threat to Life Posting on Deep Paste. │
│ JA i 1 (U) Opening EC                                                  │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA02731254 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2025-05-02 20:12:00)
Re:
Trauma Journal from
The journal is called an "upside-down" book. Patients like wrote their entries on the right-
hand side of the notebook, and then doctors, staff and other patients would write on the back of
those pages, upside down — words of encouragement and positive thoughts. Everything is in
chronological order and the writings and notes from other people were made contemporaneously,
in 2012.
Below are excerpts from some of her entries from her Trauma Journal:

• May 15, 2012
• June 5, 2012
• June 12, 2012
• c le.June 24, 2012
• July 6, 2012 0 A • July 7, 2012 (<
• July 8, 2012
b%\/
C )
ICY
' C
\ \ 'S
*/ AO
<<\''c- O ' ;-\O 0 0 4,O
‘173/4.
1
May 15, 2012
I am going to make the goal of writing at least twice a week, maybe more but I always say that
and never do. But since its for trauma no one has to see it.
At the end of my stay, I'm going to have all of the staff sign this book the right way up with the
person I'm most able to talk to be the first.
At first when I heard it was approved I thought Id be mil to Arizona but when they said
was best fit because I'm able to work with I wanted to scream and
cry because I haven't been back to Florida since my last time with Ghislaine and Jeffrad so
that was so scary and I didn't want to have a man therapist even if he does know about I
won't be able to talk to him even though it turns out that he is super nice and understands me.
The flight wasn't nearly as bad as I thought it would be. I felt wei
other people since I was always on private planes but I think I I
The flight attendant, I wish I got her name, she could tell
to the pilot and I kept looking to make sure it wasn't one o ey'
but it wasn't. During the flight she would make sure
and drinks and when I got really scared as we
with me. I started getting really scared once 14 wese
terrified that maybe this was a set-up and whi I tit t off
Ghislaine but the flight attendant didn't
and then helped me to find the driver
The drive was super scary. The
so many people drive BLAC
And he was nice but it
internal panic as I wa
right to Jeffrey's h
gross, disgusting pi ansi
the roads felt the same beca
e on a plane with so many
better. More safe.
sa„,fhrst she introduced me
is at could be co-pilot
Notairokay3 pt giving me free snacks
tl !t e looked at fun magazines
beca se had to meet a driver and I was
plane I'd see Mr. Juan or maybe even
e. he walked with me to get my things
sure he knew where he was taking me.
e car was too much like Ghislaine's. Why do
th windows that seem so dark.
as trying to stop the memories and I started to have
w dows because it looks so much like we were heading
ed to think I'd been set up and we'd soon see his stupid,
any time and I don't know if I am even that close to there but
verything is so flat here.
I couldn't manage because I was becoming more and more convinced he was kidnapping me and
I would have to face Jeffrey against after leaving how I did so all I could make out was "yes" "no"
"thank you" and some "uh huhs" so he probably thinks I'm so rude. It ended up being fine but it
was super hard to keep it together. The campus is beautiful but the ool reminds me too much of
bad things so I won't be going to that. It has changed a lot since
so maybe they got money from that to make it so pretty.
And. is really nice but I still wish I could have gotten a girl therapist because I know I won't
be able to talk about any of this trauma. I don't like to go to the groups outside of the healing
garden or the other building because I get so much panic that I think Jeffrey or Ghislaine will just
pop up.
2
May 25. 2012
...Like the idiot that I am did happy claps and quickly realized what I was doing and he said I
immediately had a change in body language and looked distant and sad and asked why something
happy made me so sad and I wanted to tell how even being here is traumatic and that I'm so scared
that Jeffrey is around every corner but then I remember the rules. ....
I'm so fucked up being down here again. But no words would come. But I told him that I was
writing about it and that I started to confide a bit in= and my friend
I've slowly started to tell her what happened with Jeffrey and Ghislaine and why nighttime is
especially hard here.
There are times I can tell she does not really think Ghislaine is vegeld but she doesn't want to
C)
upset me.
4(... I need more clarification about the rules and what stuff( st be re especially since I'm
in I want to be able to tell = every single viti„..
I'm not even sure how you're supposed to talk a e
say the words out loud. I can't. I think if I w,
think I am bad and I don't want that.
suggested that I try to write it all
dare do that tonight. I'm way too
Othat. I don't know how to
of my trauma everyone would
in this weird list type thing but I don't
June 5, 2012
I wish I could rip all these pages out and rewrite them nicely, but ■ says I can't. Not everything
has to be perfect and definitely not a book that no one will ever see. I got two more stickers in my
fun book and that makes me so proud! That sounds pathetic. But I am learning to trust I. more
and more even though he's a man. I'm still terrified that Jeffrey will walk through the door at any
moment but now that I'be been here for almost a month, things have become routine which I'm
s000 grateful for.
June 12 2012
■ keeps reminding me that I don't need to be so rigid and uniform and it's okay to sometimes
break certain rules but I don't think that's exactly right.
never stops bragging about her stupid beauty pageant...
want to be in the room with her .. and I was SO wrong about
thought she was and doesn't understand why its triggeri
me so much of but not as bad. At least she's teachi
rather than teaching me how to do grown up things .she
confess.
But I think■ will be proud of how I handle
m trauma but I haven't been reall so I deci
talked to this evening and I prett
I can't write the other word and s
didn't need to be said. I kno
Ghislaine did was "normal
understand. I have a fee
Jeffrey.
is just mean and I never
She isn't neariakind as I
and I can't II him. reminds
e how e things in Japanese
ste with a secret she had to
to ay if I have been writing about
o that tonight since
cause of the new trio that formed. I
hing except for the
everything that I felt it was something that
sh% kept asking me if I understood that nothing
g" but I tried to explain to her, but she didn't
ye that Ghislaine didn't know about anyone else but
She would try to spl eally t nd calmly that it doesn't make sense for her to be so close
and to now know, especial so many men were up from the city and the fact that I met her
and Jeffrey up near the city t started getting really really super distressed and thank goodness
was there and started to count my fingers because I couldn't breathe. I genuinely felt
like I was dying of a heart attack (which the nurse said it was a panic attack and not a heart-attack)
but it felt like one. She thinks I should tells and that it would be helpful for me but I made sure
she remembered her promise to me about not telling anyone since I made the same. She said it
would always be safe with her and I know she's being honest. I think.
I told her I would consider telling who has officially become my most favorite counselor
here. But I told her I may not be able to tell her names because of my promise and now I think
even would have to tell.
3
And that made me more scared because she reminds me of and she has the female version
accent of Jeffrey so I'm just a mess and nodded and she said in such a funny way.
had the same idea about maybe writing out a list or timeline of my trauma just to myself
and then maybe once I'm able to share then it will be kept safe until that time. I think I will try to
do that but there isn't the time tonight.
June 24, 2012
family but I was convinced it was to meet Jeffrey, so I tucked myself in so tight under
the table, covered my ears and the voice just continues. The next thing I know I have staff and
other girls who didn't have family surrounding me and had cold ice in my hand. I was searching
desperately for_, but she wasn't there and was trying to convince me that it
was safe to come out but I wouldn't until finally came. Everyone was just staring at me, and
it was so embarrassing and I asked what happened but she said that it wasn't important to
talk about. Remembered I was supposed to go see so
and it was  with the same accent. I wanted to just s•
because family bought me the most lovely stuffed
he moves his head.
to walk me to the door
quickly okay though
e tlPat plays a lullaby and
I talked more with and told her about ed and I wasn't sure how to
handle that because I wasn't sure if she was ad at me sa t I hugged her and she hugged
back so tight. I don't think that helped m getting things out will help but that
part only made me feel like a monster.
July 6, 2012
O
I made my first intentional e et ani any people saw and cried. And poor■ was so
t because it wasn't wi es any weeks of the dog card, but it was with u
I had an abs ltdo_ o e meal room being changed. I did it! I did it!
July 7, 2012
I made her promise until 1 Pffrs old and we pinky swore. I met my goal of connecting with a
staff member and I told her erything. She is safe and I know it will be safe with her. She said as
long as I'm wearing her bracelet. I am safe to now write the trauma in here. I don't need to be
detailed but for me to process and understand. She doesn't think I have a full understanding and
thinks one day I'll need and want to process it with a grown up when and if I am ready but she
wouldn't explain the things she felt I didn't understand. I promised I would do that as soon as she
left and so I know I must do it before she gets back for lights out. I'm not sure how to do this but
I'll do my best and if I did it wrong I'm sure she'll say something.
- From 16-18 — MiAldie, Jeffrey, Ghislaine, Trio sent to many in DC, NY, FL, island,
too many (I hate HATE)
4
How in the hell am I suppose to have "radical acceptance" of these thin s? It's a honor story that
I survived why was I allowed to survive? Am I a monster? I wish would hurry up and
come back because I don't know if Ghislaine should be in there. and thinks so,
thinks so but what am I missing? Why won't say? I'm going to ask as soon as
she returns. I don't want to radically accept. I want to know why. What could I possibly learn from
this? A priest! I planned that out so well. He couldn't talk or tell. He is supposed to be good. Why?
I need to go find and ask for medication.
July 8, 2012
I don't want to leave any time soon. I don't feel ready. I mean I do with eating, I won't put my
recovery in danger but I can't radically accept.. and assured me they'd find a team
back home to help me but do I even deserve help unraveling all of that? I feel so stressed out and
overwhelmed and I have so many questions. No one is safe outs j, of here so how I will ever
understand if I have to keep the promise. says tha ad promise but its all so
confusing. I don't think I will write more. I think I've fulfille
.
ignmer and won't have time
t 48*tonce I return home and have to go back to school, work, a ving
5
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Norman Finkelstein [academia] scholar, well known critic of Israel, sworn enemy of Alan Dershowitz 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00796700 (Jmail)
 [legal] detailed notes on Epstein's relationship with Alan Dershowitz
EFTA00173350 (Jmail)
 [politics] letter from Senator Dick Durban to Pam Bondi, Senator Chuck Grassley
(inferred timestamp: 2025-07-18 12:21:00)
United States Senate
COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY
WASHINGTON. DC 20510-6275
July 18, 2025

The Honorable Pam Bondi
Attorney General
U.S. Department of Justice
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, DC 20530

Dear Attorney General Bondi:

On July 7, the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
released an unsigned memorandum regarding the Trump Administration's "exhaustive review of
investigative holdings relating to Jeffrey Epstein." This memorandum made two official findings:
(1) "[t]his systemic review revealed no incriminating `client list"; and (2) "[a]fter a thorough
investigation, FBI investigators concluded that Jeffrey Epstein committed suicide in his cell at
the Metropolitan Correctional Center in New York City on August 10, 2019."'

The first finding directly contradicts public statements you have repeatedly made. On
February 21, 17 days after your confirmation as Attorney General, you were asked directly by
Fox News' America Reports host John Roberts: "DOJ may be releasing the list ofJeffrey
Epstein's clients; will that really happen?"' Your response was: "It's sitting on my desk right now
to review." On February 27, you released binders of documents related to Epstein to
conservative influencers and commentators,' but despite the major media event the White House
staged around this release, these files were largely already publicly available? After intense
blowback from this incident, you appeared on another Fox News show, Life Liberty Levin, and
claimed that a "whistleblower" told you that "New York SDNY [was] sitting on thousands of
pages of documents"; that "we will get everything"; that you were "assured" there was more; and
that the country would eventually see "the full Epstein files.'
1 Memorandum from Dep't of Justice and Fed. Bureau of Investigation on Review of Investigative Holdings
Relating to Jeffrey Epstein (Jul. 7, 2025), available at https://www.justice.gov/opatmedia/1407001/dl?inline
[hereinafter July 7 memorandum].
Haley Chi-Sing, Bondi says Epstein client list 'sitting on my desk right now 'and is reviewing JFK, MLK files, FOX
NEWS (Feb. 21, 2025), https://www.foznews.com/politics/bondi-says-epstein-client-list-sitting-my-desk-right-now-
reviewing-jflc-mlk-files.
3 Id.
4 Press Release, DOJ, Attorney General Pamela Bondi Releases First Phase of Declassified Epstein Files (Feb. 27,
2025), available at httpslAvww.justice.gov/opa/priattorney-general-pamela-bondi-releases-first-phase-declassified-
epstein-files.
s Anna Durkin Richer & Michael R. Sisak, No new bombshells in Justice Department's release ofJeffrey Epstein
files, AP (Feb. 27, 2025), https://apnews.corniarticle/jeffrey-epstein-files-pam-bondi-trump-
1 a6a(3 e9fa I cfb6d267985a971a4929a.
6 Life Liberty Levin, Pam Bondi on stonewalled Epstein files: We will get everything, FOX NEWS (Feb. 27, 2025),
https://www.foznews.cornivideo/6369422747I I2?msockid=01561c16(5d864072e93086ff44c65df; see also
Elizabeth Crisp, Bondi says she was misled on Epstein documents, THE HILL (Mar. 3, 2025),
https://thehill.com/homenews/administration/5172660-attomey-general-pam-bondi-epstein-files.
According to information my office received, you then pressured the FBI to put
approximately 1,000 personnel in its Information Management Division (IMD), including the
Record/Information Dissemination Section (RIDS), which handles all requests submitted by the
public under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and Privacy Act, on 24-hour shifts to
review approximately 100,000 Epstein-related records in order to produce more documents that
could then be released on an arbitrarily short deadline. This effort, which reportedly took place
from March 14 through the end of March, was haphazardly supplemented by hundreds of FBI
New York Field Office personnel, many of whom lacked the expertise to identify statutorily -
protected information regarding child victims and child witnesses or properly handle FOIA
requests.
My office was told that these personnel were instructed to "flag" any records in which
President Trump was mentioned. Notably, in 2002, Mr. Trump said of Mr. Epstein, "I've known
Jeff for 15 years. Terrific guy, He's a lot of fun to be with. It is even said that he likes beautiful
women as much as I do, and many of them are on the younger side." 7Just yesterday, it was
reported that the Department previously reviewed a "leather-bound album" comprised of dozens
of letters from Mr. Epstein's friends in celebration of his 50th birthday in 2003. 8 The letters were
collected by Mr. Epstein's partner Ghislaine Maxwell and included one from President Trump
that allegedly "contains several lines of typewritten text framed by the outline of a naked woman,
which appears to be hand-drawn with a heavy marker ... and the future president's signature is a
squiggly `Donald' below her waist." 9
Despite tens of thousands of personnel hours reviewing and re-reviewing these Epstein-
related records over the course of two weeks in March, it took DOJ more than three additional
months to officially find there is "no incriminating `client list,'" and the memorandum with this
finding includes no mention of the whistleblower or additional documents, the existence of
which you publicly claimed on February 27.
The second finding in the July 7 memorandum does not contradict any official statement
from DOJ and accords with the DOJ Inspector General's investigation into the Bureau of
Prisons' custody of Jeffrey Epstein. 10 However, public skepticism of the government's
transparency in this matter has been needlessly increased due to your release of surveillance
video from outside of Jeffrey Epstein's cell in the hours leading up to his death, which the July 7
memorandum described as "full raw" footage;" in fact, the footage was likely modified,
according to the metadata embedded in the video.' 2
7 Landon Thomas, Jr., Jeffrey Epstein: International Moneyman of Mystery', N.Y. MAG (Oct. 28, 2002),
https://nymag.com/nyrnetrolnews/people/n_7912.
Khadeeja Safdar & Joe Palazzolo, Jeffrey Epstein's Friends Sent Him Bawdy Letters for a 50th Birthday Album.
One Was From Donald Trump, WALL ST. J. (July 17, 2025), https://wunv.wsj.com/politics/trump-jeffrey•epstein-
birthday-letter-we-have-certain-things-in-common-f9 I 8d796.
9/d.
w See generally, DEP'T OF JUSTICE, OFF. OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL, INVESTIGATION AND REVIEW OF THE
FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS' CUSTODY, CARE, AND SUPERVISION OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN AT THE METROPOLITAN
CORRECTIONAL CENTER IN NEW YORK, NEW YORK (JUT). 2023), available at
https://oigjustice.gov/sites/default/files/reports/23-085.pdf.
11 July 7 memorandum at 2. rx Dhruv Mehrotra, The FBI's Jeffrey Epstein Prison Video Had Nearly 3 Minutes Cut Out, WIRED
(Jul. 15, 2025),
https://www.wired.com/story/the-fbis-jeffrey-epsteinprison-video-had-nearly-3-minutes-cut-out; Dhruv Mehrotra,
2
Given the serious questions about the veracity of your public statements regarding the
Epstein-related records in DOJ's possession and the effect those questions are having on the
public's ability to trust DOJ's July 7 finding that there is "no incriminating `client list,'" I ask
that you provide the following information and materials no later than August 1, 2025.

1. Have you personally reviewed all files in DOJ's possession related to Jeffrey Epstein?
2. The records DOJ released on February 27 did not include a client list. Why did you
publicly claim on February 21 that the client list was "sitting on my desk right now to
review"?

a. If it was not a client list, what was "sitting on your desk" at that moment?
3. Please provide the names and titles of the Department ethics officials with whom you
consulted on your potential conflict of interest in this matter and any records or
materials related to this consultation.

4. When did the whistleblower disclose to you that thousands of pages of additional
Epstein-related records existed?

a. Through what process did the whistleblower make this disclosure to you?
b. Was the whistleblower's disclosure provided to Congress or the DOJ Office of
Inspector General (OIG)? If no, please transmit a copy of the disclosure to the
Committee and the CHG.

c. Did DOJ identify additional documents based on the whistleblower's
disclosure?
5. Aside from the negative backlash you received over the February 27 record release,
what was the purpose of placing almost 1,000 FBI IMD personnel on 24-hour shifts
to review Epstein-related records over the course of a two-week period in March?

6. Who made the decision to reassign hundreds of New York Field Office personnel to
this March review of Epstein-related records?

7. Why were personnel told to flag records in which President Trump was mentioned?
a. Please list all political appointees and senior DOJ officials involved in the
decision to flag records in which President Trump was mentioned.

b. What happened to the records mentioning President Trump once they were
flagged?
Metadata Shows the FBI's 'Raw'Jeffrey Epstein Prison Video Was Likely Modified, WIRED (Jul. II, 2025),
https://www.wired.com/story/metadata-shows-the-dojs-raw-jeffrerepsteinprison-video-was-likely-modified.
3

c. Is there a log of the records mentioning President Trump? If yes, please
transmit a copy of the log to the Committee and the O1G.

8. Did personnel review any correspondence to Mr. Epstein, including letters compiled
in a "leather-bound album" as part of this year's review?

a. Did personnel review any correspondence between President Trump and Mr.
Epstein, including a letter in the reported "leather-bound album" as part of this
year's review?

9. Why is the July 7 memorandum making the two official findings regarding Jeffrey
Epstein unsigned by any DOJ or FBI officials?

10. Please describe in detail the process that occurred in the three-month period between
April and the July 7 memorandum, after the March review of documents, that led to
the findings in the July 7 memorandum.

11. Please list all political appointees and senior DOJ officials involved in the review of
the Epstein-related records since February 2025.

12. Please list all political appointees and senior DOJ officials involved in the drafting of
the July 7 memorandum.

13. Why does the July 7 memorandum describe the surveillance footage as "full raw"
when it was modified?

a. Please describe in detail all of the modifications made to the "full raw"
surveillance footage before its publication.
I look forward to your full and immediate responses to these questions. Prompt attention
to this important matter is crucial to understanding the truth and preventing this Administration's
actions from causing greater harm.
Sincerely,
;Ott. ) 24/ 41-1 --/
Richard J. Durbin
Ranking Member
cc: The Honorable Charles E. Grassley
Chairman, Senate Committee on the Judiciary
4
From: )1O.1 fornmnnntionce (5M03
To: polfworear (OM
Subject: FW: Letter to AG Bondi from 53C RM Durbin - 7/18/25
Date: Friday, July 18, 2025 12:34:06 PM
Attachments: 7025-07-1R R in I eltor M AG Bondi re Fostoinali
Please assign to OLA , thank you.
Best,
Office of Legislative Affairs
U.S. Department of Justice
From: Kobayashi, Veda (Judiciary-Dem)
Sent: Friday, July 18, 2025 12:21 PM
To: DOJ Correspondence (SMO)
Cc: JudDem Durbin Oversight
Subject: [EXTERNAL) Letter to AG Bondi from SJC RM Durbin - 7/18/25
Hello,
Attached, please find a letter from Ranking Member Durbin to AG Bondi. Can you please
confirm receipt?
Thanks!
Best,
Veda E. Kobayashi I she/her
Professional Staff Member
Senate Committee on the Judiciary
Ranking Member Richard J. Durbin (D-IL)
EFTA00164939 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ Powerpoint summary of Epstein investigation by Child Sex Trafficking Task Force
(approximate date: 2025-09-01)
Jeffrey Epstein
Investigations
31E -MM- 108062 : Child Sex Trafficking
72 -MM -113327: Obstruction of Justice
50D -NY-3027571: Child Sex Trafficking
90A -NY-3151227: Death Investigation
TIMELINE
7/24/2006- FBI West Palm Beach RA
opened investigation
6/2008 - Epstein accepts plea deal
9/2008 - Epstein begins 18month
sentence
10/28/2009 - FBI West Palm Beach RA
opens obstruction case into
12/8/2009 -
black book seized
arrested -
12/6/2018 - FBI NewYork opens
investigation into Epstein
7/2/2019 - Epstein Indicted
7/6/2019 - Epstein arrested at
Teterboro airport in New Jersey
7/8/2019- Detained at MCC -
Psych evaluation and observation
7/10/2019 - Placed with
in the SHU
7/23/2019- Suicide attempt
7/23/2019-7/24/2019 -Suicide watch
7/24/2019-7/29-2019 - Placed on
psychological observation
7/29/2019 - MCC Chief Psychologist
approves Epstein to be removed from
suicide watch
7/29/2019- New cellmate
in SHU
8/9/2019- Cellmate released
8/10/2019- Suicide
6/29/2020 - Maxwell indicted
7/2/2020 - Maxwell arrested
in New Hampshire
3/29/2021 - Superseding indictment
11/29/2021 - Maxwell trial begins
12/30/2021 - Maxwell convicted
6/28/2022 - Maxwell sentenced to 20
years
7/7/2022 - Maxwell Appeal
9/17/2024 - Appeal denied
4/10/2025 -Writ of Certiorari filed
7/22/2025 - DOJ formally opposed
Writ
31E -MM -108062

• 7/24/2006 FBI West Palm Beach Resident Agency opened investigation at the request of
Palm Beach County who obtained 1 state felony charge indictment

• 5/2007 - 60 count indictment drafted against Epstein
• 7/2007 — Epstein attorneys and AUSAs from Southern District of Florida met.

• Deal offered 2 state level charges (solicitation of prostitution and solicitation of prostitution with
a minor), 18 months in prison, register as a sex offender, and Non Prosecution Agreement
covering Epstein, 4 co-conspirators ( , and
) and any potential co-conspirators.

• 6/2008 — Epstein accepts deal
• 9/2008 — Epstein reports to jail
• Serves less than 13 months during which Epstein is allowed out of prison 12 hours a day to work
at his foundation.
72 -MM -113327

• 10/28/2009, FBI Miami Palm Beach RA opened an obstruction of justice case with
subject , a former employee of Epstein. failed to comply
with a federal subpoena and attempted to sell the requested documents to the
attorney for $50,000.

• The items included a small black bound book and handwritten notes regarding payments
made to victims.

• 12/8/2009 - was arrested for obstruction
• Items referenced above were seized
• 2010 - Convicted and sentenced to 18 months
5OD-NY-3O27571

• On 12/6/2018, at the request of the U.S. Attorney's Office of Southern District of New York,
FBI New York opened an investigation into allegations that Jeffery Epstein sexual abused
minors in the mid 2000's at various locations including his residents in New York.

• 3 Protective Orders cover all serials in 50D case
• 291 National Threat Operations Center (NTOC) tips

• 52 anonymous
• FBI followed up on 239 and 27 resulted in secondary contact
• 91 identified victims
• Investigators are aware there are numerous unidentified victims, who did not come forward and
could not be identified by investigative means

• Overseas victims- United Kingdom and Sweden
• 153 pieces of evidence seized under seal
• 3 Serials in 50D are classified at S//NF which have no investigative value

• Serial 538 - 11/4/2020; 539 -11/9/2020; 684 -1/20/2022
• 2 Serials in 50D are restricted which have no investigative value
5OD-NY-3O27571
SEARCH WARRANTS7/6/2019 - 9 East 71st St, New York, NY Search Warrant
• 2 items seized (blueprints, tablet)
• 7/7/2019 - 9 East 71st St, New York, NY Search Warrant - extension of July 6

• 23 items seized (CDs, photographs, costumes, erotic sculptures, sex toys, massage table, cash disbursement
records, letters)

• 7/11/2019 - 9 East 71st St, New York, NY Search Warrant - based on July 6/7 broader scope
• 43 items seized (desktops, hard drives, recorders, tablets, CDs/DVDs, USBs, camera, phone, SD card, server,
envelopes of cash, passport)

• 8/12/2019 - Little Saint James Island Search warrant
• 48 items seized (servers, surveillance system, phone system, CDs/DVDs, hard drives, desktops, laptops, tablets,
logbooks, employee records, recorder, music player, photographs, camera, remodeling documents, blueprints,
password list)

• 4 additional search warrants were obtained for items (devices or binders) seized during the execution of
these search warrants.
*All Warrants are scoped between 2002-2005
5OD-NY-3O27571
FINANCIALS

• Victims were paid in cash
• Between 2007 and 2011 over $21,000,000 was transferred from Epstein's accounts to
Maxwell's accounts, and then promptly moved to other accounts associated with
Epstein.

• Approximately $17,000 in cash seized during execution of search warrant at 9 East 71st
Street
5OD-NY-3O27571
CSAM

• Highly Responsive Material (85 GB) breakdown: Over one million images and
videos were extracted from Epstein's devices. Approximately 34,000 were marked
responsive.

• Approximately 15-20 images of CSAM (less than 1%)* not self -produced
• Approximately 90% of the files are adult pornography/adult erotica/age-difficult
pornography and erotica

• Approximately 9% of the files are personal or generic internet images
• *The CSAM was identified initially in Griffeye, a forensic tool used to analyze digital
content, and it identified the images as "known series."

╭─ Page 9, Image 1 ─╮
│ 50D-NY-3027571    │
│ VICTIMS           │
╰───────────────────╯

5OD-NY-3O27571
INDICTMENT

• Indictment - 7/2019
• Sex Trafficking Conspiracy
• Sex Trafficking
• Assest Forfeiture — New York residence

• 7/6/2019Epstein arrested at Teterboro airport in New Jersey
PROFFERS
FBI -attended Proffers SDNY Attorney Proffers
Les Wexner
Abigail Wexner
90A -NY-3 151227

• 8/10/2019, at approximately 6:30 am, Epstein was discovered unresponsive in his MCC jail
cell. Preliminary investigation revealed a series of protocol failures by MCC personnel, and
technical failures/deficiencies within MCC. As a result, a death investigation was initiated.

• 08/09/2019 approximate 7:49 pm - Epstein last observed on video returning to Special Housing Unit
(SHU) from attorney visit. Last time we see Epstein08/09/2019 10:00 pm - Lock down for the tier
• 08/09/2019 approximately 10:30 pm - Correction Officer Tova Noel seen on video walking up to each
tier

• 08/09/2019 approximately 10:40 pm - A CO, believed to be Tova Noel, carried linen or inmate
clothing up to the L Tier, last time any CO approached the only entrance to the SHU tier

• 08/10/2019 6:33 am — MCC staff discovered Epstein hanged in cell
90A -NY-3 151227
wievMd atgfrA vriri

• Approximately 450 hours of video from 7/23/2019 - 8/10/2019 (first suicide attempt - completed suicide) reviewed

• Approximately 150 cameras total in MCC
• DVR1 - functioning
• DVR2 - system failure on 7/29/2019, resulting in the system not recording. On 8/8/2019, BOP learned that DVR
#2 system was not recording.
5 times inmate head count was not conducted between 7/23/2019 - 8/9/2019
CO Michael Thomas was working 2 of those 5 shifts, including the shift during which Epstein committed
suicide

• 43 Interviews conducted: 28 MCC Staff Members (2 Interviews only OIG was present), 15 Inmates in the SHU
Case closed 12/5/2022, with no criminality found pertaining to Epstein's death. OCME autopsy report stated cause of
death was hanging and the manner of death was suicide.

• SDNY charged COs Michael Thomas and Tova Noel with False Records and Conspiracy and entered into a 6-month
deferred prosecution agreement in 5/2021. As of the case closing the set terms had been satisfied.

• During an interview on 8/16/2019 with
below note:
Epstein's second roommate, AUSA made the
-told (re aftnely- hug /yvvy.ccoc vig vim cent .1=evit +41 la loll tvvictc- -fmas •Lennti wt4-1 -11 walk. tip I-4%a otv 
44A4. - .1.sta vvi wt./Qv, ri  ft,
cottActy cry ht,
MAXWELLMaxwell was accused of assisting, facilitating, and contributing to Epstein's abuse of
minors by recruiting, grooming and abusing minors.

• Indictment - 6/29/2020
Conspiracy to Entice Minors to Travel to Engage in Illegal Sex Acts
Enticement of a Minor to Travel to Engage in Illegal Sex Acts
Conspiracy to transport Minors with Intent to Engage in Criminal Sexual Activity

• Transportation of a Minor with Intent to Engage in Criminal Sexual Activity
• Perjury (2 counts)
• Arrested on 7/2/2020 in New Hampshire
1 phone taken during arrest, other devices observed in home but not seized

• Superseding indictment - 3/2021
• Addition of sex trafficking of a minor and sex trafficking conspiracy
- charged victim
MAXWELL
TRIAL

• Trial - 11/29/2021 - 12/29/2021
Charges:
• Count 1- Conspiracy to Entice Minors to Travel to Engage in Illegal Sex Acts - Guilty ( December 29,2021)

• Count 2- Enticement of a Minor to Travel to Engage in Illegal Sex Acts - Not Guilty ( December 29,2021)

• Count 3- Conspiracy to transport Minors with Intent to Engage in Criminal Sexual Activity- Guilty ( December 29,2021)

• Count 4 -Transportation of a Minor with Intent to Engage in Criminal Sexual Activity - Guilty ( December 29,2021)

• Count 5- Sex Trafficking Conspiracy - Guilty ( December 29,2021)
• Count 6- Sex Trafficking of a Minor — Guilty ( December 29,2021)

• 2 Perjury charges were intended to be litigated at a later time, SDNY chose not to
pursue after initial trial.

• The defense presented focused on discrediting witnesses, questioning their ability to
recall activities from decades prior, and aimed to portray Maxwell as a victim of
circumstances and Epstein's scapegoat. Claimed Maxwell was targeted by Epstein and
was unaware of abuse due to secrets kept by Epstein.

• 6/28/2022 Sentencing - 20 years in prison with 5 years supervised release and $750,000
fine.
MAXWELL
TRIAL VICTIMS
aka " " - testified
- testified
) - testified under first name only
aka " "— testified
) - charged
MAXWELL
POST -TRIAL

• Appeal against sex trafficking conviction - 7/7/2022
• Federal court upholds conviction - 9/17/2024
• Writ of Certiorari filed with Supreme Court - 4/10/2025Justice Department formally opposed writ - 7/22/2025DOJ interview of Maxwell - 7/24/2025, 7/25/2025
PROMINENT NAMES
Trump :

1. stated Epstein introduced her to Trump
who subsequently forced her head down to his
exposed penis which is subsequently bite. In
response, Trump punched her in the head and kicked
her out.

2. remember Epstein introduced her to
Trump saying "This is a good one, huh" and Trump
responded "Yes".
Weinstein :

1. stated she gave Weinstein a
massage, during which he fondled her, masturbated
and offered to pay her extra if he could ejaculate on
her chest.

2. stated Weinstein came to her
apartment, offered her a job and then tried to follow
her into the shower.

3. stated Epstein told her to give Weinstein a
massage, during which Weinstein tells her to take off
her shirt, she refuses and then Weinstein threatens to
get women to come force her too.
Glen Dubin :
stated Maxwell instructed her
to give Dubin a massage and do what she did for
Epstein.
Prince Andrew :

1. stated Maxwell told her to
make Prince Andrew happy by doing "exact same
things to him that she did for Epstein because he is
good friends with Maxwell."

2. Steve Scully witnessed Prince Andrew on Epstein's
Island grinding against a young girl.
3. stated Prince Andrew and Epstein flew
on Epstein's plane and had orgies.
Jes Staley :
stated Epstein told her to give Staley
a massage at Epstein's mansion. Staley forced her to
hands on his crotch and had "rough sex" with her.
Leon Black :

1. stated Epstein told her to give Black
a massage while Black was naked. stated
another female gave Black a massage and he made
her preform oral sex. Epstein made jokes about
Black's penis size.

2. stated Black raped her numerous
times and sex trafficked her (including at Epstein's).
Black threatened to destroy her life and stated he
connections with the police.
Les Wexner :

1. stated Epstein earned his money from
having homosexual sex with Weimer.
Alan Dershowitz
1. stated she gave him a massage on
Epstein's plane. (not a minor)
Bill Clinton :
, not a victim in Epstein case, claimed
she was invited to an orgy with Clinton but did not
attend
Howard Lutnick :

1. reported that Lutnick made his
money through Ponzi schemes and money
laundering. Lutnick and Epstein were neighbors and
Epstein sold Lutnick a home for $10 which was then
sold for millions.
William Barr/Leon Black:

1. NTOC filed by , stated Barr and
Black were present during abuses.
stated was at Epstein's for a model event, ran into
Barr who stated he wanted to see her next time he
came. At another point, Epstein asked if she had
ever met Ban.
*Numerous anonymous NTOC's were received with
allegations against prominent individuals.
MISCONCEPTIONS

• Based on review of evidence and victim statements no orgies, or threesomes which
included 2 males
• Victims were not held captive
• Epstein did not regularly prostitute the victims in exchange for money
QUESTIONS?
EFTA00001926 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Ver4 11.
51.511n CUZU
on new — been
Rol have been for
have ,
„Lae Z. pert, Ls.? Wr y  ikiny hal5
ri"C 47051year WCUld
4 a wander fa/ iiiiic ..: •-. f • ,
.. MI 5iefer :..., , trip and also 44 h,,I ,,,,,,  ' 11.-44) iitexic,,I visit me for ?he v,„ /4: .... iiitc.1:49,a 
olritintic your apQrinzeizi in iii,.. :
4n/itch eta sier and Leis stic:53,,
lig  life so , to have ins own 51,,ace tut:. i,_ . s:/ery .litc4 draw with-out jai any o artyorit .. . crryilly a bni
.-..i be cm/lei atui
iniviiny on erinzii.y or other Prier - r 1,1i, a19°
vet hind of on 0 help -ezn friend dlekezni-Ira, hrt ill )9 `4'',.-7-1,„!.4.--trie-himi, r have no/ 'c• : ,..72 Si .'t  
.. • ; ; 'ic C.' net of:- ...eci O:::':
+4c. .47; Me iiiO51 .,. ic>ii h(21'. ‘.--;:. - ... iva5h me lo 4,-.7ty. • h"../ ?fiiiiik ail, ...' i bk:Mank volt:',7 
vozi ,'11,y 1 ..- ojr ele
, ,, ,
╔══════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Hongbo Robert Bao [tech] Peter Thiel's Valar Ventures 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00001951 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Nova TO tel-up the Itablø • n.• et. &gated obi.- ...uon le, lie rubber taaropers

ph. Ow 1..1 of your land, bump the W. Proo•ro gly• face .uonnt and n.. will <penrya. II me I • • Open 'be
onetow'hap
••• elnerftlt-O
rtes too O
To Set the table
t/Pright, • When at table la hilly opened. tit the tabbe tapelykt until all fost teas act on the floor Lift Ceti end of 
the %chic...Kona down on the middle and
tension day cables • tusk. (flg ti To Change the TOW* Height: to o at hole rna reprewn“ the goo./ hop,ht and after 
renaming the knob pot the bolt through that
hole fte ego e and laftern the knob by lund oolil ono: Repeat on al) otbcr leg ea.. cc. tong all [µteharme al ,op, low»,
.1.g .41
III III II II II ill il! ii
LISTED
lo Clot* ttallt US:

no. table ea Vs We ~I Oa • hasp«. Os tit øn • won« a ~Er the whit by nattgoo the iftlalealaiS ~Own into due ay ~Wt. Ms 
It Ponta atom tbe ~taw

• Pold the Ion bao at. obis sad tube sow the ~not la Si Or cad he conk* are Ian& of abc table hash
ly-6 thr two ~tog of vow table asset to lock ths 61
Tor TØ with the tNo%u Option: • with pat obit on lb alit. eraa the cables born Ow tap Obi Ha) and tror) the usiftock 
clap to the ante (hi ti • )bld Olt
IhOgottOrbt the tubbable and tty abc uNe down An on tnt fluor GW-9)

• To haunt In horned height aeti.~. see at  CAlftION latt that la-knot attc %bubo CAM. Option
CAUTION
Dynamic Load Rating:
450 lbs.
andcrafted in tin: i •s.k.
OAF:W0RKS.. Inc. 923 Fiss ‘elkwTing Neu Prude" PA t7 49 Toll free Phone. 800-54PrfigS0 Hoot 717-235430i Toll Free MX. 
877-562-4787 F.% 717..2;5-6798 www.aalowd
EFTA00002134 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
\N"
s.•-•
\-\\\N•
/// '' ' ' ' '''''''''
younitif/i/II/19///:
id/lit//t1/!!'"1/11 ,,,,,,,////////////,3/4
;/virt,1/4//////f4frbi. niiill1/1/10111/111111111 • w 1/49/ 41/////////5 it/
f01/1 lit
IlltiVIIIIIM11111/111
A
"
,///,/////////n///7/241.41/./
,l/
/1////////”//////////41/4/
,,,
llllllllllllllllllllllll
/,,,,,/,•///./////1/40//,l
ll ”MI/"414199
a //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
ihnammil12117111/
//////// W/04011,414//1•1
,611 ,//'Sill)

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ MMM               │
│                   │
│ MOMMA,            │
│                   │
│ WU                │
│ Ln                │
│ MII)              │
│                   │
│ ” TMM)            │
│ Md                │
│ YM                │
│ EL                │
│ Uy                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002223 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
e um
AL 4 r. 110,-

• id
1 1.11 \r ite\ :47^ ;
rub. 1- ,
A •  dip —a 17 7 14, fit
...r,r.../TA1;,r III , lei

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002529 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
mg, nhi,%.I I,MHVIiVxbNnt()I7Abl•(ViSdkpin"projeckw:- I &Inns -try Parilt1 1.‘

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002547 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
.•••••••••••/1/1M/IMM••••.a.
- '•••••••

• IfF
11,5121
n
146/311
10Kr
a
t
HP
MODEL:
116BB976
• •5•••
en OtEll$1
HP
PIN:
43,16S-003
PRODuC
•
SINGAPORE
•
CT:
28976026CWBE20
43
7
NI
76
(
E
D33077
€4,1•102SI
voce
arras
00)32T
PART
NUMBER:
•9F6066-035.
*41
2
3..5
IHIlAl
LOT
NUMBER:
PA
-01-092076P
FIRMWARE
HPDC
IWImWIIIIWWIIII
IWIIWMIIuuINWI
14j
'I•50
aeC
5e4W
2A4Ele
SERIAL
NUMBER:
somm,H6e0*
• • ST9146802SS
I
•
1111111111111filliff,IllfillIll
GPN:
375863-010
•
100422661
lfithm
EFTA00003038 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
uarters,
Suite
B-3,
St.
Thomas.
VI
00802-1348
Phone:
E-mail:
thesaintjames.group@gmail.com
Emergency
Contact
Form
Today's
Date:
Li_
_
14
—
7_0
17
Employee
Name:
I
ii(c
Beiyhrt.S.6244
Physical
Address:
Mailing
Address:
Cell
Phone:
E-mail: Title/Position: Allergies
or
Health
Concern
I NI
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:
3 -
`1,5
-2-o
lc/
-5C151-0,
Phone
(other):
Marital
Status:
Driver's
License
No:
Current
Medications:
4
Doctors
Name:
Doctors
Name:
Doctors
Phone.
Doctors
Phone:
in
case
of
emergency,
please
contact:
Name
—
1,
Phone:
Relationship
—1-1Ce
4C1
Nam,
Phone:
I
Relationship:
12
foth
e y
j
This
information
is for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others.

╭─────────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ [eae — « [3-235 -a2017 |              │
│                                       │
│ Maurice  Sealutua Sher ue of Cis I co │
│ Oe                                    │
│                                       │
│ 58 Thomas 0-I poko2 |                 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00005731 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
•
sits ren. o
yo-nek-e ere N y

4
OIL ek z . (2\ jc\4.\-4/\\Qpa c900,ar
NyA vAN-c Atfceigk 0- parrs vEW,ACCteltv—r el/et va gyo 721.87 _cup, p7 cws-e.s- T/e
7 1-ST/CE /IL Ate3 /Areal
als4s- reit. of
X,tare-e
A/7/070,3
a
eJusticeNY Integrated Justice Ponal Page 1 of 1
eJusticeNYINTEGRATED JUSTICE PORTAL
PeopI  • pNIV Photo System  • DMv Photo Reavest 1+• Feedback
DMV Photo Request
DMV Photo
ase Number:
ame:
lientID:
DMV Transaction Number:
DMV Transaction Date/Time:
0 DI
June 6, 2019 11:41 AM ED
... 6/6/2019
EFTA00005924 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
*d e
NJP Response Page 1 ct 1
Unouthorfrod scan. reproduction, or dlonnilnotlor is prot•lb.ted.
RECEIVED AT 07/02/2019 19:27:08 10
DR.
19:1,91,2019 24038
19:37 07/02/2019 00336 NY10100T2
*0420470034
TXT
PALM BEACH FL 3348e
PALM BEACH FL 33480
TYPE LIC: CLASS E OPERATOR DOB: HT: 510 RACE: W SEX: F
CURRENT LICENSE ISSUED: 06/29/2009 EXPIRED: 06 29
EXPIRED LICENSE SOC SEC:
END OF DDL/DHSMV RESPONSE.
Unauthorized access, reproduction, or dissemination is prohibited.
https://www.ejustice.ny.gov/IWUViewMessagc.jsp?msgid=26693548zpager.offse 7/2/2011)
Grand Jury Subpoena
PrritebStatez pistrict QImS
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
TO:
GREETINGS:
WE COMMAND YOU that all and singular business and excuses being laid aside, you appear and attend before
the GRAND JURY of the people of the United States for the Southern District of New York, at the 'Jnited States
Courthouse, 40 Foley Square, Room 220, in the Borough of Manhattan. City of New York, Na.. York, in the
Southern District of New York, at the following date, time and place:
Appearance Date: July 24, 2019 Appearance Time: 10:00 a.m.
to testify and give evidence in regard to an alleged violation of :
I
and not to depart the Grand Jury without leave thereof, or of the United States Attorney, and that you bring
with you and produce at the above time and place the following:
See attached Advice of Rights
Failure to attend and produce any items hereby demanded will constitute contempt of court and will
subject you to civil sanctions and criminal penalties, in addition to other penalties of the Law.
DATED: New York, New York
lv 5,2019
GEOFFREY S. B AN
United States Attorney for the
cnilthprn
Assistant United States Attorneys
One St. Andrew's Plaza
New York, New York 10007
Telephone: (212) 637-2415
rev. 02.01.12
Advice of Rights

I. You may refuse to answer any question if a truthful answer to the question would tend to
incriminate you.

2. Anything that you do say may be used against you by the grand jury or in a subsequent legal
proceeding.

3. If you have a lawyer, the grand jury will permit you a reasonable opportunity to step outside the
grand jury room to consult with your lawyer if you so desire.

4. If you would like a lawyer but do not have funds to retain one, you may make an application to
the United States Magistrate Judge who will decide whether to appoint a lawyer to represent you.
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
TheSilvioI Mello Building
One Sam Andrew's Plaza
New York New York 10007
July 5, 2019
Re: Grand Jury Subpoena
Please be advised that the accompanying grand jury subpoena has been issued in connection with
an official criminal investigation of a suspected felony being conducted by a federal grand jury. The
Government hereby requests that you voluntarily refrain from disclosing the existence of the subpoena to
any third party. While you are under no obligation to comply with our request, we are requesting you not
to make any disclosure in order to preserve the confidentiality of the investigation and because disclosure
of the existence of this investigation might interfere with and impede the investigation.
Moreover, if you intend to disclose the existence of this subpoena to a third party, please let me
know before making any such disclosure.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
Very truly yours,
GEOFFIEY S. BERMAN
I InitaA limn o
Assistant United States Attorneys

(212) 637-2415
Page 1 of 1
file:///CilUsers/byme941477/AppData/LocaVMicrosoft/WindowatTemporary%20Interner/o... 7/2/2019

╭──────────────────────────────────────── Page 6, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ ee ee ee eS ge ee ee                                                                            │
│ Page 1 of 1                                                                                     │
│                                                                                                 │
│ file:///C:/Users/byrne941477/AppData/Local/Microsoft/ Windows/Temporary%20Internet%... 7/2/2019 │
│ TT                                                                                              │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00006367 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
r
IMPQRTAP1T WIESS?A.GE:
FOR
DATE— Alit a
4 a Fir,zz-i..
M
TELEPHONED : .%(PLF,4kSE:41- .
Vitigilersiakt :. - WiLi,o4Aciikit4 ",
kom,WV,09 1u 410-,
!ROSS yglypioii, t 00eciAi., ATOM**
MESSAGE  • • 1 1.31:7‘f(?
tiLA•  A14, ii*E ffictpet?
OF
PHONE!
MOBILE
*LEpHotsito : ?AAcg-c!aii-...
c. AmE 1p ?0” ,om wi WILCCAU.AGAIN  1'
WAIsitotO SEE YOU ' RUSH
iiatpi3mc0 voyil pit; SEECIA4A7TEN11OINL 4-1:
MESSAGE  1' 1t. t. '.0
t
- ., „:„„ 1 1, 1.-‘t ri
SIGNED S
1184
•
SIGNED
•
• PPR  ' tfQ7e: Iht „- •
tbAtE  1 1451c, .  Ths  isrA
OF  , NI1 n il A X‘APE.
PHONE/
MOBILE  • •
TEI:ROHONEIft .... .  -.'  it.gfrof GALL •. . ..
'GAME TckstE YOU ' WILL CALLSAIN . *AM. TO SEE RUSH . . .. .YOU
RERJRRED YOUR CAU,. . ... .. . . ..
.
BRECIALATYENTION.
MESSAGE  It 1-1 If)4
SIGNED
CA LL rt.. "
I

╭──────────── Page 2, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ A                                        │
│                                          │
│ fed                                      │
│ 2a                                       │
│                                          │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE | IMPORTANT MESSAGE    │
│                                          │
│ a é                                      │
│                                          │
│ i                                        │
│                                          │
│ a ___                                    │
│                                          │
│ TELEPHONED: [PLEASE CALL                 │
│ [Galas TO:sE= YOU Witt GALL AGAIN        │
│ Juan to seevoy [__[avsH                  │
│                                          │
│ RETURNED YOURGAR| | SPEOIAL ATTENTION    │
│                                          │
│ PHONE)                                   │
│ MOBILE,                                  │
│                                          │
│ dy od                                    │
│                                          │
│ TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL,                  │
│ {Game 70 See YOu | Twix calLacann        │
│ [WANTS TOSEE YOu RUSH                    │
│                                          │
│ AETURNED YOUR GaL(| [SPECIAL ATTENTION   │
│                                          │
│ wessae. RETUNING YOUR Cau"               │
│                                          │
│ b                                        │
│                                          │
│ LEE ci                                   │
│                                          │
│ eens                                     │
│                                          │
│ BED                                      │
│                                          │
│ +]                                       │
│                                          │
│ SIGNED. ifs                              │
│                                          │
│ Bp                                       │
│                                          │
│ Need                                     │
│                                          │
│ Sw                                       │
│                                          │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE |                      │
│ roa_MR- EPSTEIN ee                       │
│ a                                        │
│                                          │
│ or MS MAXWELL                            │
│                                          │
│ PHONE!                                   │
│ MOBILE.                                  │
│                                          │
│ MOBILE.                                  │
│                                          │
│ TELEPHONED PLEASE.CALL                   │
│ CAWETO SEE YOU [WILE CALL AGAIN          │
│ WANTS TO SEE YOU. RUSH                   │
│                                          │
│ RETURNED YouR Can, | [SPECIAL ATTENTION, │
│                                          │
│ WS Ne G                                  │
│                                          │
│ TELEPHONED [> JReASe can                 │
│                                          │
│ Cale 10 SE YOU | [WRLLCALLAGAN           │
│ lwanTsT0 See YOU | [RUSH I               │
│ RETURNED YOUR Galt| | SBEgIALATIENTION | │
│                                          │
│ wesssce ‘lease Catt                      │
│                                          │
│ essrce TELL HIM To                       │
│                                          │
│ LA                                       │
│                                          │
│ IW Retevence AME                         │
│                                          │
│ 1@                                       │
│                                          │
│ gyda                                     │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00006380 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
' 3Cia\-Le n 4} C" 3
r
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR 1 --1 •
DATE 1 i 9 0 TIME  ' (I'
M
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
SIGNED 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
v FOR IP -
D .( 1'4S/1- A.M. P.M.
M
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME•TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
SIGNED 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR •
•
OF
PHONE/. MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL • .
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
. \Iwo '? rchtafr.
SIGNED
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR
6--./ .1 ...,A.M.
D •---eP.M.
M
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE GALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
ar; SIGNED it

╭──────────── Page 2, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                        │
│                                          │
│ FOR,                                     │
│                                          │
│ os                                       │
│                                          │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                        │
│                                          │
│ FoR. al                                  │
│                                          │
│ ae                                       │
│                                          │
│ ia ak                                    │
│                                          │
│ PHONE)                                   │
│                                          │
│ MOBILE.                                  │
│                                          │
│ [TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL                  │
│ (CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN         │
│                                          │
│ WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH                    │
│ RETURNED YOUR GALL| _| SPECIAL ATTENTION │
│                                          │
│ PHONE!                                   │
│                                          │
│ MOBILE.                                  │
│                                          │
│ TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL                   │
│ (CAME TO SEE YOU [WILL GALLAGAIN         │
│                                          │
│ [wants 70 see vou | [rua                 │
│ [Return voun cauc| [speci ATTENTION      │
│                                          │
│ i i i                                    │
│ obove,                                   │
│                                          │
│ MESSAGE. MESSAGE.                        │
│                                          │
│ Viez te Call har                         │
│                                          │
│ “The > Female                            │
│                                          │
│ HELO                                     │
│                                          │
│ Dov haw                                  │
│                                          │
│ Wa Ww al |                               │
│                                          │
│ v2)                                      │
│ ey                                       │
│                                          │
│ eae                                      │
│ aoa                                      │
│                                          │
│ SIGNED,                                  │
│                                          │
│ a                                        │
│ a                                        │
│                                          │
│ @@.s                                     │
│                                          │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE |                      │
│                                          │
│ ron le                                   │
│                                          │
│ jaa                                      │
│                                          │
│ IGOBDSD                                  │
│                                          │
│ PHONE                                    │
│ MOBILE,                                  │
│                                          │
│ a                                        │
│ og                                       │
│                                          │
│ oo                                       │
│                                          │
│ a                                        │
│ Seta paaon                               │
│ mere fe                                  │
│ RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIALATTENTION |    │
│                                          │
│ TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL                   │
│ (CAMEO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN           │
│ WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH                    │
│                                          │
│ RETURNED YOUR CALL| || SPECIAL ATTENTION │
│                                          │
│ @                                        │
│                                          │
│ MESSAGE. MESSAGE.                        │
│                                          │
│ SIGNED.                                  │
│                                          │
│ foes ne A SW                             │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────╯

IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR  fi
DATE I Z
M
OF
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL '
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AG*,
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH.
RETURNED YOUR CALL I SPECIAL ATTENTION
TIME  10S OO  P.M
MESSAGE
\C73?..i 6
SIGNED   1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR - 3 •
IDATE I ? °1• !DC- TIME oc. 00 r itt
M
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU •
,
WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL • SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
r? tisa c,..1.1 kr-, to?di
SIGNED it •
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
•FOR IA t • - 3 ..T .. , ...- . , , C.M. / DATE I CY) -nmE 43 i3 PM
i
M -1
OF r 9) let .g N \
PHONE/.MOBILE
TELEPHONED ! PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU . RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL : SPECIAL ATTENTION
. MtSSAGE -
el l \ CS •IS \ NG v V't Ski • •
C 6 11! n vw‘‘)Cd--.. - .T\ 8?S A .
. . Call I, 161-
SIGNED 1164
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR
DATE  I
OF
PHONE MOBIL
TELEPHONED I Pt FASE CALL I
CAME TO SEE YOU I WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL
I
SPECIAL ATTENTION
TIME 4.(i. I A.M.
MESSAGE

╭───────────────────────────────── Page 3, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────────╮
│ i                                                                                 │
│ y                                                                                 │
│                                                                                   │
│ Orns                                                                              │
│                                                                                   │
│ PouDooDOUCLS                                                                      │
│                                                                                   │
│ re                                                                                │
│                                                                                   │
│ |                                                                                 │
│ ae                                                                                │
│                                                                                   │
│ errrerre                                                                          │
│                                                                                   │
│ Sererrerr!                                                                        │
│                                                                                   │
│ Fleles                                                                            │
│                                                                                   │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                                 │
│                                                                                   │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                                 │
│                                                                                   │
│ rons —{ E.                                                                        │
│                                                                                   │
│ nie                                                                               │
│                                                                                   │
│ ron                                                                               │
│                                                                                   │
│ pare___11 2 /: te lOlO9 Biv,                                                      │
│                                                                                   │
│ ome 29]o5 __ ie 1a in GHP                                                         │
│                                                                                   │
│ M                                                                                 │
│ oF. oF Rrzi                                                                       │
│                                                                                   │
│ feted fetid                                                                       │
│                                                                                   │
│ Telepaons> | [PEAS mL Trecerioneo | [Pease can                                    │
│ (AME TO SEE VOU | | WILL CALLAGAN [GAME TO SEEYOU | [WILL CALLAGAN                │
│ WANTS T0 SEE YOU | [RUSH WANTS T0 SEE YOU |__| RUSH                               │
│ RETURNED YOUR GALL| | SPECIAL ATTENTION RETURNED YOURCALL| | SPECIALATTENTION |_| │
│ MESSAGE wessace:                                                                  │
│                                                                                   │
│ Were colt hee,                                                                    │
│                                                                                   │
│ This is her new                                                                   │
│                                                                                   │
│ Coll, number. Peace                                                               │
│                                                                                   │
│ call her                                                                          │
│                                                                                   │
│ SIGNED.                                                                           │
│                                                                                   │
│ SIGNED.                                                                           │
│                                                                                   │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                                 │
│                                                                                   │
│ FoR. DE                                                                           │
│                                                                                   │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                                 │
│ FoR =                                                                             │
│                                                                                   │
│ = no hile = “1 Alt                                                                │
│ DATE. toad time 2:00 Ph owe GoJo swe £10 A                                        │
│ oF oF.                                                                            │
│ PHONE/| . PHON!                                                                   │
│ MOBILE MOBILE                                                                     │
│ FFELEPHONED PLEASE OAL Taieon> | [Reasecan                                        │
│ CAWETO SEEVOU | [WILL GALLAGAN CAMEO SEE YOU WiLL CALL AGAIN                      │
│ WANTS TO SEE YOU | [RUSH WANTS TO SEE YOU |_| RUSH                                │
│ RETURNED YOUR CALL] __ | SPEGIALATTENTION FETURNED YOUR Cali |_| SPECIALATTENTION │
│ MESSAGE MESSAGE.                                                                  │
│ nN                                                                                │
│ - - =— .                                                                          │
│ Plesse coil bev bok AL beve 3 tewele                                              │
│                                                                                   │
│ SIGNED,                                                                           │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007714 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007720 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007872 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
,
5 :v
E IDE ON 4 tt*FEDERAL BUREAU OF ItAViES
:II •
O avtr ON ts FEDERAL BURET OF i
'1 1B7-7
1.
hS 1OZ1
1-:a° "'SC)
sodirokow

╭──── Page 3, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR I- 5
DATE / 3/4 4 ,--r . TIME sg M --< tre rr ,Znise #
OF
PHON
MOBIL
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL ■
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN ■
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH ■
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTE N I ION
MESSAGE i
/ ...ivemzect ..,_ Atzt lid,
ad fin) -4Y- beitvede
/O to — /O  3t' /Of
SIGNE i
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR J . F .
DATE /O/1/ bc" TIME aiilitI A
M TO 6 0 75 fro ck mei api....
OF
PHON
MOBIL
TELEPHONED .-- PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
•

a. SIGNE i 1184
.4•Aas•%-- ,,sWalle•
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR j  • e • DATE  id, C  TIME  7 :7 0
Mje I-7 Ce2k1SW 1 /Y4
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED X PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
SIGNE
a
1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE",
FOR
DATE
M  31't7 (i sle/inn ilh
OF
PHONE/
MOBLF
TELEPHONED X PLEASE CALL • .
CAME TOSEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETUAMED Y9Uft C4L SPEOI4 ATTENTION

Cr) f  •
10I leS e  TIME 0  in
MESSAGE
SIGNE 1184
/8 7- 7 .

╭─ Page 7, Image 1 ─╮
│ IB7-7             │
╰───────────────────╯

IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR 3- ^E.
DATE irilliti-C TIP/ :_an
M 370 14 L4 5 ht2 ck wag
OF
PHO
MOB
TELEPHONED M .  PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU' 'WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE-YOU 'RUSH
RETURNED YOURCALL' SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
a SIGNED 1184
. IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR j "-- if •
DATE /14O/9 -e -  TIME 5 it -
m Sendini t3c-r •
OF
PHON
MOBIL
ni• TELEPtivraP  ' PLEASE CALL
CAME l`GEEE YOU WILL.CAU. AC4IN
WANTS It Aet you •RUSH ■
•PEIVRNEE YOUR Orli, IIIaFTCIAIATtENTIptt •
MESSAGE
t i ‘,:or ..14:70ine ratztatfir
401 144 1 Vi‘ beim/ea se
/0 cr - ro 3 v AMPY
EFTA00007968 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00008020 (Jmail)
 [book] "Massage for Dummies"
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
"Massage for Dummies"
EFTA00008482 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Chain of Custody - ELSUR Evidcatt Mc  Snip Envelope
FD-5044 (Rev. S-31-2017)
Case File #:  7 6 - 04- 3) 5 9 .5q 9  #:
Doc#  Total #  ,nitre
Case Agent/Task Force Officer.  SR
4
Evidence Type: 0 Title 111 ❑ FISA 0 Consensual Monitoring 0 Computer Trespass
El /Video Surveillance ❑ PR/IT ❑ Aerial Survelliance 0 Object T
EI/ Ijon-Custodial — Overt Interview 0 Custodial — Interview
0 Non-Custodial — Surreptitious Interview 0 Other
Enclosure: ErOriginat 0 Enhanced Original
Media Type: lia(CD/DVD/Blue Ray 0 Hard Drive 0 SD Card 0 Other
Intercept Date(s):  .eil li RI  Location:
Download Date:  I3. it( 3.2,  Download Time:  1995 pen
Title Ill/CM Interceptees —Er/Listed Below or 0 Sec Attached
'Chat- a is_ 1-1-ar ric
Print Name:
Signature: ,
Date:  T. Mime: Reason:  TR"
Tracking ti  -
Print Name:
Signature:
Date:
Reason:
Tracking #:
_Lei., Ye ky
Print Name:
Signature:   Signature: Print Name:
Date:  IS) 2 i ff  Time:  t O 1 2 Date:  1 //3 Time: •
e co. LA-lia r ( Reason:  --darinse;$ S2
Reason:
Tracking #:
Print Name:
Signature: n
Date: Tior: O
ROYOaC  I VI, pi) r 01(4 ih
MASS
Tracking #:
Print Name:
Signature:
Date: 2— /
Reason:
Tracking #:

╭────────────────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────────────────────────────╮
│ Q me) e                                                                      │
│ econ ELS eset See Er PLE MH BT ENE                                           │
│                                                                              │
│ cuore: 70¢-NY-3)54 599 we                                                    │
│                                                                              │
│ Doct Total                                                                   │
│                                                                              │
│ ‘Case Agent/Task Force Officer: __S/                                         │
│                                                                              │
│ Evidence Type: C1] Tide © E] ISA [J Consensual Monitoring) Computer Trespass │
│ Lf Video Surveillance COPRTT —DDAerial Surveltiance [1 Object T              │
│ 1 ‘won- Catal ~ Over aterview CO Custodial - Interview                       │
│ D Non-Custodial—Surreptitious Interview  [] Other.                           │
│                                                                              │
│ Enclosure: (Original 1 Enhanced Original                                     │
│                                                                              │
│ Media Type: EXcDDVDBIueRay CHardDrive 1 SDCerd O]_Other                      │
│                                                                              │
│ Download Date: jaa. Download Time:___ 12.35 pim                              │
│                                                                              │
│ Title UCM Interoeptees Beene See Attached                                    │
│ mn Pe                                                                        │
│                                                                              │
│ ‘Accepted Custody Released Custody                                           │
│                                                                              │
│ Print Name:                                                                  │
│ Signature:                                                                   │
│                                                                              │
│ Date:__T71s 3 ‘Time:                                                         │
│                                                                              │
│ Reason: k                                                                    │
│ ‘Tracking                                                                    │
│                                                                              │
│ Print Name: Print Name:                                                      │
│ Signature: Signature:                                                        │
│ Date: 1/18] 29, Time:_|OLZerar, Date Time:                                   │
│                                                                              │
│ Reason Pre ee ary Reason — 74                                                │
│ faces al eer =                                                               │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008487 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Oras .4t Evidence Envelope
Enclosure: el Original 0 Duplicate 0 Enhanced Original
Medium: 0 Magnetic Tape 0 Computer Disk 0 Printed Material
Case Filers 1X - MS1 -  tnIa -7  IDA  it 4 Cast Agt. Tape/Disk*:
Agt. Supervising Title III Intercepts:
O Court Authorized Intercept Source/SymboIN:

• Consensual Monitoring Intercept- CMN (if assigned):  Crtii ,64P
piSe Telephonic (TCM) 0 Nontelephonic (NTCM)
If NTCM Specify Device Used:
❑ Recording of an Interview
❑ Volunteered/Subpoenaed Medium - Not FBI ELSUR
O Other Type of Recordin Interception, Specify:
Intercept Date: Place:
Data Transferred for Permanent Storage Date;

• Consensual: List Interceptees Below
OM re A hm ibeA( Az  FL
1110 3 /0 9  Time: (P. 5 ipm
0 Court Authorized: Enter" See Log" Below
Signatu
Date: it
ented Custody ',pleated
Signature:
rustodv
jul 10\ Time: Date: )4../#1 .
Reason: Lvrr jit4Gf4 Reason: /C
03 AO -1-1•1
Signature
Date:
Reason:
NOLLVOI1S3ANI
30
Signature:
Date:
Reason:
1.1 01.1t,
I'll HI MIMI°
E02782876

╭───── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ = PEUENAL BYUNEAY Ur meee │
│ fe . Y                    │
│                           │
│ INVESTIGATION             │
╰───────────────────────────╯
EFTA00039312 (Jmail)
 [government] Program Statement / Memo about BOP Pharmacy Program
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Program Statement / Memo about BOP Pharmacy Program
EFTA00101927 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of (unknown), claims Glenn and Eva Dubin's Swiss au pair was being held against her will
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) .1 of 1.
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
OFFICIAL. RECORD
Date of entry  02/26/2021
, date of birth (DOB) , was interviewed
telephonically. After being advised of the identity of the interviewing
Agent and the nature of the interview, provided the following
information:
has been around EVA DUBIN; they both worked in the same
industry. has pictures of people directly associated with JEFFREY
EPSTEIN. does not have pictures of a crime being committed, nor did
she witness anything. has sat at dinners with famous people.
heard directly from a young lady who was an au pair to GLEN
DUBIN and EVA DUBIN. The young lady told she was being held against
her wishes, but did not believe it at the time.
resides in California. The DUBINs have been in California.
is originally from New York.
sent a photograph to writer in which identified EVA. EVA
had just had breast implants after her cancer.
advised there were "key players" involved in trafficking from
Switzerland. knew this for a fact because she had heard it.
knows of a "key player" who she believed to be involved. This
key player was a multimillionaire who showed her a chain of a golden penis.
He told her he was part of a group who drinks the blood of children.
did not want to give his name at the time of this interview.
was not comfortable sharing names over the phone. wanted
to speak in person. Then advised she was not comfortable meeting in
person due to the pandemic. A virtual interview was coordinated for
2/11/2021.
Investigation on 02/08/2021 ■t New York, New York, United States (Phone)
File# SOD—NY-3027571 Date drafted 02/24/2021
by
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Alistair Darling [europe] former UK Chancellor of the Exchequer under Gordon Brown 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00263284 (Jmail)
 [government] notes about deceit and sexual manipulation by Australian professor Vincent Bulone
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
2018-2019 *PATTERNS OF BEHAVIOR*
CONSPIRED SEXUAL TARGETING - VINCENT BULONE
*MARRIAGE PROPOSAL* - CONNECTED TO *FRANCE* SWEDEN
PATTERN OF CONDUCT / BEHAVIOUR
* Portrayed himself as a relationship / Defacto relationship -  <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>

• Targeting on a dating site
*  • Gained trust - generous - kind - sensitive - portrayed as being caring and supportive,
1 kind natured and trust worthy

• Deceitful - Lying about his relationship partner Tula Terry - Lying about his name - Lying about the photographs on 
the dating site that were a prostitute -
Lying about looking for sexual experimentation - constant lying about his behaviour and activities • Prostitution 
involvement - Sophia, Adelaide

• Continuous lying - Deceitful Behaviour
• Denial of behaviour - Womanising
• Portrayed betrayal to cause emotional devastation  - Scratches on his neck and shoulders as if being with another 
woman and lying claiming that "Your nails
are slCur when we had not had sexual relations before the event
4- • Started saying "Thank you" after sexual interactions - form of grooming for
1 prostitution and disrespect of the relationship and victim
? Reverse tactic of Fraudulent Activity and Targeting - Toconfuse the victim and make her believe that he had become the
target and he was not the predator of
sexual
targeting and government targeting
4 • Conspiring with the Government - Second attempt of Murder to appear as suicide /
* Psychological encouragement - Chiming that I had a Mental Health Problem and that
I was delusional about his behaviour
"*. • Womanising - Constant contact with other woman - Constant attention to other women
- constantly talldng about other women  A >fr• • Marriage proposals - Numerous marriage proposals - Creating a false 
sense of security4  6 Dpg
leading to emotional destruction to create vulnerability / fall into the arms of someone else for emotional comfort

• Started to become un-supporting - Claimed he would reduce his work travel
commitments but instead increased them leaving me at home un-supported and alone
in the home - Resulting in emotional vulnerability
i • Started to show a lack of interest in sexual relations

• Portrayed as a relationship - Introduced me to his parents and sister in _-
Deceitful behaviour, no respect for his family or myself - Introduced me to his
employment colleagues

• Provided a lavish lifestyle and numerous expensive gifts
g_• Sexual Targeting during my fathers illness, Terminal Cancer * • Denial of involvement in targeting or knowledge of 
the targeting - Deceitful behaviour

• Emotional destruction
*  . Intellectual Property Theft - Medical Research Project 2014 - 2016, hand written in
Port Pirie and a proposal submitted to Pharmaceutical Company 2016 in his possession
PAC and funded by the Government

• Unusual comments
4 . Suicidal tendencies - Threatening suicide
Unusual behaviour - portrayed behaviour of what I was researching on Goggle about
womanising*hile he was at work-  Watching / Access to Government Shared Illegal
Surveillance
At  • Family Criminal Involvement - Murder / Grandfather, Sicily
• Ceased contact without explanation
I removed all business concepts from my computer and copied all flies to a disconnected
harddrive. The business concepts and developments were stored in a locked vault designed
through McAfee Security System and was password protected. McAfee Security System is
password protected and password protected for administration changes as well
All newly created accounts and security systems are 2 step verification coded, and
Authentication app is required in order to access any accounts or systems on my new
computer system, mobile phone and Apple Tablet.
Second hacking occurred following all these measures being used and put in place.
Mobile phone security upgrade - Finger print authentication on all access to apps, screen,
opening of phone, security systems, phone calls, messages, photo gallery / McAfee Security
System - Nord VPN - Malwarebytes Security System - Password and fingerprint encoded on
all access points
Refer to file - Telstra report Fraudulent activity - Continuous hacking of account / personal
and then business account - Direct Targeting of the Individual
Government are gaining direct access through the account registered in their company
Telstra / Government owned / Foreign investors
I am now currently not receiving constant correspondence from my contracted publisher
Austin Macauley Publishers, London concerning the second contract,  second edition of the
book developments : Email :
Business email, server GoDaddy, America
Suspected : Intellectual Property Theft / Publishing House Copyright Laws, individuals
involved in the targeting to sell the books on the Black Market and intercept success of the
publications sabotaging the publishing house, Austin Macauley Publishers, investment in
their client / profit from book sales and the success of their client / victim of targeting
cce,-ve N t ,14 - F-ReM)CC-j-- CRI t-t t Nn L Oc.--T I ki L Ty
• c_oNeCcere--- 0  •-cc. t\ et yoeK - eiecareft Mv5,cvvEtt..
FAMILY HISTORY OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY - BULONE
Vincent Bulone informed me during our relationship that his grandfather, Vincenzo k
eiG Salvatore Balon Sic'  was involved in a murder.  His grandfathetWincenzo Stivatore -f
--,kBulone ha w of dead a man in Sicily over a woman and then fled tmNew Yorab  escape
conviction and to hide. Vincent Bulone is named after his grandfather  but was adapted for
the French region from Vincenzo Salvatore Bulone to Vincent Salvatore Bulone.
Vincent Bulone's family relocated to France from Sicily :
4Address
Vincent Bulone has a older sister who resides in France also.
At the time of meeting his sister she was going through a divorce. She has two children, a so
and a daughter, the daughters name is Sophinette, wh#Vincent is in constant contact withW
his sister and neice+via Whatsapp app' -
Refer to Folder 17. Whatsapp app
First met on MANI Dating Site / Phone contact - Stated that his name was "David" 75.61-•/ ac I s Deceitful Behaviour / 
nature
Capable of being dishonest / lying
Vinront
-TRON5F6ARC.-1-0 TO WORK
llotQC NOMC3ER FROM Pticcsie
Messages in this that
private and protected
end-to-end encryption team,
more_
Hi Darling, I have just
installed Viber on this
phone as I have it
connected to internet
all the time, which is
difficult with the other one
especially when I travel.
I wilt use this account
from now on to chat with
you  It is also now my real
name Vincent instead of_
the stupid other one...  love-
you my sexy star, at work
xxx love
hi ric4riinri ole;:lxi no
7/13/2020 Mall - Outlook
PdpfctRn‘-/ I AC RELeTtoNSH tP - iSELEWFUL. NIMORE-(No subject) Core MeRa.iBcte: AS3 Kficrnav of 1-RCAel -ELM v - conls 
e czen > Tue 13/08/20191136 PM
it To: Vincent Bulone <  s kAcbc t4 u tsAwaRscH &Wit
I spoke to you once and you attracted my heart V with darling,princet will marry you,trust me,I
princess;darling. Please trust me with all of your
Sent from my iPad
...••••••
httos://outlook.live.cornImail/0/AQMIcADAwATNamYAZC11M2UM.TZhNVVM1MDACLTAwegAuAAADXVQ1yWlen0laOW4Coha6GAEAXoEEi%2F... 
1/1

╭──────────────────────────────────────────────── Page 4, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 711372020 el - RI Ovtiook                                                                                        │
│ PoRTRAYING RELATIONSHIP - DECEITFUL NATORE                                                                       │
│ (No subject) COPE = MARRIAGE | ASSINATION OF TARGETED                                                            │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ TIM - IS a                                                                                                       │
│ ns -                                                                                                             │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ Tue 13/08/2019 11:36 PM                                                                                          │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ Te Mincont bulone <M 2 - SWEDEN uNWERSIY EMAIL                                                                   │
│ *                                                                                                                │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ I spoke to you once and you attracted my heart ®# with darling,prince& will marry you,trust me @                 │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ princessidarling, Please trust me with all of your 2                                                             │
│ Sent from my iPad                                                                                                │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ htts:v/outlook live.com/mail/O/AQMKADAwATNiZmYAZC1jM2USLTZhNWMIMDACLTAwCgAuAAADXVQ1yWien0ieOW4CohQ6GAEAXOEEI%2F. │
│                                                                                                                  │
│ 4n                                                                                                               │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

9(ci EUROPE
ylecri (VG poRen1T5 IN
-RoNce -
I1 ENi B(-3(-°N
,R.I."Rf)Y6-1> REartIC-4 \ISM
:ovspfRED
?c
OSF~ ) \;) c 1-1 c-c.-• a.> 3 --Eget.)
KTH
zc, Lot:, e-
* Seaweed Applications
demi
Seawee
Applications
Opportunities and Challenges 2019
)Q Miu toN Dou-EM Cliket.71-
01•%Qekv -r•I 1\)C4.)19 CC- S-15NT
Plsci N .!
MS
AIEL.4z) ce.s cow -SST)'e
(7\

╭────────── Page 5, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ JIG Euro FE                          │
│ MEETING PARENTS IN)                  │
│                                      │
│ ANCE rors                            │
│ “URTRAYED ONS                        │
│ ONSPIRED si                          │
│                                      │
│ ViscesT BOONE                        │
│ eaweed Applicatio:                   │
│                                      │
│ ’ Seaweed                            │
│ Applications                         │
│                                      │
│ -{ Opportunities and Challenges 2019 │
│                                      │
│ 12 MILUON DOLLAR GRANT               │
│ UNIVERSITY PNNGNCEMENT               │
│                                      │
│ Pisani y 7 Ozh                       │
│ Ms                                   │
│                                      │
│ ABELAIDE CNIVERSITY                  │
│ B PTENP ANTS |                       │
│                                      │
│ ™s                                   │
│                                      │
│ ~                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────╯

QS \ICH° LOGICAL COO NSECA-A t\C-4 CNC CORI' - el\ri
v iNce-Nyr ee Uc,NE (32olci
GOVERNMENT TARGETING :
MOTIVE :
INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY THEFT
Refer to Stage 4 1993 - 2020 Intellectual Property Theft
INTENTION :
SEXUAL TARGETING
Deformation of Character / Reputation / Credibility
Sexual Targeting / Sexual abuse to cause Deformation of Character / bodily harm /
psychological harm
Portrayed relationships - Emotional destruction - Creating vulnerability / emotional
diversion and a need for comfort or self destruction
Pqrtrayed relationships / emotional destcuction - Words stated following sexual interactions
by predator to victim of sexual targeting  Thank you" - Form of Grooming of the victim for
government Prostitution / Self destruction / discrediting the victims reputation and in
connection with Prostitution and Human Trafficking
ENDANGERMENT
Shared access to Government Illegal Surveillance of Privacy of own home / locations / access
to victims personal location / privacy including nudity, family members, friends, personal
activities
Exact locations at exact time I am in that location
FRAUDULENT ACTIVITY
Excessive living expenses - Reducing income
Impeding on business source of funding - Closure of business / establishment and success
Reducing sources of income - Attempt at resulting in Bankruptcy
Reducing sources of income - Reducing funding for Legal Assistance to Contest and defend
against the illegal activity
Blocking access to marketing publication of first novel - Impeding upon success and financial
gain
Blocking access to assistance / medical/ legal - Cover up of the truth - Impeding upon Legal
assistance to contest and prosecute - evidence in my possession
Segregation from family and friends - Creating vulnerability / emotional needs / sexual
targeting / segregating from protection and support
ATTEMPTED MURDER TO APPEAR AS SUICIDE OR NATURAL CAUSES : 51C
Falsified diagnosis, Psychosis / Schizophrenia - Resulting in detainment and prescribed
medication / side effects Suicidal Tendencies
Illegal Lawyer Representation, Heidi Salvemini, Westside Lawyers, Port Pirie - Illegally
Obtained Medical Records of falsified diagnosis of Psychosis, Dr Kajani, Port Pine
Resulting in detainment and prescribed medication / side effects Suicidal Tendencies
Vincent BulonA- ncouragement into Psychological Counselling / Mental Health StateP)1
Second attempt to have me detained and medicated on prescribed medication / Side effects
Suicidal Tendencies
" • ■ V:1C-kj,,11-3,2 CZ )(-- 1 C C -MN C C:1- ",„:7 c:  cc
Vincent- - Ok i
NI Ko (ti - Mig' Hi darling, V: "3 ‘A ' b can
skype tonight, it will be
best as it will be peaceful.
Yes I saw the video and
the kiss but I could not
hear what you were
saying. One thing at a time
darlingyou have first to -c_t,,cc_co,pc,
see your  GP tomorrow and
take it from there. I would
not worry too much about
Chicken Time, sounds to
me like they were going
to exploit you, the fact
they didn't reply says a
lot about their attitude.
You will find something
good in due time, but for
now'ou  need rest and
reconstruction  until you
feel like the wonderful
and beautiful woman you
are. You were not born
to suffer, nobody is, you
go • 0 ' •
has nc-en.aariin
You cannot disappear. You
have so much you can
contribute, look forward.
I am not the centre of the
universe, you need to seek
support  and counseling,-,
so you can overcome
your fears of me being
unfaithful and others
wanting to hurt you.
Nobody wants to hurt you,
people that have met you
in my environment think
you are wonderful, look
Stay for instance.
VilIcent
dive you trfefrfoney for
the first visit but go from
referral from your doctor
otherwise it won't work.
Yes I'll do that.*.you'll be
with me first time so you
can pay while we're there
no need to transfer any
money.
don't want  record either _,
as this might impact my
future in Australia. So it cr.(0._(..,
has to be ayour  name
from your doctor. And I
can pay the first visit. Ask
how much it costs as I am
getting seriously in the
red with a lot of wasted
money.

╭─────── Page 9, Image 1 ───────╮
│ vous:                         │
│                               │
│ Vincent                       │
│                               │
│ give you tre-treney for       │
│ the first visit but go from   │
│ referral from your doctor     │
│ otherwise it wont work.       │
│                               │
│ PM                            │
│                               │
│ Yes I'll do that4you'll be    │
│ with me first time so you     │
│ can pay while we're there |   │
│ no need to transfer any       │
│                               │
│ money.                        │
│                               │
│ | don't want record either    │
│ as this might impact my       │
│ future in Australia. So it    │
│ has to be at your name        │
│ from your doctor. And |       │
│ can pay the first visit. Ask. │
│ “how much it costs as !am     │
│ getting seriously in the      │
│ red ws alot oi hae is         │
╰───────────────────────────────╯

Vincent
ent
Let's go to shower no
I have enough. I have
explained the same things
one million times You
simply  want to believe
only what you make up-
and do not trust me.
I know you are very
intelligent. I respect you
and always will. I believe
in you and your future
and your talent. I don't
care about anyone else's
business.
to shower now.
I love you.
Because it k keeps
haunenina continuously.
Vincent
Why didn't you Tell me
earlier? I mentioned it a
vveek ago when I found
out by accident looking for
info about the ceo of pirsa
being sacked and you
didn't say anything. How
is this going to help you
anyway'You also need
*psychologicarbelp darling.
You still need to be cured
darling.
I love you and I am not
giving up.
They have received over
1,000 complaints darling.
'INI hope you are not making
things up with icac
because of the_past. What
is this mess going to give
you at the end? I am so
worried about you.
ID
4MI
•
Vincent
have over frYterzIrted
futile things, t swear and
ask god to kill me on the
spot if I lie. I have never
lied to you or disrespected
you. Please don't start
the discussion again but
I want you to know that
and hope you will one day
believe me otherwise we
cannot be together.
If you saw a gp there is no
way they would link  you
to icac and the rest. How
*are you going to get help
to recover from all these
psychological traumas c--t
.4 without medical help?
If we ever get together
again I will need to be
able to work normally
and trust nothing similar
as last Thursday will
happen ever again. And
'YID ,  164 Mr
like. Xxkiss
Ok beautiful, will text
again when at home. Love
Just arrived home
beautiful. A bit tired, it
was a long day since
6:30 this morning but
it was a delight to see
youAlitam happy to'll000l
thelosychologisflor  you c<cp,o-y
but remember  you need
a referral for Medica__:gi,
reimbursement. Let me
know how ypu'd like to
proceed and I will help
you. It's a good idea
darling to do iOYou need
help and some therapy_
will be highly beneficial to
NMI
Vincent
y vse,,,tt3ri."Ff ,1fitiV I I CIL VVVI IN
all tht;11.1 - ithout
any precipitation of my
feelings
I am supporting you and
accept how you feel and I
have corrected things.
Otherwise I would not
he here talking to you,
coming over the weekend,
-Abooking_psychologist etc
01)t , wrie Cs`., c3c
But it took along time,
don't you think that I
became cautious of it,
like I had to make sure it
wasn't happening again all
the time at first..don't you
have any understanding
of th a t..that it was
(ik.iv
.."7 I didn ' t (II\W
vvitt1H41 kitow
why  \Art‘ div Ii I.ILII it )
Ubit cwpoinin  ulit <I►icf
i:111 11w rtr,1 If  voti
Ilmot I
,t wiumitni.•(‘( vot
4:11O11Iti (ţo \tom own
tilis ) (I4)111(t I11 11t^ \t(sţv
I \V iII (', I t
šit  .I" , I ,II ii \Mil)
I Ii.iv( ' l icit t `Vi 'l l ' .1 .111k'ţi
It ) ( i( ) i l it . _ j,
. 4» •, , I t ' ' . Í í II
tllci tIt.illt'•.•.Iiit. t i
ytlilt i11t , ii Iţt ti \
II( i\. ; I ( )\,,t ' Vt tH
r\l, ţIl iţ 11w .it
II pr t
t
4
4

╭────── Page 15, Image 1 ──────╮
│ 11156 Ota em -               │
│                              │
│ Vincent                      │
│                              │
│ I didn't give details but    │
│ they wanted to know          │
│ why we are making            │
│                              │
│ that appointment and         │
│                              │
│ all the rest. If you are     │
│ going to tell them 1am       │
│                              │
│ a womanizer then you         │
│ should go on your own as     │
│ this is Hot going to be very │
│ constructive... twill eat    │
│ now as lam starving and      │
│ | have not even started      │
│ what lwanted to do, this is  │
│ 90 disruptive and Stresstul  │
│                              │
│ and depressing me. Enjoy     │
│ your movie and try to rest   │
│ now Love you xxx             │
│                              │
│ No not the reason at all     │
│ it just o 6 a two aided      │
╰──────────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 17, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 18, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

D1/4111..set. ,   - 7 " I TANDARY 62&20
ale° suPPUED Ccacyace "cr' EV, beKke of tORGESTING . Vi KceiCTI tit  Zis- atcl c_us.)spiREJ -cEsciet._ -MereStart of 
relationship - DatingThelatIonship
stresses  that  I have been reacting  to IF
2errre -R.t (5Et -beg t u:44. - se xc4;L mgke_tern f\k t.
Ai.. Italian Restaurant
Young Italian waitress was being very friendly with Vincent - Vincent was responding being over
friendly and flirty / charming in return. Acting like I wasn't even there - having personal
conversations with each other in Italian - she turned her back towards me and focused the
attention on Vincent - Vincent precipitated the behaviour - she leant right down towards him and
placed her hand affectionately on his shoulder talking Italian. Vincent barely paid me any
attention. I gave her a cross look and also a concerning look towards the manager of the
restaurant who was in the kitchen. The waitress was taken off our table and replaced with another
and put on the bar. After the meal Vincent turned sideways to me and faced the Italian waitress in
the bar and followed her movements around the bar as if trying to catch her attention. I gave him
a disconcerting look. We left the restaurant. I told him off back in the hotel room.
I felt embarrassed, disrespected and betrayed, demeaned.
Vincent apologised for his behaviour.
4
. 1.
Robbie Davies -Adelaide University - Colleague
While Vincent was in another relationship - He left this relationship for me, had started dating me
while in that relationship, was on a dating site
Vincent told me that he had been sending Robbie Davies personal photos of himself, going to
university dinners with her and presentations and lunches with her while at work - messages sent
by text, phone. Robbie Davies was constantly ringing him every Sunday night - personal
conversations and while he was travelling - she had invited him out to stay at her house out of
town for a weekend - Vincent said that it was for a university conference, work related event - I
said not without me your not - It didn't eventuate Vincent informed me. Robbie Davies seemed to
seeking his attention continuously, constantly and he was responding. This happened
continuously.
Vincent and I went away for a romantic weekend, Robbie Davies rang on the Sunday night when
we got back to his house - personal conversation - Vincent told her where he went for the
weekend and did not mention that he was with me and spoke as if he went alone - Did not
mention me once. He said the words goodnight to her. I questioned why he didn't mention that we
had gone together or me at all - He said that he didn't speak about his personal life with his
colleagues and that he wanted to tell her face to face not over the phone.
This continued for months.
I found out my dad had cancer 2 days earlier and waited all day for his comfort.
He did not ask me how I was or mention my dad at all when he arrived home. The moment he got
home all he spoke about was Robbie Davies and didn't even ask how I was - I told him off.
He told me that he told her about me and our relationship - he said that she laughed.
He told me how she was always acting playful with him and with each other and going to lunch
with each other at work while I sat at home waiting for him at the end of each day.
He stopped going to dinners and presentations he was going to with her and did not take me
instead.
I told him to back this friendship off and stop acting that way with another women and that it was
hurting me, disrespecting our relationship and causing mistrust and damage.
He told me he had stopped and stopped speaking about her at home all the time. But her emails
kept coming through with personal emojos attached - not professional
He snuck into the ensuite bathroom with his tablet one weekend after getting notification on his
phone when we where out together that weekend and acted strangely when he read it and did not
tell me anything, acted secretly. When I became suspicious of his behaviour I checked his phone
while he was in the, bathroom. It was from Robbie Davies seeking his attention. When I
confronted him and said did you sneak into the bathroom to send Robbie Davies a message he
firmly and defensively denied it and said that I was being paranoid and told me if I didn't trust him
our relationship was not going to work.
I kept on about it for weeks because I knew the truth. He finally angrily admitted it when I told him
I looked at his phone and blamed me for putting pressure on him about being on his emails all the
time and every moment we were together.
He never apologised and made me feel guilty for wanting him to give me some undivided
attention away from work.
Told me that he had bought her a present - a silk scarf - he had also bought a silk scarf for me when we first starting 
dating - I told him that it was
inappropriate and personal and as he had bought one for me does he do that with all the women and I said it was now 
nothing special and had no special meaning
and that I would not now ever wear it. He denied that he was doing anything wrong.
I went to a university conference, Robbie Davies was there, I walked up to join Vincent's PA who was standing with her 
talking, I was visible to Robbie Davies.
She would not look at me and held her head down towards the floor and rushed away quickly , did not say hello or 
acknowledge me in anyway.
A Michelle - Adelaide University - employee
Michelle kept messaging Vincent day and night through personal messaging apps with her personal issues. Contacted 
Vincent once at 4am in the morning with her
personal issues while he was away from the university travelling in the US - He got out of bed to address and support 
her personal issues.
This went on for months
Would notfir her even though she was submitting wrong results and incompetent at her job - he was letting everyone else 
go when the grant money ran out but
extended her contract. I told him to back this personal contact off and as her boss his relationship at work should be 
professional and he was acting
inappropriately in a relationship (ours) which was damaging and disrespectful towards me. He denied that he was doing 
anything wrong. This behaviour stopped.
Annie - Adelaide University - Colleague
Kept getting sms messages at the same time every night when he got home from work - was acting strangely and 
suspiciously - He never spoke about Annie to me or
mentioned her name. I found his behaviour odd and suspicious and relating to previous behaviour so I checked his sms 
messages on his tablet that were connected
to his phone. I found numerous messages to Annie -meeting her for lunch constantly - lots of interaction - picking her 
up from another location of campus in my
red car that he had bought for me and telling her that he missed her - I felt Betrayed. — f..Ec4(2. CT o
I confronted him and told him that I had read the messages on his tablet - He said that it was a joke - seemed nervous 
and defensive - we argued - told him he
was lying to me, hiding things and it was inappropriate behaviour in a relationship, that he was hurting me.
He denied that he was doing anything wrong and blamed me for not trusting him. Pattern forming - Behavioural - I was 
aware
He disconnected his phone from the tablet so no sms messages could be seen on it and changed his password when he 
travelled next.
Saw the messages to Annie saying he was drinking with the girls and she should come and join him - Denied he was 
drinking at work and I was being paranoid - he
was doing this after he had asked me to stop drinking - I quit for nearly a year - He also asked me to quit cigarettes -
I did for nearly 7 months - he was
doing this at work while I sat alone at home waiting for him to come home at the end of everyday.
Natelie Betts - Adelaide University - employee
I met her at a university lunch for Christmas - seemed very comfortable and friendly with Vincent -
playful - sat down inbetween me and Vincent as we sat next to each other on a long wooden
bench at the table, nearly in Vincent's lap - I saw it as a rival behaviour and odd and disrespectful
to a couple and their relationship.
Vincent was receiving constant messages from her while we were together and still messaging as
soon as he got home from work while ignoring me and played with her - playful messages,
laughing and giggling - sided with each other playfully against a company - told Natelie the way
that this company had treated him which he had not spoke to me about or even mentioned -
spoke about her constantly.
XI noticed a pattern of his behaviour coming home playful and excessively on a high of playfulness
• and happiness when she was at work - came home stressed and unhappy and saying his days
were not constructive or productive and the atmosphere at work was boring because people were
on holidays - she was on holidays. Told him it should be more productive because there's less
distractions. He didn't seem excited about being with me.
Never spoke about her husband or remembered his name but claimed to have gone out to their
place for dinner once before he had met me - I went to school with her husband.
She was sending him messages of chocolate cake that she had made and that she would bring it
to work for him.
Told me all about how Natelie was building a business and what it entailed - I asked him about
what my business entailed that I was building, he could not answer me, he didn't know.
Romantic Getaway
Went away together for a weekend - it was a place that she had just been to for a holiday - she
kept sending him emails on where to go and what to do there - he said how nice she is and goes
out of her way to do things for him - when he had asked her to do overtime and extra work at
work sfterrefused and said that she wouldn't do it
Spoke about her constantly the whole time we were away. I said that I would cook him something
special - he said that she had spent a whole weekend cooking that dish for him before we had
met - I got angry with him by the end of the weekend - I had had enough and felt unimportant like
she had the influence over him and she was all he was thinking about and we only went there
because of that influence.
He told me that he had bought her a silk scarf as a present - personal present not professional as
he had bought for me and Robbie Davies.
This behaviour continued for months
I told him to stop it, it was disrespectful to our relationship and damaging, hurting me.
He denied that he was doing anything wrong - he stopped this behaviour so he told me.
She asked him to come to her place for dinner to teach her son French lessons. He said she in-
vited us as her husband who I went to school with wanted to meet me and then mentioned about
her son. At a university conference she asked me for us to come to her place for dinner as her
son was going to France and he could learn the language from Vincent - she did not mention her
husband at all or of him wanting to meet me. I told Vincent no we would not go and I didn't want
to know her, that I found her to be disrespectful towards our relationship and me and acting inap-
propriately. He told me this had stopped.
Under suspicion
He kept coming home with scratches on his shoulders and neck under a shirt and woollen jumper
that he wore to work - I told him I was going to get some woolmix because he has scratches on
his shoulders and neck every time he wears that jumper - he blamed my nails - we had not made
love - the scratches stopped
Suzanne - Adelaide University - Colleague
Suzanne said that she was glad to met me at a university conference - that Vincent now had a
spring in his step and adored me after seeming to have such a heavy life - told me he had told her
he was coming up to the country to meet me when we had first met - mentioned my photograph in
his office - he had never mentioned Suzanne before - had told me about Robbie Davies that he
didn't talk about his personal life with his colleagues when I had confronted him about her.
When confronted with this he told me that I was being paranoid - blamed me and denied any
wrong doing.
Office - Adelaide Uhiversity
Gave him a photograph in a frame as a present for valentines day that he had told me that he had
placed on his desk and removed it on the weekends so that the cleaners did not disturb his per-
sonal belongings - he had numerous displays of presents and personal cards from colleagues on
his shelves that are never shifted - went to office during the week - my picture was not displayed
and sat in the packaging on the bench upon the pile of papers and things as if never touched and
had just been placed there and forgotten - I asked him to put it on the display shelves with his
HRGETC ---D V Cal M CnNCELI__ t\PPoi MEnr - AweRG:
V (Nce-Nec boccNie: coNtQCreD P NE IN OCWED -Th -R6
other displays facing the door entrance as you walk in - he placed it in a corner shelving where it is barely visible to
anyone that walks in the office and
sitting at his office table. Noticed a receipt for jewellery and a Gucchi carry bag in his office - when confronted he 
told me that it was a joke and there was
nothing to it
He had told me that he had bought a silk scarf for his PA - who is my friend
f Stopped looking deep into my eyes and telling me I had the most beautiful eyes and started to look away all the time, 
dropping his eyes from mine - I found
this behaviour deceitful like he had something to hide. Walking along the beach - talking about the blue of the sky - I 
said you use to say my eyes were bluer
and more beautiful than the sky - Vincent answered yes they are but I like brown eyes too - he has never mentioned brown
eyes before
Wouldn't stop messaging and talking to his ex who lived in Sweden where he also worked for nearly a year - did not tell 
anyone in Sweden that we were together
for nearly a year - said that he did not talk about his personal life with his colleagues but everyone knew that he had 
been with his ex while they were
together.
I had to keep quiet and stay out of view while living with him in his home every time he Skyped with his parents and he 
pretended with them to still be with his
ex partner - he told me he didn't want to worry them about him or cause them to worry - said that he wanted to tell them
in person - he told them nearly a year
later while he was travelling - then he introduced me over Skype.
2\k, He took me to Norway - while at the airport a woman colleague approached, they were talking very friendly - he had 
never mentioned her to me - she looked
me up and down strangely
While at a science conference he chased after this woman attentively while I was with him talking friendly on a personal
level - followed her to a dining table,
we sat down, he turned his back to me and gave her his full attention, laughing and giggling together while she was 
flicking her hair and laughing with him
while he leaned in closer - I felt ignored, embarrassed and disrespected -inappropriate behaviour to our relationship - 
He finally turned to me - I gave him a
disconcerting look - he kept his attention on me after that and ignored her - I told him off for this when we got back 
to the hotel room - he denied that he was
acting inappropriately
A-
. Sitting in an airport - Europe after the convention - a blonde lady was sitting in a chair next to us - Vincent 
started staring at her and followed her with
his eyes up and down the corridor and back while he sat next to me like I wasn't even there - I threatened to walk out 
and come back to Australia that it was
the end of our relationship - he got very worried and apologised.
I met his parents on this trip.
Vincent asked me to marry him several times, I said yes - when I would talk about it, when and how he would tell me that
it made him feel nervous - he says now
that he won't marry me until I trust him
Marta - Adelaide University - connected to a colleague - Science Twitter account
This woman suddenly appeared on his twitter account - she was following him on the account and
he took a keen interest in her - following her following him and on the account all the time - he
showed me a picture of her and said that he had asked a colleague about her and the picture she
was using on her twitter account was not her but a picture of a young blond student of hers.
Vincent had had no previous direct contact with Marta before this - Marta started sending him
personal photos of her holidays, beaches by email and personal messages - when confronted he
denied he had donesnything wrong and that she was connected to one of his projects through a
direct colleague of the project but that he had not had direct contact with her before - I said what
did you do or how did you act with her to make her think that she could get personal with you - he
denied doing anything wrong and that he did not respond to the email and blamed me for being
untrusting and paranoid.
Kylie - Adelaide University - colleague
Vincent and I were messaging during the morning—he said that he was swamped with work and
under the pump, very busy and he had to work more that evening as he had been during the
week - something, intuition made me look at his work day calendar on his tablet, daily tasks - the
afternoon was set aside and read Drinks with Kylie - he did not mention this or have not heard of
Kylie before - when confronted he denied doing anything wrong and that it was a farewell party for
Kylie and a lot of people had been invited as she was leaving the university - I questioned the
content of the message as displayed on his calendar which seemed unprofessional and said that
it would have been more professional and logical to have been written in as Farewell party for
Kylie if that's what it was - once again he described her personally as not being attractive and
blamed me for being untrusting and paranoid
I over reacted to this event after all of these events happening continuously over a period of a
year and I had become exasperated with this kind of behaviour which was extremely hurtful,
frustrating and demeaning and I felt unsupported emotionally - I slapped him a couple of times
hard when I was confronting him over this event - I moved out of the house - we are still together
but need-to address these issues and me to re learn how to react to emotional stresses - Vincent
has recently agreed and now says that he does understand how I feel about this behaviour and
accepts how I feel - I now feel relieved and am hoping to mend our relationship with this new
understanding and acceptance
I have suffered bad relationships of violence, betrayal, lies and cheating which made me very
aware of odd, peculiar behaviour and deceitful behaviour which Vincent was displaying
continuously. I do not think that I was making this up and was within my rights to feel lied to,
betrayed, disrespected and demeaned. It felt like a disrespect of my intelligence, intuition and to
me as a person and my experiences within relationships very obvious.
He said I had no right to check his personal messages based on all this information
Vincent lived a life of solitude, dedicated to work, very lonely, no woman affections until late in life.
I was his second relationship. I feel that he is inexperienced in relationships and had felt
neglected emotionally and physically for most of his life and developed this behaviour of seeking
women's attention at work because of this lifestyle and is unaware of his own behaviour and now
does not want to give up the attention he receives as it makes him feel important and not
neglected, this is why he denies the behaviour and blames me.
I feel now because I have had bad relationships and a hard life that I wanted to badly believe that
I was worthy of love and deserved the life he gave me, that I wanted it so badly that I took the
blame, turned a blind eye reluctantly against my intuition and made excuses for his behaviour
because of the life that he had lived and his inexperience in relationships. That I wanted to give
him everything he had not had and wanted him to feel loved. I found him endearing. I do love him
very much and want to address these issues in our relationship and re learn how to react cor-
rectly to emotional stresses without over reacting and going to extremes - I want to learn how to
express how I feel correctly before it becomes a explosive issue. I want Vincent to address this
behaviour, accept it as inappropriate and to not hurt me with it anymore.
Sweden - Free coffee - a man in a restaurant at the units where we were staying was giving me
free coffee - Vincent became jealous and tight lipped, angry and accused me of flirting with him to
get the coffee and said that he would shoot him—he now says that he was joking and denies that
he got jealous
A man said hello to me on a footpath as I got out of the car -Vincent became instantly angry and
jealous and said you only said hello back because your polite didn't you - I said yes - he said I'll
kill him
4
If a man looked at me admiringly he would put his arm around me and say fuck off she's mine
He was jealous and angry over any man showing me any interest even though I did not respond
EFTA00507626 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYCO24328.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024328.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case
Data:
Messages
(11401-
11500 of
14749)
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 10:53:27 (UTC)
Sender: Self 'eeitune ail.com
Participants: ( ), Self ( jeeitunes®gmail.com )
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 11:18:34 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
Read em and weep
freud said that women your age need a man that is strong enough to
protect them from THEMSELVES! Seems like he was talking directly to you
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 11:18:34 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
freud said that women your age need a man that is strong enough to
protect them -----------from THEMSELVES! Seems like he was talking directly to you
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 12:04:44 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
In addition , I suggest when applying for work. That you tell your prospective employer.
Why they should hire you. . not why they shouldn't
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 12:04:44 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
In addition , I suggest when applying for work. That you tell your prospective employer.
Why they should hire you. . not why they shouldn't
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 12:42:27 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ), Self ( )
From dive : jp working behind the scene!
iMessage
[3] 2019-05-18 12:42:27 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 12:43:07 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: Lawrence ( ), Self (
iMessage
[4] 2019-05-18 12:43:07 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: Lawrence ( ), Self (
)
From dive : jp working behind the scene!
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 12:44:13 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
)
)
)
Oy
Oy
Causing staff to push back
iMessage
[3] 2019-05-18 12:44:13 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 13:08:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants:
gal
). Self(
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 13:08:10 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 13:08:10 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
)
Causing staff to push back
)
)
)
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/18/worldieurope/austria-strache-resigns-video.html?
smid=nytcore-ios-share
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-18 13:08:10 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
https://vvww.nytimes.com/2019/05/18/worldieurope/austria-strache-resigns-video.html?
smid=nytcore-ios-share
iMessage
2019-05-1813:08:39 UTC 5
Sender: (
Participants: I ), Self (
Big problem
iMessage
2019-05-18 13:08:39 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
)
Big problem
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 13:23:33 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
Russians are good at what they ye been doing for years Camera in the cell phone charger a
bit antiquated
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-18 13:23:33 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
Russians are good at what they ye been doing for years Camera in the cell phone charger a
bit antiquated
iMessage
2019-05-18 13:24:29 UTC) 1
Sender: (
Participants: ( ), Self (
The guy was solid -- this will only make Kurtz stronger
)
iMessage
2019-05-1813:24:29 UTC 5
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
The guy was solid -- this will only make Kurtz stronger
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-18 14:15:46 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
Re :china -keep in mind by reducing the yuan rate the exporters will receive more yuan
per dollar. The reserves as they are in dollars already will be worth more in yuan . And as
the local debt is in yuan easier to pay back and strengthens the banks
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 14:15:46 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ), Self ( )
Re :china -keep in mind by reducing the yuan rate the exporters will receive more yuan
per dollar. The reserves as they are in dollars already will be worth more in yuan . And as
the local debt is in yuan easier to pay back and strengthens the banks
iMessage
2019-05-18 14:17:17 UTC) 151
Sender:
Participants:
So what does that mean???
), Self (
iMessage
2019-05-18 14:17:17 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (
So what does that mean???
iMessage
[1]2019-05-1R 14:27:57 (1. I (. )
Sender: Self ir
Participants: ), Self(
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 14:27:57 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-18 14:28:24 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 14:28:24 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
)
)
Isabel blumberg gyno after shifirin
Isabel blumberg gyno after shifirin
Watch currency movement
)
Watch currency movement
iMessage
2019-05-18 14:34:22 (UTC) [5]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( )
Huge upset in Australia
iMessage
2019-05-1814:34:22 UTC 1
Sender: (
Participants: ( ).
Huge upset in Australia
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-18 14:35:44 (1 1( )
Sender: Self
Participants:
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 14:35:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants:
), Self (
). Self(
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 14:37:34 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
)
)
)
China will use proxy and currency to offset lower export keeping numbers in yuan
growing . Recall gdp in local currency
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-18 14:37:34 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
China will use proxy and currency to offset lower export keeping numbers in yuan
growing . Recall gdp in local currency
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 14:50:50 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ). Self( )
Yes
Yes
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 14:50:50 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 14:50:50 (UTC)
Sender: Self )
Participants: ). Self ( )
iMessage
[6] 2019-05-18 22:07:48 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: Larry Summers ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:07:48 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: Larry Summers ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:08:04 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self(
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 22:08:04 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-18 22:17:08 (UTC)
)
)
)
How are you
How are you
Feeling better today?
)
Feeling better today?
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
My point is that you are attempting to use money , finance and the economy as a deterrent
or weapon, it does not work . I can get around it , in a myriad of ways. . you need other
fronts.
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:17:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ), Self ( )
My point is that you are attempting to use money , finance and the economy as a deterrent
or weapon, it does not work . I can get around it , in a myriad of ways. . you need other
fronts.
iMessage
2019-05-18 22:38:52 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
Much better !
iMessage
2019-05-18 22:38:52 (11TC) I21
Sender: Mn sillia&
Participants: ), Self (
Much better !
iMessage
)
2019-05-18 22:38:55 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
iMessage
2019-05-18 22:38:55 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:39:05 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ), Self ( )
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 22:39:05 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
2019-05-18 22:39:24 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (
Such an amazing day and wonderful weather
iMessage
2019-05-18 22:39:24 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (
Such an amazing day and wonderful weather
iMessage
2019-05-18 22:39:34 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (
Which make me so happy too
iMessage
2019-05-18 22:39:34 (11TC) f2]
Sender: I=Mai l
Participants:
Which make me so happy too
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:40:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants:
), Self (
). Self(
)
)
)
)
)
Yay
Yay
ood irl. That's more like it.
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 22:40:10 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
ood irl. That's more like it.
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 22:41:18 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
)
)
I spoke to her and told her you are my new assistant and to take special care.
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:41:18 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants:
iMessage
), Self ( )
I spoke to her and told her you are my new assistant and to take special care.
2019-05-18 22:42:47 UTC) 1
Sender: ( )
Participants: ), Self( )
I read about her - she is amazing !
Thank u .
How is Florida ?
iMessage
2019-05-18 22:42:47 UTC 2
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
I read about her - she is amazing !
Thank u .
How is Florida ?
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:49:38 (UTC)
Sender: Self n=l1=
Participants: ), Self ( )
Super sunny and calm
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 22:49:38 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:49:57 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ), Self (
)
Super sunny and calm
)
What time do you finish work on Monday ? Do you know
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 22:49:57 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:50:29 TC)
Sender: Self
Participants: (
)
What time do you finish work on Monday ? Do you know
). Self (
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 22:50:29 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-18 22:52:32 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
)
She s obviously jewish
)
She s obviously jewish
)
Her clients are the wealthiest families in New York and she is very kind
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-18 22:52:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ), Self ( )
iMessage
Her clients are the wealthiest families in New York and she is very kind
2019-05-18 23:12:55 UTC 1
Sender: (
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
Working till 18:00 on Monday
iMessage
2019-05-I8 23:12:55 (UR )121
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( )
Working till 18:00 on Monday
iMessage
2019-05-18 23:32:59 UTC) 7
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( )
Hey Jeffrey! Thank you so much for everything!! Pm finally settled. It was so helpful to
have Jojo and Leo with me and Lesley who was texting me also!
iMessage
2019-05-18 23:32:59 (UTC) [1]
Sender: +
Participants: M ), Self ( )
Hey Jeffrey! Thank you so much for everything!! Pm finally settled. It was so helpful to
have Jojo and Leo with me and Lesley who was texting me also!
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 01:46:44 UTC
Sender: Self (
Participants: ), Self (
iMessage
[7] 2019-05-19 01:46:44 UTC
Sender: Self (
Participants: ), Self (
)
)
Great
Great
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 02:00:45 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
Don't forget to do your gratitude exercise before going to sleep
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-19 02:00:45 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-19 10:11:OR (11TC)
Sender: Self Al=rM
)
Don't forget to do your gratitude exercise before going to sleep
Participants:
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 10:11:08 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants:
), Self (
), Self (
iMessage
[8] 2019-05-19 11:00:41 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: Eduardo ( ), Self ( )
)
Did you go to church
)
Did you go to church
Lorenzo e medici is trying to start a crypto bank . Weird - want s to talk
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 11:00:41 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: Eduardo ( ), Self ( )
Lorenzo e medici is trying to start a crypto bank . Weird - want s to talk
iMessage
2019-05-19 11:35:06 (UTC) [5]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self (
Of course
iMessage
2019-05-19 11:35:06 C 1
Sender: (
Participants: I ).
Of course
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:16:33 UTC 9
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (
I'm going to Europe tomorrow
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:16:33 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (
going to Europe tomorrow
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:16:52 UTC 1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (
Mathematics is ordered thought
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:16:52 (UTC) N1
Sender: Martin (
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (
Mathematics is ordered thought
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:39:10 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ) )
)
)
)
)
)
facetime?
iMessage
[2] 2019-05-19 12:39:10 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
facetime?
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:39:30 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
Do you know when you are back?
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-19 12:39:30 (UTC)
Sender: Self
Participants: ), Self (
Do you know when you are back?
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:41:38 C
Sender: Self
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (
Illusion
iMessage
[9] 2019-05-19 12:41:38 UTC
Sender: Self ( )
Participants: Martin ( ), Self (
Illusion
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:47:40 UTC) [11
Sender:
Participants:
31 May
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:47:40 UTC 5
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (
31 May
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-19 12:48:41 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:48:41 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
iMessage
[5] 2019-05-19 12:49:34 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self (
)
)
)
K
K
I m on island 3-10 , 13 in New York with Davos pres. And then Paris
iMessage
[1] 2019-05-19 12:49:34 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: ( ), Self ( )
I m on island 3-10 , 13 in New York with Davos pres. And then Paris
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:52:47 UTC) [11
Sender:
Participants:
Where r u now ??
), Self (
iMessage
2019-05-19 12:52:47 UTC 5
Sender:
Participants: ( ), Self (
Where r u now ??
)
)
Notes
[1] Source
Device
[1] Source File
[2] Source
Device
[2] Source File
[3] Source
Device
[3] Source File
[4] Source
Device
[4] Source File
[5] Source
Device
[5] Source File
[6] Source
Device
[6] Source File
[7] Source
Device
[7] Source File
[8] Source
Device
[8] Source File
[9] Source
Device
[9] Source File
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/chat.db
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-05-214
36.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-06-034
13.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/20 I 9-06-03/Lawtemc on 2019-05-19 at 23.01.19.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-05-214
35.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-05-194
48.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-06-02/-F
4.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Libraty/Messages/Archive/2019-05-21/Eduardo on 2019-05-20 at 22.04.53.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-05-224
10.ichat
on 2019-05-21 at 06.25.
on 2019-05-18 at 08.44.
on 2019-05-20 at 07.44.
on 2019-05-19 at 10.17.
n 2019-05-18 at 21.46.4
on 2019-05-19 at 21.28.
Case Data: Messages (11301-11400 of 14749) Case Data: Messages (11501-11600 of 14749)
EFTA00800508 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Brad Edwards Epstein v. Scott Rothstein, Brad Edwards, & L.M., see quote: "cars, boats, houses that were placed in Larry 
Visoski's name"
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN
AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Case No. 502009CA040800XXXXMB
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Plaintiff,
vs.
SCOTT ROTHSTEIN, individually;
BRADLEY EDWARDS, individually,
Defendants/Counter-Plaintiffs.
VOLUME I
VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION
OF
BRADLEY EDWARDS
Taken on Behalf of Plaintiff
Friday, November 10th, 2017
10:02 a.m. - 6:16 p.m.
2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard
West Palm Beach, Florida 33409
Examination of the witness taken before
Sonja D. Hall
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
1665 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard, Suite 1001
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
APPEARANCES:
For Plaintiff:
LINK & ROCKENBACH, P.A.
1555 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard, Suite 301
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
By SCOTT J. LINK, ESQUIRE
By KARA BERARD ROCKENBACH, ESQUIRE
For Plaintiff:
ATTERBURY, GOLDBERGER & WEISS, P.A.
250 Australian Ave. South, Suite 1400
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
By JACK A. GOLDBERGER, ESQUIRE
For Plaintiff:
DARREN K. INDYKE, PLLC
575 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY 10022
By DARREN K. INDYKE, ESQUIRE
For Defendants/Counter-Plaintiffs:
SEARCY, DENNEY, SCAROLA, BARNHART &
SHIPLEY, P.A.
2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard
West Palm Beach, FL 33409
By JACK SCAROLA, ESQUIRE
By DAVID P. VITALE, JR.
ALSO PRESENT
Visual Evidence, Incorporated
601 N. Dixie Highway, Suite A
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
By Andrew Mazoleny, Videographer
Tina Campbell, Paralegal
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
INDEX
Videotaped Deposition of BRADLEY EDWARDS Page No.
Direct Examination by Mr. Link 8
Cross -Examination by Mr. Scarola 310
Redirect Examination by Mr. Link 325
Certificate of Oath 340
Certificate of Reporter 341
Read & Sign Letter to Witness 342
No.
PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT INDEX
Description Page No
1 Affidavit of Jeffrey Epstein 92
2 News Article 96
3 News Article 100
4 News Article 112
5 News Articles 145
6 Complaint 147
7 Complaint and Demand for Jury Trial 171
8 Email 178
9 Complaint 179
10 Answer and Counterclaim 185
11 Letter 189
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
12 RRA Firm Directory 190
13 Email 190
14 Jane Doe motion 220
15 Email 231
16 Order 238
17 Fourth Amended Counterclaim 239
18 Email 259
19 Email 264
20 Email 267
21 Seventh Amended & Supplemental Witness List 268
22 Expert Witness Report (Jansen) 284
23 Brad Edwards Time 290
24 National Crime Victim Bar Association 297
25 Brad Edwards' Accolades 300
DEFENDANTS/COUNTER-PLAINTIFFS' EXHIBIT INDEX
(No exhibits were marked.)
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: This is the 10th day
of November 2017. The time is 10:03 a.m.
This is the videotaped deposition of
Bradley Edwards, Esquire, in the matter of
Epstein versus Rothstein and Edwards.
This deposition is taking place at 2139
Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard, West Palm Beach
33409.
My name is Andrew Mazoleny. I am the
videographer representing Visual Evidence,
Incorporated.
Will the attorneys please announce
their appearances for the record?

MR. LINK: Scott Link on behalf of the
plaintiff.
MS. ROCKENBACH: Kara Rockenbach on
behalf of the plaintiff.

MR. INDYKE: Darren Indyke on behalf of
the plaintiff.
MR. GOLDBERGER: Jack Goldberger on
behalf of the plaintiff.

MS. CAMPBELL: And Tina Campbell
parallel on behalf of the plaintiff.
MR. SCAROLA: Jack Scarola and David
Vitale representing Bradley Edwards, who is
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
the counter -plaintiff in this action; and
for all practical purposes, the plaintiff in
the claim against Jeffrey Epstein.
THEREUPON,
BRADLEY EDWARDS,
being a witness in the notice heretofore
filed, and being first duly sworn in the above cause,
testified on his oath as follows:
THE WITNESS: I do.

MR. SCAROLA: Before we begin the
substantive questioning, I want to make it
clear on the record as a consequence of an
exchange of communications that has occurred
with opposing counsel, opposing counsel has
taken the position that Mr. Edwards is going
to be deposed as if he had never been
deposed before, that is, opposing counsel
recognizes no restrictions on the scope of
this deposition.
The scope of the deposition was the
subject of a lengthy hearing before Judge
Hafele that took place on Tuesday,
October 3rd, 2017.
During the course of that hearing the
Court made it very clear that questioning
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
would be limited to four specific areas
identified by the Judge: The filing of a
federal lawsuit on behalf of LM, which was
based upon facts that also supported the
filing of a state court claim; interaction
between Mr. Edwards and Mr. Rothstein and
others at Rothstein, Rosenfeldt Adler that
would relate to any potential knowledge that

Mr. Edwards had or should have had with
regard to the conduct of a Ponzi scheme by
Mr. Rothstein; the filing of a motion
seeking the posting of a $14 million bond
and issues relating to damages.
We are here for purposes of responding
to questions in those specific areas as
directed by the Court. It is our intention
to allow opposing counsel broad latitude
within those four areas. But we will raise
appropriate objections to any inquiries that
are outside those four areas, unless it can
be demonstrated that in some manner I have
misread, in spite of careful review, the
transcript of that hearing and the ruling of
the Court.
So my suggestion is, if opposing
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
counsel continues to take the position that
this deposition is going to be conducted as
if Mr. Edwards had never been deposed
before, that we should at least deal with
those four areas as to which there is
agreement for inquiry, then we will worry
about whether any inquiry outside those four
areas will be allowed. Thank you.

MR. LINK: Obviously we disagree and we
are ready to proceed.
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. LINK:
Q Ready, Mr. Edwards?
A Ready.
Q Are you feeling anxiety today?
A Sure.
Q Tell me about it. What anxiety do you feel
today?
A I'm still -- I'm still being accused for
committing crimes that I didn't commit, and this case
is my only chance to finally set that record straight.
Q So tell me about the anxiety, though. What
are you feeling? Anxiety is an emotional reaction to
something, correct?
A Well, for today
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Yeah.
A -- I think that if you sit in this chair and
I ask you questions, you would have anxiety as well.
Q Okay. So you have anxiety today about my
asking you questions. Is that what the anxiety is?
A No. It's about getting this case over.
Q So you have anxiety about the length of
time the case has been pending?
A Well, with everyday it's worse. I want the
case over, and I want to right the wrong that's been
done. So the fact that I have a whole team of lawyers
over there -- I don't think Mr. Goldberger does it
anymore -- but there's lawyers on that side who
continue to falsely claim that I was part of a Ponzi
scheme.
In fact, Tonja Haddad just did it a month
ago.
Q So I don't see Tonja or her dad sitting
here. Do you?
A You are all together. You are all
representing --

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Pardon me.
Would you please allow Mr. Edwards to
complete his answer?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Yes, sir. Go ahead.
A You also decided to sign on and represent a
serial child molester, so you have adopted that
position.
Q Okay. Anything else to add to that?
A No.
Q So you see the lawyers that are here.

Ms. Rockenbach is with my new law firm, Link &
Rockenbach, correct?
A I got your card the other day. Thank you.
Q How did it look?
A Pretty good.
Q Pretty good? How about really good?
A I only looked at one side. Sorry. I will
check it out.
Q Ms. Rockenbach is with me. You see that.

Mr. Goldberger is down at the end of the table,
right? And Tina, who is a legal assistant at my
firm. Tonja Haddad is not here, is she?
A There isn't just a table long enough, I
assume. But, no.
Q Your lawyer hasn't shared with you -- you
haven't seen -- heard that they are withdrawing from
the case?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A No.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Has there
been a notice of withdrawal? Because I
haven't seen it either.
MR. LINK: I think we represented it to
Judge Hafele on Wednesday with the 8:45 when
Kara was in front of them.

MR. SCAROLA: I have seen no notice of
withdrawal. So as we sit here today, there
are a total of, I think, six law firms that
are representing Mr. Epstein.
BY MR. LINK:
Q And one really good one. The one you saw
the card on this week, right?
Okay. So I want to focus on this anxiety.
We all have anxiety in life, right? I wake up every
morning with anxiety about something. How my kid's
doing in college. Did he get home last night. Is
my son going to get a hit today on the baseball
team.
I want to talk about a different kind of
anxiety. The anxiety that you feel in November 2017
that relates back to the lawsuit that was filed in
December 2009. Can you separate that anxiety that I
am talking about?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
with.
A Just an anxious feeling to get this over
Q And you had that anxious feeling every
single day from December 2009 through today
November 10th, 2017?
A The more reminders that I have of the case,
and the fact that there still looms this false
allegation over my head, that is clearly a trigger.
Q You said it looms this false allegation.
What is the false allegation looming over your head?
A That I was a participant in a Ponzi scheme
with one of the individuals that might be the most
hated person in South Florida, especially amongst our
profession.
Q Mr. Rothstein?
A Right.
Q But why is there an allegation hanging over
your head? The case against you was dismissed in
2012, correct?

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Which case?
BY MR. LINK:
Q The case against you by Mr. Epstein was
dismissed in 2012, was it not?
A Right. The case was dismissed.
Q Five years ago the case was dismissed,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
true?
A Yes.
Q So what I'm trying to understand is, you
said that this was hanging over your head. Since
2012 there has not been a pleading that was alive in
circuit court from Mr. Epstein directed at you, true?
Since 2012?
A Has there -- was there a pleading against me
since 2012.
Q Yes, sir.
A The answer to that question is no.
Q So 2012, this allegation, that you said was
hanging over your head, has been removed, true?
A The complaint was dismissed.
Q Right. That was the allegation. And that
complaint has been dismissed.

MR. SCAROLA: Compound.
THE WITNESS: You are asking two
different things.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Well, you said --
A The allegation was made.
Q In 2009.
A -- and 9 million people read that allegation.
And --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q We are going to get to all of that.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me.
THE WITNESS: If you don't want me to
answer the question, then don't then ask
a question, I will answer, and you can shape
it however you want.
If you want me to give you an answer,
I'm willing to sit here and give you a full
answer.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I do. And I asked you if there has been a
pleading making those allegations since 2012.
A That's not the question that you asked. But
is that now the question that you are asking?
Q Yes.
A Sure. Pleadings have been filed, including
by Mr. Epstein's long-time recruiter of girls for him,

Ms. Maxwell. She made an allegation -- the same
allegation as part of a motion to recuse me as trial
counsel in a totally separate case.
Q What case was that you just brought up?
A versus Maxwell.
Q Where was that case pending?
A In New York.
Q And you were counsel in that case?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Yes.
Q Are you admitted in New York?
A I was pro hac.
Q Who was the admitted lawyer in New York?
A David Boies.
Q So you and Mr. Boies worked on that case
together?
A Yes.
Q How did Mr. Boies get involved?
A We co-represented , who is
also one of Mr. Epstein's victims.
Q Okay. Talking about the case you just
mentioned to me where you said Ms. Maxwell -- is that
right?
A Yes.
Q -- filed a pleading. Was Mr. Epstein a
party in that case?
A He had a joint defense agreement with her, so
he was -- he was basically advising her behind the
scenes. So for lack of a better word, he was basically
a party to the case.
Q So you have been practicing how many years
now? Fifteen?
A Yeah.
Q And you know what a party to a case is,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
right, in a civil lawsuit?
A I do.
Q Was Mr. Epstein a party in that lawsuit?
A A party in the sense was he in the style of
case, he was not.
Q Do you know what a party is in a lawsuit?
A Do you?
Q Yes, sir, I do.
A Okay. So right before trial we had an
argument that I believe was going to go in our favor
that we were going to be able to use his --

Mr. Epstein's Fifth Amendment invocation against
Ms. Maxwell, because of the LiButti factors, and
because he was basically a party and interest to the
case.
Was he in the style of the case? He was
not. But because they were so tightly connected as
conspirators, his interests were so intertwined with
hers, that we were going to be able to use his Fifth
Amendment invocation against her, which is a very
unusual and atypical situation.
Q Sounds like an interesting evidentiary
issue.
A Agreed.
Q In that case, who brought the client to
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
whom? Did you have the client and you went to

Mr. Boies, or did Mr. Boies have it and he came to
you?
A I represented first.
Q What made you go to David Boies?
MR. SCAROLA: You don't need to answer
that question. We object on the basis of
work product.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Other than work product, was there a reason
that you went to Mr. Boies for this what type of
case is it, by the way? I'm sorry. The case that
you filed.
A When David Boies became involved with
-- it's a complicated question,
because as a client in the case that was brought the
defamation case -- she was David Boies' client before
mine. In a more general sense, in terms of who
represented first, myself or Mr. Boise, I did.
I represented her in the Crime Victims' Rights Act
case.
Q Here in Florida?
A Here in Florida.
Q Yes, sir.
A David and David's firm filed the defamation
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
action and represented her in the defamation action
before bringing me in.
Q Who did Ms. Roberts sue in the defamation
action?
A Ghislaine Maxwell.
Q They did not sue Mr. Epstein?
A No.
Q And they brought you into the case after it
was filed to provide assistance?
A Correct.
Q So David Boies hires you in Florida to help
him prosecute the case; is that right?
A When you say the case, we are talking the
defamation action?
Q The defamation case, yeah. Dave Boise's
firm --
A We are talking multiple cases, so I just want
to make sure that we make the question and the answer
clear. Yes, defamation case he brought me in.
Q So David Boies filed the defamation action
and made the decision to co-counsel with you in
Florida to help him in New York; is that right?
A He made the decision to co-counsel with me.
Q In a New York case?
A In a New York case.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Got it. Okay.
In that case, Mr. Boies had represented
in a prior proceeding other than a
defamation action, or only in the defamation action?
A I am trying get the timing. He represented
her in another proceeding. Whether it was a prior
proceeding --
Q What was the other proceeding? Then we
will figure out the chronology.
A He represented her as a witness.
Q In what case was that?
A In a defamation action I filed against Alan
Dershowitz.
Q You're right. It is completed.
So the first action that gets filed is you
sued Alan Dershowitz?
A Right.
Q For defamation?
A Right.
Q That case has been dismissed, right?
A Right.
Q In that case was a witness?
A She was subpoenaed by Dershowitz to be a
witness.
Q And she hired David Boies to represent her?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Correct.
Q As a witness?
A Right.
Q And was she deposed in that case?
A She was.
Q And Mr. Boies was there to represent her?
A Someone from his firm was there to represent
her.
Q Then as a result of that, he ended up
representing -- Mr. Boies ended up representing her
in her own defamation case?
A Right. I'm not sure that the chronology is
exactly that, whether her deposition came first or the
defamation action came first. In fact, I think the
defamation action was filed before her deposition in
the other case, but that's why this just gets a little
complicated.
Q The chronology is complicated?
A Right.
Q I got it.
Now, is that case still pending, the
defamation case?
A No.
Q That case has been resolved?
A Settled in May, I believe, of this year.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q 2017?
A Correct.
Q So I want to get back to anxiety. And you
understand what I've meant that I have anxiety every
day. Everybody in life has levels of anxiety. You
agree with that?
A I suppose.
Q I had a lot of anxiety when I took the bar
exam. You may not have.
A In some different form -- I think that's a
word that's used that describes a bunch of different
feelings.
Q Absolutely. I agree.
What I'm really trying to understand
is I want to compartmentalize this. I'm focused
now on 2012, once Mr. Epstein dismissed his claims
against you in court. So from that date through
today, that cloud is no longer hanging over your
head. I would like to understand what your anxiety
is that relates to the lawsuit filed in 2009. How
it's impacting you on a day-to-day basis.
A It's hard for me to answer your question,
while along the way I'm disagreeing with the various
statements that you're making.
Q Tell me what you disagree with, sir.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A You're making a statement the cloud is no
longer over my head. That's the basis -- that's the
predicate for your ultimate question. That's just not
true.
Q So as you sit here today, there's a cloud
over your head as a result of the 2009 lawsuit that
was filed that was dismissed in 2012?
A For sure.
Q And how does it impact you? What I am
trying to understand is, you are going to ask the
jury to award money to you based on your level of
anxiety, right?
That's one of the things you want the jury
to do, is to say, I have anxiety and I want to be
compensated.
A As lawyers, what we have is our reputation.
That's what was destroyed.
Q We are going to get to reputation.
A That's --

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Please --
MR. LINK: I'm sorry. I apologize.
I'm just trying to streamline this. We will
get to reputation.

MR. SCAROLA: Well, what will
streamline it is if you ask a question and
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
allow Mr. Edwards to complete his answer
before you interrupt him.
MR. LINK: I got it. Thank you.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So I want to make sure that I understand --
I want you to tell us -- you are asking the jury to
award you an amount of money based on your having
suffered every day anxiety as a result of the lawsuit
that was filed in December 2009. Do I have that
right?
A Do you have that right? The anxiety is
related -- directly related to the harm done to my
reputation as a consequence of the filing of this false
lawsuit making up that I am a criminal associated with
who is known to be a terrible and horrible person. I
mean, that is the -- the anxiety is related to that.
Q I understand that generally. But I need to
know specifically. Let me start by this.
How much are you asking the jury to award
you for your day-in-and -day -out anxiety from
December 2009 through today?
A An amount of money that fairly and fully
would measure the magnitude of the harm done to my
reputation, and any consequential feelings that have
resulted or continue to exist because of the damage
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
done to my reputation.
Q How much are you asking for, sir, as it
relates to anxiety?
A I just explained to you.
Q There's not a dollar figure?
A What six people believe will measure the
magnitude of the harm that was done. If we want to
talk about the harm that was done, and then me tell you
how I would measure the magnitude of that damage, I
will try to walk you through that.
Q That would be great. But let's start here.
I want you to start with telling me has the anxiety
from 2009 through today increased or decreased?
A Until -- until the truth is known and this
case is behind me, it's the same.
Q So the anxiety level you have been burdened
with every single day since December of 2009 hasn't
changed in a positive or negative way?
A Well, there's no scale for anxiety. You know
this. Like you said, you have anxiety every single
day. It's not like you wake up and there's an anxiety
meter.
Now, when I was first served with the
lawsuit and people were asking about it and people
were talking about it all the time as, Hey, look,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
so-and-so is also saying this lawsuit was filed.
There's these big-time lawyers that are behind it
pushing this. People are now believing that you're
part of this.
Now, when you're hearing that all of the
time and you're having to deal with that on a
day-to-day basis, then your anxiety level, to use
your word, is -- I wouldn't say higher, but it's
aggravated on a more consistent basis.
Q So --
A These days I hear it less.
Q So from 2009 through today, what other
events have happened, other than the December 2009
Epstein lawsuit against you, that have caused you
anxiety? Anything?
A Nothing that comes to mind.
Q Any mortgage foreclosure actions against
you during that time period?
A Did I have a foreclosure action? I think I
did, but not one that caused me anxiety.
Q So having your house sold at sale didn't
cause you any anxiety?
A No.
Q Ever get sued for not paying a credit card
after 2009?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Could you show me something to refresh my
recollection? I don't remember that.
Q Being sued for not paying a credit card,
would that cause you anxiety?
A No. I don't remember it, so it doesn't.
Q Any other lawsuits filed against you for
not paying your debts, for money that you owed to
people or banks?
A Talking about since 2009?
Q Yes, sir.
A Do you have anything that could refresh my
recollection on this? Not that I recall.
Q As you sit here, you don't remember being a
defendant in a civil lawsuit where any entity has
claimed you did not pay them money that you owed
them?
A Ever in my life?
Q No. Since 2009, sir.
A I had an action that resulted from a line of
credit that I had prior to going to RRA, that I was
told when I went to RRA was going to be paid, and it
wasn't. And I resolved that at some point in time
after suit was filed.
Yeah, I believe that suit was filed and
then I resolved the case. It's not something that
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
caused me anxiety.
Q So the three lawsuits that we just
discussed where you were sued for not paying your
debts back, that didn't cause you any anxiety; is
that right?
A Right. There was never a time where I wasn't
going to pay my debt, so it didn't cause me anxiety.
Q Well, your house was sold at a foreclosure
sale, wasn't it?
A The answer to your question is yes.
Q That didn't cause any anxiety?
A No. The circumstances of that did not cause
me anxiety.
Q And you said that Mr. Rothstein promised to
pay off your $200,000 credit line that you took out
in order to start your sole practice as a lawyer; is
that right?
A He promised to pay the credit line over the
time that I was employed at RRA at some point. I don't
remember it being $200,000. You are just throwing
these facts into the question that I don't recall.
Q So how much money did you borrow in order
to start your sole practice law firm?
A I don't remember that.
Q Did Mr. Rothstein promise you during the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
time that you were interviewing that he would make
the monthly payments or he would pay whatever that
amount was off?
A My meeting with him was about 10 minutes.
And what he said was, do you have a line of credit?
Don't worry about it. It will be paid off at some
point in time that you are at this firm. We are going
to treat you fairly. That was it. There was no
specifics about it. Nobody laid out the credit line.
It wasn't that kind of meeting.
Q I got it.
Did you ever ask Mr. Rothstein to pay it
off during the time that you were employed by him?
A No. I hardly talked to the guy.
Q My question wasn't whether you talked to
him. It was whether you ever asked him to fulfill
A In order to ask somebody you have to talk to
them.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Doesn't
asking involve talking?
MR. LINK: You can do it by email or
letter. Lots of different ways,

Mr. Scarola.
BY MR. LINK:
Q But did you, in any form of communication,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
ask Mr. Rothstein to fulfill his promise to you -- as
an inducement to become an employee there -- that he
would pay off whatever line of credit you had?
A No.
Q No. You did not?
A Right. I answered the question. No.
Q I just didn't hear you.
A Still no.
Q Were there any other financial incentives,
other than paying off the line of credit, in the 10
minutes you spent with Mr. Rothstein, that made you
decide that's the place you wanted to work?
A No.
Q Anything else since 2009 through today that
has caused anxiety, other than the fact that

Mr. Epstein filed his claim in December?
A I think I told you. That word encompasses so
many different feelings. Like you said, we all feel
anxiety to some degree every single day.
I mean, I try cases. I'm a trial lawyer,
so there's anxiety. There's healthy anxiety.
There's unhealthy anxiety. Do things cause anxiety?
Everything causes some form of anxiety.
Q So you get anxious before you try a case?
A Sure.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q You have anxiety?
A For sure.
Q Have you communicated to any of the folks
you've represented since 2009 that you are suffering
from a high level of anxiety, an anxiety that should
be compensated by a jury in describing for them
whether you were fit to represent them?

MR. SCAROLA: Objection.
Attorney -client privilege. Don't answer
that question.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Have you not retained -- have you not been
retained by any client since 2009 as a result of this
compensable level of anxiety that you suffer every
day?
A Explain your question a little better.
Q Are there any clients that you wanted to be
your client that said, I'm not going to hire you,

Mr. Edwards, because I can see you're manifesting
some level of anxiety, that's not just a typical
anxiety that we all go through, it's a heightened
level, it's a compensable level, as a result of

Mr. Epstein's lawsuit?
A No.
Q Any clients fire you as a result of this
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
heightened level of anxiety?
A No.
Q Have you made more money collectively each
year from January 2010 forward to today than you did
January 2010 back to when you started practicing law?
You are staring at your lawyer. You want
an objection.
A I will answer the question if he wants me to
answer the question.

MR. SCAROLA: You can answer that
question.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I'm asking big picture.
A All right. Can you repeat the question?
Q Let me do it again. It will probably be
easier. The good news is, I never remember what just
came out of my mouth.
Here is the point. I want to look at this
injury to your reputation and your embarrassment and
all of these other things you are asking the jury to
award money to you for, right? That's what you're
asking the jury to do, to compensate you for the
impact that the Epstein lawsuit had on your ability
to practice law. True?

MR. SCAROLA: No.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
THE WITNESS: I can't tell if you're
talking or asking a question.

MR. SCAROLA: There is no claim in this
case for either lost earnings or diminished
earning capacity. That's been made clear on
the record previously.

MR. LINK: I understand that, and
that's not -- let me back up. That's a good
point. Mr. Scarola, thank you for helping
me with that. I appreciate it.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Is the reputation that was injured Bradley
Edwards as an individual, or Bradley Edwards as a
licensed practicing lawyer?
A Both.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I'm going to
object to the form of the question. It
attempts to draw a distinction that makes no
sense to me.
BY MR. LINK:
Q We all have a reputation as a person in our
community, just as a father, as a husband, right? In
our regular community we have a reputation, right?
A Okay.
Q Do you?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Do I have a reputation?
Q Yes, sir.
A Everybody has a reputation.
Q Right. Then we have -- separate from that,
we have a reputation. If we're lawyers, we have a
reputation with judges. We have a reputation with
opposing counsel. We have a reputation with our
co-counsel. And we have what I will call a
professional reputation. And we spend a lot of time
and effort protecting our professional reputation.
You agree with that statement?
A Yes.
Q What I'm trying to understand is, was it
your are you seeking compensation from the jury
for the filing of that complaint based on harm to
your reputation in your professional capacity as a
lawyer or in your personal capacity as a husband?

MR. SCAROLA: And I object to the form
of the question, because it leaves out the
obvious third alterative, which is both.
BY MR. LINK:
Q You can answer my question.
A Both. I answered the question the first time
both.
Q Can you separate for me -- and tell me from
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
a compensatory standpoint money the jury should award
to you, what has happened to your reputation from a
personal standpoint? Give me an example.
Do you have friends that will no longer
talk to you since the filing of the complaint by
Mr. Epstein?
A Do I have friends who don't talk to me
because of that?
Q Yeah. Do you have friends that --
A You are talking about the people who knew me?
The people who knew me?
Q Yeah.
A No.
Q So in November of 2009, before the lawsuit
was filed, I assumed you had friends, right?
A Right.
Q Do you still have those same friends today
for the most part?
A I still have friends today.
Q Did anybody come up to you and say, Listen,
Brad, you know, I used to like you and I used to like
being your friend. You were a swell guy to hang out
with, but geez, I see Epstein filed this claim
against you and I don't want to be your friend
anymore?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Are you talking now about lawyers or are you
talking about --
Q No, personal.
A People who are nonlawyers.
Q Nonlawyers. Because you said both.
A I'm just trying to get a category so I
understand the question. So have nonlawyers come up to
me and say I will no longer be your friend because of
the lawsuit?
Q Yeah.
A No.
Q Do you go to a church?
A Not regularly.
Q Did you go to a church in 2009?
A Periodically. But nobody has come up to me
at church and said I'm not going to be your friend
anymore or associate with you because of this lawsuit.
The people who know me don't do this.
Q So from a personal standpoint anyone who
knew you, your reputation really didn't take a hit as
a result of Epstein filing his lawsuit in
December 2009.
A The lawsuit is not about -- about
reputational damage that was caused to me by the people
who know me well. The people who know me well know
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
that those things are not true.
The lawyers I practice with know that
those things are not true. It's the rest of the
world that --
Q Oh, okay.
A Your reputation is made up of what society
thinks of you. The people who don't know me and only
got a snapshot of this person -- is Rothstein's
co-conspirator in a Ponzi scheme and continue to spread
that message from that point in time forward, whether
it's 9 million people or 100 million people, my
reputation right there suffered damages that, unless
and until a jury returns a verdict in my favor, can't
be undone.
Q So these are the nameless, faceless folks
that you don't know, that you have never met, never
had conversations with, never interacted with, who
are -- that have impacted your reputation.
A Your question is way too extreme.
Q So you told me it's anyone who knows you,
knows for sure that there's nothing
A I didn't tell you that.
Q You didn't?
A No. Who knows me well.
Q They have to know you well, right?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Can I just finish my answer?
Q Sure.
A I let you finish every question. You refuse
to let me finish the answer.
Q Answer away, sir.
A If it's an attorney who knew me well before
this, who worked with me, knew my ethics, knew my
abilities as a trial lawyer, they knew this to be
false.
If it were lawyers who did not know me or
knew of me but didn't really know me well, then
certainly this looks like where there's smoke
there's fire, and it impacts your reputation in the
minds of all of those people.
Whether lawyers or nonlawyers, the same
exact thing can be said for the rest of the
9 million or so people who saw these false
allegations.
Q So I like the where there's smoke there's
fire. That's an interesting statement. Would the
same thing be true about what Mr. Rothstein was doing
that where there's smoke there's fire?
A What does your question mean?
Q Well, you used this analogy where there's
smoke there's fire. You saw the press that was out
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
about Mr. Rothstein in November -- the month of
November 2009 describing all of the vehicles he owned
and something about a pair of $1.5 million
Lamborghinis or something, mansions and a
million -dollar wedding, and $8 million home here, and
a $7 million home there -- these numbers may not be
exactly accurate, but close to that. And how the law
firm was 70 lawyers, and a payroll of X dollars was
surviving, and that there was a lot of speculation in
the press about how Rothstein did it, whether he did
it alone, and whether there were potential unnamed
co-conspirators. Do you remember reading about that?

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I am going to
object to the question. It grossly
compound, it lacks factual predicate, and is
not capable of reasonably being responded
to.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Give it a try.
A Some of those things I believe I read about
or was told about after the implosion of RRA. Some of
those things don't sound familiar to me at all. But
you strung together --
Q A lot of stuff.
A -- a bunch of things, some of which I
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
remember, some I don't.
Q Let's pick it apart a little bit. When you
worked at --
A I don't know what this has to do with smoke
and fire, but
Q You said where there's smoke there must be
fire, and --

MR. SCAROLA: No, that's not what he
said.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Well, maybe I misheard you. What did you
say about smoke and fire?
A That when someone reads the complaint about
me, they are going to read this and believe that if
these allegations are being made by this person, who is
a wealthy person, who has lawyers that also have good
reputations, and it details out like a criminal
complaint, that if somebody is willing to make this
type of detailed complaint it must be true
Q Right and --
A -- about me.
Q I got that. I understand that.
By the way, you said somebody with this
kind of money makes this complaint. So you were a
Florida lawyer in December 2009, right?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Right.
Q And what was Mr. Epstein, the person you
just said if somebody makes these allegations
everybody will believe they're true? What was his
state in life at the time, December 2009?
A He had a bunch of different states in life.
Q What was it in December 2009?
A I think he was out of jail.
Q So he had served time, right -- jail time?
A Right.
Q And he was an admitted what?
A Sex offender.
Q Admitted sex offender who did jail time.
A Right.
Q And you are telling me that if somebody
looked at the allegations made by the admitted sex
offender who did jail time compared to you, that you
think anybody who read them would say, We believe
what Mr. Epstein says in here, and where there's
smoke there must be fire so the allegations must be
true?

MR. SCAROLA: I am going to object as
incomplete hypothetical.
THE WITNESS: They are very detailed
allegations. And when you read it in
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
conjunction with what was going on at the
time, how hated Mr. Rothstein was at the
time, then, yeah, people are going to
believe that those allegations are true.
BY MR. LINK:
Q All right. Good.
A At least that's my perception as well, which
is causes --
Q Can you tell me one person who came up to
you after the lawsuit was filed and said, I believe,

Mr. Edwards, that what Mr. Epstein's lawyers wrote in
this complaint against you, that that's true?
A What will typically happen at the courthouse
would be lawyers would come up and say, Hey, so-and-so
was just saying this complaint was just filed against
you by Mr. Epstein, and that in reality there might
have been real cases against Mr. Epstein, but you
didn't have those, that you actually represented
clients who had nothing to do with him. You fabricated
cases with Rothstein, and they are speculating that you
will be arrested with Mr. Rothstein for the fabrication
of Epstein cases and pretending that you represented
Epstein victims. That would happen with great
frequency when it was hot, when it was hot in the
press.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Okay. I got that. And that makes sense.
Did you have a concern that you might be
arrested or indicted?
A No.
Q None at all?
A Zero.
Q Did you ever hire a criminal lawyer?
A No.
Q Never consulted with one?
A No.
Q So you said -- I think I heard you say in
December 2009 everyone who knew your reputation about
your level of ethics and professionalism would have
known that the allegations were untrue. Did I get
that close?
A The people that knew me very well would have
known that it was not true, yes.
Q So before December 2009, did you ever have
any ethical issues that you had to deal with?

MR. SCAROLA: Let me object to the form
of the question as vague.
THE WITNESS: Such as what? Not that I
remember.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Nothing that you remember. All right.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
You graduated from law school in May or
June 2001?
A Somewhere around there, yeah.
Q And you were admitted -- when did you take
the bar exam?
A In July of 2001.
Q And did you pass the bar exam on your first
try?
A Yes.
Q And then you were not admitted until March
of 2002, correct?
A Correct.
Q Was there a holdup on your -- on your bar
being admitted, something about your character and
fitness evaluation?
A There was -- there was a delay in the
finalization of that.
Q Based on their taking an extended look at
your character and fitness to practice law in the
State of Florida, right?
A Right. There's two elements of it. There's
the test and character fitness.
Q Right. I understand. And the delay, which
was almost a year from when you graduated, was the
character and fitness part. You passed the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
test-taking part, right?
A I got my -- we got our scores back in late
September, and then I was admitted in March. So it's
not almost a year.
Q No. I said from when you graduated.
A I know, but it just makes it seem longer than
it is. I mean, I know you chose when I graduated. I
would not have been admitted anyway until October.
Q Did you file your application to join the
bar before you graduated or -- and before you took
the test, or did you wait to do that until after you
took test?
A No, I filed it before I graduated school.
Q You filed it before you got out of law
school, right? It's a long process.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. One question
at a time, please.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So you filed the application before you got
out of law school, right?
A Yes.
Q So that's close to a year since you filed
the application before you were approved, based on
their extended evaluation of your character and
fitness to practice law?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Yeah. I don't quarrel with that.
Q What were the incidents they were looking
at that delayed them? Do you remember?
A No. I don't remember the incidents that they
were looking at. It was --
Q You really don't have any idea what they
were looking at? What caused them concern?

MR. SCAROLA: Objection. Compound.
THE WITNESS: I believe it related to
when I was a juvenile. I think that was the
first thing I had to answer about.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Okay. Was there more than one?
A Do you have anything that can refresh my
recollection so I know exactly what it was that I was
doing back in 2000 or 2001?
Q I'm asking you, sir, if you remember what
the incidents were that were in your past that the
bar examiners were looking at in evaluating your
character and fitness. And if you're telling me you
don't remember, then you don't remember.
A It was incidents related to an arrest. And I
think that one of them was when I was a juvenile.
Q And the other arrest?
A I believe it was an underage drinking arrest.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q That was the first arrest, right? Were
there two arrests?
A And the other one was a possession of
prescription without a prescription.
Q What was the prescription?
A I don't remember the name of it right now.
But if you showed it to me then I would know. If you
said it, I would know.

MR. LINK: So we have been going about
an hour. Why don't we take a couple minute
break if that's okay, because I need to take
a break?
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
10:48 a.m. and we are going off the record.
(A recess was had.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
10:58 a.m. We are back on the record.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Edwards, I got a little derailed.
There was a question that I asked about, and then I
meandered away from it. I was saying starting in
December 2009 when the lawsuit was filed -- and I
think I asked about January 1 just to make it
simpler. So January -- let's talk about January 1,
2010 looking back to when you started practicing law
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
in 2002, compared to January 1, 2010, forward through
today. During those two separate time frames, in
which one have you collectively in total made more
money in your profession as a lawyer?
A Since 2010?
Q So January -- is it easy -- is January a
good way to do it? Is it easier to think about
the --
A That's fine.
Q So in January 2010 through today, your
income as a lawyer has been collectively greater than
it was from January 2010 back to 2002 when you
started practicing.
A Right.
Q Would you say it has doubled during that
time period?

MR. SCAROLA: I am going to object to
the question and instruct you not to answer
on the basis of economic privacy. The
question is not relevant, material nor
reasonably calculated to lead to the
discovery of relevant material information.

MR. LINK: And I take it, Mr. Scarola,
any question I would ask like that -- not
asking about the specific dollars, but just
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
the parameters, you will have the same
objection?

MR. SCAROLA: Well, I don't know,
because I did allow you to ask the one
question --
MR. LINK: You did.
MR. SCAROLA: -- that you asked that
was answered. So you are going to need to
ask your questions, and I will make a
determination as to whether I will assert an
objection and instruct Mr. Edwards not to
answer based upon what the question is.

MR. LINK: Fair enough.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So, Mr. Edwards in comparing those two time
frames, 2002 through 2010 -- which was an eight -year
time period of practice, right?
A Right.
Q I saw you counting on your fingers.
compared to 2010 through 2017, which is
a seven-year time frame, in the seven years
A We are almost up to January 2018, though,
so --
Q Let's make it '18.
A We're about even.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Fair enough. Let's make it eight to eight
so we're comparing apples to apples.
A Yeah.
Q Would you say that your income as a lawyer,
as a professional, in the second half of your career,
the past eight years, is significantly greater than
your income was in the first eight years of your
practice?

MR. SCAROLA: I'm going to object to
the question on the basis that it's vague.
But can you go ahead and answer that
question.
THE WITNESS: The answer is yes.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Thank you for answering that.
We were talking about some ethics issues
and whether you had any, and I was asking you what
you remember. Do you remember -- as we were talking
about your reputation -- do you remember any
incidents while you were working for the Broward
State Attorney's office where anything that you did
was called into question or there were any news
reports or anything?
MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I am going to
object. The question is vague and compound.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
THE WITNESS: What's the question?
BY MR. LINK:
Q When you -- you worked for the Broward
State Attorney's office?
A Basically three years.
Q Three years, okay.
During that three-year time period
well, let me ask you this. Why did you leave? Was
there -- why did you leave?
A Just time to leave.
Q What does that mean? Was there an offer on
the table? Were you asked to leave? What was the
reason?
A I tried a bunch of case. I wanted to try
civil cases. I wanted to try civil cases from the
beginning. I wanted experience as a trial lawyer. I
went to the state attorney's office. I got a lot of
experience, and it was time to leave and do what I
wanted to do. So that's it.
Q So was there anything that happened shortly
before you left that -- where anybody called into
question anything you did as far as your
representation of the State of Florida on behalf of
the Broward State Attorney's Office?
A My supervisors would have said that I was
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
probably the best prosecutor there at the time, so that
was not -- that was never something that happened.
Q I wouldn't find any reports about a
tampered -with video being placed into evidence or
anything like that if I searched the Internet using
your name? Is that true?
A I know that case. But that case is not me
tampering with anything. That case was me prosecuting
somebody for what they did in a very effective, very
fair way, the most fair way possible; him getting
convicted, him going to prison, him getting upset, and
suing me, the State Attorney Mike Satz, all of the
police officers involved in the case. So that's what
happened.
I know -- that's Donald Baker. I know the
Donald Baker case well.
Q So you were sued?
A Yeah.
Q So Mr. Epstein's suit was not the first one
against you that called into question something that
you are doing as a lawyer; is that true?
A I didn't know about that lawsuit when I was
first sued, because the AG's office was representing
me. I was no longer at the state attorney's office.
So they picked up and represented the suit. And I
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
heard it was dismissed right away. I didn't keep up
with the case.
Q I understand. But my question was so that
you had, before Mr. Epstein sued you, been sued based
on conduct, something that allegedly you did during
your work as a lawyer, right?
A True.
Q Where was that lawsuit filed, sir?
A If you can show me, I'm not going to quarrel
with it. I just don't know that I have seen it -- in
Florida.
Q Were you served with a lawsuit?
A I think I was served with a lawsuit.
Q Did it cause anxiety when you were served?
A No.
Q Well, you were alleged to have done
something that was unethical, correct?
A He made these allegation before in court. We
had hearings over it, over his 57 -- his 38 -- 3.850
motion for his ineffective assistance of counsel. I
had heard this whole thing. It was -- it was such
nonsense that was being made by a criminal that -- sour
grapes. He lost a trial and had to go to prison. I
didn't even want to recommend prison in the case.
The fact is, he had committed a murder
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
previously in his life, so he was HOQ qualified,
which necessitated a five-year prison sentence. I
didn't think he deserved that for that crime, nor
did I recommend it. It was just part of the
guidelines by the state. So I knew it was a harsh
sentence for the crime that he committed. He was
upset about it, and he took it out on everybody.
Q So you weren't -- you didn't suffer any
anxiety or concern at all about a lawsuit that was
filed in 2004 that related to allegations of
unethical conduct in a proceeding that you were the
lead trial lawyer?
A Zero.
Q Did anybody ask you about the alleged
unethical conduct that was in that lawsuit?
A No.
Q Did you read the press that was involved
with the filing of the lawsuit against you based on
your work as a prosecutor?
A I don't remember there being press about the
lawsuit that was filed.
Q You don't?
A No.
Q Anybody ask you -- assume for a minute
there was some press. Did anybody ask you about it?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Object to the
improper question.
MR. LINK: It was a really bad
question, wasn't it?

MR. SCAROLA: Yeah. Terrible.
MR. LINK: Thank you. I object.
MR. SCAROLA: Good.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I don't even know how to follow up with
that one it was so bad.
A It's tough.
Q You're right.
Did anybody in your -- in the profession,
lawyers that you dealt with from time to time or
regularly, comment to you about the lawsuit that was
filed against you in 2004?
A No.
Q Did the filing of that lawsuit have
anything to do with your termination at the state
attorney's office for Broward?
MR. SCAROLA: Object.
THE WITNESS: I wasn't terminated from
the state attorney's office.
BY MR. LINK:
Q How about did it have anything to do with
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
your decision to resign?
A Absolutely not.
Q Do you remember that the lawsuit alleged a
1983 violation?
A No.
Q How long was the lawsuit pending?
A I have no idea. I never read the lawsuit.
Q So you were served with a lawsuit, you were
sued, and you don't even read it? Is that true?
A I didn't even read it. That's true. I doubt
Judge Gates read it. I doubt Mike Satz read it.
Q You were a defendant.
A So were they. We were all joined together.
The police department. Everybody was defendants.
Q No big deal?
A It was a joke.
Q How many associates were employed at
Bradley Edwards & Associates?
A I don't think I ever had associates. I
had -- I had law clerks that the plan was always when
they passed the bar that they would be associates, but
that's just -- I didn't have the firm open long enough.
Q Did you ever check with the Florida Bar to
see if it was a violation of the bar ethics rules to
call yourself Bradley Edwards & Associates if you had
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
no associates?
A No.
Q Are you familiar today with the ethical
rule that involves your calling your law firm Bradley
Edwards & Associates and whether that is proper under
the bar rules?
A No. Even if you plan to have associates in
the near future? I have never read that rule, I don't
believe.
Q And when you left the state attorney's
office, did you form Bradley Edwards & Associates
then?
A No.
Q What did you do?
A I worked for a law firm, Kubicki Draper.
Q How long were you at Kubicki Draper?
A Approximately three years.
Q So three years at state attorney's office,
right?
A Just short of.
Q Three years at Kubicki Draper?
A Approximately, right.
Q What type of firm was Kubicki Draper at the
time? That would have been 2005-ish.
A '04, '05, '06, '07. Insurance defense.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q So you left the state attorney's office and
did insurance defense work?
A Correct.
Q What type of work did you do? Tell me the
clients that you represented generally.
A I represented individuals who were
primarily car accident cases. Those are the types of
trials that I tried.
Again, my objective was get as many trials
as I could at the firm. That -- it was primarily
auto accident cases.
Q So these are folks who were insured by
insurance companies?
A Right.
Q And behalf of the insurance companies they
would retain the law firm that you worked for to
represent their insureds.
A Right.
Q And so the insureds were the folks that
were being blamed for whatever the car accident was.
Is that true?
A For the most part.
Q Did you have any plaintiff's cases on
behalf of insureds?
A I don't think so.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q So they would have all been where an
insured was being sued by somebody claiming that
their car caused them some injury, I take it. Is
that right?
A Right.
Q Anything there other than
A That's why I made that caveat before.
Sometimes it wasn't they were being blamed for causing
the accident. They owned the car or something like
that. Dangerous instrumentality or something.
Q I understand. So they were all defendants.
Not plaintiffs.
A Correct.
Q I know you said earlier you tried a lot of
cases at the state attorney's office. I saw
somewhere in your file roughly 60 cases there.
A At least.
Q At least 60. Were any of those cases
involving -- you mentioned a murder what I would
call dangerous criminals?
A Yeah, of course.
Q Tell me some of the more dangerous
criminals that you prosecuted during a trial.
A Armed robbers.
Q Armed robbers with guns?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Right.
Q Who else?
A I mean, kidnappers. Any prosecuted cases
where there were gang stabbings and -- plenty of
violent criminals.
Q Did any of those violent criminals, like
the gang members and the murders and the kidnappers
and the armed robbers, cause you to have any fear of
physical injury to yourself? Were you afraid they
were going to hurt you?
A No. I don't believe so. It's hard to tap
into old feelings like that and rewind time, but I
don't think so. I never had any fear of them doing
anything to me.
Q I assume there were gang members that you
were prosecuting and probably gang members you were
not prosecuting within that category.
A Sometimes you're prosecuting gang members and
your best witness is also a gang member. That's the
nature of that world.
Q And you weren't afraid -- physically you
weren't afraid of one of these gang members -- or
prosecuting that case or being involved was going to
come -- cause physical harm to you, were you?
A No.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q What about the physical harm to your
family, were you worried that -- I guess I should
have asked. Were you married?
A No. Predates all of that, so --
Q Fair enough.
A Also, that's kind of a time period pre-family
where you just generally have less responsibilities and
less fears as a human being.
Q When were you married?
A 2005.
Q Any of those folks ever get out of prison
after you were married, people that you put away?
A I assume.
Q Were you worried that one of them was going
to come back, since you prosecuted them, and hurt you
or your family? You have that fear?
A No. I never really put thought in my mind
that their target was the prosecutor. I was just
carrying out what my job was if there was evidence of a
crime.
Q You don't think they really liked you, do
you -- the gang members and the murderers -- for you
trying to put them in prison?
A Assuming after they went to jail they didn't
like me or the cops or the state attorney or the judge
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
or anybody else.
Q What is it about Mr. Epstein you met

Mr. Epstein in person, right?
A Yes, several times.
Q How tall is he, roughly?
A Six-foot maybe. I have only read his sex
offender profile. And I think it says six-foot on his
flyer.
Q How tall are you?
A Five -ten.
Q He's taller than you are?
A I don't know that. I just remember seeing
his sex offender -- that's what sticks out in my mind
when I tell you the answer to that. I think it says
six foot.
Q Are you physically afraid of him, of

Mr. Epstein?
A Physically if I was in hand-to-hand combat
with him would I be afraid of him?
Q Are you in fear of him? Do you have a fear
that he will cause a physical injury and he will hurt
you?
A In a fistfight?
Q Generally, do you have a fear that he will
cause you physical injury -- Mr. Epstein?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A In any sense of the word?
Q Yes, sir.
A If he personally?
Q Yes, sir.
A I don't fear that he personally is going to
attack me at some point in time. I think I'm answering
the question that you're asking.
Q Do you think he's going to attack your
family?
A Do I think that Jeffrey Epstein is going to
come to my house personally and attack me? No, I don't
think that.
Q Yes.
You don't have that fear, do you?
And this lawsuit was filed in December

2009. From 2009 through to today, has Mr. Epstein
threatened you with any physical harm?
A Has he threatened me with physical harm? He
has certainly said things to make it known to me that
me or my family could be harmed. But again, not that
he personally would do it.
Q Tell me what he said to you that makes you
think that Mr. Epstein was threatening to harm you
physically.
A I can almost tell you verbatim.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Please.
A Brad, if you continue to prosecute these
cases this way, somebody is going to get hurt. You are
lucky that we are not litigating this in New York,
because you know that I have a lot of friends, a lot of
power. The fact that we are dealing with one another,
I have so much more money than you and resources. This
is not a fair fight. I could have you and your family
under surveillance 24 hours a day. So think about that
as you are prosecuting these cases.
Those types of statements he made to me
several times.
Q When he said that, it sounds like he was
talking about the disparity in economics. His
ability to hire lawyers. But did you feel that he
was physically threatening you? That he was going to
physically hurt you?

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I'm going to
object to the form of the question. I
object to the predicate. It's argumentive.
If the question is, Did you feel he was
physically going to hurt you, that question
is repetition. And also in the context of
the discussion that has occurred, vague and
ambiguous, because you are failing to
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
distinguish between what Mr. Epstein was or
may have been threatening to do personally
and what Mr. Epstein is capable of having
been done.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So from December 2009 through today, have
you been living in fear, sir, that Mr. Epstein
personally, or otherwise, was going to cause physical
harm to your body?
A The "or otherwise," yes. The "personally,"

no. I don't think he's personally going to do any of
the dirty work nor do I think he normally does. I
think that he has people do those things for him.
Q What do you think he has people do?
A Whatever he wants done.
Q I see. So you think that, based on your
conversation with Mr. Epstein, that over the last
eight years there was always this fear in your mind
that somebody was lurking around and going to cause
you physical harm, right?
A The only problem with your question is based
on your conversation. That's not the only reason that
I think that. It's not based on my conversation with
Epstein. It's based on the totality of the
circumstances.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
I mean, I had been involved in the
investigation of Mr. Epstein and his conduct for
many, many years. I know a lot about him. He knows
I know a lot about him. I have talked to a lot of
people about him, a lot of people who believe he's a
very dangerous people. I believe he's a very
dangerous person. He's made it pretty clear to me
that he's a very dangerous person.
Someone would be crazy not to have some
form of fear that something could happen when you
become a target of his. That lawsuit is a clear
indication that I am a direct target of his. No
doubt in my mind.
Q I got it.
So for the last eight years how many
bodyguards have you hired?
A Bodyguards?
Q Yes, sir, to protect from you physical harm
that Mr. Epstein is going to cause you or somebody
else on his behalf.
A I haven't hired bodyguards. But I don't
think a bodyguard is going to do any good.
Q So have you -- you never hired a bodyguard,
right?

MR. SCAROLA: That question was asked
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
and answered.
BY MR. LINK:
Q For you -- no bodyguards for you?
A Per se, I have not hired a bodyguard.
Q How about for your family? Have you hired
protection to keep Mr. Epstein or somebody he knows
from causing physical harm to them?
A No, with the exception of there were times
where I had an investigator who would -- when I knew
that Mr. Epstein had investigators following me, I
would have an investigator to watch out during those
periods of time. I think it only happened twice.
Q Well, you had investigators working on the
Epstein case long before he sued you, didn't you?
A Of course.
Q You had former law enforcement officers on
the team at Mr. Rothstein's firm investigating

Mr. Edwards (sic), didn't you?
A I am Mr. Edwards.
Q I'm sorry. Mr. Epstein. Maybe they
investigated you too. Who knows at that firm, right?
Let me try it again.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Did you at Mr. Rothstein's firm --

MR. SCAROLA: I move that Counsel's
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
comments be stricken.
MR. LINK: About the Rothstein's firm?
That's fair.

MR. SCAROLA: Thank you.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I think there's all kinds of security and
things at Mr. Rothstein's firm we will get to, but
let me try it again.
While you were employed by Mr. Rothstein,
you had former police officers that were used to
investigate Mr. Epstein, correct?
A While I was at RRA, investigators were
investigating issues related to the Epstein cases, yes.
Q Some of them were former law enforcement
employees, right?
A That's true.
Q One was a former sheriff?
A If you're talking about Ken Jenne, I don't
know how much he did in investigating anything, but he
worked there.
Q Mr. Jenne was a former sheriff?
A Mr. Jenne was a former sheriff.
Q Did he have any issues of his own with law
enforcement? Any procedures before he started
working at Mr. Rothstein's firm?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A I believe that I know the same thing you do.
Q What do you know?
A He was arrested at some point in time when he
was the sheriff.
Q And you were aware of that when he was
employed by Mr. Rothstein and working on the Epstein
file?

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Objection,
compound.
BY MR. LINK:
Q You can answer.
A I was.
MR. SCAROLA: That assumes facts not in
evidence.
THE WITNESS: I was aware that -- I was
aware that he had been arrested when he was
the sheriff.
When I was working at -- at the time I
was working at RRA, I knew that Ken Jenne at
some time prior had been arrested while he
was acting sheriff.
BY MR. LINK:
Q What other former law enforcement folks at
Rothstein's firm were assigned as investigators on
the Epstein matters?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A I worked with Mike Fisten. That was the
investigator I communicated with.
Q Tell me about Mike Fisten. What was his
former role before he worked at Rothstein?
A He was a Miami -Dade homicide detective.
Q Did he have any issues before joining

Mr. Rothstein's firm?
A I don't know.
Q Don't know.
Does he still work for you?
A No.
Q Did he work for you after you left
Mr. Rothstein's firm?
A He did.
Q For how long did he work for you?
A I don't remember.
Q Before you -- and that was at your own law
firm. You started a law firm after Rothstein, right?
A We started Farmer, Jaffe, Weissing, Edwards,
Fistos & Lehrman basically right -- RRA imploded. We
started that firm.
Q And the investigator went with you?
A He was an employee of ours.
Q Did you do any background check on him
before hiring him as an employee at your law firm?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A I knew his résumé. I mean, I knew that he
was a Miami -Dade homicide detective. I knew that. I
had talked to Pat Roberts, who also was an
investigator, who had told me how highly credentialed
Mike was. I had talked to Pat Diaz, who was also a
Miami -Dade homicide detective. And all three of them
did work for us after RRA. So these are all
investigators that I knew and I still know them today.
Q Did all of those investigators work on the
Epstein matter?
A To some degree, yes.
Q How many investigators in total from the
Rothstein firm and the subsequent firm, the Farmer
firm, were involved in investigating Mr. Epstein?
A Ever?
Q Yes.
A Over the course of time?
Q Yes, sir.
A The first investigator I used was Wayne
Black. I don't know if Wayne did any work after we
left RRA. The RRA period is -- you know, that's a
six-month period that we are talking about. He
definitely did work while I was at RRA. I don't know
about after. He might have even done work before --
before I went to RRA.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Mike Fisten was the primary person -- the
investigator that worked on the case while I was at
RRA and also the primary investigator after.
Mike then delegated to other investigators
other work. I know for a fact that Pat Roberts was
one of those people. And I also know that Pat Diaz
was.
Q So that's four investigators that were
retained to investigate Mr. Epstein?
A Yeah. Not altogether. Not all working
together, but yes. Wayne Black didn't work with them,
but yes.
Q I'm just talking about the number --
A Yeah.
Q -- of investigators. So four --

MR. SCAROLA: When you say retained to
investigate Mr. Epstein, you're suggesting
that the purpose for which they were hired
was to investigate Mr. Epstein, or are you
only asking whether at some point in time
during their employment they investigated

Mr. Epstein?
MR. LINK: That question.
THE WITNESS: Yeah. At some point in
time those four people investigated
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Mr. Epstein.
BY MR. LINK:
Q On your behalf?
A What do you mean on my behalf?
Q You were the lead lawyer in the Epstein
files, right?
A RRA paid them while there. They were just
employees of RRA, same as me. And then afterwards, my
next firm paid Mr. Fisten. He was our investigator
after that.
Q I asked a bad question. Let's go back to
RRA for a minute. So you said these investigators,
the three that you mentioned --
A Right.
Q -- were employees of RRA?
A I believe so. I don't know about Pat Diaz.
He might have been contracted out by Mike Fisten for
extra help. But Pat Roberts and Mike Fisten were
employees for sure.
Q So who was it at RRA that made the decision
to bring in the first investigator, Mr. Wayne Black?
A I think I did. I think I brought him in -- I
think I was at least talking to him before I went to
RRA. And then when I got to RRA, I don't believe there
was already an investigative division in place. I
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
could be wrong about that.
If memory serves me right, I don't
remember there being -- Mike Fisten was the first
investigator I communicated with there. I don't
think he worked there yet. So I think that when I
got there, I had already talked to Wayne Black, and
he was initially retained by RRA, meaning, I think
that they paid him.
Q Let's see if I can help you with this --
the chronology. The lawsuits that -- the first three
lawsuits that you filed against Mr. Epstein were
filed by Bradley Edwards & Associates
A Back in 2008.
Q -- in 2008.
A Right.
Q Before you joined RRA in 2009, you did not
use or pay for an investigator?
A I don't know if that's right or wrong. It's
right around that time where I was leaving one firm and
starting another that I was talking to Wayne Black. I
would have to look and see when his engagement letter
was to know did I talk to him and then he was hired by
RRA, or had I already hired him, you know let's say,
March, and then I went to RRA in April. It's right in
that time. I don't know.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Do you remember Bradley Edwards &
Associates ever paying an investigator related to the
Epstein matters?
A I don't remember one way or the other.
Q So if you did, it would have been at the
very tail end of the Bradley Edwards law firm?
A Correct.
Q And then once you started at RRA, there
were at least four different investigators that did
some amount of work on the Epstein cases?
A Including Wayne Black, who may have carried
over from my firm.
Q Right. When you look at Bradley Edwards &
Associates, as you sit here, you don't remember
whether you retained Wayne Black or not, right?
A Right. I can do it this way, which probably
helps you. Even if I retained him beforehand, I don't
think he did any work on the Epstein case until after I
was at RRA. That's how close in time that was.
So, yes, there were four people that were
investigators, at least, who did work on the Epstein
file during the period of time that I was at RRA.
Q And during that period of time, was about
six months, there were at least four investigators
that were assigned to work on the Epstein matter?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Not exclusively, but yes.
Q And you said at least four. Can you think
of anybody else that was assigned to work on the
Epstein matters at RRA?
A Well, no. And I'm even including Pat
Roberts, who I'm not sure was an employee there. I
think that Mike Fisten brought him in for additional
help.
Q Let's not --
A When you assign, it's not like I'm assigning
people or anybody is -- you know, I don't know that.
Q Let's go back and try and do this again. I
think we are both missing each other here.
A Okay.
Q It doesn't matter to me whether they were
employees of RRA or contracted for. What I'm really
trying to understand is, in the six months that you
were at RRA, the number of investigators that --
during that six-month period -- spent any amount of
time working on the Epstein matters. And you have
identified four for me so far. Right?
A Right. Here is where I think we are missing
each other. The four -- those were four investigators
that were working Epstein -related cases on behalf of
clients and Jane Doe. I'm sure -- although
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
I don't know -- that of the other 15, 16, 17 lawsuits
that were filed by Bob Josefsberg or Mr. Herman or
Mr. Scarola, there were probably also investigators
also working on Epstein cases. Just had nothing to do
with me.
Q I'm only asking about you, sir. I don't
care who Mr. Scarola --
A If you go back and read back the question,
that's not how it reads. It reads: Were these the four
people who were working on the Epstein investigation?
Q So let me try -- it was not supposed to be
a trick question at all.
When you started at RRA, you had three
pending lawsuits against Mr. Epstein.
A Right.
Q While you were at RRA you added a fourth
lawsuit against Mr. Epstein.
A Fourth client.
Q I said a fourth lawsuit.
A Which one?
Q You do not remember filing a lawsuit while
you were with Mr. Rothstein's firm?
A I filed many lawsuits against Mr. Epstein.
Q I'm talking about the six-month period of
time while --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A I represented three clients while I was at
Epstein (sic) for sure. While I was at RRA I
represented three different clients.
Q So while you were with Mr. Rothstein's you
represented three individual clients that had
lawsuits against Mr. Epstein?
A Right.
Q You also filed a fourth lawsuit while you
were employed by Mr. Rothstein against Mr. Epstein,
correct?
A On behalf of who already had a state
case against Mr. Rothstein (sic) . It wasn't a new
client.
Q I didn't ask about client. Lawsuit. So
you filed one lawsuit at RRA and three lawsuits
before joining RRA?
A Sure.
Q And for those four lawsuits that you -- and
you were the lead lawyer on those four suits.
A Yes.
Q And you were the lead lawyer at Brad
Edwards & Associates?
A Yes.
Q And you were the lead lawyer at Rothstein's
firm?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A That's your entire question? Was I the lead
lawyer at Rothstein's firm? No.
Q You were not the lead lawyer at Rothstein's
firm for the three individuals that you brought with
you that had lawsuits against Mr. Epstein.
A On those cases, I was the lead lawyer.
Q That's what we're talking about.
A You just asked the question, Were you the
lead lawyer at Rothstein's firm?
Q On the three cases -- okay. Fair enough.
A You just refuse to add that in. It's not
going to read back right on the record. We are both
lawyers here, we know what -- playing with words is not
what I want to do today.
Q If there's any part of what I'm doing that
makes you uncomfortable or if you think I'm playing
with words, just like that, just let me know and we
will fix it. How is that?
A I will.
Q So for the four pending lawsuits while you
were a six-month employee of Mr. Rothstein, there
were at least four investigators that spent some
amount of time investigating Mr. Epstein?
A Yes.
Q Are there possibly more than four
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
investigators during the six-month window for those
four lawsuits that were utilized to investigate

Mr. Epstein?
MR. SCAROLA: Objection to the extent
the question calls for speculation.
THE WITNESS: There's possibly more
investigators who investigated Mr. Epstein
on behalf of either-or Jane Doe.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Can you tell me who those investigators
were during the six-month period that you were
employed by Mr. Rothstein?
A I just told you the ones I recall. Is it
possible there could have been more? There could have
been.
Q Who was it on the -- let me back up for a
second. Was there a litigation team for the three
clients that went from Bradley Edwards, PA to

Mr. Rothstein's firm when you joined Rothstein's
firm? Was there a team put together for those three
clients?
I know you were the lead lawyer for those
clients at Rothstein's firm.

MR. SCAROLA: The question included the
phrase, When you joined the Rothstein firm.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
I'm trying to understand are you asking
whether at that time a team was assembled --
MR. LINK: Yes.
MR. SCAROLA: -- or whether at any time
subsequent to that time a team was
assembled.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Was there a team. When you went over there
with the three lawsuits, was there a team that worked
on those three matters.
A I did not take a team over to the Rothstein
firm.
Q And when got to the Rothstein firm, who was
assigned to help you with the three clients that were
suing Mr. Epstein?
A So the way that RRA was set up, there were
divisions. And there was a tort division there.
Q So were you assigned to the tort division?
A I was one of the tort lawyers who was there.
I primarily worked the cases. I also had other legal
minds within the law firm that would bounce ideas
around, cover hearings. The one that probably
participated the most on an active basis was Bill
Berger.
I don't remember when he joined the firm.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
I don't think he was there when I first got there,
but I could be wrong about that.
Actively involved in any of the -- Paul
Cassell, who was not even at that firm, was the
other person that I communicated with the most on
those cases about what was actually going on and
strategy and things like that.
Q I want to focus on for the six months you
were at Rothstein, okay. That's what I'm focused on.
For the three clients that had lawsuits pending
against Mr. Epstein, I'm just trying to have you tell
me which lawyers -- we are focused on lawyers for the
moment -- we've already covered investigators --
which lawyers worked with you, were part of your
team. You said Bill Berger.
A It's the work with you. Bill Berger did
things. He went to hearings and things like that.
Q Did you not consider that him working with
you?
A I did. He's in that category.
Q Who else?
A There were other people, like -- there was a
former FBI agent. I don't remember her last name, but
I think her name is Cara. She was a lawyer. And I
would communicate with her about different aspects of
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
the investigation. Did she work with me? I don't
think that she did anything. She could have attended a
deposition. If she did, I don't necessarily remember.
Q Let me pause for one second. Was she
working as an investigator or as a lawyer when you
would communicate with her?
A A lawyer.
Q Do you remember her last name?
A No.
Q Was it Holmes?
A Than doesn't help to jog my memory. Sorry.
Q Did she communicate with you about the
claims against Mr. Epstein?
A At times I believe she did.
Q Did you discuss with her how to maximize
the recovery against Mr. Epstein?
A That's not something I would communicate to
her. That could be something she might communicate to

me. But I don't know about that.
Q Tell me why she would do that. Why would
she communicate to you as the lead lawyer for these
A She may not. I mean, I'm just saying. I
don't do that, hey, talk to somebody who doesn't -- who
doesn't know as much as me about the case and say, How
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
do we maximize recovery. I would know that. That's
what my job was.
Q So you wouldn't need Cara to tell you how
you should or how you could maximize recovery against

Mr. Epstein?
A I didn't need anybody to tell me how to do
anything. But at that firm, there were a lot of
lawyers with a lot of experience, and taking
information from them that's helpful on any case -- as
it still is today how I practice how you probably
practice -- it's no different.
Q So other than Mr. Berger and Cara --
somebody with a last name was there anyone else
that was part of the team?

MR. SCAROLA: At RRA or working
together with --
MR. LINK: Yes.
MR. SCAROLA: Just at RRA?
MR. LINK: Just at RRA. Same topic we
have been on.
THE WITNESS: The team is me and any
lawyer who wants -- any lawyer there who
knows about the case who wants to tell me
anything about their own opinions about the
case.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I guess let's try it a different way. Who
drafted the papers that would get filed on behalf of
the three clients while you were at RRA?
A Ninety-eight percent of them would be me or
Paul Cassell, if not 100 percent. I can't remember
anybody else drafting anything, but I could be wrong.
Q So if I look at papers that were filed
during the period of time that you were with RRA in
the three lawsuits against Mr. Epstein, 98 percent of
those documents were probably drafted by you and/or

Mr. Cassell, or the two of you together?
A Yes. And probably more by Mr. Cassell doing
the drafting than me. But yes. I mean, that's --
Q So if you wanted to hire a -- let me try
that again.
If you wanted to assign an investigator at
RRA work to do on the Epstein matter, how would you
do that? Who would you talk to? Was there a
process involved?
A I don't know what the initial process was. I
don't remember that. But once I was introduced to Mike
Fisten, I would just talk to Mike. I mean, that's who
I talked to. Mike, this is what I think that we need
to do next. Mike would say, Okay, let's get it done,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
or think about this.
Q So any of the decisions that were made
during the six months that you were at Rothstein were
made, from a strategic standpoint, by you as the lead
lawyer?
A Yes. By me or by Paul Cassell. I mean, I
think there was a time where we had pretty equal say in
what we were doing next.
Q Mr. Cassell was not an employee of
Rothstein?
A Right.
Q You were the sole employee of Rothstein's
firm that made decisions -- strategic decisions for
the three clients?
A Yes.
Q Did you make the strategic decision to file
the fourth lawsuit in federal court?
A It wasn't my idea initially, but I quickly
agreed with the idea. That was Paul's idea, and he was
right on it, so I didn't -- I didn't come up with the
idea, but I should have.
Q It was Mr. Cassell's idea to file the
federal court complaint for Plaintiffillill?
A Right.
Q Were there -- did you consider filing
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
federal court complaints for the other two plaintiffs
that you represented?
A Well --

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Let me
interrupt here for just a moment.
Obviously, what Mr. Edwards considered,
his mental processes, are clearly attorney
work product. I am more than happy to have
him answer that question, but I don't want
him to answer that question if the argument
is going to be made that, by responding to
this particular question, he has broadly
waived work-product privilege.
If we can agree that the answer to this
question will not constitute a waiver of
attorney work-product privilege, generally I
don't have a problem with his responding to
it.

MR. LINK: I will agree with that.
MR. SCAROLA: And for shorthand
purposes, there may be other questions that
fall into the same category, and I will just
say, can we have the same agreement as to no
waiver, and you will know what I'm talking
about, okay?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

MR. LINK: You're giving me more credit
than I'm due, but I think I will figure it
out.
THE WITNESS: So, I believe your
question was did we consider filing federal
lawsuits for the other clients, that
being -- other than
BY MR. LINK:
Q Yeah. While you were employed at RRA.
A Got it.
So Jane Doe, we filed in federal court
already. So her case was already in federal court.
However, there was a time, during this
same time, that we weren't -- we weren't completely
satisfied with the way we had pled it, so -- and for
the same reason that I'm going to tell you as to why
we filedilill But there wasn't the need to file on
the other cases that we saw coming up
case.
I'm trying to figure out the best way to
say this without invading the attorney -client
privilege. Let's -- let me back up and explain it
this way.
The non-prosecution agreement
Q Let me just stop you, because I think I
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
asked you a really simple question. I thought my
simple question was did you consider doing it? And
you haven't told me yes you did or no you haven't.
And Mr. Scarola made an objection. I don't want you
to just give a speech, and I don't think Mr. Scarola
does.
A In general terms, we thought about it being
the best idea in general.
Q Did you draft, in fact, while you were at

Mr. Rothstein's firm, a federal complaint for the
other state court plaintiffs?
A We either did or we conceptually agreed that
we were going to. We agreed that we should.
Q Okay. While you were at Mr. Rothstein's
firm, you and Mr. Cassell agreed that you would file
a second complaint on behalf of one of your clients
that was in state court, and that complaint would be
filed in federal court, just like the complaint
was?

MR. SCAROLA: Same agreement.
MR. LINK: Same agreement.
THE WITNESS: I believe so. We may
have actually drafted it.
BY MR. LINK:
Q And that complaint was not filed, true?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Which complaint?
Q The one that we just talked about.
A
Q Yes. So the complaint was drafted
A We didn't file a separate
Q So what you and Mr. Cassell decided
while you were at Rothstein you would do was never
filed, right?
A We never filed a separate complaint for
in federal court.
Q And once you left Mr. Rothstein's firm, you
didn't file a federal case on behalf of , right?
A I did not.
Q And you did not serve Mr. Epstein after you
left the Rothstein firm with the lawsuit, did
you?
A I have come to know from hearing over the
years that it was never served, but I don't recollect
whether it was served or not. I do remember at some
point in time saying we should serve this. I don't
remember it never being served or it being served. I
know that it was dismissed at the same time as the
other cases were settled.
Q Let me ask it this way. Do you know --

MR. GOLDBERGER: Excuse me, Scott. The
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
videographer says he has five minutes.
THE WITNESS: We have five minutes.

MR. LINK: Yeah. I think I can finish
this up.
BY MR. LINK:
Q The . federal lawsuit -- like the
lawsuit -- was, in fact, drafted while you were with
Rothstein's firm.
A We just went there through this. I don't
remember whether it was drafted. I remember believing
it should be drafted.
Q And making the decision with Mr. Cassell to
do that?

MR. LINK: No waiver.
MR. SCAROLA: Thank you. We could do
this. Just give me a continuing agreement
that there's no waiver, and I will let him
continue to answer questions about this
federal lawsuit.

MR. LINK: Agreed.
THE WITNESS: Sorry. State that
question again.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I just want to --
A We were talking about
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q I want to tie it together, all right?
So a decision was made on behalf of
by you and Mr. Cassell while you were an employee at
RRA to bring a separate federal court action against

Mr. Epstein.
A And we did.
Q And you did.
Also while you were at RRA, you and
Mr. Cassell made the decision that you would file a
lawsuit in federal court for—, just like you had
done for
A Correct.
Q After leaving the Rothstein firm, you never
filed the federal lawsuit for
A Correct.
Q And after leaving the Rothstein firm, you
never served Mr. Epstein with the federal case?
A You're telling me that?
Q Yes.

MR. SCAROLA: I object to Counsel
testifying.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Do you remember that being the case? You
do not?
A I don't remember it not being filed, but I
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
have heard that --

MR. SCAROLA: Served.
THE WITNESS: Served -- but I have
heard that enough to believe it to be true
that it wasn't served on him.

MR. LINK: Good place to take a break.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
11:49 a.m. This concludes tape one. We are
going off the record.
(A recess was had.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
12:05 p.m. This is the beginning of tape
two. We are back on the record.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Edwards, do you now have in front of
you Plaintiff's Exhibit 1 --
A Yes.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 1 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q -- which is the affidavit of Mr. Epstein?
Have you seen this before?
A I saw it when it was originally filed.
Q Would you please --

MR. SCAROLA: For the record, we have
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
moved to strike this affidavit. We believe
it to be inadmissible. It is violative of
the sword -shield doctrine, and we object to
its use.
BY MR. LINK:
Q You may look at the entire affidavit if you
want, but I'm going to focus you on paragraph six at
least to start with. Just take a moment to read
paragraph six.
A Okay, I read it.
Q Looking at the first sentence, do you have
any reason to believe that that first sentence is not
true?

MR. SCAROLA: I'm going to object.
There are a wide variety of separate factual
assertions contained within that first
sentence, and therefore, the question is
compound.
THE WITNESS: This is -- purports to be
statements made by Jeffrey Epstein, which is
pretty interesting, given that he invokes
his Fifth Amendment right against
self-incrimination every time I've ever
asked him anything that was on the record.
So his statement in early November 2009 --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
this is his statement about what stories
were in the press at the time.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I'm asking you if this factual assertion in
the first sentence is -- do you agree it's a true
statement or not?

MR. SCAROLA: And my objection is,
there is not a factual assertion, but a
multiplicity of allegations included in that
first sentence, so the question is compound.
THE WITNESS: Let me just read it out
loud then I will try to answer your
question.
"In early November 2009, stories in the
press, on the news, and on the Internet were
legion about the implosion of RRA."
BY MR. LINK:
Q Let's just break it down statement by
statement. Is that a true statement?
MR. SCAROLA: I am going to object to
that question on the basis that it is vague
and ambiguous, particularly with regard to
what legion means.
THE WITNESS: There were stories in the
news about the implosion of RRA. That's
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
true.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Multiple stories?
A Yeah. That's what the news cycle was about
in Broward County at the time, was the implosion of
RRA.
Q Not just Broward, it was statewide news?
A It was statewide news.
Q It was national news?
A The RRA implosion was --
Q Yes, sir.
A -- was widespread news. I don't know --
yeah, I think it was national news. Certainly where we
lived everybody knew about it.
Q No question that in early November 2009 the
press and the news was extensive relating to the
implosion of the Rothstein firm?
A Absolutely.
Q And that press included information about
the Ponzi scheme that was perpetrated at Rothstein,
true?
A I believe so. I mean, I don't know about
November 2009, but at some point in time after --
pretty soon after it was -- there was news about it
being a Ponzi scheme that Rothstein was running a
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Ponzi scheme. It could have been December. It could
have been January. I don't know. Right after.
Q Let's take a look at some of the November
articles.
A Okay.
Q Let me show you what's marked Plaintiff's
Exhibit 2. Are you familiar with the Legal Junkies?
A No.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 2 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q You see this is dated November 2nd, 2009?
Upper left-hand corner.
A Yes.
Q Wall Street Journal Law Blog, do you see
that?
A Point me where.
Q Upper left-hand corner.
A Yes.
Q Do you see that on November 2nd, that there
was this article about the Rothstein law firm?
A There was an article about the Rothstein law
firm, yes.
Q Including the investment scheme and the
structured settlements.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Let me read it and I will tell you what I
think it's about. Do you want me to read the
updated --
Q No. I just want to make sure -- this is
November 2nd. The statement we looked at was in
early November 2009. And I'm showing you some of the
articles to confirm that this statement in this
affidavit that we are focused on, this one aspect of
it, was true.

MR. SCAROLA: For purposes of this line
of questioning, since there has been no
predicate laid with this witness as to the
authenticity of this document, we will
accept your representation that it is
authentic. But we don't know that
independently. So we are making that
assumption for purposes of allowing this
further line of questioning.
THE WITNESS: And consistent with any
answer, this is an article that confirms
what I said, which is, there was news about
the implosion of RRA.
At this point in time -- you have given
me an article from 11/2/09 -- there's
nothing that identifies whatever Scott
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Rothstein was alleged to have done as a
Ponzi scheme at this time.
BY MR. LINK:
Q In this one article?
A In this one I don't see it yet. I'm not
saying it didn't happen. It could have. But what
you're showing me doesn't say that.
Q We're going to get there. We're going to
take a look at these. So this one comes out
November 2nd. And I see that your name is on the
second page. Bradley J. Edwards as a lawyer at
Rothstein, Rosenfeldt & Adler. You see that?

MR. SCAROLA: Help me.
MR. LINK: About maybe 10 down from the
column.
THE WITNESS: It's on the fourth page.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Fourth page, there's a list of --
A Yeah, I was a lawyer at RRA, so yes it
lists looks like it lists every lawyer at RRA.
There's a list that goes on for two pages, so yes.
Q So in this article --
A My name is there.
Q -- your name is there.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
MR. LINK: Yes sir.
MR. SCAROLA: You are referencing that
as being part of this article. It, in fact,
appears to be a blog-posted comment to the
article, as opposed to part of the article
itself.

MR. LINK: I will take that
representation.
MR. SCAROLA: Somebody in response to
the article posted a list of the lawyers in
the firm. Fair?

MR. LINK: Fair. Fair enough.
BY MR. LINK:
Q This is the first time -- Mr. Edwards --
MR. SCAROLA: Can we also agree that
whoever posted this isn't even identified?

MR. LINK: We can agree it is what it
is. Whatever it says, it says.
THE WITNESS: It says unregistered
guest.

MR. SCAROLA: Unregistered guest.
Whoever that is.
MR. LINK: Whoever that is. Okay.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Edwards, I'm not sure I got an answer.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
And if I did, I apologize. I didn't meant to ask it
again. But in looking at Plaintiff's Exhibit 2, is
this the first time that you have -- that you knew
that your name was listed by somebody related to that
article?
A I don't know. I don't know one way or the
other.
Q Now, let's take a look at Exhibit 3.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 3 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q This is a November 6 article. And the
headline is "Scott Rothstein: The Jeffrey Epstein
and Bill Clinton ploy." Do you see that?
A Yes.
Q Did you see this article when it came out
November 6, 2009?
A I don't remember. Like you said, there were
a lot of articles. I don't know which ones I saw,
which ones I didn't.
Q Do you see that on the second page it talks
about the Ponzi imploding? In the upper top, page
two.
A Yeah, I know. It's the end of a sentence. I
am just reading the beginning. Yes.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q So by November 6, at least, this article is
mentioning the word Ponzi.
A Somebody is calling it a Ponzi by then
Q So do you now agree with me that there were
stories in the press in early November 2009
discussing the Ponzi scheme perpetrated at RRA?
A I agree

MR. SCAROLA: Again, assuming the
authenticity of this online printout, I will
agree that this online printout says what it
says and makes reference to the Ponzi scheme
imploding.
THE WITNESS: I will agree to the same
thing.
BY MR. LINK:
Q The reason I'm showing you this article is
because when I asked you if that part of the sentence
of paragraph six was accurate, you said, I don't
remember whether the word Ponzi was used in the
articles in November or whether it was December.
A Exactly.
Q So I am showing these to you now to confirm
that, in fact, in early November the Ponzi scheme was
being discussed in the press.
A I will agree that it appears that the New
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Times used the word Ponzi on November 6th of 2009. I
don't think that we are disputing at all that this was
a Ponzi scheme. Everybody knows what it was, so --
Q It's not whether -- I'm not disputing with
you whether it was. We know that it was. I'm asking
you whether the statements in this affidavit -- the
factual statements so far -- we are on paragraph six
only -- were accurate.
So the statement that I was focused on was
that in early November 2009, that the Ponzi scheme
perpetrated at the firm, meaning RRA, was in the
press and on the news. You agree that it was?
A I agree that this article on November 6 of
2009 said the word Ponzi. It could have very well been
in a bunch of articles by then. It could have very
well been on the news. I'm not disputing it being
there. I just don't remember the timing of when
everybody decided what it was.
Q And you see on page two, that's a picture
of Mr. Epstein, right?
A Yes.
Q And underneath his picture it says,
"Epstein was bait." You see that?
A I do see that.
Q Was Mr. Epstein used as bait by the RRA
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
firm to attract potential investors?
A I don't see that sentence.
Q I'm asking you.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I'm going to
object, unless a predicate is laid with
regard to Mr. Edwards' personal knowledge.

MR. LINK: He has or he doesn't. He
can answer the question.
THE WITNESS: Are you referring to a
specific sentence in this article?
BY MR. LINK:
Q Do you see the words under his picture?
A Yes. It says, "Epstein was used as bait."
Q Read the sentence. It says, "One way he
did it --" talking about Mr. Rothstein -- "was by
tricking investors into believing that his firm was
representing numerous underaged girls who had sex
with Palm Beach billionaire and convicted child
sex-offender Jeffrey Epstein, sources have
confirmed."
A I see that sentence, too.
Q And I asked you whether Mr. Epstein was
used as bait to attract potential investors.

MR. SCAROLA: And I have objected,
unless a predicate is laid with regard to
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

Mr. Edwards' personal knowledge.
THE WITNESS: I would have no way of
knowing that.
BY MR. LINK:
Q And do you see the next sentence says
this is November 6 -- "On top of that, Rothstein
claimed that he had flight logs showing that Epstein
flew extremely prominent people, including former
President Bill Clinton, on his private jet with some
of the plaintiffs."
A I see that sentence.
Q The person who obtained the flight logs
from Mr. Epstein for his airplanes during the RRA
period of representing the three investors (sic) was
you, correct?
A I was one of numerous attorneys who took
pilot depositions. And as a consequence of a subpoena
duces tecum, the pilot brought the flight logs to the
deposition. So I was one of several lawyers who had
access to flight logs as a result of that deposition
that we took in the legitimate cases where we
represented and Jane Doe, who were actual
underaged victims of Jeffrey Epstein's child
molestation. That's what happened.
Q Did any of those three folks that you
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
represented tell you that they had sex on

Mr. Epstein's plane?
MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I'm going to
object. That clearly calls for
attorney -client privileged information.
BY MR. LINK:
Q And when they were asked that question
during their depositions in the underlying cases, did
any of them testify that they were on Mr. Epstein
planes and had sex on them?
A When they were asked what they told me?
Q No. During their depositions -- not what
they told you. When they were asked during their
depositions. I am getting away from the
attorney -client. It was a good objection.
During their depositions they were asked
whether they were on Mr. Epstein's plane and had sex
with him. Did any of the three folks that the
Rothstein firm represented say they were, in fact,
on the plane and had sex with Mr. Epstein on his
plane?
A They were asked that question?
Q Do you know whether they were, sir?
A No, I don't remember whether they were. They
were asked a lot of questions.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q So if you don't remember, you don't
remember.
A I don't remember.
Q Do you know who the sources are that have
confirmed that the Rothstein firm used Epstein as
bait?
A No.
Q You said there were several lawyers -- and
let me make sure I understand that. I am talking
about the lawyers at the Rothstein firm. I thought
you told me that you were the lead lawyer for the
three clients with claims against Mr. Epstein during
the six months that you were employed at the
Rothstein firm.
A I did tell you that.
Q And you, in fact, were the lawyer for the
Rothstein firm that took the depositions of the
pilots, true?
A Right.
Q And so you would have been the lawyer at
the Rothstein firm that had received the flight logs
from the pilots, true?
A All right. Here is what I'm trying to tell
you is -- so, Bob Josefsberg was prosecuting cases
against Jeffrey Epstein on behalf of --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Let me stop you.

MR. SCAROLA: No. I'm sorry.
MR. LINK: I don't want to
interrupt him if he's
Jack, he's answering my question.
THE WITNESS: I am.

MR. SCAROLA: Well, that's fine. You
can move to strike the response, but you
can't interrupt him.
MR. LINK: Actually, I can.

MR. SCAROLA: No, you cannot.
MR. LINK: My question was really
simple.
MR. SCAROLA: Well, whether it's simple
or not, he's going to answer the question
and complete his response. If you find it
to be unresponsive, you can move to strike.
But he's permitted to complete his answer.

MR. LINK: He's actually not. He's not
permitted to answer a question I haven't
asked. And you know that.

MR. SCAROLA: Continue, if you would
with your response.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Edwards, answer question, please.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A I am answering question.
Q You are?
A Yes.
Q So my question was really simple.

MR. SCAROLA: No, I'm sorry. You are
not going to ask another question until
Mr. Edwards has had a chance to respond to
the question that you already asked when you
interrupted him in the middle of his answer.
You may not like the answer. You may
think it's unresponsive. You can move to
strike it. But he gets to finish it. So
continue if you would, please.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So before you continue it --

MR. SCAROLA: No, not before he
continues --
BY MR. LINK:
Q You are going to answer my question?
That's what you were going to do?
A Yes, I'm going to answer your question.
Q Then answer my question.
A So, Bob Josefsberg represented a volume of
girls, who, when they were underaged, were molested by
Jeffrey Epstein. Adam Horowitz represented six or
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
seven girls who were victims of Jeffrey Epstein's
molestation. I represented three girls who were
victims of Jeffrey Epstein's molestation.

Mr. Scarola's firm represented females who were victims
of Jeffrey Epstein's molestation, and so did Sid
Garcia, and so did Spencer Kuvin.
There were so many girls that Jeffrey
Epstein molested while they were underaged that
there were many lawyers involved.
When we took depositions of anyone, all of
the plaintiffs' lawyers would decide together whose
deposition we were taking, what the objective was,
and what evidence that we could obtain from them.
With respect to the pilots, the subpoena
duces tecum required for the pilot to bring the
flight logs. The flight logs were produced at the
deposition, and produced so that all of the
plaintiffs' lawyers would have them.
So to say that I'm the one who got them
from the pilot, maybe I was. Maybe it was Jack,
maybe it was Bob. But they were copied. And I had
access to them for sure. Bob had access to them for
sure. All of the plaintiffs' lawyers did at the
same time. It wasn't me out on some vigilante
mission that got these flight logs.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
That's the only clarification that I'm
trying to make for you. I think that we are not
necessarily on a different page with what you want.
Q And you think that answer is responsive to
my question?
A Yes. Was I the person who got the flight
logs? That's your question.
Q No. I said were you the lawyer at the
Rothstein firm -- only asked you about the Rothstein
firm. I don't care about Mr. Scarola. He wasn't
even at the deposition. I don't care about

Mr. Josefsberg, unless you are telling me he gave the
flight logs to somebody at the Rothstein firm, and
then I will ask Bob if that's true.
A It wouldn't be to me.
Q That's was my question. Was there somebody
other than you that would have had possession of
bringing those flight logs back to the Rothstein firm
while you were an employee?
A From wherever I got it from, right. No.
Q Just you, right?
A Yes.
Q Okay. That was my question.
And --
A Apparently I didn't understand it. Sorry.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q I tried to ask it again, but Mr. Scarola
insisted that you give me your speech, and that's
okay.

MR. SCAROLA: Objection. Move to
strike. Argumentive.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Did the flight logs that you took back to
the Rothstein firm have information about Bill
Clinton, for example, being on the plane?
A The flight logs did indicate that Bill
Clinton was one of the passengers with Jeffrey Epstein
and his co-conspirators on his airplane, yes.
Q Do you know whether Mr. Scarola or

Mr. Josefsberg or any of the other lawyers that you
mentioned when you were discussing the flight logs
would have provided that information to

Mr. Rothstein?
A I wouldn't think that anyone provided that
information to Mr. Rothstein.
Q I'm asking about the lawyer you mentioned.
Mr. Scarola, your lawyer here, who you represented
A I don't think so.
Q You don't think he gave it to

Mr. Rothstein, do you?
A No.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q You don't think Mr. Josefsberg did, do you?
A No.
Q You don't think Mr. Kuvin did, do you?
A No.
Q You don't think Ted Leopold did, do you?
A No. I don't believe anyone did.
Q Let's take a look at this next one.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 4 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q Are you on any medication today for your
anxiety?
A No.
Q Have you ever been on medication for
anxiety --
A No.
Q Let me just finish.
Have you ever been on medication for
anxiety since December 2009?
A No.
Q This is an article dated November 12. This
is an article in the Sun Sentinel. "FBI doubts
Rothstein ran a Ponzi scheme alone." Do you see
that --
A Yes.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q -- is the headline. Take a minute and take
a look at it.
A Yep.
Q Do you know Mr. John I'm probably saying
this wrong -- John Gillies
A No.
Q -- the head of the FBI in South Florida?
When he said, "I do not believe that this was a
one-man show." You see that statement?
A I do.
Q You see that Mr. Rosenfeldt, at the bottom,
said that he had no clue about what was going on?
A I see a statement in this article that says,
Rothstein's partner, Stuart Rosenfeldt, has said he
had, quote, no clue, end quote, about the alleged
fraud.
Q Was that Mr. Rosenfeldt's position during
the last few days of the Rothstein firm while you
were employed there?
A I don't know that I gathered his position
about anything.
Q You're aware that he filed, on behalf of
the law firm, a preemptive lawsuit to appoint a
receiver. You knew that?
A I do remember it was filed. Those kind of
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
details aren't totally fresh in my mind. I don't know
that he filed it as opposed to somebody. I don't know.
Q Wasn't it a big deal when you learned out
that the firm you were working for had committed a
massive 1.some-billion-dollar Ponzi scheme?
MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I'm going to
object to that question. It assumes facts
not in evidence, and that is that the firm
committed a Ponzi scheme.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Go ahead?
A This was big news to everybody, yes.
Q How did you find out?
A I remember going to a meeting on -- I believe
it was a Monday -- like down in, like, a
cafeteria -style -- the bottom floor of the building
that the firm was located in. I don't remember exactly
what was told to us, but somebody came in and said
Rothstein's in Morocco, trust funds are missing, the
firm's closing down. I don't think I stayed for much
more than that.
Q It was a pretty horrific day, I would
guess.
A Yeah, it was a bad day.
Q Is there any doubt in your mind that in
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
early November 2009, that the press and the news
covered the implosion of RRA --
A No.
Q -- and covered the Ponzi scheme perpetrated
at that firm? Right?
A No. There's no doubt.
Q And so this first sentence is a true,
factual sentence from paragraph six
A What exhibit are we on?
Q We are on Exhibit Number 1, which would be
affidavit -- the sworn statement by Mr. Epstein.
A Okay, first sentence.
Q Is there anything that you would say is
inaccurate or untrue about the first sentence of
paragraph six?
A "In early November 2009, stories in the
press, on the news, and on the Internet were legion
about the implosion or RRA, the Ponzi scheme
perpetrated at that firm, and the misuse in the Ponzi
Scheme of certain civil cases then being litigated
against me by RRA partner, Edwards."
To the extent that it's saying that the
press was -- the press was -- that I was involved in
the Ponzi scheme, that's not true.
Q Does this sentence say you were involved in
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
the Ponzi scheme, sir?
A Well, it says, "The Ponzi scheme perpetrated
at the firm, and the misuse in the Ponzi scheme of
certain civil cases then being litigated against me by
RRA partner, Edwards." It's trying to imply that.
Q Okay. But does it say that?
A It implies that. It's not perfectly written.
Q Were Mr. Epstein's files being used as part
of the Ponzi scheme?
A You showed me an article that says that --
Q They were?
A Yeah. "One way he did it was by tricking
investors into believing that his firm as representing
numerous underaged girls who had sex with Palm Beach
billionaire and convicted sex offender Jeffrey
Epstein."
That doesn't say that the cases against
Epstein -- it doesn't say anything about the
legitimate cases against Epstein.
Q I didn't say it did, did I?
All I'm asking you is, isn't it a fact
isn't it a true fact that these articles say that
Scott Rothstein used the Epstein litigation in order
to attempt to entice investors to make the
investment?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
13.7

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me.
THE WITNESS: So far you haven't shown
me that.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Then let's go back and take a look at
Exhibit Number 3 that we walked through and has

Mr. Epstein's picture that says Epstein was bait.
A Right.
Q You see that?
A Yes.
Q So I want you to read that -- this article,
and tell me if you agree that this article -- whether
it was true or not -- that this article suggests that
the cases that you were handling as the lead
lawyer --
A Right.
Q were being used by Rothstein as bait in
order to lure investors.
A Is there a part of the article that you want
to point me to, or do you want me to read this whole
article?

MR. SCAROLA: Can we agree Mr. Edwards'
name appears nowhere in this article?
MR. LINK: What does that have to do
with anything, Jack?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

MR. SCAROLA: You just asked him
whether the article says that the cases that
he was prosecuting were being used as bait.

MR. LINK: Sure.
MR. SCAROLA: Mr. Edwards' name is not
referenced. There's no --
MR. LINK: I never said that it was,
Jack.

MR. SCAROLA: There's no reference in
this article to the cases that Brad was
prosecuting.
MR. LINK: I never said it was. Is
that an objection to the form? What is it?

MR. SCAROLA: That's exactly what it
is. You are --
MR. LINK: Then say, objection to the
form.
MR. SCAROLA: You are misrepresenting
what the article says. It says what it
says. It doesn't identify the cases that
Brad was prosecuting.

MR. LINK: You didn't hear my question.
Listen, I have let you give a lot of
speeches today, and they have been very
informative and I have enjoyed them. But if
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
you have an objection, please just make it
to form now.

MR. SCAROLA: That's fine.
MR. LINK: Thank you.
THE WITNESS: Let me just read the
article now.
MR. SCAROLA: And while Brad is reading
the article, could we have the question read
back please.
(Thereupon, the requested portion of the
record was read back by the reporter as
above duly recorded. )

MR. SCAROLA: Do we agree that what you
were asking was whether Brad's cases were
being used to lure investors?

MR. LINK: That's what I said.
MR. SCAROLA: That's right. That's
what I've objected to, because Brad's not
referenced anywhere in the article. It
doesn't say that.
MR. LINK: I never said he was. Let's
not argue about it. The question is what it

is. You got your objection. It's one of my
better questions of the day.
THE WITNESS: So what this article says
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Edwards, do you remember the question?
A You can ask it again.
Q So let me give you the question to help
maybe clarify Mr. Scarola's comments. Were there any
other lawyers at the Rothstein firm while you were
there that represented any other plaintiffs, other
than the three that we have been talking about, in
lawsuits against Mr. Epstein?
A Well, and Jane Doe were the only
case at RRA.
Q So the only cases at RRA were the cases
that you were the lead lawyer for, correct?
A The only legitimate cases against Jeffrey
Epstein where the clients were actually molested by
Jeffrey Epstein, I was the lead lawyer on. That's what
this article is talking about, but yes.
Q I just wanted to clarify, because I asked
if the cases that you were the lead lawyer on, those
three are the cases that this article is discussing
that Mr. Rothstein was using?
A I doesn't appear to be. What this article
appears to be saying is that -- and this is from Bill
Scherer -- saying he used Epstein cases as showpiece as
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
bait. He would use legitimate cases as bait for luring
investors into fictional cases, which -- it then talks
about -- there were legitimate cases, such as
which were being handled -- it says here by RRA lawyer
Bill Berger -- William Berger. Sources say they
believe Berger wasn't involved in the scam.
So the article is saying what Rothstein
was doing is taking cases that were legitimate and
being legitimately prosecuted by his firm, and
making up a fictionalized version of it over here to
sell to investors, not using -- not selling these
cases or anything like that. That's not what this
article says.
Q So when you read this article and the other
articles I have shown you, is it your position that

Mr. Rothstein was not using the Epstein files in
order to entice investors to participate in the Ponzi
scheme?

MR. SCAROLA: Sorry. That question
confuses me, because your predicate was when
you read these articles --

MR. LINK: This is your objection to
form? Is this your objection to form?
MR. SCAROLA: It is objection to form.

MR. LINK: Then just make an objection
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
to form, Jack.
MR. SCAROLA: I'm trying to understand
what the question means.

MR. LINK: It doesn't matter to me if
you understand it.
MR. SCAROLA: Are you asking him what
the article says, or are you asking him what
his personal belief is?

MR. LINK: I don't know, but that's
great coaching. How about we go back to
object to the form.
MR. SCAROLA: Okay. Object to the
form.

MR. LINK: Fair enough.
MR. SCAROLA: Yes.
THE WITNESS: You were actually asking
me what my interpretation of the article is.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I did. That was before, and then I asked
you another question.
A Okay.
Q And my question was, as a matter of fact --
forget what this article says -- as a matter of fact,
do you now know that Mr. Rothstein used the cases
that you were in charge of -- I'm not saying he did
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
inflate them, he didn't manipulate them, he didn't do
other things -- but the cases you were in charge of
against Mr. Epstein were used by Mr. Rothstein to
attempt to perpetuate his Ponzi scheme? Is that a
true statement?

MR. SCAROLA: Objection. No proper
predicate.
THE WITNESS: What I believe, based on
things that I have read after the fact, is
that Rothstein used the details of the
legitimate cases against Jeffrey Epstein to
lure investors into purchasing some
fictitious cases that never existed, that
may have -- where he may have said Epstein
was somehow involved, but he wasn't
involved. That's what I believe to be true
now.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Are you aware, sir, of the press articles
and the Razorback lawsuit that alleges that the real
Epstein files that were at the Rothstein firm were
put in a room for investors to look at?

MR. SCAROLA: Objection, compound.
THE WITNESS: I'm aware of the
Razorback lawsuit. I'm aware of -- the same
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
articles that you're aware of --
BY MR. LINK:
Q You're aware of?
A I'm aware of.
Q And Mr. Epstein was aware of at the time?
A How would I know? I don't know what he was
aware of.
Q Do you think he was probably aware of the
one with his picture that says, "Epstein was bait"?
A No idea. Regardless, it has nothing to do
with him. He's not suffered any damage by -- no matter
what type of spin of this whole thing that you try to
create, there's no damage to Mr. Epstein that Rothstein
was telling a random story about him about fake cases.
Q Okay.
A It doesn't make the legitimate cases
fabricated. That's absurd.
Q So is there someplace in what we're looking
at, Exhibit 1 here, this affidavit, where Mr. Epstein
ever says that the three individual clients that you
represented and the cases that they filed in court
were somehow not legitimately filed?

MR. SCAROLA: Are you asking whether
that appears in the affidavit?
MR. LINK: Yeah.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I'm not sure -- you've given me that
speech. Is there anything in here?
A Sure. I mean, his complaint against me, that
I committed RICO and fraud and perjury and all of these
other crimes that he accused me of, is all about this
allegation that I fabricated the cases on behalf of
basically fictitious victims against him. And he
elaborated on that in his deposition and said that I
ginned up the cases. I mean, yeah, that's what his
complaint is about, the fabricated cases.
Q I'm asking. Is that what Mr. Rothstein
did? Did Mr. Rothstein do everything that you just
described to me?
A I don't know. I know what you know.
Q Based on what you read. Based on what you
have read, did Rothstein make up stories about
Epstein --
A Yes.
Q -- in order to lure investors?
A It appears that way from exactly what you're
looking at. Rothstein made up Epstein stories and
whatever stories about whoever else in the world to try
to run a Ponzi scheme.
Q Agreed.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A We agree.
Q So take a look at paragraph seven. You see
it says, "In November 2009, Mr. Epstein became aware
of news stories that, as a result of the Ponzi scheme
at RRA, the Florida Bar had commenced investigations
into over one half of the attorneys employed by RRA."
Did the Florida Bar commence
investigations into over one half of the attorneys
employed by RRA?
A I don't know.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I object to
the predicate of the question, not to the
question.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Did you see news stories back in
November 2009 that made that statement?
A I don't think so. I'm not saying they don't
exist. I just didn't see them. I wasn't watching all
of RRA news stories about the implosion. I was more
worried with starting a new firm and dealing with the
lawsuit that was filed against me and that fallout.
Q I understand. Let me ask you this. Do you
have any information that would make you think or
any evidence that you could present that would show
that the statement in paragraph seven was untrue at
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
the time that it was made?
A So he -- he is making this statement on
June 30th, 2017, this year, about --
Q News stories that existed in 2009. I'm
asking you
A That's not what this is about. It's about --
you're talking paragraph seven.
Q Yes.
A Which says, "I also became aware --"
Q You missed the first three words.
A In November of 2009.
Q Right.
A News stories about the Florida Bar
investigation?
Q Right. And I'm asking you, do you have any
evidence that, in November 2009, there were not news
stories that the Florida Bar had commenced
investigations into over one half of the attorneys
employed at RRA?
A I don't have evidence one way or the other,
whether there were news stories, whether there weren't,
or Jeffrey Epstein knew about them or he didn't, or he
became aware or he didn't. I don't know any of those
things.
Q So let me try it again. Are you aware of
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
any evidence that would prove that there were no news
stories in November 2009 that the Florida Bar has
commenced investigations into over one half of the
attorneys employed by RRA?

MR. SCAROLA: Didn't Mr. Edwards just
tell you he doesn't know one way or another?
THE WITNESS: I have no idea.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So if I asked are you aware of any
evidence, instead of just saying no, you want to tell
me you have no idea, yes, no, maybe.
A Am I aware of evidence? You might have it
right in front of you right now.
Q I might. I'm asking you if you're aware.
A I don't see this in front of me right now.
So I am not aware of the evidence one way or the other,
whether the Florida Bar opened up an investigation into
over one half of the lawyers or that there were news
stories in November of 2009 that says that.
All I have now right about the 2009 --
November 2009 are the things that you have given me.
And none of them say that, at least from what I have
read. But I'm not saying it doesn't exist.
Q It's okay. Let's do this then. Let's go
ahead and mark -- when we take a break here to eat,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
we will go ahead and mark all of these news articles
from November 2009 -- and you are welcomed to go
through them to see if you find any evidence that
supports a position that what Mr. Epstein is saying
in this affidavit is untrue in any way. Okay?
A What does it matter whether I know this or
not? Either it is supported or it's not supported.
And good. If it's supported, great. It's still
irrelevant. And if it's not supported, okay, too.
What does it matter what I know about

Mr. Epstein's mental state about Florida Bar
inquiries?
Q I'm not asking about mental state at all.
I haven't asked that question one time, sir.
A He said, "when I became aware."
Q I didn't ask you whether he's aware.
That's not been my question.

MR. SCAROLA: But you've repeatedly
asked whether the statement in paragraph
seven is true. And the statement in
paragraph seven is an assertion of what

Mr. Epstein became aware of, what his state
of mind was, whether he knew --
MR. LINK: Is this form again? Jack, I
remember exactly what I asked, so please,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
just limit it to form, if you would.
I know you love lecturing me, and I
appreciate it, and you teach me every step
of the way. But please refrain from
counseling so much.

MR. SCAROLA: Please refrain from
misrepresenting the record.
MR. LINK: I do not believe I am, and I
will stand by the record.
BY MR. LINK:
Q And if I have somehow misled you or did
something inappropriate on the record
unintentionally, then I apologize, Mr. Edwards. But,
in fact, you are not just a witness in this case.
You are a lawyer of record, aren't you?
A Yes.
Q Which means that you're going to be a
lawyer trying this case, as I understand, right?

MR. SCAROLA: No, it doesn't mean that.
MR. LINK: He can't answer that?
THE WITNESS: I don't think I need to
tell you who is trying the case.

MR. SCAROLA: I'm the attorney in this
case.
MR. LINK: Okay.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
MR. SCAROLA: Your question was about
who is going to be trying the case.

MR. LINK: And he can answer that.
MR. SCAROLA: And I'm telling you who
is going to try the case, and that doesn't
include Bradley Edwards as a lawyer trying
the case.

MR. LINK: Is there a reason he
couldn't answer that?
MR. SCAROLA: Pardon me?
MR. LINK: Is there a reason he
couldn't answer that?

MR. SCAROLA: It is not within the
scope of his responsibility to answer it.
It is within the scope of my responsibility
to answer it. And if what you are really
looking for is an answer to the question, I
have just given it you to.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So you don't intend to participate in the
trial of this case?
A It depends on how successful you guys are in
continuing with the case the way that --
Q So there's a possibility you will
participate in the trial of this case in --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A There's a possibility that I wouldn't even be
alive when this case is tried if we continue going down
this road.
Q Okay, let's not talk about your pending
death. Are you in good condition? You're health's
okay?
A I believe so.
Q How old are you?
A Forty-one.
Q Any medication you are on?
A No.
Q So I'm asking you, is it your intent that
you will participate in the trial of this case?
A I don't think that I need to tell you our
strategy as to who is going to participate at what
stage in this case at all, nor would I ask you or
expect for you to tell me yours.
Q But you are both a plaintiff, a witness and
an attorney representing yourself in this case?
A I've agreed to that already, yes.
Q Do you know why you were left off of the
witness list for this case and were just added last
night at 5:30 p.m.?
A Again, other information that is
attorney -client privileged information that I'm not
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
obligated to tell you.
Q I didn't ask you about your communications
with your lawyer. I asked if you know --
A How else would I know?

MR. SCAROLA: You asked why. How else
would he know?
BY MR. LINK:
Q Then you can say there's a privilege.

MR. SCAROLA: That's what he just did.
THE WITNESS: I just told you that. I
said it.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Is there anything other than communication
with yourself as a lawyer and with Mr. Scarola as to
why, as the plaintiff in this case, you were not
listed as a witness?
A You would have to ask my lawyers as to
witness lists, exhibit lists and those types of things
that --
Q That you are unaware of?
A That they deal with.
Q Do you work on the day-to-day handling of
the lawsuit?

MR. SCAROLA: Objection. Work -product
privilege.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
MR. LINK: What does that tell me about
his anticipating thoughts about trial?

MR. SCAROLA: What he is doing in
connection with this case is a work-product
privilege.
MR. LINK: I didn't ask what he was
doing. I asked if he worked on the case
day-to-day. I didn't ask for any specific
thing he did, Jack. I don't know how that
can be work product.
You stand by your objection?

MR. SCAROLA: Yeah, I do.
BY MR. LINK:
Q When the -- let's go back to the time
period before the lawsuit was dismissed -- the claims
against you were dismissed by Mr. Epstein. Did you
work on the defense of that case?
A I had no choice.
Q You didn't have a lawyer.
A Right, but I knew the details. I had to
spend a lot of time defending that case.
Q But you said you had no choice. When you
represent clients, a lot of them are not lawyers,
right?
A It was the nature of the lawsuit.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q There was something about the lawsuit when
it was filed that made it -- you uncomfortable
relying on Mr. Scarola to do the work?
A It required -- it was about legal actions
that I had taken in the case. I had taken those
actions, so I had to do the work.
Q So you had to do the legal work because of
legal actions that you had taken? Is that what you
are telling me?
A I was most equipped I'm a lawyer. I was
most equipped to answer as to the falsity of the
complaint that was filed against me. I was best suited
to point out and to strategize as to what needed to be
done to prove the falsity of those allegations.
Q And I'm sure Mr. Scarola appreciated that
help.
A I'm sure.
Q And did you draft the counterclaim?

MR. SCAROLA: Same agreement.
MR. LINK: Well, it can't be. You're
seeking recovery for the pleadings. It's in
everything you've disclosed. It can't be --
THE WITNESS: Not for the counterclaim,
I don't think --

MR. LINK: It can't be part of the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
agreement.
THE WITNESS: For the counterclaim, we
are not seeking fees for that.
BY MR. LINK:
Q You're not?
A That's the affirmative case, as opposed to
the defense of the case.
Q Okay.
A If what you're representing to me is that
statement you just made to me is true, I will accept
your word for it, but I don't believe it to be true.
Q I'm not going to represent anything to you
about your time.
A Okay.
Q If you're telling me that you are not
that all of your time that you recorded, 1,300 hours,
was in defending solely the claim brought by

Mr. Epstein, then that's what you're telling me, and
the records are what the records are.
A The time records are what the time records
are.
Q But I'm asking you, are you telling me that
the 1,300 -plus hours that you are seeking
compensation for were spent solely on defending
against the complaint Mr. Epstein filed against the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Rothstein -- against Mr. Rothstein and against you?
A If you show me my time records I can answer
that question without any doubt.
Q I'm asking you. You are the plaintiff in
this case and you are seeking that recovery.
A I understand that. But why won't you give me
something that will help to refresh my recollection on
exactly what -- and the only thing that's holding me up
is that there were various versions of both the
complaint and the counterclaim that overlapped one
another. But I believe that the time records that were
submitted to you, which -- which is less than the total
time records that I kept up to that point, I believe
that they were reduced by my counsel to the time that
was spent -- to my time that was spent defending the
case.
But I can tell you without any doubt, if
you will just show me the documents, because I know
that you have them.
Q We are going to look at a lot of documents.
A Okay.
Q But I am certainly allowed to test your
memory.
A That's my memory.
Q That's all I am doing.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
I guess you are telling me that you gave
all the contemporaneous time records to Mr. Scarola,
and somebody in his office determined what to be
produced as to what you're seeking recovery for.
A This gets into attorney -client privilege.
Q You told me you gave them all to
Mr. Scarola, and they decided what to give me. Is
that what you said?
A There's no way for me to answer that question
as to how the time records that were produced in this
case came to be without getting into discussions with
counsel.
Q Did you keep contemporaneous time records?
A Yes.
Q So starting in -- when did you start
keeping contemporaneous time records of the amount of
time you spent on the Epstein versus Rothstein and
Edwards matter?
A I don't know exactly.
Q You know what contemporaneous time records
are?
A Yes.
Q Day-to-day, writing down your time.
A I understand.
Q And that's what you did. So somewhere
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
there is backup for what has been produced to me that
would show me day-to-day what you wrote down on a
day-to-day basis? Is that true? That's how you kept
your time?
A You just asked a bunch of different
questions. Somewhere is there -- is that how I kept my
time? Just one question and I will answer it.
Q It was an amazing question if you piece
them all together. Let's try it one by one.
A Okay.
Q Did you keep, starting in December 2009,
daily time sheets?
A I don't know that I started -- I don't think
I started then. I think that it was subsequent to
that. And I know because I remember where I was when I
had a specific conversation that led me to begin
keeping them contemporaneously.
So I know that there was a period of time
that passed before I started keeping them
contemporaneously where I had to go back and try to
figure out for a period of a month or six weeks or
so the time that I had spent.
Q It's my understanding that the tort group,
which you mentioned at the Rothstein firm, did not
keep daily time records.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Okay.
Q Did you keep daily time records when you
were at the Rothstein firm?
A I don't think that your statement that you
just represented is true. I think that the tort group
did keep daily time records. But if you say it's true,
I will accept it.
Q Let me just ask about you. Did you keep
daily time records at the Rothstein firm?
A We were required to put time in daily. And I
believe I did every -- I don't know that I did every
day, but I did for the most part.
Q So when is it that you made the decision to
start recording your time related to the Epstein
matter on a daily basis?
A I don't know exactly.
Q You said you remembered the exact precise
time that you did it.
A I remember the location where I was standing.
I don't remember the precise day that -- I was in the
Palm Beach County courthouse. I can picture where I
was standing. I don't know where in the course of this
litigation that that occurred, like what time period.
Q Do you generally remember? Was it weeks?
Months? A year? Two years?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A No, it wasn't that long. It was within the
first -- at least six, eight months of the lawsuit
beginning.
Q So then how did you create your time for
the first six to eight months?
A It could have been a month, then. You know,
it could have been six months.
Q I understand.
A That's what I said. But then you said, How
did you create it for the first six to eight months? I
mean, there was a period of time that I had to go back
and look at the documents that had been filed, what
part -- what role I played in drafting those documents,
those types of things that you would always do to go
back and figure out how much time that you spent on
anything.
Q Well, if you're taking contemporaneous time
records -- you're making contemporaneous time
records, you don't have to do that.
A And there came a point in time where I was
keeping contemporaneous time records.
Q You remember that point where you asked me
to let you finish?
A Yeah.
Q Okay. Same deal, all right.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Got it.
Q So if you were keeping contemporaneous time
records, you wouldn't have to go back and recreate
your time, because it would be there day-to-day.
A Agreed.
Q So if you started you said, six to eight
months. Let's say between one month and eight
months -- the way you went back to recreate your time
is to look at everything you did day-to-day and wrote
down time for that, I take it. Is that right?
A If you could just show me my time records, I
will tell you exactly what I did to -- and I will
probably be able to tell you when I started keeping
contemporaneous time records
Q I'm asking if you remember.
A -- because it would be on a more regular
basis.
Q I'm asking you if you remember how you
recreated the time, what you did?
A Yeah. Sure. I would look at a docket. Pull
up the pleading that had been filed, and say, Okay, I
did -- I drafted this pleading. I know what work went
into drafting that pleading. Probably took me two
hours, I would say it's a .5. I will underestimate
Q So you reduced your time?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A I would not exaggerate my time.
Q I didn't say that. I asked if you reduced

it. You said I spent two hours and I put down a .5.
A I would make sure it was conservative, yeah.
Q So when I look at your timeline here, you
actually spent more time than you would have billed
for?
A I have spent so much more time on dealing
with Jeffrey Epstein than I have put on any time
record, yes.
Q And in 2009, did you have any clients that
paid you on an hourly-rate basis?
A I don't remember.
Q In 2010 did you have clients that paid you
on an hourly -rate basis?
A I just don't remember.
Q Have you ever had a client pay you on an
hourly-rate basis?
A Yes.
Q When was that?
A I have clients right now that pay me on an
hourly basis.
Q When is the first one that you can remember
that paid you on an hourly-rate basis?
A Oh, God. I don't know. 2007.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q And how much did they pay an hour?
A I don't remember that.
Q Do you remember how much you billed when
you were at Kubicki Draper -- hourly rate?
A I don't.
Q What hourly rate -- do you have clients
that pay you hourly rate now?
A Yes.
Q What rate do they pay you?
A Varying, but up to 500 an hour.
Q What's the lowest amount you are being
paid?
A I believe 350.
Q How long ago did the client that is paying
you 550 (sic) an hour retain you?
A I said 500. And if I didn't say 500, then I
mean --

MR. SCAROLA: You did say 500 --
BY MR. LINK:
Q Maybe I misheard it.
MR. SCAROLA: -- and it was misstated
as 550, I'm sure inadvertently.
THE WITNESS: What was your question
then? How long ago?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Yeah. How long ago did this client hire
you and agreed to the $500 an hour?
A Within the last year.

MR. LINK: Let's go ahead -- are they
going to bring the food here?
BY MR. LINK:
Q While we take our break, I will mark these
and show them to you. We will do them as a composite
exhibit. These are the November news articles we
talked about.
A Okay.
(Plaintiff's Composite Exhibit Number 5
was marked for identification. )
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
1:06 p.m. We are going off the record.
(A recess was had.)
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE
FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT, IN
AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
Case No. 502009CA040800XXXXMB
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Plaintiff,
vs.
SCOTT ROTHSTEIN, individually;
BRADLEY EDWARDS, individually,
Defendants/Counter-Plaintiffs.
VOLUME II
VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION
OF
BRADLEY EDWARDS
Taken on Behalf of Plaintiff
Friday, November 10th, 2017
10:02 a.m. - 6:16 p.m.
2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard
West Palm Beach, Florida 33409
Examination of the witness taken before
Sonja D. Hall
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
1665 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard, Suite 1001
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
1:45 a.m. We are back on the record.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Edwards, take a look at Exhibit 6,
which is the Razorback complaint. We were talking
about it 50 minutes ago, before we broke. And I
would like you to turn to page nine in the complaint,
paragraph 25.
A Okay.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 6 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q During the six months that you worked at

Mr. Rothstein's firm, were you aware that he owned an
87-foot yacht?
A I knew he had a boat. I knew he had a yacht,
but I didn't know it was 87 feet. I had been to his
house one time.
Q I'm going to get to his house. Had you
been on his yacht?
A No.
Q Had you seen it?
A It was in the backyard of his house the time
I went over.
Q So you saw the 87 -- you didn't know it was
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
87 feet. However many feet the yacht was, you saw
it.
A I saw a boat back there, yeah. I mean, there
was a canopy that was kind of blocking what I could see
and what I couldn't, but yeah.
Q And which house was it that you went to?
A I only knew of one house, so I don't know.
It was in Fort Lauderdale.
Q It was in Fort Lauderdale.
You see here it says he owned 16 different
real estate properties, paragraph 25?
A Yes.
Q The house you went to was in Fort
Lauderdale?
A Yes.
Q Did you go there during the time that you
were employed by Mr. Rothstein?
A Yes.
Q What was the purpose of going to his house?
Was there a function?
A Yeah, it was a function.
Q For employees, or was it a fundraiser?
A No, it was a fundraiser of some sort.
Q Do you remember for whose benefit the
fundraiser was?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A He had his hands in so many things.
Hospitals and -- you know, heart associations and
whatever it was. But I don't remember which one it
was. He had things at his house all the time. This is
the only one I went to, but I don't remember what it
was.
Q Big house?
A Oh, yeah, it was a big house.
Q You see here it mentions 25 cars. Were you
aware he had multiple cars?
A I think I knew he had two.
Q Which ones?
A I don't remember. The one I can picture was
either a Bentley -- I think it was a Bentley.
Q Were you aware that he owned interest in
some of the restaurants in town?
A I knew he owned Bova.
Q What was Bova?
A It was the restaurant downstairs of the law
firm.
Q I know you had mentioned before that there
was security -- somewhere I read that there was
security in Mr. Rothstein in the offices?
A There was.
Q Everywhere? I never went to his offices,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
so I don't know.
A So there were uniformed, armed police
officers on every floor. Actual, police officers.
BSO, Fort Lauderdale police officers all the time,
every single floor, all day, every day from the day
that I first got there until the last day.
Q Did you think that was odd?
A Well, I thought it was different, for sure,
because you don't see police officers walking around
here. But it was actual police. It wasn't, like, the
mob dressed as police. It was police.
Q I understand.
A If anything, it was -- it's crazy -- has more
security. I did ask somebody about it one time and
they said that a lawyer had been murdered, before I got
there, that was a partner at that firm, and that
Rothstein's feeling was that he doesn't want that to
ever happen again. So if he has the money for
additional security, why not hire Fort Lauderdale
police and secure everybody, which was the response I
got.
Q Had you ever been in an office before or
since that had armed police security guards?
A Not like that. Maybe I have been to a bank
and there's been one police officer there, but
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q I am talking a law firm. Any other law
firms?
A No.
Q And the bank has usually one armed police
officer.
A Right.
Q Bank where they keep money and stuff like
that?
A I go to the same kind of banks you do, so
yes.

MR. SCAROLA: You walked right past our
security guard when you came in today.
MR. LINK: And I was intimidated. I'm
sure I saw him -- him, her. Just one?
MR. SCAROLA: Just one. At the front
door.
MR. LINK: I saw the lions. But that's
not the security guard.
THE WITNESS: They transform.
BY MR. LINK:
Q The security -- in addition -- how many
armed guards on each floor? Two? Multiple?
A Multiple.
Q Other than multiple armed guards on each
floor --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Police officers.
Q Police officers.
A Right.
Q On-duty police officers.
A Appeared to be, yes. Uniformed.
Q Uniformed -- okay, got it.
Multiple on-duty, uniformed police
officers in the building. There was also electronic
security and cameras and stuff like that?
A I think there was signage that said that
there was cameras. Whether there was actually cameras,
I just can't remember anymore, but I think so.
Q Everywhere?
A I just don't remember anymore. I don't know.
But if you could imagine what looks like the most
secure place, that is what the law firm looked like.
I say that -- I remember the signage --
because I remember there being a sign that said
there's video or audio surveillance on one of the
doors -- one of the main doors to the building. And
there might have actually been or there might have
been fake cameras or something. I don't know.
Q But as far as you could tell, and the
sign --
A I believe there was surveillance everywhere.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q So you worked at a law office that had
surveillance everywhere and armed uniformed police
guards on every floor?
A The perception of surveillance everywhere,
and yes, police officers on every floor.
Q Did you ever go into Mr. Rothstein's -- as
I understand it, he had a personal office on his own
floor, and more secure than any banks that you and I
go into.
A Yes. There were multiple levels of security
to ever get into his office.
Q Did you ever go into his office?
A I did. I had a back surgery sometime that
summer in 2009. And because I needed time off for the
back surgery, I went in there that time.
Q To ask --
A To tell him, look, I need a couple weeks off
because I'm having back surgery. That's the time I
remember talking to him.
Q He said okay?
A Yeah.
Q So you said multiple levels. How would I
get to him? What did you have to go through?
A I remembered it better then than I do now.
Let me think about this. He had somebody sitting
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
outside of doors, kind of like would be normal --
probably like your offices, there's a secretary or
paralegal or somebody there.
That person would have -- if you didn't
have an appointment with that person, whoever that
person was, you could not get past that level.
Q So that's the first level, the scheduling
person?
A Yeah. And that's kind of, like, normal.
Like most -- then there was a door. I think it had --
I think you needed a key or -- like a fob to get into.
That just got you into a hallway. It didn't really
lead you anywhere. If you only got past that first
level, you are just stuck for life.
Q Let me make sure I've got this. I get past
the typical reception -type person. I then, with a
fob, get into the hallway.
A Hallway.
Q Then what happens?
A There's another double set of doors. Looks
like that, but just bigger doors. Looks like the doors
that you come in through here.
Q So that the jury will understand, you are
pointing to typical wood doors -- double doors going
into a conference room.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A And behind that would be his office.
Q And what was in front of the doors? How
did you get to those doors? Do you remember?
A I think you could just walk.
Q But from the hallway -- you're in the
hallway
A Yeah, I mean -- you know, it's kind of like
you're in a corridor that's, from recollection, 12 feet
by 15 feet. And if you walked straightforward 15 feet
and his doors were unlocked, you could open the doors
and you could walk in.
Q And you could walk in?
A Yes.
Q And there he was?
How big was his office?
A As big as this room or -- yeah, as big as
this room.
Q So we're sitting in Mr. Scarola's library
conference room. I don't know the dimensions of it,
but maybe 30 by 30ish. Close?

MR. SCAROLA: Thirty by 20.
THE WITNESS: Thirty by 20.
BY MR. LINK:
Q At least that size?
A From my recollection, that's pretty accurate.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
I mean, it was big.
Q Biggest law office you have been in for an
individual lawyer?
A I don't know. Top of my head you know. I
think so. As big any I have been in.
Q Bigger than the office you had?
A Oh, yeah. Cubbyhole.
Q Bigger than Mr. Scarola's office?
A Mr. Scarola has a very nice office, too,
but --
Q It's not that big. I have been in it, too.
A Right.
Q And I remember reading somewhere about
there's a private elevator or some special elevator.
A I didn't know that until after the news
article and something came out. I never saw the
private elevator.
Q But you know what I'm talking about?
A I heard about it. I think that afterwards
there was something on the news where Kendall Coffey
was talking about there being a private elevator, and
that's where I learned it.
Q Turn to page 12, if you would, please.
So I apologize, but I don't think that I
mentioned that we are looking at Exhibit Number 6,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
which is the Razorback Funding versus Rothstein
lawsuit filed November 20th, 2009.
A Now I am on page 12.
Q Now you are page 12, yes, sir.
We are looking -- this is November 20th --
so the Razorback -- putting this in context for the
jury, the Razorback Funding lawsuit against
Rothstein was filed November 20th, 2009. Do you see
that?
box?
A Where do you see --
Q Look at the very first page. You see the
A Yeah. Okay.
Q November 20th, 2009?
A Yes.
Q And the lawsuit that Mr. Epstein filed
against Mr. Rothstein and you was filed December 7th,
2009.
A Taking your word for it.
Q I will show you my copy. We are going to
mark it. But you see in the middle, December 7?
A Yeah, says December 7. That's when it's
stamped into the clerk.
Q So before Mr. Epstein's lawsuit, first came
the Razorback lawsuit against Mr. Rothstein
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
chronologically?
A Correct.
Q If you turn -- you're on page 12, paragraph

40. Do you see that in the Razorback lawsuit,
paragraph 40, page 12, it talks about the Ponzi
scheme and how one of the settlements that was being
offered to potential investors related to Jane Doe
versus Jeffrey Epstein pending in the Southern
District of Florida? Do you see that?
MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me.
THE WITNESS: I read the paragraph.
That's not that it says, though.
BY MR. LINK:
Q What does it say?
A Well, it says, "In incertain instances, the
purported settlements" -- talking about the Rothstein's
fraudulent settlements -- "were based on actual cases
being handled by RRA. For example, one of the
settlements involved herein was based upon facts
surrounding Jeffrey Epstein, the infamous billionaire
financier. In fact, RRA did have inside information
due to its representation of one of Epstein's alleged
victims in a civil case styled Jane Doe versus Jeffrey
Epstein pending in the Southern District of Florida."
Q Keep reading up to the next -- you didn't
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
finish the paragraph where it says --
A I was still reading, though.
Q Okay.
A "Representatives of D3 were offered, quote,
the opportunity, end quote, to invest in a pre-suit
$30 million court settlement against Epstein arising
from the same set of operative facts as the Jane Doe
case, but involving a different underaged female
plaintiff."
Q Keep going, please.
A Keep going?
Q Yeah. Where it starts with, "To augment."
A There's an attachment, too.
But, "To augment his concocted story,
Rothstein invited D3 to his office to view the 13
banker's boxes of actual case files in Jane Doe in
order to demonstrate that the claims against Epstein
were legitimate and that the evidence against
Epstein was real."
Keep going?
Q No. I just -- the statement that I made --
that I thought you disagreed with -- was that the
actual Jane Doe lawsuit that you were the lead lawyer
for was used by Rothstein to try and induce folks to
make an investment in his Ponzi.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A I guess where we are having a disagreement is
the word used. To me that's an implying that Rothstein
is selling something related to the legitimate cases.
It's pretty obvious or clear from this that what
Rothstein was doing was using the fact that real
legitimate cases against Epstein were actually being
litigated in his law firm to, as this says, concoct a
story about some other situation, and ask investors to
buy into some made up fictitious story.
Q I think we are saying the same exact thing.
A Right. So we are not in disagreement.
Q I think we are saying the exact same thing.
The way I read Razorback, I believe, is the way you
read it, which is that, yes, there are real -- three
real lawsuits.
A Right.
Q That you are in charge of.
A Yes.
Q And those --
A They say one. But you are right, three.
Q I know, three.
A Yes.
Q The three real lawsuits that you are in
charge of, that Rothstein, to raise money, makes up
additional information about other clients that the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
firm does not represent. It's phony, and in order to
show that what he is doing is real, he uses the real
Jane Doe lawsuit that you're in charge of and lets
them look at boxes. That's the way I read it. Do
you agree with that?
A I mean, I would say it differently than you,
but I think we don't disagree too much.
Q Was there ever a pre-suit settlement of
$30 million with Mr. Epstein?
A No.
Q Did Mr. Epstein offer $200 million as it
reports in paragraph four to settle the claims?
A No. This has to do with a story that
Rothstein was making up, apparently.
Q Right. I understand that. But there are
some parts of his story that weave in the reality of
what you were doing, right. You were, in fact,
representing Jane Doe in a lawsuit against Epstein?
A Right. Girls that were actually molested by
Jeffrey Epstein, yes, that's what I was doing.
Q There were, in fact, banker's boxes of the
actual case files for Jane Doe within the Rothstein
offices, right?
A Yes.
Q Those actual banker's boxes were used by
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Rothstein to show potential investors?
A Invest in my story over here. And in case
you're not believing it, look, there's an actual
file -- these are legitimate cases and you can look it
up on Pacer, and it's really happening. He really is
that bad person they say he is. I think that that is
actually what happened.
Q Got it.
A Yeah.
Q You see here, that I said he was weaving
some of the reality into his story --
A Make his story more believable, it looks
like.
Q He talks about -- he talked about -- and
according to the Razorback complaint, the
high-profile witnesses and the private jet. You see
that in the middle of --
A Point me to it.
Q -- page 13?
A Okay.
Q "Rothstein claimed that his investigative
team" -- we talked about who those investigators were
earlier right?
A Right.
Q -- "discovered" -- the team did --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
"discovered that there were high -profile witnesses
onboard Epstein's private jet where some of the
alleged sexual assaults took place, and showed D3"
the potential investors -- "copies of a flight log
Right?
A Yeah.
Q -- "purportedly containing names of
celebrities, dignitaries and international figures."
A Right.
Q Did the flight log in fact contain names of
celebrities?
A Epstein's flight log does contain names of
celebrities. Those are the people he hung out with.
Q And dignitaries?
A What's the definition of dignitary? I think
so.
Q Good enough for me.
And international figures.
A Yes.
Q So there is some truth that Rothstein is
weaving in, based on documents, the flight log that
was obtained by you as the lead trial lawyer in the
pending lawsuits?
A There is some truth in the pending lawsuits?
Q No. I'm saying that what Rothstein was
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
doing -- we all --
A He used actual evidence to support a
fabricated story.
Q And the actual evidence that was referred
to here are these flight logs that you as the lead
lawyer obtained and brought back to the Rothstein
firm, right?
A I maintain the evidence for all of my cases
at the Rothstein firm where I worked, yes.
Q That's all I was confirming.
A Does it appear that Rothstein gained access
to it and used it to support his fairytale? It does.
Q It does, right? And you agree with that.
A Yes.
Q So paragraph 41.
A Yes.
Q In this case, Razorback -- this is not

Mr. Epstein's suit, right? This is Bill Scherer
representing the Razorback client that he represented
suing Rothstein is making these allegations?
A Yes.
Q Right? Okay.
So Mr. Scherer -- do you know Mr. Scherer?
A I know him now better than I did then. I
didn't know him at all then.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q What was his reputation in Fort Lauderdale
in 2009?
A He owned a law firm that had been around a
while.
Q A long time, right?
A Yeah.
Q So Mr. Scherer prints here in his Razorback
suit, as an example of how they were trying to lure
investors in the Ponzi scheme, that RRA relentlessly
pursued flight data and passenger manifests regarding
flights Epstein took with other famous individuals,
knowing full well that no underage women were onboard
and no elicit activities took place. Do you see
sentence?
A Yes.
Q How is it that Mr. Scherer is aware of that
information at the time? Do you know?
A That information is false, so he's not aware
of anything.
Here is the problem with the whole thing.

Mr. Epstein knows that information is false.
Q He knows what information is false?
A It says, "RRA relentless pursued flight data
and passenger manifests regarding flights Epstein took
with other famous individuals knowing full well that no
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
underaged women were onboard." There were underage
women onboard. Epstein knew that. So he knows this to
be false. "And no elicit activities took place."
Epstein knows elicit activities took place on his
airplane, so he knows that to be false.
He can't just adopt what Bill Scherer says
and say, Oh, that forms the basis of something I
believe. It can't possibly form the basis of what
he believes, because he knows it to be false.
Q Okay. So did any of the three clients that
you represented while you were at Mr. Rothstein's
testified that they went on Mr. Epstein's plane?
A They were not three of -- they were not on

Mr. Epstein's plane. They were not the victims on the
plane.
Q So the clients that you represented -- you
individually while at the Rothstein firm -- your
three clients testified or admitted that they never
traveled on Mr. Epstein's plane, correct?
A If they testified truthfully, they would say
that. I just don't remember if they were asked that
question.
Q But you know the question is
A I do know the answer to that question for
sure.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Did you know that in 2009.
A Of course.
Q Did you know that the three clients that
you were representing had never had sex with a
dignitary or had been molested by a dignitary?

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. The only way
that Brad would have knowledge with regard
to those matters would be as a consequence
of attorney -client privilege communications.
I think you can get the same
information by rephrasing your question as
to what they have testified to, but you
can't get it that way.

MR. LINK: Well, the reason I asked it
that way is he doesn't really remember what
they testified to.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Right?
A Not every question.
Q I got it.
So was there any testimony from your three
clients that anyone of the three of them had sex
with a celebrity that's associated with Mr. Epstein?
A No.
Q Had sex with a dignitary associated with
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Mr. Epstein?
A No.
Q Had sex with an international figure
associated with Mr. Epstein?
A No.
Q Touched, fondled, inappropriate activity in
any shape, form or way with a celebrity, dignitary or
international figure associated with Mr. Epstein?
A There was not, and that's why we never made
such allegations.
Q When you were utilizing the investigators
at the Rothstein firm, what would you have to do to
get payment in order pay them?
Wayne Black, as an example, you said was
an independent person that had to be paid. What
would you do?
A Wayne Black. I think that I would just tell
Russ Adler, Hey, I have hired this investigator.
That's what I recall doing with Wayne Black.
And I remember this better because I
remember Wayne Black coming to me saying, Look, I'm
still not getting paid, and me saying, You're
talking to the wrong guy. Talk to Russ, because he
is kind of the head of the tort division, for lack
of a better word. So I'm not the guy to pay you. I
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
know I brought you in, but you have to talk to him.
And I know that it was tough for Wayne to get paid.
Q So who is Russ?
A Russ Adler.
Q Mr. Adler was the head of the practice
group you worked for?
A Yes.
Q Mr. Adler was convicted of some crime as
well?
A Political campaign contribution something.
Q And in order for you to pay an
investigator, you had to go to Mr. Adler and ask him
to submit a check request?
A That's just overbroad.
So Wayne Black, specifically, because he
is outside, when it was -- I need to be hired (sic),
I would tell Russ, Hey, this is the investigator
that I want -- that I want to hire for this case,
and then Russ dealt with him however it was for him
to get paid.
The problem was that whatever they worked
out for him to get paid, Wayne didn't get paid, so
Wayne came back to me saying, Hey, I'm still not
getting paid. Nobody has paid my invoice. I would
just pass that on to Russ.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q What would Russ say -- Mr. Adler?
A It's getting paid.
Q But it never did?
A I don't know. I think it did eventually get
paid. I'm not sure that it didn't. But there was --
it was longer than I would ever go to pay my bills. I
would pay -- he didn't pay it.
But the other investigators -- your
question was just overbroad -- the other
investigators were employees of the firm, so I
didn't go to them -- I didn't go to anybody about
Mike Fisten or Pat Roberts, how they were going to
get paid. They were just employees on salary, I
believe.
Q I thought that I asked it if they were not
employees. But I may not have, so I appreciate it.
A Just clarifying.
Q Mr. Fisten, I read he was he would
attend the meeting with the investors on the Epstein
case?
A I don't believe that.
Q You don't believe that's true.
A No.
Q But you have seen that said?
A I have seen that said somewhere. I don't
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
know if it's in the context of this lawsuit I have seen
it said, or I have seen it said somewhere else. But I
find that very, very hard to believe.
Q But you know that allegation was out there?
A Right. Like I am saying, I don't know if it
was an allegation that was thrown out there by
Epstein's defense team or by somebody else, but the
first time I have heard that is not right now.
Q Understood.
Take a look, if you will, at Exhibit 7,
please.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 7 was marked
for identification.)
THE WITNESS: What about Exhibit 7?
BY MR. LINK:
Q Exhibit Number 7, which is the versus
Jeffrey Epstein Complaint filed January 24th, 2009.
A Okay.
Q This is a complaint that you drafted?
A Like I told you, I think Paul drafted much
more of this, if not the entire document. I don't know
how much --
Q Take a look at the last page. This
complaint is 234 pages long. I only see one lawyer
submitting this complaint.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Okay.
Q What do you see?
A No, I submitted the complaint for sure. I'm
the Florida lawyer.
Q I have seen other pleadings that you've
submitted and it has Mr. Cassell's name on it, has

Mr. Howell's name on it.
A Yes.
Q In fact, both of them were on the state
court complaint that you filed for , true?
A Sure.
Q But on this one, on the 234-page complaint,
the only name on it is Bradley Edwards, Rothstein,
Rosenfeldt & Adler, true?
A That's true.
Q Is that your signature?
A No.
Q Whose signature is that?
A I don't know. I don't know. That's not my
signature.
Q Who did you authorize to sign this to file
it?
A I would have told one of the paralegals to
file it.
Q And sign your name on a federal court
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
pleading?
A No. I would not have told them to do that.
I think that typically when that is done, it's an
electronic signature that's --
Q You think this is an electronic signature?
A No, no, I don't think that. I'm saying when
we file cases in federal court.
Q You know what an electronic signature looks
like, right?
A I wasn't saying that.
Q Okay, good. Because you just said
typically.
This is a real signature, agreed?
A Right.
Q So who signed a federal court, 234-page
complaint for you?
A I don't know whose signature that is. I just
told you that.
Q Does that signing -- having somebody else
sign this for you, that you don't know who it is,
comply with your Rule 11 obligations?
A I did not have somebody else sign this for
me.
Q You just said it's not your signature.
A It's not my signature.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Then who signed it for you?
A I don't know who signed this.
Q Okay.
A I wanted it filed. I mean --
Q You were in such a hurry to file it that
you couldn't sign it yourself?
A Until right now I believed I signed it
myself. I would have signed it myself.
Q But you didn't?
A That's not my signature. No, I didn't. But
I wanted this filed. I'm not saying I didn't want this
filed. I wanted this filed. I'm glad that it was
filed. It should have been filed.
Q You can't tell me who signed it for you?
A No.
Q Did you authorize somebody to sign this
complaint on your behalf?
A No.
Q Then did you fulfill --
A I authorized someone to file it. I
authorized someone to file the complaint.
Q I authorize my legal assistant and
secretaries to file things that I sign all the time.
I assume that's what you're talking about.
A Yes.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q If I file a federal court lawsuit, 234
pages, it will have my signature on it.
A Okay.
Q Isn't that what you do?
A Typically. If -- yes, I would think so.
Q I would hope so.
A That's not necessarily true. I file
pleadings and other lawyers in my firm file pleadings
for me -- or sign signatures for me.
Q They sign your name?
A No, not sign my name.
Q Somebody signed your name here?
A Nobody signed my name. That doesn't say my
name. But I agree with you that somebody signed above
where it says my name.
Q This isn't a significant block that says
Scott Link and Kara Rockenbach and one of us signs
for the two of us. This only has one name on it,
Bradley Edwards. At the very least it should say
"for."
A Sure. I agree with you that this should say
somebody is signing for me.
Q So do you think it's compliant with your
Rule 11 obligation to have somebody sign this
234-page complaint to say, Juliette Smith for Bradley
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

J. Edwards complies with your obligations?
A Until right now, this second, I didn't know
that anyone else other than me signed this complaint.
I believed that I either signed it or that it was
electronically -- my electronic signature was on this
complaint.
Q I got it. But you see now
A I see it.
Q -- that it's not true. And I'm asking you
does it comply with your Rule 11 obligations to have
a 234-page complaint filed in federal court with a
signature on it that's not yours and not somebody you
authorized?
A I don't know if it does or not. But I would
sign this document.
Q I understand you would. But you didn't.
A And I agree with it being signed.
Q And it was filed with some name that you
don't even know who it is, do you?
A Right. But I'm not running from the
document. I agree this document should have been
signed. It's as if -- you can treat it like I signed
the document.
Q I agree, but is that what a federal judge
would say to you?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A You can.
Q Would a federal judge say that under Rule

MR. SCAROLA: I am going to object to
that question. It's argumentive. It calls
for speculation. You don't have to answer.
BY MR. LINK:
Q You practice in federal court right?
A Yes.
Q You know what Rule 11 is, right?
A I do.
Q We have to sign under Rule 11 as lawyers?
A I have never had Rule 11 sanctioned against
me, so --
Q You don't know the obligations under Rule
11 as a lawyer? Just because you haven't been
sanctioned, that means you don't know what your
obligations are?
A I do.
Q So what are your obligations?

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. That question
is argumentive. It's not relevant or
material or reasonably calculated to lead to
the discovery of relevant and material
information. You don't need to answer.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Can you please tell me, as the lawyer who
authorized this to be filed, what your Rule 11
obligations were in July 2009 about signing this
pleading?

MR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same
instruction.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Take a look at the civil cover sheet, last
page. See where it says, "The above information is
true and correct to the best of my knowledge.
Signature of attorney of record"? Is that your
signature, sir?
A No.
Q Do did you authorize that signature on this
civil cover sheet for the federal case?
A I authorized the case to be filed. That's
all I authorized.
Q Sir, listen, please. My question is really
easy. Did you authorize somebody to sign this
document as though they were you for this federal
court civil cover sheet?
A No.
Q Let's mark this. I'll hand you Exhibit 8.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 8 was marked
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q Remember you mentioned earlier Cara, who
was an attorney and former FBI agent who worked for

Mr. Rothstein's firm, right?
A Yes.
Q So I'm showing you what's just been marked
as Exhibit 8. Cara L. Holmes, is that the Cara you
were referring to?
A I think so. I didn't know another Cara,
so --
Q And this is dated July 29th, 2009, right?
A Right.
Q About the same time that you filed the
234-page federal court complaint, right?
A Five days later.
Q What does Ms. Holmes say to you about
strategy relating to Mr. Epstein?
A "I think our best bet is to go after those
close to Epstein."
Q So let's take a look at this next exhibit,
Exhibit 9, which is the complaint filed on
December 7th by Mr. Epstein against Scott Rothstein,
Bradley Edwards and_
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 9 was marked
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
for identification.)
THE WITNESS: Uh-huh.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I would like you to please identify the
allegations in this complaint that cause your loss of
reputation.
A I would have to start basically reading the
entire complaint into the record.
Q Take your time.
A You want me to read the complaint to the
court reporter?
Q No. I want you to read it to yourself
just read it to yourself. The document is an
exhibit. Read it, then we can go through it
paragraph by paragraph and then you can answer my
question.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: There's less than 10
minutes left on the tape.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Why don't we take a break while you read
the complaint, and you can -- maybe if you want to
mark on there, why don't you mark each paragraph that
you read that caused injury to your reputation?
A How do you want me to mark it?
Q Put a bracket around or a checkmark.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Whatever is easiest for you.
MR. LINK: Okay. We can go off the
record.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
2:22 p.m. This is the end of tape two. We
are going off the record.
(A recess was had.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
2:34 p.m. This is the beginning of tape
three and we are back on the record.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Okay. Mr. Edwards, you were going to go
through the Exhibit Number 9, which was the
December 7th, 2009 complaint filed by Mr. Epstein
against Scott Rothstein, Bradley Edwards andllill
and you were going to highlight the paragraphs that
caused injury to your reputation.
A The complaint as a whole.
Q The entire complaint?
A The entire complaint This is a complaint
that says that Scott Rothstein and I ran a Ponzi scheme
in which we together committed many federal crimes and
state crimes and fabricated cases and committed bar
violations and were guilty of conspiracy and RICO, and
fraud and conspiracy to commit fraud.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
It reads like a federal indictment. And
there's no way to take pieces out of it that would
not injure somebody, because as a whole, this is
about as damaging to any lawyer's reputation as it
possibly could be, and it was intended to do that.
When I read back over it, I just remember
how unbelievably painful it was when I received it
and how I still feel today as a consequence of the
things that were put out there.
This is a criminal indictment against me.
That's what this is.
Q Can you point to the paragraphs, please,
that you just read through that contain the
inaccurate statements you just referred to?
A Start from the beginning.
Q So if I read the summary of the action,
tell me what's inaccurate about that. What's untrue
about the summary of the action, sir?
A These are statements that are consumed within
the counts at the back, which I'm part of every one of
those counts, so this applies to me. None of it is
true as it pertains to me.
Q I asked you to point out in the summary of
the action what is untrue. Can you take a look at
that and tell me --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Scott Rothstein aided by others. The clear
implication is that the others are me and
Q Does it say that there?
A It does. That's what a complaint is. It's
adopting everything into the count at back of this
complaint. The whole thing is about me.
Q It is? So is III. a lawyer?
A No. She's one of the females that

Mr. Epstein molested, and in this complaint alleges
that she wasn't molested and she was somehow
fabricating her claim against him.
Q Did III. authorize the 234-page complaint
we looked at that was Exhibit Number 7?
A Yes.
Q She authorized that filing?
A Yes.
Q So when I look at Summary of Action, first
sentence, it says, "Attorney Scott Rothstein aided by
other lawyers and employees at the firm" ... "for
personal greed enrichment."
Where does it talk about III. in there?
Does it?
A It's about me.
Q Well, you said you and III. When you said
how this impacts you, you said other lawyers like me
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
and III. That's what you said.

MR. SCAROLA: No.
THE WITNESS: That's not what I said.
That's fine.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Then I heard you wrong.
So in the Summary of Action, do you see
your name in there?
A My name is in the style of the case.
Q I know that, sir. I'm asking you about the
summary of the action.
A It speaks for itself. Whether my name is in
there generally or specifically, that's what this
complaint is talking about. And this complaint is
clearly designed to talk about me throughout the entire
case. Sometimes specifically, sometimes generally.
Q No question you're a defendant. And I'm
asking you what in the Summary of Action is an untrue
statement?
A Those things in the summary of the action, I
did not do.
Q I don't see that it says that you did in
the summary of the action.

MR. SCAROLA: Objection, argumentive.
THE WITNESS: It does. You can't just
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
take this piece. The whole complaint refers
to itself.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So can you point to a single sentence in
the Summary of Action that is an untrue statement?
A Sure.
Q Which one?
A All of it as it pertains to me.
Q Look at paragraph six. Can you tell me why
you denied being an employee, agent or associate or
partner, shareholder or other representative of RRA?
A You have my answer?
Q I do.
Take a look at Exhibit 10, which is the
answer and counterclaim of defendant Bradley
Edwards, which was date stamped December 21st, 2009,
and I believe it was filed with the clerk on the
17th of 2009. Okay?
A I think this would invade the attorney -client
privilege to tell you why.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 10 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q Why you denied --
A Yes.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q -- being a partner at RRA?
A Okay. I wasn't a partner at RRA, so that's
one reason.
Q So you weren't a partner at RRA?
A I was not.
Q So for the six months that you were
employed there, you did not hold yourself out as a
partner of the Rothstein firm; is that true?
A You are asking a different question. What
I'm saying is --
Q Okay.
A I don't understand the faces, but --
Q Let me start over. Did you hold yourself
out as a partner of the Rothstein law firm?
A This is something that we have gone over in
prior depositions. We are just rehashing what other
lawyers have asked me and I've explained this in
detail.

MR. SCAROLA: And because that is in
fact the case, and because that is clearly
outside the scope of the admitted areas of
inquiry for this deposition, I am going to
instruct Brad not to answer.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Were you an employee of the Rothstein firm?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

MR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same
instruction.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Were you an associate of the Rothstein
firm?

MR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same
instruction.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Did you get paid by the Rothstein firm for
the six months that you worked there?

MR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same
instruction.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Were you paid as a W-2 employee or a 1099
employee?

MR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same
instruction.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Did you have a website for Jeffrey (sic)
Edwards & Associates?

MR. SCAROLA: Did you mean that
question as you asked it?
MR. LINK: I think so.
MR. SCAROLA: No, I don't think so.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Your answer is no?

MR. GOLDBERGER: Change the first name.
MR. LINK: I'm sorry. You're right.
Thank you.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Did you have a website for Bradley Edwards
& Associates?
A I don't think so.
Q When you would sign letters while you were
at the Rothstein firm, did you ever sign as a partner
of that firm?

MR. SCAROLA: Same objection. Same
instruction.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Do you agree that it would have been
reasonable for a person who was not within the
Rothstein firm to conclude that you were a partner of
that firm?
MR. SCAROLA: Question calls for
speculation and is an incomplete
hypothetical.
THE WITNESS: I don't know what would
have been reasonable for somebody to infer
in terms of how anyone was paid or whether
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
they shared equity according to any title.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I am going to show you Plaintiff's Exhibit
Number 11.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 11 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q Can you tell us what Exhibit 11 is, please?
A It's a letter about depositions that were
already set by other plaintiff counsel and depositions
that we intended to take, in addition to those that
were already set.
Q What day is this letter?
A July 22nd, 2009.
Q Is it referencing any particular cases you
were working on.
A I don't see it, but it's representing it's
Epstein -- it's Epstein related.
Q Epstein related. All right. And how did
you sign that letter?
A Um.
Q What does the signature block say, sir?
A That's my signature, but --
Q What does the signature block say?
A Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler, Bradley J.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Edwards, Esquire, Partner for the Firm.
Q And who signed that letter for you?
A I don't know.
Q Take a look at Exhibit 12 and go to page
five, please.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 12 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q Exhibit 12 is the Rothstein Rosenfeldt
Adler Firm Directory Updated: October 23rd, 2009. Do
you see your name listed under Attorneys and Staff on
page five.
A Yes.
Q What is your title, sir?
A It says partner. I have never seen this
document before, but that's what it says.
Q Did you have an employment with the
Rothstein firm?
A Again, something else that has been asked in
previous depositions, but the answer, again, is no.
Q Take a look at Number 13.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 13 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q This is a May 22nd, 2009 email from Bradley
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
J. Edwards to somebody at the Palm Beach Post, right?
A It appears to be a writer, I'm assuming, at
the Palm Beach Post. I don't remember her.
Q So back in May 2009, you were corresponding
with a writer at the Palm Beach Post about the
lawsuit, Jane Doe versus United States of America?
A Yeah. I'm telling that person that the
non-prosecution agreement was released pursuant to
protective order, so I can't discuss the contents of
the non-prosecution agreement. I'm assuming that
reporter called asking about the contents.
Q What does the signature block say?
A I'm not contesting that the signature block
probably always said Bradley Edwards, Partner,
Rothstein Rosenfeldt Adler. I would guess everything
that was signed there probably said that.
Q So you held yourself out as a partner in
the law firm, true?
A What does partner mean between us? I mean, a
partner is an equity partner. In a business, I was
not, nor did I ever tell anybody that I was. Lawyers
in the law firm, all -- almost all went by either
partner or shareholder, with very few exceptions.
So partner was an informal title that
indicated I carried my caseload as opposed to I
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
worked on somebody else's cases.
I was never an equity partner. I never
acted like I was an equity partner. I never told
anyone I was an equity partner, which in the sense
of a business is what an actual partner is.
So that's the full and complete answer.
Did it say partner as opposed to just mere employee
or whatever else it would say? Yes, that's what it
said.
Q Did you ever clarify when you were having
conversations with these folks that you just
mentioned that you never said I'm an equity, I'm an
owner, so on and so forth; that you were simply an
employee of the firm?
A Sure. With anyone that I had these
discussions with, including Michael Pike, who was one
of Mr. Epstein's lawyers. We talked about the
arrangement there, and including whether he would want
to come over to RRA at some point in time.
Q Tell me what you told him about the
arrangement there and why he might want to come over?
A It's a good law firm. It's a good law firm.
You get a lot of help. There's sufficient staff. You
will like it. You don't have to represent pedophiles.
You can actually be on the other side of the cases.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
And at the time I didn't think that he was a bad guy,
and he -- and we had those types of conversations.
Q And you said to him, they will give you the
title partner but it doesn't really mean you're a
partner, but you get to hold yourself out to the
public as though you're a partner? Did you talk to
him about?
A Nobody says that.
Q The conversation you had with Mr. Pike must
have been before the lawsuit was filed against you in
December.
A I said it was while I was at RRA, which was
before the lawsuit was filed against me in December.
Q Now, if you would, please, turn to page --
A Which exhibit are we looking at?
Q Huh?
A Which exhibit?
Q We are on Exhibit 9, the complaint, which
you said the entire thing has caused damage to your
reputation, right? And did it --
Let's back up for a second. When did you
receive a copy of this complaint?
A I don't remember.
Q Were you personally served with it?
A Yes.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Where were you served at?
A I believe at a restaurant.
Q Which restaurant?
A I don't remember.
Q How many times have you been served by --
have you been served with a complaint?
A This is the only one that's memorable to me.
But we talked about a complaint previously.
Q Talked about several.
A I presume that I was served. I don't
remember being served, but I'm sure there's a
certificate of service where I was. Or if there was
substitute service at a law firm or something else,
that's possible too.
This complaint, though, I remember that I
was personally served. I am not sure exactly where
I was.
Q
the 7th?
A Your guess is as good as mine on that.
Q If you look at the counterclaim that was
prepared, do you remember when you started drafting
that?
Were you served on the 7th or was it after
A No.
Q How long after you received a copy of the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
complaint that was filed on December 7th did you
start drafting the counterclaim?
If we're looking at the counterclaim -- do
you have that in front of you? I believe that's
Exhibit Number --

MR. SCAROLA: I don't know that it was
marked.
MR. LINK: Did we not mark it?
THE WITNESS: Yeah, it's 10.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So we're looking at Exhibit Number 10 --
let me back up. Did you draft the counterclaim
that's attached to the answer?
A No.
Q Who did?
A I don't know.
Q Mr. Scarola's office?
A Yes.
Q So Mr. Scarola's office drafted an abuse of
process counterclaim based on the filing of a
complaint? Is that true?
A It appears that way. I mean, the document
speaks for itself. There's a signature for that
office, so it looks like that's what happened. I only
know what you are knowing right now.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Do you remember earlier you told me about
how much time you had to spend on this doing the
legal work because you were the one who knew and that
you were the one doing the drafting, not Mr. Scarola
or his firm?

MR. SCAROLA: That's an inaccurate
representation of the earlier testimony.
THE WITNESS: The record will speak for
itself just how badly you just bastardize
what I just said.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So this counterclaim that was filed, you
didn't draft it. Did you approve it before it was
filed?
A I'm sure.
Q Had there been any other pleadings or
anything done since December 7th and when this
counterclaim was prepared?
A Your question is had there been anything
done --
Q In this lawsuit --
A Oh, in this suit.
Q -- that you sued for abuse of process,
other than the filing of the complaint? Anything
else happen? Any other papers filed? Anything take
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
place?
A Did anything happen? Did anything take
place? Or were any papers filed?
Q Yeah. All the above.
A Which one is your question?
Q All of the above.
A I'm sure things happened.

MR. SCAROLA: Objection, compound.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Okay, what happened?
A You want me to recall what I did every day
between December 7th and December 21st?
Q No, sir. I want you to tell me what was
the abuse of process. What took place after the
complaint was filed to justify this counterclaim.

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Can you tell
me where within the Court's defined area of
inquiry those questions fall?

MR. LINK: Uh-huh. I can.
MR. SCAROLA: Where?
MR. LINK: Probable cause and damages.
MR. SCAROLA: Filing of the federal
lawsuit, interaction with Rothstein and
knowledge of the Ponzi scheme, $14 million
bond --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

MR. LINK: That's your reading of it,
not mine. I sent you an entire email with
all of the Court's statements about starting
over --

MR. SCAROLA: I read every one.
MR. LINK: -- and probable cause --
MR. SCAROLA: I read every one --
MR. LINK: -- and damages --

MR. SCAROLA: You're wrong.
MR. LINK: And this relates to damages.
MR. SCAROLA: How does it relate to
damages?

MR. LINK: Because he's claiming
damages in this lawsuit. And he is seeking
damages from when he filed this. And I want
to find out what his damages were.

MR. SCAROLA: He's seeking damages from
the point at which he was maliciously named
in a false and fraudulent claim by a serial
pedophile.

MR. LINK: Good statement. I'm sure
the jury will enjoy that.
But for my purposes and today, are you
instructing him not to answer?

MR. SCAROLA: Yes.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So, are the damages you are seeking in this
case related to the complaint that was filed on
December 7th, 2009?
A They are related yes, they were proximally
caused by the complaint.
Q This is the complaint we're talking about,
right?
A Yes.
Q December 7, 2009.
A Yep.
Q And now we are looking at your answer and
the counterclaim to that complaint, right?
A Okay.
Q And through the counterclaim is how you
seek damages, isn't it, sir?
A I don't think this is the operative
counterclaim. Do you?
Q I didn't say it was the one operative
today. It's the one that you filed as soon as you
received the lawsuit in less than 14 days.
A Your statement is the counterclaim that we
are looking at is the one through which you are seeking
damages?
Q Yeah. When you first filed the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
counterclaim you sought damages, correct?

MR. SCAROLA: This is an abuse of
process counterclaim.
MR. LINK: I know. And I am trying to
find out what the damages are.

MR. SCAROLA: The case that is being
prosecuted currently is a malicious
prosecution claim that relates back to the
December 7th, 2009 case.
As you are well aware, a malicious
prosecution claim cannot be filed until the
underlying action has been disposed of in
favor of Mr. Edwards.

MR. LINK: I actually thought that was
true, but you didn't wait that long. I do
agree with that statement. You're right.
But this is the pleading that was filed
that seeks damages, and it is the response
to the complaint.
If you won't let me ask him questions
about it, then instruct him not to answer
and we will go see what Judge Hafele says.

MR. SCAROLA: Well, let me hear what
the question is.
MR. LINK: I just asked it.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

MR. SCAROLA: So far you haven't asked
one that I'm going to let him answer.
MR. LINK: That's fine.
BY MR. LINK:
Q What were your damages, sir -- what were
your damages on December 21st, 2009?
A It was the same types of damages that I am
claiming now, in that the complaint that was filed
against me was -- and it was intentionally designed to
link me to Scott Rothstein, who at that moment was the
most hated person in South Florida. And link me to him
in a way that was as if Scott Rothstein and I together
were running this Ponzi scheme.
And he did it -- Jeffrey Epstein did this
at a time when everyone -- everyone -- not
locally -- and as you said, nationally -- was paying
attention to the story, so as to cause the most
damage possible.
Since that point in time, those damages
have continued to increase. But they began right
from the time that this was filed. So whatever
damages, whatever cause of damage that I was seeking
back then, it's the same thing as now.
Q I got it. So it's the filing of the
complaint that caused damages, not it's being
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
disseminated? Is that right?
A Well, the filing of the complaint and the
consequences of that filing, which included the
dissemination of the information contained within that
complaint.
Q I understand that. Can you tell me,
please, one piece of information that was
disseminated publicly in newspaper, in articles,
somewhere before December 17th, when the counterclaim
was filed with the clerk? Tell me one public
document, news story, anything, discussing

Mr. Epstein's complaint against you.
A The complaint. That's public.
Q I understand.
A Okay. There it is.
Q Who saw it? Didn't somebody have to see
it? It's like if a tree falls it doesn't matter --
in the woods -- and nobody hears it.
What I'm asking you is, who saw it? Who
read it?
A The Epstein complaint was also a highly
publicized case, so then he makes this filing at this
time.
Q Right. I got that. My question is simple.
Who was it disseminate to, other than the court,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
before December 17th when the counterclaim was filed?
A You are going to have to tell me.
Q Do you know one person it was disseminated
to that caused damage before you sued Mr. Epstein on
your counterclaim?
A Well, yeah.
Q Who?
A It was disseminated to whoever received a
copy of the complaint. I mean, how do I know who your
team -- I know we are through many lawyers now -- who
your team disseminated it to and who was getting
information about this.
Q I'm trying to understand. If your
reputation --
MR. SCAROLA: I'm sorry. You're
interrupting Mr. Edwards.
BY MR. LINK:
Q I thought you were done. My apologies.
A And at the time when it was filed against me,
the purpose also was to sidetrack me from the
prosecution of his cases -- the cases that I was
pursuing against him -- basically to extort me into
abandoning the legitimate cases that I was handling
against him, to inconvenience me, take my time away,
and make me have to deal with this complaint that I was
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
now being served with by Mr. Epstein.
Q Did I interrupt you?
A No. I will finish right there.
Q Good. I didn't want to interrupt you.
So, are you telling this jury that the
three clients that you represented, the settlements
that you obtained for them were somehow impacted by
your inability to fulfill your professional
obligations as a result of this counterclaim -- this
lawsuit being filed against you?
A No. I'm telling you that's what Jeffrey
Epstein wanted to happen, but I didn't let happen.
Q He failed; is that right?
A Look at the numbers. He said it was a
fabricated case. He paid millions of dollars for these
allegedly fabricated cases. It was all a big, fat lie
that he put in that complaint, which the jury is going
to get to hear about.
Q So his intent was to shut you down and make
you not settle the cases, or to somehow give them
away. He failed, because you, on behalf of your
clients, got every single penny they deserved, didn't
you?
A I did well for them.
Q You wouldn't have settled them if you
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
didn't believe you had reasonable settlements for
them, would you?
A It was not my choice to settle the cases. It
was my clients' choice.
Q Of course.
A So you say I wouldn't have settled them.
Look, I would have rather tried all three of them, to
tell you the truth.
Q Of course. I know that now.
But you settled those three cases. And as
a member of this bar, you did not believe that your
representation was somehow impacted by the filing of
this complaint, did you?

MR. SCAROLA: Objection, compound.
THE WITNESS: Thank goodness that Jack
was there to help me defend against that
lawsuit, otherwise, Mr. Epstein could have
been successful.
BY MR. LINK:
Q But he wasn't, was he?
A We made sure that my representation of my
clients was not compromised because of his attempt to
destroy my reputation.
Q And that's what I was asking.
A I did a pretty good job with that.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q You fulfilled your professional
responsibilities and obligations to your client and
negotiated fair settlements for them, right?
A I believe so.
Q Good.
And focusing on this window of when you
are sued and when the counterclaim is filed, do you
know of any press that ran a story about the Epstein
lawsuit against Rothstein and Brad Edwards?
A And what I was getting at before answering
this question is, even when you were asking me
questions about the press and the timing of the press
with respect to the Ponzi scheme, I don't remember the
chronology of any of the press or any of the news on
any of these things.
I would have to look and see what was out
there at that time to be able to answer that
question. I just don't remember.
Q Have you sought press from December 2009
forward about your litigation with Mr. Epstein?
A If you could show me something to refresh my
recollection, I will try to answer that question. I
would do anything possible to mitigate the damage that

Mr. Epstein tried to cause. If the opportunity arose
and I thought the press could assist me in that
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
endeavor I would do it. Did it do it? I don't
remember doing it.
Q You don't remember having communication
with the press about your litigation with

Mr. Epstein?
MR. SCAROLA: Which litigation are we
talking about? Are we talking about
Mr. Epstein --
MR. LINK: His -- his litigation.

MR. SCAROLA: Yes. I understand that.
But he had -- he had litigation against
Mr. Epstein in which he was representing
clients. He also had litigation with

Mr. Epstein in which Mr. Epstein was suing
him. He also had litigation with
Mr. Epstein in which he was suing

Mr. Epstein. So the question -- so the
question is vague and ambiguous because we
don't know what lawsuit you are talking
about.
BY MR. LINK:
Q We have been talking about the Epstein
versus Rothstein and Edwards lawsuit, right, in this
deposition?
So I'm talking about Epstein versus
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Rothstein and Edwards. And in the counterclaim by
Brad Edwards against Mr. Epstein, I'm asking you if
you've ever gone to the press or talked to the press
about that lawsuit and counterclaim.
A Those are two different questions. I would
say that the answer to the first question, did I go to
the press
Q Uh-huh.
A -- I believe with great certainty that's not
true. Did I --
Q You don't recall issuing any press releases
about the litigation?
A At any point in time? Even with
Q Well, after it was filed, December 7th,
2009.
A I don't remember issuing a press release.
But thinking back on it, when the case was dismissed
against me, that seems like an opportune time to
release a press release in order to mitigate the
damages that were being caused.
If I didn't, I wish I had. But I don't
remember doing that.
Did I ever speak to somebody from the
press who called me about it? I would if I believed
that it would mitigate the damages. I don't
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
remember a specific conversation like that.
Q Well, the lawsuit Mr. Epstein filed against
you was dismissed in 2012.
A Three years later.
Q 2012, okay.
And I asked you earlier if the dismissal
of that lawsuit stopped the damages that you are
claiming, and you said, No, it carries all the way
on to today. You remember telling me that?
A It carries on until a jury decides otherwise,
decides that these things against me were untrue and
hurtful.
Q What I have been asking you is, you filed a
counterclaim on December 15th, 10 days after the
lawsuit was filed. And I am trying --
A I think that's 14. 7th to the 21st.
Q The 17th is when it's filed. The 21st is
when it's stamped.
A Oh, it is. Okay.
Q Whether it's the 17th or the 21st
A Okay.
Q One's 10, one's 14th, right?
A Yeah. Very soon after.
Q Had you been contacted by the press during
that 10-to-14-day window to ask you questions about
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Mr. Epstein's lawsuit against you?
A I just don't remember anymore.
Q Did you have any damages -- any damages --
real damages on the 17th or the 21st of December 2009
related to the December 7th lawsuit Mr. Epstein
filed?
A Of course.
Q What were they?
A I was just linked with the biggest Ponzi
schemer in history as his primary co-conspirator. The
only lawyer in the whole law firm singled out by
Jeffrey Epstein in a complaint as being the
co-mastermind of a Ponzi scheme. It's filed in the
local community.
Every day my reputation is being tarnished
by that. That's going to be patently obvious to
anybody who sees this situation.
To you right now, you know this. That's a
complaint that's harmful. You read this and you go,
there's a criminal indictment basically against me
in the legal community that links me with the most
hated person in South Florida right now.
So the feeling that you get when you read
that is, I know that this is really, really, really
bad. There's only one way to come back from this,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
and that's to prove that this is false. That's why
we are here still.
Q Only one way to come back from this you
said. Come back from what? Your career has been
more successful than ever since this lawsuit was
filed, right?
A Well, this kind of goes back to before. The
people who really know me and know the outstanding work
that I do for clients and see -- I'm a successful
lawyer in that way.
The people who don't know me, the
9 million people who read this who won't call me,
that don't want to have anything to do with
me because of this association, and this being what
they remember from that period of time and my
relationship to that period of time. There's only
one way to do this.
Q So you're really bothered that 9 million
people haven't called you? You just said these
9 million people aren't going to call you. Do you
think they were going to call you before the Epstein
suit?
A The only thing that matters to you is not
your reputation amongst your best friends. It's your
reputation in the community as a lawyer.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Yes, it's general people. I care about
people. And I care about what people think about
me. The truth, not some false indictment against
me.
Q Who do you think Mr. Epstein hurt more from
a financial standpoint and from a pain and suffering
and anxiety standpoint, you or the three clients that
you were representing while you were at the Rothstein
firm? Who's more the victim here? You or those
three folks, sir?
A It's tough put me up against -- it's not just
those three victims. It's the hundreds and hundreds of
little girls that he's molested over the years. I
mean, that's what he does on a day-to-day basis.
That's what he's still doing, I'm sure.
So hurting people is something that he
will do in any way, shape or form. But the fact is,
he tried to hurt me in a way so that he could
continue to hurt others and not have me call him out
on it.
Who's hurt more?
Q Yeah.
A It's different ways. He hurt my reputation
more, because I had more of a reputation in the
community. He hurt them more physically and
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
emotionally and has caused, you know, certain lives to
be destroyed.
I think I'm a stronger person than some of
them. I was older. I wasn't a 14-year -old little
girl. It's just very hard. You're comparing apples
and oranges. We have all been hurt to the maximum
degree possible. And that's always been his intent.
Q So let's go back to 2009 and '10, and have
you focus on my question. That was a good speech,
and I appreciate that. But I asked you whether the
three folks you represented -- not these hundreds
that you didn't represent or these thousands that you
think exist, or whatever you think Mr. Epstein is
doing today. You represented three individuals,
correct?
A Yes. At that time, yes.
Q At that time.
A Yes.
Q And you settled all three of their
lawsuits, right?
A I did. They settled their lawsuits, yes.
Q You were their lawyer, weren't you?
A I was. But I don't want you to make it seem
like I chose to settle their lawsuits. My clients
choose what they're going to do. They settled their
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
lawsuits. I was their lawyer, yes.
Q So you were their lawyer. You told me they
were really good lawsuits. You were proud of the job
you did, right? Isn't that what you told me?
A I was proud of the job that I did, yes.
Q Good. So I'm asking about those three
people and the harm that you believe Mr. Epstein
inflicted on those three people that you represented.
Do you think, sir, that the harm he inflicted on you
is more or less than the harm he inflicted on those
three individuals that you just told us about.

MR. SCAROLA: That question has been
asked and answered in great detail.
THE WITNESS: The best way for us to
get the answer to that question is, in this
trial we can try each one of those cases and
let the jury determine what amount of
damages fairly and fully compensates each
one of us for the harm he's cause, and we
will have our answer who was harmed worse.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Well, is that what your intent is in this
case, is
A No, I'm trying to answer your question.
Q -- to try the clients' cases that you
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
settled?
A No. No. I'm just trying to play into your
sociological experiment that you are trying to ask me
about.
Q I was just asking you to tell me
A If I were a juror?
Q No, sir, you, as the plaintiff in this
case. If you believe that the harm inflicted on you
by Mr. Epstein by filing his complaint in
December 2009 causes you more anxiety and suffering
than whatever he did to the three folks you
represented?

MR. SCAROLA: And that question is
argumentive. It's not reasonably calculated
to lead to the discovery of admissible
evidence. It's the fourth time you have
asked it. It's been answered. I will
instruct you not to answer again.
BY MR. LINK:
Q When Mr. Epstein filed his complaint
against you in December 2009, did he issue a press
release?
A Other than to take the Fifth, he doesn't say
anything.
Q So my question was, did he issue a press
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
release? I know you like to keep telling your story
as a trial lawyer, but my question was, did he issue
a press release?

MR. SCAROLA: Objection to the form of
the question.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Did he?
MR. SCAROLA: It's argumentive.
THE WITNESS: You tell me whether he
issued a press release. He's your client.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So you don't know whether Mr. Epstein
issued a press release related to the lawsuit he
filed against you that you are seeking damages for?
A If he did issue a press release, I did not
personally see it. If you are going to show me a press
release, then I'm not going to debate you with it.
Q You ever file any papers in federal court
that were devoid of factual support?
A What does that mean?
Q Have you ever filed any papers against

Mr. Epstein that were determined to be devoid of
factual support?
A What are we looking at?
Q Just asking you that question, sir.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Oh, in my life? Up to today, or are we going
back to 2009? I'm confused what time period we are on.
Q 2009.

MR. SCAROLA: The first question wasn't
limited to Epstein. The next time the
question was asked, it was limited to
Epstein.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Let me ask it again. Was there ever any
time that you filed a federal court paper, motion,
pleading related to a case with Mr. Epstein that it
was determined to be devoid of factual support?
A Not that I recall.
Q You remember filing a petition to have

Mr. Epstein post a bond while you were working at the
Rothstein firm?
A Yeah, I remember that motion.
Q Did you sign that motion?
A Let me see.
Q Do you remember if you signed that motion?
A No. But I remember --
Q Do you remember the court's ruling on the
motion?
A It was denied.
Q Do you remember the Court making any
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
specific findings about your factual basis for
bringing the motion?
A I don't. But it was I believe that the
court denied it because prejudgment, you can't freeze
assets.
Q Did you have any evidence before you filed
that motion that Mr. Epstein was transferring his
assets offshore?
A Yeah, I had many sources during this
investigation. And we had significant evidence that
the way in which -- the way -- what we should fear is
that we would get a judgment and there would be no
money in his name, and that the money would have been
transferred offshore.
Q Who is the source that told you,
specifically at the time you filed the federal court
pleadings, that Mr. Epstein was, in fact,
transferring every dollar that he had offshore, so
there would be nothing left to pay the plaintiffs you
represented? Who was that?
MR. SCAROLA: Objection, work product.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Was it something you relied on in filing
the federal court action under your Rule 11
obligations?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A It's not something that I relied on in filing
this case.
Q No, sir. I'm not talking about that. I'm
talking about the federal court case where you sought
a bond in which you still have Rule 11 obligations.
Right?
A Right.
Q And before you file something in federal
court, you have to have a factual evidentiary basis
to do so, correct?
A Correct.
Q I'm asking you what was your factual
evidentiary basis for seeking the relief that you
sought on the bond motion.
A I had numerous sources. I had numerous
sources, and numerous sources that was (sic) shared
amongst plaintiff's counsel on the case.
Q I don't want to know about sources. I want
to know about evidence. Evidence is not protected.
You have to submit it to the court.
I'm not looking for your confidential
sources. I want to know what evidence you had, sir.
A Well, we knew that there were cars, boats,
houses that were placed in Larry Visoski's name.
That's some evidence that we had.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Uh-huh.
A And other than that, we had individuals who
were familiar with Mr. Epstein and knew him some of
which had known him for many years -- to provide us
good information that that's what he was doing.
Q And they were going to get on the stand and
testify.
A Would they have testified to that if
subpoenaed and on the stand? Yes.
Q Is there a reason you didn't get affidavits
from these folks to support your petition, if they
would have testified?
A Yes, there is.
Q What was the reason?
A This is also work-product privilege
information.
Q Let's take a look at Plaintiff's Exhibit
Number 14.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 14 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q So we are on Exhibit Number 14, which is
United States District Court for the Southern
District of Florida. And if you go to page four of
this exhibit, you will find the motion for injunction
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
to restrain fraudulent transfer of assets. You see
that?
A Yes.
Q First, let's take a look at the last page.
A Of this exhibit or of the motion?
Q Of the motion.
A Which is page 21 of the exhibit.
Q I think it's page 19 of 41 at the top,
right?
A Okay.
Q You see that's an electronic signature,
right?
A Yes. This is what typically was on -- the
electronic signature that we would use when I would
authorize filings. That's what I was talking about
earlier.
Q And you see this one includes Paul Cassell,
right?
A Yeah, I do.
Q Now, let's go back to page four of 41.
A He drafted this motion, so I know
Q He drafted it?
A Yeah.
Q But you put your name on it and filed this,
right?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Of course. And I agreed with it.
Q So let's take a look. This motion was on
behalf of plaintiff Jane Doe?
A Right.
Q And you represented Jane Doe
A Yes.
Q -- while you were at Mr. Rothstein's firm.
And this was filed while you were at Mr. Rothstein's
firm, right?
A It was.
Q Look at the first paragraph on page five.
It says, "Epstein is a billionaire, who recently has
been fraudulently transferring his assets overseas."
Do you see that?
A Yes.
Q What evidence -- admissible evidence -- did
you have of that statement before you made it in this
pleading?
A I had information that he was doing this from
sources, including sources close to him. I had
evidence that he had placed significant assets into at
least one other person's name, as well as properties
that were placed in the names of corporations or other
companies, as I remember, that was already going to
make it difficult on the collection end.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q So what I'm asking is about your statement
here, sir, which is, that I would like to know the
evidence that you had that he was fraudulently
transferring his assets overseas. What evidence do
you have -- or did you have at the time?

MR. SCAROLA: That's the question that
was just asked and just answered.
MR. LINK: He didn't answer it.
MR. SCAROLA: I disagree with you.

MR. LINK: Okay.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Will you answer the question for me
specifically on transferring his assets overseas?
You told me about titling them, you told me about
things, but you didn't tell me about the evidence for
transferring his assets overseas.
A I told you that we had a very good source of
information that had given us this information that was
a longtime associate of Mr. Epstein's.

MR. SCAROLA: Are you disregarding the
affidavit attached to the motion? Are you
asking for information apart from the
affidavit attached to the motion?

MR. LINK: I'm asking what evidence he
had of this happening.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
MR. SCAROLA: But there's an affidavit
attached to the motion.

MR. LINK: I know there is, and it
doesn't answer this question.
MR. SCAROLA: Well, respectfully, I
disagree.

MR. LINK: Okay. We disagree a lot
today. It's okay.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Scarola wants you to look at the
affidavit. Who signed the affidavit?

MR. SCAROLA: Mr. Scarola wants to know
whether your question is excluding the
affidavit.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Take a look at the affidavit and tell me
who signed it.
A Paul Cassell.
Q And he's a lawyer, right?
A Yes, he's a lawyer.
Q And he's a lawyer involved in this case,
right?
A He was a lawyer --
Q Was he going to get on the stand as the
lawyer involved in this case and testify about
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
personal knowledge that Mr. Epstein transferred
assets overseas? Was he going to do that?

MR. SCAROLA: Was he going to do that
in this case?
BY MR. LINK:
Q Was he going to do it then?
A You will have to take Mr. Cassell's
deposition and ask him that question.
Q So did you have -- did you and Mr. Cassell,
when you filed this injunction paper in federal
court, have evidence -- not sources -- I mean you
were a prosecutor. You know the difference between
sources and evidence, right?
There's lots of information out there.
Doesn't mean we get it in evidence, right? You know
that, as a trial lawyer.
A Okay.
Q You agree with me?
A I agree with you.
Q What evidence did you have?
MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. May he finish
the answer to the question that you asked
before you ask the next question?
THE WITNESS: This case was a little
different than most in this sense. If I get
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
information in a case, such as this, I can
then take Mr. Epstein's deposition and say,
Is it true that you are transferring assets
here, there and everywhere? And if he tells
me the truth, he's going to tell me, Yes,
and then I will have that evidence.
He restricted our ability to gain
evidence on many subjects, not only by
claiming the Fifth himself, but having his
co-conspirators claim the Fifth, and then
having the next tier of associates show up
with lawyers who were paid by him, which
restricted our ability to gain the
testimonial evidence that we would need to
support many of our -- many of the things
that we knew about the case.
In this case, on this particular
subject, we had good sources, reliable
sources. And as this affidavit indicates,
other plaintiff lawyers and I -- speaking on
behalf of Paul Cassell -- have been greatly
concerned that Epstein might attempt to
transfer many of these assets overseas with
the intent to defeat any judgment.
This was one of the topics -- one of
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
the many topics that, amongst plaintiffs'
counsel, we discussed as the way in which
Epstein intended to ultimately defeat these
cases, which would ultimately prove his
serial sexual molestation of minors.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So is your concern something that's
evidence?
A And we had a source telling us our concern
was true.
Q I understand.
A Okay, so --
Q I have heard about the source. I am asking
you about evidence. You told me you had concerns.
Okay, I don't know that a federal judge cares about
your personal concerns. I doubt that a federal judge
cares that you have a source who won't get on the
stand.
So whenever I have filed a motion for
injunction, I intend to put evidence on in front of
the court. And I'm asking you, sir, what evidence
did you have in this federal proceeding to prove
your statement that Mr. Epstein was fraudulently
transferring his assets overseas?

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I'm going to
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
object to Counsel's speech about Counsel's
experience. Move that it be stricken.
And the question as to what evidence
did Mr. Edwards have

MR. LINK: Yes.
MR. SCAROLA: -- is a question that has
been asked and answered repeatedly.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So would you agree you had no admissible
evidence at the time that you filed this pleading?
A Hold on one second. So --
Q Yes, sir.
A -- this is evidence.
Q What is it?
A In request for admission I asked

Mr. Epstein
Q Yes.
A -- admit you are moving financial assets
overseas outside of the direct territorial reach of the
US and Florida courts.
Question 22, you were making asset
transfers with the intent to defeat any judgment
that might be entered against you in this case or
similar cases.
Twenty-three, do you currently have the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
ability to post a $15 million bond to satisfy a
judgment in this case without financial or other
difficulty?
Q Uh-huh.
A If he told the truth, he would have said yes.
And that is what the adverse inference requirement
allows for us to draw when he says in response to those
direct requests for admissions that he's invoking his
Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination, which
is tantamount to an admission. So that is evidence.
Q Okay. So you think that the adverse
inference
A That's going to happen in this case, too.
Q Hang on. Let me just make sure I
understand.
You thought when you filed this that
having an adverse inference to a question --
whatever question you asked -- because he raised the
Fifth, makes it an admission? That's your
understanding of an adverse inference in federal
court?
A I had an admission by Mr. Epstein in response
to his question.
Q That was it? You told me he pled the Fifth
and didn't answer. All I'm asking is, was it your
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
belief that at the time in federal court that an
adverse inference based on raising a Fifth Amendment
privilege is an admission of your question?
A If his answer to that --

MR. SCAROLA: I'm sorry. The question
about what Mr. Edwards' belief was is
clearly a question that invades the
work-product privilege.

MR. LINK: Okay. Fair enough.
BY MR. LINK:
Q But the only evidence you had that you can
point to was your asking Mr. Epstein a question that
he raised his constitutional privilege to and that
you considered that an admission for purposes of
federal court?
MR. SCAROLA: Pardon me. That's
compound. You can ask him what the evidence
was. You cannot ask him what he considered.
What he considered is an operation of his
mind, and that is protected work product.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Do you remember on September 29, 2009,
writing a memo saying it would be really nice if we
can find evidence of a transfer?
A Show it to me. I will see it.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 15 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q Take a look at Exhibit 15. This is an
email from Mr. Edwards to Ken Jenne. You remember
you told me earlier you weren't sure if Ken Jenne,
who was the sheriff that had criminal issues, worked
on the Epstein matter. You see his name there?
A Yes.
Q Who is Elizabeth Villar?
A I don't remember her.
Q Was she an investigator?
A No. I don't think that there
investigators that I remember.
So this is on the subject of forensics.
Q Yep. Do you see the sentence that says,
"We need to be able to file a supplement to his
were any female
response, and it will be great to put in evidence of
a transfer."
So that you wanted to get a forensic
report done at that time and were having trouble
do you remember this -- you were having trouble
getting the funding necessary to pay the forensic
person to determine if there had been any transfers
of assets?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A That's not true, the statement that you just
made, having trouble getting the --
Q Okay. That statement that I just made is
untrue and not supported by the files that have been
produced in this case? Is that your testimony?
A Right. You are basically implying that the
Josefsberg firm and the Searcy firm -- and nobody could
come up with money to do this.
This is clearly talking about the checks
that were coming from the other plaintiff's lawyers
for the purposes of hiring the forensic accountant.
Q Did Mr. Searcy -- did Mr. Scarola sign this
injunction paper?
A No. But now you're talking about two
different things.
Q Did Mr. Josefsberg sign this paper?
A You are talking about different things.
Q I'm asking you did they sign it.
A You tell me. Did they sign it?
Q I don't see it.
A Okay, then they didn't.
Q Did Mr. Scarola in his case file a federal
injunction seeking a bond?
A No. I did the work.
Q Did Mr. Josefsberg?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
You did the work -- this is for

Mr. Scarola's case?
A No, but -- yes, the cases --
Q This is one of Mr. Scarola's cases?
A The cases were combined.
Q Let's look at the style. I just want to
make sure I understand this.
This motion you filed was to benefit
Mr. Scarola's client; is that right?
A No. What I'm saying is it was filed in Jane
Doe No. 2, Jane Doe No. 3, Jane Doe No. 4, Jane Doe No.
5, Jane Doe No. 6, Jane Doe No. 7, C.M.A., Jane Doe,
Doe No. 2, Doe No. 101, Doe No. 102.
So there was a motion filed in that case,
filed by me. This was work that was done by me to
freeze Mr. Epstein's money so that he could not move
assets out of the country and defeat any judgment
that I was to obtain.
Q For your client, right?
A Right.
Q Mr. Scarola even filed a federal court
action on behalf of his client?
A No. You're showing me this email that's
talking about -- an email that I sent about other
firms' checks that relate to the forensic accountant.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
That's why I'm telling you, you're talking about
different things here.
Q This says right here, right, "Epstein has
to respond to the Judge as to why he's taking the
Fifth on all asset transfer questions."
You just read me asset transfer questions,
true?
A And if -- and if his answer to those
questions was no, that obviously wouldn't incriminate
him. He's not moving money overseas, okay, it doesn't
incriminate him. So clearly the answer was going to
incriminate him.
Now it looks like -- I'm saying -- the
Judge is going to make him respond as to why.
What we need is to file a supplement. It
would be great to have evidence of the transfer --
Q I agree --
A -- to file with our supplement.
Q -- it would have been great.
Did you have any evidence of the transfer?
It's what I've been asking for.
A We didn't have evidence that we could use at
that time to support the transfer. What we had was a
really good source, and we had evidence that Epstein's
invocation of the Fifth was evidence that he had indeed
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
done those things.
Q Is there any part of Rule 11 that says that
you do not have to have an evidentiary support for
your filings because a witness takes the Fifth
Amendment?

MR. SCAROLA: You know -- you know that
Rule 11 requires a good faith basis.
MR. LINK: I do.
MR. SCAROLA: It does not require that
you have evidence in your possession at the
time of the filing.
Complaints are filed on the basis of
good faith with a view towards obtaining
evidence all the time.

MR. LINK: And that's okay.
MR. SCAROLA: That's okay, as long as
there's a good faith basis.
MR. LINK: I agree with that.

MR. SCAROLA: So you are talking about
apples and oranges. You don't have to have
evidence for filing.
MR. LINK: This isn't a complaint.
This is a motion for injunction, which is
not --

MR. SCAROLA: You do not have to have
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
evidence at the time of the filing of the
motion. You have to have a good faith
belief that it's well-founded.

MR. LINK: Okay.
MR. SCAROLA: But you're arguing and my
arguing about what about Rule 11 has to do
with these pleadings has nothing to do with
any of these issues in this lawsuit. But it
has a lot to do with wasting time in this
fourth section of Mr. Edward's deposition
the fourth and last session of Mr. Edward's
deposition.
MR. LINK: I think it's really most of
the first session, but that's okay. I
understand your position.
BY MR. LINK:
Q All right, so let me just wrap this up real
quick. All these Jane Does on here that you
mentioned, Mr. Scarola, did he have any clients in
this federal case that you are aware of?
A I think he represented C.M.A. Although, you
shake your head no, so maybe you know information that
I don't. If you are telling me the truth, I will
believe you.
Q I'm not telling you anything, sir.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A You are shaking your head.
Q Did Mr. Scarola have one of these Jane Doe
clients?
A You can't ask the question, then shake your
head, which indicates an answer no, and then ask me to
answer the question.
If you're telling me the answer is no, I
will agree with you. I assume you're telling me the
truth.
Q I'm not telling you any answer, sir.
That's your job.
A Why are you still shaking your head? Still.
Right now you are still shaking your head.
Q Maybe I have some kind of a twitch in my
neck. I don't know.
A So do know the answer to the question?
Q I'm not here to answer the question, sir.
A I don't know.
Q Did Mr. Josefsberg have any plaintiffs in
this federal action?
A I believe so.
Q Did Mr. Josefsberg authorize you to file
the motion for injunction on his behalf -- of his
clients?
A He knew that it was being filed.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q You can file whatever you want for your
clients. I get that.
Did Mr. Josefsberg authorize you to file
this motion on behalf of his clients?
A No. That's not how we worked.
Q All right. Take a look, if you would,
please, at Exhibit Number 16.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 16 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q Is my head still shaking no or --
A No, it's not. It's still now.
Q Okay. Good.
This is the order that the court entered
on the motion for injunction, true -- see Judge
Marra -- November 5th, 2009?
A Yeah.
Q And I want you look on page three. Do you
see where it says, "Plaintiff's motion"
A I'm going to read it. I will get there.
Q Okay.
A Yeah.
Q Do you see where the federal district court
judge says, "Plaintiff's motion is entirely devoid of
evidence of defendants alleged fraudulent transfers"?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
You see the court's statement?
A Yes. I'm just reading it in the context of
the rest of the order.
Q Is there something in the context of the
order that changes the court's words that the motion
that you and Mr. Cassell filed was entirely devoid of
evidence of Mr. Epstein's alleged fraudulent
transfers?
A No. I see that that is what the court says.
And also in light of the defendant being a billionaire,
the various retitling of vehicles in the view of the
court was de minimis in relativity.
So, yeah -- and there's a long string --
cite of cases indicating that prejudgment relief of
this type is not easy to obtain.
Q Mr. Edwards, I'm handing you what we just
marked as Exhibit 17, which is the Fourth Amended
Counterclaim that you filed against Mr. Epstein,
correct?
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 17 was marked
for identification.)
THE WITNESS: It appears like that's
what this is.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Would you take a look, please -- and this
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
is the operative pleading? Do you know?
A Are we on the fourth amended -- I don't know.
Are we on the fourth amended counterclaim? Not sure.
Q Not sure. Okay.
A I don't think so. Well, I only say that
because count one is abuse of process. I don't know
that we have an abuse of process in this case still
left. I thought it was only malicious prosecution. I
could be wrong.
Q Let's take a look at paragraph five. This
was filed on January 9th, 2013. Do you see that, the
Fourth Amended Counterclaim?
A Paragraph five?
Q No, the entire counterclaim. Look at the
first page of it. See the file stamp?
A January 9, 2013.
Q So as of January 13, 2000 -- January 9th,
2013 -- look at the last sentence of paragraph five.
Can you tell me on that day who are the victims
seeking compensatory and punitive damages against

Mr. Epstein that you represented?
A Okay.
MR. SCAROLA: If that information has
not been publicly disclosed, then I instruct
you that it is attorney -client privilege and
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
you should not respond.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Without disclosing their names, I will ask
the question differently.
Were you representing, in January 2013,
undisclosed victims that had compensatory and
punitive damage claims yet to be filed against

Mr. Epstein?
A I don't know. I don't know if at that time I
was or not.
Q Well, that's what this statement says,
right?
A It doesn't really. It says that upon
information and belief, federal law enforcement
continues to investigate additional allegations of
Epstein's serial abuse and molestation of children.
Q That's not the sentence we were just
looking at.
A "As a consequence" -- that's the sentence you
are looking at. "As a consequence of the" -- that's
what it says in the first sentence -- "Epstein
continues to face the potential of further criminal
prosecution and huge civil judgments from both
compensatory and punitive damages in favor of many
victims of his depraved criminal exploitation of
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
children" --
Q Including victims represented by Edwards.
A -- "including victims represented by
Edwards."
Q So I'm asking you, did you, in fact, in
January 2013 represent any victims of Mr. Edwards
(sic) that still had --
A Epstein.
Q I'm sorry. Mr. Epstein. Let me do it
again.

Mr. Edwards, did you in January 2013
represent any victims that had potential claims for
both compensatory and punitive damages against

Mr. Epstein?
MR. SCAROLA: You're misreading the
sentence. It doesn't say what you think --
what you are reading it to say. And as the
author of the sentence, I can tell you it
doesn't say what you think it says.

MR. LINK: I think it says exactly the
way I'm reading it, but it doesn't really
matter. So in answering my -- someone else
will decide what it says, not you or me.

MR. SCAROLA: Well, I will decide what
it says because I wrote it.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
MR. LINK: Well, I don't think it
actually works that way. I expect the jury
will have to determine --

MR. SCAROLA: And I suspect that --
MR. LINK: That's improper --
MR. SCAROLA: -- to examine this
witness about the allegations --

MR. LINK: -- in a pleading.
MR. SCAROLA: -- in an unsworn
pleading. That's correct.
MR. LINK: We will find out.

MR. SCAROLA: Okay.
BY MR. LINK:
Q In any event, did you, in fact, in
January 2013 have any clients that you were
representing that still had potential civil
compensatory and punitive damages claims against

Mr. Epstein?
A I don't remember if in January of 2013 I
represented anybody who was a victim of Mr. Epstein's
molestation. I just don't remember.
Q Take a look at the last sentence of
paragraph six and the first sentence of paragraph
seven.
A Okay.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Tell me which lawyers were unable to
persist in the prosecution of their claims based on

Mr. Epstein's tactics?
A It doesn't say that. You are just reading
something into it a paragraph that's not even close to
what it says.
Q Talks about intimidating his victims and
their legal counsel into abandoning their legitimate
claims or resolving those claims for substantially
less than their just value, right? That's a
statement of fact in here of what has happened.
And it says, "Epstein's tactics have
proven successful, while other victims have thus far
withstood this continued assault upon them and
persisted in the prosecution of their claims."
Right?
So if Mr. Epstein's tactics proved
successful, then he must have intimidated victims
and their legal counsel into abandoning their
legitimate claims or abandoning their legit claims
or resolving them for substantially less than their
just value. And I would like to know who those
lawyers and victims were, sir.

MR. SCAROLA: That is argumentive. It
is a misreading of the sentence.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

MR. LINK: Okay.
MR. SCAROLA: And if the question is
are you aware of victims who were
intimidated by Epstein and compromised their
claims for less than their value, that's a
legitimate question. But skip the whole
bunch of rhetoric that precedes it and ask
that question.

MR. LINK: You are done?
MR. SCAROLA: Yeah.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Do you remember my question?
A Hardly.
Q Me too.
So what I'm trying to understand is this
most current lawsuit against that Mr. Epstein has
allegations in it. And I know when we looked at

Mr. Epstein's complaint against you, you were
bothered by allegations that were in there that you
said were untrue, right?
A Yeah. The complaint is untrue.
Q I'm just looking at these allegations that
your lawyer filed on your behalf. Did you review
this complaint, this counterclaim before it was
filed?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A At some point in time, but not recently.
Q I said before it was filed.
A I'm sure.
Q And if there was something that you saw in
there that you thought Mr. Scarola got wrong or was
inaccurate, he unintentionally made a mistake, you
would have pointed it out, right?
A Well, Mr. Scarola was one of the lawyers who
also represented Epstein victims, so he knew -- he knew
the case, so did I. Did he know facts that I didn't
know? Maybe. But this doesn't look foreign to me. I
mean, Epstein intimidated victims. You've seen the
police reports. He intimidated victims. He
intimidated their families.
Q And their legal counsel, you say in here.

Mr. Scarola did not --
MR. SCAROLA: No, no. The complaint
said he attempted to intimidate victims and
legal counsel, and in some circumstances he
was successful.

MR. LINK: Right. I'm trying to figure
out who it was.
MR. SCAROLA: Okay, well, then ask that
question --

MR. LINK: I did.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
MR. SCAROLA: -- are you aware of
victims or legal counsel who were
intimidated?

MR. LINK: I asked it my way. You are
better at it than I am. I will keep going
my way.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Can you tell me one lawyer who was
intimidated and resolved or abandoned a legitimate
claim, or resolved it for substantially less? Can
you tell me one?
A Because of intimidation, many of the victims
either didn't bring claims or abandoned their claims or
settled them for much -- well below the value of the
cases.
Q You said lawyer. Tell me one lawyer,
please, is what I asked. One lawyer. Did

Mr. Scarola? There's no chance, right?
MR. SCAROLA: How about one question at
a time.
MR. LINK: Fair enough.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Did Mr. Scarola capitulate and was afraid
of Mr. Epstein?
A It wasn't the --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

MR. SCAROLA: That's two questions.
MR. LINK: It was?
MR. SCAROLA: Yes. Did Mr. Scarola
capitulate? Was Mr. Scarola intimidated by

Mr. Epstein?
MR. LINK: I bet he can handle that
question.
MR. SCAROLA: I'm sure he can, but the
law requires that you ask one question at a
time.

MR. LINK: It actually requires that
you just object to the form and then we will
see. That's what it requires. I know you
know that. I think you taught me that
during my objections.

MR. SCAROLA: Let's ask the proper
question, please.
THE WITNESS: All right. What's the
question?
BY MR. LINK:
Q Can you tell me one lawyer that represented
an Epstein plaintiff that abandoned their claim based
on Mr. Epstein's intimidation?
A I believe what is being said here is that the
intimidation of the victim caused the lawyer or the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
victim to settle the case or the lawyer to not be able
to get the full value of the case.
I think that if you talk to Bob
Josefsberg, he will tell you that that happened.
Q That he settled his cases for less than he
otherwise would have because of him being intimidated
or not getting the evidence?
A His clients being intimidated.
Q I will ask him that.
A Perfect.
Q You can try to massage the words, as you
have done, but this says intimidate his victims and
their legal counsel. And I keep asking you about
legal counsel.
A And I keep telling you to ask him. Ask some
other legal counsel. It wasn't me.
Q This isn't his pleading. This is yours,
sir. And I'm asking you in this pleading that you
filed to please tell me one person that you are
referring to in this statement that you made. One.
Tell me one lawyer that abandoned a legitimate claim.
A I just told you who to go to ask and you
acted like I didn't say it.
Q Sir, your pleadings says that a legal
counsel abandoned a legitimate claim.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A It's Jack Scarola's --

MR. SCAROLA: My pleading does not say
-- my pleading does not say that any lawyer
was intimidated. My pleading says that
Jeffrey Epstein sought to intimidate victims
and their legal counsel into abandoning
their legitimate claims. That's what it
says. That's what he sought to do.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Can you identify any lawyers that were
intimidated and abandoned their claim, please? If
you can't, you can't. Just say, I don't know of any.
A I just told you it wasn't me.
Q I didn't ask if it was you, sir. I said if
you can identify any. This is about the 50th time
I've asked you can you tell me any lawyers that have
abandoned their claim. And all you have to say is, I
don't know of any. Or I do know, and here is who
they are.
A Any lawyers that abandoned their claim?
Q Yes.
A I don't know of any lawyers that abandoned
their claim.
Q Okay. Thank you.
Do you know of any lawyers that have
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
resolved their claim for substantially less than
their just value?
A I don't know of any lawyers that had a claim.
But if they had a claim against Mr. Epstein, I don't
know of any lawyer who abandoned his claim for
substantially less value.
Q Now, I'm not talking about a lawyer's
claim.
A That's what you just asked me.
Q No, it's not. It's the claim for the
clients they represent.
A Okay.
Q I am assuming that's what your paragraph
talks about here, are lawyers representing victims,
and that those lawyers, as a result of intimidation,
either walked away from the case, or took less money
than they thought was professionally and ethically
available for the case because of the intimidation.
That's what we're talking about.
So let's try it again, which is really
simple. Are you aware of any lawyer that abandoned
a legitimate claim filed on behalf of a client
because they were intimidated by Mr. Epstein?

MR. SCAROLA: Who is the they you're
speaking with?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
MR. LINK: What?
MR. SCAROLA: You used a pronoun.
MR. LINK: Yeah.
MR. SCAROLA: The pronoun followed two
specific references. One was a reference to
client and the other was a reference to
lawyer.
BY MR. LINK:
Q You can answer the question.
A So am I aware -- is it your question or does
it relate to this paragraph? Does your question relate
to the paragraph?
Q Ignore the paragraph for a minute.
A Pretend the paragraph doesn't exist
Q I can tell it's confusing.
A It is, because it doesn't relate to your
question, but -- okay.
So your question is --
Q You're objecting too? Now you're objecting
for yourself.
A No. I just thought that you were trying to
relate it to this paragraph, and that's what's making
this hard.
Q Don't worry about what's going on in my
head.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A So omit the paragraph?
Q I would like to know if you can identify
one lawyer that represented a victim with a
legitimate claim against Mr. Epstein where that
lawyer abandoned that claim because of Mr. Epstein's
intimidation.
A I'm not sure one way or the other. Like I
said, if -- Bob Josefsberg represented a lot of people.
If anybody's claim was abandoned because of
intimidation, he would probably know better than me.
Q Mr. Josefsberg is not sitting in that
chair, sir.
A Right.
Q I'm asking you. So if you don't know one,
is it hard no say I don't know of any?
A I believe victims abandoned their claims. I
remember that as a fact. I believe also that they were
represented by Mr. Josefsberg. I'm not positive about
that, but that's to the best of my memory. That's what
I think happened.
How this has anything to do with this
lawsuit, God only knows. But I'm trying for you.
Q So I should talk to Mr. Josefsberg to see
if, when he was legal counsel for a victim he
abandoned a legitimate claim because he was
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
intimidated by Mr. Epstein. Is that what you're
saying?
A That's not what I said. I said whether a
victim abandoned her claim where he happened to be the
lawyer because she was intimidated or Mr. Epstein used
his -- employed his extraordinary financial resources,
sought to avoid damages by employing extraordinary
resources at his disposal with the purpose of
intimidating his victims or legal counsel, I think that
that would be the person you would ask about that.
Q All right.
Turn to paragraph 25, which is on page
eight.
A Okay.
Q You see that it talks about Mr. Epstein
filing this claim against Edwards and Edwards' client
A I do.
Q -- for the sole purpose of further
attempting to intimidate?
A Yes.
Q And to abandoning or settling their
legitimate claims.
A Right.
Q We talked about that earlier, right?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Yes.
Q And can you -- III. was a defendant in this
lawsuit, right?
A Right.
Q At the time that she was a defendant, she
was represented by you and your law firm as her
lawyer against Mr. Epstein, right?
A Correct.
Q Did you and your law firm represent III. in
the defense of this lawsuit?
A Yes.
Q And in representing III. in the defense of
this lawsuit where you're also a defendant, did you
charge her for that work?
A No.
Q Did you do it on a contingency basis?
A No.
Q Did you charge her for costs?
A No.
Q Did you have a written fee agreement with
her?
A Specifically for the defense of this case?
Q Yes, sir.
A Not a fee agreement, because I didn't charge
her a fee, and I don't think that there was a written
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
agreement at all, to the best of my memory.
Q Did you have any writing with her at all
discussing the terms upon which this representation
would go forward?
A No, other than I told her I would represent
her pro bono in this. It was unfair that this was his
tactic to try to extort her into abandoning her claim,
as well.
Q Did you have any writing with her
describing a conflict situation related to your being
a defendant in this lawsuit representing her in the
claims against Mr. Edwards (sic) and defending
A Epstein.
Q Epstein. Thank you.
-- and defending her in the claim brought
by Mr. Epstein against her?
A I don't know if she signed a conflict waiver.
I'm trying to think through what that conflict would

be. It's not jumping out at me. I don't think that
she signed a conflict waiver.
Q Just so I get the names right -- thank you
for correcting me.
At the time you, Brad Edwards, represented
in a state lawsuit against Mr. Epstein.
A Right.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q You, Brad Edwards, represented in a
federal lawsuit against Mr. Epstein.
A Right.
Q Mr. Epstein sued_ and you individually
in December 2009.
A Right.
Q Your law firm and you represented yourself,
right, in the defense of Mr. Epstein's suit?
A Mr. Scarola represented me.
Q Well, you filed a notice of appearance.
A Not then.
Q When did you file it?
A I don't remember. You would have to show me
the pleading, but not initially.
Q But you did, before Mr. Epstein's suite was
dismissed, file a notice of appearance, right?
A Before Mr. Epstein Mr. Epstein's lawsuit
with m was dismissed?
Q Against you.
A Against me was dismissed?
Q Uh-huh.
A Yes.
Q And Mr. Epstein sued_ and you and your
law firm agreed to represent her without charging her
to defend against the lawsuit Mr. Epstein brought?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A That's right.
Q And as far as you can remember, there's no
written fee agreement?
A True.
Q And there's no written conflict waiver
letter?
A Yes. We just went through that.

MR. SCAROLA: Good place for a break?
MR. LINK: Yeah. Perfect. Thank you.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
4:01 p.m. This is the end of tape three and
we are going off the record.
(A recess was had.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
4:17 p.m. This is the beginning of tape
four. We are back on the record.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Edwards, looking at Exhibit 18 -- we
started the day talking about lawyers in the
Rothstein firm that worked on the Epstein matters
with you. And that is -- you testified earlier that
Russell Adler -- this is an email from him -- was the
head of the tort group.
A Right.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 18 was marked
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q And this is a memo from him to you copying
Marc Nurik. Marc Nurik was a lawyer at Rothstein's
firm?
A One of the criminal defense lawyers.
Q And it's references Mr. Epstein's
non-prosecution agreement?
A That's what it looks like.
Q And it looks like it's a message from
Mr. Adler to you. Says, "Brad, Wayne Black and I
just had a great conversation with Marc Nurik about
the non-prosecution agreement, and I need you to
please get in contact with Marc and meet with him to
discuss the possibilities. Bring with you a copy of
the agreement."
Next sentence says, "We also discussed the
assets situation and there are some major
possibilities that need to be explored with Marc and
others."
"Get on it" exclamation point.
Were you reporting to Mr. Adler in how to
represent the three Rothstein clients -- the three
ladies -- on how to prosecute the Epstein matters?
A Well, this email is dated April 8th, 2009, so
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
I had just started at the firm. I had just got there.
Russ Adler was one of the only lawyers
that I had known for years before I got to the firm.
And Russ Adler handled sexual abuse cases. So,
especially in the beginning, I talked to Russ about
how to kind of navigate through the complications
with Jeffrey Epstein and with the type of defense
that was going on. So this just appears that Wayne
Black and Russ Adler -- Wayne was the
investigator -- that they were talking also about
how to -- what we needed to do in the investigation.
Yeah, Russ was definitely involved then.
He didn't do much in the day-to-day, so I don't want
to say anything to that.
Q I understand. But I'm talking about on
April 8th, 2009, it looks to me like he's giving you
instructions on what to do. Do you agree?
A Not giving me instructions on what to do. I
mean, he's telling me bring Marc Nurik the
non-prosecution agreement, is the instruction.
If anything, we are working together with
the common goal.
Q The get on it, exclamation point --
A We're buddies. Then we were just friends.
Get on it is let's do this.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q So at least in April of 2009, Russ Adler, a
tort lawyer; Bradley Edwards, a tort lawyer; and Marc
Nurik, a criminal lawyer, are caucusing about the
Epstein litigation?
A About the non-prosecution agreement,
specifically, which is a complicated document that
related to the civil litigation, yeah. But that's why
we would involve Marc, because of the complications
related to that criminal document.
Q And was Mr. Adler a partner?
A No. I don't believe so. No.
I think there were only two equity
partners, which was Scott Rothstein and Stuart
Rosenfeldt.
Q As Mr. Adler the Adler at Rothstein,
Rosenfeldt & Adler?
A Yes.
Q So he was a named partner?
A He was a name on the door. I believe he was
a partner at the time. I did believe that, because his
name was on the door.
Q How about Mr. Nurik? Was he a partner?
A No.
Q Did you believe he was a partner at the
time?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A No. I learned -- I don't know about that
time. A month into my being there, I learned that only
Scott and Stuart were the actual partners.
Q Equity partners?
A Yes.
Q That he owned the firm?
A Yeah. The name partner really just meant you
kind of controlled your own life.
Q Did you talk with former Judge Bill Berger
about the Epstein the three Epstein cases that you
brought to the firm.
A Yes. And Bill Berger was the one I told you
earlier, he actually did certain things on the case:
attended hearings, may have helped to draft a motion or
two.
Q Let's take a look at this one. Was
Mr. Berger a partner?
A No.
Q Did he hold himself out as a partner?
A I don't know that, but I believe that if --
he may have carried that title partner, which means he
had his own division. He didn't have to report to
anybody.
Q If we look on the firm --
A That directory thing --
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q -- directory.
A I hadn't seen that until you showed it to me.
It's not going to surprise me if it says partner.
Q Berger's name probably says partner and so
does Mr. Adler and Mr. Nurik, right?
A Presumably.
Q So this is an email and it says May 19th.
And it's from Mr. Berger to Bradley Edwards -- that's
you -- Russell Adler, Steven Jaffe. Who is Steven
Jaffe?
A He's a lawyer there and in the successor firm
that I started after this.
Q And Matthew Weissing?
A Same.
Q And Gary Farmer?
A Same.
Q Is this Gary Farmer senior or junior?
A On this email that's junior.
Q So we have got Berger, Edwards, Adler,
Jaffe, Weissing and Farmer on email. Six lawyers.
A Right.
Q Discussing meeting with a psychologist
expert related to Epstein?
A Right.
Q And it's Berger inviting you, in fact, to
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
attend an interview of Dr. Amy Swan, a psychologist,
"who we're considering as the damages expert in
Epstein cases."
A Right. Yeah, the cases were being tried in
West Palm Beach -- in Palm Beach where Judge Berger had
just come off the bench. So the question really was,
who are the psychologists who treat sex abuse victims
in that area. And Judge Berger believed that she was
somebody that he thought was well qualified who had
appeared in front of him. So that's who he wanted us
to interview.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 19 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q I got. He's asked five lawyers to --
invited them to participate in the interview?
A Yeah.
Q Right?
A I can't I can't imagine that many showed
up to that, but yeah.
Q Was Mr. Weissing, would he show up as a
partner on the directory?
A I don't know. Presumably though most
everybody had that title.
Q Do you have the directory handy?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Tell me what exhibit it is. I'm sure I do.
Q I think it's down at the bottom.
A Maybe it was earlier in the day than I
thought, unless I passed it. Yeah, I passed it.
Q Right after that.
A I will find mine. Ten -- here it is.
Exhibit 12. You were asking me about Berger, right?
Q Yeah. Let's just look at the folks that
were all invited to attend this meeting.
A William Berger says -- next to title, it says
shareholder.
Q Shareholder. Okay. Is that different than
a partner?
A In reality, no. But it's a different title.
Everybody was an employee, but -- it's a different word
than a partner.
Q Well, you said earlier that there's a
difference between a partner and a shareholder. And
a shareholder means you actually have equity in the
firm.
A No, I didn't say that. Again, you're making
things up. Totally made up.
Q Okay. Then I misunderstood you. What is a
shareholder?
A I don't know. Another title that was given
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
at the firm. I think everybody was just an employee.
There were two equity partners: Scott Rothstein and
Stuart Rosenfeldt. Everybody else, some form of
employee with a different name next to them,
meaningless.
Q Well, I see just on this very first page of
Exhibit 12, I see there's a partner. I see Russ
Adler is a shareholder. Roger Alvarez is an
associate. Larry Barsky is an associate. Bill
Berger is a shareholder. Shawn Birken is a partner.
Then you have law clerk, shareholder for Boden, and
partner for Bofshever.
I see lots of different titles.
A I do too. It's a made up stratification that
somebody created at the firm.
Q All right.
So who else was on that list that we just
looked at of the five names?
A Russ Adler, which we went to.
Q Shareholder. Berger, shareholder.
A Steve Jaffe.
Q How about Mr. Jaffe? So far working on --
with two shareholders and a partner.
A Page seven.
Q What is Mr. Jaffe?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Partner.
Q Partner. Okay.
A Farmer. Farmer says shareholder.
Q So we have three shareholders --
A And Weissing says partner.
Q And all partners. All right. Stuart
Rosenfeldt says shareholder, by the way.
So he had the same title as Adler, Berger
and Farmer?
A Apparently, on this directory he did.
Q Okay.
A And Scott Rothstein says managing partner,
chairman, CEO.
Q Okay.
A I assume Mr. Rothstein named everybody, then,
since he's the only one with the highest title.
Q Look at Number 20.
A Yes, sir.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 20 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q This just follows up on what you testified
earlier. This is from Susan Stirling. Who is Susan
Stirling?
A That name is familiar. I don't remember.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q This is about Epstein. And it's her saying
to you, "I promise I will tell you about every check
I get. So far it has only been the one for the
motorcycle."
A So it looks like I sent an email before that
saying did we get a check to Wayne Black yet. That's
probably after he called me saying he hasn't been paid.
If not, let me know, and I will tell Russ about this,
again. Which is what I was saying, I will tell Russ
somebody needs to get paid.
She says, "No. I promise I will tell you
about every check I get. So far it has only been
one for the motorcycle." That's a different case.
That was a motorcycle in storage on another case.
Q So when you were mentioning about paying
Wayne Black and talking to Russ, this is --
A That's consistent with exactly what my memory
was this morning, is Wayne was saying he wasn't getting
paid, and I was referring it to Russ.
Q Mr. Edwards this is Exhibit 21
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 21 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q And this is the Seventh Amended and
Supplemental Witness List filed on your behalf last
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
night at 5:20 p.m.
Can you tell me, please, what
-- what factual knowledge and information
she has and why she's expected to be presented as a
witness?
A I think who is going to be called and in what
order and what they're going to present is better asked
of my attorney, who is presenting the case. But I know
Q Did I ask that? I don't remember asking
that.
A I thought you asked what information
was going to testify to in this case.
Q Right. Not when or if. She's listed here
as expected to be presented, right?
A It would be in response to any question --
any witness would be in response to any questions that

Mr. Scarola asks of them.
Q True.
A So I know what she would say if she told the
truth: Jeffrey Epstein was my employer. He hired me to
assist him in recruiting underaged girls so that he
could molest them. He did it all over the world. I
watched him traffic them nationally, internationally,
and I was also made to participate in that. And then
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
when Mr. Epstein was discovered by the FBI, he
assaulted me on an airplane to get me to cooperate with
him and not cooperate with the victims.
If she was going to tell the truth, that's
along the lines of what she would say.
Q We are talking about the counterclaim for
malicious prosecution, right, calling her in the
counterclaim claim for malicious prosecution, right?
A Right. The cases weren't fabricated.
Epstein really is a child molester. The underlying
cases that you were prosecuting against him really were
legitimate underlying cases. III. was a victim, not
fabricated.
Q Was there something in the claim that

Mr. Epstein brought where he said anything about his
interaction with and the case that you filed?
Where does he say that?
A Yeah. He says --
Q Show me where that is.
A He says -- look at this deposition. He
says --
Q I'm asking you about the complaint that he
filed that you say -- as I understand you -- you have
one count, malicious prosecution, right? And that
you say on December 9th, 2007, when that complaint
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
was filed --
A 7, 2009. I got you.
Q December 7th, 2009 -- that Mr. Epstein did
not have a -- did not have probable cause to file
that proceeding. That's the complaint you brought,
right?
A Right.
Q So, understanding what was in Mr. Epstein's
mind about what he knew about Rothstein and his Ponzi
scheme, and what he knew about any connection to
that -- that he might have in his head, how does
have personal knowledge about that?
A You just reframed this case to something that
this case is not.
Q Really. Tell me what the case is about
then.
A Well, at least as it relates to
Q No, no. Is it not a malicious prosecution
case?
A It is a malicious prosecution case.
Q And it's whether or not Mr. Epstein had
probable cause when he filed it, right?
A To bring the complaint that he filed. Right.
Q The proceeding that he brought, whether he
had probable cause
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Yes.
Q -- is one of the elements.
A Sure. That's one of the elements.
Q Does ave any factual
information related to whether Mr. Epstein had
probable cause to make the allegations he did about

Mr. Rothstein and about you?
A Mr. Epstein --
MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. To the extent
that relevance is a legal concept, the
question calls for a legal conclusion. I
object to the form of the question on that
basis.

MR. LINK: Understood. Thank you.
THE WITNESS: Mr. Epstein's complaint
against me for the crimes that he alleged
that I and Scott Rothstein and
committed is predicated upon the assertion
by him that I fabricated cases of a sexual
nature on behalf of victims, or fictitious
victims, including
And in furtherance of these fictitious
cases, that I conducted irrelevant discovery
that could serve no purpose but to pump a
Ponzi scheme.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
would be able to testify
that 's case was not fabricated, was not
as Mr. Epstein elaborated in his deposition,
ginned up; that it was indeed legitimate.
She was a legitimate victim. My pursuit of
discovery, including the flight logs, was
relevant to the proof of her claim,
including the punitive damage claim that I
was prosecuting, which would refute the
probable cause he claims existed when he
filed the complaint against me.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So help me understand. I know you have got
a bunch of these folks --
A I don't know if I can say it better than
that.
Q You said it very well.
What I'm asking about is -- if I
understand the counterclaim that you filed the
probably cause requires a reasonably cautious person
to have a good faith belief, essentially, in the
things that they allege -- Mr. Scarola said it more
articulately earlier, right -- and so that it has to
do with the allegations made.
Does Ms. IIIIIIIIIhave any knowledge about
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
what Mr. Rothstein was doing?
A Ms. has knowledge about what

Mr. Epstein did, and therefore, what Mr. Epstein knew.
And therefore, what Mr. Epstein said in his complaint
was knowingly false.
Q Let me try my question again.
A Which means no probable cause.
Q I must have confused you. Did Ms.
have any knowledge about what Scott Rothstein was
doing?
A Ask her.
Q Pardon me?
A Ask her.
Q You don't know?
A I don't know if she knew what Scott Rothstein
was doing.
Q Did Ms. have any idea what you were
doing at the Rothstein firm? Were you talking to
her? Did she participate?
A Not to my knowledge she didn't know what I
was doing.
Q So Ms. testimony has to do with
claims made by victims that have settled their cases,
right?
MR. SCAROLA: It has to do with what
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Mr. Edwards has described in detail it has
to do with. He doesn't --
What purpose does it serve for you to
recharacterize in five words the lengthy
answer that he gave you explaining in detail
the relevant, quote, unquote, knowledge that
you asked him?
BY MR. LINK:
Q I'm just trying to understand how the
knowledge is part of your case. That's what I'm
asking. I understand.
So her knowledge is about what she knew
about Mr. Epstein before he did his plea deal,
right?
A And after.
Q And after.
A It's what she knew about what Mr. Epstein did
and what Mr. Epstein knew at the time that he filed the
false complaint against me. That's what it is.
Q Did she talk to Mr. Epstein at the time he
filed the complaint and say, What's in your mind? Is
that what she's going to say? Mr. Epstein told me in
December of 2009 this is why I filed this complaint?
A All right. Let me just give you an example.
Q Okay.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A as on the airplane with Jeffrey
Epstein and an underaged girl. Jeffrey Epstein makes
the allegation in the complaint that the proof that
Brad Edwards was pumping a Ponzi scheme is that he
sought flight logs, despite knowing that there were no
underaged girls on the airplane. Jeffrey Epstein knew
that to be false, because there were indeed underaged
girls on the airplane.
To the extent that Jeffrey Epstein himself
won't say that I knowingly filed this false
allegation, could say, I know that
Jeffrey Epstein knew that that was a false
allegation, because I too was on the airplane and so
was this underaged girl, and he knew that.
So at the time that he filed this
complaint, he knew that it was false, the
allegations that he was making, which allegedly
formed the basis of his assertion that I was
involved in a Ponzi scheme.
Q Okay.
You lost me, but I'm not going --
A Read it back. I think it makes sense.
Q I'm not going to try to figure that out.
Do you have anyone that can testify about
what was in Mr. Epstein's mind in December 2009 at
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
the time that the lawsuit was filed about why he
filed it?
A Mr. Epstein testified to that.
Q Other than Mr. Epstein, do you have any
witnesses that are going to testify about the reasons
why Mr. Epstein made the decision to file the
lawsuit?
A No. It's very obvious why he filed the
lawsuit.
Q You have no other witnesses other than

Mr. Epstein, correct?
A We have attempted to take his attorneys'
depositions and they have all rejected that
opportunity. So he has no witnesses that can testify
as to what was in his mind at that time.
Q You are the plaintiff in the counterclaim,
right?
A We will see how this unfolds, right?
Q Let me just wrap this up, because you have
given me a lot of information to which I think are
simple questions. Do you have a witness that will
testify, other than Mr. Epstein, about what was in
his mind in December 2009 about why he brought the
lawsuit?

MR. SCAROLA: Direct evidence or
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
circumstantial evidence or both?
THE WITNESS: Let me think about that
question. About why he brought the lawsuit.
Specifically that.

MR. LINK: Can you read back the
question for him, please?
I won't take that as coaching at all.
In any event, well done. But I don't think
you heard my question.
Can you read it back?
(Thereupon, the requested portion of the
record was read back by the reporter as
above duly recorded. )
THE WITNESS: A witness other than

Mr. Epstein, no.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Thank you.
Why was Bill Berger added to the witness
list last night?
A You will have to ask somebody other than
myself.
Q Do you know what Mr. Berger -- why he's
listed as an expert in this case?
A Again, that's a question for the lawyers.
Q Do you know when Mr. Berger agreed to
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
testify as an expert in this case, or if he has?
A Also a question for Mr. Scarola.
Q Have you --

MR. SCAROLA: All of which I will be
happy to answer at the appropriate time.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Do you know what factual knowledge
Mr. Berger has upon which he will predicate an expert
opinion in the case?
A Again, this is not a question for me.
Q How about Earleen Earleen?
A He certainly knows why certain discovery was
done and for what legitimate purpose it was done. But
what he's going to testify to, again, that's just a
question for somebody else.
Q I will ask him. That's okay.
Earleen Cote --
A She's --
Q Do you know why she was listed last night
at 5:20 p.m. to the Seventh Amended and Supplemental
Witness List?
A She's a -- she's my former boss at Kubicki
Draper.
Q Why was she listed last night? What is she
going to testify about Mr. Epstein?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A She will not testify about Mr. Epstein's
knowledge of what was in his mind before -- whatever
that question was you asked. She won't testify about
that.
Q Can you tell me what the purpose for her
being included? What is the knowledge she has about
the lawsuit?
A No. Only about me.
Q She's going to testify about you as an
employee at Kubicki Draper?
A I have known her for many years, from that
time until today, so she can testify about
Q About what? Related to the lawsuit.
A Sure. How the lawsuit has affected me over
time.
Q I see. Okay. So she's not -- that's what
she's going to testify about. Okay.
How about -- you took Mr. Dershowitz off
the witness list. Do you know why Mr. Dershowitz is
no longer --
A I didn't know he was on the witness list.
Q On for years.
A By you or by us?
Q This is your witness list, not mine.
You don't know why he was on there. Okay.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
How about Prince Edwards? Do you know why
Prince Edwards was on the witness list? Is
he coming here to testify?
A I don't even know who that is.
Q You don't even know who he is?
A Prince Edwards. No.
Q Do you know whether he's coming to testify?
A I don't know who that is. How would I know
if he's coming to testify.
Q You're the plaintiff and a lawyer in the
case.
A Is that a real person?
Q He's on your witness list, sir, not mine.
A Show me where that is.
Q You don't have the witness list -- you, you
have the witness list. I can't tell you. I'm
looking at a chart, and they are not alphabetical.
It's like a scrambled witness list.
A Let me try.
Q I think he goes by Price Andrew, I'm told.
A Okay. Prince Andrew. If he testifies, he
would have relevant information.
Q Do you know what he has?
A Yeah. I know that Jeffrey Epstein lent at
least one underaged female to Prince Andrew.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Lent? What do you mean by that? Tell me
what you mean by that, please.

MR. SCAROLA: The witness
identification actually appears at number
48, Prince Andrew Albert Christian Edwards,
which is his full legal name. Duke of York,
Buckingham Palace Road, London.
THE WITNESS: I would love for him to
testify.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Has he been subpoenaed, do you know?
A I don't know. We have tried to subpoena him
in the past, and he doesn't seem to want to testify.
Q The Royals are not easy to get in a circuit
court?
A Apparently not. I think that your client
would have the ability to get him here, though, so I
would hope he could.
Q Since he's on your witness list --

Mr. Edwards -- I suspect that you would be the one
that would be calling him.
A Like I said, I would love to.
Q On the witness list, if you would, turn to
the back page -- Mr. Scarola's office didn't number
the pages -- oh, 18 of 22. He did. You see under
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
expert witnesses on page 18 of 22 --
A Yes.
Q -- Mr. Josefsberg? Has he agreed to be an
expert witness?
A Again, that's a question for Mr. Scarola.
Q Have you talked to Mr. Josefsberg --
A Ever?
Q No. Let me finish.
Have you talked to Mr. Josefsberg about
testifying in this case?
A Have I personally?
Q Yes.
A No.
Q How about Charles Lichtman at Berger
Singerman? Has he agreed to provide expert opinions
in this case?
A All of these witnesses, you would have to ask
Mr. Scarola.
Q So you told me --
A He's in charge of the case.
Q I got it.
So there's one, two, three, four, five,
six, seven, eight, nine expert witnesses listed?
A Most of which appear to be the plaintiff
attorneys who handled the other -- who represented the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
other victims against Mr. Epstein, and would testify
that all of the discovery that Mr. Epstein claims to
have been done and so improper for some improper
purpose were joint decisions by all of us, and was
entirely proper and served very relevant purposes for
all of our clients.
Q Now, you have Earleen Cote -- who you told
me was a personal friend -- listed as an expert
witness. Does she have an expert opinion she's going
to provide to the jury?
A That's a question that is directed better to
Jack.
Q One of the experts that's listed --
Exhibit 22.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 22 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q -- actually provided a report in your case.
A It looks like, from the expert witness list
that you showed me before, that he's the only one
that's above the paragraph saying, The following, or
attorneys that are not retained, or are specifically
employed to provide expert testimony. So that's
probably why we have a report, because he's the one
expert that has been employed to provide expert
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
testimony.
Q I understand. He's the only one that
complied with the disclosure rules and has a report,
but the rest are listed as under the actual expert
witness section.
A I hear you.
Q So in looking at -- do you have the report
in front of you, which we just marked as Exhibit 22
for Bernard Jansen, PhD?
A Yeah.
Q When was Mr. Jansen retained?
A I don't know.
Q Your counterclaim has been pending since
December 2009, correct?
A Yes.
Q Do you know why Mr. Jansen did not provide
a report until 2017?
A Don't know.
Q Do you know why Mr. Jansen was not listed
on any exhibit list from the beginning of the case --
the first -- I think it was five -- maybe five or six
witness list to the court?
A With certainty I don't know. I know the
types of things he does. And typically his report is
most useful right before trial, because it is a
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
quantification of the number of people who have seen
the articles associated -- depending on the type of
lawsuit in which he's testifying -- with the derogatory
and defamatory statements, so --
Q Dr. Jansen --

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. I'm sorry.
You interrupted Mr. Edwards.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Did I, Mr. Edwards?
A Yes. I was almost finish, though.
So his report can't be completed until
well, you want it to be complete as close up to the
trial as possible so that you can have the final
numbers.
Q I understand you can update reports. But
you could have retained him at any time, because
there were other trial settings and there would have
been a witness list, right?
A Well, we have been on appeal for a while,
but --
Q I understand. But you've had five trial
settings.
In any event, you have used Mr. Jansen
before, correct?
A I have used Mr. Jansen before. As a
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
plaintiff I have not. This is my first time, I think.
Q As a lawyer?
A Yes.
Q I saw on his Appendix B on page 77 he lists
a lawsuit versus Maxwell, that we talked
about earlier --
A That's the one I told you earlier.
Q -- with Boies Schiller --
A Right.
Q -- and your firm, Jaffe, Weissing, Edwards,
Fistos & Lehrman, right?
A Exactly.
Q And is that where you met Mr. Jansen,
during that lawsuit.
A Yes.
Q Was he somebody that the Boies Schiller
firm recommended that you use?
A In that lawsuit?
Q Yes.
A I don't remember who first found him. I
would say that in the first call with Mr. Jansen, right
before he was hired, it was either myself and
Mr. Boies, or somebody from his firm. So together we
found him.
I think he testified in the Erin Andrews
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
case. That's initially how we discovered him.
Q If you flip back in this report to
forward in the report. Sorry -- to page 13. You see
the first article that he references is from
October 4th, 2017.
A I do see that.
Q This is one of the articles he references
as being dissemination of defamatory material about
you, correct?
A I don't know. I haven't read this report.
Q You didn't read his report?
A No.
Q So what was it that he was retained to do,
then, if you didn't read his report? Do you know?
A It wasn't so I could read his report. That's
definitely not what he was retained to do.
Q Okay. Did you understand that he was
supposed to do a search to see where articles had
been disseminated and the number of viewers?
A How many viewers viewed the dissemination of
the false allegations that were made against me that
were prompted or set in motion by Mr. Epstein's
complaint.
Q So he lists some examples here on page 13.
Are you familiar with the article, October 3rd, 2017,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
in the Palm Beach Post about Jeffrey Epstein paid
three women $5.3 million to end sex lawsuits?
A Yeah.
Q Did your office or Mr. Scarola's office
invite that reporter to the hearing on that day?
A I did not. I wasn't even in town, I don't
believe, for that day.
Q Do you know whether Mr. Scarola had lunch
with that reporter that day before the article came
out or the day before?
A I do not know. I don't think it's of
consequence, since that article contains these false
allegations, and it was only set in motion by this
complaint.
Q So even if you reached out and asked a
reporter to attend a hearing and publish an article,
that's Mr. Epstein's responsibility because he sued
you in December 2009; is that right?
A You got it. Although, I didn't do that.
Q You retained Mr. Scarola on a contingency
fee to represent you in this case?
A Yes.
Q So you haven't had to pay Mr. Scarola for
his work; is that correct?
Let's take a look at Exhibit 23.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 23 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q Can you tell me from looking at Exhibit 23,
which is a compilation of Brad Edwards' time, when it
is that you started taking contemporaneous notes of
your time -- contemporaneous time records?
A I believe by February.
Q Of February 2010?
A I believe so.
Q What is it about February 2010 that makes
you think that's when you started?
A It looks like that's when
Q Is there something different about that
February 2nd entry that's different than the
January 29th and 30th entry?
A No. What I thought was that there was a
hearing, because I remember -- like I said, I remember
being at a hearing at the courthouse. But now that I'm
looking at this, this says, "Review of" -- it's a
notice.
Okay, it was before my deposition, which
was March 23rd, 2010. It was before that day.
Q Before March 23rd?
A That's the date that it says my deposition
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
was taken here.
Q Was your deposition taken for 12 hours?
A It was similar to today, which, you know, I
left my house this morning at whatever time. It was
it's going to be longer than 12 hours, you know.
Q So you bill from the time you leave your
house until the time you get back?
A Yeah. For that day I wrote that down. The
time I left -- the time I came here -- the whole time
that this deposition took out of my life that day, I
billed it.
Q When you're billing clients, do you bill
clients for the amount of time it takes you to drive
from your house to wherever the deposition is, if you
are charging them on an hourly-rate basis?
A That's usually worked out with the client.
Sometimes if it's out of town, I tell them you are
going to have to pay for travel. But most of the time
not if it's out of town. If it's in town -- it's down
the street, I bill from -- there's usually preparation
before the deposition, too, so, you know, it's --
Q I'm just reading what you wrote here. And
what you wrote is deposition of Brad Edwards at
Searcy Denney, 12 hours?
A Yeah. It was probably longer than that.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
From the time that I -- the time that it took out of my
day was longer than that. And that wasn't in billing a
client. It was -- I couldn't do anything for any
client that day, because I was wrapped up in this
nonsense.
Q Well, you said -- okay. Let's go back,
then, and take a look at the beginning. Remember, I
asked you about your review of the complaint? You
said you did that on the 7th. And I total 22.7 hours
that you have recorded to review the complaint in
this case.
A I have reviewed it for longer than that. I
may not
Q So to read this complaint you spent more
than 22 hours?
A Over the course of the last eight years, yes.
Q I'm talking about in the first five days,
it has the 22 hours, sir.
A If that's what the time records say. That
doesn't seem --
Q You have got 8.1 on the 7th. You see that?
Initial complaint, review and research.
A It's not just reviewing the complaint. It's
also research related to the complaint, which includes
a lot of things.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.

MR. SCAROLA: Do you have any questions
relating to these time records that concern
any of the four areas that the Court has
described, other than a general review of
the time records that was already conducted
by your predecessor counsel and still
co-counsel Fred Haddad?

MR. LINK: I am asking about his claim
for damages.
MR. SCAROLA: Yes, sir. I understand
that. But this aspect of his claim for
damages was the subject of prior deposition
testimony.
These records were produced in advance
of that deposition. Mr. Haddad had them.

Mr. Haddad conducted an examination with
regard to these time records.
We are not going to go through that
again. That is an area that was inquired
into. And everything about these time
records could reasonably have been asked at
that time or was asked at that time.

MR. LINK: I understand.
MR. SCAROLA: So I'm going to object to
any further questions, unless those
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
questions can be tied into the areas
specifically permitted by Judge Hafele.

MR. LINK: I believe Judge Hafele has
given me permission to ask about damages.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So would you take a look, if you would, at
September 2nd, 2010? And do you see on that date you
recorded 41 hours of time?
A It wasn't all done on that date.
Q By September 2nd, 2010, you told me you
were keeping contemporaneous time records. So if you
were keeping contemporaneous time records, you
recorded on that date 41 hours.
A But I'm not billing a client. This is
keeping records for me, so I know how much time I'm
spending on the file.
If you have seen the summary judgment
motion and seen the undisputed statement of facts,
and seen the volume of exhibits attached to it, you
would know how long is spent to assemble that
motion, and know that that's not really an
unbelievable amount of time.
So by that date, that's the number of
hours that I had spent on that, that block billed
that. This is not something that -- I am doing it
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
for me. It's not going to a client.
Q But you are doing it in order to recover
damages against Mr. Epstein, right?

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. Don't answer
that question.
And unless you can tie a specific
question regarding these time records to the
area specifically identified by Judge
Hafele, or demonstrate that the questions
that you are asking are questions that could
not reasonably have been covered during the
third session of Mr. Edwards' deposition,
then we will not answer the questions.

MR. LINK: So, if I understand it, any
questions that I have that relate to damages
that are set forth on Exhibit 23, your
position is I'm not allowed to ask?

MR. SCAROLA: Unless they can
specifically be tied to the filing of the
federal lawsuit, interaction with Rothstein
and knowledge of the Ponzi scheme, or the
$14 million bond motion, that's correct.
This aspect of damages was fully and
completely explored by Mr. Haddad. We are
not here to redepose Mr. Edwards with regard
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
to matters that were already covered. And
no objections were raised with regard to
those questions, so this is not an area
where the Court sought a clearer record with
regard to the nature of the objections that
were being raised and any privilege
assertions that were being raised.

MR. LINK: Okay. You're entitled to
instruct him. I disagree with the way you
read the transcript. It is what it is.

MR. SCAROLA: That's fine.
MR. LINK: So the record is clear,
there are many questions I would want to ask
you about these time records, particularly
in light of you telling me that you kept
contemporaneous records, which I don't think
is true, based on the time that I see here
and based on the testimony I just heard,
which is that I block billed here, and that
I would like to explore that further.

Mr. Scarola --
MR. SCAROLA: Your personal assessment
of Mr. Edwards' credibility is neither
relevant nor material, particularly when
your predecessor counsel had every
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
opportunity to explore issues regarding
credibility with regard to these records.
MR. LINK: Move on?
MR. SCAROLA: Please do.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Edwards, since 2009 when Mr. Epstein's
lawsuit was filed, you have actually made
presentations about the Epstein case and about
representing sexual abuse victims, right?
A I have definitely made presentations about
representing sexual abuse victims. And one of those
cases is the case against Jeffrey Epstein.
Q Okay. Let's take a look at Exhibit 24.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 24 was marked
for identification.)
BY MR. LINK:
Q If you would, I would like you to turn to
-- it's page 99. This was part of a bigger package.
I think it's a presentation you made to the National
Crime Victim Bar Association. Do you remember that
presentation?
A Let me see. Where was it? I know where it
was --
Q If you look on page one, it says, "Bradley
Edwards. Protecting the Rights of Crime Victims.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Why do we do what we do. Papers and Presentations."
You see that?
A I have given that presentation.
Q Turn to page 99.
A Yep.
Q So, if you look at Subsection F, you make
the comment in A that defendant will likely invoke
the Fifth. Does that mean the Fifth Amendment? Is
that what you mean by that, the constitutional right
to not testify against yourself?
A The Fifth -- your client does it all the
time. Yes, that's what I'm talking about.
Q Were you talking about Mr. Epstein here or
generally?
A Doesn't look like --
Q Doesn't look like Mr. Epstein to me.
A It doesn't look like it.
Q In most cases that are brought involving
sexual abuse, do the defendants invoke the Fifth
Amendment?
A When you sue a pedophile, typically they
invoke the Fifth. I mean, I can't even think of an
instance where they haven't.
The only time that they don't is if they
try to claim that it was negligent or they
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
misunderstood the age or misapprehended something
about the situation. But where they're actually
guilty, yeah, they take the Fifth.
Q You see here where you say here in those
cases where somebody pleads the Fifth, you can and
should ask -- something you put in quotes pressure
point questions. You see that?
A Yeah.
Q And then you give an example of a pressure
interrogatory.
A Yep.
Q What do you mean by finding pressure points
to ask defendants?
A Well, so this is talking about in an STD
transmission case, which I have had a bunch of them
not a bunch of them, four or five of them. And one of
the things that is difficult about those cases is
proving that the perpetrator -- the perpetrator usually
doesn't admit, Yeah, I knew I had it beforehand. So in
this case, getting the names and numbers of all their
prior girlfriends and tracing back the disease is a
pressure point that typically when they see that you
are headed down this road that you are ultimately going
to get information from previous people to be able to
prove your case, it will lead to the defendant
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
understanding that you got me and --
Q A settlement?
A Yeah, and the case will settle.
Q So that if you apply the appropriate
pressure to the right -- in the right circumstances,
you will get them to settle?
A Yeah.
Q Is that a tactic that you were teaching
that folks should do if you were representing a
plaintiff, which is to find the right pressure points
so that you can extract the best settlement possible?
A Well, that's what every plaintiff lawyer does
in every case, is try to maximize the recovery. And in
order to do that, you need the right evidence. And in
order to get the right evidence, these are the types of
questions that you need to do to get it.
Q And you have to squeeze the pressure point,
right? Push the pressure point to get the best
settlement?
A You've got to get the right evidence to get
it, yeah. Of course.

MR. LINK: Let's mark this as a
composite Exhibit 25.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Number 25 was marked
for identification.)
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
BY MR. SCAROLA:
Q Mr. Edwards, one of the things I have seen
is that you have been -- you have gotten awards and
accolades and different recognition by your peers
over the years, right?
A Mr. Haddad and I talked about this ad nauseam
at my second deposition, so yes. You've noticed the
same thing that your predecessor noticed.
Q What I was going to ask you is, I didn't
see any such accolades or awards before
December 2009. Were you rated by Martindale -Hubbell
before December 2009?
A This is the same line of questioning. We are
just rehashing the same thing.
Q So you don't want to answer?

MR. SCAROLA: I will let you answer
THE WITNESS: It's not that I don't
want to answer, it's just wasting time.

MR. SCAROLA: I will let you
answer that one question.
THE WITNESS: I don't know.
When Mr. Haddad told me last time all
of the accolades, it was -- most of it was
news to me. Some of the things I didn't
even know about. Martindale -Hubbell, I do.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Was I rated before that? I don't know.
You would have to go back.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So the things in this exhibit --
A It's mainly Martindale -Hubbell.
Q -- 20 -- 30 -- 23 -- 23.

MR. SCAROLA: Twenty-five.
MR. LINK: Twenty-five?
MR. SCAROLA: Yes, sir.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Exhibit 25, you're aware of all of these
because you ordered plaques, right?
A I personally didn't. Did my firm? I don't
know. Like, I have never seen this before. I don't
know what this organization is. I haven't seen it.
Was it ordered? Possibly.
Q Do you put these plaques up in your office?
A I may have three plaques up in my office.

No. I don't have all these plaques.
Q You don't have all these plaques up in --
where are you storing your plaques?
A I don't know. That's a good question.
"Highest possible rating in both legal
ability and ethical standards." I feel like I would
have remembered seeing this plaque. I haven't seen
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
it.
Q But you see the picture of the plaque?
A I do.
Q With your name on it?
A You've made a great exhibit here. I'm going
to use it in my next presentation.

MR. SCAROLA: Marketers send you these
things with a picture of your plaque all the
time.
MR. LINK: Not me. They know better.
Why don't we take a couple minute's
break. Let me sort through some of this and
see where we can get to to move it along.
How's that?
THE WITNESS: Anything to move it
along.
MR. SCAROLA: Sounds promising.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
5:15 p.m. We are going off the record.
(A recess was had.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is
5:35 p.m. We are back on the record.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Mr. Edwards, Bill Corte, who is he?
A He's an IT guy.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Worked at the Rothstein firm?
A Yes.
Q And did he join the firm that you guys set
up, Farmer
A No.
Q Tell me the name of the firm again.
A Farmer, Jaffe, Weissing, Edwards, Fistos &
Lehrman.
Q Did not join them?
A No.
Q Did you work with him while he was at
Rothstein when you were employed there?
A We were both employed there.
Q Did you work with him on any of the Epstein
files?
A No. He didn't work on Epstein files. He was
an IT guy.
Q I understand.
Did you use him for any part of the
Epstein cases?
A I don't think he worked on any -- we didn't
have any IT needs, I don't believe.
Q We talked earlier about the settlement with
the three clients that you represented when you were
at Rothstein, and I think the number was
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
5.2 million --
A It was 5.5 million. It settled in July of
2010, not while I was at Rothstein.
Q No, I understand. They were the three
same three clients you represented while you were at
Rothstein's, right?
A Yes.
Q Can you tell me, of the 5.5, how much did
the three collectively collect from that?
A I don't remember that.
Q You didn't take those cases on a pro bono
basis, did you?
A No. It was a contingency arrangement,
similar to my arrangement with Mr. Scarola in this
case.
Q Okay. I understand. I understand.
So that contingency, do you remember what
percentage the contingency was?
A I don't.
Q Was it a third, 40 percent?
A Probably -- I don't know. But the standard
is between zero and a million, 40 percent if it's in
litigation; 1 to $2 million, 30 percent; and then over
$2 million, 20 percent or something. There's a sliding
scale. That's probably what was used.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Somewhere in that range, though. So on
average between 30 to 35 percent on total?
A Yeah.
Q Did your clients fund their expenses in the
litigation?
A No.
Q You fronted the expenses for them -- the
law firms did?
A Yeah.
Q The expenses that were fronted by the
Rothstein firm, were they ever collected?
A What do you mean by that?
Q So I assume when you were at the Rothstein
firm there were expenses advanced on behalf of the
three clients, right?
A Right.
Q And when Rothstein's firm went away, were
those expenses that the Rothstein firm advanced ever
paid to the trustee --
A Yeah.
Q -- or paid back --
A Yeah.
Q They were?
A Yes.
Q And how much was paid to the trustee for
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
the expenses?
A I don't remember that. I think this was
asked in a prior deposition and I gave the answer. I
remember this line of questioning, and I knew then. I
just don't now. Too many years have passed.
Q But there is some amount of the recovery
that went to the trustee, right?
A Yes.
Q Do you remember what the total costs were
that the three clients had deducted from the
settlement amount?
A I don't. Again, I definitely testified about
this at a time that I knew it, which was either my
second or third deposition. I don't remember anymore.
Q Do you have a rough estimate in your mind
about what the expenses were or the costs that were
advanced?
A Approximately $200,000.
Q When -- at the Rothstein firm, the
four-plus investigators that would work on the
matter, would they record their time as an expense
that the clients would pay?
A No.
Q They did not.
So a couple hundred thousand dollars in
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
costs, roughly 30, 32 percent contingency fee. I
got that about right?
A Yeah. I mean based on the math that we're
doing. Again, I'm approximating based on --
Q I understand.
A Yeah.
Q So -- that's really hard math. I like a
round number. Roughly a million six or seven in fees
to your -- to the firm?
A It wasn't that much, because we had to pay a
portion of the fees to the trustee, too.
Q Oh, they got a portion of the fees and the
cost?
half.
A Yes.
Q Do you remember what portion they got?
A I don't.
Q Half? More? Less?
A I just don't remember. I think less than
Q Do you? All right.
Other than --
A It worked out based on how long different
lawyers were there. And I was at RRA for such a short
period of time that it would not have been half.
That's my deductive reasoning that leads me to answer
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
that question that way.
Q I got it.
So there was -- obviously there were three
firms that had an interest in whatever the fee
recovery was. Brad Edwards, PA?
A Yep.
Q The Rothstein firm?
A Wait. No. Brad Edwards, PA didn't
It was the Rothstein firm -- when I came
to that firm, all of my cases became RRA cases. I
didn't retain --
Q Separate interest --
A No. I didn't retain any separate interest.
I just became an employee of a firm.
Q And gave them the cases?
A They were their cases.
Q I got it.
A So when I left, I took the cases with me
because there was no RRA anymore.
Q I didn't understand. Let me make sure I
got this. When you left Brad Edwards, PA and
became -- the salaried employee?
A Yes.
Q Salaried employee -- you brought those
cases with you and did not retain any percentage in
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
those cases?
A Correct.
Q Got it. And when those case leave and go
to the new Farmer firm, those cases go with, and
there's an agreement with the trustee for Rothstein
about how fees and costs will be shared?
A Exactly.
MR. LINK: Thank you very much. I have
questions only as to the areas that you
instructed him not to answer. But other
than that, I'm finished.
CROSS-EXAMINATION
BY MR. SCAROLA:
Q Brad, there were a number of questions
asked of you in regard to signatures on documents
that you do not recognize. But you testified that it
was your intent that those documents be filed under
your authority; is that correct?
A Right.
Q Do you have any reason to believe that,
although you did not recognize those signatures, that
those documents were signed without your authority?
A No. As I explained, I authorized the cases
to be filed. And any attorney could sign the pleading
and have it filed. It was my pleading. I wanted it to
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
be filed. Attorneys sign pleadings for people all the
time. So I authorized it to be filed.
Q There was --
A I think that the implication was that I
authorized somebody to sign my signature. I didn't
authorize anybody to sign my signature. I authorized
the cases to be filed -- an attorney could sign it, get
it filed.
Q Was that an unusual circumstance?
A No.
Q Was it unique in any respect with regard to
anything having to do with the Epstein cases?
A No.
Q Is it unusual in your experience for other
lawyers to operate in the same fashion?
A No. I signed pleadings. People sign
pleadings for me. It happens in every law firm that I
know, so --
Q You were also asked questions about your
knowledge of the compromise of claims based on
Jeffrey Epstein's intimidation. Did you have any
authority to settle claims without the knowledge and
consent of your clients?
A No.
Q Did you have any authority to refuse to
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
settle claims where your clients directed that their
claims be compromised?
A Repeat that question again.
Q Yes. You told us that you couldn't settle
a claim without your clients' authority. Did you
have any authority to refuse to settle a claim where
your client directed you to settle it?
A I did not. And as I explained, I wanted to
try all of those cases and not settle them. I settled
them because the clients wanted them settled.
Q Did Jeffrey Epstein's intimidation of
clients, to your knowledge, and without violation of
any attorney -client communication privilege, have an
impact on the amount for which claims against Jeffrey
Epstein were being settled?

MR. LINK: Object to the form. You are
going to testify about what the client said
but you are not waiving the privilege?

MR. SCAROLA: No. I'm asking him
whether from his perspective, as the trial
lawyer on those cases, whether Jeffrey
Epstein's intimidation had any impact on the
amount for which the claims were settled.
THE WITNESS: We are talking about just
the cases that I handled or all of the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
cases?
BY MR. SCAROLA:
Q Right now I'm talking about just cases that
you handled.
A Of course. It wasn't just my clients. Every
single one of the girls were scared to death of Jeffrey
Epstein and his intimidation, and my clients were no
different. It was the same. His intimidation was very
successful in reducing the amount that should been paid
to every single one of these abused girls very
successfully.

MR. LINK: I am going to object and
move to strike as inconsistent with the
testimony that you already gave under oath
to me, but you may continue.
BY MR. SCAROLA:
Q Do you have an opinion with regard to the
full value of the claims of the three clients that
you represented?
A Sure.
Q Did the value of those claims exceed the
amounts for which they actually settled?
A Of course.
Q What are the factors that go into the
assessment of the value of a claim against Jeffrey
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Epstein?

MR. LINK: Object to the form.
THE WITNESS: In my view, it was the
disparity of age between Jeffrey Epstein and
the particular victim. The way -- the types
of conduct, specifically, that Jeffrey
Epstein engaged in with the particular
victim. It wasn't all identical.
The psychological control that Jeffrey
Epstein gained over the particular victim,
the method that he gain that control over
the particular victim, and the lasting
impact that his abuse played in that
particular victim's life. Some recovered
better than others. Some didn't do well at
all.

MR. LINK: When you say some, are we
talking about your three clients?
THE WITNESS: I think we're talking
about how do you go into evaluating a claim
against Jeffrey Epstein.
MR. LINK: Generically, unrelated to
anyone specifically?
MR. SCAROLA: Generically.
MR. LINK: Okay.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
THE WITNESS: And then -- and then it
was an assessment of punitive damages,
which, from the best that any of us could
tell, it appeared that his net worth was
going to be in the range of $2 billion. And
the idea of punitive damages was to punish
him for the conduct that he committed
against that particular victim as well as to
deter him from engaging in similar conduct.
So understanding just how many other
victims had been abused, how long he had
been abusing these victims, with what --
with what frequency he was engaging in this
conduct, were all variables that would go
into making a determination just what amount
of money somebody would have to assess
against him to deter him from this habitual
conduct that he had been engaged in for
many years.
So when I put into a complaint that we
were requesting $50 million -- which is the
exact same number that Jeff Herman put into
his complaint -- I thought that was a very
fair number.
And in fact, I always knew that if you
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
took a billion dollars from Jeffrey Epstein
and left him with a billion dollars, you
would not have actually satisfied the rule
under punitive damages, because he would not
have been deterred from that future conduct
and using his money to create this pyramid
of underaged girls that he could abuse.
So all of that was what went into how I
assessed the value of all of these cases.
BY MR. SCAROLA:
Q Your earlier testimony established that
there were two separate cases filed in different
jurisdictions on behalf of One claim filed in
state court, one claim filed in federal court,
correct?
A Correct.
Q You have also acknowledged that both of
those claims arose out of the same misconduct on
Jeffrey Epstein's part, correct?
A That's correct.
Q Did the federal lawsuit seek the same
relief that the state lawsuit sought?
A No.
Q Explain that, if you would, please.
A So when Jeffrey Epstein agreed to a
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
non-prosecution agreement with the federal government,
there was a provision within that agreement that said
that if one of his victims brought a case against him
exclusively under 18 USC 2255, then only under that
circumstance of bringing that case exclusively under
that count would Jeffrey Epstein not contest liability
and agree to a minimum statutory damage amount of
$150,000. He later contested and said that an earlier
application of the statute applied and it should only
be $50,000.
But nonetheless, that was the general
principle. That statute did not allow for punitive
damages. And as I just explained, we assessed the
punitive damages as being extraordinary in the case.
So that's the answer to that question in
terms of the difference of the damages that we were
claiming in the state action, which contained a
claim for punitive damages and proceeded under
common law theories of battery or intentional
affliction, emotional distress. Those kinds of
things in the federal claim was to proceed under 18
USC 2255.
What happened in the summer of 2009 was
that it was realized -- like I said, not by me -- it
was initially realized by Mr. Cassell, but I agreed,
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
that III. 's case was proceeding only in state court,
and that we had not taken advantage at all of the
provision in the non-prosecution agreement, which
would allow for statutory damages under 18 USC 2255,
and that 's birthday -- 21st birthday, I
believe -- was coming up in August, and that the
statute of limitations would run -- or begin to run
at that birthday for bringing the 2255 claims.
Q Explain to the ladies and gentlemen of the
jury, if you would please, what the statute of
limitations as applied under the circumstance meant.
What was the significance of the statute of
limitations?
A Well, the statute of limitations in any sense
is you only have so long from the time that the tort or
the crime is committed to bring a claim, otherwise it's
waived forever.
So what we did not want to do is fail to
bring the claim under 2255 and that claim expire at
her 21st birthday, and it ultimately be a more
beneficial claim to have brought and us not have the
ability to bring it any more. Because it was also
around that same time that we began to believe
that -- there was an argument -- and perhaps the
right argument -- the argument that I still believe
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
to this day probably we would win on, but it never
got tested -- was that while Jeffrey Epstein, under
2255, would have to agree -- if you exclusively sued
him under that -- would have to agree to admit to
liability and to statutory minimum damages of
150,000. It was his position that that would be the
maximum regardless of the number of times that he
molested that particular person.
IMIIIII's circumstance, she had been
molested by him for years and dozens and dozens and
dozens of times. I don't know how many times.
Maybe 100 times while a minor. So we started to
think, you know what, if you settled one of these
cases for $150,000, it's grossly undervaluing the
case. If he has to admit to liability and you can
multiply 150,000 times the number of offenses that
he committed, it saves that victim from having to
endure extensive discovery and intimidation that
they -- especially -- was having to endure.
And if we win that argument, then that's definitely
the best way to try this case, especially for
Q Why that difference? Why would be
shielded from abuse to which she was subjected in the
state court proceeding if the determination was made
to proceed in federal court under 18 USC 2255?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A If that determination was made in federal
court, she would not have been shielded in state court,
but we could have dismissed the state court claim and
only proceeded under the federal case. Then we would
be presenting a case in front of the jury where all of
the -- let's call it dirt that Jeffrey Epstein had dug
up about would not be -- would not all have to
come into evidence, and we could save her some of the
problems that we assessed as being problems with her
case.
Q You spoke about the statute of limitations
andM turning 21. What is the statute of
limitations that applies in a federal 18 USC 2255
claim?
A From recollection, there were two readings of
the statute. I haven't seen the statute in a long
time -- at least in a while -- but it's -- it uses some
language that it's three years from the date that the
disability no longer exists, which we interpret as her
being a minor. So I think it's three years from the
time that she's no longer a minor.
So at the time she turned 21, there was an
argument that her 2255 claims, if we chose to
proceed under them, would have expired.
Q Did the timing of the filing of that
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
federal action have anything to do with any factor,
other than those that you have just described, the
potential expiration of the statute of limitations
and your desire to take advantage of the provisions
of the non-prosecution agreement as a potential
alternative to the state court claim?
A That is the only reason that we filed it at
that time.
Q Did Scott Rothstein have any role
whatsoever in that decision -making process?
A He never had any role in any decision -making
process with anything to do with any of these cases, so
no.
Q Did you become aware of the fact that your
Epstein -related files at some point in time had been
requested by Scott Rothstein?
A Yes.
Q How did you become aware of that?
A I think Mike told me -- Fisten.
Q Was there any explanation offered as to why
Scott Rothstein wanted to see the Epstein -related
files?
A That if these cases went to trial, he wanted
to try the cases with me.
Q He who?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A He, Scott Rothstein, wanted to try the case
with me. That's the explanation that I was given.
Q And was there anything suspicious about the
head partner in the firm telling you that in this
high-profile case he wanted to be part of the
prosecution team?
A No. If my associate brought in a
high-profile case right now, I would be the one to try
the case, despite the fact that she may be the only one
who knows anything about it. So there's nothing
suspicious about that.
Q Files got returned to you?
A Yes, files did get returned to me.
Q And -- was there anything about the request
for review of the files on the basis that Scott
Rothstein was considering participating in the
prosecution of those claims that aroused any
suspicion on your part?
A No.
Q Was there anything else that went on in the
short period of time that you were in that law firm
that gave any cause for you to suspect that your
files were being used in any way, directly or
indirectly, in connection with any illegal activity
of any kind?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A No. I was just a lawyer just working my case
and trying to prove my case. That's it. I wasn't
concerned with whatever other signals or signs there
were. But there weren't any. The most suspicious
thing was, there were police officers walking the
hallway. But police officers in the building didn't
give me that type of suspicion. It was an unnecessary
degree of security over the law firm, at best. But
with these files or any of the files, no suspicion
whatsoever.
Q Who were your coworkers in that law firm?
Who were the other lawyers that you were working
with?
A Just generally who was in the law firm?
Q Yeah. Give us a general description of the
quality of the people that were working for
Rothstein, Rosenfeldt & Adler during the period of
time that you became associated with the firm.
A Well, while I was at the firm, I worked with
Bill Berger, who had just come off the bench. He was a
judge.
Q There's been a number of references to Bill
Berger having just come off the bench. Was Judge
Berger a respected member of the judiciary in Palm
Beach County?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A Very much so, and that's why I welcomed him
to help with the file.
Q Did he leave under any circumstances that
gave rise to any suspicion whatsoever?

MR. LINK: Object to the form.
THE WITNESS: Not at all.
BY MR. SCAROLA:
Q Who were the other people that you were
working with?
A Like I said, I conducted -- I ran the files.
But other people --
Q When I say working with, I'm not talking
about limiting that question to people who worked on
the Epstein files. Who were the other folks that
were a part of this firm?
A Steve Jaffe, Gary Farmer, Matt Weissing.
Gary's Farmer's father was an appellate judge. In
fact, I think he was still on the bench then when we
were working there together. Gary is a senator now.
Matt Weissing, who became my partner. Steve Jaffe,
same. Mark Fistos, same.
These are high-quality people. Good
lawyers. The people that I associated with there,
good lawyers, good people, not doing anything bad.
They're just lawyers who are good lawyers. That's
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
it.
Q Did any of these high -qualify, respected,
good lawyers ever express any suspicion to you about
any of the activities that were being conducted
within that law firm?
A Not at all.
Q Did the unraveling of the Ponzi scheme come
as a total and complete surprise to you?
A Of course, yes.
Q Did you speak to anybody within the firm,
among those respected lawyers that you have
described, who indicated to you that the unraveling
of the Ponzi scheme did not come as a total and
complete surprise to them?
A All of them were just as surprised.

MR. SCAROLA: I have no further
questions.
MR. LINK: I have couple follow-ups on
it.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. LINK:
Q So, in your evaluation of the plaintiffs'
cases, generically, I didn't hear you describe any
aspect of the plaintiffs' past. Did you consider the
plaintiffs' past?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A I did.
Q You didn't say that when Mr. Scarola asked
you.

MR. SCAROLA: I disagree with you. I
think that that was identified. But the
record will speak for itself. That question
is argumentive.
THE WITNESS: I considered their past.
BY MR. LINK:
Q Okay. Talking generically.
A Sure. For a bunch of reasons, not the least
of which was how vulnerable were they before
Mr. Epstein abused them, how easy pry were they. That
factored big time into my assessment of the value of
the cases.
Q Did you factor into consideration other
sexual activity that they may have had?
A Sure. I took everything about them.
Q Whether they had worked as prostitutors
before?
A Before meeting Jeffrey Epstein?
Q Yeah.
A I don't remember that ever being the case
with any of them before meeting Jeffrey Epstein. That
might have been right after.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q Any of them ever worked at strip clubs
before meeting Mr. Epstein? Those kind of factors --
A All of those things I will take into
consideration. Every single one of these. These were
just little girls, so, yes,
into consideration.
Q Did you take into consideration any of them
having fake IDs that expressed an age of 18 or older?
Did you take that into consideration?
A That's ridiculous? That's just not true.
Q You didn't?
A There's, like, 100 underaged girls. That was
not a factor in this case. It might be --
Q I'm asking if it's a factor you'd take into
consideration generically.
I didn't think Mr. Scarola asked you about
a specific case. I said is this generic, and he
said, yes, this is generic.
A Are you talking about any case or just
Jeffrey Epstein?
Q No. He asked you about a generic case.
A With Jeffrey Epstein?
Q Yes.
A Yes. Somebody having a fake ID, I think that
that was, like, one of the defenses that somebody ran
I took all of those things
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
early on, but it's not a factor to consider in this
case.
Q Okay. So that's not a factor you would
have considered?
A No. I would have considered it if that was
true across the board. It just wasn't a factor in any
case related to Jeffrey Epstein.
Q Would you consider it a factor of any of
the victims changing their testimony from when they
spoke with the FBI until when they were -- when they
retained a lawyer? Would that impact your evaluation
of cases?
A I took into consideration all of those
circumstances.
Q All of those kinds of things.
How much did net from the settlement
proceeds?
A I don't remember.
Q Of the gross amount of the 5.5, which
portion was allocated to

MR. SCAROLA: Excuse me. That assumes
that there was a lump -sum settlement that
involved an allocation among the three.

MR. LINK: I was not suggesting it was
a lump -sum at all. I just know the total
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
number is 5.5.

MR. SCAROLA: When you talk about
allocating a portion of the 5.5, that
suggests --
MR. LINK: I will ask the question
again.

MR. SCAROLA: Okay. Thank you.
BY MR. LINK:
Q What was the settlement amount for
A You know it as well as me. I believe
$1 million. I could be wrong on that though.
Q Mr. Scarola asked you a bunch of questions
about the federal lawsuit and the statute of
limitations. Are you telling us that you filed a
245-page complaint to simply toll the statute of
limitation?
A It's only as long as it is because of the
number of times that Jeffrey Epstein molested her. As
you will see, it's just count after count after count,
so that we captured the number of counts that would
incorporate what he did to this particular person.
If it was one of the females who had only
gone to his house one or two times, it would be a
much shorter complaint. It's being held against me
that he molested so many times.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
Q I asked you if it's true that you filed
that complaint simply to toll the statute of
limitations. That's what I asked.
A And I've already explained that, yes, that's
why we filed it, to toll the statute of limitations.
Q And by filing it and not serving it, did
that accomplish the goal you set out?
A It did. Although, I ordered it to be served.
I mean, I wanted that complaint served.
Q Did you do anything -- did you believe it
had been served? Was it your mental state when you
left the Rothstein firm that that complaint had been
served on Mr. Epstein?
A I think I knew at that point in time that it
hadn't been served yet. But the intention was to serve
it, and I wanted it served on him at his house when he
was in town. It just wasn't always easy to serve
Mr. Epstein.
Q Did you -- tell me what efforts you made to
serve that complaint.
A I don't remember. What I usually do is serve
Q I don't want to know what you usually do.
What did you do to serve that complaint?
A I, like you, don't walk around serving
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
complaints, so I don't make efforts to serve anybody.
I'm not a process server. I tell somebody I want it
served, and hopefully they get a process server to
serve the complaint.
Q Who did you tell to hire a process server,
sir? Who did you tell to hire a process server?
A I don't remember who was doing that at RRA at
that time. We are talking about eight years ago.
Q Well, when you went -- started your own
firm, the Farmer Jaffe firm, did you make efforts to
serve the complaint?
A I don't remember.
Q Well, if you did, there would be some
correspondence or communication, I assume, with a
process server or somebody --
A I would think so.
Q Do you still have the communications and
files that relate to the federal court complaint
during the time period at Farmer Jaffe?
A I don't know. It is so not important to me
right now. I don't know.
Q But it was really important to you at the
time, because of the statute of limitations and her
21st birthday --
A We filed the complaint. We tolled the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
statute of limitations. I don't need to serve it
before then.
Q You would have to serve it to prosecute it,
right, and to recover under it? If the ultimate
goal, based on what you told me, is to recover
damages, then you can't accomplish that unless you
serve the complaint, agreed?
A You can accomplish that, but all you need to
do is file the complaint before the statute of
limitations run. That tolls the statute.
Q Sir, I'm asking about recovering the
damages. You gave us this whole litany of the
damages that you wanted to recover, and that by doing
this federal complaint you could recover money for
on the statutory counts. And I'm asking you in
order to accomplish the goal that you have told the
jury during Mr. Scarola's questioning, didn't you
have to first serve the complaint?
A If we were going to go to trial on the
federal case and not the state case, we would have had
to serve the complaint, and we would have had to drop
the state court case, go to trial on that complaint
because we would have had to proceed against him
exclusively under that count. So, yes, we --
Q You don't usually have to serve the
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
complaint until right before trial?
A I didn't say that.

MR. SCAROLA: He didn't say that.
BY MR. LINK:
Q You said if you were going to try it you
would have to serve it.
A You're just making things up.
MR. SCAROLA: He didn't say anything
like that.
BY MR. LINK:
Q So let me ask you this. When you filed
that complaint, was it your intent to prosecute that
action -- to move that action forward?
A When I filed that complaint it was to
preserve the statute of limitations in case we wanted
to go forward on that case and not the state case.
We were weighing, tactically, which way is
better for III
Q And did you make the decision to not pursue
the federal court case before service was effected?
A We ultimately made the decision to go forward
on the state court cases with and with
Q When was that decision made, sir?
A I don't remember when that decision was made.
Q Can you tell me approximately how long
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
after the complaint was filed that you made the
decision to abandon it?
A I don't know that we ever made the decision
to abandon it. Like I said, it was all premised on
this argument as to whether or not you are going to get
a multiplier by the number of events.
And I seem to remember that we started
getting into the legal pleadings on that debate
where Jeffrey Epstein was saying, no, it's $150,000,
regardless of the number of times I molested
anybody. And we were saying, No, you get the
multiplier. You can't molest somebody one time, pay
$150,000, and then get 99 free molestations. That
was, at least, our argument.
It was briefed in early 2010, I think, in
the Jane Doe case, in response to a motion for
summary judgment. And when that case settled, I
don't believe that Judge Marra had yet ruled on that
issue. In fact, I know that it was never ruled
upon. We never got the answer to that question.
So by that point in time, we had decided
we're going forward on the state court cases with
respect till.' and and we will go forward on
the federal case with respect to Jane Doe. And if
we win on that argument with Jane Doe, it may prompt
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
us to dismiss the counts that are not 2255 with
respect to Jane Doe. That was what was going on in
our mental processes with respect to how we were
going to process -- prosecute these cases.
Q So when did you withdraw the federal court
action foil.?
A I believe it was dismissed by stipulation as
part of the settlement when Jeffrey Epstein paid III. a
million dollars for molesting her. That's what I
believe.
Q So it sat there -- even though it wasn't
served, you didn't dismiss the case until there was a
settlement?
You filed it, but you didn't serve it?
A Right. I think that's right. It got
dismissed in 2010 when he settled the cases, when he
settled her --
Q So it just sat there without being
prosecuted, the federal court case?
A Yes. I think it got joined with the other 15
or 16 cases for discovery purposes and whatever else,
so I don't know about just sit there. It's not like a
normal case where it just sits.
Q Can you conduct discovery in a case before
you serve it? Can you do that?
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
A What would discovery look like? It's still
taking the same depositions of the same people, the
same time. So we were conducting discovery on behalf
of
In the state court action, it would have
looked exactly the same over here, which all would
have been together with all of the other victims
that he molested. So it wasn't like a single -act
case where you are not getting to do anything.
Everything else was happening. We weren't
hamstrung.
Q There wasn't anything happening for in
the federal court, was there?
A She's still the same person. Whether she has
a case in the state court or the federal court, we
still needed to conduct discovery against Jeffrey
Epstein to prosecute the same type of case.
Q So Scott Rothstein, what was his trial
experience in the fall of 2009?
A I was told from the time that I got there
that he was this amazing employment lawyer, trial
lawyer, and that's how -- that's how he had built this
reputation as -- that he was the best employment trial
lawyer in South Florida.
Q So you practiced in Fort Lauderdale for
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
seven years before you joined the firm -- before you
joined Rothstein's firm?
A I mean, I was a prosecutor for three of those
years, so you don't really know anybody. When you're a
prosecutor you know -- that's a different world.
Q You know criminals?
A Yeah, you know criminals. Exactly. And then
I was insurance defense attorney for the next three
years.
Q So you don't really know anybody?
A Well, you just know a different world of
people. It's not the same thing. I didn't run into
Scott Rothstein.
Q Had you ever heard of him?
A No. I had not really heard of him. I mean,
I heard of him from -- I had heard of the firm from
Russ Adler. I worked out of the same gym as Russ, so
he would tell me all the time how great the firm was
and how great Scott was. Personally, I had no
experience with the guy.
Q When Mr. Rothstein decided he was going to
be the lead trial lawyer, which case was that?
A He didn't decide he was going to be the lead
trial lawyer. You just make things up in questions all
day long.
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
I was told that he was going to try the
case with me. Period. Not more than, not less than
that. That's just it. Not be the lead, not be the
second, not be the third.
Q Just try the case with you?
A That's what I was told.
Q And that was okay because he was head of
the firm and he owned the files, right?
A Correct.
Q You were an employee, in your mind, and he
was the lawyer ultimately at the firm responsible for
the three clients, true?
A There's seventy lawyers at the firm. They
all work for him. Hundreds of files. He's still the
equity partner of the firm, so they are the firm's
files. They are not --
Q I understand. You told me earlier. And I
didn't realize that, that the interest that Bradley
Edwards, PA had in three files, you gave up to

Mr. Rothstein and became a salary employee,
essentially.
A Gave up to RRA.
Q Mr. Rothstein's firm, correct?
A Right. We've established this.
Q And so that Mr. Rothstein was the lawyer at
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
that firm as the -- one of two equity shareholders
who was ultimately responsible for the three Epstein
matters?
A For every case in the entire firm, including
those --
Q Including the three Epstein matters?
A Every case, yeah.
MR. LINK: I have no further questions.
MR. SCAROLA: I have nothing further.
We will read.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is 6:16
p.m., and that concludes this deposition.
- - -
(The deposition was concluded
at 6:16 p.m. )
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
CERTIFICATE OF OATH
STATE OF FLORIDA
: SS
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH )
I, the undersigned authority, certify that
BRADLEY EDWARDS personally appeared before me and was
duly sworn.
WITNESS my hand and official seal this 13th
day of November, 2017.
Sonja D. Hall
Commission No. : FF 082994
Notary Public - State of Florida
My Commission Expires: 2-01-18
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
REPORTER'S DEPOSITION CERTIFICATE
STATE OF FLORIDA )
: SS
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH )
I, SONJA D. HALL, certify that I was
authorized to and did stenographically report the
deposition of BRADLEY EDWARDS; that a review of the
transcript was requested; and that the transcript is a
true and complete record of my stenographic notes.
I further certify that on the 13th day of
November, 2017, I notified JACK SCAROLA, ESQUIRE that
the deposition of BRADLEY EDWARDS was ready for
reading and signing by the witness.
I further certify that I am not a relative,
employee, attorney, or counsel of any of the parties,
nor am I a relative or employee of any of the parties'
attorney or counsel connected with the action, nor am
I financially interested in the action.
Dated this 13th day of November, 2017.
SONJA D. HALL
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
TO: BRADLEY EDWARDS
c/o JACK SCAROLA, ESQUIRE
SEARCY, DENNEY, SCAROLA, BARNHART &
SHIPLEY, P.A.
2139 Palm Beach Lakes Boulevard
West Palm Beach, FL 33409
By JACK SCAROLA, ESQUIRE
RE: JEFFREY EPSTEIN vs. SCOTT ROTHSTEIN,
individually; BRADLEY EDWARDS, individually
At the conclusion of your deposition given
in the above -styled cause you indicated you wished to
read and sign the transcript.
This letter is to advise you that your
deposition is read and we ask that you call our
office at at your earliest convenience
for an appointment to come in.
If you are a party in this action and your
attorney has ordered a copy of this transcript, you
may wish to read his copy and forward to us a
photostatic copy of your signed correction sheet.
It is necessary that you do this as soon as
possible, since the transcript cannot be held beyond
two weeks from the date of this letter.
If you have any reason which you would like
for me to place on your deposition as to your failure
to sign the same, please advise.
Thank you for your prompt attention.
Very truly yours,
PALM BEACH REPORTING SERVICE, INC.
1665 Palm Beach Lakes Blvd.,
Suite 1001
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
BY: SONJA D. HALL
Date: November 13th, 2017
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
CORRECTION SHEET:
NAME: BRADLEY EDWARDS
RE: JEFFREY EPSTEIN vs. SCOTT ROTHSTEIN,
individually; BRADLEY EDWARDS, individually
The following corrections, additions or
deletions were noted on the transcript of the
testimony which I gave in the above -captioned matter
held on November 10th, 2017:
PAGE(S) LINE(S) SHOULD READ
SIGNATURE:
DATE:
Palm Beach Reporting Service, Inc.
EFTA00810362 (Jmail)
 [tech] Valar Ventures investor questionnaire
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
VALAR GLOBAL FUND IV LP
SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE
Your investment in Valar Global Fund IV LP (the "Fund") can only be made by means of the
completion, delivery and acceptance of the subscription documents in this package.
Please complete and submit the following documents:
o SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE: Complete all requested
information in this Subscription Agreement and Investor Questionnaire and date and sign the
signature page.
o IRS FORM W-9 OR FORM W-8: Complete and sign IRS Form W-9 or the applicable Form W-8
to certify your tax identification number or status.
Valar Ventures GP IV LLC (the "General Partner") reserves the right to request any additional
documentation necessary to verify your identity or otherwise complete the review process. The Fund and
the General Partner shall be held harmless by any such prospective limited partner against any loss arising
as a result of a failure to provide any requested documentation.
We take precautions to maintain the privacy of personal information concerning current and prospective
individual investors. For more information, please refer to our Privacy Policy attached as ExIIIBIT E.
THE OFFERING OF SECURITIES DESCRIBED IN THIS SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT HAS NOT
BEEN REGISTERED UNDER THE UNITED STATES SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED
(THE "SECURITIES ACT"), OR UNDER ANY SECURITIES LAWS OF ANY STATE OF THE
UNITED STATES OR ANY OTHER JURISDICTION. THIS OFFERING IS MADE PURSUANT TO
RULE 506 OF REGULATION D UNDER SECTION 4(AX2) OF THE SECURITIES ACT, WHICH
EXEMPT FROM SUCH REGISTRATION TRANSACTIONS NOT INVOLVING A PUBLIC
OFFERING. FOR THIS REASON, THESE SECURITIES WILL BE SOLD ONLY TO INVESTORS
WHO MEET CERTAIN MINIMUM SUITABILITY QUALIFICATIONS DESCRIBED HEREIN.
AN INVESTOR SHOULD BE PREPARED TO BEAR THE ECONOMIC RISK OF AN INVESTMENT
IN THE FUND FOR AN INDEFINITE PERIOD OF TIME BECAUSE THE PARTNERSHIP
INTERESTS HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OR THE LAWS OF
ANY OTHER JURISDICTION, AND, THEREFORE, CANNOT BE SOLD UNLESS THEY ARE
SUBSEQUENTLY REGISTERED OR AN EXEMPTION FROM REGISTRATION IS AVAILABLE.
THERE IS NO OBLIGATION ON THE ISSUER TO REGISTER THE PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS
UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OR THE LAWS OF ANY OTHER JURISDICTION. TRANSFER
OF THE PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS IS ALSO RESTRICTED BY THE TERMS OF THE
PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT RELATING THERETO.
PROSPECTIVE FOREIGN INVESTORS SHOULD CONSULT WITH THEIR OWN COUNSEL
REGARDING WHETHER OR NOT TO INVEST IN THE FUND. IT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY OF
ANY PERSON OR ENTITY WISHING TO PURCHASE AN INTEREST TO SATISFY HIMSELF,
HERSELF OR ITSELF AS TO THE FULL OBSERVANCE OF THE LAWS OF ANY RELEVANT
TERRITORY OUTSIDE OF THE UNITED STATES IN CONNECTION WITH ANY SUCH
PURCHASE, INCLUDING OBTAINING ANY REQUIRED GOVERNMENTAL OR OTHER
CONSENTS OR OBSERVING ANY OTHER APPLICABLE FORMALITIES.
In_  SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE
VALAR GLOBAL FUND IV LP
Investor Information
Legal Investor Name
Mailing Address Line #1
Mailing Address Line #2
City State ZIP Country
Street Address Line #1 (if different)
Street Address Line #2 (if different)
City State ZIP Country
Phone
Fax
Primary Email
State and Country of Organization (entities only)
Principal Place of Business (entities only)
State and Country of Residency (individuals)
Wire and Check Delivery Instructions for Distributions
Please provide wire and/or check delivery instructions for the transfer of any payments due from the
Fund. These instructions must be provided at account inception. The Investor may change these wire
instructions but may be required to provide an appropriate signature guarantee by a qualified financial
institution (note that a signature guarantee is different than a notarized signature).
Bank:
Bank Address:
Telephone Number of Bank:
9-Digit ABA:
SWIFT:
Account Name:
Account Number:
FFC Account Name: (if applicable):
FFC Account Number: (if applicable):
Reference / Attention (if applicable):
To be completed by investors with assets held at an offshore bank:
Correspondent Bank:
Correspondent ABA:
Correspondent SWIFT:
Correspondent Account Number:
Correspondent Misc. Details:
Instructions for Physical Check Delivery (if preferred)
Payee Name
Payee Address
Special Instructions
Primary Contact (1)
The following individual will receive all correspondence listed below, and is fully authorized to update
and change ownership information, provide instructions, and address procedural questions regarding the
Interest.
Contact Name
Company Name (if applicable)
Title (if applicable)
Mailing Address (if different from Investor)
City State ZIP
Street Address (if different from Investor)
City State ZIP
Phone
Fax
Email
Relationship to Investor
Other Interested Parties
Name (2)
Title
Mailing Address
City State ZIP
Phone
Name (3)
Title
Mailing Address
City State ZIP
Phone
Name (4)
Title
Mailing Address
City State ZIP
Phone
Street Address (if different)
City State ZIP
Relationship
Fax
Email
Street Address (if different)
City State ZIP
Relationship
Fax
Email
Street Address (if different)
City State ZIP
Relationship
Fax
Email
Please indicate below the appropriate correspondence for each party listed above.
Contact
Financial
Reports
Capital
Call
Notices
Cash
Distribution
Notices
Stock
Distribution
Notices
K-1 and
Tax
Reporting
General
Notices
*Stock
Distribution
Contact
**Fully
Authorized

(1) X X X X X X X X
(2)
(3)
(4)
Key
* Stock Distribution Contact = Person(s) to be called by the distributing broker upon distribution of
Securities.
** Fully Authorized = Authorized to update contact info, add/remove parties to the account, and change
ownership information, such as wiring instructions.
PLEASE NOTE: If copies of correspondence, periodic reports, capital calls, distribution notices, tax
information, etc. should be provided to additional parties, please provide specific instructions and
complete contact information as noted above (or separately). Please note that if any information is
requested to be delivered to a party other than the Limited Partner, the General Partner will retain sole and
absolute discretion over whether such additional party may receive the information, and such additional
party may be required to execute a nondisclosure agreement in connection therewith. Also note that the
General Partner will eventually need wire and check delivery instructions for the transfer of any payments
due from the Fund. If such information is not provided at account inception, the General Partner will
request such information after the closing.
Investor Type. The Interest will be held under the following type of ownership / structure [Please check
all applicable boxesj:
❑ Individual ❑ Joint Individuals ❑ Limited Liability Company ❑ Limited Partnership
❑ Revocable Trust with grantors ❑ Irrevocable Trust ❑ IRA / Keogh / SEP
❑ C Corporation ❑ Tax-Exempt Organization ❑ S Corporation ❑ General Partnership
❑ Employee Benefit Plan ❑ ERISA Partner ❑ Estate ❑ Nominee ❑ Foreign Government Entity
❑ U.S. State or Municipal Government Entities ❑ Pension Plan ❑ Fund of Funds
❑ Insurance Company ❑ Investment Company Registered with SEC ❑ Broker-Dealer
❑ Private Fund ❑ Bank Holding Company ❑ Private Foundation ❑ 501(cX3)
❑ Government Pension Plan ❑ Foreign Investor ❑ Other

1. Accredited Investor Status. The Investor is an "accredited investor" (within the meaning of Rule 501
under the Securities Act). Please see the definition of "accredited investor" in EXHIBIT A.
❑ Yes ❑ No

2. Qualified Client Status. The Investor is a "qualified client" (within the meaning of Rule 205-3 under
the Advisers Act). Please see the definition of "qualified client" in EXHIBIT B.
❑ Yes ❑ No

3. Qualified Purchaser Status. The Investor is a "qualified purchase?' (within the meaning of Section
2(a)(51) under the Companies Act). Please see the definition of "qualified purchase?' in EXHIBIT C.
❑ Yes ❑ No

4. Investment Company Act Matters. If the Investor is an Entity (including a trust), is the Investor
either (a) an "investment company" under the United States Investment Company Act of 1940, as
amended (the "Companies Act"), or (b) relying on either Section 3(c)(1) or Section 3(c)(7) of the
Companies Act to be excepted from the definition of "investment company" as defined in Section 3(a) of
the Companies Act.'
❑ No
❑ Yes, the Investor relies on Section 3(c)(1) of the Companies Act
❑ Yes, the Investor relies on Section 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act
❑ Yes, the Investor is an investment company
I See definitions in EXHIBIT D hereto.
If the Investor relies on either Section 3(c)(I) or Section 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act, in order to
accurately count the number of beneficial owners of the Fund, please specify the number of beneficial
owners of the outstanding securities (other than short-term paper) of the Investor and any existing or
prospective limited partners of the Fund that control, are controlled by, or are under common control with
the Investor (such other limited partners referred to as "Affiliated Investors"):
[Insert Number]
The Investor further represents and warrants that neither the Investor nor any Affiliated Investor has been
structured or operated for the purpose of circumventing the registration requirements of the Companies
Act.

5. Written Disclosure Exceptions.
If the Investor has information or an exception to disclose to the General Partner in accordance
with paragraph 5(a) of this Agreement (e.g., ERISA status, FOIA disclosures, an SPV created to
invest in the Fund, AIFMD matters, etc.), please describe below or attach additional pages:
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND
INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE as of the date written below.
INDIVIDUAL INVESTOR: ENTITY INVESTOR:
(Signature) (Legal Name of Entity)
By:
Name:
Date:  Title:
Date:
(Print Name)
CAPITAL COMMITMENT: $
SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE
ACCEPTANCE PAGE
(To Be Completed by the General Partner)
By its execution of this Acceptance Page, the General Partner and the Fund hereby accept the foregoing
subscription on the terms set forth in this Subscription Agreement and Investor Questionnaire either for

(a) the Capital Commitment set forth below or (b) if the Capital Commitment below is left blank, the
Investor's Capital Commitment amount shall be as set forth on the Investor's signature page to this
Subscription Agreement and Investor Questionnaire, and by such acceptance admits the Investor as a
Limited Partner, and binds itself and the Investor to the terms of the Partnership Agreement and this
Subscription Agreement and Investor Questionnaire.
Capital Commitment: $
SUBSCRIPTION ACCEPTED:
Accepted on:
GENERAL PARTNER:
VALAR VENTURES GP IV LLC
By:
Name:
Title: Managing Member
FUND:
VALAR GLOBAL FUND IV LP
By: Valar Ventures GP IV LLC
Its: General Partner
By:
Name:
Title: Managing Member
This SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE (this "Agreement") is entered into
by and among Valar Ventures GP IV LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the "General
Partner"), Valar Global Fund IV LP, a Delaware limited partnership (the "Fund"), and the investor
identified on the signature page hereto (the "Investor") in connection with the Investor's purchase of a
limited partner interest (the "Interest") in the Fund, and admission of the Investor as a Limited Partner
pursuant to the terms of the Fund's Limited Partnership Agreement, as it may be amended from time to
time (the "Partnership Agreement"). Capitalized terms used herein and not otherwise defined shall have
the meanings given to them in the Partnership Agreement.
The Investor subscribes for an Interest, and the General Partner, the Fund, and the Investor hereby
agree as follows:

1. Subscription for a Limited Partner Interest.
(a) Subject to the terms and conditions set forth in this Agreement, the Investor agrees (a) to
purchase from the Fund the Interest at a purchase price equal to 100% of the amount set
forth on the Investor's signature page hereto on the line captioned "Capital Commitment"
or such lesser amount as the General Partner may accept pursuant to paragraph 3(b) of
this Agreement (the Investor's "Capital Commitment"), payable in the manner and at the
times provided in the Partnership Agreement, (b) to become a party to, and be bound by
all the terms and provisions of, the Partnership Agreement and to perform all obligations
therein imposed upon a Limited Partner with respect to the Interest and (c) to become a
Limited Partner of the Fund.

(b) The Investor agrees to contribute, in installments, an aggregate amount equal to the
Investor's Capital Commitment pursuant to the terms of, and at the times required by, the
Partnership Agreement. (All references herein are to United States Dollars.) All
payments of the Investor's Capital Commitment shall be made by wire transfer pursuant
to instructions provided by the General Partner prior to the due date of such payments.
The Investor understands that, except as otherwise provided in the Partnership
Agreement, the Investor may not make less than the full amount of any required capital
contribution or return less than the total amount of distributions required to be returned,
and that default provisions with respect thereto, pursuant to which the Investor may suffer
substantial adverse consequences (including, but not limited to, the loss of its entire
investment in the Fund), are contained in the Partnership Agreement.

2. Adoption. If the Investor is accepted as a Limited Partner pursuant to paragraph 3 below, the
Investor hereby agrees to be bound by all the terms and provisions of the Partnership Agreement
(whether or not such Investor has signed the Partnership Agreement) and to perform all
obligations imposed upon a Limited Partner with respect to the Interest.

3. Acceptance of Subscription; Delivery of Partnership Agreement. The Investor understands
and agrees that this subscription is made subject to the following terms and conditions:

(a) The General Partner shall have the right to review the suitability of any person desiring to
purchase an Interest and, in connection with such review, to waive such suitability
standards as to such person as the General Partner deems appropriate under applicable
law;

(b) The General Partner shall have the right, in its sole discretion, to reject this subscription,
in whole or in part, and the subscription shall be deemed to be accepted only when the
Investor has been admitted to the Fund as a Limited Partner (i.e., Limited Partner's
subscription was accepted by the General Partner);

(c) The General Partner shall have no obligation to accept subscriptions in the order
received;
(d) The Investor hereby requests and authorizes the General Partner to enter the Investor's
name in the books and records of the Fund as a holder of the Interest;

(e) The Interest to be created on account of this subscription shall be created only in the
name of the Investor, and the Investor agrees to comply with the terms of the Partnership
Agreement and to execute any and all further documents necessary in connection with
becoming a Limited Partner of the Fund; and
(0 The Investor hereby undertakes in respect of the Interest that the Investor (i) shall comply
with the restrictions on transfer of the Interest contained in the Partnership Agreement;
and (ii) understands that upon a default of the Investor's capital contribution obligations
to the Fund, the Interest may, among other consequences, be subject to forfeiture in
accordance with the terms of the Partnership Agreement.

4. Conditions to Closing. The Fund's obligations hereunder are subject to acceptance by the
General Partner of the Investor's subscription and to the fulfillment, prior to or at the time of
closing, of each of the following conditions:

(a) The representations and warranties of the Investor contained in this Agreement and the
Partnership Agreement shall be true and correct at the time of closing; and

(b) All proceedings in connection with the transactions contemplated hereby and all
documents and instruments incident to such transactions shall be satisfactory in substance
and form to the General Partner, the Fund and Cooley LLP, legal counsel to the Fund
("Fund Counsel"), and the General Partner, the Fund or Fund Counsel shall have
received all such counterpart originals or certified or other copies of such documents as
the General Partner may request.

5. Investor's Representations. In connection with the Investor's purchase of the Interest, the
Investor makes the following representations and warranties on which the General Partner, the
Fund and Fund Counsel are entitled to rely:

(a) Except as otherwise disclosed in writing to the General Partner in this Agreement prior to
the acceptance by the General Partner of the Investor's subscription:
(0 To the best of the Investor's knowledge, the Investor does not control, nor is it
controlled by, or under common control with, any other Limited Partner of the
Fund.

(ii) If an entity, the Investor has made investments prior to the date hereof or intends
to make investments in the near future. If the Investor is an entity that has
beneficial owners (as applicable), each beneficial owner of interests in the
Investor has and will share in the same proportion of each such investment.
(iii) If an entity, the Investor's investment in the Fund will not constitute more than
forty percent (40%) of the Investor's assets (including for this purpose any
committed capital for an Investor that is an investment fund). The term
"committed capital" includes all amounts which have been contributed to the
Investor by its shareholders, partners, members or other beneficial owners plus
all amounts which such persons remain obligated to contribute to the Investor.

(iv) If the Investor is an entity that has beneficial owners (as applicable), the
governing documents of the Investor require that each beneficial owner of the
Investor, including, but not limited to, shareholders, partners and beneficiaries,
participate through such beneficial owner's interest in the Investor in all of the
Investor's investments and that the profits and losses from each such investment
are shared among such beneficial owners in the same proportions as all other
investments of the Investor. No such beneficial owner may vary such beneficial
owner's share of the profits and losses or the amount of such beneficial owner's
contribution for any investment made by the Investor.

(v) If an entity, the Investor was not organized or recapitalized (and is not to be
recapitalized) for the specific purpose of acquiring the Interest. The term
"recapitalized" shall include new investments made in the Investor solely for the
purpose of financing its acquisition of the Interest and not made pursuant to a
prior financial commitment.

(vi) The Investor does not have, in purchasing an Interest, a principal purpose of
permitting the Fund to satisfy the 100-partner limitation contained in Treasury
Regulations Section 1.7704-1(h)(1) and, to the best of the Investor's knowledge,
no owner of a beneficial interest in the Investor has such a purpose.
(vil) The Investor is not an "employee benefit plan," as defined in Section 3(3) of
ERISA, that is subject to the provisions of Part 4 of Title I of ERISA, a "plan," as
defined in Section 4975(e)(1) of the Code, that is subject to Section 4975 of the
Code, or an entity that is deemed to be a "benefit plan investor" under the U.S.
Department of Labor final plan assets regulation, 29 C.F.R. §2510.3-101, as
amended (the "Regulation") and as modified by Section 3(42) of ERISA.
(viii) The following representations are included with the intention of enabling the
Fund to qualify for the benefit of a "safe harbor" under Treasury Regulations
from treatment of the Fund as an entity subject to corporate income tax. Either:

(1) The Investor is not a partnership, grantor trust, or Subchapter S
corporation for U.S. federal income tax purposes, or

(2) The Investor is a partnership, grantor trust, or Subchapter S corporation
for U.S. federal income tax purposes, but (1) at no time during the term
of the Fund will 65% or more of the value of any beneficial owner's
direct or indirect interest in the Investor be attributable to the Investor's
interests in the Fund, (2) less than 65% of the value of the Investor is
attributable to the Investor's interests in the Fund, and (3) permitting the
Fund to satisfy the 100-partner limitation set forth in Section 1.7704-
1(h)(1)(ii) of the Treasury Regulations is not a principal purpose of any
beneficial owner of the Investor in investing in the Fund through the
Investor.
If the Investor is unable to make either of such representations, the Investor
hereby agrees to provide the General Partner, prior to the effective date of the
purchase of the Interest, with evidence (including opinions of counsel, if
requested) satisfactory in form and substance to the General Partner relating to
the status of the Fund under Section 7704 of the Code. Further, if at any time
after the effective date of the purchase of the Interest the Investor can no longer
make either of such representations, the Investor shall promptly notify in writing
the General Partner.

(ix) Neither the Investor nor any of its Beneficial Ownersi has been subject to any
Regulation D Rule 506(d) disqualifying event as defined below and is not subject
to any proceeding or event that could result in any such disqualifying event
("Disqualifying Event"). The following representations apply to the Investor as
well as each direct and indirect owner of the Investor that would own twenty
percent (20%) or more of the Fund's Interests if such owner were a direct limited
partner in the Fund (each a "Significant Owner"). By way of example only, if
the Investor owns 40% of the Fund's Interests, the Investor would have a
Significant Owner if one of the Investor's beneficial owners owns 50% or more
of the outstanding equity of the Investor. Each of the enumerated instances
below is a "Disqualifying Event." The Investor or any Beneficial Owner has
been subject to a Disqualifying Event if such person:

(1) Has been convicted within ten years of the date hereof of any felony or
misdemeanor (i) in connection with the purchase or sale of any security,

(ii) involving the making of any false filing with the U.S. Securities and
Exchange Commission (the "SEC') or (iii) arising out of the conduct of
the business of an underwriter, broker, dealer, municipal securities
dealer, investment adviser or paid solicitor of purchasers of securities;

(2) Is subject to any order, judgment or decree of any court of competent
jurisdiction entered within five years of the date hereof that presently
restrains or enjoins such person from engaging or continuing to engage
in any conduct or practice (i) in connection with the purchase or sale of
any security, (ii) involving the making of any false filing with the SEC or
(iii) arising out of the conduct of the business of an underwriter, broker,
dealer, municipal securities dealer, investment adviser or paid solicitor of
purchasers of securities;

(3) Is subject to a final order of a state securities commission (or an agency
or officer of a state performing like functions); a state authority that
supervises or examines banks, savings associations or credit unions; a
state insurance commission (or an agency or officer of a state performing
like functions); an appropriate federal banking agency; the U.S.
2 "Beneficial Owner" means an individual or entity who, directly or indirectly, through any contract, arrangement,
understanding, relationship or otherwise has or shares, or is deemed to have or share: (I) voting power, which includes 
the power
to vote, or to direct the voting of, the Interest; andfor (2) investment power, which includes the power to dispose, or 
to direct the
disposition of, the Interest, as determined consistent with Rule 13d-3 of the U.S. Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the
"Exchange Act').
Commodity Futures Trading Commission; or the National Credit Union
Administration that (i) as of the date hereof, bars such person from (A)
association with an entity regulated by such commission, authority,
agency or officer, (B) engaging in the business of securities, insurance or
banking or (C) engaging in savings association or credit union activities
or (ii) constitutes a final order based on a violation of any law or
regulation that prohibits fraudulent, manipulative or deceptive conduct
entered within ten years of the date hereof;

(4) Is subject to any order of the SEC pursuant to Section 15(b) or 15B(c) of
the Exchange Act or Section 203(e) or (f) of the Investment Advisers Act
that as of the date hereof (i) suspends or revokes such person's
registration as a broker, dealer, municipal securities dealer or investment
adviser, (ii) places limitations on the activities, functions or operations of
such person or (iii) bars such person from being associated with any
entity or from participating in the offering of any penny stock;

(5) Is subject to any order of the SEC entered within five years of the date
hereof that presently orders such person to cease and desist from
committing or causing a violation or future violation of CO any scienter-
based anti-fraud provision of the federal securities laws or (ii) Section 5
of the Securities Act;

(6) Is, as of the date hereof, suspended or expelled from membership in, or
suspended or barred from association with a member of, a registered
national securities exchange or a registered national or affiliated
securities association for any act or omission to act constituting conduct
inconsistent with just and equitable principles of trade;

(7) Has filed (as a registrant or issuer), or was or was named as an
underwriter in, any registration statement or Regulation A offering
statement filed with the SEC that, within five years of the date hereof,
was the subject of a refusal order, stop order or order suspending the
Regulation A exemption, or is presently the subject of an investigation or
proceeding to determine whether a stop order or suspension order should
be issued; or

(8) Is subject to a United States Postal Service false representation order
entered within five years of the date hereof or is presently subject to a
temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction with respect to
conduct alleged by the United States Postal Service to constitute a
scheme or device for obtaining money or property through the mail by
means of false representations.

(9) To the best of the Investor's knowledge, neither the Investor nor any
Beneficial Owner or Significant Owner is currently the subject of any
threatened or pending investigation, proceeding, action or other event
that, if adversely determined, would give rise to any of the events
described in clauses (1)-(8) above.

(x) The Investor will immediately notify the General Partner in writing if the
Investor or any of its Beneficial Owners become subject to a Disqualifying Event
at any date after the date hereof. In the event that the Investor or any Beneficial
Owner becomes subject to a Disqualifying Event at any date after the date hereof,
the Investor agrees and covenants to use its best efforts to coordinate with the
General Partner (i) to provide documentation as reasonably requested by the
General Partner related to any such Disqualifying Event and (ii) to implement a
remedy to address the Investor's or the Beneficial Owner's changed
circumstances such that the changed circumstances will not affect in any way the
Fund's or its affiliates' ongoing and/or future reliance on the Rule 506 exemption
under the Securities Act. The Investor acknowledges that, at the discretion of the
General Partner, such remedies may include, without limitation, the waiver of all
or a portion of the Investor's voting power in the Fund, the Investor's removal
from the Fund, and/or the Investor's withdrawal from the Fund through the
transfer or sale of its Interest in the Fund. The Investor also acknowledges that
the General Partner may periodically request assurance that the Investor and its
Beneficial Owners have not become subject to a Disqualifying Event at any date
after the date hereof, and the Investor further acknowledges and agrees that the
General Partner shall understand and deem the failure by the Investor to respond
in writing to such requests to be an affirmation and restatement of the
representations, warranties and covenants in this paragraph and paragraph
5(a)(ix).

(xi) Except as otherwise disclosed in writing in this Agreement, the Investor and any
Beneficial Owner of the Investor do not and will not "beneficially own" (within
the meaning of Rule I3d-3 of the Exchange Act) any other limited partner
interest in the Fund except for the interest subscribed to by the Investor in this
Agreement, and the Investor and any Beneficial Owner of the Investor have not
agreed with one or more other Limited Partners (or the "beneficial owners" of
such Limited Partner(s)) to act together for the purpose of acquiring, holding,
voting or disposing of limited partner interests in the Fund (within the meaning
of Rule I 3d-5 of the Exchange Act).
(xii) Neither the Investor nor one or more of the Investor's beneficial owners is either
(A) a public agency, department, office or pension plan, or (B) subject (or is an
agent, nominee, fiduciary, custodian or trustee of an entity which is itself subject)
to (1) Section 552(a) of Title 5, of the United States Code (commonly known as
the "Freedom of Information Act") or state freedom of information statutes or
other similar federal, state, county or municipal public disclosure statutes or
regulations, whether foreign or domestic, (2) disclosure obligations with respect
to any of the Fund's Confidential Information to a government agency or other
regulatory body, trading exchange, or other market where interests in such
investor are sold or traded (or to the regulating body thereof), whether foreign or
domestic, or (3) disclosure obligations with respect to any of the Fund's
Confidential Information to a government body, agency or committee (including,
without limitation, any disclosures required in accordance with the Ethics in
Government Act of 1978, as amended, and any rules and regulations of any
executive, legislative or judiciary organization), whether foreign or domestic.
(ilii) The Investor acknowledges that neither the General Partner nor its Affiliates
provide, or intend to provide, advice to the Fund with respect to investment
strategies that are "plans or programs for the investment of the proceeds of
municipal securities or the recommendation of and brokerage of municipal
escrow investments" (within the meaning of Rule 15Ba 1 -1 promulgated under
the Exchange Act). The Investor represents and agrees that none of its
contributions to the Fund will consist of "proceeds of municipal securities"
(within the meaning of Rule 15Bal-1).
(xiv) The Investor (a) is not resident or domiciled in a member state of the European
Economic Area (an "EEA Member State") or in Switzerland, Guernsey or
Jersey, (b) does not have, and is not part of a group that includes an entity that
has, a registered office in an EEA Member State or in Switzerland, Guernsey or
Jersey, (c) has made its own decision to invest, and is not following or
implementing a decision to invest that was taken by, on the instructions of, or on
behalf of any other legal or natural person who is resident or domiciled or has a
registered office in an EEA Member State or in Switzerland, Guernsey or Jersey,
and (d) does not have and is not relying to any extent on an investment manager
with discretionary authority to make the decision to invest for the Interests on
behalf of or for the account of the Investor, where that manager is resident or
domiciled or has a registered office in an EEA Member State or in Switzerland,
Guernsey or Jersey. If any of clauses (a) through (d) above are untrue, the
Investor hereby certifies, represents and confirms the following:

(1) Any document or information sent or otherwise communicated to the
Investor relating to the Fund or any related investment was sent to the
Investor at its request or that of its agent or representative and otherwise
upon its own initiative;

(2) The Investor is (i) a "professional investor", if Investor is resident or
domiciled or has its registered office in an EEA Member State, as that
term is used in and defined by the European Union's Markets in
Financial Instruments Directive (2004/39/EC); (ii) a regulated financial
intermediary, or a non-regulated "qualified investor", under the Swiss
Federal Act on Collective Investment Schemes (CISA); or (iii) the
nearest equivalent to a "professional investor", a regulated financial
intermediary and/or a non-regulated "qualified investor" under the
equivalent legislation of Guernsey or Jersey;

(3) None of the Fund, the Management Company, the General Partner, or
their respective members, managers, partners, principals, directors,
officers, consultants, employees, affiliates, agents, personnel, and related
persons have engaged in any "marketing", "distribution", or "promotion"
of the Fund, and they have not "circulated" the Fund, to Investor and, as
far as the Investor is aware, such persons have not engaged in any
"marketing", "distribution", or "promotion" of, and they have not
"circulated", the Fund in an EEA Member State, Switzerland, Guernsey
or Jersey either. (For these purposes, (i) "marketing" has the meaning
given to it in and by the Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive
(2011/61/EU); (ii) "distribution" has the meaning given to it in any by
the Swiss Federal Act on Collective Investment Schemes (CISA); (iii)
"promotion" has the meaning given to it in and by the Protection of
Investors (Bailiwick of Guernsey) Law 1987; and (iv) "circulated' has
the meaning given to it in and by the Control of Borrowing (Jersey) Law
1947 and the Control of Borrowing (Jersey) Order 1958;

(4) The Investor confirms that it was not solicited to express an interest in
the Fund;
(5) The Investor is aware that the Fund has not been approved for marketing,
distribution, promotion or circulation in an EEA Member State,
Switzerland, Guernsey or Jersey; and that interests in the Fund cannot be
marketed, distributed, promoted, circulated, offered or sold in any of
these jurisdictions without the permission of the relevant authorities; and

(6) The Investor acknowledges, for the avoidance of doubt, that the
indemnification obligations of the Investor pursuant to the
indemnification provision in this Agreement apply to the Investor with
respect to these matters.

(b) The Investor has received, read and understands that certain Confidential Private
Placement Memorandum, as it may be amended and supplemented from time to time (the
"Memorandum"), the Partnership Agreement, and this Agreement, and acknowledges
and agrees that the Memorandum, the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement
constitute the sole offering materials on which the offer of the Interest to the Investor is
based. No representations or warranties have been made to the Investor by the Fund, the
General Partner or any agent of said persons, other than as set forth in the Memorandum,
the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement.

(c) The Investor is acquiring the Interest solely for the Investor's own account and not
directly or indirectly for the account of any other person whatsoever (or, if the Investor is
acquiring the Interest as a trustee, solely for the account of the trust or trust account
named herein) for investment and not with a view to, or for sale in connection with, any
distribution of the Interest. The Investor does not have any contract, undertaking or
arrangement with any person to sell, transfer or grant a participation to any person with
respect to the Interest.

(d) The Investor has such knowledge and experience in financial and business matters that
the Investor is capable of evaluating the merits and risks of the investment evidenced by
the Investor's purchase of the Interest, and the Investor is able to bear the economic risk
of such investment including the risk of complete loss.

(e) The Investor has had access to such information concerning the Fund as the Investor
deems necessary to enable the Investor to make an informed decision concerning the
purchase of the Interest. The Investor has had access to representatives of the General
Partner and the opportunity to ask questions of, and receive answers satisfactory to the
Investor from, such representatives concerning the offering of Interests and the Fund
generally. The Investor has obtained all additional information requested by the Investor
to verify the accuracy of all information furnished in connection with the offering of
Interests, evaluate the merits and risks of an investment in the Interest or otherwise
relative to the proposed activities of the Fund.
The Investor understands that the Interest has not been registered under the United States
Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the "Securities Act") or any securities law of any
state of the United States or any other jurisdiction, in each case in reliance on an
exemption for private offerings.

(g) The Investor is aware that (i) the Investor must bear the economic risk of investment in
the Interest for an indefinite period of time, possibly until final winding up of the Fund,

(ii) because the Interest has not been registered under the Securities Act, there is currently
no public market therefor and it is not anticipated that such a market will ever develop,
(iii) the Investor may not be able to avail itself of the provisions of Rule 144 of the
Securities Act with respect to the Interest, and (iv) the Interest cannot be sold or
otherwise disposed of unless subsequently registered under the Securities Act or an
exemption from such registration is available. The Investor understands that the Fund is
under no obligation, and does not intend, to effect any such registration at any time. The
Investor also understands that sales or transfers of the Interest are further restricted by the
provisions of the Partnership Agreement and, as applicable, securities laws of other
jurisdictions and the states of the United States. The Investor has no need for liquidity in
connection with its purchase of the Interest, and is able to bear the risk of loss of its entire
investment in the Interest.
(h) The Investor agrees not to resell or otherwise transfer all or any part of the Interest,
except as permitted by law, including without limitation, any regulations under the
Securities Act and the applicable securities acts or similar statutes of the jurisdiction in
which the Investor resides, including all regulations and rules of such laws, together with
applicable published policy statements, instruments, notices and blanket orders or rulings
of general applications (collectively, "Applicable Securities Laws"), and the terms of this
Agreement and the Partnership Agreement. The transfer of the Interest and the
substitution of another Limited Partner for the Investor is restricted by and subject to the
terms of the Partnership Agreement and the consent of the General Partner.
The Fund is relying on (and the offering is conditional upon) an exemption from the
requirement to provide the Investor with a prospectus under the Applicable Securities
Laws and, as a consequence of acquiring the Interest pursuant to such exemption, certain
protections, rights and remedies provided by the Applicable Securities Laws, including
statutory rights of rescission or damages, may not be or may only be partially available to
the Investor, or others for whom it is contracting hereunder. Such persons may not
receive information that would otherwise be required to be provided under the Applicable
Securities Laws and the Fund is relieved from certain obligations that would otherwise
apply under the Applicable Securities Laws. The Investor acknowledges that the Investor
is purchasing the Interest without being furnished any offering literature or prospectus
other than the Memorandum, the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement. The
Investor did not rely on any information whatsoever, except for the Memorandum, the
Partnership Agreement and this Agreement, to make such decision and such materials
were not accompanied by any advertisement, including, without limitation, in printed
public media, radio, television or telecommunications, including electronic display and
the intemet, or part of a general solicitation.
The Investor acknowledges that it is not purchasing the Interest as a result of or
subsequent to (i) any advertisement, article, notice or other communications published in
any newspaper, magazine or other similar media (including any intemet site that is not
password protected) or broadcast over television or radio, or (ii) any seminar or meeting
whose attendees, including the Investor, had been invited as a result of, subsequent to or
pursuant to the foregoing.

(k) The Fund is not being registered, and the General Partner does not have any intention of
registering the Fund, as an "investment company" as the term "investment company" is
defined in Section 3(a) of the U.S. Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the
"Investment Company Act"). None of the General Partner, the Management Company
or their respective members, managers, shareholders, partners, or any other person
selected by the General Partner to act as agent or adviser of the Fund with respect to
managing the affairs of the Fund is currently intended to be registered as an investment
adviser under the U.S. Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended (the "Advisers
Act").
The purchase of the Interest by the Investor is consistent with the general investment
objectives of the Investor. The Investor hereby acknowledges that it has not relied on the
General Partner, the Management Company or any of their respective officers, directors,
employees, members, managers, partners, managing directors or Affiliates for investment
advice with respect to an investment in the Fund.

(m) The Investor's full legal name, true and correct address of residence (for individuals) or
principal place of business (for entities), phone number, electronic mail address, United
States taxpayer identification number (each, if applicable) and other contact information
are provided in this Agreement. For so long as the Investor holds an Interest, the Investor
hereby agrees to promptly notify the General Partner of any change in such contact
information after the date hereof.

(n) The Investor received this Agreement and the Partnership Agreement and first learned of
the Fund in the jurisdiction listed as the address of the Investor set forth in this
Agreement, and intends that the Applicable Securities Laws of that jurisdiction alone
shall govern this transaction. If the Investor is not a resident of the United States, the
Investor understands that it is the responsibility of the Investor to satisfy himself, herself
or itself as to full observance of the laws of any relevant territory outside of the United
States in connection with the offer and sale of the Interest, including obtaining any
required governmental or other consent or observing any other applicable formalities.

(o) The execution and delivery of the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement, the
consummation of the transactions contemplated thereby and the performance of the
obligations thereunder will not conflict with or result in any violation of or default under
any provision of any other agreement or instrument to which the Investor is a party or any
license, permit, franchise, judgment, order, writ or decree, or any statute, rule or
regulation, applicable to the Investor.
(p)
(q)
No suit, action, claim, investigation or other proceeding is pending or, to the best of the
Investor's knowledge, is threatened against the Investor that questions the validity of the
Partnership Agreement or this Agreement or any action taken or to be taken pursuant to
the Partnership Agreement or this Agreement.
The Investor has full power and authority to make the representations referred to in this
Agreement, to purchase the Interest pursuant to this Agreement and the Partnership
Agreement and to deliver and perform its obligations under the Partnership Agreement
and this Agreement. If the Investor is an entity, the person executing this Agreement has
the full power and authority to execute and deliver this Agreement on behalf of the
Investor, and such entity is duly formed and organized, validly existing, and in good
standing under the laws of its jurisdiction of formation, and such entity is authorized by
its governing documents to execute, deliver and perform its obligations under this
Agreement. Furthermore, such investment is in accordance with all laws applicable to
the Investor's operations. The Partnership Agreement and this Agreement create valid
and binding obligations of the Investor and are enforceable against the Investor in
accordance with their terms, except as enforcement may be limited by applicable
bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization, arrangement, moratorium or other similar laws
affecting creditors' rights, and subject to general equity principles and to limitations on
availability of equitable relief, including specific performance.

(r) The Investor acknowledges that the Investor understands the meaning and legal
consequences of the representations and warranties made by the Investor herein. Such
representations and warranties are complete and accurate, shall be complete and accurate
at the time of closing and may be relied upon by the Fund, the General Partner and Fund
Counsel. Said representations and warranties shall survive delivery of this Agreement
and the Partnership Agreement. If in any respect such information shall not be complete
and accurate prior to the time of closing, the Investor shall give immediate written notice
of such incomplete or inaccurate information to the General Partner, specifying which
representations or warranties are not complete and accurate and the reasons therefor. In
the event that after the time of closing the Investor becomes aware that any of the
representations and warranties made by the Investor herein become incomplete or
inaccurate as of such time, the Investor shall give immediate written notice of such
incomplete or inaccurate information to the General Partner, specifying which
representations or warranties are not complete and accurate and the reasons therefor.

(s) To the fullest extent permitted by law, the Investor hereby agrees to indemnify and hold
harmless the Fund, Fund Counsel, the Management Company, the General Partner
(including without limitation the General Partner acting as tax matters partner,
Partnership Representative, or as liquidator), the tax matters partner, the Partnership
Representative and each member, partner, shareholder, managing director, manager,
director, officer, employee, consultant, agent, advisor or affiliate thereof (each, an
"Indemnified Party") from and against any and all loss, damage or liability due to or
arising out of any inaccuracy or breach of any representation or warranty of the Investor
or failure of the Investor to comply with any covenant or agreement set forth herein, in
the Partnership Agreement, or in any other document furnished to any Indemnified Party
specifically supplementing the information in this Agreement by the Investor in
connection with the subscription for an Interest. The Investor shall reimburse each
Indemnified Party for its legal and other fees and expenses (including the cost of any
investigation and preparation) as they are incurred in connection with any such claim,
action, proceeding or investigation, whether in the United States or any other jurisdiction.
The reimbursement and indemnification obligations of the Investor under this paragraph
shall survive any closing applicable to the Investor (or, if this Agreement is terminated
pursuant to paragraph 3(b) above, such termination) and shall be in addition to any
liability which the Investor may otherwise have (including, without limitation, liabilities
under the Partnership Agreement), and shall be binding and inure to the benefit of any
successors, assigns, heirs, estates, executors, administrators and personal representatives
of the Indemnified Parties.

(t) The Investor confirms that the Investor has been advised to consult with the Investor's
attorney regarding legal matters concerning the Fund and to consult with independent tax
advisers regarding the tax consequences of investing in the Fund. The Investor
acknowledges that he, she or it understands that any anticipated United States federal or
state income tax benefits may not be available and, further, may be adversely affected
through adoption of new laws or regulations or amendments to existing laws or
regulations. The Investor acknowledges and agrees that the Fund is providing no
warranty or assurance regarding the ultimate availability of any tax benefits to the
Investor by reason of the Investor's investment in the Fund. The Investor has consulted
with, and relied solely upon, its own accountant or tax advisors in connection with its
decision to acquire the Interest
The Investor understands that information relating to the Investor shall appear on the
financial statements and other records of the Fund. The Investor acknowledges and
agrees that other Partners may receive such information as permitted by the Partnership
Agreement or as required by applicable laws and may share such information with their
advisors and other parties.
(v)
(w)
(I)
(y)
The Investor understands and agrees that the General Partner may cause the Fund to
make an election under Section 754 of the Code or an election to be treated as an
"electing investment partnership" for purposes of Section 743 of the Code. If the Fund
elects to be treated as an electing investment partnership, the Investor shall cooperate
with the Fund and the General Partner to maintain that status and shall not take any action
that would be inconsistent with such election. Upon request, the Investor shall provide
the General Partner with any information necessary to allow the Fund to comply with (a)
its obligations to make tax basis adjustments under Sections 734 or 743 of the Code and
(b) its obligations as an electing investment partnership.
The Investor acknowledges that an investment in the Fund involves a high degree of risk
and that there can be no assurance that the Fund's investment objectives will be achieved,
or that a limited partner will receive a return of its capital. The Investor acknowledges
that the Investor has received and carefully reviewed and understands the various risks of
an investment in the Fund, as well as the fees and conflicts of interest to which the Fund
is subject, as set forth in the Memorandum, the Partnership Agreement and this
Agreement. The Investor hereby consents and agrees to the payment of the fees so
described to the parties identified as the recipients thereof, and to such conflicts of
interest.
The investor understands that an investment in the Fund may constitute a "reportable
transaction" under recently promulgated Treasury Regulations. The Investor
acknowledges that it will not be admitted to the Fund without providing the General
Partner with certain information, including its capital commitment, tax identification
number (if any), and date of admission to the Fund and that such information may be
disclosed to the IRS and/or certain advisors to the Fund's Partners to facilitate
compliance with such Treasury Regulations.
The Investor acknowledges and agree that: (i) for purposes of convenience or pursuant to
customary usage within the venture capital industry, members of the General Partner or
other Persons may occasionally refer to members of the General Partner as "partners" or
"general partners;" (ii) the sole constituent general partner of the Fund is the General
Partner, and not any of the individuals who (indirectly through the General Partner)
participate in the management of the Fund; and (iii) except as otherwise specifically set
forth in a written agreement executed by the Persons in question, and notwithstanding
any usage or implication to the contrary, no member of the General Partner is actually a
constituent partner of the Fund (or any other partnership).

6. Anti -Money Laundering Regulations. The Investor hereby acknowledges that the General
Partner and the Fund's intent is to comply with all applicable federal, state and local laws
designed to combat money laundering and similar illegal activities, including the provisions of
the Uniting and Strengthening America by Fulfilling Rights and Ending Eavesdropping Dragnet -
collection and Online Monitoring Act of 2015 (the "FREEDOM Act"). In furtherance of such
efforts, the Investor hereby represents, covenants, and agrees that, to the best of the Investor's
knowledge based on reasonable investigation:
(a)
(b)
None of the Investor's capital contributions to the Fund (whether payable in cash or
otherwise) shall be derived from or related to money laundering or similar activities
deemed illegal under U.S. federal laws and regulations.
No contribution or payment by the Investor to the Fund, to the extent that such
contribution or payment is within the Investor's control, and no distribution to the
Investor (assuming it is made with instructions provided to the General Partner by the
Investor) shall cause the Fund, the General Partner, the Management Company, the
Managing Directors or any of their respective Affiliates to be in violation of U.S. federal
anti-money laundering laws, including without limitation the U.S. Bank Secrecy Act, the
U.S. Money Laundering Control Act of 1986, the U.S. International Money Laundering
Abatement and Financial Anti-Terrorism Act of 2001, the FREEDOM Act or any other
anti-money laundering laws or regulations, in each case, such statute as amended to date
and any successor statute thereto and including all regulations promulgated thereunder.

(c) When requested by the General Partner, the Investor will provide any and all additional
information, and the Investor understands and agrees that the General Partner may release
confidential information about the Investor and, if applicable, any underlying beneficial
owner or Related Persons to any person, deemed reasonably necessary to ensure
compliance with all applicable laws and regulations concerning money laundering and
similar activities. The General Partner reserves the right to request any information as is
necessary to verify the identity of the Investor and the source of any payment to the Fund.
In the event of delay or failure by the Investor to produce any information required for
verification purposes, the subscription by the Investor may be refused.

(d) Except as otherwise disclosed in writing to the General Partner, the Investor represents
and warrants that neither it, nor any person controlled by, controlling or under common
control with the Investor, any of the Investor's beneficial owners, any person for whom
the Investor is acting as agent or nominee in connection with this investment, nor in the
case of an Investor which is an entity, any Related Person is:
a Prohibited Investoe

(ii) a Senior Foreign Political Figure,s any member of a Senior Foreign Political
Figure's "immediate family," which includes such Senior Foreign Political
3 "Related Person" shall mean, with respect to any entity, any interest holder, director, senior officer, trustee, 
beneficiary
or grantor of such entity; provided that in the case of an entity that is a publicly traded company or a tax qualified 
pension or
retirement plan in which at least 100 employees participate that is maintained by an employer that is organized in the 
U.S. or is a
U.S. government entity (a "Qualified Plan"), the term "Related Person" shall exclude any interest holder holding less 
than 5% of
any class of securities of such publicly traded company and beneficiaries of such Qualified Plan. 4 For purposes of this
subparagraph (d), "Prohibited Investor"
shall mean a person or entity whose name appears on

(i) the List of Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked Persons maintained by the U.S. Office of Foreign Assets 
Control;

(ii) other lists of prohibited Persons as may be mandated by applicable law or regulation; or (iii) such other lists of 
prohibited
Persons as may be provided to the Fund in connection therewith.
Figure's parents, siblings, spouse, children and in-laws, or any Close Associate'
of a Senior Foreign Political Figure, or a person or entity resident in, or organized
or chartered under, the laws of a Non-Cooperative Jurisdiction; ?
(iii) a person resident in, or organized or chartered under, the laws of a jurisdiction
that has been designated by the U.S. Secretary of the Treasury under the
FREEDOM Act (or any predecessor law) as warranting special measures due to
money laundering concerns; or

(iv) a person who gives the Investor reason to believe that its funds originate from, or
will be or have been routed through, an account maintained at a Foreign Shell
Bank,8 an "offshore bank," or a bank organized or chartered under the laws of a
Non-Cooperative Jurisdiction.
(e) If the Investor is purchasing the Interest as agent, representative, intermediary/nominee or
in any particular capacity for any other person, or is otherwise requested to do so by the
General Partner, it shall provide a copy of its anti-money laundering policies ("AML
Policies") to the General Partner. The Investor represents that it is in compliance with its
AML Policies, its AML Policies have been approved by counsel or internal compliance
personnel reasonably informed of anti-money laundering policies and their
implementation and it has not received a deficiency letter, negative report or any similar
determination regarding its AML Policies from independent accountants, internal
auditors or some other person responsible for reviewing compliance with its AML
Policies.
(0 The Investor hereby agrees to (i) immediately notify the General Partner if it knows, or
has reason to suspect that any of the representations in this paragraph 6 have become
For purposes of this subparagraph (d), "Senior Foreign Political Figure" shall mean a senior official in the executive,
legislative, administrative, military or judicial branches of a foreign government (whether elected or not), a senior 
official of a
major foreign political party, or a senior executive of a foreign government-owned corporation. In addition, a Senior 
Foreign
Political Figure includes any corporation, business or other entity that has been formed by, or for the benefit of, a 
Senior Foreign
Political Figure.
6 For purposes of this subparagraph (d), "Close Associate of a Senior Foreign Political Figure" shall mean a Person
who is widely and publicly known internationally to maintain an unusually close relationship with the Senior Foreign 
Political
Figure, and includes a Person who is in a position to conduct substantial domestic and international financial 
transactions on
behalf of the Senior Foreign Political Figure.
7 For purposes of this subparagraph (d), "Non-Cooperative Jurisdiction" shall mean any foreign country that has been
designated as non-cooperative with international anti-money laundering principles or procedures by an intergovernmental 
group
or organization, such as the Financial Task Force on Money Laundering, of which the U.S. is a member and with which
designation the U.S. representative to the group or organization continues to concur.
For purposes of this subparagraph (d), "Foreign Shell Bank" shall mean a Foreign Bank without a Physical Presence
in any country, but does not include a Regulated Affiliate.
A "Foreign Bank" shall mean an organization that (i) is organized under the laws of a foreign country, (ii) engages in
the business of banking, (iii) is recognized as a bank by the bank supervisory or monetary authority of the country of 
its
organization or principal banking operations, (iv) receives deposits to a substantial extent in the regular course of 
its business,
and (v) has the power to accept demand deposits, but does not include the U.S. branches or agencies of a foreign bank.
"Physical Presence" shall mean a place of business that is maintained by a Foreign Bank and is located at a fixed
address, other than solely a post office box or an electronic address, in a country in which the Foreign Bank is 
authorized to
conduct banking activities, at which location the Foreign Bank (i) employs one or more individuals on a full-time basis,
(ii)
maintains operating records related to its banking activities, and (iii) is subject to inspection by the banking 
authority that
licensed the Foreign Bank to conduct banking activities.
"Regulated Affiliate" shall mean a Foreign Shell Bank that is an affiliate of a depository institution, credit union or
Foreign Bank that maintains a Physical Presence in the U.S. or a foreign country regulating such affiliated depository 
institution,
credit union or Foreign Bank.
incorrect or if there is any change in the information affecting these representations and
covenants, and (ii) provide the General Partner with a reasonably detailed description of
any such inaccuracy or change.

(g) The Investor agrees that, if at any time it is discovered that any of the foregoing anti-
money laundering representations are incorrect, or if otherwise required by applicable
laws or regulations related to money laundering and similar activities, the General Partner
may undertake appropriate actions, and the Investor agrees to cooperate with such
actions, to ensure compliance with such laws or regulations, including, but not limited to
segregation and/or redemption of the Investor's Interest in the Fund or freezing the
Investor's account.

7. Withholding. The General Partner is required to withhold a certain portion of the taxable income
and gain allocated or distributed to the Investor unless the Investor provides documentation
confirming that the Investor is not subject to withholding, or is subject to a reduced rate of
withholding. The Investor should consult with a tax advisor concerning the application of the
U.S. withholding rules to the Investor.
The type of documentation required by the Investor is a function of whether the Investor is a
Foreign Person or a United States person. "Foreign Persons" include nonresident aliens, foreign
corporations, foreign partnerships, foreign trusts or foreign estates (as each of those terms is
defined in the Code and Treasury Regulations). "United States person" has the meaning set forth
in EXHIBIT D. In the case of entities that are disregarded for purposes of U.S. tax law (e.g.,
fiscally transparent entities with a single owner that have not elected to be taxed as a corporation
for U.S. tax purposes), such entities are treated as United States persons or Foreign Persons
depending on the residence and status of their owners, rather than on where the disregarded
entities are organized. Thus, an investor that is a U.S. disregarded entity with a foreign owner
will generally be treated as a Foreign Person and should complete and submit the appropriate
Form W-8 based on the owner's status. An investor that is a foreign disregarded entity with a
U.S. owner will generally be treated as a United States person and should complete and submit
Form W-9. Please contact the General Partner if you need additional information.

8. FATCA. Please note, pursuant to the requirements of Sections 1471-1474 of the Code (the
"FATCA") the Fund will generally be required to impose a 30% withholding tax on payments
made by the Fund to a Limited Partner that is either a foreign financial institution (an "FFT') as
defined in Section 1471(d)(4) of the Code or a non-financial foreign entity (an "NFFE") as
defined in Section 1472(d) of the Code. To avoid this withholding tax, the Fund will require that
all Limited Partners (a) establish with the General Partner, by providing all information that the
General Partner may reasonably request, that they are neither an FFI nor an NFFE, (b) if they are
an FFI, establish with the General Partner that they have entered into, and are maintaining, an FFI
Agreement in compliance with Section 1471(bX1) of the Code, or are otherwise exempt from the
withholding requirements of Section 1471 of the Code, and (c) if they are an NFFE, certify that
they have no "substantial United States owners," disclose all information that the Fund is required
to obtain pursuant to the FATCA regarding such substantial United States owners or adequately
show that they are otherwise exempt from the withholding requirements of Section 1472 of the
Code. Substantial United States owners are, generally, U.S. persons with at least a 10% interest
(held directly or indirectly) in the NFFE. The General Partner will notify the Investor of any
additional documentation, certification or other actions required of the Investor in order to allow
the Fund to comply with the FATCA. Failure to timely provide the required information may
result in the Investor's interest in the Fund being redeemed.

9. Power of Attorney. By signing this Agreement, the Investor constitutes and appoints the
General Partner as its agent, true and lawful representative and attorney -in-fact, in its name,
place, and stead to make, execute, sign, acknowledge, deliver or file (a) the Fund's Certificate of
Limited Partnership and any other instruments, deeds, documents and certificates which may
from time to time be required by any law to effectuate, implement and continue the valid and
subsisting existence of the Fund, (b) the Partnership Agreement, (c) all instruments, deeds,
documents and certificates that may be required to effectuate the dissolution and termination of
the Fund in accordance with the provisions hereof and the Act, (d) all instruments, deeds,
documents, or certificates that may from time to time be required of the Fund by the laws of the
United States of America or any other jurisdiction in which the Fund shall conduct its affairs in
order to qualify or otherwise enable the Fund to conduct its affairs in such jurisdictions, (e) all
amendments of the Partnership Agreement effected in accordance with the terms of the
Partnership Agreement including, without limitation, amendments reflecting the addition or
substitution of any Limited Partner, or any action of the Limited Partners duly taken pursuant to
the Partnership Agreement whether or not such Limited Partner voted in favor of or otherwise
approved such action, and (f) any other instrument, certificate, document, accession agreement or
deed of adherence required from time to time to admit a Limited Partner, to effect the substitution
of a Limited Partner, to effect the substitution of a Limited Partner's assignee as a Limited
Partner, to effect a Transfer pursuant to the Partnership Agreement or to reflect any action of the
Limited Partners provided for in the Partnership Agreement. The foregoing grant of authority
(I) is irrevocable, coupled with an interest in favor of the General Partner and deemed to be given
to secure the performance of the Investor's obligations under this Agreement and the Partnership
Agreement and shall survive the death or disability of a Limited Partner that is a natural person or
the merger, dissolution or other termination of the existence of a Limited Partner that is a
corporation, association, partnership, limited liability company or trust, and (2) shall survive the
assignment by the Investor of the whole or any portion of its interest, except that where the
assignee of the whole thereof has furnished a power of attorney, this power of attorney shall
survive such assignment for the sole purpose of enabling the General Partner to execute,
acknowledge and file any instrument necessary to effect any permitted substitution of the
assignee for the assignor as a Limited Partner and shall thereafter terminate. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, this power of attorney and the power of attorney referenced in the Partnership
Agreement granted by each Limited Partner shall expire immediately on the dissolution of the
Fund. The Investor is aware that the General Partner and each Limited Partner will rely on the
effectiveness of such powers in concluding that the Investor is bound by, and subject to the
Partnership Agreement. The Investor agrees to execute such other documents as the General
Partner may reasonably request in order to affect the intention and purposes of the power of
attorney contemplated by this paragraph. The execution of this power of attorney is not intended
to, and does not, revoke any prior or concurrent powers of attorney executed by the Investor.
This power of attorney is not intended to, and shall not, be revoked by any subsequent power of
attorney the Investor may execute. This power of attorney shall be governed by and construed in
accordance with the internal laws of the State of Delaware.

10. Fund Legal Matters. The Investor understands that the General Partner has retained Fund
Counsel in connection with the formation of the Fund and the offering of the Interests and may
retain Fund Counsel as legal counsel in connection with the management and operation of the
Fund, including, without limitation, making, holding and disposing of investments, or any dispute
that may arise between the Investor or any other Limited Partner, on the one hand, and the
General Partner, the Fund, the Management Company or their respective Affiliates, on the other
hand (the "Fund Legal Matters"). The Investor acknowledges that Fund Counsel will not
represent the Investor or any other Limited Partner or prospective limited partner of the Fund,
unless the General Partner and the Investor or such other Limited Partner or prospective limited
partner otherwise agree and the Investor or such other Limited Partner or prospective limited
partner separately engage Fund Counsel, in connection with the formation of the Fund, the
offering of the Interests or any Fund Legal Matter. The Investor will, if it wishes counsel in
connection with the formation of the Fund, the offering of the Interests or any Fund Legal Matter,
retain its own independent counsel with respect thereto and will pay all fees and expenses of such
independent counsel

11. Survival of Agreements, Representations and Warranties. All agreements, representations
and warranties contained herein or made in writing by or on behalf of the Investor, the Fund or
the General Partner in connection with the transactions contemplated by this Agreement shall
survive the execution of this Agreement and the Partnership Agreement, any investigation at any
time made by the Investor, the Fund or the General Partner or on behalf of any of them and the
sale and purchase of the Interest and payment therefor and the dissolution and termination of the
Fund.

12. Legends. The Investor consents to the placement of the legends contained on page 1 of this
Agreement and any other legend required or reasonably advisable, as determined by Fund
Counsel, by applicable law.

13. Severability. Any term or provision of this Agreement that is invalid or unenforceable in any
jurisdiction shall, as to such jurisdiction, be ineffective to the extent of such invalidity or
unenforceability without rendering invalid or unenforceable the remaining terms or provisions of
this Agreement or affecting the validity or enforceability of any of the terms or provisions of this
Agreement in any other jurisdiction.

14. Counterparts, Execution and Delivery. This Agreement may be executed in two or more
counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original but all of which together shall constitute
one and the same instrument. A facsimile or other reproduction of this Agreement may be
executed by the Investor and/or the General Partner, and an executed copy of this Agreement may
be delivered by the Investor and/or the General Partner by facsimile or similar electronic
transmission device pursuant to which the signature(s) and questionnaire responses can be seen,
and such execution and delivery shall be considered valid, binding and effective for all purposes.
At the request of any party hereto, the Investor and the General Partner agree to execute an
original of this Agreement as well as any facsimile or other reproduction hereof

15. Assignment. This Agreement is not transferable or assignable by the Investor.
16. Amendments. This Agreement may be amended, changed, waived, discharged or terminated
only with the written consent of the Investor and the General Partner.

17. Arbitration. The Investor hereby acknowledges and agrees that any claim, dispute or
controversy of whatever nature arising out of or relating to this Agreement shall be resolved by
final and binding arbitration in accordance with the terms of the Partnership Agreement.

18. Privacy. If the Investor is a natural person (including a natural person investing through an
individual retirement account or "IRA"), the Investor has carefully read the notice regarding
privacy of financial information under the U.S. Federal Trade Commission privacy rule, 16
C.F.R. Part 313 (the "Privacy Rule"), attached hereto as EXHIBIT E, and agrees that the Interest
is a financial product that the Investor has requested and authorized. The Investor acknowledges
and agrees that the Fund may disclose nonpublic personal information of the Investor to other
limited partners of the Fund (including prior to the General Partner's acceptance of this
Agreement) as well as to any Portfolio Companies of the Fund, Fund's accountants, attorneys and
other service providers as necessary to effect, administer and enforce the Fund's and the limited
partners' rights and obligations.

19. Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the
laws of the State of Delaware in all respects as such laws are applied to agreements among
Delaware residents entered into and performed entirely within Delaware, without giving effect to
conflict of law principles thereof.

20. Consent to Electronic Delivery. The Investor hereby agrees that the Fund may deliver all
notices, financial statements, tax reports, valuations, reports, reviews, analyses or other materials,
and all other documents, information and communications concerning the affairs of the Fund and
its investments, including, without limitation, information about the Portfolio Companies of the
Fund, required or permitted to be provided to the Investor under the Partnership Agreement or
hereunder by means of facsimile or e-mail (to the facsimile number or e-mail address set forth in
this Agreement, or other number or address as provided in writing by the Investor to the Fund), or
by posting on an electronic message board or by other means of electronic communication.
[REMAINDER OF PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
EXHIBIT A
ACCREDITED INVESTOR DEFINITION
Accredited Investor Representation. The Investor is an "accredited investor" (within the meaning of
Rule 501 under the Securities Act), if any of the following are true with respect to the Investor:
(a)
(b)
If an individual, the Investor has a net worth 9, either individually or upon a joint basis with the
Investor's spouse, of at least $1,000,000, or has had an individual income in excess of $200,000
for each of the two most recent years, or a joint income with the Investor's spouse in excess of
$300,000 in each of those years, and has a reasonable expectation of reaching the same income
level in the current year.
The Investor is an irrevocable trust with total assets in excess of $5,000,000 whose purchase is
directed by a person with such knowledge and experience in financial and business matters that
such person is capable of evaluating the merits and risks of the prospective investment.

(c) The Investor is a bank, insurance company, investment company registered under the Companies
Act, a broker or dealer registered pursuant to Section 15 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934,
as amended, a business development company, a Small Business Investment Company licensed
by the United States Small Business Administration, a plan with total assets in excess of
$5,000,000 established and maintained by a state for the benefit of its employees, or a private
business development company as defined in Section 202(a)(22) of the Advisers Act.

(d) The Investor is an employee benefit plan and either all investment decisions are made by a bank,
savings and loan association, insurance company, or registered investment advisor, or the
Investor has total assets in excess of $5,000,000 or, if such plan is a self-directed plan, investment
decisions are made solely by persons who are accredited investors.

(e) The Investor is a corporation, partnership, limited liability company or business trust, not formed
for the purpose of acquiring the Interest, or an organization described in Section 501(c)(3) of the
Code, in each case with total assets in excess of $5,000,000.
The Investor is an entity in which all of the equity owners, or a living trust or other revocable
trust in which all of the grantors and trustees, qualify under clause (a), (b), (c), (d) or (e) above or
this clause (f).
9 In calculating the Investor's "net worth": (i) the Investor's primary residence shall not be included as an asset;

(ii) indebtedness that is secured by the Investor's primary residence, up to the estimated fair market value of the
primary residence at the time of the closing on the Investor's investment in the Fund (the "Closing"), shall not
be included as a liability (except that if the amount of such indebtedness outstanding at the time of the Closing
exceeds the amount outstanding 60 days before such time, other than as a result of the acquisition of the primary
residence, the amount of such excess shall be included as a liability); and (iii) indebtedness that is secured by
the Investor's primary residence in excess of the estimated fair market value of the primary residence at the time
of the Closing shall be included as a liability. In calculating the Investor's joint net worth with the Investor's
spouse, the Investor's spouse's primary residence (if different from the Investor's own primary residence) and
indebtedness secured by such primary residence should be treated in a similar manner.
EXHIBIT A
EXHIBIT B
QUALIFIED CLIENT DEFINITION
Qualified Client Representation. The Investor is a "qualified client" (within the meaning of Rule 205-3
under the Advisers Act), if any of the following are true with respect to the Investor:
(a)
(b)
The Investor is a natural person, trust or a company10 that has made a Capital Commitment of at
least $1,000,000.
The Investor is a natural person (together with assets held jointly with a spouse), trust or a
company that has a net worth' of more than $2,100,000.

(c) The Investor is a Qualified Purchaser (within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51) under the
Companies Act) (see EXHIBIT C).
Notwithstanding the foregoing, if the Investor is a company that (i) would be an "investment company"
under the Companies Act but for the exception provided from that definition by section 3(c)(1) of the
Companies Act, (ii) is an investment company registered under the Companies Act, or (iii) is a "business
development company," as defined in section 202(aX22) of the Advisers Act (each, an "Excluded
Company"), all of the Investor's equity owners must be "qualified clients" (as described above) and if
any of the Investor's equity owners is an Excluded Company, such equity owners must also "qualified
clients" (as described above) in order for the Investor to be deemed a "qualified client"
I0 For purposes of this Exhibit, "company" has the same meaning as in Section 20200(5) of the Advisers Act, but
does not include a company that is required to be registered under the Companies Act but is not registered.
In calculating the Investor's "net worth": (i) the Investor's primary residence shall not be included as an asset;

(ii) indebtedness that is secured by the Investor's primary residence, up to the estimated fair market value of the
primary residence at the time of the closing on the Investor's investment in the Fund (the "Closing"), shall not
be included as a liability (except that if the amount of such indebtedness outstanding at the time of the Closing
exceeds the amount outstanding 60 days before such time, other than as a result of the acquisition of the primary
residence, the amount of such excess shall be included as a liability); and (iii) indebtedness that is secured by
the Investor's primary residence in excess of the estimated fair market value of the primary residence at the time
of the Closing shall be included as a liability. In calculating the Investor's joint net worth with the Investor's
spouse, the Investor's spouse's primary residence (if different from the Investor's own primary residence) and
indebtedness secured by such primary residence should be treated in a similar manner.
EXHIBIT B
EXHIBIT C
QUALIFIED PURCHASER DEFINITION
Please review both Part 1 and Pan 11 of this Exhibit C
Qualified Purchaser Representation (Part I). The Investor is a "qualified purchaser" (within the
meaning of Section 2(a)(51) under the Companies Act), if any of the following are true with respect to the
Investor:
(a)
(b)
The Investor is an individual (including any person who is acquiring the Interest with his or her
spouse in a joint capacity, as community property or similar shared interest) who either
individually or together with the Investor's spouse, owns Investments u that are Valued at not less
than $5,000,000.
The Investor is an entity that owns Investments that are Valued at not less than $5,000,000 and is
owned directly or indirectly by two (2) or more natural persons related as siblings, spouses
(including former spouses) or direct lineal descendants by birth or adoption, spouses of such
persons, the estates of such persons, or foundations, charitable organizations or trusts established
by or for the benefit of such persons.

(c) The Investor is a trust not covered by clause (b) above and not formed for the specific purpose of
acquiring the Interest, as to which the trustee or other person authorized to make decisions with
respect to the trust and each settlor or other person who has contributed assets to the trust is a
person described in clause (a) or (b) above or clause (d) below.

(d) The Investor is an entity, acting for its own account or the accounts of others described in clause
(a), (b) or (c) above, this clause (d) or clause (e) below, that in the aggregate owns and invests on
a discretionary basis Investments that are Valued at not less than $25,000,000.
(e) The Investor is an entity, all of the outstanding securities of which are owned by persons or
entities described in clause (a), (b), (c) or (d) above or this clause (e).
(0 The Investor is a "qualified institutional buyer" as defined in paragraph (a) of Rule 144A under
the Securities Act, acting for its own account, the account of another qualified institutional buyer,
or the account of a qualified purchaser; provided that (i) a dealer described in paragraph (a)(1)(ii)
of Rule 144A must own and invest on a discretionary basis at least $25,000,000 in securities of
issuers that are not affiliated persons of the dealer and (ii) a plan referred to in paragraph
(a)(1)(i)(D) or (a)(I)(i)(E) of Rule 144A, or a trust fund referred to in paragraph (aX1)(i)(F) of
Rule 144A that holds the assets of such a plan, will not be deemed to be acting for its own
account if investment decisions with respect to the plan are made by the beneficiaries of the plan,
except with respect to investment decisions made solely by the fiduciary, trustee or sponsor of
such plan.
12 For purposes of this paragraph, the terms "Investments" and "Valued" shall have the meanings provided in
EXHIBIT D hereto.
EXHIBIT C
Qualified Purchaser Representation (Part II). If one of the representations set forth in clauses (b)
through (0 in Part I above are true and the Investor would be treated as an "investment company" under
the Companies Act but for the fact that the Investor qualifies for one of the exemptions from the
definition of "investment company" provided for in Sections 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act", in
order for the Investor to indicate that it is a "qualified purchaser" the Investor certifies that the Investor
has read and understands the provisions of Section 2(a)(51XC) of the Companies Act and Rule 2a51-2
promulgated under the Companies Act excerpted on EXHIBIT D hereto and can make one of the
following representations:

(a) No consent of the Investor's direct or indirect beneficial owners is required for the
Investor's treatment as a "qualified purchaser" (within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51)
under the Companies Act) with respect to the Fund.

(b) Both of the following are true (NOTE — this representation is only required if the
Investor was formed on or before April 30, 1996): (A) all of the beneficial owners of the
Investor's outstanding securities (other than short-term paper), determined in accordance
with Section 3(c)(I)(A) of the Companies Act, that acquired such securities on or before
April 30, 1996 have consented to the Investor's treatment as a "qualified purchaser"
under the Companies Act with respect to the Fund• and (B) each direct and indirect
owner of the Investor who: (i) acquired its interest in the Investor on or before April 30,
1996; and (ii) would be an "investment company" under the Companies Act but for the
exclusions from the definition of "investment company" provided for in Sections 3(c)(1)
or 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act, has consented to treatment of the Investor has a
"qualified purchaser" under the Companies Act with respect to the Fund.

(c) If one of the representations set forth in clauses (b) or (c) in Part I above are true, all
of the trustees, directors or general partners of the Investor have consented to the
Investor's treatment as a "qualified purchaser" (within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51)
under the Companies Act) with respect to the Fund.
13 Relevant excerpts of Section 3(cXl) and 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act are provided in EXHIBIT D attached hereto.
EXHIBIT C
EXHIBIT D
DEFINITIONS
"United States person" shall mean an individual who is a citizen of the United States or a resident alien
for U.S. federal income tax purposes; a corporation, an entity taxable as a corporation, or a partnership
created or organized in or under the laws of the United States or any state or political subdivision thereof
or therein (including the District of Columbia); an estate, the income of which is subject to U.S. federal
income taxation regardless of its source; or a trust if (y) a court within the United States is able to exercise
primary supervision over its administration and one or more United States persons have the authority to
control all of its substantial decisions or (z) such trust was in existence on August 20, 1996 and was
treated as a domestic trust on August 19, 1996 and such trust has a valid election in effect under
applicable U.S. Treasury regulations to be treated as a United States person.
"Investments" shall mean any of the following:
"Securities" as such term is defined by Section 2(a)(1) of the Securities Act.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, securities of an issuer that controls, is controlled by, or is
under common control with the Investor shall not be deemed Investments unless the
issuer is:

(i) An investment company or a company that would be an investment company but
for the exclusions provided by Sections 3(c)(1) through 3(cX9) of the Companies
Act, a foreign bank or insurance company, an issuer of asset-backed securities that
meets certain requirements or a commodity pool;

(ii) A company whose equity securities are listed on a national securities exchange,
traded on Nasdaq or listed on a "designated offshore securities market" (as defined
by Regulation S promulgated pursuant to the Securities Act); or
(iii) A company with shareholders' equity of not less than $50,000,000 (determined in
accordance with generally accepted accounting principles) as reflected on the
company's most recent financial statements (provided such financial statements
present information as of a date not more than sixteen (16) months preceding the
Investor's investment in the Fund).

(2) Real estate held for investment purposes (i.e., not used by the undersigned for personal
purposes or as a place of business or in connection with the trade or business of the
undersigned).
"Commodity Interest" (i.e., commodities futures contracts, options on such contracts or
options on commodities that are traded on or subject to the rules of (i) any contract
market designated for trading under the Commodity Exchange Act and rules thereunder
or (ii) any board of trade or exchange outside the United States, as contemplated in Part
30 of the rules under the Commodity Exchange Act) held for investment purposes.

(4) Physical commodities (with respect to which a Commodity Interest is traded on a market
specified in paragraph 3 above) held for investment purposes.
Financial contracts within the meaning of Section 3(c)(2)(BXii) of the Companies Act
held for investment purposes.

(6) If the Investor is a company that would be an investment company but for the exclusion
provided by Section 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act, or a commodity pool, any
amounts payable to the Investor pursuant to a binding commitment pursuant to which a
person has agreed to acquire an interest in, or make capital contributions to, the Investor
upon demand by the Investor.
(3)
(5)
EXHIBIT D

(7) Cash and cash equivalents (including bank deposits, certificates of deposit, bankers
acceptances and similar bank instruments held for investment purposes and the net cash
surrender value of insurance policies).
"Valued" shall mean either the fair market value or cost of Investments net of the following deductions:
( 1) the amount of any outstanding indebtedness incurred to acquire such Investments; and

(2) if the holder of the Investment is a company, any outstanding indebtedness incurred by
any owner of such company to acquire such Investments.
SECTION 2(O51)(C) OF THE COMPANIES ACT:
"The term "qualified purchaser" does not include a company that, but for the exceptions provided for in
paragraph (1) or (7) of Section 3(c), would be an investment company (hereafter in this paragraph referred
to as an "excepted investment company"), unless all beneficial owners of its outstanding securities (other
than short-term paper), determined in accordance with Section 3(c)(1)(A), that acquired such securities on
or before April 30, 1996 (hereafter in this paragraph referred to as "pre-amendment beneficial owners"),
and all pre-amendment beneficial owners of the outstanding securities (other than short-term paper) or any
excepted investment company that, directly or indirectly, owns any outstanding securities of such excepted
investment company, have consented to its treatment as a qualified purchaser. Unanimous consent of all
trustees, directors, or general partners of a company or trust referred to in clause (ii) or (iii) of
subparagraph (A) shall constitute consent for purposes of this subparagraph."
RULE 2A51-2 AS PROMULGATED UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT:
"(a) Beneficial Ownership: General. Except as set forth in this section, for purposes of Sections
2(a)(51XC) and 3(c)(7)(B)(ii) of the Act, the beneficial owners of securities of an excepted investment
company...shall be determined in accordance with Section 3(c)(1) of the Act.

(b) Beneficial Ownership: Grandfather Provision. For purposes of Section 3(c)(7)(BXii) of the
Act, securities of an issuer beneficially owned by a company (without giving effect to Section 3(c)(1XA)
of the Act ("owning company") shall be deemed to be beneficially owned by one person unless: (1) The
owning company is an investment company or an excepted investment company; (2) The owning
company, directly or indirectly, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with, the issuer;
and (3) On October 11, 1996, under Section 3(c)(1)(A) of the Act as then in effect, the voting securities of
the issuer were deemed to be beneficially owned by the holders of the owning company's outstanding
securities (other than short-term paper), in which case, such holders shall be deemed to be beneficial
owners of the issuer's outstanding voting securities.

(c) Beneficial Ownership: Consent Provision. For purposes of Section 2(a)(51XC) of the Act,
securities of an excepted investment company beneficially owned by a company (without giving effect to

Section 3(c)(1)(A) of the Act ("owning company") shall be deemed to be beneficially owned by one
person unless: (1) The owning company is an excepted investment company; (2) The owning company
directly or indirectly controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with, the excepted investment
company or the company with respect to which the excepted investment company is, or will be, a
qualified purchaser; and (3) On April 30, 1996, under Section 3(c)(1)(A) of the Act as then in effect, the
voting securities of the excepted investment company were deemed to be beneficially owned by the
holders of the owning company's outstanding securities (other than short-term paper), in which case the
holders of such excepted company's securities shall be deemed to be beneficial owners of the excepted
investment company's outstanding voting securities.
EXHIBIT D

(d) Indirect Ownership: Consent Provision. For purposes of Section 2(aX51)(C) of the Act, an
excepted investment company shall not be deemed to indirectly own the securities of an excepted
investment company seeking a consent to be treated as a qualified purchaser ("qualified purchaser
company") unless such excepted investment company, directly or indirectly, controls, is controlled by, or
is under common control with, the qualified purchaser company or a company with respect to which the
qualified purchaser company is or will be a qualified purchaser.

(e) Required Consent: Consent Provision. For purposes of Section 2(aX51)(C) of the Act, the
consent of the beneficial owners of an excepted investment company ("owning company") that
beneficially owns securities of an excepted investment company that is seeking the consents required by

Section 2(a)(51)(C) ("consent company") shall not be required unless the owning company directly or
indirectly controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with, the consent company or the
company with respect to which the consent company is, or will be, a qualified purchaser."
SECTION 3(c)(1)(A) OF THE COMPANIES ACT:
"[N]one of the following persons is an investment company ...

(I) Any issuer whose outstanding securities (other than short-term paper) are beneficially
owned by not more than one hundred persons and which is not making and does not presently
propose to make a public offering of its securities ... For purposes of this paragraph:

(A) Beneficial ownership by a company shall be deemed to be beneficial ownership by one
person, except that, if the company owns 10 per centum or more of the outstanding
voting securities of the issuer and is or, but for the exception provided for in this
paragraph or paragraph (7), would be an investment company, the beneficial ownership
shall be deemed to be that of the holders of such company's outstanding securities (other
than short-term paper)."
SECTION 3(c)(7) OF THE COMPANIES ACT:
"[N]one of the following persons is an investment company ...
(7) (A) Any issuer, the outstanding securities of which are owned exclusively by
persons who, at the time of acquisition of such securities, are qualified purchasers, and
which is not making and does not at the time propose to make a public offering of such
securities. Securities that are owned by persons who received the securities from a
qualified purchaser as a gift or bequest, or in a case in which the transfer was caused by
legal separation, divorce, death, or other involuntary event, shall be deemed to be owned
by a qualified purchaser, subject to such roles, regulations, and orders as the Commission
may prescribe as necessary or appropriate in the public interest or for the protection of
investors."
EXHIBIT D
EXHIBIT E
PRIVACY POLICY
Pursuant to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, Public Law No. 106-102, and the rule issued by the Federal
Trade Commission regarding the Privacy of Consumer Financial Information, 16 C.F.R. Part 313 (the "FTC
Privacy Rule"), institutions that provide certain financial products or services to individuals to be used for
personal, family, or household purposes are required to provide written notices to their customers regarding
disclosure of nonpublic personal information. We have been advised that we may be subject to such
requirement. This notice is being provided to you to comply with the FTC Privacy Rule.
We understand that it is our obligation to maintain the confidentiality of information with regard to
our investors generally. As a consequence, we do not disclose any nonpublic personal information about our
investors or former investors to anyone other than our affiliates and service providers, except as permitted by
law and as described in the following sentences. Consistent with industry practice (and the provisions of our
fund agreements), we may distribute certain personally identifiable financial information such as the names of
investors, the amount of their capital commitments and capital account information, to all investors or
prospective investors in each specific fund and in future funds. In addition, in order to accurately and
efficiently conduct the Fund's investment program, we must collect, maintain, use and disclose certain non-
public information about you and the Fund's other investors. Finally, we may disclose certain personally
identifiable financial information such as the names of investors and the amount of their capital commitments
to the portfolio companies of the Fund (including prior to the General Partner's acceptance of this Agreement).
Furthermore, we may be required by law to provide to self-regulatory organizations and governmental
authorities or agencies information about the identity of our investors as well as their individual receipts of
income and gross proceeds, including but not limited to for the purpose of compliance with the Sections 1471-
1474 of the United States Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended from time to time (or any corresponding
provisions of succeeding law).
AFFILIATES & SERVICE PROVIDERS
We collect, and may disclose to our affiliates and service providers (e.g., our attorneys, accountants,
auditors, administrators, entities that assist us with the distribution of stock to our investors and placement
agents for future fundraising activities) on a "need to know" basis, certain nonpublic personal information
about you from the following sources:

• Information we receive from you as set forth in your subscription agreement, investor questionnaire,
or similar forms, such as your name, address, and social security or tax identification number, and
• Information about your transactions with us, our affiliates and service providers, or others, such as
your participation in each of our funds, such as your capital account balance, contributions and
distributions and, in the case of an investor that is an individual retirement account, information with
regard to such account.
We restrict access to nonpublic personal information about you to those employees who need to know
that information to provide services to the fund and its investors. We maintain physical, electronic, and
procedural safeguards to guard your nonpublic personal information. In addition, we will continue to assess
new technology for protecting information with regard to our investors.
In connection with fundraising efforts for future funds, we may disclose information about existing
investors to one or more placement agents for use in marketing efforts, including communication with
prospective future investors.
The policy may change from time to time, but you can always review our current policy by asking us
for a copy.
EXHIBIT E
Form W-9 (Rev. December 2014)
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Request for Taxpayer
Identification Number and Certification
Give Form to the
requester. Do not
send to the IRS.
Print or type
See Specific Instructions on page 2.
1 Name (as sham on you' income tax return). Name is requred on this line: do not leave this line blank.
2 Business name/disregarded entity name. if different from above
3 Check appropriate box for federal tax classification: check only one of the following seven boxes:
0 Individual/sole proprietor or 0 C Corporation 0 S Corporation 0 Partnership
single-member LLC
O Limited liability company. Enter the tax classification (C=C corporation. S=S cciperetion.P=partnership).
Note. For a single-member LLC that is disregarded. do not check LLC: check the appropriate box in
the tax classification of the angle-member owner.
0 Other (see instructions).
0 Trust/estate
4 Exemptions
certain entities.
instructions
Exempt payee
Exemption
code (if any)
(Accees to accams
(codes apply only to
not individuals; see
on page 3):
code Of any)
from FATCA reporting the line above for
miviesombxentle me U. S)
8 Address (number. street. and apt. or suite no.) Requesters name and address (optional)
8 City. state. and ZIP code
7 List account number(s) here Condone°
Part I Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN)
Enter your TIN in the appropriate box. The TIN provided must match the name given on line 1 to avoid
backup withholding. For individuals. this is generally your social secunty number (SSN). However. for a
resident alien. sole proprietor, or disregarded entity, see the Part I instructions on page 3. For other
entities, it is your employer identification number (EIN). If you do not have a number. see How to got a
TIN on page 3.
Note. If the account is in more than one name. see the instructions for line 1 and the chart on page 4 for
guidelines on whose number to enter.
ligusi  Certification
Under penalties of perjury, I certify that:

1. The number shown on this form is my correct taxpayer identification number (or I am waiting for a number to be issued
to me): and

2. I am not subject to backup withholding because: (a) I am exempt from backup withholding, or (b) I have not been 
notified by the Internal Revenue
Service (IRS) that I am subject to backup withholding as a result of a failure to report all interest or dividends, or 
(c) the IRS has notified me that I am
no longer subject to backup withholding; and
Social security number
or
Employer identification number
3. I am a U.S. citizen or other U.S. person (defined below): and
4. The FATCA code(s) entered on this form (if any) indicating that I am exempt from FATCA reporting is correct.
Certification instructions. You must cross out item 2 above if you have been notified by the IRS that you are currently 
subject to backup withholding
because you have failed to report all interest and dividends on your tax return. For real estate transactions. item 2 
does not apply. For mortgage
interest paid, acquisition or abandonment of secured property, cancellation of debt, contributions to an individual 
retirement arrangement (IRA), and
generally, payments other than interest and dividends. you are not required to sign the certification. but you must 
provide your correct TIN. See the
instructions on page 3.
Sign I Signature of
Here U.S. person ► Date ►
General Instructions
Section references are to the Internal Revenue Code unless otherwise noted.
Future developments. Information about developments affectrg Form W-9 (such
as legislation enacted after we release it) is at wwwars.gov/M9.
Purpose of Form
M individual or entity Form W-9 requester) who is required to file an information
return with the IRS must obtain your correct taxpayer identification number (TIN)
which may be your social security number (SSN). ndividual taxpayer identification
number (MN). adoption taxpayer identification nu rnber (ATIN). or employer
identification number (EIN). to report on an information return the amount paid to
you. or other amount reportable on an information return. Examples of information
returns include. but are not limited to. the following:

• Form 1099-INT (interest earned or paid)
• Form 1099-DIV (dividends. including those from stocks or mutual funds)

• Form 1099-MISC (various types of income, prizes, awards, or gross proceeds)
• Form 109943 (stock or mutual fund sales and certain other transactions by
brokers)

• Form 1099-S (proceeds from real estate transactions)
• Form 1099-K (merchant card and Med party network transactions)

• Form 1098 Nome mortgage interest). 1098-E (student loan interest). 1098-1
(tuition)
• Form 1099-C (canceled debt)
• Form 1099-A (acquisition or abandonment of secured property)
Use Form W-9 only if you are a U.S. person (including a resident alien). to
provide your correct TIN.
If you do not return Form W-9 to the requester with a TIN. you might be subject
to backup withholding. See What is backup withholding? on page 2.
By signing the filled-out form. you:

1. Certify that the TIN you are giving is correct (or you are welkin for a number
to be issued).
2. Certify that you are not subject to backup withholding. or

3. Clain exemption from backup withholding if you area U.S. exempt payee. If
applicable. you are also certifying that as a U.S. person. your allocable share of
any partnership income from a U.S. trade or business is not subject to the
withholding tax on foreign partners' share of effectively connected income. and
4. Certify that FATCA code(s) entered on this form (if any) indicating that you are
exempt from the FATCA mewing, is correct. See What is FATCA reporting? on
page 2 for further infatuation.
Cat. No. I 0231X Form W-9 (Rev. 12-2014)
TAX WITHHOLDING INFORMATION / INSTRUCTIONS FOR FOREIGN PERSONS
The General Partner is required to withhold a certain portion of the taxable income and gain allocated or
distributed to each Investor unless the Investor provides documentation confirming that such Investor is
not subject to withholding, or is subject to a reduced rate of withholding. The following information is
provided to assist the Investor in complying with the U.S. rules for backup withholding and withholding
with respect to income earned by Foreign Persons (as defined below). This information is only a
summary, and is not a substitute for the advice of a tax advisor. Each Investor is urged to consult with a
tax advisor concerning the application of the U.S. withholding rules to such Investor.
The type of documentation required by the Investor is a function of whether the Investor is a Foreign
Person. "Foreign Persons" include nonresident aliens, foreign corporations, foreign partnerships, foreign
trusts or foreign estates (as each of those terms is defined in the Code and Treasury Regulations). In the
case of entities that are disregarded for purposes of U.S. tax law (e.g., fiscally transparent entities with a
single owner that have not elected to be taxed as a corporation for U.S. tax purposes), such entities are
treated as U.S. Persons' or Foreign Persons depending on the residence and status of their owners, rather
than on where the disregarded entities are organized. Thus, an investor that is a U.S. disregarded entity
with a foreign owner will generally be treated as a Foreign Person and should complete and submit the
appropriate Form W-8 (as discussed below) based on the owner's status. An investor that is a foreign
disregarded entity with a U.S. owner will generally be treated as a U.S. Person and should complete and
submit Form W-9 (as discussed below).
If the Investor is a U.S. Person, please complete U.S. Internal Revenue Service Form W-9. Such Investor
agrees to notify the General Partner within 60 days if the Investor ceases to be a U.S. Person.
If the Investor is a Foreign Person, please complete either U.S. Internal Revenue Service Form W-8BEN,
W-8BEN-E, Form W-8ECI, Form W-8EXP or Form W-8IMY (along with any accompanying
withholding certificates or other required statements, if appropriate), in accordance with the instructions
provided below and the printed instructions included with the appropriate form. Links to these forms and
their instructions are also included at the end of this instruction. These forms must be updated and
provided again to the General Partner in certain circumstances, as described in the printed instructions
provided with each form. Additionally, the General Partner may request updated submissions of the
Investor's Form W-8BEN, W-BEN-E, Form W-8ECI, Form W-8EXP or Form W-8IMY when
amendments to these forms are made.
"U.S. Person" means an individual who is a citizen of the U.S. or a resident alien for U.S. federal income
tax purposes; a corporation, an entity taxable as a corporation, or a partnership created or organized in or under the
laws of the U.S. or any state or political subdivision thereof or therein (including the District of Columbia); an
estate, the income of which is subject to U.S. federal income taxation regardless of its source; or a trust if (i) a 
court
within the U.S. is able to exercise primary supervision over its administration and one or more U.S. Persons have the
authority to control all of its substantial decisions or (ii) such trust was in existence on August 20, 1996 and was
treated as a domestic trust on August 19, 1996 and such trust has a valid election in effect under applicable Treasury
Regulations to be treated as a U.S. Person.
The following summary guidelines are provided for the benefit of those Foreign Persons required to
provide Form W-8. In addition to the information provided herein, please refer to the printed instructions
included for the applicable From W-8 for more detailed guidelines.

(a) The following Foreign Persons should complete and provide Form W-8EXP:
a foreign government;
(ii) an international organization;
(iii) a foreign central bank of issue;

(iv) a foreign tax-exempt organization;
(v) a foreign private foundation; and
(vi) the government of a U.S. possession claiming the applicability of Section 115(2), 501(c),
892, 895 or 1443(b) of the Code.

(b) An investor that holds an interest in the Fund which is effectively connected with the investor's
conduct of a U.S. trade or business should complete and provide Form W-8ECI.

(c) The following Foreign Persons should complete and provide Form W-8IMY:
Any Foreign Person (including a custodian, broker, nominee or agent) that holds the
Fund interest on behalf of another person;

(ii) Any Foreign Person that is a flow-through entity or fiscally transparent (including a
foreign partnership or foreign trust);
(iii) A foreign branch of a U.S. Person to establish that it is a qualified intermediary that is not
acting for its own account; and

(iv) A U.S. branch of a foreign bank or foreign insurance company, to represent that (A) the
interest in the Fund is not effectively connected with the conduct of a U.S. trade or
business and (B) that either (1) the U.S. branch is to be treated as a U.S. person with
respect to any payments associated with the interest in the Fund; or (2) the U.S. branch is
providing the documentation of the persons for whom it holds the interest in the Fund.
In order to avoid withholding on income allocated to an interest in the Fund held by the Foreign
Persons described in this paragraph (c), such Foreign Persons must also provide additional
information and documentation as detailed in the printed instructions accompanying
Form W-8IMY.
Most Foreign Persons described in this paragraph (c) will need to provide the infortnation
including, but not limited to, the following:

(1) A withholding statement including:
the name, address, U.S. TIN# (including an MN#, if any) and type of
withholding documentation for every person for whom documentation
has been received;

(ii) whether each such person is a U.S. Person exempt from backup
withholding, a U.S. Person subject to backup withholding, or a Foreign
Person;
(iii) whether each Foreign Person is a beneficial owner or intermediary, flow-
through entity or U.S. branch;

(iv) how income attributable to the interest in the Fund should be allocated
among the beneficial owners on whose behalf the interest in the Fund is
held (see printed instructions to Form W-8IMY (attached) for an
alternative allocation procedure);

(A) for each beneficial owner who is a Foreign Person, the
applicable rate of withholding, country of residence, the basis for
any reduced rate of withholding, and other information; and

(B) any other information requested by the General Partner for
purposes of fulfilling its withholding obligations.

(2) A Form W-8 and other documentary evidence supporting the information
contained in the withholding statement for each beneficial owner listed in the
withholding statement.
Certain Foreign Persons described in this paragraph (c) may have entered into an agreement with
the U.S. Internal Revenue Service to act as a withholding foreign partnership, withholding foreign
trust, or qualified intermediary. Such Foreign Persons should consult the printed instructions to
Form W-8IMY to determine the information they must provide to the General Partner to reduce
or eliminate withholding on income allocated to their interests in the Fund.

(d) A Foreign Person who is not described in paragraph (a), (b) or (c) above, and who will be the
beneficial owner of an interest in the Fund, should complete and provide Form W-8BEN or
W-8BEN-E.
** Most investors will need to complete Form W-8BEN (if they are investing as individuals) or
Form W-8BEN-E (if they are investing as entities (other than foreign investment funds))**
Form W-8BEN (for individuals): htta://wvnv.irs.eov/aub/irs-adf/fw8ben.ridf
Form W-8BEN Instructions: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/iw8ben.pdf
Form W-8BEN-E (for entities): http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/fw8bene.pdf
Form W-8BEN-E Instructions: httplAvww.irs.eov/imb/irs-pdf/iw8bene.pdf
Form W-8IMY: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/fw8imv.pdf
Form W-8IMY Instructions: htm://wwvv.irs.eov/Dub/irs-pdf/iw8imv.ildf
Form W-8ECI: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/fw8eci.pdf
Form W-8ECI Instructions: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/iw8eci.pdf
Form W-8EXP: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdflfw8exp.pdf
Form W-8EXP Instructions: httm//vvww.irs.Rov/pub/irs-ridf/iw8exp.pdf
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Hedosophia [publicist] Ian Osborne VC fund, invested in Alibaba, launched infamous SPACs with Chamath advised by Epstein 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00810474 (Jmail)
 [tech] Valar Ventures Fall 2018 Update
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
"
1-1 : 1
.1.111:17.
Z • _
Z - • - 'trait
- • -a  -
"...II: ass.:  .111 •
".111104

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ────╮
│ FP rer SS &- FS AE~E TD │
│                         │
│ haa                     │
│                         │
│ Fall 2018-Update        │
╰─────────────────────────╯

Valar Fund I / Performance
Fund 1 Performance
Inception: October 2010
Capital Commitments: $100.0M
Current FMV (including distributions made): $400.6M
Multiple (Gross & Net): 4.2x / 3.3x
IRR (Gross & Net): 35.4% / 29.1%
% of Fund Invested / Reserved: 100%
DPI: 1.6x
Performance Drivers: Xero (95% exited), Transferwise
This document is confidential, trade secret, and not for further circulation. This document is informational and is not 
an offer or solicitation to buy, sell or
hold any securities. Except where otherwise indicated. "Fund I" refers to all funds and investment
vehicles managed by Valar Ventures Management LLC, on an aggregate basis, prior to the formation of Valar Global Fund II
LP, "Fund 2" refers to Valor Global
Fund II LP and Valar Global Principals Fund II LP, on an aggregate basis, "Fund 3" refers to
Valar Global Fund III LP and Valar Global Principals Fund III LP. on an aggregate basis. and "Fund 4" refers to Velar 
Global Fund IV LP and Valar Global
Principals Fund IV LP, on an aggregate basis. Except where otherwise stated, figures presented herein
are unaudited internal estimates in USD as of 10x312018. after giving effect to tam sheets for investments not yet 
closed. Gross figures arc based on invested
capital only and do not include the impact of fees, expenses and carry, and net figures are calculated
by reducing gross investment profits by a flat 25% for hypothetical management fees, expenses. and carry.
VALAR /
War Fund I
•
w
* '_
•
TransferWise
Replacing the Infrastructure for Cross-Border Money
3- —
Java
Jakarta
cluno
4 Suraka, ihov;

╭───────────────── Page 3, Image 1 ──────────────────╮
│ * .* =                                             │
│ =e ¢                                               │
│ sit                                                │
│ “/ TransferWise                                    │
│                                                    │
│ Replacing the Infrastructure for Cross-Border Mone │
│                                                    │
│ oot ra ll                                          │
│ SiNGAPORE :                                        │
│ cM oe                                              │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Valar Fund 1 /1),•!-10-!
Transferwise Updates
I Exceeded projections in Q3, adding 446k new users
(+39% year-over-year) and processing £6.5B in
transaction volume (+66% year-over-year).
1 Monthly revenue passed £16M in October (more
than $250M annualized), with EBITDA in Q3
reaching 7% of gross revenues.
1 Grown team to 1315 employees at the end of Q3
2018, and added three new leased spaces allowing
the team to scale to 1750 over the coming year.
1 Rolling out debit card to EU businesses with 5,600
cards issued so far.
1 As Transferwise is profitable, no financing
transactions are planned for 2018; Potential
secondary round contemplated in mid-2019.
1 Valar is the largest outside investor in Transferwise,
retaining over 12% of the company following last
year's partial sale.
Bye bye bank fees, hello
world
Janos...1 m•la. peep. •Prea ..“ Ovid bran , to pet • ye*
..cluiveest• end • but.. Ewa" t.n•
S ly ii  IP TreniAnWles see/ Over 4 ',Mae
- titte happy offileomen
Send meet iterohve
1000
4.1/10 To. B4 es••
Yew to.4d lave up te MOW*
Stetetkil sp.. bp Oct IS
_s USD -
EUR
Not all exchange rates are
created equal.
0•••• 1.•
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$22.2M
$253.6M
11.4x
$1.7B
IA Ventures, Andreessen Horowitz, IVP
VALAR / 3
Valar Fund I / Performance Driven
Beautiful Accounting Software

╭───────── Page 5, Image 1 ──────────╮
│ Valar Fund 1 / Performance Drivers │
│                                    │
│ xelo                               │
│                                    │
│ Beautiful Accounting Software      │
│                                    │
│ Neen Ee EEE                        │
│ —_                                 │
│                                    │
│ VALAR / 4                          │
╰────────────────────────────────────╯

• Valar Fund 1 / Pcrformance Driver.
Xero Updates
✓ In 2010, Xero became Valar's first investment, with a
$3M check at a $100M valuation.
✓ Today, Xero is a $4B company, publicly traded on
the Australian Stock Exchange.
✓ In 2017, Valar sold 95% of its holdings, distributed
close to $100M in cash and stock to our investors.
Valar Global Fund I still retains a small stake.
✓ Xero now has over 1.5M customers in 180+
countries.
✓ The company is profitable, with A$26.0 million in
EBITDA in FY2018.
✓ Revenue has grown from $6M annualized when
Valar first invested in 2010 to over $600M
annualized today.
✓ Xero's continued success since our partial exit last
year will impact our thinking about the timing for
exiting our other winners in the future.
Wire coming to a city near you
Minos to free to meet the etre team sod IN: the
'oleo updates. wishes IS °sumo!,
A real-time view of your cash flow
small Wiriness accesoning setwine that s onion. smut end ouanpully inatical
play vide.) C .)
Run your business on the go Get paid faster with online invoicing
use ow mob,:{ app to reconcile. send invoices or
create 0...trisection+. - learn ewshernie.
Send online invoices to sour customers - and get
updated when they're married
Reconcile in seconds
import and categorize your latest bank banns -wont
ale are. Then click to reconcile.
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV (includes distributions):
Gross Multiple:
Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$31.4M
$127.2M
4.0x
$3.9B today / $2.0B at time of Valar's major exit
Accel, Matrix Capital, Fidelity, Blackstone, TCV
VALAR / 5
Valar Fund 2 / Pei for
Fund 2 Performance
Inception: January 2015
Capital Commitments: $102.3M
Current FMV: $243.9M
Multiple (Gross & Net): 2.7x / 2.1x
IRR (Gross & Net): 42.6% / 33.3%
% of Fund Invested / Reserved: 100%
Performance Drivers: N26, Breather, Kalo, Even
VALAR / 6
Valar Fund 2 / Performance Drivers
N26
Mobile Banking Made Easy
$
VALAR
Valar Fund 2 / Pcrionnanec Dri
N26 Updates
✓ Exceeded projections in Q3, reaching £3.9M in
monthly revenue in August.
✓ Adding over 100k new customers per month, passing
2.2M total customers.
✓ Revenue per active user is growing faster than
forecast, reaching £93 in September.
✓ Successfully launched in the UK in October 2018.
✓ US launch planned for March 2019, with 15
employees already in place in New York City.
✓ Continued rapid pace of new product launches and
customer adoption — 150,000 "Spaces" already
created since launch in July 2018.
✓ Customers becoming more profitable — 55% margin
for each active customer.
✓ Series D financing planned for Q4 2018; following
that round, Valar expects to still own approximately
12% of the company.
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$25.7M
$182.7M
7.1x
$1.5B
Tencent, Allianz, Hedosophia, Greyhound
VALAR / s
Valar Fund 2 /
MEr
aD breather
Bringing Flexibility to Commercial Real Estate
breather
Valar Fund 2 / Performance Driver::
Breather Updates
✓ Revenue growing 70% YoY, with September seeing a
new high of $2.6M.
✓ Margin has improved significantly since the
beginning of the year, a core focus of the company.
✓ Continued move to multi-day and month+ bookings,
which are the fastest growing segment of the
business. Month+ grew from $91k in December
2017 to $590k in September 2018.
✓ Adding spaces between 2,000 and 10,000 square feet
in target zones to take advantage of Month+ demand.
✓ Team continues to grow, now at 119; projected to
reach 145 by year end.
✓ CEO transition to the Board; new CEO search
making good progress.
✓ $43M Series D financing completed in H1 2018;
Company funded into 2020.
How Breather works
1. Eaa,ly re: wive ace
2. Scrnia,e and secure access
3. Take a tout
As+ is moo urn epos' di pont., NM> furw..t flatus.
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$25.5M
$42.3M
1.7x
$295.6M
RRE, Menlo Ventures, Google Ventures, Temasek
✓ Valar Fund 2 owns 14.3% of Breather. VALAR / 10
Valar Fund 2! Pcfrormoncc
kalo Work with Anyone, Anywhere

╭───────── Page 12, Image 1 ─────────╮
│ Valar Fund 2 / Performance Drivers │
│                                    │
│ kalo                               │
│                                    │
│ Work with Anyone, Anywhere         │
│                                    │
│ a a a. ae                          │
│                                    │
│ VAAR /                             │
╰────────────────────────────────────╯

kalo Ov•ev•r* SOitIPOSIS • Reiourca • 0/140••••• Login R•aushi D•mo
Valar Fund 2 / Pcr.aGrmance Drivers
Kalo Updates
1 Kalo's core focus is on adding freelancers to its
platform. August and September were its strongest
months yet, with 80k new freelancers onboarded.
1 Monthly revenue hit $80k in September 2018, still
small, but up 6X from the beginning of the year.
1 Key logos closed in Q3 including Lululemon, Mic,
Complex Magazine, ESPN and RGA.
1 Pipeline of new strategic logos includes The New
York Times, Walmart, Compass, Linkedln, Levi's
Nike and TechCrunch.
1 COO/CFO search underway, important to building
out the team's operational capabilities.
1 Kalo maintains significant cash reserves, with
funding into 2020.
✓ Valar Fund 2 owns approximately 24% of Kalo.
Make working with
freelancers a breeze.
Ka;o s freelancer management piatform is trusted by Google.
Airbnb. Expedia, IDEO and more to onboard freelancers in
minutes. track their profiles and contracts. and get them paid
on ti me.
Okra/Amain 0
SURFACE
o gle %.' d
•
IDEO
airbre
Cnail=ii•
NM IN •
FIF Expedia
'pre-Kaha was a maze of multr.tablzedGooe* soremr:kzets. rims my, z
one prase. Onboatd.ng takes minutes not days and our freelancers get pad on time'
Lily Wan. Surface Magaxine
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$12.4M
$16.5M
1.3x
$70.0M
Kindred, Goldcrest, SciFi VC (Max Levchin)
VALAR / 12

╭────── Page 14, Image 1 ──────╮
│ Performance Drivers          │
│                              │
│ aameven                      │
│                              │
│ How Busy People Master Money │
╰──────────────────────────────╯

= Even The Even ago Offa Shen as a benefit COWn10210 t”e aap
Valar Fund 2 / Peribrmance Driver,.
Even Updates
I Exceeded member growth and revenue plans, hitting
$1.69M revenue in September 2018; On track to
achieve $18M in revenues for full year 2018.
I Served over 25,000 people and delivered over $200
million in access to wages.
I Grown team from 19 to 50 so far in 2018.
I Set aggressive goals for the end of 2018 — to serve
over 25% of Walmart's employees, add an additional
40,000 members outside of Walmart, and onboard
150,000 Even members to the Savings account
platform.
I Demonstrated a significant retention advantage
between Walmart employees using Even and those
that are not; Actual numbers are very impressive
(although not yet publicly announced).
✓ Valar is the second largest investor in Even, with a
13.2% ownership stake in the company.
psyched n 8 day•
$28O
0
?.)
How busy people
master their money
Get pad on demand, budget instantly, and save
automatically wrth Even.
12.7k ratings 12.6k ratings
4.9
AppSrore
4.8
► -"c"; 4%,..„
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$5.4M
$10.4M
1.9x
$99.3M
Khosla Ventures, BoxGroup, Allen & Company
VALAR / 14
Valar Fund 3 / PCITOI 111:IIICC
Fund 3 Performance
Inception: July 2016
Capital Commitments: $103.9M
Current FMV: $176.8M
Multiple (Gross & Net): 2.1x / 1.7x
IRR (Gross & Net): 69.8% / 54.2%
% of Fund Invested / Reserved: 100%
Performance Drivers: Stash, Qonto, Octane, Petal, Jetty
VALAR / 15
Valar Fund 3 /
sTt
Investing Made Simple
VALAR / to

╭───────── Page 17, Image 1 ─────────╮
│ Valar Fund 3 / Performance Drivers │
│                                    │
│ 2ASH                               │
│                                    │
│ Investing Made Simple              │
│                                    │
│ VALAR / 16                         │
╰────────────────────────────────────╯

STASH Par• ••••••••• 8.1r•no Cnod Learn Si.opm for
Valar Fund 3 / Pcriorm:Inec I )rivers
Stash Updates
✓ Continued rapid user growth, reaching 2.5M users
and 1.5M funded accounts in September. CAC
remains stable at < $20 per new user.
1 Revenue has grown 5x YoY, exceeding forecasts
with $3.8M in Q3. Revenue expected to hit $100M
annualized by the end of next year.
1 Gross margins (negative last year) are now positive
and nearing 50%.
I Accelerated pace of new product launches.
Retirement and custodial accounts, as well as
insurance referrals, all growing exponentially. Stash
debit card, cash back and gifting launching in Q4.
1 Over $2.5M has been pre-funded for the Stash Debit
product, with 50k sign ups during a 3 week period.
1 Series D financing expected in Q4 2018.
1 Valar is the second largest investor in Stash, with a
19% ownership stake in the company.
1
Put your money where it matters
Fro nr oatco to V. *nom, g. tvc n W.Y raters )a you WO SLIM
You can met in a Seam of sans a-ci LW. mai .s Grotty waled bir our
•Iv•IbTOM Pt•• tasel On same ralo0.Itieng
flak proles
Erpbre an •••••••1•••••
ren. LLC tr, in. el •• rve: ,
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$29.6M
$65.6M
2.2x
$347.5M
USV, Coatue, Goodwater, Jim Breyer
VALAR / 17
Valar Fund 3 /
Octane Lending
Fast and Easy Lending
for Powersports Dealers
VALAR / 1
Octane Lending Home Features Lenders About Us Login Sign Up Free Add Financing Link
Valar Fund 3 / Per!hi -mance Drivers
Octane Updates
✓ Now servicing 857 active dealers across multiple
verticals.
✓ Reached $850k in monthly revenue in September
($10M annualized); Expect revenue to pass $1M
monthly before year end.
✓ Hit $6.5M in originations in August 2018 (2.4x year-
over-year growth)
✓ Targeting $150M in originations and $23M in
revenue in 2019.
✓ Strong hiring for the company's Direct-to-Consumer
initiative, to be launched in 2019.
✓ Valar Fund 3 is the largest shareholder in Octane,
with a 16% ownership stake in the company.
FINANCE MORE CUSTOMERS
IN LESS TIME. Octane Lending provides fast and easy powersports lending for dealers. For free,
LILARN MORt TRY IT IOII Mt
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$16.2M
$20.3M
1.2x
$130.5M
IA Ventures, Third Prime Capital, Contour
VALAR / 19
Valar Fund 3 / Performance Drivers
Petal
Credit Underwriting Without FICO
ca\ \GIs:0
VALAR / 20
Valar Fund 3 / ['orlon-Imre,' Drivers
Petal Updates
✓ Product went live in July with 5,000 cards issued to
date. Forecast to issue 75,000 additional cards over
the next 12 months.
✓ Average spend per card per month so far is $650 per
month, 10% above forecast.
✓ Monthly revenue currently at $100k, expected to 10x
in the next 6 months, reaching $2M by next summer.
✓ Rapid rollout of product features in the near term,
including cashback and card linked offers, split
payments for large purchases, credit score in the app
and companion savings accounts.
✓ Team growing quickly, from 16 at the end of 2017, to
45 today. Plan shows 67 further hires by June 2019.
✓ In December 2017, Valar Fund 3 led Petal's Series A
financing, acquiring a 20% stake in the company.
Valar Fund 4 is now leading Petal's Series B round at
a $100M pre-money valuation and will acquire an
additional 14% of Petal.
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$28.6M
$38.1M
1.3x
$125M
Third Prime Capital, Brooklyn Bridge Ventures
VALAR / 21
War Fund 3 /
Jetty
Revolutionary Renters Insurance
VALAR / 22
Valar Fund 3 / l'cribrrimnrc Drivers
Jetty Updates
1 Between Q1 and Q2, policy sales increased by 31%,
with the real estate partner channel growing 85%.
I Launched 12 new partners including Related,
Greystar and Tishman Speyer, with nearly 200k units
signed.
I Generated $275k in revenue in Q2 with close to
$800k in gross premium sold in June 2018.
1 The current product offering includes traditional
renters insurance, security deposit coverage and a
lease guarantee product; The company plans to roll
out a pet insurance product next.
1 Series B financing expected in Q4 2018.
1 Valar Fund 3 owns 19% of Jetty and will look to
increase its stake in the Series B round.
Better, more
affordable
renters insurance
from S5/mo.
tt-
as 111
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$8.1M
$8.1M
1.0x
$42.5M
Ribbit Capital, BoxGroup, SV Angel
VALAR / 23
Valar Fund 4/ Port
Fund 4 Portfolio Update
Inception: January 2018
Capital Commitments: $133.4M
Deployed Capital: $67.1M (all investments held at cost)
Gross Multiple: 1.0x
% of Fund Invested / Reserved: 75%
Portfolio Companies: Petal, Coya, Bestow, Qonto, TaxFix, LoanStreet
VALAR / 24
Valar Fund 4 /
qonto
Business Banking Made Easy
MAR / 25

╭───── Page 26, Image 1 ─────╮
│ Valar Fund 4/00            │
│                            │
│ >< gonto                   │
│                            │
│ Business pontine Made Easy │
│                            │
│ VALAR / 25                 │
╰────────────────────────────╯

qonto On. .•••••••
Valar Fund 4 / h,\ C St
Qonto Updates
I Product launched in July 2017 and customer base has
grown to 22,500 business clients.
I Reached $575k in revenue in August 2018.
I Received European Passporting license in June 2018,
allowing for expansion to 11 other European
countries.
I In the process of building and deploying their own
payment infrastructure and core banking systems.
✓ Valar led Qonto's Series B financing through Valar
Fund 4 in September 2018. We also led the Seed and
Series A rounds though Fund 3.
I In aggregate, Valar funds own 25% of Qonto.
Your finances on auto-pilot
Saw time
:a. 3 Monitor your expenses, for free4ancers and teams
Make accounting easier
Checkout ow, Snit:Waft
Valar Cost Basis: $27.0M
Current FMV: $52.3M
Gross Multiple: 1.9x
Current Company Valuation: El 55.0M
Other Key Investors: Alven Capital
I
VALAR / 26
Valor Fund 41
CO :'A
Digital, Flexible, Affordable Insurance
Valar Fund 4 / •,,I I >1111C II IS
Coya Updates
✓ Insurance license issued in June 2018.
✓ First products went live in Germany in September.
✓ Initial renters policy can be obtained in less than 60
second. Users receive a digital offer by simply
entering their name, postal code and apartment size.
✓ Plans to offer customizable products that adapt to
clients' individual needs, including so-called "micro
policies" that allow clients to insure individual
objects for only a few days or even hours.
✓ First corporate partnership also now live. B2B2C
channel is attractive as Coya can innovate on the
actual insurance product offered (as opposed to other
"insuretechs" who are limited by the products their
underlying license holder is willing to underwrite).
✓ Valar led Coya's Seed financing round through Valar
Fund 3 in 2017, and Valar Fund 4 led Coya's Series
A financing in May 2018. In aggregate, Valar funds
own 31% of Coya.
A new view
insurance.
Digital. Fl
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$21.8M
$26.0M
1.2x
€75M
E.ventures, SCOR, Yabeo
VALAR / 28
Valar Fig. 4
1/4nCi4') bestow
Life Insurance that is Fast, Easy and Affordable
ValarFund4/CIr \!..11,111,,
Bestow Background
I Bestow is a life insurance company that is expanding
the market for term life insurance through
technology.
1 The company currently operates as an MGA and has
secured agency licenses in 49 states. Bestow is in the
process of becoming a fully licensed insurance
carrier in Texas.
1 By selling directly to consumers and removing blood
draws from the underwriting process, Bestow is able
to offer term life in much smaller and more
affordable increments — to a wider population.
1 The company has partnered with Sammons and
Munich Re to underwrite its policies and to reinsure
the risk.
I In April, Valar led Bestow's Series A financing with
an $11M investment at a $44M pre-money valuation.
✓ Valar Fund 4 owns 20% of Bestow.
S bestow
Take our 3 minute
assessment.
0  T II tittle Neu. yourself.
This hey we ton twee • perfect helot, Mal is
&Pored la ,wan. yOur I arra ,/
',III A out ol So quenlearsItt
r Bask auntkffit about yo u• Inettelosna
I health so we (err get the hest .at. lot you.
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$11.0M
$11.0M
1.Ox
$55M
NEA, 8VC, Morpheus Ventures
VALAR / 30
&MVO WWII/ err •
_tad Valar Fund 4 /
'monf amalgam.*
taxfix Hassle-Free Tax Filing
from Your Phone
POWER
OF PARKS
•
••
•••• •• • - -. •• 0
-0 I. •
•• • • I • •
o

• • • •
• , •' 4 1 • •
• •'
• • •
1
•
•
• • es* • * •
• •
•
• IP • `
•
• • I •• •
• 0•1/)
• • •
• •
••
a V
0 •
•
•

• s • •
•
AN
•
•
•
• • •
• •
" • • •
•
• , • •
• • a I % • I  • • • a • I
a • a 0
• a
•
•
• 0;
• • %
t be

• •
a • •
• •
St‘‘ • I 1 •• 1 0
•• • •
• •
k .• • *lb.  711,•
• ,,,,
_ • •
VALAR / 31
CS
Valar Fund 4 / Core In\ estinctit!,
Taxfix Background
✓ Taxfix was founded in Berlin by Mathis Buechi and
Lino Teuteberg, repeat entrepreneurs who previously
founded Smallpdf, a SaaS business with over 15
million customers.
1 Taxfix asks users simple questions and optimizes
their taxes intelligently - completing the whole
process in 60 minutes or less.
1 While it is not currently tax season, the company is
experiencing 38% month-over-month revenue
growth, with approximately 10,000 new installs per
week.
1 Taxfix is focused on preparing for the next tax year
in Germany and taking steps towards expansion to
Italy, France and the UK.
1 In August, Valar led the Series A round for Taxfix,
investing E6.6M at a €25M pre-money valuation.
1 Valar Fund 4 owns 20% of Taxfix.
taxfix
The Tax App
File your taxes on your mobile
phone! Answer simple questions
and receive 935 € tax return in
average.
d Appgrore Google Play
Doing your taxes in 5 simple steps
1st
lent4
No M1 •••••••••
WWI
nee
loam .11 set
aa•I pas..

• nin.
*W.
dl
0 0
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$7.8M
$7.5M (change due to FX)
1.0x
£33M
Creandum, Redalpine Venture Partners
VALAR / 32
Valar Fund 4/
LOANSTREET
A Marketplace for Commercial Loans
A A A
LOANSTREET Clients Services About Us Media Resources Careers Sly Up Login
Valar Fund 4 / ( of
LoanStreet Background
✓ LoanStreet connects financial institutions to a
network of lenders by standardizing and automating
the complex process of loan syndication.
1 LoanStreet's mission is to bring simplicity and
innovation to all aspects of a lender's syndication
program.
1 LoanStreet's registered users and AUM are growing
steadily month-over-month. Growth acceleration is
expected starting in Q4 of this year.
1 LoanStreet's long-term goal is to expand its platform
beyond credit unions to regional and national banks,
and ultimately to alternative lenders.
✓ In June, Valar led the Series A round for LoanStreet,
investing $5.2M at a pre-money valuation of
$19.5M.
1 Valar Fund 4 owns 20% of LoanStreet.

• I II •
• • • .•
0 • • ...
s • •
• • •
*
•
tot •
•
•
SERVICES
LoanStreet's products and services allow lenders of all sizes to originate, manage and trade
loans on infinitely scalable infrastructure.
PARTICIPATION &
SYNDICATION REPORTING
Il
ANALYTICS ORIGINATION &
ADMINISTRATION
•

• •
• • •
• • •
• • re
•
• •
• •
•
• •
• • • • •
.
• •
• • •
• • • • • •
• • • • •
•
•
•
•
• •
• • •
• • • •
•
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Gross Multiple:
Current Company Valuation:
Other Key Investors:
$5.2M
$5.2M
1.Ox
$26M
Third Prime Capital
VALAR / 34
EFTA01093509 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Crypto Currency Partners II partnership draft for Epstein crypto fund
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS II, LP
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
THE LIMITED PARTNER INTERESTS IN THIS PARTNERSHIP (THE "/NTEREVIS")
HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE
COMMISSION UNDER THE U.S. SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED (THE
"SECURITIES ACT') OR QUALIFIED UNDER ANY STATE SECURITIES LAW. A
HOLDER OF AN INTEREST MAY NOT SELL, PLEDGE, HYPOTHECATE OR
OTHERWISE TRANSFER THAT INTEREST, OR ANY INTEREST IN THAT INTEREST (A
"TRANSFER'), UNLESS THE HOLDER CAN DEMONSTRATE THAT THE PROPOSED
TRANSFER WILL NOT VIOLATE THE REGISTRATION REQUIREMENTS OF THE
SECURITIES ACT AND ANY ANALOGOUS REQUIREMENTS OF APPLICABLE STATE
LAW. IN ADDITION, UNDER THIS AGREEMENT, TRANSFERS OF INTERESTS (EVEN
TRANSFERS THAT ARE PERMISSIBLE UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT AND
APPLICABLE STATE LAW) GENERALLY REQUIRE THE GENERAL PARTNER'S
CONSENT. EXCEPT IN EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES, LIMITED PARTNERS
MAY NOT WITHDRAW ANY OF THE CAPITAL ATTRIBUTABLE TO THEIR INTERESTS.
ACCORDINGLY, INVESTORS SHOULD BE AWARE THAT THEY MAY BE REQUIRED
TO BEAR THE FINANCIAL RISKS OF THIS INVESTMENT FOR AN INDEFINITE
PERIOD OF TIME.
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
[THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
ACTIVE 20358ASSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
ARTICLE I NAME, PURPOSE AND OFFICES OF PARTNERSHIP 1
1.1 Name 1
1.2 Purpose 1
1.3 Principal Offices 1
1.4 Registered Agent and Office 2
ARTICLE II TERM OF PARTNERSHIP 2
2.1 Term 2
2.2 Events Affecting A Limited Partner 2
2.3 Events Affecting The General Partner 2
ARTICLE III NAME AND ADMISSION OF PARTNERS 2
3.1 Name And Address 2
3.2 Initial Closing Date; Admission Of Additional Partners 2
ARTICLE IV CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS, AND NONCONTRIBUTING PARTNERS 3
4.1 Capital Contributions Of The Limited Partners. 3
4.2 Capital Contributions Of The General Partner 4
4.3 Noncontributing Partners 4
4.4 Early Termination of the Investment Period 6
ARTICLE V CAPITAL ACCOUNTS AND ALLOCATIONS OF PROFITS AND LOSSES 6
5.1 Capital Accounts 6
5.2 Allocation of Profit and Loss 7
5.3 Special Allocations 7
5.4 Income Tax Allocations 8
5.5 Tax Elections 9
ARTICLE VI MANAGEMENT FEE; PARTNERSHIP EXPENSES 10
6.1 Management Fee. 10
6.2 Expenses 10
ARTICLE VII WITHDRAWALS BY AND DISTRIBUTIONS 10 THE PARTNERS 11
7.1 Interest 11
7.2 Withdrawals By The Partners 11
7.3 Partners' Obligation To Repay Or Restore 11
7.4 Distributions — General Principles. 11
7.5 Amounts and Priority of Distributions 12
7.6 Tax Distributions. 12
7.7 Withholding Obligations. 13
7.8 Limitation on Distributions 13
7.9 Mandatory Withdrawal. 13
7.10 Reallocation In the Event of Default or Withdrawal 14
ARTICLE VIII MANAGEMENT DUTIES AND RESTRICTIONS 14
8.1 Management 14
8.2 No Control by the Limited Partners; No Withdrawal 15
8.3 Activities of the General Partner 15
ACTIVE 203518680v.2
8.4 No Removal of General Partner 15
ARTICLE IX TRANSFER OF PARTNERSHIP IIVI I Rrisrs 16
9.1 Transfer by General Partner; Withdrawal 16
9.2 Transfer by Limited Partner 16
9.3 Requirements for Transfer 16
9.4 Substitution as a Limited Partner 17
9.5 Expenses of Transfer 17
ARTICLE X DISSOLUTION AND LIQUIDATION OF THE PARTNERSHIP 17
10.1 Dissolution 17
10.2 Winding Up Procedures 17
10.3 Final Distribution 18
10.4 Liquidating Trust 18
ARTICLE XI FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING, REPORTS, VOTING AND CONFIDENTIALITY 18
11.1 Financial Accounting; Fiscal Year 18
11.2 Supervision; Inspection Of Books 19
11.3 _Quarterly Reports 19
11.4 Annual Report; Financial Statements of the Partnership 19
11.5 Tax Returns and Information 19
11.6 Tax Matters Partner 19
11.7 Annual Meetings Error! Bookmark not defined.20
11.8 Voting 20
11.9 Confidential Information 20
ARTICLE XII VALUATION; ADVISORY COMMITTEE 21
12.1 Valuation 21
12.2 Advisory Committee 21
ARTICLE XIII OTHER PROVISIONS 22
13.1 Governing Law 22
13.2 Limitation of Liability of the Limited Partners 22
13.3 ERISA Partners 22
13.4 Private Foundation Partners 22
13.5 Exculpation. 23
13.6 Indemnification 23
13.7 Execution 24
13.8 Other Instruments and Acts 24
13.9 Binding Agreement 24
13.10 Notices 24
13.11 Power of Attorney 24
13.12 Amendment; Waiver 25
13.13 Entire Agreement 25
13.14 Titles; Subtitles 26
13.15 Partnership Name 26
13.16 Legal Counsel 26
13.17 Arbitration; Jurisdiction 26
13.18 S bap , 27
13.19 Interpretation 27
ARTICLE XIV CERTAIN DEFINITIONS 28
ACTIVE 2035/81030v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
CRYPTO CURRENCY PARTNERS II, LP
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
THIS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (this "Agnomens') is made and entered into as
of October , 2014, by and among STEPHENS INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, LLC, a Delaware
limited liability company (the "General Panne?) and the parties listed from time to time on the books
and records of the Partnership as limited partners (the "Limited Partners"), who hereby form CRYPTO
CURRENCY PARTNERS II, LP (the "PatInersh0"), pursuant to the provisions of the Delaware
Revised Uniform Limited Partnership Act (the "Acs'').
WITNESSETH:
WHEREAS, the Partnership was formed pursuant to a Certificate of Limited Partnership
executed by the General Partner and filed for recordation in the office of the Secretary of State of the
State of Delaware dated as of August 6th, 2014.
WHEREAS, the parties hereto have heretofore operated the Partnership under an oral
partnership agreement (the "Formation Agreement") and desire to replace the Formation Agreement in
full with this Agreement.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual promises and agreements herein
made and intending to be legally bound hereby, the parties hereto agree to amend and restate the
Formation Agreement in its entirety to read as follows:
ARTICLE I
NAME, PURPOSE AND OFFICES OF PARTNERSHIP
1.1 Name. The name of the Partnership is "Crypto Currency Partners II, LP". The
affairs of the Partnership shall be conducted under the Partnership name or such other name as the
General Partner may, in its discretion, determine.
1.2 Purpose. The purpose of the Partnership is to make investments ("Portfolio
Investments") in privately held, early stage companies involved in the crypto currency industry (as
broadly defined), as well as in other related industries, and in Crypto Currencies. The Partnership
will have the power to do any and all acts necessary, appropriate, desirable, incidental or convenient
to or for the furtherance of the purposes described in this Section 1.2, including any and all of the
powers that may be exercised on behalf of the Partnership by the General Partner pursuant to this
Agreement. In furtherance of these purposes, the Partnership may exercise all rights, powers,
privileges, and other incidents of ownership or possession with respect to Portfolio Investments held
or owned by the Partnership; enter into, make, and perform all contracts and other undertakings
related to the foregoing; and engage in all related activities and transactions as may be necessary,
advisable, or desirable to carry out the foregoing, as determined by the General Partner.
1.3 Principal Offices. The principal office of the Partnership is located at I Ferry
Building, Suite 255, San Francisco, California 94111, or such other place or places as the General
Partner may from time to time designate.
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CRYPT() CURRfiNCY PARritiRC II, LP
Limited Patinenbip Armed —Page
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
1.4 Registered Agent and Office. The name of the registered agent for service of
process of the Partnership and the address of the Partnership's registered office in the State of
Delaware is Incorporating Services, Ltd., 3500 South Dupont Highway, Dover, Delaware 19901 or
such other agent or office in the State of Delaware as the General Partner may from time to time
designate.
ARTICLE II
TERM OF PARTNERSHIP
2.1 Term. The term of the Partnership commenced upon the date of filing of the
Certificate of Limited Partnership of the Partnership with the Secretary of State of Delaware and
shall continue until the Partnership is dissolved pursuant to Section 10.1.
2.2 Events Affecting a Limited Partner. The death, temporary or permanent
incapacity, insanity, incompetency, bankruptcy, liquidation, dissolution, reorganization, merger, sale
of all or substantially all of the stock or assets of, or other change in the ownership or nature of a
Limited Partner shall not dissolve the Partnership.
2.3 Events Affecting the General Partner. Except as described in Section 10.1(c),
changes in the ownership or nature of the General Partner shall not cause the dissolution of the
Partnership, and upon the happening of any such event, the affairs of the Partnership shall be
continued automatically by a successor entity formed by the continuing members of the General
Partner or by the remaining general partner(s) of the Partnership, if any.
ARTICLE III
NAME AND ADMISSION OF PARTNERS
3.1 Name And Address. The General Partner shall cause the books and records of
the Partnership to be amended from time to time to reflect the addresses of the General Partner and
each Limited Partner (the General Partner and the Limited Partners shall be referred to collectively as
the "Partners" and individually as a "Parini?) and changes thereto and the transfer of Interests and
changes in Capital Commitments that are accomplished in accordance with the provisions hereof.
3.2 Initial Closing Date; Admission Of Additional Partners.

(a) Additional persons may be admitted as Limited Partners, or existing
Limited Partners may increase their Capital Commitment to the Partnership (in each case, a "later-
admitted Partin?) at one or more closings (each, a "Clueing, (i) at the General Partner's sole
discretion at any time until the 6-month anniversary of the Initial Closing Date; (ii) with the consent
of the General Partner and a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners; or (iii) pursuant to
Sections 4.3 or 9.4.

(a) Each later-admitted Partner may be required to make a Capital
Contribution of up to such later-admitted Partner's pro rota share, based on the Partners' respective
Capital Commitments, of all Capital Contributions (other than Capital Contributions to pay the
Management Fee described in Section 6.1 in respect of such Capital Commitments) made by earlier-
admitted Partners (taking into account the Capital Commitments of other later-admitted Partners
admitted at the applicable Closing and any distributions made to the earlier-admitted Partners)
("Catch-Up Contribution?). Catch -Up Contributions may (in the General Partner's discretion) be
retained by the Fund, or distributed (in whole or in part) to the Partners in proportion to their
Percentage Interests. Catch -Up Contributions distributed to Partners shall be added back to their
CRYP7T) CURRENCY PAW:IV/MT II, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Astrrment—Page 2
ACTIVE 20358111180v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
respective Unfunded Capital Commitments and be subject to recall by the General Partner pursuant
to Article IV.

(b) In addition to the foregoing, each later-admitted Partner will be required to
make a Capital Contribution to the Fund equal to his, her or its allocable share of the Management
Fee that otherwise would have been payable had the later-admitted Partner been admitted on the
Initial Closing Date. All such amounts will be paid over to the General Partner (or its designee).

(c) Each later-admitted Partner shall participate in all of the Partnership's
Portfolio Investments and bear its share of all Organizational Expenses and Partnership Expenses in
accordance with its Percentage Interest, as if such later-admitted Partner had been admitted as of the
Initial Closing Date. The General Partner shall adjust the Percentage Interests of the Partners as
necessary to take into account Capital Commitments from later-admitted Partners.
(c1) Each additional person admitted as a Partner shall execute and deliver to
the Partnership any document(s) deemed appropriate by the General Partner, including a counterpart
of this Agreement.
ARTICLE IV
CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS, AND NONCONTRIBUTING PARTNERS
4.1 Capital Contributions Of The Limited Partners.

(a) The General Partner may require each Partner to make one or more Capital
Contributions in an amount equal to all or any portion of such Partner's Unfunded Capital
Commitment by providing a written notice to such Partner pursuant to Section 4.1(b) (a "Capital
Cat) prior to the date on which such Capital Contribution shall be due (the "Call Da/4 All Capital
Contributions must be submitted by wire transfer or check in the form of cash; provided that the
General Partner may permit Partners to contribute Crypto Currencies or other non -cash assets in the
General Partner's discretion. The General Partner shall determine the value of any non -cash assets
contributed in accordance with Section 12.1 as of the applicable Call Date; provided, that the value of
any non -cash assets contributed by the General Partner pursuant to Section 4.2 shall be determined
in accordance with that section. The Partnership may assess a special charge against the Partner
contributing non -cash assets equal to the actual costs the Partnership incurs in connection with
accepting such assets, including the costs of liquidating those assets, adjusting the Partnership's
portfolio to accommodate them, or performing special tax-related accounting functions. Any such
special charge may be assessed as of the Call Date on which the assets are contributed or as of the
end of the Period in which the Partnership incurred them. Such special charge shall not be treated as
a Capital Contribution and shall not reduce the contributing Partner's Unfunded Capital
Commitment. Each Limited Partner's Capital Commitment may be used for all Partnership
purposes permitted herein. Except as otherwise provided in Section 4.1(c) below, no Capital Calls
shall be issued after the expiration of the Investment Period.
(b) A Capital Call shall be in the form of a written notice given to all Partners
in any manner permitted by Section 13.10 at least 10 Business Days before the Call Date, provided,
that such prior written notice shall not be required in connection with any Capital Contribution to be
made at a Closing. A Capital Call shall specify the dollar amount required to be contributed by the
relevant Partner, and the Call Date, and each Limited Partner shall be required to make a Capital
Contribution in the amount specified on that Call Date. The General Partner may amend, delay or
rescind Capital Calls at any time prior to the relevant Call Date. The amendment, delay or rescission
of a Capital Call shall not affect or abridge the right of the General Partner to issue any subsequent
Capital Call. The General Partner will generally be entitled to determine each Partner's share of each
CR MD CURAhNCY PA RTNHRS 11, LP
Ladled Patinenbip Arming —Page 3
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
Capital Call in its discretion; provided, that (for the avoidance of doubt, and notwithstanding anything
to the contrary contained in this Agreement) no Partner will be required to contribute more than his,
her or its Unfunded Capital Commitment in response to any Capital Call. In addition, the General
Partner generally intends to "normalize" the Partners' Capital Contributions so that the aggregate
amount of capital contributed by the Partners over the Investment Period will be in proportion to
their respective Percentage Interests by the end of the Investment Period. Accordingly, any Partner
who, as of any Call Date, has contributed aggregate amounts in excess of his, her or its Percentage
Interest of all Capital Contributions previously made by the Partners may be excused (by the General
Partner, in its discretion) from making additional Capital Contributions until that excess is eliminated;
similarly, any Partner who has contributed less than his, her or its Percentage Interest of all such
Capital Contributions may be required to make Capital Contributions in excess of his, her or its
Percentage Interest until that shortfall is eliminated.

(c) During the Harvesting Period, the General Partner may only issue Capital
Calls for the purpose of: (1) paying ongoing Organizational Expenses, Partnership Expenses and
liabilities, including the Management Fees (or the establishment of reserves for such amounts);

(ii) making investments that are in process as of the end of the Investment Period; (ii) making
follow-on investments in existing Portfolio Investments; or (iv) enabling the Partnership to acquire a
Defaulting Partner's Interest pursuant to Section 4.2(b) below. The "Nanning Period' is the period
commencing on the day after the expiration of the Investment Period and ending on the fourth
anniversary thereafter; prodded, that such period may be extended for up to 12 months at the election
of the General Partner, acting in its sole discretion, and for a further 12-month period with the
consent of a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners.
4.2 Capital Contributions Of The General Partner. The General Partner's Capital
Commitment shall not be less than the lesser of: (i) 2.5% of the aggregate Capital Commitments of
the Limited Partners; or (ii) $500,000. The General Partner intends to satisfy its Capital
Commitment partially by making "in -kind" contributions of securities (in addition to cash) to the
Partnership. These securities were acquired by the General Partner in private transactions prior to
the date hereof, are illiquid, and will be valued at cost (i.e., at the price at which the General Partner
acquired the securities, without regard to any deemed appreciation or depreciation in their fair market
value). While the General Partner believes that valuing these securities at cost is reasonable, Limited
Partners acknowledge that the General Partner has a conflict of interest in valuing such securities and
that the contribution of such securities to the Partnership will not be at "arm's -length". By signing
this Agreement, each Limited Partner shall be deemed to have consented to the foregoing.
4.3 Noncontributing Partners.

(a) The Partnership shall be entitled to enforce the obligations of each Limited
Partner to make cash contributions up to the total amount of such Limited Partner's Capital
Commitment and to pay back distributions as required herein, and the Partnership shall have all
remedies available at law or in equity in the event any such contribution or payment is not so made,
including the right for the Partnership to apply proceeds that otherwise would be distributed to a
noncontributing Limited Partner toward any delinquent contributions or required return of
distributions (the "Default Amount'), or any costs or expenses described below. The Limited Partners
agree that the Partnership's choice of remedies, including the remedies set forth in Sections 4.3(b)
and 4.3(d) below, shall be at the General Partner's sole discretion and shall be binding upon the
other Partners and the Partnership without any liability to the General Partner. A noncontributing
Limited Partner may, at the General Partner's discretion, be required to pay all costs and expenses
incurred by the Partnership in enforcing such Limited Partner's contribution obligation, including
attorneys' fees. Amounts so paid pursuant to the immediately preceding sentence shall not be treated
CRYPIDCURRIINCY PARTNERS II, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Agrerment—Page 4
ACTIVE 20351ISSSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
as Capital Contributions and shall not reduce the noncontributing Partner's Unfunded Capital
Commitment.
(b) Without limiting any right of the Partnership pursuant to Section 4.3(a)
above, if any Limited Partner fails to make any of the contributions or payments when due, the
General Partner may, at its option, declare the Limited Partner to be in default (such event, an "Event
of Default' and such Limited Partner, a "Defaulting Limited Panne?). The General Partner shall
provide such Defaulting Limited Partner notice of its default, which may give rise to the
consequences set forth in this Section 4.3(b) and Section 4.3(d). In such case, the General Partner,
in its sole discretion, may elect one or more of the following remedies (or any combination thereon:
CO cause the Defaulting Limited Partner to forfeit its right to
participate in any Portfolio Investments made after the Event of Default;
cause the Defaulting Limited Partner to transfer all of its Interest
to one or more Non -Defaulting Partners selected by the General Partner, which have agreed to
purchase such Interest, effective immediately, at a transfer price equal to the lesser of (A) 50% of
such Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Account or (B) 50% of the Fair Market Value of the
Defaulting Limited Partner's Interest, determined by the General Partner in accordance with

Section 12.1. In such case, the Defaulting Limited Partner shall be treated as having no further
Interest, and shall no longer be a Limited Partner;
(iii) cause the Defaulting Limited Partner to sell all of its Interest to one
or more third parties at a price determined by the General Partner in its sole discretion to be fair and
reasonable under the circumstances (which determination shall be final and binding on the
Defaulting Limited Partner). Such Person or Persons shall, after executing such instruments and
delivering such opinions and other documents as are in form and substance satisfactory to the
General Partner, be admitted to the Partnership as a substituted Limited Partner or Partners with
respect to such Interest, and shown as such on the books and records of the Partnership. In the case
of a forced sale pursuant to this Section 4.3(b)(iii), the Defaulting Limited Partner shall be entitled
to receive 50% of the proceeds of such forced sale, after deduction for any expenses incurred by the
Partnership resulting from its default, and the Partnership shall be entitled to receive the remaining
portion of such proceeds for distribution to the Non -Defaulting Partners in a fair and equitable
manner as determined in good faith by the General Partner. After giving effect to any forced sale
pursuant to this Section 4.3(b)(iii), the Defaulting Partner shall be treated as having no further
Interest, and shall no longer be a Limited Partner; and/or

(iv) cause the Defaulting Limited Partner to (x) forfeit up to 50% of its
Capital Account balance and (y) limit any future distributions of Current Proceeds and Disposition
Proceeds to the Defaulting Limited Partner to amounts attributable to that reduced Capital Account
balance and any future Capital Contributions. The amount of the Capital Account balance forfeited
(and the right to future distribution of Capital Proceeds and Disposition Proceeds attributable
thereto) shall be reallocated to the Non -Defaulting Partners in accordance with their respective
Percentage Interests. If the General Partner exercises its remedies under this Section 4.3(b)(iv) in
respect of an Event of Default, the Defaulting Partner shall not be relieved of its obligation to make
Capital Contributions subsequent to such Event of Default.

(c) Any distribution or payment to a Defaulting Partner pursuant to

Section 4.3(b) may, in the sole discretion of the General Partner, be made in cash, in the form of a
promissory note of the Partnership (bearing no interest), or any combination thereof.
CR Yin?) CURRENCY P/IRTNtiRf it LP
Parinerthip Agatmott—Page 5
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT

(d) At any time after an Event of Default, the General Partner may, in its sole
discretion, take any or all of the following actions with respect to the Default Amount:
cause the Limited Partners to make additional Capital
Contributions (not in excess of their Unfunded Capital Commitment) in proportion to their
respective Percentage Interests to fund the Default Amount;
cause the Partnership to borrow funds to cover the Default
Amount (including from the General Partner);
(iii) increase its own Capital Contribution to fund the Default Amount;
or

(iv) institute proceedings on behalf of the Partnership to recover the
Default Amount, in which case the Defaulting Limited Partner shall be liable for all costs and
expenses incurred by the Partnership in enforcing such the Default Amount, including attorneys fees.

(e) If the General Partner elects to take the action specified in

Section 4.3(d)(i), the General Partner shall make an additional Capital Call in accordance with

Section 4.1 to the Non -Defaulting Partners.
(0 Each Partner hereby agrees that the charging of expenses to a Defaulting
Limited Partner and/or the buy-out or transfer of a Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Account
pursuant to the above provisions of this Section 4.3 represent liquidated and agreed upon current
damages to the Non -Defaulting Partners for the default (it being agreed that it would be difficult to
fix the actual damages to the Non -Defaulting Partners). Each Partner further agrees that the
aforesaid liquidated damages provision constitutes reasonable compensation to the Partnership and
its Non -Defaulting Partners for the additional risks and damages sustained by them when and if any
Partner shall default on an obligation to pay any Capital Contribution when due.
4.4 Early Termination of the Investment Period. The General Partner at any time
may terminate the Investment Period if, in the good faith judgment of the General Partner, changes
in applicable law, regulation, case law, judicial or administrative order or decree or governmental
license or permit, or any interpretation thereof by any governmental or regulatory authority or court
of competent jurisdiction, or in business conditions, make such termination necessary or advisable in
the interests of the Partnership or any of the Partners.
ARTICLE V
CAPITAL ACCOUNTS AND ALLOCATIONS OF PROFITS AND LOSSES
5.1 Capital Accounts.

(a) A separate capital account (the "Capital Amount') shall be established and
maintained for each Partner. The Capital Account of each Partner shall be credited with such
Partner's Capital Contributions to the Partnership, all Profits allocated to such Partner pursuant to

Section 5.2 and any items of income or gain that are specially allocated pursuant to Section 5.3 or
otherwise pursuant to this Agreement; and shall be debited with all Losses allocated to such Partner
pursuant to Section 5.2, any items of loss or deduction of the Partnership specially allocated to such
Partner pursuant to Section 5.3 or otherwise pursuant to this Agreement, and all cash and the
Adjusted Asset Value of any property (net of liabilities assumed by such Partner and the liabilities to
which such property is subject) distributed by the Partnership to such Partner. To the extent not
provided for in the preceding sentence, the Capital Accounts of the Partners shall be adjusted and
CRYPID CURRENCY PARTicnat 11,1.P
Limited Patinersh0 Astroment—Page 6
ACTIVE 20351ISSSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
maintained in accordance with the rules of Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv), as the
same may be amended or revised, and the provisions of this Agreement shall be interpreted
consistently therewith; provided, however that such adjustment and maintenance does not have a
material adverse effect on the economic interests of the Partners. Any references in any section of
this Agreement to the Capital Account of a Partner shall be deemed to refer to such Capital Account
as the same may be credited or debited from time to time as set forth above. In the event of any
transfer of any Interest in accordance with the terms of this Agreement, the transferee shall succeed
to the Capital Account of the transferor to the extent it relates to the transferred Interest.
(b) Except as may arise solely by reason of the operation of Section 13.6(b),
no Partner shall be required to pay to the Partnership or to any other Partner the amount of any
negative balance that may exist from time to time in such Partner's Capital Account, including at the
time of liquidation of the Partnership.
5.2 Allocation of Profit and Loss. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement,
Profits and Losses (and, to the extent necessary, individual items of income, gain, loss and deduction)
for any Fiscal Period shall be allocated among the Partners in a manner such that the Capital
Account of each Partner, immediately after making such allocation and after taking into account
amounts specially allocated pursuant to Section 5.3 or any other provision of this Agreement, is, as
nearly as possible, equal (proportionately) to (i) the distributions that would be made to such Partner
pursuant to Section 7.5 if the Partnership were dissolved, its affairs wound up and its assets sold for
cash equal to their Adjusted Asset Value, all Partnership liabilities were satisfied (limited with respect
to each nonrecourse liability to the Adjusted Asset Value of the assets securing such liability), and the
net assets of the Partnership were distributed in accordance with Section 7.5 to the Partners
immediately after making such allocation, minus (ii) such Partner's share of Partnership Minimum
Gain and Partner Nonrecourse Debt Minimum Gain, computed immediately prior to the
hypothetical sale of assets. The General Partner shall be entitled to adjust the allocations of Profits
and Losses (and items thereof) to take into account any of the economic provisions of this
Agreement, including the timing and amount of actual distributions to the Partners; provided, however
that any such adjustment shall not affect the amount distributable to a Partner pursuant to this
Agreement.
5.3 Special Allocations. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the allocations provided in
this Article V shall be subject to the following exceptions:

(a) Minimum Gain Chtngeback. Notwithstanding any other provision in this
Article V, if there is a net decrease in Partnership Minimum Gain or Partner Nonrecourse Debt
Minimum Gain (determined in accordance with the principles of Treasury Regulations
Sections 1.704-2(d) and 1.704-2(0) during any Partnership taxable year, the Partners shall be specially
allocated items of Partnership income and gain for such year (and, if necessary, subsequent years) in
an amount equal to their respective shares of such net decrease during such year, determined
pursuant to Treasury Regulations Sections 1.704-2(g) and 1.704-20)(5). The items to be so allocated
shall be determined in accordance with Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-2(f). This Section 5.3(a)
is intended to comply with the minimum gain chargeback requirements in such Treasury Regulations
Sections and shall be interpreted consistently therewith; including that no chargeback shall be
required to the extent of the exceptions provided in Treasury Regulations Sections 1.704-2M and
1.704-20)(4).

(b) _Qualified Income ()pet. In the event any Partner unexpectedly receives any
adjustments, allocations, or distributions described in Treasury Regulation Section 1.704-
1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), (5) or (6), items of Partnership income and gain shall be specially allocated to such
Partner in an amount and manner sufficient to eliminate the deficit balance in his Capital Account
CR 177I7 CURAhNCY PA RTNI9175 11,1-P
Limited Patinetthip Agennestt—Page 7
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
created by such adjustments, allocations or distributions as promptly as possible. This

Section 5.3(b) is intended to comply with the "qualified income offset" requirement in such
Regulation section shall be interpreted consistently therewith.

(c) Gross Income Allocation. In the event any Partner has a deficit Capital
Account at the end of any Fiscal Period that is in excess of the sum of: (i) the amount such Partner is
obligated to restore, if any, pursuant to any provision of this Agreement; and (ii) the amount such
Partner is deemed to be obligated to restore pursuant to the penultimate sentences of Treasury
Regulations Section 1.704-2(g)(1) and 1.704-2®(5), each such Partner shall be specially allocated
items of Partnership income and gain in the amount of such excess as quickly as possible; provided,
however that an allocation pursuant to this Section 5.3(c) shall be made only if and to the extent that a
Partner would have a deficit Capital Account in excess of such sum after all other allocations
provided for in this Section 5.3(c) have been tentatively made as if Section 5.3(b) and this

Section 5.3(c) were not in this Agreement.
(c0 Nonrecourse Deductions. Nonrecourse Deductions shall be allocated to the
Partners in proportion to their Capital Contributions with respect to the related Portfolio
Investment.

(e) Partner Nontreourre Deductions. Partner Nonrecourse Deductions for any
Fiscal Period shall be allocated to the Partner who bears the economic risk of loss with respect to the
liability to which such Partner Nonrecourse Deductions are attributable in accordance with Treasury
Regulations Section 1.704-2(j).
(0 Curative Allocations. If any special allocations are made under
Sections 5.3(a), (13), (c), (d), or (e) (the "Regulatory Allocation!) the General Partner may take such
Regulatory Allocations into account in making subsequent allocations of Profits or Losses (or items
thereof), and may make such further special allocations as may be necessary or appropriate so as to
prevent such Regulatory Allocations from distorting the manner in which Partnership distributions
will be divided among the Partners pursuant to this Agreement.

(g) General Partner Expenses. To the extent, if any, that General Partner
Expenses and any items of loss, expense or deduction resulting therefrom are deemed to constitute
items of Partnership loss or deduction rather than items of loss or deduction of the General Partner,
such General Partner Expenses and other items of loss, expense or deduction shall be allocated
100% to the General Partner.

(h) Payee Allocation. In the event any payment to any person that is treated by
the Partnership as the payment of an expense is recharacteri2.ed by a taxing authority as a Partnership
distribution to the payee as a partner, such payee shall be specially allocated an amount of
Partnership gross income and gain as quickly as possible equal to the amount of the distribution.
5.4 Income Tax Allocations.

(a) Except as otherwise provided in this Section 5.4 or as otherwise required
by the Code and the rules and Treasury Regulations promulgated thereunder, a Partner's distributive
share of Partnership income, gain, loss, deduction, or credit for income tax purposes shall be the
same as the adjustments to the Partner's Capital Account pursuant to this Agreement.

(b) In accordance with Code Section 704(c) and the Treasury Regulations
thereunder, income, gain, loss and deduction with respect to any asset contributed to the capital of
the Partnership shall, solely for tax purposes, be allocated among the Partners so as to take account
CRYPT?) CURRENCY PA RTIVERT11,1,
Limited Patinersh0 Averment—Page 8
ACTIVE 20351SSSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
of any variation between the adjusted basis of such property to the Partnership for federal income
tax purposes and its initial Adjusted Asset Value, using any method under Treasury Regulation 1.704-
3 as the General Partner determines to be fair and reasonable.

(c) In the event the Adjusted Asset Value of any Partnership asset is adjusted
pursuant to the terms of this Agreement, subsequent allocations of income, gain, loss and deduction
with respect to such asset shall take account of any variation between the adjusted basis of such asset
for federal income tax purposes and its Adjusted Asset Value in the same manner as under Code

Section 704(c) and the Treasury Regulations thereunder, in a manner that the General Partner
determines to be fair and reasonable.
(c1) No Partner shall file a notice with the Internal Revenue Service under

Section 6222(b) of the Code in connection with such Partner's intention to treat an item on such
Partner's federal income tax return in a manner which is inconsistent with the treatment of such item
on the Partnership's federal income tax return unless such Partner has, not less than 30 days prior to
the filing of such notice, provided the tax matters partner with a copy of the notice and thereafter in
a timely manner provides such other information related thereto as the tax matters partner shall
reasonably request.

(e) All matters concerning the determination and allocation among the Partners
of the amounts to be determined and allocated pursuant to this Agreement, including the items of
income, gain, deduction, loss and credit to be determined and allocated pursuant to Sections 5.2, 5.3
and 5.4, and including the taxes thereon and accounting procedures applicable thereto, shall be
determined by the General Partner unless specifically and expressly otherwise provided for by the
provisions of this Agreement, and such determinations and allocations shall be final and binding on
all the Partners.
5.5 Tax Elections. Each Limited Partner hereby agrees and covenants that it shall not
make an election under Code Section 732(4) with respect to property distributed to it by the
Partnership without the prior written consent of the General Partner. The General Partner may, but
shall not be obligated to, cause the Partnership to make an election under Code Section 754 or an
election to be treated as an "electing investment partnership" within the meaning of Code

Section 743(e) or any other election for the Partnership as determined in the General Partner's sole
discretion. If the Partnership elects to be treated as an electing investment partnership, each Limited
Partner shall (a) reasonably cooperate with the Partnership to maintain such status, (b) not take any
action that would be inconsistent with such election, (c) provide the General Partner with any
information necessary to allow the Partnership to comply with its obligations under Sections 734 or
743 of the Code and its tax reporting and other obligations as an electing investment partnership and

(cl) provide the General Partner and such limited Partner's transferee, promptly upon request, with
the information required to be furnished to the Partnership or such transferee, including such
information as is necessary to enable the Partnership and such transferee to compute the amount of
losses disallowed under Code Section 743(e), but in no event shall such Limited Partner be required
to provide such information prior to its receipt of its Schedule K-1 for such taxable year, except to
the extent of information, if any, required by the Partnership to complete its Schedule K-Is.
Regardless whether the Partnership makes the election to be an electing investment partnership,
promptly upon request, each Limited Partner shall provide the General Partner with any information
related to such Partner necessary to allow the Partnership to (i) make any tax basis adjustments under
Sections 734 or 743 of the Code (in the event the General Partner makes a Code Section 754
election) and (ii) to comply with any other tax reporting obligations of the Partnership.
CRYPM CURREN:CY PA WENti ItS II I-P
Limited Partnership Armand—Page 9
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
ARTICLE VI
MANAGEMENT FEE; PARTNERSHIP EXPENSES
6.1 Management Fee.

(a) Beginning on the Initial Closing Date, the Partnership shall be obligated to
pay the General Partner (or its designee) a fee (the "Management Fee") for each calendar quarter during
the term of the Partnership. The Management Fee will be payable in advance on the first day of each
calendar quarter (or, for the first period, as of the Initial Closing Date) in an amount equal to 0.625%
per quarter 2.5% per annum) of: (A) prior to the expiration of the Investment Period, the
aggregate Capital Commitments of the Limited Partners as of the first day of the relevant calendar
quarter; and (B) thereafter, the amount of any Capital Contributions that remain invested in Portfolio
Investments as of the first day of such calendar quarter, as determined by the General Partner. The
Management Fee for the first period (i.e., the period commencing on the Initial Closing Date) will be
prorated based on the number of days remaining in the relevant calendar quarter.

(b) The Management Fee for any calendar quarter shall be reduced (but not
below $0) by the fair value (when awarded) of any compensation paid to the General Partner, or to
any member or manager of the General Partner (including any Principal), as transaction, break-up,
board or consulting fees by any entity in which the Partnership has an interest in the immediately
preceding calendar quarter. If the value of any such compensation exceeds the Management Fee for
any calendar quarter (so that the Management Fee for that calendar quarter would be reduced to SO
by operation of the preceding sentence), then the Management Fees in subsequent calendar quarters
will be similarly reduced (in each case, not below $0), until the aggregate amount by which the
Management Fees have been reduced is equal to the fair value (when awarded) of such
compensation.
6.2 Expenses.

(a) The General Partner shall bear all normal operating expenses incurred by it
and the Partnership in connection with the management of the Partnership. Such normal operating
expenses shall include expenditures on account of salaries, compensation or fringe benefits for its
direct employees, overhead expenses of the General Partner or its direct employees, including rent
and general office expenses, and other expenses incurred with respect to the Partnership's
operations.

(b) In addition to any Management Fee payable pursuant to Section 6.1, the
Partnership shall bear all costs and expenses incurred in connection with carrying on the business of
the Partnership (collectively, "Partnership Expenses), including: (i) all out-of-pocket fees, costs and
expenses (including legal, accounting and other professional fees) directly related to the negotiation,
consummation, making, management, valuation, holding and disposition of Portfolio Investments;

(ii) all out-of-pocket expenses directly related to the purchase or sale of proposed Portfolio
Investments that are not consummated; (iii) all administrative expenses of the Partnership such as the
costs of the annual audit and the preparation and distribution of financial, tax and other reports to
Partners and other legal and accounting expenses; (iv) expenses relating to meetings of Partners;

(v) expenses of the Advisory Committee; (vi) insurance, indemnification or litigation expenses;
(vii) any taxes, fees or other governmental charges levied against the Partnership; (viii) expenses of
liquidating the Partnership; (ix) expenses incurred by the tax matters partner; and (x) any other
expenses incurred by the General Partner for or on behalf of the Partnership.

(c) The Partnership shall bear all organizational and syndication costs,
placement and other fees, and expenses incurred by or on behalf of the General Partner or the
CR MD CURRENCY PA RTMIRT ii, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Astroment—Page 10
ACTIVE 20358111180v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
Partnership in connection with the formation and organization of the Partnership and the General
Partner, including legal, accounting and any other fees or expenses incident thereto ("Otgankational
Expentet).
ARTICLE VII
WITHDRAWALS BY AND DISTRIBUTIONS TO THE PARTNERS
7.1 Interest. No interest shall be paid to any Partner on account of its interest in the
capital of or on account of its investment in the Partnership.
7.2 Withdrawals By The Partners. No Partner may withdraw any amount from its
Capital Account unless such withdrawal is made pursuant to this Article VII or Article X.
7.3 Partners' Obligation To Repay Or Restore. Except as required by law or the
terms of this Agreement, no Partner shall be obligated at any time to repay or restore to the
Partnership all or any part of any distribution made to it from the Partnership in accordance with the
terms of this Article VII or Article X.
7.4 Distributions - General Principles.

(a) Genre. Except as otherwise expressly provided herein, no Partner shall
have the right to withdraw capital from the Partnership or to receive any distribution or return of its
Capital Contribution. Distributions of Partnership assets that are provided for in this Article VII or
in Article X shall be made only to Persons (or their designated custodians) who, according to the
books and records of the Partnership, were the holders of record of Interests in the Partnership on
the date determined by the General Partner as of which the Partners are entitled to any such
distributions.
(b)
below:
Timing of Distributions. Distributions shall be made at the times provided

(i) Current Proceeds shall be distributed at such times and intervals as
the General Partner shall determine, but in no event later than 45 days following the end of the
calendar quarter in which the Current Proceeds are received by the Partnership; prodded, however that
no such distributions need be made if the total amount of Current Proceeds received by the
Partnership is of a de mimimis amount as reasonably determined by the General Partner.
0i) Disposition Proceeds shall be distributed as soon as practicable
after the date those Disposition Proceeds are received by the Partnership.

(c) Distributions will generally be made in cash in United States dollars by wire
transfer of immediately available funds to the account specified in each Limited Partner's
Subscription Agreement. The Partnership may, however, in the General Partner's discretion, make
non-cash distributions (including distributions of crypto currencies). Any non-cash assets to be
distributed shall be valued in accordance with Section 12.1 and distributed according to Section 7.5,
in the same order and priority as a distribution of an equivalent amount of cash.
(c1) The amount of any taxes paid by or withheld from receipts of the
Partnership from a Portfolio Investment that is allocable to a Partner (as determined in good faith by
the General Partner) shall be deemed to have been distributed to such Partner as Current Proceeds
or Disposition Proceeds to the extent that the payment or withholding of such taxes reduced Current
CRYPMCIMUtliNCY PARTNERS 11,1-P
Limited Patinersh# Agnyment—Page 11
ACTIVE 2035181030v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
Proceeds or Disposition Proceeds, as the case may be, otherwise distributable to such Partner as
provided herein.

(e) Amounts distributed during the Investment Period to a Limited Partner
pursuant to Section 7.5(a) (and similar amounts distributed to the General Partner representing a
return of the General Partner's Capital Contributions) shall be deemed to be Recyclable
Distributions.
7.5 Amounts and Priori0 of Distributions. Each distribution of Proceeds
attributable to a Portfolio Investment shall first be tentatively allotted among the Partners in
accordance with their Percentage Interests as of the distribution date (even if the Partners' respective
Capital Contributions are not then "normalized" as contemplated in Section 4.1(b) and are not in
proportion to their respective Percentage Interests as of that date). The portion so allotted to the
General Partner shall then be distributed to the General Partner, and the portion so allotted to each
Limited Partner shall be re-allotted as between that Limited Partner (the "Subject  Limited Partner") and
the General Partner and distributed to them as follows:

(a) First, 100% to the Subject Limited Partner, until the aggregate amount
distributed to the Subject Limited Partner under this Section 7.5(a) equals the aggregate amount of
the Subject Limited Partner's Capital Contributions to the Partnership; and

(b) Second, 25% to the General Partner and 75% to the Subject Limited Partner.
Distributions to the General Partner under Section 7.5(b) above may be referred to herein as the
General Partner's "Craned Interest' as to the relevant Limited Partner. The General Partner may vary
the manner in which its Carried Interest as to any particular Limited Partner is calculated by separate
written arrangement with that Limited Partner.
7.6 Tax Distributions.

(a) The Partnership may make, in the reasonable discretion of the General
Partner, distributions to the General Partner in amounts intended to enable the General Partner (or
any person whose tax liability is determined by reference to the income of the General Partner) to
discharge his, her or its respective U.S. federal, state and local income tax liabilities arising from
aggregate allocations of Profits and Losses made (or to be made) pursuant to this Agreement in
respect of the Carried Interest ("Tax Di:bib:dice). Tax Distributions may be made periodically
throughout each calendar year in order to allow the General Partner (or any person whose tax liability
is determined by reference to the income of the General Partner) to make quarterly estimated tax
payments. Tax Distributions will be based upon the highest marginal effective tax rate (as determined
for each calendar year in which income is allocated to the General Partner in respect of the Carried
Interest) (federal, state and local) payable by a married individual living in San Francisco, California
and filing a joint return.

(b) Cash distributions made pursuant to Section 7.5 during a particular
calendar year shall reduce the distributions otherwise required by Section 7.6(a) with respect to such
calendar year.

(c) The amounts distributed to the General Partner pursuant to Section 7.6(a)
shall reduce, on a dollar -for -dollar basis, the distributions that otherwise would be next due to the
General Partner under the applicable provisions of Section 7.5 (or as applicable, Section 10.3(b)),
and, accordingly shall, for all purposes of this Agreement, be deemed to have been made pursuant to
such provisions of Section 7.5 (or Section 10.3(b), as applicable).
CRYPIDCURRENCY PAW:WERT ii, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Agrerment—Page 12
ACTIVE 2035aSSSay.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
7.7 Withholding Obligation.

(a) To the extent the Partnership is required by law to withhold or to make tax
payments on behalf of or as to any Partner (e.g., (i) backup withholding or (II) withholding as to
Partners that are neither citizens nor residents of the United States, including under Section 1446 of
the Code or otherwise ("Tax Payment!), the Partnership may withhold such amounts and make such
tax payments as may be required.

(b) All Tax Payments made on behalf of a Partner will, at the option of the
Partnership, either be (i) promptly paid to the Partnership by the Partner on whose behalf such Tax
Payments were made, or (i) repaid by reducing the amount of the current or next succeeding
distribution or distributions that otherwise would have been made to such Partner (or, if such
distributions are not sufficient for that purpose, by so reducing the proceeds of liquidation otherwise
payable to such Partner). Whenever the General Partner selects option (ii) pursuant to the preceding
sentence for repayment of a Tax Payment by a Partner, for all other purposes of this Agreement such
Partner will be treated as having received all distributions (whether before or upon liquidation)
unreduced by the amount of such Tax Payments.

(c) Each Partner hereby agrees to indemnify and hold harmless the Partnership
and the General Partner from and against any liability as to Tax Payments required to be made (and
regardless of whether such Tax Payments were in fact made) on behalf of or as to such Partner.

(d) Each Partner will promptly give the Partnership any certification or
affidavit that the Partnership may request in connection with this Section 7.7.
7.8 Limitation on Distributions. Notwithstanding any provisions to the contrary
contained in this Agreement, the Partnership shall not be required to make a distribution to a Partner
on account of its Interest if such distribution would violate any provision of the Act or any other
applicable law, or cause such Partner to have a negative balance in its Capital Account (in excess of
any amount allowed under the Treasury Regulations).
7.9 Mandatog Withdrawal

(a) A Limited Partner may be required to withdraw from the Partnership if
(i) in the reasonable judgment of the General Partner based upon an opinion of counsel to the
Partnership, by virtue of that Limited Partner's Interest, assets of the Partnership are reasonably
likely to be characterized as assets of an employee benefit plan for purposes of the Plan Assets
Regulations or ERISA, whether or not such plan is subject to ERISA or the Code, the Partnership is
reasonably likely to be subject to any requirement to register under the Investment Company Act or
the General Partner is reasonably likely to be in violation of the Investment Advisers Act, or (ii) in
the reasonable judgment of the General Partner, by reason of that Limited Partner's Interest, a
significant delay, extraordinary expense or material adverse effect on the Partnership, the General
Partner, any Portfolio Investment or any prospective investment is likely to result.

(b) A mandatory withdrawal pursuant to this Section 7.9 will be effective as of
(i) the end of the day on which the notice of withdrawal is given; (i) any later time the General
Partner specifies in that notice; or (iii) as to an ERISA Partner, any time as of which the General
Partner determines that the ERISA Partner's ownership of its entire Interest could cause the
Partnership's assets to include "plan assets" within the meaning of ERISA or any other time the
General Partner determines (either of which times may be earlier than the date on which the notice
of withdrawal is given).
CR 177i) CURAHNCYPARnrtet H, LP
limited Partnership Arement—Page 13
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT

(c) The withdrawing Limited Partner shall be entitled to receive within
120 days after the date of such withdrawal an amount equal to the Fair Market Value of such
Partner's Interest as determined by the General Partner in accordance with Section 12.1.

(d) Any distribution or payment to a withdrawing Limited Partner pursuant to
this Section 7.9 may, in the sole discretion of the General Partner, be made immediately in cash,
Crypto Currencies (valued by the General Partner in accordance with Section 13.1) or in the form of
non -interest bearing installment payments, at the time of cash distributions to the Partners or at such
other times as determined by the General Partner. In determining the timing of payments to be
made to the withdrawing Limited Partner, the General Partner will use reasonable efforts to make
payments in cash to the extent reasonably available and subject to the ongoing cash requirements of
the Partnership as determined by the General Partner.
7.10 Reallocation In the Event of Default or Withdrawal. If the General Partner
elects to take any of the actions specified in Sections 4.3(b) and/or 4.3(d) and/or 7.9, the General
Partner shall amend this Agreement (without the consent of any other Partner) to reflect such
transactions (including appropriate changes to the Percentage Interests as determined by the General
Partner in good faith) and cause the books and records of the Partnership to be amended
accordingly.
ARTICLE VIII
MANAGEMENT DUTIES AND RESTRICTIONS
8.1 Management. Subject to the provisions of this Agreement and any limitations
imposed by law, the General Partner shall have the sole and exclusive right to manage, control, and
conduct the affairs of the Partnership and to do any and all acts on behalf of the Partnership,
including the power and authority to:

(a) Receive, buy, sell, exchange, trade and otherwise dispose of Portfolio
Investments and other property of the Partnership;

(b) borrow money or property on behalf of the Partnership, encumber
Partnership property for the purpose of obtaining financing for the Partnership's business, and
extend or modify any obligations of the Partnership;

(c) Employ or retain any qualified person to perform services or provide advice
on behalf of the Partnership and pay reasonable compensation therefor;

(d) Compromise, arbitrate or otherwise adjust claims in favor of or against the
Partnership, and commence or defend litigation with respect to the Partnership or any assets of the
Partnership, at the Partnership's expense;

(e) Cause the Partnership to purchase and maintain, at the Partnership's
expense, insurance coverage reasonably satisfactory to the General Partner with regard to any
circumstance or condition that may affect the Partnership (including any employee or agent thereof),
the General Partner (or any member, employee or agent thereof) in its capacity as such, or any
Person in connection with service by such Person, at the request of the General Partner, as an officer
or director of a Portfolio Investment;
Cause the Partnership to enter into, make and perform upon such
contracts, agreements and other undertakings, and to do such other acts, as it may deem necessary or
CRYPM CURRENCY PAR:IV/MT 11, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Arrnment—Page 14
ACTIVE 20351111SSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
advisable for, or as may be incidental to, the conduct of the business of the Partnership, including
contracts, agreements, undertakings and transactions with a Partner or Person related to a Partner;

(g) To establish reserves for any Partnership purposes and to fund such
reserves with any Partnership assets;

(b) Open, conduct business regarding, draw checks or other payment orders
upon, and close cash, checking, custodial or similar accounts with banks on behalf of the Partnership
and pay the customary fees and charges applicable to transactions in respect of all such accounts; and
CO Assume and exercise all of the authority, rights and powers of a general
partner under the laws of the State of Delaware.
8.2 No Control hy the Limited Partners; No Withdrawal. The Limited Partners
shall take no part in the control or management of the affairs of the Partnership nor shall the Limited
Partners have any authority to act for or on behalf of the Partnership or to vote on any matter
relative to the Partnership and its affairs except as is specifically permitted by this Agreement or
required by law. Except as specifically set forth in this Agreement, the Limited Partners shall have
no right to withdraw from the Partnership.
8.3 Activities of the General Partner.

(a) The Principals shall devote only as much of their time and resources to the
Partnership's activities as they deem necessary and appropriate.

(b) Until the earlier of: (i) the end of the Investment Period; or (ii) the Full
Investment Date, neither the General Partner nor any Principal (as long as such Principal continues
to provide services to the General Partner) may form another pooled investment vehicle with
objectives substantially similar to those of the Partnership without the consent of a Majority in
Interest of the Limited Partners; provided, &mem; that nothing in this Agreement shall be deemed to
prohibit the General Partner or its Affiliates from engaging in marketing activities with respect to
such a pooled investment vehicle. Nothing herein shall prevent the General Partner or the Principals
from entering into joint ventures with third parties in which the Partnership has a direct or indirect
interest.

(c) Except as provided in Sections 8.3(a) and 8.3(b), the General Partner, any
member of the General Partner, any Principal, or any Affiliate, officer, director or employee of the
General Partner or a Principal shall not be precluded from engaging in or pursuing, directly or
indirectly, any activity, investment, or business venture of any kind, nature or description,
independently or with others. Each of the Limited Partners hereby consents and agrees to the
foregoing, and agrees that neither the Partnership nor any of its Partners shall have any rights in or to
such activity, investment, or business venture, or any profits derived therefrom.
(d) Each of the Limited Partners hereby recognizes and agrees that the General
Partner may offer (but is under no obligation to provide) the right to participate in investment
opportunities of the Partnership to other private investors, groups, partnerships or corporations
(including any Limited Partner) at such times as the General Partner determines in its sole discretion.
8.4 No Removal of General Partner. The General Partner may not be removed
(whether by a vote of the Limited Partners or otherwise).
CRYP7I7 CURAHNCY PART:Vitt it LP
Limited Patine.* Agnyment—Page 15
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
ARTICLE IX
TRANSFER OF PARTN I INTERESTS.
9.1 Transfer by General Partner; Withdrawal. The General Partner shall not sell,
assign, mortgage, pledge or otherwise dispose of its Interest without the prior written consent of a
more than Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners; provided, however, that the General Partner may
transfer its Interest to an Affiliate without the consent of any Partner. The General Partner will not
voluntarily withdraw from the Partnership.
9.2 Transfer by Limited Partner. No Limited Partner shall sell, assign, pledge,
mortgage, or otherwise dispose of or transfer its Interest without the prior written consent of the
General Partner, which consent may be granted or withheld in the General Partner's sole and
absolute discretion. Notwithstanding the foregoing, after delivery of the opinion of counsel
hereinafter required by Section 9.3, a Limited Partner may sell, assign, pledge, mortgage, or
otherwise dispose of or transfer its Interest without such consent (a) to an Affiliate (including an
estate planning vehicle); (b) pursuant to a merger, plan of reorganization, sale or pledge of, or other
general encumbrance on all or substantially all of the Limited Partner's assets; (c) as may be required
by any law or regulation; or (d) by testamentary disposition or intestate succession.
9.3 Requirements for Transfer. No transfer or other disposition of the interest of any
Limited Partner shall be permitted until the General Partner shall have received an opinion of
counsel reasonably satisfactory to it (or waived such requirement) that the effect of such transfer or
disposition would not:
result in the Partnership's assets being considered "plan assets" within the
meaning of the Plan Assets Regulation, or in a non-exempt "prohibited transaction," as defined in

Section 4975 of the Code or Section 406 of ERISA;

(b) result in the termination of the Partnership's tax year under

Section 708(b)(I)(B) of the Code;
(c) result in violation of the Securities Act, any comparable state laws or the
applicable securities laws of any other jurisdiction;
(c0 require the Partnership to register as an investment company under the
Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended;

(e) require the Partnership, the General Partner, or any member of the General
Partner to register as an investment adviser under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended;
(0 result in a termination of the Partnership's status as a partnership for
federal income tax purposes;

(g) result in a violation of any law, rule, or regulation by the transferring
Limited Partner, the Partnership, the General Partner, or any member of the General Partner; or
(h) cause the Partnership to be deemed a "publicly traded partnership" within
the meaning of Section 7704(b) of the Code.
Such legal opinion shall be provided to the General Partner by the transferring Limited Partner or
the proposed transferee. Upon request, the General Partner will use its good faith diligent efforts to
CRIPM aRRENcr PARMTHRT it, Ili
Limited Parmash0 Astrnment—Page 16
ACTIVE 20351ISSSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
provide any information possessed by the Partners and reasonably requested by the transferring
Limited Partner to enable it to render the foregoing opinion.
9.4 Substitution as a Limited Partner. A transferee of a Limited Partner's interest
pursuant to this Article IX shall become a substituted Limited Partner only with the consent of the
General Partner, which consent may be withheld in the General Partner's sole and absolute
discretion for any reason or for no reason, and only if such transferee (a) elects to become a
substituted Limited Partner and (b) executes, acknowledges and delivers to the Partnership such
other instruments as the General Partner may deem necessary or advisable to effect the admission of
such transferee as a substituted Limited Partner, including the written acceptance and adoption by
such transferee of the provisions of this Agreement. No assignment by a Limited Partner of its
Interest shall release the assignor from its liability to the Partnership pursuant to Section 4.1 hereof,
provided, however that if the assignee becomes a Limited Partner as provided in this Section 9.4, the
assignor shall thereupon so be released (in the case of a partial assignment, to the extent of such
assignment). Regardless whether the transferee is admitted as a substituted Limited Partner, the
transferor shall have no further voting or inspection rights under this Agreement.
9.5 Expenses of Transfer. Any costs or expenses (including but not limited to
reasonable attorneys fees) incurred by the Partnership in connection with the transfer of a
Partnership interest hereunder (including any costs associated with any opinion rendered pursuant to

Section 9.3 above) shall be borne by the transferring Partner.
ARTICLE X
DISSOLUTION AND LIQUIDATION OF THE PARTNERSHIP
10.1 Dissolution. The Partnership will be dissolved and its affairs will be wound up
upon the earlier to occur of the following times or events:

(a) Upon expiration of the Harvesting Period as provided in Section 4.1(d);
(b) The election of the General Partner to dissolve the Partnership;

(c) The cessation of the sole remaining General Partner's status as General
Partner; or
(d) Any other event that applicable law specifies must operate as an event
causing the dissolution of a limited partnership notwithstanding any provision to the contrary in the
limited partnership's agreement of limited partnership.
10.2 Winding Up Procedures. Upon dissolution pursuant to Section 10.1, the
Partnership shall be wound up and liquidated in an orderly manner. The General Partner or, if there
is no general partner, a liquidator appointed by a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners (the
General Partner, in such role, or such liquidator, the "Liquidator"), shall proceed with the Dissolution
Sale and the final distribution. In the Dissolution Sale, the Liquidator shall use its reasonable efforts
to reduce to cash and cash equivalent items such assets of the Partnership as the Liquidator shall
deem it advisable to sell, subject to obtaining fair value for such assets and any tax or other legal
considerations (including legal restrictions on the ability of a Limited Partner to hold any assets to be
distributed in kind). The Liquidator, in its discretion, may distribute assets in kind to the Partners,
either directly, through a liquidating trust (pursuant to Section 10.4), or other vehicle.
CR 177i) CU RAHNCY PARTNIAT 11, LP
limited PatmershO Agmment—Page 17
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
10.3 Final Distribution. After the Dissolution Sale, the proceeds thereof and the other
assets of the Partnership including any remaining Portfolio Investments, shall be distributed in one
or more installments in the following order of priority:

(a) To satisfy all creditors of the Partnership (including the payment of
expenses of the winding -up, liquidation and dissolution of the Partnership), including Partners who
are creditors of the Partnership, to the extent otherwise permitted by law, either by the payment
thereof or the making of reasonable provision therefor (including the establishment of reserves, in
amounts established by the Liquidator); and
(b) The remaining proceeds, if any, plus any remaining assets of the
Partnership, shall be applied and distributed to the Partners as soon as practicable, in the same
manner as distributions under Section 7.5. Such distribution shall be made after giving effect, to the
Partners' Capital Accounts, all contributions, distributions and allocations for all periods, including
the period during which such distribution occurs). It is the intention of the Partners that the positive
Capital Account balance of each Partner immediately prior to the receipt of any liquidating
distributions by such Partner will be equal to the amount distributable to such Partner pursuant to

Section 7.5, and in the event that a Partner's Capital Account is not equal to such amount, the
General Partner shall cause the allocations of Profits and Loss, or items thereof (including items of
gross income and deductions), to the extent of such Profits, Losses, or items, for the tax year of the
Partnership ending with the liquidation (and, to the extent necessary, for the prior tax year if the tax
return for such prior tax year has not been tiled) to be allocated in such a way so as to cause each
Partner's Capital Account balance immediately prior to the receipt of any liquidating distributions to
equal to the extent possible the amount that such Partner is entitled to receive pursuant to Section
7.5.
10.4 Liquidating Trust. At the election of the Liquidator, Portfolio Investments held
by the Partnership at the time of its dissolution or at any time during the process of its winding -up
and liquidation may be placed in a "Liquidating Trust" for the benefit of the Partners. The Liquidator
or its designee shall be the trustee of the Liquidating Trust. The trustee shall use its reasonable best
efforts to manage the Liquidating Trust such that the Liquidating Trust qualifies as a "liquidating
trust" within the meaning of Treasury Regulations Section 301.7701-4(d) and shall use its reasonable
efforts to sell or distribute the assets of the Liquidating Trust as promptly as is consistent with
applicable legal or contractual obligations and with maximizing the value of the Liquidating Trust
assets for the benefit of the beneficiaries (as determined by the trustee in its reasonable discretion).
The trustee shall not be required to take any steps constituting active management of the Liquidating
Trust assets and, without limitation on the preceding clause, shall not be required to seek purchasers
for Portfolio Investments. Each Partner's interest in the assets of the Liquidating Trust shall be the
same as if such assets had, at the time such assets were placed in the Liquidating Trust, been
distributed to the Partners by the Partnership in accordance with Section 10.3(b) and then
contributed by the Partners to the Liquidating Trust in exchange for trust interests proportionate to
their respective contributions.
ARTICLE XI
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING, REPORTS, VOTING AND CONFIDENTIALITY
11.1 Financial Accounting; Fiscal Year. The books and records of the Partnership
shall be kept in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement and otherwise in accordance with
generally accepted accounting principles consistently applied and shall be audited at the end of each
fiscal year (beginning with the first full calendar year of the Partnership) by an independent public
accounting firm selected by the General Partner. The Partnership's fiscal year shall be the calendar
year.
CRYPIT) CURRENCY PAW:WERT II, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Astrnment—Pagt IR
ACTIVE 20351111SSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
11.2 Supervision; Inspection Of Books. Proper and complete books of account of the
business of the Partnership, copies of the Partnership's federal, state and local tax returns for each
fiscal year, a current Schedule of Partners set forth in the books and records of the Partnership, this
Agreement and the Partnership's Certificate of Limited Partnership shall be kept under the
supervision of the General Partner at the principal office of the Partnership. Each Limited Partner
has the right, on reasonable request and subject to whatever reasonable standards as the General
Partner may from time to time establish (including standards for determining whether the purpose
for the request is reasonably related to the limited Partner's Interest as a Limited Partner), to obtain
from the General Partner for purposes reasonably related to the Limited Partner's Interest as a
Limited Partner the information set forth above in this Section 11.2 as well as information regarding
the status of the business and financial condition of the Partnership (generally consisting of the
Partnership's financial statements) and whatever other information regarding the affairs of the
Partnership as is just and reasonable in light of the purpose related to the Limited Partner's Interest
as a Limited Partner for which the information is sought. The General Partner may, however, keep
confidential from any Limited Partner any information the disclosure of which the General Partner
in good faith believes could be harmful to the business of the Partnership or is otherwise not in the
best interests of the Partnership, or that the Partnership is required by law or agreement with a third
party to keep confidential.
11.3 _Quarterly Reports. Commencing with the first full calendar quarter of Partnership
operations after the Partnership has received Capital Commitments totaling at least $5 million, the
General Partner shall transmit to the Limited Partners within 45 days after the dose of each of the
first three calendar quarters of each year (or as soon thereafter as reasonably practicable), unaudited
financial statements and a progress report on each of the Partnership's Portfolio Investments.
11.4 Annual Report; Financial Statements of the Partnership. Commencing with the
first full calendar year of the Partnership's operations after the Partnership has received Capital
Commitments totaling at least $20 million, the General Partner shall transmit to the Limited Partners
within 120 days after the dose of the Partnership's fiscal year (or as soon thereafter as reasonably
practicable), audited financial statements of the Partnership prepared in accordance with U.S.
generally accepted accounting principles, including an income statement for the year then ended and
a balance sheet as of the end of such year, a statement of changes in the Partners' Capital Accounts
and a year-end balance of each Partner's Capital Accounts (each as adjusted for unrealized gains and
losses), and a list of investments then held. The financial statements shall be accompanied by a
report from the General Partner to the Limited Partners, which shall include a status report on each
of the Partnership's Portfolio investments.
11.5 Tax Returns and Information. The General Partner shall cause the Partnership's
tax return and IRS Form 1065, Schedule K-1, to be prepared and filed on a timely basis and shall
prepare and mail to each Partner such Partner's Schedule K-1 as promptly as practicable after the
close of the Partnership's fiscal year (or as soon thereafter as reasonably practicable). The
Partnership shall upon the request of any Limited Partner promptly furnish to such Limited Partner
any information reasonably available to the Partnership that such Limited Partner may require or
reasonably request in order to withhold tax or to file tax returns and reports or to furnish tax
information to any of its partners; provided, however, that such Limited Partner agrees to pay any
additional expenses incurred by the Partnership or the General Partner to provide such additional
information.
11.6 Tax Matters Partner.
(a) The General Partner shall be the Partnership's tax matters partner under
the Code and under any comparable provision of state law. The tax matters partner shall employ
CR 177I7 CURRIiNCY PAM' 'HU ii, LP
Limited PatmershO Agmment—Page 19
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
experienced tax counsel to represent the Partnership in connection with any audit or investigation of
the Partnership by the Internal Revenue Service and in connection with all subsequent administrative
and judicial proceedings arising out of such audit. If the tax matters partner is required by law or
regulation to incur fees and expenses in connection with tax matters not affecting all the Partners,
then the tax matters partner may, in its sole discretion, seek reimbursement from those Partners on
whose behalf such fees and expenses were incurred. The tax matters partner shall keep the Partners
informed of all administrative and judicial proceedings, as required by Section 6223® of the Code,
and shall furnish to each Partner, if such Partner so requests in writing, a copy of each notice or
other communication received by the tax matters partner from the Internal Revenue Service, except
such notices or communications as are sent directly to such requesting Partner by the Internal
Revenue Service. To the fullest extent permitted by law, the Partnership agrees to indemnify the tax
matters partner and its agents and save and hold them harmless, from and in respect to (a) all fees,
costs and reasonable expenses in connection with or resulting from any claim, action, or demand
against the tax matters partner, the General Partner or the Partnership that arise out of or in any way
relate to the tax matters partner's status as tax matters partner for the Partnership and (b) all such
claims, actions, and demands and any losses or damages therefrom, including amounts paid in
settlement or compromise or any such claim, action, or demand.

(b) In no case may the General Partner cause the Partnership to elect to be
excluded from Subchapter K of the Code or to be classified as any entity other than a partnership for
United States federal or state income tax purposes.
11.7 Voting. Except as expressly set forth in this Agreement, the Limited Partners shall
have no right to vote on any matter relative to the Partnership and its affairs.
11.8 Confidential Information.

(a) Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement but subject to the
discretion of the General Partner, it is agreed that, with respect to any Limited Partner, the books
and records of the Partnership relating to the economic participation of any other Limited Partner in
the Partnership are confidential and shall not be disclosed to such Limited Partner. It is also agreed
that, subject to the discretion of the General Partner, each Limited Partner shall have no right to
receive any information with respect to the economic participation of any other Limited Partner in
the Partnership and that the Partnership may withhold any and all such information from the books
and records of the Partnership in the event that such books and records must be opened for
inspection by one or more Limited Partners.
(b) This Agreement and all financial statements, tax reports, portfolio
valuations, reviews or analyses of potential or actual investments, reports or other materials and all
other documents and information concerning the affairs of the Partnership and its investments,
including information about the entities in which the Partnership has invested or the persons
investing in the Partnership (collectively, the "Confidential Information that any Partner may receive
pursuant to or in accordance with this Agreement, or otherwise as a result of its ownership of an
Interest, constitute proprietary and confidential information about the Partnership, the General
Partner, their Affiliates and their respective portfolio companies (the "Affected Patties"). The Partners
acknowledge that the Affected Parties derive independent economic value from the Confidential
Information not being generally known and that the Confidential Information is the subject of
reasonable efforts to maintain its secrecy. The Partners further acknowledge that the Confidential
Information is a trade secret, the disclosure of which is likely to cause substantial and irreparable
competitive harm to the Affected Parties or their respective businesses. No Limited Partner shall
reproduce any of the Confidential Information or portion thereof or make the contents thereof
available to any third party other than to such Limited Partner's: (i) directors, officers, and Affiliates;
CRYPIT)CuRRavcr PARMIRT LL, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Agrerment—Pagr 20
ACTIVE 20351ISSSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
and (ii) legal, accounting or investment advisers, auditors and representatives (collectively, "Advisers')
(provided, however that such Advisers are subject to ethical or professional obligations to keep the
Confidential Information confidential or confidentiality obligations similar to the obligations set
forth in this Section 11.8(b)) without the prior written consent of the General Partner (which
consent shall include the form and content of such disclosure), except to the extent compelled to do
so in accordance with applicable law (in which case the Limited Partner shall promptly notify the
General Partner of its obligation to disclose any Confidential Information, other than for disclosures
to governmental regulatory authorities, including information regarding the requestor of and request
for such disclosure) or with respect to Confidential Information that otherwise becomes publicly
available other than through breach of this provision by a Limited Partner. Notwithstanding any
provision of this Agreement to the contrary, the General Partner may withhold disclosure of any
Confidential Information (other than this Agreement or tax reports) to any particular Limited Partner
if the General Partner reasonably determines that the disclosure of such Confidential Information to
such Limited Partner may result in the general public gaining access to such Confidential
Information.

(c) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, each Partner
(and each employee, representative or other agent of such Partner) may disclose to any and all
persons, without limitation of any kind, the U.S. federal and state tax treatment and U.S. federal and
state tax structure of the Partnership and all materials of any kind that are provided to the Partner
relating to such tax treatment and tax structure. This authorization of tax disclosure is retroactively
effective to the commencement of discussions between the Partnership or its representatives and
such Partner regarding the transactions contemplated herein.
ARTICLE XII
VALUATION; ADVISORY COMMITTEE
12.1 Valuation. For purposes of this Agreement (but except as otherwise expressly
provided for hereunder, including under Section 4.2), in the event that a determination of the fair
market value of any Portfolio Investment, Interest or any other asset (including any Capital
Contribution made in any Crypto Currency permitted by the General Partner) is required to be made,
such determination shall be made by the General Partner in good faith as of the relevant time, such
determinations to be made based on an analysis by the General Partner of all facts and circumstances
determined to be relevant in connection therewith, including the types of assets being evaluated, any
applicable restrictions on disposition thereof, the pricing of same or similar assets in similar
transactions occurring between arm's length parties, operating results and other similar factors. Any
such determination by the General Partner shall be conclusive and binding on all of the Partners for
all purposes. Any amounts so determined pursuant to this Section12.1 shall be referred to for
purposes of this Agreement as the "Fair Market Value" of the relevant asset (as applicable).
12.2 Advisory Committee.

(a) The General Partner will constitute an Advisory Committee comprised of
at least three members, each of whom shall be a representative of one or more limited Partners
chosen by the General Partner; provided, however that none of those Limited Partners shall be an
Affiliate of the General Partner (together, the "Advisog Committee). The Advisory Committee shall
meet from time to time upon request of the General Partner to consult with the General Partner on
matters it presents to the Advisory Committee, including (i) investment and financing strategies;

(ii) status of outstanding Portfolio Investments; (iii) transactions involving the General Partner or its
Affiliates or other conflict situations; (iv) asset valuations and valuation methodologies; and

(v) financial statements and reporting format. Except as otherwise expressly provided herein, any
actions taken by the Advisory Committee shall be advisory only and the General Partner shall not be
CRIPM CU RAI:NCT PARTN LP
Limited Patinersh# Agnyment—Page 2$
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
required or otherwise bound to act in accordance with any comments made by the Advisory
Committee or any of its members. The Advisory Committee shall, however, represent the Limited
Partners as a group, and any action or transaction affirmatively approved by the Advisory Committee
shall therefore constitute an approval by the Limited Partners. The Advisory Committee shall act by
majority vote of its members. Each member of the Advisory Committee shall be entitled to one
vote.

(b) The reasonable out-of-pocket expenses incurred by the Advisory
Committee and its members shall be an expense borne by the Partnership.

(c) The Advisory Committee shall take no part in the control or management
of the affairs of the Partnership, nor shall the Advisory Committee have any power or authority to
act for or on behalf of the Partnership. Members of the Advisory Committee shall be entitled to the
benefits of the exculpation and indemnification provisions of Sections 13.5 and 13.6 as provided
therein.
ARTICLE XIII
OTHER PROVISIONS
13.1 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed under the
laws of the State of Delaware as applied to agreements among the residents of such state made and
to be performed entirely within such state.
13.2 Limitation of Liability of the Limited Partners. Except as required by law or
the terms of this Agreement, no limited Partner shall be bound by, nor be personally liable for, the
expenses, liabilities, or obligations of the Partnership in excess of its Capital Commitment to the
Partnership.
13.3 BRISA Partners. Each ERISA Partner, and its responsible fiduciaries, hereby

(i) acknowledge that, for so long as the equity participation by "benefit plan investors," within the
meaning of the Plan Assets Regulation, in the Partnership is not "significant," within the meaning of
the Plan Assets Regulation, neither the Partnership, the General Partner, nor any of the Affiliates of
the General Partner, is a "fiduciary," within the meaning of ERISA, of such ERISA Partner by
reason of the ERISA Partner investing its assets in, and being a ERISA Partner of the Partnership;

(ii) acknowledge that they have been informed of and understand the investment objectives and
policies of and the investment strategies that may be pursued by, the Partnership; (ib) acknowledge
that they are aware of the provisions of Section 404 of ERISA, specifically including the "prudent
person" standard of Section 404(a)(1)(B) of ERISA and the diversification standards of

Section 404(a)(1)(C) of ERISA, and the prohibited transaction provisions of Section 406 of ERISA;

(iv) represent that they have given appropriate consideration to the facts and circumstances relevant
to the investment by that ERISA Partner's plan in the Partnership and have determined that such
investment is reasonably designed, as part of such portfolio, to further the purposes of and is an
appropriate part of the plan's investment program, (v) represent that, taking into account the other
investments made with the assets of such plan, and the diversification thereof, such plan's investment
in the Partnership is consistent with the requirements of Section 404 and other provisions of ERISA;

(v) acknowledge that they understand that current income will not be a primary objective of the
Partnership; and (vi) represent that, taking into account the other investments made with the assets
of such plan, the investment of assets of such plan in the Partnership is consistent with the cash flow
requirements and funding objectives of such plan.
13.4 Private Foundation Partners. Notwithstanding any provision of the Agreement to
the contrary, any Private Foundation Partner may elect to withdraw in whole or in part from the
CRYPIDCURRENCX PARMIRT ii, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Aga...tent—Pat 22
ACTIVE 20358111180v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
Partnership if the Private Foundation Partner shall obtain an opinion of counsel (which counsel shall
be reasonably acceptable to both the Private Foundation Partner and the General Partner) to the
effect that such withdrawal is necessary in order for the Private Foundation Partner to avoid

(a) excise taxes imposed by Subchapter A of Chapter 42 of the Code (other than Sections 4940 and
4942 thereof), or (b) a material breach of the fiduciary duties of its trustees under any federal or state
law applicable to private foundations or any rule or regulation adopted thereunder by any agency,
commission, or authority having jurisdiction; provided, however, that in the case of the imposition of
excise taxes with respect to a particular investment, the Private Foundation Partner may elect to
continue as a Partner. In the event of the issuance of the opinion of counsel referred to in the
preceding sentence, the withdrawal of and disposition of the Private Foundation Partner's Interest
shall be govemed by Sections 7.9(c) and 7.9(d) of the Agreement.
13.5 Exculpation.

(a) Neither the General Partner nor its members, employees, officers, agents,
representatives or Affiliates nor the tax matters partner nor any member of the Advisory Committee
shall be liable to any Limited Partner or the Partnership for any act or omission based upon errors of
judgment or other fault in connection with the business or affairs of the Partnership, or for losses
due to mistakes, action, or inaction, or to the negligence, dishonesty, or bad faith of any employee,
broker, consultant, or other agent of the Parmership;providk however that such employee, broker, or
other agents shall have been selected with reasonable care. The General Partner may consult with
counsel and accountants in respect of Partnership affairs and be fully protected and justified in any
action or inaction that is taken in accordance with the advice or opinion of such counsel or
accountants, provided, however that they shall have been selected with reasonable care.
Notwithstanding any of the foregoing to the contrary, (a) except with respect to members of the
Advisory Committee, the provisions of this Section and the immediately following Section shall not
be construed so as to relieve (or attempt to relieve) any person of any liability by reason of fraud,
willful violation of law that was related to the Partnership or gross negligence; and (b) members of
the Advisory Committee shall only be liable (and shall not be indemnified) for actions not taken in
good faith. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary, except in the case of actual fraud, an
individual's liability under this Section 13.5 is limited to his or her Interest.

(b) To the extent that, at law or in equity, the General Partner has duties
(including fiduciary duties) and liabilities relating thereto to the Partnership or to another Partner, the
General Partner acting under this Agreement shall not be liable to the Partnership or to any such
other Partner for its good faith reliance on the provisions of this Agreement. The provisions of this
Agreement, to the extent that they expand or restrict the duties and liabilities of the General Partner
otherwise existing at law or in equity, are agreed by the Partners to modify to that extent such other
duties and liabilities of the General Partner.
13.6 Indemnification.
(a) The Partnership agrees to indemnify, out of the assets of the Partnership
only, the General Partner, its members, employees, Affiliates, representatives and other agents, the
tax matters partner and each member of the Advisory Committee (collectively, the "Indemnified
Partial to the fullest extent permitted by law and to save and hold them harmless from and in
respect of all (i) reasonable fees, costs, and expenses paid in connection with or resulting from any
claim, action, or demand against an Indemnified Party that arise out of or in any way relate to the
Partnership, its properties, business, or affairs and (ii) such claims, actions, and demands and any
losses or damages resulting from such claims, actions, and demands, including amounts paid in
settlement or compromise (if recommended by attorneys for the Partnership) of any such claim,
action or demand; provided, however, that (i) except with respect to members of the Advisory
CRYP7I7 CURAhNCY PARTNI9RS H, LP
Limitd Patiners$ Agmment—Page
ACTIVE 2035181030v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
Committee, this indemnity shall not extend to conduct that is fraudulent, constitutes a willful
violation of law that was related to the Partnership or grossly negligent•, and (ii) with respect to
members of the Advisory Committee, this indemnity shall not apply to actions not taken in good
faith. Expenses incurred by any Indemnified Party in defending a claim or proceeding covered by
this Section shall be paid by the Partnership in advance of the final disposition of such claim or
proceeding provided the Indemnified Party undertakes to repay such amount if it is ultimately
determined that such Indemnified Party was not entitled to be indemnified. The provisions of this
Section shall remain in effect as to each Indemnified Party whether or not such Indemnified Party
continues to serve in the capacity that entitled such person to be indemnified.
(b) If the assets of the Partnership (including any Unfunded Capital
Commitments) are insufficient to satisfy any indemnification obligation pursuant to Section 13.6(a),
the Partners shall be required to return distributions to the Partnership in cash as necessary to satisfy
such obligation, to the extent of distributions received.
13.7 Execution. This Agreement may be executed in two or more counterparts, each of
which shall be deemed an original but all of which together shall constitute one and the same
instrument.
13.8 Other Instruments and Acts. The Partners agree to execute any other instruments
or perform any other acts that are or may be necessary to effectuate and carry on the partnership
created by this Agreement.
13.9 Binding Agreement. This Agreement shall be binding upon the transferees,
successors, assigns, and legal representatives of the Partners.
13.10 Notices. Any notice or other communication that one Partner desires to give to
another Partner shall be in writing, and shall be deemed effectively given upon personal delivery or
three days after deposit in any United States mail box, by registered or certified mail, postage prepaid,
upon confirmed transmission by facsimile, upon confirmed delivery by overnight commercial courier
service, addressed to the other Partner at the address shown in the books and records of the
Partnership or at such other address as a Partner may designate by 15 days' advance written notice to
the other Partners or upon electronic mail on the date sent provided confirmation of receipt of e-
mail is received.
13.11 Power of Attorney. By signing this Agreement, each Limited Partner designates
and appoints the General Partner its true and lawful attorney, in its name, place, and stead to make,
execute, sign, and file the Certificate of Limited Partnership and any amendment thereto and such
other instruments, documents, or certificates that may from time to time be required of the
Partnership by the laws of the United States of America, the laws of the state of the Partnership's
formation, or any other state or jurisdiction in which the Partnership shall do business in order to
qualify or otherwise enable the Partnership to do business in such states or jurisdictions. Such
attorney is not hereby granted any authority on behalf of the Limited Partners to amend this
Agreement except that, provided, however that any approvals required by this Agreement or applicable
law are first obtained, as attorney for each of the Limited Partners, the General Partner shall have the
authority to amend this Agreement and the Certificate of Limited Partnership (and to execute any
amendment to the Agreement or the Certificate of Limited Partnership on behalf of itself and as
attorney-in-fact for each of the Limited Partners) as may be required to effect:

(a) Admission of additional Partners pursuant to Article III, Article IV or
Article IX;
CRYPIDCURREAVX PA WITYHRT 11, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Agrerment—Page 24
ACTIVE 2035111SSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
Transfers of Interests pursuant to Article IX;
Additional Capital Contributions pursuant to Article IV;
Extensions of the Harvesting Period pursuant to Section 4.1(c);
Withdrawal of Partners pursuant to Article VII; or
(0 make, execute, sign, acknowledge and file all agreements, certificates and
other instruments that the General Partner deems appropriate or necessary to establish any
liquidating trust contemplated by Section 10.4.
The foregoing power of attorney is a special power of attorney coupled with an interest, is
irrevocable and shall not be affected by subsequent disability or incapacity of a Limited Partner but
shall expire as to a Limited Partner immediately after the complete withdrawal of such Limited
Partner as a Partner of the Partnership.
13.12 Amendment; Waiver.

(a) Except as otherwise specifically provided for in this Agreement, this
Agreement may be amended only with the written consent of the General Partner and a Majority in
Interest of the Limited Partners.

(b) The General Partner may amend this Agreement from time to time,
without the consent of any of the Limited Partners, to cure any ambiguity in this Agreement, to
correct or supplement any provision in this Agreement that may be inconsistent with any other
provision in this Agreement, to properly reflect the economic arrangement of the parties as
determined in good faith by the General Partner, or to make any other provision as to matters or
questions arising under this Agreement that will not be materially inconsistent with the provisions of
this Agreement.

(c) Notwithstanding the above:
No amendment of this Agreement may materially and adversely
affect one limited Partner in a manner not affecting the Limited Partners as a class unless each
Limited Partner adversely affected thereby has expressly consented in writing to such amendment;
No amendment of this Agreement may increase the Capital
Commitment of a Limited Partner or adversely affect the limited liability of a Limited Partner
without such Limited Partner's consent.
(a) Notwithstanding the above, the Partnership's or General Partner's (or its
members' or employees') noncompliance with any provision hereof in any single transaction or event
may be waived in writing by a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners. No waiver shall be
deemed a waiver of any subsequent event of noncompliance.
13.13 Entire Agreement. This Agreement and each subscription agreement executed by
the Limited Partners in connection with an investment in the Partnership (each a "Substription
Agreement) constitute the fa, complete, and final agreement of the Partners and supersede all prior
agreements between the Partners with respect to the Partnership. Notwithstanding the provisions of
this Agreement or any Subscription Agreement, it is hereby acknowledged and agreed that the
Partnership and the General Partner, on its own behalf or on behalf of the Partnership, without the
CR MD CURAhNCT PA RritiRS ii, LP
Limited Patinersh# Agmment—Page 25
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
approval of any Limited Partner, may enter into a separate side agreement with any Limited Partner,
executed contemporaneously with the admission of such Limited Partner to the Partnership, which
has the effect of establishing rights under, or altering or supplementing the terms hereof or any
Subscription Agreement in order to meet certain requirements of such Limited Partner.
13.14 Titles; Subtitles. The titles and subtitles used in this Agreement are used for
convenience only and shall not be considered in the interpretation of this Agreement.
13.15 Partnersbip Name. The Partnership shall have the exclusive right to use the name
"Crypto Currency Partners" as long as the Partnership continues, despite the withdrawal of any
Partner. No value shall be placed upon the name or the goodwill attached thereto for the purpose of
determining the value of any Partner's Capital Account or Interest. Notwithstanding the foregoing,
the Partners recognize and agree that the General Partner retains all rights to use the name "Crypto
Currency Partners" or deviations thereof except as specifically contemplated by this Agreement, and
neither the Partnership nor any Partner shall form any other entity using the words "Crypto Currency
Partners" or deviations thereof and neither the Partnership nor any Partner has or will claim to have
any right to use the words "Crypto Currency Partners" or deviations thereof in connection with any
other business activities except as contemplated by this Agreement or with the approval of the
General Partner.
13.16 Legal Counsel. Each Partner hereby agrees and acknowledges that Sidley Austin
LLP ("Sid/y"), has acted as counsel for the General Partner in connection with among other things,
the preparation of this Agreement and the Subscription Agreements for the Partnership (the "Fund
Documents"). Each Partner understands and acknowledges that Sidley has not represented or been
engaged to provide services to Limited Partners or the Partnership in connection with the
preparation of the Fund Documents or any terms of a Limited Partner's investment in the
Partnership. Each Partner acknowledges and agrees as follows: (i) Sidley is not representing the
interests of such Partner, and such Partner is not relying on Sidley in determining whether to enter
into any of the Fund Documents; (ii) such Partner has been advised to seek independent counsel, to
the extent he or it deems it appropriate, to protect his or its interests in connection with any of the
Fund Documents, including without limitation advice as to the tax consequences of entering into the
Fund Documents; and (iii) such Limited Partner will look solely to, and rely upon, his or its own
advisers with respect to the legal, financial and tax consequences of this investment. If and to the
extent a Limited Partner has or in the future develops any relationship with Sidley, such Limited
Partner hereby (i) consents to Sidley's representation of the General Partner (and/or one or more
principals and/or affiliates of the General Partner) in connection with the Fund Documents and the
General Partner's (or such affiliates' or principals) relationship with the Partnership and such
Limited Partner; (i) acknowledges that Sidley will not represent such Limited Partner in connection
with any dispute between the Partnership and/or the General Partner or any of the General Partner's
principals or affiliates; and (iii) agrees that Sidley may represent the General Partner and/or one or
more owners, employees, principals or affiliates of the General Partner in matters (including any such
dispute) in which the interests of the General Partner and/or its owners, employees, principals or
affiliates, are adverse to the Limited Partner's. Each Limited Partner agrees that Sidley may rely on
this section and may enforce it against such Limited Partner. Nothing in this paragraph will preclude
the General Partner from selecting different legal counsel at any time and, except as specifically
provided in this section, no Limited Partner will be deemed by virtue of this section to have waived
its right to object to any conflict of interest relating to matters other than such Limited Partner's
investment in the Partnership.
13.17 Arbitration; Jurisdiction. Any dispute, claim or controversy between or among
any of the Partners or between any Partner and the Partnership arising out of or relating to this
Agreement or any subscription by any Partner for interests in the Partnership, or any alleged breach,
CRYPIT) CURRENCY PARIAiliRS II, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Astrrment—Pagt 26
ACTIVE 20358ASSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
termination, enforcement, interpretation or validity of any of those agreements (including the
determination of the scope or applicability of this agreement to arbitrate), or otherwise involving the
Partnership, will be determined, upon the request of any party to any controversy, by binding
arbitration in New York City before a sole arbitrator, in accordance with the laws of the State of
Delaware for agreements made in and to be performed in the State of Delaware. Such arbitration
will be administered by the Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Services ("JAMS') pursuant to its
Comprehensive Arbitration Rules and Procedures, and no party to any such controversy will be
entitled to any punitive damages. Notwithstanding those rules, no arbitration proceeding brought
against the Partnership or the General Partner will be consolidated with any other arbitration
proceeding brought against the Partnership or the General Partner without the Partnership's and the
General Partner's consent. Judgment may be entered upon any award granted in any such arbitration
in any court of competent jurisdiction. The arbitrator shall, in the Award, allocate all of the costs of
the arbitration, including the fees of the arbitrator and the reasonable attorneys' fees of the prevailing
party, against the party who did not prevail.
NOTICE: By becoming a party to this Agreement, each Partner is agreeing to have all
disputes, claims or controversies arising out of or relating to this Agreement decided by
neutral binding arbitration, and is giving up any rights he or she or it might possess to have
those matters litigated in a court or jury trial. By becoming a party to this Agreement, each
Partner is giving up his or her or its judicial rights to discovery and appeal except to the
extent that they are specifically provided for under this Agreement. If any Partner refuses to
submit to arbitration after agreeing to this provision, he or she or it may be compelled to
arbitrate under federal or state law. By becoming a party to this Agreement, each Partner
confirms that his or her or its agreement to this arbitration provision is voluntary.
13.18 Severabilio. Each provision of this Agreement shall be considered severable and if
for any reason any provision that is not essential to the effectuation of the basic purposes of this
Agreement is determined by a court of competent jurisdiction to be invalid or unenforceable and
contrary to the Act or existing or future applicable law, such invalidity shall not impair the operation
of or affect those provisions of this Agreement which are valid. In that case, this Agreement shall be
construed so as to limit any term or provision so as to make it enforceable or valid within the
requirements of any applicable law, and in the event such term or provision cannot be so limited, this
Agreement shall be construed to omit such invalid or unenforceable provisions.
13.19 Interpretation. Wherever from the context it appears appropriate, each term stated
in either the singular or the plural shall include the singular and the plural, and pronouns stated in
either the masculine or the neuter gender shall include the masculine, the feminine and the neuter.

(a) Unless the context requires otherwise, the words "include," "includes" and
"including" shall be deemed to be followed by the phrase "without limitation."
(b) Whenever in this Agreement a Person is authorized or permitted or
required to make a decision or take an action, except where the authorizing, permitting or requiring
provision specifically restricts or limits that Person's discretion, the decision or action is to be taken
in that Person's sole and absolute discretion. In exercising that discretion, the Person may consider
any interests and factors he or she or it desires, including his or her or its own interests, will not be
required to consider any particular interest of or factor affecting the Partnership or any other Person
and, to the fullest extent permitted by applicable law, the Person will be relieved of any requirement
to adhere to any other or different standards under this Agreement, any other agreement or law or
equity. Whenever in this Agreement a Person is authorized or permitted but not required to make a
decision or take an action (e.g., when a provision specifies that a Person "may" make take an action),
the Person may make that decision or take that action or may decline to make that decision or take
CRYPMCURAI:NCY PARTN H, LP
Limited Palmer* Agnyment—Page 27
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
that action, in that Person's sole and absolute discretion. Whenever in this Agreement the
Partnership may make a decision or take an action, that decision or action will be in the General
Partner's sole and absolute discretion. The express statement in any provision of this Agreement to
the effect that a decision or action may be made or taken in a Person's discretion or in a Person's sole
and absolute discretion will not in any way limit the generality of the preceding provisions of this
Section. Whenever in this Agreement a Person is required to act in "good faith" or under another
express standard, the Person will be required to act under that express standard and, to the extent
permitted by applicable law, will not be subject to any other or different standards imposed by this
Agreement or any other agreement or law or equity.
ARTICLE XIV
CERTAIN DEFINITIONS
The following terms used in this Agreement will have the meanings set forth below, unless the
context otherwise requires:
"Ad' The Delaware Revised Uniform Limited Partnership Act, as
amended.
"Adjusted Asset Value"
CRI-P7D aRRENCY PA RTNHILf II, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Agarment—Pagt 28
The Adjusted Asset Value with respect to any asset shall be the
asset's adjusted basis for United States federal income tax
purposes, except as follows:

(a) In the discretion of the General Partner, the
Adjusted Asset Values of all Partnership assets may be adjusted to
equal their respective Fair Market Values, as determined by the
General Partner in accordance with Section 12.1, and the
resulting unrecognized Profit or Loss (or items thereof) allocated
to the Capital Accounts of the Partners pursuant to Article V, as
of the following times: (i) the acquisition of an additional Interest
by any new or existing Partner in exchange for more than a
minimis Capital Contribution; (ii) the distribution by the
Partnership to a Partner of more than a deruininnis amount of
Partnership assets; and (iii) any other event referred to in Treasury
Regulation Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(f).

(b) The Adjusted Asset Values of all Partnership
assets shall be adjusted to equal their respective gross Fair Market
Values, as determined by the General Partner in accordance with

Section 12.1, and the resulting unrecognized Profit or Loss (or
items thereof) allocated to the Capital Accounts of the Partners
pursuant to Article V, as of the termination of the Partnership.
(c) In the case of any Partnership asset that has an
Adjusted Asset Value that differs from its adjusted tax basis, the
Adjusted Asset Value shall be adjusted by the amount of
depreciation, depletion and amortization calculated for purposes
of the definitions of "Profit and Loss" rather than the amount of
depreciation depletion and amortization determined for
U.S. federal income tax purposes.
ACTIVE 20351ISSSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
"Advisers"
"Advirog Committee"
"Affected Parties"
"Affiliate"
"Agreement"
"Business Dag'
"Call Date"
"Capital Ammnt"
"Capital Cat
"Capital Commitment; Committed
Capital'
"Capital Contribution"
"Carried Interest
As defined in Section 11.8(b).
As defined in Section 12.2(a).
As defined in Section 11.8(b).
As to a specified person, (a) any person who directly or indirectly
owns, controls or holds with power to vote, 10% or more of any
class of equity securities of that specified person; (b) any person
10% or more of whose outstanding voting securities are directly
or indirectly owned, controlled or held with power to vote, by that
specified person; (c) any person who, directly or indirectly,
controls, is controlled by or is under common control with that
specified person; or (d) any officer, director or general partner of,
or any person who serves in a similar capacity as to, that specified
person, or of which that specified person is an executive officer,
director or general partner, or as to which that specified person
serves in a similar capacity.
As defined in the opening paragraph.
Business Day means any day except a Saturday, Sunday or other
day that commercial banks in New York, New York are
authorized by law to dose.
As defined in Section 4.1(a).
As defined in Section 5.1(a).
As defined in Section 4.1(a).
A Partner's Capital Commitment shall mean the aggregate amount
of capital that such Partner has agreed to contribute to the
Partnership. The Committed Capital of the Partnership shall
mean the sum of the Capital Commitments of all Partners.
As to any Partner at any time, the aggregate amount of capital
actually contributed to the Partnership by such Partner pursuant
to Section 4.1.
As defined in Section 7.5.
"Code" The Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (or
corresponding provisions of succeeding law).
"Confidential Infermation"
"Copto Caffeng"
"Current Piroreeds"
As defined in Section 11.8(b).
any
Means a digital form of currency that incorporates cryptographic
elements, such as bitcoin, Mastercoin, litecoin and dogecoin.
Cash proceeds from a Portfolio Investment other than
Disposition Proceeds, net of Organizational Expenses,
CR YAW CURRENCY PARTNili RS II LP
Limited Potion* Asmotent—Page 29
ACTIVE 2035&81030v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
Partnership Expenses, Management Fees and reserves therefor
allocated to such proceeds by the General Partner.
"Default Amount'
"DOEPing Limited Panne?'
"Disposition Pniceedt
"Dinobairn Salt
"ERISA"
"ERISA Panne?'
"Event of Djault"
"Fair Market Value"
"Fiscal Period'
"Full Investment Date"
"General Partne?'
"1-lenvesting Period"
CRYPII) CURRENCY PART-AV/Mfg!"
Limited Parma* Agrerment—Page 30
As defined in Section 4.3(a).
As defined in Section 4.3(b).
All amounts received by the Partnership from Realized Portfolio
Investments, net of Organizational Expenses, Partnership
Expenses, Management Fees and reserves therefor allocable
thereto by the General Partner, any liability or obligation required
to be paid by the Partnership upon that disposition and any
reserves for indemnification obligations, post -closing adjustments,
any required tax withholdings and similar obligations which the
General Partner reasonably believes are necessary.
All sales and liquidation in connection with or in contemplation of
the winding -up of the Partnership.
Means the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as
amended.
Means any Limited Partner that is an "employee benefit plan" or
is an entity that is deemed to hold "plan assets," each within the
meaning of, and subject to the provisions of, Tide I of ERISA.
As defined in Section 4.3(b).
As defined in Section 12.1.
A Fiscal Period shall be (a) a calendar year if there are no changes
in the Partners' respective interests in the Profits or Losses of the
Partnership during such calendar year except on the first day
thereof, or (b) any other period that the General Partner
determines is necessary and appropriate to comply with the
Treasury Regulations and/or to accomplish the purposes of this
Agreement.
The date on which an amount equal to 75% of the Partnership's
Committed Capital has been invested or committed for
investment, reasonably reserved for follow-on investment in
existing Portfolio Investments or applied or reasonably reserved
for Organizational Expenses and Partnership Expenses (including
the Management Fee).
Stephens Investment Management, LLC, a Delaware limited
liability company and any Person who is admitted to the
Partnership as a substitute or successor general partner in
accordance with this Agreement.
As defined in Section 4.1(c).
ACTIVE 20351111SSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
"Indemnified Parties"
"Initial Closing Date"
"Initial Closing LP"
'Interest'
'Investment Period'
"Limited Partners".
"Liquidating Trutt'
"Liquidator"
Illegotip. (or any  other specified
percentage) in Interest" of the
limited Partners
"Management Fee"
"Non-Djaulting Partners"
"Nonrecourse Deduction!'
"Organizational Expenses"
"Partner Nonretourse Debt
Minimum Gain"
"Partner Nonrecourse Deduction!'
"Partner?
"Partnership"
"Partnership Expenses"
As defined in Section 13.6.
The date of the first Closing.
As defined in Section 3.2(c).
In the context of "a Partner'' Interest," Interest means the entire
legal and equitable ownership interest of a Partner in the
Partnership at any particular time. When used in the context of
the General Partner, "Intemst' means the Partnership Interest held
by the Partner in its capacity as a General Partner. When used in
the context of a Limited Partner, "Interest' means the Partnership
Interest held by the Partner in its capacity as a Limited Partner.
The period commencing on the Initial Closing Date and ending
on the fourth anniversary of the Initial Closing Date.
As defined in the opening paragraph.
As defined in Section 10.4.
As defined in Section 10.3(a).
limited Partners having aggregate Percentage Interests of more
than 50% (or that specified percentage) of the Percentage
Interests of all of the Limited Partners other than any Defaulting
Limited Partners.
As defined in Section 6.1.
All Partners except those that the General Partner has declared
Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to Section 4.3(b).
As defined in Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-2(b).
As defined in Section 6.2(c).
An amount with respect to each partner nonrecourse debt (as
defined in Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-2(6)(4)) equal to the
Partnership Minimum Gain that would result if such partner
nonrecourse debt were treated as a nonrecourse liability (as
defined in Treasury Regulations Section 1.752-1(a)(2)) determined
in accordance with Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-2()(3).
As defined in Treasury Regulations Section 1.704-20)(2).
As defined in Section 3.1.
Crypto Currency Partners II, LP, a Delaware limited partnership.
As defined in Section 6.2(b).
CRYP7I7 CURRF\cYPARn'rsaf 11,1-P
Limited Patiners$ Aproment—Page 31
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
"Partnership Minimum Gain" As defined in Treasury Regulations Sections 1.704-2(b)(2) and
1.704-2(d).
"Parentage Interest'
"Plan Assets Regulations"
With respect to each Partner, the quotient (expressed as a
percentage) obtained by dividing: (a) such Partner's Capital
Commitment; by (b) the total Capital Commitments of all
Partners (with appropriate adjustment to reflect any changes
resulting from any remedies exercised against any Defaulting
Limited Partner pursuant to Section 4.3(b)).
The regulations issued by the Department of Labor at

Section 2510.3-101 of Part 2510 of Chapter XXV, Tide 29 of the
Code of Federal Regulations.
"Portfolio Immanent," As defined in Section 1.2.
"Ptinapa The principals of the General Partner, including W. Bradford
Stephens, P. Bart Stephens and Brock Pierce, in each case for as
long as each such individual is actively providing services to the
General Partner; "Ponape means any one of the Principals.
"Plirate Fevendation Partner" Private Foundation Partner shall mean any Limited Partner that is
a "private foundation" as described in Section 509 of the Code.
"Proreete Disposition Proceeds and Current Proceeds.
"Profit and Los!'
CRI-P7D aRRENCY PA RTNHILf II, LP
Limited Patinersh0 A,grerment—Page 32
Profit or Loss shall be an amount computed for each Fiscal
Period as of the last day thereof that is equal to the Partnership's
taxable income or loss for such Fiscal Period, determined in
accordance with Section 703(a) of the Code (for this purpose, all
items of income, gain, loss, or deduction required to be stated
separately pursuant to Code Section 703(a)(1) shall be included in
taxable income or loss), with the following adjustments:

(a) Any income of the Partnership that is exempt
from United States federal income tax and not otherwise taken
into account in computing Profit or Loss pursuant to this
paragraph shall be added to such taxable income or loss;

(b) Any expenditures of the Partnership described in
Code Section 705(a)(2)(B) or treated as Code Section 705(a)(2)(B)
expenditures pursuant to Treasury Regulation Section 1.704-
1(b)(2)(iv)(i) and not otherwise taken into account in computing
Profit or Loss pursuant to this paragraph shall be subtracted from
such taxable income or loss;

(c) Gain or loss resulting from any disposition of a
Partnership asset with respect to which gain or loss is recognized
for United States federal income tax purposes shall be computed
by reference to the Adjusted Asset Value of the asset disposed of
rather than its adjusted tax basis;
ACTIVE 20351111SSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT

(d) The difference between the gross fair market
value of all Partnership assets and their respective Adjusted Asset
Values shall be added to such taxable income or loss in the
circumstances described in the definition of Adjusted Asset Value;
(e) If the Adjusted Asset Value of any asset differs
from its adjusted tax basis for United States federal income tax
purposes the amount of depreciation, amortization or cost
recovery deductions with respect to such asset shall for purposes
of determining Profit or Losses be an amount which bears the
same ratio to such Adjusted Asset Value as the United States
federal income tax depreciation, amortization or other cost
recovery deductions bears to such adjusted tax basis (provided, that
if the United States federal income tax depreciation, amortization
or other cost recovery deduction is zero, the General Partner may
use any reasonable method for purposes of determining
depreciation, amortization or other cost recovery deductions in
calculating Profit and Loss); and
Items that are specially allocated pursuant to

Section 5.3 shall not be taken into account in computing Profit or
Loss.
"Realized Portfolio Investment'
"Regelabk Distribution"
A Portfolio Investment that has been the subject of a sale,
exchange, redemption, repayment, repurchase or other disposition
or refinancing by the Partnership for cash.
Any distribution made to a Partner during the Investment Period
that represents a return of capital, as determined by the General
Partner (including any distribution of Catch -Up Contributions
made by later-admitted Partners), which distribution shall added
back to the Partner's Unfunded Capital Commitment and be
subject to recall by the General Partner pursuant to Article IV.
"Securities Act' Securities Act is the Securities Act of 1933, as amended.
"Sid/9?' As defined in Section 13.16.
"Subject Limited Panne?' As defined in Section 7.5.
"Subscription Agreement' As defined in Section 13.13.
"Tax Payment?' As defined in Section 7.7(a).
"Ttrasug Regulation?' Treasury Regulations shall mean the Income Tax Regulations
promulgated under the Code, as such Regulations may be
amended from time to time (including corresponding provisions
of succeeding Regulations).
"Unfunded Capital Commitment" As of a Call Date with respect to a Partner, an amount equal to (i)
the amount of that Partner's Capital Commitment; minus (ii) the
amount of all Capital Contributions made by the Partner; plus (iii)
CRYPIDCURAHNCY PARTNI!RS 11, LP
Limited Patiners$ Aproment—Page 33
ACTIVE 2035&81030v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
the amount of any Recyclable Distributions made to the Partner,
in each case, determined as of that Call Date.
CRI-P7D aRREAVX PA RTNHRf 11, LP
Limited PatinerehO Agrerment—Page 34
ACTIVE 20351111SSOv.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Partners have executed this Limited Partnership Agreement as
of the date first written above.
GENERAL PARTNER:
SFEPHENS INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, LLC
By:
Name:
Title:
CRYP7I7 CURAILVCY PARTNtiltf IL LP
Limited Patiners$ Aproment—Page 35
ACTIVE 20351MS0v.2
CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT
SOLELY FOR INTENDED RECIPIENT
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Partners have executed this Limited Partnership Agreement as
of the date first written above.
LIMITED PARTNER (ENTITIES):
(print name of entity)
By:
Name:
Title:
LIMITED PARTNER (INDIVIDUALS):
(signature)
(print name of individual)
CRIPID aRRENCY PA RTNHILf II, LP
Limited Patinersh0 Agreement—Page 36
ACTIVE 20351111SSOv.2
╔══════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ian O'Donnell [tech] Peter Thiel's Valar Ventures 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01121910 (Jmail)
 [tech] Valar Ventures contract
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Name of Investor:
Investment Representative:
Investor Representative Phone #:
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND
INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE
109191599v3
VALAR GLOBAL FUND HI LP
SUBSCRIPTION INSTRUCTIONS
A subscription to invest in Valar Global Fund III LP (the "Fund") may be made only by means of the
completion, delivery and acceptance of the subscription documents in this package as follows:
Completion of the following documents:
o Subscription Agreement and Investor Questionnaire:  Complete all requested information in this
Subscription Agreement and Investor Questionnaire (the "Agreement") and date and sign a copy
of the signature page.
o Investor Information and Investor Type Representations:  Complete all requested information in
the Investor Infonnation fonn and the Investor Type Representations form attached as
SCHEDULE A and SCHEDULE B, respectively.
o IRS Form W-9 or Form W-8: Complete and sign IRS Form W-9 or the applicable Form W-8 to
certify your tax identification number or status attached as EXHIBIT B and EXHIBIT C,
respectively.
If you will be investing through multiple entities, please make additional copies of these documents as
necessary, ensuring that all documents are completed for each entity investing in the Fund.
DELIVERY INSTRUCTIONS. Investors must submit:
o A completed copy of this Agreement;
o An executed copy of the signature page to this Agreement; and
o An original, executed Form W-9 or W-8, as applicable.
These subscription documents should be delivered to the following address by overnight mail for delivery
by the date specified in the correspondence accompanying this document. Documents may be delivered
via facsimile (or by email as a PDF file):
Valar Global Fund III LP
do Cool LLP
Attention: Ian O'Donnell
Tel:
Fax:
Email:
ADDITIONAL REQUIRED DOCUMENTS. Valar Ventures GP III LLC (the "General Partner") reserves
the right to request any additional documentation necessary to verify the identity of a prospective limited
partner in the Fund. Please be aware that your failure to provide such documentation may delay your
acceptance by the General Partner or cause your subscription request to be rejected entirely. The Fund
and the General Partner shall be held harmless by any such prospective limited partner against any loss
arising as a result of a failure to provide any requested documentation.
109191599 v3
PRIVACY. The Fund takes precautions to maintain the privacy of personal information concerning the
Fund's current and prospective individual investors. For more information in this regard, please refer to
the Privacy Policy attached hereto as EXHIBIT D.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. For additional information concerning subscriptions, prospective investors
should contact James Fitzgerald at or . For questions regarding the
completion of these subscri tion documents, please contact Sandra Dayco-Coray, a senior paralegal at
Cooley LLP, at or I L For legal questions related to your
subscription or questions regarding the Partnership Agreement, please contact Ian O'Donnell or Hon bo
(Robert) Bao of Cooley LLP, legal counsel to the Fund ("Fund Counsel"), at or
or or respectively.
109191599 v3
Prospective Investor:
Contact Person:
Email:
Telephone No:
Fax No:
State/Country of Domicile:
Tax Identification Number:
Capital Commitment (USD): $
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND
INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE
THE OFFERING OF SECURITIES DESCRIBED HEREIN HAS NOT BEEN REGISTERED UNDER
THE UNITED STATES SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED (THE "SECURITIES ACT"),
OR UNDER ANY SECURITIES LAWS OF ANY STATE OF THE UNITED STATES OR ANY
OTHER JURISDICTION. THIS OFFERING IS MADE PURSUANT TO RULE 506 OF
REGULATION D UNDER SECTION 4(2) OF THE SECURITIES ACT, WHICH EXEMPTS FROM
SUCH REGISTRATION TRANSACTIONS NOT INVOLVING A PUBLIC OFFERING. FOR THIS
REASON, THESE SECURITIES WILL BE SOLD ONLY TO INVESTORS WHO MEET CERTAIN
MINIMUM SUITABILITY QUALIFICATIONS DESCRIBED HEREIN.
A SUBSCRIBER SHOULD BE PREPARED TO BEAR THE ECONOMIC RISK OF AN
INVESTMENT IN THE FUND FOR AN INDEFINITE PERIOD OF TIME BECAUSE THE LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS HAVE NOT BEEN REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OR
THE LAWS OF ANY OTHER JURISDICTION, AND, THEREFORE, CANNOT BE SOLD UNLESS
THEY ARE SUBSEQUENTLY REGISTERED OR AN EXEMPTION FROM REGISTRATION IS
AVAILABLE. THERE IS NO OBLIGATION OF THE ISSUER TO REGISTER THE LIMITED
PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OR THE LAWS OF ANY OTHER
JURISDICTION. TRANSFER OF THE LIMITED PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS IS ALSO
RESTRICTED BY THE TERMS OF THE LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT RELATING
THERETO.
109191599 v3
PART I - APPLICABLE TO ALL INVESTORS
Valar Global Fund III LP
do Cooley L„
Ann: Ian O'Donnell
Ladies and Gentlemen:
This SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE (this "Agreement") is
entered into by and among VALAR VENTURES GP DI LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the
"General Partner"), VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP, a Delaware limited partnership (the "Fund"), and
the investor identified on the signature page hereto (the "Investor") in connection with the Investor's
purchase of a limited partnership interest in the Fund (the "Interest"), and admission as a Limited Partner
therein pursuant to the Limited Partnership Agreement of the Fund (as amended from time to time, the
"Partnership Agreement"). Capitalized terms used herein and not otherwise defined shall have the
meanings given to them in the Partnership Agreement.
The Investor hereby subscribes for an Interest, and the General Partner, the Fund and the Investor
hereby agree as follows:

1. Contribution. The Investor agrees to contribute, in installments, an aggregate amount as set
forth on the signature page hereto (the Investor's "Capital Commitment") to the Fund pursuant to
the terms of, and at the times required by, the Partnership Agreement. (All references herein are
to United States Dollars.) All payments of the Investor's Capital Commitment shall be made by
check made payable to "Valar Global Fund III LP" or by wire transfer pursuant to instructions
provided by the General Partner prior to the due date of such payments.

2. Adoption. If the Investor is accepted as a Limited Partner pursuant to paragraph 3 below, the
Investor hereby agrees to be bound by all the terms and provisions of the Partnership Agreement
and to perform all obligations therein imposed upon a Limited Partner with respect to the Interest.

3. Acceptance of Subscription; Delivery of Partnership Agreement. The Investor understands
and agrees that this subscription is made subject to the following terms and conditions:

(a) The General Partner shall have the right to review the suitability of any person desiring to
purchase an Interest and, in connection with such review, to waive such suitability
standards as to such person as the General Partner deems appropriate under applicable
law;

(b) The General Partner shall have the right, in its sole and absolute discretion, to reject this
subscription, in whole or in part, and the subscription shall be deemed to be accepted by
the General Partner only when the Investor has been admitted to the Fund as a Limited
Partner;

(c) The General Partner shall have no obligation to accept subscriptions in the order
received;
(d) The Investor hereby requests and authorizes the General Partner to enter the Investor's
name in the books and records of the Partnership as a holder of the Interest;
109191599 v3 2

(e) The Interest to be created on account of this subscription shall be created only in the
name of the Investor, and the Investor agrees to comply with the terms of the Partnership
Agreement and to execute any and all further documents necessary in connection with
becoming a Limited Partner of the Fund; and
The Investor hereby undertakes in respect of the Interest that the Investor: CO shall
comply with the restrictions on transfer of the Interest contained in the Partnership
Agreement; and (ii) understands that upon a default of the Investor's capital contribution
obligations to the Fund, the Interest may, among other consequences, be subject to partial
forfeiture in accordance with the terms of the Partnership Agreement.

4. Fund's Conditions to Closing. The Fund's obligations hereunder are subject to acceptance by
the General Partner of the Investor's subscription and to the fulfillment, prior to or at the time of
closing, of each of the following conditions:

(a) The representations and warranties of the Investor contained in this Agreement shall be
true and correct at the time of closing; and

(b) All proceedings in connection with the transactions contemplated hereby and all
documents and instruments incident to such transactions shall be satisfactory in substance
and form to the General Partner, the Fund and Cooley LLP ("Fund Counsel"), and the
General Partner, the Fund or Fund Counsel shall have received all such counterpart
originals or certified or other copies of such documents as the General Partner may
request.

5. Investor's Representations. In connection with the Investor's purchase of the Interest, the
Investor makes the following representations and warranties on which the General Partner, the
Fund and Fund Counsel are entitled to rely:

(a) The Investor has received, read and understands that certain Confidential Private
Placement Memorandum, as it may be amended and supplemented from time to time (the
"Memorandum"), the Partnership Agreement, and this Agreement, and acknowledges
and agrees that the Memorandum, the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement
constitute the sole offering materials on which the offer of the Interest to the Investor is
based. No representations or warranties have been made to the Investor by the Fund, the
General Partner or any agent of said persons, other than as set forth in the Memorandum,
the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement.

(b) The Investor is acquiring the Interest solely for the Investor's own account and not
directly or indirectly for the account of any other person whatsoever (or, if the Investor is
acquiring the Interest as a trustee, solely for the account of the trust or trust account
named herein) for investment and not with a view to, or for sale in connection with, any
distribution of the Interest. The Investor does not have any contract, undertaking or
arrangement with any person to sell, transfer or grant a participation to any person with
respect to the Interest.

(c) The Investor has such knowledge and experience in financial and business matters that
the Investor is capable of evaluating the merits and risks of the investment evidenced by
the Investor's purchase of the Interest, and the Investor is able to bear the economic risk
of such investment including the risk of complete loss.
109191599 v3 3

(d) The Investor has had access to such information concerning the Fund as the Investor
deems necessary to enable the Investor to make an informed decision concerning the
purchase of the Interest. The Investor has had access to the personnel at the General
Partner and its Affiliates and the opportunity to ask questions of, and receive answers
satisfactory to the Investor from, such persons concerning the offering of Interests in the
Fund and the Fund generally. The Investor has obtained all additional information
requested by the Investor to verify the accuracy of all information furnished in
connection with the offering of Interests in the Fund.

(e) The Investor understands that the Interest has not been registered under the United States
Securities Act of 1933, as amended (the "Securities Act"), or any securities law of any
state of the United States or any other jurisdiction, in each case in reliance on an
exemption for private offerings, and the Investor acknowledges that the Investor is
purchasing the Interest without being furnished any offering literature or prospectus other
than the Memorandum, the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement.

(f) The Investor is aware that (i) the Investor must bear the economic risk of investment in
the Interest for an indefinite period of time, possibly until final winding up of the Fund,

(ii) because the Interest has not been registered under the Securities Act, there is currently
no public market therefor, (iii) the Investor may not be able to avail itself of the
provisions of Rule 144 of the Securities Act with respect to the Interest, and (iv) the
Interest cannot be sold unless subsequently registered under the Securities Act or an
exemption from such registration is available. The Investor understands that the Fund is
under no obligation, and does not intend, to effect any such registration at any time. The
Investor also understands that sales or transfers of the Interest are further restricted by the
provisions of the Partnership Agreement and, as applicable, securities laws of other
jurisdictions and the states of the United States.

(g) The Interest will not be transferred or disposed of except in accordance with the terms of
this Agreement and the Partnership Agreement and will not be sold or transferred without
registration under the Securities Act, or pursuant to an applicable exemption therefrom.

(h) The Investor's full legal name, true and correct address of residence (for individuals) or
principal place of business (for entities), phone number, fax number, electronic mail
address, United States taxpayer identification number (each, if applicable) and other
contact information are provided on SCHEDULE A hereto.
(0 The execution and delivery of the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement, the
consummation of the transactions contemplated thereby and the performance of the
obligations thereunder will not conflict with or result in any violation of or default under
any provision of any other agreement or instrument to which the Investor is a party or any
license, permit, franchise, judgment, order, writ or decree, or any statute, rule or
regulation, applicable to the Investor.

(j) No suit, action, claim, investigation or other proceeding is pending or, to the best of the
Investor's knowledge, is threatened against the Investor that questions the validity of the
Partnership Agreement or this Agreement or any action taken or to be taken pursuant to
the Partnership Agreement or this Agreement.

(k) The Investor has full power and authority to make the representations referred to in this
Agreement, to purchase the Interest pursuant to this Agreement and the Partnership
109191599 v3 4
Agreement and to deliver the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement. The
Partnership Agreement and this Agreement create valid and binding obligations of the
Investor and are enforceable against the Investor in accordance with their terms, except as
enforcement may be limited by applicable bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization,
arrangement, moratorium or other similar laws affecting creditors' rights, and subject to
general equity principles and to limitations on availability of equitable relief, including
specific performance.
The Investor acknowledges that the Investor understands the meaning and legal
consequences of the representations and warranties made by the Investor herein. Such
representations and warranties are complete and accurate, shall be complete and accurate
at the time of closing and may be relied upon by the Fund, the General Partner and Fund
Counsel. Said representations and warranties shall survive delivery of this Agreement
and the Partnership Agreement. If in any respect such information shall not be complete
and accurate prior to the time of closing, the Investor shall give immediate notice of such
incomplete or inaccurate information to the General Partner, specifying which
representations or warranties are not complete and accurate and the reasons therefor.

(m) The Investor hereby agrees to indemnify and hold harmless the Fund, Fund Counsel, the
General Partner, the Management Company and each member, managing member,
manager, partner, principal, director, officer, advisor or employee thereof (each, an
"Indemnified Party") from and against any and all loss, damage or liability due to or
arising out of any inaccuracy or breach of any representation or warranty of the Investor
or failure of the Investor to comply with any covenant or agreement set forth herein or in
any other document furnished to any Indemnified Party specifically supplementing the
infomiation in this subscription booklet by the Investor in connection with the
subscription for an Interest. The Investor shall reimburse each Indemnified Party for its
legal and other expenses (including the cost of any investigation and preparation) as they
are incurred in connection with any such claim, action, proceeding or investigation. The
reimbursement and indemnification obligations of the Investor under this paragraph shall
survive any closing applicable to the Investor (or, if this Agreement is terminated
pursuant to paragraph 3(b) above, such termination) and shall be in addition to any
liability which the Investor may otherwise have (including, without limitation, liabilities
under the Partnership Agreement), and shall be binding and inure to the benefit of any
successors, assigns, heirs, estates, executors, administrators and personal representatives
of the Indemnified Parties.

(n) The Investor confirms that the Investor has been advised to consult with the Investor's
attorney regarding legal matters concerning the Fund and to consult with independent tax
advisers regarding the tax consequences of investing in the Fund. The Investor
acknowledges that he, she or it understands that any anticipated United States federal or
state income tax benefits may not be available and, further, may be adversely affected
through adoption of new laws or regulations or amendments to existing laws or
regulations. The Investor acknowledges and agrees that the Fund is providing no
warranty or assurance regarding the ultimate availability of any tax benefits to the
Investor by reason of the Investor's investment in the Fund.

(o) The Investor understands that information relating to the Investor shall appear on the
financial statements and other records of the Fund. The Investor acknowledges and
agrees that other Partners may receive such information as permitted by the Partnership
109191599v3 5
Agreement or as required by applicable laws and may share such information with their
advisors and other parties.

(p) The Investor understands and agrees that the General Partner may cause the Fund to
make an election under Section 754 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended
(the "Code") or an election to be treated as an "electing investment partnership" for
purposes of Section 743 of the Code. If the Fund elects to be treated as an electing
investment partnership, the Investor shall cooperate with the Fund and the General
Partner to maintain that status and shall not take any action that would be inconsistent
with such election. Upon request, the Investor shall provide the General Partner with any
information necessary to allow the Fund to comply with (a) its obligations to make tax
basis adjustments under Sections 734 or 743 of the Code and (b) its obligations as an
electing investment partnership.

(q) The Investor has carefully reviewed and understands the various risks of an investment in
the Fund, as well as the fees and conflicts of interest to which the Fund is subject, as set
forth in the Memorandum, the Partnership Agreement and this Agreement. The Investor
hereby consents and agrees to the payment of the fees so described to the parties
identified as the recipients thereof, and to such conflicts of interest.

(r) The Investor acknowledges that the Investor has received the Privacy Policy Statement of
the Fund contained in EXHIBIT D attached hereto.

(s) The Investor hereby acknowledges that none of the General Partner, the Management
Company nor their respective affiliates provide, or intend to provide, advice to the Fund
with respect to investment strategies that are "plans or programs for the investment of the
proceeds of municipal securities or the recommendation of and brokerage of municipal
escrow investments" (within the meaning of Rule 15Ba 1-1 promulgated under the
Securities Act). The Investor represents and agrees that none of its contributions to the
Fund will consist of "proceeds of municipal securities" (within the meaning of Rule
15Bal-1).

(t) Except as disclosed in writing to the General Partner, neither the Investor nor any
Beneficial Owner2 has been subject to any of the following "Disqualifying Events"
specified below during the time periods specified below:
If the Investor, and/or any Beneficial Owner has been subject to a Disqualifying Event, and either (i) the
court or regulatory authority that entered the relevant order, judgment or decree has advised in writing
(whether contained in the relevant judgment, order or decree or separately to the SEC or its staff) that
disqualification under paragraph (d)(1) of Rule 506 under the Securities Act should not arise as a
consequence of such order, judgment or decree, or (ii) the SEC has issued an exemption from paragraph
(dX1) of Rule 506 with respect to such event, the Investor may provide a certified copy of such order,
judgment, decree or exemption.
2 For the purposes of the representations under this subparagraph (t), "Beneficial Owner" means an
individual or entity who, directly or indirectly, through any contract, arrangement, understanding,
relationship or otherwise has or shares, or is deemed to have or share: (I) voting power, which includes
the power to vote, or to direct the voting of, the Interest; and/or (2) investment power, which includes the
power to dispose, or to direct the disposition of, the Interest, as determined consistent with Rulel3d-3 of
the U.S. Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (the "Exchange Act").
109191599 v3 6

(i) Has been convicted, within the ten-year period ending on the date hereof, of any felony
or misdemeanor:

(A) In connection with the purchase or sale of any security;
(B) Involving the making of any false filing with the Securities and Exchange
Commission (the "SEC); or

(C) Arising out of the conduct of the business of an underwriter, broker, dealer,
municipal securities dealer, investment adviser or paid solicitor of purchasers of
securities;

(ii) Is subject to any order, judgment or decree of any court of competent jurisdiction, entered
within the five-year period ending on the date hereof, that, at this date, restrains or
enjoins such person from engaging or continuing to engage in any conduct or practice:

(A) In connection with the purchase or sale of any security;
(B) Involving the making of any false filing with the SEC; or

(C) Arising out of the conduct of the business of an underwriter, broker, dealer,
municipal securities dealer, investment adviser or paid solicitor of purchasers of
securities;
(iii) Is subject to a final order of a state securities commission (or an agency or officer of a
state performing like functions); a state authority that supervises or examines banks,
savings associations, or credit unions; a state insurance commission (or an agency or
officer of a state performing like functions); an appropriate federal banking agency; the
U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (the "CFTC); or the National Credit
Union Administration that:

(A) On the date hereof, bars the person from:
( 1) Association with an entity regulated by such commission, authority,
agency or officer;

(2) Engaging in the business of securities, insurance or banking; or
(3) Engaging in savings association or credit union activities; or

(B) Constitutes a final order based on a violation of any law or regulation that
prohibits fraudulent, manipulative, or deceptive conduct entered within the ten-
year period ending on the date hereof;

(iv) Is subject to an order of the SEC entered pursuant to Section 15(b) or 15B(c) of the
Exchange Act or Section 203(e) or (f) of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 that, as of
the date hereof:

(A) Suspends or revokes such person's registration as a broker, dealer, municipal
securities dealer or investment adviser;

(B) Places limitations on the activities, functions or operations of such person; or
109191599v3 7
(C) Bars such person from being associated with any entity or from participating in
the offering of any penny stock;

(v) Is subject to any order of the SEC entered within the five-year period ending on the date
hereof that, as of the date hereof, orders the person to cease and desist from committing
or causing a violation or future violation of:

(A) Any scienter-based anti-fraud provision of the federal securities laws, including
without limitation Section 17(a)(1) of the Securities Act, Section 10(b) of the
Exchange Act and Rule 10b-5 thereunder, Section 15(c)(1) of the Exchange Act
and Section 206(1) of the Investment Advisers Act, or any other rule or
regulation thereunder; or

(B) Section 5 of the Securities Act;
(vi) Is suspended or expelled from membership in, or suspended or barred from association
with a member of, a registered national securities exchange or a registered national or
affiliated securities association for any act or omission to act constituting conduct
inconsistent with just and equitable principles of trade;
(vii) Has filed (as a registrant or issuer), or was or was named as an underwriter in, any
registration statement or Regulation A offering statement filed with the SEC that, within
the five-year period ending on the date hereof, was the subject of a refusal order, stop
order, or order suspending the Regulation A exemption, or is, as of the date hereof, the
subject of an investigation or proceeding to determine whether a stop order or suspension
order should be issued; or
(viii) Is subject to a United States Postal Service false representation order entered within the
five-year period ending on the date hereof, or is, as of the date hereof, subject to a
temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction with respect to conduct alleged by
the United States Postal Service to constitute a scheme or device for obtaining money or
property through the mail by means of false representations.

(u) Except as disclosed in writing to the General Partner, to the best of the Investor's
knowledge, neither the Investor nor any Beneficial Owner:

(i) is subject to any action, proceeding or investigation or any impending action, order,
judgment, or decree that could give rise to any Disqualifying Event with respect to the
Investor or such Beneficial Owner;

(ii) has filed or expects to file (as registrant or issuer), or was named (or expects to be named)
as an underwriter in, any registration statement or Regulation A offering statement filed
with the SEC; or
(iii) is a member or a person associated with a member of a registered national securities
exchange or a registered national or affiliated securities association.

(v) Except as disclosed in the space provided below, neither the Investor nor any Beneficial
Owner:
109191599v3 8

(i) "beneficially owns" (within the meaning of Rule 13d-3 of the Exchange Act) any other
limited partnership interest in the Fund, except for the Interest subscribed to hereunder, or
will "beneficially own" such other interest in the Fund upon the acceptance of a
subscription agreement for such other interest by the General Partner.

(ii) has agreed with one or more other Limited Partners (or the "beneficial owners" of such
Limited Partner(s)) to act together for the purpose of acquiring, holding, voting or
disposing of limited partnership interests in the Fund (within the meaning of Rule 13d-5
of the Exchange Act).
Please disclose in the space provided below the identities of (i) any other Limited Partner with
whom the Investor or any Beneficial Owner owns a separate interest in the Fund, and (i) any
other Limited Partner (or "beneficial owner" of such Limited Partner) with whom the Investor or
any Beneficial Owner has agreed to act together for the purpose of acquiring, holding, voting or
disposing of a limited partnership interest in the Fund.
Other Limited Partner(s)

(w) If the Investor or any Beneficial Owner has agreed with one or more other Limited
Partners (or the beneficial owners of such Limited Partner(s)) to act together for the
purpose of acquiring, holding, voting or disposing of limited partnership interests in the
Fund, the group formed thereby is not subject to any Disqualifying Event.
The Investor hereby undertakes to promptly notify the General Partner if the responses to the
subparagraphs (0 to (w) become inaccurate at any time, including any time following the
admission of the Investor as a Limited Partner of the Fund.

6. Anti•Money Laundering Regulations. The Investor hereby acknowledges that the General
Partner's and the Fund's intent is to comply with all applicable United States federal, state and
local laws designed to combat money laundering and similar illegal activities, including the
provisions of the Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to
Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act of 2001 ("PATRIOT Act"). In furtherance of such efforts,
the Investor hereby represents, covenants, and agrees that, to the best of Investor's knowledge
based on reasonable investigation:

(a) None of the Investor's capital contributions to the Fund (whether payable in cash or
otherwise) shall be derived from money laundering or similar activities deemed illegal
under United States federal laws and regulations.

(b) To the extent within the Investor's control, none of Investor's capital contributions to the
Fund will cause the Fund or any of its personnel to be in violation of United States
federal anti-money laundering laws, including without limitation the Bank Secrecy Act
(31 U.S.C. 5311 et seq.), the United States Money Laundering Control Act of 1986 or the
109191599 v3 9
International Money Laundering Abatement and Anti-Terrorist Financing Act of 2001,
and any regulations promulgated thereunder.

(c) When requested by the General Partner, the Investor will provide any and all additional
information, and the Investor understands and agrees that the General Partner may release
confidential information about the Investor and, if applicable, any underlying beneficial
owner or Related Person to any person, deemed reasonably necessary to ensure
compliance with all applicable laws and regulations concerning money laundering and
similar activities. The General Partner reserves the right to request any information as is
necessary to verify the identity of the Investor and the source of any payment to the Fund.
In the event of delay or failure by the Investor to produce any information required for
verification purposes, the subscription by the investor may be refused.

(d) The Investor represents and warrants neither it, nor any person or entity controlled by,
controlling or under common control with the Investor, any of the Investor's beneficial
owners, any person for whom the Investor is acting as agent or nominee in connection
with this investment, nor in the case of an Investor which is an entity, any Related
Persons is:
a Prohibited Investor;

(ii) a Senior Foreign Political Figure, 5 any member of a Senior Foreign Political
Figure's "immediate family," which includes the figure's parents, siblings,
spouse, children and in-laws, or any Close Associate' of a Senior Foreign
Political Figure, or a person or entity resident in, or organized or chartered under,
the laws of a Non-Cooperative Jurisdiction;
(iii) a person or entity resident in, or organized or chartered under, the laws of a
jurisdiction that has been designated by the U.S. Secretary of the Treasury under

Section 311 or 312 of the PATRIOT Act as warranting special measures due to
money laundering concerns; or
3 with respect to any entity, any interest holder, director, senior officer, trustee, beneficiary or grantor of such 
entity; provided
that in the case of an entity that is a publicly traded company or a tax qualified pension or retirement plan in which 
at least 100
employees participate that is maintained by an employer that is organized in the U.S. or is a U.S. government entity (a 
"Qualified
Plan"), the term "Related Person" shall exclude any interest holder holding less than 5% of any class of securities of 
such
publicly traded company and beneficiaries of such Qualified Plan. 4 For purposes of this subparagraph (d), "Prohibited 
Investor" shall mean a person or entity
whose name appears on

(i) the List of Specially Designated Nationals and Blocked Persons maintained by the U.S. Office of Foreign Assets 
Control;

(ii) other lists of prohibited persons and entities as may be mandated by applicable law or regulation; or (iii) such 
other lists of
prohibited persons and entities as may be provided to the Fund in connection therewith.
For purposes of this subparagraph (d), "Senior Foreign Political Figure" shall mean a senior official in the executive,
legislative, administrative, military or judicial branches of a foreign government (whether elected or not), a senior 
official of a
major foreign political party, or a senior executive of a foreign government-owned corporation. In addition, a Senior 
Foreign
Political Figure includes any corporation, business or other entity that has been formed by, or for the benefit of, a 
Senior Foreign
Political Figure. 6 For purposes of this subparagraph (d), "Close Associate of a Senior Foreign Political Figure" shall 
mean a person
who is widely and publicly known internationally to maintain an unusually close relationship with the Senior Foreign 
Political
Figure, and includes a person who is in a position to conduct substantial domestic and international financial 
transactions on
behalf of the Senior Foreign Political Figure.
7 For purposes of this subparagraph (d), "Non -Cooperative Jurisdiction" shall mean any foreign country that has been
designated as non-cooperative with international anti-money laundering principles or procedures by an intergovernmental 
group
or organization, such as the Financial Task Force on Money Laundering, of which the U.S. is a member and with which
designation the U.S. representative to the group or organization continues to concur.
109191599 v3 10

(iv) a person or entity who gives Investor reason to believe that its funds originate
from, or will be or have been routed through, an account maintained at a Foreign
Shell Bank,8 an "offshore bank," or a bank organized or chattered under the laws
of a Non-Cooperative Jurisdiction.

(e) If the Investor is purchasing the Interest as agent, representative, intermediary/nominee or
in any particular capacity for any other person, or is otherwise requested to do so by the
General Partner, it shall provide a copy of its anti-money laundering policies ("AML
Policies") to the General Partner. The Investor represents that it is in compliance with its
AML Policies, its AML Policies have been approved by counsel or internal compliance
personnel reasonably informed of anti-money laundering policies and their
implementation and it has not received a deficiency letter, negative report or any similar
determination regarding its AML Policies from independent accountants, internal
auditors or some other person responsible for reviewing compliance with its AML
Policies.

(f) The Investor hereby agrees to immediately notify the General Partner if it knows, or has
reason to suspect that any of the representations in this paragraph 6 have become
incorrect or if there is any change in the information affecting these representations and
covenants.

(g) The Investor agrees that, if at any time it is discovered that any of the foregoing anti-
money laundering representations are incorrect, or if otherwise required by applicable
laws or regulations related to money laundering and similar activities, the General Partner
may undertake appropriate actions, and the Investor agrees to cooperate with such
actions, to ensure compliance with such laws or regulations, including, but not limited to
segregation and/or redemption of the Investor's Interest in the Fund or freezing the
Investor's account.
7. Withholding. The General Partner is required to withhold a certain portion of the taxable income
and gain allocated or distributed to each Investor unless the Investor provides documentation
confirming that such Investor is not subject to withholding, or is subject to a reduced rate of
withholding. The following information is provided to assist the Investor in complying with the
U.S. rules for backup withholding and withholding with respect to income earned by foreign
persons. This information is only a summary, and is not a substitute for the advice of a tax
advisor. Each Investor is urged to consult with a tax advisor concerning the application of the
U.S. withholding rules to such Investor.
For purposes of this subparagraph (d), "Foreign Shell Bank" shall mean a Foreign Bank without a Physical Presence
in any country, but does not include a Regulated Affiliate.
A "Foreign Bank" shall mean an organization that (9 is organized under the laws of a foreign country, (ii) engages in
the business of banking, (iii) is recognized as a bank by the bank supervisory or monetary authority of the country of 
its
organization or principal banking operations, (iv) receives deposits to a substantial extent in the regular course of 
its business,
and (v) has the power to accept demand deposits, but does not include the U.S. branches or agencies of a foreign bank.
"Physical Presence" shall mean a place of business that is maintained by a Foreign Bank and is located at a fixed
address, other than solely a post office box or an electronic address, in a country in which the Foreign Bank is 
authorized to
conduct banking activities, at which location the Foreign Bank (i) employs one or more individuals on a full-time basis,
(ii)
maintains operating records related to its banking activities, and (iii) is subject to inspection by the banking 
authority that
licensed the Foreign Bank to conduct banking activities.
"Regulated Affiliate" shall mean a Foreign Shell Bank that is an affiliate of a depository institution, credit union or
Foreign Bank that maintains a Physical Presence in the U.S. or a foreign country regulating such affiliated depository 
institution,
credit union or Foreign Bank.
109191599 v3 II
The type of documentation required by the Investor is a function of whether the Investor is a
Foreign Person or a United States person. "Foreign Persons" include nonresident aliens, foreign
corporations, foreign partnerships, foreign trusts or foreign estates (as each of those terms is
defined in the Code and Treasury Regulations). "United States person" has the meaning set forth
in EXHIBIT A. In the case of entities that are disregarded for purposes of U.S. tax law (e.g.,
fiscally transparent entities with a single owner that have not elected to be taxed as a corporation
for U.S. tax purposes), such entities are treated as United States persons or Foreign Persons
depending on the residence and status of their owners, rather than on where the disregarded
entities are organized. Thus, an investor that is a U.S. disregarded entity with a foreign owner
will generally be treated as a Foreign Person and should complete and submit the appropriate
Form W-8 (as discussed below) based on the owner's status. An investor that is a foreign
disregarded entity with a U.S. owner will generally be treated as a United States person and
should complete and submit Form W-9 (as discussed below).
If the Investor is a United States person, please complete IRS Form W-9 (provided with
instructions as EXHIBIT B hereto). Such Investor agrees to notify the General Partner within sixty

(60) days if the Investor ceases to be a United States person.
If the Investor is a Foreign Person, please complete either Form W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E, Form W-
8ECI, Form W-8EXP or Form W-8IMY (along with any accompanying withholding certificates,
if appropriate), in accordance with the instructions provided below and the printed instructions
included with the appropriate form. Each of these forms and their instructions is included as part
of EXHIBIT C hereto. These forms must be updated and provided again to the General Partner in
certain circumstances, as described in the printed instructions provided with each form.
The following summary guidelines are provided for the benefit of those Foreign Persons required
to provide Form W-8. In addition to the information provided herein, please refer to the printed
instructions included in EXHIBIT C hereto for more detailed guidelines.

(a) The following Foreign Persons should complete and provide Form W-8EXP:
(i) a foreign government;
(ii) an international organization;
(iii) a foreign central bank of issue;

(iv) a foreign tax-exempt organization;
(v) a foreign private foundation; and
(vi) the government of a U.S. possession claiming the applicability of Section 115(2),
501(c), 892, 895 or 1443(b) of the Internal Revenue Code.

(b) An investor that holds an Interest which is effectively connected with the investor's
conduct of a U.S. trade or business should complete and provide Form W-8ECI.

(c) The following Foreign Persons should complete and provide Form W-8IMY:
(i) any Foreign Person (including a custodian, broker, nominee or agent) that holds
an Interest on behalf of another person;
9 These forms are periodically revised by the U.S. Internal Revenue Service. Investors that need to submit an
updated Form W-S after the initial closing of the Fund should check the Internal Revenue Service web site
(vmw.irs.gov) to ensure that they have the latest version of these forms.
109191599 v3 12

(ii) any Foreign Person that is a flow-through entity or fiscally transparent (including
a foreign partnership or foreign trust);
(iii) a foreign branch of a United States person to establish that it is a qualified
intermediary that is not acting for its own account; and

(iv) a U.S. branch of a foreign bank or foreign insurance company, to represent that
(A) the Interest is not effectively connected with the conduct of a U.S. trade or
business and (B) that either (1) the U.S. branch is to be treated as a United States
person with respect to any payments associated with the Interest; or (2) the U.S.
branch is providing the documentation of the persons for whom it holds the
Interest.
In order to avoid withholding on income allocated to an Interest held by the Foreign
Persons described in this paragraph 7(c), such Foreign Persons must also provide
additional information and documentation as detailed in the printed instructions
accompanying Form W-8IMY (included with EXHIBIT C hereto).
Most Foreign Persons described in this paragraph 7(c) will need to provide the
information including, but not limited to, the following:

(1) A withholding statement including:
(i) the name, address, U.S. TIN# (including an ITIN#, if any) and
type of withholding documentation for every person for whom
documentation has been received;
whether each such person is a United States person exempt from
backup withholding, a United States person subject to backup
withholding, or a Foreign Person;
(iii) whether each Foreign Person is a beneficial owner or
intermediary, flow-through entity or U.S. branch;

(iv) how income attributable to the Interest should be allocated
among the beneficial owners on whose behalf the Interest is held
(see printed instructions to Form W-8IMY (attached) for an
alternative allocation procedure);

(A) for each beneficial owner who is a Foreign Person, the
applicable rate of withholding, country of residence, the
basis for any reduced rate of withholding, and other
information; and

(B) any other information requested by the General Partner
for purposes of fulfilling its withholding obligations.

(2) A Form W-8 and other documentary evidence supporting the information
contained in the withholding statement for each beneficial owner listed in
the withholding statement.
Certain Foreign Persons described in this paragraph 7(c) may have entered into an
agreement with the U.S. Internal Revenue Service to act as a withholding foreign
109191599 v3 13
partnership, withholding foreign trust, or qualified intermediary. Such Foreign Persons
should consult the printed instructions to Form W-8IMY to determine the information
they must provide to the General Partner to reduce or eliminate withholding on income
allocated to their Interests.

(d) A Foreign Person who is not described in paragraph 7(a), 7(b) or 7(c) above, and who
will be the beneficial owner of an Interest, should complete and provide Form W-8BEN
or W-8BEN-E.
Please note, pursuant to the requirements of Sections 1471-1474 of the Code (the "FATCA") the
Fund will generally be required to impose a 30% withholding tax on payments made by the Fund
to a Partner that is either a foreign financial institution (an "FFI -') as defined in Section
1471(d)(4) of the Code or a non-financial foreign entity (an "NFFE") as defined in Section
1472(d) of the Code. To avoid this withholding tax, the Fund will require that all Partners

(a) establish with the General Partner, by providing all information that the General Partner may
reasonably request, that they are neither an FFI nor an NFFE, (b) if they are an FFI, establish with
the General Partner that they have entered into, and are maintaining, an FFI Agreement in
compliance with Section 1471(b)(1) of the Code, or are otherwise exempt from the withholding
requirements of Section 1471 of the Code, and (c) if they are an NFFE, certify that they have no
"substantial United States owners," disclose all information that the Fund is required to obtain
pursuant to the FATCA regarding such substantial United States owners or adequately show that
they are otherwise exempt from the withholding requirements of Section 1472 of the Code.
Substantial United States owners are, generally, United States persons with at least a 10% interest
(held directly or indirectly) in the NFFE.
The General Partner will notify the Investor of any additional documentation, certification or
other actions required of the Investor in order to allow the Fund to comply with the FATCA.
Failure to timely provide the required information may result in the Investor's interest in the Fund
being redeemed.

8. Consent to Receive Schedule K-1 Electronically in Accordance with Rev. Proc. 2012-17, I.R.Q.
2012-10 (February 13, 2012). Each Limited Partner consents to the Fund's providing the
Limited Partner's annual Schedule K-ls in electronic format (the "Consent"). This Consent
shall become effective upon a Limited Partner's accessing, via email, its Schedule K-1 in an
electronic format ("Consent Procedure").
TERMS FOR PROVIDING SCHEDULE K-1 ELECTRONICALLY.

(a) Paper Statement. To the extent that a Limited Partner fails to comply with the Consent
Procedure, a paper copy of Schedule K-1 will be provided.

(b) Scope and Duration of Consent. This Consent applies to each Schedule K-1 required to
be furnished after the Consent Procedure is followed unless and until a formal request to
withdraw the Consent is received by the General Partner.

(c) Post -Consent Request for a Paper Statement. A Limited Partner may request a
paper copy of Schedule K-1 by sending an email to Valar Global Fund III LP at
. This will not be treated as a withdrawal of the Consent.
109191599 v3 14

(d) Withdrawal of Consent.
(i) A Limited Partner may withdraw the Consent by writing (electronically or on
paper) to:
Velar Global Fund III LP
Attn: Reuben Kobulnik
or by email to Reuben Kobulnik at

(ii) The withdrawal of Consent will be effective either on the date it is received or on
a subsequent date determined and communicated to the Limited Partner within a
reasonable period of time after the receipt of the withdrawal.
(iii) The General Partner will confirm the withdrawal of Consent and the date on
which it takes effect in writing (either electronically or on paper).

(iv) A withdrawal of the Consent does not apply to a Schedule K-I that was finished
electronically before the date on which the withdrawal of consent takes effect.

(e) Notice of Termination. This Consent will terminate upon a Limited Partner's
withdrawal from the Fund or upon a dissolution or termination of the fund.

(f) Updating Information. Each Limited Partner must inform the General Partner of any
updated contact information for it, including email address, mailing address and phone
number, as soon as possible by sending an email to Reuben Kobulnik at
The General Partner will send an email to inform each Limited
Partner of any change in the General Partner's contact information using the email
address on file for the Limited Partner.

(g) Hardware and Software Requirements. Access to the intemet and Adobe Reader® is
required to access, print and retain the Schedule K-1. The Schedule K-1 may be required
to be printed and attached to a federal, state, or local income tax return. The Schedule K-
1 (or amended Schedule K-1) will be retained by the Fund until the dissolution or
termination of the Fund and is available upon request.

9. Survival of Agreements, Representations and Warranties. All agreements, representations
and warranties contained herein or made in writing by or on behalf of the Investor, the Fund or
the General Partner in connection with the transactions contemplated by this Agreement shall
survive the execution of this Agreement and the Partnership Agreement, any investigation at any
time made by the Investor, the Fund or the General Partner or on behalf of any of them and the
sale and purchase of the Interest and payment therefor and the dissolution and termination of the
Fund.

10. Legends. The Investor consents to the placement of the legends contained on the signature page
of the Partnership Agreement and on page 1 of this Agreement and any other legend required or
reasonably advisable, as determined by Fund Counsel, by applicable law.
109191599 v3 15

11. Counterparts, Execution and Delivery. This Agreement may be executed in two or more
counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original but all of which together shall constitute
one and the same instrument. A facsimile or other reproduction of this Agreement may be
executed by the Investor and/or the General Partner, and an executed copy of this Agreement may
be delivered by the Investor and/or the General Partner by facsimile or similar electronic
transmission device pursuant to which the signature(s) and questionnaire responses can be seen,
and such execution and delivery shall be considered valid, binding and effective for all purposes.
At the request of any party hereto, the Investor and the General Partner agree to execute an
original of this Agreement as well as any facsimile or other reproduction hereof

12. Amendments. Neither this Agreement nor any term hereof may be changed, waived, discharged
or terminated orally, but only with the written consent of the Investor and the General Partner.

13. Assignment. This Agreement is not transferable or assignable by the Investor.
14. Power of Attorney. The Investor hereby designates, constitutes and appoints the General Partner
as the Investor's true and lawful representative and attorney -in-fact, in the Investor's name, place
and stead with full power and authority to act in the Investor's name and on the Investor's behalf
with respect to the execution and delivery of the Partnership Agreement in the form of such
Partnership Agreement provided to the Investor, as well as any amendment, restatement or other
future modification thereto approved by the Investor, with full power and authority to do and
perform each and every act and thing whatsoever required and necessary to be done in and about
the foregoing as the Investor might or could do if personally present, and the Investor hereby
ratifies and confirms all that each said attorney shall lawfully do or cause to be done by virtue of
this power of attorney. The execution of this power of attorney is not intended to, and does not,
revoke any prior powers of attorney executed by the Investor. This power of attorney is not
intended to, and shall not, be revoked by any subsequent power of attorney the Investor may
execute. This power of attorney shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the
internal laws of the State of Delaware.

15. Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the
laws of the State of Delaware in all respects as such laws are applied to agreements among
Delaware residents entered into and performed entirely within Delaware, without giving effect to
conflict of law principles thereof.
[REMAINDER OF PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK]
109191599 v3 16
PART II - TO BE COMPLETED BY INDIVIDUAL /
JOINT -INDIVIDUALS ONLY

16. Investor's Representations. In connection with the Investor's purchase of the Interest, the Investor makes
the following representation on which the General Partner, the Fund and Fund Counsel are entitled to rely:

(a) The Interest will be held under the following type of ownership [Please check the applicable box.]:
❑ Individual
❑ Joint Individuals [This includes any person acquiring an interest with his or her spouse in
a joint capacity, as community property or similar shared interest.]
❑ Individual Retirement Account (e.g. IRA, SEP or Keogh Plan)
If the "Individual Retirement Account" box is checked in this paragraph 1, please contact Fund
Counsel.

17. Accredited Investor Representation. The Investor makes the following representation regarding the
Investor's status as an "accredited investor" (within the meaning of Rule 501 under the Securities Act).
❑ (a) The Investor has a net worth 10, either individually or upon a joint basis with the Investor's
spouse, of at least $1,000,000, or has had individual income in excess of $200,000 for each
of the two most recent years, or joint income with the Investor's spouse in excess of
$300,000 in each of those years, and has a reasonable expectation of reaching the same
income level in the current year.
❑ (b) The Investor cannot make the representation set forth in the clause above.

18. Qualified Purchaser Representation. The Investor makes the following representation regarding the
Investor's status as a "qualified purchaser" (within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51) under the United States
Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the "Companies Act"))."
❑ (a) The Investor is an individual (including any person who is acquiring the Interest with his
or her spouse in a joint capacity, as community property or similar shared interest)
who either individually or together with the Investor's spouse, owns Investments that are
Valued at not less than $5,000,000, or is an individual that shall acquire the Interest as a
gift or bequest or pursuant to an agreement relating to a legal separation or divorce.
❑ (b) The Investor cannot make the representations set forth in the clause above.
10 The meaning of "net worth" (for purposes of determining whether the Investor is an "accredited investor") means the 
excess
of total assets at fair market value over total liabilities. For purposes of this calculation,

(a) the amount of the Investor's total assets shall exclude the fair market value of the Investor's primary residence, 
and

(b) the amount of the Investor's total liabilities shall include the amount of such the Investor's mortgage and other
indebtedness that is secured by the Investor's primary residence which

(i) exceeds the fair market value of the Investor's primary residence at the time of the Investor's admission to
the Fund, or

(ii) has been incurred by the Investor within the 60 day period prior to the Investor's admission to the Fund and
remains outstanding on the date of the Investor's admission to the Fund (unless such indebtedness was incurred as a 
result of
the acquisition of the Investor's primary residence).
If, at the time of the Investor's admission to the Fund, the Investor has mortgage and other indebtedness that is
described in both of subparagraphs (i) and (ii) above, then both amounts of indebtedness shall be included in the 
calculation of
the Investor's total liabilities. it For purposes of this paragraph 3, "Investments" and "Valued" shall have the 
meanings provided in EXHIBIT A hereto.
109191599 v3
Individual Investors who have agreed to and completed Part I and completed Part II of this Agreement may
skip Parts III, IV and V. Please (i) complete Part VI of this Agreement, (ii) complete and execute the signature
page to this Agreement, and (iii) complete and sign IRS Form W-9 or the applicable Form W-8.
109191599 v3
PART III - TO BE COMPLETED BY INVESTORS WHO QUALIFY AS
IRREVOCABLE OR REVOCABLE TRUSTS ONLY
Pension trusts and other similar entities should complete Part V. Individual Retirement Accounts and
similar entities should complete Pan IV.

19. Investor's Representations. In connection with the Investor's purchase of the Interest, the Investor makes
the following representation on which the General Partner, the Fund and Fund Counsel are entitled to rely:

(a) The Interest will be held under the following type of ownership [Please check the applicable box.]:
❑ Revocable Trust with grantor(s) [Please fill in the number of grantors.]
❑ Irrevocable Trust

20. Accredited Investor Representation:
(a) For Irrevocable Trusts: The Investor makes one of the following representations regarding the
Investor's status as an "accredited investor" (within the meaning of Rule 501 under the Securities
Act), and has checked the applicable representation [Please check the applicable representation.]:
❑ (i) The Investor is an irrevocable trust with total assets in excess of $5,000,000
whose purchase is directed by a person with such knowledge and experience in
financial and business matters that such person is capable of evaluating the merits
and risks of the prospective investment.
❑ (ii) The Investor cannot make the representation set forth in the clause above.

(b) For Revocable Trusts: The Investor makes the following representation regarding the Investor's
status as an "accredited investor" (within the meaning of Rule 501 under the Securities Act), and
has checked the applicable representation:
❑ (i) The Investor is a revocable trust in which all of the grantors and trustees qualify
under clause (a) in paragraph 2 of Part II (i.e., an accredited individual); OR
under clause (aXi) of this paragraph 2 of Part III (i.e., an accredited irrevocable
trust); OR under paragraph 2(i) of Part IV (i.e., an accredited IRA); OR under
clause (a), (b), (c), or (d) in paragraph 2 of Part V (i.e., an accredited entity);
OR under this clause (bXi). [If the Investor belongs to this investor category
only, please provide the names of the grantors and trustees of the Investor
and the investor category (e.g., 2(a) of Part II) which each such grantor
and trustee satisfies.)
Names of Grantors or Trustees Investor Category
❑ (ii) The Investor cannot make the representation set forth in the clause above.

21. Qualified Purchaser Representation (Part I). The Investor makes the following representation regarding
the Investor's status as a "qualified purchase?' (within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51) under the United
109191599 v3
States Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the "Companies Act')) [Please check the applicable
representation.]: 12
❑ (a) The Investor is a trust that either CO owns Investments that are Valued at not less than
5,000,000 and is owned directly or indirectly by two (2) or more natural persons related as
siblings, spouses (including former spouses) or direct lineal descendants by birth or
adoption, spouses of such persons, the estates of such persons, or foundations, charitable
organizations or trusts established by or for the benefit of such persons; or (ii) shall acquire
the Interest as a gift or bequest or pursuant to an agreement relating to a legal separation or
divorce.
❑ (b) The Investor is a trust not covered by clause (a) above and not formed for the specific
purpose of acquiring the Interest, as to which the trustee or other person authorized to
make decisions with respect to the trust and each settler or other person who has
contributed assets to the trust is a person described in clause (a) in paragraph 3 of Part II
(i.e., a qualified purchaser individual); OR under clause (a) in this paragraph 3 of Part III
(i.e., a qualified purchaser trust); OR under clause (i) in paragraph 3 of Part IV (i.e., a
qualified purchaser IRA); OR under clause (a), (b), (c) (d) or (e) in paragraph 3 of Part V
(i.e., a qualified purchaser entity).
❑ (c) The Investor cannot make any of the representations set forth in clauses (a) or (b) above.

22. Qualified Purchaser Representation (Part II). If the Investor has made one of the representations set
forth in clauses (a) or (b) of paragraph 3 above, the Investor then makes one or more of the following
representations regarding its status as a "qualified purchaser" (within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51)
under the Companies Act) [Please check the applicable representation.]:

(a) The Investor would be treated as an "investment company" under the Companies Act but for the
fact that the Investor qualifies for one of the exemptions from the definition of "investment
company" provided for in Sections 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act.11
❑ (i) True [Please answer clause (b) below.]
❑ (ii) False [Please skip to paragraph 5 below.]

(b) If the Investor has checked "true" in clause (a) of this paragraph 4 above, the Investor certifies that
the Investor has read and understands the provisions of Section 2(a)(51XC) of the Companies Act
and Rule 2a51-2 promulgated under the Companies Act excerpted on EXHIBIT A hereto and makes
one of the following representations [Please check the applicable representation.]:
❑ (i) No consent of the Investor's direct or indirect beneficial owners is required for the
Investor's treatment as a "qualified purchaser" (within the meaning of Section
2(aX51) under the Companies Act) with respect to the Fund;
❑ (ii) Both of the following are true (NOTE — Answer required only if Investor
was formed on or before April 30. 1996):

(A) all of the beneficial owners of the Investor's outstanding securities, as
determined in accordance with Section 3(c)(1)(A) of the Companies Act, that
acquired such securities on or before April 30, 1996 have consented to the
12 For purposes of this paragraph 3, "Investments" and "Valued" shall have the meanings provided in EXHIBIT A hereto.
13 Relevant excerpts of Section 3(c)(1) and 3(cX7) of the Companies Act are provided in EXHIBIT A attached hereto.
109191599 v3
Investor's treatment as a "qualified purchaser." under the Companies Act with
respect to the Fund; and

(B) each direct and indirect owner of Investor who:
(i) acquired its interest in Investor on or before April 30, 1996; and
(ii)would be an "investment company" under the Companies Act but for
the exclusions from the definition of "investment company" provided for
in Sections 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act,
has consented to treatment of the Investor as a "qualified purchaser" under the
Companies Act with respect to the Fund.
❑ (iii) The Investor made either of the representations set forth in either clause (a)
or clause (b) of paragraph 3 above, and all of the trustees of the Investor have
consented to the Investor's treatment as a "qualified purchaser" (within the
meaning of Section 2(a)(51) under the Companies Act) with respect to the Fund; or
❑ (iv) The Investor cannot make any of the representations set forth in clauses (i), (ii),
or (iii) above.

23. Exempted Investment Company. Please check the applicable representation:
❑ (a) The Investor is not an "investment company" under the Companies Act nor does the
Investor rely upon the exclusions from the definition of "investment company" provided
for in Section 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act; or
❑ (b) (i) The Investor is an "investment company" as defined in Section 3(a) of the
Companies Act but is excepted from such definition of "investment company"
solely by virtue of either Section 3(c)(1) of the Companies Act or Section 3(c)(7)
of the Companies Act.

(ii) If the Investor checked the representation set forth in the preceding paragraph
5(b)(i), the Investor and any existing or prospective Limited Partners of the Fund
that control, are controlled by, or are under common control with the Investor
(such other Limited Partners referred to as "Affiliated Investors") will collectively,
as of the Closing, have  or fewer beneficial owners of their outstanding
securities (other than short-term paper). The Investor further represents and
warrants that neither Investor nor any Affiliated Investor has been structured or
operated for the purpose of circumventing the registration requirements of the
Companies Act. [Please fill in the blank above specifying the number of
beneficial owners.]

24. Investment Representation. Please check the appropriate true or false response to each of the following
statements.
❑ True ❑ False The Investor was not organized for the purpose of acquiring the Interest.
❑ True ❑ False To the best of the Investor's knowledge, the Investor does not control,
nor is it controlled by, or under common control with, any other Limited
Partner of the Fund. [If this box is checked False, please identify the
entity] :
109191599 v3
❑ True ❑ False
❑ True ❑ False
❑ Time
The Investor has made investments prior to the date hereof or intends to
make investments in the near future and each beneficial owner of interests
in the Investor has and will share in the same proportion of each such
investment.
The Investor's investment in the Fund will not constitute more than forty
percent (40%) of the Investor's assets (including for this purpose any
committed capital for an Investor that is an investment fund).
❑ False The governing documents of the Investor require that each
beneficial owner of the Investor, including, but not limited to,
shareholders, partners and beneficiaries, participate through such
beneficial owner's interest in the Investor in all of the Investor's
investments and that the profits and losses from each such investment are
shared among such beneficial owners in the same proportions as all other
investments of the Investor. No such beneficial owner may vary such
beneficial owner's share of the profits and losses or the amount of such
beneficial owner's contribution for any investment made by the Investor.
If the "False" box is checked for any of the above statements in this paragraph 6, please provide a
brief explanation and contact Fund Counsel.

25. Benefit Plan Representation. Please check the appropriate true or false response to each of the following
statements. The Investor understands that the Fund, Fund Counsel and the General Partner are relying upon
the Investor's response within this paragraph 7 in determining fiduciary responsibilities under ERISA and
related rules and regulations.
❑ True ❑ False (i) The Investor is an "employee benefit plan" as defined in Section 3(3) of
ERISA, that is subject to the provisions of Part 4 of Title I of ERISA.
❑ True ❑ False (ii) The Investor is a"plan" (as defined in Section 4975(e)(1) of the Code),
whether or not subject to Section 4975 of the Code (including, without
limitation, individual retirement accounts and Keogh plans).
❑ True ❑ False (iii) The Investor is an entity that is deemed to be a "benefit plan investor"
under the U.S. Department of Labor final plan assets regulation, 29 C.F.R.
§2510.3-101, as it may be amended from time to time (the "Regulation"),
as modified by Section 3(42) of ERISA, because its underlying assets
include "plan assets" by reason of a plan's investment in the entity
(including, by way of example only, a partnership not qualifying as an
operating company within the meaning of the Regulation or other entity:

(A) in which twenty-five percent (25%) or more of each class of equity
interests is owned by one or more "employee benefit plans" or "plans"
described in clause (i) or (ii) above or by one or more other entities
described in this clause (iii), applying for this purpose the proportional
ownership rule set forth in the final sentence of Section 3(42) of ERISA,
and (B) that does not qualify as a "venture capital operating company" or
"real estate operating company" under the Regulation).
If the Investor is deemed a "benefit plan investor" only because of clause
(iii) above, the Investor hereby certifies that  % of the total
value of equity interests in the Investor is held by "benefit plan investors."
109191599 v3
If any of the above responses in this paragraph 7 becomes inaccurate at any time, including any time
following the closing, the Investor or the Investor's counsel should notify the General Partner or
contact Fund Counsel.

26. Tax and Grantor Trust Representations. The Investor makes the following representations regarding the
Investor's status:

(a) Is the Investor a "United States person" 14 for U.S. federal income tax purposes?
Yes:
No:
O
O
(b) (i) Is the Investor a trust and is a grantor or other person treated as the owner of any portion of
such trust under subpart E of subchapter J of the Code (any such trust, a "grantor
trust")(i.e., does the person who created the trust report the income of the trust on
his/her/its personal income tax return?)
Yes: O
No: O [Please skip to paragraph 8 below.]

(ii) If the Investor is a grantor trust, the following persons own the following percentage of
such trust:
Owner:  Percentage Ownership:
Owner:  Percentage Ownership:
Owner:  Percentage Ownership:
Owner:  Percentage Ownership:
Owner:  Percentage Ownership:
[Please submit the appropriate Form W4 or Form W-9 for each of the Owners listed
above.]
(iii) If the Investor is a grantor trust and is not a "United States person" for U.S. federal income
tax purposes, the Investor is submitting Form W-8IMY, and such documentation (e.g.,
Form W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E, W-8IMY, W-8ECI, W-8EXP or W-9) and information
pertaining to each grantor or other owner listed in item (b)(ii) above that permits the
Fund to reliably associate each such grantor's or other owner's indirect share of the Fund's
income with such grantor or other person.
Yes: O
No: O
N/A: O [The Investor is a "United States person"]

(iv) If the Investor is a grantor trust and is a "United States person" for U.S. federal income tax
purposes, the Investor is submitting such documentation (e.g., Form W-8BEN,
W-8BEN-E, W-8IMY, W-8ECI, W-8EXP or W-9) and information pertaining to each
grantor or other owner listed in item (b)(ii) above that permits the Fund to reliably
14 For purposes of this paragraph 10, "United Stores person- shall have the meaning provided in ExtuBrr A hereto.
23 109191599 v3
associate each such grantor's or other owner's indirect share of the Fund's income with
such grantor or other person.
Yes: ❑
No: ❑
N/A: ❑ [The Investor is a "United States person"]
27. Public Disclosure Obligations. Please check the appropriate true or false response to each of the
following statements and, if applicable, provide the appropriate information in each such statement.
❑ True ❑ False (a) The Investor is subject to Section 552(a) of Title 5, United States
Code (commonly known as the "Freedom of Information Act") or state
freedom of information statutes or other similar federal, state, county or
municipal public disclosure statutes or regulations, whether foreign or
domestic, in each of the following jurisdictions. [If a similar statute is
applicable, please specify the applicable statute along with the applicable
jurisdiction, to the extent brown]:
❑ True ❑ False (b) The Investor is required, by statute, regulation, contract or
otherwise, to disclose any of the Fund's Confidential Information to a
government agency or other regulatory body, trading exchange, or other
market where interests in such Investor are sold or traded (or to the
regulating body thereof), whether foreign or domestic, including but not
limited to by virtue of Investor's registration under the Securities Act or
the Companies Act, or a state, local or foreign equivalent thereof. [If
applicable, please specify the applicable statute or regulation along with
the applicable jurisdiction]:
❑ True ❑ False (c) The Investor or its Affiliate is required, or will likely be required,
to disclose Confidential Information to a government body, agency or
committee, whether foreign or domestic, by virtue of such Investor's (or
its Affiliate's) current or proposed involvement in government office.
❑ True ❑ False (d) One or more of the Investor's beneficial owners is subject (or is an
agent, nominee, fiduciary, custodian or trustee of an entity which is
subject) to the statutes, regulations, or obligations described in paragraphs
9(a), (b) or (c) above (collectively "Disclosure Obligations") [If
applicable, please specify the applicable statute or regulation along with
the applicable jurisdiction]:
❑ True ❑ False (e) To the best of the Investor's knowledge, neither the Investor nor
any of the Investor's beneficial owners are subject to Disclosure
Obligations, nor are any of them agents, nominees, fiduciaries, custodians
or trustees of an entity which is itself subject to Disclosure Obligations.
109191599 v3
Trust Investors who have agreed to and completed Pan I and completed Pan III of this Agreement may skip
Parts II, IV and V. Please (i) complete Pan VI of this Agreement, (ii) complete and execute the signature page
to this Agreement, and (iii) complete and sign IRS Form W-9 or the applicable Form W-8.
109191599.3
PART IV - TO BE COMPLETED BY INVESTORS WHO QUALIFY AS
INVESTMENT RETIREMENT ACCOUNT HOLDERS ONLY

28. Investor's Representations. In connection with the Investor's purchase of the Interest, the Investor
represents that the Interest will be held by an IRA / Keogh / SEP (collectively, "IRA") (IRA Investors must
have the IRA custodian/trustee sign this Agreement on behalf of the IRA). The Interest will be held under
the following type of ownership:
a
a
a
IRA
Keogh
SEP

29. Accredited Investor Representation. The Investor makes one of the following representations regarding
the Investor's status as an "accredited investor" (within the meaning of Rule 501 promulgated under the
Securities Act), and has checked the applicable box:
❑ The Investor is an IRA account in which all of the beneficiaries are individuals,
who have a net worth 15 either individually or upon a joint basis with the Investor's
spouse, of at least $1,000,000, or has had an individual income in excess of
$200,000 for each of the two most recent years, or a joint income with the
Investor's spouse in excess of $300,000 in each of those years, and has a
reasonable expectation of reaching the same income level in the current year. List
the beneficiaries of the Investor:
IRA Beneficiaries
O (ii) The Investor cannot make the representation set forth in clause (i) above

30. Qualified Purchaser Representation. The Investor makes one of the following representations regarding
the Investor's status as a "qualified purchaser" within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51) under the United
States Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended (the "Companies Act"), and has checked the
applicable representation:' 6
ts The meaning of "net worth" (for purposes of determining whether the Investor is an "accredited investor") means the 
excess
of total assets at fair market value over total liabilities. For purposes of this calculation,

(a) the amount of the Investor's total assets shall exclude the fair market value of the Investor's primary residence, 
and

(b) the amount of the Investor's total liabilities shall include the amount of such the Investor's mortgage and other
indebtedness that is secured by the Investor's primary residence which

(i) exceeds the fair market value of the Investor's primary residence at the time of the Investor's admission to
the Fund, or

(ii) has been incurred by the Investor within the 60 day period prior to the Investor's admission to the Fund and
remains outstanding on the date of the Investor's admission to the Fund (unless such indebtedness was incurred as a 
result of
the acquisition of the Investor's primary residence).
If, at the time of the Investor's admission to the Fund, the Investor has mortgage and other indebtedness that is
described in both of subparagraphs (i) and (ii) above, then both amounts of indebtedness shall be included in the 
calculation of
the Investor's total liabilities. 16 For purposes of this paragraph 3, "Investments" and "Valued" shall have the 
meanings provided in EXHIBIT A hereto.
109191599 v3
❑ (i) The Investor is an IRA in which all of the beneficiaries (listed above) either
individually or together with their spouse own Investments that are Valued at
not less than $5,000,000.
❑ (ii) The Investor cannot make the representation set forth in clause (i) above.

31. Custodian Information. Set forth below is the name, address and account title of the Investor on the
books and records of the custodian/trustee of the IRA.
❑ The Investor does La have a custodian/trustee.
❑ The Investor has a custodian/trustee.
The name of the custodian/trustee is:
The address of the custodian/trustee is:
The title of the Investor's account on the books and records of the custodian/trustee is:
IRA Investors who have agreed to and completed Part I and completed Part IV of this Agreement may skip
Parts II, III and V. Please (i) complete Part VI of this Agreement, (ii) have the IRA custodian/trustee
complete and execute the signature page to this Agreement on behalf of the IRA, and (iii) complete and sign
IRS Form W-9 or the applicable Form W-8.
1(191915 4)9 v3
PART V - TO BE COMPLETED BY ENTITY INVESTORS ONLY

32. Investor's Representations. In connection with the Investor's purchase of the Interest, the Investor makes
the following representation on which the General Partner, the Fund and Fund Counsel are entitled to rely:

(a) The Interest will be held under the following type of ownership [Please check the applicable box.]:
Private Tax-Exempt Foundation
Tax-Exempt Endowment
Limited Partnership
General Partnership
C Corporation
S Corporation
Limited Liability Company
Other (Please describe:
33. Accredited Investor Representation. The Investor makes one of the following representations regarding
the Investor's status as an "accredited investor" (within the meaning of Rule 501 under the Securities Act),
and has checked the applicable representation [Please check the applicable representation.]:
❑ (a) The Investor is a corporation, partnership, limited liability company or business trust, not
formed for the purpose of acquiring the Interest, or an organization described in Section
501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended (the "Code"), in each case
with total assets in excess of $5,000,000.
❑ (b) The Investor is a bank, insurance company, investment company registered under
the Companies Act, a broker or dealer registered pursuant to Section 15 of the United
States Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended, a business development company, a
Small Business Investment Company licensed by the United States Small Business
Administration, a plan with total assets in excess of $5,000,000 established and
maintained by a state for the benefit of its employees, or a private business development
company as defined in Section 202(a)(22) of the United States Investment Advisers
Act of 1940, as amended.
❑ (c) The Investor is an employee benefit plan and either all investment decisions are made by a
bank, savings and loan association, insurance company, or registered investment advisor,
or the Investor has total assets in excess of $5,000,000 or, if such plan is a self-directed
plan, investment decisions are made solely by persons who are accredited investors.
❑ (d) The Investor is an entity in which all of the equity owners qualify under clause (a) in
paragraph 2 of Part II (i.e., an accredited individual); OR under clause (aXi) of paragraph 2
of Part III (i.e., an accredited irrevocable trust); OR under paragraph 2(i) of Part IV (i.e., an
accredited IRA); OR under clause (a), (b), (c) of this paragraph 2 of Part V (i.e., an
accredited entity); OR under this clause (d) of this paragraph 2 of Part V. [If the Investor
belongs to this investor category only, please provide the name of the equity owners of
the Investor and the investor category (e.g., 2(a) of Part V) which each such equity
owner satisfies.]
Name of Equity Owners Investor Category
109191599 v3
❑ (e) The Investor cannot make any of the representations set forth in clauses (a), (b), (c) or (d)
above.

34. Qualified Purchaser Representation (Part I). The Investor makes one of the following representations
regarding the Investor's status as a "qualified purchaser" (within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51) under the
Companies Act) [Please check the applicable representation.]: 17
❑ (a) The Investor is an entity, acting for its own account or the accounts of others described
in clause (a) in paragraph 3 of Part II (i.e., a qualified purchaser individual); OR in clause

(a) or (b) of paragraph 3 of Part III (i.e., a qualified purchaser trust); OR in paragraph 3(i)
of Part IV (i.e., a qualified purchaser IRA); OR in clause (b), (c), (d) or (e) of this
paragraph 3 of Part V below; OR in this clause (a) of paragraph 3 of Part V, that in the
aggregate owns and invests on a discretionary basis Investments that are Valued at not less
than $25,000,000.
❑ (b) The Investor is an entity that either (i) owns Investments that are Valued at not less than
$5,000,000 and is owned directly or indirectly by two (2) or more natural persons related
as siblings, spouses (including former spouses) or direct lineal descendants by birth or
adoption, spouses of such persons, the estates of such persons, or foundations, charitable
organizations or trusts established by or for the benefit of such persons; or (ii) shall acquire
the Interest as a gift or bequest or pursuant to an agreement relating to a legal separation or
divorce.
❑ (c) The Investor is an entity not covered by clause (a) or (b) above and not formed for the
specific purpose of acquiring the Interest, as to which each beneficial owner is a person
described in clause (a) or (b) in paragraph 3 of Part II (i.e., a qualified purchaser
individual); OR in clause (a) in paragraph 3 of Part III (i.e., a qualified purchaser trust); OR
under paragraph 3(i) of Part IV above (i.e., a qualified purchaser IRA); OR under clause (a)
or (b) in this paragraph 3 of this Part V.
❑ (d) The Investor is an entity, all of the outstanding securities of which are owned by persons
or entities described in clause (a) in paragraph 3 of Part II (i.e., a qualified purchaser
individual); OR in clause (a) or (b) of paragraph 3 of Part III (i.e., a qualified purchaser
trust); OR in paragraph 3 of Part IV (i.e., a qualified purchaser IRA); OR under clause (a),

(b) or (c) of this paragraph 3 of Part V; OR under this clause (d) of paragraph 3 of Part V.
[If the Investor belongs to this investor category only, please provide the name of the
equity owners of the Investor and the investor category which each such equity owner
satisfies.]
Name of InvestorInvestor Category
❑ (e) The Investor is a "qualified institutional buyer" as defined in paragraph (a) of Rule
I44A under the Securities Act, acting for its own account, the account of another qualified
17 For purposes of this paragraph 3, "Investments" and "Valued" shall have the meanings provided in EXHIBIT A hereto.
109191599 v3
institutional buyer, or the account of a qualified purchaser; provided that (i) a dealer
described in paragraph (a)(1)(ii) of Rule 144A must own and invest on a discretionary
basis at least $25,000,000 in securities of issuers that are not affiliated persons of the dealer
and (ii) a plan referred to in paragraph (a)(1)(i)(D) or (aX1)(iXE) of Rule I44A, or a trust
fund referred to in paragraph (a)(1)(i)(F) of Rule 144A that holds the assets of such a plan,
will not be deemed to be acting for its own account if investment decisions with respect
to the plan are made by the beneficiaries of the plan, except with respect to
investment decisions made solely by the fiduciary, trustee or sponsor of such plan.
The Investor cannot make any of the representations set forth in clauses (a), (b), (c), (d) or

(e) above.
35. Qualified Purchaser Representation (Part II). If the Investor has made one of the representations set
forth in clauses (a) through (e) of paragraph 3 of Part V of this Agreement above, the Investor then makes
one or more of the following representations regarding its status as a "qualified purchase?' (within the
meaning of Section 2(a)(51) under the Companies Act) [Please check the applicable representation.]:

(a) The Investor would be treated as an "investment company" under the Companies Act but for the
fact that the Investor qualifies for one of the exemptions from the definition of "investment
company" provided for in Sections 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act.18
❑ (i) True [Please answer clause (b) below.]
❑ (ii) False [Please skip to paragraph 5 below.]

(b) If the Investor has checked "true" in clause (a) above, the Investor certifies that the Investor has
read and understands the provisions of Section 2(a)(51)(C) of the Companies Act and Rule 2a51-2
promulgated under the Companies Act excerpted on EXHIBIT A hereto and makes one of the
following representations [Please check the applicable representation.]:
❑ No consent of the Investor's direct or indirect beneficial owners is required for the
Investor's treatment as a "qualified purchaser" (within the meaning of Section
2(aX51) under the Companies Act) with respect to the Fund;
❑ (ii) Both of the following are true (NOTE — Answer required only if Investor was
funned on or before April 30j996):

(A) all of the beneficial owners of the Investor's outstanding securities, as
determined in accordance with Section 3(c)(1)(A) of the Companies Act, that
acquired such securities on or before April 30, 1996 have consented to the
Investor's treatment as a "qualified purchase?' under the Companies Act with
respect to the Fund; and

(B) each direct and indirect owner of Investor who:
(i) acquired its interest in Investor on or before April 30, 1996; and

(ii) would be an "investment company" under the Companies Act but for
the exclusions from the definition of "investment company" provided for
in Sections 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act,
16 Relevant excerpts of Section 3(c)(I) and 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act are provided in EXHIBIT A attached hereto.
109191599 v3
has consented to treatment of the Investor as a "qualified purchaser" under the
Companies Act with respect to the Fund.
❑ (iii) The Investor made one of the representations set forth in any of clauses (b) thru (d)
of paragraph 3 above, and all of the trustees, directors or general partners of the
Investor have consented to the Investor's treatment as a "qualified purchaser"
(within the meaning of Section 2(a)(51) under the Companies Act) with respect to
the Fund; or
❑ (iv) The Investor cannot make any of the representations set forth in clauses (i), (ii), or
(iii) above.

36. Exempted Investment Company. Please check the applicable representation:
❑ (a) The Investor is not an "investment company" under the Companies Act nor does the
Investor rely upon the exclusions from the definition of "investment company" provided
for in Section 3(c)(1) or 3(c)(7) of the Companies Act; or
❑ (h) (i) The Investor is an "investment company" as defined in Section 3(a) of the
Companies Act but is excepted from such definition of "investment company"
solely by virtue of either Section 3(c)(1) of the Companies Act or Section 3(c)(7)
of the Companies Act.

(ii) If the Investor checked the representation set forth in the preceding paragraph
5(b)(i), the Investor and any existing or prospective Limited Partners of the Fund
that control, are controlled by, or are under common control with the Investor
(such other Limited Partners referred to as "Affiliated Investors") will collectively,
as of the Closing, have  or fewer beneficial owners of their outstanding
securities (other than short-term paper). The Investor further represents and
warrants that neither Investor nor any Affiliated Investor has been structured or
operated for the purpose of circumventing the registration requirements of the
Companies Act. [Please fi ll in the blank above specifying the number of
beneficial owners.]

37. Investment Representation. Please check the appropriate true or false response to each of the following
statements.
❑ True ❑ False The Investor was not organized for the purpose of acquiring the Interest.
❑ True ❑ False
❑ True ❑ False
To the best of the Investor's knowledge, the Investor does not control, nor
is it controlled by, or under common control with, any other Limited
Partner of the Fund. [If this box is checked False, please identify the
entity]:
The Investor has made investments prior to the date hereof or intends to
make investments in the near future and each beneficial owner of interests
in the Investor has and will share in the same proportion of each such
investment.
109191599 v3
❑ True ❑ False
❑ True ❑ False
The Investor's investment in the Fund will not constitute more than forty
percent (40%) of the Investor's assets (including for this purpose any
committed capital for an Investor that is an investment fund).
The governing documents of the Investor require that each beneficial
owner of the Investor, including, but not limited to, shareholders, partners
and beneficiaries, participate through such beneficial owner's interest in
the Investor in all of the Investor's investments and that the profits and
losses from each such investment are shared among such beneficial owners
in the same proportions as all other investments of the Investor. No such
beneficial owner may vary such beneficial owner's share of the profits and
losses or the amount of such beneficial owner's contribution for any
investment made by the Investor.
Ilf the "False" box is checked for any of the above statements, please provide a brief explanation and
contact Fund Counsel.

38. Benefit Plan Representation. Please check the appropriate true or false response to the following
statement. The Investor understands that the Fund, Fund Counsel and the General Partner are relying upon
the Investor's response within this paragraph 10 in determining fiduciary responsibilities under ERISA and
related rules and regulations.
❑ True ❑ False
❑ True ❑ False
❑ True ❑ False
CO The Investor is an "employee benefit plan" as defined in Section 3(3) of
ERISA, that is subject to the provisions of Part 4 of Title I of ERISA.

(ii) The Investor is a "plan" (as defined in Section 4975(e)(1) of the Code),
whether or not subject to Section 4975 of the Code (including, by way of
example only, an individual retirement account).
(iii) The Investor is an entity that is deemed to be a "benefit plan investor"
under the U.S. Department of Labor final plan assets regulation, 29 C.F.R.
§2510.3-101, as amended (the "Regulation"), as modified by Section
3(42) of ERISA, because its underlying assets include "plan assets" by
reason of a plan's investment in the entity (including, by way of example
only, a partnership or other entity: (A) in which twenty-five percent (25%)
or more of each class of equity interests is owned by one or more
"employee benefit plans" or "plans" described in clause (i) or (ii) above or
by one or more other entities described in this clause (iii), applying for this
purpose the proportional ownership rule set forth in the final sentence of

Section 3(42) of ERISA, and (B) that does not qualify as a "venture capital
operating company" or "real estate operating company" under the
Regulation).
If the Investor is deemed a "benefit plan investor" only because of clause
(iii) above, the Investor hereby certifies that % of the total
value of equity interests in the Investor is held by "benefit plan investors."
If any of the above responses becomes inaccurate at any time, including any time following the closing,
the Investor or the Investor's counsel should notify the General Partner or contact Fund Counsel.

39. Tax Representations. The Investor makes the following representations regarding the Investor's status:

(a) Is the Investor treated as a partnership or a disregarded entity for U.S. federal income tax purposes?
Yes: ❑
No: ❑

(b) Is the Investor a "United States personi 19 for U.S. federal income tax purposes?
Yes: ❑ [Please answer clause (c) below.]
No: ❑ [Please answer clause (d) below.]

(c) If the Investor is a "United States person" for U.S. federal income tax purposes and is an entity that
is treated as a partnership or disregarded entity, then the Investor is submitting such documentation
(e.g., W-9 or an applicable W-8) that permits the Fund to reliably associate each of the entity's
owners' indirect share of the Fund's income with such owners.
Yes: ❑
No: ❑
N/A: ❑

(d) (i) If the Investor is not a "United States person" for U.S. federal income tax purposes, but is
treated as a partnership for U.S. federal income tax purposes, the following persons own
the following percentage of the Investor:
Owner:  Percentage Ownership:
Owner:  Percentage Ownership:
Owner:  Percentage Ownership:
[attach additional pages if necessary]

(ii) The Investor is submitting Form W-8IMY, and such documentation (e.g. Form W-8BEN,
W-8BEN-E, W-8IMY, W-8ECI, W-8EXP or W-9) and information pertaining to each
partner or other owner listed in item (d)(i) above that permits the Fund to reliably
associate each such partner's or other owner's indirect share of the Fund's income with
such partner or other person.
Yes: ❑
No: ❑
N/A: ❑
40. Public Disclosure Obligations. Please check the appropriate true or false response to each of the
following statements and, if applicable, provide the appropriate information in each such statement.
19 For purposes of this paragraph 10, "United States person" shall have the meaning provided in EXHIBIT A hereto.
109191599 v3
❑ True ❑ False (a) The Investor is subject to Section 552(a) of Title 5, United States
Code (commonly known as the "Freedom of Information Act") or state
freedom of information statutes or other similar federal, state, county or
municipal public disclosure statutes or regulations, whether foreign or
domestic, in each of the following jurisdictions. [If a similar statute is
applicable, please specify the applicable statute along with the applicable
jurisdiction, to the extent known].
❑ True ❑ False (b) The Investor is required, by statute, regulation, contract or
otherwise, to disclose any of the Fund's Confidential Information to a
government agency or other regulatory body, trading exchange, or other
market where interests in such Investor are sold or traded (or to the
regulating body thereof), whether foreign or domestic, including but not
limited to by virtue of Investor's registration under the Securities Act or
the Companies Act, or a state, local or foreign equivalent thereof. [If
applicable, please specify the applicable statute or regulation along with
the applicable jurisdiction]:
❑ True ❑ False (c) The Investor or its Affiliate is required, or will likely be required,
to disclose Confidential Information to a government body, agency or
committee, whether foreign or domestic, by virtue of such Investor's (or
its Affiliate's) current or proposed involvement in government office.
❑ True ❑ False (d) One or more of the Investor's beneficial owners is subject (or is an
agent, nominee, fiduciary, custodian or trustee of an entity which is
subject) to the statutes, regulations, or obligations described in paragraphs
9(a), (b) or (c) above (collectively "Disclosure Obligations") [If
applicable, please specify the applicable statute or regulation along with
the applicable jurisdiction]:
❑ True ❑ False (e) To the best of the Investor's knowledge, neither the Investor nor
any of the Investor's beneficial owners are subject to Disclosure
Obligations, nor are any of them agents, nominees, fiduciaries, custodians
or trustees of an entity which is itself subject to Disclosure Obligations.
Entity Investors who have agreed to and completed Part I and completed Part V of this Agreement may skip
Parts II, III and IV. Please (i) complete Part VI of this Agreement, (ii) complete and execute the signature page
to this Agreement, and (iii) complete and sign IRS Form W-9 or the applicable Form W-8.
109191599 I. 3
MI PART VI - TO BE COMPLETED BY ALL INVESTORS

1. Anti -Money Laundering. To comply with applicable anti-money laundering/U.S. Treasury Department
Office of Foreign Assets Control ("OFAC') rules and regulations, the Investor is required to provide the following
information as well as any other information requested by the General Partner:
Payment Information

(a) Name and address (including country) of the bank from which the Investor's payment to the Fund
is being wired (the "Wiring Bank"):
Name:
Address:
Phone:
Fax:

(b) The Investor's wire instructions at the Wiring Bank:
(c) Is the Wiring Bank located in the U.S. or another "FATF Country"?
Yes No
If yes, please answer question (d) below.
If no, please provide the information described in SCHEDULE C below.
(d) Is Subscriber a customer of the Wiring Bank?
Yes No
If no, please provide the information described in SCHEDULE C below.
As of the date hereof, countries that are members of the Financial Action Task Force on Money Laundering
("FATF Country") are: Argentina, Australia, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, China, Denmark, European
Commission, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Gulf Co-operation Council, Hong Kong, Iceland, India,
Ireland, Italy, Japan, Luxembourg, Mexico, Kingdom of the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal,
Republic of Korea, Russian Federation, Singapore, South Africa, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey,
United Kingdom and the United States.
[SIGNATURE PAGE FOLLOWS]
109191599 v3
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have executed this SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND
INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE as of the dates written below.
INDIVIDUAL INVESTOR: ENTITY INVESTOR:
(Signature) (Legal Name of Entity)
By:
Name:
Date:  Title:
Date:
(Print Name)
If an IRA, Please also Provide:
Name of Custodian:
Authorized Signatory of Custodian:
Address of Custodian:
Title of Investor account on hooks and records of Custodian:
CAPITAL COMMITMENT: $
SUBSCRIPTION ACCEPTED:
Accepted this day of
GENERAL PARTNER:
,201
VALAR VENTURES GP III LLC
By:
Name:
Title: Managing Member
FUND:
VALAR GLOBAL FUND HI LP
By: Valar Ventures GP HI LLC
Its: General Partner
By:
Name:
Title: Managing Member
SUBSCRIPTION AGREEMENT AND INVESTOR QUESTIONNAIRE
SIGNATURE PAGE
Schedule A
Investor Information
Name
Company Name
Title
Mailing Address
City State ZIP Country
Street Address (if different)
City State ZIP Country
Phone
Fax
Email
Taxpayer Identification Number
Place of Formation or Incorporation
Primary Delivery Method: (email/mail/both/none)
Type of Investor
❑ Individual ❑ Trust I Estate ❑ IRA / Keogh / SEP ❑ Community Property
❑ S Corporation ❑ C Corporation ❑ LLC ❑ Exempt Organization
❑ Limited Partnership ❑ General Partnership ❑ Other
Wire Instructions for Distributions
Please provide wire instructions for the transfer of any payments due from the Fund. These instructions must be provided
at
account inception. The Investor may change these wire instructions but may be required to provide an appropriate 
signature
guarantee by a qualified financial institution (note that a signature guarantee is different than a notarized 
signature).
Bank
Location
9-Digit ABA
SWIFT
Attention
Account Number
Account Name
Further Credit
Instructions for Physical Check Delivery
Payee Name
Payee Address
Special Instructions
SCHEDULE A
109191599 v3
Primary Contact
The following individual will receive all correspondence listed below, and is fully authorized to update and change 
ownership
information, provide instructions, and address procedural questions regarding the Interest.
Key Contact Name
Company Name
Title
Mailing Address
City State ZIP
Street Address (if different)
City State ZIP
Phone
Fax
Email
Primary Delivery Method: (email/mail/both)
Relationship to Investor
Other Interested Parties
Name Phone
Title Alt. Phone
Mailing Address Fax
City State ZIP Email
Street Address (if different)   Primary Delivery Method: (email / mail)
City State ZIP Circle as appropriate:
Relationship 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Name Phone
Title Alt. Phone
Mailing Address Fax
City State ZIP Email
Street Address (if different)   Primary Delivery Method: (email / mail)
City State ZIP Circle as appropriate
Relationship 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Name Phone
Title Alt. Phone
Mailing Address Fax
City State ZIP Email
Street Address (if different)   Primary Delivery Method: (email / mail)
City State ZIP Circle as appropriate
Relationship 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Ety.
I = All Information *
4 = Authorization to update contact info.
7 = Capital Call Notices
2 = Reports (Quarterly and Annual) 3 = Tax Reporting **
5 = Authorized to add/remove parties 6 = Fully Authorized *"
* All Information = All Reports, Tax Reporting, General Correspondence, and Transaction Confirmations
** Tax Reporting = Distribution Notices, Audited Financials, K-I 's
*** Fully Authorized = Authorized to update contact info, add/remove parties to the account, and change ownership 
information, such as wiring
instructions, etc.
SCHEDULE A
109191599v3
SCHEDULE B
INVESTOR TYPE REPRESENTATIONS
* TO BE COMPLETED BY ALL INVESTORS *
The Fund from time to time may be required pursuant to the Advisers Act to provide
certain information related to the types of beneficial owners of the Fund to the U.S. Securities
and Exchange Commission (the "SEC). As a result, the Fund is seeking the following
information.
You should check the one category below in Part A that best describes you. You should
also check one box in Part B.

A. You are a(n):
❑ Individual that is a United States person' (or a trust of such person)
❑ Individual that is not a United States person' (or a trust of such person)
❑ Broker-dealer
❑ Insurance company
❑ Investment company registered with the SEC
❑ Private fund2
❑ Non-profit
❑ Pension plan (excluding governmental pension plan)
❑ Banking or thrift institution (proprietary)
❑ State or municipal government entity3 (excluding governmental pension
plan)
❑ State or municipal governmental pension plan
❑ Sovereign wealth fund or foreign official institution
❑ A person or entity that is not a United States person' and about which the
foregoing beneficial ownership information is not known and cannot
reasonably be obtained because the beneficial interest is held through a
chain involving one or more third-party intermediaries
I "United States person" has the meaning provided in rule 203(m)-1 under the Advisers Act, which includes, among
others, any natural person that is resident in the United States.
2 "Private fund" means any issuer that would be an investment company as defined in Section 3 of the U.S.
Investment Company Act of 1940 but for Section 3(c)(I) or 3(c)(7) of that Act
3 "Government entity" means any U.S. state (including any U.S. state, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, the
U.S. Virgin Islands or any other possession of the United States) or political subdivision of a state, including: (i) 
any
agency, authority or instrumentality of the state or political subdivision; (ii) a plan or pool of assets controlled by 
the
state or political subdivision or any agency, authority or instrumentality thereof; and (iii) any officer, agent, or
employee of the state or political subdivision or any agency, authority or instrumentality thereof, acting in his or her
official capacity.
SCHEDULE B
109191599 v3
❑ Other
Specify:
B. The Investor is a fund of funds4 [Please check the applicable box.]:
❑ True
❑ False
INDIVIDUAL INVESTOR: ENTITY INVESTOR:
(Signature) (Legal Name of Entity)
(Print Name)
Date:
By:
Name:
Title:
Date:
4 "Fund of funds" means any private fund (see footnote 2 above) that invests 10% or more of its total assets in other
pooled investment vehicles, whether or not they are also private funds or registered investment companies.
SCHEDULE B
109191599 v3
SCHEDULE C
Additional Information
Note: this section applies only to prospective investors who responded "no" to paragraph 1(c) or 1(d) in
Part VI of the Subscription Agreement and Investor Questionnaire.
The following materials must be provided to the General Partner:
For Individual Investors (or, in the case of an Individual Retirement Account or Keogh Plan, the
beneficial owner)
❑ A government issued form of picture identification (e.g., passport or driver's license).
❑ Proof of the individual's current address (e.g., current utility bill), if not included in the form of
picture identification.
For Entity Investors
❑ A certificate of due formation and organization and continued authorization to conduct business
in the jurisdiction of its organization (e.g., certificate of good standing).
❑ A letter of reference from your local office of a reputable bank or brokerage firm that is
incorporated, or has its principal place of business located, in the U.S. or other FATF Country
certifying that the prospective investor (Le., the fund of funds or the entity investing on behalf of
third parties) maintains an account at such bank/brokerage firm for a length of time and
containing a statement affirming the prospective investor's integrity (a sample letter of reference
is attached hereto as ATTACHMENT I).
❑ Any other information requested by the General Partner to determine the identities of your
beneficial owners or adequacy of any anti-money laundering policies and procedures.
SCHEDULE C
109191599 v3
ATTACHMENT I
FORM LETTER OF REFERENCE
[LETTERHEAD OF LOCAL OFFICE OF FATF MEMBER BANKING INSTITUTION OR
BROKERAGE FIRM]
Valar Global Fund III LP
do Cooley LLP
Attn: Ian O'Donnell
To whom it may concern:
, the of  do hereby certify
Name Title Name of Institution
that has maintained an account at our institution for
Name of Investor
years and, during this period, nothing has occurred that would give our institution
Insert Period
cause to be concerned regarding the integrity of
Name of Investor
Do not hesitate to contact me at if you have any further questions.
Insert Telephone No.
Very truly yours,
Signature
Name:
Title:
ATTAOIMDIT I
109191599 v3
EXHIBIT A
CERTAIN DEFINITIONS & STATUTORY EXCERPTS
"Investments" means any of the following:

(I) "Securities" as such term is defined by Section 2(a)(1) of the Securities Act.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, securities of an issuer that controls, is controlled by, or is
under common control with the Investor shall not be deemed Investments unless the
issuer is:

(i) An investment company or a company that would be an investment company but
for the exclusions provided by Sections 3(c)( I) through 3(c)(9) of the Companies
Act, a foreign bank or insurance company, an issuer of asset-backed securities that
meets certain requirements or a commodity pool;

(ii) A company whose equity securities are listed on a national securities exchange,
traded on Nasdaq or listed on a "designated offshore securities market" (as defined
by Regulation S promulgated pursuant to the Securities Act); or
(iii) A company with shareholders' equity of not less than $50,000,000 (determined in
accordance with generally accepted accounting principles) as reflected on the
company's most recent financial statements (provided such financial statements
present information as of a date not more than sixteen (16) months preceding the
Investor's investment in the Company).

(2) Real estate held for investment purposes (i.e., not used by the undersigned for personal
purposes or as a place of business or in connection with the trade or business of the
undersigned).
"Commodity Interest" (i.e., commodities futures contracts, options on such contracts or
options on commodities that are traded on or subject to the rules of (i) any contract
market designated for trading under the Commodity Exchange Act and rules thereunder
or (ii) any board of trade or exchange outside the United States, as contemplated in Part
30 of the rules under the Commodity Exchange Act) held for investment purposes.

(4) Physical commodities (with respect to which a Commodity Interest is traded on a market
specified in paragraph 3 above) held for investment purposes.
Financial contracts within the meaning of Section 3(c)(2)(BXii) of the Companies Act
held for investment purposes.

(6) If the Investor is a company that would be an investment company but for the exclusion
provided by Section 3(c)(I) or 3(cX7) of the Companies Act, or a commodity pool, any
amounts payable to the Investor pursuant to a binding commitment pursuant to which a
person has agreed to acquire an interest in, or make capital contributions to, the Investor
upon demand by the Investor.
Cash and cash equivalents (including bank deposits, certificates of deposit, bankers
acceptances and similar bank instruments held for investment purposes and the net cash
surrender value of insurance policies).
"United States person" means an individual who is a citizen of the United States or a resident alien for
U.S. federal income tax purposes; a corporation, an entity taxable as a corporation, or a partnership
created or organized in or under the laws of the United States or any state or political subdivision thereof
or therein (including the District of Columbia); an estate, the income of which is subject to U.S. federal
income taxation regardless of its source; or a trust if (y) a court within the United States is able to exercise
(3)
(5)
(7)
Ewllafr A
109191599 v3
primary supervision over its administration and one or more United States persons have the authority to
control all of its substantial decisions or (z) such trust was in existence on August 20, 1996 and was
treated as a domestic trust on August 19, 1996 and such trust has a valid election in effect under
applicable U.S. Treasury regulations to be treated as a United States person.
"Valued" means either the fair market value or cost of Investments net of the following deductions:

(1) the amount of any outstanding indebtedness incurred to acquire such Investments; and
(2) if the holder of the Investment is a company described in paragraph 3(a) of Part III or
paragraph 3(b) of Part V, any outstanding indebtedness incurred by any owner of such
company to acquire such Investments.
SECTION 2(O51)(C) OF THE COMPANIES ACT:
"The term "qualified purchaser" does not include a company that, but for the exceptions provided for in
paragraph (1) or (7) of Section 3(c), would be an investment company (hereafter in this paragraph referred
to as an "excepted investment Company"), unless all beneficial owners of its outstanding securities (other
than short-term paper), determined in accordance with Section 3(c)(1)(A), that acquired such securities on
or before April 30, 1996 (hereafter in this paragraph referred to as "pre-amendment beneficial owners"),
and all pre-amendment beneficial owners of the outstanding securities (other than short-term paper) or any
excepted investment company that, directly or indirectly, owns any outstanding securities of such excepted
investment company, have consented to its treatment as a qualified purchaser. Unanimous consent of all
trustees, directors, or general partners of a company or trust referred to in clause (ii) or (iii) of
subparagraph (A) shall constitute consent for purposes of this subparagraph."
RULE 2A51..2 AS PROMULGATED UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT:
"(a) Beneficial Ownership: General. Except as set forth in this section, for purposes of Sections
2(a)(51XC) and 3(c)(7XB)(ii) of the Act, the beneficial owners of securities of an excepted investment
company...shall be determined in accordance with Section 3(c)(1) of the Act.

(b) Beneficial Ownership: Grandfather Provision. For purposes of Section 3(c)(7)(B)(ii) of the
Act, securities of an issuer beneficially owned by a company (without giving effect to Section 3(c)(1XA)
of the Act ("owning company") shall be deemed to be beneficially owned by one person unless: (1) The
owning company is an investment company or an excepted investment company; (2) The owning
company, directly or indirectly, controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with, the issuer;
and (3) On October 11, 1996, under Section 3(c)(1)(A) of the Act as then in effect, the voting securities of
the issuer were deemed to be beneficially owned by the holders of the owning company's outstanding
securities (other than short-term paper), in which case, such holders shall be deemed to be beneficial
owners of the issuer's outstanding voting securities.

(c) Beneficial Ownership: Consent Provision. For purposes of Section 2(a)(51XC) of the Act,
securities of an excepted investment company beneficially owned by a company (without giving effect to

Section 3(c)(1)(A) of the Act ("owning company") shall be deemed to be beneficially owned by one
person unless: (1) The owning company is an excepted investment company; (2) The owning company
directly or indirectly controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with, the excepted investment
company or the company with respect to which the excepted investment company is, or will be, a
qualified purchaser; and (3) On April 30, 1996, under Section 3(c)(1)(A) of the Act as then in effect, the
voting securities of the excepted investment company were deemed to be beneficially owned by the
holders of the owning company's outstanding securities (other than short-term paper), in which case the
holders of such excepted company's securities shall be deemed to be beneficial owners of the excepted
investment company's outstanding voting securities.
EXHIBIT A
109191599 v3

(d) Indirect Ownership: Consent Provision. For purposes of Section 2(aX51)(C) of the Act, an
excepted investment company shall not be deemed to indirectly own the securities of an excepted
investment company seeking a consent to be treated as a qualified purchaser ("qualified purchaser
company") unless such excepted investment company, directly or indirectly, controls, is controlled by, or
is under common control with, the qualified purchaser company or a company with respect to which the
qualified purchaser company is or will be a qualified purchaser.

(e) Required Consent: Consent Provision. For purposes of Section 2(aX51)(C) of the Act, the
consent of the beneficial owners of an excepted investment company ("owning company") that
beneficially owns securities of an excepted investment company that is seeking the consents required by

Section 2(a)(51)(C) ("consent company") shall not be required unless the owning company directly or
indirectly controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with, the consent company or the
company with respect to which the consent company is, or will be, a qualified purchaser."
SECTION 3(C)(1)(A) OF THE COMPANIES ACT:
"None of the following persons is an investment company ...
( I) Any issuer whose outstanding securities (other than short-term paper) are beneficially
owned by not more than one hundred persons and which is not making and does not
presently propose to make a public offering of its securities ... For purposes of this
paragraph:

(A) Beneficial ownership by a company shall be deemed to be beneficial ownership
by one person, except that, if the company owns 10 per centum or more of the
outstanding voting securities of the issuer and is or, but for the exception
provided for in this paragraph or paragraph (7), would be an investment
company, the beneficial ownership shall be deemed to be that of the holders of
such company's outstanding securities (other than short-term paper)."
SECTION 3(C)(7) OF THE COMPANIES ACT:
"[N]one of the following persons is an investment company ...

(7) (A) Any issuer, the outstanding securities of which are owned exclusively by persons
who, at the time of acquisition of such securities, are qualified purchasers, and
which is not making and does not at the time propose to make a public offering
of such securities. Securities that are owned by persons who received the
securities from a qualified purchaser as a gift or bequest, or in a case in which the
transfer was caused by legal separation, divorce, death, or other involuntary
event, shall be deemed to be owned by a qualified purchaser, subject to such
roles, regulations, and orders as the Commission may prescribe as necessary or
appropriate in the public interest or for the protection of investors."
109191599 v3
EXIIIBIT A
EXHIBIT B
FORM W..9
(WITH INSTRUCTIONS)
EXHIBIT B
109191599 v3
Form W-9 (Rev. August 2013)
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Request for Taxpayer
Identification Number and Certification
Give Form to the
requester. Do not
send to the IRS.
Print or type
See Specific Instructions on page 2.
Name (as shown on your income tax return)
Business name/disregarded entity name. if different from above
Check appropriate box for federal tax classification:
El Individual/sole proprietor El C Corporation El S Corporation . Partnership 0
O United liability company. Enter the tax classification (C=C corporation. S=5 corporation. P=partnership)
El Other (see instructions) li•
Trust/estate
b.
Exemptions
Exempt payee
Exemption
code (if any)
(see instructions):
code Of any)
from FATCA reporting
Address (ntrnber, street. and apt. or suite no.) Requesters name and address (optional)
City, state, and ZIP code
1St account number(s) here (optional)
Part I Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN)
Enter your TIN in the appropriate box. The TIN provided must match the name given on the "Name line
to avoid backup withholding. For individuals, this is your social security nurnber (SSN). However, for a
resident alien. sole proprietor, or disregarded entity, see the Part I instructions on page 3. For other
entities, it is your employer identification number (EIN). If you do not have a number, see How to get a
TIN on page 3.
Note. If the account is in more than one name, see the chart on page 4 for guidelines on whose
number to enter.
Social security number
Employer Identification number
Certification
Under penalties of perjury, I certify that:

1. The number shown on this form is my correct taxpayer identification number (or I am waiting for a number to be issued
to me), and

2. I am not subject to backup withholding because: (a) I am exempt from backup withholding, or (b) I have not been 
notified by the Internal Revenue
Service (IRS) that I am subject to backup withholding as a result of a failure to report all interest or dividends, or 
(c) the IRS has notified me that I am
no longer subject to backup withholding, and

3. I am a U.S. citizen or other U.S. person (defined below). and
4. The FATCA code(s) entered on this form (if any) indicating that I am exempt from FATCA reporting is correct.
Certification Instructions. You must cross out item 2 above if you have been notified by the IRS that you are currently 
subject to backup withholding
because you have failed to report all interest and dividends on your tax return. For real estate transactions. item 2 
does not apply. For mortgage
interest paid, acquisition or abandonment of secured property, cancellation of debt, contributions to an individual 
retirement arrangement (IRA). and
generally, payments other than interest and dividends, you are not required to sign the certification. but you must 
provide your correct TIN. See the
instructions on page 3.
Sign
Here Signature of
U.S. person b. Date.
General Instructions
Section references are to the Internal Revenue Code wins otherwise noted.
Future developments. The IRS has created a page on IRS.gov for information
about Form W-9. at wwwirs.gcv/w9. Information about any future developments
affecting Form W-9 (such as legislation enacted after we release it) will be posted
on that page.
Purpose of Form
A person who is required to file an ., formation return with the IRS must obtan your
correct taxpayer identification camber (TIN) to report. for example. income paid to
you. payments made to you in settlement of payment card and third party network
transactions. real estate transactions, mortgage interest you paid. acquisition or
abandonment of secured property, cancellation of debt. or contributions you made
to an IRA.
Use Form W-9 only if you are a U.S. person (ncluding a resident alien), to
provide your correct TIN to the person requesting it (the requester) and. when
applicable. to:

1. Certify that the TIN you are giving is correct (or you are waiting for a number
to be issued).
2. Certify that you we not subject to backup withholdng. or

3. Claim exemption from backup withholding if you we a U.S. exempt payee. If
applicable. you are also certifyng that as a U.S. person. your allocable share of
any partnership income from a U.S. trade or business is not subject to the
withholding tax on foreign partners' share of effectively connected income. and
4. Certify that FATCA code(s) entered on this form 0f any) indicating that you are
exempt from the FATCA vaporing, is correct.
Note. If you are a U.S. person and a requester gives you a form other than Form
W-9 to request your TIN. you must use the requester's form if it is substantially
similar to this Form W-9.
Definition of a U.S. person. For federal tax purposes. you are considered a U.S.
person if you are:

• M individual who is a U.S. citizen or U.S. resident alien.
• A partnership, corporation. company, or association created or organized ri the
United States or under the laws of the United States.

• An estate (other than a foreign estate). or
• A domestic trust (as defined in Regulations section 301.7701-7).
Special rules for partnerships. Partnerships that conduct a trade or business in
the United States are generally required to pay a withholding tax under section
1446 on any foreign partners' share of effectively connected taxable income from
such business. Further. in certain cases where a Form W-9 has not been received.
the rules under section 1446 require a partnership to presume that a partner is a
foreign person. and pay the section 1446 withholding tax. Therefore, if you are a
U.S. person that is a partner in a partnership conducting a trade or business ki the
United States. provide Form W-9 to the partnership to establish your U.S. status
and avoid section 1446 withholding on your share of partnership income.
Cat. No. 10231X Form W-9 (Rev. 8-2013)
Form W-9 (Rev. 8-2013) Page 2
In the cases below. the followng person must give Form W-9 to the partnership
for purposes of establishing its U.S. status and avoiding withholding on its
allocable share of net income from the partnership conducting a trade or business
n the United States:

• in the case of a disregarded entity with a U.S. owner. the U.S. owner of the
disregarded entity and not the entity.

• In the case of a grantor trust with a U.S. grantor or other U.S. owner. generally.
the U.S. grantor or other U.S. owner of the grantor trust and not the trust. and
• In the case of a U.S. trust (other than a grantor Mat). the U.S. trust (other than a
grantor trust) and not the beneficiaries of the trust.
Foreign person. If you are a foreign person or the U.S. branch of a foreign bank
that has elected to be treated as a U.S. person. do not use Form W-9. Instead. use
the appropriate Form W-8 or Form 8233 (see Publication 515. Withholding of Tax
on Nonresident Aliens and Foreign Entities).
Nonresident alien who becomes a resident alien. Generally, only a nonresident
aben ndividual may use the terms of a tax treaty to reduce or eliminate U.S. tax on
certain types of income. However. most tax treaties contain a provision known as
a "sating clause." Exceptions specified in the saving clause may permit an
exemption from tax to continue for °erten types of ., come even after the payee
has otherwise become a U.S. resident alien for tax purposes.
If you are a U.S. resident aben who is relying on an exception contained n the
saving clause of a tax treaty to claim an exemption from U.S. tax on cedar, types
of income. you must attach a statement to Form W-9 that specifies the following
five items:

1. The treaty country. Generally, this must be the same treaty under which you
claimed exerrption from tax as a nonresident alien.

2. The treaty article addressing the income.
3. The article number (cc location) in the tax treaty that contains the saving
clause and its exceptions.

4. The type and amount of ncome that qualifies for the exemption from tax.
5. Sufficient facts to justify the exemption from tax under the terms of the treaty
article.
Example. Article 20 of the U.S.-China income tax treaty allows an exemption
from tax for scholarship income received by a Ch nese student temporarily present
n the United States. Under U.S. law. this student will become a resident alien for
tax purposes if his or her stay in the United States exceeds 5 calendar years.
However. paragraph 2 of the first Protocol to the U.S.-China treaty (dated Aprd 30.

1984) allows the provisions of Article 20 to continue to apply even after the
Cheese student becomes a resident alien of the United States. A Chinese student
who qualifies for this exception (under paragraph 2 of the first protocol) and is
relying on this exception to claim an exemption from tax on his or her scholarship
or fellowship income would attach to Form W-9 a statement that includes the
., formation described above to support that exemption.
If you are a nonresident alien or a foreign entity. give the requester the
appropriate completed Form W-8 or Form 8233.
What is backup withholding? Persons making certain payments to you must
under certain conditions withhold and pay to the IRS a percentage of such
payments. This is called "backup withholding.' Payments that may be subject to
backup withholding include interest. tax-exempt interest. dividends. broker and
barter exchange transactions. rents. royalties. nonemployee pay. payments made
yr settlement of payment card and third party network transactions. and certain
payments from fishing boat operators. Real estate transactions are not subject to
backup withholding.
You will not be subject to backup withholding on payments you receive it you
give the requester your correct TIN. make the proper certifications. and report all
your taxable merest and dividends on your tax return.
Payments you receive will be subject to backup
withholding if:

1. You do not furnish your TN to the requester.
2. You do not certify your TIN when required (see the Part II instructions on page
3 for details).

3. The IRS tells the requester that you famished an incorrect TIN.
4. The IRS tells you that you are subject to backup withholding because you did
not report all your interest and dividends on your tax return (for reportable interest
and dividends only). or
5. You do not certify to the requester that you are not subject to backup
withholding under 4 above (for reportable interest and dividend accounts opened
after 1983 only).
Certain payees and payments are exempt from backup withholdng. See Exempt
payee code on page 3 and the separate Instructions for the Requester of Form
W-9 for more ., formation.
Also see Special rules for partnerships on page 1.
What is FATCA reporting? The Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA)
requires a participating foreign financial institution to report all United States
account holders that are specified United States persons. Certain payees are
exempt from FATCA reporting. See Exemption from FATCA repotting code on
page 3 and the Instructions for the Requester of Form W-9 for mote information.
Updating Your Information
You must provide updated information to any person to whom you claimed to be
an exempt payee if you are no longer an exempt payee and anticipate receiving
reportable payments in the future from this person. For example. you may need to
provide updated information if you are a C corporation that elects to be an S
corporation. or if you no longer are tax exempt. In addition. you must furnish a new
Form W-9 if the name or TIN changes for the account. for example. if the grantor
of a grantor trust dies.
Penalties
Failure to furnish TIN. If you fail to furnish your correct TIN to a requester. you are
subject to a penalty of 350 for each such failure unless your failure is due to
reasonable cause and not to wilful neglect.
Civil penalty for false Information with respect to withholding. If you make a
false statement with no reasonable basis that results in no backup withholdng.
you are subject to a 3500 penalty.
Criminal penalty for falsifying Information. Willfully falsifying certifications or
animations may subject you to aillktal penalties including fines and/or
imprisonment.
Misuse of TINs. If the requester discloses or uses TINs in violation of federal law.
the requester may be subject to civil and criminal penalties.
Specific Instructions
Name
If you are an individual, you must generaly enter the name shown on your income
tax return. However, if you have changed your last name. for instance, due to
manage without reforming the Social Security Administration of the name change.
enter your fret name. the last name shown on your social security card, and your
new last name.
If the account is n joint names. list first, and then circle, the name of the person
or entity whose number you entered in Part I of the form.
Sole proprietor. Enter your nclividual name as shown on your income tax return
on the 'Name' line. You may enter your business, trade, or 'doing business as
(DBA)" name on the "Business name/disregarded entity name" re.
Partnership, C Corporation, or S Corporation. Enter the entity's name on the
"Name' line and any business, trade, or "doing busness as (DBA) name' on the
"Business name/disregarded entity name" lyre.
Disregarded entity. For U.S. federal tax purposes. an entity that is disregarded as
an entity separate from its owner is treated as a "disregarded entity." See
Regulation section 301.7701-2(cX2Xiii). Enter the owner's name on the "Name"
line. The name of the entity entered on the 'Name" line should never be a
disregarded entity. The name on the "Name" line must be the name shown on the
income tax return on which the income should be reported. For example. if a
foreign LLC that is treated as a disregarded entity for U.S. federal tax purposes
has a single owner that is a U.S. person. the U.S. owner's name is requied to be
provided on the "Name" Ire. If the direct owner of the entity is also a disregarded
entity, enter the first owner that is not disregarded for federal tax purposes. Enter
the disregarded entity's name on the 'Business name/disregarded entity name'
line. If the owner of the disregarded entity is a foreign person. the owner must
complete an appropriate Form W-8 ., stead of a Form W-9. This is the case even if
the foreign person has a U.S. TIN.
Note. Check the appropriate box for the U.S. federal tax classification of the
person whose name is entered on the "Name" line (Incbvidual/sole proprietor.
Partnership, C Corporation. S Corporation, Trust/estate).
Limited Liability Company (US). If the person identified on the "Name" lire is an
LLC. check the 'Limited liability company" box only and enter the appropriate
code for the U.S. federal tax classification in the space provided. If you are an LLC
that is treated as a partnership for U.S. federal tax exposes. enter "P" for
partnership. If you are an LLC that has filed a Form 8832 or a Form 2553 to be
taxed as a corporation, enter "C' for C corporation or "S" for S corporation. as
appropriate. If you are an LLC that is disregarded as an entity separate from its
owner under Regulation section 301.7701-3 (except for employment and excise
tax), do not check the LLC box unless the owner of the LLC (required to be
identified on the 'Name" line) is another LLC that is not disregarded for U.S.
federal tax purposes. If the LLC is disregarded as an entity separate from its
owner. enter the appropriate tax classification of the owner identified on the
"Name' line.
Other entities. Enter your business name as shown on required U.S. federal tax
documents on the "Name" line. This name should match the name shown on the
charter or other legal document creating the entity. You may enter any business,
trade. or DBA name on the "Business name/disregarded entity name" line.
Exemptions
If you are exempt from backup withholding and/or FATCA reporting. enter in the
Exemptions box. any codes) that may apply to you. See Exempt payee code and
Exemption from FATCA reporting code on page 3.
Form W-9 (Rev. 8-2013) Page 3
Exempt payee code. Generally. individuals (including sole proprietors) are not
exempt from backup withholding. Corporations are exempt from backup
withholding for certain payments. such as interest and dividends. Corporations are
not exempt from backup withholding for payments made in settlement of payment
card or third party network transactions.
Note. If you are exempt from backup withholding. you should still complete this
form to avoid possible erroneous backup withholding.
The following codes identify payees that are exempt from backup withholding:
1 —An organization exempt from tax under section 501(e). any IRA. or a
custodial account under section 403(b)(7) if the account satisfies the requirements
of section 4019)(2)
2 —The United States or any of its agencies or instrumenValities
3—A state. the District of Cdumbia. a possession of the United States. or any of
their political subdivisions or nstrumedalities
4 —A foreign government or any of its political subdivisions. agencies. or
nstrumedalities
5—A corporation
6—A dealer in securities or commodities required to register in the United
States. the District of Columbia. or a possession of the United States
7—A futures commission merchant registered with the Commodity Futures
Tradng Commission
8—A real estate investment trust
9 —An entity registered at all times during the tax year under the Investment
Company Act of 1940
10—A common trust fund operated by a bark under section 584(e)
11—A financial institution
12—A middleman known n the investment community as a nominee or
custodian
13—A trust exempt from tax under section 664 or described ri section 4947
The following chart shows types of payments that may be exempt from backup
withholding. The chart applies to the exempt payees listed above. 1 through 13.
IF the payment Is for... THEN the payment Is exempt for ...
Interest and dividend payments All exempt payees except
for 7
Broker transactions Exempt payees 1 through 4 and 6
through 11 and all C corporations. S
corporations must not enter an exempt
payee code because they are exempt
only for sales of noncovered securities
acquied prior to 2012.
Barter exchange transactions and
patronage dividends
Exempt payees 1 through 4
Payments over $600 requied to be
reported and direct sales over S5.000'
Generally. exempt payees
1 through 52
Payments made in settlement of
payment card or third party network
transactions
Exempt payees 1 through 4
' See Form 1099-MISC. Miscellaneous Income. and its nstrucbons.
'However. the following payments made o a corporation and reportable on Form
1099-MISC are not exempt from backup withholding: medical and health care
payments. attorneys' fees. gross proceeds paid to an attorney. and payments for
services paid by a federal executive agency.
Exemption from FATCA reporting code. The following codes identify payees
that are exempt from reporting under FATCA. These codes apply to persons
submitting this form for accounts maintained outside of the Unrted States by
certain foreign financial institutions. Therefore. it you are only submitting this form
for an account you hold in the Unrted States. you may leave this field blank.
Consult with the person requesting this form if you are uncertain if the financial
sublubon is subject to these requirements.
A—An organization exempt from tax under section 501(e) or any ndividual
retirement plan as defined in section 7701(a)(37)
B —The United States or any of its agencies or instrumentalities
C —A state. the District of Columbia. a possession of the United States. or any
of thew political subdivisions or instrumentalities
D —A corporation the stock of which is regularly traded on one or more
established securities markets. as described in Reg. section 1.1472-1(c)(1)(i)
E —A corporation that is a member of the same expanded affaated group as a
corporation described in Reg. section 1.1472-1(c)(1)(0
F —A dealer n securities. commodities. or derivative financial instruments
(including notional principal contracts. futures. forwards. and options) that is
registered as such under the laws of the United States or any state
G —A real estate investment trust
H —A regulated investment company as defined in section 851 or an entity
registered at all times cluing the tax year under the Investment Company Act of
I —A common trust find as defined in section 584(e)
J —A bank as defined in section 581
K —A broker
L —A trust exempt from tax under section 664 or described in section 4947(a)(1)
M —A tax exempt trust under a section 403(0) plan or section 457(g) plan
Part I. Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN)
Enter your TIN in the appropriate box. If you are a resident alien and you do not
have and are not eligible to get an SSN. your TIN is you IRS individual taxpayer
identification number (ITIN). Enter it kr the social security number box. If you do not
have an ITIN. see How to get a TIN below.
If you are a sole proprietor and you have an EIN. you may enter either your SSN
or EIN. However. the IRS prefers that you use you SSN.
If you are a single-member LLC that is disregarded as an entity separate from its
owner (see Limited Liability Company (LLC) on page 2). enter the owners SSN (or
EIN. if the owner has one). Do not enter the disregarded entity's EIN. If the LLC is
classified as a corporation or partnership, enter the entity's EIN.
Note. See the chart on page 4 for further clarification of name and TIN
combinations.
How to get a TIN. If you do not have a TIN. apply for one immediately. To apply
for an SSN. get Form SS-5. Application for a Social Security Card. from your local
Social Security Administration office or get this form online at NAVW.SSELgOV. You
may also get this form by calling 1-800-772-1213. Use Form W-7. Application for
IRS Individual Taxpayer Identification Number. to apply for an MN. or Form SS-4.
Application for Employer Identification Number. to apply for an EIN. You can apply
for an EIN online by accessing the IRS website at www.irs.govlbusinesses and
clicking on Employer Identification Number (EIN) under Starting a Business. You
can get Forms W-7 and SS-4 from the IRS by visiting IRS.gov or by ceding 1-800-
TM -FORM (1-800-829-3676).
If you are asked to complete Form W-9 but do not have a 11N. apply for a TIN
and write "Applied For' in the space for the TIN. sign and date the form. and give it
to the requester. For interest and dividend payments. and certan payments made
with respect to readily tradable nstruments. generally you will have 60 days to get
a TIN and give it to the requester before you are subject to backup withholding on
payments. The 60-day rule does not apply to other types of payments. You will be
subject to backup withholding on all such payments until you provide your TIN to
the requester.
Note. Entering 'Applied For" means that you have already applied for a TIN or that
you intend to apply for one soon.
Caution: A disregarded U.S. entity that hes a foreign owner must use the
appropriate Forth W-8.
Part II. Certification
To establish to the withholding agent that you are a U.S. person. or resident alien.
sign Farm W-9. You may be requested to sign by the withholding agent even if
items 1.4. or 5 below ndicate otherwise.
For a joint account, only the person whose TIN is shown in Part I should sign
(when required). In the case of a disregarded entity. the person identified on the
"Name line must sign. Exempt payees. see Exempt payee code earlier.
Signature requirements. Complete the certification as indicated in items 1
through 5 below.

1. Interest, dividend, and barter exchange accounts opened before 1984
and broker accounts considered active during 1983. You must give your
correct TIN. but you do not have to sign the certification.

2. Interest, dividend, broker, and barter exchange accounts opened after
1083 and broker accounts considered Inactive during 1983. You must sign the
certification or backup withholding will apply. if you are subject to backup
withholding and you are merely providing your correct TIN to the requester. you
must cross out item 2 in the certification before signng the form.

3. Real estate transactions. You must sign the certification. You may cross out
item 2 of the certification.

4. Other payments. You must give your correct TIN. but you do not have to sign
the certification unless you have been notified that you have previously given an
incorrect TIN. "Other payments" nclude payments made in the course of the
requester's trade or business for rents, royalties, goods (other than bills for
merchandise), medical and health care services (including payments to
corporations), payments to a nonemployee for services, payments made in
settlement of payment card and third party network transactions, payments to
certain fisting boat crew members and fishermen, and gross proceeds paid to
attorneys (including payments to corporations).

5. Mortgage interest paid by you. acquisition or abandonment of secured
property, cancellation of debt. qualified tuition program payments (under
section 529), IRA, Coverdell ESA, Archer MSA or HSA contributions or
distributions, and pension distributions. You must give your correct TIN. but you
do not have to sign the certification.
Form W-9 (Rev. 8-2013) Page 4
What Name and Number To Give the Requester
For this type of account: Give name and SSN of:

1. Individual
2. Two or more individuals 6crnt
account)
3. Custodian account of a rnnor
(Uniform Gift to Minors Act)

4. a. The usual revocable savings
trust (grantor is also trustee)
b. So-called trust account that is
not a legal or vakd bust under
state law

5. Sole proprietorship or disregarded
entity owned by an individual
6. Grantor trust filing under Optional
Form 1099 Filing Method 1 (see
Regulation section 1.671-4(b)(2 ()1)(A)
The ndividual
The actual owner of the account or,
if combined funds. the first
individual on the account'
The mnor
The grantor-trustee
The actual owner
The owner'
The grantor'
For this type of account Give name and ON of:

7. Disregarded entity not owned by an
individual
8. A valid trust. estate, or pension trust
9. Corporation or LLC electing
corporate status on Form 8832 or
Form 2553

10. Associatica, club. religious.
charitable, educational, or other
tax-exempt organization
11. Partnership or multi-member LLC

12. A broker or registered nominee
13. Account with the Department of
Agriculture n the name of a pubic
entity (such as a state or local
government. school district. or
Frisco) that receives agricultural
program payments
14. Grantor trust filing under the Form
1041 Filing Method or the Optional
Form 1099 Filing Method 2 (see
Regulation section 1.671-4(bg2XiyEr)
The owner
Legal entity'
The corporation
The organization
The partnership
The broker or nominee
The public entity
The trust
Let first and circle the name of the person whose number you furnish. If arty one person on a
pint account has an SSN, that person's number must be furnished.
Cycle the minors name and famish the winces SSN.
'You must show your nelendual name and you may also enter yaw buvness or '00K name an
the 'Dueness narnetdrwegazded entity' name line. You may use either yew SSN or EIN fel you
have one), but the IRS encourages you to use your SSN.
'List first and circle the name of the trust. estate. or pension trust. (Do not furnsh the TIN of the
personal representatire a trustee unless the legal entity misc.,' is not desagnated inthe accoult
lite.) Also see Special odes far partnerships on page 1.
'Note. Grantor also must provide a Form W-9 to trustee of that.
Note. If no name is crcled when more than one name is listed. the number will be
considered to be that of the first name listed.
Secure Your Tax Records from Identity Theft
Identity theft occurs when someone uses your personal reformation such as your
name. social security number (SSN). or other identifying reformation. without your
permission. to commit fraud or other crimes. An identity thief may use yotr SSN to
get a job or may file a tax return using your SSN to receive a refund.
To reduce your risk:
• Protect your 55N.
• Ensure your employer is protecting your SSN. and
• Be careful when choosing a tax preparer.
If your tax records are affected by identity theft and you receive a notice from
the IRS. respond right away to the name and phone number printed on the IRS
notice or letter.
If your tax records are not currently affected by identity theft but you think you
are at risk due to a lost or stolen pose or wallet. questionable credit card activity
or credit report. contact the IRS Identity Theft Hotline at 1-800-908-4490 or submit
Form 14039.
For more information. see Publication 4535. Identity Theft Prevention and Victim
Assistance.
Victims of identity theft who are experiencing economic harm or a system
peoblem, or are seeking help in resolving tax problems that have not been resolved
through normal channels. may be eligible for Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS)
assistance. You can reach TAS by calling the TAS toll-free case intake line at
1-877-777-4778 or TTY/TDD 1-800.829-4059.
Protect yourself from suspicious amens or phishing schemes. Pheshing is the
creation and use of email and websites designed to mimic legitimate business
emails and websites. The most common act is sending an email to a user falsely
claiming to be an established legitimate enterprise in an attempt to scam the user
into surrendering private information that wdl be used for identity theft.
The IRS does not initiate contacts with taxpayers via emails. Also. the IRS does
not request personal detailed information through email or ask taxpayers for the
PIN numbers. passwords. or similar secret access information for their credit card.
bank. or other financial accounts.
If you receive an unsolicited email claiming to be from the IRS. forward this
message to phishingeirs.gov. You may also report misuse of the IRS name. logo.
or other IRS property to the Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration at
1-800-366-4484. You can forward suspicious emails to the Federal Trade
Commission at: sparneduce.gov or contact them at www.ftc.govIrcIthett or 1-877-
IDTHEFT (1-877-438-4338).
Visit IRS.gov to learn more about identity theft and how to reduce you' risk.
Privacy Act Notice

Section 6109 of the Internal Revenue Code requires you to provide yow correct TIN to persons including federal agencies)
who are requied to file information
retums with
the IRS to renal interest. dividends. or certain other income paid to you: mortgage interest you paid: the acquisition 
or abandonment of secured property: the
cancellation
of debt: or contributions you made to an IRA. Archer MSA. or HSA. The person collecting this form uses the information 
on the form to file information retums
with the IRS.
reporting the above information. Routine uses of this information include giving it to the Department of Justice for 
civil and crimnal litigation and to cities.
states. the District
of Columbia. and U.S. commonwealths and possessions for use in administering thee laws. The reformation also may be 
disclosed to other countries under a treaty.
to
federal and state agencies to enforce civil and criminal laws. or to federal law enforcement and intelligence agencies 
to combat terrcrism. You must provide
your TN
whether or not you are required to file a tax return. Under section 3406. payers must generally withhold a percentage of
taxable interest. dividend. and certain
other
payments to a payee who does not give a TIN to the payer. Certain penalties may also apply for providing false or 
fraudulent information.
EXHIBIT C
FORM W-8BEN, Font-W-8BEN-E, FORM W-8ECI,
FORM W-8EXP AND Font W-8IMY
(WITH INSTRUCTIONS)
EXHIBIT C
109191599 v3
Form W-8BEN
(Rev. February 2014)
Deparbnent of the Treasury
Interrel Revenue Service
Certificate of Foreign Status of Beneficial Owner for United
States Tax Withholding and Reporting (Individuals)
le For use by individuals. Entities must use Form W-8BEN-E.
e Information about Form W-SBEN and its separate instructions Is at wwwirs.govItormw8 ben.
e Give this form to the withholding agent or payer. Do not send to the IRS.
OMB No. 1545-1621
Do NOT use this form if: Instead, use Form:

• You are NOT an individual   W-8BEN-E
• You are a U.S. citizen or other U.S. person. including a resident alien individual   W-9

• You are a beneficial owner claiming that income is effectively connected with the conduct of trade or business within 
the U.S.
(other than personal services)   W-8ECI

• You are a beneficial owner who is receiving compensation for personal services performed in the United States   8233 
or W-4

• A person acting as an intermediary   W-8IMY
Part I Identification of Beneficial Owner (see instructions)
1 Name of individual who is the beneficial owner 2 Country of citizenship
3 Permanent residence address (street. apt. or suite no., or rural route). Do not use a box or In-care -of address.
City or town, state or province. Include postai code where appropriate. Country
4 Mailing address (if different from above)
City or town, state or province. Include postal code where appropriate. Country
5 U.S. taxpayer identification number (SSN or ITIN). if required (see instructions) Foreign tax identifying number (see 
instructions)
7 Reference number(s) (see instructions) 8 Date of birth (MM-DD-YYYY) (see instructions)
Part Claim of Tax Treaty Benefits (for chapter 3 purposes only) (see instructions)
9 I certify that the beneficial owner is a resident of within the meaning of the income tax treaty
between the United States and that country.
10 Special rates and conditions Of applicable—see Instructions): The beneficial owner is claiming the provisions of 
Article
of the treaty identified on line 9 above to claim a % rate of withholding on (specify type of income):
Explain the reasons the beneficial owner meets the terms of the treaty article:
ligaiWI  Certification
Under penalties of perjury. l declare that 1 have examined the information on this form and to the best of my knowledge 
and bebef it is true, correct, and
complete. l *Ether
certify under penalties of perjury that:

• I am the individual that is the beneficial owner (or am authorized to sign for the individual that is the beneficial 
owner) of all the income to which this
form relates or
am using this form to document myself as an individual that is an owner or account holder of a foreign financial 
lettubon.

• The person named on line 1 of this form is not a U.S. person.
• The income to which this form relates is:

(a) not effectively connected with the conduct of a trade or business ri the United States.
(b) effectively connected but is not subject to tax under an applicable income tax treaty. or
(c) the partner's share of a partnership's effectively connected ncome.

• The person named on line 1 of this form is a resident of the treaty country listed on tine 9 of the form (if any) 
withn the meaning of the income tax treaty
between
the United States and that country. and
• Foe broker transactions or baiter exchanges. the beneficial owner is an exempt foreign person as defined in the 
nstructions.
Firthermore. I authorize this form to be provided to any withholding agent that has control. receipt, or custody of the 
income of which I am the beneficial
owner or
any withholding agent that can disburse or make payments of the ncome of which I am the beneficial owner. I agree that I
will submit a new form within 30 days
if any cerdfication made on this form becomes incorrect
Sign Here
Signature of beneficial owner (or individual authorized to sign for beneficial owner) Date (MM-DD-YYYY)
Print name of signer Capacity in which acting (f forms not signed by beneficial owner)
For Paperwork Reduction Act Notice, see separate instructions. Cat. No. 250472 Form W-8BEN (Rev. 2-2014)
Instructions for
Form W-8BEN (Rev. February 2014)
Certificate of Foreign Status of Beneficial Owner for
United States Tax Withholding and Reporting (Individuals)
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Section references are to the Internal Revenue Code
unless otherwise noted.
Future Developments
For the latest information about developments related to
Form W-8BEN and its instructions, such as legislation
enacted after they were published, go to www.irs.gov/
formw8ben.
What's New
FATCA. In 2010, Congress passed the Hiring Incentives
to Restore Employment Act of 2010, P. L. 111-147 (the
HIRE Act), which added chapter 4 of Subtitle A
(chapter 4) to the Code, consisting of sections 1471
through 1474 of the Code and commonly referred to as
"FATCA" or "chapter 4". Under chapter 4, participating
foreign financial institutions (FFIs) and certain
registered-deemed compliant FFIs are generally required
to identify their U.S. account holders, regardless of
whether a payment subject to withholding is made to the
account. The IRS has published regulations that provide
due diligence, withholding, and reporting rules for both
U.S. withholding agents and FFIs under chapter 4.
This form, along with Form W-8ECI, W-BEXP, and
W-81MY, has been updated to reflect the documentation
requirements of chapter 4. In particular, this Form
W-8BEN is now used exclusively by individuals. Entities
documenting their foreign status, chapter 4 status, or
making a claim of treaty benefits (if applicable) should use
Form W-8BEN-E.
Individual account holders (both U.S. and foreign) that
do not document their status may be deemed recalcitrant
and, in some cases, subject to 30% withholding on certain
payments. Foreign individuals can avoid being classified
as recalcitrant account holders by using Form W-8BEN to
document their foreign status.
Foreign individuals should use Form W-8BEN to
document their foreign status and claim any applicable
treaty benefits for chapter 3 purposes (including a foreign
individual that is the single member of an entity that is
disregarded for U.S. tax purposes). See the instructions to
Form W-8BEN-E concerning claims for treaty benefits and
chapter 4 certifications in the case of a hybrid entity.
Reportable payment card transactions. Section
6050W was added by section 3091 of the Housing
Assistance Tax Act of 2008 and requires information
returns to be made by certain payers with respect to
payments made to participating payees in settlement of
payment card transactions and third party payment
network transactions. Information returns are not required
with respect to payments made to payees that are foreign
persons, however.
A payer of a reportable payment may treat a payee as
foreign if the payer receives an applicable Form W-8 from
the payee. Provide this Form W-8BEN to the requestor if
you are a foreign individual that is a participating payee
receiving payments in settlement of payment card
transactions that are not effectively connected with a U.S.
trade or business of the payee.
More information. For more information on FATCA, go
to www.irs.govfiatca.
General Instructions
For definitions of terms used throughout these
instructions, see Definitions, later.
Purpose of Form
Establishing status for chapter 3 purposes. Foreign
persons are subject to U.S. tax at a 30% rate on income
they receive from U.S. sources that consists of:

• Interest (including certain original issue discount (OID));
• Dividends;
• Rents;
• Royalties;
• Premiums;

• Annuities;
• Compensation for, or in expectation of, services
performed;
• Substitute payments in a securities lending transaction;
or

• Other fixed or determinable annual or periodical gains,
profits, or income.
This tax is imposed on the gross amount paid and is
generally collected by withholding under section 1441. A
payment is considered to have been made whether it is
made directly to the beneficial owner or to another person,
such as an intermediary, agent, or partnership, for the
benefit of the beneficial owner.
In addition, section 1446 requires a partnership
conducting a trade or business in the United States to
withhold tax on a foreign partners distributive share of the
partnership's effectively connected taxable income.
Generally, a foreign person that is a partner in a
partnership that submits a Form W-8BEN for purposes of
section 1441 or 1442 will satisfy the documentation
requirements under section 1446 as well. However, in
some cases the documentation requirements of sections
1441 and 1442 do not match the documentation
requirements of section 1446. See Regulations sections
1.1446-1 through 1.1446-6.
Feb 19, 2014 Cat. No. 25576H
Note. The owner of a disregarded entity (including an
individual), rather than the disregarded entity itself, must
submit the appropriate Form W-BBEN for purposes of
section 1446.
It you receive certain types of income, you must
provide Form W-8BEN to:

• Establish that you are not a U.S. person;
• Claim that you are the beneficial owner of the income
for which Form W-8BEN is being provided or a foreign
partner in a partnership subject to section 1446; and

• If applicable, claim a reduced rate of, or exemption
from, withholding as a resident of a foreign country with
which the United States has an income tax treaty and who
is eligible for treaty benefits.
You may also be required to submit Form W-8BEN to
claim an exception from domestic information reporting
and backup withholding (at the backup withholding rate
under section 3406) for certain types of income that are
not subject to foreign-person withholding at a rate of 30%
under section 1441. Such income includes:

• Broker proceeds;
• Short-term (183 days or less) original issue discount
(OID);
• Bank deposit interest;
• Foreign source interest, dividends, rents, or royalties;
and
• Proceeds from a wager placed by a nonresident alien
individual in the games of blackjack, baccarat, craps,
roulette, or big-6 wheel.
A withholding agent or payer of the income may rely on
a properly completed Form W-8BEN to treat a payment
associated with the Form W-8BEN as a payment to a
foreign person who beneficially owns the amounts paid. If
applicable, the withholding agent may rely on the Form
W-8BEN to apply a reduced rate ot, or exemption from,
withholding at source.
Provide Form W-8BEN to the withholding agent or
payer before income is paid or credited to you. Failure to
provide a Form W-8BEN when requested may lead to
withholding at the foreign-person withholding rate of 30%
or the backup withholding rate under section 3406.
Establishing status for chapter 4 purposes. An FFI
may rely on a properly completed Form W-8BEN to
establish your chapter 4 status as a foreign person. The
Form W-8BEN should be provided to the FFI when
requested. Failure to do so could result in 30 percent
withholding on income paid or credited to you as a
recalcitrant account holder from sources within the United
States. See the definition of amounts subject to
withholding, later.
Additional information. For additional information and
instructions for the withholding agent, see the Instructions
for the Requester of Forms W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E,
W-8ECI, W-8EXP, and W-8IMY.
Who Must Provide Form W-8BEN
You must give Form W-8BEN to the withholding agent or
payer it you are a nonresident alien who is the beneficial
owner of an amount subject to withholding, or if you are an
account holder of an FFI documenting yourself as a
nonresident alien. If you are the single owner of a
disregarded entity, you are considered the beneficial
owner of income received by the disregarded entity.
Submit Form W-BBEN when requested by the withholding
agent, payer, or FFI whether or not you are claiming a
reduced rate of, or exemption from, withholding.
You should also provide Form W-8BEN to a payment
settlement entity (PSE) requesting this form if you are a
foreign individual receiving payments subject to reporting
under section 6050W (payment card transactions and
third-party network transactions) as a participating payee.
However, it the payments are income which is effectively
connected to the conduct of a U.S. trade or business, you
should instead provide the PSE with a Form W-8ECI.
Do not use Form W-8BEN if you are described
below.

• You are a foreign entity documenting your foreign
status, documenting your chapter 4 status, or claiming
treaty benefits. Instead, use Form W-8BEN-E, Certificate
of Status of Beneficial Owner for United States Tax
Withholding and Reporting (Entities).

• You are a U.S. citizen (even it you reside outside the
United States) or other U.S. person (including a resident
alien individual). Instead, use Form W-9, Request for
Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification, to
document your status as a U.S. person.

• You are acting as a foreign intermediary (that is, acting
not for your own account, but for the account of others as
an agent, nominee, or custodian). Instead, provide Form
W-81MY, Certificate of Foreign Intermediary, Foreign
Flow-Through Entity, or Certain U.S. Branches for United
States Tax Withholding and Reporting.

• You are a disregarded entity with a single owner that is
a U.S. person. Instead, the owner should provide Form
W-9. If the disregarded entity is a hybrid entity claiming
treaty benefits, the entity should complete Form
W-8BEN-E even if the single owner of such entity is a U.S.
person that must also provide a Form W-9. See the
instructions to Form W-8BEN-E for information on hybrid
entities claiming treaty benefits.

• You are a nonresident alien individual who claims
exemption from withholding on compensation for
independent or dependent personal services performed in
the United States. Instead, provide Form 8233, Exemption
from Withholding on Compensation for Independent (and
Certain Dependent) Personal Services of a Nonresident
Alien Individual, or Form W-4, Employee's Withholding
Allowance Certificate.
• You are receiving income that is effectively connected
with the conduct of a trade or business in the United
States, unless it is allocable to you through a partnership.
Instead, provide Form W-8ECI, Certificate of Foreign
Person's Claim That Income Is Effectively Connected With
the Conduct of a Trade or Business in the United States. If
any of the income for which you have provided a Form
W-8BEN becomes effectively connected, this is a change
in circumstances and Form W-8BEN is no longer valid
with respect to such income. You must file Form W-8ECI.
See Change in circumstances, later.
Giving Form W-8BEN to the withholding agent. Do
not send Form W-8BEN to the IRS. Instead, give it to the
person who is requesting it from you. Generally, this will
be the person from whom you receive the payment, who
-2-
credits your account, or a partnership that allocates
income to you. An FFI may also request this farm from you
to document your account as other than a U.S. account.
Give Form W-8BEN to the person requesting it before the
payment is made to you, credited to your account, or
allocated. If you do not provide this form, the withholding
agent may have to withhold at the 30% rate (under
chapter 3 and 4), backup withholding rate, or the rate
applicable under section 1446. If you receive more than
one type of income from a single withholding agent for
which you claim different benefits, the withholding agent
may, at its option, require you to submit a Form W-8BEN
for each different type of income. Generally, a separate
Form W-8BEN must be given to each withholding agent.
Note. If you own the income or account jointly with one or
more other persons, the income or account will be treated
by the withholding agent as owned by a foreign person
that is a beneficial owner of a payment only if Forms
W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E are provided by all of the owners.
If the withholding agent or financial institution receives a
Form W-9 from any of the joint owners, however, the
payment must be treated as made to a U.S. person and
the account treated as a U.S. account.
Change in circumstances. If a change in circumstances
makes any information on the Form W-8BEN you have
submitted incorrect, you must notify the withholding agent,
payer, or FFI with which you hold an account within 30
days of the change in circumstances and you must file a
new Form W-8BEN or other appropriate form.
If you use Form W-8BEN to certify that you are a
foreign person, a change of address to an address in the
United States is a change in circumstances. Generally, a
change of address within the same foreign country or to
another foreign country is not a change in circumstances.
However, if you use Form W-8BEN to claim treaty
benefits, a move to the United States or outside the
country where you have been claiming treaty benefits is a
change in circumstances. In that case, you must notify the
withholding agent, payer, or FFI within 30 days of the
move.
If you become a U.S. citizen or resident alien after you
submit Form W-8BEN, you are no longer subject to the
30% withholding rate under section 1441 or the
withholding tax on a foreign partner's share of effectively
connected income under section 1446. To the extent you
have an account with an FFI, your account may be subject
to reporting by the FFI under chapter 4. You must notify
the withholding agent, payer, or FFI within 30 days of
becoming a U.S. citizen or resident alien. You may be
required to provide a Form W-9. For more information,
see Form W-9 and its instructions.
You may be a U.S. resident for tax purposes
depending on the number of days you are
physically present in the United States over a
3-year period. See Publication 519, available at irs.gov/
publications/o519. If you satisfy the substantial presence
test, you must notify the withholding agent, payer, or
financial institution with which you have an account within
30 days and provide a Form W-9.
A CAUT 0
Expiration of Form W-8BEN. Generally, a Form
W-8BEN will remain in effect for purposes of establishing
foreign status for a period starting on the date the form is
signed and ending on the last day of the third succeeding
calendar year, unless a change in circumstances makes
any information on the form incorrect. For example, a
Form W-8BEN signed on September 30, 2015, remains
valid through December 31, 2018.
However, under certain conditions a Form W-8BEN will
remain in effect indefinitely until a change of
circumstances occurs. To determine the period of validity
for Form W-8BEN for purposes of chapter 4, see
Regulations section 1.1471-3(c)(6)(ii). To determine the
period of validity for Form W-8BEN for purposes of
chapter 3, see Regulations section 1.1441-1(e)(4)(ii).
Definitions
Account holder. An account holder is generally the
person listed or identified as the holder or owner of a
financial account. For example, if a partnership is listed as
the holder or owner of a financial account, then the
partnership is the account holder, rather than the partners
of the partnership (subject to some exceptions). However,
an account that is held by a single-member disregarded
entity is treated as held by the person owning the entity.
Amounts subject to withholding. Generally, an amount
subject to chapter 3 withholding is an amount from
sources within the United States that is fixed or
determinable annual or periodical (FDAP) income. FDAP
income is all income included in gross income, including
interest (as well as OID), dividends, rents, royalties, and
compensation. FDAP income does not include most gains
from the sale of property (including market discount and
option premiums), as well as other specific items of
income described in Regulations section 1.1441-2 (such
as interest on bank deposits and short-term OID).
For purposes of section 1446, the amount subject to
withholding is the foreign partner's share of the
partnership's effectively connected taxable income.
Generally, an amount subject to chapter 4 withholding
is an amount of U.S. source FDAP income that is also a
withholdable payment as defined in Regulations section
1.1473-1(a). The exemptions from withholding provided
for under chapter 3 are not applicable when determining
whether withholding applies under chapter 4. For specific
exceptions applicable to the definition of a withholdable
payment, see Regulations section 1.1473-1(a)(4)
(exempting, for example, certain nonfinancial payments).
Beneficial owner. For payments other than those for
which a reduced rate of, or exemption from, withholding is
claimed under an income tax treaty, the beneficial owner
of income is generally the person who is required under
U.S. tax principles to include the payment in gross income
on a tax return. A person is not a beneficial owner of
income, however, to the extent that person is receiving the
income as a nominee, agent, or custodian, or to the extent
the person is a conduit whose participation in a
transaction is disregarded. In the case of amounts paid
that do not constitute income, beneficial ownership is
determined as if the payment were income.
-3-
Foreign partnerships, foreign simple trusts, and foreign
grantor trusts are not the beneficial owners of income paid
to the partnership or trust. The beneficial owners of
income paid to a foreign partnership are generally the
partners in the partnership, provided that the partner is not
itself a partnership, foreign simple or grantor trust,
nominee or other agent. The beneficial owners of income
paid to a foreign simple trust (that is, a foreign trust that is
described in section 651(a)) are generally the
beneficiaries of the trust, if the beneficiary is not a foreign
partnership, foreign simple or grantor trust, nominee or
other agent. The beneficial owners of a foreign grantor
trust (that is, a foreign trust to the extent that all or a
portion of the income of the trust is treated as owned by
the grantor or another person under sections 671 through
679) are the persons treated as the owners of the trust.
The beneficial owners of income paid to a foreign complex
trust (that is, a foreign trust that is not a foreign simple
trust or foreign grantor trust) is the trust itself.
For purposes of section 1446, the same beneficial
owner rules apply, except that under section 1446 a
foreign simple trust rather than the beneficiary provides
the form to the partnership.
The beneficial owner of income paid to a foreign estate
is the estate itself.
Note. A payment to a U.S. partnership, U.S. trust, or
U.S. estate is treated as a payment to a U.S. payee that is
not subject to 30% withholding under chapter 3 or 4. A
U.S. partnership, trust, or estate should provide the
withholding agent with a Form W-9. For purposes of
section 1446, a U.S. grantor trust or disregarded entity
shall not provide the withholding agent a Form W-9 in its
own right. Rather, the grantor or other owner shall provide
the withholding agent the appropriate form.
Chapter 3. Chapter 3 means Chapter 3 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Withholding of Tax on Nonresident Aliens
and Foreign Corporations). Chapter 3 contains sections
1441 through 1464.
Chapter 4. Chapter 4 means Chapter 4 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Taxes to Enforce Reporting on Certain
Foreign Accounts). Chapter 4 contains sections 1471
through 1474.
Deemed -compliant FFI. Under section 1471(b)(2),
certain FFIs are deemed to comply with the regulations
under chapter 4 without the need to enter into an FFI
agreement with the IRS. However, certain
deemed-compliant FFIs are required to register with the
IRS and obtain a GIIN. These FFIs are referred to as
registered deemed -compliant FFIs. See Regulations
section 1.1471-5(f).
Disregarded entity. A business entity that has a single
owner and is not a corporation under Regulations section
301.7701-2(b) is disregarded as an entity separate from
its owner. A disregarded entity does not submit this Form
W-8BEN to a partnership for purposes of section 1446 or
to an FFI for purposes of chapter 4. Instead, the owner of
such entity provides appropriate documentation. See
Regulations section 1.1446-1 and section 1.1471-3(a)(3)
(v), respectively.
Certain entities that are disregarded for U.S. tax
purposes may be recognized for purposes of claiming
treaty benefits under an applicable tax treaty (see the
definition of hybrid entity below). A hybrid entity claiming
treaty benefits is required to complete Form W-8BEN-E.
See Form W-8BEN-E and its instructions.
Financial account. A financial account includes:

• A depository account maintained by a financial
institution;
• A custodial account maintained by a financial
institution;

• Equity or debt interests (other than interests regularly
traded on an established securities market) in investment
entities and certain holding companies, treasury centers,
or financial institutions as defined in Regulations section
1.1471-5(e);
• Cash value insurance contracts; and
• Annuity contracts.
For purposes of chapter 4, exceptions are provided for
accounts such as certain tax-favored savings accounts;
term lite insurance contracts; accounts held by estates;
escrow accounts; and annuity contracts. These
exceptions are subject to certain conditions. See
Regulations section 1.1471-5(b)(2). Accounts may also
be excluded from the definition of financial account under
an applicable IGA.
Financial institution. A financial institution generally
means an entity that is a depository institution, custodial
institution, investment entity, or an insurance company (or
holding company of an insurance company) that issues
cash value insurance or annuity contracts.
Foreign financial institution (FFI). A foreign financial
institution (FFI) generally means a foreign entity that is a
financial institution.
Foreign person. A foreign person includes a
nonresident alien individual and certain foreign entities
that are not U.S. persons (entities should complete Form
W-8BEN-E rather than this Form W-8BEN).
Hybrid entity. A hybrid entity is any person (other than
an individual) that is treated as fiscally transparent in the
United States but is not treated as fiscally transparent by a
country with which the United States has an income tax
treaty. Hybrid status is relevant for claiming treaty
benefits.
Intergovernmental agreement (IGA). An IGA means a
Model 1 IGA or a Model 2 IGA. For a list of jurisdictions
treated as having in effect a Model 1 or Model 2 IGA, see
"List of Jurisdictions" available at www.irs.gov/tatca.
A Model 1 IGA means an agreement between the
United States or the Treasury Department and a foreign
government or one or more agencies to implement
FATCA through reporting by FFIs to such foreign
government or agency thereof, followed by automatic
exchange of the reported information with the IRS. An FFI
in a Model 1 IGA jurisdiction that performs account
reporting to the jurisdiction's government is referred to as
a reporting Model 1 FFI.
A Model 2 IGA means an agreement or arrangement
between the U.S. or the Treasury Department and a
foreign government or one or more agencies to implement
-4-
FATCA through reporting by FFIs directly to the IRS in
accordance with the requirements of an FFI agreement,
supplemented by the exchange of information between
such foreign government or agency thereof and the IRS.
An FFI in a Model 2 IGA jurisdiction that has entered into
an FFI agreement is a participating FFI, but may be
referred to as a reporting Model 2 FFI.
Nonresident alien individual. Any individual who is not
a citizen or resident alien of the United States is a
nonresident alien individual. An alien individual meeting
either the "green card test" or the "substantial presence
test" for the calendar year is a resident alien. Any person
not meeting either test is a nonresident alien individual.
Additionally, an alien individual who is a resident of a
foreign country under the residence article of an income
tax treaty, or an alien individual who is a bona fide
resident of Puerto Rico, Guam, the Commonwealth of the
Northern Mariana Islands, the U.S. Virgin Islands, or
American Samoa is a nonresident alien individual. See
Pub. 519, U.S. Tax Guide for Aliens, for more information
on resident and nonresident alien status.
Even though a nonresident alien individual
married to a U.S. citizen or resident alien may
choose to be treated as a resident alien for
certain purposes (for example, filing a joint income tax
return), such individual is still treated as a nonresident
alien for chapter 3 withholding tax purposes on all income
except wages. For purposes of chapter 4, a nonresident
alien individual who holds a joint account with a U.S.
person will be considered a holder of a U.S. account for
chapter 4 purposes.
Participating FF1. A participating FFI is an FFI (including
a Reporting Model 2 FFI) that has agreed to comply with
the terms of an FFI agreement. The term participating FFI
also includes a qualified intermediary (CH) branch of a
U.S. financial institution, unless such branch is a reporting
Model 1 FFI.
Participating payee. A participating payee means any
person that accepts a payment card as payment or
accepts payment from a third party settlement
organization in settlement of a third party network
transaction.
Payment settlement entity (PSE). A payment
settlement entity is a merchant acquiring entity or third
party settlement organization. Under section 6050W, a
PSE is generally required to report payments made in
settlement of payment card transactions or third party
network transactions. However, a PSE is not required to
report payments made to a beneficial owner that is
documented as foreign with an applicable Form W-8.
Recalcitrant account holder. A recalcitrant account
holder for purposes of chapter 4 includes an individual
who fails to comply with the requests of an FFI for
documentation and information for determining the U.S. or
foreign status of the individual's account, including
fumishing this Form W-8BEN when requested.
U.S. person. A U.S. person is defined in section 7701(a)
(30) and includes an individual who is a citizen or resident
of the United States.
A CAU 0
Withholding agent. Any person, U.S. or foreign, that has
control, receipt, custody, disposal, or payment of U.S.
source FDAP income subject to chapter 3 or 4 withholding
is a withholding agent. The withholding agent may be an
individual, corporation, partnership, trust, association, or
any other entity, including (but not limited to) any foreign
intermediary, foreign partnership, and U.S. branches of
certain foreign banks and insurance companies.
For purposes of section 1446, the withholding agent is
the partnership conducting the trade or business in the
United States. For a publicly traded partnership, the
withholding agent may be the partnership, a nominee
holding an interest on behalf of a foreign person, or both.
See Regulations sections 1.1446-1 through 1.1446-6.
Specific Instructions
Part I
Line 1. Enter your name. If you are a foreign individual
who is the single owner of a disregarded entity that is not
claiming treaty benefits as a hybrid entity, with respect to
a payment, you should complete this form with your name
and information. If the account to which a payment is
made or credited is in the name of the disregarded entity,
you should inform the withholding agent of this fact. This
may be done by including the name and account number
of the disregarded entity on line 7 (reference number) of
the form. However, if the disregarded entity is claiming
treaty benefits as a hybrid entity, it should complete Form
W-8BEN-E instead of this Form W-8BEN.
Line 2. Enter your country of citizenship. If you are a dual
citizen, enter the country where you are both a citizen and
a resident at the time you complete this form. If you are
not a resident in any country in which you have
citizenship, enter the country where you were most
recently a resident. However, if you are a United States
citizen, you should not complete this form even if you hold
citizenship in another jurisdiction. Instead, provide Form
Line 3. Your permanent residence address is the
address in the country where you claim to be a resident
for purposes of that country's income tax. If you are
completing Form W-8BEN to claim a reduced rate of
withholding under an income tax treaty, you must
determine your residency in the manner required by the
treaty. Do not show the address of a financial institution, a
post office box, or an address used solely for mailing
purposes. If you do not have a tax residence in any
country, your permanent residence is where you normally
reside.
If you reside in a country that does not use street
addresses, you may enter a descriptive address on line 3.
The address must accurately indicate your permanent
residence in the manner used in your jurisdiction.
Line 4. Enter your mailing address only if it is different
from the address you show on line 3.
Line 5. If you have a social security number (SSN), enter
it here. To apply for an SSN, get Form SS-5 from a Social
Security Administration (SSA) office or online at
www.socialsecurity.gov/online/ss-5.html. If you are in the
-5-
United States, you can call the SSA at 1-800-772-1213.
Complete Form SS-5 and return it to the SSA.
If you do not have an SSN and are not eligible to get
one, you can get an individual taxpayer identification
number (ITIN). To apply for an ITIN, file Form W-7 with the
IRS. It usually takes 4-6 weeks to get an ITIN. To claim
certain treaty benefits, you must complete line 5 by
submitting an SSN or ITIN, or line 6 by providing a foreign
tax identification number (foreign TIN).
A CAUTIOI
An ITIN is for tax use only. It does not entitle you
to social security benefits or change your
employment or immigration status under U.S.
law.
A partner in a partnership conducting a trade or
business in the United States will likely be allocated
effectively connected taxable income. The partner is
required to file a U.S. federal income tax retum and must
have a U.S. taxpayer identification number (TIN).
You must provide an SSN or TIN if you are:

• Claiming an exemption from withholding under section
871(f) for certain annuities received under qualified plans,
or

• Submitting the form to a partnership that conducts a
trade or business in the United States.
If you are claiming treaty benefits, you are generally
required to provide an ITIN if you do not provide a tax
identifying number issued to you by your jurisdiction of tax
residence on line 6. However, an ITIN is not required to
claim treaty benefits relating to:

• Dividends and interest from stocks and debt obligations
that are actively traded;
• Dividends from any redeemable security issued by an
investment company registered under the Investment
Company Act of 1940 (mutual fund);

• Dividends, interest, or royalties from units of beneficial
interest in a unit investment trust that are (or were upon
issuance) publicly offered and are registered with the SEC
under the Securities Act of 1933; and

• Income related to loans of any of the above securities.
Line 6. If you are providing this Form W-8BEN to
document yourself with respect to a financial account that
you hold at a U.S. office of a financial institution, provide
the tax identifying number (TIN) issued to you by your
jurisdiction of tax residence unless:
• You have not been issued a TIN, or
• The jurisdiction does not issue TINs.
If you have not provided your jurisdiction of residence
TIN on line 6, provide your date of birth in line 8.
Line 7. This line may be used by the filer of Form
W-8BEN or by the withholding agent to whom it is
provided to include any referencing information that is
useful to the withholding agent in carrying out its
obligations. For example, withholding agents who are
required to associate the Form W-8BEN with a particular
Form W-81MY may want to use line 7 for a referencing
number or code that will make the association clear. A
beneficial owner can use line 7 to include the number of
the account for which he or she is providing the form. A
foreign single owner of a disregarded entity can use line 7
to inform the withholding agent that the account to which a
payment is made or credited is in the name of the
disregarded entity (see instructions for line 1).
Line 8. If you are providing this Form W-8BEN to
document yourself with respect to a financial account that
you hold with a U.S. office of a financial institution, provide
your date of birth. Use the following format to input your
information MM-DD-YYYY. For example, if you were bom
on April 15, 1956, you would enter 04-15-1956.
Part II
Line 9. If you are claiming treaty benefits as a resident of
a foreign country with which the United States has an
income tax treaty for payments subject to withholding
under chapter 3, identify the country where you claim to
be a resident for income tax treaty purposes. For treaty
purposes, a person is a resident of a treaty country if the
person is a resident of that country under the terms of the
treaty. A list of U.S. tax treaties is available at http://
www.irs.gov/Individuals/Intemational-Taxpavers/Tax-
Treaties.
If you are related to the withholding agent within
the meaning of section 267(b) or 707(b) and the
aggregate amount subject to withholding
received during the calendar year exceeds $500,000,
then you are generally required to file Form 8833
Treaty-Based Return Position Disclosure Under Section
6114 or 7701(b). See the Instructions for Form 8833 for
more information on the filing requirements.
Line 10. Line 10 must be used only if you are claiming
treaty benefits that require that you meet conditions not
covered by the representations you make on line 9 and
Part III. For example, persons claiming treaty benefits on
royalties must complete this line if the treaty contains
different withholding rates for different types of royalties.
However, this line should always be completed by foreign
students and researchers claiming treaty benefits. See
Scholarship and fellowship grants, later, for more
information.
This line is generally not applicable to treaty benefits
under an interest or dividends (other than dividends
subject to a preferential rate based on ownership) article
of a treaty.
Nonresident alien who becomes a resident alien.
Generally, only a nonresident alien individual can use the
terms of a tax treaty to reduce or eliminate U.S. tax on
certain types of income. However, most tax treaties
contain a provision known as a "saving clause" which
preserves or "saves" the right of each country to tax its
own residents as if no tax treaty existed. Exceptions
specified in the saving clause may permit an exemption
from tax to continue for certain types of income even after
the recipient has otherwise become a U.S. resident alien
for tax purposes. The individual must use Form W-9 to
claim the tax treaty benefit. See the instructions for Form
W-9 for more information. Also see Nonresident alien
student or researcher who becomes a resident alien, later,
for an example.
Scholarship and fellowship grants. A nonresident
alien student (including a trainee or business apprentice)
or researcher who receives noncompensatory scholarship
A CAUTION
-6-
or fellowship income can use Form W-8BEN to claim
benefits under a tax treaty that apply to reduce or
eliminate U.S. tax on such income. No Form W-8BEN is
required unless a treaty benefit is being claimed. A
nonresident alien student or researcher who receives
compensatory scholarship or fellowship income must use
Form 8233, instead of Form W-8BEN, to claim any
benefits of a tax treaty that apply to that income. The
student or researcher must use Form W-4 for any part of
such income for which he or she is not claiming a tax
treaty withholding exemption. Do not use Form W-8BEN
for compensatory scholarship or fellowship income. See
Compensation for Dependent Personal Services in the
Instructions for Form 8233.
If you are a nonresident alien individual who
received noncompensatory scholarship or
fellowship income and personal services income
(including compensatory scholarship or fellowship
income) from the same withholding agent, you may use
Form 8233 to claim a tax treaty withholding exemption for
part or all of both types of income.
Completing lines 3 and 9. Most tax treaties that
contain an article exempting scholarship or fellowship
grant income from taxation require that the recipient be a
resident of the other treaty country at the time of, or
immediately prior to, entry into the United States. Thus, a
student or researcher may claim the exemption even if he
or she no longer has a permanent address in the other
treaty country after entry into the United States. If this is
the case, you can provide a U.S. address on line 3 and
still be eligible for the exemption if all other conditions
required by the tax treaty are met. You must also identify
on line 9 the tax treaty country of which you were a
resident at the time of, or immediately prior to, your entry
into the United States.
Completing line 10. You must complete line 10 if you
are a student or researcher claiming an exemption from
taxation on your noncompensatory scholarship or
fellowship grant income under a tax treaty.
Nonresident alien student or researcher who
becomes a resident alien. You must use Form W-9 to
claim an exception to a saving clause. See Nonresident
alien who becomes a resident alien, earlier, for a general
explanation of saving clauses and exceptions to them.
Example. Article 20 of the U.S.-China income tax
treaty allows an exemption from tax for scholarship
income received by a Chinese student temporarily
present in the United States. Under U.S. law, this student
will become a resident alien for tax purposes if his or her
stay in the United States exceeds 5 calendar years.
However, paragraph 2 of the first protocol to the
U.S.-China treaty (dated April 30, 1984) allows the
provisions of Article 20 to continue to apply even after the
Chinese student becomes a resident alien of the United
States. A Chinese student who qualifies for this exception
(under paragraph 2 of the first protocol) and is relying on
this exception to claim an exemption from tax on his or her
scholarship or fellowship income would complete Form
W-9.
Part III
Form W-8BEN must be signed and dated by the beneficial
owner of the amount subject to withholding or the account
holder of an FFI (or an agent with legal authority to act on
the person's behalf). If Form W-8BEN is completed by an
agent acting under a duly authorized power of attorney for
the beneficial owner or account holder, the form must be
accompanied by the power of attorney in proper form or a
copy thereof specifically authorizing the agent to
represent the principal in making, executing, and
presenting the form. Form 2848, Power of Attomey and
Declaration of Representative, can be used for this
purpose. The agent, as well as the beneficial owner or
account holder, may incur liability for the penalties
provided for an erroneous, false, or fraudulent form.
A CAL) 0
If any information on Form W-8BEN becomes
incorrect, you must submit a new form within 30
days unless you are no longer an account holder
of the requester that is an FFI and you will not receive a
future payment with respect to the account.
Broker transactions or barter exchanges. Income
from transactions with a broker or a barter exchange is
subject to reporting rules and backup withholding unless
Form W-8BEN or a substitute form is filed to notify the
broker or barter exchange that you are an exempt foreign
person.
You are an exempt foreign person for a calendar year
in which:

• You are a nonresident alien individual or a foreign
corporation, partnership, estate, or trust;
• You are an individual who has not been, and does not
plan to be, present in the United States for a total of 183
days or more during the calendar year; and

• You are neither engaged, nor plan to be engaged
during the year, in a U.S. trade or business that has
effectively connected gains from transactions with a
broker or barter exchange.
Paperwork Reduction Act Notice. We ask for the
information on this form to carry out the Internal Revenue
laws of the United States. You are required to provide the
information. We need it to ensure that you are complying
with these laws and to allow us to figure and collect the
right amount of tax.
You are not required to provide the information
requested on a form that is subject to the Paperwork
Reduction Act unless the form displays a valid OMB
control number. Books or records relating to a form or its
instructions must be retained as long as their contents
may become material in the administration of any Internal
Revenue law. Generally, tax returns and return
information are confidential, as required by section 6103.
The time needed to complete and file this form will vary
depending on individual circumstances. The estimated
average time is:
Recordkeeping
Learning about the law or the form . .
Preparing the form
2 hr., 52 min.
2 hr., 05 min.
2 hr., 13 min.
-7-
If you have comments concerning the accuracy of
these time estimates or suggestions for making this form
simpler, we would be happy to hear from you. You can
send us comments from www.irs.govfiormspubs/. Click on
"More Information" and then on -Give us feedback".
You can write to Internal Revenue Service, Tax Forms
and Publications, SE:W:CAR:MP:TFP, 1111 Constitution
Ave. NW, IR-6526, Washington, DC 20224. Do not send
Form W-8BEN to this office. Instead, give it to your
withholding agent.
-8-
Form W-8BEN-E (February 2014)
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Do NOT use this form for: Instead use Form:

• U.S. entity or U.S. citizen or resident   W-9
• A foreign individual   W-8BEN (Individual)
• A foreign individual or entity claiming that income is effectively connected with the conduct of trade or business 
within the U.S
(unless claiming treaty benefits)  W-8ECI

• A foreign partnership. a foreign simple trust, or a foreign grantor trust (unless claiming treaty benefits) (see 
instructions for exceptions) .   W-8IM`f

• A foreign government. international organization, foreign central bank of issue, foreign tax-exempt organization. 
foreign private
foundation. or government of a U.S. possession claiming that income is effectively connected U.S. income or that is 
claiming
the applicability of section(s) 115(2). 501(c). 892. 895. or 1443(b) (unless claiming treaty benefits) (see 
instructions) . . . . W-8ECI or W-8EXP
• Any person acting as an intermediary   W-8IM`f
Certificate of Status of Beneficial Owner for
United States Tax Withholding and Reporting (Entities) a For use by entities. Individuals must use Form W-BBEN. a 
Section references en to the Internal Revenue
Code.
a Information about Form W-8BEN-E and its separate instructions is at www.in.govlIonnwabene.
a Give this form to the withholding agent or payer. Do not send to the IRS.
OMB No. 154S-1621
Part I
1 Name of organization that is the beneficial owner
Identification of Beneficial Owner
2 Country of incorporation or organization
3 Name of disregarded entity receiving the payment Of applicable)
4 Chapter 3 Status (entity type) (Must check one box only):
O Simple trust O Grantor trust
O Central Bank of Issue O Tax-exempt organization
❑ Corporation
El Complex trust
O Private foundation
O Disregarded entity
O Estate
If you entered disregarded entity. partnership, simple trust, or grantor trust above, is the entity a hybrid making a 
treaty
claim? If *Yes- complete Part III.
O Partnership
O Government
ID Yes El No
5 Chapter 4 Status (FATCA status) (Must check one box only unless otherwise indicated). (See instructions for details 
and complete the
certification below for the entity's applicable status).
O Nonparticipating FFI (including a limited FFI or an FFI related to a O Nonreporting IGA FFI (including an FFI treated 
as a registered
Reporting IGA FFI other than a registered deemed-compliant FFI deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable Model 2 IGA).
or participating FFI). Complete Part XII.
O Participating FFI. O Foreign government. government of a U.S. possession, or foreign
O Reporting Model 1 FFI. central bank of issue. Complete Part XIII.
O Reporting Model 2 FFI. O International organization. Complete Part XIV.
O Registered deemed-compliant FFI (other than a reporting Model 1 O Exempt retirement plans. Complete Part XV.
FFI or sponsored FFI that has not obtained a GIIN). O Entity wholly owned by exempt beneficial owners. Complete Part 
XVI.
O Sponsored FFI that has not obtained a GIIN. Complete Part IV. O Territory financial institution. Complete Part XVII.
O Certified deemed-compliant nonregistering local bank. Complete O Nonfinancial group entity. Complete Part XVIII.
Part V. O Excepted nonfinancial start-up company. Complete Part XIX.
O Certified deemed-compliant FFI with only low-value accounts. O Excepted nonfinancial entity in liquidation or 
bankruptcy.
Complete Part VI. Complete Part XX.
O Certified deemed-compliant sponsored. closely held investment O 501(c) organization. Complete Part XXI.
vehicle. Complete Part VII. O Nonprofit organization. Complete Part XXII.
O Certified deemed-compliant limited life debt investment entity. O Publicly traded NFFE or NFFE affiliate of a publicly
traded
Complete Part VIII. corporation. Complete Part XXIII.
O Certified deemed-compliant investment advisors and investment O Excepted territory NFFE. Complete Part XXIV.
managers. Complete Part IX. O Active NFFE. Complete Part XXV.
O Owner-documented FFI. Complete Part X. O Passive NFFE. Complete Part XXVI.
O Restricted distributor. Complete Part XI. O Excepted inter-affiliate FFI. Complete Part XXVII.
O Direct reporting NFFE.
❑ Sponsored direct reporti NFFE. Complete Part IIIXXV
6 Permanent residence address (street. apt. or suite no.. or meal route). Do not use a M. box or in-care-o1 address 
(other than a registered address).
City or town. state or province. Include postal code where appropriate. Country
7 Mailing address (If different from above)
City or town. state or province. Include postal code where appropriate. Country
8 U.S. taxpayer identification number (TIN). if required 9a O GIIN b O Foreign TIN 10 Reference number(s) (see 
instructions)
Note. Please complete remainder of the form including signing the form in Part XXIX.
For Paperwork Reduction Act Notice, see separate instructions. cat. No. 59689N Form W-8BEN-E (2-2014)
Form w-88EN-E (2-2014) Page 2
Part II Disregarded Entity or Branch Receiving Payment. (Complete only if disregarded entity or branch of an
FFI in a country other than the FFI's country of residence.)
11 Chapter 4 Status (FATCA status) of disregarded entity or branch receiving payment
O Limited Branch. O Reporting Model 1 FFI. O U.S. Branch.
O Participating FFI. O Reporting Model 2 FFI.
12 Address of disregarded entity or branch (street. apt. or suite no.. or rural route). Do not use a M. box or In-care 
-of address (other than a
registered address).
City or town, state or province. Include postal code where appropriate.
Country
13 GIIN (if any)
Part III Claim of Tax Treaty Benefits (rf applicable). (For chapter 3 purposes only)
14 I certify that (check all that apply):
a O The beneficial owner is a resident of  within the meaning of the income tax
treaty between the United States and that country.
b O The beneficial owner derives the Item (or Items) of income for which the treaty benefits are claimed. and. if 
applicable. meets the
requirements of the treaty provision dealing with limitation on benefits (see instructions).
c O The beneficial owner is claiming treaty benefits for dividends received from a foreign corporation or interest from 
a U.S. trade or business
of a foreign corporation and meets qualified resident status (see instructions).
15 Special rates and conditions (if applicable—see instructions): The beneficial owner is claiming the provisions of 
Article
of the treaty identified on line 14a above to claim a  % rate of withholding on (specify type of income):
Explain the reasons the beneficial owner meets the terms of the treaty article:
Sponsored FFI That Has Not Obtained a GIIN
16 Name of sponsoring entity:
17 Check whichever box applies.
El I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is an FFI solely because it is an investment entity:
• Is not a QI. WP. or WT: and
• Has agreed with the entity identified above (that is not a nonparticipating FFI) to act as the sponsoring entity for 
this entity.
O I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is a controlled foreign corporation as defined in section 957(a):
• Is not a QI. WP. or WT:
• Is wholly owned. directly or indirectly. by the U.S. financial institution identified above that agrees to act as the 
sponsoring entity for this
entity: and

• Shares a common electronic account system with the sponsoring entity (Identified above) that enables the sponsoring 
entity to identify all
account holders and payees of the entity and to access all account and customer information maintained by the entity 
including. but not
limited to. customer identification information. customer documentation. account balance. and all payments made to 
account holders or
payees.
Part V
18 O I certify that the FFI Identified in Part I:

• Operates and is licensed solely as a bank or credit union (or similar cooperative credit organization operated without
profit) in its country of
incorporation or organization:

• Engages primarily in the business of receiving deposits from and making loans to. with respect to a bank. retail 
customers unrelated to such
bank and. with respect to a credit union or similar cooperative credit organization. members. provided that no member 
has a greater than five
percent interest in such credit union or cooperative credit organization:

• Does not solicit account holders outside its country of organization:
• Has no fixed place of business outside such country (for this purpose. a fixed place of business does not include a 
location that is not
advertised to the public and from which the FFI performs solely administrative support functions):

• Has no more than $175 million in assets on its balance sheet and. if it is a member of an expanded affiliated group, 
the group has no more
than $500 million in total assets on its consolidated or combined balance sheets: and

• Does not have any member of its expanded affiliated group that is a foreign financial institution. other than a 
foreign financial institution that
is incorporated or organized in the same country as the FFI identified in Part I and that meets the requirements set 
forth in this Part V.
Certified Deemed -Compliant Nonregistering Local Bank
Form W-8BEN-E (2-2014)
Form W-88EN-E (2-2014) Page 3
learill Certified Deemed-Compliant FFI with Only Low-Value Accounts
19 0 I certify that the FFI Identified in Part I:

• Is not engaged primarily in the business of investing, reinvesting. or trading in securities. partnership interests, 
commodities. notional
principal contracts. insurance or annuity contracts. or any interest (including a futures or forward contract or option)
in such security,
partnership interest. commodity. notional principal contract, insurance contract or annuity contract:

• No financial account maintained by the FFI or any member of its expanded affiliated group, if any. has a balance or 
value in excess of
$50,000 (as determined after applying applicable account aggregation rules): and

• Neither the FFI nor the entire expanded affiliated group. if any. of the FFI, have more than $50 million in assets on 
its consolidated or
combined balance sheet as of the end of its most recent accounting year.
Part VII Certified Deemed-Compliant Sponsored, Closely Held Investment Vehicle
20 Name of sponsoring entity:
21 0 I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is an FFI solely because it is an investment entity described in §1.1471-5(e)(4):
• Is not a 01, WP, or WT:

• Has a contractual relationship with the above identified sponsoring entity that agrees to fulfill all due diligence, 
withholding. and reporting
responsibilities of a participating FFI on behalf of this entity; and

• Twenty or fewer individuals own all of the debt and equity interests in the entity (disregarding debt interests owned 
by U.S. financial
institutions. participating FFIs. registered deemed-compliant FFIs. and certified deemed-compliant FFIs and equity 
interests owned by an
entity if that entity owns 100 percent of the equity interests in the FFI and is itself a sponsored FFI).
Part VIII
22 0 I certify that the entity identified in Past I:

• Was in existence a of January 17, 2013;
• Issued all classes of its debt or equity interests to investors on or before January 17. 2013. pursuant to a trust 
indenture or similar agreement; and

• Is certified deemed-compliant because it satisfies the requirements to be treated as a limited life debt investment 
entity (such as the
restrictions with respect to its assets and other requirements under § 1.1471.50)(2)0v)).
Part IX
Certified Deemed-Compliant Limited Life Debt Investment Entity
Certified Deemed-Compliant Investment Advisors and Investment Managers
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is a financial institution solely because it is an investment entity described in §1.1471.5(e)(4X0(A): and

• Does not maintain financial accounts.
Owner-Documented FFI
Note. This status only applies if the U.S. financial institution or participating FFI to which this form is given has 
agreed that it will treat the FFI as an
owner-documented FFI (see instructions for eligibility requirements). In addition, the FFI must make the certifications 
below.
24a 0 (All owner-documented FFIs check here) I certify that the FFI identified in Part I:

• Does not act as an intermediary;
• Does not accept deposits in the ordinary course of a banking or similar business;

• Does not hold. as a substantial portion of its business, financial assets for the account of others:

• Is not an insurance company (or the holding company of an insurance company) that issues or is obligated to make 
payments with respect to
a financial account;

• Is not owned by or in an expanded affiliated group with an entity that accepts deposits in the ordinary course of a 
banking or similar
business. holds, as a substantial portion of its business, financial assets for the account of others. or is an 
insurance company (or the holding
company of an insurance company) that issues or is obligated to make payments with respect to a financial account: and

• Does not maintain a financial account for any nonparticipating FFI.
Form W-8BEN-E (2-2014)
Fowl, w-BEEN-E (2-2014) Page 4
Part X Owner-Documented FFI (continued)
Check box 24b or 24c, whichever applies.
b ❑ I certify that the FFI Identified in Part I:

• Has provided. or will provide. an FFI owner reporting statement that contains:
• The name, address, TIN (if any). chapter 4 status, and type of documentation provided (if required) of every 
individual and specified U.S.
person that owns a direct or Indirect equity interest in the owner-documented FFI (looking through all entities other 
than specified U.S.
persons):

• The name. address. TIN (if any). chapter 4 status. and type of documentation provided (if required) of every 
individual and specified U.S.
person that owns a debt interest in the owner-documented FFI (including any indirect debt interest, which includes debt 
interests in any
entity that directly or indirectly owns the payee or any direct or indirect equity interest in a debt holder of the 
payee) that constitutes a
financial account in excess of $50.000 (disregarding all such debt interests owned by participating FFIs. registered 
deemed-compliant FFIs.
certified deemed-compliant FFIs. excepted NFFEs. exempt beneficial owners. or U.S. persons other than specified U.S. 
persons): and

• Any additional information the withholding agent requests in order to fulfill its obligations with respect to the 
entity.
c ❑ I certify that the FFI Identified in Part I has provided. or will provide. an auditor's letter. signed within four 
years of the date of payment.
from an independent accounting firm or legal representative with a location in the United States stating that the firm 
or representative has
reviewed the FFI's documentation with respect to all of its owners and debt holders identified in 
§1.1471-3(d)(6)(ivXA)(2). and that the FFI
meets all the requirements to be an owner-documented FR The FFI Identified in Part I has also provided. or will provide,
an FFI owner
reporting statement of its owners that are specified U.S. persons and Form(s) W-9. with applicable waivers.
Check box 24d if applicable.
d ❑ I certify that the entity identified in line 1 is a trust that does not have any contingent beneficiaries or 
designated classes with unidentified
beneficiaries.
Part XI
25a
Restricted Distributor
❑ (All restricted distributors check here) I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Operates as a distributor with respect to debt or equity interests of the restricted fund with respect to which this 
form is furnished;

• Provides investment services to at least 30 customers unrelated to each other and less than half of its customers are 
related to each other:

• Is required to perform AML due diligence procedures under the anti-money laundering laws of its country of 
organization (which is an FATF-
compliant jurisdiction):

• Operates solely in its country of incorporation or organization, has no fixed place of business outside of that 
country, and has the same
country of incorporation or organization as all members of its affiliated group. if any:

• Does not solicit customers outside its country of incorporation or organization:
• Has no more than $175 million in total assets under management and no more than $7 million in gross revenue on its 
income statement for
the most recent accounting year.

• Is not a member of an expanded affiliated group that has more than $500 million in total assets under management or 
more than $20 million
in gross revenue for its most recent accounting year on a combined or consolidated income statement: and

• Does not distribute any debt or securities of the restricted fund to specified U.S. persons, passive NFFEs with one or
more substantial U.S.
owners. or nonparticipating FFIs.
Check box 25b or 25c, whichever applies.
I further certify that with respect to all sales of debt or equity interests in the restricted fund with respect to 
which this form is furnished that are made
after December 31. 2011. the entity identified in Part I:
b ❑ Has been bound by a distribution agreement that contained a general prohibition on the sale of debt or securities to
U.S. entities and U.S.
resident individuals and is currently bound by a distribution agreement that contains a prohibition of the sale of debt 
or securities to any
specified U.S. person. passive NFFE with one or more substantial U.S. owners. or nonparticipating FFI.

• ❑ Is currently bound by a distribution agreement that contains a prohibition on the sale of debt or securities to any 
specified U.S. person.
passive NFFE with one or more substantial U.S. owners. or nonparticipating FFI and, for all sales made prior to the time
that such a
restriction was included in its distribution agreement. has reviewed all accounts related to such sales in accordance 
with the procedures
identified in §1.1471-4(c) applicable to preexisting accounts and has redeemed or retired any, or caused the restricted 
fund to transfer the
securities to a distributor that is a participating FFI or reporting Model 1 FFI securities which were sold to specified
U.S. persons. passive
NFFEs with one or more substantial U.S. owners, or nonparticipating FFIs.
Part XII
26 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Meets the requirements to be considered a nonreporting financial institution pursuant to an applicable IGA between the
United States and
Nonreportin9 IGA FFI

• Is treated as a  under the provisions of the applicable IGA (see instructions): and
• If you are an FFI treated as a registered deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable Model 2 IGA. provide your GIIN:
Form W-8BEN-E (2-2014)
Form W-8BEN-E (2-2014) Page 5
Part XIII
27 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is the beneficial owner of the payment and is not engaged in 
commercial financial activities of a
type engaged in by an insurance company. custodial institution. or depository institution with respect to the payments. 
accounts. or
obligations for which this form is submitted (except as permitted in §1.1471-6(h)(2)).
Part XIV
Foreign Government, Government of a U.S. Possession, or Foreign Central Bank of Issue
International Organization
Check box 28a or 28b, whichever applies.
28a ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is an international organization described in section 7701(a)(18).
b ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is comprised primarily of foreign governments:
• Is recognized as an intergovernmental or supranational organization under a foreign law similar to the International 
Organizations Immunities
Act:

• The benefit of the entity's income does not inure to any private person:
• Is the beneficial owner of the payment and is not engaged in commercial financial activities of a type engaged in by 
an insurance company.
custodial institution. or depository institution with respect to the payments. accounts. or obligations for which this 
form is submitted (except as
permitted in §1.1471-6(h)(2)).
Part XV Exempt Retirement Plans
Check box 29a, b, c, d, e, or 1, whichever applies.
29a ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is established in a country with which the United States has an income tax treaty in force (see Part III if claiming 
treaty benefits):

• Is operated principally to administer or provide pension or retirement benefits: and
• Is entitled to treaty benefits on income that the fund derives from U.S. sources (or would be entitled to benefits if 
it derived any such income)
as a resident of the other country which satisfies any applicable limitation on benefits requirement.
b ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is organized for the provision of retirement. disability, or death benefits (or any combination thereof) to 
beneficiaries that are former
employees of one or more employers in consideration for services rendered:

• No single beneficiary has a right to more than 5% of the FFI's assets:
• Is subject to government regulation and provides annual information reporting about its beneficiaries to the relevant 
tax authorities in the
country in which the fund is established or operated: and

• Is generally exempt from tax on investment income under the laws of the country in which it is established or operates
due to its status as
a retirement or pension plan:

• Receives at least 50% of its total contributions from sponsoring employers (disregarding transfers of assets from 
other plans described in
this part. retirement and pension accounts described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA. other retirement funds 
described in an
applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA. or accounts described in §1.1471-5(b)(2)(i)(A)):

• Either does not permit or penalizes distributions or withdrawals made before the occurrence of specified events 
related to retirement.
disability. or death (except rollover distributions to accounts described in §1.1471-5(b)(2)(i)(A) (referring to 
retirement and pension accounts).
to retirement and pension accounts described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA. or to other retirement funds 
described in this part or
in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA): or

• Limits contributions by employees to the fund by reference to earned income of the employee or may not exceed $50.000 
annually.

• ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:
• Is organized for the provision of retirement. disability, or death benefits (or any combination thereof) to 
beneficiaries that are former
employees of one or more employers in consideration for services rendered:

• Has fewer than 50 participants:
• Is sponsored by one or more employers each of which is not an investment entity or passive NFFE:

• Employee and employer contributions to the fund (disregarding transfers of assets from other plans described in this 
part. retirement and
pension accounts described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA. or accounts described in §1.1471-5(b)(2)(i)(A)) are 
limited by reference to
earned income and compensation of the employee. respectively:

• Participants that are not residents of the country in which the fund is established or operated are not entitled to 
more than 20 percent of the
fund's assets: and

• Is subject to government regulation and provides annual information reporting about its beneficiaries to the relevant 
tax authorities in the
country in which the fund is established or operates.
d ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is formed pursuant to a pension plan that would meet the requirements
of section 401(a). other
than the requirement that the plan be funded by a trust created or organized in the United States.

• ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is established exclusively to earn income for the benefit of one or 
more retirement funds
described in this part or in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA. accounts described in §1.1471-5(b)(2)(i)(A) 
(referring to retirement and
pension accounts). or retirement and pension accounts described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA.
Form W-8BEN-E (2-2014)
Form W-8SEN-E (2-2014) Page 6
Lauri Exempt Retirement Plans (Continued)
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is established and sponsored by a foreign government. international organization. central bank of issue, or government
of a U.S. possession
(each as defined in §1.1471-6) or an exempt beneficial owner described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA to 
provide retirement,
disability, or death benefits to beneficiaries or participants that are current or former employees of the sponsor (or 
persons designated by such
employees): or

• Is established and sponsored by a foreign government. international organization. central bank of issue. or government
of a U.S. possession
(each as defined in §1.1471-6) or an exempt beneficial owner described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA to 
provide retirement,
disability. or death benefits to beneficiaries or participants that are not current or former employees of such sponsor.
but are in consideration
of personal services performed for the sponsor.
Part XVI
30 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is an FFI solely because it is an investment entity:
• Each direct holder of an equity interest in the investment entity is an exempt beneficial owner described in §1.1471-6
or in an applicable
Model 1 or Model 2 IGA:

• Each direct holder of a debt interest in the investment entity is either a depository institution (with respect to a 
loan made to such entity) or an
exempt beneficial owner described in §1.1471-6 or an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA.

• Has provided an owner reporting statement that contains the name. address. TIN (if any). chapter 4 status. and a 
description of the type of
documentation provided to the withholding agent for every person that owns a debt interest constituting a financial 
account or direct equity
interest in the entity: and

• Has provided documentation establishing that every owner of the entity is an entity described in §1.1471-6(b), (c), 
(d), (e). (0 and/or (g) without
regard to whether such owners are beneficial owners.
Territory Financial Institution
31 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a financial institution (other than an investment entity) that is
incorporated or organized under
the laws of a possession of the United States.
Excepted Nonfinancial Group Entity
32 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is a holding company. treasury center. Of captive finance company and substantially all of the entity's activities are
functions described in
§1.1471-5(e)(5)(1)(C) through (E):

• Is a member of a nonfinancial group described in §1.1471-5(e)(5)0)(8):
• Is not a depository or custodial institution (other than for members of the entity's expanded af0liated group): and

• Does not function (or hold itself out) as an investment fund, such as a private equity fund, venture capital fund. 
leveraged buyout fund, or any
investment vehicle with an investment strategy to acquire or fund companies and then hold interests in those companies 
as capital assets for
investment purposes.
Entity Wholly Owned by Exempt Beneficial Owners
Part XVIII
Part XIX Excepted Nonfinancial Start -Up Company
33 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Was formed on (or. in the case of a new line of business, the date of board resolution approving the new line of 
business)
(date must be less than 24 months prior to date of payment):

• Is not yet operating a business and has no prior operating history or is investing capital in assets with the intent 
to operate a new line of
business other than that of a financial institution or passive NFFE:

• Is investing capital into assets with the intent to operate a business other than that of a financial institution: and

• Does not function (or hold itself out) as an investment fund. such as a private equity fund. venture capital fund, 
leveraged buyout fund, or any
investment vehicle whose purpose is to acquire or fund companies and then hold interests in those companies as capital 
assets for investment purposes.
laud Excepted Nonfinancial Entity in Liquidation or Bankruptcy
34 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Filed a plan of liquidation. filed a plan of reorganization. or filed for bankruptcy on
• During the past 5 years has not been engaged in business as a financial institution or acted as a passive NFFE:

• Is either liquidating or emerging from a reorganization or bankruptcy with the intent to continue or recommence 
operations as a nonfinancial
entity: and

• Has. or will provide. documentary evidence such as a bankruptcy filing or other public documentation that supports its
claim if it remains in
bankruptcy or liquidation for more than three years.
Part XXI
35 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a 501(c) organization that:

• Has been issued a determination letter from the IRS that is currently in effect concluding that the payee is a section
501(c) organization that is
dated  : or

• Has provided a copy of an opinion from U.S. counsel certifying that the payee is a section 501(c) organization 
(without regard to whether the
payee is a foreign private foundation).
501(c) Organization
Form W-8BEN-E (2-2014)
Form W-88EN-E (2-2014) Page 7
tiat ita  Non-Profit Organization
36 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a non-profit organization that meets the following requirements:

• The entity is established and maintained in its country of residence exclusively for religious. charitable. 
scientific. artistic, cultural or educational
purposes:

• The entity is exempt from income tax in its country of residence:
• The entity has no shareholders or members who have a proprietary or beneficial interest in its income or assets:

• Neither the applicable laws of the entity's country of residence nor the entity's formation documents permit any 
income or assets of the entity
to be distributed to. or applied for the benefit of. a private person or non-charitable entity other than pursuant to 
the conduct of the entity's
charitable activities or as payment of reasonable compensation for services rendered or payment representing the fair 
market value of property
which the entity has purchased: and

• The applicable laws of the entity's country of residence or the entity's formation documents require that. upon the 
entity's liquidation or
dissolution, all of its assets be distributed to an entity that is a foreign government. an integral part of a foreign 
government, a controlled entity
of a foreign government. or another organization that is described in this Part XXII or escheats to the government of 
the entity's country of
residence or any political subdivision thereof.
Part XXIII Publicly Traded NFFE or NFFE Affiliate of a Publicly Traded Corporation
Check box 37a or 37b, whichever applies.
37a ❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is a foreign corporation that is not a financial institution: and
• The stock of such corporation is regularly traded on one or more established securities markets, including
(name one securities exchange upon which the stock is regularly traded).
b ❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is a foreign corporation that is not a financial institution:
• The entity identified in Part I is a member of the same expanded affiliated group as an entity the stock of which is 
regularly traded on an
established securities market:

• The name of the entity. the stock of which is regularly traded on an established securities market. is   : and

• The name of the securities market on which the stock is regularly traded is
Part XXIV Excepted Territory NFFE
38 ❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is an entity that is organized in a possession of the United States:

• The entity identified in Part I:
• Does not accept deposits in the ordinary course of a banking or similar business.

• Does not hold. as a substantial portion of its business, financial assets for the account of others. or

• Is not an insurance company (or the holding company of an insurance company) that issues or is obligated to make 
payments with respect
to a financial account: and

• All of the owners of the entity identified in Part I are bona fide residents of the possession in which the NFFE is 
organized or incorporated.
Part XXV Active NFFE
❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is a foreign entity that is not a financial institution:
• Less than 50% of such entity's gross income for the preceding calendar year is passive income: and

• Less than 50% of the assets held by such entity are assets that produce or are held for the production of passive 
income (calculated as a
weighted average of the percentage of passive assets measured quarterly) (see instructions for the definition of passive
income).
Passive NFFE Part XXVI
40a ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a foreign entity that is not a financial institution (other than
an investment entity organized in a
possession of the United States) and is not certifying its status as a publicly traded NFFE (or affiliate). excepted 
territory NFFE. active
NFFE. direct reporting NFFE. or sponsored direct reporting NFFE.
Check box 40b or 40c, whichever applies.
b ❑ I further certify that the entity identified in Part I has no substantial U.S. owners. or
c ❑ I further certify that the entity identified in Part I has provided the name, address. and TIN of each substantial 
U.S. owner of the NFFE in Part )00(
Excepted Inter -Affiliate FFI Part XXVII
41 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is a member of an expanded affiliated group:
• Does not maintain financial accounts (other than accounts maintained for members of its expanded affiliated group):

• Does not make withholdable payments to any person other than to members of its expanded affiliated group that are not 
limited FFIs or
limited branches:

• Does not hold an account (other than a depository account in the country in which the entity is operating to pay for 
expenses) with or receive
payments from any withholding agent other than a member of its expanded affiliated group: and

• Has not agreed to report under §1.t471.4(d)(2)0li)(C) or otherwise act as an agent for chapter 4 purposes on behalf of
any financial institution. including
a member of its expanded affiliated group.
Form W-8BEN-E (2-2014)
Form W-88EN-E (2-2014) Page 8
Part XXVIII Sponsored Direct Reporting NFFE
42 Name of sponsoring entity:
43 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I Is a direct reporting NFFE that is sponsored by the entity 
identified in line 42.
Part XXIX Certification
Under penalties of Iselin. I declare that I have examined the information on this form and to the best of my knowledge 
and belief it is true, correct, and
complete. I further
certify under penalties of perjury that:

• The entity identified on Irks 1 of this form is the beneficial owner of all the income to which this tom, relates. is 
tang this form to certify its status for
chapter 4
purposes. or is a merchant sutaittng this form for purposes of section 6050W.

• The entity identified on line 1 of this form is not a U.S. person.
• The raceme to which this teem relates is: (a) not effectively connected with the conduct of a trade or business in the
United States. (b) effectively
connected but is
not subject to tax under an income tax treaty, or (c) the partner's share of a partnership's effectively connected 
income. and
• For broker transacticos or barter exchanges. the beneficial owner is an exempt foreign person as defined in the 
instructions.
Furthermore. I authorize this fan to be provided to any withholding agent that has control. receipt. or custody of the 
ncome of which the entity on line 1 is
the beneficial
owner or any withholding agent that can disburse or make payments of the income of which the entity on line 1 is the 
beneficial owner.
I agree that I will submit a new form within 30 days If any certification on this form becomes incorrect.
Sign Here
Signature of individual authorized to sign for beneficial owner Print Name Date (MM-DD-YYYY)
❑ I certify that I have the capacity to sign for the entity identified on line 1 of this form.
Substantial U.S. Owners of Passive NFFE
As required by Part KOJI, provide the name, address, and TIN of each substantial U.S. owner of the NFFE. Please see 
instructions for definition of
substantial U.S. owner.
Name Address TIN
Fam W-8BEN-E (2-2ou)
Instructions for
Form W-8BEN-E (June 2014)
Certificate of Status of Beneficial Owner for
United States Tax Withholding and Reporting (Entities)
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Section references are to the Internal Revenue Code
unless otherwise noted.
Future Developments
For the latest information about developments related to
Form W-8BEN-E and its instructions, such as legislation
enacted after they were published, go to www.irs.gov/
formw8bene.
What's New
FATCA. In 2010, Congress passed iring Incentives
to Restore Employment Act of 2010,111-147 (the
HIRE Act), which added chapter 4 of Subtitle A
(chapter 4) to the Code, consisting of sections 1471
through 1474 of the Code and commonly referred to as
"FATCA" or "chapter 4." Under chapter 4, foreign financial
institutions (FFIs) that are participating FFIs and certain
registered deemed-compliant FFIs are generally required
to identify their U.S. account holders, regardless of
whether a payment subject to withholding is made to their
accounts. In January 2013, final regulations were
published that provide due diligence, withholding, and
reporting rules for both U.S. withholding agents and FFIs
under chapter 4. Additionally, temporary and proposed
regulations were released in February 2014 providing
updated rules under chapter 4 as well as guidance
coordinating chapters 3 and 61 with the requirements of
chapter 4. U.S. withholding agents and FFIs will be
required to begin withholding on withholdable payments
for chapter 4 purposes beginning on July 1, 2014.
This form, along with Forms W-8ECI, W-8EXP, and
W-81MY, has been updated to reflect the documentation
requirements of chapter 4. In particular, this Form
W-8BEN-E is now used exclusively by entities to
document their status both as a payee under chapter 4
and beneficial owner under chapter 3 (chapter 3) of the
Code when required (including an entity eligible to claim
treaty benefits for reduced withholding), and under certain
other sections of the Code to establish their status for
withholding or reporting purposes. Individuals
documenting their foreign status (or making a claim of
treaty benefits for reduced withholding) should use Form
W-8BEN instead of this form.
An entity account holder holding accounts with certain
FFIs that does not document its applicable chapter 4
status when required may be treated as a recalcitrant
account holder or nonparticipating FFI and will be subject
to 30% withholding on withholdable payments it receives
from the FFI. A foreign entity account holder can avoid
being classified as a recalcitrant account holder or
nonparticipating FFI by using this form to document its
applicable chapter 4 status.
Chapter 4 also requires withholding agents to withhold
on certain payments made to a foreign entity that does not
document its chapter 4 status and, in some cases,
disclose its substantial U.S. owners. In general, a foreign
entity receiving a withholdable payment should provide
this form when requested to avoid withholding
consequences.
Reportable payment card transactions. Section
6050W was added by section 3091 of the Housing
Assistance Tax Act of 2008 and requires information
returns to be made by certain payers with respect to
payments made to participating payees (as defined in
Regulations section 1.6050W-1(a)(5)) in settlement of
payment card transactions and third party payment
network transactions. Information returns are not required
with respect to payments made to payees that are foreign
persons, however.
A payer of a reportable payment for chapter 61
purposes (i.e., Form 1099 reporting purposes) may treat a
payee as foreign if the payer receives an applicable Form
W-8 from the payee. Provide this Form W-8BEN-E to the
requestor if you are a foreign entity that is a participating
payee receiving payments in settlement of payment card
or third party network transactions that are not effectively
connected with a U.S. trade or business of the
participating payee.
General Instructions
For definitions of terms used throughout these
instructions, see Definitions, later.
Purpose of Form
This form is used by foreign entities to document their
status for purposes of chapter 3 and chapter 4, as well as
for certain other code provisions.
Foreign persons are subject to U.S. tax at a 30% rate
(the foreign-person withholding rate) on income they
receive from U.S. sources that consists of:

• Interest (including certain original issue discount (OID));
• Dividends;
• Rents;
• Royalties;
• Premiums;

• Annuities;
• Compensation for, or in expectation of, services
performed;
• Substitute payments in a securities lending transaction;
or
Jun 20, 2014 Cat. No. 59691Z

• Other fixed or determinable annual or periodical gains,
profits, or income.
This tax is imposed on the gross amount paid and is
generally collected by withholding under section 1441 or
1442 on that amount. A payment is considered to have
been made whether it is made directly to the beneficial
owner or to another person, such as an intermediary,
agent, or partnership, for the benefit of the beneficial
owner.
In addition, section 1446 requires a partnership
conducting a trade or business in the United States to
withhold tax on a foreign partner's distributive share of the
partnership's effectively connected taxable income.
Generally, a foreign person that is a partner in a
partnership that submits a Form W-8 for purposes of
section 1441 or 1442 will satisfy the documentation
requirements under section 1446 as well. However, in
some cases the documentation requirements of sections
1441 and 1442 do not match the documentation
requirements of section 1446. See Regulations sections
1.1446-1 through 1.1446-6. Further, the owner of a
disregarded entity, rather than the disregarded entity
itself, submits the appropriate Form W-8 for purposes of
section 1446.
A withholding agent or payer of the income may rely on
a properly completed Form W-8BEN-E to treat a payment
associated with the Form W-8BEN-E as a payment to a
foreign person who beneficially owns the amounts paid. If
applicable, the withholding agent may rely on the Form
W-8BEN-E to apply a reduced rate of, or exemption from,
withholding. If you receive certain types of income, you
must provide Form W-8BEN-E to:

• Claim that you are the beneficial owner of the income
for which Form W-8BEN-E is being provided or a partner
in a partnership subject to section 1446; and

• If applicable, claim a reduced rate of, or exemption
from, withholding as a resident of a foreign country with
which the United States has an income tax treaty that is
eligible for treaty benefits.
You may also use Form W-8BEN-E to identify income
from a notional principal contract that is not effectively
connected with the conduct of a trade or business in the
United States to establish the exception to reporting such
income on Form 1042-S. See Regulations section
1.1461-1(c)(2)(ii)(F).
You may also be required to submit Form W-8BEN-E to
claim an exception from domestic information reporting on
Form 1099 and backup withholding (at the backup
withholding rate under section 3406) for certain types of
income. Such income includes:

• Broker proceeds.
• Short-term (183 days or less) original issue discount
(short-term OID).
• Bank deposit interest.

• Foreign source interest, dividends, rents, or royalties.
Provide Form W-8BEN-E to the withholding agent or
payer before income is paid or credited to you. Failure to
provide a Form W-8BEN-E when requested may lead to
withholding at a 30% rate (foreign-person withholding
rate) or the backup withholding rate.
In addition to the requirements of chapter 3, chapter 4
requires withholding agents to identity the chapter 4 status
of entities that are payees receiving withholdable
payments (see the instructions for Part I, line 5, of this
form, later). A withholding agent may request this Form
W-8BEN-E to establish your chapter 4 status and avoid
withholding at a 30% rate (the chapter 4 rate) on such
payments.
Chapter 4 also requires participating FFIs and certain
registered deemed-compliant FFIs to document their
entity account holders in order to determine their
chapter 4 status regardless of whether withholding applies
to any payments made to the entities. If you are an entity
maintaining an account with an FFI, provide this Form
W-8BEN-E when requested by the FFI in order to
document your chapter 4 status.
Additional information. For additional information and
instructions for the withholding agent, see the Instructions
for the Requester of Forms W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E,
W-8ECI, W-8EXP, and W-81MY.
Who Must Provide Form W-8BEN-E
You must give Form W-8BEN-E to the withholding agent
or payer it you are a foreign entity receiving a withholdable
payment from a withholding agent, receiving a payment
subject to chapter 3 withholding, or if you are such an
entity maintaining an account with an FFI requesting this
form.
Do not use Form W-8BEN-E if you are described
below.

• You are U.S. person (including U.S. citizens, resident
aliens, and entities treated as U.S. persons, such as a
corporation organized under the law of a state). Instead,
use Form W-9, Request for Taxpayer Identification
Number and Certification.

• You are a foreign insurance company that has made an
election under section 953(d) to be treated as a U.S.
person. Instead, provide a withholding agent with Form
W-9 to certify to your U.S. status even if you are
considered an FFI for purposes of chapter 4.

• You are a nonresident alien individual. Instead, use
Form W-8BEN, Certificate of Foreign Status of Beneficial
Owner for United States Tax Withholding and Reporting
(Individuals).

• You are a disregarded entity with a single owner that is
a U.S. person and you are not a hybrid entity claiming
treaty benefits. Instead, the single owner should provide
Form W-9.

• You are a disregarded entity with a single owner that is
not a U.S. person or a branch of an FFI claiming its status
for chapter 4 purposes and you are not a hybrid entity
claiming treaty benefits. Instead, the single owner should
provide Form W-8BEN or Form W-8BEN-E (as
appropriate). Note, however, that the single entity owner
may be required to identify the branch (including a
disregarded entity) in Part II of the owner's Form
W-8BEN-E and, in some cases, provide the legal name of
the disregarded entity in Part I, line 3 (see the specific
instructions for line 3, later).

• You are acting as an intermediary (that is, acting not for
your own account, but for the account of others as an
agent, nominee, or custodian), a qualified intermediary, or
-2- Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014)
a qualified securities lender (QSL) with regard to a
payment of U.S. source substitute dividends. Instead,
provide Form W-8IMY, Certificate of Foreign Intermediary,
Foreign Flow-Through Entity, or Certain U.S. Branches for
United States Tax Withholding and Reporting.

• You are receiving income that is effectively connected
with the conduct of a trade or business in the United
States, unless it is allocable to you through a partnership.
Instead, provide Form W-8EC1, Certificate of Foreign
Person's Claim That Income Is Effectively Connected
With the Conduct of a Trade or Business in the United
States. If any of the income for which you have provided a
Form W-8BEN-E becomes effectively connected, this is a
change in circumstances and Form W-8BEN-E is no
longer valid. You must file Form W-8ECI. See Change in
circumstances, later.

• You are filing for a foreign government, international
organization, foreign central bank of issue, foreign
tax-exempt organization, foreign private foundation, or
govemment of a U.S. possession claiming the
applicability of section 115(2), 501(c), 892, 895, or
1443(b). Instead, provide Form W-8EXP, Certificate of
Foreign Govemment or Other Foreign Organization for
United States Tax Withholding and Reporting, to certify as
to your exemption and identify your applicable chapter 4
status. However, provide Form W-8BEN-E if you are
claiming treaty benefits, providing the form only to claim
you are a foreign person exempt from backup withholding,
or providing this form solely to document your chapter 4
status. For example, a foreign tax-exempt entity receiving
royalty income that is not exempt because it is taxable as
unrelated business income but is eligible for a reduced
rate of withholding under a royalty article of a tax treaty
should provide Form W-8BEN-E. You should use Form
W-8ECI if you are receiving effectively connected income
(for example, income from commercial activities that is not
exempt under an applicable section of the Code).

• You are a foreign flow-through entity receiving a
withholdable payment or a payment subject to chapter 3
withholding, other than a hybrid entity claiming treaty
benefits on its own behalf. Instead, provide Form W-8IMY.
However, if you are a foreign partner, beneficiary, or
owner of a flow-through entity and you are not yourself a
flow-through entity, you may be required to furnish a Form
W-8BEN-E with respect to your interest in the
flow-through entity. If you are not receiving withholdable
payments or payments subject to withholding under
chapter 3, however, a foreign flow-through entity may still
provide this Form W-8BEN-E to an FFI requesting this
form solely for purposes of documenting your account as
part of its due diligence obligations under chapter 4 or an
applicable IGA.

• You are a reverse hybrid entity transmitting beneficial
owner documentation provided by your interest holders to
claim treaty benefits on their behalf. Instead, provide Form
W-8IMY.

• You are a withholding foreign partnership or a
withholding foreign trust within the meaning of sections
1441 and 1442 and the accompanying regulations. A
withholding foreign partnership or a withholding foreign
trust is a foreign partnership or trust that has entered into
a withholding agreement with the IRS under which it
agrees to assume primary withholding responsibility for
each partner's, beneficiary's, or owner's distributive share
of income subject to withholding under chapters 3 and 4
that is paid to the partnership or trust. Instead, provide
Form W-RIMY.

• You are a foreign partnership or foreign grantor trust
providing documentation for purposes of section 1446.
Instead, provide Form W-8IMY and accompanying
documentation. See Regulations sections 1.1446-1
through 1.1446-6.
• You are a foreign branch of a U.S. financial institution
that is an FFI (other than a qualified intermediary branch)
under an applicable Model 1 IGA. For purposes of
identifying yourself to withholding agents, you may submit
Form W-9 to certify to your U.S. status.
Giving Form W-8BEN-E to the withholding agent. Do
not send Form W-8BEN-E to the IRS. Instead, give it to
the person who is requesting it from you. Generally, this
will be the person from whom you receive the payment,
who credits your account, or a partnership that allocates
income to you. An FFI may also request this form from you
to document the status of your account.
When to provide Form W-8BEN-E to the withholding
agent. Give Form W-8BEN-E to the person requesting it
before the payment is made to you, credited to your
account or allocated. If you do not provide this form, the
withholding agent may have to withhold at the 30% rate
(as applicable under chapters 3 or 4), backup withholding
rate, or the rate applicable under section 1446. If you
receive more than one type of income from a single
withholding agent for which you claim different benefits,
the withholding agent may, at its option, require you to
submit a Form W-8BEN-E for each different type of
income. Generally, a separate Form W-8BEN-E must be
given to each withholding agent.
Note. If you own the income with one or more other
persons, the income will be treated by the withholding
agent as owned by a foreign person that is a beneficial
owner of a payment only if Form W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E
(or other applicable document) is provided by each of the
owners. An account will be treated as a U.S. account for
chapter 4 purposes by an FFI requesting this form if any of
the account holders is a specified U.S. person or a
U.S.-owned foreign entity (unless the account is otherwise
excepted from U.S. account status for chapter 4
purposes).
Change in circumstances. If a change in
circumstances makes any information on the Form
W-8BEN-E you have submitted incorrect for purposes of
either chapter 3 or chapter 4, you must notify the
withholding agent or financial institution maintaining your
account within 30 days of the change in circumstances
and you must file a new Form W-8BEN-E (or other
appropriate form as applicable). See Regulations sections
1.1441-1(e)(4)(ii)(D) for the definition of a change in
circumstances for purposes of chapter 3. See Regulations
section 1.1471-3(c)(6)(ii)(E) for the definition of a change
in circumstances for purposes of chapter 4.
Expiration of Form W-8BEN-E. Generally, a Form
W-8BEN-E will remain valid for purposes of both chapters
3 and 4 for a period starting on the date the form is signed
and ending on the last day of the third succeeding
Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014) -3-
calendar year, unless a change in circumstances makes
any information on the form incorrect. For example, a
Form W-8BEN signed on September 30, 2014 remains
valid through December 31, 2017.
However, under certain conditions a Form W-8BEN-E
will remain in effect indefinitely until a change of
circumstances occurs. To determine the period of validity
for Form W-8BEN-E for purposes of chapter 4, see
Regulations section 1.1471-3(c)(6)(ii). To determine the
period of validity for Form W-8BEN-E for purposes of
chapter 3, see Regulations section 1.1441-1(e)(4)(ii).
Definitions
Account holder. An account holder is generally the
person listed or identified as the holder or owner of a
financial account. For example, if a partnership is listed as
the holder or owner of a financial account, then the
partnership is the account holder, rather than the partners
of the partnership. However, an account that is held by a
disregarded entity (other than a disregarded entity treated
as an FFI for chapter 4 purposes) is treated as held by the
person owning the entity.
Amounts subject to withholding under chapter 3.
Generally, an amount subject to chapter 3 withholding is
an amount from sources within the United States that is
fixed or determinable annual or periodical (FDAP) income.
FDAP income is all income included in gross income,
including interest (as well as OID), dividends, rents,
royalties, and compensation. FDAP income does not
include most gains from the sale of property (including
market discount and option premiums), as well as other
specific items of income described in Regulations section
1.1441-2 (such as interest on bank deposits and
short-term OID).
For purposes of section 1446, the amount subject to
withholding is the foreign partner's share of the
partnership's effectively connected taxable income.
Beneficial owner. For payments other than those for
which a reduced rate of, or exemption from, withholding is
claimed under an income tax treaty, the beneficial owner
of income is generally the person who is required under
U.S. tax principles to include the payment in gross income
on a tax return. A person is not a beneficial owner of
income, however, to the extent that person is receiving the
income as a nominee, agent, or custodian, or to the extent
the person is a conduit whose participation in a
transaction is disregarded. In the case of amounts paid
that do not constitute income, beneficial ownership is
determined as if the payment were income.
Foreign partnerships, foreign simple trusts, and foreign
grantor trusts are not the beneficial owners of income paid
to the partnership or trust. The beneficial owners of
income paid to a foreign partnership are generally the
partners in the partnership, provided that the partner is not
itself a partnership, foreign simple or grantor trust,
nominee or other agent. The beneficial owners of income
paid to a foreign simple trust (that is, a foreign trust that is
described in section 651(a)) are generally the
beneficiaries of the trust, if the beneficiary is not a foreign
partnership, foreign simple or grantor trust, nominee or
other agent. The beneficial owners of income paid to a
foreign grantor trust (that is, a foreign trust to the extent
that all or a portion of the income of the trust is treated as
owned by the grantor or another person under sections
671 through 679) are the persons treated as the owners of
the trust. The beneficial owners of income paid to a
foreign complex trust (that is, a foreign trust that is not a
foreign simple trust or foreign grantor trust) is the trust
itself.
For purposes of section 1446, the same beneficial
owner rules apply, except that under section 1446 a
foreign simple trust rather than the beneficiary provides
the form to the partnership.
The beneficial owner of income paid to a foreign estate
is the estate itself.
Note. A payment to a U.S. partnership, U.S. trust, or
U.S. estate is treated as a payment to a U.S. payee that is
not subject to 30% withholding for purposes of chapter 3
and chapter 4. A U.S. partnership, trust, or estate should
provide the withholding agent with a Form W-9. For
purposes of section 1446, a U.S. grantor trust or
disregarded entity shall not provide the withholding agent
a Form W-9 in its own right. Rather, the grantor or other
owner shall provide the withholding agent the appropriate
form.
Chapter 3. Chapter 3 means Chapter 3 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Withholding of Tax on Nonresident Aliens
and Foreign Corporations). Chapter 3 contains sections
1441 through 1464.
Chapter 4. Chapter 4 means Chapter 4 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Taxes to Enforce Reporting on Certain
Foreign Accounts). Chapter 4 contains sections 1471
through 1474.
Chapter 4 status. The term chapter 4 status means a
person's status as a U.S. person, specified U.S. person,
foreign individual, participating FFI, deemed-compliant
FFI, restricted distributor, exempt beneficial owner,
nonparticipating FFI, territory financial institution,
excepted NFFE, or passive NFFE. See Regulations
section 1.1471-1(b) for the definitions of these terms.
Deemed -compliant FFI. Under section 1471(b)(2),
certain FFIs are deemed to comply with the regulations
under chapter 4 without the need to enter into an FFI
agreement with the IRS. However, certain
deemed-compliant FFIs are required to register with the
IRS and obtain a GIIN. These FFIs are referred to as
registered deemed -compliant FFIs. See Regulations
section 1.1471-5(f)(1).
Disregarded entity. A business entity that has a single
owner and is not a corporation under Regulations section
301.7701-2(b) is disregarded as an entity separate from
its owner. A disregarded entity does not submit this Form
W-8BEN-E to a withholding agent or FFI. Instead, the
owner of such entity provides the appropriate
documentation (for example, a Form W-8BEN-E if the
owner is a foreign entity). See Regulations section
1.1446-1 and section 1.1471-3(a)(3)(v), respectively.
However, it a disregarded entity receiving a withholdable
payment is an FFI outside the single owner's country of
organization, the owner will be required to complete Part II
-4- Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014)
of Form W-8BEN-E to document the chapter 4 status of
the disregarded entity receiving the payment.
Certain entities that are disregarded for U.S. tax
purposes may be recognized for purposes of claiming
treaty benefits under an applicable tax treaty (see the
definition of hybrid entity, later) or as an FFI under an
applicable IGA. A hybrid entity claiming treaty benefits on
its own behalf is required to complete this Form
W-8BEN-E. See Hybrid Entities under Special
Instructions, later.
Financial account. A financial account includes:

• A depository account maintained by an FFI;
• A custodial account maintained by an FFI;
• Equity or debt interests (other than interests regularly
traded on an established securities market) in investment
entities and certain holding companies, treasury centers,
or financial institutions as defined in Regulations section
1.1471-5(e);
• Certain cash value insurance contracts; and
• Annuity contracts.
For purposes of chapter 4, exceptions are provided for
accounts such as certain tax-favored savings accounts,
term life insurance contracts, accounts held by estates,
escrow accounts, and certain annuity contracts. These
exceptions are subject to certain conditions. See
Regulations section 1.1471-5(b)(2). Accounts may also
be excluded from the definition of financial account under
an applicable IGA.
Financial institution. A financial institution generally
means an entity that is a depository institution, custodial
institution, investment entity, or an insurance company (or
holding company of an insurance company) that issues
cash value insurance or annuity contracts. See
Regulations section 1.1471-5(e).
Foreign financial institution (FFI). A foreign financial
institution (FFI) generally means a foreign entity that is a
financial institution.
Fiscally transparent entity. An entity is treated as
fiscally transparent with respect to an item of income for
which treaty benefits are claimed to the extent that the
interest holders in the entity must, on a current basis, take
into account separately their shares of an item of income
paid to the entity, whether or not distributed, and must
determine the character of the items of income as if they
were realized directly from the sources from which
realized by the entity. For example, partnerships, common
trust funds, and simple trusts or grantor trusts are
generally considered to be fiscally transparent with
respect to items of income received by them.
Flow -through entity. A flow-through entity is a foreign
partnership (other than a withholding foreign partnership),
a foreign simple or foreign grantor trust (other than a
withholding foreign trust), or, for payments for which a
reduced rate of, or exemption from, withholding is claimed
under an income tax treaty, any entity to the extent the
entity is considered to be fiscally transparent (see above)
with respect to the payment by an interest holder's
jurisdiction.
For purposes of section 1446, a foreign partnership or
foreign grantor trust must submit Form W-8IMY to
establish the partnership or grantor trust as a look-through
entity. The Form W-RIMY may be accompanied by this
form or another version of Form W-8 or Form W-9 to
establish the foreign or domestic status of a partner or
grantor or other owner. See Regulations section 1.1446-1.
Foreign person. A foreign person includes a foreign
corporation, a foreign partnership, a foreign trust, a foreign
estate, and any other person that is not a U.S. person. It
also includes a foreign branch or office of a U.S. financial
institution or U.S. clearing organization if the foreign
branch is a qualified intermediary (01). Generally, a
payment to a U.S. branch of a foreign person is a payment
to a foreign person.
GIIN. The term GIIN means a global intermediary
identification number. A GIIN is the identification number
assigned to an entity that has registered with the IRS for
chapter 4 purposes.
Hybrid entity. A hybrid entity is any person (other than
an individual) that is treated as fiscally transparent (rather
than as a beneficial owner) for purposes of declaring
status under the Code but is not treated as fiscally
transparent by a country with which the United States has
an income tax treaty. Hybrid entity status is relevant for
claiming treaty benefits. A hybrid entity, is, however,
required to provide its chapter 4 status if it is receiving a
withholdable payment.
Intergovernmental agreement (IGA). An
intergovernmental agreement (IGA) means a Model 1 IGA
ohar vainMgoidn leeff2elcGt
a Model 1 o
A.Foralistor
Model
fjurisd
2 IGA,
iction
see
strea
htt
treated
i
asi
www.treasury.gov/resource-center/tax-policy/treaties/
Pages/FATCA-Archive.aspx.
A Model 1 IGA means an agreement between the U.S.
or the Treasury Department and a foreign government or
one or more agencies to implement FATCA through
reporting by FFIs to such foreign government or agency
thereof, followed by automatic exchange of the reported
information with the IRS. An FFI in a Model 1 IGA
jurisdiction that performs account reporting to the
jurisdiction's government is referred to as a reporting
Model 1 FFI.
A Model 2 IGA means an agreement or arrangement
between the U.S. or the Treasury Department and a
foreign government or one or more agencies to implement
FATCA through reporting by FFIs directly to the IRS in
accordance with the requirements of an FFI agreement,
supplemented by the exchange of information between
such foreign government or agency thereof and the IRS.
An FFI in a Model 2 IGA jurisdiction that has entered into
an FFI agreement is a participating FFI, but may be
referred to as a reporting Model 2 FR. The term
reporting IGA FFI refers to both reporting Model 1 FFIs
and reporting Model 2 FFIs collectively.
Limited branch. A limited branch means a branch of a
participating FFI that is described in Regulations section
1.1471-4(e)(2).
Nonparticipating FFI. A nonparticipating FFI means an
FFI that is not a participating FFI, deemed-compliant FFI,
or exempt beneficial owner.
Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014) -5-
Participating FFI. A participating FFI is an FR (including
a reporting Model 2 FR covered by an FFI agreement)
that has agreed to comply with the terms of an FR
agreement. The term participating FFI also includes a QI
branch of a U.S. financial institution, unless such branch is
a reporting Model 1 FFI.
Participating payee. A participating payee means any
person that accepts a payment card as payment or
accepts payment from a third party settlement
organization in settlement of a third party network
transaction.
Payee. A payee is generally a person to whom a
payment is made, regardless of whether such person is
the beneficial owner. For a payment made to a financial
account, the payee is generally the holder of the financial
account. However, under certain circumstances a person
who receives a payment will not be considered the payee.
For purposes of chapter 3, see Regulations section
1.1441-1(b)(2). For purposes of chapter 4, see
Regulations section 1.1471-3(a)(3).
Payment settlement entity (PSE). A payment
settlement entity is a merchant acquiring entity or third
party settlement organization. Under section 6050W, a
PSE is generally required to report payments made in
settlement of payment card transactions or third party
network transactions. However, a PSE is not required to
report payments made to a beneficial owner that is
documented as foreign with an applicable W-8.
Qualified intermediary (O1). A qualified intermediary
(QI) (as described in Regulations section 1.1441-1(e)(5)
(ii)) is a person that is a party to an agreement with the
IRS that is described in Regulations section 1.1441-1(e)
(5)(iii).
Recalcitrant account holder. A recalcitrant account
holder for purposes of chapter 4 includes an entity (other
than an entity required to be treated as a nonparticipating
FR by the withholding agent) that fails to comply with a
request by an FR maintaining the account for
documentation and information for determining whether
the account is a U.S. account (as defined in Regulations
section 1.1471-5(a)). See Regulations section
1.1471-5(g).
Reverse hybrid entity. A reverse hybrid entity is any
person (other than an individual) that is not fiscally
transparent under U.S. tax law principles but that is
fiscally transparent under the laws of a jurisdiction with
which the United States has an income tax treaty. See
Form W-8IMY and accompanying instructions for
information on a reverse hybrid entity making a claim of
treaty benefits on behalf of its owners.
Specified U.S. person. A specified U.S. person is any
U.S. person other than a person identified in Regulations
section 1.1473-1(c).
Substantial U.S. owner. A substantial U.S. owner (as
defined in Regulations section 1.1473-1(b)) means any
specified U.S. person that:

• Owns, directly or indirectly, more than 10 percent (by
vote or value) of the stock of any foreign corporation;

• Owns, directly or indirectly, more than 10 percent of the
profits or capital interests in a foreign partnership;
• Is treated as an owner of any portion of a foreign trust
under sections 671 through 679; or
• Holds, directly or indirectly, more than a 10 percent
beneficial interest in a trust.
An investment entity organized in a territory that is not
also a depository institution, custodial institution, or
specified insurance company is not treated as a financial
institution. Instead, it is a territory NFFE. If such an entity
cannot qualify as an excepted territory NFFE, it must
disclose its substantial U.S. owners using this definition
(applying the 10 percent threshold).
U.S. person. A U.S. person is defined in section 7701(a)
(30) and includes domestic partnerships, corporations,
and trusts.
Certain foreign insurance companies issuing
annuities or cash value insurance contracts that
elect to be treated as a U.S. person for federal
tax purposes but are not licensed to do business in the
United States are treated as FP's for purposes of
chapter 4. For purposes of providing a withholding agent
with documentation for both chapter 3 and chapter 4
purposes, however, such an insurance company is
permitted to use Form W-9 to certify its status as a U.S.
person. Likewise, a foreign branch of a U.S. financial
institution (other than a branch that operates as a qualified
intermediary) that is treated as an FFI under an applicable
IGA is permitted to use Form W-9 to certify its status as a
U.S. person for chapter 3 and chapter 4 purposes.
Withholdable payment. Withholding under chapter 4
may apply to payments of U.S. source FDAP income that
are withholdable payments as defined in Regulations
section 1.1473-1(a) to which an exception does not apply
under chapter 4. The exceptions from withholding
provided for under chapter 3 are not applicable when
determining whether withholding applies under chapter 4.
For exceptions applicable to the definition of a
withholdable payment, see Regulations section
1.1473-1(a)(4) (exempting, for example, certain
nonfinancial payments).
Withholding agent. Any person, U.S. or foreign, that has
control, receipt, custody, disposal, or payment of U.S.
source FDAP income subject to chapter 3 or 4 withholding
is a withholding agent. The withholding agent may be an
individual, corporation, partnership, trust, association, or
any other entity, including (but not limited to) any foreign
intermediary, foreign partnership, and U.S. branches of
certain foreign banks and insurance companies.
For purposes of section 1446, the withholding agent is
the partnership conducting the trade or business in the
United States. For a publicly traded partnership, the
withholding agent may be the partnership, a nominee
holding an interest on behalf of a foreign person, or both.
See Regulations sections 1.1446-1 through 1.1446-6.
A CAL) 0
-6- Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014)
Specific Instructions
A hybrid entity should give Form W-8BEN-E on
its own behalf to a withholding agent only for
income for which it is claiming a reduced rate of
withholding under an income tax treaty or to document its
chapter 4 status for purposes of maintaining an account
with an FFI requesting this form (when it is not receiving
withholdable payments or payments subject to chapter 3
withholding). Otherwise, an entity treated as a
flow-through entity should generally provide Form W-81MY
for chapter 3 or chapter 4 purposes. A reverse hybrid
entity should give Form W-8BEN-E on its own behalf to a
withholding agent only for income for which no treaty
benefit is being claimed or to establish its status for
chapter 4 purposes (when required). See the special
instructions for hybrid entities and reverse hybrid entities
below. However, a flow-through entity may provide this
Form W-8BEN-E to document its foreign status as a
participating payee receiving a payment for purposes of
section 6050W.
Part I - Identification
of Beneficial Owner
Line 1. Enter your name. If you are a disregarded entity
or branch, do not enter the business name of the
disregarded entity or branch here. Instead, enter the legal
name of the entity that owns the disregarded entity
(looking through multiple disregarded entities if
applicable) or maintains the branch. If you are a
disregarded entity that is a hybrid entity filing a treaty
claim, however, see Hybrid entities under Special
Instructions, later.
Line 2. If you are a corporation, enter your country of
incorporation. If you are another type of entity, enter the
country under whose laws you are created, organized, or
governed.
Line 3. If you are a disregarded entity receiving a
payment, enter your name (if required). You should
complete line 3 only if you are a disregarded entity
receiving a withholdable payment or hold an account with
an FFI requesting this form and you: 1) have registered
with the IRS and been assigned a GIIN associated with
the legal name of the disregarded entity; 2) are a reporting
Model 1 FFI or reporting Model 2 FFI; and 3) are not a
hybrid entity using this form to claim treaty benefits. If you
are not required to provide the legal name of the
disregarded entity, however, you may want to notify the
withholding agent that you are a disregarded entity
receiving a payment or maintaining an account by
indicating the name of the disregarded entity on line 10.
However, do not enter the name of the disregarded entity
on this line 3 except in the circumstances described.
Line 4. Check the one box that applies. By checking a
box, you are representing that you qualify for the
classification indicated. You must check the box that
represents your classification (for example, corporation,
partnership, trust, estate, etc.) under U.S. tax principles
(not under the law of the treaty country). If you are a
partnership, disregarded entity, simple trust, or grantor
trust receiving a payment for which treaty benefits are
being claimed by such entity, you must check the
"Partnership", "Disregarded entity", "Simple trust", or
"Grantor trust" box. For such a case, you must also check
the "yes" box to indicate that you are a hybrid entity
making a treaty claim. See Hybrid entities under Special
Instructions, later. If you are a flow-through entity that is
not a hybrid entity claiming treaty benefits, you should
check the box to indicate you are not making a treaty
claim. If you check the "no" box, you may only use this
form to document your chapter 4 status as an account
holder of an FFI. You may also use Form W-81MY for this
purpose. However, if you are receiving withholdable
payments or amounts subject to withholding under
chapter 3, you are required to provide Form W-8IMY and
a withholding statement (if applicable) with respect to
such payments.
A CAUTION
Only entities that are tax-exempt under section
501 should check the "Tax-exempt organization"
box. Such organizations should use Form
W-8BEN-E only if they are claiming a reduced rate of
withholding under an income tax treaty or a code
exception other than section 501. Use Form W-8EXP to
document your exemption and chapter 4 status if you are
claiming an exemption from withholding under section
501.
Line 5. Check the one box that applies to your chapter 4
status. You are not required to provide a chapter 4 status
if you are providing this form with respect to a preexisting
entity account (as described in Regulations section
1.1471-1(b)(102)) prior to July 1, 2016 (or, if you are an
entity that is treated as a prima facie FFI under
Regulations section 1.1471-2(a)(4)(ii)(B), prior to January
1, 2015). Additionally, you are only required to provide a
chapter 4 status if you are the payee of a withholdable
payment or are documenting the status of an account you
hold with an FFI requesting this form. By checking a box
on this line, you are representing that you qualify for this
classification in your country of residence.
For most of the chapter 4 statuses, you are
required to complete an additional part of this
form certifying that you meet the conditions of the
status indicated on fine 5 (as defined under Regulations
section 1.1471-5 or 1.1471-6). Make sure you complete
the required portion of this form before signing and
providing it to the withholding agent. See, however,
Entities Providing Certifications Under an Applicable IGA
under Special Instructions, later.
FFIs Covered by an IGA and Related Entities
A reporting IGA FFI resident in, or established under the
laws of, a jurisdiction covered by a Model 1 IGA should
check "Reporting Model 1 FFI." A reporting FFI resident
in, or established under the laws of, a jurisdiction covered
by a Model 2 IGA should check "Reporting Model 2 FFI." If
you are treated as a registered deemed-compliant FFI
under an applicable IGA, you should check "Nonreporting
IGA FFI" rather than "registered deemed-compliant FFI"
and provide your GIIN in Part XII, line 26. See the specific
instructions for Part XII. An FFI that is related to a
reporting IGA FFI and that is treated as a nonparticipating
Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014) -7-
FFI in its country of residence should check
nonparticipating FFI in line 5. An FFI that is related to a
reporting IGA FFI and that is a participating FFI,
deemed-compliant FFI, or exempt beneficial owner under
the U.S. Treasury regulations or an applicable IGA should
check the appropriate box for its chapter 4 status.
See httplAvww.treasuiy.gov/resource-centelltax-
policy/treaties/Pages/FATCA-Archive.aspx for a list of
jurisdictions treated as having an IGA in effect.
Non -Profit Organizations Covered by an IGA
A non-profit entity that is established and maintained in a
jurisdiction that is treated as having in effect a Model 1
IGA or Model 2 IGA, and that meets the definition of
Active NFFE under Annex I of the applicable IGA, should
not check a box for its status on line 5. Instead, see
Entities Providing Certifications Under an Applicable IGA
under Special instructions, later.
Line 6. Enter the permanent residence address of the
entity identified in line 1. Your permanent residence
address is the address in the country where the entity
claims to be a resident for purposes of that country's
income tax. If you are giving Form W-8BEN-E to claim a
reduced rate of, or exemption from, withholding under an
income tax treaty, you must determine residency in the
manner required by the treaty. Do not show the address of
a financial institution (unless you are a financial institution
providing your own address), a post office box, or an
address used solely for mailing purposes unless it is the
only address used by the entity and such address
appears in the entity's organizational documents (i.e.,
your registered address). If you do not have a tax
residence in any country, the permanent residence
address is where you maintain your principal office.
Line 7. Enter your mailing address only if it is different
from the address you show on line 6.
Line 8. Enter your U.S. employer identification number
(EIN). An EIN is a U.S. TIN for entities. If you do not have
a U.S. EIN, apply for one on Form SS-4, Application for
Employer Identification Number if you are required to
obtain a U.S. TIN. See Regulations section 1.1441-1(e)(4)
(vii) for when you are required to provide a U.S. TIN on a
Form W-8 associated with a payment subject to chapter 3
withholding.
A partner in a partnership conducting a trade or
business in the United States will likely be allocated
effectively connected taxable income. The partner is
required to file a U.S. federal income tax retum and must
have a U.S. taxpayer identification number (TIN).
You must provide a U.S. TIN if you are:

• Claiming an exemption from withholding under section
871(f) for certain annuities received under qualified plans,
or

• Claiming benefits under an income tax treaty and have
not provided a foreign TIN on line 9b.
However, a TIN is not required to be shown in order to
claim treaty benefits on the following items of income:

• Dividends and interest from stocks and debt obligations
that are actively traded;
• Dividends from any redeemable security issued by an
investment company registered under the Investment
Company Act of 1940 (mutual fund);

• Dividends, interest, or royalties from units of beneficial
interest in a unit investment trust that are (or were upon
issuance) publicly offered and are registered with the SEC
under the Securities Act of 1933; and
• Income related to loans of any of the above securities.
If you need an EIN, you are encouraged to apply
for one online instead of submitting a paper Form
SS -4. For more information, visit. www.irs.gov/
Businesses/Small-Businesses-&-Self-Employed/
Employer-ID-Numbers-EINs.
Line 9a. If you are a participating FFI, registered
deemed-compliant FFI, reporting Model 1 FFI, reporting
Model 2 FFI, direct reporting NFFE, trustee of a trustee
documented trust, or sponsored direct reporting NFFE,
you are required to enter your GIIN (with regard to your
country of residence) on line 9a. However, if your branch
is receiving the payment and required to be identified in
Part II, you are not required to provide a GIIN on this
line 9a. Instead, provide the GIIN of your branch (if
applicable) on line 13. See the instructions for Part II.
For payments made prior to January 1, 2015, however,
a Form W-8BEN-E provided by a reporting Model 1 FFI
need not contain a GIIN. For payments made prior to
January 1, 2016, a sponsored direct reporting NFFE or
sponsored FFI that has not obtained a GIIN must provide
the GIIN of its sponsoring entity.
If you are in the process of registering with the
IRS as a participating FFI, registered
deemed -compliant FFI, reporting Model 1 FFI,
reporting Model 2 FFI, direct reporting NFFE, or
sponsored direct reporting NFFE, but have not received a
GIIN, you may complete this line by writing "applied for."
However, the person requesting this form from you must
receive and verify your GM within 90 days.
Line 9b. If your country of residence for tax purposes has
issued you a tax identifying number (TIN), enter it here. If
you are providing this Form W-8BEN-E to document
yourself with respect to a financial account that you hold
at a U.S. office of a financial institution, you must provide
the taxpayer identifying number (TIN) issued to you by the
jurisdiction in which you are a tax resident unless:
• You have not been issued a TIN, or
• The jurisdiction does not issue TINs.
Line 10. This line may be used by the filer of Form
W-8BEN-E or by the withholding agent to whom it is
provided to include any referencing information that is
useful to the withholding agent to document the beneficial
owner. For example, withholding agents who are required
to associate the Form W-8BEN-E with a particular Form
W-8IMY may want to use line 10 for a referencing number
or code that will make the association clear. A beneficial
owner may also want to use line 10 to include the number
of the account for which he or she is providing the form. A
foreign single owner of a disregarded entity may use
line 10 to inform the withholding agent that the account to
which a payment is made or credited is held in the name
-8- Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014)
of the disregarded entity (unless the name of the
disregarded entity is required to be provided on line 3).
You may also use line 10 to identify income from a
notional principal contract that is not effectively connected
with the conduct of a trade or business in the United
States.
Part II - Disregarded Entity
or Branch Receiving Payment
A CAUTIOI
Only complete Part li if you are a branch of an FFI
identified in line ! receiving a withholdable
payment as an intermediary (including a branch
that is a disregarded entity) and you operate in a
jurisdiction other than the country of residence identified
on line 2. For example, assume ABC Co., which is a
participating FFI resident in Country A, operates through a
branch in Country B (which is a Model 1 IGA jurisdiction)
and the branch is treated as a reporting Model 1 FFI under
the terms of the Country B Model 1 IGA. ABC Co. should
not enter its GIIN on line 9, and the Country B branch
should complete this Part Ii by identifying itself as a
reporting Model 1 IGA FFI and providing its GUN on
line 13. Furthermore, if the Country B branch receiving the
payment is a disregarded entity you may be required to
provide its legal name on line 3. See the instructions for
Part i, line 3.
Line 11. Check the one box that applies. If you check
reporting Model 1 FFI, reporting Model 2 FFI, participating
FFI, or U.S. branch claiming a chapter 4 status other than
that of nonparticipating FFI, you must complete line 13
(see below). If you are a limited branch or branch of a
reporting IGA FFI that cannot comply with the
requirements of an applicable IGA or the regulations
under chapter 4, you must check limited branch.
Line 12. Enter the address of the branch or disregarded
entity.
Line 13. If you are a reporting Model 1 FFI, reporting
Model 2 FFI, or participating FFI, you must enter the GIIN
on line 13 of your branch that receives the payment. If you
are a disregarded entity that completed Part I, line 3 of this
form and are receiving payments associated with this
form, enter your GIIN. Do not enter your GIIN (if any) on
line 9. If you are a U.S. branch, enter a GIIN applicable to
any other branch of the FFI (including in its residence
country). For payments made prior to January 1, 2015,
however, a GIIN is not required if you check reporting
Model 1 FFI on line 11.
if you are in the process of registering with the
IRS as a participating FFI, reporting Model 1 FFi,
or reporting Model 2 FFI but have not received a
GIIN, you may complete this fine by writing "applied for."
However, the person requesting this form from you must
receive and verify your GIIN within 90 days.
Part Ill - Claim of Tax Treaty Benefits
Line 14a. An entity that is claiming a reduced rate of, or
exemption from, withholding under an income tax treaty
must enter the country where the entity identified on line 1
is a resident for income tax treaty purposes and check the
box to certify that it is a resident of that country. For treaty
purposes, a person is a resident of a treaty country if the
person is a resident of that country under the terms of the
treaty.
Line 14b. An entity that is claiming a reduced rate of, or
exemption from, withholding under an income tax treaty
must check the box to certify that it:

• Derives the item of income for which the treaty benefit
is claimed, and
• Meets the limitation on benefits provisions contained in
the treaty, if any.
An item of income may be derived by either the entity
receiving the item of income or by the interest holders in
the entity or, in certain circumstances, both. An item of
income paid to an entity is considered to be derived by the
entity only if the entity is not fiscally transparent under the
laws of the entity's jurisdiction with respect to the item of
income. An item of income paid to an entity shall be
considered to be derived by the interest holder in the
entity only if:

• The interest holder is not fiscally transparent in its
jurisdiction with respect to the item of income, and
• The entity is considered to be fiscally transparent under
the laws of the interest holder's jurisdiction with respect to
the item of income. An item of income paid directly to a
type of entity specifically identified in a treaty as a resident
of a treaty jurisdiction is treated as derived by a resident of
that treaty jurisdiction.
To determine whether an entity meets the limitation on
benefits provisions of a treaty, you must consult the
specific provisions or articles under the treaty. Income tax
treaties are available on the IRS website at www.irs.gov/
Businesses/Intemational-Businesses/United-States-
Income-Tax-Treaties- - -A-to-Z.
If an entity is claiming treaty benefits on its own behalf,
it should complete Form W-8BEN-E. If an interest holder
in an entity that is considered fiscally transparent in the
interest holder's jurisdiction is claiming a treaty benefit,
the interest holder should complete Form W-8BEN (if an
individual) or Form W-8BEN-E (if an entity) on its own
behalf as the appropriate treaty resident, and the fiscally
transparent entity should associate the interest holder's
Form W-8BEN or Form W-8BEN-E with a Form W-8IMY
completed by the fiscally transparent entity (see Hybrid
entities under Special Instructions, later).
A CAL/ 0
An income tax treaty may not apply to reduce the
amount of any tax on an item of income received
by an entity that is treated as a domestic
corporation for U.S. tax purposes. Therefore, neither the
domestic corporation nor its shareholders are entitled to
the benefits of a reduction of U.S. income tax on an item
of income received from U.S. sources by the corporation.
If you are an entity that derives the income as a
resident of a treaty country, you may check this
box if the applicable income tax treaty does not
contain a "limitation on benefits" provision.
Line 14c. If you are a foreign corporation claiming treaty
benefits under an income tax treaty that entered into force
before January 1, 1987 (and has not been renegotiated)
on (a) U.S. source dividends paid to you by another
Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014) -9-
foreign corporation or (b) U.S. source interest paid to you
by a U.S. trade or business of another foreign corporation,
you must generally be a "qualified resident" of a treaty
country. See section 884 for the definition of interest paid
by a U.S. trade or business of a foreign corporation
("branch interest") and other applicable rules.
In general, a foreign corporation is a qualified resident
of a country if any of the following apply.

• It meets a 50% ownership and base erosion test.
• It is primarily and regularly traded on an established
securities market in its country of residence or the United
States.

• It carries on an active trade or business in its country of
residence.
• It gets a ruling from the IRS that it is a qualified resident.
See Regulations section 1.884-5 for the requirements that
must be met to satisfy each of these tests.
A CAUTION
If you are claiming treaty benefits under an
income tax treaty entered into force after
December 31, 1986, do not check box 14c.
Instead, check box 14b.
Line 15. Line 15 must be used only if you are claiming
treaty benefits that require that you meet conditions not
covered by the representations you make in line 14. This
line is generally not applicable to claiming treaty benefits
under an interest or dividends (other than dividends
subject to a preferential rate based on ownership) article
of a treaty.
The following are examples of persons who should
complete this line.

• Exempt organizations claiming treaty benefits under the
exempt organization articles of the treaties with Canada,
Mexico, Germany, and the Netherlands.

• Foreign corporations that are claiming a preferential
rate applicable to dividends based on ownership of a
specific percentage of stock in the entity paying the
dividend.

• Persons claiming treaty benefits on royalties if the
treaty contains different withholding rates for different
types of royalties.
• Persons claiming treaty benefits under an "other
income" treaty article.
Parts IV Through XXVIII -
Certification of Chapter 4 Status
You should complete only one part of Parts IV through
XXVIII certifying to your chapter 4 status (if required, see
the specific instructions for line 5). Identify which part (if
any) you should complete by reference to the box you
checked on line 5. An entity that selects nonparticipating
FFI, participating FFI, registered deemed-compliant FFI,
reporting Model 1 FFI, reporting Model 2 FFI, or direct
reporting NFFE (other than a sponsored direct reporting
NFFE) in line 5 is not required to complete any of the
certifications in Parts IV through XXVIII.
IGA. In lieu of the certifications contained in Parts IV
through XXVIII of Form W-8BEN-E, a reporting Model 1
FFI or reporting Model 2 FFI in certain cases may request
alternate certifications to document its account holders
pursuant to an applicable IGA or you may otherwise
provide an alternate certification to a withholding agent.
See Entities Providing Certifications Under an Applicable
IGA under Special Instructions, later.
You are not required to complete a chapter 4
status certification if you are not the payee of a
withholdable payment or an account holder
holding an account with an FFI requesting this form.
However, you are not required to provide a chapter 4
status if you are providing this form with respect to a
preexisting entity account (as described in Regulations
section 1.1471-1(6)(102)) prior to July 1, 2016 (or, if you
are a prima facie FFI, prior to January 1, 2015).
Part IV - Sponsored FFI That
Has Not Obtained a GIIN
Line 16. Enter the name of the sponsoring entity that has
agreed to fulfill the due diligence, reporting, and
withholding obligations (as applicable) on behalf of the
sponsored FFI identified in line 1. You must provide the
sponsoring entity's GIIN on line 9a.
Note. A sponsored FFI is not required to have obtained
its own GIIN before January 1, 2016.
Line 17. You must check the applicable box to certify that
you are either a sponsored investment entity (you may
provide this certification even if you are not an FFI solely
because you are an investment entity) or sponsored
controlled foreign corporation (within the meaning of
section 957(a)) and that you satisfy the other relevant
requirements for this status.
Part V - Certified Deemed -Compliant
Nonregistering Local Bank
Line 18. A certified deemed-compliant nonregistering
local bank must check the box to certify that it meets all of
the requirements for this certified deemed-compliant
status.
Part VI - Certified Deemed -Compliant
FFI with Only Low -Value Accounts
Line 19. A certified deemed-compliant FFI with only low
value accounts must check the box to certify that it
satisfies all of the requirements for this certified
deemed-compliant classification.
Part VII - Certified Deemed -Compliant
Sponsored, Closely
Held Investment Vehicle
Line 20. Enter the name of your sponsoring entity that
has agreed to fulfill the due diligence, reporting, and
withholding obligations of the entity identified in line 1 as if
the entity in line 1 were a participating FFI. You must also
enter the GIIN of your sponsoring entity on line 9a.
Line 21. A sponsored, closely held investment vehicle
must check the box to certify that it meets all of the
requirements for this certified deemed-compliant status.
For purposes of this certification, the requirement for a
contractual relationship (referred to on line 21 of the form)
-10- Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014)
means the requirements of Regulations section
1.1471-5 (f)(2)(iii)(B).
Part VIII - Certified
Deemed -Compliant Limited Life Debt
Investment Company
Line 22. A limited life debt investment entity must check
the box to certify that it meets all of the requirements for
this certified deemed-compliant status.
Part IX - Certified Deemed -Compliant
Investment Advisors
and Investment Managers
Line 23. An investment advisor or investment manager
must check the box to certify that it meets all of the
requirements for this certified deemed-compliant status.
Part X - Owner -Documented FFI
Line 24a. An owner-documented FFI must check the box
to certify that it meets all of the requirements for this status
and is providing this form to a U.S. financial institution,
participating FFI, reporting Model 1 FFI, or reporting
Model 2 FFI that agrees to act as a designated
withholding agent with respect to the FFI identified on
line 1. See Regulations section 1.1471-5(f)(3) for more
information about an owner-documented FFI, including a
designated withholding agent.
Check either line 24b or line 24c. Do not check
both boxes.
Line 24b. Check the box to certify that you have provided
or will provide the documentation set forth in the
certifications, including the owner reporting statement
described in this line 24b. If you check the box on
line 24b, you should not check the box on line 24c.
Line 24c. Check the box to certify that you have provided
or will provide the auditor's letter (in lieu of the information
required by line 24b) that satisfies the requirements
reflected on this line.
Line 24d. Check the box if you do not have any
contingent beneficiaries or designated classes with
unidentified beneficiaries. While this certification is not
required, a Form W-8BEN-E provided by an
owner-documented FFI will remain indefinitely valid for
chapter 4 purposes absent a change in circumstances
with respect to offshore obligations (as defined in
Regulations section 1.6049-5(c)(1)) only if this
certification is provided and the account balance of all
accounts held by the owner-documented FFI with the
withholding agent does not exceed $1,000,000 on the
later of June 30, 2014, or the last day of the calendar year
in which the account was opened, and the last day of
each subsequent calendar year preceding the payment,
applying the aggregation principles of Regulations section
1.1471-5(b)(4)(iii).
Part XI - Restricted Distributor
Line 25a. A restricted distributor must check the box to
certify that it meets all of the requirements for this status.
Lines 25b and 25c. Check the appropriate box to certify
as to your status. Do not check both boxes.
A CAUTION
A restricted distributor may certify only with
respect to an account it maintains in connection
with a distribution agreement with a restricted
fund described in this Part XI. A restricted distributor that,
in connection with such a distribution agreement, receives
a payment subject to chapter 3 withholding or a
withholdable payment should complete Form W-8IMY and
not this form except to the extent it holds interests in
connection with such an agreement as a beneficial owner.
Part XII - Nonreporting IGA FFI
Line 26. Check the box to indicate that you are treated as
a nonreporting IGA FFI under an applicable IGA, including
an entity treated as a registered deemed-compliant FFI
under an applicable IGA. You must identify the applicable
IGA by entering the name of the jurisdiction that has the
applicable IGA treated as in effect with the United States.
You must also provide the withholding agent with the
specific category of FFI described in Annex II of the IGA
applicable to your status.
If you are an FFI treated as a registered
deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable Model 2 IGA,
you must also provide your GIIN in the space provided.
The GIIN does not need to be provided on line 9a. See
http://www.treasurygov/resource-centeritax-policy/
treaties/Pages/FATCA-Archive.aspx for a list of
jurisdictions treated as having an IGA in effect for
purposes of making this certification.
A CAUTION
If you are a sponsored FFI in a Model 1 IGA
jurisdiction or other nonreporting FFI in a Model 1
(GA jurisdiction that is required to report an
account, you are currently not required to provide a GIIN
in this Part XII. However, a future version of this form may
require you to provide a GIIN.
Part XIII - Foreign Government,
Government of a U.S. Possession, or
Foreign Central Bank of Issue
Line 27. A foreign government, government of a U.S.
possession, or foreign central bank of issue (each as
defined in Regulations section 1.1471-6) must check the
box and certify that it satisfies all of the requirements for
this status (including that it does not engage in the type of
commercial financial activities described on this line
except to the extent permitted under Regulations section
1.1471-6(h)(2)).
If you are a foreign govemment, govemment of a
U.S. possession, or foreign central bank of issue,
you should only complete this Form W-8BEN-E
for payments for which you are not claiming the
applicability of section(s) 115(2), 501(c), 892, 895, or
1443(b), otherwise you should use Form W-8EXP.
Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014) -11-
Part XIV - International Organization
Line 28a. Check this box to certify that you are an
international organization described in section 7701(a)
(18).
If you are an entity that has been designated as
an international organization by executive order
(pursuant to 22 U.S.C. 288 through 288f), check
box 28a. If you are claiming an exemption from
withholding for purposes of chapter 3, however, use Form
W-8EXP.
Line 28b. If you are an international organization other
than an international organization described in line 28a,
check the box to certify that you satisfy all of the
requirements for this status.
Part XV - Exempt Retirement Plans
Lines 29a, b, c, d, e, and f. An exempt retirement plan
must check the appropriate box to certify that it meets all
of the requirements for this status.
Part XVI - Entity Wholly Owned
by Exempt Beneficial Owners
Line 30. An entity wholly owned by exempt beneficial
owners must check the box to certify that it meets all of
the requirements for this status. You must also provide the
owner documentation described in this line establishing
that each direct owner or debt holder of the entity is an
exempt beneficial owner described in Regulations section
1.1471-6(b).
Part XVII - Territory
Financial Institution
Line 31. A territory financial institution must check the
box to certify that it meets all of the requirements for this
status.
Part XVIII - Excepted
Nonfinancial Group Entity
Line 32. An excepted nonfinancial group entity must
check the box to certify that it meets all of the
requirements for this status.
Part XIX - Excepted Nonfinancial
Start -Up Company
Line 33. An excepted nonfinancial start-up company
must check the box to certify that it meets all of the
requirements for this status. You must also provide the
date you were formed or your board passed a resolution
(or equivalent measure) approving a new line of business
(which cannot be that of a financial institution or passive
NFFE).
Part XX - Excepted Nonfinancial
Entity in Liquidation or Bankruptcy
Line 34. An excepted nonfinancial group entity in
liquidation or bankruptcy must check the box to certify that
it meets all of the requirements for this status. You must
also provide the date that you filed a plan of liquidation,
plan of reorganization, or bankruptcy petition.
Part XXI - 501(c) Organization
Line 35. A section 501(c) organization must check the
box and provide the date that the IRS issued the
organization a determination letter or provide a copy of an
opinion from U.S. counsel certifying that the organization
qualifies as a section 501(c) organization (without regard
to whether the organization is a foreign private
foundation).
If you are a section 501(c) organization claiming
an exemption from withholding for purposes of
chapter 3, however, use Form W-8EXP.
Part XXII - Nonprofit Organization
Line 36. A nonprofit organization (other than section
501(c) organizations) must check the box to certify that it
meets all of the requirements for this status.
IGA. For an entity that is established and maintained in
a jurisdiction that is treated as having in effect an IGA and
that is described in Annex I as a nonprofit organization
that is an Active NFFE, see Entities Providing
Certifications Under an Applicable IGA under Special
Instructions, later.
Part XXIII - Publicly Traded
NFFE or NFFE Affiliate of
a Publicly Traded Corporation
Line 37a. A publicly traded NFFE must check the box to
certify that you are not a financial institution and provide
the name of a securities exchange on which the stock of
the NFFE is publicly traded.
Line 37b. An NFFE that is a member of the same
expanded affiliated group as a publicly traded U.S. or
foreign entity must check this box, provide the name of the
publicly traded entity, and identify the securities market on
which the stock of the publicly traded entity is traded. See
Regulations section 1.1472-1(c)(1)(i) to determine if the
stock of an entity is regularly traded on an established
securities market (substituting the term "U.S. entity" for
NFFE, as appropriate for purposes of testing whether an
entity is publicly traded).
Part XXIV - Excepted Territory NFFE
Line 38. An excepted territory NFFE must check the box
to certify that it meets all of the requirements for this
classification. See Regulations section 1.1472-1(c)(1)(iii)
for the definition of an excepted territory NFFE.
Part XXV - Active NFFE
Line 39. An active NFFE must check the box to certify
that it meets all of the requirements for this status,
including the assets and passive income test described in
the certification for this part. For purposes of applying this
test, passive income includes dividends, interest, rents,
royalties, annuities, and certain other forms of passive
income. See Regulations section 1.1472-1(c)(1)(iv)(A) for
-12- Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014)
additional detail for the definition of passive income. Also
see Regulations section 1.1472-1(c)(1)(iv)(B) for
exceptions from the definition of passive income for
certain types of income.
Part XXVI - Passive NFFE
Line 40a. A passive NFFE must check the box to certify
that you are not a financial institution and are not certifying
your status as a publicly traded NFFE, NFFE affiliate of a
publicly traded company, excepted territory NFFE, active
NFFE, direct reporting NFFE, or sponsored direct
reporting NFFE.
If you are an NFFE that may qualify as an active
NFFE (or other NFFE described in another part of
this form), you may still check line 40a and
disclose your substantial U.S. owners or certify that you
have no substantial U.S. owners (see instructions to lines
40b and 40c below).
Line 40b. Check this box to certify that you have no
substantial U.S. owners.
Line 40c. If you do not check the box and make the
certification on line 40b, you must check this box 40c and
complete Part XXX to identify each of your substantial
U.S. owners and provide their name, address, and TIN.
Part XXVII — Excepted
Inter -Affiliate FFI
Line 41. An excepted inter-affiliate FFI must check the
box to certify that it meets all of the requirements of this
classification. This classification will only apply for an
excepted inter-affiliate FFI that holds a deposit account
described in the certification for this part and that is
documenting itself to the financial institution that maintains
the deposit account. You are not eligible for this
classification if you receive or make withholdable
payments to or from any person other than a member of
your expanded affiliated group, other than the depository
institution described in the previous sentence. See
Regulations section 1.1471-5(e)(5)(iv) for all the
requirements of this status.
Part XXVIII - Sponsored
Direct Reporting NFFEs
Line 42. A sponsored direct reporting NFFE must check
the box to certify that it meets all of the requirements for
this classification. You must also provide the name of your
sponsoring entity in the space provided and provide your
GIIN in line 9a (or, for payments prior to January 1, 2016,
the GIIN of your sponsoring entity).
Part XXIX - Certification
Form W-8BEN-E must be signed and dated by an
authorized representative or officer of the beneficial
owner, participating payee (for purposes of section
6050W), or account holder of an FFI requesting this form.
An authorized representative or officer must check the
box to certify that you have the legal capacity to sign for
the entity identified on line 1 that is the beneficial owner of
the income. If Form W-8BEN-E is completed by an agent
acting under a duly authorized power of attorney, the form
must be accompanied by the power of attorney in proper
form or a copy thereof specifically authorizing the agent to
represent the principal in making, executing, and
presenting the form. Form 2848, Power of Attorney and
Declaration of Representative, may be used for this
purpose. The agent, as well as the beneficial owner,
payee, or account holder (as applicable), may incur
liability for the penalties provided for an erroneous, false,
or fraudulent form. By signing Form W-8BEN-E, the
authorized representative, officer, or agent of the entity
also agrees to provide a new form within 30 days following
a change in circumstances affecting the correctness of the
form.
Broker transactions or barter exchanges. Income
from transactions with a broker or a barter exchange is
subject to reporting rules and backup withholding unless
Form W-8BEN-E or a substitute form is filed to notify the
broker or barter exchange that you are an exempt foreign
person. See certification described in the 4th bullet point.
You are an exempt foreign person for a calendar year
in which:
• You are a foreign corporation, partnership, estate, or
trust; and
• You are neither engaged, nor plan to be engaged
during the year, in a U.S. trade or business that has
effectively connected gains from transactions with a
broker or barter exchange.
Part XXX - Substantial U.S.
Owners of Passive NFFE
If you identified yourself as a passive NFFE (including an
investment entity that is a territory NFFE but is not an
excepted territory NFFE under Regulations section
1.1472-1(c)) with one or more substantial U.S. owners in
Part XXVI, you must identify each substantial U.S. owner.
Provide the name, address, and TIN of each substantial
U.S. owner in the relevant column. You may attach this
information on a separate statement, which remains
subject to the same perjury statement and other
certifications made in Part XXIX.
Special Instructions
Hybrid Entities
Hybrid entity making a claim of treaty benefits. If you
are a hybrid entity making a claim for treaty benefits as a
resident on your own behalf, you may do so as permitted
under an applicable tax treaty. You should complete this
Form W-8BEN-E to claim treaty benefits in the manner
described earlier (see instructions for completing Part III).
If you are a flow-through entity receiving a withholdable
payment, you should also provide Form W-81MY for the
entity along with a withholding statement (if required)
establishing the chapter 4 status of each of your partners
or owners. If you are a disregarded entity claiming treaty
benefits, your single owner should provide Form
W-8BEN-E or Form W-8BEN (as applicable) to the
withholding agent along with this form. You may use
line 10 to inform the withholding agent to associate the
two forms.
Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014) -13-
A CAUTION
A disregarded entity that is treated as a reporting
Model 1 FFI or reporting Model 2 FFI that is also
a hybrid entity making a claim of treaty benefits
should follow the special instructions for disregarded
entities claiming treaty benefits in an 1GA jurisdiction,
later.
Line 1. Enter your legal name (determined by reference
to your legal identity in your country of incorporation or
organization).
Line 2. Enter the country under whose laws you are
created, organized, or governed.
Line 3. Leave this line blank. For purposes of completing
this form as a hybrid entity making a treaty claim
(including a disregarded entity), you are treated as the
beneficial owner and should be identified in line 1.
Line 4. Check the box that applies among disregarded
entity, partnership, grantor trust, or simple trust. You must
also check the box indicating that you are a hybrid making
a treaty claim and complete Part III.
Line 5. Do not complete line 5.
Lines 6 and 7. Complete lines 6 and 7 as provided in the
specific instructions earlier.
Line 8. Complete line 8 in accordance with the specific
instructions for line 8, earlier.
Line 9b. If your country of residence for tax purposes has
issued you a tax identifying number, enter it here. Do not
enter the tax identifying number of your owner(s).
Line 10. This reference line is used to associate this
Form W-8BEN-E with another applicable withholding
certificate or other documentation provided for purposes
of chapter 4. For example, if you are a partnership making
a treaty claim, you may want to provide information for the
withholding agent to associate this Form W-8BEN-E with
the Form W-RIMY and owner documentation you provide
for purposes of establishing the chapter 4 status of your
owner(s).
Parts III & XXIX
You must complete Parts III and XXIX in accordance with
the specific instructions above. Complete Part II if
applicable.
Reverse Hybrid Entities
A foreign reverse hybrid entity should only file a Form
W-8BEN-E for payments for which it is not claiming treaty
benefits on behalf of its owners and must provide a
chapter 4 status when it is receiving a withholdable
payment. A foreign reverse hybrid entity claiming treaty
benefits on behalf of its owners should provide the
withholding agent with Form W-8IMY (including its
chapter 4 status when receiving a withholdable payment)
along with a withholding statement and Forms W-8BEN or
W-8BEN-E (or documentary evidence to the extent
permitted) on behalf of each of its owners claiming treaty
benefits. See Form W-8IMY and accompanying
instructions for more information.
Entities Providing Certifications
Under an Applicable IGA
A withholding agent that is an FFI may provide you with a
chapter 4 status certification other than as shown in Parts
IX through XXVIII in order to satisfy its due diligence
requirements under an applicable IGA. In such a case,
you may attach the alternative certification to this Form
W-8BEN-E in lieu of completing a certification otherwise
required in Parts IV through XXVIII provided that you: 1)
determine that the certification accurately reflects your
status for chapter 4 purposes or under an applicable IGA;
and 2) the withholding agent provides a written statement
to you that it has provided the certification to meet its due
diligence requirements as a participating FFI or registered
deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable IGA.
You may also provide with this form an applicable IGA
certification it you are determining your chapter 4 status
under the definitions provided in an applicable IGA and
your certification identifies the jurisdiction that is treated
as having an IGA in effect and describes your status as an
NFFE or FFI in accordance with the applicable IGA.
However, it you determine your status under an applicable
IGA as an NFFE, you must still determine if you are an
excepted NFFE under the Regulations in order to
complete this form. Additionally, you are required to
comply with the conditions of your status under the law of
the IGA jurisdiction if you are determining your status
under an applicable IGA. If you cannot provide the
certifications in Parts IV through XXVIII, do not check a
box in line 5. However, if you determine your status under
the definitions of the IGA and can certify to a chapter 4
status included on this form, you do not need to provide
the certifications described in this paragraph unless
required by the withholding agent or FFI to whom you are
providing this form.
Any certifications provided under an applicable IGA
remain subject to the penalty of perjury statement and
other certifications made in Part XXIX.
Entities Providing Alternate
Certifications Under Regulations
If you qualify for a chapter 4 status that is not shown in
Part I, line 5, of this form, you may attach applicable
certifications for such status from any other Form W-8 on
which the relevant certifications appear. If the applicable
certifications do not appear on any Form W-8 (if, for
example, new regulations provide for an additional
chapter 4 status and this form has not been updated to
incorporate the status) then you may provide an
attachment certifying that you qualify for the applicable
status described in a particular Regulations section in lieu
of checking a box in Part I, line 5, and providing any
chapter 4 status certifications included on this form.
Include a citation to the applicable provision in the
Regulations. Any such attached certification becomes an
integral part of this Form W-8BEN-E and is subject to the
penalty of perjury statement and other certifications made
in Part XXIX.
-14- Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014)
Paperwork Reduction Act Notice. We ask for the
information on this form to carry out the Internal Revenue
laws of the United States. You are required to provide the
information. We need it to ensure that you are complying
with these laws and to allow us to figure and collect the
right amount of tax.
You are not required to provide the information
requested on a form that is subject to the Paperwork
Reduction Act unless the form displays a valid OMB
control number. Books or records relating to a form or its
instructions must be retained as long as their contents
may become material in the administration of any Internal
Revenue law. Generally, tax returns and return
information are confidential, as required by section 6103.
The time needed to complete and file this form will vary
depending on individual circumstances. The estimated
average time is:
Recordkeeping  12 hr., 40 min.
Learning about the law or the form 4 hr., 17 min.
Preparing and sending the form   8 hr., 16 min.
If you have comments concerning the accuracy of
these time estimates or suggestions for making this form
simpler, we would be happy to hear from you. You can
send us comments from www.irs.govnormspubst Click on
"More Information" and then on -Give us feedback". You
can write to the Internal Revenue Service, Tax Forms and
Publications, SE:W:CAR:MP:TFP, 1111 Constitution Ave.
NW, IR-6526, Washington, DC 20224. Do not send Form
W-8BEN-E to this office. Instead, give it to your
withholding agent.
Instructions for Form W-8BEN-E (6-2014) -15-
Form W-8ECI
(Rev. February 2014)
Department d the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Certificate of Foreign Person's Claim That Income Is
Effectively Connected With the Conduct of a Trade or
Business in the United States
So Section references are to the internal Revenue Code.
P Information about Form W-8ECI and its separate instructions is at www.irs.govrforrnw8eci.
P Give this form to the withholding agent or payer. Do not send to the IRS.
OMB No. 1545-1621
Note. Persons submitting this form must file an annual U.S. income tax return to report income claimed to be effectively
connected with a U.S trade or business (see instructions).
Do not use this form for: Instead, use Form:

• A beneficial owner solely claiming foreign status or treaty benefits   W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E
• A foreign government. international organization. foreign central bank of issue. foreign tax-exempt organization, 
foreign private
foundation. or government of a U.S. possession claiming the applicability of section(s) 115(2). 501(c). 892. 895. or 
1443(b) . . . . yy.gExp
Note. These entitles should use Form W-8ECI if they received effectively connected income and are not eligible to claim 
an exemption for chapter 3
or 4 purposes on Form W-8EXP.

• A foreign partnership or a foreign trust (unless claiming an exemption from U.S. withholding on income effectively 
connected with the W-8BEN-E
conduct of a trade or business in the United States)   or W-81MY
W-81MY • A person acting as an intermediary
Note. See instructions for additional exceptions.
Part I Identification of Beneficial Owner (see instructions.)
1 Name of individual or organization that is the beneficial owner 2 Country of incorporation or organization
3 Name of disregarded entity receiving the payments (if applicable)
4 Type of entity (check the appropriate box): 0 Individual 0 Corporation
0 Partnership 0 Simple trust 0 Complex trust 0 Estate
0 Government 0 Grantor trust 0 Central bank of issue 0 Tax-exempt organization
0 Private foundation 0 International organization
5 Permanent residence address (street. apt. or suite no.. or rural route). Do not use a M. box or in-care-of address.
City or town. state or province. Include postal code where appropriate. Country
6 Business address in the United States (street. apt. or suite no.. or rural route). Do not use a M. box or in care-of 
address.
City or town. state. and ZIP code
7 U.S. taxpayer identification number (required—see instructions)
0 SSN or MN 0 EIN
8 Foreign tax identifying number
9 Reference number(s) (see instructions) 10 Date of birth (MM-DD-YYYY)
11 Specify each item of income that is. or is expected to be, received from the payer that is effectively connected with
the conduct of a trade or
business in the United States. (attach statement if necessary)
Part II Certification
Sign
Here
Under penalties of perjury. I declare that I have examined the information on this form and to the best of my knowledge 
and belief rt is true. correct. and
complete. I further codify under penalties of perjury that:

• I am the beneficial owner (or I am authorized to sign for the beneficial owner) of all the payments to which this form
relates.

• The amounts for which this certification is provided are effectively connected with the conduct of a trade or busness 
in the United States.

• The income for which this form was provided is includible ri my gross income (or the beneficial owner's gross ricome) 
for the taxable year. and
• The beneficial owner is not a U.S. person.
Furthermore. I authorize this form to be provided to any withholding agent that has control. receipt. or custody of the 
payments of which I am the
beneficial owner or any withholding agent that can disburse or make payments of the amounts of which I am the benehzial 
owner.
I agree that I will submit a new form within 30 days if any certification made on this form becomes Incorrect.
Signature of beneficial ovner (or individual authorized to sign for the beneficial ovine.) Print name Date (MM-DD-YYYY)
O I certify that I have the capacity to sign for the person identified on line 1 of this form.
For Paperwork Reduction Act Notice, see separate instructions. Cat. No. 25045D Form W-8ECI (Rev. 2-2014)
Instructions for Form W-8ECI r (Rev. February 2014)
Certificate of Foreign Person's Claim That Income Is Effectively Connected With
the Conduct of a Trade or Business in the United States
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Section references are to the Internal Revenue Code
unless otherwise noted.
Future Developments. For the latest information about
developments related to Form W-8ECI and its
instructions, such as legislation enacted after they were
published, go to www.irs.gov/formwaeci.
General Instructions
Note. For definitions of terms used throughout these
instructions, see Definitions, later.
Purpose of Form
Foreign persons are generally subject to U.S. tax at a 30%
rate on income they receive from U.S. sources. However,
no withholding under section 1441 or 1442 is required on
income that is, or is deemed to be, effectively connected
with the conduct of a trade or business in the United
States and is includible in the beneficial owner's gross
income for the tax year.
This withholding exemption does not apply to personal
services income and income subject to withholding under
section 1445 (dispositions of U.S. real property interests)
or section 1446 (foreign partners share of effectively
connected income).
Income effectively connected with the conduct of a
trade or business in the United States is not a
withholdable payment under chapter 4 and thus is not
subject to withholding under sections 1471 or 1472.
It you receive effectively connected income from
sources in the United States, you must provide Form
W-8ECI to:

• Establish that you are not a U.S. person,
• Claim that you are the beneficial owner of the income
for which Form W-8ECI is being provided or are an entity
engaged in a U.S. trade or business submitting Form
W-8ECI on behalf of your owners or partners, and
• Claim that the income is effectively connected with the
conduct of a trade or business in the United States.
If you expect to receive both income that is effectively
connected and income that is not effectively connected
from a withholding agent, you must provide Form W-8ECI
for the effectively connected income and Form W-8BEN,
Form W-8BEN-E, Form W-8EXP, or Form W-8IMY (as
appropriate) for income that is not effectively connected.
It you submit Form W-8ECI to a partnership, the
income claimed to be effectively connected with the
conduct of a U.S. trade or business is subject to
withholding under section 1446. If a nominee holds an
interest in a partnership on your behalf, you, not the
nominee, must submit the form to the partnership or
nominee that is the withholding agent.
If you are a foreign partnership, a foreign simple trust,
or a foreign grantor trust with effectively connected
income, you may submit Form W-8ECI without attaching
Forms W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E, or other documentation for
your foreign partners, beneficiaries, or owners.
A withholding agent or payer of the income may rely on
a properly completed Form W-8ECI to treat the payment
associated with the Form W-8ECI as a payment to a
foreign person who beneficially owns the amounts paid
and is either entitled to an exemption from withholding
under sections 1441, 1442, 1471, or 1472 because the
income is effectively connected with the conduct of a
trade or business in the United States or subject to
withholding under section 1446.
Provide Form W-8ECI to the withholding agent or payer
before income is paid, credited, or allocated to you.
Failure by a beneficial owner to provide a Form W-8ECI
when requested may lead to withholding at the 30% rate
or the backup withholding rate under section 3406.
Additional information. For additional information and
instructions for the withholding agent, see the Instructions
for the Requester of Forms W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E,
W-8ECI, W-8EXP, and W-8IMY.
Who Must Provide Form W-8ECI
You must give Form W-8ECI to the withholding agent or
payer it you are a foreign person and you are the
beneficial owner of U.S. source income that is (or is
deemed to be) effectively connected with the conduct of a
trade or business within the United States.
Do not use Form W-8ECI if:

• You are a nonresident alien individual who claims
exemption from withholding on compensation for
independent or certain dependent personal services
performed in the United States. Instead, provide Form
8233, Exemption from Withholding on Compensation for
Independent (and Certain Dependent) Personal Services
of a Nonresident Alien Individual, or Form W-4,
Employee's Withholding Allowance Certificate.

• You are the beneficial owner of a payment subject to
withholding and are claiming an exemption from
withholding for a reason other than a claim that the
income is effectively connected with the conduct of a
trade or business in the United States. For example, if you
are a foreign person who is the beneficial owner of U.S.
source income that is not effectively connected with a
U.S. trade or business and you are claiming a reduced
rate of withholding under an applicable income tax treaty
in effect, do not use Form W-8ECI. Instead, provide Form
W-8BEN, Certificate of Foreign Status of Beneficial Owner
for United States Tax Withholding (Individuals) or Form
W-8BEN-E, Certificate of Status of Beneficial Owner for
United States Tax Withholding and Reporting (Entities).

• You are a foreign person receiving proceeds from the
disposition of a U.S. real property interest. Instead, see
Form 8288-B, Application for Withholding Certificate for
Feb 25, 2014 Cat. No. 25902V
Dispositions by Foreign Persons of U.S. Real Property
Interests.

• You are filing for a foreign government, international
organization, foreign central bank of issue, foreign
tax-exempt organization, foreign private foundation, or
govemment of a U.S. possession claiming the
applicability of section 115(2), 501(c), 892, 895, or
1443(b). Instead, provide Form W-8EXP, Certificate of
Foreign Govemment or Other Foreign Organization for
United States Tax Withholding and Reporting. However,
you should use Form W-8BEN-E if you are claiming treaty
benefits or are providing the form only to claim exempt
recipient status for backup withholding purposes. You
should use Form W-8ECI, however, if you received
effectively connected income (for example, income from
commercial activities).

• You are acting as an intermediary (that is, acting not for
your own account or for that of your partners, but for the
account of others as an agent, nominee, or custodian)
with respect to a payment subject to withholding. Instead,
provide Form W-8IMY, Certificate of Foreign Intermediary,
Foreign Flow-Through Entity, or Certain U.S. Branches for
United States Tax Withholding and Reporting.

• You are a withholding foreign partnership or a
withholding foreign trust for purposes of sections 1441
and 1442 that is receiving income which is not effectively
connected with the conduct of a U.S. trade or business. A
withholding foreign partnership is, generally, a foreign
partnership that has entered into a withholding agreement
with the IRS under which it agrees to assume primary
withholding responsibility for each partners distributive
share of income subject to withholding that is paid to the
partnership. A withholding foreign trust is, generally, a
foreign simple trust or a foreign grantor trust that has
entered into a withholding agreement with the IRS under
which it agrees to assume primary withholding
responsibility for each beneficiary's or owner's distributive
share of income subject to withholding that is paid to the
trust. Instead, provide Form W-8IMY.

• You are a foreign corporation that is a personal holding
company receiving compensation described in section
543(a)(7). Such compensation is not exempt from
withholding as effectively connected income, but may be
exempt from withholding on another basis.
• You are a foreign partner in a partnership and the
income allocated to you from the partnership is effectively
connected with the conduct of the partnership's trade or
business in the United States. Instead, provide Form
W-8BEN or Form W-8BEN-E (as applicable). However, if
you made or will make an election under section 871(d) or
882(d), provide Form W-8ECI. In addition, if you are
otherwise engaged in a trade or business in the United
States and you want your allocable share of income from
the partnership to be subject to withholding under section
1446, provide Form W-8ECI.
Giving Form W-8ECI to the withholding agent. Do not
send Form W-8ECI to the IRS. Instead, give it to the
person who is requesting it from you. Generally, this will
be the person from whom you receive the payment, who
credits your account, or a partnership that allocates
income to you. Give Form W-8ECI to the person
requesting it before the payment is made, credited, or
allocated. If you do not provide Form W-8ECI, the
withholding agent may have to withhold at the 30% rate or
the backup withholding rate. A separate Form W-8ECI
must be given to each withholding agent.
U.S. branch of foreign bank or insurance company.
A payment to a U.S. branch of a foreign bank or a foreign
insurance company that is subject to U.S. regulation by
the Federal Reserve Board or state insurance authorities
is presumed to be effectively connected with the conduct
of a trade or business in the United States if the
withholding agent has an EIN provided by the branch. The
presumption does not apply if the branch provides a
withholding agent with a Form W-8BEN-E for the income.
Change in circumstances. If a change in circumstances
makes any information on the Form W-8ECI you have
submitted incorrect, you must notify the withholding agent
or payer within 30 days of the change in circumstances
and you must file a new Form W-8ECI or other
appropriate form. For example, if during the tax year any
part or all of the income is no longer effectively connected
with the conduct of a trade or business in the United
States, your Form W-8ECI is no longer valid. You must
notify the withholding agent and provide Form W-8BEN,
W-8BEN-E, W-8EXP, or W-8IMY. See Regulations
section 1.1441-1(e)(4)(ii)(D) for the definition of a change
in circumstances for purposes of chapter 3. See
Regulations section 1.1471-3(c)(6)(ii)(E) for the definition
of a change in circumstances for purposes of chapter 4.
Expiration of Form W-8ECI. Generally, a Form W-8ECI
will remain in effect for a period starting on the date the
form is signed and ending on the last day of the third
succeeding calendar year, unless a change in
circumstances makes any information on the form
incorrect (see Change in circumstances above for the
requirements to provide a new form). For example, a
Form W-8ECI signed on September 30, 2015, remains
valid through December 31, 2018. Upon the expiration of
the 3-year period, you must provide a new Form W-8ECI.
Definitions
Beneficial owner. For payments other than those for
which a reduced rate of withholding is claimed under an
income tax treaty, the beneficial owner of income is
generally the person who is required under U.S. tax
principles to include the income in gross income on a tax
return. A person is not a beneficial owner of income,
however, to the extent that person is receiving the income
as a nominee, agent, or custodian, or to the extent the
person is a conduit whose participation in a transaction is
disregarded. In the case of amounts paid that do not
constitute income, beneficial ownership is determined as
if the payment were income.
Foreign partnerships, foreign simple trusts, and foreign
grantor trusts are not the beneficial owners of income paid
to the partnership or trust. The beneficial owners of
income paid to a foreign partnership are generally the
partners in the partnership, provided that the partner is not
itself a partnership, foreign simple or grantor trust,
nominee or other agent. The beneficial owners of income
paid to a foreign simple trust (that is, a foreign trust that is
described in section 651(a)) are generally the
beneficiaries of the trust, if the beneficiary is not a foreign
partnership, foreign simple or grantor trust, nominee or
-2- Instructions for Form W-8ECI (Rev. 2-2014)
other agent. The beneficial owners of a foreign grantor
trust (that is, a foreign trust to the extent that all or a
portion of the income of the trust is treated as owned by
the grantor or another person under sections 671 through
679) are the persons treated as the owners of the trust.
The beneficial owners of income paid to a foreign complex
trust (that is, a foreign trust that is not a foreign simple
trust or foreign grantor trust) is the trust itself.
Generally, these beneficial owner rules apply for
purposes of sections 1441, 1442, and 1446, except that
section 1446 requires a foreign simple trust to provide a
Form W-8 on its own behalf rather than on behalf of the
beneficiary of such trust.
The beneficial owner of income paid to a foreign estate
is the estate itself.
A payment to a U.S. partnership, U.S. trust, or U.S.
estate is treated as a payment to a U.S. payee. A U.S.
partnership, trust, or estate should provide the withholding
agent with a Form W-9. However, for purposes of section
1446, a U.S. grantor trust shall not provide the withholding
agent a Form W-9. Instead, the grantor or other owner
must provide Form W-8 or Form W-9 as appropriate.
Chapter 3. Chapter 3 means Chapter 3 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Withholding of Tax on Nonresident Aliens
and Foreign Corporations). Chapter 3 contains sections
1441 through 1464.
Chapter 4. Chapter 4 means Chapter 4 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Taxes to Enforce Reporting on Certain
Foreign Accounts). Chapter 4 contains sections 1471
through 1474.
Disregarded entity. A business entity that has a single
owner and is not a corporation under Regulations section
301.7701-2(b) is disregarded as an entity separate from
its owner. A disregarded entity does not submit Form
W-8ECI to a partnership for purposes of section 1446.
Instead, the owner of such entity provides the appropriate
documentation. See Regulations section 1.1446-1.
Effectively connected income. Generally, when a
foreign person engages in a trade or business in the
United States, all income from sources in the United
States other than fixed or determinable annual or
periodical (FDAP) income (tor example, interest,
dividends, rents, and certain similar amounts) is
considered income effectively connected with a U.S. trade
or business. FDAP income may or may not be effectively
connected with a U.S. trade or business. Factors to be
considered to determine whether FDAP income and
similar amounts from U.S. sources are effectively
connected with a U.S. trade or business include whether:
• The income is from assets used in, or held for use in,
the conduct of that trade or business, or
• The activities of that trade or business were a material
factor in the realization of the income.
There are special rules for determining whether income
from securities is effectively connected with the active
conduct of a U.S. banking, financing, or similar business.
See section 864(c)(4)(B)(ii) and Regulations section
1.864-4(c)(5)(ii) for more information.
Effectively connected income, after allowable
deductions, is taxed at graduated rates applicable to U.S.
persons and resident aliens, rather than at the 30% rate.
You must report this income on your annual U.S. income
tax or information return.
A partnership that has effectively connected income
allocable to foreign partners is generally required to
withhold tax under section 1446. The withholding tax rate
on a partners share of effectively connected income is
35% for corporate partners and 39.6% for all other taxable
partners. In certain circumstances the partnership may
withhold tax at the highest applicable rate to a particular
type of income (tor example, long-term capital gain
allocated to a noncorporate partner). Any amount withheld
under section 1446 on your behalf, and reflected on Form
8805 issued by the partnership to you may be credited on
your U.S. income tax return.
Foreign person. A foreign person includes a
nonresident alien individual, a foreign corporation, a
foreign partnership, a foreign trust, a foreign estate, and
any other person that is not a U.S. person.
Nonresident alien individual. Any individual who is not
a citizen or resident alien of the United States is a
nonresident alien individual. An alien individual meeting
either the "green card test" or the "substantial presence
test" for the calendar year is a resident alien. Any person
not meeting either test is a nonresident alien individual.
Additionally, an alien individual who is a resident of a
foreign country under the residence article of an income
tax treaty, or an alien individual who is a bona fide
resident of Puerto Rico, Guam, the Commonwealth of the
Northern Mariana Islands, the U.S. Virgin Islands, or
American Samoa is a nonresident alien individual.
A CAUTIO
Even though a nonresident alien individual
married to a U.S. citizen or resident alien may
choose to be treated as a resident alien for
certain purposes (for example, filing a joint income tax
return), such individual is still treated as a nonresident
alien for withholding tax purposes on all income except
wages.
See Pub. 519, U.S. Tax Guide for Aliens, for more
information on resident and nonresident alien status
including information about the "green card test" and
"substantial presence test".
Withholding agent. Any person, U.S. or foreign, that has
control, receipt, custody, disposal, or payment of U.S.
source FDAP income subject to chapter 3 withholding is a
withholding agent. For purposes of chapter 4, any person,
U.S. or foreign, that has control, receipt, custody,
disposal, or payment of a withholdable payment is a
withholding agent. The withholding agent may be an
individual, corporation, partnership, trust, association, or
any other entity including (but not limited to) any foreign
intermediary, foreign partnership, and U.S. branches
treated as U.S. person. Generally, the person who pays
(or causes to be paid) an amount subject to withholding to
the foreign person (or to its agent) must withhold.
For purposes of section 1446, the withholding agent is
the partnership conducting the trade or business in the
United States. For a publicly traded partnership, the
withholding agent may be the partnership, a nominee
holding an interest on behalf of a foreign person, or both.
See Regulations sections 1.1446-1 through 1.1446-6.
Instructions for Form W-8ECI (Rev. 2-2014) -3-
Withholdable payment. A withholdable payment means
any payment of U.S. source FDAP income, subject to
certain exemptions described in Regulations sections
1.1471-2(b) and 1.1473-1(a). However, no exceptions to
withholding on U.S. source FDAP income for purposes
other than chapter 4 apply when determining whether a
payment is a withholdable payment. For example, an
exclusion from an amount subject to withholding under
Regulations section 1.1441-2(a) does not apply for
purposes of determining whether a payment constitutes a
withholdable payment. Under chapter 4, a payment of
effectively connected income is not a withholdable
payment.
U.S. person. A U.S. person is defined in section 7701(a)
(30) and includes an individual who is a citizen or resident
of the United States, as well as domestic partnerships,
corporations, trusts, and estates.
Specific Instructions
Part I
Line 1. Enter your name. If you are filing for a
disregarded entity with a single owner who is a foreign
person, this form should be completed and signed by the
foreign single owner. If the account to which a payment is
made or credited is in the name of the disregarded entity,
the foreign single owner may inform the withholding agent
of this fact. This may be done by including the name of the
disregarded entity on line 3 (name of disregarded entity (if
applicable)) of Part I of the form.
If you own the income or account jointly with one
or more other persons, the income or account will
be treated by the withholding agent as owned by
a foreign person if Forms W-8ECI are provided by all of
the owners. If the withholding agent receives a Form W-9,
Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and
Certification, from any of the joint owners, the payment
must be treated as made to a U.S. person.
Line 2. If you are filing for a corporation, enter the country
of incorporation. If you are filing for another type of entity,
enter the country under whose laws the entity is created,
organized, or governed. If you are an individual, provide
your country of residence for tax purposes.
Line 3. Enter the name of the disregarded entity
receiving the payment. This line is not required but may
assist the withholding agent that is making a payment to
you. The withholding agent may request additional
referencing information (such as your account number)
which should be entered on line 9. See the instructions for
line 9 below. When completing this form, do not provide
information concerning the disregarded entity on any line
other than this line 3 or line 9. Instead, you should
complete the form using the information of the owner of
the disregarded entity.
Line 4. Check the box that applies. By checking a box,
you are representing that you qualify for this classification.
You must check the one box that represents your
classification (for example, corporation, partnership, etc.)
under U.S. tax principles. If more than one classification
applies to you, select the most specific status available.
For example, if you are a private foundation, you are also
considered a tax-exempt organization. You should check
the box for private foundation rather than the box for
tax-exempt organization.
Line 5. Your permanent residence address is the
address in the country where you claim to be a resident
for that country's income tax. Do not show the address of
a financial institution, a post office box, or an address
used solely for mailing purposes unless such address is
the registered address of an entity identified on line 1
which does not have another address in the jurisdiction. If
you are an individual who does not have a tax residence
in any country, your permanent residence is where you
normally reside. If you are not an individual and you do not
have a tax residence in any country, the permanent
residence address is where you maintain your principal
office.
Line 6. Enter your business address in the United States.
Do not show a post office box.
Line 7. Enter your U.S. taxpayer identification number
(TIN). A U.S.TIN is a social security number (SSN),
employer identification number (EIN), or IRS individual
taxpayer identification number (ITIN). Check the
appropriate box for the type of U.S. TIN you are providing.
You are required to provide a TIN for this form to be valid.
If you are an individual, you are generally required to
enter your SSN. To apply for an SSN, get Form SS-5 from
a Social Security Administration (SSA) office or online at
httoilwww.socialsecurity.govissnumberiss5.htm. If in the
United States, you can call the SSA at 1-800-772-1213.
Fill in Form SS-5 and return it to the SSA.
If you do not have an SSN and are not eligible to get
one, you must get an ITIN. To apply for an ITIN, file Form
W-7 with the IRS. It usually takes 4-6 weeks to get an
MN.
If you are not an individual (for example, if you are a
foreign estate or trust), or you are an individual who is an
employer or who is engaged in a U.S. trade or business
as a sole proprietor, use Form SS-4, Application for
Employer Identification Number, to obtain an EIN. If you
are a disregarded entity, enter the U.S. TIN of your foreign
single owner.
You may also apply for an EIN online. For more
information, visit www.irs.gov/Businesses/Small-
Businesses-&-Self-Employect/Apply-for-an-
Emplover-Identffication-Number4EINFOnline.
Line 8. Enter the tax identifying number (TIN) issued to
you by your jurisdiction of tax residence unless:
• You have not been issued a TIN, or
• The jurisdiction does not issue TINs.
Line 9. This line may be used by the filer of Form W-8ECI
or by the withholding agent to whom it is provided to
include any referencing information that is useful to the
withholding agent in carrying out its obligations. For
example, a beneficial owner may use line 9 to include the
name and number of the account for which he or she is
providing the form.
Line 10. Provide your date of birth if you are an
individual. Use the following format to input your
Instructions for Form W-8ECI (Rev. 2-2014)
information MM-DD-YYYY. For example, if you were born
on April 15, 1956, you would enter 04-15-1956.
Line 11. You must specify the items of income that are
effectively connected with the conduct of a trade or
business in the United States. You will generally have to
provide Form W-8BEN, Form W-8BEN-E, Form W-8EXP,
or Form W-81MY for those items from U.S. sources that
are not effectively connected with the conduct of a trade
or business in the United States. See Form W-8BEN,
Form W-8BEN-E, Form W-8EXP, or Form W-81MY, and
the associated instructions for more details.
It you are providing this form to a partnership because
you are a partner and have made an election under
section 871(d) or section 882(d), attach a copy of the
election to the form. If you have not made the election, but
intend to do so effective for the current tax year, attach a
statement to the form indicating your intent. See
Regulations section 1.871-10(d)(3).
Part II
Signature. Form W-8EC1 must be signed and dated by
the beneficial owner of the income, or, it the beneficial
owner is not an individual, by an authorized representative
or officer of the beneficial owner. If an authorized
representative or agent is completing Form W-8EC1 on
behalf of the beneficial owner of the income, the
representative or agent must check the box to certify that
he or she has the legal capacity to sign for the person
identified on line 1. It Form W-8EC1 is completed by an
agent acting under a duly authorized power of attorney for
the beneficial owner, the form must be accompanied by
the power of attorney in proper form or a copy thereof
specifically authorizing the agent to represent the principal
in making, executing, and presenting the form (note that
this requirement does not apply to a partnership or other
flow-through entity submitting this form with respect to a
payment of effectively connected income that is
beneficially owned by the entity's partners or owners).
Form 2848, Power of Attorney and Declaration of
Representative, may be used for this purpose. The agent,
as well as the beneficial owner, may incur liability for the
penalties provided for an erroneous, false, or fraudulent
form.
A CAUTION
If any information on Form W-8ECI becomes
incorrect, you must submit a correct new form
within 30 days to the requester of this form unless
you will not receive a future payment from the withholding
agent that would require an updated Form W-8.
Paperwork Reduction Act Notice. We ask for the
information on this form to carry out the Internal Revenue
laws of the United States. If you want to receive
exemption from withholding on income effectively
connected with the conduct of a trade or business in the
United States, you are required to provide the information.
We need it to ensure that you are complying with these
laws and to allow us to figure and collect the right amount
of tax.
You are not required to provide the information
requested on a form that is subject to the Paperwork
Reduction Act unless the form displays a valid OMB
control number. Books or records relating to a form or its
instructions must be retained as long as their contents
may become material in the administration of any Internal
Revenue law. Generally, tax returns and return
information are confidential, as required by section 6103.
The time needed to complete and file this form will vary
depending on individual circumstances. The estimated
average time is: Recordkeeping, 4 hr., 4 min.; Learning
about the law or the form, 1 hr., 51 min.; Preparing
and providing the form, 3 hr., 12 min.
It you have comments concerning the accuracy of
these time estimates or suggestions for making this form
simpler, we would be happy to hear from you. You can
send us comments from www.irs.govfiormspubs! Click on
"More Information" and then on "Give us feedback." You
can write to the Internal Revenue Service, Tax Forms and
Publciations, SE:W:CAR:MP:TFP, 1111 Constitution Ave.
NW, IR-6526, Washington, DC 20224. Do not send Form
W-8ECI to this office. Instead, give it to your withholding
agent.
Instructions for Form W-8ECI (Rev. 2-2014) -5-
Fo. W-8EXP (Rev. April 2014)
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Certificate of Foreign Government or Other Foreign
Organization for United States Tax
Withholding and Reporting
(For use by foreign governments, international organizations, foreign central banks of issue, foreign
tax-exempt organizations. foreign private foundations, and governments of U.S. possessions.)
fa Information about Form W-8EXP and Its separate instructions Is at wwwirs.gov/fortmv8exp.
la Section references are to the Internal Revenue Code.
la Give this form to the withholding agent or payer. Do not send to the IRS.
OMB No. 1545.1621
Do not use this form for:

• A foreign government or other foreign organization that is not claiming the applicability of section(s) 115(2). 
501(c). 892. 895.
or 1443(b)

• A beneficial owner solely claiming foreign status or treaty benefits
• A foreign partnership or a foreign trust

• A person claiming that income is effectively connected with the conduct of a trade or business in the United States
• A person acting as an intermediary
Part I
Instead, use Form:
W-8BEN-E or W-BECI
W-8BEN or W-88EN-E
W-8BEN-E or W-RIMY
W-8ECI
W-BIMY
Identification of Beneficial Owner
1 Name of organization 2 Country of ncorpasson or organization
3 Type of
entity
O Foreign government
O International organization
O Foreign central bank of issue (not wholly
owned by the foreign sovereign)
0 Foreign tax-exempt organization
0 Foreign private foundation
0 Government of a U.S. prKsPssion
4 Chapte 4 Status (FATCA status):
0 Participating FFI.
O Reporting Model 1 FFI.
O Reporting Model 2 FFI.
O Registered deemed-compliant FFI
(other than a Reporting Model 1 FFI).
O Nonreporting IGA FFI. Complete Part III.
O Territory financial institution. Complete Part III.
O International organization.
O Foreign government (including a political subdivision).
government of a U.S. possession, or foreign central bank of
issue. Complete Part III.
O Exempt retirement plan of foreign government. Complete Part III.
O 501(c) organization. Complete Part III.
O Passive NFFE. Complete Part III.
O Direct reporting NFFE.
O Sponsored direct reporting NFFE. Complete Part III.
5 Permanent address (street. apt. or suite no.. or rural route). Do not use a M. box or In-care -of address (other than 
a registered address).
City or town, state or provrice. Include postal code where appropriate. Country
ft MaIng address different from above).
City or town. state or proynce. Include postal or ZIP code where appropriate. Country
7 U.S. TIN. if required (see instructions) 8a 0 GIIN b 0 Foreign TIN (see instructions)
9 Reference number(s) (see instructions)
Part II
10 For a foreign government:
a 0 I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a foreign government within the meaning of section 892 and the 
payments are
within the scope of the exemption granted by section 892.
Check box 10b or box 10c. whichever applies:
b 0 The entity identified in Part I is an integral part of the government of
c 0 The entity identified in Part I is a controlled entity of the government of
11 For an international organization:
❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is an international organization within the meaning of section 7701(a)(18) and

• The payments are within the scope of the exemption granted by section 892.
12 For a foreign central bank of issue (not wholly owned by the foreign sovereign):
❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is a foreign central bank of issue.
• The entity identified in Part I does not hold obligations or bank deposits to which this form relates for use in
connection with the conduct of a commercial banking function or other commercial activity, and
• The payments are within the scope of the exemption granted by section 895.
Qualification Statement for Chapter 3 Status
For Paperwork Reduction Act Notice, see separate Instructions. Cat. No. 25401F Form W-8EXP (Rev. 4-2014)
Fomi W-8EXP (Rev. 4-2014) Page 2
Part II
13 For a foreign tax-exempt organization, including foreign private foundations:
If any of the income to which this certification relates constitutes income includible under section 512 in computing 
the
entity's unrelated business taxable income, attach a statement identifying the amounts.
Check either box 13a or box 1313:
a ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I has been issued a determination letter by the IRS dated
that is currently in effect and that concludes that it is an exempt organization described in section 501(c).
b ❑ I have attached to this form an opinion from U.S. counsel concluding that the entity identified in Part I is 
described in
section 501(c).
For section 501(c)(3) organizations only, check either box 13c or box 13d:
Qualification Statement for Chapter 3 Status (continued)
❑ If the determination letter or opinion of counsel concludes that the entity identified in Part I is described in 
section 501(c)(3),
I certify that the organization is not a private foundation described in section 509. I have attached an affidavit of 
the
organization setting forth sufficient facts for the IRS to determine that the organization is not a private foundation 
because it
meets one of the exceptions described in section 509(a)(1). (2), (3). or (4).
d ❑ If the determination letter or opinion of counsel concludes that the entity identified in Part I is described in 
section 501(c)(3),
I certify that the organization is a private foundation described in section 509.
14 For a government of a U.S. possession:
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a government of a possession of the United States, or is a political
subdivision
thereof, and is claiming the exemption granted by section 115(2).
Qualification Statement for Chapter 4 Status (if required)
15 Fora nonreporting IGA FFI:
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Meets the requirements to be considered a nonreporting financial institution pursuant to an applicable IGA between the
United States
and

• Is treated as a   under the provisions of the applicable IGA (see instructions): and
Part III
• If you are an FFI treated as a registered deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable Model 2 IGA, provide your GIIN:
16 For a territory financial institution:
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a financial institution (other than an investment entity) that is 
incorporated or
organized under the laws of a possession of the United States.
17 For a foreign government (including a political subdivision), government of a U.S. possession, or foreign central 
bank of issue:
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is the beneficial owner of the payment and is not engaged in commercial
financial
activities of a type engaged in by an insurance company, custodial institution, or depository institution with respect 
to the
payments, accounts, or obligations for which this form is submitted (except as permitted in Regulations section 
1.1471-6(h)(2)).
18 For an exempt retirement plan of a foreign government:
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is established and sponsored by a foreign government, international organization, central bank of issue, or government
of a
U.S. possession (each as defined in Regulations section 1.1471-6 or an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA) to provide
retirement, disability, or death benefits to beneficiaries or participants that are current or former employees of the 
sponsor (or
persons designated by such employees): or

• Is established and sponsored by a foreign government, international organization, central bank of issue, or government
of a
U.S. possession (each as defined in Regulations section 1.1471-6 or an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA) to provide
retirement. disability, or death benefits to beneficiaries or participants that are not current or former employees of 
such
sponsor, but are in consideration of personal services performed for the sponsor.
19 Fora 501(c) organization:
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is an entity described in section 501(c) but is not an insurance 
company described
in section 501(c)(15).
20 For a passive NFFE:
a ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a foreign entity that is not a financial institution (other than 
an investment entity
organized in a possession of the United States).
Check box 20b or 20c, whichever applies.
b ❑ I further certify that the entity identified in Part I has no substantial U.S. owners, or
c ❑ I further certify that the entity identified in Part I has provided a statement including the name, address, and TIN
of each
substantial U.S. owner of the NFFE (see instructions).
21 Name of sponsoring entity:
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a direct reporting NFFE that is sponsored by the entity identified 
in line 21.
Form W-8EXP (Rev. 4-2014)
Fowl, W-8EXP (Rev. 4-2014) Page 3
Part IV
Sign
Here
Certification
Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have examined the information on this form and to the best of my knowledge 
and
belief it is true. correct, and complete. I further certify under penalties of perjury that:

• The organization for which I am signing is the beneficial owner of the income and other payments to which this form 
relates,

• The beneficial owner is not a U.S. person,
• For a beneficial owner that is a controlled entity of a foreign sovereign (other than a central bank of issue wholly 
owned by a
foreign sovereign), the beneficial owner is not engaged in commercial activities within or outside the United States, 
and
• For a beneficial owner that is a central bank of issue wholly owned by a foreign sovereign, the beneficial owner is 
not
engaged in commercial activities within the United States.
Furthermore. I authorize this form to be provided to any withholding agent that has control, receipt, or custody of the 
payments
of which I am the beneficial owner or any withholding agent that can disburse or make payments of the amounts of which I
am
the beneficial owner.
I agree that I will submit a new form within 30 days if any certification made on this form becomes incorrect.
Signature of authorized official Print name Date (MM-DO-YrN)
❑ I certify that I have the capacity to sign for the entity identified on line 1 of this form.
Form W-8EXP (Rev. 4-2014)
Instructions for Form
W-8EXP (Rev. April 2014)
Certificate of Foreign Government or Other Foreign Organization for United States
Tax Withholding and Reporting
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Section references are to the Internal Revenue Code
unless otherwise noted.
General Instructions
Future developments. For the latest information about
developments related to Form W-8EXP and its
instructions, such as legislation enacted after they were
published, go to www.irs.gov/formwSexp.
What's New
Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA). In
2010, Congress passed tl- liring Incentives to Restore
Employment Act of 2010. M. 111-147 (the HIRE Act),
which added chapter 4 of Subtitle A (chapter 4) to the
Code, consisting of sections 1471 through 1474 of the
Code and commonly referred to as "FATCA" or
"chapter 4." Under chapter 4, participating foreign
financial institutions (FFIs) and certain registered
deemed-compliant FFIs are generally required to identify
their U.S. account holders, regardless of whether a
payment subject to withholding is made to the account. In
January 2013, final regulations were published that
provide due diligence, withholding, and reporting rules for
both U.S. withholding agents and FFIs under chapter 4.
Additional temporary and proposed regulations were
published in March 2014 providing updated rules under
chapter 4 as well as guidance coordinating chapter 4 with
chapters 3 and 61. U.S. withholding agents and FFIs will
be required to begin withholding on withholdable
payments for chapter 4 purposes beginning on July 1,
2014.
This form, along with Form W-8BEN, W-8ECI, and
W-8lMY, has been updated to reflect the documentation
requirements of chapter 4. In particular, this Form
W-8EXP is now used by a foreign government or other
organization claiming the applicability of section(s) 115(2),
501(c), 892, 895, or 1443(b) to certify its exemption under
the applicable code provision for chapter 3 purposes and
certify to its chapter 4 status when receiving a
withholdable payment or to document its status as an
account holder of a participating FFI or registered
deemed-compliant FFI.
However, a foreign government or other organization
claiming treaty benefits for income which is not subject to
one of these statutory exemptions should use Form
W-8BEN-E instead of this form. Such an entity
documenting only its status for chapter 4 purposes may
also provide Form W-8BEN-E instead of this form.
A foreign government or other organization that fails to
provide this form (or other applicable certification form)
when requested may be treated as a nonparticipating FFI
subject to 30% withholding on withholdable payments
paid to the organization. In general, a foreign government
or other organization receiving a withholdable payment
should provide this form when requested to avoid
incorrect withholding consequences.
Note. For definitions of terms used throughout these
instructions, see Definitions, later.
Purpose of Form
Under chapter 3, foreign persons are subject to U.S. tax at
a 30% rate on income they receive from U.S. sources that
consists of interest (including certain original issue
discount (OID)), dividends, rents, premiums, annuities,
compensation for, or in expectation of, services
performed, or other fixed or determinable annual or
periodical gains, profits, or income. This tax is imposed on
the gross amount paid and is generally collected by
withholding under section 1441 or 1442 on that amount. A
payment is considered to have been made whether it is
made directly to the beneficial owner or to another person
for the benefit of the beneficial owner.
Foreign persons are also subject to tax at graduated
rates on income they earn that is considered effectively
connected with a U.S. trade or business. If a foreign
person invests in a partnership that conducts a U.S. trade
or business, the foreign person is considered to be
engaged in a U.S. trade or business. The partnership is
required to withhold tax under section 1446 on the foreign
person's distributive share of the partnership's effectively
connected taxable income.
If you receive certain types of income, you must
provide Form W-8EXP to:

• Establish that you are not a U.S. person,
• Claim that you are the beneficial owner of the income
for which Form W-8EXP is given, and
• Claim a reduced rate of, or exemption from, withholding
as a foreign government, international organization,
foreign central bank of issue, foreign tax-exempt
organization, foreign private foundation, or government of
a U.S. possession.
In general, payments to a foreign government
(including a foreign central bank of issue wholly-owned by
a foreign sovereign) from investments in the United States
in stocks, bonds, other domestic securities, financial
instruments held in the execution of governmental
financial or monetary policy, and interest on deposits in
banks in the United States are exempt from tax under
section 892 and exempt from withholding under sections
1441 and 1442. Payments other than those described
above, including income derived in the U.S. from the
conduct of a commercial activity, income received from a
controlled commercial entity (including gain from the
Apr 29, 2014 Cat. No. 25903G
disposition of any interest in a controlled commercial
entity), and income received by a controlled commercial
entity, do not qualify for exemption from tax under section
892 or exemption from withholding under sections 1441
and 1442. See Temporary Regulations section 1.892-3T.
In addition, certain distributions to a foreign govemment
from a real estate investment trust (REIT) may not be
eligible for relief from withholding and may be subject to
withholding at 35% of the gain realized. For the definition
of "commercial activities," see Temporary Regulations
section 1.892-4T.
Amounts allocable to a foreign person from a
partnership's trade or business in the United States are
considered derived from a commercial activity in the
United States. The partnership's net effectively connected
taxable income is subject to withholding under section
1446.
In general, payments to an international organization
from investment in the United States in stocks, bonds and
other domestic securities, interest on deposits in banks in
the United States, and payments from any other source
within the United States are exempt from tax under
section 892 and exempt from withholding under sections
1441 and 1442. See Temporary Regulations section
1.892-6T. Payments to a foreign central bank of issue
(whether or not wholly owned by a foreign sovereign) or to
the Bank for International Settlements from obligations of
the United States or of any agency or instrumentality
thereof, or from interest on deposits with persons carrying
on the banking business, are also generally exempt from
tax under section 895 and exempt from withholding under
sections 1441 and 1442. In addition, payments to a
foreign central bank of issue from bankers' acceptances
are exempt from tax under section 871(i)(2)(C) and
exempt from withholding under sections 1441 and 1442.
Effectively connected income or gain from a partnership
conducting a trade or business in the United States may
be subject to withholding under section 1446.
Payments to a foreign tax-exempt organization of
certain types of U.S. source income are also generally
exempt from tax and exempt from withholding. Gross
investment income of a foreign private foundation,
however, is subject to withholding under section 1443(b)
at a rate of 4%. Effectively connected income or gain from
a partnership conducting a trade or business in the United
States may be subject to withholding under section 1446.
Payments to a government of a possession of the
United States are generally exempt from tax and
withholding under section 115(2).
To establish eligibility for exemption from 30% tax and
withholding for chapter 3 purposes under sections 892,
895, 501(c), or 115(2), a foreign government, international
organization, foreign central bank of issue, foreign
tax-exempt organization, foreign private foundation, or
govemment of a U.S. possession must provide a Form
W-8EXP to a withholding agent or payer with all
necessary documentation. The withholding agent or payer
of the income may rely on a properly completed Form
W-8EXP to treat the payment, credit, or allocation
associated with the Form W-8EXP as being made to a
foreign government, international organization, foreign
central bank of issue, foreign tax-exempt organization,
foreign private foundation, or govemment of a U.S.
possession exempt from withholding at the 30% rate (or,
where appropriate, subject to withholding at a 4% rate).
Provide Form W-8EXP to the withholding agent or
payer before income is paid, credited, or allocated to you.
Failure by a beneficial owner to provide a Form W-8EXP
when requested may lead to withholding at the 30% rate,
the backup withholding rate, or the rate applicable under
section 1446.
In addition to the requirements of chapter 3, chapter 4
requires withholding agents to identify chapter 4 status of
payees receiving withholdable payments to determine
whether withholding applies under chapter 4. Under
chapter 4, certain foreign govemments, foreign central
banks, intemational organizations, and foreign entities
described in section 501(c) (other than an insurance
company described in section 501(c)(15)) are not subject
to withholding under chapter 4. A withholding agent may
request this Form W-8EXP to establish your chapter 4
status and avoid withholding.
Chapter 4 also requires participating FFIs and certain
registered deemed-compliant FFIs to document entity
account holders in order to determine their chapter 4
status regardless of whether withholding applies to any
payments made to the entities. If you maintain an account
with an FFI and have a chapter 4 status shown in Part I,
line 4 of this form, provide this Form W-8EXP when
requested by the FFI in order to document your chapter 4
status.
Additional information. For additional information and
instructions for the withholding agent, see the Instructions
for the Requester of Forms W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E,
W-8ECI, W-8EXP, and W-8IMY.
Who must file. You must give Form W-8EXP to the
withholding agent or payer if you are a foreign
govemment, international organization, foreign central
bank of issue, foreign tax-exempt organization, foreign
private foundation, or govemment of a U.S. possession
receiving a withholdable payment or receiving a payment
subject to chapter 3 withholding, or are such an entity
maintaining an account with an FFI requesting this form.
Do not use Form W-8EXP if:

• You are not a foreign government, international
organization, foreign central bank of issue, foreign
tax-exempt organization, foreign private foundation, or
govemment of a U.S. possession receiving amounts
subject to withholding under chapter 3 claiming the
applicability of section 115(2), 501(c), 892, 895, or
1443(b). Instead, provide Form W-8BEN-E, Certificate of
Status of Beneficial Owner for United States Tax
Withholding and Reporting (Entities), or Form W-8ECI,
Certificate of Foreign Person's Claim That Income Is
Effectively Connected With the Conduct of a Trade or
Business in the United States. For example, if you are a
foreign tax-exempt organization claiming a benefit under
an income tax treaty, provide Form W-8BEN-E.

• You are receiving withholdable payments from a
withholding agent requesting this form and you do not
have a chapter 4 status identified in Part I, line 4 of this
form.
-2- Instructions for Form W-8E/CP (Rev.4-2014)

• You are acting as an intermediary (that is, acting not for
your own account, but for the account of others as an
agent, nominee, or custodian). Instead, provide Form
W-RIMY, Certificate of Foreign Intermediary, Foreign
Flow-Through Entity, or Certain U.S. Branches for United
States Tax Withholding and Reporting.

• You are receiving income that is effectively connected
with the conduct of a trade or business in the United
States. Instead, provide Form W-8ECI.

• You are a tax-exempt organization receiving unrelated
business taxable income subject to withholding under
section 1443(a). Instead, provide Form W-8BEN-E or
Form W-8ECI (as applicable) for this portion of your
income.
• You are a foreign partnership, a foreign simple trust, or
a foreign grantor trust. Instead, provide Form W-8ECI or
Form W-81MY. However, a foreign grantor trust is required
to provide documentation of its grantor or other owner for
purposes of section 1446. See Regulations section
1.1446-1.
Giving Form W-8EXP to the withholding agent. Do
not send Form W-8EXP to the IRS. Instead, give it to the
person who is requesting it from you. Generally, this
person will be the one from whom you receive the
payment, who credits your account, or a partnership that
allocates income to you. Generally, a separate Form
W-8EXP must be given to each withholding agent.
Give Form W-8EXP to the person requesting it before
the payment is made, credited, or allocated to you or your
account. If you do not provide this form, the withholding
agent may have to withhold tax at the chapter 3 or
chapter 4 rate 30%, the backup withholding rate
(determined under section 3406), or the rate applicable
under section 1446. If you receive more than one type of
income from a single withholding agent, the withholding
agent may require you to submit a Form W-8EXP for each
different type of income.
Change in circumstances. If a change in circumstances
makes any information on the Form W-8EXP you have
submitted incorrect, you must notify the withholding agent
within 30 days of the change in circumstances and you
must file a new Form W-8EXP or other appropriate form.
Expiration of Form W-8EXP. Generally, a Form
W-8EXP remains in effect indefinitely until a change of
circumstances makes any information provided on the
form incorrect. In some cases, however, Form W-8EXP
will remain valid only for a period starting on the date the
form is signed and ending on the last day of the third
succeeding calendar year. For example, a Form W-8EXP
provided on February 15, 2015 by a controlled entity of a
foreign government would be subject to the three-year
validity period and thus would expire on December 31,
2018 for chapter 3 purposes. For more exceptions to the
indefinite validity period, see Regulations section
1.1441-1(e)(4)(ii) for chapter 3 purposes and Regulations
section 1.1471-3(c)(6)(ii) for chapter 4 purposes.
Definitions
Amounts exempt from tax under section 895. Section
895 generally excludes from gross income and exempts
from U.S. taxation income a foreign central bank of issue
receives from obligations of the United States (or of any
agency or instrumentality thereof) or from interest on
deposits with persons carrying on the banking business
unless such obligations or deposits are held for, or used in
connection with, the conduct of commercial banking
functions or other commercial activities of the foreign
central bank of issue.
Amounts exempt from tax under section 892. Only a
foreign government or an international organization as
defined below qualifies for exemption from taxation under
section 892. Section 892 generally excludes from gross
income and exempts from U.S. taxation income a foreign
govemment receives from investments in the United
States in stocks, bonds, or other domestic securities;
financial instruments held in the execution of
govemmental financial or monetary policy; and interest on
deposits in banks in the United States of monies
belonging to the foreign government. Income of a foreign
govemment from any of the following sources is not
exempt from U.S. taxation.
• The conduct of any commercial activity.
• A controlled commercial entity.
• The disposition of any interest in a controlled
commercial entity. For the definition of "commercial
activity," see Temporary Regulations section 1.892-4T.

Section 892 also generally excludes from gross income
and exempts from U.S. taxation income of an international
organization received from investments in the United
States in stocks, bonds, or other domestic securities and
interest on deposits in banks in the United States of
monies belonging to the international organization or from
any other source within the United States.
Amounts subject to withholding. Generally, an amount
subject to chapter 3 withholding is an amount from
sources within the United States that is fixed or
determinable annual or periodical (FDAP) income. FDAP
income is all income included in gross income, including
interest (as well as OID), dividends, rents, royalties, and
compensation. FDAP income does not include most gains
from the sale of property (including market discount and
option premiums), as well as other specific items of
income described in Regulations section 1.1441-2 (such
as interest on bank deposits and short-term OID).
For purposes of section 1446, the amount subject to
withholding is the foreign partner's share of the
partnership's effectively connected taxable income.
Generally, an amount subject to chapter 4 withholding
is an amount of U.S. source FDAP income that is also a
withholdable payment as defined in Regulations section
1.1473-1(a) to which an exception does not apply under
chapter 4. The exemptions from withholding or taxation
provided for under chapter 3 are not applicable when
determining whether withholding applies under chapter 4.
For exceptions applicable to the definition of a
withholdable payment, see Regulations section
1.1473-1(a)(4) (exempting, for example, certain
nonfinancial payments).
Beneficial owner. For payments other than those for
which a reduced rate of, or exemption from, withholding is
claimed under an income tax treaty, the beneficial owner
of income is generally the person who is required under
Instructions for Form W-8EXP (Rev.4-2014) -3-
U.S. tax principles to include the payment in gross income
on a tax return. A person is not a beneficial owner of
income, however, to the extent that person is receiving the
income as a nominee, agent, or custodian, or to the extent
the person is a conduit whose participation in a
transaction is disregarded. In the case of amounts paid
that do not constitute income, beneficial ownership is
determined as if the payment were income.
Foreign partnerships, foreign simple trusts, and foreign
grantor trusts are not the beneficial owners of income paid
to the partnership or trust. The beneficial owners of
income paid to a foreign partnership are generally the
partners in the partnership, provided that the partner is not
itself a partnership, foreign simple or grantor trust,
nominee or other agent. The beneficial owners of income
paid to a foreign simple trust (that is, a foreign trust that is
described in section 651(a)) are generally the
beneficiaries of the trust, if the beneficiary is not a foreign
partnership, foreign simple or grantor trust, nominee or
other agent. The beneficial owners of income paid to a
foreign grantor trust (that is, a foreign trust to the extent
that all or a portion of the income of the trust is treated as
owned by the grantor or another person under sections
671 through 679) are the persons treated as the owners of
the trust. The beneficial owners of income paid to a
foreign complex trust (that is, a foreign trust that is not a
foreign simple trust or foreign grantor trust) is the trust
itself.
The beneficial owner of income paid to a foreign estate
is the estate itself.
These beneficial owner rules apply primarily for
purposes of withholding under sections 1441 and 1442.
The rules also generally apply for purposes of section
1446, with a few exceptions. See Regulations section
1.1446-1 for instances where the documentation
requirements of sections 1441 and 1442 differ from
section 1446.
Chapter 3. Chapter 3 means Chapter 3 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Withholding of Tax on Nonresident Aliens
and Foreign Corporations). Chapter 3 contains sections
1441 through 1464.
Chapter 4. Chapter 4 means Chapter 4 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Taxes to Enforce Reporting on Certain
Foreign Accounts). Chapter 4 contains sections 1471
through 1474.
Commercial activities. For purposes of chapter 4,
commercial activities are financial activities of a type
engaged in by an insurance company, custodial
institution, or depository institution (including the act of
accepting deposits). An exempt beneficial owner will not
be considered exempt for chapter 4 purposes with
respect to payments derived from an obligation held in
connection with a commercial financial activity. See
Regulations section 1.1471-6(h), including limitations on
the scope of a commercial financial activity. For purposes
of chapter 3, commercial activities are described in
Temporary Regulations section 1.892-4T.
Controlled commercial entity. A controlled commercial
entity is an entity engaged in commercial activities
described in Temporary Regulations section 1.892-4T
(whether within or outside the United States) if the foreign
government holds:
• Any interest in the entity that is 50% or more of the total
of all interests in the entity, or
• A sufficient interest or any other interest in the entity
which provides the foreign government with effective
practical control of the entity.
An entity includes a corporation, a partnership, a trust
(including a pension trust) and an estate. A partnership's
commercial activities are attributable to its general and
limited partners for purposes of determining whether the
partner is a controlled commercial entity for purposes of
section 892. The partnership's activities will result in the
partnership having to withhold tax under section 1446 on
commercial income that is the effectively connected
taxable income allocable to a foreign government partner.
Note. A foreign central bank of issue will be treated as
a controlled commercial entity only if it engages in
commercial activities within the United States.
Chapter 4 status. The term chapter 4 status means a
person's status as a U.S. person, specified U.S. person,
foreign individual, participating FFI, deemed-compliant
FFI, restricted distributor, exempt beneficial owner,
nonparticipating FFI, territory financial institution,
excepted NFFE, or passive NFFE. See Regulations
section 1.1471-1(b) for the definitions of these terms.
Deemed -compliant FFI. Under section 1471(b)(2),
certain FFIs are deemed to comply with the regulations
under chapter 4 without the need to enter into an FFI
agreement with the IRS. However, certain
deemed-compliant FFIs are required to register with the
IRS and obtain a Global Intermediary Identification
Number (GIIN). These FFIs are referred to as registered
deemed -compliant FFIs. See Regulations section
1.1471-5(f).
Exempt beneficial owner. An exempt beneficial owner
means a person that is described in Regulations section
1.1471-6 and includes a foreign government, a political
subdivision of a foreign government, a wholly owned
instrumentality or agency of a foreign government or
governments, an international organization, a wholly
owned agency or instrumentality of an international
organization, a foreign central bank of issue, a
government of a U.S. possession, certain retirement
funds, and certain entities wholly owned by one or more
exempt beneficial owners. In addition, an exempt
beneficial owner includes any person treated as an
exempt beneficial owner under an applicable Model 1 IGA
or Model 2 IGA.
Financial institution. A financial institution generally
means an entity that is a depository institution, custodial
institution, investment entity, or an insurance company (or
holding company of an insurance company) that issues
cash value insurance or annuity contracts. See
Regulations section 1.1471-5(e).
Foreign central bank of issue. A foreign central bank of
issue is a bank that is by law or government sanction the
principal authority, other than the government itself, to
issue instruments intended to circulate as currency. Such
a bank is generally the custodian of the banking reserves
of the country under whose law it is organized. The Bank
Instructions for Form W-8EXP (Rev.4-2014)
of International Settlements is treated as though it were a
foreign central bank of issue.
A foreign central bank of issue must provide Form
W-8EXP to establish eligibility for exemption from
withholding for payments exempt from tax under either
section 892 or section 895.
Foreign financial institution (FFI). A foreign financial
institution (FFI) generally means a foreign entity that is a
financial institution.
Foreign person. A foreign person includes a
nonresident alien individual, foreign corporation, foreign
partnership, foreign trust, foreign estate, foreign
government, international organization, foreign central
bank of issue, foreign tax-exempt organization, foreign
private foundation, or govemment of a U.S. possession,
and any other person that is not a U.S. person. It also
includes a foreign branch or office of a U.S. financial
institution or U.S. clearing organization if the foreign
branch is a qualified intermediary. Generally, a payment to
a U.S. branch of a foreign person is a payment to a foreign
person.
Foreign government. For chapter 3 purposes, a foreign
govemment includes only the integral parts or controlled
entities of a foreign sovereign as defined in Temporary
Regulations section 1.892-2T. Similar definitions apply for
chapter 4 purposes under Regulations section
1.1471-6(b).
An integral part of a foreign sovereign, in general, is
any person, body of persons, organization, agency,
bureau, fund, instrumentality, or other body, however
designated, that constitutes a governing authority of a
foreign country. The net eamings of the governing
authority must be credited to its own account or to other
accounts of the foreign sovereign, with no portion
benefiting any private person.
A controlled entity of a foreign sovereign is an entity
that is separate in form from the foreign sovereign or
otherwise constitutes a separate juridical entity only if:

• It is wholly owned and controlled by the foreign
sovereign directly or indirectly through one or more
controlled entities.

• It is organized under the laws of the foreign sovereign
by which it is owned.
• Its net earnings are credited to its own account or to
other accounts of the foreign sovereign, with no portion of
its income benefiting any private person.
• Its assets vest in the foreign sovereign upon
dissolution.
A controlled entity of a foreign sovereign also includes
a pension trust defined in Temporary Regulations section
1.892-2T(c) and may include a foreign central bank of
issue to the extent that it is wholly owned by a foreign
sovereign.
A foreign govemment must provide Form W-8EXP to
establish eligibility for exemption from withholding for
payments exempt from tax under section 892 or for
purposes of establishing its status as an exempt beneficial
owner.
Intergovernmental agreement (IGA). An IGA means a
Model 1 IGA or a Model 2 IGA. For a list of jurisdictions
treated as having in effect a Model 1 or Model 2 IGA, see
"List of Jurisdictions" available at www.irs.gov/fatca.
A Model 1 IGA means an agreement between the
United States or the Treasury Department and a foreign
govemment or one or more agencies to implement
FATCA through reporting by FFIs to such foreign
govemment or agency thereof, followed by automatic
exchange of the reported information with the IRS. An FFI
in a Model 1 IGA jurisdiction that performs account
reporting to the jurisdiction's government is referred to as
a reporting Model 1 FFI.
A Model 2 IGA means an agreement or arrangement
between the U.S. or the Treasury Department and a
foreign government or one or more agencies to implement
FATCA through reporting by FFIs directly to the IRS in
accordance with the requirements of an FFI agreement,
supplemented by the exchange of information between
such foreign govemment or agency thereof and the IRS.
An FFI in a Model 2 IGA jurisdiction that has entered into
an FFI agreement is a participating FFI, but may be
referred to as a reporting Model 2 FFI.
International organization. For purposes of chapter 3,
an international organization is any public international
organization entitled to enjoy privileges, exemptions, and
immunities as an intemational organization under the
International Organizations Immunities Act (22 U.S.C.
288-288(f)). In general, to qualify as an international
organization, the United States must participate in the
organization pursuant to a treaty or under the authority of
an Act of Congress authorizing such participation.
Any organization that qualifies as an international
organization under chapter 3 also qualifies as an
international organization under chapter 4.
For purposes of chapter 4, an intemational organization
also includes any intergovernmental or supranational
organization that is comprised primarily of foreign
govemments, that is recognized as an intergovernmental
or supranational organization under a foreign law similar
to 22 U.S.C. 288-288(f) or that has in effect a
headquarters agreement with a foreign government, and
whose income does not inure to the benefit of private
persons.
Participating FFI. A participating FFI is an FFI (including
a reporting Model 2 FFI ) that has agreed to comply with
the terms of an FFI agreement. The term participating FFI
also includes a QI branch of a U.S. financial institution,
unless such branch is a reporting Model 1 FFI.
Specified U.S. person. A specified U.S. person is any
U.S. person other than a person identified in Regulations
section 1.1473-1(c).
Substantial U.S. owner. A substantial U.S. owner (as
described in Regulations section 1.1473-1(b)) means any
specified U.S. person that:

• Owns, directly or indirectly, more than 10 percent (by
vote or value) of the stock of any foreign corporation;

• Owns, directly or indirectly, more than 10 percent of the
profits interests or capital interests in a foreign
partnership;

• Is treated as an owner of any portion of a foreign trust
under sections 671 through 679; or
Instructions for Form W-80(11 (Rev.4-2014) -5-
• Holds, directly or indirectly, more than a 10 percent
beneficial interest in a trust.
Territory financial institution. The term territory
financial institution means a financial institution that is
incorporated or organized under the laws of any U.S.
territory. However, an investment entity that is not also a
depository institution, custodial institution, or specified
insurance company is not a territory financial institution.
Withholdable payment. The term withholdable payment
means an amount subject to withholding for purposes of
chapter 4 as described in "Amounts subject to
withholding," earlier. Also see Regulations section
1.1473-1(a) for the definition of withholdable payment.
Withholding agent. Any person, U.S. or foreign, that has
control, receipt, custody, disposal, or payment of U.S.
source FDAP income subject to chapter 3 or 4 withholding
is a withholding agent. The withholding agent may be an
individual, corporation, partnership, trust, association, or
any other entity, including (but not limited to) any foreign
intermediary, foreign partnership, and U.S. branches of
certain foreign banks and insurance companies.
Specific Instructions
Part I — Identification of Beneficial
Owner
Before completing Part I, complete the Worksheet for
Foreign Govemments, International Organizations, and
Foreign Central Banks of Issue, later, to determine
whether amounts received are or will be exempt from U.S.
tax under section 892 or 895 and exempt from withholding
under sections 1441 and 1442. Use the results of this
worksheet to check the appropriate box on line 3 and in
Part II. Do not give the worksheet to the withholding agent.
Instead, keep it for your records.
Line 1. Enter the full name of the organization.
Line 2. Enter the country under the laws of which the
foreign government or other foreign organization was
created, incorporated, organized, or governed.
Line 3. Check the one box that applies. A foreign central
bank of issue (wholly owned by a foreign sovereign)
should check the "Foreign government" box. If you are a
foreign private foundation, you should check the "foreign
private foundation" box rather than the "foreign
tax-exempt organization" box.
Line 4. Check the one box that applies to your chapter 4
status (if necessary). You are required to provide a
chapter 4 status if you are the payee of a withholdable
payment or hold an account with an FFI requesting this
form. See Regulations section 1.1471-3(a) for the
definition of a payee for purposes of chapter 4. By
checking a box on this line, you are representing that you
qualify for this classification and, if you are claiming a
status as an exempt beneficial owner, that you are the
beneficial owner of the payments to which this form
relates for purposes of chapter 4.
For certain chapter 4 statuses, you are required
to complete an additional fine on this form
certifying that you meet the conditions of the
status indicated on fine 4 (as defined under Regulations
section 1.1471-5 or 1.1471-6 or an applicable IGA). Make
sure you complete the required portion of this form before
signing and providing it to the withholding agent.
A CAL) 0
If you do not certify as to your chapter 4 status,
this Form W-8EXP will not be valid for purposes
of chapter 4 if you receive a withholdable
payment at any time in the future. For example, if you do
not certify as to your chapter 4 status because the only
payments you receive from the withholding agent are with
respect to grandfathered obligations described in
Regulations section 1.1471-2(b), then you will be required
to resubmit Form W-8EXP and certify to your chapter 4
status if you receive a withholdable payment in the future.
You may consider certifying to your chapter 4 status even
if not required in order to avoid resubmitting Form
W-8EXP to the withholding agent See "Expiration of Form
W-8EXP," earlier.
Line 5. The permanent address of a foreign government,
international organization, or foreign central bank of issue
is where it maintains its principal office. For all other
organizations, the permanent address is the address in
the country where the organization claims to be a resident
for tax purposes. Do not show the address of a financial
institution, a post office box, or an address used solely for
mailing purposes unless such address is the only
permanent address you use and it appears as your
registered address in your organizational documents.
Line 6. Enter the mailing address only if it is different from
the address shown on line 5.
Line 7. A U.S. taxpayer identification number (TIN)
means an employer identification number (EIN). A U.S.
TIN is generally required if you are claiming an exemption
or reduced rate of withholding based solely on your claim
of tax-exempt status under section 501(c) or private
foundation status. Use Form SS-4, Application for
Employer Identification Number, to obtain an EIN.
Line 8a. If the organization has registered with the IRS as
a participating FFI (including a reporting Model 2 FFI),
registered deemed-compliant FFI, (including a reporting
Model 1 FFI ), direct reporting NFFE, check the box for
"GIIN" and provide your GIIN. For payments made prior to
January 1, 2015, a Form W-8EXP provided by a reporting
Model 1 FFI need not contain a GIIN. For payments made
prior to January 1, 2016, a sponsored direct reporting
NFFE may provide the GIIN of its sponsoring entity.
Line 8b. If the organization has been issued a tax
identification number in its country of residence, enter it
here.
Line 9. This line may be used by the filer of Form
W-8EXP or by the withholding agent to whom it is
provided to include any referencing information that is
necessary or useful to the withholding agent in carrying
out its obligations. For example, a filer may use line 9 to
include the name and number of the account for which the
filer is providing the form.
-6- Instructions for Form W-8EXP (Rev.4-2014)
Part II — Qualification Statement for
Chapter 3 Status
You are not required to complete a chapter 3
qualification statement if you are submitting this
form to document your chapter 4 status and are
not receiving a payment that is subject to withholding
under chapter 3. However, in such a case, you may also
provide Form W-8BEN-E to document your chapter 4
status.
Line 10. All foreign governments claiming the
applicability of section 892 must check box 10a as well as
box 10b or box 10c, whichever applies. Enter the name of
the foreign sovereign's country on line 10b (if the entity is
an integral part of a foreign government) or on line 10c (if
the entity is a controlled entity). A central bank of issue
(wholly owned by a foreign sovereign) should check
box 10c.
Line 11. Check this box if you are an international
organization. By checking this box, you are certifying to all
the statements made in line 11.
Line 12. Check this box if you are a foreign central bank
of issue for purposes of chapter 3 (see definitions) not
wholly owned by a foreign sovereign. By checking this
box, you are certifying to all the statements made in
line 12.
Line 13. If you are a foreign tax-exempt organization, you
must attach a statement setting forth any income that is
includible under section 512 in computing your unrelated
business taxable income.
Box 13a. Check this box if you have been issued a
determination letter by the IRS. Enter the date of the IRS
determination letter.
Box 13b. Check this box it you do not have an IRS
determination letter, but are providing an opinion of U.S.
counsel concluding that you are an organization
described in section 501(c).
Box 13c. If you are a section 501(c)(3) organization,
check this box if you are not a private foundation. You
must attach to the withholding certificate an affidavit
setting forth sufficient facts concerning your operations
and support to enable the IRS to determine that you would
be likely to qualify as an organization described in section
509(a)(1), (2), (3), or (4). See Rev. Proc. 92-94, 1992-2
C.B. 507, section 4, for information on affidavit
preparation of foreign equivalents of domestic public
charities.
Box 13d. Check this box if you are a section 501(c)(3)
organization and you are a private foundation described in
section 509.
Line 14. Check this box if you are a government of a U.S.
possession. By checking this box you are certifying to the
statements made in line 14.
Part III — Qualification Statement for
Chapter 4 Status
You are not required to complete a chapter 4
qualification statement if you are not the payee of
a withholdable payment or are not an
accountholder holding an account with an FFI requesting
this form.
Line 15. Check this box to indicate that you are treated
as a nonreporting FFI under an applicable IGA (and as
defined in the IGA). You must identify the applicable IGA
by entering the name of the jurisdiction that has the
applicable IGA in effect with the United States. You must
also provide the withholding agent with the class of entity
described in Annex II of the IGA applicable to your status.
If you are an FFI treated as a registered
deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable Model 2 IGA,
you must provide your GIIN in the space provided.
Line 16. Check this box if you are a territory financial
institution. By checking this box, you are certifying to the
statement in line 16.
Line 17. Check this box if you are a foreign government,
government of a U.S. possession, or foreign central bank
of issue as defined for purposes of chapter 4 (see
Regulations section 1.1471-6). By checking this box, you
are certifying to the statement made in line 17.
Line 18. Check this box if you are an exempt retirement
plan of a foreign government as defined for purposes of
chapter 4. By checking this box, you are certifying to all
the statements made in line 18.
Line 19. Check this box if you are a 501(c) organization
other an insurance company described in section 501(c)
(15). By checking this box, you are certifying to the
statement made in line 19.
Line 20. Check box 20a if you are passive NFFE. If you
do not have any substantial U.S. owners, check box 20b.
If you have any substantial U.S. owners, you must provide
a statement providing the information set forth on line 20c.
Line 21. Check box 21 if you are a sponsored direct
reporting NFFE. Provide the name of your sponsoring
entity in the space provided. By checking this box, you are
certifying to the statements made in line 21.
Part IV - Certification
Form W-8EXP must be signed and dated by an
authorized official of the foreign government, international
organization, foreign central bank of issue, foreign
tax-exempt organization, foreign private foundation, or
government of a U.S. possession, as appropriate. By
signing Form W-8EXP, the authorized representative,
officer, or agent also agrees to provide a new form within
30 days following a change in circumstances that makes
any certification made on the form incorrect (unless no
future payments will be made to the organization by the
withholding agent). The authorized representative, officer,
or agent must also check the box to certify that he or she
has the capacity to sign for the organization.
Instructions for Form W-8EXP (Rev.4-2014) -7-
Paperwork Reduction Act Notice. We ask for the
information on this form to carry out the Internal Revenue
laws of the United States. You are required to provide the
information. We need it to ensure that you are complying
with these laws and to allow us to figure and collect the
right amount of tax.
You are not required to provide the information
requested on a form that is subject to the Paperwork
Reduction Act unless the form displays a valid OMB
control number. Books or records relating to a form or its
instructions must be retained as long as their contents
may become material in the administration of any Internal
Revenue law. Generally, tax returns and return
information are confidential, as required by section 6103.
The time needed to complete and file this form will vary
depending on individual circumstances. The estimated
average time is: Recordkeeping,6 hr., 42 min.; Learning
about the law or the form, 5 hr.,18 min.; Preparing and
providing the form, 8 hr., 2 min.
If you have comments concerning the accuracy of
these time estimates or suggestions for making this form
simpler, we would be happy to hear from you. You can
send us comments from www.irs.govIformspubs. Click on
"More Information" and then on "Give us feedback". You
can write to the Internal Revenue Service, Tax Forms and
Publications, SE:W:CAR:MP:TFP, 1111 Constitution Ave.
NW, IR-6526, Washington, DC 20224. Do not send Form
W-8EXP to this office. Instead, give it to your withholding
agent.
-8- Instructions for Form W-8EXP (Rev.4-2014)
Keep for Your Records
WORKSHEET FOR FOREIGN GOVERNMENTS, INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATIONS, AND FOREIGN CENTRAL BANKS OF ISSUE
(Do not give to the withholding agent)
Complete this worksheet to determine whether amounts received are or will be exempt from United States tax under section
892 or section 895 and exempt from withholding under sections 1441 and 1442.
• Foreign governments and foreign central banks of issue, start with question 1.
• International organizations, go directly to question 6.
FOREIGN GOVERNMENT Yes No
1 a Is the foreign government an integral part of a foreign sovereign (see Definitions)?
(If "Yes," go to question 4. If "No," answer question 1 b.)
b Is the foreign government a controlled entity of a foreign sovereign (see Definitions)?
(If "Yes," answer question 2a. If "No," go to question 7a.)
2 a Is the controlled entity a foreign central bank of issue (see Definitions)?
(If "Yes," answer question 2b. If "No," go to question 3.)
b Is the foreign central bank of issue engaged in commercial activities within the United States?
(If "Yes," answer question la. If "No," go to question 4.)
3 Is the controlled entity engaged in commercial activities anywhere in the world?
(If "Yes," income is not exempt from tax under section 892 and may be subject to withholding. Do not
complete Form W-8EXP for such income. Instead, complete Form W-8BEN-E or W-8ECI. If No,"
answer question 4.)
4 Does the foreign government or foreign central bank of issue (wholly owned by the foreign sovereign)
receive income directly or indirectly from any controlled commercial entities or income derived from the
disposition of any interest in a controlled commercial entity (see Definitions)?
(If "Yes," income is not exempt from tax under section 892 and may be subject to withholding. Do not
complete Form W-8EXP for such income. Instead, complete Form W-8BEN-E or W-8ECI. If No,"
answer question 5.)
5 Is any of the income received by the foreign government or foreign central bank of issue (wholly owned
by the foreign sovereign) from sources other than investments in the United States in stocks, bonds,
other domestic securities (as defined in Temporary Regulations section 1.892-31(a)(3)), financial
instruments held in the execution of governmental-financial or monetary policy (as defined in
Temporary Regulations section 1.892-3T(a)(4) and (a)(5)), or interest on deposits in banks in the
United States?
(If "Yes," income is not exempt from tax under section 892 and may be subject to withholding. Do not
complete Form W-8EXP for such income. Instead, complete Form W-8BEN-E or W-8ECI. If No,"
check the appropriate box on line 10 of Form W-8EXP.)
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O
INTERNATIONAL ORGANIZATION Yes No
6 Is the international organization an organization in which the United States participates pursuant to any
treaty or under an Act of Congress authorizing such participation and to which the President of the
United States has issued an Executive Order entitling the organization to enjoy the privileges,
exemptions, and immunities provided under the International Organization Immunities Act (22 U.S.C.
288, 288e, 2880?
(If "Yes," check the box on line 11 of Form W-8EXP. If "No," income may be subject to withholding. Do
not complete this form for such income. Instead, complete Form W-BBEN-E or W-8ECI.)
O O
FOREIGN CENTRAL BANK OF ISSUE Yes No
7 a Is the entity, whether wholly or partially owned by the foreign sovereign, a foreign central bank of
issue?
(If "Yes," answer question 7b. If "No," income is not exempt from tax under section 895 and may be
subject to withholding. Do not complete Form W-8EXP for such income. Instead, complete Form
W-8BEN-E or W-8ECI.)
b Is the income received by the foreign central bank of issue from sources other than obligations of the
United States (or any agency or instrumentality thereof) or from interest on deposits with persons
carrying on the banking business?
(If "Yes," income is not exempt from tax under section 895 and may be subject to withholding. Do not
complete Form W-8EXP for such income. Instead, complete Form W-8BEN-E or W-8ECI. If No,"
answer question 7c.)
c Are the obligations of the United States (or any agency or insbumentality thereof) or bank deposits
owned by the foreign central bank of issue held for, or used in connection with, the conduct of
commercial banking functions or other commercial activities by the foreign central bank of
issue?
(If "Yes," income is not exempt from tax under section 895 and may be subject to withholding. Do not
complete Form W-8EXP for such income. Instead, complete Form W-8BEN-E or W-8ECI. If No,"
check the box on line 12 of Form W-8EXP.)
O
O
O
O
O
O
-9-
Porn, W-8IMY (Rev. Apnl 201e)
Deparbnent of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Sevice
Certificate of Foreign Intermediary, Foreign Flow-Through Entity, or Certain
U.S. Branches for United States Tax Withholding and Reporting
► Section references are to the Internal Revenue Code.
► Information about Form W-8IMY and its separate instructions is at www.irs.govilomnv8imy.
► Give this form to the withholding agent or payer. Do not send to the IRS.
OMB No. 1545.1621
Do not use this form for

• A benefioial owner solely claiming foreign status or treaty benefits
• A hybrid entity darting treaty benefits on its own behalf

• A foreign person claiming that income is effectively connected with the conduct of a trade or business ki the United 
States

• A disregarded entity with a single foreign owner that is the beneficial owner of the income to which this form 
relates. Instead.
the single foreign owner should use
Instead, use Form:
W-8BEN or W-8BEN-E
W-8BEN-E
W-8ECI
W-8BEN. W-8ECI, or W-8BEN-E

• A foreign government. ntemational organization. foreign central bank of issue. foreign tax-exempt organization. 
foreign private
fandation. or government of a U.S. possession claiming the applicability of section(s) 115(2). 501(c). 892. 895. or 
1443(b)   W-8EXP
• u.S. entity or U.S. citizen or resident   W-9
W-8BEN. W-8BEN-E. or W-8ECI • A foreign person documenting themselves for purposes of section 6050W
Part I
1 Name of ndividual or organization that is acting as intermediary
Identification of Entity
2 Country of ncorporation or organization
3 Name of disregarded entity of applicable)
4 Chapter 3 Status:
❑ Qualified intermediary. Complete Part III.
❑ Nonqualified intermediary. Complete Part IV.
❑ Territory financial institution. Complete Part V.
❑ U.S. branch. Complete Part VI.
❑ Withholding foreign partnership. Complete Part VU.
5 Chapter 4 Status:
❑ Nonparticipating FFI (including a limited FFI or limited branch).
Complete Part IX (If applicable).
❑ Participating FFI.
❑ Reporting Model 1 FFI.
❑ Reporting Model 2 FFI.
❑ Registered deemed-compliant FFI (other than a reporting Model 1 FFI
or sponsored FFI that has not obtained a GUN).
❑ Territory financial institution. Complete Part V.
❑ Sponsored FFI that has not obtained a GIIN (other than a certified
deemed-compliant sponsored, closely held investment vehicle).
Complete Part X.
❑ Certified deemed-compliant nomegistering local bank. Complete Part
XII.
❑ Certified deemed-compliant FFI with only low-value accounts. Complete Part XIII.
❑ Certified deemed-compliant sponsored, closely held investment
vehicle. Complete Part XIV.
❑ Certified deemed-compliant limited life debt investment entity.
Complete Part XV.
❑ Withholding foreign trust. Complete Part VII.
❑ Nonwithholding foreign partnership. Complete Part VIII.
❑ Nonwithholding foreign simple trust. Complete Part VIII.
❑ Nonwithholding foreign grantor trust. Complete Part VIII.
❑Owner-documented FFI. Complete Part XI.
❑ Restricted distributor. Complete Part XVI.
❑ Foreign central bank of issue. Complete Part XVII.
❑ Nonreporting IGA FFI. Complete Part XVIII.
❑ Exempt retirement plans. Complete Part XIX.
❑ Excepted nonfinancial group entity. Complete Part )O(.
❑ Excepted nonfinancial start-up company. Complete Part )O(l.
❑ Excepted nonfinancial entity in liquidation or bankruptcy.
Complete Part XXII.
❑ Publicly traded NFFE or NFFE affiliate of a publicly traded
corporation. Complete Part XXIII.
❑ Excepted territory NFFE. Complete Part XXIV.
❑Active NFFE. Complete Part XXV.
❑ Passive NFFE. Complete Part XXVI.
❑ Direct reporting NFFE.
❑ Sponsored direct reporting NFFE. Complete Part XXVII.
Permanent residence address (street. apt. or suite no., or rural route). Do not use a MI. box or incare-of address 
(other than a registered address).
City or town, state or province. Include postal code where appropriate. Country
7 Mailing address (If different from above)
City or town, state or province. Include postal code where appropriate. Country
8 U.S. taxpayer identification number, if required ►
❑ GI-EIN ❑ WP-EIN
9 GIIN (if applicable)
❑ WT-EIN O EIN O SSN or ITIN
10 Reference number(s) (see Instructions)
For Paperwork Reduction Act Notice, see separate Instructions. Cat. No. 25402O Form W-8IMY (Rev. 4-2014)
Form W-NMY (Rev. 4-2014) Page 2
Disregarded Entity or Branch Receiving Payment (Complete only if disregarded entity or branch of an
FFI in a country other than the FFI's country of residence.)
11 Chapter 4 Status (FATCA status) of disregarded entity or branch receiving payment.
❑ Limited branch. ❑ Reporting Model 1 FFI.
❑ Participating FFI. ❑ Reporting Model 2 FFI.
12 Address of branch (street. apt. or suite no., or rural route). Do not use a `tax or in-care-of address (other than a 
registered address).
❑ U.S. Branch.
City or town, state or province. Include postal code where appropriate.
13 GIIN of any) ►
Part Ill
14a ❑ (All qualified intermediaries check here) I certify that the entity identified in Part I (or branch. if relevant):

• Is a qualified intermediary and is not acting for its own account with respect to the account(s) identified on line 10
or in a withholding
statement associated with this form: and

• Has provided or will provide a withholding statement, as required, for purposes of chapters 3 and 4 that is subject to
the certifications made
on this form.
Cheek all that apply:
b ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I of this form is not providing a withholding statement associated with
this form because it assumes
primary withholding responsibility for purposes of chapters 3 and 4. and either:

• Primary Form 1099 reporting and backup withholding responsibility: or
• Reporting responsibility as a participating FFI or registered deemed-compliant FFI with respect to accounts that it 
maintains and that are
held by specified U.S. persons as permitted under Regulations sections 1.6049.4(c)(4)(1) or (c)(4)(ii) in lieu of Form 
1099 reporting.
• ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I of this form assumes primary withholding responsibility under 
chapters 3 and 4 with respect to
payments made to each account identified on this line 14c (or on an attachment to this form) ►
Country
Chapter 3 Status Certifications
Qualified Intermediary
d ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I of this form assumes primary Form 1099 reporting and backup 
withholding responsibility with
respect to payments made to each account identified on this line 14d or on an attachment to this form or reporting 
responsibility as a
participating FFI or registered deemed-compliant FFI with respect to accounts that it maintains and that are held by 
specified U.S. persons
as permitted under Regulations sections 1.6049.4(cX4)(i) or (c)(4)(h) in lieu of Form 1099 reporting ►
e ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I of this form does NOT assume primary Form 1099 reporting and backup 
withholding responsibility
and is using this form to transmit Forms W-9 with respect to each account(s) held by a U.S. non-exempt recipient 
identified on this line 14e
or in a withholding statement associated with this form ►
If the entity identified on Part I of this form has allocated or will allocate a portion of a payment to a chapter 4 
withholding rate pool of
U.S. payees on a withholding statement associated with this form (check all that apply):
(I) ❑ I certify that the entity meets the requirements of Regulations section 1.6049-4(c)(4)(Iii) with respect to any 
account holder of an
account it maintains that is included in a withholding rate pool of U.S. payees provided on a withholding statement 
associated
with this form.
Op ❑ To the extent the entity is providing a withholding statement that includes a chapter 4 withholding rate pool of 
U.S. payees that
are accountholders of an intermediary or flow-through entity receiving a payment from the entity identified on line 1. I
certify
that the entity on line 1 has obtained or will obtain documentation sufficient to establish each such intermediary or 
flow-
through entity's status as a participating FFI. registered deemed-compliant FFI, or FFI that is a qualified 
intermediary.
f ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I of this form is acting as Qualified Securities Lender with respect to
payments associated with this
form that are U.S. source substitute dividends received from the withholding agent.
Part IV Nonqualified Intermediary
Check all that apply:
15a ❑ (All nonquatified intermediaries and qualified intermediaries that are not acting in their capacity as such check 
here) I certify that the entity
identified in Part I of this form is not acting as a qualified intermediary with respect to each account(s) for which 
this form is provided and is
not acting for its own account.
b ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I of this form is using this form to transmit withholding certificates 
and/or other documentation and
has provided. or will provide, a withholding statement, as required.

• ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I of this form meets the requirements of Regulations section 
1.6049-4(c)(4)(0 with respect to any
account holder of an account it maintains that is included in a withholding rate pool of U.S. payees provided on a 
withholding statement
associated with this form.
d ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I of this form is acting as a Qualified Securities Lender with respect 
to payments associated with
this form that are U.S. source substitute dividends received from the withholding agent.
Form W-RIMY (Rev. 4-2014)
Form W-NMY (Ftev. 4-2014) Pop 3
Territory Financial Institution
16 a 0 I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a financial institution (other than an investment entity that 
Is not also a depository institution,
custodial institution, or specified insurance company) that is incorporated or organized under the laws of a possession 
of the United States.
Check whichever box applies:
b 0 I further certify that the entity identified in Part I is using this form as evidence of its agreement with the 
withholding agent to be treated as
a U.S. person for purposes of chapters 3 and 4 with respect to any payments associated with this withholding 
certificate.
e 0 I further certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• is using this form to transmit withholding certificates and/or other documentation for the persons for whom it 
receives a payment: and

• Has provided or will provide a withholding statement, as required.
Part VI
17 a 0 I certify that the entity identified in Part I is receiving payments that are not effectively connected with the 
conduct of a trade or business in
the United States.
Check whichever box applies:
b 0 I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a U.S. branch of a foreign bank or insurance company described in 
Regulations
section 1.1441-1(b)(2)(iv)(A) that is a participating FFI (including a reporting Model 2 FFI). registered 
deemed-compliant FFI (including a
reporting Model 1 FFI). or NFFE that is using this form as evidence of its agreement with the withholding agent to be 
treated as a U.S.
person with respect to any payments associated with this withholding certificate.
e 0 I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is using this form to transmit withholding certificates and/or other documentation for the persons for whom the branch
receives a
payment: and

• Has provided or will provide a withholding statement, as required.
Withholding Foreign Partnership (WP) or Withholding Foreign Trust (WT)
18 0 I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a withholding foreign partnership or a withholding foreign trust 
that is compliant with the terms
of its WP or WT agreement.
Part VIII
19 0 I certify that the entity Identified in Part I:

• Is a nonwithholding foreign partnership, a nonwithholding foreign simple trust, or a nonwithholding foreign grantor 
trust and that the
payments to which this certificate relates are not effectively connected, or are not treated as effectively connected, 
with the conduct of a
trade or business in the United States: and

• Is using this form to transmit withholding certificates and/or other documentation and has provided or will provide a 
withholding
statement, as required for purposes of chapters 3 and 4, that is subject to the certifications made on this form.
Certain U.S. Branches
Part VII
Nonwithholding Foreign Partnership, Simple Trust, or Grantor Trust
Chapter 4 Status Certifications
Nonparticipating FFI with Exempt Beneficial Owners
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is using this form to transmit withholding certificates and/or other 
documentation and has provided
or will provide a withholding statement that indicates the portion of the payment allocated to one or more exempt 
beneficial owners.
laja  Sponsored FFI That Has Not Obtained a GIIN
21 a Name of sponsoring entity: IP
Check whichever box applies.
b 0 I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is an FFI solely because it is an investment entity:
• Is not a Ol, WP. or WI: and
• Has agreed with the entity identified above (that is not a nonparticipating FFI) to act as the sponsoring entity for 
this entity.
c 0 I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is a controlled foreign corporation as defined in section 957(a):
• Is not a Ol, WP. or WT:
• Is wholly owned. directly or indirectly, by the U.S. financial institution identified above that agrees to act as the 
sponsoring entity for this
entity: and

• Shares a common electronic account system with the sponsoring entity (identified above) that enables the sponsoring 
entity to identify all
account holders and payees of the entity and to access all account and customer information maintained by the entity 
including, but not
limited to. customer identification information, customer documentation, account balance. and all payments made to 
account holders or
payees.
Form W-RIMY (Ftev. 4-2014)
Form W-8IMY (Ftev. 4-2014) Page 4
Owner-Documented FFI
Note. This status only applies if the U.S. financial institution. participating FFI. reporting Model 1 FFI, or reporting
Model 2 FFI to which this form Is
given has agreed that it will treat the FFI as an owner-documented FFI. The owner-documented FFI must make the 
certifications below.
22a ❑ I certify that the FFI identified in Part I:

• Does not act as an intermediary:
• Does not accept deposits in the ordinary course of a banking or similar business:

• Does not hold, as a substantial portion of its business. financial assets for the account of others;

• Is not an insurance company (or the holding company of an insurance company) that issues or is obligated to make 
payments with
respect to a financial account:

• Is not affiliated with an entity (other than an FFI that is also treated as an owner-documented FFI) that accepts 
deposits in the ordinary
course of a banking or similar business, holds, as a substantial portion of its business, financial assets for the 
account of others, or is an
insurance company (or the holding company of an insurance company) that issues or is obligated to make payments with 
respect to a
financial account; and

• Does not maintain a financial account for any nonparticipating FFI.
Check whichever box applies:
b ❑ I certify that the FFI identified in Part I:

• Has provided. or will provide, an FFI owner reporting statement (Including any applicable owner documentation) that 
contains:

(I) The name, address, TIN (if any). chapter 4 status, and type of documentation provided (if required) of every 
individual and specified
U.S. person that owns a direct or indirect equity interest in the owner-documented FFI (looking through all entities 
other than
specified U.S. persons):

(II) The name, address. TIN (if any). chapter 4 status, and type of documentation provided Of required) of every 
individual and specified
U.S. person that owns a debt interest in the owner-documented FFI (including any indirect debt interest, which includes 
debt interests
in any entity that directly or indirectly owns the payee or any direct or indirect equity interest in a debt holder of 
the payee) that
constitutes a financial account in excess of $50,000 (disregarding all such debt interests owned by participating FFIs. 
registered
deemed-compliant FFIs. certified deemed compliant FFIs. excepted NFFEs. exempt beneficial owners, or U.S. persons other 
than
specified U.S. persons): and
OH) Any additional infonsation the withholding agent requests in order to fulfill its obligations with respect to the 
entity.
o ❑ I certify that the FFI identified in Part I:

• Has provided, or will provide, an auditor's letter. signed no more than four years prior to the date of payment, from 
an independent
accounting firm or legal representative with a location in the United States stating that the firm or representative has
reviewed the FFI's
documentation with respect to all of its owners and debt holders identified in Regulations section 
1.1471.3(d)(5)(iv)(A)(2) and that the FFI
meets all the requirements to be an owner-documented FFI. The FFI identified in Part I has also provided, or will 
provide, an FFI owner
reporting statement and Form W-9, with applicable waivers, as described in Regulations section 1.1471 -3(d)(6)(N).
Certified Deemed-Compliant Nonregistering Local Bank
23 ❑ I certify that the FFI identified in Part I:

• Operates and Is licensed solely as a bank or credit union (or similar cooperative credit organization operated without
profit) in its country
of incorporation or organization;

• Engages primarily in the business of receiving deposits from and making loans to, with respect to a bank, retail 
customers unrelated to
such bank and. with respect to a credit union or similar cooperative credit organization, members, provided that no 
member has a greater
than five percent interest in such credit union or cooperative credit organization:

• Does not solicit account holders outside its country of organization:
• Has no fixed place of business outside such country (for this purpose, a fixed place of business does not include a 
location that Is not
advertised to the public and from which the FFI performs solely administrative support functions):

• Has no more than $175 million in assets on its balance sheet and, if it is a member of an expanded affiliated group, 
the group has no
more than $500 million in total assets on its consolidated or combined balance sheets: and

• Does not have any member of its expanded affiliated group that is a foreign financial institution, other than a 
foreign financial institution
that is incorporated or organized in the same country as the FFI identified in Part I and that meets the requirements 
set forth in this Part XII.
Certified Deemed-Compliant FFI with Only Low -Value Accounts Part XIII
24 ❑ I certify that the FFI identified in Part I:

• Is not engaged primarily in the business of investing, reinvesting, or trading in securities, partnership interests, 
commodities, notional
principal contracts. insurance or annuity contracts, or any interest (Including a futures or forward contract or option)
in such security,
partnership interest, commodity, notional principal contract. insurance contract or annuity contract:

• No financial account maintained by the FFI or any member of its expanded affiliated group. If any. has a balance or 
value in excess of
$50,000 (as determined after applying applicable account aggregation rules); and

• Neither the FFI nor the FFI's entire expanded affiliated group, if any, have more than $50 million in assets on its 
consolidated or
combined balance sheet as of the end of its most recent accounting year.
Form W-8IMY (Rev. 4-2014)
Fomi W-8IMY (Rev. 4-2014) Page 5
Part XIV
25a
b
Certified Deemed-Compliant Sponsored, Closely Held Investment Vehicle
Name of sponsoring entity: ►
❑ I certify that the FFI identified in Part I:

• Is an FFI solely because it is an investment entity described in Regulations section 1.1471-5(e)(4):

• Is not a CI. WP. or WT:
• Will have all of its due diligence. withholding, and reporting responsibilities (determined as if the FFI were a 
participating FFI) fulfilled by
the sponsoring entity identified in line 25a: and

• Twenty or fewer individuals own all of the debt and equity interests in the entity (disregarding debt interests owned 
by U.S. financial
institutions, participating FFIs. registered deemed-compliant FFIs. and certified deemed-compliant FFIs and equity 
interests owned by an
entity that owns 100 percent of the equity interests in the FFI identified in Part I and is itself a sponsored FFI).
Part XV
26 ❑ I certify that the FFI identified in Part I:

• Was in existence as of January 17. 2013:
• Issued all classes of its debt or equity interests to investors on or before January 17. 2013 pursuant to a trust 
indenture or similar
agreement: and

• Is certified deemed-compliant because it satisfies the requirements to be treated as a limited life debt investment 
entity (such as the
restrictions with respect to its assets and other requirements under Regulations section 1.1471-4(0(2)(1v)).
Part XVI
27a ❑ (All restricted distributors check here) I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Operates as a distributor with respect to debt or equity interests of the restricted fund with respect to which this 
form is furnished;

• Provides investment services to at least 30 customers unrelated to each other and less than half of its customers are 
related to each
other:

• Is required to perform AML due diligence procedures under the anti-money laundering laws of its country of 
organization (which is a
FATF-compliant jurisdiction):

• Operates solely in its country of incorporation or organization. has no fixed place of business outside of that 
country, and has the same
country of incorporation or organization as all members of its affiliated group. if any:

• Does not solicit customers outside its country of incorporation or organization:
• Has no more than $175 million in total assets under management and no more than $7 million in gross revenue on its 
income statement
for the most recent accounting year.

• Is not a member of an expanded affiliated group that has more than $500 million in total assets under management or 
more than $20
million in gross revenue for its most recent accounting year on a combined or consolidated income statement: and
• Does not distribute any debt or securities of the restricted fund to specified U.S. persons. passive NFFEs with one or
more substantial
U.S. owners. or nonparticipating FFIs.
Check whichever box applies:
I further certify that with respect to all sales of debt or equity interests in the restricted fund with respect to 
which this form is furnished that are made
after December 31. 2011. the entity identified in Part I:
b ❑ Has been bound by a distribution agreement that contained a general prohibition on the sale of debt or securities to
U.S. entities and U.S.
resident individuals and is currently bound by a distribution agreement that contains a prohibition of the sale of debt 
or securities to any
specified U.S. person. passive NFFE with one or more substantial U.S. owners. or nonparticipating FFI.
❑ Is currently bound by a distribution agreement that contains a prohibition on the sale of debt or securities to any 
specified U.S. person,
passive NFFE with one or more substantial U.S. owners. or nonparticipating FFI and. for all sales made prior to the time
that such a
restriction was included in its distribution agreement. has reviewed all accounts related to such sales in accordance 
with the procedures
identified in Regulations section 1.1471-4(c) applicable to preexisting accounts and has redeemed or retired any 
securities which were sold
to specified U.S. persons. passive NFFEs with one or more substantial U.S. owners, or nonparticipating FFIs. or will 
transfer the securities
to a distributor that is a participating FFI reporting Model 1 FFI, or reporting Model 2 FFI.
Part XVII
28 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is treated as the beneficial owner of the payment solely for 
purposes of chapter 4 under
Regulations section 1.1471-6(d)(4).
Certified Deemed-Compliant Limited Life Debt Investment Entity
Restricted Distributor
Foreign Central Bank of Issue
Form W-8IMY (Rev. 4-2014)
Form W-SIMY (Rev. 4-2014) Page 6
Part XVIII Nonreporting IGA FFI
og ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Meets the requirements to be considered a nonreporting financial institution pwsuant to an IGA between the United 
States and

• Is entitled to the provisions of the IGA because the entity (or relevant branch) is considered a
under the provisions of the applicable IGA: and

• If you are an FFI treated as a registered deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable Model 2 IGA. provide your GIIN:
Part XIX
Check whichever box applies.
30a ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is established in a country with which the United States has an income tax treaty in force:
• Is operated principally to administer or provide pension or retirement benefits: and

• Is entitled to treaty benefits on income that the fund derives from U.S. sources (or would be entitled to benefits if 
it derived any such
income) as a resident of the other country which satisfies any applicable limitation on benefits requirement.
b ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is organized for the provision of retirement. disability. or death benefits (or any combination thereof) to 
beneficiaries that are former
employees of one or more employers in consideration for services rendered:

• No single beneficiary has a right to more than 5% of the FFI's assets:
• Is subject to government regulation and provides annual information reporting about its beneficiaries to the relevant 
tax authorities in the
country in which the fund is established or operated: and
Pr•
Exempt Retirement Plans
Is generally exempt from tax on investment income under the laws of the country in which it is established or operates 
due to its
status as a retirement or pension plan:
Receives at least 50% of its total contributions from sponsoring employers (disregarding transfers of assets from other 
plans
described in this part. retirement and pension accounts described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA. other 
retirement funds
described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA. or accounts described in Regulations section 1.1471-5(b)(2)0XA));
(ill) Either does not permit or penalizes distributions or withdrawals made before the occurrence of specified events 
related to
retirement. disability, or death (except rollover distributions to accounts described in Regulations section 
1.1471-5(b)(2)(i)(A)
(referring to retirement and pension accounts). to retirement and pension accounts described in an applicable Model 1 or
Model 2
IGA. or to other retirement funds described in this part or in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA): or
(iv) Limits contributions by employees to the fund by reference to earned income of the employee or may not exceed 
$50,000 annually.
c ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is organized for the provision of retirement. disability. or death benefits (or any combination thereof) to 
beneficiaries that we former
employees of one or more employers in consideration for services rendered:

• Has fewer than 50 participants:
• Is sponsored by one or more employers. each of which is not an investment entity or passive NFFE.

• Employee and employer contributions to the fund (disregarding transfers of assets from other plans described in this 
part. retirement and
pension accounts described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA. or accounts described in Regulations section 
1.1471-5(b)(2)(i)(A)) are
limited by reference to earned income and compensation of the employee. respectively:

• Participants that are not residents of the country in which the fund is established or operated are not entitled to 
more than 20 percent of
the fund's assets: and

• Is subject to government regulation and provides annual information reporting about its beneficiaries to the relevant 
tax authorities in the
country in which the fund is established or operates.
d ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is formed pursuant to a pension plan that would meet the requirements
of section 401(a). other
than the requirement that the plan be funded by a trust created or organized in the United States.
e ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is established exclusively to earn income for the benefit of one or 
more retirement funds described
in this part or in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA. accounts described in Regulations section 1.1471-5(b)(2)(i)(A) 
(referring to
retirement and pension accounts). or retirement and pension accounts described in an applicable Model 1 or Model 2 IGA.
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is established and sponsored by a foreign government, international organization, central bank of issue, or government
of a U.S.
possession (each as defined in Regulations section 1.1471-6) or an exempt beneficial owner described in an applicable 
Model 1 or Model
2 IGA to provide retirement. disability. or death benefits to beneficiaries or participants that are current or former 
employees of the sponsor
(or persons designated by such employees): or

• Is established and sponsored by a foreign government, international organization. central bank of issue. or government
of a U.S.
possession (each as defined in Regulations section 1.1471-6) or an exempt beneficial owner described in an applicable 
Model 1 or Model
2 IGA to provide retirement. disability. or death benefits to beneficiaries or participants that are not current or 
former employees of such
sponsor, but are in consideration of personal services performed for the sponsor.
Form W-8IMY (Rev. 4-2014)
Form W-81MV (Rev. 4-2014) Page 7
Ltrita  Excepted Nonfinancial Group Entity
31 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is a holding company, treasury center. or captive finance company and substantially all of the entity's activities are
functions described in
Regulations section 1.1471-5(e)(5)(i)(C) through (E):

• Is a member of a nonfinancial group described in Regulations section 1.1471-5(e)(5)(1x8);
• Is not a depository or custodial institution (other than for members of the entity's expanded affiliated group): and

• Does not function (or hold itself out) as an investment fund, such as a private equity fund, venture capital fund, 
leveraged buyout fund or
any investment vehicle with an investment strategy to acquire or fund companies and then hold interests in those 
companies as capital
assets for investment purposes.
Part XXI
32 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Was formed on (or in the case of a new line of business, the date of board resolution approving the new line of 
business)
(date must be less than 24 months prior to date of payment):
Excepted Nonfinancial Start -Up Company

• Is not yet operating a business and has no prior operating history or is investing capital in assets with the intent 
to operate a new line of
business other than that of a financial institution or passive NFFE: and

• Does not function (or hold itself out) as an investment fund. such as a private equity fund. venture capital fund. 
leveraged buyout fund. or
any investment vehicle whose purpose is to acquire or fund companies and then hold interests in those companies as 
capital assets for
investment purposes.
Part XXII Excepted Nonfinancial Entity in Liquidation or Bankruptcy
❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Filed a plan of liquidation. filed a plan or reorganization, or filed for bankruptcy on the following date:

• Has not been engaged during the past 5 years in business as a financial institution or acted as a passive NFFE:

• Is either liquidating or emerging from a reorganization or bankruptcy with the intent to continue or recommence 
operations as a
nonfinancial entity: and

• Has provided, or will provide. documentary evidence such as a bankruptcy filing or other public documentation that 
supports its claim if
it remains in bankruptcy or liquidation for more than three years.
Part XXIII
Check whichever box applies:
34a ❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is a foreign corporation that is not a financial institution: and
• The stock of such corporation is regularly traded on one or more established securities markets. including
b ❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is a foreign corporation that is not a financial institution:
• The entity identified in Part I is a member of the same expanded affiliated group as an entity the stock of which is 
regularly traded on an
established securities market:

• The name of the entity, the stock of which is regularly traded on an established securities market. is : and

• The name of the securities market on which the stock is regularly traded is ►
Part XXI
Publicly Traded NFFE or NFFE Affiliate of a Publicly Traded Corporation
Excepted Territory NFFE
❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is an entity that is organized in a possession of the United States:

• The entity identified in Part I:
(I) Does not accept deposits in the ordinary course of a banking or similar business.
(II) Does not hold. as a substantial portion of its business. financial assets for the account of others. and
(III) Is not an insurance company (or the holding company of an insurance company) that issues or is obligated to make 
payments with
respect to a financial account: and

• All of the owners of the entity identified in Part I are bona fide residents of the possession in which the NFFE is 
organized or incorporated.
htrM2  Active NFFE
36 ❑ I certify that:

• The entity identified in Part I is a foreign entity that is not a financial institution:
• Less than 50% of such entity's gross income for the preceding calendar year is passive income: and

• Less than 50% of the assets held by such entity are assets that produce or are held for the production of passive 
income (calculated as a
weighted average of the percentage of passive assets measured quarterly). See the instructions for the definition of 
passive income.
Form W-8IMY (Rev. 4-2014)
Form W-8IMY (Rev. 4-2014) Page 8
Part XXVI
37 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I:

• Is a foreign entity that is not a financial institution (this category includes an entity organized in a possession of
the United States that
engages (or holds itself out as being engaged) primarily in the business of investing. reinvesting. or trading in 
securities. partnership
interests. commodities. notional principal contracts. Insurance or annuity contracts. or any interest in such security. 
partnership interest.
commodity. notional principal contract. insurance contract or annuity contract): and
• Is using this form to transmit withholding certificates and/or other documentation and has provided or will provide a 
withholding
statement. as required.
Passive NFFE
Part XXVII Sponsored Direct Reporting NFFE
38 Name of sponsoring entity:
39 ❑ I certify that the entity identified in Part I is a direct reporting NFFE that is sponsored by the entity 
identified in line 38.
Part XXVIII Certification
Under penalties of paltry. I declare that I have examined the information on this form and to the best of my knowledge 
and belief it is true. correct. and
complete.
Furthermore. I authorize this form to be provided to any withholdeig agent that has control. receipt. or custody of the 
income for which I am providing this
form or any
withholding agent that can disburse or make payments of the amounts for which I am providing this town.
I agree that I will submit a new form within 30 days if any certification made on this form becomes incorrect
Sign Here Signature of authorized official Date (MM-DD-YYYY)
Form W-8IMY (Rev. 4-2014)
Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. June 2014)
Certificate of Foreign Intermediary, Foreign Flow -Through Entity, or Certain U.S.
Branches for United States Tax Withholding and Reporting
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
Section references are to the Internal Revenue Code unless
otherwise noted.
General Instructions
Future developments. For the latest information about
developments related to Form W-81MY and its instructions,
such as legislation enacted after they were published, go to
tiniewirs.gov/formw8imy.
What's New
Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA). In 2010,
Congress passed the Hiri entives to Restore
Employment Act of 2010, M. 111-147 (the HIRE Act), which
added chapter 4 of Subtitle A (chapter 4) to the Code,
consisting of sections 1471 through 1474 of the Code and
commonly referred to as "FATCA" or "chapter 4." Under
chapter 4, foreign financial institutions (FFIs) that are
participating FFls and certain registered deemed-compliant
FFIs are generally required to identify their U.S. account
holders, regardless of whether a payment subject to
withholding under chapter 3 or chapter 4 is made to the
account. In January 2013, final regulations were published
that provide due diligence, withholding, and reporting rules
for both U.S. withholding agents and FFIs under chapter 4.
Additionally, temporary and proposed regulations were
published in February 2014 providing updated rules under
chapter 4 as well as guidance coordinating chapters 3 and
61 with chapter 4. U.S. withholding agents and FFIs will be
required to begin withholding under chapter 4 on certain
payments beginning on July 1, 2014.
This form, along with Forms W-8BEN, W-BECI, and
W-8EXP, has been updated to reflect the withholding and
documentation requirements of chapter 4. In particular, this
Form W-8IMY is now used by an intermediary or flow-through
entity to certify as to its status under both chapter 3 and
chapter 4 and to address special provisions for
intermediaries and flow-through entities that are FFls.
In general, intermediaries and flow-through entities
receiving reportable amounts will be required to provide both
their chapter 3 status and the chapter 3 status of persons for
whom they receive such payments.
An intermediary or flow-through entity receiving a
withholdable payment will be required to provide its chapter 4
status and the chapter 4 status of persons for whom it
receives a withholdable payment when required for chapter 4
purposes. Failure to provide this information may subject the
intermediary or flow-through entity to withholding at a 30%
rate.
Qualified Securities Lender. Section 541 of the HIRE Act
added section 871(m) (formerly section 871(1)) to the Code,
which provides that certain dividend equivalent payments are
treated as U.S. source dividends subject to withholding at a
30% rate under chapter 3 (absent a code based exemption
or applicable income tax treaty provision) and under
chapter 4. For this purpose, the term "dividend equivalent"
includes "any substitute dividend made pursuant to a
securities lending or sale-repurchase transaction that
(directly or indirectly) is contingent upon, or determined by
reference to, the payment of a dividend from sources within
the United States."
Notice 2010-46 (2010-24 I.R.B. 757), however, provides
that a withholding agent is not required to withhold on a
dividend equivalent payment that is a substitute dividend
made to a Qualified Securities Lender (QSL) that certifies to
the withholding agent that it is acting as a QSL. The required
certifications for QSL status have been added to this Form
W-8IMY. For more information about 0SLs or withholding on
dividend equivalents generally, see Notice 2010-46, which
can be found at www.irs.gov/file source/puMrs-utV
notice 2010 46.01.
Note. For definitions of terms used throughout these
instructions. see Definitions, later.
Purpose of Form
Under chapter 3, foreign persons are generally subject to
U.S. tax at a 30% rate on income they receive from U.S.
sources that consists of interest (including certain original
issue discount (OID)), dividends, rents, premiums, annuities,
compensation for, or in expectation of, services performed,
or other fixed or determinable annual or periodical (FDAP)
gains, profits, or income. This tax is imposed on the gross
amount paid and is generally collected by withholding under
section 1441 or 1442 on that amount. A payment is
considered to have been made whether it is made directly to
the beneficial owner or to another person, such as an
intermediary, agent, trustee, executor, or partnership, for the
benefit of the beneficial owner.
Under chapter 4, withholding agents must withhold at a
30% rate under sections 1471 and 1472 on withholdable
payments made to nonparticipating FFIs (including when the
nonparticipating FR is a flow-through entity or is acting as an
intermediary), certain other foreign entities, and certain
account holders of FFIs. For example, if a U.S. withholding
agent makes a payment of portfolio interest described in
section 871(h) to an account maintained by a
nonparticipating FR, the payment will be subject to a 30%
withholding tax under section 1471 even if the
nonparticipating FR is an intermediary or flow-through entity
and the beneficial owner for whom the intermediary or
flow-through is acting is a foreign individual who provides a
valid Form W-8BEN.
Foreign persons are also subject to tax at graduated rates
on income they earn that is considered effectively connected
with a U.S. trade or business. If a foreign person invests in a
partnership that conducts a U.S. trade or business, the
foreign person is considered to be engaged in a V.S. trade or
business. The partnership is required to withhold tax under
section 1446 on the foreign person's distributive share of the
partnership's effectively connected taxable income. The
partnership may generally accept any form submitted for
purposes of section 1441 or 1442, with few exceptions, to
establish the foreign status of the partner. See Regulations
sections 1.1446-1 through 1.1446-6 to determine whether
Jun 18, 2014 Cat No. 25904R
the form submitted for purposes of section 1441 or 1442 will
be accepted for purposes of section 1446.
A CAUT101.
For purposes of section 1446, Form W-8/MY may
only be submitted by an upper-tier foreign
partnership or a foreign grantor trust, both of which
must furnish additional documentation for their owners.
Additional information. For additional information and
instructions for the withholding agent, see the Instructions for
the Requester of Forms W-8BEN, W-8BEN-E, W-8ECI,
W-8EXP, and W-8IMY.
Who Must File
Except as otherwise provided, you should provide Form
W-8IMY when receiving a reportable amount or withholdable
payment (see Definitions, later) on behalf of another person
or as a flow-through entity. When receiving a withholdable
payment, your chapter 4 status is also required to be
included on the form unless otherwise provided in
accordance with these instructions. Form W-RIMY must be
provided by the following persons.

• A foreign person, or a foreign branch of a U.S. person, to
establish that it is a qualified intermediary that is not acting for
its own account, to represent that it has provided or will
provide a withholding statement, as required, or, if
applicable, to represent that it has assumed primary
withholding responsibility under chapters 3 and 4 of the Code
(excluding section 1446) and/or primary Form 1099 reporting
and backup withholding responsibility.

• A foreign person to establish that it is a nonqualified
intermediary that is not acting for its own account, to certify
its chapter 4 status (if required), to certify whether it reports
U.S. accounts under chapter 4 (if required), and to indicate, if
applicable, that it is using the form to transmit withholding
certificates and/or other documentary evidence and has
provided, or will provide, a withholding statement, as
required. A U.S. person cannot be a nonqualified
intermediary.

• A V.S. branch that is acting as an intermediary to
represent that the income it receives is not effectively
connected with the conduct of a trade or business within the
United States and either that it is using the form (a) to
evidence it is treated as a V.S. person under Regulations
section 1.1441-1(b)(2)(iv)(A) with respect to any payments
associated with the Form W-8IMY, or (b) to certify to its
chapter 4 status and to transmit the documentation of the
persons for whom it receives a payment and has provided, or
will provide, a withholding statement, as required.

• A financial institution incorporated or organized under the
laws of a U.S. territory that is acting as an intermediary or is a
flow-through entity to represent that it is a financial institution
(other than an investment entity that is not also a depository
institution, custodial institution, or specified insurance
company) and either that it is using the form (a) to evidence it
is treated as a U.S. person under Regulations section
1.1441-1(b)(2)(iv)(A) with respect to any payments
associated with the Form W-8IMY, or (b) to certify that it is
transmitting documentation of the persons for whom it
receives a payment and has provided, or will provide, a
withholding statement, as required.

• A foreign partnership or a foreign simple or grantor trust to
establish that it is a withholding foreign partnership or
withholding foreign trust under the regulations for sections
1441 and 1442 and to certify its chapter 4 status (if required).

• A foreign partnership or a foreign simple or grantor trust to
establish that it is a nonwithholding foreign partnership or
nonwithholding foreign simple or grantor trust for purposes of
sections 1441 and 1442, to certify to its chapter 4 status (if
required), and to represent that the income is not effectively
connected with a V.S. trade or business, that the form is
being used to transmit withholding certificates and/or
documentary evidence, and that it has provided or will
provide a withholding statement as required.

• A foreign partnership or foreign grantor trust to establish
that it is an upper-tier foreign partnership or foreign grantor
trust for purposes of section 1446 and to represent that the
form is being used to transmit withholding certificates and/or
documentary evidence and that it has provided, or will
provide, a withholding statement, as required.

• A flow-through entity (including a foreign reverse hybrid
entity) transmitting withholding certificates and/or other
documentary evidence to claim treaty benefits on behalf of its
owners, to certify its chapter 4 status (if required), and to
certify that it has provided, or will provide, a withholding
statement, as required.

• A nonparticipating FFI acting as an intermediary or that is a
flow-through entity using this form to transmit a withholding
statement and withholding certificates or other
documentation for exempt beneficial owners described in
Regulations section 1.1471-6.

• A QSL certifying to a withholding agent that it is acting as a
QSL with respect to U.S. source substitute dividends
received from the withholding agent pursuant to a securities
lending transaction (as described in Notice 2010-46).

• A foreign intermediary or flow-through entity not receiving
withholdable payments or reportable amounts that is holding
an account with a participating FFI or registered
deemed-compliant FFI providing this form for purposes of
documenting the chapter 4 status of the account holder.
However, no withholding statement is required to be
provided along with Form W-RIMY if it is being provided by
an FFI solely to document such an account when no
withholdable payments or reportable amounts are made to
the account. Also note that the entity may instead provide
Form W-8BEN-E when it is not receiving withholdable
payments or reportable amounts to document its status as an
account holder.
This form may serve to establish foreign status for
purposes of sections 1441, 1442, and 1446. However, any
representations that items of income, gain, deduction, or loss
are not effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business
will be disregarded by a partnership receiving this form for
purposes of section 1446 as the partnership will undertake its
own analysis.
Do not use Form W-8IMY if you are described below.

• You are the beneficial owner of U.S. source income (other
than income that is effectively connected with the conduct of
a trade or business within the United States) and you need to
establish that you are not a U.S. person, establish your
chapter 4 status (if required), or claim a reduced rate of
withholding on your own behalf under an income tax treaty (if
applicable). Instead, submit Form W-8BEN, Certificate of
Status of Beneficial Owner for United States Tax Withholding
and Reporting (Individuals) or Form W-8BEN-E, Certificate of
Foreign Status of Beneficial Owner for United States Tax
Withholding and Reporting (Entities).

• You are filing for a hybrid entity claiming treaty benefits on
its own behalf. Instead, provide Form W-8BEN-E to claim
treaty benefits. However, if you are receiving a withholdable
payment you may also be required to provide this Form
W-RIMY to establish your chapter 4 status (unless you are a
disregarded entity) and the chapter 4 status of each of your
-2- Instructions for Form W-RIMY (Rev. 6-2014)
owners. See the instructions to Form W-8BEN-E for more
information about hybrid entities claiming treaty benefits.

• You are filing for a reverse hybrid entity that is not claiming
treaty benefits on behalf of its interest holders. Instead,
provide Form W-8BEN-E on your own behalf.

• You are the beneficial owner of income that is effectively
connected with the conduct of a trade or business within the
United States. Instead, provide Form W-BECI, Certificate of
Foreign Person's Claim That Income Is Effectively
Connected With the Conduct of a Trade or Business in the
United States.

• You are a nonresident alien individual who claims
exemption from withholding on compensation for
independent or certain dependent personal services
performed in the United States. Instead, provide Form 8233,
Exemption From Withholding on Compensation for
Independent (and Certain Dependent) Personal Services of a
Nonresident Alien Individual, or Form W-4, Employee's
Withholding Allowance Certificate.

• You are filing as a disregarded entity (a business entity
that has a single owner and is not a corporation under
Regulations section 301.7701-2(b) is disregarded as an
entity separate from its owner). Instead, the single owner (if a
foreign person) should provide the appropriate Form W-8
based on the single owner's status.
• You are filing for a foreign government, international
organization, foreign central bank of issue, foreign
tax-exempt organization, foreign private foundation, or
govemment of a V.S. possession claiming the applicability of
section 115(2), 501(c), 892, 895, or 1443(b), and, if required,
claiming an exemption from chapter 4 withholding. Instead,
provide Form W-8EXP, Certificate of Foreign Government or
Other Foreign Organization for United States Tax
Withholding and Reporting. However, these entities should
use Form W-8BEN-E instead if they are claiming treaty
benefits or are providing the form only to claim exempt
recipient status for Form 1099 and backup withholding
purposes.
Giving Form W-RIMY to the withholding agent. Do not
send Form W-RIMY to the IRS. Instead, give it to the person
who is requesting it. Generally, this person will be the one
from whom you receive the payment, who credits your
account, or a partnership that allocates income to you.
When to provide Form W-8IMY to the withholding agent.
Give Form W-8IMY to the person requesting it before income
is paid to you, credited, or allocated to your account. If you
do not provide this form, the withholding agent may have to
withhold at the 30% rate (for a payment subject to
withholding under chapter 3 or a withholdable payment under
chapter 4), backup withhold, or withhold at the applicable
rate for net effectively connected taxable income allocable to
a foreign partner in a partnership under section 1446.
Generally, a separate Form W-8IMY must be submitted to
each withholding agent from whom you receive a payment.
Expiration of Form W-8IMY. Generally, a Form W-8IMY
remains valid until the status of the person whose name is on
the certificate is changed in a way relevant to the certificate
or there is a change in circumstances that makes the
information on the certificate no longer correct. The indefinite
validity period does not extend, however, to any other
withholding certificates, documentary evidence, or
withholding statements associated with the certificate.
Change in circumstances. If a change in circumstances
makes any information on the Form W-8IMY (or any
documentation or a withholding statement associated with
the Form W-RIMY) you have submitted incorrect for purposes
of chapter 3 or chapter 4 (when relevant), you must notify the
withholding agent within 30 days and file a new Form
W-RIMY or provide new documentation or a new withholding
statement (as applicable). You must update the information
associated with Form W-SIMY as often as is necessary to
enable the withholding agent to withhold at the appropriate
rate on each payment and to report such income.
See Regulations sections 1.1441-1(e)(4)(ii)(D) for the
definition of a change in circumstances for purposes of
chapter 3. See Regulations section 1.1471-3(c)(6)(ii)(E) for
the definition of a change in circumstances for purposes of
chapter 4.
Definitions
Account holder. An account holder is generally the person
listed or identified as the holder or owner of a financial
account (other than an agent or nominee that is not an FFI).
For example, if a partnership is listed as the holder or owner
of a financial account, then the partnership is the account
holder, rather than the partners of the partnership. However,
an account that is held by a disregarded entity is treated as
held by the person owning the entity.
Amounts subject to withholding. Generally, an amount
subject to chapter 3 withholding is an amount from sources
within the United States that is fixed or determinable annual
or periodical (FDAP) income. FDAP income is all income
included in gross income, including interest (as well as OID),
dividends, rents, royalties, and compensation. FDAP income
does not include most gains from the sale of property
(including market discount and option premiums), as well as
other specific items of income described in Regulations
section 1.1441-2 (such as interest on bank deposits and
short-term OID).
Withholding under chapter 4 applies to payments of U.S.
source FDAP income that are withholdable payments as
defined in Regulations section 1.1473-1(a) to which an
exception does not apply under chapter 4. The exemptions
from withholding provided for under chapter 3 are not
applicable when determining whether withholding applies
under chapter 4. For exceptions applicable to the definition of
a withholdable payment, see Regulations section
1.1473-1(a)(4) (exempting, for example, certain nonfinancial
payments).
For purposes of section 1446, the amount subject to
withholding is the foreign partner's share of the partnership's
effectively connected taxable income.
Beneficial owner. For payments other than those for which
a reduced rate of, or exemption from, withholding is claimed
under an income tax treaty, the beneficial owner of income is
generally the person who is required under U.S. tax
principles to include the payment in gross income on a tax
return. A person is not a beneficial owner of income,
however, to the extent that person is receiving the income as
a nominee, agent, or custodian, or to the extent the person is
a conduit whose participation in a transaction is disregarded.
In the case of amounts paid that do not constitute income,
beneficial ownership is determined as if the payment were
income.
Foreign partnerships, foreign simple busts, and foreign
grantor trusts are not the beneficial owners of income paid to
the partnership or bust. The beneficial owners of income paid
to a foreign partnership are generally the partners in the
partnership, provided that the partner is not itself a
Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014) -3-
partnership, foreign simple or grantor trust, nominee, or other
agent. The beneficial owners of income paid to a foreign
simple trust (that is, a foreign trust that is described in section
651(a)) are generally the beneficiaries of the trust, if the
beneficiary is not itself a foreign partnership, foreign simple
or grantor trust, nominee, or other agent. The beneficial
owners of income paid to a foreign grantor trust (that is, a
foreign trust to the extent that all or a portion of the income of
the trust is treated as owned by the grantor or another person
under sections 671 through 679) are the persons treated as
the owners of the trust. The beneficial owner of income paid
to a foreign complex trust (that is, a foreign trust that is not a
foreign simple trust or foreign grantor trust) is the trust itself.
The beneficial owner of income paid to a foreign estate is
the estate itself.
Note. A payment to a U.S. partnership, V.S. trust, or U.S.
estate is treated as a payment to a U.S. payee that is not
subject to 30% withholding for purposes of chapter 3 and
chapter 4. A U.S. partnership, trust, or estate should provide
the withholding agent with a Form W-9. For purposes of
section 1446, a U.S. grantor trust or disregarded entity shall
not provide the withholding agent a Form W-9 in its own right.
Rather, the grantor or other owner shall provide the
withholding agent the appropriate form.
Chapter 3. Chapter 3 means Chapter 3 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Withholding of Tax on Nonresident Aliens
and Foreign Corporations). Chapter 3 contains sections 1441
through 1464.
Chapter 3 withholding rate pool. A chapter 3 withholding
rate pool is a payment of a single type of income, based on
the categories of income reported on Form 1042-S (for
example, interest or dividends), that is not subject to
withholding under chapter 4 but is subject to a single rate of
withholding for chapter 3 purposes and is paid to foreign
persons or, in the case of a zero-percent pool, U.S. exempt
recipients not included in a separate pool of exempt
recipients. See the instructions for the withholding statement
of a Cl, later.
Chapter 4. Chapter 4 means Chapter 4 of the Internal
Revenue Code (Taxes to Enforce Reporting on Certain
Foreign Accounts). Chapter 4 contains sections 1471
through 1474.
Chapter 4 status. The term chapter 4 status means a
person's status as a U.S. person, specified U.S. person,
foreign individual, participating FFI, deemed-compliant FFI,
restricted distributor, exempt beneficial owner,
nonparticipating FR, territory financial institution, excepted
NFFE, or passive NFFE. See Regulations section
1.1471-1(b) for the definitions of these terms.
Chapter 4 withholding rate pool. The term chapter 4
withholding rate pool means a pool identified on a
withholding statement (see the description for a withholding
statement of a al and an Nal, later) provided by an
intermediary or flow-through entity with respect to a
withholdable payment that is allocated to payees that are
nonparticipating FFIs. The term chapter 4 withholding rate
pool also includes a pool identified on an FFI withholding
statement provided by a participating FR or registered
deemed-compliant FFI with respect to a withholdable
payment that is allocated to a class of recalcitrant account
holders subject to withholding under chapter 4 as described
in Regulations section 1.1471- 4(d)(6)(i) (including a pool of
account holders to which the escrow procedures for dormant
accounts apply). Finally, a chapter 4 withholding rate pool
also includes a pool of U.S. persons included in a U.S. payee
pool described in Regulations section 1.6049-4(c)(4)
provided by a participating FFI (including a reporting Model 2
FFI), a registered deemed-compliant FFI (including a
reporting Model 1 FFI), or a CI.
Deemed-compliant FFI. Under section 1471(b)(2), certain
FFIs are deemed to comply with the regulations under
chapter 4 without the need to enter into an FR agreement
with the IRS. However, certain deemed-compliant FFIs are
required to register with the IRS and obtain a GIIN. These
FFIs are referred to as registered deemed-compliant FM.
See Regulations section 1.1471-5(f)(1) and also an
applicable IGA for entities treated as registered
deemed-compliant FFIs.
Disregarded entity. A business entity that has a single
owner and is not a corporation under Regulations section
301.7701-2(b) is disregarded as an entity separate from its
owner. A disregarded entity does not submit this Form
W-8IMY to a withholding agent or FFI. Instead, the owner of
such entity provides the appropriate documentation (for
example, a Form W-8BEN-E if the owner is a foreign entity).
See Regulations section 1.1446-1 and section 1.1471-3(a)(3)
(v), respectively. However, if a disregarded entity receiving a
withholdable payment is an FR outside the single owners
country of organization, the owner will be required to
complete Part II of Form W-8IMY to document the chapter 4
status of the disregarded entity receiving the payment except
as otherwise provided in these instructions.
Certain entities that are disregarded for U.S. tax purposes
may be recognized for purposes of claiming treaty benefits
under an applicable tax treaty (see the definition of hybrid
entity, later). See Form W-SBEN-E and the accompanying
instructions for more information about a hybrid entity
claiming treaty benefits on its own behalf.
Financial account. A financial account includes:

• A depository account maintained by an FFI:
• A custodial account maintained by an FFI:
• Equity or debt interests (other than interests regularly
traded on an established securities market) in investment
entities and certain holding companies, treasury centers, or
financial institutions as defined in Regulations section
1.1471-5(e);
• Certain cash value insurance contracts; and
• Annuity contracts.
For purposes of chapter 4, exceptions are provided for
accounts such as certain tax-favored savings accounts, term
life insurance contracts, accounts held by estates, escrow
accounts, and certain annuity contracts. These exceptions
are subject to certain conditions. See Regulations section
1.1471-5(b)(2). Accounts may also be excluded from the
definition of financial account under an applicable IGA. See
Regulations section 1.1471-5(b)(5) to determine when an FFI
maintains a financial account.
Financial Institution. A financial institution generally
means an entity that is a depository institution, custodial
institution, investment entity, or an insurance company (or
holding company of an insurance company) that issues cash
value insurance or annuity contracts. See Regulations
section 1.1471-5(e).
Fiscally transparent entity. An entity is treated as fiscally
transparent with respect to an item of income to the extent
that the interest holders in the entity must, on a current basis,
take into account separately their shares of an item of income
paid to the entity, whether or not distributed, and must
-4- Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014)
determine the character of the items of income as if they
were realized directly from the sources from which realized
by the entity.
Flow-through entity. A flow-through entity is a foreign
partnership (other than a withholding foreign partnership), a
foreign simple or foreign grantor trust (other than a
withholding foreign trust), or, for payments for which a
reduced rate of withholding is claimed under an income tax
treaty, any entity to the extent the entity is considered to be
fiscally transparent (see above) with respect to the payment
by an interest holder's jurisdiction.
Foreign financial institution (FFI). A foreign financial
institution (FFI) generally means a foreign entity that is a
financial institution.
Foreign person. A foreign person includes a nonresident
alien individual, a foreign corporation, a foreign partnership, a
foreign trust, a foreign estate, and any other person that is
not a U.S. person. It also includes a foreign branch or office
of a U.S. financial institution or U.S. clearing organization if
the foreign branch is a qualified intermediary. Generally, a
payment to a U.S. branch of a foreign person is a payment to
a foreign person.
Global intermediary Identification number (GIIN). The
term GIIN means a global intermediary identification number.
A GIIN is the identification number assigned to an entity that
has registered with the IRS for chapter 4 purposes.
Hybrid entity. A hybrid entity is any person (other than an
individual) that is treated as fiscally transparent (rather than
as a beneficial owner) for purposes of declaring status under
the Code but is not treated as fiscally transparent by a
country with which the United States has an income tax
treaty. Hybrid entity status is relevant for claiming treaty
benefits for purposes of chapter 3. A hybrid entity, may,
however, be considered the payee for purposes of chapter 4
(see Regulations section 1.1471-3(a) defining who is a payee
of a withholdable payment). See the special instructions for
hybrid entities, later, and Regulations section 1.1471-3(d) for
the documentation requirements with respect to entities
receiving withholdable payments.
Intergovernmental Agreement (IGA). An IGA means a
Model 1 IGA or a Model 2 IGA. For a list of jurisdictions
treated as having in effect a Model 1 or Model 2 IGA, go to
innvw.treasury.goviresource-centeritax-policy/treaties/Pages/
FATCA-Archive.aspx.
A Model 1 IGA means an agreement between the United
States or the Treasury Department and a foreign govemment
or one or more agencies to implement FATCA through
reporting by FFIs to such foreign government or agency
thereof, followed by automatic exchange of the reported
information with the IRS. An FR in a Model 1 IGA jurisdiction
that performs account reporting to the jurisdiction's
govemment is referred to as a reporting Model 1 FFI.
A Model 2 IGA means an agreement or arrangement
between the U.S. or the Treasury Department and a foreign
govemment or one or more agencies to implement FATCA
through reporting by FRs directly to the IRS in accordance
with the requirements of an FFI agreement, supplemented by
the exchange of information between such foreign
govemment or agency thereof and the IRS. An FFI in a
Model 2 IGA jurisdiction that registered with the IRS to obtain
a GIIN and agreed to comply with the terms of an FFI
agreement is treated as a participating FFI, but may be
referred to as a reporting Model 2 FFI.
Intermediary. An intermediary is any person that acts as a
custodian, broker, nominee, or otherwise as an agent for
another person, regardless of whether that other person is
the beneficial owner of the amount paid, a flow-through
entity, or another intermediary.
Qualified intermediary (O1). A CH is a person that is a
party to a withholding agreement with the IRS (described in
Regulations section 1.1441-1(e)(5)(iii)) and is:

• A foreign financial institution (other than a V.S. branch of
an FFI) that is a participating FR, registered
deemed-compliant FFI (including an FFI treated as a
registered deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable IGA),
FFI treated as a deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable
IGA subject to due diligence and reporting requirements
similar to those applicable to a registered deemed-compliant
FFI under Regulations section 1.1471-5(f), or limited FFI
(through December 31, 2015);

• An exempt beneficial owner that is a central bank of issue
that meets the requirements of and agrees to be treated as a
participating FR (including a reporting Model 2 FFI) or a
registered deemed-compliant FFI (including a reporting
Model 1 FFI) with respect to any account that it maintains
and that is held in connection with a commercial financial
activity described in Regulations section 1.1471-6(h) and for
which it receives a withholdable payment;

• A foreign branch or office of a U.S. financial institution or a
foreign branch or office of a U.S. clearing organization;

• A foreign corporation for purposes of presenting claims of
benefits under an income tax treaty on behalf of its
shareholders to the extent permitted to act as such by the
IRS; or

• A foreign entity other than an FFI that is acting as an
intermediary for either withholdable payments or reportable
amounts that the IRS accepts as a qualified intermediary.
Qualified securities lender (QSL). A QSL is a person
that:

• Is a bank, custodian, broker-dealer, or clearing
organization that is subject to regulatory supervision by a
govemmental authority in the jurisdiction in which it was
created or organized and is regularly engaged in a trade or
business that includes the borrowing of securities of
domestic corporations (as defined in section 7701(a)(4))
from, and lending of securities of domestic corporations to,
its unrelated customers; and
• Is subject to audit under section 7602 or is a QI that
satisfies the requirements for QSL status and acts as a QSL
under its Ol agreement.
For more information on OSLs and the requirements
related to withholding on substitute dividends, see Notice
2010-46. You can find Notice 2010-46 in Internal Revenue
Bulletin (IRB) 2010-24 at www.irs.gov/file source/pub/its-O/
notice 2010 46.pdf.
Nonqualifled intermediary. A nonqualified intermediary
is any intermediary that is not a U.S. person and that is not a
qualified intermediary.
Limited branch. A limited branch means a branch of a
participating FFI that is described in Regulations section
1.1471-4(e)(2).
Nonwithholding foreign partnership, simple trust, or
grantor trust. A nonwithholding foreign partnership is any
foreign partnership other than a withholding foreign
partnership. A nonwithholding foreign simple trust is any
foreign simple trust that is not a withholding foreign trust. A
nonwithholding foreign grantor trust is any foreign grantor
trust that is not a withholding foreign trust.
Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014) -5-
Participating FFI. A participating FFI is an FR (including a
reporting Model 2 FFI covered by an FFI agreement) that has
agreed to comply with the terms of an FFI agreement. The
term participating FFI also includes a QI branch of a U.S.
financial institution, unless such branch is a reporting Model
1 FFI.
Payee. A payee is generally a person to whom a payment is
made, regardless of whether such person is the beneficial
owner. For a payment made to a financial account, the payee
is generally the holder of the financial account. However,
under certain circumstances a person who receives a
payment will not be considered the payee. For purposes of
chapter 3, see Regulations section 1.1441-1(b)(2). For
purposes of chapter 4, see Regulations section 1.1471-3(a)
(3).
Reportable amount. Solely for purposes of the statements
required to be attached to Form W-8IMY, a reportable
amount is an amount subject to withholding under chapter 3,
U.S. source deposit interest (including original issue
discount), and V.S. source interest or original issue discount
on the redemption of short-term obligations. It does not
include payments on deposits with banks and other financial
institutions that remain on deposit for 2 weeks or less or
amounts received from the sale or exchange (other than a
redemption) of a short-term obligation that is effected outside
the United States. It also does not include amounts of original
issue discount arising from a sale and repurchase transaction
completed within a period of 2 weeks or less, or amounts
described in Regulations section 1.6049-5(b)(7), (10), or (11)
(relating to certain obligations issued in bearer form). See the
instructions for Forms 1042-S and 1099 to determine
whether these amounts are subject to information reporting.
Reverse hybrid entity. A reverse hybrid entity is any
person (other than an individual) that is not fiscally
transparent under U.S. tax law principles but that is fiscally
transparent under the laws of a jurisdiction with which the
United States has an income tax treaty.
Territory financial institution. The term territory financial
institution means a financial institution that is incorporated or
organized under the laws of any U.S. territory. However, an
investment entity that is not also a depository institution,
custodial institution, or specified insurance company is not a
territory financial institution. A territory financial institution
acting as an intermediary or that is a flow-through entity may
agree to be treated as a U.S. person under Regulations
section 1.1441-1(b)(2)(iv)(A).
U.S. branch treated as a U.S. person. The phrase U.S.
branch treated as a U.S. person means a U.S. branch of a
participating FR, registered deemed-compliant FR, or NFFE
that is treated as a U.S. person under Regulations section
1.1441-1(b)(2)(iv)(A)•
Withholdable payment. The term withholdable payment
means an amount subject to withholding for purposes of
chapter 4 as described in Amounts subject to withholding,
earlier. Also see Regulations section 1.1473-1(a) for the
definition of withholdable payment.
Withholding agent. Any person, U.S. or foreign, that has
control, receipt, custody, disposal, or payment of U.S. source
FDAP income subject to chapter 3 or a withholdable payment
under chapter 4 is a withholding agent. The withholding
agent may be an individual, corporation, partnership, trust,
association, or any other entity, including (but not limited to)
any foreign intermediary, foreign partnership, and U.S.
branches of certain foreign banks and insurance companies.
For purposes of section 1446, the withholding agent is the
partnership conducting the trade or business in the United
States. For a publicly traded partnership, the withholding
agent may be the partnership, a nominee holding an interest
on behalf of a foreign person, or both. See Regulations
sections 1.1446-1 through 1.1446-6.
Withholding foreign partnership (WP) or withholding
foreign trust (WT). A WP or WT is a foreign partnership or
a foreign simple or grantor trust that has entered into a
withholding agreement with the IRS in which it agrees to
assume primary withholding responsibility for purposes of
chapter 4 and under sections 1441 and 1442 for all payments
that are made to its partners, beneficiaries, or owners, except
as otherwise provided in the withholding agreement.
Withholding statement. A withholding statement provides
an allocation (by income type) to each payee (or withholding
rate pool, if applicable) of each payment an intermediary or
flow-through entity receives. The withholding statement
forms an integral part of the withholding certificate, and the
penalties of perjury statement provided on the withholding
certificate shall apply to the withholding statement. The
withholding statement may be provided in any manner the
intermediary or the flow-through entity and the withholding
agent mutually agree, including electronically if certain
safeguards conceming electronic transmission are met. A
withholding statement also provides information required for
purposes of chapter 4 if the intermediary or flow-through
entity is receiving a withholdable payment, in which case the
entity must provide an FR withholding statement, chapter 4
withholding statement, or exempt beneficial owner
withholding statement (as applicable). See Regulations
section 1.1471-3(c)(3)(iii)(B).
Specific Instructions
Part I — Identification of Entity
Line 1. Enter your name. By doing so, you are representing
to the payer or withholding agent that you are not the
beneficial owner of the amounts that will be paid to you
(unless you are acting as a QSL for certain payments
associated with this form). If you are a disregarded entity, do
not enter the business name of the disregarded entity here.
Instead, enter the legal name of the entity that owns the
disregarded entity (looking through multiple disregarded
entities, if applicable).
Line 2. If you are a corporation, enter the country of
incorporation. If you are another type of entity, enter the
country under whose laws you are created, organized, or
govemed. If you are an individual, provide your country of
residence for tax purposes.
Line 3. If you are a disregarded entity receiving a payment,
enter your name (if required). You should complete line 3
only if you are a disregarded entity receiving a withholdable
payment or hold an account with an FFI requesting this form
and you:

• Have registered with the IRS and been assigned a GIIN
associated with the legal name of the disregarded entity; and
• Are a reporting Model 1 FFI or reporting Model 2 FFI
If you are not required to provide the legal name of the
disregarded entity, however, you may want to notify the
withholding agent that you are a disregarded entity receiving
-6- Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014)
a payment or maintaining an account by indicating the name
of the disregarded entity on line 10. However, do not enter
the name of the disregarded entity on this line except in the
circumstances described.
Une 4. Complete this line to establish your entity status for
purposes of chapter 3. Check the one box that applies. If you
are a foreign partnership receiving the payment on behalf of
your partners, check the "Withholding foreign partnership"
box or the "Nonwithholding foreign partnership" box,
whichever is appropriate. If you are a foreign simple trust or
foreign grantor trust receiving the payment on behalf of your
beneficiaries or owners, check the "Withholding foreign trust"
box, the "Nonwithholding foreign simple trust" box, or the
"Nonwithholding foreign grantor trust" box, whichever is
appropriate. If you are a foreign partnership (or a foreign
trust) receiving a payment on behalf of persons other than
your partners (or beneficiaries or owners), check the
"Qualified intermediary" box or the "Nonqualified
intermediary" box, whichever is appropriate. A foreign
reverse hybrid entity that is providing documentation from its
interest holders to claim a reduced rate of withholding under
a treaty should check the appropriate box (including
"Withholding foreign partnership" or "Withholding foreign
trust" if the entity has entered into a withholding agreement).
See Parts III through VIII, later, if you are acting in more than
one capacity. A partnership or grantor trust submitting Form
W-RIMY solely because it is allocated income effectively
connected with a U.S. trade or business as a partner in a
partnership should check the box for nonwithholding foreign
partnership or nonwithholding foreign grantor trust and, if it is
submitting or will submit documentation for its partners or
owners, it should complete Part VIII.
Form W-BIMY may be submitted and accepted to
satisfy documentation requirements for purposes of
withholding on certain partnership allocations to
foreign partners under section 1446. Section 1446 generally
requires withholding when a partnership is conducting a
trade or business in the United States and allocates income
effectively connected with that trade or business (ECI) to
foreign persons that are partners in the partnership. Section
1446 can also apply when certain income is treated as
effectively connected income of the partnership and is so
allocated.
An upper-tier partnership that is allocated ECI as a partner in
a partnership may, in certain circumstances, have the
lower-tier partnership perform its withholding obligation.
Generally, this is accomplished by the upper-tier partnership
submitting withholding certificates of its partners (for
example, Form W-BBEN) along with a Form W-8/MY, which
identifies itself as a partnership, and identifying the manner in
which ECI of the upper-tier partnership will be allocated to the
partners. For further information, see Regulations section
1.1446-5. A foreign grantor trust that is allocated ECI as a
partner in a partnership should provide the withholding
certificates of its grantor (for example, Form W-8BEN) along
with its Form W-BIMY which identifies the trust as a foreign
grantor trust. See Regulations section 1.1446-1(c)(200(E) for
the rules requiring it to provide additional documentation to
the partnership.
Une 5. Check the one box that applies to your chapter 4
status. You are not required to provide a chapter 4 status if
you are providing this form with respect to a preexisting entity
account (as described in Regulations section 1.1471-1(b)
(102)) prior to July 1, 2016 (or, if you are a prima facie FFI,
prior to January 1. 2015). Additionally, you are only required
to provide a chapter 4 status if you are acting as an
intermediary with respect to a withholdable payment, you are
a How-through entity receiving a withholdable payment on
behalf of your owners (including a reverse hybrid entity
providing documentation on behalf of its owners to claim
treaty benefits), you are providing a withholding statement
associated with this form that allocates a portion of the
payment to a chapter 4 withholding rate pool of U.S. payees
with respect to your direct account holders (as described in
Regulations section 1.6049-4(c)(4), or you are providing this
form to an FFI requesting this form to document your
chapter 4 status. By checking a box on this line, you are
representing that you qualify for this classification.
For most of the chapter 4 classifications, you are
required to complete additional certifications found
in a separate part of this form (see Parts IX through
Vaal). Complete the appropriate part of this form certifying
that you meet the conditions of the status indicated on line 5
(as defined under Regulations sections 1.1471-5 or
1.1471-6). Make sure you complete the required portion of
this form before signing and providing it to the withholding
agent.
FFIs Covered by IGAs and Related Entities
A reporting FFI resident in, or established under the laws of,
a jurisdiction covered by a Model 1 IGA should check
"Reporting Model 1 FFI." A reporting FFI resident in, or
established under the laws of, a jurisdiction covered by a
Model 2 IGA should check "Reporting Model 2 FFI." If you
are treated as a registered deemed-compliant FFI under an
applicable IGA, you should check "Nonreporting IGA FFI"
rather than "registered deemed-compliant FFI." See the
specific instructions for Part XVIII. An FFI that is related to a
reporting IGA FFI and that is treated as a nonparticipating FFI
in its country of residence should check nonparticipating FFI
in line 5. An FFI that is related to a reporting IGA FFI and that
is a participating FFI, deemed-compliant FFI, or exempt
beneficial owner under the U.S. Treasury regulations or an
applicable IGA should check the appropriate box depending
on its chapter 4 status rather than the box for nonparticipating
FFI.
See www.treasury.goviresource-centeritax-policy/treaties/
Pages/FATCA-Archive.aspx for a list of jurisdictions treated
as having an IGA in effect.
Une 6. Enter the permanent address of the entity identified
on line 1. Your permanent residence address is the address
in the country where you claim to be a resident for purposes
of that country's income tax. Do not show the address of a
financial institution (other than yourself), a post office box, or
an address used solely for mailing purposes unless such
address is the only permanent address you use and it
appears in your organizational documents (i.e., your
registered address). If you do not have a tax residence in any
country, the permanent residence address is where you
maintain your principal office or, if you are an individual,
where you normally reside.
Une 7. Enter your mailing address only if it is different from
the address you show on line 6.
Une 8. You must provide an employer identification number
(EIN) if you are a U.S. branch or territory financial institution
that agrees to be treated as a U.S. person under Regulations
section 1.1441-1(b)(2)(iv)(A), an upper-tier partnership that is
allocated ECI as a partner in a partnership, or a foreign
grantor trust that is allocated ECI as a partner.
InStruCtiOns for Form W-RIMY (Rev. 6-2014)
If you are acting as a qualified intermediary, withholding
foreign partnership, or withholding foreign trust, check the
appropriate box and enter the EIN that was issued to you in
such capacity (your "O1-EIN," "WP-EIN," or "WT-EIN"). If you
are not acting in that capacity, you must use your U.S.
taxpayer identification number (TIN), if any, that is not your
OI-EIN, WP-EIN, or WT-EIN.
A nonqualified intermediary, a nonwithholding foreign
partnership, or a nonwithholding foreign simple or grantor
trust is generally not required to provide a U.S. TIN.
However, a QSL providing this form with respect to a U.S.
source substitute dividend must provide an EIN (including a
Cll-EIN if the QSL is a CM).
Line 9. If you are a participating FFI (including reporting
Model 2 FFI), registered deemed-compliant FFI (including a
reporting Model 1 FFI), direct reporting NFFE (including a
sponsored direct reporting NFFE), or trustee of a trustee
documented FFI, you are required to enter your GIIN (with
regard to your country of residence) on line 9.
For payments made prior to January 1, 2015, however, a
Form W-8IMY provided by a reporting Model 1 FFI need not
contain a GIIN. For payments made prior to January 1, 2016,
a sponsored direct reporting NFFE or sponsored FFI that has
not obtained a GIIN may provide the GIIN of its sponsoring
entity.
If you are in the process of registering with the IRS
as a participating FFI, registered deemed-compliant
FFI, reporting Model 1 FFI, reporting Model 2 FFI,
direct reporting NFFE, or sponsored direct reporting NFFE
but have not received a MIN, you may complete this line by
writing "applied for." However, the person requesting this
form from you must receive and verify your GIIN within 90
days.
Line 10. This line may be used by the filer of Form W-8IMY
or by the withholding agent to whom it is provided to include
any referencing information that is useful to the withholding
agent in carrying out its reporting and withholding obligations.
For example, a withholding agent who is required to
associate a particular Form W-SBEN or Form W-8BEN-E
with this Form W-SIMY may want to use line 10 for a
referencing number or code that will make the association
clear.
Part II — Disregarded Entity or
Branch Receiving Payment
A CAU11011
Only complete Part II if you are a branch of an FR
identified in line 1 receiving a withholdable payment
as an intermediary (including a branch that is a
disregarded entity) and you operate in a jurisdiction other
than the country of residence identified on line 2. For
example, assume ABC Co., which is a participating FR
resident in Country A, operates through a branch in Country
B (which is a Model 1 IGA jurisdiction) and the branch is
treated as a reporting Model 1 FFI under the terms of the
Country B Model 1 !GA. ABC Co. should not enter its GIIN on
line 9, and the Country B branch should complete this Part
by identifying itself as a reporting Model 1 IGA FR and
providing its GIIN on line 13. Furthermore, if the Country B
branch receiving the payment is a disregarded entity you
may be required to provide its legal name on line 3. See the
instructions for Part 1, line 3.
Line 11. Check the one box that applies. If you check
reporting Model 1 FFI, reporting Model 2 FFI, participating
FFI, or U.S. branch claiming a chapter 4 status other than
that of nonparticipating FFI, you must complete line 13. If you
are a limited branch or branch of a reporting IGA FFI that
cannot comply with the requirements of an applicable IGA or
the regulations under chapter 4, you must check
nonparticipating FFI.
Line 12. Enter the address of the branch or disregarded
entity.
Line 13. If you are a reporting Model 1 FR, reporting Model
2 FFI, or participating FFI, you must enter on line 13 the GIIN
of your branch that receives the payment. If you are a
disregarded entity that completed Part I, line 3 of this form
and are receiving payments associated with this form, enter
your GIIN. Do not enter your GIIN (if any) on line 9. If you are
a U.S. branch, enter a GIIN applicable to any other branch of
the FFI (including in its residence country) of which the
branch is a part. For payments made prior to January 1,
2015, however, a GIIN is not required if you check reporting
Model 1 FFI on line 11. If you are a CM that is an NFFE and a
withholding agent requests your chapter 4 status, you may
provide a statement certifying to your chapter 4 status as an
NFFE.
If you are in the process of registering with the IRS
as a participating FR, reporting Model 1 FR, or
reporting Model 2 FR but have not received a GIIN,
you may complete this line by writing "applied for." However,
the person requesting this form from you must receive and
verify your GIIN within 90 days.
Certification of Chapter 3 Status:
Parts III Through VIII
You should only complete one part from Parts III through VIII.
If you are acting in multiple capacities, provide separate
Forms W-8IMY for each capacity. For example, if you are
acting as qualified intermediary for one account, but a
nonqualified intermediary for another account, provide one
Form W-8IMY in your capacity as a qualified intermediary
and a separate Form W-8IMY in your capacity as a
nonqualified intermediary.
Part III — Qualified Intermediary
Check box 14a if you are a qualified intermediary (Cl)
(whether or not you assume primary withholding
responsibility) for the income for which you are providing this
form. A O1 that is an FFI receiving a withholdable payment
must be a participating FFI, registered deemed-compliant
FFI, exempt beneficial owner that is a central bank of issue
that meets the requirements of and agrees to be treated as a
participating FR (including a reporting Model 2 FR) or a
registered deemed-compliant FFI (including a reporting
Model 1 FFI) with respect to any account that it maintains
and that is held in connection with a commercial financial
activity described in Regulations section 1.1471-6(h) and for
which it receives a withholdable payment, or FFI treated as a
deemed-compliant FFI under an applicable IGA that is
subject to due diligence and reporting requirements similar to
those applicable to a registered deemed-compliant FFI. By
checking the box, you are certifying to all of the statements
contained on line 14a.
Check box 14b only if you are not providing a withholding
statement with this form because you have assumed primary
withholding responsibility under both chapter 3 (nonresident
alien withholding) and chapter 4 with respect to the
account(s) and you are either assuming primary Form 1099
-8- Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014)
reporting and backup withholding responsibility or are
permitted to satisfy and do satisfy your chapter 61
requirements as a participating FFI or registered
deemed-compliant FFI as described in Regulations section
1.6049-4(c)(4).
Check box 14c if you have assumed only primary
withholding responsibility under both chapter 3 (nonresident
alien withholding) and chapter 4 with respect to the
account(s) identified on this line or in a withholding statement
associated with this form.
Check box 14d if you have assumed only primary Form
1099 reporting and backup withholding responsibility with
respect to the accounts identified on this line or in a
withholding statement associated with this form (including
satisfying as a participating FFI or registered
deemed-compliant FFI your Form 1099 reporting to the
extent permitted under Regulations sections 1.6049-4(c)(4)(i)
and (c)(4)(ii))•
Check box 14e only if you have not assumed primary
Form 1099 reporting and backup withholding responsibility
and are transmitting Forms W-9 (or otherwise providing
information for the withholding agent to report on Form 1099,
including when backup withholding applies or withholding
under chapter 4 with respect to recalcitrant account holders)
with respect to each U.S. non-exempt recipient account
identified on this line or in a withholding statement associated
with this form. If you are allocating any portion of the payment
on a withholding statement to a chapter 4 withholding rate
pool of U.S. payees in lieu of providing Forms W-9, you must
additionally certify that (as applicable):

• For each account holder included in a chapter 4
withholding rate pool of U.S. payees who holds an account
that you maintain, you are permitted to provide this pool
under Regulations section 1.6049-4(c)(4)(iii) (including for
payments of income other than interest for which reporting
would be required under chapter 61 but for a coordination
rule similar to that provided in Regulations section
1.6049-4(c)(4)(iii)); and/or
• For a withholding rate pool of U.S. payees that includes
account holders of another intermediary or flow-through
entity, you have obtained or will obtain documentation to
establish that the intermediary or flow-through entity is a
participating FR, registered deemed-compliant FR, or a
qualified intermediary. See Regulations sections 1.1471-3(d)
(4) and 1.1471-3(e) for more information on the requirements
for documenting such chapter 4 statuses.
Check box 14f to certify that you are a athat is acting as
a CiSL with respect to all payments associated with this form
that are U.S. source substitute dividends made by a party to
a securities lending transaction (as described in Notice
2010-46).
Although a CI obtains withholding certificates or
appropriate documentation from beneficial owners, payees,
and, if applicable, shareholders, as specified in its
withholding agreement with the IRS, a CI does not need to
attach the certificates or documentation to this form.
However, to the extent you have not assumed primary Form
1099 reporting or backup withholding responsibility and are
not permitted to allocate the payment to a chapter 4
withholding rate pool of U.S. payees under Regulations
section 1.6049-4(c)(4)(iii), you must disclose the names of
those U.S. persons for whom you receive reportable amounts
and that are not exempt recipients (as defined in Regulations
section 1.6049-4(c)(1)(ii) or under section 6041, 6042, 6045,
or 6050N). You should make this disclosure by attaching to
Form W-8IMY the Forms W-9 (or substitute forms) of
persons that are U.S. non-exempt recipients. If you do not
have a Form W-9 for a non-exempt U.S. payee, you must
attach to Form W-8IMY any information you do have
regarding that person's name, address, and TIN for a
withholding agent to report the payment.
Withholding statement of a O1. As a 01, you must provide
a withholding statement to each withholding agent from
which you receive reportable amounts or withholdable
payments if you have not assumed primary reporting and
withholding responsibility under chapter 3 and chapter 4 with
respect to the payment and, if you are receiving a reportable
amount on behalf of a V.S. nonexempt recipient, you have
not assumed primary Form 1099 reporting and backup
withholding responsibility for the payment. The withholding
statement becomes an integral part of the Form W-8IMY and,
therefore, the certification statement that you sign in Part
XXVII of the form applies to the withholding statement as well
as to the form.
See your Of Agreement for a more comprehensive
description of the rules applicable to your
withholding statement, including the requirements of
the statement under both chapter 3 and chapter 4 for
reportable amounts that are also withholdable payments.
A COV1, Ul
A Cil withholding statement must:

• Designate those accounts for which you act as a 01 (01
designated account),
• Designate those accounts for which you are assuming
primary withholding and reporting responsibility under
chapter 3 and chapter 4 of the Code,

• If applicable, certify that you are acting as a QSL with
respect to any U.S. source substitute dividends, and

• Provide information to allocate the payment, as
applicable, to chapter 3 withholding rate pools and to
chapter 4 withholding rate pools.
For chapter 4 purposes. A O1 receiving a withholdable
payment must provide a withholding statement which
satisfies the requirements of an FR withholding statement or
chapter 4 withholding statement (if the (Nis not an FFI) when
the Oldoes not assume primary withholding responsibility
under chapter 3 and chapter 4 and Form 1099 reporting and
backup withholding responsibility for the payment.
A O1 that is an FFI may provide an FFI withholding
statement to allocate the payment to chapter 4 withholding
rate pools (as applicable), including a single pool of
nonparticipating FFIs, a single pool of recalcitrant account
holders of the CI or another intermediary that is a
participating FFI or registered deemed-compliant FFI, and, if
the Cil does not assume primary Form 1099 and backup
withholding responsibility, a chapter 4 withholding rate pool
of U.S. payees. See also Form 1099 reporting, later. A
chapter 4 withholding rate pool of U.S. payees may include:

• If the O1 is a reporting Model 1 FEL an account holder that
is not withheld on under chapter 3, chapter 4, or section 3406
that the CI reports as a U.S. account pursuant to the Model 1
IGA because the account has U.S. indicia and the CI has not
obtained appropriate documentation to treat the account as
held by other than a specified V.S. person;

• If the QI is a reporting Model 2 FFI, an account holder that
is not withheld on under chapter 3, chapter 4, or section 3406
that the 01 reports as an account holder of a non-consenting
U.S. account as described in the Model 2 IGA;
• For a non-U.S. payor (as described in Regulations section
1.6049-5(0)(5)) that is a participating FR (including a
Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014) -9-
reporting Model 2 FFI), registered deemed-compliant FFI, or
reporting Model 1 FFI, an account holder not withheld on
under chapter 4 or section 3406 who the 01 reports under
chapter 4 or an applicable 1GA (including the account
holder's TIN).
An FFI withholding statement must also identify each
intermediary or flow-through entity that is receiving a
payment on behalf of a payee and include such entity's
chapter 4 status and GIIN (if applicable), excluding any
intermediary or flow-through entity that is an account holder
or interest holder in another 01, WP, or WT. An FFI
withholding statement of a 01 may combine withholding rate
pool information provided by such an entity to the O1 with
withholding rate pools comprised of accounts that the 01
maintains.
A O1 that is not an FFI and that does not assume primary
withholding responsibility under chapter 3 and chapter 4
must provide a chapter 4 withholding statement that contains
the name, address, TIN (if any), entity type (if applicable),
and chapter 4 status of each payee, the amount allocated to
each payee, a valid withholding certificate or other
documentation sufficient to establish the payee's chapter 4
status. However, a chapter 4 withholding statement may
include pooled information for payees that are
nonparticipating FFIs that hold accounts that the 01
maintains or hold accounts with an intermediary or
flow-through entity receiving the payment from the O1. See
Regulations section 1.1474-1(d)(3).
For chapter 3 purposes. In the case of a reportable
amount that is a withholdable payment, any portion of the
payment for which you are acting as a 01 that is not allocated
to a chapter 4 withholding rate pool or a U.S. non-exempt
recipient (including for backup withholding purposes) must
be allocated to a chapter 3 withholding rate pool or pool of
U.S. exempt recipients. A chapter 3 withholding rate pool is a
payment of a single type of income, based on the categories
of income reported on Form 1042-S or Form 1099 (for
example, interest or dividends), that is subject to a single rate
of withholding and is exempt from chapter 4 withholding. The
chapter 3 withholding rate pool may be established by any
reasonable method agreed upon by you and the withholding
agent. For example, you may agree to establish a separate
account for a single chapter 3 withholding rate pool or you
may agree to divide a payment made to a single account into
portions allocable to each chapter 3 withholding rate pool.
You must provide the chapter 3 withholding rate pool
information that is required for the withholding agent to meet
its withholding and reporting obligations. A withholding agent
may request any information reasonably necessary to
withhold and report payments correctly.
Form 1099 reporting. If you do not assume primary Form
1099 reporting and backup withholding responsibility, you
must provide payee specific information for each U.S.
non-exempt recipient account holder (other than those U.S.
payees included in a chapter 4 withholding rate pool of U.S.
payees (described in Regulations section 1.6049-4(c)(4)(iii)
and earlier in these instructions) or when the altemative
procedure is used (see later)). The pools are based on valid
documentation that you obtain under your withholding
agreement with the IRS or, if a payment cannot be reliably
associated with valid documentation, under the applicable
presumption rules.
Example 1. A 01 that is a participating FFI receives a
$100 payment of U.S. source dividends on an account that is
a O1 designated account held with the withholding agent for
the following recipients:

• $20 to NPFFI, a nonparticipating FFI that is an account
holder of the O1;
• $10 each on behalf of two recalcitrant account holders of
the O1($20 total), each with U.S. indicia (as described in
Regulations section 1.1441-7(b)(5)) associated with the
account;

• $5 each on behalf of A and B, U.S. individual account
holders of the O1 that the 01 reports as U.S. accounts
pursuant to its chapter 4 reporting obligations as a
participating FR ($10 total);

• $10 on behalf of C, a U.S. exempt recipient that is not a
specified U.S. person and is an indirect account holder of the
O1 (who beneficially owns the payment through an account
with another participating FFI);

• $20 on behalf of D, a U.S. non-exempt recipient that is a
specified U.S. person who is an indirect account holder of the
O1 (that beneficially owns the payment through an account
with a certified deemed-compliant FFI described in
Regulations section 1.1471-5(0(2)); and
• $10 each on behalf of two nonresident alien individuals
who are account holders of the O1, one of whom is entitled to
a 15% rate of withholding under an applicable income tax
treaty.
The dividend payment is both a withholdable payment
under chapter 4 and a reportable amount under chapter 3.
The O1 assumes primary withholding and reporting
responsibility under chapter 3 and chapter 4 as well as
primary Form 1099 reporting and backup withholding
responsibility. As a result, the O1 is not required to provide a
withholding statement allocating the payment to specific
payees or withholding rate pools. The O1 will provide Form
W-RIMY and check boxes 14a and 14b.
Example 2. The facts are the same as Example 1,
except O1 is a non-U.S. payor under Regulations section
1.6049-5(c)(5) and does not assume primary Form 1099 and
backup withholding responsibility but reports the accounts of
A and B as U.S. accounts under Regulations section
1.1471-4(d).
01 must provide a withholding statement allocating $20 of
the payment to D, and $10 to a chapter 4 withholding rate
pool of U.S. payees. 01 need not allocate any portion of the
payment specifically to A or B because CI is a non-U.S.
payor that is permitted to include A and B in a chapter 4
withholding rate pool of U.S. payees under Regulations
section 1.6049-4(c)(4)(i). The O1 will provide Form W-8IMY
and check boxes 14a, 14c, 14e, and 14e(i).
Example 3. The facts are the same as Example 1, except
OI is a U.S. payor and does not assume primary Form 1099
and backup withholding responsibility.
Because O1 is a U.S. payor, it is not permitted to, under
Regulations section 1.6049-4(c)(4)(i) and (iii), to include A
and B in a chapter 4 withholding rate pool of U.S. payees. CI
must provide a withholding statement allocating $5 of the
payment to A, $5 of the payment to B, $10 of the payment to
C, and $20 of the payment to D along with Forms W-9 for
each of them. O1 will provide Form W-8IMY and check boxes
14a, 14c, and 14e.
Example 4. The facts are the same as Example 1,
except CH is a non-U.S. payor that does not assume primary
withholding and reporting responsibility under chapter 3 and
chapter 4. CI also does not assume primary Form 1099 and
backup withholding responsibility.
-10- Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014)
If the O1 does not assume primary withholding and
reporting responsibility under chapter 3 and chapter 4 as well
as primary Form 1099 reporting and separate backup
withholding responsibilities, the QI will provide an FFI
withholding statement with the following pools:

• Nonparticipating FFI Pool — $20 (which is subject to
chapter 4 withholding);
• Recalcitrant Account Holder Pool — $20 (which is subject
to chapter 4 withholding and which is aggregated in a single
pool of recalcitrant account holders rather than each class
described in Regulations section 1.1471-4(d)(6));

• Chapter 4 Withholding Rate Pool of U.S. Payees — $10
(for the portion of the payment allocable to A and B);

• Chapter 330% Rate Pool — $10;
• Chapter 3 15% Rate Pool — $10; and
• 0% Rate Pool —$10 (for the portion of the payment
allocable to C).
CI will also be required to allocate $20 to a separate
withholding rate pool for D because D is a U.S. non-exempt
recipient who cannot be included i hapter 4 withholding
rate pool of U.S. payees (because account is maintained
by a certified deemed-compliant FFI). See Regulations
section 1.6049(c)(4)(iii), but see the alternative procedure for
U.S. non-exempt recipients, later.
Alternative procedure for U.S. non-exempt recipients.
If approved by the withholding agent, you can establish:

• A single pool (not subject to backup withholding) for all
U.S. non-exempt recipient account holders for whom you
have provided Forms W-9 or are includible in a chapter 4
withholding rate pool of U.S. payees prior to the withholding
agent making any payments. Alternatively, you may include
such U.S. non-exempt recipients in a zero rate withholding
pool that includes U.S. exempt recipients and foreign
persons exempt from non-resident alien withholding provided
all the conditions of the alternative procedure are met; and
• A separate pool for all U.S. non-exempt recipient account
holders subject to backup withholding for whom you have not
provided Forms W-9 prior to the withholding agent making
any payments.
If you elect the alternative procedure, you must provide
the information required by your Qlwithholding agreement to
the withholding agent not later than January 15 of the year
following the year in which the payments are paid. Failure to
provide this information may result in penalties under
sections 6721 and 6722 and termination of your withholding
agreement with the IRS.
A The amount allocable to these two pools under the
alternative procedure excludes amounts allocated to
the chapter 4 withholding rate pool of U.S. payees.
Updating the statement. The statement by which you
identify the relevant withholding rate pools must be updated
as often as is necessary to allow the withholding agent to
withhold at the appropriate rate on each payment and to
correctly report the income to the IRS. The updated
information becomes an integral part of Form W-8IMY.
Part IV — Nonqualified Intermediary
If you are providing Form W-8IMY as a nonqualified
intermediary (NQI), you must check box 15a. By checking
this box, you are certifying to all of the statements on
line 15a.
If you are required to provide a chapter 4 status on
line 5 (see specific instructions for line 5) and are
acting as an intermediary fora withholdable
payment, you must provide your chapter 4 status on line 5 or
as otherwise permitted in these instructions to avoid
withholding at the chapter 4 rate of 30% being applied to any
withholdable payment you receive from the withholding agent
regardless of whether you check box 15b (except for
documentation provided with respect to exempt beneficial
owners). See the specific instructions for Part IX.
Check box 15b if you are using this form to transmit
withholding certificates or other documentation along with a
withholding statement (subject to the certifications on this
form) that satisfies the requirements of chapters 3 and 4
(including if you are providing pooled information for
purposes of chapter 61 under the alternative procedure for
U.S. non-exempt recipients, discussed later, or chapter 4
withholding rate pools (as applicable) for a withholdable
payment).
Check box 15c to certify that you are permitted under
Regulations section 1.6049-4(c)(4) to provide a chapter 4
withholding rate pool of U.S. payees to which a payment is
allocated on a withholding statement associated with the
Form W-8IMY.
Check box 15d to certify that you are acting as a CISL with
respect to the accounts identified on this line or in a
withholding statement associated with this form with respect
to a payment that is a U.S. source substitute dividend.
If you are acting on behalf of another NQI or on behalf of a
foreign partnership or foreign trust that is not a withholding
foreign partnership or a withholding foreign trust, you must
attach to your Form W-8IMY the Form W-8IMY of the other
NQI, foreign partnership, or foreign trust together with the
withholding certificates and other documentation attached to
that Form W-8IMY that is required, as applicable, for both
chapter 3 and chapter 4 purposes.
Withholding statement of an NQI. An NCH must provide a
withholding statement and appropriate documentation to
obtain reduced rates of withholding for its customers under
chapter 3 and chapter 61 and to avoid certain reporting
responsibilities. However, see the paragraph later describing
an NCI's withholding statement for chapter 4 purposes for
when an NCI may provide a chapter 4 withholding rate pool
of U.S. payees without such documentation. The withholding
statement must be provided prior to a payment and becomes
an integral part of the Form W-8IMY and, therefore, the
certification statement that you sign in Part XXVIII of the form
applies to the withholding statement as well as to the form.
For chapter 4 purposes. An NCI receiving a
withholdable payment must provide a withholding statement
which satisfies the requirements of an FFI withholding
statement or chapter 4 withholding statement (if the NQI is
not a participating FFI or registered deemed-compliant FFI).
An FFI withholding statement may allocate the payment to
chapter 4 reporting rate pools (as appropriate), including a
chapter 4 withholding rate pool for nonparticipating FFIs,
recalcitrant account holders (in each class of account holders
described in Regulations section 1.1471-4(d)(6)(i)), and, for
an NCI that is a participating FFI (including a reporting Model
2 FFI) or a registered deemed-compliant FFI (including a
reporting Model 1 FFI), U.S. payees (see the description of
the chapter 4 withholding rate pool of U.S. payees described
in Withholding statement of a O1, earlier). However, an NCI
may allocate a portion of a reportable amount (regardless of
whether the payment is a withholdable payment) to a
chapter 4 withholding rate pool of V.S. payees when the NCI
satisfies the requirements to provide such a pool (including
Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014)
the requirement to certify to its status as a participating FFI
(including a reporting Model 2 FFI) or registered
deemed-compliant FFI (including a reporting Model 1 FFI)).
The withholding statement must also identify each
intermediary or flow-through entity that is receiving a
payment (excluding any intermediary or flow-through entity
that is an account holder or interest holder in another QI, WP,
or WT), each such entity's chapter 4 status and GIIN (if
applicable), and the chapter 4 withholding rate pools
associated with each such entity receiving the payment.
A chapter 4 withholding statement must contain the name,
address, TIN (if any), entity type, chapter 4 status of each
payee, the amount allocated to each payee, and a valid
withholding certificate or other documentation sufficient to
establish each payee's chapter 4 status. However, a
chapter 4 withholding statement may instead include pooled
information for payees that are nonparticipating FFIs. The
withholding statement must also identify each intermediary or
flow-through entity that is receiving a payment (excluding any
intermediary or flow-through entity that is an account holder
or interest holder in another O1, WP, or WT), each such
entity's chapter 4 status and GIIN (if applicable), and the
chapter 4 withholding rate pools associated with each such
entity receiving the payment.
For chapter 3 and chapter 61 purposes. For chapter 3
and chapter 61 purposes, a withholding statement for a
reportable amount must include the information described
later. For such payments that are also withholdable
payments, the withholding statement should allocate only the
portion of the payment that was not allocated to a chapter 4
withholding rate pool (as described earlier) or to a payee
identified on the withholding statement to whom withholding
was applied under chapter 4, as follows:

• Include the name, address, U.S. TIN (if any), chapter 4
status (for a foreign person receiving a withholdable
payment), and the type of documentation (documentary
evidence, Form W-9, or type of Form W-8) for every person
for whom documentation has been received and must state
whether that person is a U.S. exempt recipient, a U.S.
non-exempt recipient, or a foreign person. The statement
must indicate whether a foreign person is a beneficial owner
or an intermediary, flow-through entity, V.S. branch, or
territory financial institution and the type of recipient, based
on the recipient codes shown on Form 1042-S;

• Allocate each payment by income type to every payee for
whom documentation has been provided. The type of income
is based on the income codes reported on Form 1042-S (or,
if applicable, the income categories for Form 1099). If a
payee receives income through another NQI, flow-through
entity, or U.S. branch acting as an intermediary, your
withholding certificate must also state the name, address,
U.S. TIN (if known), and, for a withholdable payment, the
chapter 4 status (if required) and GIIN (if applicable) of the
other NQI or V.S. branch from which the payee directly
receives the payment or the flow-through entity in which the
payee has a direct ownership interest. If another NQI,
flow-through entity, or V.S. branch fails to allocate a
payment, you must provide, for that payment, the name of
the NQI, flow-through entity, or U.S. branch that failed to
allocate the payment;

• If a payee is identified as a foreign person, you must
specify the rate of withholding under chapter 3 to which the
payee is subject, the payee's country of residence and, if a
reduced rate of withholding is claimed, the basis for that
reduced rate (for example, treaty benefit, portfolio interest, or
exemption under section 501(c)(3), 892, or 895). The
statement must also include the U.S. or foreign TIN (if
required) and, if the beneficial owner is not an individual and
is claiming treaty benefits, state whether the limitation on
benefits and section 894 statements have been provided by
the beneficial owner. You must inform the withholding agent
as to which payments those statements relate; and
• Include any other information the withholding agent
requests in order to fulfill its withholding and reporting
obligations under chapters 3 and 4 of the Code and/or Form
1099 reporting and backup withholding responsibility.
Alternative procedure for Mts. To use the alternative
procedure you must inform the withholding agent on your
withholding statement that you are using the procedure and
the withholding agent must agree to the procedure.
Under this procedure, you must provide a withholding
agent with all the information required on the withholding
statement (see Withholding statement of an NOI, earlier) and
all payee documentation, except the specific allocation
information for each payee, prior to the payment of a
reportable amount. In addition, you must provide the
withholding agent with withholding rate pool information. The
withholding statement must assign each payee that is not
subject to withholding under chapter 4 to a chapter 3
withholding rate pool prior to the payment of a reportable
amount. The withholding rate pool may be established by any
reasonable method agreed upon by you and the withholding
agent. For example, you may agree to establish a separate
account for a single withholding rate pool, or you may agree
to divide a payment made to a single account into portions
allocable to each withholding rate pool. You must determine
withholding rate pools based on valid documentation or, to
the extent a payment cannot be reliably associated with valid
documentation, the applicable presumption rules.
You must provide the withholding agent with sufficient
information to allocate the income in each withholding rate
pool to each payee (including U.S. exempt recipients) within
the pool no later than January 31 of the year following the
year of payment. If you fail to provide allocation information, if
required, by January 31 for any withholding rate pool, you
may not use this procedure for any payment made after that
date for all withholding rate pools. You may remedy your
failure to provide allocation information by providing the
information to the withholding agent no later than February
14.
In the case of a reportable amount that is also a
withholdable payment, an NQI may include amounts
allocable to a chapter 4 withholding rate pool (other than a
chapter 4 withholding rate pool of U.S. payees) and payees
subject to chapter 4 withholding for whom the NQI will
provide payee specific information in a 30-percent rate pool
together with payees subject to chapter 3 withholding at the
30-percent rate and may not otherwise apply these
provisions for payments made to U.S. non-exempt recipients
(regardless of whether the payment is a withholdable
payment). For the amount of the payment allocable to a
chapter 4 withholding rate pool of U.S. payees, an NQI may
include such an amount in the withholding rate pool that is
exempt from withholding (an NQI can include such payees in
an exempt pool regardless of whether the payment is a
withholdable payment). The NQI must identity prior to the
payment each chapter 4 withholding rate pool to be allocated
a portion of the payment and must also allocate by January
31 the portion of the payment to each such pool in addition to
allocating the payment to each other payee as described in
the preceding paragraph. See Regulations section
-12- Instructions for Form W-RIMY (Rev. 6-2014)
1.1441-1(e)(3)(iv)(D)(2) for further information on alternative
procedures for an NQI.
Part V — Territory Financial
Institution
Line 16
Check box 16a to certify that you are a financial institution
(other than an investment entity that is not also a depository
institution, custodial institution, or specified insurance
company) incorporated or organized under the laws of a
possession of the United States.
You must also check either box 16b or 16c. Check
box 16b to certify that you have agreed to be treated as a
U.S. person for purposes of both chapter 3 and chapter 4
with respect to payments associated with this Form W-8IMY.
In this case, you will be responsible for chapter 3 withholding
and reporting, backup withholding under section 3406, and
chapter 4 withholding and reporting for any payments you
make to persons for whom you are receiving a reportable
amount or withholdable payment. If you check this box 16b,
you must provide an EIN on line 8.
Check box 16c to certify that you are a territory financial
institution that has not agreed to be treated as a U.S. person.
You must certify that you are transmitting withholding
certificates or other documentation for persons for whom you
are receiving a payment (as required for chapter 3,
chapter 61, and section 3406 purposes, and, in the case of a
withholdable payment, documentation required for chapter 4
withholding and reporting purposes). See Regulations
section 1.1471-3(a)(3)(iv). You must also certify that you
have provided or will provide a withholding statement (as
required). The withholding statement must provide the same
information outlined under Withholding statement of an NQI,
earlier, including the applicable chapter 4 information if you
are receiving a withholdable payment.
A CAUTION
A territory entity that is a flow-through entity but is
not a territory FI may not complete this Part V and
agree to be treated as a U.S. person. Instead,
complete Part IV or Part VIII, as appropriate.
Part VI — Certain U.S. Branches
Line 17
Check box 17a to certify that you are a U.S. branch
described in Regulations section 1.1441-1(b)(2)(W) receiving
income that is not effectively connected with the conduct of a
trade or business in the United States.
You must also check either box 17b or 17c. Check
box 17b to certify that you are a U.S. branch of a foreign bank
or insurance company described in this certification that is a
participating FR, registered deemed-compliant FFI, or NFFE
that has agreed with the withholding agent to be treated as a
U.S. person with respect to payments associated with this
Form W-8IMY. In such case, you will be responsible for
chapter 3 withholding and reporting, backup withholding
under section 3406, chapter 4 withholding and reporting for
any payments you make to persons for whom you are
receiving a withholdable payment, and will be treated as a
U.S. payor for chapter 61 purposes. See Regulations section
1.6049-5(c)(5)(i)(F). You must provide your EIN on line 8
and, if you are a branch of an FR receiving a withholdable
payment, a GIIN on line 9 of another branch of the FFI of
which you are a part.
Check box 17c to certify that you are a U.S. branch that
does not have an agreement with the withholding agent to be
treated as a U.S. person. You must certify that you are
transmitting withholding certificates or other documentation
for persons for whom you are receiving the payment. You
must also certify that you have provided or will provide a
withholding statement (as required) and, if you are receiving
a withholdable payment, provide your chapter 4 status in Part
I, line 5 (if required). The withholding statement must provide
the same information outlined under Withholding statement
of an NQI, earlier, including the applicable chapter 4
information required for the withholding statement if you are
receiving a withholdable payment. See the information for an
FFI withholding statement or a chapter 4 withholding
statement in Withholding statement of an NQI, earlier.
Part VII — Withholding Foreign
Partnership (WP) or Withholding
Foreign Trust (WT)
Check box 18 if you are a WP or a WT for the accounts for
which you are providing this form and you are receiving the
income on behalf of your partners, beneficiaries, or owners. If
you are not receiving the income on behalf of your partners,
beneficiaries, or owners, do not complete this Part VII.
Instead, complete Part III or Part IV, whichever is appropriate.
If you are acting as a WP or WT, you must assume
primary withholding and reporting responsibility under
chapter 3 and chapter 4 for all payments that are made to
you for your partners, beneficiaries, or owners. Therefore,
you are not required to provide information to the withholding
agent regarding each partner's, beneficiary's, or owners
distributive share of the payment and the information for the
withholding agent to report under section 1472 (if otherwise
required). If you are also receiving payments from the same
withholding agent for persons other than your partners,
beneficiaries, or owners, you must provide a separate Form
W-RIMY for those payments. If you are receiving a
withholdable payment, you must provide a chapter 4 status in
line 5 other than that of a nonparticipating FR and provide
your GIIN (if applicable).
Part VIII — Nonwithholding Foreign
Partnership, Simple Trust, or Grantor
Trust
Check box 19 if you are a foreign partnership or a foreign
simple or grantor trust that is not a WP or WT. By checking
this box, you are certifying to both of the statements on
line 19.
Note. If you are receiving income that is effectively
connected with the conduct of a trade or business in the
United States, provide Form W-8ECI (instead of Form
W-8IMY). If you are not receiving the income on behalf of
your partners, beneficiaries, or owners, do not complete Part
VIII. Instead, complete Part III or Part IV, whichever is
appropriate. If you are a hybrid entity claiming treaty benefits,
provide Form W-8BEN-E. However, if you are receiving a
withholdable payment you may also be required to provide
this Form W-8IMY and disclose your chapter 4 status and the
chapter 4 status of each of your owners. See the instructions
to Form W-8BEN-E for more information about hybrid entities
claiming treaty benefits.
If you are acting on behalf of an NQI or another foreign
partnership or foreign trust that is not a withholding foreign
Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014) -13-
partnership or a withholding foreign trust, you must associate
with your Form W-81MY the Form W-81MY of the other
foreign partnership or foreign trust together with the
withholding certificates and other documentation attached to
that other form.
If you are receiving a withholdable payment, you must
provide a chapter 4 status in fine 5 other than that of a
nonparticipating FFI and provide your GIIN (if applicable) and
the information required for the withholding agent to report
under section 1472.
Withholding statement of nonwithholding foreign part-
nership or nonwIthholding foreign trust. You must
provide the withholding agent with a withholding statement to
obtain reduced rates of withholding and relief from certain
reporting obligations. The withholding statement must
provide the same information outlined under Withholding
statement of an NOI, earlier. The withholding statement
becomes an integral part of the Form W-8IMY. Thus, if you
are an FFI and allocate any portion of the payment to a
chapter 4 withholding rate pool of V.S. payees with respect to
accounts that you maintain, you must meet the requirements
of Regulations section 1.6049-4(c)(4)(iii) and certify to your
status in Part I, line 5 as a participating FFI, registered
deemed-compliant FFI, reporting Model 1 FFI, or reporting
Model 2 FFI. By providing a withholding statement making
such an allocation with this form, you certify that you meet the
requirements outlined for an Nal withholding statement
described earlier.
Certain special rules for partnerships and trusts. Under
certain conditions, a QI, WT, or WP may apply special
provisions of the relevant withholding agreement to certain
partnerships and trusts that are not acting as a WP or WT.
See the QI agreement, WP agreement, or WT agreement (as
applicable) specifying these special procedures.
Certification of Chapter 4 Status:
Parts IX Through XXVII
You should complete only one part certifying to your
chapter 4 status (if required). Identify which part (if any) you
should complete by reference to the box you checked on
line 5.
Part IX — Nonparticipating FFI With
Exempt Beneficial Owners
You are not required to complete this part unless you
are a nonparticipating FF7 providing documentation
on behalf of an exempt beneficial owner.
Check box 20 to certify that you are transmitting
withholding certificates or other documentation for exempt
beneficial owners for chapter 4 purposes on whose behalf
you are receiving a payment that is a withholdable payment.
See Regulations section 1.1471-6. You must also certify that
you have provided or will provide a withholding statement (as
required) allocating a portion of the payment to the exempt
beneficial owners as required under Regulations section
1.1471-3(d)(8)(ii). The withholding statement must include
the name, address, TIN (if any), entity type, and chapter 4
status of each exempt beneficial owner on behalf of which
the nonparticipating FFI is receiving the payment, the amount
of the payment allocable to each exempt beneficial owner, a
valid withholding certificate or other documentation sufficient
to establish the chapter 4 status of each exempt beneficial
owner under the requirements of chapter 4, and any other
information the withholding agent reasonably requests in
order to fulfill its obligations under chapter 4. Additionally, the
withholding statement must provide all information required
for purposes of chapter 3 with respect to each exempt
beneficial owner if the payment is subject to withholding
under chapter 3. The withholding statement must allocate the
remainder of the payment that is not allocated to an exempt
beneficial owner to the nonparticipating FFI receiving the
payment.
Part X — Sponsored FFI That Has Not
Obtained a GIIN
On line 21a, enter the name of the sponsoring entity that has
agreed to fulfill your chapter 4 due diligence, reporting, and
withholding obligations on your behalf. You must provide the
sponsoring entity's GIIN on line 9. However, you will be
required to obtain a GIIN by January 1, 2016.
You must check the applicable box in line 21b or 21c to
certify that you are either an investment entity or controlled
foreign corporation (within the meaning of section 957(a))
and satisfy the other relevant requirements for this
classification.
Part XI — Owner -Documented FFI
A CAUTIO
Art owner-documented FFI should only complete
Form W-8IMY if it is a flow-through entity receiving
income allocable to its partners, owners, or
beneficiaries. An owner-documented FFI is not permitted to
act as an intermediary with respect to a withholdable
payment.
All owner-documented FFIs must check box 22a to certify
that you satisfy the requirements for this classification and
are providing this form to a U.S. financial institution,
participating FFI, or reporting Model 1 FFI that has agreed to
act as a designated withholding agent with respect to the
entity identified on line 1 (see Regulations section 1.1471-5(f)
(3)).
You must also check either box 22b or 22c. Check
box 22b to certify that you have provided or will provide the
documentation set forth in the certifications, including the
owner reporting statement described in this line 22b. Check
box 22c to certify that you have provided or will provide an
auditors letter (in lieu of the information required by
line 22(b)) that satisfies the requirements described in this
line.
Part XII — Certified
Deemed -Compliant Nonregistering
Local Bank
All nonregistering local banks must check box 23 to certify
that you satisfy all of the requirements for this certified
deemed-compliant classification.
Part XIII — Certified
Deemed -Compliant FFI with Only
Low -Value Accounts
All FFIs with only low-value accounts must check box 24 to
certify that you satisfy all of the requirements for this certified
deemed-compliant classification.
-14- Instructions for Form W-RIMY (Rev. 6-2014)
Part XIV — Certified
Deemed -Compliant Sponsored,
Closely Held Investment Vehicle
On line 25a, enter the name of the sponsoring entity that has
agreed to fulfill your chapter 4 due diligence, reporting, and
withholding obligations on your behalf. You must also enter
the GIIN of your sponsoring entity on line 9.
All sponsored, closely held investment vehicles must
check box 25b to certify that you satisfy the requirements for
certified deemed-compliant classification as a sponsored
entity.
Part XV — Certified
Deemed -Compliant Limited Life Debt
Investment Company
All limited life debt investment entities must check box 26 to
certify that you satisfy the requirements for this certified
deemed-compliant classification.
Part XVI — Restricted Distributor
All restricted distributors must check box 27a to certify that
you satisfy the requirements for this classification.
You must also check either box 27b or 27c, as
appropriate, to certify that your distribution agreement meets
the requirements of this classification.
Part XVII — Foreign Central Bank of
Issue
A foreign central bank of issue must check box 28 to certify
that you are acting as an intermediary and are an entity
defined in Regulations section 1.1471-6 that is treated as the
beneficial owner of the payment for chapter 4 purposes
(applying the rule in Regulations section 1.1471-6(d)(4)). You
cannot be treated as an intermediary for purposes of this Part
XVII if you are receiving the payment in connection with a
commercial activity described in Regulations section
1.1471-6(h)(1) or are not receiving payments subject to
chapter 3 withholding.
Part XVIII — Nonreporting IGA FFI
Check box 29 to indicate that you are treated as a
nonreporting IGA FFI under an applicable IGA, including an
entity treated as a registered deemed-compliant FFI under an
applicable IGA. You must identify the applicable IGA by
entering the name of the jurisdiction that has the applicable
IGA in effect with the United States. You must also provide
the withholding agent with the class of entity described in
Annex II of the IGA applicable to your status. If you are an FFI
treated as a registered deemed-compliant FFI under an
applicable Model 2 IGA, you must provide your GIIN in the
space provided. The GIIN does not need to be provided on
line 9. See www.treasurygov/resource-center/tax-policy/
treaties/Pages/FATCA-Archive.aspx for a list of jurisdictions
treated as having an IGA in effect for purposes of making this
certification.
If you are a sponsored FF1 in a Model 1 IGA
jurisdiction or other nonreporting FR in a Model 1
1GA jurisdiction that is required to report an account,
you are currently not required to provide a GIIN in this Part
XII. However, a future version of this form may require you to
provide a MIN.
Part XIX — Exempt Retirement Plans
All exempt retirement plans must check the appropriate box
to certify that you satisfy the requirements for this
classification.
A CAUTION
If you are not a flow-through entity or acting as an
intermediary with respect to the payment for
chapter 3 purposes, do not complete Form W-81MY.
If you are the beneficial owner of the payment and are
claiming an exemption under sections 115(2), 892, or 895 as
well as exempt beneficial owner status under Regulations
section 1.1471-6 you should provide Form W-8EXP. If you
are receiving payments which do not qualify fora statutory
exemption from tax but for which you are claiming benefits
under an applicable income tax treaty, provide Form
W-8BEN-E.
Part XX - Excepted Nonfinancial
Group Entity
All excepted nonfinancial group entities must check box 31 to
certify that you satisfy the requirements for this classification.
Part XXI — Excepted Nonfinancial
Start -Up Company
All excepted nonfinancial start-up companies must check
box 32 to certify that you satisfy the requirements for this
classification. You must also provide the date you were
formed or your board passed a resolution (or equivalent
measure) approving a new line of business (which cannot be
that of a financial institution or passive NFFE).
Part XXII — Excepted Nonfinancial
Entity in Liquidation or Bankruptcy
All excepted nonfinancial group entities in liquidation or
bankruptcy must check box 33 to certify that you satisfy the
requirements for this classification. You must also provide the
date that you filed a plan of liquidation, plan of reorganization,
or bankruptcy petition.
Part XXIII — Publicly Traded NFFE or
NFFE Affiliate of a Publicly Traded
Corporation
All publicly traded NFFEs must check box Ma to certify that
you are not a financial institution and provide the name of a
securities exchange on which the stock of the NFFE is
publicly traded.
An NFFE that is a member of the same expanded
affiliated group (as described in Regulations section
1.1471-5(i)) as a publicly traded U.S. or foreign entity must
check this box, provide the name of the publicly traded entity,
and identify the securities market on which the stock of the
publicly traded entity is traded. See Regulations section
1.1472-1(c)(1)(i) to determine if an entity is publicly traded.
Part XXIV — Excepted Territory NFFE
All excepted territory NFFEs must check box 35 to certify that
you satisfy the requirements for this classification. See
Regulations section 1.1472-1(c)(1)(iii) for the definition of an
excepted territory NFFE.
Part XXV — Active NFFE
All active NFFEs must check box 36 to certify that you satisfy
the requirements for this classification.
hntruCtiOns for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014) -15-
Part XXVI — Passive NFFE
All passive NFFEs must check box 37 to certify that you are
not a financial institution (other than an investment entity
organized in a possession of the United States). You must
also certify that you have provided a withholding statement
associated with Form W-RIMY to the extent you are required
to provide a withholding statement.
Part XXVII — Sponsored Direct
Reporting NFFE
All sponsored direct reporting NFFEs must certify that you
are not a financial institution and provide the name of your
sponsoring entity. Provide your GIIN or, prior to January 1,
2016, the GIIN of your sponsor on line 9.
Part XXVIII — Certification
Form W-81MY must be signed and dated by a person
authorized to sign a declaration under penalties of perjury on
behalf of the person whose name is on the form. By signing
Form W-81MY the authorized representative, officer, or agent
also agrees to provide a new form within 30 days following a
change in circumstances (unless no future payments will be
made to the intermediary or flow-through entity by the
withholding agent and the requestor does not need an
updated form for chapter 4 purposes).
Special Instructions
Entities Providing Certifications Under an
Applicable IGA (Do Not Complete Line 5)
A withholding agent that is an FFI may provide you with a
chapter 4 status certification other than as shown in Parts IX
through XXVII in order to satisfy its due diligence
requirements under an applicable IGA. In such a case, you
may attach the alternative certifications to this Form W-81MY
in lieu of completing a certification otherwise required in Parts
IX through XXVII provided that you: 1) determine that the
certification accurately reflects your status for chapter 4
purposes or under an applicable IGA; and 2) the withholding
agent provides a written statement to you that it has provided
the certification to meet its due diligence requirements as a
participating FR or registered deemed-compliant FFI under
an applicable IGA.
You may also provide with this form an applicable IGA
certification if you are determining your chapter 4 status
under the definitions provided in an applicable IGA and your
certification identifies the jurisdiction that is treated as having
an IGA in effect and describes your status as an NFFE or FFI
in accordance with the applicable IGA. However, if you
determine your status under an applicable IGA as an NFFE,
you must still determine if you are an excepted NFFE under
the regulations in order to complete this form. Additionally,
you are required to comply with the conditions of your status
under the law of the IGA jurisdiction if you are determining
your status under an applicable IGA. If you cannot provide
the certifications in Parts IX through XXVII, do not check a
box in line 5. However, if you determine your status under the
definitions of the IGA and can certify to a chapter 4 status
included on this form, you do not need to provide the
certifications described in this paragraph unless required by
the withholding agent or FFI to whom you are providing this
form.
Any certifications provided under an applicable IGA
remain subject to the penalty of perjury statement and other
certifications made in Part XXVIII.
Entities Providing Alternate Certifications Under
Regulations
If you qualify for a chapter 4 status that is not shown in Part I,
line 5, of this form, you may attach applicable certifications
for such status from any other Form W-8 on which the
relevant certifications appear. For example, if you are a
certified deemed-compliant investment advisor or investment
manager described in Regulations section 1.1471-5(f)(2)(v)
that is a flow-through entity, you may attach the certifications
found in Part IX of Form W-8BEN-E. If the applicable
certifications do not appear on any Form W-8 (if, for example,
new regulations provide for an additional chapter 4 status
and this form has not been updated) then you may provide
an attachment certifying that you qualify for the applicable
status described in a particular Regulations section in lieu of
checking a box in Part I, line 5. Include a citation to the
applicable provision in the Regulations. Any such attached
certification becomes an integral part of this Form W-RIMY
and is subject to the penalty of perjury statement and other
certifications made in Part XXVIII.
Paperwork Reduction Act Notice. We ask for the
information on this form to carry out the Internal Revenue
laws of the United States. You are required to provide the
information. We need it to ensure that you are complying with
these laws and to allow us to figure and collect the right
amount of tax.
You are not required to provide the information requested
on a form that is subject to the Paperwork Reduction Act
unless the form displays a valid OMB control number. Books
or records relating to a form or its instructions must be
retained as long as their contents may become material in
the administration of any Internal Revenue law. Generally,
tax retums and return information are confidential, as
required by section 6103.
The time needed to complete and file this form will vary
depending on individual circumstances. The estimated
average time is: Recordkeeping,11 hr., 43 min.; Learning
about the law or the form, 5 hr., 55 min.; Preparing the
form, 7 hr., 34 min.
If you have comments concerning the accuracy of these
time estimates or suggestions for making this form simpler,
we would be happy to hear from you. You can send us
comments from www.irs.qov/formspubs. Click on More
Information" and then on "Give us feedback? You can write
to the Internal Revenue Service, Tax Forms and Publications,
1111 Constitution Ave. NW, IR-6526, Washington, DC

20224. Do not send Form W-SIMY to this office. Instead, give
it to your withholding agent.
-16- Instructions for Form W-8IMY (Rev. 6-2014)
EXHIBIT D
PRIVACY POLICY
This Privacy Notice is included in compliance with the Federal Trade Commission's
rules regarding the privacy of nonpublic personal information. This Privacy Notice
explains the manner in which VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP (the "Fund") will
collect and use nonpublic personal information about our partners. This Privacy
Notice applies only to partners who are individuals.
The Fund collects nonpublic personal information about you from the following
sources:

• Subscription Agreements or other forms (for example, name, address, Social
Security number, assets and income); and

• Ownership records of the Fund (such as the amount of your percentage
ownership interest and any capital commitment).
The Fund is committed to protecting your privacy and maintaining the confidentiality
and security of your personal information. We do not disclose any personal
information we receive from you unless required by law or to discharge our
management duties. We expect to disclose limited information about your interest in
the Fund only as necessary to (i) effect in kind distributions of our portfolio securities
through brokers and (ii) fulfill our financial reporting obligations to our partners. We
may also disclose certain of your information to our outside service providers, such
as lawyers and auditors, but only as permitted by law and as necessary in performing
our management duties.
The Fund considers the protection of sensitive personal information to be a sound
business practice and intends to scrupulously guard the privacy of our partners.
EXHIBIT D
121611407 v2
EFTA01125108 (Jmail)
 [government] DHS receipt for I129 Petition for a Nonimmigrant Worker filed by Sublime Art LLC, Arda Beskardes
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Department of Homeland Security
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Form I-797C, Notice of Action
THIS NOTICE DOES NOT GRANT ANY IMMIGRATION STATUS OR BENEFIT.
RECEIFTNOMBER
EAC-14-121-52156 CASETYPE I129 PETITION FOR A NONIMMIGRANT WORKER
RECEIVED DATE
March 27, 2014
PRIORITY DATE PETITIONER
SUBLIME ART LLC NOTICE DATE
March 27, 2014
PAGE
1 of 1 BENEFICIARY
ARDA BESKARDES
If ARDA BESKARDES ESQ
Notice Type: Receipt Notice
Amount received: $325.00 V.S.
Class requested: 01
417 BERGEN ST
BROOKLYN NY 11217
Receipt Notice- This notice confirms that USCIS received your app ication or petition ("this case") as shown above. 
ffenyt485e cal 800.375-5283 b la us krbw.
This will help avoid future problems.
iimigratien status cr benefit, nor is it evidence that this case is still pending. It only petition was filed on the 
date shown.
very by case type. You can check our website at ww.uscis.gov for our current "processing the particular office to which 
this case is or becomes assigned. On our
website's "case
also view status or sign up to receive free e-mail updates as we complete key processing steps the time this case is 
pending, however, our systems will show
only that the case has been status will not have changed, because we will be working on other cases that were filed 
notify you by mail, and show in our systems,
when we make a decision on this case Or if we you do not receive an initial decision or update from us within our 
current processing time,
Please save this notice, and any other notice we send you about this case, and
any papers you send us by any means, along with any proof of delivery to us. Please have you contact us about this case.
and approval of a Form I-I30, Petition for Allen Relative, is only the first step in to the United States. The 
beneficiaries of a petition must wait until a
visa number is the next step to apply for an immigrant visa or adjustment of status to lawful permanent resources, USCIS
may wait to process I-230 forms until
closer to the time when a visa number may be years after the petition was tiled. Nevertheless, USCIS processes I-130 
forms in time to take the next step toward
permanent residence once a visa number does become available. petition, you decide to withdraw your petition, your 
family relationship with the a U.S. citizen,
call 800-375-5283.
some types of cases USCIS requires biometrics. In such cases. USCIS will send you a SEPARATE date, time and place for 
you to go to a USCIS Application Support
Center (ASC) for WAIT for that separate appointment notice and take it (NOT this receipt notice) to your photo 
identification. Acceptable kinds of photo
identification aro: a passport or national your country, a drivers license, a military photo identification, or a 
state-Issued photo receive more than ono ASC
appointment notice, even for different cases, take them both to the
address changes while your case is pending, call 800-375-5283 or use the "Online Change
Otherwise, you might not receive notice of our action on this case.
of the United States Immigration t Nationality Act (INA), the information provided on and in is submitted under penalty 
of perjury. USCIS and the U.S.
Department of Homeland verify this information before and/or after adjudication to ensure conformity with applicable 
other authorities. Methods used for
verifying information may include, but are not limited and records, contact by correspondence, the Internet, or 
telephone, and site residences. Information
obtained during the course of verification will be used to determine Applicants, petitioners, and representatives of 
record will be provided an opportunity
before any formal decision is made and/or proceeding is initiated.
above InbrmMbn b Intoned, please knmedbWy
This notice does rot grant any
shows that the application or
ProceseingtIme - Processing times
times" for this case type at
status online" page, you can
on this case. During most of
received, and the processing
earlier than this one. We will
need something from you. If
check our website or call 000-375-5283. please make and keep a copy of
all these papers with you if
Ifiliklosselsani-130Petition - Filing
helping a relative immigrate
available before they can take
residence. To best allocate
will become available, which
not to delay relatives' ability
If, before final action on the
beneficiary ends, or you become
AppicedoMIROUMngbkawAdes- In
appointment notice with a specific
biometrics processing. You must
ASC appointment along with your
photo identification issued by
identification card. If you
first appointment.
Wyetiraddre$SchanDOS- If your mailing
of Address" function on our website.
NOTICE: Pursuant to the terms
support of applications and petitions
Security reserve the right to
laws, rules, regulations, and
to, the review of public information
inspections of businesses and
eligibility for the benefit sought.
to address derogatory information
Please see the additional information on the back. You will be notified separately abou any other cases you f ed U.S. 
CITIZENSHIP & IMMIGRATION SVCS
VERMONT SERVICE CENTER
75 LOWER WELDEN STREET
SAINT ALBANS VT 05479-0001
Customer Service Telephone: (800) 375-5283
III II I III
Please see the back of this notice for important information. Fonn 1.797C 01/02112
EFTA01286359 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank statement for Epstein's Southern Trust Company
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Deutsche Bank El
Deutsche Bank Must Co. Americas
345 Park Avenue - NYC20-0102
New York. NY 10154
Sol I I tERN TRUST COMPANY. INC.
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3
ST TH0NLAS
00802
UNITED STATES VI
August 1.2016 to August 31. 2016
Summary' of Account Ilalanee(s)
Account Account Number Balance
For personal assistance call:
Steuart Oldricld
212-454-2881
Balance
Elite Money Market Deposit 44-129444 948,881,918.37
liegiming Balance as of August I. 2016 $52,124,43.91
Deposits and Other Credits $7.374.46
Checks Paid 50.00
ATM and Dcbit Card Withdrauals 50.00
Service Charges and Other Fees $0.00
Other Debits (93.250,000.00 )
Ending Balance as of August 31. 2016
Transaction 1)etail
Dale Ekrozipeion Debit
548.881.918.37
Credit
Beginning Balance ax of August I. 2016 552.124.54.3.91
08-16 l Cash Mgmt Ink Dr
REF 22912571. FUNDS TRANSFER TO
DEP 35269691 FROM
(2,000,000.00 ) 50,124,543.91
08-IS a Outgoing Money Tmsf
TO SILICON VALLEY BANK AiC 330152042
7 VALAR GLOBAAL FUND III LP
(1.250,000.00 ) 48.874.543.91
08-31 x Interest Pmmeni 7374.46 48.881.918.37
Ending Balance as of August 31. 2016 (3.250.000.00 ) $7374.46 48.881.91837
NI items an credited subject to final collodion and receipt of procee‘h in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
44129244
I of 3 SDNY_GM_00042843
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0005667
Deutsche Bank
Deposits and Other Credits
Date Description
08-31 Interest Pasment
.Haunt
57.374.46
Service Charges and Other Fees
Total NSF Mum item fees for this statement period 90.00
Total NSF Mum item fees for this calendar star 50.00
Total (herdrall lees for this :statement period 90 .00
Total thenfrall fees for this calendar year 50.(K)
Other Debits
Date Description Amount
Ott-16 Cash tilgrni Trsfr Dr (52.000.000.00
08-18 Outgoing Money Tntsf (51.250.000.00
Interest Cakulation
Annual Percentage Yield Limed 0.17°o
Interest Earned 'This Period 37374.46
Interest Paid Year To Dale 564.427.76
All items an credited subject to final collection and receipt of proceeds in cash a by unconditional credit to and 
accepted by Deutsche Bank Trust Company
Americas
44129244
2 of 3 SDNY_GM_00042844
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0005668
Deutsche Bank
In Case of Enron or Questions

I. Electronic Funds Transfers
Telephone us at 1-866-362-4796. or write to us at Deutsche Dank Trust Company Americas. 345 Park Avenue. WNI Banking 
Team -
NYC20-0102. New York New York 10154 as soon as you can. if you think your gateman or receipt is wrong or if you need 
more
information about a transfer listed on the statement or receipt. We MUST hear from you no later than 60 days after we 
sent you the
FIRST statement on which the error or problem appeared.

• Tell us your name and account number
- Describe the error or transfer you are unsure about. and explain as clearly as you can why you believe it is an error 
or %shy you
need more infoimation

• Tell in the dollar amount of the suspected error
Please note that if you initially provide the above information to If% via telephone. we may squire that you send your 
complaint or
inquiry in writing within 10 business days.
We will investigate your complaint and will correct any error promptly. If we take more than 10 business days (or 20 
days for new
accounts) to do this, we will provisionally credit your account for the amount you think is in error, so that you will 
have the use of the
money during the time it takes us to complete ow investigation At the conclusion of our involigation we will inform you 
of our results.

2. Non-Electronic Funds Transfers
Contact the Bank immediately at 1-866-362-4796 if vow statement is incorrect or if y041 need more information about any 
non-electronic
funds transactions (checks or deposits) on this statement. If any such error appears. you must notify the Belk in 
writing no later than
30 days after the statement was made available to you. Please see vow Terms and Conditions for flintie r infonnmion on 
the terms
governing your account.

3. Verifying Preauthorized Credits
If you have arranged to have direct deposits made to your account at least once every 60 days from the same person or 
company. you
can telephone us at 1.866-362.47% to find out whether the deposit has been made.
1 1 I .1'. • 2 1 SDNY_GM_00042845
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0005669
EFTA01617521 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage from Eduardo Teodorani
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739 TE
TEODORANI Eduardo
2018/05/27
1212 5333739
Sorry, I can't talk right now.
08:45:03 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Call me when you can worried about ITALY
TE 09:24:09 pm
1212 5333739
Steve Bannon will be in Rome . Do you want to meet
09:44:42 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Ok
TE 09:47:41 pm
2018/06/14
TEODORANI Eduardo
In Paris 22 23 24
01:46:21 pm
Is that gay coming to see you
TE 03:05:39 pm
Call in 1hr
09:47:05 pm
1212 5333739
TEODORANI Eduardo
Can Ugo come and which day
TE 03:08:25 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Ok
03:09:34 pm
Which day
TE 03:09:43 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Ok
03:10:27 pm
Morning or evening Ugo coming on purpose
TE 03:14:58 pm
Si
03:06:01 pm
1212 5333739
I prefer ego to everyone else
03:09:14 pm
1212 5333739
24?
03:10:19 pm
1212 5333739
Too early to make plans.
03:15:25 pm
•
•
•
•
TEODORANI Eduardo
Ok
TE 03:15:32 pm
2018/06/20
1212 5333739
Paris
06:11:39 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Be there on Friday
TE 06:13:05 pm
1212 5333739
Steve did nit come
06:23:15 pm
2018/06/22
TEODORANI Eduardo
Arriving at 6pm dinner shall we Invite Carla without husband
TE 08:21:26 am
1212 5333739
Steve did not come
09:37:34 am
TEODORANI Eduardo
But my wife miss you
09:46:44 am
Me too happy to see you
Carla and Monica for drink
TE 09:49:05 am
1212 5333739
? MI free at 9
09:49:44 am
TEODORANI Eduardo
iri
TE 09:51:23 am
1212 5333739
Tell me your plan
03:04:1S pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
With ex First Lady shall pass at yours around 10 if is ok for you
TE 04:53:39 pin
1212 5333739
—1 1 Perfect
04:59:39 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Too tired coming tomorrow if of for you
TE 07:58:29 pm
1212 5333739
Ok as always.
07:59:43 pin
TEODORANI Eduardo
Tomorrow if ok I come at yours around 1 pm
TE 08:02:22 pin
After 1 ?
1212 5333739

K. Alone or with something cute ?
08:02:42 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Very cute blue eyes
TE 08:03:47 pin
2018/06/23
1212 5333739
Time?
10:38:36 am
I left
12:34:41 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Shall I come to you
12:39:17 pin
I will try you later
12:42:23 pin
I am here till tomorrow
TE 01:22:01 pm
1212 5333739
Tried to call
01:52:52 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Send me ad
TE 01:54:22 pin
1212 5333739
22 ave foch
02:03:28 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Shall I come around 10 if is ok for you master
TE 04:23:30 pin
1212 5333739
Ok
04:23:45 pm
TEODORANI Eduardo
Master is better tomorrow morning because Davina she is not well and I rather not
leave her alone check this girl that I want to introduce you you Pilar fogliati.
See you tomorrow.
TE 06:12:32 pm
V Read
1212 5333739
Hope she feels better
06:21:30 pm
I have meetings until 1230
06:21:39 pm
V Sent
╔════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Purevsuren Lundeg [mongolia] Mongolian ambassador to the UN 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01618400 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage from Renata Bolotova (???) screenshot(s)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
Hi sneaky
09:10:29 pm
Met with
09:11:18 pin
yesterday
2016/11/09
1212 5333739
great , what a life you have
09:11:26 pm
09:11:27 pm
I am S00000 lucky!!!
09:11:49 pm
To have you!!! `it
09:1 1:58 pm
1212 5333/39
i can seen sat
09:11:59 pm
What time?
09:12:06 pm
1212 5333739
4
09:12:14 pm
Ok
09:12:40 pm
Sneaky thank so so much for money!!!ti a,“? r-? 1,1 r-?
09:31:27 pm
•
•
Can't wait to see you
09:31:47 pm
Your meeting w
12:35:37 am
2016/11/10
at 4 pm confirmed =,‘"
2016/12/01
Hi sneaky how r you? Miss you!! What should I say
07:13:21 pm
1212 5333739
14th
08:34:09 pm
Ok sa,
09:17:04 pm
Do you mean seeing him onl4th?
09:17:34 pin
09:40:49 pm
1212 5333739
Yes
10:04:18 pm
Ok what time
10:04:39 pm
2016/12/02
Sent an attachment
Filename: New Recording 57.m4a
Path: New Recording 57.m4a
Size: 3 MB
Type: audio/x-m4a
04:33:39 pm
Sent an attachment
Filename: Sonata For Violin And Piano ( Claude Debussy ).m4a
Path: Sonata For Violin And Piano ( Claude Debussy ).m4a
Size: 1 MB
Type: audio/x-m4a
04:34:08 pm
My favorite pieces from the last night concert
04:35:00 pm
Froral: "Hi, thanks for your message. All good. Unfortunately I'm traveling on
14th for a week. Is there a chance to meet earlier or on 13th?"
04:44:47 pm
1212 5333739
Check on 12th
04:45:18 pm
Fro. "Yes. Anytime he is available"
04:51:29 pm
What time would you like him to come
04:51:45 pm
10:30am?
04:51:56 pm
2016/12/12
"Hi Jeffrey says he can not mee
me!?) He is just too busy! OK?"
04:16:27 pm
Did you mean
04:16:35 pm
Ok
04:56:00 pin
(I think this is the name he gave
1212 5333739
Yes
04:46:14 pm
•

• L25:VS p
Sounds like he is trying to intrigue you
09:29:07 pm
2016/12/17
Sneaky my sneaky, sorry missed your call tried to call you back .4
03:39:06 pm
2016/12/18
Sneaky morning tried to call you. Did you talk to Purevsuren? How was it?
03:45:05 pm
07:28:33 pm
1212 5333739
yes
08:08:45 pm
Ok great just wanted to make sure, all went well
08:11:26 pm
2016/12/22
Thank you so much sneaky for my ticket to Washington 444PIIIMI I hope to see you
soon! Miss you and talk to you tmr
10:33:02 pm
1212 5333739
of course
10:33:24 pm
2016/12/23
12:34:42 am
11:12:58 pin
•
•
Omg how sweet froast ,
11:13:18 pin
Sent an attachment
Filename: IMG_8290.mp4.mov
Path: IMG_8290.mp4.mov
Size: 13 MB
Type: video/quicktime
06:28:27 pin
2016/12/24
2016/12/25
O
03:57:08 pm
0
2016/12/28
1212 5333739
hope new year is fun see you soon
01:22:30 pm
Sent
Thank you sneaky for money!
Jean luc keep sending me a weird stuff so I blocked his number.
08:46:50 pin
Have a peaceful new year!
08:47:43 pm
V Read
EFTA01682078 (Jmail)
[government] FBI report about 
investigation targets
EFTA02730274 (Jmail)
 [government] evidence inventory that appears to have since been deleted from the DOJ website
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
Directory
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B005_BLUEPRINTS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B005_BLUEPRINTS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B005_BLUEPRINTS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B005_BLUEPRINTS 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B010_MISC DOGS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020 MISC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B020_EMAIL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020 JE 50 BDAY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B020 LSJ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_LARGE PORTRAITS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_LESLEY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_MACKLA 11-03
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020 MIS AFRICA PICS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B02
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B020_NUDES 00-24
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B020_PHOTOS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_PHOTOS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_RED TRI-FOLD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_SLIDES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anAlE1088_EMPLOYEE LIST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am UB114_BLUEPRINTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am UB114_LITTLE SAINT JAMES US VIRGIN ISLANDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7amUB114_LITTLE ST JAMES ISLAND
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7amUB114_LITTLE ST JAMES-S ISLAND CARIBBEAN SEA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7amUB114_MISC SKETCHES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B135_A YEAR TO REMEMBER ARCHETYPE 2005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am UB135_LAKE WORTH COMMUNITY HIGH SCHOOL 200
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG W-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am \1B135_TAKE A 2ND LOOK AMALGAM 2005
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_ALAN DERSHOWITZ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_ANAL WAND FORK HANDLE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_ARREST NOTICE TO APPEAR
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_CAD CALLS TO JES HOUSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_DAVID RODGERS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_DELORATORS AT HOUSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_EPSTEIN PLANES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_EPSTIEN PASSENGER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_FOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_IMPORTANT MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_JET INFO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2 CELL PHONE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_MISC DOC 006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_MISC DOGS 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 007
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_MY SPACE 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_MY SPACE 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_NEW YORK POST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 00;
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 00.
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 00!
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_PHONE RECORDS PAGAN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PHOTO LINE UPS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PROPERTY REC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_RENTAL AGREEMENT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_STATE OF FLORIDA 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_STATE OF FLORIDA 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_SUB REQUESTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_SUB RESULTS_ REQUESTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2 TRASH PULL 9-21-05
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2 TRASH RESULTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2am\1B140 2 OF 2_100-PAR 11-6-06 TRASH
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2am\1B140 2 OF 2_2006 RECENT INTEL ON EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 2 OF 2 ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2am\1B140 2 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2am\1B140 2 OF 2_EPSTEIN TRIAL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2am\1B140 2 OF 2_FOLDER 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2am\1B140 2 OF 2_FOLDER 006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2am\1B140 2 OF 2_MEDIA UNTIL 5-08
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 2 OF 2_MEDIA UP TO 10-6-09
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 2 OF 2_MISC DOCS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B006_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B007_PHOTOGRAPHS OF A LIVING ROOM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B014_OOH BY JE JOUE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am UB016_COSTUMES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B017_PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am UB021_PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am ‘18021ML.S.I 6-03
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am ‘18023_PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am ‘18024_BRONZE SCULPTURE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am ‘18027_STUFFED DOG
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am ‘18086_LSJ NOTEPAD 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am ‘18086_LSJ NOTEPAD 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am UB089_MISC DOC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am ‘18090_LSJ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am ‘18090_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am ‘18090_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am UB094_NOTEPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B100_EMPLOYEE CONTACT LIST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9amUB101_PHOTOGRAPH
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am \18104_2021-00585-1 ITEM 1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am UB105_LSJ AND GSJ BOAT LOG 2019
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am UB113_BOAT TRIP LOGS EMPLOYEE LISTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9amUB125_CARLOS AND
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am UB126_LSJ NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am UB137_PHOTO-TO JEFFREY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_BANK STATEMENTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_BINDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_BSAR TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_CDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_COURT DOGS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_DISKS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_DVDS
Wds-fs-prod \ procADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_EPSTEIN_OPEN SOURCE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-procAprocaDCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_GJ MATERIAL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 4
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 5
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 6
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 7
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 8
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001 THUMBDRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 1 1A1-1A14
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 10 1A130-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 111A151-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 12 1A171-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 2 1A15-1A26
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 3 1A27-1A39
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 4 1A40-1A49
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 71A76-1A93
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 8 1A94-1A11
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 9 1A111-1A1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF PROFFER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
-21
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 ARREST OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN
.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 5 1A50-1A62
.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 6 1A63-1A75
.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ IDCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
5-29-19
TERVIEW 5-29-19
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 FEDEX DELIVERY CONFIRMATION
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 NTERVIEW
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_INTERVIEW NOTES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_INTERVIEW OF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_INTERVIEW OF 9-1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 ITEMS FROM EPSTEIN RETURNED 7
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 JUAN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 LARRY VISOSKI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_LETTER FRO FAKE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1
NTERVIEW-PREP
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_RECEIPT FOR PROPERTY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
OVIDED BY BRA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm ‘12001_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm ‘12004_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm ‘12009 MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm ‘12076 PASSPORT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm ‘12091 PHOTO ALBUM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm ‘12092_FOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm ‘12092_THE WIRTANEN TENNIS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm UB108_VOICE RECORDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - fpm \1B110 PAPER WITH PASSWORDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - fpm \1B138 CD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 2pm ‘113015 MISC PERSONAL ITEMS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 2pm ‘113073_HARD DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 2pm ‘113074_HARD DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 2pm ‘113083_IPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 2pm ‘113084 IPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03 DEFENSE ARGUMENT IV
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2 lA \ BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2 lA \ BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN JEFFREY INVES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN V CITIBANK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03 FBI MIAMI ATTN SA NE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_FLIGHT ACTIVITY LOGS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_FLIGHT ACTIVITY LOGS
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_FLIGHT MANIFEST LIST
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCWHE BIG M-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_FLIGHT RECORDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A\ BOX MM 03 JEFFREY EPSTEIN CALL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03 MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2 lA \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2 lA \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2 lA \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03 NOTEPAD 006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03 NOTEPAD 007
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 008
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_PARTIAL I-REPORT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 0 PHONE ANAL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03 USDC SOUTHERN DIST-
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03 USDC SOUTHERN DIST-
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2 lA \ BOX MM 05_4-01-03 TO 1-01-04
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_ -03-04 TC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_ 2-08-05 TC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_ 1-04 TO 1-06
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_ 1-04 TO 05-05
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05 ITEM 2 2 OF 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 3 OF 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 BOOK 1 OF 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2 lA \ BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS COPIEL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2 lA \ BOX MM 05 3-08-04 TO 1:
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2 lA \ BOX MM 05 03-05 TO 04-0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05 1-04 TO 3-05
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_7378
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14 EPSTEIN 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14 EPSTEIN 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14 EPSTEIN ACCURINT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FGJ PRESENTATION
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14 FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14 FOLDER 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FOLDER 005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_GIRLS INVOLVED
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_GRAND JURY EXHIBITS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_INDICTMENT-CHART-TESTIM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 10
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14 JANE DOE NO 12-13
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 14
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A\ BOX MM 14 JANE DOE NO 15
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 16
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 18
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 2
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 3
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 7
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 9
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOES 1-19
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A\ BOX MM 14 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14 PBPD-INCIDENT REPORT
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_PBPD-PROBABLE CAUSE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_PBPD-PROPERTY RECEIPTS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_PHOTOGRAPHS AND MP JAI%
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_RAW DATA
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT C
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT C
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B022_BAG OF CDS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B038_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B039_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B040_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B044_SIM CARD
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B045_11 DISC
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B046_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B047_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B048_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B049_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B050_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B051 FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B052_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B055_IPHONE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B056_HARD DRIVE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B063_BAG OF CDS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B064_VOICE RECORDER
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B066_VOICE RECORDER
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B067_IPAD
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B068_IPAD
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B071_CELLPHONE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B075_BINDER 001
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B075_BINDER 002
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B078_BINDER 001
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B078_BINDER 002
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B078_BLUE BINDER 1
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B078_BLUE BINDER 2
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B095_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1 \18141_BUNDLE OF CDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1 \16142_CASSETTE TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1 \16142_MICROCASSETTES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1 \16142_VHS TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1005_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024 FLASH CARDS PUT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_COPIES 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-1024_COPIES 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-1024_COPY 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_MISC PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-1025_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-1027_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-1064_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-1092_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-1219_COPY DVDS FROI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-1245_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-257_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-368_05-1024_COPY 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-368_05-1024_COPY 00:
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-378_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-379_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-380_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-381_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-382_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0S-383_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-384_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-38S_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-386_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-874_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-878_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-901_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-91S_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-941_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-943_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-944_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_06-24_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_CDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_ENVELOPE_PICTURES-NAM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_EPSTIEN CIVIL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FAX
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDER-PROBABLE CAUSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDER_
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDER_
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCWHE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDE
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_F0LDER_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG M-TIFAWave006 ‘3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_F0LDER_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_F0LDER_SUB REQUESTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_NATI0NAL COMPLIANCE CI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_0FFICIAL POLICE PHOTOGF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH INVESTIGATI(
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH PAPERS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH PD PROPERT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH POLICE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAV
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_ NYC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_UNITED STATES DISTRICT C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_USAO VISITOR
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-GI SEC OC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-al SEC OC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-al SEC OC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-al SEC 00
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-al SER lfi
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_50D-NY-3027571 SEC 0015
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_50D-NY-3027571-al SEC 0t
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_BLUEPRINTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_CERTIFIED COPY OF BIRTH
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_DISKS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_FLATLEY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_MAXWELL SECURITY FOOT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_ RTIFIE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_TRANSFER OF EPSTEIN CAS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_ _
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \prod \DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_ARREST OF GHISLAINE IS;
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_BRAD EDWARDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_BRAVO ZONE SEARCH PI
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2 CHARLIE DELTA ZONES:
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG M-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_DAVID RODGERS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_EVIDENCE LOG_SIGN-IN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_FARO LASER SCAN DATA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_FARO LASER SCAN DATA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_FLIGHT LOGS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_INTERVIEW OF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \111003_ITEM 7-8 MICRO_CASSETTE TAP
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 V.B003_ITEM-1 MICRO TAPE
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B003_ITEM-10 CASSETTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1BOOLITEM-11-12-13-14-15 MISC NOT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B003_ITEM-5 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B003_ITEM-6 FOLDER WITH 6 PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B003_ITEM-9 DISC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B003_ITEMS 2-3-4 MICRO TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B003_ITEMS-16-17-18_MISC INVOICES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B003_ITEMS-19 THRU 24 EPTSTEIN NO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B003_MISC NOTES AND RECEIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-1 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B004_ITEM-10 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-11 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-12 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-13 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-14 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-15 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-16 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-17 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-18 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-19 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-2 JETBLUE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-20 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-21 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-22 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-3 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_ITEM-5 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-6 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-7 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-8 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-9 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM4 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B004_JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MESSAGES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_1TEM-12 ALFREDO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13008_ITEM-1 VHS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-11 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-13 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-14 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-15 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-16 VHS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-17 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-18 MESSAGE_MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B008 ITEM-19 DISC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-2 VHS-DISC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-3 VHS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-4 VHS
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-5 VHS
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\1B008_ITEM-6 VHS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B008 ITEM-7 VHS-DISC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B008 ITEM-8 16 DISC PALM BEACH PD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PA1B008_ITEM 9 10 SUPOENA-CINGULAR
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 01_PALM BEACH COUNTY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 0l_VIC FOLDERS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 01 VICTIM BINDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 01 VICTIM BINDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 01 VICTIM BINDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 03
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 03_TELEPHONE REPORTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 03_US DOJ US ATTORNEY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 06_PHONE RECORDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4 ITEM-1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4 ITEM-2A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4 ITEM-2B
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4 ITEM-2C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-4
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4 ITEM-5
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4 ITEM-6
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4 ITEM-7
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4 ITEM-8
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9B
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9D
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9E
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9F
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9G
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9H
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-91 PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_2 TWIN TORPEDOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-24
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-25
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-26
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-27
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-M
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-29
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-30A 308 30C 30D .
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-18 AT T
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-18 NORTH OCEAN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4 ITEM-18 ROCK MIX
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-19 MINI DV CASSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-20 BURLWOOD CC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4 ITEM-20 PHOT BOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-21A PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-21B PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-22A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-22B PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-23A RECEIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-23B SOAP ON THE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM23B PENI-SOAPS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM23B SEXY LOVING S
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-31
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-32
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-33
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-34A-K
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-35
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-37
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-38
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-39
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-40
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-41
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-42
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-43
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-44
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B002 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM 20-21 MICRO TAPE-PALM
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM-1 THRU 3 MICRO TAPES
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-10 EMAILS_CABATO NILD
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-12 VHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-13 VHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-14 DISC
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM-15 THRU 17 VHS-MICRO
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM-18 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM-19 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM-22 MICRO TAPE_MESSAG
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-4 EARNINGS STATEMENT
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-4 RECEIPTS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-5
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-5 FLOOR PLANS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-6 DRAWN BY HALL
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-7 MESSAGES
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-8 VHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-9 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B009_AN INVITATION TO POETRY
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B009_VICTORIA SECRET BRA
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B010_MASSAGE FOR DUMMIES
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B019_3 PHONE MESSAGE BOOKS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B020_MESSAGE BOOK
Wds-fs-proA  prod\  DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_ADULT VIDEO WAREI
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_BEAR STEARNS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_BROWARD CENTER F
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANCGRO
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANK 001
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANK 002
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_JEGE HYPERION-HELI
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02 _JEGE-HYPERION MAI%
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_JP MORGAN CHASE 0
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_JP MORGAN CHASE 0
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_THE SHUBERT ORGAt
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 -
.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_
lA \BOX MM 02_ DTG OPERATIONS DB
lA \BOX MM 02_ EXTRA TOUCH FLOW
lA \BOX MM 02_ FEDERAL EXPRESS
1A \BOX MM 02 FINANCIAL COMPANI -
1A \BOX MM 02 FOLDER -
1A \BOX MM 02 HYPERION-JEGE BUSI -
.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_
lA \BOX MM 02_ LARRY VISOSKI W2 S1
1A \BOX MM 02 PALM BEACH COUNT -
1A \BOX MM 02_ REIMER EMPLOYMEP
lA \BOX MM 02_ RPBHS
lA \BOX MM 02 WESTERN UNION 001 _
lA \BOX MM 02 WESTERN UNION 00; _
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_WOLF CAMERA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_SUBPOENA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P3 \ 1B039_2020-01577-1 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P3 \ 1B039_2020-01577-1 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P3 \ 1B039_LETTER 1A65
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PHOTO 10
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PHOTO 11
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PHOTO 12
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PHOTO 16
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PHOTO 17
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PHOTO 18
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PHOTO 19
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PHOTO 20
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PHOTO 5
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B019_MISC PRINTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B135_A SPLASH OF CLASS ARCHETYPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B135_A WALK IN OUR SHOES-01
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B135_A WALK IN OUR SHOES-02
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_ALL EYES ON US ARCHETYPE 200
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_ALL EYES ON US ARCHETYPE 200
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_ARCHETYPE ROYAL PALM BEACH
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \III135_ARCHETYPE ROYAL PALM BEAC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B135_NOTHING BUT-AMALGAM 2004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B135_PIECES OF OUR PUZZLE ARCHE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B135_THE DAYS OF YORE JAVELIN 200
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-10B PLACE HOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-10G PLACE HOLDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-10H PLACE HOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-11A PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-11B PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-12A PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-12B PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-13 TWO VHS TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-14 FROM —T
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG W-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-15 ABC NOTE ABO
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-16 MESSAGE BOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-17 MESSAGE BOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-1 RECORDS LISTED FOR EP!
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-10 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-11 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-12 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-13 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-14 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-15 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-16 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-17 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-18 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-19 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-2 EPSTEIN NOTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-20 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-21 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-22 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-23 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-24 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-25 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-26 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-27 MEASSGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-28 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-29 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-3 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_ITEM-30 RECORDS LISTED FOR El
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-4 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-5 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-6 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-7 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-8 BROKEN HANDLE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005 ITEM-9 BALANCE SHEET DEC 31:
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B00S_JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MISC MESSAC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN_RELATED EN1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005 RECORDS LISTED FOR EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ALBERTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_GHISLAINE MAXWELL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_INVOICES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM 28-29 MICRO TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-1OA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-1OB
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006 ITEM-10C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-1OD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2 \ 1B006_ITEM-10E
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-10F
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG W-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2 \ 1B006_ITEM-11A
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-11B
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-11C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-11D
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-11E
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2 \ 1B006_ITEM-12A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-13
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-14 VHS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-15 TRHU 17 MICRO TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-18 THRU 21 MICRO TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-22 MISC NOTES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-23-24 MICRO TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-26 BROKEN HANDLE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-27 MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-27 TRANSACTION REGISTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-4
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-5
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-6
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-7
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-8
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-9
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEMS-25 MISC NOTES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MESSAGES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_MAPQUEST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_MEDICAL SUPPLIES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2 \ 1B006_MORE LEGG ROOM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_SCARLETTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P3\ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P3\ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P3\ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P3\ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 001_72-MM-113327-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 001 _JE AND GM 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 001 _JE AND GM 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_1B-143
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_AIRMAIL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_ATTENTION
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_CALENDAR
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_CONFIDENTIAL CRIMINAL
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_COWLES STORY A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611 ENVELOPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_ENVELOPE_EXECUTIVE SUFI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_ENVELOPE_ORIGINAL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_EPSTEIN JEFFREY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_EPSTEIN_LETTER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_EXHIBIT MM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FAO SDNY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611 FOLDER 006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GHISLAINE MAXWELL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GRAND JURY SUBPOENA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_IMAGES FROM MIAMI BOX
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_JE DIAMOND APPRAISALS F
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_JEFFREY EPSTEIN SIGNIFICA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 61
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_MASSEUSES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_MEDIA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_NEW YORK OFFICE OF THE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_NEW YORK POLICE DEPAR
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_POSTAGE PAID ENVELOPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_RED FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_RED FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_RED FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611 REPORTS ACCURINTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 6114
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_SCENE2GO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_SUBPOENAS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_ IDEO INiI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_VICiIM NAME LIST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_VICiIM SERVICES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_YELLOW FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_YELLOW FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENi OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENi OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENi OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04 STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENi OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENi OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENi OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENi OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENi OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_SUPOENA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 08_SCHOOL RECORDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 08_SUBPOENA TO TESTIFY
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_5-21-2007 PHONE RECC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_727 BOEING-N908JE_JE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_CALL_FLIGHT LOGS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_CALL_FLIGHT LOGS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11 CALL FLIGHT LOGS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 111MNDIVIDUAL SW%
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_DTG OPERATIONS DBA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_FAX
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_FAX ACTIVITY LOG
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM ll_GULFSTREAM-N9091E_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_MONEY TRANSFER REC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_NATIONAL COMPREHEI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_NEWS POSTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_PALM BEACH POLICE DI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_PALM BEACH POLICE P1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_PASSENGER MANIFEST!
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_PHOTOS
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_REPORT RESULTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_ OMPAN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11 SUBPOENA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12 31E-MM-108062-FF SEI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12 31E-MM-108062-SBP S
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_SENTINEL REPORTS SER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_SERIAL REPORT FOR CA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_31E-MM -108062
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 13_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13 CIVIL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13 COMPUTERS REMOVEC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13 COURT ORDERS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13J
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_EMPLOYEES-JE 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13 EMPLOYEES-JE 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13 FBI MIAMI TO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_FLIGHT RECORDS FAA-P
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 13_FLIGHT RECORDS JET Al
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_FLIGHT RECORDS MANI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_FLIGHTS-ICE TEC-INTL-C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13 GHISLAINE MAXWELL 1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_PALM BEACH PD PROP(
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_PALM BEACH PD PROP(
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 13 TECS-CUSTOMS ICE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 13 THE STATE OF FL COUN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_10-06-2005 CALL SUM%
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_302531E-MM -108062
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_ADMIN SUBPOENAS-O1.
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15 ADMINISTRATIVE-FEDE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15 CORPORATE RECORDS-.
\\ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15 DEFENSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_ECS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_EPSTEIN-WORK RELEAS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_EXPERTS-KEN LIMNING
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15 FEDEX FBI NEW YORK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG M-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_FORFEITURE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GERALD B LEFCOURT FE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GERALD B LEFCOURT JP
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM &al TRANSCRIPTS-G1 LET
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM &al TRANSCRIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_G1 TRANSCRIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_G1 TRANSCRIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT
I
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPTS-
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCLI \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_G1 TRANSCRIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GRAND JURY SUBPOEN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_INSERTS 31E-MM-1080
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_INVOICES-EXPENSES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_1E-AIRCRAFT PHOTOS N
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_MESSAGE PAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_MISC FORMS 990-PF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_ORDER-WHO BROUGH"
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ Dal \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PBPD PROPERTY RECEIF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PBPD PROPERTY RECEIF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 15_PBPD TRASH PULLS-TR/
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PBPD-PROPERTY RECEII
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PBPD-SEARCH WARRA(
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PHOTO LINE-UPS-PHOT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_RENTAL CARS DOLLAR_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-CASE NO 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-CASE NO 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-FL VS JEFFF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-MISC COVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-MISC POST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-PALM BEAT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-SEARCH-AF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-STATE CAS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE SUBPOENAS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_TRANSCRIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LETTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LETTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LETTE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_WESTERN UNION-WES1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_WORK RELEASE APPLIC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008 \3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_31E-MM -108062-G1 SEI
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ 5E4
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ SO
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_GJ SUBPOENA LOGS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_GJ TESTIMONYS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 2C G.I TESTIMONY
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_2009
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_ 1A-1C REPORT FOR CM
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22 1A-1C REPORT FOR CAS -
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062 GRAN
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-104
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-105
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-108
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-109
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-114
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-115
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 -
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 -
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 -
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 -
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 -
4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22
4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22
4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22
4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22
4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22
4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22
_ATTYS LETTERS-MISC
_CALLFREQUENCYFORI
_CASE NO 2008CF00938
_CHILD MOLESTERS-A B
_DATA DEMONSTRATIVE
_FEDEX ENVELOPE TO S
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_GERALD B LEFCOURT N
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_GRAND JURY SUBPOEN
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_JASON
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_MASTER
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_NOTEPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_PALM BEACH PD FAX TI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_PALM BEACH PD INCIDI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_PLEA IN THE CIRCUIT a
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIMWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ Dal \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave008 \3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 22_REC0RDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_REC0RDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22MM G DOB
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_SERIAL 31E-MM-10806
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_SERIAL REPORT FOR CA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_SEX OFFENDER CONTIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_T-MOBILE CALL LOGS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_T-MOBILE CALL LOGS-0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIMWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIMWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES LIT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_W(
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ForFDPSImport\050D-NY-3027571 Serials 1-21
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ForFDPSImport\050D-NY-3027571 Serials 101-150
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ForFDPSImport\050D-NY-3027571 Serials 22-49
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ForFDPSImport\050D-NY-3027571 Serials 50-99
C: \temp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel\ForFDPSImport\050D-
- 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22 DOB
- 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
NY-3027571-ELA
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ ForFDPSImport\ 050D-NY-3027571-FF
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ ForFDPSImport\ 050D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 151-183
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-IsIV-3027571 Serials 184-240
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-IsIV-3027571 Serials 241-292
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-W-3027571 Serials 294-350
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 351-373
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 374-382
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 383-397
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-W-3027571 Serials 398-405
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 406-450
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 451-499
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 500-557
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 558-585
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 586-622
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 623-636
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 637-660
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 661-706
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\009A-NY-3144791 Serials 1-7
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\050D-NY-3027571 Serial 293
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\72-MM-1133217 Serials 1-61
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\72-MM-1133217 Serials 62-64
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\72-MM-113327-1A1-1A19
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\72-MM-113327-ELA Serials 1-3
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 1-65
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 115-119
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 120
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 121-146
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 147-179
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 64-97
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 98-114
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-SBP Serials 1-6
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 180-211
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\050D-NY-3027571-FA
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 1-70 Part 1 (p1-250)
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 1-70 Part 2 (p251-44
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 176-250
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 251-263
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 71-175 Part 1 (p1-24
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 71-175 Part 2 (p249-
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 1(p1-29
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 2 (p256
CAtemp \ACCD_Project\ Epstein \Sentinel\Wave004\ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 3 (p511
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 1_1 (pl
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 1_2 (p1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 1(p1-29
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 2 (p251
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 3 (p501
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 4 (p751
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 1(p1-2°
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 2 (p251
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 3 (p501
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 4 (p751
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 1(p1-29
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 2 (p251
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 3 (p501
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 1(p1 -1i
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 2 (p175
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 3 (p349
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A80
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A82
C:\temp\ACCD Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part I
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part a.
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 4
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A1-1A9 Part 1 (r
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A1-1A9 Part 2 (g
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A142-1A146
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A28-1A49 Part I
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A28-1A49 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 3
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 3
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A52-1A78 Part I
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A52-1A78 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A78 Pt. 2 -1A86
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A78 Pt. 2 - 1A86
CAtemp \ ACCD_ProjectVpstein \ Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 3
CAtemp \ ACCD_ProjectVpstein \ Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_ProjectVpstein \ Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 3
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-FF Serial 10
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-FF Serials 1-9
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GJ Serial 46
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GJ Serials 1-45
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-SBP Serials 1-87 Part 1 (p1-:
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-SBP Serials 1-87 Part 2 (p25
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\SOD-NY-3027571 GJ Serial 21
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\SOD-NY-3027571-GJ Serial 7
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\SOD-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 14-20
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 1-6
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 22-36
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571-GI Serials 37-39
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004 \ ForFDPSImport\50D-W-3027571-GJ Serials 40-44
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004\ ForFDPSImport\50D-W-3027571-GJ Serials 8-13
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A20 Part 1 (p1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A20 Part 2 (p2
C:\temp\ACCD Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A20 Part 3 (p4
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A28 Part 1(p1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A28 Part 2 (p
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A28 Part 3 (pz.,
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 1 (p
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 2 (p2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 3 (p5
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 4 (p7
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 5 (p1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 6 (p1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 7 (p1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 8 (p1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 9 (p2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 1_1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 1_2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 1_3
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 2_1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 2_2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 3
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 4
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 5
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A1-1A5 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A1-1A5 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \ Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A1-1A5 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \ Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport \31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A17-1A19 Pa
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \ Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A17-1A19 Pa
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-6.1-1A Serials 1A21-1A30
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A38-1A42 Pa
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A38-1A42 Pa
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A6-1A8 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A6-1A8 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A6-1A8 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A9-1A16 Pan
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A9-1A16 Pan
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 1-5
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 10-11
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 12-13
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 14-17
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 6 - 8
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 9
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005\ForFDPSImport\90C-NY-3154599-al (Serial 1-2)
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 001 Serial 1-14 (212 pz
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 002 Serial 14 Part 3 Oi
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 003 Serial 14 Part 1 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 004 Serial 14 Part 2 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 005 Serial 14 Part 4 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 006 Serial 14 Part 5 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 007 Serial 14 Part 6 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 008 Serial 15-30 (225 r
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 009 Serial 31-50 (302 r
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 010 Serial 51-54 part 1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 011 Serial 54 Part 2 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 012 Serial 54 Part 3 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 013 Serial 54 Part 4 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 014 Serial 54 Part 5 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 015 Serial 54-2 Part 1 (
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 016 Serial 54-2 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 017 Serial 54-2 Part 3
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 018 Serial 54-2 Part 4
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 019 Serial 54-2 Part 5
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 020 Serial 54-2 Part 6
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006\ForFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 021 Serial 55 - 61 (19 il
Case Number Case_ID File
I 662053-000 1233554 18005_BLUEPRINTS 001
1662053-000 1233554 1B005_BLUEPRINTS 002
1662053-000 1233554 1B005_BLUEPRINTS 003
1662053-000 1233554 1B005_BLUEPRINTS 004
1662053-000 1233554 1B010 MISC DOCS
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 MISC
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_EMAIL
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 JE 50 BDAY
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 LSJ
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 _LARGE PORTRAITS
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 _LESLEY
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_MACKLA 11-03
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 MIS AFRICA PICS
1662053-000 1233554 1B020
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_NUDES 00-24
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_PHOTOS 001
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_PHOTOS 002
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_RED TRI-FOLD
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_SLIDES
1662053-000 1233554 1B088_EMPLOYEE LIST
1662053-000 1233554 1B114_BLUEPRINTS
1662053-000 1233554 1B114_LITTLE SAINT JAMES US VIRGIN ISLANDS
1662053-000 1233554 1B114_LITTLE ST JAMES ISLAND
1662053-000 1233554 1B114_LITTLE ST JAM ES-S ISLAND CARIBBEAN SEA
1662053-000 1233554 1B114_MISC SKETCHES
1662053-000 1233554 1B135_A YEAR TO REMEMBER ARCHETYPE 2005
1662053-000 1233554 1B135 _LAKE WORTH COMMUNITY HIGH SCHOOL 2005
1662053-000 1233554 1B135 TAKE A 2ND LOOK AMALGAM 2005
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_ALAN DERSHOWITZ
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_ANAL WAND FORK HANDLE
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_ARREST NOTICE TO APPEAR
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_CAD CALLS TO JES HOUSE
1662053-000 1233554 18140 1 OF 2_DAVID RODGERS
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_DELORATORS AT HOUSE
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_EPSTEIN PLANES
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_EPSTIEN PASSENGER
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_FOLDER
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_FOLDER 002
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_FOLDER 003
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_IMPORTANT MESSAGE
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2 _JET INFO
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 O ELL PHONE
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOC 006
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 001
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 002
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 003
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 004
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 005
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 007
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MY SPACE 001
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MY SPACE 002
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_NEW YORK POST
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 001
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 002
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 003
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 004
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 005
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PHONE RECORDS
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PHOTO LINE UPS
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PROPERTY REC
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_RENTAL AGREEMENT
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_STATE OF FLORIDA 001
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_STATE OF FLORIDA 002
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_SUB REQUESTS
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_SUB RESULTS_ REQUESTS
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_TRASH PULL 9-21-05
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_TRASH RESULTS
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_100-PAR 11-6-06 TRASH
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_2006 RECENT INTEL ON EPSTEIN
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_EPSTEIN TRIAL
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_FOLDER 004
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_FOLDER 006
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_MEDIA UNTIL 5-08
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_MEDIA UP TO 10-6-09
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_MISC DOCS 003
1662053-000 1233554 1B006_MISC DOCS
1662053-000 1233554 1B007_PHOTOGRAPHS OF A LIVING ROOM
1662053-000 1233554 1B014_OOH BY JE JOUE
1662053-000 1233554 1B016_COSTUMES
1662053-000 1233554 1B017_PHOTOS
1662053-000 1233554 1B021_PHOTOS
1662053-000 1233554 1B021 LSJ 6-03
1662053-000 1233554 1B023_PHOTOS
1662053-000 1233554 1B024_BRONZE SCULPTURE
1662053-000 1233554 1B027_STUFFED DOG
1662053-000 1233554 1B086_LSJ NOTEPAD 001
1662053-000 1233554 1B086_LS1 NOTEPAD 002
1662053-000 1233554 1B089_MISC DOC
1662053-000 1233554 1B090_LSJ
1662053-000 1233554 1B090_MISC DOCS
1662053-000 1233554 1B090_NOTEBOOK
1662053-000 1233554 1B094_NOTEPAD
1662053-000 1233554 1B100_EMPLOYEE CONTACT LIST
1662053-000 1233554 1B101_PHOTOGRAPH
1662053-000 1233554 1B104_2021-00585-1 ITEM 1
1662053-000 1233554 1B105_LSJ AND GSJ BOAT LOG 2019
1662053-000 1233554 1B113_BOAT TRIP LOGS_EMPLOYEE LISTS
1662053-000 1233554 1B125_CARLOS AND
1662053-000 1233554 1B126_LS1 NOTEBOOK
1662053-000 1233554 1B137_PHOTO-TO JEFFREY
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_BANK STATEMENTS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_BINDER
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_BSAR TRANSCRIPT
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_CDS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_0OURT DOCS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_DISKS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_DVDS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_EPSTEIN_OPEN SOURCE
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER 001
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER 002
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_GJ MATERIAL
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 2
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 3
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 4
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 5
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 6
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 7
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 8
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_MISC DOCS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_NOTEBOOK
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001 THUMBDRIVE
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 1 1A1-1A14
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 10 1A130-1A150
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_lA SUPPLEMENT VOL 11 1A151-1A170
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_lA SUPPLEMENT VOL 12 1A171-1A195
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_lA SUPPLEMENT VOL 2 1A15-1A26
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 3 1A27-1A39
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 41A40 -1A49
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_lA SUPPLEMENT VOL 5 1A50-1A62
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_lA SUPPLEMENT VOL 6 1A63-1A75
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_lA SUPPLEMENT VOL 7 1A76-1A93
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_lA SUPPLEMENT VOL 81A94-1A110
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 9 1A111-1A129
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 PROFFER
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 ARREST OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2
1662053-000 I1233554IBOX 1 OF 2 _FEDEX DELIVERY CONFIRMATION
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_ITEMS FROM EPSTEIN RETURNED TO LAWYER
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_LARRY VISOSKI
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_LETTER FROM FAKE NY LICENSE
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_RECEIPT FOR PROPERTY
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_USB OF PHOTOS PROVIDED BY BRAD EDWARDS
1662053-000 1233554 1B001_NOTEBOOK
1662053-000 1233554 1B004_NOTEBOOK
1662053-000 1233554 1B009 MISC DOCS
1662053-000 1233554 1B076 PASSPORT
1662053-000 1233554 1B091 PHOTO ALBUM
1662053-000 1233554 1B092 FOLDER
1662053-000 1233554 1B092 THE WIRTANEN TENNIS
1662053-000 1233554 1B108_VOICE RECORDER
1662053-000 1233554 1B110 PAPER WITH PASSWORDS
1662053-000 1233554 1B138 CD
1662053-000 1233554 1B015 MISC PERSONAL ITEMS
1662053-000 1233554 1B073 HARD DRIVE
1662053-000 1233554 1B074 HARD DRIVE
1662053-000 1233554 1B083_IPAD
1662053-000 1233554 1B084 IPAD
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 DEFENSE ARGUMENT NOTES
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 EPSTEIN JEFFREY INVESTIGATION
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN V CITIBANK
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 FBI MIAMI ATTN
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 FLIGHT ACTIVITY LOGS 001
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 FLIGHT ACTIVITY LOGS 002
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 FLIGHT MANIFEST LIST
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 FLIGHT RECORDS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 JEFFREY EPSTEIN CALL CHARTS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 MISC DOCS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 001
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 002
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 003
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 004
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 005
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 006
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 007
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 008
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_PARTIAL I-REPORT
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 PHONE ANALYSIS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FL 001
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FL 002
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_4-01-03 TO 1-01-04
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 2 OF 3
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 3 OF 3
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 BOOK 1 OF 3
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 001
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 002
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 003
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS COPIED 01-23-2008
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_7378
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_EPSTEIN 001
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_EPSTEIN 002
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_EPSTEIN ACCURINT
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FG1 PRESENTATION
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 001
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 002
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 003
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 004
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 005
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_GIRLS INVOLVED
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_GRAND JURY EXHIBITS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_INDICTMENT-CHART-TESTIMONY
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 10
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 12-13
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 14
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 15
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 16
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 18
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 2
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 3
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 7
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 9
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOES 1-19
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JEFFREY EPSTEIN
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_PBPD-INCIDENT REPORT
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_PBPD-PROBABLE CAUSE
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_PBPD-PROPERTY RECEIPTS
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_PHOTOGRAPHS AND MP JANE DOE NO 6-13
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_RAW DATA
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_USDCSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FL 001
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_USDCSOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FL 002
1662054-000 1233555 1B022_BAG OF CDS
1662054-000 1233555 1B038_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B039_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B040_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B044_SIM CARD
1662054-000 1233555 1B045_11 DISC
1662054-000 1233555 1B046_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B047_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B048_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B049_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B050_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B051_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B052_FLASH DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B055_IPHONE
1662054-000 1233555 1B056_HARD DRIVE
1662054-000 1233555 1B063_BAG OF CDS
1662054-000 1233555 1B064_VOICE RECORDER
1662054-000 1233555 1B066_VOICE RECORDER
1662054-000 1233555 1B067_IPAD
1662054-000 1233555 1B068_IPAD
1662054-000 1233555 1B071_CELLPHONE
1662054-000 1233555 1B075_BINDER 001
1662054-000 1233555 1B075_BINDER 002
1662054-000 1233555 1B078_BINDER 001
1662054-000 1233555 1B078_BINDER 002
1662054-000 1233555 1B078_BLUE BINDER 1
1662054-000 1233555 1B078_BLUE BINDER 2
1662054-000 1233555 18095 NOTEBOOK
1662054-000 1233555 1B141_BUNDLE OF CDS
1662054-000 1233555 1B142_CASSETTE TAPES
1662054-000 1233555 1B142_MICROCASSETTES
1662054-000 1233555 1B142_VHS TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1005_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024 FLASH CARDS PUT ON CDS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPIES 001
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPIES 002
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 001
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 002
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 003
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_MISC PHOTOS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1025_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1027_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1064_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1092_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1219_COPY DVDS FROM PBSO
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1245_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-257_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-368_05-1024_COPY 001
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-368_05-1024_COPY 002
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-378_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-379_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-380_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-381_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-382_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-383_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-384_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-385_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-386_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-874_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-878_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-901_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-915_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-941_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-943_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-944_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_06-24_COPY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_CDS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_ENVELOPE_PICTURES-NAMES
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_EPSTIEN CIVIL
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FAX
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FOLDER
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FOLDER-PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT
.
1662054-000
.
1233555 BOX 002_FOLDER_MISC DOGS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002 FOLDER SCHWEGEL
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FOLDER_SUB REQUESTS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_NATIONAL COMPLIANCE CENTER
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_OFFICIAL POLICE PHOTOGRAPHS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH INVESTIGATION
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH PAPERS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH PD PROPERTY RECEIPT
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH POLICE
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PHOTOS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_USAO VISITOR
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-GJ SEC 001 SER 1A1-1A15
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-GJ SEC 002 SER 1A16-1A29
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-GJ SEC 003 SER 1A30-1A44
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-GJ SEC 004 SER 1A45-1A61
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-GJ SER 1A26 ONLY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_50D-NY-3027571 SEC 001 SER 1A64
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_50D-NY-3027571-GJ SEC 005 SER 1A62-
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_BLUEPRINTS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_CERTIFIED COPY OF BIRTH CERTIFICATE
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_DISKS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_FLATLEY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_MAXWELL SECURITY FOOTAGE
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_ CERTIFIED BIRTH CERT
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_TRANSFER OF EPSTEIN CASE FILES TO WFO
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2 PROFFER 9-10-19
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2 ALPHA ZONE SEARCH PAPERWORK
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_BRAVO ZONE SEARCH PAPERWORK
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_CHARLIE_DELTA ZONES SEARCH PAPERWORK
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_DAVID RODGERS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2 EVIDENCE LOG SIGN IN LOG MAP NOTES
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_FARO LASER SCAN DATA 001
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_FARO LASER SCAN DATA 002
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_FLIGHT LOGS
11-21-19
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_ITEM 7-8 MICRO_CASSETTE TAPES
1662054-000 1233555 1B003 ITEM-1 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_ITEM-10 CASSETTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_ITEM-11-12-13-14-15 MISC NOTES
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_ITEM-5 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_ITEM-6 FOLDER WITH 6 PHOTOS
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_ITEM-9 DISC
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_ITEMS 2-3-4 MICRO TAPES
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_ITEMS-16-17-18_MISC INVOICES
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_ITEMS-19 THRU 24 EPTSTEIN NOTES
1662054-000 1233555 1B003_MISC NOTES AND RECEIPTS
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-1 NOTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-10 NOTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-11 MESSAGE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-12 MESSAGE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-13 NOTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-14 MESSAGE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-15 MESSAGE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-16 MESSAGE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-17 MESSAGE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-18 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-19 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-2 JETBLUE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-20 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-21 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-22 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-3 NOTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-5 MESSAGE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-6 NOTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-7 NOTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-8 NOTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM-9 NOTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004_ITEM4 NOTE
1662054-000 1233555 1B004 CONTACT LIST
1662054-000 1233555 1B004 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MESSAGES
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_1TEM-12
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-1 VHS
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-11 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-13 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-14 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-15 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-16 VHS
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-17 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-18 MESSAGE_MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-19 DISC
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-2 VHS-DISC
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-3 VHS
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-4 VHS
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-5 VHS
1662054-000 1233555 1B008_ITEM-6 VHS
1662054-000 1233555 1B008 ITEM-7 VHS-DISC
1662054-000 1233555 1B008 ITEM-8 16 DISC PALM BEACH PD
1662054-000 1233555 1B008 ITEM-9-10 SUPOENA-CINGULAR WIRELESS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 0l_PALM BEACH COUNTY RA 31E-MM
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 0l_VIC FOLDERS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 01_VICTIM BINDER 001
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 01_VICTIM BINDER 002
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 01_VICTIM BINDER 003
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 0
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 03_TELEPHONE REPORTS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 03_US DOJ US ATTORNEY SOUTHERN DIST FL
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 06_PHONE RECORDS
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4 ITEM-1
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4 ITEM-2A
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4 ITEM-2B
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4 ITEM-2C
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4 ITEM-3
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4_ITEM-4
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4 ITEM-5
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4 ITEM-6
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4 ITEM-7
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4 ITEM-8
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4_ITEM-9A
1662054-000 1233555 1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9B
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4_ITEM-9C
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4_ITEM-9D
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4_ITEM-9E
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4_ITEM-9F
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4_ITEM-9G
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4_ITEM-9H
1662054-000 1233555 1B0011 OF 4_ITEM-9I PHOTO
1662054-000 1233555 1B0013 OF 4_2 TWIN TORPEDOS
1662054-000 1233555 1B0013 OF 4_ITEM-24
1662054-000 1233555 1B0013 OF 4_ITEM-25
1662054-000 1233555 1B0013 OF 4_ITEM-26
1662054-000 1233555 1B0013 OF 4_ITEM-27
1662054-000 1233555 1B0013 OF 4_ITEM-28
1662054-000 1233555 1B0013 OF 4_ITEM-29
1662054-000 1233555 1B0013 OF 4_ITEM-30A 30B 30C 30D 30E 30F
1662054-000 1233555 1B0013 OF 4_MISC DOGS
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-18 AT_T
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-18 NORTH OCEAN WAY
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-18 ROCK MIX
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-19 MINI DV CASSETTE TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-20 BURLWOOD COLLECTION
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-20 PHOT BOOK
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-21A PHOTO
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-21B PHOTO
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-22A
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-22B PHOTO
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-23A RECEIPT
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM-23B SOAP ON THE ROPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM23B PENI-SOAPS
1662054-000 1233555 1B0014 OF 4_ITEM23B SEXY LOVING SOAP
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-31
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-32
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-33
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-34A-K
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-35
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-37
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-38
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-39
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-40
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-41
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-42
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-43
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-44
1662054-000 1233555 1B002 1 OF 2_MISC DOGS
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM 20-21 MICRO TAPE-PALM BEACH POLICE
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-1 THRU 3 MICRO TAPES
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-10 EMAILS -MICRO
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-12 VHS
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-13 VHS
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-14 DISC
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-15 THRU 17 VHS-MICRO TAPES
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-18 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-19 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-22 MICRO TAPE_MESSAGE
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-4 EARNINGS STATEMENT
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-4 RECEIPTS
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-5
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-5 FLOOR PLANS
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-6 DRAWN BY
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-7 MESSAGES
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-8 VHS
1662054-000 1233555 1B007_ITEM-9 MICRO TAPE
1662054-000 1233555 1B009_AN INVITATION TO POETRY
1662054-000 1233555 1B009_VICTORIA SECRET BRA
1662054-000 1233555 1B010_MASSAGE FOR DUMMIES
1662054-000 1233555 1B019_3 PHONE MESSAGE BOOKS
1662054-000 1233555 1B020_MESSAGE BOOK
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02 W2 STATEMENTS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_ADULT VIDEO WAREHOUSE
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_BEAR STEARNS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_BROWARD CENTER FOR THE PERFORMING ARTS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANCGROUP
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANK 001
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANK 002
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_DR THOMAS ROFRANO RECORDS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_DTG OPERATIONS DBA DOLLAR RENT A CAR
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02 EXTRA TOUCH FLOWERS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_FEDERAL EXPRESS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_FINANCIAL COMPANIES-GERALD B LEFCOURT
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_FOLDER
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_HYPERION-JEGE BUSINESS RECORDS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02 RECORDS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_JEGE HYPERION-HELICOPTER
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_JEGE-HYPERION MANIFESTS LOGBOOK
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_JP MORGAN CHASE 001
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_JP MORGAN CHASE 002
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_LARRY VISOSKI W2 STATEMENTS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_PALM BEACH COUNTY HEALTH DEPARTMENT
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_REIMER EMPLOYMENT AGENCY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_RPBHS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_THE SHUBERT ORGANIZATION
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_WESTERN UNION 001
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_WESTERN UNION 002
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_WOLF CAMERA
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 001 SER 1-
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 001 SER 1A1-1A5
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-al SEC 002 SER 1A6-1A8
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 004 SER 1A17-1A19
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 005 SER 1A20 ONLY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_SUBPOENA
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 005 SER 1A28-1A49
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 006 SER 1A39 ONLY
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 007 SER 1A50-1A51
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 008 SER 1A52-1A78
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 009 SER 1A78
1662054-000 1233555 1B039_2020-01577-1 001
1662054-000 1233555 1B039_2020-01577-1 002
1662054-000 1233555 1B039_LETTER 1A65
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 10
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 11
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 12
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 16
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 17
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 18
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 19
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 20
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 5
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PRINTS
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_A SPLASH OF CLASS ARCHETYPE 2004
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_A WALK IN OUR SHOES-01
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_A WALK IN OUR SHOES-02
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_ALL EYES ON US ARCHETYPE 2003-01
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_ALL EYES ON US ARCHETYPE 2003-02
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_ARCHETYPE ROYAL PALM BEACH HIGH 02-01
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_ARCHETYPE ROYAL PALM BEACH HIGH 02-02
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_NOTHING BUT-AMALGAM 2004
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_PIECES OF OUR PUZZLE ARCHETYPE 2006
1662055-000 1233556 1B135 THE DAYS OF YORE JAVELIN 2004
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-10B PLACE HOLDER FOR PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-10G PLACE HOLDER FOR PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-10H PLACE HOLDER FOR PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-11A PHOTO
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-11B PHOTO
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-12A PHOTO
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-12B PHOTO
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-13 TWO VHS TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-14 FROM TEALA 2 DISC
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-15 ABC NOTE ABOUT PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-16 MESSAGE BOOK
1662055-000 1233556 1B0012 OF 4_ITEM-17 MESSAGE BOOK
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-1 RECORDS LISTED FOR EPSTEIN
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-10 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-11 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-12 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-13 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-14 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005 ITEM-15 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-16 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-17 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-18 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-19 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-2 EPSTEIN NOTE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-20 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-21 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-22 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-23 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-24 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-25 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-26 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-27 MEASSGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-28 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-29 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-3 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-30 RECORDS LISTED FOR EPSTEIN
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-4 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-5 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-6 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-7 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-8 BROKEN HANDLE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-9 BALANCE SHEET DEC 31 2004
1662055-000 1233556 1B005 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MISC MESSAGES
1662055-000 1233556 1B005 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN_RELATED ENTITIES
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_RECORDS LISTED FOR EPSTEIN
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ALBERTO
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_GHISLAINE MAXWELL
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_INVOICES
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM 28-29 MICRO TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-1
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-10A
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-10B
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-10C
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-10D
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-10E
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-10F
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-11A
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-11B
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-11C
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-11D
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-11E
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-12A
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-13
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-14 VHS
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-15 TRHU 17 MICRO TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-18 THRU 21 MICRO TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-2
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-22 MISC NOTES
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-23-24 MICRO TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-26 BROKEN HANDLE
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-27 MISC DOGS
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-27 TRANSACTION REGISTER
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-3
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-4
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-5
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-6
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-7
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-8
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEM-9
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_ITEMS-25 MISC NOTES
1662055-000 1233556 1B006 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MESSAGES
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_MAPQUEST
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_MEDICAL SUPPLIES
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_MORE LEGG ROOM
1662055-000 1233556 1B006_SCARLETTS
1662055-000 1233556 1B006
1662055-000 1233556 ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A-NY-3151227-1A SUPP SEC 001 SER 1A1-
1662055-000 1233556 ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A-NY-3151227-1A SUPP SEC 002
1662055-000 1233556 ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A-NY-3151227-1A SUPP SEC 003
1662055-000 1233556 ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A-NY-3151227-1A SUPP SEC 004
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 001_72-MM-113327-1A
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 001_JE AND GM 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 001_JE AND GM 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_1B-143
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 AIRMAIL
1662055-000 11233556IBOX 611_CALENDAR
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_CONFIDENTIAL CRIMINAL DIVISION
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_COWLES STORY A
.
1662055-000
.
1233556 BOX 611_ENVELOPE_EXECUTIVE SUMMARY OF REPORT
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_ENVELOPE_ORIGINAL
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_EPSTEIN JEFFREY
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_EPSTEIN_LETTER
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_EXHIBIT MM
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FAO SDNY
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 004
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 005
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 FOLDER 006
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 GHISLAINE MAXWELL
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_GRAND JURY SUBPOENA
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 6
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_IMAGES FROM MIAMI BOXES
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 JE DIAMOND APPRAISALS FROM SAFE
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_JEFFREY EPSTEIN
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_JEFFREY EPSTEIN SIGNIFICANT CASE NOTIF
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_MASSEUSES
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_MEDIA
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_NEW YORK OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_NEW YORK POLICE DEPARTMENT DOCS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_ E
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_POSTAGE PAID ENVELOPE
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_RED FOLDER 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_RED FOLDER 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_RED FOLDER 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_REPORTS_ACCURINTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 SCENE2GO
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 SUBPOENAS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_ VIDEO INTERVIEW
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_VICTIM NAME LIST
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 VICTIM SERVICES
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_YELLOW FOLDER 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_YELLOW FOLDER 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 004
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 005
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 006
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 007
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 008
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 009
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04 SUPOENA
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 08 SCHOOL RECORDS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 08 SUBPOENA TO TESTIFY BEFORE GRAND JURY
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 09 MASTER PHONE REPORT
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_5-21-2007 PHONE RECORDS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_727 BOEING-N9081E JEGE INC
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL_FLIGHT LOGS 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 CALL FLIGHT LOGS 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 CALL FLIGHT LOGS 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 INDIVIDUAL SUMMARY PAGES
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 DTG OPERATIONS DBA DOLLAR RENT A CAR
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_FAX
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_FAX ACTIVITY LOG
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 GULFSTREAM-N909JE HYPERION AIR INC
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 MISC DOCS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 MONEY TRANSFER RECORDS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 NATIONAL COMPREHENSIVE REPORTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_NEWS POSTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT DOCS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_PALM BEACH POLICE PROPERTY RECEIPTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 PASSENGER MANIFESTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 REPORT RESULTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11 COMPANY INFO _
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_SUBPOENA
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 001 SER 1-70
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 002 SER 71-175
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 003 SER 176-
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 014 SER 1A118-1A131
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 015 SER 1A132-1A141
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 016 SER 1A142-1A146
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM-108062-FF SEC 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM-108062-SBP SEC 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_SENTINEL REPORTS SERIALS 251-258
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_SERIAL REPORT FOR CASE 31E-MM-108062-SBP
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_31E-MM -108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_CIVIL
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_COMPUTERS REMOVED FROM RESIDENCE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_COURT ORDERS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13 GUGGENHEIM
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_EM PLOYEES-JE 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_EMPLOYEES-JE 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_FBI MIAMI TO
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13 FLIGHT RECORDS FAA-AMOC
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_FUGHT RECORDS JET AVIATION
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_FUGHT RECORDS MANIFESTS-DEFENSE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_FUGHTS-ICE TEC-INTL-DOM
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_GHISLAINE MAXWELL 12-25-61
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_MAGAZINES-NEWSPAPERS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_PALM BEACH PD PROPERTY RECEIPT 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_PALM BEACH PD PROPERTY RECEIPT 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_TECS-CUSTOMS ICE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_THE STATE OF FL COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_10-06-2005 CALL SUMMARY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_302S 31E-MM-108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_ADMIN SUBPOENAS-OUTSTANDING
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_ADMINISTRATIVE-FEDERAL SUBPOENAS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_CORPORATE RECORDS-JEGE_HYPERION
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_DEFENSE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_ECS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_EPSTEIN-WORK RELEASE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_EXPERTS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_FEDEX FBI NEW YORK
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_FOLDER 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15 FOLDER 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_FORFEITURE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GERALD B LEFCOURT FEBRUARY 1 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GERALD B LEFCOURT JANUARY 24 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_Gl TRANSCRIPTS-GJ LETTERS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT APRIL 24 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT FEB 27 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT FEB 6 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT MARCH 20 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT MAY 22 2007
1662486-000
1662486-000
BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT MAY 8 2007
BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPTS-OPERATION LEAP YEAR
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT' MAY 8 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT' PRIL 24 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GRAND JURY SUBPOENAS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_INSERTS 31E-MM -108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_INVOICES-EXPENSES
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_1E-AIRCRAFT PHOTOS MIAMI FLIGHT SURV
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_MESSAGE PAD
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_MISC FORMS 990-PF
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_ORDER-WHO BROUGHT WHO
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD PROPERTY RECEIPTS-PBPD PROPERTY REC
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD PROPERTY RECEIPTS-PROB CAUSE AFF
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD TRASH PULLS-TRASH PULLS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD-PROPERTY RECEIPTS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD-SEARCH WARRANT-STATE AND CDS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PHOTO LINE-UPS-PHOTO LINE-UPS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_RENTAL CARS DOLLAR_DTG-DTG OPS-DOLLAR
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-CASE NO 2006CF9454AXX
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-CASE NO 2008CF009381AXX
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-FL VS JEFFREY EPSTEIN
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-MISC COURT DOCS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-MISC POST-IT NOTES
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-PALM BEACH BOOKING CARD
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-SEARCH-AFFIDAVIT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-STATE CASE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE SUBPOENAS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_TRANSCRIPTS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LETTERS-FOLDER
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LETTERS-VICTIM LETTER
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LMERS-VICTIM-WITNESS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_WESTERN UNION-WESTERN UNION
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15 WORK RELEASE APPLICATION JEFFREY EPSTEIN
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 010 SER 1A78-86
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 011 SER 1A87-1A97
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 012 SER 1A98-1A108
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 013 SER 1A109-1A117
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 006 SER 1A21-1A37
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 007 SER 1A38-1A42
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 008 SER 1A43-
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20_GJ SUBPOENA LOGS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20 J TE TIMONYS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 2 1 TESTIMONY MULTIPLE-INDICTMENT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_1A-1C REPORT FOR CASE 31E-MM -108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 001 SER 1A1-1A9
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 002 SER 1A10 ONLY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 004 SER 1A27 ONLY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE0003 SER1A11-1A26 01
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE0003 SER1A11-1A26 02
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_1A-1C REPORT FOR CASE 31E-MM -108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_2009
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062 GRAND JURY MATERIAL
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-104
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-105
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-108
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-109
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-114
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-115
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_ATTYS LETTERS-MISC
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_CALL FREQUENCY FOR NUMBER 917-855-3363
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_CASE NO 2008CF009381A MOTION TO CLARIFY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_CHILD MOLESTERS-A BEHAVIORAL ANALYSIS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 DATA DEMONSTRATIVES KIRKLAND_ELUS LLP
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FEDEX ENVELOPE TO
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FOLDER 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FOLDER 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FOLDER 003
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_GERALD B LEFCOURT PC
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_GFtAND JURY SUBPOENAS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_JASON
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_MASTER
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_MISC DOCS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_NOTEPAD
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_PALM BEACH PD FAX TO
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_PALM BEACH PD INCIDENT REPORT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_PLEA IN THE CIRCUIT COURT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT PALM BEACH PD
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-INCIDENT REPORT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-JAN 24 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-JULY 25 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-JUNE 25 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-MISC NOTEPADS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_SERIAL 31E-MM-108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_SERIAL REPORT FOR CASE 31E-MM -108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_SEX OFFENDER CONTINUUM
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_T-MOBILE CALL LOGS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_T-MOBILE CALL LOGS-OUR COPY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 01 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 02 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 03 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 04 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 05 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 06 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 07 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 08 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 09 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 10 DISKS-NO BOX EXISTS DIGITAL
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 11 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 12 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 13 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 14 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 15 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 16 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 17 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 18 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 19 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 20 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 21 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 22 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_LITIGATION DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_WORKING COPY DISKS 1D2 1D3 1D4
1662056-000 1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serials 1-21
1662056-000 1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serials 101-150
1662056-000 1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serials 22-49
1662056-000 1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serials 50-99
1662056-000 1233557 0S0D-NY-3027571-ELA
1662056-000 1233557 050D-NY-3027571-FF
1662056-000 1233557 050D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 151-183
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 184-240
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 241-292
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 294-350
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 351-373
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 374-382
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 383-397
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 398-405
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 406-450
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 451-499
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 500-557
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 558-585
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 586-622
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 623-636
1662056-000 1233557 SOD-NY-3027571 Serials 637-660
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 661-706
1662056-000 1233557 009A-NY-3144791 Serials 1-7
1662056-000 1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serial 293
1662056-000 1233557 72-MM-1133217 Serials 1-61
1662056-000 1233557 72-MM-1133217 Serials 62-64
1662056-000 1233557 72-MM-113327-1A1-1A19
1662056-000 1233557 72-MM-113327-ELA Serials 1-3
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 1-65
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 115-119
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 120
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 121-146
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 147-179
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 64-97
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 98-114
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227-SBP Serials 1-6
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 180-211
1662057-000 1233558 050D-NY-3027571-FA
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 1-70 Part 1 (p1-250)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 1-70 Part 2 (p251-441)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 176-250
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 251-263
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 71-175 Part 1 (p1-248)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 71-175 Part 2 (p249-413)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 1 (p1-255)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 2 (p256-510)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 3 (p511-761)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 1_1 (p1-161)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 1_2 (p162-322)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 2
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 1 (p1-250)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 2 (p251-500)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 3 (p501-750)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 4 (p751-839)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 1 (p1-250)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 2 (p251-500)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 3 (p501-750)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 4 (p751-882)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 1(p1-250)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 2 (p251-500)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 3 (p501-663)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 1 (p1-174)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 2 (p175-348)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 3 (p349-521)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A80
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A82
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Part 1 (p1-211)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Part 2 (p212-422)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Part 3 (p423-633)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 1 (p1-250)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 2 (p251-500)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 3 (p501-750)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 4 (p751-925)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Part 1 (p1-181)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Part 2 (p182-362)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Part 3 (p363-576)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A1-1A9 Part 1(p1-250)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A1-1A9 Part 2 (p251-360)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Part 1 (p1-250)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Part 2 (p251-500)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Part 3 (p501-715)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A142-1A146
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A28-1A49 Part 1 (p1-213)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A28-1A49 Part 2 (p214-294)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 1 (p1-174)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 2 (p175-347)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 3 (p348-520)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A52-1A78 Part 1 (p1-229)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A52-1A78 Part 2 (p230-458)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A78 Pt. 2 -1A86 Part 1 (p1-149)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serials 1A78 Pt. 2 - 1A86 Part 2 (p150-341)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 1 (p1-250)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 2 (p251-500)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 3 (p501-716)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part 1 (p1-226)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part 2 (p227-424)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part 3 (p425-601)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-FF Serial 10
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-FF Serials 1-9
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-61 Serial 46
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-61 Serials 1-45
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serials 1-87 Part 1 (p1-249)
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serials 1-87 Part 2 (p250-286)
1662057-000 1233558 SOD-NY-3027571 GJ Serial 21
1662057-000 1233558 SOD-NY-3027571-6J Serial 7
1662057-000 1233558 SOD-NY-3027571-6J Serials 14-20
1662057-000 1233558 SOD-NY-3027571-6J Serials 1-6
1662057-000 1233558 SOD-NY-3027571-6J Serials 22-36
1662057-000 1233558 SOD-NY-3027571-6J Serials 37-39
1662057-000 1233558 SOD-NY-3027571-6J Serials 40-44
1662057-000 1233558 SOD-NY-3027571-6J Serials 8-13
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A20 Part 1 (p1-212)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-6J-1A Serial 1A20 Part 2 (p213-424)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A20 Part 3 (p425-636)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A28 Part 1 (p1-176)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A28 Part 2 (p177-351)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A28 Part 3 (p352-526)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A41 Part 1 (p1-250)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-61-1A Serial 1A41 Part 2 (p251-500)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM -108062-61-1A Serial 1A41 Part 3 (p501-750)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM -108062-61-1A Serial 1A41 Part 4 (p751-1000)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM -108062-61-1A Serial 1A41 Part 5 (p1001-1250)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-61-1A Serial 1A41 Part 6 (p1251-1500)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-6J-1A Serial 1A41 Part 7 (p1501-1750)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A41 Part 8 (p1751-2000)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A41 Part 9 (p2001-2156)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A43 Part 1_1 (p1-198)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A43 Part 1_2 (p199-395)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A43 Part 1_3 (p396-592)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -1A Serial 1A43 Part 2_1 (p1-160)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -3A Serial 1A43 Part 2_2 (p161-319)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-6J-1A Serial 40 Part 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-61-1A Serial 40 Part 2
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-61-1A Serial 40 Part 3
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-6J-1A Serial 40 Part 4
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-al -3A Serial 40 Part 5
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-6J-1A Serials 1A1-1A5 Part 1 (p1-225)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-61-1A Serials 1A1-1A5 Part 2 (p226-450)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM -108062-61-1A Serials 1A1-1A5 Part 3 (451-675)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM -108062-61-1A Serials 1A17-1A19 Part 1(p1-250)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM -108062-61-1A Serials 1A17-1A19 Part 2 (p251-462)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A21-1A30
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A38-1A42 Part 1 (p1-182)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A38-1A42 Part 2 (p183-366)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A6-1A8 Part 1 (p1-184)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A6-1A8 Part 2 (p185-371)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A6-1A8 Part 3 (p372-557)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A9-1A16 Part 1 (p1-249)
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A9-1A16 Part 2 (p250-476)
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 1-5
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 10-11
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 12-13
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 14-17
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 6 - 8
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 9
1662431-000 1233922 90C-NY-3154599-G1 (Serial 1-2)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 001 Serial 1-14 (212 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 002 Serial 14 Part 3 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 003 Serial 14 Part 1 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 004 Serial 14 Part 2 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 005 Serial 14 Part 4 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 006 Serial 14 Part 5 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 007 Serial 14 Part 6 Only (244 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 008 Serial 15-30 (225 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 009 Serial 31-50 (302 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 010 Serial 51-54 part 1 (311 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 011 Serial 54 Part 2 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 012 Serial 54 Part 3 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 013 Serial 54 Part 4 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 014 Serial 54 Part 5 Only (56 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 015 Serial 54-2 Part 1 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 016 Serial 54-2 Part 2 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 017 Serial 54-2 Part 3 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 018 Serial 54-2 Part 4 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 019 Serial 54-2 Part 5 Only (250 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 020 Serial 54-2 Part 6 Only (244 pages)
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 021 Serial 55 - 61 (19 pages)
Section Section-Padded TIF_Count TIF Running Count
1 01 5 5
1 01 26 31
1 01 26 57
1 01 31 88
1 01 3 91
1 01 3 94
1 01 1 95
1 01 2 97
1 01 2 99
1 01 5 104
1 01 2 106
1 01 2 108
1 01 2 110
1 01 2 112
1 01 2 114
1 01 109 223
1 01 29 252
1 01 8 260
1 01 2 262
1 01 2 264
1 01 9 273
1 01 11 284
1 01 59 343
1 01 32 375
1 01 11 386
1 01 273 659
1 01 172 831
1 01 234 1065
1 01 3 1068
1 01 6 1074
1 01 63 1137
1 01 19 1156
1 01 18 1174
1 01 15 1189
1 01 76 1265
1 01 70 1335
1 01 14 1349
1 01 18 1367
1 01 22 1389
1 01 32 1421
1 01 6 1427
1 01 81 1508
1 01 243 1751
1 01 15 1766
1 01 16 1782
1 01 13 1795
1 01 38 1833
1 01 212 2045
1 01 200 2245
1 01 64 2309
1 01 91 2400
1 01 54 2454
1 01 2 2456
1 01 14 2470
1 01 88 2558
1 01 20 2578
1 01 88 2666
1 01 104 2770
1 01 9 2779
1 01 111 2890
1 01 21 2911
1 01 14 2925
1 01 39 2964
1 01 6 2970
1 01 82 3052
1 01 8 3060
1 01 25 3085
1 01 31 3116
1 01 6 3122
1 01 41 3163
1 01 46 3209
1 01 102 3311
1 01 3 3314
1 01 2 3316
1 01 7 3323
1 01 20 3343
1 01 13 3356
1 01 34 3390
1 01 2 3392
1 01 2 3394
1 01 2 3396
1 01 1 3397
1 01 2 3399
1 01 12 3411
1 01 4 3415
1 01 2 3417
1 01 1 3418
1 01 1 3419
1 01 1 3420
1 01 1 3421
1 01 2 3423
1 01 25 3448
1 01 9 3457
1 01 23 3480
1 01 2 3482
1 01 1 3483
1 01 1 3484
1 01 2 3486
1 01 90 3576
1 01 41 3617
1 01 11 3628
1 01 24 3652
1 01 1 3653
1 01 11 3664
1 01 89 3753
1 01 8 3761
1 01 11 3772
1 01 159 3931
1 01 71 4002
1 01 24 4026
1 01 25 4051
1 01 124 4175
1 01 38 4213
1 01 13 4226
1 01 48 4274
1 01 72 4346
1 01 56 4402
1 01 68 4470
1 01 68 4538
1 01 18 4556
1 01 37 4593
1 01 44 4637
1 01 12 4649
1 01 7 4656
1 01 3 4659
1 01 3 4662
1 01 44 4706
1 01 4 4710
1 01 15 4725
1 01 19 4744
1 01 70 4814
1 01 46 4860
1 01 58 4918
1 01 44 4962
1 01 15 4977
1 01 4 4981
1 01 13 4994
1 01 4 4998
1 01 9 5007
1 01 22 5029
1 01 12 5041
1 01 19 5060
1 01 8 5068
1 01 14 5082
1 01 4 5086
1 01 10 5096
1 01 7 5103
1 01 13 5116
1 01 18 5134
1 01 13 5147
1 01 9 5156
1 01 10 5166
1 01 12 5178
1 01 6 5184
1 01 16 5200
1 01 8 5208
1 01 7 5215
1 01 2 5217
1 01 8 5225
1 01 10 5235
1 01 15 5250
1 01 5 5255
1 01 9 5264
1 01 2 5266
1 01 4 5270
1 01 14 5284
1 01 15 5299
1 01 6 5305
1 01 24 5329
1 01 9 5338
1 01 7 5345
1 01 15 5360
1 01 58 5418
1 01 15 5433
1 01 11 5444
1 01 7 5451
1 01 5 5456
1 01 3 5459
1 01 3 5462
1 01 4 5466
1 01 5 5471
1 01 16 5487
1 01 8 5495
1 01 6 5501
1 01 12 5513
1 01 3 5516
1 01 10 5526
1 01 5 5531
1 01 12 5543
1 01 5 5548
1 01 4 5552
1 01 10 5562
1 01 6 5568
1 01 5 5573
1 01 8 5581
1 01 5 5586
1 01 12 5598
1 01 5 5603
1 01 6 5609
1 01 19 5628
1 01 2 5630
1 01 8 5638
1 01 6 5644
1 01 2 5646
1 01 14 5660
1 01 13 5673
1 01 28 5701
1 01 52 5753
1 01 5 5758
1 01 5 5763
1 01 6 5769
1 01 9 5778
1 01 9 5787
1 01 2 5789
1 01 7 5796
1 01 5 5801
1 01 19 5820
1 01 5 5825
1 01 7 5832
1 01 2 5834
1 01 6 5840
1 01 8 5848
1 01 5 5853
1 01 18 5871
1 01 4 5875
1 01 3 5878
1 01 29 5907
1 01 17 5924
1 01 8 5932
1 01 2 5934
1 01 6 5940
1 01 9 5949
1 01 3 5952
1 01 11 5963
1 01 5 5968
1 01 15 5983
1 01 11 5994
1 01 9 6003
1 01 11 6014
1 01 8 6022
1 01 13 6035
1 01 2 6037
1 01 2 6039
1 01 3 6042
1 01 151 6193
1 01 113 6306
1 01 5 6311
1 01 19 6330
1 01 23 6353
1 01 71 6424
1 01 305 6729
1 01 2 6731
1 01 2 6733
1 01 3 6736
1 01 5 6741
1 01 2 6743
1 01 2 6745
1 01 3 6748
1 01 3 6751
1 01 375 7126
1 01 6 7132
1 01 275 7407
1 01 117 7524
1 01 37 7561
1 01 36 7597
1 01 245 7842
1 01 158 8000
1 01 13 8013
1 01 9 8022
1 01 55 8077
1 01 74 8151
1 01 55 8206
1 01 30 8236
1 01 1 8237
1 01 10 8247
1 01 47 8294
1 01 12 8306
1 01 36 8342
1 01 6 8348
1 01 6 8354
1 01 35 8389
1 01 60 8449
1 01 56 8505
1 01 52 8557
1 01 17 8574
1 01 590 9164
1 01 242 9406
1 01 47 9453
1 01 393 9846
1 01 137 9983
1 01 49 10032
1 01 52 10084
1 01 54 10138
1 01 189 10327
1 01 10 10337
1 01 114 10451
1 01 126 10577
1 01 176 10753
1 01 133 10886
1 01 269 11155
1 01 155 11310
1 01 97 11407
1 01 191 11598
1 01 100 11698
1 01 53 11751
1 01 122 11873
1 01 1 11874
1 01 255 12129
1 01 79 12208
1 01 224 12432
1 01 112 12544
1 01 14 12558
1 01 142 12700
1 01 3 12703
1 01 2 12705
1 01 2 12707
1 01 3 12710
1 01 4 12714
1 01 4 12718
1 01 2 12720
1 01 3 12723
1 01 2 12725
1 01 4 12729
1 01 2 12731
1 01 163 12894
1 01 81 12975
1 01 77 13052
1 01 56 13108
1 01 2 13110
1 01 3 13113
1 01 3 13116
1 01 82 13198
1 01 148 13346
1 01 52 13398
1 01 52 13450
1 01 19 13469
1 01 2 13471
1 01 2 13473
1 01 2 13475
1 01 2 13477
1 01 12 13489
1 01 2 13491
1 01 2 13493
1 01 2 13495
1 01 2 13497
1 01 2 13499
1 01 2 13501
1 01 2 13503
1 01 5 13508
1 01 2 13510
1 01 28 13538
1 01 2 13540
1 01 2 13542
1 01 3 13545
1 01 3 13548
1 01 3 13551
1 01 20 13571
1 01 21 13592
1 01 17 13609
1 01 3 13612
1 01 14 13626
1 01 11 13637
1 01 122 13759
1 01 5 13764
1 01 3 13767
1 01 2 13769
1 01 3 13772
1 01 34 13806
1 01 3 13809
1 01 5 13814
1 01 8 13822
1 01 2 13824
1 01 4 13828
1 01 13 13841
1 01 52 13893
1 01 2 13895
1 01 3 13898
1 01 4 13902
1 01 2 13904
1 01 2 13906
1 01 4 13910
1 01 3 13913
1 01 4 13917
1 01 5 13922
1 01 7 13929
1 01 4 13933
1 01 7 13940
1 01 26 13966
1 01 13 13979
1 01 22 14001
1 01 9 14010
1 01 10 14020
1 01 10 14030
1 01 21 14051
1 01 41 14092
1 01 4 14096
1 01 2 14098
1 01 19 14117
1 01 3 14120
1 01 34 14154
1 01 51 14205
1 01 9 14214
1 01 59 14273
1 01 32 14305
1 01 2 14307
1 01 61 14368
1 01 139 14507
1 01 10 14517
1 01 19 14536
1 01 14 14550
1 01 17 14567
1 01 14 14581
1 01 69 14650
1 01 10 14660
1 01 7 14667
1 01 164 14831
1 01 4 14835
1 01 30 14865
1 01 28 14893
1 01 21 14914
1 01 35 14949
1 01 41 14990
1 01 22 15012
1 01 23 15035
1 01 64 15099
1 01 20 15119
1 01 53 15172
1 01 314 15486
1 001 72 15558
2 002 107 15665
3 003 23 15688
4 004 41 15729
1 01 45 15774
1 001 7 15781
5 005 30 15811
1 01 7 15818
1 01 2 15820
1 01 5 15825
1 01 4 15829
1 01 7 15836
1 01 9 15845
1 01 12 15857
1 01 37 15894
1 01 17 15911
1 01 9 15920
1 01 9 15929
1 01 22 15951
1 01 7 15958
1 01 7 15965
1 01 12 15977
1 01 10 15987
1 01 8 15995
1 01 4 15999
1 01 2 16001
1 01 5 16006
1 01 17 16023
1 01 7 16030
1 01 15 16045
1 01 8 16053
1 01 19 16072
1 01 31 16103
1 01 5 16108
1 01 12 16120
1 01 9 16129
1 01 27 16156
1 01 14 16170
1 01 146 16316
1 01 12 16328
1 01 5 16333
1 01 11 16344
1 01 10 16354
1 01 10 16364
1 01 7 16371
1 01 7 16378
1 01 9 16387
1 01 10 16397
1 01 4 16401
1 01 7 16408
1 01 8 16416
1 01 2 16418
1 01 30 16448
1 01 4 16452
1 01 19 16471
1 01 9 16480
1 01 33 16513
1 01 6 16519
1 01 2 16521
1 01 2 16523
1 01 19 16542
1 01 6 16548
1 01 6 16554
1 01 20 16574
1 01 18 16592
1 01 7 16599
1 01 5 16604
1 01 21 16625
1 01 4 16629
1 01 30 16659
1 01 12 16671
1 01 18 16689
1 01 10 16699
1 01 8 16707
1 01 5 16712
1 01 6 16718
1 01 18 16736
1 01 6 16742
1 01 4 16746
1 01 4 16750
1 01 9 16759
1 01 13 16772
1 01 30 16802
1 01 19 16821
1 01 2 16823
1 01 2 16825
1 01 2 16827
1 01 2 16829
1 01 2 16831
1 01 2 16833
1 01 2 16835
1 01 2 16837
1 01 2 16839
1 01 2 16841
1 01 2 16843
1 01 3 16846
1 01 2 16848
1 01 2 16850
1 01 2 16852
1 01 2 16854
1 01 2 16856
1 01 2 16858
1 01 3 16861
1 01 2 16863
1 01 2 16865
1 01 2 16867
1 01 2 16869
1 01 46 16915
1 01 63 16978
1 01 3 16981
1 01 3 16984
1 01 3 16987
1 01 3 16990
1 01 3 16993
1 01 4 16997
1 01 3 17000
1 01 3 17003
1 01 2 17005
1 01 4 17009
1 01 2 17011
1 01 3 17014
1 01 3 17017
1 01 3 17020
1 01 5 17025
1 01 10 17035
1 01 7 17042
1 01 396 17438
1 01 1 17439
1 01 415 17854
1 01 459 18313
1 01 110 18423
1 01 98 18521
1 01 259 18780
1 01 56 18836
1 01 47 18883
1 01 242 19125
1 01 340 19465
1 01 86 19551
1 01 301 19852
1 01 16 19868
1 01 262 20130
1 01 348 20478
1 01 232 20710
1 01 332 21042
1 01 38 21080
1 01 175 21255
1 01 1 21256
1 01 196 21452
1 01 331 21783
1 01 336 22119
1 01 45 22164
1 01 137 22301
1 01 20 22321
1 01 158 22479
1 01 485 22964
1 01 19 22983
1 01 265 23248
1 01 270 23518
1 01 111 23629
1 01 190 23819
1 01 1 23820
1 01 2 23822
1 01 2 23824
1 01 6 23830
1 01 2 23832
1 01 2 23834
1 01 1 23835
1 01 1 23836
1 01 1 23837
1 01 2 23839
1 01 2 23841
1 01 2 23843
1 01 2 23845
1 01 2 23847
1 01 1 23848
1 01 2 23850
1 01 2 23852
1 01 3 23855
1 01 3 23858
1 01 1 23859
1 01 2 23861
1 01 1 23862
1 01 26 23888
1 01 3 23891
1 01 5 23896
1 01 1 23897
1 01 7 23904
1 01 4 23908
1 01 2 23910
1 01 2 23912
1 01 5 23917
1 01 61 23978
1 01 27 24005
1 01 2 24007
1 01 2 24009
1 01 3 24012
1 01 3 24015
1 01 2 24017
1 01 2 24019
1 01 1 24020
1 01 2 24022
1 01 2 24024
1 01 7 24031
1 01 4 24035
1 01 13 24048
1 01 15 24063
1 01 2 24065
1 01 7 24072
1 01 3 24075
1 01 2 24077
1 01 3 24080
1 01 5 24085
1 01 2 24087
1 01 2 24089
1 01 9 24098
1 01 10 24108
1 01 6 24114
1 01 15 24129
1 01 6 24135
1 01 6 24141
1 01 6 24147
1 01 10 24157
1 01 6 24163
1 01 6 24169
1 01 6 24175
1 01 43 24218
1 01 29 24247
1 01 6 24253
1 01 5 24258
1 01 8 24266
1 01 9 24275
1 01 6 24281
1 01 6 24287
1 01 3 24290
1 01 2 24292
1 01 389 24681
1 01 204 24885
1 01 73 24958
1 01 3 24961
1 01 13 24974
1 01 128 25102
1 01 8 25110
1 01 226 25336
1 01 641 25977
1 01 641 26618
1 01 22 26640
1 01 21 26661
1 01 9 26670
1 01 96 26766
1 01 60 26826
1 01 97 26923
1 01 29 26952
1 01 110 27062
1 01 446 27508
1 01 357 27865
1 01 305 28170
1 01 71 28241
1 01 3 28244
1 01 17 28261
1 01 22 28283
1 01 4 28287
1 01 3 28290
1 01 25 28315
1 01 4 28319
1 01 6 28325
1 001 207 28532
1 001 673 29205
2 002 562 29767
3 003 434 30201
4 004 442 30643
5 005 627 31270
1 01 9 31279
5 005 281 31560
6 006 663 32223
7 007 520 32743
8 008 456 33199
9 009 520 33719
1 01 37 33756
1 01 2 33758
1 01 5 33763
1 01 98 33861
1 01 129 33990
1 01 186 34176
1 01 137 34313
1 01 98 34411
1 01 77 34488
1 01 116 34604
1 01 193 34797
1 01 97 34894
1 01 174 35068
1 01 353 35421
1 01 92 35513
1 01 93 35606
1 01 109 35715
1 01 109 35824
1 01 88 35912
1 01 87 35999
1 01 95 36094
1 01 133 36227
1 01 158 36385
1 01 2 36387
1 01 2 36389
1 01 2 36391
1 01 3 36394
1 01 3 36397
1 01 3 36400
1 01 3 36403
1 01 3 36406
1 01 4 36410
1 01 3 36413
1 01 199 36612
1 01 190 36802
1 01 7 36809
1 01 3 36812
1 01 3 36815
1 01 3 36818
1 01 3 36821
1 01 3 36824
1 01 4 36828
1 01 3 36831
1 01 3 36834
1 01 3 36837
1 01 3 36840
1 01 3 36843
1 01 3 36846
1 01 3 36849
1 01 3 36852
1 01 3 36855
1 01 3 36858
1 01 3 36861
1 01 3 36864
1 01 3 36867
1 01 3 36870
1 01 3 36873
1 01 3 36876
1 01 6 36882
1 01 3 36885
1 01 3 36888
1 01 3 36891
1 01 4 36895
1 01 3 36898
1 01 15 36913
1 01 59 36972
1 01 13 36985
1 01 4 36989
1 01 3 36992
1 01 15 37007
1 01 6 37013
1 01 2 37015
1 01 1 37016
1 01 3 37019
1 01 3 37022
1 01 3 37025
1 01 1 37026
1 01 1 37027
1 01 15 37042
1 01 2 37044
1 01 1 37045
1 01 2 37047
1 01 2 37049
1 01 37 37086
1 01 312 37398
1 01 2 37400
1 01 2 37402
1 01 9 37411
1 01 2 37413
1 01 2 37415
1 01 26 37441
1 01 2 37443
1 01 2 37445
1 01 40 37485
1 01 19 37504
1 01 1 37505
1 01 1 37506
1 01 2 37508
1 01 1 37509
1 01 1 37510
1 01 2 37512
1 01 1 37513
1 01 4 37517
1 01 46 37563
1 01 10 37573
1 01 1 37574
1 01 3 37577
1 01 4 37581
1 01 20 37601
1 001 123 37724
2 002 118 37842
3 003 84 37926
4 004 191 38117
1 01 485 38602
1 01 407 39009
1 01 367 39376
1 01 4 39380
1 01 23 39403
1 01 16 39419
1 01 49 39468
1 01 23 39491
1 01 13 39504
1 01 9 39513
1 01 31 39544
1 01 23 39567
1 01 11 39578
1 01 2 39580
1 01 32 39612
1 01 9 39621
1 01 11 39632
1 01 13 39645
1 01 60 39705
1 01 125 39830
1 01 3 39833
1 01 74 39907
1 01 6 39913
1 01 33 39946
1 01 3 39949
1 01 25 39974
1 01 43 40017
1 01 10 40027
1 01 83 40110
1 01 35 40145
1 01 9 40154
1 01 14 40168
1 01 3 40171
1 01 57 40228
1 01 34 40262
1 01 144 40406
1 01 16 40422
1 01 4 40426
1 01 49 40475
1 01 55 40530
1 01 5 40535
1 01 13 40548
1 01 48 40596
1 01 7 40603
1 01 9 40612
1 01 6 40618
1 01 23 40641
1 01 21 40662
1 01 11 40673
1 01 14 40687
1 01 8 40695
1 01 22 40717
1 01 68 40785
1 01 13 40798
1 01 27 40825
1 01 11 40836
1 01 40 40876
1 01 60 40936
1 01 40 40976
1 01 37 41013
1 01 15 41028
1 01 4 41032
1 01 8 41040
1 01 6 41046
1 01 60 41106
1 01 1 41107
1 01 29 41136
1 01 11 41147
1 01 20 41167
1 01 10 41177
1 01 57 41234
1 01 313 41547
1 01 764 42311
1 01 419 42730
1 01 298 43028
1 01 587 43615
1 01 111 43726
1 01 132 43858
1 01 373 44231
1 01 12 44243
1 01 86 44329
1 01 301 44630
1 01 16 44646
1 01 232 44878
1 01 262 45140
1 01 348 45488
1 01 334 45822
1 01 38 45860
1 01 197 46057
1 01 133 46190
1 01 268 46458
1 01 356 46814
1 01 356 47170
1 01 107 47277
1 01 73 47350
1 01 2 47352
1 01 2 47354
1 01 2 47356
1 01 2 47358
1 01 67 47425
1 01 47 47472
1 01 73 47545
1 01 2 47547
1 01 2 47549
1 01 55 47604
1 01 61 47665
1 01 2 47667
1 01 37 47704
1 01 2 47706
1 01 93 47799
1 01 53 47852
1 01 2 47854
1 01 2 47856
1 01 136 47992
1 01 46 48038
1 01 28 48066
1 01 4 48070
1 01 2 48072
1 01 2 48074
1 01 103 48177
1 01 110 48287
1 01 266 48553
1 01 337 48890
1 01 96 48986
1 01 96 49082
1 01 44 49126
1 01 20 49146
1 01 309 49455
1 01 156 49611
1 01 484 50095
1 01 19 50114
1 01 418 50532
1 01 270 50802
1 01 111 50913
1 01 152 51065
1 01 124 51189
1 01 32 51221
1 01 81 51302
1 01 52 51354
1 01 238 51592
1 01 288 51880
1 01 201 52081
1 01 84 52165
1 01 20 52185
1 01 21 52206
1 01 4 52210
1 01 173 52383
1 01 120 52503
1 01 44 52547
1 01 42 52589
1 01 92 52681
1 01 409 53090
1 01 111 53201
1 01 69 53270
1 01 6 53276
1 01 30 53306
1 01 25 53331
1 01 70 53401
1 001 423 53824
2 002 421 54245
3 003 211 54456
14 014 629 55085
15 015 710 55795
16 016 136 55931
1 001 29 55960
1 001 285 56245
1 01 48 56293
1 01 3 56296
1 01 76 56372
1 01 103 56475
1 01 10 56485
1 01 55 56540
1 01 37 56577
1 01 90 56667
1 01 139 56806
1 01 204 57010
1 01 2 57012
1 01 127 57139
1 01 8 57147
1 01 89 57236
1 01 84 57320
1 01 32 57352
1 01 55 57407
1 01 90 57497
1 01 45 57542
1 01 205 57747
1 01 94 57841
1 01 97 57938
1 01 54 57992
1 01 90 58082
1 01 30 58112
1 01 3 58115
1 01 29 58144
1 01 3 58147
1 01 69 58216
1 01 75 58291
1 01 30 58321
1 01 5 58326
1 01 62 58388
1 01 187 58575
1 01 1 58576
1 01 122 58698
1 01 177 58875
1 01 13 58888
1 01 10 58898
1 01 2 58900
1 01 5 58905
1 01 11 58916
1 01 90 59006
1 01 23 59029
1 01 2 59031
1 01 53 59084
1 01 36 59120
1 01 2 59122
1 01 8 59130
1 01 35 59165
1 01 136 59301
1 01 23 59324
1 01 12 59336
1 01 14 59350
1 01 2 59352
1 01 134 59486
1 01 6 59492
1 01 135 59627
1 01 23 59650
1 01 39 59689
1 01 2 59691
1 01 7 59698
1 01 51 59749
1 01 31 59780
1 01 17 59797
1 01 29 59826
1 01 50 59876
1 01 88 59964
1 01 4 59968
1 01 4 59972
1 01 59 60031
1 01 52 60083
1 01 2 60085
1 01 115 60200
1 01 27 60227
1 01 111 60338
1 01 60 60398
1 01 24 60422
1 01 24 60446
10 010 334 60780
11 011 687 61467
12 012 609 62076
62743 13 013 667
6 006 489 63232
7 007 359 63591
8 008 591 64182
1 01 63 64245
1 01 401 64646
1 01 404 65050
1 01 402 65452
1 001 343 65795
2 002 762 66557
4 004 883 67440
3 003 316 67756
3 003 202 67958
1 01 8 67966
1 01 239 68205
1 01 16 68221
1 01 3 68224
1 01 4 68228
1 01 1 68229
1 01 7 68236
1 01 3 68239
1 01 1 68240
1 01 21 68261
1 01 52 68313
1 01 37 68350
1 01 22 68372
1 01 41 68413
1 01 14 68427
1 01 369 68796
1 01 38 68834
1 01 11 68845
1 01 3 68848
1 01 11 68859
1 01 3 68862
1 01 50 68912
1 01 3 68915
1 01 38 68953
1 01 4 68957
1 01 6 68963
1 01 93 69056
1 01 19 69075
1 01 49 69124
1 01 61 69185
1 01 45 69230
1 01 188 69418
1 01 60 69478
1 01 4 69482
1 01 16 69498
1 01 3 69501
1 01 2 69503
1 01 14 69517
1 01 96 69613
1 01 13 69626
1 01 70 69696
1 01 87 69783
1 01 86 69869
1 01 93 69962
1 01 19 69981
1 01 80 70061
1 01 4 70065
1 01 21 70086
1 01 21 70107
1 01 15 70122
1 01 242 70364
1 01 48 70412
1 01 76 70488
1 01 5 70493
1 01 9 70502
1 01 11 70513
1 01 3 70516
1 01 3 70519
1 01 3 70522
1 01 3 70525
1 01 3 70528
1 01 3 70531
1 01 7 70538
1 01 3 70541
1 01 3 70544
1 01 3 70547
1 01 3 70550
1 01 5 70555
1 01 3 70558
1 01 9 70567
1 01 3 70570
1 01 3 70573
1 01 5 70578
1 01 9 70587
1 01 3 70590
1 01 7 70597
1 01 3 70600
1 01 113 70713
1 01 151 70864
1 01 137 71001
1 01 114 71115
1 01 2 71117
1 01 221 71338
1 01 147 71485
1 01 108 71593
1 01 227 71820
1 01 416 72236
1 01 544 72780
1 01 244 73024
1 01 232 73256
1 01 226 73482
1 01 269 73751
1 01 182 73933
1 01 206 74139
1 01 489 74628
1 01 492 75120
1 01 467 75587
1 01 485 76072
1 01 499 76571
1 01 376 76947
1 01 21 76968
1 01 1 76969
1 01 258 77227
1 01 8 77235
1 01 286 77521
1 01 16 77537
1 01 494 78031
1 01 46 78077
1 01 536 78613
1 01 501 79114
1 01 499 79613
1 01 476 80089
1 01 498 80587
1 01 167 80754
1 01 482 81236
1 01 157 81393
1 01 250 81643
1 01 171 81814
1 01 210 82024
1 01 153 82177
1 01 248 82425
1 01 165 82590
1 01 255 82845
1 01 255 83100
1 01 251 83351
1 01 161 83512
1 01 161 83673
1 01 200 83873
1 01 250 84123
1 01 250 84373
1 01 250 84623
1 01 89 84712
1 01 250 84962
1 01 250 85212
1 01 250 85462
1 01 132 85594
1 01 250 85844
1 01 250 86094
1 01 163 86257
1 01 174 86431
1 01 174 86605
1 01 173 86778
1 01 91 86869
1 01 202 87071
1 01 211 87282
1 01 211 87493
1 01 211 87704
1 01 250 87954
1 01 250 88204
1 01 250 88454
1 01 175 88629
1 01 181 88810
1 01 181 88991
1 01 214 89205
1 01 250 89455
1 01 110 89565
1 01 250 89815
1 01 250 90065
1 01 215 90280
1 01 131 90411
1 01 213 90624
1 01 81 90705
1 01 174 90879
1 01 173 91052
1 01 173 91225
1 01 229 91454
1 01 229 91683
1 01 149 91832
1 01 192 92024
1 01 250 92274
1 01 250 92524
1 01 216 92740
1 01 226 92966
1 01 198 93164
1 01 177 93341
1 01 1 93342
1 01 30 93372
1 01 19 93391
1 01 208 93599
1 01 249 93848
1 01 37 93885
1 01 831 94716
1 01 771 95487
1 01 187 95674
1 01 67 95741
1 01 263 96004
1 01 768 96772
1 01 164 96936
1 01 483 97419
1 01 212 97631
1 01 212 97843
1 01 212 98055
1 01 176 98231
1 01 175 98406
1 01 175 98581
1 01 250 98831
1 01 250 99081
1 01 250 99331
1 01 250 99581
1 01 250 99831
1 01 250 100081
1 01 250 100331
1 01 250 100581
1 01 156 100737
1 01 198 100935
1 01 197 101132
1 01 197 101329
1 01 160 101489
1 01 159 101648
1 01 877 102525
1 01 500 103025
1 01 509 103534
1 01 500 104034
1 01 501 104535
1 01 225 104760
1 01 225 104985
1 01 225 105210
1 01 250 105460
1 01 212 105672
1 01 99 105771
1 01 182 105953
1 01 184 106137
1 01 184 106321
1 01 187 106508
1 01 186 106694
1 01 249 106943
1 01 227 107170
1 01 274 107444
1 01 361 107805
1 01 165 107970
1 01 210 108180
1 01 112 108292
1 01 387 108679
1 01 84 108763
1 01 212 108975
1 01 250 109225
1 01 250 109475
1 01 250 109725
1 01 250 109975
1 01 250 110225
1 01 244 110469
1 01 225 110694
1 01 302 110996
1 01 308 111304
1 01 250 111554
1 01 250 111804
1 01 250 112054
1 01 56 112110
1 01 250 112360
1 01 250 112610
1 01 250 112860
1 01 250 113110
1 01 250 113360
1 01 244 113604
1 01 19 113623
Directory
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B005_BLUEPRINTS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B005_BLUEPRINTS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B005_BLUEPRINTS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B005_BLUEPRINTS 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B010_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020 MONTY MISC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B020_EMAIL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B020_JE 50 BDAY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_ LSJ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B020_LARGE PORTRAITS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_MACKLA 11-03
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_MIS AFRICA PICS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B020_NUDES 00-24
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B020_PHOTOS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_PHOTOS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_RED TRI-FOLD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B020_SLIDES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7anA1B08ELEMPLOYEE LIST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am\1B114_BLUEPRINTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7amUB114_LITTLE SAINT JAMES US VIRGIN ISLANDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7amUB114_LITTLE ST JAMES ISLAND
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7amUB114_LITTLE ST JAMES-S ISLAND CARIBBEAN SEA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7amUB114_MISC SKETCHES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7amUB135_A YEAR TO REMEMBER ARCHETYPE 2005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7amUB135_LAKE WORTH COMMUNITY HIGH SCHOOL 200
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG W-TIFA3.12.2025 - 7am \1B135_TAKE A 2ND LOOK AMALGAM 2005
Case Number Case_ID File Section Section-Padded
I 662053-000 1233554 18005_BLUEPRINTS 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B005_BLUEPRINTS 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B005_BLUEPRINTS 003 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B005_BLUEPRINTS 004 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B010_MISC DOGS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 MONTY MISC 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_EMAIL 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 JE 50 BDAY 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 _LARGE PORTRAITS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_MACKLA 11-03 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_MIS AFRICA PICS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_NUDES 00-24 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_PHOTOS 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_PHOTOS 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_RED TRI-FOLD 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B020_SLIDES 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B088_EMPLOYEE LIST 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B114_BLUEPRINTS 1
01 1662053-000 1233554 1B114_LITTLE SAINT JAMES US VIRGIN ISLANDS
1662053-000 1233554 1B114_LITTLE ST JAMES ISLAND 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B114_LITTLE ST JAM ES-S ISLAND CARIBBEAN SEA 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B114_MISC SKETCHES 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B135_A YEAR TO REMEMBER ARCHETYPE 2005 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B135 _LAKE WORTH COMMUNITY HIGH SCHOOL 2005 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B135 TAKE A 2ND LOOK AMALGAM 2005 1 01
TIF_Count TIF Running Count
5 5
26 31
26 57
31 88
3 91
3 94
1 95
2 97
2 99
5 104
2 106
2 108
2 110
2 112
2 114
109 223
29 252
8 260
2 262
2 264
9 273
11 284
59 343
32 375
11 386
273 659
172 831
234 1065
Directory
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_ALAN DERSHOWITZ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_ANAL WAND FORK HANDLE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_ARREST NOTICE TO APPEAR
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_CAD CALLS TO JES HOUSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_DAVID RODGERS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_DELORATORS AT HOUSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_EPSTEIN PLANES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_EPSTIEN PASSENGER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_FOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_IMPORTANT MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_JET INFO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2 ELL PHONE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_MISC DOC 006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_MISC DOGS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 007
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_MY SPACE 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_MY SPACE 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_NEW YORK POST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 00;
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 00?
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG M-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2am \1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG M-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH PO RTMENT 00!
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PHONE RECORD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_PHOTO LINE UPS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_PROPERTY REC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_RENTAL AGREEMENT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_STATE OF FLORIDA 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_STATE OF FLORIDA 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_SUB REQUESTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2_SUB RESULTS_ REQUESTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2amUB140 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_TRASH PULL 9-21-05
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 1 OF 2_TRASH RESULTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 2 OF 2_100-PAR 11-6-06 TRASH
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA13140 2 OF 2_2006 RECENT INTEL ON EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 2 OF 2_EPSTEIN TRIAL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA1B140 2 OF 2_FOLDER 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2am UB140 2 OF 2_FOLDER 006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2am UB140 2 OF 2_MEDIA UNTIL 5-08
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA13140 2 OF 2_MEDIA UP TO 10-6.09
Wds-fs-prod \prod \DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 2anA113140 2 OF 2_MISC DOGS 003
Case Number Case_ID File Section Section-Padded
I 662053-000 1233554 18140 1 OF 2_ALAN DERSHOWITZ 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_ANAL WAND FORK HANDLE 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_ARREST NOTICE TO APPEAR 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_CAD CALLS TO JES HOUSE 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_DAVID RODGERS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_DELORATORS AT HOUSE 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_EPSTEIN PLANES 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_EPSTIEN PASSENGER 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_FOLDER 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_FOLDER 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_FOLDER 003 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_IMPORTANT MESSAGE 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2 JET INFO 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2 ELL PHONE 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOC 006 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 003 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 004 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 005 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18140 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 007 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MY SPACE 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_MY SPACE 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_NEW YORK POST 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 003 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B1401 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 004 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B1401 OF 2_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 005 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PHONE RECORD 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PHOTO LINE UPS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_PROPERTY REC 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B1401 OF 2_RENTAL AGREEMENT 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_STATE OF FLORIDA 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_STATE OF FLORIDA 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_SUB REQUESTS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_SUB RESULTS_ REQUESTS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_ 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_TRASH PULL 9-21-05 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 1 OF 2_TRASH RESULTS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_100-PAR 11-6-06 TRASH 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_2006 RECENT INTEL ON EPSTEIN 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2 EPSTEIN TRIAL 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_FOLDER 004 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_FOLDER 006 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_MEDIA UNTIL 5-08 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_MEDIA UP TO 10-6-09 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B140 2 OF 2_MISC DOCS 003 1 01
TIF_Count TIF Running Count
3 3
6 9
63 72
19 91
18 109
15 124
76 200
70 270
14 284
18 302
22 324
32 356
6 362
81 443
243 686
15 701
16 717
13 730
38 768
212 980
200 1180
64 1244
91 1335
54 1389
2 1391
14 1405
88 1493
20 1513
88 1601
104 1705
9 1714
111 1825
21 1846
14 1860
39 1899
6 1905
82 1987
8 1995
25 2020
31 2051
6 2057
41 2098
46 2144
102 2246
3 2249
2 2251
7 2258
20 2278
13 2291
34 2325
Directory
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B006_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B007_PHOTOGRAPHS OF A LIVING ROOM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B014_OOH BY JE JOUE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B016_COSTUMES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B017_PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B021_PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B021.4 -03
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B023_PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B024_BRONZE SCULPTURE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9amUB027_STUFFED DOG
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B086 NOTEPAD 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B086 NOTEPAD 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B089_MISC DOC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B090
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9anA1B090_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B090_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B094_NOTEPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B100_EMPLOYEE CONTACT LIST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B101_PHOTOGRAPH
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B104_2021-00585-1 ITEM 1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B105 BOAT LOG 2019
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B113_BOAT TRIP LOGS_EMPLOYEE LISTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am\1B125_CARLOS AND
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9amUB126 NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am \181.37_PHOTO-TO JEFFREY
Case Number CASE_ID File Section Section-Padded TIF_Count
I 662053-000 1233554 18006_MISC DOCS 1 01 2
2 1662053-000 1233554 1B007_PHOTOGRAPHS OF A LIVING ROOM 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B014_OOH BY JE JOUE 1 01 2
1662053-000 1233554 1B016_COSTUMES 1 01 1
1662053-000 1233554 1B017_PHOTOS 1 01 2
1662053-000 1233554 1B021_PHOTOS 1 01 12
1662053-000 1233554 1B021 LSJ 6-03 1 01 4
1662053-000 1233554 1B023_PHOTOS 1 01 2
1662053-000 1233554 1B024_BRONZE SCULPTURE 1 01 1
1662053-000 1233554 1B027_STUFFED DOG 1 01 1
1662053-000 1233554 1B086 _LSJ NOTEPAD 001 1 01 1
1662053-000 1233554 1B086 _LSJ NOTEPAD 002 1 01 1
1662053-000 1233554 1B089_MISC DOC 1 01 2
1662053-000 1233554 18090 _LSJ 1 01 25
1662053-000 1233554 1B090_MISC DOCS 1 01 9
1662053-000 1233554 1B090_NOTEBOOK 1 01 23
1662053-000 1233554 1B094_NOTEPAD 1 01 2
1662053-000 1233554 1B100_EMPLOYEE CONTACT LIST 1 01 1
1662053-000 1233554 1B101_PHOTOGFtAPH 1 01 1
1662053-000 1233554 1B104_2021-00585-1 ITEM 1 1 01 2
1662053-000 1233554 1B105 _LSJ AND GSJ BOAT LOG 2019 1 01 90
1662053-000 1233554 1B113_BOAT TRIP LOGS_EMPLOYEE LISTS 1 01 41
1662053-000 1233554 1B125_CARLOS AND 1 01 11
1662053-000 1233554 1B126 _LSJ NOTEBOOK 1 01 24
1662053-000 1233554 1B137_PHOTO-TO JEFFREY 1 01 1
TIF Running Count
Directory
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_BANK STATEMENTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_BINDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_BSAR TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_CDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_COURT DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_DISKS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_DVDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_EPSTEIN_OPEN SOURCE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_GJ MATERIAL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 4
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 5
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 6
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 7
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 8
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 001 THUMBDRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 1 1A1-1A14
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 10 1A130-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 111A151-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 12 1A171-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 2 1A15-1A26
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 3 1A27-1A39
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 4 1A40-1A49
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 5 1A50-1A62
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 61A63-1A75
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 71A76-1A93
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 8 1A94-1A11
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 9 1A111-1A1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 PROFFER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 ARREST OF JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_FEDEX DELIVERY CONFIRMATION
NTERVIEW
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 ITEMS FROM EPSTEIN RETURNED T
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 LARRY VISOSKI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2 _LETTER FRO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 9am PIAMBox 1 OF 2_RECEIPT FOR PROPERTY
Wds-fs-prod \prod \DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFA3.12.2025 - 9am P1-1A\BOX 1 OF 2_USB OF PHOTOS PROVIDED BY BRA
Case Number CASE_ID File Section
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_BANK STATEMENTS 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_BINDER 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_BSAR TRANSCRIPT 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_CDS 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_0OURT DOCS 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_DEPARTM ENT OF JUSTICE 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_DISKS 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_DVDS 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_EPSTEIN_OPEN SOURCE 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER 001 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER 002 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_GJ MATERIAL 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 1 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 2 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 3 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 4 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 5 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 6 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 7 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_FOLDER_NOTEBOOK 8 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_MISC DOCS 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001_NOTEBOOK 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 001 THUMBDRIVE 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 1 1A1-1A14 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 10 1A130-1A150 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 11 1A151-1A170 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 12 1A171-1A195 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 2 1A15-1A26 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 3 1A27-1A39 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 41A40 -1A49 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 5 1A50-1A62 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 6 1A63-1A75 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 7 1A76-1A93 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 8 1A94-1A110 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_1A SUPPLEMENT VOL 9 1A111-1A129 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 PROFFER 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 1
1662053-000 I 1233554 I BOX 1 OF 2_ I 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 _FEDEX DELIVERY CONFIRMATION 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 _ITEMS FROM EPSTEIN RETURNED TO LAWYER 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_LARRY VISOSKI 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2 1
1662053-000 .1233554 . BOX 1 OF 2_LETTER FRONnKE NY LICENSE 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_RECEIPT FOR PROPERTY 1
1662053-000 1233554 BOX 1 OF 2_USB OF PHOTOS PROVIDED BY BRAD EDWARDS 1
Section-Padded TIF_Count TIF Running Count
01 11 11
01 89 100
01 8 108
01 11 119
01 159 278
01 71 349
01 24 373
01 25 398
01 124 522
01 38 560
01 13 573
01 48 621
01 72 693
01 56 749
01 68 817
01 68 885
01 18 903
01 37 940
01 44 984
01 12 996
01 7 1003
01 3 1006
01 3 1009
01 44 1053
01 4 1057
01 15 1072
01 19 1091
01 70 1161
01 46 1207
01 58 1265
01 44 1309
01 15 1324
01 4 1328
01 13 1341
01 4 1345
01 9 1354
01 22 1376
01 12 1388
01 19 1407
01 8 1415
01 14 1429
01 4 1433
01 10 1443
01 7 1450
01 13 1463
01 18 1481
01 13 1494
01 9 1503
01 10 1513
01 12 1525
01 6 1531
01 16 1547
01 8 1555
01 7 1562
01 2 1564
01 8 1572
01 10 1582
01 15 1597
01 5 1602
01 9 1611
01 2 1613
01 4 1617
01 14 1631
01 15 1646
01 6 1652
01 24 1676
01 9 1685
01 7 1692
01 15 1707
01 58 1765
01 15 1780
01 11 1791
01 7 1798
01 5 1803
01 3 1806
01 3 1809
01 4 1813
01 5 1818
01 16 1834
01 8 1842
01 6 1848
01 12 1860
01 3 1863
01 10 1873
01 5 1878
01 12 1890
01 5 1895
01 4 1899
01 10 1909
01 6 1915
01 5 1920
01 8 1928
01 5 1933
01 12 1945
01 5 1950
01 6 1956
01 19 1975
01 2 1977
01 8 1985
01 6 1991
01 2 1993
01 14 2007
01 13 2020
01 28 2048
01 52 2100
01 5 2105
01 5 2110
01 6 2116
01 9 2125
01 9 2134
01 2 2136
01 7 2143
01 5 2148
01 19 2167
01 5 2172
01 7 2179
01 2 2181
01 6 2187
01 8 2195
01 5 2200
01 18 2218
01 4 2222
01 3 2225
01 29 2254
01 17 2271
01 8 2279
01 2 2281
01 6 2287
01 9 2296
01 3 2299
01 11 2310
01 5 2315
01 15 2330
01 11 2341
01 9 2350
01 11 2361
01 8 2369
01 13 2382
01 2 2384
01 2 2386
01 3 2389
Directory
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pnA1B001_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pnA1B004_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 1pnAlE1009_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 1pnA1B076_PASSPORT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 1pnA1B091_PHOTO ALBUM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 1pnA1B092_FOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 1pnAlE1092_THE WIRTANEN TENNIS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm UB108_VOICE RECORDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm UB110_PAPER WITH PASSWORDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 1pm ‘1B138_CD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 2pm ‘18015_MISC PERSONAL ITEMS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 2pm ‘18073_HARD DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 2pnA1B074_HARD DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 2pm\1B083_IPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 2pm\1B084_IPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_DEFENSE ARGUMENT N
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN JEFFREY INVES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN V CITIBANK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_FBI MIAMI ATTN SA NE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_FLIGHT ACTIVITY LOGS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_FLIGHT ACTIVITY LOGS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_FLIGHT MANIFEST LIST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_FLIGHT RECORDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03 JEFFREY EPSTEIN CALL (
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 007
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 008
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_PARTIAL I-REPORT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_ PHONE ANAL'
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_USDC SOUTHERN DISTF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_USDC SOUTHERN DISTF
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 03_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_4-01-03 TO 1-01-04
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A\ BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 2 OF 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 3 OF 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 BOOK 1 OF 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS COPIEL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05 3-08-04 TO E
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05 03-05 TO 04-0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - 4PM P2-1A \ BOX MM 05 1-04 TO 3-05
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_7378
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14 EPSTEIN 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_EPSTEIN 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_EPSTEIN ACCURINT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FGJ PRESENTATION
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FOLDER 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_FOLDER 005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_GIRLS INVOLVED
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_GRAND JURY EXHIBITS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_INDICTMENT-CHART-TESTIM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 10
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 12-13
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 14
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 15
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 16
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 18
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 7
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 9
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JANE DOES 1-19
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_PBPD-INCIDENT REPORT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_PBPD-PROBABLE CAUSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_PBPD-PROPERTY RECEIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_PHOTOGRAPHS AND MP JAN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_RAW DATA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 144
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave005 ‘3.12.2025 - P2-1A \ BOX MM 14_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave005\3.12.2025 - P2-1A\BOX MM 14_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT C
Case Number CASE _ID File Section Section-Padded
1662053-000 1233554 18001_NOTEBOOK 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18004_NOTEBOOK 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18009_MISC DOCS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18076_PASSPORT 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18091_PHOTO ALBUM 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18092_FOLDER 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18092_THE WIRTANEN TENNIS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B108_VOICE RECORDER 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B110_PAPER WITH PASSWORDS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 1B138_CD 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18015_MISC PERSONAL ITEMS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18073_HARD DRIVE 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18074_HARD DRIVE 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18083_IPAD 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 18084_IPAD 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_ 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_DEFENSE ARGUMENT NOTES 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN JEFFREY INVESTIGATION 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_EPSTEIN V CITIBANK 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_FBI MIAMI ATTN 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_FLIGHT ACTIVITY LOGS 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_FLIGHT ACTIVITY LOGS 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_FLIGHT MANIFEST LIST 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_FLIGHT RECORDS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03 _JEFFREY EPSTEIN CALL CHARTS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_MISC DOCS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_ 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 003 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 004 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 005 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 006 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 007 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_NOTEPAD 008 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_PARTIAL I-REPORT 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 0 PHONE ANALYSIS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FL 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FL 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 03_ 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_4-01-03 TO 1-01-04 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 2 OF 3 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 3 OF 3 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_ITEM 2 BOOK 1 OF 3 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS 003 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 05_MESSAGE PADS COPIED 01-23-2008 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_7378 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_EPSTEIN 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_EPSTEIN 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_EPSTEIN ACCURINT 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FGI PRESENTATION 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 002 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 003 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 004 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_FOLDER 005 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_GIRLS INVOLVED 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_GRAND JURY EXHIBITS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_INDICTMENT-CHART-TESTIMONY 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 10 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 12-13 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 14 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 15 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 16 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 18 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 2 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 3 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 7 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOE NO 9 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JANE DOES 1-19 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_JEFFREY EPSTEIN 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_PBPD-INCIDENT REPORT 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_PBPD-PROBABLE CAUSE 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_PBPD-PROPERTY RECEIPTS 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_PHOTOGRAPHS AND MP JANE DOE NO 6-13 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_RAW DATA 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 144 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FL 001 1 01
1662053-000 1233554 BOX MM 14_USDC SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FL 002 1 01
TIF_Count TIF Running Count
151 151
113 264
5 269
19 288
23 311
71 382
305 687
2 689
2 691
3 694
5 699
2 701
2 703
3 706
3 709
375 1084
6 1090
275 1365
117 1482
37 1519
36 1555
245 1800
158 1958
13 1971
9 1980
55 2035
74 2109
55 2164
30 2194
1 2195
10 2205
47 2252
12 2264
36 2300
6 2306
6 2312
35 2347
60 2407
56 2463
52 2515
17 2532
590 3122
242 3364
47 3411
393 3804
137 3941
49 3990
52 4042
54 4096
189 4285
10 4295
114 4409
126 4535
176 4711
133 4844
269 5113
155 5268
97 5365
191 5556
100 5656
53 5709
122 5831
1 5832
255 6087
79 6166
224 6390
112 6502
14 6516
142 6658
3 6661
2 6663
2 6665
3 6668
4 6672
4 6676
2 6678
3 6681
2 6683
4 6687
2 6689
163 6852
81 6933
77 7010
56 7066
2 7068
3 7071
3 7074
82 7156
148 7304
52 7356
52 7408
Directory
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B022_BAG OF CDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B038_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B039_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B040_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B044_SIM CARD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B045_11 DISC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B046_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B047_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B048_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B049_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PIA1B050_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PIA1B051_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PIA1B052_FLASH DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B055_IPHONE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B056_HARD DRIVE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B063_BAG OF CDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B064_VOICE RECORDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B066_VOICE RECORDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B067_IPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B068_IPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PIA1B071_CELLPHONE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm PIA1B075_BINDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B075_BINDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B078_BINDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B078_BINDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B078_BLUE BINDER 1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B078_BLUE BINDER 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1\1B095_NOTEBOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1 \16141_BUNDLE OF CDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1 \16142_CASSETTE TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1 \16142_MICROCASSETTES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1 \13142_VHS TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1005_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024 FLASH CARDS PUT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_COPIES 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_COPIES 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1024_MISC PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1025_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1027_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1064_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1092_COPY
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1219_COPY DVDS FROt
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-1245_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-257_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-368_05-1024_COPY 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-368_05-1024_COPY 00:
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-378_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-379_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-380_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-381_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-382_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-383_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-384_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-385_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-386_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-874_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-878_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-901_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-915_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-941_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-943_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_05-944_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_06-24_COPY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_CDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_ENVELOPE_PICTURES-NAN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_EPSTIEN CIVIL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FAX
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDER-PROBABLE CAUSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDER_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDER_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_FOLDER_SUB REQUESTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_NATIONAL COMPLIANCE CI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_OFFICIAL POLICE PHOTOGF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH INVESTIGATIt
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH PAPERS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH PD PROPERT1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH POLICE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFs\Wave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAV
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_UNITED STATES DISTRICT C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG M-TIFAWave006 U.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 002_USAO VISITOR
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-61 SEC 00
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003_TRANSFER OF EPSTEIN CAS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_ALPHA ZONE SEARCH PA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_ARREST OF GHISLAINE IV
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_BRAVO ZONE SEARCH P1
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 003
31E-NY-3027571-al SEC 00 -
_31E-NY-3027571-al SEC 00
_31E-NY-3027571-61 SEC 00
_31E-NY-3027571-61 SER 1A
_SOD-NY-3027571 SEC 0015
- SOD-NY-3027571-GL SEC 0t
_BLUEPRINTS
CERTIFIED COPY OF BIRTH —
DISKS —
FLATLEY — MAXWELL SECURITY FOOT
CERTIFIE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_DAVID RODGERS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_EVIDENCE LOG SIGN-IN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_FARO LASER SCAN DATA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_FARO LASER SCAN DATA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_FLIGHT LOGS
- 8pm P1-1A\BOX 2 OF 2_CHARLIE_DELTA ZONES
\ \ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13003_ITEM 7-8 MICRO_CASSETTE TAPI
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13003_ITEM-1 MICRO TAPE
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B003_ITEM-10 CASSETTE
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B003_ITEM-11-12-13-14-15 MISC NOTI
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\18003 ITEM-5 MICRO TAPE
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13003_ITEM-6 FOLDER WITH 6 PHOTOS
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13003_ITEM-9 DISC
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13003_ITEMS 2-3-4 MICRO TAPES
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13003_ITEMS-16-17-18_MISC INVOICES
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13003_ITEMS-19 THRU 24 EPTSTEIN NO
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13003_MISC NOTES AND RECEIPTS
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13004_ITEM-1 NOTE
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-10 NOTE
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-11 MESSAGE
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-12 MESSAGE
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2\18004 ITEM-13 NOTE
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \13004_ITEM-14 MESSAGE
\\ ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-15 MESSAGE
\\ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-16 MESSAGE
\\ids-fs-prod \ prod \ Dal \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-17 MESSAGE
\\ids-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIMWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-18 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004 ITEM-19 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004 ITEM-2 JETBLUE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004 ITEM-20 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004 ITEM 21 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM 22 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-3 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004 ITEM-5 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004 ITEM 6 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004 ITEM-7 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004 ITEM-8 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM-9 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ITEM4 NOTE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004_ CONTACT LIS1
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B004 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MESSAGES
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 1TEM-12
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM-1 VHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008_ITEM 11 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008_ITEM-13 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008_ITEM-14 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM 15 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM-16 VHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM-17 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM-18 MESSAGE MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008_ITEM-19 DISC
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008_ITEM-2 VHS-DISC
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM-3 VHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM-4 VHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM 5 VHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM 6 VHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008_ITEM 7 VHS-DISC
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008_ITEM-8 16 DISC PALM BEACH PD
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2 \ 1B008 ITEM-9-10 SUPOENA-CINGULAR
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 01 PALM BEACH COUNTY I
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 01 VIC FOLDERS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 01 VICTIM BINDER 001
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 0l_VICTIM BINDER 002
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 01_VICTIM BINDER 003
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 03_
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 03 TELEPHONE REPORTS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 03_US DOJ US ATTORNEY S
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.12.2025 - 8pm P2-1A\BOX MM 06_PHONE RECORDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-2A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-2B
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-2C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-4
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-S
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-6
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-7
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-8
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9B
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9D
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9E
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4 ITEM-9F
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9G
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9H
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 1 OF 4_ITEM-91 PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_2 TWIN TORPEDOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-24
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-25
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-26
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-27
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-28
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-29
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_ITEM-30A 308 30C 30D .
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 3 OF 4_MISC DOCS
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-18 AT T
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-18 NORTH OCEAN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-18 ROCK MIX
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-19 MINI DV CASSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-20 BURLWOOD C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-20 PHOT BOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-21A PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-21B PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-22A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-22B PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-23A RECEIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM-23B SOAP ON THE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM23B PENI-SOAPS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B001 4 OF 4_ITEM23B SEXY LOVING S
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-31
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-32
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-33
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-34A-K
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-35
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-37
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-38
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-39
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-40
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-41
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-42
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-43
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B002 1 OF 2_ITEM-44
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B002 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM 20-21 MICRO TAPE-PALM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM-1 THRU 3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-10 EMAILS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-12 VHS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-13 VHS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-14 DISC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-15 THRU 17 VHS-MICRO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-18 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-19 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-22 MICRO TAPE_MESSAG
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-4 EARNINGS STATEMENT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM-4 RECEIPTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B007_ITEM-
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM-5 FLOOR PLANS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-6 DRAWN BY HALL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-7 MESSAGES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B007_ITEM-8 VHS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B007_ITEM-9 MICRO TAPE
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B009_AN INVITATION TO POETRY
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 \ 1B009_VICTORIA SECRET BRA
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B010 MASSAGE FOR DUMMIES
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B019 3 PHONE MESSAGE BOOKS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2\1B020_MESSAGE BOOK
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_ADULT VIDEO WARS.
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02 BEAR STEARNS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02 BROWARD CENTER F
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02 COLONIAL BANCGRO
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANK 001
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANK 002
Wds-fs-proA  prod\  DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 0
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_DTG OPERATIONS DB
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_EXTRA TOUCH FLOW
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_FEDERAL EXPRESS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_FINANCIAL COMPANI
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_FOLDER
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_HYPERION-JEGE BUSI
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_JEGE HYPERION-HELI
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02 JEGE-HYPERION MAI%
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_JP MORGAN CHASE 0
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_JP MORGAN CHASE 0
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_LARRYVISOSKI W2 r
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 02_PALM BEACH COUNT
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_REIMER EMPLOYMErs
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_RPBHS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_THE SHUBERT ORGAF
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_WESTERN UNION 00:
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_WESTERN UNION 00;
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 02_WOLF CAMERA
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1 !,
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1 !,
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1 !,
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1 !,
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1 !,
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1 !,
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 16_SUBPOENA
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P2 - 1A \BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P3 \ 1B039_2020-01577-1 001
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave006\3.13.2025 - 10am P3 \ 1B039_2020-01577-1 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\ 3-TIFAWave006 ‘3.13.2025 - 10am PA1B039_LETTER 1A65
.13.2025 - 10am P2 - lA \BOX MM 0
Case Number CASE _ID File Section
1662054-000 1233555 1B022_BAG OF CDS 1
1662054-000 1233555 1B038_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18039_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18040_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18044_SIM CARD 1
1662054-000 1233555 18045_11 DISC 1
1662054-000 1233555 18046_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18047_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18048_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18049_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18050_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18051_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18052_FLASH DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18055_IPHONE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18056_HARD DRIVE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18063_BAG OF CDS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18064_VOICE RECORDER 1
1662054-000 1233555 18066_VOICE RECORDER 1
1662054-000 1233555 18067_IPAD 1
1662054-000 1233555 18068_IPAD 1
1662054-000 1233555 18071_CELLPHONE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18075_BINDER 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 18075_BINDER 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 18078_BINDER 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 18078_BINDER 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 18078_BLUE BINDER 1 1
1662054-000 1233555 18078_BLUE BINDER 2 1
1662054-000 1233555 18095_NOTEBOOK 1
1662054-000 1233555 18141_BUNDLE OF CDS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18142_CASSETTE TAPES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18142_MICROCASSETTES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18142_VHS TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1005_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024 FLASH CARDS PUT ON CDS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPIES 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPIES 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_COPY 003 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1024_MISC PHOTOS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1025_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1027_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002 05-1064 COPY 1
1662054-000
1662054-000
1233555 BOX 002_05-1092_COPY 1
1233555 BOX 002 05-1219 COPY DVDS FROM PB50 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-1245_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-257_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-368_05-1024_COPY 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-368_05-1024_COPY 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-378_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-379_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-380_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-381_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-382_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-383_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-384_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-385_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-386_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-874_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-878_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-901_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-915_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-941_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-943_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_05-944_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_06-24_COPY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_CDS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_ENVELOPE_PICTURES-NAMES 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_EPSTIEN CIVIL 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FAX 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FOLDER 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FOLDER-PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT 1
1 1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FOLDER_MISC DOCS
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FOLDER j 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_FOLDER_SUB REQUESTS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_NATIONAL COMPLIANCE CENTER 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_OFFICIAL POLICE PHOTOGRAPHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH INVESTIGATION 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH PAPERS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH PD PROPERTY RECEIPT 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH POLICE 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002 PHOTOS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT 1
1662054-000 1123355516OX 002_UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 002_USAO VISITOR 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-al SEC 001 SER 1A1-1A15 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-al SEC 002 SER 1A16-1A29 2
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-al SEC 003 SER 1A30-1A44 3
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-GJ SEC 004 SER 1A45-1A61 4
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_31E-NY-3027571-GJ SER 1A26 ONLY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_50D-NY-3027571 SEC 001 SER 1A64 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_50D-NY-3027571-GJ SEC 005 SER 1A62- 5
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_BLUEPRINTS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_CERTIFIED COPY OF BIRTH CERTIFICATE 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_DISKS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_FLATLEY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_MAXWELL SECURITY FOOTAGE 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003_ CERTIFIED BIRTH CERT 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 003 TRANSFER OF EPSTEIN CASE FILES TO WFO 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2 PROFFER 9-10-19 1
1662054-000 1123355516OX 2 OF 2_ALPHA ZONE SEARCH PAPERWORK I 1
1662054-000 1123355516OX 2 OF 2_ARREST OF GHISLAINE MAXWELL I 1
1662054-000 1123355516OX 2 OF 2_BRAVO ZONE SEARCH PAPERWORK I 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_CHARLIE_DELTA ZONES SEARCH PAPERWORK 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_DAVID RODGERS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_ 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_EVIDENCE LOG_SIGN-IN LOG_MAP NOTES 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_FARO LASER SCAN DATA 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_FARO LASER SCAN DATA 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_ 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX 2 OF 2_FLIGHT LOGS 1
1 1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEM 7-8 MICRO_CASSETTE TAPES
1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEM-1 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEM-10 CASSETTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEM-11-12-13-14-15 MISC NOTES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEM-5 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEM-6 FOLDER WITH 6 PHOTOS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEM-9 DISC 1
1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEMS 2-3-4 MICRO TAPES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEMS-16-17-18_MISC INVOICES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18003_ITEMS-19 THRU 24 EPTSTEIN NOTES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18003_MISC NOTES AND RECEIPTS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-1 NOTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-10 NOTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-11 MESSAGE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-12 MESSAGE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-13 NOTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-14 MESSAGE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-15 MESSAGE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-16 MESSAGE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004 ITEM-17 MESSAGE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004 ITEM-18 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-19 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-2 JETBLUE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-20 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-21 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-22 JEFFREY E EPSTEIN 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-3 NOTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-5 MESSAGE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-6 NOTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-7 NOTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-8 NOTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM-9 NOTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ITEM4 NOTE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_ CONTACT LIST 1
1662054-000 1233555 18004_JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MESSAGES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_1TEM-12 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-1 VHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-11 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-13 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-14 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-15 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-16 VHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-17 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-18 MESSAGE_MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-19 DISC 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-2 VHS-DISC 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-3 VHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-4 VHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-5 VHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-6 VHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-7 VHS-DISC 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-8 16 DISC PALM BEACH PD 1
1662054-000 1233555 18008_ITEM-9-10 SUPOENA-CINGULAR WIRELESS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 01_PALM BEACH COUNTY RA 31E-MM 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 0l_VIC FOLDERS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 01_VICTIM BINDER 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 01_VICTIM BINDER 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 01_VICTIM BINDER 003 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 0 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 03 TELEPHONE REPORTS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 03_US DOJ US ATTORNEY SOUTHERN DIST FL 1
1 1662054-000 1123355516OX MM 06_PHONE RECORDS
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-1 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-2A 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-2B 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-2C 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-3 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-4 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-5 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-6 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-7 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-8 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9A 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-98 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4 ITEM-9C 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9D 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9E 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9F 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9G 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9H 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 1 OF 4_ITEM-9I PHOTO 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 3 OF 4_2 TWIN TORPEDOS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 3 OF 4_ITEM-24 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 3 OF 4_ITEM-25 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 3 OF 4_ITEM-26 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 3 OF 4_ITEM-27 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 3 OF 4_ITEM-28 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 3 OF 4_ITEM-29 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 3 OF 4_ITEM-30A 30B 30C 30D 30E 30F 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 3 OF 4_MISC DOCS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM-18 AT_T 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM-18 NORTH OCEAN WAY 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM-18 ROCK MIX 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM-19 MINI DV CASSETTE TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM-20 BURLWOOD COLLECTION 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM-20 PHOT BOOK 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM-21A PHOTO 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM-21B PHOTO 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM-22A 1
1662054-000 1233555 180014 OF 4_ITEM-22B PHOTO 1
1662054-000 1233555 180014 OF 4_ITEM-23A RECEIPT 1
1662054-000 1233555 180014 OF 4_ITEM-23B SOAP ON THE ROPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 180014 OF 4_ITEM23B PENI-SOAPS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18001 4 OF 4_ITEM23B SEXY LOVING SOAP 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-31 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-32 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-33 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-34A-K 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-35 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-37 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-38 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-39 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-40 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-41 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-42 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-43 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_ITEM-44 1
1662054-000 1233555 18002 1 OF 2_MISC DOCS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM 20-21 MICRO TAPE-PALM BEACH POLICE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-1 THRU 3 MICRO TAPES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-10 EMAILS_ 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-12 VHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-13 VHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-14 DISC 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-15 THRU 17 VHS-MICRO TAPES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-18 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-19 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-22 MICRO TAPE_MESSAGE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-4 EARNINGS STATEMENT 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-4 RECEIPTS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-5 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-5 FLOOR PLANS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-6 DRAWN BY 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-7 MESSAGES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-8 VHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18007_ITEM-9 MICRO TAPE 1
1662054-000 1233555 18009_AN INVITATION TO POETRY 1
1662054-000 1233555 18009_VICTORIA SECRET BRA 1
1662054-000 1233555 18010 MASSAGE FOR DUMMIES 1
1662054-000 1233555 18019_3 PHONE MESSAGE BOOKS 1
1662054-000 1233555 18020_MESSAGE BOOK 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02 W2 STATEMENTS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_ADULT VIDEO WAREHOUSE 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_BEAR STEARNS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_BROWARD CENTER FOR THE PERFORMING ARTS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANCGROUP 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANK 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_COLONIAL BANK 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02 ECORDS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_DTG OPERATIONS DBA DOLLAR RENT A CAR 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_EXTRA TOUCH FLOWERS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_FEDERAL EXPRESS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_FINANCIAL COMPANIES-GERALD B LEFCOURT 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_FOLDER 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_HYPERION-JEGE BUSINESS RECORDS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02 RECORDS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02 _AGE HYPERION-HELICOPTER 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02 JEGE-HYPERION MANIFESTS LOGBOOK 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_JP MORGAN CHASE 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_JP MORGAN CHASE 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_LARRY VISOSKI W2 STATEMENTS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_PALM BEACH COUNTY HEALTH DEPARTMENT 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_REIMER EMPLOYMENT AGENCY 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_RPBHS 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_THE SHUBERT ORGANIZATION 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_WESTERN UNION 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_WESTERN UNION 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 02_WOLF CAMERA 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1 SEC 001 SER 1- 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1 SEC 001 SER 1A1-1A5 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 002 SER 1A6-1A8 2
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16 3
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 004 SER 1A17-1A19 4
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_31E-MM -108062-G1 SEC 005 SER 1A20 ONLY 5
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 16_SUBPOENA 1
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 005 SER 1A28-1A49 5
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 006 SER 1A39 ONLY 6
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 007 SER 1A50-1A51 7
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 008 SER 1A52-1A78 8
1662054-000 1233555 BOX MM 19_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 009 SER 1A78 9
1662054-000 1233555 18039_2020-01577-1 001 1
1662054-000 1233555 18039_2020-01577-1 002 1
1662054-000 1233555 18039_LETTER 1A65 1
Section-Padded TIF_Count TIF Running Count
01 19 19
01 2 21
01 2 23
01 2 25
01 2 27
01 12 39
01 2 41
01 2 43
01 2 45
01 2 47
01 2 49
01 2 51
01 2 53
01 5 58
01 2 60
01 28 88
01 2 90
01 2 92
01 3 95
01 3 98
01 3 101
01 20 121
01 21 142
01 17 159
01 3 162
01 14 176
01 11 187
01 122 309
01 5 314
01 3 317
01 2 319
01 3 322
01 34 356
01 3 359
01 5 364
01 8 372
01 2 374
01 4 378
01 13 391
01 52 443
01 2 445
01 3 448
01 4 452
01 2 454
01 2 456
01 4 460
01 3 463
01 4 467
01 5 472
01 7 479
01 4 483
01 7 490
01 26 516
01 13 529
01 22 551
01 9 560
01 10 570
01 10 580
01 21 601
01 41 642
01 4 646
01 2 648
01 19 667
01 3 670
01 34 704
01 51 755
01 9 764
01 59 823
01 32 855
01 2 857
01 61 918
01 139 1057
01 10 1067
01 19 1086
01 14 1100
01 17 1117
01 14 1131
01 69 1200
01 10 1210
01 7 1217
01 164 1381
01 4 1385
01 30 1415
01 28 1443
01 21 1464
01 35 1499
01 41 1540
01 22 1562
01 23 1585
01 64 1649
01 20 1669
01 53 1722
01 314 2036
001 72 2108
002 107 2215
003 23 2238
004 41 2279
01 45 2324
001 7 2331
005 30 2361
01 7 2368
01 2 2370
01 5 2375
01 4 2379
01 7 2386
01 9 2395
01 12 2407
01 37 2444
01 17 2461
01 9 2470
01 9 2479
01 22 2501
01 7 2508
01 7 2515
01 12 2527
01 10 2537
01 8 2545
01 4 2549
01 2 2551
01 5 2556
01 17 2573
01 7 2580
01 15 2595
01 8 2603
01 19 2622
01 31 2653
01 5 2658
01 12 2670
01 9 2679
01 27 2706
01 14 2720
01 146 2866
01 12 2878
01 5 2883
01 11 2894
01 10 2904
01 10 2914
01 7 2921
01 7 2928
01 9 2937
01 10 2947
01 4 2951
01 7 2958
01 8 2966
01 2 2968
01 30 2998
01 4 3002
01 19 3021
01 9 3030
01 33 3063
01 6 3069
01 2 3071
01 2 3073
01 19 3092
01 6 3098
01 6 3104
01 20 3124
01 18 3142
01 7 3149
01 5 3154
01 21 3175
01 4 3179
01 30 3209
01 12 3221
01 18 3239
01 10 3249
01 8 3257
01 5 3262
01 6 3268
01 18 3286
01 6 3292
01 4 3296
01 4 3300
01 9 3309
01 13 3322
01 30 3352
01 19 3371
01 2 3373
01 2 3375
01 2 3377
01 2 3379
01 2 3381
01 2 3383
01 2 3385
01 2 3387
01 2 3389
01 2 3391
01 2 3393
01 3 3396
01 2 3398
01 2 3400
01 2 3402
01 2 3404
01 2 3406
01 2 3408
01 3 3411
01 2 3413
01 2 3415
01 2 3417
01 2 3419
01 46 3465
01 63 3528
01 3 3531
01 3 3534
01 3 3537
01 3 3540
01 3 3543
01 4 3547
01 3 3550
01 3 3553
01 2 3555
01 4 3559
01 2 3561
01 3 3564
01 3 3567
01 3 3570
01 5 3575
01 10 3585
01 7 3592
01 396 3988
01 1 3989
01 415 4404
01 459 4863
01 110 4973
01 98 5071
01 259 5330
01 56 5386
01 47 5433
01 242 5675
01 340 6015
01 86 6101
01 301 6402
01 16 6418
01 262 6680
01 348 7028
01 232 7260
01 332 7592
01 38 7630
01 175 7805
01 1 7806
01 196 8002
01 331 8333
01 336 8669
01 45 8714
01 137 8851
01 20 8871
01 158 9029
01 485 9514
01 19 9533
01 265 9798
01 270 10068
01 111 10179
01 190 10369
01 1 10370
01 2 10372
01 2 10374
01 6 10380
01 2 10382
01 2 10384
01 1 10385
01 1 10386
01 1 10387
01 2 10389
01 2 10391
01 2 10393
01 2 10395
01 2 10397
01 1 10398
01 2 10400
01 2 10402
01 3 10405
01 3 10408
01 1 10409
01 2 10411
01 1 10412
01 26 10438
01 3 10441
01 5 10446
01 1 10447
01 7 10454
01 4 10458
01 2 10460
01 2 10462
01 5 10467
01 61 10528
01 27 10555
01 2 10557
01 2 10559
01 3 10562
01 3 10565
01 2 10567
01 2 10569
01 1 10570
01 2 10572
01 2 10574
01 7 10581
01 4 10585
01 13 10598
01 15 10613
01 2 10615
01 7 10622
01 3 10625
01 2 10627
01 3 10630
01 5 10635
01 2 10637
01 2 10639
01 9 10648
01 10 10658
01 6 10664
01 15 10679
01 6 10685
01 6 10691
01 6 10697
01 10 10707
01 6 10713
01 6 10719
01 6 10725
01 43 10768
01 29 10797
01 6 10803
01 5 10808
01 8 10816
01 9 10825
01 6 10831
01 6 10837
01 3 10840
01 2 10842
01 389 11231
01 204 11435
01 73 11508
01 3 11511
01 13 11524
01 128 11652
01 8 11660
01 226 11886
01 641 12527
01 641 13168
01 22 13190
01 21 13211
01 9 13220
01 96 13316
01 60 13376
01 97 13473
01 29 13502
01 110 13612
01 446 14058
01 357 14415
01 305 14720
01 71 14791
01 3 14794
01 17 14811
01 22 14833
01 4 14837
01 3 14840
01 25 14865
01 4 14869
01 6 14875
001 207 15082
001 673 15755
002 562 16317
003 434 16751
004 442 17193
005 627 17820
01 9 17829
005 281 18110
006 663 18773
007 520 19293
008 456 19749
009 520 20269
01 37 20306
01 2 20308
01 5 20313
Directory
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PHOTO 10
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PHOTO 11
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PHOTO 12
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PHOTO 16
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PHOTO 17
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PHOTO 18
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PHOTO 19
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PHOTO 20
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PHOTO 5
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B019_MISC PRINTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1\1B135_A SPLASH OF CLASS ARCHETYPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_A WALK IN OUR SHOES-01
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_A WALK IN OUR SHOES-02
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_ALL EYES ON US ARCHETYPE 200
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_ALL EYES ON US ARCHETYPE 200
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_ARCHETYPE ROYAL PALM BEACH
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_ARCHETYPE ROYAL PALM BEACH
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \16135_NOTHING BUT-AMALGAM 2004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P1 \13135_PIECES OF OUR PUZZLE ARCHET'i
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PIA1B135_THE DAYS OF YORE JAVELIN 2001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-10B PLACE HOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4 ITEM-10G PLACE HOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-10H PLACE HOLDER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-11A PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-11B PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-12A PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-12B PHOTO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-13 TWO VHS TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-14 FROM TE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-15 ABC NOTE ABOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-16 MESSAGE BOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B001 2 OF 4_ITEM-17 MESSAGE BOOK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005 ITEM-1 RECORDS LISTED FOR EP!
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-10 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-11 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-12 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005_ITEM-13 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005_ITEM-14 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005_ITEM-15 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005_ITEM-16 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005 ITEM-17 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005_ITEM-18 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005_ITEM-19 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG M-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005_ITEM-2 EPSTEIN NOTE
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave007 U.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005_ITEM-20 MESSAGE
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005_ITEM-21 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BO05_ITEM-22 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-23 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-24 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-25 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-26 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-27 MEASSGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-28 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BO05_ITEM-29 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-3 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-30 RECORDS LISTED FOR E
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-4 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-5 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-6 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_ITEM-7 MESSAGE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-8 BROKEN HANDLE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1BOO5_ITEM-9 BALANCE SHEET DEC 31
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005 _JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MISC MESSA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B005 _JEFFREY E EPSTEIN_RELATED EN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B005_RECORDS LISTED FOR EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_GHISLAINE MAXWELL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_INVOICES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM 28-29 MICRO TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-10A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-10B
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-10C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-10D
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-10E
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-10F
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-11A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-11B
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-11C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-11D
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-11E
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-12A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-13
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-14 VHS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2 \ 1B006_ITEM-15 TRHU 17 MICRO TAPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-18 THRU 21 MICRO TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-22 MISC NOTES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-23-24 MICRO TAPES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2 \ 1B006_ITEM-26 BROKEN HANDLE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2 \ 1B006_ITEM-27 MISC DOCS
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG W-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2 \ 1B006_ITEM-27 TRANSACTION REGISTE
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_ITEM-4
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-5
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-6
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-7
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-8
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEM-9
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_ITEMS-25 MISC NOTES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006 _JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MESSAGES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_MAPQUEST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_MEDICAL SUPPLIES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006_MORE LEGG ROOM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm PA1B006_SCARLETTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2\1B006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P3\ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P3\ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave007\3.13.2025 - 4pm P3\ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave007 U.13.2025 - 4pm P3\ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A
Case Number CASE _ID File
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 10
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 11
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 12
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 16
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 17
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 18
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 19
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 20
1662055-000 1233556 1B019_MISC PHOTO 5
1662055-000 1233556 18019_MISC PRINTS
1662055-000 1233556 18135_A SPLASH OF CLASS ARCHETYPE 2004
1662055-000 1233556 18135_A WALK IN OUR SHOES-01
1662055-000 1233556 18135_A WALK IN OUR SHOES-02
1662055-000 1233556 18135_ALL EYES ON US ARCHETYPE 2003-01
1662055-000 1233556 18135_ALL EYES ON US ARCHETYPE 2003-02
1662055-000 1233556 18135_ARCHETYPE ROYAL PALM BEACH HIGH 02-01
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_ARCHETYPE ROYAL PALM BEACH HIGH 02-02
1662055-000 1233556 1B135_NOTHING BUT-AMALGAM 2004
1662055-000 1233556 18135_PIECES OF OUR PUZZLE ARCHETYPE 2006
1662055-000 1233556 18135_THE DAYS OF YORE JAVELIN 2004
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-10B PLACE HOLDER FOR PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-10G PLACE HOLDER FOR PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-10H PLACE HOLDER FOR PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-11A PHOTO
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-11B PHOTO
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-12A PHOTO
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-12B PHOTO
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-13 TWO VHS TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-14 FROM TEALA 2 DISC
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4 ITEM-15 ABC NOTE ABOUT PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-16 MESSAGE BOOK
1662055-000 1233556 18001 2 OF 4_ITEM-17 MESSAGE BOOK
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-1 RECORDS LISTED FOR EPSTEIN
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-10 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-11 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-12 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-13 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-14 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-15 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-16 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-17 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 1B005_ITEM-18 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005 ITEM-19 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-2 EPSTEIN NOTE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-20 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005 ITEM-21 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-22 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-23 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-24 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005 _ITEM-25 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005 _ITEM-26 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005 _ITEM-27 MEASSGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-28 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-29 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-3 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-30 RECORDS LISTED FOR EPSTEIN
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-4 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-5 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-6 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-7 MESSAGE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-8 BROKEN HANDLE
1662055-000 1233556 18005_ITEM-9 BALANCE SHEET DEC 31 2004
1662055-000 1233556 18005 _JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MISC MESSAGES
1662055-000 1233556 18005 _JEFFREY E EPSTEIN_RELATED ENTITIES
1662055-000 1233556 18005_RECORDS LISTED FOR EPSTEIN
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ALBERTO
1662055-000 1233556 18006_GHISLAINE MAXWELL
1662055-000 1233556 18006_INVOICES
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM 28-29 MICRO TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-1
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-10A
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-108
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-10C
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-10D
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-10E
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-10F
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-11A
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-11B
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-11C
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-11D
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-11E
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-12A
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-13
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-14 VHS
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-15 TRHU 17 MICRO TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-18 THRU 21 MICRO TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-2
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-22 MISC NOTES
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-23-24 MICRO TAPES
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-26 BROKEN HANDLE
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-27 MISC DOCS
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-27 TRANSACTION REGISTER
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-3
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-4
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-5
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-6
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-7
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-8
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEM-9
1662055-000 1233556 18006_ITEMS-25 MISC NOTES
1662055-000 1233556 18006 _JEFFREY E EPSTEIN MESSAGES
1662055-000 1233556 18006_MAPQUEST
1662055-000 1233556 18006_MEDICAL SUPPLIES
1662055-000 1233556 18006_MORE LEGG ROOM
1662055-000 1233556 18006_SCARLETTS
1662055-000 1233556 18006
1662055-000 1233556 ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A-NY-3151227-1A SUPP SEC 001 SER 1A1-
1662055-000 1233556 ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A-NY-3151227-1A SUPP SEC 002
1662055-000 1233556 ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A-NY-3151227-1A SUPP SEC 003
1662055-000 1233556 ASSORTED STUFF 90A-NY-3151227_90A-NY-3151227-1A SUPP SEC 004
Section Section-Padded TIF_Count TIF Running Count
1 01 98 98
1 01 129 227
1 01 186 413
1 01 137 550
1 01 98 648
1 01 77 725
1 01 116 841
1 01 193 1034
1 01 97 1131
1 01 174 1305
1 01 353 1658
1 01 92 1750
1 01 93 1843
1 01 109 1952
1 01 109 2061
1 01 88 2149
1 01 87 2236
1 01 95 2331
1 01 133 2464
1 01 158 2622
1 01 2 2624
1 01 2 2626
1 01 2 2628
1 01 3 2631
1 01 3 2634
1 01 3 2637
1 01 3 2640
1 01 3 2643
1 01 4 2647
1 01 3 2650
1 01 199 2849
1 01 190 3039
1 01 7 3046
1 01 3 3049
1 01 3 3052
1 01 3 3055
1 01 3 3058
1 01 3 3061
1 01 4 3065
1 01 3 3068
1 01 3 3071
1 01 3 3074
1 01 3 3077
1 01 3 3080
1 01 3 3083
1 01 3 3086
1 01 3 3089
1 01 3 3092
1 01 3 3095
1 01 3 3098
1 01 3 3101
1 01 3 3104
1 01 3 3107
1 01 3 3110
1 01 3 3113
1 01 6 3119
1 01 3 3122
1 01 3 3125
1 01 3 3128
1 01 4 3132
1 01 3 3135
1 01 15 3150
1 01 59 3209
1 01 13 3222
1 01 4 3226
1 01 3 3229
1 01 15 3244
1 01 6 3250
1 01 2 3252
1 01 1 3253
1 01 3 3256
1 01 3 3259
1 01 3 3262
1 01 1 3263
1 01 1 3264
1 01 15 3279
1 01 2 3281
1 01 1 3282
1 01 2 3284
1 01 2 3286
1 01 37 3323
1 01 312 3635
1 01 2 3637
1 01 2 3639
1 01 9 3648
1 01 2 3650
1 01 2 3652
1 01 26 3678
1 01 2 3680
1 01 2 3682
1 01 40 3722
1 01 19 3741
1 01 1 3742
1 01 1 3743
1 01 2 3745
1 01 1 3746
1 01 1 3747
1 01 2 3749
1 01 1 3750
1 01 4 3754
1 01 46 3800
1 01 10 3810
1 01 1 3811
1 01 3 3814
1 01 4 3818
1 01 20 3838
1 001 123 3961
2 002 118 4079
3 003 84 4163
4 004 191 4354
Directory
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 001_72-MM-113327-1A
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 001_JE AND GM 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 001_JE AND GM 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_1B-143
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_AIRMAIL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_CALENDAR
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_CONFIDENTIAL CRIMINAL (
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_ENVELOPE_EXECUTIVE SUP
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX 611_ENVELOPE_ORIGINAL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_EPSTEIN JEFFREY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_EPSTEIN_LETTER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611 EXHIBIT MM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FAO SDNY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 004
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 005
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_FOLDER 006
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 61
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GHISLAINE MAXWELL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX 611
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GRAND JURY SUBPOENA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_ E
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_IMAGES FROM MIAMI BOX
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_JE DIAMOND APPRAISALS F
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611 _JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX 611 _JEFFREY EPSTEIN SIGNIFICA
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1MBOX 611_MASSEUSES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG M-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_MEDIA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_NEW YORK OFFICE OF THE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_NEW YORK POLICE DEPAR
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX 611_POSTAGE PAID ENVELOPE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_RED FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_RED FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_RED FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_REPORTS_ACCURINTS
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_SCENE2GO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_SUBPOENAS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX 611_ VIDEO INT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_VICTIM NAME LIST
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_VICTIM SERVICES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_YELLOW FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX 611_YELLOW FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOU
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 04_SUPOENA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 08_SCHOOL RECORDS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 08_SUBPOENA TO TESTIFY
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_5-21-2007 PHONE RECC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_727 BOEING-N908.IE JE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1MBOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 003
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_CALL_FLIGHT LOGS 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM ll_CALL_FLIGHT LOGS 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM ll_CALL_FLIGHT LOGS 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM ll_DTG OPERATIONS DBA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_FAX
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_FAX ACTIVITY LOG
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM ll_GULFSTREAM-N9091E_
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_MONEY TRANSFER REC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_NATIONAL COMPREHEI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_NEWS POSTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_PALM BEACH POLICE DI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_PALM BEACH POLICE P1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_PASSENGER MANIFEST,
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_REPORT RESULTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_SUBPOENA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM-108062-FF SE(
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM-108062-SBP S
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_SENTINEL REPORTS SER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_SERIAL REPORT FOR CA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_31E-MM -108062
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_CIVIL
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_COMPUTERS REMOVED
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_COURT ORDERS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 1
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_EMPLOYEES-JE 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_EMPLOYEES-JE 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_FBI MIAMI TO SA MANI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_FLIGHT RECORDS FAA4
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_FLIGHT RECORDS JET Al
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_FLIGHT RECORDS MANI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_FLIGHTS-ICE TEC-INTL-C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_GHISLAINE MAXWELL 1
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 1 INDIVIDUAL SUP
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_PHOTOS
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 11_ _COMPAN
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 0
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 0
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1MBOX MM 13_MAGAZINES-NEWSPAP
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_PALM BEACH PD PROP
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_PALM BEACH PD PROP
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_TECS-CUSTOMS ICE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 13_THE STATE OF FL COUN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_10-06-2005 CALL SUM
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_3025 31E-MM -108062
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_ADMIN SUBPOENAS-O
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_ADMINISTRATIVE-FEDE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_CORPORATE RECORDS-
Wds-fs-procI\ prod \ DCLI\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_DEFENSE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_ECS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_EPSTEIN-WORK RELEAS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_EXPERTS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_FEDEX FBI NEW YORK
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_FORFEITURE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GERALD B LEFCOURT F
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GERALD B LEFCOURTJ
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPTS-al LE
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_G1 TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_G1 TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPTS-
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_G1 TRANSCRIPT
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_GRAND JURY SUBPOEN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_INSERTS 31E-MM-1080
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_INVOICES-EXPENSES
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_1E-AIRCRAFT PHOTOS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15 MESSAGE PAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_MISC FORMS 990-PF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_ORDER-WHO BROUGH
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PBPD PROPERTY RECEI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PBPD PROPERTY RECEI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PBPD TRASH PULLS-T
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PBPD-PROPERTY RECEI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PBPD-SEARCH WARRA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_PHOTO LINE-UPS-PHO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_RENTAL CARS DOLLAR
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-CASE NO 2
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-CASE NO 2
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-FL VS JEFF
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG M-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-MISC COU
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM &STATE CASE-MISC POS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-PALM BEA
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-SEARCH-A
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-STATE CAS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_STATE SUBPOENAS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_TRANSCRIPTS
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LETT
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS L
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS L
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 15_WESTERN UNION-WES
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM &WORK RELEASE APPLIC
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ SE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_GJ SUBPOENA LOGS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20_GJ TESTIMONYS
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 20 GJ TESTIMON
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_1A-1C REPORT FOR
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_1A-1C REPORT FOR
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_2009
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062 GRA
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-104
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-105
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-108
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-109
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-114
Wds-fs-proA prod\ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-115
Wds-fs-prod \prod \DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\ BOX MM 22_ATTYS LETTERS-MISC
Wds-fs-prod\ prod\ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_CALL FREQUENCY FOR
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_CASE NO 2008CF00938
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_CHILD MOLESTERS-A B
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_DATA DEMONSTRATIV
Wds-fs-prod \ procIWCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1MBOX MM 22_FEDEX ENVELOPE TO SI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_FOLDER 001
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_FOLDER 002
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_FOLDER 003
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_GERALD B LEFCOURT IN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_GRAND JURY SUBPOEN
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_JASON
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_MASTER
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_MISC DOCS
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_NOTEPAD
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_PALM BEACH PD FAX T
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_PALM BEACH PD INCID
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_PLEA IN THE CIRCUIT C
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_PROBABLE CAUSE AFFI
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCO
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_SERIAL 31E-MM-10806
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_SERIAL REPORT FOR CA
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_SEX OFFENDER CONTIN
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_T-MOBILE CALL LOGS
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22_T-MOBILE CALL LOGS-0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod. \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ proADCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG E\3-TIFs\Wave008\3
\\ids-fs-prod\prod\DCU\THE BIG M-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\BOX MM 22
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES BO
.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod\DCLI \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave008\3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod\DCLI \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCWHE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_B0
Wds-fs-prod \ prod \ DCU \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00A3.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BC
Wds-fs-prod\prod\DCLI \THE BIG E\3-TIFAWave00£43.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES LIT
Wds-fs-prod \prod \DCU \THE BIG E \ 3-TIFAWave008 U.13.2025 - 4pm P2-1A\SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES WI
Case Number CASE_ID File
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 001_72-MM-113327-1A
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 001_JE AND GM 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 001_JE AND GM 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_1B-143
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_AIRMAIL
1662055-000 11233556 BOX 611_CALENDAR
1662055-000 11233556IBOX 611_CONFIDENTIAL CRIMINAL DIVISION
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_ENVELOPE_EXECUTIVE SUMMARY OF REPORT
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_ENVELOPE_ORIGINAL
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_EPSTEIN JEFFREY
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_EPSTEIN_LETTER
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_EXHIBIT MM
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FAO SDNY
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 004
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_FOLDER 005
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 FOLDER 006
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_GHISLAINE MAXWELL
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_GRAND JURY SUBPOENA
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_GREEN FOLDER 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 61
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 IMAGES FROM MIAMI BOXES
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 JE DIAMOND APPRAISALS FROM SAFE
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 JEFFREY EPSTEIN
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 JEFFREY EPSTEIN SIGNIFICANT CASE NOTIF
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 MASSEUSES
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_MEDIA
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_NEW YORK OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_NEW YORK POLICE DEPARTMENT DOCS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_POSTAGE PAID ENVELOPE
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_RED FOLDER 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_RED FOLDER 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_RED FOLDER 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 REPORTS ACCURINTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 SCENE2GO
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611 SUBPOENAS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_ VIDEO INTERVIEW
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_VICTIM NAME LIST
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_VICTIM SERVICES
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_YELLOW FOLDER 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX 611_YELLOW FOLDER 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 004
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 005
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 006
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 007
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 008
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04_STATEMENT OF ACCOUNTS 009
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 04 SUPOENA
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 08_SCHOOL RECORDS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 08_SUBPOENA TO TESTIFY BEFORE GRAND JURY
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_5-21-2007 PHONE RECORDS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_727 BOEING-N9081E JEGE INC
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL RECORDS 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL_FLIGHT LOGS 001
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL_FLIGHT LOGS 002
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_CALL_FLIGHT LOGS 003
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 1 INDIVIDUAL SUMMARY PAGES
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_DTG OPERATIONS DBA DOLLAR RENT A CAR
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_FAX
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_FAX ACTIVITY LOG
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_GULFSTREAM-N9091E_HYPERION AIR INC
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_MISC DOCS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_MONEY TRANSFER RECORDS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_NATIONAL COMPREHENSIVE REPORTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_NEWS POSTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT DOCS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_PALM BEACH POLICE PROPERTY RECEIPTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_PASSENGER MANIFESTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_PHOTOS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_REPORT RESULTS
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 1 _COMPANY INFO
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 11_SUBPOENA
1662055-000 1233556 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 001 SER 1-70
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 002 SER 71-175
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062 SEC 003 SER 176-
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 014 SER 1A118-1A131
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 015 SER 1A132-1A141
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 016 SER 1A142-1A146
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM-108062-FF SEC 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_31E-MM-108062-SBP SEC 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_SENTINEL REPORTS SERIALS 251-258
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 12_SERIAL REPORT FOR CASE 31E-MM-108062-SBP
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_31E-MM -108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_CIVIL
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_COMPUTERS REMOVED FROM RESIDENCE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_000RT ORDERS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 1
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_EMPLOYEES-JE 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_EMPLOYEES-JE 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_FBI MIAMI TO SA
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_FLIGHT RECORDS FAA-AMOC
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_FLIGHT RECORDS JET AVIATION
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_FLIGHT RECORDS MANIFESTS-DEFENSE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_FLIGHTS-ICE TEC-INTL-DOM
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_GHISLAINE MAXWELL 12-25-61
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_MAGAZINES-NEWSPAPERS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_PALM BEACH PD PROPERTY RECEIPT 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_PALM BEACH PD PROPERTY RECEIPT 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_TECS-CUSTOMS ICE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 13_THE STATE OF FL COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_10-06-2005 CALL SUMMARY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_3025 31E-MM -108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_ADMIN SUBPOENAS-OUTSTANDING
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_ADMINISTRATIVE-FEDERAL SUBPOENAS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_CORPORATE RECORDS-JEGE_HYPERION
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_DEFENSE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_ECS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_EPSTEIN-WORK RELEASE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_EXPERTS-KEN LANNING
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_FEDEX FBI NEW YORK
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_FOLDER 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_FOLDER 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_FORFEITURE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GERALD B LEFCOURT FEBRUARY 1 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GERALD B LEFCOURT JANUARY 24 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_61 TRANSCRIPTS-61 LETTERS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT APRIL 24 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT FEB 27 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT FEB 6 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GJ TRANSCRIPT MARCH 20 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_61 TRANSCRIPT MAY 22 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_61 TRANSCRIPT MAY 8 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_61 TRANSCRIPTS-OPERATION LEAP YEAR
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 8 2007 TRANSCRIPTS
611662486-000 1234023
TRANSCRIPTSMRAY
BOX MM
15_15_61
IL 24 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_GRAND JURY SUBPOENAS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_INSERTS 31E-MM-108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_INVOICES-EXPENSES
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_1E-AIRCRAFT PHOTOS MIAMI FLIGHT SURV
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_MESSAGE PAD
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_MISC FORMS 990-PF
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_ORDER-WHO BROUGHT WHO
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD PROPERTY RECEIPTS-PBPD PROPERTY REC
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD PROPERTY RECEIPTS-PROB CAUSE AFF
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD TRASH PULLS-TRASH PULLS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD-PROPERTY RECEIPTS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PBPD-SEARCH WARRANT-STATE AND CDS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_PHOTO LINE-UPS-PHOTO LINE-UPS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_RENTAL CARS DOLLAR_DTG-DTG OPS-DOLLAR
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-CASE NO 2006CF9454AXX
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-CASE NO 2008CF009381AXX
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-FL VS JEFFREY EPSTEIN
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-MISC COURT DOGS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-MISC POST-IT NOTES
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-PALM BEACH BOOKING CARD
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-SEARCH-AFFIDAVIT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE CASE-STATE CASE
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_STATE SUBPOENAS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_TRANSCRIPTS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LETTERS-FOLDER
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LETTERS-VICTIM LETTER
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_VICTIM-WITNESS LETTERS-VICTIM-WITNESS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_WESTERN UNION-WESTERN UNION
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 15_WORK RELEASE APPLICATION JEFFREY EPSTEIN
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 010 SER 1A78-86
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC O11 SER 1A87-1A97
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 012 SER 1A98-1A108
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 17_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 013 SER 1A109-1A117
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 006 SER 1A21-1A37
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20_31E-MM -108062-G1 SEC 007 SER 1A38-1A42
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20_31E-MM-108062-GJ SEC 008 SER 1A43-
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20_GJ SUBPOENA LOGS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20_G1 TESTIMONYS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 20 GJ TESTIMONY MULTIPLE-INDICTMENT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_1A-1C REPORT FOR CASE 31E-MM-108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 001 SER 1A1-1A9
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 002 SER 1A10 ONLY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SEC 004 SER 1A27 ONLY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE0003 SER1A11-1A26 01
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 21_31E-MM -108062-1A SE0003 SER1A11-1A26 02
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_1A-1C REPORT FOR CASE 31E-MM-108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_2009
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062 GRAND JURY MATERIAL
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-104
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-105
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-108
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-109
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-114
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_31E-MM -108062-115
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 H DOB 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 H DOB 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 D DOB 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 D DOB 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_ATTN SA
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_ATLYS LETTERS-MISC
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_CALL FREQUENCY FOR NUMBER 917-855-3363
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_CASE NO 2008CF009381A MOTION TO CLARIFY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_CHILD MOLESTERS-A BEHAVIORAL ANALYSIS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_DATA DEMONSTRATIVES KIRKLAND_ELLIS LLP
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FEDEX ENVELOPE TO SA-
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FINAL DO:
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FINAL G DOB
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FOLDER 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FOLDER 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_FOLDER 003
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_GERALD B LEFCOURT PC
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_GRAND JURY SUBPOENAS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 DOB 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 DOB 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_MASTER
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_MISC DOCS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 001
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 002
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_NOTEPAD
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_PALM BEACH PD FAX T'
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_PALM BEACH PD INCIDENT REPORT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_PLEA IN THE CIRCUIT COURT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_PROBABLE CAUSE AFFIDAVIT PALM BEACH PD
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-INCIDENT REPORT
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-JAN 24 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-JULY 25 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-JUNE 25 2007
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_RECORDS FROM LEFCOURT-MISC NOTEPADS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 G DOB
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 SERIAL 31E-MM -108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_SERIAL REPORT FOR CASE 31E-MM-108062
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_SEX OFFENDER CONTINUUM
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_T-MOBILE CALL LOGS
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22_T-MOBILE CALL LOGS-OUR COPY
1662486-000 1234023 BOX MM 22 DOB
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 01 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 02 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 03 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 04 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 05 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 06 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 07 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 08 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 09 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 10 DISKS-NO BOX EXISTS DIGITAL
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 11 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 12 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 13 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 14 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 15 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 16 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 17 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 18 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 19 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 20 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 21 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_BOX MM 22 DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES_LITIGATION DISKS
1662486-000 1234023 SUPPLEMENTAL DISKS OF BOXES WORKING COPY DISKS 1D2 1D3 1D4
Section Section-Padded TIF_Count TIF Running Count
1 01 485 485
1 01 407 892
1 01 367 1259
1 01 4 1263
1 01 23 1286
1 01 16 1302
1 01 49 1351
1 01 23 1374
1 01 13 1387
1 01 9 1396
1 01 31 1427
1 01 23 1450
1 01 11 1461
1 01 2 1463
1 01 32 1495
1 01 9 1504
1 01 11 1515
1 01 13 1528
1 01 60 1588
1 01 125 1713
1 01 3 1716
1 01 74 1790
1 01 6 1796
1 01 33 1829
1 01 3 1832
1 01 25 1857
1 01 43 1900
1 01 10 1910
1 01 83 1993
1 01 35 2028
1 01 9 2037
1 01 14 2051
1 01 3 2054
1 01 57 2111
1 01 34 2145
1 01 144 2289
1 01 16 2305
1 01 4 2309
1 01 49 2358
1 01 55 2413
1 01 5 2418
1 01 13 2431
1 01 48 2479
1 01 7 2486
1 01 9 2495
1 01 6 2501
1 01 23 2524
1 01 21 2545
1 01 11 2556
1 01 14 2570
1 01 8 2578
1 01 22 2600
1 01 68 2668
1 01 13 2681
1 01 27 2708
1 01 11 2719
1 01 40 2759
1 01 60 2819
1 01 40 2859
1 01 37 2896
1 01 15 2911
1 01 4 2915
1 01 8 2923
1 01 6 2929
1 01 60 2989
1 01 1 2990
1 01 29 3019
1 01 11 3030
1 01 20 3050
1 01 10 3060
1 01 57 3117
1 01 313 3430
1 01 764 4194
1 01 419 4613
1 01 298 4911
1 01 587 5498
1 01 111 5609
1 01 132 5741
1 01 373 6114
1 01 12 6126
1 01 86 6212
1 01 301 6513
1 01 16 6529
1 01 232 6761
1 01 262 7023
1 01 348 7371
1 01 334 7705
1 01 38 7743
1 01 197 7940
1 01 133 8073
1 01 268 8341
1 01 356 8697
1 01 356 9053
1 01 107 9160
1 01 73 9233
1 01 2 9235
1 01 2 9237
1 01 2 9239
1 01 2 9241
1 01 67 9308
1 01 47 9355
1 01 73 9428
1 01 2 9430
1 01 2 9432
1 01 55 9487
1 01 61 9548
1 01 2 9550
1 01 37 9587
1 01 2 9589
1 01 93 9682
1 01 53 9735
1 01 2 9737
1 01 2 9739
1 01 136 9875
1 01 46 9921
1 01 28 9949
1 01 4 9953
1 01 2 9955
1 01 2 9957
1 01 103 10060
1 01 110 10170
1 01 266 10436
1 01 337 10773
1 01 96 10869
1 01 96 10965
1 01 44 11009
1 01 20 11029
1 01 309 11338
1 01 156 11494
1 01 484 11978
1 01 19 11997
1 01 418 12415
1 01 270 12685
1 01 111 12796
1 01 152 12948
1 01 124 13072
1 01 32 13104
1 01 81 13185
1 01 52 13237
1 01 238 13475
1 01 288 13763
1 01 201 13964
1 01 84 14048
1 01 20 14068
1 01 21 14089
1 01 4 14093
1 01 173 14266
1 01 120 14386
1 01 44 14430
1 01 42 14472
1 01 92 14564
1 01 409 14973
1 01 111 15084
1 01 69 15153
1 01 6 15159
1 01 30 15189
1 01 25 15214
1 01 70 15284
1 001 423 15707
2 002 421 16128
3 003 211 16339
14 014 629 16968
15 015 710 17678
16 016 136 17814
1 001 29 17843
1 001 285 18128
1 01 48 18176
1 01 3 18179
1 01 76 18255
1 01 103 18358
1 01 10 18368
1 01 55 18423
1 01 37 18460
1 01 90 18550
1 01 139 18689
1 01 204 18893
1 01 2 18895
1 01 127 19022
1 01 8 19030
1 01 89 19119
1 01 84 19203
1 01 32 19235
1 01 55 19290
1 01 90 19380
1 01 45 19425
1 01 205 19630
1 01 94 19724
1 01 97 19821
1 01 54 19875
1 01 90 19965
1 01 30 19995
1 01 3 19998
1 01 29 20027
1 01 3 20030
1 01 69 20099
1 01 75 20174
1 01 30 20204
1 01 5 20209
1 01 62 20271
1 01 187 20458
1 01 1 20459
1 01 122 20581
1 01 177 20758
1 01 13 20771
1 01 10 20781
1 01 2 20783
1 01 5 20788
1 01 11 20799
1 01 90 20889
1 01 23 20912
1 01 2 20914
1 01 53 20967
1 01 36 21003
1 01 2 21005
1 01 8 21013
1 01 35 21048
1 01 136 21184
1 01 23 21207
1 01 12 21219
1 01 14 21233
1 01 2 21235
1 01 134 21369
1 01 6 21375
1 01 135 21510
1 01 23 21533
1 01 39 21572
1 01 2 21574
1 01 7 21581
1 01 51 21632
1 01 31 21663
1 01 17 21680
1 01 29 21709
1 01 50 21759
1 01 88 21847
1 01 4 21851
1 01 4 21855
1 01 59 21914
1 01 52 21966
1 01 2 21968
1 01 115 22083
1 01 27 22110
1 01 111 22221
1 01 60 22281
1 01 24 22305
1 01 24 22329
10 010 334 22663
11 011 687 23350
12 012 609 23959
13 013 667 24626
6 006 489 25115
7 007 359 25474
8 008 591 26065
1 01 63 26128
1 01 401 26529
1 01 404 26933
1 01 402 27335
1 001 343 27678
2 002 762 28440
4 004 883 29323
3 003 316 29639
3 003 202 29841
1 01 8 29849
1 01 239 30088
1 01 16 30104
1 01 3 30107
1 01 4 30111
1 01 1 30112
1 01 7 30119
1 01 3 30122
1 01 1 30123
1 01 21 30144
1 01 52 30196
1 01 37 30233
1 01 22 30255
1 01 41 30296
1 01 14 30310
1 01 369 30679
1 01 38 30717
1 01 11 30728
1 01 3 30731
1 01 11 30742
1 01 3 30745
1 01 50 30795
1 01 3 30798
1 01 38 30836
1 01 4 30840
1 01 6 30846
1 01 93 30939
1 01 19 30958
1 01 49 31007
1 01 61 31068
1 01 45 31113
1 01 188 31301
1 01 60 31361
1 01 4 31365
1 01 16 31381
1 01 3 31384
1 01 2 31386
1 01 14 31400
1 01 96 31496
1 01 13 31509
1 01 70 31579
1 01 87 31666
1 01 86 31752
1 01 93 31845
1 01 19 31864
1 01 80 31944
1 01 4 31948
1 01 21 31969
1 01 21 31990
1 01 15 32005
1 01 242 32247
1 01 48 32295
1 01 76 32371
1 01 5 32376
1 01 9 32385
1 01 11 32396
1 01 3 32399
1 01 3 32402
1 01 3 32405
1 01 3 32408
1 01 3 32411
1 01 3 32414
1 01 7 32421
1 01 3 32424
1 01 3 32427
1 01 3 32430
1 01 3 32433
1 01 5 32438
1 01 3 32441
1 01 9 32450
1 01 3 32453
1 01 3 32456
1 01 5 32461
1 01 9 32470
1 01 3 32473
1 01 7 32480
1 01 3 32483
Directory Case Number
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ForFDPSImport\0S0D-NY-3027571 Serials 1-21 1662056-000
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ForFDPSImport\0S0D-NY-3027571 Serials 101-150 1662056-000
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ ForFDPSImport\ MOD-W-3027571 Serials 22-49 1662056-000
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ ForFDPSImport\ MOD-W-3027571 Serials 50-99 1662056-000
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ForFDPSImport\050D-IsIV-3027571-ELA 1662056-000
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ForFDPSImport\050D-W-3027571-FF 1662056-000
CAtemp\ACCD_Project \ Epstein \ Sentinel \ForFDPSImport\050D-INIV-3027571-INTELPRODS 1662056-000
Case_ID File Section Section-Padded TIF_Count TIF Running Count
1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serials 1-21 1 01 113 113
1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serials 101-150 1 01 151 264
1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serials 22-49 1 01 137 401
1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serials 50-99 1 01 114 515
1233557 050D-NY-3027571-ELA 1 01 2 517
1233557 050D-NY-3027571-FF 1 01 221 738
1233557 050D-NY-3027571-INTELPRODS 1 01 147 885
Directory
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 151-183
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 184-240
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 241-292
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 294-350
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 351-373
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 374-382
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 383-397
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 398-405
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 406-450
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 451-499
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 500-557
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-IsIV-3027571 Serials 558-585
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-IsIV-3027571 Serials 586-622
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-W-3027571 Serials 623-636
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 Serials 637-660
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \ Sentinel \Wave002VorFDPSImport\50D-W-3027571 Serials 661-706
Case Number Case_ID File Section Section-Padded TIF_Count
I 662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 151-183 1 01 108
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 184-240 1 01 227
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 241-292 1 01 416
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 294-350 1 01 544
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 351-373 1 01 244
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 374-382 1 01 232
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 383-397 1 01 226
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 398-405 1 01 269
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 406-450 1 01 182
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 451-499 1 01 206
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 500-557 1 01 489
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 558-585 1 01 492
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 586-622 1 01 467
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 623-636 1 01 485
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 637-660 1 01 499
1662056-000 1233557 50D-NY-3027571 Serials 661-706 1 01 376
TIF Running Count
Directory
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\009A-W-3144791 Serials 1-7
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\050D-NY-3027571 Serial 293
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ Wave003VorFDPSImport\ 72-MM-1133217 Serials 1-61
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \ Wave003VorFDPSImport\ 72-MM-1133217 Serials 62-64
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\72-MM-113327-1A1-1A19
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\72-MM-113327-ELA Serials 1-3
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 1-65
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 115-119
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 120
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 121-146
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 147-179
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 64-97
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 98-114
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-SBP Serials 1-6
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave003VorFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227 Serials 180-211
Case Number Case_ID File Section Section-Padded TIF_Count
I 662056-000 1233557 009A-NY-3144791 Serials 1-7 1 01 I-- 21
1662056-000 1233557 050D-NY-3027571 Serial 293 1 01 1
1662056-000 1233557 72-MM-1133217 Serials 1-61 1 01 258
1662056-000 1233557 72-MM-1133217 Serials 62-64 1 01 8
1662056-000 1233557 72-MM-113327-1A1-1A19 1 01 286
1662056-000 1233557 72-MM-113327-ELA Serials 1-3 1 01 16
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 1-65 1 01 494
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 115-119 1 01 46
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 120 1 01 536
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 121-146 1 01 501
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 147-179 1 01 499
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 64-97 1 01 476
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 98-114 1 01 498
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227-SBP Serials 1-6 1 01 167
1662056-000 1233557 90A-NY-3151227 Serials 180-211 1 01 482
TIF Running Count
Directory
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\050D-NY-3027571-FA
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 1-70 Part 1(p1-250)
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 1-70 Part 2 (p251-44
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 176-250
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 251-263
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 71-175 Part 1(p1-24
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062 Serials 71-175 Part 2 4)249-
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 1(p1-29
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 2 (p256
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 3 (p511
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 1_1 (p1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 1_2 (p1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 1(p1-2°
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 2 (p251
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 3 (p501
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 4 (p751
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 1(p1-2°
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 2 (p251
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 3 (p501
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 4 (p751
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 1(p1-2°
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 2 (p251
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 3 (p501
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 1 (p1-li
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 2 (p175
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 3 (p349
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A80
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A82
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part I
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part I
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 4
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A1-1A9 Part 1(p
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A1-1A9 Part 2 (p
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_ProjectVpstein \ Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Par
CAtemp \ ACCD_ProjectVpstein \ Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImporA31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A142-1A146
CAtemp \ ACCD_ProjectVpstein \ Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A28-1A49 Part 1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A28-1A49 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part I
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A52-1A78 Part I
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A52-1A78 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A78 Pt. 2 - 1A86
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A78 Pt. 2 - 1A86
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part I
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part a
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-FF Serial 10
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-FF Serials 1-9
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GJ Serial 46
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GJ Serials 1-45
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-SBP Serials 1-87 Part 1 (p1-:
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-SBP Serials 1-87 Part 2 (p25
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571 GJ Serial 21
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\SOD-NY-3027571-GJ Serial 7
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 14-20
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 14
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 22-36
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\50D-IsIV-3027571-GJ Serials 37-39
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\50D-IsIV-3027571-G1 Serials 40-44
CAtemp \ACCD_Project\ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave004VorFDPSImport\50D-W-3027571-G1 Serials 8-13
Case Number Case_ID File Section
1662057-000 1233558 050D-NY-3027571-FA 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 1-70 Part 1 (p1-250) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 1-70 Part 2 (p251-441) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 176-250 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 251-263 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 71-175 Part 1(p1-248) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062 Serials 71-175 Part 2 (p249-413) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 1 (p1-255) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 2 (p256-510) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A10 Part 3 (p511-761) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 1_1 (p1-161) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 1_2 (p162-322) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A11 Part 2 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 1 (p1-250) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 2 (p251-500) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 3 (p501-750) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A13 Part 4 (p751-839) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 1 (p1-250) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 2 (p251-500) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 3 (p501-750) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A27 Part 4 (p751-882) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 1 (p1-250) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 2 (p251-500) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A39 Part 3 (p501-663) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 1 (p1-174) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 2 (p175-348) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A78 Part 3 (p349-521) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A80 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serial 1A82 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Part 1 (p1-211) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Part 2 (p212-422) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A109-1A117 Part 3 (p423-633) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 1 (p1-250) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 2 (p251-500) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 3 (p501-750) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A11-1A26 Part 4 (p751-925) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Part 1 (p1-181) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Part 2 (p182-362) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A118-1A131 Part 3 (p363-576) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A1-1A9 Part 1(p1-250) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A1-1A9 Part 2 (p251-360) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Part 1 (p1-250) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Part 2 (p251-500) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A132-1A141 Part 3 (p501-715) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A142-1A146 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A28-1A49 Part 1 (p1-213) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM -108062-1A Serials 1A28-1A49 Part 2 (p214-294) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 1 (p1-174) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 2 (p175-347) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A50-1A51 Part 3 (p348-520) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A52-1A78 Part 1 (p1-229) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A52-1A78 Part 2 (p230-458) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A78 Pt. 2 - 1A86 Part 1 (p1-149) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A78 Pt. 2 - 1A86 Part 2 (p150-341) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 1 (p1-250) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 2 (p251-500) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A87-1A97 Part 3 (p501-716) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part 1 (p1-226) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part 2 (p227-424) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-1A Serials 1A98-1A108 Part 3 (p425-601) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-FF Serial 10 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-FF Serials 1-9 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-GJ Serial 46 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-GJ Serials 1-45 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serials 1-87 Part 1(p1-249) 1
1662057-000 1233558 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serials 1-87 Part 2 (p250-286) 1
1662057-000 1233558 50D-NY-3027571 al Serial 21 1
1662057-000 1233558 50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serial 7 1
1662057-000 1233558 50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 14-20 1
1662057-000 1233558 50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 1-6 1
1662057-000 1233558 50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 22-36 1
1662057-000 1233558 50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 37-39 1
1662057-000 1233558 50D-NY-3027571-GJ Serials 40-44 1
1662057-000 1233558 SOD-NY-3027571-a' Serials 8-13 1
Section-Padded TIF_Count TIF Running Count
01 157 157
01 250 407
01 171 578
01 210 788
01 153 941
01 248 1189
01 165 1354
01 255 1609
01 255 1864
01 251 2115
01 161 2276
01 161 2437
01 200 2637
01 250 2887
01 250 3137
01 250 3387
01 89 3476
01 250 3726
01 250 3976
01 250 4226
01 132 4358
01 250 4608
01 250 4858
01 163 5021
01 174 5195
01 174 5369
01 173 5542
01 91 5633
01 202 5835
01 211 6046
01 211 6257
01 211 6468
01 250 6718
01 250 6968
01 250 7218
01 175 7393
01 181 7574
01 181 7755
01 214 7969
01 250 8219
01 110 8329
01 250 8579
01 250 8829
01 215 9044
01 131 9175
01 213 9388
01 81 9469
01 174 9643
01 173 9816
01 173 9989
01 229 10218
01 229 10447
01 149 10596
01 192 10788
01 250 11038
01 250 11288
01 216 11504
01 226 11730
01 198 11928
01 177 12105
01 1 12106
01 30 12136
01 19 12155
01 208 12363
01 249 12612
01 37 12649
01 831 13480
01 771 14251
01 187 14438
01 67 14505
01 263 14768
01 768 15536
01 164 15700
01 483 16183
Directory
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A20 Part 1 (p1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A20 Part 2 (p2
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A20 Part 3 (p4
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A28 Part 1 (p1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A28 Part 2 (p1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A28 Part 3 (p2
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 1 (p1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 2 (p2
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-0-1A Serial 1A41 Part 3 (p5
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-0-1A Serial 1A41 Part 4 (p7
C:\temp\ACCD Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 5 (p1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 6 (p1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 7 (p1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 8 (p1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 9 (p2
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 1_1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 1_2
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 1_3
C:\temp\ACCD Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 2 1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A43 Part 2_2
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 1
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 2
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 3
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 4
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 5
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A1-1A5 Part
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A1-1A5 Part
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A1-1A5 Part
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A17-1A19 Pa
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A17-1A19 Pa
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A21-1A30
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A38-1A42 Pa
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A38-1A42 Pa
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A6-1A8 Part
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A6-1A8 Part
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A6-1A8 Part
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A9-1A16 Parl
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A9-1A16 Parl
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-G1 Serial 1-5
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 10-11
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 12-13
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-GJ Serial 14-17
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport\90A-NY-3151227-G1 Serial 6 - 8
C:\temp\ACCD Project \ Epstein \ Sentinel \Wave005 \ ForFDPSImport \90A-NY-3151227-al Serial 9
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \ Sentinel \Wave005VorFDPSImport\90C-NY-3154599-al (Serial 1-2)
Case Number Case ID File Section
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A20 Part 1 (p1-212) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A20 Part 2 (p213-424) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A20 Part 3 (p425-636) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A28 Part 1 (p1-176) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A28 Part 2 (p177-351) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A28 Part 3 (p352-526) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 1A41 Part 1 (p1-250) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A41 Part 2 (p251-500) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A41 Part 3 (p501-750) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-6.1-1A Serial 1A41 Part 4 (p751-1000) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-6.1-1A Serial 1A41 Part 5 (p1001-1250) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A41 Part 6 (p1251-1500) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A41 Part 7 (p1501-1750) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A41 Part 8 (p1751-2000) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A41 Part 9 (p2001-2156) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A43 Part 1_1 (p1-198) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A43 Part 1_2 (p199-395) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A43 Part 1_3 (p396-592) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A43 Part 2_1 (p1-160) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 1A43 Part 2_2 (p161-319) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 40 Part 1 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 40 Part 2 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 40 Part 3 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serial 40 Part 4 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serial 40 Part 5 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A1-1A5 Part 1 (p1-225) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A1-1A5 Part 2 (p226-450) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serials 1A1-1A5 Part 3 (451-675) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A17-1A19 Part 1 (p1-250) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serials 1A17-1A19 Part 2 (p251-462) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serials 1A21-1A30 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serials 1A38-1A42 Part 1 (p1-182) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serials 1A38-1A42 Part 2 (p183-366) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serials 1A6-1A8 Part 1(p1-184) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serials 1A6-1A8 Part 2 (p185-371) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serials 1A6-1A8 Part 3 (p372-557) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A Serials 1A9-1A16 Part 1 (p1-249) 1
1662431-000 1233922 31E-MM-108062-GMA Serials 1A9-1A16 Part 2 (p250-476) 1
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-al Serial 1-5 1
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-al Serial 10-11 1
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-al Serial 12-13 1
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-al Serial 14-17 1
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-al Serial 6 - 8 1
1662431-000 1233922 90A-NY-3151227-al Serial 9 1
1662431-000 1233922 90C-NY-3154599-GJ (Serial 1-2) 1
Section-Padded TIF_Count TIF Running Count
01 212 212
01 212 424
01 212 636
01 176 812
01 175 987
01 175 1162
01 250 1412
01 250 1662
01 250 1912
01 250 2162
01 250 2412
01 250 2662
01 250 2912
01 250 3162
01 156 3318
01 198 3516
01 197 3713
01 197 3910
01 160 4070
01 159 4229
01 877 5106
01 500 5606
01 509 6115
01 500 6615
01 501 7116
01 225 7341
01 225 7566
01 225 7791
01 250 8041
01 212 8253
01 99 8352
01 182 8534
01 184 8718
01 184 8902
01 187 9089
01 186 9275
01 249 9524
01 227 9751
01 274 10025
01 361 10386
01 165 10551
01 210 10761
01 112 10873
01 387 11260
01 84 11344
Directory I
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 001 Serial 1-14 (212 pg
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 002 Serial 14 Part 3 Oi
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 003 Serial 14 Part 1 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 004 Serial 14 Part 2 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 005 Serial 14 Part 4 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 006 Serial 14 Part 5 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 007 Serial 14 Part 6 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 008 Serial 15-30 (225 r
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 009 Serial 31-50 (302 r
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 010 Serial 51-54 part 1
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 011 Serial 54 Part 2 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 012 Serial 54 Part 3 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 013 Serial 54 Part 4 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 014 Serial 54 Part 5 Or
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 015 Serial 54-2 Part 1 (
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 016 Serial 54-2 Part 2
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 017 Serial 54-2 Part 3
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 018 Serial 54-2 Part 4
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 019 Serial 54-2 Part 5
CAtemp \ ACCD_Project \ Epstein \Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NY-3154599 Sec 020 Serial 54-2 Part 6
CAtemp \ACCD_Project \ Epstein \ Sentinel \Wave006VorFDPSImport\090C-NN-3154599 Sec 021 Serial 55 - 61 (19 il
Case Number Case_ID File I Section
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 001 Serial 1-14 (212 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 002 Serial 14 Part 3 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 003 Serial 14 Part 1 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 004 Serial 14 Part 2 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 005 Serial 14 Part 4 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 006 Serial 14 Part 5 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 007 Serial 14 Part 6 Only (244 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 008 Serial 15-30 (225 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 009 Serial 31-50 (302 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 010 Serial 51-54 part 1 (311 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 011 Serial 54 Part 2 Only (250 pages) I 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 012 Serial 54 Part 3 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 013 Serial 54 Part 4 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 014 Serial 54 Part 5 Only (56 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 015 Serial 54-2 Part 1 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 016 Serial 54-2 Part 2 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 017 Serial 54-2 Part 3 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 018 Serial 54-2 Part 4 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 019 Serial 54-2 Part 5 Only (250 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 020 Serial 54-2 Part 6 Only (244 pages) 1
1662431-000 1233922 090C-NY-3154599 Sec 021 Serial 55 - 61 (19 pages) 1
Section-Padded TIF_Count TIF Running Count
01 212 212
01 250 462
01 250 712
01 250 962
01 250 1212
01 250 1462
01 244 1706
01 225 1931
01 302 2233
01 308 2541
01 250 2791
01 250 3041
01 250 3291
01 56 3347
01 250 3597
01 250 3847
01 250 4097
01 250 4347
01 250 4597
01 244 4841
01 19 4860
EFTA02731410 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-01)
iht
- 4. ..• ..,..
4, ' . . - 4o-A, .,, <

• ..... ,:< —, ..• I, el • rr
- .. .. • 0.•••,. a • I. ..4.. 4 h . • .., - - 1....0*.i. i s
... 4.....fr• afel:li . IIPP• ..... 4*r 1. 01$6,
et.

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA01618426 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2026-01-01 01:08:02)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000
•
1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
•
Hi sneaky,
Could I do a haircut with
06:46:53 pm
Sincerely, Dam fuck
06:47:22 pm
Thank you!!!
06:47:33 pm
2017/05/18
tomorrow for my big graduation please --
1212 5333739
Yes
06:47:16 pm
2017/05/19
01:31:24 din
1212 5333739
Tell him to call
01:32:54 am
Tomorrow? What time?
01:36:08 am
1212 5333739
anytime
01:39:00 am
Ok
01:41:19 am
To give him grout number or office
01:41:35 am
*your number
01:41:45 am
1212 5333739
office
03:12:43 am
Ok
03:20:27 am
Would be ok Hell you around 6:30 pm when he arrives to D.C.?
07:10:18 pm
1212 5333739
7
08:00:56 pm
Ok
08:20:02 pin
Sneaky could I please come with my parents to bring presents whet omes with
her mother? I know you hate this kind of things so it won't be long and they don't
speak English anyway
08:52:53 pm
7pm
08:52:59 pm
•
•
10:02:22 pm
2017/05/26
Sent an attachment
Filename: IMG_9517.mp4.mov
Path: IMG_9517.mp4.mov
Size: 16 MB
Type: video/quicktime
03:02:05 pm
Sneaky thank you so so so much! It was amazing! My parents saying big thank you!
And that they really enjoyed Billy Joel concert, they could have only dreamed about 14
*4 .4
03:03:22 pm
2017/05/29
•
•
•
Sneaky what time should I come?
11:24:19 pm
2017/05/30
How did you sleep sneaky
04:03:59 pm
1212 5333739
greatttttt
06:05:13 pm
Do you need me today for massage? I have a dinner date in the evening but can work
around your schedule if you let me know time or, perhaps, come in the afternoon in an
hour or so
06:12:44 pm
:) I am glad you slept well Vb
06:13:03 pm
2017/06/01
Hi sneaky,
How was your colonoscopy?
is asking what time would be convenient to call you today?
02:05:58 pm
1212 5333739
Now
03:19:27 pm
•
•
Sorry just seeing it
03:37:16 pm
Ok will tell now
03:37:20 pin
Thank you sneaky but I don't want you to pay for a ticket if I can just catch a ride with
you and I buy a ticket for my way back or if you need me I can help you on PB but just
don't want to disrupt your "solo" plans b
06:57:15 pm
*in
06:57:33 pm
2017/06/02
Is it still ok for me to come today? When do you leave?
12:45:38 am
How was the dinner?
12:45:52 am
1212 5333739
Now good
01:05:27 am
Ok coming 1,1
01:08:02 am
Sneaky, how do you feel? How is your back?
04:58:15 pin
Let me know if you need me to massage it!
04:58:32 pm
Didn't understand, too much noise in the background
06:15:08 pm
Where r you? And where r going to house
06:15:41 pm
Ah ok
06:15:44 pin
I am at gym 63rd street steer for another 40-45 min
06:16:10 pin
Just came in
06:16:15 pm
Do you want me to come after or you need me now?
06:16:34 pin
Oh great ok
06:16:45 pm
1212 5333739
Going to house
06:15:30 pm
1212 5333739
Perfect come after
06:16:30 pm
•
•
Sneaky underestimated, just finished work out need to shower and wash my head
would be 3:30-3:40 ok?
06:59:13 pm
Running a bit late sorry! Al am oh way
07:44:21 pm
Read
1212 5333739
Ok
07:07:05 pm
s, Sent
EFTA00001886 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
Invallba Oar a.
a wed Glob re isnot rI Pal. I ni Vittaa• _ _ b.WNW IOU A
•
L., al.. Mm N.r4 ml ...swank ihs Ilitiwc XrunrCly sith tla
ra.mMrn plosyaine Is Is lur c is rcists or walks., reps.'s. funurst to
V.  blni. L...k Ink 'I.Sam. I 7W •Nenstabla IN a note nil Watts]
IX* rvn mm Sn Scl I Yr cr, rniftnornaml Srw Inr. lirran *We mauls arc
on Ills dill I sat anis a sr .4 Ibis rIslifirstr.
Mallt.RIMIIIICAOCJAIVIWKI011•al
••••NateA/OSITel N Vie I ith.triti•esenguresite e••••vlr beers
I la owl/ toenail Or. /la • • •Lenni • Pe Tar ban N. +N. ww• a`aw ry beabb•••••••10/alleest•neto• see ••• ewe emo,  
Mulote. ao !Loa, it ... 0 ,r e .
•••••••••Iitimeas Nal N leeleunkb. Wee pa/enure • Os ••• OS • • elms blot NM WVINNON MSS* WOWN1•10,0 l'Owb.• abbr. eve 
rb b rk iseilimilholSa••••••11bi•Nrs•Plas
fl eCeerrema Mac. neap.. &... Wyk", Saps abnoei

• bear ali•Ills••••••tidodef IP•petab. lapfien•p as.ryry 30.. Ts mina...re DeWn•MY listrep•Sa P/ me an pa fee ea tens 
an•weerip heron dap so.... iloie

• bbiellOilitTN••••••• ISO d•Ofrie loin* Vuw bbbaa0 • rota re a Naar • re Carman . o AA,. pt. bre•••••••••lapa ISO dam 
day sow amps eon., any *roma wax, ONO.
snow :taw TOSII•milak•SPOROM•PONI
6 pallotior• Mamas is sae. oodles Woe ro ar we antes bison fawn Deverwr Jab • Iv* pot inb.••• sal I tras a . 1Sn YOSPO, 
.pa sax, /I I eillyalifille•Mili I
1...IatfilHaiaba m tab sierprilen, Pommes/ yai en est) b ilico.r • pew $:**O.n ..... • a b my .• b w a orniN MatiTiel 
Owl *saner a • irol Ras I I fa
Me•••••./Mairain••••••••).• brawl/flay, brigs. npfd• y *nark. pew.. • nal•bad•Rilellisdbe illfilmeleate braise raft fun 
IlliOesnen ma Wow t.
bille•••11•Iliba•••••••••••••••ltale•LObill.M1

• 411•113.1•111t et. ponderusessbet
• Iona wawa %nth men mi. AO eft*. re le.• O.c. ...eras papa:1w • "them ayastbi OS sew OWy xe now I> 'sow rasa° T.T. vc, 
• or- • ta straalln Wes WV IS
ilebaftafiriaawri oda swage!
Nana
MIS
FMILURC TO 00 SO MAY StilaJte a YOU TO CRIMaNill. PROSICUTION
YOUR NeXT REM AAAAA ION Matt: 03.05.2020
IS SI. MICPAIRrII a ie raw 11.5 Ma,
/PT 4fAcv
/04
sow..
CY/ r sr. hsercs , p • 0,Lei a, sr So. ar,IS POLS! Ir. 7r, n .skstrdri Ohs/ Aks.

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ────╮
│ ee ae                   │
│                         │
│ "HEIR Raa Ra roo Soe    │
│ tReet V1 2: prety ey ny │
╰─────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002528 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
NOG FIRE WALL -ROUTER
NOG -SWITCH -24
NDC-FOSW--16
Nina 1 a*,
/ ,anason 1/2
rat
EFTA00002565 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
Ipsoi kopor sm, 1.. 2 mommurn wommona ororms, owe .20.101,1, 0,0,041goo % ,...,_

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Se                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00004060 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
• Ti't, Most Popular Men's Club
in Florida for the Last 6 Years
Sun & Mo
In The Biz No (seer 'or our ITB Guests SIOD YOU
Battles for Everyone, induding ABSCH.
BACARDI, (UERVO, JACK & much more
Thursday
Couples Night free Admission for both, S100 Bottles
of MOET WHITESTAR for oll couples
FREE LUNCH BUFFET
WEEKDAYS, NOON-SPM 1/2 Rice on All Cocktails, Beers and
Champagne Boons Roon-Bpm
Full Nudity, Full Liquor, Full Friction Dances
Open Late 7 Nights
Sun-Wed id Sara • Thurs t I 6antl.ii-S1i
Always Hiring Ask about ournc house
www SrarlettsCaba retain
05510T
Amateur Contest
TUESDAYS roadcast live on "93 ROCK'
SW Corner of 195 & Hallandale Bch Blvd bolo Discomou rift 954-455 8318
y.
g(0 12-6
╔═══════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Musha Cay [business] island owned by David Copperfield 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00004577 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00005855 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
1
. • ...‘ le .),/)/O.41'
#
4-g7/.721 7 71
-->vwV747.5" * 747 7-1 14(P
'Z'S' -7. ' .--...71/c/n .e., "?.z. ,,,,,,,,,, . 7 /4/1-e!F

╭─── Page 1, Image 1 ───╮
│ Eel: ALLRESS          │
│ (0 ie FL SEIT         │
│                       │
│ From £2 ph Sal 9 hove │
│                       │
│ lacra bench (A        │
│ x oy ROEM             │
╰───────────────────────╯

/1/1";69 -72 ye A"- e7Y, -7720 2 ,  ICk
Tipster submitted the following: was a big part of the Jeffrey E stein scandal.
The FBI mistakenly gathered information about her aecause stole her
driver's license to enter Epstein's prope gave
"massages' and then recruited outer :irls as she got older. may be a victim or
she may be a criminal. has a lot of information about the Epstein case, but she
denies it." resides a lu ite, FL 33458. Email address
and cell phone.-
NJP Response Page 1 of 2
Unauthorized access, reproduction, or dissemination Is prohlbfted.
W- CFIVF1) AT Ocr01/2C 19 17P47 (r,
DR-
27:47 09/03/2019 00000
17:47 09/03/2019 00061 NY10100T2
TXT
JUPITER FL 33458
WELLINTON FL 33414
TYPE LIC: CLASS E OPERATOR D08: HT: 508 RACE: W SEX: F
CURRENT LICENSE ISSUED: 07/29/2011 EXPIRES: 09/16/2019 REP. LIC. ISSUED 08/11/15
VALID LICENSE SOC SEC E
This information should only be used as authorized by Florida Statute,
section 119.0712(2)(c):

1. Emergency contact information contained in a motor vehicle record is
confidential and exempt from s. 119.07(1) and s. 24(a), Art. I of the State
Constitution.

2. Without the express consent of the person to whom such emergency contact
laws://www.ejustice.ny.gov/JWIIViewMessagejsp?msgid=27883658cpageroffset 9/3/2019
NJP Response Page 2 of 2
information applies, the emergency contact information contained in a motor
vehicle record may be released only to law enforcement agencies for purposes
of contacting those listed in the event of an emergency.
EMERGENCY CONTACT INFORMATION:
PARENT
WELLINTON FL 33414
WORK: N/A CELL:
PALM BEAC GARDENS
WORK: N/A
PARENT
FL 33410
CELL:
END OF DDL/DHSMV RESPONSE.
Unauthorized access, reproduction, or dissemination is prohibited.
https://www.ejustice.ny.govIJWL'ViewMessagejsp?msgid=27883654tpager.offset=0 9/3/2019
EFTA00005932 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
Aware
N f , Al/ //e
"e.
Last Name:
First Name:
Birth Date:
Encntr Date: 11082015
Encntr Time- 0000
Person Encounter Detail
Encounter Person Detail
Last Name :
First Name :
Middle Innlal :
Gender: F
Date Of Binh :
Document Number :
Document Type:
Document Country :
Class Of Admission :
Admit Until Date :
PASSPORT
UNITED STATES
Encounter Detail
Encounter Line Type :
Encounter Date :
Encounter Time :
Terminal Lane :
Site.Cricounter Location :
ADVANCED PASSENGE
12108/2015
00 00
Innen nd 'Outbound :
Inspector:
Primary Query Result :
Referred To Agency :
OUTBOUND
No Namo No Name / 17E
3
NOT REFERRED
Manifest Data
Manifest Indicator • R Transmitted By:
Passenger Status ON BOARD Carrier Code :
FlighLAressel Number : 4 Arrival Location :
Departure Location : JFK - JOHN F KENNED‘
TK
TK
06/06/2019 15:38 EDT
U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
Generated By Page 1 of 2
Last Name First Name DOB Doc
Type
Document
Number
Date.Time Carder
Code
Carrier
Num.
110 Site I nsp Type Status Ret AFT
Loe Deo Loe
Milli P 12/08/2315
00:00
TK 4 C Name No
Name, No
APIS ON BOARD IST JFK
P 11/16/2315 TK 11 I A477 APC' TI APES ON BOARD JFK 1ST
22:10 AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, JFK
a
P 08/04/2314
00:00
DY 7012 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS REQUEST CPH JFK
a
P 03/18/2314
05:05
UA 83 I A105 APIS ON BOARD ENS DEL
P 01/1012114 VA 48 0 lame No APIS ON BOARD Pc*I SWF
00:00 Name, Ho
IIIIII P 10/15/2313 DL 245 I A471 APC APIS ON BOARD JFK FC0
16:41 AUTOMATED
PASSPORT
CONTROL, JFK
IIIIII P 09/01/2313 DL 245 C Name No APIS ON BOARD FCO JFK
00:00 Name, No
IIIIII P 04/25/2111 86 157 i A471 APIS JFK clIN
13:42
IIIII, P 04/21/2313 86 751 0 Name No APIS cm JFK
00100 Name, No
.
Cl 01/07/2)12
00:50
LR 66) 1 A 471 APIS JFK 530
P 12/30/2311 CH 237 0 Name No APIS PT? MIA
00:00 Name, No
IIIII/ P 06/28/2311 7P 104 C Name NO APIS LIS KKR
00:00 Name, No
Jr e 02/11/2311
00:00
CO 84 0 Name No
Name, No
APIS TLV SKR
Cl S 03/06/2310 AA 95) I A473 APIS JFK GRU
06:46
a il
Cl S 01/09/2310
16:09
86 868 I A471 AIRLINE.
(NOT
JFK KIN
API)
YogithworeallecortN:II
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive

╭───────────────── Page 4, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ U.S. Customs and Border Protection                │
│ U.S. Department of Homeland Security              │
│ TECS - Person Encounter List                      │
│                                                   │
│ Last Name                                         │
│                                                   │
│ First Namo                                        │
│                                                   │
│ rary                                              │
│                                                   │
│ ry                                                │
│ ted                                               │
│                                                   │
│ For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

U.S. Customs and Border Protection
U.S. Department of Homeland Security
TECS - Person Encounter List
06/06/2019 15:38 EDT
Cods Value
BEE NRWARK INTRRVATIONAI
BCM MUMBAIOCHHAPRATI SNIVAJI INTL, INDIA
MIA MIAMI INTL, FL
DEL INDIRA GANDHI INIL
1ST ATATURK
GRU SAO PAULO, BRAZIL - GUARULNOS INTL
JFK JOHN F KENNEDY INTL
KIN KINGSTON, NORMAN MANI'S)!
EC° ROME, FIUMICINO
PTY PANAMA, OMAR TORRIJOS N
LIS LISBON, LISBOA
S00 SAN JOSE, JUAN SANTAMARIA 1NIL
CPM COPENHAGEN AIRPORT
CLN CANCUN
TLV BEN OURION INTL
Gererated  By Page 2 of 2
Vales
P P PASSPORT
CI CI - PERMANENT RESIDENT CARD (1998 - 2003)
Cods Value
A473 A413 - NEW YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 8
A471 A471 - NEW YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 4
A105 A105 - NEWARK, INTL AP TERMINAL C
A477 A477 - NEW YORK, JFK AIRPORT, TERM 1
For Official Use Only / Law Enforcement Sensitive
eJusticeNY Integrated Justice Portal Pagc 1 of 1
eJusticeNYINTEGRATED JUSTICE PORTA
People • pmv Moto SvMem  • DMV Photo 12c41.;nt  + roorl!
DMV Photo Request
DMV Photo
- U J4
ADOUt >itt Mao Srtc P)Iic es
Subject Information
Name:
ClIentID:
Case Number:
DMV Transaction Number:
Bac<
DMV Transaction Date/Time: 2019.06-06 13:03:20 827
June 6, 2019 1:03 PM EDT
https://www.ejustice.ny.gov/wpsimyportalAut/p/alaY9Lc4JAEIR_Sw5edwaluB4xJgTLil9... 6/6/2019

(36) Page 1 of 2
AL About
To see Mat me mates will Intols mod Mrs hand MOST
Nana
Work andMu:ohm
Maces Ste's 1 ne•cl
Contact &XI !MK oft,
family an, ott411013/11PS
DeWitt AtoutMl
te (went;
ril Photos
P110106 Agana
Chock -Ins
No tettOCOShip into to St101,
S...
Treats Atm* friends PIMPS M0re
Add rtlottel

01101. C0INERSATI0N1
Create new VOW
https://www.facebook.com/I 6/6/2019
(36) Page 2 of 2
Mwlo
0010u. C,VIRSA IONS
Cms• 'few >ow
https://www.facebook.co 6/6/2019
Pave of 1
-
https://scontent-lga3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/26815514_10215539679745538_48346738878... 6/6/2019
6:6,2019 TLOxp - Comprehensive Report
Important:
This is NOT a CONSUMER REPORT and does not constitute a "consumer report" under the Fair Credit Reporting Act
("FCRA"). This report may not be used to determine the eligibility for credit, insurance, employment or any other
purpose regulated under the FCRA.
This system may be used only in accordance with your Subscriber Agreement, the Gramm -Leach -Bliley Act ("GLBA"),
the Driver's Privacy Protection Act ("DPPA") and all other applicable laws. User agrees to having knowledge of all
applicable laws pertaining to the usage of data. User accepts all responsibility civilly and criminally for any use of 
this
system.
Violations of these restrictions or misuse of this system will cause your access to be terminated and will cause an
immediate investigation.
Comprehensive Report
Comprehensive Report Report Legend
Date: 06/06/2019
Reference ID: NONE
Subject Information
(Best Information for Subject)
Name:.
Date of Birth:
ago
SSN: Unlock has
been ogge . issued in NEW YORK
between 2008.2010
, Bom.years
Other Individuals Observed with shared
SSN: None
Table of Contents
- Deceased Person
0 - View Address Map
84 - View Social Network(s)
Relatives
> - 1st Degree of Separation
- 2nd Degree of Separation
>>> - 3n1 Degree of Separation
Other Names Associated with Sub ect
o
Other DOBs Associated with Subject
None found
Possible Phones Associated with
Subject Show Carriers ]:
ET) (Mobile) (86%)
(ET) (VolP) (66%)
(ET) (LandLine) (66%)
Indicators
Bankruptcies: No
Liens: No
Judgments: Yes
Property. No
Corporate Affiliations: No
Criminal/Traffic: No
Global Watch Lists Match: No
The Global Watch List
Check covers 60+
sanctions and watch lists,
including OFAC (SDNs and
other lists), EU
Consolidated List, HM
Treasury Sanctions, UN
Consolidated List and
MORE
Click hero for a detailed
coverage list including
update frequency.
Email Addresses Associated
with Subject
unSocial Me ta asic earch
https://tIoxpAlo.cornrsearch.php 1/4
616/2019 TLOxp • Comprehensive Report
Subject Information
Potential Subject Photos (None Found)
Possible Criminal Records (None Found)
Possible Employers (None Found)
Address Summary (1 Found)
Address Details (1 Found)
Cities History (1 Found)
Counties History (1 Found)
Driver's License Information (1 Found)
Utilities (2 Found)
Professional Affiliations (None Found)
Professional Licenses (None Found)
Bankruptcy Records (None Found)
Liens (None Found)
Judgments (1 Found)
Current Property Deeds (None Found)
Past Property Deeds (None Found)
Property Foreclosures (None Found)
Property Assessments (None Found)
Evictions (None Found)
Current Vehicle Information (None Found)
Past Vehicle Information (None Found)
FL Accidents (None Found)
Global Watch Lists (None Found)
US Business Affiliations (None Found)
UCC Filings (None Found)
US Corporate Affiliations (None Found)
Aircraft Records (None Found)
Pilot Licenses (None Found)
Voter Registrations (None Found)
Hunting Permits (None Found)
Weapon Permits (None Found)
Possible Relatives - Summary (None Found)
Likely Associates - Summary (None Found)
Possible Associates - Summary (None Found)
Potential Subject Photos (None Found)
Possible Criminal Records (None Found)
Possible Employers (None Found)
Address Summary (1 Found)
IS, ASTORIA, NY 11106.3731 (QUEENS COUNTY)
Address Details (1 Found)
ASTORIA, NY 111063731 (QUEENS COUNTY)
ren con ains: units
Current Private Phone at address
(ET) -
Ow .
View Person Record I
PurIMMIN IE
Purchase Price:
Assessed Value: $35,167
Land Square Feet: 1,900
Cities History (1 Found)
ASTORIA, NY (QUEENS COUNTY)
Back to Summary ]
Counties History (1 Found)
https://tIoxpllo.comMearch.php 2/4
6/6/2019
QUEENS, NY
TLOxp - Comprehensive Report
Driver's License Information (1 Found)
TORIA, NY 11106.3731 (QUEENS COUNTY)
bck has been logged.
DL S
Reported Date:
Date of Birth: , Born Wears ago
Utilities (2 Found)
Name: M. [ View Person Record ]
First Seen by U • " • 12011
Date Reported:
Service Phone:
Phone Type: nown
Listing Type: Unknown
Time Zone: ET
Carrier: SPRINT SPECTRUM LP
Carrier Type: WIRELESS
City: NEW YORK CITY ZONE 8
State: NY
Billing Address: ASTORIA, NY 11106-3731 (QUEENS COUNTY)
Narne:M [ View Person Record ]
First Seen by Utilities: 04/30/2011
Date Reported:
Service Phone:
Phone Type:  Un nowr.. M
Listing Type: Unknown
Time Zone: ET
Carrier: SPRINT SPECTRUM LP
Carrier Type: WIRELESS •
City: NEW YORK CITY ZONE 8
State: NY
Billing Address: ASTORIA, NY 11106-3731 (QUEENS COUNTY)
Professional Affiliations (None Found)
Professional Licenses (None Found)
Bankruptcy Records (None Found)
Liens (None Found)
Judgments (1 Found)
View Person Record ]
111: ASTORIA, NY 11106-3731 (QUEENS COUNTY)
Filing Type: CIVIL JUDGMENT
Plaintiff: CAPITAL O N A
Court Case Number:
Total Judg
Filing Date
Current Property Deeds (None Found)
Past Property Deeds (None Found)
httpsfilloxpAlo.comisearch.php 3/4
61612019 TLOxp - Comprehensive Report
Property Foreclosures (None Found)
Property Assessments (None Found)
Evictions (None Found)
Current Vehicle Information (None Found)
Past Vehicle Information (None Found)
FL Accidents (None Found)
Global Watch Lists (None Found)
US Business Affiliations (None Found)
UCC Filings (None Found)
US Corporate Affiliations (None Found)
Aircraft Records (None Found)
Pilot Licenses (None Found)
Voter Registrations (None Found)
Hunting Permits (None Found)
Weapon Permits (None Found)
Possible Relatives - Summary (None Found)
Likely Associates - Summary (None Found)
Possible Associates - Summary (None Found)
htipsfilloxp.tio.com/search.php 4/4
EFTA00005994 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00006066 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
vJ - 7- Pkitaten, er
•••••••• •In•
a Cower number
0017 66/188
Vdd II omsmo.16466666188 0017
illiatlon numb. r CEIN) 1 erepes,Ips.olia candenssien
7890.65
2 Federal Interne tax Wthheid s
714.35
c Employees name, address, and ZP code
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
3 SOON security want;
7890.65
4 Sethi *acuity tax wlfiteld
489.22
358 8L BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
s Medicate wages and Ups
7890.65
0 Medicare to vitinekt
114.41
7 Social security bps 8 Allocated lips
9 Advance EC payment 10 Dependent care benefits
. • ... Sup. 11 Nonqualifled plans 12a See Instructons for box 12
: C I 6.00
13 tame Art Ir pir 12b
MIAMI BEACH, FL 33139 El fl ri I 14 Other 12c
i I pd iL
I Employee's address and ZIP codo
m..a.iiici4..it
15 Sate Employers no illi weber
VL
16 Slate %nos, tips. etc. 17 Stale mccmo tax 18 Lad wages, tips, etc. 10 Local Sorra tax 20 Wally rime
W0 Wage and Tax
- 2 Statement
‘--For Employer.
2006 D0p3nrilallt of the Trossury—Internal Parent* Service
For Privacy Act and Paperwork Reduction
Act Notice, ace back at Copy D.
a C./mud number
0017 66/18E Void O si
c•Ae No. tS4S-0008 18E 0017 biliiiir number ono i Wasps. has. other compensation
38536.47 2 Federal income tax vrithhekl
3463.23 i...‘ EmplOyer's name, address, and ZIP code
'JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 358 EL BRILLO WAY PALM BEACH, FL 33480
3 Social security wages
38536.47 4 Social secunty tax witnheld
2389.26 5 Medicare wages end tips
38536.47 6 Medcare tax withheld
558.78 7 Sodal security tips 8 Allocated tips
o Advance BC payment 10 Dependent care benefits
•
f Employee's address and ZIP code
11 Norgualified plans 12a See instructions,
IC for box 12
I 28.62 13 Se:iilg or  /tor

n. El n il 21) i
I 14 Other 12c
12d
A 15 Su* Employer's mate ID number
FL  i
___I
16 $ale wages, lips. etc. 17 State income lax 18 Local vow, fee, etc 19 Local income tax 20 Locally name
Form IN-2 Wage and Tax
Statement
Copy 0 -For Employer.
2005 Department of the Treasury—Internal Revenue Service
For Privacy Act end Paperwork Reduction
Act Notice, see back of Copy D.
a Control number
Void El OMB No. 1545-0008
b Employer identification number (E/N) 1 Wages. tips, other compernal0n 2 Federal income tax relate!
c Employer's name. address, and ZIP code 3 Soda; socially wages 4 Social security lax wittteld
5 Medicare wages and tips 6 Medicare tax withheld
7 Soma security lips 8 Allocated tips
d Employee's social security number 9 Advance SIC payment 10 Dependent care benefits
e Empbyee's lust nave and initial Last name
f Employee's address and ZIP cede
11 NOnquaGfred plans e12a See 1/1.5111.1C1i011S
S
for box 12
1 13 anat. m saan/ efrobste win w
El n n nb c
. I
14 ()lbw 12e c
S I 120 c •
77
A 15 Ste. Employer's slate ID number
•
16 Slam wagon, ups, etc. 117 State income tax
f
18 Local wages, tips. etc.
,
19 Local exam lax 20 Locally name
'1-2 Wage and Tax
Statement
'or Employer.
200.5 Department of the Treasury—Imemal Revenue Serene
For Privacy Act and Paperwork Reduction
Act Notice. see back of Copy D.
EFTA00006374 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
A 3-cvmagThat.1 -

V II
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR -T -: F. .
s's:/42,3 -DATE TIME _56:! )2 :  9  A.
M
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED ,,)‹ ..1 PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
.,....--
SIGNED k a
II"
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR 3 -  • 5 -
DATE 7 9  3 40-5-- TIME l :
•M
•
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL ■
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN ■
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
/ en -it
SIGNED a 1 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR J -- /--€
DATE 1/0/4 7/0 7-C TIME Yvetr
R4 --- C- oAt - dy Xerer
/
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU. I WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
7:011--9„ ),Veng etat22 / .44.0,
Cr/ a, /1 -# be 44/eat
/0 '42j  - /0 34° P/Y
SIGNED 11184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR / 41 / 1 fie( et
DAT 0-.2-0S TIME f
Q
••
30 A.M PM.
M
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED V PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
SIGNED 1184

O.1\-t 11%
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR S g
DATE  a -- TIME tall--SH...te
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED X PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU • WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH ,
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
SIGNED...T
•. Ws 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR 0- - El
DATE si a 1 / b -r • TIME -/C I P.
M in T5 l -OCKn4a
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH '
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
a SIGNED -1,--  1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR 3 .-  . /F.
DAT O / --- TIME . 7.1-s
M
.
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED, PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU ROSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSA , i
Co a 41
girdatiliP7
air - 4 Pat
----,
SIGNED_1„ 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR t • ..3-- DATE l' e2 / Ds IS e
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED X PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN .
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
......... a SIGNED 1 11134

• • Messages
.Tr
••
=
4:27PM II had n the line for you. . 6 4:
•  11 r:
4:2 APIs call. 8PM
M
Mr'
11:ISOPM
4:55PM

• I had n the line for you. He will call back since he
has n he library.
I forwarded helicopter pictures from
yahoo.
can work tomorrow at 4pm.
Outstanding
4:56PM
Callers
4:56PM
got her aesthetician license and can not do facials.
GYM works in Pails: 3 weeks 1/2 to finish. Pinto waiting for a
starting date ( possibly 8 days of advance to organize it).
Pagc4of4 C9'14 162
The mail server Is down; but I will email the plans as soon as I
can.
li/late:bgekedifaireria ,
li
t-,q5i2sz)_9tsS ta_relmfom)   tiyitgrimri ormTrffi tmnIt%
Copyright (c) 2000-2004, Epstein interests, Inc. All Rights Reservet
http://dommOl/foxhaven/wc.d117Gmay—Kszpisplay 4/11/2005
EFTA00007157 (Jmail)
 [government] victim list and police log
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH -POLICE DEPARTMENT

• Incident Report
Page:
NI 111I Program: CS3 C: 1L
Case No  1-05-000368
SPECIAL NOTES : DO NOT RELEASE Occur From Date: 1/27/05 0000
Occur To Date : 1/27/05 0000 Report Date . : 3/14/05 1600
Day Of Week . : Thursday,
Common/Location: 358 EL BRILLO WY
City  • PALM BEACH, FL
Location Type : RESIDENCE -SINGLE
Beat Assignment: DETECTIVE BUREAU
Dept Class . .
Case Status . :
Supervisory Dt. :
Entry Date
Names')
Vehicles?
Narrative?
*********VEHICLE
Case number . : 1-05-000368
State Veh Type :
Make
Model Name . . :
Style . . . .
Color - Bottom :
VIN
Disposition . :
Insured by . . :
Vehicle locked :
Date recovered : 0/00/00
Street number
City
Recovery code
Be On Look Out?:
*********PERSO N R
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City  • WEST PALM BEACH,
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . . :
Sex  • t talen
Home Phone No. :
Weight   0
**************
FAMILY
Map Reference
Report Officer
Case Status Dt
3/14/05
4/06/05
Property? •
Offenses?
Related Cases?
: 10
: 1/11/15
N FORMATION #
Category . , . :
Year
Model
Permit Number
Color - Top
License #
Stolen value . • : 0
Insured
Keys in car . :
Lein holder
Recovery value : 0
NCIC number . :
P ORTING
Last Name
1 *********************
N F O -
:1 • 4
FL 33412
Employer?
Oper Lic No
Race
Height
Other Phone Nbr:
SUSPECT/ARRESTEE INFO
Case Number . : 1-05-000368 Prompt valid in:
Street Number
City
Birth Date .
Employer? .
Oper Lic NO.   :
Other Phone Nbr:
Sex  •
Minimum Weight :
ROYAL PALM BEA
Female
PL 334121460
Maximum Age
Occupation . .
FL Home Phone No.
Race
Minimum Height
Maximum Height
# 1
*********
FL,
RMATION- # 1
: In
White
: 0
: 0
* *
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
Case No
Maximum Weight :
Aliases? . . :
Hair Color . :
Hair Style .
Glasses . . •
Facial Hair
Teeth
Hat
Shirt
Shoes
•
Body Marks #2 :
Body Marks #4 :
Arrest Case No.:
**************
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 2
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
S
Case Number . :
Street Number :
City
Birth Date . .
Employer? . .
Oper Lic No. .
Other Phone Nbr:
Sex   Fema
Minimum Weight : 0
Maximum Weight : 0
Aliases •
Hair Color .
Hair Style .
Glasses . .
Facial Hair •
Teeth  •
Hat
Shirt
Shoes
Body Marks #2 :
Body Marks #4 :
Arrest Case No.:
**************
Case Number .
Street Number
City
Birth Date . . :
Employer? . . :
Oper Lic No. . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Sex  •
Minimum Weight :
Maximum Weight :
Aliases 9
Hair Color . . :
Hair Style . . :
1-05-000368
0 Misc. ID# . .
MO/Crime Spec?
Hair Length .
Eye Color . .
Complexion .
Build
Speech
Coat
Pants
Body Marks #1 :
Body Marks #3 :
Status   STILL SUSPECT
Additional UCR?:
(Continued)
•
USPECT/ARRESTEE INFORMATIO1 - 1.
1-05-000368 Prompt valid in:
358 EL BRILLO WY
PALM BEACH. FL 000033480
Maximum Age .
Occupation . .
Home Phone No
Race
e Minimum Height
Maximum Height
Misc. ID# . .
MO/Crime Spec?
Hair Length •
Eye Color .
Complexion .
Build
Speech
Coat
Pants
Body Marks #1 :
Body Marks #3 :
Status
Additional UCR?:
SUSPECT/AR
: 1-05-000368
: 358 EL BRILLO WY
PALM BEACH FL 000033480
Maximum Age
Occupation . .
FL Home Phone No
Race
Male Minimum Height
0 Maximum Height
0 Misc. ID#

• mo/crime Spec?
Hair Length .
Eye Color . .
RESTEE INFO
Prompt valid in:
IIISONAL ASST/EPSTEIN
ite
STILL SUSPECT
RMATION-
EPSTEIN, JEFFREY
: 52
White
: 0
: 0
# 3 **
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 3
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368
'Glasses .
Facial Hair
Teeth
Hat
Shirt  •
Shoes
Body Marks #2 :
Body Marks #4 :
Arrest Case No. :
•
. :
************** V
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Prompt valid in: ■
Street Number
City   WEST
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . . : STUDENT
Home Phone No.
Sex   Female
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : JUVENILE
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
************** VICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex  • Female
Weight  • 0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : ADULT
Residency Sts :
Can Identify .
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
************** yicTIm
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
PALM BEACH, FL 33412
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
Complexion
Build
Speech
Coat
Pants
Body Marks #1 :
Body Marks #3 :
Status  • STILL SUSPECT
Additional UCR?:
(Continued)
I C T I M INFORMATION -# 1 ********************
•
•
White
INFORMATION - # 2
Prompt valid in: •
PALM BEACH FL 000033480
********************
Employer? . . :
Oper Lic No. . :
Race  • White
Height
Misc. ID#
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
• 0
INFORMATION -# 3 ********************
Prompt valid in:
PALM BEACH, FL 000033480
Employer?
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 4
Prograin: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
Occupation
Home Phone No. :
Sex   Female
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . :
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
JUVENILE Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Med Treatment : Phys First Name:
Phys Last Name :
************** ICTIM INFORMATION -# 4 ********************
Case Number . : 1-05-000368 Prompt valid in:
Street Number :
City • PALM BEACH FL 000033480
Birth Date/Age Employer? . . :
Occupation . . : Oper Lic No.
Home Phone No. : Race  • White
Sex  Female Height  0
Weight  0 Misc. ID# . . :
Be On Look Out?: Other Phone Nbr:
Victim Type .
Residency Sts
Can Identify .
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment
Phys Last Name
Oper Lic No. . :
Race •
Height
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
White
(Continued)
**************
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City  • PALM BEACH
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex  • Female
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : ADULT
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
: JUVENILE
ICTIM
************** V
Case Number . :
Prompt valid in:
ICTIM
1-05-000368
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
INFORMATION -# 5********************
Prompt valid in:
FL 000033480
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race   White
Height   0
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
.Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
. :
. :
INFORMATION -# 6 ********************
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 5
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City  •
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex •
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . :
Residency Sts
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
**************
PALM BEACH. FL 000033480
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID#
Other Phone Nbr:
JUVENILE Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
Female
✓ICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City  • PALM BEACH
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex   Female
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type .
Residency Sts
Can Identify .
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment
Phys Last Name
**************
: JUVENILE
✓ICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . .
Home Phone No.
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type : JUVENILE
Residency Sts
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name
PALM BEACH
Female
************** ✓ICTIM
(Continued)
White
INFORMATION -# 7********************
Prompt valid in:
FL 000033480
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race   White
Height   0
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID .
Phys First Name:
. :
. :
INFORMATION -# 8 ********************
Prompt valid in:
FL 000033480
Employer? . . :
Oper Lic No. . :
Race   White
Height   0
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
INFORMATION -# 9********************
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 6
Program: CMS301L
Case No
Case Number .
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . :
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
************** V
Case Number . :
Prompt valid in:
Street Number :
City  •
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex  •
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . :
Residency Sts :
Can Identify .
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
************** V
Case Number . :
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type .
Residency Sts
Can Identify .
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment
1-05-000368
1-05-000368
PALM BEACH. FL
ema e
JUVENILE
ICTIM
1-05-000368
PALM BEACH. FL
Female
JUVENILE
ICTIM
1-05-000368
PALM BEACH. FL
Female
ADULT
Prompt valid in:
Employer? . • :
Oper Lic No. • :
Race  • White
Height   0
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
(Continued)
INFORMATION -# 10 *******************
Employer? . . :
Oper Lic No.
Race   White
Height   0
Misc. ID# .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
INFORMATION -# 11 *******************
Prompt valid in:
Employer?
Oper Lic No. . :
Race   White
Height   0
Misc: ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 7 )
Program: CMS301L
Case No -1-05-000368
Phys Last Name :
************** VICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No.
FemaleSex
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : ADULT Residency Type :
Residency Sts : File Charges . :
Can Identify . : Victim Sobriety:
Injury Extent : Injury Type 1 :
Injury Type 2 : Hospital ID . :
Med Treatment : Phys First Name:
Phys Last Name :
PALM BEACH. FL
(Continued)
INFORMATION -# 12 *******************
Prompt valid in:
Employer?
Oper Lic No.
Race  • White
Height  • 0
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
************** V
Case Number . :
Street Number :
City  •
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex  •
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : JUVENILE Residency Type :
Residency Sts : File Charges . :
Can Identify . : Victim Sobriety:
Injury Extent Injury Type 1 :
Injury Type 2 : Hospital ID . :
Med Treatment : Phys First Name:
Phys Last Name :
ICTIM
1-05-000368
INFORMATION -# 13 *******************
Prompt valid in:
PALM BEACH FL 000033480
Employer?
Oper Lic No.
Race  • White
Height  • 0
0 Misc. ID# . :
Other Phone Nbr:
. :
. :
************** VICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : JUVENILE
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
PALM BEACH, FL
Female
INFORMATION -# 14 *******************
Prompt valid in:
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID#
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
White
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 8
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment
Phys Last Name :
************** VICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number
City  • PALM BEACH FL
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex   Female
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : ADULT
Residency Sts
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment
Phys Last Name :
************** ICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number
City  •
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex  • Female
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : JUVENILE
Residency Sts
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment
Phys Last Name :
**************
PALM BEACH FL
VICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No.
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : JUVENILE
Residency Sts
PALM BEACH FL
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
INFORMATION - # 15
Prompt valid in:
Employer?
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID#
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
(Continued)
*******************
White
INFORMATION - # 16
Prompt valid in:
*******************
Employer?
Oper Lic No. .
Race   White
Height   0
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
INFORMATION - # 17
Prompt valid in:
*******************
Employer? . .
Oper Lic No. ,
Race   White
Height   0
Misc. ID# . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 9
Programl CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Can Identify . : Victim Sobriety:
Injury Extent : Injury Type 1 :
Injury Type 2 : Hospital ID . :
Med Treatment : Phys First Name:
Phys Last Name :
*********
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number
City
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . .

• t llem
Home Phone No. :
Sex   ae
Weight  • 0
Other Phone Nbr:
OTHER PERSON
********* 0
INFO
Last Name
RMATION
FL 33411
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Person Type
THER PERSON
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number : 358 EL BRILLO WY
City  • PALM BEACH FL 000033480
Birth Date/Age : Employer? . •
Home Phone No. : Race
IllOccupation . . : Oper Lic No. . •
Sex   Female Height
Weight   0 Person Type : THER PERSON
Other Phone Nbr:
White
: OTHER PERSON
III ,- 1 *********
********* 0
Case Number
Street Number
City
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . .
Home Phone No
Sex
THER PERSON
: 1-05-000368

• ROYAL PALM BEACH,
Female
Weight   0
Other Phone Nbr:
********* 0
INFORMATION - 2*********
Last Name . . :
INFORMATION - *********
Last Name . . :
FL 33411
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race   White
Height   0
Person Type : OTHER PERSON
THER PERSON
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . .
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Other Phone Nbr:

• ROYAL PALM BEACH, FL
INFORMATION - 4*********
Last Name . . :
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
White
0 Person Type : OTHER PERSON
********* 0
Case Number
THER PERSON
. : 1-05-000368
INFORMATION  5*********
Last Name . .
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
Case No
Street Number :
City
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
1-05-000368
Page: 10
Program: ams3on
(Continued)
Birth Date/Age : Employer? . •
•
Occupation . . : Oper Lic No. . :
Home Phone No. : Race  • White
Sex  • Fema e Height  • 0
Weight  • 0 Person Type . : OTHER PERSON
Other Phone Nbr:
Case Number .
Employer Name
Address . . .
City/State/Zip
Phone Number .
***EMPLOYER INFORMATION***
:. 1-05-000368
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33407
*********OTHER PERS
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number
City   WELLINGTON FL 33414
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . . : STUDENT
Home Phone No. :
Sex   Ma e
Weight . . . : 0
Other Phone Nbr:
Case Number . :
Address . . . :
City/State/Zip :
Phone Number . :
O N INFORMATION *********
Last Name . .
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race   White
Height   0
Person Type : OTHER PERSON
***EMPLOYER INFORMATION***
1-05-000368 Employer Name
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33415
*********OTHER PERSO
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City  • WEST PALM BEACH,
Birth Date/Age : 0/00/0000 0
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex  • Male
Weight  • 0
Other Phone Nbr: '
********* O THER PERSO
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City • WEST PALM BEACH,
Birth Date/Age : 0/00/0000 0
Occupation . . :
Sex  • Female
Home Phone No. :
N INFORMATION - 7 *********
Last Name . . :
FL 33412
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race   White
Height   0
Person Type : OTHER PERSON
N INFORMATION -# 8*********
Last Name . .
FL 33411
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height  • 0

Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 11
Program: ams3olL
Case No
Weight
Other Phone Nbr:
1-05-000368
OTHER P E R
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. : I
Sex  • Female
Weight  0
Other Phone Nbr:
Original Report 1,0
Person Type
(Continued)
: OTHER PERSON
S O N INFORMATION -# 9*********
Last Name . . :
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33417
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Person Type
White
: OTHER PERSON
NARRATIVE  # 1
Reported By:
Entered By. :
On 03/14/2005, I received a call from a woman who did  not wish to
identify herself (later identified as I ). She stated
that her fourteen year old step daughter (later identified as
) possibly ma have been 'MI. in Palm Beach by a wea lthy
man. According to she earn of the possible'
by a third party. S e exp ained that she had received a call from the
mother of her stepdaughter's friend. The mother claimed to have
overheard a conversation between her daughter and a male friend; they
were talking about . The conversation was about how had met
with a 45- ear -old man and had sex with him and was paid or it. I
advised that I would like to meet with her to obtain a more
detailed statement and facts. stated she did not know what
to do and had to discuss the matter with her husband. At this point
did not provide me with a call back number or any other
information. She stated that she would contact me once she had spoken
with her husband and mother.
•
On 03/14/2005 received a call from III I . They stated
it was all right to speak to their aughter via cell phone III
Her mother IIIIIII had been ma e aware of the case.
They agreed to meet me at the police department later this date.
9/20/05
9/20/05
On 03 14/2005, Mr. accompanied by his wife
came to the Palm Beach Po ice Department where they advised
me that they believed their fourteen year old daughter may have had
some type of sexual relationship with an older male who resided in
Palm Beach. Neither knew the suspect's name or address. Both stated
that their daughter did not talk to them about the incident, nor would
she admit to it.
identified his daughter as ME
wjf DOB • resides with her biological mother
at , RPB, 33411,
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 12
Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368
her sister resides with Mr.
currentl atten in
the fame ies to provi•e one on one as we
According to Mrs. she believes
Sunday, Feb 6, 2005. A riend of
their house and left. They believe
with the older gentleman, though they
lives close by with her mother. Mrs.
was introduced to. b
goes to
that on Sunday, pic up
they met the man. Supposedly, t e man has a lot of money and often
has young girls come over to his house. III' offers these girls a
way to make fast cash. The man starts wit a massa e. If he likes
them, he keeps them around and does more. The
other than she lives on
did not have
any information on , the
(Continued)
Both and are
is an
ILI
Rschool w i
a so coor•Inates with
as amily counseling.
Mrs.
foun
the call
between
Mrs.
the incident occurred on
named IIIII picked her up at
initiates the relationshi
not have any proof.
further explaine t at
a boy she was dating
Mrs. continued
rove to Pa m Beach where
talked of a conversation that she had with
e mother of a former friend of She
strange that they were no onger friends until she received
from her mother tellini iiii of the conversation she overheard
and a boy named
told me of an incident
of into a fight at school ( Mrs.
found over $300.00 in purse.

gave different
explanations for the large sum of money. Initially the school
administration thought it was drug related but then dismissed the
claim. Since that day,
ay
not return to school; she ran away
Thursday, 02/10th or Fri ay 02/11 and returned to her mother's house
later that night after
'
midni ht. It was not until after
III.' received the call from mother,
that she earned IIIIII was the girl that got into
fight wit The fight was instigated when accused
being a prostitute.
who has legal joint custody of his daughter
signed the affidavit of prosecution indicating he wished to
prosecute against the inappropriate sexual behavior with his
fourteen -year-old daughter.
that occurred on 02/09/2005.
Mr. stated that he had no objections with our
with his daughter about the incident. Mr.
mother is aware of the allegations an a
cooperate. According to Mrs. she does not
daughter had any additional contact with the suspect
the
of
agency speaking
stated that
so was willing to
believe her
as she was with
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 13
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS30lL
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
her mother and then placed into
the School Board Police who provided me the information
also known as
, West Palm Beach, Florida. Chec ing e
sc o0 oar recor s for and , there was no
disciplinary record found. I was advised if no disciplinary action
was taken for a fight, such as an expulsion or detention, the incident
may not have been recorded. This was at the discretion of the
individual school security and principal.
03/15/2005, I called the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office and left a
message for PBSP Sgt. , Child Abuse Unit.
On 03/15/2005, I went to
female I.  Also present was
therapist. During an audiotaped interview I hs e wit
about the allegations that were made. init.. enie
anything had ha ened onl admitting to going with (later
owed. en a.
identified as to Palm Beach to pick u money was
ile as the of her former
She u imM ildmitted to nowing that
wor e• or a wea t iman and possibly did sexual favors for him. S e
also admitted that IIIIII had offered her an opportunity to make
money.
where I met with white
identified boss as a white male named "Jeff" who
ive in Palm Beach ater positively identified as Jeffrey Epstein) .
explained that she was first a roached by to go with
er to Jeff's house, when they were at house. According to
she was not sure exactl
agree to o with her.
he heard inviting
it was to p— icck up money t e man owed state
told her that she would pick her up at er ouse on Sunday.
was not sure of the exact dates but knew it was a Sunday. According
to along with an unknown ossibly
pie e er up at er father's house on
father that they were oin shopping. It was ater
that icked his daughter up.
drove a
what was going on with but
boyfriend) became angry when
to accomoany her. believed
female,
told her
confirmed by
According to Mr.
drove along with the unknown female to Palm Beach.
O i
Sometime on tit wa t ere, a conversation occurred between and
whereby told IIIIIIII that if Jeff asked her
age, s e should say s e was eighteen.
t IIIIIIII ree girls walked up a drivewa
guard/security room. In fact,
them asking what they wanted.
Jeff. The male allowed them to
recalled that Jeff's house was on a dead end street. All
act what appeared to be a small
recalled a male approaching
stated they were there to see
continue walking up to the house.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
Case No • 1-05-000368
Page: 14
Program: CMS301L
(Continued)
stated the man told them that Epstein was not there but was
expecte back. He allowed them to enter the house, via the kitchen.
He offered them something to drink while they waited inside. Shortly
after, Epstein and a woman, described as white with hair entered
the kitchen. believed the woman was Epstein's Assistant.
added t at t e woman did not seem friendly and kept her
responses short and direct. Epstein introduced himself to as
Jeff . got the impression that Epstein and riend
forty-five years oilliF ing face, and bushy eyebrows, with graying
knew eac. of er. described Epstein as being approximately
hair.
and left the kitchen leaving
rien alonlill ille kitchen. They returned a
and
s ore time ater. They
all spoke briefly in the kitchen. While speaking to me,
became upset and started to cry. stated the woman instructed
her to follow her upstairs, which s e i According to the
woman led her to a room that had a massage table in it. T e woman
started to fix up the room, uttin the covers on the table and taking
lotions out. She then told that Epstein would be up in a
and told
second. The woman left the room, and soon afte  walked in
to take off her clothes. Aswas telling me
what had appene , she looked away from me and inted finger,
repeatedly pressed it into her thigh. stated he was stern
when he told her to take off her clothes. said she did not
know what to do as she was the only one there.
shirt leaving her bra on. E stein, dressed in a tower old her t
take o every ing. sta e s e remove er pants leaving
her thong panties on. pstein then instructed her to give him a
massage pointing to a specific lotion for her to use. Epstein laid on
the table, face down. As bean to give Epstein the massage,
he told her to •et on hi stated she straddled herself
on E•steln's back
e turne• aroun
giving Epstein t e massage,
later explained that
stated she was dis usted by
Epstein's actions •ut si• not say an ing. According to
Epstein told her that she "had a really hot body." Epstein excuse
hlmself and went to the bathroom where she believed he masturbated
Epstein returned to the room and told that he was
one and gave her three hundred dollars. They went ack down stairs
asked ow i it go and asked what did she ( iliol l
where the met Epstein said good-bye and the left
allegedly stated "I row." stated they then went shopping.
When told that stein asked for a massage,
stated
con
got aid, but that she did not know why
since s e was con i ent that did not do anything.
described Epstein's house as a two story pink house with a
Ca i ac Escalade parked in the drivewa . There were gates leading
O illill into the property. From the kitchen, recalled walking up a
flight of stairs, lined with photograp s, to a room. Upon entering
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 15
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
the room there was a large bathroom to the right. recalled a
hot pink and reen sofa in the room. There was a door on each side of
the sofa. recalled there being a mural of a naked woman.Ili, in
the room, as we as several photographs of naked women on a shelf.
stated Epstein did not change in front of her but did take
o as towel, exposing himself. recalled Epstein being
hairy especially on his chest. s ein a so had a hairline that
continued to his buttocks. dmitted to seeing his penis. I
asked if she knew w atbeing circumcised meant and she stated
no. then said that she thought Epstein was on steroids
because e was a "really built guy and his wee wee was very tiny."
would explain that when she stated "wee wee" she meant penis.
stated Epstein exposed himself when he took his towel off,
p acing it on the floor as he laid down on the table.
said Epstein was specific in his instruction to her on how to
massage, telling her to go clockwise, etc. recalled that
Epstein got up from the table and went to the bat room where she heard
him making, what she believed to be sexual type of noises. (moaning)
He then returned to the room where he again laid down on the table.
Epstein then turned over and instructed
As she did this, Epstein continued to ma e moaning noises.
resumed massaging his chest area.
on t e ground. Epstein turned to his side
ground
stated Epstein
ta e.
his chest.
to
was now standing
an wit the towel on the
reca e
to wipe himself as e got o t e
a so reca e. Epstein having a noticeable freckle on
Epstein then left the room and got dressed. She went back
downstairs where she met an t e unknown white female.
admitted to getting paid III hundred dollars in cash from Epstein.
Before they left, Epstein asked to leave her phone number.
As they were leaving the house asked what had happened
and how much she was paid. stated seemed upset or
"ifs when she told her that s e received three hundred dollars.
stated received onliiiii hundred dollars that day.
stated that she believed was paid two hundred dollars for
bringing her.
IIIIII told that if they do this every Saturday, they could
be rich; agreed. They then went shoppin though she is not
sure where. Posse ly at TJ Maxx or Marshall's. stated she
never saw a ain as she got into a fight at sc oo . She had
not spoken wit either as her mother took away her cell phone.
I asked if she was aware of any video equipment while she was
in the jill iqe stated no.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 16
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
stated she was afraid that
ice
retaliate
orherfamily if she ever went to the •o ice regarding the
stated that her father's was recently
admitted to te
Accor ing to
l. w a ad happened wi
•ecame angry and u set, punchin a hole
t Epstein.
in the wall. guessed that it was who told
about the inci en , and now there were rumors in school about
and what she did with Epstein.
against her
incident.
I then talked to about truth and lying. We talked about the
color sweater she was wearing. denied having sexual
intercourse with stein. She enie ouchin his penis.
again admitted
agreed to cooperating with the police department in placing a
p one call to in a controlled setting. I met with Ms.
and advised her o the families' as well as IIII
willingness to cooperate with this investigation. Copies of this
interview were placed into evidence.
I made contact with mother of I
advised her briefly o my investigation. She was aware o'll!!
incident and stated that she overheard a portion of a conversation
that her daughter was having with a boy named
that it was her opinion that both girls liked
recalled hearing her daughter calling a w ore.
stated
admitted that she did not listen to the entire conversation ut id
confront her daughter about it later. told her mother that
somethin to the effect that hilillipt with an older man for
money. stated that s e would not object to me speaking with
her daug er. It was s belief that everyone in the school
i ve known about t is ecause of the fight that her daughter
and had gotten into. I reminded
was an ongoing investigation and requested she not
that I had contacted her. She agreed.
On 03/16/2005, PESO Sgt. left a message that he was
returning my call. I spo e wi and discussed the case with him
and inquired if he had an ropen allegations or cases where the suspect
iii resided in Palm Beach. stated he was unaware of any.
offered any assistance i needed. IIII stated it was his experience
that due to the age of the parties involved, it would be difficult to
interview them and expect the investigation to remain confidential.
that this
iscuss the fact
Because of the time delay, there was no need for the victim to be
taken to a medical facility for a physical for the purpose of
obtaining evidence.
On 03/17/2005, I queried Jeffery Epstein on the internet and obtained
Date: 7/25/06 Page: 17 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: 00$48301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
a hoto of Epstein to be used in a photo line up. I met with
at which time she viewed the photo line up. She imme lately
recognized Epstein and pointed to him (Position 45). signed
the photo line up under Epstein's picture. This sign ine up was
placed into evidence.
On 03/18/2005, I met with at her residence
placing a controlled call to .
and asked if she could arrange anot er meeting wit
stated that she would have to call him and make the
copy of this conversation was placed into evidence.
03/19/2005, I s oke with
advised that
uncle. is sc e uled
03/21/2005, I coordinated with
surveillance on 358 El Brillo.
for the purpose
spoke with
Jeff.
arrangements. A
and and was
tl...lte to visit wit er aunt and
to return to Florida on 03/27/2005
PB BSF Unit and OCVAN to initiate
of
03/21/2005, Coordinated with Det. re ardin trash pulls from 358
El Brillo. On this same date I ca ed to schedule an
appointment to speak with She state t e sc ool guidance
counselor was reluctant toll. police presence at the school. I
assured her that I would respond to the school in civilian clothes and
an unmarked vehicle.
called me back and advised that I did not need to make
an appointment to see
I received a return phone call from stating that
would be attending the with
I received messages from
I conducted a computer query on Epstein. The results of this query
indicated the most recent driver's license on file for Epstein was for
the state of Florida, which had expired.
A cross reference of Epstein s residence,
revealed the followin affiliated names:
w/m dob
Maxwell, uk , coy A computer
history.
On 03/23/2005, I spoke with cell phone wk . I
requested that she not discuss e incident with anyone inc u ing her
daughter as I did not want the investigation compromised. I was
told at t is time that IIIII and have not been getting along due
to the fact that IIIII has ecided to continue living with her father.
On 03 29/2005, I placed telephone calls to both the and
residences requesting to speak with them regar ing the
358 El Brillo, Palm Beach,
w/f, dob
, & G is aine N.
query for both returned no
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 18
Program: CMS30lL
Case No   1-05-000368
investi ation. I received return phone calls from Mrs.
Mrs. and advised them that I would be contacting
to coordinate a time to meet with
chedi ll be disrupted aslittle asi
was at the re est o oth and Mrs. that
a sou ate t em to t e investigation thus far. Both
IIIs•ea in•
stated thehe had no objection to my meeting with
she identified the cell phone
as eing t e phone assigned to
ha• no objections and provided consent to giving
po ice •e artment for the use of placing controlled phone

it. stated the phone had been taken away from as part
of her unis ent for not doing well in school. According to
used to be an excellent student, but in the past two
mont s has become irritable, verbally abusive to the family and has
opposite ofii• stated they are going le normall is. IM
run away. stated her daughter's recent behavior is the
through wit t .L e school but none of this had
come up. Arrangements were ma e for Det. to retrieve
the cell phone from at her place o• emp oyment.
I called and requested to speak
with Ms. Upon she advised me that she
was in the mi dle of an would call me back once the
IIIII!. were complete• Ms. stated the sessions should be
cone u ed by 7:00 PM. At approximately 8:00PM I had called Ms.
at which time I left a message on her voice mail requesting a return
phone call. I spoke with Ms. and advised her that I did not
meet with her daughter and that I would again attempt to coordinate a
school schedule. time with the counselor so as not to disrupt
had no objections. Shortly after speaking with Ms.
I received a call from Ms. I explained the situation and
requested a time to meet wit Back reviewed schedule and
advised that would be available after 3:00PM.
(Continued)
and
e. I
and
In
er of
Ms.
It to the
calls from
On 03 30 2005, I met with M and at s.
. I reminded of er conversation wit
During t is time initiate a conversation with me in w ich
she admitted that s e was not telling me everything that had ha ened
during the time she was alone with Epstein. According to
while she and Epstein were alone on the second floor Epstein used a
stated there
I
i Epstein ever as e• er age an• s e state• he had.
stated she told him she was eighteen. When Epstein asked
what school she was in, responded she was in the twelfth
grade at During t e course of this incident,
stated Epstein to her that had worked for him for years.
We then continued with the controlled call to
one,
At
approximately 3:35 from her cell p one, made a call to
home, was not home. was told
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 19
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
•
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
was at working a double and could be reached on her
W/F, is em loyed at III
, ocated on in Wellington.
that
cell
called During the conversation between
an asked what happened, s a inq t at
she a ear rumors that
asked if they, meaning
claimed to have heard t at
Jeffrey. tol•
know anything a out Epstein.
someone to work tomorrow and as
stated she would call Epstein and then call
was going to press charges.
arents, knew about Jeffery.
father had found out alt
hat the her parents) did not
told that Epstein needed
if she was available.
back.
During the course of these conversations with , she would
at times appear to be articulate and well spoken. S e wou d then
'III,
start to act in an immature manner b looking around, not paying
attention, drawing on a paper. would offer me a high five
whenever she claimed to have to] me t e truth in the details of the
afternoon at Epstein's house. would sit in the chair, with
her knees propped up to her chest as s e admitted that she did not
tell me the all the details of her encounter with Epstein during our
first meeting. As a means of positive reinforcement I would high five
On 03 31 2005 sub oenaliiifests for
an d an p one
numbers were ra to .
On 04/01/2005, I met with members of PB BSF Unit for the purpose of
conducting surveillance on 358 El Brillo. Cross-reference supplement.
On 04/01/2005, I met with Det. of the Palm Beach Police
Department who provided me a collilcithe concealed weapons permit for
Mr. Epstein. It revealed Epstein had a valid permit. There was no
current photo attached to the renewal notice.
On this same date I queried various different web sites for a possible
identification of the purple item retrieved from the trash pull from
358 El Brillo. The item was similar in description as the one
described by and used by Epstein.
I made contact with Spicygear.com and spoke with the owner
emailed a photograph of the item for his opinion. He identi ie the
items as a Jelly Anal Wand of some sort. The item is easily available
at sex shops in South Florida.
04/06/2005, I conducted business queries into Epstein utilizing the
internet. I located articles relating to financial reports. There
was no local history.
On 04/01/2005 - 04/03/2005, with the assistance of there was
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
Case No • 1-05-000368
continued surveillance on the property.
On 04/04/2005, I obtained a cop of voice mail messages, dated 03/31
and 04/01 from to A female identifying
herself as states that she cou up to take her to
Epstein's house for an eleven o clock appointment. A copy of this was
placed into evidence.
On 04/05/2005, a trash pull was conducted at 358 El Brillo by Det. III
and me. There were several messages written on various forms of
papers. There was a message from indicating 11:00. The
following was additional information o tained from tras retrieved
from 358 El Brillo: Jean Luc 6:20 AM;
Page: 20
Program: CMS301L
(Continued)
Friday 5:30PM;
a message receipt
She is looking to speak to you .;
On 04/06/2005
Epstein
I faxed sub oena requests to SA
and I phone records. P one numbers
office for
On 04/06/2005, I called , , ext
and spoke with Prince a He con irme t at they had
a student by the name of . He requested a written request
prior to releasing any ad itiona information. On this same date I
faxed a request for student and parent information on IIII
I advised that due to this being an open investigation
he was not to discuss the matter with anyone.
On 04/08/2005, I received
following information:
Wellington, Florida
wor
a providing me the
33414. Parents name:
w m DOB
04/07/1. The following information was retrieved: Jet Aviation
Det. provided me with trash obtained from 358 El Brillo for 04/06
800-538-0724 itinerary, indicating a departure date of 04/05/2005 at
4:00 PM with an arrival in New York Cit of 6:15PM. Flight crew
captain , co-captain, , flight engineer
Larr Morrison. Call sign N908JE; a note stating Bye J. thank you
ll l.
4PM
hand written notes & messa es 11 12:30 chicken,
4 3 September I I x8, work Su
Monday after school?; e t message or ;
works 4-9 Monday and Tuesday, leaves
sc oo @ 11:30 AMA will be here tomorrow @ 10:30 Am; Mrs.
. There was no trash for 04/08/05.
04 22 05 received the results of a subpoena request from for
The results only provided subscriber information. I
contacted investigative Subpoena Compliance Center who
stated the request was not complete and the results would be sent to
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 21
Incident Report Program: CN1S301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
me as soon as the query was finished.
Cross-referencing the names and
well as phone numbers, which were o taine from message notes
trash pulls, I identified the before mentioned individuals as
acquainted with someone at 358 El Brillo. DOB
DL and DOB FL
both ove e egal age o consent.
On 05/03/2005, I s oke with
investigation. sta l t at
school. Her con ac with the outside
access to the phones.
allowed to go anywhere a one.
(Continued)
as
via
being
FL
are
and updated her on the
was doing well in the
si  limited as they do not have
and she is not
On 05/11/2005, I made arrangements to meet with and
On Thursday, 05/12/05, I s oke with l regarding the case.
They will be moving to . T ey wi l be very busy over
the next few weeks but wou e avai able via phone. Will coordinate
a date to meet to discuss the matter further.
During this week I conducted surveillance at Epstein s residence and
at the airport, but there was nothing to indicate that Epstein was in
town.
Due to conflictin appointments, rescheduled until 06/02/2005, to meet
with Ms.
I also spoke with and updated her to the investigation.
On 06/02/2005, I met with and advised
that she could be reached via er cell p one untillitl illiable to
provide me with her new contact information.
I also received a message from
but the line was busy.
Attempted call back
June 14, 2005, I received information that Epstein's plane was at
Jet Aviation. I spoke with Det. III regarding surveillance.
I called the and asked
she was not wor ing to ay. This would in icate that
employed there.
On 07/07/2005 I faxed
Epstein, and
subpoena requests only
sub oena requests to SA
s phone records.
and
provided su scri er an
I was advised
was still
office for
P one numbers
The original
billing information.
On 07/20/2005, conducted a trash pull arranged by Ofc. Inside
there were misc. papers with phone numbers and names. lite were
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 22
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: amsolL
Case No - 1-05-000368 (Continued)
misc. female hygiene products in the trash. Based on a prior Auto
Track report done on 358 El Brillo a ossible subject residing at the
residence is fit the description provided
by officers A lla conducted surveillance in the area of a female
seen entering and leaving the residence.
On 07/21/05, I received the dated 07/18/05, which was
clerked by ASO
On 07/26/2005, I received the results of Subpoena.
On 08/04/05, I received from with the results of
the query.
out of state.lilliappeare that all was going willi
I spoke with who confirmed that was still living
I left a message for at
On 08/08/2005, I received the results of
During the week of 09/08/2005, I checked 358 El Brillo and the Palm
Beach International Airport but there was no direct indication that
Epstein was in town.
On 09/08/2005, I reviewed the case notes of this file, as the case
will be turned over to Det.
subpoena.
On 09/11/2005, while on patrol, I conducted a check at Epstein's
residence and found that it still had the hurricane shutters on. On a
drive by the Palm Beach International Airport later that afternoon, I
did not observe Epstein's plane.
On 09/14/2005, I conducted a check at the Palm Beach International
Airport but did not see Epstein s plane.
find out if there was any change
On 09/19/2005, I spoke with
I was told no. I left a message for
in order to provide her with Detective
to keep her updated and to
ress or hone numbers for
at
information.
**************************** N A R R A T I V E # 2 ***************************
NA Reported By: 9/21/05 ,
Entered By.: II 9/21/05
On September 19, 2005, I met with Officer and received the
information pertaining to this case. Members of the Burglary Strike
Force had previousl been conducting surveillance on both Epstein and
Officer was assigned to monitor the stein home and
Sgt and Officer were assigned to monitor Both
teams provided a surveillance log that will be place into the
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 23
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
attachment file.
(Continued)
Det. was assigned to relieve Officer at 4:00 pm; he
informe me that at approximately 8:00 pm, Epstein had left for the
airport and his private jet was sitting on the tarmac. Epstein's
private vehicle drove to the jet and unloaded packages into the jet.
It appeared that Epstein left the county at this time. Surveillance
will continue to determine when Epstein will return.
Inv Continues.
**************************** N A R R A T I V E
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
# 3 ***************************
Mr •
9/23/05
9/23/05
On Friday, September 23, 2005 at approximately 1:45 p.m., I began to
copy a tape micro cassette, under case number 05-368 and property
number 05-243, tape number 1. I placed the tape in the telex copy-et,
series 2 machine and began to go through the copying process.
Approximately 1/2 through the tape, the tape wrapped around the
spindle and became locked and stretched the tape. I examined it and
determined that it was in the best interest to leave it as it is as a
prior copy had been made and turned over to Sergeant
immediately took the tape to Sergeant III" and allow,. to examine
it and then obtained the copy from him an Detective and
brought the copy of the tape down and made a copy for im ased on
that. The tape was placed back in the original container and is
retained in the evidence bag under the previously mentioned property
number of 05-243. It is not advisable to attempt to copy this tape as
further damage could result to the recorded material and there is an
existing copy anyway.
****************************NARRATIvE
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
# 4 ***************************
9/26/05
9/26/05
On 3-24-05 at 11:00 pm, a copy of tape 2 (case number 05-294) had been
made for Det. by Evidence S ecialist The copy
was turned over to Detective
On Friday, 09-23-05 at approimately 2:15 pm, I was in the process of
reproducing audio tapes (micro and standard) to standard size when it
was discovered, in the test review process that tape number 2 was
blank. I notified Sgt. and Det. IIIIIIII I was informed that
they had a prior copy alillicould use it to make a master tape. I did
so and when reviewini iiiilsigning the evidence sheet, I noticed
Evidence Specialist had written "#2 is blank."
I obtained that copy from Det. and made a new copy on a
standard size tape. The new copy was placed in the evidence bag under
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 24
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368
property number 05-294 with the blank tape.
****************************
NA
(Continued)
NARRATIVE # 5***************************
Reported By: I'll" 9/26/05
Entered By.: 9/28/05
Copies of the tapes that were submitted into evidence were requested.
Additionally, trash pulls were started on September  21, 2005. Sgt.
made tele hone contact withl , of
and requested that trash be collecte at
the stein House locate at 358 El Brillo in Palm Beach. Sgt
met with and observed him
enter the property at 358 El Brillo. Shortly thereafter,
exited the property and placed the three white trash bags in the empty
well in the rear of the truck. then drove away where he met
with Sgt. who remove the bags from the well and placed
them into one arge lack trash bag. The bag was returned to the
Police Station where I was waiting for him. Upon his arrival, we
inspected the bags where several notes and papers were found. These
notes contained names of irls with times. Additionally, there was a
note from and to Jeffrey Epstein on a note ad, which
stated,"For a good time ca 1 and at " Also,
there was another telephone number on the note . Also found
was a written note, which stated, can not come at 7 p.m.
tomorrow because of . These items were written on notepads that
contain Jeffrey Epstein on the bottom of the notes. These items were
placed into evidence for future follow up. I requested subpoenas for
subscriber information on the telephone numbers listed above on the
are  assign to Cingular Cellular Serviffi l Ot l ir notes
note from and The cellular telephones and
1.1 1111nd within the trash on Jeffrey Epstein ad papers that
contained telephone numbers. One note had " with
written on it. This cellular number is assign to
. Another sheet had writte which is assign to Be 1
South Telecommunications. The subpoenas were picked up and submitted
to Cingular and Bell South Telecommunication for subscriber
information.
On September 22, 2005, I was informed by Sgt. that there
would be no trash pick up as it was recycle pic up ay. A request
for copies of the micro and standard size cassettes were requested
from crime scene to familiarize myself with the interviews conducted.
On September 23, 2005, the tapes were received and I began to become
familiar with the interviews that were conducted. Det. had met
with Town of Palm Beach an observed
him enter the property of 358 El Brillo. Shortly thereafter,
exited the property and placed the three white trash bags in the empty
well in the rear of the truck. then drove away where he met
with Det. who removed the bags from the well and placed them
into one large lack trash bag. The bag was returned to the Police
Station where I was waiting for him. Upon his arrival, we inspected
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 25
Incident Report Program: CIMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
the bags where several notes and papers were found. The notes will be
inspected for future use. The items collected were placed into
evidence.
It became evident that some of the recordings were recorded with
background noise and some interference. The calls most affected were
the control phone calls from the victim to the suspect
I obtained the graphic equalizer and discovered that the ca ls are
able to be legible with the use of the equalizer by lowering the
background noise and increasing voice gain. I also learned that a
tape was broken during the coping of the tape. I returned the copy of
the tape marked Property Number 05-243 to have it recopied to have an
original in evidence and a working copy with the file.
U on researching the file, it was discovered that the suspect,
cellular calls were sub oenaed incorrectly. The suspect
to e one number was and the original request was for
I requeste t e information through Cingular Cellular
Service rom Februar 2005 through the present. The purpose was to
have a record of making calls to victim, Jeffrey Epstein and
the frequency of ca s. The request was submitted to the State
Attorney's Office.
Investigation Continues. ...
****************************NARRAT/VE
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
# 6 ***************************
• On or about September 23, 2005 at approximately 0915 hours
responded to 358 El Brillo and met with PB
had been previously note lec assist in trash
pulls at the rest ence of Jeffrey Epstein, 358 El Brillo, Palm Beach,
Florida. I observed enter the driveway of 358 El Brillo and
remove several plastic ags of trash and place the contents into the
back of an empty sanitation truck.
trash from the trash was transported to the Palm Beach
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the
Police Department where I began sifting through its contents. There
was a total of 4 white in color plastic bags and each contained
documentation and correspondence for 358 El Brillo and Jeffrey
Epstein. All documents of evidentiary value were removed and turned
over to Det. for follow-up.
10/06/05
10/06/05
On or about September 26, 2005 at approximate) 0900 hours I
waded to 358 El Brillo and met with PB
had been previously notified to assist in trash  at III.
the resi ence of Jeffrey Epstein, 358 El Brillo, Palm Beach, Florida.
I observed enter the driveway of 358 El Brillo, where no trash
was located wit in the receptacles. I left the area without incident
Date: 7/25/06 Page: 26 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: .0018301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
and notified Det. to that affect.
On or about September 27, 2005 at approximate) 0915 hours
si ded to 358 El Brillo and met with PB
I observed "III enter the driveway o 358 El Brillo 11111
remove one plastic ag of trash and place it in the back of an empty
truck.
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the trash
from the truck. Itl itrash was transported to the Palm Beach Police
Department where I began sifting through its contents. There was a
total of 1 white in color plastic bag which contained correspondence
for 358 El Brillo. All documents of evidentiary value were removed
and turned over to Det. for follow-up.
On or about Monday October 3, 2005 at approximate) 0915 houriimi
res onded to 358 El Brillo and met with PB
I observed enter the driveway o 358 E Brillo and
remove several plastic ags o trash and place the contents into the
back of an empty sanitation truck.
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the
trash from the truck. The trash was transported to the Palm Beach
Police Department where I began sifting through its contents. There
was a total of 7 white in color plastic bags with a red tie and 1
black in color bag which contained 2 white in color plastic bags with
a red tie. Each of the bags contained documentation and
correspondence for 358 El Brillo and Jeffrey Epstein. Inside of one
of the white in color bags, I located a broken piece of a hard plastic
or clear acrylic stick, which was shaped with small ridges. This
device is commonly used as a sexual toy which is inserted into the
vagina or anus for stimulation. This item, along with all documents
of evidentiary value were removed and turned over to Det. for
follow-up.
On or about Tuesday October 4, 2005 at approximate) 0928 houiiim I
res onded to 358 El Brillo and met with PB
I observed enter the driveway o 358 E Brillo and
remove several plastic bags  trash and place the contents into the
side well of the sanitation truck. This side of the truck is separate
from the rear of the truck and does not come into contact with other
trash.
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the
trash from the true . The trash was transported to the Palm Beach
.Police Department where I began sifting through its contents. There
was a total of 2 white in color plastic bags which were tied at the
top. Each of the bags contained documentation and correspondence for
358 El Brillo and Jeffrey Epstein. All documents of evidentiary value
were removed and turned over to Det. for follow-up.
On or about Wednesday October 5, 2005 at approximately 0928 hours, I
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 27
Time:. 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
responded to 358 El Brillo and met with PB
I observed enter the driveway o 3 Bri o and
remove several plastic ags o trash and place the contents into the
bed of the sanitation truck.
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the
trash from the ti•Mhe trash was transported to the Palm Beach
Police Department where I began sifting through its contents, with the
assistance of Det. There were a total of 2 bags, one of
which was white in co or and tied in a knot at the top, and the other
was a black in color bag, which contained two white in color trash
bags along with loose debris. Each of the bags contained
documentation and correspondence for 358 El Brillo and Jeffrey
Epstein. All documents of evidentiary value were removed and turned
over to Det. for follow-up.
****************************NAREATIv
NA Reported By: 10/07/05
10/07/05
E # 7 ***************************
Entered By.:
trash collections  residence at 358 El Brillo Road. On
I met with Det. and requested further assistance to maintain
October 3, 2005, at approximately 10:30 am, I was contacted b Sgt.
to respond to the Palm Beach Police Station. Det. had
observed Jeff Epstein ridin his bicycle on South County Roa . Upon
my arrival, I met with S t who advised, as Epstein was currently
in Town; we interview as to her involvement with Epstein
and the girls that are roug o his house. As we were to interview
in the county, (outside of our jurisdiction), I contacted the
tate Attorney s Office Investigation Division and made contact with
Assistant Supervisor Investi ator I requested
assistance to interview
county. Supervisor
as e interview iii loccur in the
us at the location an interview of
assigned Investigator to assist
Det. had responded to the address of and
vehic e parked in the driveway. ve is e a
Florida Tag of was par in the driv IIIIII
in Loxahatchee. g and I res onded to
ewa
awaited the arrival of Investigator Upon his arrival, he
was briefed that should she wish to il linterviewed within her home he
would be needed. However, should agree to return to the olice
station for further questioning, he wou d not be needeliii iit.
and I knocked on the door and met with was to d
that we were investigatin a claim invo ving Je rey Epstein of El
Brillo in Palm Beach. was asked if she wanted to accompany us
back to the police station or further questioning. She was also told
that at the conclusion of the interview she would be returned home.
She agreed and wished to change her clothes prior to accompanying us
back to the police station. At the conclusion of her chili
clothes, she advised she was ready to go. I thanked Inv. and
advised she was going to voluntarily return to the police station.
viewed her
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 28
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CI0SS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Upon entry in the unmarked Detective vehicle, I placed a tape
recor er vat in the vehicle to record any conversations within the
vehicle. During the ride back to the olice station, advised
she is attending at the
an is majoring in .
Upon our arrival at the police station, was brought to the
interview room in the Detective Bureau. I explained to that 1
appreciated her willingness to assist us and informed her t at should
she desire to leave at any time she may do so. I further explained
the interview room door is only closed for privac stated she
understood. During the taped sworn interview, was asked how
she came in contact with Epstein. state ac when she turned
17 ears of age she was approaciii iii afriend in the
in Rivera Beach. was askecilililhe wante to make
money.
She was told she would have to provide a massage and should make
$200.00. thought about the offer and agreed to meet with
Jeffrey. (Unknown last name) and IIII (Unknown last name)
picked her up and she was taken to Epstein's house. Upon her arrival
at the house, she was introduced to Epstein in the'kitchen of the
house. She was also introduced to a white female known to her as
She was led u stairs to the main bedroom known to her as Jeff
Epstein s bedroom. arranged the massage table and covered the
table with a sheet. S e brow ht out the massage oils and laid them
next to the massage bed. theh left the room and informed her
Jeff would be in a minute. Jeff entered the bedroom wearing only a
towel. He lay on the table onto his stomach and icked massage oil
for
me
rub on him. During the massage, stated, He tried
to touc me and I stopped him. I asked how he trie to touch her. He
and she felt uncomfortable. also stated
Epstein as a vi rator, which is large and white in co or.
told Epstein I'll massa e ou but I don't.want to be touche
stated she At the conclusion of the
massage, Epstein pai 200.00 or the massage. He explained, I
know you re not comfortable, but I'll a ou if you bring some girls.
He told her the younger the better. stated she once tried to
bring a 23- ear-old female and Epstein s a ed that the female was too
old. was asked how many girls she brow ht in total to Epstein.
stated six that she can remember. stated she broil.
an t e victim in this case.
I asked which one was the youngest. advised the victim
was the youngest. III'. stated every girl s ebrought knew what to
expect when they arrive . They were told they would provide a
massage, possibly naked, and some touching. I asked her if the victim
was aware. She stated every girl she brought knew what to expect.
She explained she knew the victim wanted to make money. She
approached the victim and explained about going to work for Jeff. The
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 29
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
victim agreed and arrangements were made to bring the victim to
Epstein's house on a weekend. stated that she and
(later identified as picked up the victim at t e
victim s house. They trave e o pstein's House and entered through
the kitchen door. They met with the house chef and Epstein s
in the kitt illiarea. led the victim upstairs and Epstein went
assistant The victim was introduced to Epstein while they were
upstairs. When the massage was over, the victim returned to the
kitchen area. stated she was paid $200.00 for bring the victim
to Epstein's. stated the victim told her she was paid $300.00
for the massage. Back in the vehicle, asked the victim what
happened. The victim told her about the massage and then they went
shopping. stated the victim was the last person she brought to
Epstein. She further stated that she had changed her cellular number
to avoid being contacted by She continued that when Epstein
announces to his assistant t a e is traveling to Palm Beach,
would contact
identified as
to arrange girls for E stein.
Date of Birth , a told
tthat Je i es to have his fun wit
later
e girls.
stated that once her parents discovered that she was visiting
E

stein, they disapproved of the encounters with him and she stopped.
eaves messa es. With the assist tirM
further stated that still tries to call the house and
we were able to
identif , DOB DOB
DOB DOB
Sgt entered the room and explained that based on her own
statements, she had im licated herself with bringing underage girls to
Epstein's house. was aware of what she had stated and wished
to assist further in opes to receive a lesser charge.
provided cellular telephone numbers for the girls she ha mentioned
previously. Additionally, she also rovided possible addresses and
areas in which they lived. As was being taken home in the
vehicle, a tape recorder was place within the vehicle to record any
conversations within the vehicle. Durin the drive back to her home,
made the comment I m like a . (Hollywood Madam who
sent girls to clients for sexual favors in Ca ifornia) . was
dropped off at her house without incident.
Sgt and I went to in Loxahatchee,
Florida lin an attempt to spear wit . We met with
( Mother) at t e ront oor. We explained Mrs.
the ongoing investigation and felt that may have additional
information as we had information that sfR illilorked for Jeff. Mrs.
introduced us to her husband and allowed us ent into the
home. We sat in the dinning room and met with
was 1111.11111 Iwould be speaking with her. She expressed,
Date of Birth As she was under the age o eig teen, Mrs.
if her daughter had information she wanted to assist. As we
interviewed , she denied having any inappropriate
encounters with Jeff Epstein . She stated she had gone to Jeff s
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 30
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
House with approximately eight months ago and sat in the
kitchen wit e ouse chef but nothing hap ened. As the parents were
present during the interview, we felt that was withholding
information from us. She made several comments as to she has put the
entire incident behind her. I left my direct . telephone number and
advised should she wish to s eak with me again to telephone me. Sgt
and I thanked Mrs. for her time and left the area.
She stated she would ask er again after we left as to what happened
at Epstein s house. I informed her that had my telephone
number and hopefully she would call.
S t and I then attempted contact with at
in oxahatchee. We met with who stated was
her daughter. IIIII was at the We ing on a and was not ome. We
explained the ongoing investigation and felt the may have
additional information as we had information thatIt illhad worked for
Jeff. We left our phone numbers and asked her to telephone me upon
her daughter's return. We then left the area.
!. had spoken
On October 4, 2005, at approximate) 8:05 am, Sgt had retrieved
a voice mail message from She state
with her daughter and she
She
ormation as to what occurred at Jeff
shower at the moment an woullilliiraveling back to to attend
s house. I contacted who stated her daughter was in the
College. I informed her I would be en route to her ome in
Loxahatchee. Det. and I drove to the home and met with
and During a sworn to ed statement,
told she could make money working for Jeff. lawas to she would
o the house by She wasstate she was to
have to provide a massage to Jeff. stated u ffo er arrival to
the house she was brought to the kite en area by
introduced to Jeff's assisP and  brought upstairs to the
They met with the house chef and stayed in the kitchen. She was
mater bedroom. prepared the room and massage table for a
massage. Epstein entered the room and she provided a massage.
stated she kept her clothes on durin the massa e. She stated
sometime durin the massage Epstein and
said she was wier e out y t e inci ent
invo ving Je . At t e conclusion of the massage, she was paid
$200.00 for the massage. I asked if she has an formal training
in massages to which she replied no. I asked her if received
any monies for taking her to perform the massa e. stated El
also received money for takin her there. state she went wit.
l”
sta she waited in the itc en wit was to en
and another girl, to Je 's house once.
while
upstairs by stated she only did the massage once, as she
was wierded out y t e whole experience. At the conclusion of the
interview and the to e was stopped, I was informed that IIII had
attempted to reach via cell phone. A voice mail message on
October 4, 2005 at 10:59 am, revealed a female voice who identified
herself as who requested her to call her back reference the
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report Time: 8:47:53
Page: 31
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
police questioning. This voice mail message was recorded onto a micro
cassette. rovided the incoming telephone number as
stated she inadvertently told about
t e police investigation because had calleAl li'll lher
about how she just received a ren a car from Jeff Epstein.
had called her to tell her that she was given a _rental car,
, to utilize to visit family and visit Je
as e• er w was oing on at the house that the police would
•e as ing questions. stated then called Jeff and
and asked what was going on reference t e ongoing police
investigation. According to has since then been tr ing to
contact her to ask about the po ice questions. . I instructed not
to contact 'and do not provide an  more information to as
and what was transpiring.she would note y Jeff Epstein
Investigation Continues. ..
****************************NARRATIVE
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
# 8 ***************************
• 10/07/05
10/07/05
On March 30, 2005, I was asked by Sgt. to be in
conducting surveillance and trash pulls re erence Detective
conducting a criminal investigation involving Jeffrey Epstein. I was
advised that Epstein was possibly engaging in sexual contact with
young females.
On March 30, 2005, I made contact with Town of Palm Beach
and requested trash pulls or E
Brillo Way to egin on Marc 1, 2005.
On March 31, 2005 at 9:20 a.m., I responded to the area of 358 El
I observed enter rivAIII II58 El
Brillo Wa and met with Town of Palm Beach
Brillo Way, collect the trashbagsfrom Epstein's property and lace
the contents into an empty sanitation truck. I followed to a
nearby area, were he turned over seventeen white plastic tras ags,
which were collected from Epstein's property.
I took the trash bags to the sanitation department were I sifted
through its contents. I collected mail correspondence from Armani
Exchaiii iiddressed to Jeffrey E. Epstein notepaper
with , an important messy e note a er addressed to
J.E dated 03 29 05 at 8:15 p.m. reference U.S Airwa
boarding ass copy for passenger,
food service ID for
aine Maxwell notepaper wit names and pi numbers. numbers.
Photocopies of the trash collected were attached with the supplement.
Detective was advised of the contents that were collected for
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 32
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (continued)
On March 31, 2005, Sgt. requested that I set up a
surveillance vehicle on E Bri o Way an conduct video surveillance
of the front exterior of Epstein's residence. At 3:00 p.m., I set up
a surveillance vehicle equipped with a video monitoring device. The
surveillance vehicle was parked on El Brillo Way approximately fifty
feet east of Epstein's driveway. The purpose of the video
surveillance was to gather investigative intelligence by monitoring
and recording all vehicle and pedestrian traffic entering and leaving
Epstein's property.
The video surveillance tapes were changed daily with a new Maxell
T-160 VHS tape. Video surveillance was established for Epstein s from
March 31, 2005 through April 05, 2005. On April 05, 2005, video
surveillance was concluded. I reviewed the video tapes and advised
Detective the surveillance videos yielded no evidentiary value.
On April 01, 2005 at 9:30 a.m., I responded
Brillo Way to meet with Town of Palm Beach
While parked in the area of 358 El Bri o Way waiting to
co ect E stein s trash, I observed a white female, who I recognized
as from her Florida driver's license photograph. I
made no contact with While parked in the area, I also
observed Epstein s GMC Yu on truck leave the property as well as other
vehicles arrive and park across the street from the property. The
occupants of these vehicles appeared to be housekeepers, maintenance
men, and gardeners.
to the area of 358 El
At 9:38 a.m. I met with Town of Palm Beach
III"  I observed ill enter the driveway o 358 E Brillo
Way and collect the trash from Epstein s property. I followed
to a predetermined area at which time I collected the trash ba s from
the sanitation truck. I transported the trash bags to the
department, where I sifted through its contents. I collected mail
correspondences addressed to Jeffre E stein automotive records and
personal documents for and as well as
Jeffre Epstein note apil ill'h e names an appointment times for
and No last names or other personal information was
written on t e notepaper.
While sifting through Epstein s trash, I also collected a three-inch
purple finger size object, which had a broken end. The object
appeared to be a broke piece from a sexual toy similar to a (Cyclone
Vibrator) possibly used for rectal ratification. The sexual object
was photographed for Detective packaged in a biohazard evidence
bag (possible body fluids) and secured as investigative evidence. All
items collected from Epstein s trash were turned over to Detective
for evidentiary purposes.
On April 05 2005 at 9:18 a.m. I met with Town of Palm Beach
I observed enter the III
driveway of 358 El Brillo way an collect the trash from Epstein s
property. I followed to a predetermined area at which time I
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 33
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
collected the trash bags from the sanitation truck. I transported the
trash bags to the sanitation department, where I sifted through its
contents. I collected mail correspondenceg addressed to Jeffrey
Epstein as well as notepaper (Important Message) with names and
telephone numbers. The following are items collected from Epstein s
trash.
blank piece of wie aper
black paper
black a er
David
MSN Hotmai we page with email address
The following items were documented for Detective
investigation for evidentiary purposes.
On April 06, 08, 11, 12, 13, 15 2005 at a roximately 9:30 a.m, I
met with Town of Palm Beach I observed the
employee enter the driveway o 358 E Bri o Way and collect the trash
from Epstein's property. I followed the employee to a predetermined
area at which time I collected the trash bags from the sanitation
truck. I transported the trash bags to the department,
where I sifted through its contents.
All of the documents collected from Epstein's trash during my
assistance were turned over to Detective Pagan for evidentiary
purposes.
On June 14, 2005, Detective contacted me and advised
that the airplane belonging to Je rey Epstein of
was parked at the Palm Beach International Airport.
Detective requested that I begin trash pulls for the purpose of
gathering evi ence and intelligence.
I made contact with Town of Palm Beach
and requested trash pulls M. PA ay o egin
orauM12005.
On June 15, 2005, I met with a I observed the
employee enter the driveway of 358 E BriAl ltr nd collect the trash
from Epstein s property. I followed the employee to a predetermined
area at which time .I collected the trash bags from the sanitation
truck. I transported the trash bags to the sanitation department,
where I sifted through its contents. The trash yielded negative
results and no evidence was collected.
No further trash was collected throughout the week due to the fact
that Epstein s security gates remained closed throughout the week;
therefore, the sanitation employees were unable to gain access onto
the property for collection of the trash.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 34
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
All evidence and intelligence gathered by this officer
over to the detective bureau and no further action has
this officer.
End of supplement.
(Continued)
has been turned
been taken by
****************************NARRATIVE # 9 *************************** .
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
10/07/05
10/10/05
On October 4, 2005, I made telephone contact with
who had left several messages on voice mail. During t e mellr ilie
advised she was not completely truthful when we met in person but
would like to speak with me to advise what had happened. She further
advised she did not-want to speak of this incident in front of her
mother. At a roximatel 15:48 m I made telephone contact with
at During a taped recorded
statement, state t e -o lowin : Approximately a year ago,
when she was sixteen years of age took her to Jeff's  house
twice. The first time she went, drove to the house.
They entered through the kitchen area w ere she was introduced to
room up with a massage bed and brought out the oil.. use. Jeff then
and Jeff. She was taken upstairs to a bedroom by who set the
entered the room wearing a towel. He lay on the table and picked out
to rub on him. At one point during the massage,
at which oint she became very upset and
discontinued t e massage. Both and Jeffrey had a verbal
disa•reement at which time she le t wit out being paid. She met with
who was sitting in the kitchen and told her let's o.
a vised she received no money for that day. also
was going on, t!IIIIIIIim know and he'll stop. She knew that the more
sal• t at had told her if she was uncomfortable with what
you do the more you are paid.
Several weeks later advised she agreed to be taken a second
time by
kitchen an
Once t ey arrived at the residence, sat
in the took her upstairs to the master be room again.
set the room up with a massage bed and brought out the oils to
use. Jeff then entered the room wearing a towel. He lay on the table
and picked out a lotion for to rub on him. At one oint
during the massage, he tried to . As was
wearing tight jeans and had a tig e on e was
Jeff then rolled onto his back during e massage; e
then became upset again and
told him she i 't want to a discontinued the
massage and was paid $200.00. en wen downstairs where
t.!. said she never returned to lti ouse.11
was waiting for her. old she wanted to
was a so a he
house and had a problem with Jeff. S e providilillielephone number
stated she is aware that her friend,
a lotion for
he tried to
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 35
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
for  The interview was concluded and the micro cassettes were
turn in as evidence.
On October 5 2005 I researched the incoming telephone number that
had left a message. The telephone number,
was assigne to ATT Cingular Cellular service. I prepared a  a
request and faxed the request to the State Attorney s Office.
Information requested was subscriber information as well as all
incoming and outgoing calls for the months of September and October
2005.
Palm Beach. Det.
I later researched III. and discovered she resides in Royal
at er residence
and I rove to Royal Palm Beach and met with
in Royal Palm Beach.
i
lape
agreed to s speak with us in the kitchen area. During a sworn
M statement, stated the following: On or about November
2004, she was approached by and asked if she wanted to l'
make money. She agreed and was toil!! would provide a massage to
wealthy man in Palm Beach. IIIIII picked her up and drove her to a
house in Palm Beach. She was rou ht into the kitchen area of the
house. She further stated that l', went with them. They were broug t P i into ti!illi w ere she wastchen
( and Il (
introduced to Jeff and other females. stated she was
introduced to a helper of Jeff- the fema e was described as white
female (unknown name with hair. She stated that the assistant
was familiar with T e assistant set up the massage table and
put out lotions to e used. She told Jeff would available in a
minute. Jeff entered the room wearing on y a towel. Jeff lay on the
massa e table and picked a lotion to rub on his thighs and back.
further stated that during the massage Jeff asked her to remove
didn't she FP I
her c othes. She complied and removed her pants and blouse.
remember if she had removed her bra but feels that
was certain that she staved in her thong underwear.
was instructed
to return to t e group at w is time Je turned to ave his chest
rubbed. advised it was at this time she is sure he was
masturbating. did not want to look at his penis area because
she was uncomforta e. Jeff removed a lar e white vibrator and turned
it on. stated he
S ort y t erea ter, Je ejacu ated
and removed himse rom t e table. He walked over to where the
shower was and opened the glass door. She waited as he was taking a
shower in her direct view. When I asked how old she was when
this occurred, she stated she had just turn seventeen. At the
conclusion of the shower, was paid either $350.00 or $400.00.
She stated she wasn't sure, ut knows it was close to $400.00. At the
conclusion of the interview, stated she never returned to
provide a massage for Jeff. e a vised she was ashamed and
uncomfortable with the situation.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 36
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 Continued)
Det. and I then left the area and responded to the
where III. and all the above -mentioned girls a
attended. I met with Scho Police Officer, Off I
ex lained I was looking for a previous student who attended
I inquired about I further explained
t at I was working a case in which most of III IIIrls I have
interviewed are either witnesses or victims and felt that 'III may be
one .as well. Officer researched his previous student records
and .found III S e attended the same year and graduated
in the same as t e other girls. I was provided the last known
address of
At approximatel 2:10 and I met with at
her residence, n Royal Palm Beac . As was
iiiiiieventeen years o age, I a. notified her mother, Mrs.
that she would be interviewed reference an ongoing
investigation in Palm Beach. I assured her that her daughter was not
a suspect. I explained the possibility of her being either a witness
or victim. Mrs. IIIII advised she wanted to cooperate and
consented to the interview. During a sworn tape statement,
stated the following: at the age of sixteen during the mont of
September 2004 she was approached by for a chance to
make money. was friends with the rien s o IFNI and knew the
same eopl . had been previously told by her
l . called aperson known to as
iends what
an
did for Je
M Sscheduled the appointment. picked 'III upigl idrovi llir
to Palm Beach to a street called Bri o Way. T y drove to the end of
the street and entered a large drivewa . They entered the kitchen
area of the house and met with Jeff. was introduced to Jeff.
led upstairs to the main e room area and set up the room
wit a massage table and set out the oils. dimmed the lights
room wearing only a towel. IW Illpicked oils and instructed her to rub
and turned on soft music. exited the room and Jeff entered the
his legs, under his buttocks, back and chest area. Jeff asked her to
get comfortable. IIIII advised she did not remove her clothes. She
was wearing tight jeans and a cropped tank top exposing her belly
area. During the massage, Jeff removed his towel. As rubbed
his chest area, Jeff
however was unable to due to the tightness of the jeans
an a tiiit elt. II. advised Jeff bean to masturbate as
IIIIII Je moaned as she IIIIII III She !Nerved
e was continuin to masturbate and attempted to
,kept masturbating until e climaxed. He cleaned himself with the
pulled back. and Jef stoppe . However,
towel he was previously wearing. I asked if she knew the
difference between circumcised and not circumcised. She explained she
knew and advised Jeff was circumcised. was paid $200.00 for the
massage and left the area. She met with who was waiting in the
kitchen area and left the house.
fiRthen explained she never provided another massage for Jeff. She
owever, go to the house with and as they
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 37
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
went to wor or Jil l
took another friend of
sa in th!llhen area with to
that while they waited for the
(Continued)
advised she was present when
She advised she rode over and
wait for advised
house the prepare lunch for
them, as it was almost lunc time. As was finished with the
massage, they left the area. I asked if ever told what
would be ex ected of her when she provided a massage. IIII! stated
yes, told her that a massage would be expected posse ly naked
and posse y some touching involved. has no formal training in
providing massages.
spoke about a third and last time she went to Jeff's house.
drove another girl, who is friend, to
e 's house. state s e ew t at had made mone
providing girls or Jeff and she wanted to •o t e same. took
them in the kitchen area of the house and introduced
and took upstairs to the main be room.
a vise she oesn t know w
iiiiiipreceived 100.00 from
ened as did not speak about
what happened in the room. for
going with her to Jeff s house and recommending was
unable to remember I telephone number. T e interview was
concluded and we le t the area.
Investigation Continues. ..
****************************
NA
NARRATIVE 10 **************************
Reported By: 10/09/05
Entered By.:
On October 6 2005, Det. and I went to
in We met wit Dean of Students,
exp aine to Mr. 'II that we were investi atin a crime
Town of Palm Beach and felt that a student,
information. confirmed that is a student and
on the Or
the time o our arrival.
She was in
sent a securit guar
in class and bring her to hte office. Mr. allowed
interview in an empty conference room.
10/10/05
located
I
within the
may have
currently
at
to interview her. She advise tililas aware of the ongoing
At 11:45 am I met with and explained to her why we there
investigation. stated she had previously spoken with
who told her she was interviewed by detectives. During a sworn
tape statement, stated she knew that worked for
Jeff in Palm Beac . advised she has been there many times for
massages. I asked her if she had formal training in providing
massages, stated she did not. advised she was told what
was expecte o her by providing massages and would have to remove
clothing but if she felt uncomfortable just to say so and Jeff would
stop pushing the issue. began providing massages and advised
she kept her clothes on. S e considered Jeff a pervert who kept
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 38
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
pushing to go further and further. explained she would keep
telling him she had a boyfriend and that it would not be right to her
boyfriend. It wasn t until recently admitted to removing her
clothes and staying in her thong underwear to provide a massage.
explained Jeff wanted to be rubbed on his back and recently he
!!! turning over to have her rub'his chest as he masturbated. He
would try to as she rubbed his chest. stated,
Jeff would tr to get away with more and more on each massage.
iiiiinally, drove her to the house for the original massage.
left er cell phone number and every time Jeff would come
iff rtown would call her for an appointment. Each time she
went, wou d meet her at the kitchen door area. She would bring
her upstairs and prepare the massage table. advised Jeff would
and
would
her questions about herself. He knew she was a and
would be attending . I asked i Ie new I real
age, stated Je i t care. The most recent massage she
provill i!as on October 1, 2005. During the massage she asked Jeff if
she could borrow one of his vehicles to visit her family and boyfriend
in Orlando. Jeff had told she could borrow one of his vehicles but
later stated he would rent her a car. She continued with the massage
. I as .Jeff
asked i s e was wearing un•er
thong underwear. Once he tried to
away from him and he would stop.
vibrator on her. was aware o
never would allow himtto use the vibrator on her. She described the
vibrator as a large white vibrator with a huge'head on the tip of the
vibrator. She stated he kept the vibrator in a closet near the
massage table. advised she had been doing the massage for
approximately two years, which meant she would have started doing
massages for Jeff at the age of sixteen.
e replied her
she would pull
was as e• i he ever used a
t e vibrator but advised she
litimed her that Jeff had rented !Pa new
stated she was contacted by on October 3 2005.
should come by the house to ick it up. in orme
have the car for a month. stated Je knew her
working properly and had miser appointments in the past because of
her car bein inoperable. explained the car is currently parked
next to the field. I as e her if she ever took any one to the
house. a lained she took a friend of hers who
has return to to attend co ege. I as ed she ever allowed
another female in the room. Mill advised no one was brought  into the
room with her. At the conclusion of the interview, Det. and I
went to the iiiiiiir and located the
Florida tag . The vehicle is registere
out of the Palm Beach International Airport.
had
she would
car was not
iligiiiiiiiintact was made with the victim's mother, at
. I explained to her tat I was ollowing up on this case
and provided a complete update on the case.
Investigation Continues.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 39
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
****************************NARRATIVE # 11 **************************
NA Reported By: 10/21/05 ,
Entered By.: II 10/21/05
On October 10 2005 at a roximately 2:30 p.m., I made tele hone
contact with During a taped conversation, was
told of an ongoing investigation in which I felt she had in ormation
pertaining to Jeffrey Epstein. explained she met Epstein when
she was just sixteen years of age. She was approached by
massages.
a friend who also had previously gone to stein'shouse for
advised she was working at the when
she was approached. told her that she wou ave to provide
a massage to EpStein an s e would have to perform this massage
illthought about the offer and stated she could make $200.00
on minutes of work. She agreed to perform the massage and
30 set the appointment for her that same day. remembered it
was a weekend as she only worked on the weekends.
took her to the house where she was intro uced to Jeff Epstein's
assistant. took her upstairs to a master bedroom.
explained that as she was walking up the stairs she observed several
phot ographs of naked women along the walls and tables of the house.
O
further explained that she was brought into the bedroom where
prepared the room by setting up the massage table and provided
t e oils for her to rub on Epstein.
Epstein entered the room and introduced himself. Epstein lay on the
table and told her to get comfortable. _could not remember if he
was naked or if he entered the room with a towel. stated she
She continued rubbing
e turned over onto his back.
provided
his legs, t ig s an eet.
She continued to rub his le s with the oils. Epstein
I if she
c rcumc se an un-c rcumcise meant.
new w at
stated circumcised is when
the penis has no foreskin and the head of the penis is visible.
said Epstein is circumcised. began to cry on the telephone an
stated she had been to his hou'illundreds of times over a two-year
period. She claimed to have made thousands of dollars during her
visits. stated she could not remember how many times exactly she
went to Epstein's home but said it was a lot.
gl instructed to
became more upset, crying hysterically and stated she was paid
by Epstein. E ste
nas esca
Additionally,
She claimed he
cou • not continue
and wanted some time to regain er composure. I explained to to
take her time. After taking several minutes to regain her composure I
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 40
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
explained that I would travel to meet
had additional information to provide.
explained the importance to meet with
agreed and made arraignments for Det.
in Jacksonville, Florida.
(Continued)
with her in person as I felt she
I met with Sgt. and
in person. Sgt.
and I to meet wit
On October 11, 2005, at 4:10 p.m. Det.
and her friend, in
Jac sonvi e, Florida.  wante to have present or
support. I21(212ined toher that I did not ave 2pEoblem as long as
she wanted IIIIII present during the interview. IIII stated she
wanted her present. I explained that as was present she was
not allowed to comment or ask any questions uring the interview. She
was only there to comfort should the interview upset her.
During a sworn taped statement,
e
how everything be an.
She said she was brought through t e kitchen area where she met
for the first time. She was led to the master bedroom, Epstein s
room. III explained that as she was walking up the stairs she
observe several photographs of naked women along the walls and tables
of the house.
and I met with
further explained that she was brought into the
bedroom, where prepared the room by setting u the massage table
and provided the oils for her to rub on Epstein. explained she
remembered the steam room area, which contained two arge showers.
Epstein entered the room from the steam room area and introduced
himself. Epstein lay on the table and told her to get comfortable.
iliffe was naked or if he entered the room with a towel. stein then
removed her skirt and kept her shirt on. She could not remember
instructed her to remove her shirt.
S e continued rubbing his legs,
t ig s an• eet. a•vise• e turned over onto his back. She
continued to rub his egs with the oils. Epstein
Epstein ejaculated which meant t e massage
was over. At t e cone usion of the maiiiie, aid 200.00.
They walked together downstairs where and were
waiting. stated received an unknown amount o money for
taking her to Epstein. Epstein instructed to leave her cellular
telephone number so that he could contact her when he is in town.
explained that she continued to go to Epstein s house and became
a regular at the house. She could not provide an exact number but
claimed she had been their hundreds of times. She claimed sexual
activities did not occur every time she was there. There were times
she went to dinners and parties with Epstein. explained that
things began to escalate more than the massa•e. T e encounters
included bringing in his assistant, explained
Epstein had purchased her from her fame y in E stein
bragged he brow ht her into the United States to • is
sex slave. advised he was naked in the bedroom, she entere and 'Ili removed her c othing. entered the room from the 
steam room
area already naked. He instructed to on
Date:
to
7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
Case No • 1-05-000368
an additional 1111.00 for her
five minutes. agreed to
200.00. exD ained that
refused to perform that act.
Page: 41
Program: CMS301L
(Continued)
stein offered her
for
itional
Thins continued to escalate b •urchasin stated She
had
Each time somet n new was lntr uce• a t ona mon es were produced
and offered for to allow the acts to happen. was adamant
that she performs a l these acts but there was an understanding with
Epstein that no vaginal penetration would occur with his penis.
explained that Epstein's penis was deformed. explained that is
penis was oval shaped. She claimed when Epstein's penis was erect, it
was thick toward the bottom but was thin and small toward the head
portion. She called it egg-shaped.
continued.that the encounters with
er became a ritual. would arrive at the ouse
u•stairs where and Epstein were waitin•.
oin them
Epstein and
an walk herself
l•igned
would
Epstein or
stein
anation revea e• t ey were n a
t is incident occurred)I lle came to the house after had in
advised one day, ( was unable to state and exact date when
her that Epstein had arrived. She arrived at the house and went
upstairs to the master bedroom. advised she immediately
her clothin as
bedroom. explained that
encounter to include
that and was
as e or a sheet of
master bathroom and where
turned
state• Epste n •egan to
•ecame u•set over this. She said
, as he
S e screame• no an stein sto red. S e to • im t at s e
want to Epstein apologized for
actions an su sequent y pal er a thousand dollars for that
Additionally, shortly thereafter, Epstein gave a
in color for her personal use.
removing
paper and
•stein
stein were already nakell!!lle
and she had a
reme ered
er se rom the massage table.
drew the massage table in the
and she were. E•stein
advised there were times that she
iiiiiin's house. advised she was
e
the house because she was so sore.
advise s e had difficulty wa it e carte
advised that other
not
his
visit.
was so sore when she left
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 42
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 Continued
than that one time, when stein
there was no other
•
illeinis house. provided the name of IIIII
provided names of girls that she knew of that have gone to
and feels she
still ma
ii
iiigoing to the house to massage Epstein. According to
is still
When asked if she had been recently contacted by anyone of the house,
lliRount. The email was just
advised she received an email from from
hick is her emai
a e o, ow are you oing type of email. There had been no other
contact from the house. The interview was concluded and left the
area. The tapes and drawing were submitted into evidence.
Investigation continues...
****************************NARRATIVE # 12
NA Reported By: RECAREY
Entered By.:
**************************
• 11/01/05
11/07/05
On October 12, 2005, Det. and I traveled to the Orlando area
and made telephone contact wit agreed to meet
with us as we were in the Orlando area. rove ed directions to
her apartment. Det. and I met wit who stated, during a
sworn taped statement t at nothing happen etween her and Epstein.
M oken with other people who advised differently. stated
appeared nervous during the interview. I assured her that I
she only went a couple of times and provided a massage to Epstein.
She stated she was brought to the Epstein house in March of 2005.
prove  a massage, fully
brought her to work. has no formal training in
providing massages. stated s
clothed for $200.00. As I sensed hesitancy in her answers, I asked
if she had been contacted by anyone from the house.
state she was interviewed already by an investigator for Epstein. He
met with her on OctobeIA L 2005, at a Roadhouse in Orlando. He
identified himself as IIII and in ired about the police investigation
and left his telephone number for additional contact.
provided no additional in ormat on, as it appeared her
responses were almost scripted. We left the area and returned to Palm
Beach Police Department.
Based on the information acquired during the interviews, a search
warrant was prepared for entr at the Epstein home. On October 18,
She found there was sufficient pro able cause and signed the warrant
2O05, I met with Judge who reviewed the warrant request.
request. On October 20, 2005, at approximately 9:36 am, members of
the Palm Beach Police Investigations Unit executed the search warrant
at 358 El Brillo in Palm Beach. Membets of the Investi ations Unit
included Capt S t Det. Det. Det.
Det. Det. the crime scene unit and myself.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 43
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
As we entered onto the property, we encountered the house manager,
who was in the guest portion of the house. The
guest ouse section had o en doors and no forced entr was made. I
made contact with Date of Birt , Fl DL
an n ormed him of the searc warrant for the
preen ses. T e members of the Police Department entered the residence
and announced we had a search warrant. A safety search was done and
members exited the home. I read the search warrant to as Mgr
videotaped the search warrant execution. Severe interior
decorators were located on the properly I spoke with of
in New York. Mr. IIII stated he is Miesigner for

Mr. Epstein's. omes. He advised he was contacted in March of 2005 to•
do a complete overhaul on the house. He advised he was on the phone
with Mr. Epstein when officers announced the search warrant. Mr.
Epstein was then made aware of the search warrant. Mr. advised,
his contact with Epstein is strictly business and he has never
witnessed Epstein with any girls except for his assistants, or
I then interviewed of
Mr. stated he1,1111011111tor
he personally worked on the New Yor
Epstein. He has previously met with
assistants in New York and in Florida
Epstein everywhere he goes.
in New York.
or seven years. He advised
and Palm Beach home for Mr.
and Epstein's
. Estes state t ey travel with
I interviewed of Jersey City, New Jersey.
stated t illjust arrive rom Scot and and has worked with
or only one month. She stated she has never met Epstein and has not
seen him. The interview was then concluded.
I then s oke with of in New York
City. s ate e as een Epstein's for seven
years. He urt er stated he deals with stein's assistants and
speaks with E stein on the phone. stated he mainly speaks
with Epstein s main assistant, who travels with Epstein.
state he only has contact. with Epstein when his services
are needed.
At approximately 10:30 am, I was informed that the videotaping was
concluded. I entered the residence and located two covert (hidden)
cameras. The first camera was a covert wall clock in the garage area.
I traced the wire behind the clock and removed the RCA wire and
unplugged the camera. The other covert camera was located within a
desk clock beside Epstein's desk. I traced the wire behind the clock
and unplugged the RCA wire. I could not locate another camera. I
then began with the search of the residence for the specified
evidence.
My search consisted of the second floor. Det.
were
and I began in
the master bedroom area where several items were ocated. They were
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 44
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
marked to be retrieved by the evidence custodian. In the master desk
with Epstein's notepads marked Jeffre E stein we located a hi h
school transcript from for
Also in the room, was t e resser armoire where we ocated a
ott e of peach flavored Joy Jelly (Sexual Lubricant): Additionally,
there were several photographs of young naked teenage girls within the
closet, which was consistent with what the witnesses said. The
massage table was also located within the master bedroom. Video tapes
were located beside the television, which were also collected. An
itemized list of the property and locations was prepared on the
property receipts. At approximately 2:55 pm, the house was secured;
the exit of the residence was videotaped. Upon our exit of the
property, I encountered Atty. Guy Fronstein who advised he was
representing Mr. Epstein. He provided a business card and provided
his assistance with the investigation.
Due to Hurricane Wilma, which struck South Florida causing massive
power outages, the courthouse was closed due to the lack of power. I
was previously told that the Chief Judge had extended the filing
deadlines due to the hurricane and the Courthouse being closed. On
October 27, and 28, 2005 the courthouse was closed and I could not
file the search warrant and inventory at the clerk's office. On
October 31, 2005, I responded to the courthouse and filed the
paperwork along with an order to seal, signed by Judge Johnson, to
deny any release of any paperwork on this case.
INV CONTINUES..
***************************NARRATIVE # 13 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
10/20/05
11/07/05
On October 20, 2005, at a roximately 8:30 a.m., Thursday morning, I
was advised by Captain that a search warrant would be executed
and that I was to assemble the Crime Scene Investigative Team and
stand by the south side of the building ready to go. I designated
Evidence Specialist to handle the inventory return, the
documentation of the property receipts and the collection and ba ing
of the evidence at the scene. I further instructed CSI III ID
to accompany us and perform the role of photographing the
scene and the items that may be taken into custody by the affiant,
Detective ID #
My responsibility was to go through from the reading of the warrant to
the final exit from the residence and perform a video recording of the
reading of the warrant, the initial walk through of the residence
showing the current condition and then finally a walk through of the
residence at the time of the police exit.
We started out towards the residence, which was located at 358 El
Brillo and arrived at approximately 9:33 a.m. The search was
conducted, items were collected by Evidence Specialists
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 45
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
photographed by CSI and then videotaped by myself. The search
was concluded at approximately 3:05 p.m. whereupon Detective
and I were the last two officers in the house. upon securing ill ill
residence we met with the gentleman who identified himself to
Detective as the lawyer for the defendant and he was informed
that the residence was secured and that copies of the inventory return
had been left on the first floor table of the personal assistant's
office.
Detective and I returned to Police Headquarters and secured
for the day.
****************************NARRATIVE 14 **************************
NA Reported By: 11/07/05
Entered By.: 11/07/05
On October 20, 2005, I assisted Defective in the execution of
a search warrant at 358 El Brillo Way, Palm eac , Florida, 33480.
Upon the announcement of the search warrant, immediate contact was
made with three white males who came out of the house or surrounding
structures. Those males were identified as
As
watch over these three males. Once the house
and As other members of t ice epartment e po
the e,
was cleared, those males were turned over to Detective
main housji lill cabana and the servant's quarters. We started in the
Detective and I were assigned to assist in the search of the
garage. All areas of the garage were searched to include four
vehicles. These vehicles were three black Mercedes Benz cars
registered to Jeffrey Epstein. The fourth vehicle was a Harley
Davidson motorcycle, green in color, registered to Jeffrey Epstein.
Nothing was recovered from the garage.
A towel closet and pantry located off the kitchen were searched and
yielded negative results.
The kitchen was searched and taken into evidence was a phone message
book that was located near a house phone.
North of the kitchen was an office room which contained a computer.
The room had a closet that contained a locked gun locker. The
combination was entered by in the presence of Sgt. and
the safe was opened. Items were taken from the room. See M ill
completed property receipt for a detailed list.
A green bathroom located on the first floor was searched and nothing
was taken.
A closet located just west of the green bathroom was searched. Two
massage tables were located in the closet along with a photo of a nude
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 46
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
female from the waist up. See the property receipt for details.
I searched two bedrooms and their adjoining bathrooms, which were
located on the second floor on the East side of the house. In the
Northeast bedroom closet I found adult sex toys called Twin Torpedoes.
Soap made in the shape of a penis and vagina were also found in these
upstair bedrooms. See the property receipt for details.
I searched the pool cabana located on the South side of the pool.
Photos were taken from the wall. See the property receipt for
details.
I assisted in the search of living quarters. Numerous CD s
along with a message book was seize . See the property receipt for
details.
****************************NARRATIVE # 15 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
11/08/05
11/08/05
On November 1, 2005, I was contacted by Atty. Gus Fronstin, who
advised he was willing to assist with the investigation. Atty.
Fronstin advised he would try to have his client, Jeffrey Epstein
available to be interviewed. I explained I would be interested in
conducting an interview with his client as well as other employees
that are employed within the house. Atty. Fronstin advised he would
return my call once he received confirmation on the interviews.
residence. I left a business card for her to return R il. Upon
On November 6, 2005, I attempted contact with at her
returnin to the olice department, I had received a telephone call
from 1 returned her call at and spoke
with e made arrangements to respon to t e station to
provi e an nterview. At approximately 3:30 pm, she arrived at the
Palm Beach Police Station with her boyfriend. Her boyfriend was
allowed to sit in the lobby area while Ms. was interviewed.
I took Ms to the Detective Bureau Interview room. I closed the
door for privacy and explained to her that I appreciated her coming to
the police station for the interview. During the sworn taped
statement, she advised she was at Jeffrey Epstein s house one time.
A roximately two months ago, she was approached by a girl,
i who was dating her roommate, to make some quick money.
advised she was in need to make some quick cash to make the rent t t
month. She agreed to go to the house. She had been told by
that the massage would have to be done in her underweajl iill!
a vised drove with her and brought her into the house. They
walked into the kitchen area and took the stairs upstairs.
further stated she was brought into a master bedroom area. i! li
advised she recalled seeing portraits of naked women throughout the
room. A massage table was already out near the sauna/shower area in
the master bedroom. Epstein entered the room wearing only a towel and
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 47
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued
introduced himself as Jeff. lip advised she recalled she and
removed their clothing down totheir panties, Epstein lay on his
stomach area and they provided a massage on his legs and feet area. I
asked if she had any formal massage training and she replied
no. advised she was topless and the panties she wore were the
boy s or s lace panties. She and continued the massage until
the last ten minutes of the massage, Epstein, told to leave the
room so that could finish the massage.
got dressed and Epstein turned over onto his back. Epstein then
removed the towel, which had been around his waist. Epstein laid
stated as she did this, E stein as she IR A his
there naked and requested that rub his chest area.
chest. stated he and he '
produce a arge white vi rator wit a are ea . S e stated it was
within a drawer in his master bathroom.
advised he never wit t e
vi ra or.
He continued t•
sae• s e was very uncom ort e uringte
inci en ut new it was almost over. Epstein climaxed and started to
remove himself from the table. He wiped himself with the towel he had
on previousl and went into the shower area. got dressed and
met with in the kitchen area. E stein came into the kitchen and
provided $200.00 for brin ing and paid $200.00 to
for provi in
i
the massage. was o d to leave her telephone
to
number with his assistant or future contact. provided
her cellular te ephone number for future contact. was asked
if she was recently contacted about this investigation y anyone from
the Epstein organization. She replied she was called but it was for
work. She stated she was called by for her to return to work
for Epstein. stated work is t e term used by to provide
the massage in un erwear. advised she declined, as she was not
comfortable in providing tha ype of work. The interview was
concluded and the videotape was placed into evidence.
Investigation Continues..
****************************NARRAT
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
I V E 16 **************************
11/10/05
11/10/05
On November 7, 2005, I made telephone contact with who
advised she would be able to meet with me at her home. Det.
and I traveled to her home in Royal Palm Beach and made contact with
11 1
During a sworn totaped statement stated she met
.3  , Epstein through would approach females
who wished to work for him. state she was asked to work for
him but declined. exp aine that work means give massages.
She was asked about any ormal training in providing massages to which
she said no. said she accompanied and other females
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53 . Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 48
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 Continued)
who were taken to Epstein s house to provide massages.
further stated she had been to the house approximate or 5 times in
limit ear. She accompanied with
, and
Each time t e gir s were to en over, t ey were previously told they
would have to provide a massage, possibly naked. It was also told that
should Epstein require them to do anything extra and the were not
comfortable just to tell him and he would stop. stated
received $200.00 for each, girl she brought over to massage
Jeffrey Epstein. When I asked which girl appeared to be the youngest,
she replied, the victim, as she stated she was fifteen years old at
the most; she looked really young. further stated each time
she went to the house, she sat in the Itchen and waited with
until the massage was over. She further stated that the cook wou
make lunch or a snack for them as they waited. I asked her if there
was anything that caught her attention within the home.
stated there were a lot of naked girls in photographs throug out the
house. The interview was concluded and the tape was turned into
evidence.
Investigation Continues. .
****************************NARRATIvE # 17 **************************
NA Reported By: 11/10/05
Entered By.: II 11/10/05
Beachi ll'ileft my business card at her fr!!!illor. Ms
in Ro al Palm Det. and I attempted contact with
returned my call and arranged a meeting with me at the Pa m Beach
Police Department for November 8, 2005. At approximately 2:00pm,
arrived at the Palm Beach Police Department. She was brought
into the interview room and the door was closed for privacy. She was
told that I appreciated her coming to the police station for
questioning regarding an on going investigation. She was told that I
was investigating a crime involving Jeffrey Epstein and knew, based on
the investigation, that she had encounters with him in the past.
During a sworn taped statement, stated she had met Epstein
a roximatel tiiiiiiirs ago. She wasfirst introduced to Epstein by
approached her about working for Epstein and
prow din a massage to him for $200.00. The arrangements were made
and as could not take her the day the arran ements were made
took also attended
and was familiar with Epstein.
Ric illen door. She had met with an assistant and another
recalled she was brought there and entered through the back
several photograp s oil!!!ed females throughout the house.
assistant brought her upstairs as she observed
stated stein came in the room, wearing only a towel, and lai on the
table. stated he picked out the oils he wanted her to use and
requeste s e remove her clothing to provide the massage.
stated that on the first massage she provided she did not remove her
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 49
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
clothing. stated she had returned several times after that.
Each time s e returned more things happened. stated that the
same thing would happen. Epstein would walk into t e master
bedroom/bathroom area wearin only a towel. He would masturbate as
she provided a massage. stated she was unsure if he climaxed
as he masturbated under the towel. Additionally she never looked blow
his waist. She claimed that Epstein would convince her to remove her
clothes. She eventually removed her clothes and sta ed in her thong
anties. On occasion E•stein would
s e provi•e• a massage e wou • mastur•ate. a
formal training in providing a massage. stated
two females during her visits to rovide massages.
brouglii ii(r1 named
rougit. A ditiona
very beginning. The
into evidence.
and
stated s
y,
interview
Investigation continues.. .
1111111 from
e receive 200.00 for eac gir s e
was given $200.00 for taking her in the
was concluded and the tape was placed
Every time
e• she has no
she brought
stated she
****************************NARRATIVE # 18 **************************
NA Reported By: 11/13/05
Entered By.: 11/14/05
On November 8, 2005, I made telephone contact with W/F,
, at her residence. responded to II II.ice station
or an interview reference an ongoing investigation. At approximately
2:30 pm, she arrived at the Palm Beach Police Station and was brought
into the interview room for the interview. The door was closed for
privacy and she was told that I appreciated her cooperation in this
case. During a sworn taped statement, stated she had met
Jeffrey Epstein approximately one year ago. She was approached by a
subject known to her as had asked her if she wanted
to make money providin• massa•es to E•stein. had heard that
several girls from were doi this and
making money. She agree• an• was to en to t e house by
had introduced her to and Epstein and brought her upstairs to a
master bedroom and Master bathroom where a massage table was prepared
and the proper oils were taken out. left the room and waited
downstairs for III. stated Epstein entered the room wearing a
towel and she provided a massage wearing only her thong panties.
advised Epstein had masturbated every time she provided a
massage. She stated Epstein continued to masturbate until he
climaxed; once that occurred the massage was over. She felt the whole
situation was weird but she advised she was paid $200.00 for providing
the massage. She also stated received $200.00 for bring to
Epstein.
stated she had gone a total of 15 times to his residence to
provide a massage and things had escalated from just providing a
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 50
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 Continued)
massa•e. Epstein be
Epstein also
as she provide• t e massa e.
state on one occasion, he offered extra monies to
. She stated this all occurred on the massa e table.
stated Epstein
an
and climaxed onto the
massage to e. receive 350.00 for her massage. I asked her
if she had any forma training in providing massages, stated she
did not.
and
continued to state on one other occasion, Epstein introduced his
assistant, into the massage. was brou ht into room with
to rove e a massa e. E stein a
as t ey prove e a massage to
Epstein. Epste n, watt e an masturbated as this occurred. On other
occasions, Epstein introduced the lar e white vibrator massa er
d1.-ii the massage. Epstein
II she provided the massage.
stated the last time she spoke with anyone at the house, was
during the weekend of October 2 or 3, 2005. with stated
she had brou ht two eople to the Epstein house. She provided the
names of and (unknown last name . It should
noted, had een previously identified as and had
been previously interviewed. The interview was consconcluded and the
videotape was placed into evidence via the locker system.
On November 9, 2005, Sgt and I traveled to
in Boynton Beach, Flori a in hopes to interview , the
ormer houseman of Epstein's home. As no one was home, a business
card was left for him to return my call. We then traveled to II
"MI,in Miami in hopes to interview a former
of Epstein. We did not locate them at home. I left a
business card for him to return my call.
We then traveled to and met with Dean of Students, Mr.
We requeste to speak with was re
interviewed, as she still was in ossession of the rental car that
Epstein had acquired for her. stated that Epstein's
assistant, had called her on her ce lular telephone an informed her
that rental was extended for her. I. stated she had paid an
additional $625.00 for her to keep t e rental an extra month.
was asked if she had any additional contact with either Epstein or
anyone from his organization. stated she did not, other than
the telephone call informing her that she could keep the car for an
extra month. did not provide any additional information.
On November 10, 2005, at approximately 9:47 am,
IIIIIIIIIIiad telephoned reference my business card found on his oor.
stated he had worked with Epstein for approximately six mont s a ter
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 51
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
the previous houseman left. stated that it' was his
responsibility to keep the identity o the masseuses private. Mr.
E stein had a massage in the morning and one in the afternoon. Mr.
stated he would rather speak about this in private. He
a vise e would come to the police station to speak with me.
stated he would return my call on Monday, November 14, 2905.
I then made telephone contact with . He advised he found
my card on his door and wanted to know w at I needed to speak with him
about. I explained to that I was conducting an investigation
on his former employer, Mr. Epstein. stated he would return my
call shortly as he was in the middle o ro'ect at his home. I
received a telephone call from Attorne from

Mr. stated he represented Mr. an •i• not want me
spec ing with his client. I then made to ephone contact with the
State Attorney s Office and confirmed that subpoenas would be issued
to the former employees to assist in the investigation.
I then made telephone contact with Attorney Guy Fronstin, attorney for
Mr. Epstein. I explained to Mr. Fronstin that I would like to speak
with Mr. Epstein. He stated Mr. Epstein is not in residence in
Florida at this time and would check with him to ascertain if he could
be here by Wednesday November 16, 2005 for an interview. Mr. Fronstin
stated he would return my call should Mr. Epstein decide to come in to
the police station for an interview.
Investigation continues.
****************************NARRATIVE # 19 tk*************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
On November 14, 2005, Det. and I traveled to
in Loxahatchee, spoke with S e was
RI of the ongoing investigation involving Epstein. advised
Floridaa an
she had gone to the house on several occasions. During a sworn taped
statement, she advised she started oing to the house approximates
one year a o and was brought by (Unknown last name).
stated brought her into the ouse and she was introduce to a
girl name Once she met her, brought her upstairs into a
master bedroom bathroom. stated she met Jeffrey in the
bathroom. He lay on the table and picked the massage oils. She
provided the massage, as he lay naked on the massage bed. She stated
she rubbed his calves and back area. Upon the end of the massage,
Epstein removed himself from the massage table and paid her $300.00
for the massage.
11/16/05
11/16/05
stated she had only been at the house approximately five or
six times. said each time she went to the house she was
notified by Epstein's assistant, that Epstein was in town and
would like her to work. stated she returned to the house and
was again led upstairs by She provided the massage, clothed.
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 52
Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368
advised it wasn't really weird until later on.
as e i she ever removed her clothing to provide a massage.
stated it was not until the third time she went that she remove er
clothing. stated she was notified by that Epstein
wanted her to come to work. She arrived at theille and was led
upstairs by She started providin the massage when Epstein
asked her to remove her clothing. removed her pants, shirt
and bra. She stayed in her thong panties and continued rubbing
Epstein. E stein turned over onto his back and she rubbed his chest
area. stated she knew he was masturbating himself as she
providing t e massage. stated she believed he climaxed based
on his breathing. She di not want to view either the climax or the
fact that he was masturbating. stated once the breathing
relaxed he got up and told her to get ressed. She was paid $300.00
for her services.
stated on the last time she went to provide a massa e, she
ortable she was now datillilir current boyfriend and did not ee cora
was notified by to come to the house and work. stated
going. She recalled it was approximately January 2005. She said she
went, already thinking that this would be the last time. She went
upstairs and went into the master bathroom. She met with Epstein,
who was wearin only a towel as he entered the room to lie on the
table. stated Epstein caught her looking at the clock on
several occasions. Epstein asked her if she was in a hur
stated her boyfriend was in the car waiting for her. •urt er.
stated that Epstein got upset, as she wasn't enjoying t e massage.
She told him that she didn't want to continue and she would not be
back. Epstein told her to leave as she was ruining his massage. I
asked her if she had any contact with Epstein's organization, she
stated she received $200.00 from Western Union in Royal Palm Beach and
Okeechobee Blvd as a Christmas gift. advised she had no
formal training in provide any massages. also stated she was
sixteen years old when she first went to Epstein's house.
At a roximately 4:22 pm, I made telephone contact with
at She agreed to meet with me at a public place.
suggeste s e come to the police station for an interview. did
not want to meet at the police station. I recommended we meet at the
Palm Beach Gardens Mall in the food court area. She agreed and an
appointment was made for November 15, 2005 at 5:00 pm at the food
court.
Investigations Continue.
****************************NARRATIVE # 20 **************************
NA Reported By: 11/16/05
Entered By.: 11/17/05
On 10/20/2005, I assisted executing a search warrant at 358 El
Brillo Way in the Town of Palm Beach Palm Beach County Florida under
the direction of affiant Detective
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 53
Time: 8:47r53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Detective and I searched the pantry room that is west
next to the kitc en. T 's room had all white cabinets with a dark
grey and black counter top. We did not find anything in this room.
We searched the yellow and blue room that is west next to the
pantry room. This room had a very large statue of man with a bow.
Taken into evidence from this room were nine photographs in frames of
various women.
We searched the main entrance foyer that is to the north of the
yellow and blue room. This room contained two bamboo chairs and
ottomans with cushions. It also contained a round table with numerous
books.
We searched another blue room that is west of the foyer. This
room had a stereo system and book shelves that were from the floor to
the ceiling. Taken into evidence from this room were eight
photographs in frames of various women and/or Epstein, the owner of
the residence.
We searched the room to the west of the blue room that has
sliding glass doors that lead out to the pool. In this room in a
dresser were two DVD's and two VCR tapes. These items were taken into
evidence.
We searched a 2004 black Chevy Suburban bearing Florida tag
on t e
, registered to Jeffrey Epstein DOB , which was located
illi i east side of the driveway facing sour I lfound a Thrifty
rental agreement between the passenger seat and the middle console.
The name on the rental agreement was from
Palm Beach Gardens Florida 334 e p one number on e
rental agreement was The Vehicle rented was a
aring F or a tag . The vehicle was
rente on 9 25 05 at 17:58 hours and was returne on 9/26/05 at 16:52
hours. The last four numbers of the credit card used are
Detective found a piece of paper in the middle console that
said I use t e cash in here to fill up the tank and was signed by
I searched the 2005 black Cadillac Escalade ESV bearing Florida
tag registered to Jeffrey Epstein dob , which was
locate on the west side of the driveway facing sout I did not find
anything in this vehicle.
All of the items that were taken into evidence were photographed
in the place they were located and then turned over to crime scene.
****************************NARRATIVE # 21 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
11/17/05
11/17/05
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 54
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
in Royal Palm Beach. We met with a
and I traveled to .On November 15, 2005, Det.
seventeen-year old juvenile who was not in schoo this day due to a
cold from which she was suffering. was told that I needed to
speak with her in reference to an ongo ng investigation involving a
subject she would know as Jeffrey Epstein. Prior to speaking with
her, I explained that because of the fact that she is a minor, I
needed to speak with her parents •rior to speaking with her. She
telephoned her father, Mr. on his cell phone and
explained to him that Det. an• I were there to speak with her.
I spoke with Mr. on t e telephone and informed him I needed
to s ak with his aug ter in reference to an ongoing investigation.
Mr. advised he had no problem with us speaking with his
daug ter.
During a sworn taped statement, stated she met Jeffrey
Epstein over aii .rai•She was sixteen years of age and was
approached by who informed her that she could make monies
that she would have to provide this massage tills. made the
providing a massage to Epstein for $200.00. had informed her
arrangements with Epstein and his assistants and took to the
house. stated and she entered through a g ass door
that led into a kitchen. took her upstairs, to a master bedroom
and master bathroom. She recalled the bathroom had a large pink
couch, sauna and matchin shower. stein entered into the room
wearing only a towel. and removed their clothing
remaining only in thong un erwear. S e further stated that Epstein
lay on his chest on the table. E stein selected which oils to use for
the massage. Both and provided the massage on his
legs, back and feet. Forty minutes into the massage, Epstein turned
over onto his back and requested wait downstairs in the kitchen
area for Epstein instructed to finish the massage.
As got dressed, starting rub trig his chest.
left the room, and Epstein e an masturbating himself as
rubbed Epstein s chest. stated he continued mastur at ng
until he climaxed on the towe e was wearing. When asked if he had
removed the towel she stated he turned the towel around so that the
opening would allow him to expose himself. After he cleaned himself
off with the towel, he instructed the massage was done and to
get dressed and met with him downstairs. got dressed and met
with Epstein in the kitchen area. She was pal 200.00 dollars for
providing the massage. stated she was aware that also
received monies for the same t ing.
The second time she went to the house she was again approached by
asked if she wanted to return to the house to provide
anot er massage; agreed and the arran ements were made by
for her to return to the house. stated drove her
to the house and knocked on the same glass door that leads to the
kitchen area. The were allowed entry into the house by one of the
staff members. led her upstairs to the master bedroom and
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 55
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
alone. Epstein entered. iroom again wearing only a towel.
master bathroom area. left this time to do the massage
began removing her clothing as she did the last time she was at t e
house. Epstein instructed her to get naked. He lay on the table on
began massaging his legs and back. his stomach as
As finished with E stein's back and legs, Epstein then turned
over onto his back. started to rub his chest and he began
masturbating himself. As rubbed his chest, Epstein leaned
over and produced a massager vibrator.
stated she continued to rub his chest as this was occurring.
She described the vibrator massa•er as lane •re with a lar•e head.
Epstein
He then
and concentrated on masturbating himself. stated he
climaxed onto the towel again and informed her that the massage was
done. got dressed and met with who was waitin in the
kitchen area. She received $200.00 for t e massage. said
she never returned to the house and had no desire to return to the
house. was asked if she received any formal massa e
training. S e advised she had no formal training. was asked
if Epstein knew her real age. stated he knew as e asked her
questions about herself and hi sc oo . He was aware she attended
and is still attending
The interview was concluded. I suggeste
d
d inform her parents
of what occurred at the Epstein house. tated she would tell
her father as he was unaware this had occurred. I left my business
card for any questions they may have. We left the area and returned
to the police station. The tape was placed into evidence.
Investigation Continues.
**************************** N A R R A
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
T I V E # 22 **************************
a MI
11/17/05
11/17/05
On November 15, 2005, Officer and I res onded to the Palm Beach
Gardens Mall food court section to meet with At
approximate) 5:10 p.m., arrived and met with us at the food
court. provided a sworn taped statement in which she stated
she had been at the Epstein house over fifty times. She be an going
to Epstein's house when she turned eighteen years old. was
asked if she knew of the on-going investigation. stated she
was aware there was an investigation as she had been to d by other
girls that were interviewed. Additionally, she has had several
telephone conversations with Epstein's assistants as to what had been
going on during the investigation.
I asked how she was introduced to Epstein. stated she
did not want to disclose who brought her to the house but she would
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 56
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
respond to an other questions. When I asked her what happened at the
house, stated everything happened. It all began with the
massages. Each time she went more things happened. She would massage
Epstein and he would masturbate and climax. She stated thins
escalated from there. She
He intro
with
as Epstein an
is was •one at Epstein's direction.
man
S e was told to
ad sexual intercourse. All
could not provide exact dates as she had been to the house
stated Epstein inserte
. When I as e er i t ere a
een any vagina in ercourse wi pstein she stated she did not have
sex with him. She did admit having III , his assistant.
stated not every time she went invo velil i xual favors.
Molts she would just talk with him and get paid. I asked her how
much she was paid each time she went to Epstein s residence.
stated she got paid $300.00 every time she went to the house. S e was
told to bring other girls to him to provide massages. declined
stating that she does what she does. and did not want to introduce
anyone else to do what she does. stated she had never received
any formal training in providing massages.
I showed a photo line up in which was placed in
position six. She reviewed the six photographs an immediately
identified as the person with whom she had
intercourse. Ad itiona y, it was the same person she watched have
s photo as the person she identified. We then left!!!
intercourse with Epstein. She signed the photo line-up under
ma an returned to the police station. The photo line up and tape
were placed in to evidence.
times.
Investigation Continues. ..
SO
****************************NARRATIVE # 23 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
11/29/05
12/01/05
On November 17, 2005, I received a phone message from Atty. Guy
Fronstin who advised to call his cellular phone reference his client
Jeffrey Epstein. I telephoned his cell phone and left a message for
him to return my call. I did not receive a call back on Thursday,
November 17, 2005. On Friday, November 18 2005, I retrieved another
voice mail from my work phone from Mr. Fronstin advising he would not
produce his client Jeffrey Epstein for any statement. Fronstin stated
he had spoken with ASA Lana Belohlavek and expressed Mr. Epstein has a
passion for massages. I called ASA Lana Belohlavek and confirmed that
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 57
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Fronstin had telephoned her reference this case. Although nothing was
discussed, Mr. Fronstin did advise her that Epstein is very passionate
about massages.
I also spoke with ASA Daliah Weiss reference ,
and . She advised that they a een serve t rough
a subpoena process server. They were both scheduled to appear on
Monday November 21, 2005 at 12:00 p.m.
On November 21 2005 I met with ASA Weiss, Atty. and
and at the State Attorney Office. ASA Weiss ad
re ested a court reporter to be resent to take the statement of the
I s oke with , in the presence of her attorney,
She adv se s e a worked for Epstein for eight
years, from t e period of 1994 through 2002. She advised she had
never had any direct conversations with him. She stated it was her
husband who spoke directly with Epstein. Her work consisted of doing
house cleaning, shopping and other preparations when Epstein would
Oilarrive in town. stated the preparations consisted of preparing
the house and bat rooms for his arrival. She advised she did view
several masseuses that arrived at the house. She advised that two or
three girls would come during a day and provide the massages. The
girls that arrived looked young in age. Mrs. did not know any
of the girls personally and were always different. She was told that
when Epstein was in residence he did not want to encounter the
during his stay in Palm Beach.
I then spoke with Mr. in the presence of his attorney,
. Mr. IIIIII state that he was employed for eleven years with
Mr. Epstein. He originally was hired as a part time employee and then
moved up into a full time position. His duties included everything.
stated he was the house manager, driver and house maintenance
person. It was his responsibility to prepare the house for Epstein s
arrival. When asked about cooks or assistants, stated they
traveled with Epstein on his private plane. He remembered dealing
with his girlfriend, Ms. Maxwell originally and then dealt with
Epstein directly.
I asked Mr. about massages that occurred within the home. Mr.
stated Mr. Epstein had up to three massages a day. Each
masseuse that visited the house was different. stated that
towards the end of his employment, the masseuses were younger and
sixteen or seventeen years of age ajill illost. The massages would
younger. When asked how young, Mr. stated they appeared to be
occur in Epstein's bedroom or bathroom. There were times he recalled
that he would set up the massage tables either in Epstein s bedroom or
in his bathroom. I asked if there were things going on other than a
massage. stated that there were times towards the end of his
employment t at he would have to wash off a massager/vibrator and a
long rubber penis, which were in the sink after the massage.
Additionally, he.stated the bed would almost always have to be made
after the massage. was never privy to what went on during the
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 58
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
massages.
He was asked if he remembered any names of the girls that massaged
Epstein. He tried to remember and was unable to provide any exact
names of any girls. was asked about any contact with anyone
from the Epstein organization. said he did speak with Mr.
Epstein shortl after my initial contact with him to find out what was
Mi ll
going on. also stated that approximately on November 11, 2005,
he was contacte by a private investigator from the Law Office of Roy
Black. The investigator had called him to meet with him to ascertain
what he was going to tell the police. stated they met at the
Carrabba s Restaurant in Boynton Beach an iscussed the same
questions I was asking him. I informed Mr. and Mr.
that as this is an ongoing investigation an anyt ing we discuss
should be confidential. They both acknowledged the fact that the
information would be kept confidential. It should be noted that a
court reporter was present during the interviews and would be
providing a copy of the statements to me when they become available
On November 21, 2005, I received a voice mail from Mr. Fronstin who
advised he would not be making Mr. Epstein available for any
statements. He did have some words that he wanted to relay on behalf
of Mr. Epstein. I telephoned his office and left a message for him to
return my call.
On November 29, 2005, I received a call back from Mr. Fronstin who
left a voice mail after hours on November 28, 2005, advising he would
return my call during normal business hours to speak with me reference
the case on November 29, 2005.
****************************NARRATIVE # 24 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.: • 11/29/05
12/01/05
On November 29, 2005, at approximately 2:30 p.m. I received a
telephone call on the department issued cell phone. Mr. Fronstin
stated he was calling to relay information that Mr. Epstein wished he
could relay. Mr. Fronstin stated that he would not allow Mr. Epstein
to speak with me at this time. He further stated that Mr. Epstein is
very passionate about massages. He continued that Mr. Epstein had
allegedly donated over $100,000 to the Ballet of Florida for massages.
The massages are therapeutic and spiritually sound for him that is
why he has had many massages. Mr. Fronstin stated he appreciated the
way the investigation has not been leaked out into the media. I
explained to Mr. Fronstin that it is as important to protect the
innocent if the allegations are not substantiated. Mr. FronStin was •
told of the allegations that the private investigators assigned to the
case have been portraying themselves as police officers.
Additionally, I explained that my cell phone had been called by the
private investigators. Mr. Fronstin advised he was not aware of that
and advised they were under the direction of Attorney Roy Black in
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 59
Incident Report Program: CM5301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued) .
Miami. Mr Fronstin further stated Epstein had originally called Mr.
Dershorwitz in Boston, who recommended Roy Black in Miami, who asked

Mr. Fronstin to assist. I informed him that if and when any charges
would be presented I would notify him. The call was then terminated.
Investigation continues.
**************************** N A R R A T I V E
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
25 **44**********************
12/15/05
12/16/05
A review of the telephone message books, which were obtained during
the search warrant, was conducted in which various messages from
different dates were made to Jeffrey Epstein. The telephone message
books have a duplicate copy (Carbon Copy) which, once a phone message
is written into the book, the top copy is then torn on the perforated
edge and the carbon copy is left in the book. First names of girls,
dates and telephone numbers were on the copy of the messages. I
recognized various numbers and names of girls that had already been
interviewed. The body of the messages was time of the day that they
called for confirmation of "work." Other names and telephone numbers
were located in which the body of the messages were, "I have girls for
him" or "I have 2 girls for him." These messages were taken by
for Jeffrey Epstein. Based on the context of the body of the
messages, I requested subpoenas for subscriber information on the
telephone numbers and the time frame involved. Copies of the messages
were made for evidentiary purposes.
I obtained yearbooks for 2005

2003. I first rev ewe the 2005 yearbook and located most
girls I had spoken with. Additionally, I located
Based on the corrected name spelling, I was able to ocate
residence in Loxahatchee. On December 8, 2005, Det.
in Loxahatchee. I located
she is attendin
, 2004 and
of the
er to her
and I
responded to at
her home. She a v se an is
participating in the so s e can maintain her
part time job. As she s st a minor, I left my business card to
have her mother return my call to request an interview with her
daughter. We then left the area.
I also had previousl researched
telephone number
information on
of
that she is the daughter of
contact with
her front door

Mr. w t
return my call.
. A
The
the telephone number for " and
subpoena had been issued for the
telephone number was registered to
A query of revealed
and is currently residing at
in West Pa m Beac . Det. and I attempted
with negative results. Ill'llliy business card on
re esting she return my call. We then responded to
in West Palm Beach. I also attempted contact with
negative results. I left my business card for him to
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
Case No • 1-05-000368
Page: 60
Program: CMS301L
(Continued)
On December 9 2005, I received a telephone call from IIII
mother, who was made aware of the on going
investigation in Palm Beach. MIM advised she was told of
everything that occurred at Epstein's house involving Epstein and his
staff. She advised she would allow me to question her daughter about
what occurred and would cooperate with the investigation.
provided me with cellular telephone number to schedule an
appointment for an o icial interview. I telephoned her cellular
telephone and made a tentative appointment for Monday, December 12,
2005.
I then received a telephone call from father of
who stated he found the business car on is door. I
exp ained that I was conducting an investigation and needed to speak
with IIIII as she ma have information that could assist in the
investigation. Mr. stated that his daughter no longer resides
with him and has her own trailer in another trailer park. He advised
he would tell her to call me.
On December 12, 2005, due to
were made to meet with
at 5:00 pm. On December 13
Loxahatchee and met with
statement, stated t w n she was sixteen years old, she was
taken to Epstein's house to provide a massage for mone
stated it was before Christmas last year when approached
her and asked if she needed to make money for C rIstmas• stated
she did and agreed toprovide a massage for money. ma e
arrangements to take to the house and drove to the house
to "work." !III', state s e could not remember the street name but
would be able to drive to the street. They drove to the last house on
the street and pulled in the last house on left side. They walked up
the driveway and entered through a side gate which led to a kitchen
door. They knocked on the door and were encountered by an employee
who described as a
that they were expected. The
with long hair.
white female with
a conflict with schedules, arrangements
05, Det.
IatM F
on Tuesday, December 13, 2005
and I traveled to
During a sworn taped
looking lady." They informed her
were then encountered by a white female
was unable to remember the name of the
iar but knew she was Epstein's assistant.
She was led upstairs by the white female who explained that there
would be lotions out already and Epstein would choose the lotion he
wanted her to use. She was led through a spiral staircase which led
to a master bedroom and bathroom. The massage table was already set
up in the bathroom. described the bathroom as a large spacious
,bathroom with a steam room and shower beside it with a sink to the
right. was introduced to Jeff who was on the phone when she
entered. Jeff was wearing a white towel and la on his stomach so
that IIIIII may massage his feet and calves. started the
massage with the massage oil Jeff chose and rubbed his feet and
calves. Jeff got off the phone and requested she massage his back as
well. began rubbing his back and got to the small of his back.
During the rubbing of his back Jeff asked her to get comfortable. He
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 61
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
requested she remove her pants and shirt.
and pulled her pants off.
As she finished the small
back. He instructed she
began to rub his chest, Je as e er ques
remembered telling him she attended
Jeff asked her if she was sexually active. Be ore
could answer, he also asked what sexual positions does she enjoy
M illed rubbing his chest. Epstein reached u and
stated she was shy didn't like talking about those things. She
from the front. explained the
stein
(Continued)
removed her shirt
stayed in
e back. Jeff
er ra and thong panties.
then turned onto his
As
ons out erself.
said "no, I don't like that.!
en remove• is towe an lay on the bed naked exposing his
He be an touching his penis and masturbated as he
explained Jeff then
•
she
was uncom or able.
ense• up an s a e was aware t she
stated that Jeff told her , "Relax, I'm not going She
ur er explained Jeff commented to her how beautiful and se s e
was. Jeff then
time e e•t
stated he said he
climaxed onto t e towe e a. .een previous y wearing an• got up from
the table. Jeff told her there was $200.00 dollars for her on the
dresser within the master bathroom. Jeff also told her that there was
there to massage him. Jeff told her to leave M telephone number
an additional $100.00 that was to be given to for bringing her
with his assistant as he wanted to see her again. Jeff stated his
assistant would contact her to work again soon.
ETFFItteliFfl- 4C74trZWNITM
Dur this
I asked her if she ever received any formal massage training to which
stated she did not. stated it was the only time she
ever went to work for Jeff and ew what happened to her was wrong.
She stated she no longer speaks to because she was upset that
took her there. She further stated that she had never been
contacted for any additional work. The interview was terminated and
we left the area.
Investigation Continues. ..
****************************NARRATIVE
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
# 26 **************************
• 12/18/05
12/19/05
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 62
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
On 102005 at approx 0930hrs I assisted with the execution of a
search warrant at 358 El Brillo Ave, Palm Beach.
Initially I was assigned to enter the residence and conduct a
sweep of the premises for safety purposes. I then accompanied CSEU
tech while she photographed the exterior of the house. Once
this was com lete I was assigned to search certain areas of the house
with Det. as part of the search warrant.
We began in the garage, searching three Mercedes Benz vehicles, a
Harley Davidson motorcycle and adjacent closets in the garage.
Nothing of evidentiary value was located.
We then searched two closets off the kitchen area on the east
side. These can best be described as pantry or storage closets.
Nothing of evidentiary value was obtained.
A small office with adjoining bath was then searched. In the bath
area I located a phone message book with recent messages. This item
wasseized as evidence. Please note this bath and shower area are not
used as designed but are storage areas containing a variety of items
to include a gun safe in the shower and assorted household items.
We then searched a bath area and closet at the base of the main
stairs in the foyer. Inside the closet two massage tables were
located as well as partial nude female photographs. These items were
later seized as evidence. Nothing of evidentiary value was noted in
the bathroom.
We then searched two bedrooms upstairs on the east side of the
residence. Located in the bath room of the south bedroom was penis
shaped soap. Located in the bedroom of the northern bedroom was penis
and vagina shaped soap as well as an adult sex toy. These items were
seized as evidence.
We then searched the pool cabana located in the south west corner.
of the property. Several photographs of nude females were seized as
evidence.
I was then assigned to stand by with a person I believe was
Mr. was in the residence at the
eginning o t e search warrant. He was present during the warrant
service and subsequent search. I stood by with him until the search
was completed and I departed the residence. I had no conversation
with him regarding the reason for our presence.
Regarding seized evidence, all items were photographed in place
and then collected by CSEU personnel.
This concludes my involvement in this case.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
Case No • 1-05-000368
**************************** N A R R A T I V E
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
# 27
Page: 63
Program: CMS301L
(Continued)
**************************
• On Thursday, October 20, 2005 at approximately 0936 hours
in the execution of a search warrant located at
Palm Beach, Florida residence of Jeffrey Epstein. I was
by Case Agent Det. to secure all computer
related material from t e rest ence.
12/21/05
12/21/05
I assisted
instructed
and media
Upon my arrival I was directed by Det. to a room designated as
the Kitchen Staff Office. I observed a, Si ver in color, CPU with the
left side cover removed, exposing the CPU s hardware sitting on floor
next to a glass type desk. The CPU had no discernable identifiers or
features indicating a make or model. This CPU was powered off with
the power cord not plugged in. The keyboard and mouse were atop the
CPU. It should be noted that the CPU was not connected to a monitor,
printer, or other media device. On the back Panel of the CPU, I
observed an A/V card with RCA jacks attached. This type of hardware
would allow audio and video to be downloaded onto the CPU s hard disk'.
The ends of the RCA jacks were unattached at the time of the search
and no external camera was located within this room.
The CPU was located on the right side of a desk that held a flat panel
LCD screen. The desk also held another keyboard and mouse, indicative
of a second computer; however, no other computer was found. It
appeared as though a second computer had been recently removed as the
cables ends from the monitor, keyboard and mouse were in the same
area. A further search of the room revealed no media storage devices,
i.e. CD s, Floppy Disks, Zip Disks, etc. This type of media is
commonly stored in an area where computers are placed, yet no media
was found.
After completing a search of this room, I secured the CPU and turned
all items over to the Evidence Custodian for future forensic analysis
via a property receipt.
I was then directed by Det. to a room designated as the Garden
Room, where I observed a woo en esk facing west. The desk held a
flat screen LCD monitor, keyboard, mouse, media card reader and
printer; however, no CPU was located. All of the cables were removed
from an area where a computer had once been. A search of the desk
area revealed no signs of any media devices.
Det. directed me to a third location designated as the Cabana
room, which is detached from the residence and located just south of
the pool. In the South East corner of the room, I observed an office
type setting, with an L-shaped desk holding a flat screen LCD monitor,
keyboard, mouse and printer; however, no CPU was located. All of the
cables were removed from an area where a computer had once been. A
search of the desk area revealed no signs of any media devices.
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
On December 20 2005
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 64
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report . Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Det. directed me to a second detached structure located on the
South Eas corner of the property. This area of this structure was
assigned with single letters to identify a particular part of the
room. In the office area, designated as Room B, I observed a powered
on Dell Dimension 2350, attached to an LCD flat panel monitor. The
screen displayed an open Microsoft Internet Explorer browser with URI,
address of http://home.bellsouth.net/. I observed no other active
windows in the Start panel window and photographed screen. The power
cord was removed from the back of the Dell CPU and I disconnected the
cable modem to prevent remote access. At that time, the Dell CPU,
marked with Serial Number was secured and turned over the
evidence custodian for future orensic analysis via property receipt.
I also located several media related items within Room B, which were
recorded onto a property receipt and turned over the Evidence
Custodians.
I then responded to a Bedroom designated as Room F, where I observed a
white in color CPU marked Premio. The Premio CPU was in a computer
desk which held a white CRT monitor, both of which were powered on.
The CRT monitor displayed a message from Norton Antivirus software,
warning of an expired subscription. I observed no other active
windows in the Start panel window and photographed screen. I removed
the power cable from the back of the Premio CPU and shutdown all other
media. The Premio CPU, marked with Serial Number was
secured and turned over the evidence custodian for uture orensic
analysis via property receipt. I also located several media related
items within Room F, which were recorded onto a property receipt and
turned over the Evidence Custodians.
This concluded my participation in the search of the residence.
**************************** N A R R A T I V E # 28 **************************
a In
who rest es in Miami, e process servers previous y an
was not served the investigative subpoena. A telephone message was
left as she is not available durin the week of 12/19/2005. I made
contact with State Attorney Inv and requested the same
via telephone message.
I then researched the victim's II cellular telephone subpoena data
which had been received from a previous subpoena re est. I analyzed
the records which depict several calls from The
telephone calls start on February 6, 2005 at 12:49 pm.; the same day
which the victim and the victim's father stated the incident occurred
at Epstein s house. The first incoming call was from
residence at . The second incoming call from
12/21/05
12/21/05
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 65
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No - 1-05-000368 (Continued)
were one minute or  time frame was within thirteen minutes
cellular phone occurred at 1:02 pm. The call durations
apart. It should be noted that I residence was in close
proximity to the victim's. The next call occurred at 5:50 pm when the
victim telephoned I residence. Several calls were made after
the above mentionellills both incoming and outgoing to
Further analysis showed no telephone calls to either cellular
telephone or residence were registered prior to Fe ruary 6,
2005.
Additional) , I also conducted an analysis on the telephone calls from
The subscriber information confirmed that the number is
registers to Il 'III' from Hialeah, Florida. The address was
crossed reference to t e Office of Kiraly and Riley Private
Investigators. I researched the web page www.rileykiraly.com which
also showed various cases in which they assisted. I also located
another web site under www.coralspringssparklandrotary.org in which
Mr. Riley attended a Miami Rotary meeting and confirmed Atty. Roy
Black is among his clientele.
The  lephone calls revealed
and
interview them, or just prior. A
which revealed he holds a current
had telephone contact with
either just after I attem&2 to
ackground was conducted on
Private Investi ator License. A
I also researched the girls using www.myspace.com. This web site is a
new social networking service that allows members to create unique
personal profiles online in order to find and communicate with old and
new friends. The site allows one to establish your own myspace.com
page and decorate the page an way one wishes. I found the followin
eo le have m space sites:
, and
I received a packet which contained a CD which
contained the resu is o t e subpoena request for verbatim calls on
An analysis will be conducted in the near future on the
p one n ers called.
Investigation Continues.
****************************NARRATIVE # 29 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
Upon doing research on the message
warrant I located the identity of
was registered to
seventeen years old and is atten•ing t
12/27/05
12/29/05 .
books recovered in the search
" The telephone number
She currentl is
. I
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 66
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
responded to also known as the
I ocate• . I located
niside the in orme at I was
investigating a case against Jeffrey Epstein and knew she had been at
the house. started to cry and advised she had put that part
of her life e in her. I explained that although she is seventeen
years old I needed to inform her parents that she would be
interviewed. She provided her home telephone number. I attempted
contact and left voice mail messages at the house to speak with her
'parents.
Det. and I  then located at her residence located
at in West Palm Beat ilI I attempted to interview her
about Je rey Epstein. She advised she is so in love with Jeff
Epstein and would do anything for him. She further explained that she
would not speak with us about him either negative or positive. She
asked us to leave her property. I informed her that although she did
not wish to speak with us, I had sufficient information at this point
in the investigation to know she was at Epstein's house and provided
girls to Epstein to work. I also explained that prior to our arrival
at her residence I had telephone contact with her father
who was told she would be interviewed. is
currently seventeen years old and as a juvenile, parental notification
would be required. We then left the area and returned to the police
station.
While at the police station, I left another tele hone message for
s parents. I began an anal sis of Cellular
to e one. The telephone number is assign to
and the financially responsi e party is Jeffrey Epstein o 457
Madison Ave. in New York City, New York. The time frame which was
subpoenaed was September 2005, through October 2005. There were
eighty seven pages of calls made either to the cell phone or from the
cell phone. The local (561) numbers were analyzed. A spread sheet
was prepared and placed into the attachment file of who was called.
The unknown numbers were researched using FoneFinder.com and subpoenas
were requested to determine subscriber information. This was done to
identify additional victims or witnesses. The analysis revealed that
had called the victim/witnesses frequently when Epstein was in
the Town of Palm Beach to "work." This confirms what the girls
interviewed had previously stated. would notify them when
Epstein was in town and their willingness to "work." The CD was placed
into evidence.
Investigation Continues.
****************************
NA
NARRATIVE # 30 **************************
Reported By: 1/03/06 ,
Entered By.: 1/03/06
On December 29, 2005, I received a facsimile from National Compliance
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 67
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 Continued)
from Cingular Wireless for tele hone number
• lIgn
was the tele hone number for during the time rame when
the victim, was brought to t e Epstein house to "work." An
analysis of t e phone records, of all incoming and out oing calls,
showed that on February 6, 2005, the day the victim, was brought
first called Epstein's assistant,
t 12:50 pm (EST). T e next ca l was made to Epstein's
m Beach, at 12:52 pm (EST). The following call was made
to the victim, at 1:01 pm (EST) and at 1:02 pm (EST). This
confirms the intimation provided by the victim and victim's father.
I photo copied the records and enlarged the page 8 of 10 to show the
calls made by on February 6, 2005.
To this date, I have not heard from parents. I
will attempt to establish contact with them during the evening hours.
I received a package from Atty. Guy Fronstin, which was hand
delivered at the police station. Within the package, was a letter
from Alan Dershowitz and two www.m s ace.com profiles. The profiles
were that of and MySpace..com is a social
networking service t at allows me ers to create unique personal
profiles online in order to find and communicate with old and new
friends. This package was in response to a previous meeting in which

Mr. Dershowitz called to assist in the investigation in providing any
additional witnesses such as house employees who have been reluctant
to speak with law enforcement.
I reviewed the profiles Mr. Dershowitz enclosed. who designed
her biiimiiibe " ," still attends
sends and receives messages from friends which contain
some TATATIty. Upon reviewing her friends' comments section from
Myspace, most of her good friends sent messages to establish contact
and invite her to go out.
I then reviewed
Dershowitz. Ms. esMier blog to be " Her blog
states that her interests include music, theater an wee (Marijuana) .
I reviewed her packet in which IIII declares her love for her live-in
boyfriend. She also describes using marijuana with her boyfriend
The letter Mr. Dershowitz sent advised he was looking into the
allegation that one of the private investigators used by the private
attorneys of Epstein, attempted to impersonate or state that they were
police officers from Palm Beach. Mr. Dershowitz advised that the
investigators used to interview had "quite a distinct
speech impediment", did not claim to e nor id they impersonate
themselves as a police officer. This package was sent to both ASA
Lana Belohlavic and ASA Daliah Weiss at the State Attorney's Office.
web blog which was rovided by Mr.
I made telephone contact with ASA Weiss to confirm she received the
packiii iiid request an interview with
and She advised she would assist in attempt
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 68
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
contact Mr Dershowitz.
(Continued)
On January 3, 2006, I received a telephone call from ASA Weiss who
informed me that she made telephone contact with Mr. Dershowitz. She
had requested the employees be available the week of January 3, 2006.
Mr. Dershowitz informed her that the assistants are out of the
country and would require additional time to locate them and make them
available.
Investigation Continues.
**************************** N A R R A T I V E
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
# 31 **************************
• on Thursday, 03/31/05, I started conducting surveillance at 358 El
Brillo. At this point I observed at 1155 hours, a
FL tag in Roadway, FL tag
earing FL tag in Roa way, Blac
driveway and a Black Cadd Esca ade in driveway.
observed in roadway, Black
drivewa B acc Ca y Esca a e in drive and a
tag At 1615 hours I observed a
roadway, B ack Chevy Suburban in drive, B
driveway and a III.' III car in roadway.
On Friday, 04/01/05, I continued surveillance at 358 El Brillo. At
1130 hours I observed a bearing FL tag in
roadway, Black Cadd Esca a e in driveway and a III unknown make model
bearing FL tack in roadway. At 1227 hours, I observed a
in roadway, Black Caddy Escalade in driveway and a
B ack Cif SUV ocated behind the Escalade. At 1345 hours, I
observed a in roadwa and a Black Chevy SUV in
served a in
1/03/06
1/03/06
driveway. tAA  hours, I o
roadway, Black Chevy SUV in driveway, B ac Ca y Escalate  driveway
and a dark unknown model/make car parked in garage.
On Saturday, 04/02/05, I continued surveillance at 358 El Brillo. At
0713 hours, I observed a bearing FL tag in roadway
and a Black Caddy Escala e in riveway. At 0814 hours, I observed a
in roadway, Black Caddy Escalade in driveway and a
At 0952 hours, I observed a
in roadway, Black Caddy Escalade in driveway,
in roadway and also a Grey unknown make/model with a B.M in
trunk retrieving landscaping tools.
At 1155 hours, I observed a bearing FL to parking
in the roadway in front of 35 ri o. A W/F, air, teens to
early 20's, thin and tall wearing a white tank top an short blue jean
shorts, exited the vehicle and walked to the rear of the house. I
also observed a in roadway,
in roadway and a B ac Ca y Esca ade in driveway. At 1310 ours, I
in drive,
evy Suburban in
At 1325 Hours I
Chevy Suburban in
car bearing FL
y Escalade in
in
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 69
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
observed a W/F driver leaving the area, on
roadway and a bearing FL tag Then o serve 3 W Fs,
approximately 16 to 18 years of agfLigging. All 3 females ran into
the driveway. There were 2 with IIIII hair and one hair.
On Sunday, 04/03/05, I continued surveillance at 358 El Brillo. At
0719 hours I observed a in roadway and a Black
Caddy Escalade. At 0934 hours, I observed a in
roadway and a Black Cadd Escalade in driveway.
observed only the
At 1057 ours I
On Tuesday, 04/05/05, I continued surveillance at 358 El Brillo. At
1052 hours, I observed a in roadwa , a
, bearing FL to in roaill a bearing FL
tag in roadway, in roa way, Black
Merce es in driveway being was ed by a B M and an unknown dark car
parked in the garage. At 1059 hours a'Ill l drove to
the house of 358 El Brillo and parked in t e riveway. At 1119 hours,
I observed the leave the area and the drive
was the pool man.
At 1126 hours, I observed a Grey unknown make/model car park in
'roadway. w/M got out of the car and walked to a house on the south
side of At
white box truck parked behin 11ance
1406 hours, I observed a 1111.1111 parked on
roadway
suburban.
**************************** N A R R A T I V E
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
# 32 **************************
■ 1/03/06
1/03/06
On 03/31/05, at approximately 1500 hours while conducting surveillance
at 358 El Brillo, I observed a Black Cadillac Escalade, unknown tag, a
Black Chevrolet Suburban, unknown tag, a Black Mercedes S600 FL tag
arked in the east drilTlaynext to the 3-car garage. There
was a FL tag IIIIII parked on the street in front of
the rest ence.
At approximately 1700 hours, I observed the Black Suburban, Black
At 1750 hours, there was no cRITT IR IM es. At 1840 hours, I
Escalade, Black Mercedes and parked in the same place.
observed the Black Escalade, Black Suburban and Black Mercedes along
with a FL tag all parked in the east
driveway an a FL tag parked on the street in
front of the residence.
At 2000 hours, I observed the Black Escalade, Black Suburban parked in
the ease driveway and the and parked on the
street.
On Friday, 04/01/05 at approximately 1700 hours, I observed the Black
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 70
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
Escalade and Black Suburban parked in the east driveway and the III
parked on the street in front of the residence. At 1820
ours o served the Suburban and in the same place and a
FL tag park." the street in front of t
rest ence. At 250 there was no change. At 2330 I observed the
Black Escalade parked in the driveway and the parked on
the street in front of the residence.
On Saturday, 04/02/05 at approximately 1700 hours,
Escalade unknown tag, parked in the driveway and a
tag parked in the street in front of the resi
hours t e Escalade and
I observed a Black
FL
ence. At 1805
were in the same position and the Black
Mercedes FL tag was also parked in the east driveway. At 192O
a an
the same position. At M ilhours and 2145 hours there were no
vehicles observed.
hours the Escala were the only vehicles and both were in

At. 2115 hours, I observed a Black Mercedes, 4-door parked in the east
driveway FL tag At 2300 hours, 2350 hours and 0045 hours, the
Black Mercedes was e only vehicle observed.
**************************** N A R R A T I V E # 33 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
I made contact with Mr. father of
who was told that I wishe to interview his daughter. Mr.
stated he was aware and had spoken with his daughter about t e
incident. He stated that his daughter had previously told him that
she was hired to model lingerie at a Palm Beach mansion. Mr.
stated he knew nothing else about what she did when she went to
"work." Mr. advised he would cooperate with the investigation
and make his aug er available for interviews. I asked if she was
available for an interview, stated she was not at home at the
moment. I informed him I wou ma e contact with her at a later time.
Mr. expressed his interest in the resolution in this matter
as he stated this information has affected his daughter emotionally.
On January 4, 2005, I acquired the subpoenas from the State Attorney's
Office for Cingular Wireless, Metro PCS Verizon Bell South
Telecommunications and Sprint for the from
cellular telephone. The su poenas were sent to the
respective to ephone carriers for subscriber information.
I received a telephone call from State Attorney's Office, who informed
was •resent at the State Attorney's Office for anitilliew. me that the former houseman for Jeffrey Epstein,
was issued an investi•ative sub•oena
. I respon e to t e
State Attorney's O ce an• encountere• Mr. waiting in the
to the interview room.
1/05/06
1/05/06
lobby. I brought Mr.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 71
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
During a sworn taped statement, Mr. stated he was employed
by Jeffrey Epstein for approximately six mont s. He was referred by
associates and his employment lasted the months of November 2004
through May 2005. His responsibilities as house manager included
being the butler, chauffer, chef, houseman, run errands for Mr.
Epstein and provide for Epstein's guests. advised he had
very limited contact with Mr. Epstein. If needed to relay a
messa e to Mr. Epstein, he would have to note y Epstein's secretary
ii in New York City, who would then notify Epstein'spersonal
assistant, who would relay the message to Epstein.
stated Epstein id not want to see or hear the staff when he was in
residence.
I asked if E stein received many guests during his stay in
Palm Beac . advised he had many guests. I asked
specifically a out masseuses coming to the house. stated he
would have two massages a day. Epstein would have one massage in the
mornin and one massage in the afternoon everyday he was in residence.
stated he would be informed to expect someone and make them
com orta e until either or Epstein would meet with them.
stated once the masseuses would arrive, he would allow them
entry into the kitchen area and offer them something to drink or eat.
They would then be encountered by either or Epstein limigi mm
would be taken upstairs to provide the massage. I asked if
any of the masseuses appeared young in age. He advised hrTITTIr mask
their ages but felt they were very young. stated they ate
like his own daughter who is in high school stated they
would eat tons of cereal and drink milk all the time.
stated the girls that would come appeared to be too young to e
masseuses. He stated one time under E stein's direction, he delivered
a dozen roses to for one of the girls
that came to prove e a massage. He knew t e irls were still in high
school and were of high school age. I asked about the
massages. He felt there was a lot more going on an just massages.
He would clean Mr. Epstein's bedroom after the alleged massages and
would discover massager/vibrators and sex toys scattered on the floor.
He also said he would wipe down the vibrators and sex toys and put
them away in an armoire. He described the armoire as a small wood
armoire which was on the wall close to Epstein's bed.
Epstein ordered to go to the
car for the same gir e rought the roses to, so t
her self to Epstein's house without incident.
always needed rides to and from the house.
as a "human ATM machine" and was ordered by ps ein o maintain a
minimum balance of $2,000 dollars on him at all times. When a girl
would come by the house and Mr. E stein was either not in residence or
was not at home at the time, was to provide the girl
(masseuse) several hundred do ars or their time and to notif
Epstein the amount they were given. Epstein also ordered to
and rent a
at she could drive
said the girl
referred himself
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 72
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: O48301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
purchase several gifts and provide them as tips to the girls. I asked
what kind of gifts. stated he purchased IPODS, jewelry,
anything the girls wou want.
stated the amount of girls that came to the house was
approximately fifteen. Each of the irls knew each other and all
seemed to know at who Mr. Epstein was.
When asked to iden y ese g r s, o r guez stated he could not at
the moment but knew he wrote their names down on a journal he kept
during his employ with Mr. Epstein. He kept a journal in the event he
needed to explain either to Mr. Epstein or his assistants what was
done at the house or who visited the house as he stated he was
in-charge of Mr. Epstein's personal security while in Palm Beach. I
informed him I would need to view this journal to which he stated he
would research the book and contact me to provide the book. The
interview was concluded and left the area. I returned back to the
police station where the micro cassette was laced into evidence. At
approximately 7:20 pm, I was notified located the journal
and would call me on January 5, 2005 to prove e the journal.
Investigation Continues&&
**************************** N A R R A T I V E
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
# 34 **************************
a El
1/09/06
1/10/06
On January 5, 2006, I attempted to meet with to
recover the folder or journal in which he kep. Meno l...were
given to him during his employ with Mr. Jeffrey Epstein. He kept this
folder to justify what he did during his employ should the need arise
to justify what occurred with the monies he had to keep or any
questions as to the petty cash he withdrew from the household account
from the bank. At approximately 10:00 pm, I attempted contact with
Mr. and discovered he was assisting his wife at her lace of
employmen and would not be able to meet with me. Mr.
stated he would meet with me on January 6, 2006, in Browar ounty, in
the morning hours.
On January 6, 2006
call from Mr.
be traveling nort
am, I met with
in Boca R

• a note wit
bucket of roses to
, at approximately 9:00 am, I received a telephone
who advised he had the file in hand and would
ound to meet
to rent a car or
contract. I returne
folder into evidence.
pro•uce• a green
ein's stationa
A
and
to t e Palm
with me in Broward County. At 10:50
at the •arkin• lot of Bank of America
(known as the
o •er w ich contained documents,
with direction to deliver a
after 'I'll! (MI
so in t at same note was irection
direction to extend the rental
Beach Police Station and placed the
I received a fax from from the subpoena request sent on
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
Page:
Program:
CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
01-04-06,
registere rom e- [essEPalm Beac
chiropractor and as an o ice located
Palm Beach. The cellular number is Dr
number.
persona
On January 9, 2006, Det. and I traveled to
Palm Beach Gardens in an a emp to locate
been previously seen on the property and i enti ied t
Florida Drivers License and Florida license Plate. A
was left for her to return my call. We then traveled
and located
spea wi us and in a private room will.. sc oO
taped statement.
•
(Continued)
in West
ce ular
IMIL MoI d
roug her
business card
to the
agreed
provided us a
in
During the statement, advised that when she was fifteen or
sixteen years ofae sewas taken to Jeffrey Epstein's house by her
associate, stated this occurred late May 2004
or early J11 11104. e was to she could model lingerie for money
for a wealthy Palm Reacher. She remembered they traveled by yellow
cab from their residence in West Palm Beach to Epstein's house. She
remembered encountering Epstein at the front door during the evening
hours.
He introduced himself and brought them into the kitchen so that the
chef could prepare somethin for them to eat. After having a meal,
Wa and Epstein brought upstairs to a master bedroom which
large bathroom. She o served a large style shower, sauna and
there was a large massage bed also in the bathroom. Epstein entered a
said they would provide a massage on his feet. askedirt ihey
room within the bathroom and came out wearing onl a towel.
are doing this. told her this was part o t e routine and told
her to rub his le s an calves. Epstein had told to get
comfortable. continued rubbing Epstein's ca ves and feet. At
Epstein's direction, then left the room leaving there
by herself. Epstein to to get comfortable. removed
her blouse and pants and staye in her panties. stated she
was not wearing a bra. She believed she was wearin t ong panties.
Epstein turned over onto his back and began Epstein
Epstein instructe
Durin the first
massa e she stated E stein was
He put is an s un er t e towe an
appeare as to mastur ate himself however she never saw his penis.
She continued rubbing his chest until he grabbed her and pulled her
closer to him. He appeared to have climaxed because after he pulled
her closer to him the massage was over. Epstein had told her that
there was two hundred dollars for her on the dresser. He told her
that she could not tell an one what happened at the house or bad
things could happen. stated she went to Epstein's house three
er to
stated the on t e irst time; e
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 74
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
or four times total. was very scared and felt very nervous.
She knew because of Epstein's money he was powerful. After the
massage, Epstein ordered his houseman at the time to drive the girls
home. The employee was to drop off the girls at their house and watch
them go inside their house.
could not remember who the houseman was. She stated Epstein
an is assistant would call her at her father's house to
arrange for her to come and "work." She advised each time she returned
to the house, Epstein would do the same thing. stated it was
a routine with Epstein. She would rub his feet an ca ves. He would
then turn over and begin to
' Tiimiiii difference was that it was Epstein's
as e wou • mastur•ate and finally climax
an• t e massage wou •e over. She was paid $200.00 each time she
went. Each time she went she was reminded not to speak of what
happened at the house and that she would be contacted again. She
began to purposely miss the calls when either
call her. She once brought a friend, '
or Epstein would
unknown last n me t
work for Epstein. She was paid $200.00 for bringing aligliii stated she no longer retuned to work for Epstein. She also 
stated
that she wanted to notify the police of what happened at the house.
stated she was scared of what could have happened to her or
er amily if she notified authorities.
On January 10, 2006, I received the results from the sub oena from
BellSouth Telecommunications for tele hone number The
is assigned to Mr. father in Palm
Beac Gardens. I also receive t e resu is from which
confirmed the money order sent to from Jeffrey
Epstein in New York City. The "wire" was sent y Jeffrey Epstein of
457 Madison Ave in New York City on December 23, 2004 at 12:05 pm.
The amount of $222.00 was charged to Epstein's credit card so that
could receive $200.00 in Royal Palm Beach. The twenty-two
o ars was for processing and local fees to send the money via
A copy of the check presented to was also
attac e to t e receipt of the wire. This confirme w at
advised she received as a Christmas bonus from Epstein.
Investigation continues.
****************************NARRATIVE if 35 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
, is assigne
Epstein o 457 Madison Ave in New Yor City. is the current
houseman/house mans er for 358 El Brillo Way in Pa m Beachi El13480.
The second number, , is assigned to IIIIII of
al • 1/10/06
1/10/06
I received and reviewed the Cingular Wireless results from the
subpoena requests for subscriber information for
The first nu er,
in care of Jeffrey
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 75
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
in West Palm Beach. Research conducted on
Continued)
is a licensed Massage
active license number
assigned to
Research on Mr.
Physician.
therapist with a Florida
had beenprevious)
The last number is
of in Palm Beac Gardens.
revealed that he is a Florida Chiropractic
Vehicles that were previously documented on the property while
surveillance was being conducted were researched. I determined a
bearing Florida license IIII-IIII was seen on the
property in w ich a young white female was seen entering the Epstein
property. Research was conducted which revealed that the vehicle is
of Lake Worth. Mr. has two daughters,
is currently residing in
is rest ing with her father in Lake
revealed she was recently involved
. A request to
registered to
and
Connecticut and
Worth. Research
in a
discover any n ormation rom t = was requested.
I spoke with ASA Daliah Weiss who informed me that
will be available for an interview tomorrow at the State Attorney's
Office in West Palm Beach at 1:30 pm. I informed her that I would be
at her office for the interview.
**************************** N A R R A T I V E #36 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.: • On Januar 19 2006, Det. and I met with at
in Palm Beach Gardens. was identified as a
IIIIIII
licensed massage therapist who had previously been seen on Epstein's
property when physical surveillance was done.
on going investigation and I felt she may have in ormation pertaining
to the case. During a sworn taped statement, stated she met
Epstein three ears a o when Ghaline Maxwell approached her while she
was attending to work around Epstein's
house. Maxwel a to er t at t ey needed some irls to work at
the house to answer phones and run errands. accepted the job
and began working at Epstein's house on El Brillo in Palm Beach.
stated it was a part time job during the time she went to
She continued going to Epstein's house and
woul e note ie wen Epstein would travel to Palm Beach.
advised she would be notified by Maxwell, Epstein or ill
assistant, when he would travel to Palm Beach. stated she
began providing massages to Epstein before she became a massage
iiiii pist. She continuedgiving massages not only to Epstein but to
and his assistant. was asked about
what occurre uring the massages. stated as she was twenty
1/23/06
1/23/06
was told of the
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 76
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
three years old when she met Epstein, anything that happened was
between two consenting adults. I explained to her that she was not in
any trouble however as art of this investigation, I needed to ask
certain questions. stated that there were times that Epstein
would ask her to er orm urin the massage. He would instruct her to
stated she felt
"grosse " a out t e e avior ut as s e was getting paid, she just
massa es
continued.
nakilliiiistein would on occ
also advised she would on occasion perform the
asion, utilize the
when she performed the massages.
exp aine tat Epstein never exposed himself to her as he
maintained himself covered under the towel he would be wearing. When
Epstein would masturbate he would be covered.
I asked if ever received any gifts, or any gratuities from
Epstein. advised aside from bein aid well she advised
Epstein too care of her tuition from College.
She received a rental car for a week w en er scooter roke down.
Additionally she received other gifts from Epstein. stein also
recommended her to another client who resides at in Palm
Beach. The client she was referred to was " un nown ast name,
and his wife, who she provided a massages to. T e statement was
concluded and placed into evidence upon our return to the Palm Beach
Police Department.
While at the police station, I researched Florida tag which
was also previously seen on the property when there was physical
surveillance being done at the property. The vehicle is registered
of Lake Worth, Florida. Researchin• Mr. and the
vi le revealed that his dau.hter ha
T e ve icle is
date of
Lake Worth.
iwiiiyspace.co
photograp e
, resides at in
space page called
In her web page, shows various photos of
at a each. An interview is forthcoming.
to
A review of the video disks which was extracted at the Palm Beach
County Sheriff's Office Computer Crime Unit revealed that only one
hidden camera was functional at the time. Several images of E stein
worliiiiit his office were seen. Additional footage of
and was seen. There was other footage of females
seen. The i entity of the females is unknown at this time, until such
time as I meet with certain females to show the video footage to
confirm if in fact, it is them on the video. At this time it appears
that and are seen sitting with Epstein beside
his desk in t e evening hours. Due to poor lighting, a direct
confirmation cannot be made at this time.
Inv. Continues.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
Case No • 1-05-000368
**************************** N A R R A T
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
On January 25, 2006, Det and
in Lake Worth and met wit
year, when'she was seventeen years o
through her former room mate
Epstein at the time.
when they modeled.
an
explaine
and advised her that s e was in Palm Beach and requested to see her.
IIIII made arrangements to meet with her at Epstein's house.
arrived and met Epstein and II.. and NM went to the Pa m
Beach Mall together and went s opping. advised that IIIII and
she had received money from Epstein to go to the mall. They visited
Victoria's Secret and purchased undergarments from the store utilizing
monies given by Epstein. advised she purchased one item and
purchase various items. The money used to purchase the items
was the money given by Epstein.
explained  er For and continued shopping and having a day together.
stated  how she and Epstein have been datin ea and he as een paying all of her bills. claimed advised
they met in New York and had been dating ever since. They ater
returned to Epstein's home and encountered Epstein. He had a brief
about her modeling career. He knew of her
He requested to see her modeling
I V
Page: 77
Program: ONIS301L
(Continued)
E fi 37 **************************
1/30/06
1/30/06 • I, responded to
conversation with
modeling career from
portfolio and explained explainecdtthat he could hel her with modeling jobs.
had her book with her to show and showed the book to I'll(stein. He commented negatively about er photographs and 
portfolio.
felt uncomfortable with the comments made as she had been
working with other professional modeling companies who had offered her
work from her photographs. E stein requested to see what was
purchased at the mall. took out the undergarments which were
purchased. She immediate y showed Eiiiiin different siiiiiurchased.
Epstein then requested to view what purchased. was
reluctant to show the outfit however since it was Epstein's money that
purchased the item she pulled it out of the bag. Epstein asked her
to try it on. looked at who told her "yeah, try it on."
Feeling compellel mT! try the un ergarment outfit on; she went to
another room and put on the bra and panty set. She walked out to the
living room where they were sitting, and modeled the suit. She then
went back into the other room and chaniiiiiack into her clothes.
returned into the room and told she would be going home.
scheduled another day for to return for massages with her.
stated ast
a e, s e met Jeffrey Epstein
was allegedly dating
ad once cohabitated together
called her on her telephone
a.n.. stated within that same week, she returned to meet with
ave a massage. had told her that she would be
iiiiiwith her as she wou be going on a bike ride with Epstein.
explained she could stay at the house and take advantage of the
massage.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report
Case No • 1-05-000368
Page:
Program:
CMS301L
(Continued)
!!!!!stated she met with an unknown massa e therapist and had the
already set up in a guest room. removed her clothing,
leaving herpanties on, and wrapped herse with a towel for the
massage. remembered that the door to the guest room was closed
but not loc e'Pill. As the therapist was working her back, the door was
opened by Epstein and entered into the room. was trying to
conceal herself as Epstein was talking to her a out his chiropractic
session. Epstein told turn over onto her back.
eventually turned over exposing her breasts to Epstein as he applied
pressure on her shoulder and her waist. stated Epstein "popped"
removed her self from the to le, got dressed and left
further stated had attempted to call her on
several occas ons to invite her bac o Epstein's house to which
replied "I'm busy." advised she has not had contact with eit er
or Jeffrey pstein. It should be noted that her mother,
was present during the interview. The interview was
concluded and we thanked them her for their time.
her back.
the house.
****************************NARRATIVE 38 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.: A.
1/31/06
1/31/06
On January 27 2006 I made telephone contact with
at . is a licensed massage therapist w o is
frequen e e ome o effrey Epstein. Ms. III. has been unable to
meet with me in Palm Beach County, and because s e lives and works in
Port St Lucie, a telephone interview was conducted. I explained to
Ms. that there was an on going investigation involving Jeffrey
Epstein.
stated she knows Epstein and has been e •lo ed by him for
approximately three years. Epstein has paid to •erform Swedish
Massages (Deep Tissue) on him and other guests. explained that
approximately three year ago she met Ghislaine Maxwe and Jeffrey
Epstein through a mutual friend. Epstein and Maxwell were looking for
a massage therapist. stated since that time, she is notified
when Epstein is coming to alm Beach. stated she comes to his
house and provides the massage or massages explained she has
also massaged his guests and assistants. continued that she is
paid $100.00 and hour for the massage.
made heiliM iuncomfortable. stated she only provided massages
I asked if anything occurred during the massage that would have
and that was it. She never was approached for anything else. I asked
if Epstein ever asked her to rub his chest she stated she would not
rub his chest as that is not part of her massage. explained
that she was not Epstein's type. The girls she wou see at Epstein's
house were very thin, beautiful and without tattoos. explained
she has several tattoos that are visible. Maxwell an Epstein have
commented negatively about her tattoos previously when she has
provided massages.
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 79
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
stated she only provided massages for Epstein and his
associates and nothing happened during those massages. stated
as she does Swedish style massages, the patient is usual sore after
the massages. I thanked her for her assistance and the interview was
concluded at this time.
I received a facsimile from service on telephone
number , which is assignee , pilot for Mr.
Epstein, w o rest es in Lake Worth. to ep one number was
dialed on several occasions by A background on
indicated he has a valid FAA pitq l!icense First Class for the
Southern FAA Region. has another historical FAA license for
Airline Transport Pilot.
Investigation Continues.
****************************NARRATIVE # 39 **************************
NA Reported By: 2/14/06
Entered By.: 2/16/06
On Friday, February 3, 2006, I had made arrangements to meet with
at the Palm Beach Police Station. At approximately
arrived at the police
, she stated she met
and was brought to
advised this occurred on
informed her if she wanted
reed and was brought to
stated she had been to
1:00pm, and her friend,
station. During an interview wit
Epstein when she turned eighteen years
Epstein's house to provide a massa•e.
May of 2005. She advised
to provide a massage for $200.00.
Epstein's house to provide a massage.
the house on many occasions during the massage sessions.
also stated she would remove her clothing to provide the massage on
Epstein. advised Epstein would pay her $300.00 to rub his
back, legs an c est. During the massages, Epstein would masturbate
himself as she rubbed his chest. I asked her if Epstein ever
during the massages. replied. "Yes." I as  her
1 Epstein ever stated he
massage
She state t is occurre one time on y. state t e massage
would be over when Epstein would climax onto a towel. I asked
if she had an formal massage training to which she replied
that she did not.
to the house to "wor ."
house. She advised she receive• money for bringing people to the
house to "work." stated - she brought a girl named " and
her friend was still waitin for
lobby of the police station. I thanked forher time and her
in e
cooperation and escorted her to the lobby.
was then asked if she ever brought anyone
stated she brought two people to the
I asked Ms if I could speak with her about this investigation. I
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 80
Incident Report Program: ams3olLTime: 8:47:53
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
brought her to the interview room and explained to her that I was
conducting an investigation on Jeffrey Epstein and felt she may have
information ertainiii iio the investigation. Ms identified
and resides in Wellington, Florida. She herself as
advised approxima ely a year iiiiihe was brought to Epstein's house to
provide a massage for money. stated she needed to make money and
felt it was a quick way to make some money. stated she was
brought to the house by and was intr uced to Epstein and his
assistant. She was broug t to is main bathroom and provided a
massage. I asked her if she provided the massage naked. stated
She rubbed Epstein's legs, back and chest. I as a if
ein touched her during the massage. She advised he did not,
however he did masturbate himself as she rubbed his chest. Once he
climaxed the massage was over. She was paid her money and left the
area. advised it occurred one time and she never returned to
Epstein's ouse. The interview was concluded and was escorted to
the lobby.
with Ms.
and attempted to
contact her on several occasions. I ca e and spoke
I located a telephone number for
who advised she would speak wit me in Deerfield Beach
where she resides. Due to a scheduling conflict, we were unable to
meet. I informed her I would contact her to schedule another
appointment to speak with her about this investigation. I have
attempted to meet with her and make telephone contact with negative
results.
On February 13, 2006 I met with at
in Lake Worth. was identi ie as Epstein's pi ot. I spoke
with who a vised he has been employed with Epstein since 1991.
He ies oth planes for Epstein depending where he wants to fl to.
was asked about passengers in the plane he flies.
state unless Epstein flew to his island off of St Thomas, t ere would
be no way of knowing who the passengers were. I mentioned a recent
fli ht to Ohio, where flew to Ohio to pick up
remes er
stated he recce e flying on several occasions an i III, stated once he is in the cockpit, he does not
know who e passengers are. When he prepares the passenger
manifests he lists stein and his assistants he knows by name,
and stated he would list either female or male
passen ers on t e manifests only to keep a count on the passengers.
Mrs. came into the living room and recommended that her
husban consult with an attorney. Mr. agreed he would speak
with the family attorne to inform him o t is questioning. I
explained to Mr. that he was not the suspect in this
Ai,
investigation an cease all questions. Based on the fact
could not advise who passengers were in the plane, I then
area.
I attempted to locate at in
Wellington. I left mylillikiss card for er to return my call. On
February 14, 2006, at 12:06 pm, I received a call back from Ms.
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 8:47:53
Page: 81
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
on my voice mail. Ms Fp left her telephone number for a return
call . I etheramessage to return call.
Investigation Continues..
**************************** NARRATIVE
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
#40 **************************
2/21/06
2/22/06
On February 15, 2006, I made telephone contact with who
provided directions to where I could locate her. Det an I
res onded to in Lake Park to meet wit
Upon my arriva , I met with lip in the parking fo t irectly
e in MAACO Auto Painting. She was advised I was there to speak with
her about an ongoing investigation that concerned Jeffrey Epstein in
Palm Beach. stated she knows Epstein very well and did not want
to speak with me about Mr. Epstein. She was very fond of Epstein and
did not want to speak with me about anything concerning Jeffrey
Epstein. I explained to her that she was seen at the house and I
would like to speak with her. She stated she knew there was an
investigation and that I had spoken with other eo le and therefore I
should know what happened at Epstein's house. ended the
conversation and walked back into her boyfriends usiness,
Det and I left the area and returned 1 111111
po Ice station.
Investigation continues.
****************************NARRATIVE # 41 **************************
al In
4/10/06
4/10/06
A Grand Jury Session was requested during the month of February 2006,
in which all the girls that had been interviewed would have been
called to testify before the Grand Jury to seek an indictment against
Jeffrey Epstein. Due to subsequent meetings with the State Attorney's
Office and Defense Attorney Alan Dershowitz the Grand Jury was
postponed until a later time. Dershowitz had provided a package of
material on the main victims in this case in which they appear on
myspace.com and speak about alcohol use and some marijuana use. The
State Attorney's Office wanted time to review the material.
I requested additional subpoenas from the State Attorney's Office in
which I requested information from Dollar Rent a Car and Jet Aviation.
The information re ested from Dollar Rent a Car was for the rented
vehicle by while under the employ of Epstein for one
of the victims. The of er subpoena requested was for Jet Aviation for
dates and times when Epstein's planes were in Palm Beach County.
I continued to research other names that were acquired either from
interviews or intelligence gathered during the investigation. I
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 82
Program: CMS301L
Case No  • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
located in Royal Palm Beach. I responded to
in Roya Pa m Beach'. During the interview
state she knew I would be speaking with her, state she
was first introduced to Epstein when she turn eig teen years old.
stated she was sure of her age as it was her senior year in.
She advised she was brought there to
ma e money an was o s e would have to provide a massage to this
Palm Beach guy. She remembered she met Epstein and his assistant
in the kitchen area. She stated she was taken b one of her
got readylill ithe massage. He exited his bathroom naked and
while E stein riends, She stated she went upstairs with
turned around. Epstein asked her if being naked offended her.
stated it made her uncomfortable. Epstein then put on a
towe an lay on the table. stated she rubbed his back and
feet. She stated she had no massage raining or experience.
Radabau h stated during the massage, Epstein attem ted to
pulled away as he e told
im again s e was uncomfortable with him Eps tin then
cut the massage short and became upset wit er. Epstein aid her
$200.00 for the massage and told her to leave the house.
never returned to the house. She did advise of one time s e went with
however she waited in the car for as she did not
want to go into the house. At the conclusion of visit with
Epstein they left the area. stated she a eard from other
girls that have gone to the house t at Epstein now required them to do
the massage naked and allow him to touch them in their private areas
for monies. The interview was concluded as did not have any
other information to provide.
I then learned from the original victim, III the defense attorney had
learned of her identity. I spoke with the ather of the victim, who
stated there has been a private investigator on his house
photographing his family and chasiii visitors who come to the house.
He provided a Florida License of This vehicle is registered
to Ivan Robles of West Palm Beach. APIs is a private investigator
intern who is licensed by the state. I informed the State Attorney's
Office of the above information.
I received the Grand Jury subpoenas
for a Grand Jury session to be held on Apri 18, t roug Apri 20,
2006.
Investigation continues.
****************************NARRATIvE # 42 **************************
NA 4/14/06Reported By: ,
Entered By.: II 4/18/06
The Grand Jury Subpoenas were personally served to the individuals
they were issued to. On A ril 5, 2006, at approximately 7:30 p.m., I
personally served who had informed me that the
private investigators were s i Illotographing the family. On April
Date: 7/25/06
Time: 8:47:53
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 83
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
10, 2006, at approximately 2:30 p.m., I served II at her residence in
Royal Palm Beach. The subpoena was given to her mother, III
I learned through one of the victims III that she was personally
contacted through a source that has maintained contact with Epstein.
The source assured she would receive monetary compensation for her
assistance in not cooperating with law enforcement.
and
also stated
she was told, "Those who help him will be compensate and those who
hurt him will be dealt with." I told III that tampering with a
witness/victim is an arrestable offense and very serious. I asked her
who approached her during this encounter. II originally was reluctant
to provide the name of the person who approached her to offer her not
to testify because she felt they were still friends.
On April 11, 2006, Det and I traveled to
and met with the victim, III identified
, as the person w o approached her in Ro
s e was ome during Spring Break in March 2006.
did not want to pursue the intimidation charges on
concerned that the defense attorney was given a copes the report as
certain things she had told me in confidence were repeated to her by
Prior to our departure, was given a copy of her
subpoena for the Grand Jury whit was sc eduled to commence April 18,
2006.
Tallahassee, Florida
W/F,
as Pa m Beach while
also stated she
was
Upon our return from Tallahassee, I notified the State Attorney's
Office of what was told to me. I also notified them that the
subpoenas were delivered and they would be calling
for arrangements for the ate and time needed for the Grand Jury. I
spoke with ASA Weiss and informed her of the possible intimidation by
the defense.
On April 13, and April 14, 2006 I attempted contact on several
occasions with ASA Weiss and ASA Belohlavic to ascertain when the
victims needed to report for Grand Jury testimony. Messages were left
on their voicemail. On April 17, 2006, during the hours of 9:00 am
and 11:30 am, I again left messages for ASA Weiss and ASA Belohlavic
for either of them to return my call as I had not heard from the State
Attorney's Office as to the time and date of the Grand Jury.
At approximately 12:30 pm, I went to the State Attorney's Office and
located ASA Weiss and ASA Belohlavic in their offices. I entered ASA
Belohlavic's office who informed me that she was going to return my
call. She explained that an offer was made to the defense, Atty Guy
Fronstin and Atty Alan Dershowitz. The offer is
When asked about
that was the
cell phone rang and went to voice
and played the message on speaker
Belohlavic stated
. ASA Belohlavic
mai S e chec ed her voice mail
. The caller identified himself as
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 84
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
. Belohlavic stated a probable
cause wou e nee e o oo ps ein in the count 'ail and would let
me know as to when it would be needed.
S e exp acne• to ave C se
Rester ca tarry Kris er a•out e deal. I left the area and
returned to the police station where I briefed the Chief about the
deal offered.
I checked my voice mail messages and discovered. a message from III
stepmother for the victim She was calling because the State
Attorney's Office still ha not returned any of her calls as to when
they are needed for this case. I then called ASA Belohlavic's office
and left messages for her to call the victims on this case and
explained to them what the State Attorney's Office had done.
On April 17, 2006, at approximately 4:30 pm, State Attorney
Investigator Tim Valentine called to officially notify me of the
cancellation of the Grand Jury. He requested I contact the victims
that had been served to appear, to notify them of the cancellation. I
advised valentine that as this Grand Jury session was called based on
the State Attorney's Office decision to have the victims heard by the
Grand Jury that I felt it was the States Attorney's Office
responsibility to contact the victims and advise them of the reason
they were no longer needed.
****************************NARRATIVE # 43 **************************
NA Reported By: 5/04/06
Entered By.: 5/04/06
As I had not received any contact from anyone at the State Attorney's
Office, on May 1, 2006, I prepared three arrest warrant requests and
submitted them to the State Attorney's Office. The packages were
delivered to the Crimes against Children Unit in care of ASA Lana
Belohlavek. Jeffrey Epstein's arrest warrant was requested for 4
counts of Unlawful Sexual activity with certain minors and one count
of Lewd and Lascivious Molestation. Epstein's
assistant's, arrest warrant request was or 4 counts of Principal in
the 1st degree Unlawful Sexual activity with certain minors and one
count of Principal in the 1st degree Lewd and Lascivious Molestation.
s arrest warrant request was for Lewd and Lascivious
Acts on a victim under 16 years of age. The receipt of delivery was
signed and brought back to the records division at the police
department.
On May 3, 2006, at approximately 2:54 pm, I received a telephone call
from ASA Daliah Weiss on my cellular telephone. ASA Weiss advised she
•1
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 85
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
has been taken off the Jeffrey Epstein case because her husband is
employed with Attorney Jack Goldberger. Attorney Goldberger is the
attorney of record for Jeffrey Epstein. His previous attorney, Guy
Fronstin, has been fired from representation. ASA Lana Belohlavek has
been assigned the case. ASA Weiss stated she can no longer speak
about the Epstein case with me. I thanked her for her telephone call.
ASA Weiss further stated that ASA Belohlavek would be calling me.
****************************NARRATIvE # 44 **************************
NA Reported By:
Entered By.:
5/15/06
5/15/06
On May 10, 2006, information was received that Epstein's associate,
Leslie Wexner, The Limited Inc, CEO's, plane had arrived in West Palm
Beach, PBIA. The plane, a Gulfstream 4 bearing a registration,
was on the tarmac at Galaxy Aviation. As Epstein had recently
acquired the services of a new attorney, and the fact that Epstein's
house is currently under remodeling, it was believed that Epstein may
be in Palm Beach. I conducted physical surveillance at the residence,
358 El Brillo Way. I observed a large construction crew conducting
remodeling at the house. The contractor, David Norr, was observed
driving a Ford E lorer, white in color. The vehicle has a Florida
registration of
on County Road. Det
Norr left Epstein's house and traveled north
and I conducted surveillance on Norr.
Norr traveled to several construction sites and checked on certain
jobs. Surveillance was discontinued on Norr and Det and I
traveled to Galaxy Aviation. I observed the white plane with a blue
stripe along the body and tail of the plane; the tail number was
visible on the bottom of the tail, closer to the body of the plane.
We maintained visual surveillance on the plane until 4:57 p.m. , when a
caravan of Cadillac Escalades drove onto the tarmac. We observed
several people exit the vehicles and discovered that they were part of
the executive team for Limited Inc.' The executives were in Palm Beach
County for an executive meeting for the day. They arrived in Palm
Beach County on May 9, 2006 at 9:30 pm and were scheduled to leave on
the 10th at 5:00 pm.
On May 12, 2006, I met with ASA Lana Belohlavek at the State
Attorney's Office. She explained that her boss, Barry Krischer, was
requesting this case be taken to the Grand Jury again. I ex lained to
her I had re ested arrest warrants for Jeffrey Epstein,
and . I asked that she either issue the warrants or
direct file, as so much time has elapsed since the original request to
the Grand Jury. I explained that the Palm Beach Police Department had
concluded the case in December of 2005 and has been waitin for the
case to o forward. Belohlavek stated the
S e state she wou a vise me of the answer.
****************************NARRATIVE # 45 **************************
NA Reported By: 6/05/06
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 86
Time: 8:47:53 • Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
Entered By.:
(Continued)
6/06/06
On May 22 2006, I received several phone calls throughout the day
from Mr. II who stated he had been followed aggressively by a private
investigator. Mr. I stated that as he drove to and from work and
running errands throughout the county, the same vehicle was behind him
runnin other vehicles off the road in an attempt not to lose sight of

Mr. vehicle.
I explained to him as Mr. Epstein had retained new legal council it
was possible it would be new private investigators following him to
observe his daily activities. I also explained to him that there was
a meeting scheduled with ASA Lana Belohlavek and Attorney Jack
Goldberger at Mr. Krischer's office scheduled on June 1, 2006 at 9:00

am. I attempted to call ASA Lana Belohlavek to inform her of the
private investigators following Mr. however; she was on her vacation
during the week of May 22 through May 30 2006.
On May 23, 2006, I received other phone calls from Mr. and Mrs. who
advised they were able to acquire the private investigators license
plate information. The subject following them was again driving very
aggressively and caused Mrs. to run off the road. Mrs.. stated
.
the vehicle is a green Chevy Monte Carlo bearing Florida tag
The vehicle is registered to Zachary Bechard of Jupiter Flori
Bechard is employed with Candor Investigations from Jupiter, Florida.
Bechard is a licensed Private Investigator in the State of Florida.
Since the discovery of the threat made against one of the victims in
this case ( I re ested subpoenas for all calls made to and
received from during the month of March 2006 for her
cell •hone and home phone. I had confirmed with
the exact dates of Sarin• Break for 2006. The Spr ng Break
was from I received a subpoena
from wit a ca s ma .e ulifthe month of March 2006.
I reviewed t e 989 calls made and received during the month of March
2006. I observed on March 7, 2006, made and received thirty
five calls during that day.
Date
7-Mar-06
Time
11:03 AM
Seconds
In/Out
Outbound
To/From
561XXXX
7-Mar-06 11:16 AM 6 Inbound 561XXXX
7-Mar -06 11:22 AM 887.2 Inbound 561XXXX
7-Mar-06 11:37 AM 48 Outbound
7-Mar-06 11:39 AM 28.2 Inbound
7-Mar-06 12:02 PM 727.2 Inbound
The table reflects the date of the calls, time of day (EST) , duration
Date: 7/25/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 87
Time: 8:47:53 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No - 1-05-000368 (Continued)
of call in seconds, inbound or outbound calls and calls made to or
from IIIIIII phone. On March 7, 2006, at 11:03 am, made a call
to the victim III which lasted 492 seconds (8 minutesIIIII2 seconds).
The victim then returned the call at 11:16 am which lasted 6 seconds.
The victim then made contact with at 11:22 am for 877.2 seconds
(14 minutes and 6 seconds) . These sequences of calls were consistent
with what the victim had described to me on the date of the
intimidation. Immediately after speaking with the victim, makes
a call to Epstein's assistant, which lasts for
forty-eight secotr ill call is then immediately received, a telephone
number registered to a Corporation affiliated with Jeffrey Epstein
located at 457 Madison Ave in New York. An extensive computer check
revealed 457 Madison Ave is a business address in which Epstein has
his cor orations assigned to. Epstein had corporation attorney,
register the businesses and register himself as an
agent. I a so observed Epstein has his El Zorro Ranch Corporation,
New York Strategy Group, Ghislaine Corporation, J Epstein and Company
and the Financial Strategy Group registered to this same address.
Finally, a third call is received by at 12:02 pm from the same
corporate number which lasts 12 minutes and 1 second. It should be
noted that there is no further contact with either the victim during
the month of March or A ril of 2006. I also noted that there was no
further contact with or Jeffrey Epstein during the
remainder of the mont o Marc or April 2006.
On June 1, 2006, ASA Lana Belohlavek telephoned me to inform me of the
meeting that occurred with Atty. Jack Goldberger and her reference
this case. She advised she would make her determination on whether to
file on this case or not by Monday June 5, 2006.
Inv Continues.
****************************NARRATIVE # 46 **************************
NA
* *
Reported By: Ewa  7/12/06
Entered By.: 7/12/06
On June 29, 2006, I had spoken to ASA Lana Belohlavic who informed me
that the case would be sent to the Grand Jury for charges. She
informed me that the grand jury would convene on July 19, 2006 to hear
the Epstein case. Belohlavic stated State Attorney Barry Krisher made
the determination to go the Grand Jury to hear the case.
On July 12, 2006, I spoke with Mrs.. mother of the victim, III who
inquired about the status of the case. I explained to her that I was
told we would be going to the Grand Jury during the week of July 19,
2006. She stated she had not been contacted as of yet by the State
Attorney's Office for any information. I provided her with the
telephone numbers to the State Attorney's Office.
Investigation continues...
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * END OF REPORT * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Date:( 8107/0•6
Time 9:25:15
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 1
Program: CMS301L
Case Number . :
SPECIALINOTES :
Occur From Date:
Report Date . :
Common/Location:
City
Location Type :
Beat Assignment:
Dept/Class . . :
Case Status . :
Supervisory Dt.:
Names'
Vehicles? .
Narrative? .
Interfaces?
************** S
Case Number . :
Street Number :
City
Birth Date . . :
Employer? . . :
Oper Lic No. . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Sex  •
Minimum Weight :
Maximum Weight :
Aliases'
Hair Color . : SALT & PEPPER
Hair Style .
Glasses . . . : No
Facial Hair
Teeth
Hat
Shirt
Shoes
Body Marks #2 :
Body Marks #4 :
Arrest Case No.:
1-06-001078
DO NOT RELEASE
3/01/04 0000
7/28/06 1200
M BEACH, FL
GOVERNMENT/PUBLIC BUILDING
DETECTIVE BUREAU Map Reference
POLICE INFORMATION Report Officer
OPEN ACTIVE Case Status Dt
7/28/06 Entry Date . .
Property? . .
Offenses? . .
Related Cases? :
JUVENILES
Occur To Date : 5/31/05 0000
Day Of Week . : Monday
8/04/06
USPECT/ARRESTEE INFORMATION- #1 **
1-06-001078 Prompt valid in: EPSTEIN, JEFFREY
358 EL BRILLO WY
PALM BEACH, FL 000033480
1/20/1953 51 Maximum Age .
Occupation .
FL Home Phone No.
Race
Minimum Height
Maximum Height
Misc. ID# . .
MO/Crime Spec?
Hair Length' .
Eye Color . .
Complexion .
Build
Speech
Coat
Pants
Body Marks #1 :
Body Marks #3 :
Status
Additional UCR?:
Male
***********4** V I C
Case Number . :
Street Number :
City  •
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex  •
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . :
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
T I'M I N
1-06-001078
ROYAL PALM BEACH,
WAITRE
Female
: 51
: FINANCIAL ADVISOR
White
: 600
: 0
: BLUE
: LIGHT

• MEDIUM
STILL SUSPECT
FORMATION -# 1 ********************
Prompt valid in:
FL 33411
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
•
•
•
FL
Date: 8/07/06
Time: 9:25:15 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 2
Program: CMS301L
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name : .
1-06-001078 (Continued)
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
***EMPLOYER INFORMATION***
Case Number . : 1-06-001078
Address . . . :
City/State/Zip : WELLINGTON, FL 000033480
Phone Number . :. 561/000-0000
************** VICTIM
Case Number . : 1-06-001078
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex  •
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . :
Residency Sts
Can Identify .
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
**************
INFORMATION
Employer Name :
- # 2 *****+**************
Prompt valid in:
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33413
Female
VICTIM
Case Number . : 1-06-001078
City  • NIKIBECIBOY i,
Street Number :
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex   Female
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type .
Residency Sts
Can Identify .
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
************** VICTIM
Case Number . : 1-06-001078
Street Number :
City  - LAKE WORTH, FL 33463
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . .
Employer? . . :
Oper Lic No. :
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
INFORMATION
Prompt valid
FL 33436
FL

•   te
- # 3 ********************
in:
Employer? . . :
Oper Lic No.
Race   White
Height
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
FL
INFORMATION -# 4********************
Prompt valid in:
Employer? . .
Oper Lic No. . FL
Date: 8/07/06
Time: 9:25:15
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 3
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Home Phone No. :
Sex  •
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type .
Residency Sts
Can Identify .
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
Fema
****************************
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
NARRATIVE
Original Report LO Reported By:
Entered By.:
1-06-001078
White
•
(Continued)
# 1 ***************************
IIIIII!il l
7/28/O6
8/04/O6
On July 27, 2006, the Palm Beach Police Department received a phone
call from a woman said she read a recent newspaper
article about the arrest o Jef rey Epstein and advised she has
information about Epstein. An attempt was made to Interview
immediately but she advised she had to work and would not be available
to meet on this date. said she could meet with Detectives on
July 28, 2006, at 12 Noon.
On July 28, 2006, at approximately 1200 HRS, II DOB
, came to the Palm Beach Police Station. I verifie
identification by her Florida driver's license. said s e read an
article in the Palm Beach Post newspaper on July 25, 2006, which
advised Jeffrey Epstein was arrested. said the article advised a
lie detector test was passed by Epstein w ich stated Epstein did not
know the girls in question where under the age of 18. she was a
victim of Epstein and she advised she told him on numerous occasions
she was only 17 years of age. I took a sworn taped statement from
said she had approximately ten contacts with Epstein between the
m i in.
2004, she was han
e in contact w
ging out
th Epste
with !tend named
saillile nig Pebruar of
months of February 2004 and May 2005. explained how she first
ca
said told her she could make some monr , r!!ssaging a man
that ive in Palm Beach. said the next morning, she received a
hone call from asking if she wanted to go to see this man.
said she deci e to go with to Palm Beach. IIII said
told her she would have to massage this man and possibly take
her clothes off. told she would receive approximately
$200 for this massage.
said she drove to Palm Beach. II!. said she took the
Southern Blvd. Bridge into Palm Beach and then rove North on the road
next to the beach (A1A) . said she turned onto El Brillo and
drove to the last house on the left. described the house as
being white in color. She parked the car in home's driveway and
Date: 8/07/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 4
Time: 9:25:15 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
1-06-001078 (Continued)
noticed two black Suburban SUVs. She advised there were two black
Mercedes Benz vehicles in the garage along with a Harley Davidson
motorcycle. said they walked through a gate to the back door
where they were reeted by a
Illiof uniform. said the woman to
advised to to e
asillin in her
sal a
do.
then entered the kitchen.
and approximate y
e bathroom and show
woman who was wearing some type
d them to wait in the kitchen for
described
up to t what to
!Iksaid once in the upstairs bathroom, she noticed a massage table
e middle of the room. saw a green and pink couch in the
room. saw numerous towe s stacked in the left corner of the
room. said Epstein entered the room wearing a robe. said
the man introduced himself as Jeffrey and shook her hand. Epstein
also said hello to IIII said Epstein dropped his robe and
was wearing a towel around his waist. Epstein laid face down on the
table at which time she and
while they were massaging Epstein, through conversation, sheltirised
began to massage him. said
Epstein she was 17 years of age and still in High School. said
after approximate) 10-15 minutes, E stein asked the girls to
their tops off. said she and took their tops of
exposing their bras. III said secondslater Epstein asked them to
take their bras off, w is both did,
said after more massage, Epstein as e
present with Epstein.
s off, which she did.
room, leaving only
her to take her pax
nude at this time. said Epstein got up rom the table and sat on
the aforementioned couc . said Epstein sat on the towel and
masturbated in front of her. said Epstein's penis was fully
bathroom. said the ue/gray vibrator was skinny at the handle
exposed. stein told to get a vibrator out of a drawer in the
but had a large ball at the to said the vibrator was more of a
sex toy than a massage item. said Epstein
but she told him she did not want im to tout er.
sal Epstein asked her to talk dirty to him. said once
Epstein climaxed, he told her the money was next to  sink, and then
he jumped into the shower. said she put her clothes on and both
her and left the house. said she thinks
received 200.
to eave t e
said Epstein asked
said she was totally
said she went to
two other occasions. said eventual) , Epstein's assistant
iiiiein's house with on either one or
would call her to make appointments. said would call. '
from different phone numbers but most o the time it was from
showed me her cell hone which had this number in
ericaaddress oo under the name of said after her first
visit, Epstein started to
stein would also
and
said in Marc of 2004 she believes on er i t visit to
Epstein's home, Epstein
Date: 8/07/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 5
Time: 9:25:15 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
1-06-001078 (Continued)
said Epstein did this for approximately one minute until she told
said Epstein did stop and no more took
place. IIII sal Epstein would ask her on occasion i s e wou have
intercourse with him but she always denied his requests. 'II! said
Epstein offered her more money for sex but she repeatedly ec ined.
said Epstein told her she should be a.model and he would help her
ecome a model. IIII said Epstein told her he could not wait until
she turned 18 years of age so he could fly her to Paris, France. IIII
said she last had contact with Epstein or his assistant was in
May of 2005.
lille two friends,
said
II DOB II. and
DOB
said she told two friends about what she did at Epstein's home.
, both agreed to meet wit Epstein an provide massages.
sal s e told both girls that they would have to massage this
man and possibly get undressed. told both irls they would
receive approximately $200 fcr these massages. said she is
unaware how many times or went to Epstein's house.
advised she did not to or she was
reporting these actions to the po ice.
had in her possession two tubes
sal came from Epstein's home. IIII
she got these lotions from Epstein's
posses them. I completed a property
placed the lotions into evidence.
of Bath and Body Works lotion she
said she did not remember when
home but she no longer wanted to
receipt which signed and
ll
signed an affidavit stating she wished to prosecute Epstein based
on is actions. reiterated she told Epstein on numerous
occasions she was on y 17 years of age when the above took place.
This affidavit was placed into the attachment file.
This video tape of the interview was placed into evidence.
*.***************************NARRATIvE 2***************************
NA Reported By: 8/04/06
Entered By.: 8/04/06
On July 31MOL L_at222Eacimately 1115
met with 'MI IIIIIII II DOB
was either 16 or 17 years of age.
advised she did meet a man named
Jeffrey
for this man.
HRS, Detective and I
at her home.
in 2004 when she e ieves she
said she provided a massage
said sometime in 2004, her friend told her she
could make $300 for giving a man a massage. said
approximately two weeks later she decided to go with to this
man's house. said
Palm Beach area. sal she did not know the exact location of
drove her to a large in the West
the house but believes the house was near water. said it was
Date: 8/07/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:25:15
Page: 6
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
1-06-001078 (Continued)
approximately 8:30 PM when they arrived. said both she and
drank beer and used Xanax before they arrived at this house.
said she was under the influence of the beer and Xanax.
said upon arrival, they met with a woman who was in her
described this woman as being t e manager of the girls
t at visit this  house. said they went into the kitchen and
woman and also sculptursaid she saw numerous photos of r
then she and were le to a massage room in the house. i l
naked woman throughout the house.
named Jeffrey entered the room wearing a robe. said Jeffrey
removed his robe and lay down on the massage tab e. said she
and massaged Jeffrey for approximately 20 minutes. said
she massaged Jeffrey's legs using some type of lotion. said
Jeffrey asked to leave the room. said Jeffrey as ed her
to take her shir off. said she removed her shirt exposing
her bra. said e rey asked her to remove her other clothes
but she re use is request. said she was wearing a short
skirt and underwear along with a ra. said Jeffrey began to
masturbate in full view of her. sai s e did see Jeffre 's
enis. said Jeffre
said moments later, a man
e e uncom or a• e and
as e Je frey to stop, w is he •i• said once Jeffre was
done masturbating, she went downstairs an• met with
said they both received $200 but she could not remeilll itho gave them
the money.
I showed a photo lineup containing Jeffrey Epstein.
positively i entified Epstein as the man in picture three.
said Jeffrey did not ask her how old she was. said
s e could not remember if she mentioned she was in HighSchool.
said she knew of other girls who went to Jeffre 's house.
sup lied those names, and a
gir named
signed an affidavit stating she wishes to prosecute based On
Epstein's activities.
truth.
swore that her above statement was the
This interview was digitally recorded and.this recording along with
the photo lineup were placed into evidence.
On July 31 2006 .a raximately 1230
met with DOB
advised slralTernow a man named Je re
she mete.. when she was in
believes she was eit er
HRS, Detective
at her home.
Epstein.
, which was in
1 or 17 years of
said a fellow student at
advised her she could make $200 for massaging a man.
and I
vised
e year
age.
said
Date:
Time:
8/07/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 7
9:25:15 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
sa
r ng a friend.
and advised her s
said drove them to Epstein's house.
meet with Epstein and they both received $200.
had no more contact with Epstein or Epstein's assis an
i irls were
advised she knew
ll!!!!!
and
many girls to Epstein's
interview.
she
1-06-001078 (continued)
could not remember the girls name but it started with a "III
said this girl " was in a lower grade then she was.
said this girl " icked her up in a cab and the cab took
t em to Palm Beach. said the cab had to o over a bridge and
she thought the name o e street was said once
at the house, they waited in the kitchen. sal she saw
numerous attractive females walking around t e ouse. said
one of the females, a who was a roximately ll years o age,
appeared to work for Eps eln. said " took her upstairs and
told her to get into her bra an panties. said she removed
her ants and shirt and was only wearing her ra and panties.
said she saw a massage table in the bathroom a couch in the
room, a shower off to the side, and lotions. said Epstein
entered the room wearing sleeping pants. said Epstein got on
the table and she began giving him a massage. said left
the room. said Epstein asked her how o s e was an she
said she was f or 17.
she was when'this occurre .
High School. said
clothes and she re used.
started to masturbate in fu v
said she saw his penis
ac on and went downstairs and
said she received $200 for that
could not remember exactly how old
said she told him she was in
stein asked her to take off all of her
said Epstein rolled to his side,
ew of her and ejaculated in his hand.
said she put her clothes
eventua y left  in a cab.
visit.
said a roximately two months later, she received a phone
woman at the house who asked her if she needed a
she did not want to see Epstein again but was told
said she contacted her friend
e could make $200 for massa ing a man.
said
said shell.
of other irls that went to
,
Epsteine.
said t e gar s e ows as " b
ouse besides those mentioned in this
said during the course of her conversation with Epstein, he
tol her she was beautiful and that he wanted her to live with him in
Los Angeles
I showed a photo lineup containing Epstein.
positively identified Epstein from photo three.
signed an affidavit stating she wishes to prosecute based on
Epstein's activities.
truth.
swore that her above statement was the
This interview was digitally recorded and this recording and the photo
Date: 8/07/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 8
Time: 9:25:15 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
lineup were placed into evidence.
On July 31, 2006, at a proximatel
met with DOB
advised s e i ave contact wi
in High School.
an s e elieves she was 16 years
1-06-001078 (Continued)
1400 HRS, Detective
at the Boynton Beach Ma
Jeffrey Epstein when she was a
said it was either in 2003 or 2004
of age when they met.
and I
Illilliend said advised her she could make
advised back in 2003 she was introduced to Jeffrey Epstein by
$200 for giving this man a massage. said told her she
drove her to a big house in the Town of Palm Beac AM not
might have to get undressed during t e massage. said
ive an exact address or location but said it was near t e beach.
said once at the home, a thin white female with hair,
approximately II ears of a e answered the door. t inks the
woman's name was said she and entere the kitchen
and then went ups airs to a at room. said there was a massage
table in the middle of the bathroom. said Epstein entered the
bathroom wearing a towel around his waist. said E stein took a
shower and then lay down on the table fully nu e. said she and
R to go on the balcon which did. Epstein asked I ll
started to massage Epstein's legs and chest. said iiiiiin
to taeher clothes off. said s e took all her clothes Tillimrld
she was nude. said s e continued to massage E stein at which
time Epstein began to masturbate in her full view. said she
did see Epstein's enis. said while he mastur ating Epstein
did
but s
said E stein stopped masturbating
see im ejacu a e. said Epstein of u from
the table and she immediately put her c ot es back on. said
she and then went downstairs. said she receive 200 from
said she believes a so received $200 from
sai
M ilir age
d
mention she
was in.
either
I showed
identifie
Epstein
was
never asked her how old she was nor did she tell
said during small talk with Epstein she did
in school but she never said what level of school she
said she never returned to Epstein's house nor has
or Epstein made attempts to contact her.
a photo lineup containing Epstein. positively
Epstein is position three.
advised she knew of other irls
T ese girls are
advised s e as no pro essiona
e ieve the other girls are trained in
that went to Epstein's home.
and
massage training nordoes  she
massage therapy.
signed an affidavit stating she wishes to prosecute based on
Epstein's activities. swore that her above statement was the
truth.
Date: 8/07/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 9
Time: 9:25:15 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
1-06-001078 (Continued)
This interview was taped using a digital recorder. This recording was
placed into evidence along with the photo lineup.
Investigation Continues.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * END OF REPORT * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
EFTA00007654 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
II I; I III IIi I I 4 I
as

╭─ Page 2, Image 1 ─╮
│ 05-74             │
│ | (29543,         │
╰───────────────────╯

I
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Jeffrey E. Epstein
(-•"--14-6,-
(1) (17 5-1 0 .'?
-Pr v N-46 /0 /,.?.O
I
Jeffrey E. Epstein

╭─── Page 5, Image 1 ───╮
│ = Pheke Bude fOraiten │
│ om oe .               │
│ ooo                   │
│                       │
│ Jeffrey E. Epstein    │
╰───────────────────────╯

L
IrAS3R 03Ell TICKET  Cova*aaof AND, BAGGAGE CHECK M*JCCT
an if ffali
JAL:LI -Lr
r •ANSPOR1AT II •
W s
CAC.. awe
50.00 rat"
13
00602742864736 I 0 006 2925085LL6 S
JSD50.0
Saber
PI 'War CW
IILL:aimr] "mcgt Jr TO
nmat
.4ENANgusmomgwwwwvAx SPECIAL SERVICE , TICKET
"rArris YOUR RP'
N47 VALID F P SGR TICKET 00612492382 -94
Wale irr erowww nal
Z"Irtrit 111 IRI hC
WO 'C Ma .a a.. J .
0/20 ,1CoitraoL *room n OX0•Ise kart*
ww.M.4.0 - - Cs/400a
NOT VALID FOR -MA.
as an. wan. WOO w a.+ Waver
0 TDS-214250851.16 S

╭─────────────────── Page 6, Image 1 ────────────────────╮
│ PASSENGER TORT NR                                      │
│ meee ci AECELPT SPECIAL. SERVICE                       │
│                                                        │
│ bisapesbeeteetecssefr _ MTATS™ts youR RES              │
│ t eanyyegte I * VALID F:                               │
│ 3] PSGR TICKET cos 1245238294 wor                      │
│ | ee eee at                                            │
│ joT_ VALID FOR TRAVEL                                  │
│ y= mere coma boom                                      │
│                                                        │
│ 00602742864736 | O OOb e9@508SLbb S o “DWEHesoa5Lib Ss │
│ USD50.0)                                               │
│                                                        │
│ al                                                     │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

PASSENGER TICKET AND BAGGAGE CHECK
NOTICE
I NOTICE
This portion of the ticket should be
retained as evidence of your
journey.
International (Warsaw Convention) Notice
If the passenger's journey involves an ultimate destination or stop in a country other than the country
of departure, the Warsaw Convention may be applicable and the Convention governs and in most
cases limits the liability of carriers for death or personal injury and for loss of or damage to baggage. k
See also the notices entitled 'Advice to International Passengers on Limitation of Liability' and "Notice
of Baggage Liability Limitations'.
Domestic Notice
Air transportation to be provided between points in the U.S. (including its overseas territories and
Possessions) is subject to the individual contract terms (including rules, regulations, tariffs and
conditions) of the transporting air carriers, which are herein incorporated by reference and made part I
of the contract of carriage.
Where this coupon is issued for transportation, or services other than air travel, specific terms and
conditions may apply. These terms and conditions may be included in the ticket set or may be obtained
from the issuing company or agent.
Please make sure you have received the important legal notices entitled 'Conditions of Contract', 3
'Notice of Incorporated Terms', 'Notice of Baggage Liability Limitations', and 'Notice of Overbooking' i
or the specific terms and conditions relating to non-air transportation or services. If not, contact the •
nearest office of the company or agent to obtain copies.
S
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Jeffrey E. Epstein

╭─ Page 9, Image 1 ──╮
│ Jeffrey E. Epstein │
╰────────────────────╯

i)1 AA4r .
‘14( ; el l ck' bk i
Jeffrey E. Epstein
0-1A-
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Jeffrey E. Epstein

╭─ Page 14, Image 1 ─╮
│ ay                 │
│ Gle & poe          │
│                    │
│ Vg                 │
│                    │
│ File               │
│                    │
│ Jeffrey E. Epstein │
╰────────────────────╯

IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR ../..-
DATE / 0 / OJP TIME / 6  /- 53g )
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED rai PLEASE CALL ■
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN ■
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH ■
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE.
a -SIGNED  1 -- -- 1104
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAIE TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU , FLUSH
-SPECIAL RETURNEDYOUR CALL ATTENTION a 41
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR j --• F . _
DATE - TIME _Z>.: 1-4 1a)
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED )1 PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL
-.
SPECIAL ATTENTION
AESSAGE _
a
SIGNED t - 1184
Jeffrey E. Epstein

╭─ Page 18, Image 1 ─╮
│ Clitus—%           │
│ ayer *             │
│ pita               │
│ Pole               │
│                    │
│ Jeffrey E. Epstein │
╰────────────────────╯

LO.„' /74  C -e_
tooeol
Jeffrey E. Epstein
TO I-95 FROM JET AVIATION:
EXIT LEFT OUT OF JET AVIATION'S GATE. TRAVEL
6/10TH OF A MILE AND TURN RIGHT. TURN RIGHT
AGAIN AND STAY TO THE RIGHT SIDE OF THE ROAD.
FOLLOW SIGNS TO SOUTHERN BLVD. EAST. THEN
LOOK FOR 1-95 STRAIGHT AHEAD.
I ,
•
I
TO JET AVIATION FROM I-95:
FROM I-95 EXIT ON SOUTHERN BLVD. WEST.
TRAVEL WEST TO THE 3RD TRAFFIC LIGHT
AND TURN RIGHT (YOU WILL BE FACING THE
BOMB GROUP RESTAURANT). TURN RIGHT
AND TRAVEL BACK THE WAY YOU CAME ON
PERIMETER ROAD. THE 2ND JET AVIATION
81100160ti LEFT #1515 IS THE TERMI-
NAL BUILDING.
*THANK YOU FOR CHOOSING
atJET 1111711117111/ THE ONLY GLOBAL BUSINESS AVIATION SERVICE COMPANY
JET AVIATION PALM BEACH
1515 PERIMETER RD.
PALM BEACH INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33406
DIRECT 561-233-7200
TOLL FREE 800-538.0724
FAX 561-233-7240
JA -01
/2--PAX/CREW CAR TYPE/MODEL
DATE
ENTERPRISE
HERTZ
AVIS
OTHER TIME
I

╭──── Page 21, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

HP Officejet 7310 Log for
Personal Printer/Fax/Copier/Scanner
Oct 03 2005 135PM
Last Transaction
Date Time Type Identification Duration Pages Result
Oct 3 1:35PM Fax Sent 0:22 1 Jammed
HP Officejet 7310 Log for
Personal Printer/Faxtopier/Scanner
Oct 03 2005 10:06AM
Last Transaction
Date Time Type Identification Duration Pages Result
Oct 3 10:06AM Fax Sent 0:22 1 Jammed
Ft; /qr. we_yiler,
Fom. , z)e -  fe(-ri
O.2) ,-„„tahr fr
HP Officejet 7310 Log for
Personal Printer/Fax/Copier/Scanner
Oct 03 2005 10:04AM
Last Transaction
Date Time Type Identification Duration Pages Result
Oct 3 10:04AM Fax Sent 0:23 1 Jammed
Eor -#10,1-1

╭──── Page 26, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007741 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007747 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007753 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007775 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00039156 (Jmail)
 [government] Standards of Employee Conduct
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
Standards of Employee Conduct
EFTA00039367 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Reentry Services Division
MEMORANDUM FOR
FROM:
Washington, DC 20534
SEP i 7 2019
REGIONAL DIRECTOR
mnpmupaem opy-TrN
, Assistant Director
Reentry 'Services Division
SUBJECT: Psychological Reconstruction
Inmate Epstein, Jeffrey (76318-054)
Inmate Jeffrey Epstein (76318-054) died by suicide on
August 10, 2019, while housed at the Metropolitan Correctional
Center (MCC) in New York. The attached psychological reconstruction
was completed by Drs. , National Suicide Prevention
Coordinator, , Sex Offender Treatment Programs
Coordinator, , Mental Health Treatment Coordinator and
Mr. , Correctional Services Administrator,
Northeast Regional Office. A summary review of these and other
recent reconstruction findings is forthcoming. Distribution of this
report is limited to staff named in this memorandum.
Recommendations at the conclusion of the report should prove
beneficial to staff at the facility and will be used to inform our
national suicide prevention program. Within sixty days  of receipt
of this memorandum and report, please provide me with a written
response which outlines corrective actions as well as a plan for
implementation, based on recommendations contained within. The
institution response should be routed by the Warden through the
Regional Director to the Assistant Director, Reentry Services
Division.
If you have questions or concerns regarding this request, please
contact me at
cc: , Assistant Director, CPD
, Assistant Director, PRD
, Assistant Director, BED
, Acting Warden, MCC New York
SON\100015278
Page 27(
PSYCHOLOGICAL RECONSTRUCTION OF INMATE DEATH
This is an interim report, due to an inability to gather all necessary data. Formal interviews were not conducted as a 
part of this reconstruction to avoid interference with pending
investigations
by other Department of Justice components. A copy of the video is normally made by Special Investigative Staff following
a significant incident, but there was no such video in this
case since the original video was confiscated by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) prior to the beginning of 
this reconstruction. The absence of these two sources of
information severely limited the ability to establish accurate timelines, confirm subjective reports, establish
converging and diverging lines of facts, or discover new areas of inquiry. As a result,
information typically gathered, reviewed and consolidated during a reconstruction to support
actionable findings and recommendations is limited.
Name: Jeffrey Epstein
Register Number: 76318-054
Date of Death: 08-10-2019
Prepared by: National Suicide Prevention Coordinator,
Psychology Services Branch, Central Office
BACKGROUND INFORMATION

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein was a 66-year-old, White male who died on August 10, 2019, while housed at the Metropolitan 
Correctional Complex (MCC), in New York, New York. James C. Wills,
former Acting Assistant Director, Reentry Services Division, a inted a team to conduct a psychological reconstruction. 
The team consisted of National Suicide Prevention Coordinator,
Central Office; Sex Offen er reatment Programs Coordinator, Central Office; en t Treatment Coordinator, Central Office; 
and
orrectional Services Administrator, Northeast Regional Office. This reconstruction was established in accordance with 
Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) Program Statement 5324.08, Suicide
Prevention Program.
Social History: Mr. Epstein did not have a Pm-Sentence Report (PSR) available at the time of the reconstruction; 
therefore, no official information regarding social history was
accessible. The following was gathered from publicly available documents. Mr. Epstein was born in 1953 and grew up in a 
middle-class family in the neighborhood of Sea Gate on Coney
Island,
Brooklyn, New York, with one brother. After early promotion in two grades, Mr. Epstein graduated from Lafayette High 
School in 1969, at the age of 16. He attended Cooper Union and New
York University but did not graduate from either. Mr. Epstein taught at the Dalton School, a private school on the Upper
East Side of Manhattan from September 1974 until he was
1
SDNY_00015279
Page 271
dismissed in June 1976 for inadequate development as a teacher. Following that, he held a
number of positions in the financial industry to include a position as a limited partner at
Bear Stearns until he was dismissed for unknown policy violations in 1981. He also worked as a
financial consultant and founded at least two separate companies.
Mr. Epstein had two si ificant eriods of employment. The first of these was his position as a
consultant with in the late 1980s. Mr. was described as his
first mentor. Mr. was later convicted and incarcerated for running a large Ponzi
scheme. He implicated Mr. E stein in fraudulently diverting company funds for his own
personal use. Years later, Mr. Epstein's sole client at J. Epstein and km
granted him power of attorney over his affairs. Despite also being identified as Mr.
s ,
mentee, Mr. Epstein was again accused of misappropriating funds—more than 46 million
dollars. These large sums are believed to be the seed money Mr. Epstein used to establish his
considerable fortune. These events are indicative of Mr. Epstein's highly-regarded intelligence
and charismatic personality.
Legal History: Mr. Epstein had a history of adult criminal charges and convictions. In
June 2008, he entered into a non-prosecution agreement and pleaded guilty to one count
Solicitation of Prostitution and one count Procuring a Person Under the Age of 18 for
Prostitution in the state of Florida. He was sentenced to 30 months: 18 months of incarceration
and 12 months of probation. He was also mandated to register as a sex offender under the
National Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act. Mr. Epstein served 13 of his 18-month
incarceration and then successfully completed 12 months of probation. It is unclear whether he
followed the sex offender registration guidelines in each place he owned a residence.
In regard to pending charges, Mr. Epstein was formally charged with Sex Trafficking Conspiracy
in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 371 and Sex Trafficking in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a), (b) (2), 2
on July 2, 2019. Specifically, he was accused of sexually exploiting and abusing minor females
over the course of several years. Charging documents allege Mr. Epstein enticed and recruited
minor females to engage in sexual activity. The minor females were reportedly compensated
with cash following the sexual encounters and some were encouraged to find other minor
females to accompany them to Mr. Epstein's residences in New York or Florida. He pleaded not
guilty to these charges and was in pretrial status at the time of his death.
In a 37-page Decision & Order Remanding the Defendant, signed by Judge Richard M. Berman
on July 18, 2019, 18 pages were dedicated to detailing the danger Mr. Epstein posed to others
and the community. The document also alleged he was a flight risk. As a result, Mr. Epstein's
proposed bail package was determined to be inadequate. He was denied pretrial release and held
on remand.
2
SDNY_0001 5280
Page 272
Institutional History: On July 6, 2019, Mr. Epstein was arrested at Teterboro Airport in
New Jersey upon his return from Paris, France. It is unknown whether he was anticipating this
arrest. He was transported to MCC New York and keyed into SENTRY at 9:24 p.m. that
evening. Mr. Epstein was placed in a general population housing unit for approximately 22
hours. On July 7, 2019, at approximately 7:20 p.m. he was moved to the Special Housing Unit
(SHU) pending reclassification due to the significant increase in media coverage and awareness
of his notoriety among the inmate population.
With regard to his adjustment to a correctional setting, Mr. Epstein received one incident report
while in BOP custody for Self-Mutilation on July 23, 2019. As of August 15, 2019, the incident
report had been expunged though it is unclear why it had been expunged and whether

Mr. Epstein knew this. Also, a review of financial transactions associated with Mr. Epstein's
Son account revealed one of his attorneys was depositing funds into his cellmate's (inmate
commissary account for unknown reasons.
HEALTH CARE AND PERSONALITY DESCRIPTION
BOP Electronic Medical Records (BEMR) indicate Mr. Epstein was diagnosed with
hyperlipidemia, sleep apnea, hypertension, constipation, prediabetes, neuralgia, and neuritis
unspecified. He was prescribed the following mediations: docusate sodium, milk of magnesia,
omega 3, methylprednisone, and bisacodyl. Mr. Epstein was also prescribed insulin, and the
prescription required him to go to the institution pharmacy for administration of this medication.
However, the dates for which it was prescribed have a notation indicating "dose not indicated,"
thus it does not appear insulin was routinely medically necessary. The rest of the medications
prescribed were self-carry. lie also had a continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) machine
which is typically used to treat sleep apnea. Mr. Epstein was provided with his personal CPAP
machine on July 30, 2019, per BEMR.
In regard to mental health history and treatment, there are no known available records. Any
records that may have been maintained relating to Mr. Epstein's incarceration in Florida were
not available for review as of the date of this report. With regard to Psychology Data System
records in BEMR (PDS-BEMR), Dr. I, Forensic Psychologist at
MCC New York completed a routine Intake Screening on July 8, 2019. During this screening,

Mr. Epstein denied any history of mental health problems, substance abuse, and treatment. No
symptoms of mental illness were observed. He was classified as Mental Health Care Level 1 and
was not diagnosed with a mental illness.
Following a cons 1 i n with Dr. , National Suicide Prevention Coordinator on
July 8, 2019, Dr. Chief Psychologist at MCC New York determined Mr. Epstein
should be pre-emptively evaluated for suicide risk upon his return from court. Primary
consideration was given to his various risk factors for suicide such as his high profile case and
media attention, pending sex offense charges, pre-trial status, and an ongoing court proceeding.
Mr. Epstein returned from court on July 8, 2019, after normal business hours. He denied suicidal
3
SDNY_00015281
Page 273
thoughts at that time, but due to the potential for other risk factors listed above, the on-call
psychologist placed Mr. Epstein on Psychological Observation in one of the suicide watch cells
until he could be assessed in person by a BOP psychologist. Psychological Observation is a
form of individual monitoring that is less restrictive than Suicide Watch. It is used for inmates
who are stabilizing and not yet prepared for placement in general population or restrictive
housing. It is often used to transition inmates off of Suicide Watch in order to monitor their
transition and safety after an acute suicidal crisis. On July 9, 2019, Mr. Epstein underwent a
formal, in-person suicide risk assessment with Dr. . She determined that, while suicide
watch was not warranted at that time, Mr. Epstein should remain on Psychological Observation
status out of an abundance of caution. He was removed from Psychological Observation on
July 10, 2019.
On July 23, 2019, Dr. ME, the on-call psychologist was notified Mr. Epstein had been found
in his cell with a piece of orange cloth around his neck. Reportedly, he was observed lying in the
fetal position on the floor with a noose around his neck. Medical staff evaluated Mr. Epstein and
found friction marks and superficial reddening of the neck skin and one knee. He was placed on
suicide watch by the Operations Lieutenant at a roximately 1:40 a.m. pending a formal in-
person suicide risk assessment. Dr. , Staff Psychologist at MCC New York,
assessed Mr. Epstein for risk of suicide later in the morning of July 23, 2019, and determined he
should remain on suicide watch. Mr. Epstein denied any knowledge of how he received marks
on his neck and initially informed staff he believed his cellmate, , had
attempted to kill him. Special Investigative Services (SIS) staff opened an investigation to assess

Mr. Epstein's safety and collect facts surrounding the episode. Despite this investigation, staff
was unable to determine whether he was assaulted or engaged in self-directed violence.

Mr. Epstein was removed from suicide watch on July 24, 2019, after 31 hours and 5 minutes.
Thereafter, he remained in the suicide watch cell and was placed on Psychological Observation,
where he remained housed until July 30, 2019, according to PDS-BEMR records. A discrepancy
exists regarding when he was removed from Psychological Observation. His cell assignment,
per SENTRY, indicates he was transferred back to the Special Housing Unit (SHU) on
July 29, 2019, whereas PDS-BEMR indicates he was removed from Psychological Observation
on July 30, 2019, at approximately 8:15 a.m.

Mr. Epstein attended a court hearing on July 31, 2019, and, upon his return, the United States
Marshals Service (USMS) provided paperwork to Receiving and Discharge (R&D) staff that
noted "suicidal tendenci.r. was notified on August 1, 2019, about this paperwork.
She consulted with Dr. and then met with Mr. Epstein to conduct a suicide risk
assessment. She determined suicide watch was not warranted at that time.

Mr. Epstein remained classified as a Mental Health Care Level 1 throughout his time at
MCC New York. During his contacts with psychologists, Mr. Epstein routinely denied current
mental health symptoms to include suicidal ideation, and he did not exhibit symptoms of a
serious mental illness. However, there was evidence Mr. Epstein was experiencing challenges
4
SDNY_00015282
Page 274
adjusting to his environment and changes in his lifestyle. He reported frequent complaints of
difficulty sleeping. He did not have access to his CPAP machine until it was reportedly provided
to him on July 30, 2019. Mr. Epstein also reported he was bothered by noise in the SHU. At
times, he noted concerns related to his safety in SHU or on a general population housing unit.
On two occasions, July 26, 2019, and July 27, 2019, he describlif self as a coward and as
someone who does not like pain. On July 28, 2019, he told Dr. the toilet in his cell would
not stop flushing for an extended period of time, and he then took to sifting in the corner with his
hands over his ears. Mr. Epstein indicated he was agitated following this incident and was
unable to sleep that night.
ANTECEDENT CIRCUMSTANCES

Mr. Epstein entered BOP custody on July 6, 2019, with a history of convictions for sexual
offenses and allegations comprised of more serious charges. The current indictment alleged
sexual crimes against minors, and he was facing up to 45 years in prison. On July 18, 2019,

Mr. Epstein's request for bail and pretrial release was denied.
On July 23, 2019, Mr. Epstein was found unresponsive in his cell. The motivation and context
were never fully determined. After 31 hours and 5 minutes on Suicide Watch, he was then
placed on Psychological Observation. On July 30, 2019, Mr. Epstein was removed from
Psychological Observation. Dr. sent an e-mail reporting Mr. Epstein had been removed
from Psychological Observation and needed to be housed with an appropriate cellmate. This
e-mail was sent to 71 MCC New York staff and, as of August 13, 2019, only 27 staff members
had opened the message.
On August 9, 2019, a federal court unsealed approximately 2,000 pages of documents into the
public domain. These included graphic allegations against Mr. Epstein. Included was a book
order receipt for titles such as SM 101: A Realistic Introduction; SlaveCraft: Roadmaps for
Erotic Servitude; and Training with Miss Abernathy: A Workbook for Erotic Slaves and Their
Owners. Additional high profile public figures were also named in the released documents. The
documents were part of a defamation lawsuit filed by a woman who
alleged Mr. Epstein had victimized her, against a British socialite, Ghislaine Maxwell, who was

Mr. Epstein's ex-girlfriend, associate, and alleged to have assisted with his criminal activities.
According to staff report, Mr. Epstein was afforded telephone calls on two different days
although it is unknown whether they were legal or social calls. No recording of the calls exist
and it is not known with whom he was speaking. One occurred on or around July 16, 2019, and
the other on August 9, 2019. Legal calls are not monitored, and would not be recorded. A
social call would be recorded; given the limited information known about Mr. Epstein,
knowledge of the content of any social calls would have been crucial to helping staff work with
him.
Following his final telephone call on the evening of August 9, 2019, Mr. E stein was moved into
his SHU cell. He was single-celled at that time because his cellmate #85993-054)
5
SDNY_00015283
Page 275
did not return from court. The need for a cellmate was communicated between Day Watch

(DW) and Evening Watch (EW) shifts in the SHU, but no cellmate was  placed with him  by the
EW staff. According to a memorandum from Senior Officer Specialist I  , SHU
staff were informed at approximately 1:50 m. Omit Mr. Epstein's cellmat would likely not
return from court. Furthermore, Officer noted Mr. Epstein would need a cellmate upon
arrival from his attorney visit.
A review of the 30-minute rounds forms indicate unit rounds were co e entire MW
shift on August 10, 2019. However, a memorandum from Lieutenant indicates
Officer Tova Noel and Material Handler Supervisor Michael Thomas made a statement after

Mr. Epstein's death that they did not complete proper 30-minute rounds at 3:00 a.m. or 5:00 a.m.
DESCRIPTION OF SCENE
A detailed description of the scene was unavailable because the officers who discovered
Mr. Epstein did not write memorandums and could not be interviewed. According to the Report
of Incident, on August 10, 2019, at approximately 6:33 a.m., while serving the breakfast meal in
the SHU, Range 9 South, Mr. Epstein was found unresponsive in his cell. Staff reportedly called
for medical assistance, activated the body alarm, and began life-saving measures. Arriving staff
stated they brought an automated external defibrillator (AED) and stretcher. Cardiopulmonary
resuscitation (CPR) reportedly continued while the AED was placed on Mr. Epstein. The AED
reportedly indicated no shock advised and CPR was continued. Mr. Epstein was escorted to
Health Services at approximately 6:39 a.m., and Emergency Medical Services (EMS) arrived at
6:43 a.m. He was transported to the local hospital at approximately 7:10 a.m. Mr. Epstein was
pronounced deceased at 7:36 am. It was not possible to confirm this timeline without viewing
video footage.
CONCLUSIONS/RECOMMENDATIONS
A general appreciation of risk factors for suicide specific to sex offenders is necessary when
reviewing Mr. Epstein's death. These factors, as well as more general risk factors for suicide,
were likely present. There are several common factors that increase risk for suicide in
individuals with a history of a sexual offense. These include stigma due to the nature of
sexually-based crimes (both within society and the prison system), a disruption of the ability to
utilize sex as a coping mechanism (which can lead to increased levels of distress and negative
affect), and grief about loss experienced in regards to arrest. This grief may be secondary to the
loss of former lifestyle, loss of physical items or collections related to sexual offenses, and/or the
loss of perceived relationships with victims. Other factors that may increase risk for suicide
among individuals accused of a sex offense include safety concerns, potentially long sentences,
and lack of skills necessary to navigate social relationships in prison.

Mr. Epstein was a high-profile, pretrial detainee awaiting trial on sex trafficking offenses. He
had been a successful, wealthy businessman with a number of high-profile acquaintances that he
accumulated through a combination of charisma, charm, and intelligence. Despite his many
associates, he had limited significant or deep interpersonal ties. Although Mr. Epstein appeared
6
SDNY_00015284
Page 276
to cultivate a large social and professional network, he was estranged from his only brother.
Indeed, his identity appeared to be based on his wealth, power, and association with other high-
profile individuals. Approximately two-and-a-half weeks before his death, Mr. Epstein appeared
to attempt suicide, but ultimately denied it was a suicide attempt. He was convincing in his
denial. On that occasion, he was saved because his cellmate notified BOP staff. In the weeks
before his death, he made statements that he was "a coward" and was having difficulty adapting
to his diminished circumstances. He also frequently referenced poor sleep and an inability to
tolerate the noise of prison. On the day before his death, a number of documents in his case were
unsealed, further eroding his previously-enjoyed elevated status and potentially implicating some
of his associates. The lack of significant interpersonal connections, a complete loss of his status
in both the community and among associates, and the idea of potentially spending his life in
prison were likely factors contributing to Mr. Epstein's suicide.
The following recommendations concern institution operations:

1. Single Ceiling: It is recommended that all inmates be double-celled unless safety
concerns or an odd number of inmates precludes this. Priority should be given to inmates
with a history of mental illness, self-directed violence, recent stressors (e.g., losses, newly
sentenced, etc.)
It is recommended that a system of control be implemented explaining who will be
notified when a Suicide Watch or Psychological Observation ends and how that
communication will take place. Because this is a life safety issue, the system of control,
once approved by the warden, should be reviewed in formal meetings such as staff
recalls, department head meetings, and lieutenants meetings.

2. Rounds: 30-minute rounds are required by P5500.14, Correctional Services Procedures
Manual.
3. Cellmate Assignments: Wh
would be his cellmate. As explained by
ein was placed in SHU on July 7, 2019,
Exec  Staff decided Mr.

Dr. , input was not sought from Psychology Services and it is not clear if or how
sex - ific needs and associated risk were incorporated into the housing plan.

Mr. was also a high profile inmate—an ex-police officer charged in multiple
murders. However, he and Mr. Epstein did not share the risk associated with being a sex
offender and their pairing may have aggravated Mr. Epstein's risk for self-directed
violence. In an effort to treat Mr. Epstein the same as other inmates, a statement repeated
by multiple staff, Executive Staff may have inadvertently overlooked the need to consider
unique risk factors associated with individuals whim been charged with and
V ense. On July 25, 2019, Dr. sent an e-mail to
, Associate Warden explaining a consultation betwee
and Dr. ; National Suicide Prevention Coordinator. In the e-mail, Dr.
7
SDNY_00015285
Page 277
reviewed the consult and recommendation from the Psychology Services Branch, Central
Office that Mr. Epstein be housed with another inmate who had also been accused of
committing a sex offense. There is no evidence this information was considered beyond
this e-mail, and Mr. Epstein was never housed with another inmate charged or convicted
of a sexual offense.
It is recommended Executive Staff and Correctional Services staff include a psychologist
in decisions about cellmates as a means of incorporating expertise about suicide risk,
mental health needs, and interventions for psychological stability.

4. Documentation Accuracy: On July 23, 2019, Mr. Epstein was found unresponsive in his
cell. He had abrasions on his neck and knee. There are inconsistencies between
documents describilicircumstances of the scene. In a General Administrative Note
in PDS-BEMR.  r. documented information received from Operations Lieutenant
that Mr. • found with a string loosely hanging around his
neck." In contrast, Officer, who responded to this errancy, wrote a
memorandum dated July 23, 2019. In that memorandum, Officer wrote he saw

Mr. Epstein "laying down near his bunk with what appeared to be a piece of handmade
orange cloth around his neck." It is critical that all descriptions of the incident accurately
reflect objective evidence.
Officer  wrote Mr. Epstein an incident report for Self-Mutilation on
July 23, 2019, after he was found unresponsive in his cell but prior to having the
necessary facts to determine whether he likely engaged in a Bureau violation. BOP
policy expects staff to write an incident report within 24 hours of having the information
that an inmate likely violated BOP rules but without making a presumptive decision
about guilt. A Special Investigative Services Threat Assessment was completed
August 2, 2019, but results were inconclusive as to whether Mr. Epstein engaged in self-
directed violence, willingly fought with his cellmate, or was assaulted by his celhnate. It
is recommended that staff remain open to all reasonable explanations for a behavior and
take the appropriate actions when a final determination is made. Although the incident
report was later expunged, inmates frequently experience significant stress when they
contemplate the potential consequences associated with findings of guilt.

Dr. entered a Psychology Services Intake Screening into PDS-BEMR on
July 8, 2010. The document has three typographical errors. She selected the No Sexual
Offense Convictions check box when, in fact, Mr. Epstein was previously convicted of
Solicitation of Prostitution and Procuring a Person Under the Age of 18 for Prostitution.
Second, Mr. Epstein was erroneously identified as a Black male in this document.
Finally, there is one instance where he was mistakenly referred to as Mr. Brown.
8
SIDNY_00015286
Page 2!

Dr. acompleted a Risk of Sexual Abusiveness document on July 8, 2019. She
marked "History of prior prison sexual predation" in the affirmative. This is not accurate.
Mid-Level Practitioner, completed a History and Physical on
July 9, 2019. An Intake Screening should have been conducted within 24 hours of his
entry into Bureau custody which was on July 6, 2019, according to P6031.04, Patient
Care.
Officer was responsible for observing Mr. E stein and documenting his
behavior while on suicide watch on July 23, 2019. Officer mistakenly used a
Suicide Watch Log Book intended for inmate companion documentation between
1:40 am. and 6:00 am. on July 23 2019, when he should have been using the Staff
Suicide Watch Log Book. Ms. Drug Treatment Specialist, reportedly
noticed this error and subsequent y an copied all of Officer ing entries from 1:40
a.m. to 6:00 a.m. into a Staff Suicide Watch Log Book. She then initialed these entries,
and this makes it appear as if she was the one conducti the watch. This information
was discovered and conveyed in an e-mail from Ms. Associate Warden
to Dr. with a carbon copy to Warden on ugust 12, 2019. Of note,
Ms. did not make an entry explaining why she was making the log book changes.
Staff Suicide Watch Log  These were not a part of the original entries made by
Additionally, Ms. then wrote entries for 6:15, 6:30, 6:45 and 7:00 a.m. in the
Officer nor was Ms. assigned to work the Suicide Watch post. Due to the
inability to interview staff at s time, it is unknown why Ms. attempted to correct
Officer error, or made any of the subsequent log entries. t is recommended that
if a staff mem r makes an entry error (e.g., writes in the incorrect suicide watch log
book), the staff member should describe the error in the correct log book, to include
indicating when they became aware of the error. The staff member should then notify the
Chief Psychologist.
A review of Special Housing Unit Records (BP-A0292) revealed a number of incomplete
entries. This document is used to monitor provision and receipt of basic services such as
recreation, medical rounds, showers, meal consumption, etc. The Officer in Charge
signature is missing on 10 occasions and a medical provider's signature is missing in
seven instances. There are six instances in which it is not clear if Mr. Epstein ate his
meal. There are nine instances in which it is not clear if Mr. Epstein took a shower.
There are ten instances in which it is not clear if Mr. Epstein was offered recreation.
P5500.15, Correctional Services Manual requires accurate and complete information on
the BP-A0292.
A review of Psychology Observation Log Books revealed significant discrepancies from
the approved Psychological Observation Procedural Memorandum, dated April 15, 2019.
A Correctional Officer is required to complete hourly rounds and sign the log book; 179
9
SDNY_00015287
Page 2n
out of 183 round signatures were missing. The lieutenant is required to sign the log book
one time per shift and signatures were missing in 10 of 23 instances. A Physician
Assistant is required to sign one time per shift and 16 of 16 instances were missing. It is
recommended that a further review of Psychological Observation procedures be
conducted.

5. Telephone Calls: In a PDS-BEMR note written by Dr.= on July 16, 2019, she was
informed by an unnamed staff member that a lieutenant facilitated two telephone calls for

Mr. Epstein. It is unknown when and to whom these calls were placed and no evidence
that they took place on a monitored telephone.
According to a memorandum from Unit Managers on August 10, 2019,

Mr. Epstein terminated his legal on August 9, 2019, in order to place a
telephone call to his family. Mr. (who was the Institutional Duty Officer that
week) escorted Mr. Epstein to SHU around 7:00 p.m. that evening and he was placed in
the shower area on G tier. While there, he was provided the telephone to make a call.
Since Mr. Epstein reportedly did not have his PAC or PIN number, which is required to
use the inmate telephone system, the Unit Manager placed dialing a number that
reportedly began with area code 347. Mr. Epstein told Mr. he was calling his
mother who, according to public records, has been deceased since 2004.
It is recommended that all telephone calls, other than legal calls, be made on monitored
lines to be available for post-call review or on a speaker phone so staff can monitor what
is discussed.

6. Direct Observation: Mr. Epstein was on suicide watch from July 23, 2019, until
July 24, 2019. While on suicide watch on July 23, 2019, Mr. Epstein attended an
attorney visit from approximately 12:40 p.m. until 7:15 p.m. During this time, he was
without "direct, continuous observation" by a dedicated BOP staff member as required by
P5324.08. While on Psychological Observation, he attended attorney visits on
July 24, 2019, for 11.25 hours; on July 25, 2019, for 11.25 hours; on July 26, 2019, for
9.25 hours; on July 27, 2019, for 11.33 hours; on July 28, 2019, for 10.5 hours; and on
July 29, 2019, for 8 hours. On July 30, 2019, Psychology Observation was terminated.
During these visits, continuous observation by a dedicated BOP staff member was not
maintained as required by MCC New York's Procedural Memorandum for Psychological
Observation.

7. Follow-Up: Mr. Epstein arrived at MCC New York on y 6, 2019. While
conducting the 10:00 p.m. institution count that evening..., Facili iiissistant
mated she obsery • • an his cell. In e-mail she sent to Drs. and
El and Lieutenant later that evening, she described Mr. Epstein as
"distraught, sad and a little confused." She said she then asked Mr. Epstein if he was
10
SDNY_00015288
Page 28C
okay, and he reportedly said he was. However, Ms.= noted in her e-mail she was
not convinced of this, adding, "He seems dazed and withdrawn." She went on to say, "So
just to be on the safe side and prevent any suicidal thoughts can some
Psychology come and talk with him." Despite the fact that Lieutenan opened
the e-mail there is no evidence that he contacted the on-call illogist as is required by
P5324.08, Suicide Prevention Program. Additionally, if Ms was concerned about
suicide risk, P5324.08, Suicide Prevention Pro ires her to maintain direct,
continuous observation of Mr. Epstein. When Dr. the e-mail the following
Monday morning, Mr. Epstein was evaluated by Dr. at approximately
9:30 a.m.

Mr. Epstein was denied bail on Thursday, July 18, 2019. This was a significant
disappointment for Mr. Epstein and likely challenged his ability and willingness to adapt
to incarceration. Given the potential impact of the judge's decision, a psychologist
should have siscesced Mr. Epstein's mental status upon his return to the institution. The
BOP developed a SENTRY assignment of PSY ALERT for purposes such as this.
Specifically PSY ALERT is used "to ensure, if movement occurs, that all staff consider
the special psychological and management-related risks associated with the inmate."
Furthermore, P5324.07, SENTRY Psychology Alert Function states, "When a decision to
move [any PSY ALERT] inmate occurs, any special psychological needs of the inmate
are reviewed and considered by Psychology Services staff [and] any safety and security
concerns are highlighted for non-Psychology Services staff." Psychologists should use
the PSY ALERT assignment more frequently with high profile cases and with inmates
who have a history or charge of sex offense. Both of these groups of inmates are
susceptible to exaggerated or unrealistic fears about correctional settings and experience
stress associated during movement and periods of transition (e.g., cell/unit changes,
movement to and from court, institutional movement, and release of information through
the media).

Mr. Epstein was reportedly in court on July 31, 2019. It is unknown what time he
departed or returned to MCC New York because this information was not entered in
SENTRY. Regardless, upon his return, the United States Marshals Service (USMS)
provided R&D staff with a Prisoner Custody Alert Notice regarding Mr. Epstein. The
notice indicated Mr. Epstein had "mit Mental Concerns Suicidal Tendencies." The
USMS requested R&D staff sign the lam and theyibleparted with the signed copy.
On August 1, 2019, at 8:46 a.m., Dr.  sent Dr. an e-mail reporting she had
just become aware of the above information. In the absence of additional information
about this notation, this should have been considered a referral to Psychology Services
about a potentially suicidal inmate and procedures should have been followed as outlined
in P5324.08, Suicide Prevention Program. Specifically, when a staff member becomes
aware an inmate may be thinking about suicide during normal working hours, that staff
member must contact Psychology Services and maintain the inmate under direct,
11
SDNY_00015289
Page 281
continuous observation until he is placed on Suicide Watch or seen by a psychologist.
There is no evidence Mr. Epstein was monit under these conditions from the time he
returned from court until he was seen by Dr. for a suicide risk assessment on
August 1, 2019, at approximately 1:30 p.m.

8. Inmate Accountability and Assignment Accuracy: According to a SENTRY quarters
roster generated on August 10, 2019, at 12:51 a.m., there were three inmates assigned to

Mr. Epstein's SHU cell, Z04-206LAD, including him, is death. However,
his SHU cell was only a double occupancy cell. Inmate (#86710-054),
itunatel  (#79793-054), and Mr. Epstein were all assigned to the same cell.
On August 13, 201941.12:06 na iad 12:08 p.m., a quarteilaggy roster was
generated for inmate and , respectively. Inmate cell assignment was
Z04-206LAD from Aue 019, until August 11, 2019, when he was moved to cell
Z04-212UAD. Inmat cell assignment was Z04-206UAD from August 1, 2019,
until August 11, 2019, when he was moved to cell Z04-207LAD. A quarters history
roster was generated for Mr. Epstein on August 13, 2019, at 9:07 a.m. His cell
assignment was Z04-206LAD from July 29, 2019, until August 10, 2019.
On Monday, August 12, 2019, photographs of nametags on SHU cell doors and SHU
locator forms were sent to the Correctional Service Department iaartIortheast Region.
The SHU locator form is dated August 9, 2019. It shows inmate'jaw& 207L
(SENTRY states he was moved to this cell on August 11, 2019), inmate in cell
a212U (SENTRY states he was moved to this cell on August 11, 201 ' to Epstein in
cell 220L (SENTRY never shovgjgajp this cell) along with inm (#85993-
054). The locator shows inmate (#92299-054) and inmate (#6 50)
in cell 206. The photo sheets show the ' with inmates Epstein and '
identification cards on the door. Inmate , Reg. No. 85993-054 was in cell
Z06-220U from August 5, 2019 to August 9, 2019.
MCC New York has four suicide watch cells and each is for single occupancy use. The
suicide watch cells are located in Health Services. Each cell is abbreviated with the unit
code H01 in SENTRY followed by the four-digit cell number. The doors are identified
by a painted number from one to four. Two reviews were conducted. The first revealed

Mr. Epstein was in H01-001L according to SENTRY but the Suicide Watch Log Books
indicate he was in cell 4. A second review was conducted on August 13, 2019, while
there were four inmates on in these cells. SENTRY showed two inmates assigned to
HO1-001L, one assigned to H01-002L, and the fourth inmate assigned to a general
population housing unit. Through physical observation of the dedicated suicide watch
cells there were four H01 cells, however a review of the BOPWARE Inmate Housing
Format, only shows three cells.
12
SDNY_00015290
Page 282
Inmate movement and assignments are not accurately reflected in SENTRY as required
by P5500.14, Correctional Service Procedures Manual.

9. Attorney Log Books: Four log books were not secured following Mr. Epstein's death.
Specifically, three Attorney Log Books located in the Attorney Visiting and Front Lobby
areas and an Inmate Search Log Book located in the Attorney Visiting area were not
secured. All four books were still in use at the outset of the reconstruction and after the
reconstruction team advised staff to secure them. P5324.08 states, "In the event of a
suicide, institution staff, particularly Correctional Services staff, and other law
enforcement personnel, will handle the site with the same level of protection as any crime
scene in which a death has occurred." This policy further states, "All possible evidence
and documentation will be preserved to provide data and support for subsequent
investigators doing a psychological reconstruction."
Further, a review of the attorney log books identified many errors and signify a systemic
concern. For example, there were two concurrently open attorney log books in the
Attorney Visiting area. Further, the different purposes of the two attorney log books, one
in the Attorney Visit area and one in the Front Lobby, could not be explained. BOP staff
were unable to articulate a system of control for the log books, and during the
reconstruction, some of the log books could not be accounted for. Within the log books,
entries were made out of chronological order, attorneys did not consistently sign in and
out, significant information was illegible or missing, columns were not consistently
labeled, log book opening and closing dates were inconsistent, and the cover had been
torn off of several books. At the current time, these log books are not functioning as an
adequate system of control and monitoring.

10. Automatic External Defibrillators: A review of available AEDs in the institution
revealed that the list used for accountability and inspection purposes was inaccurate and
incomplete.

11. Post Orders & SHU Training: SHU Post Orders Sign-In Shce viewed for the 3nd
Quarter, spanning June 9, 2019, to September 7, 2019. Officetrililif failed to sign post
orders for SHU #3 post.
Quarterly SITU Training Sign-In Sheets were reviewed. The 2019 r Quarter SHU
Training was conducted on June 6, 2019. Three staff assigned to rd
Roster ' attend or receive the S1411 Training: Officer
Officer , and Officer

12. Staffing: The Drug Abuse Program Coordinator positon at MCC New York was
abolished during Phase I of the staff realignment during fiscal year 2018. Re-establishing
13
SDNY_00015291
Page 28.2
the Drug Abuse Program Coordinator position would provide the institution with an
additional supervisory psychologist to provide critical clinical services.
Staffing in the Correctional Services department is relevant to the reconstruction.
However, the details about this topic are provided in an After Action Review completed
separately from this report.

13. Sex Offense Risk Factors: A broad understanding of risk factors associated with sex
offenders, by staff at MCC New York, did not appear to be present in all staff but was
vital to his adjustment and safety in prison. A more focused management strategy is
recommended, particularly in complex and high profile cases. Supplemental training on
sex-offender specific risk factors is recommended for all staff and should be provided by
Executive Staff and Psychology Services.
14
SDNY_00015292
Page 284
DOCUMENTS EXAMINED
TRU-INTEL Download Report of Incident (583), 586, & Global Report
TRUVIEW — Money Exchanged; Phone, Email, & Visitor Lists; Calls; Messages; Visits; Timeline
TRU-SCOPE — Logs, High Risk Inmates, Inmates Lists, etc.
Staff Memorandums
Staff E-Mail
Photographs of Scene; Deceased, Autopsy
Video Showing Scene and Staff Response
Sentry Documentation
SIS Case File Index
Psychology File PDS-BEMR
Psychological Observation Procedural Memorandum
Post Orders
Lieutenant Logs
Attorney Logs
Staff Roster
Medical Information/Records (BEMR)
BOP Twenty-Four Hour Death Report
Pre-Sentence Report
Note(s) Left Behind by Deceased
Time Line
Autopsy Request & Report
Inmate Central File
Court Return Screening Form
Prisoner Remand Form (If applicable)
USM 129 Individual Custody/Detention Report (If applicable)
Prisoner Custody Alert Notice
Staff Sign-In Log 1 Week Prior to Suicide (If applicable)
Detention Orders (If applicable)
30 minute SHU rounds
BP 292's & 295's
15
SDNY_00015293
Page 28:
EFTA00039998 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION

1. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900.0613.7745-G
(b) (6), (b) (7XC), (b) (7)(F)
Pa e of 1
2. DATE OF REPORT: 08/19/2019

4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
6. TYPE OF REPORT:
() REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
( COLLATERAL LEAD
13 WITNESS INTERVIEW
ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
) CS REQUEST
[ ) ARREST/CLOSE
[ ) INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
[x] MEMORANDUM TO FILE (USMI 1 1359934)
it DUE DILIGENCE
OTHER

7. HOURS WORKED:
On August 10,_2019 EPSTEIN committed suicide while in custody in New York. On August 12, 2019 Senior
Inspector (Sp= spoke with the US Virgin Islands AUSA's office in regards to this case. Based upon the
above information all parties agreed this case would be dropped.
As such the search warrant for EPSTEINs phone was cancelled, the MLAT requests for all countries were
cancelled, and all investigative activities were cancelled.
This case is now closed.

(b) (6), (b) (7XC), (b) (7)(F)
8. SIGNATURE (Name and Title) 9. DATE
08/19/2019 2:07 PM EDT
rount..vestigator

10. APPROVED (Name and Title) I I. DATE
08/21/2019 9:42 AM EDT
letInspeclor
12. DISTRIBUTION
DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
_OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE. THE. AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:43 AM EDT

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7XF)
US. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page I of 2

I. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900.0613-7745-G
2. DATE OF REPORT: 07/10/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTE1N,JEFEREY EDWARD

3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
6. TYPE OF REPORT:
[ ) REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
)
[ COLLATERAL LEAD
[xl WITNESS INTERVIEW (USMII 1342335)
El
ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
CS REQUEST El
ARREST/CLOSE
INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
MEMORANDUM TO FILE
DUE DILIGENCE
OTHER

7. HOURS WORKED:
On July 10 2019 at approximately 6:15 pm Senior Inspector (SI) contacted ill by
phone. SI introduced himself as a Deputy United States Mars  and ex lain i e receive er p one
number from a Miami Herald reporter. Sl= explained Ms. told him she would be
expecting his ca stated she did not recognize the phone number but suspected thats what that call was
for.
SI explained why he was calling and askedIMI if she had a few moments. She stated yes.
SI  asked her to start from the beginning with what she had said to Ms. regarding Jeffrey
EPSTEIN. stated that she is an Air Traffic Controller and that Jeffrey EPSTEIN parks his plane at the base
of the controlY)wer at the airport when he arrives. stated she has seen EPSTEIN get off the plane with
young girls. recalled two specific times with t e irst being two girls who appeared to be eleven (11) to
twelve (12) years old with white skin. stated another time a girl looked to be sixteen (16) maybe seventeen

(17) or eighteen (18) and appeared to be o mixed race. stated the dates of these occurrences were between
June/ July of 2018 through November of 2018. NI stat she started MIIMM1 in April of 2018 and was
fully qualified after May so it was after that. She only worked M' for about one (1) year.
SI= asked how far away was EPSTEIN from the control tower when they observed him. stated
mai,&fifty (50) yards but they were using binoculars to look.
SI= asked if they get the flight plans? stated that they typically get the out bound but not the inbound
SI asked what information is in the flight plans? stated ATC information and route.

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Title) 9. DATE
07/10/2019 6:42 PM EDT
nmmi ll..vestigator
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) 11. DATE
07/11/201910:35 AM EDT
Inspector

12. DISTRIBUTION
_DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
_OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OE THE UNITED srA us MARSHA LS SERVICE. NEITHER
TT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:42 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
Page 2 of 2
1. F1D: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0613-7745-G
2. DATE OF REPORT: 07/10/2019

4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
SI asked if it shows who is on the flight and where they are from? stated no.
SI MI  asked if there was anyone else who would be willing to talk to him that worked withM. Ell stated
there might be another person and that she would check and call SI back.
SI thanked• for her time and concluded the phone call.
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE. NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY RE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:42 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C). (b) (7)(F)
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION Page 1 of 1
I. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-I900-0613-7745-G

2. DATE OF REPORT: 06/13/2019
4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:

6. TYPE OF REPORT:
[ REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
[ COLLATERAL LEAD
( WITNESS INTERVIEW
( ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
( CS REQUEST
I 1 ARREST/CLOSE
INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
MEMORANDUM TO FILE
( j DUE DILIGENCE
(xi OTHER: (APPROVAL FOR INVESTIGATION)

7. HOURS WORKED:
On June 30, 2008 Jeffrey Epstein (DOB: 01/20/1953) was convicted of F.S 796.03 in the state of Florida for
procuring a person under the age of 18 for prostitution and sentenced to 13 months incarceration. As a result of
this conviction EPSTEIN must register as a sex offender.
On March 15, 2019 EPSTEIN went to the US Virgin Island Department of Justice located on the island of St.
Thomas and spoke in person to the Sex Offender Registry Coordinator. During this meeting EPSTEIN signed
the Notification of Duty to Report travel.
On 3/19/2019 the USMS received notification from the US Virgin Islands Sex Offender Registry that EPSTEIN
was traveling to France from 3/19/2019 through 03/29/2019 via his private jet (N212JE). No other countries are
listed on the notification form. According to a public website that tracks flight activity EPSTEIN traveled on
March 22, 2019 to Vienna, Austria and on March 27, 2019 to Monaco. These countries are not listed on the
notification form.
Based on the above information, an MSO4 investigation has been initiated to determine if EPSTEIN is in
violation of 18 USC 2250 (b) regarding his failure to report international travel.

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Title) 9. DATE
06/13/2019 2:01 PM EDT
nminal Investigator
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) II. DATE
06/13/2019 3:46 PM EDT
tel tef inspector

12. DISTRIBUTION
DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08272019 11:41 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION

(b) (6), (b) (7XC). (b) (7XF)
Page I of I
I. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0613-7745-G
2. DATE OF REPORT: 08/05/2019

4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
6. TYPE OF REPORT:
[ 1 REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
[ ] COLLATERAL LEAD
] WITNESS INTERVIEW
ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
] CS REQUEST
ARREST/CLOSE
[ ] INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
[x] MEMORANDUM TO FILE (USM I I 1353667)
[ ]
OTHER
DUE DILIGENCE
[ ]

7. HOURS WORKED:
On July 14, 2019 Senior Inspector (SDI. an  traveled to the US Virgin Islands (STT) to work on an
operation involving International Megans w °MU —While there SI met with the AUSA's office to
discuss this case.
- On July 17, 2019 SI spoke with the AUSA  in regards to submitting an MLAT request to the
countries of France, No;: tco, Austria, and Morocc AUSA MI stated he would submit the requests.
- On or about July 19, 2019 SI and.. spoke with Customs and Border Protection (CBP) in regards
to obtaining flight logs and rec.. EP s private plane. CBP stated these could be obtained through
the pilots themselves or maybe the FAA.
- On July 22, 2019 SI submitted a search warrant to AUSA for EPSTEINs phone number that he
listed he can be reache on during international travel. SIM isi ng to gain historical information that
may provide insight to countries EPSTEIN visited while on international travel.
- On August 5, 2019 SI received information from the FAA in regards to flight plan histories. This
information reveals numerous morc Countries of international travel by EPSTEINs jet. It will be investigated
further.
The investigation continues..

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Title) 9. DATE
08/05/2019 12:23 PM EDT
mmnii.westigator
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) I I. DATE
08/06/2019 1:21 PM EDT
let nspec or

12. DISTRIBUTION
_DISTRICT
HEADQUARTERS
:OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE. NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:42 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION

(b) (6). (b)(7KC). (b) (7)(F)
Page I of 2
I. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900.0613.7745-G
2. DATE OF REPORT: 06/24/2019

4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED BY
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
6. TYPE OF REPORT:
( ] REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
] COLLATERAL LEAD
(x] WITNESS INTERVIEW (USMI I 1335209)
( ] ADMINISTRATIVE SUBPOENA
) CS REQUEST
( ] ARREST/CLOSE
El
INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
MEMORANDUM TO FILE
[ ] DUE DILIGENCE
[ ] OTHER

7. HOURS WORKED:
On June 24, 2019 at approximately 1100 hours Supervisory Inspector (SI))  Senior Inspector (S1)
met with Investigative reporter (Miami Herald) at the Don ite Diner located in Hollywood,
Flblida.
During the interview SI asked Ms. if she knew of anyone who may have information in regards to
EPSTEIN. Ms scat he has an informant who worked at the airport and the informant stated she has
seen EPSTEIN Mg with girls under the age of 18 within the last seven months. Her informant has
the witnessed the irls board a helicopter at his island (Little St. James) and fl to the airport to board EPSTEIN's
airplane. SI asked if the informant had any records of this. Ms. stated the informant ar ti.me
text messages t at she sent to her friends upon witnessing the events. is informant now lives in ,
. Ms. gave her phone number to SI

Ms. stated she also knows a female who was employed for one week at EPSTEIN's residence before
being re  by him. This informant's boyfriend is still employed by EPSTEIN and Ms. will reach out
to see if he will speak with SI

Ms. also stated is one of EPSTEIN's disgruntled attorneys who may have information,
but requested SI not contact im yet.

Ms. stated owned a modeling company and helped recruit girls for EPSTEIN.
Ms.  stated =II= was the Police Chief during the original EPSTEIN investigation and may be able
to provide more iniliThricerning their investigation with EPSTEIN.

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Title) 9. DATE
06/24/2019 1:05 PM EDT
nmi~ rose investigator
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) I I. DATE
06/28/2019 11:15 AM EDT
inspector

12. DISTRIBUTION
DISTRICT
_HEADQUARTERS
OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT'S THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE. NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY SE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE ME AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08/27/2019 11:41 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION

(b) (6), (b) (7XC), (b) (7)(F)
Page 2 of 2
I. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0613-7745-G
2. DATE OF REPORT: 06/24'2019

4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEINJEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY:
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
The interview concluded at approximately noon and S)_ told Ms he would be in touch.
Case continues...
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT IS TILE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAI BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH LOANED.
08127/2019 11:41 AM EDT
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Marshals Service
REPORT OF INVESTIGATION

(b) (6), (b) (7)(C), (b) (7)(F)
Page I of
I. FID: 10127184
CASE: CC-1900-0108-2923-G
2. DATE OF REPORT: 01/08/2019

4. SUBJECT NAME: EPSTEIN,JEFFREY EDWARD
3. REPORTED
BY
AT: WOO
5. MERGED FIDs:
6. TYPE OF REPORT:
REPORT OF ELECTRONIC INTERCEPTION
COLLATERAL LEAD
WITNESS INTERVIEW
[ ]
]
CS
ADMINISTRA
REQUEST
TIVE SUBPOENA
[ ] ARREST/CLOSE
] INTELLIGENCE UPDATE
1 MEMORANDUM TO FILE
) DUE DILIGENCE

x) OTHER: (APPROVAL FOR INVESTIGATION)
7. HOURS WORKED:
Jeffrey EPSTEIN was referred to the USMS IML Unit by the US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of
New York as a convicted Sex Offender from the state of Florida who travels frequently Internationally and may
have not reported all his International travel as required by International Megan's Law.
EPSTEIN was convicted in 2008 in the state of Florida of procuring a person under the age of 18 for
prostitution, sentenced to 13 months incarceration and is required for life as a sex offender in the state of
Florida.
EPSTEIN is currently registered as a sex offender in the US Virgin Islands as his primary address and he has
secondary addresses in Florida, NY, New Mexico, and Paris France. In NY state, EPSTEIN is classified as a
Level 3 sex offender (highest-risk) with a lifetime registrant requirement.
Investigation reveals EPSTEIN travels Internationally quite frequently using private planes and may have
failed to report all his International travel. Based upon this information, a MSO4 investigation has been
initiated to determine if EPSTEIN is in Violation of Title 18 Section 2250(b) regarding his failure to report
International travel.
End of Report

8. SIGNATURE (Name and Title) 9. DATE
0I /08'2019 10:56 AM EST
inspectortoe
10. APPROVED (Name and Title) 1 I. DATE
01/08/2019 3:51 PM EST
telInspector

12. DISTRIBUTION
_DISTRICT
HEADQUARTERS
OTHER
UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE
THIS REPORT LS THE PROPERTY OF THE UNITED STATES MARSHALS SERVICE NEITHER
IT NOR ITS CONTENT MAY BE DISSEMINATED OUTSIDE THE AGENCY TO WHICH WANED.
08/27/2019 11:41 AM EDT
EFTA00040126 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
x
S2 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
v.
GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
Defendant.
x

MS. MAXWELL'S MOTION FOR AN ORDER AUTHORIZING A SUBPOENA
PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P 17(c)(3)
Jeffrey S. Pagliuca
Laura A. Menninger
HADDON, MORGAN & FOREMAN P.C.
Christian R. Everdell
COHEN & GRESSER LLP
Bobbi C. Stemheim
Law Offices of Bobbi . Stemheim
Attorneys for Chislaine Maxwell
Defendant Ghislaine Maxwell requests that the Court enter an Order authorizing her
counsel to issue a subpoena under Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 17(c) to
Administrator, Epstein Victim's Compensation Program, for certain items identified in
Attachment A to the proposed Subpoena, together attached as Exhibit 1 to this Motion, for the
following reasons:

I. Background
On October 11, 2021, the government began producing 3500 material to the defense.
These rolling productions confirmed that the four Accusers referenced in the indictment applied
for and received millions of dollars from the Epstein Victim Compensation Fund. Ms. Maxwell
requests the Court's assistance in subpoenaing documents submitted by the Accusers and the
witnesses for use at trial. The documents should be returned to this Court for an in camera
review and, subject to the Court's review, disclosed to the defense to be used for impeachment of
the witnesses at trial.

II. Legal Standard
Rule 17(c) permits subpoenas compelling the production of "books, papers, documents,
data, or other objects" prior to trial. Fed. R. Crim. P. 17(c)(1). Most district courts in the Second
Circuit, including this Court, apply the analysis set forth in United States v. Nixon, 418 U.S. 683,
699-700 (1974). See United States v. Pena, No. 15-CR-551 (A.1N), 2016 WL 8735699, at *1 —2
(S.D.N.Y. Feb. 12, 2016). The party requesting the information "must make a preponderance
showing that the materials requested are relevant, specifically identified, admissible, and not
otherwise procurable by the exercise of due diligence." Id. (quotations and citations omitted).
III. Factual and Procedural History

A. The Allegations in the Superseding Indictment
Counts One and Three of the S2 Indictment allege that Ms. Maxwell conspired to violate
two separate provisions of the Mann Act, 18 U.S.C. §§ 2422, 2423(a). Count One alleges that
Ms. Maxwell conspired to entice "one and more individuals" to travel in interstate and foreign
commerce to engage in "sexual activity for which a person can be charged with a criminal
offense" in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2422. (S2 Indictment fill -13). Count Three alleges that Ms.
Maxwell conspired to transport "an individual" in interstate and foreign commerce to engage in
"sexual activity for which a person can be charged with a criminal offense" in violation of 18
U.S.C. § 2423(a). (Id. 1116-19). Counts One and Three allege overt acts purportedly involving
Accusers 1, 2, and 4 and Witness -3.'
Count Two of the S2 Indictment alleges enticement to engage in illegal sex acts in
violation of the Mann Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2422. Count Four alleges transportation of a minor to
engage in illegal sexual activity in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2423. Counts Two and Four concern
Accuser -1.
Counts Five and Six of the S2 Indictment allege that Ms. Maxwell violated and conspired
to violate the federal sex trafficking statute, 18 U.S.C. § 1591. Count Five alleges that Ms.
Maxwell conspired with Epstein and others to recruit "a person" knowing that the person "had
not attained the age of 18 years and would be caused to engage in a commercial sex act" in
violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591(a). (Id. 7723-24). Count Six charges Ms. Maxwell with a
substantive violation of § 1591(a), claiming she "did recruit, entice, harbor, transport, provide,
' Pursuant to the Court's ruling at the November 10, 2021 conference, we will refer to Accuser-3 as
"Witness-3." However, for ease of reference, we will refer to these four women collectively as the
"Accusers."
2
and obtain by any means" individuals who were under the age of 18, including Accuser-4, "who
were then caused to engage in at least one commercial sex act with Jeffrey Epstein." (Id. 127).
Both counts are based on the allegations of Accuser -4 and allege conduct that purportedly
occurred "[f]rom at least in or about 2001, up to and including in or about 2004." (Id. if 23, 27).
B. The Accusers and The Epstein Victim Compensation Fund
Accusers 1 and 2 sued the Epstein Estate and simultaneously applied to the Epstein
Victim Compensation Fund. Accuser -4 previously sued Epstein and and reached a
settlement for those claims. Ms. Maxwell was not mentioned in that lawsuit. Accuser -4 and
Witness -3 applied to the Epstein Victim Compensation Fund. All four women chose to accept
compensation from the Epstein Victim Fund. In its 3500 disclosures, the government has
provided statements from the Accusers indicating that Accuser -1 resolved her claims for
$5,000,000; Accuser -2 for $1,500,000; Witness-3 for $3,250,000 and Accuser -4 for $3,500,000.
The Protocol for receiving compensation is attached as 1 to Attachment A. The Protocol
requires a written submission. The claims are evaluated per the Protocol which credits
"[w]hether there exists any information and/or pertinent findings offered by the appropriate
Office of the District Attorney, United States Attorney's Office, or other law enforcement
agency." Accordingly, the Protocol credits claimants who have had charges filed against Epstein
or any employee of Epstein. The June 2019 indictment against Epstein did not include the
allegations of the four Accusers that are contained in the S2 Indictment charging Ms. Maxwell.
Under the terms of the Protocol, the Accusers here, and their civil lawyers, stood to benefit if the
prosecution against Ms. Maxwell went forward. The Protocol also rewards Accusers who have
filed a lawsuit, legal action or claim of sexual abuse against Epstein, or the Estate, which
includes any employees or former employees of Epstein. Lawyers for Accuser -2 and Witness -3
3
were instrumental in creating and structuring the terms of the Protocol. See Co-Executors'
Corrections to Attorney General's Status Report on Voluntary Compensation Program and
Renewed Request for Ruling, Fanner v. Indyke, No. 19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF, Dkt. 73-1.

1. Specificity
The Protocol establishes a process that all claimants must follow. The "Claimant" must
submit a "Claim Form" with documentation. These claims are then evaluated based on the
criteria established in the Protocol. Any deficiencies in the claim are communicated to the
Claimant. If a claim is approved, the Administrator sends the Claimant an offer letter and a
release. Ms. Maxwell is requesting specific documents identified in the Protocol, including the
Claim Form with any supporting documentation, correspondence between the Claimant (or her
attorney) and the Administrator, a copy of the check issued to the Claimant, and a copy of the
release signed by the Claimant.

2. Admissibility
There are no evidentiary impediments to admissibility. The documents are relevant,
authentic, and an appropriate evidentiary foundation can be established under many rules of
evidence. The Claim Form is a prior statement of the Accusers about the events alleged in the S2
Indictment. The Claim Forms and subsequent communications are admissible impeachment
evidence at trial.
3. Relevance
As previously stated, Accusers 1 and 2 sued the Epstein Estate and simultaneously
applied to the Epstein Victim Compensation Fund. Accuser-4 previously sued Epstein and
and reached a settlement for those claims. Ms. Maxwell was not mentioned in that
lawsuit. Accuser-4 and Witness-3 applied to the Epstein Victim Compensation Fund. All four
women here chose to accept compensation from the Epstein Victim Fund. In its 3500 disclosures
4
the government has provided statements form the Accusers indicating that Accuser -1 resolved
her claims for $5,000,000; Accuser-2 for $1,500,000; Witness-3 for $3,250,000 and Accuser -4
for $3,500,000.
The Protocol for receiving compensation is attached as Exhibit 1 to Attachment A. The
Protocol requires a written submission. The claims are evaluated per the Protocol which credits
"(w]hether there exists any information and/or pertinent findings offered by the appropriate
Office of the District Attorney, United States Attorney's Office, or other law enforcement
agency." Accordingly, the Protocol credits claimants who have had charges filed against Epstein
or any employee of Epstein. The June 2019 indictment against Epstein did not include the
allegations of the four Accusers that are contained in the S2 Indictment charging Ms. Maxwell.
Under the terms of the Protocol the Accusers here, and their civil lawyers, stood to benefit if the
prosecution against Ms. Maxwell went forward. The Protocol also rewards Accusers who have
filed a lawsuit, legal action or claim of sexual abuse against Epstein, or the Estate, which
includes any employees or former employees of Epstein. Lawyers for Accuser -2 and Witness-3
were instrumental in creating and structuring the terms of the Protocol. See Co-Executors'
Corrections to Attorney General's Status Report on Voluntary Compensation Program and
Renewed Request for Ruling, Fanner v. Indyke, No. 19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF, Dkt. 73-1.
The documents sought are obviously relevant -- statements of the Accusers about what
they claim happened for purposes of securing a settlement. Similarly, the amount of
compensation is also relevant. "Relevant evidence means evidence having any tendency to make
the existence of any fact that is of consequence to the determination of the action more probable
or less probable than it would be without the evidence." United States v. Malpeso, 115 F.3d 155,
162-63 (2d Cir. 1997) (quoting Fed. R. Evid. 410).
5
This trial will turn on the credibility of the individuals accusing Ms. Maxwell of these
crimes. The Court should allow broad cross-examination during the trial on general issues of bias
and motive for fabrication to protect Ms. Maxwell's rights under the Confrontation Clause of the
United States Constitution. A criminal defendant "states a violation of the Confrontation Clause
by showing that [s]he was prohibited from engaging in otherwise appropriate cross-examination
designed to show a prototypical form of bias on the part of the witness, and thereby 'to expose to
the jury the facts from which jurors could appropriately draw inferences relating to the reliability
of the witness.' Delaware v. Van Arsdall, 475 U.S. 673 (1986) (quoting Davis v. Alaska, 415
U.S. 308, 318, (1974)). "[T]he exposure of a witness' motivation in testifying is a proper and
important function of the constitutionally protected right of cross-examination.' Olden v.
Kentucky, 488 U.S. 227, 231 (1988) (quoting Davis, 415 U.S. at 316-17). The possibility of an
economic reward is classic impeachment material. United States v. Bagley, 473 U.S. 667, 684,
(1985).
Full and complete cross-examination of the Accusers is impossible without understanding
the complete terms of the agreement with the Epstein Fund, including the claims concerning Ms.
Maxwell, as well as others. Cf. Moore v. Marr, 254 F.3d 1235, 1244 (10th Cir. 2001) (noting that
witnesses' "application for victim compensation payments and application for and receipt of
emergency victim compensation payments may well have been 'favorable' within the meaning
of Brady," requiring government disclosure of exculpatory evidence to criminal defendants);
payments and promises made to cooperating witnesses. See also, United States v. DeLeon, 428 F.
Supp. 3d 675, 697 (D.N.M. 2019); and United States v. Sedaghaty, 728 F.3d 885, 898 (9th Cir.
2013), "Impeachment evidence is especially likely to be material when it impugns the testimony"
of witnesses "critical to the prosecution's case."
6
Dated: November 14, 2021
Respectfully submitted,
s/ Jeffrey S. Pagliuca
Jeffrey S. Pagliuca (pro hac vice)
Laura A. Menninger
HADDON, MORGAN & FOREMAN P.C.
Christian R. Everdell
COHEN & GRESSER LLP
Bobbi C. Stemheim
Law Offices of Bobbi C. Sternheim
Attorneys for Ghislaine Maxwell
7
Certificate of Service
I hereby certify that on November 14, 2021, I electronically filed the foregoing Ms.
Maxwell's Motion for an Order Authorizing a Subpoena Pursuant to Fed. R. Crim. P 17(c)(3)
with the Clerk of Court using the CM/ECF system which will send notification of such filing to
the following:
U.S. Attorney's Office, SDNY
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York. NY 10007
s/
8
EFTA00084614 (Jmail)
 [government] Palm Beach Police incident report detailing the investigation into Jeffrey Epstein
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
•• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 1 Incident Report Program: CMS301L TiMe: 9:27:55
Case No
SPECIAL NOTES :
Occur To Date :
Day Of Week . :
Common/Location:
City  •
Location Type :
Beat. Assignment:
Dept Class . . :
Case Status . :
Supervisory Dt.:
Entry Date . . :
Names'
Vehicles? . . :
Narrative? . . :
1-05-000368
DO NOT RELEASE
1/27/05 0000
Thursday
358 EL BRILLO WY
PALM BEACH, FL
RESIDENCE -SINGLE FAMILY
DETECTIVE BUREAU Map Reference
SEXUAL BATTERY Report Officer
OPEN / ACTIVE  Case Status Dt
3/14/05
4/06/05
Property? . .
Offenses? . .
Related Cases?
*********VEHICLE
Case number . : 1-05-000368
State Veh Type :
Make  •
Model Name . . :
Style  •
Color - Bottom :
VIN
Disposition .
Insured by . . :
Vehicle locked :
Date recovered : 0/00/00
Street number :
City
Recovery code :
Be On Look Out?:
*********PERSON R E
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . .
Home Phone No. :
Sex  • Female
Weight  • 0
************** S
Case Number   :
Street Number
City
Birth Date .
Employer? .
Dper Lic No.   :
Other Phone Nbr:
Sex  •
Minimum Weight :
USPECT
1-05-000368
Female
N F ORMATION #
Category . . .
Year  • 0
Model
Permit Number :
Color - Top
License #
Stolen value . : 0
Insured . . . :
Keys in car . :
-Lein holder .
Recovery value : 0
PORTI
NCIC number . :
N G
Last Name
N F 0 r
. . :
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Other Phone Nbr:
Occur From Date: 1/27/05 0000
Report Date . : 3/14/05 1606
: 3 14 05
1 *********************
it 1 *********
• wnite
• 0
/ARRESTEE IN
Prompt valid in:
FORMATTnM-
Maximum Age . : 18
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Race  • White
Minimum Height : 0
Maximum Height : 0
# 1 * *
3(E MN- 1OFO&O2- J7
Date: 7/13/06
9:27:55 Time:
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident. Report
Page: 2
Program: CMS301L
Case No
Maximum Weight :
Aliases'
Hair Color . •
Hair Style .
Glasses . .
Facial Hair •
Teeth
Hat
Shirt
Shoes
Body Marks #2 :
Body Marks #4 :
Arrest Case No.:
1-05-000368
(Continued)
Misc. ID# . .
MO/Crime Spec?
Hair Length •
Eye Color .
Complexion .
Build
Speech
Coat
Pants
Body Marks #1
Body Marks #3 :
Status   STILL SUSPECT
Additional UCR?:
************** S USPECT/AR RESTEE INFORMATIC1LU - # 2 **
Case Number . : 1-05-000368 Prompt valid in:
Street Number : 358 EL BRILLO WY
City   PALM BEACH, FL 00
Birth Date . . : 5/25/1979 25 Maximum Age . : 25
Employer? . . : Occupation . . : T/EPSTEIN
Oper Lic No. . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Sex
Minimum Weight :
Maximum Weight :
Female
Home Phone No.
Race  •
Minimum Height :
Maximum Height :
Misc. ID# . . :
ite
Aliases' MO/Crime Spec? :
Hair Color .
Hair Style .
Glasses . .
Facial Hair •
Teeth
Hat
Shirt
Shoes
Hair Length
Eye Color .
Complexion .
Build
Speech
Coat
Pants
Body Marks #1 :
Body Marks #2 : Body Marks #3 :
Body Marks #4 :
Arrest Case No.:
Status  •
Additional UCR?:
STILL SUSPECT
**************
Case Number .
Street Number
City
Birth Date .
Employer?
SUSPECT/
: 1-05-000368
: 358 EL BRILLO WY
PALM BEACH, FL 000033480
. : 1/20/1953 52 Maximum Age
Occupation
ARRESTEE INFORMATION -
Prompt valid in: EPSTEIN, JEFFREY
: 52
.
Oper Lic No. . :
Other Phone Nbr:
FL
. .
Home Phone No.
Race  White
Sex  • Male Minimum Height : 0
Minimum Weight : 0 Maximum Height : 0
Maximum Weight
Aliases'
Hair Color . .
Hair Style . .
:
:
:
0 Misc. ID# . .
MO/Crime Spec?
Hair Length .
Eye Color . .
3 **
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 3
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued) Glasses . . . : Complexion . . :

• •
Teeth  Speech
Hat  Coat
Shirt  Pants
Shoes  Body Marks #1 :
Body Marks #2 : Body Marks #3 :
Body Marks #4 : Status  STILL SUSPECT Arrest Case No.:
**************
Case Number . :
Prompt valid in:
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type .
Residency Sts :
Can Identify .
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Aed Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
k*************
ICTIM
1-05-000368
ema e
• 0
JUVENILE
VICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
2ity
3irth Date/Age :
Dccupation . .
Tome Phone No.
3ex  • Female
sleight  • 0
3e On Look Out?:
7ictim Type . : ADULT
Residency Sts :
Zan Identify .
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
led Treatment :
?hys Last Name :
INFO
Additional UCR?:
RMATION -# 1********************
14 Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race   White
Height   0
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
PALM BEACH
k************* VICTIM
:ase Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
:ity   PALM BEACH, FL 000033480
3irth Date/Age : 16 Employer? .
INFORMATION -# ********************
Prompt valid in:
FL 000033480
18 Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
. :
White
INFORMATION - 1
Prompt valid in:
********************
fvt- /006)01-37
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 4
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
Occupation . Oper Lic No. . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight  •
Race  •
Height
Misc. ID# . . :
White
0 r•emate
Be On Look Out?: Other Phone Nbr:
Victim Type . : JUVENILE Residency Type :
Residency Sts : File Charges . :
Can Identify . : Victim Sobriety:
Injury Extent Injury Type 1 :
Injury Type 2 : Hospital ID . :
Med Treatment : Phys First Name:
Phys Last Name :
**************
Case Number .
Street Number
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : JUVENILE
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
************** ICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
INFORMAT I 0 N -
Prompt valid in: 1
R *************. *****
Street Number :
City   PALM BEACH,
Birth Date/Age : 18
Occupation
FL 000033480
Employer?
Oper Lic No.
Race   White
. .
Home Phone No.
Sex  • Female
Weight  - 0
Height   0
Misc. ID# . . :
Be On Look Out?: Other Phone Nbr:
Victim Type .
Residency Sts
Can Identify .
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment
Phys Last Name
VICTIM
: 1-05-000368
PALM BEACH, FL
remale

• 0
INFORMATION -
Prompt valid in:
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height . 0
Misc. ID# . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . .
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
********************
. :

• White
: ADULT
************** V I C T I M
Case Number . : 1-n5-onni68
Prompt valid in:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
INFORMATION -# 6 ********************
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Pager 5
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City  • PALM
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . .
Home Phone No.
Sex   Female
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : JUVENILE
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
BEACH, FL
:1
************** V I C T I M
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City  • Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . •
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
PALM BEACH, FL
Female
•
•
k************* V
Case Number . :
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Dccupation . .
Home Phone No.
Sex   Female
weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : JUVENILE
Residency Sts :
2an'Identify .
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2 :
Ned Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
JUVENILE
ICTIM
1-05-000368
PALM BEACH, FL
Employer?
Oper Lic No.
Race  • White
Height  • 0
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
INFORMATION
Prompt valid
INFO
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height . - . . :
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
(Continued)
- # ************** ***
in:
White
RMATION -#  R *******************
Prompt valid in:
Employer? . , :
Oper Lic No. . :
Race
Height
Misc. ID#
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
White
************** V ICTIM INFORMATION -# 9********************
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 6
Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex  • Female
Weight  - 0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type .
Residency Sts
Can Identify .
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment
Phys Last Name
PALM BEACH, FL
**************
Case Number . :
Prompt valid in:
Street Number :
City  •
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . .
Home Phone No
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . :
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
************** V
Case Number . :
Street Number :
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . .
Home Phone No. :
Sex  • Female
Weight   0
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . : ADULT
Residency Sts :
Can Identify . :
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
JUVENILE
ICTIM
1-ns-nonis8
Prompt valid in:
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . • :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
. :
. :
(rnntinnotil
White
INFORMATION -# 10 *******************
PALM BEACH, FL
Female
JUVENILE
ICTIM
1-05-000368
PALM BEACH, FL
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
. :
. :
White
INFORMATION - # *******************
Prompt valid in:
Employer? . . :
Oper Lic No. . :
Race
Height
Misc. ID# .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
White
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 7
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
Phys Last Name :
**************
Case Number .
Street Number
City
Birth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Be On Look Out?:
Victim Type . :
Residency Sts
Can Identify .
Injury Extent :
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
**************
Case Number .
Street Number
City
Birth Mite/Age :
Dccupation . . :
Some Phone No. :
3ex
weight . . :
3e On Look Out?:
7ictim Type . :
Residency Sts :
:an Identify . :
Enjury Extent :
[njury Type 2 :
Red Treatment :
?hys Last Name :
V
: 1-05-000368
PALM BEACH, FL
F*************
;lase Number .
Street Number :
:ity
3irth Date/Age :
Dccupation . . :
come Phone No. :
3ex
eight
3e On Look Out?:
fictim Type . :
tesidency Sts :
:an Identify . :
:njury Extent :
Female
JUVENILE
VICTIM
: 1-05-000368
PALM BEACH, FL
Female
JUVENILE
VICTIM
: 1-05-000368
PALM BEACH, FL
Female
ADULT
(Continued)
INFORMATION - *******************
Prompt valid in:
ICTIM I N F
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . .
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
•
White
ORMATION - # 11
Prompt valid in:
I N F
•
******** ********* **
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race  • White
Height  • 0
Misc. ID# . . •
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
O R M A T I O N -# *******************
Prompt valid in:
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim. Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :

• White
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 8
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report .Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Injury Type 2 :
Med Treatment :
Phys Last Name :
************** V ICTIM
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number :
City   PALM BEACH,
Birth Date/Age : 19
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
INFORMATION -
Prompt valid in:
FL 000033480
Employer? . . :
**** *********
Occupation . . : Oper Lic No. . :
Home Phone No. : Race  • White
Sex
Weight
Female
Height
Misc. ID# . - :
Be On Look Out?: Other Phone Nbr:
Victim Type . : ADULT Residency Type :
Residency Sts : File Charges . :
Can Identify . : 'Victim Sobriety:
Injury Extent : Injury Type 1 :
Injury Type 2 : Hospital ID . :
Med Treatment : Phys First Name:
Phys Last Name :
************** V
Case Number . . :
Street Number :
City  •
3irth Date/Age :
3ccupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
4eight
3e On Look Out?:
fictim Type .
residency Sts
:an Identify .
Enjury Extent
Enjury Type 2
4ed Treatment
?hys Last Name
•
t*************
7ase Number
Street Number
City
3irth Date/Age
)ccupation . .
tome Phone No
;ex
eight
le On Look Out?:
lictim Type . :
residency Sts :
ICTIM
1-05-000368
PALM BEACH, FL
Female
JUVENILE
VICTIM
: 1-05-000368

• PALM BEACH, FL
Female
JUVENILE
I N F ORMATIoN -  ig *******************
Prompt valid in:
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID# . . :
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1 :
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
•
White
INFORMATION -# *********** ******
Prompt valid in:
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Misc. ID#
Other Phone Nbr:
Residency Type :
File Charges . :
White
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 9
Program: CMS301L
Case No
Can Identify .
Injury Extent
Injury Type 2
Med Treatment
Phys Last Name
********* OTHER
Case Number   :
Street Number
City
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . .
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Other Phone Nbr:

• 1-05-000368
PERSON
Female
*********,OTHER PERSON
Case Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number : 358 EL BRILLO WY

• PALM BEACH, FL 000033480
Victim Sobriety:
Injury Type 1
Hospital ID . :
Phys First Name:
(Continued)
INFORMATION  -# 1*********
Last Name . . :
Employer? . .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height
Person Type
City
Birth Date/Age :
Dccupation . . :
Some Phone No. :
3ex  • Female
4eight  • 0
)ther Phone Nbr:
V******** 0 THER PERSON
:ase Number . : 1-05-000368
Street Number
:ity
3irth Date/Age : 35 Employer?
)ccupation . . : Oper Lic No.
Come Phone No. : Race
Female
(eight   0
)ther Phone Nbr:
White
: OTHER PERSON
INFORMATT
Last Name . .
********OTHER PERSON
:ase Number . : 1-05-000368
:treet Number
!fly
:firth Date/Age :
iccupation . . :
:ome Phone No. :
ex
'eight
ther Phone Nbr:
Male

• 0 •
******** 0
ase Number
n M 4 ") **  ******
Employer?
Oper Lic No. : M625620855610 FL
Race  • White
Height  • 510
Person Type : OTHER PERSON
Last Name . . :
ilill********* INFORMAT
. :
. :

• White
Height  • 0
: OTHER PERSON Person Type
INFORMAT - *********
Last Name . .
37 Employer?
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height  • 0
. : OTHER PERSON

• White
Person Type
THER PERSON INFORMAT IIIIIN  5
. : 1-05-000368 Last Name . .
*********
Date:* 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
Case No
Street Number
City
•
:
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
1-05-000368
Page: 10
Program: CMS301L
(Continued)
Birth Date/Age : Employer? . . :
Occupation . . : Oper Lic No. . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
Weight
Other Phone Nbr:
Female
561/000-0000
Race
Height
Person Type
•
:
White
OTHER PERSON
***EMPLOYER INFORMATION***
Case Number .
Employer Name :
Address . . .
City/State/Zip : WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33407
Phone Number . :
*********OTHER P E R
Case Number . :
Street Number :
City
Bitth Date/Age :
Occupation . . :
Home Phone No. :
Sex
'leight
ether Phone Nbr: •
:ase Number . :
kddress . . . :
:ity/State/Zip
?hone Number . :
1-05-000368
STUDENT
Male
S C N INFORMATION
Last Name . . :
Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race  • White
Height   0'
Person Type . : OTHER PERSON
- # 6
***EMPLOYER INFORMATION***
1-05-000368  Employer Name
WEST PALM BEACH, FL 33415
. :
. :
*********
e******** OTHER P E R S O N INFORMATION  - 4 7*********
:ase Number . : 1-05-000368 Last Name . . :
;treet Number :
:ity  •
Birth Date/Age : 0/00/0000 0
)ccupation . .
tome Phone No. :
:ex   male
!eight   0
)they Phone Nbr:
.******** O
:ase Number
:treet Number :
!ity
:firth Date/Age
'ccupation . .
:ome Phone No
ex
THER P E R

• 1-n9-nnol6s
: 0/00/0000 0
• Female
Employer? . . :
Oper Lic No. . :
Race  • White
Height   0
Person Type : OTHER PERSON
S O N INFORMATION  - # 8*********
bAqt Name . . :
Employer? .
Oper Lic No
Race
Height  • 0
. :

• Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 11
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
Weight  • 0
Other Phone Nbr:
*********OTHER PERSON
Case Number
Street Number
City
Birth Date/Age
Occupation . .
Home Phone No
Sex •
Weight
Other Phone Nbr:
: 1-05-000368

• Female
• n
(Continued)
Person Type . : OTHER PERSON
INFORMAT - *********
Last Name . .
16 Employer? .
Oper Lic No.
Race
Height  • 0
Person Type . : OTHER PERSON
. :
. :
• White
****************************NARRATTVE  4 1 ***************************
Original Report LO Reported By: 9/20/05
Entered By.: 9/20/05
On 03/14/2005, I received a call from a woman who did not wish to
identify herself (later identified as  ). She st
fourteen year old step daughter (later identified as
possibly may have been molested in Palm Beach by a wea thy
man. According to , she learned of the possible molestation
by a third party. She explained that she had received a call from the
mother of her stepdaughter's friend. The mother claimed to have
overheard a convers•• . between her daughter and a male • nd; they
were talking. about The conversation was about how had met
with a 45- ear-old man and had sex with him and was paid for it. I
advised that I would like to meet with her to obtain a more
detailed statement and facts.
to do and had to discuss the matter wit
stated she did not know what
husband. At this point
did not provide me with a call number or any other
information. She st that she would contact me once she had spoken
with her husband and mother.
On 03/14/2005 received
right to sp
Her mother
They anreed to meet me
a call from Mr. & Mrs They stated
to their daughter via cell phone
had been ma e aware of the case.
e po ice department later this date.
On 03/14/2005, Mr. accompanied by his wife
came to the Palm beacn volice Department where they a vise
me that they believed their fourteen year old daughter may have had
some type of sexual relationship with an older male who resided in
Palm Beach. Neither.knew the suspect's name or address. Both stated
that their daughter did not talk to them about the incident, nor would
she admit to it.
identified his daughter as
w/f,  DOB resides with her biological mot er
at 1 is a
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 12
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
her sister res'
currently attending
involuntary admitted juvenile educational aci ity. stays at the
facilit during the week and comes home on the weeken . According to
she was admitted to the school because of disciplinary
problems that recently escalated. The facility also coordinates with
the families to provide one on one as well as family counseling.
(Liapizinued)
and are
wh' 's an
According to Mrs. she b
Sunday, Feb 6, 2005. A friend of
their house and left. They believe
with the older gentleman, though they
s close by with her er. Mrs.
was
goes t
that on Sunday, picked up and
they met the man. Supposedly, t e man h
has young girls come over to his house.
way to make fast cash. The man starts with a
them, he keeps the d and does more. The
any information on other than she lives
Mrs.
found it
the call
between
the in occurred on
named picked her up at
n
initiated the relati
ot have any proof.
further explained that
, a boy she was dating
. Mrs. continued
drove to Palm Beach where
t of money and often
offers these girls a
massa e. If he likes
on did not have
on
talked of a conversation that she had with
the mother of a former friend of She
strange that they were no longer friends until she received
from her mother tellini miii of the conversation she overheard
and a boy named
told me of an incid ccurred on 0 2005.
lb got into a fight at school ( HS). s. Assistant
Principal, found over $300.00 in purse. gave different
explanations for the large sum of money. Initially the school
administration thought ias drug related but then dismissed the
claim. Since that day, Illildid not return to school; she ran away
Thursday, 02/10th or Friday 02/11 and returned to her mother's house
later that night after " t. It was not until after
received the call from s mother,
at she learned was the girl that got int
fight with The fight was instigated when
ik.
accused of
being a prostitute.
, who has legal joint custody of his daughter lin
signed the affidavit of prosecution indicating he wished to
prosecute against the inappropriate sexual behavior with his
fourteen -year -old daughter.
Mr. stat t he had no objections wi ency speaking
is daug about the incident. Mr. stated that
mother is aware of the allegations and also was willing to
cooperate. According to Mrs. she does not believe her
daughter had any additional contact with the suspect as she was with
• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 13
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No - 1-05-000368
her mother and then placed into
I co. e School Board P  lire who nvenrided me r
for , also known as
t Palm  Beach. Florida.  Chec ing t e
school board records for and   there was no
disciplinary record foun . I was advised if no disciplinary action
was taken for a fight, such as an expulsion or detention, the incident
may not have been recorded. This was at the discretion of the
individual school security and principal.
(Continued)
03/15/2005, I called the Palm Beach County Sheriff's Office and left a
message for PBSP Sgt. Child Abuse Unit.
On 03/1B/90nc T went
female
therapist. During an
about the allegations
anything had y admitting to going with
identi ) alm neAch  to pick up money was
owed. Identified  as the cousin of her filia l,
boyfriend She ultimately admitted to knowing that
worked for a wealth and possibly did sexual favors for him. She
also admitted that  had offered her an opportunity to make
money.
identified s boss as a white male named "Jeff" who
lived in Palm Beach Pter positively identified as agLkigy Epstein) .
explained that she was first a roached by IIIIII to go with
her to Jeff's house, when they were at house. Acci6glig to
she was not sure exactly what w s going on with I'll'. but
agree  her. ONION ( boyfriend) became angry when
he heard inviting IMMEMMEM to
it was to pick up money the man owed r stated
ny her. mmigi:
told her that she would pick her up at her house on Sunday.
wa  exact dates but knew it was a Sunday. According
tO alnnn with an nnknnwn nnaRi  liiiii ic female,
picked her up at her . told her
father that the were221aa shopping. It was later confirmed by
that minim picked his daughter up. According to Mr
, drove a pick up truck.
to
Also present was
audiotaped interview
that were made.
re I met with white
oke with
init . denied
•
Impdrove  along with the unknown female to P ch.
Sometime on the w re, a conversation occurred between and
w hereby told that if Jeff asked her
age, she should sarle ilias eighteen.
recalled that Jeff's house was on a dead end street. All
three girls walked up a drivewa ast what appeared to be a small
guard/security room. In fact, recalled a male approaching
them asking what they wanted. stated they were there to see
Jeff. The male allowed them to continue walking up to the house.
• Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 14
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
stated the man told them that Epstein was not there but was
expected back. He allowed them to enter the house, via the kitchen.
He offered them something to drink while they waited inside. Shortly
after, Epstein and a woman, described as white with blond hair entered
the kitchen. believed the woman was Epstein's Assistant.
added that the woman did not seem friendly and kept her
responses short and direct. Epstein introduced hims as
Jeff . got the impression that Epstein and riend
knew each other. described Epstein as being approximately
forty-five years old, a long face, and bushy eyebrows, with graying
hair.
and Epstein left the kitchen leaving and
friend alone in the kitchen. They returned a s or time later. They
all spoke briefly in the kitchen. While speaking to me,
became upset and started to cry. stated the woman instructed
her to follow her upstairs, which she did. According to , the
woman led her to a room that had a massage table in it. The woman
started to fix up the room, uttin the covers on the table and taking
lotions out. She then told that Epstein would be up in a
second. The woman left the room, and soon after, Epstein walked in
and told to take off her clothes. As was telling me
what had happened, she looked away fro ii- -90 with a pointed finger,
repeatedly pressed it into her thigh. -d he was stern
when he told her to take off her clothes. =aid she did not
know what to do as she was
stated she was •is usted by
Epstein's actions •u •I• not say anything. According to
Epstein told her that she "had a really hot body." Epstein excused
himself and went to the bathroom where she believed he masturbated
again. Epstein returned to the room and told
done and gave e hundred dollars. They went down stairs
where m liftili Epstein said good-bye and the
asked how Mil go and asked what did she
When told that E stein asked for a massage,
allegedly statedL;1liow." stated they then went shopping.
stated also iiiir, but that she did not know why
since she was confident that did not do anything.
at he was
described Epstein's house as a two story pink house with a
Cadillac Escalade parked in the drivewa . There were gates leading
into the property. From the kitchen, recalled walking up a
flight of stairs, lined with photographs, to a room. Upon entering
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 15.
Incident Report Program: CUS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368  (Continued)
the room there was a largeloathroom to the right. recalled a
hot pink aniiiiiii isofa in the room. There was a door on each side of
the sofa. recalled there being a mural of a naked woman in
the room, as well as several photographs of naked women on a shelf.
stated  Epstein did not chiiiiiiilfront of her but did take
of is towel, recalled Epstein being
hairy especial y on is ches L his  a-Igo Hari a hairline , that
contingagLtaamsis buttocks.
asked if she knew what being
Mino. then said that she t
e

was a "really built guy
would explain that when she stated
stated Epstein exposed himself when e too his towel off,
placing it on the floor as he laid down on the table
circumcised meant and she stated
said Epstein was specific in his in truc ' n to her on how to
massage, telling her to go clockwise, etc. recalled that
Epstein got up from the table and went to the bathroom where she heard
him making, what she believed to be sexual type of noises. (moaning)
He then returned to the room where he again laid down on the t
Epstein then turned over and instructed to massage
As she did this, Epstein continued to make moaning noises.
a so reca Epstein wing a not ce-• e rec eon
his chest. •
downstairs where she met arlirli lunknown white female.
Epstein then left the ro got dressed. She went back
admitted to getting paid three hundred dollars in cash from Epstein.
Before they left, Epstein asked r phone number.
As they were leaving the house
and how much she was paid.
It s when she told her tha
stated received onl
stated that she believed
bringing her.
t that if they do this every Saturday, they could
be rich; agreed. They then went shopp'n t h she is not
sure whey i ly at TJ Maxx or Marshall's. stated she
never saw as she got into a fight at school. She had
not 'spoken with either as her mother took away her cell phone.
to leave
asked
stated
hundred dollars that day.
.
was
e received three hundre .
was paid two hundred dollars for
he
what had happened
seemed upset or
I asked  if she was aware of any video equipment while she was
in the room. She stated no.
• Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 16
Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
11111111 stated she was afraid that would retaliate against her
or her family if she ever went to the police regarding the incident.
stated that her father's vehicle was recently vandalized.
admitted to teni.n what had happened with Epstein.
According to IIIIIIII became angry and u set, punching  a hole
in the wall. guessed that it was who told
about the incident, and now there were rumors in school about
and what she did with Epstein.
I then talked to about truth and lying. We talked about the
color sweater she was wearing. denied having sexual
intercourse with Epstein. She denied touching his penis.
again admitted to observing Epstein masturbate.
agre o
111 1
operating with the police department in iiiiig a
phone call to in a controlled setting  T mirth wihh ms.
and advised her of t e families' as well as
willingness to cooperate with this investigation. Copies of this
interview were placed into evidence.
I made contact with mother of , I
advised her briefly of my investigation. She was aware of the
incident and stated that she overheard a portion of a  conversation
that her daughter was having with a boy named IMMO. stated
that it was her opinion that both girls liked
recalled hearing her daughter calling a whore.
admitted that she did not listen to the entire conversation but did
confront her daughter about it later. told her mother that
something to the effect that had slept with an older man for
money. stated that she would not object to me speaking with
her daughter. It was s belief that everyone in the school
may have known about this because of the fight that her daughter
and had gotten into. I reminded that this
was an ongoing investigation and requested she no discuss the fact
that I had contacted her. She agreed.
On 03/16/2005, PBSO Sgt. a message that he was
returning my call. I spoke with and discussed the case with him
and inquired if he had agy2pen allegations or cases where the suspect
resided in Palm Beach. MIME stated he was unaware of any.
offered any assistance if needed.MEMEN stated it was his experience
that due to the age of the parties involved, it would be difficult to
interview them. and expect the investigation to remain confidential.
Because of the time delay, there was no need for the victim to be
taken to a medical facility for a physical for the purpose of
obtaining evidence. There was also no need to take her to CPT as she
was already in a juvenile facility, with an assigned therapist, in
which coordinating a day and time to obtain a statement could be made.
On 03/17/2005, I queried Jeffery Epstein on the internet and obtained

• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 17
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Co rd)
of Epstein to be used in a photo line up. I met with
at which time she viewed the photo line up. She immediately
recognized Epstein and pointed to him (Position #5). signed
the photo line up under Epstein's picture. This signed line up was
placed into evidence.
On 03/18/2005, I met with
placing a controlled call to
residence for the purpi
spoke
and asked if she could arrange another meeting with Jeff.
stated that she would have to call him and make the arrangements.
copy of this conversation was placed into evidence.
03/19/2005, I ' and
advised left the state to visit with her aunt and
uncle. is scheduled to return to Florida on 03/27/2005
03/21/2005, I co  rdinated wit PB BSF Unit and OCVAN to initiate
surveillance on
and was
03/21/2005, Coordinated with Det. regarding trash  pulls from 358
El Brillo. On this same I called  to schedule an
appointment to speak with . She stated the school guidance
counselor was reluctant to have police presence at the school. I
assured her that I would respond to the school in civilian clothes and
an unmarked vehicle.
called
an appointment to see

• ed a return phone call from
would be attending the family therapy
hark anti advised that I did not need to make
stating lid.
sessions with
I received messages from
I conducted a computer query on Epstein. The results of this query
indicated the most recent driver's license on file for Epstein was for
the state of Florida, which had expired.
A cross reference of Epstein s residence,
revealed the following affiliated nam
Mark L.  PrIrein  /m dob
Maxwell, uk/f, dob I
history.
Palm Beach,
, dob
& Gins aine N.
. A computer query for both returned no
On 03/23/2005, I spoke with -
requested that she not discuss the
daughter as I did not want t
told at this time that and
to the fact that AIM has decided
cell phone wk
incident with anyone including her
vestigation compromised. I was
have not been getting along due
to continue living with her father.
On 03/29/2005, I placed telephone calls to both the and
MUMMIMMI residences requesting to speak with them regarding the
• Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Page: 18
Program: CMS301L
Case No - 1-05-000368
iiiIMI
investi ation. I received return phone calls from Mrs.
' ed them that I would be contacting
to dinate a t' eet wi
was at the request of both and Mrs. that
classroom and therapy schedule be disrupte as ittle
also u dated them to the investigation thus far. Both
stated t o objection to my meeting wit
speaking with Ms. she identified the  re11 nhone n
as being the phone assigned to
had no objections and provided consent to giving it to the
poll ent for the use of placing controlled phon lls from
it-. stated the phone had been taken away from as part
of her un ent for not doing well in school. According to
used to be an excellent student, but in the past two
months has rritable, verbally abusive to the family and has
run away. stated her daug ' ecent behavior is the
opposite of what she normally is. stated they are going
through family therapy sessions wit t e sc ool b of this had
come up. Arrangeme ade for Det. Captain to retrieve
the cell phone from at her place of employment.
I called and requested to speak
with Ms. . Upon speaking with Ms. she advised hat she
was in the middle of therapy s ons and would call me once the
sessions were completed. Ms. stated the sessions s ou d be
concluded by 7:00 PM. At approximately 8:00PM I had called Ms.
at which time I'left a message voice mail requesting a return
phone call. I spoke with Ms. and advised her that I did not
meet with her daughter and that I wou d again attempt to coordinate a
the counselor so as not to disrupt IMOD s school sc
had no objections. ortly after speaking with Ms.
I received a call from Ms. fined the situation an
requested a t' to meet wit reviewed s schedule and
advised that would be available after 3:00PM.
rn n1/z/1/inns I met with Ms. and   at ,
. I reminded of her conversation wit
During this time initiated a conversation with me ink
she admitted that s e was not telling me everything that had ha ened
during the time she was alone with Epstein. According to ,
nued)
T is
strict
• le. I
and
In
er of
Ms.
asked
n
I
if Epstein ever asked her age and s e state• e had.
stated she told him she was eighteen. When Epstein asked
what school chi= urns in, responded she was in the twelfth
grade at j. During Ila minurse of'this incident, Mill
stated Epstein told her that IIIIII had worked for him for years.
We then continued wit trolled call to At
imately 3- er cell p one, mile call to
s home, was not home. was told
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 19
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No. .
that
cell phone,
Olive Garden Restaurant,
was at working
W/F,
located on
(Continued)
could be reached on her
oye  at The
in
During the conversation between •
and d what happened, st
she a eard rumors t was going to press charges.
asked if they, meaning arents, knew about Jeffery.
claimed to have heard that father had found out about
Jeffrey.     told that they (her parents) did not
know anything about Epstein. told that Ei eeded
someone to work tomorrow and asked if she was avai ab
stated she would call Epstein and then call
hat
During the course of these conversations with   she would
at times appear to be articulate and well spoken. She would then
start to act in an immature manner b looking around, not paying
attention, drawing on a paper. would offer me a high five
whenever she claimed to have told me the truth in the details of the
afternoon at Epstein's house. would sit in the chair, with
her knees propped up to her chest as s e admitted that she did not
tell me the all the details of her encounter with Epstein during our
m eting. As a means of positive reinforcement I would high five
On 03/31/2005, subpoena
and Cingular Wireless,
numbers) were drafted.
requests for T-MailiallgWireless
and phone
On 04/01/2005, I met with m  mherq of PP BSF Unit for the purpose of
. Cross-reference supplement. conducting surveillance on
On 04/01/2005, I met with Det. III. of the Palm Beach Police
Department who provided me a copy o the concealed weapons permit for
Mr. Epstein. It revealed Epstein had a valid permit. There was no
current photo attached to the renewal notice.
On this same . .
described by
date I queried various different web sites for a possible
of the purple item retrieved from the trash pull from
item was similar in description as the one
and used by Epstein.
I made contact with Spicygear.com and spoke with the owner John. I
emailed a photograph of the item for his opinion. He identified the
items as a Jelly Anal Wand of some sort. The item is easily available
at sex shops in South Florida.
04/06/2005, I conducted business queries into Epstein utilizing the
internet. I located articles relating to financial reports. There
was no local history.
On 04/01/2005 - 04/03/2005, with the assistance of BSF, there was
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 20
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
continued surveillance on the property.
On 04/04/2005,
and 04/01 f
herself as
(Continued)
cop' ' it messages, dated.03/31
to . A female identifying
states that she could pick up to take her to
Epstein's house for an eleven o clock appointment. A copy of this was
placed into evidence.
On 04/05/2005,
and me. There
papers. There
follo
from
a trash pull was conducted at   by Det.
were several messa itten on var forms of
was a message from , indicating 11:00. The
tional information o•
•
Friday 5:30PM;
; message receipt dated 4 4 1:05-
She is looking to speak to you .;
On 04/06/ I faxed sub oena requests to SA
E•stein
office for
and s •hone records. (Phone numbers
•
On 04/06/2005, I called  , ext
311, and spoke with Princi al He confirmed that they, had
a student by the name of . He requested a written request
prior leasing any additional information. On this same date I
faxed lid a re or student and parent information on
. I advised that due to this being an open investigation
he was not to discuss the matter with anyone.
On 04/08/2005, I received a messa e from rovidin me the
foll ' ' ation: , w/m DOB
Parents name:
work
Det. ONO provided me with trash obtained from   for 04/06
04/07/05. The following information was retrieved: Jet Aviation
800-538-0724 itinerary, indicating a departure date of 04/05/2005 at
4:00 PM with An Arrival in New Yo  k city of 6.1SPM.  Flight crew
captain  , co-captain,  `,
orrison. Call sign N908JE; a note stating
hand written notes & messages 11-Gle
, 3 September B & J, Big Screen x8,
a after schagjad left message

• IIIII works 4-9 Monday an es ay, eaves
school @ 11:30 AM; will be here tomorrow @ 10:30 Am; Mrs.
Business There was no trash for 04/08/05.
04/22/05 received the results of a subpoena request from Bellsouth for
sults only provided subscriber information. I
contacted Investigative Subpoena Compliance Center who
stated the request was not complete and the results would be sent to
flight engineer
Bye J. thank you
•30 chicken,
• Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 21
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
me as soon as the query was finished.
Cross-referencing the names
well as phone numbers, which were
trash pulls, I identified t
c• ainted w'
bo wove t e ega age o
(Continued)
notes
as
via
and
obtained from
do
message
i '
are
On 05/03/2005, I ith and updated her on the
investigation. state t t was doing well in the
school. Her contact wi

he outside is limited as they do not have
0 access to the phones. comes home on the weekends and she is not
allowed to go anywhere a one.
On 05/11/2005, I made arrangements to meet with and
On Thursday, 05/12/05, I spoke with regarding the case.
They will be moving to GA in July 2005. ey  be very busy over
the next few weeks but would be available via phone. Will coordinate
a date to meet to discuss the matter further.
During this week I conducted surveillance at Epstein s residence and
at the airport, but there was nothing to indicate that Epstein was in
town.
Due to conflinting appointments, rescheduled until 06/02/2005, to meet
with
I also spoke with and updated her to the investigation.
On 06/02/2005, I met with and advised
that she could be reached via her cell phone until she is able to
provide me with her new contact information.
I also received a message from . Attempted call •
but the line was busy.
June 14, 2005, I received information that Epstein's plane was at
Jet Aviation. I spoke with Det. regarding surveillance.
I called the Olive Garden and asked for advised
she was not working today. This would indicate that
s
as still
employed there.
On 07/07/ I faxed na requests to SA
Epstein, and
sub oe office for
hone records. (Phone numbers
The original
subpoena requests only provided subscriber and billing information.
On 07/20/2005, conducted a trash pull arranged by Ofc. . Inside
there were misc. papers with phone numbers and names. There were
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page:
Program:
CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368
misc. female hygiene
Track report
residence is
by officers who had conducted
seen entering and leaving the
(Continued)
he trash. Based on a prior Auto
sible subject residing at the
fit the description provided
surveillance in the area of a female
residence.
On 07/21/05, I received the Duces Tecum dated
clerked by ASO
On 07/26/2005, I received the results of Bell
07/18/05, which was
South Subpoena.
On 08/04/05, I received DHL Express from T mobile with the results of
the query.
I spoke with   who confirmed that was still living
out of state. It appeared that all was going we .
I left a message for at
On 08/08/2005, I received the results of Cingular cell phone subpoena
During the week of 09/08/2005, I checked   and the Palm
Beach International Airport but there was no direct indication that
Epstein was in town.
On 09/08/200s, I reviewed th notes of this file, as the case
will be turned over to Det.
On 09/11/2005, while on patrol, I conducted a check
residence and found that it still had the hurricane
drive by the Palm Beach International Airport later
did not observe Epstein's plane.
at Epstein's
shutters on. On a
that afternoon, I
On 09/14/2005, I conducted a check at the Palm Beach International
Airport but did not see Epstein s plane.
On 09/19/2005, I spoke with   to keep her updated a
find out if there was any change of e n
I was told no. I left a message for at
in order to provide her with Detective s information.
**************************** N A R R A ***************************
NA Reported By: 9/21/05
Entered By.: . 9/21/05
On September 19, 2005, I met with Officer and received the
information pertaining to this case. Members of the Burglary Strike
ad previo en conducting surveillance on both Epstein and
Officer assigned to monitor the E • home and
Sgt and Officer were assigned to monitor . Both
teams provided a surveillance log that will be placed into the
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 23
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
attachment file.
(Continued)
Det. was assigned to relieve Officer at 4:00 pm; he
infor!!d!!! that at approximately 8:00 pm, Epstein had left for the
airport ail his private jet was sitting on the tarmac. Epstein's
private vehicle drove to the jet and unloaded packages into the jet.
It appeared that Epstein left the county at this time. Surveillance
will continue to determine when Epstein will return.
Inv Continues.
**************************** N A R R A ***************************
NA Reported By: . 9/23/05
Entered By.: . 9/23/05
On Friday, September 23, 2005 at approximately 1:45 p.m., I began to
copy a tape micro cassette, under case number 05-368 and property
number 05-243, tape number 1. I placed the tape in the telex copy -et,
series 2 machine and began to go through the copying process.
Approximately 1/2 through the tape, the tape wrapped around the
spindle and became locked and stretched the tape. I examined it and
determined that it was in the best interest to leave  it is as a
prior copy had been made and turned ovarimrog Sergeant . I
immediately took the tape to Sergeant MINIM and allow • to examine
it and then obtained the copy from him and Detective and
brought the copy of the tapilliwn and made a copy for him based on
that. The tape was placed in the original container and is
retained in the evidence bag under the previously mentioned property
number of 05-243. It is not advisable to attempt to copy this tape as
further damage could result to the recorded material and there is an
existing copy anyway.
****************************NARRA ***************************
NA Reported By: . 9/26/05
Entered By.: . 9/26/05
On 3-24-05 at
MIMI' ••
pm, a copy of tape 2 frac° ?lumbar nc- 94) had been
made for Det. by Evide ialist
11.1a . The copy
was turned over to Detective.
On Friday, 09-23-05 at approimately 2:15 pm, I was in the process of
reproducing audio tapes (micro and standard) to standard size when it
was discovered, in the review pro at tape number 2 was
Ol blank. I notified Sgt. and Det. . I was informed that
they had a prior copy an i I could use it to make a master tape. I did
so and when reviewin signing the evidence sheet, I noticed
Evidence Specialist had written "#2 is blank."
I obtained that copy from Det. and made a new copy on a
standard size tape. The new copy was placed in the evidence bag under
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 24
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
property number 05-294 with the blank tape.
(Continued)
NA Reported By: 9/26/05
Entered By.: 9/28/05 •
**************************** NARRA ***************************
Copies of the tapes that were submitted into evidence were requested.
riairinn=ily, trash pulls were started ow  21, 2005. Sgt.
made telephone contact with , Supervisor of
the Sanitation Department, and requested that trash be collected at
1-ha PII I-‘'i   House located at 358 El Bril ach. Sgt
met with Sanitation worker, and observed  him
enter the property at 358 El Brillo. Shortly therea ter,
he r
exited the property and placed white trash bags in the empty
well in t  rfla flf *he truck. then drove away where he met
with Sgt. I  who removed the bags from the well and placed
them into one large black trash bag. The bag was returned to the
Police Station where I was waiting for him. Upon his arrival, we
inspected the bags where several notes and papers were found. These
notes con ' ames
and
'rls with times. Additionally, 'there was a
note from
stated,"For a good time call
t ey Els on
and
d, which
." Also,
there was another telephone number note . Also found
was a written note, which stated, can not come at 7 p.m.
tomorrow because of soccer. These items were written on notepads that
contain Jeffrey Epstein on the bottom of the notes. These items were
placed into evidence for future follow up. I requested subpoenas for
subscriber • tionpa6he telephone numbers listed n the
m and IIIII. The cellular telephones and
are both assigned to Cingular Cellular Service. Other notes
were found within the trash on Jeffrey Epst ' paper
contained telephone numbers. One note had ' with
written on it. This cellular number • gne to Cingu ar Ce ular
Service. Another sheet had written which is assigned to Bell
South Telecommunications. The subpoenas were picked up and submitted
to Cingular and Bell South Telecommunication for subscriber
information.
On September 22, 2005, I was informed by Sgt.   that there
would be no trash pick up as it was recycle pick up day. A request
for copies of the micro and standard size cassettes were requested
from crime scene to familiarize myself with the interviews conducted.
On September 23, 2005, the tapes were received and I beg become
familiar with the interviews that were con had met
with Town of Palm Beach Sanitation worker, an o
him enter the property of 358 El Brillo. Sort y t ereafter,
exited the property and placed e white trash bags in t e empty
well in th -- of the truck. s then drove away where he met
with Det. I'll'. who removed the ags rom the well and placed them
into one large black trash bag. The bag was returned to the Police
Station where I was waiting for him. Upon his arrival, we inspected
• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 25
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
the bags where several notes and papers were found. The notes will be
inspected for future use. The items collected were placed into
evidence.
It became evident that some of the recordings were recorded with
background noise and some interference. The calls most...ire
the control phone calls from the victim to the suspect .
I obtained the graphic equalizer and discovered that the calls are
able to be legible with the use of the equalizer by lowering the
background noise and increasing voice gain. I also learned that a
tape was broken during the coping of the tape. I returned the copy of
the tape marked Property Number 05-243 to have it recopied to have an
original in evidence and a working copy with the file.
earching the file, it was discovered that the suspect,
cellular cal
er was
oenaed incorrectly. The suspect
and the original request was for
I requested the information through Cingular Cellular
Service o Febrilarv--2-ans-±-b-rough the present. The purpose was to
have a record of   calls to victim, Jeffrey Epstein and
the frequency of calls. The request was submitted to the State
Attorney's Office.
Investigation Continues.. ..
**************************** N A R R A T T V F. 3k F ***************************
NA Reported By: 10/06/05
Entered By.: . 10/06/05
On or about S 2005 at approximately 0915 hours, I
r t
and met with PB Sanitation worker
had been previously notified to assist in trash
pulls at the residen frey Epstein, 358 El Brillo, Palm Beach,
Florida. I observed enter the driveway of 358 El Brillo and
remove several plastic bags of trash and place the contents into the
of an empty sanitation truck.
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the
trash from the truck. The trash was transported to the Palm Beach
Police Department where I began sifting through its contents. There
was a total of 4 white in color plastic bags and each contained
documentation and correspondence for 358 El Brillo and Jeffrey
Epstein. All ts.of evidentiary value were removed and turned
over to Det. for follow-up.
On or about Srntemher 21 9005 at approximately 0900 hours, I
and met with PB Sanitation worker
had been previously notified to assist in trash pulls at
the residenc Jeffrey Epstein, 358 El Brillo, Palm Beach, Florida.
I observed enter the driveway of 358 El Brillo, where no trash
was located wit in the receptacles. I left the area without incident
• Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 26
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-0 ua.a..
and notified Det. to that affect.
(Continued)
On or about September 27, 2005 at approximately 0915 hours,
iiiii
I observed
nded to 358 El an d• lo  met with PB Sanitation worker •
enter the driveway of 358 illo and
remove one plastic ag of trash and place it in the of an empty
sanitation truck.
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the trash
from the truck. ',trash was transported to the Palm Beach Police
Department where I began sifting through its contents. There was a
total of 1 white in color plastic bag which contained correspondence
for 358 El Brillo. All limits of evidentiary value were removed
and turned over to Det. for follow-up.
On or about Monday October 3, 2005 at approximately 0915 hour'.
d to 358 El Br' met with PB Sanitation worker
O A, I observed enter the driveway of 358 El Brillo and
ve several plasticbags of trash and place the contents into the
of an empty sanitation truck.
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the
trash from the truck. The trash was transported to the Palm Beach
Police Department where I began sifting through its contents. There
was a total of 7 white in color, plastic bags with a red tie and 1
black in color bag which contained 2 white in color plastic bags with
a red tie. Each of the bags contained documentation and
correspondence for 358 El Brillo and Jeffrey Epstein. Inside of one
of the white in color bags, I located a broken piece of a hard plastic
or clear acrylic stick, which was shaped with small ridges. This
device is commonly used as a sexual toy which is inserted into the
vagina or anus for stimulation. This item, along with alts
of evidentiary value were removed and turned over to Det. for
follow-up.
On or about Tuesday October 4, 2005 at approximately 0928 ho I
d to 358 El Br* met with PB Sanitation worker uilli
. I observed enter the driveway of 358 El Brillo and
remove several plastic bags of trash and place the contents into the
side well of the sanitation truck. This side of the truck is separate
from the rear of the truck and does not come into contact with other
trash.
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the
trash from the truck. The trash was transported to the Palm Beach
Police Department where I began'sifting through its contents. There
was a total of 2 white in color plastic bags which were tied at the
top. Each of the bags contained documentation and correspondence for
358 El Brillo and Jeffrey Epstein. ents of evidentiary value
were removed and turned over to Det. for follow-up.
On or about Wednesday October 5, 2005 at approximately 0928 hours, I
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 27
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
d to 358 El Briiii iiii
I observed
remove several plastic!= mm7
bed of the sanitation truck.
(Continued)
met with PB Sanitation  worker .Taff
enter the driveway of   and
o trash and place the contents into the
I then followed to a predetermined location and seized the
trash from the truck. The trash was transported to the Palm Beach
.
Police Department w egan sifting through its contents, with the
assistance of Det. There were a total of 2 bags, one of
which was white in color and tied in a knot at the top, and the other
was a black in color bag, which contained two white in color trash
bags along with loose debris. Each of the bags contained
documentation and correspondence for 358 El Brillo and Jeffrey
Epstein. All is of evidentiary value were removed and turned
over to Det. for follow-up.
**************************** N A R R A ***************************
NA Reported By: 1O/07/05
Entered By.: . 1O/07/05
I met with Det. and requested further assistance to maintain
trash collections at Epstein's residence at 358 El Brillo Road. On
er 3, 2005, at approximately 10:30 am, I was contact Sgt.
to respond to the Palm Beach Police Station. Det. had
observed Jeff Epstein ridi bicycle on South County Road. Upon
my arrival, I met wit o advised, as Epstein was currently
in Town; we interview as to her involvement with Epstein
e girls that are brought to his house. As we were to interview
in the county, (outside of our jurisdiction), I contacted the
State Attorney s Office Investigation Division, and made contact with
Assistant Supervisor Inv tor Carlos Ortiz. I requested
assistance to interview as the interview may occur in the
county. Supervisor Ortiz assigned ' ator Mike Waites to assist
us at the location and interview of
responded to the Det. had f and viewed her
vehicle parked in the alill vehicle a red Plymn*ith Menn
nrina clnrida TACT n s parked in the driveway of
Sgt and I responded to 120th Ave and
awaited the arrival of Investigator Mike Waites. Upon his arrival, he
was briefed that should she wish tiiiiiinterviewed within her home he
would be needed. However, should agree to return to the ce
station for further questioning, he wouiiiiitiiiiiiedei lli iit.
and I knocked on the door and met with . was told
that we were investigatliagAclaim involving Jeffrey Epstein of El
iiiilo in Palm Beach. IIIIII was asked if she wanted to accompany us
to the police station for further questioning. She was also told
that at the conclusion of the interview she would be returned home.
agreed and wished to change her clothes prior to accompanying us
to the police station. At the conclusion of her changing
clothes, she advised she was ready to go. I thanked Inv. Waites and
advised she was going to voluntarily return to.the police station.
• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 28
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
Upon s entry in the unmarked Detective vehicle, I placed a tape
recorder within the vehic  record any conversation in the
vehicle. During the ride to the police station, advised
she is attending Palm Beach Community College at the Palm Beach
Gardens Campus and is majoring in journalism.
Upon our arrival at the police station, was broug the
interview room in the Detective Bureau. I explained to that I
appreciated her willingness to assist us'and informed her that should
she desire to leave at any time she may do so. I fur plained
the interview room door is only closed for priv stated she
understood. During the taped swor • iew, was asked how
she came in contact with Epstein. stat when she turned
Beach Resort in Rivera Beach.
17 years of age she was approac  a friend
was asked if she wanted to make
in the Canopy
money.
She was t would have to provide a massage and should make
$200.00. thought about the offer. agreed to meet with
Jeffrey. (Unknown last name) and (Unknown last name)
picked her up and she was taken to Epstein's house. Upon her arrival
at the house, she was introduced to Epstein in the kitchen of the
lime. She was also introduced to a white female known to her as
She was led irs to the main bedroom known to her as Jeff
Epstein s bedroom. arranged the massage table and covered the
table with a sheet. She b t out the massage oils and laid them
next to the massage bed. then left the room and informed her
Jeff would be in a minute. Jeff entered the bedroom wearing only a
tow  lay on the table onto his stomach ed massage oil
fore to rub on him. During the massage, stated,
massage, Epstein pal or the massage. He explained, I
know you re.not comfortable, but I'll ou if you bring some girls.
He told her the younger the better.  stated she once tried to
bring ear-old female and Epstein stated that the female was too
was'asked how many girls she t in total to Epstein.
d rariari Rh° hrOlii ii' c
and the victim in this case.
I asked whi was the youngest. advised the victim
was the youngest.  stated every girl she brought knew what to
expect whrn (-hru arrived. They were told they would provide a
massage, I , and some touching. I asked her if the victim
was aware. She stated every girl she brought knew what to expect.
She explained she knew the victim wanted to make money. She
approached the victim and explained about going to work for Jeff. The
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 29
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
victim agreed and arrangements
Epstein's house on a
(later identified as
upstairs. Whe
kitchen area.
to Epstein's.
'for the massage.
happened. iiiiiictim told her about the massage and then they went
shopping. stated the victim was the last person she brought to
Epstein. She further state t she had changed her cellular number
to avoid being contacted by . She continued that when Epstiii,
announces to
would contact
istant that he is traveling to Peach,
range girls for  PvIt. i , later
fied as Date of Birth  , had told
that Jeff likes to have his fun with the girls.
(Continued)
ade to bring the victii iiii
stated that she and
picked up the victim at the
victim s house. They traveled to Epstein's House and entered through
the kitchegaaor. They met with the house chef and Epstein s
assistant The v m was introduced to Epstein while they were
in the kitchen area. led the victim upstairs and Epstein went
assage was over, the victim returned to the
stated she was paid $200.00 for bring the victim
stated the victimiiiii iher she was paid $300.00
in the vehicle, asked the victim what
stated that once her
Min, they disapproved o
further stated that
leaves m- the
parents discovered that she was visiting
e encounters with him and she stopped.
still trio call the house and
were
DOB
, and DOB
Sgt entered the room and explained that based on her own
statements, she h ' icated herself with bringing underage girls to
Epstein's house. was aware of what she had stat wished
to assist further in hopes to receive a lesser charge.
provided cellular telephone numbers for the girls she had mentioned
previously. Additionally, she alag mgrovided possible addresses and
areas in which they lived. As III'. was being taken home in the
vehicle, a tape recorder was placed within the vehicii lio record any
sations within the vehicle. During the drive to her home,
made the comment i m like a Heidi Fliess. (Hollyw ram who
sent girls to clients for sexual favors in California). was
dropped off at her house without incident.
Sgt and I went to
Floriaa.ya maamat speak with . We met with
Mrs. ( s Mother) at t door. We 'explained
the ongoing investigation and felt that may have additional
on as we had information that she had worked for Jeff. Mrs.
introduced us to her husband and allowed  ng entry intn  the
home. We sat " ing room and met with  ,
firth As she was under the age of eighteen, Mrs.
was advised we would be speaking with her. She expressed,
.
if her daughter  had information  she wanted to assist. As we
interviewed I , she denied having any inappropriate
encounters with Jeff (Epstein) . She stated she had gone to Jeff s
• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 30
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  (Continued)
House with lila. approximately eight months ago and sat in the
kitchen with the house chef but nothing hap s the parents were
present during the interview, we felt that was withholding
information from us. She made several comments as to she has put the
entire incident behind her. I left my direct telephone number and
rd should she wish to gnAnk with me again to telephone me. Sgt
and I thanked Mrs. for her time and left the area.
She stated she would ask her again after as to what happened
at Epstein s house. I informed her that had my telephone
number and hopefully she would call.
attempted co
We met wit
her daughter. was at the Ma
explained the ongoing investigation an elt the
additional information as we had information that
Jeff. We left our phone numbers and asked her to
her daughter's return. We then left the area.
On October 4, 2005, at app
a voice mail message from
with her daughter and
s house. I contacted
at
o stated was
a s not home. We
may have
she had worked for
telephone me upon
05 am, Sgt had retrieved
She stated she had spoken
ation as to what occurred at Jeff
who sta er daughter was in the
shower at the moment and would be traveling
College. I inform I would be en route
Det. I drove to the
and . During a sw
state she was to en to the house by
told she could make money working fo f. She was told she would
have to provide a massage to Jeff. stated er arrival to
the house she was brought to the kitchen area by
They met with house chef and stayed in the kitchen. She was
introduced to Jeff's assistant and was brought upstairs to the
mater bedroom. prepared the room and massage table for a
massage. Epstein entered the room and she provided a massage.
sal s e
involving Jeff. At the conclusio
$200.00 for the massage. I asked if she has a al training
in massages to which she replied no. I asked her i re
any monies for taking her to perform the maiiiii stated
eceived money for t e re. stated she weiiiiith
till to Orlando to attend
home in
home and met
Nit tement,
She was
wler e ou .y e Incl en
e massage, she was paid
iiiiii iiiii ii
and another girl, ff's ho
stated she w ' d i kitchen with , while was taken
upstairs by . stated she only did the massage once, as she
was wierded out by the whole experience. At the conclus of the
interview and the taligigas stopped, I was informed that had
attempted to reach IIIII via cell phone. A voice mail message on
October 4,  at 10:59 am, revealed a female ce who identified
herself as who requested her to call her reference the
through its contents.
with
Exch n ad
J.E dated 03
boarding pass copy for passenger, , Montg County,
Health Department food service ID NO#40820 for
and Ghislaine Maxwell notepaper with names and phone numbers
Photocopie the trash collected were attached with the supplement.
Detective was advised of the contents that were collected for
evidentiary value.
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55.
Page: 31
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No 1-05-000368 (Continued)
police quest- g. This voice mail message was recorded onto a micro
vided the incoming telephone n
stated she ' ently told about
t e police investigation because had called her to t
about how she just received a rental car froth Jeff Epstein.
had called her to tell her that she was given a rental car, a 2005
Nissan Sentra, to utilize to visit family and visit Jeff.
asked her what wailing on ouse that the police w
e asking questions.
ill
stated then called Jeff and
and asked what was going on r nc e ongoing police
investigation. According to , has since then been g to
contact her ask about the police questions. I instruct not
to contact and do not provide  more information to as
she would notify Jeff Epstein and what was transpiring.
Investigation Continues.. .
****************************NARRA 8 ***************************
NA Reported By: 10/07/05
Entered By.: . 10/07/05
On March 30, 2005, I was asked by Sgt.   to
conducting surveillance and trash pulls reference Detective
conducting a criminal investigation involving Jeffrey Epstein. I was
advised that Epstein was possibly engaging in sexual contact with
young females.
On March 30, 2005,
Supervisor
Way to begin on March 31, 2005.
act with Town of Palm Beach Sa ' • n
and requested trash pulls for
On March 31, 2005 at 9:20 a.m., I responded to the area of 358 El
Brillo W t with Town ohisliaeach sanitation employee,
Jeffrey . I observed IIIIIIII enter the driveway of 358 El
Brillo Way, collect the trash bags from Epstein's propert ace
the contents into an empty sanitation truck. I followed to a
nearby area, were he turned over seventeen white plastic trash bags,
which were collected from Epstein's property.
I took the trash bags to the
, an
29 05 at 8:15 p.
sanitation department were I sifted
'1 correspondence from Armani
, Jeffrey E. Epstein notepaper
important mes er addressed to
m. reference , U.S Airways

• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 32
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 ,  (Continued)
On March 31, 2005, Sgt .MI I   requested that I set up a
surveillance vehicle on El Brillo Way and conduct video surveillance
of the front exterior of Epstein's residence. At 3:00 p.m., I set up
a surveillance vehicle equipped with a video monitoring device. The
surveillance vehicle was parked on El Brillo Way approximately fifty
feet east of Epstein's driveway. The purpose of the video
surveillance was to gather investigative intelligence by monitoring
and recording all vehicle and pedestrian traffic entering and leaving
Epstein's property.
The video surveillance tapes were changed daily with a new Maxell
T-160 VHS tape. Video surveillance was established for Epstein s from
March 31, 2005 through April 05, 2005. On April 05, 2005, video
e
surveillaniss concluded. I reviewed the video tapes and advised
Detectiv the surveillance videos yielded no evidentiary value •
On April 01, 2005 at 9:30 a.m., I responded to the area of 358 El
o Way to meet with Town of Palm Beach sanitation employee,
. While parked in the area of 358 El Brillo Way waiting to
col h Pnetp.in e  trash, I observed a white female, who I recognized
as   fragmlaxalgrida driver's license photograph. I
made no contact with While parked in the area, I also
observed Epstein s GMC Yukon truck leave the property as well as other
vehicles arrive and park across the street from the property. The
occupants of these vehicles appeared to be housekeepers, maintenance
men, and gardeners.
I met with Tglia.if Palm Beach sanitation employee,
I observed enter the driveway of 358 El Br*
Way and collect the trash from Epstein s property. I followed
to a predetermined area at which time I collected the trash bags rom
the sanitation truck. I transported the trash bags to the sanitation
department, where I sifted through its contents. I collected mail
correspondences addressrA  Pn Jaffrav VE/Steil) antomntivo   records and
personal documents for I  and   as well as
Epst&tg.garapaper with the names and appointment times for
and No last names or other personal information was
written on the notepaper.
While sifting through Epstein s trash, I also collected a three-inch
purple finger size object, which had a broken end. The object
appeared to be a broke piece from a sexual toy similar to a (Cyclone
Vibrator) possibly used for rec atification. The sexual object
was photographed for Detective lilt, packaged in a biohazard evidence
bag (possible body fluids) and secured as investigative evidence. All
collected from Epstein s trash were turned over to Detective
for evidentiary purposes.
On April 05, 2005 at ill... m i.
sanitation employee,
driveway of 358 El Bri iiiy and
property. I followed to a
met with Town.aL.galm Beach
I observed enter the
collect the trash from Epstein s
predetermined area at which time I
• Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 33
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
collected the trash bags from the sanitation truck. I transported the
trash bags to the sanitation department, where I sifted through its
contents. I collected mail correspondences addressed to Jeffrey
Epstein as well as notepaper (Important Message) with names and
telephone numbers. The following are items collected from Epstein s
trash.
P. ( blank piece paper (
black paper
MSN Hotmail web page with email address ( .com)
The following items were documented for Detectivellilli s
investigation for evidentiary purposes.
On April 06, 08, 11, 12, 13, 15, 2005, at approximately 9:30 a.m, I
met with Town of Palm Beach sanitarinn emniflyees. I observed the
employee enter the driveway of I way and collect the trash
from Epstein's property. I followed the employee to a predetermined
area at which time I collected the trash bags from the sanitation
truck. I transported the trash bags to the sanitation department,
where I sifted through its contents.
All of the documents collected from Epstei itrash during my
assistance were turned over to Detective for evidentiary
purposes.
On June 14, 2005, Detective contacted me and advised
that the airplane belonging to Jeffrey Epstein of 358 El Brillo Way
was parked at the Palm Beach International Airport.
Detective requested that I begin trash pulls for the purpose of
gathering evidence and intelligence.
ct with Town of Palm Beach Sanitation Office Supervisor
and requested trash pulls for 358 El Brillo Way to begin
on June 15, 2005.
On June 15, 2005, I met with a sanitation employee. I observed the
employee enter the driveway of 358 El Brillo Way and collect the trash
from Epstein s property. I followed the employee to a predetermined
area at which time I collected the trash bags from the sanitation
truck. I transported the trash bags to the sanitation department,
where I sifted through its contents. The trash yielded negative
results and no evidence was collected.
No further trash was collected throughout the week due to the fact
that Epstein s security gates remained closed throughout the week;
therefore, the sanitation employees were unable to gain access onto
the property for collection of the trash.
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 34
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
All evidence and intelligence gathered by this officer has been turned
over to the detective bureau and no further action has been taken by
this officer.
End of supplement.
****************************NARRA ***************************
NA Reported By: 10/07/05
Entered By.: . 10/10/05
On October 4, 2005, I made telephone contact with
who had left several messages on voice mail. During the message, she
advised she was not completely truthful when we met in person but
would like to speak with me to advise what had happened. She further
advised she did not want to speak of this incident in front of her
imat • , I made telephone contact with
t . During a taped recorded
stated the fol : Approximately a year ago, statement,
when she was sixteen years of ag her to Jeff's house
twice. The first time she went, drove to the house.
They entered through the kitchen area where she w troduced to
and Jeff. She was taken upstairs to a bedroom by who set the
room up with a massage bed and brought out the oils to use. Jeff then
entered the rnn ing a towel. He lay on the table and picked out
a lnti
Both Jeffrey had a ver
at which time she left without being paid. She met with
who was sitting in the kitchen and told he ' o.
ekiteceived no money for that day. also
had told her if she was uncomfort le with what said that
was going on, to let him know and he'll stop. She knew that the more
you do the more you are paid.
Several advised she agreed to be
time by Once they arrived at the residence,
ta
sat
econd
e kitchen and took her upstairs to the master bedroom again.
set the room up with a massage bed and brought out the oils to
use. Jeff then entered the ring a towel. He lay on the table
and picked out a lotion for to rub on him. At
As was
came upset again and
told him she didn't want to be discontinued the
was paid $200.00. th downstairs where
waiting for her. She told she w
leave. said she never ret t se.
stated she is aware that her friend, was also at the
house and had a problem with Jeff. She provided a telephone number
• Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 35
Incident Report  Program: CMIS301L
Case No. : 1-05-000368 (Continued)
for . The interview was concluded and the micro cassettes were
turn in as evidence.
On Octobeilill researched the incoming telephone umber that
had left a message. The telephone number,
was assigned to ATT Cingular Cellular service. I prepared a subpoena
request and faxed the request to the State Attorney s Office.
Information requested was subscriber information as well as all
incoming and outgoing calls for the months of September and October
2005. .
tat her residence in   Beac
. and I dr s  a  et with
and ' she resides in
h.
ter researche
agreed to algaal6with us in the kitchen area. During a sworn
taped statement, IIIIII stat I wing: On or about November
2004, she was approached by and asked if she wanted to
make money. She agreed and ld she would provide a massage to
wealthy man in Palm Beach. Milli picked her up and drove her to a
house in Palm Beach. She was brripechl- inrn rha kitc o
house. She further stated that I' ) and (II)
went with them. They were brought int itchen where she was
introduced to Jeff and other females. stated she was
introduced to a helper of Jeff; the fema e was described as white
female (unknown n with blond hair. She stated that the assistant
was familiar with . The assist up the massage table and
put out lotions to be used. She told Jeff would available in a
minute. Jeff entered the room wearing on y a towel. Jeff on the
e table and sicked a lotion to rub on his thi•hs and
an• remove• imse rom e e. a wa over o w e e e
shower was and opened the glass door. Shil ed as he was taking a
shower in her direct view. When I asked how old she was when
this occurred, she stated glagmlaid just turned seventeen. At the
conclusion of the shower, IIIIII was paid either $350.00 or $400.00.
She stated she wasn't sure, biamkagws it was close to $400.00. At the
conclusion of the interview, IIIIII stated she never returned to
provide a massage for Jeff. She advised she was ashamed and
uncomfortable with the situation.
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
e area and responded to the
and all the ab  vp-mAntinni.d girls had
attended. I met with School Police Officer,  T
T was lnoking for a previous  qturient who attended
I inquired about  h I further explained
that I was working a case in which most of the girls I hav
interviewed are eithe
one as wel
and found

Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 36
Program: CMS301L
Case No. . 1-05-000368
and I then 1
School where
frontinnrsd)
elenlained
and turned on soft music.
room wearing only a towel. J
his legs, under hi tocks,
get comfortable. advisee did not remove her clothes. She
was wearing tight jeans and a cropped tank top exposing belly
area. During the massage
s or victims and felt that may be
researched his previous student records
She attended the same year and graduated
in the same  as the other girls. I was provided the last known
address of .
At approximate) at
her residence, . As was
seventeen years of age, I had notified her mother, Mrs.
, that she would be interviewed reference an ongoing
investigation in Palm Beach. I assured her that her daughter was not
a suspect. I explained the possibility of ing either a witness
or victim. Mrs. advised she wanted I iii to coopera
minted to the interview. During a sworn taped statement,
stated the following: at the ag during the month of
September 200 e was approached by chance to
make money. was friends with the friends of and knew the
eople.
did for Jeff.
h previously told by her frimagg whs....
cal
and scheduled the appointment.
erson i to as IIIII
picked up and drove her
to Palm Beach to a street called Brillo Way. They drove to the end of
the street and entered a large drivew hey entered the kitchen
f the e and met with Jeff. ail" was introduced to Jeff.
led upstairs to the main bedroogimizad and set up the room
with a massage table and set- the oils. IIIIII dimmed the lights
exited the room and Jeff entered the
icked oils and instructed her to rub
and chest area. Jeff asked her to
I asked
difference between circumcised and not c'
knew and advised Jeff was circumcised.
massage and left the area. She met with
kitchen area and left the house.
if she knew the
i cised. She explained
llilli
as paid $200.00 for
who was waiting in
she
the
the
then explained she never provided another ag  Jeff. She
did however, go to the house with and ( ) as they
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 37
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  • 1-05-000368
iend of
went to work ff.
sat in the kitchen area wit to
that while they waited for the
them, as it was almost lunchtime. As
massage, they left the area. I asked
woul ected of her when she provided a massage.
yes, told her that a massage woyilgimlie expected
and possibly some touching involved. IIIII has no formal training in
providing massages.
laspoke about a third
drove an girl,
(Continued)
advised she was present when
She advi e lover and
wait for . advised
chef prepared lunch for
wa shed with the
if old what
e went to ' house.
is friend,
Jeff's house. stated she knew that had mad
providing girls for Jeff and she wanted to do the s
• the en ar e house and introduced
and took upstairs to bedroom.
advised she doesn t know wh
'
pened as did nom
what happened in the room. received $100.
going with her to J ouse and recommending
unable to remember s telephone number. The
concluded and we left the area.
Investigation Continues...
to
about
for
was
interview was
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 10/09/05
Entered By.: . 10/10/05
On October 6, 2005, Det. and I went to Lynn University located
in Boca Raton. We met with Dean of Students, Paul Turner. I
explained to Mr. Turner that we were invest" agile within the
Town of Palm Beach and felt that a s t, , may have
information. Turner confirmed that  is a student and currently
on the soccer team for Lynn University. She was in computer claim,
the time of our arrival. Turner sent a security guard to locate
in class aiiiiiing her to the office. Mr. Turner allowed us to
interview in an empty conference room.
At 11:45 am I met with and explained to her why we there
to interview here advised she was aware of the ongoing
igation. IIIII stated she had previously spoken with
who told e was interviewed by d i l
workg
eurin a sworn
taped statement, ted she knew that ed for
Jeff in Palm Beach. advised she has been there many times for
massages. le ad her if she had for raining in providing
massages, stated she did not. advised she was told what
was expected of her by providing massages and would have to remove
clothing but if she felt magamfortable just to say so and Jeff would
stop pushing the issue. IIIII began providing massages and advised
she kept her clothes on. She considered Jeff a pervert who kept
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 38
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
pushing to go further and further. explained she would keep
telling him she had a boyfriend and t t would not be right to her
bo friend.
Jeff would t
nally,
left
into
get away with more and more on each massage.
drove her to the house for the original massage.
her cell phone number and every time Jeff would come
would call her for an appointment. Each time she
went, would meet her at the kitchen door . She would bring
her upstairs and prepare the mass
I asked if he knew her real
age, stated Jeff didn t care. The most recent massage she
provided was on October 1, 2005. During the massage she asked Jeff if
she could borrow one of his vehicles to visit her family and boyfriend
in Orlando. Jeff had told she could borrow
was asked if he ever used a
vibrator on her. was aware of the vibrator but advised she
never would allow him to use the vibrator on her. She described the
vibrator as a large white vibrator with a huge head on the tip of the
vibrator. She sgagga he kept the vibrator in a closet near the
massage table. IIIII advised she had been doing the massage for
approximately two years, which meant she would have started doing
massages for Jeff at the age of sixteen.
stated she was contacted by on October 3, 2005. had
informed her that Jeff had rented her a nagMissan Sentii iiid she
should come by the house to informed she would l  it up. IIII
have the car for a month. stated Jeff knew her car was not
working properly and had mi appointments in the past because of
her car being inoperable. IA explained the car is currently parked
next to field. I asked her  if ¢he (WRY'  took any one to the
house.  explained she took  , a friend'of hers who
has returned to Orlando to at college. I asked she ever allowed
mit another female in the room. IIIII advised no one was bro • to the
room with her. At the conclusion of the interview, Det. and I
went to the a and located the Silver Nissan Sentra bearing
Florida tag . The vehicle is. registered to Dollar rent a car
out of the Palm Beach International Airport.
Talimnhnna remtact was made with
I explained to her that I was following up on this case
and provided a complete update on the case.
Investigation Continues.
the victim's mother, at
• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 39
Incident Report Program: CNIS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
**************************** N A R R A . **************************
NA Reported By: 1O/21/05
Entered By.: . 1O/21/05
On October 10 9009 at annroximately 2:30 p.m., I made tel ne
contact with I  . During a taped conversation,  was
told of an ongoing investigationii iwhich I felt she had information
pertaining to Jeffrey Epstein. explained she met Ep  en
just sixteen years of age. She was approached by
, a ' nd who also had previously gone to pnRrain's  house for
massages. advis.......was working at the Mall when
, told her that she would have to provide she was approached.
ssage to Epstein and she would have to perform this massage naked.
thought about the offer and stated she could make $200.00 for
minutes of work. She.agreed to perform the aaaaage and
set the appointment for her that same day. IIII reme
was a weekend as she only worked at the mall on th...lekends.
took her to ...house where she was introduced to J Epsteinis
took her upstairs to a master bedroom.
,
assistant.
explained that as she was walking up the stairs she observed several
'Iliographs of naked women along the walls and tables of the house.
further explained that she was brought into the bedroom where
prepared the room by setting up the massage table and provided
t e oils for her to rub on Epstein.
Epstein entered the room.and introduced elf. Epstein lay on the
table and told her to get comfortable. could remember if he
was naked or if he entered the room with a towel. stated she
stated she had been to his house undreds of times over a two-year
period. ...claimed to have made thousands of dollars during her
visits. stated she could not remember how many times exactly she
went to Epstein's home but said it was a lot.
became more upset, crying hysterically and stat
and instructed
could not ggatinue
and wanted some time to regain her composure. I explained to to
take her time. After taking several minutes to regain her composure I
• Date: 7/13/06 .PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Page: 40
Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
explained that I would travel to meet with her in person T felt she
had additional information to provide. met with Sgt.
explained the importance to meet with
agreed and made arraignments for Det.
in Jacksonville, Florida.
2005, at 4:10 p.
li d'wanted to have present for
support.
she wanted
fined to her that I did not have oblem as
she wanted
long as
present during the inte stated she
wanted her present. I explained that as was present she was
not allowed to comment or ',any questions during the interview. She
was only there to comfort should the interview upset her.
During a sworn taped statement, explained how everything b
She said she was brought through the kitchen area where she met
lob
for th ' st time. She was led to the master bedroom, Epstein s
room. explained that as she was walking up the stairs she
observe sever otographs of naked women along the walls and tables
of the house. further explained that she was brought into the
bedroom, where prepared the room by setting u e massage table
and provided the oils for her to rub on Epstein. explained she
remembered the steam room area, which contained two large showers.
Epstein entered the room from the steam room area and introduced
elf
person. Sgt.
and I to meet with
massage
was over. of the m e, 200.00.
The gwalk ether 'rs where and were
ywaiting. ell', stated received an unknown amount of money for
taking her to Epstein. Epstein instructed to leave her cellular
telephone number so that he could contact her when he is in town.
explained that she continued to go to Epstein s house and became
a regular at the house. She could not provide an exact number but
claimed she had been their hundreds of times. She claimed sexual
activities did not occur every time she was th
she went to dinners and parties with Epstein.
things began to escalate more than
included bringing in his assistant,
Epstein had purchased her from her family in Yugosl
bragged he biiiiht her into the United States to be
sex slave.
There were times
explained that
e encounters
explained
avia. Epstein
his Yuctoslavian
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 41
Program: CMS301L
Case 00368
Each time someth new was introduced additional
and offered for to allow the acts to happen.
exp acne• t at Epstein's penis was •e orme• exp acne• a
penis was oval shaped. She claimed when Epstein's penis was erect, it
was thick toward the bottom but was thin and small toward the head
portion. She called it egg-shaped.
her became a ri would arrive at the house a.. .alk herself
upstairs, where
continued that t xual encounters withl
and Epstein were wai
, Epstein and
would
advised one day, ( was unable to state and exagL date when
this incident occurred) , she came to the house after IIII had informed
her that Epstein had arrived. Sh rived at the house and went
upstairs to the advised she immediately removed
Epstein apologized or
actions and subsequently paid her a thousand dollars  for that
sh  rtly thereafter, Epstein gave
her personal use.
IS
visit
• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 42
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case • - -
provided name
Epstein's house.
v he anina to
girls that she knew of one to
provided the name of I  and feels she
the hnnRe to maGGage  Epstein. According to
asked if she had been recently cont d by anyone of the house,
ived an email from from
, which is her email account. The email was just
a e o, ow are you doing type of email. There had bee other
contact from the house. The interview was concluded and left the
area. The tapes and drawing were submitted into evidence.
Investigation continues...
**************************
NA Reported By: 11/01/05
Entered By.: 11/07/05
****************************NARRA
On October 12, 2005, Det.
and made telephone contact with
with us as we were in iando area.
her apartment. Det.
Ilitaped statement that nothing happened between her and Epstein.
appeared nervous during the interview. I assure ithat I
a spoken with other people who advised differently. stated
she only went a couple of times and provided a massage to Epstein.
t o was brought to the E ' ouse in March of 2005.
broughtliggLo work. has no formal training in
i llillproviding ing massages. 'III. stated s e provided a massage, fully
d for $200.00. As I sensed hesitancy in her answers, limit
if she had been contacted by anyone from the house.
stated she was interviewed already by an investigator for Epstein. He
met with her on October 8, 2005, at a Roadhouse in Orlando. He
identified himself as Paul and
for additional contact.
inaaired Alrut the police investigation
ft his telephone number I
provided no additional information, as it appeared her
number
were almost scripted. We left the area and returned to Palm
Beach Police Department.
Based on the information acquired during the interviews, a search
warrant was prepared for entry at the Epstein home. On October 18,
2005, I met with Judge Laura Johnson who reviewed the warrant request.
She found there was sufficient probable cause and signed the warrant
request. On October 20, 2005, at approximately 9:36 am, members of
the Palm Beach Police Investigations Unit executed the search warrant
at 358 El Bril Palm B Membeiiiii the I Dttions Unit
Capt
Det. ,
met.
Det. , the crime scene unit and myself
,
WigOrlando area
agreed to meet
rovided directions to
and I met with who stated, during a
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Page: 43
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
La usg. antarAA onto :the property, we encountered the house manager,
who was in the guest portion of the house. The
guesthouse s was made. I
rya onntart
ectio doors and no f
wit  nit: Date of Birth , Fl DL
, and informed him of the searc warrant for the
premises. The members of the Police Department entered the residence
and announced we had a search warrant. A safety searc e and
ited the home. I read the search warrant to as Mgr
videotaped the search warrant execution. Several interior
decorators were located on the property. I spoke with Mark Zeff, of
in New York. Mr. Zeff stated he is the designer for

Mr. Epstein's homes. He advised he was contacted in March of 2005 to
do a complete overhaul on the house. He advised he was on the phone
with Mr. Epstein when officers announced the search warrant. Mr.
Epstein was then made aware of the search warrant. Mr. Zeff advised,
his contact with Epstein is strictly business and he has nevi.
M essed Epstein with any girls except for his assistants, or
I then interviewed of
Mr. Estes stated he has worked for Zeff
he personally worked on the New York
Epstein. He has previously met with
assistants in New York and in Florida.
Epstein everywhere he goes.
in New York.
for seven years. He advised
Palm e for Mr.
and , Epstein's
Estes stated they travel with
St viewed   of
stated she just arrived from Scotland and has worked with Zeff
for only one month. She stated she has never met Epstein and has not
seen him. The interview was then concluded.
I then
Moh
of
City. stated he has been Epstein's Architect for seven
years. He further stated he deals " ein's assistants and
speaka 't ein on the phone. stated he mainly speaks
illi
, Epstein s main assistant, who travels with Epstein.
stated he only has contact with Epstein when his services
are needed.
At approximately 10:30 am, I was informed that the videotaping was
concluded. I entered the residence and located two covert (hidden)
cameras. The first camera was a covert wall clock in the garage area.
I traced the wire behind the clock and removed the RCA wire and
unplugged the camera. The other covert camera was located within a
desk clock beside Epstein's desk. I traced the wire behind the clock
and unplugged the RCA wire. I could not locate another camera. I
then began with the search of the residence for the specified
evidence.
My search consisted of the second floor. Det. and I began in
the master bedroom area where several items were located. They were
•  • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Page: 44
Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
marked to be retrieved by the evidence custodian. In the master desk
with Epstein's notepads  marked Jef in we locat
of transcript from   School for
. Also in the room, was the dresser armoire where we ocated a
bottle of peach flavored Joy Jelly (Sexual Lubricant). Additionally,
there were several photographs of young naked teenage girls within the
closet, which was consistent with what the witnesses said. The
massage table was also located within the master bedroom. Video tapes
were located beside the television, which were also collected. An
itemized list of the property and locations was prepared on the
property receipts. At approximately 2:55 pm, the house was secured;
the exit of the residence was videotaped. Upon our exit• of the
property, I encountered Atty. Guy Fronstein who advised he was
representing Mr. Epstein. He provided a business card and provided
his assistance with the investigation.
Due to Hurricane Wilma, which struck South Florida causing massive
power outages, the courthouse was closed due to the lack of power.
was previously told that the Chief Judge had extended the filing
deadlines due to the hurricane and the Courthouse being closed. On
October 27, and 28, 2005 the courthouse was closed and I could not
file the search warrant and inventory at the clerk's office. On
October 31, 2005, I responded to the courthouse and filed the
papekwork along with an order to seal, signed by Judge Johnson, to
deny any release of any paperwork on this case.
INV CONTINUES..
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 10/20/05
Entered By.: .
.
11/07/05
On October 20, 2005, a ximately 8:30 a.m., Thursday morning, I
was advised by Captain that a search warrant would be executed
and that I was to assemble the Crime Scene Investigative Team and
stand by the south ide of the  building ready to go. I designated
Evidence Specialist to handle the inventory return, the
documentation of the property receipts and the collectio Ing
of the evidence at the scene. I further instructed CSI , ID
Ila to accompany us and perform the role of photograp Ing t e
scene and e.. m e taken into custody by the affiant,
Detective
My responsibility was to go through from the reading of the warrant to
the final exit from the residence and perform a video recording of the
reading of the warrant, the initial walk through of the residence
showing the current condition and then finally a walk through of the
residence at the time of the police exit.
ted out towards the residence, which was located at
and arrived at approximately 9:33 a.m. The searci iiiii
conducted, items were collected by Evidence Specialists
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: • 45
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000 (Continued)
photographed by CSI and then videotaped by myself. T
was concluded at approximately 3:05 p.m. whereupon Detective
and I were the last two officers in the house. Upon securing the
residence with the gentleman who identified himself to
Detective as the lawyer for the defendant and he was informed
that the residence was secured and that copies of the inventory return
had been left on the first floor table of the personal assistant's
office.
Detective and I returned to Police Headquarters and secured
for the day.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 11/07/05
Entered By.: . 11/07/05
IIIIIII T AqiqTqrl  efective in the execution of
Way, Palm Beac , Florida, 33480.
On October 20, 2005,
a search warrant at
Upon the announcement of the search warrant, immediate contact was
made with three white males who came out of the hnugin nr at,  rounding
structures. Those males were identified as I  I, Daniel
Estes, and Mark Zeff. As other members of the police department
cleared the home, I kept watch over these three males. house
was cleared, those males were turned over to Detective
Detective and I were assigned to assist in the search of the
main house, the cabana and the servant's quarters. We started in the
garage. All areas of the garage were searched to include four
vehicles. These vehicles were three black Mercedes Benz cars
registered to Jeffrey Epstein. The fourth vehicle was a Harley
Davidson motorcycle, green in color, registered to Jeffrey Epstein.
Nothing was recovered from the garage.
A towel closet and pantry located off the kitchen were searched and
yielded negative results.
The kitchen was searched and taken into evidence was a phone message
book that was located near a house phone.
North of the kitchen was an office room which contained a computer.
The room had a closet that • d a locked gun locker. Ti m
combination was entered by in the presence of Sgt.
the safe was opened. Items were taken from the room. See the
completed property receipt for a detailed list.
and
A green bathroom located on the first floor was searched and nothing
was taken.
A closet located just west of the green bathroom was searched. Two
massage tables were located in the closet along with a photo of a nude
• • Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 46 Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued) female from the waist up. See the property receipt for details.
I searched two bedrooms and their adjoining bathrooms, which were located on the second floor on the East side of the 
house. In the Northeast bedroom closet I
found adult sex toys called Twin Torpedoes. Soap made in the shape of a penis and vagina were also found in these 
upstair bedrooms. See the property receipt for
details.
I searched the pool cabana located on the South side of the pool. Photos were taken from the wall. See the property 
receipt for details.
I assisted in the search of I  I living quarters. Numerous CD s along with a message book was seized. See the property 
receipt for details.
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported.By: 11/08/05 Entered By.: . 11/08/05
On November 1, 2005, I was contacted by Atty. Gus Fronstin, who advised he was willing to assist with the investigation.
Atty. Fronstin advised he would try to
have his client, Jeffrey Epstein available to be interviewed. I explained I would be interested in conducting an 
interview with his client as well as other
employees that are employed within the house. Atty. Fronstin advised he would return my call once he received 
confirmation on the interviews.
On November 6, 2005, I attempted contact with   at her residence. I left a business card for her to return my call. Upon
retur • olice department, I had
rer-iyind n ri-liephone call from . I returned her call at I I and spoke with e made arrangements to respond to the 
station to provi e an interview. At
approximately 3:30 pm, she arrived at the Palm Beach Police Station with her boyfrieni iii iir boyfriend was allowed to 
sit in the lobby area while Ms. was
interviewed.
I took Ms to the Detective Bureau Interview room. I closed the door for privacy and explained to her that I appreciated 
her coming to the police station for the
interview. During the sworn taped statement, she advised she was at Jeffrey Epstein s house o
pvitimately two months ago, she was approached by a girl,
( who was dating her roommate, to make some quick money. advised she was in need to make some quick cash to make the r
. She agreed to go to the house. She had been told by
e massage would have to be done in her underwear. She
walked into the kitchen area and took the stairs upstairs.
drove with her and brought her into the houseilliily advised
further stated she was brought into a master.bedroom area. She
advised she recalled seeing portraits of naked women throughout the
room. A massage table was already out near the sauna/shower area in
the master bedroom. Epstein entered the room wearing only a towel and
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 47
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Cont'
introduced himself as Jeff. advised she recalled she and
I
aske
no.
She and continued t ssage until
the last ten mils of the massage, Epstein, told to leave the
room so that could finish the massage.
if she had any formal massage training and she replied
got dressed and Epstein turned over onto his . Epstein then
on previ an• went into t ower area. go •resse
met with
provided
in the kitchen area. in came into the kitciii iii
for providi
$200.00 for b g and paid $200.00 to
massage. was told to leave ephone
number with, his assistant for future contact provided
her cellular telephone number for future contact. was asked
if she was recently contacted about this investigation by anyone from
the Epstein organization. She repli
work. She stair was called by
is
for her to to work
t e term used by to provide for Epstein. state
the massage in underwear. advised she decline , as she was not
comfortable in providing that type of work. The interview was
concluded and the videotape was placed into evidence.
Investigation Continues..
e was called but it was for
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 11/10/05
Entered By.: . 11/10/05
On November 7, 2005, I made telephone contact with o
advised she would be able to et with me at her home. Det.
veled to her home in Be ade contact with
Wit During a swot em stated she met
Jeffrey Epstein through woul approach females
who wished to work state she was asked to work for
him but declined. explained that work means give massages.
She was asked y formal training in p g massages to which
she said no. said she accompanied and other females
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 48
Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 inued)
who were taken to Epstein s house to provide massages.
•
further stated she had been to tiiiiiise app o es in
r  year $hp accompanied with
, the 14-year -old victim, and
Each time the girls were taken over they were previously told they
would have to provide a massage,  . It was also told that
should Epstein require them to do anything extra were not
table just to tell him and he would stop. stated
received $200.00 for each girl she brought over to massage
Jeffrey Epstein. When I asked which girl appeared to be the youngest,
she replied, the victim, as she stat as fifteen years old at
the most; she looked really young. further stated e e
she went to the house, she sat in thekitchen and waited with
•
until the massage was over. She further stated that the cook would
make lunch or a snack for them as they waited. I asked ' ere
was anything that caught her attention within the home.
stated there were a lot of naked girls in photographs throughout the
house. The interview was concluded and the tape was turned into
evidence.
Investigation Continues..
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 11/10/05
Entered By.: 11/10/05
Det. and I attempted contact with
Beach. I left my business card at her front door. Ms
returned my call and arranged a meeting with me at the Palm Beach
epartment for November 8, 2005. At approximately 2:00pm,
arrived at the Palm Beach Police Department. She was brought
into the interview room and the door was closed for privacy'. She was
told that I appreciated her coming to the police station for
questioning regarding an on going investigation. She was told that I
was investigating a crime involving Jeffrey Epstein and knew, based on
the investigation, that she had ers with him in the past.
During a sworn taped statement, stated she had met Epstein
mil
' timirs ago. She was first introduced to Epstein by
approached her about working for Epstein and
providimassage to him for $200.00. The arrangements were made
coullisake he day the arra Ne   m
took
ade
.
nements  P.
also attended
School and was familiar with Epstein.
recalled she was brought there and en through the
kitchen d
brought her upstairs as she obse
hi,' with an assistant and another
assistant.
several photographs of naked females throughout the house.
stated ' came in the room, wearing only a towel, and laid on the
table. stated he picked out the oils he wanted her and
requested she remove her clothing to provide the massage.
stated that on the first massage she provided she did not remove her
I
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 49
Program: CMS301L
Case No  00368
clothing.
Iiiiiii
stated she had returned sev
Each time she returned more things happened.
same thing would happen. Epstein would walk
we
(Continued)
es after that.
stated that the
Additionally she never looked blow
his waist.. She claimed that Epstein would convince her to remove her
clothes.
she provided a massage
formal training in providing a
two females during h 'sits
illifht a gir
School.
and
brought. Additionally, wa
very beginning. The interview wa
into evidence.
Investigation continues.. .
. Every time
ed she has no
brought
ges.
from
200.00 for eac girl s e
s given $200.00 for taking her in the
s concluded and the tape was placed
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 11/13/0S
Entered By.: . 11/14/05
MMIIMII II e po ice station
On November 8, 2005, I made tel e contact with IIM, W/F,
at her residence. responded to t
for an interview reference an ongoing investigation. At approximately
2:30 pm, she arrived at the Palm Beach Police Station and was brought
into the interview room for the interview. The door was closed for
privacy and she was told that I apprecisgaher cooperation in this
case. During a sworn taped statement, I'll§ stated she had met
Jeffrey Epstein approxi iiii yeiiligo. She was approached by a
subject known to her as . had her if she wanted
to make money provi g ein. had heard that
several girls from Schoo were doi is
making money. She agr d was taken to the house by
had introduced her to and Epstein and brought her upstairs to a
master bedroom and Master bathroom wh ia massage table was prepared
and the proper •' wer- en out. left the room and waited
downstairs for stated Epstein entered the room wearing a
once that occurr the massage was over. S e e t the whole
situation was weird but she ad d she was paid $200.00 for pilling
the massage. She also stated received $200.00 for bring to
Epstein.
stated she had gone a total of 15 times to his residence to
provide a massage and things had escalated from just providing a
• S Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 50
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No. . . .
ne occasion,
d)
received $350.00 for her massage m..Lasked her
if she had any formal training in providing massages, stated she
did not.
cont • to state on one oth- casion, Epstein introduced his
tant, , into the mas
wit
ed the last time she spoke with anyone at the Mc was
during the weekend of October 2 or 3, 2005. stated
she ha ple
and
Epstein house. She provided the
names o c (unknown last  nAmm.) Tt  bould
noted, had been previously identified as L  and had
been previously interviewed. The interview was concluded and the
videotape was placed into evidence via the locker system.
On November 9, 2005, Sgt and I traveled to
Florida in hopes to interview , the
former houseman of Epstein's home. As no one was home, a busi
n_ar_d was eft for him to return my call. to
in Miami in hopes to interview , a former
ouse man of Epstein. We did not locate them at home. I left a
business card for him to return my call.
traveled to Lynn University  Deallietudents, Mr.
wit We requested to speak with . was re
interviewed, as she still was i session of thiliiiral car that
Epstein had acquired for her. stated that, Epstein's
assistant, had called her on her cellu lar telephone and informed her
that rental was extended for her. stated she had paid an_
additional $625.00 for her to keep the rental an extra month.
was asked if she had any additiiiii icontact with either Epstein or
anyone from his organization. stated she did not, other than
the telephone informing her that she could keep the car for an
extra month. did not provide any additional information.
On November 10, 2005, at approximately 9:47 am, d
telephoned reference my business card found on his door.
stated he had worked with Epstein for approximately six months after
ilk Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEl l, Page: 51
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
the previous houseman left. stated that it was his
responsibility to keep the identity of the masseuses private. Mr.
ad a massage in the morning and one in the afternoon. Mr.
stated he would rather speak about this in private. He
e would come to the police station to speak with me.
stated he would return my call on Monday, November 14, 2005.
I then made telephone contact with . He advised he found
my card on his door an d to know what I needed to speak with him
about. I explained to that I wilamijaducting an investigation
on his former employer, Mr. Epstein. I'll'. stated he would return my
call shortly as he was in the middle of a project at his ho
received a telephone call from Attorn ld Morrell from

Mr. Morrell stated he represented Mr.  and did not want me
speaking with his client. I then made telephone contact with the
State Attorney s Office and confirmed that subpoenas would be issued
to the former employees to assist in the investigation.
I then made telephone contact with Attorney Guy Fronstin, attorney for
Mr. Epstein. I explained to Mr. Fronstin that I would like to speak
with Mr. Epstein. He stated Mr. Epstein is not in residence in
Florida at this time and would check with him to ascertain if he could
be here by Wednesday November 16, 2005 for an interview. Mr. Fronstin
stated he would return my call should Mr. Epstein decide to come in to
the police station for an interview.
Investigation continues.
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 11/15/05
Entered By.: 11/16/05
and I tr
and spoke with She was
o o e ongoing investigation involving Epstein. advised
she had gone to the house on several occasions. During a sworn taped
statement, she advised she start ' g to the house approxi
one ye nd was brought by (Unknown last name) .
stated ought her into the and she was introduced to a
master bedroom bathroom.
. ,
stated she met Jeffrey in the
girl name Once she brought her upstairs into a
bathroom. He lay on the table and picked the massage oils. She
Epstein removed himself from the massage table and paid her $300.00
for the massage.
st
six times.
notified by , Epstei ' 'stant, that Epstein was in town and
would like her to work. stated she returned to the house and
was again led upstairs by . She provided the massage, clothed.
had only been at the house approximately five or
said each time she went to the house she was
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 52
Program: CMS301L
Case . : 1-05-000368
advised it wasn't really weird until later on.
as e if she ever removed her clothing to provide a massa
wanted hen t
stated she was notified by
e to work. She
for her services.
ued)
She was paid $300.00
stated lilt last time she went to provide , she
was notified by to come to the house and work. stated
she was now dating her current boyfriend and did not feel comfortable
going. She recalled it was approximately January 2005. She said she
went, already thinking that this would be the last time. She went
upstairs and went into the master bathroom. She met with Epstein,
who was ' only a towel as he entered the room to lie on the
table. stated Epstein caught her looking at the clo
s
several occasions. Epstein asked her if she was in a
her boyfriend was in the car waiting for her. further
stated that Epstein got upset, as she wasn't enjoying the massage.
told him that she didn't want to continue and she would not be
Epstein told her to leave as she was ruining his massage. I
asked her if she had any contact with Epstein's or she
stated she received $200.00 from West--• in Beach and
Okeechobee Blvd as a Christmas gift. iced s e ad no
formal training in provide any massages. also stated she was
sixteen years old when she first went to Epstein's house.
At ' tely 4:22 pm, I made telephone contact with
at . She agreed to meet with me at a public place.
suggested she come to the police station for an interview. i did
not want to meet at the police station. I recommended we meet at the
Palm Beach Gardens Mall in the food court area. She agreed and an
appointment was made for November 15, 2005 at 5:00 pm at the food
court.
Investigations Continue.
**************************** N A R R A ***************.***********
NA Reported By: 11/16/05
Entered By.: 11/17/05
10/20/2005, I assisted executing a search warrant at
Way in the Town of Palm Beaciallifich County Florida under
the direction of affiant Detective
Date: 7/13/06 -1101 BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN,
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Case No • 1-05-000368
Page: 53
Program: CMS301L
(Continued)
Detective and I searched the pantry room that is west
next to the kitchen. This room had all white cabinets with a dark
grey and black counter top. We did not find anything in this room.
We searched the yellow and blue room that is west next to the
pantry room. This room had a very large statue of man with a bow.
Taken into evidence from this room were nine photographs in frames of
various women.
We searched the main entrance foyer that is to the north of the
yellow and blue room. This room contained two bamboo chairs and
ottomans with cushions. It also contained a round table with numerous
books.
We searched another blue room that is west of the foyer. This
room had a stereo system and book shelves that were from the floor to
the ceiling. Taken into evidence from this room were eight
photographs in frames of various women and/or Epstein, the owner of
the residence.
We searched the room to the west of the blue room that has
sliding glass doors that lead out to the pool. In this room in a
dresser were two DVD's and two VCR tapes. These items were taken into
evidence.
searched a 2004 black Chevy Suburb g Florida tag
, registered to Jeffrey Epstein DOB , which was located
co he east side of the driveway facing south. I found a Thrifty
rental agreement between the passenger  Qinnl- and rho  iddle
The name  on the rental agreement was   from
Palm Beach Garden  PlnrinA 3410. The phone number on the
rental agreement was I  The rented was a white
2005 Chrysler Sebring bearing Florida tag . The vehicle was
rented on 9/25/05 at 17:58 hours and was returned on 9/26/05 at 16:52
hours. T ur numbers of the credit card used are .
Detective found a piece of paper in the middle console that
sed the cash in here to fill up the tank and was signed by
ched the 2005 black Cadillac Escala aring Florida
tag , registered to Jeffrey Epstein dob , which was
locate on the west side of the driveway facing south. I did not find
anything in this vehicle.
All of the items that were taken into evidence were photographed
in the place they were located and then turned over to crime scene.
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 11/17/05
Entered By.: 11/17/05
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
401_ PALm BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN, Page: 54
Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368
needed to speak with her p
telephoned her father, Mr.
explained to him
I spoke with Mr.
to s ' h his daughter in reference to an ongoing investigation.
Iiiiiiii Mr. advised he had no problem with us speaking with his
daug ter.
(Continued)
n Nnvemher is 2nns nar, and
r We met with , a
seventeen-year old juvenile who was • chool this day due to a
cold from which she was suffering. was told that I needed to
speak with her in reference to an ongoing investigation involving a
subject she would know as Jeffrey Epstein. Prior to speaking with
her, I explained that because of the fact that she is a minor, I
o speaking with her. She
, on his cell phone and
and I were there to speak with her.
on the telephone and informed him I needed
During a sworn taped statement, stated she met Jeffrey
Epstein over  UP'Ar Ann  She was sixteen years of age and was
approached by  who informed her t he could make monies
providing a massage to Epstein for $200.00. ha rmed her
that she would have to ptovide this massage topless. de the
arrangements with Epste* his assistants and took to the
house. Dorschel stated nd she entered through a glass door
that led into a kitchen. took her upstairs, to a master bedroom
and master bathroom. She recalled the bathroom had a large pink
couch, sauna and mat h'
over ont
wit Epste n in t e
providing the massage.
received monies for the
Forty minut
and requested
e for
to the massage, Epstein turned
stairs in the kitchen . . sage.
got dressed and met
. She was paid $200.00 dol ifor
stated she was aware that also
same thing.
ecoilime she went to the house she was again approached by
as • e wanted to return to the house to provide
er massage; a greed and t ements wratiaade by
for her to return to the house. stated IIIII drove her
to t e house and knocked on the same glass door that leads to the
kitchen area. Tisere allowed entry into the house by one of the
staff members. led her upstairs to the master bedroom and
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENI III-
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Page: 55
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
master bathroom area.
(Continued)
left this time to do th
got dressed and met with who wa in the
itc en area. She received $200.00 for the massage. said
she' neve ed to the house and had no desire to return to the
house. was asked if she received any forme
training. She advised she had 1 training. was asked
if Epstein knew her real age. stated he knew as he asked her
questions about herself sirlanro no was aware she attended
and is still attending   School.
The interview was concluded. I suggest inform her parents
of what occurred at the Epstein house. stated she would tell
her father as he was unaware this had occurred. I left my business
card for any questions they may have. We left the area and returned
to the police station. The tape was placed into evidence.
Investigation Continues.
**************************** N A R R **************************
NA Reported By: 11/17/05
Entered By.: . 11/17/05
On November 15, 2005, Officer and I r  AAnol F^ *he Palm Beach
Gardens Mall food court s to meet with   At
approxi 5:10 p.m., arrived and met with us at the food
court. provided a sworn taped statement in which she stated
she had een at the Epstein house over fifty times. Sh going
to Epstein's house when she turned eighteen years was
asked if she knew of the on-going investigation. stated she
was aware there was an investigation as she had been told by other
girls that were interviewed. Additionally, she has had several
telephone conversations with Epstein's assistants as to what had been
going on during the investigation.
I asked how she was introduced to Epstein. stated she
did not want to disclose who brought her to the house but she would
this was done at Epstein's direction.
When I asked her if there had
been any vaginal intarnmuras with Rnetain ah, ctatad ahc Aid not have
stated not every time she went involved sexual favors.
Sometimes she would just talk with him and get paid. I asked
much she was paid each time she went to Epstein s residence.
stated she got paid $300.00 every time she went to the
told to bring other girls to him to provide massages.
stating that she does what she doeiiiiiidid not want to
anyone else to do what she does. stated she had
any formal training in providing massages.
I showed
position
a photo line up in which
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 56
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
respon other questions. When I asked her what happened at the
house, stated everything happened. It all beg  n with the
appened.
All
.th him.
She was
declined
introduce
never received
was placed in
'ately
She signed the photo line-up un•er
s photo as the person she identified. We then left the
mall and returned to the police station. The photo line up and tape
were placed in to evidence.
Investigation Continues. ..
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 11/29/05
Entered By.: . 12/01/05
On November 17, 2005, I received a phone message from Atty. Guy
Fronstin who advised to call his cellular phone reference his client
Jeffrey Epstein. I telephoned his cell phone and t a message for
him to return my call. I did not receive a call  on Thursday,
November 17, 2005. On Friday, November 18 2005, I retrieved another
voice mail from my work phone from Mr. Fronstin advising he would not
produce his client Jeff Epstein for any statement. Fronstin stated
he had spoken with ASA Belohlavisnd expressed Mr. Epstein has a
passion for massages. I called ASA Belohlavek and confirmed that
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT. Page: 57
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Fronstin had telephoned her reference this case. Although nothing was
discussed, Mr. Fronstin did advise her that Epstein is very passionate
about massages.
illiso sp Daliah Weiss reference the previous employees,
and . She advised that they had been served through
a subpoena process server. They were both scheduled to appear on
Monday November 21, 2005 at 12:00 p.m.
ovembsaa,aga5 I met with ASA Weiss, Atty. Donnie Murrell and
and at the State Attorney Office. ASA Weiss had
no ted a court report sent to take the statement of the

s. I spoke with , in the presence of her attorney,
Donnie Murrell. She advised she had worked for Epstein for eight
years, from the period of 1994 through 2002. She advised she had
never had any direct conversations with him. She stated it was her
husband who spoke directly with Epstein. Her work consisted of doing
house cleaning,
•
g and other preparations when Epstein would
arrive in town. stated the preparations consisted of preparing
the house and bathrooms for his arrival. She advised she did view
several masseuses that arrived at the house. She advised that two or
girls that arrived looked young in age. Mrs. did not know any
three girls would cpme during a day and provi assages. The
of the girls personally and were always different. She was told that
when Epstein was in residence he did not want to encounter the Alessis
during his stay in Palm Beach.
Murrell. Mr.
I then spoke will,.
stated that he was employed for eleven years with
in the presence of his attorney, Donnie
Mr. Epstein. He originally was hired as a part time employee and then
iiiiilup into a full time position. His duties included everything.
stated he was the house manager, driver and house maintenance
person. It was his responsibility to prepare t e for Epstein s
arrival. When asked about cooks or assistants, stated they
traveled with Epstein on his private plane. He reme ered dealing
with his girlfriend, Ms. Maxwell originally and then dealt with
Epstein directly.
d Mr.
stated Mr. Epstein had up to three massagaaaaay. Each
about massages that occurred within the home. Mr.
masseuse that visited the house was different. stated that
towards the end of his employment, seuses were younger and
younger. When asked how young, Mr. stated they appeared to be
sixteen or seventeen years of age at the most. The massages would
occur in Epstein's bedroom or bathroom. There were times he recalled
that he would set up the massage tables either in Epstein s bedroom or
in his bat. o I asked if there were things going on other than a
massage. stated that there were times towards the end of his
employment that he would have to wash off a massager/vibrator and a
long rubber penis, which were in the sink after the massage.
Additionally, he sta., bed would almost always have to be made
after the massage. was never privy to what went on during the
Date: 7/13/06 M BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENIl fr
Time: 9:27:55
Page: 58
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No - 1-05-000368 (Continued)
massages.
He was asked if he remembered any names of the girls that massaged
Epstein. He tried t er and was unable to provide any exact
names of any girls. was about any contact with anyone
from the Epstein organization. said he did speak with Mr.
Epstein shoiiii lifter my initial contact with him to find out what was
going on. also stated that approximately on November 11, 2005,
he was contacted by a private investigator from the Law Office of Roy
Black. The investigator had called hi et with him to ascertain
what he was going to tell the police. stated they met at the
Carrabba s Restaurant in Boynton Beach and ed the same
questions I was asking him. I informed Mr. and Mr. Morrell
that as this is an ongoing investigation and anything we discuss
should be confidential. They both acknowledged the fact that the
information would be kept confidential. It should be noted that a
court reporter was present during the interviews and would be
providing a copy of the statements to me when they become available
On November 21, 2005, I received a voice mail from Mr. Fronstin who
advised he would not be making Mr. Epstein available for any
statements. He did have some words that he wanted to relay on behalf
of Mr. Epstein. I telephoned his office and left a message for him to
return my call.
On November 29, 2005, I received a call back from Mr. Fronstin who
left a voice mail after hours on November 28, 2005, advising he would
return my call during normal business hours to speak with me reference
the case on November 29, 2005.
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 11/29/05
Entered By.: 12/01/05
On November 29, 2005, at approximately 2:30 p.m. I received a
telephone call on the department issued cell phone. Mr. Fronstin
stated he was calling to relay information that Mr. Epstein wished he
could relay. Mr. Fronstin stated that he would not allow Mr. Epstein
to speak with me at this time. He further stated that Mr. Epstein is
very passionate about massages. He continued that Mr. Epstein had
allegedly donated over $100,000 to the Ballet of Florida for massages.
The massages are therapeutic and spiritually sound for him that is
why he has had many massages. Mr. Fronstin stated he appreciated the
way the investigation has not been leaked out into the media. I
explained to Mr. Fronstin that it is as important to protect the
innocent if the allegations are not substantiated. Mr. Fronstin was
told of the allegations that the private investigators assigned to the
case have been portraying themselves as police officers.
Additionally, I explained that my cell phone had been called by the
private investigators. Mr. Fronstin advised he was not aware of that
and advised they were under the direction of Attorney Roy Black in
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN1 I Page: 59
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Miami. Mr Fronstin further stated Epstein had originally called Mr.
Dershorwitz in Boston, who recommended Roy Black in Miami, who asked

Mr. Fronstin to assist. I informed him that if and when any charges
would be presented I would notify him. The call was then terminated.
Investigation continues.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: • 12/15/05
Entered By.: . 12/16/05
A review of the telephone message books, which were obtained during
the search warrant, was conducted in which various messages from
different dates were made to Jeffrey Epstein. The telephone message
books have a duplicate copy (Carbon Copy) which, once a phone message
is written into the book, the top copy is then torn on the perforated
edge and the carbon copy is left in the book. First names of girls,
dates and telephone numbers were on the copy of the messages. I
recognized various numbers and names of girls that had already been
interviewed. The body of the messages was time of the day that they
called for confirmation of "work." Other names and telephone numbers
were located in which the body of the messages were, "I have gi
him" or "I have 2 girls for him." These messages were taken by
for Jeffrey Epstein. Based on the context of the body of the
messages, I requested subpoenas for subscriber information on the
telephone numbers and the time frame involved. Copies of the messages
were made for evidentiary purposes.
I obtained Royal Palm   School yearbooks for 2005, 2004 and

2003. I first reviewed the 2005 yearbook and loca na mnnt of rho
girls I had spoken with. Additionally, I located
Based on the corrected name spelling, I was able to 1- •er to her
residence in Lnwahatrhac3 ()T.) TIPOAMIlgir  8, 2005, De I
responded to   at
her home. She advised she is attending an• is
participating in the early release program so s e can ma ntain her
part time job. As she is still a minor, I left my business card to
have her mother return my call to request an interview with her
daughter. We then left the area.
I also had previo
telephone numbe
ed the telephone number for " " and
A subpoena had been issued for the
lephone numbe ered to
query of revealed
Det. and I attempted
and ' ently residing at
results. I left my business card on
call. We then responded to
I also attempted contact with

Mr. with negative results. I left my business card for him to
return my call.
Date:
i Time:
It
7/13/06 PA M BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEA I  Page: 60
9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS30lL
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
n nPOPMhAr a 7005, I received a telephone call from
's mother, who i e aware of the on going
investigation in Palm Beach. advised she was told of
everything that occurred at Epstein's house involving Epstein and his
staff. She advised she would allow me to question her daug out
what occurred an ooperate with the investigation.
provided me with cellular telephone number to schedule an
appointment for an official interview. I telephoned her cellular
telephone and made a tentative appointment for Monday,. December 12,
2005.
WMreceived a telephone call from , father of
, who stated he found the business card on his door. I
expla..that I was conducting an investigation and needed to speak
with as she m information that could assist in the
investigation. Mr.  stated that his daughter no longer resides
with him and has her own trailer in another trailer park. He advised
he would tell her to call me.
On December 12, 2005, due tn a  onnflirt  with schedules, arrangements
were made to meet with o• day, December 13, 2005
at 5:00 pm. On December and I traveled to
Loxahatchee et with During a sworn taped
statement, stated that when she was sixteen years nl e was
taken to Epstein's house to provide a massage
stated it was before Christmas last year when roached
her and asked if she needed to make money for Chris stated
she did and agreed to de a massage for money. made
arrangement ke I'll'. to the house and drove to the house
to "work." stated she could not remember the street name but
would be ab e to drive to the street. They drove to the last house on
the street and pulled in the last house on left side. They walked up
the driveway and entered through a side gate which led to a kitchen
door...) , knocked on the door and were encountered by an employee
who described as a "Spanish looking lady." They informed her
that they were expecte were then encountered by a white female
with long blond hair. was unable to remember the name of the
white female with blond hair but knew she was Epstein's assistant.
She was led upstairs by the white female who explained that there
would be lotions out already and Epstein would choose the lotion he
wanted her to use. She was led through a spiral staircase which led
to a master bedroom throom. The massage table was already set
up in the bathroom. described the bathroom as a large spacious
bathroo steam room and shower beside it with a sink to the
right. was introduced to Jeff who was on the phone when she
enteril.... eff was wearing a white towel and l is stomach so
that may massage his feet and calves. started the
massage with the massage oil Jeff chose and r e is feet
calves ......I got off the phone alagmrequested she massage his
well. began rubbirile III. and got to the small of his
During the rubbing of his Jeff asked her to get comfortable.
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
411  -PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN,
Incident Report
Page:
Program:
CMS301L
Case ed)
, Jeff asked her quetinnc Ahni
remembered telling him she attendedl
Sc ool. Jeff asked her if she was sexually active. Before
• answer, he also asked what sexual positions does she enjoy.
Jeff told her there was $200.00 dollars for her on the
resser within the master bathroom. Jeff also  her that there was
an additional $100.00 that was to be given to for bringing her
there to massage him. Jeff told her to leave her telephone number
with his assistant as he wanted to see her again. Jeff stated his
assistant would contact her to work again soon.
Mid her if she ever rec y formal massage training to which
stated she did not. stated it was the only time she
ever went to work for Jeff and knew  happened to her was wrong.
"stated she no longer speaks to because she was upset that
took her there. She further stated that she had never been
contacted for any additional work. The interview was terminated and
we left the area.
Investigation Continues. ..
**************************** N A R R A • **************************
NA Reported By: 12/18/05
Entered By.: 12/19/05
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENO Page: 62
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368 (Continued)
On 102005 at approx 0930hrs I assisted with the execution of a
search warrant at 358 El Brillo Ave, Palm Beach.
Initially I was assigned to enter the residence and conduct a
sweep e premises for safety purposes. I then accompanied CSEU
tech while she photographed the exterior of the house. Once
this was ciiiiiie I was assigned to search certain areas of the house
with Det. as part of the search warrant.
We began in the garage, searching three Mercedes Benz vehicles, a
Harley Davidson motorcycle and adjacent closets in the garage.
Nothing of evidentiary value was located.
we then searched two closets off the kitchen area on the east
side. These can best be described as pantry or storage closets.
Nothing of evidentiary value was obtained.
A small office with adjoining bath was then searched. In the bath
area I located a phone message book with recent messages. This item
was seized as evidence. Please note this bath and shower area are not
used as designed but are storage areas containing a variety of items
to include a gun safe in the shower and assorted household items.
We then searched a bath area and closet at the base of the main
stairs in the foyer. Inside the closet two massage tables were
located as well as partial nude female photographs. These items were
later seized as evidence. Nothing of evidentiary value was noted in
the bathroom.
We then searched two bedrooms upstairs on the east side of the
residence. Located in the bath room of the south bedroom was penis
shaped soap. Located in the bedroom of the northern bedroom was penis
and vagina shaped soap as well as an adult sex toy. These items were
seized As evidence.
We then searched the pool cabana located in the south west corner
of the• property. Several photographs of nude females were seized as.
evidence.
w ssigne by

with a person I believe was
iii Mr. was in the residence at the
beginning o t e i search warrant. He was present during the warrant
service and subsequent search. I stood by with him until the search
was completed and I departed the residence. I had no conversation
with him regarding the reason for our presence.
Regarding seized evidence, all items were photographed in place
and then collected by CSEU personnel.
This concludes my involvement in this case.
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN1I 0 Page: 63
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: 0/0301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 12/21/05
Entered By.: 12/21/05
On Thursday, October 20, 2005 at approximately 0936 hours, I assisted
in the execution of a search warrant located at 358 El Brillo Way,
Palm Beach, Florid ' Jeffrey Epstein. I was instructed
by Case Agent Det. , to secure all computer and media
related material from the residence.
Upon my arrival I was directed by Det. to a room designated as
the Kitchen Staff Office. I observed a, Silver in color, CPU with the
left side cover removed, exposing the CPU s hardware sitting on floor
next to a glass type desk. The CPU had no discernable identifiers or
features indicating a make or model. This CPU was powered off with
the power cord not plugged in. The keyboard and mouse were atop the
CPU. It should be noted that the CPU w t connected to a monitor,
a l'
printer, or other media device. On the Panel of the CPU, I
observed an A/V card with RCA jacks attar e . This type of hardware
would allow audio and video to be downloaded onto the CPU s hard disk.
The ends of the RCA jacks were unattached at the time of the search
and no external camera was located within this room.
The CPU was located on the right side of a desk that held a flat panel
LCD screen. The desk also held another keyboard and mouse, indicative
of a second computer; however, no other computer was found. It
appeared as though a second computer had been recently removed as the
cables ends from the monitor, keyboard and mouse were in the same
area. A further search of the room revealed no media storage devices,
i.e. CD s, Floppy Disks, Zip Disks, etc. This type of media is
commonly stored in an area where computers are placed, yet no media
was found.
After completing a search of this room, I secured the CPU and turned
all items over to the Evidence Custodian for future forensic analysis
via a property receipt.
I was then directed by Det. to a room designated as the Garden
Room, where I observed a wooden desk facing west. The desk held a
flat screen LCD monitor, keyboard, mouse, media card reader and
printer; however, no CPU was located. All of the cables were removed
from an area where a computer had once been. A search of the desk
area revealed no signs of any media devices.
Det. directed me to a third location designated as the Cabana
room, which is detached from the residence and located just south of
the pool. In the South East corner of the room, I observed an office
type setting, with an L-shaped desk holding a flat screen LCD monitor,
keyboard, mouse and printer; however, no CPU was located. All of the
cables were removed from an area where a computer had once been. A
search of the desk area revealed no signs of any media devices.
Date: 7/13/06 ItiM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN4Ifr Page: 64
Time: 9:27:55 . Incident Report 'Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Det. directed me to a second detached structure located on the
South East corner of the property. This area of this structure was
assigned with single letters to identify a particular part of the
room. In the office area, designated as Room B, I observed a powered
on Dell Dimension 2350, attached to an LCD flat panel monitor. The
screen displayed an open Microsoft Internet Explorer browser with URL
address of http://home.bellsouth.net/. I observed no other active
windows in the Start panelgyadow and photographed screen. The power
cord was removed from the of the Dell CPU and I disconnected the
cable modem to prevent remote access. At that time, the Dell CPU,
marked with Serial Number 6WTVN21, was secured and turned over the
evidence custodian for future forensic analysis via property receipt.
I also located several media related items within Room B, which were
recorded onto a property receipt and turned over the Evidence
Custodians.
I then responded to a Bedroom designated as Room F, where I observed a
white in color CPU marked Premio. The Premio CPU was in a computer
desk which held a white CRT monitor, both of which were powered on.
The CRT monitor displayed a message from Norton Antivirus software,
warning of an expired subscription. I observed no other active
windows in. the Start pane ndow and photographed screen. I removed
the power cable from the of the Premio CPU and shutdown all other
media. The Premio CPU, marked with Serial Number 2000091078, was
secured and turned over the evidence custodian for future forensic
analysis via property receipt. I also located several media related
items within Room F, which were recorded onto a property receipt and
turned over the Evidence Custodians.
This concluded my participation in the search of the residence.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 12/21/05
Entered By.: • 12/21/05
On December 20, 2005, I contacted ASA
subpoena the Epstein former houseman,
who resides in Miami, had eluded
was not served the investigative
left as she is not available dur'
contact with State Attorney Inv
via telephone message.
the process servers previously and
subpoena. A telephone message was
wig 12/19/2005. I made
and requested the same
I then researched the victim's II cellular telephone subpoena data
which had been received from a previous subpolar, I analyzed
the records which depict several calls from  The
telephone calls start on February 6, 2005 at 12:49 pm.; the same day
which the victim and the victim's father stated the incident ccurred
at Epstein s prIncgo mho first incoming call was from
residence at I.  The second incoming call from
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPAR
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Case No • 1-0c-annien
cellular phone occurred at 1:02 pm.
Page:
Program:
CMS301L
(Continued)
The call durations
were one minute or less. The t e was within thirteen minutes
apart. It should be noted that s residence was in close
proximity to the v is. The next call occurred at 5:50 pm when the
victim telephoned s residence. Several calls were fter
the above mentioned calls both incoming and outgoing
Further analy ' ed no telephone calls to either cellular
telephone or residence were registered prior to February 6,
2005.
I also conducted an analysis on the telephone calls from
The subscriber information confirmed that the number is
registers to Paul A Lavery from Hialeah, Florida. The address was
crossed referenced to the Office of Kiraly and Riley Private
Investigators. I researched the web page www.rileykiraly.com which
also showed various cases in which they assisted. I also located
another web site under www.coralspringssparklandrotary.org in which

Mr. Riley attended a Miami Rotary meeting and confirmed Atty. Roy
Black is among his clientele.
elenhnnp ralla  revealed  T.A rv_had telephone contact with
and  either just after I attempted to
interview them, or just prior. A background was conducted on Lavery
which revealed he holds a current Private Investigator License. A
criminal arrest record revealed he had been previously arrested for
possession of cocaine and solicitation of prostitution.
I also researched the girls using www.myspace.com. This web site is a
new social networking service that allows members to create unique
personal profiles online in order to find and communicate with old and
new friends. The site allows one to establish your own myspace.com
page and decorate the page 1 '
, and
I received a Cingular Wireless packet which contained a CD which
nntained t  e results of the subpoena request for verbatim calls on
An analysis will be conducted in the near future on the
phone numbers called.
Investigation Continues.
****************************NARR A **************************
NA Reported By: 12/27/05
Entered By.: 12/29/05
Upon doing research on the message b
warrant T  located the identity
was registered to
seventeen years old and is attending the
vered in the search
" The telephone number
is
. I
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 66
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1  nq nnriqgp (Continued)
responded to   Lakes Boulevard, also known as th
ll. I located the Simon Youth Foundation. I located
inside the foundation and informed her that I was
investigati against Jeffrey Epstein and knew she had been at
the house. started to cry and advised she had put that part
of her life behind her. I explained that although she is seventeen
years old I needed to inform her parents that she would be
interviewed. She provided her home telephone number. I attempted
contact and left voice mail messages at the house to speak with her
parents.
De at her residence located
at . I attempted to interview her
about Jeffrey Epstein. She advised she is so in love with Jeff
Epstein and would do anything for him. She further explained that she
would not speak with us about him either negative or positive. She
asked us to leave her property. I informed her that although she did
not wish to speak with us, I had sufficient information at this point
in the investigation to know she was at Epstein's house and provided
girls to Epstein to work. I also explained that prior to rrival
illresidence I had telephone contact with he
, who was told she would be interviewed. is
currently seventeen years old and as a juvenile, parents notification
would be required. We then left the area and returned to the police
station.
mi t
the police station, I left another m sage for
's parents. .1 began an Cel
one. The telephone number is assrAe to
the financially responsible party is Jeffrey Epstein o III in New York City, New York. The time frame which was
subpoenaed was September 2005, through October 2005. There were
eighty seven pages of calls made either to the cell phone or from the
cell phone. The local (561) numbers were analyzed. A spread sheet
was prepared and placed into the attachment file of who was called.
The unknown numbers were researched using FoneFinder.com and subpoenas
were requested to determine subscriber information. This was done to
fy additional victims or witnesses. The analysis revealed that
had called the victim/witnesses frequently when Epstein was in
the Town of Palm Beach to "work." T firms what the girls
interviewed had previously stated. would notify them when
Epstein was in town and their willingness to "work." The CD was placed
into evidence.
Investigation Continues.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 1/03/06
Entered By.: 1/03/06
On December 29, 2005, I received a facsimile from National Compliance
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 67
Incident Report Program: CMIS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 tinned)
aL
Center from Cingular Wireless, ne number . This
was the tele one number for during the t me frame when
the victim, II, was brought to the Epstein house to "work." An
analysis of the phone records, of all incoming and oulaping calls,
showed that o ary 6, 2005, t
first called
y ictim, II, was brought
to , Epstein's assistant,
at t 12:50 pm (EST). The next call was made to Epstein's
house in Palm Bsph, at 12:52 pm (EST). The following call was made
to the victim, I., at 1:01 pm (EST) and at 1:02 pm (EST) . This
confirms the information provided by the victim and victim's father.
I photo copiediiii iiecords and enlarged the page 8 of 10 to show the
calls made by on February 6, 2005.
To this date, i have not heard from 's parents. I
will attempt to establish contact willikilliduring the evening hours.
I received a package from Atty. Guy Fronstin, which was hand
delivered at the police station. Within the package, was a letter
from Alan Del-tainwit7 am two wviur mvanara relpi profiles. The profiles
were that of I  and I H MySpace.com is a social
networking service that allows members to create unique personal
profiles . online in order to find and communicate with old and new
friends. This package was in response to a previous meeting in which

Mr. Dershowitz called to assist in the investigation in providing any
additional witnesses such as house employees who have been reluctant
to speak with law enforcement.
I reviewed the p s Mr. Der
log to be "
School, sends and receives messages from friends which contain
,"
enclosed. s
still attends
'tz
some profanity. Upon reviewing her friends' comments section from
Myspace, most of her good friends sent messages to establish contact
and invite her to go out.
I then reviewed 's web blog which
Dershowitz. Ms. designed he ii
states that her interests incl
I reviewed her packet in which er ove or er iv'.
• nd. She also describes with her boyfriend
The letter Mr. Dershowitz sent advised he was looking into the
allegation that one of the private investigators used by the private
attorneys of Epstein, attempted to impersonate or state that they were
police officers from Palm Beach. mr  nerghowitz advised that the
investigators used to interview I , had "quite a distinct
speech impediment", did not'claim to be nor did they impersonate
selves as a police officer. This package was sent to both ASA
Belohlavic and ASA Daliah Weiss at the State Attorney's Office.
was provided by Mr.
I made telephone contact with ASA Weis c she rerPiNrPri the
packique and reef:lest an interview with
and I . She advised she would assist in attempting to
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT. Page: 68
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
contact Mr Dershowitz.
On January 3, 2006, I received a telephone call from ASA IIIII who
informed me that she made telephone contact with Mr. Dershowitz. She
had requested the employees be available the week of January 3, 2006.
Mr. Dershowitz informed her that the assistants are out of the
country and would require additional time to locate them and make them
available.
Investigation Continues.
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 1/03/06
Entered By.: . 1/03/06
On Thursday, 03/31/05, I started conducting surveillance at 358 El
Brillo. is point I observed at 1155 hours, tima bearing
FL tag in Roadway, bearing FL tag in drive, Tan
Honda Civic bearing FL tag in Roadway, Black Chevy Suburban in
driveway and a Black Cad ade in driveway. At 1325 Hours I
observed Tan Honda Civic in roadway, Black Chevy Suburban in
drivigig nmelack Caddy Esca a e in drive and a White Kia ring FL
tag IIIIII. At 1615 hours I observed a Tan Honda Civic, in
roadway, Black Chevy Suburban ive, Black Caddy Escalade in
driveway and a White Kia car in roadway.
On Friday, 04/01/05, I continued surveillance at 358 Elmaga lio. At
1130 hours I observed a Tan Honda Civic bearing FL tag IIIIII in
roadway, Black Escalade in driveway and a Tan unknown make/model
bearing FL in roadway. At 1227 hours, I observed a Tan
Honda Civic in roadway, Black Caddy Escalade in driveway and a
Black Chevy SUV located be ' e Escalade. At 1345 hours, I
driveway. At 1558 hours, I observed a Tan Honda Civic in
in roadway and a Bla SUV in observed a Tan Honda Civic
roadway, Black Chevy SUV in driveway, Black Caddy Escalade in driveway
and a dark unknown model/make car parked in garage.
On Saturday, 04/02/05, I continued surveillance at 35 rillo. At
0713 hours, I observed a Red Explorer bearing FL tag in roadway
and a Black C scalade in driveway. At 0814 hours, I observed a
Red Explorer roadway, Black Caddy Escalade in driveway and a
T nda Civic At 0952 hours, I observed a Red Explorer
in roadway, Black Caddy Escalade in driveway, Tan Honda Civic
in roadway and also a Grey unknown make/model with a B.M in
trunk retrieving landscaping tools.
At 1155 hours, I observed a Grey Camaro bearing FL tag , parking
in the roadway in front of 358 El Brillo. A W/F, blond hair, teens to
early 20's, thin and tall wearing a white tank top and short blue jean
shorts, exited the vehicle walked to the rear of the house. I
also observed a Red Explorer in roadway, Tan Honda Civic
in roadway and a slack Caddy Escalade in driveway. At 1310 hours, I
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT. Page: 69
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
observed a Red Explorer W/F driver le e area, Tan subcompact on
roadway and a Red Neon bearing FL tag Then observed 3 W/Fs,
approximately 16 to 18 years of age jogging. All 3 Wiles ran into
the driveway. There were 2 with blond hair and one hair.
On Sunday, 04/03/05, I continued survei
in roadway an ck
at 358 El Brillo. At
0719 hours I observed a Tan Honda Civic
Caddy Escalade. At 0934 hours, I observe a Tan Honda Civic in
c
roadway and a Black Caddy Escalad veway. At 1057 hours I
observed only the Tan Honda Civic
• I
On Tuesday, 04/05/05, I continued sury ce at 358 El Brillo. At
1052 hours, I observed a &gag liiplorer in roadway, a Green
Exp earing FL tag IIIIII in roadw Grey Altima bearing FL
tag in roadway, White Ford Truck in roadway, Black
Mercedes in driveway being washed by a B M and an unknown dark car
parked in the garage. At 1059 hours a Blue Chevy Suburban drove to
the house of 358 El Brillo and n the driveway. At 1119 hours,
I observed the White Fort Truck leave the area and the drive
was the pool man.
At 1126 hours, I observed a Grey unknown make/model car park in
roadway. W/M got out of the car and walked to a house on the south
side of El Brillo. At 1406 hours, I observed a Red Explorer parked on
roadway and a large white box truck parked behind the surveillance
suburban.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 1/03/06
Entered By.: . 1/03/06
On 03/31/05, at approximately 1500 hours while conducting surveillance
at 358 El Brillo, I observed a Black Cadillac Escalade, unknown tag, a
...Chevrolet Suburban, unknown tag, a Black Mercedes 5600 FL tag
parked in the east dr' ext to the 3-car garage. There
was a Tan Honda Civic FL tag parked on the street in front of
the residence.
At approximately 1700 hours, I observed the Black Suburban, Black
Escalade, Black Mercedes and Tan Honda Civic parked in the same place.
At 1750 hours, there was no change in vehicles. At 1840 hours, I
observed the Black Escalade, Black and Black Mercedes along
with a Silver Hyundai Accent FL tag parked in the east
driveway and a Red Ford Explorer FL tag parked on the street in
front of the residence.
At 2000 hours, I observed the Black Escalade, Black Suburban parked in
the ease driveway and the Red Explorer and Tan Civic parked on the
street.
On Friday, 04/01/05 at approximately 1700 hours, I observed the Black
Date: 7/13/06 /IL BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN/IV Page: 70
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
Escalade and Black Suburban parked in the east driveway and the Tan
Honda Civic parked on the street in front of the residence. At 1820
hours, I observed the Su  and Civic in the same place and a Gold •
Chevrolet Camaro FL tag parked on the street in front of the
residence. At 2250 there was no change. At 2330, I observed the
Black Escalade parked in the driveway and the Red Explorer parked on
the street in front of the residence.
On Saturday, 04/02/05 at approximately 1700 hours, I observed a Black
Esc unknown tag, parked in the driveway and a Tan Honda Civic FL
tag parked in the street in front of the residence. At 1805
hours the Escal  Civic were in the same position and the Black
Mercedes FL tag was also parked in the east driveway. At 1920
hours the Escalade and Civic were the only vehicles and both were in
the same position. At 2030 hours and 2145 hours there were no
vehicles observed.
At 2115 hours, I rved a Black Mercedes, 4-door parked in the east
driveway FL tag . At 2300 hours, 2350 hours and 0045 hours, the
Black Mercedes was the only vehicle observed.
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 1/05/06
Entered By.: 1/05/06
I made contact with Mr. , father of ,
who was told that I wished to interview his daughter. Mr.
stated he was aware and had spoken with his daughter about the
incident. He stated that his daughter had previously told hi
she was hired to model lingerie at a Palm Beach mansion. Mr.
stated he k ing else about what she did when she went. to
"work." Mr. advised he would cooperate with the investigation
and make his daughter avail interviews. I asked if she was
available for an interview, stated she was not at home at the
mome informed him I would make contact with her at a later time.
Mr. expressed his interest in the resolution in this matter
as he stated this information has affected his daughter emotionally.
On January 4, 2005, I acquired the subpoenas from the State Attorney's
Office for Cingular Wireless, Metro PCS, Verizon, Bell South
f ations and Sprint for the unknown telephone numbers from
's cellular telephone. The subpoenas were sent to the
respective telephone carriers for subscriber information.
I received a telephone call from State Attorney's• • , • rmed
me that the former houseman for Jeffrey Epstein, ,
. nt at the State Attorney's Office for an interview.
was issued an investigative subpoena for an interview on the
on-goings at Epstein's house during his empl sponded to the
State Attorney's Offic ountered Mr. waiting in the
lobby. I brought Mr. to the interview room.
Date: 7/13/06 IL BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN4I 0
Incident Report Time: 9:27:55
Page: 71
Program: CMS301L
Case No 1-05-000368
During a sworn taped statement, Mr.
by Jeffrey Epstein for approximately six months. He was referred by
associates and his
(Continued)
stated he was employed
advised he had
very im to contact with Mr. Epstein. If needed to relay a
m  to Mr. Epstein, he would have to notify Epstein's secretary
assistant,  who would relay the message to Epstein.
" " i York City, who would then notify Epstein's York
Epstein id not want to see or hear the staff when he was in
residence.
I asked stein received many guests during his stay in
Palm Beac . advised he had many guests.
specifically about masseuses coming to the house. stated he
would have two massages a day. Epstein would have one massage in the
d one massage in the afternoon everyday he was in residence.
stated he woul informed to expect someone and make them
com orta e until either or Epstein would meet with them.
stated once the masseuses would arrive, he would allow them
entry into the kitchen area and offer theisiii
or Epste
ething to drink or eat.
They would then be encountered by either
would be taken upstairs to provide the massage. I asked if
IIIII
any of the masseuses appeared young in age. 'sed he didn't ask
their ages but felt they were very young. ated they ate
like his own daughter who is in high school. hey
would eat tons of cereal and drink milk all the time..
stated the girls that would come appeared to be too young to be
masseuses. He st ire under_Ertein'S direction, he delivered
a dozen roses to   School for one of the girls
that came to provide a massage. He knew the ' e still in high
school and were of high school age. I asked about the
massages. He felt there was a lot more going on than just massages.
He would clean Mr. Epstein's bedroom after the alleged massages and
would discover massager/vibrators and sex toys scattered on the floor.
He also said he would wipe down the vibrators and sex toys and put
them away in an armoire. He described the armoire as a small wood
armoire which was on the wall close to Epstein's bed.
Epstein ordered to go to the Dollar rent a car and rent a
car for the same girl he brought the roses to, he could drive
her self to Epstein's house without incident said the girl
always needed rides to and from the house. referred himself
as a "human ATM machine" and was ordered by Epstein to maintain a
minimum balance of $2,000 dollars on him at all times. When a girl
would come by the house and M n was either not in residence or
was not at home at the time, was to provide the girl
(masseuse) several hundred dollars for their time and to '
Epstein the amount they were given. Epstein also ordered to
Date: 7/13/06 PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENI lfr
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Page: 72
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
purchase several gif vide them as tips to the girls. I asked
what kind of gifts. stated he purchased IPODS, jewelry,
anything the girls wou want.
stated the amount of girls
approximately fift
seemed to know at
When asked to identi y these girls,
the moment but knew he wrote their names down on a journal he kept
during his employ with Mr. Epstein. He kept a journal in the event he
needed to explain either to Mr. Epstein or his assistants what was
done at the house or who visited the house as he stated he was
in-charge of Mr. Epstein's personal security while in Palm Beach. I
informed him I would need to view this journal to which he stated he
would research the book and contact me to provide the book. The
interview was concluded and left the area. I returned back to the
police station where the micro cassett ed into evidence. At
approximately. 7:20 pm, I was notified located the journal
and would call me on January 5, 2005 to provide the journal.
Investigation Continuesaa
came to the house was
knew each other and all
1 who Mr. Epstein was.
stated he could not at
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 1/09/06
Entered By.: . 1/10/06
On January 5, 2006, I attempted to meet with to
recover the folder or journal in which he kept the notes that were
given to him during his employ with Mr. Jeffrey Epstein. He kept this
folder to justify what he did during his employ should the need arise
to justify what occurred with the monies he had to keep or any
questions as to the petty cash he withdrew from the household account
fro . At approximately 10:00 pm, I attempted contact with
Mr. and discovered he was assisting his wife ace of
employment and would not be able to meet with me. Mr.
stated he would meet with me on January 6, 2006, in Broward County, in
the morning hours.
On January 6, approximately 9:00 am, I received a telephone
call from Mr. who advised he had the file in hand and would
be traveling n with me in Broward County. At 10:50
am, I met with at the parking lot of Bank of America
in Boca R to Road and Military Trail (known as the Polo
Center). produced a green folder which contained documents,
a note wit Mr. Ep tlinnaru wir4  direction t ' er
bucket of roses to  I School after  (III) high school drama °lie. Also in that same note was direction
to rent a car for  ( ) and direction to extend the rental
contract. I returned to the Palm Beach Police Station and placed the
folder into evidence.
I received a fax from Verizon from the subpoena request sent on
• • Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report
Page: 73
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
01-04-06, for telephone number
registered to Dr Perry Bard, from West
chiropractor and has an office located
Palm Beach. The cellular number is Dr
number.
Palm Ram oh flr
(Continued)
. The phone number is
RArd  is a
in West
Bard's personal cellular
n ,Tannary 9 900  , Det.' and I tray
in an attempt to locate , who had
been previously seen on the property and identified through her
Florida Drivers License and Florida license Plate. A business card
was left for her to return my W traveled o the Simon
Youth Foundation and located agreed to
speak with us and in a private room within the school provided us a
taped statement.
During the statement, advised that when she was fifteen or
,
sixteen yeami he en to Jeffrey Epstein's house by her
associate stated this occurred late May 2004
or early June 2004. She was told she could model lingerie for money
for a wealthy Palm Beacher. She remembered they traveled by yellow
cab from their residence in West Palm Beach to Epstein's house. She
remembered encountering Epstein at the front door during the evening
hours.
He introduced himself and brought them into the kitchen so that the
ould prepare somethi em to eat. After having a meal,
and Epstein brought upstairs to a master bedroom which
had a large bathroom. She observed a large style shower, sauna and
there was a large massage bed also in the bathroom. Epstein d a
room within the bathroom and came out wearing o wel.
said they would pAggiga a massage on his feet. asked why they
are doing this. IIIIII told her this was part of tine and told
her to rub his d calves. Epstein had told to get
comfortable. ued rubbing Epstein's eet. At
Epstein's dir
Epstein had to • er t at
there was two hundred dollars for her on the dresser. He told her
that she could not tell  what happened at the house or bad
things could happen. stated she went to Epstein's house three
Date: 7/13/06 Ilk BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 74
Time: • 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-00036 (Continued)
was very scared and felt very nervous. or four times total.
She knew because of Epstein's money he was powerful. After the
massage, Epstein ordered his houseman at the time to drive the girls
home. The employee was to drop off the girls at their house and watch
them go inside their house.
could not seer who the houseman was. She stated Epstein
and his assistant would call her at her father's house to
arrange for her to come and "work." She advised • e she returned
to the house, Epstein wo
She was paid $200.
went. Each time she went she was reminded not to
happened at the house and that she would be co,
began to purposely miss the calls when
call her. She once brought a friend,
work for Epstein. She was paid $200.00 for bringing
stated she no longer retuned to work for Epstein. Sheer  state
e wanted to notify the police of what happened at the house.
stated she was scared of what could have happened to her or
her family if she notified authorities.
On January 10, 2006, I received the results from t
BellSouth t o Mr.
number is assigned to Mr.
Beach Gardens. I also received t
confirmed the money order sent to
Mnal -4,iii in Maw York City. The "wire" was sent
in New York City on December 23, 2004 at 12:05 pm.
nt of $222.00 was charged to PrInewi  'S credit card so that
could receive $200.00 in Beach. The twenty-two
dollars was for processing and local fees to send ey via
Western Union. A copy of the check presented to
attached to the receipt of the wire. This confirmed w at
advised she received as ,a Christmas bonus from Epstein.
00 eac time s e
speak of what
ed again. She
or Epstein would
name. to
Investigation continues.
from
The
at er in Palm
estern Union which
from Jeffrey
y Jeffrey Epstein of
Sig
**************************** N A R R A ******************,r*********************
NA Reported By: 1/10/06
Entered By.: 1/10/06
and reviewed the Cingular
eaLs_Enrauhscribe
I received
a
to i.
Epstein of ty.
houseman/house mans Way in
The second number,  is assigned to
Wireless results from the
for telephone numbers
The first number,
f Jeffrey
is the current
3480.
of
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT• Page: 75
Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case  n • 1-AR-Anng6A
revealed she is a licensed Massag
conditional/active license number
. Research conducted on
iinued)
a Florida
had been previously
Requests for copies
of the reports involving the arrests were reques Palm
Beach County Sheriff's Office.
assigned to Thomas Rofrano of
Research on Mr. Rofrano, revealed that he is a F or ca C iropractic
Physician.
Vehicles that were previously documented on the
surveillance was being conducted were res
Chevrolet Camaro, bearing Florida license
property in which a young white female was seen
nducted which revea
La o
property while
I determined a tan
, was seen on the
entering the Epstein
at the vehicle is
h ers,
esi ng with her father in Lake
Worth. Research on revealed she was recently involved
in a traffic stop in Lake Clarke Shores in May 19, 2005. A request to
discover any information from the stop was requested.
I spoke with ASA Daliah Weiss who informed me that
will be available for an interview tomorrow at the State Attorney's
Office in West Palm Beach at 1:30 pm. I informed her that I would be
at her office for the interview.
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 1/23/06
Entered By.: • 1/23/06
was
licensed massage therapist hw o had previous y
property when physical surveillance was done.
on going investigation and I felt she may hay
to the case. During a sworn taped statement,
Epstein three r2InrC nan when mhnline  Maxwell approac ed her while she
was attending I   College to work around Epstein's
house. Maxwell had told her that they neede irls to work at
the house to answer phones and run errands. accepted the job
Palm Beach. an working at Epstein's house on El Bri
it was a part time job during the time she went to
College. She continued going to Epstein's ho
would be notified when Epstein would travel to Palm B,
advised she would be notified by Maxwell, Epstei
assistant, when he would travel to Palm Beach.
began providing massages
at
identified as a
on Epstein's
was told of the
ation pertaining
stated she met
Conti
and
what occurred during the
stated she
to Epstein before she became a massage
iving massages not o Epstein but to
his ass was asked about
massages.
,
state as she was twenty
Date: 7/13/06
Time: 9:27:55
4Il PALM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT ' ' Page: 76
Incident Report Program: CNIS301L
Case No
three years
between two
any trouble
I asked if
Epstein.
Epstein took
She received
1-05-000368 (Continued)
old when she met Epstein, anything that happened was
consenting adults. I explained to her that she.was not in
however a of this investig
ever received any gifts, or any gratuities from
advised aside from b  inn raid well, she advised
care of her tuition from   College.
a rental car for a week w en her scooter broke down.
Additionally she received other gifts from Epstein. Epstein also
recommended her to another client who resides at Breakers Row in Palm
Beach. The client she was referred to was "Glenn" unknown last name,
and his wife, who she provided a massages to. The statement was
concluded and placed into evidence upon our return to the Palm Beach
Police Department.
was also previously seen on the property when there wallitilical
While at the police station, I researched Florida tag which
being done at the properly. The vehicle • egistered
of Lake Worth, Florida. c r. and the
vehicle revealed that his- daughter, , ha een driving
the vehicle and was cited for unlawful speed n Lake Clark Sho,
ehicle is a tan, hpvrnier  Camaro, 2-do
, resides at
space page called
illirspace.com In her web page, shows various photos of
photographed at a beach. An interview is forthcoming.
th,
A review of the video disks which was extracted at the Palm Beach
County Sheriff's Office Computer Crime Unit revealed that only one
hidden camera was functional at the time. Several image
workyagat,  hig nffire  were seen. Additional footage of
and I'll. I was seen. There was other footage o females
seen. The identity of the females is unknown. at this time, until such
time as I meet with certain females to show the video footage to
that
'confide ct, Shin the video. At this time it appears
and are seen sitting with Epstein beside
his desk in the evening hours. Due to poor lighting, a direct
confirmation cannot be made at this time.
to
Inv. Continues.
Date: 7/13/06 IltM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Page: 77
Program: CNIS3'01L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
****************************NARRA *******************t******
NA Reported By: 1/30/06
Entered By.: 1/30/06
n Jnnnary 9S 9 M16,  Det
and met with
year, when she was seventeen
through her former roo
Epstein at the time. and
when they modeled. explained
made arrangements to
arrived and met Epstein andmiiilir
Beach Mall together and went shopping.
stated last
ge, met Jeffrey Epstein
was allegedly dating
once cohabitated together
called her on her telephone
dvised her that she was in Palm Beach and requested to se
at Ep 's house.
went to
advised that
m
and
she had received money from Epstein to go to the mall. They visited
Victoria's Secret and purciiiii undergarments from the store utilizing
given by Epstein. advised she purchased one item and
purchase various items. The money used to purchase the items
was the money given by Epstein.
continued shopping and having
and he has been paying all of her bills.
explained how she and Epsteinstated
they met in New York and had been dating ever
a day together.
been datiii miacl iller
claimed advised
since. Thrr miTter
returned to Epstein' ome and encountered Epstein. He had a brief
out her modeling career. He knew of her
modeling career from . He requested to see her modeling
olio and explained that he coul p her with modeling jobs.
had her book with her to show IIIII and showed the book to
• . He commented negatively about her photographs and portfolio.
felt uncomfortable with the comments made as she had been
working with other professional modeling companies who had offered her
work from her photographa ommapstein requested to see what was
purchased at the mall. IIIII took out the undergarments which were
purchased. She immediately showed Eiiiiin different s urchased.
Epstein then requested to view what purchased. was
reluctant to show the outfit however since it was Epstein's money that
purchased the ill...she pulled list of the bag. Epstein asked her
to try it on: looked at who told her "yeah, try it on."
Feeling compelled to try the undergarment outfit on; she went to
another room and put on the bra and panty set. She walked out to the
living room where they were sitting, and modeled the suit. She then
ack into the other room and chan ack into her clothes.
returned into the room an she would be going home. d,"
scheduledanother day for to return for massages with her.
stated within t ame week, she returned to meet with
and have a massage. had told her that she would be unable to
with her as she would be going on a bike ride with Epstein.
explained she could stay at the house and take advantage of the
massage.
conversation with
Date: 7/13/06 IMBEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT Page: 78
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case Mn  . . : 1-05-000368
stated she met with an unknown m
remembered that the door to t
but not locked. As the therapist was working
opened by Epstein and entered into the room.
conceal herself as Epst
session. E
eventually
prelim o
her
the house.
(Continued)
the
room was closed
, the door was
was trying to
s talking to her ab hischiropractic
her .
Epstein as e applied
shoulder and her waist. stated Epstein "popped"
emoved her sel
l
f the to le, got dressed and left
further state had attempted to call her
several occasions tomjamite her o Epstein's house to which
'm busy." IIIII advised she has not had contact with ei er
Jeffrey Epstein. It should be noted that her mother,
was present during the interview. The interview was
concluded and we thanked them her for their time.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 1/31/06
Entered By.: • 1/31/06
On 7=nnnrxt 97  00iiiiiiade telephone contact with I  ,
at  . is a licensed massa aplst who had
frequented the home of Jeffrey Epstein. ms. has been unable to
meet with me in Palm Beach County, and because s e lives and works in
Por cie, a telephone interview was conducted. I explained to
Ms. that there was an on going investigation involving Jeffrey
Epstein.
stated she knows Epstein and has been ed by him for
approximately three years. Epstein has paid erform Swedish
Massages (Deep Tissue) on him and other guests. explained that
approximately three year ago she met Ghislaine Maxwe and Jeffrey
Epstein through a mut end. Epstein and Maxwell were looking for
a massage therapist. stated si t time, she is notified
when Epstein is coming to Palm Beach. d she comes to his
house and provides the massage or massages explained she has
also massaged his guests and assistants. continued that she is
paid $100.00 and hour for the massage.
I asked if anything oc during the massage that would have
made her feel uncomfortable. stated she only provided massages
and that was it. She never was approached for anything else. I asked
if Epstein ever asked her to rub his chest she statue would not
rub his chest as that is not part of her massage. explained
that she was not Epstein's type. The girls she wou Epstein's
house were very thin, beautiful and without tattoos. explained
she has several tattoos that are visible. Maxwell andEpstein have
commented negatively about her tattoos previously when she has
provided massages.
Date: 7/13/06 AL BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT!' Page: 79
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
stated she only provided massages for Epstein an
and
'
associates  nothing happened during those massages. • stated
as she does Swedish style massages, the patient is usual y a sore after
the massages. I thanked her for her assistance and the interview was
concluded at this time.
I recei.vflA = fare -I-mile from T-Mobile
number   which is assign
Epstein, who resides in Lake Wo
dialed on several occasions by . A background on
indicated he has a va ' pilot license First Class for the
Southern FAA Region, has another historical FAA license for
Airline Transport Pilot.
Cell
to ep
telephone
, pilot for Mr.
one number  was
Investigation Continues.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 2/14/06
Entered By.: . 2/16/06
uary 3, 2006, I had made arrangements to meet with
on. At approximately
arrived at the police
she stated she met
1:00pm,
station.
Epstein when she turned eighteen years
Epstein's house to provid
May of 2005. She advised
to provide a massage for $200.00.
Epstein's house to provide a massage.
the house on man occasions durin• the
t the Palm Beac
and her friend,
During an interview with
if she ha
that she did not.
to the house to "work."
house. She advis
house to "w
her friend was still w r
lobby of the police station. I thanked for
cooperation and escorted her to the lobby.
old and was brought to
She advised this occurred on
informed her if she wanted
eed and was brought to
stated she to
massa•e sessions.
. I as e
al massage training to which she replied
then asked if she ever brought anyone
stated she brought two people to the
eceived money for bringing people
tated she brought a gir and
in t e
ime and her er
I asked Ms if I could speak with her about this investigation.
Date: 7/13/06 • AIM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENIII r
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Page: 80
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
brought her to the interview room and explained to her that I was
conducting an investigation on Jeffrey Epstein
information  ni2.1-r=lnlna t-o the investigat
herself as I   and resides in
advised approximately a year
provide a massage for money.
b
felt it was a quick way
to the house by
WWI
assistant.
It she may have
identified
, Florida. She
lite was broug t to Epstein's house to
stated she ded to make money and
some money. stated she was
and was introduced to Epstein and his
vi
She was pai er money an le the
area. advised it occurred one time and she n  returned to
Epstein's house. The interview was concluded and was escorted to
the lobby. •
I located a telephone number for ted to
contact his several occasions. I cal e and spoke
with Ms. who advised she would speak wit me in eerfield Beach
where she resides. Due to a scheduling conflict, we were unable to
meet. I informed her I would contact her to schedule another
appointment to speak with her about this investigation. I have
attempted to meet with her and make telephone contact with negative
results.
with
met with   at
was identified as Epstein's pilot. I spoke
who advised he has been employed with Epstein since 1991.
s both .planes for Epstein depending where he wants to o.
was asked about passengers in the plane he flie8.
stated unless Epstein flew to his island off of St Thomas,
be no way of knowing wli61,166.passengers were. I menti
to Ohio, where IIIIIII flew to Ohio to pick up
l  he ed flying on several occasions an
remember
know who the passengers are. When he prepares the passenger
mante and his assistants he knows by name,
and stated he would list either female or male
pass—eadisaingn the manifests only to keep a count on the passengers.
Mrs. EMI= came into the living room and recommended that her
husband consult with an attorney. Mr.
with the family airmrsirsita to inform him o t is questioning. I
explained to Mr. IIIIIII that he was not the suspect in thi
investigation and ceased all questions. Based on the fact
could not advise who passengers were in the plane, I then le e
area.
stated once he is in the cockpit,
agreed he would speak
t ere would
a recent
he does not
T . 4-+.11"/ " .-  to locate   at
I left my business card for her to re sula my call. On
February 14, 2006, at 12:06 pm, I received a call I= from Ms.
Date: 7/13/06 AIM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENAD Page: 81
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report ' Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-00036
on my  vnine mail  ms left her telephone number for a return
call   I e t her a message to return call.
Investigation Continues..
(Continued)
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 2/21/06
Entered By.: . 2/22/06
On February 15, 2006, I made telephone contact with who
provided dir  ntinna tn wharf T could locate her. Det I
ded to  in La k to meet with
Upon my arrival, I met with in the parking lot directly
e ind NAACO Auto Painting. She was a vised I was there to speak with
her about an iiiiing investigation that concerned Jeffrey Epstein in
Palm Beach. stated she knows Epstein very well and did not want
to speak with me about Mr. Epstein. She was very fond of Epstein and
did not want to speak with me about anything concerning Jeffrey
Epstein. I explained to her that she was seen at the house and I
would like to speak with her. She stated she knew there was an
investigation and that I had spoken with other  and therefore 1
should know what happen Epstein's house. ended
on and into her boyfriends business,
Det and I left the area and returned to the
po ice station.
Investigation continues.
**************************** N A R R A # 41 **************************
NA Reported By: MOWN 4/10/06
Entered By.: 4/10/06
A Grand Jury Session was requested during the month of February 2006,
in which all the girls that had been interviewed would have been
called to testify before the Grand Jury to seek an indictment against
Jeffrey Epstein. Due to subsequent meetings with the State Attorney's
Office and Defense Attorney Alan Dershowitz the Grand Jury was
postponed until a later time. Dershowitz had provided a package of
material on the main victims in this case in which they appear on
myspace.com and speak about alcohol use and some marijuana use. The
State Attorney's Office wanted time to review the material.
I requested additional subpoenas from the State Attorney's Office in
which I requested information from Dollar Rent a Car and Jet Aviation.
The inform • om Dollar Rent a Car was for the rented
vehicle by while under the employ of Epstein for one
of the victims. The other subpoena requested was for Jet Aviation for
dates and times when Epstein's planes were in Palm Beach County.
I continued to research other names that were acquired either from
interviews or intelligence gathered during the investigation. I
Date: 7/13/06 PIIM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT. '
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report
Page: 82
Program: CMS301L
Beach. I respo
. During the int
stated she knew I would be speaking with her. stated she
introduced to Epstein when she turned eighteen years old.
pa ghe  was sure of her age as it was her senior year in
School. She advised she was brought there to
ma e money and was told she would have to provide a massage to this
each guy. She remembered she met Epstein and his assistant
in itchen area. She stated she was to one of her
got ready for the massage. He exited his bathroom na edtaild
riends, . She stated she went upstairs with
ound. Epstein asked her if being naked offended her.
stated it made her able. Epstein then puts'.
towel and lay on the table. stated she rubbed his and
g s r e m
$200.00 for the massage and told her to leave the house.
P.Irp" rerurn  d to the house. She did advise of e she went with
however she waited in the car for she did not
want to go into the house. clusion of visit with
Epstein they left the area. stated she had heard fkom other
girls that have gone to the house that Epstein now required them to do
the massage naked and allow him to touch th ' *r. private areas
for monies. The interview was concluded as did not have any
other information to provide.
I then learned from the original victim, II, the defense attorney had
learned of her identity. I spoke with the father of the victim,, who
stated there has been a private investigator on his house
photographing his family and cha • • tors who come to the house.
He provided a Florida License ofs . This vehicle is registered
to Ivan Robles of West Palm Beach. Robles is a private investigator
intern who is licensed by the state. I informed the State Attorney's
Office of the above information.
I received the Grand Jury subpoenas to be delivered to three victims
for a Grand Jury session to be held on April 18, through April 20,
2006.
Investigation continues.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 4/14/06
Entered By.: 4/18/06.
The Grand Jury Subpoenas were personally served to the individuals
they were issued to. On April 5,m&006, at approximately 7:30 p.m., I
personally served the parents of II, who had informed me that the
private investigators were still photographing the family. On April
Date: 7/13/06 AlkM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENA Page: 83
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CIMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
in inns at approximately 2:30 p.m., I served II at her residence in
Beach. The subpoena was given to her mother, II .
I learned through one of the victims lIl that she was personally
contacted through amaource that has maintained contact with Epstein.
The source assured II she would receive monetary comp sation for her
assistance in not cooperating with law enforcement. II also stated
she was told, "Those who help him wile compensated and those who
hurt him will be dealt with." I told that tampering with a
witness/victim is an arrestable offense an ery serious. I asked her
who approached her during this encounter. originally was reluctant
to provide the name of the person who approached her to offer her not
to testify because she felt they were still friends.
On April 11, 2006, Det I traveled
--A -1-*- -4th the victim, identified
e, Florida
, W/F,
, as the person who approached her in Beach while
she was home during Spring Break in March 2006. o slated she
did not want to pursue the intimidation charges on II was
concerned that the defense attorney was given a copy o the report as
"srin things she had told me in confidence were repeated to her by
Prior to our departure, the victim was given a copy of her
subpoena for the Grand Jury which was scheduled to commence April 18,
2006.
Upon our return from Tallahassee, I notified the State Attorney's
Office of what was told to me. I also notified them that the
subpoenas were delivered to the witnesses and they would be calling
for arrangements for the date and time needed for the Grand Jury. I
spoke with ASA Weiss and informed her of the possible intimidation by
the defense.
On April 13, and April 14, 2006 I attempted contact on several
occasions with ASA Weiss and ASA Belohlavic to ascertain when the
victims needed to report for Grand Jury testimony. Messages were left
on their voicemail. On April 17, 2006, during the hours of 9:00 am
and 11:30 am, I again left messages for ASA Weiss and ASA Belohlavic
for either of them to return my call as I had not heard from the State
Attorney's Office as to the time and date of the Grand Jury.
At approximately 12:30 pm, I went to the State Attorney's Office and
located ASA Weiss and ASA Belohlavic in their offices. I entered ASA
Belohlavic's office who informed me that she was going to return my
call. She explained that an offer was made to the defense, Atty Guy
Fronstin and Atty Alan Dershowitz. The offer is 1 count of Agg
Assault with intent to commit a felony, five years probation, with
adjudication withheld. Epstein would have to submit to
psychiatric/sexual evaluation and no unsupervised visits with minors.
When asked about the all the other victims, ASAJelohlavic stated
that was the only offer made as to one victim, II. ASA Belohlavic
cell phone rang and went to voice mail. She checked her voice mail
and played the message on speaker. The caller identified himself as
Date: 7/13/06 •M BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENO Page: 84
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No  1-05-000368. (Continued)
Atty Guy Fronstin and acknowledged the deal made between them.
Fronstin stated in the message, he spoke with his client, Jeffrey
Epstein, and agreed to the deal. Fronstin asked to call off the grand
jury as they would accept this deal. Belohlavic stated a probable
cause would be needed to book Epstein in the county jail and would let
me know as to when it would be needed. I explained my disapproval of
the deal and not being consulted prior to the deal being offered.
However I expressed that was only my opinion and the final approval
would come from the Chief of Police. She explained to have Chief
Reiter call Barry Krisher about the deal. I left the area and
returned to the police station where I briefed the Chief about the
deal offered.
I checked my voice mail m ges and discovered a message from MI
stepmother for the victim °, She was calling because the State
Attorney's Office still had not returned any of her calls as to when
they are needed for this case. I then called ASA Belohlavic's office
and left messages for her to call the victims on this case and
explained to them what the State Attorney's Office had done.
On April 17,  'nog AnnrnX  nr  imately 4:30 pm, State Attorney
Investigator called to officially notify me of the
cancellation of the Grand Jury. He requested I contact the victims
that had been served to appear, to notify them of the cancellation. I
advised Valentine that as this Grand Jury session was called based on
the State Attorney's Office decision to have the victims heard by the
Grand Jury that I felt it was the States Attorney's Office
responsibility to contact the victims and advise them of the reason
they were no longer needed.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 5/04/06
Entered By.: . 5/04/06
As I had not received any contact from anyone at the State Attorney's
Office, on May 1, 2006, I prepared three arrest warrant requests and
submitted them to the State Attorney's Office. The packages
delivered to the Crimes against Children Unit in care of ASA
Belohlavek. Jeffrey Epstein's arrest warrant was requested for 4
counts of Unlawful Sexual activity wi r • 'nors and one count
of. Lewd and Lascivious Molestation. , Epstein's
assistant's, arrest warrant request was for 4 counts of Principal in
the 1st degree Unlawful Sexual activity with certain minors and one
e:Illel warranttll 1s
degree Lewd and
1::(71i1r1cciuta:cctnit ion. '
Acts on a victim under 16 years of age. The receipt of delivery was
signed and brought back to the records division at the police
department.
On May 3, 2006, at approximately 2:54 pm, I received a telephone call
from ASA Daliah Weiss on my cellular telephone. ASA Weiss advised she
Date: 7/13/06 tM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENJI, Page: 85
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMIS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
has been taken off the Jeffrey Epstein case because her husband is
employed with Attorney Jack Goldberger. Attorney Goldberger is the
attorney of record for Jeffrey Epstein. His previo ttorney, Guy
Fronstin, has been fired from representation. ASA Belohlavek has
been assigned the case. ASA Weiss stated she can no onger speak
about the Epstein case with me. I thanked her for her telephone call.
ASA Weiss further stated that ASA Belohlavek would be calling me.
****************************NA R RA **************************
NA Reported By: 5/15/06
Entered By.: 5/15/06
On May 10, 2006, information was received that Epstein's associate,
Leslie Wexner, The Limited Inc, CEO's, plane had arrived in West Palm
Beach, PBIA. The plane, a Gulfstream 4 bearing a N900LS registration,
was on the tarmac at Galaxy Aviation. As Epstein had recently
acquired the services of a new attorney, and the fact that Epstein's
house is currently under remodeling, it was believed that Epstein may
pnim nn-ch. I conducted physical surveillance at the residence,
Way. I observed a large construction crew conducting
remodeling at the house. The contractor, David Norr, was observed
driving a Ford E white in color. The vehicle has a Florida
registration of r left Epstein's house and traveled north
on County Road. Det and I conducted surveillance on Norr.
Norr traveled to several construction sites and chec ertain
jobs. Surveillance was discontinued on Norr and Det and I
traveled to Galaxy Aviation. I observed the white plane wi a blue
stripe along the body and tail of the plane; the tail number was
visible on the bottom of the tail, closer to the body of the plane.
We maintained visual surveillance on the plane until 4:57 p.m., when a
caravan of Cadillac Escalades drove onto the tarmac. We observed
several people exit the vehicles and discovered that they were part of
the executive team for Limited Inc. The executives were in Palm Beach
County for an executive meeting for the day. They arrived in Palm •
Beach County on May 9, 2006 at 9:30 pm and were scheduled to leave on
the 10th at 5:00 pm.
On May 12, 2006, I met with ASA Belohlavek at the State
Attorney's Office. She explained that her boss, Barry Krischer, was
requesting this case be taken to the Grand Jury again. I a o
her Ili milted arrest warrants for Jeffrey Epstein,
and . I asked that she either issue the warrants or
direct file, as so much time has elapsed since the original request to
the Grand Jury. I explained that the Palm Beach Police Department had
concluded the case in December of 2005 and has been waiting for the
case to go forward. Belohlavek stated the original offer was again
offered to the new defense attorney. She was waiting for their answer
by Friday May 19, 2006. She stated she would advise me of the answer.
**************************** N A R R A **************************
NA Reported By: 6/05/06
Date: 7/13/06 AIM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMEN. Page: 86
Time: 9:27:55 Incident Report Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368
Entered By.:
(Continued)
6/06/06
On May 22 2006, I received several phone calls throughout the day
from Mr. IL who st d he had been followed aggressively by a private
investigator. Mr. stated that as he drove to and from work and
running errands throughout the county, the same vehicle was behind him
ru  other vehicles off the road in an attempt not to lose sight of

Mr. vehicle.
I explained to him as Mr. Epstein had retained new legal council it
was possible it would be new private investigators following him to
observe his daily activities. mmLmialso explained to him that there was
a meeting scheduled with ASA IIII Belohlavek and Attorney Jack
Goldberger at Mr. Krischer's iiiice scheduled on June 1, 2006 at 9:00

am. I attempted to call ASA BeIohlavek to inform her of the
private investigators following Mr. however; she was on her vacation
during the week of May 22 through May 30 2006.
On May 23, 2006, I received other phone calls from Mr. and Mrs. I who
advised they were able to acquire the private investigators license
plate information. The subj t following them was again d/iving very
aggressively and caused Mrs. to run off the road. Mrs. M.
the vehicle is a green Chevy Monte Carlo bearing Florida tag
The vehicle is registered to Zachary Bechard of Jupiter Florid
Bechard is employed with Candor Investigations from Jupiter, Florida.
Bechard is a licensed Private Investigator in the state of Florida.
Since the overy of the threat made against one of the victims in
dthis case (mg  T roemoArad  subpoenas for all calls made to and
received from during the month of March 2006 for her
cell phone and home phone. I had confirmed with Florida State
University the exact dates of Spring Break for 2006.. The Spring Break
was from March 4, 2006 through March 12, 2006. I received a subpoena
from Sprint/Nextel with all calls made during the month of March 2006.
I reviewed the 989 calls made and re d during the month of March
2006. I observed on March 7, 2006, made and received thirty
five calls during that day.
Date
7-Mar -06
Time
11:03 AM
Seconds
In/Out
Outbound
To/From
561XXXX
7-Mar -06 11:16 AM 6 Inbound 561XXXX
7-Mar -06 11:22 AM 887.2 Inbound 561XXXX
7-Mar -06 11:37 AM 48 Outbound
7-Mar -06 11:39 AM 28.2 Inbound
7-Mar -06 12:02 PM 727.2 Inbound
The table reflects the date of the calls, time of day (EST) , duration
Date: 7/13/06 4ILM BEACH POLICE DEPARTMENT
Incident Report Time: 9:27:55
Page: 87
Program: CMS301L
Case No • 1-05-000368 (Continued)
of ca econds, inbound or outbound calls and ca ade to or
from e. On March 7, 2006, at 11:03 am, made a call
to the victim ■ which lasted 492 seconds (8 minutes and 2 seconds).
The victim then returned the call 16 am which lasted 6 seconds.
The victim then made contact with at 11:22 am for 877.2 seconds
(14 minutes and 6 seconds) . These sequences of calls were consistent
with what the victim had described to me on the date of the
intimidati I tely after speaking with the victim, makes
a call to , Epstein's assistant, which lasts for
forty-eight seconds. A call is then immediately received, a telephone
number regi oration affiliated with Jeffrey Epstein
located a in New York. An extensive computer check
revealed is a business address in which Epstein has
his corporations assigned to. Epstein had corporation attorney,
Darren Indyke, register the businesses and register himself as an
agent. I also observed Epstein has his El Zorro Ranch Corporation,
New York Strategy Group, Ghislaine Corporation, J Epstein and Company
and the Financial Strategy Group reg., to this same address.
Finally, a third call is received by at 12:02 pm from the same
corporate number which lasts 12 minutes and 1 second. It should be
noted that there is no further contact with either the victim during
the month of March or iii iii06. I also noted that there was no .
further contact with or Jeffrey Epstein during the
remainder of the month of March or April 2006.
On June 1, 2006, ASA Belohlavek telephoned me to inform me of the
meeting that occurred with Atty. Jack Goldberger and her reference
this case. She advised she would make her determination on whether to
file on this case or not by Monday June 5, 2006.
Inv Continues.
****************************NARRA **************************
NA Reported By: 7/12/06
Entered By.: . 7/12/06
On June 29, 2006, I had spoken to ASA Belohlavic who informed me
that the case would be sent to the Grand Jury for charges. She
informed me that the grand jury would convene on July 19, 2006 to hear
the Epstein case. Belohlavic stated State Attorney Barry Krisher made
the determination to go the Grand Jury to hear the case.
On July 12, 2006, I spoke with Mrs. IL mother of the victim, II, who
inquired about the status of the case. I explained to her that I was
told we would be going to the Grand Jury during the week of July 19,

2006. She stated she had not been contacted as of yet by the State
Attorney's Office for any information. I provided her with the
telephone numbers to the State Attorney's Office.
Investigation continues.. .
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * END OF REPORT * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
EFTA00582627 (Jmail)
 [academia] space station
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
Institute for Scientific Simulation
Infusing Enterprises with
Advanced Modeling & Simulation Technologies
David M. Russell, Ph.D.
ISS Business Presentation
Spring 2003
The ISS Mission
Mission Statement
"Improve Engineering Enterprises through the Use
of Advanced Modeling and Simulation Software"
Our Expertise
Modeling and Simulation Software Systems
Systems Engineering & Engineering Software
Artificial and Computational Intelligence
Intelligent Information Acquisition & Management
Consulting & Training in Advanced Technologies
ISS Senior Partners

• David M. Russell, • Leading Software Developer & Scientist
• F. Brett Berlin
Outstanding Computer Technologist

• Michael D. Williams,
Expert in Artificial Intelligence Software
• Christine Maxwell
Visionary Designer of Internet Technologies

• Arana Greenberg
Pioneer of New Media Technologies
ISS Corporate Partners
• Strategic Insight, Ltd.
Government Contractor in Executive Consulting

• CSC (Computer Sciences Corp.)
Leading Enterprise Systems Contractor
• SAIC (Science Applications Intl C
Leading Government Systems Integrator

• Launchspace, Inc.
Leading Group of Spacecraft Designers
• Aerospace Consulting Group, Inc.
Outstanding Talent Resource for the Aerospace Sciences
ISS Products Under Development

• ACES TM
Advanced Collaborative Engineering System
• Mentor -Based Software Systems
On-Demand Web-Based Training & Learning Tools

• Compound Media Interfaces
Integrated Multi -Media Interfaces for Software Tools
• Web-Based Simulators
Simulators Using Expert Systems and Knowledge Databases

• Intelligent Automation Tools
Automated Tool Interoperability Using Intelligent Agents
ACESTM
Advanced Collaborative Engineering System
** Features*

• Intelligent Modeling & Simulation System
• Universal Systems Application Interface
• Dynamic Objects
11

• Emergent Systems Behavior
• Advanced Performance Modeling
• Rich Systems Collaboration
ACESTM
Advanced Collaborative Engineering System
*" Benefits*'` N

• Integrates Enterprise Resources
• Automates Redundant Human Activities
• Captures Enterprise Intellectual Capital

• Improves the Systems Engineering Process
• Reduces Time to Market
• Reduces Program Costs
ACES Case Study
IMAGESAT: A Real-World Satellite Design Project

• Who: Naval Research Lab (NRL) and NASA Jet
Propulsion Laboratory (JPL)
• Project: Redesign Communications Satellite

• Objective: Perform Engineering Design Trade-Off
Studies with Fixed Cost, Mass, Power
Constraints
• Results: Matched NRL PDR Results after 5 and 1/2
Weeks (NRL - 18 Mo.) & Met JPL Constraints

• Outcome: NRL Ordered GENSAT Alpha for $150,000
ACES Opportunities
• On-Going Contract Business Development:
Department of Defense
U.S. Navy
U.S. Air Force
U.S. Intelligence Agencies (NSA, CIA, FBI, DIA)
NASA

• Near-Term Markets: Commercial Space & Aerospace
• Future Markets: Engineering Markets
Communications, Education, others
ISS Action Plan

• Current Focus:
- Build ISS Team & ISS Recognition
- Generate Early ISS Contract Business
- Develop ACESTM (Next Generation of GENSAT)

• Action Plan:
- Close Initial ISS Government Contract Business
- Complete Series B Financing
- Complete & Demonstrate ACES Prototype
EFTA00591691 (Jmail)
 [tech] Valar Ventures contract
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
126316015 v3
Table of Contents
Page
ARTICLE 1 NAME, PURPOSE AND OFFICES OF PARTNERSHIP
1.1 Name
1.2 Purpose
1.3 Principal Office  1
1.4 Registered Agent and Office 1
ARTICLE 2 TERM OF PARTNERSHIP 1
2.1 Term  1
2.2 Events Affecting a Member of the General Partner 2
2.3 Events Affecting a Limited Partner of the Partnership 2
2.4 Events Affecting the General Partner 2
ARTICLE 3 NAME AND ADMISSION OF PARTNERS 2
3.1 Name and Address 2
3.2 Admission of Additional Partners 2
3.3 Removal of the General Partner 3
ARTICLE 4 CAPITAL ACCOUNTS, CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS AND
NONCONTRIBUTING PARTNERS 4
4.1 Capital Accounts 4
4.2 Capital Contributions of the Limited Partners 4
4.3 Capital Contributions of the General Partner 6
4.4 Acquisition of an Additional Interest by the General Partner 6
4.5 Noncontributing Partners 6
4.6 Suspension Period  10
ARTICLE 5 PARTNERSHIP ALLOCATIONS 11
5.1 Allocation of Profit or Loss  11
5.2 Allocation of Ordinary Income and Ordinary Loss 13
5.3 Reallocation of Contingent Losses  13
5.4 Special Allocations  14
5.5 Regulatory Allocations  14
5.6 Income Tax Allocations  15
ARTICLE 6 MANAGEMENT FEE; PARTNERSHIP EXPENSES 15
6.1 Management Fee  15
6.2 Expenses 17
r.
126316015 v3
Table of Contents (Cont'd)
Page
ARTICLE 7 WITHDRAWALS BY AND DISTRIBUTIONS TO THE PARTNERS
18
7.1 Interest  18
7.2 Withdrawals by the Partners  18
7.3 Partners' Obligation to Repay or Restore  18
7.4 Mandatory Distributions  18
7.5 Discretionary Distributions and Rules Regarding Distributions  19
7.6 Withholding Obligations 20
ARTICLE 8 MANAGEMENT DUTIES AND RESTRICTIONS 21
8.1 Management 21
8.2 No Control by the Limited Partners; No Withdrawal 22
8.3 Existing Funds: Follow-On Funds; Parallel Funds 22
8.4 Investment Opportunities and Conflicts of Interest 23
ARTICLE 9 INVESTMENT REPRESENTATION AND TRANSFER OF
PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS 27
9.1 Investment Representation of the Limited Partners 27
9.2 Qualifications of the Limited Partners 28
9.3 Transfer by General Partner 28
9.4 Transfer by Limited Partner 28
9.5 Requirements for Transfer 28
9.6 Substitution as a Limited Partner 29
9.7 Expenses of Transfer 29
ARTICLE 10 DISSOLUTION AND LIQUIDATION OF THE PARTNERSHIP 30
10.1 Extension of Partnership Term 30
10.2 Early Termination of the Partnership 30
10.3 Winding Up Procedures 30
10.4 Payments in Liquidation 31
10.5 Return of Excess Distributions 31
ARTICLE 11 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING, REPORTS AND MEETINGS 33
11.1 Financial Accounting; Fiscal Year 33
11.2 Supervision: Inspection of Books 33
11.3 Quarterly Reports 33
176316015 v3
Table of Contents (Cont'd)
Page
I 1.4 Annual Report; Financial Statements of the Partnership 33
I 1.5 Website Based Reporting 33
I 1.6 Annual Meeting 34
I 1.7 Tax Returns 34
11.8 Tax Matters Partner 34
11.9 Partnership Funds 35
ARTICLE 12 VALUATION; ADVISORY COMMITTEE 35
12.1 Valuation 35
12.2 Advisory Committee 36
ARTICLE 13 PARTNERS SUBJECT TO SPECIAL REGULATION 36
13.1 ERISA Partners 36
13.2 Governmental Plan Partners 37
13.3 Private Foundation Partners 38
ARTICLE 14 CERTAIN DEFINITIONS 38
14.1 Accounting Period 38
14.2 Adjusted Asset Value 38
14.3 Adjusted Capital Account Balance 38
14.4 Affiliate 39
14.5 Capital Account 39
14.6 Capital Commitment; Committed Capital 39
14.7 Code 39
14.8 Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss 39
14.9 Reserved 39
14.10 Marketable; Marketable Securities; Marketability 39
14.11 Nonmarketable Securities 40
14.12 Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss 40
14.13 Partnership Percentage 40
14.14 Percentage in Interest; Majority in Interest 40
14.15 Prime Rate 40
14.16 Profit or Loss 40
14.17 Regulated Partner 41
126316015 v3
Table of Contents (Cont'd)
Page
14.18 Securities 41
14.19 Securities Act 41
14.20 Short-Term Securities 41
14.21 Thiel Persons 41
14.22 Treasury Regulations 41
ARTICLE 15 OTHER PROVISIONS 41
15.1 Governing Law 41
15.2 Limitation of Liability of the Limited Partners 41
15.3 Exculpation 42
15.4 Indemnification 43
15.5 Arbitration 44
15.6 Execution of Documents 45
15.7 Other Instruments and Acts 45
15.8 Binding Agreement 45
15.9 Notices; Electronic Transmission of Reports 45
15.10 Power of Attorney 45
15.11 Amendment 46
15.12 Entire Agreement 46
15.13 Titles; Subtitles 47
15.14 Partnership Name 47
15.15 Confidentiality 47
EXHIBIT A: Schedule of Partners   A-1
iv.
126316015 v3
INDEX OF DEFINITIONS
Term Paragraph
Accounting Period 14.1
Act Preamble
Adjusted Asset Value 14.2
Adjusted Capital Account Balance 14.3
Administrator 15.5(a)
Advisory Committee 12.2
Affected Parties 15.15(a)
Affiliate 14.4
Affiliates Fund 8.3(c)
Affiliated Party 8.4(b)
After-Tax Distribution Amount 10.5(b)
Agreement Preamble
Annual Tax Amount 7.4(a)
Arbitration 15.5(a)
Arbitrator 15.5(a)
Capital Account 14.5
Capital Commitment 14.6
Carried Interest Distributions 10.5(b)
Cashless Portion 4.3
Claim 15.5(a)
Code 14.7
Commencement Date 2.1
Commitment Period 4.2(a)
Committed Capital 14.6
Confidential Information 15.15(a)
Contingent Loss 5.3(a)
Deemed Gain 14.8
Deemed Loss 14.8
Default Notice 4.5(b)
Defaulting Limited Partner 4.5(b)
Deemed Contribution Shortfall 10.5(d)
DOL Regulations 4.2(b)
ERISA 4.2(b)
ERISA Partner 13.1(a)
Fee Adjustment 6.1(c)(ii)
First Allocation Hurdle 5.1(b)
General Partner Preamble
Governmental Plan Partner 13.2
Indemnified Parties 15.4
Late Admission Charge 3.2(c)
Limited Partners Preamble
Loss 14.16
Majority in Interest 14.14
Management Company 8.1
Management Fee 6.1(a)
Management Fee Percentage 6.1(b)
Managing Member 4.6(b)
v.
126316015 v3
Term Paragraph
Marketable 14.10
Marketable Securities 14.10
Marketability 14.10
Nonmarketable Securities 14.11
Optionees 4.5(b)(vii)
Optionor 4.5(b)(vii)
Ordinary Income 14.12
Ordinary Loss 14.12
Paragraph 10.5 Reapplication Amount 4.2(d)(iii)
Parallel Funds 8.3(c)
Partners 3.1
Partnership Preamble
Partnership Percentage 14.13
Percentage in Interest 14.14
Pooled Vehicle Partner 15.15(e)
Prime Rate 14.15
Prior Funds 8.3(a)(ii)
Private Foundation Partner 13.2
Profit 14.16
Regulated Partner 14.17
Regulatory Allocations 5.5(a)
Remaining Portion 4.5(b)(vii)(2)
Reporting Site 11.5
Second Allocation Hurdle 5.1(b)
Securities 14.18
Securities Act 14.19
Short-Term Securities 14.20
Side Letter 15.12
Special Purpose Investment Fund 8.4(a)
Subject Reports 11.5
Successor Fund 8.3(a)(iii)
Successor Fund Eligible Date 8.3(b)
Suspension Event 4.6(b)
Suspension Period 4.6(b)
Tax Payments 7.6(a)
Termination Date 2.1
Thiel Activities 15.3(d)
Thiel Persons 14.21
Treasury Regulations 14.22
Trigger Event 3.3(c)
UBTI 8.4(g)
VCOC 4.2(b)
VCOC Notice 4.2(b)
vi.
126316015 v3
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
This LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (the "Agreement") of VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
(the "Partnership") is made and entered into as of by and among VALAR VENTURES GP HI LLC, a
Delaware limited liability company (the "General Partner"), and each investor who is identified as a
limited partner on EXHIBIT A and who is admitted to the Partnership as of such date (the "Limited
Partners"), who hereby form the Partnership pursuant to the provisions of the Delaware Revised Uniform
Limited Partnership Act (the "Act"), as follows:
ARTICLE 1
NAME, PURPOSE AND OFFICES OF PARTNERSHIP
1.1 Name. The name of the Partnership is VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP. The affairs of the
Partnership shall be conducted under the Partnership name, or such other name as the General Partner may,
in its discretion, determine.

1.2 Purpose. The primary purpose of the Partnership is to provide a limited number of select
investors with the opportunity to realize long-term appreciation, generally from venture capital investments
in earlier-stage, high-growth technology companies as a result of direct, privately negotiated investments in
equity or equity-oriented securities of private and public companies. The general purposes of the
Partnership are to buy, sell, hold, and otherwise invest in Securities of every kind and nature and rights and
options with respect thereto, including, without limitation, stock, notes, bonds, debentures, and evidence of
indebtedness; to exercise all rights, powers, privileges, and other incidents of ownership or possession with
respect to Securities held or owned by the Partnership; to enter into, make, and perform all contracts and
other undertakings; and to engage in all activities and transactions as may be necessary, advisable, or
desirable to carry out the foregoing.

1.3 Principal Office. The principal office of the Partnership shall be at 915 Broadway, Suite
1101, New York, NY 10010, or such other place or places as the General Partner may from time to time
designate. The General Partner shall provide the Limited Partners with prompt written notice of any change
in the location of the Partnership's principal office.

1.4 Registered Agent and Office. The name of the registered agent for service of process of
the Partnership and the address of the Partnership's registered office in the State of Delaware shall be The
Corporation Trust Company, 1209 Orange Street, Wilmington, Delaware 19801, or such other agent or
office in the State of Delaware as the General Partner may from time to time designate.
ARTICLE 2
TERM OF PARTNERSHIP
2.1 Term. The term of the Partnership shall commence upon the date of the filing of the
Certificate of Limited Partnership of the Partnership with the office of the Secretary of State of the State of
Delaware. The term of the Partnership shall continue until the tenth anniversary of the date on which the
initial capital contribution is due (such date of the initial capital contribution being referred to herein as the
"Commencement Date" and such tenth anniversary being referred to as the "Termination Date"), unless
extended pursuant to paragraph 10.1 or sooner dissolved as provided in paragraph 10.2.
126316015 v3
2.2 Events Affecting a Member of the General Partner. Except as specifically provided in
paragraph 10.2, the death, bankruptcy, withdrawal, insanity, incompetency, temporary or permanent
incapacity, expulsion, removal, liquidation, dissolution, reorganization, merger, sale of all or substantially
all the stock or assets of, or other change in the ownership or nature of any member of the General Partner
shall not dissolve the Partnership.
2.3 Events Affecting a Limited Partner of the Partnership. The death, bankruptcy,
withdrawal, insanity, incompetency, temporary or permanent incapacity, liquidation, dissolution,
reorganization, merger, sale of all or substantially all the stock or assets of, or other change in the ownership
or nature of a Limited Partner shall not dissolve the Partnership.

2.4 Events Affecting the General Partner. Except as specifically provided in paragraph 10.2,
the withdrawal, bankruptcy, expulsion, resignation, removal, liquidation, dissolution, reorganization,
merger, sale of all or substantially all the stock or assets of, or other change in the ownership or nature of the
General Partner shall not constitute an "event of withdrawal" of the General Partner under the Act, and
upon the happening of any such event, the affairs of the Partnership shall be continued without dissolution
by the General Partner or any successor entity thereto.
ARTICLE 3
NAME AND ADMISSION OF PARTNERS
3.1 Name and Address. The name and address of the General Partner and each Limited
Partner (hereinafter the General Partner and the Limited Partners shall be referred to collectively as the
"Partners" and each individually as a "Partner"), the amount of such Partner's Capital Commitment to the
Partnership, and such Partner's Partnership Percentage are set forth on a separate and confidential EXHIBIT
A hereto, marked as EXHIBIT A•1 thru EXHIBIT Al (with a separate EXHIBIT A for each Partner). The
General Partner shall cause EXHIBIT A to be amended from time to time to reflect the admission of any new
Partner, the withdrawal or substitution of any Partner, the transfer of interests among Partners, receipt by
the Partnership of notice of any change of address of a Partner or the change in any Partner's Capital
Commitment or Partnership Percentage. An amended EXHIBIT A shall supersede any prior EXHIBIT A and
become a part of this Agreement. A copy of the most recent amended EXHIBIT A shall be kept on file at the
principal office of the Partnership.
3.2 Admission of Additional Partners.

(a) Except as provided in paragraphs 3.2(b), 4.5(b)(vii)(4) and 9.6, an additional
person may be admitted as a Partner only with the consent of the General Partner and Eighty Percent in
Interest of the Limited Partners.

(b) Notwithstanding subparagraph (a) above, additional persons may be admitted as
Limited Partners (or existing Limited Partners may increase their Capital Commitments) with the consent
of only the General Partner on or before the date that is six (6) months after the date hereof; provided that
the aggregate capital commitments to the Partnership and the Parallel Funds shall not exceed two hundred
and fifty million dollars ($250,000,000).

(c) Each additional person admitted as a Limited Partner subsequent to the date hereof
(and each existing Limited Partner that increases its Capital Commitment) shall (i) execute and deliver to
the Partnership a counterpart of this Agreement or otherwise take such actions as the General Partner shall
deem appropriate in order for such Limited Partner to become bound by the terms of this Agreement, (ii)
contribute that portion of its (or such) Capital Commitment which is equal to the portion of the respective
2.
126316015 v3
Capital Commitments contributed to date by the Partnership's previously admitted Limited Partners, and
(iii) pay to the Partnership a "Late Admission Charge" (which shall be deemed Ordinary Income of the
Partnership and not be treated as a capital contribution) equal to interest on the amount contributed by such
Partner pursuant to the preceding clause (ii) at an annual interest rate that is two hundred basis points (2.0%)
higher than the Prime Rate (determined as of the close of business on the date of such admission or
increase), compounded daily, from the date(s) that such Partner would have been required to contribute
such amount if it had been admitted (or had such increased Capital Commitment) at the initial closing of the
Partnership; provided that this clause (iii) shall not apply to a Limited Partner admitted to the Partnership
(or allowed to increase its Capital Commitment) within ninety (90) days from the Commencement Date.
Limited Partners admitted to the Partnership after the date hereof will not be entitled to share in or be
allocated any Ordinary Income (including, without limitation, Late Admission Charges) accruing on or
prior to their admission date. At the election of the General Partner, any Late Admission Charge owed to
the Partnership by a Limited Partner may be paid to the Partnership through an offsetting reduction in such
Limited Partner's Capital Account balance.

(d) Upon the admission of any additional Limited Partner pursuant to this paragraph
3.2, the General Partner may, in its sole discretion, make a special distribution of all or a portion of the
initial contribution of capital made by such additional Limited Partner. Such distribution shall be made to
all Partners in accordance with Partnership Percentages (as adjusted to reflect the admission of such
additional Limited Partner) and shall be deemed to be a return of capital to such Partners; provided,
however, that such Partners shall be deemed, for the purposes of paragraph 4.2, not to have contributed the
amount of such distribution, and the amounts of their respective unfunded Capital Commitments shall be
increased accordingly.
3.3 Removal of the General Partner.

(a) Immediately following a Trigger Event (as defined below), the General Partner
shall provide notice to the Limited Partners of the Trigger Event, and at the election of Two-Thirds in
Interest of the Limited Partners, pursuant to a vote occurring during any time during the one hundred and
eighty (180) day period following such notice to the Limited Partners, the General Partner may be removed
from its capacity as the general partner of the Partnership.

(b) In the event of the removal of the General Partner pursuant to paragraph 3.3(a), the
Limited Partners, acting by the same Percentage in Interest required of the vote to remove, shall be entitled
to appoint a replacement general partner on such economic terms and other terms as the replacement
general partner and a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners may agree. In such event: (i) the
removed General Partner shall not be entitled to retain any rights or powers of a general partner of the
Partnership and shall become a special limited partner of the Partnership with a continued interest in
allocations of Profit and Loss and distributions of Partnership cash and assets pursuant to Articles 5, 7 and
I() hereof; (ii) the removed General Partner shall no longer be required to make additional capital
contributions to the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 4.3 and the removed General Partner's Capital
Commitment shall be equal to the amount actually contributed pursuant to paragraph 4.3; (iii) the removed
General Partner shall be entitled to receive all allocations and distributions to which it would otherwise be
entitled to receive had it not been removed when, as and if such allocations and distributions are made, in
respect of all activities of and investments by the Partnership that occurred or were committed to by the
Partnership prior to the effective date of removal; provided, however, that the removed General Partner
shall be entitled to receive one hundred percent (100%) of all allocations and distributions in respect of its
capital contributions; (iv) the removed General Partner shall not be entitled to receive any payments of
management fee pursuant to paragraph 6.1 with respect to any period of time after the date of its removal; (v)
the removed General Partner and any Indemnified Party shall remain entitled to exculpation and
indemnification pursuant to paragraphs 15.3 and 15.4 with respect to any matter arising prior to or out of
3.
126316015 v3
events or circumstances existing prior to the General Partner's removal; and (vi) an interest in the
Partnership equal to the General Partner's unfunded Capital Commitment and the remaining carried interest
in the Partnership shall be transferred to the replacement general partner upon its admission to the
Partnership.

(c) For purposes of this paragraph 3.3, a "Trigger Event" shall have occurred if the
General Partner or any Managing Member is (i) found by a court of competent jurisdiction or arbitration
carried out pursuant to paragraph 15.5 to have committed (or enters a plea of nolo contendere to having
committed) embezzlement, fraud or any other act involving material improper personal benefit against the
Partnership or its assets, or (ii) is convicted of a violation of federal or state securities law or a felony (but
not including a felony involving the use of a motor vehicle) in a manner that had a material adverse effect
on the Partnership; provided, however, that no Trigger Event shall be deemed to have occurred if, in the
case of acts by a Managing Member, the offending individual is removed as a managing member of the
General Partner within thirty (30) days after the court judgment or arbitration decision, or conviction, which
would otherwise have given rise to a Trigger Event under this paragraph 3.3.

(d) Notwithstanding anything in paragraph 15.11 and in the event of any election
made to remove the General Partner, the Partners agree to amend this Agreement in good faith in order to
give effect to the foregoing provisions of this paragraph 3.3, including but not limited to revising Exhibit A
to reflect changes in the Partners' identities, Capital Commitments and Partnership Percentages.

(e) The General Partner shall promptly notify the Limited Partners if the General
Partner or any Managing Member is found to have committed (or enters a plea of nolo contendere to having
committed) embezzlement, fraud or any other act involving material improper personal benefit, or is
convicted of a violation of federal or state securities law or a felony, regardless of whether any such act
relates to the Partnership or not.
ARTICLE 4
CAPITAL ACCOUNTS, CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS
AND NONCONTRIBUTING PARTNERS
4.1 Capital Accounts. An individual Capital Account shall be maintained for each Partner.
4.2 Capital Contributions of the Limited Partners.

(a) Each Limited Partner shall contribute capital to the Partnership as requested by the
General Partner upon ten (10) business days' prior written notice (which such notice shall be given by
electronic mail or by a nationally recognized overnight courier, specifying next day delivery, in accordance
with paragraph 15.9); provided, that the initial capital contribution from each Limited Partner shall not be
due earlier than January I, 2016. The General Partner may request capital contributions from the Limited
Partners, on the terms specified in this paragraph 4.2(a) or as altered under a Side Letter. Except as set forth
in paragraphs 3.2(c) and 4.2(b), each capital contribution shall be in accordance with Partnership
Percentages; provided, however, that the capital contributions from the Limited Partners may be adjusted
by the General Partner in good faith in order to account for the fact that no Management Fee is chargeable in
respect of the General Partner's interest in the Partnership. Notwithstanding anything in the foregoing to
the contrary, no Limited Partner shall be required to contribute any capital after the fifth anniversary of the
Commencement Date (the period between the Commencement Date and the fifth anniversary thereof being
referred to herein as the "Commitment Period"), except as may be necessary for (a) Partnership expenses,
including, but not limited to, payment of any Management Fee (as defined below) due to the General
Partner; (b) completion of transactions evidenced by a written terms sheet (or other similar statement of
4.
126316015 v3
intent to make an investment that has been executed by the Partnership) prior to the end of the Commitment
Period; (c) follow-on investments in the Securities of issuers in which the Partnership holds a pre-existing
interest as of the date of such proposed follow-on investment; and (d) fulfillment of such Limited Partner's
obligations pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(i). Further, each Limited Partner's obligation to contribute capital
shall also be subject to those limitations set forth in paragraph 4.6. Each capital contribution by any Limited
Partner shall be made in U.S. dollars and made in cash or by transfer of immediately -available funds.
(b) Notwithstanding paragraph 4.2(a), with respect to the Partnership's initial request
for capital contributions under this paragraph 4.2, in the event that the sum of the Capital Commitments of
all Limited Partners that are "benefit plan investors" is such as would make their "equity participation" in
the Partnership "significant," within the meaning of those terms under U.S. Department of Labor
Regulation § 2510.3-101, as modified by Section 3(42) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of
1974, as amended ("ERISA") (the "DOL Regulations"), then no such Limited Partner shall be required to
contribute capital to the Partnership pursuant to this Agreement until such time as the General Partner shall
have delivered to such Limited Partner an opinion of counsel (which opinion and counsel shall be
reasonably acceptable to the Limited Partner) to the effect that the Partnership's first portfolio company
investment (other than a short-term investment of funds pending long-term commitment) has qualified or
will qualify upon the funding of each Limited Partner's initial capital contribution as a "venture capital
investment" within the meaning of the DOL Regulations such that the Partnership will qualify as a "venture
capital operating company" (a "VCOC') within the meaning of the DOL Regulations (the "VCOC
Opinion"). In the event that such a Limited Partner has not received the VCOC Opinion prior to the date on
which any capital contribution would otherwise be due under paragraph 4.2(a), such Limited Partner shall
pay such capital contribution into an interest -bearing escrow account designated by the General Partner.
The terms of any such escrow account shall be determined by the General Partner in compliance with
ERISA (including the principles and conditions indicated in Dept. of Labor Adv. Op. 95-04A), to the extent
applicable. Upon delivery of the VCOC Opinion, all amounts in the escrow account shall be delivered to
the Partnership in fulfillment of such Limited Partner's then-outstanding obligations under paragraph
4.2(a).

(c) The General Partner may, in its sole discretion, return to the Partners all or a
portion of any capital contribution intended for a proposed investment which is not consummated as
anticipated pro raw in accordance with their respective capital contributions; provided, however, that such
returned capital shall be added back to unfunded Capital Commitments pro rata in accordance with the
percentages in which such returned capital was attributed to the Capital Commitments when such capital
was called and be subject to recall by the General Partner pursuant to this Article 4.

(d) (i) If, in the discretion of the General Partner, Partnership assets are
insufficient to fulfill any indemnification obligation of the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 15.4 prior to
the final liquidation of the Partnership, the General Partner may to the fullest extent permitted by applicable
law require each Partner to contribute capital to the Partnership in an amount up to such Partner's unfunded
Capital Commitment, if any.
If, in the discretion of the General Partner, Partnership assets remain
insufficient to fulfill any indemnification obligation of the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 15.4, and
following the contribution to the Partnership of the maximum amount then permitted by paragraph 4.2(d)(i),
the General Partner may recall distributions previously made to the Partners solely for the purpose of
fulfilling or satisfying such an obligation or liability. Such distributions shall be recalled from the Partners
in the same proportions as the expense (or loss) of the indemnity obligation giving rise to such
recontribution was allocated to the Partners pursuant to Article 5. In no event shall any Partner be required
to contribute capital pursuant to this paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) in an amount in excess of the lesser of (1) all
distributions previously received by the Partner from the Partnership or (2) twenty-five percent (25%) of
5.
126316015 v3
such Partner's Capital Commitment. In no event will the General Partner be permitted to call capital
pursuant to this paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) in connection with a certain distribution after the earlier of (A) the date
two (2) years after the Termination Date (or any subsequent date to which the Partnership term has
previously been extended pursuant to paragraph 10.1) and (B) the date three (3) years after the date of such
distribution.
(iii) In the event that the Partners are required to return distributions as
provided in paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) following the final liquidation of the Partnership, paragraph 10.5 shall be
reapplied to account for the associated indemnification expense and, to the extent that the General Partner
would have any additional obligation to return capital pursuant to paragraph 10.5 as a result of such
reapplication (the "Paragraph 10.5 Reapplication Amount"), the proportions in which the Partners bear
the return obligation pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) shall be appropriately adjusted by increasing the
General Partner's obligation to contribute capital to the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) by the
Paragraph 10.5 Reapplication Amount, and reducing the aggregate obligation of the Limited Partners to
contribute capital pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) by a like amount. For the purpose of this paragraph
4.2(d)(iii) only, the aggregate maximum amount that the General Partner may be required to return to the
Partnership pursuant to paragraph 10.5 shall not be limited to After-Tax Distribution Amount.
4.3 Capital Contributions of the General Partner. The General Partner and/or its
designated Affiliate shall contribute capital to the Partnership, and have a Capital Commitment, in an
amount equal to at least one percent (1%) of the aggregate Capital Commitments of all Partners, on the
same schedule and terms under which any Limited Partner makes a contribution. Further, the General
Partner or its Affiliates, or their respective members, may contribute additional capital to one or more
Parallel Funds. Each collective capital contribution to be made by the General Partner or its designated
Affiliate shall be reduced by eighty percent (80%) (such amount being the "Cashless Portion"), provided,
that the General Partner or its designated Affiliate may elect to contribute its respective portion of such
collective contribution obligation entirely in cash. Notwithstanding the preceding, for purposes of applying
all other provisions of this Agreement (other than this paragraph 4.3), the General Partner or its designated
Affiliate shall be treated as if it had made each capital contribution in full without reduction for any
Cashless Portion; provided, however, that the Capital Account of the General Partner or its designated
Affiliate shall not include any Cashless Portion. If a designated Affiliate of the General Partner makes the
Capital Commitment described in this paragraph 4.3, then the interest so held by the designated Affiliate
shall be a Limited Partner's interest and treated as an interest held by a Limited Partner for all purposes
under this Agreement.

4.4 Acquisition of an Additional Interest by the General Partner. In the event that the
General Partner or its designated Affiliate acquires or holds an additional interest in the Partnership with a
Capital Commitment that exceeds one percent (1%) of the aggregate Capital Commitments of all Partners
(pursuant to a transfer from another Limited Partner or otherwise), the General Partner shall have two (2)
Partnership Percentages and two (2) Capital Account balances for purposes of making Partnership
allocations (including any reallocation of Contingent Losses pursuant to paragraph 5.3), as if such
additional excess interest were held by a separate entity which is a Limited Partner, although for all other
purposes the General Partner shall have only one Capital Account.
4.5 Noncontributing Partners.

(a) The Partnership shall be entitled to enforce the obligations of each Limited Partner
to make the contributions to capital set forth in paragraph 4.2, and the Partnership shall have all remedies
available at law or in equity in the event any such contribution is not so made. If any legal proceedings
relating to the failure of a Limited Partner to make such a contribution are commenced, such Limited
6.
126316015 v3
Partner shall pay all costs and expenses incurred by the Partnership, including attorneys' fees and expenses,
in connection with such proceedings.
(b) Additionally, without in any way limiting any remedy which the Partnership may
pursue pursuant to paragraph 4.5(a), should any Limited Partner fail to make any of the capital
contributions required of it under this Agreement, such Limited Partner shall be in default. In the event of
such default, the General Partner may, in its sole discretion, elect to enforce one or more of the provisions of
this paragraph 4.5(b) in connection with such a default, to which each Limited Partner hereby expressly
consents, provided such default shall have continued uncured for ten (10) or more days after delivery of the
Default Notice described in the following sentence (after such ten (10)-day period, such Limited Partner
shall be deemed a "Defaulting Limited Partner"). The General Partner shall deliver written notice to such
Defaulting Limited Partner in the event that it determines to utilize one or more of the powers set forth in
this paragraph 4.5(b) (a "Default Notice"). If the default shall have continued uncured for ten (10) or more
days after delivery of the Default Notice, the Defaulting Limited Partner may not make any additional
contributions of capital against such Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Commitment (other than to fund
Management Fees and other expenses of the Partnership) without the written consent of the General Partner,
which consent may be granted or denied in the sole discretion of the General Partner. In enforcing any of
the following provisions of this paragraph 4.5(b) against a Defaulting Limited Partner, the General Partner
agrees that it shall use commercially reasonable efforts to enforce such provisions against such Defaulting
Limited Partner in a manner so as to prevent the other non-Defaulting Limited Partners from bearing a net
economic burden attributable to Management Fees that, absent such default, would be borne by the
Defaulting Limited Partner if the Defaulting Limited Partner were to retain its interest in the Partnership
and make capital contributions in respect thereof.

(i) The General Partner may waive, in whole or in part, the requirement of
payment with respect to any due and unpaid capital contributions by a Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant
to this Agreement and reduce such Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Commitment accordingly.
The General Partner may extend the time of payment for a Defaulting
Limited Partner of any due and unpaid capital contributions by such Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to
this Agreement.
(iii) The General Partner may declare the entire amount of a Defaulting
Limited Partner's then unfunded Capital Commitment to be immediately due and payable.

(iv) On behalf of the Partnership, the General Partner may enforce, by
appropriate legal proceedings, the Defaulting Limited Partner's obligation to make payment on the amount
of any due and unpaid capital contributions by such Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to this Agreement
or to pay the entire amount of such Defaulting Limited Partner's then unfunded Capital Commitment.

(v) The Defaulting Limited Partner shall have no right to participate in any
vote or consent of the Partners required under this Agreement or permitted under the Act and the Capital
Commitment of such Defaulting Limited Partner shall not be included for purposes of calculating a
Majority in Interest or other Percentage in Interest of the Limited Partners for purposes of this Agreement.

(vi) Should the General Partner, in its sole discretion, elect to exercise the
provisions of this paragraph 4.5(b)(vi), such Defaulting Limited Partner shall pay all expenses to be
incurred or anticipated to be incurred by the Partnership in connection with the default and interest on the
amount of the contribution to the Partnership then due at the Prime Rate plus one hundred (100) basis points
per annum (or if less, the highest rate permitted by applicable law), such interest to accrue from the date the
contribution to the Partnership was required to be made pursuant to this Agreement until the date the
7.
126316015 v3
contribution is made by such Defaulting Limited Partner, unless such payment is waived by the General
Partner. The accrued interest shall be paid by the Defaulting Limited Partner to the Partnership upon
payment of such contribution. The accrued interest so paid shall not be treated as an additional contribution
to the capital of the Partnership, but shall be deemed to be income to the Partnership; provided, however,
that such income shall not be allocated to the Capital Account of the Defaulting Limited Partner. Until such
time as the unpaid contribution and accrued interest thereon shall have been paid by the Defaulting Limited
Partner, the General Partner may elect to withhold any or all distributions to be made to such Defaulting
Limited Partner pursuant to Article 7 or Article 10 and recover any such unpaid contribution and accrued
interest thereon by set off against any such distribution withheld.
(vii) Should the General Partner, in its sole discretion, elect to exercise the
provisions of this paragraph 4.5(b)(vii), the General Partner and the nondefaulting Limited Partners (the
"Optionees"), shall have the right and the option, but not the obligation, to acquire the Partnership interest
of the Defaulting Limited Partner (the "Optionor"), as follows:

(1) The General Partner shall notify the Optionees of the default
within twenty (20) days of the expiration of the ten (10) day notice period commencing upon delivery of the
Default Notice. Such notice shall advise each Optionee of the portion and the price of the Optionor's
interest available to it. The portion available to each Optionee shall be a fraction, the numerator of which is
its Capital Commitment and the denominator of which is the aggregate Capital Commitments of the
Optionees. The aggregate price for the Optionor's interest shall be the lesser of fifty percent (50%) of (A)
the amount of the Optionor's Capital Account calculated as of the due date of the additional contribution
and adjusted to reflect the allocation of the appropriate proportion of the Partnership's unrealized gains and
losses as of the due date of such defaulted contribution, and (B) the aggregate amount of the Optionor's
capital contributions actually made less any distributions (valued at their fair market value on the date of
distribution in accordance with paragraph 12.1) on or prior to such due date. The price for each Optionee
shall be prorated according to the portion of the Optionor's interest purchased by each such Optionee. The
option granted hereunder shall be exercisable at any time after the date thirty (30) days following the date of
the initial notice of default from the General Partner to the Optionor by delivery to the Optionor of a notice
of exercise of option together with a nonrecourse promissory note for the purchase price and a security
agreement in accordance with subparagraph (5) below, which notice and documents the General Partner
shall promptly forward to the Optionor.

(2) Should any Optionee not exercise its option within said thirty (30)
day period provided in subparagraph (1), the General Partner shall immediately notify the other Optionees
who have elected to exercise their option, which Optionees shall have the right and option ratably among
them to acquire the portion of the Optionor's interest not so acquired (the "Remaining Portion") within
thirty (30) days of the date of the notice specified in this subparagraph (2) on the same terms as provided in
subparagraph (1).

(3) Any amount of the Remaining Portion not acquired by the
Optionees pursuant to subparagraph (2) may be acquired by the General Partner within thirty (30) days of
the expiration of the thirty (30) day period specified in subparagraph (2) on the same terms as set forth in
subparagraph (1); provided, however, that the General Partner shall not be obligated to make the additional
contributions otherwise due from the Optionor with respect to the Remaining Portion so acquired.

(4) Any amount of the Remaining Portion not acquired by the
Optionees and the General Partner pursuant to subparagraphs (2) or (3) may, if the General Partner deems it
in the best interest of the Partnership, be sold by the General Partner to any other investor, on terms not
more favorable to such parties than those applicable to the Optionees' option, and upon the consent of the
8.
126316015 v3
General Partner, any such third party purchaser may become a Limited Partner to the extent of the interest
purchased hereunder.

(5) The price due from each of the General Partner and the Optionees
(and, if applicable, any third party purchaser pursuant to subparagraph (4)) shall be payable by a noninterest
bearing, nonrecourse promissory note (in such form as the General Partner shall designate) due upon final
liquidation of the Partnership. Each such note shall be secured by the portion of the Optionor's Partnership
interest so purchased by its maker pursuant to a security agreement in a form designated by the General
Partner and shall be enforceable by the Optionor only against such security.
(6) Upon exercise of any option hereunder, each Optionee (and, if
applicable, any third party purchaser pursuant to subparagraph (4)) shall be obligated (A) to contribute to
the Partnership that portion of the additional capital then due from the Optionor equal to the percentage of
the Optionor's interest purchased by such person and (B) except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (3),
to pay the same percentage of any further contributions otherwise due from such Optionor on the date such
contributions are otherwise due. Each person who purchases a portion of the Optionor's Partnership
interest shall be deemed to have acquired such portion as of the due date of the additional capital
contribution with respect to which the Optionor defaulted, and any distributions made after the due date on
account of the Optionor's interest shall be distributed among such purchasers (and, unless the entire interest
was purchased, the Optionor) in accordance with their ultimate respective interests in the Optionor's
interest. Distributions otherwise allocable to the Optionor under the preceding sentence shall first be used
to offset any defaulted contribution of the Optionor still due to the Partnership. Upon completion of any
transaction hereunder, the General Partner shall cause EXHIBIT A to be amended to reflect all necessary
changes resulting therefrom including, without limitation, admission of a purchaser as a Limited Partner,
and adjustment of Capital Account balances, Capital Commitment amounts and Partnership Percentages as
of the date of Optionor's default to reflect the acquisition from Optionor of the appropriate pro raw portion
of each such item (including, if applicable, the reduction of aggregate Capital Commitments and resulting
adjustment of Partnership Percentages in connection with any acquisition of any Remaining Portion by the
General Partner pursuant to subparagraph (3)). The purchase and transfer of the Partnership interest of the
Optionor shall occur automatically upon exercise by any Optionee or the General Partner of its option
hereunder, or by any third-party purchaser pursuant to subparagraph (4), without any action by Optionor.

(7) Notwithstanding the sale of any portion of an Optionor's interest
pursuant to this paragraph 4.5(b)(vii), such Optionor shall not be released from its unfunded Capital
Commitment except as actually funded by the acquirer of any such portion of Optionor's interest.

(8) In the event that any amount of the Remaining Portion is not
acquired by the Optionees, the General Partner and any third party purchasers pursuant to paragraphs
4.5(b)(vii)(I)-(4), then, in its sole discretion, the General Partner may apply any of the remedies described
in paragraphs 4.5(a) and (b) to such unsold portion.
(viii) The General Partner may, in its sole discretion, elect to remove such
Defaulting Limited Partner from the Partnership, in which event (I) fifty percent (50%) of the Defaulting
Limited Partner's Capital Account balance shall be forfeited and reallocated to the Capital Accounts of the
nondefaulting Partners proportionally, based on, with respect to each such Partner, the ratio that its
Partnership Percentage immediately prior to such calculation bears to the aggregate Partnership
Percentages of all Partners (other than the Defaulting Limited Partner), (2) the remaining fifty percent (50%)
of the Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Account balance shall be payable by the Partnership in
installments over a period of no more than three (3) years from the effective date of the removal of such
Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to this paragraph 4.5(b)(viii), and (3) the Defaulting Limited Partner's
Partnership Percentage shall be reduced to zero.
9.
126316015 v3

(ix) The General Partner may, in its sole discretion, elect to use reasonable
efforts to assist such Defaulting Limited Partner transfer its entire interest in the Partnership.

(x) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, each Limited
Partner (1) agrees that it will execute any instruments or perform any other acts that are or may be necessary
to effectuate and carry out the transactions contemplated by this paragraph 4.5, and (2) designates and
appoints the General Partner its true and lawful attorney, in its name, place and stead, to make, execute, and
sign any and all instruments, documents, or certificates on behalf of any Defaulting Limited Partner in order
to give effect to any remedy against such Defaulting Limited Partner (including, but not limited to, the
remedies set forth in this paragraph 4.5(b)).

(xi) The Partners agree that the General Partner's authority and discretion to
enforce any remedy against a Defaulting Limited Partner (including but not limited to the remedies set forth
in this paragraph 4.5(b)) supersede any fiduciary duties of the General Partner to such Defaulting Limited
Partner. The Partners further agree that the remedies set forth in this paragraph 4.5(b) are fair and
reasonable in light of the difficulty in ascertaining the actual damages that would be incurred by the
Partnership and the nondefaulting Partners as a result of the Defaulting Limited Partner's failure to
contribute capital when due pursuant to the terms of this Agreement.
(xii) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this paragraph 4.5, a
Regulated Partner shall not be declared to be in default by the General Partner with respect to any due and
unpaid capital contributions in the event that such Regulated Partner is entitled to withdraw from the
Partnership (or the General Partner has requested such withdrawal) pursuant to Article 13 and the failure to
make such due and unpaid capital contributions is the consequence of or attributable to such withdrawal.
4.6 Suspension Period.

(a) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement to the contrary, no Limited
Partner shall be required to contribute capital to the Partnership in respect of its Capital Commitment during
any Suspension Period (as defined in paragraph 4.6(b)) except for:

(i) Partnership expenses, including payment of any Management Fee due to
the General Partner;
follow-on investments in portfolio companies in which the Partnership
had invested prior to commencement of the Suspension Period, so long as the Advisory Committee
consents to each such follow-on investment;
(iii) investments which the Partnership had committed to make as evidenced
by a written term sheet prior to commencement of the Suspension Period; and

(iv) fulfillment of such Limited Partner's obligations pursuant to paragraph
4.2(d).

(b) In the event that either (i) James Fitzgerald or (ii) Andrew McCormack (each, a
"Managing Member," and together, the "Managing Members") ceases to be a managing member of the
General Partner, or otherwise ceases to participate in the management of the Partnership or fails to meet his
obligation to devote his business time to the Partnership to the extent required under paragraphs 8.3(a) or
8.3(b) (the "Suspension Event'), the Commitment Period shall automatically be suspended and a
"Suspension Period" shall begin (during which the activities described in paragraph 4.6(a) shall not be
permitted).
10.
126316015 v3

(c) Upon the occurrence of a Suspension Event, the General Partner shall promptly
notify the Limited Partners of the Suspension Event, and shall promptly circulate a written ballot to the
Limited Partners which asks the Limited Partners to vote on whether the Commitment Period shall be
terminated as a result of such Suspension Event, and shall use its reasonable best efforts to have the Limited
Partners cast their vote on such ballot. If a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners do not
affirmatively vote to end the Suspension Period within one hundred eighty (180) days of the
commencement of the Suspension Period, the Commitment Period shall be automatically terminated and
the Suspension Period shall continue. If a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners do affirmatively
vote to terminate the Suspension Period within one hundred eighty (180) days of the commencement of the
Suspension Period, then the Suspension Period shall be automatically terminated and the Commitment
Period shall be reinstated. Notwithstanding the preceding or any other provision of this Agreement to the
contrary, a Suspension Period may be terminated, and the Commitment Period shall be reinstated, at any
time upon the affirmative vote of a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners.
ARTICLE 5
PARTNERSHIP ALLOCATIONS
5.1 Allocation of Profit or Loss. Except as otherwise provided in this Article 5:

(a) Profit of the Partnership for each Accounting Period shall be allocated as follows:
(i) First, an amount of the Partnership's gains from the sale of Securities,
Deemed Gain allocable to the Partners in connection with a distribution or other disposition of Securities,
and Deemed Gain allocable in connection with a revaluation of Securities for any reason, shall be allocated
one hundred percent (100%) to the General Partner until the cumulative amount allocated to the General
Partner pursuant to this paragraph 5.1(a)(i) in such Accounting Period and all prior Accounting Periods is
equal to the aggregate amount of all Fee Adjustments.
Second, for so long as the "First Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is
not met, the remaining items of Profit for such Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Partners to cause
the cumulative allocations made pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) through 5.1(a)(iv) to have been made as
follows:

(1) Eighty percent (80%) of such Profit to the Capital Accounts of all
of the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages; and

(2) Twenty percent (20%) of such Profit to the Capital Accounts of all
of the Partners to the extent that such accounts were previously allocated a Contingent Loss that has not
been restored by previous allocations pursuant to this paragraph. Such Profit shall be allocated to a
Partner's Capital Account on the basis of the proportion that the unrestored Contingent Losses contained in
such Partner's Capital Account bears to the aggregate unrestored Contingent Losses contained in all
Partners' Capital Accounts. Any balance of said twenty percent (20%) of the Partnership's Profit shall be
allocated to the Capital Account of the General Partner.
(iii) Next, after and to the extent that the First Allocation Hurdle has been met,
and until the "Second Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is met, the remaining items of Profit for such
Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Partners to cause the cumulative allocations made pursuant to
paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) through 5.1(a)(iv) to have been made as follows:
I I.
126316015 v3

(1) Seventy-five percent (75%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages; and

(2) Twenty-five percent (25%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the
Partners to the extent that such accounts were previously allocated a Contingent Loss that has not been
restored by previous allocations pursuant to this paragraph. Such Profit shall be allocated to a Partner's
Capital Account on the basis of the proportion that the unrestored Contingent Losses contained in such
Partner's Capital Account bears to the aggregate unrestored Contingent Losses contained in all Partners'
Capital Accounts. Any balance of said twenty-five percent (25%) of the Partnership's Profit shall be
allocated to the Capital Account of the General Partner.

(iv) Next, after and to the extent that the Second Allocation Hurdle is met, the
remaining items of Profit for such Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Partners to cause the
cumulative allocations made pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) through 5.1(a)(iv) to have been made as
follows:

(1) Seventy percent (70%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages; and

(2) Thirty percent (30%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the Partners
to the extent that such accounts were previously allocated a Contingent Loss that has not been restored by
previous allocations pursuant to this paragraph. Such Profit shall be allocated to a Partner's Capital
Account on the basis of the proportion that the unrestored Contingent Losses contained in such Partner's
Capital Account bears to the aggregate unrestored Contingent Losses contained in all Partners' Capital
Accounts. Any balance of said thirty percent (30%) of the Partnership's Profit shall be allocated to the
Capital Account of the General Partner.

(b) Losses of the Partnership for each Accounting Period shall be allocated as follows:
(i) First, to the extent of the Profits allocated pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a)(iv)
with respect to prior Accounting Periods, items of Loss for such Accounting Period shall be allocated in
proportion to and in reverse order of such Profit allocations;
Next, to the extent of the Profits allocated pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a)(iii)
with respect to prior Accounting Periods, any remaining items of Loss for such Accounting Period shall be
allocated in proportion to and in reverse order of such Profit allocations; and
(iii) Next, any remaining items of Loss for such Accounting Period shall be
allocated: (x) twenty percent (20%) to the Capital Account of the General Partner; and (y) eighty percent
(80%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages.

For all purposes under this Agreement, the "First Allocation Hurdle" shall be determined as of the time
that any item of Profit or Loss is to be allocated pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) and 5.1(a)(iii), and shall be
deemed to have been met to the extent that each Limited Partner has been allocated net Profits pursuant to
this Article 5 in an amount equal to two hundred percent (200%) of its respective Capital Commitment (as
defined below) as of such time of determination (i.e., an amount sufficient to enable the Partnership to
distribute to such Limited Partner an amount equal to three hundred percent (300%) of such Limited
Partner's Capital Commitment).
12.
126316015 v3
For all purposes under this Agreement, the "Second Allocation Hurdle" shall be determined as of the time
that any item of Profit or Loss is to be allocated pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(iii) and 5.1(a)(iv), and shall
be deemed to have been met to the extent that each Limited Partner has been allocated net Profits pursuant
to this Article 5 in an amount equal to five hundred percent (500%) of its respective Capital Commitment as
of such time of determination (Le., an amount sufficient to enable the Partnership to distribute to such
Limited Partner an amount equal to six hundred percent (600%) of such Limited Partner's Capital
Commitment).

(c) Solely in consideration of the fact that no Management Fee is chargeable in respect
of the General Partner's Partnership Percentage in the Partnership, items of Loss attributable to the
Management Fee for each Accounting Period shall not be allocated to the Capital Account of the General
Partner with respect to its Partnership Percentage.

5.2 Allocation of Ordinary Income and Ordinary Loss. Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss
of the Partnership for each Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Capital Accounts of all of the
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages.
5.3 Reallocation of Contingent Losses.

(a) Except as provided in paragraph 5.3(b), if, for any Accounting Period, after the
allocations provided in this Article 5 have been made, the balance of the Adjusted Capital Account Balance
of the General Partner has been reduced to less than the product of the General Partner's Partnership
Percentage and the sum of the balances of the Adjusted Capital Account Balances of all Partners, an amount
of the Loss (the "Contingent Loss") allocated to the General Partner for such Accounting Period shall be
reallocated from the General Partner's Capital Account to all of the Partner's Capital Accounts (in
proportion to each Partner's respective Partnership Percentage) so that the General Partner's Adjusted
Capital Account Balance is equal to no less than the product of (I) the sum of the Adjusted Capital
Account Balances of all Partners and (II) the quotient of (i) the sum of (A) the amount of the General
Partner's cumulative capital contributions made in cash as of such time plus (B) the aggregate
allocations of Profit to the General Partner pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a) over (ii) the sum of (X) the
amount of all of the Partners' capital contributions made in cash as of such time plus (Y) aggregate
allocations of Profit to the General Partner pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a); provided, that the General
Partner's Adjusted Capital Account Balance may be less than that amount by the amount, if any, that
the General Partner would be required to contribute to the Partnership pursuant to either paragraph
10.5(a) or paragraph 10.5(d) as of such time if all of the assets of the Partnership were sold at such time
for their Adjusted Asset Values and the proceeds thereof were distributed to the Partners pursuant to
paragraph 10.4. For purposes of this paragraph 5.3, the General Partner's Adjusted Capital Account shall
not be deemed to include any amounts attributable to a Limited Partner's interest held by the General
Partner, but shall be deemed to include any outstanding obligations by the General Partner to contribute
capital to the Partnership.

(b) The amount of Contingent Loss that would otherwise be reallocated from the
General Partner's Adjusted Capital Account under paragraph 5.3(a) shall instead be allocated to the General
Partner's Adjusted Capital Account until allocations of loss to the General Partner's Adjusted Capital
Account pursuant to this paragraph 5.3(b) equal the amount of distributions, if any, that the General Partner
would have to return to the Partnership under paragraph 10.5 if the Partnership were then in liquidation.
5.4 Special Allocations. To the extent the Partnership has taxable interest income or expense
with respect to any promissory note between any Partner and the Partnership as holder and maker or maker
and holder pursuant to Section 483, Sections 1271 through 1288, or Section 7872 of the Code, such interest
13.
126316015 v3
income or expense shall be specially allocated to the Partner to whom such promissory note relates, and
such Partner's Capital Account adjusted if appropriate.
5.5 Regulatory Allocations.

(a) This Agreement is intended to comply with the safe harbor provisions set forth in
Treasury Regulation 1.704-1(b) and the allocations set forth in paragraph 5.5(b) (the "Regulatory
Allocations") are intended to comply with certain requirements of Treasury Regulation Section 1.704-1(b).
In the event the Regulatory Allocations result in allocations being made that are inconsistent with the
manner in which the Partners intend to divide Partnership Profit and Loss as reflected in paragraphs 5.1, 5.2,
5.3 and 5.4, the General Partner shall use its reasonable best efforts to adjust subsequent allocations of any
items of gain, loss, income, deduction, or expense such that the net amount of the Regulatory Allocations
and such subsequent special adjustments to each Partner is zero.

(b) The allocations provided in this Article 5 shall be subject to the following
exceptions:
(i) Any loss or expense otherwise allocable to a Limited Partner which
exceeds the positive balance in such Limited Partner's Capital Account shall instead be allocated first to all
Partners who have positive balances in their Capital Accounts in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages, and when all Partners' Capital Accounts have been reduced to zero, then to the General
Partner; income shall first be allocated to reverse any loss or expense allocated under this paragraph
5.5(b)(i), in reverse order of such loss or expense allocations, until all such prior loss or expense allocations
have been reversed.
In the event any Limited Partner unexpectedly receives any adjustments,
allocations, or distributions described in Treasury Regulation Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4) through (d)(6),
which causes or increases a deficit balance in such Limited Partner's Capital Account, items of Partnership
income and gain shall be specially allocated to such Limited Partner in an amount and manner sufficient to
eliminate the deficit balance in its Capital Account created by such adjustments, allocations, or distributions
as quickly as possible.
(iii) For purposes of this paragraph 5.5(b), the balance in a Partner's Capital
Account shall take into account the adjustments provided in Treasury Regulation Section
1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4) through (d)(6).

(c) If additional persons are admitted to the Partnership as Limited Partners
subsequent to the date hereof (or existing Limited Partners increase their Capital Commitments), then
organizational costs, fees (including the Management Fee set forth in paragraph 6.1) and expenses, and
individual items of Ordinary Income, Ordinary Loss, Profit and Loss of the Partnership that are allocated to
the Partners on or after the effective date of such admission (or increase), shall be allocated first to such new
Partners (or such existing Limited Partners that increased their Capital Commitments) to the extent
necessary to cause such persons to be treated with respect to such items as if they had been Partners (or had
such increased Capital Commitments) from the date hereof.
5.6 Income Tax Allocations.

(a) Except as otherwise provided in this paragraph or as otherwise required by the
Code and the rules and Treasury Regulations promulgated thereunder, a Partner's distributive share of
Partnership income, gain, loss, deduction, or expense for income tax purposes shall be the same as is
entered in the Partner's Capital Account pursuant to this Agreement.
14.
126316015 v3

(b) In accordance with Code Section 704(c) and the Treasury Regulations thereunder,
income, gain, loss, deduction, and expense with respect to any asset contributed to the capital of the
Partnership shall, solely for tax purposes, be allocated among the Partners so as to take account of any
variation between the adjusted basis of such property to the Partnership for federal income tax purposes and
its initial Adjusted Asset Value.

(c) In the event the Adjusted Asset Value of any Partnership asset is adjusted pursuant
to the terms of this Agreement, subsequent allocations of income, gain, loss, deduction, and expense with
respect to such asset shall take account of any variation between the adjusted basis of such asset for federal
income tax purposes and its Adjusted Asset Value in the same manner as under Code Section 704(c) and the
Treasury Regulations thereunder.
ARTICLE 6
MANAGEMENT FEE; PARTNERSHIP EXPENSES
6.1 Management Fee.

(a) Commencing as of the Commencement Date, the Management Company shall be
compensated on a quarterly basis for services rendered to the Partnership by the payment in advance by the
Partnership in cash to the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate that makes the capital contributions
referenced in paragraph 4.3) on the first day of each fiscal quarter (or any applicable partial fiscal quarter,
including without limitation, a partial fiscal quarter commencing as of the Commencement Date) of a
management fee (the "Management Fee"). No Management Fee will be chargeable in respect of the
interest in the Partnership held by the General Partner or its designated Affiliate attributable to a Partnership
Percentage.

(b) The Management Fee for each fiscal quarter (prior to the adjustments described in
paragraph 6.1(c)) shall be an amount equal to the aggregate Capital Commitments made by the Limited
Partners as of the first day of each such quarter multiplied by 0.625% (the percentage applicable for any
period referred to herein as the "Management Fee Percentage"); provided, that the Management Company
hereby irrevocably waives an aggregate amount of the Management Fee equal to 80% of the General
Partner's Capital Commitment, with reductions in the Management Fee to be applied as set forth in
paragraph 6.1(c)(ii). Notwithstanding the foregoing, (i) the Management Fee for each of the Partnership's
first and last fiscal quarters shall be proportionately reduced based upon the ratio that the number of days in
each such period bears to ninety (90), (ii) an additional Management Fee shall be payable upon the date of
admission of any Limited Partner (or increase in an existing Limited Partner's Capital Commitment)
subsequent to the date hereof to reflect the increased Capital Commitments calculated as if such Limited
Partner had been admitted to the Partnership (or had such increased Capital Commitment) as of the date
hereof, and (iii) for each fiscal year commencing on or after the fifth anniversary of the Commencement
Date, the Management Fee Percentage applicable in fiscal quarters during such fiscal year (prior to the
adjustments described in paragraph 6.1(c)) shall be equal to the greater of (A) the quarterly Management
Fee Percentage applicable in the prior fiscal year reduced by an amount equal to 0.025% or (B) 0.375%.

(c) The Management Fee otherwise payable by the Partnership to the Management
Company pursuant to paragraph 6.1(a) for a fiscal quarter shall be offset (in the following order of
application):

(i) First, by one hundred percent (100%) of the amount of any cash or
non-cash compensation in the form of stock, options, warrants or other similar rights (net of the amount
paid for any such stock or securities) paid as directors, consulting, management service, advisory,
15.
126316015 v3
consultant, transaction, commitment, breakup or broken deal fees or similar fees to the General Partner, the
Management Company, or the respective managing members or managers of such entities, during the
immediately preceding quarter by or in connection with any company in which the Partnership holds an
investment or any company in which the Partnership actively sought to invest but did not, net of any
unreimbursed expenses of the General Partner or the Management Company, or the managing members or
managers of such entities, and as adjusted for any similar reductions with respect to any Parallel Fund or
any "Prior Fund", on a pro rata basis based on the aggregate capital commitments made to the applicable
Parallel Funds and Prior Funds, to prevent double counting; provided, however, any reduction pursuant to
this paragraph 6.1(c)(i) in connection with any cash or non-cash compensation paid to any such parties by a
company in which an "Affiliated Party" (as defined below) or a member, employee or Affiliate thereof
holds an investment as of the date hereof shall be limited to the amount directly attributable to the
Partnership's actual investment in such company (taking into account of any proration due to the
investments of any Parallel Fund or Prior Fund); and
Next, by an equal portion (measured over all quarterly periods during the
Partnership's Commitment Period and as adjusted for any increase in the Capital Commitment of the
General Partner or its designated Affiliate) of the aggregate amount of the Management Fee waived by the
Management Company pursuant to paragraph 6.1(b) (the amount of each such reduction being a "Fee
Adjustment").

In the event the offsets required by this paragraph 6.1(c) for a fiscal quarter exceed the Management Fee
payable for such fiscal quarter, the amount of such excess shall be offset against the Management Fee
otherwise payable in subsequent fiscal quarters until there has been a full reduction of Management Fees
with respect to amounts described in this paragraph 6.1(c). In the event that there are insufficient
Management Fees payable such that the foregoing offset amounts are unable to be completely exhausted by
the time of the Partnership's final distribution pursuant to paragraph 10.4, then the General Partner shall,
immediately prior to the Partnership's final distribution, return any such unexhausted offset amount to the
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages; provided, however, that any Limited
Partner may elect, by advance written notice to the General Partner, to refrain from being allocated, and
from having distributed to it, its portion of such returned offset amount.

(d) Solely for purposes of determining the value of any stock, options, warrants or
other similar rights that may offset the Management Fee as described in paragraph 6.1(c)(i), the following
rules shall apply:

(i) All non-cash compensation in the form of stock received by any of the
General Partner, the Management Company, or the managing members or managers of such entities shall
be valued as of the time of receipt in accordance with the rules set forth in paragraph 12.1.
All non-cash compensation in the form of options, warrants or other
similar rights received by any of the parties shall be valued, in accordance with the rules set forth in
paragraph 12.1, upon the earliest to occur of (a) the distribution to the Partners of any Securities underlying
such options, warrants or other similar rights, (b) the conversion of such options, warrants or other similar
rights into cash, (c) the date on which the Securities underlying such options, warrants or other similar
rights become Marketable Securities (to the extent such options are exercisable at such time) or (d) the date
that is, in the General Partner's reasonable estimation, one year prior to the date of dissolution of the
Partnership. The value of options, warrants or other similar rights shall be, on a per share basis, the
difference, as of the valuation date, between the exercise price and the fair market value of the securities on
such date. No value shall be attributable to options, warrants or other similar rights if the applicable
securities are of a portfolio company that has been written off or written down to a nominal amount as of the
valuation date.
16.
126316015 v3
6.2 Expenses.

(a) From the Management Fee, the Management Company and the General Partner
shall bear all normal operating expenses incurred in connection with the management of the Partnership, the
General Partner and the Management Company, except for those expenses borne directly by the Partnership
as set forth in subparagraphs (b), (c) and (d) below and elsewhere herein. Such normal operating expenses
to be borne by the General Partner (or its designee) shall include, without limitation, expenditures on
account of salaries, wages, travel, entertainment, and other expenses of employees, consultants and agents
of the Partnership (other than consultants employed with respect to investments or proposed investments),
the General Partner or the Management Company, overhead and rentals payable for space used by the
General Partner (or its designee) or the Partnership, office expenses, expenses for clerical and consulting
services, and expenses incurred in evaluating investment opportunities and managing investments of the
Partnership.

(b) The Partnership shall bear all costs and expenses incurred by the General Partner
and/or the Management Company in connection with the following:
(i) Expenses incurred in the holding, purchase, sale or exchange of Securities
(whether or not ultimately consummated), including, but not by way of limitation, private placement fees,
finder's fees, interest on borrowed money, real property or personal property taxes on investments
(including documentary, recording, stamp and transfer taxes), brokerage fees or commissions, legal fees,
expenses incurred in performing due diligence with respect to a purchase, sale or exchange of Securities
(whether or not ultimately consummated), consulting fees relating to investments or proposed investments;
and
Expenses incurred in connection with the investigation, prosecution or
defense of any claims by or against the Partnership, including claims by or against a governmental authority,
audit and accounting fees, taxes applicable to the Partnership on account of its operations, fees incurred in
connection with the maintenance of bank or custodian accounts, and all expenses incurred in connection
with the registration of the Partnership's Securities under applicable securities laws or regulations,
expenses incurred by the General Partner in serving as the tax matters partner (as described in paragraph
11.6), the Management Fee, the cost of liability and other premiums for insurance protecting the
Partnership, the General Partner, its managers, and the Management Company and its managers and
employees from liability to third parties that relates to the Partnership and its activities and investments, all
out-of-pocket expenses of preparing and distributing reports to Partners, expenses associated with
Partnership communications with Partners, including preparation of annual or other reports to the Limited
Partners, out-of-pocket costs associated with Partnership meetings, all legal, audit and accounting fees
relating to the Partnership and its activities (including, without limitation, for third party bookkeeping
services), all costs and expenses arising out of the Partnership's indemnification obligation pursuant to this
Agreement, and all expenses that are not normal operating expenses.

(c) The Partnership shall bear all organizational and syndication costs, fees, and
expenses incurred by or on behalf of the General Partner in connection with the formation and organization
of the Partnership and the General Partner, including legal and accounting fees and expenses incident
thereto (but not including any private placement fees, finder's fees or other similar fees paid to an
independent third party in connection with the sale of interests in the Partnership); provided, however, that
the amount of such costs, fees and expenses that are borne by the Partnership shall not exceed in the
aggregate five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000).
17.
126316015 v3

(d) The Partnership shall bear all liquidation costs, fees, and expenses incurred by the
General Partner (or its designee) in connection with the liquidation of the Partnership at the end of the
Partnership's term, specifically including but not limited to legal and accounting fees and expenses.

(e) Each of the Partnership and the General Partner agree to reimburse the other as
appropriate to give effect to the provisions of this paragraph 6.2 in the event that either such party pays an
obligation that is properly the responsibility of the other.
ARTICLE 7
WITHDRAWALS BY AND DISTRIBUTIONS TO THE PARTNERS
7.1 Interest. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, no interest shall be paid to any
Partner on account of its interest in the capital of or on account of its investment in the Partnership.
7.2 Withdrawals by the Partners. No Partner may withdraw any amount from its Capital
Account unless such withdrawal is made pursuant to this Article 7, Article 10 or Article 13.
7.3 Partners' Obligation to Repay or Restore. Except as required by law or the terms of this
Agreement, no Limited Partner shall be obligated at any time to repay or restore to the Partnership all or any
part of any distribution made to it from the Partnership in accordance with the terms of this Article 7.
7.4 Mandatory Distributions.

(a) The General Partner may cause each Partner to be paid in cash, following the end
of each fiscal year during the term of the Partnership, an amount equal to the net taxable income allocated to
such Partner as a result of such Partner's ownership of an interest in the Partnership for the current fiscal
year multiplied by the highest blended federal, state and local marginal income tax rate then applicable to an
individual residing in any state of the United States applied by taking into account the character of the
taxable income in question (i.e., long-term capital gains, ordinary income, etc.) (such product, such
Partner's "Annual Tar Amounr); provided, however, that the General Partner shall not be required to
make any such distribution if the total amount to be distributed to all Partners is less than one million dollars
($1,000,000); provided, further, that for each fiscal year the amount distributed to any Partner pursuant to
this paragraph 7.4(a) shall not exceed the amount by which (A) such Partner's cumulative aggregate Annual
Tax Amounts for such fiscal year and all prior fiscal years exceeds (B) the cumulative aggregate cash
distributions made to such Partner pursuant to paragraphs 7.4(a) and 7.5 through the end of such fiscal year
(and including all prior fiscal years). The provisions of this paragraph 7.4 shall apply equally to all Partners,
without regard to their tax-exempt status under the Code.

(b) Subject to the maintenance of reasonable cash reserves (as determined and
established at the discretion of the General Partner), within ninety (90) days of the end of each fiscal year,
the General Partner shall distribute, in cash, to all Partners in proportion to their Partnership Percentages, an
amount equal to the amount of net Ordinary Income, if any, allocated to each Partner's Capital Account
during such fiscal year.
7.5 Discretionary Distributions and Rules Regarding Distributions.

(a) Except as otherwise provided in paragraph 7.5(g), the General Partner may make a
distribution of cash or Marketable Securities as follows.
18.
126316015 v3

(i) First, to the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages such that each such Partner has received distributions pursuant to paragraph 7.4 and this
paragraph 7.5(a)(i) in an amount equal to (but not greater than) such Partner's aggregate capital
contributions (including the amount of all Fee Adjustments in the case of the General Partner), less the net
Ordinary Losses, if any, previously allocated to such Partner pursuant to paragraph 5.2 (all measured as of
the time the distribution is to be made);
Second, until the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited Partner
pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) is equal to three hundred percent (300%) of such
Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution, such distribution shall be made to
the Partners in the proportions necessary to cause cumulative distributions made pursuant to paragraph
7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) to have been
made: (1) eighty percent (80%) to all Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages and

(2) twenty percent (20%) to the General Partner;
(iii) Third, to the extent that the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited
Partner pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) exceeds three hundred percent (300%) of
such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution, such distribution shall be
made one hundred percent (100%) to the General Partner until the General Partner has received aggregate
distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made
pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) equal to twenty-five percent (25%) of the cumulative distributions made
pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph
7.5(a)(i));

(iv) Fourth, until the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited Partner
pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) is equal to six hundred percent (600%) of such
Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution, such distribution shall be made to
the Partners in the proportions necessary to cause cumulative distributions made pursuant to paragraph
7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) to have been
made: (1) seventy-five percent (75%) to all Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages and (2) twenty-five percent (25%) to the General Partner;

(v) Fifth, to the extent that the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited
Partner pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) exceeds to six hundred percent (600%) of
such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution, such distribution shall be
made one hundred percent (100%) to the General Partner until the General Partner has received aggregate
distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made
pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) equal to thirty percent (30%) of the cumulative distributions made pursuant
to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i));
and

(vi) Sixth, such distribution shall be made: (1) seventy percent (70%) to all
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages and (2) thirty percent (30%) to the
General Partner.

(b) Notwithstanding paragraph 7.5(a), the General Partner may at any time waive a
distribution of cash or Marketable Securities that would otherwise be made to it pursuant to paragraphs
7.5(a)(ii) through 7.5(a)(vi) and instead make such distribution one hundred percent (100%) to all Partners
in accordance with their respective Partnership Percentages; provided, however, that the Partnership may
make subsequent distributions of cash to the General Partner to the extent of any such waived distribution at
such times as the General Partner shall determine.
19.
126316015 v3

(c) Whenever more than one type of Marketable Securities is being distributed in kind
in a single distribution or whenever more than one class of Marketable Securities of a portfolio company (or
a portion of a class of such Marketable Securities having a tax basis per share or unit different from other
portions of such class) are distributed in kind by the Partnership, each Partner shall receive its ratable
portion of each type, class or portion of such class of Marketable Securities distributed in kind (except to the
extent that a disproportionate distribution is necessary to avoid distributing fractional shares).

(d) Marketable Securities distributed in kind pursuant to this paragraph 7.5, or
Securities distributed pursuant to paragraph 10.4, shall be subject to such conditions and restrictions as the
General Partner determines are legally required or appropriate. Whenever types or classes of Securities are
distributed in kind, each Partner shall receive its ratable portion of each type or class of Securities
distributed in kind.

(e) Immediately prior to any distribution in kind, the Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss of
any Marketable Securities distributed pursuant to this paragraph 7.5, or Securities distributed pursuant to
paragraph 10.4, shall be allocated to the Capital Accounts of all Partners as Profit or Loss pursuant to
Article 5.

(f) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, in the event the
Partnership distributes to the Partners any Marketable Securities or cash proceeds from the sale or other
disposition of Securities or other property of the Partnership within one hundred eighty (180) days of the
date the Partnership acquired the Securities of the applicable portfolio company, a portion of the distributed
capital that represents the Partnership's original cost basis of such Securities shall be added back to the
unfunded Capital Commitments of the Partners pro rata in accordance with the percentages in which the
capital contributed to purchase such Securities of the applicable portfolio company and each Partner may be
required to recontribute capital on the terms set forth in paragraph 4.2 to the Partnership an amount equal to
the product of: (x) such Partner's Partnership Percentage; and (y) the Partnership's original cost basis of the
Securities being distributed or which were sold or otherwise disposed of in connection with such
distribution.

(g) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this paragraph 7.5, no
distribution shall be made to the General Partner to the extent it would create or increase a deficit in its
Capital Account; provided, however, that the General Partner shall be entitled to receive a special
distribution in an amount equal to the amount of any distribution otherwise foregone pursuant to this
paragraph 7.5(g), to the extent that such special distribution would not create or increase a deficit in the
General Partner's Capital Account.

(h) All distributions of cash to be made by the Partnership, pursuant to paragraphs 7.4
or 7.5 or otherwise, shall be made in U.S. dollars.
7.6 Withholding Obligations.

(a) If and to the extent the Partnership is required by law (as determined in good faith
by the General Partner) to make payments ("Tax Payments") with respect to any Partner in amounts
required to discharge any legal obligation of the Partnership or the General Partner, including any
obligation pursuant to FATCA, to make payments to any governmental authority with respect to any federal,
state or local tax liability of such Partner arising as a result of such Partner's interest in the Partnership, then
the amount of any such Tax Payments shall be deemed to be a loan by the Partnership to such Partner,
which loan shall: (i) be secured by such Partner's interest in the Partnership; (ii) bear interest at the Prime
Rate (as defined in paragraph 14.15); and (iii) be payable upon demand; provided, however, that the
General Partner shall use commercially reasonable efforts to provide the Partners notice of the amount of
20.
126316015 v3
any anticipated Tax Payments in advance of the Partnership's payment thereof and will, upon written
request from any Partner, allow such requesting Partner to pay the Partnership an amount of cash equal to
the amount of such Tax Payments in lieu of treating any such Tax Payment as a loan. Each Limited Partner
will, as applicable, take such actions as are required to establish to the reasonable satisfaction of the General
Partner that the Limited Partner is (i) not subject to the withholding tax obligations imposed by Section
1471 of the Code and (ii) not subject to the withholding tax obligations imposed by Section 1472 of the
Code. In addition, each Limited Partner will assist the Partnership and the General Partner with any
applicable information reporting or other obligation imposed on the Partnership, the General Partner, or
their respective Affiliates, pursuant to FATCA. For purposes of this Agreement, "FATCA" shall mean the
Foreign Account Tax Compliance provisions enacted as part of the U.S. Hiring Incentives to Restore
Employment Act and codified in Sections 1471 through 1474 of the Code, all rules, regulations and other
guidance issued thereunder, and all administrative and judicial interpretations thereof.

(b) If and to the extent the General Partner determines that the Partnership is required
to make any Tax Payments with respect to any distribution to a Partner, (i) the General Partner shall use
commercially reasonable efforts to provide the Partner advance notice of the amount of such anticipated
Tax Payments and (ii) either (A) such Partner's proportionate share of such distribution shall be reduced by
the amount of such Tax Payments (provided, however, that such Partner's Capital Account shall be adjusted
pursuant to paragraph 14.5 for such Partner's full proportionate share of the distribution), or (B) such
Partner shall pay to the Partnership prior to such distribution an amount of cash equal to such Tax Payments.
In the event a portion of a distribution in kind is retained by the Partnership pursuant to clause (A), such
retained Securities may, in the discretion of the General Partner, either (i) be distributed to the Partners in
accordance with the terms of this Article 7 including this paragraph 7.6(b), or (ii) be sold by the Partnership
to generate the cash necessary to satisfy such Tax Payments. If the Securities are sold, then for purposes of
income tax allocations only under this Agreement, any gain or loss on such sale or exchange shall be
allocated to the Partner to whom the Tax Payments relate.

(c) If the Partnership is required to withhold taxes pursuant to this paragraph 7.6 with
respect to any Limited Partner or if any tax is required to be withheld on amounts receivable by the
Partnership (including any tax required to be withheld by another party paying proceeds to the Partnership)
and is attributable to any Limited Partner, the General Partner shall upon request by such Limited Partner
use commercially reasonable efforts to provide any Limited Partner with such information and assistance as
is reasonably necessary for such Limited Partner to obtain an exemption from or refund of such withheld
amounts.
ARTICLE 8
MANAGEMENT DUTIES AND RESTRICTIONS
8.1 Management. The General Partner shall have the sole and exclusive right to manage,
control, and conduct the affairs of the Partnership and to do any and all acts on behalf of the Partnership,
including exercise of rights to elect to adjust the tax basis of Partnership assets and to revoke such elections
and to make such other tax elections as the General Partner shall deem appropriate. The General Partner is
hereby authorized to enter, by itself or on behalf of the Partnership, into an agreement with Valar Ventures
LLC, a Delaware limited liability company or another entity beneficially owned by the Managing Members
and a Thiel Person (the "Management Company") for the provision of certain management, administrative,
operational and other services with the respect to the Partnership on terms to be determined and agreed to by
the General Partner, provided, however, that the General Partner shall remain ultimately responsible for the
overall management of the Partnership and for its duties and responsibilities hereunder; provided, further,
that any such agreement that the Partnership enters with an Affiliate of the General Partner shall be on terms
21.
126316015 v3
that are no less favorable to the Partnership than the terms that would be obtained from an independent
third-party acting at arms' length.

8.2 No Control by the Limited Partners; No Withdrawal. No Limited Partner shall take
part in the control or management of the affairs of the Partnership nor shall any Limited Partner have any
authority to act for or on behalf of the Partnership or to vote on any matter relative to the Partnership and its
affairs except as is specifically permitted by this Agreement. Except as specifically set forth in this
Agreement, no Limited Partner shall withdraw or be required to withdraw from the Partnership.
8.3 Existing Funds; Follow-On Funds; Parallel Funds.

(a) Before the Successor Fund Eligible Date (as defined in paragraph 8.3(b) below),
each of the Managing Members, for so long as they are managing members of the General Partner, shall
devote substantially all of his business time to manage the affairs of the Management Company, the
General Partner, the Partnership, the "Parallel Funds" (as defined below), and the "Prior Funds" (as defined
below), those entities formed for the purpose of managing the foregoing, or any portfolio company or
potential portfolio company of any of the foregoing or other entity invested in by the Partnership (which
may include being seconded to a portfolio company or potential portfolio company or other entity invested
in by the Partnership or a Prior Fund for such period of time as the General Partner determines, in good faith,
may benefit the Partnership or such Prior Fund, as applicable). From and after the Successor Fund Eligible
Date, each of the Managing Members, for so long as they are managing members of the General Partner,
shall only be required to devote such business time as they reasonably and in good faith deem to be
appropriate to manage the affairs of the Management Company, the General Partner, the Partnership, the
Parallel Funds and the other aforementioned entities.

Subject to the foregoing, the General Partner, the Management Company, the Managing Members, and
their respective affiliates, members and employees may:

(i) Engage in or own an interest in any other business, partnership, limited
liability company, limited liability partnership, corporation or other entity or association (including,
without limitation, buying and selling securities for their own accounts and the accounts of Prior Funds and
other investment vehicles, but subject in any event to the provisions of paragraph 8.4);

(ii) Continue to act as managers, members, employees, or consultants to Valar
Global Fund I LP, Valar Global Principals Fund I LP, Valar Global Fund II LP, Valar Global Principals
Fund II LP, Valar Ventures LP, VV Global LP, VV Global Principals LP, Valar Co-Invest I LP, and VV
Xero Holdings LLC and to other entities affiliated therewith (collectively, the "Prior Funds");
(iii) Form and operate one (1) or more successor venture capital investment
funds whose purpose is substantially the same as the Partnership's purpose (each, a "Successor Fund"),
subject to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b); and/or

(iv) Form and operate one or more Parallel Funds (as defined in paragraph
8.3(c)).

(b) On or after the earlier of (i) such time as at least seventy-five percent (75%) of the
Partnership's Committed Capital has been invested, committed or reserved for investment in portfolio
companies, or applied, committed or reserved for Partnership working capital or expenses, or (ii) the end of
the Commitment Period (such earlier time, the "Successor Fund Eligible Date"), the Managing Members
shall only be required to devote such business time to the Partnership as they deem to be appropriate (acting
reasonably and in good faith) and may, at their sole and absolute discretion, form and operate one or more
22.
126316015 v3
Successor Funds. In addition, the General Partner, the Managing Members and/or their Affiliates may, at
any time, form, operate and devote such business time as is reasonably necessary to the management of one
or more "Special Purpose Investment Funds" described in paragraph 8.4(a).
(c) Pursuant to paragraph 8.3(a)(iv), the General Partner and the Managing Members
may form and serve as general partner (or in a similar management role) of (i) one or more entities
organized to accommodate the capital investment of the members of the General Partner and the
Management Company and their employees or consultants and their respective families, and of other
persons having strategic or other important relationships with the Partnership (each, an "Affiliates Fund"),
and (ii) one or more investment partnerships or similar entities to accommodate the tax, regulatory or other
special needs of investors who otherwise would invest as Limited Partners of the Partnership (together with
any Affiliates Fund, the "Parallel Funds"). Each Parallel Fund (other than an Affiliates Fund) shall be
governed by a limited partnership agreement (or other similar constitutive document) whose terms are
substantially the same as this Agreement (and, for the avoidance of doubt, an Affiliates Fund may have
different economic terms than the Partnership (including, without limitation, a reduced or waived
management fee and/or carried interest in profits payable to its general partner or manager)). In the event
that any Parallel Fund is formed, upon each purchase of Securities (other than short-term obligations such
as money market instruments) by the Partnership, each Parallel Fund will simultaneously invest on the
same terms as the Partnership pro raw in accordance with the remaining available capital of each such fund,
and reflecting the reserve policies for each such fund (e.g. because Affiliate Funds may not charge
management fees and thus may not reserve for them); provided, however, that a Parallel Fund shall not be
required to make any such investment in a Security if the General Partner receives from the issuer thereof a
written notice to the effect that the issuer will not permit such Parallel Fund to invest on the same terms as
the Partnership or such investment would be prohibited by the terms of the governing agreement of such
Parallel Fund. Each Parallel Fund shall also dispose of each such Security at substantially the same time
and on substantially the same terms as the Partnership; provided, however, that the foregoing requirement
shall not apply with respect to dispositions of Securities made in connection with the liquidation of the
Partnership or a Parallel Fund; provided, further, that a Parallel Fund shall not be required to make any such
divestment of a Security if the General Partner receives from the issuer thereof a written notice to the effect
that the issuer will not permit such Parallel Fund to dispose of such Security on the same terms as the
Partnership or such divestment would be prohibited by the terms of the governing agreement of such
Parallel Fund. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement to the contrary, except as provided
in paragraph 10.3(b), in no event shall the General Partner cause or permit the Partnership, or any Parallel
Fund to make or dispose of an investment, or make a distribution of cash or property to the Partners, other
than on a pari passu basis with all other such funds based on their respective amounts of committed capital
from equityholders (determined as of all capital commitments were made at the same time). Each of the
Limited Partners hereby consents and agrees to the foregoing activities and investments and further
consents and agrees that neither the Partnership nor any of its Partners shall have any rights in or to such
activities or investments, or any profits derived therefrom.
8.4 Investment Opportunities and Conflicts of Interest.

(a) Each opportunity to invest at least one hundred fifty thousand dollars ($150,000)
into a company that is presented to the Managing Members, for so long as they are managing members of
the General Partner, and that otherwise meets the investment objectives of the Partnership (e.g., the
potential investment is sufficiently large, the potential investment is not expected to require an inordinate
portion of the Partnership's capital, the company is at an appropriate stage of development, the Partnership
has sufficient capital available at the time the investment is to be made, etc.), shall be offered to the
Partnership and each Parallel Fund in proportion to their relative available capital (measured as of the time
of such presentation); provided, however, that (i) the preceding restriction shall only apply from and after
the Commencement Date until the earlier of the end of the Commitment Period or the time at which a
23.
126316015 v3
Successor Fund may be formed pursuant to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b) and (ii) any such
opportunities may be allocated in whole to the Prior Funds, or such opportunities may be allocated partially
to the Partnership and the Parallel Funds and partially to the Prior Funds, until the Prior Funds have been
fully invested and reserved for follow-on investments and expenses, as determined by the General Partner
in its sole and absolute discretion. In furtherance of the foregoing, from and after the Commencement Date
until the earlier of the end of the Commitment Period or the time at which a Successor Fund may be formed
pursuant to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b), each of the General Partner and the Management
Company shall require that the Managing Members and managers of such entities shall promptly present to
the General Partner each investment opportunity that is presented to them and that is consistent with the
investment objectives of the Partnership as described in this paragraph 8.4(a).

Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this paragraph 8.4(a) or any other provision of this
Agreement to the contrary, the restrictions described in this paragraph 8.4(a) shall not apply to the
participation of any Affiliated Party in any investment opportunity with respect to which: (i) the applicable
Affiliated Party's participation has been approved by the Advisory Committee; (ii) the applicable Affiliated
Party or an Affiliate thereof (in each case, other than any investment fund managed thereby) has initially
invested prior to the date hereof or pursuant to the other provisions of this paragraph 8.4(a) and/or
paragraph 8.4(c); (iii) the General Partner has determined, in good faith, does not meet the investment
objectives of the Partnership; or (iv) a Special Purpose Investment Fund has been formed. For the
avoidance of doubt, the following shall automatically be deemed not to be investment opportunities of the
Partnership (and may be invested in by the General Partner, any Affiliated Party, or any Affiliate or
employee thereof or any investment fund managed thereby notwithstanding any provision of this
Agreement to the contrary): (i) any investment opportunity in a company (including, without limitation, in
the preferred stock of such company) that the General Partner has considered and has rejected as being
unsuitable for the Partnership in accordance with the rules and procedures by which the General Partner
makes investment decisions (Le., because the number of Managing Members required to approve the
opportunity have considered the opportunity and rejected it as being unsuitable for the Partnership), so long
as the Managing Members who rejected the opportunity and their respective Affiliates do not then
participate in such opportunity; (ii) any investment opportunity with respect to which the Advisory
Committee is asked to approve the Partnership's participation, but which the Advisory Committee does not
so approve; (iii) any investment opportunity in a company that has a "pre -money valuation" greater than
five hundred million dollars ($500,000,000), as determined by the Management Company in its sole
discretion, as of the date of the proposed investment (other than follow-on investments in companies in
which the Partnership already holds an existing interest as of the date of such proposed follow-on
investment); and (iv) any investment opportunity to be held by a Special Purpose Investment Fund.
A "Special Purpose Investment Fund" means an investment fund created by the General Partner or any
Affiliated Party to invest in a specified investment opportunity, which meets the Partnership's investment
objectives. A Special Purpose Investment Fund must meet the following criteria: (a) each Partner is
provided the first opportunity (on at least seven (7) days advance notice) to invest in such special purpose
investment fund on a pro ram basis determined by reference to the total of (x) the Partners' respective
Capital Commitments and (y) the respective capital commitments that the constituent partners in any
Parallel Funds have made to such Parallel Funds, and (b) such special purpose investment fund charges a
carried interest and/or management fee that are no higher than those charged to the Partnership. No Special
Purpose Investment Fund with aggregate capital commitments that exceed 30% of the amount of the
aggregate Capital Commitments to the Partnership shall be formed or organized without the Advisory
Committee's prior approval.

(b) The term "Affiliated Party", as used herein, means any Managing Member, the
General Partner, the Management Company, or any member, employee or Affiliate thereof; provided,
however, that for all purposes under this Agreement, no Th el Person shall be deemed to be an Affiliated
24.
126316015 v3
Party. Notwithstanding paragraph 8.4(a), each Limited Partner hereby acknowledges and agrees that the
General Partner may offer to other private investors, groups, partnerships or corporations (including,
without limitation, any Limited Partner, and the Affiliates, members and employees of the foregoing parties
and any Prior Funds or Successor Funds) the right to participate in investment opportunities of the
Partnership or opportunities which may meet the investment objectives of the Partnership (as determined by
the General Partner in good faith) whenever the General Partner, in its sole and absolute discretion, so
determines; provided, however, that (i) an Affiliated Party may only take or participate in investment
opportunities meeting the investment objectives of the Partnership to the extent so provided in paragraphs
8.4(a) and 8.4(c) and (ii) such investment opportunity, if meeting the investment objectives of the
Partnership (as determined by the General Partner in good faith), shall be offered to the Partnership before it
is offered to any other party.

(c) Until the earlier of the time that the Commitment Period ends or a Successor Fund
may be formed pursuant to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b), each Affiliated Party or Affiliate thereof
shall not be permitted to receive and keep any preferred stock, common stock, options or other similar
instruments to purchase the same of any Partnership portfolio company without the consent of the Advisory
Committee; provided, however, that the Affiliated Parties may, collectively, invest up to one hundred fifty
thousand dollars ($150,000) into any Partnership portfolio company that are not Marketable Securities.

(d) Each Limited Partner hereby agrees that, the Partnership may invest in any
company in which a Successor Fund or Prior Fund (or any other investment fund managed by any of the
General Partner, the Affiliated Parties or their Affiliates) holds an interest, whenever the General Partner, in
its discretion, so determines that an investment in such company would be appropriate for the Partnership;
provided, however, that without the consent of the Advisory Committee, the Partnership may not make an
investment of more than five million dollars ($5,000,000) in any such company. In addition, without the
consent of the Advisory Committee, the Partnership shall not invest in any company in which the Managing
Members, the General Partner, the Management Company or any of their Affiliates hold a direct interest
(i.e., an interest not held through a Successor Fund, Prior Fund or other investment fund managed by any of
the General Partner, the Affiliated Parties or their Affiliates).

(e) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, the Partnership may not
purchase Securities from or sell Securities to the General Partner, any Parallel Fund or related entity, any
Affiliated Party, any Thiel Person or an Affiliate thereof or any investment fund managed thereby; provided,
however, that each Limited Partner hereby agrees that, following the final admission of Limited Partners
pursuant to paragraph 3.2(b) the Partnership may purchase Securities from or sell Securities to one or more
Parallel Funds at cost for the purpose of allocating then-existing Securities between such entities in
proportion to their respective available capital.

(f) Each Limited Partner hereby agrees that: (i) an Affiliated Party, an Affiliate
thereof or any member or employee of any of the foregoing, or any investment fund managed thereby may
invest personally in Securities of any portfolio company where the Securities of such portfolio company are,
at the time of such investment, Marketable Securities; provided that, the aggregate amount of any such
investments in the same portfolio company may not exceed 2% of the aggregate cost basis of the
Partnership's investment(s) in such portfolio company; and (ii) any Successor Fund or Prior Fund (or other
fund described in paragraph 8.3(b) to the extent the applicable investment does not meet the investment
objectives of the Partnership) may invest in a portfolio company of the Partnership.

(g) The General Partner shall use its reasonable best efforts to operate the Partnership
in a manner that will not cause any Partner subject to Section 511 of the Code to recognize unrelated
business taxable income under Section 512 of the Code or unrelated debt -financed income under Section
514 of the Code ("UBTF'); provided, however, that the Partnership may, subject to paragraph 8.4(n),
25.
126316015 v3
borrow money pending the due date of a capital call so long as such borrowing would be repaid promptly
following the delivery of capital due in connection with such capital call and would not create a material
likelihood that any Limited Partner subject to Section 511 of the Code would incur UBTI.

(h) For so long as "equity participation" in the Partnership by "benefit plan investors"
is "significant" (as such terms are defined in the DOL Regulations), (i) the General Partner shall use its
reasonable best efforts to operate the Partnership such that it qualifies as a "venture capital operating
company" under the DOL Regulations, (ii) at least 30 days prior to the end of the Partnership's "annual
valuation period" (as such term is defined in the DOL Regulations), the General Partner shall deliver to
each Limited Partner a certificate, prepared in consultation with counsel to the Partnership, which confirms
that the Partnership qualifies as a venture capital operating company and will continue to qualify as a
venture capital operating company immediately following the expiration of the annual valuation period and
(iii) the General Partner shall notify each Limited Partner as promptly as practicable following any
determination by the General Partner that there is a material likelihood that the Partnership has ceased to
qualify as a venture capital operating company.

(i) The General Partner shall use its commercially reasonable efforts to: (w) avoid
causing any Limited Partner, solely as a result of such Limited Partner's status as a limited partner in the
Partnership, to be required to file income tax returns other than any return, certification or statement
necessary to obtain a refund of or reduction in tax in any jurisdiction outside of the United States in
connection with the Partnership's investment in any portfolio company organized or with its principal place
of business or primary operations in such jurisdiction; (x) operate the Partnership in a manner that will not
cause it to be engaged in a "trade or business within the United States" within the meaning of Section 864(b)
of the Code; (y) avoid the Partnership realizing income that is or is treated as being "effectively connected"
with the conduct of a trade or business in the United States for United States federal income tax purposes;
and (z) prevent the Partnership from acquiring any interest in real property located in the United States for
purposes of Section 897 of the Code or in any company that is at the time of such investment a "United
States real property holding corporation" within the meaning of Section 897(c) of the Code.
After the General Partner has used commercially reasonable efforts to avoid the Partnership realizing
income that is or is treated as being "effectively connected" with the conduct of a trade or business in the
United States, if the General Partner has actual knowledge that a particular transaction will generate income
"effectively connected" with a trade or business in the United States (within the meaning of the Code), or
similar income in another country, the General Partner shall use reasonable best efforts to provide each
Limited Partner with such information that is reasonably available to the General Partner and which such
Limited Partner reasonably requests in order to file any federal, state or local tax return in the United States
or such other country in which such income is generated.

For transactions causing any Limited Partner, solely as a result of such Limited Partner's status as a limited
partner in the Partnership, to be required to file income tax returns other than any return, certification or
statement necessary to obtain a refund of or reduction in tax in any jurisdiction outside of the United States
in connection with the Partnership's investment in any portfolio company organized or with its principal
place of business or primary operations in such jurisdiction, the General Partner shall use commercially
reasonable efforts to provide such Limited Partner with such information that is reasonably available to the
General Partner and which such Limited Partner reasonably requests in order to file income tax return in
such jurisdiction.
Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, the Partnership may not
invest more than five percent (5%) of the Partnership's Committed Capital in a "blind pool" investment
fund that is managed and controlled by an unaffiliated third party and that pays its manager performance
based compensation.
26.
126316015 v3

(k) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, no more than twenty-five
percent (25%) of the Partnership's aggregate Capital Commitments (determined on the basis of acquisition
cost at the time of investment) may be invested in the Securities of, or loaned to, any one (1) portfolio
company (including, for this purpose, the Affiliates of such portfolio company).

(I) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, not more than fifteen
percent (15%) of the Partnership's Capital Commitments (determined on the basis of acquisition cost at the
time of investment) may be invested in Securities that are publicly traded, excluding Securities issued in a
private offering by an issuer who then also has outstanding publicly -traded Securities.

(m) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee and subject to paragraph
8.4(g), the General Partner may not cause the Partnership to incur debt, or guaranty indebtedness of the
Partnership's portfolio companies (and including, for this purpose, their respective Affiliates), in an
aggregate amount exceeding the lesser of (A) ten percent (10%) of the Partnership's Capital Commitments
(determined on the basis of acquisition cost at the time of investment) and (B) the amount of aggregate
Capital Commitments of the Partners that have not been contributed to the Partnership as of the date of such
debt or guaranty indebtedness; provided, however, that amounts borrowed by the Partnership pending the
due date of a capital call, which are due to be, and are, fully repaid promptly following the delivery of
capital from the Partners which was due in connection with such capital call shall not be treated as
indebtedness of the Partnership for purposes of the limitation in this paragraph 8.4(m).
(n) The cumulative aggregate cost basis of portfolio company investments made by
the Partnership may not exceed one hundred twenty percent (120%) of the aggregate Capital Commitments
of the Partners.
ARTICLE 9
INVESTMENT REPRESENTATION AND TRANSFER
OF PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS
9.1 Investment Representation of the Limited Partners. This Agreement is made with each
of the Limited Partners in reliance upon each Limited Partner's representation to the Partnership, which by
executing this Agreement each Limited Partner hereby confirms, that its interest in the Partnership is to be
acquired for investment, and not with a view to the sale or distribution of any part thereof, and that it has no
present intention of selling, granting participation in, or otherwise distributing the same, and each Limited
Partner understands that its interest in the Partnership has not been registered under the Securities Act and
that any transfer or other disposition of the interest may not be made without registration under the
Securities Act or pursuant to an applicable exemption therefrom. Each Limited Partner further represents
that it does not have any contract, undertaking, agreement, or arrangement with any person to sell, transfer,
or grant participations to such person, or to any third person, with respect to its interest in the Partnership.
9.2 Qualifications of the Limited Partners. Each Limited Partner represents that it is an
"accredited investor" within the meaning of that term as defined in Regulation D promulgated under the
Securities Act.

9.3 Transfer by General Partner. The General Partner shall not sell, assign, mortgage,
pledge or otherwise dispose of its interest in the Partnership or in its capital assets or property without the
prior written consent of Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners. Admissions of new members of the
General Partner or the transfer of interests in the General Partner by its members shall not be deemed to be
a sale or other disposition of the General Partner's interest in the Partnership for purposes of this paragraph
9.3; provided, however, that without the prior consent of a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners, new
27.
126316015 v3
members may not be admitted to the General Partner, and interests in the General Partner may not be
transferred, to the extent that the effect of such admissions and transfers would result in fifty percent (50%)
or more of the interests in the General Partner being owned by persons who are not Managing Members.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, in no event shall the General Partner make any transfer of an interest in the
Partnership prohibited by the events described in paragraphs 9.5(a) through 9.5(h).
9.4 Transfer by Limited Partner. No Limited Partner shall sell, assign, pledge, mortgage, or
otherwise dispose of or transfer its interest in the Partnership, directly or indirectly, without the prior written
consent of the General Partner, which consent may be granted or denied in the sole discretion of the General
Partner (which consent shall not be required in the event of a transfer pursuant to the following sentence of
this paragraph 9.4). Notwithstanding the foregoing, after delivery of the opinion of counsel hereinafter
required by this Article 9 (provided, however, that the General Partner may, in its sole discretion, waive the
requirement of an opinion of counsel), a Limited Partner may sell, assign, pledge, mortgage, or otherwise
dispose of or transfer its interest in the Partnership, directly or indirectly, without such consent (a) to any
entity directly or indirectly holding eighty percent (80%) or more of the ownership interests of the Limited
Partner (including profits or other economic interests) or any entity of which eighty percent (80%) or more
of the beneficial ownership (including profits or other economic interests) are held directly or indirectly by
such entity, including any entity of which the Limited Partner holds, directly or indirectly, eighty percent
(80%) or more of the beneficial ownership (including profits or other economic interests), (b) pursuant to a
merger, plan of reorganization, sale or pledge of, or other general encumbrance on all or substantially all of
the Limited Partner's assets, (c) as may be required by any law or regulation, (d) by testamentary
disposition or intestate succession, (e) to a trust, profit sharing plan or other entity controlled by, or for the
benefit of, such Limited Partner or one or more of its family members or (f) during the six (6) month period
immediately following its admission as a Limited Partner, to an Affiliate entity that is also a Limited Partner
where the sole purpose of such transfer is to adjust the relative holdings of such Affiliate and the original
Limited Partner. A change in any trustee or fiduciary of the Limited Partner shall not be considered to be a
transfer, sale, assignment, mortgage, pledge or other disposition under this paragraph 9.4, provided written
notice of such change is given to the General Partner within a reasonable period of time after the effective
date thereof.

9.5 Requirements for Transfer. No transfer or other disposition of the interest of the Limited
Partner shall be permitted until the General Partner shall have received an opinion of counsel satisfactory to
it (or waived such opinion requirement) that the effect of such transfer or disposition would not:

(a) result in the Partnership's assets, or any portion thereof, being considered, in the
opinion of counsel for the Partnership, as "plan assets" within the meaning of the DOL Regulations, or
result in a non-exempt prohibited transaction under Section 4975 of the Code;

(b) result in a violation of the Securities Act or any comparable state law;
(c) require the Partnership to register as an investment company under the Investment
Company Act of 1940, as amended;

(d) require the Partnership, the General Partner, or any member of the General Partner
to register as an investment adviser under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended;

(e) result in a termination of the Partnership's status as a partnership for tax purposes;
(t) result in a violation of any law, rule, or regulation by the Limited Partner, the
Partnership, the General Partner, or any member of the General Partner;
28.
126316015 v3

(g) cause the Partnership to be deemed to be a "publicly traded partnership" as such
term is defined in Section 7704(b) of the Code; or
(h) result in a violation of this Agreement.

Such legal opinion shall be provided to the General Partner by the transferring Limited Partner or the
proposed transferee. Any costs associated with such opinion shall be borne by the transferring Limited
Partner or the proposed transferee. Upon request, the General Partner will use its good faith diligent efforts
to provide any information possessed by the Partnership and reasonably requested by a transferring Limited
Partner to enable it to render the foregoing opinion. Notwithstanding any provision of this Article 9 to the
contrary, the General Partner may, in its sole discretion, waive the requirement of an opinion of counsel
provided for in this paragraph 9.5. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, in no event shall the
General Partner consent to any transfer of an interest in the Partnership, or waive the requirement of an
opinion of counsel with respect to any transfer for which the consent of the General Partner is not required,
if such transfer would, in the reasonable determination of the General Partner, result in any of the events
described in paragraphs 9.5(a) through 9.5(h). Any transfer of an interest in the Partnership in violation of
the requirements of paragraph 9.4 or this paragraph 9.5 shall be null and void ab initio.
9.6 Substitution as a Limited Partner. A transferee of a Limited Partner's interest pursuant
to this Article 9 shall become a substituted Limited Partner only with the consent of the General Partner
(which consent shall not be required in the event of a transfer pursuant to paragraph 9.4(0) and only if such
transferee (a) elects to become a substituted Limited Partner and (b) executes, acknowledges and delivers to
the Partnership such other instruments as the General Partner may deem necessary or advisable to effect the
admission of such transferee as a substituted Limited Partner, including, without limitation, the written
acceptance and adoption by such transferee of the provisions of this Agreement. No assignment by a
Limited Partner of its interest in the Partnership shall release the assignor from its liabilities to the
Partnership, including but not limited to those liabilities enumerated in paragraph 4.2; provided, however if
the assignee becomes a Limited Partner as provided in this paragraph 9.6, the assignor shall thereupon so be
released (in the case of a partial assignment, to the extent of such assignment).

9.7 Expenses of Transfer. Any costs or expenses (including but not limited to reasonable
attorneys' fees) incurred by the Partnership in connection with the transfer of a Partnership interest
hereunder (including any costs associated with any opinion rendered pursuant to paragraph 9.5 above) shall
be borne jointly and severally by the transferring Limited Partner and the proposed transferee.
ARTICLE 10
DISSOLUTION AND LIQUIDATION OF THE PARTNERSHIP
10.1 Extension of Partnership Term. Upon the Termination Date, or such subsequent dates to
which the Partnership term has previously been extended pursuant to this paragraph 10.1, the General
Partner in its sole discretion may extend the Partnership term for up to two (2) additional one (1) year
periods and, thereafter and with the consent of a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners, for additional
one ( 1) year periods thereafter. During any such one (1) year extension periods, the General Partner shall
use its reasonable efforts to convert the Partnership's Nonmarketable Securities into Marketable Securities
or cash, and all Securities that become Marketable Securities during such period or periods shall be
promptly distributed by the Partnership. The General Partner shall not purchase the Securities of any new
issuer in which the Partnership does not already hold an interest during such period; provided, however, that
the General Partner may (a) purchase additional Securities of a portfolio company if it deems such a
purchase to be in the best interests of the Partnership, and (b) exchange the Securities of a portfolio
company for other Securities. The Management Fee for each fiscal quarter during an extension period (i)
29.
126316015 v3
shall be an amount equal to the product of (A) the lower of (I) the cost basis of the portfolio company
Securities held by the Partnership as of the first day of such fiscal quarter and (II) the fair market value of
such Securities multiplied by (B) the Management Fee Percentage in effect as of the first day of such fiscal
quarter (as determined under Article 6), and (ii) shall otherwise be governed by the provisions set forth in
Article 6.
10.2 Early Termination of the Partnership.

(a) The Partnership shall dissolve, and the affairs of the Partnership shall be wound up
prior to the Termination Date (or such subsequent dates to which the Partnership term has previously been
extended pursuant to paragraph 10.1):

(i) ninety (90) days after the withdrawal, bankruptcy, or dissolution of the
General Partner, unless a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners elect to continue the Partnership
within such ninety (90) day period;
upon the election of Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners within
sixty days (60) days of the delivery of the notice of Trigger Event; or
(iii) at any time upon the election of Eighty Percent (80%) in Interest of the
Limited Partners.

(b) In the event that the Partnership is dissolved pursuant to the provisions of this
paragraph 10.2, a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners shall elect one or more liquidators to manage
the liquidation of the Partnership in the manner described in paragraphs 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5.
10.3 Winding Up Procedures.

(a) Promptly upon dissolution of the Partnership (unless the Partnership is continued
in accordance with this Agreement or the provisions of the Act), the affairs of the Partnership shall be
wound up and the Partnership liquidated. The closing Capital Accounts of all the Partners shall be
computed as of the date of dissolution as if the date of dissolution were the last day of an Accounting Period
in accordance with Article 5, and then adjusted in the following manner:

(i) All assets and liabilities of the Partnership shall be valued as of the date of
dissolution.
(ii) The Partnership's assets as of the date of dissolution shall be deemed to
have been sold at their fair market values and the resulting Profit or Loss shall be allocated to the Partners'
Capital Accounts in accordance with the provisions of Article 5.

(b) Distributions during the winding up period may be made in cash or in kind or
partly in cash and partly in kind; provided, however, that the General Partner or the liquidator, as the case
may be, shall notify the Limited Partners at least ten (10) business days prior to making a distribution in
kind pursuant to this paragraph 10.3(b). The General Partner or the liquidator shall use its best judgment as
to the most advantageous time for the Partnership to sell Securities or to make distributions in kind. All
cash and each Security distributed in kind after the date of dissolution of the Partnership shall be distributed
ratably in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 4.2(d), if applicable, but otherwise in accordance
with Article 7, unless such distribution would result in a violation of a law or regulation applicable to a
Limited Partner, in which event, upon receipt by the General Partner of notice to such effect, such Limited
Partner may designate a different entity to receive the distribution, or designate, subject to the approval of
30.
126316015 v3
the General Partner (which may be withheld in the General Partner's sole discretion), an alternative
distribution procedure (provided, however, that such alternative distribution procedure does not prejudice
any of the other Partners). Each Security so distributed shall be subject to reasonable conditions and
restrictions necessary or advisable, as determined in the reasonable discretion of the General Partner or the
liquidator, in order to preserve the value of such Security or for legal reasons.

10.4 Payments in Liquidation. The assets of the Partnership shall be distributed in final
liquidation of the Partnership in the following order:

(a) to the creditors of the Partnership, including those Partners who are creditors of the
Partnership, in the order of priority established by law, either by payment or by establishment of reserves;
and

(b) the balance, if any, to the General Partner and the Limited Partners as if such
distributions were made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(b) and paragraph 7.5(a), as applicable; provided,
however, that the General Partner shall be obligated to contribute to the Partnership an amount in cash, or
Securities (previously distributed in kind from the Partnership) with a fair market value equal to the
amounts the General Partner is obligated to pay back under paragraph 10.5(a).
10.5 Return of Excess Distributions.

(a) Notwithstanding paragraphs 7.3 and 10.4, upon liquidation of the Partnership
pursuant to this Article 10, the General Partner shall be required to pay back to the Partnership the amount
by which the Carried Interest Distributions (as defined below in paragraph 10.5(b)) exceeds (i) in the event
that the First Allocation Hurdle has not been met, 20% of the aggregate distributions made to the Partners
pursuant to paragraphs 7.5(a)(ii)-(vi), (ii) in the event that the First Allocation Hurdle has been met but the
Second Allocation Hurdle has not been met, 25% of the aggregate distributions made to the Partners
pursuant to paragraphs 7.5(a)(ii)-(vi), or (iii) in the event that the Second Allocation Hurdle has been met,
30% of the aggregate distributions made to the Partners pursuant to paragraphs 7.5(a)(ii)-(vi).
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the General Partner's payment obligation pursuant to this paragraph 10.5(a)
shall not exceed the After-Tax Distribution Amount (as defined below in paragraph 10.5(b)).

(b) For purposes of this paragraph 10.5: (i) the "Carried Interest Distributions" shall
equal all distributions to the General Partner other than distributions made to the General Partner in respect
of its Partnership Percentage (excluding amounts returned to the Partnership by the General Partner
pursuant to paragraphs 4.2(d)(ii) prior to final liquidation of the Partnership); and (ii) the "After -Tax
Distribution Amount" shall be equal to the Carried Interest Distributions, less the gross tax liabilities that
the General Partner would have incurred on all allocations of taxable income (net of losses) made with
respect to the General Partner's interest in the Company (other than the portion of its interest attributable to
its Partnership Percentage) if: (x) at all times the General Partner were subject to the highest blended federal,
state and local marginal income tax rate then applicable to an individual residing in any state in the United
States, applied by taking into account the character of the taxable income in question (i.e., long-term capital
gains, ordinary income, etc.); and (y) all such allocations resulted from fully taxable transactions, plus any
tax benefit actually received by the General Partner in the year in which the General Partner is required to
make a payment pursuant to this paragraph 10.5, as reasonably determined by the General Partner, which
such tax benefit is attributable solely to the making of such payment and which benefit shall be determined
after first taking all other items of income, gain, loss, deduction or credit of the General Partner (or its direct
or indirect owners) into account.

(c) In the event that the assets of the General Partner are insufficient to satisfy the
obligation described in paragraph 10.5(b), each Managing Member and managing member of the General
31.
126316015 v3
Partner shall be severally liable for and shall personally guaranty his or her pro rata share of the General
Partner's remaining obligation to the Partnership under this paragraph 10.5 by executing a written guaranty
(in substantially the same form provided to the Limited Partners prior to the date first written above). The
pro rata shares described in the preceding sentence shall be based on relative distributions received by each
such Managing Member, or managing member of the General Partner, from the General Partner. The
General Partner's operating agreement shall contain a provision requiring each newly-admitted managing
member to personally guaranty his, her or its respective pro rata share of the General Partner's obligation
under this paragraph 10.5 by executing a written guaranty (in substantially the same form provided to the
Limited Partners prior to the date first written above).
(d) In addition to the amount to be contributed by the General Partner pursuant to
paragraph 10.5(a), if, upon liquidation of the Partnership, the cumulative Fee Adjustments applied against
Management Fees paid pursuant to paragraph 6.1 for all Accounting Periods, exceeds the sum of (i) the
cumulative Profits of the Partnership for all Accounting Periods less (ii) the cumulative Losses of the
Partnership for all Accounting Periods (such amount the "Deemed Contribution Shortfall"), then the
General Partner or its designated Affiliate with a capital contribution obligation shall be required to pay
back to the Partnership, the lesser of (x) the Deemed Contribution Shortfall and (y) the distributions
received by the General Partner that are attributable to the cumulative amount of Profit allocated to the
General Partner pursuant to paragraph 5.I(a)(i), in each case less the gross tax liabilities that the General
Partner would have incurred on all allocations of taxable income (net of losses) made with respect to the Fee
Adjustments if: (x) at all times the General Partner or its designated Affiliate were subject to the highest
blended federal, state and local marginal income tax rate then applicable to an individual residing in any
state in the United States, applied by taking into account the character of the taxable income in question (i.e.,
long-term capital gains, ordinary income, etc.); and (y) all such allocations resulted from fully taxable
transactions, plus any tax benefit actually received by the General Partner or its designated Affiliate in the
year in which the payment is required pursuant to this paragraph 10.5(d), as reasonably determined by the
General Partner, which such tax benefit is attributable solely to the making of such payment and which
benefit shall be determined after first taking all other items of income, gain, loss, deduction or credit of the
General Partner or its designated Affiliate (or their direct or indirect owners) into account. In the event that
the assets of the General Partner or its designated Affiliate are insufficient to satisfy the obligation
described in the preceding sentence, all members of the General Partner or its designated Affiliate will on a
several, but not joint, basis contribute capital to the General Partner or its designated Affiliate in an amount
equal to each such member's pro rata share of the remaining obligation to the Partnership (based on the
member's pro rata participation in any Cashless Portion of any capital contributions to the Partnership).
ARTICLE 11
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING, REPORTS AND MEETINGS
11.1 Financial Accounting; Fiscal Year. The books and records of the Partnership shall be
kept in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement and otherwise in accordance with generally
accepted accounting principles consistently applied, and shall be audited at the end of each fiscal year
beginning with fiscal year 2016 by an independent public accountant selected by the General Partner. The
Partnership's fiscal year shall be the calendar year.
11.2 Supervision; Inspection of Books. Proper and complete books of account of the
Partnership, copies of the Partnership's federal, state and local tax returns for each fiscal year, the Schedule
of Partners set forth in EXHIBIT A, this Agreement and the Partnership's Certificate of Limited Partnership
shall be kept under the supervision of the General Partner at the principal office of the Partnership. Such
books and records shall be open to inspection (including by email or other electronic means) by the Limited
32.
126316015 v3
Partners, or their accredited representatives, at not less than three (3) business days' notice, at any
reasonable time during normal business hours.

11.3 Quarterly Reports. The General Partner shall use reasonable best efforts to transmit to
the Limited Partners, within sixty (60) days after the close of each of the first three quarters of each fiscal
year beginning with fiscal year 2016, a list of investments then held, together with a valuation of the
investments then held and unaudited financial statements of the Partnership, including a statement of capital
accounts.

11.4 Annual Report; Financial Statements of the Partnership. Beginning with fiscal year
2016, the General Partner shall use reasonable best efforts to transmit to the Limited Partners within ninety
(90) days after the close of the Partnership's fiscal year audited financial statements of the Partnership
prepared in accordance with the terms of this Agreement and otherwise in accordance with generally
accepted accounting principles, including an income statement for the year then ended and a balance sheet
as of the end of such year, a statement of changes in the Partners' Capital Accounts, and a list of
investments then held. The financial statements shall be accompanied by a report from the General Partner
to the Limited Partners, which shall include a status report on investments then held, a summary of
acquisitions and dispositions of investments made by the Partnership during the preceding quarter and a
valuation of each such investment.

11.5 Website Based Reporting. The General Partner shall be entitled, in its sole discretion, to
transmit the reports and statements described in paragraphs 11.3 and 11.4 (the "Subject Reports") to one or
more Limited Partners solely by means of granting such Limited Partners access to a database or other
forum hosted on a website designated by the General Partner (the "Reporting Site"), with such parameters
regarding access and availability of information for review as the General Partner deems reasonably
necessary to protect the confidentiality and proprietary nature of the information contained therein
(including, but not limited to, establishing password protections for access to the Reporting Site and having
such Subject Reports available for review for a restricted period of time (but in no event less than thirty (30)
days from the date the Limited Partners are notified that such Subject Reports are posted on the Reporting
Site)). The General Partner shall provide each Limited Partner to which it will transmit Subject Reports
pursuant to this paragraph 11.5 notice of the first date on which a new Subject Report will be posted on the
Reporting Site for such Limited Partner's review and shall either (i) make each Subject Report printable or

(ii) upon written request by a Limited Partner, deliver a mailed copy of the Subject Report to such Limited
Partner. Unless the General Partner exercises its discretion pursuant to and in compliance with paragraph
15.15(c) to restrict access to certain Confidential Information that may be included in a Subject Report
posted on the Reporting Site, the Subject Reports posted on the Reporting Site shall contain all of the
material information included in those Subject Reports transmitted to Limited Partners other than pursuant
to this paragraph 11.5 and shall be print-capable. The Subject Reports shall be posted on the Reporting Site
within the same number of days after the end of the applicable fiscal quarter or Fiscal Year as is required
pursuant to paragraphs 11.3 and 11.4.

11.6 Annual Meeting. A meeting of the Partners shall be held annually from the year of 2016.
Such annual meeting may be held at the principal office of the Partnership (unless otherwise designated by
the General Partner) or be held by conference call as determined by the General Partner.
11.7 Tax Returns.

(a) The General Partner shall endeavor to cause the Partnership's estimated federal,
state and local tax returns, IRS Form 1065, Schedule K-1 and any other tax information reasonably
requested by a Limited Partner to be prepared and delivered to the Limited Partners within ninety (90) days
after the close of the Partnership's fiscal year.
33.
126316015 v3
(b) Each Limited Partner hereby agrees and covenants that it shall not make an
election under Section 732(d) of the Code with respect to property distributed to it by the Partnership
without the prior written consent of the General Partner. The General Partner may, but shall not be
obligated to, cause the Partnership to make an election under Section 754 of the Code or an election to be
treated as an "electing investment partnership" within the meaning of Section 743(e) of the Code. If the
Partnership elects to be treated as an electing investment partnership, each Limited Partner shall (i)
reasonably cooperate with the Partnership to maintain such status, (ii) shall not take any action that would
be reasonably inconsistent with such election, (iii) provide the General Partner with any information
necessary to allow the Partnership to comply with its obligations to make tax basis adjustments under
Sections 734 or 743 of the Code and its tax reporting and other obligations as an electing investment
partnership, and (iv) provide the General Partner and any such Limited Partner's transferee (if applicable),
promptly upon request, with the information required under Section 6031(b) of the Code or otherwise to be
furnished to the Partnership or such transferee, including such information as is reasonably necessary to
enable the Partnership and such transferee to compute the amount of losses disallowed under Section 743(e)
of the Code, but in no event shall such Limited Partner be required to provide such information prior to its
receipt of its Schedule K-I for such taxable year, except to the extent of information, if any, required by the
Partnership to complete its Schedule K-Is. Whether or not the Partnership makes such election, promptly
upon request, each Limited Partner shall provide the General Partner with any information related to such
Partner reasonably necessary to allow the Partnership to comply with (i) its obligations to make tax basis
adjustments under Sections 734 or 743 of the Code and (ii) any other tax reporting obligations of the
Partnership.

11.8 Tax Matters Partner. The General Partner shall be the Partnership's tax matters partner
under the Code and under any comparable provision of state law. The General Partner shall have the right
to resign as tax matters partner by giving thirty (30) days' written notice to each Partner. Upon such
resignation a successor tax matters partner shall be selected by a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners.
The tax matters partner shall employ experienced tax counsel to represent the Partnership in connection
with any audit or investigation of the Partnership by the Internal Revenue Service and in connection with all
subsequent administrative and judicial proceedings arising out of such audit. If the tax matters partner is
required by law or regulation to incur fees and expenses in connection with tax matters not affecting all the
Partners, then the Partnership shall be entitled to reimbursement from those Partners on whose behalf such
fees and expenses were incurred. The tax matters partner shall keep the Partners informed of all
administrative and judicial proceedings, as required by Section 6223(g) of the Code, and shall furnish to
each Partner, if such Partner so requests in writing, a copy of each notice or other communication received
by the tax matters partner from the Internal Revenue Service, except such notices or communications as are
sent directly to such requesting Partner by the Internal Revenue Service. The relationship of the tax matters
partner to the Limited Partners is that of a fiduciary, and the tax matters partner has fiduciary obligations to
perform its duties as tax matters partner in such manner as will serve the best interests of the Partnership and
all of the Partnership's Partners. To the fullest extent permitted by law, but subject to the limitations and
exclusions of paragraph 15.4, the Partnership agrees to indemnify the tax matters partner and its agents and
save and hold them harmless, from and in respect to all (a) fees, costs and expenses in connection with or
resulting from any claim, action, or demand against the tax matters partner, the General Partner or the
Partnership that arise out of or in any way relate to the tax matters partner's status as tax matters partner for
the Partnership, and (b) all such claims, actions, and demands and any losses or damages therefrom,
including amounts paid in settlement or compromise of any such claim, action, or demand.
11.9 Partnership Funds. Cash held by the Partnership shall be promptly deposited into an
account in a reputable bank or financial institution (as determined by the General Partner in its reasonable
discretion).
34.
126316015 v3
ARTICLE 12
VALUATION; ADVISORY COMMITTEE
12.1 Valuation. Subject to the specific standards set forth below, the valuation of Securities
and other assets and liabilities under this Agreement shall be at fair market value. Except as may be
required under applicable Treasury Regulations, no value shall be placed on the goodwill or the name of the
Partnership in determining the value of the interest of any Partner or in any accounting among the Partners.

(a) The following criteria shall be used for determining the fair market value of
Securities:
(i) If traded on one or more securities exchanges or the NASDAQ National
Market System, the value shall be deemed to be the Securities' closing price on the principal of such
exchanges on the valuation date.
If actively traded over the counter (other than on the NASDAQ National
Market System), the value shall be deemed to be the closing price of such Securities on the valuation date.
(iii) If there is no active public market, the value shall be the fair market value
thereof, as determined by the General Partner, taking into consideration the purchase price of the Securities,
developments concerning the investee company subsequent to the acquisition of the Securities, any
financial data and projections of the investee company provided to the General Partner, and such other
factor or factors as the General Partner may deem relevant.

(b) If the General Partner in good faith determines that, because of special
circumstances, the valuation methods set forth in this Article 12 do not fairly determine the value of a
Security, the General Partner shall make such adjustments or use such alternative valuation method as it
deems appropriate.

(c) The General Partner shall have the power at any time to determine, for all purposes
of this Agreement, the fair market value of any assets and liabilities of the Partnership, subject to paragraph
12.1(d).

(d) If within thirty (30) days of receipt of a proposed valuation established by the
General Partner pursuant to this paragraph 12.1, the Advisory Committee notifies the General Partner of an
objection to such proposed valuation, then, if the General Partner and the Advisory Committee cannot
otherwise mutually agree on the valuation, the General Partner and the Advisory Committee may each
appoint an independent securities expert to render a valuation, and the average of such experts valuations
shall be adopted as the Partnership's valuation. The fees and expenses of any expert retained in accordance
with this paragraph I2.1(d) shall be borne by the Partnership.

12.2 Advisory Conunittee. The General Partner will appoint an Advisory Committee (the
"Advisory Committee") that will serve as such for the Partnership and the Parallel Funds and shall consist of
no less than three (3) and no more than seven (7) representatives of the Limited Partners and constituent
limited partners of Parallel Funds selected by the General Partner from time to time in its reasonable
judgment; provided, however, that any Limited Partner that is an Affiliate of the General Partner, the
Management Company, any Managing Member or any of their respective members, employees or
Affiliates may not be appointed to be a member of the Advisory Committee; provided, further, that if the
General Partner affirmatively removes a representative of a Limited Partner from serving on the Advisory
Committee, other than for conduct that the General Partner determines in its reasonable discretion, is
35.
126316015 v3
harmful to the Partnership or a Parallel Fund, then such Limited Partner shall be entitled to appoint a
replacement member of the Advisory Committee who is reasonably acceptable to the General Partner. The
duties of the Advisory Committee will include: (a) consideration of any approvals sought by the General
Partner pursuant to the terms of this Agreement; (b) upon request by the General Partner, advising with
respect to all matters pertaining to conflicts of interest by the Partnership, the General Partner or any of the
members of the General Partner; and (c) such advice and counsel as is requested by the General Partner in
connection with the Partnership's investments and other Partnership matters. However, subject to
paragraph 12.1(d), the General Partner will retain ultimate responsibility for asset valuations and for
making all investment decisions. The Partnership will reimburse each member for his or her reasonable
out-of-pocket expenses. All actions, consents or approvals of the Advisory Committee shall require a
majority of its members serving at the time such action, consent or approval is taken, which actions,
consents or approvals may be carried out by telephone, facsimile or electronic mail or other means
reasonably acceptable to the General Partner.
ARTICLE 13
PARTNERS SUBJECT TO SPECIAL REGULATION
13.1 ERISA Partners.

Each Limited Partner that is, or whose equity interests are at least partially owned
by, a "benefit plan investor" within the meaning of, and subject to the provisions of, ERISA, (each, an
"ERISA Partner") hereby (i) acknowledges that it is its understanding that neither the Partnership, the
General Partner, nor any of the Affiliated Entities of the General Partner, are "fiduciaries" of such Limited
Partner within the meaning of ERISA by reason of the Limited Partner investing its assets in, and being a
Limited Partner of, the Partnership; (ii) acknowledges that it has been informed of and understands the
investment objectives and policies of, and the investment strategies that may be pursued by, the Partnership;
(iii) acknowledges that it is aware of the provisions of Section 404 of ERISA relating to the requirements
for investment and diversification of the assets of employee benefit plans and trusts subject to ERISA; (iv)
represents that it has given appropriate consideration to the facts and circumstances relevant to the
investment by that ERISA Partner's plan in the Partnership and has determined that such investment is
reasonably designed, as part of such portfolio, to further the purposes of such plan; (v) represents that,
taking into account the other investments made with the assets of such plan, and the diversification thereof,
such plan's investment in the Partnership is consistent with the requirements of Section 404 and other
provisions of ERISA; (vi) acknowledges that it understands that current income will not be a primary
objective of the Partnership; and (vii) represents that, taking into account the other investments made with
the assets of such plan, the investment of assets of such plan in the Partnership is consistent with the cash
flow requirements and funding objectives of such plan.

(b) Notwithstanding any provision contained herein to the contrary, each ERISA
Partner may elect to withdraw from the Partnership, or upon demand by the General Partner shall withdraw
from the Partnership, at the time and in the manner hereinafter provided, if either the ERISA Partner or the
General Partner shall obtain an opinion of counsel (which counsel shall be reasonably acceptable to both the
ERISA Partner and the General Partner) to the effect that, as a result of applicable statutes, regulations, case
law, administrative interpretations, or similar authority (i) the continuation of the ERISA Partner as a
Limited Partner of the Partnership or the conduct of the Partnership will result, or there is a material
likelihood the same will result, in a material violation of ERISA, or (ii) all or any portion of the assets of the
Partnership constitute assets of the ERISA Partner and are subject to the provisions of ERISA to
substantially the same extent as if owned directly by the ERISA Partner. In the event of the issuance of such
opinion of counsel, a copy of such opinion shall be given to all the ERISA Partners, together with the
written notice of the election of the ERISA Partner to withdraw or the written demand of the General
36.
126316015 v3
Partner for withdrawal, whichever the case may be. Thereupon, unless within ninety (90) days after receipt
of such written notice and opinion the General Partner is able to eliminate the necessity for such withdrawal
to the reasonable satisfaction of the ERISA Partner and the General Partner, whether by correction of the
condition giving rise to the necessity of the ERISA Partner's withdrawal, or the amendment of this
Agreement, or otherwise, such ERISA Partner shall withdraw its entire interest in the Partnership, such
withdrawal to be effective upon the last day of the fiscal quarter during which such ninety (90) day period
expired.

(c) The withdrawing ERISA Partner shall be entitled to receive within ninety (90)
days after the date of such withdrawal an amount equal to the amount of such Partner's Capital Account as
of the effective date of such withdrawal.

(d) Any distribution or payment to a withdrawing ERISA Partner pursuant to this
paragraph may, in the sole discretion of the General Partner, be made in cash, in securities, in the form of a
promissory note, the terms of which shall be mutually agreed upon by the General Partner and the
withdrawing ERISA Partner, or any combination thereof.
(e) Any valuation necessary for the purposes of a distribution or payment to a
withdrawing ERISA Partner pursuant to this paragraph shall be made by the General Partner in good faith
pursuant to paragraph 12.1.

13.2 Governmental Plan Partners. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the
contrary, any Limited Partner that is either a -governmental plan" as defined in Title 29, Section 1002(32)
of the United States Code or an employee benefit plan subject to Governmental Plan Regulations (a
"Governmental Plan Partner") may elect to withdraw from the Partnership, or upon demand by the
General Partner shall withdraw from the Partnership, if either the Governmental Plan Partner or the General
Partner shall obtain an opinion of counsel (which counsel shall be reasonably acceptable to both the
Governmental Plan Partner and the General Partner) to the effect that the Governmental Plan Partner, the
Partnership, or the General Partner would be in violation, or there is a material likelihood the same would
result, of any Governmental Plan Regulation, as a result of the Governmental Plan Partner continuing as a
Limited Partner, and, in the case of an opinion obtained by the General Partner, that such violation would
have a material adverse effect on the General Partner or the Partnership. In the event of the issuance of the
opinion of counsel referred to in the preceding sentence, the withdrawal of and disposition of the
Governmental Plan Partner's interest in the Partnership shall be governed by paragraph 13.1 of the
Agreement, as if the Governmental Plan Partner were an ERISA Partner.

13.3 Private Foundation Partners. Notwithstanding any provision of the Agreement to the
contrary, any Limited Partner that is, or whose equity interests are at least partially owned by, a "private
foundation" as described in Section 509 of the Code (a "Private Foundation Partner"), may elect to
withdraw from the Partnership, or upon demand by the General Partner shall withdraw from the Partnership,
if either the Private Foundation Partner or the General Partner shall obtain an opinion of counsel (which
counsel shall be reasonably acceptable to both the Private Foundation Partner and the General Partner) to
the effect that such withdrawal is necessary in order for the Private Foundation Partner to avoid (a) excise
taxes imposed by Subchapter A of Chapter 42 of the Code (other than Sections 4940 and 4942 thereof), or

(b) a material breach of the fiduciary duties of its trustees under any federal or state law applicable to private
foundations or any rule or regulation adopted thereunder by any agency, commission, or authority having
jurisdiction. In the event of the issuance of the opinion of counsel referred to in the preceding sentence, the
withdrawal of and disposition of the Private Foundation Partner's interest in the Partnership shall be
governed by paragraph 13.1, as if the Private Foundation Partner were an ERISA Partner.
37.
126316015 v3
ARTICLE 14
CERTAIN DEFINITIONS
14.1 Accounting Period. An Accounting Period shall be (a) a calendar year if there are no
changes in the Partners' respective interests in the Profits or Losses of the Partnership during such calendar
year except on the first day thereof, or (b) any other period beginning on the first day of a calendar year, or
any other day during a calendar year upon which occurs a change in such respective interests, and ending on
the last day of a calendar year, or on the day preceding an earlier day upon which any change in such
respective interests shall occur.

14.2 Adjusted Asset Value. The Adjusted Asset Value with respect to any asset shall be the
asset's adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes, except as follows:

(a) The initial Adjusted Asset Value of any asset contributed by a Partner to the
Partnership shall be the gross fair market value of such asset at the time of contribution, as determined by
the contributing Partner and the Partnership.

(b) In the discretion of the General Partner, the Adjusted Asset Values of all
Partnership assets may be adjusted to equal their respective gross fair market values, as determined by the
General Partner, and the resulting unrealized profit or loss allocated to the Capital Accounts of the Partners
pursuant to Article 5, as of the following times: (i) upon distribution by the Partnership to a Partner of more
than a de minimis amount of Partnership assets, unless all Partners receive simultaneous distributions of
either undivided interests in the distributed property or identical Partnership assets in proportion to their
interests in Partnership distributions as provided in paragraphs 7.4, 7.5 and 7.6, and (ii) the grant of an
additional interest in the Partnership by any new or existing Partner.

(c) The Adjusted Asset Values of all Partnership assets shall be adjusted to equal their
respective gross fair market values, as determined by the General Partner, and the resulting unrealized
profit or loss allocated to the Capital Accounts of the Partners pursuant to Article 5, as of the termination of
the Partnership either by expiration of the Partnership's term or the occurrence of an event described in
paragraph 10.2.

14.3 Adjusted Capital Account Balance. The Adjusted Capital Account Balance for each
Partner shall be equal to the balance in the Partner's Capital Account as of the end of the relevant
Accounting Period, after giving effect to the following adjustments:

(a) Credit to such Capital Account any amounts which the Partner is obligated to
restore (calculated as if all assets of the Partnership were sold for their Adjusted Asset Values and the
Partnership were in liquidation), including, without limitation, amounts described in paragraph 10.5, or is
deemed to be obligated to restore pursuant to the penultimate sentence of Treasury Regulations Section
1.704-1(b)(4)(iv)(0; and

(b) Debit to such Capital Account the items described in Sections
1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(5), and 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(6) of the Treasury Regulations.
14.4 Affiliate. An Affiliate of any person shall mean (a) any person that directly, or indirectly
through one or more intermediaries, controls, or is controlled by or is under common control with the
person specified or (b) such person's family members within the same line of direct consanguinity or a first
degree of collateral consanguinity; provided, however, that for all purposes under this Agreement, no Thiel
38.
126316015 v3
Person shall be deemed to be an Affiliate of any Managing Member, the General Partner or the
Management Company.

14.5 Capital Account. The Capital Account of each Partner shall consist of its original capital
contribution, (a) increased by any additional capital contributions, its share of income or gain that is
allocated to it pursuant to this Agreement, and the amount of any Partnership liabilities that are assumed by
it or that are secured by any Partnership property distributed to it, and (b) decreased by the amount of any
distributions to or withdrawals by it, its share of expense or loss that is allocated to it pursuant to this
Agreement, and the amount of any of its liabilities that are assumed by the Partnership or that are secured by
any property contributed by it to the Partnership. The foregoing provision and the other provisions of this
Agreement relating to the maintenance of Capital Accounts are intended to comply with Treasury
Regulation Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(iv), and shall be interpreted and applied in a manner consistent with such
Regulations. In the event the General Partner shall determine that it is prudent to modify the manner in
which the Capital Accounts, or any debits or credits thereto, are computed in order to comply with such
Regulations, the General Partner may make such modification, provided, however, that it is not likely to
have more than an insignificant effect on the total amounts distributable to any Partner pursuant to Article 7
and Article 10.
14.6 Capital Commitment; Committed Capital. A Partner's Capital Commitment shall
mean the amount that such Partner has agreed to contribute to the capital of the Partnership as set forth
opposite such Partner's name on its EXHIBIT A hereto. The Partnership's Committed Capital shall equal
the sum of the aggregate Capital Commitments of all Partners.

14.7 Code. The Code is the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended from time to time (or
any corresponding provisions of succeeding law).
14.8 Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss. The Deemed Gain from any in kind distribution of
Securities shall be equal to the excess, if any, of the fair market value of the Securities distributed (valued as
of the date of distribution in accordance with paragraph 12.1), over the aggregate Adjusted Asset Value of
the Securities distributed. The Deemed Loss from any in kind distribution of Securities shall be equal to the
excess, if any, of the aggregate Adjusted Asset Value of the Securities distributed over the fair market value
of the Securities distributed (valued as of the date of distribution in accordance with paragraph 12.1).
14.9 Reserved.
14.10 Marketable; Marketable Securities; Marketability. These terms shall refer to
Securities that are (i) (A) traded on a national securities exchange or over the counter or (B) currently the
subject of an effective Securities Act registration statement, (ii) not subject to underwriter "lockup" or other
contractual restrictions and (iii) may be sold by each distributee Limited Partner without restriction under
applicable securities laws of the United States or the applicable laws of the jurisdiction of the exchange on
which such Securities are actively traded (other than volume limitations imposed under Securities and
Exchange Commission Rule 144 or similar volume limitations imposed by another jurisdiction).
Notwithstanding the foregoing, a Security shall not be deemed to be a Marketable Security if, in the good
faith judgment of the General Partner, the market on which such Security trades is not adequate to permit an
orderly sale of all shares of such Security held by the Partnership within a reasonable time period.
14.11 Nonmarkcta hie Securities. Nonmarketable Securities are all Securities other than
Marketable Securities.

14.12 Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss. Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss shall be an
amount computed for each Accounting Period as of the last day thereof that is equal to the sum of all
39.
126316015 v3
income received by the Partnership during such Accounting Period from the investment of idle funds in
Short-Term Securities.

14.13 Partnership Percentage. The Partnership Percentage for each Partner shall be equal to
the Capital Commitment of such Partner stated as a percentage of the aggregate Capital Commitments of
the Partnership, and shall be set forth opposite each Partner's name on its EXHIBIT A hereto. For the
avoidance of doubt, the Partnership Percentage of the General Partner shall not be reduced by any Fee
Adjustment amounts.

14.14 Percentage in Interest; Majority in Interest. A specified fraction or percentage in
interest of the Partners or of the Limited Partners shall mean those partners or limited partners of the
Partnership and the Parallel Funds whose Capital Commitments to the Partnership and capital commitments
to the Parallel Funds, stated as a percentage of the aggregate capital commitments of the Partnership and all
of the Parallel Funds, equal or exceed the required fraction or percentage in interest of all such partners or
limited partners. A Majority in Interest shall mean more than fifty percent (50%) in interest. Any limited
partnership interest owned or controlled by the General Partner, the Management Company, the Managing
Members or any of their employees or Affiliates shall be deemed not to be outstanding for purposes of any
determination under this Agreement of a particular percentage in interest of the Limited Partners and shall
be excluded from voting in any vote taken or consent granted by the Limited Partners under this Agreement.
14.15 Prime Rate. The Prime Rate shall mean an interest rate equal to the floating commercial
rate of interest published in the Wall Street Journal (or its successors) as its prime rate.
14.16 Profit or Loss. Profit or Loss shall be an amount computed for each Accounting Period as
of the last day thereof that is equal to the Partnership's taxable income or loss for such Accounting Period,
determined in accordance with Section 703(a) of the Code (for this purpose, all items of income, gain, loss,
or deduction required to be stated separately pursuant to Code Section 703(a)( 1) shall be included in taxable
income or loss), with the following adjustments:

(a) Any income of the Partnership that is exempt from federal income tax and not
otherwise taken into account in computing Profit or Loss pursuant to this paragraph shall be added to such
taxable income or loss;

(b) Any expenditures of the Partnership described in Code Section 705(a)(2)(B) or
treated as Code Section 705(a)(2)(B) expenditures pursuant to Treasury Regulation Section
1.704-1(b)(2)(iv)(i) and not otherwise taken into account in computing Profit or Loss pursuant to this
paragraph shall be subtracted from such taxable income or loss;

(c) Gain or loss resulting from any disposition of a Partnership asset with respect to
which gain or loss is recognized for federal income tax purposes shall be computed by reference to the
Adjusted Asset Value of the asset disposed of rather than its adjusted tax basis;

(d) The difference between the gross fair market value of all Partnership assets and
their respective Adjusted Asset Values shall be added to such taxable income or loss in the circumstances
described in paragraph 14.2;

(e) Items which are specially allocated pursuant to paragraphs 3.2(c), 4.5(b)(vi), 5.2
and 5.3 shall not be taken into account in computing Profit or Loss; and
The amount of any Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss on any Securities distributed in
kind shall be added to or subtracted from (as the case may be) such taxable income or loss.
40.
126316015 v3
14.17 Regulated Partner. Regulated Partner shall refer to each ERISA Partner, Governmental
Plan Partner, and Private Foundation Partner.

14.18 Securities. Securities shall mean securities of every kind and nature and rights and options
with respect thereto, including stock, notes, bonds, debentures, evidences of indebtedness and other
business interests of every type, including partnerships, joint ventures, proprietorships and other business
entities.

14.19 Securities Act. Securities Act shall mean the Securities Act of 1933, as amended.
14.20 Short -Term Securities. Short -Term Securities shall mean commercial paper, certificates
of deposit, treasury bills, and other money market investments with maturities of less than twelve (12)
months.

14.21 Thiel Persons. Thiel Persons shall mean Peter Thiel, Peter Thiel's retirement accounts and
Thiel Capital LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, any wholly owned subsidiary of any of the
foregoing, and any successor in interest thereto.

14.22 Treasury Regulations. Treasury Regulations shall mean the Income Tax Regulations
promulgated under the Code, as such Regulations may be amended from time to time (including
corresponding provisions of succeeding Regulations).
ARTICLE 15
OTHER PROVISIONS
15.1 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed under the laws of
the State of Delaware as such law would be applied to agreements among the residents of such state made
and to be performed entirely within such state.

15.2 Limitation of Liability of the Limited Partners. Except as required by law or by
paragraphs 4.2 or 9.7 of this Agreement, no Limited Partner shall be bound by, nor be personally liable for,
the expenses, liabilities, or obligations of the Partnership in excess of its Capital Commitment to the
Partnership.
15.3 Exculpation.

(a) Neither the tax matters partner, the General Partner, the Management Company,
the members of the Advisory Committee nor their respective managers, members, partners, principals,
officers, employees, Affiliates or agents (including solely with respect to the conduct of any member of the
Advisory Committee, the Limited Partner responsible for the appointment of such member of the Advisory
Committee) shall be liable, responsible or accountable in damages or otherwise to the Limited Partners or
the Partnership for honest mistakes of judgment, or for action or inaction, taken in good faith and in the best
interests of the Partnership, or for losses due to such mistakes, action, or inaction, or to the negligence,
dishonesty, or bad faith of any employee, broker, or other agent of the Partnership, provided, however, that
such employee, broker, or agent was selected, engaged, and retained with reasonable care. The General
Partner and such persons may consult with counsel and accountants in respect of Partnership affairs and be
fully protected and justified in any action or inaction that is taken in accordance with the advice or opinion
of such counsel or accountants, provided, however, that (i) they shall have been selected with reasonable
care, (ii) with regard to the General Partner, such action or in action shall not constitute gross negligence or
41.
126316015 v3
fraud, and (iii) the General Partner or other such persons shall have relied on their advice or opinion in good
faith.

(b) Notwithstanding any contrary provision in paragraph 15.3(a) above, the provisions
of this paragraph and the immediately following paragraph shall not be construed so as to relieve (or
attempt to relieve) any (i) member of the Advisory Committee or any Thiel Person of any liability by reason
of bad faith, (ii) other person by reason of recklessness, bad faith, gross negligence or intentionally
wrongful conduct, (iii) person by reason of any material breach by the General Partner of this Agreement or
of its fiduciary duties to the Partnership that has a material adverse effect upon the economic interests of the
Limited Partners in the Partnership (in addition to the expense of such indemnity claim) and that remains
uncured following ten (10) business days' written notice of such material breach to the General Partner, or

(iv) person to the extent (but only to the extent) that such liability may not be waived, modified, or limited
under applicable law, but shall be construed so as to effectuate the provisions of such paragraphs to the
fullest extent permitted by law.

(c) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement: (i) to the extent that,
at law or in equity, an Indemnified Party (as defined in paragraph 15.4) has duties (including fiduciary
duties) and liabilities relating thereto to the Partnership, any Partner or any other person, such Indemnified
Party acting under this Agreement shall not be liable to the Partnership, and Partner or any other person for
breach of fiduciary duty for its good faith reliance on the provisions of this Agreement (or for taking actions
that are permitted under this Agreement); and (ii) the provisions of this Agreement, to the extent that they
restrict or eliminate the duties (including fiduciary duties) and liabilities relating thereto of an Indemnified
Party otherwise existing at law or in equity, are agreed by each Partner and the Partnership to replace such
other duties and liabilities of such Indemnified Party.

(d) Each Partner acknowledges and agrees that: (i) certain Thiel Persons are members
of the Management Company and/or the General Partner; (ii) one or more Thiel Persons and their Affiliates
are or may be involved in or have an economic interest in, directly or indirectly, in their capacity as
managers, advisers, directors, founders, sponsors, partners, members or otherwise, other financial,
investment and professional activities, and may engage for their own accounts and for the accounts of
others in any such ventures and activities (without regard to whether the interests of such ventures and
activities conflict with those of the Partnership); (iii) nothing in this Agreement is intended, or shall be
deemed, to restrict or in any way limit the Thiel Persons' or their Affiliates' ability to engage in any such
ventures or activities; (iv) neither the Partnership nor any Partner shall have any right by virtue of this
Agreement or the existence of the Partnership in and to such ventures or activities or to the income or profits
derived therefrom; (v) no Thiel Person shall have any fiduciary or other duties to any Partner or the
Partnership created as a result of, or pursuant to, this Agreement or as a result of the Thiel Activities (as
defined below), or any duty or obligation to make any reports to any Partner or the Partnership, with respect
to any such ventures or activities; and (vi) the functions and activities of any Thiel Person with respect to
the Partnership (the "Thiel Activities") being limited to, as applicable, (x) being a limited partner of the
Partnership or a Parallel Fund, (y) having any ownership interest the Management Company and/or the
General Partner, and (z) taking any actions as a result of a Thiel Person's ownership interest in the
Management Company or the General Partner, (1) shall not alter or impair the limitation on liability of any
Thiel Person as a limited partner under the Partnership Act, (2) in no event shall the Thiel Activities give
rise to a conclusion, under Section 17-303 of the Partnership Act or otherwise, that any Thiel Person
participates in the control of the Partnership, (3) the obligations and responsibilities of the Thiel Persons are
limited to those of a limited partner, and (4) this Agreement and the documentation contemplated hereby
shall be interpreted in accordance with the foregoing.

(e) This paragraph 15.3 is intended to apply solely for the benefit of the Limited
Partners, and in no way shall be construed or interpreted as inuring to the benefit of any other person or
42.
126316015 v3
entity, including, without limitation, creditors of the Partnership, of the General Partner or of the members
of the General Partner or other third parties.

15.4 Indemnification. The Partnership agrees to indemnify, out of the assets of the Partnership
only (but including amounts that the Partners may be required to contribute pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)),
the General Partner, the Management Company, the members of the Advisory Committee (including solely
with respect to the conduct of any member of the Advisory Committee, the Limited Partner responsible for
the appointment of such member of the Advisory Committee), the tax matters partner and their respective
managers, members, partners, principals, officers, employees, Affiliates and agents (each an "Indemnified
Party" collectively the "Indemnified Parties") to the fullest extent permitted by law and to save and hold
them harmless from and in respect of all (a) reasonable fees, costs, and expenses, including legal fees, paid
in connection with or resulting from any claim, action, or demand against the Indemnified Parties that arises
directly or indirectly out of or in any way relates to the Partnership, its properties, business, or affairs, or any
other enterprise that such Indemnified Party is or was serving, as a director, officer, employee or otherwise,
at the request of the Partnership, the General Partner or the Management Company, and (b) such claims,
actions, and demands described in the preceding clause (a), and any losses or damages resulting from such
claims, actions, and demands, including amounts paid in settlement or compromise (if recommended by
attorneys for the Partnership) of any such claim, action or demand; provided, however, that this indemnity
shall not extend to: (i) any claim or proceeding solely between or among the General Partner, Management
Company, the Managing Members, or any of their respective managers, members, partners, principals,
officers, employees, Affiliates or agents; or (ii) any conduct which constitutes bad faith on the part of any
Advisory Committee member or Thiel Person or any conduct which constitutes recklessness, bad faith,
gross negligence or intentionally wrongful conduct on the part of any other Indemnified Party or any claim,
action or demand that arises from any material breach by the General Partner of this Agreement or of its
fiduciary duties to the Partnership that has a material adverse effect upon the economic interests of the
Limited Partners in the Partnership (in addition to the expense of such indemnity claim) and that remains
uncured following ten (10) business days' written notice of such material breach to the General Partner.
Expenses incurred by any Indemnified Party in defending a claim or proceeding covered by this paragraph
shall be paid by the Partnership in advance of the final disposition of such claim or proceeding (regardless
of whether the claim asserts that the Indemnified Party is not entitled to such indemnification pursuant to
clause (ii) of the proviso of the preceding sentence); provided, the Indemnified Party undertakes to repay
such amount if it is ultimately determined that such Indemnified Party was not entitled to be indemnified;
provided, further, that no such advance shall be paid in the case of (A) a claim or proceeding solely between
or among the General Partner, Management Company, the Managing Members, or any of their respective
managers, members, partners, principals, officers, employees, Affiliates or agents or (B) any claim or
proceeding brought by a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners against an Indemnified Party. The
provisions of this paragraph 15.4 shall remain in effect as to each Indemnified Party whether or not such
Indemnified Party continues to serve in the capacity that entitled such person to be indemnified. In the
event that an Indemnified Party is also entitled to indemnification by a portfolio company of the Partnership,
the General Partner or the Management Company, the Partners hereby acknowledge and agree that (i) the
portfolio company shall be the indemnitor of first resort and the Partnership shall be the indemnitor of
second resort and the General Partner and the Management Company shall be the indemnitors of third
resort (Le., the portfolio company's obligations to such an Indemnified Party shall be primary, the
Partnership's obligations to such an Indemnified Party shall be secondary and any obligation of the General
Partner and/or the Management Company to advance expenses and/or to provide indemnification for the
same expenses or liabilities incurred by such an Indemnified Party shall be tertiary), (ii) that, to the extent
such an Indemnified Party is otherwise eligible hereunder for advancement of expenses, the Partnership
shall be required to advance the full amount of expenses incurred by such an Indemnified Party and shall be
liable for the full amount of all fees, costs and any other items described in clauses (a) and (b) of the first
sentence of this paragraph without regard to any rights such an Indemnified Party may have against the
General Partner or the Management Company and (iii) the Partnership hereby irrevocably waives,
43.
126316015 v3
relinquishes and releases the General Partner and the Management Company from any and all claims
against such parties for contribution, subrogation or any other recovery of any kind in respect of the
foregoing provisions of this sentence.
15.5 Arbitration.

(a) Any claim, dispute, or controversy of whatever nature arising out of or relating to
this Agreement, including, without limitation, any action or claim based on tort, contract, or statute
(including any claims of breach), or concerning the interpretation, effect, termination, validity, performance
and/or breach of this Agreement ("Claim"), shall be resolved by final and binding confidential arbitration
("Arbitration") before a single arbitrator ("Arbitrator") selected from and administered by Judicial
Arbitration and Mediation Service Inc. (the "Administrator") in accordance with its then existing
arbitration rules or procedures regarding commercial or business disputes. The arbitration shall be held in
San Francisco, California or New York, New York, in the sole discretion of the General Partner.

(b) Depositions may be taken and full discovery may be obtained in any arbitration
commenced under this provision.

(c) The Arbitrator shall, within fifteen (15) calendar days after the conclusion of the
Arbitration hearing, issue a written award and statement of decision describing the essential findings and
conclusions on which the award is based, including the calculation of any damages awarded. The
Arbitrator shall be authorized to award compensatory damages, but shall not be authorized (i) to award
non-economic damages, such as for emotional distress, pain and suffering or loss of consortium, (ii) to
award punitive damages, or (iii) to reform, modify or materially change this Agreement or any other
agreements contemplated hereunder; provided, however, that the damage limitations described in parts (i)
and (ii) of this sentence will not apply if such damages are statutorily imposed. The Arbitrator also shall be
authorized to grant any temporary, preliminary or permanent equitable remedy or relief he or she deems just
and equitable and within the scope of this Agreement, including, without limitation, an injunction or order
for specific performance.

(d) Each party shall bear its own attorney's fees, costs, and disbursements arising out
of the arbitration, and shall pay an equal share of the fees and costs of the Administrator and the Arbitrator;
provided, however, the Arbitrator shall be authorized to determine whether a party is substantially the
prevailing party, and if so, to award to that substantially prevailing party reimbursement for its reasonable
attorneys' fees, costs and disbursements (including, for example, expert witness fees and expenses,
photocopy charges, travel expenses, etc.), and/or the fees and costs of the Administrator and the Arbitrator.
Absent the filing of an application to correct or vacate the arbitration award under Title 10 of the Delaware
Code sections 5713 through 5717, each party shall fully perform and satisfy the arbitration award within
fifteen (15) days of the service of the award.

(e) By agreeing to this binding arbitration provision, the parties understand that they
are waiving certain rights and protections which may otherwise be available if a Claim between the parties
were determined by litigation in court, including, without limitation, the right to seek or obtain certain types
of damages precluded by this paragraph 15.5, the right to a jury trial, certain rights of appeal, and a right to
invoke formal rules of procedure and evidence.
15.6 Execution of Documents. This Agreement may be executed in two (2) or more
counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original but all of which together shall constitute one (1)
and the same instrument.
44.
126316015 v3
15.7 Other Instruments and Acts. The Partners agree to execute any other instruments or
perform any other acts that are or may be reasonably necessary to effectuate and carry on the partnership
created by this Agreement.

15.8 Binding Agreement. This Agreement shall be binding upon the transferees, successors,
assigns, and legal representatives of the Partners.

15.9 Notices; Electronic Transmission of Reports. Any notice or other communication that
one Partner desires to give to another Partner shall be in writing, and shall be deemed effectively given: (a)
upon personal delivery to the Partner to be notified, (b) upon confirmed transmission by electronic mail,
telex or facsimile if sent during normal business hours of the recipient, if not, then on the next business day,

(c) five (5) days after having been sent by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested, postage
prepaid, or (d) three (3) days after deposit with a nationally recognized overnight courier, specifying next
day delivery, with written verification of receipt. All communications shall be addressed to the other
Partner at the address shown on its EXHIBIT A or at such other address as a Partner may designate by ten

(10) days' advance written notice to the other Partners. In addition to the provisions of paragraph 11.5, the
General Partner shall be entitled to transmit to the Limited Partners by e-mail the reports required by
paragraphs 113, 11.4, and 11.7.

15.10 Power of Attorney. By signing this Agreement, each Limited Partner designates and
appoints the General Partner its true and lawful attorney, in its name, place, and stead to make, execute, sign,
and file the Certificate of Limited Partnership and any amendment thereto and such other instruments,
documents, or certificates that may from time to time be required of the Partnership by the laws of the
United States of America, the laws of the state of the Partnership's formation, or any other state in which the
Partnership shall conduct its affairs in order to qualify or otherwise enable the Partnership to conduct its
affairs in such jurisdictions. Such attorney is not hereby granted any authority on behalf of the Limited
Partners to amend this Agreement except that as attorney for each of the Limited Partners, the General
Partner shall have the authority to amend this Agreement and the Certificate of Limited Partnership (and to
execute any amendment to the Agreement or the Certificate of Limited Partnership on behalf of itself and as
attorney in fact for each of the Limited Partners) as may be required to effect:

(a) Admission of additional Partners pursuant to Article 3;
(b) Additional capital contributions pursuant to Article 4;

(c) Transfers of Limited Partnership interests pursuant to Article 9; and
(d) Extensions of the Partnership term pursuant to Article 10.

This power of attorney and the power of attorney referenced in paragraph 4.5(b)(x) granted by each Limited
Partner shall expire as to such Partner immediately after the dissolution of the Partnership or the
amendment of the Partnership's EXHIBIT A to reflect the complete withdrawal of such Partner as a Partner
of the Partnership.
15.11 Amendment.

(a) Except as provided by the immediately preceding paragraph and subject to
paragraph 15.11(b), this Agreement may be amended only with the written consent of the General Partner
and a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners.
45.
126316015 v3

(b) Notwithstanding paragraph 15.11(a), no amendment to the provisions of Article 13
may be made without the consent of each ERISA Partner, Governmental Plan Partner and Private
Foundation Partner who may be materially adversely affected by such amendment, (ii) the General Partner
may amend this Agreement without the consent of the other Partners to reflect changes validly made in the
membership of the Partners and the capital contributions of the Partners, and (iii) no amendment to this
Agreement may modify any provision requiring the consent of more than a Majority in Interest of the
Limited Partners without the consent of such higher Percentage in Interest.

(c) Notwithstanding paragraphs 15.11(a) and (b), no amendment of this Agreement
may modify the method of making Partnership allocations or distributions, modify the method of
determining the Partnership Percentage of any Partner, reduce any Partner's Capital Account, increase any
Partner's Capital Commitment to the Partnership, modify any provision of this Agreement pertaining to
limitations on liability of the Limited Partners or change the restrictions contained in this paragraph
15.11(c), unless each Partner adversely affected thereby in a manner different than the other Partners has
expressly consented in writing to such amendment. In addition, the General Partner shall not cause or
consent to the amendment of paragraphs 8.4(b), 8.4(e), 14.21, 15.2, 15.3, 15.4 or this paragraph 15.11 of
this Agreement in a manner that would adversely affect a member of the Advisory Committee or a Thiel
Person without the express written consent of each such member of the Advisory Committee or Thiel
Person that would be adversely affected thereby.

(d) The Partnership's or General Partner's (or its managers', members' or employees')
noncompliance with any provision hereof in any single transaction or event may be waived prospectively or
retroactively in writing by the same Percentage in Interest of the Limited Partners that would be required to
amend such provision pursuant to paragraphs 15.11(a), (b) or (c). No waiver shall be deemed a waiver of
any subsequent event of noncompliance except to the extent expressly provided in such waiver.
(e) The General Partner may, without the consent of the Limited Partners, amend this
Agreement, as the General Partner determines to be advisable to address the effects (or potential effects) of
legislation that has been enacted, or regulations (whether proposed, temporary or final) that have been
issued, in either case that change (or, in the General Partner's good faith determination propose to change or
alter) the tax consequences of the operation of paragraphs 4.3, 5.1, and 6.1 or any other provision of this
Agreement related to the satisfaction of the General Partner's Capital Commitment through the waiver of
management fees and related allocations and distributions, so long as any such amendment does not result
in any material adverse effect on any Limited Partner or delay the timing or reduce the aggregate amount of
distributions to which any Limited Partner is entitled under this Agreement.

15.12 Entire Agreement. This Agreement (together with the representations and warranties of
each Limited Partner set forth in any Subscription Agreement executed by such Limited Partner) and any
Side Letter (as defined in this paragraph 15.12) constitute the full, complete and final agreement of the
Partners, and supersede all prior agreements between the Partners with respect to the Partnership.
Notwithstanding the provisions of this Agreement or any Subscription Agreement entered into by a Limited
Partner in connection with its admission to the Partnership, it is hereby acknowledged and agreed that the
Partnership and the General Partner, on its own behalf or on behalf of the Partnership or a Parallel Fund,
without the approval of any Limited Partners, may enter into a side letter or similar agreement to or with a
limited partner of the Partnership or a Parallel Fund (each a "Side Letter"), executed contemporaneously
with the admission of such limited partner to the Partnership or such Parallel Fund, which has the effect of
establishing rights with respect to the Partners or the Partnership or supplementing the terms hereof or any
Subscription Agreement in order to meet certain requirements of such Limited Partner, including, without
limitation, the Management Fee chargeable with respect to such Limited Partner. The parties hereto agree
that any terms contained in a Side Letter shall govern, for purposes of this Agreement or any Subscription
46.
126316015 v3
Agreement, and be valid, binding and enforceable as among the Limited Partner that is a party thereto, the
General Partner and/or the Partnership.

15.13 Titles; Subtitles. The titles and subtitles used in this Agreement are used for convenience
only and shall not be considered in the interpretation of this Agreement.

15.14 Partnership Name. The Partnership shall have the exclusive right to use the Partnership
name as long as the Partnership continues. Upon termination of the Partnership, the Partnership shall assign
whatever rights it may have in such name to the General Partner. No value shall be placed upon the name or
the goodwill attached to it for the purpose of determining the value of any Partner's Capital Account or
interest in the Partnership.
15.15 Confidentiality.

(a) This Agreement and all financial statements, tax reports, portfolio valuations,
reviews or analyses of potential or actual investments, reports or other materials and all other documents
and information concerning the affairs of the Partnership and its investments, including, without limitation,
information about the portfolio companies of the Partnership (collectively, the "Confidential
Information"), that any Limited Partner may receive or that may be disclosed, distributed or disseminated
(whether in writing, orally, electronically or by other means) to any Limited Partner or its representatives,
including Confidential Information disclosed to members of the Advisory Committee, pursuant to or in
accordance with this Agreement, or otherwise as a result of its ownership of an interest in the Partnership,
constitute proprietary and confidential information about the Partnership, the General Partner and its
Affiliates and the Partnership's portfolio companies (the "Affected Parties"). Each Limited Partner
acknowledges and agrees that the Affected Parties derive independent economic value from the
Confidential Information not being generally known and that the Confidential Information is the subject of
reasonable efforts to maintain its secrecy. Each Limited Partner further acknowledges and agrees that the
Confidential Information is a trade secret, the disclosure of which is likely to cause substantial and
irreparable competitive harm to the Affected Parties or their respective businesses.
(b) Each Limited Partner agrees to hold all Confidential Information in confidence,
and not to disclose any Confidential Information to any third party without the prior written consent of the
General Partner. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, each Limited Partner may disclose such
Confidential Information: (i) to its officers, directors, trustees, wholly -owned subsidiaries, employees and
outside experts (including but not limited to its attorneys and accountants) on a "need to know" basis, so
long as such persons are bound by the same duties of confidentiality to the Partnership as such Limited
Partner, and so long as such Limited Partner shall remain liable for any breach of this paragraph 15.15 by
such persons; (ii) to the extent that such information is required to be disclosed in connection with any civil
or criminal proceeding; (iii) to the extent that such information is required (as determined in good faith by
the disclosing Limited Partner after consultation with counsel) to be disclosed by applicable law in
connection with any governmental, administrative or regulatory proceeding or filing (including any
inspection or examination or any disclosure necessary in connection with a request for information made
under a state or federal freedom of information act or similar law), after reasonable prior written notice to
the General Partner (except where such notice is expressly prohibited by law); (iv) to the extent that such
information was received from a third party not subject to confidentiality limitations and such Limited
Partner can establish that it rightfully received such information from such party other than as a result of the
breach of this paragraph 15.15; (v) to the extent such information was rightfully in such Limited Partner's
possession prior to the Partnership's conveyance of such information to such Limited Partner, as evidenced
by the Limited Partner's prior written records; or (vi) to the extent that the information provided by the
Partnership is otherwise available in the public domain in the absence of any improper or unlawful action
on the part of such Partner. Any Limited Partner seeking to make disclosure in reliance on the foregoing
47.
126316015 v3
clauses (ii) and (iii) above shall use its best efforts to claim any relevant exception under such laws or
obligations which would prevent or limit public disclosure of the Confidential Information and provide the
General Partner immediate notice upon the Limited Partner's receipt of a request for disclosure of any
Confidential Information pursuant to such laws or obligations.

(c) Each Limited Partner also agrees that any document constituting or containing, or
any other embodiment of, any Confidential Information shall be returned to the Partnership upon the
General Partner's request. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, the General
Partner may withhold disclosure of any Confidential Information (other than this Agreement or tax reports)
to any particular Limited Partner if the General Partner reasonably determines that the disclosure of such
Confidential Information to such Limited Partner may result in the general public gaining access to such
Confidential Information or that such disclosure is not in the best interests of the Partnership or its
investments; provided, however, that to the extent that any information is not delivered to a Limited Partner
based on the General Partner's exercise of its discretion under this sentence, such information shall be made
available for review, but not copying, during regular business hours at a location mutually determined by
the General Partner and such Limited Partner. In no event shall a Limited Partner be denied access to
information deliverable pursuant to paragraph 11.7 of this Agreement.

(d) With respect to each Limited Partner that is subject to any "freedom of
information," "sunshine" or other law, rule or regulation that imposes upon such Limited Partner an
obligation to make information available to the public, the Partnership hereby requests confidential
treatment of the Confidential Information, and such Limited Partner shall use commercially reasonable
efforts to take such action as necessary for such Confidential Information to be exempt from disclosure, to
the maximum extent permitted under such law, rule or regulation.

(e) With respect to each Limited Partner that is a "fund of funds" or a similar pooled
investment vehicle (but specifically excluding any pension, retirement or similar benefit plan) (a "Pooled
Vehicle Partner"), the Pooled Vehicle Partner shall, subject to paragraph 15.15(d), be permitted to make
disclosure to its direct equity owners (but not to any indirect or other beneficial owners), that are subject to
a written confidentiality agreement or obligation that provides a degree of protection to the Partnership
comparable to that provided in this paragraph 15.15, of solely the following Confidential Information: (i)
the Pooled Vehicle Partner's status as a Limited Partner of the Partnership, (ii) the amount of such Pooled
Vehicle Partner's Capital Commitment, (iii) the total amount of such Pooled Vehicle Partner's Capital
Commitment that has been drawn down pursuant to capital calls, (iv) quarterly and annual reports
summarizing the status of the Pooled Vehicle Partner's investment in the Partnership (except that any
financial information regarding the Partnership and any information concerning any portfolio company in
which the Partnership has invested shall not be disclosed and must be redacted), and (v) the name and
address of the Partnership.

(f) The General Partner agrees to hold the identity of each Limited Partner in
confidence if requested to do so by such Limited Partner, and not to disclose such identity to any third party
without the prior written consent of such Limited Partner; provided, however, that the General Partner may
disclose such identity (i) to its members, Affiliates, employees and outside experts (including but not
limited to its attorneys and accountants) so long as such persons have an obligation to maintain such
identity in confidence; (ii) to the extent that such information is required to be disclosed in connection with
any civil or criminal proceeding; (iii) to the extent that such information is required (as determined in good
faith by the General Partner) to be disclosed by applicable law in connection with any governmental,
administrative or regulatory proceeding or filing (including any inspection or examination or any disclosure
necessary in connection with a request for information made under a state or federal freedom of information
act or similar law); or (iv) to the extent that the information provided by the Partnership is otherwise
available in the public domain in the absence of any improper or unlawful action on the part of such Partner.
48.
126316015 v3

(g) Each Limited Partner agrees to notify such Limited Partner's attorneys,
accountants and other similar advisers about their obligations in connection with this paragraph 15.15 and
will further cause such advisers to abide by the aforesaid provisions of this paragraph 15.15.

(h) Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this paragraph 15.15, each Partner
(and each Affiliate and Person acting on behalf of any such Partner) agrees that each Partner (and its
attorneys, accountants and other similar advisers) may disclose to appropriate governmental authorities, the
tax treatment and tax structure of the formation and operation of the Partnership and materials (including
opinions or other tax analyses) that are provided to such Partner relating to such tax treatment and tax
structure. This authorization is not intended to permit and does not authorize the disclosure of any of the
following Confidential Information or other information relating to the Partnership: (i) any information not
related to the tax treatment or tax structure of the formation or operation of the Partnership, (ii) the identities
of Partners or potential investors in the Partnership, (iii) the identities of any portfolio companies or
potential portfolio companies of the Partnership or a Prior Fund, (iv) the existence or status of any
negotiations to which the Partnership or its Affiliate is a party, (v) any pricing or financial information
(except to the extent such pricing or financial information is related to the tax treatment or tax structure of
the formation or operation of the Partnership), or (vi) any other term or detail not relevant to the tax
treatment or the tax structure of the Partnership.
[Remainder of page intentionally left blank.]
49.
126316015 v3
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Partners have executed this Limited Partnership Agreement as of the
date first written above.
GENERAL PARTNER:
VALAR VENTURES GP III LLC
By:  Nr —
James Fitzgerald, Managing Member
LIMITED PARTNER:
VALAR VENTURES GP III LLC
as attorney -in-fact, for and on behalf of each Limited Partner
c -
By:
James Fitzgerald, Managing Member
"THE SECURITIES EVIDENCED BY THIS PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT HAVE NOT BEEN
REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED (THE "1933 ACT"), AND
MAY NOT BE SOLD, TRANSFERRED, ASSIGNED OR HYPOTHECATED UNLESS THERE IS AN
EFFECTIVE REGISTRATION STATEMENT UNDER THE 1933 ACT COVERING SUCH
SECURITIES OR THE GENERAL PARTNER RECEIVES AN OPINION OF COUNSEL FOR THE
HOLDER OF THESE SECURITIES REASONABLY SATISFACTORY TO THE GENERAL
PARTNER, STATING THAT SUCH SALE, TRANSFER, ASSIGNMENT OR HYPOTHECATION IS
EXEMPT FROM THE REGISTRATION AND PROSPECTUS DELIVERY REQUIREMENTS OF THE
1933 ACT."
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
SIGNATURE PAGE. TO LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
EFTA00603445 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Honeycomb Asset Management July 2017 report
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
July 19. 2017
Dear Honeycomb Partners:
Below please find Honeycomb's O2 2017. Year To Date (YTD), and Inception To Date (ITD) Fund performance since
our July 2016 institutional launch.
2017 Performance -Gross and Nee
O2 2017 Year To Date Inception To Date
(Last Twelve Months)
Honeycomb Class A (gross) 3.3% 15.3% 20.0%
Honeycomb Class A (net) 2.7% 12.2% 15.9%
Honeycomb Class B (gross) 3.3% 15.5% 20.5%
Honeycomb Class B (net) 2.7% 12.4% 16.3%
Internal capital anchored our June 2016 soft launch which also included select Mends and family capital. The Funds June 
2016 net performance was
-3.4% and -3.3% for classes A and B. respectively. Inception To Date net performance is e12.7% and 4 13.1% for classes A
arid B. respectively.
ilcluding the June 2016 soft launch. Past performance is not indicative or a guarantee of future results.
O2 2017 Performance and Portfolio Discussion
In the second quarter, we took the opportunity to be tactical around our fundamental investing process. In early May,
we rotated the portfolio into value and media stocks. We reduced exposure to FANG as near-term price targets were
achieved following a dramatic increase in the first four months of the year. However. our long media and broadcasting
exposures negatively impacted our performance in May. From a lower gross position, we were able to take advantage
of the June 9-12th NASDAQ sell-off and re-initiate these growth-oriented positions at what we believed were attractive
risk-rewards at prices 5% to 10% lower. We finished June up slightly for the month and overall we had a good quarter.
Gross Long and Short Security Selection Contribution - O2 2017'
10%
-10%
7.3%
Long
-3.6%
Shorl
3.7%
Total
'The security attrbutian above differs from the 2017 performance table as it does not take into account management fee. 
ilcentive allocation. forwards
or Fund expenses. Past performance is not indicative or a guarantee of future results.
645 Unison Avenue. le^ Flaw. New York. NY 10022
Conlklenbal - NIX for OislrbIXbn
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
From a sector perspective, a significant portion of the portfolio's exposures for the quarter were in Information
Technology and Consumer Discretionary, with positions in Information Technology driving our positive performance.
Exposures for Q2 averaged approximately 190% gross and 56% net, which compares to 222% gross and 53% net
averages in O1.

On the long side, Alibaba was our largest contributor and had been a top 5 position coming into the second quarter.
Formula One Group (ticker: FWONK) also led our gains along with investments in Google and Charter
Communications. These gains were offset by the losses in Fox, CBS and Sinclair Broadcasting.
On the short side we had two significant detractors of performance in the quarter. Shod positions in a TV shopping
network and a European internet company were the largest losses to performance. We benefited from our short
positions in telecom service providers, advertising companies, and a large cap technology company (serving primarily
as a hedge).
Thematic Introduction: OLED — Moving Beyond the TV
In past quarterly letters and discussions, we have highlighted our interest in artificial intelligence, machine 
learning,
autonomous driving, and new technologies made possible by advances in digital computing. At the same time however,
game-changing innovation is also happening in the physical world which we have been exploring more closely.
One such advancement already at the phase of commercial adoption is OLED technology. OLEDs are "Organic Light-
Emitting Diodes" and their properties enable them to emit crystal clear images without a backlight, which is required by
traditional displays, making them more power efficient. This means OLED screens are paper-thin, flexible, foldable
and can be applied on any surface from plastic to glass. This goes beyond TVs. Imagine the ability to turn windows,
walls, and even car tail lights into a working display. Smartphone and appliance manufacturers, auto OEMs, and
industries of all kinds are already planning for a future where they can incorporate this technology into their products
due to the improved performance and longer battery life. Goldman Sachs recently estimated that the OLED industry
will triple to $46bn from its current size by 2020. The applications for OLED are seemingly endless.
Potential OLED applications: Moving Beyond the TV
As we are beginning our work on this mega trend, we are exploring not only the OLED manufacturers but also their
equipment suppliers. Applied Materials (ticker: AMAT), a current portfolio holding, is a supplier of semiconductor 
capital
equipment and is a leading provider in the OLED space, a fact that is underappreciated by the market because OLED-
related sales represent a minority of AMAT's revenues today. Despite its dominant position in a high-growth segment,
AMAT trades as a semicap company for a cyclically low multiple of 14x forward PIE despite growing earnings more
than 20%. As OLED-related sales become a more substantial part of AMAT's business and help smooth out the
cyclicality of its earnings trajectory, we believe the stock will benefit from a multiple re-rating as well.
2
Conlidonbal - No! for Disliaton
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
We are in the process of researching other ways to play this trend. While OLED has been around for a few years and
the stocks involved may reflect the potential, the S-curve of mass adoption is now in sight and will take it to the next
level of general awareness. We often find in technology the early bird doesn't get the worm, it eats dirt. The bird that
comes after the early bird is the one that enjoys the fruits of that labor!
What does OLED mean for advertising?
The impact of OLED displays will extend far beyond the devices themselves. At Honeycomb we think about capturing
the entire value chain of an idea and ask ourselves how might this trend impact other names in our portfolio. According
to industry experts we have spoken to, by 2020 approximately 60% of smartphones will have OLED screens. Some of
these screens can unfold and double the size of your display allowing you to browse the internet and watch videos
more comfortably while keeping your current phone size unchanged.
Illustrative smartphone prototype with OLED display
- Closed a AL Opening Completely Open
We are thinking about what impact this may have on the consumption of YouTube, which already has 1.5 billion daily
active users currently spending 40 minutes per day on the site, streaming a total of 1 billion hours per day. Netflix
watchers are currently streaming 1 billion hours per week. Both platforms may see a significant increase in viewing
hours in a world with bigger, foldable smartphone screens. Additionally, we are analyzing the potential for mobile video
advertising to drive more ad dollars to companies like Google and Facebook. Historically, there was a negative impact
on advertising rates and conversion from the desktop to mobile transition when screen sizes got smaller. OLED devices
could reverse this trend by allowing more potential surface area to advertise. In this scenario, we believe consensus
estimates are dramatically underestimating the potential for advertising revenue growth in the future especially given
video advertising rates are much higher than click-through links.
Year In Review and Business Update
Over our first 12 months in business we reflect on what we did well and where we fell short. We did a good job of taking
risk in our portfolio (which is the mantra of our shop) and delivering strong returns. Since launch, our gross exposure
has averaged 209% with an average 51% net exposure.

When it came to hiring talent, however, we didn't take much risk. We interviewed over 100 candidates and probably
should have pulled the trigger on more than one occasion. Our bar remains high as we seek professionals with a
combination of raw intelligence, common sense, passion and cultural fit centered on creativity and resilience. Our idea
flow remains strong and we look to better monetize this with additional bandwidth of added talent. Expect to hear
progress on this front in the future.

In terms of asset raising, we are extremely proud of the methodical approach we have taken to build our firm. We have
had inflows every month since launch and have diversified the partnership by investor type and geographic
representation. We believe that our investor base is a strategic asset that has helped our performance. Your confidence
in our investment process allows us to do our best work, especially in volatile times.
3
Conlidontial - Not for Dithibution
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
Closing Remarks
It is an exciting time to be a new hedge fund launch. Starting a business has been an incredibly rewarding experience
for our team. It continues to be a learning opportunity that requires skill. strategy, preparation and patience. We will
continue to grow our assets, talent, and industry knowledge while staying focused on our goal of generating excellent
returns on your capital.
Best regards.
The Honeycomb Team
CONTACT INFORMATION:
Dominique Ahumada
Head of Capital Partnerships
4
Conti oNial - Not for
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
f Mono, a Important I egni nisrIMirr
'Honeycomb Master Fund LP (the -Master Fund') includes al or substantially al inveslible assets from its feeder hands. 
Honeycomb Partners LP ('Domestic Fuld).
Honeycomb Intermediate Fund LP and Honeycomb Offshore Fund Lid. (collectively. the 'Funds'). However. investors are 
expected to invest at the feeder fund not
at the Master Fund level. The reflected returns assume a representattve investor invested in the Domestic Fund in each 
of (1) the Class A interests that are
subject
to a management fee 01 2% and incentive allocation of 20% and (I1) the Class B interests that are subject to a 
management fee of 1.5% and an incentive alocation
of 20%. 'Net' reflects the performance 01 the Domestic Fund net of management lee. expenses and incenttve Matelot. 
'Gross' reflects the performance of the
Domestic Fund net ol management fee and expenses. but gross of incentbre alocation. Returns assume the reinvestment of 
all dividends. interest. income and
profits. The management fee and expense agues used for performance calculatbns are ;to -rated for the performance 
period. and incentive allocation calculations
reflect an invesbnent since the Domestic Fund's July 1.2016 institutional launch dale. The reflected reams assume 
participation by the Class A and B
representative
investor In -new issue' investments. Individual results will vary (potentially considerabtyi depending on. among other 
things. investing at the offshore feeder
fund
rather than the Domestic Fund level. new issue eligblty. the timing of contributionstsubscriplions and 
withdrawals/redemptions, different lee arrangements and
any
accumulated loss carry-brands. This performance information is estimated and Honeycomb Asset Management LP (the 
-investment Manager') makes no
representations as to the accuracy or completeness thereof. and such Information shout' not be rowed upon for investment
related or other purposes. The
performance information is based on unaudited information as of the date hereof and 9 subject to change as actual 
performance for the relevant period is
finalized.
Past performance is not indicative of future results.
Legal Disclosure:
This investor letter is confidential. Is Intended only for the person to whom it has been provided and under no 
circumstances may a copy be shown. cooed.
transmitted.

or otherwise given to any person other than the aulhorued recipient without the poor written consent of the Investment 
Manager. Except as 0th Anse specifically
set forth heren. the intonation in this letter is as of the dale hereol. Notwithstanding anything to the colliery 
herein, each recipient to this document (and
each
employee. representative. or recipient) may disclose to any and all pencils, without limitation of any kind, the tax 
treatment and lax structure of the Funds
any of
their transactions, and all materials of any kind (including opinions or other tax analyses) relating to such tax 
treatment and tax structure, it bong
understood that
'tax treatment' and 'tax structure' do not include the name or identifying information of a Fuld or a transaction.
The distribution 01 the inlormation contained herein may be restricted in certain jurisdictions: accordingly. h is the 
responsibility ol any prospective
investor to sail*
itself as to compliance with relevant laws and regulatbns. The recipient and its professional advisors, by accepting 
deavery of this document, agree to keep
°credential al  matters herein and to return this document promptly upon the request of the Investment Manager.
The informality) contained herein is preliminary and is provided for discussion purposes only. This information is only 
a summary of key inlormabon: d is not
compete
and does not contain certain material information about the Funds. inducting important conflict of interests disclosures
and risk factors associated with an
investment
in the Funds and a subject to change without notice.

This document has been supped for discussion purposes only, and therefore no representation or warranty is made. Mather 
expressed or implied. by the Fulda
or the Investment Manager or any of their partners, employees. members, or agents as to the accuracy or completeness of 
the intonation provided herein. This
document may be amended at any time. There is no express or implied obligation to update you of any changes to the 
information set forth herein. The information
contained herein should not be relied upon as the basis of any investment decision or for any other purpose.
This document is not intended to be. nor should it be construed et used as an offer to sell. or a solicitation of any 
offer to buy, interests or shares in the
Funds. No
offer or solicitation may be made prior to the delivery of a definitive offering memorandwn (the 'Memorandum') which 
will contain additional information about
the
Funds, including disclosures relating to risk factors and conflicts of interest. The information contained herein does 
not take 1610 account the particular
investment
objectives or finanoal circumstances of any scenic person who may receive it and is qualified in its entirely by the 
Memorandum. In the event of any
discrepancies
between the information contained herein and the Memorandum, the Memorandum will control. The inlormation herein a not 
intended to provide. and should not be
relied upon for, accounting, and legal or tax advice or investment recommendations. Each reopient 01 this document 
should make an independent investigation as
to all matters concerning an investment in the Funds or otherwise deserted herein. including consulting with its own 
lax, legal. accounting or other advisors
about
the matters concerning an investment in the Funds or otherwise discussed herein. In making an investment decision, 
investors must rely upon their own
examination
of the Funds and the leans of the offering, including the merits and risks involved.

An Investment in the Funds may not be sulfide for al Investors. An investment in the Funds will be sLortabb only for 
certain financially
sophisticated investors who meet certain eligibility requirements. have no need for immediate liquidity in their 
investment. and can bear the risk of an
investment in
the Funds for an extended period of lime.

Investing in financial markets involves a substanbal degree of risk. There can be no assurance that the investment 
objectives described herein will be achieved.
Investment losses may occur, and investors could lose some or all 01 thew investment. No guarantee or representation is 
made that the Funds' investment program.
including. without Irritation, its invesbnent objectives. diversification strategies. or isk monitoring goals, wil be 
successful, and investment results may
vary
subsiaMially over time. Nothing herein is intended to imply that the Fwids investment methodology may be considered 
'conservative', 'sale', 'risk free' or 'risk
averse-. Economic, market and other conditions could also cause the Funds to alter their investment objectives. 
guidelines and restriction.
Certain Information contained in this document constitutes "omen:Hooking statements', which can be identified by the use
of forward-locking terminology such as
"may'. ler. 'should'. 'expect'. 'anticipate'. 'target'. 'project', 'estimate', ;Mend'. 'continue' or 'believe' or the 
negatives thereof or other valatons
thereon or
°covetableterminology. Due to various risks and uncertainties and assumptions made by the investment Manager, actual 
events or results or the actual performance
of the Funds may differ materially from those reflected or contemplated in such forward-looking statements.
The estimates. investment strategies and investment themes, and views expressed in this document are based won past or 
current market conditions andbr data
and information provided by unaffiliated third parties (which has not been independently verified) and is subject to 
change wehout notice. In addition. many of
the
views expressed herein are subjective andbr reflect the Investment Managers estimates or forecasts on future decisions 
and market events. Such statements
should not be understood lobe predictions or guarantees of any particular outcome, or of the Investment Manager's 
commitment to invest in any particular
Industry,
sector, region. or company. In particular, you should be aware that any new technologies or products discussed herein 
are unproven, may never develop as the
investment Manager anticipates. could be superseded by other technologies, and are subject to sigrificani investment 
risks.
Past performance is not indicative nor a guarantee of future returns.

Honeycomb Offshore Fund Lid. (the 'Offshore Fund') has not been approved for distribution in or from Switzerland by the 
Swiss Financial Market Supervisory
Authority. Asa result. the Offshore Fund's shares may only be offered or distributed to qualified investors within the 
meaning of Swiss law. The Representative
of
the Offshore Fund n Switzerland is Bastions Partners Office SA with registered office at Route de Chene 61A. 1208 
Geneva. Switzerland. The Paying Agent n
Switzerland is Banque Heritage SA. with registered office al Route de Chene 61.1208 Geneva. Switzerland. The place of 
performance and jurisdiction for shares of
the Offshore Fund distributed in or from Switzerland are at the registered office of the Representative.
5
Conti:tenon! - Not for Disaixban
EFTA00808277 (Jmail)
 [tech] Valar Ventures contract
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
I VALAR GLOBAL FUND HILV LP
AMENDED AND RESTATED
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
I 147765658 v.1-1
Table of Contents
Page
ARTICLE 1 NAME, PURPOSE AND OFFICES OF PARTNERSHIP
1.1 Name
1.2 Purpose
1.3 Principal Office
1.4 Registered Agent and Office
ARTICLE 2 TERM OF PARTNERSHIP
2.1 Term
2.2 Events Affecting a Member of the General Partner
2.3 Events Affecting a Limited Partner of the Partnership 2
2.4 Events Affecting the General Partner 2
ARTICLE 3 NAME AND ADMISSION OF PARTNERS 2
3.1 Name and Address 2
3.2 Admission of Additional Partners 2
3.3 Removal of the General Partner 3
ARTICLE 4 CAPITAL ACCOUNTS, CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS AND
NONCONTRIBUTING PARTNERS 4
4.1 Capital Accounts 4
4.2 Capital Contributions of the Limited Partners 4
4.3 Capital Contributions of the General Partner 6
4.4 Acquisition of an Additional Interest by the General Partner 6
4.5 Noncontributing Partners 6
4.6 Suspension Period 10
ARTICLE 5 PARTNERSHIP ALLOCATIONS 11
5.1 Allocation of Profit or Loss 11
5.2 Allocation of Ordinary Income and Ordinary Loss 13
S4 Realleeatiert-ef-cenfingent-Lesses
5.43 Special Allocations -1413
5.4 Regulatory Allocations   B
5.5 ReguleteFyIncome  Tax Allocations 14
Ineeme-Tax-Afiesatiens 44
ARTICLE 6 MANAGEMENT FEE; PARTNERSHIP EXPENSES 15
r.
147765658 v.14
Table of Contents a)
Page
6.1 Management Fee 15
6.2 Expenses 17
ARTICLE 7 WITHDRAWALS BY AND DISTRIBUTIONS TO THE PARTNERS 18
7.1 Interest 18
7.2 Withdrawals by the Partners 18
7.3 Partners' Obligation to Repay or Restore 18
7.4 Mandatory Distributions 18
7.5 Discretionary Distributions and Rules Regarding Distributions 19
7.6 Withholding Obligations 24-20
ARTICLE 8 MANAGEMENT DUTIES AND RESTRICTIONS 2221
8.1 Management 2221
8.2 No Control by the Limited Partners; No Withdrawal 22
8.3 Existing Funds; Follow-On Funds; Opportunity Fund;. Parallel Funds 22
8.4 Investment Opportunities and Conflicts of Interest 24
ARTICLE 9 INVESTMENT REPRESENTATION AND TRANSFER OF
PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS 2;28
9.1 Investment Representation of the Limited Partners 2-728
9.2 Qualifications of the Limited Partners 28
9.3 Transfer by General Partner 28
9.4 Transfer by Limited Partner 28
9.5 Requirements for Transfer 2829
9.6 Substitution as a Limited Partner  29
9.7 Expenses of Transfer 2930
ARTICLE 10 DISSOLUTION AND LIQUIDATION OF THE PARTNERSHIP 30
10.1 Extension of Partnership Term 30
10.2 Early Termination of the Partnership 30
10.3 Winding Up Procedures 4031
10.4 Payments in Liquidation  31
10.5 Return of Excess Distributions 31
ARTICLE 11 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING, REPORTS AND MEETINGS 33
11.1 Financial Accounting; Fiscal Year 33
147765658 v44
Table of Contents a)
Page
11.2 Supervision; Inspection of Books 33
11.3 Quarterly Reports 33
11.4 Annual Report; Financial Statements of the Partnership 33
11.5 Website Based Reporting 4434
1 1.6 Annual Meeting 34
11.7 Tax Returns 34
11.8 Tax Matters Partner 4435
11.9 Partnership Funds 3336
ARTICLE 12 VALUATION; ADVISORY COMMITTEE 4536
12.1 Valuation 4436
12.2 Advisory Committee 3637
ARTICLE 13 PARTNERS SUBJECT TO SPECIAL REGULATION 3637
13.1 ERISA Partners 3637
13.2 Governmental Plan Partners 4438
13.3 Private Foundation Partners 3839
ARTICLE 14 CERTAIN DEFINITIONS 3839
14.1 Accounting Period 3439
14.2 Adjusted Asset Value 3839
14.3 Adjusted Capital Account Balance 39
14.4 Affiliate 4940
14.5 Capital Account 4940
14.6 Capital Commitment; Committed Capital 4940
14.7 Code 3940
14.8 Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss 3940
14.9 Reserved 40
14.10 Marketable; Marketable Securities; Marketability 40
14.11 Nonmarketable Securities 4041
14.12 Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss 4041
14.13 Partnership Percentage 4041
14.14 Percentage in Interest; Majority in Interest 4041
14.15 Prime Rate 4041
147765658 v44
Table of Contents a)
Page
14.16 Profit or Loss 4041
14.17 Regulated Partner  44-42
14.18 Securities 4442
14.19 Securities Act 4442
14.20 Short-Term Securities 44-42
14.21 Thiel Persons 4442
14.22 Treasury Regulations 4442
ARTICLE 15 OTHER PROVISIONS 42
15.1 Governing Law 42
15.2 Limitation of Liability of the Limited Partners 42
15.3 Exculpation 4243
15.4 Indemnification /B14
15.5 Arbitration 4445
15.6 Execution of Documents 4546
15.7 Other Instruments and Acts 4546
15.8 Binding Agreement 4546
15.9 Notices; Electronic Transmission of Reports 4446
15.10 Power of Attorney 4546
15.11 Amendment 4647
15.12 Entire Agreement 47
15.13 Titles; Subtitles 4748
15.14 Partnership Name 4-748
15.15 Confidentiality 4448
EXHIBIT A: Schedule of Partners A-1
iv.
147765658 v44
INDEX OF DEFINITIONS
Term Paragraph
Accounting Period 14.1
Act Preamble
Adjusted Asset Value 14.2
Adjusted Capital Account Balance 14.3
Administrator 15.5(a)
Advisory Committee 12.2
Affected Parties 15.15(a)
Affiliate 14.4
Affiliates Fund 8.3(c)
Affiliated Party 8.4(b)
After-Tax Distribution Amount 10.5(a)
Agreement Preamble
Annual Tax Amount 7.4(a)
Applicable Tax Rate 10.5(a)
Arbitration 15.5(a)
Arbitrator 15.5(a)
Capital Account 14.5
Capital Commitment 14.6
Carried Interest Distributions 10.5(a)
Cashless Contribution 4.3
Claim 15.5(a)
Code 14.7
Combined Capital Commitments 8.4(a)
Commencement Date 2.1
Commitment Period 4.2(a)
Committed Capital 14.6
Confidential Information 15.15(a)
Geatiagent-Less
Deemed Gain 14.8
Deemed Loss 14.8
Default Notice 4.5(b)
Defaulting Limited Partner 4.5(b)
DOL Regulations 4.2(b)
ERISA 4.2(b)
ERISA Partner 13.1(a)
Fee Adjustment Amount 6.1(c)(ii)
First Allocation Hurdle 5.1(b)
Funded Percentage 10.5(b)
General Partner Preamble
Governmental Plan Partner 13.2
Indemnified Parties 15.4
Initial Closing Date Preamble
Late Admission Charge 3.2(c)
Limited Partners Preamble
Loss 14.16
Majority in Interest 14.14
Management Company 8.1
Management Fee 6.1(a)
v.
147765658 v44
Term Paragraph
Management Fee Percentage 6.1(b)
Managing Member 4.6(b)
Marketable 14.10
Marketable Securities 14.10
Marketability 14.10
Nonmarketable Securities 14.11
Opportunity Fund 8.3(b)
Optionees 4.5(b)(vii)
Optionor 4.5(b)(vii)
Ordinary Income 14.12
Ordinary Loss 14.12
Paragraph 10.5 Reapplication Amount 4.2(d)(iii)
Parallel Funds 8.3(c)
Partners 3.1
Partnership Preamble
Partnership Percentage 14.13
Partnership Representative 11.8(b)
Percentage in Interest 14.14
Placement Agent Fees 6.1(e)
Pooled Vehicle Partner 15.15(e)
Prime Rate 14.15
Prior Funds 8.3(a)(ii)
Private Foundation Partner 13.2
Profit 14.16
Regulated Partner 14.17
Regulatory Allocations 5.34(a)
Remaining Portion 4.5(b)(viiX2)
Reporting Site 11.5
Second Allocation Hurdle 5.1(b)
Securities 14.18
Securities Act 14.19
Short-Term Securities 14.20
Side Letter 15.12
Special Purpose Investment Fund 8.4(a)
Subject Reports 11.5
Successor Fund 8.3(a)(iii)
Successor Fund Eligible Date 8.3(b)
Suspension Event 4.6(b)
Suspension Period 4.6(b)
Target•-Balance Srl
Tax Payments 7.6(a)
Termination Date 2.1
Thiel Activities 15.3(d)
Thiel Persons 14.21
Treasury Regulations 14.22
Trigger Event 3.3(c)
UBTI 8.4(g)
Uncalled Amount 6.1(c)(ii)
Uncalled Cashless Contribution 6.1(c)(ii)
VCOC 4.2(b)
vi.
I 147765658 •44
Term Paragraph
VCOC Notice 4.2(b)
vii.
I 147765658 v44
VALAR GLOBAL FUND HMV LP
AMENDED AND RESTATED LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
This AMENDED AND RESTATED LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT (the "Agreement") is made
and entered into as of June 24December , 20167 (the "Initial Closing Date"),  by and among VALAR
VENTURES GP 4141V LLC, a Delaware limited liability company (the "General Partner"), and each
investor who is identified as a limited partner on EXHIBIT A hereto (the "Limited Partners"), who hereby
amend and restate the initial limited partnership agreement dated January-20December   , 20167
(ille ttitiai-Closing-Daten)-of VALAR GLOBAL FUND 141IV LP (the "Partnership"), formed pursuant to
the provisions of the Delaware Revised Uniform Limited Partnership Act (the "Act'), to read in its
entirety as follows:
ARTICLE 1
NAME, PURPOSE AND OFFICES OF PARTNERSHIP
I
I
1.1 Name. The name of the Partnership is VALAR GLOBAL FUND HMV LP. The affairs of
the Partnership shall be conducted under the Partnership name, or such other name as the General Partner
may, in its discretion, determine.

1.2 Purpose. The primary purpose of the Partnership is to provide a limited number of select
investors with the opportunity to realize long-term appreciation, generally from venture capital
investments in earlier-stage, high-growth technology companies as a result of direct, privately negotiated
investments in equity or equity -oriented securities of private and public companies. The general purposes
of the Partnership are to buy, sell, hold, and otherwise invest in Securities of every kind and nature and
rights and options with respect thereto, including, without limitation, stock, notes, bonds, debentures, and
evidence of indebtedness; to exercise all rights, powers, privileges, and other incidents of ownership or
possession with respect to Securities held or owned by the Partnership; to enter into, make, and perform
all contracts and other undertakings; and to engage in all activities and transactions as may be necessary,
advisable, or desirable to carry out the foregoing.

1.3 Principal Office. The principal office of the Partnership shall be at 915 Broadway, Suite
1101, New York, NY 10010, or such other place or places as the General Partner may from time to time
designate. The General Partner shall provide the Limited Partners with prompt written notice of any
change in the location of the Partnership's principal office.

1.4 Registered Agent and Office. The name of the registered agent for service of process of
the Partnership and the address of the Partnership's registered office in the State of Delaware shall be The
Corporation Trust Company, 1209 Orange Street, Wilmington, Delaware 19801, or such other agent or
office in the State of Delaware as the General Partner may from time to time designate.
ARTICLE 2
TERM OF PARTNERSHIP
2.1 Term. The term of the Partnership shall commence upon the date of the filing of the
Certificate of Limited Partnership of the Partnership with the office of the Secretary of State of the State
of Delaware. The term of the Partnership shall continue until the tenth anniversary of the date en-vAilehof
the Partnership's  initial eapitel-eentribution-is-dueinvestment  in a portfolio company  (such date of the
initial capital contribution being referred to herein as the "Commencement Date" and such tenth
147765658 v44
anniversary being referred to as the "Termination Date"), unless extended pursuant to paragraph 10.1 or
sooner dissolved as provided in paragraph 10.2.

2.2 Events Affecting a Member of the General Partner. Except as specifically provided in
paragraph 10.2, the death, bankruptcy, withdrawal, insanity, incompetency, temporary or permanent
incapacity, expulsion, removal, liquidation, dissolution, reorganization, merger, sale of all or substantially
all the stock or assets of, or other change in the ownership or nature of any member of the General Partner
shall not dissolve the Partnership.
2.3 Events Affecting a Limited Partner of the Partnership. The death, bankruptcy,
withdrawal, insanity, incompetency, temporary or permanent incapacity, liquidation, dissolution,
reorganization, merger, sale of all or substantially all the stock or assets of, or other change in the
ownership or nature of a Limited Partner shall not dissolve the Partnership.

2.4 Events Affecting the General Partner. Except as specifically provided in paragraph
10.2, the withdrawal, bankruptcy, expulsion, resignation, removal, liquidation, dissolution,
reorganization, merger, sale of all or substantially all the stock or assets of, or other change in the
ownership or nature of the General Partner shall not constitute an "event of withdrawal" of the General
Partner under the Act, and upon the happening of any such event, the affairs of the Partnership shall be
continued without dissolution by the General Partner or any successor entity thereto.
ARTICLE 3
NAME AND ADMISSION OF PARTNERS
3.1 Name and Address. The name and address of the General Partner and each Limited
Partner (hereinafter the General Partner and the Limited Partners shall be referred to collectively as the
"Partners" and each individually as a "Partner"), the amount of such Partner's Capital Commitment to
the Partnership, and such Partner's Partnership Percentage are set forth on a separate and confidential
EXHIBIT A hereto, marked as EXII IBIT A-1 thru EXHIBIT A-i (with a separate EXHIBIT A for each Partner).
The General Partner shall cause EXHIBIT A to be amended from time to time to reflect the admission of
any new Partner, the withdrawal or substitution of any Partner, the transfer of interests among Partners,
receipt by the Partnership of notice of any change of address of a Partner or the change in any Partner's
Capital Commitment or Partnership Percentage. An amended EXHIBIT A shall supersede any prior
EXHIBIT A and become a part of this Agreement. A copy of the most recent amended EXHIBIT A shall be
kept on file at the principal office of the Partnership.
3.2 Admission of Additional Partners.

(a) Except as provided in paragraphs 3.2(b), 4.5(bXvii)(4) and 9.6, an additional
person may be admitted as a Partner only with the consent of the General Partner and Eighty Percent in
Interest of the Limited Partners.

(b) Notwithstanding subparagraph (a) above, additional persons may be admitted as
Limited Partners (or existing Limited Partners may increase their Capital Commitments) with the consent
of only the General Partner on or before the date that is sianine (62) months after the Initial
GlesingCommencement  Date; provided that the aggregate capital commitments to the Partnership and the
Parallel Funds shall not exceed two hundred and-fifty-million dollars ($2500,000,000).

(c) Each additional person admitted as a Limited Partner subsequent to the Initial
Closing Date (and each existing Limited Partner that increases its Capital Commitment) shall (i) execute
2.
147765658 v44
and deliver to the Partnership a counterpart of this Agreement or otherwise take such actions as the
General Partner shall deem appropriate in order for such Limited Partner to become bound by the terms of
this Agreement, (ii) contribute that portion of its (or such) Capital Commitment which is equal to the
portion of the respective Capital Commitments contributed to date by the Partnership's previously
admitted Limited Partners, and (iii) pay to the Partnership a "Late Admission Charge" (which shall be
deemed Ordinary Income of the Partnership and not be treated as a capital contribution) equal to interest
on the amount contributed by such Partner pursuant to the preceding clause (ii) at an annual interest rate
that is two hundred basis points (2.0%) higher than the Prime Rate (determined as of the close of business
on the date of such admission or increase), compounded daily, from the date(s) that such Partner would
have been required to contribute such amount if it had been admitted (or had such increased Capital
Commitment) at-the-initial-Glesingas of the Rartnershiplnitial  Closing Date; provided that this clause (iii)
shall not apply to a Limited Partner admitted to the Partnership (or allowed to increase its Capital
Commitment) within ninety (90) days from the Commencement Date. Limited Partners admitted to the
Partnership after the Initial Closing Date will not be entitled to share in or be allocated any Ordinary
Income (including, without limitation, Late Admission Charges) accruing on or prior to their admission
date. At the election of the General Partner, any Late Admission Charge owed to the Partnership by a
Limited Partner may be paid to the Partnership through an offsetting reduction in such Limited Partner's
Capital Account balance.

(d) Upon the admission of any additional Limited Partner pursuant to this paragraph
3.2, the General Partner may, in its sole discretion, make a special distribution of all or a portion of the
initial contribution of capital made by such additional Limited Partner. Such distribution shall be made to
all Partners in accordance with Partnership Percentages (as adjusted to reflect the admission of such
additional Limited Partner) and shall be deemed to be a return of capital to such Partners; provided,
however, that such Partners shall be deemed, for the purposes of paragraph 4.2, not to have contributed
the amount of such distribution, and the amounts of their respective unfunded Capital Commitments shall
be increased accordingly.
3.3 Removal of the General Partner.

(a) Immediately following a Trigger Event (as defined below), the General Partner
shall provide notice to the Limited Partners of the Trigger Event, and at the election of Two-Thirds in
Interest of the Limited Partners, pursuant to a vote occurring during any time during the one hundred and
eighty (180) day period following such notice to the Limited Partners, the General Partner may be
removed from its capacity as the general partner of the Partnership.

(b) In the event of the removal of the General Partner pursuant to paragraph 3.3(a),
the Limited Partners, acting by the same Percentage in Interest required of the vote to remove, shall be
entitled to appoint a replacement general partner on such economic terms and other terms as the
replacement general partner and a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners may agree. In such
event: (i) the removed General Partner shall not be entitled to retain any rights or powers of a general
partner of the Partnership and shall become a special limited partner of the Partnership with a continued
interest in allocations of Profit and Loss and distributions of Partnership cash and assets pursuant to
Articles 5, 7 and 10 hereof; (ii) the removed General Partner shall no longer be required to make
additional capital contributions to the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 4.3 and the removed General
Partner's Capital Commitment shall be equal to the amount actually contributed pursuant to paragraph
4.3; (iii) the removed General Partner shall be entitled to receive all allocations and distributions to which
it would otherwise be entitled to receive had it not been removed when, as and if such allocations and
distributions are made, in respect of all activities of and investments by the Partnership that occurred or
were committed to by the Partnership prior to the effective date of removal; provided, however, that the
removed General Partner shall be entitled to receive one hundred percent (100%) of all allocations and
3.
147765658 •44
distributions in respect of its capital contributions; (iv) the removed General Partner shall not be entitled
to receive any payments of management fee pursuant to paragraph 6.1 with respect to any period of time
after the date of its removal; (v) the removed General Partner and any Indemnified Party shall remain
entitled to exculpation and indemnification pursuant to paragraphs 15.3 and 15.4 with respect to any
matter arising prior to or out of events or circumstances existing prior to the General Partner's removal;
and (vi) an interest in the Partnership equal to the General Partner's unfunded Capital Commitment and
the remaining carried interest in the Partnership shall be transferred to the replacement general partner
upon its admission to the Partnership.

(c) For purposes of this paragraph 3.3, a "Trigger Event' shall have occurred if the
General Partner or any Managing Member is (i) found by a court of competent jurisdiction or arbitration
carried out pursuant to paragraph 15.5 to have committed (or enters a plea of nolo contendere to having
committed) embezzlement, fraud or any other act involving material improper personal benefit against the
Partnership or its assets, or (ii) is convicted of a violation of federal or state securities law or a felony (but
not including a felony involving the use of a motor vehicle) in a manner that had a material adverse effect
on the Partnership; provided, however, that no Trigger Event shall be deemed to have occurred if, in the
case of acts by a Managing Member, the offending individual is removed as a managing member of the
General Partner within thirty (30) days after the court judgment or arbitration decision, or conviction,
which would otherwise have given rise to a Trigger Event under this paragraph 3.3.

(d) Notwithstanding anything in paragraph 15.11 and in the event of any election
made to remove the General Partner, the Partners agree to amend this Agreement in good faith in order to
give effect to the foregoing provisions of this paragraph 3.3, including but not limited to revising Exhibit
A to reflect changes in the Partners' identities, Capital Commitments and Partnership Percentages.
The General Partner shall promptly notify the Limited Partners if the General
Partner or any Managing Member is found to have committed (or enters a plea of nolo contendere to
having committed) embezzlement, fraud or any other act involving material improper personal benefit, or
is convicted of a violation of federal or state securities law or a felony, regardless of whether any such act
relates to the Partnership or not.
ARTICLE 4
CAPITAL ACCOUNTS, CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS
AND NONCONTRIBUTING PARTNERS
4.1 Capital Accounts. An individual Capital Account shall be maintained for each Partner.
4.2 Capital Contributions of the Limited Partners.

(a) Each Limited Partner shall contribute capital to the Partnership as requested by
the General Partner upon ten (10) business days' prior written notice (which such notice shall be given by
electronic mail or by a nationally recognized overnight courier, specifying next day delivery, in
accordance with paragraph 15.9); provided, that the initial capital contribution from each Limited Partner
shall not be due earlier than January 1, 20168. The General Partner may request capital contributions
from the Limited Partners, on the terms specified in this paragraph 4.2(a) or as altered under a Side Letter.
Except as set forth in paragraphs 3.2(c) and 4.2(b), each capital contribution shall be in accordance with
Partnership Percentages; provided, however, that the capital contributions from the Limited Partners may
be adjusted by the General Partner in good faith in order to account for the fact that no Management Fee
is chargeable in respect of the General Partner's interest in the Partnership. Notwithstanding anything in
the foregoing to the contrary, no Limited Partner shall be required to contribute any capital after the fi fth
4.
147765658 v44
anniversary of the Commencement Date (the period between the Commencement Date and the fifth
anniversary thereof being referred to herein as the "Commitment Period"), except as may be necessary
for (a) Partnership expenses, including, but not limited to, payment of any Management Fee (as defined
below) due to the General Partner; (b) completion of transactions evidenced by a written terms sheet (or
other similar statement of intent to make an investment that has been executed by the Partnership) prior to
the end of the Commitment Period; (c) follow-on investments in the Securities of issuers in which the
Partnership holds a pre-existing interest as of the date of such proposed follow-on investment; and (d)
fulfillment of such Limited Partner's obligations pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(i). Further, each Limited
Partner's obligation to contribute capital shall also be subject to those limitations set forth in paragraph
4.6. Each capital contribution by any Limited Partner shall be made in U.S. dollars and made in cash or
by transfer of immediately -available funds.

(b) Notwithstanding paragraph 4.2(a), with respect to the Partnership's initial request
for capital contributions under this paragraph 4.2, in the event that the sum of the Capital Commitments
of all Limited Partners that are "benefit plan investors" is such as would make their "equity participation"
in the Partnership "significant," within the meaning of those terms under U.S. Department of Labor
Regulation § 2510.3-101, as modified by Section 3(42) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act
of 1974, as amended ("ERISA") (the "DOL Regulations"), then no such Limited Partner shall be
required to contribute capital to the Partnership pursuant to this Agreement until such time as the General
Partner shall have delivered to such Limited Partner an opinion of counsel (which opinion and counsel
shall be reasonably acceptable to the Limited Partner) to the effect that the Partnership's first portfolio
company investment (other than a short-term investment of funds pending long-term commitment) has
qualified or will qualify upon the funding of each Limited Partner's initial capital contribution as a
"venture capital investment" within the meaning of the DOL Regulations such that the Partnership will
qualify as a "venture capital operating company" (a "VCOC') within the meaning of the DOL
Regulations (the "VCOC Opinion"). In the event that such a Limited Partner has not received the VCOC
Opinion prior to the date on which any capital contribution would otherwise be due under paragraph
4.2(a), such Limited Partner shall pay such capital contribution into an interest-bearing escrow account
designated by the General Partner. The terms of any such escrow account shall be determined by the
General Partner in compliance with ERISA (including the principles and conditions indicated in Dept. of
Labor Adv. Op. 95-04A), to the extent applicable. Upon delivery of the VCOC Opinion, all amounts in
the escrow account shall be delivered to the Partnership in fulfillment of such Limited Partner's
then-outstanding obligations under paragraph 4.2(a).

(c) The General Partner may, in its sole discretion, return to the Partners all or a
portion of any capital contribution intended for a proposed investment which is not consummated as
anticipated pro rata in accordance with their respective capital contributions; provided, however, that
such returned capital shall be added back to unfunded Capital Commitments pro raw in accordance with
the percentages in which such returned capital was attributed to the Capital Commitments when such
capital was called and be subject to recall by the General Partner pursuant to this Article 4.

(d) If, in the discretion of the General Partner, Partnership assets are
insufficient to fulfill any indemnification obligation of the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 15.4 prior to
the final liquidation of the Partnership, the General Partner may to the fullest extent permitted by
applicable law require each Partner to contribute capital to the Partnership in an amount up to such
Partner's unfunded Capital Commitment, if any.

(ii) If, in the discretion of the General Partner, Partnership assets remain
insufficient to fulfill any indemnification obligation of the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 15.4, and
following the contribution to the Partnership of the maximum amount then permitted by paragraph
4.2(d)(i), the General Partner may recall distributions previously made to the Partners solely for the
5.
147765658 v44
purpose of fulfilling or satisfying such an obligation or liability. Such distributions shall be recalled from
the Partners in the same proportions as the expense (or loss) of the indemnity obligation giving rise to
such recontribution was allocated to the Partners pursuant to Article 5. In no event shall any Partner be
required to contribute capital pursuant to this paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) in an amount in excess of the lesser of

(I) all distributions previously received by the Partner from the Partnership or (2) twenty-five percent
(25%) of such Partner's Capital Commitment. In no event will the General Partner be permitted to call
capital pursuant to this paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) in connection with a certain distribution after the earlier of
(A) the date two (2) years after the Termination Date (or any subsequent date to which the Partnership
term has previously been extended pursuant to paragraph 10.1) and (B) the date three (3) years after the
date of such distribution.
(iii) In the event that the Partners are required to return distributions as
provided in paragraph 4.2(dXii) following the final liquidation of the Partnership, paragraph 10.5 shall be
reapplied to account for the associated indemnification expense and, to the extent that the General Partner
would have any additional obligation to return capital pursuant to paragraph 10.5 as a result of such
reapplication (the "Paragraph 10.5 Reapplication Amount), the proportions in which the Partners bear
the return obligation pursuant to paragraph 4.2(dXii) shall be appropriately adjusted by increasing the
General Partner's obligation to contribute capital to the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) by the
Paragraph 10.5 Reapplication Amount, and reducing the aggregate obligation of the Limited Partners to
contribute capital pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) by a like amount. For the purpose of this paragraph
4.2(d)(iii) only, the aggregate maximum amount that the General Partner may be required to return to the
Partnership pursuant to paragraph 10.5 shall not be limited to After-Tax Distribution Amount.
4.3 Capital Contributions of the General Partner. The General Partner and/or its
designated Affiliate shall contribute capital to the Partnership, and have a Capital Commitment, in an
amount equal to 1.0028% of the aggregate Capital Commitments of all Partners, on the same schedule
and terms under which any Limited Partner makes a contribution. Further, the General Partner or its
Affiliates, or their respective members, may contribute additional capital to one or more Parallel Funds.
Twenty percent (20%) of each capital contribution made by the General Partner or its designated Affiliate
shall be made in cash. Eighty percent (80%) of each capital contribution made by the General Partner or
its designated Affiliate shall not be made in cash, but shall be deemed to have been made by the General
Partner or its designated Affiliate and shall result in a dollar-for-dollar reduction in the amount of
management fee that it would otherwise receive pursuant to paragraph 6.1 in the manner set forth in
paragraph 6.1(cXii) (the amount of each such deemed contribution, a "Cashless Contribution"). If a
designated Affiliate of the General Partner makes the Capital Commitment described in this paragraph
4.3, then the interest so held by the designated Affiliate shall be a Limited Partner's interest and treated as
an interest held by a Limited Partner for all purposes under this Agreement.

4.4 Acquisition of an Additional Interest by the General Partner. In the event that the
General Partner or its designated Affiliate acquires or holds an additional interest in the Partnership with a
Capital Commitment that exceeds 4410281.0% of the aggregate Capital Commitments of all Partners
(pursuant to a transfer from another Limited Partner or otherwise), the General Partner shall have two (2)
Partnership Percentages and two (2) Capital Account balances for purposes of making Partnership
allocations—(4flekieting—aar realleeatien—ef--Centingent—hesses—pursufrat—te—pacagraph-5,33, as if such
additional excess interest were held by a separate entity which is a Limited Partner, although for all other
purposes the General Partner shall have only one Capital Account.
4.5 Noncontributing Partners.

(a) The Partnership shall be entitled to enforce the obligations of each Limited
Partner to make the contributions to capital set forth in paragraph 4.2, and the Partnership shall have all
6.
147765658 44
remedies available at law or in equity in the event any such contribution is not so made. If any legal
proceedings relating to the failure of a Limited Partner to make such a contribution are commenced, such
Limited Partner shall pay all costs and expenses incurred by the Partnership, including attorneys' fees and
expenses, in connection with such proceedings.

(b) Additionally, without in any way limiting any remedy which the Partnership may
pursue pursuant to paragraph 4.5(a), should any Limited Partner fail to make any of the capital
contributions required of it under this Agreement, such Limited Partner shall be in default. In the event of
such default, the General Partner may, in its sole discretion, elect to enforce one or more of the provisions
of this paragraph 4.5(b) in connection with such a default, to which each Limited Partner hereby
expressly consents, provided such default shall have continued uncured for ten (10) or more days after
delivery of the Default Notice described in the following sentence (after such ten (10)-day period, such
Limited Partner shall be deemed a "Defaulting Limited Partner"). The General Partner shall deliver
written notice to such Defaulting Limited Partner in the event that it determines to utilize one or more of
the powers set forth in this paragraph 4.5(b) (a "Default Notice"). If the default shall have continued
uncured for ten (10) or more days after delivery of the Default Notice, the Defaulting Limited Partner
may not make any additional contributions of capital against such Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital
Commitment (other than to fund Management Fees and other expenses of the Partnership) without the
written consent of the General Partner, which consent may be granted or denied in the sole discretion of
the General Partner. In enforcing any of the following provisions of this paragraph 4.5(b) against a
Defaulting Limited Partner, the General Partner agrees that it shall use commercially reasonable efforts to
enforce such provisions against such Defaulting Limited Partner in a manner so as to prevent the other
non-Defaulting Limited Partners from bearing a net economic burden attributable to Management Fees
that, absent such default, would be borne by the Defaulting Limited Partner if the Defaulting Limited
Partner were to retain its interest in the Partnership and make capital contributions in respect thereof.
The General Partner may waive, in whole or in part, the requirement of
payment with respect to any due and unpaid capital contributions by a Defaulting Limited Partner
pursuant to this Agreement and reduce such Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Commitment
accordingly.

(ii) The General Partner may extend the time of payment for a Defaulting
Limited Partner of any due and unpaid capital contributions by such Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant
to this Agreement.
(iii) The General Partner may declare the entire amount of a Defaulting
Limited Partner's then unfunded Capital Commitment to be immediately due and payable.

(iv) On behalf of the Partnership, the General Partner may enforce, by
appropriate legal proceedings, the Defaulting Limited Partner's obligation to make payment on the
amount of any due and unpaid capital contributions by such Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to this
Agreement or to pay the entire amount of such Defaulting Limited Partner's then unfunded Capital
Commitment.

(v) The Defaulting Limited Partner shall have no right to participate in any
vote or consent of the Partners required under this Agreement or permitted under the Act and the Capital
Commitment of such Defaulting Limited Partner shall not be included for purposes of calculating a
Majority in Interest or other Percentage in Interest of the Limited Partners for purposes of this Agreement.

(vi) Should the General Partner, in its sole discretion, elect to exercise the
provisions of this paragraph 4.5(bXvi), such Defaulting Limited Partner shall pay all expenses to be
7.
147765658 v44
incurred or anticipated to be incurred by the Partnership in connection with the default and interest on the
amount of the contribution to the Partnership then due at the Prime Rate plus one hundred (100) basis
points per annum (or if less, the highest rate permitted by applicable law), such interest to accrue from the
date the contribution to the Partnership was required to be made pursuant to this Agreement until the date
the contribution is made by such Defaulting Limited Partner, unless such payment is waived by the
General Partner. The accrued interest shall be paid by the Defaulting Limited Partner to the Partnership
upon payment of such contribution. The accrued interest so paid shall not be treated as an additional
contribution to the capital of the Partnership, but shall be deemed to be income to the Partnership;
provided, however, that such income shall not be allocated to the Capital Account of the Defaulting
Limited Partner. Until such time as the unpaid contribution and accrued interest thereon shall have been
paid by the Defaulting Limited Partner, the General Partner may elect to withhold any or all distributions
to be made to such Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to Article 7 or Article 10 and recover any such
unpaid contribution and accrued interest thereon by set off against any such distribution withheld.
(vii) Should the General Partner, in its sole discretion, elect to exercise the
provisions of this paragraph 4.5(b)(vii), the General Partner and the nondefaulting Limited Partners (the
"Optionees"), shall have the right and the option, but not the obligation, to acquire the Partnership interest
of the Defaulting Limited Partner (the "Optionor"), as follows:

(1) The General Partner shall notify the Optionees of the default
within twenty (20) days of the expiration of the ten (10) day notice period commencing upon delivery of
the Default Notice. Such notice shall advise each Optionee of the portion and the price of the Optionor's
interest available to it. The portion available to each Optionee shall be a fraction, the numerator of which
is its Capital Commitment and the denominator of which is the aggregate Capital Commitments of the
Optionees. The aggregate price for the Optionor's interest shall be the lesser of fifty percent (50%) of (A)
the amount of the Optionor's Capital Account calculated as of the due date of the additional contribution
and adjusted to reflect the allocation of the appropriate proportion of the Partnership's unrealized gains
and losses as of the due date of such defaulted contribution, and (B) the aggregate amount of the
Optionor's capital contributions actually made less any distributions (valued at their fair market value on
the date of distribution in accordance with paragraph 12.1) on or prior to such due date. The price for each
Optionee shall be prorated according to the portion of the Optionor's interest purchased by each such
Optionee. The option granted hereunder shall be exercisable at any time after the date thirty (30) days
following the date of the initial notice of default from the General Partner to the Optionor by delivery to
the Optionor of a notice of exercise of option together with a nonrecourse promissory note for the
purchase price and a security agreement in accordance with subparagraph (5) below, which notice and
documents the General Partner shall promptly forward to the Optionor.

(2) Should any Optionee not exercise its option within said thirty
(30) day period provided in subparagraph (1), the General Partner shall immediately notify the other
Optionees who have elected to exercise their option, which Optionees shall have the right and option
ratably among them to acquire the portion of the Optionor's interest not so acquired (the "Remaining
Portion") within thirty (30) days of the date of the notice specified in this subparagraph (2) on the same
terms as provided in subparagraph (1).

(3) Any amount of the Remaining Portion not acquired by the
Optionees pursuant to subparagraph (2) may be acquired by the General Partner within thirty (30) days of
the expiration of the thirty (30) day period specified in subparagraph (2) on the same terms as set forth in
subparagraph (1); provided, however, that the General Partner shall not be obligated to make the
additional contributions otherwise due from the Optionor with respect to the Remaining Portion so
acquired.
8.
147765658 v44

(4) Any amount of the Remaining Portion not acquired by the
Optionees and the General Partner pursuant to subparagraphs (2) or (3) may, if the General Partner deems
it in the best interest of the Partnership, be sold by the General Partner to any other investor, on terms not
more favorable to such parties than those applicable to the Optionees' option, and upon the consent of the
General Partner, any such third party purchaser may become a Limited Partner to the extent of the interest
purchased hereunder.

(5) The price due from each of the General Partner and the
Optionees (and, if applicable, any third party purchaser pursuant to subparagraph (4)) shall be payable by
a noninterest bearing, nonrecourse promissory note (in such form as the General Partner shall designate)
due upon final liquidation of the Partnership. Each such note shall be secured by the portion of the
Optionor's Partnership interest so purchased by its maker pursuant to a security agreement in a form
designated by the General Partner and shall be enforceable by the Optionor only against such security.
(6) Upon exercise of any option hereunder, each Optionee (and, if
applicable, any third party purchaser pursuant to subparagraph (4)) shall be obligated (A) to contribute to
the Partnership that portion of the additional capital then due from the Optionor equal to the percentage of
the Optionor's interest purchased by such person and (B) except as otherwise provided in subparagraph
(3), to pay the same percentage of any further contributions otherwise due from such Optionor on the date
such contributions are otherwise due. Each person who purchases a portion of the Optionor's Partnership
interest shall be deemed to have acquired such portion as of the due date of the additional capital
contribution with respect to which the Optionor defaulted, and any distributions made after the due date
on account of the Optionor's interest shall be distributed among such purchasers (and, unless the entire
interest was purchased, the Optionor) in accordance with their ultimate respective interests in the
Optionor's interest. Distributions otherwise allocable to the Optionor under the preceding sentence shall
first be used to offset any defaulted contribution of the Optionor still due to the Partnership. Upon
completion of any transaction hereunder, the General Partner shall cause EXHIBIT A to be amended to
reflect all necessary changes resulting therefrom including, without limitation, admission of a purchaser
as a Limited Partner, and adjustment of Capital Account balances, Capital Commitment amounts and
Partnership Percentages as of the date of Optionor's default to reflect the acquisition from Optionor of the
appropriate pro rata portion of each such item (including, if applicable, the reduction of aggregate Capital
Commitments and resulting adjustment of Partnership Percentages in connection with any acquisition of
any Remaining Portion by the General Partner pursuant to subparagraph (3)). The purchase and transfer
of the Partnership interest of the Optionor shall occur automatically upon exercise by any Optionee or the
General Partner of its option hereunder, or by any third-party purchaser pursuant to subparagraph (4),
without any action by Optionor.

(7) Notwithstanding the sale of any portion of an Optionor's interest
pursuant to this paragraph 4.5(b)(vii), such Optionor shall not be released from its unfunded Capital
Commitment except as actually funded by the acquirer of any such portion of Optionor's interest.

(8) In the event that any amount of the Remaining Portion is not
acquired by the Optionees, the General Partner and any third party purchasers pursuant to paragraphs
4.5(b)(viiX1)-(4), then, in its sole discretion, the General Partner may apply any of the remedies described
in paragraphs 4.5(a) and (b) to such unsold portion.
(viii) The General Partner may, in its sole discretion, elect to remove such
Defaulting Limited Partner from the Partnership, in which event (1) fifty percent (50%) of the Defaulting
Limited Partner's Capital Account balance shall be forfeited and reallocated to the Capital Accounts of
the nondefaulting Partners proportionally, based on, with respect to each such Partner, the ratio that its
Partnership Percentage immediately prior to such calculation bears to the aggregate Partnership
9.
147765658 v44
Percentages of all Partners (other than the Defaulting Limited Partner), (2) the remaining fifty percent
(50%) of the Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Account balance shall be payable by the Partnership in
installments over a period of no more than three (3) years from the effective date of the removal of such
Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to this paragraph 4.5(b)(viii), and (3) the Defaulting Limited
Partner's Partnership Percentage shall be reduced to zero.

(ix) The General Partner may, in its sole discretion, elect to use reasonable
efforts to assist such Defaulting Limited Partner transfer its entire interest in the Partnership.

(x) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, each
Limited Partner (I) agrees that it will execute any instruments or perform any other acts that are or may
be necessary to effectuate and carry out the transactions contemplated by this paragraph 4.5, and (2)
designates and appoints the General Partner its true and lawful attorney, in its name, place and stead, to
make, execute, and sign any and all instruments, documents, or certificates on behalf of any Defaulting
Limited Partner in order to give effect to any remedy against such Defaulting Limited Partner (including,
but not limited to, the remedies set forth in this paragraph 4.5(b)).

(xi) The Partners agree that the General Partner's authority and discretion to
enforce any remedy against a Defaulting Limited Partner (including but not limited to the remedies set
forth in this paragraph 4.5(b)) supersede any fiduciary duties of the General Partner to such Defaulting
Limited Partner. The Partners further agree that the remedies set forth in this paragraph 4.5(b) are fair
and reasonable in light of the difficulty in ascertaining the actual damages that would be incurred by the
Partnership and the nondefaulting Partners as a result of the Defaulting Limited Partner's failure to
contribute capital when due pursuant to the terms of this Agreement.
(xii) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this paragraph 4.5, a
Regulated Partner shall not be declared to be in default by the General Partner with respect to any due and
unpaid capital contributions in the event that such Regulated Partner is entitled to withdraw from the
Partnership (or the General Partner has requested such withdrawal) pursuant to Article 13 and the failure
to make such due and unpaid capital contributions is the consequence of or attributable to such
withdrawal.
4.6 Suspension Period.

(a) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement to the contrary, no
Limited Partner shall be required to contribute capital to the Partnership in respect of its Capital
Commitment during any Suspension Period (as defined in paragraph 4.6(b)) except for:
Partnership expenses, including payment of any Management Fee due to
the General Partner;

(ii) follow-on investments in portfolio companies in which the Partnership
had invested prior to commencement of the Suspension Period, so long as the Advisory Committee
consents to each such follow-on investment;
(iii) investments which the Partnership had committed to make as evidenced
by a written term sheet prior to commencement of the Suspension Period; and

(iv) fulfillment of such Limited Partner's obligations pursuant to paragraph
4.2(d).
10.
147765658 v44
(b) In the event that either (i) James Fitzgerald or (ii) Andrew McCormack (each, a
"Managing Member," and together, the "Managing Members") ceases to be a managing member of the
General Partner, or otherwise ceases to participate in the management of the Partnership or fails to meet
his obligation to devote his business time to the Partnership to the extent required under paragraphs 8.3(a)
or 8.3(b) (the "Suspension Event'), the Commitment Period shall automatically be suspended and a
"Suspension Period" shall begin (during which the activities described in paragraph 4.6(a) shall not be
permitted).

(c) Upon the occurrence of a Suspension Event, the General Partner shall promptly
notify the Limited Partners of the Suspension Event, and shall promptly circulate a written ballot to the
Limited Partners which asks the Limited Partners to vote on whether the Commitment Period shall be
terminated as a result of such Suspension Event, and shall use its reasonable best efforts to have the
Limited Partners cast their vote on such ballot. If a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners do not
affirmatively vote to end the Suspension Period within one hundred eighty (180) days of the
commencement of the Suspension Period, the Commitment Period shall be automatically terminated and
the Suspension Period shall continue. If a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners do affirmatively
vote to terminate the Suspension Period within one hundred eighty (180) days of the commencement of
the Suspension Period, then the Suspension Period shall be automatically terminated and the Commitment
Period shall be reinstated. Notwithstanding the preceding or any other provision of this Agreement to the
contrary, a Suspension Period may be terminated, and the Commitment Period shall be reinstated, at any
time upon the affirmative vote of a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners.
ARTICLE 5
PARTNERSHIP ALLOCATIONS
5.1 Allocation of Profit or Loss. Except as otherwise provided in this Article 5:
(a) Profit (and solely to the extent necessary under paragraph 5.1(aXi), Loss) of the
Partnership for each Accounting Period shall be allocated as follows:
First, one hundred percent (100%) to the General Partner until the
cumulative Profit allocated to the General Partner pursuant to this paragraph 5.1(a)(i) in such Accounting
Period and all prior Accounting Periods (net of any Loss allocated to the General Partner in such
Accounting Period and all prior Accounting Periods pursuant to this paragraph 5.1(aXi)) is equal to the
aggregate Fee Adjustment Amounts through such time; provided, however, that such allocation shall be
made only (i) from Profit in such Accounting Period consisting solely of the excess of (A) gains from the
sale or disposition of Securities (including any Deemed Gain in connection with a distribution of
Securities) and qualified dividend income over (B) losses from the sale or disposition of Securities
(including any Deemed Loss in connection with a distribution of Securities), and (ii) in an amount no
greater than the cumulative net Profit of the Partnership from its inception through such time. If there has
been an allocation of Profit pursuant to this paragraph 5.1(a)(i) for any Accounting Period and the
Partnership has a Loss in any subsequent Accounting Period, then, notwithstanding the other provisions
of this paragraph 5.1, the General Partner shall be allocated an amount of such Loss up to the amount
necessary to ensure that the General Partner has been allocated an aggregate amount of Profit pursuant to
this paragraph 5.1(a)(i) no greater than the Partnership's cumulative net Profit through such time;
provided, that the amount of Loss to be allocated to the General Partner pursuant to the preceding
sentence shall be limited in the General Partner's good faith discretion to ensure that there is not an
allocation of a duplicative amount of Loss (by reason of allocations of Loss to the General Partner
pursuant to this paragraph 5.1(a)(i) and paragraph 5.1(b)(iii)(y)) which Loss is intended to reverse an
allocation of Profit pursuant to this paragraph 5.1(a)(i). For purposes of this paragraph 5.1(a)(i) and
11.
147765658 v44
paragraph 10.5(b), the calculation of the Partnership's "cumulative net Profit" and determination of
"Loss" shall include special allocations made by the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 5.1(c)-enE1-372. It
is intended that the General Partner's interest represented by Fee Adjustment Amounts constitutes a
"profits interest" within the meaning of Internal Revenue Service Revenue Procedure 93-27 (1993-27
C.B. 343) and the provisions of this Article 5 and Article 7 shall be implemented accordingly.

(11) Second, for so long as the "First Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is
not met, the remaining items of Profit for such Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Partners to
cause the cumulative allocations made pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) through 5.1(a)(iv) to have been
made as follows:
(I) First, one hundred percent (100%)  to the Capital Accounts of
the Partners, until the aggregate Profit allocated to the Partners pursuant to this subparagraph
5.1(a)(ii)(1) for all Accounting Periods equals the aggregate Loss allocated pursuant to subparagraph
5.1(b)(iii) for all Accounting Periods; and then
(21 Next:
if ) (4)-Eighty percent (80%) of such Profit to the Capital
Accounts of all of the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages; and
fil) (23-Twenty percent (20%) ef-suell-Pfern-te-the-Garitel
Accounts of all-of the Partn.rs to the extent that such accounts were previously allocated a Contingent
Less-that has not-.been-cesteced-by-pcevious--allocationc pursuant-to this paragraph. Such Profit hatI-be
elleeeteci-te-a-Pactnerls-cepitelaeeeunt-en-the-basis-ef--the-prepernen-thet-the-uncestered-Gentingent
Lesses-eetueinefl-in-sneh-Paptnefls-Gapnal-Aeeeunt-beafs-te-tlie-aggr-egate-aares.tefed-Gentingent-L-esses
eenteined-in-all-PactftesnCepital-Aeeeuntsr Any-balanee-ef--said—wmatnefeent—(20%)—ef--the
Partnership2s-Prefit-shatl-be-elleeateel-to the Capital Account of the General Partner.
(iii) Next, after and to the extent that the First Allocation Hurdle has been
met, and until the "Second Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is met, the remaining items of Profit for
such Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Partners to cause the cumulative allocations made
pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) through 5.1(a)(iv) to have been made as follows:
First, one hundred percent (100%) to the Capital Accounts of
the Partners, until the aggregate Profit allocated to Partners pursuant to this subparagraph
5.1(a)(iii)(1) for all Accounting Periods equals the aggregate Loss allocated pursuant to subparagraph
5.1(b)(ii) for all Accounting Periods; and then
al Next:
(1)-Seventy-five percent (75%) to the Capital Accounts
of all of the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages; and
(2)-Twenty-five percent (25%) to the Capital Aeeeunts
ef-ell-ef-the-Pertners-te-the-entent-thet-sueli-neeeunts-were-previeusly-alleented-a-Gentintent-hess-that-lies
net-been-resteced-by-rwevieus-alleeatiens-ftutsuent-te-this-peFagrefth,Such-Prefit-shell-be-alleested-te-a
PeEtnefls-Cepitalaseeunt-en-the-basts-ef-the-ffepectien-thet-the-unEestered-Gentingent-Lesses- eentainefl
in-sueli-PaFtner-ls-Gapitel-Meeunt-beaEs-te-the-aggeegete-unr-estefefl-Gentingent-L-esses-eentaine€1-in-atl
12.
147765658 v44
PannefsGapital-AeeauatsAny-balanee-af--salii-twenty-fwe-peceent-(2-5 2/03-ef--the-Partnecsli ern
shall-be-aneeated-te-the-Capital-Account of the General Partner.

(iv) Next, after and to the extent that the Second Allocation Hurdle is met,
the remaining items of Profit for such Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Partners to cause the
cumulative allocations made pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) through 5.1(a)(iv) to have been made as
follows:

(1) First, one hundred percent (100%) to the Capital Accounts of
the Partners, until the aggregate Profit allocated to Partners pursuant to this subparagraph
5.1(a)(iv)(1) for all Accounting Periods equals the aggregate Loss allocated pursuant to subparagraph
5.1(b)(i) for all Accounting Periods; and then

f) Next -
(13-Seventy percent (70%) to the Capital Accounts of all
of the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages; and

111) (2)-Thirty percent (30%) to the Capital Aeeetints-ef--all
of thc Partncrs to the extent that such accounts wrc prcvioualy allocated a Contingcnt Loss that has not
been-restored-bnceviens-allocations-pursuant-to-this-paragraphrSuelv-Profit-sltall-be-allocated-to-a
Partner's Capital  ACC-OHM on-the-basis-of-the-proportion-that-the-unrestored-centingent-Lesses-coniained
alleeated-te-the-Gapital-Account of the General Partner.

(b) After the application of paragraph 5.1(aXi), remaining Losses of the Partnership
for each Accounting Period shall be allocated as follows:

(1) First, to the extent of the Profits allocated pursuant to paragraph
5.1(a)(iv) with respect to prior Accounting Periods, items of Loss for such Accounting Period shall be
allocated in proportion to and in reverse order of such Profit allocations;

(ii) Next, to the extent of the Profits allocated pursuant to paragraph
5.1(a)(iii) with respect to prior Accounting Periods, any remaining items of Loss for such Accounting
Period shall be allocated in proportion to and in reverse order of such Profit allocations; and
(iii) Next, any remaining items of Loss for such Accounting Period shall be
allocated: (x) twenty percent (20%) to the Capital Account of the General Partner; and (y) eighty percent
(80%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages.

For all purposes under this Agreement, the "First Allocation Hurdle" shall be determined as of the time
that any item of Profit or Loss is to be allocated pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) and 5.1(a)(iii), and shall
be deemed to have been met to the extent that each Limited Partner has been allocated net Profits
pursuant to this Article 5 in an amount equal to two hundred percent (200%) of its respective Capital
Commitment (as defined below) as of such time of determination (Le., an amount sufficient to enable the
Partnership to distribute to such Limited Partner an amount equal to three hundred percent (300%) of
such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment).
13.
147765658 v44
For all purposes under this Agreement, the "Second Allocation Hurdle" shall be determined as of the
time that any item of Profit or Loss is to be allocated pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(iii) and 5.1(a)(iv), and
shall be deemed to have been met to the extent that each Limited Partner has been allocated net Profits
pursuant to this Article 5 in an amount equal to five hundred percent (500%) of its respective Capital
Commitment as of such time of determination (is, an amount sufficient to enable the Partnership to
distribute to such Limited Partner an amount equal to six hundred percent (600%) of such Limited
Partner's Capital Commitment).
(c) Solely in consideration of the fact that no Management Fee is chargeable in
respect of the General Partner's Partnership Percentage in the Partnership, items of Loss attributable to
the Management Fee for each Accounting Period shall not be allocated to the Capital Account of the
General Partner with respect to its Partnership Percentage.
5.2 Allocation of Ordinary Income and Ordinary Loss. Ordinary Income or Ordinary
Loss of the Partnership for each Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Capital Accounts of all of the
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages.

5.2-Realleeatien-ef-contingent-Lesses.--11 7-fer-any-Aeseunting-Peried r  efter-the-alleeatiens
prealed-in-pacagraph-5,1-hew-been-made r tite-beleftee-ef--the-Adjusted-C-apitel-Aeeeent-ef-the-Genefal
Partner-hes-been-reeleeed-te-less-than-1,002.8%-ef-the-setn-ef--the-balenees-ef-the-Adjusted-Cepind
Aeeennts-ef-all-Partnersr, en-amennt-ef--the-Less-fthescontingent-Lessn)-alleeated-te-the-Generel-Penner
for such Accounting Pcriod shall bc reallocated from th: Ccaerat-Partncr's Capital-Account-te-till-of-the
REHinefELCapitalAccounts-(40-prepectien-to-each-PartnerIS-ftSpiX4V4344114410FShip-P41fGef148S-S041#M41403
Gefferal-Partnerlsadjusted-Gapiiel-Aeseust-balanee-is-equa140-110-less-thea-thetteduel-ef--(4)-the-sum-ef
theadjusted-Capitel-lkeeeent-baktnees-ef-all-Pertneffi-rmakintie teisetient-ef-(74)-the-sani-ef-(*)
the-arneent-ef-theratenecal-Paftnerls-eapital-eentributiens-rnede-in-eash-as-ef-sueh-time-ftlus-Eyyaggregate
alleeetiens-ef-net-Prefit-te-the-General-Pertneentirsuent-te-paragrap -54(a)(i)-divieleel-by-(B-)-the-StlfWer
(*)-the-ameunt-ef-ell-ef-the-PactnersLearitel-eentEibutiens-made-in-eash-as-ef-sueh-tirme-pins-(y)-amegate
alleeatiens-ef-net-Prefit-te-the-Generel-Paftner-persuern-te-pacagraph-54(ak sueh-arneent r  the-Generai
PertnerlsTerger-Bnienee puteses-ef--this-pacegranh-5.3 7 the-General-Pectnerls-Adinsted-Cepita4
Account-shall -not be deemed to include any amountc attributable to a Limited Partner's interest-held -by
the-General-Partner,
53 5A-Special Allocations. To the extent the Partnership has taxable interest income or
expense with respect to any promissory note between any Partner and the Partnership as holder and maker
or maker and holder pursuant to Section 483, Sections 1271 through 1288, or Section 7872 of the Code,
such interest income or expense shall be specially allocated to the Partner to whom such promissory note
relates, and such Partner's Capital Account adjusted if appropriate.
5.4 &5-Regulatory Allocations.

(a) This Agreement is intended to comply with the safe harbor provisions set forth in
Treasury Regulation 1.704-1(b) and the allocations set forth in paragraph 5.44(b) (the "Regulatory
Allocations") are intended to comply with certain requirements of Treasury Regulation Section
1.704-1(b). In the event the Regulatory Allocations result in allocations being made that are inconsistent
with the manner in which the Partners intend to divide Partnership Profit and Loss as reflected in
paragraphs 5.1, 5.2= 5,3 and 5.4, the General Partner shall use its reasonable best efforts to adjust
subsequent allocations of any items of gain, loss, income, deduction, or expense such that the net amount
of the Regulatory Allocations and such subsequent special adjustments to each Partner is zero.
14.
147765658 v44

(b) The allocations provided in this Article 5 shall be subject to the following
exceptions:
I
Any loss or expense otherwise allocable to a Limited -Partner which
exceeds the positive balance in such Limited -Partner's Capital Account shall instead be allocated first to
all Partners who have positive balances in their Capital Accounts in proportion to their respective
Partnership Percentages, and when all Partners' Capital Accounts have been reduced to zero, then to the
General Partner; income shall first be allocated to reverse any loss or expense allocated under this
paragraph 5.34(b)(i), in reverse order of such loss or expense allocations, until all such prior loss or
expense allocations have been reversed.

(ii) In the event any Limited Partner unexpectedly receives any adjustments,
allocations, or distributions described in Treasury Regulation Section 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4) through
(dX6), which causes or increases a deficit balance in such Limited Partner's Capital Account, items of
Partnership income and gain shall be specially allocated to such Limited Partner in an amount and manner
sufficient to eliminate the deficit balance in its Capital Account created by such adjustments, allocations,
or distributions as quickly as possible.
(iii) For purposes of this paragraph 5.$4(b), the balance in a Partner's Capital
Account shall take into account the adjustments provided in Treasury Regulation Section
1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4) through (d)(6).

(c) If additional persons are admitted to the Partnership as Limited Partners
subsequent to the Initial Closing Date (or existing Limited Partners increase their Capital Commitments),
then organizational costs, fees (including the Management Fee set forth in paragraph 6.1) and expenses,
and individual items of Ordinary Income, Ordinary Loss, Profit and Loss of the Partnership that are
allocated to the Partners on or after the effective date of such admission (or increase), shall be allocated
first to such new Partners (or such existing Limited Partners that increased their Capital Commitments) to
the extent necessary to cause such persons to be treated with respect to such items as if they had been
Partners (or had such increased Capital Commitments) from the Initial Closing Date.
5.5 54 -Income Tax Allocations.

(a) Except as otherwise provided in this paragraph or as otherwise required by the
Code and the rules and Treasury Regulations promulgated thereunder, a Partner's distributive share of
Partnership income, gain, loss, deduction, or expense for income tax purposes shall be the same as is
entered in the Partner's Capital Account pursuant to this Agreement.

(b) In accordance with Code Section 704(c) and the Treasury Regulations
thereunder, income, gain, loss, deduction, and expense with respect to any asset contributed to the capital
of the Partnership shall, solely for tax purposes, be allocated among the Partners so as to take account of
any variation between the adjusted basis of such property to the Partnership for federal income tax
purposes and its initial Adjusted Asset Value.

(c) In the event the Adjusted Asset Value of any Partnership asset is adjusted
pursuant to the terms of this Agreement, subsequent allocations of income, gain, loss, deduction, and
expense with respect to such asset shall take account of any variation between the adjusted basis of such
asset for federal income tax purposes and its Adjusted Asset Value in the same manner as under Code

Section 704(c) and the Treasury Regulations thereunder.
15.
147765658 v44
ARTICLE 6
MANAGEMENT FEE; PARTNERSHIP EXPENSES
6.1 Management Fee.

(a) Commencing as of the Commencement Date, the Management Company shall be
compensated on a quarterly basis for services rendered to the Partnership by the payment in advance by
the Partnership in cash to the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate that makes the capital
contributions referenced in paragraph 4.3) on the first day of each fiscal quarter (or any applicable partial
fiscal quarter, including without limitation, a partial fiscal quarter commencing as of the Commencement
Date) of a management fee (the "Management Fee"). No Management Fee will be chargeable in respect
of the interest in the Partnership held by the General Partner or its designated Affiliate attributable to a
Partnership Percentage.

(b) The Management Fee for each fiscal quarter (prior to the adjustments described
in paragraph 6.1(c)) shall be an amount equal to the aggregate Capital Commitments made by the Limited
Partners as of the first day of each such quarter multiplied by 0.625% (the percentage applicable for any
period referred to herein as the "Management Fee Percentage"). Notwithstanding the foregoing, (i) the
Management Fee for each of the Partnership's first and last fiscal quarters shall be proportionately
reduced based upon the ratio that the number of days in each such period bears to ninety (90), (ii) an
additional Management Fee shall be payable upon the date of admission of any Limited Partner (or
increase in an existing Limited Partner's Capital Commitment) subsequent to the Initial Closing Date to
reflect the increased Capital Commitments calculated as if such Limited Partner had been admitted to the
Partnership (or had such increased Capital Commitment) as of the Initial Closing Date, and (iii) for each
fiscal year commencing on or after the fifth anniversary of the Commencement Date, the Management
Fee Percentage applicable in fiscal quarters during such fiscal year (prior to the adjustments described in
paragraph 6.1(c)) shall be equal to the greater of (A) the quarterly Management Fee Percentage applicable
in the prior fiscal year reduced by an amount equal to 0.025% or (B) 0.375%.

(c) The Management Fee otherwise payable by the Partnership to the Management
Company pursuant to paragraph 6.1(a) for a fiscal quarter shall be offset (in the following order of
application):
First, by one hundred percent (100%) of the amount of any cash or
non-cash compensation in the form of stock, options, warrants or other similar rights (net of the amount
paid for any such stock or securities) paid as directors, consulting, management service, advisory,
consultant, transaction, commitment, breakup or broken deal fees or similar fees to the General Partner,
the Management Company, or the respective managing members or managers of such entities, during the
immediately preceding quarter by or in connection with any company in which the Partnership holds an
investment or any company in which the Partnership actively sought to invest but did not, net of any
unreimbursed expenses of the General Partner or the Management Company, or the managing members
or managers of such entities, and as adjusted for any similar reductions with respect to any Parallel Fund
er-any s_Prior Fund;  Successor Fund or Opportunity Fund, on a pro rata basis based on the aggregate
capital commitments made to the applicable Parallel Funds-and, Prior Funds, Successor Funds or
Opportunity Fund, to prevent double counting; provided, however, any reduction pursuant to this
paragraph 6.1(cXi) in connection with any cash or non-cash compensation paid to any such parties by a
company in which an "Affiliated Party" (as defined below) or a member, employee or Affiliate thereof
holds an investment as of the Initial Closing Date shall be limited to the amount directly attributable to
16.
147765658 v44
the Partnership's actual investment in such company (taking into account of any proration due to the
investments of any Parallel Fund-er, Prior Fund, Successor Fund or Opportunity Fund); and
(ii) Next, by the amount of Cashless Contributions made with respect to the
immediately preceding quarter; provided, that to the extent that, on the eighth (81h) anniversary of the
Commencement Date there remains an uncalled portion of the Capital Commitment of the General
Partner or its designated Affiliate pursuant to paragraph 4.3 (such portion, the "Uncalled Amount"), then
the Management Fee otherwise payable by the Partnership on the next date when Management Fee shall
be paid shall be reduced by an amount equal to eighty percent (80%) of the Uncalled Amount (such
amount, the "Uncalled Cashless Contribution"). Each of (i) a Cashless Contribution other than a
Cashless Contribution made after the eighth (8'h) anniversary of the Commencement Date and (ii) the
Uncalled Cashless Contribution shall constitute a "Fee Adjustment Amount'.

In the event the offsets required by this paragraph 6.1(c) for a fiscal quarter exceed the Management Fee
payable for such fiscal quarter, the amount of such excess shall be offset against the Management Fee
otherwise payable in subsequent fiscal quarters until there has been a full reduction of Management Fees
with respect to amounts described in this paragraph 6.1(c). In the event that there are insufficient
Management Fees payable such that the foregoing offset amounts are unable to be completely exhausted
by the time of the Partnership's final distribution pursuant to paragraph 10.4, then the General Partner
shall, immediately prior to the Partnership's final distribution, return any such unexhausted offset amount
to the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages; provided, however, that any
Limited Partner may elect, by advance written notice to the General Partner, to refrain from being
allocated, and from having distributed to it, its portion of such returned offset amount that is attributable
to the application of paragraph 6.1(c)(i).

(d) Solely for purposes of determining the value of any stock, options, warrants or
other similar rights that may offset the Management Fee as described in paragraph 6.1(cXi), the following
rules shall apply:
All non-cash compensation in the form of stock received by any of the
General Partner, the Management Company, or the managing members or managers of such entities shall
be valued as of the time of receipt in accordance with the rules set forth in paragraph 12.1.

(ii) All non-cash compensation in the form of options, warrants or other
similar rights received by any of the parties shall be valued, in accordance with the rules set forth in
paragraph 12.1, upon the earliest to occur of (a) the distribution to the Partners of any Securities
underlying such options, warrants or other similar rights, (b) the conversion of such options, warrants or
other similar rights into cash, (c) the date on which the Securities underlying such options, warrants or
other similar rights become Marketable Securities (to the extent such options are exercisable at such time)
or (d) the date that is, in the General Partner's reasonable estimation, one year prior to the date of
dissolution of the Partnership. The value of options, warrants or other similar rights shall be, on a per
share basis, the difference, as of the valuation date, between the exercise price and the fair market value of
the securities on such date. No value shall be attributable to options, warrants or other similar rights if the
applicable securities are of a portfolio company that has been written off or written down to a nominal
amount as of the valuation date.
ft} On a cumulative basis, after the application of other reductions of the
Management Fee set forth in paragraph 6.1(c), the Management Fee shall be reduced by one hundred
percent (100%) of any net placement fees, broker fees or similar charges payable with respect to the sale
of interests to Limited Partners ("Placement Aaent Fees"). To the extent that the amount referred to in
the preceding sentence exceeds the Management Fee, such excess shall be carried forward and, if not
17.
147765658 v44
previously applied against such Management Fee, shall (notwithstanding anything herein to the contrary,
but subject to the Act) be paid by the General Partner to the Limited Partners upon liquidation of the
Partnership.
6.2 Expenses.

(a) From the Management Fee, the Management Company and the General Partner
shall bear all normal operating expenses incurred in connection with the management of the Partnership,
the General Partner and the Management Company, except for those expenses borne directly by the
Partnership as set forth in subparagraphs (b), (c) and (d) below and elsewhere herein. Such normal
operating expenses to be borne by the General Partner (or its designee) shall include, without limitation,
expenditures on account of salaries, wages, travel, entertainment, and other expenses of employees,
consultants and agents of the Partnership (other than consultants employed with respect to investments or
proposed investments), the General Partner or the Management Company, overhead and rentals payable
for space used by the General Partner (or its designee) or the Partnership, office expenses, expenses for
clerical and consulting services, and expenses incurred in evaluating investment opportunities and
managing investments of the Partnership.

(b) The Partnership shall bear all costs and expenses incurred by the General Partner
and/or the Management Company in connection with the following:
Expenses incurred in the holding, purchase, sale or exchange of
Securities (whether or not ultimately consummated), including, but not by way of limitation, private
placement fees, finder's fees, interest on borrowed money, real property or personal property taxes on
investments (including documentary, recording, stamp and transfer taxes), brokerage fees or
commissions, legal fees, expenses incurred in performing due diligence with respect to a purchase, sale or
exchange of Securities (whether or not ultimately consummated), consulting fees relating to investments
or proposed investments; and

(ii) Expenses incurred in connection with the investigation, prosecution or
defense of any claims by or against the Partnership, including claims by or against a governmental
authority, audit and accounting fees, taxes applicable to the Partnership on account of its operations, fees
incurred in connection with the maintenance of bank or custodian accounts, and all expenses incurred in
connection with the registration of the Partnership's Securities under applicable securities laws or
regulations, expenses incurred by the General Partner in serving as the tax matters partner (as described in
paragraph 11.6), the Management Fee, the cost of liability and other premiums for insurance protecting
the Partnership, the General Partner, its managers, and the Management Company and its managers and
employees from liability to third parties that relates to the Partnership and its activities and investments,
all out-of-pocket expenses of preparing and distributing reports to Partners, expenses associated with
Partnership communications with Partners, including preparation of annual or other reports to the Limited
Partners, out-of-pocket costs associated with Partnership meetings, all legal, audit and accounting fees
relating to the Partnership and its activities (including, without limitation, for third party bookkeeping
services), all costs and expenses arising out of the Partnership's indemnification obligation pursuant to
this Agreement, and all expenses that are not normal operating expenses.

(c) The Partnership shall bear all organizational and syndication costs, fees, and
expenses incurred by or on behalf of the General Partner in connection with the formation and
organization of the Partnership and the General Partner, including legal and accounting fees and expenses
incident thereto (but not including any private placement fees, finder's fees or other similar fees paid to
an independent third party in connection with the sale of interests in the Partnership); provided, however,
18.
147765658'14
that the amount of such costs, fees and expenses that are borne by the Partnership shall not exceed in the
aggregate five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000).

(d) The Partnership shall bear all liquidation costs, fees, and expenses incurred by
the General Partner (or its designee) in connection with the liquidation of the Partnership at the end of the
Partnership's term, specifically including but not limited to legal and accounting fees and expenses.

(e) Each of the Partnership and the General Partner agree to reimburse the other as
appropriate to give effect to the provisions of this paragraph 6.2 in the event that either such party pays an
obligation that is properly the responsibility of the other.
ARTICLE 7
WITHDRAWALS BY AND DISTRIBUTIONS TO THE PARTNERS
7.1 Interest. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement, no interest shall be paid to
any Partner on account of its interest in the capital of or on account of its investment in the Partnership.
7.2 Withdrawals by the Partners. No Partner may withdraw any amount from its Capital
Account unless such withdrawal is made pursuant to this Article 7, Article 10 or Article 13.
7.3 Partners' Obligation to Repay or Restore. Except as required by law or the terms of
this Agreement, no Limited Partner shall be obligated at any time to repay or restore to the Partnership all
or any part of any distribution made to it from the Partnership in accordance with the terms of this Article
7.
7.4 Mandatory Distributions.

(a) The General Partner may cause each Partner to be paid in cash, following the end
of each fiscal year during the term of the Partnership, an amount equal to the net taxable income allocated
to such Partner as a result of such Partner's ownership of an interest in the Partnership for the current
fiscal year multiplied by the highest blended federal, state and local marginal income tax rate then
applicable to an individual residing in any state of the United States applied by taking into account the
character of the taxable income in question long-term capital gains, ordinary income, etc.) (such
product, such Partner's "Annual Tax Amount'); provided, however, that the General Partner shall not be
required to make any such distribution if the total amount to be distributed to all Partners is less than one
million dollars ($1,000,000); provided, further, that for each fiscal year the amount distributed to any
Partner pursuant to this paragraph 7.4(a) shall not exceed the amount by which (A) such Partner's
cumulative aggregate Annual Tax Amounts for such fiscal year and all prior fiscal years exceeds (B) the
cumulative aggregate cash distributions made to such Partner pursuant to paragraphs 7.4(a) and 7.5
through the end of such fiscal year (and including all prior fiscal years). The provisions of this paragraph
7.4 shall apply equally to all Partners, without regard to their tax-exempt status under the Code.

(b) Subject to the maintenance of reasonable cash reserves (as determined and
established at the discretion of the General Partner), within ninety (90) days of the end of each fiscal year,
the General Partner shall distribute, in cash, to all Partners in proportion to their Partnership Percentages,
an amount equal to the amount of net Ordinary Income, if any, allocated to each Partner's Capital
Account during such fiscal year.
19.
147765658 v44
7.5 Discretionary Distributions and Rules Regarding Distributions.

(a) Except as otherwise provided in paragraph 7.5(g), the General Partner may make
a distribution of cash or Marketable Securities as follows.
First, to the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages such that each such Partner has received distributions pursuant to paragraph 7.4 and this
paragraph 7.5(a)(i) in an amount equal to (but not greater than) such Partner's aggregate capital
contributions (including all Fee Adjustment Amounts in the case of the General Partner), less the net
Ordinary Losses, if any, previously allocated to such Partner pursuant to paragraph 5.2 (all measured as of
the time the distribution is to be made);

(ii) Second, until the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited Partner
pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) is equal to three hundred percent (300%) of such
Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution, such distribution shall be made
to the Partners in the proportions necessary to cause cumulative distributions made pursuant to paragraph
7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) to have
been made: (1) eighty percent (80%) to all Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages and (2) twenty percent (20%) to the General Partner;
(iii) Third, to the extent that the cumulative amount distributed to each
Limited Partner pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) exceeds three hundred percent
(300%) of such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution, such
distribution shall be made one hundred percent (100%) to the General Partner until the General Partner
has received aggregate distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other
than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(aXi)) equal to twenty-five percent (25%) of the
cumulative distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than
distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i));

(iv) Fourth, until the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited Partner
pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) is equal to six hundred percent (600%) of such
Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution, such distribution shall be made
to the Partners in the proportions necessary to cause cumulative distributions made pursuant to paragraph
7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) to have
been made: (1) seventy-five percent (75%) to all Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages and (2) twenty-five percent (25%) to the General Partner;

(v) Fifth, to the extent that the cumulative amount distributed to each
Limited Partner pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) exceeds to six hundred percent
(600%) of such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution, such
distribution shall be made one hundred percent (100%) to the General Partner until the General Partner
has received aggregate distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other
than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) equal to thirty percent (30%) of the cumulative
distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made
pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)); and

(vi) Sixth, such distribution shall be made: (1) seventy percent (70%) to all
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages and (2) thirty percent (30%) to the
General Partner.
20.
147765658 v44

(b) Notwithstanding paragraph 7.5(a), the General Partner may at any time waive a
distribution of cash or Marketable Securities that would otherwise be made to it pursuant to paragraphs
7.5(a)(ii) through 7.5(a)(vi) and instead make such distribution one hundred percent (100%) to all
Partners in accordance with their respective Partnership Percentages; provided, however, that the
Partnership may make subsequent distributions of cash to the General Partner to the extent of any such
waived distribution at such times as the General Partner shall detennine.

(c) Whenever more than one type of Marketable Securities is being distributed in
kind in a single distribution or whenever more than one class of Marketable Securities of a portfolio
company (or a portion of a class of such Marketable Securities having a tax basis per share or unit
different from other portions of such class) are distributed in kind by the Partnership, each Partner shall
receive its ratable portion of each type, class or portion of such class of Marketable Securities distributed
in kind (except to the extent that a disproportionate distribution is necessary to avoid distributing
fractional shares).

(d) Marketable Securities distributed in kind pursuant to this paragraph 7.5, or
Securities distributed pursuant to paragraph 10.4, shall be subject to such conditions and restrictions as
the General Partner determines are legally required or appropriate. Whenever types or classes of
Securities are distributed in kind, each Partner shall receive its ratable portion of each type or class of
Securities distributed in kind.

(e) Immediately prior to any distribution in kind, the Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss
of any Marketable Securities distributed pursuant to this paragraph 7.5, or Securities distributed pursuant
to paragraph 10.4, shall be allocated to the Capital Accounts of all Partners as Profit or Loss pursuant to
Article 5.

(f) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, in the event the
Partnership distributes to the Partners any Marketable Securities or cash proceeds from the sale or other
disposition of Securities or other property of the Partnership within one hundred eighty (180) days of the
date the Partnership acquired the Securities of the applicable portfolio company, a portion of the
distributed capital that represents the Partnership's original cost basis of such Securities shall be added
back to the unfunded Capital Commitments of the Partners pro raw in accordance with the percentages in
which the capital contributed to purchase such Securities of the applicable portfolio company and each
Partner may be required to recontribute capital on the terms set forth in paragraph 4.2 to the Partnership
an amount equal to the product of: (x) such Partner's Partnership Percentage; and (y) the Partnership's
original cost basis of the Securities being distributed or which were sold or otherwise disposed of in
connection with such distribution.

(8) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this paragraph 7.5, no
distribution shall be made to the General Partner to the extent it would create or increase a deficit in its
Capital Account; provided, however, that the General Partner shall be entitled to receive a special
distribution in an amount equal to the amount of any distribution otherwise foregone pursuant to this
paragraph 7.5(g), to the extent that such special distribution would not create or increase a deficit in the
General Partner's Capital Account.

(h) All distributions of cash to be made by the Partnership, pursuant to paragraphs
7.4 or 7.5 or otherwise, shall be made in U.S. dollars.
21.
147765658 v44
7.6 Withholding Obligations.

(a) If and to the extent the Partnership is required by law (as determined in good
faith by the General Partner) to make payments ("Tar Payments") with respect to any Partner in amounts
required to discharge any legal obligation of the Partnership or the General Partner, including any
obligation pursuant to FATCA, to make payments to any governmental authority with respect to any
federal, state or local tax liability of such Partner arising as a result of such Partner's interest in the
Partnership, then the amount of any such Tax Payments shall be deemed to be a loan by the Partnership to
such Partner, which loan shall: (i) be secured by such Partner's interest in the Partnership; (ii) bear
interest at the Prime Rate (as defined in paragraph 14.15); and (iii) be payable upon demand; provided,
however, that the General Partner shall use commercially reasonable efforts to provide the Partners notice
of the amount of any anticipated Tax Payments in advance of the Partnership's payment thereof and will,
upon written request from any Partner, allow such requesting Partner to pay the Partnership an amount of
cash equal to the amount of such Tax Payments in lieu of treating any such Tax Payment as a loan. Each
Limited Partner will, as applicable, take such actions as are required to establish to the reasonable
satisfaction of the General Partner that the Limited Partner is (i) not subject to the withholding tax
obligations imposed by Section 1471 of the Code and (ii) not subject to the withholding tax obligations
imposed by Section 1472 of the Code. In addition, each Limited Partner will assist the Partnership and
the General Partner with any applicable information reporting or other obligation imposed on the
Partnership, the General Partner, or their respective Affiliates, pursuant to FATCA. For purposes of this
Agreement, "FATCA" shall mean the Foreign Account Tax Compliance provisions enacted as part of the
U.S. Hiring Incentives to Restore Employment Act and codified in Sections 1471 through 1474 of the
Code, all rules, regulations and other guidance issued thereunder, and all administrative and judicial
interpretations thereof.

(b) If and to the extent the General Partner determines that the Partnership is
required to make any Tax Payments with respect to any distribution to a Partner, (i) the General Partner
shall use commercially reasonable efforts to provide the Partner advance notice of the amount of such
anticipated Tax Payments and (ii) either (A) such Partner's proportionate share of such distribution shall
be reduced by the amount of such Tax Payments (provided, however, that such Partner's Capital Account
shall be adjusted pursuant to paragraph 14.5 for such Partner's full proportionate share of the
distribution), or (B) such Partner shall pay to the Partnership prior to such distribution an amount of cash
equal to such Tax Payments. In the event a portion of a distribution in kind is retained by the Partnership
pursuant to clause (A), such retained Securities may, in the discretion of the General Partner, either (i) be
distributed to the Partners in accordance with the terms of this Article 7 including this paragraph 7.6(b),
or (ii) be sold by the Partnership to generate the cash necessary to satisfy such Tax Payments. If the
Securities are sold, then for purposes of income tax allocations only under this Agreement, any gain or
loss on such sale or exchange shall be allocated to the Partner to whom the Tax Payments relate.

(c) If the Partnership is required to withhold taxes pursuant to this paragraph 7.6
with respect to any Limited Partner or if any tax is required to be withheld on amounts receivable by the
Partnership (including any tax required to be withheld by another party paying proceeds to the
Partnership) and is attributable to any Limited Partner, the General Partner shall upon request by such
Limited Partner use commercially reasonable efforts to provide any Limited Partner with such
information and assistance as is reasonably necessary for such Limited Partner to obtain an exemption
from or refund of such withheld amounts.
22.
147765658 44
ARTICLE 8
MANAGEMENT DUTIES AND RESTRICTIONS
8.1 Management. The General Partner shall have the sole and exclusive right to manage,
control, and conduct the affairs of the Partnership and to do any and all acts on behalf of the Partnership,
including exercise of rights to elect to adjust the tax basis of Partnership assets and to revoke such
elections and to make such other tax elections as the General Partner shall deem appropriate. The General
Partner is hereby authorized to enter, by itself or on behalf of the Partnership, into an agreement with
Valar Ventures LLC, a Delaware limited liability company or another entity beneficially owned by the
Managing Members and a Thiel Person (the "Management Company") for the provision of certain
management, administrative, operational and other services with the respect to the Partnership on terms to
be determined and agreed to by the General Partner, provided, however, that the General Partner shall
remain ultimately responsible for the overall management of the Partnership and for its duties and
responsibilities hereunder; provided, fi rther, that any such agreement that the Partnership enters with an
Affiliate of the General Partner shall be on terms that are no less favorable to the Partnership than the
terms that would be obtained from an independent third-party acting at arms' length.
8.2 No Control by the Limited Partners; No Withdrawal. No Limited Partner shall take
part in the control or management of the affairs of the Partnership nor shall any Limited Partner have any
authority to act for or on behalf of the Partnership or to vote on any matter relative to the Partnership and
its affairs except as is specifically permitted by this Agreement. Except as specifically set forth in this
Agreement, no Limited Partner shall withdraw or be required to withdraw from the Partnership.
8.3 Existing Funds; Follow -On Funds; Opportunity Fund;  Parallel Funds.

(a) Before the Successor Fund Eligible Date (as defined in paragraph 8.3(b) below),
each of the Managing Members, for so long as they are managing members of the General Partner, shall
devote substantially all of his business time to manage the affairs of the Management Company, the
General Partner, the Partnership, the "Parallel Funds" (as defined below), and-the "Prior Funds"  (as
defined below), the "Opportunity Fund"  (as defined below), those entities formed for the purpose of
managing the foregoing, °rand any portfolio company or potential portfolio company of any of the
foregoing or other entity invested in by the Partnership (which may include being seconded to a portfolio
company or potential portfolio company or other entity invested in by the Partnership -era a Prior Fund or
Opportunity Fund for such period of time as the General Partner determines, in good faith, may benefit
the Partnership -e such Prior Fund, or Opportunity Fund as applicable). From and after the Successor
Fund Eligible Date, each of the Managing Members, for so long as they are managing members of the
General Partner, shall only be required to devote such business time as they reasonably and in good faith
deem to be appropriate to manage the affairs of the Management Company, the General Partner, the
Partnership, the Parallel Funds and the other aforementioned entities.

Subject to the foregoing, the General Partner, the Management Company, the Managing Members, and
their respective affiliates, members and employees may:
Engage in or own an interest in any other business, partnership, limited
liability company, limited liability partnership, corporation or other entity or association (including,
without limitation, buying and selling securities for their own accounts and the accounts of Prior Funds
and other investment vehicles, but subject in any event to the provisions of paragraph 8.4);

(ii) Continue to act as managers, members, employees, or consultants to
Valar Global Fund I LP, Valar Global Principals Fund I LP, Valar Global Fund II LP, Valar Global
23.
147765658 v44
Principals Fund II LP, Valar Global Fund III LP, Valar Global Principals Fund III LP, Valar  Ventures LP,
VV Global LP, VV Global Principals LP, Valar Co-Invest I LP, Valar Co-Invest 2 LP and VV Xero
Holdings LLC and to other entities affiliated therewith (collectively, the "Prior Funds");
(iii) Form and operate one (1) or more successor venture capital investment
funds whose purpose is substantially the same as the Partnership's purpose (each, a "Successor Fund"),
subject to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b); and/or

(iv) Form and operate one or more Parallel Funds (as defined in paragraph
8.3(c)):; and/or
paragraph 8.3(b).
Form and operate an Opportunity Fund, subject to provisions of

(b) On or after the earlier of (i) such time as at least seventy-five percent (75%) of
the Partnership's Committed Capital has been invested, committed or reserved for investment in portfolio
companies, or applied, committed or reserved for Partnership working capital or expenses, or (ii) the end
of the Commitment Period (such earlier time, the "Successor Fund Eligible Date"), the Managing
Members shall only be required to devote such business time to the Partnership as they deem to be
appropriate (acting reasonably and in good faith) and may, at their sole and absolute discretion, form and
operate one or more Successor Funds. In addition, the General Partner, the Managing Members and/or
their Affiliates may, at any time, form, operate and devote such business time as is reasonably necessary
to the management of one or more "Special Purpose Investment Funds" described in paragraph 8.4(a). In
addition, the Limited Partners acknowledge and agree that the Management Company may form an
investment fund to participate (concurrently or otherwise) in later stage and other investment
opportunities whose "pre -money" valuation exceeds the valuation at which the Partnership typically
would invest, both in portfolio companies of the Partnership and otherwise (the "Opportunity Fund").
The general partner of an Opportunity Fund shall be an Affiliate of the General Partner or the
Management Company.
(c) Pursuant to paragraph 8.3(aXiv), the General Partner and the Managing Members
may form and serve as general partner (or in a similar management role) of (i) one or more entities
organized to accommodate the capital investment of the members of the General Partner and the
Management Company and their employees or consultants and their respective families, and of other
persons having strategic or other important relationships with the Partnership (each, an "Affiliates
Fund"), and (ii) one or more investment partnerships or similar entities to accommodate the tax,
regulatory or other special needs of investors who otherwise would invest as Limited Partners of the
Partnership (together with any Affiliates Fund, the "Parallel Funds"). Each Parallel Fund (other than an
Affiliates Fund) shall be governed by a limited partnership agreement (or other similar constitutive
document) whose terms are substantially the same as this Agreement (and, for the avoidance of doubt, an
Affiliates Fund may have different economic terms than the Partnership (including, without limitation, a
reduced or waived management fee and/or carried interest in profits payable to its general partner or
manager)). In the event that any Parallel Fund is formed, upon each purchase of Securities (other than
short-term obligations such as money market instruments) by the Partnership, each Parallel Fund will
simultaneously invest on the same terms as the Partnership pro rata in accordance with the remaining
available capital of each such fund, and reflecting the reserve policies for each such fund (e.g. because
Affiliate Funds may not charge management fees and thus may not reserve for them); provided, however,
that a Parallel Fund shall not be required to make any such investment in a Security if the General Partner
receives from the issuer thereof a written notice to the effect that the issuer will not permit such Parallel
Fund to invest on the same terms as the Partnership or such investment would be prohibited by the terms
of the governing agreement of such Parallel Fund. Each Parallel Fund shall also dispose of each such
24.
147765658 v44
Security at substantially the same time and on substantially the same terms as the Partnership; provided,
however, that the foregoing requirement shall not apply with respect to dispositions of Securities made in
connection with the liquidation of the Partnership or a Parallel Fund; provided, further, that a Parallel
Fund shall not be required to make any such divestment of a Security if the General Partner receives from
the issuer thereof a written notice to the effect that the issuer will not permit such Parallel Fund to dispose
of such Security on the same terms as the Partnership or such divestment would be prohibited by the
terms of the governing agreement of such Parallel Fund. Notwithstanding any other provision of this
Agreement to the contrary, except as provided in paragraph 10.3(b), in no event shall the General Partner
cause or permit the Partnership, or any Parallel Fund to make or dispose of an investment, or make a
distribution of cash or property to the Partners, other than on a pan passu basis with all other such funds
based on their respective amounts of committed capital from equityholders (determined as of all capital
commitments were made at the same time). Each of the Limited Partners hereby consents and agrees to
the foregoing activities and investments and further consents and agrees that neither the Partnership nor
any of its Partners shall have any rights in or to such activities or investments, or any profits derived
therefrom.
8.4 Investment Opportunities and Conflicts of Interest.

(a) Each opportunity to invest at least one hundred fifty thousand dollars ($150,000)
into a company that is presented to the Managing Members, for so long as they are managing members of
the General Partner, and that otherwise meets the investment objectives of the Partnership (e.g., the
potential investment is sufficiently large, the potential investment is not expected to require an inordinate
portion of the Partnership's capital, the company is at an appropriate stage of development, the
Partnership has sufficient capital available at the time the investment is to be made, etc.), shall be offered
to the Partnership and each Parallel Fund in proportion to their relative available capital (measured as of
the time of such presentation); provided, however, that (i) the preceding restriction shall only apply from
and after the Commencement Date until the earlier of the end of the Commitment Period or the time at
which a Successor Fund may be formed pursuant to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b) and (ii) any
such opportunities may be allocated in whole to the Prior Funds or Opportunity Fund, or such
opportunities may be allocated partially to the Partnership and the Parallel Funds and partially to the Prior
Funds and Opportunity Fund, until the Prior Funds and Opportunity Fund have been fully invested and
reserved for follow-on investments and expenses, as determined by the General Partner in its sole and
absolute discretion. In furtherance of the foregoing, from and after the Commencement Date until the
earlier of the end of the Commitment Period or the time at which a Successor Fund may be formed
pursuant to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b), each of the General Partner and the Management
Company shall require that the Managing Members and managers of such entities shall promptly present
to the General Partner each investment opportunity that is presented to them and that is consistent with
the investment objectives of the Partnership as described in this paragraph 8.4(a).
Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this paragraph 8.4(a) or any other provision of this
Agreement to the contrary, the restrictions described in this paragraph 8.4(a) shall not apply to the
participation of any Affiliated Party in any investment opportunity with respect to which: (i) the
applicable Affiliated Party's participation has been approved by the Advisory Committee; (ii) the
applicable Affiliated Party or an Affiliate thereof (in each case, other than any investment fund managed
thereby) has initially invested prior to the Initial Closing Date or pursuant to the other provisions of this
paragraph 8.4(a) and/or paragraph 8.4(c); (iii) the General Partner has determined, in good faith, does not
meet the investment objectives of the Partnership; or (iv) a Special Purpose Investment Fund has been
formed. For the avoidance of doubt, the following shall automatically be deemed not to be investment
opportunities of the Partnership (and may be invested in by the General Partner, any Affiliated Party, or
any Affiliate or employee thereof or any investment fund managed thereby notwithstanding any provision
of this Agreement to the contrary): (i) any investment opportunity in a company (including, without
25.
147765658 v44
limitation, in the preferred stock of such company) that the General Partner has considered and has
rejected as being unsuitable for the Partnership in accordance with the rules and procedures by which the
General Partner makes investment decisions (Le., because the number of Managing Members required to
approve the opportunity have considered the opportunity and rejected it as being unsuitable for the
Partnership), so long as the Managing Members who rejected the opportunity and their respective
Affiliates do not then participate in such opportunity; (ii) any investment opportunity with respect to
which the Advisory Committee is asked to approve the Partnership's participation, but which the
Advisory Committee does not so approve; (iii) any investment opportunity in a company that has a
"pre-money valuation" greater than fivetwo hundred and fifty  million dollars (U0250,000,000), as
determined by the Management Company in its sole discretion, as of the date of the proposed investment
(other than— llow on invoelmenic in companiet in which the Partnership already holt an eticting
interest as of the-date-of-such-proposed-follow on-investment} and; (iv) any investment opportunity to be
held by a Special Purpose Investment Fund; (v) any investment opportunity in a portfolio company of a
Prior Fund, Successor Fund or Opportunity Fund; and (vi) any investment opportunity offered to a Prior
Fund, Successor Fund or Opportunity Fund.

A "Special Purpose Investment Fund' means an investment fund created by the General Partner or any
Affiliated Party to invest in a specified investment opportunity, which meets the Partnership's investment
objectives. A Special Purpose Investment Fund must meet the following criteria: (a) each Partner is
provided the first opportunity (on at least seven (7) days advance notice) to invest in such special purpose
investment fund on a pro rata basis determined by reference to the total of (x) the Partners' respective
Capital Commitments and (y) the respective capital commitments that the constituent partners in any
Parallel Funds have made to such Parallel Funds, and (b) such special purpose investment fund charges a
carried interest and/or management fee that are no higher than those charged to the Partnership. No
Special Purpose Investment Fund with aggregate capital commitments that exceed 30% of the amount of
the aggregate combined Capital Commitments to the Partnership and the capital commitments of the
Parallel Funds (the "Combined Capital Commitments")  to the Partnership shall be formed or organized
without the Advisory Committee's prior approval.

(b) The term "Affiliated Party", as used herein, means any Managing Member, the
General Partner, the Management Company, or any member, employee or Affiliate thereof; provided,
however, that for all purposes under this Agreement, no Thiel Person shall be deemed to be an Affiliated
Party. Notwithstanding paragraph 8.4(a), each Limited Partner hereby acknowledges and agrees that the
General Partner may offer to other private investors, groups, partnerships or corporations (including,
without limitation, any Limited Partner, and the Affiliates, members and employees of the foregoing
parties and any Prior Funds—era Successor Funds or Opportunity Fund) the right to participate in
investment opportunities of the Partnership or opportunities which may meet the investment objectives of
the Partnership (as determined by the General Partner in good faith) whenever the General Partner, in its
sole and absolute discretion, so determines; provided, however, that (4)-an Affiliated Party may only take
or participate in investment opportunities meeting the investment objectives of the Partnership to the
extent so provided in paragraphs 8.4(a) and 8.4(c)-and-00-stieli-inyestinent-eppertunityr  if -meeting-the
efferecl-te-the-Partnership-befere-it-is-effered-te-any-ether-pany.

(c) Until the earlier of the time that the Commitment Period ends or a Successor
Fund may be formed pursuant to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b), each Affiliated Party or Affiliate
thereof shall not be permitted to receive and keep any preferred stock, common stock, options or other
similar instruments to purchase the same of any Partnership portfolio company without the consent of the
Advisory Committee; provided, however, that the foregoing restriction shall not apply to an investment
held through a Successor Fund or Prior Fund; provided, further, that the Affiliated Parties may,
26.
147765658 v44
collectively, invest up to one hundred fifty thousand dollars ($150,000) into the Securities of  any
Partnership portfolio company that are not Marketable Securities.

(d) Each Limited Partner hereby agrees that, the Partnership may invest in any
company in which a Successor Fund-et, Prior Fund or Opportunity Fund (or any other investment fund
managed by any of the General Partner, the Affiliated Parties or their Affiliates) holds an interest,
whenever the General Partner, in its discretion, so determines that an investment in such company would
be appropriate for the Partnership; provided, however, that witheut—the—eefisent—ef—tke—MMsecy
Gemelitteer the-Partnerskip-may-ilet-make-an-investryfrent-efillefe-thea-five-millieri-delleEs-Essaheogyie
any-sueh-eempany,In-additienr  without the consent of the Advisory Committee, the Partnership shall not
invest in any company in which the Managing Members, the General Partner, the Management Company
or any of their Affiliates hold a direct interest (i.e., an interest not held through a Successor Fund, Prior
Fund, Opportunity Fund or other investment fund managed by any of the General Partner, the Affiliated
Parties or their Affiliates).

(e) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, the Partnership may not
purchase Securities from or sell Securities to the General Partner, any Parallel Fund or related entity, any
Affiliated Party, any Thiel Person or an Affiliate thereof or any investment fund managed thereby;
provided, however, that each Limited Partner hereby agrees that, following the final admission of Limited
Partners pursuant to paragraph 3.2(b) the Partnership may purchase Securities from or sell Securities to
one or more Parallel Funds at cost for the purpose of allocating then-existing Securities between such
entities in proportion to their respective available capital.
I
Each Limited Partner hereby agrees that: (i) an Affiliated Party, an Affiliate
thereof or any member or employee of any of the foregoing, or any investment fund managed thereby
may invest personally in Securities of any portfolio company where the Securities of such portfolio
company are, at the time of such investment, Marketable Securities; provided that, the aggregate amount
of any such investments in the same portfolio company may not exceed 2% of the aggregate cost basis of
the Partnership's and Parallel Funds' investment(s) in such portfolio company; and (ii) any Successor
Fund-era Prior Fund or Opportunity Fund (or other fund described in paragraph 8.3(b) to the extent the
applicable investment does not meet the investment objectives of the Partnership) may invest in a
portfolio company of the Partnership.

(g) The General Partner shall use its reasonable best efforts to operate the
Partnership in a manner that will not cause any Partner subject to Section 511 of the Code to recognize
unrelated business taxable income under Section 512 of the Code or unrelated debt-financed income
under Section 514 of the Code ("UBTf'); provided, however, that the Partnership may, subject to
paragraph 8.4(n), borrow money pending the due date of a capital call so long as such borrowing would
be repaid promptly following the delivery of capital due in connection with such capital call and would
not create a material likelihood that any Limited Partner subject to Section 511 of the Code would incur
UBTI.
For so long as "equity participation" in the Partnership by "benefit plan
investors" is "significant" (as such terms are defined in the DOL Regulations), (i) the General Partner
shall use its reasonable best efforts to operate the Partnership such that it qualifies as a "venture capital
operating company" under the DOL Regulations, (ii) at least 30 days prior to the end of the Partnership's
"annual valuation period" (as such term is defined in the DOL Regulations), the General Partner shall
deliver to each Limited Partner a certificate, prepared in consultation with counsel to the Partnership,
which confirms that the Partnership qualifies as a venture capital operating company and will continue to
qualify as a venture capital operating company immediately following the expiration of the annual
valuation period and (iii) the General Partner shall notify each Limited Partner as promptly as practicable
27.
147765658 v44
following any determination by the General Partner that there is a material likelihood that the Partnership
has ceased to qualify as a venture capital operating company.
The General Partner shall use its commercially reasonable efforts to: (w) avoid
causing any Limited Partner, solely as a result of such Limited Partner's status as a limited partner in the
Partnership, to be required to file income tax returns other than any return, certification or statement
necessary to obtain a refund of or reduction in tax in any jurisdiction outside of the United States in
connection with the Partnership's investment in any portfolio company organized or with its principal
place of business or primary operations in such jurisdiction; (x) operate the Partnership in a manner that
will not cause it to be engaged in a "trade or business within the United States" within the meaning of

Section 864(b) of the Code; (y) avoid the Partnership realizing income that is or is treated as being
"effectively connected" with the conduct of a trade or business in the United States for United States
federal income tax purposes; and (z) prevent the Partnership from acquiring any interest in real property
located in the United States for purposes of Section 897 of the Code or in any company that is at the time
of such investment a "United States real property holding corporation" within the meaning of Section
897(c) of the Code.

After the General Partner has used commercially reasonable efforts to avoid the Partnership realizing
income that is or is treated as being "effectively connected" with the conduct of a trade or business in the
United States, if the General Partner has actual knowledge that a particular transaction will generate
income "effectively connected" with a trade or business in the United States (within the meaning of the
Code), or similar income in another country, the General Partner shall use reasonable best efforts to
provide each Limited Partner with such information that is reasonably available to the General Partner
and which such Limited Partner reasonably requests in order to file any federal, state or local tax return in
the United States or such other country in which such income is generated.

For transactions causing any Limited Partner, solely as a result of such Limited Partner's status as a
limited partner in the Partnership, to be required to file income tax returns other than any return,
certification or statement necessary to obtain a refund of or reduction in tax in any jurisdiction outside of
the United States in connection with the Partnership's investment in any portfolio company organized or
with its principal place of business or primary operations in such jurisdiction, the General Partner shall
use commercially reasonable efforts to provide such Limited Partner with such information that is
reasonably available to the General Partner and which such Limited Partner reasonably requests in order
to file income tax return in such jurisdiction.

(j) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, the-Pannership-niefrnot
invest more than five percent (5%) of the Pet4ftefship1/2 —Gemmiaed—C—apite4Combined Capital
Commitments (determined on the basis of acquisition cost at the time of investment) may be invested by
the Partnership and the Parallel Funds in a "blind pool" investment fund that is managed and controlled
by an unaffiliated third party and that pays its manager performance based compensation.
I
I

(k) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, no more than twenty-five
percent (25%) of the Partneishipls-agvegateCombined Capital Commitments (determined on the basis of
acquisition cost at the time of investment) may be invested by the Partnership and the Parallel Funds in
the Securities of, or loaned to, any one (I) portfolio company (including, for this purpose, the Affiliates of
such portfolio company).
Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, not more than fifteen
percent (15%) of the PettnershiplsCombined Capital Commitments (determined on the basis of
acquisition cost at the time of investment) may be invested by the Partnership and the Parallel Funds in
28.
147765658 v44
Securities that are publicly traded, excluding Securities issued in a private offering by an issuer who then
also has outstanding publicly-traded Securities.
(m) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee and subject to paragraph
8.4(g), the General Partner may not cause the Partnership to incur debt, or guaranty indebtedness of the
Partnership's portfolio companies (and including, for this purpose, their respective Affiliates), in an
aggregate amount exceeding the lesser of (A) ten percent (10%) of the Partnership's Capital
Commitments (determined on the basis of acquisition cost at the time of investment) and (B) the amount
of aggregate Capital Commitments of the Partners that have not been contributed to the Partnership as of
the date of such debt or guaranty indebtedness; provided, however, that amounts borrowed by the
Partnership pending the due date of a capital call, which are due to be, and are, fully repaid promptly
following the delivery of capital from the Partners which was due in connection with such capital call
shall not be treated as indebtedness of the Partnership for purposes of the limitation in this paragraph
8.4(m).
The cumulative aggregate cost basis of portfolio company investments made by
the Partnership may not exceed one hundred twenty percent (120%) of the aggregate Capital
Commitments of the Partners.
ARTICLE 9
INVESTMENT REPRESENTATION AND TRANSFER
OF PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS
9.1 Investment Representation of the Limited Partners. This Agreement is made with
each of the Limited Partners in reliance upon each Limited Partner's representation to the Partnership,
which by executing this Agreement each Limited Partner hereby confirms, that its interest in the
Partnership is to be acquired for investment, and not with a view to the sale or distribution of any part
thereof, and that it has no present intention of selling, granting participation in, or otherwise distributing
the same, and each Limited Partner understands that its interest in the Partnership has not been registered
under the Securities Act and that any transfer or other disposition of the interest may not be made without
registration under the Securities Act or pursuant to an applicable exemption therefrom. Each Limited
Partner further represents that it does not have any contract, undertaking, agreement, or arrangement with
any person to sell, transfer, or grant participations to such person, or to any third person, with respect to
its interest in the Partnership.

9.2 Qualifications of the Limited Partners. Each Limited Partner represents that it is an
"accredited investor" within the meaning of that term as defined in Regulation D promulgated under the
Securities Act.

9.3 Transfer by General Partner. The General Partner shall not sell, assign, mortgage,
pledge or otherwise dispose of its interest in the Partnership or in its capital assets or property without the
prior written consent of Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners. Admissions of new members of
the General Partner or the transfer of interests in the General Partner by its members shall not be deemed
to be a sale or other disposition of the General Partner's interest in the Partnership for purposes of this
paragraph 9.3; provided, however, that without the prior consent of a Majority in Interest of the Limited
Partners, new members may not be admitted to the General Partner, and interests in the General Partner
may not be transferred, to the extent that the effect of such admissions and transfers would result in fifty
percent (50%) or more of the interests in the General Partner being owned by persons who are not
Managing Members. Notwithstanding the foregoing, in no event shall the General Partner make any
29.
147765658 v44
transfer of an interest in the Partnership prohibited by the events described in paragraphs 9.5(a) through
9.5(h).

9.4 Transfer by Limited Partner. No Limited Partner shall sell, assign, pledge, mortgage,
or otherwise dispose of or transfer its interest in the Partnership, directly or indirectly, without the prior
written consent of the General Partner, which consent may be granted or denied in the sole discretion of
the General Partner (which consent shall not be required in the event of a transfer pursuant to the
following sentence of this paragraph 9.4). Notwithstanding the foregoing, after delivery of the opinion of
counsel hereinafter required by this Article 9 (provided, however, that the General Partner may, in its sole
discretion, waive the requirement of an opinion of counsel), a Limited Partner may sell, assign, pledge,
mortgage, or otherwise dispose of or transfer its interest in the Partnership, directly or indirectly, without
such consent (a) to any entity directly or indirectly holding eighty percent (80%) or more of the
ownership interests of the Limited Partner (including profits or other economic interests) or any entity of
which eighty percent (80%) or more of the beneficial ownership (including profits or other economic
interests) are held directly or indirectly by such entity, including any entity of which the Limited Partner
holds, directly or indirectly, eighty percent (80%) or more of the beneficial ownership (including profits
or other economic interests), (b) pursuant to a merger, plan of reorganization, sale or pledge of, or other
general encumbrance on all or substantially all of the Limited Partner's assets, (c) as may be required by
any law or regulation, (d) by testamentary disposition or intestate succession, (e) to a trust, profit sharing
plan or other entity controlled by, or for the benefit of, such Limited Partner or one or more of its family
members or (f) during the six (6) month period immediately following its admission as a Limited Partner,
to an Affiliate entity that is also a Limited Partner where the sole purpose of such transfer is to adjust the
relative holdings of such Affiliate and the original Limited Partner. A change in any trustee or fiduciary
of the Limited Partner shall not be considered to be a transfer, sale, assignment, mortgage, pledge or other
disposition under this paragraph 9.4, provided written notice of such change is given to the General
Partner within a reasonable period of time after the effective date thereof.

9.5 Requirements for Transfer. No transfer or other disposition of the interest of the
Limited Partner shall be permitted until the General Partner shall have received an opinion of counsel
satisfactory to it (or waived such opinion requirement) that the effect of such transfer or disposition would
not:

(a) result in the Partnership's assets, or any portion thereof, being considered, in the
opinion of counsel for the Partnership, as "plan assets" within the meaning of the DOL Regulations, or
result in a non-exempt prohibited transaction under Section 4975 of the Code;

(b) result in a violation of the Securities Act or any comparable state law;
(c) require the Partnership to register as an investment company under the
Investment Company Act of 1940, as amended;

(d) require the Partnership, the General Partner, or any member of the General
Partner to register as an investment adviser under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, as amended;

(e) result in a termination of the Partnership's status as a partnership for tax
purposes;
result in a violation of any law, rule, or regulation by the Limited Partner, the
Partnership, the General Partner, or any member of the General Partner;
30.
147765658 v44

(g) cause the Partnership to be deemed to be a "publicly traded partnership" as such
term is defined in Section 7704(b) of the Code; or
(h) result in a violation of this Agreement.

Such legal opinion shall be provided to the General Partner by the transferring Limited Partner or the
proposed transferee. Any costs associated with such opinion shall be borne by the transferring Limited
Partner or the proposed transferee. Upon request, the General Partner will use its good faith diligent
efforts to provide any information possessed by the Partnership and reasonably requested by a
transferring Limited Partner to enable it to render the foregoing opinion. Notwithstanding any provision
of this Article 9 to the contrary, the General Partner may, in its sole discretion, waive the requirement of
an opinion of counsel provided for in this paragraph 9.5. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary
herein, in no event shall the General Partner consent to any transfer of an interest in the Partnership, or
waive the requirement of an opinion of counsel with respect to any transfer for which the consent of the
General Partner is not required, if such transfer would, in the reasonable determination of the General
Partner, result in any of the events described in paragraphs 9.5(a) through 9.5(h). Any transfer of an
interest in the Partnership in violation of the requirements of paragraph 9.4 or this paragraph 9.5 shall be
null and void ab initio.

9.6 Substitution as a Limited Partner. A transferee of a Limited Partner's interest pursuant
to this Article 9 shall become a substituted Limited Partner only with the consent of the General Partner
(which consent shall not be required in the event of a transfer pursuant to paragraph 9.4(f)) and only if
such transferee (a) elects to become a substituted Limited Partner and (b) executes, acknowledges and
delivers to the Partnership such other instruments as the General Partner may deem necessary or advisable
to effect the admission of such transferee as a substituted Limited Partner, including, without limitation,
the written acceptance and adoption by such transferee of the provisions of this Agreement. No
assignment by a Limited Partner of its interest in the Partnership shall release the assignor from its
liabilities to the Partnership, including but not limited to those liabilities enumerated in paragraph 4.2;
provided, however if the assignee becomes a Limited Partner as provided in this paragraph 9.6, the
assignor shall thereupon so be released (in the case of a partial assignment, to the extent of such
assignment).

9.7 Expenses of Transfer. Any costs or expenses (including but not limited to reasonable
attorneys' fees) incurred by the Partnership in connection with the transfer of a Partnership interest
hereunder (including any costs associated with any opinion rendered pursuant to paragraph 9.5 above)
shall be borne jointly and severally by the transferring Limited Partner and the proposed transferee.
ARTICLE 10
DISSOLUTION AND LIQUIDATION OF THE PARTNERSHIP
10.1 Extension of Partnership Term. Upon the Termination Date, or such subsequent dates
to which the Partnership term has previously been extended pursuant to this paragraph 10.1, the General
Partner in its sole discretion may extend the Partnership term for up to two (2) additional one (1) year
periods and, thereafter and with the consent of a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners, for
additional one (I) year periods thereafter. During any such one (I) year extension periods, the General
Partner shall use its reasonable efforts to convert the Partnership's Nonmarketable Securities into
Marketable Securities or cash, and all Securities that become Marketable Securities during such period or
periods shall be promptly distributed by the Partnership. The General Partner shall not purchase the
Securities of any new issuer in which the Partnership does not already hold an interest during such period;
provided, however, that the General Partner may (a) purchase additional Securities of a portfolio company
31.
147765658 v44
if it deems such a purchase to be in the best interests of the Partnership, and (b) exchange the Securities of
a portfolio company for other Securities. The Management Fee for each fiscal quarter during an
extension period (i) shall be an amount equal to the product of (A) the lower of (I) the cost basis of the
portfolio company Securities held by the Partnership as of the first day of such fiscal quarter and (II) the
fair market value of such Securities multiplied by (B) the Management Fee Percentage in effect as of the
first day of such fiscal quarter (as determined under Article 6), and (ii) shall otherwise be governed by the
provisions set forth in Article 6.
10.2 Early Termination of the Partnership.

(a) The Partnership shall dissolve, and the affairs of the Partnership shall be wound
up prior to the Termination Date (or such subsequent dates to which the Partnership term has previously
been extended pursuant to paragraph 10.1):
ninety (90) days after the withdrawal, bankruptcy, or dissolution of the
General Partner, unless a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners elect to continue the Partnership
within such ninety (90) day period;

(ii) upon the election of Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners
within sixty days (60) days of the delivery of the notice of Trigger Event; or
(iii) at any time upon the election of Eighty Percent (80%) in Interest of the
Limited Partners.

(b) In the event that the Partnership is dissolved pursuant to the provisions of this
paragraph 10.2, a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners shall elect one or more liquidators to
manage the liquidation of the Partnership in the manner described in paragraphs 10.3, 10.4 and 10.5.
10.3 Winding Up Procedures.

(a) Promptly upon dissolution of the Partnership (unless the Partnership is continued
in accordance with this Agreement or the provisions of the Act), the affairs of the Partnership shall be
wound up and the Partnership liquidated. The closing Capital Accounts of all the Partners shall be
computed as of the date of dissolution as if the date of dissolution were the last day of an Accounting
Period in accordance with Article 5, and then adjusted in the following manner:

(I) All assets and liabilities of the Partnership shall be valued as of the date
of dissolution.
(ii) The Partnership's assets as of the date of dissolution shall be deemed to
have been sold at their fair market values and the resulting Profit or Loss shall be allocated to the
Partners' Capital Accounts in accordance with the provisions of Article 5.

(b) Distributions during the winding up period may be made in cash or in kind or
partly in cash and partly in kind; provided, however, that the General Partner or the liquidator, as the case
may be, shall notify the Limited Partners at least ten (10) business days prior to making a distribution in
kind pursuant to this paragraph 10.3(b). The General Partner or the liquidator shall use its best judgment
as to the most advantageous time for the Partnership to sell Securities or to make distributions in kind.
All cash and each Security distributed in kind after the date of dissolution of the Partnership shall be
distributed ratably in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 4.2(d), if applicable, but otherwise in
accordance with Article 7, unless such distribution would result in a violation of a law or regulation
32.
147765658 v44
applicable to a Limited Partner, in which event, upon receipt by the General Partner of notice to such
effect, such Limited Partner may designate a different entity to receive the distribution, or designate,
subject to the approval of the General Partner (which may be withheld in the General Partner's sole
discretion), an alternative distribution procedure (provided, however, that such alternative distribution
procedure does not prejudice any of the other Partners). Each Security so distributed shall be subject to
reasonable conditions and restrictions necessary or advisable, as determined in the reasonable discretion
of the General Partner or the liquidator, in order to preserve the value of such Security or for legal
reasons.

10.4 Payments in Liquidation. The assets of the Partnership shall be distributed in final
liquidation of the Partnership in the following order:

(a) to the creditors of the Partnership, including those Partners who are creditors of
the Partnership, in the order of priority established by law, either by payment or by establishment of
reserves; and

(b) the balance, if any, to the General Partner and the Limited Partners as if such
distributions were made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(b) and paragraph 7.5(a), as applicable; provided,
however, that the General Partner shall be obligated to contribute to the Partnership an amount in cash, or
Securities (previously distributed in kind from the Partnership) with a fair market value equal to the
amounts the General Partner is obligated to pay back under paragraphs 10.5(a) and 10.5(b).
10.5 Return of Excess Distributions.
(a) Notwithstanding paragraphs 7.3 and 10.4, upon liquidation of the Partnership
pursuant to this Article 10, the General Partner shall be required to pay back to the Partnership the
amount by which the Carried Interest Distributions (as defined below) exceeds (i) in the event that the
First Allocation Hurdle has not been met, 20% of the aggregate distributions made to the Partners
pursuant to paragraphs 7.5(aXii)-(vi), (ii) in the event that the First Allocation Hurdle has been met but
the Second Allocation Hurdle has not been met, 25% of the aggregate distributions made to the Partners
pursuant to paragraphs 7.5(a)(ii)-(vi), or (iii) in the event that the Second Allocation Hurdle has been
met, 30% of the aggregate distributions made to the Partners pursuant to paragraphs 7.5(a)(ii)-(vi).
Notwithstanding the foregoing, the General Partner's payment obligation pursuant to this paragraph
10.5(a) shall not exceed the After -Tax Distribution Amount (as defined below). For purposes of this
paragraph 10.5: (i) the "Carried Interest Distributions" shall equal all distributions to the General Partner
other than distributions made to the General Partner in respect of its Partnership Percentage (excluding
amounts returned to the Partnership by the General Partner pursuant to paragraphs 4.2(d)(ii) prior to final
liquidation of the Partnership); and (ii) the "After -Tax Distribution Amount" shall be equal to the Carried
Interest Distributions, less the gross tax liabilities that the General Partner would have incurred on all
allocations of taxable income (net of losses) made with respect to the General Partner's interest in the
Company (other than the portion of its interest attributable to its Partnership Percentage and excluding
allocations made pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a)(i)) if: (x) at all times the General Partner were subject to
the highest blended federal, state and local marginal income tax rate then applicable to an individual
residing in any state in the United States, applied by taking into account the character of the taxable
income in question (i.e., long-term capital gains, ordinary income, etc.) (such tax rat; the "Applicable
Tax Rate"); and (y) all such allocations resulted from fully taxable transactions, plus any tax benefit
actually received by the General Partner in the year in which the General Partner is required to make a
payment pursuant to this paragraph 10.5(a), as reasonably determined by the General Partner, which such
tax benefit is attributable solely to the making of such payment and which benefit shall be determined
after first taking all other items of income, gain, loss, deduction or credit of the General Partner (or its
direct or indirect owners) into account. In the event that the assets of the General Partner are insufficient
33.
147765658 v44
to satisfy the obligation described in this paragraph 10.5(a), each Managing Member and managing
member of the General Partner shall be severally liable for and shall personally guaranty his or her pro
rata share of the General Partner's remaining obligation to the Partnership under this paragraph 10.5(a) by
executing a written guaranty (in substantially the same form provided to the Limited Partners prior to the
date first written above). The pro rata shares described in the preceding sentence shall be based on
relative distributions received by each such Managing Member, or managing member of the General
Partner, from the General Partner. The General Partner's operating agreement shall contain a provision
requiring each newly-admitted managing member to personally guaranty his, her or its respective pro rata
share of the General Partner's obligation under this paragraph 10.5(a) by executing a written guaranty (in
substantially the same form provided to the Limited Partners prior to the date first written above)
(b) Notwithstanding paragraphs 7.3 and 10.4, upon liquidation of the Partnership
pursuant to this Article 10, but prior to the application of paragraph 10.5(a), the General Partner (or its
designated Affiliate, as applicable) shall be required to pay back to the Partnership the amount by which
the cumulative net distributions received by the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate, as applicable)
in respect of its Partnership Percentage exceed the distributions the General Partner (or its designated
Affiliate, as applicable) would have received in respect of its Partnership Percentage (treating all such
distributions and related allocations as having taken place in one Accounting Period) if the Partnership
Percentage of the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate, as applicable) for this purpose were equal to
the Funded Percentage of the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate, as applicable). For purposes of
this paragraph 10.5(b), the "Funded Percentage of the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate, as
applicable) shall be a percentage equal to a fraction, the numerator of which is (1) the sum of (A) the cash
capital contributions of the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate, as applicable) and (B) allocations
of Profit (net of Loss) to the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate, as applicable) in respect of Fee
Adjustment Amounts made pursuant to paragraph 5.1(aXi) and the denominator of which is (2) the sum
of (A) the cash capital contributions of all Partners and (B) allocations of Profit (net of Loss) to the
General Partner (or its designated Affiliate, as applicable) in respect of Fee Adjustment Amounts made
pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a)(i); provided, however, that the amount of repayment described in this
paragraph 10.5(b) shall be limited to the distributions received by the General Partner (or its designated
Affiliate, as applicable) in respect of Fee Adjustment Amounts (other than amounts returned to the
Partnership by the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate, as applicable) pursuant to paragraph
4.2(d)(ii) prior to final liquidation of the Partnership) reduced by the gross tax liabilities that the General
Partner would have incurred on all allocations of taxable income (net of losses) made pursuant to
paragraph 5.1(a)(i) if: (x) at all times the General Partner were subject to the Applicable Tax Rate; and (y)
all such allocations resulted from fully taxable transactions, plus any tax benefit actually received by the
General Partner in the year in which the General Partner is required to make a payment pursuant to this
paragraph 10.5(b), as calculated by the Partnership's accountants, which such tax benefit is attributable
solely to the making of such payment and which benefit shall be determined after first taking all other
items of income, gain, loss, deduction or credit of the General Partner (or its direct or indirect owners)
into account. In the event that the assets of the General Partner or its designated Affiliate are insufficient
to satisfy the obligation described in the preceding sentence, all members of the General Partner or its
designated Affiliate will on a several, but not joint, basis contribute capital to the General Partner or its
designated Affiliate in an amount equal to each such member's pro rata share of the remaining obligation
to the Partnership (based on the member's pro rata participation in any Cashless Contribution of any
capital contributions to the Partnership).
34.
147765658 v44
ARTICLE 11
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING, REPORTS AND MEETINGS
11.1 Financial Accounting; Fiscal Year. The books and records of the Partnership shall be
kept in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement and otherwise in accordance with generally
accepted accounting principles consistently applied, and shall be audited at the end of each fiscal year
beginning with fiscal year 20168 by an independent public accountant selected by the General Partner.
The Partnership's fiscal year shall be the calendar year.

11.2 Supervision; Inspection of Books. Proper and complete books of account of the
Partnership, copies of the Partnership's federal, state and local tax returns for each fiscal year, the
Schedule of Partners set forth in EXHIBIT A, this Agreement and the Partnership's Certificate of Limited
Partnership shall be kept under the supervision of the General Partner at the principal office of the
Partnership. Such books and records shall be open to inspection (including by email or other electronic
means) by the Limited Partners, or their accredited representatives, at not less than three (3) business
days' notice, at any reasonable time during normal business hours.

11.3 Quarterly Reports. The General Partner shall use reasonable best efforts to transmit to
the Limited Partners, within sixty (60) days after the close of each of the first three quarters of each fiscal
year beginning with fiscal year 20168, a list of investments then held, together with a valuation of the
investments then held and unaudited financial statements of the Partnership, including a statement of
capital accounts.
I
11.4 Annual Report; Financial Statements of the Partnership. Beginning with fiscal year
20168, the General Partner shall use reasonable best efforts to transmit to the Limited Partners within
ninety (90) days after the close of the Partnership's fiscal year audited financial statements of the
Partnership prepared in accordance with the terms of this Agreement and otherwise in accordance with
generally accepted accounting principles, including an income statement for the year then ended and a
balance sheet as of the end of such year, a statement of changes in the Partners' Capital Accounts, and a
list of investments then held. The financial statements shall be accompanied by a report from the General
Partner to the Limited Partners, which shall include a status report on investments then heldr  a-summary
ef-aequisitiens-aufl-elispesitions-ef-Mvestmenele-by-the-Pacmer-ship-during-tlie-rweeeding-quefter and
a valuation of each such investment.

11.5 Website Based Reporting. The General Partner shall be entitled, in its sole discretion,
to transmit the reports and statements described in paragraphs 11.3 and 11.4 (the "Subject Reports") to
one or more Limited Partners solely by means of granting such Limited Partners access to a database or
other forum hosted on a website designated by the General Partner (the "Reporting Site"), with such
parameters regarding access and availability of information for review as the General Partner deems
reasonably necessary to protect the confidentiality and proprietary nature of the information contained
therein (including, but not limited to, establishing password protections for access to the Reporting Site
and having such Subject Reports available for review for a restricted period of time (but in no event less
than thirty (30) days from the date the Limited Partners are notified that such Subject Reports are posted
on the Reporting Site)). The General Partner shall provide each Limited Partner to which it will transmit
Subject Reports pursuant to this paragraph 11.5 notice of the first date on which a new Subject Report
will be posted on the Reporting Site for such Limited Partner's review and shall either (i) make each
Subject Report printable or (ii) upon written request by a Limited Partner, deliver a mailed copy of the
Subject Report to such Limited Partner. Unless the General Partner exercises its discretion pursuant to
and in compliance with paragraph 15.15(c) to restrict access to certain Confidential Information that may
be included in a Subject Report posted on the Reporting Site, the Subject Reports posted on the Reporting
35.
147765658 v-14
Site shall contain all of the material information included in those Subject Reports transmitted to Limited
Partners other than pursuant to this paragraph 11.5 and shall be print-capable. The Subject Reports shall
be posted on the Reporting Site within the same number of days after the end of the applicable fiscal
quarter or Fiscal Year as is required pursuant to paragraphs 11.3 and 11.4.
11.6 Annual Meeting. Unless a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners
Annual -Meeting. Aagree otherwise, a meeting of the Partners shall be held annually from the year of

20168. Such annual meeting may be held at the principal office of the Partnership (unless otherwise
designated by the General Partner) or be held by conference call as determined by the General Partner.
11.7 Tax Returns.

(a) The General Partner shall endeavor to cause the Partnership's estimated federal,
state and local tax returns, IRS Form 1065, Schedule K-1 and any other tax information reasonably
requested by a Limited Partner to be prepared and delivered to the Limited Partners within ninety (90)
days after the close of the Partnership's fiscal year.
I
(b) Each Limited Partner hereby agrees and covenants that it shall not make an
election under Section 732(d) of the Code with respect to property distributed to it by the Partnership
without the prior written consent of the General Partner. The General Partner may, but shall not be
obligated to, cause the Partnership to make an election under Section 754 of the Code or an election to be
treated as an "electing investment partnership" within the meaning of Section 743(e) of the Code. If the
Partnership elects to be treated as an electing investment partnership, each Limited Partner shall (i)
reasonably cooperate with the Partnership to maintain such status, (ii) shall not take any action that would
be reasonably inconsistent with such election, (iii) provide the General Partner with any information
necessary to allow the Partnership to comply with its obligations to make tax basis adjustments under
Sections 734 or 743 of the Code and its tax reporting and other obligations as an electing investment
partnership, and (iv) provide the General Partner and any such Limited Partner's transferee (if applicable),
promptly upon request, with the information cequir-ed-imdet--Seetien-603-1-(4)-ef-the-C-ede-er--ethefwise-te
be-fiffnislieti-te-the-Papinefship-er-suelv-IffinsfeFeer iaeluding-suell-infematieit-as-is-reasenebly-necessary
to enable the Partnership and such transferee to compute the amount of losses disallowed under Section
743(e) of the Code, but in no event shall such Limited Partner be required to provide such information
prior to its receipt of its Schedule K-1 for such taxable year, except to the extent of information, if any,
required by the Partnership to complete its Schedule K-Is. Whether or not the Partnership makes such
election, promptly upon request, each Limited Partner shall provide the General Partner with any
information related to such Partner reasonably necessary to allow the Partnership to comply with (i) its
obligations to make tax basis adjustments under Sections 734 or 743 of the Code and (ii) any other tax
reporting obligations of the Partnership.
11.8 Tax Matters Partner.

itn The General Partner shall be the Partnership's tax matters partner under the Code
and under any comparable provision of state law. The General Partner shall have the right to resign as tax
matters partner by giving thirty (30) days' written notice to each Partner. Upon such resignation a
successor tax matters partner shall be selected by a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners. The tax
matters partner shall employ experienced tax counsel to represent the Partnership in connection with any
audit or investigation of the Partnership by the Internal Revenue Service and in connection with all
subsequent administrative and judicial proceedings arising out of such audit. If the tax matters partner is
required by law or regulation to incur fees and expenses in connection with tax matters not affecting all
the Partners, then the Partnership shall be entitled to reimbursement from those Partners on whose behalf
such fees and expenses were incurred. The tax matters partner shall keep the Partners informed of all
36.
147765658 v44
administrative and judicial proceedings, as required by Section 6223(g) of the Code, and shall furnish to
each Partner, if such Partner so requests in writing, a copy of each notice or other communication
received by the tax matters partner from the Internal Revenue Service, except such notices or
communications as are sent directly to such requesting Partner by the Internal Revenue Service. The
relationship of the tax matters partner to the Limited Partners is that of a fiduciary, and the tax matters
partner has fiduciary obligations to perform its duties as tax matters partner in such manner as will serve
the best interests of the Partnership and all of the Partnership's Partners. To the fullest extent permitted
by law, but subject to the limitations and exclusions of paragraph 15.4, the Partnership agrees to
indemnify the tax matters partner and its agents and save and hold them harmless, from and in respect to
all (a) fees, costs and expenses in connection with or resulting from any claim, action, or demand against
the tax matters partner, the General Partner or the Partnership that arise out of or in any way relate to the
tax matters partner's status as tax matters partner for the Partnership, and (b) all such claims, actions, and
demands and any losses or damages therefrom, including amounts paid in settlement or compromise of
any such claim, action, or demand.

ffl  For fiscal years of the Partnership beginning after December 31, 2017 (or if the
effective date of Section 1101 of the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015 is extended, such later extended
date): (i) the General Partner shall be designated the "partnership representative" within the meaning of
Code Section 6223(a) (the "Partnership Representative') and the General Partner shall be authorized to
take any actions necessary under Treasury Regulations or other guidance to cause the General Partner to
be designated as such; (ii) the Partnership and each Partner agree that they shall be bound by the actions
taken by the Partnership Representative, as described in Code Section 6223(b); (iii) the Partners consent
to the election set forth in Code Section 6226(a) and agree to take any action, and furnish the General
Partner with any information necessary, to give effect to such election if the General Partner decides to
make such election; (iv) any imputed underpayment imposed on the Partnership pursuant to Code Section
6232 (and any related interest, penalties or other additions to tax) that the General Partner reasonably
determines is attributable to one or more Partners shall be promptly paid by such Partners to the
Partnership (pro rata in proportion to their respective shares of such underpayment) within fifteen days
following the General Partner's request for payment (and any failure to pay such amount shall result in a
subsequent reduction in distributions otherwise payable to such Partner plus interest on such amount
calculated at the Prime Rate plus two percent (2%)) and/or shall constitute an event of default subject to
the terms of paragraph 4.5); provided, that in making the determination of which Partners (including
former Partners) any such imputed underpayment is attributable to, the General Partner will allocate any
imputed underpayment imposed on the Partnership (and any related interest, penalties, additions to tax
and audit costs) among the Partners in good faith taking into account each Partner's particular status,
including, for the avoidance of doubt, a Partner's tax-exempt status; and (v) paragraphs 11.8(a), 15.3 and
15.4 shall apply to the General Partner in its capacity as Partnership Representative. Any references to
Code Sections set forth in this paragraph 11.8(b) refer to those Sections as in effect for fiscal years of the
Partnership beginning after December 31, 2017. Regarding the potential obligation of a former Partner
under this paragraph, the following shall apply: (i) each Partner agrees that notwithstanding any other
provision in this Agreement if it is no longer a Partner it shall nevertheless be obligated for any
responsibilities under this paragraph as if it were a Partner at the time of demand hereunder; and (ii) the
General Partner will not consent to the Transfer of interest of any Limited Partner unless the transferee
receiving such interest agrees that in the event the transferor of such interest does not fulfill its obligation
under the preceding clause (i) within 20 Business Days following written demand by the General Partner,
such transferee shall be jointly and severally liable with such transferor for such obligation and the
General Partner may thereafter treat the transferee as the relevant Partner for purposes of this paragraph.
37.
147765658 v.14
11.9 Partnership Funds. Cash held by the Partnership shall be promptly deposited into an
account in a reputable bank or financial institution (as determined by the General Partner in its reasonable
discretion).
ARTICLE 12
VALUATION; ADVISORY COMMITTEE
12.1 Valuation. Subject to the specific standards set forth below, the valuation of Securities
and other assets and liabilities under this Agreement shall be at fair market value. Except as may be
required under applicable Treasury Regulations, no value shall be placed on the goodwill or the name of
the Partnership in determining the value of the interest of any Partner or in any accounting among the
Partners.

(a) The following criteria shall be used for determining the fair market value of
Securities:
If traded on one or more securities exchanges or the NASDAQ National
Market System, the value shall be deemed to be the Securities' closing price on the principal of such
exchanges on the valuation date.

(ii) If actively traded over the counter (other than on the NASDAQ National
Market System), the value shall be deemed to be the closing price of such Securities on the valuation date.
(iii) If there is no active public market, the value shall be the fair market
value thereof, as determined by the General Partner, taking into consideration the purchase price of the
Securities, developments concerning the investee company subsequent to the acquisition of the Securities,
any financial data and projections of the investee company provided to the General Partner, and such
other factor or factors as the General Partner may deem relevant.

(b) If the General Partner in good faith determines that, because of special
circumstances, the valuation methods set forth in this Article 12 do not fairly determine the value of a
Security, the General Partner shall make such adjustments or use such alternative valuation method as it
deems appropriate.

(c) The General Partner shall have the power at any time to determine, for all
purposes of this Agreement, the fair market value of any assets and liabilities of the Partnership, subject
to paragraph 12.1(d).

(d) If within thirty (30) days of receipt of a proposed valuation established by the
General Partner pursuant to this paragraph 12.1, the Advisory Committee notifies the General Partner of
an objection to such proposed valuation, then, if the General Partner and the Advisory Committee cannot
otherwise mutually agree on the valuation, the General Partner and the Advisory Committee may each
appoint an independent securities expert to render a valuation, and the average of such experts valuations
shall be adopted as the Partnership's valuation. The fees and expenses of any expert retained in
accordance with this paragraph 12.1(d) shall be borne by the Partnership.

12.2 Advisory Committee. The General Partner will appoint an Advisory Committee (the
"Advisory Committee") that will serve as such for the Partnership and the Parallel Funds and shall consist
of no less than three (3) and no more than seven (7) representatives of the Limited Partners and
constituent limited partners of Parallel Funds selected by the General Partner from time to time in its
38.
147765658 v44
reasonable judgment; provided, however, that any Limited Partner that is an Affiliate of the General
Partner, the Management Company, any Managing Member or any of their respective members,
employees or Affiliates may not be appointed to be a member of the Advisory Committee.  The General
Partner may remove any member of the Advisory Committee at any time in its sole and absolute
discretion; provided, fi tethefhowever, that if the General Partner affirmatively removes from the Advisory
Committee  a representative of a Limited Partner crent-sepeing-en-theadvisepy-Getimitteewho  has been
granted a right to appoint such representative,  other than for conduct that the General Partner determines
in its reasonable discretion, is harmful to the Partnership or a Parallel Fund, then such Limited Partner
shall be entitled to appoint a replacement member of the Advisory Committee who is reasonably
acceptable to the General Partner. The duties of the Advisory Committee will include: (a) consideration
of any approvals sought by the General Partner pursuant to the terms of this Agreement; (b) upon request
by the General Partner, advising with respect to all matters pertaining to conflicts of interest by the
Partnership, the General Partner or any of the members of the General Partner; and (c) such advice and
counsel as is requested by the General Partner in connection with the Partnership's investments and other
Partnership matters. However, subject to paragraph 12.1(d), the General Partner will retain ultimate
responsibility for asset valuations and for making all investment decisions. The Partnership will
reimburse each member for his or her reasonable out-of-pocket expenses. All actions, consents or
approvals of the Advisory Committee shall require a majority of its members serving at the time such
action, consent or approval is taken, which actions, consents or approvals may be carried out by
telephone, facsimile or electronic mail or other means reasonably acceptable to the General Partner.
ARTICLE 13
PARTNERS SUBJECT TO SPECIAL REGULATION
13.1 ERISA Partners.

(a) Each Limited Partner that is, or whose equity interests are at least partially owned
by, a "benefit plan investor" within the meaning of, and subject to the provisions of, ERISA, (each, an
"ERISA Partner") hereby (i) acknowledges that it is its understanding that neither the Partnership, the
General Partner, nor any of the Affiliated Entities of the General Partner, are "fiduciaries" of such
Limited Partner within the meaning of ERISA by reason of the Limited Partner investing its assets in, and
being a Limited Partner of, the Partnership; (ii) acknowledges that it has been informed of and
understands the investment objectives and policies of, and the investment strategies that may be pursued
by, the Partnership; (iii) acknowledges that it is aware of the provisions of Section 404 of ERISA relating
to the requirements for investment and diversification of the assets of employee benefit plans and trusts
subject to ERISA; (iv) represents that it has given appropriate consideration to the facts and
circumstances relevant to the investment by that ERISA Partner's plan in the Partnership and has
determined that such investment is reasonably designed, as part of such portfolio, to further the purposes
of such plan; (v) represents that, taking into account the other investments made with the assets of such
plan, and the diversification thereof, such plan's investment in the Partnership is consistent with the
requirements of Section 404 and other provisions of ERISA; (vi) acknowledges that it understands that
current income will not be a primary objective of the Partnership; and (vii) represents that, taking into
account the other investments made with the assets of such plan, the investment of assets of such plan in
the Partnership is consistent with the cash flow requirements and funding objectives of such plan.

(b) Notwithstanding any provision contained herein to the contrary, each ERISA
Partner may elect to withdraw from the Partnership, or upon demand by the General Partner shall
withdraw from the Partnership, at the time and in the manner hereinafter provided, if either the ERISA
Partner or the General Partner shall obtain an opinion of counsel (which counsel shall be reasonably
acceptable to both the ERISA Partner and the General Partner) to the effect that, as a result of applicable
39.
147765658 44
statutes, regulations, case law, administrative interpretations, or similar authority (i) the continuation of
the ERISA Partner as a Limited Partner of the Partnership or the conduct of the Partnership will result, or
there is a material likelihood the same will result, in a material violation of ERISA, or (ii) all or any
portion of the assets of the Partnership constitute assets of the ERISA Partner and are subject to the
provisions of ERISA to substantially the same extent as if owned directly by the ERISA Partner. In the
event of the issuance of such opinion of counsel, a copy of such opinion shall be given to all the ERISA
Partners, together with the written notice of the election of the ERISA Partner to withdraw or the written
demand of the General Partner for withdrawal, whichever the case may be. Thereupon, unless within
ninety (90) days after receipt of such written notice and opinion the General Partner is able to eliminate
the necessity for such withdrawal to the reasonable satisfaction of the ERISA Partner and the General
Partner, whether by correction of the condition giving rise to the necessity of the ERISA Partner's
withdrawal, or the amendment of this Agreement, or otherwise, such ERISA Partner shall withdraw its
entire interest in the Partnership, such withdrawal to be effective upon the last day of the fiscal quarter
during which such ninety (90) day period expired.

(c) The withdrawing ERISA Partner shall be entitled to receive within ninety (90)
days after the date of such withdrawal an amount equal to the amount of such Partner's Capital Account
as of the effective date of such withdrawal.
(d) Any distribution or payment to a withdrawing ERISA Partner pursuant to this
paragraph may, in the sole discretion of the General Partner, be made in cash, in securities, in the form of
a promissory note, the terms of which shall be mutually agreed upon by the General Partner and the
withdrawing ERISA Partner, or any combination thereof.
Any valuation necessary for the purposes of a distribution or payment to a
withdrawing ERISA Partner pursuant to this paragraph shall be made by the General Partner in good faith
pursuant to paragraph 12.1.

13.2 Governmental Plan Partners. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the
contrary, any Limited Partner that is either a "governmental plan" as defined in Title 29, Section
1002(32) of the United States Code or an employee benefit plan subject to Governmental Plan
Regulations (a "Governmental Plan Partner") may elect to withdraw from the Partnership, or upon
demand by the General Partner shall withdraw from the Partnership, if either the Governmental Plan
Partner or the General Partner shall obtain an opinion of counsel (which counsel shall be reasonably
acceptable to both the Governmental Plan Partner and the General Partner) to the effect that the
Governmental Plan Partner, the Partnership, or the General Partner would be in violation, or there is a
material likelihood the same would result, of any Governmental Plan Regulation, as a result of the
Governmental Plan Partner continuing as a Limited Partner, and, in the case of an opinion obtained by the
General Partner, that such violation would have a material adverse effect on the General Partner or the
Partnership. In the event of the issuance of the opinion of counsel referred to in the preceding sentence,
the withdrawal of and disposition of the Governmental Plan Partner's interest in the Partnership shall be
governed by paragraph 13.1 of the Agreement, as if the Governmental Plan Partner were an ERISA
Partner.

13.3 Private Foundation Partners. Notwithstanding any provision of the Agreement to the
contrary, any Limited Partner that is, or whose equity interests are at least partially owned by, a "private
foundation" as described in Section 509 of the Code (a "Private Foundation Partner"), may elect to
withdraw from the Partnership, or upon demand by the General Partner shall withdraw from the
Partnership, if either the Private Foundation Partner or the General Partner shall obtain an opinion of
counsel (which counsel shall be reasonably acceptable to both the Private Foundation Partner and the
General Partner) to the effect that such withdrawal is necessary in order for the Private Foundation
40.
147765658 v44
Partner to avoid (a) excise taxes imposed by Subchapter A of Chapter 42 of the Code (other than Sections
4940 and 4942 thereof), or (b) a material breach of the fiduciary duties of its trustees under any federal or
state law applicable to private foundations or any rule or regulation adopted thereunder by any agency,
commission, or authority having jurisdiction. In the event of the issuance of the opinion of counsel
referred to in the preceding sentence, the withdrawal of and disposition of the Private Foundation
Partner's interest in the Partnership shall be governed by paragraph 13.1, as if the Private Foundation
Partner were an ERISA Partner.
ARTICLE 14
CERTAIN DEFINITIONS
14.1 Accounting Period. An Accounting Period shall be (a) a calendar year if there are no
changes in the Partners' respective interests in the Profits or Losses of the Partnership during such
calendar year except on the first day thereof, or (b) any other period beginning on the first day of a
calendar year, or any other day during a calendar year upon which occurs a change in such respective
interests, and ending on the last day of a calendar year, or on the day preceding an earlier day upon which
any change in such respective interests shall occur.

14.2 Adjusted Asset Value. The Adjusted Asset Value with respect to any asset shall be the
asset's adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes, except as follows:

(a) The initial Adjusted Asset Value of any asset contributed by a Partner to the
Partnership shall be the gross fair market value of such asset at the time of contribution, as determined by
the contributing Partner and the Partnership.

(b) In the discretion of the General Partner, the Adjusted Asset Values of all
Partnership assets may be adjusted to equal their respective gross fair market values, as determined by the
General Partner, and the resulting unrealized profit or loss allocated to the Capital Accounts of the
Partners pursuant to Article 5, as of the following times: (i) upon distribution by the Partnership to a
Partner of more than a de minimis amount of Partnership assets, unless all Partners receive simultaneous
distributions of either undivided interests in the distributed property or identical Partnership assets in
proportion to their interests in Partnership distributions as provided in paragraphs 7.4, 7.5 and 7.6, and (ii)
the grant of an additional interest in the Partnership by any new or existing Partner.

(c) The Adjusted Asset Values of all Partnership assets shall be adjusted to equal
their respective gross fair market values, as determined by the General Partner, and the resulting
unrealized profit or loss allocated to the Capital Accounts of the Partners pursuant to Article 5, as of the
termination of the Partnership either by expiration of the Partnership's term or the occurrence of an event
described in paragraph 10.2.

14.3 Adjusted Capital Account Balance. The Adjusted Capital Account Balance for each
Partner shall be equal to the balance in the Partner's Capital Account as of the end of the relevant
Accounting Period, after giving effect to the following adjustments:

(a) Credit to such Capital Account any amounts which the Partner is obligated to
restore (calculated as if all assets of the Partnership were sold for their Adjusted Asset Values and the
Partnership were in liquidation), including, without limitation, amounts described in paragraph 10.5, or
is deemed to be obligated to restore pursuant to the penultimate sentence of Treasury Regulations Section
1.704-1(b)(4)(ivXf); and
41.
147765658 v►4
(b) Debit to such Capital Account the items described in Sections
1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(4), 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(dX5), and 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(dX6) of the Treasury Regulations.
14.4 Affiliate. An Affiliate of any person shall mean (a) any person that directly, or indirectly
through one or more intermediaries, controls, or is controlled by or is under common control with the
person specified or (b) such person's family members within the same line of direct consanguinity or a
first degree of collateral consanguinity; provided, however, that for all purposes under this Agreement, no
Thiel Person shall be deemed to be an Affiliate of any Managing Member, the General Partner or the
Management Company.

14.5 Capital Account. The Capital Account of each Partner shall consist of its original
capital contribution, (a) increased by any additional capital contributions, its share of income or gain that
is allocated to it pursuant to this Agreement, and the amount of any Partnership liabilities that are
assumed by it or that are secured by any Partnership property distributed to it, and (b) decreased by the
amount of any distributions to or withdrawals by it, its share of expense or loss that is allocated to it
pursuant to this Agreement, and the amount of any of its liabilities that are assumed by the Partnership or
that are secured by any property contributed by it to the Partnership. The foregoing provision and the
other provisions of this Agreement relating to the maintenance of Capital Accounts are intended to
comply with Treasury Regulation Section 1.704-1(b)(2Xiv), and shall be interpreted and applied in a
manner consistent with such Regulations. In the event the General Partner shall determine that it is
prudent to modify the manner in which the Capital Accounts, or any debits or credits thereto, are
computed in order to comply with such Regulations, the General Partner may make such modification,
provided, however, that it is not likely to have more than an insignificant effect on the total amounts
distributable to any Partner pursuant to Article 7 and Article 10.
14.6 Capital Commitment; Committed Capital. A Partner's Capital Commitment shall
mean the amount that such Partner has agreed to contribute to the capital of the Partnership as set forth
opposite such Partner's name on its EXHIBIT A hereto. The Partnership's Committed Capital shall equal
the sum of the aggregate Capital Commitments of all Partners.

14.7 Code. The Code is the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended from time to time (or
any corresponding provisions of succeeding law).
14.8 Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss. The Deemed Gain from any in kind distribution of
Securities shall be equal to the excess, if any, of the fair market value of the Securities distributed (valued
as of the date of distribution in accordance with paragraph 12.1), over the aggregate Adjusted Asset Value
of the Securities distributed. The Deemed Loss from any in kind distribution of Securities shall be equal
to the excess, if any, of the aggregate Adjusted Asset Value of the Securities distributed over the fair
market value of the Securities distributed (valued as of the date of distribution in accordance with
paragraph 12.1).
14.9 Reserved.

14.10 Marketable; Marketable Securities; Marketability. These terms shall refer to
Securities that are (i) (A) traded on a national securities exchange or over the counter or (B) currently the
subject of an effective Securities Act registration statement, (ii) not subject to underwriter "lockup" or
other contractual restrictions and (iii) may be sold by each distributee Limited Partner without restriction
under applicable securities laws of the United States or the applicable laws of the jurisdiction of the
exchange on which such Securities are actively traded (other than volume limitations imposed under
Securities and Exchange Commission Rule 144 or similar volume limitations imposed by another
jurisdiction). Notwithstanding the foregoing, a Security shall not be deemed to be a Marketable Security
42.
147765658 v44
if, in the good faith judgment of the General Partner, the market on which such Security trades is not
adequate to permit an orderly sale of all shares of such Security held by the Partnership within a
reasonable time period.

14.11 Nonma rketa hie Securities. Nonmarketable Securities are all Securities other than
Marketable Securities.

14.12 Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss. Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss shall be an
amount computed for each Accounting Period as of the last day thereof that is equal to the sum of all
income received by the Partnership during such Accounting Period from the investment of idle funds in
Short-Term Securities.

14.13 Partnership Percentage. The Partnership Percentage for each Partner shall be equal to
the Capital Commitment of such Partner stated as a percentage of the aggregate Capital Commitments of
the Partnership, and shall be set forth opposite each Partner's name on its EXHIBIT A hereto. For the
avoidance of doubt, the Partnership Percentage of the General Partner shall not be reduced by any Fee
Adjustment Amounts.

14.14 Percentage in Interest; Majority in Interest. A specified fraction or percentage in
interest of the Partners or of the Limited Partners shall mean those partners or limited partners of the
Partnership and the Parallel Funds whose Capital Commitments to the Partnership and capital
commitments to the Parallel Funds, stated as a percentage of the aggregate capital commitments of the
Partnership and all of the Parallel Funds, equal or exceed the required fraction or percentage in interest of
all such partners or limited partners. A Majority in Interest shall mean more than fifty percent (50%) in
interest. Any limited partnership interest owned or controlled by the General Partner, the Management
Company, the Managing Members or any of their employees or Affiliates shall be deemed not to be
outstanding for purposes of any determination under this Agreement of a particular percentage in interest
of the Limited Partners and shall be excluded from voting in any vote taken or consent granted by the
Limited Partners under this Agreement.

14.15 Prime Rate. The Prime Rate shall mean an interest rate equal to the floating commercial
rate of interest published in the Wall Street Journal (or its successors) as its prime rate.
14.16 Profit or Loss. Profit or Loss shall be an amount computed for each Accounting Period
as of the last day thereof that is equal to the Partnership's taxable income or loss for such Accounting
Period, determined in accordance with Section 703(a) of the Code (for this purpose, all items of income,
gain, loss, or deduction required to be stated separately pursuant to Code Section 703(a)( I) shall be
included in taxable income or loss), with the following adjustments:

(a) Any income of the Partnership that is exempt from federal income tax and not
otherwise taken into account in computing Profit or Loss pursuant to this paragraph shall be added to such
taxable income or loss;

(b) Any expenditures of the Partnership described in Code Section 705(a)(2)(B) or
treated as Code Section 705(a)(2XB) expenditures pursuant to Treasury Regulation Section
1.704- I (b)(2)(ivXi) and not otherwise taken into account in computing Profit or Loss pursuant to this
paragraph shall be subtracted from such taxable income or loss;
43.
147765658 44

(c) Gain or loss resulting from any disposition of a Partnership asset with respect to
which gain or loss is recognized for federal income tax purposes shall be computed by reference to the
Adjusted Asset Value of the asset disposed of rather than its adjusted tax basis;

(d) The difference between the gross fair market value of all Partnership assets and
their respective Adjusted Asset Values shall be added to such taxable income or loss in the circumstances
described in paragraph 14.2;
I
(e) Items which are specially allocated pursuant to paragraphs 3.2(c), 4.5(b)(vi) ; and
5.2 and 5.3 shall not be taken into account in computing Profit or Loss; and
The amount of any Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss on any Securities distributed
in kind shall be added to or subtracted from (as the case may be) such taxable income or loss.
14.17 Regulated Partner. Regulated Partner shall refer to each ERISA Partner, Governmental
Plan Partner, and Private Foundation Partner.

14.18 Securities. Securities shall mean securities of every kind and nature and rights and
options with respect thereto, including stock, notes, bonds, debentures, evidences of indebtedness and
other business interests of every type, including partnerships, joint ventures, proprietorships and other
business entities.

14.19 Securities Act. Securities Act shall mean the Securities Act of 1933, as amended.
14.20 Short -Term Securities. Short -Term Securities shall mean commercial paper, certificates
of deposit, treasury bills, and other money market investments with maturities of less than twelve (12)
months.

14.21 Thiel Persons. Thiel Persons shall mean Peter Thiel, Peter Thiel's retirement accounts
and Thiel Capital LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, any wholly owned subsidiary of any of the
foregoing, and any successor in interest thereto.

14.22 Treasury Regulations. Treasury Regulations shall mean the Income Tax Regulations
promulgated under the Code, as such Regulations may be amended from time to time (including
corresponding provisions of succeeding Regulations).
ARTICLE 15
OTHER PROVISIONS
15.1 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed under the laws of
the State of Delaware as such law would be applied to agreements among the residents of such state made
and to be performed entirely within such state.

15.2 Limitation of Liability of the Limited Partners. Except as required by law or by
paragraphs 4.2 or 9.7 of this Agreement, no Limited Partner shall be bound by, nor be personally liable
for, the expenses, liabilities, or obligations of the Partnership in excess of its Capital Commitment to the
Partnership.
44.
147765658 v44
15.3 Exculpation.

(a) Neither the tax matters partner, the General Partner, the Management Company,
the members of the Advisory Committee nor their respective managers, members, partners, principals,
officers, employees, Affiliates or agents (including solely with respect to the conduct of any member of
the Advisory Committee, the Limited Partner responsible for the appointment of such member of the
Advisory Committee) shall be liable, responsible or accountable in damages or otherwise to the Limited
Partners or the Partnership for honest mistakes of judgment, or for action or inaction, taken in good faith
and in the best interests of the Partnership, or for losses due to such mistakes, action, or inaction, or to the
negligence, dishonesty, or bad faith of any employee, broker, or other agent of the Partnership, provided,
however, that such employee, broker, or agent was selected, engaged, and retained with reasonable care.
The General Partner and such persons may consult with counsel and accountants in respect of Partnership
affairs and be fully protected and justified in any action or inaction that is taken in accordance with the
advice or opinion of such counsel or accountants, provided, however, that (i) they shall have been selected
with reasonable care, (ii) with regard to the General Partner, such action or in action shall not constitute
gross negligence or fraud, and (iii) the General Partner or other such persons shall have relied on their
advice or opinion in good faith.

(b) Notwithstanding any contrary provision in paragraph 15.3(a) above, the
provisions of this paragraph and the immediately following paragraph shall not be construed so as to
relieve (or attempt to relieve) any (i) member of the Advisory Committee or any Thiel Person of any
liability by reason of bad faith, (ii) other person by reason of recklessness, bad faith, gross negligence or
intentionally wrongful conduct, (iii) person by reason of any material breach by the General Partner of
this Agreement or of its fiduciary duties to the Partnership that has a material adverse effect upon the
economic interests of the Limited Partners in the Partnership (in addition to the expense of such
indemnity claim) and that remains uncured following ten (10) business days' written notice of such
material breach to the General Partner, or (iv) person to the extent (but only to the extent) that such
liability may not be waived, modified, or limited under applicable law, but shall be construed so as to
effectuate the provisions of such paragraphs to the fullest extent permitted by law.

(c) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement: (i) to the extent that,
at law or in equity, an Indemnified Party (as defined in paragraph 15.4) has duties (including fiduciary
duties) and liabilities relating thereto to the Partnership, any Partner or any other person, such
Indemnified Party acting under this Agreement shall not be liable to the Partnership, and Partner or any
other person for breach of fiduciary duty for its good faith reliance on the provisions of this Agreement
(or for taking actions that are permitted under this Agreement); and (ii) the provisions of this Agreement,
to the extent that they restrict or eliminate the duties (including fiduciary duties) and liabilities relating
thereto of an Indemnified Party otherwise existing at law or in equity, are agreed by each Partner and the
Partnership to replace such other duties and liabilities of such Indemnified Party.

(d) Each Partner acknowledges and agrees that: (i) certain Thiel Persons are
members of the Management Company and/or the General Partner; (ii) one or more Thiel Persons and
their Affiliates are or may be involved in or have an economic interest in, directly or indirectly, in their
capacity as managers, advisers, directors, founders, sponsors, partners, members or otherwise, other
financial, investment and professional activities, and may engage for their own accounts and for the
accounts of others in any such ventures and activities (without regard to whether the interests of such
ventures and activities conflict with those of the Partnership); (iii) nothing in this Agreement is intended,
or shall be deemed, to restrict or in any way limit the Thiel Persons' or their Affiliates' ability to engage in
any such ventures or activities; (iv) neither the Partnership nor any Partner shall have any right by virtue
of this Agreement or the existence of the Partnership in and to such ventures or activities or to the income
or profits derived therefrom; (v) no Thiel Person shall have any fiduciary or other duties to any Partner or
45.
147765658 v44
the Partnership created as a result of, or pursuant to, this Agreement or as a result of the Thiel Activities
(as defined below), or any duty or obligation to make any reports to any Partner or the Partnership, with
respect to any such ventures or activities; and (vi) the functions and activities of any Thiel Person with
respect to the Partnership (the "Thiel Activities") being limited to, as applicable, (x) being a limited
partner of the Partnership or a Parallel Fund, (y) having any ownership interest the Management
Company and/or the General Partner, and (z) taking any actions as a result of a Thiel Person's ownership
interest in the Management Company or the General Partner, (1) shall not alter or impair the limitation on
liability of any Thiel Person as a limited partner under the Partnership Act, (2) in no event shall the Thiel
Activities give rise to a conclusion, under Section 17-303 of the Partnership Act or otherwise, that any
Thiel Person participates in the control of the Partnership, (3) the obligations and responsibilities of the
Thiel Persons are limited to those of a limited partner, and (4) this Agreement and the documentation
contemplated hereby shall be interpreted in accordance with the foregoing.

(e) This paragraph 15.3 is intended to apply solely for the benefit of the Limited
Partners, and in no way shall be construed or interpreted as inuring to the benefit of any other person or
entity, including, without limitation, creditors of the Partnership, of the General Partner or of the members
of the General Partner or other third parties.

15.4 Indemnification. The Partnership agrees to indemnify, out of the assets of the
Partnership only (but including amounts that the Partners may be required to contribute pursuant to
paragraph 4.2(d)), the General Partner, the Management Company, the members of the Advisory
Committee (including solely with respect to the conduct of any member of the Advisory Committee, the
Limited Partner responsible for the appointment of such member of the Advisory Committee), the tax
matters partner and their respective managers, members, partners, principals, officers, employees,
Affiliates and agents (each an "Indemnified Party" collectively the "Indemnified Parties") to the fullest
extent permitted by law and to save and hold them harmless from and in respect of all (a) reasonable fees,
costs, and expenses, including legal fees, paid in connection with or resulting from any claim, action, or
demand against the Indemnified Parties that arises directly or indirectly out of or in any way relates to the
Partnership, its properties, business, or affairs, or any other enterprise that such Indemnified Party is or
was serving, as a director, officer, employee or otherwise, at the request of the Partnership, the General
Partner or the Management Company, and (b) such claims, actions, and demands described in the
preceding clause (a), and any losses or damages resulting from such claims, actions, and demands,
including amounts paid in settlement or compromise (if recommended by attorneys for the Partnership) of
any such claim, action or demand; provided, however, that this indemnity shall not extend to: (i) any
claim or proceeding solely between or among the General Partner, Management Company, the Managing
Members, or any of their respective managers, members, partners, principals, officers, employees,
Affiliates or agents; or (ii) any conduct which constitutes bad faith on the part of any Advisory
Committee member or Thiel Person or any conduct which constitutes recklessness, bad faith, gross
negligence or intentionally wrongful conduct on the part of any other Indemnified Party or any claim,
action or demand that arises from any material breach by the General Partner of this Agreement or of its
fiduciary duties to the Partnership that has a material adverse effect upon the economic interests of the
Limited Partners in the Partnership (in addition to the expense of such indemnity claim) and that remains
uncured following ten (10) business days' written notice of such material breach to the General Partner.
Expenses incurred by any Indemnified Party in defending a claim or proceeding covered by this
paragraph shall be paid by the Partnership in advance of the final disposition of such claim or proceeding
(regardless of whether the claim asserts that the Indemnified Party is not entitled to such indemnification
pursuant to clause (ii) of the proviso of the preceding sentence); provided, the Indemnified Party
undertakes to repay such amount if it is ultimately determined that such Indemnified Party was not
entitled to be indemnified; provided, fi irther, that no such advance shall be paid in the case of (A) a claim
or proceeding solely between or among the General Partner, Management Company, the Managing
Members, or any of their respective managers, members, partners, principals, officers, employees,
46.
147765658 44
Affiliates or agents or (B) any claim or proceeding brought by a Majority in Interest of the Limited
Partners against an Indemnified Party. The provisions of this paragraph 15.4 shall remain in effect as to
each Indemnified Party whether or not such Indemnified Party continues to serve in the capacity that
entitled such person to be indemnified. In the event that an Indemnified Party is also entitled to
indemnification by a portfolio company of the Partnership, the General Partner or the Management
Company, the Partners hereby acknowledge and agree that (i) the portfolio company shall be the
indemnitor of first resort and the Partnership shall be the indemnitor of second resort and the General
Partner and the Management Company shall be the indemnitors of third resort (i.e., the portfolio
company's obligations to such an Indemnified Party shall be primary, the Partnership's obligations to
such an Indemnified Party shall be secondary and any obligation of the General Partner and/or the
Management Company to advance expenses and/or to provide indemnification for the same expenses or
liabilities incurred by such an Indemnified Party shall be tertiary), (ii) that, to the extent such an
Indemnified Party is otherwise eligible hereunder for advancement of expenses, the Partnership shall be
required to advance the full amount of expenses incurred by such an Indemnified Party and shall be liable
for the full amount of all fees, costs and any other items described in clauses (a) and (b) of the first
sentence of this paragraph without regard to any rights such an Indemnified Party may have against the
General Partner or the Management Company and (iii) the Partnership hereby irrevocably waives,
relinquishes and releases the General Partner and the Management Company from any and all claims
against such parties for contribution, subrogation or any other recovery of any kind in respect of the
foregoing provisions of this sentence.
15.5 Arbitration.

(a) Any claim, dispute, or controversy of whatever nature arising out of or relating to
this Agreement, including, without limitation, any action or claim based on tort, contract, or statute
(including any claims of breach), or concerning the interpretation, effect, termination, validity,
performance and/or breach of this Agreement ("Claim"), shall be resolved by final and binding
confidential arbitration ("Arbitration") before a single arbitrator ("Arbitrator") selected from and
administered by Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Service Inc. (the "Administrator") in accordance with
its then existing arbitration rules or procedures regarding commercial or business disputes. The
arbitration shall be held in San Francisco, California or New York, New York, in the sole discretion of the
General Partner.

(b) Depositions may be taken and full discovery may be obtained in any arbitration
commenced under this provision.

(c) The Arbitrator shall, within fifteen (15) calendar days after the conclusion of the
Arbitration hearing, issue a written award and statement of decision describing the essential findings and
conclusions on which the award is based, including the calculation of any damages awarded. The
Arbitrator shall be authorized to award compensatory damages, but shall not be authorized (i) to award
non-economic damages, such as for emotional distress, pain and suffering or loss of consortium, (ii) to
award punitive damages, or (iii) to reform, modify or materially change this Agreement or any other
agreements contemplated hereunder; provided, however, that the damage limitations described in parts (i)
and (ii) of this sentence will not apply if such damages are statutorily imposed. The Arbitrator also shall
be authorized to grant any temporary, preliminary or permanent equitable remedy or relief he or she
deems just and equitable and within the scope of this Agreement, including, without limitation, an
injunction or order for specific performance.

(d) Each party shall bear its own attorney's fees, costs, and disbursements arising out
of the arbitration, and shall pay an equal share of the fees and costs of the Administrator and the
Arbitrator; provided, however, the Arbitrator shall be authorized to determine whether a party is
47.
147765658 v44
substantially the prevailing party, and if so, to award to that substantially prevailing party reimbursement
for its reasonable attorneys' fees, costs and disbursements (including, for example, expert witness fees
and expenses, photocopy charges, travel expenses, etc.), and/or the fees and costs of the Administrator
and the Arbitrator. Absent the filing of an application to correct or vacate the arbitration award under
Title 10 of the Delaware Code sections 5713 through 5717, each party shall fully perform and satisfy the
arbitration award within fifteen (15) days of the service of the award.

(e) By agreeing to this binding arbitration provision, the parties understand that they
are waiving certain rights and protections which may otherwise be available if a Claim between the
parties were determined by litigation in court, including, without limitation, the right to seek or obtain
certain types of damages precluded by this paragraph 15.5, the right to a jury trial, certain rights of
appeal, and a right to invoke formal rules of procedure and evidence.
15.6 Execution of Documents. This Agreement may be executed in two (2) or more
counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original but all of which together shall constitute one (1)
and the same instrument.

15.7 Other Instruments and Acts. The Partners agree to execute any other instruments or
perform any other acts that are or may be reasonably necessary to effectuate and carry on the partnership
created by this Agreement.

15.8 Binding Agreement. This Agreement shall be binding upon the transferees, successors,
assigns, and legal representatives of the Partners.

15.9 Notices; Electronic Transmission of Reports. Any notice or other communication that
one Partner desires to give to another Partner shall be in writing, and shall be deemed effectively given:
(a) upon personal delivery to the Partner to be notified, (b) upon confirmed transmission by electronic
mail, telex or facsimile if sent during normal business hours of the recipient, if not, then on the next
business day, (c) five (5) days after having been sent by registered or certified mail, return receipt
requested, postage prepaid, or (d) three (3) days after deposit with a nationally recognized overnight
courier, specifying next day delivery, with written verification of receipt. All communications shall be
addressed to the other Partner at the address shown on its EXHIBIT A or at such other address as a Partner
may designate by ten (10) days' advance written notice to the other Partners. In addition to the provisions
of paragraph 11.5, the General Partner shall be entitled to transmit to the Limited Partners by e-mail the
reports required by paragraphs 11.3, 11.4, and 11.7.

15.10 Power of Attorney. By signing this Agreement, each Limited Partner designates and
appoints the General Partner its true and lawful attorney, in its name, place, and stead to make, execute,
sign, and file the Certificate of Limited Partnership and any amendment thereto and such other
instruments, documents, or certificates that may from time to time be required of the Partnership by the
laws of the United States of America, the laws of the state of the Partnership's formation, or any other
state in which the Partnership shall conduct its affairs in order to qualify or otherwise enable the
Partnership to conduct its affairs in such jurisdictions. Such attorney is not hereby granted any authority
on behalf of the Limited Partners to amend this Agreement except that as attorney for each of the Limited
Partners, the General Partner shall have the authority to amend this Agreement and the Certificate of
Limited Partnership (and to execute any amendment to the Agreement or the Certificate of Limited
Partnership on behalf of itself and as attorney in fact for each of the Limited Partners) as may be required
to effect:

(a) Admission of additional Partners pursuant to Article 3;
48.
147765658 v44
(b) Additional capital contributions pursuant to Article 4;

(c) Transfers of Limited Partnership interests pursuant to Article 9; and
(d) Extensions of the Partnership term pursuant to Article 10.

This power of attorney and the power of attorney referenced in paragraph 4.5(b)(x) granted by each
Limited Partner shall expire as to such Partner immediately after the dissolution of the Partnership or the
amendment of the Partnership's EXHIBIT A to reflect the complete withdrawal of such Partner as a Partner
of the Partnership.
15.11 Amendment.

(a) Except as provided by the immediately preceding paragraph and subject to
paragraph 15.11(b), this Agreement may be amended only with the written consent of the General Partner
and a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners.

(b) Notwithstanding paragraph 15.11(a), no amendment to the provisions of Article
13 may be made without the consent of each ERISA Partner, Governmental Plan Partner and Private
Foundation Partner who may be materially adversely affected by such amendment, (ii) the General
Partner may amend this Agreement without the consent of the other Partners to reflect changes validly
made in the membership of the Partners and the capital contributions of the Partners, and (iii) no
amendment to this Agreement may modify any provision requiring the consent of more than a Majority in
Interest of the Limited Partners without the consent of such higher Percentage in Interest.

(c) Notwithstanding paragraphs 15.11(a) and (b), no amendment of this Agreement
may modify the method of making Partnership allocations or distributions, modify the method of
determining the Partnership Percentage of any Partner, reduce any Partner's Capital Account, increase
any Partner's Capital Commitment to the Partnership, modify any provision of this Agreement pertaining
to limitations on liability of the Limited Partners or change the restrictions contained in this paragraph
15.11(c), unless each Partner adversely affected thereby in a manner different than the other Partners has
expressly consented in writing to such amendment. In addition, the General Partner shall not cause or
consent to the amendment of paragraphs 8.4(b), 8.4(e), 14.21, 15.2, 15.3, 15.4 or this paragraph 15.11 of
this Agreement in a manner that would adversely affect a member of the Advisory Committee or a Thiel
Person without the express written consent of each such member of the Advisory Committee or Thiel
Person that would be adversely affected thereby.

(d) The Partnership's or General Partner's (or its managers', members' or
employees') noncompliance with any provision hereof in any single transaction or event may be waived
prospectively or retroactively in writing by the same Percentage in Interest of the Limited Partners that
would be required to amend such provision pursuant to paragraphs 15.11(a), (b) or (c). No waiver shall
be deemed a waiver of any subsequent event of noncompliance except to the extent expressly provided in
such waiver.

(e) The General Partner may, without the consent of the Limited Partners, amend
this Agreement, as the General Partner determines to be advisable to address the effects (or potential
effects) of legislation that has been enacted, or regulations (whether proposed, temporary or final) that
have been issued, in either case that change (or, in the General Partner's good faith determination propose
to change or alter) the tax consequences of the operation of paragraphs 4.3, 5.1, and 6.1 or any other
provision of this Agreement related to the satisfaction of the General Partner's Capital Commitment
through the waiver of management fees and related allocations and distributions, so long as any such
49.
147765658 v44
amendment does not result in any material adverse effect on any Limited Partner or delay the timing or
reduce the aggregate amount of distributions to which any Limited Partner is entitled under this
Agreement.

15.12 Entire Agreement. This Agreement (together with the representations and warranties of
each Limited Partner set forth in any Subscription Agreement executed by such Limited Partner) and any
Side Letter (as defined in this paragraph 15.12) constitute the full, complete and final agreement of the
Partners, and supersede all prior agreements between the Partners with respect to the Partnership.
Notwithstanding the provisions of this Agreement or any Subscription Agreement entered into by a
Limited Partner in connection with its admission to the Partnership, it is hereby acknowledged and agreed
that the Partnership and the General Partner, on its own behalf or on behalf of the Partnership or a Parallel
Fund, without the approval of any Limited Partners, may enter into a side letter or similar agreement to or
with a limited partner of the Partnership or a Parallel Fund (each a "Side Letter"), executed
contemporaneously with the admission of such limited partner to the Partnership or such Parallel Fund,
which has the effect of establishing rights with respect to the Partners or the Partnership or supplementing
the terms hereof or any Subscription Agreement in order to meet certain requirements of such Limited
Partner, including, without limitation, the Management Fee chargeable with respect to such Limited
Partner. The parties hereto agree that any terms contained in a Side Letter shall govern, for purposes of
this Agreement or any Subscription Agreement, and be valid, binding and enforceable as among the
Limited Partner that is a party thereto, the General Partner and/or the Partnership.
15.13 Titles; Subtitles. The titles and subtitles used in this Agreement are used for
convenience only and shall not be considered in the interpretation of this Agreement.
15.14 Partnership Name. The Partnership shall have the exclusive right to use the Partnership
name as long as the Partnership continues. Upon termination of the Partnership, the Partnership shall
assign whatever rights it may have in such name to the General Partner. No value shall be placed upon
the name or the goodwill attached to it for the purpose of determining the value of any Partner's Capital
Account or interest in the Partnership.
15.15 Confidentiality.

(a) This Agreement and all financial statements, tax reports, portfolio valuations,
reviews or analyses of potential or actual investments, reports or other materials and all other documents
and information concerning the affairs of the Partnership and its investments, including, without
limitation, information about the portfolio companies of the Partnership (collectively, the "Confidential
Information"), that any Limited Partner may receive or that may be disclosed, distributed or disseminated
(whether in writing, orally, electronically or by other means) to any Limited Partner or its representatives,
including Confidential Information disclosed to members of the Advisory Committee, pursuant to or in
accordance with this Agreement, or otherwise as a result of its ownership of an interest in the Partnership,
constitute proprietary and confidential information about the Partnership, the General Partner and its
Affiliates and the Partnership's portfolio companies (the "Affected Parties"). Each Limited Partner
acknowledges and agrees that the Affected Parties derive independent economic value from the
Confidential Information not being generally known and that the Confidential Information is the subject
of reasonable efforts to maintain its secrecy. Each Limited Partner further acknowledges and agrees that
the Confidential Information is a trade secret, the disclosure of which is likely to cause substantial and
irreparable competitive harm to the Affected Parties or their respective businesses.

(b) Each Limited Partner agrees to hold all Confidential Information in confidence,
and not to disclose any Confidential Information to any third party without the prior written consent of
the General Partner. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, each Limited Partner may disclose such
50.
147765658 v44
Confidential Information: (i) to its officers, directors, trustees, wholly -owned subsidiaries, employees and
outside experts (including but not limited to its attorneys and accountants) on a "need to know" basis, so
long as such persons are bound by the same duties of confidentiality to the Partnership as such Limited
Partner, and so long as such Limited Partner shall remain liable for any breach of this paragraph 15.15 by
such persons; (ii) to the extent that such information is required to be disclosed in connection with any
civil or criminal proceeding; (iii) to the extent that such information is required (as determined in good
faith by the disclosing Limited Partner after consultation with counsel) to be disclosed by applicable law
in connection with any governmental, administrative or regulatory proceeding or filing (including any
inspection or examination or any disclosure necessary in connection with a request for information made
under a state or federal freedom of information act or similar law), after reasonable prior written notice to
the General Partner (except where such notice is expressly prohibited by law); (iv) to the extent that such
information was received from a third party not subject to confidentiality limitations and such Limited
Partner can establish that it rightfully received such information from such party other than as a result of
the breach of this paragraph 15.15; (v) to the extent such information was rightfully in such Limited
Partner's possession prior to the Partnership's conveyance of such information to such Limited Partner, as
evidenced by the Limited Partner's prior written records; or (vi) to the extent that the information
provided by the Partnership is otherwise available in the public domain in the absence of any improper or
unlawful action on the part of such Partner. Any Limited Partner seeking to make disclosure in reliance
on the foregoing clauses (ii) and (iii) above shall use its best efforts to claim any relevant exception under
such laws or obligations which would prevent or limit public disclosure of the Confidential Information
and provide the General Partner immediate notice upon the Limited Partner's receipt of a request for
disclosure of any Confidential Information pursuant to such laws or obligations.

(c) Each Limited Partner also agrees that any document constituting or containing, or
any other embodiment of, any Confidential Information shall be returned to the Partnership upon the
General Partner's request. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary, the General
Partner may withhold disclosure of any Confidential Information (other than this Agreement or tax
reports) to any particular Limited Partner if the General Partner reasonably determines that the disclosure
of such Confidential Information to such Limited Partner may result in the general public gaining access
to such Confidential Information or that such disclosure is not in the best interests of the Partnership or its
investments; provided, however, that to the extent that any information is not delivered to a Limited
Partner based on the General Partner's exercise of its discretion under this sentence, such information
shall be made available for review, but not copying, during regular business hours at a location mutually
determined by the General Partner and such Limited Partner. In no event shall a Limited Partner be
denied access to information deliverable pursuant to paragraph 11.7 of this Agreement.

(d) With respect to each Limited Partner that is subject to any "freedom of
information," "sunshine" or other law, rule or regulation that imposes upon such Limited Partner an
obligation to make information available to the public, the Partnership hereby requests confidential
treatment of the Confidential Information, and such Limited Partner shall use commercially reasonable
efforts to take such action as necessary for such Confidential Information to be exempt from disclosure, to
the maximum extent permitted under such law, rule or regulation.

(e) With respect to each Limited Partner that is a "fund of funds" or a similar pooled
investment vehicle (but specifically excluding any pension, retirement or similar benefit plan) (a "Pooled
Vehicle Partner"), the Pooled Vehicle Partner shall, subject to paragraph 15.15(d), be permitted to make
disclosure to its direct equity owners (but not to any indirect or other beneficial owners), that are subject
to a written confidentiality agreement or obligation that provides a degree of protection to the Partnership
comparable to that provided in this paragraph 15.15, of solely the following Confidential Information: (i)
the Pooled Vehicle Partner's status as a Limited Partner of the Partnership, (ii) the amount of such Pooled
Vehicle Partner's Capital Commitment, (iii) the total amount of such Pooled Vehicle Partner's Capital
51.
147765658 44
Commitment that has been drawn down pursuant to capital calls, (iv) quarterly and annual reports
summarizing the status of the Pooled Vehicle Partner's investment in the Partnership (except that any
financial information regarding the Partnership and any information concerning any portfolio company in
which the Partnership has invested shall not be disclosed and must be redacted), and (v) the name and
address of the Partnership.
The General Partner agrees to hold the identity of each Limited Partner in
confidence if requested to do so by such Limited Partner, and not to disclose such identity to any third
party without the prior written consent of such Limited Partner; provided, however, that the General
Partner may disclose such identity (i) to its members, Affiliates, employees and outside experts (including
but not limited to its attorneys and accountants) so long as such persons have an obligation to maintain
such identity in confidence; (ii) to the extent that such information is required to be disclosed in
connection with any civil or criminal proceeding; (iii) to the extent that such information is required (as
determined in good faith by the General Partner) to be disclosed by applicable law in connection with any
governmental, administrative or regulatory proceeding or filing (including any inspection or examination
or any disclosure necessary in connection with a request for information made under a state or federal
freedom of information act or similar law); or (iv) to the extent that the information provided by the
Partnership is otherwise available in the public domain in the absence of any improper or unlawful action
on the part of such Partner.

(1) Each Limited Partner agrees to notify such Limited Partner's attorneys,
accountants and other similar advisers about their obligations in connection with this paragraph 15.15 and
will further cause such advisers to abide by the aforesaid provisions of this paragraph 15.15.
Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this paragraph 15.15, each Partner
(and each Affiliate and Person acting on behalf of any such Partner) agrees that each Partner (and its
attorneys, accountants and other similar advisers) may disclose to appropriate governmental authorities,
the tax treatment and tax structure of the formation and operation of the Partnership and materials
(including opinions or other tax analyses) that are provided to such Partner relating to such tax treatment
and tax structure. This authorization is not intended to permit and does not authorize the disclosure of
any of the following Confidential Information or other information relating to the Partnership: (i) any
information not related to the tax treatment or tax structure of the formation or operation of the
Partnership, (ii) the identities of Partners or potential investors in the Partnership, (iii) the identities of any
portfolio companies or potential portfolio companies of the Partnership or a Prior Fund, (iv) the existence
or status of any negotiations to which the Partnership or its Affiliate is a party, (v) any pricing or financial
information (except to the extent such pricing or financial information is related to the tax treatment or tax
structure of the formation or operation of the Partnership), or (vi) any other term or detail not relevant to
the tax treatment or the tax structure of the Partnership.
[Remainder of page intentionally left blank.]
52.
147765658 v44
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Partners have executed this Amended and Restated Limited
Partnership Agreement as of the date first written above.
GENERAL PARTNER:
I
I
I
VALAR VENTURES GP REV LLC
By:
James Fitzgerald, Managing Member
LIMITED PARTNER:
VALAR VENTURES GP !HIV LLC
as attorney -in-fact, for and on behalf of each Limited Partner
By:
James Fitzgerald, Managing Member
"THE SECURITIES EVIDENCED BY THIS PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT HAVE NOT BEEN
REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED (THE "1933 ACT"), AND
MAY NOT BE SOLD, TRANSFERRED, ASSIGNED OR HYPOTHECATED UNLESS THERE IS AN
EFFECTIVE REGISTRATION STATEMENT UNDER THE 1933 ACT COVERING SUCH
SECURITIES OR THE GENERAL PARTNER RECEIVES AN OPINION OF COUNSEL FOR THE
HOLDER OF THESE SECURITIES REASONABLY SATISFACTORY TO THE GENERAL
PARTNER, STATING THAT SUCH SALE, TRANSFER, ASSIGNMENT OR HYPOTHECATION IS
EXEMPT FROM THE REGISTRATION AND PROSPECTUS DELIVERY REQUIREMENTS OF
THE 1933 ACT."
VALAR GLOBAL FUND HIP/ LP
SIGNATURE PAGE TO AMENDED AND RESTATED LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
I 44776-54-58-4
EXHIBIT A-1
I 147765658 v44
EFTA00810285 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
Schedule K-1
(Form 1065)
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service
M18
For calendar year 2018, a tax year
beginning   along
Partner's Share of Income, Deductions,
Credits, etc. ► See back of form and separate Instructions.
■ Part III
El Amended K-1
OMB No. 1545.0123
Partner's Share of Current Year Income,
Deductions. Credits and Other items
1 Ordinary business income (loss) 15 Credits
2 Net rental real estate income (ass)
3 Other net rental mono (loss) 16 Foreign transactions
Part I Information About the Partnership
A Partnership's employer identification number
Guaranteed payments
B Partneshp's name. address. dry. state. and 2IP code
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
915 BROADWAY, SUITE 1101
NEW YORK, NY 10010
C IRS Center where partnership Ned return
EFI LE
O 1- 1 Check if this Is a publicly traded pannershp (PTP)
5 Interest income
4,431.
Sa Ordinary divdends
6b Qualified dividends
6c Dividend equivalents
7 Royalties
Part II Information About the Partner
S Net short-term capital gain (loss)
E Partners identifying number 14
F Partners name, address. ply. state. and 2IP code
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, B3

ST. THOMAS, VI 00802
G Lj General partner or LLC
member-manager
• Domestic partner
It What type of entity is the partner?
12 If this partner is a retirement plan (IRASEPiKeogIVetc.). check here
Partners share of profit loss. and capital (see instructions):
Beginning Ening
Profs 21.050907 % 21.052781
Loss 21.050907 21.052781
Capital 21.030678 21.050678
usi Umited partner«. other LLC
member
Foreign partner
S CORPORATION
K Partners snare of liabilities:
Beginning
Non recourse
enumailipmeg nonrecourses
Recourse
$
$
$
Ending
o
9a
*
Net long-term capital gain (loss)
-1,434,504.
9b Collectibles (28%) gain (loss)
17 Nieman* minimum UM (AMT) Items
9c Unrecaptured section 1250 gain
10 Net section 1231 gain (loss)
18 Tax-exempt Income and
nondeductible expenses
11 Other income (loss)
19 Distributions
12 Section 179 deduction
13 Other deductions
W* STMT A
B
10 Selt'employment earnings (loss)
L Partners capital account analysis:
Beginning capital account   13,194,855.
Capital contributed during the year   $  300,000 .
Current year increase (decrease) $  —1, 844, 658.
Withdrawals 8 distributions . . .   $ (
Ending tetanal account   11,650,197.
Tax basis ❑ GAAP DI Section 700(0) book
Other (explain)
IA Did the partner contnbute property with a built-in gain or loss?

EN. Eyes
Other information
4 431.
414,585.
'See attached statement for additional information.
For IRS Use Only
If "Yes.' attach statement (see instructions)
For Paperwork Reduction Act Notice, see Instructions for Form 1065.
SA
$P1200 1.000
4638KC 700W
wvntir .gov/Formt065 Schedule K-1 (Form 10602018
Schedule K. (Form 1065) 2018 PARTNER # 14 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC. Page 2
This list Identifies the codes used on Schedule K-1 for all partners and provides summarized reporting information for 
partners who file Form 1000.
For detailed reporting and filing Information, see the separate Partners Instructions for Schedule K-1 and the 
Instructions for your Income tax return.

1. Ordinary business Income (loss). Determine witether the income (loss) is Cado Report on
passive or nonpassive and enter on your return as lams. J Work opportunity credit
Report on K Disabled access credit
Passive loss See the Partners Instructions
Passive income Schedule E. Me 28. column (h)
Nonpassive loss See the Partners Instructions
L Empowerment zone
employment credit
IA Credit la increasing research activities See the Partners Instructions
Nonpassrve income Schedule E. Me 28. column (k)

2. Net rental real estate Income (loss) See the Partners Instructions
N Credit la employer social
secunty and Medicare taxes

3. Other net rental Income (loss) O Backup withhdding
Net income Schedule E. Me 28. column (h)
Net loss See the Partners Instructions
P Other crews

16. Foreign transactions
0. Guaranteed payments Schedule E. Me 28. column (k)
5. Interest Income Form 1040. Ine2b
A Name of country or U.S.
possession Form 1116. Pan I
6a. Ordinary dividends Form 1040. Ine3b B Gross income from all sources
6b. Oualifled dividends Form 1040. line 3a C Gross Income sourced al puma lapel
6c. Dividend equivalents See the Partners Instructions Foreign gross income sourced et peRnersh0 level

7. Royalties Schedule E. line 4 O Section 951A category
8. Net short-term capital gain (loss) Schedule D. line 5 E Foreign branch category Form 1116. Pan I
9a. Net long-term capital gain (loss) Schedule D. line 12 F Passive category
9b. Collectibles (28%) gain (loss) 28% RateGan Worksheet. line 4 O General category
(Schedule D instructions) H Other
9c. Unrecaptured section 1250 gain See the Partners Instructions Deductions allocated and apportioned at partner level

10. Net section 1231 gain (loss) See the Partners Instructions I Interest expense Form 1116. Pan I
11. Other Income (loss) J Other Form 1116. Pat I
Code Deductions allocated and apportioned et partnersh#3 level to foreign source
income A Other portfolio income (loss) See the Partners Instructions
B Involuntary conversions See the Partners Instructions
C Sec. 1256 contracts 8 straddles Form 6781. line 1
K Section 951A category
L Foreign branch category
O Mining exploration costs recapture See Pit 535 PA PassMs category Form 1116. Pat I
E Cancellation ol debt Schedule 1 (Form 1000). line 21 or N General category
Form 982 O Other
F Section 951A income Other in f oation
O Section 965(a) leCluSKal P Total foreign taxes paid Form 1116. Pan II
H Subpart F income ether than See the Partners Instructions 0 Total foreign taxes accrued Form 1116. Pan II
sections 951A and 965 inclusion R Reduction in taxes available for craft Form 1116. line 12
I Other ncome (less) S Foreign trading gross receipts Form 8873 12. Section 179 deduction See the Partner's Instructions
T Extraterritorial ncome exclusion Form
13. Other deductions U Section 951A(c)(1)(A) tested income
A Cash contnbutions (60%)
B Cash contnbutions (30%)
V Tested foreign income tax See the Partners Instrucbons W Section 965 information
C Noncash contnbutions (50%) X Other foreign transactions
0 Noncash contnbutions (30%) See the Partners 17. Alternative minimum tax (AMT) hems
E Capital gain property to a 50% Instructions A Post-1986 deprecation adjustment
organization (30%) 8 Adjusted gain or loss See the Partners
F Capital gain property (20%) C Depletion (other than oil 8 gas) Instructions and
0 Contributions (100%) D Oct. gas. 8 geothermal gross income the Instructions tar
H Investment Interest expense Form 4952. line E Oil. gas. 8 geothermal - deductions Form 6251
I Deductions royally income Schedule E. line 19 F Other AMT tams
J Section 59(0(2) expenditures See the Partners Instructions 18. Tax-exempt Income and nondeductible e pauses
K Excess business nterest expense See the Partners Instructions A Tax-exempt interest income Form 1040. Me 2a
L Deductions portfolio (other) Schedule A. Me 16 B Other tax-exempt ncome See the Partners Instrucbons
IA Amounts paid to medical insurance Schedule A. line 1 or Schedule C Nondeductible expenses See the Partners 
Instrucbons
(Form 1040). Ire 29 19. Distributions
N Educational assistance benefits See the Partners Instructions A Cash and marketable securities
O Dependent care benefits Form 2441. line 12 B Distribution subject to section 737 See the Partner's Instructions
P Preproductive period expenses See the Partners Instructions C Other property
0 Commercial revitalization deduction 20. Other Information
from rental real estate ettnnies See Form 8582 instructions A Investment income Form 4952. Me 0a
R Pensions and IRAs See the Partners Instructions B Investment expenses Form 4952. Me 5
S Reforestation expense deduction See the Partners Instructions C Fuel tax credit information Form 4136
T through V Reserved for future use D Qualified rehabilitation expenditures See the Partners Instructions
W Other deductions See the Partner's Instructions (other than rental real estate)
X Section 965(c) deduction E Basis ol energy property See the Partners Instructions

10. Sell-employment earnings (loss) F Recapture of low-income housing Form 8611. Me 8
credit (section 420)(5))
Note: If you have a section 179 deduction or any partner-level deductions. see the 0 Recapture of low-income housing 
Form 8611. Me 8
Partners Instructions before completing Schedule SE. credit (other)
A Net earrings (loss) from H Recapture of investment credit See Form 4255
sell-employment Schedule SE. Seaton A or B I Recapture of other creeks See the Partners Instructions
B Gross farming or fishing income See the Partners Instructions J Look-track interest completed See Form 8697
C Gross non-farm income See the Partners Instructions long-term contracts
15. Credits
A Low-income housing credit (section
K Look-back interest - Income forecast See Form 8866
method
420)(5)) from pre-2008 buildings
B Low-income housing credit
(other) from pre-2008 buildings
L Dispositions of property with
section 179 deductions
PA Recapture of section 179 deduction
C Low-Income housing credit (section N Interest expense for corporate
partners 020)(6)) from post-2007 buildings
O Low-Income housing credit (other)
from post-2007 butdngs
E Qualified rehabilitation
expenditures (rental real estate)
See the Partners Instructions 0 through Y
2 Section 199A income
AA Section 199A W-2 wages
AB Section 199A unadanted basis
AC Section 199A REIT dividends
See the Partners
Instructions
F Other rental real estate cream AD Section 199A PTP income
O Other rental credits PE Excess taxable income H Undistnbuted capital gains credit Schedule 5 (Form 1040), line 74. box
a AF Excess business interest income
I Biofuel producer credit See the Partners Instructions JSA
8PI303 1.000
AO Gross receipts for section 59A(e)
AH Other information
4638KC 700W
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER # 14 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
ITEM L - CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS
CASH CONTRIBUTIONS 300,000.
TOTAL CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS 300,000.
LINE 9 - NET LONG-TERM CAPITAL GAIN(LOSS)
LINE 9B
28% GAIN(LOSS)
LINE 9A
TOTAL
FROM PORTFOLIO ACTIVITIES -1,434,504.
TOTAL NET LONG-TERM CAPITAL GAIN(LOSS) -1,434,504.
LINE 13 - OTHER DEDUCTIONS
W OTHER DEDUCTIONS
OTHER DEDUCTIONS INCLUDED IN ITEM L, CURRENT YEAR INCREASE (DECREASE)
MANAGEMENT FEES 367,717.
PORTFOLIO DEDUCTIONS - OTHER 46,868.
TOTAL BOX W
PARTNER FOOTNOTES ASSOCIATED W/SCH. K-1, LINE 20
INFORMATION FOR FORM 8886, REPORTABLE TRANSACTION
DISCLOSURE STATEMENT:
IN THE NORMAL COURSE OF INVESTMENT ACTIVITY, THE
PARTNERSHIP SOLD ITS INVESTMENT IN OPPA, LTD A
IRC SECTION 165 LOSS. PARTNERSHIPS ARE REQUIRED TO
FILE FORM 8886, REPORTABLE TRANSACTION DISCLOSURE
STATEMENT, IN TRANSACTIONS WHICH IRC SECTION 165
LOSSES EXCEED $2 MILLION. ALTHOUGH THE PARTNERSHIP
DID NOT MEET THIS THRESHOLD, AS DEFINED IN
TREAS. REG. SECTION 1.6011-4(B) (5) (I) (C), WE ARE
PROVIDING YOUR ALLOCABLE SHARE OF THIS IRC SECTION
165 LOSS. YOU MAY HAVE ADDITIONAL LOSS ALLOCATED
FROM RELATED VALAR ENTITIES AS PART OF THE SAME
TRANSACTION. PER TREAS. REG. SECTION 1.6011-4(B)
(5)(I) (A)-(D), PARTNERS OTHER THAN CORPORATIONS
GENERALLY ARE REQUIRED TO FILE FORM 8886,
REPORTABLE TRANSACTION DISCLOSURE STATEMENT, FOR
ANY IRC SECTION 165 LOSS OF AT LEAST $2 MILLION IN
ANY SINGLE TAXABLE YEAR. PLEASE CONSULT YOUR TAX
ADVISIOR IN DETERMINING WHETHER YOU ARE REQUIRED
TO FILE FORM 8886. INFORMATION FOR FORM 8886 IS
AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST.
YOUR ALLOCABLE SHARE OF THE ABOVE IRC SECTION 165
LOSS FROM THE PARTNERSHIP IS:
414,585.
-403,870.
SP9OCO 1.000
4638KC 700W
STATEMENT 1
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER II 14 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES
LINE 13W -OTHER DEDUCTIONS:
THESE EXPENSES ARE PORTFOLIO DEDUCTIONS FORMERLY REPORTED ON BOX 13K
AS 2% PORTFOLIO DEDUCTIONS THAT ARE NON-DEDUCTIBLE FOR CERTAIN
TAXPAYERS, INCLUDING INDIVIDUALS, AND WOULD REDUCE YOUR TAX BASIS IN
THE PARTNERSHIP. PLEASE CONSULT YOUR TAX ADVISOR.
ITEM L:
YOU SHOULD CONSULT YOUR TAX ADVISOR TO DETERMINE YOUR TAX BASIS IN
YOUR PARTNERSHIP INTEREST. YOU SHOULD DETERMINE WHETHER LOSSES OR
EXPENSES APPEARING ON YOUR K-1 ARE SUBJECT TO SUSPENSION AND WHETHER
THERE ARE OTHER LIMITATIONS OR ISSUES THAT MAY ARISE BY VIRTUE OF
YOUR TAX BASIS IN YOUR PARTNERSHIP INTEREST OR FOR OTHER REASONS.
CAPITAL ACCOUNT RECONCILIATION:
THE PARTNERSHIP MAINTAINS CAPITAL ACCOUNT IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION
704(B) AND REPORTS THESE BALANCES ON SCHEDULE K-1. FOR FINANCIAL
PURPOSES, THE PARTNERSHIP MAINTAINS CAPITAL ACCOUNTS IN ACCORDANCE
WITH GENERALLY ACCEPTED ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES (GAAP) .
UBTI FOOTNOTE:
TAX-EXEMPT PARTNERS ARE ADVISED THAT THE PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REPORTING
UNRELATED BUSINESS TAXABLE INCOME ("UBTI") DURING THE 2018 TAXABLE
YEAR BASED ON INFORMATION AVAILABLE TO THE PARTNERSHIP.
EFFECTIVELY CONNECTED INCOME (ECI) :
THE PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REPORTING EFFECTIVELY CONNECTED INCOME ("ECI")
DURING THE 2018 TAXABLE YEAR BASED ON INFORMATION AVAILABLE TO THE
PARTNERSHIP.
ITEM J:
PARTNER PERCENTAGES REFLECTED IN ITEM J ARE CALCULATED PURSUANT TO
IRS INSTRUCTIONS, AND MAY VARY FROM PERCENTAGES UNDER THE PARTNERSHIP
AGREEMENT.
SECTION 199A AND SECTION 163(J) :
THIS PARTNERSHIP IS NOT ENGAGED IN A TRADE OR BUSINESS AS DEFINED
UNDER I.R.C. SEC. 162. ADDITIONALLY, THIS PARTNERSHIP IS NOT INVESTED
IN A FLOW -THROUGH ENTITY WITH ITEMS NECESSARY FOR ITS PARTNER'S
CALCULATION OF EITHER SEC. 199A OR SEC. 163(J) . THEREFORE, SEC. 199A
IS NOT APPLICABLE. THE PARTNERSHIP DOES NOT HAVE ANY INTEREST EXPENSE
ALLOCABLE TO A TRADE OR BUSINESS, THUS IT IS NOT SUBJECT TO INTEREST
EXPENSE LIMITATIONS UNDERS SEC. 163(J). PLEASE CONSULT YOUR TAX
ADVISOR.
CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE STATEMENT 2
$P9003 1.003
4638KC 700W
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER II 14 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES (CONT'D)
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES
FORM 8621 INFORMATION
IF APPLICABLE, VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP HAS MADE TIMELY QUALIFIED
ELECTING FUND ("QEF") ELECTION(S) WITH RESPECT TO ITS INVESTMENTS IN
UNDERLYING PASSIVE FOREIGN INVESTMENT COMPANIES ("PFIC"), EFFECTIVE
FOR EACH YEAR OF OWNERSHIP, AND HAS FILED THE REQUIRED FORMS 8621 FOR
ALL YEARS OF OWNERSHIP.
THE DIRECT US SHAREHOLDER THAT HAS MADE A QEF ELECTION FOR A PFIC IS
REQUIRED TO INCLUDE INCOME CURRENTLY UNDER IRC SECTION 1293, AND TO
FILE FORM 8621. AS A PARTNER THAT HAS INVESTED IN A US PARTNERSHIP
THAT HAS MADE THE QEF ELECTION AND FILED FORM 8621 (IF APPLICABLE),
YOUR ALLOCABLE SHARE OF THIS INCOME IS NOT REQUIRED TO BE FURTHER
REPORTED ON AN ADDITIONAL FORM 8621. THE SERVICE HAS REVISED THE
INSTRUCTIONS FOR FORM 8621 TO FORMALLY CLARIFY THAT NO ADDITIONAL
FORM 8621 REPORTING IS NECESSARY UNDER THESE FACTS. PLEASE CONSULT
YOUR TAX ADVISOR.
DETRUN
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES
FORM 8938 INFORMATION
IN 2018, INDIVIDUALS AND CERTAIN DOMESTIC ENTITIES ARE REQUIRED TO
REPORT THEIR DIRECT OR INDIRECT INVESTMENTS ON FORM 8938 IF A CERTAIN
THRESHOLD IS MET. IF YOUR INTERESTS IN THE BELOW FOREIGN ENTITIES ARE
ONLY THROUGH YOUR OWNERSHIP IN VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP, YOU DO NOT
NEED TO INCLUDE THESE ENTITIES ON FORM 8938. HOWEVER, IF YOU HAVE ANY
OTHER DIRECT OR INDIRECT INVESTMENTS IN THE FOREIGN ENTITIES NOTED
BELOW, PLEASE CONSULT YOUR TAX ADVISOR TO DETERMINE YOUR FILING
REQUIREMENTS. THE VALUE PROVIDED REPRESENTS THE VALUE OF THE ASSETS
HELD BY VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP. YOU MUST DETERMINE YOUR PRO RATA
SHARE ACCORDINGLY.
BREATHER PRODUCTS INC.
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET: STOCK
FEIN: FOREIGNUS
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR: NO
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR: NO
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR: $28,746,321
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY: CORPORATION
MAILING ADDRESS: 5605 AVENUE DE GASPE,
SUITE 610
MONTREAL, QC, H2T 2A4
CANADA
EDEN, LTD. (AKA DINDA)
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET: PARTNERSHIP INTEREST
FEIN: FOREIGNUS
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR: NO
CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE STATEMENT 3
IIP9OCO 1.000
4638KC 700W
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER II 14 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES (CONT'D)
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
EDEN, LTD. (AKA DINDA)
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
EYE EM LIMITED
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
GRANIFY INC.
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
GRANIFY INC.
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
NO
$704,361
PARTNERSHIP
C/O CAMPBELL CORPORATE
SVC LTD
SCOTIA CENTRE, P.O. BOX 268
GRAND CAYMAN CJ KY1-1104
CAYMAN ISLANDS
CONVERTIBLE NOTE
FOREIGNUS
NO
NO
$195,103
PARTNERSHIP
C/O CAMPBELL CORPORATE
SVC LTD
SCOTIA CENTRE, P.O. BOX 268
GRAND CAYMAN CJ KY1-1104
CAYMAN ISLANDS
STOCK
FOREIGNUS
NO
YES 4/9/2018
$173,819
CORPORATION
69 GREAT HAMPTON STREET,
BIRMINGHAM, B18 6EW UK
STOCK
FOREIGNUS
NO
NO
$3,782,163
CORPORATION
10130-103 ST NW,
SUITE 2100,
EDMONTON, ALBERTA,
T5J 3N9 CANADA
CONVERTIBLE NOTE
FOREIGNUS
NO
NO
$489,600
CORPORATION
10130-103 ST NW,
SUITE 2100,
EDMONTON, ALBERTA,
9P9000 1.000
4638KC 700W
CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE STATEMENT 4
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER II 14 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES (CONT'D)
N26 GMBH
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
OPPA, LTD.
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
OPPA, LTD.
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
VEND LIMITED
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
DEPOSIT SOLUTIONS GMBH
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
T5J 3N9 CANADA
STOCK
FOREIGNUS
NO
NO
$165,487,274
CORPORATION
KLOSTERSTRABE 62
10179 BERLIN,
GERMANY
PARTNERSHIP INTEREST
98-1022690
NO
YES 2/8/2018
$3
PARTNERSHIP
C/O CAMPBELL CORPORATE
SVC LTD
SCOTIA CENTRE, P.O. BOX 268
GRAND CAYMAN CJ KY1-1104
CAYMAN ISLANDS
CONVERTIBLE NOTE
98-1022690
NO
YES 2/8/2018
$1
PARTNERSHIP
C/O CAMPBELL CORPORATE
SVC LTD
SCOTIA CENTRE, P.O. BOX 268
GRAND CAYMAN CJ KY1-1104
CAYMAN ISLANDS
STOCK
FOREIGNUS
NO
NO
$1,702,344
CORPORATION
2 NUFFIELD ST
NEWMARKET,
AUCKLAND 1023
NEW ZEALAND
STOCK
FOREIGNUS
SP9003 1.000
4638KC 700W
CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE STATEMENT 5
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER 11 14 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES (CONT'D)
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
NO
YES 10/3/2018
$3,416,589
CORPORATION
ZIRKUSWEG 1,
20359 HAMBURG,
GERMANY
FORM 5471 INFORMATION
DURING 2018, VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP ("THE FUND") INDIRECTLY DISPOSED
OF STOCK IN A CONTROLLED FOREIGN CORPORATION ("CFC") AND CEASED TO BE
A 10% U.S. SHAREHOLDER.
THE FUND WILL FILE FORM 5471 "INFORMATION RETURN OF U.S. PERSONS WITH
RESPECT TO CERTAIN FOREIGN CORPORATIONS" TO FULFILL ITS FILING
RESPONSIBILITY.
PLEASE CONSULT YOUR TAX ADVISOR TO DETERMINE YOUR FILING REQUIREMENT
WITH REGARD TO THIS FOREIGN CORPORATION. A COPY OF EACH FILING IS
AVAILABLE UPON YOUR REQUEST.
FOREIGN CORPORATION
MAILING ADDRESS
OPPA DESIGN LTDA.
RUA ASPICUELTA,
153-PINHEIROS
SAO PAULO, SP 05433-010
BRAZIL
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP'S INTEREST
BEGINNING
ENDING
25.307%
0.000%
FORM 5471 INFORMATION
DURING 2018, VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP ("THE FUND") WAS A 10% US
SHAREHOLDER OF A FOREIGN CORPORATION, BREATHER PRODUCTS INC.
AS A RESULT OF TAX LAW CHANGES BROUGHT ABOUT BY THE TAX CUTS AND JOBS
ACT OF 2017, CERTAIN FOREIGN SUBSIDIARIES OF BREATHER PRODUCTS INC.
("THE ENTITIES") MAY POTENTIALLY BE CONSIDERED TO BE CONTROLLED
FOREIGN CORPORATIONS ("CFCS"), RESULTING IN A 5471 FILING
REQUIREMENT. IF APPLICABLE, THE FUND WILL FILE FORM 5471 "INFORMATION
RETURN OF U.S. PERSONS WITH RESPECT TO CERTAIN FOREIGN CORPORATIONS"
TO FULFILL ITS FILING RESPONSIBILITY.
HOWEVER, BASED ON AVAILABLE INFORMATION AS OF THE DATE OF THIS K-1,
THE FUND IS NOT ABLE TO MAKE A DEFINITIVE DETERMINATION AS TO WHETHER
OR NOT THE ENTITIES HAVE CFC STATUS.
PLEASE CONTACT THE FUND IF YOU BELIEVE THAT A 5471 FILING REQUIREMENT
MAY APPLY TO YOU IF THE ENTITIES ARE CONSIDERED TO BE CFCS.
sP9000 1.000
4638KC 700W
CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE STATEMENT 6
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER # 14 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES (CONT'D)
FOREIGN CORPORATION
MAILING ADDRESS
BREATHER PRODUCTS UK LIMITED
HILL HOUSE, 1 LITTLE NEW STREET
LONDON, UK EC4A 3TR
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP'S INTEREST:
BEGINNING 12.8295%
899003 I 003
4638KC 700W
STATEMENT 7
NEW
YORK
STATE
Department of Taxalion and Finance
New York Corporate Partner's
Schedule K-1 Tax Lay/ - Article 9-A
For calendar year 2018 or tax year beginning 181 and ending
IT-204-CP
Final K-1
Amended K-1
Partners: Before completing your franchise tax return, see Form IT-204-CP-I. Partner's Instructions for Form IT-204-CP 
(available al wmv.tax.ny.gov).
Partnership's Information
Partnership's name (as shown on Form IT-204)
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
A Mark an X in the box if either applies to your entity El Publicly traded partnership
Partnership's EIN
a Portfolio investment partnership
B Tax shelter registration number, if any
Partner's Information (see instructions)
Partner's name
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
Partners address
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, B3
City

ST. THOMAS
C
D
The is a X Q Gene LLC Limited partner or other LLC member partner fiWkail OMB vows* boil al partner or member-manager
What is the New York tax filing status of the partner? Mark an X in the appropriate box. It known )
0 C corporation S corporation 0 Partnership
E If the partner is a disregarded entity, enter the EIN of the entity reporting the income of
the partner (it known)
F Did the partner sell its entire interest during the tax year? F Yes O  No El
O Partner's share of profit, loss, and capital BeglnNng Ending

1) Profit G1 210509 % 21.0527 %
2) Loss  G2 21.0509 % 21.0527 %
3) Capital G3 21.0306 % 21.0506 cleg
H Partner's share of liabilities at the end of the year

1) Nonrecourse  H1
2) Qualified nonrecourse financing  H2
3) Recourse  H3
State
VI
ZIP code
Partners EIN
I Partner's capital account analysis

1) Beginning capital account   It
2) Capital contributed during the year - cash  12
3) Capital contributed during the year - property  13

4) Current year increase (decrease)  14
5) Withdrawals and distributions - cash  15
6) Withdrawals and distributions - property  16

7) Ending capital account   17
8) Method of accounting (mark an X in the appropriate box)
El Tax basis El GAAP El Book El Other (subnul explanation)
-1844658
SEE STATEMENT 1
4638KC 700W
8Q35020
Page 2 of 11 IT-204-CP (2018) 100502 1.000
J Was Form CT-2658-E filed with the partnership?  J Yes ❑ No
K NYS estimated tax paid on behalf of partner (from Form CT-2658) Date Amount
1) First installment K1
2) Second installment  K2
3) Third installment  K3
4) Fourth installment  K4
Total NYS estimated tax paid on behalf of partner (add Ones K1 through K4)
L Was the partnership required to report any nonqualified deferred compensation, as required by
IRC § 457A, on its 2018 federal return? (see instructions)  L Yes ❑ Not  X
Partner's share of entire net income (ENI) information when the corporate partner's New York tax filing
status is a C corporation
ENI addition modifications
1 Total additions
A - Number 8- Amount A- Number 8- Amount
la EA- Id a -
lb EA - le EA -
lc EA - If EA -
ENI subtraction modifications
2 Total subtractions
A - Number 8- Amount A- Number 8 - Amount
2a ES- 2d ES-
2b ES- 2e ES-
2c ES- 2f ES-
Partner's proportionate part of assets and liabilities (for New York C corporate partners only)
Average value
3 Total assets 3
4 Real property and marketable securities included on line 3  4
5 Real property and marketable securities at fair market value (NOV)  5
6 Average value of adjusted total assets  6
7 Total liabilities  7
8 Liabilities directly attributable to business capital  8
9 Liabilities directly attributable to investment capital  9
II III 4638KC 700W
6°8408030
IT-204-CP (2018) Page 3 of 11
Partner's proportionate pad of items related to investment capital under Article 9-A (for New York
C corporate partners only)
Part 1 - Investment capital that generates income claimed not taxable by New York under the U.S. Constitution
Description of asset (identity each asset, and enter number of shares (if applicable) and date acquired here: for each 
asset complete columns
through G on the corresponding lines below: enter only directly owned assets in items A through F and Total from 
additional sheet(s))
For each item listed, in columns A through G, enter the information for the partnership as a whole.
Item A- Description of asset B- Number of shares
acquired, if appicable
C- Date acquired
A
B
C
D
E
F
Item D
Number of
shares sold, if applicable
E
Date sold
F
Average
FMV
G
Liabilities directly
attributable
H
Net average
FMV
A
B
C
D
E
F
Total from additional sheet(s)
Total from partnerships
10 Total proportionate part of columns F
and G (see instructions) 10
Part 2 - Investment capital - stocks actually held more than one year
Description of investment (identify each investment. and enter number of shares and date acquired here: for each 
investment complete columns D
through G on the corresponding lines below: enter only directly owned investments in items A through F and Total from 
additional sheet(s))
For each item listed, in columns A through G, enter the information for the partnership as a whole.
Item A- Name/CUSIP/CIN$Aot number B- Number of shares
acquired
C- Date acquired
A
B
C
D
E
F
Item D
Number of
shares sold
E
Date sold
F
Average
FMV
G
Liabilities directly
attributable
H
Net average
FMV
A
B
C
D
E
F
Total from additional sheet(s)
Total from partnerships
11 Total proportionate part of columns F
and G (see instructions) 11
III IIII III 'l I l 1 4638KC 700W
Page 4 of 11 IT-204-CP (2018)
8Q35040
8O35Oa 1.000
Part 3 - Investment capital - stocks presumed held more than one year
Description of investment (identify each investment. and enter number of shares and date acquired here: for each 
investment complete columns F
and G on the corresponding lines below: enter only director owned investments in items A through F and Total from 
additional sheet(s))
For each item listed, in columns A through G, enter the information for the partnership as a whole.
Item A- Name/CUSINCINS/lot number B- Number of shares acquired C- Date acquired
A
B
C
D
E
F
Item D
Number of
shares sold
E
Date sold
F
Average
FMV
G
Liabilities directly
attributable
H
Net average
FMV
A
B
C
D
E
F
Total from additional sheet(s)
Total from partnerships
12 Total proportionate part of columns F
and G (see instructions) 12
Part 4 - Total investment capital
13 Total average FMV and liabilities directly attributable
(add lines TO, I I. am:112h columns Fend 0) . . . 13
Part 5 - Prior year investment capital - stocks that d d not meet holding period requirement
Description of investment (identity each investment. and enter number of shares and date acquired here: for each 
investment complete columns D
through G on the corresponding tines below: enter only directly owned investments in items A through F and Total from 
additional sheet(s))
For each item listed, in columns A through G, enter the information for the partnership as a whole.
Item A - Name/CUSINCINSnot number 8 - Number ol shares acquired C - Date acquired
A
B
C
D
E
F
Item D
Number of
shares sold
E
Date sold
F
Average FMV
as previously reported
G
Liabili es directly attributable
as previously reported
H
Net average
FMV
A
B
C
D
E
F
Total from additional sheet(s)
Total from partnerships
14 Total proportionate part of columns F
and G (see instructions) 14 _i_
117004183065 III III III i 4 63 8KC 700W
sottiaBi5dat50
IT-204-CP (2018) Page 5 of 11
Part 6 - Prior year gross Investment Income for stocks that did not meet holding period requirement
15 Prior year presumed gross investment income from stocks presumed in the prior year to
be held more than one year that failed to meet the presumption (see inseuctions) 15
Partner's share of items related to investment and other exempt income under Article 9-A (for New York
C corporate partners only)
16 Gross exempt cross-article dividends
17 Gross exempt controlled foreign corporation (CFC) income
18 Gross exempt unitary corporation dividends
19 Gross investment income from investments generating income not taxable by New York
State under the U.S. Constitution
20 Dividend income from investment capital from stocks actually held more than one year
21 Net capital gains or losses from investment capital from stocks actually held more
than one year
22 Dividend income from investment capital from stocks presumed held more than one year
Partner's share of items related to interest deductions directly attributable to investment and other
exempt income under Article 9-A (for New York C corporate partners only)
23 Interest expense per federal Form 1065, line 15
24 Interest deductions directly attributable to income reported on line 16
25 Interest deductions directly attributable to income reported on line 17
26 Interest deductions directly attributable to income reported on line 18
27 Interest deductions directly attributable to income reported on line 19
28 Interest deductions directly attributable to income reported on line 20
29 Interest deductions directly attributable to income reported on line 21
30 Interest deductions directly attributable to income reported on line 22
31 Interest deductions directly attributable to business capital
28,
29,
Partner's share and proportionate part of items related to subtraction modification for qualified banks
32 Qualified residential loan portfolio assets
33 Gross interest income from qualifying loans
33a Gross interest income from all loans
33b Gross interest expense from aU loans
3b
Partner's share and proportionate part of items related to manufacturing
34 Total receipts from the sale of goods by manufacturing
34a Receipts received from the generation and distribution of electricity, the distribution of natural
gas, and the production of steam associated with the generation of electricity
35 Adjusted basis of qualified manufacturing property
35a Number of employees employed in manufacturing in New York
34a
35a
4638KC 700W
Page 6 of 11 IT-204-CP (2018) 103506 1.000
Partner's share of New York modifications (for New York S corporate partners only)
36 New York State additions
Number A— Total amount
36a EA-
36b EA-
36c EA-
36d EA -
36e E A-
36f EA -
37 Total addition modifications (total of column A. lines 36a through 360  37
36 New York State subtractions
Number A - Total amount
38a E S -
38b E S -
36c E S -
38d E S -
38e E S -
38f E S -
39 Total subtraction modifications (total of column A. lines 38a through 380  39
40 Additions to itemized deductions
Letter Amount
40a
40b
40c
40d
40e
40f
41 Total additions to itemized deductions (add lines 40a through 400  41
42 Subtractions from itemized deductions
Letter Amount
42a
42b
42c
42d
42e
42f
43 Total subtractions from itemized deductions (add lines 42a through 420  431
III III II 111111 4 63 8KC 700W
8O3550 1.000
IT-204-CP (2018) Page 7 of 11
Partner's share of income, deductions, etc. (from federal Form 1065, Schedule K-1)
Partner's distributive share items
45 N
48 I
50 R
51 N
52 N
53 N
55 S
57 T
58 D
59 D
Ordinary business income (loss)  44
et rental real estate income (loss)   45
Other net rental income (loss)   46
uaranteed payments   47
merest income  48 4431
Ordinary dividends  49
oyalties   _50
et short-term capital gain (loss)  _5J
et long-term capital gain (loss)   _52 -14 34 504
et section 1231 gain (loss)  _53
Other income (loss)  54
Identify:
action 179 deduction  _55
ther deductions  56 414585
kleolifY: SEE STATEMENT 1
ax-exempt income and nondeductible expenses  _57
istributions - cash and marketable securities   58
'stributions - other property  _59
Other items not included above that are required to be reported separately to partners   60 -410154
Identity: SEE STATEMENT 1
Partner's credit Information (see instructions)
Part 1 - Flow-through credit bases and information
Brownfield redevelopment tax credit (Form CT611. Form CT-611. , or Form CT-611.2)
61 Site preparation credit component
62 Tangible property credit component
63 On-site groundwater remediation credit component
A - Fenn CT411 - Form CT411.1 C - Form C1411.2
EZ capital tax credit (Form CT-602)
64 Recapture of credit for investments in certified EZ businesses
65 Recapture of credit for contributions of money to EZ community development projects
QEZE tax reduction credit (Form CT-604-CP)
66 QEZE employment increase factor
67 QEZE zone allocation factor
68 OEZE benefit period factor
Excelsior jobs program tax credit (Form CT-607)
69 Excelsior jobs tax credit component
70 Excelsior investment tax credit component
71 Excelsior research and development tax credit component
72 Excelsior real property tax credit component
117007183065 III III III i
4 638KC 700W
Page 8 of 11 rT-204-CP (2018)
8Q35510 800561 1.000
Partners credit Information (continued)
Farmers' school tax credit (Form CT-47)
73 Acres of qualified agricultural property
74 Acres of qualified conservation property
75 Eligible school district property taxes paid
76 Acres of qualified agricultural property converted to nonqualified use
Other flow -through credit bases and Information
Credit bases
Code Amount
recaptures
Code Amount
77a 77d
77b 77e
77c 77f
Credit information
Code Information Code Information
sift 77j
77k
Part 2 Flow-th ough credits, addbacks, and
78 Flow-through credits
Code Amount Code Amount
78a 76e
78b 78f
78c 78g
78d 78h
79 Addbacks of credits and recaptures
Code Amount Code Amount
79a 79d
79b 79e
79c 79f
Part 3 START-UP NY tax elimination credit information (Form CT-638)
80 START-UP NY business certificate number (Form DTF-74)
81 Year of START-UP NY business tax benefit period
82 START-UP NY area allocation factor
Partner's share of apportionment and Metropolitan Commuter Transportation D strict (MCTD) Information
Part 1
1 During the reporting year, did the partnership do business, employ capital, own or lease property, maintain
an office, or derive receipts from activity, in New York State? (mark an X in the appropriate box) Yes ❑ No ❑x
2 During the reporting year, did the partnership do business, employ capital, own or lease property, maintain
❑ an office, or derive receipts from activity, in the MCTD? (mark an X in the appropriate box) Yes ❑ No
Average value of property
3 Real estate owned
4 Real estate rented
5 Inventories owned
6 Tangible personal property owned
7 Tangible personal property rented
A- MCTD
B- New York State
4638KC 700W
8Q35520 BOSSS2 1.000
IT-204-CP (2018) Page 9 of 11
Part 2
Receipts from:

Section 210-A.2
1 Sales of tangible personal property
2 Sales of electricity
3 Net gains from sales of real property

Section 210-A.3
4 Rentals of real and tangible personal property . . .
5 Royalties from patents, copyrights, trademarks, and
similar intangible personal property
6 Sales of rights for certain closed-circuit and cable
TV transmissions of an event

Section 210-A.4
7 Sale, licensing, or granting access to digital products
7a Sale, licensing, or granting access to digital products
8 This line intentionally left blank

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(A)
9 Interest from loans secured by real property
10 Net gains from sales of loans secured by real properly . .
11 Interest from loans not secured by real property ❑ 12 Net gains from sales of loans not secured by
real properly ❑

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(B) ❑
13 Interest from federal debt
15 Interest from NYS and Its political subdonstons debt . . . .  15
16 Net gains from federal. NYS. and NYS polrlical Sub:In/1SiOAS debt .
17 Interest from other states and their political
subdivisions debt
18 Net gains from other states and their political
subdivisions debt

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(C) ❑
19 Interest from asset-backed securities and other
government agency debt
20 Net gains from government agency debt or
asset-backed securities sold through an exchange .
21 Net gains from all other asset-backed securities . . .

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(D) ❑
22 Interest from corporate bonds
23 Net gains from corporate bonds sold through
broker/dealer or licensed exchange
24 Net gains from other corporate bonds

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(E)
25 Net interest from reverse repurchase and securities
borrowing agreements
A
MCTD
B
New York State
C
Everywhere
7a

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(F)
26 Net interest from federal funds

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(I) ❑ 27 Net income from sales of physical commodities . .

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(J) ❑
28 Marked to market net gains
A
4 638KC 700W
Page 10 of 11 IT-204-CP (2018)
8Q35530 BC135S3 1.000
Part 2
Receipts from:
A
MCTD
B
New York State
C
Everywhere

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(H)
210-A.5(a)(2)(G)
29 Interest from other financial
30 Net gains from othe
30a Net gains from othe
(broker/dealer/exchange)
30b Other income from
30c Other income from
(broker/dealer/exchange)
30d Dividends from stock
30e Net gains from sales
30f Net gains from sales
financial
financial
other
other
that
of
of
instruments
instruments
instruments
financial instruments. . .  30b
financial instruments
is business capital
stock that is business capital
partnership interests
30a
30c
30d
30e
30f

Section 210-A.5(b)
31 Brokerage commissions
32 Margin interest earned on behalf of brokerage accounts
33 Fees for advisory services for underwriting
or management of underwriting
34 Receipts from primary spread of selling concessions
35 Receipts from account maintenance fees
36 Fees for management or advisory services
37 Interest from an affiliated corporation

Section 210-A.5(c)
38 Interest, fees, and penalties from credit cards . . .
39 Service charges and fees from credit cards
40 Receipts from merchant discounts
41 Receipts from credit card authorizations and
settlement processing
42 Other credit card processing receipts

Section 2104.5(d)
43 Receipts Irom certain services to Investment companies 43

Section 210-A.6
44 Receipts from railroad and trucking business 44

Section 210-A.6-a
45 Receipts from the operation of vessels 45

Section 2104.7
46 Receipts from air freight forwarding
47 Receipts from other aviation services

Section 2104.8
48 Advertising in newspapers or periodicals
49 Advertising on television or radio
50 Advertising via other means

Section 210-A.9
51 Transportation or transmission of gas through pipes 51

Section 2104.10
52 Receipts from other services/activities not specified
52a Receipts from other services/activities not specified
52a
4638KC 700W
soaN386 40
IT-204-CP (2018) Page 11 of 11
Payroll AMCTD BNew York State
53 Wages and other compensation of employees except general executive officers. . . . 53
54 Average number of individuals employed full time in New York State (excluding employees with
partnership-wide authority)  54
Gross proceeds or receipts from certain sales
(for apportionment purposes) (see instructions)
A
MCTD
B
New York State
c
Everywhere
55 Sales of loans secured by real property
56 Sales of loans not secured by real property
57 Sales of other asset-backed securities
58 Sales of corporate bonds
59 Sales of physical commodities
Marked to market net gain or loss from deemed sales (for apportionment purposes)
60 Of loans secured by real property
61 Of loans not secured by real property
62 Of federal debt instruments
63 Of New York State and its political subdivisions debt instruments
64 Of other states and their political subdivisions debt instruments
65 Of government agency debt or asset-backed securities (through exchange)
66 Of all other asset-backed securities
67 Of corporate bonds through licensed exchange or broker/dealer
68 Of other corporate bonds
69 Of physical commodities
70 Of other financial instruments of one type
Items related to repurchase agreements and securities borrowing/lending agreements
71 Value of reverse repurchase agreements when partnership is purchaser/lender
72 Value of borrowing agreements when partnership is securities borrower
73 Value of repurchase agreements when partnership is seller/borrower
74 Value of lending agreements when partnership is securities lender
75 Interest income from reverse repurchase agreements and securities borrowing agreements
76 Interest expense from repurchase agreements and securities lending agreements
4638KC 700W
VALAR GLOBAL FUND II LP
IT 204-CP, PAGE 1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES
ITEM I METHOD OF ACCOUNTING : OTHER
704(B)
PARTNER'S SHARE OF INCOME, DEDUCTIONS, ETC
FEDERAL
LINE 56 - OTHER DEDUCTIONS
OTHER DED INCL IN ITEM L, CURRENT YR INCREASE 414585
TOTAL OTHER DEDUCTIONS 414585
FEDERAL
LINE 60 - OTHER ITEMS
INVESTMENT INCOME 4431
LESS: INVESTMENT EXPENSE 414585
TOTAL OTHER ITEMS -410154
STATEMENT 1
SXXCG3 1.00)
4638KC 700W
EFTA00810333 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
Schedule K-1
(Form 1065)
Department of the Treasury
Internal Revenue Service For calendar year 2018. a tax year
beginning   rancho
M18
Partner's Share of Income, Deductions,
Credits, etc. la See back of form and separate Instructions.
r--1 Amended K-1 OMB No. 1545-0123
Part III Partner's Share of Current Year Income,
Deductions. Credits and Other Items
1 Ordinary business income (loss) 1S Credits
2 Net rental real estate income (loss)
3 Other net rental mono (loss)
B
16 Foreign transactions
405.
Part I Information About the Partnership
A Partnership's employer identification number
ailli ame. address. dry. state, and 2IP code
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
915 BROADWAY, SUITE 1101
NEW YORK NY 10010
C IRS Center where partnership filed return
EFI LE
▪ 1 1 Check if this is a publicly traded pannershp (PTP)
I Guaranteed payments
I
5 Interest Income
4,162.
6e Ordinary dadends
66 Qualified dvklends
60 Dividend equivalents
7 Royalties
Part II Information About the Partner
Net short-term capital gain (loss)
618.
17 Alternative minimum UM(AMT) Items
E Partners identifying number 13
F Partner's name, address. any, state. and 2IP code
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, B3
ST.THOMAS, VI 00802
G U  General partner or LLC 1_2(j Limited partner a other LLC
member-manager member
• EI Domestic partner ❑ Foreign partner
It What type of entity is the partner?  S CORPORATION
12 If this partner is a retirement plan (lRASEPrKeogIVetc.). check here ❑
Partners share of profit. loss. and capital (see instructions):
Profs
Beginning
34.169883
Sting
34.174477 %
Loss 34.169883 34.174477 %
Capital 34.152663 34.152184 %
▪ Partners share of liabilities:
Beginning
Non recourse $
Ending
enumailipmeg nonrecourses $
Recourse  $
L Partners capital account analysis:
Beginning capital account
Capital contributed during the year
Current year increase (decrease)
Withdrawals & distributions . .
Ending tetanal account
16, 332,775.
. $ 3,750,000.
$ —646,464.
. $ (
19,436,311.
Tax basis n GAAP DI Section 700(0) book
Other (molar')
IA Did the partner contnbute property with a built-in gain or loss?

EN. Eyes
9a Net long-term capital gain (loss)
9b Collectibles (28%) gain (loss)
9c Unreceptured section 1250 gam
10 Net section 1231 gain (loss)
18 Tax-exempt Income and
nondeductible expenses
11 Other income (loss)
19 Distributions
12 Section 179 deduction
13 Other deductions
H* 6,363. A
PI* STMT B
14 Self-employment earnings (loss)
Other information
4,162.
644,881.
'See attached statement for additional information.
For IRS Use Only
II -Yes.' attach statement (see instructions)
For Paperwork Reduction Act Notice. see Instructions for Form 1065.
SA
SPU001.000
3597LP 700W
www.ir .gov/Formt065 Schedule K-1 (Form 1065)2018
Schedule K. (Form 1065) 2018 PARTNER # 13 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC. Page 2
This list Identifies the codes used on Schedule K-1 for all partners and provides summarized reporting information for 
partners who file Form 1000.
For detailed reporting and filing Information, see the separate Partners Instructions for Schedule K-1 and the 
Instructions for your Income tax return.

1. Ordinary business Income (loss). Determine witether the income (loss) is Cado Report on
passive or nonpassive and enter on your return as lams. J Work opportunity credit
Report on K Disabled access credit
Passive loss See the Partners Instructions
Passive income Schedule E. Me 28. column (h)
Nonpassive loss See the Partners Instructions
L Empowerment zone
employment credit
IA Credit la increasing research activities See the Partners Instructions
Nonpassrve income Schedule E. Me 28. column (k)

2. Net rental real estate Income (loss) See the Partners Instructions
N Credit la employer social
secunty and Medicare taxes

3. Other net rental Income (loss) O Backup withhdding
Net income Schedule E. Me 28. column (h)
Net loss See the Partners Instructions
P Other crews

16. Foreign transactions
0. Guaranteed payments Schedule E. Me 28. column (k)
5. Interest Income Form 1040. Ine2b
A Name of country or U.S.
possession Form 1116. Pan I
6a. Ordinary dividends Form 1040. Ine3b B Gross income from all sources
6b. Oualifled dividends Form 1040. line 3a C Gross Income sourced al puma lapel
6c. Dividend equivalents See the Partners Instructions Foreign gross income sourced et peRnersh0 level

7. Royalties Schedule E. line 4 O Section 951A category
8. Net short-term capital gain (loss) Schedule D. line 5 E Foreign branch category Form 1116. Pan I
9a. Net long-term capital gain (loss) Schedule D. line 12 F Passive category
9b. Collectibles (28%) gain (loss) 28% RateGan Worksheet. line 4 O General category
(Schedule D instructions) H Other
9c. Unrecaptured section 1250 gain See the Partners Instructions Deductions allocated and apportioned at partner level

10. Net section 1231 gain (loss) See the Partners Instructions I Interest expense Form 1116. Pan I
11. Other Income (loss) J Other Form 1116. Pat I
Code Deductions allocated and apportioned et partnersh#3 level to foreign source
income A Other portfolio income (loss) See the Partners Instructions
B Involuntary conversions See the Partners Instructions
C Sec. 1256 contracts 8 straddles Form 6781. line 1
K Section 951A category
L Foreign branch category
O Mining exploration costs recapture See Pit 535 PA PassMs category Form 1116. Pat I
E Cancellation ol debt Schedule 1 (Form 1000). line 21 or N General category
Form 982 O Other
F Section 951A income Other in f oation
O Section 965(a) leCluSKal P Total foreign taxes paid Form 1116. Pan II
H Subpart F income ether than See the Partners Instructions 0 Total foreign taxes accrued Form 1116. Pan II
sections 951A and 965 inclusion R Reduction in taxes available for craft Form 1116. line 12
I Other ncome (less) S Foreign trading gross receipts Form 8873 12. Section 179 deduction See the Partner's Instructions
T Extraterritorial ncome exclusion Form
13. Other deductions U Section 951A(c)(1)(A) tested income
A Cash contnbutions (60%)
B Cash contnbutions (30%)
V Tested foreign income tax See the Partners Instrucbons W Section 965 information
C Noncash contnbutions (50%) X Other foreign transactions
0 Noncash contnbutions (30%) See the Partners 17. Alternative minimum tax (AMT) hems
E Capital gain property to a 50% Instructions A Post-1986 deprecation adjustment
organization (30%) 8 Adjusted gain or loss See the Partners
F Capital gain property (20%) C Depletion (other than oil 8 gas) Instructions and
0 Contributions (100%) D Oct. gas. 8 geothermal gross income the Instructions tar
H Investment Interest expense Form 4952. line E Oil. gas. 8 geothermal - deductions Form 6251
I Deductions royally income Schedule E. line 19 F Other AMT tams
J Section 59(0(2) expenditures See the Partners Instructions 18. Tax-exempt Income and nondeductible e pauses
K Excess business nterest expense See the Partners Instructions A Tax-exempt interest income Form 1040. Me 2a
L Deductions portfolio (other) Schedule A. Me 16 B Other tax-exempt ncome See the Partners Instrucbons
IA Amounts paid to medical insurance Schedule A. line 1 or Schedule C Nondeductible expenses See the Partners 
Instrucbons
(Form 1040). Ire 29 19. Distributions
N Educational assistance benefits See the Partners Instructions A Cash and marketable securities
O Dependent care benefits Form 2441. line 12 B Distribution subject to section 737 See the Partner's Instructions
P Preproductive period expenses See the Partners Instructions C Other property
0 Commercial revitalization deduction 20. Other Information
from rental real estate ettnnies See Form 8582 instructions A Investment income Form 4952. Me 0a
R Pensions and IRAs See the Partners Instructions B Investment expenses Form 4952. Me 5
S Reforestation expense deduction See the Partners Instructions C Fuel tax credit information Form 4136
T through V Reserved for future use D Qualified rehabilitation expenditures See the Partners Instructions
W Other deductions See the Partner's Instructions (other than rental real estate)
X Section 965(c) deduction E Basis ol energy property See the Partners Instructions

10. Sell-employment earnings (loss) F Recapture of low-income housing Form 8611. Me 8
credit (section 420)(5))
Note: If you have a section 179 deduction or any partner-level deductions. see the 0 Recapture of low-income housing 
Form 8611. Me 8
Partners Instructions before completing Schedule SE. credit (other)
A Net earrings (loss) from H Recapture of investment credit See Form 4255
sell-employment Schedule SE. Seaton A or B I Recapture of other creeks See the Partners Instructions
B Gross farming or fishing income See the Partners Instructions J Look-track interest completed See Form 8697
C Gross non-farm income See the Partners Instructions long-term contracts
15. Credits
A Low-income housing credit (section
K Look-back interest - Income forecast See Form 8866
method
420)(5)) from pre-2008 buildings
B Low-income housing credit
(other) from pre-2008 buildings
L Dispositions of property with
section 179 deductions
PA Recapture of section 179 deduction
C Low-Income housing credit (section N Interest expense for corporate
partners 028)(6)) from post-2007 buildings
O Low-Income housing credit (other)
from post-2007 butdngs
E Qualified rehabilitation
expenditures (rental real estate)
See the Partners Instructions 0 through Y
2 Section 199A income
AA Section 199A W-2 wages
AB Section 199A unadanted basis
AC Section 199A REIT dividends
See the Partners
Instructions
F Other rental real estate cream AD Section 199A PTP income
O Other rental credits PE Excess taxable income H Undistnbuted capital gains credit Schedule 5 (Form 1040), line 74. box
a AF Excess business interest income
I Biofuel producer credit See the Partners Instructions JSA
8PI303 1.000
AO Gross receipts for section 59A(e)
AH Other information
3597LP 700W
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP 81-1155894
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER # 13 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
ITEM L - CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS
CASH CONTRIBUTIONS 3,750,000.
TOTAL CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS 3,750,000.
ITEM L - RECONCILIATION OF INCOME
INCOME (LOSS) FROM SCH. K-1, LINES 1 - 11 4,780.
LESS: DEDUCTIONS FROM SCH. K-1, LINES 12, 13, 16P, AND 16Q 651,244.
TOTAL INCOME PER SCHEDULE K-1 -646,464.
TOTAL INCOME PER ITEM L, CURRENT YEAR INCR(DECR) -646,464.
LINE 5 - INTEREST INCOME
OTHER INTEREST INCOME
INTEREST INCOME 3,757.
FROM PASS -THROUGH ENTITIES 405.
TOTAL INTEREST INCOME 4,162.
LINE 8 - NET SHORT-TERM CAPITAL GAIN(LOSS)
FROM PASS -THROUGH ENTITIES 618.
TOTAL NET SHORT-TERM CAPITAL GAIN(LOSS) 618.
LINE 13 - OTHER DEDUCTIONS
H - INVESTMENT INTEREST EXPENSE
OTHER INVESTMENT INTEREST
FROM PASS -THROUGH ENTITIES
TOTAL BOX H
W OTHER DEDUCTIONS
5,982.
381.
6,363.
OTHER DEDUCTIONS INCLUDED IN ITEM L, CURRENT YEAR INCREASE (DECREASE)
MANAGEMENT FEES
PORTFOLIO DEDUCTIONS - OTHER
FROM PASS -THROUGH ENTITIES
554,815.
85,006.
5,060.
TOTAL BOX W 644,881.
009003 1.000
3597LP 700W
STATEMENT 1
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP 81-1155894
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER II 13 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
LINE 16 - FOREIGN TRANSACTIONS
LINE 16B - GROSS INCOME FROM ALL SOURCES (NONRIC)
FROM PASS -THROUGH ENTITIES 405.
TOTAL BOX B 405.
LINE 161 - INTEREST EXPENSE
FROM PASS -THROUGH ENTITIES 381.
TOTAL BOX I 381.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES
LINE 13W -OTHER DEDUCTIONS:
THESE EXPENSES ARE PORTFOLIO DEDUCTIONS FORMERLY REPORTED ON BOX 13K
AS 2% PORTFOLIO DEDUCTIONS THAT ARE NON-DEDUCTIBLE FOR CERTAIN
TAXPAYERS, INCLUDING INDIVIDUALS, AND WOULD REDUCE YOUR TAX BASIS IN
THE PARTNERSHIP. PLEASE CONSULT YOUR TAX ADVISOR.
ITEM L:
YOU SHOULD CONSULT YOUR TAX ADVISOR TO DETERMINE YOUR TAX BASIS IN
YOUR PARTNERSHIP INTEREST. YOU SHOULD DETERMINE WHETHER LOSSES OR
EXPENSES APPEARING ON YOUR K-1 ARE SUBJECT TO SUSPENSION AND WHETHER
THERE ARE OTHER LIMITATIONS OR ISSUES THAT MAY ARISE BY VIRTUE OF
YOUR TAX BASIS IN YOUR PARTNERSHIP INTEREST OR FOR OTHER REASONS.
CAPITAL ACCOUNT RECONCILIATION:
THE PARTNERSHIP MAINTAINS CAPITAL ACCOUNT IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION
704(B) AND REPORTS THESE BALANCES ON SCHEDULE K-1. FOR FINANCIAL
PURPOSES, THE PARTNERSHIP MAINTAINS CAPITAL ACCOUNTS IN ACCORDANCE
WITH GENERALLY ACCEPTED ACCOUNTING PRINCIPLES (GAAP) .
UBTI FOOTNOTE:
TAX-EXEMPT PARTNERS ARE ADVISED THAT THE PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REPORTING
UNRELATED BUSINESS TAXABLE INCOME ("UBTI") DURING THE 2018 TAXABLE
YEAR BASED ON INFORMATION AVAILABLE TO THE PARTNERSHIP.
EFFECTIVELY CONNECTED INCOME (ECI) :
THE PARTNERSHIP IS NOT REPORTING EFFECTIVELY CONNECTED INCOME ("ECI")
DURING THE 2018 TAXABLE YEAR BASED ON INFORMATION AVAILABLE TO THE
PARTNERSHIP.
ITEM J:
CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE STATEMENT 2
0P9000 1.000
3597LP 700W
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP 81-1155894
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER it 13 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES (CONT'D)
PARTNER PERCENTAGES REFLECTED IN ITEM J ARE CALCULATED PURSUANT TO
IRS INSTRUCTIONS, AND MAY VARY FROM PERCENTAGES UNDER THE PARTNERSHIP
AGREEMENT.
SECTION 199A AND SECTION 163(J) :
THIS PARTNERSHIP IS NOT ENGAGED IN A TRADE OR BUSINESS AS DEFINED
UNDER I.R.C. SEC. 162. ADDITIONALLY, THIS PARTNERSHIP IS NOT INVESTED
IN A FLOW -THROUGH ENTITY WITH ITEMS NECESSARY FOR ITS PARTNER'S
CALCULATION OF EITHER SEC. 199A OR SEC. 163(J) . THEREFORE, SEC. 199A
IS NOT APPLICABLE. THE PARTNERSHIP DOES NOT HAVE ANY INTEREST EXPENSE
ALLOCABLE TO A TRADE OR BUSINESS, THUS IT IS NOT SUBJECT TO INTEREST
EXPENSE LIMITATIONS UNDERS SEC. 163(J). PLEASE CONSULT YOUR TAX
ADVISOR.
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES
FORM 8621 INFORMATION
IF APPLICABLE, VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP HAS MADE TIMELY QUALIFIED
ELECTING FUND (^QEV') ELECTION(S) WITH RESPECT TO ITS INVESTMENTS IN
UNDERLYING PASSIVE FOREIGN INVESTMENT COMPANIES (mPFIC"), EFFECTIVE
FOR EACH YEAR OF OWNERSHIP, AND HAS FILED THE REQUIRED FORMS 8621 FOR
ALL YEARS OF OWNERSHIP. THE DIRECT US SHAREHOLDER THAT HAS MADE A
QEF ELECTION FOR A PFIC IS REQUIRED TO INCLUDE INCOME CURRENTLY UNDER
IRC SECTION 1293, AND TO FILE FORM 8621. AS A PARTNER THAT HAS
INVESTED IN A US PARTNERSHIP THAT HAS MADE THE QEF ELECTION AND FILED
FORM 8621 (IF APPLICABLE), YOUR ALLOCABLE SHARE OF THIS INCOME IS NOT
REQUIRED TO BE FURTHER REPORTED ON AN ADDITIONAL FORM 8621. THE
SERVICE HAS REVISED THE INSTRUCTIONS FOR FORM 8621 TO FORMALLY
CLARIFY THAT NO ADDITIONAL FORM 8621 REPORTING IS NECESSARY UNDER
THESE FACTS. PLEASE CONSULT YOUR TAX ADVISOR.
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES
FORM 8938 INFORMATION
IN 2018, INDIVIDUALS AND CERTAIN DOMESTIC ENTITIES ARE REQUIRED TO
REPORT THEIR DIRECT OR INDIRECT INVESTMENTS ON FORM 8938 IF A CERTAIN
THRESHOLD IS MET. IF YOUR INTERESTS IN THE BELOW FOREIGN ENTITIES ARE
ONLY THROUGH YOUR OWNERSHIP IN VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP, YOU DO NOT
NEED TO INCLUDE THESE ENTITIES ON FORM 8938. HOWEVER, IF YOU HAVE ANY
OTHER DIRECT OR INDIRECT INVESTMENTS IN THE FOREIGN ENTITIES NOTED
BELOW, PLEASE CONSULT YOUR TAX ADVISOR TO DETERMINE YOUR FILING
REQUIREMENTS. THE VALUE PROVIDED REPRESENTS THE VALUE OF THE ASSETS
HELD BY VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP. YOU MUST DETERMINE YOUR PRO RATA
SHARE ACCORDINGLY.
OLINDA S.A.S
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET: STOCK
FEIN: FOREIGNUS
CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE STATEMENT 3
009003 1.000
3597LP 700W
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP 81-1155894
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER II 13 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES (CONT'D)
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
BROLLY UK TECHNOLOGY LIMITED
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
BROLLY UK TECHNOLOGY LIMITED
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
N26 GMBH
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
COYA AG
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
SPACESHIP FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LTD
NO
NO
$42,306,859
CORPORATION
8 RUE DU SENTIER,
PARIS,75002
FRANCE
STOCK
FOREIGNUS
NO
NO
$229,345
CORPORATION
125 CHARING CROSS ROAD,
SOHO,
LONDON WC2H OEW,
UNITED KINGDOM
CONVERTIBLE NOTES
FOREIGNUS
YES 2/26/2018
NO
$237,575
CORPORATION
125 CHARING CROSS ROAD,
SOHO,
LONDON WC2H OEW,
UNITED KINGDOM
STOCK
FOREIGNUS
NO
NO
$24,419,437
CORPORATION
KLOSTERSTRABE 62
10179 BERLIN,
GERMANY
STOCK
FOREIGNUS
NO
NO
$7,927,383
CORPORATION
OHLAUER STR. 43
10999 BERLIN,
GERMANY
009000 1.000
3597LP 700W
CONTINUED ON NEXT PAGE STATEMENT 4
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP 81-1155894
SCH K-1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES PARTNER II 13 SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
PARTNER FOOTNOTES (CONT'D)
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX YEAR:
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
SPACESHIP FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LTD
DESCRIPTION OF ASSET:
FEIN:
ASSET ACQUIRED DURING THE YEAR:
ASSET DISPOSED DURING THE YEAR:
MAXIMUM VALUE OF ASSET DURING TAX
TYPE OF FOREIGN ENTITY:
MAILING ADDRESS:
YEAR:
STOCK
FOREIGNUS
YES 9/19/2018
NO
$599,550
CORPORATION
SUITE 4.02,
77 KING STREET,
SYDNEY NSW 2000,
AUSTRALIA
CONVERTIBLE NOTE
FOREIGNUS
NO
YES 9/19/2018
$599,550
CORPORATION
SUITE 4.02,
77 KING STREET,
SYDNEY NSW 2000,
AUSTRALIA
009000 1.000
3597LP 700W
STATEMENT 5
NEW
YORK
STATE
Department of Taxalion and Finance
New York Corporate Partner's
Schedule K-1 Tax Lay/ - Article 9-A
For calendar year 2018 or tax year beginning 181 and ending
IT-204-CP
Final K-1
Amended K-1
Partners: Before completing your franchise tax return, see Form IT-204-CP-I. Partner's Instructions for Form IT-204-CP 
(available al wmv.tax.ny.gov).
Partnership's Information
Partnership's name (as shown on Form IT-204)
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
Partnership's EIN
A Mark an X in the box if either applies to your entity El Publicly traded partnership a Portfolio investment 
partnership
B Tax shelter registration number, if any
Partner's Information (see instructions)
Partners name
SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY, INC.
Partners address
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, B3
City

ST. THOMAS
C
D
The partner is a (matk an X 10 fat trttO/Mart UV Q Gene al partner or LLC member-manager
What is the New York tax filing status of the partner? Mark an X in the appropriate box. It known )
0 C corporation S corporation 0 Partnership
Limited partner or other LLC member
E If the partner is a disregarded entity, enter the EIN of the entity reporting the income of
the partner (it known)
F Did the partner sell its entire interest during the tax year? F Yes O  No 0
O Partner's share of profit, loss, and capital Beginning Ending

1) Profit 34.1698 % 34.1744 %
2) Loss  G2 34.1698 % 34.1744 %
3) Capital G3 34.1526 % 34.1521 %
H Partner's share of liabilities at the end of the year

1) Nonrecourse  HI
2) Qualified nonrecourse financing  H2
3) Recourse  H3
State
VI
ZIP code
Partners EIN
I Partner's capital account analysis

1) Beginning capital account   It
2) Capital contributed during the year - cash  12
3) Capital contributed during the year - property  13

4) Current year increase (decrease)  14
5) Withdrawals and distributions - cash  15
6) Withdrawals and distributions - property  16

7) Ending capital account   17
8) Method of accounting (mark an X in the appropriate box)
El Tax basis El GAAP El Book El Other (subnul explanation)
HEE
-646464
SEE STATEMENT 1
3597LP 700W
8Q35020
Page 2 of 11 IT-204-CP (2018) 100502 1.000
J Was Form CT-2658-E filed with the partnership?  J Yes ❑ No
K NYS estimated tax paid on behalf of partner (from Form CT-2658) Date Amount
1) First installment K1
2) Second installment  K2
3) Third installment  K3
4) Fourth installment  K4
Total NYS estimated tax paid on behalf of partner (add Ones K1 through K4)
L Was the partnership required to report any nonqualilied deferred compensation, as required by
IRC § 457A, on its 2018 federal return? (see instructions)  L Yes El No [TI
Partner's share of entire net income (ENI) information when the corporate partner's New York tax filing
status is a C corporation
ENI addition modifications
1 Total additions
A- Number 8- Amount A- Number 8- Amount
la EA- Id EA-
1b EA- le EA-
lc EA- lf a-
ENI subtraction modifications
2 Total subtractions  2
A- Number 8- Amount A- Number 8 -Amount
2a ES- 2d ES -
2b ES- 2e ES -
2c ES- 2f ES -
Partner's proportionate part of assets and liabilities (for New York C corporate partners only)
Average value
3 Total assets
4 Real property and marketable securities included on line 3
5 Real property and marketable securities at fair market value (NOV)
6 Average value of adjusted total assets
7 Total liabilities
8 Liabilities directly attributable to business capital
9 Liabilities directly attributable to investment capital
II III
3597LP 700W
6°8408030
IT-204-CP (2018) Page 3 of 11
Partner's proportionate pad of items related to investment capital under Article 9-A (for New York
C corporate partners only)
Part 1 - Investment capital that generates income claimed not taxable by New York under the U.S. Constitution
Description of asset (identity each asset, and enter number of shares (if applicable) and date acquired here: for each 
asset complete columns
through G on the corresponding lines below: enter only directly owned assets in items A through F and Total from 
additional sheet(s))
For each item listed, in columns A through G, enter the information for the partnership as a whole.
Item A- Description of asset 0- Number of shares
acquired, if appicable
C- Date acquired
A
B
C
D
E
F
Item D
Number of
shares sold, if applicable
E
Date sold
F
Average
FMV
G
Liabilities directly
attributable
H
Net average
FMV
A
B
C
D
E
F
Total from additional sheet(s)
Total from partnerships
10 Total proportionate part of columns F
and G (see instructions) 10
Part 2 - Investment capital - stocks actually held more than one year
Description of investment (identify each investment. and enter number of shares and date acquired here: for each 
investment complete columns D
through G on the corresponding lines below: enter only directly owned investments in items A through F and Total from 
additional sheet(s))
For each item listed, in columns A through G, enter the information for the partnership as a whole.
Item A- Name/CUSIP/CIN$Aot number B- Number of shares
acquired
C- Date acquired
A
B
C
D
E
F
Item D
Number of
shares sold
E
Date sold
F
Average
FMV
G
Liabilities directly
attributable
H
Net average
FMV
A
B
C
D
E
F
Total from additional sheet(s)
Total from partnerships
11 Total proportionate part of columns F
and G (see instructions) 11
III IIII III 'l I l 1 003183065
3597LP 700W
Page 4 of 11 IT-204-CP (2018)
8Q35040
8O35Oa 1.000
Part 3 - Investment capital - stocks presumed held more than one year
Description of investment (identify each investment. and enter number of shares and date acquired here: for each 
investment complete columns F
and G on the corresponding lines below: enter only director owned investments in items A through F and Total from 
additional sheet(s))
For each item listed, in columns A through G, enter the information for the partnership as a whole.
Item A- Name/CUSINCINS/lot number B- Number of shares acquired C- Date acquired
A
B
C
D
E
F
Item D
Number of
shares sold
E
Date sold
F
Average
FMV
G
Liabilities directly
attributable
H
Net average
FMV
A
B
C
D
E
F
Total from additional sheet(s)
Total from partnerships
12 Total proportionate part of columns F
and G (see instructions) 12
Part 4 - Total investment capital
13 Total average FMV and liabilities directly attributable
(add lines TO, I I. am:112h columns Fend 0) . . . 13
Part 5 - Prior year investment capital - stocks that d d not meet holding period requirement
Description of investment (identity each investment. and enter number of shares and date acquired here: for each 
investment complete columns D
through G on the corresponding tines below: enter only directly owned investments in items A through F and Total from 
additional sheet(s))
For each item listed, in columns A through G, enter the information for the partnership as a whole.
Item A - Name/CUSINCINS4ot number 8 - Number ol shares acquired C - Date acquired
A
B
C
D
E
F
Item D
Number of
shares sold
E
Date sold
F
Average FMV
as previously reported
G
Liabili es directly attributable
as previously reported
H
Net average
FMV
A
B
C
D
E
F
Total from additional sheet(s)
Total from partnerships
14 Total proportionate part of columns F
and G (see instructions) 14 _i_
117004183065 III III III i 3597LP 700W
sottiaBi5dat50
IT-204-CP (2018) Page 5 of 11
Part 6 - Prior year gross Investment Income for stocks that did not meet holding period requirement
15 Prior year presumed gross investment income from stocks presumed in the prior year to
be held more than one year that failed to meet the presumption (see inseuctions) 15
Partner's share of items related to investment and other exempt income under Article 9-A (for New York
C corporate partners only)
16 Gross exempt cross-article dividends
17 Gross exempt controlled foreign corporation (CFC) income
18 Gross exempt unitary corporation dividends
19 Gross investment income from investments generating income not taxable by New York
State under the U.S. Constitution
20 Dividend income from investment capital from stocks actually held more than one year
21 Net capital gains or losses from investment capital from stocks actually held more
than one year
22 Dividend income from investment capital from stocks presumed held more than one year
Partner's share of items related to interest deductions directly attributable to investment and other
exempt income under Article 9-A (for New York C corporate partners only)
Interest expense per federal Form 1065, line 15
Interest deductions directly
Interest deductions directly
Interest deductions directly
Interest deductions directly
Interest deductions directly
Interest deductions directly
Interest deductions directly
Interest deductions directly
attributable to income reported on line 16
attributable to income reported on line 17
attributable to income reported on line 18
attributable to income reported on line 19
attributable to income reported on line 20
attributable to income reported on line 21
attributable to income reported on line 22
attributable to business capital
28,
29,
Partner's share and proportionate part of items related to subtraction modification for qualified banks
32 Qualified residential loan portfolio assets
33 Gross interest income from qualifying loans
33a Gross interest income from all loans
33b Gross interest expense from aU loans
3b
Partner's share and proportionate part of items related to manufacturing
34 Total receipts from the sale of goods by manufacturing
34a Receipts received from the generation and distribution of electricity, the distribution of natural
gas, and the production of steam associated with the generation of electricity
35 Adjusted basis of qualified manufacturing property
35a Number of employees employed in manufacturing in New York
34a
35a
3597LP 700W
Page 6 of 11 IT-204-CP (2018) 103506 1.000
Partner's share of New York modifications (for New York S corporate partners only)
36 New York State additions
Number A— Total amount
36a EA-
36b EA-
36c EA-
36d EA -
36e E A-
36f EA -
37 Total addition modifications (total of column A. lines 36a through 360  37
36 New York State subtractions
Number A - Total amount
38a E S -
38b E S -
36c E S -
38d E S -
38e E S -
38f E S -
39 Total subtraction modifications (total of column A. lines 38a through 380  39
40 Additions to itemized deductions
Letter Amount
40a
40b
40c
40d
40e
40f
41 Total additions to itemized deductions (add lines 40a through 400  41
42 Subtractions from itemized deductions
Letter Amount
42a
42b
42c
42d
42e
42f
43 Total subtractions from itemized deductions (add lines 42a Through 420  43!
III III 3597LP 700W
8O3550 1.000
I7-204-CP (2018) Page 7 of 11
Partner's share of income, deductions, etc. (from federal Form 1065, Schedule K-1)
Partner's distributive share items
45 N
48 I
50 R
51 N
52 N
53 N
55 S
57 T
Ordinary business income (loss)  44
et rental real estate income (loss)   45
Other net rental income (loss)   46
uaranteed payments   47
'Wrest income  48 4162
Ordinary dividends  49
oyalties   _50
et short-term capital gain (loss)  _51 618
et long-term capital gain (loss)   _52
et section 1231 gain (loss)  _53
Other income (loss)  54
Identify:
action 179 deduction  _55
'ther deductions  56 651244
kloolifY: SEE STATEMENT 1
ax-exempt income and nondeductible expenses  _57
istributions - cash and marketable securities   58
'stributions - other property  _59
Other items not included above that are required to be reported separately to partners   60 -640719
Identity: SEE STATEMENT 1
Partner's credit Information (see instructions)
Part 1 - Flow-through credit bases and information
Brownfield redevelopment tax credit (Form CT611. Form CT-611. , or Form CT-611.2)
61 Site preparation credit component
62 Tangible property credit component
63 On-site groundwater remediation credit component
A - Fenn CT-611 - Form CT-611.1 C - Form C1411.2
EZ capital tax credit (Form CT-602)
64 Recapture of credit for investments in certified EZ businesses
65 Recapture of credit for contributions of money to EZ community development projects
QEZE tax reduction credit (Form CT-604-CP)
66 QEZE employment increase factor
67 QEZE zone allocation factor
68 OEZE benefit period factor
Excelsior jobs program tax credit (Form CT-607)
69 Excelsior jobs tax credit component
70 Excelsior investment tax credit component
71 Excelsior research and development tax credit component
72 Excelsior real property tax credit component
117007183065 III III III i
3597LP 700W
Page 8 of 11 rT-204-CP (2018)
8Q35510 800561 1.000
Partners credit Information (continued)
Farmers' school tax credit (Form CT-47)
73 Acres of qualified agricultural property
74 Acres of qualified conservation property
75 Eligible school district property taxes paid
76 Acres of qualified agricultural property converted to nonqualified use
Other flow -through credit bases and Information
Credit bases
Code Amount
recaptures
Code Amount
77a 77d
77b 77e
77c 77f
Credit information
Code Information Code Information
sift 77j
77k
Part 2 Flow-th ough credits, addbacks, and
78 Flow-through credits
Code Amount Code Amount
78a 76e
78b 78f
78c 78g
78d 78h
79 Addbacks of credits and recaptures
Code Amount Code Amount
79a 79d
79b 79e
79c 79f
Part 3 START-UP NY tax elimination credit information (Form CT-638)
80 START-UP NY business certificate number (Form DTF-74)
81 Year of START-UP NY business tax benefit period
82 START-UP NY area allocation factor
Partner's share of apportionment and Metropolitan Commuter Transportation D strict (MCTD) Information
Part 1
1 During the reporting year, did the partnership do business, employ capital, own or lease property, maintain
an office, or derive receipts from activity, in New York State? (mark an X in the appropriate box) Yes ❑ No ❑ 2 During 
the reporting year, did the partnership
do business, employ capital, own or lease property, maintain
an office, or derive receipts from activity, in the MCTD? (mark an X in the appropriate box) Yes ❑ No ❑
Average value of property
3 Real estate owned
4 Real estate rented
5 Inventories owned
6 Tangible personal property owned
7 Tangible personal property rented
A- MCTD
B- New York State
3597LP 700W
8Q35520 BOSSS2 1.000
IT-204-CP (2018) Page 9 of 11
Part 2
Receipts from:

Section 210-A.2
1 Sales of tangible personal property
2 Sales of electricity
3 Net gains from sales of real property

Section 210-A.3
4 Rentals of real and tangible personal property . . .
5 Royalties from patents, copyrights, trademarks, and
similar intangible personal property
6 Sales of rights for certain closed-circuit and cable
TV transmissions of an event

Section 210-A.4
7 Sale, licensing, or granting access to digital products
7a Sale, licensing, or granting access to digital products
8 This line intentionally left blank

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(A)
9 Interest from loans secured by real property
10 Net gains from sales of loans secured by real properly . .
11 Interest from loans not secured by real property ❑ 12 Net gains from sales of loans not secured by
real properly ❑

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(B) ❑
13 Interest from federal debt
15 Interest from NYS and Its political subdonstons debt . . . .  15
16 Net gains from federal. NYS. and NYS polrlical Sub:In/1SiOAS debt .
17 Interest from other states and their political
subdivisions debt
18 Net gains from other states and their political
subdivisions debt

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(C) ❑
19 Interest from asset-backed securities and other
government agency debt
20 Net gains from government agency debt or
asset-backed securities sold through an exchange .
21 Net gains from all other asset-backed securities . . .

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(D) ❑
22 Interest from corporate bonds
23 Net gains from corporate bonds sold through
broker/dealer or licensed exchange
24 Net gains from other corporate bonds

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(E)
25 Net interest from reverse repurchase and securities
borrowing agreements
A
MCTD
B
New York State
C
Everywhere
7a

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(F)
26 Net interest from federal funds

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(I) ❑ 27 Net income from sales of physical commodities . .

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(J) ❑
28 Marked to market net gains
3597LP 700W
Page 10 of 11 IT-204-CP (2018)
8Q35530 BC135S3 1.000
Part 2
Receipts from:
A
MCTD
B
New York State
C
Everywhere

Section 210-A.5(a)(2)(H)
210-A.5(a)(2)(G)
29 Interest from other financial
30 Net gains from othe
30a Net gains from othe
(broker/dealer/exchange)
30b Other income from
30c Other income from
(broker/dealer/exchange)
30d Dividends from stock
30e Net gains from sales
30f Net gains from sales
financial
financial
other
other
that
of
of
instruments
instruments
instruments
financial instruments. . .  30b
financial instruments
is business capital
stock that is business capital
partnership interests
30a
30c
30d
30e
30f

Section 210-A.5(b)
31 Brokerage commissions
32 Margin interest earned on behalf of brokerage accounts
33 Fees for advisory services for underwriting
or management of underwriting
34 Receipts from primary spread of selling concessions
35 Receipts from account maintenance fees
36 Fees for management or advisory services
37 Interest from an affiliated corporation

Section 210-A.5(c)
38 Interest, fees, and penalties from credit cards . . .
39 Service charges and fees from credit cards
40 Receipts from merchant discounts
41 Receipts from credit card authorizations and
settlement processing
42 Other credit card processing receipts

Section 2104.5(d)
43 Receipts Irom certain services to Investment companies 43

Section 210-A.6
44 Receipts from railroad and trucking business 44

Section 210-A.6-a
45 Receipts from the operation of vessels 45

Section 2104.7
46 Receipts from air freight forwarding
47 Receipts from other aviation services

Section 2104.8
48 Advertising in newspapers or periodicals
49 Advertising on television or radio
50 Advertising via other means

Section 210-A.9
51 Transportation or transmission of gas through pipes 51

Section 2104.10
52 Receipts from other services/activities not specified
52a Receipts from other services/activities not specified
52a
3597LP 700W
soa8A383$4O
IT-204-CP (2018) Page 11 of 11
Payroll AMCTD BNew York State
53 Wages and other compensation of employees except general executive officers. . . . 53
54 Average number of individuals employed full time in New York State (excluding employees with
partnership-wide authority)  54
Gross proceeds or receipts from certain sales
(for apportionment purposes) (see instructions)
A
MCTD
B
New York State
c
Everywhere
55 Sales of loans secured by real property
56 Sales of loans not secured by real property
57 Sales of other asset-backed securities
58 Sales of corporate bonds
59 Sales of physical commodities
Marked to market net gain or loss from deemed sales (for apportionment purposes)
60 Of loans secured by real property
61 Of loans not secured by real property
62 Of federal debt instruments
63 Of New York State and its political subdivisions debt instruments
64 Of other states and their political subdivisions debt instruments
65 Of government agency debt or asset-backed securities (through exchange)
66 Of all other asset-backed securities
67 Of corporate bonds through licensed exchange or broker/dealer
68 Of other corporate bonds
69 Of physical commodities
70 Of other financial instruments of one type
Items related to repurchase agreements and securities borrowing/lending agreements
71 Value of reverse repurchase agreements when partnership is purchaser/lender
72 Value of borrowing agreements when partnership is securities borrower
73 Value of repurchase agreements when partnership is seller/borrower
74 Value of lending agreements when partnership is securities lender
75 Interest income from reverse repurchase agreements and securities borrowing agreements
76 Interest expense from repurchase agreements and securities lending agreements
3597LP 700W
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
IT 204-CP, PAGE 1 SUPPORTING SCHEDULES
ITEM I METHOD OF ACCOUNTING : OTHER
(7048)
PARTNER'S SHARE OF INCOME, DEDUCTIONS, ETC
FEDERAL
LINE 56 - OTHER DEDUCTIONS
INVESTMENT INTEREST EXPENSE 6363
OTHER DED INCL IN ITEM L, CURRENT YR INCREASE 644881
TOTAL OTHER DEDUCTIONS 651244
FEDERAL
LINE 60 - OTHER ITEMS
INVESTMENT INCOME 4162
LESS: INVESTMENT EXPENSE 644881
TOTAL OTHER ITEMS -640719
STATEMENT 1
BXX063 1.003
3597LP 700W
EFTA01063691 (Jmail)
 [misc] inventory of the contents of address books and Skype logs seized from Epstein computers
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
• NYC024363.dmg
(Evidence ID: NYC024363.dmg - 001)
o Case Data
• Calendar Items
• Calls
• Contacts
• Messages
• Notes
• Top Contacts
• User Accounts
Case Data: Contacts (1-100 of 4285)
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First (MS)
Last desmond_shum
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-02-01 22:19:44 (UTC)
Modification Date 2012-03-17 01:15:05 (UTC)
ID 4787
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First (M30
Last desmond_shum
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC) Date
ID 768
Contact
Source Device NYC024363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Stoty/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb Path
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First MS)
Last desmond_shum
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:00 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 63
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First (•5ta)
Last desmond_shum
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 731
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First (•5ta)
Last desmond_shum
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 731
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
ID 2237
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
ID 1885
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First  0
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 139
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First  0
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 1260
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abdourahman
Last Boreh
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2012-03-17 01:15:04 (UTC)
Modification Date 2013-04-22 00:01:54 (UTC)
ID 5053
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abdourahman
Last Boreh
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC) Date
ID 753
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abdourahman
Last Boreh
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC) Date
ID 756
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abdourahman
Last Boreh
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 19:10:48 (UTC)
ID 1437
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abigail
Last Wexner
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 216
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abigail
Last Wexner
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:03:59 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 23
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abigail
Last Wexner
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 216
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abram
Last Muljana
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC) Date
ID 767
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abram
Last Muljana
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 663
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Abram
Last Muljana
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 663
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Accessories
ID 2345
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Accessories
ID 2930
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
Last
ID
Adam
Lapsevich
2517
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Adam
Bly
2014-08-07 22:04:04 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
186
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
Adam
Bly
2962
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story I 1 -2 I -2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Adam
Bly
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 629
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Adam
Last Bly
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
ID 629
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
ID 1601
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Adel
Middle E.
Last Ghazzawi
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:08 (UTC)
ID 730
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Adel
Middle E.
Last Ghazzawi
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:09 (UTC) Date
ID 261
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbulAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Adel
Middle E.
Last Ghanawi
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-02-19 16:30:53 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 730
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First advanced
Last irrigation mark domenico
ID 1023
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Aeroplan
ID 727
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First afri
Last xp
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC) Date
ID 549
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Stoty/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First afri
Last xp
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2011-11-21 17:17:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 1417
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
ID 2149
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ahmed
Last Protocal
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:14 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 512
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application SupportlAddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ahmed
Last Protocal
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:15 (UTC)
ID 24
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Ahmed
Last Protocal
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2010-12-04 01:04:28 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 24
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Air
Last canada
ID 803
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Al
Last seckel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
ID 506
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Al
Last seckel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:05 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC) Date
ID 245
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Al
Last Quinlan
ID 2045
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Al
Last seckel
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 506
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alan
Last Markowitz
ID 579
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First alan
Last wilks
ID 2265
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First alan
Last wilks
ID 2465
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alan
Middle M.
Last Dershowitz
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 378
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alan
Last Guth
ID 1047
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alan
Last Guth
ID 138
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alan
Middle M.
Last Dershowitz
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 378
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alan
Middle M.
Last Dershowitz
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:28 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC) Date
ID 878
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alan
Last Handel
ID 2109
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path
SourceType
First
Last
ID
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
Skype
Alan
Handel
1381
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Alana
Righi
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 151
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Alana
Righi
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Vlodilication Date 2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
ID 151
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Alana
Righi
2014-08-07 22:04:31 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:33 (UTC)
1003
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawkrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First alannoah79
ID 2714
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Albert
Last sanford
ID 1585
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Albert
Last sanford
ID 1709
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Albert
Last sanford
ID 2061
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Aleksander
Last Sichkar
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:07 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:09 (UTC) Date
ID 307
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Aleksander
Last Sichkar
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 445
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Aleksander
Last Sichkar
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:08 (UTC)
ID 445
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Aleksandra
Last Eriksson
ID 199
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First alesia
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC) Date
ID 765
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First alesia
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 273
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First alesia
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 273
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First alex
Last vilenkin
ID 771
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alex
Last Pam
ID 651
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alex
Last Pam
ID 3158
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alexa
Middle N.
Last Staley
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 494
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Alexa
N.
Staley
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 494
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Middle
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Modification
Date
ID
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
Alexa
N.
Staley
2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC)
2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
772
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC)
ID 534
Source Device
Path
SourceType
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 626
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011 .abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 534
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 626
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:00 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 69
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:04 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:06 (UTC) Date
ID 195
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alice
Last Hargrove
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:28 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC) Date
ID 905
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alice
Last Kreeger
ID 395
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alice
Last Jacobs
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 237
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alice
Last Hargrove
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 547
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First Alice
Last Kreeger
ID 3398
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alice
Last Hargrove
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:29 (UTC)
ID 547
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBooklAddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alice
Last Jacobs
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2010-12-17 23:10:29 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:01 (UTC)
ID 237
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First Alice
Last Jacobs
Email (Work)
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:03:59 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 29
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-06-15 21:51:42 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 775
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-06-15 21:51:42 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 775
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-06-15 21:51:42 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 774
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/jeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
Last
ID 337
Source Device
Path
SourceType
Contact
NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
/Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
Mac AddressBook
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:25 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:26 (UTC)
ID 786
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-10-12 01:30:16 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 863
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-06-11 03:20:26 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:40 (UTC)
ID 773
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Desktop/contacts /story 11-21-2011.abbu/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Phone Number (Mobile)
Creation Date 2011-06-11 03:20:26 (UTC)
Modification Date 2011-11-17 20:12:18 (UTC)
ID 773
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBookJSources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-
B48D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Phone Number
(Mobile)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:39 (UTC)
Modification Date 2014-08-07 22:04:41 (UTC)
ID 1181
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skypedeevacation/main.db
SourceType Skype
First
ID 4919
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/AddressBook/Sources/DOEBC1B4-16FF-49AC-B4
8D-BDA3E8561617/AddressBook-v22.abcddb
SourceType Mac AddressBook
First
Last
Email (Work)
Creation Date 2014-08-07 22:04:00 (UTC)
Modification 2014-08-07 22:04:02 (UTC) Date
ID 118
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First alison
Last reeves
ID 166
Contact
Source Device NYCO24363.dmg/Macintosh HD
Path /Users/Story/Library/Application Support/Skype/lawlcrauss/main.db
SourceType Skype
First alison
Last reeves
ID 1929
Case Data: Contacts (Index) Case Data: Contacts (101-200 of 4285)
EFTA01087311 (Jmail)
 [money] Leon Black Family Partners cash projections
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
BLACK FAMILY PARTNERS
CASH PROJECTIONS
FY 2014
FY 2014 FY 2014
NOV DEC
CASH APO APO
10/31/2014 DISTRIB DISTRIB
11/21/2014 12/15/2014
CASH -BOFA 0135 5,493,853
CASH-SOFA 0127 N/A
CASH -JPM 2008 66,393
INFLOWS
APO DISTRIBUTION PER SH $ 0.73 $ 0.18
APO DISTRIBUTION - $ 67,683,532 16,689,090
TRA
DISTRIBUTION TO OWNERS (67,683,532)
NET WITHHELD BY BFP 16,689,090
HERITAGE
TIMBER SALE
KNOWLEDGE UNIVERSE LIQUIDATION
DIVIDEND - AINV
TOTAL
FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015
FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015 FY 2015
JAN FEB MAR APRIL MAY JUN JULY
APO APO APO
DISTRIB DISTRIB DISTRIB
2/28/2015 4/14/2015 5/7/2015
0.70
84,372,622 64,902,016
(67,683,532) (64,902,016)
16,689,090
REPAYMENT OF PHAIDON UNE
REDEMPTION - LOAN CASCADE
MONTHLY DISBURSEMENTS
FCI CAPITAL CALL
COF III CONINVEST III CAPITAL CALL
ATHENE CAPITAL CALL
TENFORE CAPITAL CALL
FAMILY OFFICE
(10,000,000)
(736,524)
(183,000) (183,000)
NET CASH BY MONTH (919,524) 6,506,090
CASH BALANCE 5,560,246 4,600,722 11,146,812
RESIDUAL FUNDING OF ATHENE - MAY BORROW FROM LOB 2014 LLC
228,000
16,000,000
4,000,000
$ 0.30 $ 0.42
27,815,150 38,941,209
24,470,699
(52,285,849) (38,941,209)
120,726 120,726 120,726
10,030,030
(10,000,000)
(736,524) (2,500,000) (2,500,000)
(366,000)
(40,000,000)
(250,000)
(200,000) (200,000) (183,000) (183,000) (183,000) (183,000) (183,000)
7,648,726 15,550,000 3,817,000 (2,562 274) 83,000) 83,000) (40,062,274)
5,586,566
18,795,538 34,345,538 38,162,538 35,600,265 35,417,265 35,234,265 44,828,009)
Page 1 of 2
BLACK FAMILY PARTNERS
CASH PROJECTIONS
FY2015
FY 2015
AUG
APO
DISTRIB
8/7/2015
FY2015
FY 2015
SEP
FY2015
FY 2015
OCT
FY2015
FY 2015
NOV
APO
DISTRIB
11/7/2015
FY2015
FY 2015
DEC
TOTAL
CASH -BOFA 0135
CASH -BOFA 0127
CASH -JPM 2008
INFLOWS
APO DISTRIBUTION PER SH $ 0.42 $ 0.42
APO DISTRIBUTION - $ 38,941,208 38,941,209 209,540,793
TRA 24470499
DISTRIBUTION TO OWNERS (38,941,208) (38,941,209) (234,011,492)
NET WITHHELD BY BFP
HERITAGE 228,000
TIMBER SALE 16,000,000
KNOWLEDGE UNIVERSE LIQUIDATION
DIVIDEND - AINV 120,726 482,906
REPAYMENT OF PHAIDON UNE
REDEMPTION - LOAN CASCADE
MONTHLY DISBURSEMENTS
FCI CAPITAL CALL
COF III CONINVEST III CAPITAL CALL (5,000,000)
ATHENE CAPITAL CALL (40,000,000)
TENFORE CAPITAL CALL (250,000) (500,000)
FAMILY OFFICE (183,000) (183,000) (183,000) (183,000) (183,000) (2,230,000)
NET CASH BY MONTH (433,000) (183,000) (62,274) (183,000) (183,000)
CASH BALANCE (5,261,009) (5,444,009) (5,506,283) (5,689,283) (5,872,283)
(31,019,094)
RESIDUAL FUNDING OF ATHENE - MAY BOF
Page 2 of 2
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ari Glass [finance] Boothbay manager whom Epstein called "a bit sketchy" but invested $50 million with 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01088824 (Jmail)
 [finance] Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies Fund pitch deck
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
B
BOOTHBAY FUND MANAGEMENT. LLC
Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies, LP
OVERVIEW PRESENTATION
As of December 31 . 2015
• IIIITIM.Tifer
" 1 144 9 74,_ --# 4
yirgeff
yo.
• ---•;?25600"-Ir. __-. •
-•.:;4212irliar STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL. NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION.
B IMPORTANT DISCLAIMERS
THIS DOCUMENT IS NOT AN OFFER TO SELL OR THE SOLICITATION OF AN OFFER TO BUY INTERESTS IN BOOTHBAY ABSOLUTE RETURN 
STRATEGIES, LP OR ITS
SUBSIDIARIES (TOGETHER, THE "FUND"). AN OFFERING OF INTERESTS WILL BE MADE ONLY BY MEANS OF A CONFIDENTIAL PRIVATE 
OFFERING MEMORANDUM
AND ONLY TO QUALIFIED INVESTORS IN JURISDICTIONS WHERE PERMITTED BY LAW.
An investment in the Fund is speculative and involves a high degree of risk. The Fund will have substantial limitations 
on investors' ability to redeem or
transfer their
investments, and no secondary market for the Fund's interests exists or will develop. All of these risks, and other 
important risks, are described in detail in
the Fund's
Confidential Private Offering Memorandum. Prospective investors are strongly urged to review the Confidential Private 
Offering Memorandum carefully and consult
with
their own financial, legal and tax advisors, before investing.
There can be no assurances that the Fund will have a return on invested capital similar to the returns of other accounts
managed by An Glass or Boothbay Fund
Management LLC (together with its affiliates. "Boothbay") because, among other reasons, there may be differences in 
investment policies, economic conditions,
regulatory
climate, portfolio size, portfolio managers, leverage and expenses. In addition, there is no guarantee that Boothbay 
will succeed in attracting portfolio
managers or that it
will be able to construct a successful platform of portfolio managers. The fact that other accounts managed by Ari Glass
or Boothbay have realized gains In the
past Is not
an indication that the Fund will realize any gains In the future. Prior performance Is not necessarily Indicative of 
future results.
The material contained herein is confidential and for sole use of the recipient. No portion of this material may be 
reproduced, copied, distributed, modified or
made
available to others without express written consent of Boothbay. This material is not meant as a general guide to 
investing, or as a source of any specific
investment
recommendation, and makes no implied or express recommendations concerning the matter in which any accounts should or 
would be handled.
This document contains certain forward -looking statements and projections. Such statements and projections are subject 
to a number of assumptions, risks and
uncertainties which may cause actual results, performance or achievements to be materially different from future 
results, performance or achievements expressed
or
implied by these forward -looking statements and projections. Prospective investors are cautioned not to invest based on
these forward -looking statements
and projections.
The information in this document is current as of the date listed on the cover page and is subject to change or 
amendment. Inception•to•date (ITD) information
relates to the
period between July 1. 2014 and the date listed on the cover page of this document. The delivery of this document at any
time does not imply that the
information contained
herein is correct at any time subsequent to such date. Certain information contained herein has been supplied to 
Boothbay by third parties. While Boothbay
believes such
sources are reliable, it cannot guarantee the accuracy of any such information and does not represent that such 
information is accurate or complete.
Distribution of this information to any person other than the person to whom this information was originally delivered 
or to such person's advisors is
unauthorized and any
reproduction of these materials, in whole or in part, or the disclosure of any of the contents, without the express, 
prior written consent of Boothbay in each
such instance is
prohibited. Receipt of this document by an investor domiciled or with a registered office in the EEA is solely in 
response to a request for information about
the Fund which
was initiated by such investor.
B TABLE OF CONTENTS
FIRM OVERVIEW
FUND EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Page 4
LEADERSHIP TEAM I Page 5
PERFORMANCE HIGHLIGHTS I Page 6
DOWNSIDE PROTECTION I Page 7
INVESTMENT PHILOSOPHY SUMMARY I Page 8
INVESTMENT STRATEGY SUMMARY I Page 9
MANAGER SELECTION PROCESS I Page 10
RISK MANAGEMENT I Page 11
PORTFOLIO CONSTRUCTION I Page 12
FUND TERMS I Page 13
APPENDIX I Pages 15 to 20
Page 3
B FIRM OVERVIEW
B
Boothbay Absolute Return Strategies, LP ("Boothbay") is a market
neutral multi -strategy fund, launched in July 2014 by An Glass to effectively combine
and optimize alternative investment strategies into a single product with superior, non-
correlated risk-adjusted returns. Mr. Glass brings decades of operating and investing
experience to Boothbay, where he and his team use a combination of proprietary
technology and qualitative judgment to identify and invest in talented emerging
investment managers. Allocations are made through a managed accounts structure,
creating diverse alpha streams within a cohesive portfolio. Boothbay currently
allocates to over eighty managers.
N.
B FUND EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Boothbay enhances the benefits of manager diversification by investing in uncorrelated
alternative strategies, that provide alpha generation from independent return sources
UNIQUE
STRATEGY
EFFICIENT
STRUCTURE
PROVEN
TRACK RECORD
ACTIVE
RISK MANAGEMENT

• A global, market neutral, multi -strategy fund that seeks to produce stable returns with low volatility by dynamically
allocating
capital across 80+ managers and strategies within a single product

• Focuses largely on emerging managers with expertise across many industries and geographies
• Leverages experience and knowledge with emerging managers to structure allocations with competitive terms and capacity
A proprietary portfolio construction tool, based on manager position and return analytics helps to optimize investment 
allocations

• Allocations can be made via a down side protected 'first -loss' capital allocation tool (slide 15)
• Daily position -level transparency enables market neutral stance (+/-10% beta adjusted net exposure)

• Operational efficiency derived from the cross-margining of managed accounts allows for dynamic allocations

• Managed account structure removes operational risk often associated with emerging managers
• Boothbay l 2015 return of 10.08% vs. S&P 500 23 2015 return of -0.73%

• Intense focus on risk management was a factor in having a worst month loss of less than 50 bps'
• Beta of 0.01 to the S&P 500 1.2.3

• Proprietary systematic risk infrastructure assesses risk at the position, manager and overall fund levels

• Customized terms and risk parameters (exposure, concentration, liquidity) are implemented for every manager
• Active risk budgeting process uses covariance matrix to optimize manager selection, distribute allocations and manage
concentrations

1. See Endnote I on page 22 foe important information.
2. See Endnote 2 on page 22 for important information.
3. The SW 500 is an American stock market index based on the market cepa/Mations of 500 large companies haying common 
stock kited on the NYSE or NASDAO. The 5&P
500 index components and their weightings
are determined by 5&P Dow Jones Indices
In=
B LEADERSHIP I LAM
Ad Glass brings over 18 years of industry experience in manager selection, asset allocation, risk
management, and operations
ARI GLASS
Founder & Managing Member
SHANE BURN
Head of Manager Research & Risk
DANIEL BLOOM
Chief Financial Officer
EDGAR HAJJAR
Head of Programming & Development
RESPONSIBILITIES
Supervises manager allocations and
portfolio construction decisions
Head of fundamental strategies
Established capabilities in key
investment allocation metrics
Influence in the marketplace to
negotiate and structure terms with
underlying managers
Oversees firm's research process
Head of quantitative strategies
Head of risk governance
Insight into alternative traits and
evaluation methodologies
Manages financial reporting and
related processes
Maintains appropriate internal controls
Coordinates activities with external
auditors and service providers
Develops multi -tiered applications to
support operations and trading
Creation of automated stock borrow
and trading tool -sets
CAREER HIGHLIGHTS
From 2000 to 2007, Chief Operating
Officer of Intrepid Capital Management.
a Soros seeded Tiger Cub and $2.5
billion hedge fund
In 2004, launched Intrepid Associates,
identified and developed new portfolio
manager talent
From 2007-2009. focused on new
strategy identification as President at
Platinum, an award -winning hedge
fund, with approximately $750 million
in assets under management
Portfolio Manager, Statistical Arbitrage,
at Double Alpha from 2002-2003
From 2004-2007. Senior Analyst at
ACAM Advisors hedge fund of funds
Managing Director at Lake Hill Capital.
heading research functions, 2011-2012
Chief Investment Officer at Insana
Capital Partners, responsible for
investment platforms and portfolios
From 2004 to 2007. managed the
operations at Altrinsic Global Advisors.
a $7bn investment management firm
From 2007 to 2011 at Deloitte and
Touche LLP. advised companies
related to operations, technology
and compliance
Over ten years of enhancing the front -
to-back office operations of global
financial institutions; Globeop, UBS &
Alliance Bernstein
Project Lead. MF Global, 2001 to 2006.
building trading systems with Sarbanes
Oxley compliant functionality
VP of Systems at Fortis Bank. 2006 to
2009, managing trading technology
developers across middle and back -
office systems

Sr. Project Manager, OTO Financial,
2009 to 2012, heading algorithmic.
high -frequency trading development
and writing FIX engines
N.
PERFORMANCE HIGHLIGHTS
Boothbay has delivered superior risk -adjusted returnsl across various market conditions
compared to other relevant indices 2
SUPERIOR RISK ADJUSTED RETURNS (ITD)1. 2
£ 10%
a re 8%
6%
4%
et 2%
0%
.2%
-4%
Boothbayl
■
HFRX Absolute
Return°
■
Boothbay Sharpe
ratio (LTD) 3.31
S&P SOO Index'
■
HFRX Global
Hedge Fund'
IN
.6%
0.0% 2.0% 4.0% 6.0% 8.0% 10.0% 12.0% 14.0%
Annualized Standard Deviation
0
RETURNS DISTRIBUTION (ITD)1•2
9
a
7
6
5
3
2

• Boolhbay • S&P 500 Index 3
0
a
1 1 d<-1% -1%b-D.5% -0.5% la 0% 0% le 0.5% 0.5% t01% >1%
Nel Monthly Return
EQUITY CURVE (ITD)la
115%
110%
105%
100%
95%
90%
Boothbay I — — — S&P 500 Index 3 - HFRX Absolute Return - HFRX Global Hedge Fund
s
•••
•••
•••
••• •
•-• •
•

• _ - - •
Jul -14 Aug -14 Sep -14 Oct -14 Nov -14 Dec -14 Jan -15 Feb -15 Mar -15 Apr -15 May -15 Jun -15 Jul -15 Aug -15 Sep -15 
Oct -15 Nov -15 Dec -15

1. See Endnote Ion page 22 for mpanant information.
2. Sec Erb:Moto 2 on page 22 for mpanant information
3.1he SIP 500 is an American Cock market index based co the market capealizations of 500Iarge companes havingcommon 
stock kited on the NYSE or NASDAO. The S&P
SOO index components and their weghtings are determined by SSP Dow Jones
Indices.
4 The HFRX - Absolute Return is an nclex consInJoted ay Hedge Fund Research. Inc. that eXhitrtS lanai volatilities 
andIowa( coodatons to stars:laid drectenal
benchmarks of away market and hedge fund ndustryeederrnance.

S. The HFRX - GebelHodge Fund is an MGM* constructed by Kedge Fund Research. Inc_ designed to be representave of the 
meted composition of the hedge fund unwise.
It is composed of al Nigel* hedge fund nonage:. Including WI not limited to
convert/ale arising*. distressed seCUM10; CCIU/ty httl9C. CCIU/ty 11131k01 natal CVOrlt Wheel% macro. merger arbitrage. 
and relative ratio aragiage. The
suategas are asset weighted based on the distneuten of assets in the hedge fund industry.
DOWNSIDE PROTECTION
Boothbay has historically generated returns with low variability and has protected capital
during market downturns
DEMONSTRATED LOW VOLATILITY 2
3.99% • HFRX Global Fund
ITD
2.25%
11.88% HFRX Absolute Return

• S&P 500 Index -__MEN 4.49%
YTD 13.66% • Boothbay
81%
4.80%
6 Months 17.11%
0.71%
5.09%
3 Months
101%
18.56%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30%
Annualized Standard Deviation by Period
DOWNSIDE PROTECI1ON (ITD) 2

• BoothbayS&P 500 Index
HFRX Absolute Return° ■ HFRX Global Hedge Funds
MONTHLY RETURNS WHEN S&P500 DOWN

• Boothbay'
-5%
-7%
Jul-14 Sep -14

I. See Endnote Ion page 22 for important information.
2. See Endnote 2 on page 22 for important information.

3. The SSP 500 6 an American stock market index based on the market capitalizations of 500 large companies having common
stock listed on the NYSE or NASDAQ. Tne
S&P 500 index components and their weightings
are determined by S&P Dow Jones Indices.

4. The HFRX - Absolute Return is an index constructed by Hedge Fund Research. Inc. that exhibits lower volatiities and 
lower correlations to standard
directional benchmarks of equity market and hedge fund industry
performance.

5. The HFRX - Global Hedge Fund 6 an index constructed by Hedge Fund Research. Inc. designed to be representative of the
overall composition of the hedge fund
universe. It is comprised of as eligible hedge fund
strategies. including but not limited to convertible arbitrage. distressed securities.equity hedge. equity market 
neutral event driven, macro, merger arbitrage,
and relative value arbitrage. The strategies ere asset weighted
based on the distribution of assets in the hedge fund industry.

• S&P 500 Index 3
Dec -14 Jan-15 Mar-15 Jun-15 Aug-15 Sep-15 Dec -15
B INVESTMENT PHILOSOPHY SUMMARY
Boothbay believes that superior portfolio construction involves integrating non -correlated
strategies by unifying diverse alpha streams
THERE ARE FOUR FOUNDATIONAL TENETS OF BOOTHBAY'S PHILOSOPHY
BOOTHBAY BELIEVES:

(1) DYNAMIC MANAGEMENT
of Intended Idiosyncratic Exposures is Key to Performance

• Boothbay believes that beta is highly correlated, especially in
times of stress - idiosyncratic alpha is not

• Use stringent selection criteria to identify superior
managers with the ability to consistently capitalize on specific
market inefficiencies

• Selected managers generally derive alpha from diverse
drivers that typically move independently of each other

(2) EMERGING MANAGERS
Possess a Distinct Advantage which Boothbay utilizes

• Boothbay believes that smaller managers have greater
upside return dispersion than their larger counterparts

• Nimble size often facilitates greater agility to take measured
risks and move swiftly to capture unique opportunities

• Smaller managers can invest in less crowded ideas without
sacrificing liquidity
• Compelling negotiating economics exist with emerging
managers, which can lead to greater net return potential

(3) STRATEGIC ALLOCATIONS

• Capital is deployed based on manager background, strategy
timing, volatility, and correlations to market and to other
strategies

• Individual managers operate within negotiated risk-
parameters for optimized capital efficiency
• Active hedging employed, within the context of the overall
portfolio, targeting market neutral exposure
(4) STRUCTURE MATTERS

• Boothbay believes that managed accounts enable more
reliable, real-time measurement of risk, correlations, and
returns

• The cross-margin aspect of managed structure provides
greater capital efficiency
• Boothbay believes that this structure removes operational
risk often associated with emerging managers
B INVESTMENT STRATEGY SUMMARY
CAPITAL ALLOCATION BY STRATEGY & SUB-STRATEGY'
European On* Stat Arb Eq Stet Arb
MK StatArb Lf S Cc FX Systematic
Eq StetAft • CTA
Ouant MulF str at
Global StatArb
Eq Stet Arb•ADRAtb '``
Japanese Eq sty Stat Arb
CIA
Equty Tec
US Equty0werstfied
Intraday Egip
ST Cattily...
CurrencyArbitraye
CEF MDNage
Index Rebel
SpecialSts
EncrgyTradnu
CEF Arb
Quantitative
29%
Other
22%
LevetecIETF Aett anacion  USEquity/4March
US Equity Fnancets
Low Net
Fundamental LS
49%

• Percentage allocations of Boothbay as of 12/31/15. Percentages reflect LP
equivalent allocations and does not include First Loss allocations
US Equity- PAT
US Equty- GbbalUtlities
-.SECILlity. market neutral
US &tidy - Consumer
US Equity • ROTS
L/S Equty- Biotech
US Equly SmalCap
US Eqult SpeoalStuations
US Equty- Energy
US Equly Diversified
US Equity
US Equity Europe
US Equty US Dallies
US EquityAs ia
I
ni
NUMBER OF MANAGERS
GEOGRAPHIC BREAKDOWN (GM))
Multi -Strategy
71
Asia
8%
2';
US &Canada
85%
B MANAGER SELECTION PROCESS
Boothbay utilizes a four-step process to allocate to managers who seem to demonstrate
disciplined risk management and repeatable strong performance that Boothbay believes is
likely to persist
MANAGER SOURCING EVALUATION
FOUR TO EIGHT WEEKS
ONBOARDING TRADING/MONITORING
Ongoing Qualitative Quantitative Negotiated Terms Ongoing

• High quality of new idea flow • Style and strategy • Track record • Trading/position limit construction • Dynamic 
capital allocation

• Avoid negative sourcing bias • Robustness of philosophy • Measure risks taken • Technology requirements • Active limit
monitoring

• Depth of experience • Position/sector • Market access • Performance monitoring
Strong Sourcing Network • Quality of the team concentration • Reporting • Correlation monitoring

• Referrals • Investment approach • Geographic exposures • Pre-trading tests • Risk management
• Managers • Portfolio construction • Leverage usage • Prime Broker selection • Exposure monitoring

• Allocators • Risk discipline • Retum analysis • Investment • Compliance attestation
• Service Providers • Operational controls • COBRA (in-house system) Management Agreement

• Prime Brokers
• Conferences
• Trading guidelines
• Infrastructure
• Statistical assessment
• Correlation analysis

• First loss structure, or hybrid,
if merited
• Industry Press • Volatility analysis • Rights to future capacity
Investment Team • Liquidity analysis
Screening • Max VaR/Max drawdown

• Call(s)
• Meeting(s)
• Investment
Committee review
• Understand
manager's edge
• Background checks
• Professional references
N.
B RISK MANAGEMENT
Boothbay's multi -tiered risk framework is used to manage a balance between risks and
opportunity. Risk Management is a core function at Boothbay and is rooted in all key decisions
POSITION & MANAGER LEVEL PORTFOLIO LEVEL ORGANIZATIONAL
Contemporary Risk Measuring Coordination
Recognize and Respond to Risks Signals in Real-time
Ongoing Oversight and Weekly Risk Meeting
Exposures measured against coded
parameters, continuously
Diversification of positions and sources of return
Hedging at the position level
Bespoke risk guidelines set for over 80 portfolio
managers at the strategy level

• Maximum Position Limits
• Exposures
• Position Trading Liquidity
• Leverage
Scenario analysis to define probabilities of outcomes
Ability to map the portfolio into risk estimation
mechanisms, tracking positions and exposures
across multiple managers
Cutting edge analytical tools bring together qualitative
and quantitative methods
Enhanced efficiency through unified integration and
daily data consistency
Hedging of excess unwanted factor exposures
Risk guidelines set at the portfolio level with rigorous
monitoring

• Leverage and Margin
• Liquidity
• Exposures
• Correlations
Resourced with a dedicated risk and operations team.
including three analysts with coding skills
Demonstrated culture of awareness and proper
controls with an understanding of risk complexities
Written policies and procedures

• Trading and operations
• Disaster Recovery Plan
• Trading and Operations
Service providers carefully selected and monitored

• Independent Administrator
• Prime Brokers and Counterparties
• Legal and Compliance
• Auditor
N.
B PORTFOLIO CONSTRUCTION
Dynamic Hedging
Residual factors and market
beta hedged at portfolio level
Portfolio Optimization
Allocation scenario analysis
Maximize Sortino and Sharpe Ratios
Integrated Risk Metrics
Continuous across SMAs
Volatility based position sizing
Regression Analysis
Multiple predictor variables
Robust factor decomposition
Continuous Risk Management
Multiple portfolio return and distribution
characteristics monitored daily
Daily Statistics
Correlation, Beta, Sortino, Sharpe,
Calmar, Max drawdown, Win Rates on
up/down days
Manager Assessment
Exposures, correlations and other
position•based drill downs
Idiosyncratic Allocations
Identification of desired
strategic exposures
N.
B FUND TERMS
SUBSCRIPTIONS Monthly
MINIMUM INVESTMENT I $1,000,000 (at discretion of general partner to accept lower amounts)
HIGH WATER MARK I Yes
FEES: 2-YEAR LOCK UP I 0.25% per quarter (approximately 1% annually) management fees and 14.0% incentive allocation 
(1-Year lock available)
EXPENSES I Pass through expense model
ADMINISTRATOR I NAV Consulting Inc.
AUDITOR I KPMG
LEGAL COUNSEL I Kleinberg, Kaplan, Wolff & Cohen...
PRIME BROKER
UBS
BNP Paribas
Other
N.
...g-„a.
St
XICINaddV
B FIRST LOSS PROGRAM
The First Loss program aims to provide downside protection and capital efficiency
STRUCTURE
ACCOUNT LOSSES
HYBRID ALLOCATIONS

• Manager is generally required to provide capital to the Boothbay of up to 10% of the total managed account size, in an
effort to protect investors against losses up to that same amount. In exchange, the manager receives a relatively high
percentage of profits generated

• Example: Boothbay offers $10MM managed account to manager A. Manager A is required to provide $1MM to Boothbay,
and account is terminated if Manager A looses $900K (with real time risk information monitored by Boothbay)

• Non linear risk / reward ratio, making greater leverage appropriate on this strategy
• Capital efficiency and cross margining means relatively little equity is required from the Boothbay

• The manager's capital account is allocated all losses in the managed account up to capital invested, after which the
account may generally be terminated. This reduces the risk to the Boothbay's capital

• Systems and stop outs are in place to enable Boothbay to generally curtail risk of further losses beyond amount of
manager capital provided

• While Boothbay may give away relative excess upside on the trade, if monitored correctly, generally losses to 
investors
should be minimized

• Hybrid deals are an allocation managers receive that combines first-loss and traditional allocation terms
• Benefits include manager recruiting edge and strong risk / reward ratio
B PERFORMANCE AND RISK STATISTICS
MONTHLY NET RETURNS'
JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN JUL AUG SEPT OCT NOV DEC YTD ITD
2014 -0.28% 0.28% -0.34% -0.49% 1.00% 1.34% 1.50%
2015 0.81% 1.54% 1.46% 0.42% 1.75% 0.06% 0.52% 0.75% 0.67% 0.34% 0.89% 0.45%
2016
10.08% 11.74%
Esti .-.,,ted monthly re,,,m
PERFORMANCE STATISTICS 1'2
Performance Statistics
Cumulative Net Total Return
Boothbay
Average Annualized Net Return
Percentage of Up Months
Percentage of Down Months
Best Month Net Return
Worst Month Net Return
Standard Deviation
Sharpe Ratio
Sortino
Calmer Ratio
Largest Consecutive Gain
Largest Drawdown
Beta to SPX
spx3 HFRX Index
Absolute  Return  Index °
HFRX Index
Global  Hedge  Fund
11.74% 4.27% 1.81% -5.86%
7.68% 2.83% 1.21% -3.95%
83% 50% 61% 39%
17% 50% 39% 61%
1.75% 8.30% 1.15% 2.02%
-0.49% -6.26% -0.65% -2.2t%
2.25% 11.88% 1.82% 3.99%
3.31 0.29 0.67 -0.99
13.84 0S0 t.22 418
9.26 0.32 t.02 -0.65
12.67% 9.15% 3.82% 2.84%
-0.83% -8.89% 418% -6.04%
0.01 1.00 0.07 0.27

I. See Endnote Ion page 21 for Imponant information.
2. See Endnote 2 on page 21 for important information.

3. The S&P 500 is an American stock market index based on the market capitalizations of 500 large companies having 
COMMOO stock listed on the NYSE or NASDAQ.
The S&P 500 index components and their weightings
are determined by S&P Dow Jones Indices.

4. The HFRX - Absolute Rebrn is an index constructed by Hedge Fund Research, Inc. that exhibit lower volatilnies and 
lower correlations to standard cirectional
benchmarks of equity market and hedge fund industry
performance.
5. The HFRX - Global Hedge Fund is an Index constructed by Hedge Fund Research. Inc. designed to be representative of 
the overall composition of the hedge fund
universe. It is comprised of all eligtile hedge fund
strategies: including but not invited to convenible arbitrage. distressed securities. equhy hedge, equity market 
neutral. event driven. macro. merger arbitrage.
and relative value arbitrage. The strategies are asset weighted
based on the dstribution of assets in the hedge fund industry.
■-
B MANAGEMEN I BIOGRAPHIES
ARI GLASS
Managing Member
SHANE BURN
Head of Manager
Research and Diligence,
Investment Committee
Member
Ari Glass is the founding partner and managing member of Boothbay. Boothbay was founded in 2012 to manage assets for two
families and in July 2014 launched the Fund to include outside investors. At Boothbay, Mr. Glass is responsible for 
overall portfolio
allocations and construction, for managing the Investment Team and overseeing the manager sourcing, monitoring and 
selection
processes. Mr. Glass runs Boothbay's strategy, business development and distribution arrangements.
Previously, Mr. Glass served as President of Paine Heights Management LLC, initially a part of Platinum Management (NY) 
LLC
(Platinum"). While at Paine Heights, Mr. Glass oversaw many of the company's interests, including the management of a 
special
opportunity hedge fund that invested in the SPAC marketplace and, through a subsidiary, advised on a transaction in the 
New Jersey
Solar Energy sector. From 2007 through 2009, Mr. Glass was the President of Platinum, where in addition to overseeing 
all non -
investing activities he shared responsibilities for asset allocation and risk management, including the selection of 
portfolio managers
for Platinum's Multi -Manager private investment funds. While Mr. Glass was President of Platinum, the fund won two 
industry awards
for Multi Strategy Fund of the Year. Prior to joining Platinum, from 2000 to 2007, Mr. Glass served as the Chief 
Operating Officer of
Intrepid Capital Management (*Intrepid"), a $2.5 billion hedge fund organization seeded by Soros Fund Management and 
spun out of
Tiger Management. At Intrepid. Mr. Glass oversaw all non•portfolio related activities. In 2004. Mr. Glass launched 
Intrepid Associates.
an affiliated entity that added fund managers to Intrepid's platform, including sector funds in the healthcare and 
global
utilities spaces.
From April 1998 until August 2000. Mr. Glass worked as Chief Financial Officer at Vector Capital Management ("Vector"), 
a statistical
arbitrage hedge fund in Norwalk. CT. Mr. Glass graduated from Queens College. with honors, with a B.A. in Accounting and
Information Systems.
Shane Burn joined Boothbay in 2014 and is the Head of Manager Research and Diligence and a member of the Investment
Committee. Mr. Burn has over 20 years of experience on Wall Street. He was most recently a Managing Director at Lake 
Hill Capital.
Prior to that, he served as Chief Financial Officer at Titan Capital and Chief Investment Officer of Insana Capital 
Partners fund of
hedge funds. Prior to Insana, he was a Senior Analyst at ACAM Advisors fund of hedge funds. Prior experience includes: 
Double
Alpha Group, where he was a senior trader and assistant portfolio manager in Statistical Arbitrage; J.P. Morgan 
Securities, where he
was a Vice President in the Equity Derivatives Group: and Niederhoffer Investments, where he traded currencies, futures 
and options
for the funds as a proprietary trader. Mr. Bum began his career in 1988 at Sanford Bernstein as a Portfolio Management 
Administrator
for high -net-worth equity and bond portfolios. Mr. Burn has an M.B.A in Finance from the Stern School of Business at 
New York
University, where he was a Leonard N. Stern Scholar, and an undergraduate degree in Economics from Johns Hopkins 
University.
N.
B MANAGEMENT BIOGRAPHIES
DANIEL BLOOM
Chief Financial Officer
EDGAR HAJJAR
Head of Programming
& Development
MICHAEL LWIN
Quantitative & Risk Analyst
FREDERICK RICHARDSON
Business Development
Daniel Bloom is the Chief Financial Officer and a Partner in Boothbay and has been with the firm since inception. He 
manages all
financial and operational related activities of Boothbay. From 2007 to 2011. Mr. Bloom was with Deloitte and Touche LLP 
in their
advisory practice. with a specific focus on the investment management industry. He advised companies with their 
strategies as they
related to operations, technology and compliance. From 2004 to 2007. Mr. Bloom managed the operations at Altrinsic 
Global
Advisors, an investment management firm with approximately $7 billion under management, that manages both long and long 
-short
global equity portfolios. Previously. Mr. Bloom held various positions at Globeop. UBS and Alliance Bernstein. Daniel is
a CPA in New
York and graduated with honors from Yeshiva University.
Edgar Hajjar joined Boothbay in January 2012 and has twenty-five years of experience in both business and technology
management. He has worked as a banker, trader and analyst as well as a software developer. His expertise consists of 
department
operations and technology implementations. His background includes extensive understanding in managing corporate 
business and
financial operations, establishing and directing technology programs, and leading IT and business functions. His 
background in
finance and his technical knowledge allow him to develop and deliver multi -tiered applications that support both our 
operations as
well as our traders. He has created several databases as well as applications that support daily operations, 
reconciliations, analytics,
historical market data management. automated stock borrow services as well as our proprietary trading platform.
Michael Lwin joined Boothbay in January 2012, developing statistical and operational tools for portfolio construction, 
risk assessment,
and compliance monitoring, as well as researching market phenomenon and current financial literature. Mr. Lwin was an 
integral
component in building COBRA. Boothbay's proprietary portfolio optimization application. Prior to joining the team at 
Boothbay, he
interned at The CME Group (NY location) as a Settlement Analyst. where he optimized preexisting code. automated data 
acquisition
procedures across multiple platforms, and presented exotic derivative products upcoming on the exchange to the 
settlement team.

Mr. Lwin earned his Masters degree in Financial Engineering from Baruch College having transitioned from an academic 
career in
Applied Mathematics and Physics.
Frederick Richardson joined Boothbay in July 2013. He received his BSc in Biochemistry from The University of Leeds, 
England. Mr.
Richardson is responsible for managing the Business Development and Investor Relations. Mr. Richardson also manages 
sourcing of
managers for Boothbay with a focus on building new and current relationships for Boothbay.
B ENDNOTES

1. All returns in this document assume an investment at inception in Class 1A (2-year lock -up) and are net of a 1.00% 
annual management fee and a 14% incentive
allocation. Such returns are net of expenses and reflect the reinvestment of dividends, capital gains and other earnings
and assumes "new issues" eligibility.
Performance for an individual investor may differ due to, among other things, the timing of subscriptions and 
withdrawals, applicable management fees and
performance compensation rates and the extent to which an investor may participate in "new issues." Past performance is 
not indicative of future results. All
performance values or the Fund other than any annual values reported for the year -ended December 31, 2014 are based on 
unaudited data.

2. The benchmark indices included herein have not been selected to represent appropriate benchmarks against which to 
compare the Fund's performance. but are
included to allow for comparison of the Funds' performance to that of certain well-known indices. Comparisons to indices
have limitations because the
composition of
indices (for example, in terms of number and type of securities) and the volatility and other material characteristics 
of indices may differ substantially from
the Fund. In
addition, unlike the Fund, which is actively managed and may periodically maintain cash positions, indices are unmanaged
and are fully invested. Therefore.
performance of the Fund may differ substantially from the performance of an index. Because of these differences, an 
index's returns should not be viewed as a
representation that the Fund's portfolio is comparable to the securities comprising such index and should not be relied 
upon as an accurate measure of
comparison.

3. The sector and strategy exposure charts should not be construed as providing any assurance or guarantee as to the 
composition of the Fund's portfolios in the
future.
Actual portfolio composition may, and at times will, differ from such historical exposures.
B CONTACT INFORMATION
Boothbay Fund Management, LLC
810 7th Avenue
6th Floor
New York. NY 1O019
FREDERICK RICHARDSON
Office:
E-mail:
EFTA01357341 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
Activity Page 1 of 2
Fis Prime Compliance Suite
Add New I Create Case I Activity Report I Close
GENERAL MORECATANS TWAIS AUOTT NOTES
Activity: • 12546601
Transaction No:
Customer Id:
Assovntldi
Paymt Method:
Cash Trani
Wan Ref:
Related Ref: j11961251
Party Information
Onoinator
Name: wog JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Account:
Customer Id: Id:
Address:
Previous Next O
Branch:
Cust Name:
Book Date: 1923/2016
Value Date:
Tran Date:
Instructions:
v Department:
(BT Money Transfer Omni Account
Recy/Pay:
Base Amount:
Currency:
Flt Amount:
1,700.00
9/23/2016 USD
9/24/2016 4:10:16 AM
cT00 RED ICON [(TR, E3 SAINT 7i-KVAS
00802 UNITED STATES VIRGIN ISLANDS
ci ty:
State: 1ST THOMAS Zip:
Country:
Originator Bank
Id:
Name: 'LEGAL WORKSTATION
Beneficiary
Name: FI ROLAY ALEKSANDROVICH GYROV
Account:
Customer Id: Id: I
Address:
CitV: r---
State:
Country:
Beneficiary Bank
Id:
Zip: I
Name: ISBERBANK OF RUSSIA
Account: II Account:
Customer Id:
Address:
City:
state:
Country:
la
Customer Id: I
rAddress: `•, LfIERTI :;ATER )." ;CIA' 17
City: 'MOSCOW
State: zip: I
v
zip: 1117997
V
Sender's Correspondent Receiver's Correspondent
Id:
Name:
Account:
Customer Id:
Address:
ci ty:
State:
Country:
Id:
Name:
Account:
Customer Id:
Address:
City:
State:
Country: I
I
Zip: I
V
Zip: I
https://primebsapro.svc.db.com/primecompliancesuite/Activity.aspx?RecordlD=12546601... 3/16/2017
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0043820
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY GM_00190004
EFTA01656409 (Jmail)
 [government] FinCEN Suspicious Activity Report filed by Deutsche Bank about Darren Indyke for structured transactions
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
FinCEN I Financial C rimes Enforcement Network
United Saws ()Tatman of& Ttmury
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000110544793 and DCN:
Filing Information
Type of Report Continuing Activity Report
Filing Date 08/17/2017
Received Date 08/17/2017
Entry Date 08/18/2017
Amended Prior BSA ID: 31000106384765
Submission Method Electronic discrete filing
Subject Information
Subject 1 of 1 Indyke
Role Subject
Subject Type Other
Individual/Organization Individual
Last(or Entity) Name Indyke
First Name Darren
Middle Name K
Alternate Name(s) Alternate Name Darren K. Indyke PLLC
Gender Type Male
Date of Birth
SSN/ITIN
Form(s) of Identification Identification 1 of 2
Identification Type Driver's license/State ID
Identification Number
Issuing State Code NJ
Issuing State New Jersey
Issuing Country Code US
Identification 2 of 2
Identification Type Other
Identification Number 300503849
Other Text The Lawfirm's TIN
Issuing Country Code US
Address(es) Address 1 of 2
Address Type Subject permanent/mailin • address
Street Address
City
Page 1 The enclosed mformation was corrected and disseminated under provision: of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and 
U.S. Department of the Treasury regaations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The mformation is sensitive m nature and is to be treats accadingly. The information 
may be used only fa a purpose con ustent
with acr.nnal. tax. or regulatory
mvestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of mtelligence or countermtelligence activities. incluctIg analysis, to 
protect against mtemational terrorism. See
31 U S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of Financial Crimes 
Enforcement Netwakor his authorized
delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of passtle criminal 
activity. akin to confidential informant
tips. Unauthorized release of information
collected wider the BSA may result in criminal or civil :webs:.
ULM/9011000 LE AISEI
FinCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network
United Stain pepsnum dtc Ticasuty
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000110544793 and DCN:
Subject Information
State
ZIP Code
Country US
US - Enhanced
Address 2 of 2
Address Type Subject permanent/mailing address
Street Address
City
State
ZIP Code
Country US
US - Enhanced
Occupation/Type of Business Attorney
Corroborative Statement to
Filer
No
Relationship to Reporting
Institution(s)
Institution TIN 134941247
Relationship of Subject Customer. Yes
Affected Account(s) Account Numb
Financial Institution TIN 134941247
Suspicious Activity Information
Amount Involved $15,000
Cumulative Amount $38,000
Date or Date Range of Activity 06/21/2017 - 06/23/2017
Structuring Other. Ongoing structuring concern
Financial instrument or
payment mechanism
Personal/Business check
Activity Location
Financial Institution Location 1 of 1
No Branch Activity Involved Yes
Type of Financial Institution Depository institution
Page 2 The enclosed mformation was caected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (Me SSA) and U.S. 
Department of the Treasury reguLations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U S C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The mformation is sensitive n nature and is to be treats accordingly. The information 
may be used only for a purpose con ustent
with a crrnmat. tax. or regulatory
nvestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of ntelligence or counterntelligence activities. inclueng analysis, to 
protect against ntemational terrorism. See
31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of Fnancial Crates 
Enforcement Network or his authorized
delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of passtle criminal 
activity. akin to ccofidential informant
tips. Unauthorized release of information
collected wider the BSA may result in criminsi or civil :webs:.
£6L4450LL000L£ VS9
FinCEN I Financial C rimes Enforcement Network
Wuxi Sues Deptantau due Tiegouty
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000110544793 and DCN:
Activity Location
Primary Regulator Federal Reserve
RSSD Number 214807
Legal Name Deutsche Bank Trust Co. Americas
EIN 134941247
Address Address Type Address where transaction occurred
Street Address 60 Wall Street
60 WALL ST - Enhanced
City New York
NEW YORK - Enhanced
State NY
NY - Enhanced
ZIP Code 10005-2858
10005-2858 - Enhanced
Country US
US - Enhanced
Internal Control File Number SP 2641
Loss To Financial Institution $0
Filer Information
Primary Regulator Federal Reserve
Filer Name Deutsche Bank Trust Co. Americas
EIN 134941247
Address Address Type Reporting party address
Street Address 60 Wall Street
60 WALL ST - Enhanced
City New York
NEW YORK - Enhanced
State NY
NY - Enhanced
ZIP Code 10005-2858
10005-2858 - Enhanced
Country US
US - Enhanced
Type of Financial Institution Depository institution
RSSD Number 214807
Internal controVfile number SP 2641
Contact for Assistance Full Name AMLCentral
Page 3 The enclosed eformaticn was colected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and U.S.
Department of the Treasury regulations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The eformation is sensitive .1 nature and is to be treated accordingly. The information
may be used only for a purpose con
ustent with a criweal, tax. or regulatory
evestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of etelligence or counteretelligence activities. inclueng analysis. to 
protect against eternational terrorism. See
31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. dixIo--ed. or transmitted without pro; approval of the Director of Feancial Crates 
Enforcement Network or his authorized
delegate_ Suspicious activity reports feed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of par...sable criminal
activity. akin to cceklenbal informant
tips_ Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
£6L4450LL000LE VS9
FinCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network
United Sates Depairmaic ti the To:gouty
\tre. ,
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000110544793 and DCN:
Filer Information
Phone Number
Phone Type Work
Law Enforcement Information
No Law Enforcement Information Available
Narrative
Internal File Reference Number. SP 2641, Analyst - WJH
Deutsche Bank Trust Company Americas (-DBTCA1 is filing this SAR to report ongoing check cashing activities of a 
Deutsche
Bank Wealth Management ("WM") client which appear to have been structured in order to circumvent Currency Transaction
Reporting ("CTR") reporting requirements.
This SAR supplements previous SARs filed on 09/07/2016 and 06/02/2017 concerning Darren K. Indyke (*Indyke"), who is the
same party involved in the transactions described below. This current SAR contains transactions which were not reported 
in the
previously-filed SAR.
Indyke is an attorney practicing law in the State of New York. Indyke maintains a WM business checking account as 
follows:
Account Number: Open Date: 11/1/2013, registered as Darren K. Indyke PLLC
Indyke is the sole member and owner of the law firm. Indyke's personal residence is on record as
WM account records indicate that Jeffrey Epstein ("Epstein") of 6100 Red Hook Quarter B3, St. Thomas, US VI 00802, has
appointed Indyke to act as agent for him. Epstein maintains a WM checking account as follows: Account Number: 35269691,
Open Date: 03/08/2016, registered as Jeffrey Epstein, 6100 Red Hook Qtr, B3, Saint Thomas, United States Virgin Islands
00802-1348.
On a monthly basis, Indyke has routinely cashed a S7,500 check drawn on Epstein's WM account at the WM private bank 
branch
Page 4 The enclosed alormation was selected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and U.S.
Department of the Treasury regdations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.

5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The alternation is sensitive n nature and is to be treated accordingly. The information
may be used only for a purpose con
ustent with a crime* tax. or regulatory
evestigation or proceeding. Of in the conduct of ntelligence Of counterntelligence activities. indudwg analysis. to 
protect against ntemational terrorism. See
31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannel be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. Of transmitted without pro; approval of the Director of Fnancial Cranes 
Enforcement Network or his authorized
delegate- Suspicious activity reports fled under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of passible criminal 
activity. akin to confklenbal informant
tips Unauthorized release of information
collected ruder the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
£6Lbb901100016:VSB
FinCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network United Sates Depatheatt ti the Ttertuty
„
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000110544793 and DCN:
Narrative
located at 345 Park Avenue, New York, NY. Occasionally, Indyke also withdraws funds from his own accounts at the same 
time.
DBTCA has previously filed CTRs on the cash withdrawal activities of Indyke exceeding $10,000 on 05/28/2014 02/16/2016, 
and
12/21/2016.
Suspicious Activity:
According to a WM bank teller from 345 Park Avenue the following events transpired:

1) On 06/21/2017, Indyke cashed Check number 1055, dated 06/20/2017, made payable to cash and drawn on Indyke's WM
attorney business checking account in the amount of $7,500.

2) On 06/22/2017, Indyke, in his capacity as agent for Epstein, arranged to withdraw 6,600 Euros in a foreign currency 
exchange
transaction that was completed using Epstein's WM checking account. Indyke explained the reason for this transaction was
to
have cash on hand for his client's vacation in the upcoming week.

3) On 06/23/2017, Indyke cashed Check number 1125, dated 04/25/2017, made payable to cash and drawn on Epstein's WM
checking account in the amount of S7,500.00.
Inconnection with the activities detailed in the previous SARs filed, Indyke made inquiry with branch personnel on more 
than one
occasion regarding the regulatory reporting requirements associated with his intended check withdrawal activities. When
advised that a CTR would be required, Indyke altered his transaction pattern, presumably to avoid CTR filing 
requirements.
The current activity appears to be a continuation of Indyke structuring of his cash withdrawal activities in order to 
avoid the CTR
requirement.
On 07/25/2017, members of the WM AFC Team and the Relationship Manager of Indyke's accounts had a telephone conference
Page 5 The enclosed eformaticn was colected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (Me SSA) and U.S. 
Department of the Treasury regulations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The eformation is sensitive it nature and is to be treated 'secede*. The information 
may be used only for a purpose con ustent
with a crime* tax. or regulatory
evestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of etelligence or counteretelligence activities. inclueng analysis. to 
protect against eternational terrorism. See
31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. dixIo--ed. or transmitted without vim approval of the Director of Feancial Crates 
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate
Suspicious activity reports fled under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of pass.ible criminal 
activity. akin to ccerklenbal informant
tips- Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
C6a1901100016:VSEI
FinCEN Financial Crimes Enforcement Network icti Sows peps onalt al the forbuty
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000110544793 and DCN:
Narrative
call with Indyke to discuss the their concerns with the activity described above and in the prior SARs.
Indyke was informed that his pattern of cashing checks gives the appearance of structuring to avoid CTRReporting. WM AFC
explained the concept of structuring to the client. WM AFC made it clear that they were not mandating that he change the
manner
in which he chooses to conduct his business or how he should cash his checks, but the pattern of check cashing activity 
was
problematic for both him and DBTCA.
Indyke stated that he frequently requires cash for his business as well as for Mr. Epstein's household expenses, and did
not
realize that he was cashing checks in any particular concerning pattern. Moreover, Indyke stated that it was not his 
intention to
structure any of the activity described above.
Page 6 The enclosed nformatico was cSected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (Me SSA) and U.S. 
Depatment of the Treasury regttations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.

5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The nformation a sensitive ri nature and is to be treats accadingly. The information 
may be used only for a purpose consistent
with acratiS, tax. or regulatory
investigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of ntelligence or counterntelligence activities. inclueng analysis. to 
protect against nternational terrorism.
See 31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of Friancial Crates 
Enforcement Network or h's authorized
delegate. Suspicious activity reports feed under
the GSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of psystle criminal 
activity. akin to confidential informant
tips. Unauthorized release of information
collected wider the BSA may result in criminal or civil :webs:.
£6LflSOLL0001£:\SB
EFTA02729877 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about "MCC Corruption Case" is about guards on duty when Epstein died
(inferred date: 2026-01-02)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 2-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
mwoniury  08/30/2019
, Corrections Officer at Bureau of Prison's (BOP)
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER (MCC), 150 Park Row, New York, New York,
date of birth (DOB) was interviewed by FBI Special Agent (SA)
, FBI Task Force Officer (TFO) , and Office of the
Inspector General (OIG) SA at the United States Attorneys
Office (USAO), Southern District of New York (SDNY), 1 St. Andrews Plaza,
New York, New York. TFO advised that there is an on-going
criminal investigation and he has an obligation to answer questions
truthfully and that it would be a federal crime to lie to a federal agent
during the meeting. SA provided with an OIG "Warnings and
Assurances to Employee Requested to Provide Information on a Voluntary
Bases" form, which signed and was witnessed by SAs and
Moore. SA retained the original and a copy is attached in the IA
section of this report.
After being advised of the identity of the interviewing investigators and
the nature of the interview, provided the following information:
has worked for BOP for four years. was working an overtime
shift in the Special Housing Unit (SHU), 10 South, on a 12am-8am shift at
the time that JEFFREY EPSTEIN was found unresponsive in his cell.
couldn't recall the exact date but did recall that it was the previous
Saturday. had worked a 12pm-8pm shift the previous day, had a four
hour break, and then started the overtime shift of 12a-8a. Unit 10 South is
a completely locked down unit where the Corrections Officer is alone in the
unit.
recalled he did the 12am count with and that Officer NOEL
helped him do the 3am and 5am counts. further stated that for the 3am
and 5am counts, the control center had called about the counts and he
advised control that he wanted someone to assist him in doing the counts
Im•estigationan 08/16/2019 at New York, New York, United States (In Person)
File *1 90A-NY-3151227, 90C-NY-3154599 Date dratted 08/19/2019
by

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
90A-NY-3151227
(U) Interview of Corrections Officer
Continuation of FD-302 of On 08/16/2019 ,page 2 of 2
because he was by himself. said that there should always be a double
staff count and that he always wanted a partner to do the count and wouldn't
do a count without a partner. advised that while doing the counts, an
officer should see breathing flesh. When and NOEL did the 3am and 5am
counts, they counted five inmates.
Officer THOMAS relieved at some point during the shift to give him
a break. Lieutenant came by at some point to check on
however, didn't remember the exact time.
was in 10 South when the call came over, referring to when EPSTEIN
was found unresponsive in his cell. then worked another shift in the
SHU, 8am-4pm.
stated that he once fed EPSTEIN because EPSTEIN had not received
his meal and that EPSTEIN was grateful. said that EPSTEIN didn't
appear to be dangerous and that EPSTEIN never offered him money for
anything. stated that he was shocked that this had happened, referring
to EPSTEIN's death. said that EPSTEIN was supposed to be watched more
closely and that the rounds should have been conducted regardless of
whether EPSTEIN had previously been on suicide watch or not.
was then shown a picture of . When looked at
the picture, said that he wanted a lawyer. Investigators discontinued
questioning at that time.
On his own accord, then stated something to the effect of "I want
to be clear, I never brought stuff into the jail or allowed stuff in. I
never did that."
was advised that his cell phone, which had been surrendered at the
security checkpoint at the entrance of the USAO, was seized by the FBI. The
cell phone, a Motorola G6/XT1921-5, IMEI 99000544589395, was seized pursuant
to a search warrant issued by SDNY. was then told that he could get
his phone back that day if he gave investigators his passcode. told
investigators that he was not going to give them his passcode. was
given an FD-597, receipt for property, which was signed by and TFO
EFTA00002012 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-03)
1144
1.44,1
lilt. I I al WI 02/07 0 0070 714 010 020143 11.001 AV oast LEON D BLACK DEBRA BLACK
r 44 r 1 A41T, ne••••4-. .  0A
4444. .unn rur ittil I -27009
1`444. 1 010
Slotting -42 P27144
0101 11 1hratig% 013111 Y. 441 0 BP Pe 24
A.. .,4. Nuenber 0610 0.1117 awe
TRUST "8""
Our Oohs, Booking service ;Mown yeti to cli,rett balances, track uctoolit activity and mere. With Online Banking you O 
MAO view up to 18 months of this
statement online and evezi turn n orf delivery of your paper slot lllll ent. Enroll .t
Customer Service Intelmotion
www.bankofornerica.Com
For :Man ionul information or service. T.. Or you may write to: it 1.800.878.7878 Customer Service Bank of America. N.A.
1.800.288.4408 TIM)/71`11 Users Only
1),..<4 P.O. Box 25118 1.800.688.60860 En Espanol Tempe. FL 33622.5118 --- •
Deposit Accounts
MOM Premium Tiered Interest Checking
Interest Checking
LEON 1) BLACK DEBRA BLACK MELANIE SPINELLA POA
Your Account ut a Glance
A CC(/11114 Number 0000 0662 3840 13.1000ms Balance on 01-01.11 $ 3,295,278.44 Deposits and Other Additions + 
20,724,721.06 Checks Posted - 6.025.000.00 or bog.
SuiThicti, ,rr. - 17,146,592.73 ending iiialionco• on 01-3/- I I $ 848,411.77
Annual Percentage Yield Earned this Statement Period: 0.50%
lnfor., Paid Year to Date: $1,239.71
Your Advantage Pricing Relationship
0'-

╭──────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ lly                                              │
│                                                  │
│ DEBRA BLACK                                      │
│                                                  │
│ Our Online Banking service allows you to check b │
│                                                  │
│ DF ieiisie.tce TOBE                              │
│                                                  │
│ Premium Tiered Interest Checking                 │
│ Interest Checking                                │
│                                                  │
│ LEON D BLACK DEBRA BLACK                         │
│ MELANIE SPINELLA POA,                            │
│                                                  │
│ ; fT anual                                       │
│                                                  │
│ 6,025,000.00 Period: 0.50%.                      │
│ / 17'46'592.23 Interest Paid Year te             │
│ Ending Balance on 01-31-11 $ 548;406.77          │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00004763 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00006487 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2006
(inferred date: 2026-01-03)
phone bill covering 2006
EFTA00006587 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2006-09-04 to 2016-10-15
(inferred date: 2026-01-03)
phone bill covering 2006-09-04 to 2016-10-15
EFTA00007975 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00008585 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Jeffrey Epstein
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Elliott Broidy [republican] RNC chair, impregnated / paid off / paid for an abortion for a Playboy Playmate he had affair with 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00090314 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI tip about Masha Drokova, Jared Kushner, Ivanka Trump, Chabad, Alan Dershowitz, etc.
(inferred date: 2026-01-03)
FD -1023 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
CHS REPORTING DOCUMENT
HEADER
Source ID:
Date:
Case Agent Name:
S-00099701
10/19/2020
Field Office/Division: Los Angeles
Squad: 101
SOURCE REPORTING
Date of Contact: 10/16/2020
List all resent including yourself (do not include the CHS):
Si
Type of Contact: Other
Other Contact Type: Encrypted Messaging App
Date of Report: 10/19/2020
Substantive Case File Number
804I-LA-3315657-INTELPRODS
Substantive Case File Number
50D-NY-3027571
Check here if additional reporting is in Echo
No
Source Reporting:
(U) Captioned Confidential Human Source (CHS) was asked by the handling agent about information he/she may be aware of
related to improper domestic or foreign influence over the electoral process in the U.S. CHS already provided some of 
this
information documented in previous reports, but he/she expanded on several matters, as described below:
(U Harvard Law Professor Alan Dershowitz (Dershowitz). CHS learned that
Dershowitz influenced many students from wealthy families. For example. Josh Kushner (Josh) and Jared Kushner (Jared) 
were
both his students. Dershowitz told CHS that if he were young again, he would be holding a stun gun as an Israeli 
Intelligence
(Mossad) agent. CHS believed Dershowitz was co-opted by Mossad and subscribed to their mission. CHS still continues to
communicate occasionally for Dershowitz [See previous reporting].

(U)Jeffrey Epstein (Epstein) was represented by Dershowitz. CHS remembered Dershowitz tell Alex Ocasta (U.S. Attorney of
Southern District of Florida at the time) that Epstein belonged to both U.S. and allied intelligence services. CHS 
shared phone calls
between Dershowitz and Epstein during which he/she took notes. After these calls, Mossad would then call Dershowitz to 
debrief.
Epstein was close to the former Prime Minister of Israel, Ehud Barak (Barak) and trained as a spy under him. Barak 
believed
Netanyahu was a criminal. Saudi Arabia, Israel and the United Arab Emirates (UAE) are allied against Qatar, Turkey, Iran
and
Syria. One of CHS' (who presumably worke asked CHS a lot of questions about Epstein. CHS
became convinced t t pstein was a co-opted Mossad Agent see previous reporting).
FD-1023 Page 1 of 3 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
FD-1023 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
CHS REPORTING DOCUMENT
(U)Masha Drokova (Drokova), telephone numbed. is based in Silicon Valley. She has been running a firm called Day
One Ventures, which is supposedly an early stage investment company. She used to be Russian President Vladimir Putin's 
main
contact in the Russian Youth movement. CHS and Drokova spoke, but Drokova did not talk at all about technology; instead,
she
looked at CHS and said. "You knew Epstein, didn't you." She said Epstein was a "wonderful man" and that it was a crying 
shame
what had being done to him. CHS concluded Day One Ventures was in Silicon Valley to steal technology.
(U)CHS advised Chabad is doing everything they can to co-opt the Trump presidency. Chabad is basically state-sanctioned
Judaism. It is used by Putin to keep tabs on all the Russo-Jewish oligarchs. On the day Trump was elected President. 
Ivanka
Trump (Ivanka) and Jared were at the gravesite of Rabbi Scheersom, who was the most powerful Rabbi in the Chabad 
network.
Jared didn't disclose his stake in Cadre, because of its ties to the Russian state (NFI). CHS believed this was/is the 
"real" Russian
collusion story. Kushner has moved a lot of Russian investment money around. The FBI should investigate Kushner's family
charities to find evidence of corruption and money laundering. Chabad routinely uses charities to launder money.
(U)CHS provided the attached article entitled "Jim McGreevey and His Main Man By Craig Horowitz," published 09/10/2004. 
While
the article is old and centered on Charles Kushner (Charles), it highlights and documents the deep ties the Kushner 
family has with
Israel and their history of corrupt business practices and alleged violations of election laws. CHS stated that if the 
FBI is serious
about investigating the Kushners and their relationships with Middle East. they should look closely at Ken Kurson. who 
"knows
everything" (NFI). CHS advised Henry Kissinger introduced Charles to Cui Tiankai. the Chinese ambassador to the U.S., a
relationship that could have been helpful; at around the same time of the introduction, Anbang was entering negotiations
with the
Kushners over 666 Fifth Avenue.

(U)Hary Tanoesoedinbjo (Hary) has been involved has developed Trump's hotels and is a billionaire. Ha
introduced him/her to the In Indonesian. Nary bought his Beverl Hills home from Trump
at an inflated price (NFI). 0 was at Hary's house when Ha hat Trump told him
that he was going to "fuck Amazon" over their military contracts. CHS advised that this was a real collusion story - 
Trump has been
compromised by Israel. and Kushner is the real brains behind his organization and his Presidency.
(U)Igor Korbatov (Igor) brokered the sale of a Beverly Hills mansion Trump acquired for $800,000 less than the market 
value. CHS
referenced the attached article that summarized the matter - "A small-time scam artist gave Trump a mansion for SO. 
Why?"
published April 12 2018 by Lance Williams and Matt Smith in "Reveal from The Center for Investigative Reporting." Ross 
Delston. a
Washington, D.C.-based attorney and consultant on financial crimes to the International Monetary Fund, said the deal 
included
"many facets that don't add up" and that the deal warrants further scrutiny and investigators should follow up on the 
"numerous
oddities and red flags that this series of transactions raises."
(U)The Fisches (NFI) signed the deed transferring the Beverly Hills home. The Fisches are prominent Los Angeles real 
estate
investors and political donors. They have given more than $250,000 to GOP candidates and causes, records show. They were
guests at the White House when George W. Bush was president and accompanied him on a trip to Israel, Selma Fisch said in
a
phone interview. Their daughter and wife of the sales broker. Lisa Korbatov (Lisa). is a GOP activist and president of 
the Beverly
Hills Unified school board; Lisa is an active member of the Jewish community in Beverly Hills. After one season on the 
West Coast,
"The Apprentice" moved back to New York. Trump never lived in the Beverly Hills mansion. In the summer of 2009, he sold 
the
home for $9.5 million - $800,000 less than the previous year's price - to a Swiss entity associated with the family of 
Eka Widjaja, an
Indonesian billionaire financier. The sale was in cash. Trump's former lawyer, Michael Cohen, filed the legal papers for
the shell
company involved in the mansion's purchase, and he notarized the deed when Trump sold the property, records show. He 
didn't
respond to multiple requests for comment.
FD-1023 Page 2 of 3 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
FD-1023 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
CHS REPORTING DOCUMENT
OFFICIAL RECORD •
(U)CHS statecl l Renda Tillerson (Renda), telephone numbe . Renda is the wife of Rex
Tillerson (Rex), former Secretary of State for Trump. Renda told CHS about smears in the New York Post and how Jared was
running a rival State Department operation. Rex affirmed Renda's claim. Renda was introduced to CHS by Daren Blanton
(Blanton). Renda and Rex both told CHS they had been under intense surveillance. Renda told CHS she can't wait for the 
FBI to
call her, so that she can tell them everything she knows.

(U)According to Jed Shugerman and Whitney Webb, Leon Black (Black) owns the mercenary firm formerly known as Blackwater,
now Constellis, which has been accused of being involved in several arms and human trafficking scandals. Black is also 
the CEO
of Apollo. "@NYTimes" noted that Black "inexplicably stood by Jeffrey Epstein. recently giving him $50M." Apollo also 
lent the
Kushners $184 million (USD) while Kushner was facing his 666 5th Avenue disaster. (see attached screenshots for 
references]
(U)Elliott Broidy (Broidy) recently plead to charges related to money laundering unregistered lobbying for the UAE. 
Broidy
previously paid a former Playboy Model over $1 million to stay quiet about an affair he had with her. Broidy allegedly 
successfully
lobbied to increase U.S. sanctions on the Government of Qatar. CHS advised since Broidy was purportedly the largest fund
raiser
for Trump, supporting esidential election, he apparently used his access to Trump to lobby. Joel Mowbray (Mowbray).
telephone  has been in Broidy's inner circle. CHS believed Mowbray was an unregistered lobbyist. Mowbray
was one of the "shiftiest" people CHS had ever encountered. Mowbray was a convert to Judaism. CHS stated Mowbray would 
flip
on Broidy because he's a "flipper." Congressman Ed Royce (Royce) was close to Broidy and has been trying to do shady 
things
(NFI). Royce's wife may be a lobbyist who works with Broidy.

(U)CHS emphasized the importance for the FBI to investigate Gawker for its involvement in pushing Russian propaganda. 
Matt
Melen told CHS that after Gawker was destroyed, the Russian Intelligence Service started using Zero Hedge to influence 
U.S.
people.
Synopsis:
Foreign influence on U.S. officials by Israel, Russia, and UAE
SIGNATURE
Submitted By
First Level Approved By
Mon, 19 Oct 2020 15:23:26 -07:00
Mon, 19 Oct 2020 15:26:20 -07:00
FD-1023 Page 3 of 3 FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
EFTA00103908 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-03)
JSRsEPS1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
x
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
v.
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
Before:
x
19 CR 490 (RMB)
New York, N.Y.
August 27, 2019
10:30 a.m.
HON. RICHARD M. BERMAN,
District Judge
APPEARANCES
GEOFFREY S. BERMAN
United States Attorney for the
Southern District of New York
BY:
Assistant United States Attorneys
MARTIN G. WEINBERG, PC
Attorney for Defendant
BY: MARTIN G. WEINBERG
STEPTOE & JOHNSON, LLP
Attorneys for Defendant
BY: REID WEINGARTEN
MICHAEL MILLER
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JaRsEPS1
(Case called)
THE COURT: Good morning, everybody. Please be
seated.
So just some housekeeping. We have a podium here for
both attorneys and others who may be speaking, and so we would
like you, attorneys and others who are speaking, to come up to
the podium. This room is a little cavernous. We thought the
podium over there would be more comfortable.
For starters, and for this you don't have to go up to
the podium, if you could just indicate your names. This table
in front to my left, your right, are defense counsel, and that
table to my right, your left, are government attorneys.
If we could just ask the attorneys to introduce
themselves.

MS. : Good morning, your Honor.
and for the government. Joining us at counsel table
are Special Agent of the FBI and Detective
of the NYPD.

MR. WEINGARTEN: Good morning, your Honor.
Reid Weingarten.
MR. WEINBERG: Martin Weinberg.
Good morning, your Honor.
THE COURT: Good morning.
MR. MILLER: Good morning, your Honor.
Michael Miller from Steptoe & Johnson on behalf of the
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
defendant.
THE COURT: Great.
Again, good morning to all of you. This hearing that
we're having today considers the government's motion to dismiss
the indictment in this case.
I must add that it also serves as the opportunity for
me to thank all of you, the attorneys and the victims who are
here today, among others, for your very hard work and
dedication in this case.
We also have here today the U.S. Attorney for the
Southern District of New York, Geoffrey Berman, who has also
been very helpful and indispensable in this matter.
The news on August 10, 2019, that Jeffrey Epstein had
been found dead in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional
Center, at the MCC, was certainly shocking. Most of you, and
myself for that matter, were anticipating that the next steps
in this case would be defense motion practice, including a
motion to dismiss, followed by a trial on the merits before a
jury, if the motions were not successful, and through which the
accusers and the accused would come face
everyone to get their day in court. Mr.
obviously means that a trial in which he
to face, allowing
Epstein's death
is a defendant cannot
take place. It is a rather stunning turn of events.
The government's motion to dismiss the indictment
because of Jeffrey Epstein's death on August 10, 2019, is
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
relatively straightforward. In my view, a public hearing
clearly is nevertheless the preferred vehicle for its
resolution.
Incidentally, while I'm on this subject, I got some
help today from the New York Law Journal from two professors
who write that a hearing is -- let me tell you exactly what
they said. They say, in part, that this is an odd moment for
transparency in a criminal case. I think that is an odd
sentence to hear about, transparency in a criminal case.
They go on to say that normally, if a prosecutor seeks
to dismiss an indictment for such an obviously worthy reason,
the court would simply grant the request. As to that
statement, I respectfully say it is incorrect as a matter of
law.
They go on to say the judge would not schedule a
hearing and he definitely would not allow the victims to speak.
If he did hold a hearing, whatever informational interests the
victims may have would be served by affording them a chance to
attend the hearing, not by giving them a speaking role.
I read it. It was incredulous. I'm still
incredulous. I don't quite understand at all. There is a
suggestion in the article that the reason they are making these
suggestions has to do with minimization of drama in this case.
In the Jeffrey Epstein case, there has not been much a
minimization of drama, and what little drama might happen
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
today, I don't think it would be very significant.
On a somewhat more serious note, don't quote me on
this, but it is my understanding that one of the authors of
that article is himself counsel in one of the Epstein -related
cases. I was surprised to learn that very recently. I'm
certain it is true. I was also surprised that that aspect was
not disclosed in the Law Journal.
But in any event, I think you know where I'm heading.
I respectfully disagree with the Law Journal piece. I was
saying that the government's motion is relatively
straightforward, and in my view, a public hearing is clearly,
nevertheless, the preferred vehicle for its resolution. I'm
still convinced of that.
A few may differ on this, but public hearings are
exactly what judges do. Hearings promote transparency and they
provide the court with insights and information which the court
may not otherwise be aware of.
The victims have been included in the proceeding today
both because of their relevant experiences and because they
should always be involved before rather than after the fact.
Indictment 19 CR 490 charges Jeffrey Epstein with sex
trafficking and with conspiracy to commit sex trafficking. The
U.S. Attorney, on August 19, 2019, requested that the court
approve the government's proposed order of nolle prosequi. 1
think that's a rough justice. That means nolle prosequi,
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
discontinuance by the prosecutor of all or of a part of the
case that he or she has commenced.
The government in its motion concludes that Epstein's
death abates these proceedings. In accordance with Federal
Rule of Criminal Procedure 57(b), I determined to hold a public
hearing and
opportunity
That is the
I notified the victims that they would be given the
to be heard before any final action on the motion.
purpose also of today's proceeding. I would do
that every time.
Also, recognized that Epstein, Mr. Epstein died before
any judgment of conviction against him had been obtained, and
that the government's proposed order appears, in form and
substance, to be appropriate.
Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 48(a) codifies the
nolle prosequi process. It is entitled dismissal, and it
states in relevant part that the government may, with leave of
the court, dismiss an indictment, information, or complaint,
and that leave of the court proviso, you should know, was added
as an amendment to the original draft of Rule 48, which had
originally provided for automatic dismissal upon the motion of
the government.
This proviso, in my judgment, is clearly directed
toward an independent judicial assessment of the public
interest in dismissing the indictment. Thus, even whereas, in
this case, the standard of court review is deferential, the
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
court must still make its own independent determination. A
conclusory statement from the government that dismissal is
appropriate does not satisfy the court's obligations.
It is also, in my view, required that the court
consider the views of the victims in the case at the hearing
and before deciding whether to grant the motion. This is being
done here both as a matter of law and as a measure of respect
that we have for the victims' difficult decisions to come
forward in this matter.
In a case called United States v. Heaton,
H-e-a-t-o-n-, the government filed a Rule 48 motion for leave
to dismiss a charge against a defendant who allegedly committed
a sexual offense against a young victim. Although I should
point out, very importantly, that that defendant was still
alive, which distinguishes it from our case.
Nevertheless, I think it is irrelevant because in
evaluating the Rule 48 motion, then district Judge Paul G.
Cassell -- who is now a law professor at the University of Utah
and is regarded to be a noted expert in victims' rights --
concluded that under the Crime Victims' Rights Act, victims
have broad rights that extend to a court's decision whether to
grant a government motion to dismiss under Rule 48.
I completely share that viewpoint in these
circumstances, even though the facts of our case, as I said,
are somewhat different from those in Heaton. I believe it is
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
the court's responsibility, and manifestly within its purview,
to ensure that the victims in this case are treated fairly and
with dignity.
The fundamental substantive principle which applies in
considering the government's motion is termed the rule of
abatement. This principle originated in the English common
law. It was adopted by most U.S. federal courts, but more
recently, it has faced some appropriate criticism. The rule of
abatement is best explained in the Second Circuit case of
U.S. v. Wright.
In that Wright case, two defendants had pled guilty to
embezzlement and tax evasion. Both defendants appealed, but
one of the defendants died while his appeal was pending in the
Second Circuit. The Court of Appeals rule that under the rule
of abatement, the judgment of conviction against the deceased
defendant was required to be vacated and the indictment was to
be dismissed. The Wright court held that when a convicted
defendant dies while his direct appeal as of right is pending,
his death abates not only the appeal, but also proceedings had
during the course of the prosecution.
The Second Circuit incidentally has also held that
when a criminal conviction abates upon the death of a
defendant, any restitution ordered as a result of that
conviction must also abate, and it is also ruled the same with
respect to associated forfeiture orders.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
This latter application of the rule of abatement
regarding forfeiture has not been universally accepted among
federal courts, but it certainly is the law in this circuit.
Some of you may be interested to know that some United States
courts, state courts, have criticized the rule of abatement,
particularly in the face of growing recognition of victims'
rights in the criminal justice system, including the Crime
Victims' Rights Act.
It has been written and contended in the Brooklyn Law
Review -- I can give you the cite later -- that when courts
abate criminal convictions, they reimpose a burden on victims
that legislatures intended to alleviate through these victim
rights statutes. The state Supreme Court has even concluded
that the expansion and codification of victims' rights provides
the changed conditions needed for overruling the rule of
abatement. It has also been stated that Alaska's statute and
its constitution now require the criminal justice system to
accommodate the rights of crime victims. Further, that the
abatement of criminal convictions has important implications
for these rights.
But coming back to our case, which is what you are
concerned about and I am as well, it is appropriate to conclude
that if the rule of abatement applies to a convicted defendant
as in the Wright case, it should also apply a fortiori in the
Epstein case, which was still in the pretrial phase when
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
IC
J8RsEPS1

Mr. Epstein died, when there had been no conviction.
So that's just some background I wanted to share with
you. At this point in time, I would like to turn to the
government prosecutors to hear from them in support of their
Rule 48 application to dismiss the Epstein indictment.

MS. : Thank you, your Honor.
Would you like me to address the court from the
podium?
THE COURT: If you wouldn't mind.

MS. : Thank you, your Honor.
I believe your Honor has accurately summarized the
state of the law, as set forth in our papers, in light of the
clear Second Circuit law, that upon the death of a defendant
before a final entry of a judgment of conviction, all
proceedings must be abated.
In light of that clear law, the government is legally
obligated to seek dismissal of the pending indictment against
Jeffrey Epstein, and we respectfully submit, likewise, that the
entry of the proposed order is similarly required by law.
A few notes to make about that, though, your Honor.
To be very clear, dismissal of this indictment as to Jeffrey
Epstein in no way prohibits or inhibits the government's
ongoing investigation into other potential coconspirators, nor
does it prevent the bringing of a new case in the future or the
prosecution of new defendants.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
It also does nothing to prevent the government from
continuing to explore the possibility of seeking civil
forfeiture of any assets that were used to facilitate the
crimes charged in this indictment. Indeed, as has been stated
publicly, investigations into those matters have been ongoing,
remain ongoing, and will continue following dismissal of the
indictment here.
I would also like to note that, as the government has
previously mentioned, this dismissal in no way lessens the
government's resolve to stand up for the victims in this case,
both those who have come forward and those who have yet to do
so. We agree with your Honor's sentiment that those victims
should be respected, and we appreciate your Honor's recognition
of that.
One housekeeping matter that I did want to reference
for your Honor. The protective order in this case requires
destruction or return of any and all discovery material upon
conclusion of the case. We have been in communication with
defense counsel, who have confirmed that they have returned all
physical copies that they have of discovery that the government
has produced to date, and they are in the process of deleting
any copies that they may have made. So the parties are in
compliance with the protective order.
Finally, I just wanted to say a word about the victims
in this case, and particularly those who are here in court
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
today. I'll note that in light of the court's order indicating
that the victims and their counsel would be permitted to be
heard in court here today, the government has endeavored to
provide notice to all known victims of today's proceeding. We
did so either directly where a victim was not represented by
counsel or through counsel where a victim is represented by an
attorney.
The government does not know exactly how many victims
or their attorneys are here today and we do not know how many
of them or their counsel would like to speak. To the extent
any individuals do wish to speak, we do not know the substance
of what they would like to say. We have left that entirely up
to the individual decisions of the victims and their attorneys.
I will note, though, that throughout this case, the
government has endeavored and done our utmost to fulfill our
obligations under the Crimes Victims' Rights Act. We have done
so by trying to keep as many victims as we are aware of up to
date about the ongoing case and about any developments in the
case.
We will continue to provide services and offer
services to any of the victims in this case, even after the
indictment is dismissed. Both the U.S. Attorney's office and
the FBI have been in touch with all known victims or have
attempted to be in touch with all known victims, either again
directly where victims are not represented by counsel or
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
through counsel where they have attorneys. We have expressed
to them that services are available for those who wish to take
advantage of them.
Unless the court has any questions for me, the
government will otherwise rest on its papers.
THE COURT: I just have one question.
The protective order, is that self-executing or do 1
need to do something?

MS. : It is self-executing, your Honor.
THE COURT: Thanks very much, Ms.
MS. : Thank you, your Honor.
THE COURT: Yes.
I'll turn to counsel for the defense at this time.

Mr. Weingarten, I'm happy to hear from you.
MR. WEINGARTEN: Thank you.
Your Honor, I think it is an understatement of the
year to say the world looks and feels differently today than it
did the last time I was before you. For us, the elephant in
the room is what happened to our client. I would like to tell
you how we see the world and where we are on that subject.
We start with the Attorney General's statements,
public statements, that there were very serious improprieties
in the jail. We obviously read the press. We see that the
warden has been taken out. We see that the guards on duty at
the time have been put on leave. We understand guards are
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JaRsEPS1
refusing to cooperate with the investigation. We have heard
allegations that people at the time who had responsibility for
protecting our client falsified information. We understand
that there were orders out there that Jeffrey Epstein was never
to be left alone and that the orders were ignored by many of
the employees of the prison.
In a word, yikes. In addition, obviously we followed
the medical examiner's report, or we haven't followed the
report, we haven't seen it, but heard conclusions, initially
not enough evidence to come to a conclusion, wanted to see
more. We assumed she was talking about the videotapes, but
then came to the conclusion that it was suicide.
We report to the court that --
THE COURT: Suicide by hanging --

MR. WEINGARTEN: Yes.
THE COURT: -- was her conclusion?
MR. WEINGARTEN: Yes.
And we report to the court that we had a doctor there
at the time, and we also have been in receipt of a tremendous
amount of medical and scientific evidence volunteered to us
opining that the injuries suffered, as reported, were far more
consistent with assault than with suicide, and we are happy to
supply the court with all the information that we have.
Now, in addition, as the court noted, we were underway
with our pretrial motions, and as the court obviously
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
understands, the NPA and the role of the NPA was going to be
critically important. And I would simply like to report that
we went pretty far along.
We interviewed all of the relevant lawyers on the
defense side who participated in the NPA, and we were satisfied
that we had a very strong argument that every one of those
lawyers believed with an objective basis that the deal was
global. That is, at the time --
THE COURT: I'm sorry, that?
MR. WEINGARTEN: The deal of the NPA was global. That
is, more specifically, at the time,
agents knew of conduct in New York,
defense counsel negotiating in good
the Florida prosecutors and
and that no competent
faith with the prosecutors
would have ever agreed to a deal back then that allowed New
York prosecutors to indict for precisely the same conduct in
the future, which, of course, is what happened.
In addition, we have come up with very powerful
evidence, we believe, that Florida prosecutors, who
participated in the deal, steered the victims and the alleged
victims to New York on more than one occasion because they did
not want to suffer the sleights of attacks against them. So we
have advanced the ball on this very subject and we are prepared
to completely report to the court as to where we are and what
we've done.
Another point. We obviously had contact with our
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
client at or around the time of his death, and obviously the
attorney -client privilege survives death and we are not going
to forfeit the privilege, but we will report to the court, with
as much specificity as the court may want, that at or around
the time of his death, we did not see a despairing, despondent
suicidal person. Details to follow, if the court wishes.
The 800-pound gorilla, for us, of course, are the
video surveillance tapes. Obviously we assume there is a tape
that leads directly to the door where Jeffrey Epstein was
housed. If that tape reports for 12 hours before his death
that no one went in and out of that room, then the suggestion
that there was something other than a suicide seems
preposterous.
But there is no such evidence that has surfaced to
date. Just the opposite. We have heard, and we actually read
in the press, that the tapes were either corrupted or not
functioning. Talk about a yikes. If, in fact, the system was
broken for six months before Jeffrey Epstein was housed, I
mean, that would be stunning incompetence. If it was allowed
to continue to be inoperative when Jeffrey Epstein was housed,
it would be incompetence times ten. But what if the tapes only
broke down or were inoperative or were corrupted on the day he
was killed or the day he died? Then we're in a completely
different situation.
So where does this lead? I think where it leads,
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
Judge, is there are incredibly important questions that remain
open. The public interest in this matter is obvious from this
courtroom. There are conspiracy theories galore. We are all
for finding the truth. We believe this court has an
indispensable role to play.
Whether or not this indictment is dismissed, I think
this court has the inherent authority to find out what happened
on its watch. Obviously, when the court detained Jeffrey
Epstein, the court did not anticipate that weeks later he would
be dead in his cell. I think given the inherent authority of
the court, the court should make inquiry.
This could come in many forms. Obviously the court
made inquiry as to what happened in the first incident. When
there was an allegation of an attempted suicide, the court made
inquiry. The court obviously was interested.
I recall your language. You talked about that being
one of the several open questions indicating an interest on the
court for the others as well. Obviously, the ultimate question
is what happened to the client.
THE COURT: You're talking about the July 23, 2019
incident?
MR. WEINGARTEN: Yes.
The court obviously could hold hearings. The court
could assign a lawyer to help the court. I think this is an
area where there is intense public interest. We have complete
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
confidence in the prosecutors in the Southern District and the
FBI to do a competent investigation. But these are allegations
against serious components of the United States Department of
Justice. Sometimes the appearance of justice is just as
important as justice itself.
I think the court supervising, or at least keeping an
interest in this proceeding, is incredibly important for the
public to have confidence in the ultimate findings, and
certainly for us to have confidence in the ultimate findings.
One more issue, Judge. The conditions of the jail, in
a word, they were dreadful. Not just for Jeffrey Epstein, but
for many of the prisoners over there. This is a prison within
the shadows of this courthouse. The situation is rife with
vermin. The abuse and the conditions in that prison, in
word, are a disgrace and everybody knows it.
A person with authority told us, someone with
knowledge, that the prisoners in Guantanamo -- and he spoke
with personal knowledge -- are treated better than the
prisoners right across the way. The feds certainly know how
run a disciplined, clean prison. I've been in 20 of them.
They know how to do it just fine. And the question is, why in
the world does it not happen down the road? I think that is a
perfectly legitimate subject for the court to make inquiry.
In a word, we want the court to help us find out what
happened. The court has a role to play. It is the institution
a
to
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
that most people have confidence in in these very troubled
times.
So whether or not you dismiss the indictment, to us,
is beside the point. We want you to stay on the case, we want
you to conduct an investigation, and we want to know what
happened here.
Thank you, your Honor.
THE COURT: Just so it is clear, so your view on the
motion directly on its merits of the nolle prosequi order and
application by the U.S. Attorney, do you have a view on that?

MR. WEINGARTEN: I think if the court felt that the
case had to stay alive for the court to continue, we would
oppose it. I think --
THE COURT: I'm sorry, if what?

MR. WEINGARTEN: If the issue, if you took the
position for you to conduct the investigation or lead the
investigation or participate in the investigation, then we
want, the role we want you to play, if the indictment has to be
alive, we would oppose the motion.
I don't think you need to do that. I think you can
dismiss the indictment.
THE COURT: So you're suggesting that you support the
government's motion, just viewed in the context of --

MR. WEINGARTEN: Yes, of course.
THE COURT: Great.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
MR. WEINBERG: Judge, if I can just supplement?
THE COURT: Absolutely.

MR. WEINBERG: Thank you, sir.
Thank you, as an out-of-town lawyer for the privilege
to appear in front of you, your Honor.
THE COURT: It's my pleasure.
MR. WEINBERG: First, as to the conditions, we think
your Honor trusted the government, the Bureau of Prisons, to
keep our client safe and keep him in civilized conditions. The
government will again ask, as to other defendants, that they be
detained at the MCC, some subset of them will end up in the SHU
unit.
It is a horrific. I've called it medieval. There's
vermin on the floor. There is wet from the plumbing. There is
no sunlight. There is limited exercise. It is simply
conditions that no pretrial detainee -- and I would go farther
as a criminal defense lawyer -- no United States defendant
should be subjected to.
Certain judges have taken views of the conditions. We
would urge your Honor, the government talks about and we talk
about transparency, to see what kind of conditions there exist
within 50 or 100 yards of one of the great United States
district courts.
Second, in terms, we have a profound problem with the
conclusions of the medical examiner. There are for three
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
reasons, your Honor.
One is the timing of Mr. Epstein's demise. It was on
August 10. On August 12, a bail pending appeal motion was
being filed in the Second Circuit. On August 12 or 13, the
United States Attorneys were going to respond to our request
for the preservation and production of documents that would
have facilitated and furthered our efforts to demonstrate
communications between the Southern District of Florida, the
Northern District of Georgia, which was standing in the shoes
of the Southern District of Florida main justice and the
Southern District.
In other words, we were beginning the process
discharging our responsibilities. There had been no new
evidence that Mr. Epstein had committed any offense against a
minor after 2005. The subject matter of the New York
prosecution was squarely within the heartland of the Florida
NPA. We had a significant motion to dismiss. This was not a
futile, you know, defeatist attitude.
Third, we had all the discovery motions that your
Honor had scheduled. So the timing for a pretrial detainee to
commit suicide on August 10, when his bail pending appeal
motion is being filed on August 12, strikes us as implausible.
Second, we had an independent doctor who was present
at the autopsy which occurred on August 11. On August 11, the
city medical examiner's findings were inconclusive. We are
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
told by a very experienced forensic pathologist that the broken
bones in Mr. Epstein's neck, in his larynx, are more consistent
with external pressure, with strangulation, with homicide, if
you will, than with suicide. It doesn't exclude suicide, but
the pure medical forensic evidence creates profound issues
about what happened to him.
Also the time of death. Our medical examiner's
opinion is it occurred at least 45 minutes and probably hours
before 6:30 a.m. on August 10, when he was first found, if you
will, according to the reports. Yet he was moved, something
that is not ordinary in these circumstances.
I would also --
THE COURT: Excuse me. He was moved?

MR. WEINBERG: Instead of having the cell in the
condition it was found, if he had been dead for 45 minutes or
two hours or four hours, there were efforts to move him and,
therefore, make it more difficult to reconstruct whether or not
he died of suicide or some other cause.
I spoke to Stacey Richmond, who is a responsible
member of this court who represents the family of Mr. Epstein.
She spoke to the medical examiner on the Friday after
Mr. Epstein's death and asked why, if the conclusion was made
late in the afternoon on Friday that week. She specifically
asked about what extrinsic nonmedical evidence caused the
medical examiner to go from uncertain to suicide, and she was
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
told that the medical examiner had seen nine minutes of one
video which was on a stairwell between floors at the MCC. She
was told that the principal video that would have showed the
whole hall was corrupted. It was in DC with the FBI to see if
they can reconstruct it.
And I asked the same questions that my co-counsel did,
you know, was the dysfunction of the critical pivotal video, in
the most secure prison east of Florence, out in Colorado known
to the MCC before August 10, or was this corruption occurring
on August 10, which would again cause us to be skeptical of the
servitude of the medical examiner's conclusions that this was
suicide rather than some other cause.
So with my co-counsel, we ask your Honor, it is not a
question of trust or not trust. They ask you to detain people
and you trust the Bureau of Prisons. And it is within your
inherit authority, your Honor, to find out what happened to our
client.
We are angry about the conditions he was held in. And
we're also angry, quite frankly, your Honor, that the only
source of information that we get as to what happened to him is
through the media rather than through the United States
Attorney's office. We've made requests informal. We have
made Touhy requests. We've been told there is a pending
investigation.
But we trust your Honor and the judiciary, and with
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JaRsEPS1
all due respect, we believe there is an inherent and central
role, a pivotal role in your Honor to find out what happened to
a defendant in a case before the court, whether or not the
court grants the nolle pros today or whether it holds it
pending an investigation into Mr. Epstein's death.
We're not here without significant doubts regarding
the conclusion of suicide. We are not here to say what
happened. We don't know what happened. But we deeply want to
know what happened to our client.
Thank you, sir.
THE COURT: And you, as Mr. Weingarten, have the same
view of the nolle prosequi motion?

MR. WEINBERG: Yes, your Honor.
THE COURT: OK.
MS. : Your Honor, may I respond to some of those
points?
THE COURT: Sure.

MS. : Thank you, your Honor.
Just briefly. With the exception of the noting that
the defense does not have an objection to the government's
motion, virtually everything else that defense counsel just
argued, respectfully is completely irrelevant to the purposes
of today's proceeding and to the motion that is pending before
your Honor.
As an initial matter, the question --
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
THE COURT: Well, it may be. Well, I don't know. You
say irrelevant.
It is a public hearing, and I think it is fair game
for defense counsel to raise its concerns.

MS. : Certainly, your Honor. But it is
irrelevant to whether or not the motion should be granted.
THE COURT: Right. I get that.

MS. : I would also note that the question of
Mr. Epstein's death is the subject of an ongoing and active
investigation, as has been publicly noted, by a separate team
of Assistant United States Attorneys from the Southern District
of New York, separate from the team who is handling this
prosecution, as well as a separate team of FBI agents.
There is an ongoing and active grand jury
investigation into the circumstances surrounding Mr. Epstein's
death. It is the function of a grand jury and of the Federal
Bureau of Investigation to investigate crimes in the federal
court system. It is not the purview, respectfully, of the
court to conduct an investigation into uncharged matters.
So respectfully, we disagree with defense counsel's
suggestion that the court has some authority to conduct an
independent investigation. To the extent any other defendants
who are detained in the MCC have concerns about the conditions
or believe that the conditions are relevant to a future or
current bail determination, it is for those defendants and
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JaRsEPS1
their counsel to raise those arguments and for the judges
hearing those arguments to evaluate those claims. It is not
relevant to today's proceedings.
Thank you, your Honor.
THE COURT: In those other cases, Ms. , judges do
have authority to investigate, but don't here?

MS. : Not to investigate, your Honor, but to
hear arguments about the conditions of confinement in the MCC
as they may relate to any bail determination. I believe that
was the argument that was made.
The bigger picture here, your Honor, is that the focus
of today's proceeding, as we understand it, is to allow the
victims who have gathered here today to be heard and to comment
upon the case and to comment upon the motion that is pending,
and to bring this case to a close.
THE COURT: Got it.

MR. WEINGARTEN: May I?
THE COURT: Sure.
MR. WEINGARTEN: We obviously saw this as, perhaps,
the last opportunity to be before you, and we wanted to take
advantage of the opportunity to say our peace and thank you for
allowing us.
There is precedent here. Ted Stevens, the Senator
from Alaska case in Washington, DC, Judge Emmet Sullivan
ordered an independent investigation by a private lawyer when
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JaRsEPS1
he was deeply troubled by the alleged Brady violations. I
represented the prosecutors in that case, so I'm very, very
familiar with it.
It is analogous. It is a situation where there was
tremendous controversy over what happened in the case and
whether or not the prosecutors went off the reservation. Judge
Sullivan -- and there were three or four independent -- not
independent, DOJ inquiries into the very same matter. But
Judge Sullivan wanted his own opportunity to make a judgment
with his own independent investigation.
THE COURT: OK.

MR. WEINBERG: If I could just add one precedent, your
Honor.
The Chief judge in the District of Massachusetts or
the Chief Judge at the time, Judge Wolf, in a case called
U.S. v. Fleming, when the conditions at Walpole, which is a
state prison where federal prisoners were being held -- we
don't have a federal MCC in Boston went to the prison,
stayed in the prison to determine whether or not the complaints
about the conditions were authentic.
I think your Honor has the inherent authority to go to
the ninth floor and see how the MCC houses pretrial detainees.
Thank you.
THE COURT: Are you saying that whether or not the
motion is granted that is pending before us?
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1

MR. WEINBERG: Yes, your Honor.
I think, like when appeals are taken, bail issues
remain before the district court. Jurisdiction is not
completely divested. Your Honor issued a pretrial detention
order and your Honor has the power, the inherent authority,
they are not going to refuse to allow you to go look at the
ninth floor. They are going to count on you to make decisions
in the future.
I just trust that the executive branch is not going to
prevent the judicial branch from looking into the death of
Jeffrey Epstein or the conditions in the SHU unit at the MCC,
sir.
THE COURT: Great. Thank you.

MS. : May I, your Honor?
Just very briefly, your Honor. I would note that upon
the dismissal of the indictment, which I believe the parties
agree is appropriate in this case, there would be no case.
There would be no jurisdiction for the court to conduct any
sort of inquiry, even if the court had such authority.
THE COURT: Right.

OK. I think we've heard enough.
It is at this point in the hearing that I would like
to call upon victims' counsel, plural, for any remarks they may
have and they may wish to make. Also, to introduce their
clients, those of them who wish to be heard.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
It would be helpful if, in doing that, if counsel -

Mr. Edwards and I see and I see Mr. Boise as well -- I know
they are counsel to several, at least several of the victims.
It would be helpful if whoever is speaking, both Mr. Edwards
and Mr. Boise, would indicate to the court whether or not they
have discussed the pending motion with their clients, that is
to say and the rule of abatement, etc., etc. with them prior to
today's hearing.
Are we going to hear from Mr. Edwards first, is that
right?

MR. EDWARDS: Thank you, your Honor.
THE COURT: You bet.
It would be helpful, Mr. Edwards, if you would state
and spell your name for the court reporter.
If you are going to introduce someone else, which I
trust that you are, if you could state and spell their name as
well.

MR. EDWARDS: Yes, your Honor.
May it please the court. Brad Edwards, B-r-a-d
E-d-w-a-r-d-s, with the law firm of Edwards Pottinger.
I have in the courtroom today 15 victims that I
represent and have represented over the years. There are at
least 20 more who didn't make this hearing today for a
multitude of reasons, some out of fear of public exposure,
others because the way in which this case ended will never
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JaRsEPS1
bring full justice, and they decided it was best for them not
to talk today.
Some of my clients are going to address the court that
are here today. Others are not. Some are going to use their
names, and have in the past, and others wish to remain
anonymous. And I have instructed each of them to inform the
court reporter that they will be proceeding as Jane Doe so that
the court reporter can take them down.
THE COURT: For those who wish to remain anonymous?

MR. EDWARDS: Exactly, your Honor.
THE COURT: And that is satisfactory, as far as I am
concerned.
MR. EDWARDS: Before we do that, I would like to
address a couple of the things that have occurred this morning.
First of all, whether relevant or not, I personally,
and on behalf of my clients, do appreciate the presentation
that Mr. Weingarten made and Mr. Marty Weinberg made.
I have tremendous respect for Mr. Weinberg. I've
worked with him through this and related cases for years, and I
understand the reason why they made the presentation that they
made.
There is two things of interest to our clients in that
respect. One is, because of the tragic ending, that none of my
clients wanted, nor did I, nor did anyone else, if there is
some civil rights violation and there is some civil remedy for
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1

Mr. Epstein that goes to the estate, certainly the victims are
interested in that as they might help to repair the damage
done.
Second, Mr. Epstein's untimely death, the timing is
curious to us. But more so, it makes it absolutely impossible
for the victims to ever get the day in court that they wanted
in court and to get full justice. That now can never happen.
I know that Mr. Epstein's attorneys say he wanted it, and they
know, we did too. And there are a lot of people here today
that are very sad by the way that this ended for both
Mr. Epstein and the fact that full justice was robbed from
them, once again.
The second issue I wanted to address was the Law
Review or the Law Journal article that your Honor referenced,
which is troubling because the opinion seems to say that
transparency is not appropriate in the criminal system and is
not appropriate at this point in time.
That's tough to swallow, especially in this case,
given the long history of this case. Personally, it is tough
to swallow, and on behalf of my clients, I can say that is very
concerning. Transparency is the only way that the justice
system works. We know this because there was a similar
investigation of Mr. Epstein many years ago, from 2005 to 2008.
My personal involvement in this case was because a
young female came into my office named , and she
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
came to me not asking to file a lawsuit against Jeffrey
Epstein, but simply asking for the government to talk to her.
She was cooperating in an FBI investigation and wanted the
government to speak with her, and I thought that was going to
be an easy task.
It was only a few months later that we learned that
this investigation that was represented to my client in written
form, that it would be a long investigation, and to be patient.
Basically, to hang tight. It was resolved by way of a secret
deal that never allowed any of the more than 30 victims who had
been identified of Mr. Epstein's abuse in Florida to ever
participate in a single hearing. There was a hearing. They
were never notified.
I then went on to represent many of them in civil
cases and also in extensive pro bono work. And I can tell your
Honor that while Jeffrey Epstein's abuse of them hurt them and
harmed them for many years, the feelings they had was
aggravated exponentially by the facts that they had no rights
in the criminal justice system, by the fact that they were
treated as if they didn't matter. They were not allowed their
rights under the Crime Victims' Rights Act to meaningfully
confer with prosecutors, to be treated with fairness, to be
treated with dignity. That is what this is supposed to be
about, and to have notice of hearings.
So I do want to thank your Honor, and especially the
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
prosecutors who have worked this investigation and this case,
which is very different in experience for all of my clients and
the other Epstein victims in this case, because they were
allowed to be a part of the process. While some of them
elected not to be here today, that opportunity should always be
allowed for them.
In 2008, we filed that case under the Crime Victims'
Rights Act because our clients' rights were violated, and as
your Honor knows, a federal judge has ruled in our clients'
favor that their rights were violated. So this hearing today
means a lot to them. The fact that they may never get their
chance to speak in court, they may never get complete closure,
and all of us have to wonder, if their rights had been afforded
them the first time, would any of us be here right now. Or
wouldn't it more likely be the case that everyone, including
Jeffrey Epstein, would have turned out better for it?
Today, I have not only represented, but met and become
very close with many of these victims. Many of these
survivors. They are very strong people. They are people who
have persevered through a lot of adversity. It's been a roller
coaster of emotions that has led us to where we are today. And
while they have all been cast over the years because of the
secrecy of the first investigation, in the shadow as victims,
you can't put them all in one bucket and say one size fits all.
They are each individual people who were harmed differently and
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS1
distinctly through not only the abuse, but the system.
And on behalf of all of them, I would like to thank
your Honor for the fairness with which they've been treated,
and the United States Attorney's office for the way in which
you have handled this investigation, and especially how you
have treated the victims in this case.
Like I said, I have many who want to speak. Some that
can't. This is a very difficult day for them. But we
appreciate the opportunity and the invitation.
The first client that I have that is going to address
your Honor is the one who walked into my office in 2008 asking
just to be heard,
THE COURT: Hold on one second. Did you all want to
be seated?
You don't need to be standing. Whatever is more
comfortable until you're ready to give some comments. It's up
to you.

Ms. , if you could spell your name for the court
reporters, please.
MS. , last name
Min
(Continued on next page)
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2

MS. : My name is , and I'm a victim
of Jeffrey Epstein. Jeffrey Epstein sexually abused me for
years, robbing me of my innocence and mental health. Jeffrey
Epstein has done nothing but manipulate our justice system,
where he has never been held accountable for his actions, even
to this day.
Jeffrey Epstein robbed myself and all the other
victims of our day in court to confront him one by one, and for
that he is a coward.
I want to thank the U.S. Attorney's for seeking
justice that has been long over due, and most importantly,
given us, the victims, our day in court to speak our peace and
find some sort of closure. I feel very angry and sad that
justice has never been served in this case. Thank you.
THE COURT: Thanks very much.
MR. EDWARDS: I believe my next client who is going to
speak is probably going to speak as Jane Doe.
JANE DOE NO. 1: Yes, Jane Doe.
THE COURT: We'll say Jane Doe No. 1, just for the
record.
JANE DOE NO. 1: Okay. Thank you for allowing us to
speak today. I've shifted what I want to say in hearing
what's already been said, and just about the question of
Jeffrey's death. I don't know what the relevance is to this
hearing, but I do know that it is profoundly relevant to my
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
life, as a victim. I don't like that word, but I still feel
like I am learning the ways that he's impacted me as a complex
situation, but he was also a major part of my life. As
destructive as that relationship was and as much of a villain
as we have created him to be -- based on facts we've created
him to be a villain -- he's a complex villain and actually all
of that is irrelevant. Anybody deserves -- an investigation is
the right thing to do. Like, we do need to know how he died.
It felt like a whole new trauma all over again, and I
don't know why, you know, because I I'm trying to defend
myself against him at this point in my life, but it still does
not feel good. It didn't feel good to wake up that morning and
find out that he had allegedly committed suicide. Okay. But I
also wanted to say to the press, I'm reading -- I read my story
in the paper. I read so many other girls' stories that are so
similar to my own, and everything that's been focused on is not
the most important part of it.
There was -- the problem with focusing on these, the
facts of the situation, that were out of the ordinary and like
because he was such a grand person, and it was just a unique
situation. I know that that's the more interesting side of the
story, but I don't want to be used as entertainment. And the
problem, the fundamental problem of the whole situation is the
element of exploitation and coercion, and these are things that
so many girls can relate to.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
And even though this Jeffrey Epstein brought it to a
grand scale, on some level, a lot of girls could relate to the
trauma that we are talking about, and even though this whole
situation sucks, I would like to think that it may be possibly
a catalyst for change because, obviously, as we're seeing with
the "Me Too" movement, change needs to happen and it's -- what
I'm seeing in the papers is not a common story, but it's so
much more common than you realize. That's all. Thank you.
THE COURT: Thank you very much.
MR. EDWARDS: I believe that the next client is going
to also be a Jane Doe; so I think for the purposes of the
record it will be Jane Doe 2.
THE COURT: Yes.
JANE DOE NO. 2: Good morning, your Honor.
THE COURT: Good morning. How are you?
JANE DOE NO. 2: Doing okay. I hadn't prepared any
words to speak today, but there is something that was on my
mind this morning when I got here. It's been on my mind in
reading through the press and through the people that I've
spoken to about it, friends, family. It's something that's
bothered me because I think it has a lot of blame in it, as
well, a little bit of what my friend, who was up here, was
speaking about.
I think that a lot of people asked why we spent so
much time, why we stayed. It's an experience that's really
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
hard to explain to people who haven't gone through it. I think
there's a writer, Thomas Nagel, who wrote an essay called "What
is it like to be a bat?" And I think that he touches on it
pretty strongly and if you haven't experienced something, it's
very hard to fully understand why someone makes the decisions
they do and what the circumstances were.
I don't want to speak for all of the victims. I think
each of us has a different story and different circumstances
for why we stayed in it, but for me, I think he was really
strategic in how he approached each of us. Things happened
slowly over time. We didn't -- it almost was like, putting it
like that analogy of a frog being in a pan of water and slowly
turning the flame up. You didn't realize it was happening, and
it just -- I don't think anyone can fully understand the
experience, but I just -- the blame feels very strong.
There's a lot of support as well, but I just want
people to try and understand that we aren't bad people. We
weren't trying to -- it wasn't a situation where we were trying
to extort money from someone. A lot of us were in very
vulnerable situations and in extreme poverty, circumstances
where we didn't have anyone on our side, to speak on our
behalf, and that's really scary.
You start to blame yourself because, at first, you
don't tell anyone what's happening, and it becomes your deep,
dark secret that you tried to keep from everyone. And I didn't
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JSRPEPS2
even know I was a victim until I spoke with my lawyers. I had
no idea. I had so much self-hatred and doubt and just guilt
for everything. I still do. I still don't feel like I deserve
to say I'm a victim, and I think that's a big problem with our
society right now, that people are still blaming victims, and I
think that does need to change.
I hope that today people understand that each of us
has a story, has a past, has a family and just give us a chance
to you know, that's basically all I just wanted to say.
THE COURT: Thank you so much.
JANE DOE NO. 2: Thank you so much.
THE COURT: Okay.

MR. EDWARDS: Okay. I think that the next person who
is going to speak is also going to be speaking as Jane Doe; so
for the purpose of the record, Jane Doe No. 3.
JANE DOE NO. 3: Thank you for allowing us to speak
today. I came to New York City 15 years ago to pursue modeling
from a small town. I signed on with an agency and was excited
to pursue my passion and my dream. Several months later, I met
a female who told me about Mr. Epstein. She portrayed him as
an amazing man who genuinely cared for people and that he was
going to be able to help me in a modeling career.
I was excited to meet him, after hearing her talk
about him. He sounded like an amazing person. An introduction
was made at his New York home, and it is there that I was
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
.1C
J8RPEPS2
sexually assaulted. I left his home, after he threw me,
basically put money on the table, and I was ashamed. I was
embarrassed. This was not the way I was brought up, and I
couldn't believe this had happened to me.
I left and my world kind of spiraled after that. I
stopped going on modeling castings. I gained weight. I became
depressed. I stopped going out with my friends, and only five
months after I had been in New York City to pursue my dream, I
left. I left the modeling industry, and I left New York City,
and I totally switched my career paths.
I buried this deep within me, and all of the new
occurrences that have come up in the media is what brought it
back up for me. And I feel sickened and saddened that it took
so many years, and God knows how many victims, for this tc
finally come out, but I'm thankful it did. And I'm just angry
that he's not alive anymore to have to pay the price for his
actions. So I thank you for your time.
THE COURT: You're very welcome.

MR. EDWARDS: Your Honor, Jane Doe No. 4, I believe,
is going to speak now.
JANE DOE NO. 4: Good morning, your Honor.
THE COURT: Good morning.
JANE DOE NO. 4: I just have something very short to
say. I met Jeffrey Epstein at a very vulnerable place in my
life, and whatever the outcome is with everything, I just
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
wanted to express that we, the victims, we will always carry
irreparable damage and pain throughout our lives after this.
It's something that's never going to go away.
You know, whoever we marry in our life, whatever
future we have in our life, it's always going to be something
that's always there for us. And I'm very nervous right now.
And Jeffrey Epstein, he took away the chance I had at having
the future I had envisioned for myself as a young girl, and 1
think many of us here today will never fully heal from that
pain and the heartache that we'll continue carrying with us.
So I just wanted to say that. It's something that
it's irreparable. I can't even really use a better word to
describe that. So thank you for hearing us today.
THE COURT: You're very welcome.
MR. EDWARDS: Your Honor, Jane Doe No. 5 would like to
speak.
JANE DOE NO. 5: This is a letter that I wrote; so
it's going to be: Dear Jeffrey, I think you are a mentally
disturbed human being. You used your power to make me believe
at a young age that I could have my dreams of being a model.
You paid for your freedom. You violated my rights. You should
have to pay for them, just as anyone else. You got a plea deal
that no one else would have been able to get. You used your
money to get out of paying the price for your actions.
Also, as a victim, I never got to see what the
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
agreement was or why the special treatment got approved.
think you should have been in jail for several years in
population and live like everyone else that is mentally
disturbed like you. You paid for yourself to get special
treatment while you were in jail. I don't even think you spent
a day in a jail as a normal human being.
You had investigators come to my house and also went
to my friend's house to question them. I will never be able to
over -- I will never be able to get over the overwhelming
emotions and embarrassment I experienced from that trauma. 1
needed therapy several times a week and had high stress and
anxiety levels.
You paid your way to make the public think that the
girls had nothing in life going on for them. You wanted to try
and blame that we were lower class and that was the problem
with the girls. I was from a middle class family and did well
in school. I lived the American girl dream -- or the American
girl life. I went on family vacations around the world, grew
up in a good city, and my parents are still married to this
day. Basically, everything you said that we didn't have in our
life, I did.
It all came down to I was told I was making $200 in an
hour. Being young, that was a lot of money, and I didn't know
any better. Sadly, you were the one with an illness that you
should have to go and see a doctor and also have a mentor group
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
for the sickness you have. I will continue with writing my
book about that secret life, with all the newspaper articles of
the case, my high school agenda book of official dates. I'm
basing that proof that I deposited cash after leaving
Jeffrey's. I still have all of the information, articles that
I collected over the years.
You mentally and physically traumatized me. I went to
therapy, and it was the best thing I did for myself. If anyone
only learns one thing from this case, I hope is that money
should not let you buy your way free. A crime is a crime and a
victim is a victim. Thank you.
THE COURT: Thank you. Thank you very much.
MR. EDWARDS: Your Honor, my next client is
MS. : I met Jeffrey Epstein through my first
massage teacher, a man who took me in as his apprentice to
teach me a practice I wanted to learn while in desperate search
to find a cure for a debilitating neurological disorder that
have, which manifests into violent vomiting attacks, largely
triggered by stress. It's called Cyclic Vomiting Syndrome.
I was recruited by Ghislaine Maxwell. Upon my first
meeting of her, I wouldn't know I had been recruited until many
years later, when I would read it in a headline. Ghislaine and
Jeffrey took me in. They sent me to school. They gave me a
job. They flew me around the world, introduced me to a world I
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
had only dreamt of and made me feel as though I had become a
part of their family, another thing I was desperately searching
for.
But on my third or fourth time meeting them, they
brought me to Jeffrey's island for the first time, and on the
first night there, came tapping on my door late at
night to inform me Jeffrey was ready for another massage. My
instincts told me this didn't feel right, but I got up and
followed her to a villa I hadn't yet seen. Jeffrey and
Ghislaine's villa.
I began my massage, trying not to let him smell my
fear and obvious discomfort, but before I knew what was
happening, he grabbed onto my wrist and tugged me towards the
bed. I tried to pull away, but he was unbuttoning my shorts
and pulling my body onto his already naked body faster than 1
could think. I was searching for words but all I could say was
meek, "No, please stop," but that just seemed to excite him
more.
He continued to rape me, and when he was finished, he
hopped off and went to the shower. I pulled my shorts up, and
I ran as fast as I could back to my own villa, my feet bloodied
from the rocks. I cried myself to sleep that night.
I spent two weeks vomiting, almost to death, in a
Los Angeles hospital after that first encounter. Jeffrey's
abuse would continue for the next three years, and I allowed it
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
to continue because I had been taken advantage of my entire
life and had been conditioned to just accept it.
It took me a long time to come forward, too long
maybe, and all it took to bring -- and all that it took to
bring this man to justice has been robbed by his death. Every
day, every week I've spent in the hospital since, I've suffered
and he has won. Every job offer that's been offered to me and
then retracted because of my connection to this case, I have
suffered and he has won. Every public humiliation I have
endured, I have suffered and he has won. Every relationship
that I've had to end because of the abuse that I have endured
by the hands of this man, I have suffered and he has won.
Every woman sitting in this room today, and all of the
women who have yet come forward and who have not yet to come
forward and whose lives have been affected by Jeffrey Epstein's
sick abuse of young girls, we have all suffered, and he is
still winning in death.
I refuse to let this man win in death. I couldn't
fight back when Jeffrey Epstein sexually abused me because I
hadn't yet found my voice. Well, I have found my voice now,
and while Jeffrey may no longer be here to hear it, I will not
stop fighting, and I will not be silenced anymore. I needed
him to hear the pain he's caused, what I've gone through
because of him. I wrote a 350-page book of all the pain that I
have endured at the hands of this man that I really needed him
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JSRPEPS2
to hear. His death has robbed me of that justice.
Please don't rob us of justice again. Thank you.
THE COURT: Thank you.

MR. EDWARDS: Your Honor, I think I have one more
client that is going to speak today,
THE COURT: Would you spell that?

MS. DE : Good morning, your Honor.
THE COURT: Good morning.
MS. DE : My name is spelled
Thank you, your Honor, for giving us the opportunity
to be heard this morning.
THE COURT: Sure.

MS. DE : When I was introduced to Jeffrey
Epstein, I was young and full of hope and the foolishness of
teenager. I was idealistic, and I saw the good in people.
Jeffrey Epstein manipulated me, coerced me and sexually abused
me.
Something I think is very important to communicate is
that loss of innocence, trust and joy is not recoverable. The
abuse, spanning several years, was devaluing beyond measure and
affected my ability
both in my work and
fathom what he took
to form and maintain healthy relationships,
my personal life. He could not begin to
from us, and I say "us" because I am every
girl he did this to, and they're all me. And today we stand
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JSRPEPS2
together, those that are present and those that aren't.
I was a victim, and it has taken me many, many years
to stand here and say, yes, it was me. I was a victim, but 1
will not remain a victim and be silent for one more day.
Although I think it's tragic when anybody dies before their
time, I'm extremely relieved that Jeffrey Epstein will not be
in a position to hurt anymore children or anymore women, and
I'm glad to be part of a group of women who are now bonded
forever in the trauma that we endured at the hands of this man.
Thank you.
THE COURT: Thank you.

MR. EDWARDS: Your Honor, we had one client who was
not able to be here but sent a message through a letter. Her
name is last name,
. And Brittany Henderson, of my office, is going to
read her letter as instructed.
THE COURT: Sure.

MS. HENDERSON: Thank you, your Honor.
THE COURT: Yup.
MS. HENDERSON: What happened to me occurred many
years ago when I was in high school, but it still effects my
life. I was told then that Jeffrey Epstein was going to be
held accountable, but he was not. In fact, the government
worked out a secret deal and didn't tell me about it. The case
ended without me knowing what was going on, without him being
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JSRPEPS2
held responsible, without any explanation and without a chance
for my voice to be heard. I was treated like I did not matter.
Many years later, he was arrested again. These
investigators and attorneys representing the United States have
been completely different. I am still mad, concerned and
confused about how he committed suicide and escaped
responsibility again, but I know it is not the fault of the
judge or the government attorneys.
I was allowed to be a part of the process this time.
My attorney was able to tell me what was going on at every
stage because they kept him informed. Thank you for inviting

me. It means more to me than you can ever know. I was not
able to be here this time, but I know that I was allowed to be
and I had the chance to attend this hearing, which is helping
me in my healing process. The fact that I mattered this time
and the other victims mattered is what counts. For that, I am
grateful.
THE COURT: Thank you.

MR. EDWARDS: Your Honor, finally, in 2008 when I
filed the case under the Crime Victims Rights Act, it wasn't me
alone. I did it with Paul Cassell and Jay Howell.
Paul Cassell is here today, and I think your Honor
even cited to a piece of -- an opinion of his from when he was
on the bench, and he has some remarks to make.
Once again, your Honor, I really do believe that this
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
is a model for how victims should be treated in a criminal
process, and we really do appreciate it. Thank you.
THE COURT: Thank you.
MR. CASSELL: I'll be very brief because I know there
are others that want to speak here. I'm Paul Cassell,
C-a-s-s-e-1-1, previously served as a federal judge at the
District of Utah, currently a law professor, where I teach
crime victims rights at the University of Utah, College of Law.
I just wanted to take one minute to address some
suggestion that there would be no need for a hearing this
morning. I think, having heard already from these powerful
victims and recognizing how important giving those statements
will be in the trajectory of their lives, makes clear that your
Honor has followed exactly the right path. Legally, there is
one precedent, which is U.S. v. Heaton, a case that you cited
that I wrote about a decade ago, and as explained in that
opinion, victims have important interests in the criminal
justice system that can only be recognized if they're given
their day in court.
With all due respect to other law professors that have
recently written an article, I think transparency is one of the
overriding objectives in our criminal justice system, and the
one substantive action that I would urge your Honor to take
today is to publish your remarks as a published opinion. The
Heaton case is, to my knowledge, the only reported decision on
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
this particular issue, even though it's more than a decade old
and, yet, we can see today that these problems recur in many
other cases. Your remarks today, I think, should be published
so that they can serve as a guide for other judges around the
country.
I would encourage you to add into your remarks a
reference to the Crime Victims Rights Act. The Crime Victims
Right Act promises victims the right to be treated with
fairness, dignity and respect, and the process that we see
unfolding this morning is a clear example of how victims can be
treated with fairness, dignity and respect.
So I know that your Honor is wondering what is the
appropriate action here. Unfortunately, it seems like there
are no other legal options, but there was a legal option for
you to decide to exercise, which was to allow these victims to
come forward. And if there's been one positive thing that has
come out of the tragedies, the abuse, the other events of this
case, it's been your decision to allow these victims to be
heard this morning, and I encourage you to publish your
decision and to encourage other judges to follow what is
clearly a model for crime victims rights and is clearly an
example that should be followed in other cases down the road.
THE COURT: Thank you very much. I appreciate your
being here. I had no idea that you would be here when I wrote
the remarks, but it was clear from the literature that you are
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
the leading expert formerly of the District Court of Utah, I
believe, and it's a pleasure to have you here today.

MR. CASSELL: Thank you, your Honor.
THE COURT: Thanks.
Mr. Boies?
MR. BOIES: Thank you, your Honor. David Boies of
Boies Schiller Flexner. We have with us today five of the
victims that we represent. There are a number of additional
victims who either were unable to attend or are still unwilling
to come forward publicly. This has been an enormously
traumatic aspect of their lives, something that, as you've
already heard and will hear more today, is something that they
can never entirely escape from.
I want to, as prior counsel have, commend both the
Court and counsel for the Department of Justice for the
consideration and respect and attention that they have paid to
the victims. We believe that that is not only right, as a
matter of human dignity, but we think that is exactly what the
law requires and intends.
I will be more blunt than the Court has been, or
Professor Cassell has been about Professor Green's article.
That is an article that cites no authority, and I believe there
is no authority for his proposition. I entirely respect his
right to advocate on behalf of his client Alan Dershowitz, who
has retained him in connection with litigation that we've
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
brought against Mr. Dershowitz, but I would have expected that
the Law Journal or Professor Green himself would have disclosed
that connection, which I think is a conflict.
But regardless of the appropriateness of his
disclosure, or lack of disclosure, I think that his article
opposing allowing the victims to have a voice in this
proceeding is inconsistent not only with the policy that
underlies the Crime Victim Rights Act and the very statute that
Mr. Epstein is being prosecuted under, but it ignores the
actual language of those statutes, and many other statutes, in
which Congress has made clear that the purpose of the criminal
law is no longer simply to punish the individual defendant, but
it is to find some way of trying to mitigate the damage that
has been done to the victims through restitution and economic
mitigation, but also through the ability to confront and to
have the court system and the justice system and the
prosecutors treat these victims as they are victims, as they
are human beings, and they are entitled to the respect that our
society needs to give every human being. So I think that this
is not only commendable, but I think it is what the law
requires.
In response to the question the Court asked, I have
discussed this hearing with my clients. I have told them that,
under the applicable law, the government has no alternative but
to move to dismiss this case, and I believe under the
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
applicable law in this circuit, the Court has no alternative
but to grant that motion.
I think the current law is outdated, as the Court
suggested in some of its remarks. I think there will come a
time when either an Appellate court or the Congress will make
clear that, just as it's possible to continue civil cases
against someone after they have deceased, it is possible, at
least for purposes of things like restitution, to continue
criminal cases, but we are not there now. And, fortunately, in
this case, there are other ways and perhaps even more efficient
ways to vindicate the interests of the victims here.
We greatly appreciate the remarks of the
representative of the Department of Justice today, and we, too,
on behalf of the victims, are not going to stop when we walk
out of this courtroom. We are going to continue to seek
vindication against Mr. Epstein's estate and, in some senses,
perhaps even more important, against the people who worked with
him and enabled him.
As you have already heard, and will hear more,

Mr. Epstein did not act alone. He could not have done what he
did, on the scope and the scale of what he did, for as many
years as he did it without the activities and support and the
co-conspirator activity of a number of other key individuals,
and those individuals also need to bear their share of
responsibility, and those people need to have a reckoning as
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
well.
My partner Sig McCawley, who's been working with me
for more than five years on this case, is going to, with the
Court's permission, introduce five of our clients who will
speak briefly to your Court. Thank you very much.
THE COURT: Thank you very much, Mr. Boies. Pleasure
to have you here.

MS. McCAWLEY: Thank you, your Honor, the first victim
that would like to speak today is
THE COURT: Can we have the spelling of your name?

MS. McCAWLEY: Sure. Sigrid, S-i-g-r-i-d, and the
last name is M-c-C-a-w-1-e-y, and I'm a partner at Boies
Schiller Flexner.
THE COURT: Thank you.

MS. : Good morning.
THE COURT: Good morning.
MS. : Thank you, prosecutors and Judge, and the
Court. My name is . I note today I do feel
respected and listened to; so I appreciate that, and I have to
say that I commend the boldness of the New York prosecutors for
pursuing a man that has, you know -- and others, that have
clearly taken a lot from a lot of people.
17 years ago I knew him only as "Jeffrey." I was
recruited and brought from California to New York, and that
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JSRPEPS2
experience for the last 17 years has been a dark corner in my
story, in my life, in my life story and that has been
definitely made worse by my own self-shame and that -- and
anger for normalizing all of the red flags. I feel like we are
conditioned to do that, and that's something that needs to
change.
So I'm here today, you know, I'm coming forward
because it is time to bring light to that darkness, and it's
time to replace that darkness with light. And I am a survivor
of this, and I do aim to progress further from being a
survivor, you know. I feel I've worked hard, quite hard, to
get to where I'm at now, and I'm definitely at a place in my
life where I will no longer cover up. I'll no longer cover up
what needs to be brought to light.
Jeffrey is no longer here, and the women that helped
him are, Ghislaine Maxwell. My experience is with Ghislaine
Maxwell and , and they definitely need to be held
accountable for helping him, helping themselves, helping one
another carry on this huge, almost like a system. So they need
to be held accountable, all of them, and I would like to see
that, certainly on behalf of myself and for everyone here.
Thank you.
THE COURT: Thanks so much.

MS. McCAWLEY: Our next client, who is going to speak
this morning, is
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2

MS. : Good morning, your Honor.
THE COURT: Good morning. How are you?
MS. : Okay. Thank you. My name is
, that's
I am a victim of Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell
in the dark and cruel and criminal acts they committed against
me and hundreds of other girls and young women for years and
years and years, unstopped.
Thank you for allowing me to address the Court and
speak the truth. I commend the prosecutors from the Southern
District of New York for the ongoing investigation and its
pursuit of justice for us victims. It has given me hope, and I
will not let go of that hope.
When I was recruited by Ghislaine Maxwell at
Mar-a-Lago, just before I was 17, I thought I was given a big
break, and I'd be able to reset my life and become an actual
real massage therapist. My hopes were quickly dashed, and my
dreams were stolen. Jeffrey Epstein
this is not about how he died. This
He will not have his day in
is no longer alive, but
is about how he lived.
court, but the reckoning
of accountability has begun, supported by the voices of these
brave and beautiful women in this courtroom today. The
reckoning must not end. It must continue. He did not act
alone and we, the victims, know that. We trust the government
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
is listening and that the others will be brought to justice.
Thank you, your Honor.
THE COURT: Thank you very much.

MS. McCAWLEY: The next client of ours that will be
speaking this morning is
MS. Thank you, your Honor. My name is
I'm a victim of Jeffrey Epstein and
Ghislaine Maxwell's international sex trafficking ring.
I would like to thank the Court for the dignity and
the respect you are showing me here today, as well as the other
victims. I would also like to acknowledge and extend my
gratitude to the prosecutors from the Southern District of
New York for pursuing justice on behalf of the victims.
Please, please finish what you have started. I struggled to
find the words to adequately say how important your work is to
us.
For a very long time Jeffrey Epstein gamed the system
at every level, and when he realized he couldn't do that any
longer, he showed the world what a depraved and cowardly human
being he is by taking his own life. But we, the victims, are
still here, prepared to tell the truth, and we all know he did
not act alone. We are survivors, and the pursuit of justice
should not abate. Thank you, your Honor.
THE COURT: You're very welcome.

MS. McCAWLEY: Our next client who is going to be
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
speaking this morning is

MS. : Good morning, your Honor.
THE COURT: Good morning.
MS.
I had the opportunity to speak at Jeffrey Epstein's
bail hearing, and I really appreciate that you heard me and
listened to me that day. I am so sorry that others will not
have the opportunity to stand before him the way that I did.
But I'm here today to speak on behalf of my sister,
, who could not be here.
Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell not only assaulted
her, but as we're hearing from so many of these brave women
here today, they stole her dreams and her livelihood. She
risked her safety in 1996, so many years ago, to report them,
to no avail, and it is heartbreaking to her and to me that all
this destruction has been wrought since that time.
We were deeply disappointed and disturbed by Epstein's
death and the fact that that was allowed to happen while he was
in the government's custody, and I'm encouraged to hear that
there will be a full investigation as to how that was allowed
to happen.
But it is extremely important, as others are saying,
that he did not act alone and that the other people that were a
part of what he did are held accountable and that that
investigation continues.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
I believe that we have a real problem in this country
with perpetrators of sexual abuse and sexual assault being held
accountable. There are so many roadblocks to victims being
heard, to cases being investigated thoroughly, and then to
those cases being prosecuted. And so I think this is a really
important signal to send a message to victims out there that
people will take you seriously, people will follow through, and
that even those in power, as we have unfortunately seen, that
has not been often are able to escape that, that even those in
power will be held accountable. Thank you.
THE COURT: Thanks so much.

MS. McCAWLEY: Our next client, who's going to address
the Court is . She says it much more
beautifully than I do; so I'll let her say it.
MS. : My first name is spelled,
-• last name is
My name is , and I am a victim of
Jeffrey Epstein and the sophisticated sex trafficking operation
he ran, where he allegedly was to be a financier.
I was 20 and previously modeled and was living in the
West Village. I met a young woman named Rena through a mutual
friend. We were friends for a few months. She was an amazing
artist and liked to party. One day she called me and asked if
I was interested in meeting a friend of hers. She told me he
wanted to meet me and really liked blonds, and I thought he was
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
our age and liked to do the same things we did at that age; so
I agreed.
On a sunny, crisp day, we took the train together to
the Upper East Side. She then began to talk a little bit about
him on our way to his house. I was at his house. I was
sexually assaulted by both Rena and Jeffrey Epstein in his
mansion. It left me feeling both disgusted and betrayed.
As we walked home to the subway afterwards, she
continued to tell me about the man who had just abused me with
her participation. She seemed exhilarated from the horrific
experience. I was shocked and in a daze. This is a few things
that she had told me. She told me he went to Cooper Union. He
was a mathematical genius. That he had favorite girls that he
would take to Chanel for 15-minute, all-you-can-buy shopping
trips. She told me his right-hand person had connection to the
arts and the fashion world, and she could help me.
This is not my complete story. I'll stop here. I'm
in a good, stable place in my life, and I had decided to come
forward to be a voice to the victims who may not be able to
tell their story, or at least not yet. I feel like I am a
survivor.
Thank you, Judge Berman, for inviting victims to speak
today before you. We hope the government is listening very
closely to the words we are saying.
THE COURT: Thank you very much.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2

MR. BOIES: Your Honor, just very briefly.
THE COURT: Sure.
MR. BOIES: I would like to express to the Court how
proud I am of all of these women who have come forward. It's
taken an enormous amount of strength and courage for them to do

so. Thank you.
THE COURT: Thanks, Mr. Boies. Hold on one second.
(Pause)
MS. LERNER: Thank you, your Honor. My name is
Kimberly Lerner, of Lerner and Lerner, and your Honor, with
your permission, I would like my client, , to
stand next to me.
THE COURT: Sure.

MS. LERNER: Would that be okay?
THE COURT: Absolutely.
MS. LERNER: Your Honor, I would like to begin by
saying that I am in awe of all of these beautiful women. I
just want to let you know, on behalf of and myself, we
admire you, we respect you, and we applaud you, and you are
brave survivors. And heart is with all of you, and
we thank you so much for coming forward.
, when she went public, she thought she was
one of the only ones, and to see all of these faces is, I know,
amazing for her.
Jeffrey Epstein was a predator, a pedophile and a sick
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
individual. However, he was also a thief. He stole
childhood dreams, her innocence and her self-confidence. She
was 14 years old. What he could not buy, he forcibly took.
Why? Because he surrounded himself with a network of powerful
people who not only looked the other way, but also actively
facilitated and participated in his sexual abuse of children.
Jeffrey Epstein thought he was above the law, and
essentially he was until now. The system let and the
other victims down, but it does not have to end here. We ask
the U.S. Attorney's Office and the FBI to bring all of
Epstein's enablers and co-conspirators to justice.
It has taken 18 years to find her voice, and
again, Jeffrey Epstein has tried to silence her. While she
will never have her chance to face him in court, he no longer
has any power over her. Today, this brave survivor will be
heard.
MS. Thank you for allowing me to be able to
have my chance in court today, to be able to tell you what this
horrific man did to my life. You can't even imagine how much
it affected my childhood, all the way through my adult life.
He robbed me of my dreams. He robbed me of my chance to pursue
a career I always adored. He stole my chance at really feeling
love because I was so scared to trust anyone for so many years
that I had such severe anxiety. I didn't want to leave my
house let alone my bed.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
The fact that he felt entitled to take away my
innocence, the fact that he felt that he could do whatever he
wanted, regardless of the laws, hurts me so very much. It took
me years to tell anyone what Epstein did to me because I was so
ashamed and embarrassed at what people would say or think of me
until I found out there were other victims, girls just like me.
I knew I could no longer keep my silence no matter how ruthless
and powerful Epstein was, and still is even after his death.
The fact I will never have a chance to face my
predator in court eats away at my soul. Even in death, Epstein
is trying to hurt me. I had hoped to at last get an apology,
but this evil man had no remorse or caring for what he did to
anyone. I felt let down by the people who were supposed to
watch him in prison. They let this man kill himself and kill
the chance of justice for so many others in the process, taking
away our ability to speak.
Out of all the damages and side effects that Epstein
caused by his heartless and selfish acts, it's very hard to put
my feelings and emotions into words, trying to let his
horrendous actions go and attempting to forgive him, has been
so difficult for me. Yet, as hard as it's been to come so
publicly forward, I refuse to let Epstein take me as a victim
anymore.
I am a survivor. The many that stand before me here
today that have shared the horrific experiences with this
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
deplorable human being, because even though this weak, evil
coward tried to steal all of our childhoods, tried to steal all
of our innocence and tried to steal all of our means of
justice, he will never steal our inner strength, and he will
never, ever, ever steal our voice. Thank you so much.
THE COURT: You're welcome.

MS. GIBBS: Good morning, your Honor. Teri Gibbs,
T-e-r-i, G-i-b-b-s. For the record, I am a California
attorney. I'm not admitted to the New York State bar. I am
here to make a statement on behalf of New York attorney, Lisa
Bloom. I work for her firm, The Bloom Firm.
Lisa Bloom represents four of Jeffrey Epstein's
victims, Jane Doe 6, for the record, Jane Doe 7 and Jane Doe 8.
I am so proud of all of you victims who are here today and are
able to voice yourselves today. I will not and cannot comment
on the criminal case, or Ms. Bloom's communications with her
clients.
Ms. Bloom would like to share three of her client's
statements for the record. Here are the statements. Statement
of Jane Doe 6.
To the Honorable Richard M. Berman. Jeffrey Epstein
stole my innocence. He gave me a life sentence of guilt and
shame. I do not consider myself a victim. I see myself a
survivor. The abuse that I endured cannot continue. Let's
stop this before it happens to other young women. Jane Doe.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
Statement of Jane Doe 7. To the Honorable Richard M.
Berman. I used to be relatively carefree, inquisitive, hopeful
and excited about life, but my life changed because of Jeffrey
Epstein. My perspective on life became very dark when I was
unknowingly recruited by one of his agents. Jeffrey Epstein
ruined me. His recruiter ruined me. The far-reaching
consequences of that day ruined my family's lives.
I've chosen to remain anonymous in order to protect my
family from unwanted media attention.
I was just trying to figure out my path in life when I
encountered Jeffrey Epstein in his New York City mansion. I
cannot even begin to summarize the many detriments this
experience of sexual assault has had on my life. Immediately
following the incident, I was unable to function and be around
other people. My parents had to rescue me and bring me home,
where I became a recluse for years.
I was changed forever and buried my assault deep down,
where the darkness couldn't hurt me anymore, but of course, it
has always been here, lingering and affecting me unconsciously.
At the time, I was mired in shame, guilt and humiliation. I
had somehow tricked myself into thinking that I had allowed the
assault to happen, that I did it to myself, that I don't
deserve to be alive or to be loved. I believed that I was a
disgusting, shameful person who does not deserve to ever be
happy. These are the thoughts I've lived with on a daily
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
basis.
Furthermore, because I couldn't tell anyone, out of
fear of judgment, blame or retaliation, keeping this secret
completely hindered my ability to uncover why these issues
existed for me, which could have led to a path of healing over
the years.
It is time for those of power to do the right thing.
It is time for compassion toward our fellow human beings to
reign over money, power and greed. We need to protect our most
vulnerable to allow them a chance at a normal life, and nothing
should come in the way of that. I believe that for future
generations, including my own children, this case will set a
precedent that victims must no longer suffer in silence on our
own or be shamed for coming forward to seek protection.
This case should demonstrate to those who want to harm
others that there will be a reckoning, and they will pay dearly
for the harm they inflict on innocent people. Judge Berman, :
thank you for from the bottom of my heart for this forum and
opportunity.
To all of those survivors who came before me, I
commend your bravery. There is no way I could have done this
without you.
Thank you to the public following this story, for your
outrage and desire for answers, which will hopefully move this
case forward so that victims can stop having to relive their
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RPEPS2
experiences every day and move on to begin to heal.
God bless the victims, their families, the
investigators and public servants working so diligently to find
those answers and to right all these wrongs. Jane Doe 7.
(Continued on next page)
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
CH
J8RsEPS3
THE COURT: Thanks very much.
MS. GIBBS: One more. Statement of Jane Doe 8.
In the past few weeks, I have had to reflect on my
interaction with Jeffrey Epstein and realized that, though I
have yet to put it all behind me, I am still a victim. I say
this because I have to come to terms with it in an effort to
truly get past the abuse I suffered at the hands of Epstein.
Pursuing criminal penalties against him and having an
opportunity to address the egregious crimes he committed
against me and other young woman would have helped my recovery
process. This all came to an abrupt halt when he took his own
life. This point of disclosure is lost.
I cannot say that i am pleased he committed suicide,
but I am at peace knowing he will not be able to hurt anyone
else. However, a sad truth remains. I, along with other
people, will never have an answer as to why. I will never have
an apology for the wrongdoing. And most importantly, Epstein
will not be justly sentenced for his crimes. Now I sit in my
home questioning the well-being of those girls like myself. In
choosing death, Epstein denied everyone justice.
Any efforts made to protect Epstein's name and legacy
send a message to the victims that he wins and that he is
untouchable. I understand his case may be dismissed or closed,
but this makes me feel as though I, and anyone else who fell
pry to his hands, simply do not matter.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
I ask that you very seriously consider the final
decision, because it will undoubtedly affect all other facets
of this case, including any future charges brought against the
recruiters or third parties to his crimes. I do not want the
narrative to be, Those poor girls. I want to send a message to
anyone who would consider engaging in similar acts to think
twice beforehand. I want some sort of closure for those of us
who relive those horrible moments where we were assaulted,
abused, and taken advantage of by Epstein.
You have the opportunity to help us seek that closure.
I appreciate your time and consideration and ask for your
continued support in dealing with this case to illustrate that
we, Epstein's victims, do matter.
Sincerely, Jane Doe 8.
On behalf of Lisa Bloom and The Bloom Firm, thank you,
your Honor.
THE COURT: Thank you, Ms. Gibbs.
Did we have any other victim's counsel or victims?
Ms. Allred.
MS. ALLRED: Good morning, your Honor.
THE COURT: Good morning. How are you?
MS. ALLRED: Fine. Thank you.
Allred, Maroko & Goldberg by Gloria Allred,
G-1-o-r-i-a A-1-1-r-e-d.
Your Honor, thank you so much for this opportunity to
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
afford the victims their voice, because many of them have never
spoken before. They never spoke in Florida. They never spoke
anywhere. They never told their mother. They never told their
father. They never told their family members. This is an
opportunity for them to be heard. We thank you for that.
Your Honor, for 43 years my firm has been the leading
women's rights private law firm in the United States. We have
helped thousands of victims. And I, as an officer of the
court, and as a believer in the system, have tried to encourage
the victims to have confidence in the system that should
provide them access to justice that should help them to assert
and vindicate their rights in a court of law. It has been
increasingly difficult in this case for me to say to my clients
that they should have confidence in the system of justice given
what has occurred in this case, People v. Jeffrey Epstein.
Having said that, I am encouraged by the fact that
this court, essentially, in an unprecedented situation where
the defendant is deceased, is still affording these victims an
opportunity to be heard. So we thank you for that. It is some
encouragement.
Your Honor, you also asked do our clients wish to be
heard in reference to some of the issues that have been raised
this morning, including what should happen into this case.
Your Honor, there has been a suggestion that the court should
investigate the circumstances of the death of Mr. Epstein. I'm
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
not going to repeat the arguments made by counsel, but I would
say that if there is jurisdiction, and I know that is a legal
issue which has been previously argued, that certainly it would
increase the confidence of my clients. Not just my clients,
but victims all over, and some are, by the way, located in
other parts of the world, to have the court oversee the
investigation.
We are encouraged by the sensitivity of the attorneys
for the United States Attorney's office for the Southern
District of New York and the investigation that is going on
with the separate team. However, and, of course, the defense
is also conducting its own investigation. But I do think the
greatest confidence would be if the court in some way would be
able to oversee an investigation because the court is a neutral
party. And although the court certainly has a stake in finding
out what happened to defendants who are in the custody of the
federal system and who should be there to face the prosecutors
and the charges against them, but now are not because clearly
the system has failed.
And the United States Attorney has admitted that, and
even before he admitted that, everybody knows the system
failed. Failed the victims, failed the court, failed everyone.
In any event, your Honor, having seen so many
thousands of victims of gender violence, sex harassment, sexual
assault, I've dealt with child sex trafficking, child
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
molesters, I mean, this is a unique case because there are so
many victims and so many failures of the system. At this
point, what we would really ask for is not just words, but
words have been helpful, but deeds, and that is very important.
In addition, I would like to say, throughout this case
is the running theme of the betrayal of trust. Betrayal of
trust by Jeffrey Epstein. Betrayal of trust by the system.
And betrayal of trust to the victims who had a right to
justice. And the Crime Victims' Act should not just be words,
it should have meaning and it should be enforced.
In essence, we are asking, although you may need to,
of course, grant this motion to dismiss, I think because the
court has shown sensitivity to victims and victims' needs, if
there is a way to at least keep the record open so that victims
who have not been able to be physically present in the
courtroom today and who have not been able to submit to the
court any letters, victim impact, and who have not been able to
secure attorneys or speak to attorneys yet -- so, for example,
I'll still hearing from victims who I have not been able to
meet with yet because they just recently are now contacting
me -- so if they could submit, at least for the record, their
victim impact statements, that, I think, would be a very
important assistance to them. So that would be, at least they
would know that what they are sharing is on the record.
So, in summary, I would say that they are looking
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
forward to the very serious investigation by the United States
Attorney of who may have conspired in this case, and that is
very hopeful, and we're hoping that everyone who may have a
role to this criminal prosecution will submit that evidence.
This is about power. This is about many victims
having lived in fear -- fear of the rich, the powerful, the
famous, fear that the system will not afford them justice. So
fear of not coming forward. And fear, of course, is a weapon
that the rich, powerful, famous, and sexual predators used to
silence the victims. But that is gone for a lot of victims
because they refuse to suffer in silence.
Finally, it does take courage to speak truth to power.
We thank this honorable court for giving these victims a voice.
We thank them, even after the death of the defendant, for
showing respect for the victims, allowing them dignity,
allowing them a voice. We do want truth, we do want justice,
we do want accountability, and we do want those conspirators to
face the justice system.
Your Honor, right now we have two of our clients who
would like to address the court.
THE COURT: Sure.

MS. ALLRED: Then I have a couple of statements on
victims who do not wish to address the court.
As they come up, we'll give them the opportunity to
say either their name or Jane Doe.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
By the way, thank you, your Honor, for allowing some
of these victims to be called Jane Doe. What number the court
affords to them, we'll accept whatever that is.
Thank you.
THE COURT: We're up to nine.
MS. ALLRED: Thank you.
MS. Hello. My name is . That _5
I was going to start this statement by saying that 1
was a victim of Jeffrey Epstein. But that's not the case. I'm
still a victim of Jeffrey Epstein. I'm still a victim because
the fear of not being heard stopped me from telling my story
for so many years. This lingering fear almost stopped me from
attending this monumental movement of strength and power.
I'm still a victim because I am fearful for my
daughters and everyone's daughters. I'm fearful for their
future in this world, where there are predators in power, a
world where people can avoid justice if their pockets run deep
enough.
I'm still a victim because the 17-year-old was
manipulated into thinking she had found someone who cared,
someone who wanted to help. Jeffrey knew I had nowhere to go.
He knew I was vulnerable, and he took advantage of that poor
girl, who will never be the same.
I cannot eat at the thought that Jeffrey Epstein -- _
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
cannot eat at the thought of Jeffrey Epstein not serving the
time he needed to realize the pain and suffering he caused so
many vulnerable young girls. He thought he was untouchable,
and honestly, so did I. I thought he was the most powerful
person I would ever meet.
But the end is here and here I stand becoming more
powerful than he will ever be. Thank you.
THE COURT: Thank you.
JANE DOE: Jane Doe.
Um, in 2004, when I was 15 years old, I flew on
Jeffrey Epstein's plane to Zorro Ranch, where I was sexual
molested by him for many hours. What I remember most vividly
was him explaining to me how beneficial the experience was for
me and how much he was helping me to grow. Yikes.
I remember feeling so small and powerless, especially
after he positioned me by laying me on his floor so that I was
confronted by all the framed photographs on his dresser of him
smiling with wealthy celebrities and politicians.
After he finished with me, he told me to describe in
detail how good my first sexual experience felt. That was the
first of many lies I was forced to carry for him, the weight of
which proliferated my trauma. I felt powerless not merely
because one man wanted to strip me of my innocence, but because
I was the victim of a system that just enfranchises human
beings, making them vulnerable to pedophilic exploitation.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
As unjust as what happened to me was, I believe that
experience to be a symptom of insidious and pathological
violence that extreme wealth yields, a violence which
ultimately stays hidden through channels of extreme power that
serve it.
I first identified with this feeling the night after I
was molested by Epstein, when another girl and I took out two
of his ATVs and raised them across the mesa. I crashed mine
and expressed my concern to the other girl of getting in
trouble, which she replied to me, Don't worry, no one gets in
trouble for anything here.
Even as a child, I understood, in a sad and precocious
way, what I hoped we have the ability of changing now. Even
though Epstein is dead, there is still justice to be brought
for the crimes we felt powerless against concealing for him and
the system that supported him for all these years.
Thank you.
THE COURT: You're very welcome.
MS. ALLRED: Thank you.
Your Honor, may it please the court. I would like to
read a statement for Jane Doe, my client, who is present in
court, but requested that I read it.
We only have one opportunity at childhood. One
opportunity to develop. One opportunity to find direction for
our lives. Jeffrey Epstein robbed and denied me at each
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
opportunity he had.
I came from a small Texas town, not far from the New
Mexico border. My mother died when I was 11, after suffering
from cancer for many years. My father was devastated, as were
my siblings and I. My father was saddled with debt. My only
hope for college was to get a scholarship.
When I was 15, I was a blossoming freshman in high
school and was trying to carry on my mother's dream. She
wanted me to master the violin. After school, I would often go
to a mall in a nearby city. A lady approached me and saw I had
a violin case with me and asked if I was any good. We talked
about the violin, my family, and why I had clothes that looked
like hand-me-downs.
The lady told me she works for a very rich man who had
a home close by and that he would pay to hear me play. I was
told that if I could get away, she could arrange for
transportation to and from his place and have me back before
anyone knew I was gone. After some hesitation, I agreed. This
decision was the beginning of the end of my childhood.
The man who only identified himself as J or Jeff had
asked if I would give him a massage, and over four visits,
eventually progressed to forced oral copulation. The money he
gave me further placed my young soul into a perverse sense of
hell.
I was so utterly disgusted with myself and what he did
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
to me that I stopped going to see him. I had documented the
events with a Texas rape crisis center about the man I know now
as Jeffrey Epstein.
Epstein targeted and took advantage of me, a young
girl, whose mother had recently died a horrific death and whose
family structure had deteriorated. His actions placed me, a
young girl, into a downward spiral to the point where I
purchased a gun and drove myself to an isolated place to end my
suffering.
A voice that could only have been from my mother told
me, quote, I am not the victim, I am the victor, and I dare not
pull the trigger." I returned the gun days later.
Epstein is a coward. He lived his life leaching off
the souls of inspiring, young girls due to the fact that he
could never know how it feels inspired to live. Like a leach,
once Epstein had his fill, he would unlatch and seek out
another victim.
The only sense of justice I had hoped to see was
Epstein being sentenced. However, Epstein died as he lived,
taking the easy way out without any responsibility.
Your Honor, the next statement is also a statement of
a Jane Doe. May it please the court.
I was a 16-year-old virgin when Jeffrey Epstein first
raped me. I was naive and gullable. He was a pillar of
finance and a giant in the world that I was an insignificant
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
part of. I was so impressed that this great man would even
talk to me and impart any of his wisdom on me. I gladly jumped
at the chance to meet him again, when he told me how impressed
he was with my personal story and maturity for my age.
When I was in his presence, he made an effort to call
celebrities and influential people on speakerphone, like
Academy Award-winning actresses and super models, who always
answered his calls. Sadly, I was impressed.
He was friends with former and future heads of states
and every other fixture in the New York social scene and
beyond. He knew important people in my own world that I looked
up to and revered, but he spoke about them like they were sweet
distractions far beneath his stature. He could easily reach
down from his position and influence the people directly
involved with my daily life and future prosperity. I was the
perfect victim.
My whole life was extremely turbulent. But one of my
mother's greatest wishes was that all her children would
graduate from respectable universities. He promised me that he
would write me a letter of recommendation for Harvard if I got
the grades and scores needed for admission. His word was worth
a lot, he assured me, as he was in the midst of funding and
leading Harvard's studies on the human brain, and the president
was his friend.
The fact that all of you already know these next
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
details, which I'll share, should ignite fire instead of induce
the complacency they did in the past, when heard repeatedly
over the years, but yes, an innocent massage turned sexual
almost immediately.
"Here, come. Come help me with a kink in my shoulder
while we finish our discussion." A large vibrator and a couple
of hundred dollars, disgust and dirty secret, more praise and
imparted wisdom from a godlike figure, a deliberate diabolical
depression of grooming and submission for his pleasure and
release. Even if I resisted, I was no match for him. I felt
powerless, ashamed, and embarrassed. I wanted to vomit
remembering these moments.
What I learned in those depraved sessions, staring up
at the dome ceiling in his private massage room, tore a violent
hole through any normal sexual awakening. I'm haunted forever,
having learned everything there is to know about sex through a
vile criminal. Every time a new molestation would bring a new
lesson, the progressive and constant unwinding. I was nothing
more than a teenage prostitute. I was his slave.
I had never even kissed a boy before I met him, and
never throughout the horrific abuse did Jeffrey Epstein kiss me
even once. When he stole my virginity, he washed my entire
body compulsively in the shower and then told me, "If you're
not a virgin, I will kill you." And then I wasn't a virgin
anymore.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
He forcefully penetrated me. I was numb. There was
pain, but his use of the vibrator and his fingers in previous
sessions with me had left a black hole-like void between my
legs. I protested, but he forced my face into the bed to
stifle my cries. That was my first time.
I got a few hundred dollars, as usual, as he led me
out of his mansion with assurances that I was on the right path
guided by him. I lied to myself and tried to believe him. 1
became a hollow shell. If I missed an appointment, he
threatened me
how important
won't say the
and let
my time
word --
me know who was in charge. "Do you know
is? I'll bury you. I owe this -- I
F'ing town." He would hang up.
I would stand there frozen in the street, terrified
that his assistant would call to reschedule. I made sure to
stay in line and not disobey him. I was in complete denial.
Being paid after every scheduled meeting felt routine and
disgusting. He was the master of the universe and the world
bent to his will.
He would eventually brag to his assistants about my
ability to please him sexually right in front of me, leaving me
feeling grotesque and worthless. Everything in my outside life
was falling apart. I distanced myself from friends and grew
further away from my family. I felt less human after each
ordeal. My psyche broke down completely and wouldn't let me
continue.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
One day I walked out of his residence and passed a
girl similar to myself. When I turned around, she was entering
Jeffrey's residence. He no longer even tried to schedule his
appointments with other girls in secrecy from me. Maybe he
never did. I was too stupid to see.
My world shattered. I had been so naive. I had an
epiphany in a calvary of desperation. I realized I was just
one of many young girls he had in rotation come to perform for
him for money. I went into a deep depression and never lifted
completely. I wanted to inflict pain on myself. I was
humiliated, angry, and suicidal. I locked myself away from
everything. I cut myself off forever from the world I had
known.
I endured the daily agony of knowing my life would
never be the same. I could never go back to New York City and
the wonderful life I had taken for granted before I met this
demon named Jeffrey Epstein.
This creature had manipulated and outwitted the whole
system, including some of the most intelligent scientists,
political people, prosecutors, and power players. How easy was
it to manipulate a 16-year-old virgin who never had a boyfriend
and came from a background of hardship with no parental
guidance or support.
I went to therapy and was given antidepressants for
severe anxiety and depression. My only solace, years later,
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JaRsEPS3
was my desire to succeed on my own terms. I emersed myself
into my studies and was accepted to every college I applied to,
graduating from a top university. To this day, there is still
an ache in my being that I did not apply to Harvard in fear of
his influence there.
They say you never forget your first. I'm in a
never-ending nightmare trying to do just that. I'm forever
suffering because everything reminds me of that horror. This
new wave of worldwide publicity only worsens my despair.
It was only many years later that I was finally
intimate with a man again, and those moments were marred by my
actions as a child with Jeffrey Epstein. Even now is
impossible to separate his treachery from any care of a good
man.
For one brief moment there was elation when he was
recently arrested. I would finally get my chance to see him
again face to face and show him what I had become, that I had
succeeded on my own, that I was worth something in spite of his
abuse, and that I had surmounted the monumental obstacles he
laid before me throughout my entire life since falling prey to
him.
I had hoped humanity would prevail, but it seems to me
that he outsmarted everyone so far, and his ghost is still
laughing at us. I appeal to all of those just and true that
his evil legacy and his death not stand in the way of
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
JaRsEPS3
resolution and justice for all of his underaged victims.
Thank you, your Honor.
And then just one last one, and this is much shorter.
Statement of Jane Doe, also my client.
I was a model in another country when I came to the
United States. I was told by a booker that I needed to meet
with a man named Jeffrey Epstein, who was the owner of
Victoria's Secret. The booker told me that Mr. Epstein could
help me get into Victoria Secret's world.
It was my childhood dream to be a Victoria's Secret
model. So I went one day in the afternoon and I met
Mr. Epstein in his office in his mansion in New York. A woman
introduced herself and suggested to me that I should be
extremely nice to Mr. Epstein, because if he liked me, he would
probably have photographers shooting photos of me right away.
The told me to go upstairs and directed me to Jeffrey
Epstein's office. Mr. Epstein had a white robe on and we
chatted very briefly. I had my portfolio of photos, but he
didn't even look at it. Suddenly, he took his robe off and got
close to me. I got up to leave, but the door was locked.
I didn't know what was going on. It was my first
official meeting to be cast in the United States. I was a
young girl and confused. He got very close to me, and I had a
skirt on. He started to touch my genitals. I refused him.
Then he went to the massage table and showed me the vibrator.
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
I took it and threw it at him.
At that point, I ran to the door again and figured out
how to get out of there. A girl outside asked me where I was
going and she said to be careful. She said that Mr. Epstein
knew a lot of powerful people, including Bill Clinton, and that
if I didn't do what Mr. Epstein wanted, I would not be able to
have any job in the industry.
I was so scared. I couldn't wait to get out of there,
and I left. I took the train home. I had spent all of my
savings getting Victoria's Secret lingerie to prepare for what
I thought would be my audition. But instead, it seemed like a
casting call for prostitution. I felt like I was in hell.
Thank you, your Honor.
Thank you.
THE COURT: Thank you, Ms. Allred.
Was there anybody else, any victim's counsel or any of
the other victims who have not been heard and wish to be heard?
Well, OK then. All I have to say, really, is thank
you, all of you, for your participation in today's remarkable
hearing. I think everybody has benefited greatly from your
input, and especially from the testimony of victims here today
and who have had the courage to come forward.
We have also benefited throughout these proceedings,
however brief altogether, from the attorneys' legal advocacy
and their written and oral submissions. I'm grateful to them
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
J8RsEPS3
as well, both for the government and the defense and those
representing the victims.
Finally, we're also grateful to the press for their
very diligent coverage of seemingly every detail of this case.
That concludes our work for today and we stand
adjourned.
Thanks.
(Adjourned)
SOUTHERN DISTRICT REPORTERS, P.C.
EFTA00165652 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank showing Caroline Lang co-ownership with Epstein (?)
(inferred date: 2026-01-03)
Deutsche Bank
Wealth Management
Business Deposit Account Opr.4n •-:
Prytanep. I.L.C.
Account Tina
ETYtaneXt.i-L.0
Try:et/Company Name
1100 RED ROOKCIUARTER. 63
Mailing AddrenA
WPM'S 2️⃣lone rwrnau:
LeaMAettme 61 diliforori from mediae xletene
07122/2016
Dm- le.vi1i,, Agr.
away...MO MN/
St Thomas, USVI
Ry..11,q
stoic.
Other etwrotw
Stat.)
00602
Lp
bit
Client Relationship
1.7: Corporation ✓ Limited Liability Company BIC, Attorney Escrow Account
Foundation Partnership Landlord Master Escrow
al Non-Profit Organization Limited Liability Partnership ILLPI Trust Estates
Private Wealth PremiumTM
DBTCA Accounts Deutsche Bank AG NY Branch Accounts
V: Checking Account Deutsche Bank AG NY Preferred Banking Account
Checking with Interest Deutsche Bank AG NY Preferred Certificate of Deposit
n Money Market Deposit
AM' I. • in Permo torn
DBTCA Certificate of Deposit woe, oceiunt Ale,' wan a rt e AG Aelettee Teton
and %too Algona.
An Tenn
Cash Master Sweep Account
744* .:ArnOtrig Trn)gee Amnon:
Banking Services
Deluxe Checkbook
Name Only Name and Address
Sere Oise Cow
Internet Banking Services
DB Private Wealth Online Plus
: Link to existing online relationship:
Debit Cards— Business Debit Card
Duplicate Statement
Nan , .
C.11 Sloe ZinCee)
VVI11167245 015024_090816
etge 1 of 3
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0001394
Notice of Customer Identification Policy
Important Information
To help the government fight the funding of terrorism and money Laundering activities. Federal law requires all 
financial
institutions to obtain, verify and record information that identifies each {lemon who establishes an account, investment
or other business relationship with a financial institution. This means that we will ask lot vote name. address and 
other
information that will allow us to identify yOu. We may also ask to see identifying documents such as a certificate of
formation or good standing (legel entities) or a passport or other photo identification rinclividualsa
Information Sharing
You authorize Deutsche Bank to share information about you and your Account as sot forth in our Privacy Policy, 
including
any disclosures that (1) Deutsche Bank believes are required by applicable law and regulations that apply to Deutsche 
Bank
or others, including disclosure of information about you and your Account to any government agency or sell-regulatory
body on request. (2) is necessary or appropriate in connection with Deutsche. Bank's provision of services under this
Agreement, or (3) is requested by a financial institution. financial nee/mediae" 01 other third party in order to assist
such
person with compliance with law applicable to such person in connection with services provided to you or on your behalf.
3rd EU Notice
Governmental rules have also broadened the scope of the Bank's obligations to aid in the fight against money laundering
and terrorist financing: these rules call for an active involvement of both 45501 management ferns and their clients. 
For
new and existing clients we currently have a legal obligation to ask our customers questions regarding their identities,
addresses. source of funds and, if necessary. legal representatives. authorized signatories, beneficial owners or 
control
structures and to collect requisite documentation to substantiate the information. Also. enhanced anti-money laundering
requirements require that should any of the above personal or institutional information change. our clients would be 
obliged
to immediately notify us of the changelS) and provide us with relevant documentation to verify these changes.
ATNVDebit Service
You agree that the retention or use of the ATM./Debit card constitutes acceptance of the terms and conditions of the
Cardholder Agreement contained in the Terms and Conditions of Deposit Accounts.
Internet Banking Service
If you have selected to receive Internet Banking Services, you urelerstand that you will be required to enter into a 
separate
Internet Banking Services Agreement with DBTCA before you can access the Internet Banking Service.
Acknowledgement of Receipt of Privacy Notice
By signing below, you acknowledge receipt of DBTCA's Riven' NONA incirldthlm the Application Package.
Non-U.S. Organizations:
Confirmation of Tax and Compliance Responsibilities
You confirm that it is your responsibility to fulfill any tax obligations and any other regulatory reporting duties 
applicable to
it in any relevant jurisdictions that may arise in connection with assets. income or transactions in your aocountls) and
your
business relationship with DBTCA. Furt ermore. you confirm that the necessary information Ito the best of your knowledge
and capabilities) is made available no less than annually to the relevant beneficial uwricits). settloas). 
beneficiaryliesa
panner(st, etc.. to enable himfherAhem to fulfill any respective tax obliciations mat may arise for him/nal/thorn in 
connection
with your business relationship with DBTCA.
Please complete and attach separate We or W-9 documentation as applicable.
Terms and Conditions and Representations
By signing below, you acknowledge receipt of the Terms and Conditions Inn Deposit Accounts attached to this Application
and agree to be bound by them. In addition, you agree to notify us immediately of any material change to the information
provided by you on this Application.
You represent and warrant that all of the information provided by you on this Application is accurate.
The Terms and Conditions for Deposit Accounts are subject to change.
Wiiii57246 015624.090516 eye 7 013
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0001395
Acceptance
You understand that this application is subject to acceptance by DBTCA.
0-01AILAA. Authorized Signer
Darren WSW..
Print Nan*
oaa
For Bank Use Only
Reviewed by:
----
Signature
Tale
aa- 1/4 4.(zaccizrz_
AuP
/[ stir
Accepted by DBTCA:...„..)
Olasc dck
1-3t r ec-frter
Coale
Account numbers: numbers:
OM
MMOA
Autatorima Swan,
Pant Vane
NOW
cc ceac
WhIlf720 01561+.090816
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0001396
EFTA01656415 (Jmail)
 [government] FinCEN Suspicious Activity Report filed by Charles Schwab about Richard Kahn for $45 million transaction
(inferred date: 2026-01-03)
FinCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network
UnIttci Sacs ()optimal( tithe Treasury
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Filing Information
Type of Report Continuing Activity Report
Filing Date 10/11/2019
Received Date 10/11/2019
Entry Date 10/15/2019
Amended Prior BSA ID: 31000150416250
Submission Method Electronic discrete filing
Subject Information
Suaj•ctl •
Role Subject
Subject Type Purchaser/Sender
Individual/Organization Individual
Last(or Entity) Name EPSTEIN
First Name JEFFREY
Gender Type Male
Date of Birth ././.1
SSN/ITIN
Form(s) of Identification Identification Type Passport
Identification Number
Issuing Country Code US
Address(es) Address Type Subject permanent/mailing address
Street Address 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3 - Enhanced
City ST THOMAS
ST THOMAS - Enhanced
State VI
VI - Enhanced
ZIP Code 008021348
00802-1348 - Enhanced
Country VI
US - Enhanced
Phone Number(s) Type Work
Number
Email(s)
Occupation/Type of Business Executive/Southern Trust Co.
Corroborative Statement to
Filer
No
Page 1 The enclosed nformatico was corrected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and 
U.S. Deportment of the Treasury regdations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The reformation a sensitive ti nature and is to be treats accadingly. The information 
may be used only for a purpose consistent
with acr.-mat tax. or regulatory
nvestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of intelligence or counterntelligence activities. indueng analysis. to 
protect against nternational terrorism. See
31 U S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of Frnancial Craws 
Enforcement Network or he authorized
delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of pass.ble criminal 
activity. akin to ccofidential informant
tips. Unauthorized release of information
collected wider the BSA may result in aiminal or civil :wens:.
8605ZL5510001£:bSB
FinCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network
United Sums Departmait elute Ttaouty
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Subject Information
Relationship to Financial
Institution(s)
Institution TIN 941737782
Relationship of Subject Customer. Yes
Affected Account(s) Account 1 of 2
Account Number 41224708
Closed Yes
Financial Institution TIN 941737782
Account 2 of 2
Account Number 14332170
Closed Yes
Financial Institution TIN 941737782
Subject 2 of 4 : KAHN
Role Subject
Subject Type Purchaser/Sender
Individual/Organization Individual
Last(or Entity) Name KAHN
First Name RICHARD
Gender Type Male
Date of Birth
SSN/ITIN
Form(s) of Identification Identification Type Passport
Identification Number
Issuing Country Code US
Address(es) Address 1 of 3
Address Type Subject permanent/mailing address
Street Address
City
State
ZIP Code
Country I
US - Enhanced
Address 2 of 3
Address Type Subject permanent/mailing address
Street Addres
Page 2 The enclosed nformatico was ca ected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S.
Department of the Treasury regaations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.

5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The nformation a sensitive ti nature and is to be treats accadingly. The information 
may be used only fa a purpose consistent
with acrtnoal, tax. or regulatory
nvestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of intelligence or counterntelligence activities. incluttn analysis. to 
protect against nternational terrorism.
See 31 U S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of Frnancial Craws 
Enforcement Netwakor he authorized delegate.
Suspicious activity reports filed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of passtle criminal 
activity. akin to ccofidential informant
tips. Unauthorized release of information
collected wider the BSA may result in criminal or civil :webs:.
86093L99WOOIC.VSO
FinCEN Financial Crimes Enforcement Network
United States Dcpanntent dike Treasury
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Subject Information
City
State
ZIP Code
Country US
US - Enhanced
Address 3 of 3
Address Type Subject permanent/mailing address
Street Address
City
State
ZIP Code
Country US
US - Enhanced
Phone Number(s) Phone Number 1 of 2
Type Work
Number
Phone Number 2 of 2
Type Mobile
Number
Email(s)
Occupation/Type of Business Executive/HBRK ASSOCIATES INC
Corroborative Statement to
Filer
No
Relationship to Financial
Institution(s)
Institution TIN 941737782
Relationship of Subject Customer. Yes
Affected Account(s) Account 1 of 2
Account Number
Closed Yes
Financial Institution TIN 941737782
Page 3 The enclosed mformation was caected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and U.S. 
Department of the Treasury regaations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U S C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The mformation is sensitive m nature and is to be treats accadingty. The information 
may be used only fa a purpose con ustent
with a crammat. tax. or regulatory
myestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of mtelligence or countermtelligence activities. incluttlg analysis, to 
protect against mtemational terrorism. See
31 U S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of Financial Crnes 
Enforcement Netwakon his authorized
delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of passtle criminal 
activity. akin to ccofidential informant
tips. Unauthorized release of information
collected wider the BSA may result in criminal or civil :miens:.
8609ZL9510001C.VSO
FinCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network United Soto Doparmait t4 the pussy
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Subject Information
Account 2 of 2
Account Number 14332170
Closed Yes
Financial Institution TIN 941737782
Role Subject
Subject Type Purchaser/Sender
Individual/Organization Organization
Last(or Entity) Name SOUTHERN COUNTRY INTERNATIONAL INC.
EIN 660821138
Form(s) of Identification Identification Type Other
Other Text CORPORATION FORMATION DOCUMENTS
Issuing State Code VI
Issuing State Virgin Islands, U.S.
Issuing Country Code VI
Address(es) Address Type Subject permanent/mailing address
Street Address 6100 RED HOOK QTRS STE 8-3
6100 RED HOOK QTRS STE 8-3 - Enhanced
City ST THOMAS
ST THOMAS - Enhanced
State VI
VI - Enhanced
ZIP Code 008021348
00802-1348 - Enhanced
Country VI
US - Enhanced
NAICS Code 5239
NAICS Code Text Other Financial Investment Activities
Phone Number(s) Type Work
Number (340) 775-2525
Relationship to Financial
Institution(s)
Institution TIN 941737782
Relationship of Subject Customer. Yes
Affected Account(s) Account Number 14332170
Closed Yes
Financial Institution TIN 941737782
Role Subject
Page 4 The enclosed mformaticn was ca ected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (Me SSA) and U.S. 
Department of the Treasury regttations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U S C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The mformation a sensitive n nature and is to be treats accadingty. The information may
be used only fa a purpose consistent
with acrmoa tax. or regulatory
nvestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of intelligence or counterntelligence activities. incluctIg analysis. to 
protect against ntemational terrorism.
See 31 U S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of Fnancial Craws 
Enforcement Network or his authorized
delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under
the GSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of pass.ble criminal 
activity. akin to ccofidential informant
tips. Unauthorized release of information
collected wider the GSA may result in criminsi or civil :webs:.
86053L99LCHNIC VS8
FinCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network
Usual Sores Degrattmast of the Treasury
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Subject Information
Subject Type Purchaser/Sender
Individual/Organization Organization
Last(or Entity) Name SOUTHERN TRUST COMPANY INC.
EIN 660779861
Form(s) of Identification Identification Type Other
Identification Number 1217721L
Other Text Secretary of State
Issuing State Code VI
Issuing State Virgin Islands, U.S.
Issuing Country Code VI
Address(es) Address Type Subject permanent/mailing address
Street Address 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER B3 - Enhanced
City ST THOMAS
ST THOMAS - Enhanced
State VI
VI - Enhanced
ZIP Code 008021348
00802-1348 - Enhanced
County VI
US - Enhanced
NAICS Code 5221
NAICS Code Text Depository Credit Intermediation
Phone Number(s) Type Work
Number (340) 775-2525
Relationship to Financial
Institution(s)
Institution TIN 941737782
Relationship of Subject Customer. Yes
Affected Account(s) Account Number 41224708
Closed Yes
Financial Institution TIN 941737782
Suspicious Activity Information
Amount Involved $45,360,202
Cumulative Amount $73,018,526
Date or Date Range of Activity 07/15/2019 - 09/03/2019
Money laundering Suspicious EFT/wire transfers
Financial instrument or
payment mechanism
Funds transfer
Page 5 The enclosed nformation was colected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and U.S.
Department of the Treasury regulations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chwter X. The nformation is sensitive n nature and is to be treated accoddingty. The information 
may be used only for a purpose consistent
with a etyma& tax. or regulatory
evestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of ntelligence or counterntelligence activities. inclueng analysis. to 
protect against nternational terrorism. See
31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. dixlosed. or transmitted without pith approval of the Director of Estancia Crates 
Enforcement Network or his authorized
delegate_ Suspicious activity reports fled under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of pa:cable criminal 
activity. akin to cooklenbal informant
tips_ Unauthorized release of information
collected ruder the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
86093L99LOOOIC VSO
FinCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network
United Sums Department of Mc rtirbuty
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Activity Location
No Branch Activity Involved Yes
Type of Financial Institution Securities/Futures Subsidiary of financial/bank holding company
Clearing broker-securities
Primary Regulator SEC
RSSD Number 1026641
Legal Name Charles Schwab & Co., Inc
EIN 941737782
Address Address Type Address where transaction occurred
Street Address 211 Main St
211 MAIN ST - Enhanced
City San Francisco
SAN FRANCISCO - Enhanced
State CA
CA - Enhanced
ZIP Code 94105
94105-1905 - Enhanced
Country US
US - Enhanced
Internal Control File Number CA154479
Filer Information
Primary Regulator Federal Reserve
Filer Name The Charles Schwab Corporation
EIN 943025021
Address Address Type Reporting party address
Street Address 211 Main St
211 MAIN ST - Enhanced
City San Francisco
SAN FRANCISCO - Enhanced
State CA
CA - Enhanced
ZIP Code 94105
94105-1905 - Enhanced
Country US
US - Enhanced
Type of Financial Institution Other. Savings and Loan
Holding Company
Page 6 The enclosed mformatico was caected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (Me SSA) and U.S. 
Department of the Treasury regdations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U S C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The mformation a sensitive m nature and is to be treated accadingly. The information 
may be used only for a purpose consistent
with germinal, tax. or regulatory
investigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of mtelligence or countermtelligence activities. inclueng analysis. to 
protect against mtemational terrorism. See
31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of Palencia Crates 
Enforcement Network or he authorized
delegate. Suspicious activity reports ftled under
the GSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of passtle criminal 
activity. akin to confidential informant
tips. Unauthorized release of information
collected wider the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
8605ZLSSLOONC VSO
• CEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network n UnItai Scams Department tithe Ticaouty
Ci2
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Filer Information
RSSD Number 1026632
Internal control/file number CA154479
Contact for Assistance Full Name AMLI - AML Investigations
Phone Number
Phone Type Work
Law Enforcement Information
Law Enforcement Agencies
Contacted
Agency Name DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE (DOJ) SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW
YORK
Law Enforcement Contact(s) Full Name ALEX ROSSMILLER
Phone Number
Phone Type Work
Contact Date 07/14/2019
Narrative
This Continuing Activity SAR is being filed by The Charles Schwab Corporation on behalf of Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. 
("Schwab"),
a registered broker dealer, as a result of continued concerning activity initially reported on 07/13/2019 (DCN 
31000150416250).
The initial SAR was filed due to concerns with attempted wires for the purpose of real estate, in light of negative 
media
surrounding Jeffrey Epstein. There appears to be continuing outgoing activity of concern in the amount of 
S45,360,202.00, given
the continued negative media surrounding Jeffrey Epstein and his estate.
Please refer to internal number CA154479 when requesting more information regarding this report.
The four subjects of this continuation SAR are:

1. Southern Trust Company LLC who established a relationship with Schwab in April 2019 consisting of a corporate 
brokerage
account, 4122-4708. The company is registered in the United States (U.S.) Virgin Islands, license number 1-21-772-1L, as
a
business and management consulting firm, and was established in December 2018.

2. Southern Country International, LTD who established a relationship with Schwab in April 2019 consisting of a 
corporate
brokerage account, 1433-2170. Per account documentation the company is established in the US Virgin Islands, formally
Page 7 The enclosed reformation was connected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and 
U.S. Department of the Treasury regdations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.

5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chwter X. The eformation is sensitive it nature and is to be treated accordingly. The information 
may be used only for a purpose
consistent with a crineal. tax. or regulatory
evestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of etelligence or counteretelligence activities. inclueng analysis, to 
protect against etemational terrorism. See
31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of Feancial Cranes 
Enforcement Network or his authorized
delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of passable criminal 
activity. akin to ccnklenbal informant
tips_ Unauthorized release of information
collected trader the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
8609ZL99100016:VS9
in CEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network Unita' Saws Deparoncric of the Tanury
\ C.0
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Narrative
registered as the Financial Strategy Group Ltd and is in the financial services industry.

3. Jeffrey Epstein (66 years old) established a relationship with Schwab in April 2019 and acts as an internal control 
person and
beneficial owner on three accounts; the role does not grant him authority to act upon the Schwab accounts. Jeffrey 
Epstein is
deceased as of 08/10/2019, but is included as a subject of this SAR due to the negative media involving Federal charges.
His
disclosed employer is an Executive at Southern Trust Company Inc.
4. Richard Kahn (46 years old) established a relationship with Schwab in April 2019 consisting of three active corporate
accounts.
His disclosed employment is a Senior Executive at HBRK Associates Inc. Richard Kahn appears to be a close business 
partner in
various ventures with Jeffrey Epstein, including Southern Trust Company.
The outgoing activity of concern during this continuation investigative occurred in two of the Schwab accounts. The 
Schwab
corporate brokerage account 41224708 registered to Southern Trust Company, Inc., and the Schwab corporate brokerage 
account
14332170 registered to Southern Country International, LTD. Richard Kahn is the authorized agent on both of the 
accounts,
providing him the authority to act upon the accounts, and Jeffrey Epstein is listed as an internal control person and 
100 percent
beneficial owner; Jeffrey Epstein does not have any authority to act upon the accounts.
Schwab made a business decision to terminate the relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, Richard Kahn, and the entities 
associated
with the corporate accounts. As of the filing of this SAR, the three accounts have been closed and Schwab has ceased the
relationship with Jeffrey Epstein, Richard Kahn, Southern Trust Company LLC, Southern Country International, LTD, and 
Southern
Financial LLC.
Schwab's continuation investigation encompassed the time period ranging from 07/11/2019 to 09/18/2019. The activity in
question occurred between 07/15/2019 and 09/03/2019, referenced in Part II, line 30 of this SAR. The dollar amount
$45360,202.00, referenced in Part II, line 29 of this SAR, represents the total amount of outgoing activity of concern 
which were
identified during the continuation investigation review. The cumulative filing amount $73,018,525.94, referenced in Part
II, line 31
Page 8 The enclosed eformation was colected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and U.S.
Department of the Treasury regulations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.
5311, et seg.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The eformation is sensitive it nature and is to be treated accordingly. The information
may be used only for a purpose
consistent with a crams{ tax. or regulatory
evestigation or proceeding. Of in the conduct of etelligence a counteretelligence activitiesoncludeg analysts, to 
protect against eternabonal terrorism. See 31
U.S.C. 5311. The information carnal be
further released. disseminated. dixlosed. or transmitted without per approval of the Director of Feancial Crates 
Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate-
Suspicious activity reports fled under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of pa:cable criminal 
activity. akin to co:tridental informant
tips- Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
8609ZL991000IX:VSEI
F nCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network Unita' Sows peps IIIICIC a the Tanury
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Narrative
of this SAR is the total amount of activity of concern reported in the initial SAR filed on 07/13/2019 and this SAR 
filing.
Jeffrey Epstein was arrested and federally charged on 07/08/2019 with one count of sex trafficking of minors, and one 
count of
conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking of minors, alleging the activity took place between2002 and 2005, possibly with 
an
exchange of funds for acts. Jeffrey Epstein was held in Federal custody as prosecutors considered Jeffrey Epstein a very
high
flight risk given his enormous wealth, international ties, and private planes. On 08/10/2019, Jeffrey Epstein was found 
deceased
while in jail by an apparent suicide. Per internet research two days prior to Jeffrey Epstein's death, he executed his 
last will and
testimony where it appears his assets were moved into a trust that has been filed in the US Virgin Islands. The 
executors of Mr.
Epstein's will are Richard Kahn and Darren Indyke.
The initial SAR filed by Schwab on 07/13/2019 (DCN 31000150416250) reported concerns with international wires attempted 
to
be remitted from the Schwab account registered to the Southern Financial LLC to an individual in Morocco for real estate
purposes. In light of the negative media surrounding Jeffrey Epstein, which included a bail hearing, Schwab filed to 
report the
attempted money movement for an individual considered a flight risk. The outgoing wires were attempted to be remitted to
Marc
Leon, a partner at Kensington Morocco, which appears to offer luxury properties in Morocco and France
(www.kensingtonmorocco.com). The attempted international wires which were identified in the initial investigation review
were
ultimately canceled or reversed at the request of the account agent, Richard Kahn.
During this continuation investigation, additional outgoing funds remitted from the accounts up until account closure 
raised
concerns given the continued media coverage on Jeffrey Epstein. It should be noted the outgoing funds were primarily 
remitted
between 07/15/2019 and 08/02/2019, while Jeffrey Epstein was alive in Federal custody and before his will was executed 
and
filed in the US Virgin Islands.
Between 07/15/2019 and 08/.2019, the two corporate accounts sent 16 individuals wires for an aggregated amount of
$45,354,912.12. The wires were sent to individuals and companies that appear connected and/or associated with Jeffrey 
Epstein
as follows:
Page 9 The enclosed nformatico was colected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and U.S.
Department of the Treasury regulations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.
5311. et seq.: 31 CFA Chyle; X. The nformation is sensitive n nature and is to be heated accadingly. The information may
be used only Ice a purpose conustent
with acanna& tax, or regulatory
nvestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of ntelligence or counterntelligence activities. induct -5g analysis, to 
protect against ntemational terrorism.
See 31 U.S.C. 5311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without pia approval of the Director of Financial Crates 
Enforcement Network or his authorized
delegate_ Suspicious activity reports filed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of passable criminal 
activity. akin to ccnklenhal informant
tips- Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
8609ZLS91000IX:VSEI
FinCEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network United SOICS Dept (mai r u u.< Lmusy
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Narrative
Eleven of the 16 wires were remitted to accounts held at TD Bank that appear to be registered to: HBRK Associates Inc. 
NES;
HBRK Associates Inc. Neptune; HBRK Associates Inc. LSJ; HBRK Associates Inc. Plan D; HBRK Associates Inc. Hyperion; HBRK
Associates Inc. Zorro; and HBRK Associates Inc. JEGE, for various amounts for an aggregated amount of S14,660,567.89.
HBRK Associates Inc. is actively registered in the State of New York with Richard Kahn as the registered agent. A 
Bloomberg
article indicated HBRK Associates Inc. allegedly helped arrange travel for Epstein's accusers between New York and 
Florida.
The identifiers or acronyms that were listed after the beneficiary name of HBRK Associates Inc., were also listed in the
wire
memos for example -HBRK Associates Inc. NES" with the memo "NES LLC - BILL PAY " or "HBRK Associates Inc. ZORRO" with 
the
memo stating -ZORRO - BILL PAY." Research of the identifiers listed appear to reference to a businesses or possible 
assets
associated to Mr. Epstein as follows:
LSJ appears to be an acronym to reference Little St. James (LSJ), the smaller private island owned by Mr. Epstein and 
according
to lawsuits is where Epstein ran a "complex commercial sex trafficking and abuse ring." NES appears to be associated to 
the
company that owned Epstein's New York Mansion located at Nine East 71st Street (NES), and ZORRO appears to be Epstein's
ranch located in New Mexico.
The identifiers JEGE, PLAN D, and HYPERION appear to be shell companies which held or still are the owners of Epstein's
Gulfstream aircrafts. NEPTUNE appears to be a business associated to Epstein's address in which allegedly donated money 
to a
democratic campaign in 2014.
In addition, one wire was remitted to LSJE LLC to an account at FirstBank Puerto Rico listing Epstein's address as the 
beneficiary
address listing "FUNDING OPERATING ACCOUNT" as the memo for S2,536,513.89.Per open source media, LSJE LLC appears to
control Little St. James Island, pay employees of the island, linked to various imports as the consignee of various 
items shipped
to and from the islands.
Page 10 The enclosed eformaticn was colected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and 
U.S. Department of the Treasury regulations
implementing the BSA. See 31 U.S.C.
5311, et seg.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The eformation is sensitive al nature and is to be treated accccdingty. The information
may be used only la a purpose con
ustent with a crime* tax. or regulatory
evestigation or proceeding. or in the conduct of etelligence or counteretelligence activities. inclueng analysis, to 
protect against eternational terrorism. See
31 US.C. 6311. The information cannot be
further released. disseminated. disclosed. or transmitted without vim approval of the Director of Feancial Cranes 
Enforcement Netwarkor his authorized delegate
Suspicious activity reports fled under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of par.c.ible criminal 
activity. akin to calla:lento' informant
tips- Unauthorized release of information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
8609ZL591000IX:VS9
Fit -IGEN I Financial Crimes Enforcement Network United bows Deparimoit ti the Ticbuty
BSAR Transcript
BSA: 31000155725098 and DCN:
Narrative
While the following four wires were remitted to beneficiaries appearing to be lawyers, given the negative media 
surrounding
Jeffrey Epstein, research is unable to definitely identify if they are of concern:
Two wires were remitted to DARREN K INDYKE PLCC IOLA TRUST ACCOUNT for a total amount of $12,657,830.34. One of the
wires listed "escrow for legal fees." Per open source media, Darren Indyke is a lawyer based in New York, as well as the
co-
executor of Mr. Epstein's estate. Per an article posted by the Wall Street Journal, Darren Indyke established companies,
handled
matters involving charitable giving, and represented in real estate dealings for Mr. Epstein.
MARTIN G. WEINBERG, PC received one wire for $3,500,000.00. Per research is a lawyer in Boston offering attorney 
services for
white collar crime and appeared to be representing Jeffrey Epstein.
STEPTOE JOHNSON LLP, appearing to be an international law firm offering criminal services received one wire for 
$12,000,00.00.
As a result of account closure, Schwab issued two checks on 08/02/2019 and 09/03/2019 to Southern Trust Company Inc. 
(6100
RED HOOK QUARTER B3 ST THOMAS US Virgin Islands) for a total of $5,289.82, the remaining funds in the account.
Please see the attached CSV for detailed information regarding the outgoing funds of concern as noted above.
Schwab determined to file this SAR reporting continued concerns with outgoing funds identified between the initial SAR 
filing and
the Schwab initiated closure of the accounts, given the continued negative media surrounding Jeffrey Epstein and his 
estate.
Schwab maintains all supporting documentation. Written requests for supporting documentation may be sent to
. Please refer to internal number CA154479 when requesting more information regarding this report.
Page 11 The enclosed eformation was colected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank Secrecy Act (the SSA) and 
U.S. Department of the Treasury regulations
implementing the BSA. See 31 USG.

5311. et seq.: 31 CFR Chapter X. The eformation is sensitive a nature and is to be treated accordingly. The information 
may be used only la a purpose con ustent
with a crime* tax. or regulatory
evestigation 04 proceeding. Of in the conduct of etelligence Of counteretelligence activitiesoncludeg analysis. to 
protect against eternahonal terrorism. See 31
LIS.C. 5311. The information cams be
further released. disseminated. disclo--ed. or transmitted without vim approval of the Director of Feancial Crates 
Enforcement Network or his authorized
delegate_ Suspicious activity reports filed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of passable criminal 
activity. akin to cceklenbal informant
tips. Unauthorized release ol information
collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
8609ZL991000IX:Val
EFTA00008529 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Jeffrey Epstein
EFTA00002388 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
:f•••• • 4.1:
r.
'444
•te"rib'
-t,
€V‘• -•-•c" ••-•• •
"r5
tg • ti t
cin;-•
iv a

• •
• • • • /ow
•
• 0..5:,:.44.4",1 4,,j;--- 1-4-st 4');;;;Irsi
szitt; •Ased7 1.
4 1;
c? .: .'t:Af:rj ercc 73..^ yes.", P-
47:1;•':4 4. • N.10... 1, 'Mt .% -Frrx•- #4
A1S; " "." 44  ‘r.  ravp,4::# • - - 3-‘•
%.;-'1,,•?• • 4.4 ) -4fr arter- \si :N4' 13.-t.ac•-• • •
•"- <FA; ✓  zr4
‘•If?,......;;;
-2sv,,r-eng, • . .-44-;;;:r -"ag— •4 • - Rd- • .4.*"  iNtaz zi.:S.1 42Y"'"-. .44 • W • - _ ' • • -Ls& • yr
• - k:1
<- -
EFTA00002467 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
0
TOSHIBA
Se ft' 1 a t• 1.035-S3P41 SYMP.! UNIT
PART NO. PSKEI0U-02002X <ESs.e>
DC 19V = 3 42A
FCEEOCEO.  pOI .)20 423
ins
L •-1_ NMNBLOBPgIBETO".
'II! IIII
noun OWNOWO
&CAUTION
*C SAW CM BECOME m01.
4.00 PROLONGED OC•CrACT
100RIEVEN1KA140Virt 10 Sal
} AN ATTENTION
I TR GAZE al PC KV" SECRAUFFER
IENATIR LE CONTACT PAOLONGE
AVIC LA PEN. POVR PREVENR
Its Rr.aues OC BRVWRES

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ mun               │
│ WOH               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00003158 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
• j•
IDA1/2741Ra 510all) OF --
GLVERAL INFOR.II4710\
DATE SI. i 11-i TA t el
CASE ID -SIC-NM - "Set -A_5 -1.%
LOCATION
PREPARER/PHOTOGRAPHER
REMARKS
SA s 1 ..... "/"- •'• • •-, Jo li .. 7....n.1,- c \ • Alih r‘o
PHOTO 0 DESCRIPTION OF PHOTOGRAPHIC SUBJECT/ MISCELLANEOUS COMMENTS
111 '5' C.- p.a."- 4.3 La-ct -•
is  • 2ST 4....A- r o CC•co_ ....- 0-s

15. LSI-
1
004.N of- vt- 1/4
LS‘L 1-SS ()its \Ls
lira 4A t c...10.5thn.
1.6 7.-1‘5" c • ....wj acm- ti, -• , I ..,,...lairs
Lb} o4 Zcs
t‘s-1.:14, 11 oFC+ 'ars.
1-1- I- LYP• Y.,  c,nk. sLoi c..c.....
L'il- . .10.-O1.-• Ma-km a tt•4.*_ cr 0 .
tvt/L) 'X le-N.. • 4 . rg.
Leto - LS -Z. ..a ,i,,,.,_ 1-`s -7..t., q,.,,,v act., €.64‘.
'Levs. co -", 17,4 -Vite— i.. S ti C.0 tit"
t c% C. %striaI ti.
L 4 }-lA- 3 00 s 4-St .-•<.,,,, .4 •
3of -I•oz-
.
4-K-t- saatil ocA, t.t •
So 3 -3 %IN a.e....v..........k% °CC. 4.4,
10 S- 3,4 e.._*.; ....I, a c'P.,:k,
St)? 94.,s-c_iss •
4

╭────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────╮
│ GENERAL INFORMATION          │
│                              │
│ CASE 22                      │
│ LOCATION LAt\s SA. e meat Ae │
│ PREPARER/PHOTOGRAPHER        │
│ REMARKS                      │
│                              │
│ PHOTO #                      │
╰──────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00004012 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
PHOTO
FAST"
TEL. (590 ) 27.87.08
Gustavia
97133 SAINT-BARTHELEMY F.W.1
r
§tv.4■ ■
Sujet :
Date :
••••
•
_
--asterme^-•
.
. 0.1 •
a.

• 1 %Jo •
I Nk •
at,
-• Ns: .1Ir %I. 1
...
..- " 1••••• •‘ • •••
ell1/4„ •-• — *e-
Z • a' -
V • ki• ' • v.w •
w pro 4
EFTA00004477 (Jmail)
 [misc] Epstein 50th birthday photo book 12 "THAIS, MOSCOW GIRLS, AFRICA, HAWAII, [REDACTED] [REDACTED], Zorro, [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED], 
CRACK WHOLE PROPOSAL, BALI/THAILAND/ASIA, RUSSIA, [REDACTED], [REDACTED], NUDES, YOGAL GIRLS
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
Epstein 50th birthday photo book 12 "THAIS, MOSCOW GIRLS, AFRICA, HAWAII, [REDACTED] [REDACTED], Zorro, [REDACTED] 
[REDACTED] [REDACTED], CRACK WHOLE PROPOSAL, BALI/THAILAND/ASIA, RUSSIA, [REDACTED], [REDACTED], NUDES, YOGAL GIRLS
EFTA00005832 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
Dot
SA N uNicifiNvv -ft tAiw
Savzot, Vntrtik - VezeLio OSAv1/4) (2- pis 2-0 yrs-/rob - 2,1->o
ca ^ u -2t ,
.4t 2-0O5.

╭─────── Page 2, Image 1 ───────╮
│ HBA                           │
│                               │
│ ee                            │
│ =                             │
│                               │
│ NEW Poste — Unlewny te lev    │
│ Hid Sclorol, Breil. — peck bu │
│                               │
│ Sanda uy                      │
│ Dade ra NYC 20s               │
╰───────────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 6, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

eJusticeNY Integrated Justice Portal Page 1 of 1
eJusticeNY. INTEGRATED JUSTICE PORTAL
People • Pmv Photo System • pnw Photo ReatieSt+ Feedback
IDMV Photo Request
DMV Photo
Subject Information
Name:
lent1D:
ase Number:
MV Transaction Number:
MV Transaction Date/Time:
31ENY3027175
1168491
2019-06-06 13:44:13:513
About Site Mae Site Policies lune 6, )019 1 -40 PM FUT
https://www.ejustice.ny.gov/wps/myportalnut/p/al/jY_LcoJAEEW JQu3OwlEHJdYiQTLi... 6/6/2019
EFTA00005959 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

NJP Response Page 1 of 2
Uneuthortest scam, reproduction, or dlommitnetIon b prowbSd.
RECEIVED AT 07/02/2319 18:43:28 qp
DR.
18:40 07/02/2019 23479
18:40 07/02/2019 00209 NY10100T2
'0420466983
TXT
V-262-792-79-685-e ORGAN DONOR
MIAMI BEACH FL 33139
MIAMI BEACH FL 33139
TYPE LIC: CLASS E OPERATOR /MTRCY ALSO DOB: HT: 507 RACE: W SEX: F
CURRENT LICENSE ISSUED: 02/12/2014 EXPIRES: 05/25/2022 REP. LIC. ISSUED 01/30/18
VALID LICENSE SOC SEC:
This information should only be used as authorized by Florida Statute,
section 119.0712(2)(c):

1. Emergency contact information contained in a motor vehicle record is
confidential and exempt from s. 119.07(1) and s. 24(a), Art. I of the State
Constitution.
2. Without the express consent of the person to whom such emergency contact
https://www.ejustice.ny.gov/JWINiewMessagejsp?msgid=26693088cpager.offset 7/2/2019
NW Response Page 2 of 2
information applies, the emergency contact information contained in a motor
vehicle record may be released only to law enforcement agencies for purposes
of contacting those listed in the event of an emergency.
EMERGENCY CONTACT INFORMATION:
HOSA isi
MIAMI BEACH
WORK: N/A
FL 33139
END OF DDL/DHSN RESPONSE.
Unauthorized access, reproduction, or dissemination Is prohibited.
CELL:
https://www.ejustice.ny.gov/JWINiewMessagejsp?msgid=2669308&pagersoffset*1 7/2/2019
히OZ/TJL 3S! tujsdq/dde/uioa " 1uu.n3oninaos,:sduq
騶
口
cooz uer
人INnOD NH0人 M크N
g799-配001 AN )ldO人M크N
903a k士V - C 00乙 urr
人INflOO N님0人 六八크N
0?L09的CL 人N ‘壯均人/小크!나
I 10乙 6ny- LOG亡 6nv
人1Nfl03NH0人 사1크卜I'
81t9-S900l AN 거do人M크N
1 山z dag
人JNfl03 NHO人
. M크N ' Q얹)01 人卜1 )180人PA訓
랴0Z Je씨
人.13町}03 Nd0人 /叭크!4
乙DIP=比001 人N ’거do人MaM
{1Hr川'4 ;adQdqM9p4 -!그
a거U市
J하삐 JO 5 unajppy
마oz 8ny
人INflOONHO人 MRM
U7 . 口兀7 n 人 ' d yHn人 /n 나\d
h10乙 AON - 1가{玘 qe크
人 I NnflO a avo기川win
나3V크日 IrWIN
SHO工V기aNI (引캐어Id
3 따乙 川卜t PIOZ 八0卜1
:卜moD 크ova니川出N
1i百玎 『C ii " H3V크e ivv哨
0999尸oat끄 ON 三'-It八SYNOHI
:8m
SS3NOUV NSS
?乙 /gn
: a坦a dx크
卜Lqad (9-)se口月比Sm馴凡
:GIBQ aflssl 텨BW84 - JPUaQ
거:쁘竺요l0 ,:eOy
:日m
" 1
크WVN liv
auleN 咨川J :awep se
LI1 I. 아 I, 띠1n$eH
z .rc'

╭───────────────── Page 4, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ Page | of 2                                       │
│                                                   │
│ Results 1 to 1 of 1                               │
│                                                   │
│ AL NAME SSN ADDRESS PHONE(S) INDICATORS           │
│                                                   │
│ 2]                                                │
│                                                   │
│ MAMI BEACH, FL 39139-7362,                        │
│ MIAMLDADE COUNTY                                  │
│                                                   │
│ v2014 -A                                          │
│                                                   │
│ saree 35109-4766,                                 │
│                                                   │
│ MIAMI-DADE COUNTY                                 │
│                                                   │
│ NEWYORK NY 10022-5146,                            │
│ NEWYORK COUNTY                                    │
│                                                   │
│ NEWYORK. NY 10085-6218.                           │
│ NEWy                                              │
│                                                   │
│ ‘Aug 2007 - Aug                                   │
│                                                   │
│ IEW YORK. NY 10055:                               │
│ NEWYORK COUNTY                                    │
│                                                   │
│ NEWYORK COUNTY                                    │
│ Jan 200                                           │
│                                                   │
│ https://sccure.accurint.com/app/bps/mise 7/2/2019 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Page 2 of 2
ALL NAME SSN ADDRESS PHONE(S) INDICATORS
HONOLULU. HI 96816-2014
HONOLULU COUNTY
Mey 2001 - Jun 200'
4.1.1712 0833,
HONOLULU COUNTY
Mar 2000 - Apr 2001
NEW YORK. NV 10003-8537
NEW YORK COUNTY
Results 1 to 1 of 1
Last Name: First Name: DOB:
Your DPPA Permissible Use: Court, Law Enforcement, or Government Agencies
Your GLBA Permissible Use: Law Enforcement Purposes
Your DMF Permissible Use: No Permissible Purpose
https:Isecurc.accurint.coin/app/bps/mise 7/2/2019
WS Adams
Advanced Person Search
I maw. Nan.
Binc1.4 Pans Hige, '
Osvcis•an
lY Cole I 1 Radius (mit)
0 incal• norm .ansten•
City

OM. Fkst Seen
Show AdditoNS 5.400105'144, 44rocn Fame
Rooulto1 to 7 of 7
Last 144ese: Pint Ramo: =DM
SI  HAW MN
D.
041.0 Foams*
•v4.4 444,4•••
Stab,
Oat. Lag 34•4
AOURLIS
Ores, I the
Scorch Cleat POI'',
Rdenow
Imortaft
mews meson awe's* fl ea ea
malln 414 144n.Odin•
lams
sr4 944 404 dolci.
Mina
To4lal *ISM ''' (to Pflo'r
14•71414 Rill/ACM
4 Sworn haliehe
400 , 4•0 , r4tErl
F.Cret "t ."'Wwi wn
Compri...sun
Cumw C..< myvn Addrn• R own
NIftta) Idertity Laprpet 44..4 Rota Zi onne.t.wary: tpaft Rotobret
litighbOr. ..enh 9•4•1 4 As $44.44.4
lociACI, KOa V•ual L4,1
$032.13tattISIMIlti
Sew p Pot
NOPCS) 1401C4'('
RIEBESIOW.
t011OP RICH Qat, l•  u$1 -114 NAVE)
Polio 04 ,41.1414.. 0.7
WO
RWNWLE NC
Fob 2CP0 • Jan X49
01.
MV

w. 04 Ffitt14
to Wit Mai 37
4R 4r ynieJS
cor WW.
WwWW WO)
MO

╭───────── Page 6, Image 1 ─────────╮
│ Advanced Person Search omen | tet │
│                                   │
│ Results 1 t07 of 7                │
╰───────────────────────────────────╯

Puna! >see 400RESS PKOME(S) FOICATOIS
VEWrdER NY 10E1410 POW TOM(
•Cf CON NEW YORK COUN - y
VZ•13-21:114 HOW, .1 u
Au ?JAW SSN ACORESS INDICATORS
Results 1=7
List tiamEMMIIIkst Name: 00B:
Your OPPA !Porn-4001e User Cowt, Urn We:cement GmerrmtM Arndt:
Yam els* Perinlesib'e tart: taw Intr.:cement kraosts
Your DM Permissible Use, Ao ',Wills:tic Purpose
EFTA00006107 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
FBI - Miami
Name/Squad:
16320 NW 2nd Avenue
N. Miami Beach, FL 33169-6508
FOR INTERNAL USE ONLY
TO : °Albany
°Albuquerque
°Anchorage
°Atlanta
=Baltimore
=Birmingham
°Boston.
°Buffalo
°Charlotte
°Chicago
°Cincinnati
°Cleveland
oColumbia
°Dallas
°Denver
=Detroit
=El Paso
°FEHR)
Honolulu
o Houston
o Indianapolis
Jackson
o Jacksonville
o Kansas City
cm Knoxville
o Las Vegas
o Little Rock
o Los Angeles
o Louisville
o Memphis
ci Miami
o Milwaukee
o Minneapolis
o Mobile
o Newark
o New Haven
o New Orleans
lir:INew York City := Washington Field
°Norfolk
o Oklahoma City
o Omaha
o Philadelphia
o Phoenix
o Pittsburgh
o Portland
o Richmond
o Sacramento
Saint Louis
tzi Salt Lake City
ci San Antonio
= San Diego
o San Francisco
o San Juan
o Seattle
Springfield
o Tampa
CM Butte OSC C Quantico (CIRG) p Savannah OSC
o Clarksburg (CJIS) o Quantico (Training) in Winchester (RMD)
o Pocatello (PSCU) Quantico (ERF-OTD)
Quantico (Lab)
o Fort Pierce, RA
o Homestead, RA
° Key West, RA
o West Palm Beach, RA
Abu Dhabi
Accra
o Addis Ababa
o Algiers
o Amman
o Ankara
o Astana
o Athens
o Baghdad
o Bangkok
o Beijing
rzi Berlin
o Bern
o Bogota
CI Brasilia
Cl Bridgetown.
o Brussels
o Bucharest
o Budapest
CI Buenos Aires
o Cairo
o Canberra
o Caracas
Via FBIHQ
o Copenhagen
o Dakar
o Doha
o Hong Kong
o Islamabad
o Jakarta
°Kabul
o Kuala Lumpur
°Kyiv
°Lagos
=London
°Madrid
o Manila
o Mexico City
CI Moscow
CI Nairobi
CI New Delhi.
Ottawa
o Panama City
In Paris
Phnom Penh
O Pretoria
° Rabat
o Riyadh
cm Rome
o San Salvador
o Sanaa
o Santiago
Santo Domingo
in Sarajevo
Seoul
o Singapore
Sofia
°Tallinn
=Tbilisi
Tel Aviv
=Tokyo
CI Vienna
Warsaw
CLASSIFICATION LEVEL
(CHECK ONE)
UNCLASSIFIED, NOT SENSITIVE
=SENSITIVE, BUT UNCLASSIFIED
°CONFIDENTIAL
° SECRET
ATTENTION:
Ala 11bantemen I Prop=
5/11
Complaint Form
FD-71 (Rev. r-13.92) •
NOTE: Hand print names legibly; handwriting aatiafactory for remainder.
Indict,: (I Negative LJ See below
Subjarl name and aliases
'‘',.
Character of cam
C L . ic. ?trik,if« . ptb
-1 4C43 (psi e..-4 CompleDig Protect Sawa
twoal g ettlephoolo Date Time
Address Subject of
.,.//plit
act Sex
Race Sex
O Male
Height Hair Ruild Binh Date and Birthplace
•Ei Age O female ❑ Weight Eyes Complexion Social Security Number
,1D ' Scars, marts ant other date
Facts of complaint
Cope..(SL...betrA C)6_... 1 agS W.4.k s \.‘ 42 Z s  ck  k:X ;...k.e., ‘s; inua.A 6,...k..,s4 ck.„,..
- e:"P.. .? -k4k ,..tc-es c., k\42.4- .-sYsk4-rs (a Ag.-., (C (i t s Le \-‘a.- c)‹..5‘.. )
1),tc.sof,,m--\ P.«-k- LASoe\N. tr'Ske>4 S'Lle 14\4. ?\. -..\ -es <2,,,A ,S0 5,\.-xt_s ‘•
O...T.), -r5 L4-142i.it k") (,,c.•-•'4 -st( . -{‹,e . 4.-k-usas f>jragA-;c4 bC>1.9-/ -"S.
C-\.)  5 .k 2" ‘ i:<- \  Cr‘C`) € k; ;v.& e2,_,ce-"\e, ki. 4-€1/4..\-,4 r ic.Lvccs
e- (7 ta., c\--‘,<> c_\ - i.,\:,...‘,..X• b NA3 , 2 t'.)1E I 1\S . N ND14S
\\ 3/4", eetee:bn
b
-\ L\ .IL \.e k-4,, ct..".)7n...,t te\t,,,:ik k-te.fi-if et
ca 1/4\
Do i. S. ant ~is epees.
LV.5g.C.1). 26-77/ 1
:.:..ARRL,..,iu,71.[Do v .,
I - 6G P— lc? ii9 -SÅ-S
~STAMP

╭─────────────────────────── Page 2, Image 1 ───────────────────────────╮
│ ‘Complaint Form                                                       │
│ FD71 @ev. 413-92)                                                     │
│                                                                       │
│ Indices: [) Negative                                                  │
│                                                                       │
│ NOTE: Hand print names legibly; handwriting satisactory for reminder. │
│ O seebelow                                                            │
│                                                                       │
│ ‘Sebjectb name and aliases ‘Chacter of case                           │
│ eae ~ Complainant [J] Protect Source                                  │
│ vous! (Telephonic Date, Time,                                         │
│ “Addess of Sabjest                                                    │
│ Haigh Tair Build ue Binh Date and Birthplace                          │
│ Weight Eyes ‘Complexion ‘Sosial Security Number                       │
│                                                                       │
│ aot                                                                   │
│ Picks                                                                 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00006369 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
r

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ r,... Jon oe FY.  │
╰───────────────────╯

IMPORT ESSAGE
FOR
-., DATE 1 / -7 47 On TIM ,r -_E I ' --4-i (-A.Pr
M
OF \
PHONE/ \ 1/4
MOBILE \(Cu k i% now. AINe In•...1.0"at V }
..•
TELEPHONED ' PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU
1
WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL MENTION
MESSAGE

• 4 ,.._.,
-"" he jS any , -r; y wAsnj
v 5: 3° eFYik
C a SIGNED 1184.
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR :F-
DATE 11 7 .0 IE 4 iztO •%el
M
OF
PH • MOST r•
TELEPHONED i PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU 5 WILL CALL AGAIN I
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE '
I
e ?S'e" .14 ,,,,,..

• < x -,
\ C_-------- ea SIGNED 7 not
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR TA 7 b
1 . ! L A.M. SATE  li 2 1 i 0 5 TIME t .. 51 (52! ko
M
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONES PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU I RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
•
MESSAGE
- \--.2) \ c 2, 0  ,:-....12A \n
\..- \
. .
. . .
a.
SIGNED • 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR . -1 W-- • n
DATE / .2 --- '?s. THAE Z : 4D ct*-
t,A
OF
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL .
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN. . ■
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
I le ?se, (-651.‘ knkvh
kNA2A- L ciiirti
at SIGNED I1µ

╭──────────────────────── Page 2, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ aa                                                              │
│ vb                                                              │
│                                                                 │
│ 0AoON99""”"-”-0""7"9"“""—™                                      │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                               │
│                                                                 │
│ A= :                                                            │
│                                                                 │
│ oh                                                              │
│                                                                 │
│ jire___2i]o5" swe 25 Ai                                         │
│                                                                 │
│ — CUE                                                           │
│ o                                                               │
│                                                                 │
│ ‘TELEPHONED. PLEASE CALL                                        │
│ ‘CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN                                │
│ WANTS 70 SEE YOU RUSH                                           │
│                                                                 │
│ RETURNED YOUR CALL| __| SPECIAL ATTENTION                       │
│                                                                 │
│ oF. s                                                           │
│                                                                 │
│ wie You Wnaw Ure number)                                        │
│                                                                 │
│ oameTo see VOU | [Witt CALL AGAN                                │
│ ANTS TOSEEVOO | — [RH                                           │
│                                                                 │
│ bovOvdeLY                                                       │
│                                                                 │
│ Message MESSAGE                                                 │
│                                                                 │
│ Dhe is conbicming Vieaso celh hor                               │
│                                                                 │
│ ip Biss PA                                                      │
│                                                                 │
│ seule                                                           │
│                                                                 │
│ a ew ta”                                                        │
│                                                                 │
│ cm =                                                            │
│                                                                 │
│ OOO LOHOHHHHVI                                                  │
│                                                                 │
│ AN                                                              │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                               │
│ ror E                                                           │
│ pare__1 1.23 iie240 Bit                                         │
│ ry 7                                                            │
│ g OF.                                                           │
│                                                                 │
│ PHONE/                                                          │
│ MOBILE.                                                         │
│                                                                 │
│ PLEASE CALL TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL                              │
│ [oaveTo sez vou | wit. caLLAean CAMETO SEEYOU_| | WiLL CALLAGAN │
│ [wants 0 see vou | [ruse WANTS TO SEE VOU                       │
│                                                                 │
│ RETURNED YOURCALL| | SPECIALATTENTION | _| RETURNED YOUR CALL   │
│                                                                 │
│ Message MESSAGE.                                                │
│                                                                 │
│ “Weese Vall bon Vie ose Meal) Lam                               │
│                                                                 │
│ <r)                                                             │
│ KC                                                              │
│                                                                 │
│ L@2@SESBBS@Daae                                                 │
│                                                                 │
│ R)                                                              │
│                                                                 │
│ 4                                                               │
│ '                                                               │
│ 3                                                               │
│ a                                                               │
│ a                                                               │
│ a                                                               │
│ H                                                               │
│ F                                                               │
│ a                                                               │
│ i                                                               │
│ a                                                               │
│ a                                                               │
│ a                                                               │
│ i 4                                                             │
│ (                                                               │
│ Py                                                              │
│ a                                                               │
│ z                                                               │
│ x                                                               │
│                                                                 │
│ 2                                                               │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007600 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
╭── Page 1, Image 1 ───╮
│ | Wood “TEGHNOLOGY   │
│ METAL TECHNO LOGY    │
│ ~— TAL TECHNOLOGY    │
│ . y e                │
│                      │
│ PLEASE nex To        │
│                      │
│ ‘woot                │
│                      │
│ Inc.                 │
│                      │
│ CONOVER, NC 23613    │
│ PHONI                │
│ FAX                  │
│                      │
│ CSN STORES, INC,     │
│                      │
│ , MA @2116           │
│                      │
│ 1204 71010342970)    │
│                      │
│ UPS—BES i            │
│ BACK, DescRIF        │
│ ORDERED              │
│                      │
│ i Bal                │
│                      │
│ YO 1260 B . EBONY    │
│ 1 CARTONS @          │
│                      │
│ 1 UNITS SHIPPED      │
│                      │
│ CD STORAGE TOWER     │
│ 0.008 =              │
│                      │
│ 42700                │
│ ez                   │
│                      │
│ _03/28/05|           │
│ DUNS #61-284-1759    │
│                      │
│ “358 EL BRILLO WAY - │
│                      │
│ PALM BEACH, FL 33480 │
│                      │
│ (0) A (3) <i         │
╰──────────────────────╯

o ttMSN Flo  Message
•a. .........-
trup:Vbylpd.baytgili ailinsn.coirVegi-binigetmsg?msg=MSCII I I..
•
MSN Home I My MSN I Hotmail I Shopping Money I People & Chat 1.1gnifiel,„ t! Web Search: I
Hotmail Today I Mail I Calendar I Contacts
hotmall.com
eg, Reply I kb Reply All I a t Forward I Put n Folder ie Print View I Save Address
From :
Sent:
To
Subject:
auto-confum@amazon.com <autO-Confirm@amazon.com>
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:25 AM
Your Order with Amazon.com
amazon.com.and you're done: WVIEW CART I WISH LIST I \Y0UR ACCOUNT) I HEW
Thanks for your order,
Want to track your order status?
Learn how with our animated demo!
Dld you know you can view and edit your orders online, 24 hours a
day? Click Your Account to:

• Access 'Where's My Stuff?'
• Combine orders
• Change payment method
• Change shipping address
• Cancel unshipped items

• Change gift messaging
• Co much more...
Purchasing Information:
E-mail Address:
Billing Address: Shipping Address:
hIslaine rnaxw II
new yo c, new yor
United States
Order Grand Total: $29.94
Earn 3% rewards on your Amazon.com jjurchases with the Amazon
Visa Card. Learn More
Order Summary: 1 Shipping Details: (order wLltarrive in 1 shci ent)
Order #:
Shipping One-Day Shipping Method:
Shipping Group my items into as few shipments as possible Preference
new york, ny 10021
United States
Options I Help
Free Newsletters
I nf 7 3/24/2005 9:36 '
."1". 'IC • •Ai • I V. •• •••••. • • •
•
'''
amazon.com.
Billing Address:
Jeffrey Epstein
358 El Brims Way
Palm Beach, Florida 33480
USA
Ainnom • amazon.com. 1850 Merceron, Rd.
Lexington, KY 40511
Jeffiey Epstein •
35$ El Bravo Way
Patm Bank Florida 33480
USA
r, 11 ildnet57708/-3-/nex /2436223. BORTExtrastTraok
Shipping Address:
JeffreyBpstein
358 El Brillo Way .
Palm Heath, Florida 33480
USA
Your order

• •
of September 4, 2005 (Order ID 103-171782(1-4508648) '•
Qty. Item ItemPrice • Total
• .
IN THIS SHIPMENT
1 SM 101: A Realistic Introduction $16.47 $16.47
I Wiseman, ay --- Paperback
r C-2 *1 0963976389
1 SlaveCraft: Roadmaps for Erotic Servitude --Principles, Skills and Tools . 515.95 •
Baldwin, Guy -- Paperback ' . ‘ •-S:
$15.95.. •
P•  C-2 *1 1881943143 • 44`\...th w:.
1 Training With Miss Abernathy: A Workbook for Erotic Slaves and Their.."' '.x.- 511.95 .

• Owners
Abernathy, Christina --- Paperback •• • .
(s" C-2'!), 1890159077 " :
Ife •
1
Thisibipment completes your order.
c • http://iirivnb itv.M.coin
Cour Account'L
FV.
For detailed information about this and other orders, please visit
Your Account. You can also print invoices, change your etnalit
address and payment settings; alter your communication
preferences; and much more — 24 hours ketay — at.
http://www.arnazon:eorn/your—accoun, •
Retuhis Me Eapyl.
VWthttp://www.saazoit.com/returns to return any item —
including gifts —.in unopened or original condition within 30
days fora full refund (other restrictions apply). Please have
your ord./ ID ready. ,
•or
Thatdo for shopping at Amazon.coa arta PleidAr
one again€
•
Subtotal . 514.37  . . • . •
Shipping & Handling . I -$24.4r
Order Total  868,83.2 • f .
Paid via Amex
Balance due
amazon.come
C.
6/ rbrd 57708/-3 -/ /SORTEstFastTrack/nest/2436223/0912-OA0/0911-194Sinvwd Sox or pad: Baja 1.2x9k2 v
III III IIIII IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII ,
FedEx I Ship Manager Page 1 of 1
parsii.e0: (212)150.9095
, NY 10022
CAS/411/1"/Na
SHP TO: (561)832-0232 BILL SENDER
Jeffrey Epstein
358 El Brillo Way
Palm Beach, FL 33480
Ship Dam: ISSEPO5 Actual Wgt 2 B
SySemit: 151 8MANET2200
Account/KS  "•••••
REF: mail
II1111111I1111111IVII1111111NIIIIllU 11111111111Delivery Add es Ba Code
;"
PRIORITY OVERNIGHT
TRK#
33480 -FL-US
RES
FORM
(201
TUE
Deliver By: •
20SEP05
FLL • AA
XH LNAA
Shipping Label: Your shipment is complete

1. Use the 'Print feature from your browser to send this page to your laser or inkjet printer.
2. Fold the printed page along the horizontal line.
3. Place label in shipping pouch and affix it to your shipment so that the baroode portion of the label can be read and 
scanned.
Warning: Use only the printed original label for shipping. Using a photocopy of this label for shipping purposes is 
fraudulent
and could result in additional billing charges, along with the cancellation of your FodEx account number.
Use of this system constitutes-your agreement to the service conditions in the current FedEx Service Guide, (wobble on 
fedex.com. FedEx will not
be responsible for any claim in excess of $100 per package, whether the result of loss, damage, delay, nondelivery, 
misdeilvery, or misinformation.
unless you declare a higher yak*, pay an additional charge, document your actual loss and file a timely daim. 
Limitations found in the current FedEx
Service Guide appty. Your light to recover from FedEx for any foss, inducing intrinsic value of the package. loss of 
sales, income interest, profit,
enamels fees, costs, and other forms of damage whether direct, incidental, consequential, or special is limited to the 
greater of 5100 or the
authorized declared value. Recovery cannot exceed actual documented loss. Maximum for items of extraordinary value is 
$500. e.g. jewelry,
precious metals, negotiable instruments and other items listed in our Service Guide. Written claims must be filed within
strict time limits, see current
FedEx Service Guide-
4,4
https://www.fedex.com/egi-bin/ship_it/unity/3IiUv5FiRx0IcUg2BcRw0HbQr4AgXt6IaUr... 9/19/2005
.:• """*"" t•

• u.s.posmar7
THEiHou)Eflimho'
• >it:d i ...-. 1 Z.,. "
•an Francisco, CA 94311 • Foninaster. Fionadeliver September 79, 20Q. •
./ r
DR CURRENT
REs11:::ttift***5-DIG0I0T1 3p31188011AE'LLGER3RRHIgAEPN.:USTTS
iN PTLSOALBUteREI;fiC14E.. •
1P128 227 337t KEY: KX057255
70748 Tow, CENTER AT BOLA RATOti -
358 EL BRILLO NAY 2/052 SAUGRASS MILLS
%MIT
PALM BEACH FL 3348C THE MILL AT WELLINGTON GREEN
!nlin:ilnlulLleit III
*7. ae•
ti •
Town of Pal,
,Pollee Depa
EVIDEI
CASE itt 3S )
p
0
CONTE!

• l'-Ae,yoy Suspect;
51I,
s
SUCK d5
ay.s
i‘cycr\.
Officer: ea
a‘ a
t .
Labs:
KL-231
outer
parr comes in its o‘in mesh
teze.,
.Tiane, you
canweit . , „.
SpecifyS, M, L or XI 5,r an/ , . 1., ,
A tin
(women 9'10; . 11,  (1
'9 or veX-Largi(riie s :2 Pi
lio
...
r *
fe "Cd.or <lippe   .
reve-
, ..,
-40 i;
w.
t>:-.....; a l; •
jet ''.
41* .
.

• : • . • . ... ' 2
I.
'. • ... 's " • • •  :. 4.
' ..
• 1 .4
• .

╭─ Page 6, Image 1 ─╮
│ Town of Pal       │
│ .Police Depa      │
│                   │
│ EVIDE|            │
│ Gas 105 3B yay    │
│                   │
│ CONTE?            │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00007685 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
MSN Home I My MSN Hotmail I Shopping I Money I People & Chat 15/0nOlitesel Web Search: I
Reply 1/4.O Reply All !  o Forward &I  Put in Fold° , Print View LI Save Address
To :
Subject ! Your Order wail Ansazon.com
Sent :
From:
amazon.com.
match.com
nvsn
"41 Hotmail
day? Click Your Account to:
Thanks for your order,
Want to track your order status?
Learn how with our animated demo!
Did you know you can view and edit your orders online, 24 hours a

• Access 'Where's fry Stuff"
• Combine orders
• Change payment method
• Cancel unsnipped items
• Change gift messaging

• Do much more. .
• Change shooing address
auteenntirm'Oamarnn corn eanto-erofirenroOrnaeon coin
Monday, March 21, 2005 3:25  AM
find gmgieg in 4::,u,13 area
and you're done um CART I WISH LIST I YOUR ACCOUN1) I HELP
Today Mail Calendar
II I...
Calendar I contacts
GIGI cid Trash Carta Inbox
a•
Cpbcns Help
Free Newsletters
SJO
Purchasing Information:
E-mail Address:
Billing Address:
ohrslaine maxwell
new york, new york 10022 new york, fly 10021
United States United States
Order Grand Total: $29.94
Earn 3% rewards on your Amazon.com purchases with the Amazon
Visa Card. Leam More
Order Summary:
Shipping Details: (order will arrive in 1 shipment)
Order #:
Shipping One -Day Shipping Method:
Shipping
Preference:  Group my items into as few shipments as possible
I 012 3/24t20050:36
EFTA00007686 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
(i 2eklyi
A
kobk,i911-e, yecAst-
o-Pkilia lov-k Snrifhoms —
1 4 - Doc 2,,,z.c.r ok
ba-tisktvlai,  virus
ibua-
ciau lAave tmve.;
Caii, Cause..
or, 1.2- 4,1U-C4SQ4:.
coin IJOQ/A - 1QuA .
k)(1.1, Lt42
Jeffrey E. Epstein

╭── Page 2, Image 1 ───╮
│ dean Luc - zee       │
│                      │
│ the note cat         │
│ beeen ox             │
│ The Hoe lear we a    │
│ Qratis avian Virus — │
│ Th 3 Conable but     │
│ wave wove; FL        │
│ COUSe impotence,     │
│ ove                  │
│ Cow Qn               │
│ peg Ute - ma         │
│                      │
│ | Jeffrey E. Epstein │
╰──────────────────────╯
╔═════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 OGE [government] Office of Government Ethics 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00007859 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
eel%
Town of Palm Beach A pe
Police Department I st ick'
EVIDENCE
CASEY 65 ^ 1CA?  PROPERTY/  DC' /On
CONTENTS
(2-4‘443
Item Quantity Description
3 \e'er Piri.nr
Suspect: s cum it
Warta
. Date:fir 20 • Or
Lab*:
RL•231

• •
• •
ZR.S7VE [TROT. VIP. , -MSt.{.
.4.4.- UV.; ,ir:GTALL NE./
\  .4.4 . Ptii-r .4 cili:Pr..1
RELOCATE ExAT C.o"....ii., T& -2t.
4 Cass4o015irik., ...ill "ra Pits/ MO
..7 0..... yhez P...D 'city T.G.
PER MIA ~Larking. _
,i
\-AIR. PTE4A•LT COIL.4244. pa..k...-. .
isa•-a, T. Cie <sate_ , G ER GETCRIAIL,
br 74.4:17/ 6 0.1-ri Osl• op /,x....7
D rorc. ♦• 4,1:17144.  •Is
.1
twat
liaubL  • 6~
i4to.
Ert.sityt. Teecatc
oge. RAVER iwa. Rirsto'
INSTALL clew g.e.Dcacnat
- riercivtal.EC
;,-
74EL/ccii4R-TERRAGG rw
lac4 Gapi ITAvIR, (AS)
sie.,44.1.
,2-Qmovt ERA-. pece
EALAWR, ez;crli or
-- biRvi-LA: no 4 .$,TAU-
R.,2174“ <
Ei
...g-
.a4rT 4 .fibT•44.
&C. • E. 1.5 1 To
Cairn' •ivr.  Fe -1A
rant 4.A-oT
HEAT% F ww4AGE
to 44.0i TS' otA FRIA
rt Y
f4R-4
Peri>4. awe*

• W. LAC, ii.issrALL
(FS atria) Gitlea s,  PAatir
Exydr. rloToGUO GARAcvE
Cww•tso R Rbis•-•1
KITCIaerJ
------- e
Iger , e'de D0•01'.
PuriPs. Fitgass
iiicer. arc. REPIOJE. 44,J.
Igavexttile. aware,. ticape

• esior...1. IC Se true.,
IA FAO nil 407.1.1-
/4e+. -ma+.< ria.irla, lO rimc44.
raia-~ao
r1010- SoieAL STAIR -4-  •
Taco
•
•
—44ALtki

• MOT
l, Ittinr.Pgzen Aet ,t ,
,9 a„„,4 S,
4171 FI
11 co
a - - isl'atAl‘i Ag,i,  ti,kteal si.ccia.
ATOP Riitit SROsiL •C42( . 4.•
•-1 .(...44i 4 isnitizr. _ _ _
E4
rip. Ai.i....lovwc., 0 1 ilAicwt....t.,(srs•
•
'
Tv
L 1
trisår cEå
~Lark, AG R4.-wt, Yo
AGGoil Ogg. 4441TRZ'a
C-rfiRe.sor. eab-siew 1

'
V!...-11.M, &On
-- __ . - 177-17.,tigat Crietbt
PW -19•Tior4 ei-LITTEL1/43
p r- - - _ occe
CiarZart Kborl
_ - -
I •
OlrIIrIG goori
L -•
EiT
%kg P
- _ _
FO ;'GC  ,
irm.1.1. 46, Lay.irigeo ,r .-015{KLL P.to •
CI^ / 114~14 F1.4. 4fl iaN 4(1 -
~Eit> GL, issistt.
aP _
'31
\ i•is. - 44.i. .'td Yloicigit-60
si.s>r4e. Cioilt. C CitivfAiScr
"rivi raj s

• ' >

ht. -4 &pixel CDs* 'au.—
Ta\ c/..iciapt'l • i) ,
\j kpte..yogicj
~LT -.a
\T. Tum L
•
A
{its , ccit.4 isp•
•
i••• PRAT c: -
tlktkca•zc.i
•
..1/415-a•LL pied er.44,:r , Ce41 14(1 lektf
•",~10 t W-.rJ
R001
4,1•1.1• ctilisuil Fait>
‘7 ,1 00cRsa
'rREOZ' sr. tail T4E•S
C it., 0.-CGo
LAKE i0Ot''
.A•o iust

• R•j- •• ‘.
•
•• 'R.. v,. •71E.O waist? I
cue.» tr
aertatil 1
C•ssrCe
iiiorA
4
,L AE.:NPECA,_,i lj
.., r •
- 41 II-5I
Ex."'
C
dab;
I
I
I
II
I
I,
Ir
-C1
-4
MALL 74C.. 0f1744.c.-rmiii-E
n,4.1i., rat og
goom-riaitentE.0
waa., Ai
09C.J.V(.
Lai,•riekei CRro wALL -1
Pool. 140TEso
ooNblwcj ./s/ pooL-rit•LL.
GauAGE eii4A Woot-• AZA.400-,
0--0  %lira ~La CovR2
Ova .4.14 CONERETE. 4
reAvaTde. 4L4ltifii So VATti4.
Go4Ofts-1 nk.. wipe-.
•FLE
NaeR Lire , (kw
114.. RapAiR 64~4
RE SURFACE- gthilRE
r4TERiciE. op ;octal
1-
0'4 1--ei tut -
EPSTEIN
RESIDENCE
358 EI Brill° Way
Palm ricach. Florida
ARCM
i X
A•So4 LNI ID A

V. , nl NI in V ❑ t LA
NO DESCRIPTION DATE
REVIS/ONS
DRAWING TITLE
Firzsr
ni.a.7i/34.. site Par*1
SCALE
4o_
DAT 2.4574
PROJECT NO
DRAWING NO A -I

╭── Page 3, Image 1 ──╮
│ dene pig weaual eh  │
│                     │
│ wens (63)           │
│                     │
│ cone, TURNS, wd     │
│                     │
│ ewintriNG Fook      │
│                     │
│ | tet Shel Coe wal  │
│                     │
│ “any                │
│                     │
│ extra Cee wall      │
│                     │
│ SSS SSS             │
│                     │
│ EPSTEIN             │
│ RESIDENCE           │
│                     │
│ 358 El Brillo Way   │
│ Palm Beach, Florida │
│                     │
│ So. bEScH           │
│                     │
│ Fest FL             │
╰─────────────────────╯

1

1. —
-
Too R.A. to ea Alan""Al
2:o NOT aw-Lkoit CooeF ?Areas.
tatty PKG. c
r
EAti  ocx>f 7 014ber •
GUEST Roar) .
GUStr itochi s2
CitlEtt X1 . 5
1.1ouggepes coal
_ 4 —Koff  ovecileki
'NALCO
fterove. wuJooM,r. CUT rteozonley
°oval To rtooa LEvv,L. a4411.44.L
wo,O Dace,.
mo:ar tept....m tW elrrie.A.: he Cram
vetlistie 0
eke Limas-
t,X .Tegefect4I
Mel t&
e:E.OCCer
-
fi
dog
14
—

44114. EJEV CRelerla
TOP SAL lett ALloopNuri
Ge-letAL biaresz
'24 t i To et
YOsoALA TLC. 04 cLo.:".

• 1.0144.4. FAL gegielt CeAreTtler."
fr ate 7. et

7. nc rtAetso Erie W.
2. Ctalleb • 5 1c St WS sett,
MAAPA.E. 71.e....1 +-ALLA
OitAvattAjo te-to.rf f Veal
rLaotn To so, 3.e'elseb.
FLoovo To tee cs-c.es+
eo tr.."-04 Ele:v14, 444.
ERWael 041 Tee 4.. t Plaza c1.4)
”I-4..L.L. New cizeh.,4 t+nAcith., Gael koartt N is °b.
mai
cs../ Et Tv M'..1 "co{ 44
.4
. _
• I  ‘.../Erdr
;  Ecoc TECO2C4.
'0144.
trbeA ciicc Cos NK.4 ezankNi
:zee.... te.r..
O.-C40.
HiVisi LL Oita fraikkes
re HAL To 2C. TAAL

4. iNoTALL. clew Doolteo. fecoee-•to
Coo, NLb r.o.¢g.EO
5 Ithalle.LL ?abet Gv8 PoLLTioN,
ileadie ,  Arra
to A.C. 5.2 C.orITEK:Hog. "s14-1
flab€ Seksee O. % . FbC
tioSSCATeael'a To AG. terwpi
blebeler Reale ran Pylon.
EPSTEIN
RESIDENCE
358 El Brine Way
Palm Beach, Florida
'AL I BEACH. FLA.

NO. DESCRIPTICLN ItATE REVIS/ONS
DRAWING TITLE
eaal40 FLOCK fiShl
SCALE V igil -CI. '
atTE 4.4 M4
e " I An
PROJECT NO.
DRAWING NO. A-2.

╭──── Page 4, Image 1 ─────╮
│ —_                       │
│                          │
│ EPSTEIN                  │
│ RESIDENCE                │
│                          │
│ 358 El Brillo Way        │
│ Palm Beach, Florida      │
│                          │
│ elie “ £                 │
│ LL Hea ently t 3 a       │
│                          │
│ ieee —                   │
│ “ _ PALM BEACH, FLA,     │
│                          │
│ Guest Rooy* |            │
│                          │
│ (etue Foor)              │
│                          │
│ _ Hloucexeerer _         │
│ Guest Kooy *2_ STING Roo │
│                          │
│ (ence aor)               │
│                          │
│ S=__——                   │
│                          │
│ I as He                  │
│                          │
│ eae oer                  │
│ Fos PRT                  │
│                          │
│ No DE                    │
│                          │
│ DRawine THE              │
│                          │
│ econo FLoce Puss         │
│                          │
│ scars #10".              │
│                          │
│ nen 4.4 94               │
│ Feoncrma                 │
│                          │
│ peweincna  A-2           │
╰──────────────────────────╯

I CaMovt Earn" Ooort , iti.,7.11
,E.., %., Woad- irkU.../ 40S.
d‘NN,fV40.4. eXIST 1.21ET 1 Car pa
er.4.41. tit.' l'aLIT 1.1 Isrtir bal.:.
CEMovr, Erittf ~41T,II4MALL. tk..,
•
EP6TEi NI
REST DEIJGE
5ss fwbLL o ,arrøst.ri b53.444
ARCHITECT
NEW YORK. NEW YORK
I 0 0 2 I
TEL:
PAC:
Actcameo tb~i

NO. DESCRIPTION DATE
REVISIONS
~INC TITLE
ElfraglEiC PA,ANItn Ptak
cAsanIA.
SCALE 14' s .1-c"
DATE 3.23-94
PROJECT Nn
DRAVENCI,p, - IS

╭─ Page 5, Image 1 ──╮
│ *                  │
│                    │
│ Nev FEN Le.        │
│ phere              │
│                    │
│ “SWIMMING Pool     │
│                    │
│ Epstein            │
│ Resi DENCE         │
│                    │
│ 288 eb pelle way   │
│ PALM Bead FLA,     │
│                    │
│ a T                │
│ —                  │
│                    │
│ rr                 │
│                    │
│ aemccnjes MECKTECT │
│                    │
│ —                  │
│                    │
│ Beeeck PANG lane   │
│ CABANE. PLAN       │
╰────────────────────╯
EFTA00007962 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00008488 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
Intercept
Date:
Data
Transferred
for
Permanent
Storage
-
Date:
Chain
of
Custody-ELSUR
Evidence
Envelope
Fri-aothotev. Enclosure:
i
Original
0
Duplicate
0
Enhanced
Original
Medium:
0
Magnetic
Tape
0
Computer
Disk
0
Printed
Material
Case
Filc4:
1
— AllA/1
4"113377

I Da:

iii)
--.
Case
Agt.:
Tape/Diskth
Agt.
Supervising
Title
III
Intercepts:

O
Court
Authorized
Intercept
- Souree/Symbol#:

Consensual
Monitoring
Intercept
- CM#
(if
assigned):
&s4
6-5-41
Telephonic
(TCM)
0
Nontelcphonie
(NTCM)
If
NTCM
Specify
Device
Used:

O
Recording
of
an
Interview
O
Volunteered/Subpoenaed
Medium
- Not
FBI
ELSUR
O
Other
Type
of
Recording/Inteeption.
Specify:

/0/V1101
rc
Place:
Vil/
S
Ale\
beacl
,/ pz-
/obi
foci
Tim
d
:447//
11
O
Consensual:
List
Interceptees
Below
0
Court
Authorized:
Enter
" See
Log"
Below
*64-1-4-c-brA
tetaiLni
vAtifedo
Choir;
c7-
5“
eleased
Custody
Signature Date: ReasorT
ill
*SCA
Signature Date:
Time:
L31,2___
!WTI
ie,
7
lime:
Reason:
Slot
(>1,
e—
Signature: Date: Reason:

_
Signature: Date:
kr)-7

.
Reason:

•4433
tic
V
tir
izt, uoic:
S
AL
BUREi

Signature
.
Date: Reason:
Time
.
\\-i\\.
ILIMAII,
AC
Cantina
na.tansake
•
Signature: Date: Reason:
dUi
Time:
I
Signature: Date: Reason:

FEDEFU
Lr
Time: --v
Ulgi"
EFTA00039208 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
PROGRAM STATEMENT
()PI: CPD/CSB
NUMBER: 5521.06
DATE: June 4, 2015
RULES EFFECTIVE: July 6. 2015
Searches of Housing Units, Inmates,
and Inmate Work Areas
/5/
Approved: Charles E. Samuels, Jr.
Director, Federal Bureau of Prisons

I. PURPOSE AND SCOPE
§552.10 Purpose and scope.
In order to further the safe, secure, and orderly running of its institutions, the
Bureau of Prisons conducts searches of inmates and of inmate housing and work
areas to locate contraband and to deter its introduction and movement. Staff
shall employ the least intrusive method of search practicable, as indicated by the
type of contraband and the method of suspected introduction.
Non-intrusive sensors should be used whenever feasible. When searches are required, staff shall
avoid unnecessary force and strive to preserve the dignity of the individual being searched.

a. Summary of Changes
Policy Rescinded
P552I.05 Searches of Housing Units. Inmates, and Inmate Work Areas (06/30/97)
■ Included updated regulation language concerning electronic searches and x-rays.
Federal Regulations from 28 CFR are shown in this type.
Implementing instructions are shown in this type.
■ Added language clarifying cross-gender use of electronic search equipment.
■ Added language concerning cross-gender pat searches of female offenders.
■ Added language concerning pat searches of transgender inmates.

b. Program Objectives. The expected results of this program are:
■ Inmates will live and work in a safe and orderly environment.
■ Human Resources Office responsibilities will be clearly defined.
■ Searches of inmates and housing and work areas will be conducted without unnecessary
force and in ways that, insofar as is practical, preserve the dignity of inmates.

c. Institution Supplement. None required. Should local facilities make any changes outside
the required changes in the national policy or establish any additional local procedures to
implement the national policy, the local Union may invoke to negotiate procedures or
appropriate arrangements.

d. Pretrial/Holdover Procedures. Procedures required in this Program Statement are
applicable to pretrial and holdover inmates.

2. SEARCHES OF INMATES
§ 552.11 Searches of inmates.
a. Electronic devices. Inspection of an inmate's person using electronic devices
(for example, metal detector, ion spectrometry device, or body imaging search
device) does not require the inmate to remove clothing. The inspection may also
include a search of the inmate's clothing and personal effects. Staff may conduct
an electronic device search of an inmate on a routine or random basis to control
contraband.
Cross-gender staff may operate electronic devices revealing body contours if appropriate filters
are used.

b. Pat search. An inspection of an inmate using the hands does not require the
inmate to remove clothing. The inspection includes a search of the inmate's
clothing and personal effects. Staff may conduct a pat search of an inmate on a
routine or random basis to control contraband.
The Warden may install metal detection devices within the institution as necessary for the
control of contraband. A metal detector search may be done in addition to the pat search.
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing information: this type.
Any pat search shall be conducted as outlined in the Program Statement Correctional Services
Manual.
(1) Female Inmates. According to the Prison Rape Elimination Act (PREA) Standards for
Adult Prisons and Jails, Title 28 C.F.R. § 115.15(b), cross-gender pat-down searches of female
inmates are not permitted, absent exigent circumstances. As a result, male staff are not permitted
to pat-search female inmates, unless exigent circumstances exist.
Cross-gender pat searches of female inmates are permitted if exigent circumstances exist. The
PREA regulations, Title 28 C.F.R. § 115.5, define "exigent circumstances" as "any set of
temporary and unforeseen circumstances that require immediate action in order to combat a
threat to the security or institutional order of a facility."
Staff of the same sex as the inmate shall make the search, except where circumstances are such
that delay would constitute an immediate threat to the inmate, staff, others, property, or
institution security. Other options, such as detaining the inmate until a female staff member
arrives if feasible, should be considered before a cross -gender pat search is conducted.
A memorandum will be prepared documenting a cross-gender pat search of a female inmate by a
male staff member, which will be submitted to the Lieutenants' Office and forwarded to the
PREA Compliance Manager. All cross-gender pat searches of a female inmate by a male staff
member must be reported to protect staff from unfounded allegations. The memorandum must
establish the identity of all involved in the pat search; i.e., inmates, staff, and others; and the
circumstances giving rise to the search.
Random pat searches remain a primary security and management tool for the detection of
contraband. Electronic devices will be used to supplement these efforts, as negotiated locally,
taking population size, security level, facility mission, etc., into account; however, electronic
searches are not substitutes for pat searches.
Post assignments may not be restricted on the basis of gender. Institutions will evaluate
operational concerns consistent with collective bargaining obligations, the Master Agreement,
and other laws, rules, and regulations. The agency will continue to comply with Title VII and
other Equal Employment Opportunity Commission authorities in implementing this policy.

(2) Transgender Inmates. For purposes of pat searching, inmates will be pat-searched in
accordance with the gender of the institution, or housing assignment, in which they are assigned.
Transgender inmates may request an exception. The exception must be pre-authorized by the
Warden, after consultation with staff from Health Services, Psychology Services, Unit
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing information: this type. 3
Management, and Correctional Services. Exceptions must be specifically described (e.g., "pat
search only by female staff'), clearly communicated to relevant staff through a memorandum,
and reflected in SENTRY (or other Bureau database: e.g.. posted picture file). Inmates should be
provided a personal identifier (e.g., notation on commissary card. etc.) that indicates their
individual exception. to be carried at all times and presented to staff prior to pat searches.

(3) Conducting Pat Searches. Staff are trained how to conduct pat searches during
Introduction to Correctional Techniques. Annual Training. a Sallyport video titled "Inmate Pat
Search," and written policy.

c. Visual search. A visual inspection of all body surfaces and body cavities.
Any visual search shall be conducted and documented in the appropriate visual search log book.
as outlined in the Program Statement Correctional Services Manual.

(1) Staff may conduct a visual search where there is reasonable belief that
contraband may be concealed on the person, or a good opportunity for
concealment has occurred. For example, placement in a special housing unit
(see 28 CFR 541, subpart B), leaving the institution, or re-entry into an institution
after contact with the public (after a community trip, court transfer, or after a
"contact" visit in a visiting room) is sufficient to justify a visual search. The
visual search shall be made in a manner designed to assure as much privacy to
the inmate as practicable.
28 CFR 541. subpart B. refers to the Program Statement Special Housing Units. Except in
minimum security institutions. inmates must undergo a visual search when leaving the
institution, for whatever reason (even when being released). Examples of other situations
requiring visual searches include:
■ Processing an inmate into an institution through Receiving and Discharge.
■ Placing an inmate in the Control Unit.
■ Conducting periodic visual searches of inmates returning from outside work details.

(2) Staff of the same sex as the inmate shall make the search, except where
circumstances are such that delay would mean the likely loss of contraband.
Where staff of the opposite sex makes a visual search, staff shall document the
reasons for the opposite sex search in the inmate's central file.
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing infonnation: this type. 4
While post assignments may not be restricted on the basis of sex, a staff member may not
perform routine visual searches of inmates of the opposite sex, such as could be required by
assignment to such posts as the visiting room and receiving and discharge units.

d. Digital or simple instrument search. Inspection for contraband or any other
foreign item in a body cavity of an inmate by use of fingers or simple instruments,
such as an otoscope, tongue blade, short nasal speculum, and simple forceps. A
digital or simple instrument search may be conducted only by designated
qualified health personnel (for example, physicians, physician assistants, and
nurses) upon approval of the Warden or Acting Warden and only if the Warden or
Acting Warden or has reasonable belief that an inmate is concealing contraband
in or on his person. If located, the contraband or foreign item may be removed
immediately by medical staff if such removal can easily be effected by use of
fingers or the simple instruments referred to above.
Staff shall document all digital and simple instrument searches and the reasons for the searches
in the inmate's central file.
Persons of the opposite sex from the inmate may not observe the digital or simple instrument
search.
To document the search staff shall use the Search for Contraband: Digital, Simple Instrument, X-
Ray Examination form (BP-A0313).

(1) Staff shall solicit the inmate's written consent prior to conducting a digital or
simple instrument search. However, the inmate's consent is not required.

(2) Staff may not conduct a digital or simple instrument search if it is likely to
result in physical injury to the inmate.

3. CLOSE OBSERVATION ("DRY CELL" STATUS)
§552.12 Close observation.
When there is reasonable belief that an inmate has ingested contraband or
concealed contraband in a body cavity and the methods of search specified in
§552.11 are inappropriate or likely to result in physical injury to the inmate, the
Warden or designee may authorize the placement of an inmate in a room or cell
for the purpose of staff's closely observing that inmate until the inmate has
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing infonnation: this type. 5
voided the contraband or until sufficient time has elapsed to preclude the
possibility that the inmate is concealing contraband.
Such placement is commonly referred to as "dry cell" status. Section 552.11 refers to Section 2
of this Program Statement.
■ Regular duty hours. The Warden or designee may authorize dry cell status.
■ Other times. The Warden's designee, ordinarily the Operations Lieutenant, in consultation
with the Duty Officer and Administrative Duty Officer, may authorize dry cell status.
Dry cell status is often appropriate when staff believe an inmate has ingested contraband.
Ordinarily, when staff believe that a female inmate has concealed contraband in her vagina, dry
cell status is not the appropriate search method, since it is possible for her to thus conceal
contraband for an extended period of time.
Ordinarily, an inmate of either gender will not be able to conceal contraband in his/her anal
cavity for an extended period of time.

a. The length of close observation status will be determined on an individual
basis. Ordinarily, the Captain, in consultation with qualified health personnel,
shall determine when termination is appropriate. The status of an inmate under
close observation for as long as three days must be reviewed by the Segregation
Review Official according to the provisions in §541.22(c) of this chapter, and the
initial SRO review conducted within three work days shall be a formal hearing.
Maintaining an inmate under close observation beyond seven days requires
approval of the Warden, who makes this decision in consultation with the Captain
and qualified health personnel.

Section 541.22 (c) refers to Section 4 of the Program Statement Special Housing Units. That
section, which applies to review of inmates housed in administrative detention, requires that the
SRO conduct a record review within three work days; however, for an inmate in dry cell
status, a formal in-person hearing is required.
Since it is unlikely that the objective of dry cell status will not be achieved within seven days,
prior approval of the Warden, in consultation with the Captain and appropriate medical staff,
is required to continue dry cell status beyond seven days.

b. The supervising staff member shall be the same sex as the inmate and shall
maintain complete and constant visual supervision of the inmate.
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing information: this type. 6
The inmate shall never be allowed freedom to move around unsupervised, or be given the
opportunity to dispose of any objects he/she may be concealing.

(1) The supervising staff member shall be issued a portable radio and flashlight.
(2) A daily log and Special Housing Unit Record shall be maintained on each inmate in dry cell
status.

(3) Watch calls shall be made by radio.
(4) The Lieutenant shall ensure staff have reviewed the Post Orders prior to assuming the post.
If it is necessary for the staff member to leave the area, the Operations Lieutenant shall provide a
relief person. The Operations Lieutenant shall brief that person of his/her responsibilities. The
inmate must not be left unattended during the relief period.

(5) Trash may not be allowed to accumulate, and each item shall be thoroughly searched before
disposal.
(6) The inmate is to be given a visual search prior to placement in the room and issued a jump
suit (or other suitable loose-fitting clothing). The inmate is to be given a visual search and the
inmate's living area must be thoroughly searched at least once each shift, being careful not to set
a pattern. Prior to each search, the Operations Lieutenant must be notified and a second person
provided for inmate supervision.

(7) Staff shall notify the Operations Lieutenant when contraband is found. The staff member
shall secure the contraband in a plastic evidence bag, and proper documentation and chain of
evidence shall be maintained.

c. The supervisor responsible for initiating the close observation watch shall
advise the inmate of the conditions and of what is expected.
Documentation of this notification is to be made through the Administrative Detention Order
form (BP-A0308).

(1) The inmate shall be required to provide a urine sample within two hours of
placement under close observation in accordance with the provisions of §550.30
of this chapter on urine surveillance. A second urine sample is required prior to
releasing the inmate from close observation.
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing information: this type. 7
§ 550.30 of this chapter refers to the Program Statement Urine Surveillance and Narcotic
Identification.

(2) The light will be kept on at all times.
(3) No inmate under close observation status may be allowed to come into
contact with another inmate.

(4) The inmate ordinarily may not be allowed personal property while under close
observation status, except legal and personal mail and a reasonable amount of
legal materials when requested. Personal hygiene items will be controlled by
staff.

(5) When the inmate is lying on a bed, the inmate shall be required to lie on top of
the mattress in full view, weather and room temperature permitting. When
necessary for the inmate to use cover, hands must remain visible at all times so
that staff can observe any attempt to move contraband.
An inmate might attempt to remove and/or insert contraband from or into a body cavity, so it is
important to constantly observe his/her hands.

(6) Due to security concerns, the inmate ordinarily may not be permitted
recreation outside of the cell.

(7) The inmate is to be served the same meals as those served to the general
population unless medically contraindicated.
All meals are to be inspected for contraband prior to delivery to the inmate. Any food remaining
after the meal, as well as the utensils and tray. are to be thoroughly inspected before being sent
back to Food Service.

(8) No medications may be given to the inmate except for those prescribed and
given by hospital personnel. No laxatives may be given except natural laxatives,
i.e., coffee, prune juice, etc.

(9) When the inmate needs to urinate and/or defecate, the inmate will be
furnished an empty hospital bed pan.
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing infonnation: this type. 8
Staff supervising the inmate shall notify the Operations Lieutenant, who shall furnish a second
staff member for supervision. Using rubber gloves and forceps or a tongue depressor, staff shall
closely inspect the results to ascertain whether any contraband is present.

(10) When the inmate requests to shave, to brush teeth, or other such request, a
wash pan and container of water is to be provided for use in the cell.

(11) Institution staff shall be available to the inmate upon request, within reason
and within the bounds of security concerns.

d. Each Captain shall develop Post Orders providing guidance to staff supervising an inmate on
dry cell status. Consideration should be given to the use of video camera during the dry cell
status.

e. Any questions, emergency, or other situation that arises shall immediately be brought to the
attention of the Operations Lieutenant. It is the supervising employee's responsibility to ensure
the inmate does not dispose of any concealed item, or to allow an activity that would allow the
inmate access to it, thereby jeopardizing the security and good order of the institution, staff, and
inmates.

f. It is recommended that one or more rooms or cells be identified as dry cells that meet the
following requirements:
■ The room should be free of hiding places and be equipped with only a bed.
■ Doors should have proper observation panels to protect staff and to allow unobstructed
observation.
■ Windows in the dry cell should have a security screen to prevent loss of contraband.
■ If the designated area is equipped with a toilet and/or sink, the water to the cell should be
shut off, and removed prior to the inmate's being allowed into the mom. The water should
remain off for the duration of the dry cell process.
■ Prior to placement of an inmate in dry cell status, the room to be used should be completely
searched and determined to be free of contraband. Potential hiding places, if any, for the
contraband should be noted.
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing information: this type. 9

4. MEDICAL X-RAY DEVICE, MAJOR INSTRUMENT, OR SURGICAL INTRUSION
§ 552.13 Medical x-ray device, major instrument, or surgical intrusion.

a. The institution physician may authorize use of a major instrument (including
anoscope or vaginal speculum) or surgical intrusion for medical reasons only,
with the inmate's consent.
The use of a fluoroscope. major instrument, or surgical intrusion may be authorized only for
medical reasons. The inmate's consent is needed prior to this use.

b. The institution physician may authorize use of a medical x-ray device for
medical reasons and only with the consent of the inmate. When there exists no
reasonable alternative, and an examination using a medical x-ray device is
determined necessary for the security, good order, or discipline of the institution,
the Warden, upon approval of the Regional Director, may authorize the institution
physician to order a non -repetitive examination using a medical x-ray device for
the purpose of determining if contraband is concealed in or on the inmate (for
example: in a cast or body cavity). The examination using a medical x-ray device
may not be performed if it is determined by the institution physician that it is
likely to result in serious or lasting medical injury or harm to the inmate. Staff
shall place documentation of the examination and the reasons for the
examination in the inmate's central file and medical file.
For purposes of this rule. theoretical harm that might result from a single X-ray exposure does
not constitute a situation likely to result in serious or lasting medical injury or harm to the
inmate.

(1) The Warden and Regional Director or persons officially acting in that capacity
may not redelegate the authority to approve an examination using medical x-ray
device for the purpose of determining if contraband is present. An Acting
Warden or Acting Regional Director may, however, perform this function.
When the case requires the Warden's approval. and the situation occurs when neither the Warden
or Acting Warden is available, the Institution Duty Officer or Administrative Duty Officer
should be contacted. Upon determining that an X-ray examination appears warranted. the Duty
Officer is to contact the Regional Director or Acting Regional Director for an approval to
conduct the examination.
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing infommtion: this type. 10
A copy of the completed BP-A0313 shall be forwarded to the Regional Director who authorized
the search.

(2) Staff shall solicit the inmate's consent prior to an examination using a
medical x-ray device. However, the inmate's consent is not required.

c. The Warden may direct searches of inanimate objects using a medical x-ray
device where the inmate is not exposed.
When the case requires the Warden's approval, and the situation occurs when the Warden is not
available, this function may be performed by the Acting Warden, Institution Duty Officer, or
Administrative Duty Officer. The authority is not delegated to any other staff member.
Procedures for disposition of contraband found shall be developed locally and in accordance
with the FBI and U.S. Attorney requirements for possible prosecution.

5. SEARCH OF INMATE HOUSING AND WORK AREAS
§552.14 Search of inmate housing and work areas.
a. Staff may search an inmate's housing and work area, and personal items
contained within those areas, without notice to or prior approval from the inmate
and without the inmate's presence.
Searches of housing units and of work areas shall be completed as outlined in the Program
Statement Correctional Services Manual. Each institution shall establish procedures to ensure
all housing units and work areas are searched routinely, but irregularly, since such inspections
are primarily designed to:
■ Detect contraband.
■ Prevent escapes.
■ Maintain sanitary standards.
■ Eliminate fire and safety hazards.
When there is a question of legitimacy of some religious article, the Chaplain should be
consulted.
Staff shall maintain written documentation of each housing unit search within the individual
housing unit. Work areas (including industries) shall be searched each work day by shop
supervisors, and these inspections shall be supplemented with periodic searches by regular
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing information: this type. 11
search teams. Documentation of daily searches is not required; however, these should be
informally monitored to ensure compliance. The Captain shall maintain documentation of search
team inspections.

b. Staff conducting the search shall leave the housing or work area as nearly as
practicable in its original order.

6. AGENCY ACA ACCREDITATION PROVISIONS
(See the Program Statement Directives Management Manual, Section 2.5 & 10.3.)
■ American Correctional Association 4ih Edition Standards for Adult Correctional Institutions:
4-4192, 4-4193, 4-194, 4-4282.
■ American Correctional Association 4th Edition Standards for Adult Local Detention
Facilities: 4-ALDF-6C-19, 4-ALDF-2C-01, 4-ALDF-2C-01, 4-ADLF-2C-05,
4-ALDF-2C-03.
■ American Correctional Association, 2nd Edition Standards for the Administration of
Correctional Agencies: 2-CO-3A-01.
REFERENCES
Program Statements
P5270.10 Special Housing Units (7/29/11)
P5500.11 Correctional Services Manual (3/31/15)
P6060.08 Urine Surveillance and Narcotic Identification (3/8/01)
Federal Regulations
Rules cited in this Program Statement are contained in 28 CFR §§ 552.10 through 552.14.
BOP Fonns
BP-A0308 Administrative Detention Order
BP-A0313 Search for Contraband: Digital, Simple Instrument, X-Ray Examination
Records Retention Requirements
Requirements and retention guidance for records and information applicable to this program are
available in the Records and Information Disposition Schedule (RIDS) on Sallyport.
P5521.06 6/4/2015 Federal Regulations from 28 CFR: this type. Implementing information: this type. 12
EFTA00173569 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about hack of FBI Epstein files repository by foreign actor
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
I, Aaron E. Spivack, having been duly sworn by Supervisory
Special Agent (SSA) Dannie W. Price, Jr., hereby make the
following statement to SSA Price and SSA Matthew A. Zavala on
01/26/2024 and SSA Price and SSA Claudia Dubravetz on
08/08/2024, whom I know to be SSAs of the Federal Bureau of
Investigation (FBI), assigned to the Inspection Division (INSD)
at the time of my statement. My attorney, Richard J. Roberson,
Jr., was present during my statement on both occasions, via
telephone. This statement took place over a two-day period. The
statement initiated on 01/26/2024, and again on 08/08/2024,
after additional allegations were added:
I entered on duty (EOD) on 02/21/2006, as an Intelligence
Analyst (IA). I EOD on 10/08/2008, as a Special Agent (SA) and I
am currently assigned to the New York Field Office (NYFO) in
that capacity.
I understand that this is an internal investigation
regarding an allegation that Special Agent Aaron E Spivack
improperly stored digital evidence at his residence in violation
of 1.6- Investigative Deficiency- Improper Handling of Property
in the Care, Custody, or Control of the Government. On
10/30/2023 the following expanded allegations were added:
Special Agent Aaron E. Spivack improperly handled, documented,
and stored digital evidence and failed to secure CSAM within
policy, resulting in a cyber intrusion in violation of 1.6-
Investigative Deficiency- Improper Handling of Property in the
Care, Custody, or Control of the Government and 5.17- Security
Violation- Failure to Secure sensitive Equipment/ Materials. On
02/07/2024 the following expanded allegations were added:
Special Agent Aaron E. Spivack exceeded the limits of his
authority by contracting an outside company to develop computer
software on behalf of the FBI in violation of 2.8 Misuse of
Position and 5.23 Violation of Miscellaneous Rules/Regulations.
I have been further advised of my rights and
responsibilities in connection with this inquiry as set forth on
a "Warning and Assurance to Employee Required to Provide
Information" form FD-645 which I have read and signed. I
understand from my review of the FD-645 that should : refuse to
answer or fail to reply fully and truthfully during this
interview, I can expect to be dismissed from the rolls of the
FBI.
I am currently assigned to CT-25, which is a hybrid
Domestic Terrorism and Child Exploitation squad. I was assigned
to CY-3 in May 2010 and officially named on the squad in July
2010. This was when Innocent Images was combined with Cyber. C-
20 was the Human Trafficking (HT) squad at the time. I believe
it was 2015 when Violent Crimes Against Children (VCAC) and HT
were combined under C-20. The squad is split and has the HT side
and the VCAC side . Agents primarily work
their assigned violations, but we come together as a squad for
operations.
I believe Digital Extraction Technician (DExT) training was
opened to VCAC Agents in 2012. Scott Le9ford was my instructor
for DExT. and led
the Cyber Action Team (CAT). I believe at least three or four of
us initially received DExT training, but I think all of us
eventually were trained. However, once the child exploitation
program moved from the Cyber Division to the Criminal Division,
that changed. The funding we received through the Criminal
Division was significantly less than what we received through
Cyber Division, so the DExT program was no longer able to put on
as many classes and certify as many people as it had before. By
the time of the intrusion that forms the basis of this internal
inquiry, only about half of the "child exploitation" Agents on
my squad were DExT certified. This is while we were still with
CY-3. We got certified because the Computer Analysis Response
Team (CART) was long overburdened, and not familiar with the
nuances of the child exploitation violation, such as the types
of programs used by offenders, the vernaculars, etc.
I MIrong
lighds -on"
the hands of the offenders the FBI waea
This was around the same time Agents working
other violations began to see an increase in the collection and
reliance of digital evidence. As DExTs, we were encouraged, and
in some cases I believe required, to assist CART with their
backlog by conducting DExT extractions for other squads. the
time—the ',At, and el.." ..rq
with thcir invcctigations. The other reason was to eliminate the
lag time in searching evidence and identifying contact offenders
(offenders who physically exploited or physically assaulted
children) sooner.
VCAC investigations are different than other FBI
investigations since VCAC usually does a search warrant at the
beginning of our investigations, where other squads do them last
to complete their investigations.
Mike Osborn was a Unit Chief (UC) of the Crimes Against
Children Human Trafficking Unit (CACHTU) at FBI Headquarters
(HQ) and eventually an Assistant Special Agent in Charge (ASAC)
at NYFO. He was a huge proponent of DExT. Being DExT trained
allowed us to conduct our own data extractions faster, but more
importantly; it allowed for a faster and more efficient way of
identifying contact, or "hands-on", offenders and, thus, rescue
child victims of sexual abuse
victimized.
before they could be further
After becoming DExT certified, we received DExT equipment
that allowed us to image, process, and better review the digital
files. The DExT training allowed us to better use FBI analytical
programs to review digital evidence. Being DExT certified
allowed us to assist CART by offering an alternative for other
squads to use for data extractions. At the time, CART was not
located in the NYFO Headquarters City (HOC). CART was located in
Moonachie, New Jersey. It could take an hour to get to the CART
lab. CART evidence reviews needed to take place there. It could
take all day. CART eventually moved to NYFO, HOC.
The volume of data extractions we took on lessened the
burden on CART. At least in New York, CART only had one or two a
few-examiners who could handle data extractions immediately, and
almost certainly none who could respond after hours or on
weekends. eeete-e4-tbeft-weerld-delery-tbeer
Since we dealt with child victims, it was, and is,
imperative that the digital evidence be processed immediately.
In nearly every child exploitation investigation the digital
evidence is quite literally the evidence to prove the crime and
without a prompt review, there is no probable cause to effect an
arrest, putting the lives of child victims in continued danger.
u- Cel f-cli-g thut a pivean .,h—owed a child ...0u4dradt—be
arrested  becaldec we did not have the pr per technical
capabilities.  It is that very risk, the risk of continued abuse,
that has prompted the FBI to enact new policies requiring
expeditious investigation into allegations of child
exploitation. This includes the expeditious review of evidence.
Prior to the DExT training, on-sight forensics was not
really a practice. We had to take digital evidence back to the
office to view it and we relied more on the post search
interview. After a search, we had to go back and arrest an
offender once we found the evidence. This made for a
significantly more dangerous arrest because the offenders knew
we were coming. There was also the potential for offender
suicide. We had three offender suicides that I can recall. There
was also concern there could be a delay in reviewing evidence
that, if seen sooner, would allow us to remove a child from
harm's way.
NYFO SAs Linh Phung, Tommy Thompson, Mitch Thompson, and I
were DExT trained. SA Cindy Wolff (aka Cindy Dye) was also DExT
trained. Cindy was the last to be trained
At the time, I was the most junior Agent
on the squad. Before being DExT trained, all of our digital
evidence was submitted to CART for data extractions, imaging,
and processing. We did have access to CAIR, a forensic tool for
data review  , but the program was slow, not capable of
handling large evidence reviews, did not work all that well, and
did not do what we in the child exploitation program needed it
to do.
was no secret and was widely known, and
one of the reasons for the creation of the autonomous DExT labs.
Additi sally having t rely on CART f r evidence  pr cecsing, and
Lie seta
evidence  review.
After collecting digital evidence, I would enter the
digital evidence into the Evidence Control Unit (ECU) and get a
1B evidence number assigned. I would then enter a CART request
with a description of what forensic examinations I needed to be
performed and information on the device that needed to be
extracted. Then I would submit it to CART. It could take a day
or two to get the evidence to CART and the amount of time it
would take CART to process the evidence varied. It could take
weeks or months. Once it was extracted, CART would process it in
the Forensic Tool Kit (FTK). We could review the data on CAIR or
go to Moonachie to review it. Everyone on the squad, for the
most part, chose to go to Moonachie. CART Digital Forensic
Examiners Stephen Flatley and Carlos Koo eventually set up a
spot in NYFO, HQC to do data extractions.
Even after receiving DExT training, we used CART for things
like very large d unl ado media dumps/extractions and encrypted
files. We also used them to help us with understanding what some
of the digital evidence was. I believe CART may have provided us
a digital copy of the data extraction and I think it may have
been on DVD. It would have been accessible on operational Wide
inacc+—Area Network (OpLAN - OPWAN) as well. I do not recall what
we did with the copies on DVD. CART may have checked them into
evidence and provided a working copy. The DExT trained Agents
would do data dumps on everything we could like hard drives,
loose media, and thumb drives. All telephones we seized
initially still needed to go to CART for processing.
In 2015, generally if it was a device we could image, we
would follow this process. We would use write blockers to assure
we did not accidentally manipulate the original data. We would
create an image of our evidence, sometimes we would use another
hard drive. We imaged and processed the data. We had some hard
drives but I am not sure where they came from. I believe HQ sent
us a box of hard drives. I also believe CART may have given us
some as well.
We used a forensic duplicator called 13leek—Ben a TD3, and
later a TX-1 as well as Fit Imager, to image a the device onto a
hard drive and make the derivative evidence. We would then make
a working copy image off of the derivative evidence. We would
work off the working copy.
I am pretty sure the derivative evidence was cataloged and
placed in the Evidence Control Room (ECR) if that was the
policy, but if that was not the policy we
that.
would not have done
The DExT Program provided us with Redundant Array of
Independent Disks (RAIDS). These RAIDS were to be used to house
our working copy evidence images. Once we ran out of hard drives
for derivative evidence, we were instructed to use the RAIDS. I
believe these instructions were provided by HQ, either our
Program Manager (PM), the DExT PM, or both. I wao told by ,
squedmate—er—a—swpervistr—teirmtge—thrdatt—tep—a—Reawftelent—krralp
f Independent  Dicks (RAID) tower.
Typically, the person running a Group I or Group II
Undercover Operation COCO) and the squad SSA would be the people
who communicated with HQ for resources. I recall in 2015, I sent
an email to II IIILWee the case
Group g, asking for some fl acity Ewe—tra
hard drives with our remaining Group II funds. At the
time we were still merged with Cyber. When we moved to the
Criminal Division, our funds were wiped out.
Linh Phung left NYFO and became a DExT PM. She would
complain about a lack of funding. I was running out of hard
drive space for derivative evidence and of storage space in
general. The PMs told us buying hard drives in bulk was a
problem. The stores had a capacity limit. I would purchase the
drives on Amazon, like I was instructed to do by HQ, until my
covert account was shut down by Amazon since the purchasing of
large quantities of hard drives was flagged as suspicious. We
were purchasing from New Egg, like I was instructed to do by HQ,
specifically SSA Heath Graves who was the DExT PM, who could
sell bulk (10 or more hard drives), but I was later told by
someone in the procurement unit we could not use New Egg fer
purchascc. I went to CART who gave us what hard drives they
could spare. I have various correspondence with HQ advising
there was a lack of funding. This not only affected us getting
hard drives, but also various other things. Phung provided us
with more RAID towers for storage, and instructed us to use the
storage to meet our needs, which included the creation of
derivative and working copy evidence.
I also learned
the purchase of the
or was allocated to
who was the DExT PM
DExT PM. After the
funds were available, but not designated for
hard drives. Money III either was not there
something else. I spoke with Heath Graves
and then Jim Harrison who is the current
Inspection that was related to the C-20
computer lab cyber intrusion, the squad received some hard
drives, and then was denied funds for hard drives from CACHTU
who told us to go to CART. CART then referred us back to CACHTU.
I worked with someone from the Laboratory Division to help
figure out another process. I believed it was a waste of money
and resources to purchase expensive hard drives just to get
destroyed. I spoke with a UC about
derivative storage that was stand alone. The UC liked the
suggestion.
In 2018 I did a five-week TDY at CACHTU. My former SSA,
Sean Watson, was the UC there. My job was to call every VCAC
eq-"L —kid, Group I and Group II UCO Case Agent and ask
questions about the issues they were having and to provide
recommendations on how to better the program, how CACHTU could
better assist the field, things that needed improvement, etc. I
creating reusable virtual
that
.1-1" -f DE-T .,t..£f, 1,Lt that
were not, and generally  that there wac a lack of training,
guidance, direction, and perc IIH.- within the program. I drafted
a summary on the calls I made and created a section for
complaints from the field in reference to DExT, and provided my
assessment to CACHTU leadership.
This same assessment, as well as additional details were
also provided to Bryan Vorndran, who was the Deputy Assistant
Director (DAD) who covered child exploitation,
This
came as DAD Vorndran separately requested a working group of
Subject Matter Experts (SMEs) to address the needs of the VCAC
program. I explained to him how we had equipment and training
needs, and provided my assessment both orally and in several
documents.
In 2018 I sent an email
e
efwEJERTI.
XDX4L.II.sent  a
EP
appropriate money for equipment,
I talked about the need to
Others and I made it very clear to HQ that we
did not have hard drives. Every now and then they would send us
some and every now and then they would send funds, but nothing
was consistent. I also informed my SSA of the need for hard
drives. I was aware he knew we needed them and there were no
funds. Other Agents were dealing with the same issues. It has
been, and continues to be, the practice of VCAC Agents to create
derivative copies of original evidence if derivative hard drives
are available. However, given the long history of not receiving
either the hard drives or the funds to purchase them, VCAC
Agents have been left with no alternative but to store their
derivative evidence on local storage. If we had hard driven t•
attltrbti—aat4vat+n —t-oP4e$7""e —Iteekl—Felteellt-ce'F'9-411—evi'cienee-rI4
we didn't, we wouldn't.
In 2017 I began to gain a voice among many FBI Child
Exploitation circles. I took over our squad's Group II ?COMM
ry
in front of the
•
are  every uHIIIIIIII
six Lt ye would
a Group I, it IIIII also III
Assistant Director During the I brought up the
funding issues. In the funding section we discussed what we
spent and what we anticipated to spend. Thag.4.49.50.1
program compared to the four years prior. This meant an increase
of approximately 2000 undercover sessions in the same four-year
span. More significantly, however, was how I tasked undercovers
and provided direction to ensure the program worked to identify
the most vulnerable of the exploited children; and set out to
rescue them. The results cannot be overstated in that the lives
of hundreds of children were saved. While I am personally
responsible for saving the lives of hundreds, many hundreds, if
not thousands, more were saved because of how I managed and
a the child exploitation program.
The pracLace ut creat.:flg de.nvaLlve evidence copies:
separate hard drives to be checked into evidence was dependent
upon whether or not we were provided funds to purchase the
drives or the drives themselves. Early on, when VCAC fell under
the Cyber Division, we had regular access to these drives, but
when the program was moved into the Criminal Division that
changed. Despite repeated requests, as well as having alerted
everyone within the chain of command, we were told to figure it
out. We had been advised that if derivative hard drives were not
available, to store the derivative evidence on our local
storage, which is what we did
f-- C 20 ehertrei—te—ftet—eddi-nrelet-i-yetiana
c picc t evidence,  but it happened. It may have been in 2016 or
2017 and possibly happened because we did not have hard drives.
I believe we were initially getting some hard drives from
DExT after completing the certification course. DExT Slowly went
to no longer providing hard drives to new DExT certified agents
at all. I do not know what they are teaching about digital
evidence storage in DExT or how to get drives, but I know from
other Agents who have attended the DExT training more recently
that guidance has still been to seek funding from CACHTU, who
again has been stating they do not have the funds.
Until approximately February 2023, the NYFO did not have a
designated Information System Security Officer ( SSO). This is
a required position, and I think it being left unfilled
exacerbated many of the problems that are discussed herein.
As recently as December 2023, my squad has attempted to get
funds for derivative hard drives. On a couple of occasions the
funds were obligated, however in other requests the funds were
not. In those requests CACHTU stated, via email, that there were
no longer funds for the drives and that the squad should inquire
with CART to obtain them. Subsequently, CART denied the request
as they too needed their hard drives. Even after the intrusion
and the negative attention we received regarding derivative
evidence hard drives, the squad was again put in a position
where they were unable to comply with policy because the FBI
would not provide the requisite hard drives or funding needed to
be compliant. When the squad had been able in some instances to
use case funds to make a hard drive purchase, the newly-
appointed ISSO found the drives to be in violation of policy
since the hard drives themselves were not manufactured in the
United States. This, again, put the squad in an impossible
situation with no alternatives being offered. It was also quite
ridiculous as it is likely that none of our computer equipment
is manufactured in the United States.
Whs., fle Nee
funds t get hard drivec, it vac denied by cccurity  bccaucc they
rt.,t en.ed- tb.. UGA
After the process changed, we would image the original
evidence onto the RAID Storage or Network Attached Storage
(NAS). At times I would create a second copy. If I made a second
copy, I would use one as the Main copy and the other was the
Working copy. If I did one copy, that one would be used as the
Working copy. At times I would make multiple Working copies.
I wee—personally made derivative copies whenever I was
afforded with the requisite hard drives. However, just because I
did not always receive the drives did not mean my VCAC
investigations ceased. Of course, I as well as others, still had
to adapt and overcome and felt that while I may not have been
able to create derivative copies for all of the evidence, the
reasons for that were well documented and out of my control. III
iLto the lack of
for
fro.
a rock
dership
stored dl  at
ducted
And
like
ies"
net mak1aq
derivative  c pies. -nd did n t have the rcc urccc to d c and I
did not kn w what cloc t d .
Throughout most of its existence e C-20 lab was Internet
connected. One or two of the DExT machines were connected to the
Internet, but we were "stand-alone" and not connected to any FBI
systems. Additionally, our lab was "missattributed" and able to
be used in covert capacities and to access websites that could
contain Child Sexual Abuse Material (CSAM). I -ecelled L-1.4
inctructcd  that the DExT w rk stati a was ctand al nc.
Initially, in approximately 2012, the C-20 lab was not connected
to the Internet, but at the time we had little reason outside of
software updates to be connected to the Internet. Several years
later that changed as the advancement in our software and
capabilities grew, requiring our computers to be InternetH
connected. The only guidance or direction
time was that our Internet -connected DExT
connected to a FBI network, and as far as
we received at the
computers not be
I have always been
aware that is the only policy on the matter as well. Even FBI HQ
implemented investigative steps that required DExT labs to be
Internethconnected, such as the method that was used to transmit
CSAM to the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children,,
whereas previously it had been to do so via a storage media.
Later, the FBI created the "SIFTS" program which
portal for CSAM transmission. I.. 2012 it. —ea. W..
receiving  programs  that needed  interact  access-.
In approximately 2022, CACHTU advised the field that the
licensing method for one of our most used programs, "Axiom", was
moving from dongle-based to cloud-based. CACHTU wanted to pilot
the cloud-based method and elicited the assistance of five or
six VCAC squads from across the FBI to do so, one of which wee
our squad. This pilot program, which began prior to our
intrusion and continued well after, required the DExT computers
to be connected to the Internet. The C 20 lab was pil ting a
edeed beacd Arm., 11----iag. It allowed us to check out a
license when we needed to. In order to do so, we needed to stay
was an online
on the Internet to use it. There was some level of security
provided by the switch box and some on the NAS itself.
The computers, NAS, and RAID tower storage that contained
CSAM were then all connected to the internet. We received
guidance from CACHTU, specifically from the DExT PMs, to disable
the antivirus to use the Axiom since the antivirus would flag
the program. I believe this came from Tommy, Heath, CART, and
others. Squad C-20 did not know how to set up the Internet and
the switch box. we reached out to computer scientists and CART
and received some help. I do not know anything about networking
and how to set up networks. The Computer Scientists also did not
know. I believe someone from the Operational Technology Division
(OTD) told me to Google it. Networking is not a DExT function
and is not in my skill set, so I did not even know what
questions to ask. The off-the-shelf security that was in place
kas what we were using. I and the squad asked everyone we could
think of for help - CART, the Computer Scientists, OTD, the
Office of the Chief Information Officer (OCIO), Management
Information Systems (MIS) , etc. - however, all were of no help.
Computer Scientist Jim Walsh helped us set up some of the
equipment. Christian Idsola from CART also helped, as did
another CART employee whose name I cannot recall. Anthony
Broderick who is the NYFO CART networking guy was asked for
help. He told me to read the manuals and said he did not have
Connented[DIVII: ShouldlmnsomeNnth
almthmvthelmpedionalma-ofwhkhthechamcs
amlikelydaivedfrom-mknomeasasymmu
admMisumorAwanuopMmiliatoutulmnNOTA
cannot be viewed fromthesame lens as someone who
isasysadmin
DW
2024-09-16 21:33:00
Commented f.IR2RI j: Yes! I'm glad you
remembered that. Please add.
Jim Roberson
2024-09-17 10:41:00
the bandwidth to support us. These communications, along with
many others, occurred in writing via email and I can provide
them to investigators
Our request was simple - to network the few standalone
computers in our lab. However, no responsible entity within the
FBI would assist, so we had to reach out to friends and
colleagues to help on their own. While their help was valuable,
none of our volunteered help came from anyone who was a network
or systems administrator, and the FBI's network or system
administrators would not assist. The various networking and
system administrative units in the FBI handle FBI networks, and
the few that handle covert/misattributed networks do not handle
CSAM networks. Despite the irrelevance of the latter from a
technical perspective, CSAM is off putting and no one wanted to
assist and CACHTU did not know what to do. In fact, CACHTU was
aware that this was an issue affecting so many other FBI Offices
that it encouraged us to find the solution so that it could be
emulated across the other VCAC DExT labs.
In our desperation to find someone with a networking/system
administrator background to help us, we put out a Confidential
Human Source (CHS)canvass for assistance with our network
through our CHS Coordinator. I also reached out to OTD, and
Counterterrorism Division (CTD) Cyber looked at our network and
could not figure it out. We had a Counterterrorism (CT) CHS come
over and look at the network and he/she advised networking was
not his/her specialty. The CHS was a former contractor for the
FBI and had a TS clearance. This occurred when the lab was on
the 9th floor prior to it getting flooded.
After the 9th floor lab flooded, some of the equipment was
replaced by CACHTU and CART was able to salvage some of the
equipment. We moved the C-20 lab to the 10th floor in December
2020. I received approval on 12/22/2020 to purchase switches,
NASs, cables, and hard drives. This equipment was purchased with
$34,000 in CACHTU funding, which also supplied the Long Island
Resident Agency (RA) with similar equipment.
CACHTU PM Leslie was a former NYFO Agent and knew
about these issues.
During the COVID pandemic there were three of us from my
squad who came to the office on a regular basis; myself, SA Matt
Deragon, and SA Brian Gander. The guidance, however, was to work
from home. The C-20 SSA at the time was Sean Watson. SSA Watson
provided guidance to work from home, in addition to the guidance
pushed by the FBI Director, our II, and others in FBI
management. This guidance included conducting limited forensics
from home, and CACHTU pushed out to the field temporary AXIOM
licenses for the sole purpose of conducting limited forensic
reviews from home. AXIOM gave everyone  limited access t work
4-aem—hame-r However, since the bulk of my forensic reviews meant
reviewing CSAM, I came into the office almost I wac in tho
ee—i-n—e4temoo daily to do CSAM reviews. This is a fact and
can be corroborated by SAs Deragon and Gander, as well as by
checking the building access logs which will show I used my
access badge to enter the building and the frequency I accessed
the building. Other work was done from home. I looked at emal
subpoena returns and reviewed working copy material that did not
include CSAM. Anything I took home was covered under policy, and
was covered under the guidance being disseminated. I have a
lureau-issued laptop computer
purposes.
that I utilized for these
At the time, I was working on three cases primarily: Robert
Hadden, Darnel Feagins, and Jacob Daskal.
To conduct the investigation for Hadden I was doing web-
based interviews from home and writing FD-302s and subpoena
returns which were all non-CSAM related. For the Daskal case I
completed a 69-page review. I took metadata-related information.
Some of it was exported from Daskal's computer, but none of it
was CSAM
For the Darnel Feagins case I was splitting the
work. I did not do CSAM-related work from home. I did not take
any storage devices home that were original or derivative
evidence. Any copies or data I took home would have been al4
working copies. If I did take data home-, it would have been a
- 1 g owpy. It would have been impossible for me to take
derivative copies home in general.
I was coming in every day to do my CSAM reviews. I au.n1J
1 g int telegram  with my micattributcd  laptop. I was taking  ml
Online  Covert Employee  (OCE) devices  home to conduct  work and my
GSA and ASAC &seat it. AveuLs b-lieved the, natl. -  '
t d it. We n w have EC authority.  Th cc Devices may have.
c-flt...:“ed CLAM mk. I do not believe I was doing any OCE work at
the time since we were instructed not to. We were trying NOT to
create a need for 'gents to have to run out on warrants gisigi
conduct Knock and Talks KT* due to unless an
emergency - BUT, I and other OCEs would do OCE work from
everywhere, including home, but all of that was covered under
I
As I was authorized to do, I would take home removable
storage devices like a hard drive or thumb drive that contained
working -copy data and/or other material that would allow me to
work from home. Some of my devices, including my FBI-issued OCE
phone and my FBI-issued and encrypted laptop, may have had CSAM
on them. As an OCE, I was authorized to do this since
communicating as an OCE with VCAC offenders requires around -the-
clock communication. This is all also covered under our Group
authority.
As for any evidence review I did from home, all was done in
accordance with policy and guidance. Any evidence I did take
home was all authorized under policy - it was not original or
derivative and was only working copies. As a matter of
logistics, I would not have been able to take home original or
derivative evidence as I do not have the technical equipment at
home to review them on my laptop. Rather, in accordance with
policy and guidance, I had copied select datasets from evidence
sources onto a thumb drive or external hard drive as working
copies, which I would review at home. The original device would
have been checked into the ECU and a copy would have been on the
C-20 lab server.
The lab server had to be connected to the Internet in order
to send CSAM to NCMEC. As mentioned previously, the official way
to send CSAM 4mageo—toINCMEC is to use the SIFTS online portal.
. They will accept hard
drives but it is not what they want, and NCMEC has been moving
to eliminate the use of hard drives altogether.
There are conflicting policies, and I brought this up while
assisting in revising the policy. I am one of, if not the only,
Court -certified expert witness for the entire FBI for child
exploitation.
During COVID, the concept of remote working was becoming a
thing. The idea came up during COVID to be able to do remote
work since that is what the FBI was beginning to promote. The
idea was continued by hearing from other members of law
enforcement, including some within the FBI, that they were using
versions of remote computing to access their forensic labs while
away, such as wee on TDY or at a conference. The intention was
not to work from home, per se, but rather to increase the
efficiency of the forensic review process. The steps of imaging
and processing evidence before it is ready for review can
sometimes take days. During this time there is little for the
DExT Agent to do while the computer is doing its processing
work. What little there is for the DExT Agent to do is often
what separates one stage of this process from the next. So if a
stage is completed on a Saturday, it will not move to the next
stage until the DExT Agent does the very few things needed to
precede, which may not happen until the following Monday. This
may then kick the process off to the next stage, but now the
Agent may have to wait several hours or longer for the next
step. In order to be more efficient and to allow this process to
begin on a Friday, for example, and be ready for review on a
Monday, the idea of remote computing was a reasonable solution.
Remote computing would have allowed €ee a .the DExT Agent to
remote in over a weekend to initiate the next stage of a process
so that the process took advantage of the weekend to conduct the
lengthy steps so that by Monday it was ready for review. The
downloading process could take a while, but the steps between
the process were three or four clicks. If I knew a hard drive
was going to take a day or so, and the next process would also
take a day or so, I did not want to go into the office just to
click a button. Especially in a densely populated area like New
York City during COVID. The idea was to be able to remote into
the server and tell the computer to move to the next step of the
process.
Our use of remote computing was reinforced I cam: by this
idea a few years ago when I attended training provided by the
International Association of Computer Investigative Specialists
(IACIS) Fre-i-esee during which we went through basic computer
forensics. I heard about law enforcement use of Remote Desktop
Protocol (RDP). I believe RDP was being used in the Bureau but I
am not sure what for purposes or on what devices. I spoke with
several others in the FBI about RDP, including the DExT PM at
the time, SSA Heath Graves, who mentioned he had either been
using it or toyed around with the idea. SSA Graves mentioned to
me that setting it up and using it was fairly easy and that all
I needed to do was follow Microsoft's directions as they were
pretty easy to follow. SSA Graves knew what my intentions were
and thought it was a great idea to be able to remote in to cut
the lag time of our processing.
I thought the C-20 system was secure. I attempted to access
the C-20 computer lab through RDP. I believed the lab's security
prevented me from remoting in. I had no idea that in so doing I
had opened the lab's RDP port and that i--thel—ftert—lerrew it had
worked. I could access the port from in the lab, but once
outside the lab, I was unable to gain access to the network.
thought the security was doing what it was supposed to. I was
later advised that the RDP configuration was mostly correct and
that I was a step or two away from having set it up successfully
and securely. latcr found  out I wao a otcp or two from making  it
ouper  occurc but did not know what I wan doing. I was not trying
to be lazy or silly, I wanted to be more efficient in the
download process. Sometimes I would start a process on a Friday
only to come in on Monday and see it crashed and needed to be
restarted. The RDP would have allowed me to see the crash and
restart the process remotely. I had the idea of tcicw rking im
COVID.
I believe enabling remote access to the C-20 computer lab
was a good initiative,
the
leaked
as in the 41
be "very gocaM IE
ect.
in the qh... place,
1 u44 :at.. My heart and mind were
ilerwas  nota 11
setting up not kOAMIIIIto  Set
repeated rea
nuntable
Mencoura
my
I thought
attempt to remote into the C-20 lab did not work because the
security settings were effective good. I asked for help, even
help with RDP, from nearly every unit in the FBI that had
anything to do with networking, DExT, etc., including CACHTU and
the DExT PMs. All I got in response was encouragement in what I
was doing, but no form of technical assistance.
I attempted to set the RDP up in either the Fall/Winter of
2022 or early 2023 De -e-he- 2022 es Jantar), 2023. The intrusion
happened on Super Bowl Sunday of 2023 and I discovered it the
very next day; on Monday.
I provided the interviewing SSAs with an outline I drafted
on 02/13/2024 of the intrusion situation which I read out loud.
I signed the copy of the outline and provided it to the
interviewing SSAs to add to my statement. The following is from
my outline. This portion of my statement is written as it
appears in the physical outline:
Seamus, below is a timeline of what transpired today,
noting that we had no idea this was a potential hack until late
this afternoon. Given the potential that someone accessed our
lab to do this, and that the issue may have been with the way we
setup our network, below is also a little insight to the many
attempts we've made to get the FBI to assist in both physical
security to the lab and to help with networking:
Today's events (approx times)
-7:30am - I arrived at the office and noticed my Talino computer
had restarted.
-7:40am - I logged in to my Talino and a txt file popped up that
said in part my network has been compromised and provided an
email address to contact. This file was in the "startup" folder
so when logging in it opened automatically. I ran my computer's
anti-virus software, which was up to date and active, and it
identified one potential threat which I attempted to remove.
While this is not common, it is also not unusual given the data
we recover from 305 subject devices.
-I attempted to remove the potential threat, but my
administrative privileges had been removed, and despite many
attempts to gain access, I could not
-8:30am - I reached out to Christian Idsola at CART for help,
but he was going to be tied up for a couple of hours
-9:00am, I reached out to Talino for help and they walked me
through some steps, but nothing worked. They then advised me of
a process to take to run antivirus software against my Talinos
Operating System hard drive, which took some time but identified
the likely source of the threat, which was attributed to a
forensic program we use called Axiom. The threat was determined
to possibly be a "booby -trap" left by a subject (who is a
hacker) that was tripped when the Axiom forensic program ran
across it. After this discussion it was believed that was the
reason for the issues and we then began working on a solution,
which seemed likely to fix my issue.
-Around this time I also noticed our main server was down, but I
didn't think too much of it since we just added a new switch and
tried to configure some ports to run at different settings to
increase our bandwidth. I assumed at the time the lack of access
was a result of incorrectly applying the settings to
the "LAG" and "BOND" configurations of the switch. I was able to
see that according to the switch, the server seemed to be
connected just fine, so I spent some time troubleshooting it.
-Around 11:00am or so I was finally on instant message chat with
the makers of the server, Synology, who had us conduct some
tests and they ultimately concluded that a possible issue was a
defective hard drive in the server. This was a problem sine the
server is "raided" and finding the defective hard drive was a
time-consuming and difficult task, but several of us began our
attempts.
-3:00pm - Is when Christian Idsola and Lewis LNU from CART came
over to help. After a bunch of triage and testing we could not
figure out why we could not connect to the server, since by all
accounts it was working.
-We then noticed that our other servers (NAS1 and NAS2) were
also not working properly, although we were able to access their
control windows, unlike with the Synology server. After some
digging around we noticed the folders that contain our data was
missing. Initially we thought this was due to a firmware
issue since Christian and I had dealt with that in the past and
resembled the same issue.
-Around 3:30pm or so we located the log files and began combing
through, which is when we noticed strange IP activity that took
place yesterday from two IP addresses. The activity included
combing through certain files pertaining to the Epstein
investigation. I reached out to one of the case agents to see if
they were in the office yesterday, thinking that maybe they
inadvertently changed a setting on the NAS or if they noticed
anything strange about them.
-Around 4/4:30pm we dove into the IPs and checked all of our
computers to see which had the IPs in question. One computer,
our discovery computer, matched one of them and is located in a
room next to the lab, The other IP is one we don't recognize,
but is the same address as the IPson our network, leading us to
believe it was a computer that accessed our network somehow. We
were not able to identify the computer, but it had to have
accessed our network either by being plugged into the network,
or possibly by telnetting in virtually.
-5:00pm - we realized we were hacked and discussed what we
needed to do to ensure its contained.
-5:15pm, we immediately saved our logs and shut everything down.
We disconnected the Internet and ensured anything containing a
log file was preserved.
-5:30pm - I began calling my SSA, Bob Whelp in Security, Jessica
Cardenas at CART, Amit Patel in Cyber. Physical Security
-nec, 2021 - Moved into the 10th floor lab
-Dec, 2021 - made numerous requests for an electronic keypad
lock on the door only to be told by the locksmith there is no
funding for a lock. These requests have been made numerous times
from Dec, 2021 until a couple months ago, when the response was
to make numerous copies of the key we have to the lab
Networking/Network Security
-Since approx 2017 we have elicited help from CART and Cyber in
networking our lab, all to no avail. Some CART and Cyber folks
have come over on their good graces, but they were not network
savvy and just tried to do what they could. Some months ago (I
can look up the exact date) we again requested help from CART,
but were told their networking person was too busy to help. This
meant no one with networking experience or ability was willing
to help, so we had to figure it out on our own.
- End of the Outline -
Once I realized it was an intrusion, I called SSA Seamus
Clarke, and Bob welp with Security. I also called CART and
Cyber. This all occurred the same day I found out about the
intrusion.
The switch box was for the internal network. We had a
server rack and a server. We had a switch box and we just added
a second switch box. We also had a misattributed Internet that
was connected to the 0CE computers. The switch boxes were never
connected together. The Internet entered through a router that
was connected to the DExT computer and connected to the switch
box. I believed all were secure.
I believed, since we had a revolving door of Computer
Scientists and CART members, and since CACHTU was aware and
having other offices emulate the C-20 computer lab, I thought we
were good.
When the intrusion happened, we were in the middle of
piloting Axiom. I tried to figure  out Python and Cithub  and I
talked Le pewp1 en he.. to . I thought of a lot of
different things to allow remote access. We were trying to be on
the cutting edge and think outside the box. We have a large set
of hash files that we sent to NCMEC. A hash is a random string
of text used to verify the integrity of a file.
Rikela atir t- -1tW iriiiiiniquiliind can
cataloged. --Regarding -CsAm,-all-fileiare -"hashed"
values are distributed throughout law enforcement aridIPOUTE
Sector entities. using these hashes, CSAM can be detsiMWdifi
1ifiles hash matches that of a CSAM hash, the filiaRIS
0.dentified as CSAm without even having to see it. q.ltel—een—be
used t ensure  that a d wnl ad file is legitimate. We wanted to
share what we had with the RAs. 500 terabytes of data was gone
as a result of the intrusion . I was able to recover about 400
terabytes of that data, however. I was told to Google how to
recover the data. No one else tried to help us.
The OCIO Section Chief (SC), Matt Smith, was pissed because
he found an email I had sent prior to the intrusion requesting
assistance that no one had responded to. I spoke with SC Smith
who believed this was part of systemic failures. We asked for
help, and our requests fell on deaf ears. We were always
referred to someone else. I understand I opened the C-20 lab's
RDP ports, but it was my fault for turning  on the RDP sights. I
Was trying to make things better, and moreover CACHTU and other
HQ and management entities knew what I was doing and supported
me. The policies are not easy to find. FBI HQ Criminal
Investigative Division (CID) DAD Jose Perez has since
acknowledged the policy for the lab was vague or non-existent,
I was not part of the conversations to conduct a Security
Incident Reporting System (SIRS) report.
I believe that if I did not have the initiative, we would
not have had our successes. I continued to receive praise for my
work, and CACHTU has continued to ask me to review policy before
it is sent out to the field. I took over the Group I UCO and
doubled its statistical accomplishments. I have rescued more
exploited children than anyone in the NYFO and in most of the
Bureau. All I wanted to do was better the Bureau.
howa
bebee everything I did was with good intentions. I  love this job._
I was not reckless. There was no self-interest involved. I was
always trying to do the right thing. I also want to point out
Commented (JR3): Excellent!
Jim Roberson
2024-09-17 10:50:00
Commented 1CT4R31: I modified this a little.
Want to chat with you about it later.
00 TechTeam
2024-09-18 11:13:00
that I was Pic# awarded the Medal of Excellence for my work,
among other acce.
Prior
standard fo
ratings wer
often toute
the Bureau.
victims be
ands I9
Af
-[to CART_Lirna4 0
a-4 r hers on myal
ppnwrimallIMMIIIMIllitirded to be imagOOM,
processed, and all but 12 of these devices had been taken to
CART. Prior to the intrusion Agents on the squad could begin
imaging evidence they seized the same day and were generally
done imaging all their evidence within a few days. However, the
average completion time for CART to image devices was
approximately 30.5 days. This is a staggering number and is a
prime example of why the DExT program is so important and how
much of an impact the DExT lab had on my squad's ability to
swiftly and effectively conduct  child exploitation
investigations.
Additionally, this summary highlighted an instance it
hich, because of the lag time at CART and the amount of time it
took to image and process devices, an offender who was a citizen
of another country managed to flea the United States before the
review could be completed. It is almost certain this would not
have happened if the DExT review could have taken place in the
squad's lab. However, it did happen, and again illustrates the
significance of the lab and why the enhancements I made over the
years, and the numerous pleas I made for help, were  so
important.
This summary haj to  rteall
Agents, and I can mail lkue4.
I briefly mentioned ApostleX earlier in my statement. It
is both the name of a company and their product. I had no
previous relationship with the company. ApostleX came to the
FBI. They were touring the United states and approaching law
enforcement and intelligence agencies promoting their product.
They are a startup company. ApostleX reached out to several
entities within the FBI; not just the NYFO. One of the ApostleX
employees is a retired agent from NYFO named Chris Braga. I knew
Braga from NYFO as a polygrapher. In October 2021 Braga reached
out to me and several other individuals in the NYFO about
ApostleX. I initially did not care much about the product. They
were pitching a preservation tool that was geared towards CHSs.
It initially did not sound relevant to what we in C-20 were
working. Braga worked it out with others in the NYFO and set up
a few information sessions for different NYFO Divisions. Our
Gang squad, C-30 had an information session. On 10/20/2021, the
C-30 SSA sent out an email to my SSA who sent the invite for the
presentation to our squad. Another Agent from my squad and I
decided to attend. I attended what I believed was a Bureau-
sanctioned information session.
I showed up late and left early. The portion I did sit in
on talked about how ApostleX helped with their CHS's use of 3rd
party apps. The lack of technology available to preserve
encrypted apps, or self-destruct communications, was a widely
known issue. Self-destruct apps cannot be recovered, which makes
them very popular with VCAC offenders. There were not good
methods to capture the information. We voiced concerns about
this for years, but there was no fix. We did not have the
ability to go after VCAC offenders who used self-destruct apps
like Wicker. There were, and remain, no ways for us to preserve
that. When conducting chat operations, depending on the
application being used, the OCEs are unable to preserve the
chats with the offenders. Some applications allow for as short
as a one second self-destruct period, meaning that after one
second of viewing the chat, it is deleted and gone forever.
There is no forensic program in existence within the FBI to
preserve that chat. Furthermore,
designed in such a way that
these self-destruct apps are
efEee—t-he—WC--cra.w—t-he—aPP—e+—i-Fialeri-‘
s gene. If if an OCE attempts to yen—screen record or use a
screen shot to preserve a chat they either alert the person on
the other end or do not allow the screenshot to be taken. The
Bureau's answer to this problem was not really an answer. Some
responses to this problem were to use another device to
photograph the chats, which is problematic for a variety of
reasons, while other responses were for our issue to be passed
around.
Once ApostleX came along and I heard what their product did
for CHSs, I asked if it would work for encrypted chats and self-
destruct chats. They said it would. I left the meeting and met
with ApostleX after the presentation was over. When we met we
discussed if their technology would do what I described. They
advised they would check and get back with me. They got back to
us in early November 2021 and advised they believed they had the
ability to incorporate what I was asking for. I lead the effort
with ApostleX but my squad was involved. I spoke with SSA Seamus
Clark and ASAC John Penza (retired). We saw the benefit of it
for VCAC purposes. My bosses wanted me to explore it. It was
early on, and we needed to do everything right.
I believe there were a ton of Agents, throughout the
Bureau, simultaneously engaged in similar conversations with the
ApostleX company, discussing how to purchase the tool. The
ApostleX company has been to multiple FBI offices and may have
had conversations with Safe Streets. I believe the ApostleX
company pitched OTD and other III. At one point I even had
Executive Assistant Directors (EAD) reach out to me personally
about ApostleX.
On 11/08/2021, ApostleX requested I sign a nondisclosure
agreement. I reached out to NYFO Chief Division Counsel (CDC)
Tara Semos and we may have also spoken with an Assistant
Division Counsel (ADC). The decision was that we would not sign
anything. We did not have the position or authority. I told this
to ApostleX, but I also told them that we were not going to
steal their intellectual property.
People liked the Bpostlex program. The consensus was that
it was not a fully developed program, but it could be developed.
I be44eve—kno 1/4 there are currently wet-e—a number of programs
that are used today in the FBI that were made through Agent
input, and some that were created entirely by Agents themselves.
Axiom is a CART-approved tool that the Bureau uses. I was asked
to work with Axiom on how it was useful for us and what changes
we could be made to make it better for the case Agent. With
respect to ApostleX, my understanding was that we were talking
to a company that was brought in to us to fix a problem Agents
encounter when dealing with a throughout the Bureau routinely
CHS or an OCE ; namely the undetected real time preservation of
their text chats.
We communicated with CACHTU who liked ApostleX, but said
they would not commit funding.
In November 2021 ApostleX was still conceptual. It was in
the right direction but needed to be refined. They knew from a
big picture standpoint what the problems were. From a technical
standpoint the product was a home run.
Nothing I or my squad did was done in a vacuum. We briefed
all the way up to the ASAC (Penza) level. He did not want us to
go to the Assistant Director in Charge (ADIC) with a problem. He
wanted us to also have a solution before we briefed the ADIC. He
wanted the product to be more developed. He did not want an on-
paper solution.
At no point did anyone on my squad or I sign a contract
with ApostleX, or with anyone else for that matter . We were
going through the (PgIA) steps to get
the Bureau to sign a contract. We also never orally or verbally
agreed to a contract. It was our goal to have the FBI take on
pursuing a contract, not us.
At this point ApostleX was a concept and not a product. My
chain of command had no issue with me working with ApostleX to
develop the concept into a product. We were briefing our chain
of command regularly and we even brought in our Intel
supervisors. We wanted to make the product useful, not only to
us, but to other people throughout the Bureau as well. We
brought in CHS Coordinators, people from Intel, and people from
the VC program. We did not want to think singularly about our
violation.
It is required by FBI policy that we preserve OCE sessions,
but even to this day the technology does not exist to do it. I
saw it almost as an entrapment for OCEs, in that we are required
by FBI policy to preserve chats, yet the FBI has not provided us
with a means to do so. We saw ApostleX as an opportunity to
address   this and other concerns, follow policy, and
follow the law. I believed  certain  methods  to preserve  were
Current methods include all or nothing solutions, which result
in "over -collection" and create potential First Amendment
issues, in that they may record the communications of people who
were not involved in child exploitation crimes or violating the
law. ApostleX addressed this. The support we got from the onset
of that vision was incredible.
FBI HQ knew what we were doing because I discussed with
them the problems we were having with apps like Wicker. ApostleX
was already successful with apps like Telegram, and were working
on Signal and a few others. The ApostleX ',release engineers
figured out how to make their program work with Signal while we
were working with them. They were going in the right direction,
we just needed to guide them towards a total solution to our
actual needs nudge them. They were already working on trying to
fix the problem OCEs were having in 2021. We just needed to work
on how to preserve apps that created secret and self-destructing
chats.
The ApostleX company was never given access to FBI
information. They did not come into FBI space. We would FaceTime
them. we   never gave them anything that belonged to
the FBI. The ApostleX program was installed on a completely
standalone computer that was connected to a misattributed
Internet line. It was not attached to any FBI networks, covert
networks, or storage containers. The computer with the ApostleX
program was in FBI space. It was an old computer that was going
to be thrown away. It was a covert computer. I cannot recall if
we had a Computer Scientist (CS) wipe the drive of the computer
or if it was provided to us with no drives and we installed
wiped drives. Either way, we had to install operating systems.
The CS was Jim Walsh. The computers were given to us to use at
our discretion. I do not remember if I told him what the
computers were going to be used for. I am not sure if we got the
computers before or after we heard the ApostleX sales pitch. One
event did not trigger the other,
ApostleX III *MA* on a main computer. In our case it was
the one we set up. The ApostleX database resides on the computer
and the computer's sole function was to run the Apostlex server.
ApostleX allowed undercover phones to connect to it. Apostlex is
a server that sits on a computer and runs in the background.
There is a web-based computer interface. It only works from one
particular computer which sits behind a Virtual Private Network
(VPN) . If I am an OCE using the Telegram app I would connect my
Telegram account to ApostleX. There is an authentication
process. We had the company add an icon that let the OCE know
ApostleX was preserving the chats. The ApostleX company added a
small icon that showed ApostleX was active. ApostleX's
integration was chat application specific, so we were only
preserving what needed to be preserved. It started with
Telegram. Around the time we were told to shut down, it worked
with signal. We were getting close with What's App.
Any Telegram account we wanted to preserve would be added
to the ApostleX account. We had the ability to select what was
relevant and what was not.
could do an account takeover of a Subject's account. With
Apostlex there is an ability to not over collect.
With appropriate authorization, wi
ApostleX was initially grabbing everything, and we would
need to check what to preserve. We wanted to make a parameter
for how long to keep information that was not checked, which
would then be purged. The accounts would be taken over through
consent or with a warrant. We were testing the capability of
Apostlex to preserve self-destructing chats. Initially, in the
testing environment, the disappearing chats were preserved on
both the sender and the receiver's telephones, which obviously
would not work for us.
that.
We worked with the company to address
The ApostleX company did not have the ability to access the
data we collected from chat applications, but they could see the
telemetry coding. I believe OCIO looked at that and were happy
with it. SC Matt Smith from OLIO was also involved and sent
Requests for Information REIs) to our local ISSO, Jim Eckel,
who reviewed ApostleX, the code, and had at least one call with
them that I was a part of. I believe he also had additional
communications with them that I was not a part of. In the end, I
know that OCIO's questions were sufficiently answered. dealing
with that.
We never went live with the ApostleX program and only
operated it in a testing environment. We did not use active
cases. We used dummy phones and OCEs chatting on the Telegram
application. We added a bunch of older OCE Telegram accounts to
test it out. All of the accounts we used were real covert
accounts. Some of the accounts were historical
attached  t them that Lerc cxp scd to Apostle)'. When we synced
ApostleX to chat application accounts, the entire history of the
chat application account would be pulled. The information was
exclusively stored on the local hard drive of the computer
running ApostleX. One of the Telegram accounts I used for
testing was about 12 years old. The test accounts I used were
not involved in any chat groups that were pertinent. I am not
sure about the other folks who were testing ApostleX. I do not
believe anyone cared about the accounts we used. I believe the
historical data attached to the accounts had already been
adjudicated but it is possible some of the information may not
have been. I cannot say there was no evidentiary data put on the
standalone ApostleX computer. I do not believe having
information on the ApostleX computer was any different than
having it on any other computer,
. I did use a historic case to demonstrate
how we could export from ApostleX for discovery purposes. The
case was not fully adjudicated at that point. I am certain dews#
believe the accounts we were using had no impact on w uld have
temptem‘sed any ongoing investigation. There was likely CSAM
from the historical accounts that was extracted and uploaded
onto the ApostleX computer when the historic accounts were
synced with the ApostleX program. The ApostleX company or anyone
else could not see it, however.
It took a while to set the standalone ApostleX computer up.
We may have hooked the computer up in December 2021 or January

2022. We tested it intermittently for a couple of months. It
would be a days long process to reconfigure things. We would
give feedback to the ApostleX engineers who monitored the
telemetry data and could see the issues with the ApostleX
program from their end as we tested it. Sometimes the fixes took
a few hours or a day or two. Once they had a fix, ApostleX
engineers would send me a tout document with instructions on how
to fix the issues. Any message that was sent from the company
was done through Bureau email. The instructions It would be a
tewe—deawmerserwritten in the email itself or provided verbally.
Though it is possible I may have used my personal telephone to
communicate with ApostleX engineers using the video
teleconferencing application, Zoom, I do not recall for sure. I
do believe I may have used my FBI laptop and possibly my OCE
telephone for the Zoom calls with ApostleX engineers, however.
I used a mixture  f pert nal and Bureau  devices t receive tho
instructions  and communicate  with the Ap sticX company. At times
I used my per• nal telephone  t c nduct teleph nc calls r vides
ch"ts ItsIth the Apoetl-X en 51—e..s while I ..as in FBI
prod minatcly  uccd Bureau equipment. Sometimes the ApostleX
engineer could see me during our Zoom calls and sometimes not.
We sanitized the FBI space if the engineer would be able to see
me. We would input the instructions sent by the ApostleX company
into the computer with the ApostleX program on it. Ede —fret-M
kThic is sounding  way off
II Ay,,,,L1X wth. by lin need to elailf, e.aie
I think this should  be rcmcvcdH There were a couple  of
times I had "tech people", SA Robert Depresco, and—SA Martin
Nachman, and others look at the ApostleX computer and to review
the code. I also provided the code and entire system to the NYFO
I550, Jim EckleJ and others from OCIO to review the code and
system. Additionally, I advised OTD and FBI HQ that they could
review it as well. It is possible I forwarded the codes for
other people to look it.
for updating the
There was no formalized process set up
standalone ApostleX computer. The updates
consisted mostly of updating a configuration file and if I
needed to change code it was due to the configuration file. I
Commented IJR5I: I'm not sure how to
incorporate this infommtion into the sentence. Aaron.
Jim Roberson
2024-09-16 10:12:00
Commented TCT6R5II: I'm not sure either. l was
in FBI space when speaking with them, but so what?
C20 TechTeam
2024-09-17 06:37:00
Commented pR7R5I: OK. Just delete it, then?
Jim Roberson
2024-09-17 10:54:00
Commented OK. Fix it and remove
whatever is misleading or incorrect.
Jim Roberson
2024-09-16 10:15:00
Commented (CT9R81: Can we just delete it?
00 TechTeam
2024-09-17 08:59:00
Commented jJRI0R8J: Yep. Delete it. If
INSD makes an issue of it vec can talk it out with them.
Jim Roberson
2024-09-17 10:55:00
made the deliberate decision not to let the ApostleX company
remote access into the standalone ApostleX computer. During this
process, I felt like the ApostleX company was a verified entity
and I was working with someone the Bureau invited in.
We ran the security process through OCIO and the NYFO ISSO,
Jim Eckle, and Certified Information Systems Security Officer
(CISSO) Robert Cavallo who were all satisfied with the setup.
The NYFO did not have either the ISSO or the CISSO positions
staffed until February 2023, however. Only Ny squad SSA, branch
ASAC, ad NYr0 CDC, and CACHTU were all aware of ApostleX and of
what we were doing with them from the very earliest stages.
There were others in the office who knew as well. As we
progressed with our testing and development of the program,
others were involved to include the Office of General Counsel
(OGC), the General Counsel himself, the Procurement Office,
several ACsl, the NYFO ADIC, and
various other leaders in FBI management. At a minimum, my squad
SSA, branch ASAC and NYFO CDC all knew what we were doing. OTD
was also involved but not at this stage. CACHTU was aware and
the Child Exploitation Operational Unit (CEOU) was also aware. I
had gone back and forth with them a bit. There was communication
on 11/08/2021.
I was passionate about this product as a force multiplier.
I can assure you there was nothing done in a vacuum.
Oben I
started working with ApostleX on this product, my chain of
command knew. My chain gave me the thumbs up to proceed and my
guidance was to get to a point where it was functional before we
briefed the ADIC. From the very beginning I had the approval of
my SSA, ASAC and CDC. I reached out to CACHTU to see who I
needed to work with to get it approved. They said if I could
develop the tech, it would be fucking  great. We also discussed
funding, and CACHTU was not sure who would fund ApostleX. They
said that perhaps they could fund the VCAC portion of it, but
that for ae enterprise -wide use funding would have to come from
OTD or elsewhere. Thereitiei—i-t—wes—rtert—geinerbe—be—fttrgekud—ernel—E
did not honeys  CACHTU  w uld fund it until there was a w
product.
As I mentioned previously, i n April or May 2022, I went to
an IACIS conference and the ApostleX program was working. Leslie
Adamczck, who was a former squad mate and a VCAC PM, was also in
attendance. I told her about the product. She said it needed to
be briefed at the Program Coordinators (PCOR) conference. That
was the perfect venue since it would be attended by VCAC PCORs
from every Field Office I was added to the list of presenters.
I had conversations with the PMs and UC who were in charge of
the conference, and I was added to the agenda. I worked on a
presentation and showed it to SSA Adamczck. She loved it. SSA
Commented OK. Remove it.
Jim Roberson
2024-09-16 11 :14:00
Adamczck was a PM for CACHTU at the time and was coordinating
with the person who put the conference together. I submitted a
summary of what ApostleX was and what I was presenting on. I
submitted a draft of my presentation prior to the conference
SSA Clarke was present during my presentation.
The PCOR conference presentation went well. There were
numerous L. h.nd fall e4 questions and I had people who called me
to talk more about it later. I heard from an Agent in Las Vegas
whose SSA, Matt Schaeffer, was on an 18-month TDY to CACHTU as
an Assistant Section Chief (ASC). The-ASC Schaeffer did not like
the ApostleX program. The feedback was all positive except what
I heard second-hand from ASC Schaeffer. During my presentation I
made it clear that ApostleX was technology that we were
developing but that we did not have yet. If I made comments
during the presentation about not following policy in my work
with the Apostlex company, it was done as a joke. I was briefing
a room full of supervisors as well as CACHTU about a program
designed to help all of their Agents. In no way, shape, or form
did I ever say, in any serious fashion, that I violated policy
ene4or that I paid anything for ApostleX. There is a possibility
that I may have made jokes about paying the Apostlex company a
dollar for the program, but I did not pay them a dollar, nor any
amount for that matter. At some point early on there may have
been wee—a conversation with Apostlex about if we should pay the
company a dollar. We were concerned that we were using a product
for free. I took the question to legal or maybe even my bosses.
The decision was made not to pay them. I remember this
conversation occurring, but I do not recall the details since no
monetary exchange ever took place. I began hearing rumors in
March or April of 2023 about things I said during my ApostleX
presentation at the VCAC PCOR conference
context.
being taken out of
There was never a contract between the FBI and
ApostleX, either orally or in writing, and if there had been it
would have been through approved channels and not with me.
During the PCOR conference, ApostleX was still soliciting
the FBI about their product. Around that time, ASAC Penza
retired and at some point, Spencer Horn became ASAC. The
ApostleX program was not active; there was no contract, and my
chain of command was aware of what I was doing. The guidance to
get the concept to a place where it was a better solution before
it was briefed higher up the chain of command continued after
ASAC Penza retired and ASAC Horn came in. The SAC was eventually
briefed.
A few days after the VCAC PCOR conference I heard from
Joanna Pasquarelli who iS a General Attorney (GA) for OGC. GA
Pasquarelli attended the VCAC PCOR conference and saw my
presentation. GA Pasquarelli informed me we needed to stop
testing ApostleX immediately. She did not say we needed to stop
working with the ApostleX company, but to shut down the computer
with the Apostlex program. We did so immediately. She also
informed me we needed a PIA. She also had concerns about the
Fair Act and the procurement process in relation to how we
worked with the company. We discussed the laws about companies
bidding on the chance to work with the FBI on a product as
opposed to a single source product. This process eventually
included a lot of people from OGC. I spoke with CDC Semos about
my conversation with GA Pasquarelli. I was sent a "pony" of the
PIA which I filled +.e out and returned. GA Pasquarelli was very
pleased with what I turned in. There were a lot of email
communications and Microsoft Teams calls. We had to do some
comparisons to see if there were other companies who offered
products similar to ApostleX.
I had spoken with OTD about the issues with OCEs were
having capturing chats on encrypted applications and capturing
disappearing chats in the past. We had tried, unsuccessfully, to
get OTD involved prior to this process. After OGC was involved,
they required us to check with OTD on what they had to address
the issue, or if they could come up with a solution in house. We
also asked if OTD would work with the ApostleX company to
develop the ApostleX product. We learned there was a product
called Eagle Claw available which I believe should be taken off
the approved list of tools to use. There was only one guy at the
time working on Eagle Claw, and he said what I described of
ApostleX was a homerun. Eagle Claw had a lot of limitations. We
spoke with a lot of people about existing programs and external
products as part of the procurement process. Nothing could do
what Apostlex could do.
I continued to work through my chain of command, CACHTU,
OGC, Safe Streets, OCIO, NYFO ISSO, Finance and Facilities
Division (FFD), OTD, and various units within OTD. We were
moving along up and through the holidays of 2022. There were a
lot of revisions to the PTA. We worked through an emergency in
which Boston Field Office had a hands-on offender and they
needed to preserve their chat information.
I
worked with OGC GA Christopher Dearing on PIP. revisions. I was
delayed getting back to him due to a trial. Once I got back to
him, the cyber intrusion of the C-20 computer lab happened.
The standalone computer containing the ApostleX program had
been turned off in our testing environment since July 2022. We
were not using it at all. I am not sure if it was even plugged

in. I heard there was a rumor that some people believed Apostlex
had to do with the C-20 lab computer intrusion. I received an
email from CDC Semos that ApostleX was going to be shut down due
to the belief it was involved in the intrusion. This was
completely untrue, of course. ApostleX had nothing to do with
the intrusion. I believe CDC Semos cleared this rumor up with
OGC. My chain of command wanted ApostleX to continue to move
forward because they saw value in it.
4-11OIIVion t2
SAC Robert
IIIIIIID
other. - Lives,
We saw that NYFO Criminal Division and CACHTU were being a
roadblock. We had a meeting with SAC Brodack prior to the C-20
lab intrusion to get the ADIC involved in the ApostleX project
to push the needle forward. We wanted to be able to pilot the
program. Some of the questions from DGC asked who was supporting
the ApostleX project. The intrusion happened before a formal
briefing could take place, however.
There was a meeting about ApostleX with NYFO
Counterterrorism (CT) Division SAC Robert Cassane in August
2023. CDC Semos, ASAC Horn, the ISS0, SSA of the Tech squad,
Eddie Pennetta, SA Depresco, and SA Nachman. The meeting was
about trying to use a Domestic Terrorism (DT) case as a pilot
case for ApostleX. There were still conversations about ApostleX
taking place until I was noticed of this INSD internal
investigation.
I was working with the International Terrorism Operations
Section (ITOS) and some thigh -tech unit. They were asking for
information to push up to EAD Larissa Napp, who reached out to
me personally. I had my ASAC respond to her on my behalf.
After the C-20 lab intrusion, CACHTU wanted nothing to do
with ApostleX. NYFO wanted to see if they could do something
with ApostleX on their own. They also got CT involved to see if
they could push ApostleX through their networks. There were
conference calls with the ApostleX company to field questions.
Representatives from the ApostleX company may have also gone to
Huntsville, Alabama and spoken with the AD of OTD.
There was confusion on getting the Authority to Operate
(ATO) . It was a chicken or the egg situation. We did not know
Commented 1JR12I: Can you identify this unit
by name?
Jim Roberson
2024-09-16 12:41:00
Commented 1CT13R12I: Ill try to find their
name - there were a couple units that worked on the
development of tech - some in CT some in Crim.
maybe one in OTD
C20 TechTeam
2024-09-17 09:15:00
which one we needed first, the ATO or the PTA. We were working
on the ATO process as well.
CACHTU funded the equipment for the c-20 lab. I believe
Group I UCOs were exempt from needing an ATO. ASAC Horn was
trying to see if we could get approval to use ApostleX under the
Group I because he believed we would not need an ATO. I believe
this was discussed with CDC Semos, because I was present when
they argued about it. wk had a did n t agroc with ASAC ❑orn's
onscoomcnt. When I was putting together the information for the
C-20 lab, I did not know about an ATO requirement. I later found
out we did not need an ATO for covert purchases. I think they
may have tried to change that after-the-fact.
There was a financial threshold for the lab purchases. This
was approved by Jack Cordes in OGC. It outlined what was needed
for the C-20 lab and how we were going to use the equipment. I
believe everything that needed an F number received one.
Noone ever told me of the requirement for an ATO for the C-20
lab. It came up after ASAC Horn and CDC Semos had their
discussions.
Some of the ApostleX company sits in Ireland and some in
the United States (Us). They are registered in the US to
receive government contracts.
Our squad's end-of-year review for fiscal year 2022
mentioned ApostleX as one of the reasons to give us a gold
rating. However, ApostleX was also lictcd   _eferenced as the
reason for a lower program rating for fiscal year 2023. CACHTU
initially rated our squad "gold", the highest rating, but Deputy
Director Paul Abbate later changed our rating to "red", the
worst rating, and included the reference to ApostleX and its
direct involvement in the intrusion as the reason, which is
categorically false. My ASAC attempted to fight this false
narrative but was told it could not be changed.
I never understood undcrotand   that just working with
ApostleX in general could cause procurement issues, and even to
this day as much as I have learned from all of this, I know that
Try Hy:Cy-merit did not and would not cause r,--:urement issues.
lasme_Iparne
nu e_ same OGC
was trying to figure out how to make it work. As mentioned
previously, I think it is also important to note that NYFO did
not have an ISSO or a CISSO when the C-20 lab was set up. IIII
f iced
Robert Welp. this
position  was only t  the ISSO and CISSO
:I have ed a document to
NYFO SAC
of not having
Commented (JRI4I: Are you talking about the
NYFO Chief Security Officer. or CSO. here? If so use
higher titk.
Jim Roberson
2024-09-17 11:03:00
Commented iCTI5R141: 1 don't know that he
even had a proper tide. He was filling a vacancy
C20 TechTeam
2024-09-18 15:04:00
these positions filled and the steps he took to fill them. If
these positions had been filled there is little doubt that I
would have received the assistance I needed to ensure our
network was secure. However, these positions were not filled,
and I was nevertheless encouraged to enhance our lab by all
levels of management and received the necessary approvals along
the way. I should not be punished for failures in hindsight that
were out of my control. While I take responsibility for all of
my actions, I am confident that nothing I did was without
approval and everything was done in the interest of improvement.
Under no circumstances whatsoever did exceed my authority
by contracting an outside company. There was no contact. My
'chain of command, including our CDC and later gm-, to includ4
the General Counsel himself, knew I was speaking with Apostle*
pm creating a solution to a problem. I engaged the PTA process
ps instructed, working for months with many FBI lawyers,
procurement officers, and management' all ensuring ourpursuiE
of this_ needed program was done correctly. Any_notion that
I violated any policy, rule, or regulation is categorically
Lastly, it should be noted that, since the intrusion, my
squadlmates and I have been referenced as having been "System
Administrators", which we absolutely are not. The INSD report
identifies me, and others on my squad, as having been System
did not and do not possess. None of us on my squad do.
In my defense I allikands , n
snag supporting documentationil large
IIIIIIIILL,these documents rasa and;mAi
more if
I am willing and eager to voluntarily take a polygraph
examination concerning the truthfulness of the information
contained in this signed, sworn statement. I have no other
pertinent information regarding the aforementioned allegations.
I have been advised that I should submit any additional
information of which I may become aware, regarding this inquiry,
to the Internal Affairs Section (IAS)/Inspection Division (INSD)
or to the Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR).
I have been given the opportunity to review this statement
and make any changes prior to signing it.
I was instructed on 01/26/2024 not to discuss this matter
with anyone other than the person(s) conducting this interview,
representatives from IAS/INSD, Security Division - Clearance
Referral Evaluations Unit, OPR, the FBI Ombudsman, and/or an FBI
Employee Assistance Program (EAP) Counselor. I have been told
that should I decide to discuss this matter with anyone else, I
must first obtain authorization from the interviewer(s).
I have read this statement, consisting of this and 36 other
pages and it is true and correct
Aaron E. Spivack
sworn to and subscribed before me on the Xnd day of
September, 2024, in New York, NY.
Dennis W. Price, Jr.
Witness:
Commented (CT161: 1 provided far more than 36
pages - if he is referring to my attachments then this
number is far off
C20 TechTeam
2024-09-17 11:00:00
Commented (JR17R16(: I think this is only
referring to the number of pages of the actual statement
itself. Not the attachments. You can fix it. The
statement is a lot longer now than it was originally due
to all of our edits.
Jim Roberson
2024-09-17 11:11:00
witness
EFTA02690885 (Jmail)
 [finance] ATorus pitch deck
(inferred date: 2026-01-04)
ATORUS
DRAFT - January 2014
Agenda eATORUS

• Overview 3
• Founding Partners 4
• Investment Strategy 5
• Investment Methodology 6
• Key Differentiating Factors 12
• Track Record 13
• Contact Information 15
• Disclaimer 16
Overview - Atorus
✓ The investment strategy is scalable, highly
liquid, and transparent which aims to
minimize volatility and generate consistent
returns.
✓ Atorus is headquartered in Weston, MA as a
Registered Investment Advisor in the state
of Massachusetts.
✓ Atorus is in its pre-launch phase, targeting
an initial capital raise of $100m for a launch
date of March 1st, 2014.
A TORUS
✓ The investment strategy is scalable, highly
liquid, and transparent which aims to
minimize volatility and generate consistent
returns.
✓ Atorus is headquartered in Weston, MA as a
Registered Investment Advisor in the state
of Massachusetts.
✓ Atorus is in its pre-launch phase, targeting
an initial capital raise of $100m for a launch
date of March 1st, 2014.
Founding Partners AT° R U S
The Founding Partners of Atorus met in 2006, when they began collaborating on research and development of what are now 
the
underlying insights of the Atorus trading methodology.
Diverse backgrounds and experience combined with complementary skill sets is the foundation for creating, developing, 
and growing
the Atorus trading methodology into a global, leadership-driven asset management business.
Michael J. Fowler— Partner & Chief Investment Officer
(trading, position level analysis and quantitative systems
development).
Michael's career has been focused on understanding the
nuances of complex financial systems and other markets. In
2007 Michael was the Co-Founder and Senior Portfolio
Manager at Red Dot Trading, LLC, where in cooperation with
Joshua, he was responsible for the day to day trading of a
sector specific core listed-equity book. Prior to this, he was
the Director of Structured Products & Finance at The Geneva
Group in New York where he was responsible for developing
financial structures to provide bank-regulatory capital relief
solutions given Basel II risk re-weightings. Michael also
focused on project and acquisition financings primarily in the
infrastructure, real estate and energy industries, including the
acquisition of London City Airport by various European banks.
He began his financial career at the age of 14 as a runner for
the American Stock Exchange and at the age of 16 was hired
by the hedge fund MHG Capital as an equity and equity
derivatives trader. Michael is an avid ultra marathoner who
runs 50 and 100 mile+ races.
Joshua L. Levy — Partner & Chief Operating Officer (quantitative
systems development and implementation. operations and trading).
Joshua has largely focused on understanding what makes
companies grow and prosper and bringing simplicity and systematic
thinking to complex processes. In 2007, Joshua co-founded Red Dot
Trading, LLC with partner Michael Fowler, where they both traded
the core-equity book. Prior to founding Red Dot Trading, LLC,
Joshua was the Director of Private Investments at MUUS Asset
Management, a Connecticut-based private equity firm, where he was
responsible for the operational restructuring and management of
portfolio companies in the real estate, automotive, and energy
industries. With MUUS Asset Management, he completed the
successful turnaround of Sol Incorporated from bankruptcy to 2x
revenue, strong profitability, and positioning for acquisition. Prior to
MUUS Asset Management, Joshua worked at Alvarez & Marsal
Europe in both Stockholm, Sweden and London, England where he
focused on advising distressed international companies and their
debt restructurings. In 1996, he founded Creative Ideas International,
a consumer goods distribution and marketing firm in Eastern Europe,
which he then sold to a NYSE listed company in 2001. Recognized
as a global operations and turnaround expert, Joshua has served
since 2004 as a Board Member of Round Hill Capital LLC, a $4
billion global real estate investor / asset manager. He holds an MBA
from the MIT Sloan School of Management and a BA from Vanderbilt
University. Joshua is an enthusiastic ice hockey goalie and has
played for teams in the USA, Poland and Norway.
4
Investment Strategy AT° R U S
Atorus is a global multi -strategy fund with a systematic bias that hinges on Price Movement  and Volatility.
HOW?

• The Fund invests in 350+ positions across two main asset classes: global macro instruments and listed equities.

• Each position is systematically chosen to minimize  correlation risk taking into account volatility,  randomness,  low
correlation  and asset class diversification  to deliver profits for investors in up and down markets.

• The effective 'neutrality of the overall portfolio dampens the volatility of returns month-on-month.

• Within the portfolio, directional bets are taken on individual positions via systematic trade management -irrespective
of
portfolio considerations.

• Atorus cuts beta on losing positions and lets winners run by incrementally 'pyramiding' up.
• Atorus targets a Profit Factor of 2.5X and a Win Ratio** of > 40%. The magnitude of winners more than offsets losers.

• Systematic Trade management on individual long and short positions is driven by analysis of TIME and VOLATILITY.

• Returns therefore take a 'stair step' profile, with incremental gains, targeting 11.2% in positive calendar quarters 
and -4.7% in
down calendar quarters, with 85% positive rolling yearly returns.
` Profit Factor: The ratio of the avg. realized gain on a profitable trade divided by the average realized loss on a 
losing trade.
** Win/Loss Ratio: The percentage of profitable trades.
5
Investment Methodology
The Atorus investment methodology utilizes 3 discrete  investment modules.
NI
4
Directional Bias of Individual Positions & Timing
Portfolio Construction
Risk Control
. ATORUS
Investment Methodology
ortfolio
Construction
'ATORUS

• Systematic portfolio construction screens for assets with low intra-portfolio correlation.
• The goal is to maximize randomness I minimize basis and attribution risk I maximize outsized price persistence
and construct a portfolio to mitigate correlation risk.

• Portfolio positions are diversified by Region, Asset Class, Directional Bias and Volatility State.
• The two main components of the portfolio: "Global Macro" and "Listed Equities" balance returns across global
volatility states.
— When markets are 'moving,' i.e. high volatility, the importance of the contribution from listed equities will
be equal to that of the Global Macro book. When volatility is low, the Listed Equity book positions will
make a larger contribution to the portfolio.

• Global Macro Instruments> FX, G20 Rates, Equity Index Futures, ETFs
• Listed Equities from G7 and BRIG countries, of which there must be;
✓ Minimum market cap of $10billion+
✓ Average daily turnover of $50million/day
»Correlation determines investment opportunities but does not affect the individual direction of any position.
Investment Methodology
Directional Bias of Individual
Positions & Timing
ti ATORUS

• Determining the directional bias and profiting from 'large' movements, whether long or short, is the foundation of the
strategy.

• Subjective factors are removed in favour of Atorus' disciplined, systematic approach.
• Proprietary calculations of changes in realized volatility and price movement alter the timing of entry and exit.

• Volatility scales. As volatility increases our perspective is tightened, allowing for a quick reaction on the
directionality of an individual position.

• This protects the Atorus portfolio against a common event where an increase of a stock price of 20% — 30%
which took 6 months to achieve is not lost in 30 days.

• In simple terms, if realized volatility is not changing, portfolio positions are maintained so as not to sell at the
bottom and buy at the top of mini trends.
Investment Methodology
irectional Bias of Individu
Positions & Timing (cont.)
'ATORUS

• Trajectory and momentum of asset prices accurately reflect the fundamentals; often one year ahead.
• Atorus does not establish any arbitrary targeted net directional bias for the portfolio or for any subsector of the
portfolio.

• Portfolio bias is generated by the aggregate of our individual position bias rather then any defined targets — if
Atorus is expressing a particular net directional bias, it is likely we are experiencing outsized profits across 
multiple
positions.

• Key Points:
✓ Mean reversion is against the ethos of our strategy. The mean has the most 'noise'.
✓ No moving averages or technical analysis.
✓ Keep losers small and winners big.
✓ Time is always a variable.
✓ No 'trend' following.
✓ Low turnover of positions.
Atorus Proprietary Research
"Volatility Scales." Changes in realized volatility alter the speed at which the price of a security can change.
In 14.363 daily observations of the S&P500. which includes The Cuban Missile Crisis. Inflation of the 1970s. S&L Crisis,
LTCM, 9/11,
Tech Crash, and the Financial Crisis, our predicted volatility in the next period is only exceeded 177 times or 1.23% of
the time, with
no clustering of these outcomes. When exceeded. the average error is only 26% more than the prediction.
9
Investment Methodology
Risk Control
Risk control is achieved by systematically managing:

• Entry/ Exit Points:
- Minimum of 5 days entry 'smoothing the noise' > beneficial relative to targeted hold period.

• Leverage:
— Never used at the inception of a trade, on an individual position basis.
- Anticipated average net leverage of 2.2 X (can be tailored for each investor)
'ATORUS

• Position Sizing:
- Designed to limit downside risk
— No human discretion.
- Realized volatility of security determines the size of an allocation.
— Calculated for potential maximum targeted impact loss and a balanced positive impact from winners to NAV.
— Position sizing increases as winners are leveraged in declining notional amounts at target price levels informed by 
realized
volatility.
— 5% soft maximum position size.
10
Investment Methodology
Risk Control (cont.)

• Average Hold period is 30 days for losing trades, 6 months for winners (can be multiple years).
'ATORUS

• Alpha is generated on moves of 20-30 X average realized vol, which generally does not occur over short time
intervals.

• The Fund does not dollar cost average its positions and losers are closed swiftly.
Risk Control  is designed to enhance winners and minimize losers.
Portfolio Construction  and Directional Bias of Individual Positions and Timing are designed to mitigate downside
volatility.
1
Key Differentiating Factors ATORUS
✓ Cohesiveness; The Partners have worked and traded together since 2007. Their backgrounds, experiences and
strengths are different & complimentary.
✓ The managers have a deep understandings of complex systems and trading. They have BOTH respect for market
forces and dedication to discipline, order, and operational excellence.
✓ A unique investment approach combines three discrete investment modules; portfolio construction, the directional
bias of individual positions and timing, and strict and methodical risk control.
✓ Measurement of return is on an absolute basis. Our focus is on our Win/Loss Ratio and Profit Factor.
✓ No risk of style drift.
✓ Focus on consistency of returns with minimized monthly volatility; 'Stairstep' return profile.
✓ Customizable strategy can be tailored to specific regions, sectors, and risk profiles.
Track Record AT° RU S

• The team managed a $50million (avg. notional risk of $100MM) portfolio for a European Bank from
September 2011 to June 2013.
,7 Sector specific mandate experienced low correlation to broader markets even during market declines.
✓ Track record is non-portable as it is derived from a managed account and part of a broader portfolio.
✓ Win ratio of 38% achieved.
✓ Realized profit factor of 2.25X
✓ Generated positive returns on months with large market drawdowns (September 2011, May 2012)
$1,500,000
$1,000,000
$500,000
-4—Profit by Percentile
5-
5(500,000)
$(1,000,000)
oes e e e Q,o4 e ccr
3
Track Record (cont.) . ATORUS
• With Global mandate, over 400+ positions, backtested results
✓ 85% positive rolling yearly returns
✓ Low drawdowns
✓ Largest positive position accounts for less than 3% of total P/L
✓ Positive returns in market declines, by design, while still maximizing upside
✓ IRR of 31% gross returns
✓ Following charts display (1) Fund dollar NAV with initial capital of $1 OOMM and (2) percentile distribution of
rolling yearly returns
20,000,000,000
15,000,000,000
10,000,000,000
5,000,000,000
I  i I I I 1 I I 1 I
in l.C. N 0O O1 O el rs4 en .4. In 1/4O N. 0O O1 O el C.1 rn m al a) m m o O O O O o o o O o ri ri ri ri
O1 O1 O1 O1 O1 O O O O O O O O O O O O O O ri rt rt ri rt N N N N N N N N N N N N N N --- --- --- --- --- --- ----NJ N N
N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N N ----
---- --- --- --- --- ---ri .. . ....... rt el el el el el el el
Contact Information • ATORUS
For further information:
Joshua Levy, Partner, Atorus
Michael Fowler, Partner, Atorus
Disclaimer ti ATORUS
This presentation is provided for informational and discussion purposes only and does not constitute a solicitation or 
an offer to provide
investment management services. Any solicitation, if made, will be made only pursuant to an Investment Management 
Agreement (`IMA'). In
the case of any inconsistency between the descriptions or terms in this document and the IMA, the IMA shall control. 
This document may not be
reproduced or distributed in any format without the express written approval of Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC. While all 
information prepared in
this document is believed to be accurate. Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC makes no express warranty as to its completeness or
accuracy, nor can
it accept responsibility for errors in this document. To the maximum extent permitted by law. Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC
disclaims any and all
liability in the event any information, commentary, analysis, opinions, advice and/or recommendations in this 
presentation prove to be
inaccurate, incomplete or unreliable, or result in any investment or other losses. The information contained herein does
not purport to contain all
of the information that may be required to evaluate an investment . Ability to achieve investment objectives may be 
affected by a variety of risks
not discussed herein. A prospective investor understands the nature of the investment and can bear the economic risk of 
such investment
In considering any performance information contained herein, investors shall bear in mind that past or projected 
performance is not necessarily
indicative of future results, and there can be no assurance that target returns will be met. The prior results of the 
principals is representative of
their direct investment responsibilities utilizing the investment strategy methodology represented herein, but within a 
larger fund vehicle and may
not reflect results of the vehicle.
The investment strategy is speculative and involves a high degree of risk. Opportunities for withdrawal of funds are 
restricted, so investors may
not have access to capital when it is needed. The portfolio composition, which is under the sole trading authority of 
Red Dot Trade Finance,
LLC, may not be fully diversified and this lack of diversification may result in higher risk. Leverage, that is 
borrowing on margin, will be employed
in the portfolio, which can make investment performance volatile, requires investment gains to be in excess of the cost 
of borrowing, and could
result in losses to investors in excess of their principal. The investment strategy involves the purchase and sale of 
options and other leveraged
derivative instruments, which can result in losses in excess of the capital in an investor's account.
NOTICE OF PENDING REGISTRATION : Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC has a pending application to become a Registered Investment 
Advisor.
but is currently not registered with any regulatory authority. Atorus. LLC registration is pending at time of 
publication of this document. Atorus.
LLC is intended to be the investment vehicle and Red Dot Trade Finance, LLC the Registred Investment Advisor.
16
EFTA00007401 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2004-08-25 to 2005-07-13
(inferred date: 2026-01-05)
phone bill covering 2004-08-25 to 2005-07-13
EFTA00264995 (Jmail)
 [article] see quote: "reportedly removed computer drives and other electronic equipment from the financier's Florida mansion"
(inferred date: 2026-01-05)
.4CODC . tt4EDDINC* *PATrERA OF WHA%1100R4 6/22R2, 1:00 PM Bill Clinton - Wikipedia
ASSAsS I KAT tocA
laws for gays and for the private sector Employment Non-Discrimination Act, which, buoyed by
his lobbying, failed to pass the Senate by a single vote in 1.996.1wi Advocacy for these issues,
paired with the politically unpopular nature of the gay rights movement at the time, led to
enthusiastic support for Clinton's election and reelection by the Human  Rights CampaignP37)
Clinton came out for gay marriage in July 2009 1a1 and urged the Supreme Court to overturn
DONA in 2o13.1101 He was later honored by GLAAD for his prior pro-gay stances and his reversal
on DOMA.(1-44-1
The 1996 United States campaign
finance controversy was an alleged
effort by China to influence the
domestic policies of the United
States, before and during the
Clinton administration, and
involved the fundraising practices
of the administration itself  (-46-1(144
Despite the evidenceP 46b 481 the
Chinese  _government denied all
accusations 49)
1
"When I took office, only high energy physicists had ever
heard of what is called the Worldwide Web ... Now even
my cat has its own page."
Bill Clinton's announcement of Next Generation
Internet initiative, October 1996.  1Th 5
As part of a 1996 initiative to curb illegal immigration, Clinton signed the Illegal Immigration
Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act (IIRIRA) on September 30, 1996. Appointed by
Clinton,L1$Ol the U.S. Commission on Immigration Reform recommended reducing legal
immigration from about 800,000 people a year to about 550,00o 11511152]
Ken Gormley, author of The Death of American Virtue: Clinton vs. Starr, reveals in his book that
Clinton narrowly escaped possible assassination in the Philippines in November 1996. During his
visit to the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum in Manila, while he was on his way
to meet with a senior member of the Philippine government, Clinton was saved from danger
minutes before his motorcade was scheduled to drive over a bridge charged with a timed
improvised explosive device (IED).11531 According to officials, the IED was large enough to "blow
up the entire presidential motorcade" .“ 54 Details of the plot were revealed to Gormley by Lewis C.
Merletti, former member of the presidential protection detail and Director of the Secret Service.
Intelligence officers intercepted a radio transmission indicating there was a wedding cake under a
bridge.11131 This alerted Merletti and others as Clinton's motorcade was scheduled to drive ver a
major bridge in downtown Manila.IM1 Once more, the wedding"worP  was thettode  namtused
by a terrorist group for a past #assassination attempt -154- Merletti wanted to reroute the
motorcade, but the alternate route would add forty-five minutes to the drive time. Clinton was very
angry, as he was already late for the meeting, but following the advice of the secret service possibly
saved his life. Two other bombs had been discovered in Manila earlier in the week so the threat
level that day was highP 551 Security personnel at the Manila International Airport uncovered
several grenades and a timing device in a travel bag.li561 Officials also discovered a bomb near a
major U.S. naval base. ag The president was scheduled to visit both these locations later in the
week. An intense investigation took place into the events in Manila and it was discovered that the
group behind the bridge bomb was a Saudi terrorist group in Afghanistan known as al-Qaeda and
the plot was mastermititled by Osama bin Laden.[ Until recently, this thwarted assassination
attempt was never made public and remained top secret. Only top members of the U.S. intelligence
community were aware of these events
4 PFI7TERrJ CF BE HO vice, - sex° it, IFMC,C_-1-ff\;C, - HeRRtt9GE
Second term (1997-2001) POCOSE31-S ,
Pro- CogINCR un)Oseet_ comNaris a DE N AMC
httiwi/An wikinwdia orniveiki/Rill Clinton 15/59
- : W22/22.1:31 PM
Cr5TC (ACV Jeffrey Epstein - Wkipedia
Epstein attended local public schools, first attending Public School 288, and then Mark Twain
Junior High School nearby Luis In 1967, Epstein attended the National Music Camp at the
Lnterlochen Center for the Arts.la21 He began playing the piano when he was five.(321 He graduated
in 1969 from Lafayette High School at age 16, having skipped two grades.(31113.2-1 Later that year, he
attended classes at Cooper Union until he changed colleges in 2972.131 From September 1971, he
attended the Courant Institute  of Mathematical Sciences at New York University, but left without
receiving a degree in June 1974.01[32-r —
Career
Teaching
Epstein started working in September 1974 as a physics and mathematics teacher for teens at the
Dalton School on the Upper East Side of Manhattan.Mbal  Donald Barr, who served as the
headmaster until June 1974,W-D5A321 was known to have made several unconventional
recruitments at the time, although it is unclear whether he had a direct role in hiring
Epstein$131[Vg381 Three months after Barr's departure, Epstein began to teach at the school,
despite his lack of credentials.L] Epstein allegedly showed inappropriate behavior toward
underage students at the time. 31L3-1 He became acquainted with Alan Greeplag, the chief
executive officer of Bear Stearns, whose son and daughter were attending the school. Greenberg's
daughter, Lynne Koeppel, pointed to a parent-teacher conference where Epstein influenced
another Dalton parent into advocating for him to Greenberg.(353 In June 1976, after Epstein was
dismissed from Dalton for "poor performance"Pa ][391[4131 Greenberg offered him a job at Bear
Stearns.[ao1IM1
Banking
' Epstein joined Bear Stearns in 1976 as a low-level junior assistant to a floor traderiA He swiftly
moved up to become an options trader,  working in the special products division, and then advised
the bank's wealthiest clients, such as Seagram president FASonfman, on tax mitigation
strategies.1322-431641 Jimmy Cape,  the bank's later chief executive officer, praised Epstein's skill
with wealthy clients and complex products. In 1980, four years after joining Bear Stearns, Epstein
became a limited partner.M
In 1981, he was asked to leave Bear Stearns for, according to his sworn testimony, being guilty of a
"Reg D violation".1-45113413°1 Even though Epstein departed abruptly, he remained dose to Cayne
and Greenberg and was a client of Bear Stearns until its collapse in 2008.1423
Finanbial consulting
In August 1981, Epstein founded his own consulting firm, Intercontinental Assets Group Inc.
(IAG),14§1 which assisttcl clients in recovering stolen money from fraudulent brokers and
lawyers.E3-21 Epstein described his work at this time as being a high-level bounty hunter.  He told
friends that  he worked sometimes as a consultant for governments  and the very wealthy to recover
embezzled funds, while at other times he worked for clients who had embezzled funds 130X41
Spanish actress and heiress Ana Obreg6n was one such wealthy client, whom Epstein helped in
1982 to recover her father's millions in lost investments, which had disappeared when Drysdale
Government Securities collapsed because of fraud.1413-1
\prilM OF 5egoAki...-rekrze-nAt PIRECT TARc er OF ersieN - Npodse-LL
coNN)ecTE-.O -cc a&-31- c;cA) - SE , OAL a)se fZ 0Q6,
V1 CO ict 1/41- ISCIS r.; C-,z5 eu6O.1 pc.)acpptienn - - GMAT - a009
raels - erelfr`IL plool
On .s.lit AV) Fn iThrxiar)Pit4r-AIT 0-16CM aaiN S5 eLAti 20%0

1. (urn
tiuttlitte Peat (C
(I Pl•atf t• 4-
SUbjer I
Re I lin Specialist Medical Centre
Lulls. ,!me Pear (2. Pr.: e peril r, n gal entrr information nn... I
1.n wit -lints Pearce P • Medical centre itJr
1,,, w‘eltne Prarce te: f Iklc5 dpplication;
lat.rveltnt Pr Ants
"' or, I
/3f."(Itit lint F At,
'a, flu. lint, P.
epirlinc Pi - IP -
• • I r "'hill PI 1“
Pr: _ c tr . uFFXEdicet ( entre info; met
P.F; The specialist fvledical (eptie.

Re. Specialist Merlsra
I., 1 '.;), . I.lt.dn•A
f ;,, ; 1, •i.•
'Message cannot be found
! P-- From a
VVi;liam Smith
Subject
(Spam] Specialist Medical Centre

╭───── Page 4, Image 1 ──────╮
│ PLAN PDCVELO PMENT - EMAIL │
│                            │
│ MAIL - 200g                │
│                            │
│ MEDICAL                    │
╰────────────────────────────╯

TIFF FILES - eRCEE-55 t-b/eac Cmeit_ LOGO IIIAMEIC EMAIL NEi,S - Ca , n€PftRilk-7(5\3-; t.rarer rn -47.vvrr, •
r-neclical .ansocsation letter
bilSIr letterhead mockup
'?k,f..151C Letteheartti-Adani  — 1-ANX-N<IECC-
I .1`.1( loge
loyo5. -
It -trick! sp.:
Eutf --K:c 6- - P-18 4te - CPSt - f)ItiZET-C1 GU:at-C/OK
medical association lettet
MSIC Intel head nu:i up
MSK Letterheatis•Arlam

b. MS1C logo
NASiC logos
- Kecc -- (QED VIP\ EMAIL 1 ,151C
MStC v5
[1 I (2)
N, IC  09011 (3)
MS1C2Ologorl 1 k4)
KISIC-20Intiog 1 (5)
MSIC%:10loyo[i]
MS1C%2.0boyolli

tk. Ptiblicationl.pub Supplies mix figuiet...pt,„ ."'.  ;.
13/04 /44.:(iic
i - 2C: /I 9
: 9.4:k
vs, frtt Act si 6(.17
la/04 )2012 4-38 P,
1011
Ica) 1- ,5(cAN 2c 70
1 (M1,('61:0:, 9:?13 .1>hY ;:
,:,1 f „JR
Prs4
.It(' p,t3tp.-?i
; :41 :;"
111!
_ j. _ • 1501.1= _
E zto ^OW C O1/43 -be-- -PART - REC6- t C5 1/4/ JA- e 0 -ALL- - 1 - AA u•Si N Ni -193/Litilaal 3:11f P141
Treining%20a 320Skills%20As...2t8/04/2011 2:10 PM
1. -florin 3./04/2011 2:29 PM
RPIAssessment Matrix_2011 (1)
PPLAssessment Matrix 2011 (2)
PPLAssessment Matrix 2011
StatetoryDeclaration200602
4,0512011 1031 AN!
5.14 ?I
20
07-CXY8 ce-c.S Nag:INC ASSASstNATIU\)
44-2007 MEDICAL BUSINFSS PLAN - SOURCE OF FUNDING / HOUSE SALE IN
PROGRESS - SEXUAL TARGETING / EMOTIONAL DESTRUCTION / SEGREGATION
OF THE FAMILY - SUSPECTED GROOMING / GOVERNMENT INTENTION -
PROSTITUTION
SHAUN STEELE - QUEENSLAND - ADELAIDE - 2007- 2009 - Employed in the Mining
Industry
PH :
Residing / Marital home - On the market for sale in progress -
Sources of Funding / Medical Business Plan
Introduced and encouraged into the relationship by Peter Bannister who had pursued me at
the Newcastle Hotel, Port Pirie .
Informed by Peter Bannister that Shaun Steele did not do drugs, was not involved in illegal
activity, would treat me like a queen and protect me from my ex husband, Darren
McDiarmid / restraining order / domestic violence.
Shaun Steele had been kicked out of his home at 14 years of age - living on the streets
He had met Peter Bannister at this time who had taken Shaun Steele into his home and had
become close friends from that point on.
PATTERN OF CONDUCT / BEHAVIOUR
44 Portrayed himself as a relationship / Defacto relationship - Senate Road, Port Pirie

• Gained trust - generous - kind - portrayed as being caring and supportive
• Constant contact with other women

• Womanising
• Ricky's on his neck - portraying cheating / being with other woman
• Lack of support and emotional cruelty

• Lying / secretive
• Drug involvement - narcotics
• Previous conduct with Prostitutes - Adelaide
• Informed me about a local woman of Port Pirie who we had passed in the township
that she was a Prostitute and that him and Peter Bannister called "Cucumber girl" - I
did not knbW-it r•r roman or that there was Prostitutes in the town of Port Pink
arriage Proposal' - Creating a false sense of security - Leading to emotional
destruction ring vulnerability I fall into the arms of someone else for emotional
comfort

• Claiming I was paranoid when questioning his conduct, saying that it was all in my
mind / delusional and blaming me for my reactions causing constant self doubt / break
down in confidence / breaking down the victim
Complete emotional destruction - creating vulnerability

• Physical and emotional attack - creating fear
• Encouraged me continuously to kick my second born son Kayne out of the home

• Segregation of the older children from the home by starting arguments between me
and my children and the children themselves - Moved children from the home for their
protection - remove the mothers protection of her eldest sons / twin sons

• Focused on my youngest child - gaining trust - turning him against his mother slowly
• Focused on my daughter - gaining trust - moved to Melbourne with her father

• Trying to persuade me and encourage me to do drugs constantly
• Starting saying "Thank you" after intimate moments / sex

• Endangered my safety on a motorbike - radical riding around the hills
• Property damage
az) 1 k DAVID ClOt1WS0N L•16-ODi1J6 ASSA5S) ICIAT (CAA
2011 - 2012 M.S.I.C, COMMUNICATION TOOL, MEDICAL BUSINESS PLAN IN
PROGRESS - J MONEQUIC, FASHION DESIGN BUSINESS IN DEVELOPMENT -
SEXUAL TARGETING - DATING SITE - POLICE AND GOVERNMENT
CONNECTIONS - CONNECTIONS TO AMERICA / CHILD ABDUCTION
2011 - 2012 - DAVID JOHNSON, RENMARK SOUTH AUSTRALIA - Employed as a
Mechanic / Engineer in Renmark - Previously resided in the Northern Territory with
partner Rebecca - 2 children from the relationship - Relocated to Renmark when partner
was pregnant with first child to be close to her family.
First met David Johnson on a dating site June 2011
David Johnson came to Port Piric for first meeting - 9 Yates Street, Port Pine
Second meeting I travelled to Renmark - met him at his employment location then went to
his home - place of residence / located on edge of town in the middle of a grape vine vineyard
Portrayed himself as very sweet, romantic, caring, gentle, educated and well spoken, social
drinker
Moved to Port Pine - Defacto relationship November 2011
Gained employment at the Port Pine Smelters - Nystar
3 PATTERN OF CONDUCT / BEHAVIOUR
Portrayed himself as a relationship / defacto relationship

• Gained trust - kind - gentle - portrayed as being reserved, suppor we, caring,
understanding, loyal, honest
Lied about his relocating to Port Pine - Snuck away from Renmark without informing
anyone but his employer - Did not inform his ex partner Rebecca or his children

• Lied about his drinking habits - Heavy drinker - alcoholic
• Womanising - placed himself in locations of a woman that Shaun Steele had slept with
while I was in that relationship - Stared at her while in her presence while in my
presence - causing a sense of fore coming betrayal - start of emotional destruction

• Constantly got excited in other women's presence - acted inappropriately
• Continual sudden mechanical problems with my vehicle - continual mechanical
problems with vehicle and household white goods after end of relationship

• Lied about deleting his dating site profiles - numerous dating site profiles including
Facebook dating site

• Bought a new phone and changed his phone number - Reason no more contact with his
ex partner Rebecca, Renmark SA

• Lied about his contact with his employment officer - Ezra - Recruitment office for
Nystar, Port Pine

• Lied about his contact with a nurse of Nystar - Informed me that the nurse was a male
nurse - was a female nurse - lead testing

• Emotional turmoil - creating self doubt / loss of confidence / sense of betrayal -
breaking den the victim

• Denial of his behaviour / womanising - claiming that it was all in my mind / delusional
• Lying / secretive - conflicting / contradicting his answers when questioned about his
self doubt - questioning my own behaviour

• Marria e Pro osal False sense of security / relationship security - leading to
e ction and vulnerability - fall into the arms of someone else for
emotional comfort - I declined - the relationship did not feel stable or felt a long lasting
connection with David Johnson - no deep emotional connection
ogee - czoici v iNCElvv Boca E: AS -SASS' NATIOq
PATTERN OF CONDUCT / BEHAVIOUR
Portrayed himself as a relationship / Defacto relationship -

• Targeting on a dating site
• Gained trust - generous - kind - sensitive - portrayed as being caring and supportive,
kind natured and trust worthy

• Deceitful - Lying about his relationship partner Tula Terry - Lying about his name -
Lying about the photographs on the dating site that were a prostitute - Lying about
looking for sexual experimentation - constant lying about his behaviour and activities

• Prostitution involvement - Sophia, Adelaide
• Continuous lying - Deceitful Behaviour
• Denial of behaviour - Womanising

• Portrayed betrayal to cause emotional devastation - Scratches on his neck and
shoulders as if being with another woman and lying claiming that "Your nails are
sharp" when we had not had sexual relations before the event

• Started saying "Thank you" after sexual interactions - form of grooming for
prostitution and disrespect of the relationship and victim

• Reverse tactic of Fraudulent Activity and Targeting - To confuse the victim and make
her believe that he had become the target and he was not the predator of sexual
targeting and government targeting

• Conspiring with the Government - Second attempt of Murder to appear as suicide /
Psychological encouragement - Claiming that I had a Mental Health Problem and that
I was delusional about his behaviour

• Womanising - Constant contact with other woman - Constant attention to other women
about other women
Numerous marriage proposals - Creating a false sense of security
estruction to create vulnerability / fall into the arms of someone
else for emotional comfort

• Started to become un-supporting - Claimed he would reduce his work travel
commitments but instead increased them leaving me at home un-supported and alone
in the home - Resulting in emotional vulnerability

• Started to show a lack of interest in sexual relations
• Portrayed as a relationship - Introduced me to his parents and sister in France -
Deceitful behaviour, no respect for his family or myself - Introduced me to his
employment colleagues

• Provided a lavish lifestyle and numerous expensive gifts
• Sexual Targeting during my fathers illness, Terminal Cancer

• Denial of involvement in targeting or knowledge of the targeting - Deceitful behaviour
• Emotional destruction

• intellectual Property Theft - Medical Research Project 2014 - 2016, hand written in
Port Pine and a proposal submitted to Pharmaceutical Company 2016 in his possession
and funded by the Government

• Unusual comments
• Suicidal tendencies - Threatening suicide
• Unusual behaviour - portrayed behaviour of what I was researching on Goggle about
womanising.while he was at work - Watching / Access to Government Shared Illegal
Surveillance
• Family Criminal Involvement - Murder / Grandfather, Sicily
• Ceased contact without explanation
FAMILY NiSTORy MURDeR - FRANCE -
CerN7 f3C)CO
I removed all business concepts from my computer and copied all files to a disconnected
harddrive. The business concepts and developments were stored in a locked vault designed
through McAfee Security System and was password protected. McAfee Security System is
password protected and password protected for administration changes as well
All newly created accounts and security systems are 2 step verification coded, and
Authentication app is required in order to access any accounts or systems on my new
computer system, mobile phone and Apple Tablet.
Second hacking occurred following all these measures being used and put in place.
Mobile phone security upgrade - Finger print authentication on all access to apps, screen,
opening of phone, security systems, phone calls, messages, photo gallery / McAfee Security
System - Nord VPN - Malwarebytes Security System - Password and fingerprint encoded on
all access points
Refer to file - Telstra report Fraudulent activity - Continuous hacking of account / personal
and then business account - Direct Targeting of the Individual
Government are gaining direct access through the account registered in their company
Telstra / Government owned / Foreign investors
I am now currently not receiving constant correspondence from my contracted publisher
Austin Macauley Publishers, London concerning the second contract,  second edition of the
book developments : Email :
Business email, server GoDaddy, America
Suspected : Intellectual Property Theft / Publishing House Copyright Laws, individuals
involved in the targeting to sell the books on the Black Market and intercept success of the
publications sabotaging the publishing house, Austin Macauley Publishers, investment in
their client / profit from book sales and the success of their client / victim of targeting
FAMILY HISTORY OF CRIMINAL ACTIVITY - BULONE
Vincent Bulone informed me during our relationship that his grandfather, Vincenzo
Salvatore Bulone, Sicily was involved in a murder. His grandfather Vincenzo Salvatore
Bulone had shot dead a man in Sicily over a woman and then fled to New York to escape
conviction and to hide. Vincent Bulone is named after his grandfather but was adapted for
the French region from Vincenzo Salvatore Bulone to Vincent Salvatore Bulone.
Vincent Bulone's family relocated to France from Sicily :
Address
France
Vincent Bulone has a older sister who resides in France also.
At the time of meeting his sister she wasgoing through a divorce. She has two children, a son
and a daughter, the "daughters name is who Vincent is in constant contact with
his sister and neice via Whatsapp app
Refer to Folder 17. Whatsapp app
115M
› ,kteSre - FR^ OCE - .66)(041/44- 6 0 5C - tOCAZS
6/22/22, 1:3
Th kc -
v m cell -  Own) 6 Jeffrey Epstein Wilaperha
In March 2005, a woman contacted Florida's Palm Beach Police
Department and alleged that her 14-year-old stepdaughter had been
taken to Epstein's mansion by an older girl. While there, she was
allegedly paid $300 (equivalent to $420 in 2021) to strip and massage
Epstein.19-3.1 She had allegedly undressed, but left the encounter
wearing her underwear.19.3.1
Palm Beach Police began a 13-month undercover investigation of
Epstein, including a search of his homen941 During the
investigation, Palm Beath Police Chief Michael Reiter publicly
accused the Palm Beach County state prosecutor., Barry Krischer, of
being too lenient and called for help from the FI3I.M1
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) then became involved.
Subsequently, the police alleged that  Epstein had paid several girls to
perform sexual acts with himiN  Interviews with five alleged victims and 17 witnesses under oath,
a high-school transcript and other items found in Epstein's trash and home allegedly showed that
some of the girls involved were under 18, the youngest being 14, with many under 16.(25-19-4) The
police search of Epstein's home found two hidden cameras and large numbers of photos of girls
throughout the house, some of whom the police had interviewed in the course of their
investigation.1.9-31 Adriana Ross, a former model from Poland who became an Epstein assistant,
reportedly removed computer drives and other electronic equipment from the financier's Florida
mansion before Palm Beach Police searched the home as part of their investigation. M The court
documents record that a search of Epstein's residence by Palm Beach Police detective Joseph
Recarey in 2005 uncovered an incriminating Amazon receipt containing books on S&M. The books
he ordered are titled: SM tot A Realistic Introduction, SlaveCraft: Roadmaps for Erotic
Servitude — Principles, Skills and Tools and Training with Miss Abernathy: A Workbook for
Erotic Slaves and Their Oumers.1241
A former employee told the police that Epstein would receive massages three times a day.1931
' Eventually the FBI compiled reports on "34 confirmed minors" eligible for restitution (increased to
40 in the NPA) whose allegations of sexual abuse by Epstein included corroborating details.1221
Julie Brown's 2018 exposes in the Miami Herald  identified about 8o victims and located about 6o
4 -illern:raga:is She quotes the then police chief Reiter as saying "This was 5o-something 'shes'
and one 'he'—and the 'shes' all basically told the same story." ill Details from the investigation
included allegations that 12-year-old triplets were flown in from France for Epstein's birthday, and
flown back the following day after being sexually abused by the financier. It was alleged that young
girli were recruited from Brazil and other South American countries, former Soviet countries, and
Europe, and that Jean-Luc Brunel's "MC2" modeling agency was also supplying girls to
Epstein.195X1011ral
Epstein's 2006 mugshot
In May 2006, Palm Beach police filed a probable cause affidavit saying that Epstein should be
charged with four counts of unlawful sex with minors and one count of sexual abuse.E901°31 On
July 27, 2006, Epstein was arrested by the Palm Beach Police Department on state felony charges
of procuring a minor for prostitution and solicitation of a prostitute. He was booked at the Palm
Beach County jail and later released on a $3,000 bond.[5i(9111°41415.1' State prosecutor Krischer
later convened a Palm Beach County &rand Lux,  which was usually only done in capital cases.
Presented evidence from only two victims, the grand jury returned a single charge of felony
solicitation of prostitution,La cki to which Epstein pleaded not guilty in August 2006.rani
Epstein's defense lawyers included Ro_y Black, Gerald Lefcourt, Harvard Law School professor
Alan Dershowitz, and former U.S. Solicitor General Ken Starry.  163) Linguist Steven Pinker also
assisted.V°91
C••••••4•••
EFTA01246710 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Perry Lang, Epstein's chef who says Donald Trump came to Epstein's house for dinner
(inferred date: 2026-01-05)
FD-302(Itev.5-S-I0) -1 of 5-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
OFFICIAL RECORD
Date of entry  02/09/2021
ADAM PERRY LANG, was interviewed over video conference by AUSA
, AUSA , AUSA Detective
and Special Agent Also present for this interview was PERRY
LANG's attorneys Larry Lustberg and Marquis Whitney. After being advised of
the identity of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview,
PERRY LANG provided the following information:
PERRY LANG currently works in a restaurant business which he opened in
Napa California. He is a chef and operator. He enjoys training and
teaching people.
Between approximately 1998-2002 PERRY LANG worked for JEFFREY EPSTEIN.
Prior to working for EPSTEIN, PERRY LANG was a chef at a restaurant. He had
gotten back surgery so he looked into being a private chef. He looked in
the New York Times where he was connected to an employment agency.
He was then told to go to EPSTEIN's office around Madison Avenue in the
50's. There he met with and was interviewed by GHISLAINE MAXWELL. PERRY
LANG was very confused as to why MAXWELL interviewed him and not EPSTEIN.
MAXWELL was excited about meeting PERRY LANG. It was a whirlwind of an
interview. PERRY LANG was given an address to audition for the job. He
then goes to 71st street. He had to use his own credit card to get the food,
bring it there and cook. He was then hired.
PERRY LANG's job description was that he was basically on call 24/7. He
had a beeper. Sometimes PERRY LANG would work 30 days then he would be off
for 30 days. PERRY LANG would cook for business meetings and sometimes he
would serve at them. For dinner he would leave things out for EPSTEIN.
PERRY LANG would primarily work in New York at the 71st street address. It
was very formal. He would call MAXWELL "Ms. Maxwell" and would never call
EPSTEIN "Jeffrey".
New York, New York, United States (, Other (Video
howigation on 09/25/2020  at Conference))
Aka 500-NY-3027571
by BYRNE PAUL WILSON, Amanda Nicole Young
Dawdmfted 02/02/2021

CONFIDENTIAL 3501.129-006
Page 1 of 5
FD-302a(Rev.5-8-10)
50D —NY-3027571
CominustionofFD-302of (D) Interview of ADAM PERRY LANG .on 09/25/2020 _page 2 of S
PERRY LANG would sometimes cook at the 65th street address for MAXWELL.
PERRY LANG worked for EPSTEIN full time between 1998-2002. The job was
about the same during the whole 4 years. EPSTEIN bought the island during
that time period and was furnishing the ranch. PERRY LANG would get a call
or text from EPSTEIN's personal assistant LESLIE and sometimes MAXWELL.
They would tell PERRY LANG what the schedule is and the different things to
cook including plane snacks.
PERRY LANG mostly reported to MAXWELL; if not her, then he would report
to LESLEY (mostly in New York) .
MAXWELL was quite materialistic. She went from upbeat to withdrawn to
aggressive with PERRY LANG. She tells PERRY LANG that he is not allowed to
talk to the guests. PERRY LANG states it is almost like EPSTEIN had
something on MAXWELL. She was always running around and coordinating things
making sure he was happy. PERRY LANG thought she was his girlfriend at one
point but she was his employee.
On one occasion there was a guest who asked PERRY LANG his opinion on a
real estate matter. PERRY LANG felt like it was a set up. PERRY LANG
talked with him. MAXWELL did not talk to PERRY LANG after this interaction
for about a day.
PERRY LANG was asked about guests. PERRY LANG mentions NATHAN MYHRVOLD
(involved with Microsoft), LARRY SUMMERS and BILL CLINTON. PERRY LANG
states that CLINTON was on the plane. He ate off of PERRY LANG's cutting
board.
PERRY LANG was asked about minors. He states that he wouldn't say minors
but there were definitely young women. PERRY LANG didn't think something
was wrong and when EPSTEIN had women around, he didn't think that kids were
getting exploited. Looking back now everyone was happy go lucky.
EPSTEIN sometimes would get angry. EPSTEIN was very good at math.
EPSTEIN was laid back and the world was his oyster. PERRY LANG didn't
really know what he did.
PERRY LANG was asked if he would describe ever seeing a teenager there.
He states that got the college girl impression.
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.129-006
Page 2 of 5
FD-3029(Rev.5-8-10)
50D —NY-3027571
ContinuationofFD-302of (V) Interview of ADAM PERRY LANG .o n 09/25/2020 ,p age 3 of 5
PERRY LANG lists seeing the following girls all of whom he believed were
about 19-25 years old:
Both and worked for EPSTEIN but answered to MAXWELL.
PERRY LANG was asked about massages. He states that he believed that
massages were a big part of EPSTEIN's life at the time. EPSTEIN was a
stressed businessman that was into massage therapy. PERRY LANG later learns
that these massages were sexual.
The massages would be in the calendar and scheduled. Mostly in New York
was the only knowledge that PERRY LANG had of this. PERRY LANG did not have
access to the schedule.
In Florida, their house manager JOHN would schedule the massages.
Possibly LESLEY would schedule them but PERRY LANG would be guessing.
It's possible that and would schedule massages.
PERRY LANG was asked if he ever saw people massaging EPSTEIN. He states
yes, there was an office off to the left where they would wait. Sometimes
they would wait in the kitchen. EPSTEIN had a massage room upstairs at 71st
street. The massages happened several times a day. The people who came to
massage him were mostly female. On the island there was a male and there
was one in New York. His name was GYPSY GITA and he was a Native American
healer who would burn sage.
PERRY LANG states the women who would come were active women, college
looking girls, some maybe older. Girls would arrive and deal with the main
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.129-006
Page 3 of 5
FD•302a (Rev. 5•&10)
SOD —NY-3O27571
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of ADAM PERRY LANG ,on 09/25/2020 .p age 4 of 5
house manager LYN, whose last name was possibly FONTINELLA.
PERRY LANG dealt with RICHARD who was another house manager and JOJO the
driver.
There were several chefs prior to PERRY LANG but he does not know their
names.
PERRY LANG was asked if he's had conversations or overheard conversations
about young women to which he states no. He's asked if he's had or
overheard conversations about EPSTEIN's sexual preferences to which he
states no. He's asked if he's had or overheard conversations about the
massage to which he states no.
PERRY LANG was asked about other guests. He states that he doesn't know
of other guests who got massages. PRINCE ANDREW was a guest that MAXWELL
was very excited about. She said it was a big deal and it was PRINCE
ANDREW's first time being a guest. PERRY LANG saw him both in Florida and
the Virgin Islands. He came on the plane one time. DONALD TRUMP came for
dinner one night.
PERRY LANG is not sure who made the travel arrangements but thinks it may
have been LESLEY.
PERRY LANG recalls that the DUBINs were occasionally on the plane. He
also recalls and were on the plane. PERRY LANG was asked if he
ever observed anything strange on the plane to which he states not really.
PERRY LANG was asked if he remembers seeing anyone nude. He stated that
he was grilling in the Virgin Islands and recalls seeing a nude woman who's
name he does not know.
In 2002 he departed from EPSTEIN. PERRY LANG's wife had graduated
college and his back was better. He wanted to go into business for himself
and was nervous to quit. It was a big step but he gave his notice. EPSTEIN
seemed unphased. PERRY LANG did not have to sign any paperwork when leaving
the job. PERRY LANG just recalls signing a non-disclosure agreement prior
to starting the job.
On one occasion PERRY LANG asked for a personal day. He left food in the
fridge for EPSTEIN to eat. Later that night MAXWELL calls PERRY LANG
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.129-006
Page 4 of 5
FD-302a (Rev. 54-10)
50D —NY-3027571
CominustionofFD402of (D) Interview of ADAM PERRY LANG .on 09/25/2020 _page 5 of 5
yelling, asking if he left food out. She tells PERRY LANG to just make sure
he says he is sorry for whatever it is and EPSTEIN wanted to see him the
next morning.
The next day EPSTEIN was very aggressive with PERRY LANG. EPSTEIN was
very upset, had an intense energy and was scary.
PERRY LANG was asked if after leaving the job if he talked to anyone else
involved. PERRY LANG states yes that he chatted with EPSTEIN about PERRY
LANG's business plan. EPSTEIN tells PERRY LANG that he can call EPSTEIN if
he ever has business questions. PERRY LANG has another business meeting
with EPSTEIN. PERRY LANG thanked EPSTEIN for giving him business advice by
giving him a massage therapist on one occasion. PERRY LANG sends a 35-year -
old massage therapist to EPSTEIN's house. After the session the therapist
tells PERRY LANG that EPSTEIN tells her to tell PERRY LANG that he has a
chest full of sex toys. This incident occurred around 2003 and PERRY LANG
does not remember the therapist's name.
PERRY LANG wanted to go into a deal with a steakhouse owner who knew
EPSTEIN. This man tells PERRY LANG to go to EPSTEIN and bring him a snorkel
and a mask. PERRY LANG does this.
Around 2007 was the last time that PERRY LANG spoke with EPSTEIN.
Before 2008 PERRY LANG spoke with a female FBI agent. Towards the end of
this interview the agent tells PERRY LANG that it's about sex trafficking.
Lots of media have tried to talk to PERRY LANG but he does not speak with
them.
PERRY LANG has never spoken to private investigators.
has been quite aggressive in trying to contact PERRY
LANG. He does not recall her at all. He heard of her around 2014.
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.129-006
Page 5 of 5
EFTA00004898 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00005718 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-06)
^C.
Ameen-
..41x727,e/sof ///d4

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ || A719 WS 1/06   │
╰───────────────────╯

╭──── Page 2, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 4, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Silvia I. Motto Building
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
Yew York, New York 10007
July 5, 2019
Re: Grand Jury Subpoena
Please be advised that the accompanying grand jury subpoena has been issued in connection with
an official criminal investigation of a suspected felony being conducted by a federal grand jury. The
Government hereby requests that you voluntarily refrain from disclosing the existence of the subpoena to
any third party. While you are under no obligation to comply with our request, we are requesting you not
to make any disclosure in order to preserve the confidentiality of the investigation and because disclosure
of the existence of this investigation might interfere with and impede the investigation.
Moreover, if you intend to disclose the existence of this subpoena to a third party, please let me
know before making any such disclosure.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
By:
Very truly yours,
GEO Y S. BERMAN
Assistant United States Attorneys
Grand Jury Subpoena
Pnitetratatez Pis -frith arturt
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
TO:
GREETINGS:
WE COMMAND YOU that all and singular business and excuses being laid aside, you appear and attend before
the GRAND JURY of the people of the United States for the Southern District of New York, at the United States
Courthouse, 40 Foley Square, Room 220, in the Borough of Manhattan, City of New York, New York, in the
Southern District of New York, at the following date, time and place:
Appearance Date: July 24, 2019 Appearance Time: 10:00 a.m.
to testify and give evidence in regard to an alleged violation of:
18 U.S.C. §§ 1591, 2421, 2422, 2423, 371
and not to depart the Grand Jury without leave thereof, or of the United States Attorney, and that you bring
with you and produce at the above time and place the following:
See attached Advice of Rights
Failure to attend and produce any items hereby demanded will constitute contempt of court and will
subject you to civil sanctions and criminal penalties, in addition to other penalties of the Law.
DATED: New York, New York
July 5, 2019
GEOFFREY S. BalifAN
the
ork
Assistant United tates Attorneys
One St. Andrew's Plaza
New York, New York 10007
Telephone:
rev. 02.01.12
Advice of Rights

1. You may refuse to answer any question if a truthful answer to the question would tend to
incriminate you.

2. Anything that you do say may be used against you by the grand jury or in a subsequent legal
proceeding.

3. If you have a lawyer, the grand jury will permit you a reasonable opportunity to step outside the
grand jury room to consult with your lawyer if you so desire.

4. If you would like a lawyer but do not have funds to retain one, you may make an application to
the United States Magistrate Judge who will decide whether to appoint a lawyer to represent you.
1 o I
https://www.ejustice.ny.gov/wps/PA_DMVPhotoService/FetchlmageServlet?imageId=4790... 6/5/2019
EFTA00009512 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-06)
1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF
WEST PALM BEACH
FLORIDA
8 IN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR
arb 12
Grand Jury #07-103 (TUES-wPB)
west Palm Beach, Florida
Tuesday, May 15, 2007
15 TESTIMONY
16 OF
21 APPEARANCE:
22 III , As I ANT . ATTORNEY
23 NANCY SIEGEL, COURT RE
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 PROCEEDINGS
3 The sworn testimony of. was taken
4 before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach Division,
5 701 Clematis Street, West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County,
6 state of Florida, on the 15th day of May, 2007.
7 NANCY SIEGEL, Registered Merit Reporter and Notary
8 Public was authorized to and did report the sworn
9 testimony.
10 Thereupon,
12 a witness of lawful age, having been first duly sworn by
13 the foreperson, testified on her oath as follows:
14 BY
15 Q Good morning, Special Agent. Could you state
16 and spell your name for the record.
17 A Special Agent II
19 Q And with whom do you work?
20 A The FBI here in West Palm Beach.
21 Q And are you here today on the continuing
22 investigation known as Operation Leap Year?
23 A Yes, I am.
24 Q And you are one of the case agents on this
25 investigation, correct?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 A Yes, I am.
2 Q The last time you were here we were discussing
3 the evidence supporting various overt acts and charges
4 related to Jane Does number 1 and 2?
5 A Yes.
6 Q Today we are going to start with Jane Doe
7 number 3. Can you tell the Grand Jury who that is and
8 summarize briefly your previous testimony about her.
9 A Jane Doe number 3 is I and she first
10 started, we have first phone contact with
11 starting in December of 2004, IIIIIII would have been 16
12 or 17 at that time, let me do the math real quick, she
13 would have been 16 -- sorry, I am sorry, she would have
14 been at that time 17, let's get it right, so she started
15 phone contact, started calling her in
16 September of 2004.
17 From testimony we know that went there
18 earlier, much earlier. I, which was Jane Doe
19 number 4 you will hear about next, they were good
20 friends and they both went in the spring of '04, prior
21 to 17th birthday, so did start giving
22 mr. Epstein massages when she was 16, she performed a
23 few massages for Mr. Epstein and then took kind of a
24 little bit of a break.
25 The sexual activity that occurred with
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 Mr. Epstein when was under the age of 18
2 included
she was given gifts by Mr. Epstein, she was
5 given a , she was given Victoria Secret
6 underwear, she was also given a car that Mr. Epstein
7 rented for her for a number of months, she was paid $200
8 by Mr. Epstein and was the one that primarily
9 called to set up appointments and as you can see
10 that began in December of '04.
11 was also one of Mr. Epstein's
12 favorites, according to several of the other girls.
13 Q Just so the Grand Jury has an idea, how does
14 that translate into the number of phone calls between
15 and that you were able to calculate?
16 A called her, I guess calls between
17 the two of them ranged around 125 phone calls from
18 December 6th, 2004 until October, 2005.
19 Q And just briefly can you remind the Grand Jury
20 did ever tell Mr. Epstein her age?
21 A No, they did not ever discuss, she did not
22 tell him how old she was, but she did tell him where she
23 planned on going to school and that she was in
24 she stated that when it came to her age that
25 Mr. Epstein didn't care. As I mentioned earlier,
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
S
1 and IIIIIII were very good friends and IIIII would talk
2 about IIIIIII and Mr. Epstein would ask questions about
3 when IIIII was providing massages and as we will
4 talk about when we talk about Jane Doe number 4, which
5 is , she told Mr. Epstein that she was a junior in
6 high school and that and her were in the
7 and that they were
8 and told us that at one point IIIII had come to
9 her because she had slipped about prom and she was
10 worried because Epstein was supposed to think she was 18
11 and she had talked about the prom and said she
12 never heard anything else about it and they never
13 brought it up.
14 Q Because, according to , Mr. Epstein
15 didn't care really how old the girls were?
16 A Exactly.
17 Q And she never mentioned he asked her for her
18 age or asked for any form of identification to show
19 whether she was or was not over 18?
20 A No.
21 Q Now, if you could turn to the proposed
22 indictment and if I could ask you to look at overt act
23 number 59.
24 A we had a little knock at the door Do you
25 want me to get it?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 Q Yes.
2 (Thereupon, there was a brief pause.)
3 A I will let you see a picture of Jane Doe
4 number 4, , who we were talking about earlier, and
5 this is . Is there anyplace you want to put it
6 right down here in front?
7 - Q And just so the record is clear, those are the
8 photographs that we showed to the Grand Jury last week?
9 A Yes, it is.
10 Q So if you could turn to overt act number 59
11 which appears on page 12, and if you could explain to
12 the Grand Jury the evidence we have related to that
13 phone call or phone calls on December 6th, 2004.
14 A On December 6th, 2004 a review of the phone
15 records indicate that there was telephonic phone contact
16 between the numbers belonging to and
17 , as well as we have evidence with
18 statements of the phone calls being made to
19 her by
20 Q And overt act number 60?
21 A A review of the phone records indicate
22 telephonic contact between the numbers belonging to
23 and on December 12, 2004.
24 Q And overt act number 64?
25 A A review of the phone records indicate
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 telephonic contact between numbers belonging to IIIII
2 IIIIII and M= en December 14th, 2004.
3 Q And just so that it is clear to the Grand
4 Jury, when the overt acts says that defendant IIIIII
5 made one or more telephone calls, that means that the
6 call is originating from IIIII phone, is that
7 correct?
8 A Yes, it does.
9 Q And if you could turn to overt act number 71.
10 A On December 20th a review of the phone records
11 indicate that there was telephonic contact between III'S
12 and
13 Q And overt act number 79?
14 A On January 6th, 2005 a review of phone records
15 indicate there was telephone contact between numbers
16 belonging to and
17 Q And number 83?
18 A On January 14th, 2005 a review of the phone
19 records indicate telephonic contact between numbers
20 belonging to and
21 Q And with respect to the other overt acts
22 related to the phone calls which would be 94, 100, 102,
23 104, 112, 118, 125, 129 and 132 is the evidence the
24 same?
25 A Yes, on or about each of those dates a review
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 of the phone records indicated telephonic contact
2 between the numbers belonging to and
3 as well as statements.
4 Q Now, if I could direct your attention to Count
5 number 7 which appears on page 26 of the draft
6 indictment, that is a charge of indictment of a minor
7 during the period of December 6th, 2004 through June 2nd
8 of 2005, could you summarize for the Grand Jury the
9 evidence related to that count.
10 A On or about these dates the facility of
11 interstate commerce, the telephone, specifically
12 and were utilized to set up
13 appointments, massage appointments for Epstein.
14 During the massages and on more than one
15 occasion Epstein , he
16 used a and Epstein
17 directed to straddle him while he
18 and , he would
19 , he would as she was
20 straddling him, there was
21 , though.
22 He touched breasts, he would
23 He paid on multiple occasions $200.
24 Both and Jeffrey Epstein have escorted
25 upstairs for these massages and Mr. Epstein gave
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 a , victoria secret bra and panty sets
2 and he also rented her a car for several months.
3 Q And just so that it is clear, you mentioned he
4 paid her on several occasions, he paid her every time
5 she performed these lewd acts, correct?
6 A ves, 8200.
7 Q And is listed as a defendant with
8 respect to Jane Doe number 3 as well, and can you
9 explain to the Grand Jury a little bit more about who
10 is and why she is charged in this count?
11 A IIIIIII is one of Mr. Epstein's personal
12 assistants as well and she made appointments for him for
13 these massages.
14 we have contact between phone
15 and phone, she contacted approximately
16 25 times.
17 Q And that's why she is also charged with
18 someone who is either an aider or abetter or a
19 coconspirator with respect to this?
20 A ves.
21 Q Okay. If I could direct your attention to
22 count number 32 which appears on page 30, count number
23 32.
24 A I got 32.
25 Q what is the evidence related to?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 A I am sorry, I didn't hear you ask me the
2 question, I thought you said refer to it.
3 The evidence is we have flight records that
4 indicate on December 13th, 2004 Epstein traveled to Palm
5 Beach County on the Gulfstream, there was telephonic
6 contact between and the day
7 before or the day of travel, we also have the sexual
8 conduct between Jeffrey Epstein and as we
9 described earlier in Count 7.
10 Q And just to refresh the recollection of the
11 Grand Jury, the Gulfstream aircraft is the one owned by
12 Hyperion?
13 A Air, Inc.
14 Q And when you said that there was telephone
15 contact, you recall that in overt act number 60 that we
16 discussed phone calls on December 12th, correct?
17 A we did.
18 Q Okay. If I could direct you to count number
19 35 and if you could tell the Grand Jury about the
20 evidence according to that count.
21 A Again, we have flight records that indicate
22 that on January 6th, 2005 Epstein traveled to Palm Beach
23 County on the Gulfstream again, there was telephonic
24 contact between and the day before,
25 the day of that travel, we also talked about the sexual
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 conduct between Jeffrey and MEM, between Epstein and
2 illillt
3 Q And can you tell us again what aircraft they
4 flew on on January 6th?
5 A That was the Gulfstream which was owned by
6 Hyperion Air, Inc.
7 Q okay. If I could direct you to Count 36 and
8 again if you could summarize that evidence.
9 A we have flight records that indicate that on
10 January 14th, 2005 Epstein, and traveled to
11 Palm Beach county on the Boeing 727 that Mr. Epstein
12 owns, there was telephonic contact between
13 and the day before, the day of that
14 travel, as well as we have the sexual conduct between
15 Jeffrey Epstein and as we described
16 earlier, and I will tell you that is --
17 , Mr. Epstein's personal assistant, and is
18 we talked about just a few minutes ago,
19 Mr. Epstein, another of Mr. Epstein's personal
20 assistants.
21 Q And if I could direct your attention to Count
22 37 and ask you to summarize the evidence related to that
23 count.
24 A we have flight records that indicate that on
25 February 3rd, 2005 Mr. Epstein and traveled
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy I of 13
1 to Palm Beach County on the Boeing 727, there was
2 telephonic contact between and
3 the day before or the day of travel and we have
4 the sexual conduct between Epstein and
5 Q And if I could direct your attention to Count
6 number 38.
7 'A In count number 38 we have flight records that
8 indicate on February 10th, 2005 Mr. Epstein,
9 and traveled to
10 Palm Beach County on the Gulfstream, there was telephone
11 contact between and the day
12 before or the day of travel, we also have the sexual
13 conduct between Mr. Epstein and
14 Q Now, I am sorry, on count number 38, which
15 airline were they on?
16 A They were on the Gulfstream.
17 Q Can I ask you to double-check that? There is
18 an inconsistency between the chart and the indictment or
19 we can save that for a later date.
20 A It is right here.
21 Q I will mark that we need to check on Count
22 number 38.
23 A I have the flight manifest with me if you want
24 me to check, I don't know if you want me to do that now.
25 Q Yes, if you don't mind.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 (Thereupon, there was a brief pause.)
2 A In Count 38, flight records indicate on
3 February 10th, 2005 that Mr. Epstein, IIIII
4 IIIIIII and IME were in fact on the
5 Boeing 727.
6 Q So the draft indictment contains the correct
7 information?
8 A Yes, it does.
9 Q what company owns the Boeing 727?
10 A JEGE, Inc., Incorporated.
11 Q And if I could take you to Count number 39.
12 A Evidence shows through flight records that on
13 February 21st, 2005 Epstein,
14 and traveled to Palm Beach county on
15 the Boeing 727, there was telephonic contact between
16 and the day before or the day
17 of travel, there was also the sexual conduct between
18 Epstein and
19 Q And if I could take you to count number 40,
20 please.
21 A we have flight records that indicate on
22 February 24th, 2005 Epstein,
23 traveled to Palm Beach County on the Boeing
24 727, there was telephonic contact between
25 and the day before, the day of travel, and
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 there was sexual conduct between Jeffrey Epstein and
2 as we described earlier in Count 7.
3 Q And if you could do Count 42.
4 A We have evidence that shows flight records,
5 that flight records indicate that on March 18th, 2005
6 Epstein traveled to Palm Beach County on the Boeing 727,
7 there was telephonic contact between and
8 the day of or the day before travel, we
9 have the sexual conduct between Mr. Epstein and
10 Q And just referring to that count,
11 is named, although she was not on the flight that day,
12 is that correct?
13 A Yes.
14 Q And you said that she made the telephone calls
15 with , correct?
16 A Yes, and we also do have -- we have
17 interviewed Mr. Epstein's pilots and one of the pilots
18 indicated that was the one that arranged all of
19 Mr. Epstein's travel arrangements and so she is
20 responsible for making his arrangements to travel to
21 Palm Beach as well as call the girls for the
22 appointments.
23 Q If I could take you to Count number 43,
24 please.
25 A Flight records indicate that on March 31st,
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 2005 mr. Epstein traveled to Palm Beach County on the
2 Boeing 727, there was telephonic contact between IIIII
3 IIIIII and SIM the day before or the day of travel,
4 we also have the sexual conduct between Epstein as
5 IIIIIII  described earlier in Count 7.
6 Q Again, in Count 44, what is the evidence
7 related to that?
8 A Flight records indicate that on April 8th,
9 2005 Epstein and traveled to Palm Beach
10 county on the Gulfstream and there was telephonic
11 contact between IIIII and on the
12 day before or the day of travel, we also have the sexual
13 conduct between Mr. Epstein and
14 Q And if you could go through 45, 46 and 47.
15 A Count 45 we have flight records that indicate
16 on April 27th, 2005 Epstein and traveled to
17 Palm Beach County on the Gulfstream, there is telephone
18 contact between and the day
19 before or the day of travel and we have the sexual
20 conduct between Jeffrey and
21 In Count 46 we have flight records that
22 indicate that on May 6th, 2005 Epstein, and
23 traveled to Palm Beach County on the
24 Gulfstream.
25 we have also telephonic contact between
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 and either the day before or the
2 day of travel and we have the sexual conduct between
3 Epstein and , and in Count 47 on May 19th, 2005
4 we have flight records that indicate Epstein,
5 and traveled to Palm Beach County on
6 the Gulfstream and we have telephone contact between
7 and the day before or the day
8 of travel.
9 we also have the sexual conduct between
10 Epstein and as described in the earlier
11 count, Count 7.
12 Q Now, if I could direct your attention to Count
13 number 51 which appears on page 33, that is the sex
14 trafficking of a minor involving Jane Doe number 3, and
15 could you briefly summarize that, the evidence related
16 to that.
17 A As we discussed earlier in count 7, I told you
18 guys about the sexual conduct between Epstein and
19 , the monies that were paid to by
20 Mr. Epstein, the phone activity we discussed between
21 and , it began in December,
22 and we also have phone calls beginning in January from
23 to , at that time was 17
24 years of age, and we also have statements from
25 and regarding Mr. Epstein's knowledge of their
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 ages.
2 Q And with respect to the affect on interstate
3 commerce related to that count we have both the
4 telephone calls, correct?
S A Yes.
6 Q As well as Mr. Epstein actually traveling in
7 interstate commerce to engage in this activity, correct?
8 A Yes, we do.
9 Q Is there anything else that you would like to
10 mention about Jane Doe number 3?
11 A Not at this time, no.
12 Q If I could direct you to Jane Doe number 4 and
13 if you could summarize for the Grand Jury the
14 information related to Jane Doe number 4's activities.
15 A Jane Doe number 4 is IIIII I, I think you
16 wanted their birth dates, her birth date is
17 , she was 16 years old and attended
19 we first have contact through phone calls from
20 to on April 25th, 2004 which
21 indicates and shows that was clearly 16 years of
22 age when she started going to Mr. Epstein's and
23 performing massages for Mr. Epstein.
24 I, our Jane Doe number 1, was the one
25 who recruited , she basically told that she
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 could make $200, she needed to dress cute, he might try
2 to touch you, but if you feel uncomfortable just let him
3 know and he will stop, and the first massage that
4 did he repeatedly told , and I mentioned this to
5 you in the last Grand Jury session, she was very shy and
6 he would repeatedly tell her not to be so shy, that she
7 didn't have to be so shy.
8 Epstein asked her to remove her clothing and
9 she told him no, and throughout the massage he would
10 repeatedly grab at her, he did
11 through this first massage and pulled her
12 clothes, she would pull away and she was paid $200 for
13 that.
14 Upon leaving the first massage Mr. Epstein
15 told that if was willing to do more she
16 would get paid more. He also informed that if she
17 would bring her pretty friends he would also pay her for
18 bringing her pretty friends. He told that
19 would get her phone number.
20 says that she performed three to four
21 massages for Mr. Epstein. we have with
22 approximately a hundred phone calls between
23 and
24 when I interviewed she became very upset
25 when we got to the sexual massages that she did for
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 Mr. Epstein. At this point, this is as much as we know
2 at this point of what occurred with Mr. Epstein and
4 she did three to four massages and those last
5 massages they became more sexual in nature, he asked her
6 again to remove her clothing, this time she took her
7 shirt off, he asked her to take her bra off, she said
8 no.
9 He again would
, he did continue this time
11 she He continued to compliment
12 her, tell her she had a nice body and that she was
13 pretty.
14 says that he was very nice and engaged
15 her in conversation, asked her, you know, if she had a
16 boyfriend. In the last massage she discusses with me,
17 and this massage Mr. Epstein told her to stop being shy
18 and asked her to take her clothes off and said
19 that she had a boyfriend and she didn't feel comfortable
20 taking her clothes off and he told her you should know
21 what to expect by now when you come here, and he jerked
22 on her pants as to like jerk them down, so she did on
23 this last massage get down to her bra and underwear.
24 She describes his tone at this time being
25 frustrated and irritated, she stayed in her bra and
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 underwear, but during the massage he grabbed her bra and
2 pulled it down and , he had
3 instructed her to while she
4 was massaging his chest, he tried to grab her all over,
5 he knew that she was upset with this massage.
6 At one point Mr. Epstein asked her if she had
7 sex with her boyfriend, informs him that she is
8 still a virgin and he responds what, you don't like sex?
9 And that's pretty much the way that last massage went.
10 Q Now, Special Agent , just to
11 interrupt you, you mentioned that lane Doe number 4
12 became very upset as you were asking her about the
13 massages, correct?
14 A Yes.
15 Q And when she was describing this incident with
16 him grabbing at her breast and trying to pull her pants
17 down and instructing her to remove her pants, correct?
18 A Yes.
19 Q You had talked last week about the expert that
20 you had spoken with about interviewing victims of these
21 types of offenses?
22 A Right.
23 Q And you had told us about how a victim may be
24 reticent at first to tell the entire story until a
25 rapport is built?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 A Right.
2 Q Can you tell the Grand Jury your impressions
3 of your interview with
4 A She became so visibly upset, and a lot of the
5 girls are embarrassed of what took place, but when she
6 talked about the last massage and him grabbing her
7 breasts and fondling her breasts she was in tears and we
8 stopped the massage and we calmed her down, trying to go
9 back there was just too difficult, I could not get her
10 back to discussing anything further that had taken
11 place.
12 I have since then -- I have since talked to
13 again and I feel there is more there, but I just
14 don't think she is ready to disclose what took place.
15 Q So based upon the more than 60 telephone calls
16 as well as --
17 A Approximately a hundred.
18 Q -- 100 telephone calls and your conversations
19 with you think there is probably more than four
20 massages that happened?
21 A Yes, I do.
22 Q was there anything else that you wanted to
23 discuss with the Grand Jury?
24 A Just, as I stated in the beginning of those
25 massages, they engaged in conversation and throughout
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy I of 13
1 that conversation, you know, she did inform mr. Epstein
2 that she was a junior in high school and again she is
3 one of the girls that talks about being Mr.
4 Epstein's favorite, so because Mr. Epstein knew they
5 were friends they would engage in conversation about
6 , and would mention they were in the
7 and they would discuss the friendship
8 they had between the two girls with Mr. Epstein and
9 think that's it.
10 Q All right. If we could turn to the
11 post-indictment to overt act number 4 which appears on
12 page number 5.
13 Did you obtain telephone records for Jane Doe
14 number 4?
15 A Yes.
16 Q And did you compare those with the phone
17 records of and others?
18 A Yes, I did.
19 Q And can you tell us with respect to overt act
20 number 4 what evidence you have related to that?
21 A A review of the phone records indicate that
22 there was telephonic contact between the numbers
23 belonging to and as well as
24 statements that would call her to make
25 appointments.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 Q And if we could go through overt acts 6, 8, 9
2 and 11, all of which appear on page 6.
3 A A review of the phone records on may 3rd,
4 2004, may 14th, 2004, May 20th, 2004 and June 3rd, 2004,
5 a review of those phone records indicate that there was
6 telephonic contact between numbers belonging to IIIII
7 IIIIII and IIIII as well as IIIIIII statements.
8 Q If I could take you to overt acts 14, 15 and
9 19 which appear on page 7.
10 A A review of the phone records on June 11th,
11 2004, June 20th, 2004 and July 10th, 2004, they indicate
12 that there is telephonic contact between the numbers
13 belonging to and
14 Q And if I could ask you to turn to page 8 and
15 if you could address overt acts 24 and 25.
16 A A review of the phone records on July 18th,
17 2004 and July 22nd, 2004, a review of and
18 phone records indicate there is
19 telephonic contact belonging to both of them as well as
20 statements that would arrange
21 appointments with her.
22 Q If I could take you to page 9 of the draft
23 proposed indictment and ask about overt acts 29 and 30.
24 A A review of the phone records indicate there
25 is telephonic contact on July 22nd, 2004 and August 4th,
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 2004 between numbers belonging to and
2 as well as statements.
3 Q If I could take you to page 10 of the draft
4 proposed indictment and ask you about overt acts 37 and
5 43.
6 A A review of phone records indicate telephonic
7 contact on August 25th, 2004 and October 3rd, 2004
8 between numbers belonging to and
10 Q And if you could turn to page 11 of the draft
11 proposed indictment and if you would address overt acts
12 47 and 48.
13 A A review of the phone records indicate
14 telephonic contact on October 30th, 2004 and November
15 4th, 2004 between numbers belonging to and
16 I, as well statements.
17 Q Okay. And if you could go to page 14 of the
18 draft proposed indictment and address overt act number
19 77.
20 A A review of phone records indicate that on
21 January 4th, 2005 there was telephonic contact between
22 and as well as
23 statements.
24 Q I'm sorry. If you could turn to page 16 of
25 the draft proposed indictment and address overt act
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 number 87.
2 A A review of the phone records indicate that on
3 January 22, 2005 there is telephonic phone contact
4 between numbers belonging to IIIII IIIIII and 'III' and
S I believe I said on January 22nd, 2005.
6 Q Okay. And if you could go to page 17 and
7 address overt act number 101.
8 A on February 14th, 2005 a review of the phone
9 records indicate that there was telephonic contact on
10 that day between numbers belonging to SIIIIII and
11 I, as well as statements.
12 Q If you could turn to pages 18 and 19 and if
13 you would address overt acts 106, 114 and 116.
14 A A review of the phone records indicate that
15 there is telephonic contact between and
16 on February 24th, 2005 as well as
17 statements.
18 Q Overt act number 114 says on March 18th, 2005
19 defendant prepared a written message to defendant
20 Epstein regarding Jane Doe number 4, could you tell the
21 Grand Jury what the evidence is related to that?
22 A we have a review of the message pads that were
23 recovered during the search warrant that the state
24 served that showed that wrote a message to
25 Epstein regarding and that was done on march 18th,
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 2005.
2 Q Do you happen to remember what the message
3 said?
4 A I have those with me.
S Q would you mind getting them out?
6 A Do you want to mark it?
7 Q If you could just read it to the Grand Jury.
8 A It is a message written by for Jeffrey
9 on 3/18/2005, it looks like 4:21 p.m., and the message
10 reads is it okay if will come at 5:00 and there is
11 a question mark.
12 Q And if I could direct you to overt act number
13 116, what the evidence is related to that.
14 A A review of the phone records on march 29th,
15 2005 indicate that there is telephonic contact between
16 and as well as her --
17 statements.
18 Q And if I could take you to overt act number
19 127 which is on page 20.
20 A A review of phone records on April 11th, 2005
21 indicate that there is telephonic phone contact between
22 the numbers belonging to and as well
23 as statements.
24 Q Now, if you could go to Count number 8, which
25 alleges that between April 25th, 2004 and June 29th,
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 2005 Jeffrey Epstein, IIIII , IIIIIII IIII enticed
Jane Doe number 4 to engage in sexual activity or
prostitution.
4 A On or about these dates we have a facility of
5 interstate commerce, specifically the telephones, IIIII
, S and , which were utilized to
set up, arrange massage appointments for Epstein, we
8 have IIIII IIIIII taking IIIII upstairs to set up the
9 massage table, she would set the massage table up as
10 well as set up the lotions and the oils, we have during
11 those massages Epstein would grab and pull IIIII closer
12 to him as he , he repeatedly would ask her to
remove her clothing, wearing
Epstein would pull down
her bra and
her bra and
underwear,
15 he attempted to at one point
16 but she stopped him, he , she believes that
17 he paid her $200, he told her that he
18 would pay her to bring her pretty friends and would pay
19 her more if she would do more.
20 Q And just so that this is clear to the Grand
21 Jury, June 29th of 2005 is the day before Jane Doe
22 number 4 turned 18, is that correct?
23 A Yes.
24 Q So was there activity that continued past her
25 18th birthday?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 A Yes.
2 Q If I could direct you to count number 17,
3 which appears on page 28, and tell us about the evidence
4 related to that.
5 A we have evidence through flight records that
6 indicate on May 21st, 2004 that Epstein and
7 traveled to Palm Beach County on the
8 Gulfstream, we have telephonic contact between and
9 the day before or the day of travel and we
10 have the sexual conduct between Epstein and as we
11 described earlier in Count 8.
12 Q And if you could go through Counts 18 and 19.
13 A we have flight records that indicate on June
14 4th, 2004 Epstein and traveled to Palm
15 Beach County on the Gulfstream, we have telephone
16 contact between and the day before,
17 the day of travel, we have sexual conduct between
18 Mr. Epstein and as discussed earlier.
19 we have also Count 19 on June 20th, 2004 we
20 have flight records that indicate that Epstein and
21 traveled to Palm Beach county on the Boeing
22 727.
23 we have the telephone contacts between
24 and the day before, the day of travel, we
25 also have the sexual conduct between Jeffrey and
(
(
(
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 as we described earlier in Count 8.
2 Q Could you do the same for counts 22 and 23,
3 please.
4 A Count 22 we have flight records that indicate
5 on July 22nd, 2004 Epstein,
6 traveled to Palm Beach County on the Boeing
7 727, we have the telephonic phone contact between
8 and the day before or the day of travel, we
9 also have the sexual conduct between Jeffrey Epstein and
10 as we described earlier, and Count 23 we have
11 flight records that indicate on August 6th, 2004 Epstein
12 and traveled to Palm Beach County on the
13 Boeing 727, we have telephonic contact between
14 and two days prior to Epstein and
15 traveling to Palm Beach County, we have sexual
16 conduct between Jeffrey Epstein and as we
17 described earlier.
18 Q And if you could do the same for Count number
19 28, please.
20 A Count number 28 we have flight records that
21 indicate on November 5th, 2004 Epstein,
22 traveled to Palm Beach County on the
23 Gulfstream, we have telephonic contact between
24 and I the day before or the day of travel,
25 we have the sexual conduct between Epstein and
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 Q And if I could direct you to Count number 35,
2 you testified previously about the people who were
3 aboard the plane.
4 was there also telephone contact on January
5 6th -- excuse me, shortly before the flight on January
6 6th, 2005 between and this Jane Doe?
7 A Yes, two days before.
8 Q And if you look at Count number 40, again, you
9 had previously told us about who was on board the plane.
10 Can you tell us whether there was also telephone contact
11 shortly before that?
12 A There was telephone contact the day of or the
13 day before.
14 Q All right. Between who and who?
15 A Between and
16 Q okay. And if you could look at Count 43, you
17 also had testified previously about who was aboard the
18 plane on that day.
19 was there also telephone contact between Jane
20 Doe number 4 -- excuse me, Jane Doe number 4 and
22 A Yes, two days before.
23 Q And if I could direct you to Count number 52,
24 which is the sex trafficking offense, and if you could
25 summarize again for the Grand Jury the evidence related
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
to that.
A we discussed in Count 8 the sexual conduct
that occurred between and Epstein during the
massages that took place, we talked about the money that
5 was paid to her by Mr. Epstein and the offer of more
6 money if she would do more as well as if she would bring
7 her friends.
8 Through statements we have also that
9 has paid her in the past for bringing a
10 friend, we have the phone activity between
11 and which started in April, 2004, we know
12 was 16 at the time, we also have phone activity between
13 and beginning in the spring of 2005
14 when would be 17, with the statements of and
15 the knowledge that Mr. Epstein knew their age,
16 and we have gone through that regarding informing
17 Mr. Epstein that she was a junior in high school, that
18 she was , and then
19 statements that was concerned because she was
20 discussing prom with Mr. Epstein, and both girls at that
21 time of the phone calls were under the age of 18.
22 Q Just again so it is clear for the Grand Jury,
23 neither nor ever specifically said hey,
24 Jeffrey, I am 17, but they provided information that
25 should have caused him to try to figure out whether in
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 fact they were adults?
2 A Yes.
3 Q Any questions about Jane Doe number 4 before
4 we turn to Jane Doe number 5? Yes,
A GRAND JUROR: I have to say something here,
6 if it is a stupid question forgive me if it is,
7 from what I heard, maybe I heard wrong, there were
8 three to four massages that Jane Doe, or
9 I said that she had and you enumerated quite
10 a few sexual contact.
11 How do you know about this, do you have
12 records, how do you know they were sexual contact?
13 THE WITNESS: Through interviewing
14 A GRAND JUROR: She said she only had three to
15 four massages.
16 A GRAND JUROR: Her question is more like
17 there is 20 phone calls.
18 A GRAND JUROR: There is tons of them.
19 THE WITNESS: Exactly, that is what we were
20 discussing earlier when we discussed that there is
21 more than what is willing to admit at this
22 time.
23 A GRAND JUROR: I got Tt. So she said she
24 only had three to four.
25 A GRAND JUROR: There is a hundred phone
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 calls.
2 A GRAND JUROR: You said you found out through
3 , 1 am a little bit confused about that.
4 THE WITNESS: Through interviewing , she
5 stated that she had three or four massages from
6 Mr. Epstein.
7 BY
8 Q Special Agent , the sexual activity
9 that you described that went through, that is what
10 she said happened during those three to four massages,
11 correct?
12 A Right.
13 Q Does that answer your question?
14 A GRAND JUROR: Not really. How do we know
15 like about all these 25, 30?
16 A GRAND JUROR: There is more dates that match
17 up with the amount of massages.
18 A GRAND JUROR: There were a hundred phone
19 calls.
20 A GRAND JUROR: Are we supposed to assume a
21 phone call was made each time they had sexual
22 contact?
23 THE WITNESS: No. There are lots of phone
24 calls made arranging appointments between the
25 girls, that doesn't mean that every phone call that
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 was made was a trip over to Mr. Epstein's house to
2 perform a massage.
3 : Yes, ma'am.
4 A GRAND JUROR: Couldn't they put anything in
5 this indictment about stalking her, are there any
6 rules against stalking children?
7 : I will address -- that is a
8 legal question that I will address when the special
9 Agent is outside of the Grand Jury. Any other
10 factual questions related?
11 A GRAND JUROR: I don't have a question
12 relating to Jane Doe number 4, it was a question
13 asked last week, what does Mr. Epstein do for work,
14 how does he make his money? I asked that late,
15 late in the game last week.
16 : okay, I guess we can just
17 address that now.
18 BY III
19 Q what is Mr. Epstein's state of profession?
20 A He is an investor.
21 Q And he manages portfolios valued at about a
22 billion or more?
23 A Yes.
24 Q who is his best known client?
25 A The owner of the Limited and victoria Secret.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 Q And you mentioned that as gifts Mr. Epstein
2 tended to give victoria Secrets panties and bra sets?
3 A Yes.
4 Q Does that answer the question?
5 A GRAND JUROR: Yes.
6 Yes, ma'am.
7 A GRAND JUROR: Count 28 I thought I heard
8 that -- I thought I heard the detective say that it
9 was the Gulfstream rather than the Boeing 727 on
10 flight records, just for your info.
11 : Count number 28, let's go back
12 there.
13 BY
14 Q Could you restate for the Grand Jury which
15 company owns the Gulfstream?
16 A The Gulfstream is owned by Hyperion Air, Inc.
17 Q And the Boeing is owned by whom?
18 A JEGE, Inc.
19 Q Any other questions before we go on to Jane
20 Doe number 5? we have four minutes.
21 Special Agent , why don't I ask you
22 to step outside so I can answer that question for the
23 Grand Jury and address some issues.
24 (The witness was excused from the Grand Jury
25 room.)
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
Copy 1 of 13
1 (Questions posed by the Grand Jury.)
2 (The testimony of the witness was concluded
3 before the Grand Jury.)
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
1 CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
5 I certify pages 2 through 36 are a true transcript of my
6 shorthand notes of the testimony of II
7 before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm
8 Beach, Florida on the 15th day of Tuesday, 2007.
10 k)--)a-NLi Aug, 11 Nancy Siegel-Notary Public
12 Commission #DD0282274
13 Expires May 8, 2008
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE
(
(
(
EFTA00039295 (Jmail)
 [government] Inmate Telephone Privileges Program Statement
(inferred date: 2026-01-06)
Inmate Telephone Privileges Program Statement
EFTA00039972 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-06)
FD-302 (Rev. 5-8-10) -1 of 6 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
OFFWOU. Rummy ti ff  n .j ,—. en — .....
Date of entry  08/15/2019
, Captain, FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS (BOP), place of
employment METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER (MCC), 150 Park Row, New York,
NY 10007, was interviewed at the FBI New York Field Office, 290 Broadway,
New York, NY 10278 by FBI Special Agent and DIG Special Agent
Agents reviewed a standard OIG interview waiver form;
signed the form and agreed to a voluntary interview. After the
Agents introduced themselves and explained the purpose of the interview,
provided the following information:
began his career with the BOP in Florence, CO in 2005. In 2014,
he was transferred to the METROPOLITAN DETENTION CENTER (MDC) in Brooklyn,
NY, where he was made Deputy Captain in 2015. In 2018, was promoted
to Captain at MCC, his current position, where he oversees security for the
entire building. directly supervises approximately 13 Lieutenants,
and has approximately 125-134 line staff / Correctional Officers under his
purview. also sits on the institution's Executive staff, which also
includes the Warden. primary duty is to ensure that security
protocols are met by his Lieutenants and sub-staff, and that policy
guidelines are being followed as set forth by the BOP. Among others,
is responsible for the following: a Special Housing Unit (SHU) Lieutenant,
Lieutenant ; an Administrative Lieutenant, responsible for maintaining
paperwork, etc.; an S/S Lieutenant, responsible for paperwork; an Operations
& Activities Lieutenant(s), responsible for day-to-day operations and
maintaining order for three (3) shifts; and an Emergency Preparedness
Lieutenant, a collateral duty responsible in the event of emergency
incidents such as a fires, bomb threats, etc.
advised that his staff provides special considerations for high
profile inmates, if deemed appropriate and designated as such. In order to
ensure an inmate is provided with proper care, the facility evaluates the
inmate using several measures, including mental, physical, medical,
Investigation on 08/ 12/2019  at New York, New York, United States (In Person)
Fik Date drafted 08/13/2019
by

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Continuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of .on 08/12/2019 ins, 2 of 6
psychological, and sexual assault victim or predator assessments. Since
different inmates are admitted with different criteria, appropriate housing
varies.
interacted with inmate JEFFREY EPSTEIN on approximately three
occasions at MCC, all of which EPSTEIN maintained a pleasant demeanor.
During the first instance, EPSTEIN asked who he was, and
responded by introducing himself and explaining his position at the jail.
During another instance, explained to EPSTEIN the policy regarding
meals during attorney sessions, and made certain EPSTEIN was accommodated
with water, visits to the restroom, etc. EPSTEIN spent most of the day with
his defense counsel, and was brought down as soon as attorney visiting
opened.
was made aware of the possibility that EPSTEIN would be housed at
MCC in advance of EPSTEIN'S arrival. was not present when inmate
EPSTEIN was admitted to the facility. EPSTEIN was thoroughly vetted to
determine if he was fit for General Population (GP) and was ultimately
placed in the Special Housing Unit (SHU). MCC places inmates under three
categories of close supervision: 1. "Dry Cell" for those at risk for
smuggling contraband, 2. Psychological Observation, and 3. Suicide Watch.
advised that EPSTEIN preferred not to have a cellmate and engaged
in manipulative behavior to avoid having one, including requesting to see a
psychologist. At EPSTEIN'S request, he was interviewed by a psychologist.
Following this assessment, EPSTEIN was initially placed on Suicide Watch.
He was later interviewed again and downgraded to Psychological Observation,
because he was determined not to have suicidal tendencies. After some time,
he was returned to the SHU. began hearing talk that EPSTEIN was
trying to get back on Suicide Watch. Information like this is usually
generated from rounds, "kites", and monitoring of phone calls and letters.
On or about July 23, 2019, EPSTEIN was found unresponsive on the floor of
his cell with a homemade piece of fabric on his chest. EPSTEIN'S cellmate
had flagged the attention of a staff member, who handcuffed the cellmate and
removed EPSTEIN to bring him to the medical unit. heard from his
staff that EPSTEIN may have been faking unconsciousness, because he was
observed opening his eyes and making other suspicious movements not
consistent with an unconscious state. EPSTEIN was medically assessed and
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Continuation afFD-302 of ( U ) Interview of .on 08/12/2019 ins, 3 of 6
became coherent. EPSTEIN claimed that his cellmate,
tried to take his life. He was placed back on Suicide Watch for
approximately one week. Unlike his first and previous placement on Suicide
Watch, EPSTEIN now has definitive suicidal tendencies reported in his
incarceration history. The staff was tasked with determining whether
EPSTEIN was in fact suicidal, or using manipulative tactics to avoid
assignment of a cellmate. After Suicide Watch, EPSTEIN was placed on
Psychological Observation and eventually returned to the SHU.
At the direction of the Warden, initiated the process of compiling
possible cellmates for EPSTEIN, vetting them, and submitting candidates to
the Warden for his review. and his staff fully screened potential
cellmates and reported their determinations up to the Warden.
was selected and housed in a cell with EPSTEIN. The Assistant Warden,
Warden, and Regional Director were notified.
The Warden directed
cellmate at all times, and
on multiple occasions that EPSTEIN needed a
verbally informed his Lieutenants the
same. repeatedly directed his SHU Lieutenant, Lieutenant , that
EPSTEIN needed a cellmate at all times. Additionally, visited the
SHU on multiple occasions and directed staff to be very alert and attentive
about EPSTEIN'S special accommodations.
On Friday, August 9, 2019, Lieutenant was on leave and, thus, there
was no dedicated Lieutenant assigned to the SHU. In this event, the
Operation Lieutenant, Lieutenant , had oversight that day and took
over the responsibilities of the SHU Lieutenant. Lieutenant was
aware that EPSTEIN was required to be housed with a cellmate, because
approximately one week prior to EPSTEIN'S death, informally advised
his Lieutenants that EPSTEIN was not be housed alone, and emphasized the
need to be vigilant about "30-minute checks" and unannounced rounds.
Inmates/cellmates are moved for various reasons, including but not
limited to, an incident in the cell, visits
medical, and recreation. On Friday, August 9,
had court. It would not be uncommon for
for an extended period. EPSTEIN had an att
EPSTEIN'S attorney was processed into the fac
EPSTEIN was brought down to the attorney room.
to court, legal library,
2019, EPSTEIN'S cellmate,
to be out of his cell
orney session that day.
ility in the morning and
was not notified that
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Continuation afFD-302 of (U) Interview of .on 08/12/2019 ins, 4 of 6
was released from court.
Typically, if an inmate is likely to be discharged or transferred
following court, their property is retrieved from their cell, boxed, and
secured with a property form by Receiving and Discharge staff. All items
are normally accounted for and inventoried. In order to enter the SHU, all
staff not assigned there must identify themselves and sign the logbook, then
be physically escorted by a Correctional Officer. Alternatively, the staff
can pick up inmate property at the Unit door. A Correctional Officer
assigned to the SHU would have been aware that or any inmate's,
belongings were removed. At this time, the Correctional Officer should
notify a Lieutenant, who would in turn brief was not
notified that ' belongings were removed. advised that if he had
known that EPSTEIN was without a cellmate, he would have likely put EPSTEIN
on Psychological Observation.
knowing that ' property was moved.
is not aware of any Lieutenants
On Saturday, August 10, 2019, received a phone call from
Lieutenant around 7:00 AM, and was told that EPSTEIN was found
unresponsive in his cell. inquired about EPSTEIN'S cellmate and was
surprised to hear respond that EPSTEIN did not have a cellmate.
worked a 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM shift on August 9, 2019. was
relieved by Lieutenant , who was assigned the 10 PM - 6 AM shift.
did not personally tell that EPSTEIN required a cellmate at
all times. He believed she was aware because he had informed his
Lieutenants repeatedly, and instructed them to pass this message along and
convey the information amongst themselves. did not hold a formal
all-Lieutenant meeting regarding EPSTEIN, or send a staff email with the
Warden's directive. He verbally instructed his Lieutenants on an informal
and individual basis, as many as possible with whom he had the opportunity.
On Saturday morning, August 10, 2019, was relieved early by
In the SHU, 30-minute rounds need to be completed consistently at
nonuniform intervals within a 40-minute time frame. The purpose of these
rounds is to ensure that good order is being maintained, there is no
suspicious activity, and all inmates are accounted for and responsive. 30-
minute rounds are documented in TRUSCOPE, which serves as an electronic
logbook. After a round is physically done, the Correctional Officer can log
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Continuation afFD-302 of ( U ) Interview of .on 08/12/2019 ins, 5 of 6
in to TRUSCOPE and press a button certifying that the round was completed.
Unfortunately, sometimes officers do not complete a 30-minute round, or
exceed the 40-minute threshold. TRUSCOPE also documents from what
location/terminal the rounds are logged. is aware of at least two
(2) terminals located in the SHU. The only way to determine if a 30-minute
round was physically completed is to check the video surveillance footage.
There are two (2) Correctional Officers assigned to the SHU on morning
watch at midnight, SHU1 and SHU2. SHU2 is responsible for completing
rounds.
was unaware that the camera system in the SHU was down. He left
early on Thursday when the discussion about the camera system would have
occurred. MR. , the camera technician, notified that he was
working on the system earlier that week, but did not know specifics
and was not informed that the cameras were not functioning. Since the
building is in the middle of a camera project, assumed the camera
work may have been related. was first notified that the cameras were
down on Saturday morning, August 10, 2019, when he arrived at MCC and asked
to see the video. Correctional Officers do not typically know when the
cameras are down.
After receiving the phone call from on the morning of Saturday,
August 10, 2019, notified Associate Warden , who
informed the Warden. also attempted to call Institution Duty Officer
, the Chaplain, and the building, to get more information.
He then went to MCC, arriving before 8:00 AM, approximately. Upon arrival,
screened in and retrieved his gear from the 3rd Floor. He went to
the SHU and signed the logbook. He gathered any records pertaining to
EPSTEIN, including the 30-minute rounds logbook, the attorney conference
logbook, count slips, and El's. He could not locate EPSTEIN'S inmate file.
He also asked to view the camera footage. The Warden was already present at
the facility when arrived.
expressed to that the staff admitted to her they did not
complete rounds, the 3:00 AM and 5:00 AM counts, and that Officer
entered EPSTEIN'S cell without supervision. EPSTEIN was placed on the floor
to administer lifesaving -ff.r informed Associate Warden
about what Officers dmitted to
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
Continuation oil:D-302 of ( U ) Interview of .on 08/12/2019 ins, 6 of 6
had concerns about the whereabouts of EPSTEIN'S cellmate. Some of
his staff were under the impression that
which later confirmed was not true.
was released from the SHU,
The purpose of the 3:00 AM and 5:00 AM counts is to physically count and
confirm each person in each cell. There were no entries of counts in
TRUSCOPE the entire night. If technology is down, the Correctional Officers
also have the option to document the count on a hardcopy form. Although
there are no electronic records of counts, hardcopies may have been
retained.
All inmate phone calls in the SHU are monitored and inmates have limited
access to phone calls. All calls should be recorded. was not aware
of any issues or complaints with EPSTEIN related to phone calls. On
Saturday, August 10, 2019, was told that EPSTEIN made a phone call at
approximately 7:00 PM on the evening of Friday, August 9, 2019. It is
uncommon to make an unrecorded phone call in the SHU, and would
advise against it because calls should be surveilled. Inmates can make a
recorded phone call in the Lieutenant's Office, where it is documented in a
monitored logbook. In the SHU, Correctional Officers are not permitted to
give inmates phone calls, but a Unit Team Member or the Chaplain can take
the inmate to the Lieutenant's office to make a call. is not briefed
on phone calls in the SHU, generally.
wholeheartedly emphasized that he and his staff at MCC did their
best to supervise, safeguard and ensure the protection of EPSTEIN and all
inmates effectively. His staff is aware of the seriousness of the
investigation into EPSTEIN'S death.
EFTA00066350 (Jmail)
 [government] inventory of the contents of Epstein boxed never obtained from SDFL prosecutor office
(inferred date: 2026-01-06)
EPSTEIN BOX INVENTORY

Box 1:
Redwell with different files for each Jane Doe v. Epstein case
Cd's with Documents on 2" Supplemental Privilege Log (2) and Bates#s 002111-002266
Redwell with printout of Documents in the 2" Supplemental Privilege Log
6001 Orders
6001 Immunity Request
<REDACTED> folder
Jane Doe v. U.S. 6/23/15 production (redwell) with documents

Box 2:
Data Demonstratives Kirkland & Ellis LLP— 6 bound copies and 1 color copy
Plea Negotiations (redwell) — folders: Non Prosecution Agreement — Final; Attorney Notes re Revised
Indictment; Research re Boehm case; Research re possible misdemeanors; Notes re Plea Negotiations;
Plea Agreement drafts; Draft Non Prosecution Agreements; Information Packet drafts
Corr w. Nathan Dershowitz (file folder)
Golderberger Corr (green file folder)
Lefcourt Corr. Re: Epstein Corp. Records (green file folder)
Non Pros Agrmt & Addendum (file folder)
Mtgw/ Ken Starr (file folder)
MTarget Letter (file folder)
Notes re Post Agreement Communications (file folder)
Bert Ocariz (file folder)
6/19/08 Starr Submission to the DAG (file folder)
6/3/08 Sloman Submission to the DAG (file folder)
5/27/08 Starr Submission to the DAG (file folder)
5/15/08 Oosterbaan-Lefkowitz Ltr (file folder)
Draft It r from Sloman to Lefkowitz re termination (file folder)
Redwell — Folders: 5/22/07 Lefcourt to Lourie; 6/18/07 to Lefcourt; 6/25/07 Lefcourt to Sloman
& Lourie; 7/6/07 Lefcourt & Dershowitz to Sloman; 7/25/07 Lefcourt & Dershowitz to Menchel; 8/2/07
Sanchez to Menchel; 8/3/07 Menchel to Sanchez; 9/17/07 to Lekowitz; 10/25/07 Sloman Itr to
Davis; 11/8/07 Lefkowitz to Sloman; 11/13/07 Sloman to Lefkowitz (was this sent?); 11/28/07 Starr to
Fisher; 11/29/07 Starr to Acosta; 11/30/07 Acosta to Lefkowitz; 12/4/07 Acosta to Starr; 12/5/07 Starr
to Acosta; 12/6/07 Sloman to Lefkowitz; 12/7/07 Sanchez to Sloman; 12/7/07 Starr to Acosta; 12/11/07
Starr, Lefkowitz & Lefkowitz to Acosta; 12/13/07 Lefkowitz to 12/21/07 Lefkowitz to Acosta;
12/26/07 Lefkowitz to Acosta
Redwell — Folders: 11/15/16 Sanchez to ; 11/16/06 to Sanchez; 11/21/06 Sanchez to
; 11/29/06 to Sanchez; 12/1/06 Sanchez to 1/5/07 Sanchez to
1/8/07 to Sanchez; 1/17/07 Lourie to Sanchez; 1/18/07 Sanchez to ; 1/22/07 Sanchez
to Lourie; 1/23/07 to Sanchez; 2/1/07 Lefcourt to 2/5/07 Lefcourt to
2/12/07 Sanchez to ; 2/23/07 Lefcourt to

Box 3:
White binder with correspondence filed by Janes Does with Court — clipped section of documents with notes
White binder labeled Leap YearJ Marra Issue with notes and opinion and filed documents
Redwell labeled Telephone Charts with a post it saying Duplicate
White binder with additional documents filed in Jane Doe case
White binder with CVRA Research
White binder labeled Duplicate

Box 4:
Empty brown file folder
Jane Does v. U.S. Standing/Ripeness Research & 6(e) & Due Process Confidentiality Research (redwell)
Jane Does v. US Supplemental Briefing (redwell)
Redwell with notes; transcript of 8/14/08 hearing in Jane Doe case (DE27); DE 99 Order;
Westlaw research on Obstruction of Justice Charges can be based on false statements in state
depositions, including Civil depo, if it is likely to be turned over to federal investigation; DE15-2 Exhibit A;
"Prince's friendship with pedophile causes furor across the pond" 3/9/11 article from Palm Beach Post;
additional notes; highlighted Federal Register notices; draft letter from to Captain
,BSO re Epstein's Work Release Application; CVRA research with notes and Westlaw
printouts; CVRA Research (green file folder)
Jane Does v. U.S. Misc (green file folder)
Florida Bar (redwell) with Self Report folder and 9/16/08 Herman Ltr to

Box 5:
(green file folder)
Motion to Quash (file folder)
Motion to Quash Subpoenas (red file folder)
Stolen Globe — (red file folder)
Lefcourt Cases (file folder)
Research (green file folder)
Westlaw case printouts

Box 6:
Jane Does Litigation (redwell) with 2 email printouts, Sealed Document Tracking Form with Motion to
Seal Opposition to Petitioner's Motion Requesting an Order Directing the Government to File Redacted
Pleadings in the Public Court File, and Red File Folder with documents filed in Jane Doe case
Jane Does 1 & 2 v. U.S. (redwell) with CD inside mailing from and original redacted
documents from
Clipped research with Attachment to Subpoena NES, LLC; article titled "Working for Top Bosses on Wall
St. Has Its Perks"; Jean-Luc Brunel research; Robert Maxwell; Jeffrey Epstein
Leslie Wexner (file folder)
Kastigar Letters (file folder)
2703 Motion & Order-Cingular (red file folder)
Grand Jury Transcripts (redwell) with folders
Pros Memo (file folder) labeled Duplicate
Proposed Jury Instructions for Violations of 18 USC 2423(b) (Travel in Interstate or Foreign Commerce to
Engage in Illicit Sexual Conduct)
Pages 1-6 (of 7 pages) of Non-Prosecution Agreement with highlighted portions
Brown file folder with 6/23/08 letter from John Roth (DAG) to Lefkowitz and Starr; 11/2/2010 Privileged
Communication letter re Litigation Hold; clipped Non-Prosecution Agreement
Doe IM) v. Epstein, 08-80893-CV-KAM (red file folder)

Box 7: (labeled al Presentation Materials)
Federal Criminal Code and Rules 2006 Edition with multiple post-its
File folder with Testimony 5/8/07; Testimony 4/24/07; _Testimony
5/8/07; Testimony 2/6/07; 2/27/07 (post it says All About );
Testimony 4/24/07; Testimony 5/15/07 Testimony 3/20/07
5/8/07 estimony (file folder)
5/15/07 Testimony (file folder)
2/6/07 Testimony (file folder)
2/27/07 Testimony (file folder)
5/8/07 Testimony (file folder)
4/24/07 Testimony (file folder)
5/22/07 Testimony (file folder)
3/20/07 Testimony (file folder)
4/24/07 Testimony (file folder)
US Attorneys' Bulletin: Crafting Helpful Indictments

Box 8:
Green file folder with Grand Jury Subpoena Log— Operation Stolen Globe
12/19/07 Acosta-Sanchez letter with post it — to be produced after stay is lifted
2009R02690 Criminal Complaint folder for Op. Stolen Globe
Empty redwell — Additions to Items to be Produced after stay is lifted from privileged items
Op Stolen Globe (redwell)
4/29/2008 Grand Jury Presentation for Operation Leap Year with Indictment
OLY cd
Jane Does v. U.S. Bates Nos 000670-002110 cd
Jane Does v. U.S. 0001-1652 cd
Redwell with multiple copies of 4/29/2008 indictment
Orange Composition notebook with notes
Redwell with documents provided to on cd (000670-002110)
Redwell with correspondence between Epstein's attorney's and USAO
10/21/2009 letter to from Black
Additional correspondence between Epstein's attorneys and USAO
12/9/2009 Black Ltr re Rothstein Complaints (green file folder)
Epstein redwell with correspondence
Printout of 'MI arrest
Yellow Notepad with notes
Enforcing Victim'sRights — April 26, 2012
Index of Victim Notification Letters

Box 9:
White binder with Victim information
Witness/Victim Names Contact List (green file folder)
Flight Manifests (file folder)
Recent Atty Notes (file folder)
Ile folder)
Summary of Sexual Activity (file folder)
White binder with Victim information —
Past Employees —
White Binder with Victim Information —
White binder with victim call records

Box 10:
Redwell with no label — contains (front section) Email titled Fw: Epstein Letter; 5/15/2008 letter to Jay
Lefkowitz from handwritten list of victims; 2 copies of Privilege Log; (middle section)
copies of privileged documents
Jane Doe (redwell) — contains green file folder with Sealed Document Tracking Form with Government's
Sealed Ex Parte Motion for Modification; Order and Motion to Seal Motion to Disclose Grand Jury
Information; Sealed Document Tracking Form with Motion to Seal Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Subject
MatterJurisdiction; Sealed Order Granting Government's motion for Limited Disclosure of Grand Jury
Material; Sealed Document Tracking Form with Motion to Seal Motion to Stay Discovery Pending Ruling
Upon Respondent's Motion to Dismiss; printed stickers with "Privileged Documents Submitted Ex Parte
By the United States for in Camera Review Pursuant to DE 190"; printed stickers with "Jane Doe #1 &
Jane Doe #2 v. United States, 08-80736-CV-Ma rra/M atthewma n; DE 216 and DE 219— Notice of Filing
Supplemental Privilege Log; Notepad with notes; Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2's
Appellee Brief (red cover); Florida Law Review from Daily Business Review Thursday, August 29, 2013;
Printout of Opinion from In Re: Stake Center Locating, Inc.; DE 224; DE 225; DE 226; DE 230; email from
Dexter Lee to and Ed Sanchez; Draft Respondent's Opposition to Petitioner's Motion to Compel
Production of Documents that are not Privileged; printout of brief regarding Alvin F. Aguirre-Gonzalez;
Westlaw printouts
Redwell with emails from 2007-2008

Box 11:
FBI Palm Beach County RA, Jeffrey E. Epstein, 31E-MM White binder with PBPD Reports
Palm Beach Police/SAO Records Redwell with post it that says "This whole stack is for opposing counsel"
— includes file folders Req for Warr.; Probably Cause Aff.; Req for Epstein Warr; Request for
Warr; Incident Report; State Indictment
Work Release Notification (green file folder)
12/11/08 Ltr to PBSO re work release (brown file folder)
6/12/09 Breach Ltr (brown file folder) — post it says Epstein Defense 3
7/29/11 Letter to from Lefkowitz regarding NPA being a confidential document
9/1/2009 Letter to Jeffrey Sloman from Roy Black regarding compliance with NPA
2/18/10 Letter to from Black regarding attorney's fees
3/20/11 Letter from Acosta
Transcript of 6/12/09 Motion Hearing in Jane Doe case
Notice of Removal (DE#1) in 08-CV-8084-KAM Jane Doe case
Redwell with Epstein's Motion to Seal Non-Pros Agreement
Epstein New York Case (Redwell)
12/10/10, 3/1/11, and 9/29/11 letters from Paul G. Cassell to Wifredo A. Ferrer
Box 12:
Redwell with Notes and Jeffrey Epstein deposition documents and cds
Redwell with Breach Memo documents and documents filed by
Final Contact (file folder) with Non Prosecution Agreement
vil Complaints (green file folder)
White binder with Westlaw cases

Box 13: - Not applicable — is actually Operation Sledgehammer

Box 14:
10/15/2008 letter from to Dexter Lee
Epstein — Docs provided by Critton (redwell)
Certified Copy of State of Florida v. Jeffrey Epstein Plea Conference
Epstein v. State of Florida Order
6/27/2008 letter from to Goldberger and Black rega rding not receiving copy of proposed plea
agreement
Palm Beach Post printout 9/4/2009 "Appeals court backs unsealing of Epstein's 07 deal with feds"
6/27/2008 letter from to Goldberger and Black rega rding the plea agreement does not comply
with the NPA
7/17/2008 letter to Michael Tein from
State of Florida v. Epstein Order Releasing Documents Under Seal
Copies of multiple news stories
OLY Grand Jury Log Vol. 2
Redwell — State Court Criminal Pleadings; State Motion to Unseal NPA; Supplemental Appendix to Palm
Beach Newspapers, Inc. Response to Emergency Petition for Writ of Certiorari
Redwell with Post DC Correspondence, Epstein Attorney's Fees Correspondence
Redwell with Correspondence with Victims

Box 15:
White Binder — Operation Leap Year Response to Motion to Quash Research
D Statement of ; PBPD Follow-up phone
2; PBPD Voicemail from PBPD Voicemail
Interview w
CDs: 4/24/2007 nterview; PBPD U6-1078 Interview witl= PBPD 061078 Interview
with
Cassette tapes: Interview wit
PBPD Conversation wi
call wit
VHS: PBPD Interview o
Interview vit/ Interview w/ ; Statement
Private Island Helicopter
tatement of Statement of
Voicemail message C work; Statement o
Box of Cassette tapes: Statement o
Interview w
Box of cassette tapes: Statement o Control cal ; Conversation of
drive to station; Statement o Phone call MIN
Statement a :; Statement of tate me nt of -empty
case

Box 16:
Settlement Negotiations & Settlement Statements (brown redwell) including 5/16/2016 Settlement
Conference Summary letter to Honorable Dave Lee Brannon from ; Confidential Memorandum
on Behalf of Jane Doe No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2 Regarding Mediation; printout of docket for 08-CV-
80736; printout of Crime Victims' Services for AttorneyGeneral Pam Bondi
Empty file folder SORNA and Victims' Services Info
Clean Copies of Agreement without App D & E (file folder)
Relevant Privileged Docs (brown redwell) — 2 copies clipped with Bates Numbers P-003713-P-003746; P-
008516; P-009105-P-009111; P-012624-P-012642; P-012646; P-014011-P-014025; P-014059-P-014061;
P-014440; P-014444; P-014521-P-014522; P-014559-P-014562; P-014569-P-014573; P-014666-P-
014693; P-014712-P-014716; P-014866-P-014883
Privilege Logs (brown redwell) — all privilege logs clipped together
Jane Does Intervenors at Mediation (file folder) — includes notes and Westlaw printouts
Victim List (file folder) — includes 7/10/2008 Final Notification of Identified Victims
Victim List (file folder) — includes 7/5/2016 letter to Wells Fargo, 6/16/2016 email from to
and 7/10/2008 Notification of Identified Victims to Jack Goldberger
Declarations (file folder) — includes 3 printouts of Declaration in Suppport
of United States' Response to Victim's Emergency Petition for Enforcement of Crime Victim Rights Act,
18 U.S.C. 3771
Yellow envelope from to Dexter Lee with Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2's Supplemental
Request for Production to the Government Regarding "Victim" Status
Jane Doe case (Redwell)— includes Draft letters and settlement agreements, Jane Doe Mediation (file
folder), and Jane Does Settlement Agreement and Apology Letter (file folder)
Jane Doe Document Production (redwell) — includes 3 cds, and documents
Order Closing Case & Timeline (file folder)
Jane Does — Writ Ad Test (file fodler) includes Westlaw printout of U.S. v. Louis Rinchack

Box 17:
6/2/2017 Declaration (brown redwell)
Second Declaration of E. (file folder)
Jane Doe v. U.S. Summary Judgment prep (brown redwell) — light green file folder with
bright green file folder with notes and documents, and rubber-banded exhibits
Motion to Disclose Grand Jury Material (brown redwell) —with Copy of Motion, light green file folder
with signed sealed Orders, and light green file folder with Exhibits to Motion to Unseal Grand Jury
Materials
notes,
White binder with Jane Doe 1 and Jane Doe 2's Consolidated Statement of Undisputed Material Facts
and Motion for Partial Summary Judgment with Incorporated Memorandum of Law

Box 18:
Corr re Subpoenas (file folder)
File folders for individual subpoenas: OLY-01 through OLY-81
Ritz Compact Flash SW (file folder)
PNY Technologies Compact Flash SW (flash drive)
JE Corporations (green file folder)
Capital One (green file folder)
DTG Operations/Dollar Rent-a-Car (green file folder)
JP Morgan Chase (green file folder)
Washington Mutual (green file folder)
Redwell with folders — Computer Search; Attorney Notes from Doc Review; Notes from FedEx Records
Colonial Bank Records (redwell) with folders: JEGE, Inc.; NES, LLC
Epstein Corporate Records OLY-51, OLY-52, OLY-53, OLY-54 (red folder)
Colonial Bank (green file folder)
JEGE & Hyperion from Goldberger OLY-46 & 0LY-47 (file folder)

Box 19:
Research re JE websites (file folder)
Victim Civil Suits (file folder)
NY AUSA) - (file folder)
Dr. Anna Salter (file folder)
Interview (file folder)
Research re Travel for Prostitution (file folder)
Transcript (empty file folder)
(green file folder)
PBPD Investigative File (redwell)
(redwell)
FedEx (file folder) subpoena response with Certification
Documents 53909-004 (green file folder)
State of Delaware records (file folder)
Jet Blue records (file folder)
FL Employment Recs (file folder)
(green file folder)
Records (green file folder)
(file folder)
Bear Sterns Research (file folder)
Lawsuits involving Epstein Corps (file folder)
New York Trip (file folder)
(green file folder)
SEC records (green file folder)
Message Pads (file folder)
Anna Salter (green file folder)
Redwell wit
file folder)
Statement (file folder), (green file folder) and Info Re Planes (green
Police Reports & PC Affidavit (file folder)
Bean Sterns Subpoena Response (file folder)
Ira nscript of Interview and al Transcript (file folder)
2006R01181 Operation Leap Year Criminal Complaint folder with Expert Witness Forms (green file
folder) and asset forfeiture folder
Extra Copies (green file folder)

Box 20: (labeled Legal Research)
Epstein Redwell — folders titled: 1591 & Money Laundering; 18 USC 2425; Knowledge of Age; 2423(b)
Constitutionality and Purpose of Travel; Immunity; Mistake not a defense; Research re "pandering";
Research re Grand Jury Instructions; Telephone=Facility of Commerce; Def of Prostitution; Research re
Crime Victims Rights; Relevant Florida Statutes; Unit of Prosecution Research
Research re GrandJury Transcript (file folder)
18 USC 2255 (file folder)
Research re Grand Jury Transcript (file folder)
Original proposed Ind (file folder) — includes original indictment
Research re Overt Acts and Witness Testimony (green file folder)
Extradition (green file folder)
Corporate Liability Research (green file folder)
Research re Knowledge of Age Unnecessary (file folder)
1960 & Aiding/Abetting (green file folder)
Money Laundering (green file folder)
Attorney General Guidelines for Victim and Witness Assistance May 2005
Purpose of Travel Cases (green file folder)
Redwell with folders titled: Interstate Commerce Cases; Attorney Conflict Research; Ma nn Act/Travel to
Have Sex with a Minor; Travel Act; Florida Prostitution/Lewdness Statutes
Box 21:
Folder with notes
=subpoena (green file folder)
Research re State I ncarc (redwell) with Epstein's Motion to Return Property (file folder) and State
Docket Sheets (file folder)
Redwell with CD with nothing written on it and OLY cd; Notes and Westlaw printouts
Leap Year Filing (redwell)
I.Vork Release (file folder)
Protective Order Samples (green file folder)
Press Coverage re Work Release (green file folder)
FOIA Requests (redwell) with nIA Request to FBI folder and Ricci-Leopold Ltr to FBI
Demanding Case File folder
Docs from Civil Suits (file folder)
Dershowitz SARS (file folder)
Signed Protective Orders (file folder)
Herman Corr Re Ethics Issue (file folder)
Willits Signed Protective Order (green file folder)
Notice of Withdrawal of Motion to Quash (green file folder)
Research re Florida Procurement and Sentencing Guidelines
Operation Leap Year Revised Indictment Summary Chart (by Victim)
Research re FL DOC Regs (file folder)
Research re BOP Regs (file folder)
Supervised Release Rules (green file folder)
al Transcripts redwell
Redwell with Newspaper Articles and Press Coverage

Box 22: (labeled Phone Records)
Redwell with phone records for Jane Doe
#4, Jane Doe #12
Redwell Corrected Phone Records 5/13/07
phone records (file folder)
Lists of Identified Phone Numbers (file folder)
Redwell with Master Phone Records
Redwell with Epstein/.Phone Records
Box 23:
Redwell with 8/3/2015 Doc Production Jane Doe v. U.S.
Relevant Jane Doe v. U.S. Items(Redwell) — Reinhart review (file folder), Attorney General Guidelines for
Victim and Witness Assistance May 2005, United States of America's Response to Petitioners' Request
for Production, Items marked as removed as non-responsive
12-7-2007 draft Crime Victims' Rights — Notification of Resolution of Epstein Investigation with
envelopes (redwell)
Redwell with Items Produced to 7/19/2013 and cd copies (1 for and 1 for Judge)
Redwell with Joint Statement of Undisputed Facts, Stipulation, and Intervenors' Motion for a Protective
Confidentiality Order and Incorporated Memorandum of Law
Black binder with Doe case documents
CDs: 2n° supplemental privilege log P-013970 thru P-014923; Epstein- P-013279 thru P-013969;
OLY pictures and summaries; Lit Hold; Lit Hold PST; Reinhart
Sealed yellow envelope to Dexter Lee and A. Marie from
Redwell with Already Produced documents
2 yellow Note pads with notes
Redwell with Copies of Victim Notification Letters
Blue folder with Intervenor documents

Box 24:
West's Florida Statutes Annotated Sections 934.08 to 944.29
White binder with tax returns
Epstein State Court File (redwell) with PBSO Inmate Rules and Work Release Regulations
PTO Research (redwell)
Supreme Court case The Florida Bar vs. Jeffrey Marc Herman
Brown Box (unlabeled by #): -Mound when she was packing to leave
6(e) application and Order Sealed in Red Interoffice envelope
Attorney General Guidelines for Victim and Witness Assistance 2000
11 additional books re statutes and victims with notes
OPR Prep Box 1
Emails and other documents
OPR Prep Box 2
Timelines, notes, and emails
OPR Prep Box 3
Marked Exhibits to Response
EFTA00126948 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Bureau of Prisons personnel, see quote: "EPSTEIN claimed that his cellmate, NICHOLAS TARTAGLIONE, tried to take his 
life"
(inferred date: 2026-01-06)
FD-30.2(Rev. 54-10) -1 of 6 -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of entry  08/15/2019
<REDACTED>, Captain, FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS (BOP), place of
employment METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER (MCC), 150 Park Row, New York,
NY 10007, was interviewed at the FBI New York Field Office, 290 Broadway,
New York, NY 10278 by FBI Special Agent <REDACTED> and OIG Special Agent
<REDACTED>. Agents reviewed a standard OIG interview waiver form;
signed the form and agreed to a voluntary interview. After the
Agents introduced themselves and explained the purpose of the interview,
provided the following information:

<REDACTED> began his career with the BOP in Florence, CO in 2005. In 2014,
he was transferred to the METROPOLITAN DETENTION CENTER (MDC) in Brooklyn,
NY, where he was made Deputy Captain in 2015. In 2018, was promoted
to Captain at MCC, his current position, where he oversees security for the
entire building. directly supervises approximately 13 Lieutenants,
and has approximately 125-134 line staff / Correctional Officers under his
purview. also sits on the institution's Executive staff, which also
includes the Warden. primary duty is to ensure that security
protocols are met by his Lieutenants and sub-staff, and that policy
guidelines are being followed as set forth by the BOP. Among others,

<REDACTED> is responsible for the following: a Special Housing Unit (SHU) Lieutenant,
Lieutenant ; an Administrative Lieutenant, responsible for maintaining
paperwork, etc.; an SIS Lieutenant, responsible for paperwork; an Operations
& Activities Lieutenant(s), responsible for day-to-day operations and
maintaining order for three (3) shifts; and an Emergency Preparedness
Lieutenant, a collateral duty responsible in the event of emergency
incidents such as a fires, bomb threats, etc.

<REDACTED> advised that his staff provides special considerations for high
profile inmates, if deemed appropriate and designated as such. In order to
ensure an inmate is provided with proper care, the facility evaluates the
inmate using several measures, including mental, physical, medical,
lnvcstigationon 08/12/2019 at
Fibe# 90A-NY-3151227
New York, New York, United States (In Person)
Date dratted 08/13/2019
by

SDNY_00007681
FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
90A-NY -3151227
Comthuation of FD-302 of (U) Interview of •o,, 08/12/2019 .page 2 of 6
psychological, and sexual assault victim or predator assessments. Since
different inmates are admitted with different criteria, appropriate housing
varies.

<REDACTED> interacted with inmate JEFFREY EPSTEIN on approximately three
occasions at MCC, all of which EPSTEIN maintained a pleasant demeanor.
During the first instance, EPSTEIN asked who he was, and
responded by introducing himself and explaining his position at the jail.
During another instance, explained to EPSTEIN the policy regarding
meals during attorney sessions, and made certain EPSTEIN was accommodated
with water, visits to the restroom, etc. EPSTEIN spent most of the day with
his defense counsel, and was brought down as soon as attorney visiting
opened.

<REDACTED> was made aware of the possibility that EPSTEIN would be housed at
MCC in advance of EPSTEIN'S arrival. was not present when inmate
EPSTEIN was admitted to the facility. EPSTEIN was thoroughly vetted to
determine if he was fit for General Population (GP) and was ultimately
placed in the Special Housing Unit (SHU). MCC places inmates under three
categories of close supervision: 1. "Dry Cell" for those at risk for
smuggling contraband, 2. Psychological Observation, and 3. Suicide Watch.

<REDACTED> advised that EPSTEIN preferred not to have a cellmate and engaged
in manipulative behavior to avoid having one, including requesting to see a
psychologist. At EPSTEIN'S request, he was interviewed by a psychologist.
Following this assessment, EPSTEIN was initially placed on Suicide Watch.
He was later interviewed again and downgraded to Psychological Observation,
because he was determined not to have suicidal tendencies. After some time,
he was returned to the SHU. began hearing talk that EPSTEIN was
trying to get back on Suicide Watch. Information like this is usually
generated from rounds, "kites", and monitoring of phone calls and letters.

On or about July 23, 2019, EPSTEIN was found unresponsive on the floor of
his cell with a homemade piece of fabric on his chest. EPSTEIN'S cellmate
had flagged the attention of a staff member, who handcuffed the cellmate and
removed EPSTEIN to bring him to the medical unit. heard from his
staff that EPSTEIN may have been faking unconsciousness, because he was
observed opening his eyes and making other suspicious movements not
consistent with an unconscious state. EPSTEIN was medically assessed and
Comthuation of FU-302 of ( U ) Interview of jm 08/12/2019 .page 3 of 6
became coherent. EPSTEIN claimed that his cellmate, NICHOLAS TARTAGLIONE,
tried to take his life. He was placed back on Suicide Watch for
approximately one week. Unlike his first and previous placement on Suicide
Watch, EPSTEIN now has definitive suicidal tendencies reported in his
incarceration history. The staff was tasked with determining whether
EPSTEIN was in fact suicidal, or using manipulative tactics to avoid
assignment of a cellmate. After Suicide Watch, EPSTEIN was placed on
Psychological Observation and eventually returned to the SHU.

At the direction of the Warden, initiated the process of compiling
possible cellmates for EPSTEIN, vetting them, and submitting candidates to
the Warden for his review. and his staff fully screened potential
cellmates and reported their determinations up to the Warden. EFRAIN REYES
was selected and housed in a cell with EPSTEIN. The Assistant Warden,
Warden, and Regional Director were notified.

The Warden directed <REDACTED> on multiple occasions that EPSTEIN needed a
cellmate at all times, and <REDACTED> verbally informed his Lieutenants the
same. repeatedly directed his SHU Lieutenant, Lieutenant , that
EPSTEIN needed a cellmate at all times. Additionally, visited the
SHU on multiple occasions and directed staff to be very alert and attentive
about EPSTEIN'S special accommodations.

On Friday, August 9, 2019, Lieutenant was on leave and, thus, there
was no dedicated Lieutenant assigned to the SHU. In this event, the
Operation Lieutenant, Lieutenant , had oversight that day and took
over the responsibilities of the SHU Lieutenant. Lieutenant was
aware that EPSTEIN was required to be housed with a cellmate, because
approximately one week prior to EPSTEIN'S death, informally advised
his Lieutenants that EPSTEIN was not be housed alone, and emphasized the
need to be vigilant about "30 -minute checks" and unannounced rounds.

Inmates/cellmates are moved for various reasons, including but not
limited to, an incident in the cell, visits to court, legal library,
medical, and recreation. On Friday, August 9, 2019, EPSTEIN'S cellmate,
REYES, had court. It would not be uncommon for REYES to be out of his cell
for an extended period. EPSTEIN had an attorney session that day.
EPSTEIN'S attorney was processed into the facility in the morning and
EPSTEIN was brought down to the attorney room. was not notified that
REYES was released from court.
SDNY_00007683

FD-302a (Rev. 5-8-10)
90A-NY-3151227
Comthwnion of FU-302 of ( U ) Interview of
.O,„ 08/12/2019 .page 4 of 6

Typically, if an inmate is likely to be discharged or transferred
following court, their property is retrieved from their cell, boxed, and
secured with a property form by Receiving and Discharge staff. All items
are normally accounted for and inventoried. In order to enter the SHU, all
staff not assigned there must identify themselves and sign the logbook, then
be physically escorted by a Correctional Officer. Alternatively, the staff
can pick up inmate property at the Unit door. A Correctional Officer
assigned to the SHU would have been aware that REYES'S, or any inmate's,
belongings were removed. At this time, the Correctional Officer should
notify a Lieutenant, who would in turn brief was not
notified that REYES' belongings were removed. advised that if he had
known that EPSTEIN was without a cellmate, he would have likely put EPSTEIN
on Psychological Observation. is not aware of any Lieutenants
knowing that REYES' property was moved.

On Saturday, August 10, 2019, <REDACTED> received a phone call from
Lieutenant around 7:00 AM, and was told that EPSTEIN was found
unresponsive in his cell. inquired about EPSTEIN'S cellmate and was
surprised to hear respond that EPSTEIN did not have a cellmate.

<REDACTED> worked a 4:00 PM - 10:00 PM shift on August 9, 2019. was
relieved by Lieutenant , who was assigned the 10 PM - 6 AM shift.
did not personally tell that EPSTEIN required a cellmate at
all times. He believed she was aware because he had informed his
Lieutenants repeatedly, and instructed them to pass this message along and
convey the information amongst themselves. did not hold a formal
all -Lieutenant meeting regarding EPSTEIN, or send a staff email with the
Warden's directive. He verbally instructed his Lieutenants on an informal
and individual basis, as many as possible with whom he had the opportunity.
On Saturday morning, August 10, 2019, was relieved early by
4111E!

In the SHU, 30-minute rounds need to be completed consistently at
nonuniform intervals within a 40-minute time frame. The purpose of these
rounds is to ensure that good order is being maintained, there is no
suspicious activity, and all inmates are accounted for and responsive. 30-
minute rounds are documented in TRUSCOPE, which serves as an electronic
logbook. After a round is physically done, the Correctional Officer can log
in to TRUSCOPE and press a button certifying that the round was completed.
Unfortunately, sometimes officers do not complete a 30-minute round, or
exceed the 40-minute threshold. TRUSCOPE also documents from what
location/terminal the rounds are logged. is aware of at least two
(2) terminals located in the SHU. The only way to determine if a 30-minute
round was physically completed is to check the video surveillance footage.

There are two (2) Correctional Officers assigned to the SHU on morning
watch at midnight, SHU1 and SHU2. SHU2 is responsible for completing
rounds.

<REDACTED> was unaware that the camera system in the SHU was down. He left
early on Thursday when the discussion about the camera system would have
occurred. <REDACTED>, the camera technician, notified <REDACTED> that he was
working on the system earlier that week, but did not know specifics
not informed that the cameras were not functioning. Since the
is in the middle of a camera project, assumed the camera
may have been related. was first notified that the cameras were
on Saturday morning, August 10, 2019, when he arrived at MCC and asked
to see the video. Correctional Officers do not typically know when the
cameras are down.

After receiving the phone call from on the morning of Saturday,
August 10, 2019, notified
informed the Warden.
, who
also attempted to call Institution Duty Officer
, the Chaplain, and the building, to get more information.
He then went to MCC, arriving before 8:00 AM, approximately. Upon arrival,
screened in and retrieved his gear from the 3rd Floor. He went to
the SHU and signed the logbook. He gathered any records pertaining to
EPSTEIN, including the 30-minute rounds logbook, the attorney conference
logbook, count slips, and El's. He could not locate EPSTEIN'S inmate file.
He also asked to view the camera footage. The Warden was already present at
the facility when arrived.

<REDACTED> expressed to that the staff admitted to her they did not
complete rounds, the 3:00 AM and 5:00 AM counts, and that Officer THOMAS
entered EPSTEIN'S cell without supervision. EPSTEIN was placed on the floor
to administer lifesaving efforts. informed
about what Officers NOEL and THOMAS admitted to

CominuationofFD-3020f (U) Interview of 08/12/2019 .page 6 of 6
had concerns about the whereabouts of EPSTEIN'S cellmate. Some of
his staff were under the impression that REYES was released from the SHU,
which later confirmed was not true.

The purpose of the 3:00 AM and 5:00 AM counts is to physically count and
confirm each person in each cell. There were no entries of counts in
TRUSCOPE the entire night. If technology is down, the Correctional Officers
also have
there are
retained.
the option to document the
no electronic records of
count on a
counts,
hardcopy form.
hardcopies may
Although
have been
All inmate phone calls in the SHU are monitored and inmates have limited
access to phone calls. All calls should be recorded. was not aware
of any issues or complaints with EPSTEIN related to phone calls. On
Saturday, August 10, 2019, was told that EPSTEIN made a phone call at
approximately 7:00 PM on the evening of Friday, August 9, 2019. It is
uncommon to make an unrecorded phone call in the SHU, and would
advise against it because calls should be surveilled. Inmates can make a
recorded phone call in the Lieutenant's Office, where it is documented in a
monitored logbook. In the SHU, Correctional Officers are not permitted to
give inmates phone calls, but a Unit Team Member or the Chaplain can take
the inmate to the Lieutenant's office to make a call. is not briefed
on phone calls in the SHU, generally.
wholeheartedly emphasized that he and his staff at MCC did their
best to supervise, safeguard and ensure the protection of EPSTEIN and all
inmates effectively. His staff is aware of the seriousness of the
investigation into EPSTEIN'S death.
SDNY_00007686
╔════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Effective Altruism [journalist] cult popular with tech CEOs who want an excuse for hoarding money (e.g. SBF of FTX) 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00266322 (Jmail)
 [misc] documents about pitches for non-profits in Australia, including to Effective Altruism
(inferred date: 2026-01-06)
Electoral district of Frome - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Page 2 of 3
t•-'1LX->tc es.c)kiN-3 -5-.7) )C-Cci F-LN ,--),••3(. 1
r L;N;7-.5‘f<lc ci,L;ERNI-1O\11- - fsc_L-1
Members for Frome
First incarnation (1884-1902, two members)
Member Party Term
none 1884-1890
William Copley none 1884-1887
Clement Giles none 1887-1890
Liberal 1890-1902
Conservative 1890—late 1890s
National Defence League Late 1890s-1902
Second incarnation (1938-1977)
Ebenezer Ward
Laurence O'Loughan
Clement Giles
Member Party
Mick O'Halloran
Tom Casey
Ernest Allen
Australian Labor Party
Australian Labor Party
Term
1938-1960
1960-1970
Liberal Party of Australia 1970-1977
Third incarnation (1993—present)
Member Party Term
Rob Kerin Liberal Party of Australia 1993-2008
Geoff Brock Independent 2009—present
Election results
Main article: Electoral results for the district of Frome
South Australian state election, 2010: Frome
Party Candidate Votes 04 *To
Independent Geoff Brock 7,965 37.7 +37.7
Liberal Terry Boylan 7,713 36.5 -12.0
Labor John Rohde 3,900 18.5 -22.0
Greens Joy O'Brien 644 3.1 -0.7
Family First John McComb 561 2.7 -2.5
Save the RAH Max Van Dissel 328 1.6 +1.6
Total formal votes 21,111 97.2
Informal votes 587 2.8
Turnout 21,698 94.8
Two-party -preferred result
Finn -Hen urarinetiist nrohuilei/Plertnrol rlictrirt nP Prnmia IG/AAt11111
Electoral district of Frome - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Page 1 of 3
Electoral district of Frome
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
home is an electoral district of the House of Assembly in the Australian state of South Australia. It
is named after Edward Charles Frome, the third surveyor-general of South Australia. The electorate
is based around the industrial city of Port Pirie and the agriculture areas of Clare and Gilbert Valleys.
It covers a total of 6,889.7 km2 and takes in the towns of Auburn, Clare, Crystal Brook, Gladstone,
Laura, Mintaro, Penwortham, Port Broughton, Port Pirie, Snowtown, Tarlee and Riverton.
Frame has existed in three incarnations throughout the history of the House of Assembly: as a multi-
member marginal electorate from 1884 to 1902, as a single member electorate in a multi member
electoral system from 1938 to 1977, and as a marginal to moderately safe seat for the Liberal Party
of Australia since 1993.
The first incarnation was, like the rest of the state, independent-held until the development of the
party system until in the 1890s. The two seats were split evenly with a conservative and a liberal
member from 1890 until the seat's abolition in 1902.
The second incarnation began in 1938 after the introduction of the Playmander. The electorate was
dominated by the Labor-voting town of Port Pirie as a single member seat. The seat was won by
Mick O'Halloran, who served as Opposition Leader from 1949 until his death in 1960. After the end
of the Playmander which saw all electorates hold approximately the same number of voters, Frome
took in more rural areas around Port Pirie, and was lost by Labor to the Liberal and Country League,
until the abolition of the seat in 1977.
The third incarnation saw the seat revived at the 1991 redistribution as a marginal seat, which took in
Port Pirie and surrounding rural areas. It was first contested at the 1993 election and was won by
Liberal candidate Rob Kerin.
3/4 Kerin chose to retire in November 2008, which triggered a January 2009 Frome by-election. The seat
was won by independent Geoff Brock after a very close preference contest in which Brock fetish
second place by 30 votes, with the Liberals in front and Labor coming third. Brock received
sufficient preferences from the eliminated Labor candidate to prevail over the Liberal candidate by
over 600 votes, or 51.7 percent of the two-candidate preferred vote. He increased his primary and
two-candidate vote significantly at the 2010 election, and the Labor candidate notably won the two-
party preferred vote against the Liberal candidate by 30 votes.
Government
of South Australia
2009MHE-03570
Miss
Dear Miss
Office of the:
Minister for Health
Minister for the
Southern Suburbs
Minister Assisting the
Premier in the Arts
Level 9
1I Ferdmarsh Square
Aoe:acie SA 5000
GPO Box 2555
Aoelacle SA 5001
DX 243
Telephone 10818463 6270
Facsim te :08' 8463 6277
ivinster Healthenea'th.sa.go•
On behalf of Hon John Hill MP, Minister for Health, I acknowledge receipt of your
letter of 18 September 2009 about a Specialist Medical Centre for Port Pine.
Your correspondence is currently receiving attention and a response will be forwarded
at the earliest opportunity.
Yours sincerely
leitc4A--)
(QvCarolyn Lee
Manager
Office of the Minister for Health
Date: x-,0.0°1
Hon John Hill MP
2009MHE•03570
Mi
Dear Miss
Government
of South Australia
Minister for Health
Minister for the
Southern Suburbs
Minister Assisting the
Premier In the Arts
Love' 9
1 I Ha-xi:P.3W Sq4Aft
Adelaide SA 5000
G30 3ux 2555
ACC a Ue 54 5:101
DX 243
lerephone (08)8463 6270
Facer:ere (08)8463 6277
midrste,Heard)Ohealth.sagov.
Thank you for your letter of 18 September 2009 about the establishment of a Specialist Medical Centre in Port Pihe.
SA Health recognises and encourages private medical services to be established within rural communities. SA Health and 
Country Health SA (CHSA) have a long
established
history of working collaboratively with private medical practitioners in the provision of health services to the 
residents of local communities.
Currently, CHSA and the local Health Advisory Council for Port Pine are engaged in a 10 year health service needs and 
planning process. This process will
identify the needs of the local community and support the planning of long term health services to meet those needs. You
may wish to consider discussing your
proposal to estabhsn
the Specialist Medical Centre in Port Pine with Mr Roger Kirchner, Director Mid North Cluster, CHSA on telephone 8638 
4575.
Thank you for bringing this matter to my attention and I trust this information w:I: be of assistance to you.
Yours sincerely
MINISTER FOR HEALTH
Date: 7° 4$
•••• ..,.. . 4~0 410,0 hetet' SS',
DIRECTIONS
NIZUMV, SIZMMIIIIMINOINP
putting people fi rst
Links to Seek Lawlament On Line
South Australian Government's Notice of Vacancies website
http://www.vacancies.sa.qov.au
A Heath •
http: .sa ea
c 4 01 ?VV . n
licc1ev Y lc( V-% rear 62 no  9
careers.com.au
Australian Job Search
http://iobsearch.qov.au
Seek
http://www.seek.com.au
indeed
http://www.indeed.com.au
i;;I'S.00771
http://iobs.com.au
Jobseelcer
http://www.iobseeker.com.au
Career Ore
http://www.careerone.com.au
The Resource Channel a
http://www.theresourcechannel.com.au/job-board?
kevs=&location=1 01 &discipl i ne=All&ind ustrv=All&as=Search+Jobs&level=All&class=A
nv&posted=All&quicksearch=true
To seek Mining vacancies go to each individual company website & apply direct eg:
- BHP Biliton - Rio Tinto - Oz Minerals
- Heathgate Resources
- Skilled
- Brambles - Chandler Macleod
- Monadelphous - Santos
To seek Retail vacancies go to each individual ccmpany v,rebsite & apply direct eg:
- Kmart - Coles - Woolworths
- Auto Pro - Supa Cheap Auto - Target
- Supa Cheap - Reject Shop - Go-Lo

╭──────────────────────────────── Page 5, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────────╮
│ ions                                                                             │
│                                                                                  │
│ t                                                                                │
│                                                                                  │
│ irec                                                                             │
│                                                                                  │
│ Employment D                                                                     │
│                                                                                  │
│ South Australian Government's Notice of Vacancies webs!                          │
│                                                                                  │
│ http://www. vacancies.sa.gov.au                                                  │
│                                                                                  │
│ ae amin                                                                          │
│                                                                                  │
│ SA Health Roger Kirchner - Secre-\ 2009                                          │
│                                                                                  │
│ http://www.sahealthcareers.com.au _                                              │
│                                                                                  │
│ http://jobsearch.gov.au                                                          │
│                                                                                  │
│ ian Job                                                                          │
│                                                                                  │
│ httov/www.seek.com.au                                                            │
│                                                                                  │
│ http://www.indeed.com.au                                                         │
│                                                                                  │
│ http://jobs.com.au                                                               │
│                                                                                  │
│ Jobsesker                                                                        │
│                                                                                  │
│ http://www .jobseeker.com.au                                                     │
│                                                                                  │
│ http:/Awww.careerone.com.au                                                      │
│                                                                                  │
│ The Resource Channel (Mining Vacancies A ide!                                    │
│ http:/Awww.theresourcechannel.com.au/job-board?                                  │
│                                                                                  │
│ keys=&location=101 &discipline=All&industry=All&qs=Search+Jobs&level=All&class=A │
│ ny&posted=All&quicksearch=true                                                   │
│                                                                                  │
│ T cies go to eg:                                                                 │
│ ~ BHP Bilton ~ Rio Tinto = Oz Minerals                                           │
│                                                                                  │
│ - Heathgate Resources ~ Brambles - Chandler Macleod                              │
│                                                                                  │
│ + Skilled ~ Monadelphous - Santos                                                │
│                                                                                  │
│ - Kmart = Woolworths                                                             │
│ = Auto Pro ‘Supa Cheap Auto = Target                                             │
│ - Supa Cheap ~ Reject Shop = Go-lo                                               │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Our ref: 13YNRR063
1 May 2013
Dear Ms
g7\L; (,. Government of South Australia
::::Z sit4  SA Health
Country Health SA Local Health
Network Inc.
Yorke and Northern Rural
Region
ch Pon Pine Regional Heath Senate
The Terrace
PO Box 546
PORT PIRIE SA 5540 -
Phone (08) 8638 4581
Fax (08) 8638 4356
MIN 96 157 860 816
Websae lAW1Se health se tow aci
I write in response to your letter dated 23 April 2013 in which you are seeking information on the meetings that have 
occurred during the year of 2009 between
you and I so you can provide this information to the Minister for Health.
I can confirm that we have met on two occasions to discuss your proposed Business Plan and research and that these 
meetings were held on 11 December 2009 and 5
February 2010, as arranged by my then Executive Assistant, Ms Jemma Salvemini.
I also understand that you would like information on the role of the Port Pirie Health Advisory Council (HAC) and that 
you are considering applying to the HAC
to become a member. Can I please suggest that you write to the HAC expressing your interest in becoming a member and ask
that the HAC consider your nomination.
The letter can be made attention to Mr Barry Hay, Presiding Member of the Port Pirie Health Advisory Council, PO Box 
546, Port Pirie SA 5540.
I will be in contact with you shortly to discuss the role and function of the HAC.
Yours sincerely
ROget Kirchner
Regional Director
M~nlcPc.C a)C`a I NEsTh PLAN MS IC Cz;frieluivi CFriteN "7- c:e t- OPINAP T) FokJoit\lc,
Hon John Hill MP
Ms
near Mr;
Government
of South Australia
Minister for Health
and Ageing
Minister for Mental Hea
and Substance Abuse
-Minister for the Arts
int' 9
1: 34 oti 33a.‘33 So.- 3:
Am Go SA 5C7,3.3
G70 3ox 7355 -
Ace t oe SA SW.;
Y.< 4
Te CO ore i08i 8463 6270
1.04 ;OW 8463 627i
P‘ SA
Thank you for your letter of 31 August 2012 about establishing a specialist medical
centre at Port Pine and offering to provide the business plans and research information
collected throughout your project.
I asked Adjunct Professor Belinda Moyes, Chief Executive Officer, Country Health SA
Local Health Network (CHSA), who is responsible for Port Pine Regional Health
Service (PPRHS), to consider your offer and I am advised as follows:
As Ms may be aware, the PPRHS already provides consulting room
facilities for some specialties identified through consultation with the local general
practitioners.
In these instances, PPRHS pays the travel allowance and provides hospital
accommodation for visiting specialists providing medical inpatient services.
PPRHS also distributes monthly information to all doctors and health units within
the town and surrounding area of the specialists' visiting dates and the waiting
times to see new patients.
The completed Pod Pine GP Pius Health :are Centre, sct;eduieri Ica Sepir. 11.1fri
2013, will also have capacity to provide additional consulting space, if needed
The nature of what additional medical services may be required is yet to be
determined.
The Port Pirie Health Advisory Council has undertaken a 10 year planning
process, and is now engaging the local general practitioner in planning how to
shape medical services into the future.
If Ms would like to have input into the development of the Pod Pine GP
Plus Health Care Centre, there is a consumer group that she may wish to join.
Further information is available by contacting Ms Lisa Cockington, Regional
Director, Community Health and Primary Health Care Programs, PPRHS, CHSA,
on telephone 8638 4505 or Ms Georgina Bickley, Manager, Environmental Health
Centre, PPRHS, CHSA, on telephone 8638 4100.
Thank you you for writing to me on this matter.
Yours sincerely
n zz_ -L,,
MINISTER FOR HEALTH AND AGEING
Date -227 16 14,
YloN€"cfutc Devexemearr
1)6-Nitto Reciasi -Reqtc of es)sit.)EsS N\est4E
LIL De‘ltc. IDEStC,n16 rtfkSr (3.1/4.)520.1CS-S NAMC
ce Et.) rvt..c_SS
09 May 2011
Dear Client,
Application for Registration of a Business Name
OffICe of
consumerana
Business Affairs
Wound now. Chesser House
91-97 Grenfell Street
Adelaide SA 5000
GPO Box 1907
Adelaide SA 5001
Telephone 1300138918
Facsimile 1081 8209 9771
www.ocbastgov.au
ABN 30 652 402 747
I refer to your application (Ref: 891020), to register the above business name. The Office of
Consumer and Business Affairs (OCBA), incorporating the Corporate Affairs Commission, is considering refusing your 
application under Section 8(4) of the
Business Names Act 1996 (the
Act).
OCBA believes the name is likely to be confused with, or mistaken for the registered name(s):
However, before OCBA decides, we give you the opportunity to provide us with:

1. any further information or arguments that might influence OCBA's decision (this process can take up to 4 weeks); or
2. a letter withdrawing your application (application fees are non refundable); or 3. another name or names (up to 3) 
for OCBA to consider.
Please note: Further name choices should be substantially different from your previous name choice. Adding 
non—descriptive words e.g. services or solutions,
changing plurals to singular or vice versa, or adding acronyms e.g. SA to your original name choice is unlikely to 
change OCBA's opinion.
3.1
3.2
3.3
I:wslt Government
of South Australia
OCBA invites you to pursue any one of these 3 options within 28 days. If you have not
responded, on 9 June 2011, OCBA's decision will be that your appli  inn is refused. You will
not receive further notice and you will not be entitled to use the nam
Should this occur, you have the right to appeal against OCBA's decision to the District Court
under Section 16 of the Act within 21 days thereafter.
Should you require any further information, please contact the office on 1300 138 918.
Yours faithfully,
and Forster
or the Corporate Affairs Commission
Uta Id: Rpll
tPit t
A411/1.!
e:t)
Government
of South Australia
De REGIS -ERE -O FRoc-1 Ca S i C LF$ l M i r3 C, 'SET op co an - -
Renee t A•c-A IJD NC  I 6Q>ccE tr .; FON) im S - Qt. u u- c t-C, SCRE
OF - rt-1G (Sot% KIS S'.5".•.)
• the ATO is not satisfied that the supplier has reimbursed the GST incorrectly included in the
price to the recipient (subparagraph 105-65(1Xc)(i) of Schedule 1 to the TM); and
c the recipient is registered or required to be registered for GST purposes (subparagraph 105-
65(1)(c)(ii) of the TM).
Furthermore as a general rule, the ATO will not exercise the discretion to allow a refund or credit in
accordance with subsection 105-65(1) of Schedule 1 to the TM if the supplier has not first
reimbursed the recipient.
In your activity statements for the above mentioned periods you have reported sales and
subsequently remitted GST. Once you can show proof of reimbursement of the GST portion of
your supplies to the recipient of the supply we will refund the GST remitted.
Issue 2

Section 11-5 of the A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (GST Act) requires
that for the purchase to be creditable, it must be for a creditable purpose, supplied to you as a
taxable supply for which you are liable to provide consideration and that you are registered.

Section 382-5 of Schedule 1 to the Tax Administration Act 1953 (TM) requires that you keep
records. If you give the Commissioner a return for GST that is attributable to a tax period under
subsection 29-10(4) of the GST Act you must keep records that record and explain all transactions
and other acts you engage in that are relevant to the acquisition or importation in question; and you
must retain those records for at least 5 years after the return was given to the Commissioner.
One of the key considerations for correct attribution is when you hold a tax invoice. Subsection 29-
10(3) explains that if you do not hold a tax invoice for an acquisition when you lodge your activity
statement for the tax period to which the input tax credit would otherwise be attributable:
(a)the input tax credit (including any part of the input tax credit) is not attributable to that tax
period; and
(b)the input tax credit (or part) is attributable to the first tax period for which you give the
Commissioner a GST return at a time when you hold that tax invoice.
We have determined that you did not possess tax invoices when you lodged your activity
statement's. This is because despite our request you have not produced these documents. You
therefore have no entitlement to any input tax credits for the tax periods 1 January 2011 — 31
March 2012.
)c-You claimed GST on purchases of $7,043 at label 1B of your activity statement for the period's 1
January 2011 — 31 March 2012.
In accordance with section 105-5 of the TM the Commissioner has assessed that you are not
entitled to the credits claimed during the period 1 January 2011 — 31 March 2012. As a result of
this assessment, Label 18 will be reduced to $nil and Label 1A has been adjusted from $570 to
$57 as shown on your copy of the activity statement that you provided us.
Please refer to the summary of activity statement revisions that is attached.
Reasons for our penalty decision
Penalty shortfall amount and tax period

Section 284-75 of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (TM) imposes an
administrative penalty if you make a statement to us which is false or misleading.
Page 5 of 6
We formed our view of the facts by relying on this information:
Activity statements lodged for the tax periods 1 January 2011 — 31 March 2012
Our decision:
Issue 1
Are you entitled to be registered for GST?
NO.
Issue 2 - C t_Ot re\ n1c, E `31- e'llAt-ceN 37 Cir-F.-71 S .
Are you entitled to the GST credits claimed on Business Activity Statement/s lodged for the tax
period/s 1 January 2011 — 31 March 2012
- NO.
Why we have made this decision:
Issue 1

Section 25 of the A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (GST Act) provides that
the Commissioner must cancel your GST registration if he is satisfied that you are not carrying on
an enterprise.

Section 9-20 of the GST Act provides that an enterprise is an activity, or a series of activities, done:

(a) in the form of a business; or
(b) in the form of an adventure or concern in the nature of trade; or
(c) on a regular or continuous basis, in the form of a lease, licence or other grant of an
interest in property.
-4(c However, an enterprise does not include an activity, or series of activities, done as a private,
recreational pursuit or hobby.
In conjunction with section 9-20 of the GST act amongst some of the indicators that tell us a
business enterprise being conducted are an intention of making a profit and a reasonable prospect
of profitability, existence of a business plan, keeping of detailed business records, commercial
sales of product &/or skills, exercise of knowledge of skill (Taxation Ruling TR 97/11).
You have not supplied any of the requested information, such as a business plan, business
registration, details of your client base or advertising intentions that demonstrates that you are, in
fact, running an enterprise.
Furthermore, you have not shown a profit since you first commenced this business nor have you
provided any evidence showing any expectation of profit from this business.
Therefore your GST registration will be cancelled effective 31 December 2010.
As our decision is that your activity does not constitute an enterprise, you are not required to be
registered for GST or report GST on your sales.
Subsection 105-65(1) of Schedule 1 to the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (TAA) provides that
where goods and services tax (GST) is incorrectly included in the price of a non taxable supply, the
ATO is not obliged to refund or credit the overpaid amount to the supplier when one of the
following conditions are met:
Page 4 of 6
Kt. E O RccC`>≥
Conmonwealth Bank NtEp.c t-k to N FI9C FC.:a Commo nwealth Bank of Australia
ABN 48 123 123 124 c ":O t` 4 cij t-ler•jL. Gr 1/4 2 %C,
Working Capital Services, PBS
PO Box 4086 Freecall 1800 230 177
Panamatta Facsimile (02) 9841 1355
NSW 2124 Telex AA 27521
DX 1020 Sydney (2067 058)
2082012140951
The Proprietor
J Moneauic
Monday, 20 August 2012
Your Reference Ms
Dear Sir/Madam
Thank you for applying for a Commonwealth Bank of Australia merchant facility.
After careful consideration and evaluation of the information_provided in your appliatibri we are unable to offer you a 
merchant facility.
The Bank's decision is based on an overall assessment of the information provided in your application in accordance with
our acceptance policy.
Contributing factors for our decision may include:
The duration of your business since establishment
Your current financial position
The type of business you operate
The length and assessment of any other relationship you have with us
Due to confidentiality measures around our acceptance policy, the Bank is unable to further disclose in more detail the 
factors that led to this decision.
Thank you once again for your application. We wish you the very best in all future endeavours.
Yours sincerely,
Andrew Cheesman
General Manager
Merchant Solutions
Reference: 336020.336032 Letter l3Decline Version 8
PURCHASER'S RECEIPT
62070240 32
DEMEAD -TRenYENteRK of - siitAT It &Atter DelSicK15 t rJ POSSES5a) cr •
I-ORNA SAP 6 s Pc* n)c,
Australian Government
IP Australia
ACT 2606 AUSTRALIA Tel: 1300651 010 ABS: 36 113 072 755
'999 Imemalional- .6126263 2999 Telex: COMPAT AA 61517
Official Receipt
Customer ABN:
Customer ID:
CMR
Date:09 Aug 2012
5
NPS Batch:
Non NPS Batch:
Description Amount
Trade Marks SI80.00
TOTAL $180.00
Reference: Trade Marks TM App
Central Office
Note: Amounts shown include GST where applicable. Under Division 81 of A New Tax System (Goods
and Services Tax) Act 1999, GST is not payable on the purchase of any statutory items from IP Australia.
Australian Government
"' IP Australia
Ms
UNRECONCILED MONIES - TRADE MARKS
Your ref:
to
I
Discovery House. Phillip ACT 2606
PO Box 200. Woden ACT 2606
Australia
P 1300 651 010
(International)
E
ipaustralla.gov.au
This office is in receipt of $180 for a payment in relation to an unidentified trade mark.
Could you please advise what the payment is for and the trade mark number to which it
relates.
Please quote Batch
Yours sincerely,
,4ary Flint
Trade Marks and Designs Administration
02 6283 2023
13 November 2012
dated 09 Aug 12.
Robust intellectual property rights delivered efficiently POD PBR
ICC
a
MS%
PO BOX 200
WODEN ACT 2606
Australian Government
I P Australia
CICOOSComaanii mei•J ea Mn I WWI, I CON4.000. I MICOM00.1 I ,...®„
This remittance advice details your cheque payment. Please find
cheque attached. If you have any queries, please phone Accounting
Operations on 1300 651 010.
Overpayment on Batch -- Trademarks Refund: $180.00
Reason: No response to letter regarding payment. Refunding fees
already paid.
Your Ref: Payment by Money Order 9/8/12
Application No: N/A
AMOUNT
$180.00
TOTAL $180.00
DQ•Pen ro t\ir ) ,N c pore pitz‘e cocw_u_ - PORI PiTt‘e so Hoos tN c%
GOVERNMENT Dale PMENTT 902C- &AleRutiENT ANt7  1410tNe
- ONDER -THE Rectistkerook) cat- -3c it.u.xDoemoNls Q0 t9
12/10/2016
As a suggestion  Port Pirie Housing Project - Youth Housing - Under 25 years of age
For example
Abandon housing to be utilized for cost effective renovations suitable for youth housing and
targeted at the age range of 25 years of age and under - Low maintenance gardens / yard areas Minimum bond required - 
Lower priced bracket, rental payments
required - Inspections as per dictated in rental agreements - Group housing encouraged.
Strictly for disadvantaged, unemployed, emergency housing, youth, under 25 years of age.
Example - Rental payments - $150.00 - $200.00 price range, week
Example - Bond required - Minimum,1 month bond required
Individual Payment Scheme - Individual responsibility of payments - Rent, Bonds. Utilities
Rental agreements - Individually based according to payments of rental payments, bonds required, utility accounts
Individually based payments - Each individual is recorded on the rental agreement as being
responsible for their share of the rental payment, bond required and utilities required.
As per individual - Missed payments - Individual is given a warning of eviction and is required to forfeit their share 
of the bond upon this occurrence and is
individually evicted without this eviction
effecting the other residence of the property.
Utility payments required as per individually based and is the responsibility of the individual. Utility accounts are 
separated into an individual sum of the
total - Split payments of the account
total and placed into the individuals name as the share of responsibility
Bonds - Bonds are separated into individual payments of the total sum and responsible by the individual
Rental payments - Payments are separated into individual payments of the total sum and responsible by the individual
Example . Rental agreement - Group Housing • Rental payments - Bonds
Bond required - $400.00 - 1 month bond - $200.00 per week
Group Housing - 3 individuals - Bond split 3 ways - Rental payments split 3 ways Each individual is registered upon the 
one rental agreement and is individually
responsible for their share of the payment, splitting the total sum of the account into three individual payments 
-Including bonds required and utility accounts
applied
Concerns
Eliminates shortage of housing for the youth due to damages occurring within the housing sector
to rental property's - specifically for the youth taking into consideration, age factors, responsibility
factors, care of oneself as an individual, creates a sense of responsibility for individual payments
of the cost of living, specifically group housing.
Eliminates the stress factor of payments required which is the responsibility of the individual and
not that of a whole or sole responsibility according to the name registered on the rental
agreement, bonds and utilities.
Eliminates the effect on individuals - Group housing of payments or eviction.
Eliminates and lowers accumulated debts of rental payments, bonds, utility accounts as a whole
Damages of property are to be expected due to the learning of the youth, but remain the
responsibility of the individual - Bonds required - Cost effective renovations of the housing with
this factor considered.
PE_A\ItED F-OrQoi n)c., - DECo\rrA m Ocri- usF OF n  trRervicp4 / Si -EM t%) PCSSESSioN1 or t cavi aotz,NE
D ELion c5E_ ok)WERSITI - CAc1/41 E-Wmetic Fun)Deo
7 / 11 / 2016
Private and Confidential
Dear Sir / Madam,
I would like to introduce myself, my name is and I have been a resident of Port
Pine for 15 years.
In previous developments I have worked extensively within the Medical fields and conducting
research of public awareness concerning Health issues, involving the need for Specialists
services within the regional locations and areas of South Australia, which was developed to
extend to the Metropolitan areas of South Australia and to worldwide proportions, creating a much
needed commodity concerning the public's health issues within these regions and locations.
I am contacting you today to express my concerns in relation to the ongoing effects of the public's
health issues in regards to cross contamination caused by Airbome germs and bacteria, which
include the effects of Influenza, colds and other related causes of cross contamination of germ
contaminates.
Within my suggestion I have included the details of the suggested table of Target Markets, which
outline the services suitable for this New Development, and of whom may accept and
acknowledge a need for this New Development.
I have included and outlined in the section - Advantages - Increase - Decrease - in line with this
New Development in order fo create an understanding of the health issues of which the public or
individual, including that of Prominent positions encounter due to regular travel commitments or
work related commitments for your review.
I have included the suggestion concerning the effects of cross contamination contaminates in the
section - Solution - which entails and outlines the direction of the New Development, of which will
work in conjunction with the stipulated details of the health issues of cross contamination, within
the sectors related to work related environments and the stipulated Target Markets, included for
your review.
Although I am contacting you in regards to a suggested development, I would appreciate a
personal recognition by your company upon your consideration or acceptance of this proposal,
that I feel would greatly benefit the public view and concerns of the public's health issues but also
the medical developments within Australia and provide advancement within these areas of public
health and medicine.
My contact details have been included and are enclosed within the letter of proposal for your
convenience in regards to questions you may have or to contact myself in regards to acceptance
of this proposal.
I thank you for your time and consideration regarding this matter.
Yours Sincerely
7111 /2016
Email :
Private and Confidential
Australian Pharmaceutical Company
Airborne Germs - Cross Contamination - Airborne Contaminates - Colds - Influenza -
Associated airborne contaminates, as an example
Points of Interest : Target Market

• Transport Services
• Bus services
• Airline services
• Train services
• Tram services
• Work place environments - Office areas

• Doctor's surgery's - Waiting rooms - Consultation rooms
• Accommodation services
• Food preparation services - Kitchen staff

• Dental Clinics - Consultation rooms - Office areas - Waiting rooms
• Education Departments and services - Class rooms - Office areas

• Medical services - Establishments - Surgery - Office areas - Hospitals
• Business Class - VIP's - Prominent positions - Office areas - Personal residence - First
class travel services and areas
Advantages - Increase - Decrease

• Decrease cross contamination of germs - Through mouth, nose, touch of objects or other
persons
• Increase in work related capacity and productivity-Work place Environment

• Decrease cross contamination within Medical establishments, Hospitals, Dental
Clinics - Golden staff, for example - Mouth sores - Colds - Influenza - Increasing
productivity and capacity within the medical establishments work environment,
employee's, patients, Practicing Physicians

• Decrease cross contamination in relation to travel services and accommodation
services within the cliental and employee's

• Increasing productivity in Educational environments
• Eliminates cross contamination within Food preparation environments and all above
mentioned services - Public and personal

• Provides special services for VIP'S, Professional positions - Prominent positions - First
class travel services - Eliminates cross contamination - Increases productivity of the
individual, work place environments, employee's

• Increases and reduces costs of sterilization services - Safety of instruments and equipment
exposed and used within the Medical establishments including Doctor's surgery's,
Hospitals, Dental Clinics
• Decreasing the use of prescribed antibiotics - Immune System creating other
symptoms to occur, including the multiplying effects of super bugs associated with
influenza and other non bacterial diseases
Solution :
Formula developed and expelled through the use of Air conditioning Units within these
establishments and travel services eliminating the threat and cause of cross contamination,
decreasing work related capacity and productivity within the individual, including the practicing
physicians or employee's of these establishments.
Eliminating the threat of cross contamination, Lawsuits involved in Medical issues, cross
contamination, which include Food preparation establishments
Purifying the air in close proximity to the individual, areas of close proximity which include Travel
services, Medical establishments, Waiting rooms, Instruments used.
Targeting untreatable symptoms unsuitable for antibiotic prescribed medication, which include
Influenza, colds and other airborne disease cross contaminates.
2f3t1 MED TO Ple9NiCeR
T.t4 FoR.t.4 cc) PRWFtTE AND CoNFIDer411f 2H-- or c,,_e,\ ,,DE r- ,1 ENT B(-
e,Lr->INESt› (TR0~._ cc,ue0 nle.n BE HEPr(- -ri-t OPE..t9el
Ocnber. f -ut4DiNc., v≤.-,et>
GLEtsli5IDE COM rIoN 1-k0c2co PRO ågc..7" Shn.kuoRY
-34- PI o EASE OF Acct.) Defr c>.+.1
sit I9C-ce,-"S5 FRet-i U.K.A•rflik`l B:Itz.er4.5 I EASE eF Rce-oNcOATioi
r›. •  c.t.:51. OF cit.,' NG, E-.>c Penise5
fia.455 TO FAciuTiE6 klittieN TV Röcpt4 I L.)T Er%.151
Flee) CCING TH C...051" c.)i=" L►JIrNNG EYPeN5ES .
)I 5 EGURE: PRE el C 605“./ Pc4 6650 CLE - Fpc.4655 TO
FOOL -1c -TR AK -5 PORT i N TERMS GF cocerr
II~oRKS tN CO 63 .YDNICI 1 \ hN3 ITN EMPLOYMENT Hoosit•14
RK„)  ec-1 6[ 2,61NY. -THE C.05r5 C.)f- NG AND LiuiNG
getRRCIN CLCIMENS1-5 . RENTtg L. Rest Der\ke FOR 19
Prikk‘00 oF I s/efltS, - FINANCAleie ST f5egu -ry  .
Lb.; GLUe5TICAN'a
1 t-RONIDik‘i F Mc( L t Tt ENS
4 Avnt W -re ?
"rem, 26(.4.4Nci TO i"CronNentorTS
c 17 •
51)e- TelkKet -5 G.LCKStre eket•IlvflL I-teeLlk
Ltrf
4-1A-ND v•If<v 1"-CO ADEC"tpe 5
NOT- ‘1•4•51-42, c.4•3 H com('uteR
et: e-tzt f-Ty k-ko..),skkk) - COVER'S raNeKT- KNQiä) (3' 4  Pee%St rS r".1•C‘ •••••• •••• ••••,swN.
- FIDEA.A3DE LAJNERS , T • /
pRIV►aTE HND CoN F-t oc.'Nrt pjeccx-v-kov>FrTtc,"4
C.cNI:RNMENri" N..t•i•SESS t*Ct ,
FiCit.>f,INC4 PtkCJe-QL  TR NU PR) , ,2C17
PirfoReelf3t.E; - STUDENTS
* -MftINC-r:e5 eoucicrnonflqt, pORPosE5
1 >t r4v A eU I L.0 INC. • 51-11.),4-reD Prr THE 51oE cF c.JPL.
CPI Pr ./ kn) 8..D SPACE '" t"".Fk5C4.1 P. civ D C.)N
i-rec3Le f-"c;R Re tONS INTO Pcc)AmFrrER .le5
o/ 4 R . ervovi=moNS ) PRo ,.. .cT - s,.., i-T-Aat.x .-E Fet. (jA;bc,(9.- -1-
RE.No•)FrrtoW3 tNve4.- 1/4., ING ccrirs"; NMI *dillkii , SERVICE`
PEOPLE Pr'+'4INc4 gi tv 65 / 'AAA Tev ,s,N PPR -ric-tPr4NT5 Ex.:r.
cortink..r.)x -r , / eer5e -C) PR(..',.)E .CT tNCL)O INCt ick<ENC"/& •rioN;
UF C LE19 NI NC% PAINTING I 34-4 k FT I N C, GI= F0RN:Wr0fki
Pfke PfNfkrrnOaS ` /ARD c.t.er+NiNG I  DIGGINGGt .: HOCES Fui
re.f4c.-1i ,:, C4 col - .
3* Fl\)c- I r%)C4 FENc.t NC. (-)F ARE t9 5 e: PF,Ftfrn W. , 57 t.:, O 4==f\i"73
FROM efn-t  E NTS GF  c,ce"75I1DE HEM crtH FI4-C4 LIr
41 4 BEDRootil FBcit..4716.5 5E4, ConrrA trå Effil -fRCOM AND
FPCILI -RES ek)ILT InN iNPRORC,E55 I (35Dr)INC, -
OFFICE D e•-'5K C,k,` HE-AD L riTI ni 5 t-A DI NC, OGORS
HANGING sPrx.4-; 1A)AlkDROt3e5lci..cri ek-.) kt.1 tN -
sItikece IN F,ecvE HEF)O InitrW- -) I PULL OCWN) 1-itr4C , ED
DooRS
5 ,i KITCHEN FAcAti -re-5 - TV ibt.F.cc.)M - 3 -otr\1T - commoNpL,
col-Jr/tun", ickin-teN Fwvo -ry Rocim Ft9crLITS FOR AU_
Re NIAL. APPLICANT'S eAC PIPPCI C.111\11' SPoNsIBLE
cc-0%4i NC, oF" ONES FeOD - cobtc(NC.
D (..4 e-c> )£ 5 t 0T - 5 -1 S1pL FRt9ZZE
RE - F-"R‘PeRfrrQR SEPERfrrE" LOcAcr-RS FG14 pcoo
4a4:5-rotruaG.0
PR(uATe AND. Cors:F‘D€NTIAL
FeBRe~i 9.0'7
Gterss ,pe cor-~iri FP-IPu)yislEr•J-1 4?f_cf,CATICaNå Hoe)Sink,
Arofkbt i_ AcerimoperneN FOR Crifke'l MENTOPPoR-N -INITS,
.44 CARczttolz)-T-es jw-FRAiNCES PPPRE hi-TIS+t P*3 e.-MP
4 P&OnInf-NOrTneA (SCIUJING F_cec,8 -reo -
FkARgteTp.)(7i pve,  Merv".
Cmrr/ WAN) ?)-rrtCE • REA-JDNII-ELE coi t)t -flonl SLI -1-1,9E3Le
DuRmfrrkte5 Rt.cr-ts
94 ReNex1FrrIC_)c-- ( PRO,16eT - 5ei-ffi8LE FOR EWD4-e-T RE..~A -ricA
C_CA-4L)t.%T'i SERvic.£5 I er-c)PLE rt -r•iin)e rcNtSJ
`10LAzt. pp. -Tkc.,pr=)N -T.5/ is-lervs selEt.,) Plc1R-skC er -IKTT
COMM l.)1\: F3X t•--0 pING g.e-ne 1/4)§45-Tion..\.5 of
C.LEFN Cc)) Nrn NC. I S*1 F-n er FLAN i-r-C•Rel
i' lerf -,RFTrioN\s 7 MR0  CLeANti c, ) t)C,c,tive CF t-tc)Cc'--5 Fc.,R
FENunK, ecr
ik FENC.IN4 reNeir.x. be:  MREIct 5 ePr)Rern c) ccorf• 11
PFFIl evvi5 OF GLENsiDe riet\, -TAL. rit":7H f6C.I t, Ty
H (3 G-oRcc.*--1 FI9GILITIES Cf."7119iNe.o
TOILETRY FAC<Lir Eb r IN LA)r)R,DR.c"CS ØpINL4
OFFIC,E CUER He -t3 0 firrNc, - 5LIpllVt, Oc-cifA5 a
HATJC,) ttiG SPACE V,7P,RORt3E3C75 - icccf -n -ticJe - Beier - Ir\
5 1-ORRee. I N Aetwe HEAD W Au -5 - PL ,Lee_-0 DoiA)N
HINGED Dee Ks
•sk I<ticRely FAcIuTIE5l TV ROON1 "" CC,MMuNiOt-
COMmL)NIAL. k r -rc.)-+EN PIN() -1-k; Reeri Ff7C- I (TY ruR f)c.
fteNnpe r-rppLiciAN1 -5 6-ACH RUN'Irft Aceeri ob,crri N
Cx_t(Pf3t\i'r I S R E-5Pc.A5I BLE FbiZ Cc)OkiNc4 oF °NC -5
ECOK POW Sill NC' CoNrigarr
Commonwealth Bank of Australia
ABN 48 123 123 124
RESCUT of fReCO0LEAST MC T(ciM i Commornroalthaank
ACE, AC c-1., STILL. PRESENT ON CRC- PIT R.€51-1tti ReVOkk .
7A, 7 August 2018
MS
Dear Ms
Thank you for your Personal Loan application for $6,000.
We have carefully assessed your application and unfortunately it has been unsuccessful
based on your current financial circumstances. This decision was based on information
received from the credit reporting body, Veda Business Information Services Limited.
Loan amount: $6,000.00
What you need to know
When we make a decision about whether to provide you credit, we consider a number of
factors, including information we already hold about you, new information that you provide in
your application and credit history information provided by credit reporting bodies
Factors that can be taken into account include the adequacy of your income to meet
repayments on an ongoing basis, your other debts and financial commitments. the length of
time you have been employed and your credit history. including any bankruptcy, defaults.
serious credit infringements, the number of applications for credit you may have made and
any recorded payment defaults.
In your case, one of the factors that led us to decline your loan application was credit history
information we obtained from Veda Advantage (and in some cases Dun & Bradstreet) for the
purposes of assessing your application.
What Next?
If you would like a free copy of your credit information file from a credit reporting body you
can request this within 90 days of this letter from'
• Veda Advantage Information Services and Solutions Limited www.veda.com.au
• Dun & Bradstreet (Australia) Pty Ltd. — www.checkyourcredit.com.au
We recommend you regularly check the accuracy of information held on you by credit
reporting bodies, as incorrect information may affect your ability to obtain credit.
We're here to help
We would like to be able to help you reach your financial goals and we invite you to re-apply
at a later date. Personal circumstances can, and do, change over time, so please stay in
touch and we will be happy to meet with yOu to discuss your needs.
For information about accessing, correcting or making a complaint about the credit
infomiation that we hold about you, please visit commbank.com.au (follow the Privacy
Policy link) to view the most recent copy of our Group privacy policy.
Yours sincerely,
9 ,A)
.0/ :
Brian Moseley
General Manager, Retail Customer Service
7007 PL V03.05.59 Ovi7,8/20 8 11.15 Page 2 of 2
25th June 2019
Dear Mr Gates,
I would like to introduce myself, my name is and i am a resident of
South Australia. I have resided in numerous small communities of South Australia and
various city locations within Australia. While residing within these numerous locations i have been involved in 
submitting various suggestions of infrastructure
changes and new ideas to make improvements to the districts communities facilities and established
Infrastructures which has been recognised and implemented within the districts councils and development boards.
My qualifications include Small Business Management, Business Administration and i have developed numerous written 
business plans and proceeded to develop the
concepts to the completed stages of establishment.
Registered businesses include :
I have also developed my skills into that of writing novels and currently have a
publishing contract with Austin Macauley Publishing, London, U.K and the release of my first book will be this year, 
with two subsequent books to be submitted
and published
over the next couple of years.
I have been made aware of your remarkable interest and contributions to community
projects, worldwide issues and scientific research through my partner who is currently a Professor and Director of 
Research at the University of Adelaide, South
Australia.
I have contacted you to submit numerous business concepts / ideas and a scientific
concept / development that I have developed and designed that addresses issues within various geographical locations 
within Australia and across the world, and
of which may
be of interest to you, and, or to be considered for development.
The Youth Housing Project, Port Pine was submitted to the Port Pirie Council who
proceeded to submit the project to the South Australian Housing Commission who then proceeded to submit it to the South 
Australian Government. It was then
reviewed and considered but was rejected for funding and development by the South Australian
Government, but i was not made aware of the reasons behind the project being rejected.
Although this development was designed for the region of Port Pirie to facilitate the
resources available i do feel that there is insufficient resources available Australia and
worldwide within this area of development for the public and feel that the concept can be
used as a model to develop and construct this concept to facilitate the shortage of
affordable housing for the youth who wish to relocate to different locations for
employment or move out of home for various reasons and should be considered.
The Housing Project, Glenside was developed and designed in consideration to the
vacant and abandoned buildings that surrounded the grounds of the hospital and was
submitted to the manager of the hospital in February 2017 for consideration but was
rejected as I was informed that the vacant buildings were allocated to another
development. I am unaware whether the development was submitted for consideration
with any other department, including the South Australian Government, although I have
been made aware that the concept was developed into the form of student housing /
apartments that were developed in other locations after the dated submission of the
project, of which I received no acknowledgment.
I would also like to raise the concern and awareness of which I feel is a worldwide issue
and refers to the viewing material on Porn sites that is projected and marketed to society
in the form of suggestions of committing illegal actions and immoral behavior, for
example, to name a few :
Teachers with students
Family members conducting actions of incest
Animal sex
Older men engaging sexually with young girls and or taking their virginity
Rough / Violent / Abusive sex
Labelling women as sluts
I believe this raises the question of what impact this material may have Psychologically
on the viewer, the public, which could manifest into that viewer conducting themselves in
such behavior and illegal actions.
I also feel that in regards to the legal age of 18 of people who can enter into the sex trade
should be scrutinized and reviewed as being too young. As a teenager, an under
developed mind that does not yet have the experience or knowledge of life experience to
make mature decisions or to be responsible within their actions and are denied the right
to drink or acquire a licence in some countries based upon this evaluation until the age of
21, therefore how can they make or be capable of making this decision as a mature adult.
I do feel that this is an issue within our society and is damaging to the youth, to society
and is placing society in real danger, manifesting in sexual crimes and abuse being
committed and the inexperienced youth being taken advantage of and being introduced
to criminality in the form of alcohol abuse, drug use, violent, intimidating behaviour and
crime figures which lead to Prostitution.
I feel that this issue needs to be urgently raised with governing figures and addressed
seriously to be reformed, restructured which leads to the bill of decriminalizing
Prostitution that opens the door to criminality and criminal figures to operate legally within
this industry, to be denied and rejected to discourage this kind of practice within society
and to protect society and the youth from criminal activity.
I am raising this concern, your awareness and offering my perspective as a concerned
member of the public in the instance that you may have the same perspective and may
be in a position or have influence to bring this issue into awareness within the public or
the correct people and or governing figures which may result in action being taken.
Personal details and the business concepts / developments that have been provided are
of a confidential nature and i would appreciate your confidentiality concerning this
information.
I would appreciate your consideration concerning the developments / concepts and the
information of which i have provided. Thank you.
Kind Regards
Email :
Rccct vet to 9.e--PL'I .
Page 1 of 2
Re: Confidential - Enquiry - Business Concepts - South Australia
Nicole Ross <
Wed 11/09/2019 10:28 AM
To:
Unfortunately this doesn't fit within the scope of my program. Best of luck!
Best,
Nicole
On Tue, 10 Sep 2019 at 04:27,
wrote:
Dear Nicole Ross,
I am writing to attract your attention on a number of business concepts that i have
prepared during the past years, for which i am seeking support, either financially or
logistically, or both. All of these aim to address issues of our modern society and
support disadvantaged communities as well as advancing other areas, including medical
science and research.
Over the past decades, i have resided in numerous small communities of South
Australia and various city locations within Australia. During that time, i have submitted
various suggestions of infrastructure changes and new ideas to make improvements to
the districts community facilities and established infrastructures.
In several instances, these suggestions have received positive feedback and, where
possible, were implemented within the relevant district councils and development
boards. However, several have not been submitted or received the attention they
deserve and therefore remain open to development and implementation.
I am well aware of your remarkable interest and contributions to community projects,
worldwide issues and scientific research and therefore upon your interest i am able to
submit four concepts for your consideration, which have been constructed into
executive summaries, taking advantage of my qualifications and expertise in the field of
Small Business Management and Business Administration, hoping that they will be of
interest to you and your foundation to the extent that you would consider them for
development in Australia and/or other countries.
The projects include: a Youth Housing Project ; a Food Waste Management Project ; a
Decontamination Project to prevent microbial infections; and a Targeted Human Cell
Administration Project with the objective of directly targeting cancer cell masses within
the body, with the potential of advancement to address other medical issues.
As the proposed projects are of a Confidential nature, i will request your confidentiality
on the concepts and information provided if considered for your review and upon
submitting.
https://outlook.live.com/mail/0/sentitems/id/AQQkADAwATNiZmYAZCljM2U5LT... 12/02/2020
Page 2 of 2
I would appreciate your feedback on these different projects and remain available to
provide any further details as needed.
I thank you in advance for your consideration and look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely and respectfully
Nicole Ross
EA Grants Evaluator, Centre for Effective Altruism
centreforeffectivealtruism.orq I 2054 University Ave. #300, Berkeley, CA I
The Centre for Effective Altruism is a registered 501(c)(3) Exempt Organization in the
USA
https://outlooklive.com/mail/0/sentitems/id/AQQkADAwATNiZmYAZCUM2USLT... 12/02/2020
t C. FL) N)C>t - MeDEC RODINIP C4C/UERNIAE.-E\n"
CS1 -FBLISHWIEMT Or "IC- I iVt.00PIT ‘Ot%, ,. •!)
25th March 2020
MADEC - KADINA BRANCH
FUNDING - WEBSITE DESIGN - SHINETECH
As discussed and requested I have included the following for your review:

• Executive summary
• 1st year projection spreadsheet / income generated
• NDA
• Costings / overheads
• Hourly income / hours

• Financial Quote / website development
As informed with a meeting with Alison I have been offered a 3 month free trial of Shinetech
services for the website development with the intention to continue if satisfied to enter into a
contract of continual services with this company, which was offered for a short term contract in
the beginning stages of 1 month after the completion of the 3 month trial.
The website design development has been quoted as $50,000 for the website and an additional
$20,000 for the mobile app, which is connected to the website for convenience to the customer to
access the website from any location.
I am in negotiations with Shinetech on a developmental and monetary basis to develop the
website and launch it with the view to be continued after the 3 month free trial period.
I am negotiating terms of payment required for the development which include :

• Initial start up date - May 2020
• 1 month free trial period for customers - visitors to the website

• 2 months of membership payments from customers which will generate income
• 2 months membership payments to be collected and used as an initial lump sum payment
to Shinetech after the free trial period towards the costings of the website development

• On going payment plan with Shinetech for the website development
FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS - SHINETECH - UNDER DISCUSSION AND NEGOTIATIONS
I am currently in discussions of further developments with Shinetech which include the
development of 2 commercial products with a view to a worldwide market of sales and mass
production, which Shinetech have expressed their interest in investing in these developments.
As costings / quotes for the product development are still being negotiated I do not have this
information and can not supply it at this point in time. I do intent to financially invest in these
further developments using the surplus of income generated from the launch of the website.
I have included the following for your review:

• 1st Year projection spreadsheet - Development 1
• Executive summary - Development 1
• Executive summary - Development 2

• NDA
I would like to apply for maximum funding that can be provided as supnnrt for the website
development which is the first development of my registered business'   with a
view to further develop the business to it's full potential and aid the further developments in
discussion with Shinetech.
The business  a business that is under construction and incorporates
numerous business concepts, commercial products and medical and scientific research projects,
which I am currently researching universities in Australia and China to develop the projects to
their completion.
I am currently researching the interest of investors to invest in my business as a financial means
to develop the business to completion and reach its full potential.
I appreciate your time and consideration regarding this matter and application.
Kind Regards
DEVELOPMENT PROJECTION REPORT - FUNDING APPLICATION
STAGE 1
Website design - PENPALS - Initial Funding Application - Worldwide
Shinetech, China
• Development quoted - Website design and development - $50,000
• Additional features / projections - Mobile app connected to the website - Quoted - $20,000
Development Stages :

1. First stage will start from a small workshop which lasts days or two weeks at most. In the workshop we will discuss 
and define the vision and business
target, release plan, major functions and priorities and evaluate and choose the most suitable technologies to use. In 
this period we also make interactive
diagram (wireframe), sitemap, flow charts, discuss the UI / UX strategy (style, colour, fonts, ect). At the end of the 
workshop we will be able to develop a
successful footpath for the whole project. The main delivery of the workshop consists of wireframes, decisions specified
and technology stacks ect.

2. Stage 2 will mainly design the UI /UX of the product in details. Define the VI strategy and how the main functions 
are designed and how users use the system.
The main outputs of the stage will be UI / UX assets in PSD or Al format.

3. Stage 3 will be the main development. The output of the stage will be the executable application and is ready for 
customers to use.
Free Trial
Free trial to our potential clients who have long term development requirements to contract our developer(s) under full 
time and ongoing Time & Material
contract for 3 + months, and please be kindly noted that the free trial is not applicable to short term and one off 
software development requirements. The free
trial is usually scoped for less that one man week (40 hours), you are welcome to test our developer with a measurable 
piece of work without ay commitment of
the contract and cost, through which you can see whether the recommended developer is qualified for your requirements, 
both technical competency and cooperation
process' smoothness like communication initiatives, thinking styles, work process, agile minded, sense of being 
proactive, ect. If the free trial isn't
satisfying we can just leave it there or we can find out other candidates for you upon your request. And if the free 
trial proves good and you are satisfied
with it we hope you have the plan to contract the proven developer right after the free trial is completed. And we may 
start our official cooperation from a
short term contract like one month until you build enough confidence with us and are comfortable to commit to longer 
term contract with Shinetech.
STAGE 2
Computerized Shop Assistant - Vehicle Locator - Further Developments - Worldwide Shinetech, China
Development Stages:

1. From below information I mainly understood what you want. Also we have long-term cooperation manufacturer located in 
Shenzhen who can help for mass
production of the products. To move forward I think first stage should be to design the products.
The design of the products have been submitted to Shinetech which resulted in further discussions via Skype services in 
which they expressed their interest in
investing in these products.
2. Ok, I will check more with that. Also I need a lot of internal discussions. Please be patient. I am still waiting to 
obtain further information regarding the
development and productivity of these products once the company have discussed the project internally in full.
STAGE 3
Scientific and Medical Research Projects - Further Developments - Worldwide
Peking University / Beijing University - Arts, Science, Law, Medicine, Engineering, Agriculture
Pure and applied research - Department of Biomedical Engineering

• Decontamination Project
• Mental Health Hormonal Imbalance Disorder project
• Targeted Cell Administration project

• Seaweed Discovery project
All project development fundamentals have been completed and I have conducted research for
suitable university's which will meet the criteria of developing the projects to successful
completion. I am currently in the process of contacting the desired university, Peking University in
regards to the development of these projects and developments and the preferred candidate to
lead these projects has been assessed.
• Tu Youyou - Pharmaceutical Chemist and Educator
2011 Lasker Award - Clinical Medicine
2015 Noble Prize - Physiology or Medicine
2016 State Preeminent Science and Technology Award
STAGE 4
Business Developments - Further Developments - Worldwide
Cupids Café / Connected website - Travel Mate / Connected website - Drive Thru Coffee Hut -
Snack Shack
Shinetech - Website Development
Website Development Stages:
1.First stage will start from a small workshop which lasts around 2 weeks. In the workshop we will
discuss and define the vision and business target, release plan, major functions and priorities and
evaluate and choose the most suitable technologies to use. In this period we also make
interactive diagram (wireframe), sitemap, flow charts, discuss the UI / UX strategy (style, colour,
fonts ect ). At the end of the workshop we will be able to develop a successful footpath for the
whole product. The main delivery of the workshop consists of wireframes, decisions specified and
technology stacks, estimated work amount and cost for the subsequent stages, ect.

2. Stage 2 will mainly design the UI / UX of the product details. Define the VI strategy and how the
main functions are designed and how the user will use the system. The main outputs of the stage
will be UI / UX assets in PSD or Al format.
3. Stage 3 will be the main development. The output of the stage will be the executable
application and is ready for customers to use.
The cost for the two weeks shall be US$3,200 - AUD$5,246.75.
All fundamentals of the projects have been completed. The costings of these developments has
not yet been determined and more information needs to be obtained and continued research into
these areas will be conducted to develop these projects to establishment and completion.
STAGE 5
Government Developments - Further Developments - Worldwide
Youth Housing Project - Food Wastage Project
The fundamentals of these projects have been completed. Govemment involvement and funding
is necessary for each project and is subject to the terms and funding of the govemment in
governance at the time of development and will require contact with the goveming government
and discussions regarding the future progress and required funding of the projects.
7/13/2020 Mail - - Outlook
Confidential - MADEC Funding Application -JC INNOVATIONS - 6 Attachments
Thu 2/04/2020 1'S1 PM
To: >
>
6 attachments (28 MB)
Confidential - MADEC -Cover letter -Stages of Development -4pgs pdf.pdt Confidential - Website - Exec summary -
Development - Profit & Loss - 1st Year Projection - NDA • 10pgs pdf.pdt Confidential -MADEC -Stage 2 -Exec summary's -
!st Year Projection -NDA • Development -13pgs pdf.pdf; Confidential -MADEC - Stage 3 -Connected website development
-1pg.pdt Confidential - MADEC -Stage 4 - Scientific and Medical Research Projects -University Enquiries - 3pgs pdf.pdt
Confidential -MADEC -Investors -Cover Letters -3pgs pdf.pdt
Dear Alison,
As discussed and requested, phone interview 10am 2/4/2020, I have attached the required
documents for your review regarding the funding application for stage 1, the website development.
All fundamentals and explanations are described in the documents, including 1st Year projections
and Profit and Loss Projections and development.
Documents attached consist of:
Cover letter, Stages of Development -4pgs
Website -Exec summary - Development -Profit & Loss Projection -1st Year Projection -NDA -10pgs
Stage 2 -Exec summary's -1st Year Projection -NDA -Development - 13 pgs
Stage 3 -Connected website development - 1pg
Stage 4 -Scientific and Medical Research Projects -University enquiries -3 pgs
Investors -Cover letters -3 pgs
If you require any more information please don't hesitate to contact me.
lo.....1InsrtinrJe than reimirritatinagAkAnAWATNiZMYAZe I 
iM2U5InhNVIA4MDACLTAWC9AUAAADXV0lyWICA0la0W4C01106CIAEAX0EM2F... 1
Page I of 1
Research Project
Alison Brougham
Thu 12/03/2020 11:28 AM
To:
Cc:
Good morning Rachel,
I am seeking an appointment for to discuss a research project and the possibility of
University of Adelaide involvement. was advised that you may be the person to meet with
to discuss this opportunity.
is the Director of which is a niche business — it is a combination of numerous
businesses, websites, research projects and commercial products. is seeking your possible
involvement in order to develop the research project through to establishment of the projects
themselves.
direct contact details are and has also been cc'd into the email.
Kind regards
Alison
Alison Brougham
Manager - DES DMS
MADEC Australia
13 Taylor Street, Kadina, SA, S554
W www.matleriedu
https://outl ook. I ive.com/mail/0/i nbox/i d/AQQkA DAwATN iZmYAZC 1 jM2U5LTZh... 31/03/2020
Page 1.of 1
Research Project
Alison Brougham <
Thu 19/03/2020 10 31 AM
To:
Cc:
Good morning Jodie Ann,
>
I am seeking an appointment for to discuss a research project and the possibility of
Hinders University's involvement. was advised that you may be the person to meet with to
discuss this opportunity.
is the Director of which is a niche business — it is a combination of numerous
businesses, websites, researc prof s an commercial products. is seeking your possible
involvement in order to develop the research project through to establishment of the projects
themselves.
direct contact details are
Kind regards
Alison
Alison Brougham
Manager - DES DMS
MADEC Australia
13 Taylor Street, Kadina, SA, 5554
W yvww madec edu.au
and has also been cc'd into the email.
Recruitment solutions.
htms://outlook.live.com/mail/0/inbox/icUAQQkADAwATNiZmYAZC 1 jM2U5LTZh... 31/03/2020
<Ct., Citf<i AN7 FLA t71 ltrNtCj> ef\iiiR'Y Page I of)
Re: Referral for NES - - initial discussion request
T .1 .. 2 1. i.. 4 s44  Ph(
To: Diane Minnis < : Brougham'
Cc:
I 7 attachments (28 M8)
Confidential - MADEC -Cover letter -Stages of Development -4pgs pdt.pdt Confidential - MADEC -Stage 4 - Scientific and 
Medical
Research Projects -University Enquiries - 3pgs pdfpdf, Confidential - Website - Exec summary - Development - Profit & 
Loss - 1st
Year Projection - NDA - 10pgs pdf.pdt Confidential -MADEC - Stage 3 -Connected website development -1pgprff; 
Confidential
-MADEC -Investors -Cover Letters -3pgs pdtpdf: Confidential -MADEC -Stage 2 -Exec wmmays - 1st Year Projection -NEM •
Development -13pgs isrlf.pdf; CONFIDENTIAL -1C INNOVATIONS -Social Meda Chikkens Security Program pdtpdt
Dear Diane,
Thank you for your quick response to the referral by Allison Brougham, Madec, Kadina.
I have attached the MADEC funding application documents, 7 attachments, that i have sent to Allison
currently in regards to the busines.nt is currently under development and for your
review and knowledge so that we are able to talk more in depth about the development when we make an
appointment time to do so.
I am currently at the stage of seeking investors to fund the developments and have made the following
enquiry's and letters of funding opportunity in order to attract their interest via email and postal letters:
Gai Waterhouse
Ann Churchill Brown, RE: Nicole Kidman Foundation -Shanahan Management
Bill Gates
Andrew Forrest
I am also in the process of applying on ANGEL INVESTMENT SITE to seek investors for funding and also have
an appointment with Insurance Advisernet, Stella Monteleone for required insurance needs and obtaining
an insurance quote for the first stage of development, the Social Media Website.
The company Shinetech, China, i am currently in collaborations with regarding the technical development
of the websites, security program and commercial products and are also helping me to send letters to the
required university's in China for the Medical and Scientific Research projects. This company has shown
interest in investing in two of the commercial products, Vehicle locator and Computerized Shop assistant
but do not have any other investment or interest in the company as far as partnership, control or direction.
as owned and controlled directly 100% by myself as the director and owner of the
company, unless negotiated further in detail and negotiated terms with any investor at this stage.
I would like to allow you to review the documents of the business firstly over what time is considerate for
you, but i will be available to talk more in depth next week if this is convenient for you.
Kind Regards
From: Diane Minnis <
Sent:Thursday, 9 April 2020 12:40 PM
To: 'Alison Bro ham' <
Cc:
Subject RE: Referral for NEIS
Hi Alison &
- initial discussion request
it certainly seems that you would be eligible and benefit from the program. I can ask our trainer to give you a call if
you like to see what stages you are currently at, and where we would be able to start your process of opening for
business.
https://outlook.live.com/mail/O/sentitems/id/AQQkADAwATNiZmYAZCIjM2U5LTZ... 9/04/2020
Page 2 of 3
In the meantime, are you able to tell me a bit about your business? What level of funding are you looking for? How
much of the business have you developed? What influence will the Chinese company have on your business, i.e. will
they be a partner or be able to control your direction? (As a NEIS business, you must maintain control of your
business with at least 51% ownership).
when you can respond to this, we can have further discussions
Thanks, Di
Diane Minnis
NEIS Program Manager
IA BRACE Education 8. Training 6 Todd Street Port Adelaide SA 5015
✓ skillsolus corn au
gSkillsPlus & BRACE
From: Alison Brougham
Sent: Thursday, 9 A ril 2020 11:17 AM
To: Diane Minnis <
Cc:
Subject: Referral for NEIS - - initial discussion request
External Email
Good morning Dianne,
I have been supporting one of our DES Jobseekers who is seeking investors to fund the
development of her business. She has business training already and is really looking for mentorship and support with
funding — advocacy—to get her business idea off the ground. She has the business plan and stages all lined up and
has already had numerous discussions with a Chinese company who are very interested in her business
idea/products.
I believe she may find the NEIS program valuable. Can you please make contact with either tomorrow or
next week for an initial chat to see if the NEIS program can be of benefit to her?
number island I have ced
Kind regards
Alison
Alison Brougham
Manager - DES DMS
MADEC Australia
It T.Iv:or Strret, Kadina, SA, 55S4
W www.madesttchuou
into the email as well so you have her email address.
huos://outlook.live.com/mail/O/setuitems/id/AQQkADAwATNiZmYAZC IjM2U5LTZ... 9/04/2020
Page 3 of 3
Recruitment solutions.
4,74
madec
Disclaimer
This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for If you are not the
named addressee you should not disseminate, distribute. copy or alter this email. Any views or opinions presented in 
this email are solely those of
the author and might not represent those of BRACE Education Training 8 Employment Ltd. Warning. Although BRACE Education
Training
Employment Ltd has taken reasonable precautions to ensure no viruses are present in this email, the company cannot 
accept responsibility for any
loss or damage siting from the use of this email or attachments.
BRACE Education Training 8 Employment Ltd respects your privacy. All personal information we hold about you is kept 
confidential, according to
Australian privacy law. For more information about BRACE Education Training 8 Employment Ltd and privacy, visit our 
website.
https://outlook.live.com/maillO/sentitems/id/AQQkADAwATNiZmYAZCIjM2U5LTZ... 9/04/2020
IIII
II liii III 1(11111111
I III I!
Commonwealth Bank Commonwealth Bank of Australia
ABN 48 123 123 124
31 August 2020
Ms
f3t-Jvt t\BD,w i
6MeLoveD - NO L.-WING
EveeNsec. rrt-i
ricgemrs 1.30,0co (O ASSES-FS.
naFcAtmet) RE_As.otv - 10(.04,4 e
Application numbe
Dear
Thanks for applying for a CommBank credit card.
What you need to know
We've carefully reviewed all the information you've given us but are unable to offer you this credit
card.
We take responsible lending seriously. Unfortunately, your application does not meet our current
lending criteria
If your circumstances change you may wish to apply again. We will assess your next application
based on the information you provide us at that time and our current lending criteria.
We're here to help
If you've got a question, or need more information, call us on 13 2221. You can also drop into
your nearest branch where one of our team will help you.
Yours sincerely,
Commonwealth Bank
The credi provider is Commonseatth Bank of Australia A9N 48 123 123 124 Australian credit fmfrIce 234945
z
ZZ1751102
CH NC S101.O244.L
D900 V03.02.04
Pane 1 of 1
Ficreiztf%)c , )es
e.sTriout51 -fricNi
a
■
F 001914
cr, verrmENTy s
- SotAce:
LUSTS
- DENIED CST Ree,Frve
OF For4tmtJc4
Australian Government
Australian Taxation Office
Our reference: 7118853937560
Phone: 13 28 66
ABN: 77 663 471 614
_s)r 20 October 2020
We have changed your activity statement details -
I> Reporting period: 01/07/2020 to 30/09/2020
> Document identificati_on number:
Dear EMIL Thank you for lodging your activity statement. We have made some
changes to what you reported.
Outcome of change
The total amount of your activity statement is $0.
You will be refunded any amount to which you are entitled to your
nominated bank account To avoid any delays ensure your details are up to
date by using our online services at ato.gov.au/onlineservices
Lir tax online
The easiest way to check your account balance and lodge or revise your
activity statements is by using our online services. You can find out more
on our website at ato.gov.eu/onlineservices
Yours sincerely,
Grant Brodie
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation
NEED HELP?
Visit us at
etagov.eu/contecitue
Or
Contact upon 1328 Cle
between &Won and 51l0pm,
Monday to Friday.
If you need help in languages
other than English, you can
phone our translating and
Interpreting service on 13 14 50.
E01914-S00001-F392257 Page 1 of 2 75144.501340-05-2019
EFTA00805860 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Joi Ito's Neoteny 3 fund investor update / portfolio
(inferred date: 2026-01-06)
Neoteny 3, LP - Fund Partnership
Neoteny 3 Management, LLC - General Partner
coton/q3 Investor Update
October 23, 2017
do Neoteny 3 Management, LLC
do Prague & Company, P.C.
15 Walnut Street, Suite 150
Wellesley, MA 02481 USA
Phone: +1 (781) 237-5555, ext. 202
Fax: +1 f 78 U 237-7779
E-mail 1:
E-mail 2:
www.neoteny.com
nitotcnici3
CONTENTS
Investment Report: October 23. 2017
INVESTOR UPDATE 4
Affinity Hive. Inc. 6
AOBiome LLC 7
ASAPP, Inc.   8
Blackstorm Labs Inc 9
Bonfire Studios, Inc  10
Brave Software, Inc  11
Caffeine Inc.  12
Crowd Supply. Inc  13
Dubset Media Holdings. Inc.   14
Emerald Cloud Lab  15
gur8, Inc.   16
Formlabs Inc  17
Grasscrown, Inc  18
HE DIY. PBC  19
IdeaFlow, Inc 20
InteraXon Inc 21
Kemoko, Inc. 22
Kiang Games GmbH 23
Knit Health, Inc.  24
Leade.rs. Inc. 25
Lumii, Inc. 26
Luminoso Technologies, Inc. 27
Move38, Inc.  28
Nuna Incorporated 29
OH2 Laboratories, LLC 30
Optimus Ride Inc.   31
Neoteny 3. LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 2

╭───────────────────── Page 2, Image 1 ─────────────────────╮
│ D Ny lime) au Ny Y Ki Investment Report: October 23, 2017 │
│                                                           │
│ CONTENTS                                                  │
│ INVESTOR UPDATE                                           │
│ Affinity Hive, Ine.                                       │
│ AOBiome LLC                                               │
│ ASAPP, Inc.                                               │
│ Blackstorm Labs Inc.                                      │
│ Bonfire Studios, Inc..                                    │
│ Brave Software, Inc.                                      │
│ Caffeine Inc. 12                                          │
│ Crowd Supply, Inc.                                        │
│ Dubset Media Holdings, Inc sa                             │
│ Emerald Cloud Lab                                         │
│ figur8, Inc 16                                            │
│ Formlabs Inc. 7                                           │
│ Grasscrown, Inc. 18                                       │
│ HE DIY, PBC 19                                            │
│ IdeaFlow, Inc. 20                                         │
│ InteraXon Inc. 21                                         │
│ Kemoko, Inc.                                              │
│ Klang Games GmbH                                          │
│ Knit Health, Inc. 24                                      │
│ Leade.rs, Inc. 25                                         │
│ Lumii, Inc 26                                             │
│ Luminoso Technologies, Inc eT                             │
│ Moves, Inc. 28                                            │
│ ‘Nuna Incorporated. 29                                    │
│ OH2 Laboratories, LLC                                     │
│ Optimus Ride Inc. 31                                      │
│                                                           │
│ Neoteny 3, LP | CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION       │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

1)1tO16t1)1(13 Investment Repon: October 23. 2017
Ori. Inc.   32
Pixel Labs. Inc 33
Sannpa Limited 34
Shuttersong Incorporated 35
Top Flight Technologies, Inc. 36
Tulip Interfaces. Inc. 37
Twine Health. Inc 38
udu. Inc 39
Wait What LLC 40
Wearal it y Corporation 41
Wise Systems Inc. 42
Neoteny 3. LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 3
itytottivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
INVESTOR UPDATE
Dear Partners,
As Neoteny 3, LP (the "Fund") transitions from making investments in new portfolio companies
to solely focusing on supporting and funding its current portfolio companies, I thought it would
be an appropriate time to provide you with a more comprehensive overview of the Fund's current
portfolio.
Enclosed you will find a one page summary for each portfolio company, which includes
information about the Fund's investment in such company as well as a company description and
current highlights from the business.
The Fund reports all financial information on a U.S. tax basis and generally does not provide
valuations with respect to its investments. However, solely for purposes of this investor update,
valuation information, to the extent available, has been provided for your reference. Values have
been reported on the following basis:

• Stock investments are valued based on Internal Revenue Code Section 409A valuations,
most recent funding rounds (subsequent to the Fund's investment), and certain other
methods, as provided by the portfolio companies.
If no valuation information is available or the Fund participated in the most recent
funding round, then the stock investment is held at cost, which is equal to the stock
purchase price, or to the extent a convertible promissory note has converted into stock,
then it is equal to the convertible promissory note principal plus accrued interest.

• Debt investments are valued at cost, which is equal to the convertible promissory note
principal.
• Simple Agreements for Future Equity (SAFEs) are valued at cost, which is equal to the
instrument's purchase price.
• Warrants are valued at nil.
• To the extent portfolio companies have signaled a material downturn in their business
operations and/or the ability to obtain funding, the value of such companies have been
written down to zero under the assumption that the Fund would receive no payout upon
the liquidation of these portfolio companies.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 4
lyto[4ffivq3 Investment Report: October 23, 2017
An Internal Revenue Code Section 409A valuation is generally performed to establish the
exercise price for a company's stock option grants (a form of deferred compensation).
The Fund's investments are illiquid in nature with little, if any, market activity. Considerable
judgment is required to determine the estimates of value. Accordingly, the estimates of value
presented herein are not necessarily indicative of the amounts that the Fund could realize in an
arm's length transaction. The use of different market assumptions and/or estimation
methodologies may have a material effect on the estimated values.
The values of the portfolio companies in the aggregate should not be construed as the value of
the Fund itself. No discount has been taken into account for lack of marketability and/or lack of
control.
Lastly, note that the amount invested for each portfolio company is the sum of the investment
acquisition price, capitalized costs, and to the extent a convertible promissory note has converted
into stock, the accrued interest at the time of conversion.
For those participating in the video online mixer hosted by Affinity Hive, the enclosed
information could prove to be a helpful resource to reference in conjunction with or prior to
watching the videos.
The information provided herein is confidential in nature. Please do not distribute or discuss this
information with others. Please direct any questions or comments on the information provided to
the Fund. Thank you in advance for your cooperation.
Sincerely,
•JoicM ,
as manager of Neoteny 3 Management, LLC,
the General Partner of Neoteny 3, LP
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION
04ffoi6ffnAiz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Affinity Hive, Inc.
2627 Hanover St
Palo Alto, CA 94304
CEO: Cameron Teitelman
Website: https://affinityhive.com
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 8/8/2017 Simple Agreement for
Future Equity (SAFE) $ 250.000.00 $ 250.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 250,000.00 $ 250,000.00
Company Description:
Affinity Hive, Inc. ("Affinity Hive") is creating a way for groups of people with similar
professional interests and goals to meet-up online and build professional relationships and
conduct business.
Company Highlights:

• Affinity Hive ran its 5th online event with an 8x lift in qualified leads generated

vs. comparable offline event with 6x less time spent.

• Affinity Hive will be running the Neoteny 3, LP online meet up between portfolio
companies and investors.

• Affinity Hive is seeking introductions to conference organizers, industry experts,
and introductions to strategic angels who have expertise in online video,
conferences, and professional networks.

• Affinity Hive intends to create a new category of online video workflows for
professional networking and business interactions.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 6
4to[6tniciz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
AOBiome LLC
One Broadway, 14th Floor
Cambridge, MA 02142
CEO: Todd Krueger
Website: https://aobiome.com/
Investment.

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
175.439 3/15/2016
Series C Preferred Stock
(upon conversion of a
promissory note)
S 25,1.890.00 S 498.246.76
Valuation based
on last funding
round raised
Total $ 254,890.00 $ 498,246.76
Company Description:
AOBiome LW ("AOBiome") is dedicated to advancing the science of Ammonia Oxidizing
Bacteria (AOB) on human health. Topical applications of patented and stabilized AOB can
restore the skin's microbiome and potentially impact a wide variety of human health conditions.
Company Highlights:

• In January 2017, AOBiome partnered with iCarbon X, China's largest health data
collection and analysis platform. iCarbon X made a $30 million investment in the
company.

• AOBiome is developing first-in-class biological therapies for the treatment of
both local and systemic inflammatory conditions.

• AOBiome also created "Mother Dirt," a line of consumer biome-friendly products
targeted at restoring and maintaining the delicate balance of the skin biome.
• AOBiome is in the process of completing two Phase 2 clinical trials in Acne and
Hypertension. In addition, the company plans to start additional Phase 2 clinical
trials in Allergic Rhitinitis, Atopic Dermatitis, and Migraine. Based on the
outcome of these Phase 2 clinical trials, the company may advance to Phase 3
clinical trials. That will be dependent on the Phase 2 clinical trials being
successful in certain indications. There is no assurance that the Phase 2 clinical
trials will be successful.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 7
47/ 4to[4oniqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
ASAPP, Inc.
One World Trade Center, Floor 83, Suite N
New York, NY 10006
CEO: Gustavo Sapoznik
Website: https://asapp.co/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
1.038,317 7/23/2015
Series Seed Preferred Stock
(upon conversion of a promissory
note, and post a 7-for-1 stock split)
$ 255.869.60 S 253972.60 Cost Basis
141.773 3/15/2017 Series A Preferred Stock S 201.088.68 S 199999.18 Cost Basis
Total $ 456,958.28 $ 453,971.78
Company Description:
ASAPP, Inc. combines human and machine intelligence to transform communications.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 8
ivoof4tivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Blackstorm Labs Inc.
(f/k/a Game Closure, Inc.)
421 Castro Street
Mountain View, CA 94041
CEO: Michael Carter
Website: http://blackstormlabs.com/ and http://www.gameclosure.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
229.588 9/22/2015 Series A Preferred Stock $ 252.546.67 $ 357.187.05 409A Valuation
Total $ 252,546.67 $ 357,187.05
Company Description.
Blackstorm Labs Inc. ("Blackstorm Labs," f/k/a Game Closure, Inc.) builds open source cutting
edge gaming technology. It created DevKit, an open source tool for game developers to code
more quickly and easily using HTML5 and JavaScript, and has now expanded to other gaming
tools.
Company Highlights:

• Blackstorm Labs is in the business of powering and publishing the next wave of
top game content across all devices and drive higher user yield than any platform
to date at a quicker pace.

• Blackstorm Labs has built and launched a premier games platform, called
EverWing, which is already live on Facebook Messenger delivering Key
Performance Indicators (KPIs) beyond the current top mobile titles, and with no
marketing spend.

• Moving forward, Blackstorm Labs is rapidly expanding into further blue oceans
across over-the-top (OTT) platforms globally with the goal of resetting the mobile
games market.

• Blackstorm Labs has raised $35.0 million through Series B financing to expand
across the globe.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 9
1114to[6oniqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Bonfire Studios, Inc.
27 Needle Grass
Irvine, CA 92603
CEO: Rob Pardo
Website: https:/bonfirestudios.com
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
15.589 4/8/2016
Series A Preferred Stock
(upon conversion of a
promissory note)
$ 51.943A)0 $ 63,313.48 409A Valuation
Total $ 51,943.00 $ 63,313.48
Company Description:
Bonfire Studios, Inc. ("Bonfire Studios") is a video game studio located in California. It is
focused on making deeply engaging online multiplayer games for core gaming audiences.
Company Highlights:

• Bonfire Studios is working on the prototype for its first game.
• Bonfire Studios is redesigning its website to better represent its values and its
current business operations/strategy. A big driver for this change is to strengthen
the company's brand and its ability to recruit top talent.

• Bonfire Studios currently has a team of 12 people, and continues to identify and
hire top talent.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 10
14714to[4oniciz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Brave Software, Inc.
512 Second Street, Floor 2
San Francisco, CA 94107
CEO: Brendan Eich
Website: https://brave.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 6/2912016 Convertible Promissory Note $ 201.57100 $ 200.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 201,572.00 $ 200,000.00
Company Description:
Brave Software, Inc. ("Brave Software") aims to provide a faster, safer, and better internet
experience for its users. Through its open source browser, Brave protects users against harmful
advertising and 3rd party tracking that impacts the speed and experience of internet browsing.
Brave also is working to create an equitable revenue sharing arrangement with content
developers that respects user privacy and safety. It has released its first open-source browser.
Company Highlights:

• Brave Software raised $36 million in an Initial Coin Offering ("ICO"). The ICO
consisted of the sale of Basic Attention Token (BAT) on the Etherum (ETH), and
thus, the value of such coins with fluctuate with the ETH market.

• Brave Software has started to roll out the blockchain digital advertising and
services platform that was outlined in the ICO.

• There have been 2,719,496 downloads of the Brave brower as of September 29,
2017.
• In August 2017, there were 725,850 monthly active users (MAUs). It is expected
that this number will rise to 1 million MAUs in the next couple of months.

• Brave Software is beginning to discuss partnerships / arrangements with major
publishers, who, for instance, would receive BAT in exchange for providing free
premium content to their readers through the Brave browser. The publishers
would get a new subscriber and the company would get a very cost effective
MAU. Media companies are also interested.

• Brave Software is also pursuing relationship with smaller content producers with
fanatical followings (e.g. YouTubers, Twitch, or independent sites).
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 11
to[ 4ffivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Caffeine Inc.
Address not available
CEO: Benjamin W. Keighran
Website: Not applicable
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
4.976 5/20/2016 Series A Preferred Stock $ 10.670.28 $ 9.999.28 Cost Basis
Total $ 10,670.28 $ 9,999.28
Company Description:
Caffeine Inc. ("Caffeine") is a consumer live video streaming company that targets video
gaming.
Company Highlights:
Caffeine is still in the process of raising money from investors. The company is expected to be
formally announced later this year.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 12
elyto[4ffniciz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Crowd Supply, Inc.
340 SE 6th Ave
Portland, OR 97214
CEO: Josh Lifton
Website: https://www.crowdsupply.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
492,805 4/22/2015 Series Seed II Preferred Stock $ 101.341.35 $ 100000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 101,341.35 $ 100,000.00
Company Description:
Crowd Supply, Inc. ("Crowd Supply") is a crowd funding platform focused on new product
development projects. The platform supports campaigns, pre-orders (once a campaign has been
successfully funded) and e-commerce sales of completed, fully manufactured products.
Company Highlights:

• There has been a 88% year-over-year sales growth in Q1 2017 and the company
expects to be profitable by the end of 2017.

• Crowd Supply has struck a partnership deal with Digi-Key Electronics, one of the
largest and best-known electronic components suppliers in the world.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 13
47,4to[6ffniqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Dubset Media Holdings, Inc.
158 W 23rd Street, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10011
CEO: Stephen White
Website: http://www.dubset.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
2,433.090 1/10/2017 Series A Preferred Stock $ 104.128O0 $ 100.000.00 Cost Basis
217,859 8P_5/2017 Series A Preferred Stock $ 9.065.00 $ 8.954.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 113,193.00 $ 108,954.00
Company Description:
Dubset Media Holdings, Inc. ("Dubset") offers an innovative music marketplace for DJs, artists,
labels, publishers, and distributors. Through cutting edge technology, rights management
database, and easy to use dashboards, Dubset is creating new mix and remix distribution and
monetization opportunities built on transparency, ownership, control, and simplicity.
Company Highlights:

• Dubset created MixBANK, a platform designed to facilitate the marketplace
between DJs, rights holders, and music services. Through the company's pre-
negotiated licenses and groundbreaking technology, DJs, labels, publishers, and
music services can create and earn together, in one comprehensive platform.

• Dubset also created MixSCAN, a proprietary technology that resolves rights
challenges currently associated with mixed and remixed content, setting new
industry standards for both music and rights holder identification.

• In August 2017, Dubset announced its partnership with Sony Music (1st major
label). Sony signed on to use MixBank and other company technologies.

• In September 2017, Dubset delivered its first long form mixes to Apple.
• In August 2017, Dubset had a $1.2M Series A Extension, which resulted in a
$15.2M post money valuation of the company. It is targeting a Series B round in
Q1 2018.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 14
givto[6ffivq3 Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Emerald Cloud Lab
(f/k/a Emerald Therapeutics, Inc.)
844 Dubuque Ave
South San Francisco, CA 94080
CEO: DJ Kleinbaum
Website: https://emeraldcloudlab.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
103.664 6/19f2015 Series C Preferred Stock
(post a 4-for-1 stock split) $ 102.032.52 $ 81,108.93 409A Valuation
Total $ 102,032.52 $ 81,108.93
Company Description:
Emerald Cloud Lab (f/k/a Emerald Therapeutics, Inc.) comes from Emerald Therapeutics, a
venture-backed biotechnology company based in San Francisco, California. It is a web-based life
sciences lab, developed by scientists for scientists. Emerald Cloud Lab conducts lab experiments
designed by customers, collects the data, and organizes it into a database that its customers can
access remotely.
Company Highlights:

• Emerald Cloud Lab is working towards supporting every standard experiment
type available in the life sciences. The company is not limited to standard life
sciences experiments, but also partners with innovative labs in industry and
academia to commercialize novel protocols and essays.

• Currently, Emerald Cloud Lab allows customers to execute over 40 different
types of standard lab experiments remotely in its central facility. The lab program
guides partners through the process of on-boarding and gives them a dedicated
team to work with at the lab. The goal is for partners to bring their experiments
online and then be able to remotely access them through the lab's interface.

• Emerald Cloud Lab charges partners by experiment on a per sample basis with no
minimum transaction size.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 15
111 lytof4tivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
figur8, Inc.
2 Park Plaza, Suite 605
Boston, MA 02116
CEO: Nan-wei Gong
Website: https://www.figur8.me/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 11912O17 Simple Agreement for
Future Equity (SAFE) $ 126.430.00 $ 125.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 126,430.00 $ 125,000.00
Company Description:
Figur8, Inc. ("figur8") is a dynamic form tracking technology that measures 3D body shape and
muscle symmetry. Their patent pending technology allows them to produce low-cost, wireless-
enabled garments for a variety of applications including sizing measurements for e-commerce
fashion retailers, and elastic adhesive tape for location-specific, on-body activity tracking in
sports and fitness.
Company Highlights:

• Figur8 is creating a sport science focused wearable system for movement, muscle
and performance tracking. Its first go-to-market is sports, with a focus on
functional/activity assessment and training. This can then be translated to
movement learning and rehab for digital health and physical therapy.

• Figur8's main two market segments are: 1) sports and fitness, and 2) physical
therapy and rehabilitation.

• Figur8 has clinical trials at Mass General Hospital (MGH) regarding ACL injury
tracking and rehabilitation.

• Figur8 has started a pilot program with NFL teams and European soccer teams on
sport performance enhancement and tracking.

• Figur8's goal in its first year is to sign partnerships with 5 paying elite
professional teams.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 16
tol'oniq3 Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Formlabs Inc.
35 Medford St #201
Somerville, MA 02143
CEO: Maxim Lobovsky
Website: https://forrnlabs.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
17,045 7/22/2016 Series B Preferred Stock $ 251,761.54 $ 204.880.90
Income and
Market
Approach
Total $ 251,761.54 $ 204,880.90
Company Description:
Formlabs Inc. ("Formlabs") designs and manufactures 3D printing systems for engineers,
designers, and artists. Its current products include the Form 1+ and Form 2 3D printers.
Company Highlights:

• Formlabs has grown to a size of approximately 270 employees, with offices
recently opening up in Berlin.

• Formlabs' customer base is mainly professionals, with some hobbyists showing an
interest as well.
• There are now about 25,000 Formlabs printers out in the world.

• Formlabs' 3D printers were originally developed with prototyping in mind, but
have since shifted to manufacturing.
• 2017 is on track to double sales vs. 2016. Q2 2017 was Formlabs' >$20M quarter.
• Formlabs has had a number of new product introductions, with the launches of
Form Wash & Form Cure, Form Cell, and the Fuse 1, along with 6 new and
reformulated materials.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 17
4ffo[4ffivq3 htvestment Report: October 23, 2017
Grasscrown, Inc.
1 Little West 12th Street
New York, NY 10014
CEO: Frederick Blackford
Website: http://www.grasscrown.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 12/1/2015 Convenible Promissory Note $ 150.760.50 $ - Liquidation
Total $ 150,760.50 $ -
Company Description:
Grasscrown, Inc. ("Grasscrown") was founded in 2014 by Frederick Blackford and Tommy
Stadlen to make Polaroid an iconic technology and cultural leader again by building new
technology products. Grasscrown's debut product, Polaroid Swing, is an iOS mobile application
which gives users a new visual medium of expression and a way to share and explore it.
Company Highlights:
Grasscrown was unable to secure a Series A financing round or a bridge round from existing
investors. It is currently working on securing an exit and are in talks with a number of acquirers.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 18
lyzo[4oniciz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
HF DIY, PBC
300 Lefferts Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11225
CEO: Emile Westergaard
Website: https://www.hfdiypbc.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
4/4/2017 Convertible Promissory Note $ 252.951.50 $ 250.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 252,951.50 $ 250,000.00
Company Description:
HF DIY, PBC ("HF DIY") makes fundamental investing fun and social through a gamified
interactive platform where users can learn, test their skills, share content, and invest. The
company provides equity valuation tools and other analyses to help users develop their own
investment view of any publicly traded stock. The company neither sells securities nor allows
direct trading on its platform. Instead, it intends to partner with broker-dealers to facilitate these
transactions.
Company Highlights:

• HF DIY completed VI design and development on its investment app
GreenChiTM. It is initiating live app user testing and is expecting to do a product
beta launch before the end of the year.

• HF DIY is hying to develop GreenChiTM branding and marketing strategy around
a new approach to fundamental equity investing.

• HF DIY is attempting to create a simple yet meaningful User Interface / User
Experience (UI/UX) for its fundamental investing and portfolio management
tools. Some user testing has already been performed.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 19
414to[6t,wiz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
IdeaFlow, Inc.
2600 El Camino Real Ste 415
Palo Alto, CA 94306
CEO: Jacob Cole
Website: https://ideaflow.io/ or https://ideapad.io/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 8/17/2015 Convertible Promissory Note $ 100.344O0 $ 100.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 100,344.00 $ 100,000.00
Company Description:
IdeaFlow, Inc. ("IdeaFlow") builds web-based software for teams to collaboratively create and
analyze networks of information, supported by artificial intelligence that suggests additional
relevant connections. It has commercialized a tool for financial services firms and hopes to
broaden its scope by developing tools that unite personal information management,
collaboration, and web search.
Company Highlights:

• IdeaFlow has a private beta of its software deployed with early enterprise
customers. The beta users include Silicon Valley Bank, Raptor Capital, Charter
Partners Insurance, and Remedy Medical. It is hoping to get the product in the
hands of additional customers within the next 2-3 months.

• IdeaFlow has been working to improve the performance and loading time, and
implement common sense features that are needed for enterprise use at scale, such
as privacy.

• IdeaFlow currently has a team of 4 full time employees and 3 part time
employees, and is looking to hire 1-2 more full time web engineers.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 20
iyto[4ffivq3 Investment Report: October 23, 2017
InteraXon Inc.
511 King St West, Suite 303
Toronto, Ontario ON M5V
Canada
CEO: Derek Luke
Website: http://www.choosemuse.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
54.789 8/25/2015 Series B Preferred Stock $ 110364.73 $ 100.000.88 Cost Basis
Total $ 110,364.73 $ 100,000.88
Company Description:
InteraXon Inc. ("InteraXon") develops brain-sensing technologies, including Muse, the brain
sensing headband. Muse is the first tool in the world that gives wearers accurate, real-time
feedback on what is happening in their brains when meditating in order to improve their
meditation practice.
Company Highlights:

• Revenues are on track to double in 2017, and running the year cash flow neutral.
• InteraXon signed its first licensing agreement with Safilo Group, and is expecting
to launch its Safilo/Smith bio-sensor enabled glasses to hit the market in a few
months. The glasses look like a regular pair of glasses, but are filled with brain
sensors, altimeter, gyroscope, along with other technology.

• InteraXon is also launching its first SaaS Product aimed at clinicians called Muse
Connect, which would be a strong recurring revenue source. There are currently
1,000+ users on the free beta dashboard of Muse Connect. InteraXon is targeting
400+ subscribers within 2017.

• InteraXon signed a term sheet for its next fundraising round with a target close of
October 21, 2017.

• Going forward, InteraXon is aiming to have recurring and licensing revenue
streams in 2018, accelerate 3rd party developer eco-system, and sign a VR
licensing partnership.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 21
o[4ffivq3 Investment Report October 23, 2017
Kemoko, Inc.
211 N 5th St, Suite PH
Brooklyn, NY 11211
CEO: Fraser Kelton
Website: https://itskoko.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
128.568 2/20/2015 Series Seed Preferred Stock $ 100.000.00 $ 162.896.22 Market
Approach
27.546 7/27/2016 Series A Preferred Stock $ 51.611.37 Included Above
Total $ 151,611.37 $ 162,896.22
Company Description:
Kemoko, Inc. ("Kemoko") is the company behind the mobile app Kokobot. Kokobot was
designed to provide peer-to-peer mental health support through a social network that actually
helps you feel better.
Company Highlights:

• Kemoko's mission is to bring emotional well-being to everyone.
• Kemoko has launched KokoBot on a number of social networks, to help social
networks manage crisis, abuse, and bullying.

• Kokobot has now helped more than 1,500,000 people across 160 countries.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 22
Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Kiang Games GmbH
OranienstraBe 164
Berlin, Germany 10969
CEO: Mundi Vondi
Website: http://www.klang-games.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 12/12/2016 Convertible Loan $ 252.909.00 $ 250.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 252,909.00 $ 250,000.00
Company Description:
Kiang Games GmbH is an independent game development studio based in Berlin, Germany.
Company Highlights:

• Kiang Games GmbH is currently building a massive multiplayer game called
Seed. In the game, the user controls several characters living in an upstart
community as part of an effort to populate a new planet in a new solar system.
Unlike conventional online games, Seed will keep running with all of its denizens
24/7, whether you're actively playing or not. It is a very ambitious game that
requires over $12M to create.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 23
111 4to[4tivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Knit Health, Inc.
663 Joost Ave
San Francisco, CA 94127
CEO: David Janssens
Website: https://www.knithealth.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
478,214 9/212016 Series Seed Preferred Stock
(upon conversion of a promissory note) $ 203.954.99 $ 215,062.83 409A Valuation
84.422 9/2/2016 Shares of Common Stock
(upon conversion of a promissory note) Included Above Included Above
587.958 6/8/2017 Series Seed Preferred Stock $ 251.331.75 $ 249.882.15 409A Valuation
Total $ 455,286.74 $ 464,944.98
Company Description:
Knit Health, Inc. ("Knit Health") is a design and technology company that is building a smart
learning platform to help parents better understand and take action on their child's health and
development. The company's initial focus is on sleep.
Company Highlights:

• Knit Health has shifted focus to sleep services for families.
• Knit Health's Series Seed round final close was $2M.

• After completing an friends and family beta test, Knit Health quietly launched its
new service, a 21 day sleep assessment for families wondering how well their
child is sleeping.

• Knit Health also is in the process of developing and testing high-touch sleep
services including personalized sleep recommendations, expert reviews, and sleep
guides. Its goal is to personalize sleep insights for each individual.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 24
04t016t1)1(f3 Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Leade.rs, Inc.
38 Dolores St Unit 807
San Francisco, CA 94103
CEO: Loic Le Meur
Website: https://leade.rs/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
247.862 3110P..016 Series Seed Preferred Stock $ 2(X).670.85 $ 199.999.85 Cost Basis
Total $ 200,670.85 $ 199,999.85
Company Description:
Leade.rs, Inc. works to find new leaders in a collaborative way and help them be more successful
and have a greater impact on the world. The company has initially focused on giving new leaders
a voice through various speaking opportunities. It also plans to help new leaders broaden their
influence through the press, connecting them to investors, and anything that can help them
succeed.
Company Highlights:

• Leaden, Inc. launched its speaking platform in September 2017 with 150+
launch speakers. To promote the launch, it organized 10+ events in 12 months
including events in Paris and San Francisco. It built a database of 5,000 potential
speakers worldwide on top technology themes such as AI, VR, cryptocurrency,
and innovation. Its goal is to connect speakers to high-quality events by
streamlining the booking process, managing speaker requests, and sending new
opportunities.

• Leade.rs, Inc. is expecting about $1M in revenue in 2017, an increase from $150K
in 2016.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 25
of'ffiy qz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Lumii, Inc.
24 Drydock Avenue, Fl I
do Autodesk BUILD
Boston, MA 02110
CEO: Thomas A. Baran
Website: http://www.lumiidisplay.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 11212016 Simple Agreement for
Future Equity (SAFE) $ 127.350AX) $ 125.00a00 Cost Basis
Total $ 127,350.00 $ 125,000.00
Company Description:
Lumii, Inc. ("Lumii") makes 3D images that jump off the screen - no special glasses required.
Through research, the company has discovered how to create full-color, hologram -like prints (i.e.
3D images) using readily-available inkjet prints, media, and ink. Lumii is rolling out a design -
focused, cost-effective service that incorporates the use of this 3D technology.
Company Highlights:

• Lumii sold its first prints to the architecture firm Gensler for use in a sculpture
that represents Genslefs corporate identity.

• Lumii has also completed a successful printer-manufacturer collaboration with the
engineering team at Canon Oce. The Lumii process is now verified to work with
most of Canon Oce direct -to-substrate signage printers, which are installed in a
wide range of professional print facilities.

• Lumii has received strong interest / offers to sell Lumii prints to end users once
the service is ready.

• The key driver of opportunity for Lumii will be continued growth for 3D content.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 26
fyto[4ffivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Luminoso Technologies, Inc.
675 Massachusetts Avenue, 6th Floor
Cambridge, MA 02139
CEO: Catherine Havasi
Website: https:// luminoso.com
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
II/23/2015 Convertible Promissory Note $ 250.550.00 250.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 250,550.00 $ 250,000.00
Company Description:
Luminoso Technologies, Inc. ("Luminoso") makes products that transform the way organizations
interpret and act on large-scale customer, employee, and marketplace feedback. It analyzes data
for a number of clients, including Intel, Sony, and NASA.
Company Highlights:

• Luminoso has grown to a company of 42 employees with 8 offices in 3 countries.
• Annual sales of $3.3M in 2016, and $2.6M in 2017 to date.

• Luminoso has two revenue -generating products: Luminoso Analytics and
Luminoso Compass.
• Luminoso Analytics combines a reporting dashboard with an analyst tool to be the
quickest, easiest way to attain and communicate deep understanding of customers,
employees, and marketplace feedback. Luminoso Analytics is used by a wide
variety of Fortune 1000 companies such as Google, Apple, and Autodesk for
monitoring customer feedback.

• Luminoso Compass is our real-time product, allowing users to tap into real time,
streaming conversation to take the pulse of customer, employee, and marketplace
conversation. Examples of Compass customers include Finnish entertainment
company Supercell, for monitoring user help requests.

• Luminoso's software can natively analyze thirteen languages.
• Luminoso was named a "Cool Vendor in AI for Marketing" by Gartner, and
received a Stratus Award for Software as a Service.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 27
fytof'fffy qz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Move38, Inc.
231 Bowery, 2nd Floor
New York, NY 10013
CEO: Jonathan Bobrow
Website: https://move38.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodolo*
. 4/7,2017 Simple Agreement for
Future Equity (SAFE) $ 25.867.50 $ 25.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 25,867.50 $ 25,000.00
Company Description:
Move38, Inc. ("Move38") is creating a new kind of tabletop game, with components that think
for themselves, talk to each other, and come alive under your fingertips. The company wants to
bring the best out of digital to hands-on, face-to-face experiences.
Company Highlights:

• In May 2017, Move38 launched its first product, Troxes, a set of Origami
building blocks with the goal of raising brand awareness, building a community,
and going through the exercise of shipping a first product.

• In August 2017, Troxes entered full production. Move38 is currently in talks with
retailers for holiday season purchase orders.

• Move38 also created Blinks, which is the first tabletop game platform that can
think for itself. Each Blink is a hexagonal tile that is "ticklish" (responds to
touch), "social" (communicates with neighbors), "friendly" (magnetically attracts
to neighbors), and "playful" (loves to play games). Blinks is the flagship product
for Move38 and the goal is to release it with a specific launch game that uses the
platform.

• Move38's challenge has been developing hardware and having the bandwidth to
grow a community.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 28
11/ to[ 4ffivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Nuna Incorporated
650 Townsend St, Suite 425
San Francisco, CA 94103
CEO: Jini Kim
Website: https://www.nuna.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
9,277 7/17/2015 Series A Preferred Stock $ 101.162.93 $ 99394.93 Cost Basis
Total $ 101,162.93 $ 99,994.93
Company Description:
Nuna Incorporated ("Nuna") is a health-technology startup headquartered in San Francisco,
California. It partners with organizations to make a positive impact through data-driven
healthcare projects.
Company Highlights:

• Nuna is participating as a partner in the development of a national modernized
data platform for Medicaid. The new Medicaid data platform, when through beta
and expanded to include data from all states, has the potential to collect and
contain eligibility, provider, and managed care plan and other data for more than
73 million lives from all 50 states and the District of Columbia.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 29
i llyto[6ffniqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
OH2 Laboratories, LLC
132 Oxford St., Ste I A
Cambridge, MA 02140
CEO: David Levy
Website: http://www.oh2laboratories.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 4/7/2O15 Convenible Promissory Note $ 175.53260 $ 175.000.00 Cost Basis
50.000 4/7/2O15 Funding Units $ 75532.50 $ 75.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 251,065.00 $ 250,000.00
Company Description:
OH2 Laboratories, LLC ("OH2 Labs") is a synthetic materials lab. The company mainly focuses
on developing variant water-soluble G-protein -coupled receptors (GPCRs) that maintain the
functionality of the original. It also provides consulting services to pharma and other research
entities. It continues to seek ways to monetize its technologies in drug and related arenas.
Company Highlights:

• OH2 Labs is (i) through its research phase; (ii) has identified which company to
launch first (Biotherapeutics); and (iii) has identified which products (i.e. drug
targets) to develop first.

• OH2 Labs is hoping to open a new category of drugs, targeting GPCRs with
mAbs.
• OH2 Labs is looking to raise more funding and build strategic relationships to
further develop products and launch the company.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 30
04 to[4tivq3 Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Optimus Ride Inc.
485 Massachusetts Ave, Ste. 302
Cambridge, MA 02139
CEO: Sertac Karaman
Website: http://www.optimusride.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
370.837 10/3/2016 Series Seed Preferred Stock $ 252,166.77 $ 250.003.47 409A Valuation
Total $ 252,166.77 $ 250,003.47
Company Description:
Optimus Ride Inc. ("Optimus Ride") develops self-driving technologies to enable safe,
sustainable, and equitable mobility solutions.
Company Highlights:

• Optimus Ride has driven nearly 200 miles autonomously in the self -driving zone
in Boston's waterfront. It has now achieved basic full autonomy on public roads
after receiving approval from MassDOT back in May 2017. It has been driving
mostly during daylight hours with some driving in light rain.

• Optimus Ride is in the process of raising its Series A financing round.
• Recently, Optimus Ride received a contract from the developer of Union Point, a
large 20,000 person smart community in S. Weymouth, MA. To the company's
knowledge, this pilot is the first revenue generating self-driving vehicle program
in the world. Optimus Ride has another 5 pilots in the near term pipeline and
another 20 after that (including international pilots).

• The pilots will enable validation of the technology and market. From there,
Optimus Ride can turn key pilots into commercial deployments and
simultaneously work on scaling every aspect of the business.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 31
fyto[4tivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Ori, Inc. (f/k/a MorphLab, Inc.)
100 Morrissey Boulevard
Boston, MA 02125
CEO: Hasler Larrea
Website: http://www.orisystems.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
50.000 9/18/2015 Series Seed Preferred Stock $ 102,301.00 $ 272,797.63
Valuation based
on last funding
round raised
37.500 8/22/2016 Series Seed Preferred Stock $ 75.471.00 204,598.22
Valuation based
on last funding
round raised
37,500 12/2/2016 Series Seed Preferred Stock $ 75.141.00 $ 204.598.22
Valuation based
on last funding
round raised
Total $ 252,913.00 $ 681,994.07
Company Description:
Ori, Inc. ("Ori," f/k/a Morphlab, Inc.) enables effortless transformation of interior spaces. One of
the ways it has done this is through the creation of the Ori System (an outgrowth of a project
called CityHome). The Ori system is a multi-functional product that can be used as a bed, dining
room table, kitchen surface and more, in order to maximize the efficiency of space in tiny
apartments.
Company Highlights:

• Ori is working on local media launches.
• Ori currently has pilots in 10 cities with 13 developers.
• Ori has received commitments of $1.5M in signed purchase orders for the first
product.

• Ori has begun to establish an installation network.
• Ori is in talks with companies to establish manufacturing and retailer partnerships.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 32
lyto[ 4ffniqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Pixel Labs, Inc.
2407 Harrison St. #3
San Francisco, CA 94110
CEO: Razmig Hovaghimian
Website: http://www.pixellabs.io/ and https://www.hoodline.com/
Investment:

No. or
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
111.449 12/24/2015 Series Seed Preferred Stock $ 151380.71 $ 149.999.21 Cost Basis
- 1/2(2017 Convenible Promissory Note $ 30.671.00 $ 30.00a00 Cost Basis
Total $ 182,051.71 $ 179,999.21
Company Description:
Pixel Labs, Inc. ("Pixel Labs") runs Hoodline (f/k/a Ripple News). Hoodline is a location -based
content discovery platform, powered by local journalists and a community of contributors. It
maps the world around you, to solve local news and information discovery globally, down to a
0.2 radius. The vision of Hoodline is to allow locals to discover the pulse of their city, and for
travelers to experience a city like locals do.
Company Highlights:

• Pixel Labs' goal is to build the 'nearby button' of the internet, using AI / machine
learning to solve local content discovery on other sites / apps, via its Application
Programming Interfaces (APIs).

• Pixel Labs is working closely with Bob Iger, CEO of The Walt Disney Company,
to power a consumer vision for its platform.

• Pixel Labs' partners include Disney, Uber, Zumper, Yelp, and Eventbrite, who
take Hoodline content via an API to drive more clicks, reservations, or bookings.

• Pixel Labs has started monetizing in QI-Q3 2017, with about $600K in revenues.
Estimated 2017 revenue is $1M.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 33
to [ 4ff niq
Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Sannpa Limited
76 Crafters House, Flat 5, 76 East Road
London, Ni 6AB
United Kingdom
CEO: Wounter Sleijffers
Website: http://www.fnatic.com/
Investment:
No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
36 2/19/2016 Ordinary Stock $ 55331.75 $ 49.716.00 Cost Basis
- 12/14/2016 Loan Stock $ 13.895.00 $ 12.800.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 69,226.75 $ 62,516.00
Company Description:
Sannpa, Ltd. ("Sannpa") is the holding company for Fnatic. Fnatic is the world's number one
electronic sports brand. Started 10 years ago in the nascent competitive video gaming market,
Fnatic has grown to be a powerhouse. They won thousands of tournaments, over 10m USD in
prizes across more than 20 games, the most out of any e-sports brand. This has led to over 8m
followers across social media, with tens of millions more viewing the company's professional
players each month. As a brand, Sannpa is driven to lead the New World Sport into every
household, through content, products and experiences.
Company Highlights:

• In the past 12 months, Sannpa has been building the framework and infrastructure
to enable the company to scale and consolidate its strong position within the
eSports field.

• It has opened companies in Germany, Serbia, Hong Kong and Taiwan to help
with its stated intention of growing the Fnatic brand globally and facilitating
operations in those territories.

• Sannpa has decided to concentrate on selling its Fnatic Gear products direct to
our customers, where margins are far higher. It launched the Fnatic Summer
Collection in June 2017, which was the first seasonal collection (apparel,
accessories and merchandise) followed by the Autumn/Winter Collection in
September 2017.

• For Fnatic Gear, development of the Generation 2 products (mice & keyboards)
has been pushed back to 2018.

• Sannpa has signed sponsorship agreements with new partners DX Racer, One
Plus, and Deezer with annual value of $450K.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 34
1/ o[4ffiy Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Shuttersong Incorporated
41 Sawyer Rd.
Wellesley, MA 02481
CEO: William Agush
Website: http://www.shuttersong.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description
Amount
Invested Value
Value
Methodology
242.542 7/27/2015 Series Seed 3 Preferred Stock $ 102,010.57 $ 118.000.00
Valuation based
on proposed
funding round
26,730 3/4/2016 Series Seed 3 Preferred Stock $ 11.16138 Included Above
- 12J13/2016 Simple Agreement for Future Equity
(SAFE)
$ 5.817.00 $ 5.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 118,98935 $ 123,000.00
Company Description:
Shuttersong Incorporated ("Shuttersong") created the Shuttersong App that lets users combine
digital images with sound and share the resulting Shuttersong with family, friends, and
colleagues through social networks, e-mail, or text.
Company Highlights:

• Shuttersong continues to grow the user base of the consumer application with a
total user base of 365,000, of which 25% are considered active users.

• Shuttersong has begun attracting musical artists to the application as a way to
enrich their Instagram images. Lady Gaga's social media team indicated they will
trial one or two posts in September 2017 or early October 2017 to see if the
platform offers a new kind of interaction for her fan base.

• Shuttersong's next big development will be to integrate Google Vision into the
app. The idea is that the app would use the data from Google Vision (e.g.
location, time of day, weather) to recommend music to accompany each image.

• The main challenge is to complete the global licenses needed for proper provision
of music.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 35
11 to[ 4ffiv qz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Top Flight Technologies, Inc.
730 Eastern Ave, Suite 096
Malden, MA 02148
CEO: Long Phan
Website: http://www.tflighttech.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
85.000
6/8/2017
and
11/20/2015
Series A Preferred Stock
(upon conversion of a
promissory note plus a
follow-on investment)
$ 353.696.50 $ 850.000.00
Valuation based
on last funding
round raised
- 8/8/2017 Convertible Promissory Note $ 200.000.00 $ 200.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 553,696.50 $ 1,050,000.00
Company Description:
Top Flight Technologies, Inc. ("Top Flight") is dedicated to application -specific, cost effective
commercial solutions of unmanned aircraft vehicles (UAVs) using the latest advanced
technologies driving automation and safety. A key innovation is a very small gasoline -based
hybrid engine that has very high energy densities compared to batteries.
Company Highlights:

• Top Flight has completed testing of its AirborgTM H8 10k, a multi-function,
enhanced flight time, extended payload, quad 8-roto UAV platform.

• Top Right plans on doing a hybrid engine power system target demo in late fall
2017 with a soft launch immediately after.

• Top Flight has 5 patents cleared for international filing.
• Top Flight's core focus is now on selling first commercial product and building
100KW (power) capability in parallel.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 36
It to[ 4fffy qz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Tulip Interfaces, Inc.
561 Windsor St, B402
Somerville, MA 02143
CEO: Natan Linder
Website: https://tulip.co/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
390.640 10/05/2015
Series A Preferred Stock
(upon conversion of a promissory
note and post a 10-for-1 stock split)
$ 260347.62 $ 370.166.56
Valuation based
on last funding
round raised
211.060 5/21/2017 Series A Preferred Stock
(post a 10-for -1 stock split) $ 200.754.85 $ 199.998.35 Cost basis
Total $ 461,502.47 $ 570,164.91
Company Descript'on:
Tulip Interfaces, Inc ("Tulip Interfaces") has created a digital manufacturing system that allows
manufacturers to gain access to previously unobtainable production data.
Company Highlights:

• Tulip Interfaces is helping New Balance digitize the shop floors of its
manufacturing facilities, and as a result, thus, gain insight into the underlying
causes of production issues.

• Tulip has partnered with Merck KGaA to reduce the time it takes to fully train
new operators on the assembly of highly complicated lab equipment. Training
time has fallen by over 90%. In addition, Tulip software is being deployed to
begin measuring and analyzing assembly procedures on the production line.

• Tulip Interfaces was recently chosen as an IDC Innovator in the Analytics
Applications for Manufacturer category.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 37
11 to[6tivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Twine Health, Inc.
210 Broadway #201
Cambridge, MA 02139
CEO: John Moore
Website: https://www.twinehealth.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
152.358 11/17/2015 Series A Preferred Stock $ 201502.85 $ 75.447.68
Valuation based
on last funding
round raised
37.893 4/19/2017 Series A-1 Preferred Stock $ 20,853.11 $ 18.764.61 Cost Basis
Total $ 222,355.96 $ 94,212.29
Company Description:
Twine Health, Inc. ("Twine Health") strives to use technology to promote collaborative care
between doctors, healthcare coaches, and patients. It created the Twine App, which is intended to
help users reach their goals faster, stay healthier, and avoid unnecessary office visits.
Company Highlights:

• Twine Health has transitioned away from trying to market to healthcare
organizations, and instead, is refocusing its efforts on workplace health providers
who deliver services to employee populations of self-insured employers. It has
been a challenge to fund the right product-market fit in the U.S. healthcare
system.

• Twine Health has rebranded its solution as an Employee Health Activation
Platform and expanded its capabilities to blend the best of both worlds, including
automation for employee self-management with best-in-class health coaching
tools.

• Twine Health's near-term goal is to secure several more key customers in the
workplace health market.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 38
4ffo[4ffivq3 Investment Report: October 23, 2017
udu, Inc.
1330 Saint Mary's Street, Suite 350
Raleigh, NC 27605
CEO: Rett Crocker
Website: http://www.udu.co/
Investment:
No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 3/31/2015 Convertible Promissory Note $ 10,024.15 $ 100,000.00 Cost Basis
25.000 3/31/2015 Warrant for Common Stock $ 0.00 $ 0.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 104,324.15 $ 100,000.00
Company Description:
Udu, Inc. ("udu") is a scheduling and communication platform built on a web services
abstraction framework; chat, exchange media, and share with your favorite social networks,
while the udu App does the work of planning the event.
Company Highlights:

• Udu will be holding its first-ever "udu Unstructured Data Dash"—or "U2D2"—
event. During its presentation on the main stage, udu will invite attendees to come
to udu's stand during the conference and explain their most difficult problems that
involve finding, structuring, enriching, and delivering unstructured data. The udu
team will attempt to solve these problems as quickly as possible. The udu team is
hoping to solve them in under two weeks and, if the problem is solved, the
organization that submitted the problem will get three free months to use the udu
platform plus the solution udu built for them.

• Udu continues to work with and expand its relationships with current customers,
while also adding new customers and pilot programs.

• Udu's short-term goal is to continue to acquire additional customers, as with each
new customer, the udu technology platform becomes more robust.

• In the long-term, udu hopes that its technology will evolve to a point where a
potential user can access the udu platform via the web and easily implement a
data solution with little or no assistance from the company.

• Udu is in active discussions with additional investors to raise about $250-500K. It
is in hopes that this amount of capital will be sufficient to help the company
achieve a breakeven point and more quickly reach a revenue level that would
allow udu to raise additional growth capital via a Series A round investment.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 39
41t01 6E1)1(f3 Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Wait What LLC
26 Broadway, 8th Floor
New York, NY 10004
CEO: June Cohen
Website: https://www.waitwhat.com/
Investment:
No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
- 7/12/2017 Convertible Promissory Note $ 51276.50 $ 50.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 51,276.50 $ 50,000.00
Company Description:
Wait What LLC ("Wait What") is a first-of-its-kind content incubator that invests in, develops,
and nurtures original media properties until they achieve great scale. For a combined 16 years,
WaitWhat co-founders June Cohen and Deron Triff led TED's media organization, growing
TED Talks from zero to 1 billion views/listens each year through launching TED.com, the TED
Open Translation Project, TED Radio Hour on NPR, TED in Cinema, and nearly 100
distribution partnerships around the world. Cohen was previously VP of Content at Wired
Digital; Triff was previously VP of Digital Ventures at PBS.
Company Highlights:

• Wait What currently has two original podcasts, Masters of Scale and Sincerely, X
• Masters of Scale is hosted by LinkedIn Co-Founder and Greylock Partner Reid
Hoffman where they discuss how companies grow from zero to a gazillion.
Season 2 of Masters of Scale is fully sold and has produced more than $550,000
in revenue. It will premier November 1, 2018 with guests including Peter Thiel,
Barry Diller, Stewart Butterfield, Diane Greene, among others. Season 1 of
Masters of Scale is approaching 4 million downloads and will be fully monetized
from Zip Recruiter.

• June Cohen, Founder & CEO of Wait What, hosts Sincerely, X (TED) where she
goes in search of ideas in hiding. Wait What owns 20% of the revenue share for
the first 3 years of Sincerely, X. It was #1 on iTunes worldwide for most of
August 2017.

• Wait What is looking to hire for key positions, however traditional job listings
have not produced quality candidates. They will be moving to a recruiter to hire
top talent. They are also looking to move offices as its 7-member team has
outgrown a 4-person office.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 40
iyto[4ffivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Wearality Corporation
12605 Challenger Pkwy, Suite 160
Orlando, FL 32826
CEO: [David Smith, Chief Technology Officer]
Website: http://wearality.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
51,976 4/27/2015
Series A Preferred Stock
(upon conversion of a
promissory note)
$ 128.58244 $ 124323.29 Cost Basis
Total $ 128,582.44 $ 124,323.29
Company Description:
Wearality Corporation ("Wearality") develops field of view (FOV) head wearable display
technology that is comfortable and gives a natural visual experience. It is the creative force
behind Wearality Sky, lightweight, fold-able, open source 3D glasses that put a movie theater in
your pocket.
Company Highlights:

• Wearality created Wearality Sky, which are 3D glasses for your smartphone.
Wearality Sky won a CES Innovation Award in the category of Wireless Handset
Accessories and are currently available on Amazon.

• Wearality is currently engaging with a number of large head mount manufacturers
to either sell lenses or license lens technology.

• Wearality hopes to close a lens design deal with a potential customer, which
would be in the range of $60-$80K and would allow Wearality to both design the
prescription for the new lens as well as create an engineering/manufacturing
model that either the customer or Wearality can take to their respective
manufacturing partners.

• Some challenges for Wearality include recently restructuring its company and
laying off the entire staff Also, its current product has minimal sales with about
one product selling per day. This results in minimal cash for operations and
marketing.

• The success of Wearality rests on the repositioning the company as a premier
optics technology provider to the large-scale VR and AR manufacturers.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 41
414 to[6tivqz Investment Report: October 23, 2017
Wise Systems Inc.
17 Flagg St
Boston, MA 02138
CEO: Charles Sims
Website: http://www.wisesystems.com/
Investment:

No. of
Shares
Investment
Date Description Amount Invested Value
Value
Methodology
143.760 6/1/2016 Series One Preferred Stock $ 101,583A6 $ 163,023.84
Valuation based
on last funding
round raised
- 7/11/2017 Convenible Promissory Note $ 2080.444.00 $ 200.000.00 Cost Basis
Total $ 302,027.46 $ 363,023.84
Company Description:
Wise Systems Inc. ("Wise Systems") is a software analytic% company that provides data driven
intelligence solutions for transportation operations with the goal of saving companies time and
money. It utilizes big data to route enterprises, and analyzes real-time and historical data to
further optimize transportation operations.
Company Highlights:

• Wise Systems has successfully leveraged its ability to upsell with its largest
customer account.
• Wise Systems has created two opportunities within Fedex. In addition, it launched
four enterprise pilots.

• Wise Systems is currently working on channel strategy for 2018.
• Wise Systems completed a rollout with AB InBev's entire fleet across the United
States.

• Wise Systems raised $IM in new capital and hopes to raise a Series A in the first
half of 2018.
• Some challenges for Wise Systems include sale predictability and hiring a new
Marketing Representative.
Neoteny 3, LP I CONFIDENTIAL - NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 42
EFTA00002848 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-07)
••••01/ . 7•••• •nr
.aorivraiiert _  now
- 0" nr  U-7  -so I l's.-ra  i sarr
sae _M e ..•••••••
see_ •••" •r
sw iss' rr.,,erne..-•=r amOi017
aletsostral -
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                          Juleanna Glover [republican] CEO of powerful DC lobbying firm Ridgely|Walsh 
                     Oleg Deripaska [russia] oligarch with underage sex scandal history [moscowtimes] 
                                                 Newsmax [journalist] right wing American news outlet 
 Adnan Khashoggi [mideast] arms dealer involved in the Iran-Contra scandal, Epstein's former employer 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00042963 (Jmail)
 [government] emails from barket epstein lawfirm?
(inferred date: 2026-01-07)
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D77E62B.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.1367333.1.1 5657.1
Message Path xmllTrash/SD77E628.NEFtDOMI.NERADMI.100.1 367333.1.15657.1.xml
From Google Alerts
Display Name Goo& Alerts
Email googlealens.nerepMageogle.com
Reply To googlealens.noreply@geogk.com
Test Google Alerts
To
Subject Googie Alert - ethics
Scheduled date 2019.09.101804+94
Creation date 2019.09-10181M/44
Modified date 201949.10 182133
Deli% end date 2019.09-10 18Ok36
Message she 7689
Attachments she 121647
Total size 129347
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htin
Name TF-XT.htm
Content ID
5D77E62B.NERDOMI.NERADMI.200.2000090.1.2
208B.1®455D77F.62B.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.1
367333.1.15657.1@i 9.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100 .0.1.0. l@l8
Is Inline fake
Type Ale
Size 50232
CA 951a6ie68a58e532be7bddtt95e186B1
Hash 19874AES7859F7F5A1386O1482ACIA418657FAAN 58759AEB4E6A4DA74F2A45091A2997DE
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D77E62B.NERDOMI.NERADM1.200.2000090.1.2
208C.1(4)455D77E62B.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.1
367333.1.15657.1@l9.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100 .0.1.0. 1@l8
Is Inline fake
Type Me
Size 71415
CA 9093b8e08dcf87cd45ad3452319719a6
Hash 85142B550ACC8F5A314080E982A7DA 1DD829CF0F 9A I2FF9DA845697D6758455C885FBOBF
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2F982B80-14O3-0000.9847-BF62C05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read false
Deleted true
Opened fake
Completed fake
Security Nonnal
Box type lnbox
Return notification "hen opened false
Return notification "hen de le te d fake
Return notification "hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D77E62B.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.B67333.1.1 5657.1©19.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.0.1.0.1@1 8
Source received
Class Public
Account DOMI
Page 12452
Location ID 1540843020946
Class Name 6W.NIESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
ID 9.NERDOMLNERADMI.I00.0.I.0.I@I8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12453
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-11 032439 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Trash)
Job.cn-lebs.crGWOpenNodexn-archiving.of Agent-
actmai
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [ctrArchive
I -DailY Trash)Jobtn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNock.cn-archivinga
-nettnaill
2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag 1301'01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag B080170334XRADM 1.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12454
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12455
Sent: Tue, 10 Sep 2019 15:04:44 -0700
Subject: Google Alert - ethics
From: Goo le Alerts < ooglealerts-noreply@google.00m>
To:
ethics September 10, 2019
NEWS
Circuit judge hears arguments regarding former Marion Co. judge ethics violation
KY3
Former Marion County Judge Terry Ott found himself in trouble with the Arkansas Ethics Commission back in 2016. It
claimed Ott violated a state code ...

• •
Political donations case referred to Hempstead ethics board
Newsday
A company formed by Hempstead Town Compliance Officer Thomas Willdigg has given $800 to local Republican
committees since the town board ...
It's not about ethics, it's about how we imagine God
National Catholic Reporter
But as Massingate, a professor of theological and social ethics at Fordham University, explained in an email exchange 
and
a phone conversation, ...
•
Anti-Abuse Advocate, NY Ethics Body Spar Over Billboards
U.S. News & World Report
ALBANY, N.Y. (AP) — Kat Sullivan wanted to get the attention of New York state officials when she took out ads on
billboards criticizing the state's ...

• •
Threats over Metro Board ethics issues could get further scrutiny on Capitol Hill
WTOP
Threats over ethics issues facing then-Metro Board Chairman Jack Evans are detailed in hundreds of pages of documents
the transit system provided ...
Threats. Favors for Friends, and Ethics Violations Prompt Congressional Republicans Call for ... - Washington City Paper
House GOP wants deeper investigation of Jack Evans Metro scandal - Washington Post
Full Coverage
in ■ Flag as are'evant
Ethics Commission Investigating Top Montgomery Official's Connection to County Vendor
BethesdaMagazine.com
The Montgomery County Ethics Commission is investigating a top Montgomery County government official's contractual
relationship with a public ...

• •
MIT, Epstein scandal highlights thorny ethics of university donations
WCVB Boston
While MIT grapples with new allegations about its financial ties to Jeffrey Epstein, other universities that accepted 
donations
from the disgraced ...
IN •
Former DPH worker from Windsor fined $2500 for ethics violation
Journal Inquirer
HARTFORD — A former Department of Public Health employee from Windsor has paid a $2,500 fine to the Office of State
Ethics for violating the state's ...

• •
City Commission to Consider "Double-Fill" of Chief Ethics Officer Position
tallahasseerepons.com
The City Commission will address the need for a new Chief Ethics Officer at their Sept. 11 meeting. Current Ethics 
Officer
Julie Meadows-Keefe ...
WaPo: NOM to investigate if response to Trump violated ethics
Channel3000.com - WISC-TV3
WASHINGTON, D.C. - An official with the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration is going to investigate if the
agency violated its own ethics ...
NOAA's chief scientist will investigate why agency backed Trump over its experts on Dorian, email - Washington Post
Full Coverage
In In Flag as Irrelevant
WEB
Studying the Ethics of Medicine
NEOMED
Through the Summer Research Fellowship Program at Northeast Ohio Medical University, medicine or pharmacy students
gain intensive training in ...
• •
Industry and Stakeholders reaffirm their commitment to ensuring ethics and integrity across
health ...
IFPMA
GENEVA. 10 SEPTEMBER 2019: IFPMA is proud to be a key partner of the Business Ethics for APEC SMEs initiative, the
largest public-private ...
Human research ethics applications (HREA) resources
NHMRC
Human research ethics applications (HREA) resources. The Human Research Ethics Application (HREA) enables all
Australian research involving ...
Ethics and medical marijuana
Commission for Case Manager Certification
Ethics and medical marijuana: What you need to know Live Webinar. September 25.2019 1 to 2 p.m. ET ABOUT THE
WEBINAR.
XX
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscnbe
Receive this alert as RSS teed
Send Feedback
RE: MCC conditions
From Bruce Barket
To
ida Leisenri
ichaelBachrach
onyricco
Date 2019/08/30 10:30
Subject: RE: MCC conditions
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
I am "off" today but I can make time for a call if everyone else is available
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[P1 [F]
www.barketenstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have
received this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is
strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us
immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From: ffi l~
Sent: Thursday,
To:
Cc:
Michael Bachrach
Subject: RE: MCC conditions
Received.
nring; tonYhcco
Bruce, , would you all be free for a call tomorrow afternoon to discuss?
"l ihanks
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
1 St. Andrew's Plaza
New York. NY 10007
Page 12459
I-IL:III. DI LAX DclI Mel
Sent: Thursday, August 29, 2019 5:25 PM
To:
Cc:
Subject: MCC conditions
< >;
(USANYS)
>; tonyricco
Michael Bachrach
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the facility.

Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it himself on
August 15th. His radio has needed batteries for several days. The guards simply refuse to provide him
with the batteries and new books he believes are in his property. Several guards have been making
comments to him such as "You're threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth his try" and similar
remarks aimed at intimidating him and conveying to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not staff in the
lobby to process legal visits. I was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't stay through the count
so I had to leave before 9:30. I know I did not make an appointment but the issue wasn't a free room,
but adequate staffing in the lobby. Yesterday I was able to see my client at 5:00 as scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
(F)
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have
received this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is
strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us
immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 12460
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D68FAC3.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 B755.1
Message Path xmiklauboxi5D68FAC3.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .1373875.1.711755.1.ml
From Bruce Barket
Display Name Bruce Barket
Email
Reply. To —
Test Bruce Barket
To I I
Cc Aida Lcucnnn Michaceachrach I k talyncco
Subject RE: MCC canditisen
Scheduled date 2019.08-30103o:17
Citation date 2019-08-30 10:30:17
Modified date 201948-30 103129
Delis e red dale 2019-08-30 10:30:28
Message size 4098
Attachments size 33186
Total slze 37295
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.han
Content ID
5D68FAC3.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200C0CB.I.1
0461C. 445:5DMEAC3.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.
1373875.1.7B755.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.10 0.0.1.0.1(0)16
Is Inline fake
Type Re
Size 11542
CA 15cd403554e5e12947079c7e69496584
Hash D79EDCAF.03A022E9CBA59A4159F4A86067EAD8/30 289870732907D445846732AC7437B513
Attachment Msne.822
Name Manc.822
Content ID
5D68FAC3.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000008.1.1
0461D.1€453D68FAC3.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.
1373875.1.715755.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.16t 16
Is Inline fake
Type file
Site 21644
CA 4c6c23925233361175675ib49CRAM7a
Hash C147468E56F45987D99557CADET98732B0F4B9F5 67835F1390053FID7E71741051ADI6EA9
Recipients
Recipnt
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CAD049CA4300a8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient Aria Untiring
Display Name Aida UDC
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Distribution I ype CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID AR244985- I RAA-0000-B60A-A812D3F99FD4
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CUM 79BA4F81.399A-0000.B60A-EIB48EDIFB51
Page 12461
Distribution Tye TO
Recipient Ty User
Recipient MichaelBaelvach
Display Name MichaelBachrach
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
LIVID I5A65EI0-0C33-0000a3E7-68A6064I5CAD
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient tonyricco
Display Name tonyricco
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read We
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box brie Inbox
Return notification Mien opened false
Return notification n he n deleted lake
Return notification nhen
completed iMse
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification vshen
accepted
fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D68FAC3.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.B73875.1.7 B755.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.0.1.0.RDI
Source received
Class Public
Account YMADMINYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name OW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mafibox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.01.0.1@l6
Name Matox
Type Melbas
System true
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 12462
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-06 203032 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-lebs.cn-GWOpenNodern-archiving.oAgent-
aetmai
Gerrrated by Netrre3 Inc. [cn=Archive
I -DailY Archive3Jobrn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoietn-archivinga
-netrnail]
2020-05.19153006 EDT Tag 1301'01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-1914:4136 EDT Tag B0P01703.NOCRADNI 1.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12463
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12464
RE: M conditions
Sent: Fri, 30 Aug 2019 14:30:17 +0000
I am "off" today but I can make time for a call if everyone else is available
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If 
it is not clear that you are
the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, 
dissemination, distribution or
copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, 
please notify us immediately
by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From: [mailto
Sent: Thursday, Au ust 29 2019 7:54 PM
To: Bruce Barket•
Cc: USANYS); Aida Leisenring; tonyricco ; • Michael Bachrach
Subject: RE: MCC conditions
Received.
Bruce==, would you all be free for a call tomorrow afternoon to discuss?
Thanks
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
I St. Andrew's Plaza
New York. NY 10007
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Thursda August 29, 2019 5:25 PM
To:
Cc:
>
>. ton ricco
USANYS
>*,
; Aida Leisenring
Michael Bachrach
Subject: MCC conditions
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the facility.
Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it himself on August 15th. His radio has 
needed
batteries for several days. The guards simply refuse to provide him with the batteries and new books he believes are in 
his
property. Several guards have been making comments to him such as "You're threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth
his
try" and similar remarks aimed at intimidating him and conveying to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not staff in the lobby to process 
legal visits. I
was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't stay through the count so I had to leave before 9:30. I know I did not
make an
appointment but the issue wasn't a free room, but adequate staffing in the lobby. Yesterday I was able to see my client 
at 5:00 as
scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden City, NY 11530
[Pi [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If 
it is not clear that you are
the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, 
dissemination, distribution or
copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, 
please notify us immediately
by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Subject: Re: MCC conditions
RE: MCC conditions
From )"
Aida Lciscnrin Bruce Barkc
To ichaelBachrach
onyricco (
Date 2019/08/30 13:26
Subject: RE: MCC conditions
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
I'm available at 2pm. Would you be able to circulate a call in number, please, Bruce?
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
1 St. Andrew's Plaza
New Yorb NY 10007
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Friday, Au ust 30, 2019 1:25 PM
To:
Cc:
tonyricco >; Aida Leisenrin
>; MichaelBachrach
Do we have a time for the call and perhaps a call in number?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
maGarden Cit , NY 11530
- O
- M
Ba rket Ep_s_tein—coM
On Aug 30, 2019, at 10:30 AM, > wrote:
Good morning all,
Would 2 or 2:30 work? I am running around this morning, have a meeting at I, and
am leaving at 3.
Thanks,
Page 12467
>>> alMe 8/29/2019 7:54
PM >> >
Received.
Bruce/-, would you all be free for a call tomorrow afternoon to discuss?
Thanks,
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
1 St. Andrew's Plaza
New York, NY 10007
From: Bruce Barket <bbarketObarketepstein.com>
Sent: Thursda August 29,2019 5:25 PM
To:
Cc: (USANYS)
>; tonyricco
Michael Bachrach
Subject: MCC conditions
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the
facility.
Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it
himself on August 15th. His radio has needed batteries for several days. The guards
simply refuse to provide him with the batteries and new books he believes are in his
property. Several guards have been making comments to him such as "You're
threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth his try" and similar remarks aimed at
intimidating him and conveying to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not
staff in the lobby to process legal visits. I was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't
stay through the count so I had to leave before 9:30. I know I did not make an
appointment but the issue wasn't a free room, but adequate staffing in the lobby.
Yesterday I was able to see my client at 5:00 as scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
(Tsar/inn rift, NV 11 Sqll
Page 12468
••••.•• • N.,1,7, el I
[P1 IF]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be
privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby
notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution
or copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this
communication in error, please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately
delete this message and all its attachments
Page 12469
Properties
Property Value
Nlessage ID 5D6923F5.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 B7CE.1
Message Path xmI'Mailaou5D6923F5.NYMDOM LNYMADM1.100 , 1373875.1.787CE, I,xml
From
Display Name ).
Email . 11
UUID 79BA4F81-399A-00004360A-EI B48ED1 FB51
Reply To
Text r
To Bruce Bark!
Aida Lencnring I Alie elBachrach I
tonsrs:co Cc
Subject RE: MCC conditions
Scheduled date 2019-08-301325x7
Creation date 2019-08.301325.N7
Modified date 2019-08-30 141040
Delis cried date 2019-08-30 1326:14
Message size 4250
Attachments size 34821
Total size 39082
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hun
Content II)
5D6923E5.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000FC.1.4
5219.1445:5D6923F5.NYMD0MI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.787CE. l€: 12.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1(416
Is Inline false
Type Mc
Sim 12504
CA c9d3704a92631:4570c509d4a0a5a7066
Hash 78C9104B27639A2F73E97F52FFA2F3260FCCC084 248E4DOFBFA16F3760CA957919757B8A
Attachment Minc.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D6923F5.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.2130.20003FC.1.4
521A.1(4455D692.3F5.NYMD0MLNYMADMI.1130.1
373875.1.7B7CE1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type fie
Size 22317
CA 1157026416baa441586641438192a 166
Hash 8C62531E8BEE61E0E32C06DEC55B4BCC89F8IBCD 3238DF95E00D8BE28283A678B38F221A
Recipients 8
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0300a8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient Aida Lciscurmg
Name Display
Email
Aida I..
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type Uscr
Recipient Bruce Becket
Dis phis Name Bruce Becket
Email
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'rs-pe User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type Uscr
Recipient
Dis plan Name
Email
CND AB294985-1BAA-03004360A-A812D3F99FD4
Page 12470
Distribution Tye ('C
Recipient Ty User
Recipient MachacInaclvach
Display Name MichaelBachrach
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
LIVID 15A65E10-0O3-0000a3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient tonyricco
Display Name tonyricco
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read nue
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification .hen opened false
Return notification .hen deleted fake
Return notification .hen
completed take
Return notification .hen declined fake
Return notification nhen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D6923F5.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.787CE.R§Ifl.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1©1 6
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMINYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name liW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.111@l6
Name Maln(
Type Mailbox
System tmc
Share Type NotShared
Page 12471
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-06 203221 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-Jcbs.creGWOpenNodern-archivingeoM
ietmai
Gerrrated by Netrred Inc. [cn=Archive
_1-Daily Archive3gcnt
Jobrn-Jobsrn-GWOpenNoie.cn-archivinga
-netmad]
2020-0519153006 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19153531 EDT Tag BOP01700.frOCRADMI.N1 XRIX)hil Responsive
2020-05-191414136 EDT Tag BOP01703.1vDCRADMI.AINRIXRAI Fbggcd
Page 12472
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12473
From:
To:
C
haelBachrach
(USANYS)"
Subject:
Sent: Fri, 30 Aug 2019 17:25:47 +0000
RE: MCC conditions
I'm available at 2pm. Would you be able to circulate a call in number, please, Bruce?
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
I St. Andrew's Plaza
New York. NY 10007
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Frida Au ust 30, 2019 1:25 PM
To:
Cc:
>; Aida Leisenrin: <
>;
Subject: Re: MCC conditions
>;
Do we have a time for the call and perhaps a call in number?
>; MichaelBachrach
(USANYS) <
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
miGarden Cit , NY 11530
- O
- M
Barket Epstein.com
On Aug 30, 2019, at 10:30 AM, < > wrote:
>>>
• ton ricco
Good morning all,
Would 2 or 2:30 work? I am running around this morning, have a meeting at 1, and am leaving at 3.
Thanks,
)" > 8/29/2019 7:54 PM >»
Received.
Bruce/  would you all be free for a call tomorrow afternoon to discuss?
Thanks,
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
I St. Andrew's Plaza
New York. NY 10007
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Thursda August 29, 2019 5:25 PM
To:
Cc: >; Aida
Michael Bachrach
Subject: MCC conditions
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the facility.
Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it himself on August 151h. His
radio has needed batteries for several days. The guards simply refuse to provide him with the batteries and new
books he believes are in his property. Several guards have been making comments to him such as "You're
threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth his try" and similar remarks aimed at intimidating him and conveying
to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not staff in the lobby to process
legal visits. I was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't stay through the count so I had to leave before 9:30. 
I
know I did not make an appointment but the issue wasn't a free room, but adequate staffing in the lobby. Yesterday I
was able to see my client at 5:00 as scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
(P1 [F)
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If 
it is not
clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any
review,
dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received
this
communication in error, please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all 
its
attachments
Re: MCC conditions
From Bruce Barket
ida Leisenring
To ichaelBachrach
tonyricco
Date 2019/08/30 11:38
Subject: Re: MCC conditions
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
I will try to hook you in once we hear from the government and get a time confirmed
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci NY 11530
-
- M
Barket Epstein.com
On Aug 30, 2019, at 11:09 AM, tonyricco ‹ > wrote:
i could do either time. i can be reached on my cellular phone.
tonyricco
Sent from my Verimn, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
' aI message -----
From:
Date: 8/30/19 10:30 AM GMT-05:00
To: Bruce Barket
Aida Leisenrin
Subject: RE: MCC conditions
Good morning all,
Would 2 or 2:30 work? I am running around this morning, have a meeting at I, and
am leaving at 3.
Thanks,
0 V-1O ' 1111\ - 7.4* 1
Page 12476
..•••••••• OLLY/LVI,
PM >»
Received.
Bruce l, would you all be free for a call tomorrow afternoon to discuss?
Thanks,
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
1 St. Andrewa&Ms Plaza
New York, NY 10007
From: Bruce Barket
Sent: Thursda Au st 29 2019 5:25 PM
T
Subject: MCC conditions
Page 12477
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at
the facility.
Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it
himself on August 15th. His radio has needed batteries for several days. The guards
simply refuse to provide him with the batteries and new books he believes are in his
property. Several guards have been making comments to him such as
tlEceYoutere threatening our lives.* and ftEeeGive the big mouth his tryttE and
similar remarks aimed at intimidating him and conveying to him their displeasure
with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was
not staff in the lobby to process legal visits. I was able to see my client by 9;10, but
I couldna€TMt stay through the count so I had to leave before 9:30. I know I did not
make an appointment but the issue wasna€3'Mt a free room, but adequate staffing in
the lobby. Yesterday I was able to see my client at 5:00 as scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden City, NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client cormainication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have
received this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal
is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this cormumication in error, please notify
us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 12478
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D690AB3.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 B78A.1
Message Path xmlislaiboV5D690AB3.NYMDOMENYMADM1,100 1373875.1.7878A.I.xml
From Bruce Barket
Display Name Bruce Backe!
Email
Reply Eo
Test Bruce Barkct
To tonyneco
Cc Aida Le' ' Michaelllachrach
I:
Subject Re: MCC conditions
Scheduled date 201948-30 1137A3
Citation dale 2019-08-30 11:37A3
Modified date 2019438-30 HAWS
Delis e red dale 2019-08-30 113&28
Message size 4468
Attachments site 28538
Total slze 33017
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htrn
Name TEXT.htzn
Content ID
5D690AB3.19VMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.2000017.1.F
CEC6.1®453D690AB3.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
373875.1.7B78A.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type It
Size 9154
CA Od412027b08518ad678990570thdec91
Hash B1403C219A4D74B07D64F06E3932A3E760833D9A 13C589C6C8FC072065A86B5EC9CD4442
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D690AB3.NYMDOMENYMADM1.200.2000017.1.F
CEC7.1®455D690AEO.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
373875.1.7B78A.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1(gI6
Is Inline fake
Type Me
Size 19384
CA 79aca28818ede9b19d69029534acab6f
Hash 8234B5707ED344E59D7D9F2FE61183223A1CF08.3 ADDF733CFC313101A72937BAA9052BD16
Recipients
Recipnt
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CADO•09CA-0000418F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type CC
Recipient I spe User
Recipient Aida Ler-coring
Display Name Aida Letienrmg
Email aleisenringlubarktersteiteom
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Distribution 'Espy CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID AB294985-IBAA-O000-B60A-A812D3F99FD4
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UND 79BA4F81-399A-0300-B60A-EIB48EDIFB51
Page 12479
Distribution Tye ('C
Recipient Ty User
Recipient MichaelBacivach
Display Name MichaelBachrach
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
LIVID 15A65810-0C33-0000a3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient tonyricco
Display Name tonyricco
Email
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box brit Inbox
Return notification "hen opened false
Return notification "hen deleted fake
Return notification "hen
completed !XL.:
Return notification "hen declined false
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D690AB3.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7B78A.1®1(7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.180.0.1.0.11
Source received
Class Pubhc
Account YMADMINYMDOM1
Location II) 15908426831386
Class Name OW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder MalLox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Maims
Type Melbas
System true
Share Type NotSbarcd
Page 12480
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019.09.062033!43 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-lebs.creGWOpenNodern-archivingeoM
ietmai
Gerrrated by Netrred Inc. [cn=Archive
_1-Daily Archivc3gcnt
Job.cn-Jobsrn-GWOpenNode.cn-archivinga
-netmad]
2020-0519153006 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXR DOM] Responsive
2020-05-19153531 EDT Tag BOP01703.frOCRADMI.NIXRIXMAI Responsive
2020-05-1914:4136 EDT Tag BOP01703.34)CRADMI.AINRIXRAI Fbggcd
Page 12481
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12482
From: Bruce Barket
To: ton ricco
Subject: Re: MCC conditions
Sent: Fri, 30 Aug 2019 15:37:43 +0000
I will try to hook you in once we hear from the government and get a time confirmed
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci NY 11530
-
-M
Barket Epstein.com
On Aug 30, 2019, at 11:09 AM, tonyricco ‹ > wrote:
i could do either time. i can be reached on my cellular phone.
tonyricco
Sent from my Verizon. Samsung Galaxy smartphone
From: iiii iSnessafe >
Date: 8/30/19 10:30 AM GMT-05:00
To: Bruce Barket
Cc: "tonyricco Aida Leisenrin
"MichaelBachrach
Subject: RE: MCC conditions
Good morning all,
Would 2 or 2:30 work? I am running around this morning, have a meeting at I, and am leaving at 3.
Thanks,
>>> ‹ > 8/29/2019 7:54 PM >»
Received.
Bruce,  would you all be free for a call tomorrow afternoon to discuss?
Thanks,
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
I St. Andrew's Plaza
New York, NY 10007
From: Bruce Barket < >
Sent: Thursda August 29 2019 5:25 PM
To: (0) O›;
Cc:
Subject: MCC conditions
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the facility.
Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it himself on August 15th. His
radio has needed batteries for several days. The guards simply refuse to provide him with the batteries and
new books he believes are in his property. Several guards have been making comments to him such as
"You're threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth his try" and similar remarks aimed at intimidating
him and conveying to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not staff in the lobby to process
legal visits. I was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't stay through the count so I had to leave before
9:30. I know I did not make an appointment but the issue wasn't a free room, but adequate staffing in the
lobby. Yesterday I was able to see my client at 5:00 as scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden City, NY 11530
[P] In
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If 
it is not clear that
you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error. any review, 
dissemination.
distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this 
communication in error.
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Re: New Wrden
From
To
Date 2019/11/05 13:12
Subject: Re: New Wrden
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
I heard nothing partictiar about MDC.
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York. NY 10007
From:
To:
Date: 11/05/2019 01:04 PM
Subject: Re: New Wrden
Thank you, Your Honor. I will certainly miss NYC!
I meant to ask, are there any inquiries for MDC to address tomorrow?
Thank you again,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
p:
f:
>>> `M e 11/1/2019 1:36 PM >>>
Congratulations! But it means you'll have to move to Philly. :-)
Page 12486
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
From:
To: "z >
Date: 11/01/2019 12:37 PM
Subject: Re: New Wrden
Thank you, Your Honor,
I have advised the Warden and he will be prepared to speak as to language issues in medical and
mental health. However, due to the ongoing outside investigation, we have no new information
as to the Epstein investigation. To our knowledge, the matter is still under review by FBI, OIG,
and the USAO.
I also wanted to let you know personally before announcing it to the group that I have been
selected as the incoming Deputy Regional Counsel for the Northeast Region in Philadelphia, PA,
starting December 9. I have greatly enjoyed working with you and your staff and hope that I
have been able to assist you when requested. I am sure my successor will continue to seek to
work with all the stakeholders in doing what is best for both the general public and the inmate
population.
B  .
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Er =
>» 11/1/2019 9:51 AM >>>
One other thing that you may be able to address (although this is more minor than the other issues): how
does the prison deal with prisoners who do not speak English when they need to see a
There is some interest in hearing what is going on with the Epstein suicide investigation, bit I suspect that
Page 12487
is something the Warden cannot discuss.
See you Wednesday.
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
From:
To:
Date: 11/01/2019 07:56 AM
Subject. Re. New Wrden
Good morning Your Honor,
My apologies, but I was out of the office unexpectedly yesterday due to a family emergency.
Warden and I will be in attendance at the CJAB next week. He indicates he will be
addressing the issues that have delayed the attorney visiting study, to include those related to the
union. He will also update the Court on the female unit at MCC. Please let us know if you need
anything else.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
Ncw York, New York 10007
p:=
>>> 10/31/2019 10:39 AM >»
Will your new warden be able to attend the CJAB meeting next week?
Page 12488
will you De attending! it so, would you like to give a over explanation or tne union issues associated witn
the attorney waiting times study?
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
Page 12489
Properties
Property Value
Nlessage 1 D 5DC17527.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 ED55.1
Message Path xmiNiaiboA5DC17527.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7ED55.1./mi
From
Display Name
Email
Reply To
Test
To
Subject Re: New Wrden
Scheduled date 2019.11.05 13:1032
Creation date 2019-11-05 13:1012
Modified date 2019.11.05 13:1232
Deli% end date 2019-11.05 131108
Message size 3885
Attachments sin 26930
Total size 30826
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.Inm
Content ID
5DC17527.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.203.2000006.1.E
6B32.1@45SDC17527.NYMDOM I.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.7ED55.1@l1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type fee
Size 9143
CA 61c11335f356c915ec If5e0d3811645a7
Hash DC5046O391C434DDCIEF30EC0F6EFE5B43BFC3B0 AFECD4E494F3A5AC5F66B1052CI3C52C
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5DC17527.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.X100006.1.E
6833.1(g451DC17527.NYMDOM I.NYMADMI. 100.1
373875.1.7ED55.1@l3.NYMDOM I.NYMADM 1.100 .0.1.0.1€616
Is Inline fake
Type it
Size 17787
CA ef8celd2142d5a2985bee2c0dle90931
Hash FB5F7DDCBF372O5D0304228D7AACC19146695235 OBBB58E820315E73DCF2F0637EABC09E
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CAD0-09CA-0300-A8F4-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nomul
Box type inbox
Return notification %%hen opened false
Return notification %%hen deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined false
Return notification %%hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DCI7527.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI. ma137387517 ED55.1@la.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1® 16
Source recentd
Class Public
Account NYMADM I.NYMDOM I
Page 12490
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1006
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System IllIC
Share Type NotShored
Page 12491
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-11-15 202732 EST Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodern-archivings,Arla_I-Daily
tetmai
Gerrrated by Netgovem [en-Archive
Archi.c3
Job.cn-Jobsrn-GWOpenNoiren-archhingr
-netmad]
2020-05-19153606 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.N1XR DOM] Responsive
2020-05-19153531 EDT Tag BOP01700.NOCRADMI.N1 Ni XRIX) 1 Responsive
2020-05-19 14:41:56 EDT Tag BOP0170334)CRADMI.AIRRIXRAI Fbgged
Page 12492
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12493
To:
Subject: Re: New Wrden
From:
Sent: Tue, 5 Nov 2019 13:10:52 -0500
I heard nothing particular about MDC.
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
From
To:
Date 11;052019 01.04 PM
Subject: Re: New Wrden
Thank you, Your Honor. I will certainly miss NYC!
I meant to ask, are there any inquiries for MDC to address tomorrow?
Thank you again,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
p:
>> > < 11/1/2019 I:36 PM >»
Congratulations! But it means you'll have to move to Philly. :-)
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
From
To:
Dater: 1 I/01 /2019 1217 PM
Subject: Re: New Wrden
Thank you, Your Honor,
I have advised the Warden and he will be prepared to speak as to language issues in medical and mental health. However,
due to the ongoing outside investigation, we have no new information as to the Epstein investigation. To our knowledge,
the matter is still under review by FBI, O1G, and the USAO.
I also wanted to let you know personally before announcing it to the group that I have been selected as the incoming 
Deputy
Regional Counsel for the Northeast Region in Philadelphia, PA, starting December 9. I have greatly enjoyed working with
you and your staff and hope that I have been able to assist you when requested. I am sure my successor will continue to
seek to work with all the stakeholders in doing what is best for both the general public and the inmate population.
liest
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York. New York 10007
p:
>>> < > 11/1/20199:51 AM >»
One other thing that you may be able to address (although this is more minor than the other issues): how does the prison
deal with prisoners
who do not speak English when they need to see a =?
There is some interest in hearing what is going on with the Epstein suicide investigation, but I suspect that is 
something the Warden cannot
discuss.
See you Wednesday.
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
From:
To:
Date: 11/01/2019 07$6 AM
Subject: Re: New Wrden
Good morning Your Honor,
My apologies, but I was out of the office unexpectedly yesterday due to a family emergency.
Warden and I will be in attendance at the CJAB next week. He indicates he will be addressing the issues that have
delayed the attorney visiting study, to include those related to the union. He will also update the Court on the female 
unit at
MCC. Please let us know if you need anything else.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York. New York 10007
>» <= > 10/31/2019 10:39 AM >»
Will your new warden be able to attend the CJAB meeting next week?
Will you be attending? If so, would you like to give a brief explanation of the union issues associated with the 
attorney waiting times study?
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
Fwd: Re: Interviews
From
To
Date 2019/08/16 13:43
Subject: Fwd: Re: Interviews
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Good afternoon,
Per the below, OIG would like to interview you regardin the incident last weekend involving EPSTEIN,
Jeffrey, reg. no. 76318-054. Please call Special Agent at at your convenience.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
p:
>>  > 8/16/2019 1:41 PM >> >
Per the attached OIG would like to interview the following staff members.
>»' . (OIG)" < > 8/16/2019 12:56 PM > »
Nurse
Sent from mobile device, please excuse typos.
Special Agent
Office of the Inspector General
1 Battery Park Plaza, 29th floor
New York NY 10004
Cell
Office
> On Aug 16, 2019, at 12:34 PM, > wrote:
> Medical Staff?
> >>> . (OIG)" < > 8/16/201911:25 AM >>>
Page 12497
> We are available at all times for the medical staff interviews today, if they are willing to agree to a
voluntary interview.
> Sent from mobile device, please excuse typos.
> Special Agent
> Office of the Inspector General
> 1 Battery Park Plaza, 29th floor
> New York, NY 10004
> Cell
Office
Page 12498
Properties
Property Value
Nlessage 1 D 5D56B316.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 ACCD.1
Message Path xmrfslatoW5D568316-NYMDOMI.NYMADMI,100 .1373875.1.7ACCD.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF3IEA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: Re: Interviews
Scheduled date 2019-08.1613:4330
Creation date 2019-08-161313330
Modified date 2019-08-20 I522H8
Delis end date 2019-08-16 134330
Message size 1465
Attachments sin 2218
Total size 3694
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TF—XT.hun
Content II)
5D56B316.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.203.20000A0.1.1
47B9A.1®45:5D56B316.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.
1373875.1.7ACCD.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline fahe
Type lie
Size 2218
Date 2019-08.1609:3:5
CA 6de611889624436786f8laW7070b74
Hash 7BAD25C628E7843BOBA40ACCFDCC444FF8991F78 El9A9F630D8IFIIDFAII33CD4FF679FE35A
Recipients 5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UU1D E6D79960-68FA-0072a44E-187277817742
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08-16134330
Opened 2019-08-16 13,4358
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UU1D C4367090-01_73-0000-BBEI-DODC22E57B2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 201908.1613x33:50
Opened 2019-08-1709:28:11
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID NXH3AC10-127B-0000-AE9F-BCB76461E958
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08.161313350
DownloadedByThirdParty 2019-08.191543:11
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UU1D 15A651.10-003-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delis e red 2019-08-1613:4330
Opened 2019-08-16 14:4543
Recipient
Display Name
Page 12499
Email
QUID 9E550EDO-OIDA-0000-87F5-92775C390IBF
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delisered 2019-0R-1613,330
Opened 2019-08.1613,359
Expire 0
Delay delivety until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened hue
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Sent hem;
Return notification "hen opened fake
Return notification "hen deleted fake
Return notification %%hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D56F1316.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 ACCD.1©1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMIAoctoto.i@i
Source sent
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMD0MI
Location II) 1540842683886
Class Name CAVMF:SSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Pokier Mailbox
II) 7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Matiox
Type Mayas
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12500
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23 20A123 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Job.cn-lebs.orGWOpenNodetn-archivingx,(APIU_
=netmai
Gerrrated by Netrm8 Inc. [cn=Archive
1 -Daily Archi.c3
Johen-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoie.cn-archivinga
mietrnail]
2019-09-16 152137 EDT Exported netina inetma allowed Exponed by netmainetmainetmail
2020-05-19 153432 EDT Tag BOP01703.NIXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
20260519 15:3421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:19 EDT Tag BOP01703.NOCRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbggcd
Page 12501
RE: Tartaglkione and MCC
From (USANYS)"
Aida Lciscnring, Bruce Barkct, To
Date 2019/08/26 17:24
Subject: RE: Tartaglkione and MCC
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Miinc.822
and I are available on Wednesday at 2:30 if that works.
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Monda A ust 26, 2019 3:06 PM
To:
Cc: Aida Leisenring <
Subject: Tartaglkione and MCC
(USANYS)
In a follow up to the Government's letter to the Court on Friday I am hoping there is a time this week
to discuss the conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione would agree to withdraw his request to be
moved from MCC.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
(Fl
www.barketepsteinsom
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have
received this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is
strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us
immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 12502
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D6415CA.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.13731375.1.7 B44D.1
Message Path nnVlsiatiox/5D6415CA.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7B44D.1.4m1
From (USANYS)"
Display Name (USANYS)"
Email
QUID AB2444985-1BAA-0000460A-A812D3F99FD4
Reply To
Text USANYS)"
To
Cc
Bruce Barker;
Aida Lcsennng
Subject RE: TungIcione and MCC
Scheduled date 2019-08-26 172338
Creation date 2019-08-26172338
Modified date 201948-26 183323
Delis end date 201448-26172427
Message size 1466
Attachments sin 15926
Total size 17403
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TF—XT.htm
Content II)
5D6415CA.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20(COOF2.1.6
625E.1(4)45:5D6415CA.NYMD0MLNYMADMI.100.1
373875.1.7644D.1(01:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1(416
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 4880
CA e7933dbc5f7cd46a68c715ee759a3a37
Hash EPAD891)3A60A07667C314FEDOD9EB151A6A1F29E 6A6DB835FD817727CC7131AD3E3FE339
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D6415CA.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000F2.1.6
625E1@453D6415CA.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.71)44D. 1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .01.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type Ile
Size 11046
CA c6367c6c476adb6b8419acc4398e38d8
Hash E2C1C7E4BFEF87A2FBWIDC740B935F235405A7A 6FAD9C54375022I3096249D152802B28E
Recipients 5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000a8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient AS Leisettring
Display Name tAEmail
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient Bruce Runt
Display Name Bruce Barket
Email
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Uscr
Recipient
Display Name
Email
llUID 79BA4F81.399A-00®-B60A-EIB48EDIFB51
Distribution Type TO
Recipient fype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Page 12503
HAD I5A65EI0-0C33-0000a3E7-68A6064I5CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read tnie
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification .hen opened false
Return notification. hen deleted fake
Return notification .hen
completed false
Return notification .hen declined fake
Return notification .hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D64I5CA.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 B44D.I®la.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.01.01@i
Source =cad
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 154X44.2683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder MalLox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMLI0D.0.10.1@l6
Name Mai=
Type Maim
System true
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 12504
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-06 210031 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Jobrn-lcbs.cieGWOpenNodern-archiviageoArla_I-Daily
ictmai
Gerrrated by Netrred Inc. [cn=Archive
Archive3
Job.cn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoietn—archivinga
—netmad]
202(-05-19153006 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 12505
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12506
From:
tr i Aida Leisenring
Subject: RE: Tartaglkione and MCC
Sent: Mon, 26 Aug 2019 21:23:58 +0000
and I are available on Wednesday at 2:30 if that works.
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket
Sent: Monda Au ust 26 2019 3:06 PM
To:
Cc: Aida Leisenring
Subject: Tartaglkione and MCC
In a follow up to the Government's letter to the Court on Friday I am hoping there is a time this week to discuss the 
conditions
under which Mr. Tartaglione would agree to withdraw his request to be moved from MCC.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden City, NY 11530
[F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If 
it is not clear that you are
the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, 
dissemination, distribution or
copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, 
please notify us immediately
by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Re: meeting wiht Nick 9-16-19 @ 8;00 a.m.
From
To Bruce Barkct,
Date 2019/09/1608:42
Subject: Re: meeting wiht Nick 9-16-19 @ 8;00 a.m.
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Good morning Bruce,
Unfortunately, if your client has a noon hearing tomorrow, the USMS are going to come pick him up first
thing. As such, it is doubtful he will be here past 7 or 8 am tomorrow. Bobbi is coming to see him around
noon today. Are you able to come with Bobbi or after the count?
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 9/15/2019 10:49 PM > »
I wasn't able to get to see Nick over the weekend so I have to seem tomorrow before court on Tuesday.
I hope that is ok. I will be at the facility by 8;00.
Thank you for the social visit on Friday. Nick and his mom are very grateful and I am glad that it was
accomplished before court. It will be very helpful to us.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[Pi [F]
www.barketeostein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 12508
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D7F4ADF.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.1373875.1.7 0432.1
Message Path xmliMato:A5D7F4ADF.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .1373875.1.7C432.1ami
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To Bruce Barket:
Subject Re: mcetmg win NO. 9-16-19(a 8:00 a.m.
Scheduled date 2019-09-160811206
Creation date 2019-09-16084206
Modified date 201909-I6 08:51134
Delivered date 20194391608:42117
Message sine 1423
Attachments size 3713
Total size 5147
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hlm
Content ID
5D7F4ADENVMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000A0.1.1
4A0134.1€455D7F4ADF.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.
1373875.1.7C432.1@/1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.10 0.0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 3713
Date 2019-09.1604#204
CA 042518488530beddc6d608291890652
Hash DO5EFF.6ECFFBOBOD75168CF2AB56406CF9515DBC 62FA6B6124B1041AEt4308723FA7lOCBE2
Recipients 2
Recipient Bruce Barket
Display Name Bruce Barket
Email
Distribution T)pe TO
Recipient 'rype User
Transferred 2019-09-1608:42119
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID I5A65E10-0C33-0000a3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient "Type spe User
Delivered 2019-09-16084207
Opened 2019-09.16085107
Expire 0
Delay delivery' until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed false
Security Norrnal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification sshen opened false
Return notification sshen deleted false
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification sshen declined false
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D7F4ADF.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7C4321@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1t1 I
Source sent
Class Public
Page 12509
Account I NYMADMLNYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mal=
II) 7.NYMDOMLNYMAD641.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Muffins
Type Maibox
System tme
Share Type NotShared
Page 12510
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-27 2122:18 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodern-archivings,Artn_I-Daily
se mi
Gerrrated by Netgovem [en-Archive
Archi.c3
Job.cn-Jobsrn-GWOpenNoiren—architingr
—netmail]
2020-05191531:14 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXR DOM] Responsive
2020-05-191532A2 EDT Tag BOP01700.MXRADMI.NIXRIX)hil Responsive
2020-0519143434 EDT Tag BOP0170334)CRADM I.AIXRIX)hil Fbgged
Page 12511
Re: Defense private investigator/permission to NiSit mcc
From Sarah Sacks
To Nicole McFarland
Date 2019/12/05 13:12
Subject: Re: Defense private investigator/permission to visit
mcc
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mimc.822
Thank you, I appreciate it and will get back with the form as soon as possible.
Sarah M. Sacks, Esq.
EPSTEIN SACKS PLLC
Office:
Mobile:
CONFIDENTIALITY: This email communication and any files transmitted with it may contain
privileged and confidential information and are intended solely for the use of the individuals or
entity to whom it has been addressed. If you have received this email in error, please delete it
and notify the sender by return email.
On Thu, Dec 5, 2019 at 1:09 PM •:z1 > wrote:
Hi Sarah,
Please have the PI fill out the application and NCIC form attached hereto starting aiSle will also
need to provide a copy of his PI license and certificate. Please email it back to Ms. , cc'ed, so
she can process it.
Thank you,
> » Sarah Sacks < > 12/5/201912:24 PM > »
Hi . I'm not sure if you've already relocated but I'm hoping you can help or redirect me to someone
who can. I have a private investigator we have appointed under CJA coming to visit our client from out
of town next week Monday and Tuesday. What do we need to do to get him permission to come in with
us for a legal visit? Thank you.
Sent from my iPhone
Page 12512
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5DI 90248.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.8 0586.1
Message Path smItsladban.SDE9024ENYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.80586.1.xml
From Sarah Sacks
Display Name Sarah Sacks
Email
Reply To
Text Sarah Sacks
To
Cc I i
Subject Re: Defense private nvesugatorlpemission to vii mcc
Scheduled date 2019-12-05 13:11:15
Creation date 2019-12-05 13:11:15
Modified date 2019-12-05 13:13:15
Delivered  date 2019-12-05 13:1241
Message size 1285
Attachments size 11675
Total size 12971
Attachments 2
Attachment TF-XT.htm
Name TEXT.hun
Content ID
5DE90248,NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000049.1.3
87DA. Ifii)455DE90248.NYMDOM 1.NYMADM 1.100. 1
373875.1.80586.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .01.0.1 ®16
Is Inline false
'Ewe file
Size 2116
CA c2d66258004a44667229f7d6dOdc0255
Hash 5A656C3626FFI7EEC3B058B9C2D47B2F9AB3419E AEDEF685A90958039FD5FOFBBEE9€41F
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5DE90248.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000049.1.3
87DB.1®453DE90248.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.80586.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Sim 9559
CA 46651d07042a0a4betrx1564d052bIldf
Hash 6F6F25CDD06466EDF6426668B50ABC1 I A86543D4 64B2AA 131B6AC49D157956B5B3EE6F15
Recipients 3
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-000OA8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
1:nuil
UUID 263DFECO-05FA-000D-B8E9-E3DDF99F0ABB
Distribution Type CC
Recipient "Ispe User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
WAD C4117510-04FF-00004331C-4A46EB8DCC96
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay de liver) until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read IRK
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed false
Page 12513
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification .hen opened false
Re turn notification 'hen deleted fake
Return notification %%hen
completed fake
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification .hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DE9024&NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.1373875.1.130586.I@I:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.01.0.1@1 6
Source received
Class Pubhe
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.01.0.1@l6
Name Maibox
Type Maibox
System tme
Share Type NotShared
Page 12514
Audits
DMe Action Auditor Note
2019-12-11 103038 EST Created
en=Arehive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archivc3.cn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNode.en-archic
ticngor  tinal
Generated by Netgowm Kr -Archive
Agent 2-Zer° Day
Archcelen-Jobs.err-GWOpenNode.cn-archn
ing.o-netmai]
2020-05-19 15:3006 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 12515
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12516
From: Sarah Sacks c >
Sent: Thu, 5 Dec 2019 13:11:15 -0500
Subject:
To:
Cc:
v ' • ' sion to visit mcc
Thank you, I appreciate it and will get back with the form as soon as possible.
Sarah M. Sacks, Esq.
EPSTEIN SACKS PLLC
Office:
Mobile:
CONFIDENTIALITY: This email communication and any files transmitted with it may contain privileged and
confidential information and are intended solely for the use of the individuals or entity to whom it has been addressed.
If
you have received this email in error, please delete it and notify the sender by return email.
On Thu, Dec 5, 2019 at 1:09 PM
Hi Sarah,
IcM . > wrote:
Please have the PI fill out the application and NCIC form attached hereto starting at p. 26. He will also need to 
provide a copy of
his PI license and certificate. Please email it back to Ms. , ceed, so she can process it.
Thank you,
>>> Sarah Sacks < > 12/5/2019 12:24 PM >>>
Hi . I'm not sure if you've already relocated but I'm hoping you can help or redirect me to someone who can. I have a 
private
investigator we have appointed under CIA coming to visit our client from out of town next week Monday and Tuesday. What 
do
we need to do to get him permission to come in with us for a legal visit? Thank you.
Sent from my iPhone
The Daily 202: Trump might win a Pyrrhic victory against Obamacare, as the balance of
judicial power shifts his way
From The Washington Post
To , The Washington Post
Date 2019/07,10 10:12
Subject: The Daily 202: Trump might win a Pyrrhic victory against Obamacare,
as the balance of judicial power shifts his way
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
If you're having trouble reading this click here.
The Daily 202
Share: Listen to The Big Idea
Trump might win a Pyrrhic victory against
Obamacare, as the balance of judicial
power shifts his way
People wait in line to enter the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit in New
Orleans on Tuesday to hear arguments on whether Congress effectively invalidated
the Affordable Care Act when it zeroed out the tax imposed on those who choose not
to buy insurance. (Gerald HerbertfAP)
BY JAMES HOHMANN
with Joanie Greve and Mariana Alfaro
THE BIG IDEA: Oral arguments in New Orleans on
Tuesday over the future of the Affordable Care Act
foreshadowed the massive impact that President
Trump's free rein to fill the courts with like-minded
• -I - •II A • •
Page 12518
juages win propaoly nave on American jurispruaence
over the next generation.
For now, Trump continues to suffer legal setbacks. In a
case involving his push to add a citizenship question to the
2020 Census, a district court judge rejected the Justice
Department's request to change out its team of lawyers.
Separately, an appellate court in New York upheld a lower
court's decision that it is unconstitutional for Trump to block
critics on Twitter because he's a public official who uses the
platform to communicate with constituents.
But the balance of power is changing on the courts each
week to become more favorable to Trump, and it sure
sounded like the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit
might be ready to uphold at least parts of a federal district
judge's decision in Texas that the entire 2010 health-care
law is unconstitutional because the 2017 GOP tax bill got rid
of the individual mandate to buy insurance. Two of the three
judges on the panel expressed skepticism during the oral
arguments that Obamacare can remain intact since the
mandate was how Chief Justice John justified
upholding the law in 2012.
Judge Kurt Engelhardt, whom Trump put on the bench just
last year, was the more outspoken of the two. He repeatedly
noted that the law was written without an explicit feature
guaranteeing that if one part were ever removed by
Congress or the courts, the rest would remain in place. He
suggested that it's the job of Congress to forge a solution.
He questioned whether the courts should be "taxidermist for Page 12519
every legislative big-game accomplishment that Congress
achieves." The judge who seemed to largely agree with him
was appointed by George W. Bush. A third judge, appointed
by Jimmy Carter, stayed silent during the 90-minute hearing,
per Amy Goldstein, who was in the courtroom for us.
Engelhardt was grilling attorneys representing Democratic
attorneys general and the Democratic House. Normally it
would have been Justice Department lawyers defending a
federal law, but the Trump administration is refusing to do so
and told the 5th Circuit this spring that the administration
agrees with the plaintiffs that it should be struck down.
If Trump gets what he's hoping for in New Orleans, there's a
strong argument to be made that the president will be like
the proverbial dog that catches up with the truck. Health care
— the issue that dogged Republican candidates in the 2018
midterms more than any other — would almost certainly take
a starring role in the 2020 campaign. The Supreme Court
would probably then hear an appeal, in which would
probably again cast a deciding vote — one way or another —
in June of an election year.
McConnell mum on whether he supports Trump-Obamacare lawsuit
-- Here are three telling illustrations of how the 5th
Circuit could hand Trump a Pyrrhic victory:

1) Despite a decade of efforts to kill Obamacare, Senate
Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) refused to
say yesterday whether he supports the suit to Page 12520
invalidate the law. "I think the important thing for the public
to know is there is nobody in the Senate not in favor of
covering preexisting conditions," he said at his weekly news
conference. "And if it were, under any of these scenarios, to
go away, we would act quickly on a bipartisan basis to
restore it."
Trump has had a historically large number of judicial
vacancies to fill during his first two-and-a-half years largely
because McConnell blocked consideration of so many of
Barack Obama's nominees once he seized control of the
Senate in 2015. It was not just Merrick Garland.

2) Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine), who cast a key vote
for the tax bill that could be used as a pretext by
judicial activists to repeal Obamacare, is trying to
distance herself from the lawsuit challenging the ACA.
She also voted to confirm Engelhardt to the 5th Circuit, in
addition to Justice Brett Kavanaugh. These votes could
imperil her reelection next year. She issued a statement
saying she opposes Trump's decision not to defend the
health-care law in court. "The Affordable Care Act remains
the law of the land, and it is the Department of Justice's duty
to defend it," Collins said.
3) "Democrats are savoring the moment," Paige
Winfield Cunningham reports in the Health 202. "They're
spending the week bludgeoning Republicans over the high-
stakes lawsuit, which they well know is prime fodder for
2020 attacks. The House Oversight Committee will hold a
Page 12521
hearing this morning dubbed The Trump Administration's
Attack on the ACA: Reversal in Court Case Threatens
Health Care for Millions of Americans,' where a number of
patients and consumers advocates will testify. The
Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, the
Democratic Attorneys General Association and the
Democrat-affiliated group Protect Our Care launched
hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of print and digital
ads around the country. Democrats in Congress delivered
floor speeches castigating their GOP colleagues. House
Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerry Nadler (D-N.Y.) said
he's also planning a hearing on the lawsuit."
-- As the judges in Louisiana considered the fate of
health care for millions of people, the Senate voted 53
to 45 on party lines to confirm another controversial
Trump nominee to the 9th Circuit, the court of appeals
that has most often drawn the president's ire. Hai*
Fuchs notes that Daniel Bress's confirmation gives Trump
his seventh judge on the historically liberal bench, which
now has 16 judges nominated by Democratic presidents and
12 by Republicans. The court still has one vacancy that
Trump plans to fill. Bress, who once clerked for the late
Antonin Scalia, was nominated to fill the vacancy left by •
Kozinski, whom Kavanaugh once clerked for and who
resigned in December 2017 amid allegations of sexual
misconduct.
SuhscrihP nn Arna7nn Fr.ho Gonnlp Home Annlp I-InmpPnel and
Page 12522
other podcast players.
Welcome to the Daily 202, PowerPost's morning
briefing for decision-makers.
Sign up to receive the newsletter.
WHILE YOU WERE SLEEPING:
British Ambassador Kim Darroch speaks at an afternoon tea hosted by the British
Embassy to mark Trump's inauguration in January 2017. (Paul Morigi/Getty Images)
-- British Ambassador Kim Darroch resigned from his
post this morning after three days of public attacks
from Trump, who was angry about leaked cables that
showed the diplomat privately described the president
as "inept" and "insecure." Jennifer Hassan reports:
"Trump blasted Darroch in a series of tweets this week,
calling him 'a pompous fool' and said his administration
would not work with him." In his resignation letter, Darroch
said the "current situation is making it impossible for me to
carry out my role as I would like. Although my posting is not
due to end until the end of this year, I believe in the current
circumstances the responsible course is to allow the
appointment of a new ambassador."
Page 12523
Federal Reserve Board Chair Jerome Powell speaks at a news conference in May.
(Patrick Semansky/AP)
-- Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has two
messages for Congress this morning: Central bank
independence is critical, and an interest -rate cut is
likely at the end of July. Heather Long got a first look at
his prepared testimony before the House Financial Services
Committee: "Since [June], it appears that uncertainties
around trade tensions and concerns about the strength of
the global economy continue to weigh on the U.S. economic
outlook. Inflation pressures remain muted," Powell will say.
The U.S. economy is doing "reasonably well," Powell will
add, but he notes that business investment has "slowed
notably," probably because of the uncertainty around trade
and global growth. He will also stress that the economic
gains have not been shared evenly by everyone. Hispanics,
African Americans and people in rural communities are
continuing to have a harder time finding jobs that pay well.
-- Reader feedback: Many of you, on the left and right,
emailed in response to yestefday's_Big Idea to say that
manufacturers should keep raising wages for workers
if they want to make their industry more appealing to
young people and close the skills gap. Readers wrote
that higher salaries would have a bigger impact than any
marketing campaign from a trade association in making the
sector more appealing.
Page 12524
A protester dressed as a character from "The Handmaid's Tale" walks back to her car
in May after participating in a rally against restrictions on abortion rights in
Montgomery, Ala. (Julie Bennett/Getty Images)
-- Support for legal abortion has hit a 24-year high as
more states pass severe restrictions on the procedure,
according to a new Washington Post-ABC News poll.
EmilyGuskin an_d Scott_Clementreport_"The Post-ABC poll
finds a 60 percent majority who say abortion should be legal
in most or all cases, up from 55 percent in a 2013 Post-ABC
poll, and tying the record high level of support from 1995.
The latest survey finds 36 percent say abortion should be
illegal in all or most cases, also tying a record low. A 41
percent plurality of Americans want their own state to avoid
making it either harder or easier for women to have access
to abortion. Fewer, 32 percent, say their states should make
it easier and fewer still, 24 percent say their states should
make it harder for women to have access to abortion....
Even within party ranks, allowing or banning abortion in all
cases is a minority position. Among Democrats, 77 percent
say abortion should be at least mostly legal, but just over 4 in
10 (42 percent) say it should be legal in all cases. Among
Republicans, 52 percent say it should be at least mostly
illegal, but fewer than a quarter, 22 percent, want it to be
illegal in all cases."
State Rep. Greg Murphy debates Joan Perry on the campus of Pitt Community
College. (Deborah Griffin/Greenville Daily Reflector/AP)
Page 12525
-- North Carolina state Rep. Greg Murphy won the
Republican primary for the state's reliably red 3rd
Congressional District, besting pediatrician Joan Perry
by 20 points in a special election. Felicia Sonmez reports:
"The race had been viewed by some as a test of women's
standing within the Republican Party. Perry had won the
endorsements of all 13 House Republican women and
received nearly $1 million in support from an outside group
created to boost female Republican House candidates. But
in the end, she was outflanked by Murphy, who was backed
by several House Republican heavyweights, including Reps.
Jim Jordan (Ohio) and Mark Meadows (N.C.)."
Joe Biden stops for ice cream in Iowa in April. (Melina Mara/The Washington Post)
-- Cashing in: Joe Biden, who continues calling himself
"Middle Class Joe" on the campaign trail, earned $15.6
million over the past two years. Matt Viser and Anu
Narayanswamy: "The vast majority of the former vice
president's income — which totaled $11 million in 2017 and
$4.6 million in 2018 — came from book payments and
speaking fees, according to newly released tax returns and
financial disclosure forms required of federal office-seekers.
All told, the Bidens made nearly five times more in the past
two years than the next- highest earner, Sen. Kamala D.
Harris (D-Calif.), who with her husband earned $3.3 million.
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-
Mass.) each took in about $1.7 million in family income. ...
Page 12526
ly. UI I IL.C, I IC I ICIJ UCI ICIIICU HUH CV I CApILJJILA I UI
wealth. He gave 47 speeches, according to the new filings,
with fees as high as $234,000. His speaking fees and book
payments amounted to $10 million in 2017 and $3.2 million
in 2018. Biden was also a professor at the University of
Pennsylvania, where he was paid $371,159 in 2017 and
$405,368 in 2018."
Shane Bieber of the Indians pitches for the American League last night at Progressive
Field in Cleveland. (Jason Miller/Getty Images)
-- On the strength of its pitchers, the American League
will get home-field advantage in the World Series after
a 4-3 win in the All-Star Game. Dave Sheinen reports from
Cleveland: "Perhaps someone sneaked into the bowels of
Progressive Field on Tuesday and replaced the regular,
turbocharged 2019 baseballs with century-old versions from
the Dead Ball Era. How else to explain — in the midst of the
biggest home run binge in the history of the sport, one year
after the most homers ever hit in an All-Star Game and one
night after the most electrifying performance in the history of
the Home Run Derby — the relatively pedestrian showing in
this year's Midsummer Classic? There is one other possible
explanation, of course, and it is the one, conspiracy theories
aside, that will have to suffice: There are great pitchers
scattered across this game (shellshocked as they may be by
the nightly home run binges), and on Tuesday night they
shone brightest. ... The victory was the seventh in a row by
the AL, its 14th in the past 17 and 19th in the past 23 All-
Page 12527
Star Games."
MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred denied
yesterday that the league has knowingly "juiced"
baseballs to increase the number of home runs this
season, despite mounting complaints from pitchers.
Manfred attributed the spike in homers to naturally occurring
variances in manufacturing baseballs and vowed
transparency as officials move to correct the problem,
per Sheinin.
Perot in 1992 warned NAFTA would create 'giant sucking sound'
GET SMART FAST:

1. Ross Perot, the Texas billionaire who waged two
unsuccessful bids for president as an independent,
died at 89. Perot was lauded for starting two software
companies that later sold for billions, and his reputation
as a successful entrepreneur helped him attract nearly
20 million votes in 1992 — marking the highest vote
share for an independent or third-party bid since
Theodore Roosevelt and ultimately contributing to Bill
Clinton's victory. (Donald P. Baker)

2. Virginia's GOP-controlled General Assembly ended
a special session on gun legislation after about 90
minutes. The Virginia Senate voted along party lines to
adjourn until after the state legislative elections this
Page 12528
November, and the House quickly tollowed suit. I he
Republican House speaker accused Democratic Gov.
Ralph Northam (D) of an "election-year stunt" for
ordering the special session shortly after the May 31
mass shooting in Virginia Beach. (Gregory S.
Schneid_er,_Laura Vozzella_and Antonio Olivo)

3. Democratic megadonor Ed Buck is facing
allegations of human trafficking and revenge porn
months after he came under fire when two black
men died from overdoses in his home. Buck is now
facing two more charges in an ongoing case brought by
the mother of one of the two men who died in his West
Hollywood apartment. (The Daily Beast)

4. A Republican candidate for Mississippi governor,
Foster, refused to allow a female reporter to
travel with him alone because of her gender.
Foster's campaign told journalist Larrison Campbell she
would need to be accompanied by a male colleague if
she wanted to go on a 15-hour trip with the candidate,
saying the "optics" of the candidate with a woman could
be used to insinuate an extramarital affair. (Mississippi
Today)

5. A Senate bill would block federal funding for the
2026 World Cup until the U.S. Soccer Federation
agrees to give the national women's and men's
teams the same compensation. The proposal by Sen.
Joe Manchin Ill (D-W.Va.) comes after the women won
the World Cuo this weekend as the crowd chanted. Page 12529
"Equal pay!" (Des Bieler)

6. An inspector general report accuses the hospice
industry of repeatedly ignoring patients' pain and
needs. One particularly grisly example recounted how a
patient in Missouri was so neglected that his family had
to make a trip to the emergency room to treat a "maggot
infestation" where his feeding tube entered his
abdomen. (Chris1:mt land)

7. Electric scooters have spread to several European
capitals, where they are sparking the same
complaints heard on this side of the Atlantic. The
mayor of Paris condemned the scooters as causing "not
far from anarchy" on the city's roads, and residents of
Berlin have complained of drunk riders and at least one
instance of a man trying to access a high-speed
motorway on his e-scooter. (Rick Noack)

8. Pig-ear dog treats were recalled in 33 states
because of a potential salmonella contamination,
the FDA announced. The treats, which were sold in
bins at Pet Supplies Plus stores in the states, are
believed to be linked to an outbreak of human salmonella
infections. (USA Today)

9. A rare polio -like illness marked by muscle
weakness or paralysis affected 233 people in 2018,
the majority of them children. The CDC said the
number of recorded acute flaccid myelitis cases last
Page 12530
yCcIl I I IdUC IL LI IC VVOI bl yccii JII iuc LI IC yuvci I it ici IL
started tracking the illness in 2014. (Philadelphia
Inquirer)
10. A man who was swept over the largest waterfall at
Niagara Falls survived. Reports of the incident
sent Niagara Parks Police scrambling to get to the
waterfalls early Tuesday morning, where they found the
man with non-life-threatening injuries. (Allyson Chiu)
Trump says he feels 'very badly' for Acosta on Epstein link
THE #M ETOO RECKONING:
-- Trump is standing by his embattled labor secretary,
saying he feels "very badly" for Acosta, as
Democratic calls mounted for Acosta's resignation
over the generous plea deal he struck with financier
Jeffrey Epstein when he was a federal prosecutor.
Trump said the White House will look closely at the
circumstances surrounding the sex-charges deal negotiated
by Acosta. "I feel very badly, actually, for Secretary Acosta
because I've known him as being somebody who works so
hard and has done such a good job," the president told
reporters in the Oval Office.
-- Acosta broke his silence and defended himself on
Twitter: "The crimes committed by Epstein are horrific, and
I am pleased that NY prosecutors are moving forward with a
case based on new evidence," he wrote, suggesting that
prosecutors have new evidence he did not when he was
Page 12531
IVIICII I II V.J. CHAU! I my.
-- Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi called on Acosta
to step down, as did most of the 2020 Democratic
candidates. "Congressional Republicans supported Acosta,
saying issues about the plea deal were vetted at his
confirmation hearing in 2017. Acosta's critics said he was
not fit to lead an agency that has oversight over human
trafficking offenses," John Wagner and Lisa Rein report.
"Some attorneys for victims questioned Acosta's tweet
saying the evidence was new."
-- Acting White House chief of staff Mick Mulvaney is
privately urging Trump to dump Acosta, Politico's Eliana
and Burgess Everett report: "Acosta critics,
including Mulvaney, have argued that he has not been
aggressive enough in stamping out Obama-era workplace
regulations and employment discrimination lawsuits, and
they are using the Epstein lawsuit to push him out the door.
Mulvaney on Tuesday acknowledged the tension with Acosta
but said it was merely part of the job. 'I push all of the
Cabinet Secretaries on the deregulatory agenda, as it is a
top priority of the President,' Mulvaney said in a statement.
... One move that has particularly rankled conservatives is
Acosta's decision to allow an employment discrimination
lawsuit to proceed against Oracle, the rare Silicon Valley
company that is not entirely hostile to the GOP."
Democrats demand Acosta resign over Epstein deal
-- The Justice Department said Attorney General
Page 12532
William Barr will not recuse himself from the current
prosecution of Epstein, but he will not engage in "any
retrospective review" of the 2008 plea deal. Matt
Zapotos_ky reports: "Barr had telegraphed at his confirmation
hearing in January that he might have to step aside from any
Justice Department reviews of Epstein's case, because
another lawyer at his then-firm, Kirkland & Ellis, had
represented the wealthy financier. The other lawyer, Jay P.
Lefkowitz, helped secure [the previous deal]. The split nature
of Barr's recusal suggests that federal prosecutors in New
York — who unsealed new sex trafficking charges against
Epstein on Monday — might not be investigating authorities'
handling of the previous allegations. The Justice
Department's Office of Professional Responsibility has been
reviewing the handling of Epstein's 2008 plea deal for
possible misconduct, and Barr is recused from that."
-- The Miami Herald has reported  that Lefkowitz, Barr's
colleague at the time, had a one-on-one meeting with
Acosta at which the then-U.S. attorney agreed not to
prosecute Epstein in federal court.
-- Epstein amassed a network of powerful connections
as authorities say that he was simultaneously abusing
dozens of young girls. Marc Fisher reports: "Even as
dozens of women were looking to police, prosecutors and
courts to hold Epstein to account for his alleged sexual
abuses, he was amassing a stunning list of contacts and, in
some cases, defenders across the worlds of Hollywood
moviemaking, medical research, diplomacy, finance, politics
Page 12533
ana law. ... he donated large sums toward neuroscience
research at Harvard and a California lab. He invited
researchers to his New York house and talked math with
them over equations scrawled on a blackboard in his dining
room. He flew former president Bill Clinton and actor
Spacey to Africa to promote AIDS awareness. He was a
member of the Trilateral Commission and the Council on
Foreign Relations."
-- The criminal case against Epstein had gone cold, but
Miami Herald reporter Julie Brown kept pursuing the
story and forced authorities to pay attention. The
Times's Tiffany Hsu reports: "Months ago, she published a
meticulously researched series of articles about the secret
plea deal. ... Her work identified some 80 alleged victims ...
She worked on the award-winning series with Emily Michot,
a visual journalist at The Herald. While Mr. Epstein moved
about freely, reportedly building a new compound in the
Virgin Islands, Ms. Brown continued to dig, accumulating
enough documentation to fill a spare bedroom in her Florida
home. ... Geoffrey Berman, a federal prosecutor, said at a
news conference that his team had been 'assisted by some
excellent investigative journalism.-
-- Trump once threw a party with "28 girls" at Mar-a-
Lago. He and Epstein were the only men there. The
Times's Annie Karni and Maggie Haberman dig into the
relationship', "The year was 1992 and the event was a
'calendar girl' competition, something that George Houraney,
a Florida-based businessman who ran American Dream
Page 12534
miierpr lbe, MAU oryarliceu dl WU. I rumps request.
arranged to have some contestants fly in,' Mr. Houraney
recalled in an interview on Monday. 'At the very first party, I
said, 'Who's coming tonight? I have 28 girls coming.' It was
him and Epstein.' Mr. Houraney, who had just partnered with
Mr. Trump to host events at his casinos, said he was
surprised. 'I said, 'Donald, this is supposed to be a party
with V.I.P.s. You're telling me it's you and Epstein?" In fact,
that was the case, an indication of a yearslong friendship
between the president and Mr. Epstein that some say ended
only after a failed business arrangement between them....
"The full nature of their eventual falling out is not clear.
... The relationship with Mr. Trump turned so toxic that Mr.
Epstein at one point told friends that he blamed Mr. Trump
for his legal problems with the Palm Beach County police.
But while Mr. Trump has dismissed the relationship, Mr.
Epstein, since the election, has played it up, claiming to
people that he was the one who introduced Mr. Trump to his
third wife, Melania Trump, though neither of the Trumps has
ever mentioned Mr. Epstein playing a role in their meeting."
Trump says he had a 'falling out with Epstein years ago
SELECTIVE AMNESIA:
-- Trump has a pattern of quickly minimizing ties with
people who criticize him or who find themselves facing
an onslaught of negative attention that reflects poorly
on him. Epstein and Darroch are only the two latest
examples. Josh Dawsey reports: "Trump sat across from
Page 12535
Darroch during the annual St. Patrick's Day lunch on Capitol
Hill in March, inquiring about Brexit and bragging of his
strong political standing. ... Trump interacted with Darroch
on a number of occasions in London and Washington....
But after leaked cables showed Darroch criticizing Trump's
administration as 'inept' and the president as 'insecure,' the
president seemed to have a memory lapse. 'I don't know the
Ambassador but have been told he is a pompous fool,'
Trump wrote Tuesday on Twitter. ... Asked Tuesday about
Epstein, Trump said that he was 'not a fan' of his. ... 'I don't
think I've spoken to him for 15 years,' Trump said. In a 2002
interview with New York Magazine before Epstein was in
trouble, Trump sang a different tune. 'I've known ■ for 15
years. Terrific guy. He's a lot of fun to be with. It is even said
that he likes beautiful women as much as I do, and many of
them are on the younger side,' Trump said....
"Among those who have gotten the 'I barely know the
guy' treatment: Former acting attorney general Matthew
G. Whitaker, conservative commentator Ann Coulter,
former lawyer Michael Cohen, fired FBI director James B.
Comey, former senior White House aide Stephen K.
Bannon, former campaign chairman Paul Manafort, former
State Department official Brett McGurk, longtime adviser
Roger Stone, former White House aide Cliff Sims, former
campaign aide George Papadopoulos and even the rapper
Lil Jon, who starred on Trump's reality TV show 'Celebrity
Apprentice.' The people change, but the comments are
eerily similar — and are something of a joke among some
Trump advisers."
Page 12536
-- He is the do-as-I-say, not -as-I-do president: Trump
attacked the "Radical Left" last night for encouraging
boycotts against companies whose owners support
him, even though he has repeatedly advocated the
exact same tactic in the past against his perceived
critics. Trump was rallying to the defense of Home Depot
and its co-founder, Bernard Marcus, who have been at the
center of a boycott from liberal customers after the billionaire
said he plans to spend part of his fortune supporting
Trump's 2020 campaign.
"Among the companies he has targeted are Macy's,
which once carried his clothing line but abandoned him after
he called Mexicans `rapists' in his campaign kickoff speech
in 2015, and Apple, which he urged to release the cellphone
information of the perpetrators of the 2015 shooting in San
Bernardino, Calif.," Isaac Stanley-Becker recalls. "Last year,
he celebrated plans to boycott Harley-Davidson when the
motorcycle company said it would move some production
overseas because of steel tariffs imposed by the president.
He has also implored his Twitter followers to boycott Megyn
Kelly's show on Fox News and suggested that dropping
AT&T could compel CNN to improve its coverage of him.
The president has argued that Nike and the NFL would
encounter `anger and boycotts' as long as they support
players who kneel during the national anthem to protest
police brutality and racial injustice. He struck a different tone
on Tuesday, saying it was unfair to penalize a company
because one of its co-founders supported `your favorite
Page 12537
President, me!'"
Sater offers few details after House panel appearance
THERE'S STILL A BEAR IN THE WOODS:
-- A congressional panel grilled former Trump
associate Felix Sater for more details on the
president's failed Moscow project. Karoun Demirjian and
Tom Hamburger report: "Sater met privately with House
Intelligence Committee staffers investigating interference in
the 2016 presidential election and questions surrounding
Trump's business interests in Russia in 2016. At issue is
Michael Cohen's false testimony before the same committee
in 2017 and whether Trump was compromised by his
organization's effort to build in Moscow. When pressed
Tuesday to provide information about his knowledge of
Cohen's testimony, Sater at one point cited lawyer-client
privilege and declined to respond, according to accounts of
the exchange described by Sater's attorney and a
spokesman for the committee."
-- Federal prosecutors no longer want Michael Flynn to
testify against his former partner because they doubt
his version of events, according to a court filing.
Rachel Weiner reports: "The move could have implications
for Flynn in D.C. federal court, where he is awaiting
sentencing in a case brought by the special counsel....
Flynn had been expected to be a key witness in the Virginia
trial of Bijan Rafiekian, with whom he ran a consulting
business. A court filing from Rafiekian's attorneys includes Page 12538
an email that Assistant U.S. Attorney James P. Gillis ended
by saying prosecutors `do not necessarily agree' with Flynn's
'characterizations' of how he came to make an inaccurate
filing under the Foreign Agent Registration Act for an
influence campaign that benefited the Turkish
government. According to the email, Flynn says he did not
provide false information to his attorneys at the time, did not
read the FARA filing before signing it and was not aware
that it contained falsehoods. In their filing, Rafiekian's
lawyers say they 'interpreted the email's final sentence as a
euphemism for, `we've concluded [Flynn] is lying.'
"The decision by prosecutors could imperil Flynn's
ability to avoid incarceration for lying to the FBI unless
he is pardoned by Trump. Flynn's defense attorney,
Sidney Powell, said in a statement that 'General Flynn is still
cooperating with the government even if they don't call him
as a witness.'"
-- The Justice Department directed two former
members of Mueller's team, Aaron Zebley and James

L. Quarles, not to testify before Congress. The Times's
Nicholas Fandos and Katie Benner report: "It is unclear what
effect the Justice Department's intervention will have on the
men's eventual appearances, but it raises the prospect that
a deal lawmakers thought they had struck last month for
testimony from Mr. Mueller, the former special counsel, and
the two prosecutors could still unravel. Both Mr. Zebley and
Mr. Quarles have left the Justice Department and are now
private citizens, meaning that the department most likely
Page 12539
cannot actually block their testimony. But the department's
view — depending on how strongly it is expressed — could
have a chilling effect on two longtime employees and give
them cover to avoid testifying."
-- The House Judiciary Committee will vote tomorrow
on whether to subpoena 12 individuals with
connections to Trump, including Jared Kushner and
Jeff Sessions, for their investigation on whether the
president obstructed justice. Colby Itkowitz reports: "The
panel will also vote to subpoena documents related to the
Trump administration's zero tolerance policy on migrants
entering the country illegally, which led to the separation of
thousands of children from their parents in 2018. ... In
addition to seeking subpoenas for Kushner and Sessions,
the committee will vote to subpoena former White House
chief of staff John Kelly; [Flynn]; former Trump campaign
manager Corey Lewandowski; former deputy attorney
general Rod J. Rosenstein; former White House deputy
chief of staff Rick Dearborn; assistant attorney general Jody
Hunt; former White House staff secretary Rob Porter;
National Enquirer editor Dylan Howard; American Media Inc.
chief executive David Pecker; and Keith Davidson, former
attorney for adult-film star Stormy Daniels."
-- Ahead of the former special counsel's testimony next
week, many lawmakers admit that they have not read
Mueller's report in full. Politico's Darren Samuelsohn
reports: "Trump can't give a straight answer about the
subject. More than a dozen members of Congress readily
Page 12540
admitted ... that they too have skipped around rather than
studying every one of the special counsel report's 448
pages. And despite the report technically ranking as a best-
seller, only a tiny fraction of the American public has actually
cracked the cover and really dived in. `What's the point?'
said Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.). ... The result, say
lawmakers, historians and cultural critics, is a giant literacy
gap in the country when it comes to the most authoritative
examination into Russian interference in the 2016
presidential election and whether Trump obstructed that
investigation."
Pelosi said she will not address "anything more that
[Barr] has to say" because he "has lied to Congress."
Pelosi's comments came a day after the attorney general
accused Democrats of trying "to create some kind of public
spectacle" by calling for Mueller to publicly testify next week.
"I don't even want to address him," Pelosi said in response.
"He has lied to Congress as the attorney general of the
United States. He's lied under oath. I'm not speaking to
anything more that he has to say." (John Wagner)
-- Russian intelligence agents appear to have been the
first people to promote the conspiracy theory that DNC
staffer Seth Rich was killed by assassins working for
Hillary Clinton. Yahoo News's Michael Isikoff reports:
"Russia's foreign intelligence service, known as the SVR,
first circulated a phony `bulletin' — disguised to read as a
real intelligence report —about the alleged murder of the
former DNC staffer on July 13, 2016, according to the U.S.
Page 12541
federal prosecutor who was in charge of the Rich case. That
was just three days after Rich, 27, was killed in what police
believed was a botched robbery while walking home to his
group house in the Bloomingdale neighborhood of
Washington, D.C., about 30 blocks north of the Capitol. ...
In a graphic example of how fake news infects the internet,
those precise details popped up the same day on an
obscure website, whatdoesitmean.com, that is a frequent
vehicle for Russian propaganda. The website's article, which
attributed its claims to `Russian intelligence,' was the first
known instance of Rich's murder being publicly linked to a
political conspiracy."
-- Christopher Steele, the author of the dossier, was
interviewed for 16 hours last month as part of the
investigation by Michael Horowitz, the Justice
Department's inspector general. Politico's Natasha
Bertrand reports: "The extensive, two-day interview took
place in London while Trump was in Britain for a state visit,
[two] sources said, and delved into Steele's extensive work
on Russian interference efforts globally, his intelligence-
collection methods and his findings about Trump campaign
adviser Carter Page, who the FBI ultimately surveilled. ...
The interview was contentious at first, the sources
added, but investigators ultimately found Steele's
testimony credible and even surprising. The takeaway
has irked some U.S. officials interviewed as part of the
probe — they argue that it shouldn't have taken a foreign
national to convince the inspector general that the FBI acted
properly in 2016."
Page 12542
After crossing the Rio Grande from Mexico into the United States on June 13, Karla
Yadira Rivera, 36, cries as she walks to Border Patrol agents with her daughters
Karla, 11; Andrea, 12; and Emilia, 17, in El Paso. (Carolyn Van Houten/The
Washington Post)
THE IMMIGRATION WARS:
-- Border arrests are dropping as Mexico's crackdown
on migrants takes effect. Nick Miroff reports: "The number
of people taken into custody along the U.S. southern border
fell 28 percent in June, a drop that U.S. authorities say
reflects the early impact of Mexico's crackdown on Central
American migration. Border crossings typically rise in the
spring and slump during the scorching summer months, but
the drop registered from May to June was significantly larger
than in previous years, according to Homeland Security
statistics."
-- Migrant children in an overcrowded detention center
in Yuma, Ariz., are making sexual assault allegations
and saying they fear retaliation from U.S. agents when
they complain about poor treatment. NBC News's Jacob
Soboroff and Julia Ainsley_report: "A 16-year-old
Guatemalan boy held in Yuma, Arizona, said he and others
in his cell complained about the taste of the water and food
they were given. The Customs and Border Protection agents
took the mats out of their cell in retaliation, forcing them to
sleep on hard concrete. A 15-year-old girl from Honduras
described a large, bearded officer putting his hands inside Page 12543
her bra, pulling down her underwear and groping her as part
of what was meant to be a routine pat down in front of other
immigrants and officers. The girl said `she felt embarrassed
as the officer was speaking in English to other officers and
laughing' during the entire process, according to a report of
her account."
-- California became the first state to offer health
benefits to adult undocumented immigrants. NPR's
Bobby Allyn reports: "The measure signed by Gov. Gavin
Newsom on Tuesday extends coverage to low-income,
undocumented adults age 25 and younger for the state's
Medicaid program. Since 2016, California has allowed
children under 18 to receive taxpayer-backed healthcare
despite immigration status. And, state officials expect that
the plan will cover roughly 90,000 people. ... In California,
extending health benefits to undocumented immigrants is
widely popular. A March survey conducted by the
nonpartisan Public Policy Institute of California found that
almost two-thirds of state residents support providing
coverage to young adults who are not legally authorized to
live in the country."
-- Two active -duty Marines were arrested for allegedly
trying to smuggle three undocumented Mexican
immigrants through California. Meagan Flynn reports:
"Lance Cpls. Byron Darnell Law II and David Javier Salazar-
Quintero, based in Camp Pendleton, Calif., were arraigned
Monday in federal court on charges of transporting
undocumented immigrants `for financial gain,' accused of
Page 12544
taking jobs from `recruiters' and following instructions from
unknown people in Mexico to make extra cash on the side.
They are among several active-duty U.S. troops charged or
convicted in recent years of helping immigrants cross the
border in exchange for money, highlighting how smugglers
have sought to offer the shield of a uniform or credentials to
assist desperate immigrants on the journey north."
Footage shows hate crime being committed at Glenelg High School
THE BLACK EXPERIENCE IN AMERICA:
-- "A black_principal,Joiir white teens and the `senior
prank' that became a hate crime,"  by Jessica Contrera:
"This was the last day of the year for the class of 2018 at
Glenelg High School. There was going to be an awards
ceremony, a picnic, that end-of-a-journey feeling that always
made [Principal David Burton] so proud of his job. But as he
was on his way to work at 6:25 a.m., the assistant principal
had called, agitated and yelling about graffiti. 'It's
everywhere,' he kept saying, so Burton had leaned on the
gas and rushed the last few miles. ... He turned a corner
and saw something written in large capital letters on the
sidewalk: `BURTON IS A NIGGER.' He paused only for a
moment, looking at the words, trying to comprehend that all
of this was real. Later, school district officials, county
administrators and prosecutors would have a name for what
happened here. They would repeat it, condemn it and vow to
prevent it from occurring again. Hate crime."
-- A white man who called 911 on a black man in his Page 12545
building apologized for his actions, explaining that
they were informed by a tragic family history — his
father was murdered after confronting a mentally ill
man who showed up on his driveway. The man,
Christopher Cukor, called the cops on Wesly Michel, a man
who was going up to a friend's apartment in the same
building without using the call box. The video of their
encounter went viral online. (Eli Rosenberg)
-- Elijah Al-Amin, a black teenager, was stabbed to
death at a convenience store in Arizona by a white
man, allegedly because he was playing rap music in
his car. The man, Michael Adams, stabbed the 17-year-old
two days after Adams was released from prison, where he
had completed a sentence for assault and theft. (NBC
News)
-- The Chicago Defender, the legendary newspaper
read by generations of black Americans, printed its
final copy. The newspaper will cease its print editions after
today but will continue its digital operation. (New York
Times)
-- A graphic artist who went viral for calling out
Google's lack of a doodle celebrating Juneteenth was
contacted by the search giant about a job. Davian
Chester created his own Google doodle to celebrate the
holiday marking the end of slavery, which quickly spread
across social media and attracted the company's interest.
Chester said he is still in talks with Google about the job, but
Page 12546
in the meantime, his hometown of Columbus, Ga., has put
up a billboard of the doodle. (Allison Klein)
Tom Steyer: 'Fundamental Change' I Campaign 2020
2020 WATCH:
-- Billionaire activist Tom Steyer formally entered the
Democratic presidential primary with an announcement
video outlining his pledges to reduce corporations'
political influence and address climate change. Chelsea
Janes reports: "In January, when he announced he would
not run for president, Steyer said that rather than entering
the race he would turn his attention fully to pressuring
members of Congress to start impeachment proceedings
against [Trump]. ... On Tuesday, as he announced his
presidential bid, Steyer did not mention impeachment or
Trump, although the president was briefly seen in the video.
Trump's former campaign chairman, Paul Manafort, was
also seen in the video being led down a hallway in
handcuffs. ... Steyer will have one week to accumulate
65,000 donors to qualify for the second Democratic debate,
which will take place at the end of the month."
Biden told a voter he'll "go further" than cutting
incarceration by 50 percent. BuzzFeed News's Katherine
Miller reports: "In a video shared ... by the ACLU, Biden tells
a man, Keith Albert, who identifies himself as an ACLU
voter, that he'd 'go further than' cutting incarceration by half.
'Would you commit to cutting incarceration by 50%?' Albert
asks Biden. 'More than that. We can do it more than that,' he Page 12547
responds. Last month in Concord, New Hampshire, another
self-identified ACLU voter asked if Biden would 'commit to
cutting the prison population overall, and specifically the
federal prison population, in half' — a slightly different
wording."
-- CNN announced its rules for the next Democratic
presidential debates. From CNN's Mark Preston: "The
upcoming Democratic presidential debates will feature
opening and closing statements and two hours of debate
time each night ... While candidates will not officially learn if
they make the Detroit stage until July 17, Tuesday's call with
the 20-plus Democratic campaigns was held to help them
prepare for the debate should their respective candidates
qualify, a CNN spokesperson said." The rules include:

• Colored lights will be used to help candidates manage
their remaining response times.
• A candidate attacked by name by another candidate will
be given 30 seconds to respond.

• There will be no show of hands or one-word questions.
• A candidate who constantly interrupts others will have
their time reduced.
• Questions posed by moderators will appear on the
screen for viewers.
-- The DNC announced that the third debate, which will
be hosted by ABC News and Univision, will be held in
Houston.
rInrrinnr•ifc .nre f"niicrAel r•rt
Page 12548
-- Licit I IVGI GlJ (AI c II IGI GGJII luly I V....ILA ..7G%A WI I VC...II CI CAy II IU
Mitch McConnell as a villain in a bid to win back the
Senate and energize liberals. Costa reports: "That
effort gained new momentum on Tuesday as Amy McGrath,
a retired Marine lieutenant colonel and combat pilot,
announced she would challenge McConnell (R-Ky.) and
blamed him for turning Washington into 'something we
despise' in a campaign video that drew millions of views.
While McGrath faces a steep climb against McConnell in
ruby-red Kentucky, which President Trump carried by 30
percentage points in 2016, she is expected to raise
significant funds from national Democrats and provide the
party with a relentless and high-profile opponent."
-- Though Sen. Pat (R-Kan.) won't make an
endorsement in the Republican primary race to replace
him, he said former Kansas secretary of state Kris
Kobach faces a "very difficult" path to the Senate. The
Kansas City Star's Bryan Lowry reports: "'It seems to me if
you have just lost a statewide race, that the chances of you
winning another statewide race would be very difficult,'
told reporters. 'I have not talked to Kris about this. I
did talk to him earlier, but that was all about allegedly being
the head of DHS. But the votes weren't there.' ... Kobach's
campaign manager Steve Drake rejected ' analysis
of the race and also hit back against the criticism from
national Republicans. ... Kobach's entry could ramp up
efforts to recruit Secretary of State Pompeo into the
race."
The RN( is threatpninn to withhniri siinnort frnm Page 12549
candidates who refuse to use the party's newly
established online fundraising tool, WinRed, as
tensions over the future of the party's grass -roots
fundraising efforts reach a breaking point. Politico's.
Isenstadt reports: "The moves illustrate how Republican
leaders are waging a determined campaign to make WinRed
the sole provider of its small donor infrastructure — and to
torpedo any competitors. On Monday, the RNC sent an
eight-page cease-and-desist letter to Paul Dietzel, a
Republican digital strategist who earlier this month launched
Give.GOP, a fundraising platform that includes a directory
through which donors can give to party candidates and
organizations. In the letter, RNC chief counsel Justin Riemer
writes that while Give.GOP has a page inviting donors to
give to the RNC, the committee hasn't yet received any
funds from the platform or received any outreach from it.
Riemer also accuses Dietzel of using the committee's
trademark and logo without its permission."
-- Sarah McBride, a transgender activist who made
waves after speaking at the Democratic National
Convention in 2016, is now running for Delaware state
Senate. Deanna Paul reports: "If she wins the 2020 race to
succeed Sen. Harris McDowell, who is retiring at the end of
his term, McBride will be the state's first elected transgender
senator. ... Now serving as national press secretary for the
Human Rights Campaign, the nation's largest LGTBQ
lobbying group, she has continued to be a force for the
movement through the Trump-Pence administration, which
-I I -.A --./ .-,..-4.: I C, 1-1 -1- /1
Page 12550
bl IC UellICU VI IC Ul LI IC I I Ilibl ILI- LLID I t.../
administrations in history' during a 2018 interview."
Mexico's finance minister, Carlos Urzua, speaks as President Andres Manuel Lopez
Obrador looks on during a news conference in February. (Henry Romero/Reuters)
THE NEW WORLD ORDER:
-- Mexican Finance Minister Carlos Urzila abruptly
resigned, dealing a major blow to President Andres
Manuel Lopez Obrador's government. Mary Beth
Sheridan reports: Urzba quit after accusing Lopez Obrador's
government of making decisions "that were not grounded in
evidence and of naming officials who were ignorant of
economics. ... Lopez Obrador has sought to woo the
business community by pledging a balanced budget and a
stable peso, even as he has launched ambitious social
programs to help youth and the poor. But the peso
immediately slid after UrzCia announced his resignation on
Twitter, falling more than 2 percent, to about 19.3 pesos to
the dollar. It later recovered some ground after Lopez
Obrador named a U.S.-educated technocrat, Arturo Herrera,
as Urzua's replacement."
-- Iran's release after four years in prison of a Lebanese
businessman was meant to be seen as an opening for
U.S.-Iranian talks. But the gesture wasn't enough for
Washington. Reute ' lr,s,se,sleyWroughton sJoaatban
Landay and Arshad Mohammed report: ""It was a missed
opportunity." one U.S. source said of Nizar Zakka's June 11 Page 12551
release and the U.S. decision not to pursue talks. `We
should have explored whether there was something there.' A
second source — who is familiar with Iran's thinking and
spoke on condition of anonymity — said Iran freed Zakka as
a signal it wanted to cool tensions that have fueled fears of a
war, and described his release as `a goodwill gesture.' ...
Iranian officials declined to discuss whether it was an
overture, or what concessions Tehran wants from
Washington."
-- The Pentagon's transition plan underscores an
upheaval in leadership. Missy Ryan reports: "Mark Esper,
who became acting defense secretary on June 24 after his
predecessor, then-acting defense secretary Patrick
Shanahan, abruptly stepped aside, is expected to hand over
to a third acting secretary, Navy Secretary Richard V.
Spencer, when the White House formally submits Esper's
nomination to the Senate for confirmation. Under a federal
law known as the Vacancies Act, Esper, who has been
serving as Army secretary since 2017, is required to step
aside while the Senate considers his nomination for the top
Pentagon job. When he will do so is not clear, as the
requirement will be activated only when the White House
officially transmits his nomination to the Senate. Pentagon
chief of staff • Chewning, speaking to reporters at the
Pentagon, said the White House was expected to convey
Esper's nomination `shortly.-
-- The Pentagon said it spent at least $1.2 million on
Trump's Fourth of July celebrations. CBS News's Page 12552
Kathryn Watson reports: "That figure does not represent the
full cost of the event to taxpayers, but it does include the
cost of flying hours and transportation for tanks and fighting
vehicle platforms. Funding for the demonstrations, a
Pentagon spokesman says, came from the services' training
budgets for flying hours, and additional funds were used for
the transportation of equipment. The Pentagon noted it's
spent comparable amounts, if not more, on other events.
The Pentagon noted that San Francisco Fleet Week cost
$1.8 million in 2017, and Los Angeles Fleet Week cost $1.6
million."
A picture provided by the Saudi royal palace on June 29 shows Crown Prince
Mohammed bin Salman joking around with President Trump during their bilateral
meeting on the sidelines of the G-20 Summit in Osaka, Japan. (Bandar Al-
Jaloud/Saudi royal palace/AFP/Getty Images)
NEVER FORGET JAMAL KHASHOGGI:
-- After journalist Jamal Khashoggi was killed at the
Saudi Consulate in Istanbul, a number of lobbying
firms and think tanks in Washington began making a
rare move: They publicly severed ties with Saudi
Arabia. Months later, however, the country's efforts to
continue influencing U.S. policy remain strong. Beth
Reinhard,  Jonathan O'Connell and Tom Hamburger report:
"Since fall 2018, high-powered lobbyists and lawyers have
reaped millions of dollars for assisting the kingdom as it
works to develop nuclear power, buy American-made
Page 12553
vvecipui IJ dl IU pi olui IUC lU LI IC ..-/CIUUI - ICU
coalition waging war in Yemen, foreign lobbying records
show. One Washington-based communications firm —
whose parent company initially expressed concern when
Khashoggi disappeared — recently reported collecting
nearly $19 million for what it says was several years of work
for the Saudi government. A New York-based public
relations firm run by a former Clinton administration
appointee signed on in February to represent a Saudi
interest for as much as $120,000 a month, filings show. The
firms representing the kingdom operate under wide political
cover provided by Trump. ...
"Saudi Arabia is one of the highest -spending countries
seeking to influence U.S. policy, ranking ninth in an
analysis by the Center for Responsive Politics that
reviewed the flow of foreign money from 2017 to the
present. Roughly 20 firms are registered to lobby for Saudi
interests, compared with more than 25 before Khashoggi's
death, foreign lobbying filings show. ... At least five firms did
end up cutting business ties with Saudi interests in the fall:
Glover Park Group, BGR Group, Harbour Group, CGCN
Group and Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, filings show. Among
the lobbying firms still representing Saudi interests are
Hogan Lovells, which has been paid $1.6 million since fall;
and McKeon Group, led by Howard `Buck' McKeon, a former
Republican chairman of the House Armed Services
Committee, which has received $600,000. Two law firms are
offering advice on the kingdom's efforts to build nuclear
power plants: Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman, which got
Page 12554
nearly $1.9 million between August 2018 and January; and
King & Spalding, which received $946,000 in November."
-- Saudi Arabia invited Reporters without Borders, a
global press freedom group, to the kingdom. Kareem
Fahim reports: "The four-person delegation visited in April
and met with senior Saudi officials, including the public
prosecutor and the minister of justice, according to
Christophe Deloire, who spoke publicly about the visit for the
first time. The delegation's members demanded a
thorough investigation of the killing of Khashoggi and
pressed for the `unconditional and immediate release'
of at least 30 journalists that Reporters without
Borders says are unfairly imprisoned in the kingdom,
Deloire said. The invitation was the first from the Saudi
government to RSF and the level of access the delegation
was given was extremely rare, he said."
-- The Saudi princess who has been accused of
ordering her bodyguard to assault a workman in Paris
has gone on trial in absentia. From the BBC: "Princess
Hassa bint Salman - Crown Prince Mohammed bin
Salman's sister - faces charges of complicity to violence with
a weapon and complicity to kidnap. Her bodyguard ... is also
on trial. ... [Both] deny wrongdoing. ... Egyptian workman
Ashraf Eid told police that, in September 2016, he was
working in the Saudi king's apartment on the exclusive
Avenue Foch in Paris when he went to take pictures of the
bathroom on his mobile phone so that he could remember
where items were placed before he started. However, the
Page 12555
princess suspectea nim or wanting to seii images ne naa
taken of her in the mirror and called the guard, French
reports say. .. . According to one French account, the
workman accused the princess of saying: 'This dog must be
killed, he doesn't deserve to live. You'll see how you speak to
a princess, how you speak to the royal family.' Mr Eid told
police the bodyguard beat him up, binding his hands
and forcing him to kiss the princess's feet."
Nicki Minaj canceled a concert in Saudi Arabia after
better "educating herself on the issues." Helena
Andrews-Dyer reports: "Just one week after her
performance at the Jeddah World Fest was announced,
Minaj said in a statement that 'after careful consideration'
she could no longer participate. 'While I want nothing more
than to bring my show to fans in Saudi Arabia, after better
educating myself on the issues, I believe it is important for
me to make clear my support for the rights of women, the
LGBTQ community and freedom of expression,' Minaj said
in a statement Tuesday to the Associated Press."
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg testifies on Capitol Hill last year. (Andrew
Harnik/AP)
THE BRAVE NEW WORLD, BROUGHT TO YOU BY BIG
TECH:
-- Trump summoned Republican lawmakers, political
strategists and social media stars to the White House
to diArlISS the "onnortiinitips" of the Wph in a summit Page 12556
that critics said could empower online provocateurs.
Tony Romm, Michael Scherer and Amy B Wang report:
"The high-profile gathering follows months of attacks from
Trump claiming that Facebook, Google and Twitter ...
secretly censor right-leaning users, websites and other
content online, a charge of political bias that the tech giants
strongly deny.. ... But Trump hasn't invited any of the major
tech companies, people familiar with the White House plans
say, opting instead to grant a powerful stage to people who
have a track record of sending inflammatory tweets and
videos and posting other troubling content that social media
sites increasingly are under pressure to remove. Among the
expected attendees are James O'Keefe, the founder of
Project Veritas, which has released secretly recorded videos
of subjects, including a Google executive, in an attempt to
paint them as politically biased. Another invitee, Ben
Garrison, has published cartoons that have drawn sharp
rebukes from the Anti-Defamation League and the Southern
Poverty Law Center for including hateful text and imagery."
-- Apple, Amazon, Facebook and Google executives
will testify to Congress next week as part of the
House's antitrust investigation. Tony Romm reports:
"The hearing, scheduled for July 16 in front of the House
Judiciary Committee's subcommittee that deals with
antitrust, will bring simmering Democratic and Republican
frustrations with Silicon Valley into public view, potentially
setting the stage for further scrutiny — or regulation — of an
industry that has long insisted that its size doesn't harm
" I —44 ..-- Page 12557
I IVdIJ Ul UUI IbU I [ICI b. ki -m I li:ILUI I I UUI MAUI J CI I DCL.Ub UWI lb
The Post.)
-- Twitter will ban posts that dehumanize people based
on their religion. Hamza Shaban reports: "The update
builds on Twitter's existing policies that bar the promotion of
violence, threats and harassment against people in protected
groups. But the company has acknowledged that what many
people consider abusive tweets may not actually violate
Twitter's rules. New policies banning dehumanizing
language are an attempt to close that gap, Twitter said. ...
Twitter won't automatically flag offending posts, but will
review them when they are reported by users. The company
said it will require that dehumanizing posts are removed from
the platform, starting Tuesday."
Netflix has lost two of its most popular shows —
"Friends" and "The Office" — as old media companies
begin to flex their streaming muscles. CNBC's
Sherman reports: "Disney, AT&T's WarnerMedia, and
Comcast's NBCUniversal are all launching direct-to-
consumer streaming services by the first quarter of 2020.
And they're all coming after Netflix. Sure, there will be
enough consumer dollars to go around for Netflix to keep its
massive subscriber base, 155 million globally, growing. But
there's little doubt that part of the motivation of legacy media
companies embracing subscription streaming services is to
capture some of Netflix's valuation — or bring CEO Reed
Hastings' behemoth back down to earth."
SOCIAL MEDIA SPEED READ:
Page 12558
One of Trump's senior advisers mocked the House
speaker's conflict with some of the freshman members of
her caucus:
One of those freshman Democrats replied to Conway:
Virginia's Democratic governor slammed Republican
legislators for adjourning a special session on gun legislation
after less than two hours:
John Hickenlooper reacted to another Onion article about his
presidential campaign:
A Post reporter drew attention to how much money
politicians make from books:
Former Florida congressman Mark Foley is reportedly ready
to run for Congress again, causing a Politico editor to share
a reminder of his past:
Page 12559
Al Gore offered his condolences to the family of Ross Perot,
even though Perot endorsed George W. Bush in the 2000
election:
George W. Bush also reflected kindly upon Perot, his
father's former political rival:
Many remembered Dana Carvey's impression of Perot upon
learning of his passing:
Model Chrissy Teigen reacted to a court ruling that
said Trump can't block his critics on Twitter:
GOOD READ FROM ELSEWHERE:
-- Politico, "Ross Perot — the father of Trump," by
John F. Harris: "Ross Perot died early Tuesday morning at
89, an event that surely left many Americans with an
embarrassed thought: Wait, what? ... I am pretty sure I
thought he was already dead. The contrast between the
quietude of Perot's last aging years and the blaring trumpets
of his 20th-century business and political career is so stark it
takes some effort now to recall how large this cocksure
Texas bantam once loomed. ... But for people who on
occasion (nerhans several times 2 week) resnonci to the Page 12560
news in the Trump era by thinking to themselves, I can't
believe this is happening, Perot's story is a useful reminder
that norm-shattering, cult-of-personality politics is not an
exclusively recent phenomenon."
HOT ON THE LEFT:
"Strip club to host
golf tournament at
Trump resort in
South Florida," from
David A.
Fahrenthold:
"Trump's golf resort in
Doral, Fla., is
scheduled to host a
golf tournament
Saturday put on by a
Miami-area strip club,
which will allow golfers
to pay for a dancer to
serve as their 'caddy
girl' while they play at
the president's club.
The 'Shadow All Star
Tournament' is
organized by the
Shadow Cabaret, a
HOT ON THE RIGHT:
"Democrats have
moved `too far to the
left,' says BET
network founder Bob
," from
CNBC: "America's
political establishment
is riven with
partisanship that has
become 'very wicked
and very mean,' said
entrepreneur and
media mogul
, who added
that the Democratic
Party has become too
liberal for his liking.
'The party in my
opinion, for me
personally, has moved
too far to the left,'
• • • 55 I. . • •
Page 12561
Fla. Emanuele
Mancuso, Shadow
Cabaret's marketing
director, said in a
telephone interview
that this was the first
time the club had held
a tournament at Trump
Doral. The Trump
name and family crest
are displayed
prominently in the strip
club's advertising
materials, which offer
golfers the `caddy girl
of your choice.'
Mancuso said the strip
club did not intend to
send a political
statement by choosing
Trump's resort.
Rather, he said, the
choice was for luxury."
DAYBOOK:
- ,
of cable network BET
and RLJ Companies
business network,
[said] Tuesday. 'And
for that reason, I don't
have a particular
candidate (I'm
supporting) in the party
at this time,' he said.
described
himself as a long-time
centrist and Democrat.
He publicly supported
Hillary Clinton in the
2016 presidential
election. However, he
has since expressed
admiration for some of
[Trump's] policies,
particularly those
related to the
economy."
Trump will aive a screech and sian an executive order on Page 12562
"Advancing American Kidney Health" at the Ronald Reagan
Building and International Trade Center. Pence will deliver
remarks at a Trump Victory event in California before visiting
the Vandenberg Air Force Base.
McConnell continues to oppose reparations
F QUOTE OF THE DAY:
"I find myself once again in the same position as
President Obama. We both opposed reparations, and
we both are the descendants of slave-owners." —
Mitch McConnell responding to a report about his
ancestors owning slaves.
NEWS YOU CAN USE IF YOU LIVE IN D.C.:
-- It will be dry again today, but prepare for high
humidity. The Capital Weather Gang forecasts: "Our brief
respite from high humidity continues today as we extend our
break from showers and storms as well. We do trend a
touch hotter today, before the humidity and storm chances
come roaring back tomorrow. A few showers or storms may
linger Friday, with a hot but mostly dry weekend the way it
looks now."
-- Residents assessed the damage left behind by the
Page 12563
storm that rocked the city on Monday. Fredrick Kunkle
and Cortlynn Stark report: "A day later, things returned to
normal except for a few isolated spots, with officials saying
most of the mayhem had been short-lived. But for some, the
work was just beginning. Ayers Variety & Hardware was
open, drawing enough power from a generator to make the
cash register work. An employee escorted customers
through the dimly lit store to help them find what they
needed. ... In Montgomery County, officials were making
arrangements for permanent repairs to a giant sinkhole that
opened on Belfast Road in the Woodrock neighborhood of
Potomac. ... In Arlington, 20th Street North and 18th Street
remain closed as officials work to make repairs there. They
are expected to be fixed by end of the week."
-- The D.C. Council stripped Jack Evans of his
chairmanship on the Committee on Finance and
Revenue and said it will hire a law firm to investigate
him. Steve Thompson reports: "The council stopped short
of stripping Evans of other committee assignments — with
the embattled, longtime lawmaker casting a deciding vote. ...
Brianne K. Nadeau (D-Ward 1), who voted in favor of taking
away all of Evans's committee assignments, said the
lawmaker's situation has already left voters in his ward
disenfranchised. ... Evans spoke few words during
Tuesday's discussions, looking tired and occasionally
puffing his cheeks as he exhaled."
-- Phil Freelon, the architect who helped design the
African American Museum, died at 66. Matt Schudel
Page 12564
reports: "He had complications from amyotrophic lateral
sclerosis, sometimes known as Lou Gehrig's disease, said a
son, Deen Freelon. Since 1990, Mr. Freelon led an
architectural firm in Durham that specialized in designing
public buildings, including other cultural centers devoted to
African American life in Baltimore, Atlanta, Charlotte, San
Francisco and Greensboro, N.C. He led a consortium of
several architectural firms - formally known as the Freelon
Adjaye Bond/SmithGroup — that won the design
competition for the National Museum of African American
History and Culture in 2009. Their proposal was chosen, in a
unanimous vote, over submissions from such renowned
architects as Richard Meier, I.M. Pei and Norman Foster."
VIDEOS OF THE DAY:
Prince George's County police in Maryland launched training
efforts in July that prohibit officers from cooperating with
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents to
enforce civil deportation orders.
Training video tells Maryland officers when to cooperate with ICE
Watch a time-lapse of earthquakes and aftershocks in
California:
Watch a time-lapse of earthquakes and aftershocks in California
And Megan Rapinoe, the co-captain of the U.S. women's
soccer team, had a message for Trump:
Page 12565
You received this email because you signed up for The Daily 202 or because it is included in your
subscription.
Manage my email newsletters and alerts I Unsubscribe from The Daily 202
Privacy Policy I Help
©2019 The Washington Post I 1301 K St NW, Washington DC 20071
Page 12566
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D2511A05.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316111.5 A9D. I
Message Path xmirTrash/SD25BA05.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1 70316D.1.5A9D.I.xml
From The Washington Post
Display Name The Washington Post
Email emakiewashingtonpost.com
Reply To emaktwashingtonpost.com
Test The Washington Post
To The Washington Post
Subject The Dally 202: Truly might win a Pyrrhic victory against Otomacarc, as the balance of judicial power shifts his
way
Scheduled date 201907-1010:1127
Creation date 2019-07.1010:1127
Modified date 201907-10103332
Delivered date 201947-10 101222
Message size 86876
Attachments size 499687
Total N UR 586574
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.hnn
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID
5D25BA05.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.200006A.1.7
5CF5.1@l455D25BA05.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
70316D.I.5A9D. l@l9.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline false
Type It
Size 192535
CA 30111b195%569cc9chbe5580a8c43ba
Hash 99DFED78D03B710DF90A18ADCEIC2F5C34532DB62BF4E5B6A6D82E9448B09A30531BF4E1
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D25BA05.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.200006A.1.7
5CF6.1®455D25BA05.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
70316D.1.5A9D.1@1:9.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.I@l8
Is Inline fake
Type fie
Size 307152
CA b25d17l7d8085598feflaee0e9d7e848
Hash OD4520DDEC57FF716EA1A8B9595889813A80C103E DC235A6E6D01B7DD47CDC298DFA I 5CDE
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUI 0 835135FA0.11C6-0000-11306-FE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient The Washington Post
Display Name The Washington Post
Email emakei: washingtonpost.ceen
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read fake
Deleted true
Opened fake
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined fake
Page 12567
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D25BA05.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.170316O.1.5 A9D. l@l9.NYMDOM LNYMADM Lioo.o.i.o.ig 18
Source received
Class Public
Account
Location ID
MI
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
II) 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l8
Name Trash
Type Trash
S)stem MC
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 12568
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-07-17 0429:10 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Trashl
Job.cn=lebs.cn-GWOpenNodetn-archiviag.d Agent-
. actmai
Generated by Netrrea Inc. [cirArchive
I -Daily Trash IJob.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNotle.cn—archivinpro
-hennaillncd 2019-08-21 0936:36 EDT Expand netma inetma a nomad Expo by netmaitnetrnainetnn 0
2019-08-21 1326:05 EDT Exported arum anctina inctmai Exported by netwraitnetnralnctmail
2019.0842 174624 EDT Exponcd nconainconainctrnai Exponcd by netnutnetmailnctmail
2019-09-07180802 EDT Exported mum inctinad. nctmai Exported by netrnainetrrcanctmail
2021-05.191437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fkagged
202005-19153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Responsive
Page 12569
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12570
From: The Washin ton Post <email@washingtonpost.com>
To:
Subject: The Daily 202: Trump might win a Pyrrhic victory against Obamacare, as the balance of judicial power shifts his
way
Sent: Wed, 10 Jul 2019 14:11:27 +0000
If you're having trouble reading this, click here.
Share. MIListen to The Big Idea
Trump might win a Pyrrhic victory against
Obamacare, as the balance of judicial power shifts
his way
People wait in line to enter the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit in New Orleans on Tuesday to hear
arguments on whether Congress effectively invalidated the Affordable Care Act when it zeroed out the tax
imposed on those who choose not to buy insurance. (Gerald Herbert/AP)
BY JAMES HOHMANN
with Joanie Greve and Mariana Altaro
THE BIG IDEA: Oral arguments in New Orleans on Tuesday over
the future of the Affordable Care Act foreshadowed the massive
impact that President Trump's free rein to fill the courts with like-
minded judges will probably have on American jurisprudence over
the next generation.
For now, Trump continues to suffer legal setbacks. In a case involving
his push to add a citizenship question to the 2020 Census, a district
court judge rejected the Justice Department's request to change out its
team of lawyers. Separately, an appellate court in New York upheld a
lower court's decision that it is unconstitutional for Trump to block critics
on Twitter because he's a public official who uses the platform to
communicate with constituents.
But the balance of power is changing on the courts each week to
become more favorable to Trump, and it sure sounded like the U.S.
Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit might be ready to uphold at least
parts of a federal district judge's decision in Texas that the entire 2010
health-care law is unconstitutional because the 2017 GOP tax bill got rid
of the individual mandate to buy insurance. Two of the three judges on
the panel expressed skepticism during the oral arguments that
Obamacare can remain intact since the mandate was how Chief Justice
John justified upholding the law in 2012.
Judge Kurt Engelhardt, whom Trump put on the bench just last year,
was the more outspoken of the two. He repeatedly noted that the law
was written without an explicit feature guaranteeing that if one part were
ever removed by Congress or the courts, the rest would remain in place.
He suggested that it's the job of Congress to forge a solution. He
questioned whether the courts should be "taxidermist for every
legislative big-game accomplishment that Congress achieves." The
judge who seemed to largely agree with him was appointed by George

W. Bush. A third judge, appointed by Jimmy Carter, stayed silent during
the 90-minute hearing, per Amy Goldstein, who was in the courtroom for
US.
Engelhardt was grilling attorneys representing Democratic attorneys
general and the Democratic House. Normally it would have been Justice
Department lawyers defending a federal law, but the Trump
administration is refusing to do so and told the 5th Circuit this spring that
the administration agrees with the plaintiffs that it should be struck
down.
If Trump gets what he's hoping for in New Orleans, there's a strong
argument to be made that the president will be like the proverbial dog
that catches up with the truck. Health care — the issue that dogged
Republican candidates in the 2018 midterms more than any other —
would almost certainly take a starring role in the 2020 campaign. The
Supreme Court would probably then hear an appeal, in which
would probably again cast a deciding vote — one way or another — in
June of an election year.
McConnell mum on whether he supports Trump-Obamacare lawsuit
-- Here are three telling illustrations of how the 5th Circuit could
hand Trump a Pyrrhic victory:

1) Despite a decade of efforts to kill Obamacare, Senate Majority
Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) refused to say yesterday whether
he supports the suit to invalidate the law. "I think the important thing
for the public to know is there is nobody in the Senate not in favor of
covering preexisting conditions," he said at his weekly news conference.
"And if it were, under any of these scenarios, to go away, we would act
quickly on a bipartisan basis to restore it."
Trump has had a historically large number of judicial vacancies to fill
during his first two-and-a-half years largely because McConnell blocked
consideration of so many of Barack Obama's nominees once he seized
control of the Senate in 2015. It was not just Merrick Garland.

2) Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine), who cast a key vote for the tax bill
that could be used as a pretext by judicial activists to repeal
Obamacare, is trying to distance herself from the lawsuit
challenging the ACA. She also voted to confirm Engelhardt to the 5th
Circuit, in addition to Justice Brett Kavanaugh. These votes could imperil
her reelection next year. She issued a statement saying she opposes
Trump's decision not to defend the health-care law in court. "The
Affordable Care Act remains the law of the land, and it is the
Department of Justice's duty to defend it," Collins said.
3) "Democrats are savoring the moment," Paige Winfield
Cunningham reports in the Health 202. "They're spending the week
bludgeoning Republicans over the high-stakes lawsuit, which they well
know is prime fodder for 2020 attacks. The House Oversight Committee
will hold a hearing this morning dubbed The Trump Administration's
Attack on the ACA: Reversal in Court Case Threatens Health Care for
Millions of Americans,' where a number of patients and consumers
advocates will testify. The Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee,
the Democratic Attorneys General Association and the Democrat-
affiliated group Protect Our Care launched hundreds of thousands of
dollars worth of print and digital ads around the country. Democrats in
Congress delivered floor speeches castigating their GOP colleagues.
House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerry Nadler (D-N.Y.) said he's
also planning a hearing on the lawsuit."
-- As the judges in Louisiana considered the fate of health care for
millions of people, the Senate voted 53 to 45 on party lines to
confirm another controversial Trump nominee to the 9th Circuit,
the court of appeals that has most often drawn the president's ire.
Hailey Fuchs notes that Daniel Bress's confirmation gives Trump his
seventh judge on the historically liberal bench, which now has 16 judges
nominated by Democratic presidents and 12 by Republicans. The court
still has one vacancy that Trump plans to fill. Bress, who once clerked
for the late Antonin Scalia, was nominated to fill the vacancy left by M
Kozinski, whom Kavanaugh once clerked for and who resigned in
December 2017 amid allegations of sexual misconduct.
Subscribe on Amazon Echo, Google Home, Apple HomePod and other podcast
players.
Welcome to the Daily 202, PowerPost's morning briefing for
decision-makers.
Sign up to receive the newsletter.
WHILE YOU WERE SLEEPING:
British Ambassador Kim Darroch speaks at an afternoon tea hosted by the British Embassy to mark Trump's
inauguration in January 2017. (Paul Morigi/Getty Images)
-- British Ambassador Kim Darroch resigned from his post this
morning after three days of public attacks from Trump, who was
angry about leaked cables that showed the diplomat privately
described the president as "inept" and "insecure." Jennifer Hassan
reports: "Trump blasted Darroch in a series of tweets this week, calling
him 'a pompous fool' and said his administration would not work with
him." In his resignation letter, Darroch said the "current situation is
making it impossible for me to carry out my role as I would like. Although
my posting is not due to end until the end of this year, I believe in the
current circumstances the responsible course is to allow the
appointment of a new ambassador."
Federal Reserve Board Chair Jerome Powell speaks at a news conference in May. (Patrick Semansky/AP)
-- Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has two messages for
Congress this morning: Central bank independence is critical, and
an interest -rate cut is likely at the end of July. Heather Long got a
first look at his prepared testimony before the House Financial Services
Committee: "Since [June], it appears that uncertainties around trade
tensions and concerns about the strength of the global economy
continue to weigh on the U.S. economic outlook. Inflation pressures
remain muted," Powell will say. The U.S. economy is doing "reasonably
well," Powell will add, but he notes that business investment has
"slowed notably," probably because of the uncertainty around trade and
global growth. He will also stress that the economic gains have not been
shared evenly by everyone. Hispanics, African Americans and people in
rural communities are continuing to have a harder time finding jobs that
pay well.
-- Reader feedback: Many of you, on the left and right, emailed in
response to yesterday's Big Idea to say that manufacturers should
keep raising wages for workers if they want to make their industry
more appealing to young people and close the skills gap. Readers
wrote that higher salaries would have a bigger impact than any
marketing campaign from a trade association in making the sector more
appealing.
A protester dressed as a character from "The Handmaid's Tale" walks back to her car in May after
participating in a rally against restrictions on abortion rights in Montgomery, Ala. (Julie Bennett/Getty Images)
-- Support for legal abortion has hit a 24-year high as more states
pass severe restrictions on the procedure, according to a new
Washington Post-ABC News poll. Emily Guskin and Scott Clement
report:  "The Post-ABC poll finds a 60 percent majority who say abortion
should be legal in most or all cases, up from 55 percent in a 2013 Post-
ABC poll, and tying the record high level of support from 1995. The
latest survey finds 36 percent say abortion should be illegal in all or
most cases, also tying a record low. A 41 percent plurality of Americans
want their own state to avoid making it either harder or easier for women
to have access to abortion. Fewer, 32 percent, say their states should
make it easier and fewer still, 24 percent say their states should make it
harder for women to have access to abortion. ... Even within party
ranks, allowing or banning abortion in all cases is a minority position.
Among Democrats, 77 percent say abortion should be at least mostly
legal, but just over 4 in 10 (42 percent) say it should be legal in all
cases. Among Republicans, 52 percent say it should be at least mostly
illegal, but fewer than a quarter, 22 percent, want it to be illegal in all
cases."
State Rep. Greg Murphy debates Joan Perry on the campus of Pitt Community College. (Deborah
Griffin/Greenville Daily Reflector/AP)
-- North Carolina state Rep. Greg Murphy won the Republican
primary for the state's reliably red 3rd Congressional District,
besting pediatrician Joan Perry by 20 points in a special election.
Felicia Sonmez reports: "The race had been viewed by some as a test
of women's standing within the Republican Party. Perry had won the
endorsements of all 13 House Republican women and received nearly
$1 million in support from an outside group created to boost female
Republican House candidates. But in the end, she was outflanked by
Murphy, who was backed by several House Republican heavyweights,
including Reps. Jim Jordan (Ohio) and Mark Meadows (N.C.)."
Joe Biden stops for ice cream in Iowa in April. (Melina Mara/The Washington Post)
-- Cashing in: Joe Biden, who continues calling himself "Middle
Class Joe" on the campaign trail, earned $15.6 million over the
past two years. Matt Viser and Anu Narayanswamy: "The vast majority
of the former vice president's income — which totaled $11 million in
2017 and $4.6 million in 2018 — came from book payments and
speaking fees, according to newly released tax returns and financial
disclosure forms required of federal office-seekers. All told, the Bidens
made nearly five times more in the past two years than the next- highest
earner, Sen. Kamala D. Harris (D-Calif.), who with her husband earned
$3.3 million. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-
Mass.) each took in about $1.7 million in family income. ... Since leaving
office, he has benefited from an explosion of wealth. He gave 47
speeches, according to the new filings, with fees as high as $234,000.
His speaking fees and book payments amounted to $10 million in 2017
and $3.2 million in 2018. Biden was also a professor at the University of
Pennsylvania, where he was paid $371,159 in 2017 and $405,368 in
2018."
Shane Bieber of the Indians pitches for the American League last night at Progressive Field in Cleveland.
(Jason Miller/Getty Images)
-- On the strength of its pitchers, the American League will get
home-field advantage in the World Series after a 4-3 win in the All-
Star Game. Dave Sheinen reports from Cleveland: "Perhaps someone
sneaked into the bowels of Progressive Field on Tuesday and replaced
the regular, turbocharged 2019 baseballs with century-old versions from
the Dead Ball Era. How else to explain — in the midst of the biggest
home run binge in the history of the sport, one year after the most
homers ever hit in an All-Star Game and one night after the most
electrifying performance in the history of the Home Run Derby — the
relatively pedestrian showing in this year's Midsummer Classic? There
is one other possible explanation, of course, and it is the one,
conspiracy theories aside, that will have to suffice: There are great
pitchers scattered across this game (shellshocked as they may be by
the nightly home run binges), and on Tuesday night they shone
brightest.... The victory was the seventh in a row by the AL, its 14th in
the past 17 and 19th in the past 23 All-Star Games."
MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred denied yesterday that the
league has knowingly "juiced" baseballs to increase the number of
home runs this season, despite mounting complaints from
pitchers. Manfred attributed the spike in homers to naturally occurring
variances in manufacturing baseballs and vowed transparency as
officials move to correct the problem, per Sheinin.
Perot in 1992 warned NAFTA would create 'giant sucking sound'
GET SMART FAST:

1. Ross Perot, the Texas billionaire who waged two
unsuccessful bids for president as an independent, died at 89.
Perot was lauded for starting two software companies that later sold
for billions, and his reputation as a successful entrepreneur helped
him attract nearly 20 million votes in 1992 — marking the highest
vote share for an independent or third-party bid since Theodore
Roosevelt and ultimately contributing to Bill Clinton's victory. (Donald

P. Baker)
2. Virginia's GOP-controlled General Assembly ended a special
session on gun legislation after about 90 minutes. The Virginia
Senate voted along party lines to adjourn until after the state
legislative elections this November, and the House quickly followed
suit. The Republican House speaker accused Democratic Gov.
Ralph Northam (D) of an "election-year stunt" for ordering the
special session shortly after the May 31 mass shooting in Virginia
Beach. (Gregory S. Schneider, Laura Vozzella and Antonio Olivo)

3. Democratic megadonor Ed Buck is facing allegations of
human trafficking and revenge porn months after he came
under fire when two black men died from overdoses in his
home. Buck is now facing two more charges in an ongoing case
brought by the mother of one of the two men who died in his West
Hollywood apartment. (The Daily Beast)

4. A Republican candidate for Mississippi governor,
Foster, refused to allow a female reporter to travel with him
alone because of her gender. Foster's campaign told journalist
Larrison Campbell she would need to be accompanied by a male
colleague if she wanted to go on a 15-hour trip with the candidate,
saying the "optics" of the candidate with a woman could be used to
insinuate an extramarital affair. (Mississippi Today)

5. A Senate bill would block federal funding for the 2026 World
Cup until the U.S. Soccer Federation agrees to give the national
women's and men's teams the same compensation. The
proposal by Sen. Joe Manchin Ill (D-W.Va.) comes after the women
won the World Cup this weekend as the crowd chanted, "Equal pay!"
(Des Bieler)

6. An inspector general report accuses the hospice industry of
repeatedly ignoring patients' pain and needs. One particularly
grisly example recounted how a patient in Missouri was so neglected
that his family had to make a trip to the emergency room to treat a
"maggot infestation" where his feeding tube entered his abdomen.
(Chris Rowland)

7. Electric scooters have spread to several European capitals,
where they are sparking the same complaints heard on this
side of the Atlantic. The mayor of Paris condemned the scooters
as causing "not far from anarchy" on the city's roads, and residents
of Berlin have complained of drunk riders and at least one instance
of a man trying to access a high-speed motorway on his e-scooter.
(Rick Noack)

8. Pig-ear dog treats were recalled in 33 states because of a
potential salmonella contamination, the FDA announced. The
treats, which were sold in bins at Pet Supplies Plus stores in the
states, are believed to be linked to an outbreak of human salmonella
infections. (USA Today)

9. A rare polio -like illness marked by muscle weakness or
paralysis affected 233 people in 2018, the majority of them
children. The CDC said the number of recorded acute flaccid
myelitis cases last year made it the worst year since the government
started tracking the illness in 2014. (Philadelphia Inquirer)
10. A man who was swept over the largest waterfall at Niagara
Falls survived. Reports of the incident sent Niagara Parks Police
scrambling to get to the waterfalls early Tuesday morning, where
they found the man with non-life-threatening injuries. (Allyson Chiu)
Trump says he feels 'very badly' for Acosta on Epstein link
THE #METOO RECKONING:
-- Trump is standing by his embattled labor secretary, saying he
feels "very badly" for Acosta, as Democratic calls mounted
for Acosta's resignation over the generous plea deal he struck with
financier Jeffrey Epstein when he was a federal prosecutor. Trump
said the White House will look closely at the circumstances surrounding
the sex-charges deal negotiated by Acosta. "I feel very badly, actually,
for Secretary Acosta because I've known him as being somebody who
works so hard and has done such a good job," the president told
reporters in the Oval Office.
-- Acosta broke his silence and defended himself on Twitter: "The
crimes committed by Epstein are horrific, and I am pleased that NY
prosecutors are moving forward with a case based on new evidence,"
he wrote, suggesting that prosecutors have new evidence he did not
when he was Miami's U.S. attorney.
-- Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi called on Acosta to step down,
as did most of the 2020 Democratic candidates. "Congressional
Republicans supported Acosta, saying issues about the plea deal were
vetted at his confirmation hearing in 2017. Acosta's critics said he was
not fit to lead an agency that has oversight over human trafficking
offenses," John Wagner and Lisa Rein report. "Some attorneys for
victims questioned Acosta's tweet saying the evidence was new."
-- Acting White House chief of staff Mick Mulvaney is privately
urging Trump to dump Acosta, Politico's Eliana Johnson and Burgess
Everett report: "Acosta critics, including Mulvaney, have argued that he
has not been aggressive enough in stamping out Obama-era workplace
regulations and employment discrimination lawsuits, and they are using
the Epstein lawsuit to push him out the door. Mulvaney on Tuesday
acknowledged the tension with Acosta but said it was merely part of the
job. `I push all of the Cabinet Secretaries on the deregulatory agenda, as
it is a top priority of the President,' Mulvaney said in a statement. ... One
move that has particularly rankled conservatives is Acosta's decision to
allow an employment discrimination lawsuit to proceed against Oracle,
the rare Silicon Valley company that is not entirely hostile to the GOP."
Democrats demand Acosta resign over Epstein deal
-- The Justice Department said Attorney General William Barr will
not recuse himself from the current prosecution of Epstein, but he
will not engage in "any retrospective review" of the 2008 plea deal.
Matt Zapotosky reports: "Barr had telegraphed at his confirmation
hearing in January that he might have to step aside from any Justice
Department reviews of Epstein's case, because another lawyer at his
then-firm, Kirkland & Ellis, had represented the wealthy financier. The
other lawyer, Jay P. Lefkowitz, helped secure [the previous deal]. The
split nature of Barr's recusal suggests that federal prosecutors in New
York — who unsealed new sex trafficking charges against Epstein on
Monday — might not be investigating authorities' handling of the
previous allegations. The Justice Department's Office of Professional
Responsibility has been reviewing the handling of Epstein's 2008 plea
deal for possible misconduct, and Barr is recused from that."
-- The Miami Herald has reported that Lefkowitz, Barr's colleague at
the time, had a one-on-one meeting with Acosta at which the then-
U.S. attorney agreed not to prosecute Epstein in federal court.
-- Epstein amassed a network of powerful connections as
authorities say that he was simultaneously abusing dozens of
young girls. Marc Fisher reports: "Even as dozens of women were
looking to police, prosecutors and courts to hold Epstein to account for
his alleged sexual abuses, he was amassing a stunning list of contacts
and, in some cases, defenders across the worlds of Hollywood
moviemaking, medical research, diplomacy, finance, politics and law. ...
He donated large sums toward neuroscience research at Harvard and a
California lab. He invited researchers to his New York house and talked
math with them over equations scrawled on a blackboard in his dining
room. He flew former president Bill Clinton and actor Spacey to
Africa to promote AIDS awareness. He was a member of the Trilateral
Commission and the Council on Foreign Relations."
-- The criminal case against Epstein had gone cold, but Miami
Herald reporter Julie Brown kept pursuing the story and forced
authorities to pay attention. The Times's Tiffany Hsu reports: "Months
ago, she published a meticulously researched series of articles about
the secret plea deal. ... Her work identified some 80 alleged victims ...
She worked on the award-winning series with Emily Michot, a visual
journalist at The Herald. While Mr. Epstein moved about freely,
reportedly building a new compound in the Virgin Islands, Ms. Brown
continued to dig, accumulating enough documentation to fill a spare
bedroom in her Florida home. ... Geoffrey Berman, a federal prosecutor,
said at a news conference that his team had been 'assisted by some
excellent investigative journalism.-
-- Trump once threw a party with "28 girls" at Mar-a-Lago. He and
Epstein were the only men there. The Times's Annie Karni and
Maggie Haberman dig into the relationship: "The year was 1992 and the
event was a `calendar girl' competition, something that George
Houraney, a Florida-based businessman who ran American Dream
Enterprise, had organized at Mr. Trump's request. `I arranged to have
some contestants fly in,' Mr. Houraney recalled in an interview on
Monday. `At the very first party, I said, 'Who's coming tonight? I have 28
girls coming.' It was him and Epstein.' Mr. Houraney, who had just
partnered with Mr. Trump to host events at his casinos, said he was
surprised. 'I said, `Donald, this is supposed to be a party with V.I.P.s.
You're telling me it's you and Epstein?" In fact, that was the case, an
indication of a yearslong friendship between the president and Mr.
Epstein that some say ended only after a failed business arrangement
between them. ...
"The full nature of their eventual falling out is not clear. ... The
relationship with Mr. Trump turned so toxic that Mr. Epstein at one point
told friends that he blamed Mr. Trump for his legal problems with the
Palm Beach County police. But while Mr. Trump has dismissed the
relationship, Mr. Epstein, since the election, has played it up, claiming to
people that he was the one who introduced Mr. Trump to his third wife,
Melania Trump, though neither of the Trumps has ever mentioned Mr.
Epstein playing a role in their meeting."
Trump says he had a 'falling our with Epstein years ago
SELECTIVE AMNESIA:
-- Trump has a pattern of quickly minimizing ties with people who
criticize him or who find themselves facing an onslaught of
negative attention that reflects poorly on him. Epstein and Darroch
are only the two latest examples. Josh Dawsey reports: "Trump sat
across from Darroch during the annual St. Patrick's Day lunch on
Capitol Hill in March, inquiring about Brexit and bragging of his strong
political standing. ... Trump interacted with Darroch on a number of
occasions in London and Washington. ... But after leaked cables
showed Darroch criticizing Trump's administration as 'inept' and the
president as `insecure,' the president seemed to have a memory lapse.
'I don't know the Ambassador but have been told he is a pompous fool,'
Trump wrote Tuesday on Twitter. ... Asked Tuesday about Epstein,
Trump said that he was 'not a fan' of his. ... 'I don't think I've spoken to
him for 15 years,' Trump said. In a 2002 interview with New York
Magazine before Epstein was in trouble, Trump sang a different tune.
'I've known ■ for 15 years. Terrific guy. He's a lot of fun to be with. It is
even said that he likes beautiful women as much as I do, and many of
them are on the younger side,' Trump said....
"Among those who have gotten the `I barely know the guy'
treatment: Former acting attorney general Matthew G. Whitaker,
conservative commentator Ann Coulter, former lawyer Michael Cohen,
fired FBI director James B. Comey, former senior White House aide
Stephen K. Bannon, former campaign chairman Paul Manafort, former
State Department official Brett McGurk, longtime adviser Roger Stone,
former White House aide Cliff Sims, former campaign aide George
Papadopoulos and even the rapper Lil Jon, who starred on Trump's
reality TV show 'Celebrity Apprentice.' The people change, but the
comments are eerily similar — and are something of a joke among
some Trump advisers."
-- He is the do-as-I-say, not-as-I-do president: Trump attacked the
"Radical Left" last night for encouraging boycotts against
companies whose owners support him, even though he has
repeatedly advocated the exact same tactic in the past against his
perceived critics. Trump was rallying to the defense of Home Depot
and its co-founder, Bernard Marcus, who have been at the center of a
boycott from liberal customers after the billionaire said he plans to spend
part of his fortune supporting Trump's 2020 campaign.
"Among the companies he has targeted are Macy's, which once
carried his clothing line but abandoned him after he called Mexicans
'rapists' in his campaign kickoff speech in 2015, and Apple, which he
urged to release the cellphone information of the perpetrators of the
2015 shooting in San Bernardino, Calif.," Isaac Stanley-Becker recalls.
"Last year, he celebrated plans to boycott Harley-Davidson when the
motorcycle company said it would move some production overseas
because of steel tariffs imposed by the president. He has also implored
his Twitter followers to boycott Megyn Kelly's show on Fox News and
suggested that dropping AT&T could compel CNN to improve its
coverage of him. ... The president has argued that Nike and the NFL
would encounter 'anger and boycotts' as long as they support players
who kneel during the national anthem to protest police brutality and
racial injustice. He struck a different tone on Tuesday, saying it was
unfair to penalize a company because one of its co-founders supported
'your favorite President, me!"
Sater offers few details after House panel appearance
THERE'S STILL A BEAR IN THE WOODS:
-- A congressional panel grilled former Trump associate Felix Sater
for more details on the president's failed Moscow project. Karoun
Demirjian and Tom Hamburger report: "Sater met privately with House
Intelligence Committee staffers investigating interference in the 2016
presidential election and questions surrounding Trump's business
interests in Russia in 2016. At issue is Michael Cohen's false testimony
before the same committee in 2017 and whether Trump was
compromised by his organization's effort to build in Moscow. When
pressed Tuesday to provide information about his knowledge of Cohen's
testimony, Sater at one point cited lawyer-client privilege and declined to
respond, according to accounts of the exchange described by Sater's
attorney and a spokesman for the committee."
-- Federal prosecutors no longer want Michael Flynn to testify
against his former partner because they doubt his version of
events, according to a court filing. Rachel Weiner reports: "The move
could have implications for Flynn in D.C. federal court, where he is
awaiting sentencing in a case brought by the special counsel. ... Flynn
had been expected to be a key witness in the Virginia trial of Bijan
Rafiekian, with whom he ran a consulting business. A court filing from
Rafiekian's attorneys includes an email that Assistant U.S. Attorney
James P. Gillis ended by saying prosecutors 'do not necessarily agree'
with Flynn's 'characterizations' of how he came to make an inaccurate
filing under the Foreign Agent Registration Act for an influence
campaign that benefited the Turkish government. According to the
email, Flynn says he did not provide false information to his attorneys at
the time, did not read the FARA filing before signing it and was not
aware that it contained falsehoods. In their filing, Rafiekian's lawyers say
they 'interpreted the email's final sentence as a euphemism for, 'we've
concluded [Flynn] is lying.'
"The decision by prosecutors could imperil Flynn's ability to avoid
incarceration for lying to the FBI unless he is pardoned by
Trump. Flynn's defense attorney, Sidney Powell, said in a statement
that 'General Flynn is still cooperating with the government even if they
don't call him as a witness.-
-- The Justice Department directed two former members of
Mueller's team, Aaron Zebley and James L. Quarles, not to testify
before Congress. The Times's Nicholas Fandos and Katie Benner
report: "It is unclear what effect the Justice Department's intervention
will have on the men's eventual appearances, but it raises the prospect
that a deal lawmakers thought they had struck last month for testimony
from Mr. Mueller, the former special counsel, and the two prosecutors
could still unravel. Both Mr. Zebley and Mr. Quarles have left the Justice
Department and are now private citizens, meaning that the department
most likely cannot actually block their testimony. But the department's
view — depending on how strongly it is expressed — could have a
chilling effect on two longtime employees and give them cover to avoid
testifying."
-- The House Judiciary Committee will vote tomorrow on whether
to subpoena 12 individuals with connections to Trump, including
Jared Kushner and Jeff Sessions, for their investigation on
whether the president obstructed justice. Colby ltkowitz reports: "The
panel will also vote to subpoena documents related to the Trump
administration's zero tolerance policy on migrants entering the country
illegally, which led to the separation of thousands of children from their
parents in 2018. ... In addition to seeking subpoenas for Kushner and
Sessions, the committee will vote to subpoena former White House chief
of staff John Kelly; [Flynn]; former Trump campaign manager Corey
Lewandowski; former deputy attorney general Rod J. Rosenstein;
former White House deputy chief of staff Rick Dearborn; assistant
attorney general Jody Hunt; former White House staff secretary Rob
Porter; National Enquirer editor Dylan Howard; American Media Inc.
chief executive David Pecker; and Keith Davidson, former attorney for
adult-film star Stormy Daniels."
-- Ahead of the former special counsel's testimony next week,
many lawmakers admit that they have not read Mueller's report in
full. Politico's Darren Samuelsohn reports: "Trump can't give a straight
answer about the subject. More than a dozen members of Congress
readily admitted ... that they too have skipped around rather than
studying every one of the special counsel report's 448 pages. And
despite the report technically ranking as a best-seller, only a tiny fraction
of the American public has actually cracked the cover and really dived
in. `What's the point?' said Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.). ... The result,
say lawmakers, historians and cultural critics, is a giant literacy gap in
the country when it comes to the most authoritative examination into
Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election and whether
Trump obstructed that investigation."
-- Pelosi said she will not address "anything more that [Barr] has to
say" because he "has lied to Congress." Pelosi's comments came a
day after the attorney general accused Democrats of trying "to create
some kind of public spectacle" by calling for Mueller to publicly testify
next week. "I don't even want to address him," Pelosi said in response.
"He has lied to Congress as the attorney general of the United States.
He's lied under oath. I'm not speaking to anything more that he has to
say." (John Wagner)
-- Russian intelligence agents appear to have been the first people
to promote the conspiracy theory that DNC staffer Seth Rich was
killed by assassins working for Hillary Clinton. Yahoo News's
Michael Isikoff reports: "Russia's foreign intelligence service, known as
the SVR, first circulated a phony 'bulletin' — disguised to read as a real
intelligence report —about the alleged murder of the former DNC staffer
on July 13, 2016, according to the U.S. federal prosecutor who was in
charge of the Rich case. That was just three days after Rich, 27, was
killed in what police believed was a botched robbery while walking home
to his group house in the Bloomingdale neighborhood of Washington,
D.C., about 30 blocks north of the Capitol. ... In a graphic example of
how fake news infects the internet, those precise details popped up the
same day on an obscure website, whatdoesitmean.com, that is a
frequent vehicle for Russian propaganda. The website's article, which
attributed its claims to `Russian intelligence,' was the first known
instance of Rich's murder being publicly linked to a political conspiracy."
-- Christopher Steele, the author of the dossier, was interviewed for
16 hours last month as part of the investigation by Michael
Horowitz, the Justice Department's inspector general. Politico's
Natasha Bertrand reports: "The extensive, two-day interview took place
in London while Trump was in Britain for a state visit, [two] sources said,
and delved into Steele's extensive work on Russian interference efforts
globally, his intelligence-collection methods and his findings about
Trump campaign adviser Carter Page, who the FBI ultimately surveilled.
... The interview was contentious at first, the sources added, but
investigators ultimately found Steele's testimony credible and even
surprising. The takeaway has irked some U.S. officials interviewed as
part of the probe — they argue that it shouldn't have taken a foreign
national to convince the inspector general that the FBI acted properly in
2016."
After crossing the Rio Grande from Mexico into the United States on June 13, Karla Yadira Rivera, 36, cries
as she walks to Border Patrol agents with her daughters Karla, 11; Andrea, 12; and Emilia, 17, in El Paso.
(Carolyn Van Houten/The Washington Post)
THE IMMIGRATION WARS:
-- Border arrests are dropping as Mexico's crackdown on migrants
takes effect. Nick Miroff reports: "The number of people taken into
custody along the U.S. southern border fell 28 percent in June, a drop
that U.S. authorities say reflects the early impact of Mexico's crackdown
on Central American migration. Border crossings typically rise in the
spring and slump during the scorching summer months, but the drop
registered from May to June was significantly larger than in previous
years, according to Homeland Security statistics."
-- Migrant children in an overcrowded detention center in Yuma,
Ariz., are making sexual assault allegations and saying they fear
retaliation from U.S. agents when they complain about poor
treatment. NBC News's Jacob Soboroff and Julia Ainsley report: "A 16-
year-old Guatemalan boy held in Yuma, Arizona, said he and others in
his cell complained about the taste of the water and food they were
given. The Customs and Border Protection agents took the mats out of
their cell in retaliation, forcing them to sleep on hard concrete. A 15-year-
old girl from Honduras described a large, bearded officer putting his
hands inside her bra, pulling down her underwear and groping her as
part of what was meant to be a routine pat down in front of other
immigrants and officers. The girl said 'she felt embarrassed as the
officer was speaking in English to other officers and laughing' during the
entire process, according to a report of her account."
-- California became the first state to offer health benefits to adult
undocumented immigrants. NPR's Bobby Allyn reports: "The measure
signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom on Tuesday extends coverage to low-
income, undocumented adults age 25 and younger for the state's
Medicaid program. Since 2016, California has allowed children under 18
to receive taxpayer-backed healthcare despite immigration status. And,
state officials expect that the plan will cover roughly 90,000 people. ... In
California, extending health benefits to undocumented immigrants is
widely popular. A March survey conducted by the nonpartisan Public
Policy Institute of California found that almost two-thirds of state
residents support providing coverage to young adults who are not legally
authorized to live in the country."
-- Two active-duty Marines were arrested for allegedly trying to
smuggle three undocumented Mexican immigrants through
California. Meagan Flynn reports: "Lance Cpls. Byron Darnell Law II
and David Javier Salazar-Quintero, based in Camp Pendleton, Calif.,
were arraigned Monday in federal court on charges of transporting
undocumented immigrants 'for financial gain,' accused of taking jobs
from 'recruiters' and following instructions from unknown people in
Mexico to make extra cash on the side. They are among several active-
duty U.S. troops charged or convicted in recent years of helping
immigrants cross the border in exchange for money, highlighting how
smugglers have sought to offer the shield of a uniform or credentials to
assist desperate immigrants on the journey north."
Footage shows hate crime being committed at Glenelg High School
THE BLACK EXPERIENCE IN AMERICA:
-- "A black principal, four white teens and the `senior prank' that
became a hate crime,"  by Jessica Contrera: "This was the last day of
the year for the class of 2018 at Glenelg High School. There was going
to be an awards ceremony, a picnic, that end-of-a-journey feeling that
always made [Principal David Burton] so proud of his job. But as he was
on his way to work at 6:25 a.m., the assistant principal had called,
agitated and yelling about graffiti. 'It's everywhere,' he kept saying, so
Burton had leaned on the gas and rushed the last few miles. ... He
turned a corner and saw something written in large capital letters on the
sidewalk: 'BURTON IS A NIGGER.' He paused only for a moment,
looking at the words, trying to comprehend that all of this was real.
Later, school district officials, county administrators and prosecutors
would have a name for what happened here. They would repeat it,
condemn it and vow to prevent it from occurring again. Hate crime."
-- A white man who called 911 on a black man in his building
apologized for his actions, explaining that they were informed by a
tragic family history — his father was murdered after confronting a
mentally ill man who showed up on his driveway. The man,
Christopher Cukor, called the cops on Wesly Michel, a man who was
going up to a friend's apartment in the same building without using the
call box. The video of their encounter went viral online. (Eli Rosenberg)
-- Elijah Al-Amin, a black teenager, was stabbed to death at a
convenience store in Arizona by a white man, allegedly because he
was playing rap music in his car. The man, Michael Adams, stabbed
the 17-year-old two days after Adams was released from prison, where
he had completed a sentence for assault and theft. (NBC News)
-- The Chicago Defender, the legendary newspaper read by
generations of black Americans, printed its final copy. The
newspaper will cease its print editions after today but will continue its
digital operation. (New York Times)
-- A graphic artist who went viral for calling out Google's lack of a
doodle celebrating Juneteenth was contacted by the search giant
about a job. Davian Chester created his own Google doodle to
celebrate the holiday marking the end of slavery, which quickly spread
across social media and attracted the company's interest. Chester said
he is still in talks with Google about the job, but in the meantime, his
hometown of Columbus, Ga., has put up a billboard of the doodle.
(Allison Klein)
Tom Steyer: 'Fundamental Change' I Campaign 2020
2020 WATCH:
-- Billionaire activist Tom Steyer formally entered the Democratic
presidential primary with an announcement video outlining his
pledges to reduce corporations' political influence and address
climate change. Chelsea Janes reports: "In January, when he
announced he would not run for president, Steyer said that rather than
entering the race he would turn his attention fully to pressuring members
of Congress to start impeachment proceedings against [Trump]. ... On
Tuesday, as he announced his presidential bid, Steyer did not mention
impeachment or Trump, although the president was briefly seen in the
video. Trump's former campaign chairman, Paul Manafort, was also
seen in the video being led down a hallway in handcuffs. ... Steyer will
have one week to accumulate 65,000 donors to qualify for the second
Democratic debate, which will take place at the end of the month."
-- Biden told a voter he'll "go further" than cutting incarceration by
50 percent. BuzzFeed News's Katherine Miller reports: "In a video
shared ... by the ACLU, Biden tells a man, Keith Albert, who identifies
himself as an ACLU voter, that he'd `go further than' cutting
incarceration by half. `Would you commit to cutting incarceration by
50%?' Albert asks Biden. `More than that. We can do it more than that,'
he responds. Last month in Concord, New Hampshire, another self-
identified ACLU voter asked if Biden would `commit to cutting the prison
population overall, and specifically the federal prison population, in half'
— a slightly different wording."
-- CNN announced its rules for the next Democratic presidential
debates. From CNN's Mark Preston: "The upcoming Democratic
presidential debates will feature opening and closing statements and
two hours of debate time each night ... While candidates will not
officially learn if they make the Detroit stage until July 17, Tuesday's call
with the 20-plus Democratic campaigns was held to help them prepare
for the debate should their respective candidates qualify, a CNN
spokesperson said." The rules include:

• Colored lights will be used to help candidates manage their
remaining response times.
• A candidate attacked by name by another candidate will be given
30 seconds to respond.

• There will be no show of hands or one-word questions.
• A candidate who constantly interrupts others will have their time
reduced.
• Questions posed by moderators will appear on the screen for
viewers.
-- The DNC announced that the third debate, which will be hosted
by ABC News and Univision, will be held in Houston.
-- Democrats are increasingly focused on portraying Mitch
McConnell as a villain in a bid to win back the Senate and energize
liberals. IM  Costa reports: "That effort gained new momentum on
Tuesday as Amy McGrath, a retired Marine lieutenant colonel and
combat pilot, announced she would challenge McConnell (R-Ky.) and
blamed him for turning Washington into `something we despise' in a
campaign video that drew millions of views. While McGrath faces a
steep climb against McConnell in ruby-red Kentucky, which President
Trump carried by 30 percentage points in 2016, she is expected to raise
significant funds from national Democrats and provide the party with a
relentless and high-profile opponent."
-- Though Sen. Pat (R-Kan.) won't make an endorsement in
the Republican primary race to replace him, he said former Kansas
secretary of state Kris Kobach faces a "very difficult" path to the
Senate. The Kansas City Star's Bryan Lowry reports: "'It seems to me if
you have just lost a statewide race, that the chances of you winning
another statewide race would be very difficult,' told reporters. 'I
have not talked to Kris about this. I did talk to him earlier, but that was all
about allegedly being the head of DHS. But the votes weren't there.' ...
Kobach's campaign manager Steve Drake rejected ' analysis of
the race and also hit back against the criticism from national
Republicans. ... Kobach's entry could ramp up efforts to recruit
Secretary of State Pompeo into the race."
-- The RNC is threatening to withhold support from candidates who
refuse to use the party's newly established online fundraising tool,
WinRed, as tensions over the future of the party's grass-roots
fundraising efforts reach a breaking point. Politico's Isenstadt
reports: "The moves illustrate how Republican leaders are waging a
determined campaign to make WinRed the sole provider of its small
donor infrastructure — and to torpedo any competitors. On Monday, the
RNC sent an eight-page cease-and-desist letter to Paul Dietzel, a
Republican digital strategist who earlier this month launched Give.GOP,
a fundraising platform that includes a directory through which donors
can give to party candidates and organizations. In the letter, RNC chief
counsel Justin Riemer writes that while Give.GOP has a page inviting
donors to give to the RNC, the committee hasn't yet received any funds
from the platform or received any outreach from it. Riemer also accuses
Dietzel of using the committee's trademark and logo without its
permission."
-- Sarah McBride, a transgender activist who made waves after
speaking at the Democratic National Convention in 2016, is now
running for Delaware state Senate. Deanna Paul reports: "If she wins
the 2020 race to succeed Sen. Harris McDowell, who is retiring at the
end of his term, McBride will be the state's first elected transgender
senator. ... Now serving as national press secretary for the Human
Rights Campaign, the nation's largest LGTBQ lobbying group, she has
continued to be a force for the movement through the Trump-Pence
administration, which she called `one of the most explicitly anti-LGBTQ
administrations in history' during a 2018 interview."
Mexico's finance minister, Carlos Urzea, speaks as President Andres Manuel Lepez Obrador looks on during
a news conference in February. (Henry Romero/Reuters)
THE NEW WORLD ORDER:
-- Mexican Finance Minister Carlos Urzila abruptly resigned,
dealing a major blow to President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador's
government. Mary Beth Sheridan reports: Urziia quit after accusing
Lopez Obrador's government of making decisions "that were not
grounded in evidence and of naming officials who were ignorant of
economics. ... L0pez Obrador has sought to woo the business
community by pledging a balanced budget and a stable peso, even as
he has launched ambitious social programs to help youth and the poor.
But the peso immediately slid after Urztla announced his resignation on
Twitter, falling more than 2 percent, to about 19.3 pesos to the dollar. It
later recovered some ground after L0pez Obrador named a U.S.-
educated technocrat, Arturo Herrera, as Urzua's replacement."
-- Iran's release after four years in prison of a Lebanese
businessman was meant to be seen as an opening for U.S.-Iranian
talks. But the gesture wasn't enough for Washington. Reuters's
Lesley Wroughton, Jonathan Landay and Arshad Mohammed report: ""It
was a missed opportunity," one U.S. source said of Nizar Zakka's June
11 release and the U.S. decision not to pursue talks. 'We should have
explored whether there was something there.' A second source — who
is familiar with Iran's thinking and spoke on condition of anonymity —
said Iran freed Zakka as a signal it wanted to cool tensions that have
fueled fears of a war, and described his release as `a goodwill gesture.'
... Iranian officials declined to discuss whether it was an overture, or
what concessions Tehran wants from Washington."
-- The Pentagon's transition plan underscores an upheaval in
leadership. Missy Ryan reports: "Mark Esper, who became acting
defense secretary on June 24 after his predecessor, then-acting
defense secretary Patrick Shanahan, abruptly stepped aside, is
expected to hand over to a third acting secretary, Navy Secretary
Richard V. Spencer, when the White House formally submits Esper's
nomination to the Senate for confirmation. Under a federal law known as
the Vacancies Act, Esper, who has been serving as Army secretary
since 2017, is required to step aside while the Senate considers his
nomination for the top Pentagon job. When he will do so is not clear, as
the requirement will be activated only when the White House officially
transmits his nomination to the Senate. Pentagon chief of staff
Chewning, speaking to reporters at the Pentagon, said the White House
was expected to convey Esper's nomination 'shortly.'"
-- The Pentagon said it spent at least $1.2 million on Trump's
Fourth of July celebrations. CBS News's Kathryn Watson reports:
"That figure does not represent the full cost of the event to taxpayers,
but it does include the cost of flying hours and transportation for tanks
and fighting vehicle platforms. Funding for the demonstrations, a
Pentagon spokesman says, came from the services' training budgets for
flying hours, and additional funds were used for the transportation of
equipment. The Pentagon noted it's spent comparable amounts, if not
more, on other events. The Pentagon noted that San Francisco Fleet
Week cost $1.8 million in 2017, and Los Angeles Fleet Week cost $1.6
million."
A picture provided by the Saudi royal palace on June 29 shows Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman joking
around with President Trump during their bilateral meeting on the sidelines of the G-20 Summit in Osaka,
Japan. (Bandar Al-Jaloud/Saudi royal palace/AFP/Getty Images)
NEVER FORGET JAMAL KHASHOGGI:
-- After journalist Jamal Khashoggi was killed at the Saudi
Consulate in Istanbul, a number of lobbying firms and think tanks
in Washington began making a rare move: They publicly severed
ties with Saudi Arabia. Months later, however, the country's efforts
to continue influencing U.S. policy remain strong. Beth Reinhard,
Jonathan O'Connell and Tom Hamburger report: "Since fall 2018, high-
powered lobbyists and lawyers have reaped millions of dollars for
assisting the kingdom as it works to develop nuclear power, buy
American-made weapons and prolong U.S. assistance to the Saudi-led
coalition waging war in Yemen, foreign lobbying records show. One
Washington-based communications firm — whose parent company
initially expressed concern when Khashoggi disappeared — recently
reported collecting nearly $19 million for what it says was several years
of work for the Saudi government. A New York-based public relations
firm run by a former Clinton administration appointee signed on in
February to represent a Saudi interest for as much as $120,000 a
month, filings show. The firms representing the kingdom operate under
wide political cover provided by Trump. ...
"Saudi Arabia is one of the highest -spending countries seeking to
influence U.S. policy, ranking ninth in an analysis by the Center for
Responsive Politics that reviewed the flow of foreign money from
2017 to the present. Roughly 20 firms are registered to lobby for Saudi
interests, compared with more than 25 before Khashoggi's death,
foreign lobbying filings show. ... At least five firms did end up cutting
business ties with Saudi interests in the fall: Glover Park Group, BGR
Group, Harbour Group, CGCN Group and Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher,
filings show. Among the lobbying firms still representing Saudi interests
are Hogan Lovells, which has been paid $1.6 million since fall; and
McKeon Group, led by Howard `Buck' McKeon, a former Republican
chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, which has received
$600,000. Two law firms are offering advice on the kingdom's efforts to
build nuclear power plants: Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman, which got
nearly $1.9 million between August 2018 and January; and King &
Spalding, which received $946,000 in November."
-- Saudi Arabia invited Reporters without Borders, a global press
freedom group, to the kingdom. Kareem Fahim reports: "The four-
person delegation visited in April and met with senior Saudi officials,
including the public prosecutor and the minister of justice, according to
Christophe Deloire, who spoke publicly about the visit for the first time.
The delegation's members demanded a thorough investigation of
the killing of Khashoggi and pressed for the 'unconditional and
immediate release' of at least 30 journalists that Reporters without
Borders says are unfairly imprisoned in the kingdom, Deloire said.
The invitation was the first from the Saudi government to RSF and the
level of access the delegation was given was extremely rare, he said."
-- The Saudi princess who has been accused of ordering her
bodyguard to assault a workman in Paris has gone on trial in
absentia. From the BBC: "Princess Hassa bint Salman - Crown Prince
Mohammed bin Salman's sister - faces charges of complicity to violence
with a weapon and complicity to kidnap. Her bodyguard ... is also on
trial. ... [Both] deny wrongdoing. ... Egyptian workman Ashraf Eid told
police that, in September 2016, he was working in the Saudi king's
apartment on the exclusive Avenue Foch in Paris when he went to take
pictures of the bathroom on his mobile phone so that he could
remember where items were placed before he started. However, the
princess suspected him of wanting to sell images he had taken of her in
the mirror and called the guard, French reports say. ... According to one
French account, the workman accused the princess of saying: 'This dog
must be killed, he doesn't deserve to live. You'll see how you speak to a
princess, how you speak to the royal family.' Mr Eid told police the
bodyguard beat him up, binding his hands and forcing him to kiss
the princess's feet."
-- Nicki Minaj canceled a concert in Saudi Arabia after better
"educating herself on the issues." Helena Andrews-Dyer reports:
"Just one week after her performance at the Jeddah World Fest was
announced, Minaj said in a statement that 'after careful consideration'
she could no longer participate. 'While I want nothing more than to bring
my show to fans in Saudi Arabia, after better educating myself on the
issues, I believe it is important for me to make clear my support for the
rights of women, the LGBTQ community and freedom of expression,'
Minaj said in a statement Tuesday to the Associated Press."
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg testifies on Capitol Hill last year. (Andrew Harnik/AP)
THE BRAVE NEW WORLD, BROUGHT TO YOU BY BIG TECH:
-- Trump summoned Republican lawmakers, political strategists
and social media stars to the White House to discuss the
"opportunities" of the Web in a summit that critics said could
empower online provocateurs. Tony Romm, Michael Scherer and
Amy B Wang report: "The high-profile gathering follows months of
attacks from Trump claiming that Facebook, Google and Twitter ...
secretly censor right-leaning users, websites and other content online, a
charge of political bias that the tech giants strongly deny.. ... But Trump
hasn't invited any of the major tech companies, people familiar with the
White House plans say, opting instead to grant a powerful stage to
people who have a track record of sending inflammatory tweets and
videos and posting other troubling content that social media sites
increasingly are under pressure to remove. Among the expected
attendees are James O'Keefe, the founder of Project Veritas, which has
released secretly recorded videos of subjects, including a Google
executive, in an attempt to paint them as politically biased. Another
invitee, Ben Garrison, has published cartoons that have drawn sharp
rebukes from the Anti-Defamation League and the Southern Poverty
Law Center for including hateful text and imagery."
-- Apple, Amazon, Facebook and Google executives will testify to
Congress next week as part of the House's antitrust investigation.
Tony Romm reports: "The hearing, scheduled for July 16 in front of the
House Judiciary Committee's subcommittee that deals with antitrust, will
bring simmering Democratic and Republican frustrations with Silicon
Valley into public view, potentially setting the stage for further scrutiny —
or regulation — of an industry that has long insisted that its size doesn't
harm rivals or consumers." (Amazon founder . Bezos owns The
Post.)
-- Twitter will ban posts that dehumanize people based on their
religion. Hamza Shaban reports: "The update builds on Twitter's
existing policies that bar the promotion of violence, threats and
harassment against people in protected groups. But the company has
acknowledged that what many people consider abusive tweets may not
actually violate Twitter's rules. New policies banning dehumanizing
language are an attempt to close that gap, Twitter said. ... Twitter won't
automatically flag offending posts, but will review them when they are
reported by users. The company said it will require that dehumanizing
posts are removed from the platform, starting Tuesday."
-- Netflix has lost two of its most popular shows — "Friends" and
"The Office" — as old media companies begin to flex their
streaming muscles. CNBC's . Sherman reports: "Disney, AT&T's
WarnerMedia, and Comcast's NBCUniversal are all launching direct-to-
consumer streaming services by the first quarter of 2020. And they're all
coming after Netflix. Sure, there will be enough consumer dollars to go
around for Netflix to keep its massive subscriber base, 155 million
globally, growing. But there's little doubt that part of the motivation of
legacy media companies embracing subscription streaming services is
to capture some of Netflix's valuation — or bring CEO Reed Hastings'
behemoth back down to earth."
SOCIAL MEDIA SPEED READ:
One of Trump's senior advisers mocked the House speaker's conflict
with some of the freshman members of her caucus:
One of those freshman Democrats replied to Conway:
Virginia's Democratic governor slammed Republican legislators for
adjourning a special session on gun legislation after less than two hours:
John Hickenlooper reacted to another Onion article about his
presidential campaign:
A Post reporter drew attention to how much money politicians make
from books:
Former Florida congressman Mark Foley is reportedly ready to run for
Congress again, causing a Politico editor to share a reminder of his
past:
Al Gore offered his condolences to the family of Ross Perot, even
though Perot endorsed George W. Bush in the 2000 election:
George W. Bush also reflected kindly upon Perot, his father's former
political rival:
Many remembered Dana Carvey's impression of Perot upon learning of
his passing:
Model Chrissy Teigen reacted to a court ruling that said Trump can't
block his critics on Twitter:
GOOD READ FROM ELSEWHERE:
-- Politico, "Ross Perot — the father of Trump,"  by John F. Harris:
"Ross Perot died early Tuesday morning at 89, an event that surely left
many Americans with an embarrassed thought: Wait, what? ... I am
pretty sure I thought he was already dead. The contrast between the
quietude of Perot's last aging years and the blaring trumpets of his 20th-
century business and political career is so stark it takes some effort now
to recall how large this cocksure Texas bantam once loomed. ... But for
people who on occasion (perhaps several times a week) respond to the
news in the Trump era by thinking to themselves, I can't believe this is
happening, Perot's story is a useful reminder that norm-shattering, cult-
of-personality politics is not an exclusively recent phenomenon."
HOT ON THE LEFT:
"Strip club to host golf
tournament at Trump resort
in South Florida," from
David A. Fahrenthold:
'Trump's golf resort in Doral,
Fla., is scheduled to host a
golf tournament Saturday put
on by a Miami-area strip club,
HOT ON THE RIGHT:
"Democrats have moved
'too far to the left,' says BET
network founder Bob
," from CNBC:
"America's political
establishment is riven with
partisanship that has become
'very wicked and very mean,'
which will allow golfers to pay
for a dancer to serve as their
'caddy girl' while they play at
the president's club. The
'Shadow All Star Tournament'
is organized by the Shadow
Cabaret, a strip club in
Hialeah, Fla. Emanuele
Mancuso. Shadow Cabaret's
marketing director, said in a
telephone interview that this
was the first time the club had
held a tournament at Trump
Doral. The Trump name and
family crest are displayed
prominently in the strip club's
advertising materials. which
offer golfers the 'caddy girl of
your choice.' Mancuso said
the strip club did not intend to
send a political statement by
choosing Trump's resort.
Rather. he said, the choice
was for luxury."
DAYBOOK:
said entrepreneur and media
mogul , who
added that the Democratic
Party has become too liberal
for his liking. 'The party in my
opinion, for me personally,
has moved too far to the left,'
, the founder of cable
network BET and RLJ
Companies business network.
[said] Tuesday. 'And for that
reason, I don't have a
particular candidate (I'm
supporting) in the party at this
time,' he said. ...
described himself as a long-
time centrist and Democrat.
He publicly supported Hillary
Clinton in the 2016
presidential election.
However, he has since
expressed admiration for
some of [Trump's] policies.
particularly those related to
the economy."
Trump will give a speech and sign an executive order on "Advancing
American Kidney Health" at the Ronald Reagan Building and
International Trade Center. Pence will deliver remarks at a Trump
Victory event in California before visiting the Vandenberg Air Force
Base.
McConnell continues to oppose reparations
QUOTE OF THE DAY:
"I find myself once again in the same position as President Obama.
We both opposed reparations, and we both are the descendants of
slave-owners." — Mitch McConnell responding to a report about his
ancestors owning slaves.
NEWS YOU CAN USE IF YOU LIVE IN D.C.:
-- It will be dry again today, but prepare for high humidity. The
Capital Weather Gang forecasts: "Our brief respite from high humidity
continues today as we extend our break from showers and storms as
well. We do trend a touch hotter today. before the humidity and storm
chances come roaring back tomorrow. A few showers or storms may
linger Friday. with a hot but mostly dry weekend the way it looks now."
-- Residents assessed the damage left behind by the storm that
rocked the city on Monday. Fredrick Kunkle and Cortlynn Stark report:
"A day later, things returned to normal except for a few isolated spots,
with officials saying most of the mayhem had been short-lived. But for
some, the work was just beginning. Ayers Variety & Hardware was
open. drawing enough power from a generator to make the cash register
work. An employee escorted customers through the dimly lit store to
help them find what they needed. ... In Montgomery County, officials
were making arrangements for permanent repairs to a giant sinkhole
that opened on Belfast Road in the Woodrock neighborhood of
Potomac. ... In Arlington, 20th Street North and 18th Street remain
closed as officials work to make repairs there. They are expected to be
fixed by end of the week."
-- The D.C. Council stripped Jack Evans of his chairmanship on the
Committee on Finance and Revenue and said it will hire a law firm
to investigate him. Steve Thompson reports: "The council stopped
short of stripping Evans of other committee assignments — with the
embattled, longtime lawmaker casting a deciding vote. ... Brianne K.
Nadeau (D-Ward 1), who voted in favor of taking away all of Evans's
committee assignments, said the lawmaker's situation has already left
voters in his ward disenfranchised. ... Evans spoke few words during
Tuesday's discussions, looking tired and occasionally puffing his cheeks
as he exhaled."
-- Phil Freelon, the architect who helped design the African
American Museum, died at 66. Matt Schudel reports: "He had
complications from amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, sometimes known as
Lou Gehrig's disease, said a son, Deen Freelon. Since 1990, Mr.
Freelon led an architectural firm in Durham that specialized in designing
public buildings, including other cultural centers devoted to African
American life in Baltimore, Atlanta, Charlotte, San Francisco and
Greensboro, N.C. He led a consortium of several architectural firms —
formally known as the Freelon Adjaye Bond/SmithGroup — that won the
design competition for the National Museum of African American History
and Culture in 2009. Their proposal was chosen, in a unanimous vote,
over submissions from such renowned architects as Richard Meier, I.M.
Pei and Norman Foster."
VIDEOS OF THE DAY:
Prince George's County police in Maryland launched training efforts in
July that prohibit officers from cooperating with U.S. Immigration and
Customs Enforcement agents to enforce civil deportation orders.
Training video tells Maryland officers when to cooperate with ICE
Watch a time-lapse of earthquakes and aftershocks in California:
Watch a time-lapse of earthquakes and aftershocks in California
And Megan Rapinoe, the co-captain of the U.S. women's soccer team,
had a message for Trump:
You received this email because you signed up for The Daily 202 or because it is included in your subscription.
Manage my email newsletters and alerts I Unsubscribe from The Daily 202
Privacy Policy I Help
©2019 The Washington Post I 1301 K St NW, Washington DC 20071
Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
From
To
Date 2019/08/30 11:52
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Thanks. Yes, the TDY is related to them putting new procedures and policies in place to improve local
processes related to the incident. The TDY staff are training local staff or are providing coverage/assistance
while NYM staff put new procedures in place. Thanks in advance.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Ori inal messa e
From: < >
Date: 8/30/19 11:32 AM (GMT-05:00)
To: <a> ,
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
>»'
Hello Ray,
08/30/201911:32 > »
Yes, the MDC Brooklyn incident was covered by special project. However, this was to cover assistance
throughout the duration of the incident along with chiller and repair costs. The Regional staff could not
provide justification for additional expenses directly related to the Epstein incident. The only explanation
provided was due to staff shortage, MCC NY was bringing in staff for staff assist. I explained to the Regional
Comptroller that Bureau institutions are suffering from staff shortages nationwide and any expenses
associated with those shortages are being absorbed at those locations or Regions. We did however provide
utilization of the project code for the travel expenses of the after action team. I've advised all the Regional
Comptrollers, due to priority spending directed by DOJ, such as FSA spending, we would re-evaluate our
budget status during the first week of September to see if any additional funding can be provided. We will
certainly help if we can. Please let me know if you have any additional questions.
Thanks,
> » 8/28/2019 10:08 AM > »
- See below. Is the special project not covering the TDY cost for MCC NYM? Was the TDY cost during
the MDC BRO incident covered by the special project? Thanks in advance.
Regional Director
Northeast R ion
Page 126098/26/2019 2:34 PM > »
The Administration Division has provided us a guidance that we are not authorized to charge any of our TDY
Expenses to the project 87F, Eptein Death at the national level. It was explained to us that the project was
established for regional tracking purposes only and we at the regional level will have to absorb all TDY costs
related to MCC New York.
So far, approximately 60 staff from various institutions for various dates as early as 8/18 through 9/28 are
scheduled for TDY to New York.
The estimated costs for TDY expenses will be approximately $500.000.
Please let me know if you have any questions. Thanks.
Page 12610
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D690DEE.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.1367333.I. I 4FEC.I
Message Path untIslaibox15D690DEENERDOMINERADMI.100 .B67333.1,14FEC.Uunl
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2F9821,80-14C3-0000-9B47-BF62C05FIE96
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: Fwd: TOY Costs for MCC New York
Scheduled date 2019-03-30 1152117
Creation date 2019418.301132117
Modified date 2019.11.04 2022115
Delivered date 2019.08-30 1152:14
Message size 2747
Attachments size 3761
Total size 6519
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.him
Content ID
5D690DEE.NERDOMLNERADMI.200.2008039.1.5
2596.1€4455D690DEE.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.1
367333.1.14FEC.1®12.NERDOMINERADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
'type file
Size 3761
ef49217feb8c38914b41352f71d57e3e
Hash ODB4AC9B477F568D5A1B554C920180355AB039FD DORIB4CD43395A97761F26E74BBED57
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CUM B21i81)1:81-1B1I-00069EF2-000083219F4E
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08-30115216
DownloadedByThirdParty 2019-08-30 1152:16
Opened 2019-08-30 1156:49
Replied 2019-09-11 155523
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification when opened false
Return notification nhen deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification nhen declined fake
Return notification %%hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D690DEE.NERDOM LNERADMI.100.1367333.1. I 4FEC.1(§1:7.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.0.1.0.1€41 6
Source sera
Class Public
Account Ray' . BOP05103.NERADMLNERDOM I
Location ID 1540843020946
Class Name GW.ME.SSAGEMA1L
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Maibox
Page 12611
ID 7.NERDOMI.NERADMI.I00.0.1.01@l6
Name Ma'box
Type Mai=
System Mte
Share Type NotShared
Published 201W1 1/5.122t15
Page 12612
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
202041-01 0435:10 EST Created
en-Archive Agent_3-Scheduled Zero Day . . Trashlen-Jobs.en-GWOpenNode.errarchnitsrash
garnctmail
Generated by Netgovem [en-Archive
Agent  Zero Day }ScheduledL irjobstre.Gwoperasiodetn.urchini
go-neural
2020-05-19 1530,05 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020-05-191530.41 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020.05-19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
2020-05-1914:4136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12613
Google Alert - Federal Bureau of Prisons
From Google Alerts
To
Date 2019/09/05 13:03
Subject: Google Alert - Federal Bureau of Prisons
Attachments: TEXT.htin, Mime.822
Federal Bureau of Prisons
5.2019
NEWS
Immigration agency sets new contract with Mississippi prison
Washington Post
The Federal Bureau of Prisons had said in May that it would not renew its contract for the 2,232-bed
prison. Without a contract, more than 390 jobs ...
Immigration agency sets new contract with Mississippi prison
Raleigh News & Observer
The Federal Bureau of Prisons said in May that it would not renew its contract for the 2,232-bed
prison. Without a contract, more than 390 jobs were at ...
'Hundreds' of names hidden in still-sealed Jeffrey Epstein-
related documents
Miami Herald
The federal Bureau of Prisons, which operated the facility, has come under
intense pressure for failing to adequately monitor Epstein, and the acting ...
Fed survey says growth is steady despite Trump's trade wars
wgxa.tv
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Federal Reserve said Wednesday the U.S. .... a father who is in prison
and a mother who, as a teenager, raised him with the ... later a defense secretary, was director of
President Richard Nixon's Office of ...
James Hyman Joins Corizon Health as Chief Executive Officer
Yahoo Finance
Page 12614
Hyman's corrections experience includes leading companies that served Federal agencies, including the
Federal Bureau of Prisons, as well as 20 ...
CoreCivic's new contract is good news for area
Natchez Democrat
When news broke earlier this year that the Federal Bureau of Prisons would not renew its contract with
CoreCivic, which operates the Adams County ...
R. Kelly Ripped By Prosecutors Over Prison Mistreatment Claims, Say He
Bought Snickers
The Blast
Prosecutors are trashing R. Kelly's claims of being mistreated in prison, ... He wanted the judge to order
the Federal Bureau of Prisons immediately ...
Scranton toy company introduces new 'Army women,' hoping to promote
representation
wgxa.tv
... and previously was addicted to drugs, though she said she has been sober for 18 years following a
stint in prison. ... later a defense secretary, was director of President Richard Nixon's Office of
Economic Opportunity and Cheney, ...
IG: Migrant children traumatized, in acute distress after parental separations
wgxa.tv
After a federal judge ordered the children reunified with their parents, .... the Trump Justice Department,
which oversees the Federal Bureau of Prisons. ...
Southeastern US residents brace for Hurricane Dorian as Bahamians survey
damage
wgxa.tv
South Carolina Department of Correction officials have decided not to ... The department tweeted
Monday that staff and inmates at the Ridgeland .... of the Trump Justice Department, which oversees the
Federal Bureau of Prisons, ...
WEB
Audit of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Contract Awarded to Correct Care
Solutions. LLC for the ...
Page 12615
Oversight.gov
Audit of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Contract Awarded to Correct Care Solutions, LLC for the
Federal Correctional Complex in Coleman, Florida.
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Page 12616
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D710793.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.B26C35.1.0 374.1
Message Path xmnrashiSD710793.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.1 32605.I.C374.I.xml
From Google Alerts
Display Name Goo& Alerts
Email googlealerts-norepbxageogle.com
Reply To googlealens•noreplyM googk.com
Test Google Alerts
To
Subject Google Alert - Federal Bureau of Prisons
Scheduled date 2019-09-05 13:0B8
Creation date 2019-09-05 13:0118
Modified date 201949-05 14:1929
Delivered date 2019-09-05 13:03:16
Message she 6421
Attachments sirs 95802
Total size 102234
Attachments 2
Attachment TeXT.htm
Name TEXT.Inm
Content ID
5D7I0793.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.200C07C.1.5
13F4.1@453D710793.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1
32605.1.C374.1®19.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.1@l 8
Is Inline fake
Tspe He
Size 38829
CA 8d0e0749d79614ea999654e11741fd56
Hash 09007435485559FDEAE21F313870AF25413A86465 9A57D22C3254062397E560449AE4919I
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D7I0793.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.200:07C.1.5
13F5.1®453D710793.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
326C35.1.C374.1®19.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.1®18
Is Inline fake
Type 6k
Size 56973
CA 3c112aff4f9764380e14ffd3e2afItTfe
Hash 365FE5334AEI4E7314ACOOF34A491 1241OFF31 DB2 6FB84A08CAD8BICCACCF155BFAOEDD8F
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
tilliD 610E9350-0B4F-0000-AB39-F80F2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted true
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nonnal
Box type Inbox
Return notification %%hen opened false
Return notification %%hen deleted fake
Return notification %%hen
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined false
Return notification %Men
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D710793.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.1326C35.1.0 374.1® 19.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.I.0.1®18
Source received
Class Public
Account FAIADMI.FAIDOM I
Page 12617
Location In 1540643105474
Class Name GW.MESSACILMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
ID 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1©18
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12618
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019.09.0801:4027 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Day Trash3
Jobrn-lcbs.orGWOpenNodern-arc
aetmai
kii-6—'  ^Ag ent- '— Job.en-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoietn—archivinga
Gerrrated by Netrre8 Inc. [crrArchive
I -Daily Trash3
—nctrnail]
2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag 13O1'01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BO801703.14XRADM 1.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12619
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12620
Sent: Thu, 05 Sep 2019 10:01:58 -0700
Subject: Google Alert - Federal Bureau of Prisons
From: Goo gl  Alerts < ooglealerts-noreply@google.00m>
To:
Federal Bureau of Prisons
NEWS
Immigration agency sets new contract with Mississippi prison
Washington Post
The Federal Bureau of Prisons had said in May that it would not renew its contract for the 2,232-bed prison. Without a
contract, more than 390 jobs ...
IZ
Immigration agency sets new contract with Mississippi prison
Raleigh News & Observer
The Federal Bureau of Prisons said in May that it would not renew its contract for the 2,232-bed prison. Without a
contract, more than 390 jobs were at ...
X X
'Hundreds' of names hidden in still-sealed Jeffrey Epstein-related documents
Miami Herald
The federal Bureau of Prisons, which operated the facility, has come under intense pressure for failing to adequately
monitor Epstein, and the acting ...
Fed survey says growth is steady despite Trump's trade wars
wgxa.tv
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Federal Reserve said Wednesday the U.S. .... a father who is in prison and a mother who, as
a teenager, raised him with the ... later a defense secretary, was director of President Richard Nixon's Office of ...
James Hyman Joins Corizon Health as Chief Executive Officer
Yahoo Finance
Hyman's corrections experience includes leading companies that served Federal agencies, including the Federal Bureau of
Prisons, as well as 20 ...
• •
CoreCivic's new contract is good news for area
Natchez Democrat
When news broke earlier this year that the Federal Bureau of Prisons would not renew its contract with CoreCivic, which
operates the Adams County ...
IZ 1Z1
R. Kelly Ripped By Prosecutors Over Prison Mistreatment Claims, Say He Bought Snickers
The Blast
Prosecutors are trashing R. Kelly's claims of being mistreated in prison, ... He wanted the judge to order the Federal
Bureau of Prisons immediately ...
•IN
Scranton toy company introduces new 'Army women,' hoping to promote representation
wgxa.tv
.., and previously was addicted to drugs, though she said she has been sober for 18 years following a stint in prison. 
... later
a defense secretary, was director of President Richard Nixon's Office of Economic Opportunity and Cheney, ...
IG: Migrant children traumatized, in acute distress after parental separations
wgxa.tv
After a federal judge ordered the children reunified with their parents, .... the Trump Justice Department, which 
oversees the
Federal Bureau of Prisons, ...
Southeastern US residents brace for Hurricane Dorian as Bahamians survey damage
wgxa.tv
South Carolina Department of Correction officials have decided not to ... The department tweeted Monday that staff and
inmates at the Ridgeland .... of the Trump Justice Department, which oversees the Federal Bureau of Prisons, ...
WEB
Audit of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Contract Awarded to Correct Care Solutions, LLC
for the ...
Oversight.gov
Audit of the Federal Bureau of Prisons' Contract Awarded to Correct Care Solutions, LLC for the Federal Correctional
Complex in Coleman, Florida.
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
hid: counsel haying difficulty meeting with client
From
Dale 2019/07/07 18:22
subject: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Attachments: my' . him
I have verified Martin Weinberg is an attorney in good standing in Massachusetts. He is permitted to visit Jeffrey 
Epstein.
Sent from my Veliton. Samoans Galaxy smartphon:
- Ori messa
From:
Date: 7/7/19 6:18 PM GMT-05130
To: >,
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>>> 07/07/2019 18:18>>>
Massachusetts
From:
Sent: Sunday Ju 07
To:
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
SorryM just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
2019 18:18
<S>:
Sent from my Vernon, Samsung Galaxy smartphonc
lO iral rimessa
From:
Dot • 7/7/1 M GMT-05
To: <maiho
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>» " 07/07/2019 17:36 >>>
>. a nailto >>
With apologies for the weekend email. we have a defendant. Jeffrey Epstein, who was arrested last night and is currently
being detained at MCC, and is e
of-state.
Were concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any defendant) and so I wante
s very much,
Page 12623
Popo)Ms
IMIPTTIII Lee
MeagelD 9321307 NYI430M1 NYMADM193116BWIO 1 EMI
came Pali
I*4
DIT314 see
Caen
TT ID 27XCADDOICA4C094139IACT3IEATTD
D.FIy T.
In,
T.
MOTTO Fsd coati Soy 413949 no  )4i cbii
9094.40 ask 3)19OI471I-IQA
Creates 0re 3)190747112241
Moak.) Oat 3) WO147.5061
MINT eta dot 201•0747 ISIS 16
Meorme dm ti.
Aturbsesenit• 4391
DMA'S, DUI
Allalums I
Altstbusem TIN 119
Niim, TLX/.199
Corker ID
SOMAS, TONIDOMI NYMADMISO SOMA. I I
401) 1445))32)3573IYMI)0M1 NYMADMI NO
INIK+10 I ELDON, l Al NYNITICMI NYMADMI 1040 I 0 ID IS
It lam LYe
TD 9
S.. 4'91
CA MCI 019c07 TOO1/411346710C
Hash A ID. 1199ATMCDMD DAM...2MM ANADD 93. , I %TOT 110/31•34
Reci.44. IS
&TON°
Dspla. Num
Email
t LID PAAADONOWN00:049134111CHOIFTED
Disidbution Type TO
Rol •st soup‘14.39/
Renras
0904 Nave
Final
WO TOAMJA0410443:0A19154101113:00007
INsinhutum Tip TO
atlp. et lip 4.04934
&OP"
D9/44 Nati*
Email
t L ID DI FI:A Ia It )(0193314( Ak
Diodbutien 1)pt TO
14 IP. if I Pe up
09314 \.I1
Foull
(LID ILM. 44:4944433190 --/TLID.AAATT
Dior4•194 Tip TI)
Rolploat blur on nlaEv
&eters
Dkpla, •
lino.
ll111 4:7119.33011ANOX041100034 S
1)9.44 k9 1)p. TO
Itolgoo 9 i S 9444 Mcatin
RIOS 9
09 19. Nunt
I9.41
I III U3`99 I:UO11a0IpjY1CIMNMI6D922
INonhins TI)
INN 4. 4 In* %wait
Ree/4190
Otpla, Nast
Tarn
CLIO 20DATITIO1049430 43 RIODINA
EttlIbelles TAP TO
DTTIPM01 11 9
aeµr
OLp14 Name
FaS
ITIJID NSWOOUAI-NXNKT4AI104I41.1
INOTilmlbe Tip TO
ited l k " TM' iNup'4414
Reell it  at
Display Ns F
CLIO M)TIp2D019CI40'OAOI9NONNSN0
Dlodbudes TAP TO
DTTI144  Tit
Reelpios
tth %atm
TaS
OLIO oriuroarassa 9201033330 .
Distribuffibe Tip TO
Ratµ- TIPP 94TratirrupMmaNy
Redl itw
PINY •
real
(LID
Min be Tpp TO
a<1 ket T
144 144
Dept.. •,,,,,
Finia
I till 411Th4 I 1.011000100M.
thonnutwo Two TO
Page 12624

╭─ Page 173, Image 1 ─╮
│ Page 12624          │
╰─────────────────────╯

RaCIPhdl TIT
Red/leml
Daplira
Emil
CUM R/C7D7/044AA.00/2-A4A9-001(00000W0
Illealballea Type TO
Rddilldl TYR* S. d°
Reelpamt
DS Sant
Fail
'tin IIII6D-OCOX0X0X0
Montanan Type TO
R•Olia° in* Iirdantin
IDOPlao
Maley Name
Final
UAW A oal Dual Da4101043711-97MCARIBF
Damnation type To
Pada* at Type Spianteradalothce
Faye, 0
Delay &Inn wail 0
Dia ed laic
AniPed Die
Real nee
Deltied tale
(payed eve
Compleied &Ad
*Daily Nana
Rio Dad alba
Ream milkeslee why 'woad NM.
Reran moditeaka vats delord Da,
Retan saftatkeyebra
tamplelol kit
Remo Mikados wive tamed talc
Reran ..4 !me
ant ed Dbe
Amite ‘'irrslea Si
'aloud ID IMMO NVINICOMI NINAOMI I00. IOW* ?a I E EMI I> VOIDONILNYNADMI.1(0 al 01a lb
Snot mowed
Ow PPR
Miceli POLADYII.POLOODII
Landes ID 1,404127740IX
nu Nam OW miSyktii, ma
Wale. Rain I
Felder Mika
ID 7 NYMCOM I NYMADMI. WOO I 0 la la
Name ?data
?deem
Spies ma
Mat Type Notalared
Page 12625
Agit%
Dale gag Asir Note
gD940.15 XI ION EDT raced Jubta-klaana(PaillyeriNukinclimgai tS a -
arArclar Awn 1.0a4 Arcing
wmiail
rainaled by Nasal Ix garAitlit
I•Day Archival
Maxi"- kbacorarlaggpedaadeararglinrigg
genii
glI94.11 I aYala EDT Lapin., lona neeneintural Fa/until!" wimain-Emiseisa
NI gat.:2 17072I FDT F•PrIN .nvinnnlnnwI Fgranalb, negradromaintimai
IVIgOa IR gliga 47 EDT a n, ',anal nand tgparicdt, ntErsinetereintund
N:046.19 WEN EDT Ng )MINI Ca \MACAO glagt0()%0 abssof
NNE(aa- 19 ISM I) EDT Tag DOPOP0a MMADM I NARDOW Ravenna
:0106.D 1E-1-'01 tor lag DOPOI bg MXILADM I Mg1tDOM I Ittgagat
.31:0411.19 lagel tor log DOPOIND NIXRADM I NIXRDOMI IRC, PCant
gla‘4549 MIRO EDI lag DO•Olalla •IXRADMI.WIDOMI 'UWE
Page 12626
SW Chronological Log 7/23-24/19 re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
From
To
Date 2019/08/12 15:29
Subject: SW Chronological Log 7/23-24/19 re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg.
No. 73618-054
Attachments: TEXT.htm, 2019  08 12 15 06  02.pdf,
C./O Thomas was assigned to staff watch; however, the wrong book was used (VM companion log) in lieu of
Staff Suicide Watch log.
a DTS discovered the wrong log was used. completed a 2nd log using Suicide Watch log
initialed the log for Thomas).
Entries are identical in both logs.
Associate Warden
MCC New York
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
Page 12627
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D5185EC.NERDOMLNEFtADMI.100.B67333.1.1 44B6.1
Message Path mdCabineANERO1Inst - New YorIAAtiga5D5185EC.NERDOM LNERADM 1 A00.13 67333.1.144B6.1.xml
From
Div pia) Name
Email
UUID 835B5E40-1106-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Reply To
Text
To
Subject SW Chronological Log 7/23-2A/19 re: Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054
Scheduled date 201948-12 1529:44
Creation date 2019-08-12 1529:44
Modified date 201948-222014824
Delivered date 2019-08-12 1529:49
Message size 447
Attachments size 427597
Total size 428055
Attachments 3
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.lant
Content ID
5D5185EB.NERDOMLNERADMI.201200000D.LE
E128.1®45:5D5185EC.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.1
367333.1.144B6.1@1:5D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERA DMI.100.1367333.1.142FF.1@l3
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 866
Date 2019-08-12 112444
CA 819dflc8ac96ceeIB2847ed7d4Hbfe
Hash 3912ABEE5D87910C29654AC607251FAC43ED32664B2713561A2C26ECE4B Ft. Mo5AB7
Attachment 2019 08_12_15_06 02.pdf
Name 2019_08_12_15_06_02.pdf
Content ID
5D5185EB.NERDOMLNERADMI.X0.200000D.LE
E129.1(4/45:5D5185EC.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.1
367333.1.144/36.1@h5D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERA DMI.100.1367333.1.142FF.1@l3
Is Inline false
Type Ile
Size 426318
Date 2019-08-12 11:0621
CA b864f2d367fd77ce25a84584:Mh5ce392
Hash E5D89066F453D4DE027I4F96A86803DE06803801 30074A0FA8277FB6284FF65891B9C726
Attachment
Name _
Content ID
5D5185EB.NERDOMLNERADMI.203.2C0000D.LE
El2A.I@45:5D5185EC.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.1
367333.1.144B6 1@1:5D4E9C39.NERDOM LNERA DM1.100.1367333.1.142FF.I@l3
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 413
Date 2019-08-12 11:10:16
CA 777e9e73d5910720da47b4cRa70flal
Hash A028056B3C2094000D4CF643FC573E87013344D8 1A8E76595522.BF65018E17366E950102
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2F982B80-14C3-0900-9B47-ElF62C05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read MC
Deleted fake
Opened time
Completed fake
Page 12628
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification tshen opened false
Re turn notification %she n deleted fake
Return notification %%hen
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined false
Return notification .hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D5185EC.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.1367333.1.1 44B6.1®15D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.13
67333.1.142FF.1@l3
Source received
Class Public
Account Ray thmoral@BOP0SI03.NERADMI.NERDOMI
Location ID 1540843691206
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Aug
ID 5D4E9C39.NERDOM I .NERADM I.I03. I367333. I . I 42FF. I ®I3
Name Aug
Type Normal
System fake
Share Type NotSharcd
Published 20I918/23-0:4834
Page 12629
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019•11-042033!42 EST Created
en=Arehive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archivel.cn-JobsanGWOpenNodetn-archiv ititortictmai
Generated by Nelgowm [cm-Archive
Agent-2-Zem Day Archive hen-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNedetn-arch6
Ingo-netmaij
202005-19 I53606 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19152839 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
202045-1915:1706 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020.05-19153636 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
202005-19 14:3838 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
2020-05-19143434 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
Page 12630
Mail Attachment
2019 08 12 15 06 02.pdf
Page 12631
Suicide Watch
Chronological
Log
Inmate Companions Log
Name of inmate on watch:
Er s)-eniN
Register #:
°S
Institution:
Date Watch Began / Ended
ONLY
ITEMS
ALLOWED:
To be completed by Chief Psychologist at conclusion of watch:
Booklet of
Suicide
Mattress
SWCL - INMATE

╭────────────────────── Page 181, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ Suicide Watch                                                 │
│ Chronological                                                 │
│ Log                                                           │
│                                                               │
│ Inmate Companions Log                                         │
│                                                               │
│ Name of inmate on watch:                                      │
│                                                               │
│ — . w                                                         │
│ vy                                                            │
│ Epsi« 9 3 no                                                  │
│ Register #: 2 2 a                                             │
│ Da uv                                                         │
│ Ayre. sf 2 333                                                │
│ ol 5                                                          │
│ Institution: 2_288s                                           │
│ =zs3&2 Ss                                                     │
│ uw o nn                                                       │
│ E ooo                                                         │
│ >2555                                                         │
│ Date Watch Began / Ended 3 Sess                               │
│ 355                                                           │
│ af 4 CAAA                                                     │
│ vy                                                            │
│                                                               │
│ To be completed by Chief Psychologist at conclusion of watch: │
│                                                               │
│ Booklet ____ of                                               │
│                                                               │
│ Paper Cup                                                     │
│ Soap                                                          │
│                                                               │
│ ‘sweL-                                                        │
│                                                               │
│ INMATE                                                        │
│                                                               │
│ Tampons or                                                    │
│                                                               │
│ Eaam Canitary Ralt/Mankin                                     │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

STAPLE LOCAL PROCEDURES HERE
Check one of the following:
❑ This is the initial log book for this suicide watch.
Enter date and time watch began:
❑ This is a continuation log book for this watch.
Enter date and time this watch book was initiated:
Instructions to Observer:
Document your observations every   minutes.
Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift.
Suicide Watch Observation Log
oNnamweatocfhl:nmate else ,. n Reg IS: 1,6lb .54 Date: -1 23 1 fq
Time Observations: Briefly note your observations. Initial all entries. Initials
I : Li° A•bi in  „.„„, 40 stA ly i. Le 00 I I I -4 1.t-is- ett lei)IK 0 gEO
a 2 Alvt kW (H ;e --) i fr  1 fr
2 thvl tm 1-.. 5 i meg k -I- i 4 (co
(it i
2 0 Ai S V) (01_3 -Iry .fIl h i . ime...4
wk A 4Afr
2 1 (134A. . ch *AA 3( o (4,1
• Awl r S, ikli ISe 6
5 . r1-,, L 4„,34
-
-56. i -1-4 k4 pic 1m re_S
3:56A, 4 S i iii 4 6( 0
' /AA CI Oil ?-e3
L.- ICC 1
C lI crii)
e&
t..e.i < 7,e 1.3
30 I Ins S 44 — hm r
, nil td
,....5
fel-4
iii-p_U, c.-4-  bCei 4
t-7#ittl‘ 1 lki CO7
e,
Note to all observers: Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift.

╭─────────────────────────────────── Page 183, Image 1 ───────────────────────────────────╮
│ Suicide Watch Observation Log                                                           │
│                                                                                         │
│ eh Epsiern Regt: 14515: SY _ ate: 1/23] G                                               │
│ Time Observations: Briefly note your observations. initial all entries. initia          │
│ [Mw | Yun Breagnt un do Surcibe cei Fe                                                  │
│ Saf fw fayut os Bet                                                                     │
│ 2m | Vw 8 a be Ieleing                                                                  │
│ Dw [fu Stas] his tolled Aeizd fe ill                                                    │
│                                                                                         │
│ lia ——                                                                                  │
│ QD Fb Lm i ing ne) try Frew eat                                                         │
│ what slant —_                                                                           │
│ DW [fe Si frien ow Be ——                                                                │
│ Se | Ym Si Pig oe Be —                                                                  │
│ Len (7 oem? tales pictues of tlw                                                        │
│ BF He Bis mht —— |                                                                      │
│ 2 ith on Be)                                                                            │
│ Sl SS DS                                                                                │
│ Ey pn Sry BS                                                                            │
│                                                                                         │
│ Stig Ty ar lta                                                                          │
│                                                                                         │
│ then nd bed =<?                                                                         │
│                                                                                         │
│ live, LF Deer                                                                           │
│                                                                                         │
│ Fundng Wt Dor                                                                           │
│                                                                                         │
│ 8s at 4                                                                                 │
│                                                                                         │
│ Vhs Jig ot Davy                                                                         │
│                                                                                         │
│ Note to all observers: Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift. │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Suicide Watch
Chronological
Log
Staff Suicide Watch
Observers Only
* Namq on watch
E P1r). J.
Regittpr
3{o:StP) ,-dr-j4
InOtitiftion:
MOP. tNifttnl*yi<
DateiVatch Began ,/ Ended
July 23,2.014 -
To be completed by Chief Psychologist at conclusion of watch:
Booklet of
SWCL - STAFF

╭────────────────────── Page 184, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ Suicide Watch                                                 │
│ Chronological                                                 │
│ Log -                                                         │
│                                                               │
│ Staff Suicide Watch * :                                       │
│                                                               │
│ “Observers Only. ~                                            │
│                                                               │
│ ‘Name of inimats on ‘watch:                                   │
│ Epstein, J.                                                   │
│ Register #: 4                                                 │
│ Hosig-0sd gee                                                 │
│ Sanstitation:.                                                │
│ Daté Watch Began/ Ended . Ee                                  │
│                                                               │
│ chuly 23.2010 = July 24,4014                                  │
│                                                               │
│ To be completed by Chief Psychologist at conclusion of watch: │
│                                                               │
│ Booklet of                                                    │
│                                                               │
│ ae                                                            │
│                                                               │
│ ‘SWCL - STAFF                                                 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

STAPLE LOCAL PROCEDURES HERE
Check one of the following:
This is the initial log book for this suicide watch.
Enter date and time watch began:
July 23)2otg a4- rAomvi
This a continuation log book for this watch:
Enter date and time this watch book wailnillata td:'
Instructions to Observer:
Document your obserVations every  15  minutes.
Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift.
EQ54e_in Suicide Watch Observation Log
Nam of Inmate
on watch: Reg #: -qC 9 3 i3,- 0 54 Date: 11231n
Initials Time Observations: Briefly note your observations. Initial all entries.
V.4 DAM \nrraf. by° 0 - down fonuicide CCIIi44
I .."--6 Am in rndi-e- Iyin on bed
2:00Am Inmai-e 5 H-liri cri be'd +0 I king
2 '• i 5A NI Inrnoci-e L5ita-ve...-lig celirn3+e. 4-ried -foKiiii
Z.3Diam I nroal-e. ,5;.\--t-ins on ba•-\ +.1 it-9 +o reme-nbev-
vii-ni- hinpv-±nali
.z../45A,4 Inmaie ai-1-4-in)  on bed
3'. co Intrdlit_ , i-1-1-ing on bed
3:I 5 Atvt Li-. Arder3a-) --144es pic+uv-es cC i nrriflie
5 .30Am Inmni-e oi-V-Viro on bed
3',46Aki I nmai-e 6 i-1-ti n5 on be6
.4.00Am Incnale. c.5;4-iing on bed
4, i5mvi lornale. ,...1.1+-Kn9 on bed
4133Am nrcn+e. ,5-icirlflin a- dcor +alicir9
kA5Am Inmd-ie (.54-Ctrriin9 0.4 door 4-a I kier)
5: COAm 1 nrna -ie 5 i -Hi no on bed
5:15Am I nrnok, c5+ard ir9 614- door
5...3DAkn I nmn-i-e. 6-11-irdi no al door
5,45Atvi
4.
I nnufe. c5i-randino a+ door
lv..00Am Innft-l-e ,i-brcliryi al- disc
c9'.15 , m jai* - A10 A .4 & & or
(t?'„Bom•ii inerni-e- 64artiia 614 door
lo..45Am Inma-it. (Nan6inis al- <Inn r
7 .. 00 Ann Inmate - O-iOn6in9 ai- dour
Note to all observers: Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift.
Mail Attachment
Page 12638
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
( Preferred Voice )
( Work Voice )
( Voice Cell )
( Preferred Internet )
Version
2.1
PRODID
-//Novell Inc//Groupwise 12.0.3
X-GWTYRe
USER
F rrtaillii m
Name
Family: M.
First:
Middle:
Prefix:
Suffix:
Electronic Mail Address ( Preferred Internet )
UID
835B5E40-1106-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Telephone Number (PrefePreferred Voice )
allpi  Voice )
Tele li  ( Voice Cell )
Title
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
Last Revision
20190812T050046Z
X-GWUDF
11 (BES User ID)981
X•GWUDF
1 0(BES Ref ID)0
SW Chronological Log 7/23-24/19 re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
From
To
Date 2019/08/12 15:53
Subject: SW Chronological Log 7/23-24/19 re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg.
No. 73618-054
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Epstein SW Chronological Log 7-23-19.pdf
00 Thomas was assigned to staff watch; however, the wrong book was used (VM companion log) in lieu of
Staff Suicide Watch log.
DTS discovered the wrong log was used. completed a 2nd log using Suicide Watch log
initialed the log for Thomas).
Entries are identical in both logs.
Page 12641
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D518B84.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.B67333.1.1 44C3.1
Message Path fonlCabineRNERO0nst - New YorklAut5D518B84.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.1367333.1.144C3.1.mi
From
Dis pia) Name
Email
QUID 835B5E40-11C6-0000-03D6-FE66A7708950
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject SW Ckonalogkal Log 7/23-24/19 re: Epsteix Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Scheduled date 2019-08-12 155337
Creation date 2019-08-12 15:53:37
Modified date 2019-08-22 20:4824
Delis e red date 2019.08-12 15:53A1
Message size 311
Attachments sin 429480
Total size 429802
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hun
Content II)
5D518884.NERDOMLNERADM1.20R200000D.LE
E155.1(§45:5D518B84.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.1
367333.1.144C3.1@l5D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERA DM1.100.1367333.1.142FF.1@l3
Is Inline fake
Type ft
Size 629
Date 2019-08-12 115337
CA f355e3743565Pr7c111a6e8697147370
Hash 2B5900FB794C4BE.55A0EE2CC95540DA0743B7F2E A7ED3A5900DD50C70B89FC IEE I 172F26
Attachment Epstein SW Chronological Log 743-19.pdf
Name Epstein SW Chronological Log 7-23-19.pdf
Content ID
5D5113B84.NERDOMLNERADMI.200.2000000.1.E
E156.1(4)45:5D518B84.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.1
367333.1.144O.1(g 1:5D4E9C39.NERDOM LNERA DM I. 10R1367333.1.142FF.1@l3
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 428851
Date 2019-08-12 11:4024
CA Mfibe71€2980o93e05f4152d8b4e6b0c
Hash 653CFAFA209F389967EFB49754887FAMC61A3F261E08243157659D2D55AFF876B3C2021
Recipients
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 6 ICI:9350-0B4F-0000-AB39-F80F2A59A443
Distribution "fype CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2F982.13S0- I4C1-0000-9B47-BF62C05FIE96
Distribution Tpe TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay deliver) until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read tin
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification "hen opened fake
Page 12642
Return notification %%hen deleted false
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification 'then declined fake
Return notification 'then
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D518884.NERDOMI.NERADMLIC0.1367333.1.1 44C3.1@l5D4E9C39.14ERDOMLNERADM1.100.13
67333.1.142EF.1®13
Source received
Class it
Account DOMI
1540843691206 Location II)
Class Name 09.MF.SSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Aug
ID 5D4E9C39.NERDOMI.NERADMI.IOO.I367333.1.142FF.1Q13
Name Aug
Type Normal
Ssste m fake
Share Tspe NotShared
Published 2019E/23-0:4834
Page 12643
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-11-W206333 EST Created
en=Arehive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archive I.cn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNode.en-archiv
ilgcs ietmail
Generated by Neigpvem Kr -Archive
Agent _2-Zero Day
Atria; Len-Jobs.en-GWOperiNolesn-archia
iigo-netinail
2020-05-19 1528:59 EDT Tag ROP01703.MXRADMI.MMIDOMI Responsive
2020-05-1915:17/36 EDT Tag BOP01703.M3CRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05.19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
Page 12644
Mail Attachment
Epstein SW Chronological Log 7-23-19.pdf
Page 12645
Suicide Watch
Chronological
Log
Inmate Companions Log
Name of inmate on watch:
Er s)-eniN
Register #:
°S
Institution:
Date Watch Began / Ended
ONLY
ITEMS
ALLOWED:
To be completed by Chief Psychologist at conclusion of watch:
Booklet of
Suicide
Mattress
SWCL - INMATE

╭────────────────────── Page 195, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ Suicide Watch                                                 │
│ Chronological                                                 │
│ Log                                                           │
│                                                               │
│ Inmate Companions Log                                         │
│                                                               │
│ Name of inmate on watch:                                      │
│                                                               │
│ — . w                                                         │
│ vy                                                            │
│ Epsi« 9 3 no                                                  │
│ Register #: 2 2 a                                             │
│ Da uv                                                         │
│ Ayre. sf 2 333                                                │
│ ol 5                                                          │
│ Institution: 2_288s                                           │
│ =zs3&2 Ss                                                     │
│ uw o nn                                                       │
│ E ooo                                                         │
│ >2555                                                         │
│ Date Watch Began / Ended 3 Sess                               │
│ 355                                                           │
│ af 4 CAAA                                                     │
│ vy                                                            │
│                                                               │
│ To be completed by Chief Psychologist at conclusion of watch: │
│                                                               │
│ Booklet ____ of                                               │
│                                                               │
│ Paper Cup                                                     │
│ Soap                                                          │
│                                                               │
│ ‘sweL-                                                        │
│                                                               │
│ INMATE                                                        │
│                                                               │
│ Tampons or                                                    │
│                                                               │
│ Eaam Canitary Ralt/Mankin                                     │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

STAPLE LOCAL PROCEDURES HERE
Check one of the following:
❑ This is the initial log book for this suicide watch.
Enter date and time watch began:
❑ This is a continuation log book for this watch.
Enter date and time this watch book was initiated:
Instructions to Observer:
Document your observations every   minutes.
Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift.
Suicide Watch Observation Log
Name of Inmate ei t .,1,-, 1 ,
on watch: .)le ' I 1 Reg IS: 1,6lb .54 Date: -1 23 fq
Time Observations: Briefly note your observations. initial all entries. Initials
I : L1°AltI in  „.„„, 40 stA ly i. Le 00 I I II-4 1. qs- ,t, in) 0 gfo a 2 Alvt kW (H ;e --) i  A- 1 fr
2 Aw, tm 1-.. k5 , s meg k A rr i.1 4 (co
k ;
Wk A 4A ft
2 1 LI 34As P .) 3 6 A 4 “11 (
• Awl r C, ikli 6e 6
5.(5 L 4,,..34-56,) -1-4 k4 pic furs
4/
.3'' /AA git4-31 ?-e3
L. ICC 1
S. :r.-T el:)
e&
D . 2 A3
10 I Ins S ' 44 — hm r •
:qs- (fri cb--4J,\ 41 1 4. ,  4 : 4-1kft
, nil td
,....5
in-(
- 1,4-‘,,L. c.-4- bcei 4
ctr oe , it, ..N A
e,
Note to all observers: Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift.

╭─────────────────────────────────── Page 197, Image 1 ───────────────────────────────────╮
│ Suicide Watch Observation Log                                                           │
│                                                                                         │
│ Name otiamate- =>                                                                       │
│ fon watch: Epsiern Regt: 14515: SY _ ate: 1/23] G                                       │
│ Time Observations: Briefly note your observations. initial all entries. initia          │
│                                                                                         │
│ Ew | Yu Breaght Nam do Surcike ceil Fol                                                 │
│ Ta “Jaw Try ont Be                                                                      │
│ Zz                                                                                      │
│                                                                                         │
│ ‘em _| Te 8 wy be Ielteing                                                              │
│ Sn | Tw Sf bs7 Ms Ce lfwok trird fe il                                                  │
│                                                                                         │
│ him ——                                                                                  │
│ 2 34, Lm i ing ne) tryg Fr vtwveot                                                      │
│ what slant ———                                                                          │
│ Te | fw i Friant BE ———                                                                 │
│ Se | Ym Si Pig oe Be —                                                                  │
│ Len (7 oem? tales pictues of tlw                                                        │
│ Sue ry Siting a EO —— |                                                                 │
│ a Sted on Bed                                                                           │
│ Sl SS DS                                                                                │
│ 4 pn Sry BS                                                                             │
│ pe The vt Som +bh[ hx                                                                   │
│ Cha tna F Jer tes J                                                                     │
│                                                                                         │
│ =                                                                                       │
│                                                                                         │
│ Dan | ug Sibhien et bed                                                                 │
│ Soe | 4 liv tF Deer                                                                     │
│ Cre | en qendad wR Sa 3                                                                 │
│                                                                                         │
│ Siw [la 8s at 4                                                                         │
│ fu Va. Jig wef Dav                                                                      │
│                                                                                         │
│ Note to all observers: Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift. │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Suicide Watch
Chronological
Log
Staff Suicide Watch
Observers Only
* Namq on watch
E P1r). J.
Regittpr
3{o:StP) ,-dr-j4
InOtitiftion:
MOP. tNifttnl*yi<
DateiVatch Began ,/ Ended
July 23,2.014 -
To be completed by Chief Psychologist at conclusion of watch:
Booklet of
SWCL - STAFF

╭────────────────────── Page 198, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ Suicide Watch                                                 │
│ Chronological                                                 │
│ Log -                                                         │
│                                                               │
│ Staff Suicide Watch * :                                       │
│                                                               │
│ “Observers Only. ~                                            │
│                                                               │
│ ‘Name of inimats on ‘watch:                                   │
│ Epstein, J.                                                   │
│ Register #: 4                                                 │
│ Hosig-0sd gee                                                 │
│ Sanstitation:.                                                │
│ Daté Watch Began/ Ended . Ee                                  │
│                                                               │
│ chuly 23.2010 = July 24,4014                                  │
│                                                               │
│ To be completed by Chief Psychologist at conclusion of watch: │
│                                                               │
│ Booklet of                                                    │
│                                                               │
│ ae                                                            │
│                                                               │
│ ‘SWCL - STAFF                                                 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

STAPLE LOCAL PROCEDURES HERE
Check one of the following:
This is the initial log book for this suicide watch.
Enter date and time watch began:
July 23)2otg a4- rAomvi
This a continuation log book for this watch:
Enter date and time this watch book wailnillata td:'
Instructions to Observer:
Document your obserVations every  15  minutes.
Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift.
EQ54e_in Suicide Watch Observation Log
Nam of Inmate
on watch: Reg #: --q (4, 3 i3, - 054 Date: 11231n
Initials Time Observations: Briefly note your observations. Initial all entries.
V.4 DAM \nrraf. by° 0 - down ft) suicideC..C11#1-
I ..45A4 inrndi -e- lyin on bed
2:00Am Ennial-e 3H-liri al be'd +0 I king
2. i5A NI Inrna.1-e L5itale...-li 5 ceurn3+e. 4-rieA -foKtilr
Z.3Diam I nroal -e. ,5;1-+-ins on ba•-\ +.1 it-9 +o reme-nbet -
wiyai- hinpr±nali
.z../45A,4 Inmaie ai-1-4-in) on bed
3'.0DA)vi InryYli-t_ ,i-1-1-ing cn bed
3 I 5 Ao Li -. Arder3a -) --144es pi c+uv-es or i nrni-ie
5 .30Am Inmni-e oi-V-iiro on bed
3'. SAM Inmqi -e 60 -tin5 on be6
.4.00Am Incnale. ,5; 4-Vi  on bed
4 .. 150cuvi lornn-le c_Ii-I-1-in9 on iced
4.3OAM nrrill -e. ,5-Innflin a- dcor +alicin3
4.-45AM Inrnn4e_ (.54zarriin9 Cli. door 4-alkiryj
5*. MANI 1nrn04-e 5i-Hins on bed
5:15Am Inrnoit (-5.61rdi cl' door
5 .-3DAkn I nmn-i-e. 6-1-rirdi no al door
5,45Am Intrnfe. <3i-cooing a+ door
(v..00/\m 1 nrrq-1-e. ,i -brrlir .9 al- disc
(p'. I5 , m jai* ' Aid! A al O. di Or
p*„.BoArA int-rya -1-e- c 4Qr \aj C11- door
lo..45Am Inma -it. (Nan6inis Gil- hnor
. mAtvi Inmai -e, O -k3n6in9 01- lour
Note to all observers: Legibly print and sign your name at the beginning of your shift.
Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
From
To
Date 2019/09/11 15:55
Subject: Re: Fwd: TOY Costs for MCC New York
Attachments: TEXT.htun
Good Afternoon,
After a review of the budget, Central Office is able to cover the TDY expenses for NYM. Your financial
management staff should be receiving an e-mail shortly with the project and cost center to use for these
expenses.
Please let me know if you have any questions.
Thanks,
Senior Deputy Assistant Director
Administration Division
Federal Bureau of Prisons
>>> > 8/30/201911:52 AM >>>
Thanks. Yes, the TDY is related to them putting new procedures and policies in place to improve local
processes related to the incident. The TDY staff are training local staff or are providing coverage/assistance
while NYM staff put new procedures in place. Thanks in advance.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Front
Date 8/30/19 11:32 AM GMT-05:00
To:
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
> > > 'a 08/30/201911:32 >>>
Hello Ray,
Yes, the MDC Brooklyn incident was covered by special project. However, this was to cover assistance
throughout the duration of the incident along with chiller and repair costs. The Regional staff could not
provide justification for additional expenses directly related to the Epstein incident. The only explanation
provided was due to staff shortage, MCC NY was bringing in staff for staff assist. I explained to the Regional
Page 12652
Lomptrouter mat bureau InglEULIOF1S are surrenny rrom scary snortayes natic.mmue arm any expenses
associated with those shortages are being absorbed at those locations or Regions. We did however provide
utilization of the project code for the travel expenses of the after action team. I've advised all the Regional
Comptrollers, due to priority spending directed by DO1, such as FSA spending, we would re-evaluate our
budget status during the first week of September to see if any additional funding can be provided. We will
certainly help if we can. Please let me know if you have any additional questions.
Thanks,
> » 8/28/2019 10:08 AM > »
■ - See below. Is the special project not covering the TDY cost for MCC NYM? Was the TDY cost during
the MDC BRO incident covered by the special project? Thanks in advance.
Regional Director
Northeast R ion
> » 8/26/2019 2:34 PM > »
The Administration Division has provided us a guidance that we are not authorized to charge any of our TDY
Expenses to the project 87F, Eptein Death at the national level. It was explained to us that the project was
established for regional tracking purposes only and we at the regional level will have to absorb all TDY costs
related to MCC New York.
So far, approximately 60 staff from various institutions for various dates as early as 8/18 through 9/28 are
scheduled for TDY to New York.
The estimated costs for TDY expenses will be approximately $500.000.
Please let me know if you have any questions. Thanks.
Page 12653
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D7918ED.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.1367333.1.1 56C5.1
Message Path xmliCabinebNERO\DicetorVkDM/5D7918ED.N EFtDOMENERADMI.100.B67333.1.156C5.1.xml
From
Display Name
Entail
QUID B2E8DF81-IBII.0000-9EF2.000083219F4E
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Re: Fwd:TDY Costs for MCC New York
Scheduled date 201909-11 153523
Creation date 201909-11 15:5523
Modified date 201909-12 14:4831
Delis e red date 201909.11155526
Message size 3100
Attachments sin 4629
Total size 7740
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.hbn
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D7918ED.NERDOMLNERADM1.200.20000E7.1.6
E6D4.1®455D7918ED.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.1
367331 I.156C5.1(§1:5BA9E745.NERDOMENERA DMI.100.1367333.I.AB93.1QI3
Is Inline false
Type file
Sin 4629
Date 2019-0911 113525
CA 28c8b7abc901a8541927b6bl7102dbcd
Hash 763EE9665DC05BESBE22000SFB9B9F2F4A23DBAF 3D914AE5A6B964ABDIBIA65272A0BBA3
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
ILIUM F09FC101-l656-0000-8495.000083219F58
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UU1D 21:9821180-14O.0000-9B47-BF62C05FIE%
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Nonnal
Box type It
Return notification when opened false
Return notification when deleted false
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification when declined false
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D7918ED.NERDOMENERADMI.100.1367333.1.1 56C5.1@l5BA9E745.NERDOM I.NERADM1.100.13
67333.1.AB93.1®B
Source received
Class Public
Account RDOMI
Page 12654
Location ID 1540842445516
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder ADM
ID 5BA9E745.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.1367333.1.A 893.1@ 13
Name ADM
Type Normal
System false
Share Type NoiShared
Page 12655
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-19 203535 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Archive!
Job.en-lebs.en-GWOpenNode.en-archiviv,e Agent_I-Daily
setmai
Generated by Netrred Inc. [en-Archive
Archive!
Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNode.en—archivinga
—nettnad]
2020.05-19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.N1XR DOMI Fbeted
2020-05-19144136 EDT Tag BOP017031OCRADMI.N1 XR DOM I Flagged
2020-05-19 153006 EDT Tag BOP0I703.MXRADMI.NIXRIX Ail Responsive
2020-05-191530.41 EDT Tag BOP01703.143CRADMI.AINRIX All Responsive
Page 12656
Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
From
To
Date 2019/09/11 18:08
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
Attachments: TEXT.httn
Thanks!!
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Ori inal messa e
From: < >
Date: 9/11/19 3:55 PM (GMT-05:00)
To:
Cc:
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
>».
Good Afternoon,
09/11/2019 15:55 >> >
After a review of the budget, Central Office is able to cover the TDY expenses for NYM. Your financial
management staff should be receiving an e-mail shortly with the project and cost center to use for these
expenses.
Please let me know if you have any questions.
Thanks,
Senior Deputy Assistant Director
Administration Division
Federal Bureau of Prisons
>» > 8/30/2019 11:52 AM »>
Thanks. Yes, the TDY is related to them putting new procedures and policies in place to improve local
processes related to the incident. The TDY staff are training local staff or are providing coverage/assistance
while NYM staff put new procedures in place. Thanks in advance.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Page 12657
Ori inal messa e
From: < >
Date: 8/30/19 11:32 AM (GMT-05:00)
To:
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
> » 'a 08/30/201911:32 > > >
Hello Ray,
Yes, the MDC Brooklyn incident was covered by special project. However, this was to cover assistance
throughout the duration of the incident along with chiller and repair costs. The Regional staff could not
provide justification for additional expenses directly related to the Epstein incident. The only explanation
provided was due to staff shortage, MCC NY was bringing in staff for staff assist. I explained to the Regional
Comptroller that Bureau institutions are suffering from staff shortages nationwide and any expenses
associated with those shortages are being absorbed at those locations or Regions. We did however provide
utilization of the project code for the travel expenses of the after action team. I've advised all the Regional
Comptrollers, due to priority spending directed by DO1, such as FSA spending, we would re-evaluate our
budget status during the first week of September to see if any additional funding can be provided. We will
certainly help if we can. Please let me know if you have any additional questions.
Thanks,
> » 8/28/2019 10:08 AM > »
- See below. Is the special project not covering the TDY cost for MCC NYM? Was the TDY cost during
the MDC BRO incident covered by the special project? Thanks in advance.
Regional Director
Northeast R ion
> » 8/26/2019 2:34 PM > »
The Administration Division has provided us a guidance that we are not authorized to charge any of our TDY
Expenses to the project 87F, Eptein Death at the national level. It was explained to us that the project was
established for regional tracking purposes only and we at the regional level will have to absorb all TDY costs
related to MCC New York.
So far, approximately 60 staff from various institutions for various dates as early as 8/18 through 9/28 are
scheduled for TDY to New York.
The estimated costs for TDY expenses will be approximately $500.000.
Please let me know if you have any questions. Thanks.
Page 12658
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D793829.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.B67333.1.1 56D5.1
Message Path xmVMaixoV5D793829.NERDOMLNERADMI.100 .B67333.I.I56135.I.xml
From
Display Name
Entail
UUID 2F982B80.14C3-0000-9B47-BF62C05FIE96
Reply To
Text
To
Re:144:MT Costs for MCC New York
2019-09-11 180790
2019-09-11 18:07A0
2019-09-11 203602
20I9-09-I I 1808:41
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.hbn
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID 5D793829.NERDOMINERADMI.200.2000039.1.5 36EE. li(n)45:5D793829.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.1
367333.1.156D5.1(MI:7.NERDOMLNERADM 1.100.0.1.0.1@16
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 5365
CA 6b5d890961)38lbec2la9dDed3bfle624
Hash 08FED2ID5A7AAEE3ADC0D77334A207D8ABCIE63C6685E22079AAC6FC9ACS8DE7D4AFA34337
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID FO9FC RA - lb50-0080-8495-000083219F58
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-09-II 1808)42
DonnloadedllyThirdParty 2019-09-11180&43
Opened 2019-09-II ISIS)52,4
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CND B2E8DF81-1B11-00004EF2-000083219F4E
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-09-II I8O3.42
DonnloadedByThirdParty 2019-0%11 18138.43
Opened 2019-09-11 203537
Deleted 2019-09-I I 2036DI
Expire 0
Delay delis e ry until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read MC
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification %Men opened fake
Return notification when deleted false
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification sshen declined fake
Return notification when
accepted fake
Page 12659
Archive Version 5.3
Internal II) 5D793829.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.1367333.1.1 56C/5.1®RTNERDOMI.NERADMI.100.0.1.0.1(4)1 6
Source sent
Class Public
Account RDOMI
1540842445516 Location II)
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Mal=
Type Hatbox
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12660
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019.09.1920A2.47 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Archive)
Job.en-lebs.crGWOpenNode.en-arc hiviv,e Agcnt_I-Daily
setmai
Generated by Netrred Inc. [crrArchiye
Archive)
Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNock.cn-archivinga
-nettnad]
2020-05-19 14:34:34 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXR DOMI Fbeaced
2020-05-19144136 EDT Tag BOPOI7CONDCRADM 1.Ni XR DOM I Flagged
2020-05-19 I53006 EDT Tag BOPOI703.MXRADM 1.rd XR 1 X Ail Responsive
2020-05-19 15:30:4I EDT Tag BOPOI703.NOCRADM 1.AINit IR ri.1 1 Responsive
Page 12661
End: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
From
To
Date 2019/09/11 15:57
Subject: Fwd: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Page 12662
FYI
Sent from my %Wirral, Sammy Galaxy smanphonc
aC rr, "same
Front
Date:9/11/19 3:55 PM GMT-05:00
To:
Cc:
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs or MCC New York
>>> 09/11/2019 15:55>>>
Good Afternoon,
After a review of the budget, Central Office is able to cover the TON' expenses tin NN'\t. Your financial management 
staff should he rectis ing an e-mail
Please let me know if you have any questions.
Senior Deputy Assistant Director
Administration Division
Federal Bureau of Prisons
>>> < > 8/30/2019 11:52 AM >»
Thanks. Yes, the TDY is related to them putting new procedures and policies in place to improve local processes related 
to the incident. The TDY staff a
Sent front my Verizon. Samsung Galaxy smanphone
message
From:
Date: ft/30/19 11:32 AM (GMT-05:00
To:
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
>>> "==" 08/30/2019 11:32 >»
Hello Ray.
Yes, the MDC Brooklyn incident was covered by special project. However, this was to cover assistance throughout the 
duration of the incident along wit
evaluate our budget status during the lint week of September to see if any additional funding can be provided. We will 
certainly help if we can. Please I.
>>> 8/28/2019 10:08 AM >»
- See below. Is the special project not covering the WY cost for MCC NYM? Was the WY cost during the MDC BRO incident 
covered by the si
Regional Director
>>> 8/26/2019 2:34 PM >»
The Administration Division has provided us a guidance that we arc not authorized to charge any of our TDY Expenses to 
the project 87F.. Eptcin Death
So far, approximately 60 staff from various institutions for various dates as early as 8/18 through 9/28 are scheduled 
for TDY to New York.
The estimated costs for TDY expenses will be approximately 5500.000.
Please let me know if you have any questions. Thanks.
Page 12663
her Mrs
/*Pt* Vehee
MessagelD 3173119% NFROOMI NERADMI 1010671111.1 56C7.I
Monte Path tn•Nterhm5079195*NERDOMI NERADMI lee) 1367311I 156C7 Lead
From
DIspkt Na
Cell
trio 3 1061003141.30(0IMM7.10112COMIIIM
Reply T.
Teti
To
S610 11 hod lIed IDA Cats for MCC New Val
Selteeked date 310601.11 153637
Chew. *MORO 153.57
Madded dile 10 NOAH 155796
Delver*** *MORO 155704
Message slat 1557
Mud* Oa
**on 10151
*amen.
Anashme at 11130 Aim
%env ILXIMIn
Cereal II) 5D79110ASERDOMI NIRADMI Z3010009 1 5 1M)016015:11)19199:1NOTDOMI NEPAD111.1061
167111I ISM / 110 II NIRDOMI NTRADML 100 010 VV 14
D IS- fa*
'OM *
ke 600
CA itan: 1601556mt104301**
Halm fiSMINMacostrtAXMISAMAL'Arnhisctuil OmisnmenatacAMICOMIAIMsuir
Reel** I
RetiMem
10•141, Mat
Emil
LIAO 31110020**4000A0ATICCIMINOC6
DleMballes 1)pe TO
Deehliem TM toe
Meer* M194M1 1 05704
Dowel**111011doldmit M1940.111557.
.... SI40MII133716
Feamited 30194/011 1557*
Etplre 0
Deb, twee. *I 0
Delegated Wit
Matted fa*
Read ow
Dekk0 Mk
*fled trty
Completed fabe
Seder* *and
ma my Net lerme
Rota. rears's. Ian oilseed fabe
*In Milk** Mrs dekerd Id.
Reran metlicadeolle•
C.--0 isle
Rows lemilkstle Mem deelimed fake
*emu mallkskatae•
semis* Old
Ant.. Mal* 51
Noma, ID 10791950NERDOMI NERADMI 10.1167/311.1 5tC7.10 IIMERDOM I NERADMI.MUCt 64161 1 6
Maw sent
C . INtIc
Maim, .SUMINIADOMI
Imam ID IM011310516
an% Name GWMEssAGEMAIL
Carbalft Milm 1
Mee Mail*
ID I NFROOMINOLUMII IMO 1 0 IM 16
Ns Mad*
bre Alaltett
*Mem tow
Ma rm. Na lie
Page 12664
Avis
Doe Aar Asir Note
3/1•0949 Xt4231 EDT Creak.'
11-Alaar Awn 1.0ak Arclael
lobes- klakan4 iViererNukiraselnawAe ga -
rimemed by Kari Ix ifirAitilit
I•Daly MC Mel
Ab.carkti.coraDTOINedeararainll<
-acima)
102605-19 10 ,04 EDT Tau 301011(0 MMADM I NORTKOM Flawed
latD46- I9 144156 EDT Tag 30•00011.1MtADM I NIXRDOM I Float,'
292006.19 15300. EDT lag 30101103 ‘IXRADM I NIXRDOMI Rlysnc
20200349 153041 EDT Tau 1010,10.1 %DRAM, I MXRDOM I Mcnnt
Page 12665
Re: MCC Chicago staffing issues
From
To
Date 2019/08/21 19:31
Subject: Re: MCC Chicago staffing issues
Attachments: TEXT.lum
93-95% not too bad...way better than NY. Goal is 100 but seems like sensationalism in story. In any event,
just touch base with warden to ensure policy being followed, especially concerning the high profile inmates.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Ori inal messa e
From: < >
Date: 8/21/19 7:22 PM (GMT-05:00)
To: ' < > < >,
< >, < >
Subject: Re: MCC Chicago staffing issues
> » " * 08/21/2019 19:22 > »
We have another ICT Phase one class starting in September. As of last pay period we were close to 93
percent in custody. By Sept we should be close to 95 percent.
> » < > 8/21/2019 5:30 PM > »
II , see below link. not helping again. Not sure what the staffing is like at MCC but probably should look
into status and progress. Also may want to be sure proper procedures are happening. Would be really bad if
have another Epstein episode.
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nbcchicago.com/on-air/as-seen-on/safety-concerns-rise-at-
metropolitan-correctional-center-as-officers-continue-to-retire-557354402.html%3famp=y
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Page 12666
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D5D9BF4.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4A573 .1
Message Path xmliCabinetWCRO/5D5D9BF4.80PMSCO.PO4.10 0.13161172.1.4A573.1.nnl
From
Display Name
Email
UUID B922A560-1581.0000-B66C-FACF6A00A51C
Reply To
Text
To II I I i
Subject Re: MC 'C C'hiyago staffing MUCS
Scheduled date 2019-08-21 19:3047
Creation date 2019-08-21 1930:47
Modified date 2019-08-22 07:1(x12
Delivered date 2019-08-21 193100
Message sine 1454
Attachments fat 2437
Total size 3902
Attachments 1
Attachment TFaXT.hun
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID 5D5D9BF4.BOPMSCO.PO4.200.200000D.I.3B3A8 D.1@455D5D9BF4.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316872.
1.4A573.1®158009494.BOPMSCO.PO4.1C0.131 6B72.1.389CA.1@l3
Is Inline fake
Type fik
Sin 2437
CA 6b0d0193128c805c6b3cc9864857eba0
Has h FD3007507308.578945842BIE7134C0B884A99C706 A68705C160FFED9EA58A870B8982788E
Recipients
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID C9BD4C60-050D-0000-8363-DC66561970DB
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08.21193101
DonnloadedByllfirdPart • 2019-08-21 193103
Opened 2019-08-21 193426
Replied 2019-08-21 1934:36
Recipient
Display Name I
Email
UUID 1663D3A0.I002.0000-8CA3-000000100002
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08-21 19:3101
DoanloadedByThirdParty 2019-06.21 193102
Opened 2019-08-21 19:32:12
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 70785081-IF82-0000.8528-000083219F45
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08-21 193101
DossnloadedllyThirdParty 2019-08.211931:02
Opened 2019- 2I 2034:13
R cipient
Display Name
Email
UUID F550404( 1461)- -94D5-000083246730
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Uscr
Delivered 2019-08-21 19310D
DonnloadedByTbirdParty 2019-08.21193101
Opened 2019-08-21 73 0 2A2
Page 12667
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed fake
Stultify Normal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification when opened false
Return notification when deleted false
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification when
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal II) 505D913F4.130PMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.I.4A573 .1@i3B009494.BOPMSCO.P04103.1316B72.1.
389CA.1@l3
Source sent
Class Pubic
Account ~PO4.BOPMSCO
Location II) 1540343449744
Class Name OW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder NCRO
ID 5B009494.BOPMSCO.PO4.100. I 316B72.1.389CA . I @l3
Name NCRO
Type Normal
System fake
Share Type NotShared
Page 12668
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-31 0120A7 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive8
Job.en-Jcbsxn-GWOpenNodeararchivitgriAgelli-
tetmai
Generated by Netrnad Inc. [crt-Archive
I -DailY Archiw8Job.cn-Jobsa-GWOpenNotle.en—archivingd
—netinad]
2020-05-0 15:30A5 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 12669
Re: Fwd: Re MCC Medical Emergency
From
To
Date 2019/12/04 17:40
Subject: Re: Fwd: Re MCC Medical Emergency
Attachments: TEXT.htin
Good deal. Thanks
> » 12/4/2019 5:27 PM > »
Yes, I spoke with the RD and informed him inmate Elansky was seen in medical this afternoon. The RD
indicated he responded to the Rabbi and informed him of the same. The RD indicated unless inmate Elansky
had a major medical issue, which the assessment indicated nothing major that the assessment was sufficient
and required no additional response to the Rabbi.
Associate Warden
MCC New York
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
> > > 12/4/2019 5:17 PM > »
Did you respond to the RD an, if so, with what information? Thanks.
>>> 12/4/201911:47 AM >>>
and - Please review the attached and advise of his medical status and if/when these issues
have been addressed. Thanks
Regional Director
Northeast R ion
> » Shmuel Spritzer <shmu569@aol.com> 12/4/2019 11:45 AM > »
I am sorry to have to bring these issues to you in the
last weeks of your leadership. But because there is no
warden at MCC NY, and the following is an emergency
we bring to you- attention and you will know what to do.
Michael Elansky 90791-054 is fighting for his life, and it
seems to be neglected in a most terrible manner.
Page 12670
He writes that he has complained to his unit counselor and to health.
He has migraines for over two weeks, throwing up and diarrhea. All
who see him, can see he is in distress. Hs hands and body shake with
tremors and he feels he is becoming weaker every day. He has problems
focusing because of all this, and no one seems to care. This is the same
facility where staff was caught sleeping and forging the log, the night
Epstein committed suicide. He needs to brace himself against the wall
when he walks.
It is an emergency matter and lets hope for the best, as it has already
deteriorated to the extreme.
Thank you.
Rabbi Shmuel Spritzer
Page 12671
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5DE7EFA7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.1011.170316D.I. 13180.1
Message Path xmtiMabx45DE7EFA7.NYMDOM INYMADMI.100 .170316D.1.131B0.13anl
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 70608620-10EI-0000-947A-4AEAF7774805
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: End: Re N1CC Medical Emergency
Scheduled date 2019-12-04 17:40:16
Creation date 2019-12-04 17:40:16
Modified date 2019-12-04 170:15
Delivered date 2019-12-04 17:4036
Message size 2003
Attachments size 8799
Total size 10813
Attachments I
Attachment TEXF.htm
Name TEXT.Inm
Content ID
5DE7EFA7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000CA.1.4
OFB7.1®453DE7EFA7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
70316D.1.131B0.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 8799
Date 2019-12-04 12A0.16
CA cf33264da8b510c96aSb07325cediat05
Hash 4434350A4A4CBF7CC25C95BDF5DF056322AFOF3E 1576A65380EABBC5DIA64E588A914C55
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name _
Email
UUID 835B5EA0-l1C6-0000-B3D6-FE66AT708950
Distribution Ewe TO
Recipient T)pe User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Intox
Return notification nhen opened false
Return notification n he n deleted fake
Return notification nhen
completed false
Return notification %Oven declined false
Return notification %%hell
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal II) 5DE7EFA7.NYMDOMLNYMADM I. 100. I 703 I 6D. 1.1 31 BO. I ® Il.NYMDOM I.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1® I
Source received
Class Public
Account ESTADMI.ESTDOMI
Location ID 1540842445516
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Native Madbox
Type hatbox
Page 12672
System
Share Type
UM
NotShared
Page 12673
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2020.01-0919530130 EST ( 1 .ucd
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive!
Joben-Jcbs.cr GWOpenNodeen-archivingdAgcm_1-Daily
mtetmai
Generated by Netgovem [cn-Archiw
Archive Ioben-Jobsen-GWOpenNoieen-archningo
-netmaill
2020-05-19 I5:3606 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I ItISRI)0M1 Responsive
2020-05-19153006 EDT Tag BOP01700.frOCRADMI.NIXRIXMAI Responsive
2020-05-19 14:41:56 EDT Tag BOP017033.4)CRADMI.AIRRIX)M1 Rigged
Page 12674
Fwd: Suicide Watch/Psych Observation Update
From
To
Date 2019/08/10 19:13
Subject: Fwd: Suicide Watch/Psych Observation Update
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Sent from my Verizon. Samsung Galaxy smarrphone
message
From:
Date: 7/30/19 12:30 PM GMT-05:00
Page 12675
Su ject:Suicide Watch/Psych Observation Update
>» ' 07/30/2019 12:30 >»
Inmate Epstein #76318-
054 is being taken off of Psych Observation and needs to be housed with an appropriate cellmate.
Suicide Watch
None
Psych Observation
None
Thank you,
Page 12676
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D4F173C.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1326C35.1.B E09.1
Message Path xmYTrash/5D4F173C.NYMDOMINYMADMI.1100.1 326C35.I.BE09.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 9D77B2D0.19C1-00011A989-0200000058DO
Reply To
Text
To
kW. Suicide Watch/Psych Observation Update Subject
Scheduled date 2019-08-10 19:1146
Creation date 201908-1019:1146
Modified date 201908-1019.7:19
Delivered date 201908-10 19:1301
Message size 2967
Attachments slat 3816
Total silt 6794
Attachments 1
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEX'T.larn
Content ID
5D4F173C.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.200003&13
E968.1®45:5D4F173C.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.1
326C35.1.BE09.1@l9.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline fake
'type fie
Size 3816
e9fa850f074fc96ba9a5c7a621:90ecb6
Rash 803C39FB32AFC9EF431692D5E2B793540318C5E2 1A00EBBCFF187DCC777FEC4BDIC564BD
Recipients 1
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CND 610E935043B4F•0000•AB39•FSOF2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted 0111C
Opened Inc
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Intros
Return notification %%hen opened fake
Return notification nhen deleted fake
Return notification %%hen
completed fake
Return notification sshen declined fake
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D4F1173C.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1326C35.1.B E09.1@l9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l8
Source received
Class Public
Account FAIADMI.FAIDOM I
Location ID 1540843105474
Class Name CAV.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Trash
ID 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System trot
Page 12677
Shan.
I
H
"
Page 12678

╭─ Page 227, Image 1 ─╮
│ ‘Share Type         │
│                     │
│ NavStared           │
│                     │
│ Page 12678          │
╰─────────────────────╯

Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-11 02:1452 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent 1-Daly Trash3
Jobrn-lcbs.cn-Gi/OpenNodern-archivitg.orAgent-
Ictmai
Generated by Norma Inc. [crrArchive
I -Daily Trash3 Jobrn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNodern-archivingo
-ix trna ill
2019-08-21 094301 EDT Exponed noon Emma anetorti Exported by netmailsornainomail
2019-08-21 12:4247 EDT Exported neuna inetina anemia il Exported by netwraitneurnil.netnril
201948-21 18:10AI EDT Exponcd 11ClIllailleilltilli Militia Exported by ncuminctmainctmail
2019-08-22 16:1608 EDT Exported netmaineunAnchllad Exported by netmainctinanettnail
201949.16152150 EDT Exported neunainetominoma il Exported by norm anemia inettna il
2019-09-17 1321,40 EDT Exported netmainetmainctowl Exported by netrotilmetnuilnetmail
202045-19 153229 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXRDOM I Responsive
2020-05-19 15:32:54 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NINRDOMI Responsive
2120-0119153452 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.NIXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flamed
202045-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Fbgged
Page 12679
Re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
From
To
Date 2019/08/12 16:03
Subject: Re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Attachments: TEXT.htin
Thank you!
>.» 8/12/2019 4:02 PM >>>
FYI S/W and Psych Ops dots
Associate Warden
MCC New York
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
Page 12680
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D518DB3.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.170316111.8 440.1
Message Path xn*MatoW5D518083.NYMDOMENYMADMI,100.1703160.1.8440.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 915501ED0-01DA-0000-B7F5-92775C3901BF
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. Na 73618-054
Scheduled date 2019-08-121602.19
Creation date 2019.08-12 160259
Modified date 2019-08-12 1603:34
Delis e red date 2019438-12 160300
Message sine 223
Attachments slat 611
Total size 845
Attachments 1
Attachment TF-XT.htm
Name TEXT.him
Content ID
5D518DB3.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.2030019.1.5
OBF9.1€6455D518DB3.NYMDOMLNYMADMLIC0.1
70316D.1.8440.1®1:7.NYMDOMINYMADMLICO. 0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 611
Date 2019-08-12 120259
CA 9eB88da2c3c7a988041c59f679ee5a0
Hash Cl2D5BAD23837CA4B8771325474EBD283F8A24F4 DI 8791:59D6B6C82B2ED2FDC83E1IBC86
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name _
I:mail
UUID 835B5EA0-11C6-0600-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay dells ery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Intox
Return notification when opened false
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification when declined false
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D518DB3.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.170316111.8 440.1(§1:7.NYMDOM LNYMADM L100.0.1.0.1416
Source received
Class Public
Account MI
Location ID 1540842445516
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maibox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
Page 12681
System
Share Type
UM
NotShared
Page 12682
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08.191429:10 EDT Created
co-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archivel.cnclobscn-GWOperiNodc.cn-arehiv
iiga=nctmail
Generated by Netrinil Inc. [crrArchive
Agent 2-Zero Day
ArchiCre itn-Jobs.cirGWOpenNoie.cn-archiv
ingo-netmai]
2019-08.21093955 EDT Exported nctmaincumilmetinal Exported by rictma iL arum a actual a
2019-08-21140&47 EDT Exported nctmainctmainctmal Exported by nctma a wino a. ovum il
2019.09.07 182225 EDT Exported nctmanctmainctmal Exported by actualaminoII norm a
202005-19152859 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.M3CRDOMI Responsive
2020.051915:1706 EDT Tag ROP01703.61XRADMI.MXRDOM1 Responsive
2020-05-19143435 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
Page 12683
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 information
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
2019/08/10 16:35
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 information
TEXT.htm, Epstein Jeffre Edwar Reg. No. 73618-054
information.docx,
So far this is the documentation I have in my possession.
Associate Warden
MCC New York
150 Park Row
New Yorl NY 10007
Page 12684
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5H4EF26E.NYMDOM 1.NYMADM1.100.170316D. 1.8 1D2.1
Message Path xmlivlaibox5D4EF26E.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .170316D.1.81D2.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 835B5E40-1106-0000.B3D6-FE66A7708950
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Epsteix Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 infortnation
Scheduled date 2019-08-10163538
Creation date 2019.8-10163538
Modified date 2019.08-1017:17:12
Delivered date 2019.08-10 163558
Message size 198
Attachments size 14353
Total silt 14562
Attachments 3
Attachment TEXT.han
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID
5D4EF26E.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.20000013.1.F
4F7C.1®455D4EF26ENYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
70316D.1.81D2.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 443
Date 2019-08-10 123605
CA fld3etalklefa6990bel6fe03f3313f74
Hash B36C5E58717436A38E89BBECEC81A4BF3700884B 7B9822C5961B59A5114101C72AF36497
Attachment Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg No. 73618.054 inforrnatixtdocx
Name Epsten. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054 infonnationdocx
Content ID
5D4EF26E.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.203.200000D.I.F
4F7D.1(4)453D4EF26E.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
70316D.1.81D2.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.1(016
Is Inline fake
Type Ile
Size 13497
Date 2019-08-10 123538
CA 8ca84c34102055ad481d89cf3f52d806
Hash 87D651708CO3829180901334B47866FFF5C49F197B24D5612C4E3BECOD491B74EB8E9FA78
Attachment
Name _
Content ID
5D4EF26E.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200000D.I.F
4F7E.1@455D4E.F26E.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
70316D.1.81D11@1:7.NYMOOMI.NYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1(4;16
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 413
Date 2019-08-10 123605
CA 61958594126225538S9996a31487111)
Hash BECC90BC0417127A4B2ABD7A029CRIB2D9373EFI 181BB0FC8153F3D5843E87C8IF.C4961F
Recipients
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-0114I-0000-AB39-F130F2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08-10163558
DossnloadedB)ThirdParty 2019-0810163559
Opened 2019-08.10 17:17:19
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read truc
Page 12685
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nornnl
Box tspe Sent Item.
Return notification when opened false
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed fake
Return notification 'hen declined false
Return notification alien
accepted false
Archise Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D4EF26E.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.170316D.1.8 ID2.1@t7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1(016
Source sent
Class Public
Account
Location II)
TDOMI
Class Name GW.ME.SSAGEMA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mai=
Type Maim
Ssstem int
Share Tspe NotShared
Page 12686
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-19 1425:42 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archivel.en-Jobscn-GWOpenNode.en-archn
ingo=netmail
Generated by Neinnil Inc. [at -Archive
Agent2-Zem Day
Archive hen-Jobs.arGWOpenNoie.cn-archn
ingo-nettnai]
2019-08.2109:4039 EDT Exported netmaiLneumiLnetmail Exported by Demo il. minx, il. netma il
2119-08-21141)&47 EDT Exported netmainetmainconad Exported by netnxid.nctmol.nentoil
2019.0841 140508 EDT Exported netmainetmailnetmad Exported by netno it nee:, 'Nemo il
2019-08-M 1706:03 EDT Exported netmainetuoiLnetmail Exported by netnoil.netnurnetnuil
2019.09.07 183225 EDT Exported netimilmetimilnetmail Evened by netno it ne too IL netno il
2119-09-07183622 EDT Exported netmaiLneunaiLlICITILIII Exported by mum il.netno ilnenna it
2019.09.09030430 EDT Exported netimilneumilneunall Exported by netinalnetnoitnenrod
2119-09-09113821 EDT Exported netmaiLnetmaiLnetmail Exponed by netmainetno IL nento il
2019-09.11 12:1733 EDT Exported netimilneumineinnil Exported by netmaiLneinnilnetnetil
211409.1418:10:41 EDT Exported netmailnetmainetmail Exported by netmaineinoil.nentoil
202045.19 152839 EDT Tag BOPOI703.MXRADMI.MXFtDOMI Responsive
2020-05-1915:1706 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM1 Responsive
2020-05-19 143435 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 12687
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 information.docx
Page 12688
Documentation re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
(deceased)
SENTRY
PP44
PP37 (ARS, QTR)
PP41
PP78
PPGO
PD15 (Pending, Chrono)
PP85
PR15
BOPWare label
Administrative Detention (AD) Order 7/29/19
Inmate Personal Property Record (BP-A0383)
Electronic Medical Record (BEMR)
Psychology Data System (PDS)
Psychology Observation Log books 7/8-10/19 and 7/24-30/19
Suicide Watch Chronological log 7/23 & 24/19 and
Documentation re: Reyes, Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 (cellmate)
Court documentation regarding WAB 8/9/19
SHU file
Staff memos
Dr. , Acting Chief Psychologist
, IDO
, CO
Miscellaneous
Press Release
Relevant emails
Lt's log Friday, 8/9/19
SHU report - weekly review dated 8/8/19
SHU roster 8/8 & 9/19
SRO review roster 8/6/19
TRUSCOPE visual search log for Epstein
TRUSCOPE all log for Epstein
TRUSCOPE all log for Reyes
Visual search log book
Attorney Conference log book
Mail Attachment
Page 12691
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
( Preferred Voice )
( Work Voice )
( Voice Cell )
( Preferred Internet )
Version
2.1
PRODID
-//Novell Inc//Groupwise 12.0.3
X-GWTYRe
USER
F rrtaillii m
Name
Family: M.
First:
Middle:
Prefix:
Suffix:
Electronic Mail Address ( Preferred Internet )
UID
835B5E40-1106-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Telephone Number (PrefePreferred Voice )
allpi  Voice )
Tele li  ( Voice Cell )
Title
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
Last Revision
20190810T101631Z
X-GWUDF
11 (BES User ID)981
X•GWUDF
1 0(BES Ref ID)0
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 updt
From
To
Date 2019/08/12 11:01
Subject: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 updt
Attachments: TEXT.htm E stein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 updt.docx,
FYI....The timeline is updated to reflect coming in Saturday evening. Ltaill have
the other info regarding the warden and O1O coming in on Sunday.
Associate Warden
MCC New York
150 Park Row
New Yorl NY 10007
Page 12694
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316D.1.8 3A4. I
Message Path xmlAlaibox/5D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .1703160.1.83A4.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 835B5E40-1106-0000.B3D6-FE66A7708950
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Eos& Jeffrey Edswrd, Reg. No. 73618-054 tot
Scheduled date 2019-08-121101:16
Creation date 2019.08-12 11:01:16
Modified date 2019.08-12 110122
Delivered date 2019-08-12 1101:16
Message size 302
Attachments size 16115
Total size 16428
Attachments 3
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.larn
Content ID
5D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200000D.I.F
50AE 1€055D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100. I
70316D.I.83A4.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 552
Date 2019.08-12 0701:17
CA Offlebel90abd0a19388c3ade22c9a2b
Hash SIEE84DA293FI3C8731182F009A6607813269EA63 95F48lEAD04502C70439&5B136DD 12661
Attachment Epsteii, Jeffrey Edward, Reg No. 73618-054 updt.docx
Name Epsten. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054 updt.docx
Content ID
5D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200000D.I.F
50AF.1(g455D5146FC.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1
70316D.1.83A4.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0. l(g)16
Is lane fake
Type fee
Size 15150
Date 2019-08-12 0659:43
CA 5bec3c4131c41431:08938e24a8cObba5
Hash 03AC3E6E3B5A5AEFB65A29058B81AECOB128B18A DBE69E5E1473D0839456EC9ADI5A5IF9fil
Attachment
Manse
Content ID
sOi I 444.C.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000013.1.F
5080 1/,‘4,455D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.1001
703160.1.83A4.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1(4;16
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 413
Date 2019-08-12 07:01:17
CA 83541f5e73bc90568673fa4039ed4096
Hash A028B56B3C209400OD4CF643FC573E87013344D8 1A8E765955228F65018E17366E950102
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 9D77B2D0-19C I.0000.A9S9-0200000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 201908-121101:16
DounloadedBiThIrdParty 2019-118121101:17
Opened 2019-0842 110120
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read trot
Page 12695
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nornnl
Box tspe Sent Items
Return notification when opened false
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed fake
Return notification 'hen declined false
Return notification alien
accepted false
Archise Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D5146FC.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.170316D.1.83A4.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1®16
Source sent
Class Public
Account
Location II)
Ml
Class Name GW.ME.SSAGEMA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.10.1@l6
Name Mai=
Type Maim
Ssstem tme
Share Tspe NotShared
Page 12696
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08.19142731 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archivel.en-Jobs.en-GWOpenNode.en-archiv
ilgo=netmail
Generated by Neurnil Inc. [crrArchive
Agent2-Zem Day
Archive hen-Jobs.arGWOpenNoie.en-arehi.
ingo-nettnai]
2119-08.210900142 EDT Exported netmaiLneumiLnetmail Exported by netrm il. minx, il. netma il
2119-08-211406.+48 EDT Exported netmainetmainetmad Exported by netnoUnctnIol.neinuil
2019.08.211405:48 EDT Exported nctmainetmailnetmad Exported by mama cc lino it nernmil
2119-08-22170604 EDT Exported netmaineuroiLnetmail Exported by netnoil.netnuilnetnuil
2019.09.07 183225 EDT Exported neumilmeumilnetnoil Evened by netnoilnetnxiilnernoil
2119-09-07183622 EDT Exported netmaiLnomaiLlICITILIII Exported by mum il.netnoilnenna il
2019.09.090304:31 EDT Exported neumineumil nomad Exported by netmaiLnetnoitnettroil
2019-09-09113822 EDT Exported netmaiLnetmaiLnetmail Exported by netmainetno IL neinu il
2019-09.11 12:1734 EDT Exported neinuilneuminetnnil Exported by netmaiLnetnnilnernmil
2019-09-14 18:10A1 EDT Exported netmailnetmainetmail Exported by netmainetnoil.nernoil
2020-05.19152839 EDT Tag BOPOI703.MXRADMI.MXFtDOMI Responsive
2020-05-1915:1706 EDT Tag ROP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM1 Responsive
2020-05-19 143435 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 12697
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 updt.docx
Page 12698
Suicide Timeline re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Friday, August 9, 2019
8:00 am inmate Reyes Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 departs for court
(WAB-USMS-SDNY) . Reyes is Epstein's cellmate.
8:30 am inmate Epstein arrives in Attorney Conference. He is
visited by several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 pm inmate Epstein departs attorney conference and returns to
SHU
7:00 pm inmate Epstein provided a social call by IDO. IDO reports
inmate Epstein was in good spirits, nothing unusual.
7:32 am PIO notified of incident by the Warden
***Inmate Reyes is released from court and does not return to the
institution.
Saturday, August 10, 2019
6:33 am body alarm activated in SHU. Staff found inmate Epstein
unresponsive in cell. Staff reported to bedside of inmate and
attempted to wake him. Control announced medical emergency. CPR
initiated
6:35 am medical staff (on duty PA) on site, CPR already in
progress medical staff continues CPR and AED applied on inmate.
Control called for ambulance
6:40 am , AW notified
6:45 am EMS arrives, paramedics continue CPR. Inmate Epstein
remains unresponsive. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three
rounds of Epinephrine, IV access started, IO initiated. No pulse
found, no shock advised, inmate prepared for transport to local
hospital.
7:10 am EMS departs institution enroute to Beekman Hospital.
7:19 am USMS notified of incident.
7:20 am SIS Lt notified.
7:30 am , Warden arrives at institution. , AW
notified.
7:36 am official time of death reported by ER physician.
7:40 am Acting Chief Psychologist notified.
8:00 am and Captain arrive at institution.
8:10 am SIS Lt arrives at institution.
8:10 am CMC and SCSS notified.
8:34 am FBI notified.
9:00 am AUSA notified.
9:00 am arrives at institution.
9:00 am SIS Lt. reports to SHU. Interviews will be conducted with
inmates assigned to tier.
9:15 am CMC arrives at institution.
9:30 am Acting Chief Psychologist arrived to the institution.
9:50 am SCSS arrives at institution.
9:55 am CMC and IDO depart institution enroute to Beekman
Hospital.
10:00 am CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital, fingerprints and
photographs taken of inmate Epstein. Inmate clothing secured and
brought back to institution.
10:00 am Judge Berman notified.
10:15 am CMC return to institution.
10:45 am PIO arrived to the institution.
11:00 am next of kin (brother) notified by Case Management
Coordinator.
11:12 am press release is released to media.
11:15 am press release provided to Judge Berman.
11:15 am CST activated.
12:15 pm body release to Medical Examiner (ME) for autopsy
12:19 pm FBI arrives.
1:35 pm FBI arrives in Special Housing Unit.
1:40 pm OIG notified by the Warden and they will be sending an
Agent to NYM.
2:15 pm CST debrief conducted.
2:45 pm OIG arrived in Special Housing Unit (SHU) .
3:45 pm OIG and FBI depart SHU.
5:05 pm OIG/FBI depart institution
9:10 pm Computer Services Manager (CSM) notified to report to
institution to remove desktop from SHU.
10:46 pm CSM arrives at institution.
11:00 pm desktop removed from SHU and secured in SIS office. OIG
will retrieve desktop tomorrow morning.
Mail Attachment
Page 12701
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
( Preferred Voice )
( Work Voice )
( Voice Cell )
( Preferred Internet )
Version
2.1
PRODID
-//Novell Inc//Groupwise 12.0.3
X-GWTYRe
USER
F rrtaillii m
Name
Family: M.
First:
Middle:
Prefix:
Suffix:
Electronic Mail Address ( Preferred Internet )
UID
835B5E40-1106-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Telephone Number (PrefePreferred Voice )
allpi  Voice )
Tele li  ( Voice Cell )
Title
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
Last Revision
20190812T050046Z
X-GWUDF
11 (BES User ID)981
X•GWUDF
1 0(BES Ref ID)0
Re: Fwd: MCC Epstein (Out of the office)
From
To
Date
Subject: Re: Fwd: MCC Epstein (Out of the office)
2019/08/10 10:52
I will be out of the office on August 12-16, 2019. Please leave a detailed email message, and I
will contact you upon my return. If you require immediate assistance, please contact the
institution directly at
Associate Warden (P)
FCI Estill
100 Prison Road
Estill SC 29918
FCI:
Associate Warden
MCC New York
150 Park Row
New Yor1 NY 10007
Page 12704
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D4EAIFILNYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.170316111.8 159.1
Message Path xmlebiabox/5D4EA IF8.NYMDOMENYMADMII, 100 .170316111.8159.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID P35B5E40-11C6-0000133D6-FE66A77013950
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: Fwd: MCC Epstein (Out of the office)
Scheduled date 201908-101052)40
Creation date 2019-08-101052.+40
Modified date 201948-10105142
Delivered date 2019418-10 103140
Message sine 503
Attachments 0
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 9D77B2D0.19C 1 -0000-A989-0200000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08-10 10-52A0
DoonloadedByThirdParty 2019-08-10 105142
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
.Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nornul
Box type Sent Items
Return notification sshen opened false
Return notification sshen deleted false
Return notification sshen
completed false
Return notification sshen declined fake
Return notification sshen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D4FAIF8.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.170316D.1.8 199.141:7.NYMOOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@j16
Source sent
Class Public
Account MI
Location ID 1540842445516
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mai=
II) 7.NYMOOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Maim
System true
Share Type NoiShared
Page 12705
Audits
Dale Action Auditor Note
2019-08-19 142526 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archivelswdobscn-GWOperiNode.en-archiv
ingo=netmail
Generated by Nona Inc. [en-Archive
Agent 2-Zero Day
Archive itn_joteascwopenNoicen_archi.
iigarnettnai]
2019-08-21 0940:57 EDT Exported netmaincumiLnetmai Exported by netma anetnia iinctno a
2019-08-211413&+48 EDT Exported netmainctmainetnial Exported by netnragneunad. newt' a
2019-0947 I8:3225 EDT Exported netmainctmailocunad Exported by netno a nenunt nom il
202005-191530136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsho
Page 12706
Fwd: Re: Interviews
From
To
Date 2019/08/20 15:30
Subject: Fwd: Re: Interviews
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Thank you!
> » 8/20/2019 322 PM > »
I called and Left a Voice mail, there was no answer
Respectfully,
Clinical Nurse Specialist
Deli:IIintent Olin. ..tire
Iltneau ( Prisons
\ICC Nen York
tin Palk ltot%
New Durk. NY 10007
>>  >
Good afternoon,
8/16/2019 1:43 PM >>>
Per the below, OIG would like to interview you regardin the incident last weekend involving EPSTEIN,
Jeffrey, reg. no. 76318-054. Please call Special Agent at at your convenience.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
p:
f:
>>  > 8/16/2019 1:41 PM >> >
Per the attached OIG would like to interview the followin staff members.
> » . (OIG)" < > 8/16/2019 12:56 PM > > >
Nurse
Page 12707
sent trom mobile 'device, please excuse typos.
Special Agent
Office of the Inspector General
1 Battery Park Plaza, 29th floor
New York, NY 10004
Cell
Office
> On Aug 16, 2019, at 12:34 PM, > wrote:
> Medical Staff?
. (OIG)" < > 8/16/2019 11:25 AM >>>
> We are available at all times for the medical staff interviews today, if they are willing to agree to a
voluntary interview.
> Sent from mobile device, please excuse typos.
> Special Agent
> Office of the Inspector General
> 1 Battery Park Plaza, 29th floor
> New York, NY 10004
Cell
Office
Page 12708
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D5C122D.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 AFF1.1
Message Path imfirMaixoti5D5C122D.NYMDOMENYMADMII.100 .1373875.1.7AFFI. Extol
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CAD0.09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Fwd: Re: Interviews
Scheduled date 2019.08-20 153053
Creation date 2019.08.2015:3053
Modified date 2019.08-2015x1734
Delivered  date 2019-08-20 153033
Message sine 1781
Attachments slat 3952
Total size 5744
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.bm
Content ID
5D5C122D.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000A0.1.1
4813F.1@455D5C122D.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.
1373875.1.7AFFI. IQ 1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.10 0.0.1.0.1(4)16
Is Inline fake
brie file
Size 3952
Date 2019.08.20 II30)49
CA 50ufefibblidc58cfca7126480d840c765
Hash 3DF039FED E99) 9EC8.597867C9AAF9F55D0248E 56D3E624A316E6001:45ES34407AB8319
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID C.4367090-0E73-0000-BBEI-DODC22E57132
Distribution r spe TO
Recipient brie User
Delivered 2019-08.20153053
Opened 2019-08-20 154733
Expire o
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Securits Nomxtl
Box type Sent Items
Return notification sshen opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification like n
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification Ashen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D5C122D.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 AFF1. IQI :7.NYMDOM1.NYMADM Lioaotai@ I
Source sent
Class Public
Account NYMADM I.NYMDOM I
Location 11) 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Page 12709
OlLZ 06ed
Pam490N adi 1 antis
xui au aisis
xoqpetv adil
%Nem atuEN
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-30 2104:15 EDT Created
en=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-lebs.creGWOpenNodern-archivingeoM
ietmai
Gerrrated by Netrre8 Inc. [cn=Archive
_ 1 -Daily Archive3gcnt
Job.cn-Jobsrn-GWOpenNek.cn-archivinga
-netmail]
2020-05-19 15:34:52 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXR DOM] Responsive
2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.h0CRADMI.N1 XR DOM I Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.NIXRIX Ail Fbgged
2020-05-1914:4136 EDT Tag BOP01703.NOCRADMI.AINRIX NI Ragged
Page 12711
Fwd: Re: Interviews
From
To
Date
Subject:
2019/08/20 15:22
Fwd: Re: Interviews
Attachments: TEXT.htm
I called and Left a Voice mail, there was no answer
Respectfully,
Clinical Norse Specialist
Dettarunent Oljustice
Bureau Of Primal,.
N1CC New York
130 Park Row
New lurk. NV 10007
>>  >
Good afternoon,
8/16/2019 1:43 PM >>>
Per the below, OIG would like to interview you regardin the incident last weekend involving EPSTEIN,
Jeffrey, reg. no. 76318-054. Please call Special Agent at at your convenience.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
P.
>>> 8/16/2019 1:41 PM >> >
Per the attached OIG would like to interview the followin staff members.
. (OIG)" < > 8/16/2019 12:56 PM > »
Nurse
Sent from mobile device, please excuse typos.
Page 12712
special Agent
Office of the Inspector General
1 Battery Park Plaza, 29th floor
New York, NY 10004
Cell
Office
> On Aug 16, 2019, at 12:34 PM, > wrote:
> Medical Staff?
> >>> . (OIG)" < > 8/16/201911:25 AM >>>
> We are available at all times for the medical staff interviews today, if they are willing to agree to a
voluntary interview.
> Sent from mobile device, please excuse typos.
> Special Agent
> Office of the Inspector General
> 1 Battery Park Plaza, 29th floor
> New York, NY 10004
Cell
Office
Page 12713
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D5C1020.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 AFE9.1
Message Path xmVMaiscoOD5C1020.NYMDOMLNYMADM1,100.1373875.1.7AFE9.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
U UI 0 C4367090-0E73-0000-BBEI-DODC22E57B2
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Fwd: Re: Interviews
Scheduled date 201908-2015:2208
Creation date 2019-08-20 152208
Modified date 201948-20 153013
Delivered   date 201948-20 15:2209
Message size 1728
Attachments size 3895
Total silt' 5634
Attachments 1
Attachment TEXT.huo
Name TEXT.him
Content ID
5D5C1020.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.2C00074.1.3
C5121®453D5C1020.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.7AFE9.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 3895
Date 2019-08-20 112207
CA cdShb5ble963104cc28248e3e8915e68
Hash 4FTDAAD8IDD3EB67A60A4167C341CAE092562140 70E74C5950272A4BE5301D5ECBE0218A
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name _
I:mail
VOID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Intox
Return notification when opened false
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification when declined false
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Union 5.3
Internal ID 5D5C1020.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 AFE9.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@1 6
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MFSSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maibox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
Page 12714
System
Share Type
UM
NotShared
Page 12715
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-30 2111420 EDT i c catcil
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 JolAcn-lebs.crGWOpenNode.en-archivingdAgcnt_1-Daily
ietmai
Generated by Netrna8 Inc. [cn=Archive
Archive3
Job.cn-Jobs,cn-GWOpenNode.cn-archivingo
—netmail]
2020-05-19153432 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXR DOM] Responsive
2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.tiOCRADMI.N1 XR DOM I Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIAR I X Ai I Flagged
2020-05-1914:4136 EDT Tag BOP01703143CRADMI.Al Nit I X A1 I Flagged
Page 12716
Re: meeting with tartaglione 8015 @ 5:00 pm
From
To , Bruce Barket
Date 2019/08/13 17:14
Re: meeting with tartaglione 8015 @ 5:00
pm
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Subject:
Page 12717
Hi Bruce,
Thanks for the kind words...land I know you and the rest of the defense bar have a job to do, as do we.
That may put us at odds sometimes, but it doesn't mean we all can't respect each other.
No problem on Thursday; we'll pull Tartaglione down before the count and he can review his discovery until
count clears.
Thanks,
Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
> » Bruce Barket < > 8/13/2019 5:02 PM > »
Good afternoon,
Can I meet with Nick on Thursday, August 15th at 5:00 p.m?
By the way, I am imagine you have seen some of my comments repeating the complaints about MCC
that I have been making for years. Please know that none of that was directed at you. You both have
been professional, courteous and responsive to me, even in the face of my numerous complaints and
emails. The press does not write about the good, but I have mentioned how much I admire the legal
staff at MCC on several occasions.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci NY 11530
[P1 [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 12718
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D52EFFB.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7A9E6.1
Message Path xml Mailboxi5D52EFFB.NYMDOMENYMADMIL100 .1373875.1.7A9E6.1.imi
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 15A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Reply To
Text
To Bruce Basket
Subject Re: meeting with tanaglione 8015 Of, 500 pm
Scheduled date 2019-08-13 17:1435
Creation date 2019.08-13 17:1435
Modified date 2019-08-13 1732-44
Delivered  date 2019.08-13 17:1436
Message sine 1795
Attachments sin 4409
Total size 6215
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hlm
Content ID
5D52EFFB.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20300DA.1.8
AC53.1€455D52EFFB.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.7A9E6.1®11.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 4409
Date 2019-08-13 13:1436
CA kblafeccb7aad99c6513c58469c5bee
Hash 4CD38A1548AE7076AAED48721B8B809808D6B457 51:51:86234959505F24ED4696E146DBC6
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CAD0.09CA-0000.A8F4-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient Bruce Basket
Display Name Bruce Backe'
Email
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay de liven until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read true
Deleted false
Opened mit
Completed fake
Security Nonnal
Box type Intox
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined false
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
late real ID 5D52EFEB.NYMDOMLNYMADMimal373875.1.7A9E6.1@l11.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.10001.0.11@i
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADM I.NYMDOM I
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Page 12719
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
In 7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mail=
Type Maibox
System true
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 12720
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019.08.2320A833 EDT Created
en=Archive Agent 1-Daly Archive3
Jobsn-lebs.cn-GC/OpenNodetn-archivingdAgent-
=netmai
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [cn=Archive
I -DailY Archive3Job.cn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNok.cn-archisingo
-nctinail]
2019-09-16 I5:32:30 EDT Exported mow inetma allowed Exported by netmaineunaincunat
2020-05-19153531 EDT Tag BOP01703.NIXRADM I.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020.05191531:14 EDT Tag B01101703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020-0549
202005--19 15:32.02 EDT Tag B01701703.143CRADMI.MXRDOMI Revonsive
14:3454 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flawed
2020-05-19 1441:56 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
Page 12721
MCC conditions
From
To
Bruce Barket
ida Leisenri
Date 2019/08/29 17:25
Subject: MCC conditions
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the facility.
Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it himself on
August 15th. His radio has needed batteries for several days. The guards simply refuse to provide him
with the batteries and new books he believes are in his property. Several guards have been making
comments to him such as "You're threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth his try" and similar
remarks aimed at intimidating him and conveying to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not staff in the
lobby to process legal visits. I was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't stay through the count
so I had to leave before 9:30. I know I did not make an appointment but the issue wasn't a free room,
but adequate staffing in the lobby. Yesterday I was able to see my client at 5:00 as scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
(P1 ft )
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have
received this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is
strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us
immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 12722
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D680AA4.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 B6E3.1
Message Path xmllMabasJ5D680AA4.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7RiPums
From Bruce Barket
Display Name Bruce Barket
Email
Reply. To
Test Bruce Barket
To
Cc Aida Lciscnrin MichaclBacirach
i: tonyricco
Subject MCC conditions
Scheduled date 2019-08-291725:14
Citation date 2019-08-29 1725:14
Modified date 2019-08.291930558
Delis e red date 2019-08-29 172557
Message size 1731
Attachments sire 15500
Total she 17242
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID
5D680AA4.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.2IXI.20000E3.1.2
DE2D.1@45:5D680AA4.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.7B6E3.11412.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI-100 .0.1.0.1(§16
Is Inline fake
Type He
Size 4297
CA 066fd180f22ef43d6fe611be983acd8e
Hash 8IFT6DEB78FA102A67541E3AFA4F2DE744C8A0BE 3202B5CD6DC20A74039DA9C88CCFC5D6
Attachment Mine.822
Name Minc.822
Content ID
5D680AA4.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.20C1.20000E3.1.2
DE2E1®4550680AA4.NYMDOM1.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.7B6E3.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI-100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 11203
CA 7f013b0c192862.3368e616fa2d3e22d1
Hash BB68E2D3B32DD559C91380ACC97DA9C963C9A7D1 739C9067P2S26E0455E6DS4B790C7A66
Recipients 8
Recipnt
Display Name
_ Email
QUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000418F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient Aida LcUenring
Display Name Aida Leese
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Entail
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID AB244985-1BAA-0000-B60A-A812D3F99FD4
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
(AID 79BA4F81.399A-0000-B60A-EIB48EDlFB51
Page 12723
Distribution Tye ('C
Recipient Ty User
Recipient MichaelBaclvach
Display Name MichaelBachrach
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
LIVID 15A65E10-0C33-0000a3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient tonyricco
Display Name tonyricco
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read We
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box brie Inbox
Return notification %%hen opened fake
Return notification n he n deleted fake
Return notification nhen
completed !MN':
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification n hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D680AA4.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.loo.1373875.1.7 B6E3.I(B/P3.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1€ I
Source received
Class Pubhc
Account NYMADMINYMDOM1
Location ID 15908426831386
Class Name OW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mailbox

II) 7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.0.I.O.IQl6
Name Maim
Type Maibox
System true
Share Type NotSbarcd
Page 12724
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-06 2055132 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Jobrn-lebs.crGWOpenNodern-archivings,Arla_
ietmai
Gerrrated by Netrred Inc. [cn=Archive
I -Daily Archive3
Job.en-Jobsrn-GWOpenNok.cn-archivinga
-netmad]
202(-05-19153006 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 12725
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12726
From:
T••
>
Subject: MCC conditions
Sent: Thu, 29 Aug 2019 21:25:14 +0000
Ca,
" (USANYS)
a '
, "Michael Bachrach
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the facility.

Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it himself on August 15". His radio has needed
batteries for several days. The guards simply refuse to provide him with the batteries and new books he believes are in 
his
property. Several guards have been making comments to him such as "You're threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth
his
try" and similar remarks aimed at intimidating him and conveying to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not staff in the lobby to process 
legal visits. I
was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't stay through the count so I had to leave before 9:30. I know I did not
make an
appointment but the issue wasn't a free room, but adequate staffing in the lobby. Yesterday I was able to see my client 
at 5:00 as
scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[P) [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If 
it is not clear that you are
the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, 
dissemination, distribution or
copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, 
please notify us immediately
by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Re: Defense private investigator/permission to visit mcc
From Sarah Sacks
To Bennett Epstei
Date 2019/12/05 15:06
Subject: Re: Defense private investigator/permission to visit mcc
TEXT.htm, Joseph O'Brien certificate and license.pdf, Signed BOP Attachments: visitation form.pdf, Mime.822
Ms.
Attached please fmd the BOP visitation form and licensing credentials from the
private investigator.
Please let me know what else you need from us. We recently received CJA permission for Mr.
O'Brien to travel to NYC to visit our client with us at the MCC on Monday and Tuesday next
week, so I appreciate your helping us to expedite this process.
Best, Sarah
Sarah M. Sacks, Esq.
EPSTEIN SACKS PLLC
Office:
Mobilea
CONFIDENTIALITY: This email communication and any files transmitted with it may contain
privileged and confidential information and are intended solely for the use of the individuals or
entity to whom it has been addressed. If you have received this email in error, please delete it
and notify the sender by return email.
On Thu, Dec 5, 2019 at 1:09 PM < > wrote:
Hi Sarah,
Please have the PI fill out the application and Nac form attached hereto starting at 26. He will also
need to provide a copy of his PI license and certificate. Please email it back to Ms cc'ed, so
she can process it.
Thank you,
>>> Sarah Sacks > 12/5/201912:24 PM >>>
Hi M. I'm not sure if you've already relocated but I'm hoping you can help or redirect me to someone
who can. I have a private investigator we have appointed under GA coming to visit our client from out
of town next week Monday and Tuesday. What do we need to do to get him permission to come in with
us for a legal visit? Thank you.
Sent from my iPhone
Page 12728
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5DI 91DOD.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.8 059D.1
Message Path stilt tsladbox15DE9IDOD.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.8059D.I.xml
From Sarah Sacks
Display Name Sarah Sacks
Email
Reply To
Test Sarah Sacks
To
Cc
Subject
Bennett Epstein:
Re: Defense predate HINC•ligator pcntInsion to %rat MCC
Scheduled date 2019-12-05 1503A2
Creation date 2019-12-05 15:03:42
Modified date 2019-12-05 15:56:51
Delivered date 2019-12-05 15:0634
Message size 1581
Attachments size 5358357
Total size 5359949
Attachments 4
Attachment TF-XT.hun
Name TEXT.Ium
Content ID
5DE91DOD.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.203.2000024.1.7
6D80.1®453DE9IDOD.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
373875.1.8059D.I@II.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1 ®16
Is Inline false
'type file
Size 2459
161350250e28dee240d59a5480955c4c
Has h ECA300€AB737EC4A93A7E5ADB283C12B4leal6,Fr 73C25BC95E3F99348C91AF6A0AB8BE46
Attachment Joseph O'Brien certifcate and kensc.pdf
Name Joseph O'Brien cettificate and icertse.pdf
Content ID
5DESIDOD.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.2000024.1.7
6D81.1(4453DE9ID0D.NYMD0MI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.I.8059D.I@1:7.NYTHDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 530631
CA 9803Thcaltladificc87bldb2a408d904a
Hash 745980DDA734770DD8CE761445780966FBBE2675 8DAC3DC5198F264542F6523A6BA7BIDC
Attachment Signed BOP visitation form.pdf
Name Signed BOP visitation form.pdf
Content II/
5DE9IDOD.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.2110.2000324.1.7
6D82.16055DE9IDOD.NYMDOM I.NYMADM 1.100.1
373875.1.8059D.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.l@i6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 1726063
CA c0c6d062c55638c447ef6d9ec094134f
Hash F3656760E4D88D579A3DD675E15AC906A32734A7 5C5E3F600AD5A9F7CC6FI E9A5E23951C
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5DE91DOD.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.203.2000024.1.7
6D133.1®455DE9IDOD.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
373875.1.805911i ®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.16;416
Is Inline false
Type fie
Size 3099204
CA 89cc7a0f491c0012666521cd7e 12a105
Hash 5828D46BC7F98E0.33CE9ABD1435B678B4BF81 IC2 9330B5B79C7E575C705C3802C210CB8C
Recipients 4
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CADO-09CA-0030-A8F4-1ACF3IF-A7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient Bennett Epstein
Page 12729
Display Name Bennett Epstein
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name I
Email
263DFEC0435FA-0000-BSE9-E3DDF99F0ABB QUID
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Tye User
Re cipie nt
Display Name
Email
QUID C4 I I 75i 0441T-0000-B31C-4A46ENDCC96
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened MC
Completed fake
Security Nornnl
Bo3 is pc Irby(
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification n he n de le te d fake
Return notification %0len
completed fake
Return notification nhen declined rake
Return notification nhen
accepted fake
Archive Veosion 5.3
Internal ID 5DE9ID0O.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.1373875.1.8059D.I@II.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.0.I.0.Ifit I
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMLNYMDOMI
Location II) IS-008426133886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder MaRoox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.I.0.1@l6
Name Maibox
Type Maibox
System true
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 12730
Audits
DMe Action Auditor Note
2019-12-11 103064 EST Created
en=Arehive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archivc3.cn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNode.en-archic
ticngor  tinal
Generated by Netgowm Kr -Archive
Agent 2-Zer° Day
Archcelen-Jobs.err-GWOpenNode.cn-archn
ing.o-netmai]
2020-05-19 15:3006 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 12731
Mail Attachment
Joseph O'Brien certificate and license.pdf
Page 12732
ro,1
rAti".0.
1A*ypl+rAyil
Yofr
s1.VTATil
fArfr'l
YAT!
AIN
it`cy:
:-`ot.
ttoe4.
,rac
'4%
'4%
"44!'
Seing
accepted
by
this
prestigious
organization.
each
member
has
agreed
to
adhere
to
the
highest
level
of
integrity.
ethics.
and
standards
for
those
we
serve
and
to
our
profession.
nnrw.myfapi.org
-0 ,
~!~Q
Denise
"White.
President
.,_
)farvey
E.
,Morse,
founder
!
-0-r4' V
74.1
.
AT!'
:ATt••••
;!..PT'tt.;
Ve-f
q"4
4-SoTP.A-.
tSoTN-4
Vh:;4-Y
-A-
*ITN
V.;,.t
4--
-4
•
n,F4.n,,,Ak
,-A,N..„4N
4,„,.AN
.,,,,A 4!
...
.
.

╭─────────────────────────────────────── Page 282, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ Sasa                                                                                             │
│ Oy                                                                                               │
│                                                                                                  │
│ -                                                                                                │
│ o                                                                                                │
│ Sa                                                                                               │
│                                                                                                  │
│ Florida Association of Private Investigators, Inc.                                               │
│ GN “) OF MEMBERSHIP                                                                              │
│                                                                                                  │
│ )                                                                                                │
│                                                                                                  │
│ _—                                                                                               │
│ AX                                                                                               │
│ ANAINY                                                                                           │
│                                                                                                  │
│ x:                                                                                               │
│ Y,                                                                                               │
│                                                                                                  │
│ ‘3                                                                                               │
│                                                                                                  │
│ NWA                                                                                              │
│ ais                                                                                              │
│                                                                                                  │
│ ‘A                                                                                               │
│                                                                                                  │
│ W                                                                                                │
│                                                                                                  │
│ Being accepted by this prestigious organization. cach member has agreed to adhere to the highest │
│ level of integrity. ethics. and standards tor those we serve and to our profession.              │
│ www.mytaptorg                                                                                    │
│                                                                                                  │
│ Vpuine be/ pte Y £ Goo                                                                           │
│                                                                                                  │
│ Dentse White. President Harvey E. Morse. Founder )                                               │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

NEW YORK STATE DEPARTMENT OF STATE
consia+ a LiCEffSING SEAMUS
JOSEPH F OBRIEN
IS A QUALIFYING
Officer/Principal of
JOE OBRIEN
INVESTIGATIONS INC
a duly licensed
PRI AT isiVESI,GEOR
THIS DOES NOT CONFER NYS EMPLOYEE STATUS
non imentis
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR LICENSE
STATE OF FLORIDA
Society of Former Special
Agents of the FBI. Inc.
viczcsi
JOSEPH F O'BRIEN
Member Society National Office
and isoo)52-• /3/2
Former Special Agent ol the FBI www.soexIbtorg
•
.1' r

rr. ,
Mail Attachment
Signed BOP visitation form.pdf
Page 12736
METROPOLITAN DETENTION CENTER
100 29TH STREET
BROOKLYN, NEW YORK 11232
(718)840.4200
Dear Sir/Madam:
METROPOLITAN CORRECTIONAL CENTER
150 PARK ROW
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10007
(646) 836-6300
We are in receipt of your request that you, or a person whom you employ or supervise, be allowed
to visit and correspond in relation to legal matters with Motel Nittalijey
Federal Register Number 87066-054
In order for such visiting or correspondence to be conducted, we must request that you, or your
employee or your student, complete and sign the enclosed questionnaire. Please answer the
questionnaire, and ensure that all sections are completed. In addition, we must request that the
sponsoring attorney execute the Attorney's Statement at the end of the questionnaire. Please return
the form upon completion, either by regular or overnight mail.
**RE ADVISED HA' l KrsILM'WH EEnDAL  BE A HE FRONT
LOBBY OF THE INSTITUTION. APPLICATIONS SENT TO THIS OFFICE VIA
FACSIMILE WILL BE DESTROYED UPON RECEIPT. ONLY ORIGINAL
APPLICATIONS WILL BE PROCESSED.**
The information supplied on this questionnaire may be used for investigative purposes in
determining whether to grant this request to visit and correspond with inmates. The processing of
the applications takes a minimum of 14 days from the date of receipt. It is your responsibility to
contact the Legal Department to ascertain whether you, or your employee or student, will he
allowed to visit or correspond with the above-referenced inmate.
Cyan approval. the applicants admittance to enter will expire (1 ) year from the applicants date
of approval. It is the applicant's responsibility to reapply upon their expiration.
Page 1 of 10
GENERAL
This information is provided pursuant to Public Law 93-579, the Privacy Act of December 31, 1974.
PURPOSES & USES
The information you supply may be used as a basis for an investigation regarding your
correspondence with Nikolai Maley  Federal
Register Number  87066-054  . In the process of conducting the investigation, the
Bureau of Prisons may disclose the information to federal, state, or local law enforcement agencies.
EFFECTS OF NONDISCLOSURE
You are not required to supply the information requested on the attached questionnaire. If you do
not furnish the information requested, the processing of your request will be suspended, and you will
receive no further consideration. If you furnish only part of the information required. the processing
of your request will be attempted; however, it may be significantly delayed. If the information
withheld is found to be essential to processing your request properly, you will be so informed, and
your request will receive no further consideration unless you supply the missing information.
Although no penalties are authorized for failure to supply the requested information, failure to
supply the information could result in your not being considered for or allowed admittance to the
institution or correspondence privileges with the inmate in question.
Page 2 of 10 Rota 2.91/08
0 PARALEGAL* (See Page 51
O INTERPRETER
Q' PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR (See Page 9)
3 MITIGATION SPECIALIST (See Page 10)
3OTHER
APPLICATION TO ENTER AN INSTITUTION OR CORRESPOND WITH A FEDERAL
PRISONER AS THE REPRESENTATIVE OF A LICENSED ATTORNEY.
This form has three parts:
1.0uestionnaire: This questionnaire is to be completed by each paralegal, legal assistant, clerk,
student, interpreter, mitigation specialist or private investigator who seeks to enter an institution of
the Federal Bureau of Prisons to visit or correspond with a federal prisoner as the representative of
a licensed attorney. This application will not be processed unless this questionnaire with the original
signature is received at the Legal Department.

2. Certification: Each person seeking to enter a federal institution to visit or correspond with a
federal prisoner must sign the certification which follows the questionnaire.

3. Attorney's Statement: The licensed attorney sponsoring you must sign the sponsoring
statement. This application will not be processed if the Attorney's Sponsoring Statement is not
signed.
OUESTIONNAIRE
NOTE: Answer all questions. If a question does not apply to you , write "Not Applicable" in the
space provided for the answer.

I. Name:  IS  PI-1 f (21 aft, Le hi
A: Any alias or other name ever used:
Name:  NO-t' APPLI € Ali a  When Used:  NOT APO-wiled

2. A. Social Security Number:
B. Date of Birth:  MEM  C. Place of Birth:
D. Sex:  rri‘o; (  E. Race:  COAX -IMO ,
Page 3 of 10 Raba, 210141

3. A. Present Residential Address:
BeaA- i41.Nairi-
B. Length of time at this address:  1Lfan.
C. Home telephone number:

D. List all residential addresses (including street and number, city and state) for the last
five (5) years and dates you resided at each address:
Addressek Dates

4. A. Present Place of Employment:  6K F17144,: civarmicion iettc ,
I. Name of immediate supervisor:  Ado rindor(

II. Employer's business address:  9D G4 2 020 $* / (// Ay lane -. .3 0/
III. Employer's telephone number:  O. fa: ist qs..1
IIII. Dates of Employment: I44 pia\B. List all previous employers for the past five (5) years, including employers' 
addresses and
dates of your employment with each employer:
EMPLOYER ADDRESS RATES OF EMPLOYMENT
C "fr e4'441M" *AO to te,  Ckg rt AQ Nv ,cly I qg Pnkt ai

5. A. List all schools, universities, or other educational institutions attended from grade
Page 4 of 10 Awned w//Ox
10 to present (this should include any and all legal training that you have received):
ADDRESS. TE RECEIVED
hT-Etra://st
GoSiar 4A0Vttraut
I' t 5661n e2cresca`'9so iq • Pone PAD, ern
/V
ti  r
*B. Paralegal entrance privileges are ONLY extended to paralegals in the employ of the
sponsoring attorney, not self-employed paralegals who are consulted by attorneys.
Paralegal applications require the applicant A) be a current law school student or graduate

B) provide a copy of their paralegal certificate or C) have a minimum of (6) months
experience as a paralegal working with their sponsoring attorney AND provide a letter
from the sponsoring attorney stating the applicant's duties.

6. Have you ever been convicted of ANY criminal offense? N 0
If so, complete the following. You may exclude any convictions for minor traffic violations
(fine of 5150.00 or less)
OFFENSE DATE OF CONVICTION NAME & LOCATION OF COURT
Merl! PPA-1 OA ft -4C

7. Have you ever been confined in any jail, prison or penal institution?
If so, complete the following:
Type of Institution J acation
(State, Federal, Municipal County)
A/or ri Pa to 2.O
Ak)
Pates of Confinement
Page 5 of 10 Raised 241/08

8. Have you ever been charged with a criminal offense? If yes, please briefly summarize
circumstances and legal disposition of the case.
NO

9. A Have you ever been denied permission to visit or correspond with an inmate by an institution
within the Federal Bureau of Prisons (social or legal)?
No

B. If so, state the institution(s), inmatc(s) and datc(s) of denial.
Nor APPLislet_&
10. Are you a citizen of the United States? A.  yes
If not, give the name of the country of which you are a citizen or subject: B.
Alien Registration Number: C.
II. Are you a relative of or have a social relationship with the inmate(s) you are seeking to visit
with at the MDC/ MCC? If yes, explain relationship.
MU
I2. Arc you currently on, or seeking to be placed on the social visiting list of any inmatc(s)
housed at a federal institution?
Page 6 of 10 Revisal 2.1111/01f
STATEMENT OF APPLICANT
I certify that I am authorized to act as the legal representative of  Bennett M. Epstein
who is a licensed member of the bar of the State of New York
I request that I be allowed to interview and correspond with Nikolei Niftalijev
Federal Register Number 87066-054  , who is confined at the MDC
I am aware of my responsibility as a representative of the above-named attorney and certify
that I am able to meet this responsibility. I am also aware of the Bureau of Prisons' Policy
on Inmate Legal Activities and certify that I am able to and will adhere to the requirements
of this policy. I pledge to abide by Bureau of Prisons regulations and institution guidelines.
I hereby certify that all of the information contained in this questionnaire is true and correct
to the best of my knowledge. Furthermore, I understand that all information contained in this
questionnaire may be investigated and verified through the use of federal, state and local
authorities.
Applicant's printed name:  1egi014 P elagkipw
Applicant's signature:
Date Completed:
xa21/4
Private Investigators must submit a copy of their Private Investigators Certificate and Private
Investigator's photo identification.
Page 7 of 10 Renard 2/01/48
STATEMENT OF SPONSORING ATTORNEY
I hereby certify that I am a licensed member of the bar of the State of  New York
and that I employ or supervise
I authorize  Joseph O'Brien
Joseph O'Brien
to represent me and request that as my
representative she/he be allowed to interview and correspond with Nikolai Niftalijev
Federal Register Number  87066-054  who is currently confined at MDC
Brooklyn./ MCC New York, I further certify that  Joseph O'Brien is aware
of the responsibility of her/his role as my representative and is able to meet this
responsibility. I pledge that I will supervise my representative's activities. I accept personal
and professional responsibility for all acts of my representative which affect the institution,
its inmates or staff.
Attorney's printed name:  Bennett M. Epstein
Address:  100 Lafayette Street, Suite 502, New York, NY 10013
Telephone Numbcr.  212 684 1230
Attorney's Signature:  /s/ Bennett M. Epstein
Date Completed:  December 5, 2019
Page 8 of 10 Rated IV Mkt
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR APPLICANTS
The following visiting procedures will be applied to Private Investigators entering the
institutions:
Private Investigators on the approved list will be permitted to enter the institution without the
accompaniment of their sponsoring attorney.
Private Investigators will be required to submit a statement of sponsoring attorney as well as a
copy of their Private Investigator's License EACH TIME THEY WANT TO VISIT ON
BEHALF OF AN ATTORNEY OTHER THAN THE INITIAL SPONSORING ATTORNEY.
Your admittance to enter will expire one year from the date of your approval or upon the
expiration of your private investigators license (which ever comes first).
Private Investigators will be permitted to bring pre-approved interpreters, if necessary.
Please be advised that it is the responsibility of the Private Investigator to make her/his sponsoring
attorney aware of the above procedures. The enclosed Sponsoring Statement form can be
reproduced locally.
Page 9 of 10 Rated 2/01/18
MITIGATION SPECIALIST/ APPLICANTS
The following visiting procedures will be applied to Mitigation Specialists entering this
institution:
Mitigation Specialists/ Doctors on the approved list will be permitted to enter the institution
without the accompaniment of their sponsoring attorney.
Mitigation Specialists/ Doctors will be required to submit a court order along with the statement
of sponsoring attorney EACH TIME THEY WANT TO VISIT ON BEHALF OF AN
ATTORNEY OTHER THAN THE INITIAL SPONSORING ATTORNEY.
A new order must be produced for each inmate that the Mitigation Specialist/ seeks to
correspond with, additionally, a new order must be produced when the mitigation specialist is
renewing their application after expiration.
Mitigation Specialists/ Doctors will be permitted to bring pre-approved interpreters, if necessary.
Mitigation Specialists/ Doctors must schedule visits by faxing a copy of the order and a letter
specifying the date and time requested. The letter should include the inmate's name and register
number. The request needs lobe faxed to the respective Legal Department for the institution you
need to visit.
Please be advised that it is the responsibility of the Mitigation Specialist Doctors to make her/his
sponsoring attorney aware of the above procedures. The enclosed Sponsoring Statement form can
be reproduced locally.
Page 10 of 10 Revised 2/01/0S
ATTACHMENT B
NCIC CHECK cnv.
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE FEDERAL BUREAU OF PRISONS
AUTHORIZATION FOR RELEASE OF INFORMATION
NCIC (National Crime Information Center) CHECK
I hereby authorize a representative of the Federal Bureau of Prisons to obtain any
information on my criminal history background. I understand that this check must be done
before I am allowed to enter/serve at any Bureau facility. I also understand that refusal
to provide all necessary information nay result in 1) denial of entry into a Bureau
facility and 2) denial of volunteer/contract status.

1. `lame (Last, First, Middle)
O f WeAL I:rev.;e 1)14
2. Address (street address) (City, State, County, Zip Code)

3. Home Home Telephone Number (Area Code, Number)
4. Aliases/Nickname: Nor AptAbtaZt,
5. Citizenship (List the country you are a citizen of): Ite A

6. Social Security Number:
7. Date of Birth (Month, day, year):
8a. Sex: MA Le Bb. Race: &lute
8c. Height: (.414.511 8d. Weight: 51S1

Be. Color of Eyes: 1:34.44! 8f. Color of Hair: Mil
9. Place of Birth (City, State, County), (List city, county and country
U.S.A)
Uzi) •
if outside the
10. The above listed information is true
and correct. Applicant's Signature
%ty4le
10a. Date
/afrb
PRIVACY ACT NOTICE
Authority for Collecting Information:  E.O. 10450: 5 CSC :303-1305; 42 USC 2165 and 2455;
22 USC 2585 and 2519; and 5 USC 3301
purposes end Uses: Information provided on this form will be furnished to individuals in
order to obtain information regarding activities in connection with an investigation to
determine GO fitness for Federal employment, (2) clearance to perform contractual service
for the Federal Government, (31 security clearance or access. The information obtained
nay be furnished to third parties as necessary in the fulfillment of official
responsibilities.
;treats of Mon-disclosures:  Furnishing the requested information is voluntary, but failure
to provide all or of part the information may result in lack of further consideration for
employment, clearance or access, or in the termination of your employment.
/This tore may Do replicated els UP)
Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
From
To
Date 2019/07/07 18:18
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with
client
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Sorry just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartplione
Ori 'nal mcssa
Front ' ,,
Date: 7/7/19 5:36 PM GMT -05:00
To: >, ic li >
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>» ' )" 07/07/2019 17:36 >»
With apologies for the weekend email, we have a defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, who was arrested last
night and is currently being detained at MCC, and is expected to be presented on an indictment
tomorrow. His attorney, Martin Weinberg, has represented him in the past, and represents him in
connection with our case and has been in touch with us throughout the weekend. He went to MCC
today to meet with him in advance of the presentment tomorrow, but was just told he is not allowed in
because he is from out-of-state.
We're concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment
(as we would be for any defendant) and so I wanted to reach out to you—is it at all possible to address
this issue so Mr. Weinberg can meet with his client this evening? I'm available anytime at
to discuss, if that's helpful, or Mr. Weinberg can also be reached directly at 617-901-3472 if that's
easier (though if you reach out directly to him if you could please just let me know afterward I'd be
grateful).
thanks very much,
Page 12749
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D22376C.NYMDOMLNY1dADMI.100.1373875.1.7 mai
Message Path xraMaixoA5D22376C.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI,100.1373875.1.7885D.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: counsel hasng difficuky meeting n ah chat
Scheduled date 2019-07-07 18:18:12
Creation date 2019-07-07 18:18:12
Modified date 2019-10-15 14:1930
Delivered  date 2019-07-07 18:1820
Message size 1673
Attachments size 5188
Total size 6872
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.larn
Content ID
5D22376C.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000A0.1.1
4452D.1®455D22376C.NYMDOMI.NY1dADM1.100.
1373875.1.78135DA®la.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
'type file
Size 5188
e20d28874ecO4aaacce5f7427a0b20e4
Hash 4fiEFFADE3C88EE9F0E180781AB9CD812E982FCEF EME1766DOCABD6BB8588D55BD29B76
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LAID 41A952S1 - 121( -11111111-1460 A-1 1)EA2C9DEC56
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'fype User
Transferred 2019.07-07 18:1822
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID I5A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-07-0718:1820
Opened 2019-07-0808380
Expire 0
Delay de liven' until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read nue
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed false
Security Nonni!
Box type Sent Items
Return notification nhen opened false
Return notification when deleted false
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification sshen declined false
Return notification when
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D22376C.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1373875.1.78esal®1:7.NYMDOMENYMADMimactLai@I 6
Source sent
Class Public
Page 12750
Account I NYMADMLNYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mal=
II) 7.NYMDOMLNYMAD641.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Muffins
Type Maibox
System tme
Share Type NotShared
Page 12751
Audits
Dale Action Auditor Note
2019-12-11 06:2623 EST Created
en=Arehive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archive3.cn-Jobs.arGwopenNedetn-atchiv
ill:Armorial
Generated by Neigpvem Icn-Archive
t
Arc
Agen
hc
2-Zero Day
elen-Jobs.cre-GWOpenNock.cn-archis
ing.o-netmai]
2020-05-19 15:31:14 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-191532-02 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020.05-19153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2026-05.19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fhgged
2021.05.191437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 12752
RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
From
To
Date 2019/07/07 18:18
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
Massachusetts
From:
Sent: Sunday. July 07 2019 18:18
To:
>
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Sorry M, just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
Sent from my Verizon. Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Original messa
From: ' >
Date: 7/7/19 5:36 PM GMT-05:00
To:
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>>> " 07/07/2019 17:36 >»
With apologies for the weekend email, we have a defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, who was arrested last
night and is currently being detained at MCC, and is expected to be presented on an indictment
tomorrow. His attorney, Martin Weinberg, has represented him in the past, and represents him in
connection with our case and has been in touch with us throughout the weekend. He went to MCC
today to meet with him in advance of the presentment tomorrow, but was just told he is not allowed in
because he is from out-of-state.
We're concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment
(as we would be for any defendant) and so I wanted to reach out to you—is it at all possible to address
this issue so Mr. Weinberg can meet with his client this evening? I'm available anytime at
to discuss, if that's helpful, or Mr. Weinberg can also be reached directly at 617-901-3472 if that's
easier (though if you reach out directly to him if you could please just let me know afterward I'd be
grateful).
thanks very much,
IMF
Page 12753
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D223784.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.B73875.1.7885E.1
Message Path xmlshiaboA5D223784.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI,100.1373875.1.78856.1.xml
From
Display Name r
Email
UUID 41A95281-121C-00004360A-EDEA2C9DEC56
Reply To
Text I-
To
Subject RI: cotutscl hat mg difficulty ii cung tii th client
Scheduled date 2019-07-07 18:18A0
Creation date 2019-07-07 18:l8:40
Modified date 2019-07-07 1828:10
Delivered  date 2019-07-07 181845
Message sift 1874
Attachments size 18690
Total size 20575
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TErf.larn
Content ID
5D223784.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.20000D4.1A
4679.1@45:5D223784.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.713856.1@h7.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100.0.1.0.l@l6
Is Inline fake
'type file
Sims 6844
5d8433971c1810e30562747e0c 154582
Hash DB37557967DD446064AIAA751E966CCA711803C7 ED5D4E91A34DBA21A9448FE08fiC65676
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D223784.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000134.1.4
4E7A.1@455D223784.NYMDOM 1.NYMADM 1.100.1
37387$.1.713856.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.l@l6
Is Inline fake
Type file
Slav 11846
CA 963aa5b4e5a8aa910ab07de24eca5181
Hash 2AA48131513B577C67167EC68353AEtCA7264A 18652 C68A0098BB58B2E340285F256DB19F63
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 27SOCADO-09CA-0000-A8F0-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
F:null
UUID I5A65610-0C33-00004O67-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification when declined fake
Page 12754
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 51)2237734.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.10).1373875.1.7 885E.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l 6
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADM I.NYMDOM I
Location II) 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.01.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System truc
Share Type NutShared
Page 12755
Audits
Dale Action Auditor Note
2019-12-11 06:2624 EST Created
en=Arehive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archive3.cn-Jobs.arGwopenNedetn-atchiv
ill:Armorial
Generated by Neigpvem Icn-Archive
t
Arc
Agen
hc
2-Zero Day
elen-Jobs.cre-GWOpenNock.cn-archis
ing.o-netmai]
2020-05-19 15:31:14 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-191532-02 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020.05-19153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2026-05.19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fhgged
2021.05.191437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 12756
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12757
From:
To:
Subject: : counse aving difficulty meeting with c lent
Sent: Sun, 7 Jul 2019 22:18:40 +0000
Massachusetts
From:
Sent: Sunda Jul 07 2019 18:18
To:
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Sorry , just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
Sent fmm my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Ori inal messy e
From: ' )" <1 .>
Date: 7/7/19 5:36 PM GMT -05:00)
To: >, '( >
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>>> )" 07/07/2019 17:36 >»
With apologies for the weekend email, we have a defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, who was arrested last night and is currently
being
detained at MCC, and is expected to be presented on an indictment tomorrow. His attorney, Martin Weinberg, has 
represented
him in the past, and represents him in connection with our case and has been in touch with us throughout the weekend. He
went to MCC today to meet with him in advance of the presentment tomorrow, but was just told he is not allowed in 
because he
is from out-of-state.
We're concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any
defendant) and so I wanted to reach out to you—is it at all possible to address this issue so Mr. Weinberg can meet with
his
client this evening? I'm available anytime at to discuss, if that's helpful, or Mr. Weinberg can also be reached
directly at 617-901-3472 if that's easier (though if you reach out directly to him if you could please just let me know 
afterward I'd
be grateful).
thanks very much,
Fwd: Re: New Wrden
From
To
Date 2019/11/01 10:07
Subject: Fwd: Re: New Wrden
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Another potential question for Wednesd elieve we are still usin staff and, if we have none who speak a
particular language, a language line. Dr.= and Commander can confirm.
>» < > 11/1/2019 9:51 AM > »
One other thing that you may be able to address (although this is more minor than the other issues): how
does the prison deal with prisoners who do not speak English when they need to see a =?
There is some interest in hearing what is going on with the Epstein suicide investigation, but I suspect that is
something the Warden cannot discuss.
See you Wednesday.
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, W 10007
From
To:
Date: 11/01/2019 07:56 AM
Subject Re: New Wrden
Good morning Your Honor,
My apologies, but I was out of the office unexpectedly yesterday due to a family
emergency.
Warden and I will be in attendance at the CJAB next week. He indicates he will
be addressing the issues that have delayed the attorney visiting study, to include those
related to the union. He will also update the Court on the female unit at MCC. Please
lest lie InNeNni if ones rieiciA "ntifkiirtin 'lee.
Page 12759
ICI. U3 I\M-/VV 11 yuu I eccu al ly LIM 9 ciac.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
>>> < > 10/31/2019 10:39 AM >> >
Will your new warden be able to attend the CJAB meeting next week?
Will you be attending? If so, would you like to give a brief explanation of the union issues associated with
the attorney waiting times study?
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NW 10007
Page 12760
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5DBCO3C4.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 EAAA.I
Message Path xmlAlaiboxl5DBC03C4.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.7EAAA.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: Re: New %Jen
Scheduled date 2019-11-01 100740
Creation date 2019-11-01 101)7430
Modified date 2019-11-01 2227/37
Delis cried date 2019-11-01 10:07A0
Message site 1973
Attachments size 4120
Total site 6104
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5DBCO3C4.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.20120000A0.1.1
4E3CC.1(4)455DBCO3C4.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.
1373875.1.7EAAA.Igt 1:7.NYMDOM1.NYMADM 110 00.1.o. l@16
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 4120
Date 2019-11-01 06:0614
CA 28caaf2c44393317ab5Itc29160a5b15
Hash IAIF-55C38FF19AA9CCF1228667EOCA3968A38A48 FOB3A55D77DAFCD95A03E138028248F4
Recipients II
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type SysternOroupMernber
Delis e red 2019.11-01100740
DossnloadedByThIrdParts 2019-11-01100743
Opened 2019-1141 10:12A2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 835B5EAO-I1C6-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemCeoupMember
Delis e red 2019-11-01104700
DounioadedlIsThirdParty 2019.11-01100701
Opened 2019-11-01 1907,34
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FD13W0-0C-(K--0000.886E-1B003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystertknaupMember
Delis c red 2019-11-01104740
Opened 2019-11-01 102859
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Ut11) 2DDA9D30-I006-0080-987C-OCD8BB22F09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
De lis e red 2019.11-01104700
Page 12761
DoonloackdlisThirdParly 2019.11-01101704
Opened 2019-11-01 12:1606
Recipieni
Display Name
Email
UUID 70602920-10E I -0000-947A-4AEAFT774805
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delivered 2019-11-01100703
DoonloarledB)ThIrdParty 2019.11-011007:15
Opened 2019-11-01 1103sl5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID MCE9350-084F-0000-AB39-FSOF2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delivered 2019-11-01l00700
lkionloadedByThirdParty 2019.11-01100711
Opened 2019-11-01 11:18.49
Recipient
Display Name
Email
HID 9077B2D0-19C1-0000-A989-02000000S8D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delivered 2019-11-01101700
DounloadedB,ThirdParty 2019-11-01100704
Opened 2019-11-01 102058
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4A2 sr r NO- 1010-0000-98AE-15D55568C865
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMernber
Delivered 2019.11-01100703
DoonloadedByThirdParty 2019-11-011007:15
Opened 2019-11-01 Kb4154
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
UUID 4237CDCO-I407-0000-A820-84D2I200S4D2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroup
Delivered 2019.11-01101700
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 66E64C10- I 320-00C0-8EC1-2F2162868DCC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystonGioupMcmber
Delivered 2019-11-01100700
DounInadedllylliirdgarty 2019.11-01100705
Opened 2019-11-01 1007:22
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID SECE I IC0-091340000-RDEI-7C3A87397621
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019.11-01100700
DonnloadedByThirdParty 2019.11-01222707
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read we
Page 12762
Deleted fake
Opened truc
Completed false
Security Nornnl
Box type Sent herrn
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification %%hen deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DBC03CALNYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.1373875.I.7
EAAA.1(41fLNYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@1 6
Source sent
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12763
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-11-08 202126 EST Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodern-archivings,Airla_I-Daily
tetmai
Oeaetated by Netgovem [en-Archhe
Archi.c3
Job.cn-Jobsrn-GWOpenNoiren-archhingr
-netmail]
2020-0519153606 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19153531 EDT Tag B0P01703.frOCRADMI.N1 Ni XRIX) 1 Responsive
2020-05-19 14:41:56 EDT Tag BOP01703.11VCRADMI.AIXRIXRA 1 Fbgged
Page 12764
Fwd: Re: New Wrden
From
To
Date 2019/11/01 10:07
Subject: Fwd: Re: New Wrden
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Another potential question for Wednesd elieve we are stil using aff and, if we have none who speak a
particular language, a language line. Dr.= and Commander can confirm.
>» < > 11/1/2019 9:51 AM > »
One other thing that you may be able to address (although this is more minor than the other issues): how
does the prison deal with prisoners who do not speak English when they need to see a =?
There is some interest in hearing what is going on with the Epstein suicide investigation, but I suspect that is
something the Warden cannot discuss.
See you Wednesday.
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, W 10007
From
To:
Date: 11/01/2019 07:56 AM
Subject Re: New Wrden
Good morning Your Honor,
My apologies, but I was out of the office unexpectedly yesterday due to a family
emergency.
Warden and I will be in attendance at the CJAB next week. He indicates he will
be addressing the issues that have delayed the attorney visiting study, to include those
related to the union. He will also update the Court on the female unit at MCC. Please
lest lie InNeNni if ones rieiciA "ntifkiirtin 'lee.
Page 12765
ICI. U3 I\M-/VV 11 yuu I eccu al ly LIM 9 ciac.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
>>> < > 10/31/2019 10:39 AM >> >
Will your new warden be able to attend the CJAB meeting next week?
Will you be attending? If so, would you like to give a brief explanation of the union issues associated with
the attorney waiting times study?
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NW 10007
Page 12766
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5DBCO3C4.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 EAAB.1
Message Path xmlMaiboxl5DBC03C4.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.7EAAB.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CAD0.09CA-0000-A8F41ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: Re: New Wrden
Scheduled date 2019-11-01 10071)0
Creation date 2019-11-01 10070)
Modified date 2019-11-01 10:12_08
Delis e red date 2019-11-01 10:0701
Message site 1973
Attachments size 4120
Total site 6104
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5DBCO3C4.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.20120000A0.1.1
4E3CC.IQ453DBC03C4.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.
1373873.1.7EAAB.I@II.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
Type file
Sirs 4120
Date 2019-11-01 060654
('A 28caaf2cda393317abStc29160a5b313
Hash IAIF-55C38FF19AA9CCF1228667EOCA3968A38A48 FOB3A55D77DAFCD95A03E13B028248F4
Recipients II
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroupMernber
Delis e red 2019.11-01100740
DonnloadedByThirdPart) 2019-11-01104743
Opened 2019-1141 10:12.92
Recipient
!Sisals) Name
Email
UUID 835B5EAO-I1C6-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemCanupMember
Delis e red 2019-11-01 100700
Donnloadedlls'lltirdParty 2019-11-01 100701
Opened 2019-11-01 190704
Recipient
Display Name
Ema0
UUID 43F)13000C(K'-0000.886E-1B003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystertkanupMember
Delis 42 red 2019-11-01 100700
Opened 2019-11-01 102859
Recipient
Display Name
Entail
till) 2DDA9D30-I006-00C0-987C-OCD8BB22F09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
De lis e red 2019-11-01 100700
Page 12767
DoonloackdlisThirdParly 2019.11-01101704
Opened 2019-11-01 12:1606
Recipieni
Display Name
Email
UUID 70602920-10E I -0000-947A-4AEAFT774805
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delivered 2019-11-01100703
DoonloarledB)ThIrdParty 2019.11-011007:15
Opened 2019-11-01 1103sl5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID MCE9350-084F-0000-AB39-FSOF2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delivered 2019-11-01l00700
lkionloadedByThirdParty 2019.11-01100711
Opened 2019-11-01 11:18.49
Recipient
Display Name
Email
HID 9077B2D0-19C1-0000-A989-02000000S8D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delivered 2019-11-01101700
DounloadedB,ThirdParty 2019-11-01100704
Opened 2019-11-01 102058
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4A2 sr r NO- 1010-0000-98AE-15D55568C865
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMernber
Delivered 2019.11-01100703
DoonloadedByThirdParty 2019-11-011007:15
Opened 2019-11-01 Kb4154
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
UUID 4237CDCO-I407-0000-A820-84D2I200S4D2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroup
Delivered 2019.11-01101700
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 66E64C10- I 320-00C0-8EC1-2F2162868DCC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystonGioupMcmber
Delivered 2019-11-01100700
DounInadedllylliirdgarty 2019.11-01100705
Opened 2019-11-01 1007:22
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID SECE I IC0-091340000-RDEI-7C3A87397621
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019.11-01100700
DonnloadedByThirdParty 2019.11-01222707
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read we
Page 12768
Deleted fake
Opened We
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box twe Intox
Return notification when opened false
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed fake
Return notification 'sten declined fake
Return notification alien
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DBC03CANYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.1373875.I.7
EAAB.1(4)1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1(41 6
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Maims
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 12769
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-11-08 202127 EST Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-Jobs.erGWOpenNodern-archivings,APM_I-Daily
ietmai
Gerrrated by Netgovem [en-Archive
Archi.c3
Job.cn-Jobsrn-GWOpenNoiren-archhingr
-netmad]
2020-05-19153606 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19153531 EDT Tag BOP01700.frOCRADMI.N1 XRIX)hil Responsive
2020-05-19 14:41:56 EDT Tag BOP01703.1vDCRADMI.AIXRIXRAI Fbgged
Page 12770
Re: New Wrden
From
To
Date 2019/11/01 09:52
Subject: Re: New Wrden
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
One other thing that you may be able to address (although this is more minor than the other issues): how
does the prison deal with prisoners who do not speak English when they need to see a
There is some interest in hearing what is going on with the Epstein suicide investigation, but I suspect that
is something the Warden cannot discuss.
See you Wednesday.
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
From:
To: *c >
Date: 11/01/2019 07:56 AM
Subject: Re: New Wrden
Good morning Your Honor,
My apologies, but I was out of the office unexpectedly yesterday due to a family emergency.
Warden and I will be in attendance at the CIAB next week. He indicates he will be
addressing the issues that have delayed the attorney visiting study, to include those related to the
union. He will also update the Court on the female unit at MCC. Please let us know if you need
anything else.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Page 12771
eclat/11dt
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
p:
>>> 10/31/2019 10:39 AM >»
Will your new warden be able to attend the CJAB meeting next week?
Will you be attending? If so, would you like to give a brief explanation of the union issues associated with
the attorney waiting times study?
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
Page 12772
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5DBC0070.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 EAA6. 1
Message Path xmliMadboA5DBC0070.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.7EAA6laml
From
Display Name
Email
Reply To
Test
To
Subject Re: New Widen
Scheduled date 2019-11-01 09:5138
Creation date 2019-11-01 09.3138
Modified date 2019-11-01 123727
Delisend date 2019-11-01 0932A9
Message size 1697
Attachments sin 13651
Total size 15359
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.Inm
Content ID
5DBC0070.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.2000018.1.8
795E Ig453DBC0070NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.7EAA6.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1(g la
Is Inline false
Type Me
Size 3773
CA 9405cdb5da8986ce194c0fIbf5639a14
Hash 4FIC5F4F9A6430303C47C7E30E8F83256D9274D3 B3B98E5530BB0FDDIF09AD3A92CE28F5
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5DBC0070.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.2000018. LB
7960.1®455DBC0070.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100.1
373875.1.7EAA6.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
Type Ede
Size 9878
CA 984510a la25e3ca7ce007e682 1257699
Hash 6570BD95FC789461EAD4DDE97344C5BB3E7431B5 F.C9BB643DFD5C997191499C44ABFEC2A
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID 2750CADO-09CA-0300-A8F4-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened title
Completed false
Security Nomul
Box type Inbox
Return notification "hen opened false
Return notification "hen de le te d fake
Return notification "hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined false
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DB0:070.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 EAA61(01:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.161;1
Source received
Class Public
Page 12773
Account I NYMADMLNYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mal=
II) 7.NYMDOMLNYMAD641.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Muffins
Type Maibox
System tme
Share Type NotShared
Page 12774
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-11-08 2021:43 EST Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-lobs.en-GWOpenNodern-archivings,Arla_I-Daily
tetmai
Gerrrated by Netgovem [en-Archive
Archi.c3
Job.cn-Jobsrn-GWOpenNoiren-archhingr
-netmail]
2020-0519153606 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.N1XR DOM] Responsive
2020-05-19153531 EDT Tag BOP01703.frOCRADMI.NIXRIXMAI Responsive
2020-05-19 14:41:56 EDT Tag BOP0170334)CRADMI.AIRRIXRAI Fbgged
Page 12775
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12776
To:
Subject: Re: New Wrden
From:
Sent: Fri, 1 Nov 2019 09:51:58 -0400
One other thing that you may be able to address (altathis is more minor than the other issues): how does the prison deal
with prisoners
who do not speak English when they need to see a
There is some interest in hearing what is going on with the Epstein suicide investigation, but I suspect that is 
something the Warden cannot
discuss.
See you Wednesday.
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
From:
To: 4=IMMI IM>
Date: 11/01/2019 0756 AM
Subject: Re: New Wrden
Good morning Your Honor,
My apologies, but I was out of the office unexpectedly yesterday due to a family emergency.
Warden and I will be in attendance at the GAB next week. He indicates he will be addressing the issues that have
delayed the attorney visiting study, to include those related to the union. He will also update the Court on the female 
unit at
MCC. Please let us know if you need anything else.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York. New York 10007
P:=
>» 10/31/2019 10:39 AM >»
Will your new warden be able to attend the CJAB meeting next week?
Will you be attending? If so, would you like to give a brief explanation of the union issues associated with the 
attorney waiting times study?
Hon. Valerie Caproni
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
40 Foley Square
New York, NY 10007
Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From Google Alerts
To
Date 2019/07/29 19:05
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
Attachments: TEXT.htin, Mime.822
bureau of prisons .0 July 29, 2019
NEWS
Robbers assault woman and hold 16-year-old at gunpoint in Port Arthur
KBTV Fox 4 Beaumont
Information below from Port Arthur Police Department: ... Sheriff Stephens says the prison did not
notify her office about this latest escape Saturday.
Jeffrey Epstein's Suicide Attempt, Next Steps In Prison
Forbes
The Bureau of Prisons (BOP), which runs the the Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC) where
Jeffrey Epstein is being held on sex trafficking ...
Federal Executions to Resume
Prescott eNews
11 with a fatal injection of pentobarbital if all goes according to the plan unveiled by the Justice
Department and the U.S. Bureau of Prisons. Mitchell...
Former public defender: DOJ plan to resume federal executions a 'recipe for problems' - The Hill
Poll: Do you agree with the reinstatement of the federal death penalty? - lehighvalleylive.com
US government resumes executions using pentobarbital injection - The BMJ
Full Coverage
Flag as irrelevant
Forest Hills Attorney Who Made False Statements to Federal Agency
Sentenced to 60 Days ...
Forest Hills Post
A Forest Hills attorney has been sentenced to 60 days confinement for making false statements to the
U.S. Bureau of Prisons, the US Attorneys office ...
Page 12779
Clinton County sentenced for illegally prescribing opioids
WBKO
Cummings was also ordered to reimburse the Bureau of Prisons for the costs of his incarceration.
Cummings was charged in 2017 with 18 counts of ...
House member introduces bill to abolish federal death penalty
10TV
Just after the Department of Justice resumed capital punishment after 16 years ... Barr has now directed
the federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) to adopt a ...
Former inmates get second chance at Victoria manufacturing company
Victoria Advocate
... the act also requires the Department of Justice to develop an assessment system to be used by the
Bureau of Prisons to assess the recidivism risk of ...
PolitiFact: Yes, children at Homestead facility get far less time to call family
than federal prisoners
Tampa Bay Times
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services sent us the policy ... A federal Bureau of Prisons
policy states that inmates get 300 minutes per ...
When should children be taught about gun safety?
CBS17.com
He served in the U.S. Air Force and worked for the Federal Bureau of Prisons.
Now he is the range and education director at Triangle Shooting ...
Man jailed in missing Wisconsin brothers case is denied
bond on tampering charge
Kansas City Star
In court records, a deputy with the Caldwell County Sheriffs Office said ... from
prison in March 2018, according to the Federal Bureau of Prisons.
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Page 12780
INetedIVe U Ilb Well db 1100 I ettl
Send Feedback
Page 12781
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D3F4372NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316D.1.7 OEF.I
Message Path xmliMadboxi5D3F4372.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316D.1.70EF.I.xml
From Google Alerts
Display Name Go* Alerts
Email googlealerts-noreplyntgeogle.com
Reply To googkakns.noreply(ggoogk.com
Test Google Alerts
To
Subject Google Alert - bureau of micros
Scheduled date 201907-29190400
Creation date 201907-29190400
Modified date 201907-3007:1429
Delivered date 201907-29190523
Message sine 5662
Attachments sirs 97488
Total size 103161
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.Inm
Content ID
5D3F4372NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20800E5.1.8
75C6.1€455D3F4372NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.1001
7031 613.1.70EF. 1(§1 2.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.1@iI6
Is Inline fake
T,Pc lie
Size 39998
CA 4aadfl 14c71c8681312722ca5e9749fe
Hash OD9FCEC9118086B57E0A95C5453D471588B580D3 9A81332813F844474F87E3114881CB913361
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D3F4372.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20CCOE5.1.8
75C7.1(41455D3F4372.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
7031613.1.70EF. IQ I 2.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1 ®16
Is Inline fake
Type Me
Size 57490
CA 29832060777dad7ed2137573dfd4066d0
Hash 9F-343FCF92.574BE2D60F2CDE3F5F7CFAC4089577 DAOB568D790FBC325CC66ED14F73C863
Recipients I
Recipient
Displas Name
Email
LIVID 835B5E40-11C6-0000-B3D6FE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nomni
Box type Inbox
Return notification %%hen opened false
Return notification %%hen deleted fake
Return notification %%hen
completed fake
Return notification viten declined false
Return notification %Men
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D3F4372.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.170316D.1.7 OEF. I (01:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.10:40.1.0.1@l6
Source received
Class Public
Account ESTADMI.ESFDOMI
Page 12782
Location ID 1540642445516
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1006
Name Maiboa
Type Mailbox
System Inc
Share Type NoiShored
Page 12783
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-08 172935 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive)
Jolun-lebs.crGWOpenNodetn-archiviig.ciMgcni-
Ietmai
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [crrArchive
I -DallY ArchiveIJoben-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNociexn-archivingso
nicunail]
2019-08.21093902 EDT Exported netmainctmaancurrad Exported by netmainetinainetmaa
2019-08-21133135 EDT Exported neunainetinadnetmai Exported by netnraitnetrixanetrrail
2019.09.0718:1033 EDT Exported nctinainetnuancinna Exported by ncuminctmainetmail
202005.19153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020.05.191437:19 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
Page 12784

╭──────────────────────────────── Page 333, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────╮
│ ‘Audits                                                                           │
│ Date ‘Action ‘Auditor Nove                                                        │
│                                                                                   │
│ ~ |Generated by Netmnil Inc,[en-Archine                                           │
│ sn-Archive Agent_I-Daily Archivel Ree tbek Acer                                   │
│                                                                                   │
│ 19-08-08 172955 EDT [Created [sertaercropetadrarhvng ihe veya                     │
│ oie a1 (SOM EDT [Exported mail etmai petal [Exported by netmaibnetmaicnetma       │
│                                                                                   │
│ 9-08-21 133155 EDT — [Exported pena netma-neta [Exported by netmailnetmai-netma   │
│ Bp19.09.07 181033 EDT [Exported nail neta petal [Exported by netmaitnetmaiLnetmat │
│ 2005-19 153401 EDT [Tag [BOPOI703.MXRADMI_MXRDOMT [Responsive                     │
│ Bo2005-19 143719 EDT [Tag [BOPOI703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI [Fiaeaed                      │
│                                                                                   │
│ Page 12784                                                                        │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12785
Sent: Mon, 29 Jul 2019 16:04:00 -0700
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From: Goo gl  Alerts < ooglealerls-noreply@google.com>
To:
bureau of prisons
NEWS
Robbers assault woman and hold 16-year-old at gunpoint in Port Arthur
KBTV Fox 4 Beaumont
Information below from Port Arthur Police Department: ... Sheriff Stephens says the prison did not notify her office 
about
this latest escape Saturday.
Jeffrey Epstein's Suicide Attempt, Next Steps In Prison
Forbes
The Bureau of Prisons (BOP), which runs the the Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC) where Jeffrey Epstein is being
held on sex trafficking ...
Federal Executions to Resume
Prescott eNews
11 with a fatal injection of pentobarbital if all goes according to the plan unveiled by the Justice Department and the 
U.S.
Bureau of Prisons. Mitchell...
Former public defender: DOJ plan to resume federal executions a 'recipe for problems' - The Hill
Poll: Do you agree with the reinstatement of the federal death penalty? • lehighvalleylive.com
US government resumes executions using pentobarbital injection - The BMJ
Full Coverage
Flag as irrelevant
Forest Hills Attorney Who Made False Statements to Federal Agency Sentenced to 60 Days
Forest Hills Post
A Forest Hills attorney has been sentenced to 60 days confinement for making false statements to the U.S. Bureau of
Prisons. the US Attorney's office ...
DCX
Clinton County sentenced for illegally prescribing opioids
WBKO
Cummings was also ordered to reimburse the Bureau of Prisons for the costs of his incarceration. Cummings was charged
in 2017 with 18 counts of...
• MI
House member introduces bill to abolish federal death penalty
10TV
Just after the Department of Justice resumed capital punishment after 16 years ... Barr has now directed the federal 
Bureau
of Prisons (BOP) to adopt a ...
■
Former inmates get second chance at Victoria manufacturing company
Victoria Advocate
... the act also requires the Department of Justice to develop an assessment system to be used by the Bureau of Prisons
to assess the recidivism risk of ...
PolitiFact: Yes, children at Homestead facility get far less time to call family than federal
prisoners
Tampa Bay Times
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services sent us the policy ... A federal Bureau of Prisons policy states that
inmates get 300 minutes per ...
When should children be taught about gun safety?
CBS17.com
He served in the U.S. Air Force and worked for the Federal Bureau of Prisons. Now he is the range and education director
at Triangle Shooting ...
XX
Man jailed in missing Wisconsin brothers case is denied bond on tampering charge
Kansas City Star
In court records. a deputy with the Caldwell County Sheriff's Office said ... from prison in March 2018, according to 
the
Federal Bureau of Prisons.
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From Google Alerts
To
Date 2020/01/09 18:06
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
Attachments: TEXT.httn, Mime.822
bureau of prisons update January 9, 2020
NEWS
Federal prison reform has bipartisan support. But it's moving slowly.
Washington Post
M the center of the change is the U.S. Bureau of Prisons, which currently incarcerates about 175,250
inmates. Although the law applies only to the ...
Jail video of Jeffrey Epstein's first suicide attempt was deleted, prosecutors
reveal
CNBC
Bureau of Prisons spokesperson Emery Nelson told CNBC: "We decline to comment as the Epstein
case is under investigation by the Federal Bureau ...
Proposal Would Protect Confidentiality of Attorney-Inmate Emails
Bloomberg Law
Proposal Would Protect Confidentiality of Attomey-Inmate Emails ... electronic communications sent or
received through the Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) ...
2 men sentenced for walking near Old Faithful in Yellowstone NP
KPAX-TV
Court documents state the the 10-day jail sentence must be served by Schefflin by March 1, 2020, in the
custody of the U.S. Bureau of Prisons.
Grain fraudster Hunter Hanson to serve time in Duluth
AG Week
Federal District Judge Daniel Hovland said the Federal Bureau of Prisons attenpts to place inmates
Page 12788
within 500 miles of home to be more available for ...
Man sentenced to prison in enticing a minor case
Monitor
Man sentenced to prison in enticing a minor case ... by his probation officer, the Bureau of Prisons, and
any state sex offender registration agency.
Wyoming News Update
Sheridan Media (press release)
Authorities say the U.S. Bureau of Prisons and the U.S. Marshals Service were notified of Mahoney's
escape before a federal magistrate issued an ...
INSIGHT: The First Step Act—Earned Time Credits on the Horizon
Bloomberg Law
As of January, all inmates in the Bureau of Prisons (BOP) custody will have undergone an initial
assessment pursuant to implementing a new risk and ...
What Contract Opportunities Are Top Of Mind? 2019's Most Read RFPs
OPEN MINDS
The West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources is seeking a ... The U.S. Department of
Justice, Federal Bureau of Prisons is seeking a ...
Federal appeals court affirms Corrine Brown's fraud conviction
WJXT News4JAX
After Brown initially reported to prison, the Bureau of Prisons website showed her release date as June
6, 2022. The BOP site now shows her release ...
WEB
Correctional Program Officer (Administrator, Intelligence/Counter-Terrorism)
USAJOBS - Job Announcement
Correctional Program Officer (Administrator, Intelligence/Counter-Terrorism). Department of Justice.
Justice, Bureau of Prisons/Federal Prison System.
Page 12789
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Page 12790
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5E176BBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316111.1 69EC.I
Message Path xraMattox15E1768BC.NYMD0MI.NYMADMI.100.17031613.1.169EC.I.xml
From Google Akrts
Display Name Goo& Akrts
Email googlealerts-nareplyregeogle.earn
Reply. To googkaknsmoreplyp googk.com
Test Google Alerts
To
Subject Google Alert - bureau of prisons
Scheduled date 2020-01-09 I803:18
Creation date 2020-01-091803:18
Modified date 202001-09 182739
Delivered date 202041-09180633
Message she 6017
Attachments sin 89443
Total size 95471
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.huri
Name TEXT.Ium
Content ID
5E1768BC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.2000OD9.1.8
5019.1@453E176BBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1

703160. 1 .169EC.I@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM 1. 100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Tspe Ile
Size 35941
CA 0e467149a0f2a173331478616474bd7e
Hash B0988882545lEl I 53702847C3FAA5AC5BAB9C29F A54771809C18DBF693A8F9822664E94C
Attachment Mim.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5EI76BBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000O9.1.8
501A.1®455E176BBC.NYMDOMI.NYAIADM1.1001
7031613.1.169EC.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM I.100.0.1.0.1@16
Is Inline fake
Type He
Size 53502
CA 608eb5e2bbbe967b79&9633503f1652
Hash 19C45501EA17AFF07BC49BD9B382D4387FICII86B BD36DC48341803F32597139CC8664CE4
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID 835B5E40-1106-0000-B3D6FE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nomn1
Box type Inbox
Return notification "hen opened false
Return notification "hen de le te d fake
Return notification "hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined false
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Intents] ID 5E176BBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316D.1.1 69EC.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.101; I
Source received
Class Pubfie
Page 12791
Account MI
1540842445516 Location ID
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mal=
II) 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Maim
Type Mailbox
System tme
Share Type NotShared
Page 12792
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
3020.01-17 143732 EST Created
meArchive Agent 1-Daly Archive I Job.cn-lcbs.crGii/OpenNodetn-archising,p(A8cdt_
mictmai
Generated by Netgovem icn-Archim
I -Daily Archive!
Johen-Jobs.en-GWOpenNocle.cn-archivinpr o
mettnaill
202006-01142130 EDT Viewed B0P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1 Viewed by
BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I
2020-06-02 11:1335 EDT Viewed BOP01/29.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Viewed by
BOPOI829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I
2020-06-06202006 EDT Viewed B0P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Viewed by
BOP011829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI
2020.0606 2020:31 EDT Viewed BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Viewed by
BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI
202006-06202031 EDT Viewed BOP01829.NCRADM I.NCRDOM I Viewed by
BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI
20204549 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
202165.191437:19 EDT Tag 130P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
2020-06-01 1821,41 EDT Tag Et0P01829.NCRADM I.NCRDOM I Responsive
Page 12793
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12794
Sent: Thu, 09 Jan 2020 15:03:18 -0800
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From: Goo gl  Alerts < ooglealerts-noreply@google.00m>
To:
bureau of prisons
NEWS
Federal prison reform has bipartisan support. But it's moving slowly.
Washington Post
At the center of the change is the U.S. Bureau of Prisons, which currently incarcerates about 175,250 inmates. Although
the law applies only to the ...

• •
Jail video of Jeffrey Epstein's first suicide attempt was deleted, prosecutors reveal
CNBC
Bureau of Prisons spokesperson Emery Nelson told CNBC: "We decline to comment as the Epstein case is under
investigation by the Federal Bureau ...
aa asir' 0 ss,am:
Proposal Would Protect Confidentiality of Attorney-Inmate Emails
Bloomberg Law
Proposal Would Protect Confidentiality of Attorney-Inmate Emails ... electronic communications sent or received through 
the
Bureau of Prisons' (BOP) ...
2 men sentenced for walking near Old Faithful in Yellowstone NP
KPAX-TV
Court documents state the the 10-day jail sentence must be served by Schefflin by March 1, 2020, in the custody of the 
U.S.
Bureau of Prisons.
Grain fraudster Hunter Hanson to serve time in Duluth
AG Week
Federal District Judge Daniel Hovland said the Federal Bureau of Prisons attempts to place inmates within 500 miles of
home to be more available for ...
IZ IZ1
Man sentenced to prison in enticing a minor case
Monitor
Man sentenced to prison in enticing a minor case ... by his probation officer, the Bureau of Prisons, and any state sex
offender registration agency.
•
Wyoming News Update
Sheridan Media (press release)
Authorities say the U.S. Bureau of Prisons and the U.S. Marshals Service were notified of Mahoney's escape before a
federal magistrate issued an ...

• • Flag sa ss,
INSIGHT: The First Step Act—Earned Time Credits on the Horizon
Bloomberg Law
As of January, all inmates in the Bureau of Prisons (BOP) custody will have undergone an initial assessment pursuant to
implementing a new risk and ...

• •
What Contract Opportunities Are Top Of Mind? 2019's Most Read RFPs
OPEN MINDS
The West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources is seeking a ... The U.S. Department of Justice, Federal
Bureau of Prisons is seeking a ...
• MI
Federal appeals court affirms Corrine Brown's fraud conviction
WJXT News4JAX
After Brown initially reported to prison, the Bureau of Prisons website showed her release date as June 6, 2022. The BOP
site now shows her release ...
MIN
WEB
Correctional Program Officer (Administrator, Intelligence/Counter-Terrorism)
USAJOBS - Job Announcement
Correctional Program Officer (Administrator, Intelligence/Counter-Terrorism). Department of Justice. Justice, Bureau of
Pr'sons/Federal Prison System.
XX
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
hid: counsel haying difficulty meeting with client
From
naie 2019/07/07 18:22
subject: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Attachments: my' . him
I have verified Martin Weinberg is an attorney in good standing in Massachusetts. He is permitted to visit Jeffrey 
Epstein.
Sent from my Veliton. Samoans Galaxy smartphon:
- Ori messa
From:
Date: 7/7/19 6:18 PM GMT-05130
To: >,
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>>> 07/07/2019 18:18>>>
Massachusetts
From:
Sent: Sunday Ju 07
To:
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Sony MI,
just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
2019 18:18
<S>:
Sent from my Vernon, Samsung Galaxy smanphonc
Ou ri rimessa  al
From: " ii cmailto:Alexander.Rossmiller(rifusdoj.gov>>
Datialair cki GMT
,To: <maiho >. "". cinala >
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>» " 07/07/2019 17:36 >>>
With apologies for the weekend email. we have a defendant. Jeffrey Epstein, who was arrested last night and is currently
being detained at MCC, and is e
of-state.
Were concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any defendant) and so I wante
s very much,
Page 12797
ProperIles
POWS Vie
MesseselD 11323301 1.00MI NYMADAILI011 I ILI I
Moshe h! met 1022.1107 NYTIDOMI NYMADMI ID) 165 1.1µM I Int
Phu Mona,
Polo eh
fa0 sholetonAltho
171111 1710CADDOCCAACCOAIRAIAChlEA7175
Rn1d5 74
Ito
T.
i I i
I
Sehol Ned mailmen 617culv north Alban.
Mbedi0 Set 3119Y1-01 In:00
Creoles the 10100701112210
Mailed 0eee 9X0710 I 40
Dello fed dot 2010)747 IILISI6
Meo•re dm t119
Anerborsis dm 4Z9I
Teed ger
Allarlast, I
Asstbueem Ill14M
Niiing TEXtlin
heaMot ID
1D22107 NVAIDOMI NYMADMI SO 7:000All I I
WO II*412 ,10.2.1377NYAIDOMI.NVAIADMI 1(0
ItANIC I MCC l0; I7710.00W NYMADMI 1000 I 0 1,0I6
It last tabe
Th . RC
MM COI
CA ela.14IslOb7loteADLI04/4ka
Halt A911/1)19178.0AASECD6IDODA0I,1101 7}ADD 18117I7_ 001 I 40001,7•2
RehArno 15
Rehtle°
Dspla, N ante
Email
!AID PAAA.N110.01F700:041)1C.FDICIA1I71FD
Monsoon 01.0 TO
Itecloc et dal
Re twa al
DAplo Ave
Final
WO 12.1.410A0-104-0M0A171.00111300001
Posinhistien Tip TO
IN et l irtopMeet0
&e".
DSO,' Nape
mill
!AID DI 112A 01 II a X0F0AABCAM1P70A9I
Diotibutiun Np. TO
R.( illicit I Pe S nutAb.
Der Ate
Foul'
1.77D IL1CUt'aoowLdO0T1m1'.'J.k911AM1:1
Dioribish• Tip TO
Reclpitat Tq on
&ORR°
DAM. •
Immo
llII1 4: II.737011A7.010114100.11(4.
Disitibuo.t. Ipp TO
At oDtc at i S lime*, Wake
Wrp u.
Dap', Auer
la I
I I 10 trio. I:UW1a91pjY1QIMH54thehl
lAonott, TO
holm et hp.
Redirect',
Digt, Nat
CO I
CD .00A00 10 IMAMS 4X RIASINA
Ettelbells• Toe TO
ReelPlellelhe
Reelpitet
Mph hew
FAS
MIR IMSDIIOODA]-lgLLR1.7A11DA1 ell
Dibilettla Tip TO
Red I RRI TM sagAletteict
Red1R-
Mph As F
901711200.19CI4000.ADWOMAD100
DIDelbiAles Toe TO
Reell/t 0Ilhe
Recipient
DA %atm
Fr
M:lue'Y01de0m0W5.9.ro1000RMIY
DIstribulla hp/ 10
Re RI TIPP soetalitratrAmeict
R7R1Rmi
Mph hat
hull
14MItAWItl:-0YDHUTLHCAAllf941W I. I. ID
Mod ion Tpp TO
Reel keel %Wont. M.
Re hats
cu lt Naar
hull
1 LID 400.4 I 7011000
lksinbutsa Two To
Page 12798

╭─ Page 347, Image 1 ─╮
│ oan Sa              │
│                     │
│ a o                 │
│ mae oe              │
│ a 70                │
│ ae ae               │
│ ney ———             │
│ ‘nS =               │
│ a 70                │
│                     │
│ nee =               │
│ ‘i =                │
│ es o                │
│ ae ss               │
│ nee I               │
│ Tat _ =             │
│ a 70                │
│ ae =                │
│ ae —                │
│ ‘i                  │
│                     │
│ a 0                 │
│ ae = .              │
│                     │
│ Page 12798          │
╰─────────────────────╯

Ropiest TAX
Red/lemt
DIM" Nat
Cal
CRUD RiC7D704MAA.0072-ATALLOOX00000W0
Illitelhalb•Mpe TO
ReallemITTP S. di.
Reciplast
Die Met
Fail
I IL ID BIRDSCOX0X0X0
Mammies Type TO
STOP, " In* Sramslert
Redress
Make
Same
Fetal
TIM A WM Datil DATIOIMI711-97MCMODIF
Dishihution f nit RI
Redeem Tvgar hmtantirteeMatace
Fair 0
Delay Raven itO 0
Dar ed lake
Archived nit
Real trite
Alma tale
OPmed the
Compitied Tar
Semally Nina
Res DPI Ilia
Ream milkeske when mead rake
Rem, maltialashmaeleird tale
Retai millestliemtbrit
templaill Isla
Remo ealkeeka when drama DS
Resent seelkeelerebee
seamed file
Mate %Swam SS
'Memel ID IMMO NYMIDOMI VIIMADMI IOU SWIM I 5 MIS Na I 7 Nymnow N1 %MAD KO 0.1 PI ic I 6
Seem maimed
Clma nen
Miceli DANADAII DANDOMI
Leads. ID I SIMISSOM6
Clem Naha GP MI-MAZY MAIL
Wm Ram I
Felder Masa
ID 7 NYMCOM I NYMADMI. MOO I 0 la la
Name hletea
Slam
System Ina
Mat Type Naiad
Page 12799
Avis
Dale Again Angler Nage
11/14140.19 1173123 For Cresol
arArclar Agnkl-Data Ards,' ia , kb „
ragansled by Miami Ix lco•Aiglit
Arclawl
kbra-ktatiralepeallotkat-ercIaret
sit
<vorcr , skaresnas igagi_l•Dety
91:miail
M19.01.1111011011For Laparical In.a neeneintunal Fared by inmaininuisegail
"man 170950 FDT Faprial WIlnd MO III i 1 isitwicallaa negradromaantimai
:01W916 193313 EDl a al1,901 wand mama 1 Mil. Ui Fawn taa nturoinaarsintgroi
NNag- la 1.37'11IDr hg fit allaia 91\1111AB NIXRCOM1 abssof
Nlba:a9 191331:4 Ern lag BOPOINal 1.1‘RAI)%11 NaltLION11 Repast
)S05. 1943101 Fur lag 11010110 MXILADM 1.9001,D1)%11 Otcagamor
Z1X140-19 114.11J4 tor lag 90901, 1199`01/a0M191.10t00/11 nursed
,0114-19 Ilifll (DI I. 110•0170.‘ 91XNADMIlalt00911 Pollan
Page 12800

╭──────── Page 349, Image 1 ────────╮
│ = =                               │
│                                   │
│ fa i                              │
│ riba hes                          │
│                                   │
│ =item                             │
│ aT Ter eee                        │
│ ae TTD fevers Fipaats wrstntet eT │
│ oe STEED retire Fepsts nrtet eT   │
│ fort aroccnuraaomT — Fase         │
│ rare NNRDONT — Rene               │
│ rar ara spout — Fegan             │
│ fora ana sant — Fine              │
│ Beose esr a VV                    │
│                                   │
│ Page 12800                        │
╰───────────────────────────────────╯

Re: hi and a question
From
To
Date 2019/07/25 09:57
Subject: Re: hi and a question
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Elsorry to bother you with this:
Update: We got over 30 inquiries. My boss is drafting a very short answer that will probably say we don't
comment on an inmate's health status or conditions of confinement for privacy reasons.
My boss had me call MCC NY just now to be sure they are not releasing varying statements to the media, we
want the institution & me to use the same exact statement to all media (we'll give them the statement we
come up with shortly and be sure they're fine with it) and they just told me you're acting will call me back
shortly.
Last thing - I didn't realize he went to the hospital, I might ask your acting exec. if he's still at the hospital or
how long there, etc, if that's true (news article say he went to a hospital).
Public Information Office
r I B r of Prisons
>>  >
Yes it's all over the NY papers.
> 7/25/2019 923 AM > »
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Original message
From:' <
Date: 7/25/19 9:20 AM (GMT-05:00)
To:
Subject: Re: hi and a question
>» ' 07/25/2019 09:20 > »
Thanks , I'll take this to Nancy when I arrive in a few minutes. I saw multiple articles and Twitter posts
late last night on this too
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Page 12801
iyuldl messaye
From:
Date: 7/24/19 11:01 PM (GMT-05:00)
To:'  <
Subject: Fwd: hi and a question
> > > 07/24/2019 23:01 >>>
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Original message
From: "Weiser, Ben' <weiser@nytimes.com>
Date: 7/24/19 10:47 PM (GMT-05:00)
To:
Subject: hi and a question
> » "Weiser, Ben" 07/24/2019 22:47 » >
hi ■
hope you are well. We saw an article tonight on someting called Radaronline
reporting that Jeffrey Epstein attempted to commit suicide at the MCC
(unsuccessfully.)
Are you in a position to help me on that with some sort of confirmation or
information. (Or to dispel its veracity?) thanks, Ben
Benjamin Weiser
Reporter, The New York Times
Office: 212-556-4065
Mobile: 914-672-1595
Email: weiser@nytimes.com
@benweisernyt
Page 12802
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.165396E.1.5 93DA. I
Message Path xmlIslatoxi5D397CFE.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 .165396E.I.593DA.Uanl
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 82684981-0F46-0030-BD8C-000000000000
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: hi and a question
Scheduled date 2019-07-25 09:57:16
Creation date 201907-25 09157:16
Modified date 2019.07-2907:2153
Delivered date 2019-07-25 0957:19
Message sine 2341
Attachments size 5219
Total size 7571
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hun
Content ID
5D397CFENYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.2000736.1.2
C£49.1®455D_Pitctt.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
65396E.1.593DA.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 5219
Date 2019-07-25 0557:15
CA d30)31:4008637bla5ldb0cd95d4c1M2f
Hash CDA53378334C9C4BA51C3CEBF4203781F87A5CCC 7053481C3E02644F32477FB941E3FA56
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name _
1:mail
UUID 9D77B2D0-19C1-0000-A989-0200000058DO
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Intox
Return notification sshcn opened false
Return notification iyhe n deleted false
Return notification Mien
completed false
Return notification uhen declined false
Return notification %%hell
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D397CFE.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.165396E.1.5 SODA. I@II.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1®1
Source received
Class Public
Account DANADMI.DANDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Madbox
Type hatbox
Page 12803
System
Share Type
UM
NotShared
Page 12804
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-02 172708 EDT Created
co=Archive Agent 1-Daly Archive3
Jobgn-lobsxn-Gli/OpenNodegn-archivilgslAgent-
xetmai
Generated by Netrre0 Inc. [cn=Archive
I -Daily Archivc3Jobtn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNocletn-archivingp
-netrna ill
2119-08.21132808 EDT &potted netmainetmadmetntad Exported by netmainetmainetmad
2019-08-22 170950 EDT Exported noon inetina inetmai Exported by netorailnetrixanetrasil
2019.0946 15:33:14 EDT Exported netmainetmannetmad Exported by noon ilnetma inetma il
2020-05-19 14:37:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
2020.0549 15:3606 EDT Tag 80P01703.MXRADMI.NIXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag B0801703.MXRADMI.NIXR I HMI Responsive
2020.0549 164156 EDT Tag 80801703.MXRADMI.NIXRDOMI rbgged
Page 12805
Re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1_1
From
To
Date 2019/08/12 14:12
Subject: Re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1_1
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Thank you
>>>
review
8/12/2019 2:08 PM > »
Page 12806
Properties
Property' Value
NlessagelD 5D5173EONYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.165396E.1.5 A329.1
Message Path xmlqviaboxl5D5173E6.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.165396E1.5A329.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
til ID 9137782D0-19C1-0000-A989.O200000058D0
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: Epstein...Jeffrey Edward. Reg. Na 73618-054 1_1
Scheduled date 2019-08-12 14:1234
Creation dale 2019-08.1214:1234
Modified date 2019-08-12 14:1327
Delivered date 2019-08-12 14:1234
Message size 57
Attachments sire 298
Total sire 366
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.Iim
Name TEXT.Itm
Content ID
5D5173E&NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.200033&1.9
EB4B.1@453D5173E6.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
653%E 1.5A329.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Infine fake
TYP4 fdc
Size 298
Date 2019-08-12 10:1252
CA cab449d101665bO9ee417a5d2106858
Hash AA2AA561EB57C4ACE91BD43FDB87A3B5DOIEA7C3 I2D38E9C24EC536A803270E622DF757F
Recipients I
Re cipie nt
Display Name
Email
UV ID EB6A70E0-18C7-0000-B0CC-F23DDIFC3CEC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Ikliscred 2019-08-1214:1254
Opened 2019-08-12 14:1324
Expire 0
Delay delivers until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Boy type Sen Items
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted false
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification when
accepted fake
Archive Ve rs ion 5.3
Internal ID 5D5I73E6.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1653%E.1.5 A329.1@1.7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.I4 I 6
Source sent
Class Pubic
Account DANADM I.DANDOM I
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mains
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.01@l6
Name Mailbox
T)pe Mailbox
Page 12807
Slate m
Share Type NotSharcde
Page 12808
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23 17:22:45 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent 1-Daily Archive3
Job.en-Jobs.en-GiV0penNodeararchivitg0Agent- I-DaaY
=netmai
Generated by Netmai Inc. iciArehive
Archive3Joixen-Jobstn=GWOpenNodetwareliviig0
=mum ill
2019-09-16 15a1209 EDT Exported netmainennaineunal Expected by nrintancimaitnettnad
2020-05-19 14:34:34 EDT Tag ROP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
2020-05-19 152809 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Ragged
2D20.05-1915:17A3 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Respective
Page 12809
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 updt
From
To
Date 2019/08/12 11:01
Subject: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 updt
Attachments: TEXT.htm E stein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 updt.docx,
FYI....The timeline is updated to reflect coming in Saturday evening. Lt. will have
the other info regarding the warden and O1O coming in on Sunday.
Associate Warden
MCC New York
150 Park Row
New Yorl NY 10007
Page 12810
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.165396E.1.5 A29D.1
Message Path xml Alaibox/5D5l46FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .165396E.I.5A29D.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 835B5E40-11C6-0000433D6-FE66A7708950
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Epmeis. Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 updt
Scheduled date 2019-08-121101:16
Creation date 201948-12 11:01:16
Modified date 2019.08-12 110122
Delivered date 2019-08-12 1101:17
Message size 302
Attachments size 16115
Total silt 16428
Attachments 3
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID
5D5146FC.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.200000D.I.F
50AE.1@455D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1100A
65396E.1.5A29D.1@1:7.NYMDOM I.NYMADM I. 100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 552
Date 2019-08-12 070i:17
CA ebta42a514e1818db38eaadf338I05e0
Hash 51EE84DA293FI3C8731182FD09A6607813269EA63 95F48I EAD04502C70439&5B136DD 12661
Attachment Epsteik Jeffrey Edward, Reg No. 73618-054 updt.docx
Name Epsten. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054 updt.doex
Content ID
5D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200000111.F
50AF.1@455D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
65396E.I.5A29D.I@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type Ile
Size 15150
Date 2019-08-12 0659:43
CA I3058aae3e165e7677a816636a7a35a4
Hash 03AC3E6E3B5A5AEFB65A29058B81AECOB128B18A DBE69E5E1473D0839456EC9ADI5A5IF9E1
Attachment
Name
Content ID
sni I 444C.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.200000D.I.F
5080 1:0,455D5146FC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.1001
65396E. 1.5A290.1@1:7.NYMOOM I.NYMADM I. 100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 413
Date 2019-08-12 07:01:17
CA 4eade7414T79f490e728ba2550%7c39
Has h A028B5683C209400OD4CF643FC573E87013344D8 1A8E765955228F65018E17366F950102
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 9D77B2D0-19C I.0000•A989-0200000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read MC
Deleted fake
Opened Mt
Completed fake
Page 12811
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification tshen opened false
Re turn notification %she n deleted fake
Return notification %%hen
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification .hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D5I46FC.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100165396E.I.5 A29D.I@I:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMLICO.0.IM.ISt I
Source received
Class Public
Account DANADM I.DANDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.0.I.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Maibox
System true
Share Type NoiShared
Page 12812
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23172330 EDT Created
en=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Jobsn-lebs.orGWOpenNodetn-archivingx,(AFM_I-Daily
=netmai
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [cn=Archive
Archive3
Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoie.cn-archivingo
-netrna ill
2019-09-16 I5A2A9 EDT Exported mom inetma ancintad Exported by netmainetmainctmail
2020-05-19 143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.NIXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
2020-0549 152839 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 15:17/35 EDT Tag BOP01703.NOCRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 12813
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 updt.docx
Page 12814
Suicide Timeline re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Friday, August 9, 2019
8:00 am inmate Reyes Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 departs for court
(WAB-USMS-SDNY) . Reyes is Epstein's cellmate.
8:30 am inmate Epstein arrives in Attorney Conference. He is
visited by several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 pm inmate Epstein departs attorney conference and returns to
SHU
7:00 pm inmate Epstein provided a social call by IDO. IDO reports
inmate Epstein was in good spirits, nothing unusual.
7:32 am PIO notified of incident by the Warden
***Inmate Reyes is released from court and does not return to the
institution.
Saturday, August 10, 2019
6:33 am body alarm activated in SHU. Staff found inmate Epstein
unresponsive in cell. Staff reported to bedside of inmate and
attempted to wake him. Control announced medical emergency. CPR
initiated
6:35 am medical staff (on duty PA) on site, CPR already in
progress medical staff continues CPR and AED applied on inmate.
Control called for ambulance
6:40 am , AW notified
6:45 am EMS arrives, paramedics continue CPR. Inmate Epstein
remains unresponsive. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three
rounds of Epinephrine, IV access started, IO initiated. No pulse
found, no shock advised, inmate prepared for transport to local
hospital.
7:10 am EMS departs institution enroute to Beekman Hospital.
7:19 am USMS notified of incident.
7:20 am SIS Lt notified.
7:30 am , Warden arrives at institution. , AW
notified.
7:36 am official time of death reported by ER physician.
7:40 am Acting Chief Psychologist notified.
8:00 am and Captain arrive at institution.
8:10 am SIS Lt arrives at institution.
8:10 am CMC and SCSS notified.
8:34 am FBI notified.
9:00 am AUSA notified.
9:00 am arrives at institution.
9:00 am SIS Lt. reports to SHU. Interviews will be conducted with
inmates assigned to tier.
9:15 am CMC arrives at institution.
9:30 am Acting Chief Psychologist arrived to the institution.
9:50 am SCSS arrives at institution.
9:55 am CMC and IDO depart institution enroute to Beekman
Hospital.
10:00 am CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital, fingerprints and
photographs taken of inmate Epstein. Inmate clothing secured and
brought back to institution.
10:00 am Judge Berman notified.
10:15 am CMC return to institution.
10:45 am PIO arrived to the institution.
11:00 am next of kin (brother) notified by Case Management
Coordinator.
11:12 am press release is released to media.
11:15 am press release provided to Judge Berman.
11:15 am CST activated.
12:15 pm body release to Medical Examiner (ME) for autopsy
12:19 pm FBI arrives.
1:35 pm FBI arrives in Special Housing Unit.
1:40 pm OIG notified by the Warden and they will be sending an
Agent to NYM.
2:15 pm CST debrief conducted.
2:45 pm OIG arrived in Special Housing Unit (SHU) .
3:45 pm OIG and FBI depart SHU.
5:05 pm OIG/FBI depart institution
9:10 pm Computer Services Manager (CSM) notified to report to
institution to remove desktop from SHU.
10:46 pm CSM arrives at institution.
11:00 pm desktop removed from SHU and secured in SIS office. OIG
will retrieve desktop tomorrow morning.
Mail Attachment
Page 12817
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
( Preferred Voice )
( Work Voice )
( Voice Cell )
( Preferred Internet )
Version
2.1
PRODID
-//Novell Inc//Groupwise 12.0.3
X-GWTYRe
USER
F rrtaillii m
Name
Family: M.
First:
Middle:
Prefix:
Suffix:
Electronic Mail Address ( Preferred Internet )
UID
835B5E40-1106-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Telephone Number (PrefePreferred Voice )
allpi  Voice )
Tele li  ( Voice Cell )
Title
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
Last Revision
20190812T050046Z
X-GWUDF
11 (BES User ID)981
X•GWUDF
1 0(BES Ref ID)0
Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From Google Alerts
To
Date 2020/01/0218:02
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
bureau of prisons
cry 2, 2020
NEWS
Alarm bells growing louder to fix Florida's decaying prisons I Paula Dockery
Sun Sentinel
It's getting so bad in Florida's prisons that legislators are not only receiving dire warnings from Florida
Department of Corrections Secretary Mark Inch, ...
Talk about corrections: NJ's prisons do not have universal
testing for hepatitis I Editorial
nj.com
According to the New Jersey Department of Corrections, in the first eight
months of 2019, only 218 of our state's 19,000 prison inmates completed
Lake County Sheriffs Office launches online method to share jail population
data
Lake County Journal
The Lake County Sheriffs Office in December launched a new initiative to share demographic
information from the Lake County Jail with the ...
2019 in review: The paper's top stories of the year
The Wellsboro Ca7ette
He had been in prison since 2007. Rigas was originally to be released from prison on June 3, 2020,
according to the Federal Bureau of Prisons's ...
Year in Review: Jury sentences man to death in deadly CresCom bank
robbery
Page 12820
WMBF
CONWAY, S.C. (WMBF) - After more than two years, the case a deadly bank robbery that took the lives
of two employees reached a conclusion.
Flag as irrelevant
Jeffrey Epstein Autopsy Report Shows Broken Neck
Newsmax
Barr, whose agency oversees the Bureau of Prisons, has also demanded an investigation into
Epstein's death and ordered the removal of the prison's ...
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscnbe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Page 12821
Properties
Property Value
SlessagelD 5E0E304C.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316D.1.1 5FF2.I
Message Path xmtTrasKSEOEXHC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1 70316D.1.15FF2.13ani
From Goo& Akns
Display Name Go* Alerts
Email googlealerts-norepbM google.com
Reply. To googkakrts-noreplyg googk.com
Test Google Alerts
To
Subject Google Alert - bureau of prisons
Scheduled date 2020.01-02 180038
Creation date 2026411-02 180638
Modified date 202001-03 072132
Delivered date 2020-01-02 180253
Message she 3685
Attachments sin 61854
Total size 65550
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXI.htm
Content ID
5FITInar.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.200034D.1.3
7623.1@453E0E304C.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1
70316D.I.15FF21@l9.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline fake
"'yrs,. lie
Size 24110
CA 988149364b4c4479302e2196cfe 56380
Hash 10D0C378A9B6682DA2820321EEAE34CFF31E9A3E 79C7853806020E80763EDA3B5CF79F62
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5E0E304C.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.N40004D.1.3
7624.1®455E0E304C.NYMDOMLNYMADM 1.100.1
70316D. I . I5FF2.1 ®19.NYMDOM I.NYMADMI . 100.0.1.0.1@18
Is Inline fake
Type file
Sirs 37744
CA cf86042243e6e71132cea67874e604ebb
Hash 97CAF2D399908D787574F9EC3FC3A512.556CICF1 CB9E984534389A4B6DOCEOED951A2190
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID 835B5E40-11C6-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read fake
Deleted true
Opened false
Completed fake
Security No
Box type Inbox
Return notification sshen opened false
Return notification %she n de lc te d fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined false
Return notification %%hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5E0E304C.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.17031613.1.1 5FF2.1@l9.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.11.0.1@1 8
Source received
Class Public
Account TDOMI
Page 12822
Location ID 1540843020946
Class Name 6W.NIESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
ID 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.01.0.1@l8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12823
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2020.01-14 2339A8 EST ( i emed
cn=Arehive Agent 1-Daly Trashl Job,cn-lobs.orGi/OpenNode4n-archivioggiA84M_
=netmai
Generated by Netgovem [arArchivc
I -Daily TrashI
Johen-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoirten-archivingo
-nctmail]
2020-0602112829 EDT Viewed B0P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I Viewed by
B0P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Ebgged
2020.05-19 153421 EDT Tag Et0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-06.02 1528:34 EDT Tag Et0P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I Responsive
Page 12824
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12825
Sent: Thu, 02 Jan 2020 15:00:58 -0800
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From: Goo gl  Alerts < ooglealerts-noreply@google.00m>
To:
bureau of prisons
NEWS
Alarm bells growing louder to fix Florida's decaying prisons I Paula Dockery
Sun Sentinel
It's getting so bad in Florida's prisons that legislators are not only receiving dire warnings from Florida Department 
of
Corrections Secretary Mark Inch, ...

• MI
Talk about corrections: NJ's prisons do not have universal testing for hepatitis I Editorial
nj.com
According to the New Jersey Department of Corrections, in the first eight months of 2019, only 218 of our state's 19,000
prison inmates completed ...
Lake County Sheriff's Office launches online method to share jail population data
Lake County Journal
The Lake County Sheriff's Office in December launched a new initiative to share demographic information from the Lake
County Jail with the ...
2019 in review: The paper's top stories of the year
The Wellsboro Gazette
He had been in prison since 2007. Rigas was originally to be released from prison on June 3, 2020, according to the
Federal Bureau of Prisons's ...
Year in Review: Jury sentences man to death in deadly CresCom bank robbery
WMBF
CONWAY, S.C. (WMBF) — After more than two years, the case a deadly bank robbery that took the lives of two employees
reached a conclusion.
• •
Jeffrey Epstein Autopsy Report Shows Broken Neck
Newsman
Barr, whose agency oversees the Bureau of Prisons. has also demanded an investigation into Epstein's death and ordered
the removal of the prison's ...
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS teed
Send Feedback
Re: EPSTEIN # 76318-054 CPAP MACHINE.
From
To
Date 2019/07/12 17:58
Subject: Re: EPSTEIN # 76318-054 CPAP
MACHINE.
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Yes.
>» 7/12/2019 3:49 PM > »
I confirmed with his attorneys that he has one at home. Can medical staff have him fill out the paperwork
needed to receive it here? Thanks!
> » 7/12/2019 2:15 PM > »
The above inmate said he had his CPAP machine with him at the time of his arrest. He needs to have his
CPAP machine for his medical condition. Is it in R and D or can we find out who has his CPAP machine?
Thanks.
Page 12828
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D28CA4D.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 8EAC. I
Message Path xmliMataxd5DZSCA4D.NYMD0MENYMADMI,100.1373875.1.78EAC.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 6FECI 5F0-25C8dp00.8293-9E01000038CF
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: EPSTEIN # 76318-054 CPAP MACHINE.
Scheduled date 2019-07-1217:5837
Creation date 2019-07-12 175837
Modified date 2019-07-13 1006:57
Delivered date 2019-07-12 175838
Message sine 450
Attachments slit 789
Total size 1250
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.Ittrn
Content ID
5D28CA4D.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000AA.IA
1884.1®455D28CA4D.NYMDOMLNYMADMLIC0.1
373875.1.78EAC.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.l@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 789
Date 2019-07-12 1358A2
CA de624fad61-456ea513ce4c6d79641c99
Hash ID74106FA66F66200C478EB9DF628573EA4C3807 D73C15D48D180E3A98806BD6D13E9447
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name _
Email
MID 2750CAD0-09CA-0300-A8F4-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient T)pe User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification ohen opened false
Return notification ishe n deleted fake
Return notification ohen
completed false
Return notification ohen declined false
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D2SCA4D.NYMDON1LNYNIADNI 1.100. 1373875.1.7 8EAC.I@II.NYMDOMLNYMADMLIC0.0.1.0.1@1
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GIV.MESSAGE-MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Malawi
Type Ma ibcoc
Page 12829
System
Share Type
UM
NotShared
Page 12830
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-07-19 20-39:16 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Jobrn-lcbs.cn-GWOpenNodern-archivitg.oMgent_1-Daily
setmai
Gerrrated by Netrre8 Inc. [cn=Archive
Archive3
Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoie.cn—archisinga
-mynaill
2019-08-21 140009 EDT Expand netmainetmainetmai Exported by netmainetmaineumil
2019-09-1615:40:43 EDT Exported netmainettnainernai Exported by netmaineurcaneunaa
2020-05.1915:1803 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRI)0M1 Reporuive
2020-05-19 152931 EDT Tag 8OP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMl Et eponsive
2020-05.19143435 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRDOMI flagged
Page 12831
Re: EPSTEIN # 76318-054 CPAP MACHINE.
From
To
Date 2019/07/12 15:49
Subject: Re: EPSTEIN # 76318-054 CPAP MACHINE.
Attachments: TEXT.htm
I confirmed with his attorneys that he has one at home. Can medical staff have him fill out the paperwork
needed to receive it here? Thanks!
›» 7/12/2019 2:15 PM > »
The above inmate said he had his CPAP machine with him at the time of his arrest. He needs to have his
CPAP machine for his medical condition. Is it in R and D or can we find out who has his CPAP machine?
Thanks.
Page 12832
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 51)28ACOLNYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.78E97.1
Message Path xmlislaiboOD2SACOLNYMDOMENYMADMI,100 1373875.1.78E97,1,xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Cc 3 Subject
• 3 3 Re: EPSTEIN # 76318-054 CPAP MACHINE.
Scheduled date 2019-07-12 1549:21
Creation date 2019-07-12 15,4921
Modified date 201947-1607:17116
Delis e red date 201447-12154921
Message sin 405
Attachments silt 717
Total size 1133
Attachments 1
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D28ACOLNYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.20:00A0.1.1
44F9D.I(a453D28AC0I.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.
1373875.1.78E97.1(01I.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1()16
Is Inline false
Type lie
Size 717
Date 2019-07-12 11:49:17
CA 430846646b164e012el7469a782949e8
Hash 576515809709AB] 5F46E5R27BCD95C55ED3DA613 7E5570A68E4C44249DE6E7BD56AA7B48
Recipients 7
Recipient
Dis piss Name
Email
UUID 9791:40:W191F -00004D4F-000000100002
Distribution Type ( -C
Recipient 'Es-pe User
Delivered 2019-07-12154921
DounloadedEts ThirdParty 2019-07.1219,4729
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID CAA545C0-075A-0300-8273-8D3FADID9AB6
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-07.1215,3921
Opened 2019-07-12 154926
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 6FECI5F0-25C8-0000-8293-9€01030038CF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-07.12154921
Opened 2019-07-12 E758:13
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 7781-251, )01396-0000-A837-000000100002
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delis e red 2019-07-1215:4921
Opened 2019-0742 15,4926
Recipient
Display Name
Page 12833
Email
(Win I5A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient 'fspe User
Delivered 2019-07-12154921
Dov%nloackdByThirdrarty 2019-07-14 I13:37:19
Opened 2019-07-I5 0846042
Recipient
13is piss Name
Email
LAID 5ECEI1C0-09134-0000-EIBEI-7C3A87597621
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019.07-12154921
Opened 2019-07-12 1561135
Recipient
Dis pia) Name
Email
UtilD 961A 1530-14C3-000MICBF-C60008002200
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-07-12154921
Opened 201947-1607:1707
Expire 0
Delay delivers until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read truc
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nonml
Box tspe Sent Item
Return notification .hen opened fake
Return notification hen deleted fake
Return notification .hen
completed fake
Return notification nhen declined fake
Return notification %%hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D28ACOLNYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1373875.I.78E97.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@ll 6
Source sent
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
II) 7.NYMIX)M LNYMADM LI00.0.1.0.1®16
Name Maih'
Type Madbos
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12834
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-07.19203927 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Jobrn-lcbs.cn-GWOpenNodern-archivitg.oMgent_I-Daily
setmai
Gerrrated by Netrre8 Inc. [cn=Archive
Archive3
Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoie.cn-archisinga
-myna ill
2019-08-21 14000 EDT Expand netmainetmainetmai Exported by netmainetmaineumil
2019-09-1615:40!43 EDT Exported netmainettnainernai Exported by netmaineurralneunad
2020405.1915:1803 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRI)OM1 Rc‘portsive
202005-19152931 EDT Tag 8OP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMl Et eponsive
2020-05.19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRDOMI flagged
Page 12835
Re: EPSTEIN, Jeffrey, reg. no. 76318-054
From "Miller, Michael"
To
Date 2019/07/30 09:09
Subject: Re: EPSTEIN, Jeffrey, reg. no. 76318-054
Attachments: Mime.822
Thanks for arranging all of that, . Mike
Sent from my iPhone
> On Jul 30, 2019, at 8:40 AM, wrote:
> Good morning Mike,
> I wanted to let you know that there may be a brief delay in getting your client to attomey-
conference this morning as he is getting a shower, haircut, medical assessment, etc.
> Thank you,
Page 12836
Properties
Property Value
Nlessage 1 D 5D400943.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.B73875.1.7 9D3E.1
Message Path xmVMadboxi5D400943.NYMDOMLNYMADMI,100 .1373875.1.79D3E.I.xml
From "Miler, Michael"
Display Name "Mier, Michael'
Email
Reply To
Test "Mier, Michael
To
Subject Re: EPSTEIN, Jeffrey, reg. to 76318-054
Scheduled date 2019-07-30090904
Creation date 201947-30090904
Modified date 2019.7-3009:1225
Delivered date 201947-30090924
Message she 373
Attachments sin 5673
Total size 6057
Attachments I
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D4C0943.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.X000AE.1.3
EEF3.1®451D400943.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
373875.1.79D3E.I@Ig.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type ffie
Size 5673
CA 299535665fclg2If7a2a5a9lebb59a8f
Ilash 4DA 163F52963121B2666CEDBFF5FD85C I BB8C4F2 D2A39A908D58BB509C2127269510DDRA
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CA Du-ll'X A-0000-A8F4-IACF3IEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay denser) until 0
Delegated fake
Arch's ed fake
Read true
Deleted false
Opened Ube
Completed false
Security Neutral
Box type Inbox
Return notification %%hen opened fake
Return notification %%hen deleted fake
Return notification nhen
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification %%hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D400943.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.B73875.1.7 9D3E.1@1:7.NYNIDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1(41 6
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADM I.NYMDOM I
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name CiW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mabox
ID 7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.0.I.0.1@l6
Name Maibox
Type MIII3OX
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12837
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08.092107:45 EDT Created
cn-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Jobtn-lcbs.cn-GWOpenNodetn-arckim'"--1Agcnt_1-Daily
I Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoietn—archivingo tetmai
Generated by Netire0 Inc. [cn=Archive
Archivc3
-ne vita ill
2019-08.21140050 EDT Expand namainetmaineumi Exported by netmainetmaincumil
2019-09-1615:40!43 EDT Exported netmainettnainetmai Boomed by netmaineurrailneunad
2020435.1915:1706 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRI)OMI Responsive
2020-05.1915:1803 EDT Tag B0P01703.M3CRADM i.roxR DOM Responsive
202043519 152859 EDT Tag B0P01703.14XRADMI.NIXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 152931 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.A1 XRI/OM1 Responsive
202043549 14:3435 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12838
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12839
From:
To: >
Subject: e: P IN, Jeffrey, reg. no. 76318-054
Sent: Tue, 30 Jul 2019 13:09:04 +0000
Thanks for arranging all of that, . Mike
Sent from my iPhone
> On Jul 30, 2019, at 8:40 AM, wrote:
> Good morning Mike,
> • I wanted to let you know that there may be a brief delay in getting your client to attorney-conference this
morning as he is getting a shower, haircut, medical assessment, etc.
> you,
Re: EPSTEIN, Jeffrey, reg. no. 76318-054
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
2019/07/30 08:01
Re: EPS1'EIN, Jeffrey, reg. no. 76318-054
TEXT.htm,
Page 12841
Good Morning,
He has active refillable Rx-Vascepa which was dispensed on 7/17 for a 30 day supply..? We can place them
on PL starting tomorrow. Vascepa is on order.
No rx for back pain on file.
Thank You,
Chae
PharmD, MS, BCACP
CAPT, U.S. Public Health Service
Chief Pharmacist
MCC New York
150 Park Row,
New York, NY 10007
Phone:
Fax:
"This message is intended for official use and may contain SENSITIVE information. If this message contains
SENSITIVE information, it should be properly delivered, labeled, stored, and disposed of according to
policy?'
Commissioned Corps of the United States Public Health Service -
"Protecting, promoting, and advancing the health and safety of the
Nation"
>>  >
Good morning all,
7/30/2019 7A8 AM >>>
The above inmate's attorneys have recently alleged he is not receiving cholesterol or back pain medication.
Please see him for these and other complaints.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Page 12842
Prone riles
Property Value
Message ID 5D3FEN44.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 9D1A.1
Message Path xmliMaibox/5D314:944.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.79D1A.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 94B26681.1742.0000-BBEl-8BC2136F992F
Reply To
Text
I 1 I
I
To
Cc
Subject Re: EPSTEIN, Jeffrey. reg. no. 76318-054
Scheduled date 2019-07-30080108
Creation date 211l9-07-30080108
Modified date 201947-3008:19.39
Delis end date 201947-30080109
Message size 1168
Attachments sin 2444
Total size 3623
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D3FF914.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.20000A8.1.4
A473.1 ®453D3FF944.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875. I.79D IA.I@I ftNYMDOM I.NYMADM I.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type lie
Size 2132
Date 2019-07-30040109
CA 46c2bc675f446e8f164081534d6653c9
Hash A 12958783110CFC4ED604C78.504EA555E5B7841B6 21D729B23978194334827D35FAC5B07F
Attachment
Name
Content ID
5D3FF944.NYMDOM1.NYMADM1.200.20003A8. 1.4
A474.1®453D3FF944.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1. 100.1
373875.1.79DIA.I@II.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 312
Date 20I9-07-30040108
CA 41a1179286311061b832cfd4460td933
Hash 3DD9A34ADDCB7BBI5EC9BFEDA007D40FFCI9ABIA 51482023AE41D04245C7D27D292F10F4
Recipients
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution "fspe TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Entail
UUID 835B5E40-11C6-0000-B3D6-FE66AT708950
Distribution Tpe CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID CAA545C0.075A-0000-B273-8D3FADID9A86
Distribution Tye TO
_ Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 6FECI5F0•25C8-0000.8293.9E01000038CF
Distribution Type TO
Page 12843
Recipient Type User
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
LIVID I SAME I 0-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A6064ISCAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
LIVID SECEI1C0-0004-000BBBEI-7C3A8759762I
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type lam(
Return notification %%hen opened fake
Return notification 'then deleted fake
Return notification .hen
completed fake
Return notification t•Itc n declined false
Return notification %%hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D3FE944.NYMDOMI.NYMADM IA00.1373875.1.7 9DIA. I@LINYMDOMLNYMADMI.I 00.0 I .0. lig I 6
Source received
Class Pubhc
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 154(842683886
Class Name CiW MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Hatbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.10.1@l6
Name Main
Type Maims
System mac
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 12844
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08.09210801 EDT Created
cn-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Jobtn-lobs.cn-GWOpenNodetn-arck"m'--1Agcnt_1-Daily
I Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNozle.cn—archivingst setmai
Generated by Netrrea Inc. [cn=Archive
Archivc3
-netrna ill
2019-08.21140050 EDT Expand netmainetmainetmai Exported by netmainetmaineumil
2019-09-1615:40!94 EDT Exported netmainettnainetrnai Exported by netmainetnrailneunad
2020.0549 15:17136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRI)OMI Responsive
2020-05.1915:1803 EDT Tag B0P01703.M3CRADM i.roxR DOM Responsive
2020435.19 152859 EDT Tag B0P0170334XRADM I .51NR DOM1 Responsive
2020-05-19 152931 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXR I HMI Responsive
202043549 143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12845
Mail Attachment
Page 12846
Chief Pharmacist
( Preferred Voice )
( Work Voice )
( Preferred Internet )
Version
2.1
PRODID
-//Novell Inci/Groupwise 12.0.3
X-GWTYPE
USER
Forma
Name
Family:
First:
Middle:
Prefix:
Suffix:
El r ni M it A r ( Preferred Internet )
UID
94B26681-1742-0000-BBE1-8BC2136F992F
T tigsI  r ( Preferred Voice )
Tl apegI r ( Work Voice )
Title
Chief Pharmacist
Last Revision
201710251050858Z
EPSTEIN # 76318-054. EXTENSION CORD MEMO.
From
To
Date 2019/07/30 14:16
Subject: EPSTEIN # 76318-054. EXTENSION CORD MEMO.
Attachments: TEXT.htm, 2019_07_30_14_13 49.pdf
Please see attached.
Thanks.
Page 12848
Properties
Property' Value
Nlessagell) 5D405120.NYMDOM I.NYMADM1. 100.1373875.1.7 9DE7.1
Message Path xmliMabox/50405120.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.79DE7.1.aml
From
Midst) Name
Email
Ut ID 6FECI5E0-25C8-0000-8293-9E01000038CF
Reply' To
Test
To
Cc
Subject EPSTEIN f$ 76318-054. EXTENSION CORD MEMO.
Scheduled date 2019-07.3014:1600
Creation date 2019-07.3014:1600
Modi0ed date 2019-07.3014:1923
Delis ered date 2019-07.3014:1601
Message sine 31
Attachments sin 119320
Total slit 119362
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name Malin
Content ID
5D405120.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.20000AA.1.4
XOD.1@j455D405120.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 I
373875.1.79DE7.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1(416
Is Inline false
Type fk
Size 286
Date 2019-07-3010:1602
CA le2eace7784813c5c1c266020e1387
Hash A53714AD3FDF6C2397803DO8F858BF410DB60F84 3928FE509474E193CCE6DEFD43355298
Attachment 2019_07_30 14_13_49.pdf
Name 2019 07 30 14 13 49.pdf
Content ID
5D405120.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.20120:00AA.1.4
200E.R4)455D405120.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.79DE7.1@1:7.NYMMOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type fie
Silk 119034
Date 2019-07-3010:1353
CA 733f7b0837dfailld6380.c514a194a2a
Hash 78C2B48A83B82C8E01:7B67C459E83B58E8720006 9F3E8B3E30D972K6OF.6F32AFBC426IID
Recipients 21
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Will) 2750CADO-09CA-0000.A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Sante
Email
UUID 8AAA2680A4V-OOOOB36E-EH1C6621E5FD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Tjpe S InGroupMetuber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
WAD 523A6DA0-050B-0000.AB45-081FD20DDDD7
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Typr stem&aoupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
nip DEF72A30-13E7-0000-B09B-BCAADF980A91
Page 12849
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroupMernber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID I FACBC4041394-000OB06F-2AE2BI2AAA87
Distribution 'Uwe TO
Recipient Type SystemOrcopMeniber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4271E520-0DA7-000043100-D84E73054BF5
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Systc obey
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID DC965EL0-0435-0000-9442-60DESSF6B922
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroopMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Ut:ID ( -0670904E73-0000aBEI-DODC22E57,32
Distribution Type C(
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DDA9D30-10060000.9870.OCD8BB22F09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UV ID 867CDEFO-ODA7-0:00-97CF-7AB098665147
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroopMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 6I2ID870-0F413-00004342F-920I000038CF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type inGrouptvIcinber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 02NI A. 1-1-102-0000-B09B-I3CAADI:980A9I
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Tvpe
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID CAA545C0-075A-0000-B273-8D3FADID9AB6
Distribution Type CC
Rech e nt Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4D7666E0- I 7D8-0000-977I-000000I0C002
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S teinGroup
Recipient
Dis lay Name
Email
UUID B5C7D7406DAA-0072-A4A9-000000000030
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGrouplitiember
Page 12850
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 86310140.180Dd1011DB46D•000000000000
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemnroupMember
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
UUID 15A65EI0-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
UUID 9F550ED043IDA-0000a7F5-92775C390IBF
Distribution Type TO
Re cipie nt IV pc SysteinCiroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 51.CEIIC0-091)4.0000-BBEI-7CIA875976.21
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type 1 wr
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2B69A5D0- I91D-0000-BADI.000000100002
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email —
UUID 99A280B0-0772-0000.BBEl-323E21049E63
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification 'hen opened fake
Return notification' hen deleted fake
Return notification 'hen
completed fake
Return notification vibe n declined fake
Return not i neat ion' hen
accepted fake
Archive Ve rs ion 5.3
Internal ID 5D405120.NYMDOM I .NYMADM I. I03.1373875.1.7 9DE7.I ®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI. 100.0.1.0.1Q1 6
Source received
Class Pubic
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOM1
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folden I
Folder Mabox
ID 7.NYMDOM I.NYMADM I. 100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Madhox
System true
Share Tvpe NotShared
Page 12851
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-09 21:0607 EDT Created
cn-Archive Agent_1-Daily Archive3
Job.arlobs.en-GWOpenNodeararehiviignAgeni- I-DaaY
=neimai
Generated by Netmai Inc. [eiArchive
Archive3Jolvorelobstn.GWOpenNodetwareliviign
=nomad]
2019-08-21 14:001 EDT Exported nennaineimail.neimai Exparted by netnna netrin 8 monad
2019-09-16 15:40:44 EDT Exported nennainennalna Expected by netma a nctmamai IL netmail
2020-05-19 15:1803 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I .MXRDOM I Responsive
2020-05.19152931 EDT Tag BOPOI703.MXRADM I .1sIXRDON11 Responsive
2020-05-19 143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADNI I.MXRDON11 Fbgged
Page 12852
Mail Attachment
2019 07 30 14 13 49.pdf
Page 12853
UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT
MEMORANDUM
Metropolitan Correctional Center, New York, New York
From: M.D., Acting Clinical Director
/ 41$ 5°-4 1 la
DATE: July 30, 2019
TO: Operation and SHU Lieutenants.
Regarding: Extension Cord for Epstein, Jeffrey N 76318-054
The above inmate needs to have access to an electrical extension cord for him to use during
the evening to plug in his CPAP machine.
Epstein #76318-054 Medical/Mental Health Records
From
To
Date 2019/08/23 09:15
Subject: Epstein #76318-054 Medical/Mental Health Records
Attachments: TEXT.Inin, Certification of Identify Fonn.pdf
Good morning Michael,
I spoke with folks here and confirmed we can proceed under our usual procedure for releasing medical/psych
records to defense counsel. Accordingly, please send me a cover letter confirming you're defense counsel of
record, the attached certification of identity, and a Rule 17 subpoena (no need to be so-ordered; a clerk's
subpoena is fine). Normally we would require a HIPAA release as well, but privacy rights don't survive death
in this context. Once I receive the certification, letter, and subpoena„ I will have the USAO's Civil Division
authorize the records release as wall counsel pursuant to United States ex rel. Touhy v. Regan, 340 U.S. 462

(1951) and the associated regulations.
Please let me know if you have any questions/concerns.
Thar.iou,
Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
F.
Page 12855
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D5FAEBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 B294.1
Message Path imdcMaiocoV5D5FAEBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.78294.13ml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 15A65E100C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Epstel M76318-054 MedicaltMental Health Records
Scheduled date 2019-08-23 09:15:40
Creation date 201948-23 09:15140
Modified date 2019-08-23 12:061)9
Delis end date 2019-08-23 09:15)4I
Message size 955
Attachments sin 31289
Total size 32255
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TF—XT.him
Content II)
5D5FAEBC.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.20000DA.1.8
BA99.1€045:5D5FAEBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.7B294.1@k7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1(416
Is Inline fake
Type fie
Size 1520
Date 2019-08-23 05:1542
CA a5e6cd49ec4c4299665746d4:1830bebb
Hash EB21CA603E7FFA5C702EAD2BA2482A366E3EA6EE 7460565531B2D53031D62A9B4E2B2427
Attachment Certification of Identify Fonupdf
Name Cenificatico of Identify Form.pdf
Content ID
5D5FAEBC.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000DA.1.8
BA9A.1®455D5FAEBC.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.78294.1(§1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.10D.0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 29769
Date 2017-08-24 06:5760
CA dde0ce5744eecd6c3cd61e 1652441010
Hash 88F98643E255D31F47625376577B0780422C4122 E87DA270A31D6DEIDI7E84F16032B672
Recipients
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CAD0-09CA-000OA8F4-lACF31EA7575
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delis e ry until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read n-uc
Deleted fake
Opened nue
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Intox
Return notification %%hen opened fake
Return notification .. hen deleted fake
Page 12856
Return notification 'hen
completed take
Return notification 'hen declined false
Return notification 'hen
accepted false
Archise Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D5FAE.BC.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 D244.1@1!7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.IO0.0.1.0.I@l
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Malan
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name MabOX
Type Malyox
System trUC
Share Type NotShared
Page 12857
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-30 203836 EDT Created
co=Archive Agent_ I-Daly Archive3
JolAcn-lcbs.cn-GWOpenNode.en-archivingeoM
mietmai
Generated by Netrma Inc. [cn=Archive
_1-Daily Archive3gcm
Job.en-Jobs.an-GWOpenNoie.cn-archivinga
-netmaa]
2020-05-1915:1803 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXR DOM] Responsive
2020-05-19 152931 EDT Tag BOP01703.frOCRADMI.N1 XRIX)Ni 1 Responsive
202005.19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.1YDCRADMI.A1ARIXRA 1 Fbggcd
Page 12858
Mail Attachment
Certification of Identify Form.pdf
Page 12859
U.S Department of Justice Certification of Identity
FORM APPROVED O318 NO. 1103-0016
EXPIRES 10/31113
Privacy Act Statement. In accordance with 28 CFR Section 16.41(d) personal data sufficient to identify the individuals 
submitting requests by
mail under the Privacy Act of 1974. 5 U.S.C. Section 552a. is required. The purpose of this solicitation is to ensure 
that the records of individuals
who are the subject of U.S. Department of Justice systems of records are not wrongfully disclosed by the Department. 
Requests will not be
processed if this information is not furnished. False information on this form may subject the requester to criminal 
penalties under 18 U.S.C.

Section 1001 and/or 5 U.S.C. Section 552a(iX3).
Public reporting burden for this collection of information is estimated to average 0.50 hours per response, including 
the time for reviewing
instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing 
the collection of
information. Suggestions for reducing this burden may be submitted to the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, 
Office of Management
and Budget, Public Use Reports Project (1103-0016), Washington, DC 20503.
Full Name of Requester I
Citizenship Status 2 Social Security Number 3
Current Address
Date of Birth  Place of Birth
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the foregoing is true and 
correct, and that I am the person
named above, and I understand that any falsification of this statement is punishable under the provisions of 18 U.S.C. 
Section 1001 by a fine of
not more than 510.000 or by imprisonment of not more than five years or both, and that requesting or obtaining any 
record(s) under false
pretenses is punishable under the provisions of 5 U.S.C. 552a(i)(3) by a fine of not more than $5,000.
Signature 4 Date
OPTIONAL: Authorization to Release Information to Another Person
This form is also to be completed by a requester who is authorizing information relating to himself or herself to be 
released to another person.
Further. pursuant to 5 U.S.C. Section 552a(b). I authorize the U.S. Department of Justice to release any and all 
information relating to me to:
Print or Type Name
Name of individual who is the subject of the record(s) sought.
Individual submitting a request under the Privacy Act of 1974 must be either "a citizen of the United States or an alien
lawfully
admitted for permanent residence." pursuant to 5 U.S.C. Section 552a(aX2). Requests will be processed as Freedom of 
Information Act
requests pursuant to 5 U.S.C. Section 552. rather than Privacy Act requests. for individuals who are not United States 
citizens or aliens
lawfully admitted for permanent residence.
Providing your social security number is voluntary. You are asked to provide your social security number only to 
facilitate the
identification of records relating to you. Without your social security number, the Department may be unable to locate 
any or all records
pertaining to you. 4
Signature of individual who is the subject of the record sought.
FORM DO1-361
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 76318-054X
From
To
Date 2019/08/12 14:46
Subject: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 76318-054X
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 76318-054X.docx
Updated time line.
Page 12861
Properties
Property' Value
NlessagelD 3D517BD6.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 A87E.I
Message Path xmliMakoW5D517BD&NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7A87E.Imid
From
Calvin) Name
Email
IA ID 9D77B2D049C1-0000-A98943200000058D0
Reply' To
Tem
To
Subject Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Reg No. 76318-054X
Scheduled date 2019-08-12 14:46:46
Creation date 2019-08.1214146:46
Modified date 2019.08.12 1481656
Dells e red date 2019-08-12 1446:47
Message site 23
Attachments size 18403
Total size 18437
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.Iim
Name TEXT.Itm
Content ID
5D517EIDCNYMDOMENYMADMI.200.20000381.9
EB73.1®455D317BD6.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373873.1.7A87E.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type fie
Silt 167
Date 2019-08-12 10:46:43
CA lba2bbb903fddaca7125bff7d2lbeedf
Ilan h 49BB39391016C6E836F50AFOACB9388.301BEDDC6 527AC89C87AD9FE92FCOA22D56D7B92B
Attachment Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Reg, No. 76318-054Xdoex
Name Epsteit. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 76318-054Xdocx
Content ID
3D517BD6.NYMDOMENYMADMI.200.2000038.1.9
EB74.1@)455D517BD6.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
373875.1.7A87E.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.103 .0.1.0.1Q116
Is Inline faire
Type ft
Size 18236
Date 2019-08-12 1OA452
CA 1k1400701a5b260e140d10e6ed9a0b1
Hash 837077BD37699050348E172E2BEE249DAB90BC52 DIMOA5CE1455E0360A2703274439D773
Recipients 8
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
MID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S . tem(' tuber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
lit ID 835B5EAO-I1C6-0000-B3D6FF-66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S mGroupMetuber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
U LID 43FDB000-0O0C-0OOO-SB6E-16003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S other
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DDA9D30-I0060000-987C-0CD8BB22F09A
Distribution Tye TO
Recipient Type S to Member
Recipient
Page 12862
Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-064F-0000-AB39-F80F2A59A443
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type SysterneroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 9D77B2D0.19040000-A9894200000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGrouptekmber
Recipient
Display Name
Email _
UUID 4237CDC0-14074000-AF20-8402120084D2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroup
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 661:64C10-1320-0000-8ECI-2F2162868DCC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupielember
Expire 0
Delay delivers until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened Me
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification "hen deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted fake
Archive Ve rs ion 5.3
Internal II) 5D517BD6.NYMDOM LNYMADM 1.100.1373875.1.7 A87E.11 ®1:7.NYMDOM LNYMADM 1.100.0.1.0.1@ I
Source received
Class Pubic
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maibox
ID 7.NYMDOM I. NYMADM I. I 00.01.01@ 16
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share Type NoiShared
Page 12863
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23 203132 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent 1-Daily Archive3
Jobon-Jobs.en-GiV0penNode,ctrarehividl geni- I-DadY
=ncimai
Generated by Netmai Inc. iciArchive
Archive3Joisetelobstn=GWOpenNodetwarelivitgeo
-neuna ill
201009-16 154201 EDT Exported netmainennaineunal Expected by ottani netma I netmai
20_2005.1915:1706 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 152839 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Resportsive
2020-05.19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI nagged
Page 12864
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 76318-054X.docx
Page 12865
Suicide Timeline:
RE: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 76318-054
Friday, August 9, 2019
8:00 am: inmate Reyes Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 departs for
court (WAB-USMS-SDNY) . Reyes is Epstein's cellmate.
8:30 am: inmate Epstein arrives in Attorney Conference. He is
visited by several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 pm: inmate Epstein departs attorney conference and returns
to SHU.
7:00 pm: inmate Epstein provided a social call by IDO. IDO
reports inmate Epstein was in good spirits, nothing unusual.
Saturday, August 10, 2019
6:33 am: Body alarm activated in SHU. Staff found inmate Epstein
unresponsive in cell. Staff reported to bedside of inmate and
attempted to wake him. Control announced medical emergency. CPR
initiated
6:35 am: Medical staff (on duty PA) on site, CPR already in
progress medical staff continues CPR and AED applied on inmate.
Control called for ambulance
6:40 am: , AW notified
6:45 am: EMS arrives, paramedics continue CPR. Inmate Epstein
remains unresponsive. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three
rounds of Epinephrine, IV access started, IO initiated. No pulse
found, no shock advised, inmate prepared for transport to local
hospital.
7:10 am: EMS departs institution enroute to Beekman Hospital.
7:19 am: USMS notified of incident.
7:20 am: SIS Lt notified.
7:30 am:
notified.
, Warden arrives at institution. , AW
7:32 am: PIO notified of incident by the Warden.
7:36 am: Official time of death reported by ER physician.
7:40 am: Acting Chief Psychologist notified.
8:00 am:
institution.
8:10 am: SIS Lt arrives at institution.
8:10 am: CMC and SCSS notified.
8:34 am: FBI notified.
9:00 am: AUSA notified.
9:00 am: arrives at institution.
, AW and , Captain arrives at
Cont. Saturday, August 10, 2019
9:00 am: SIS Lt. Reports to SHU. Interviews will be conducted
with inmates assigned to tier.
9:15 am: CMC arrives at institution.
9:30 am: Acting Chief Psychologist arrived to the institution.
9:50 am: SCSS arrives at institution.
9:55 am: CMC and IDO depart institution En route to Beekman
Hospital.
10:00 am: CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital, fingerprints
and photographs taken of inmate Epstein. Inmate clothing secured
and brought back to institution.
10:00 am: Judge Berman notified.
10:15 am: CMC returns to institution.
10:45 am: PIO arrived to the institution.
11:00 am: Next of kin (brother) notified by Case Management
Coordinator.
11:12 am: Press Release released to media.
11:15 am: Press Release provided to Judge Berman.
11:15 am: Crisis Support Team activated.
12:15 pm: Body released to Medical Examiner (ME) for autopsy
12:19 pm: FBI arrives.
1:35 pm: FBI arrives in Special Housing Unit.
1:40 pm: OIG notified by the Warden and they will be sending an
Agent to NYM.
2:15 pm: Crisis Support Team debrief conducted.
2:45 pm: OIG arrived in Special Housing Unit (SHU)
3:45 pm: OIG and FBI departed from SHU.
5:05 pm: OIG/FBI departed MCC New York.
5:30 pm: CST departed MCC New York.
10:15 pm: Computer Services Manager arrives at institution to
remove hard drives (Computers) from SHU. And replaced with new
ones.
Sunday, August 11, 2019
12:15 am: Computer Services Manager departs the institution.
10:40 am: OIG Agent
at institution.
and Agent arrives
11:15 am: OIG Agent , departs institution with two
computers FPS 021407270 and FPS 0214207268.
2:00 pm: OIG Agent departs the institution.
Monday, August 12, 2019
Re: Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
From
• Greco
Date 2019/08/12 14:33
Subject: Re: Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Attachments: TEXT.htm, 2019  08 12 14 31  06.pdf
Good afternoon,
Michael
Attached please find Warden response to Your Honor's inquiry. Please let us know if you need
further information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
f.
> > > < > 8/12/201912:47 PM >>>
Please see attached letter from Judge Richard M. Berman.
(See attached file: Aug 12 letter.pdf)
Page 12870
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D5178A6.NYAIDONI I NYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 A874.1
Message Path xmVMailborJ5D5178A6.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .1373875.1 7A874.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
U CID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Cc I
Subject Re: Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Scheduled date 2019-08-12 14:33:10
Creation date 2019-08-12 1433:10
Modified date 2019-08-14 17:29:19
Delis e red date 2019-08-12 1433:10
Message site 492
Attachments sim 217047
Total site 217550
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.hon
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D5178A(..NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.20000A01.1
475DB.16055D5178A6.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.
1373875.1.7A874.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Is 1nhne false
Type tic
Size 1024
Date 2019-08-12 103347
C t 892cf1661:688f5c6e2dObe2ba578:2722
I E2031D24EFE933AB70F270F7F73A ICD07649CCEE 281016211EMEC55D9E9248C043BD7C
Attachment 2019 08_12_14_31_06.pdf
Name 2019 08_12_14_31_06.pdf
Content ID
5D5178A6.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000A0.1.1
475DC.1®45:5135178A&NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.
1373875.1.7A874.1@la.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 216023
Date 2019-08-12 1031:10
CA 059d152765a0k7c&0650a69745a 110
Dash 68576F4F10/ t.655E888BEE4B7CDOAEC5E7537D 8339653A782DIDEE74C009ABI3CF8C0C
Recipients
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID C005F303-46AA-OOOO-B60A-44273BD4879F
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-0812143332
Transferred 201908121433:13
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Distribution 'I spy TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019.0812143&17
Trans k rred 2019-08-121433:13
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08.12143&17
Transferred 2019-08-12 1433:13
Recipient Edward_FriedlandCamysd.uscourts.goy
Page 12871
Display Name Edward FriedlandEznysd.uscourts.gov
Email Edward_FriedlanCtnysduscotrts.gov
Distribution Type CC
Recipient 'I've Uscr
Delivered 2019-08.12143&17
Transferred 2019-08-12 1433:13
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
QUID 6ICE9350-0B4F-0000-AB39-FSOF2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'I've User
Delivered 2019-08-12 1433:10
DounloadedByThirdParty 2019-08.12 143764
Opened 2019-08-12 14,12-16
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CUD 6C8B5001. D-0000-860A-644679AAFI)B4
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08-12143330
Transferred 2019-08-12 1433:13
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08.1214:4323
Transferred 2019-08-12 1433:13
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened (TUC
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification .hen opened false
Return notification ..hen deleted false
Return notification .hen
completed false
Return notification alien declined fake
Return notification alien
accepted fake
Archive Version 63
Internal ID 5D5178A6.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.B73875.1.7A874.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l 6
Source sent
Class Public
Account r YMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1510842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mai ox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Maitox
Type M11130X
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12872
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23 203139 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_l-Daly Archive3 Jobrn-lcbs.crGWOpenNodern-archisingx,(Atient_
=netmaa
Gerrrated by Netrma Inc. [cn=Archive
1-Daily Archisr3
Jobrn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNode.cn-archivinga
-nctrnaa]
2019-09-16 'MIDI EDT Exported mum inetma a nomad Exponed by netmainetmainctmail
2020-05-1915:17A6 EDT Tag QOP0 I 703.MXRADM I.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-0549 152839 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 1424:34 EDT Tag BOP01703.NOCRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 12873
Mail Attachment
2019 08 12 14 31 06.pdf
Page 12874
August 12, 2019
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Office of the Warden
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York. New York 10007
(6461836-6300. (646) 836-7751 (Fax)
SENT VIA EMAIL
The Honorable Richard M. Berman, District Judge
Daniel Patrick Moynihan United
States Courthouse
500 Pearl Street
New York, New York 10007-1312
Re: EPSTEIN. Jeffrey Federal Register No. 76318-054
United States v. Jeffrey Epstein, 19-cr-00490-RMB
Dear Judge Berman:
I am writing in regards to your August 12, 2019 inquiry whether the investigations referenced in my
August 10. 2019 letter will include the incident at MCC involving Mr. Epstein on or about July 23,
2019.
I can confirm that, although an internal investigation was completed regarding the July 23, 2019
incident, the current investigations by the FBI and OIG will include this incident as well.
Accordingly, I cannot divulge any information about the prior investigation at this time.
Thank you for your time and attention to this matter. If you have any questions or concerns, please
feel free to call me at
Sincerely,
Warden
MCC New York
cc: Chief Judge Colleen McMahon
Edward Friedland, District Executive
U.S. Marshal
Assistant U.S. Attorneys
Martin Weinberg, Counsel for Mr. Epstein
Fwd: MEDIA REQUEST: Epstein & conditions at MCC
From
To
Date 2019/08/13 12:21
Subject: Fwd: MEDIA REQUEST: Epstein & conditions at
MCC
Attachments: TEXT.htm
This is concerning as this media venue is the one that has been relentless with BRO and MCC in the past.
•
»> Aviva Stahl <aviva.stahl@gmail.com> 8/13/2019 12:05 PM »>
Hi there,
I'm writing a piece for the site Gothamist about conditions at MCC. See allegations below, compiled from
defense attorneys, current prisoners and their loved ones. Please send comment ASAP if you would like to
respond.
Regards
Aviva Stahl
— that some cells in the facility are covered in mold
— that some cells in the facility have separate spouts for hot and cold water, making it impossible for
prisoners to take showers at a reasonable temperature
— that prisoners at MCC are treated with disdain. They "be lucky if they were treated like dirt under
somebody else's shoe, but they're not even treated that well," said one lamer
— that overcrowding, understaffing and underresourcing are grave problems at the facility ("whether its
people who are suicidal, people who need medical care, people who need psychiatric care, people who need
spiritual guidance or religious accommodation, people who need programming, so they don't just get
warehoused there - all of that is lacking.")
— that in the spring of 2019, toilets on the women's floor at MCC flooded, and the women were forced to
clean up the feces themselves
Follow me on Twitter @stahlidarity.
Check out my writing portfolio at stahlidarity corn, and/or get regular updates from me about my work by
signing up here.
Page 12876
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D52AB3ENYMDOMENYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 A971.1
Message Path ientrMaixoti5D52AB3ENYMDOM1.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.7A971.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
QUID FD34DF60-1406.0000-A820-84D2I200/34D2
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: MEDIA REQUEST: Epstek & conditions at MCC
Scheduled date 2019-08-13 1221:18
Creation date 2019-08-13 1221:18
Modified date 2019-08-13 122139
Delis e red date 2019-08-13 1221:19
Message size 1579
Attachments silt 2360
Total size 3950
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.Inm
Content II)
5D52AB3ENYMOOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000F5.I.5
23D7.4453D52AB3ENYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
373875.1.7A971.1@lg.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.l@l6
Is Inline false
Type lie
Size 2360
Date 2019-08.13 0821:14
CA ad37f03efaacc997fdl23alif0599377e
Hash OAEFC69A04ED2I7CEBIEC42DF2C75D028A03B199 9C5C2B614774753B8BCF5DD7EEFIE048
Recipients 3
Recipient
Display Name
—
Email
UUID 275K A On trx V0000-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type CC
Recipient 'I spy User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CUM 6 I Cl 9350-0B-W-0003-AB39-F80F2A59A443
Distribution I spy CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
nip 992D59C0-I00E-0000-BCOSOODOF6A057CD
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archised fake
Read tnt
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type lnbox
Return notification "hen opened fake
Return notification "hen deleted fake
Return notification "hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined false
Page 12877
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Imernal ID 5D52AD3E.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.1373875.I.7A97I.I@I:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.0.10.I®i
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location II) 1540842683886
Class Name G%V.MESSAGE MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.I.0.1@l6
Name Matrix
Type Madbox
System Mt
Share Tgie NotShared
Page 12878
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-2320A926 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-lcbs.orGWOpenNodern-archiving.oAgent-
ietmai
Gerrrated by Netrre8 Inc. [cn=Archive
I -DallY Archive3Johen-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNocktn-arclivingr
-netmaill
2019-09-16 15A2-101 EDT Exported walla inctma anemia a E.:Toned by netmaineunail nomad
2020-05-19153006 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 12879
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
From
To
Date 2019/08/10 14:21
Subject: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
ma
Please see the attached updated time line. If you should have any questions please feel free to
contact me.
Thank you
Page 12880
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D4ED2EENYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 A742.1
Message Path xmliMaRtx/5D4ED2EENYWIDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.7A742.1.imil
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-0B4F-0000-AB39-F80F2A59A443
Reply To
Text
To
Ce
Subject Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Rcg No. 73618.054_1
Scheduled date 2019-08-10 14:21:34
Creation date 2019-08-10142134
Modified date 201448-10142303
Delis cried date 2019-08-10 142135
Message site 135
Attachments site 15254
Total site 15400
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D4ED2EE.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI-2C0.2000062.1.6
99EA.1®455D4ED2EE.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100-I
373875.1.7A742.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type file
She 308
Date 2019-08-10 1021:40
('A bd20d87181)85ebd2ab3f525711)977tal
I CF277BCCEENFI7A8EE2/35B5E8FA56DID5E3C67E3 FOFD785169F9713EA2A2B576AE6FA06E
Attachment Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg No. 73618-054_1.doex
Name Epsteii, Jeffrey Edward, Reg No. 73618-054_1.docx
Content ID
5D4ED2EE.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.240.2000062.1.6
99E-5.1®455DOED2ELNYMDOMI.NYMADMI.103.1
373875.1.7A742.1(4)1:7-NYMEIONII.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 14476
Date 2019-08-10 102109
CA cha26d8209e6415511,270c42bddb39ad
Hash CaDC8DB5095344E96FA899AB99872BAB77610BB A275A4E2F6DCA562CFIFFICCD3B4139
Recipients 9
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO09CA-0000-A8F4•IACF3IEA7575
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type S to enter
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 83565EAO-IIC60003-B3D6.FE66A7708950
Distribution Type CC
Recipient ['pc SystemCmoupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID 43FDB000.0000.0000.8B6E-IBW3AO02D00
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type SystcmCrouptsiember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DDA9D30-l0060000-987O-OCD8BB22F09A
Distribution Type CC
Page 12881
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID 61CF9350-0B4F-0000-AB39-F130F2A59A443
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CU D 9D77B2D0- I9C I 4300-A989-0200000058M
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type SystanCroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CUM 4237CDCO-I407-0000-A820-84D2I20084D2
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type SystemGroup
Recipient
Display Name
Email
lillID 2F982BSO.I4C3-0000.9847•BF62C05FI E%
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient _
Display Name
Email
UUID 66E64C10-1320-0000-8ECI-2F21628613DCC
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read Mt
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nomtil
Box type InIxes
Return notification when opened false
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification when
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
I Me mat ID 5D4ED2EE.NYMDOM LNYMADM IA00.1373875.13 A742.1®I:7.NYMDOM LNYMADM I. ICO.O.I.01@ I
Source received
Class
Account
fis
YMADM I.NYMDOM I
Location II) 1540442683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Ma0box
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMIA00.0.I.O.ligl6
Name Mai=
Type Maalox
System MC
Share Type NotShared
Page 12882
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23203432 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Job.cn-lebs.orGWOpenNodetn-archivingx,(Agent_
=netmai
Gerrrated by Netrm8 Inc. [cn=Archive
1-Daily Archi.c3
Johen-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoie.cn-archivinga
mietrnail]
2019-09-16 15,42/02 EDT Exported netina inetma allowed Exponed by netmainetmainetmail
2020-05-1915:17A6 EDT Tag BOP01703.NIXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-0549 I52&39 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 14:3434 EDT Tag BOP01703.NOCRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbggcd
Page 12883
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Page 12884
Suicide Timeline re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Friday, August 9, 2019
8:00 am inmate Reyes Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 departs for court
(WAB-USMS-SDNY) . Reyes is Epstein's cellmate.
8:30 am inmate Epstein arrives in Attorney Conference. He is
visited by several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 pm inmate Epstein departs attorney conference and returns to
SHU
7:00 pm inmate Epstein provided a social call by IDO. IDO reports
inmate Epstein was in good spirits, nothing unusual.
7:32 am PIO notified of incident by the Warden
***Inmate Reyes is released from court and does not return to the
institution.
Saturday, August 10, 2019
6:33 am body alarm activated in SHU. Staff found inmate Epstein
unresponsive in cell. Staff reported to bedside of inmate and
attempted to wake him. Control announced medical emergency. CPR
initiated
6:35 am medical staff (on duty PA) on site, CPR already in
progress medical staff continues CPR and AED applied on inmate.
Control called for ambulance
6:40 am , AW notified
6:45 am EMS arrives, paramedics continue CPR. Inmate Epstein
remains unresponsive. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three
rounds of Epinephrine, IV access started, IC) initiated. No pulse
found, no shock advised, inmate prepared for transport to local
hospital.
7:10 am EMS departs institution enroute to Beekman Hospital.
7:19 am USMS notified of incident.
7:20 am SIS Lt notified.
7:30 am , Warden arrives at institution. , AW
notified.
7:36 am official time of death reported by ER physician.
7:40 am Acting Chief Psychologist notified.
8:00 am and Captain arrive at institution.
8:10 am SIS Lt arrives at institution.
8:10 am CMC and SCSS notified.
8:34 am FBI notified.
9:00 am AUSA notified.
9:00 am arrives at institution.
9:00 am SIS Lt. reports to SHU. Interviews will be conducted with
inmates assigned to tier.
9:15 am CMC arrives at institution.
9:30 am Acting Chief Psychologist arrived to the institution.
9:50 am SCSS arrives at institution.
9:55 am CMC and IDO depart institution enroute to Beekman
Hospital.
10:00 am CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital, fingerprints and
photographs taken of inmate Epstein. Inmate clothing secured and
brought back to institution.
10:00 am Judge Berman notified.
10:15 am CMC return to institution.
10:45 am PIO arrived to the institution.
11:00 am next of kin (brother) notified by Case Management
Coordinator.
11:12 am press release is released to media.
11:15 am press release provided to Judge Berman.
11:15 am CST activated.
12:15 pm body release to Medical Examiner (ME) for autopsy
12:19 pm FBI arrives.
1:35 pm FBI arrives in Special Housing Unit.
1:40 pm OIG notified by the Warden and they will be sending an
Agent to NYM.
2:15 pm CST debrief conducted.
Google Alert - prison
From Google Alerts
To
Date 2019/08/19 18:08
Subject: Google Alert - prison
Attachments: TEXT.httn, Mime.822
prison
Daly update
NEWS
iiVy•Lst 19. 2019 ":1
Attorney General Barr orders removal of acting US prisons director after
Epstein's death
CNBC
Attorney General William Barr has ordered the removal of a top U.S. prisons official following Jeffrey
Epstein's death. In a statement Monday, the ...
US prisons chief removed after Epstein's death - Politico
Following Epstein's prison death, Barr appoints new federal prison chief - Conservative Review
US prisons chief removed after Jeffrey Epstein's death while in federal custody - Los Angeles Times
Full Coverage
Flag as irrelevant
Man went to prison posing as his dead brother. Here's what happens next
USA TODAY
"This parolee was not willing/able to correctly ID himself as he came through the gate," an alert prison
official wrote that day in an urgent memo, which ...
Inside The Prison Where Inmates Set Each Other On Fire and Gangs Have
More Power Than Guards
ProPublica
The prison struggles to meet the fundamental duties of a correctional facility, with surging violence and,
now, a lockdown barring visits entering its ...
Sanders' criminal justice plan aims to cut prison population
Washington Post
COLUMBIA, S.C. — Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders is proposing a criminal justice
overhaul that aims to cut the nation's prison ...
Sanders: Reduce prison population - Albany Times Union
Page 12887
Sanders' criminal justice plan aims to cut prison population - ABC News
Bernie Sanders' criminal justice plan would halve prison population, legalize pot - New York Daily News
Fill Coverage
Flag as irrelevant
Woman who stole from Carlisle Barracks ordered to prison for more thefts in
West Virginia
PennLive.com
A women who is on federal probation for stealing from Carlisle Barracks has now been sentenced to
prison in West Virginia for embezzling from a ...
Groundbreaking prison peer program helps inmates in
segregation
KETV Omaha
Spreading hope behind prison walls and in the darkest places of restricted
housing-that's the goal of a new peer support program at the Nebraska ...
French couple faces prison time after being caught with 90 pounds of sand
from Sardinia
CBS News
A French couple is facing years of jail time after stealing almost 90 pounds of sand from Sardinia, the
Italian island known for its picturesque beaches.
Tourist Couple Faces Six Years in Prison for Stealing Sand From Beach in Sardinia - Newsweek
Full Coverage
Flag as irrelevant
Recidivism is good for business
Big Think
Sixty-one percent of people in prison have jobs, which pay on average about 63 cents per hour. This is
already de facto slavery, but in Texas, Georgia, ...
Prison, Logan to swap services
Altoona Mirror
If an agreement is signed, the prison administration will be able to request Logan Township's drug-
sniffing dog to search the prison. In return, prison ...
Detroit man went to prison posing as his dead brother. Here's what happens
next
Detroit Free Press
Page 12888
LANSING — When Kevin Lee Gray was arrested for home invasion in 2017, he gave police the name of
his dead brother — Sammie Lee Gray.
WEB
Can Harsher Prison Sentences Deter Domestic Violence?
DomesticShelters.org
Everts say harsher prison sentences likely won't end domestic violence.
111th Memorial Tribute to The Prison Ship Martyrs
NYC Parks
Join us at the Memorial Tribute to the Prison Ship Martyrs from the American Revolution (America's First
POWs), in conjunction with the 243rd ...
Prison Abolition, and a Mule
UC Berkeley Events Calendar - University of California, Berkeley
Prison Abolition, and a Mule: Jefferson Memorial Lecture featuring Paul Butler. Lecture I October 16 I
4:10 p.m. I Bancroft Hotel, Great Hall. Location:...
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscdbe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Page 12889
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D5AE5D4.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.1367333.1.1 4911.1
Message Path xmlefrash/SD5AE.584.NERDOMINEFtADMI.100.1 367333.1.14911.1.mi
From Google Alerts
Display Name Goog)e Alerts
Email googlealerts-noreplyMseogle.com
Reply. To googkakns•norepKivaogk.com
Test Goo* Alerts
To
Subject Google Alert - prison
Scheduled date 2019-08-19 I8:0632
Creation date 2019-08-19188632
Modified date 2019-08-19 18:1238
Delivered date 2019-08-19188833
Message she 6993
Attachments she 118534
Total size 125538
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.hun
Content ID
5D5AE5114.NERDOM I .NERADM 1.200.2000009.1.D
668&4453D5AE584.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.1
367333.1.14911.1@i 9.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100 .0.1.0. l@l8
Is Inline false
TV(' fie
Size 49136
CA 1 e875c695bb5ccf94a 15840de 17138
Has h 936DBFOB7FF6350875F0758A2AC71E49EA3EIF71 BCC4A4FEACIFFCCCED4551660WBF676
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D5AE5B4.NERDOMI.NERADMI.200.2000009.I.D
6689.1@453D5AE584.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.1
367333.1.14911.1@l9.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100 .0.1.0. 1@l8
Is Inline false
Type fk
Size 69398
CA 1609924567a I a3 1 ae09500a690fabk
Hash BB40E63E8FD47F39A63A3C068D06FBBF4EF93763 196AI212B7252DD0BCEI4631A6FF1759
Recipients I
Recipient
Displas Name
Email
QUID 2F982680-14C3-00009B47-BF62C05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read false
Deleted true
Opened false
Completed fake
Security Notmal
Box type Inbox
Return notification "hen opened false
Return notification "hen de le te d fake
Return notification "hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D5AE584.NERDOMI.NEftADM1.100.1367333.1.1 4911.1@l9.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.0.1.0.1@1 S
Source leeched
Class Public
Account RDOM I
Page 12890
Location ID 1540843020946
Class Name 6W.NIESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
ID 9.NERDOMLNERADMI.I00.0.I.0.I@I8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12891
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019.08-210335:4I EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Trash)
JolAcn-lebs.crGWOpenNodexn-arc
actmai
knii-6,—' Ag ent- n Job.cn-Jobs.cn-GWOperiNocle.cn—archivinpr o
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [ctrArchive
I -DallY Trash)
—nettnaill
202(-05-19153421 EDT Tag 13O1'01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BO80170334XRADM 1.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12892
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12893
Sent: Mon, 19 Aug 2019 15:06:52 -0700
Subject: Google Alert - prison
From: Goo le Alerts < ooglealerls-noreply@google.00m>
To:
prison .ue August 19. 2019
NEWS
Attorney General Barr orders removal of acting US prisons director after Epstein's death
CNBC
Attorney General William Barr has ordered the removal of a top U.S. prisons official following Jeffrey Epstein's death. 
In a
statement Monday, the ...
US prisons chief removed after Epstein's death - Politico
Following Epstein's prison death, Barr appoints new federal prison chief - Conservative Review
US prisons chief removed after Jeffrey Epstein's death while in federal custody - Los Angeles Times
Full Coverage
Flag as irre'evant
Man went to prison posing as his dead brother. Here's what happens next
USA TODAY
"This parolee was not willing/able to correctly ID himself as he came through the gate; an alert prison official wrote 
that day
in an urgent memo, which ...
Flag as
Inside The Prison Where Inmates Set Each Other On Fire and Gangs Have More Power
Than Guards
ProPublica
The prison struggles to meet the fundamental duties of a correctional facility, with surging violence and, now, a 
lockdown
barring visits entering its ...
Sanders' criminal justice plan aims to cut prison population
Washington Post
COLUMBIA, S.C. — Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders is proposing a criminal justice overhaul that aims to
cut the nation's prison ...
Sanders: Reduce prison population - Albany Times Union
Sanders' criminal justice plan aims to cut prison population - ABC News
Bernie Sanders' criminal justice plan would halve prison population, legalize pot - New York Daily News
Full Coverage
Flag as irre:evant
Woman who stole from Carlisle Barracks ordered to prison for more thefts in West Virginia
PennLive.com
A woman who is on federal probation for stealing from Carlisle Barracks has now been sentenced to prison in West 
Virginia
for embezzling from a ...
Groundbreaking prison peer program helps inmates in segregation
KETV Omaha
Spreading hope behind prison walls and in the darkest places of restricted housing-that's the goal of a new peer support
program at the Nebraska ...
■■
French couple faces prison time after being caught with 90 pounds of sand from Sardinia
CBS News
A French couple is facing years of jail time after stealing almost 90 pounds of sand from Sardinia, the Italian island 
known
for its picturesque beaches.
Tourist Couple Faces Six Years in Prison for Stealing Sand From Beach in Sardinia - Newsweek
Full Coverage
Flag as irre'evant
Recidivism is good for business
Big Think
Sixty-one percent of people in prison have jobs, which pay on average about 63 cents per hour. This is already de facto
slavery, but in Texas, Georgia....
Prison, Logan to swap services
Altoona Mirror
If an agreement is signed, the prison administration will be able to request Logan Township's drug-sniffing dog to 
search
the prison. In return, prison ...
Detroit man went to prison posing as his dead brother. Here's what happens next
Detroit Free Press
LANSING — When Lee Gray was arrested for home invasion in 2017, he gave police the name of his dead brother —
Sammie Lee Gray.
WEB
Can Harsher Prison Sentences Deter Domestic Violence?
DomesticShelters.org
Experts say harsher prison sentences likely won't end domestic violence.
Fag as i—e r.
111th Memorial Tribute to The Prison Ship Martyrs
NYC Parks
Join us at the Memorial Tribute to the Prison Ship Martyrs from the American Revolution (America's First POW's), in
conjunction with the 243rd ...
Prison Abolition, and a Mule
UC Berkeley Events Calendar - University of California, Berkeley
Prison Abolition, and a Mule: Jefferson Memorial Lecture featuring Paul Butler. Lecture I October 1614:10 p.m. I 
Bancroft
Hotel, Great Hall. Location:...
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Google Alert
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
prison
NEWS
- prison
Google Alerts
2019/11/25 17:03
Google Alert - prison
TEXT.htm, Mime.822
N.,. umber 25. 2019
Former incarcerated student: Society owes men and women
in prison chance to return whole
USA TODAY
PBS documentary shows how higher education helped me remove the shackles of
incarceration. College degrees in prison can do the same for ...
Prison health care costs are higher than ever in Texas. Many point to an
aging prison population.
Texas Tribune
While the total prison population declined by 3%, the number of inmates ages 55 and older increased by
65%, according to Texas Department of ...
Flag as irrelevant
Data leak reveals how China 'brainwashes' Uighurs in prison camps
BBC News
Leaked documents detail for the first time China's systematic brainwashing of hundreds of thousands of
Muslims in a network of high-security prison ...
Morning mail: China prison camps, rainforest burns, Flanagan on Morrison
The Guardian
Monday: Leaked Communist party documents reveal vast prison network detaining a million of China's
Muslim minorities. Plus: Full Story on Angus ...
Jeffrey Epstein's Death Shows the Need for Prison Reform
The New York Times
Page 12897
It would be a tragic and costly missed opportunity for the Bureau of Prisons and the United States
attorney general to fail to undertake — and to make ...
ASAP Rocky Says He'd Be Down to Perform at Swedish Prison
Complex
During a conversation with TMZ, the rapper revealed that he would love" to perform for the inmates at
the prison. Yet, he doubts that this would be ...
ASAP Rocky would love' to perform at Swedish prison - REVOLT TV
Full Coverage
Fldij as irr
Julian Assange's health is so bad he 'could die in prison', say 60 doctors
The Guardian
In the letter to the British home secretary, Priti Patel, the doctors called for Assange to be moved from
Belmarsh prison in southeast London to a ...
Gavin Newsom wants to close a California state prison. It
won't be easy
Sacramento Bee
Gov. Gavin Newsom is talking about an idea that has hung around California for
more than 150 years: dosing a state prison. Newsom brought up the ...
Zehra Dogan's prison paintings fight for the Kurdish cause
FRANCE 24
In a cramped prison cell in southeastern Turkey, a young Kurdish woman lies drawing on a mattress on
the floor. The light is poor, the air is bad and ...
The Guardian view on prisons and mothers: an injustice
The Guardian
The shameful treatment of pregnant inmates and of the children of jailed women must be addressed. No
babies should be born behind bars.
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscri be
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Page 12898
Page 12899
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5DD03945.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.B67333.1.1 7D8E1
Message Path xmlarash\5DDC0945.NERDOMI.NERADMI.I00. I 367333.1.17D8E.I.xml
From Gongle Akrts
Display Name Google Alerts
Email googlealens-nceepViugeogle.com
Reply To 8008kalerts-ixrcPIA11668k.x001
Test Goo* Alerts
To
Subject Google Alert - prison
Scheduled date 2019-11-25 17:01:18
Creation date 2019-11-25 1701:18
Modified date 2019-11-25 170509
Deli% ercd date 2019-11-25 170302
Message she 5519
Attachments she 94502
Total she 100032
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.him
Name TEXT.htm
Content In
5DDC0945.NERDOMI.NERADM1.200.2000010.1.1
B104E-1®453DDC0945.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.
B67333.I.17D8E1@l9.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline false
T%Pc Ale
Size 38562
CA 10829d8d9051:62ccf7c847f85ea66a45
Dash FCID4CICB477929A151308660FC9917017018BD98 1B9C959DOAED5181895D9D675808DDE
Attachment Mine.822
Name Minc.822
Content ID
5DDC0945.NEFtDOMI.NERADM1.200.2000010.1.1
BIO4F.1€4455DDC0945.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.
B67333.I.17D8E1@l9.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline false
Type Me
Size 55940
CA a5939958b78990a0c8ble61148715596
Hash F4FIEB6B3854D82EB116BE6D0170382CEIIMC538 02D8FB45F7CDOC9EIEDDFC8ECF400EFA
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2F982B80.14C3-0030-9B47-DF62C05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read false
Deleted true
Opened fake
Completed false
Security Nonnal
Box type inbox
Return notification "hen opened false
Return notification "hen de le tc d fake
Return notification "hen
completed false
Return notification "hen declined lake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DDC0945.NERDOMI.NERADMI.I00.1367333.I.1 7D8E.IQ1..9.NERDOMI.NERADMI.I00.0.1.0.1QI 8
Source received
Class Public
Account RDOMI
Page 12900
Location ID 1540843020946
Class Name 6W.NIESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
ID 9.NERDOMLNERADMI.I00.0.I.0.I@I8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12901
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-11-27 063536 EST Created
cn=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Trashl
Joben-lebs.orGWOpenNodeen-archiving.oAgent-
setmai
Generated by Netgovem [crrArchive
I -DailY Trash IJoben-lobsan-GWOpenNode.cn-archivmgo
—netrnail]
2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag 80801700.NOCRAD‘11.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12902
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12903
Sent: Mon, 25 Nov 2019 14:01:18 -0800
Subject: Google Alert - prison
From: Goo le Alerts < ooglealerts-noreply@google.conb
To:
prison tily update • November 25, 2019
NEWS
Former incarcerated student: Society owes men and women in prison chance to return
whole
USA TODAY
PBS documentary shows how higher education helped me remove the shackles of incarceration. College degrees in prison
can do the same for ...

• •
Prison health care costs are higher than ever in Texas. Many point to an aging prison
population.
Texas Tribune
While the total prison population declined by 3%, the number of inmates ages 55 and older increased by 65%. according to
Texas Department of ...
Rag as i-P '
Data leak reveals how China 'brainwashes' Uighurs in prison camps
BBC News
Leaked documents detail for the first time China's systematic brainwashing of hundreds of thousands of Muslims in a
network of high-security prison ...
Morning mail: China prison camps, rainforest burns, Flanagan on Morrison
The Guardian
Monday: Leaked Communist party documents reveal vast prison network detaining a million of China's Muslim minorities.
Plus: Full Story on Angus ...
•
Jeffrey Epstein's Death Shows the Need for Prison Reform
The New York Times
It would be a tragic and costly missed opportunity for the Bureau of Prisons and the United States attorney general to 
fail to
undertake — and to make ...
ASAP Rocky Says He'd Be Down to Perform at Swedish Prison
Complex
During a conversation with TMZ, the rapper revealed that he would love" to perform for the inmates at the prison. Yet, 
he
doubts that this would be ...
ASAP Rocky would "love" to perform at Swedish prison - REVOLT N
Full Coverage
Flag as irrelevant
Julian Assange's health is so bad he 'could die in prison', say 60 doctors
The Guardian
In the letter to the British home secretary, Priti Patel, the doctors called for Assange to be moved from Belmarsh 
prison in
southeast London to a ...
XXI
Gavin Newsom wants to close a California state prison. It won't be easy
Sacramento Bee
Gov. Gavin Newsom is talking about an idea that has hung around California for more than 150 years: closing a state
prison. Newsom brought up the ...
Zehra Dogan's prison paintings fight for the Kurdish cause
FRANCE 24
In a cramped prison cell in southeastern Turkey, a young Kurdish woman lies drawing on a mattress on the floor. The 
light
is poor, the air is bad and ...
Elan as irre'evaril
The Guardian view on prisons and mothers: an injustice
The Guardian
The shameful treatment of pregnant inmates and of the children of jailed women must be addressed. No babies should be
born behind bars.
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
The Daily 202: Clouds of economic uncertainty loom despite temporary reprieve from
Trump on China tariffs
From The Washington Post
To , The Washington Post
Date 2019,08/14 10:24
Subject: The Daily 202: Clouds of economic uncertainty loom despite temporary
reprieve from Trump on China tariffs
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
If you're having trouble reading this click here.
The Daily 202
Share: Listen to The Big Idea
Clouds of economic uncertainty loom
despite temporary reprieve from Trump on
China tariffs
Trump says China tariffs delayed for 'Christmas season'
BY JAMES HOHMANN
with Mariana Alfaro
THE BIG IDEA: If President Trump wanted to stabilize
the listing stock market, his Tuesday announcement
that he will temporarily postpone the implementation
of about half the tariffs on Chinese imports that he
announced 12 days earlier did the trick. But only for
the day. Companies whose supply chains depend on
China, from Apple and Best Buy to Mattel and Nike, saw
their share prices edge up.
Page 12906
The fundamentals have not changed. In fact, they
continue to worsen. And stocks tumbled this morning
when the markets opened. For the first time since 2007,
the yields on short-term U.S. bonds eclipsed those of long-
term bonds. This phenomenon, called the inverted yield
curve, has preceded every recession in the past 50 years.
Bigger picture, the United States remains engaged in a
trade war with China, the world's second-largest
economy, with no end in sight. Trump's insistence that
he still plans to impose all the previously announced duties
on Dec. 15 forces corporate chieftains to prepare for more
troubled waters ahead. Many analysts said the delay does
nothing to mitigate the ominous clouds of uncertainty that
hang over the economy. "Trade wars are good and easy to
win," Trump said last year. That was wrong.
Beyond the inverted yield curve, economists are
pointing to a litany of other early warning signs that
indicate a recession looms, despite the Federal Reserve's
recent decision to cut interest rates. There's already been a
decline in business investment, and some companies are
pulling back on hiring.
Yesterday, Trump came closer than he has before to
acknowledging  that his tariffs on Chinese imports are
really taxes on American consumers. He's been falsely
claiming that the Chinese are paying the full price of his
tariffs. "We are doing this for the Christmas season, just in
racy cnrna of thp tariffc \nini iIri haves an imnart nn I I S Page 12907
consumers," the president told reporters, as he prepared to
fly to a speech in western Pennsylvania.
It's no coincidence that the products that got a carve -
out from the planned 10 percent tariff on $300 billion
worth of imports are consumer goods such as
cellphones, laptops, strollers and sneakers. Higher
prices might have caused sticker shock over the
holidays. The prior tariffs, which have gone into effect,
mostly increased the price of component parts that
companies use to assemble something else. These new
tariffs would hit finished goods such as iPhones, which are
assembled in China, making it more likely that the higher
costs are passed on to consumers.
President Trump speaks to contractors on Monday at the Shell Chemicals
Petrochemical Complex in Monaca, Pa. (Jeff Swensen/Getty Images)
Trump wants to win reelection, and he's sensitive to
the markets. The result has been a series of erratic
policy announcements that often appear to be
improvisational and that cause whiplash for the
markets. It sometimes feels as if Trump jsAxacticing the
"madman theory" in trade negotiations. Is he being crazy?
Or crazy like a fox? For example, how seriously are we to
take it when Trump threatens, aslie did yesterday, to pull
out of the World Trade Organization?
"It's complete manipulation," said Kenny Polcari of
Page 12908
Butcher Joseph Asset Management. "[Trump] threatens
the market, by surprise, two weeks ago. The markets re-
price. Then he says, `I think we are going to delay those
tariffs.' ... The [algorithms] respond immediately and take
the market higher," Polcari told my colleagues Taylor Telford
and Thomas Heath. "Of course the market is going to rally!"
"We are all just one tweet away from significant
volatility," RSM chief economist Joe Brusuelas wrote
in a note to his clients after Trump's tariff
postponement. "The idea that this is a major source of
relief to the economy is not tethered to empirical reality."
"We were relieved. But does that stop the volatility and
instability? No," said Jay Foreman, chief executive of
the Florida -based toy company Basic Fun. Foreman told
the Associated Press yesterday that he's still considering
layoffs this fall to offset his higher costs and noted that,
despite Trump's reprieve, tariffs remain a severe threat.
"The climbdown over the China tariffs does not mean a
trade deal is now near, not least because China's
authorities currently face a much bigger problem,
namely, the challenge to their legitimacy in Hong
Kong, and that will take precedence," wrote Pantheon
Macroeconomics chief economist Ian Shepherdson in a
note to investors that Tory Newmyer covered in this
morning'_s Finance 202. "But we can fully understand
markets' relief at the lifting of the threat of tariffs on
consumer goods just ahead of the holiday shopping
Page 12909
season.
Traders on on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange. (Richard Drew/AP)
-- U.S. businesses have begun taking down job listings
because of the uncertainty caused by the trade war:
"Win Cramer had big plans to hire several new employees
this summer for his company, including a chief operating
officer, but he took the job listings down after Trump tweeted
that more tariffs would hit Chinese goods in September," our
economics correspondent Heather_LongTeported_yesterday.
"'It's the most frustrating time I've ever had running a
business, and I've been doing this for 20 years,' said
Cramer, chief executive of JLab Audio, which makes
wireless earbuds and headphones sold at Best Buy, Target
and elsewhere.
"The United States had 7.3 million job openings in
June, down from a peak of 7.6 million in November. ...
While the decline is modest, economists are concerned
hiring could dry up quickly as companies see no end in sight
to Trump's trade war and they look to cut costs. The
reduction in job openings is also widespread across many
industries, signaling how cautious companies are becoming.
A decrease in job openings has tended to be a signal
of economic trouble. ... Job openings peaked in April
2007, for example, nine months before the start of the Great
Recession. Job openings in many industries have declined
since November, including the information sector, financial
Page 12910
services, transportation and warehousing, and hotels and
food service, suggesting wide concern about future growth.
Actual hires also have slowed this year, with average
monthly job gains falling to 165,000 a month, down from
223,000 a month last year."
-- "Uncertainty" is the buzzword that keeps coming up
in notes from Wall Street institutions to their clients
that seem to become gloomier with each passing day:
"Trade's simmer has begun to boil, business
sentiment and capital spending have softened further,
global growth remains weak and inflation expectations
have fallen," Morgan Stanley's Ellen Zentner wrote on
Monday. "Heightened market volatility and increased news
flow on trade may soften consumer sentiment and
spending."
Goldman Sachs said Sunday it does not expect a trade
deal between the U.S. and China before the 2020
election. "Fears that the trade war will trigger a recession
are growing," wrote Goldman's chief U.S. economist, Jan
Hatzius, explaining why growth projections are being
lowered. "Overall, we have increased our estimate of the
growth impact of the trade war. The drivers of this modest
change are that we now include an estimate of the sentiment
and uncertainty effects ... Relatedly, the business sentiment
effect of increased pessimism about the outlook from trade
war news may lead firms to invest, hire, or produce less."
Page 12911
Tugboats manuever a container ship last week at a port in eastern China's Shandong
province. (Chinatopix via AP)
"We are worried," Bank of America Merrill Lynch chief
economist Michelle Meyer wrote Friday. "We now have
a number of early indicators starting to signal heightened
risk of recession. Our official model has the probability
of a recession over the next 12 months only pegged at
about 20 percent, but our subjective call based on the
slew of data and events leads us to believe it is closer
to a 1-in-3 chance. ... Three out of the five economic
indicators (auto sales, industrial production, and aggregate
hours worked) which track the business cycle closely are
near levels consistent at the start of the previous
recessions."
-- More dark mood music:

• Inflation in the United States was slightly higher
last month than expected: The Labor Department
announced yesterday that the consumer price index
rose 0.3 percent in July. That's modest but was above
analyst predictions.

• U.S. mortgage debt reached a record in the second
quarter, exceeding its 2008 peak as the financial
crisis unfolded. "Mortgage balances rose by $162
billion in the second quarter to $9.406 trillion,
surpassing the high of $9.294 trillion in the third quarter
of 2008, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York said
Ti icacriaw " npr thin \A/all Ctraat Int imal
Page 12912
j , 1.0,0I %A 1‘.. ,  • • VIII 'V IA VS.", ..." W.,. I 0.....

• China's economy is faltering: "The jobless rate in
Chinese cities again rebounded in July to its highest
level since regular reporting on the data began, as
employers turned cautious," today's Journal reports.
"Other key economic readings for the month, including
factory production, consumption and property
investment, came in much lower than expected."

• Germany's economy shrank slightly last quarter.
Europe's biggest economy suffered from falling exports,
and the auto industry is struggling to adjust to new
emissions standards, per the AP.
• The British economy also unexpectedly shrank, for
the first time since 2012, because of uncertainties
surrounding Brexit.
-- Finally, some good news: We're hiring! I'm looking
for an ambitious reporter to help me write The Daily
202. This is a demanding job that requires a news junkie
and a creative thinker who is skilled at connecting the dots
about news developments in Washington, around the
country and the world. The ideal candidate will have a track
record of writing conceptual scoops in the political arena,
examining key developments in the White House, Congress
or on the campaign trail in a fresh and original light. That
candidate should be able to identify key themes and story
lines from the slew of news that breaks on a daily basis, and
skillfully synthesize those events in a meaningful and
revelatory way for readers. This position is based in our
Washington newsroom. (Read the full job posting here.)
Page 12913
Trieiti me at Jarnes.nonmannewasnposi.com  II you nave
questions or ideas.
Subscribe on Amazon Echo, Gdogle_Home, Apple HomePod and
other podcast players.
Welcome to the Daily 202, PowerPost's morning
briefing for decision-makers.
Sign up to receive the newsletter.
WHILE YOU WERE SLEEPING:
Rod Blagojevich, with his wife, Patti, at his side, speaks to reporters in Chicago before
reporting to federal prison in 2012. (M. Spencer Green/AP)
-- Trump appears to have backed away from what had
been imminent plans to commute the sentence of
former Illinois governor Rod Blagojevich in the face of
massive Republican  blowback,  CNN reports: "Several
Republican lawmakers called acting White House chief of
staff Mick Mulvaney and White House counsel Pat
Cipollone. At least two of them, Reps. Darin LaHood and
Mike Bost, made their case directly to the President on
Thursday night, urging him not to go forward. ... Another
White House official said that while Blagojevich's pardon
CPPMPri imminpnt later last NA/PPk thprp hart hppn nn
Page 12914
movement on the matter since Trump spoke with the two
congressmen. It appeared to be on ice, the official said,
while offering the caveat that Trump could change his mind
and decide to move forward.
"Multiple sources familiar with the calls said Trump
and Mulvaney both did not seem aware of the details
of Blagojevich's case, even though the president had
decried the former governor as being treated 'unbelievably
unfairly.' ... Trump's son-in-law and senior adviser Jared
Kushner had been funneling messages of support for
Blagojevich's commutation to the president ... Trump
adviser and former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani also
made it clear to Trump that Blagojevich's sentence was too
harsh. Bernard Kerik, a former NYPD commissioner who
served time in prison on a tax fraud conviction and has been
advocating for Blagojevich, slammed the opposition."
Jeffress celebrates Freedom Sunday with his congregants in Dallas on June
30. (liana Panich-Linsman for The Washington Post)
2020 WATCH:
-- Opinion columnist Elizabeth Bruenig  went to her
home state of Texas for a deep dive into why Trump
seems poised to fare even better among evangelicals
in 2020 than he did in 2016. Partly this is because they are Page 12915
culture warriors and want to get another ally on the Supreme
Court, of course, but she concludes that it's also because
"the backlash against them has cemented so much of what
they already suspected about liberals' attitudes."
"Overall, American culture is hardly trending toward
adherence to evangelical beliefs, with approval of same-sex
marriage steadily rising among all religious groups (even
evangelicals), religious affiliation quickly dropping, and
support for legal abortion lingering at all-time highs," Bruenig
writes in a thoughtful essay. "In some sense it seemed
that Trump is able, by being less Christian than your
average Christian, to protect Christians who fear
incursions from a hostile dominant culture. But that
paradox also supplies a handy solution to the question of
whether Christians should direct their efforts to worldly
politics or turn inward, shunning political life for spiritual
pursuits. By voting for Trump — even over more
identifiably Christian candidates — evangelicals seem
to have found a way to outsource their fears and
instead reserve a strictly spiritual space for
themselves inside politics without placing evangelical
politicians themselves in power. In that sense, they can
be both active political agents and a semi-cloistered religious
minority, both of the world and removed from it, advancing
their values while retreating to their own societies."
-- For a separate story, religion reporter Julie Zauzmer
interviewed  more than 50 evangelical Christians in the
battleground states of Florida, Pennsylvania and Page 12916
Wisconsin: "In conversation, evangelical voters paint the
portrait of the Trump they see: a president who acts like a
bully but is fighting for them. A president who sees America
like they do, a menacing place where white Christians feel
mocked and threatened for their beliefs. A president who's
against abortion and gay rights and who has the economy
humming to boot. ... The allegations that Trump sexually
assaulted numerous women are not a moral concern, many
Christians say. ... Opponents decry his attitude toward
people of color, his approach to immigrants detained
at the border, his answers to violence in American
cities, and on and on. But in Appleton, Wis., the Rev.
Dennis Episcopo hasn't felt the need as a religious
leader to denounce any of it in front of his
congregation, which includes more than 5,000 attendees
on a typical Sunday. The megachurch that he has led for 22
years is almost entirely white and conservative, like the
lakeside region where it is located. Episcopo has not seen
any behavior from Trump in the past three years that would
prompt him to openly dissuade churchgoers from supporting
this president. 'There could be something, where society
really crosses the line on something, that I feel as a pastor I
have to get up and say something,' he muses. But it hasn't
happened yet.-
-- Former Colorado governor John Hickenlooper (D) is
considering ending his presidential bid to run for the
Senate. From_the New York Times: "Hickenlooper, who is
mired at the bottom of public polling of the presidential race,
hnnntari intn RPnatnr Mirharal Ronnrafc rar nn Fririaw ninht in
Page 12917
[Iowa] to discuss his impending decision. [They drove
around together for 20 minutes in Clear Lake before the
Wing Ding dinner.] ... Officials who have been in
discussions with the Hickenlooper campaign said Tuesday
that the former two-term governor is giving serious
consideration to switching to the Senate race but stressed
that a final decision has not yet been made. Short of a
massive change in political momentum, Mr. Hickenlooper is
certain to fail to qualify for the next round of presidential
debates in September, an additional blow to a campaign
struggling to attract attention and financial contributions. ...
"Recent days have brought unsubtle messages that high-
ranking Democratic officials in Colorado and Washington
believe Mr. Hickenlooper is in the wrong race. The Denver
Post on Sunday published  polling done on behalf of 'a
national Democratic group involved in Senate races' that
showed Mr. Hickenlooper holding a 51-point lead over two
other Democrats in the state's 2020 Senate race. On
Monday, the 314 Action Fund, a super PAC that backs
candidates who are scientists, announced a `Draft Hick for
Senate' campaign along with a poll it commissioned showing
Mr. Hickenlooper leading Senator Cory Gardner, a Colorado
Republican seeking re-election, by 13 percentage points in a
head-to-head matchup."
Beto O'Rourke, who returned to his hometown of El
Paso after the mass shooting there, may resume his
2020 campaign as early as this week amid persistent
calls for him to run for Senate instead. Su000rters of the Page 12918
former congressman want him to challenge Sen. John
Cornyn (R). (Politico)
-- Republican donors are being advised by allies of
Mike Pompeo to hold off on contributing to any of the
current Senate candidates in Kansas as the secretary
of state weighs whether to run for the open seat of
retiring Sen. Pat . From Bloomberg News: "A
Pompeo ally has been advising potential contributors to wait
until after the secretary of state makes his decision ... The
top U.S. diplomat and former CIA director, who served as a
congressman in Kansas's 4th district from 2011-2017, has
until June to enter the race."
-- Trump is trying to turn Joe Biden's gaffes into a
major liability. Matt Viser reports: "Over the last few days,
Biden has made a string of small missteps while
campaigning during a crucial stretch in Iowa. ... He has
bungled oft-repeated lines, saying `truth over facts' rather
than truth over lies. ... He spoke of meeting with Parkland
students when he was vice president, even though the
Florida school shooting occurred a year after he left office.
... On their own, none of these mistakes significantly alter
the race. ... Some say the gaffes pale in comparison to
things Trump says. ... That hasn't stopped Trump and his
allies from seizing on Biden's comments. ... On Friday, he
said `Joe is not playing with a full deck' and that
`something's going wrong with him.-
--  can learn a few lessons from Mitt Romney's
Page 12919
2012 presidential campaign, writes Dan Balz: "He
continues to lead in the polls, nationally and in early states.
He has led those polls from the start of the year to today.
Still, he is treated as being in a precarious position, a
vulnerable candidate not at his best and a few mistakes
away from a real fall. Just like Romney through much of
2011. Romney was the disrespected front-runner in the
2012 Republican field. He could be awkward as a candidate
and paid a price for it in the coverage of his campaign. But
as with Biden, he led in most — not all — surveys ahead of
the primaries and caucuses."
-- A new survey finds support for abortion rights
remains steady, despite a growing partisan divide.
Ariana Eunjung Cha and Scott Clement report: "No more
than a quarter of residents in any state supports a total ban
despite the increasing political divide on the issue. The
Public Religion Research Institute survey released Tuesday
involves an extraordinarily large sample of 40,292 interviews
measuring abortion attitudes throughout 2018, allowing it to
produce nuanced results for individual states and for very
small demographic groups. It found that Americans remain
generally supportive of abortion rights, with 54 percent
saying it should be legal in all or most cases and 40 percent
saying it should be illegal."
A chaotic day in Hong Kong ends with specter of more violence to come
THE NEW WORLD ORDER:
-- The Hong Kong protest movement is facing a tipping
Page 12920
point as demonstrators seek the sympathy of the
international community. Gerry Shih and Timothy
McLaughlin report: "After late-night mob scenes marred a
demonstration that paralyzed this city's airport, protesters on
Wednesday issued apologies seeking the international
public's sympathy and forgiveness as they fought to regain
control over a narrative that seemed to be tilting in Beijing's
favor for the first time. The appeals, which included
apologies to the police force, come as the struggle over
public opinion reaches a climax. While Hong Kong's protest
movement has become steadily radicalized and fractured,
the Chinese government has sharply ramped up a
propaganda effort in state media and on social networks to
discredit and deflate a movement that to this point enjoyed
wide support across Hong Kong society.
"Hong Kong's airport ground to a near-halt for a second day
Tuesday after protesters assailing police brutality and
government indifference occupied departure halls, sparking
tense but largely peaceful confrontations with frustrated
passengers, many of them stranded. The mood turned
darker by nightfall after protesters seized two men —
one a reporter for Chinese state media, another they
claimed to be a Chinese government agent — and
clashed with police and paramedics who tried to
evacuate the pair. At one point, protesters surrounded and
kicked a police van, sparking hand-to-hand clashes with riot
police who fired pepper spray near the departure terminal.
"On Wednesday, police warned that protesters arrested
Page 12921
during the terminal fracas could face life in prison.
Seven men aged 17 to 28 years old were detained, five for
unlawful assembly and two for assaulting police officers and
possession of offensive weapons, said Mak Chin Ho,
assistant police commissioner. ... Threats of such severe
punishment fit with an approach by Beijing, and its
supporters in the Hong Kong government, to dramatically
raise the potential cost for taking part in demonstrations."
-- China is threatening to use military -style force in
Hong Kong, hoping that threats alone will disperse
protests, as students plan to continue protesting once
universities resume classes next month. Anna Fifield
reports: "That would take the protests uncomfortably close
to celebrations planned on Oct. 1 to mark the 70th
anniversary of the foundation of the People's Republic of
China, which was established with the goal of unifying
greater China under the leadership of the Communist Party.
... That concern, combined with increasingly strident
rhetoric from Chinese officials, has raised fears about the
possibility of military intervention in Hong Kong. This week,
state-affiliated media outlets tweeted ominous videos of
Chinese tanks carrying out exercises in Shenzhen, the
southern Chinese city that borders Hong Kong, while
authorities in Beijing portrayed the protests as
`terrorism.' China already stands accused of sending in
thugs from local gangs to try to deter the protesters in Hong
Kong, and there are growing concerns that it will send in the
People's Armed Police, a paramilitary force responsible for
internal security and `stability maintenance.' Or perhaps Page 12922
even the People's Liberation Army."
How an eye patch became a symbol of the Hong Kong protests
-- Bloody eye patches have become the latest symbol
of the Hong Kong protests after a young woman was
hit in the face with a projectile that many protesters
believe was fired by police. Kati_e_MettLer rep_orts:
"Authorities said at a news conference that there was no
proof to back up that claim. From the tension, a new rallying
symbol was born. `Eye for an eye,' some protesters shouted
as they continued their sit-in ... Demonstrators also spray-
painted `eye for an eye' throughout the airport in Chinese
and in English and covered their faces with mock eye
patches made of gauze. Some colored them red, to signify
blood."
-- China asked the Trump administration to back off
after U.S. lawmakers, including Speaker Nancy Pelosi
(D-Calif.) and House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy
(R-Calif.), condemned the violence against pro -
democracy activists. From Reuters: "The United States
has denied Chinese suggestions that it has a hand in the
unrest. But China's foreign ministry spokeswoman Hua
Chunying said the lawmakers' comments have `provided
new and powerful evidence to the world.-
-- Meanwhile, Trump said the "thing" in Hong Kong
— which he called a "riot" last week — is "very
tough" but stopped short of criticizing China. From the
Page 12923
I II I ICJ.  II I UUI I II I ICI IlJ LU I cpui lel J CII IU II I CI Jet ICJ Ul
afternoon tweets, Mr. Trump took no strong position on the
demonstrations that have gripped Hong Kong for weeks and
have drawn an increasingly brutal response from local
security forces. He echoed none of the defenses of
freedom and democracy coming from both Democrats
and Republicans. ... `We'll see what happens. But I'm sure
it'll work out,' he said. He added: `I hope it works out for
everybody, including China. I hope it works out peacefully. I
hope nobody gets hurt. I hope nobody gets killed.' The
president later tweeted that intelligence reports indicated that
China's government `is moving troops to the Border with
Hong Kong.-
Mitch McConnell walks to his Senate office earlier this year. (Salwan Georges/The
Washington Post)
-- Follow the money: Senate Majority Leader Mitch
McConnell (R-Ky.) had quarterbacked the effort on
Capitol Hill to lift sanctions on Russia's largest
aluminum producer, a company that soon afterward
backed the creation of the first new aluminum -rolling
mill in the U.S. in nearly four decades — built in
McConnell's home state. Tom Hamburger and Rosalind
S. Helderman report: "In January, as the Senate debated
whether to permit the Trump administration to lift sanctions
on Russia's largest aluminum producer, two men with
millions of dollars riding on the outcome met for dinner at a
restaurant in Zurich. On one side of the table sat the head of
Page 12924
sales for Rusal, the Russian aluminum producer that would
benefit most immediately from a favorable Senate vote. ...
On the other side sat Craig Bouchard, an American
entrepreneur who had gained favor with officials in Kentucky
... By the next day, McConnell had successfully blocked the
bill, despite the defection of 11 Republicans.
"Within weeks, the U.S. government had formally lifted
sanctions on Rusal, citing a deal with the company that
reduced the ownership interest of its Kremlin-linked founder,
Oleg Deripaska. And three months later, Rusal announced
plans for an extraordinary partnership with Bouchard's
company, providing $200 million in capital to buy a 40
percent stake in the new aluminum plant in Ashland, Ky. —
a project heralded by Gov. Matt Bevin (R) `as significant as
any economic deal ever made in the history of Kentucky.' A
spokesman for McConnell said the majority leader did
not know that Bouchard had hopes of a deal with Rusal
at the time McConnell led the Senate effort to end the
sanctions. ... Democratic senators have called for a
government review of the deal, prompting a Rusal
executive in Moscow last week to threaten to pull out
of the investment."
-- Russian villagers were told to leave their town
following a missile test explosion. Will Englund reports:
"It took most of Tuesday for officials to realize how
damaging this looked given the nuclear materials involved in
the accident. Arkhangelsk Gov. Igor Orlov insisted it wasn't
an evacuation but a 'routine measure.' ... About 450 people
Page 12925
are said to live in the village, which abuts a military testing
range. ... A resident of Nyonoksa told ArkhangelskOnline
that the village has been evacuated before, presumably
because of the hazards of tests or other military activity
nearby. ... Local officials conducted a study of soil, sand,
river and seawater samples from several points in the region
and reported no excess levels of radiation, according to
media reports."
-- Russia said the explosion caused a 16-fold spike in
radiation. From the BBC: "Readings for gamma radiation at
six testing stations in Severodvinsk, a city of 180,000
people, ranged from 4 to 16 times the normal rate of 0.11
microsieverts per hour," Russia's weather sevice said.
-- Donald Trump Jr. visited Indonesia to tout his
family's new resorts and defend his father. Stanley
Widianto and Joshua Partlow report: "'We have turned down
a lot of deals,' Trump Jr. said at a news conference in the
capital city of Jakarta. 'We made a very conscious decision
of the family not to do that right now.' The Trump
Organization has promised it would make no new foreign
deals during President Trump's time in office. Plans for the
two Indonesia resorts predate the Trump presidency but
appeared to have stalled in recent years. Trump Jr. called it
'nonsense' that the president's foreign policy might be
swayed by his business interests. `He wouldn't make
decisions that affect a country based on a real estate deal,'
Trump Jr. said of his father."
-- Pakistan movari to han sinola-iisa nlastio hails Page 12926
Anyone in the capital region of 1.5 million who uses,
sells or manufactures the bags will face a fine. Pamela
Constable reports: "The ban is the latest project in Prime
Minister Imran Khan's green initiative, which began last year
with a campaign to plant 10 billion trees to fight
deforestation. ... The fines in Pakistan will also be steep —
$31 for using a single bag, $63 for selling one and up to
$31,000 for manufacturing them. The national per capita
income is $1,200 per year. Shoppers are not likely to be
aggressively pursued, but companies that make and supply
the bags have been warned that they will be inspected to
enforce the ban."
-- In a bid to retain power, Venezuelan President
Nicolas Maduro is cracking down on his own military.
From the Times: "Top military leaders have repeatedly
declared their allegiance to the Maduro administration. But
over the past two years, as the oil-rich economy crumbled
and a majority of Venezuelans were left without sufficient
food and medicine, factions within the security forces have
staged at least five attempts to overthrow or assassinate the
president. The government claims to have foiled at least a
dozen more plots in that period ... Mr. Maduro's Socialist
Party is resorting to this siege mentality to justify ubiquitous
surveillance, arbitrary detentions and the torture of perceived
enemies, including those inside Venezuela's 160,000-strong
armed forces."
Trump wants 'full investigation' into Epstein's death
Page 12927
THE DOMESTIC AGENDA:
-- The Justice Department reassigned the warden of
the federal detention center where sex offender Jeffrey
Epstein died. Two staffers were placed on leave. From
Devlin Barrett, Matt Zapotosky and Aaron C. Davis: "The
move to transfer , who had only recently
begun working as the MCC's warden, came a day after
Attorney General William P. Barr decried `serious
irregularities' there and a `failure' to keep Epstein secure. ...
Barr appointed , who has been running a
federal prison in nearby Otisville, N.Y., as the facility's new
acting warden. The MCC is run by the Bureau of Prisons,
which is part of the Justice Department and falls under
Barr's authority. ... Epstein was being held in a special
housing unit of the MCC called Nine South and should have
been checked on by the staff every 30 minutes. But
correctional officers had not done so for `several' hours
before he was found by staff as they delivered breakfast to
inmates, a person familiar with the matter said ...
"To those who have worked in or around the MCC,
Epstein's death is viewed as a symptom of long-term
problems there and, more broadly, within the Bureau
of Prisons. Hood, a former chief of internal affairs
for the bureau, said the MCC has had longtime problems
with overcrowding and understaffing. But in recent years, he
said, the bureau has been afflicted by a lack of leadership,
with a significant number of senior positions filled by
temporary appointments. ... Sometimes, incompetence in
Page 12928
the building reaches alarming proportions, observers
said. In May 2017, for instance, a bank robber named David
Evangelista was accidentally released from the MCC, even
after he told staff he still had years left on his sentence ...
Still, the MCC is considered one of the safest and most
secure lockup in the federal system. When Joaquin
Archivaldo Guzman Loera, the drug kingpin better known as
`El Chapo,' was brought to New York, he was jailed there."
-- The two prison staff members who were
guarding Epstein fell asleep and failed to check on him
for three hours, per the Times, which adds that the
staffers — both working overtime — falsely recorded in a log
that they had checked on the financier every 30 minutes, as
was required. The paper notes that such false entries in an
official log could constitute a federal crime.
-- The news of Epstein's death was posted on 4chan
more than half an hour before it became public, leading
the New York City Fire Department to look into whether
an employee shared the details improperly. From
BuzzFeed News: "Almost 40 minutes before ABC News first
reported Epstein's death on Twitter, someone posted still-
unverified details on 4chan, the anonymous message board
popular with far-right trolls and white nationalists. ... After
publishing the post, other 4chan users egged on the author.
When they expressed doubt, the original poster added more
information to the discussion thread, including a detailed
breakdown of the procedures allegedly used to resuscitate
Epstein, which suggest the poster may have been a first
Page 12929
responder, medical worker, or otherwise privy to details
about efforts to resuscitate the disgraced financier. ... After
telling BuzzFeed News the post was `under review,' an
FDNY spokesperson said authorities `determined this
alleged information did not come from the Fire Department.-
-- Trump defended his promotion of the baseless
conspiracy theory  connecting the Clintons to Epstein's
death. John Wagner reports: Trump said he "retweeted a
'very highly respected conservative pundit' who is a `big
Trump fan.' On Saturday, Trump retweeted a message from
conservative actor and comedian Terrence K. Williams that
suggested former president Bill Clinton might have been
involved in the death of Epstein, the politically connected
financier who had been facing multiple charges of sex
trafficking involving underage girls. `He's a very highly
respected conservative pundit,' Trump told reporters in New
Jersey, referring to Williams. `He's a big Trump fan. That
was a retweet, that wasn't from me. That was from him, but
he's a man with half a million followers, a lot of followers.
And he's respected.-
-- England's Prince Andrew is facing fresh scrutiny for
his past friendship with Epstein. Adam Taylor and Karla
Adam report: "Buckingham Palace has never explained the
photograph. It shows a middle-aged Prince Andrew, Duke of
York, smiling with his arm around the bare waist of
, then 17, who claims she was later paid by Jeffrey
Epstein for sexual encounters with the prince. In the
background stands Ghislaine Maxwell, a British socialite
_
Page 12930
wno accusers say was Lipstein s ginmena ana maaam. i ne
photo was reportedly taken at Maxwell's London home in
2001. ... With Epstein now dead after a suspected suicide
Saturday and Maxwell apparently outside the reach of
investigators, hiding from the limelight she once embraced,
the Duke of York may be the highest-profile member of
Epstein's circle from the time of the allegations against him.
On Friday, newly unsealed legal documents from a
defamation suit brought against Maxwell resurfaced
old accusations and elaborated on the account of
inappropriate behavior. In the documents, , now
, says she was 'trafficked' to Andrew, with
whom she claims to have had three sexual encounters."
-- David Boies, the Democratic lawyer who once
worked for Al Gore but who has been criticized for the
methods he used to defend Theranos, will once again
confront Alan Dershowitz, the intellectual bulwark on
O.J. Simpson's defense team, in a separate legal fight
over Epstein's actions. From Tom Jackman, Deanna Paul
and Manuel Roig-Franzia: "In this long-running melodrama,
Boies and his partners at Boies Schiller Flexner represent
one of Epstein's accusers, — who
was a teenage locker-room attendant at President Trump's
Mar-a-Lago resort when she met Epstein. has
alleged that Epstein demanded that she have sex with him
repeatedly when she was underage and lent her for sex to
his friends, including Dershowitz. ... Dershowitz's effort to
counter the accusations has been made all the more
nettlesome because his long-ago representation of Epstein
Page 12931
has come under greater scrutiny following Epstein's arrest
last month. Dershowitz, an emeritus Harvard University law
professor, is also fending off a defamation suit filed by
set for key oral arguments next month, in which
Boies has become a vital player. Because Epstein's death
will end his criminal case, the defamation action
against Dershowitz could be one of the dwindling number of
cases that would allow for the full public airing of numerous
accusations against Epstein that his alleged victims have
long sought."
Trump 'tired' of taxpayers paying for immigrants
-- The "Send her back!" chant continues to reverberate
in Greenville, N.C., where Trump held a rally weeks
before the El Paso shootings. For some voters there,
the chant echoes as a prelude to murder. Griff Witte
reports: "Samar Badwan, a Greenville resident, watched that
day as 8,000 neighbors and fellow citizens jammed a local
basketball arena to serenade the president with chants of
`Send her back,' a response to Trump's insistence that a
Muslim, Somali American congresswoman should `go back'
to the land of her birth. Before that day, Badwan had
never had to question whether her hijab was incompatible
with her Southern drawl. She never had to fear that her
North Carolina neighbors might hold her Palestinian heritage
against her. She never had to think that in Greenville — a
city she has been proud to call home for 30 years, raising
three children along the way — her faith would mark her as
an unwanted outsider. Then the president came to town."
Page 12932
-- A little girl begged for her father's release after he
was captured during the ICE raids in Mississippi. A
week later, he's still detained. From CNN: "Andres
Gomez-Jorge is being held at the Adams County
Correctional Facility in Natchez, Mississippi. His family
spoke on the phone with him briefly Tuesday for the first
time since his arrest. The call came hours after CNN
published a story saying that the family didn't know his
whereabouts and feared for his well-being."
-- U.S. citizens are lining up for jobs in rural
Mississippi that have opened up because of the ICE
raids, which resulted in the arrest of hundreds of
immigrant workers. Jonnelle Marte reports: "In a state
where the poultry industry is one of the biggest drivers of the
economy, some of the job applicants said they hoped the
opportunities at Koch Foods, one of the meatpacking plants
targeted by the raids, would improve their finances in both
substantial and incremental ways. They arrived seeking a
steadier paycheck. A slightly higher wage. A more
accommodating schedule. ... Even as many of the job
hunters pondered the ways the chicken-processing jobs
might bring them more stability, many of the workers — who
were required to bring two forms of identification to the job
fair — said they sympathized with the [detained employees]
... Their sentiments challenge the narratives that typically
drive the immigration debate in the United States, pitting
undocumented workers against Americans seeking
opportunity."
Page 12933
-- D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser (D) said she will not
accept a federal government plan to house
unaccompanied migrant children in Washington. Fenit
Nirappil reports: "Bowser was reacting to an application from
Dynamic Service Solutions, a federal contractor, to open a
temporary shelter for children in the District. The company
has been advertising job listings for educators, caseworkers
and medical staff members to work with 'unaccompanied
alien' children in the nation's capital. ... The proposed facility
would house as many as 242 children, according to a
person familiar with the contractor's application to the city.
Some members of the D.C. Council said they were under
the impression that the shelter would be located on private
property in Takoma, a Northwest D.C. neighborhood near
the Maryland border."
-- A House panel with jurisdiction over firearms is
expected to return early from recess to vote on new
gun -control measures. "But there's one problem:
Democrats are privately sparring over what exactly to
approve," Rachael Bade and Paul Kane report. "House
Democrats universally agree on expanding background
checks, legislation they easily passed in February. They've
also coalesced around proposals restricting high-capacity
magazines, instituting `red flag' laws that keep guns from
individuals showing warning signs of violence, and
potentially even legislation on hate crimes — ideas the
House Judiciary Committee is expected to consider the
week of Labor Day, according to two people familiar with the
f. .11 ;,-.
Page 12934
pica vveen UCIUIC LI IC I Ull I IUUJC IJ Ul I iutaity ICUUICU LU
return. But there's still disagreement on whether the House
should advance legislation reinstating an assault weapons
ban that expired 15 years ago."
-- Gun-control groups are trying to build on the
momentum after El Paso and Dayton. Amy B Wang.
Tom Hamburger, Josh Dawsey and Marissa J. Lang repod:
'People are fed up. This keeps on happening,' Christian
Heyne, vice president of policy for the Brady Campaign to
Prevent Gun Violence. `The response to this from a small
few people in one body of our federal government of
Congress is the same. That's unbelievably frustrating.'
Simultaneously, the groups are emboldened by what they
see as a vacuum created by turmoil within the National Rifle
Association. (The NRA denies its influence is slipping and
has been talking directly to the president and others in the
White House.) Gun-control activists are also aware of - if
not completely reassured by — Trump's comments that he
would support expanded background checks."
-- FBI agents found 25 guns and 10,000 rounds of
ammunition in an Ohio teen's bedroom after he
threatened to assault a law enforcement officer. From
WGN-TV: "According to court documents, the user posted
a threat to assault federal law enforcement officers writing,
`shoot every agent on sight,' in a discussion about the
Branch Davidian standoff in Waco in 1993."
-- "It's been 5 years since a police officer killed my son,
Michael Brown. Nothing has changed." Lezley
Page 12935
McSpadden,  the chief executive and founder of the Michael
O.D. Brown Foundation, writes in an op-ed for The Post:
"For many young black and brown people, the police too
often feel like an occupying force in their neighborhoods
instead of a force for good. A new study of young adults
from the GenForward Survey at the University of Chicago
found that while most white young adults believe you can
trust the police 'always' or 'often' to do what is right, less
than a third of young African Americans believe the same.
Similarly, nearly half of African Americans ages 18 to 36 say
they 'always' or 'often' go out of their way to avoid contact
with the police or other law enforcement, compared with
slightly more than a quarter of white young adults."
-- The New York Times demoted its congressional
editor after he made problematic comments on Twitter.
Paul Farhi reports: "The editor, Jonathan Weisman, came
under fire for tweets questioning whether Reps. Rashida
Tlaib (D-Mich.) and Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) actually
represented the Midwest and whether Reps. Lloyd Doggett
(D-Tex.) and John Lewis (D-Ga.) represented the Deep
South, given that their districts are primarily urban and
heavily minority. Weisman said he was questioning whether
the districts truly reflected the broader politics of their
regions, which are predominantly white and more rural. He
deleted the tweets after they were roundly criticized as
racist. He later asked author and Times contributor Roxane
Gay for an `enormous apology' in an email after she called
him out for those tweets and for criticizing him for identifying
another conoresswoman as African American without Page 12936
mentioning that her primary challenger is also African
American. Gay posted Weisman's email to her and her
assistant and criticized him for his `audacity and entitlement'
for contacting her and her publisher to demand the apology.
A Times spokeswoman, Eileen Murphy, said Weisman had
apologized to Executive Editor Dean Baguet for `his recent
serious lapses in judgment,' but that he has been demoted
and will no longer edit the newspaper's coverage of
Congress. The Times didn't specify what Weisman's duties
will be. The paper also said he would no longer be active on
social media."
QUOTE OF THE DAY: "Give me your tired and your
poor who can stand on their own two feet and who
will not become a public charge," said Ken Cuccinelli,
the acting director of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration
Services, in a twist of Emma Lazarus's famous
words etched on the Statue of Liberty. Cuccinelli
added that "all immigrants who can stand on their own two
feet, self-sufficient, pull themselves up by their
bootstraps" would be welcome in the U.S. (Colby ltkowitz
and Felicia Sonmez)
Page 12937
SOCIAL MEDIA SPEED READ:
Stephen Colbert mocked Cuccinelli for his comments:
The New York mayor's office also responded to Cuccinelli's
words:
Trump lashed out at critics who he said are "blaming him"
for the crisis in Hong Kong:
The top House Republican expressed support for the
islanders:
So did the speaker:
South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg had a grim
conversation with a voter in Iowa:
Buttigieg also went down the giant slide:
After seeing a segment on Fox News, Trump endorsed Curt
Srhillinn'c nnccihip , nnnnnaccinnal narnnainn in Ari7nna• Page 12938
\OS,.   1.....4".•••••••• SOSO. I I
And Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) wished lefties
a happy day:
VIDEOS OF THE DAY:
Stephen Colbert joked that Trump is acting like a cartoon
villain:
Trevor Noah questioned Fox News host Tucker Carlson's
sudden vacation:
You received this email because you signed up for The Daily 202 or because it is included in your
subscription.
Manage my email newsletters and alerts I Unsubscribe from The Daily 202
Privacy Policy I Help
O2019 The Washington Post I 1301 K St NW, Washington DC 20071
Page 12939
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D53E169.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316D.1.8 69A.1
Message Path xmfTrasht5D53E169.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1 70316D.I.869A.I.xml
From The Washington Post
Display Name The Washmgon Post
Email emakkwashingtonpost.com
Reply To emaktwashingtonpost.com
Test The Washington Post
To The Washington Post
Subject The Daly 202: Clouds of economic uncenainty loom despite temporary reprieve from Tnstp on China tariffs
Scheduled date 2019-08-14 102334
Creation date 2019-08-14102334
Modified date 2019-08-14 115456
Delivered date 2019-08-14 1O24r42
Message she 60708
Attachments sin 348515
Total she 409234
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.lunt
Content ID
5D53E168.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000D2.1.2
D2F9.1(a/451D53E169.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
70316121.869A.1@l9.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.P30.0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline false
T1Pe fie
Size 131933
CA 653130962245bed7be597804e637124
Hash E321401 I 1739DF7B5EC92690C222CBCD277E5802 Oil I OF638CC5D007455F8DC63CFA21335
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D53E168.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.20000132.1.2
D2FA.1(%455D53E169.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.1001
703160.1.869A.1@19.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline false
Type fie
Size 2165132
CA 1969ea822406a1e39f8e80aa36069165
Hash BBAC0FDB729029FOAEE5A0102C52IBD6CC31AA35 0949A88360644F3BBF2BD89701053200
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 835B5E40-11C6-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient The Washington Post
Display Name The Washington Post
Email emaigwashirigtonpost.com
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read fake
Deleted true
Opened fake
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification sshen opened false
Return notification %%hen deleted false
Return notification sshen
completed fake
Return notification sshen declined fake
Return notification sshen
accepted false
Page 12940
Archive Version 5.3
Internal II) 5D53E I69.NYMDOM LNYMADM I. 100.170316D.1.8 69A. I ® I9.NYMDOM LNYMADM I. 100.01.0.1@i8
Source received
Class Public
Account ESTADMI.ESTDOMI
Location II) 1540843020946
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
II) 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.1.0.1®IS
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NoiSharcd
Page 12941
Audits
Dale Action Auditor Note
2019-08-19 13A323 EDT Orated
eteArchive Agent 2-Zero Day . Trashl.cn-Jobs.crrGWOpenNcde,cn-archnarrashi sn.jobstre.GwopenNode.cgrarchivii
gornetrnsil
Generated by Neursi a Inc. [en-Archive
Agent 2-Zcro Day
go-netmadi
2019-08-21 100801 EDT Exported neunadnetnunneunail Exported by netrnainetnunneumil
2019-09-07 18:12.92 EDT Exported netmainettnaineuttul Exported by netmad.netmailnetmail
2020.05491437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADNII.MXRDOM I Flagged
2020.05-19143838 EDT Tag BOP0I703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flogged
2021-054191441:6 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
2020-05-19153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
20204549 153531 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-191536.96 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-O5-19153636 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 12942
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 12943
From: The Washin ton Post <email@washingtonpost.com>
To:
Subject: The Daily 202: Clouds of economic uncertainty loom despite temporary reprieve from Trump on China tariffs
Sent: Wed. 14 Aug 2019 14:23:34 +0000
If you're having trouble reading this, click here.
Share: InListen to The Big Idea
Clouds of economic uncertainty loom despite
temporary reprieve from Trump on China tariffs
Trump says China tariffs delayed for 'Christmas season'
BY JAMES HOHMANN
with Mariana Allaro
THE BIG IDEA: If President Trump wanted to stabilize the listing
stock market, his Tuesday announcement  that he will temporarily
postpone the implementation of about half the tariffs on Chinese
imports that he announced 12 days earlier did the trick. But only
for the day. Companies whose supply chains depend on China, from
Apple and Best Buy to Mattel and Nike. saw their share prices edge up.
The fundamentals have not changed. In fact, they continue to
worsen. And stocks tumbled this morning  when the markets
opened. For the first time since 2007, the yields on short-term U.S.
bonds eclipsed those of long-term bonds. This phenomenon. called the
inverted yield curve. has preceded every recession in the past 50 years.
Bigger picture, the United States remains engaged in a trade war
with China, the world's second-largest economy, with no end in
sight. Trump's insistence that he still plans to impose all the previously
announced duties on Dec. 15 forces corporate chieftains to prepare for
more troubled waters ahead. Many analysts said the delay does nothing
to mitigate the ominous clouds of uncertainty that hang over the
economy. "Trade wars are good and easy to win," Trump said last year.
That was wrong.
Beyond the inverted yield curve, economists are pointing to a
litany of other early warning signs that indicate a recession looms,
despite the Federal Reserve's recent decision to cut interest rates.
There's already been a decline in business investment, and some
companies are pulling back on hiring.
Yesterday, Trump came closer than he has before to
acknowledging  that his tariffs on Chinese imports are really taxes
on American consumers. He's been falsely claiming that the Chinese
are paying the full price of his tariffs. "We are doing this for the
Christmas season, just in case some of the tariffs would have an impact
on U.S. consumers," the president told reporters, as he prepared to fly
to a speech in western Pennsylvania.
It's no coincidence that the products that got a carve-out from the
planned 10 percent tariff on $300 billion worth of imports are
consumer goods such as cellphones, laptops, strollers and
sneakers. Higher prices might have caused sticker shock over the
holidays. The prior tariffs, which have gone into effect, mostly
increased the price of component parts that companies use to assemble
something else. These new tariffs would hit finished goods such as
iPhones, which are assembled in China, making it more likely that the
higher costs are passed on to consumers.
President Trump speaks to contractors on Monday at the Shell Chemicals Petrochemical Complex in
Monaca, Pa. (Jeff Swensen/Getty Images)
Trump wants to win reelection, and he's sensitive to the markets.
The result has been a series of erratic policy announcements that
often appear to be improvisational and that cause whiplash for the
markets. It sometimes feels as if Trump is practicina the "madman
theory" in trade negotiations. Is he being crazy? Or crazy like a fox? For
example, how seriously are we to take it when Trump threatens, as he
did yesterday, to pull out of the World Trade Organization?
"It's complete manipulation," said Kenny Polcari of Butcher
Joseph Asset Management. "[Trump] threatens the market, by
surprise, two weeks ago. The markets re-price. Then he says, 'I think we
are going to delay those tariffs.' ... The [algorithms] respond
immediately and take the market higher," Polcari told my colleagues
Taylor Telford and Thomas Heath. "Of course the market is going to
rally!"
"We are all just one tweet away from significant volatility," RSM
chief economist Joe Brusuelas wrote in a note to his clients after
Trump's tariff postponement. "The idea that this is a major source of
relief to the economy is not tethered to empirical reality."
"We were relieved. But does that stop the volatility and instability?
No," said Jay Foreman, chief executive of the Florida-based toy
company Basic Fun. Foreman told the Associated Press yesterday
that he's still considering layoffs this fall to offset his higher costs and
noted that, despite Trump's reprieve, tariffs remain a severe threat.
"The climbdown over the China tariffs does not mean a trade deal
is now near, not least because China's authorities currently face a
much bigger problem, namely, the challenge to their legitimacy in
Hong Kong, and that will take precedence," wrote Pantheon
Macroeconomics chief economist Ian Shepherdson in a note to
investors that Tory Newmyer covered in this morning's Finance 202.
"But we can fully understand markets' relief at the lifting of the threat of
tariffs on consumer goods just ahead of the holiday shopping season."
Traders on on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange. (Richard Drew/AP)
-- U.S. businesses have begun taking down job listings because of
the uncertainty caused by the trade war: "Win Cramer had big plans
to hire several new employees this summer for his company, including a
chief operating officer, but he took the job listings down after Trump
tweeted that more tariffs would hit Chinese goods in September," our
economics correspondent Heather Long reported yesterday. "'It's the
most frustrating time I've ever had running a business, and I've been
doing this for 20 years,' said Cramer, chief executive of JLab Audio,
which makes wireless earbuds and headphones sold at Best Buy,
Target and elsewhere.
"The United States had 7.3 million job openings in June, down from
a peak of 7.6 million in November. ... While the decline is modest,
economists are concerned hiring could dry up quickly as companies see
no end in sight to Trump's trade war and they look to cut costs. The
reduction in job openings is also widespread across many industries,
signaling how cautious companies are becoming. A decrease in job
openings has tended to be a signal of economic trouble. ... Job
openings peaked in April 2007, for example, nine months before the
start of the Great Recession. Job openings in many industries have
declined since November, including the information sector, financial
services, transportation and warehousing, and hotels and food service,
suggesting wide concern about future growth. Actual hires also have
slowed this year, with average monthly job gains falling to 165,000 a
month, down from 223,000 a month last year."
-- "Uncertainty" is the buzzword that keeps coming up in notes
from Wall Street institutions to their clients that seem to become
gloomier with each passing day:
"Trade's simmer has begun to boil, business sentiment and capital
spending have softened further, global growth remains weak and
inflation expectations have fallen," Morgan Stanley's Ellen Zentner
wrote on Monday. "Heightened market volatility and increased news
flow on trade may soften consumer sentiment and spending."
Goldman Sachs said Sunday it does not expect a trade deal
between the U.S. and China before the 2020 election. "Fears that the
trade war will trigger a recession are growing," wrote Goldman's chief
U.S. economist, Jan Hatzius, explaining why growth projections are
being lowered. "Overall, we have increased our estimate of the growth
impact of the trade war. The drivers of this modest change are that we
now include an estimate of the sentiment and uncertainty effects ...
Relatedly, the business sentiment effect of increased pessimism about
the outlook from trade war news may lead firms to invest, hire, or
produce less."
Tugboats manuever a container ship last week at a port in eastern China's Shandong province. (Chinatopix
via AP)
"We are worried," Bank of America Merrill Lynch chief economist
Michelle Meyer wrote Friday. "We now have a number of early
indicators starting to signal heightened risk of recession. Our official
model has the probability of a recession over the next 12 months
only pegged at about 20 percent, but our subjective call based on
the slew of data and events leads us to believe it is closer to a 1-in-
3 chance. ... Three out of the five economic indicators (auto sales,
industrial production, and aggregate hours worked) which track the
business cycle closely are near levels consistent at the start of the
previous recessions."
More dark mood music:

• Inflation in the United States was slightly higher last month
than expected: The Labor Department announced yesterday that
the consumer price index rose 0.3 percent in July. That's modest but
was above analyst predictions.

• U.S. mortgage debt reached a record in the second quarter,
exceeding its 2008 peak as the financial crisis unfolded.
"Mortgage balances rose by $162 billion in the second quarter to
$9.406 trillion, surpassing the high of $9.294 trillion in the third
quarter of 2008, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York said
Tuesday," per the Wall Street Journal.

• China's economy is faltering: "The jobless rate in Chinese cities
again rebounded in July to its highest level since regular reporting
on the data began, as employers turned cautious," today's Journal
reports. "Other key economic readings for the month, including
factory production, consumption and property investment, came in
much lower than expected."

• Germany's economy shrank slightly last quarter. Europe's
biggest economy suffered from falling exports, and the auto industry
is struggling to adjust to new emissions standards, per the AP.
• The British economy also unexpectedly shrank, for the first
time since 2012, because of uncertainties surrounding Brexit.
-- Finally, some good news: We're hiring! I'm looking for an
ambitious reporter to help me write The Daily 202. This is a
demanding job that requires a news junkie and a creative thinker who is
skilled at connecting the dots about news developments in Washington,
around the country and the world. The ideal candidate will have a track
record of writing conceptual scoops in the political arena, examining key
developments in the White House, Congress or on the campaign trail in
a fresh and original light. That candidate should be able to identify key
themes and story lines from the slew of news that breaks on a daily
basis, and skillfully synthesize those events in a meaningful and
revelatory way for readers. This position is based in our Washington
newsroom. (Read the full job posting here.) Email me at
James.HohmannOwashpost.com if you have questions or ideas.
Subscribe on Amazon Echo Google Home, Apple HomePod and other podcast
players.
Welcome to the Daily 202, PowerPost's morning briefing for
decision-makers.
Sign up to receive the newsletter.
WHILE YOU WERE SLEEPING:
Rod Blagojevich, with his wife, Patti, at his side, speaks to reporters in Chicago before reporting to federal
prison in 2012. (M. Spencer Green/AP)
-- Trump appears to have backed away from what had been
imminent plans to commute the sentence of former Illinois
governor Rod Blagojevich in the face of massive Republican
blowback,  CNN reports: "Several Republican lawmakers called acting
White House chief of staff Mick Mulvaney and White House counsel Pat
Cipollone. At least two of them, Reps. Darin LaHood and Mike Bost,
made their case directly to the President on Thursday night, urging him
not to go forward. ... Another White House official said that while
Blagojevich's pardon seemed imminent late last week, there had been
no movement on the matter since Trump spoke with the two
congressmen. It appeared to be on ice, the official said, while offering
the caveat that Trump could change his mind and decide to move
forward.
"Multiple sources familiar with the calls said Trump and Mulvaney
both did not seem aware of the details of Blagojevich's case, even
though the president had decried the former governor as being treated
'unbelievably unfairly.' ... Trump's son-in-law and senior adviser Jared
Kushner had been funneling messages of support for Blagojevich's
commutation to the president ... Trump adviser and former New York
City Mayor Rudy Giuliani also made it clear to Trump that Blagojevich's
sentence was too harsh. Bernard Kerik, a former NYPD commissioner
who served time in prison on a tax fraud conviction and has been
advocating for Blagojevich, slammed the opposition."
Jeffress celebrates Freedom Sunday with his congregants in Dallas on June 30. (Ilana Panich-
Linsman for The Washington Post)
2020 WATCH:
-- Opinion columnist Elizabeth Bruenig went to her home state of
Texas for a deep dive into why Trump seems poised to fare even
better among evangelicals in 2020 than he did in 2016. Partly this is
because they are culture warriors and want to get another ally on the
Supreme Court, of course, but she concludes that it's also because "the
backlash against them has cemented so much of what they already
suspected about liberals' attitudes."
"Overall, American culture is hardly trending toward adherence to
evangelical beliefs, with approval of same-sex marriage steadily rising
among all religious groups (even evangelicals), religious affiliation
quickly dropping, and support for legal abortion lingering at all-time
highs," Bruenig writes in a thoughtful essay. "In some sense it seemed
that Trump is able, by being less Christian than your average
Christian, to protect Christians who fear incursions from a hostile
dominant culture. But that paradox also supplies a handy solution to
the question of whether Christians should direct their efforts to worldly
politics or turn inward, shunning political life for spiritual pursuits. By
voting for Trump — even over more identifiably Christian
candidates — evangelicals seem to have found a way to outsource
their fears and instead reserve a strictly spiritual space for
themselves inside politics without placing evangelical politicians
themselves in power. In that sense, they can be both active political
agents and a semi-cloistered religious minority, both of the world and
removed from it, advancing their values while retreating to their own
societies."
-- For a separate story, religion reporter Julie Zauzmer interviewed
more than 50 evangelical Christians in the battleground states of
Florida, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin: "In conversation, evangelical
voters paint the portrait of the Trump they see: a president who acts like
a bully but is fighting for them. A president who sees America like they
do, a menacing place where white Christians feel mocked and
threatened for their beliefs. A president who's against abortion and gay
rights and who has the economy humming to boot. ... The allegations
that Trump sexually assaulted numerous women are not a moral
concern, many Christians say. ... Opponents decry his attitude
toward people of color, his approach to immigrants detained at the
border, his answers to violence in American cities, and on and on.
But in Appleton, Wis., the Rev. Dennis Episcopo hasn't felt the
need as a religious leader to denounce any of it in front of his
congregation, which includes more than 5,000 attendees on a typical
Sunday. The megachurch that he has led for 22 years is almost entirely
white and conservative, like the lakeside region where it is located.
Episcopo has not seen any behavior from Trump in the past three years
that would prompt him to openly dissuade churchgoers from supporting
this president. 'There could be something, where society really crosses
the line on something, that I feel as a pastor I have to get up and say
something,' he muses. `But it hasn't happened yet.-
-- Former Colorado governor John Hickenlooper (D) is considering
ending his presidential bid to run for the Senate. From the New York
Times: "Hickenlooper, who is mired at the bottom of public polling of the
presidential race, hopped into Senator Michael Bennet's car on Friday
night in [Iowa] to discuss his impending decision. [They drove around
together for 20 minutes in Clear Lake before the Wing Ding dinner.] ...
Officials who have been in discussions with the Hickenlooper campaign
said Tuesday that the former two-term governor is giving serious
consideration to switching to the Senate race but stressed that a final
decision has not yet been made. Short of a massive change in political
momentum, Mr. Hickenlooper is certain to fail to qualify for the next
round of presidential debates in September, an additional blow to a
campaign struggling to attract attention and financial contributions....
"Recent days have brought unsubtle messages that high-ranking
Democratic officials in Colorado and Washington believe Mr.
Hickenlooper is in the wrong race. The Denver Post on Sunday
published polling done on behalf of 'a national Democratic group
involved in Senate races' that showed Mr. Hickenlooper holding a 51-
point lead over two other Democrats in the state's 2020 Senate race. On
Monday, the 314 Action Fund, a super PAC that backs candidates who
are scientists, announced a 'Draft Hick for Senate' campaign along with
a poll it commissioned showing Mr. Hickenlooper leading Senator Cory
Gardner, a Colorado Republican seeking re-election, by 13 percentage
points in a head-to-head matchup."
-- Beto O'Rourke, who returned to his hometown of El Paso after
the mass shooting there, may resume his 2020 campaign as early
as this week amid persistent calls for him to run for Senate
instead. Supporters of the former congressman want him to challenge
Sen. John Cornyn (R). (Politico)
-- Republican donors are being advised by allies of Mike Pompeo
to hold off on contributing to any of the current Senate candidates
in Kansas as the secretary of state weighs whether to run for the
open seat of retiring Sen. Pat Roberts. From Bloomberg News: "A
Pompeo ally has been advising potential contributors to wait until after
the secretary of state makes his decision ... The top U.S. diplomat and
former CIA director, who served as a congressman in Kansas's 4th
district from 2011-2017, has until June to enter the race."
-- Trump is trying to turn Joe Biden's gaffes into a major liability.
Matt Viser reports: "Over the last few days, Biden has made a string of
small missteps while campaigning during a crucial stretch in Iowa. ... He
has bungled oft-repeated lines, saying 'truth over facts' rather than truth
over lies. ... He spoke of meeting with Parkland students when he was
vice president, even though the Florida school shooting occurred a year
after he left office. ... On their own, none of these mistakes significantly
alter the race. ... Some say the gaffes pale in comparison to things
Trump says. ... That hasn't stopped Trump and his allies from seizing
on Biden's comments. ... On Friday, he said 'Joe is not playing with a
full deck' and that 'something's going wrong with him.-
-- Biden can learn a few lessons from Mitt Romney's 2012
presidential campaign, writes Dan Balz: "He continues to lead in the
polls, nationally and in early states. He has led those polls from the start
of the year to today. Still, he is treated as being in a precarious position,
a vulnerable candidate not at his best and a few mistakes away from a
real fall. Just like Romney through much of 2011. Romney was the
disrespected front-runner in the 2012 Republican field. He could be
awkward as a candidate and paid a price for it in the coverage of his
campaign. But as with Biden, he led in most — not all — surveys ahead
of the primaries and caucuses."
-- A new survey finds support for abortion rights remains steady,
despite a growing partisan divide. Ariana Eunjung Cha and Scott
Clement report: "No more than a quarter of residents in any state
supports a total ban despite the increasing political divide on the issue.
The Public Religion Research Institute survey released Tuesday
involves an extraordinarily large sample of 40,292 interviews measuring
abortion attitudes throughout 2018, allowing it to produce nuanced
results for individual states and for very small demographic groups. It
found that Americans remain generally supportive of abortion rights,
with 54 percent saying it should be legal in all or most cases and 40
percent saying it should be illegal."
A chaotic day in Hong Kong ends with specter of more violence to come
THE NEW WORLD ORDER:
-- The Hong Kong protest movement is facing a tipping point as
demonstrators seek the sympathy of the international community.
Gerry Shih and Timothy McLaughlin report: "After late-night mob scenes
marred a demonstration that paralyzed this city's airport, protesters on
Wednesday issued apologies seeking the international public's
sympathy and forgiveness as they fought to regain control over a
narrative that seemed to be tilting in Beijing's favor for the first time. The
appeals, which included apologies to the police force, come as the
struggle over public opinion reaches a climax. While Hong Kong's
protest movement has become steadily radicalized and fractured, the
Chinese government has sharply ramped up a propaganda effort in
state media and on social networks to discredit and deflate a movement
that to this point enjoyed wide support across Hong Kong society.
"Hong Kong's airport ground to a near-halt for a second day Tuesday
after protesters assailing police brutality and government indifference
occupied departure halls, sparking tense but largely peaceful
confrontations with frustrated passengers, many of them stranded. The
mood turned darker by nightfall after protesters seized two men —
one a reporter for Chinese state media, another they claimed to be
a Chinese government agent — and clashed with police and
paramedics who tried to evacuate the pair. At one point, protesters
surrounded and kicked a police van, sparking hand-to-hand clashes with
riot police who fired pepper spray near the departure terminal.
"On Wednesday, police warned that protesters arrested during the
terminal fracas could face life in prison. Seven men aged 17 to 28
years old were detained, five for unlawful assembly and two for
assaulting police officers and possession of offensive weapons, said
Mak Chin Ho, assistant police commissioner. ... Threats of such severe
punishment fit with an approach by Beijing, and its supporters in the
Hong Kong government, to dramatically raise the potential cost for
taking part in demonstrations."
-- China is threatening to use military -style force in Hong Kong,
hoping that threats alone will disperse protests, as students
plan to continue protesting once universities resume classes next
month. Anna Fifield reports: "That would take the protests
uncomfortably close to celebrations planned on Oct. 1 to mark the 70th
anniversary of the foundation of the People's Republic of China, which
was established with the goal of unifying greater China under the
leadership of the Communist Party. ... That concern, combined with
increasingly strident rhetoric from Chinese officials, has raised fears
about the possibility of military intervention in Hong Kong. This week,
state-affiliated media outlets tweeted ominous videos of Chinese tanks
carrying out exercises in Shenzhen, the southern Chinese city that
borders Hong Kong, while authorities in Beijing portrayed the protests
as 'terrorism.' China already stands accused of sending in thugs from
local gangs to try to deter the protesters in Hong Kong, and there are
growing concerns that it will send in the People's Armed Police, a
paramilitary force responsible for internal security and 'stability
maintenance.' Or perhaps even the People's Liberation Army."
How an eye patch became a symbol of the Hong Kong protests
-- Bloody eye patches have become the latest symbol of the Hong
Kong protests after a young woman was hit in the face with a
projectile that many protesters believe was fired by police. Katie
Mettler reports: "Authorities said at a news conference that there was no
proof to back up that claim. From the tension, a new rallying symbol was
born. 'Eye for an eye,' some protesters shouted as they continued their
sit-in ... Demonstrators also spray-painted `eye for an eye' throughout
the airport in Chinese and in English and covered their faces with mock
eye patches made of gauze. Some colored them red, to signify blood."
-- China asked the Trump administration to back off after U.S.
lawmakers, including Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and House
Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.), condemned the violence
against pro-democracy activists. From Reuters: "The United States
has denied Chinese suggestions that it has a hand in the unrest. But
China's foreign ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said the
lawmakers' comments have `provided new and powerful evidence to the
world.-
-- Meanwhile, Trump said the "thing" in Hong Kong — which he
called a "riot" last week — is "very tough" but stopped short of
criticizing China. From the Times: "In comments to reporters and in a
series of afternoon tweets, Mr. Trump took no strong position on the
demonstrations that have gripped Hong Kong for weeks and have
drawn an increasingly brutal response from local security forces. He
echoed none of the defenses of freedom and democracy coming
from both Democrats and Republicans. ... 'We'll see what happens.
But I'm sure it'll work out,' he said. He added: 'I hope it works out for
everybody, including China. I hope it works out peacefully. I hope
nobody gets hurt. I hope nobody gets killed.' The president later tweeted
that intelligence reports indicated that China's government 'is moving
troops to the Border with Hong Kong.-
Mitch McConnell walks to his Senate office earlier this year. (Salwan Georges/The Washington Post)
-- Follow the money: Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-
Ky.) had quarterbacked the effort on Capitol Hill to lift sanctions on
Russia's largest aluminum producer, a company that soon
afterward backed the creation of the first new aluminum -rolling mill
in the U.S. in nearly four decades — built in McConnell's home
state. Tom Hamburger and Rosalind S. Helderman report: "In January,
as the Senate debated whether to permit the Trump administration to lift
sanctions on Russia's largest aluminum producer, two men with millions
of dollars riding on the outcome met for dinner at a restaurant in Zurich.
On one side of the table sat the head of sales for Rusal, the Russian
aluminum producer that would benefit most immediately from a
favorable Senate vote. ... On the other side sat Craig Bouchard, an
American entrepreneur who had gained favor with officials in Kentucky
... By the next day, McConnell had successfully blocked the bill, despite
the defection of 11 Republicans.
"Within weeks, the U.S. government had formally lifted sanctions on
Rusal, citing a deal with the company that reduced the ownership
interest of its Kremlin-linked founder, Oleg Deripaska. And three months
later, Rusal announced plans for an extraordinary partnership with
Bouchard's company, providing $200 million in capital to buy a 40
percent stake in the new aluminum plant in Ashland, Ky. — a project
heralded by Gov. Matt Bevin (R) 'as significant as any economic deal
ever made in the history of Kentucky.' A spokesman for McConnell
said the majority leader did not know that Bouchard had hopes of a
deal with Rusal at the time McConnell led the Senate effort to end
the sanctions. ... Democratic senators have called for a
government review of the deal, prompting a Rusal executive in
Moscow last week to threaten to pull out of the investment."
-- Russian villagers were told to leave their town following a
missile test explosion. Will Englund reports: "It took most of Tuesday
for officials to realize how damaging this looked given the nuclear
materials involved in the accident. Arkhangelsk Gov. Igor Orlov insisted
it wasn't an evacuation but a `routine measure.' ... About 450 people are
said to live in the village, which abuts a military testing range. ... A
resident of Nyonoksa told ArkhangelskOnline that the village has been
evacuated before, presumably because of the hazards of tests or other
military activity nearby. ... Local officials conducted a study of soil, sand,
river and seawater samples from several points in the region and
reported no excess levels of radiation, according to media reports."
-- Russia said the explosion caused a 16-fold spike in
radiation. From the BBC: "Readings for gamma radiation at six testing
stations in Severodvinsk, a city of 180,000 people, ranged from 4 to 16
times the normal rate of 0.11 microsieverts per hour," Russia's weather
sevice said.
-- Donald Trump Jr. visited Indonesia to tout his family's new
resorts and defend his father. Stanley Widianto and Joshua Partlow
report: "'We have turned down a lot of deals,' Trump Jr. said at a news
conference in the capital city of Jakarta. 'We made a very conscious
decision of the family not to do that right now.' The Trump Organization
has promised it would make no new foreign deals during President
Trump's time in office. Plans for the two Indonesia resorts predate the
Trump presidency but appeared to have stalled in recent years. Trump
Jr. called it 'nonsense' that the president's foreign policy might be
swayed by his business interests. 'He wouldn't make decisions that
affect a country based on a real estate deal,' Trump Jr. said of his
father. 1.1
-- Pakistan moved to ban single -use plastic bags. Anyone in the
capital region of 1.5 million who uses, sells or manufactures the
bags will face a fine. Pamela Constable reports: "The ban is the latest
project in Prime Minister Imran Khan's green initiative, which began last
year with a campaign to plant 10 billion trees to fight deforestation....
The fines in Pakistan will also be steep — $31 for using a single bag,
$63 for selling one and up to $31,000 for manufacturing them. The
national per capita income is $1,200 per year. Shoppers are not likely to
be aggressively pursued, but companies that make and supply the bags
have been warned that they will be inspected to enforce the ban."
-- In a bid to retain power, Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro is
cracking down on his own military. From the Times: "Top military
leaders have repeatedly declared their allegiance to the Maduro
administration. But over the past two years, as the oil-rich economy
crumbled and a majority of Venezuelans were left without sufficient food
and medicine, factions within the security forces have staged at least
five attempts to overthrow or assassinate the president. The
government claims to have foiled at least a dozen more plots in that
period ... Mr. Maduro's Socialist Party is resorting to this siege mentality
to justify ubiquitous surveillance, arbitrary detentions and the torture of
perceived enemies, including those inside Venezuela's 160,000-strong
armed forces."
Trump wants 'full investigation' into Epstein's death
THE DOMESTIC AGENDA:
-- The Justice Department reassigned the warden of the federal
detention center where sex offender Jeffrey Epstein died. Two
staffers were placed on leave. From Devlin Barrett, Matt Zapotosky
and Aaron C. Davis: "The move to transfer , who had
only recently begun working as the MCC's warden, came a day after
Attorney General William P. Barr decried 'serious irregularities' there
and a 'failure' to keep Epstein secure. ... Barr appointed
, who has been running a federal prison in nearby Otisville,
N.Y., as the facility's new acting warden. The MCC is run by the Bureau
of Prisons, which is part of the Justice Department and falls under Barr's
authority. ... Epstein was being held in a special housing unit of the
MCC called Nine South and should have been checked on by the staff
every 30 minutes. But correctional officers had not done so for 'several'
hours before he was found by staff as they delivered breakfast to
inmates, a person familiar with the matter said ...
"To those who have worked in or around the MCC, Epstein's death
is viewed as a symptom of long-term problems there and, more
broadly, within the Bureau of Prisons. Hood, a former chief of
internal affairs for the bureau, said the MCC has had longtime problems
with overcrowding and understaffing. But in recent years, he said, the
bureau has been afflicted by a lack of leadership, with a significant
number of senior positions filled by temporary appointments....
Sometimes, incompetence in the building reaches alarming
proportions, observers said. In May 2017, for instance, a bank robber
named David Evangelista was accidentally released from the MCC,
even after he told staff he still had years left on his sentence ...Still, the
MCC is considered one of the safest and most secure lockup in the
federal system. When Joaquin Archivaldo Guzman Loera, the drug
kingpin better known as 'El Chapo,' was brought to New York, he was
jailed there."
-- The two prison staff members who were guarding Epstein fell
asleep and failed to check on him for three hours, per the Times,
which adds that the staffers — both working overtime — falsely
recorded in a log that they had checked on the financier every 30
minutes, as was required. The paper notes that such false entries in an
official log could constitute a federal crime.
-- The news of Epstein's death was posted on 4chan more than half
an hour before it became public, leading the New York City Fire
Department to look into whether an employee shared the details
improperly. From BuzzFeed News: "Almost 40 minutes before ABC
News first reported Epstein's death on Twitter, someone posted still-
unverified details on 4chan, the anonymous message board popular
with far-right trolls and white nationalists. ... After publishing the post,
other 4chan users egged on the author. When they expressed doubt,
the original poster added more information to the discussion thread,
including a detailed breakdown of the procedures allegedly used to
resuscitate Epstein, which suggest the poster may have been a first
responder, medical worker, or otherwise privy to details about efforts to
resuscitate the disgraced financier. ... After telling BuzzFeed News the
post was `under review,' an FDNY spokesperson said authorities
`determined this alleged information did not come from the Fire
Department.-
-- Trump defended his promotion of the baseless conspiracy
theory connecting the Clintons to Epstein's death. John Wagner
reports: Trump said he "retweeted a 'very highly respected conservative
pundit' who is a `big Trump fan.' On Saturday, Trump retweeted a
message from conservative actor and comedian Terrence K. Williams
that suggested former president Bill Clinton might have been involved in
the death of Epstein, the politically connected financier who had been
facing multiple charges of sex trafficking involving underage girls. 'He's
a very highly respected conservative pundit,' Trump told reporters in
New Jersey, referring to Williams. 'He's a big Trump fan. That was a
retweet, that wasn't from me. That was from him, but he's a man with
half a million followers, a lot of followers. And he's respected.-
-- England's Prince Andrew is facing fresh scrutiny for his past
friendship with Epstein. Adam Taylor and Karla Adam report:
"Buckingham Palace has never explained the photograph. It shows a
middle-aged Prince Andrew, Duke of York, smiling with his arm around
the bare waist of , then 17, who claims she was later
paid by Jeffrey Epstein for sexual encounters with the prince. In the
background stands Ghislaine Maxwell, a British socialite who accusers
say was Epstein's girlfriend and madam. The photo was reportedly
taken at Maxwell's London home in 2001. ... With Epstein now dead
after a suspected suicide Saturday and Maxwell apparently outside the
reach of investigators, hiding from the limelight she once embraced, the
Duke of York may be the highest-profile member of Epstein's circle from
the time of the allegations against him. On Friday, newly unsealed legal
documents from a defamation suit brought against Maxwell
resurfaced old accusations and elaborated on the account of
inappropriate behavior. In the documents, , now
says she was `trafficked' to Andrew, with whom she claims to have had
three sexual encounters."
-- David Boies, the Democratic lawyer who once worked for Al Gore
but who has been criticized for the methods he used to defend
Theranos, will once again confront Alan Dershowitz, the
intellectual bulwark on O.J. Simpson's defense team, in a separate
legal fight over Epstein's actions. From Tom Jackman, Deanna Paul
and Manuel Roig-Franzia: "In this long-running melodrama, Boies and
his partners at Boies Schiller Flexner represent one of Epstein's
accusers, — who was a teenage locker-room
attendant at President Trump's Mar-a-Lago resort when she met
Epstein. has alleged that Epstein demanded that she have sex
with him repeatedly when she was underage and lent her for sex to his
friends, including Dershowitz. Dershowitz's effort to counter the
accusations has been made all the more nettlesome because his long-
ago representation of Epstein has come under greater scrutiny following
Epstein's arrest last month. Dershowitz, an emeritus Harvard University
law professor, is also fending off a defamation suit filed by , set
for key oral arguments next month, in which Boies has become a vital
player. Because Epstein's death will end his criminal case, the
defamation action against Dershowitz could be one of the dwindling
number of cases that would allow for the full public airing of numerous
accusations against Epstein that his alleged victims have long sought."
Trump 'tired' of taxpayers paying for immigrants
-- The "Send her back!" chant continues to reverberate in
Greenville, N.C., where Trump held a rally weeks before the El Paso
shootings. For some voters there, the chant echoes as a prelude to
murder. Griff Witte reports: "Samar Badwan, a Greenville resident,
watched that day as 8,000 neighbors and fellow citizens jammed a local
basketball arena to serenade the president with chants of 'Send her
back,' a response to Trump's insistence that a Muslim, Somali American
congresswoman should 'go back' to the land of her birth. ... Before that
day, Badwan had never had to question whether her hijab was
incompatible with her Southern drawl. She never had to fear that her
North Carolina neighbors might hold her Palestinian heritage against
her. She never had to think that in Greenville — a city she has been
proud to call home for 30 years, raising three children along the way —
her faith would mark her as an unwanted outsider. Then the president
came to town."
-- A little girl begged for her father's release after he was captured
during the ICE raids in Mississippi. A week later, he's still detained.
From CNN: "Andres Gomez-Jorge is being held at the Adams County
Correctional Facility in Natchez, Mississippi. His family spoke on the
phone with him briefly Tuesday for the first time since his arrest. The call
came hours after CNN published a story saying that the family didn't
know his whereabouts and feared for his well-being."
-- U.S. citizens are lining up for jobs in rural Mississippi that have
opened up because of the ICE raids, which resulted in the arrest of
hundreds of immigrant workers. Jonnelle Marte reports: "In a state
where the poultry industry is one of the biggest drivers of the economy,
some of the job applicants said they hoped the opportunities at Koch
Foods, one of the meatpacking plants targeted by the raids, would
improve their finances in both substantial and incremental ways. They
arrived seeking a steadier paycheck. A slightly higher wage. A more
accommodating schedule. ... Even as many of the job hunters pondered
the ways the chicken-processing jobs might bring them more stability,
many of the workers — who were required to bring two forms of
identification to the job fair — said they sympathized with the [detained
employees] ... Their sentiments challenge the narratives that typically
drive the immigration debate in the United States, pitting undocumented
workers against Americans seeking opportunity."
-- D.C. Mayor Muriel Bowser (D) said she will not accept a federal
government plan to house unaccompanied migrant children in
Washington. Fenit Nirappil reports: "Bowser was reacting to an
application from Dynamic Service Solutions, a federal contractor, to
open a temporary shelter for children in the District. The company has
been advertising job listings for educators, caseworkers and medical
staff members to work with 'unaccompanied alien' children in the
nation's capital. ... The proposed facility would house as many as 242
children, according to a person familiar with the contractor's application
to the city. Some members of the D.C. Council said they were under the
impression that the shelter would be located on private property in
Takoma, a Northwest D.C. neighborhood near the Maryland border."
-- A House panel with jurisdiction over firearms is expected to
return early from recess to vote on new gun-control measures. "But
there's one problem: Democrats are privately sparring over what
exactly to approve," Rachael Bade and Paul Kane report. "House
Democrats universally agree on expanding background checks,
legislation they easily passed in February. They've also coalesced
around proposals restricting high-capacity magazines, instituting 'red
flag' laws that keep guns from individuals showing warning signs of
violence, and potentially even legislation on hate crimes — ideas the
House Judiciary Committee is expected to consider the week of Labor
Day, according to two people familiar with the plan, a week before the
full House is officially scheduled to return. But there's still disagreement
on whether the House should advance legislation reinstating an assault
weapons ban that expired 15 years ago."
-- Gun-control groups are trying to build on the momentum after El
Paso and Dayton. Amy B Wang, Tom Hamburger, Josh Dawsey and
Marissa J. Lang report: - People are fed up. This keeps on happening,'
Christian Heyne, vice president of policy for the Brady Campaign to
Prevent Gun Violence. `The response to this from a small few people in
one body of our federal government of Congress is the same. That's
unbelievably frustrating.' Simultaneously, the groups are emboldened by
what they see as a vacuum created by turmoil within the National Rifle
Association. (The NRA denies its influence is slipping and has been
talking directly to the president and others in the White House.) Gun-
control activists are also aware of - if not completely reassured by —
Trump's comments that he would support expanded background
checks."
-- FBI agents found 25 guns and 10,000 rounds of ammunition in an
Ohio teen's bedroom after he threatened to assault a law
enforcement officer. From WGN-TV: "According to court documents,
the user posted a threat to assault federal law enforcement officers
writing, 'shoot every agent on sight,' in a discussion about the Branch
Davidian standoff in Waco in 1993."
-- "It's been 5 years since a police officer killed my son, Michael
Brown. Nothing has changed." Lezley McSpadden, the chief
executive and founder of the Michael O.D. Brown Foundation, writes in
an op-ed for The Post: "For many young black and brown people, the
police too often feel like an occupying force in their neighborhoods
instead of a force for good. A new study of young adults from the
GenForward Survey at the University of Chicago found that while most
white young adults believe you can trust the police 'always' or 'often' to
do what is right, less than a third of young African Americans believe the
same. Similarly, nearly half of African Americans ages 18 to 36 say they
'always' or 'often' go out of their way to avoid contact with the police or
other law enforcement, compared with slightly more than a quarter of
white young adults."
-- The New York Times demoted its congressional editor after he
made problematic comments on Twitter. Paul Farhi reports: "The
editor, Jonathan Weisman, came under fire for tweets questioning
whether Reps. Rashida Tlaib (D-Mich.) and Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.)
actually represented the Midwest and whether Reps. Lloyd Doggett (D-
Tex.) and John Lewis (D-Ga.) represented the Deep South, given that
their districts are primarily urban and heavily minority. Weisman said he
was questioning whether the districts truly reflected the broader politics
of their regions, which are predominantly white and more rural. He
deleted the tweets after they were roundly criticized as racist. He later
asked author and Times contributor Roxane Gay for an 'enormous
apology' in an email after she called him out for those tweets and for
criticizing him for identifying another congresswoman as African
American without mentioning that her primary challenger is also African
American. Gay posted Weisman's email to her and her assistant and
criticized him for his 'audacity and entitlement' for contacting her and her
publisher to demand the apology. A Times spokeswoman, Eileen
Murphy. said Weisman had apologized to Executive Editor Dean Baguet
for 'his recent serious lapses in judgment.' but that he has been
demoted and will no longer edit the newspaper's coverage of Congress.
The Times didn't specify what Weisman's duties will be. The paper also
said he would no longer be active on social media."
QUOTE OF THE DAY: "Give me your tired and your poor who can
stand on their own two feet and who will not become a public
charge," said Ken Cuccinelli, the acting director of U.S. Citizenship
and Immigration Services, in a twist of Emma Lazarus's famous
words etched on the Statue of Liberty. Cuccinelli added that "all
immigrants who can stand on their own two feet, self-sufficient, pull
themselves up by their bootstraps" would be welcome in the U.S. (Colby
ltkowitz and Felicia Sonmez)
SOCIAL MEDIA SPEED READ:
Stephen Colbert mocked Cuccinelli for his comments:
The New York mayor's office also responded to Cuccinelli's words:
Trump lashed out at critics who he said are "blaming him" for the crisis
in Hong Kong:
The top House Republican expressed support for the islanders:
So did the speaker:
South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg had a grim conversation with a
voter in Iowa:
Buttigieg also went down the giant slide:
After seeing a segment on Fox News, Trump endorsed Curt Schilling's
possible congressional campaign in Arizona:
And Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) wished lefties a happy
day:
VIDEOS OF THE DAY:
Stephen Colbert joked that Trump is acting like a cartoon villain:
Trevor Noah questioned Fox News host Tucker Carlson's sudden
vacation:
You received this email because you signed up for The Daily 202 or because it is included in your subscription.
Manage my email newsletters and alerts I Unsubscribe from The Daily 202
Privacy Policy I Help
©2019 The Washington Post I 1301 K St NW, Washington DC 20071
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/19 09:25
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Can you please have him seen for his request fo I understand he has not expressed
any concerns in the past, but he is facing the death penalty and is currently in SHU facing
disciplinary charges. Thanks!
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
f.
pi=
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
he found a dead rodent in his bed. Apparently he accident) smothered it while slee in . The li hts in
the cell are fre uentl off durin the da and on at ni ht.
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[P1 [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
nrnhihited If vim ciicriert that veil have received thic rnmmliniratinn in prrnr Monaco nntifv iic immediately hv
Page 12971
• r / •
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Barket;
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
15. 2019 3:48 PM
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if ou are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/2019 11:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
Page 12972
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the closing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
-M
Barket Epstein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) a(a> wrote:
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket
Sent: Frida Jul 12, 2019 3:22 PM
To: USANYS
Cc:
ton ricco >• Aida Leisenrin
>;
>:
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Page 12973
Jason,
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden City, NY 11530
- O
-M
Barket Eostein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
(USANYS)
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal As a result, the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to , and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket < >;
Cc: tonyricco ( >; Aida Leisenring
>;
(USANYS < >-
>;
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
Page 12974
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitin,tinnc cnari,littc olcn tArmitarl 7 kniirt Airlo ,nri I warn I i wins in tk,t tAfitt
Page 12975
1541.1VIIJ gAIJUe 1O,41V...4 e- IIV VI J. 4- 1144 41 14 I Tn..
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[P1 IF]
www.barketepstein.com.
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
message and all its attachments
Page 12976
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D318a2.NYMDOMENYMADMI.100.170316D.1.6 512.1
Message Path xmleMatox/51)318C82.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100.170310.1.65121.)mil
From
Display Name
Email
UUI D 2750CADO•09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tartagione
Scheduled date 2019-O7-19092522
Creation date 201947-19092522
Modified date 2019-07-19 113031
Delis e red date 2019-07-19092523
Message size 14870
Attachments silt 31284
Total size 46165
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D318C81NYMDOMINYMADMI.200.20000A0.I.I
45723.1®45D318O32.NYMDOMILNYMADMI. MO.
1703160.1.6512.1@i 17.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type tie
Size 31284
Date 2019-07-190525:15
CA I2520d54f68963bS72777I5d2cOd939b
Hash 9FAC47EF889C8DABIDACAD5E2F8199ECOCMCB8E F30882A456598418&5129251A21921O
Recipients 5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UllII) 835135E40- I IC6-0000433D6TE66A7708950
Distribution Type CC
Recipient 'I ype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID A44231 D0.082-1-0000-B58A-448148E79444
Distribution lype TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
HAD 43FDB0000C00-O000-8B6E-IB003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
t l ID 6FECI5F0-2503-0300-8293-9€01000038CF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 51C1- I IC0-09O40000-BBEI-7C3A8759762I
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Page 12977
Read true
Deleted false
Opened hue
Completed fake
Secure() Normal
Box type Intros
Return notification alien opened false
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed false
Return notification alien declined false
Return notification alien
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D318C22.NYMDOMLNYMADMIA00.170316D.1.6 5I2. I 031:7.NYMDOM LNYMADMI.100.0.1.0. I®16
Source received
Class Public
Account
Location ID
uOMI
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder MaBbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share 'Ewe NotSharcd
Page 12978
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08.01172630 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Archive)
Job.cn-lcbs.cn-GWOpenNodetn-archivingdAgcni-
ictmai
Generated by Netinail Inc. [crrArchive
I -DallY ArchiveIJohen-Jobs.en-GWOpenNocle.en-areliving,o
-netrnail]
2019-08.210933:I5 EDT Expand netniainetmaanetnviii Exported by netmainetrnainetmaa
2119-08-21093&39 EDT Exported netmainetmaineonol Exported by netnraitnettrail.neorrail
201948-21 093802 EDT Exported neunainetinail Alio:id Exported by neuminetmainctmail
2019-08-21 133258 EDT Exported neunai.netinailnclinaii Exported by netmainetmaiLnettnail
2019.094718:1104 EDT Exported neumineunaanetinail Exported by neunainettniancomil
2120-05-19153531 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
212005.1914x4156 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12979
Updated Timeline-Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
2019/08/10 17:35
Updated Timeline-Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-
054_1
TEXT.htm, Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Please see the attached.
Thank you
Page 12980
Properties
Properts Value
Nlessagell) 5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1326C35.1.B DD9.1
Message Path mnFiraslY5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1 326C35.I.BDD9.1.xml
From
Displas Name
Email
El II) 9D77B2D0.19C1-0000-A989-0200000058D0
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Updated Mackie -Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054_I
Scheduled date 2019-08-10 173534
Creation date 2019-08.10173534
Modified date 2019-08.1307:1391
Delivered date 2019-08-10 173535
Message situ 39
Attachments slit 15171
Total sift 15221
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.Iim
Name TEXT.Itm
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200003&1.9
E92E.1®455D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
326C35.1.BDD9.1@l9.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.103. 0.1.0.1®18
Is Inline fake
T)Pe file
Size 195
Date 2019-08.10133527
CA 015dedbbfca626b4d01855195395e43a
Hash 8BFD525778E713EA2A693564A702F79093B2DFCB5 F5F31E372D51535EB222F155C7E8G81 x
Attachment Epsteit. Jeffrey FAwawl. Reg. No. 73618-054_I.docx
Name EfiSICit Jeffrey Edward-Reg. No. 73618-054_1.dccx
Content II)
5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.2000038.1.9
E92F.1®455D4E0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
326C35.1.BDD9.1@l9.NYMDOMI.NYMADMIICO. 0.1.0.1®18
Is Inline fake
Tspe li}
Site 14976
Date 2019-08.10133431
CA 71807ef4T7b9c5b9709e55735fal2325
Hash CDFB9C5A667C8DAC0061A1742306DFC36065F821 565F62D6AC0B72B5FAIFFDEDFB99D819
Recipients I
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
EU II) 4237CDC0-1407-0000-A82O84D21Np84D2
Distribution 'ttype TO
Recipient 'ttype SystemGroup
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted true
Opened true
Completed fake
Stencils Normal
Box two Inbox
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification when
accepted fake
Archis e X'e rt ion 5.3
Internal ID 5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1326C35.113 DD9.1®19.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l8
Source received
Page 12981
Class Pubic
Account FAIADMI.FAIDOMI
Location II) 1540843105474
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Trash
II) 9.NYMDOMLNYMADIS41.100.0.1.0 1 ®I8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System tux
Share Type NoiShared
Page 12982
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-18 02300 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent 1-Daily Trash3
Jobcn-Jobscn-GCV0penNede.en-archivisgoith
=neimai
Generated by Netmai Inc. iciAreltive
I-Daily Trash3 Agenta l jobs.cn=GwopenNodeswarchiviigio
=wined]
2019-08-21 094335 EDT Exported mune i.netrna d. nettnai Exported by netnraa newly d. neurstil
2019-08-211413732 EDT Exported nonteincenhincinui Expected by netnuil netma IL mime
2019-08-211425:13 EDT Exported nemea it netnta normal Exported by netmail mint 0 nennail
2019-08-220227:10 EDT Exported is:Intel i went it neunai Expected by mom a retina a nenna0
2019-09-16 1542:35 EDT Expected mune ineund itnetmai Exported by neuna 0 wawa il mimed
20120-05-1915:17135 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-0619152839 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020.0549 143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 12983
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Page 12984
Suicide Timeline re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Friday, August 9, 2019
8:00 am inmate Reyes Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 departs for court
(WAB-USMS-SDNY) . Reyes is Epstein's cellmate.
8:30 am inmate Epstein arrives in Attorney Conference. He is
visited by several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 pm inmate Epstein departs attorney conference and returns to
SHU
7:00 pm inmate Epstein provided a social call by IDO. IDO reports
inmate Epstein was in good spirits, nothing unusual.
7:32 am PIO notified of incident by the Warden
***Inmate Reyes is released from court and does not return to the
institution.
Saturday, August 10, 2019
6:33 am body alarm activated in SHU. Staff found inmate Epstein
unresponsive in cell. Staff reported to bedside of inmate and
attempted to wake him. Control announced medical emergency. CPR
initiated
6:35 am medical staff (on duty PA) on site, CPR already in
progress medical staff continues CPR and AED applied on inmate.
Control called for ambulance
6:40 am , AW notified
6:45 am EMS arrives, paramedics continue CPR. Inmate Epstein
remains unresponsive. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three
rounds of Epinephrine, IV access started, IC) initiated. No pulse
found, no shock advised, inmate prepared for transport to local
hospital.
7:10 am EMS departs institution enroute to Beekman Hospital.
7:19 am USMS notified of incident.
7:20 am SIS Lt notified.
7:30 am , Warden arrives at institution. , AW
notified.
7:36 am official time of death reported by ER physician.
7:40 am Acting Chief Psychologist notified.
8:00 am and Captain arrive at institution.
8:10 am SIS Lt arrives at institution.
8:10 am CMC and SCSS notified.
8:34 am FBI notified.
9:00 am AUSA notified.
9:00 am arrives at institution.
9:00 am SIS Lt. reports to SHU. Interviews will be conducted with
inmates assigned to tier.
9:15 am CMC arrives at institution.
9:30 am Acting Chief Psychologist arrived to the institution.
9:50 am SCSS arrives at institution.
9:55 am CMC and IDO depart institution enroute to Beekman
Hospital.
10:00 am CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital, fingerprints and
photographs taken of inmate Epstein. Inmate clothing secured and
brought back to institution.
10:00 am Judge Berman notified.
10:15 am CMC return to institution.
10:45 am PIO arrived to the institution.
11:00 am next of kin (brother) notified by Case Management
Coordinator.
11:12 am press release is released to media.
11:15 am press release provided to Judge Berman.
11:15 am CST activated.
12:15 pm body release to Medical Examiner (ME) for autopsy
12:19 pm FBI arrives.
1:35 pm FBI arrives in Special Housing Unit.
1:40 pm OIG notified by the Warden and they will be sending an
Agent to NYM.
2:15 pm CST debrief conducted.
2:45 pm OIG arrived in Special Housing Unit (SHU) .
3:45 pm OIG and FBI departed from SHU.
5:05 pm OIG/FBI departed MCC New York.
Updated Timeline -Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
From
To
Date 2019/08/10 17:35
Subject: Updated Timeline-Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Please see the attached.
Thank you
Page 12987
Properties
Propertj Value
NlessagelD 5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.6 0E7A. I
Message Path xmliMabox/5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.60E7A.lang
From
Calvin) Name
Email
Ut. ID 9D77B2D049C1-0000-A9894200000058D0
Reply To
Text
To Sta
Subject Updated Taneline-Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Scheduled date 2019-08-10173534
Creation date 2019-08.10173534
Modified date 2019-08.16203209
Delis e red date 2019-08.10 173535
Message size 39
Attachments size 15171
Total size 15221
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.Iim
Name TEXT.Ishn
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.200003&I.9
E92E-1®455D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
696E30.1.60E7A.I@II.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.01()16
Is 'Idiot false
T,P9 Me
Silt 195
Date 2019-08-10133527
CA d79723133c0.24161ad9bdc 13528462519
(lash 88FD52.5778E7BEA2A693564A702F79093B2DFCB5 F5E31E372D5I535EB2221:155C7E8C818
Attachment Epstel. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054_ I.docx
Name Epsteit. Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 I.docx
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000038.1.9
E92F.1(4455D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
696E30.1.60E7A.1®1:7.NYMOOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.01@l6
Is !aline false
Type He
Size 14976
Date 2019-08.10133431
CA 85d159d829a0cab9641,028028416%58
Hash CDF139C5A667C8DAC0061A1742306DFC36065F82I 565F62D6ACOB72B5FAIITDEDEB99D819
Recipients 8
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CABODO-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S . tem(' tuber
Recipient
Displaj Name
Email
li U ID 835B5E40-I1C6-0000-B3D6FF-66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S mGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB000-0O0C-0000.8B6E-IB003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S •k caber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DDA9D304006-00:13-987C-OCD8B822F09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S to Member
Recipient
Page 12988
Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-064F-0000-AB39-F80F2A59A443
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type SysternCroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
WAD 9D77B2D0-190-0000-A989-02C00000S8D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'type SystemGrouptekmber
Recipient
Display Name
Email _
U LID 4237CDC0-1407-0000-AF20-8402120084D2
Distribution type TO
Recipient Type Sv.tcmGroup
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 661:64C10-1320-0000-SECI-2F2162868DCC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read fake
Deleted fake
Opened fake
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification nhen opened fake
Return notification "hen deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive S'en ion 5.3
Internal ID 5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.60EM.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1(01 6
Source received
Class Pubic
Account NYMADM I.NYMDOM I
Location ID I 5408-126:O8/46
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Maibcot
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.1.0.1(4)16
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 12989
Audits
Dote Action Auditor Note
2019-08-19 1642:46 EDT Created
crrArchist Agent_2-Zero Day
Archive3.co-lobs.en-GWOpenNode.ccrarchit
icg.ametma8
Generated by Narnail Inc. lereArchivc
Agent- 2-Zero Day
Archivc3xn=lobsen 0penNodexn.archiv
ing.nennai]
2019418-21140739 EDT Extorted ncimailmetnstinctmai Exposed by netnvad. netting. nomad
2019-08-21 1445:47 EDT Exported netmainetmainetmai Exported by netmadnettroincumd
2019-08-M 170534 EDT Exported ncimaiLnctmainctmad Expected by netnud.neurainennad
2019.09-16 15A233 EDT Exported nettnaiLnetnrainctinad Exported by nconaincimaiL monad
2020-05-19 152839 EDT Tag BOP01703.NIXRADNII.MXR DO ll Respersive
2020-05-1915:1706 EDT Tag BOPOI703.NIXRADNII.NIX.R1 X All Responsive
2020-05.19143435 EDT Tag ROPO I 703.NIXRAI)N11.NIXR DO MI Flagged
Page 12990
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Page 12991
Suicide Timeline re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Friday, August 9, 2019
8:00 am inmate Reyes Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 departs for court
(WAB-USMS-SDNY) . Reyes is Epstein's cellmate.
8:30 am inmate Epstein arrives in Attorney Conference. He is
visited by several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 pm inmate Epstein departs attorney conference and returns to
SHU
7:00 pm inmate Epstein provided a social call by IDO. IDO reports
inmate Epstein was in good spirits, nothing unusual.
7:32 am PIO notified of incident by the Warden
***Inmate Reyes is released from court and does not return to the
institution.
Saturday, August 10, 2019
6:33 am body alarm activated in SHU. Staff found inmate Epstein
unresponsive in cell. Staff reported to bedside of inmate and
attempted to wake him. Control announced medical emergency. CPR
initiated
6:35 am medical staff (on duty PA) on site, CPR already in
progress medical staff continues CPR and AED applied on inmate.
Control called for ambulance
6:40 am , AW notified
6:45 am EMS arrives, paramedics continue CPR. Inmate Epstein
remains unresponsive. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three
rounds of Epinephrine, IV access started, IC) initiated. No pulse
found, no shock advised, inmate prepared for transport to local
hospital.
7:10 am EMS departs institution enroute to Beekman Hospital.
7:19 am USMS notified of incident.
7:20 am SIS Lt notified.
7:30 am , Warden arrives at institution. , AW
notified.
7:36 am official time of death reported by ER physician.
7:40 am Acting Chief Psychologist notified.
8:00 am and Captain arrive at institution.
8:10 am SIS Lt arrives at institution.
8:10 am CMC and SCSS notified.
8:34 am FBI notified.
9:00 am AUSA notified.
9:00 am arrives at institution.
9:00 am SIS Lt. reports to SHU. Interviews will be conducted with
inmates assigned to tier.
9:15 am CMC arrives at institution.
9:30 am Acting Chief Psychologist arrived to the institution.
9:50 am SCSS arrives at institution.
9:55 am CMC and IDO depart institution enroute to Beekman
Hospital.
10:00 am CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital, fingerprints and
photographs taken of inmate Epstein. Inmate clothing secured and
brought back to institution.
10:00 am Judge Berman notified.
10:15 am CMC return to institution.
10:45 am PIO arrived to the institution.
11:00 am next of kin (brother) notified by Case Management
Coordinator.
11:12 am press release is released to media.
11:15 am press release provided to Judge Berman.
11:15 am CST activated.
12:15 pm body release to Medical Examiner (ME) for autopsy
12:19 pm FBI arrives.
1:35 pm FBI arrives in Special Housing Unit.
1:40 pm OIG notified by the Warden and they will be sending an
Agent to NYM.
2:15 pm CST debrief conducted.
2:45 pm OIG arrived in Special Housing Unit (SHU) .
3:45 pm OIG and FBI departed from SHU.
5:05 pm OIG/FBI departed MCC New York.
Fwd: Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
2019/12/30 09:12
Fwd: Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
TEXT.htm, Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
■ please set up a meeting to go over these issues next week.
Thank you
> » BOP-RSD/Assistant Director- 12/27/2019 9:08 AM > »
Please see attached.
Page 12994
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5I09BF95.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.6 59C3.1
Message Path smiltlailboX5E098F95.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1696E30.1.659C3.1xml
From
Dis pia) Name
Email
UUID F638D930- 1406-0000-A820-84D2120084D2
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Fwd: Psych Reconst Response - Epsten H76318-054.pdf
Scheduled date 2019.12.3009:1253
Citation date 2019-12-30091253
Modified date 2020-01-02 08:03:10
Delis e red dale 2019-12-3009:1254
Message size 154
Attachments sire 67312
Total she 67477
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.han
Content ID
5E09BF95.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000B1.1.B
3583.1@455E09BF95.NYMDOMLNYMADM 1.100.1
696E30.1.659C3.1141:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type Me
She 436
Date 2019-12-3004:1252
CA 403b&d6015293f4f3f06b392.533b096
Has h 57417B53207BECCOFF8D37FBA6F2E62BE8202605 BI0AA764F70B6C5F430049BFF245B903
Attachment Psych Rccomst Response - Epstein #76318-011.pdf
Name Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
Content ID
5E09131:95.NYMDOMINYMADMI.2C0.20000B1.1.B
3584.1@455E09BF95.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1
696E30.1.659C3.1@1:7.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type lie
She 66876
Date 2019-12-27040626
CA 9dc9te3bb7578b0d69d2ba0d5ba56071
Hash 57724D5A2505532F085BIE13472852E599E086AD8 24CF3CA6B1B2090F6E7453F4E9690332
Recipients 7
Recipient — Dis Display Name
Email
UUID 8351351:40-I I C6-0000-EOD6-FE66AT108950
Distribution Uwe TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 77IIC0440-09D3-0200-8F07-909C8F0A 1644
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB000.0COC491Oo-SB6E-IB003A002D00
Distribution Tye TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2.01M91)30- I 006-00:0-987C-0CD8B822F09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Uscr
Page 12995
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UtilD 9D77B2D0-19C1-0000-A989-0200000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient "Espe User
Recipie nt
Name
Email
Email
MID C4117510-04FF-0000433IC-4A46EB8DCC96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient I spe User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 661:64C10-B20-00(K)-NEC I -2F2167114RnrC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read Rue
Deleted fake
Opened tilt
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification ashen opened false
Return notification ashen deleted fake
Return notification sshen
completed take
Return notification 'Oren declined fake
Return notification nhen
accepted false
Archive X ersion 5.3
Internal ID 5EABBF95.NYMDOMINYMADM1.100.1696E30.1.659C3.1@lftNYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@1 6
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name CW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Waco(
Type Mailbox
System Mx
Share Type NotShared
Page 12996
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
20204M-10 1835:B EST Created
cteArchive Agent 1-Daly Archivc3
Job,en-lebson-Git/OpenNodeon-archningsrAgent-
=nctmai
Generated by Newsom [as-Archive
I -Daily Archly° Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNocle.cn-archivingo
-nettnail]
2020-06-02113023 EDT Viewed B0901829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1 Viewed by
BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1
202005-19143538 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Ebgged
2020-05-19152931 EDT Tag Et0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-1915:18.03 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-06-02159026 EDT Tag B0901829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1 Responsive
Page 12997
Mail Attachment
Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
Page 12998
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Reentry Services Division
Washington, DC 20534
DEC 2 7 TUT9
MEMORANDUM FOR , REGIONAL DIRECTOR
NORTHEAST REGION
FROM: s tant Director
Reentry Services Division
SUBJECT: Institution Response
Psychological Reconstruction
Inmate Epstein, Jeffrey (76318-054)
I have reviewed the Institution Response dated November 19, 2019, to
the Psychological Reconstruction of an inmate suicide involving
Jeffrey Epstein (76318-054) .
Some of the corrective actions and plans for implementation outlined
in the response are unclear or insufficient. Please review the
feedback provided and revise your response accordingly. An updated
Institution Response is due to me within thirty (30) days of your
receipt of this memorandum.
If you have questions or concerns, please feel free to contact me at
I appreciate your assistance with this matter.
CC: Warden, MCC New York
Institution Response Feedback
MCC New York
Epstein, Jeffrey (Reg. No. 76318-054)
Issue 1: Single Calling - Corrective Measure Accepted
The local guidelines provide a reasonable system of control to
monitor the single -ceiling of inmates in the Special Housing Unit.
National guidelines for single ceiling in the Special Housing Unit
have been incorporated into national policy and will soon be
released. Please reference these generally with a plan to
incorporate.
Issue 2: 30 Minute Rounds
The substance of the two hour Captain video review and six hour IDO
video review is unclear. Please clarify the requirement for the
Captain and IDO. Additionally, please identify the documentation
used to maintain accountability of the reviews.
Issue 3: Cellmate Assignments
Documentation exists reflecting the role of the local Psychology
Services department in communicating the importance of Mr. Epstein's
status as a sex offender with specific needs to the Associate
Warden. This includes consultation with the Psychology Services
Branch in Central Office. The communication chain and decision
making of Executive Staff lacks transparency as there is no
documentation of the process or staff members present when decisions
were made about the housing of Mr. Epstein. After the fact
explanations may not accurately reflect what occurred.
Psychology Services was not adequately represented in the decision
making of Executive Staff. Please establish a plan to increase the
input of a psychologist in placement decisions for vulnerable
inmates.
Issue 4: Documentation Accuracy
Professional responsibility requires taking into account multiple
descriptions of an incident as noted in your response. However,
when discrepancies exist these should be compiled and noted in
documentation to decrease the likelihood of conflicting conclusions.
As noted in the reconstruction report, an incident report must be
written within 24 hours of having the information that an inmate
likely violated BOP rules. An incident report was written for Mr.
Epstein prior to a determination of whether he engaged in self -
directed violence or was assaulted on July 23, 2019. Staff had
ample time to wait for the outcome of the SIS investigation of this
incident. The incident report presumed self-directed violence,
although SIS was not able to determine whether this incident was
self-directed violence or an assault. Generating the incident
report for self-directed violence is evidence of a local bias about
the July 23, 2019 incident that still exists amongst some staff at
MCC New York. Preconceived notions challenge the ability to remain
open about alternative explanations, and subsequent systemic changes
may be needed.
Please develop and provide local training for all staff that at a
minimum reviews the time frame for writing incident reports and
offers guidance when there is not clear evidence of an infraction.
Include an outline of the training and evidence of staff who
attended the training.
Typographical Errors - Corrective Measure Accepted
Medical Intake Screening - Response Accepted
Suicide Watch Log Book - Corrective Measure Accepted
BP 292s - Corrective Measure Accepted
Psychology Observation - Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 5: Telephone Calls
As noted in the response, there is a lack of documentation to
substantiate that a lieutenant facilitated two telephone calls to
Mr. Epstein. However, this does not address the report of two
telephone calls being provided. This response implies that the
reporting of two staff members is inaccurate.
The response neglects the documented telephone call to Mr. Epstein's
deceased mother.
Issue 6: Direct Observation
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 7: Follow -Up
Please provide documentation for the follow up training provided to
staff detailing the content of the training and to whom it was
provided.
Issue 8: Inmate Accountability and Assignment Accuracy
Periodic and unannounced checks are now conducted in SHU to
determine pp30 assignments and actual inmate placement match.
Please provide an operational definition of periodic. Please do the
same for routine, as it relates Executive Staff bed book counts in
all units. Where will the periodic and routine reviews be
documented and will they include the identity (e.g., name and title)
of staff who complete them?
Issue 9: Attorney Log Books
Please provide a copy of the log book audit.
Issue 10: Automatic External Defibrillators
The response states the reconstruction team reviewed an old and
outdated list from January 8, 2018. It is important to note this
list was provided to the reconstruction team by institution staff.
Provision of inaccurate documentation may reflect systemic issues
related to collecting, maintaining, and sharing relevant
documentation.
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 11: Post Orders & SIM Training
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 12: Staffing
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 13: Sex Offense Risk Factors
Psychologists are subject matter experts in sex offender risk
factors and they play a crucial role in sharing this knowledge
through traditional settings such as ICT, AT, and institutional
meetings. However, Executive Staff play a pivotal role in
establishing and addressing institutional culture and promoting and
participating in training. A lack of a broad understanding of sex
offender specific risk factors requires an intentional training
approach led by Executive Staff. They must be out front talking
about inmates with a sex offense, expressing an understanding of sex
offender dynamics, modeling agency condoned expectations for the
understanding and treatment of inmates with a sex offenses, and
assisting with institutional trainings. These practices encourage a
broader acceptance by line staff.
Noteworthy News Clips 12-9-2019
From
To
Date 2019/12/09 12:43
Subject: Noteworthy News Clips 12-9-2019
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Staff morale plummets at troubled federal lockup where Jeffrey Epstein killed himself
New York Daily News
https://www,nydailynewscorn/new-york/ny-mrc-epstein-fallout-20191209-qpyrevwxjdtxbfbo4pup5lylm-
stogibtml
The lower Manhattan federal lockup where Jeffrey Epstein killed himself is falling apart — and so is morale.
Repulsed by report of staff raping women at Florida federal prison, Rubio demands inquiry
Miami Herald
https://www.mi a mi hera Id.com/news/speci a I -repo rts/fl ori d a-pri so ns/arti r I e238130204.html
Shocked by a Miami Herald report detailing allegations of systemic sexual abuse of female inmates by male
staff at a federal facility, U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio is urging the Bureau of Prisons to conduct a thorough review
of Coleman Federal Correctional Complex.
FORMER PRISON GUARD PLEADS GUILTY TO ASSAULTING INMATE TO 'TEACH' HIM A LESSON
Newsweek
https://www.newsweek.conVprison-guard-assault-inmate-texas-1476044
A former federal prison guard pleaded guilty to battering an inmate in his custody, the Justice Department
announced Thursday, because "he wanted to teach [the inmate] a lesson."
Supreme Court won't let Justice Dept. immediately resume federal executions after hiatus
The Washington Post
https://www.washingtonpostcom/politics/courts law/supreme-court-wont-let-justice-dept-immediately-
resume-federal-executions-after-hiatus/2019/12/06/7103d8e6-1773-11ea-a659-7d69641c6f17_story.html
The Supreme Court on Friday refused to let the Justice Department immediately resume federal executions,
denying the government's request to bypass a lower-court ruling that the department likely exceeded its
powers by adopting a new lethal injection protocol.
Supreme Court Derails Plans to Resume Federal Executions
The Wall Street Journal
https://www.wsj.com/artides/judges-findi ng-of-possible- misconduct-likely-to-delay-federal -execution-
11575665275?sha reTo ken = st4234681d04e547a 78fb0d 6acd92a 535a
WASHINGTON—The Supreme Court on Friday derailed Trump administration plans to resume executing
federal prisoners next week, refusing to overrule lower-court orders allowing the condemned men to pursue
claims that the Justice Department execution protocol violates the Federal Death Penalty Act.
Page 13003
The unsigned order sent the case back to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, where
the Justice Department is appealing a district-court decision blocking executions while the issues are
litigated. "We expect that the Court of Appeals will render its decision with appropriate dispatch," the order
said.
No justice filed a dissent, but three conservative justices issued a statement suggesting they gave little
weight to the inmates argument.
"Nevertheless, in light of what is at stake, it would be preferable for the District Court's decision to be
reviewed on the merits by the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit before the executions are
carried out," Justice Samuel Alito wrote, joined by Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh.
"While we are disappointed with the ruling, we will argue the case on its merits in the D.C. Circuit and, if
necessary, the Supreme Court. The Department of Justice is committed to upholding the rule of law and to
carrying forward sentences imposed by our justice system," department spokeswoman Kerri Kupec said.
"Three courts have now agreed that the federal government's new execution protocol must be fully
adjudicated before it can be used to carry out executions," said Shawn Nolan, a federal defender
representing one of the condemned men. "The courts have made clear that the government cannot rush
executions in order to evade judicial review of the legality and constitutionality of its new execution
procedure."
The Supreme Court's order was the latest setback for the administration's drive to reactivate federal
executions at the federal prison in Terre Haute, Ind., after a 16-year hiatus. On Thursday, a federal judge in
Terre Haute blocked the government from executing Daniel Lewis Lee, who was scheduled to die on Monday
for murdering an Arkansas gun dealer and his family.
Judge J.P. Hanlon found that federal prosecutors misled jurors to believe Mr. Lee had committed a prior
murder, a factor that could have been pivotal in convincing the jury to vote for death. He stayed the
execution so further review could proceed.
On Friday, the Justice Department appealed that decision to the Seventh Circuit in Chicago, arguing that Mr.
Lee waited too long to bring his claim and that whether he had been charged with the prior murder or not
was irrelevant.
Friday's Supreme Court order lets stand, for now, a November decision by a federal-district judge in
Washington, D.C., staying the executions of Mr. Lee and three other inmates Attorney General William Barr
had selected to die at Terre Haute in December and January. Judge Tanya Chutkan found that government
plans to execute its prisoners by the same pentobarbital method likely violated the Federal Death Penalty
Act, which requires that federal prisoners be put to death according to the laws of the state in which they
were convicted.
A fifth prisoner's execution, scheduled for Dec. 11, received a stay from the Ninth Circuit, in San Francisco, so
he could pursue claims of juror bias. A hearing on that issue is scheduled for Dec. 13 before a federal judge in
Phoenix.
In Terre Haute, Judge Hanlon observed that the trial judge in 1999 found that Mr. Lee's co-defendant, Chevie
Kehoe, was more culpable for the killings. After the jury sentenced Mr. Kehoe to life imprisonment without
parole, the U.S. attorney notified the court that she wouldn't seek the death penalty against Mr. Lee.
Page 13004
That decision, however, was overruled by Eric Holder, then deputy attorney general, who convened the
Justice Department's death-penalty committee while Attorney General Janet Reno was at a White House
meeting, court opinions say.
At the penalty phase, federal prosecutors told jurors that Mr. Lee "has another murder under his belt,"
referring to a 1990 Oklahoma killing of Joey Wavra when Mr. Lee was 17. In that case, a co-defendant was
convicted of the murder, but Mr. Lee made a plea bargain with state prosecutors for robbery.
"I would suggest to you both legally and morally" Mr. Lee had "the blood of Joey Wavra" on his hands, the
prosecutor told the Arkansas jury. The plea bargain was a "gift" that Mr. Lee squandered by killing again, the
government argued.
In fact, Judge Hanlon wrote, the Oklahoma state judge had found no probable cause to charge Mr. Lee with
murder in the Wavra case.
"Mr. Lee has presented substantial grounds for claims that his death sentence is unconstitutional," wrote
Judge Hanlon, a former federal prosecutor appointed last year by President Trump. He cited Supreme Court
precedents that require the government to provide exculpatory information to the defense and prevent it
from introducing evidence it knows is false.
Page 13005
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5DEE415A.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4F-827 .1
Message Path xmlCabinetIPPAI5DEE415A.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E827.1.funl
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 737B5700-16FD-0000-BF9C-000083202C73
Reply To
Text
To
i
I
Subject Noteworthy News (lips 12-9-2019
Scheduled date 2019-12-09 1243336
Citation date 2019.12-09124306
Modified date 2019-12-09 125736
Delis end date 2019-12.09124307
Message sin 6970
Attachments sin 18224
Total sin 25205
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID 5DEEA15A.BOPMSCO.PO4.2C0.2000003.1.2437B 6.1(4455DEFAI5A.B0PMSC0.P04.100.1316B72.
1.4E827.1®155B600D9.BOPMSCO.PO4.10a 131 6672.1.4A.1@l3
Is Udine fake
TYPe Mc
Site 18224
Date 2019-12-09074307
CA e7684601cae4fle2367068e5=35ee8
Hash C2177F2B53558BB409BBA323E59C4AEA943ADBD7 FA133D31OFFBA4A503B4413F71BB2ADCO
Recipients 16
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID FO9FC101-1656-0030-8495-000083219F58
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
(3(111) ( (•51c( 90 02( F-0000.BDF1457F7FF4607B
Distribution Type 1O
Recipient Type t ker
Recipient
Display Name
Email
WAD B5927150-1653-0000-9294-751C62334A6C
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
(Jul D 11922A560-1581-0090-B66C-FACF6ACOASIC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID CD0296E0-0.14A-0000-893A-39A2FIL875A3
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID C9BD4C60-0500-0000-B363-DC66561970DB
Page 13006
Distribution Tye TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 791B2E01.157F-0000-BFB5-000083202O73
Distribution Typo. TO
Recipient I ype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 4FASEECO-0358-0000-83F5-C300F503FA00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 70485C8I-IF82-0000-8528-0000€32l9F45
Distribution Type TO
Recipient ?vise User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
(WI D 695F8300-02C5-0000-95CF-85908232EF87
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID A-T2s I st i- ;s0.0300-A5B0-7A0022000000
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type l er
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 6A70A5D0-05EF-0000-A5A4-F50F8FD3C03A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient fype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 3494D6C0- I I 52-000043502-02/305D137 I F3
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Time User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2F982B80-I4C3-0000-9B47-DF62C05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
IIIIMILD5-00008324673C LAID
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 81349E50I-2IAB-0000-B5CD-000000C00300
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Page 13007
Deleted fake
Opened We
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box twe Intros
Return notification when opened false
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed false
Return notification %%hen declined false
Return notification alien
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DEEA15A.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4E827 .1®1:55B60009.B0PMSCO.PO4.100.1316572.1.
4A.I@l3
Source received
Class Public
Account MSCO
Location ID 1540843449744
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder IPPA
ID 55B60DD9.BOPMSCO.P04100.1316B72.1.4A.1® 13
Name IPPA
Type Normal
System false
Share Type NotShared
Page 13008
Audits
Dale Action Auditor Note
2019-12-11 093931 EST Created
en-Archive Agent2-Zero Day
Archive8.en-Jobstn-GWOpenNode.cn-archis
inga=netmail
Generated by Neigpvem(en-Archive
Agent_2-Zero Day Archivestn.jobstrecwopenNodetn _archiv
logo-neural)
'NA-0/gr , 113630 EDT Viewed Et0P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Vkwed by
BOP01829.NCRADM I.NCRDOM I
2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag BOP01703.84XRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19153531 EDT Tag BOP01703.MKRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-01191437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM1 Flagged
2020-05-1914A136 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM1 Fbgged
2020.06-02 153644 EDT Tag BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Responsive
2020-06-02153704 EDT Tag B0P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1 Responsive
Page 13009
Google Alert - Bureau of Prisons
From Google Alerts
To
Date 2019/08/26 16:02
Subject: Google Alert - Bureau of Prisons
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
Bureau of Prisons
26.2019
NEWS
Barr Demotes Federal Prison Director, Taps Old Colleague Sawyer
The Chief-Leader
The shake-up at the U.S. Bureau of Prisons continues in the aftermath of Jeffrey Epstein's suicide Aug.
10 at the Metropolitan Correctional Center, with ...
Prison Guards — Overworked And Underpaid. No Wonder Epstein Died. - Above the Law
Full Coverage
Flag as Irrelevant
Video shows MCC inmate using illicit phone for Facebook Live broadcast
New York Post
An inmate awaiting trial on murder and conspiracy charges used a ... The US Bureau of Prisons, which
runs the MCC, declined to torment on Reid's ...
How Courts Could Ease The White House's Clemency Backlog
Law360
More than 11,430 federal prisoners, many of them nonviolent offenders .... but statutes also allow the
director of the Bureau of Prisons to request that ...
Letter: ADS: Two (2) articles on 8/14 "Trump amplifies conspiracy theory
linking Clintons to ...
Arizona Daily Star
The Director of the Federal Bureau of Prisons has been serving in an ACTING role for over a year. He
had no prison experience and violated rules ...
Answer Man: Bobby Medford prison release date? Parkway overlooks
Page 13010
untrimmed?
Asheville Citizen-Times
Federal Bureau of Prisons records show Medford remains in the Butner Low FCI, with a release date of
Oct. 11, 2021. Butner is a low security federal ...
Justice dept eyes fraud
The Manila Times
SOME officials of the Bureau of Corrections (BuCor) nay have committed fraud for including the name
of former Calauan mayor Antonio Sanchez in ...
DOJ to tell SC it will suspend law expanding prisoners' GCTA - Business Mirror
Senators back justice dept on suspending GCTA processing - ABS-CBN News
CHR commends DOJ, BuCor for their prudence in implementing GCTA system - Manila Bulletin
Full Coverage
Flag as irrelevant
Iran's Zarif lands in France's Biarritz, talks with US not on agenda
Yahoo News
Iranian state TV also reported that Iran's Foreign Ministry spokesman Abbas Mousavi ruled out the
possibility of any meeting between Iran's top ...
Lebanese army says one Israeli drone fell, another exploded in Beirut
overnight
Yahoo News
Justice Department: Psychologist removed Jeffrey Epstein from suicide ... led by the FBI, the
department's inspector general and the Bureau of Prisons.
Letters to the editor
Arizona Daily Star
We also see yet another example of a high-level appointment with incompetent vetting. The director of
the Federal Bureau of Prisons has been serving ...
Sheriffs office: LA deputy lied about being shot by sniper
NTV
Sheriffs office: LA deputy lied about being shot by sniper .... the Trump Justice Department, which
oversees the Federal Bureau of Prisons, is also the ...
Sheriffs office: LA deputy lied about being shot by sniper - KFXL Fox Nebraska (press release)
Full Coverage
Flag as irrelevant
Page 13011
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscnbe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Page 13012
Properties
Property Value
SlessagelD 5D6402A3.07VDOMI.OTVADM1.100.1696471.1.1 8272.1
Message Path xmiTrash3D6402A3.0TVDOMI.OTVADM1.100.1 696471.1.18272.1.xml
From Goo& Akrts
Display Name Goo& Alerts
Email googlealcrts.norepktugeogle.com
Reply To googlealens.norepitzgoogk.com
Test Google Alerts
To
Subject Google Alert - Bureau of Prisons
Scheduled date 2019-08.261601:14
Creation date 2019-08.261601:14
Modified date 2019.08-27 063828
Delivered date 2019.08-261602:44
Message she 5603
Attachments sirs 91710
Total size 97324
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hun
Content ID
5D6402A3.0TVDOMI.OTVADM1.200.20000A7.1.8
9007.1@453D6402A3.0TVDOM1.07VADMI.100.1
696471.1.18272.1@l9.07VDOMLOTVADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l18
Is Inline fake
Type Me
Size 37174
CA 63259a0adO2be39569ab9265e26008b5
Hay h 6A7B5854FB2EDF8F2D5282496E167C554373254 234BE27A253033F48C39BD7BD332857D
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D6402A3.07VDOMI.OTVADM1.200.20000A7.1.8
9008. 4455D6402A3.0TVDOMLOIVADMI.100.1
696471.1.18272.1Q 19.0TVDOMI.OTVADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline fake
Type Me
Size 54536
CA 9f7e0060e3ce38445a0fe58be9543659
Hash 8CF4A082EB3FCD8234F05E7A2F8CF718B2E2182B3 9P8744FEA3E53A114A40ABOOEED507B24
Recipients I
Recipient
Displas Name
Email
LIVID I 50118260.165F-0000-A8F4-F3000400E800
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read fake
Deleted true
Opened false
Completed fake
Security Neural
Box type inbox
Return notification "hen opened false
Return notification "hen de le te d fake
Return notification "hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D6402A3.0TVDOMI.OTVADMI.100.1696471.1.1 8212.1®1:9.07VDOMI.OTVADM 1.100.010. I ®1 8
Source received
Class Public
Account .OFF4.MIMDOMI
Page 13013
Location ID 1540843191424
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
113 9.0TVDOMLOTVADM1.100.0.1.0.1@1 8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NoiShared
Page 13014
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08.3000:1538 EDT Created
en=Archive Agent_I-Daly Trash5
JolAen-lebs.cn-GWOpenNodetn-archivingd Agent-
ietmai
Generated by Neural Inc. [en-Archive
I -Daily Trashy
Job.cn-Jobs4n-GWOpenNode.cn-archivingo
-mutual
2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM ilsi XR DOM Responsive
2020-05-19144136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM 1.N1 XR DOM I Fbgged
2020.0519153531 EDT Tag BOP01703.3AXRADM 1.NINR I X3M I Responsive
2020-O5.191536A6 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MNRDOMI Responsive
202005.191437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.14XRADMI.MXRDOMI named
Page 13015
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13016
Sent: Mon, 26 Aug 2019 13:01:14 -0700
Subject: Google Alert - Bureau of Prisons
From: Goo gl  Alerts < ooglealerts-noreply@google.00m>
To:
Bureau of Prisons
NEWS
Barr Demotes Federal Prison Director, Taps Old Colleague Sawyer
The Chief-Leader
The shake-up at the U.S. Bureau of Prisons continues in the aftermath of Jeffrey Epstein's suicide Aug. 10 at the
Metropolitan Correctional Center, with ...
Prison Guards — Overworked And Underpaid. No Wonder Epstein Died. - Above the Law
Full Coverage
ME •
Video shows MCC inmate using illicit phone for Facebook Live broadcast
New York Post
An inmate awaiting trial on murder and conspiracy charges used a ... The US Bureau of Prisons, which runs the MCC,
declined to comment on Reid's ...
• NI
How Courts Could Ease The White House's Clemency Backlog
Law360
More than 11,430 federal prisoners, many of them nonviolent offenders .... but statutes also allow the director of the 
Bureau
of Prisons to request that ...
Letter: ADS: Two (2) articles on 8/14 "Trump amplifies conspiracy theory linking Clintons to
Arizona Daily Star
The Director of the Federal Bureau of Prisons has been serving in an ACTING role for over a year. He had no prison
experience and violated rules ...
Answer Man: Bobby Medford prison release date? Parkway overlooks untrimmed?
Asheville Citizen-Times
Federal Bureau of Prisons records show Medford remains in the Butner Low FCI, with a release date of Oct. 11, 2021.
Butner is a low security federal ...
Justice dept eyes fraud
The Manila Times
SOME officials of the Bureau of Corrections (BuCor) may have committed fraud for including the name of former Calauan
mayor Antonio Sanchez in ...
DOJ to tell SC it will suspend law expanding prisoners' GCTA • Business Mirror
Senators back justice dept on suspending GCTA processing - ABS-CBN News
CHR commends DOJ, BuCor for their prudence in implementing GCTA system • Manila Bulletin
Full Coverage
ININ Pan as irre'evanl
Iran's Zarif lands in France's Biarritz, talks with US not on agenda
Yahoo News
Iranian state TV also reported that Iran's Foreign Ministry spokesman Abbas Mousavi ruled out the possibility of any
meeting between Iran's top ...
Lebanese army says one Israeli drone fell, another exploded in Beirut overnight
Yahoo News
Justice Department: Psychologist removed Jeffrey Epstein from suicide ... led by the FBI, the department's inspector
general and the Bureau of Prisons.
Letters to the editor
Arizona Daily Star
We also see yet another example of a high-level appointment with incompetent vetting. The director of the Federal Bureau
of Prisons has been serving ...
ZZ
Sheriff's office: LA deputy lied about being shot by sniper
NTV
Sheriff's office: LA deputy lied about being shot by sniper .... the Trump Justice Department, which oversees the 
Federal
Bureau of Prisons, is also the ...
Sheriffs office: LA deputy lied about being shot by sniper - KFXL Fox Nebraska (press release)
Full Coverage
l'a ,1 as i—c'evant
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Google Alert - "bureau of prisons"
From
To
Date
Google Alerts
2019/11/03 17:05
Subject: Google Alert - "bureau of prisons"
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
"bureau of prisons"
Daily update November 3. 2019
NEWS
Trevor Noah asks Hillary Clinton how she killed Jeffrey Epstein
VT
Emergency services were summoned shortly after, but he could not be resuscitated. The Bureau of
Prisons and U.S. Attorney General William Barr ...
Stenger is getting out of prison way too early
STLtoday.com
Regarding "Steve Stenger, sentenced to 46 months in prison, is now due out after 27 months, prison
says" (Oct. 26): I am pleased that former County ...
Actress Lori Loughlin and husband plead not guilty to new charges in college
scandal case
New Zealand Herald
Under what a public information officer for the Bureau of Prisons had described as "ordinary
procedure," Huffman was released before the weekend, ...
Raniere Will Not Have an Easy Time in Prison — and Probably Will Die There
Frank Report
Keith Alan Raniere — FKA The Vanguard NKA Crybaby Jane — has been in federal custody since March
25, 2018, the day he was summarily booted ...
Russian agent Maria Butina says she was cast as 'Kremlin seductress'
Herald Publicist
People die there regularly. They procure spoiled food," she mentioned. The Bureau of Prisons didn't
Page 13019
instantly reply to a request for remark by The Put ...
Russian agent Maria Butina says she was cast as 'Kremlin
seductress'
Headlinez Pro
Individuals die there on a conventional foundation. They get depraved meals,' she
said. The Bureau of Prisons didn't trusty now reply to a request for ...
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Page 13020
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5DBF08E8.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.1367333.1.1 7356.1
Message Path xmtTrash5DBF08ERNERDOMI.NERADMI.100.1 367333.1.17356.1.xml
From Googlc Alerts
Display Name Goo& Akrts
Email googleakds-norcpVirgeogic.com
Reply. To googkakns•norepiy(ggoogk.com
Test Goo& Alerts
To
Subject Googie Alert - Incau of prison"
Scheduled date 2019-11-03 17:0422
Creation date 2019-11-03 170422
Modified date 201941-03 172934
Delis end date 2019-11-03 17:05s15
Message she 3540
Attachments sin 60356
Total size 63907
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.him
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID
5DBF08E8.NERDOMI.NERADM1.200.20:004B.1.A
7B94.1®451DEIFIXE&NERDOMINERADMI.100.1
367333.1.17356.1@l 9.NEFtDOMI.NERADM1.100 .0.1.0. lig 18
Is Inline fake
TVs' rde
Size 23417
CA 80bfe7faM00a3945035.8.1180feb3081
Has h AOEE09AE7513534A20D3BF17615ED3E362CD71826 E9C86349FD19B66294936D9F7ICD09C2
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5DBFOSERNEFtDOMI.NERADM1.200.20:00$B.1.A
7B95.1®455DBF08E&NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.1
367333.1.17356.1@i 9.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100 .0.1.0. i@l8
Is Inline fake
Type fie
Size 36939
CA 7d9b0547%4B(00263021858eba3616
Hash 169D8F24EA3I872D2FF2F552ACBED76ECED6C69B 07A5A877A30B4CAF9920B2095BEE07ED
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2F982B80-14C3-0000-9B47-BF62C05F1E96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read fake
Deleted truc
Opened false
Completed fake
Security Nonni
Box type Inbox
Return notification sshen opened false
Return notification "hen de le te d fake
Return notification "hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DBF08E8.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.B67333.1.17356.1(4)19.NERDOMLNERADMI.180.0.1.0.1©1 8
Source received
Class Public
Account RDOM I
Page 13021
Location ID 1540843020946
Class Name 6W.NIESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
ID 9.NERDOMLNERADMI.I00.0.I.0.I@I8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 13022
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-11-04 16:19Y18 EST Created
en-Archive Agera 2-Zero Day _  . Trashlen-Jobs.arGWOpenNcde,en-archnarrashi snieburi.GwopertNodetn _urchivii
Rornetmail
Centrated by Netgovem [en-Archive
Agent 2-Zero Day
gametmaill
2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM1 Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag 8O901703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM1 Hawed
Page 13023
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13024
Sent: Sun, 03 Nov 2019 14:04:22 -0800
Subject: Google Alert - "bureau of prisons"
From: Goo le Alerts < ooglealerts-noreply@google.00m>
To:
"bureau of prisons"
NEWS
Trevor Noah asks Hillary Clinton how she killed Jeffrey Epstein
VT
Emergency services were summoned shortly after, but he could not be resuscitated. The Bureau of Prisons and U.S.
Attorney General William Barr ...
•
Stenger is getting out of prison way too early
STLtoday.com
Regarding "Steve Stenger, sentenced to 46 months in prison, is now due out after 27 months, prison says' (Oct. 26): I am
pleased that former County ...
X X
Actress Lori Loughlin and husband plead not guilty to new charges in college scandal case
New Zealand Herald
Under what a public information officer for the Bureau of Prisons had described as "ordinary procedure," Huffman was
released before the weekend, ...
• II
Raniere Will Not Have an Easy Time in Prison — and Probably Will Die There
Frank Report
Keith Alan Raniere — FKA The Vanguard NKA Crybaby Jane — has been in federal custody since March 25, 2018, the day
he was summarily booted ...
Russian agent Maria Butina says she was cast as 'Kremlin seductress'
Herald Publicist
People die there regularly. They procure spoiled food," she mentioned. The Bureau of Prisons didn't instantly reply to a
request for remark by The Put ...
IZ X
Russian agent Maria Butina says she was cast as 'Kremlin seductress'
Headlinez Pro
Individuals die there on a conventional foundation. They get depraved meals; she said. The Bureau of Prisons didn't
trusty now reply to a request for ...
X X
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS teed
Send Feedback
End: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
From
To
Date 2019/09/11 15:57
Subject: Fwd: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Page 13027
FYI
Sent from my %Wirral, Sammy Galaxy smanphonc
aC rr, "same
Front
Date:9/11/19 3:55 PM GMT-05:00
To:
Cc:
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs or MCC New York
>>> 09/11/2019 15:55>>>
Good Afternoon,
After a review of the budget, Central Office is able to cover the TON' expenses tin N Your financial management staff 
should he rectis ing an e-mail
Please let me know if you have any questions.
Senior Deputy Assistant Director
Administration Division
Federal Bureau of Prisons
>>> < > 8/30/2019 11:52 AM >»
Thanks. Yes, the TDY is related to them putting new procedures and policies in place to improve local processes related 
to the incident. The TDY staff a
Sent front my Verizon. Samsung Galaxy smanphone
message
From:
Date: ft/30/19 11:32 AM (GMT-05:00
To:
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
>>> "==" 08/30/2019 11:32 >»
Hello Ray.
Yes, the MDC Brooklyn incident was covered by special project. However, this was to cover assistance throughout the 
duration of the incident along wit
evaluate our budget status during the fast week of September to see if any additional funding can be provided. We will 
certainly help if we can. Please I.
>>> 8/28/2019 10:08 AM >»
- See below. Is the special project not covering the WY cost for MCC NYM? Was the WY cost during the MDC BRO incident 
covered by the si
Regional Director
>>> 8/26/2019 2:34 PM >»
The Administration Division has provided us a guidance that we arc not authorized to charge any of our TDY Expenses to 
the project 87F.. Eptcin Death
So far, approximately 60 staff from various institutions for various dates as early as 8/18 through 9/28 are scheduled 
for TDY to New York.
The estimated costs for TDY expenses will be approximately 5500.000.
Please let me know if you have any questions. Thanks.
Page 13028
err*,
Pr•Pirq Vale
MasagaD IDNI.50 NFROOMI NERADML I01067111LI MCI.'
Manama Pba tallIalboal) NERDOMI NERADMI ITO 1367131I 'WILDS
ECINIPI
DIspky Arsce
Easll
ACID JWAINOTICTOIMISIMMIM2COMIL96
Reply T.
Us
To I
S610 11 Tod Pod 101 Cab S MCC New Val
Schtdola law 3119061I 153637
Oman ea SIPPO011 03667
Madded Mk 201111b15064101
Dolan. Mk NIDOSII 155701
Message as 1551
Amason art AMI
Taal as 10151
Madmen. I
Ann/Pam Wales
Anne TLXIMIn
Coops ID somosasotoomi ALRADMISIX00139 I 5 31091610:019199:1MADOMI NERADIII. Kill
567115 I IS6C1 ISR II ALMON I AMAMI ID) 01.0 kr IA
IS lane fat
T. fk
Ma 6R14
CA MIIIIM*15101 1615616609105%
Hal RAIMMORICOSTIALARDITSAMAUAMEADCIXDSOAIIIMASMADJICAMICOIDIAIMIDIC
Recipient. I
RICO.-
DRS" As
Tall
LIVID MIIMITDRIFFDPIOAFASTATAIMMLIC6
Dladbollon 1)pt TO
NedINO , Th e Ova
Ottani, MMOSII 155701
DawaloaMlly11651Paty 20POIMII l5:1701
OP16. 6 20POOMI 155716
fIlligd TOMO-IS 06C06
Fornated MPLIPAI 1155736
Lmln 0
Dag allyerp nal 0
Delman, DM
Mahal Ma
Real my
Damn DS
()mad ex
ConmItotil fat
Maas Nets
Rey Dr* Nell lens
Ronan nonficalosolw•oproal DM
Raton anficanonten *lard fait
Ramo amnesia awn
°ma* "II
folic
Haan nalicsow ok n &amid alit
Roma 01416(abldi awn
ekePlell
ft
Make Loran 55
Saki ID 5DICITRINTRD0111 NLITADMI OM 067133.LI RCtla I tNtlIDOSILNLiADM TKOS IA RS I 6
Saw lac
Clay Pak
Acosta May Omni.. BOPIRIOINTRADMI NEIUMAII
Locales ID IMISOCL9116
Clay Nana OW MEAAMS MAIL
Esdalm laden I
rower Maas
ID I AIRDCAll AFRADMI IMO I a Tom
Nat Mayo
CM Mahn
Maas met
Mr Ope Mama
Poblithal 3319.111-LY06
Page 13029
Audits
Det Aran Molitor Mott
3/200141 tab039 EST Created
a -Waxy Aged !-Schrdabd Lem flay
bailey -Mawr< iN OirriNetkea-ardno
muted
Conerakd by Nelsintra [ay Arclat s_ Lsonutd  mt.  ou..
;;; ;I  fr.T. j ..a „ 0 th kop..;Nodouratan
gm oconall
3124!.I9 DJOOS For Tay IMO, 70I f IXRADM I MIXTROOM I Re"...na ,
MO45-I9 15.1041 EDT Tag 180.0170‘ MMIADM I MXRIXIM I Bryan.,
=W I. KAM EDT be Krona %MAIM I MIVIXIM I tbo,I
2(C003.19 144116 EDT Tag BONIN° 1.1X1IADIA I NI)JtDOM I IbswJ
Page 13030
Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
From
To
Date 2019/09/11 18:08
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
Attachments: TEXT.httn
Thanks!!
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Ori inal messa e
From: < >
Date: 9/11/19 3:55 PM (GMT-05:00)
To:
Cc:
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
>».
Good Afternoon,
09/11/2019 15:55 >> >
After a review of the budget, Central Office is able to cover the TDY expenses for NYM. Your financial
management staff should be receiving an e-mail shortly with the project and cost center to use for these
expenses.
Please let me know if you have any questions.
Thanks,
Senior Deputy Assistant Director
Administration Division
Federal Bureau of Prisons
>» > 8/30/2019 11:52 AM »>
Thanks. Yes, the TDY is related to them putting new procedures and policies in place to improve local
processes related to the incident. The TDY staff are training local staff or are providing coverage/assistance
while NYM staff put new procedures in place. Thanks in advance.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Page 13031
Ori inal messa e
From: < >
Date: 8/30/19 11:32 AM (GMT-05:00)
To:
Subject: Re: Fwd: TDY Costs for MCC New York
> » 'a 08/30/201911:32 > > >
Hello Ray,
Yes, the MDC Brooklyn incident was covered by special project. However, this was to cover assistance
throughout the duration of the incident along with chiller and repair costs. The Regional staff could not
provide justification for additional expenses directly related to the Epstein incident. The only explanation
provided was due to staff shortage, MCC NY was bringing in staff for staff assist. I explained to the Regional
Comptroller that Bureau institutions are suffering from staff shortages nationwide and any expenses
associated with those shortages are being absorbed at those locations or Regions. We did however provide
utilization of the project code for the travel expenses of the after action team. I've advised all the Regional
Comptrollers, due to priority spending directed by DO1, such as FSA spending, we would re-evaluate our
budget status during the first week of September to see if any additional funding can be provided. We will
certainly help if we can. Please let me know if you have any additional questions.
Thanks,
> » 8/28/2019 10:08 AM > »
- See below. Is the special project not covering the TDY cost for MCC NYM? Was the TDY cost during
the MDC BRO incident covered by the special project? Thanks in advance.
Regional Director
Northeast R ion
> » 8/26/2019 2:34 PM > »
The Administration Division has provided us a guidance that we are not authorized to charge any of our TDY
Expenses to the project 87F, Eptein Death at the national level. It was explained to us that the project was
established for regional tracking purposes only and we at the regional level will have to absorb all TDY costs
related to MCC New York.
So far, approximately 60 staff from various institutions for various dates as early as 8/18 through 9/28 are
scheduled for TDY to New York.
The estimated costs for TDY expenses will be approximately $500.000.
Please let me know if you have any questions. Thanks.
Page 13032
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D793829.NERDOMENERADMI.100.B67333.1.1 56D5.1
Message Path antislaimA5D793829.NERDOMENERADM1.100 .B67333.1.156135.1.xml
From
Display Name
Entail
UUID 2F982B80-14C3-0000-9B47-BF62C05FIE96
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Re: Fwd: TDY Costs fa MCC New York
Scheduled date 2019-09-I1 1807A0
Creation date 2019-09-11 18:07A0
Modified date 2019-11-04 202626
Delivered date 2019-09-II 18:08:41
Message stre 3562
Attachments sin 5365
Total sire 8938
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT:6bn
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID 5D793829.NERDOMINERADMI.200.2000039.1.5 36EE.1©453D793829-NERDOMI.NERADMI-100.1
367333.1.156D5.1(M1:7.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.0.1.0.1%)16
Is Inline fake
Type lie
Size 5365
CA bf6293945b7d7a8b8452066cd9c211346
Hash 08FED2ID5A7AAEE3ADCOD77B4A207D8ABCIE63C6 6B5E22079AAC6FC9ACINDE7D4AER4337
Recipients
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID FO9FC 101- 1 656-0000-8495-000083219F58
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-09.111808)42
DonnloadedllyThIrdParty 2019-09-11 l8f18:43
Opened 2019-09-11 190524
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CND B2E8DF81 1B1I-0000-9EF2-0000832I9F4E
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-09-11 1808.42
DownloadedByThirdParty 2019-09-I1 1801,43
Opened 2019-09-11 203557
Deleted 2019-09-11 2036:01
Purged 2019-09.26010203
Expire
Delay de livery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted false
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification when declined fake
Page 13033
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D793829.NERDOMLNERADMI.I00.1367333.I. I 56(35.I@I:7.NERDOMLNERADMI.I00.0.1.0.I@I 6
Source sent
Class Public
Account NERADMI.NERDOM I
Location ID 15406430205146
Class Name GW.ME.SSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NERDOMLNERADMI.I00.0.1.01@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System ime
Share Type NotShared
Published 2019/11/S1:26:36
Page 13034
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2020.01-01 04A8.00 EST Created
en-Archive Agent_3-Scheduled Zero Day . . Trash 1.01-Jobs.en-GWOpenNode.errarchnitsrash
garnctmail
Generated by Netgovem [en-Archive
Agent  Zero Day }ScheduledL irjobstre.Gwoperasiodetn.urchini
go-neural
2020.05-19 I5:30135 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020-05-19 1530:41 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020.0519143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
2020-0519144136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 13035
Re: Fwd: MCC Epstein (Out of the office)
From
To
Date
Subject: Re: Fwd: MCC Epstein (Out of the office)
2019/08/10 10:52
I will be out of the office on August 12-16, 2019. Please leave a detailed email message, and I
will contact you upon my return. If you require immediate assistance, please contact the
institution directly at
Associate Warden (P)
FCI Estill
100 Prison Road
Estill SC 29918
FCI:
Associate Warden
MCC New York
150 Park Row
New Yor1 NY 10007
Page 13036
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D4EAIFI.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.165396E.1.5 AlIA.1
Message Path xmllTrashf5D4EA IF&NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1 65396E.1.5A1 IA.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID A35B5E40-11C6-0000.B3D6-FE66A77013950
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: Fwd: MCC Epstein (Out of the office)
Scheduled date 2019-08-101032.40
Creation date 2019438-10 10:52:40
Modified date 201908-1015:1018
Delivered  date 2019.08-10 1032.41
Message sine 503
Attachments 0
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Ull11) 9D77B2D049C143000.A989.0200000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read false
Deleted true
Opened false
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inky(
Return notification sshen opened fake
Return notification sshen deleted fake
Return notification sshen
completed false
Return notification sshen declined fake
Return notification sshen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
I nte mal ID 5D4EA I Ft NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.16.5396E.1.5 Al IA.1 ®19.NYMDOM LNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@ I
Source received
Class Public
Account DANADMI.DANDOMI
Location ID 1540843105474
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Trash
ID 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI. 100.0.1.0.1 18
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 13037
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-11 00A4A5 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Trash3 Jobrn-lebsrn-GWOpenNodern-archivingx,(Arni_l-Daily
se mi
Generated by Netrre0 Inc. [en--Archive
Trash3
Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNedern—archivinga
-netrnail]
2019-08-21 I40625 EDT Expand netmainennainettnail Exported by netmainet
2019-09-16 154115 EDT Exported neunaineunainetrmi Exported by netmaineurra
rnaineumil
ilneunad
2020-0549 153005 EDT Tag BOP01703.M)CRADMI.MXRD034 I Responsive
Page 13038
'es e
Sen.111.2r..
To:
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Fstd: counsel having difficult, meeting nith tlleot
From
To
Date
Subject: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with
client
Attachments: TEXT.htm
2019/07/07 18:58
Sera from my Wilma, Samna Galaxy smanphone
From:
Tat • 7/7/19 6:22 PM GMT-05:00
To: •
Subjcct: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>»==. 07/07/2019 18:22 >>>
I have verified Marlin Weinberg is an attorney in good standing in Massachusetts. lie is permitted to visit Jeffrey 
Epstein.Sent from my Verizon, Samsun$
•c-/div>•cdiv>
</div><!— originalMessage -->•ccliv>— Original message -------</divxdiv>From: <Alexander.Rossmiller@usc
<-/div>
>>> •= 1>• 07/07/2019 18:18 >»
Massachusetts
From:
Sorry just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smariphone
From: •t <mailio >>
To: <math° >. < <mailtoa
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
" 07/07/2019 17:36 >»
With apologies for the weekend entail, we have a defendant. Jeffrey Epstein. who was arrested last night and is 
currently being detained at MCC. and is e
of-state.
We're concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any defendant) and so I wane
its very much,
Page 13039
'i—n
?Mein 'VS
MessegelD 7132310DI NVMDOMINYMADIMI I00 160600 I E EDI I
Mane 000 unklaibakIDDADDI NYMOOMI NYMADMI KG DOW7GI EEDII mi
From
Mph, Vs
rani
(CID sl) . in inMARDOSOCOORDO0
Rapp T.
bril
To MM
Saila Fad cowl inn; onlictity mann at th ew
&YAMS daft 3179.0107 IL* I7
Creagan as . 20I907.411 HOMO
Madded ase 20I90740 D11916
Delon. 6.4 20700747 HORN
Message Oar MO
An/thatlell fi n SDI
Th al On ces
Asurinssa I
Attain T1X1 km
Ns TLXI Inn
Cowen ID
SICLX1(01 S1%00041 VIMADMI 200 703X0S. I 9
001 IskONILLKOI NNSIDOMI NS MXIMII KO I
6MTIO I F102 In I 7 svmnomi NS manku to) olnia le.
Is last bit
Tfle He
Mn S234
CA ^tacads7bISSNEXCe7(64070.00
Hob CCA IATISIO9CAT010/711147ADINCPIVISILDIN Inn AIISICI*4.1,154.171063M00.023I Vat
S& kYs
it s Na —s
Mph.. Na
Fail
(CID 70DAMPOCOTOOXISSOl ealTIII32507A
Disirlballe• TM TO
ROOF" TM (la
%Mikes.
111.04 Nose
Fad
(CID ICSIS20 7( I 210,10.91X
Dbinbatioa Tn./ TO
DaelPlaal TYPe (seal
Ellin 0
Dein elver. non 0
Dalephol tali
Ariblved fake
Real eve
Deleted take
°read ev.
Compleled fake
Smirk. NtmS

Da. OR Into.
Reim. nothing...sines 'fnd flan
Resta amilfratis•whonkleard fake
Regan natikatke Inn.
(sa t l° 471
Take
Intent ensillenk.a when eased DM.
Reia nonicalmothea
waned lilt
spine Sen.*. l5
Incenal ID (02210DI NIMIXDONYMAILMI IGO le06,00 I FED} 1417 symnonit 70iXtailmi 00010 /*16
%nen (nosed
( In. Pane
%atm.* . LAMI I POI DON, I
Unman ID IYIYL1N6Is
(Ins NS 414 MY MAIL
Fannin Folios
Fabler Moen
ID 7 NVIAJOHI roluom I MOO I 0 In 10
_ Vast Maim
TM , IAD.'
-Y0000 int
71. 00  bra Nueelsosol
Page 13040
Arias
Dale Actin Arise Now
11/19417.15 MI DM EDT mead Juba-
.s-ArclAc Accra lOak Amin.'
Mac nA iVillyerAurk inscIonc ruAS " -
Alms.
Timoricil by liersori Ix lcrAithie
I•llay Ardor.
Ab.car-MAciraT1TreaNedeAlralainIC9
rretroll
N)19411.11 IOI OA207 EDT FAprinl larnel annul annul FATunol by agirmil 11011•111 MOS.
:19.09111 S EDT El1. 110.1 Arencl naval none. FAmscrlby Arial nand ASS
31:096.19 leT IS EDT lag 1901•01`03 lIARADMI ACCRDOM1 IF lrapcd
muag-la WI ll EDT lag WW01`0‘ lIARADM AITICOM 1 ItArmaar
:OHO -19 1S:3201 EDT lag 110P01 NA 919.1tADM 1 14/000M1 Roman<
:11:9476.19 I kW/ 1 EDT lac BONI Ail MAXADM 1 MX11,130911 TroPalry
:11,11141-19 IOW EDT lag SOTO 903 NIAltADM 1 AllallOMI 'bared
Page 13041
'es e
Sen.111.2r..
To:
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Fstd: counsel having difficult, meeting nith tlleot
From
To
Date
Subject: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with
client
Attachments: TEXT.htm
2019/07/07 18:58
Sera from my Wilma, Samna Galaxy smanphone
From:
Dat • 7/7/19 6:22 PM GMT-05:00
To: •
Subjcct: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>»==. 07/07/2019 18:22 >>>
I have verified Marlin Weinberg is an attorney in good standing in Massachusetts. lie is permitted to visit Jeffrey 
Epstein.Sent from my Verizon, Samsun$
•c-/div>•cdiv>
</div><!— originalMessage -->•ccliv>— Original message -------</divxdiv>From: <Alexander.Rossmiller@usc
<-/div>
>>> •= 1>• 07/07/2019 18:18 >»
Massachusetts
From:
Sorry just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smariphone
From: •t <mailio >>
To: <math° >. < <mailtoa
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
" 07/07/2019 17:36 >»
With apologies for the weekend entail, we have a defendant. Jeffrey Epstein. who was arrested last night and is 
currently being detained at MCC. and is e
of-state.
We're concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any defendant) and so I wane
its very much,
Page 13042
PrawnIn
DmPea> 'VS
MessegelD 5D22/001 SiCMCOMINYMAD11.11 I0110648 Id4SW]
Meson Ilelt satMairoue022.10DI NYMOOMI NYMADMI KO 16d696R1 409/ 1 we
From
Dleplit Ns
Cann
ACID . 04.14010A9100):01:00.4400
Reply T. Dbadnetenot
Tell
To I MM
Saila Pod swan Say etillnity mean ...Otto
DeWitt( doe 31100107 task] 7
Creates as . 31119.07417113917
Madded as. 2011107.01106$1050
Delivered** 20 MONO 105RY.
Message nee Ka
Aasdlemett .ln SIM
Mal s be 1Q45
Atuaness I
Attain TAX1 tan
WY nx! Jan
Can ID
serum NYMDOMI NAMADM1 2 W 20000.14. L 9
(All luatfelD10131 NY400911 NAMADM1 N01
650.68 16159/ Dell NYM110611 NAMADMI 103 010(016
I. m bid
T))t fie
Sin 5214
CA JOIDASKINIndUittlblenttld110/
Hob (CA 1ALLIACK ‘0001.16.7A11•60101(.0011111011A181CDIFIVX.4.1711163M00.0211Det
a ss 2
InctIleel
DIrapbs Arm
Fail
LAID 21/16191110.1(0‘40909/CAAXII04132509A
Distrthelle• TO
DODD" Type lace
%Mike.
Pp* Nese
End
LIVID IO MO ( I 21 A
DIstribeeies Ttpe TO
Keelldeet TYPe Asa
Kline 0
DeinWhen need 0
Delepted tali
Arcblved fake
Reid eve
Deleted (An
0 /0094 eve
Comploled Inn
Klerk, Ntmid
Na' 1119 kites
Regent notiketisennes 'tweed Ws.
Regent ttetIfeals•whe• deleted fait
Renew netIkatle•Ine•
I saT ID‘di
rake
Kenn emeilkenta when at e0ed false
Renee ..d&Mkobta
nee pied rake
tn.& t %erne. Al
Inner ID $1322•101 NVMDOMINYMAIKII KC 1656161I 144596114 Id NYMDOM1 AYSIAIMII Mel 0 OKI 6
— TAN
( Ins Pubic
Awns DIGADell BIGDOM1
Conan ID 161014,16.1111
(Ins Ns OW MISSADA.WJL
Fachnbi deaden I
Folder Mellsat
ID 7 NIA0))41 roluom nous I 016e 10
Ns Magus
TM , Mann
SWIM ow
seep TYP9 Noddeired
Page 13043
Ault.
Doe Aar Arbor Now
10Hunastl&17 EDT tread
ze-Arelar Atm_ 1 41.•1" Amin!
Jubarkb...,(AMDrthWear.d.nmAing
Wm*.
Timennetnry Naiad Inc. ics-Aithhe
I Th ." AITInef
Aba-ktkor(AOraiNcOftwircliiint
Anna)
MI948.21 102158 EDT (spinal timal no:minting. Egursed by neinvannind rein.
NICLC.21 102907 FITT Etruic.1 wund mama annul Immtica, neiind neural mum.
) -21 ITD56 EDT Brain , wtru I .ffi.i.Wind Itsiwitil 1,.. mine I nein.. twinvol
201.44‘12 rtom EDT 'scaled min.l nom., namal IF.vrinl I," norml rwurnwl norml
:019-(0.30 00:5151 EDT fmunc.1 win., mond ncirmi ENrBJ t, nine, mina rw 'mai
)120-1:6-36 15.4100 For Nato' 11P<Vtil •INX.ND‘l I NaltD31.11 !Wm.! b>
tIMO1bt PLIVCAMII MUIDOMI
Nxmo-ia 1005 EDT Tag norons %MAI -All ACCItOONI I flagod
31:11.0.‘19 1$T421 EDT Tag BMW°, ‘IXRADM I NCOU1014 I Itoment
Jo.V.0e. IV Mil IT EDT hg 11010003 %MAT"' I AIXREIOND Rnment
MVO -IV 011202 tor lag oororox MMtADM I SOCRDOMI Ropm".
.Netukt. 19 1•37.h. EDT hat BOPOITOT %IXIIALIM I Palt0()%ll *bawd
Page 13044
Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From Google Alerts
To
Date 2019/12/29 18:05
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
bureau of prisons
i9
NEWS
In the Shadow of the Federal Death Chamber, Executions Are on Hold — For
Now
The Intercept
In 1993, soon after she arrived in Terre Haute, the United States Bureau of Prisons announced that the
town would be the site for a new federal death ...
Burbank man sentenced to 12 years for illegal gun, drug possession
Chicago Sun-Times
AM -year-old man was sentenced to 12 years in prison for illegal gun and drug possession. Efren
Gutierrez pleaded guilty to federal drug and firearm ...
Honoring Native traditions behind bars
Santa Fe New Mexican
Following those hearings, Foster said, he met with officials from the Federal Bureau of Prisons and
helped create policies regarding Native American ...
Editorial: Trump had a good year — no, really
The Augusta Chronicle
... Departments of Labor, Education and Justice partnered with the Office of Personnel Management and
Bureau of Prisons to promote second-chance ...
Juelz Santana's Wife Claims He'll Be Released From Prison In Summer 2020
HipHopDX
Petersburg, VA— Juelz Santana's wife Kirnbella says her husband will be getting out of prison sooner
Page 13045
than expected. According to Federal Bureau of ...
Top 10 Posts of 2019
Patheos (blog)
In August, hedge fund operator and accused child sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein died in jail. The Federal
Bureau of Prisons said he hanged himself, ...
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Page 13046
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5E08EADLNYMDOM LNYMADM1.100.170316D.1.1 59D4.1
Message Path xmtMadbox15E08EADLNYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .170316O.1.159D4.1.xml
From Google Akrts
Display Name Goo& Akrts
Email googlealens-norepMa geogle.com
Reply To googkakrts.noreply(4 gcogle.com
Test Goo* Alerts
To
Subject Googie Alert - bureau of proms
Scheduled date 2019.12-291803:10
Creation date 2019.12-291803:10
Modified date 2019-12-30073105
Delivered date 2019.12-29180506
Message she 3498
Attachments sin $5292
Total size 5,8801
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID
5E08EADLNYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.280C048.I.7
230F.lig451E08EADLNYMDOMLNYMADM1.10a1
70316O.1.159I34.1®14.7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type Me
Size 21034
CA 7a2c1588c3975927c4ID188b1492176e5
Hash 2D47A3E8EF3513AA8EAE8A6BAB3DA6AEC4AC45EA8 143C32D65E39IF2A5D385ECB3FDA2C8C
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5E08EADLNYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.2811048. L7
2310.1®455E08EADLNYMOOMLNYMADM1.100.1
7031613.1.159134.1©1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 .0. I.0.1®16
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 34258
CA 8c870544e0141968fIc4dadfltb0HM12
Hash 38)530:W71 BED8113F43818964135B249E1F7E450E E84E191B716F6BDCC184C303AC962101
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID 835B5E40-1106-0000433DISFE66AT108950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nonni
Box type !thus
Return notification %%hen opened fake
Return notification %she n de le te d fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined false
Return notification %%hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Intents] ID 5E08EADLNYMDOMLNYMADMLIC0.170316D.1.1 59D4.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1fit I
Source received
Class Public
Page 13047
Account MI
1540842445516 Location ID
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mal=
II) 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Maim
Type Mailbox
System tme
Share Type NotShared
Page 13048
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2020-014191727±41 EST Created
en-Archive Agent 1-Daly Archive) Job,en-lebs.erGii/OpenNodeon-archningdAWM_I-Daily
=netmai
Generated by Netgovem [en-Archive
Archive!
Jobien-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoicen-archivingo
-nc tma ill
2020-06021130:44 EDT Viewed B0901929.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1 Viewed by
801101829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1
202005-19153431 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Rogow:We
2020-05-19 1437:19 EDT Tag Et0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Rigged
202041602153030 EDT Tag EIOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Responsive
Page 13049
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13050
Sent: Sun, 29 Dec 2019 15:03:10 -0800
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From: Goo gl  Alerts < ooglealerts-noreply@google.00m>
To:
bureau of prisons
NEWS
In the Shadow of the Federal Death Chamber, Executions Are on Hold — For Now
The Intercept
In 1993. soon after she arrived in Terre Haute. the United States Bureau of Prisons announced that the town would be the
site for a new federal death ...
Burbank man sentenced to 12 years for illegal gun, drug possession
Chicago Sun-Times
A 44-year-old man was sentenced to 12 years in prison for illegal gun and drug possession. Oren Gutierrez pleaded guilty
to federal drug and firearm ...
IX1
Honoring Native traditions behind bars
Santa Fe New Mexican
Following those hearings, Foster said, he met with officials from the Federal Bureau of Prisons and helped create 
policies
regarding Native American ...
IN II
Editorial: Trump had a good year— no, really
The Augusta Chronicle
... Departments of Labor, Education and Justice partnered with the Office of Personnel Management and Bureau of
Prisons to promote second-chance ...
• •
Juelz Santana's Wife Claims He'll Be Released From Prison In Summer 2020
HipHopDX
Petersburg, VA - Juelz Santana's wife Kimbella says her husband will be getting out of prison sooner than expected.
According to Federal Bureau of ...
Top 10 Posts of 2019
Patheos (blog)
In August. hedge fund operator and accused child sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein died in jail. The Federal Bureau of 
Prisons
said he hanged himself....
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS teed
Send Feedback
RE: viewing tartaglione cell
From (USANYS)"
To
Date 2019/11/27 11:36
Subject: RE: viewing tartaglione cell
Attachments: TEXT.htrn, Mirnc.822
Thanks for your email and good wishes.
I believe that- is out of the office until next week. Can this wait until then?
I hope that you too have a Happy Thanksgiving.
Take care,
U
Chief, Civil Division
U.S. Attorney's Office, SDNY
86 Chambers Street, 3"I Floor
New York, NY 10007
From:
Sent: Wednesda , November 27, 2019 11:23 AM
To: (USANYS)
Cc:
Subject: Fwd: viewing tartaglione cell
Hi
We may need wall counsel again in the Tartaglione matter in relation to the below site visit request. so
excellently helped us last time in our appearance on the conditions of confinement issue, so I cc'ed her as
well.
Thank you and I wish you and yours a Happy Thanksgiving.
Best,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York. New York 10007
Page 13053
> » Bruce Barket < C > 11/27/2019 11:15 AM >»
As part of our obligations to prepare for the penalty phase (should there be one) of Mr. Tartaglione's
trial, we would like to view the cells (including SHU ) and common areas where he has been held. It's
possible that we will want to take some photographs, but initially we just want to look at the areas
where he has been housed.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[F]
www.barketepstein.corrt
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 13054
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5DDE5FBB.BRODOMI.BROADMI.100.1306C6F I.A 5C0A.1
Message Path nnhislataxe5DDE5FBB.BRODOMI.BROADM1.100.B0656E.I.A5C0A.1.xml
From (USANYS)"
Display Name (USANYS)"
Email
QUID MFF3224-0CIA-0000-8BBB-001438BDA527
Reply To usdoigov
Text (USANYS)"
To
Ce ' M
Subject RE: viewing tartaglicec cell
Scheduled date 2019-11-27 11:36.02
Creation date 2019-11-27 11:36.132
Modified date 2019-11-27 123322
Delis end date 2019-11-27 11:3628
Message size 2262
Attachments sin 29508
Total size 31781
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TF—XT.hun
Content II)
5DDE5FIMIBRODOMI.BROADMI.200.2000089.1.6
9013.10_,t456DDE5FBB.BRODOMLBROADMI.100. I
30656F I.A5C0A.I@II.BRODOMLBROADMI.100 .0.1.0.1(016
Is Inline false
Type foe
Size 9415
CA 9948c081cae35ae140259ba40d7121b8
Rash 717BF2BC4EB0CIC6675DDA6841DE3012353AC6AE CB169E75AB90895F99DE76F45A0FD9DC
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5DDE5FBELBRODOMI.BROADMI.203.20C0089.1.6
9014.1@45DDE5FBB.BRODOMI.BROADMI.100. I
30656E.I.A5C0A.1@1:7.BRODOMLBROADMI.IC0 .0.1.0. 1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 20093
CA c3a393145698510a8d73c631982056d3
Hash 8C3833C I ID7D949F5BB708778A6BD9DI FA57224D 0C40731284556841055F7B9D0AD6821D
Recipients 3
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CAD0419CA-0000-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Displas Name
Email
QUID ('4I 17510-04FF-0000-1331C-M461238DCC96
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4A 1B8282-31F7-0000-B60A-IFDDAB07B0FA
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read we
Deleted false
Opened true
Page 13055
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification .hen opened fake
Return notification .hen deleted false
Return notification hen
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification 'hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DDE5FBB.BRODOMLBROADMI.100.130656E LA 5COA.1(41:7.BRODOMLBROADMLIC0.0.1.0.1Q1 6
Source received
Class Public
Account •.BROADMI.BRODOMI
Location ID 1540842508334
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMA1L
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Maim
ID 7.BRODOMLBROADMI.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Maibox
Type Maims
System true
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 13056
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019.12-10013231 EST Created
crt=Arehive Agent3-Schedukd Zero Day
Arehive2.en-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodetn-archis ogortictmail
Generated by Neigpvem [en-Archive
Agent 3-Scheduled Zero Day
Archh;Zen-Jobs.ensGWOpenNoiesn-archis
itgo-netmai)
2020.05-19153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Rcsponsht
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 13057
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13058
From:
To:
Cc:
Subject: RE: viewing tartaglione cell
Sent: Wed, 27 Nov 2019 16:36:02 +0000
(USANYS)" •c >
Thanks for your email and good wishes.
I believe that. is out of the office until next week. Can this wait until then?
I hope that you too have a Happy Thanksgiving.
Take care,
•
Chief, Civil Division
U.S. Attorney's Office, SONY
86 Chambers Street, 3"1 Floor
New York, NY 10007
From:
Sent: Wednesda November 27, 2019 11:23 AM
To: USANYS
Cc:
Subject: Fwd: viewing tartaglione cell
Hi
We may need wall counsel again in the Tartaglione matter in relation to the below site visit request. so excellently 
helped us
last time in our appearance on the conditions of confinement issue, so I cc'ed her as well.
Thank you and I wish you and yours a Happy Thanksgiving.
Best,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
p:
f:
> » Bruce Barket < > 11/27/2019 11:15 AM >>>
As part of our obligations to prepare for the penalty phase (should there be one) of Mr. Tartaglione's trial, we would 
like to view
the cells (including SHU ) and common areas where he has been held. It's possible that we will want to take some 
photographs,
but initially we just want to look at the areas where he has been housed.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden City, NY 11530
[F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. It 
it is not clear that you
are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, 
dissemination, distribution or
copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, 
please notify us
immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Fwd: Re: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/12/23 11:29
Subject: Fwd: Re: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.httn
They were checking on three things:

1) confirming no investigation into Tartaglione re Epstein (confirmed)
2) getting video of the 7/23/19 suicide attempt (Pina took care of it)
3) checking with SIS whether they still have the rope from that attempt (still pending)
Thanks
>>> 12/23/2019 9:07 AM >>>
Do you need me to do anything on this? Catching up on my emails now....
> » (USANYS)" < > 12/19/2019 8:13 AM > »
- can we do 10:30?
Co-Chief, Narcotics Unit
On Dec 19, 2019, at 07:55, > wrote:
Jason,
I am available to chat today. What time works for you and
Thanks,
Deputy Regional Counsel
Northeast Regional Office
U.S. Customs House
2nd and Chestnut Streets
Philadel hia, PA 19106
p:
f:
>». (USANYS)" a> 12/19/2019 7:52 AM > »
- any chance we can chat today? ppears to be out until next week and there are
some issues we need to close the loop on with you that we had been discussing while you were
still at MCC.
Page 13061
Co-Chief, Narcotics Unit
Begin forwarded message:
From:' (USANYS)" <
Date: December 18, 2019 at 15:40:58 EST
To:
Cc:
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
>
following up. Can we speak tomorrow (Thursday)? Some issues came up
at the conference today and we need to address them with you.
Co-Chief, Narcotics Unit
On Dec 17, 2019, at 13:50,
wrote:
(USANYS) <
— Right before left, we had discussed with him a
few questions from defense counsel related to Tartaglione's
penalty phase. Do you have a few minutes to jump on a call
today? Should take no more than 5 minutes, but we have a
court conference tomorrow so would be good to touch base.
Thanks!
Co-Chief, Narcotics Unit
United States Attorney's Office
Southern District of New York
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York, New York 10007
Tel:
Page 13062
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5E00A529.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.130656E.1.4 03AA.I
Message Path xmthlailboxL5E00A529.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.130656E.1.403AA.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUI 0 2750CAD04:19CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Fwd: Re: Tartaglione
Scheduled date 2019-12-23 1129:42
Creation date 2019-12-23 1129:42
Modified date 2019-12-23 11:3827
Delivered date 2019-12-23 1129.46
Message size 2320
Attachments slit 5427
Total size 7758
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.him
Content ID
5ECOA529.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.20000A0.1.1
57B51.163)455E00A529.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.103.
B0656E.1.403AA.1@1:7.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 5427
Date 2019-12-23 0529;41
CA 7dae09004923c3138c5Id7c51302654F6
Hash ID327065EC459FFA26AEAD76EC0199B6C0593E78 B3946A5AE5C3B3143D5AEAICA3AD5527
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name _
Ismail
CUM C4117510-04FF-0000-B31C-4A46EB8DCC96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Intox
Return notification uhen opened false
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification uhen
completed false
Return notification when declined false
Return notification %%hell
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5B30A529.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.130656E.I.4 03AA.1®11.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@j1
Source received
Class Public
Account ;ROADMI.BRODOMI
Location ID 1540842508334
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type hatbox
Page 13063
System
Share Type
UM
NotShared
Page 13064
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2020.01-01 083649 EST Created
cteArchive Agent 1-Daly Archiva
Job,cn-lebs.cn-GiV0penNodeon-archningdAgent-
=netmai
Generated by Netgovem [at -Archive
I -Daily Archi.c2
Jobrn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNode.co-arclivingo
mama)
2020-06-02 II:3428 EDT Viewed 80P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Viewed by
BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI
202005-191536e6 EDT Tag Ii0P01700.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-06-02 1534A0 EDT Tag FlOPOIR29.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Responsive
202045-19 14A1$6 EDT Tag Et0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fhggcd
Page 13065
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/22 10:44
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Doesn't look like he was seen yet.
Psy.D.
Chief Psychologist
U.S. Department of Justice/
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Office:
Fax:
E-mail:
>>> 7/19/2019 9:25 AM >>>
Can ou lease have him seen for his request for 7 I understand he has not expressed
any concerns in the past, but he is facing the death penalty and is currently in SHU facing
disciplinary charges. Thanks!
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
f:P=
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
he found a dead rodent in his bed. Apparently he accidently smothered it while sleeping. The lights in
the cell are fre uentl off durin the day and on at ni ht. Nick has asked to be given medication to
. His
Page 13066
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[F]
www.barketeostein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Bark
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
PM
; Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if ou are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/201911:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Page 13067
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the dosing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci NY 11530
-
M
Barket Epsteinsom
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) < > wrote:
Page 13068
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
To:
Cc:
tonyricco
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:22 PM
(USANYS)
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Jason,
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
- M
Barket Fpctein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
(USANYS)
>;
Leisenrin
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal I. As a result, the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to , and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket <
Cc: ton
(USANYS
>;
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
›- Aida Leisenring
Page 13069
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
f.
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
Page 13070
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitigations specialists also waited 2 hours. Aida and I were Lucky in that we
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
Page 13071
message and all its attachments
Page 13072
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D35938B.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1696E30.1.6 0598.1
Message Path xml/41a3xa/5D359388.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI,100.1696E30.1.60598.1.7anl
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB000-000C-00008B6E-1B003A002D00
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tartagbone
Scheduled date 2019-07-22 10:4427
Creation date 2019-07-22 109427
Modified date 2019-07-23 08:05:43
Delis e red date 201947-22 10,4427
Message size 15192
Attachments size 31906
Total size 47109
Attachments 1
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D35938B.NYMDOMINYMADMI.200.2000051.1.F
34CD.1€0455D35938B.NYMDOMILNYMADM1.100.1
696E30.1.60598.1®1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type Ile
Size 31906
Date 2019-07-22 06:4429
CA 28316e019e0e312617656342f02M033
Hash A2CA2123B018360AEC194E155F28FCE4D8CDEC5F8 CA59AA74D6DDB2ADCB38E72,325CRIMA
Recipients 5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 27500: o trx A.0000A8F4-1ACF31E47575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient fype User
Delivered 2019-07-2210:4427
DonnloadedBylnirdParty 2019-07-22 104428
Opened 2019-07-22 12:3357
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 835B5E40-11C6-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delisered 2019-07-22109427
Donnloack dByThirdPany 2019-07-22 10,4428
Opened 2019-07-22 1228:11
Recipient
Display Name
Email
t l 1 D A4423FD0-0824-00C0-B58A-448148E79444
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
De lis e red 2019-07-22 109427
Opened 2019-07-22 109827
Recipient
Display Name
Email
MID 6FEC15F0-25074000-8293-9E01030038CF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-07-22109427
Opened 201947-22 123000
Page 13073
Recipient
Display Name
Email
MD 5ECEI1C0-09D443000-BBEI-7C3A87597621
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'Fype User
Delivered 2019-07-2210:4437
Opened 2019-07-23 0805A4
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened truc
Completed fake
Security Nonml
Box type Sent Items
Return notification sshen opened fake
Return notification sshen deleted fake
Return notification sshen
completed fake
Return notification sshen declined fake
Return notification sshen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D35938B.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.6 059S. I@I:7.NYMDOM LNYMADM 1.100.0.1.0.1@l 6
Source sent
Class Public
Account M. NYMADM I.NYMDOMI
Location II) 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder MaiLox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Madbox
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 13074
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-02 211/338 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Job.en-lcbs.co-GWOpenNodetn-arck"--Agent_1-Daily
setmai
Generated by Netinail Inc. [cn=Archive
Archisr3
Job.en-Jobs.co-GWOpenNoie.co—archisinga
-neuna ill
2019-08-21 133523 EDT Exported netmaineunatneunai Exported by netmailmetmaineumil
2019-09-16 153433 EDT Exported netmainetweinetrrai Exported by netmaineurralneurad
2020415-19 153531 EDT Tag 80901703.MXRADM 1.MXRDOM 1 Revert:Kt
2020-05-1914M136 EDT Tag DOP01703.NOCRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 13075
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/22 10:43
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Hi, I wrote Dtabout this last week and I know he intended on seeing him.
Psy.D.
Chief Psychologist
U.S. Department of Justice/
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Office:
Fax:
E-mail:
>» 7/19/2019 9:25 AM > »
Can ou lease have him seen for his request for 7 I understand he has not expressed
any concerns in the past, but he is facing the death penalty and is currently in SHU facing
disciplinary charges. Thanks!
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New Yor New York 10007
p:
f.
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
he found a dead rodent in his bed. Apparently he accidently smothered it while sleeping. The lights in
the cell are fre uentl off durin the day and on at ni ht. Nick has asked to be given medication to
. His
Page 13076
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[F]
www.barketeostein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Bark
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
PM
; Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if ou are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/201911:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Page 13077
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the dosing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci NY 11530
-
M
Barket Epsteinsom
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) < > wrote:
Page 13078
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
To:
Cc:
tonyricco
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:22 PM
(USANYS)
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
- M
Barket Fpctein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
Leisenrin
(USANYS)< >
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal I. As a result, the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to , and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket <
Cc: ton
(USANYS
>;
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
>: Aida Leisenring
>;
Page 13079
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
f.
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
Page 13080
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitigations specialists also waited 2 hours. Aida and I were Lucky in that we
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
Page 13081
message and all its attachments
Page 13082
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D359349.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1696E30.1.6 0597.1
Message Path xmIrMatoxi5D359349.NYMDOMLNYMADMI,100 .1696E30.1.60597.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB000-000C-0000-8B6E-1B003A002D00
Reply To
Text
Edge
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tartagbone
Scheduled date 2019-07-22 10:4321
Creation date 2019-07-22 109321
Modified date 2019-07-23 0805:18
Delis e red date 2019-07-22104321
Message size 15237
Attachments silt 31961
Total size 47209
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.bbn
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D359349.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.20X051.1.F
34C6.1®455D359349.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
696E30.1.60597.I ®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type tie
Size 31961
Date 2019-07-22 064323
CA 21dfcbe623del la4b2714f3c5b878498
Hash OEBBO2A488DEB9A2FA33673A9629FD8ED338B36C BA 10F561D8CFA 13963C9269A79092514
Recipients 5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CA Do trx A-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Eype User
Delivered 2019-07-22 10:4321
DownloadedBy ThirdParty 2019-07-22 104322
Opened 2019-07-22 12:3355
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 835B5E40-11C6-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delisered 2019-07-22104321
DoonloackdByThirdParty 201947-22 104322
Opened 2019-07-22 122824
Recipient
Display Name
Email
t t II) A4423FD0-0824-00C0-858A-448148E79444
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
De Hs e red 2019-07-22 104321
Opened 2019-07-22 1048:18
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 6FECI5F0-25074000-8293-9E01030038CF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-07-22104321
Opened 201947-22 213452
Page 13083
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CLAD 5ECEI1C0-09D4-0000-BBEI-7C3A87597621
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'Fype User
Delivered 2019-07-2210,4321
Opened 2019-07-23 0805:19
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Nornul
Box type Sent Items
Return notification sshen opened fake
Return notification sshen deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed false
Return notification sshen declined false
Return notification alien
accepted lase
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D359349.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.6 0597.1@1:7.NYMDOM LNYMADMI. 100.0.1.0.1@I 6
Source sent
Class Public
Account NYMADMLNYMDOMI
Location II) 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder MaBaix
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Madbox
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 13084
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-02 210338 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3 Job.en-lcbs.crGWOpenNodetn-arck"--Agent_1-Daily
setmai
Generated by Netina0 Inc. [cn=Archive
Archisr3
Job.en-Jobs.co-GWOpenNoie.co—archisinga
-neuna ill
2019-08-21 133523 EDT Exported netmaineunatneunai Exported by netmailmetmaineumil
2019-09-16 153434 EDT Exported netmainetweinetrrai Exported by netmaineurralneurad
202041519 153531 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM 1.MXRDOM 1 Revert:Kt
2020-05-1914M156 EDT Tag DOP01703.NOCRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 13085
Fwd: Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
2019/08/21 10:51
Fwd: Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
TEXT.htm, Fwd: Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr
FYI myself and legal will most likely attend.
Page 13086
Properties
Property Value
Nlessagell) 5D5D2241.NERDOMINERADMI.100.1367333.1.1 49E1.1
Message Path mnleabivet \NEW:blast • New YcrIA5D5D2241.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.136733 3.1.149E1.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
la II) 70608620-10E1-0000-94744AEAFTT74805
Reply To jpetrucc4bqxgov
Text
To
Subject Fwct Older it USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Scheduled date 2019-08-21 105141
Creation date 2019-08-21 105141
Modified date 2019-11-04 1651:30
Delivered date 2019-08-21 105146
Message size 50
Attachments size 950
Total site 1011
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.larn
Name TEMA=
Content ID
5D5D2241.NERDOMLNERADM1.200.20000CA.1.8
9119.1@455D5D2241.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.1 367333.1.149E1.1@liB6858KPETDOMI.PETA
DM 1.100.B67333.1.8512.1@l3
Is Inline fake
T)ye file
Size 264
Date 2019-08-21 065143
CA 49015651c9a6183d71899428c59bef46
Hash FI6B040aKC1722AECB5833E03A4AAE18A68BDCE 536850732AECO7A55Et39AF9238F14121
Attachment NA:Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Name Fwd: Order it USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Content II)
5D5D2241.NERDOMLNERADMI.200.20300CA.1.8
911A.10a)491D5D2241.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.1 367333.1.149E1.1@l5B68581:4.PEMOMIPETA
DM I.100.1367333.1.8512.1 13
Is Inline fake
Type message
Site 686
Date 2019-08-21 09-3225
CA d6bed2b8916290972186eceb35fded29
Hash wcffimPATnIclfYuR75xAnilfq/03nQv
Recipients I
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
UT II) 2F982B80-14C3-0000-9B47-BF62C05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box two Inbox
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification when
accepted false
Archise X'ersion 5.3
Internal ID 5D5D2241.NERDOMLNERADMLIC0.1367333.1.149E1.104)1:586858F4.PETDOMI.PETADMI.100.13
67333.1.85111(013
Page 13087
Source received
Class Pubic
Account MI
1540843020946 Location Ill
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder but - New York
ID 5B6858F4.PETDOM LPETADM I .1001367333.12 512.1@1 3
Name lust - New Yin
Type Normal
System false
Share Type NotShared
Published 201W11/4-2131A0
Page 13088
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-12-31 1726:16 CST Created
en-Archive Agent 3-Scheduled Zero Day
Dash ten-Jobstn:GWOpenNodextrarchivi gent-M
go-netriell
Generated by Netgovem [clArclive
kci ahada Zara Day i rash i.e.n-Jobs,en=CWOpenNode,cnrchiii
go-neimail
202005-19 15:1705 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I .MXRDOMI Responsiv
2020-05-19 15/839 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI .MXRDOMI
Responsivee
2020-05-19 143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.84XRADM I .MXRDOMI nagged
Page 13089
Fwd: Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
From
To
Date 2019/08/2109:32
Subject: Fwd: Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
----- Ori ' al messy a ------ „
From: "
Date: 8/21/19 9:07 AM GMT-05:00
To: >
Subject: Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Page 13090
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D5D2241.NERDOM LNERADMI.200.20000A0.1.6 4985.1
From
Display Name
Emil
UUID 2750CADO09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Test
To
Subject Fwd: Order ii USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Scheduled date 2019.08-21 091, 05
Creation dale 2019.08-21 043225
Modified date 2019.08-21 10:51:45
Delis end date 2019.08-21 09:3229
Message she 403
Attachments sin 0
Total she 0
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.Ium
Content ID
5D5D2241.NERDOMLNERADM1.200.20000A0.1.6
4982.1®45D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADMI.200.2
0000A0.1.64985.1@ 1 5D5D2241.NERDOM 1.NERA DM1.200.20000CA.1.8911A.1@495D5D2241.NE
RDOMI.NERADMI-100.1367333.1.149E1.1@l5B 6858F4.PETDOMI.PETADM1.100.1367333.1.851
2.1@13
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 686
CA 8a7a3a4c6de793f60741a9c71.833fIla4
Hash 2C6D40928743E3071F4CF_63A9C0400DE7CFC7C3F 3CAEB3DBFA5387EDDX3CBD60A7C3DF3F
Attachment Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstei 19 cr 490
Name Order ii USA v. Jeffrey Epsicit 19 cr 490
Content ID
5D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADS41.200.20000A0.1.6
4983.1®493D5D2241.NERDOMLNERADMI.200.2
0000A0.1.64985.1@l6D5D2241.NERDOMLNERA DM1.200.20000CA.1.8911A.1@492D5D2241.NE
RDOMI.NERADM1.100.1367333.1.149E1.1@l1B 6858f4.PETDOMI.PETADM1.103.1367333.1.851
2.1(0,13
Is Inline false
Type message
Size 158628
Date 2019-08-21 0906:C0
CA eeb996.3211dcife2484989937c776e8ec
!lash /8ediaTz7AWOLMVIMCD+J+Ytw
Recipients 3
Recipient
Display Name
Email
WAD 70608620.10E1-0000.947A-4AEAFT774805
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4A2ACC80.1010.0000-98AE-15D55568C865
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 15A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A6064I5CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delis e ry until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read false
Page 13091
Deleted fake
Opened false
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box tspe Inbox
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification when
accepted false
Archise Version 5.3
Internal ID
5D5132241.NERDOMLNERADMI.200.20000A0.1.6 4985.1@l3D5D2241.NERDOMLNERADMI.200.20
000CA.1.8911A.1®495D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERA DM 1.100.1367333.1.149E1.1@1:5B6858F4.PET
DOM LPETADM1.100.1367333.1.85121@l3
Source received
Class Public
Account 1ERADMI.NERDOMI
Location ID 1540843020946
Class Name GW.MESSAGE-MAIL
Enclosing Folders 0
Page 13092
Audits
Date i Action i Auditor Note
Page 13093
Order in USA V. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
From
To
Date 2019/08/21 09:07
Subject: Order in USA v. Jeffrey Epstein 19 cr 490
Attachments: epstein aug 21 Order.pdf, Mime.822
Please see attached Order.
Judge Berman asked me to invite you and the new warden to the hearing.
(See attached file: epstein aug 21 Order.pdf)
Page 13094
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADMI.200.20000IB.I.I 8833.1
From
Display Name
Email
Reply To
Text
To
Order in USA v. Jeffrey 46leil 19 cr 490 Subject
Scheduled date 2019-08-21 090640
Creation date 2019.08-21 090600
Modified date 2019.08-21 103195
Delis e red date 2019-08-21 090736
Message size 146
Attachments size 0
Total Nib., 0
Attachments 2
Attachment cost*, aug 21 Order.pdf
Name cmicin aug 21 Order.pdf
Content ID
5D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADMI.200.20000IB.I.1
8B30.1®453D5132241.NERDOMI.NERADMI.200.2
000M8.1.1111133.1®13D5D2241.NERDOMI.NEftA DM1.200.X000A0.1.64983.1®493D5D2241.NE
ROOM LNERADMI.200.20000A0.1.64985. 1@l3D 5027ALNERDOMI.NERADMI.200.20000CA.1.891
IA.1@493D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.136
7333.1.149E1.1@l3B6858F4.PETDOMI.PETADM 1.100.1367333.1.8512.1®13
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 65124
CA d33adfc44eb4fdaddae4ff381a199d3
Hash D74C9F0F26D32FDF6IFBDB1015F4D206BBA459C3 1316738C066036649D63D24A82739235
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADMI.200.200001B.I.I
8B31.1@455D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADMI.200.2
00001B.1.1B833.1®BD5D2241.NERDOMI.NERA DM1.200.20000A0.1.64983.1@493D5D22A1.NE
RDOMI.NERADM1.203.20000A0.1.64985.1@l1D 5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADM1.200.20000CA.1.891
IA.14)495D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.136
7333.1.149E1.1@l5B6858F4.PETDOMI.PETADM 1.100. I 367333.1.8512.1®13
Is Inline false
Type fle
SIM 93504
CA 4aceefb881091c8b315d3024e9362613.5
HIS h 9496F1109CD0DA43DF6FA201241E6F6973E4F824 697B5F08A1A3FBF2A5C7505F88257726
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CHU 27sta Al 41 \ -0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay de lire ry until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read false
Deleted false
Opened fake
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Intox
Return notification sshen opened fake
Return notification "hen deleted false
Return notification sshen
completed false
Return notification "hen declined false
Return notification alien
accepted lake
Archive Version 5.3
Page 13095
Internal ID
5D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADMI.200.2000018.1.1 BB33.1@l3D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERADM1.200.20
000A0.1.6498.3.1@495D5D2241.NERDOMI.NERA DMI.200.20000A0.1.6498.5.1®13D5D2241.NER
DOM I.NEFtADM I .200.20000CA.1.8911A.1t6495D 5D2241.NERDOM I .NERADMI.100.1367333.I.149
EI.I@ I3B6858F4.PETDOM I .PETADM1.100.B67 3331.8512.1@l3
Source received
Class Public
Account NtRADMLNERDOM1
Location ID • 42X ii) "c
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MA IL
Enclosing Folden 0
Page 13096

╭───────────────────────────────────────── Page 645, Image 1 ──────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ [SDSD2241 NERDOMINERADMI_200.200001B.1.1 BB33.1@1SDSD2241, NERDOMI.NERADMI.20020                     │
│                                                                                                      │
│ tnternal 1D [000A0. 1.64983. 1@-49SDSD2241, NERDOMI NERA DMI, 200 200000. 1.64985. 1@ 15DSD2241, NER │
│ DOMI.NERADMI,200,20000CA. 8911. 1@249'SD $2241, NERDOMI NERADMI. 1001367333. 1,149                   │
│ El.1@1SB68S8F4,PETDOMIPETADMI. 100.1367 333.1.8512.1@13                                              │
│                                                                                                      │
│ Source received                                                                                      │
│                                                                                                      │
│ Chass Pubic                                                                                          │
│                                                                                                      │
│ ‘Account a                                                                                           │
│                                                                                                      │
│ Location 1D                                                                                          │
│                                                                                                      │
│ (Class Name [GWMESSAGE MAT                                                                           │
│                                                                                                      │
│ Enclosing Folders o                                                                                  │
│                                                                                                      │
│ Page 13096                                                                                           │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Audits
Date i Action i Auditor Note
Page 13097
Mail Attachment
epstein aug 21 Order.pdf
Page 13098
Case 1:19-cr-00490-RMB Document 48 Filed 08/21/19 Page 1 of 1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
X
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
-against-
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Government.
Defendant.
IUSDC SDNY
DOCUMENT
ELECTRONICALLY FILED
' DOC #:
DATE FILED:
ORDER
19 Cr 490
The Court will conduct a brief hearing on Tuesday, August 27,2019 at 10:30 a.m. in
connection with the none prosequi order proposed to the Court on August 19, 2019 by the United
States Attorney.
The Court believes that where, as here, a defendant has died before anyjudgment has
been entered against him, the public may still have an informational interest in the process by
which the prosecutor seeks dismissal of an indictment.
At the hearing, Counsel for the Government and for the deceased Defendant, Jeffrey
Epstein, will be heard. Counsel for the victims and the victims will also be heard, if they wish to
be.
The heating will be held in Courtroom 17B.
Dated: New York, New York
August 21, 2019
RICHARD M. BERMAN, US.D.J.
Re: counsel has ing difficulty meeting with client
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
Thank you.
2019/07/07 18:58
Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with
client
TEXT.htm
San from my Wrenn. Somwmg Galaxy smanphone
From:
Dal • 7/7/196:22 PM GMT-05:00
To:
Subject: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>>> ' 07/07/2019 18:22 >>>
I have verified Martin Weinberg is an attorney in good standing in Massachusetts. He is permitted to visit Jeffrey 
Epstein.
Sem from my Verizon. Samsung Galaxy smonphonc
Original messa a --
From: r Date: 7/7/19 6:18 PM GMT-05:00
To:
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with clientMassachusetts
From:
Sent: Sunda Ju 07
To:
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Sony M, just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
Sent from my Verinm, Samsung Galaxy sntartphonc
From:
Dot -
To: maihma> , aloia>>
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
2019 18:18
07/07/2019 18:18 >>>
>>> 07/07/2019 17:36 >>>
With apologies for the weekend email. we have a defendant. Jeffrey Epstein, who was arrested last night and is currently
being detained at MCC, and is c
of-state.
We're concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any defendant) and so I wane
its very much,
Page 13100
Ingertles
ToSerb Wet
Mtsntl0 A22COINYMDOMINYIMDMI IDA IRSNIEISFNSI
Mann Pod, 1023101)1 'MOW
IM
MOD ?e
Emil
I, DID 40AASIMAYDWAM00
Re T. Db•AleSeesysios
Vol
T.
SSD , Re (ousel horeplil des room soh ket
Sehesked dam !11907. 7tassio
(Roan doe 9190707 O
Me lo n.* 20.007.(0 TORO
Delon.** 20,1074? IMMO
Mess Oar MD
An/thefiln fin S051
Tad sbe ink
ANIONNIMb i
Atlas sm& rva km
Nese TESTA=
Cameos ID
5DORICONYMDOMI NYMADMI NO SOSAS. I 9
CARS. lMNSIJLMM10NYM110MI SYNNIIMI MI I
Ml6E I DUD. lsI/WM.0AD RAMADA° MO 0101u16

I. lam bin
T)1* He
Mn 'OS.'
CA 00!tkINDIOISISOSMTYV
Hob CATIODALYIYDPOSI 'A 0 SAINICISM•2571.10(9AMOCIISIDOSI9ONDAACIF
Reelplems
Rectie•I
Mobs Aar
De
nieD ZOO AIXSOW A.DDISAIRRIA(13I A7573
MDR •
Re at Ott

0. 0.eM WItWOI ISSI.10
DensaloakdRyllietrom 2019-0741 IRSIAI
OPeRci
Emit 0
Delete en mail 0
&Data( Jibe
ARharr0 DSc
Real toe
Dated (MR
Ded Dm
Complotd DSc
Set Pima,
RID DI• Fts Dna
on avelloaler • seed OM

N. on melleselsole•delmed NW
R. ;ern esellkailaste•
...RIOS
Cabe
D  satIlltml•• • elected Dlae
Rows .MY.wk.wl.
mo et Felt
Arehart Amiss A
lei nu( ID b:IIFO NYMDOMI.NYMADMI. 1W I6(Y.TEI.SFNS IMITTNY/MIOMI NYNIADIAL MO IA IMI 6
0.mM sea
Cl.. rek
Amur ANADDII DANDOMI
Iseselers ID ISIDsCRO.
(10* Ns CAS Mt Y101 MAIL
FatImlar /earn
Folder Maas
ID 7 NYMIDOM I NYMADM LIDOS I 0 I lo
Nes Malta
T).• Mots
System uw
Skeet Tot N'LLM.m0
Page 13101
Avis
Dale Maas Arbor Note
21/114749 Int= EDT Crean!
arArclar Agin_ I Oats Archql
Ne.crktwan-CAMDImi ,aJdearsranwpAl ca -
-rsmai
Simenied by Nasal Y[. lco•Aithq
I Th ly Archive)
AbtarlankcirelKqeSNodesralllinlq
-annuli
N. 1940621 I131:14 EDT Lq.nol ' we Ind neismintund lquieJ by rc unaincinsisnal
lillial2 'TINS EDT Eqq,1 wcsul mow* ruI flq•snlbs nomaincinq nom,
:01%09- nle Iql EDT Ill.nol venal nasal Mil. U i t-Witli b). IltlITOIMIIII“ MIMI
N:04649 SOT'S For lag WIWI CA \MAIN I NIXRCOM I lbssod
]OMFI9 Ik1114 EDT lag BOPOPOl ‘IMAIlM I NaltIDOM I Roponat
lierSOF.I9 IS-3201 CDT lag 1RMO14a NIXILPLOM I SOOIDOM I Req.:tent
:11:00.19 SOUS tor lag WKS /CO SWUM LAVIRLIONII 'bawd
31$04S19 Iflall EDT lq SOPOIIIGAI/OtAl/MIAIXRDOMI illaPant
Page 13102
Fstd: counsel having difficult, meeting nith client
From
To
Date
Subject: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with
client
Attachments: TEXT.htm
2019/07/07 18:58
Sera from my Wilma, Samna Galaxy smanphone
From:
Dat • 7/7/19 6:22 PM GMT-05:00
To:Subject: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>»==. 07/07/2019 18:22 >>>
I have verified Marlin Weinberg is an attorney in good standing in Massachusetts. lie is permitted to visit Jeffrey 
Epstein.Sent from my Verizon, Samsun
•c-/div>•cdiv>
</div><!— originalMessage -->••ccliv>— Original message -------</divxdiv>From:
<shy>
>>> •= 1>• 07/07/2019 18:18 >»
Massachusetts
From:
To:
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Sorry just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smariphone
From: •t <mailio >>
To: <math° >. < <mailtoa
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>» " 07/07/2019 17:36 >»
With apologies for the weekend entail, we have a defendant. Jeffrey Epstein. who was arrested last night and is 
currently being detained at MCC. and is e
of-state.
We're concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any defendant) and so I wane
its very much,
Page 13103
Mrs
..be M e.t1
...ma) 91)22.11:01 MN MCOM1 NYMMX01.10116.53961E U.STAM .1
Men.lePalk MYI.J, IOW NYMADMI IN. 116]06F.I.YMI.Ii
Ora
DI•0•5 ?e
Dr
(LID vo w191i 0:1069101:02001(0200
R.py T.
Tell
T.
Svirel Fadsviamtlisom ell M. u map Ookm
Sebeeked Mae 31790747 1131517
(Realm RS 3119074171101217
added as. 2011107-01106$1050
beloved al 20190747 110625
Mess sbe YR*
Asseclami Om 5D.
Tad .I /015
Auml••••6
Attain reri ltm
Mese TEXI.106
Cameos ID
m3C01.NYMDOMINYIIODMl YR ROOM& 1 9
COO 16.45:61)Th1(01 HYMN/MI 1014110.41 MO 1
65)96E1 Mal Oat 7 NINCOMI htkIADM1 IOD 0101u 1n

1. 1.4 fad
Tll* SL
Mae SMI
(A M770:6/4 1fkN1NOba0ek9.`0
Hash WA IA BMW I 71 PI L 11011 MOIVXM4.1711763M00.0211
Redress 2
ReCTIMM
Mph, ‘assm
"SIM
LTILI 201)A S 1(0640(0910l -OW 103-1 5
DkuYwk.Tlpt TO
Reet it8n 7R5 Lao
Denoted '2019 4747 1692$
Dombededllylbletrens 101907.07 IS26
°Pesci .201907472047*
pied 20194007 M7•705
Renpral
Dimples some I
(mill
came:ma moat 1.3e216,16/1DTC I 1. ID
Mon...then Tip TO
R.e a T,
Deftest., M19.07.0711156-5
Ilsmabeskal Illnllsots V1907.714926
OPOR0 2019.07.02051020
Cmdre 0
Delo401mo well 0
Datillid a
Ardis eel lake
Real true
Deified Mn
ak d ow
Comploed OW
See
Res Ole Seth
Itelm• Illiarke •memed •
Rate mstillodeenthe• *Wed OW
Rena nolfkaileales
seolgos V
OW
WellIrri ni4111.000•Endtctotad lake
Rome millIcalmosbe•
wet ed false
Ant., Woks 53
hind ID 102.2.9101NTSIE() 1 7ITMACS11.101165 1.5 1 LAC %I SARNI VIIADM 1100 0 10 14 1 6
Sate
Owl ARM
ACORNS
Leta*. ID  MMvw.
nes Nem
OW
I ado* *Mtn
folder
ID 7 NVIADOMI YMADM1.1010 10 11616
Mau Maas
TAR AlsRso
System Urn
Share T1pe 26.61issed
Page 13104
Avis
Dale Maas Arbor Note
21/114749 Int= EDT Crean!
arArclar Agin_ I Oats Archql
Ne.crktwan-CAMDImi ,aJdearsranwpAl ca -
-rsmai
Simenied by Nasal Y[. lco•Aithq
I Th ly Archive)
AbtarlankcirelKqeSNodesralllinlq
-annuli
N. 1940621 I131:14 EDT Lq.nol ' we Ind neismintund lquieJ by rc unaincinsisnal
lillial2 'TINS EDT Eqq,1 wcsul mow* ruI flq•snlbs nomaincinq nom,
:01%09- nle Iql EDT Ill.nol venal nasal Mil. U i t-Witli b). IltlITOIMIIII“ MIMI
N:04649 SOT'S For lag WIWI CA \MAIN I NIXRCOM I lbssod
liilliq-I9 Ikll:I4 EDT lag BOPOPOl ‘IMAIlM I NaltIDOM I Roponat
lierSOF.I9 IS-3201 CDT lag 110101,0 NIXILPLOM I SOOIDOM I Req.:tent
:11:00.19 SOUS tor lag WKS /CO SWUM LAVIRLIONII 'bawd
31$04S19 Iflall EDT lq SOPOIIIGAI/OtAl/MIAIXRDOMI illaPant
Page 13105
Fwd: Suicide Watch/Psych Observation Update
From
To
Date 2019/08/10 19:13
Subject: Fwd: Suicide Watch/Psych Observation Update
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Sent from my Verizon. Samsung Galaxy smarrphone
message
From:
Date: 7/30/19 12:30 PM GMT-05:00
Page 13106
<Espy /61gaoi.com>
Subject: Suicide Watch/Psych Observation Update
>» ' 07/30/2019 12:30 >»
Inmate Epstein #76318-
054 is being taken off of Psych Observation and needs to be housed with an appropriate cellmate.
Suicide Watch
None
Psych Observation
None
Thank you,
Page 13107
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D4F173C.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.165396E.1.5 Al9E.1
Message Path imil/Maiboxi5D4F173C.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .165396E.1.5A19E.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 9D77B2D0-19C1-0000-A989-0200000058D0
Reply To
Text
To
End: Suxide Watch/Psych Observation Update Subject
Scheduled date 2019-08-10 19:1146
Creation date 2019-08-10 19:1146
Modified date 201908-1019.7:19
Delivered date 2019-08-10 19:131:10
Message size 2967
Attachments size 3816
Total size 6794
Attachments I
Attachment TF-XT.htm
Name TEXT.hirn
Content ID
5D4F173C.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000038.1.9
E968.1@45:5D4F173C.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1
65396E.1.5A19E.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline fake
'type file
Size 3816
3a235391a0ac2107f0dee837dd400383
Hash 803C39FB32AFC9EF431692D5E2B79354CB18C5E2 1A00EBBCFF187DCC777FEC4BDIC564BD
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UtT1O 610E935O0B4F-0000•AB39•FSOF2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08-1019:1300
DonnloadedByThirdParty 2019-08-10 191301
Opened 2019-08-10 19:16:42
Deleted 2019-08-10 19:17:19
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read nue
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification ashen opened false
Return notification ashen deleted fake
Return notification ashen
completed fake
Return notification ashen declined false
Return notification ashen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D4F173C.NYMDOMLNYMADMI-100.165396E-1.5 Al9E.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI-1000.1.0.16t1
Source sent
Class Public
Account DANADMI.DANDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maibox
Page 13108
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0. I @ 16
Name Maim
Type Maims
System tme
Share Type NotShared
Page 13109
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23 1724A7 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Joixen-lebs.erGWOpenNodnen-archivingx,(Agent_
se mi
Generated by Netzreil Inc. [cn=Archive
1 -Daily Archive3
Johen-Jobs.co-GWOpenNode.cn—archivingo
-nctinail]
2019-09-16 1521:50 EDT Exported netmainetmainetnni Exported by netmainetmainetimil
2019-09-17 132121 EDT Exported netmainettnainettnai Exported by netmaineurrailneunad
2020.05.191437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.Al XRI)OM I Fla gged
2020-05-19 14:34134 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADM i.roxR DOM Flagged
2020.0549 15:34:52 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I .A1X 8 DOMI Responsive
2020-0519153230 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.A DR I HMI Responsive
202005.09153254 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.A1XRDOM I Responsive
Page 13110
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/19 07:22
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Good morning all,
Per the below list of complaints please look into the following:
Facilities - can you look into the alleged leak in his cell, no. 201-106?
Safety - can you let me know the last time 9 South had pest control?
SIS - can you follow up with FBI on his incident report? Can you also look into whether the alleged rodent
on his bed might have been his cellmate accusing him of being an snitch?
SHU - can you swap out his books? Can you check on the lights in his cell? Was his paper discovery
located? Is he claiming he is still missing any?
Thanks all,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York New York 10007
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
he found a dead rodent in his bed. Apparently he accidently smothered it while sleeping. The lights in
the cell are fre uentl off durin the day and on at ni ht. Nick has asked to be given medication to
. His
Page 13111
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[F]
www.barketeostein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Bark
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
PM
; Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if ou are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/201911:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Page 13112
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the dosing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci NY 11530
-
M
Barket Epsteinsom
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) < > wrote:
Page 13113
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
To:
Cc:
tonyricco
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:22 PM
(USANYS)
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Jason,
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
- M
Barket Fpctein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
Leisenrin
(USANYS)< >
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal I. As a result, the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to , and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket <
Cc: ton
(USANYS
>;
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
›- Aida Leisenring
Page 13114
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
f.
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
Page 13115
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitigations specialists also waited 2 hours. Aida and I were Lucky in that we
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
Page 13116
message and all its attachments
Page 13117
Properties
Property Value
Nlessage 1 D 5D316F9D.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1178r85.1.B 7EA.1
Message Path xm8Trashr5D316F9D.NYMDOMI,NYMADM1,100.1 326C35.1.87EA.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
I I To
I
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tanaglame
Scheduled date 2019-07-19 07:22%
Creation date 2019-07.19072205
Modified date 201907-19135559
Delis cord date 201907-19072206
Message size 15216
Attachments size 31869
Total size 47096
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.hon
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D316F9D.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20800A0.1.1
456B1. Eg453D316F9D.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.
1326C35.1.B7EA.I@IS.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 31869
Date 2019-07-19032138
CA flc74814a8a8cebb07f41)45127245716
Hash 55B7D3EE9I303 I E6I EDID733CC525B1B62C2D91B7 475AD3BBCEA5421304757D5B0F7D0A46
Recipients 10
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 28680E90-13FD-0000-SAF7-AE48A5168176
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name —
Email
UUID A4423FD0-0824-0080-B58A-448148E79444
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Uscr
Recipient
Display Name
Email eitniss@bonov
UUID AE0225F'O13F1)-000DBBA8-4AEAF7774S05
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Uscr
Recipient
Display Name
Email lischkssirgcr(tOop.gov
UUID E414F4A0-0DAA-0003.9C89-D2189E2EIF35
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient 'Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email mrba
UUID 2DA97450-1186-0800-974D-D02E22&50B78
Distribution bpi: TO
Recipient Ts-pe User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Page 13118
UUID 02817A50-1402-0X0-B09B-BCAADF980A91
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4237CDC0-1407-0000-A820-84D2120084D2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Systemeroup
Recipient
Display Name
Email rbeaudouin@tqlgov
UUID 6FECI5F0-25C8-0000$293-9E01000038CF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 15A65E104r33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 9F550EDO-OIDA-0000-B7F5-92775C390IBE
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read truc
Deleted true
.Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification sshen opened fake
Return notification %she n deleted false
Return notification %%hen
completed false
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification %%hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D316F9D.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1326C35.1.B 7EA.1(aJ1.9.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.IQ18
Source received
Class Public
Account FAIADMI.FAIDOMI
Location II) 1540843105474
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash

II) 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.1.0.1@l8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 13119
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-07.21052030 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Trash3 lotwn-Jcbs.cn-GWOpenNodeicn-archivingx,(APM_I-Daily
actmai
Generated by Nctrred Inc. [crrArchive
Trash3
Job.cn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNocle.en—areliving.o
nictrnail]
2019-08.2109,4136 EDT Exported netmainctmannonrad Exported by netmainctrnainctman
2019-08-21 133535 EDT Exported neunainctinainctmai Exported by nrtnraitnetrixanetrruil
2019.09.16 153437 EDT Exported nennainconannetmad Exported by ncumilnetmainctmail
2020-05.19153530 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020.05.1914>71S6 EDT Tag BOP0I 703.MXRADM I.MXRDOMI Flagged
Page 13120
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/19 09:25
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Can you please have him seen for his request for 7 I understand he has not expressed
any psychological concerns in the past, but he is facing the death penalty and is currently in SHU facing
disciplinary charges. Thanks!
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
f.
pi=
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
he found a dead rodent in his bed. Apparently he accident) smothered it while slee in . The li hts in
the cell are fre uentl off durin the da and on at ni ht.
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[P1 [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
nrnhihitpd If vim ciicriert that veil have received thic rnmmliniratinn in prrnr Monaco nntifv iic immediately hv
Page 13121
• r / •
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Barket;
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
15. 2019 3:48 PM
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if ou are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/2019 11:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
Page 13122
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the closing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
-M
Barket Epstein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) ca(a> wrote:
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket ec >
Sent: Frida Jul 12, 2019 3:22 PM
To: USANYS
Cc:
ton ricco >• Aida Leisenrin
>:
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Page 13123
Jason,
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden City, NY 11530
- O
-M
Barket Eostein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
(USANYS)
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal As a result, the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to , and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket < >;
Cc: tonyricco ( >; Aida Leisenring
>;
(USANYS < >-
>;
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
Page 13124
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitin,tinnc cnari,littc olcn tArmitarl 7 kniirt Airlo ,nri I warn I i wins in tk,t tAfitt
Page 13125
1541.1VIIJ gAIJUe 1O,41V...4 e- IIV VI J. 4- 1144 41 14 I Tn..
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[P1 IF]
www.barketepstein.com.
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
message and all its attachments
Page 13126
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D31£0282.NYMDOMENYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.6 04E7.1
Message Path xmPTrash/D318C&INYMDOMI.NYMADM 1.100.1 696E30.1.6WE7.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CAD049CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tartagbone
Scheduled date 2019-07-19092522
Creation date 2019-07-19092522
Modified date 201947-22 10A431
Delis e red date 201947-19092523
Message size 14870
Attachments silt 31284
Total size 46165
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htin
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D318C81NYMDOMINYMADMI.200.20000A0.I.I
45723.1®45D318032.NYMDOMILNYMADMI.100.
I696E30.1.604E7. 1 ®19.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.10 0.010.1® IS
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 31284
Date 2019-07-190525:15
CA 8la0eled45fff0055bab666c31:bald3c
Hash 9FAC47EFS89C8DABIDACAD5E2F8199ECOVACB8E F30882A456598418&5129251A219210
Recipients 5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 835135E40- I IC'6-OOOO-B3D6FE66A7708950
Distribution Type CC
Recipient 'I ype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID A4423I D0.0824-0000-B58A-448148E79444
Distribution lype TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB000000O-0000-8B6E-IB003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
t t I D 6FECI5F0-25C8-000O8293-9E01000038CF
Distribution1)pr TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 51C1- I IC0-09040000-BBEI-7C3A8759762I
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Page 13127
Read true
Deleted MC
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification alien opened fake
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed fake
Return notification alien declined fake
Return notification Mien
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal II) 5D318C82.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.60.1E7.1®1.9.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.O.IQ1 8
Source received
Class Public
Account I9019.NYMADMLNYMDOMI
Location ID 1540843105474
Class Name GIV.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
ID 9.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Twe NotSharcd
Page 13128
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-07.28063007 EDT Created
en=Archive Agent_I-Daly Trash3
Jobrn-lebs.cn-GWOpenNodern-archivingx,(Arni_
ietmai
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [en-Archive
I -Daily Trash3
Jobrn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNorle.cn—archivinga
-netrnail]
2019-08-21 133406 EDT Exponed netmainearninetnni Exported by netmainctrmincumil
2019-09-16 1534:16 EDT Exported netmainetmainetrrni Exported by netmai nerrailneunad
20200549 14/4136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Rigged
2020-05-19 153530 EDT Tag BOP01703.6OCRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 13129
Re: Fwd: Inmate Epstein #76318-054 (Suicide Watch)
From Carla Melendez
To
Date 2019/07/24 13:33
Subject: Re: Fwd: Inmate Epstein #76318-054 (Suicide
Watch)
Attachments: TEXT.htm, IMAGE.gif
Thank you
Do you have anyone in Psychological observation?
lit Please don't print this e-mail unless it's necessary
Carla- R. Me„levoltiz
Assistant Human Resource Manager
NYS Notary Public
Training Coach
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Mefropolitan Correctional Center
I50 Pork Row
New York, NY 10007
646-836-6456
646-836-7674 (fax)
E-Mcil airespAboo.gov
>>> 7/23/2019 10:56 AM >>>
Here you go.... sorry, I was in the middle of a crazy task!
Psy.D.
Chief Psychologist
U.S. Department of Justice/
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Office:
Fax:
E-mail:
Page 13130
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D385E1E.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1696E30.1.6 0751.1
Message Path xml/Trashi5D385EIENYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1 696E30.1.60751.1.xml
From Carla Mekniez
Dis pia) Name Carb Melendez
Email COrrego@top.gov
UUID 8837B770.0169-0000-98D2-E1A099256045
Reply To COrrego@bop.gov
Text Carb Mekndez
To
Subject Re: Fwd: Innate Epstein 476318-054 (Suicide Watch)
Scheduled date 2019-07-24 13:33:18
Creation date 2019.07-24 1333:18
Modified date 201947-24 13:3429
Delivered  date 2019.07-24 1333:19
Message size 710
Attachments size 4018
Total size 4739
Attachments 2
Attachment TF-XT.htm
Name TEXT.lam
Content ID
5D385E1E.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000AC.1.6
9D00.1®455D385EIENYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
696E30.1.60751.1®19.NYMDOM I.NYMADM I.100 .0.1.01(4)18
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 2675
Date 2019-07-24 093320
CA 73e7e09db97a13a2ca8e373584e1846f
Rash 87151BE01965D3D53A2BC2C147713CCC7500055C 08EC748111BBEA6AE23DAC224FAMCA6
Attachment IMAGE.sof
Name IMAGE.gif
Content ID
Is Inline nue
Type Ile
Size 1343
CA ca6.518c05807444ca4413e12ce8a5a03
Rash E5B6149C6OCE931696725DI0B769113411F97DD8948CFFF4386390EF9B9692BDEE5676379
Recipients 1
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB030-0C0C-0300-8B6E-1B003A032D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'Iype Uscr
Expire 0
Delay delivery. until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted true
Opened we
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification sshen opened fake
Return notification sshen deleted fake
Return notification "hen
completed false
Return notification sshen declined false
Return notification sshen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D385E1E.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.60751.1@lANYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@1 8
Source received
Class Public
Page 13131
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540843105474
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Trash
ID 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.10110.1.0.1@l8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System tnt
Share Type NotShared
Page 13132
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-07.28062431 EDT Created
en=Archive Agent_I-Daly Trash3
Jobro-lebs.cn-GWOpenNodern- Daily
se mi
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [en--Archive
1 -Mkt Trash3
Jobrn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNock.cn—archivinga
-nctinail]
2019-08-21 1400:55 EDT Expand netmainetmainetnni Exported by net  trmincumil
2019-09-1615:40!47 EDT Exported netmainettnainetrnai Exported by netmaincurrailneunad
2020.0549 14:34:33 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRI)OM I Flagged
2020-05-19 15:18.43 EDT Tag 80P01703.M3CRADM i.roxR DOM Responsive
2020-05.19153229 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NINR DOM1 Responsive
2020-05-19153234 EDT Tag ROP01703.MXRADMI.A1Mt I HMI Responsive
202045.19 152931 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRDOMI Responsive
Page 13133
Mail Attachment
IMAGE.gif
Page 13134
•-. a
•-. a
a
•-. a
a
•-. a
a
•-. a
a
Re: Articles today on the AG's visit to FCI Edgefield
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
2019/07/08 20:21
Re: Articles today on the AG's visit to FCI Edgefield
TEXT.htm
Thanks. Gonna be interesting to see how media plays out moving forward. I didn't speak to the
reporters today like I did with KJ. I expect a good story in the future from KJ. He was very
impressed. Don't know what today's reporters thought.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
lO iSnessal
From:
Date: 7/8/19 8:07 PM (GMT-05:00
To:
Subject: Fwd: Articles today on the AG's visit to FCI Edgefield
>>> 07/08/2019 20:07
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
----- Original message
From: Nancy Ayers <nayers®bop.gov>
Date: 7/8/19 5:28 PM (GMT-05:00
To:
Subject: Articles today on the AG's visit to FCI Edgefield
>>> "Nancy Ayers" 07/08/2019 17:28 >>>
The first two articles have more about the FSA & BOP than the latter articles:
https://www.aikenstandard.com/news/a-g-william-barr-sens-graham-scott-laud-first-
step/article_f5c9920a-a 1 ad-11e9-bd51-fbla6a9b3bde.htinl
Page 13148
https://www.indexjournal.com/news/u-s-attorney-general-visits-edgefield-
prison/article_f6073444-c746-57c8-8bd5-1ced7cbd32ff.html
https://wtop.connational/2019/07/barr-muellers-hill-testimony-will-be-public-
spectacle/ (this is an AP interview)
https://www.postandcourier.com/news/attomey-general-barr-tells-sc-reporters-he-s-found-
a/article_76547b6e-al8c-Ile9-a2e7-b7256bab1021.html
https://time.com/5622303/attomey-general-census-citizenship-question/
https://vvww.washingtontimes.com/news/2019/jul/8/william-barr-ag-says-hes-recused-jeffrey-
epstein-c/
Page 13149
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D23A5CC.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.B16B72.1.4841 1 .1
Message Path xmiCabinc6IPPA/5D23A5CC.BOPMSCO.PO4.10 0.1316B72.1.48411.1.xml
From
His pia) Name
Email
UUID B922A560.1581.0000-B66C-FACF6A00A51C
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: Articles today on the AG's visa to FCI EdgefieId
Scheduled date 2019-07-08 202123
Creation date 20I9-074313 202123
Modified date 201947-0907:36.•49
Delivered date 201947-08202132
Message sine 1964
Attachments size 2840
Total size 4815
Attachments 1
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEX'T.han
Content ID 5D23A5CC.BOPMSCO.PO4.X0.20000013.1.3AEAD I.14$55D23A5CCSOPMSCO.PO4.100.13161372.
1.48411.1@l35B60DD9SOPMSCO.PO4.100.131 6B72.1.4A.1@l3
Is Inline false
Type fik
Sim 2840
CA 71a08531:d3a5-kla981acee89bledae4
Hash 7W29A04110BE421816B2433CAIE1819899CBF228 76084BABA011:007EF171EDEID35A04A5
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 73785700-l6FD-0000-8F9C-000083ma13
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-07-0820.2132
DonnloadedBylkirdP • 2019-07-08 2021.33
Opened 2019-07-08 2025/37
Expire 0
Delay de livery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read Mt
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification "hen opened false
Return notification "hen deleted fake
Return notification "hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D23A5CC.BOPMSCO.PO4.103.1316B72.1.48411 .1@l55B60DDSI.BOPMSCO.PO4.1C0.1316B72.I.
4A.I@l3
Source sell
Class Pule
Account MSCO
Location ID 1540843449744
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder IPPA
ID 55B60DD9.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.B16B72.1.4A.1@ 13
Page 13150
1.9 °Bed
PANSWN adii annis
aciej au aisis
I°N adil
Vdd I atuEN
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-07-20 00A4:17 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive8
lolun-lebs.cit-GWOpenNodexn-archiving.ofAgent-
tetmai
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [ctrArchive
I -Daily Archive8 Johen-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoie.cn-archiving.o
nictinail]
2019-08.21132523 EDT Exponed netmainctmaancintad Exported by netmainetrnaincimaa
2019-08-22 17135:19 EDT Exported neunainetinannetmai Exported by netnxiitnetrixanetribil
2019.0947 14116A2 EDT Exported nennainconannetnna Exported by ncuminctmaincimail
2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-06.191437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 13152
Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From Google Alerts
To
Date 2020/01/03 18:04
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
bureau of prisons update January 3, 2020
NEWS
OSHA Cites Bureau of Prisons Facility for Unsafe Working Conditions
GovExec.com
For the first time, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration in late November issued a citation to
a Bureau of Prisons facility for unsafe ...
Is 2020 the year for Florida prison reform? I Paula Dockery
Tampa Bay Times
It's getting so bad in Florida's prisons that legislators are not only receiving dire warnings from Florida
Department of Corrections Secretary Mark Inch.
Decision to move Jeffrey Epstein's body after suicide violated federal prison
guidelines: report
New York Daily News
Under federal Bureau of Prisons protocol, a suicide scene must be treated with the "same level of
protection as any crime scene in which a death has ...
4 things we learned from GEO Group's lawsuit over
immigration detention in California
The Desert Sun
GEO currently operates two of its prisons — Desert View MCCF and Golden State
MCCF — under a contract with the California Department of ...
Parent convicted in college admissions scam pays $150000 fine
The Boston Globe
Page 13153
A former real estate executive sentenced in November to six months in federal prison for his role in the
nationwide college admissions cheating ...
Police officer deaths are down, but the news is still not good in Illinois
Chicago Daily Herald
Ever wonder who's in jail, why and for how long? Now you can find out through an innovative web tool
the Lake County sheriffs office is making ...
US still treats the Philippines as a captive colony
manilastandard.net
The Senate resolution described De Lima as a "prisoner of conscience ... Penitentiary her accomplice in
violating the rules of the Bureau of Prisons.
WEB
DOJ Pathways Internship Program Bureau of Prisons Student Trainee
(Human Resource Student ...
USAJOBS - Job Announcement
DOJ Pathways Internship Program Bureau of Prisons Student Trainee (Human Resource Student
Trainee ). Department of Justice. Justice, Bureau of ...
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscn be
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Page 13154
Properties
Property Value
NlessagelD 5E0F3242.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.170316D.1.1 6192.1
Message Path xmarash\SEOF8242.NYMOOMI.NYMADMI.100.I 70316D.1.16192.1.xml
From Goo& Alerts
Display Name Goog)e Alms
Email googIcalerts-norcpbse googic.com
Reply To googkakrts•norepbq googk.com
Test Google Alerts
To
Subject Google Alert - bureau of prisons
Scheduled date 2020-01-03 l8:03:13
Creation date 202001-03 1803:13
Modified date 2020-01-04 154554
Delivered date 2020-01-03 113041
Message she 4740
Attachments sin 75572
Total size 80323
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID
5E0F3242NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.200000D.1.1
005D&1@i45E0F8242.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.
170316D.I.16192.1@l9.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l18
Is Inline fake
Type Me
Size 29990
CS 7567beb512fit9491372b72a6caa0b084
Hash BCBCD6BFCCOFB8516F2EFD1384BFE818265026D6 8D23BEB97DC6C80DCE40735C2700DE86
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5E0F8242.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.200000D.1.1
005D9.1€453E0F8242.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100
170316131.16192. i@l9.NYMDOMI.NYMADM i.10 0.0.1.0.1(418
Is Inline fake
Type fie
Size 45582
CA 2376cf2803alace3c9737a41879aa85d
Hash 9281ME4Et8F5E5C5387EEOFECEABAFICA49BA4411 A9616B803IFB8DB6136DF6A664F2F82A
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 835B5E40-11C6-0000-B3ThSFE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read false
Deleted true
Opened false
Completed fake
Security Nonnal
Box type Inbox
Return notification sshen opened false
Return notification "hen de le te d fake
Return notification "hen
completed fake
Return notification "hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5E0F8242.NYMOOMI.NYMADMI.100170316D.1.1 6192.1®19.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.1000.1.0.1@ 18
Source received
Class Public
Account MI
Page 13155
Location ID 1540843020946
Class Name 6W.NIESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
ID 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.01.0.1@l8
Name Trash
Type Trash
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 13156
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2020.01-14 233537 EST Created
eteArchive Agent 1-Daly Trash 1 Job,en-lcbs.en-Gii/OpenNodexn-archningx,(A84M_
=netmai
Generated by Netgovem [en-Archive
1 -Daily Trash I
Johen-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoicen-archivinp ro
-mama]
2020-06021128:10 EDT Viewed B0P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I Viewed by
BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I
2020-05-19 14:37:18 EDT Tag lit0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Ebgged
2020-05-19153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM 1 Responsive
2020-0602152731 EDT Tag BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I Responsive
2020-06021528:16 EDT Tag BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I Responsive
Page 13157
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13158
Sent: Fri, 03 Jan 2020 15:03:13 -0800
Subject: Google Alert - bureau of prisons
From: Goo gl  Alerts < ooglealerts-noreply@google.00m>
To:
bureau of prisons
NEWS
OSHA Cites Bureau of Prisons Facility for Unsafe Working Conditions
GovExec.com
For the first time. the Occupational Safety and Health Administration in late November issued a citation to a Bureau of
Prisons facility for unsafe ...

• •
Is 2020 the year for Florida prison reform? I Paula Dockery
Tampa Bay Times
It's getting so bad in Florida's prisons that legislators are not only receiving dire warnings from Florida Department 
of
Corrections Secretary Mark Inch.
as
Decision to move Jeffrey Epstein's body after suicide violated federal prison guidelines:
report
New York Daily News
Under federal Bureau of Prisons protocol, a suicide scene must be treated with the "same level of protection as any 
crime
scene in which a death has ...
4 things we learned from GEO Group's lawsuit over immigration detention in California
The Desert Sun
GEO currently operates two of its prisons — Desert View MCCF and Golden State MCCF — under a contract with the
California Department of ...
X X
Parent convicted in college admissions scam pays $150000 fine
The Boston Globe
A former real estate executive sentenced in November to six months in federal prison for his role in the nationwide 
college
admissions cheating ...
Police officer deaths are down, but the news is still not good in Illinois
Chicago Daily Herald
Ever wonder who's in jail, why and for how long? Now you can rind out through an innovative web tool the Lake County
sheriff's off Ice is making ...

• • Pan irre vanl
US still treats the Philippines as a captive colony
manilastandard.net
The Senate resolution described De Lima as a "prisoner of conscience ... Penitentiary her accomplice in violating the 
rules
of the Bureau of Prisons.
• •
WEB
DOJ Pathways Internship Program Bureau of Prisons Student Trainee (Human Resource
Student ...
USAJOBS Job Announcement
DOJ Pathways Internship Program Bureau of Prisons Student Trainee (Human Resource Student Trainee ). Department
of Justice. Justice. Bureau of ...
You have received this email because you have subscribed to Google Alerts.
Unsubscribe
Receive this alert as RSS feed
Send Feedback
Updated Timeline -Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
From
To
Date 2019/08/10 17:35
Subject: Updated Timeline-Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Please see the attached.
Thank you
Page 13161
Properties
Propertj Value
NlessagelD 5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.170316111.8 I DD. I
Message Path xmliMabox/5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 .T703160.1.8 IDD. l.xml
From
Midst) Name
Email
tit ID 9D77B2D0.19C1-0000-A989.0200000058D0
Reply To
Test
To Sts :
Subject Updated Taneline-Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618.054_1
Scheduled date 2019-08-10173534
Creation date 2019-08401%3534
Modified date 2019-08.10222248
Delis e red date 2019-08.10173535
Message size 39
Attachments size 15171
Total size 15221
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.lint
Name TEXT.hun
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.2000038.1.9
E92E.Iq4455D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADM I. I00. I
70316D.1.8IDD. lq41:7.NYMD0MI.NYMADMI.I00. 0.1.0.1(4)16
Is Inline false
Type file
Silt 195
Date 2019-08-10133527
CA at 15639(970cbfekaecf9493ae653a I
Ilan h 88FD525778E7BEA2A693564A702F79093B2DFCB5 F5E3lE372D5I535EB222E155C7E8C818
Attachment Epstel. Jeffrey Edward Reg. No. 736113-054_1.docx
Name Epsteit. Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054 I.docx
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.2000038.1.9
E92F.1®455D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
70316D.1.8IDD.1 ®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
Type He
Size 14976
Date 2019-08.10133431
CA e91a2fe99005ee073754feb778t646.5e
Hash CDFB9C5A66703DACOOMA1742306DFC36065E82I 565F62D6ACOB72B5FAIITDEDEB99DS19
Recipients 8
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA4000-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S . tem(' tuber
Recipient
Displaj Name
Email
UU ID 835B5E4011C6-0000-B3D6FF-66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S mGroupMetuber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 43FDB000-0O0C-0000.8B6E-IB003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S • tuber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DDA9D301006-00:13-987C-OCD8B822F09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S to Member
Recipient
Page 13162
Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-064F-0000-AB39-F80F2A59A443
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type SysternCroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
WAD 9D77B2D0-190-0000-A9894Y2C0000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'type SystemGrouptekmber
Recipient
Display Name
Email _
UUID 4237CDC0-1407-0000-AF20-8402120084D2
Distribution type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroup
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 661:64C10-1320-0000-8EC1-2F2162868DCC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification "hen opened fake
Return notification "hen deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archive N'e is ion 5.3
Internal ID 5D4F0066.NYMDOM LNYMADM1.100.170316D.1.8 I DD.1€01:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM 1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Source received
Class Pubic
Account ADMI.ESTDOMI
Location IL) 1540842445516
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Malheur
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 13163
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-19 1425,45 EDT Created
crrArchhe Agent Archhel.en-Jobsirr2-Zero Day
GWOpenNode.en-archild
itg.ernetnrail
Generated by Netrnail Inc. jereArchivc
Agent
ij
2-Zero Day
ArchelAn- - JobsAn-WOpenNodeAnRarchiv
ingAteirmi]
2019-08-21 099039 EDT Exported netmaiLnetnoinettnail Exposed by netnrancimaineutra8
2019-08-21 1407:46 EDT Exported netmainetmainenntil Exported by nettroilnetrroilnetmail
2019x8-211491508 EDT Expected netnuiLnetmainennail Exported by netnod.netmailnennad
2019-08.22 170603 EDT Exported netnoiLnetmainetimil Exported by netmadnetmainennail
2019-09-07183233 EDT Expected neunaiLneunailneumil Expected by netnodnettrailneunad
2019-09-07183622 EDT Expected netmailnetmainetmail Exported by neunadnetmaiLneims8
2019-09-09030430 EDT Exported nettnaineunainetnoil Exported by netmadnetnolinctimil
2019-09-09115821 EDT Exported nettnaiLnetnuitnennail Exported by mint:id. wino il.nctina8
2019-09-11 12:1734 EDT Exported neunadnetnraineunail Exported by netnradnenroilnetmad
2019-09-1418:16901 EDT Exported nettnadocurainctmad Exported by netnrailmetmainctmail
2020-05-19 152859 EDT Tag BOE01703.84XRADMI.MXRDOMI Respersive
202005-1915:1706 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Respxisive
2020-05.19143495 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MX1tDOMI flagged
Page 13164
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Page 13165
Suicide Timeline re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Friday, August 9, 2019
8:00 am inmate Reyes Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 departs for court
(WAB-USMS-SDNY) . Reyes is Epstein's cellmate.
8:30 am inmate Epstein arrives in Attorney Conference. He is
visited by several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 pm inmate Epstein departs attorney conference and returns to
SHU
7:00 pm inmate Epstein provided a social call by IDO. IDO reports
inmate Epstein was in good spirits, nothing unusual.
7:32 am PIO notified of incident by the Warden
***Inmate Reyes is released from court and does not return to the
institution.
Saturday, August 10, 2019
6:33 am body alarm activated in SHU. Staff found inmate Epstein
unresponsive in cell. Staff reported to bedside of inmate and
attempted to wake him. Control announced medical emergency. CPR
initiated
6:35 am medical staff (on duty PA) on site, CPR already in
progress medical staff continues CPR and AED applied on inmate.
Control called for ambulance
6:40 am , AW notified
6:45 am EMS arrives, paramedics continue CPR. Inmate Epstein
remains unresponsive. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three
rounds of Epinephrine, IV access started, IC) initiated. No pulse
found, no shock advised, inmate prepared for transport to local
hospital.
7:10 am EMS departs institution enroute to Beekman Hospital.
7:19 am USMS notified of incident.
7:20 am SIS Lt notified.
7:30 am , Warden arrives at institution. , AW
notified.
7:36 am official time of death reported by ER physician.
7:40 am Acting Chief Psychologist notified.
8:00 am and Captain arrive at institution.
8:10 am SIS Lt arrives at institution.
8:10 am CMC and SCSS notified.
8:34 am FBI notified.
9:00 am AUSA notified.
9:00 am arrives at institution.
9:00 am SIS Lt. reports to SHU. Interviews will be conducted with
inmates assigned to tier.
9:15 am CMC arrives at institution.
9:30 am Acting Chief Psychologist arrived to the institution.
9:50 am SCSS arrives at institution.
9:55 am CMC and IDO depart institution enroute to Beekman
Hospital.
10:00 am CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital, fingerprints and
photographs taken of inmate Epstein. Inmate clothing secured and
brought back to institution.
10:00 am Judge Berman notified.
10:15 am CMC return to institution.
10:45 am PIO arrived to the institution.
11:00 am next of kin (brother) notified by Case Management
Coordinator.
11:12 am press release is released to media.
11:15 am press release provided to Judge Berman.
11:15 am CST activated.
12:15 pm body release to Medical Examiner (ME) for autopsy
12:19 pm FBI arrives.
1:35 pm FBI arrives in Special Housing Unit.
1:40 pm OIG notified by the Warden and they will be sending an
Agent to NYM.
2:15 pm CST debrief conducted.
2:45 pm OIG arrived in Special Housing Unit (SHU) .
3:45 pm OIG and FBI departed from SHU.
5:05 pm OIG/FBI departed MCC New York.
Jeffrey Epstein criminal case officially closed by NYC judge
From New York Daily News
To , nydailynews&sl.nydailynews.com
Date 2019/08/29 16:39
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein criminal case officially closed by NYC judge
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
Page 13168
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D67FFA3.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00170316D.1.9 DE71
Message Path xinVMatcor/5D67FFA3.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .170310.1.91:T7.1Juni
From New York Daly News
Display Name Ncw York Daly News
Email nydadyncws@itslnydailynews.com
Re pb to nydadynews(awslnydailynews.com
Te x t Ncw York Daly Ncws
To nytialyncwsrainsLnjdailyncws.com
Subject Jeffrey Epstein criminal case officially cbscd by NYC judge
Scheduled date 2019.08-29 163832
Creation date 2019-08.29163832
Modified date 2019-08-29163900
Delivered date 2019-08-29 163900
Message sin 0
Attachments site 68298
Total sin 68309
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hun
Content ID
SI)67FEA3.NYMDOMI.NYISIAD641.200.2000013.1.1
29EBB.1€7.45:5D67FFA3.NYMI)OMI.NYMADM1.103.
170316D.I.9DE7.1®11.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type fie
Sat 29868
CA b6d15ace35e3d658910a9560dMIcke
Hash 99B870E765017CA36F51E4DD38FIDC6DEE484794 EE5155A869C02EAFB670496FDA5612F1
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D67FFA3.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000013.1.1
29EBC.1®45:5D67FFA3.NYNDOMI.NYMADMI.100.
17031.513.1.9DE7.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0. Ifig16
Is Inline fake
Type It
Size 38430
CA 6158e64101c831baa4c5021893737d47
Hash B02I2D5F698F8B58640207144F5A94D94FB969D 4AAC5EIDIA7532CCD0F687378B9DIC0D
Recipients 2
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
lit II) N:5B5140-I IC6-0000.B3D6•FE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Tspe User
Recipient nydailynewsia nsinnlailynews.com
Display Name nyda dynewsOr nslnydailynews.can
Email nydadynews.IIP2v40000016edfl9e541:635a9f6c966389000790Oultbsialynews.com
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read fake
Deleted fake
Opened fake
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification .hen opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification tshen
completed false
Return notification .hen declined fake
Return notification %Ahen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Page 13169
Internal ID 5D67FFA3.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100170316D.1.9 DE7.I@I(LNYMDOMLNYMADMII010.1.0.1@l6
Source received
Class Pubic
Account ADMLESTDOM1 ___
Location ID 1540842445516
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enctoxin Folders 1
Folder Maim
ID 7.NYMDOM INYMADMI.100.0.10 I ®I6
Name Mailbox
T)Pc Mailbox
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 13170
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-05 172004 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent Job.en-Jobson-Ci/1-Daily Archive]
=mortal
Generated by Netinai Inc. iciAreltive _ Ili_ I.Daa. Archive I A
OpenNcdextrarchiviig.0 0wopenNodeswarchiviigiocoLejobsZr
=neonatal
2020-05-19 152839 EDT Tag 0OP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
20_10.05-1915:1736 CDT Tag ROP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM1 Responsive
2020-05.19143435 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I nipped
Page 13171
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13172
Subject: Jeffrey Epstein criminal case officially closed by NYC judge
From: ews <nydailynews@nsl.nydailynews.com>
To:
Sent: Thu, 29 Aug 2019 20:38:32 +0000
BREAKING NEWS
Jeffrey Epstein criminal case officially closed by
NYC judge
The sex trafficking case against Jeffrey Epstein is officially over.
Read the latest
BREAKING NEWS PRESENTED BY
UNSUBSCRIBE I NEWSLETTERS I PRIVACY POLICY I TERNS OF SERVICE
Copyright @ 2019 New York Daily News 14 New York Plaza, New York, NY 10004
ABOUT THIS EMAIL You received this email because you are following the Breaking News newsletter.
Fwd: Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
2019/12/30 09:12
Fwd: Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
TEXT.htm, Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
please set up a meeting to go over these issues next week.
Thank you
> » BOP-RSD/Assistant Director- 12/27/2019 9:08 AM > »
Please see attached.
Page 13174
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5I09BF95.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.170316D.1.1 5A7E. 1
Message Path xmtMaillown5E0583F95.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.17031613.1.15A7E.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID F638D9001406-0000-A820-84D2120084D2
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Fwd: Psych Reconst Response - Epsten H76318-054.pdf
Scheduled date 2019-12.3009:1253
Citation date 2019-12-30091253
Modified date 2019-12.301331/8
Delis e red dale 2019-12-3009:1254
Message size 154
Attachments sire 67312
Total she 67477
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXI.htm
Name TEXT.han
Content ID
5E09BF95.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000B1.1.B
3583.1@455E09BF95.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1

703160. I. 15A7E.1(0)1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI. 100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
She 436
Date 2019-12-3004:1252
CA 22114861 Ic6&1177cle9c07d37136d7bdf
Has h 57417B53207BECODFF8O37FBA6F2E62BE8202605 BIOAA764F70B6C5F430049BFF245B903
Attachment Psych Recant Response - Epstein 476318-011.pdf
Name Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
Content ID
5E09131:95.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.2CX/20003B1.1.B
3584.14455E09BF95.NYMDOMI. NYMADMI. 100.1
703160. I.15A7E. 1@1:7.NYMDOM I.NYMADM I.100 .0. 1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
She 66876
Date 2019-12-2704:0&26
CA 115d251beb74efa537932eb5cbile98120
Has h 57224D5A2505532F08581113472852E599E086AD8 24CF3CA6B1B2090F6E7453F4E9690332
Recipients 7
Recipient — Display Name
Email
UUID 8351351:40-I IC6-0000-E0D6-FE66AT108950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 77IIC0440-09D3-0300-8F07-905C8F0A 1644
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB00OOCOC4)OOOSB6E-IB003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DIM9D30- I 006-00:0-987C-OCD8B822F09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Uscr
Page 13175
Recipient
Display Name
Email
tItilD 9D77B2D0-19C1-0000-A989-0200000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient "rype User
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
LIVID C4117510-04FF-0000-B3IC-4A46EB8DCC96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient I ype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID 66164C 10-1320-00(10-SEC 1 -2F21671tenrc
Distribution T)pe TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read false
Deleted fake
Opened Mt
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification %0len opened fake
Return notification n he n deleted fake
Return notification sshen
completed t:tke
Return notification 'Olen declined fake
Return notification nhen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5E09BF95.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100.170316D.1.1 5A7E. I ®1 (I.NYMDOM LNYMADMI.100.0. 1.0.1@I
Source received
Class Pubhc
Account
Location ID
MI
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder MalLox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1(4)16
Name Matox
Type Maibox
System true
Share Type NotSbarcd
Page 13176
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2020.01-09172b33 EST Created
en-Archive Agent 11-Daly Archive)
Job,en-lcbs.en-Gii/OpenNodnen-archisingdA8481_
=nctmai
Generated by Netgovem [en-Archive
I -Daily Archive!
Jobien-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoincn-archivinga
-nettnail]
2020-06-021130:15 EDT Viewed 80P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I Viewed by
BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI
2020-05-19 14:35:39 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.MXFtDOMI Ebgged
2020-05-19152931 EDT Tag Et0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-1915:1803 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05021530:18 EDT Tag BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Responsive
Page 13177
Mail Attachment
Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
Page 13178
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Reentry Services Division
Washington, DC 20534
DEC 2 7 2019
MEMORANDUM FOR , REGIONAL DIRECTOR
FROM:
SUBJECT:
tant Director
Reentry Services Division
Institution Response
Psychological Reconstruction
Inmate Epstein, Jeffrey (76318-054)
I have reviewed the Institution Response dated November 19, 2019, to
the Psychological Reconstruction of an inmate suicide involving
Jeffrey Epstein (76318-054) .
Some of the corrective actions and plans for implementation outlined
in the response are unclear or insufficient. Please review the
feedback provided and revise your response accordingly. An updated
Institution Response is due to me within thirty (30) days of your
receipt of this memorandum.
If ou have estions or concerns, please feel free to contact me at
I appreciate your assistance with this matter.
CC:. , Warden, MCC New York
Institution Response Feedback
MCC New York
Epstein, Jeffrey (Reg. No. 76318-054)
Issue 1: Single Calling - Corrective Measure Accepted
The local guidelines provide a reasonable system of control to
monitor the single -ceiling of inmates in the Special Housing Unit.
National guidelines for single ceiling in the Special Housing Unit
have been incorporated into national policy and will soon be
released. Please reference these generally with a plan to
incorporate.
Issue 2: 30 Minute Rounds
The substance of the two hour Captain video review and six hour IDO
video review is unclear. Please clarify the requirement for the
Captain and IDO. Additionally, please identify the documentation
used to maintain accountability of the reviews.
Issue 3: Cellmate Assignments
Documentation exists reflecting the role of the local Psychology
Services department in communicating the importance of Mr. Epstein's
status as a sex offender with specific needs to the Associate
Warden. This includes consultation with the Psychology Services
Branch in Central Office. The communication chain and decision
making of Executive Staff lacks transparency as there is no
documentation of the process or staff members present when decisions
were made about the housing of Mr. Epstein. After the fact
explanations may not accurately reflect what occurred.
Psychology Services was not adequately represented in the decision
making of Executive Staff. Please establish a plan to increase the
input of a psychologist in placement decisions for vulnerable
inmates.
Issue 4: Documentation Accuracy
Professional responsibility requires taking into account multiple
descriptions of an incident as noted in your response. However,
when discrepancies exist these should be compiled and noted in
documentation to decrease the likelihood of conflicting conclusions.
As noted in the reconstruction report, an incident report must be
written within 24 hours of having the information that an inmate
likely violated BOP rules. An incident report was written for Mr.
Epstein prior to a determination of whether he engaged in self -
directed violence or was assaulted on July 23, 2019. Staff had
ample time to wait for the outcome of the SIS investigation of this
incident. The incident report presumed self-directed violence,
although SIS was not able to determine whether this incident was
self-directed violence or an assault. Generating the incident
report for self-directed violence is evidence of a local bias about
the July 23, 2019 incident that still exists amongst some staff at
MCC New York. Preconceived notions challenge the ability to remain
open about alternative explanations, and subsequent systemic changes
may be needed.
Please develop and provide local training for all staff that at a
minimum reviews the time frame for writing incident reports and
offers guidance when there is not clear evidence of an infraction.
Include an outline of the training and evidence of staff who
attended the training.
Typographical Errors - Corrective Measure Accepted
Medical Intake Screening - Response Accepted
Suicide Watch Log Book - Corrective Measure Accepted
BP 292s - Corrective Measure Accepted
Psychology Observation - Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 5: Telephone Calls
As noted in the response, there is a lack of documentation to
substantiate that a lieutenant facilitated two telephone calls to
Mr. Epstein. However, this does not address the report of two
telephone calls being provided. This response implies that the
reporting of two staff members is inaccurate.
The response neglects the documented telephone call to Mr. Epstein's
deceased mother.
Issue 6: Direct Observation
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 7: Follow -Up
Please provide documentation for the follow up training provided to
staff detailing the content of the training and to whom it was
provided.
Issue 8: Inmate Accountability and Assignment Accuracy
Periodic and unannounced checks are now conducted in SHU to
determine pp30 assignments and actual inmate placement match.
Please provide an operational definition of periodic. Please do the
same for routine, as it relates Executive Staff bed book counts in
all units. Where will the periodic and routine reviews be
documented and will they include the identity (e.g., name and title)
of staff who complete them?
Issue 9: Attorney Log Books
Please provide a copy of the log book audit.
Issue 10: Automatic External Defibrillators
The response states the reconstruction team reviewed an old and
outdated list from January 8, 2018. It is important to note this
list was provided to the reconstruction team by institution staff.
Provision of inaccurate documentation may reflect systemic issues
related to collecting, maintaining, and sharing relevant
documentation.
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 11: Post Orders & SIM Training
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 12: Staffing
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 13: Sex Offense Risk Factors
Psychologists are subject matter experts in sex offender risk
factors and they play a crucial role in sharing this knowledge
through traditional settings such as ICT, AT, and institutional
meetings. However, Executive Staff play a pivotal role in
establishing and addressing institutional culture and promoting and
participating in training. A lack of a broad understanding of sex
offender specific risk factors requires an intentional training
approach led by Executive Staff. They must be out front talking
about inmates with a sex offense, expressing an understanding of sex
offender dynamics, modeling agency condoned expectations for the
understanding and treatment of inmates with a sex offenses, and
assisting with institutional trainings. These practices encourage a
broader acceptance by line staff.
Fwd: Re: Interviews
From
To
Date 2019/09/0311:32
Subject: Fwd: Re: Interviews
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Hello all,
I just spoke with Special Agent . I requested to meet with him for my interview on 9/6/19 at
9:00 or 10:00 a.m. He will follow-up with me to advise if this time works well.
Sesiectfully,
Ph.D.
Forensic Psychologist
LT, U.S. Public Health Service
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Office:
Fax:
E-mail:
If you are emailing about an inmate that may be at risk for suicide or self-harm, this is an emergency
situation. Please ensure you make verbal contact with Psychology Staff or the on-call psychologist. Please
ensure to maintain constant visual observation of the inmate until formal steps can be taken to ensure
his/her safety pending a formal assessment by a Psychologist.
"This message is intended for official use and may contain SENSITIVE information. If this message contains
SENSITIVE information, it should be properly delivered, labeled, stored, and disposed of according to
> »
Good afternoon,
8/16/2019 1:43 PM >>>
Per the below, OIG would like to interview you regardin the incident last weekend involving EPSTEIN,
Jeffrey, reg. no. 76318-054. Please call Special Agent at at your convenience.
Thank you,
Page 13183
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
8/16/2019 1:41 PM >> >
Per the attached OIG would like to interview the following staff members.
> » . (OIG)" < > 8/16/2019 12:56 PM > »
Nurse
Sent from mobile device, please excuse typos.
Special Agent
Office of the Inspector General
1 Battery Park Plaza, 29th floor
New York, NY 10004
Cell
Office
> On Aug 16, 2019, at 12:34 PM, > wrote:
> Medical Staff?
> >>> . (OIG)" < > 8/16/2019 11:25 AM >>>
> We are available at all times for the medical staff interviews today, if they are willing to agree to a
voluntary interview.
> Sent from mobile device, please excuse typos.
> Special Agent
> Office of the Inspector General
> 1 Battery Park Plaza, 29th floor
> New York, NY 10004
Cell
Office
Page 13184
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D6E4F30.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.6 I9A3.1
Message Path xmloTrashi5D6E4F30.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100,1696E30.1.619A3.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
QUID 690BAC 10. 12704)000-AE9F-BCB76461E958
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: Re: Interviews
Scheduled date 2019-09-03 1132.130
Creation date 2019-09-03 11:325)0
Modified date 2019-09-03 12:03109
Delis e red date 2019-09-03 II:3201
Message size 2609
Attachments sin 4341
Total size 6961
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htin
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
SD6E41-30.NYMDOMINYMADMI.200.2000043.1.9
0730.1®45D6E4F30.NYMDOMENYMADMI.100.1
696E30.1.619A3.1@l9.NYMDOM I.NYMADM I. 100 .0.1.0. 1@l8
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 4341
Date 2019-09-03 073200
CA ealaSa4646712ceee60a9b6e8e256bef
Hash FC74DSEC84289C3DIA4ED038FA29C710E47184C3 37749F279C5B6F8775F0E7D068244F3D
Recipients 3
Recipient
Display Name
Elrod!
(lull) 2750( \Do fix S.0000-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'I spy User
Recipie ni
Display Name
Email
till D 4.314)B000-0C0C-0000-8B6E-1B003A002D00
Distribution I spy CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Utlj D I5A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fa/se
Arehised false
Read true
Deleted we
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification "hen opened fake
Return notification "hen de le te d fake
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification "hen declined false
Page 13185
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DbFAF30.NYMDOM LNYMADMI.100.1696E30.1.6 19A3.1@l9.NYMDOMLNYMADM 1.100.0.1.0.1 ar I 8
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540843105474
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Trash
ID 9.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.01.0.1(418
Name Trash
1-)Pe Trash
System MC
Share Type NotShared
Page 13186
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-08 01A723 EDT Created
eteArchive Agent Jobrn-lebs.en-Gi/I-Daly Trash3
OpenNodern-archisingdAgent-
=netmai
Gerrrated by Norma Inc. [arArehive
I -DailY Trash3Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoiern-archivinga
--nettnaill
2020-06-021108.+47 EDT Viewed 8OP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I Viewed by
BOP0I 829.NCRADM I .NCRDOM I
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
2020-O519143931 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
202005-19153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-O5-19153432 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Responsive
Page 13187
News Clips 10-24-2019
From
To
Date 2019/10/24 11:08
Sri bj ect: News Clips 10-24-2019
kitachments: TEXT.htm
Page 13188
NYC's MCC Prison Faces New Lawsuit in Mysterious Death of Inmate
The Jewish Voice
inmate/
The Metropolitan Correctional Center, where Jeffrey Epstein was found dead in his cell in August, will soon
face a lawsuit by the family of a different inmate who died there under controversial circumstances,
Bloomberg reported.
Cameron Douglas says spending 2 years in solitary confinement was 'torture,' but a 'necessary
tool'
Yahoo Sports
https://sports.yahoo.com/cameron-douglas-prison-solitary-confinement-100036152.html
Cameron Douglas, son of Hollywood superstar Michael Douglas and grandson of actor Kirk Douglas,
opened up on The View about his decades-long struggle with addiction and his time in prison.
For-profit prisons will phase out beginning next year
Daily Titan
https://dailytitan.conV2019/10/for-profit-prisons-close-beginning-next-year/
California will phase out the use of private for-profit prisons and immigration detention facilities starting
next year.
By 2028, they will be completely phased out.
19 Years On, Anti -Death Penalty March Sees Progress
The Austin Chronicle
https://www.austinchronicle.com/news/2019-10-25/19-years-on-anti-death-penalty-march-sees-progress/
Scott Cobb put together the first March to Abolish the Death Penalty in 2000, so when he speaks on the
progress of the movement, it is with some authority. "Back then, the death penalty was like a gospel; they
said it would never be abolished in Texas, but we've seen changes" said Cobb, who believes state-
sanctioned killing will be abolished by 2025. "I think that's a reasonable goal."
Saved by the First Step Act: Matthew Charles speaks in Steubenville
WTRF.com
https://www.wtrEcom/top-stories/saved - by-the-fi rst-step-act- matthew-charl es-speaks- in-steubenvil le/
STEUBENVILLE, Ohio (WTRF) — The Herald-Star Speaker Series returned Wednesday night with a high-
profile guest: Matthew Charles.
On January 3, Charles became the first person released under the First Step Act, which passed through
Congress and was signed into law by President Trump last year.
Page 13189
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5DB18623.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4D04D .1
Message Path xmiCabinetIPPAISDB18623.BOPMSCO,PO4.100.13161372.1.41304D.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
QUID 737135700-16FD-0000-BF9C-000083202C73
Reply To
Text
To
I
Subject News Op, 10-24-2019
Scheduled date 2019-10-24 I I:080
Citation date 2019-10.24110805
Modified date 2019-10-24 IP.31130
Delis end date 2019-10-24 119820
Message sin 2164
Attachments sin 8103
Total size 10278
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htrn
Name TEXT.htm
Content II) 5DB18613.BOPMSCO.PO4.203.2000008.1.23D72 A. 1@)455DB18623.BOPMSCO.PO4. ICI00.13161172.
1.4D04D.1®155B60DD9.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.131 6872.1.4A. I ®13
Is Inline fake
TSPe file
Size 8103
CA 66t3a92celaffl06fd17235e11560112
Hash I E72A9132B704F06163FD99C09CE4F33E9874A65 CA21611D27$8150631C298668E0997E3A
Recipients IS
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID F09FC101-1656-0000-8495-000083219F58
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID CCSISC90-02CF-0000-BDFI-437F7FF4607B
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Utill) B5927150-1653-0600-9294-751062334A6C
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
tJUID B922A560-1581-0000-B66C-FACF6A00ASIC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient I ype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID C9BD4C60-05013-0000-B363-DC66561970DB
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 794B2E01-1571-0000-BFB5-000083202C73
Distribution Type TO
Page 13190
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4FA5FIiCO-0358-Op00-83F5-C300F500FA00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Dispirit Name
Email
UUID 70485O3I - I F82-0000-8528-00C0832 I 9F45
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 695F8300-02C5-000095CF-85908232EF87
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Entail
UUID A7F28I80.038D•0000a5B04A0022000000
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Oil D 6A70A5D0-05EF-0000-A5A4-F50F8FD3CO3A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 3-PMDOCO-I152-0000-6502-02B05D137IF3
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2l. 82.li i- lit3-0000-9B47-BF621-05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID F5504140146D-000044D5-0000&324673C
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Ty User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 8B49E50 I -2 I AB-0000.85CD-OCC000000300
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type U cr
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted false
Opened truc
Completed fake
Security Nonnal
Box type Inbox
Return notification %Am, opened fake
Return notification %hen deleted fake
Page 13191
Return notification "hen
completed take
Return notification 'hen declined fake
Return notification "hen
accepted false
Archise Version 5.1
Internal ID 5DB18623130PMSCO.P04100.1316872.1.4D04D .1Q1:55B60DD9.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.
4A.1fiC,13
Source received
Class Public
Account MSCO
Location ID 1540843449744
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder IPPA
II) 55/360DD9.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.B16B72.1.4A.IQ 13
Name IPPA
Type Normal
System false
Mare Type NotShared
Page 13192
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-11-01 233835 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive8
Jolun-Jcbs.en-GWOpenNodeon-archivingoAgent-
setmai
Generated by Newsom [en-Archive
I -Daily Archive8 Johen-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoicen-archiving.0
—nettnail]
2020-05-19 15:3421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BO80170334XRADMI.MXRDOM I Fligged
Page 13193
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/19 07:22
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Good morning all,
Per the below list of complaints please look into the following:
Facilities - can you look into the alleged leak in his cell, no. 201-106?
Safety - can you let me know the last time 9 South had pest control?
SIS - can you follow up with FBI on his incident report? Can you also look into whether the alleged rodent
on his bed might have been his cellmate accusing him of being an snitch?
SHU - can you swap out his books? Can you check on the lights in his cell? Was his paper discovery
located? Is he claiming he is still missing any?
Thanks all,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
fria l
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
hp fni Intl a ripari rndont in hic hod Annarontiv hp arrirlontly cmnthprpri it whilo cippnino Tho liohtc in
Page 13194

Yr. I • t -... 0
the cell are frequently off during the day and on at night.
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Barket;
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
15. 2019 3:48 PM
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
; Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if  are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/201911:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
Page 13195
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the closing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
- M
Barket Epstein.com
Page 13196
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) ‹ > wrote:
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket
Sent: Frida , Jul 12, 2019 3:22 PM
To: USANYS
Cc:
ton
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
-M
Barket Epstein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
(USANYS)< >
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal As a result the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket <
Cc: ton >; Aida Leisenring
USANYS1 >
Page 13197
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Pi=
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Page 13198
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitigations specialists also waited 2 hours. Aida and I were Lucky in that we
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci NY 11530
[P1 [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review. dissemination. distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
Page 13199
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
message and all its attachments
Page 13200
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D316F9D.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.16B6F301.F 405.1
Message Path xmirtsialmW5D316F9D.NYMDOM 1.NYMADM 1.100 .16B6F30.1.E405.1mn1
From
Display Name
Entail
QUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
I i I g II
9 8 ii
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tartaglime
Scheduled date 2019-07-1907:22516
Creation date 201947-19072295
Modified date 2019-07-190837:12
Delivered date 2019-07-19 072206
Message sin 15216
Attachments size 31869
Total sin 47096
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hun
Content ID
5D316F9D.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.20000A0.1.1
456B1.1@45:517.316F9D.NYMOOMI.NYMADMI.100.
16B6F30.1.E405.1@1:7.NYMOOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type fde
Size 31869
Date 2019-07-19032158
CA 7dede565990.a22e70461608153421321
Hash 55B7D3EE9B031EMEDID733CC525B1B62C2D91157 475ADM3BCEA5421304757D5B0F7D0A46
Recipients 17
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmCiroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID tfliI39.40- I I (6-0000433D6-FE66AT708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
1.51.511) 2B6B0E9043FD-0000-8AF7-AE48A5168176
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID A4423FD04324-00004358A-448148E79444
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID AFMMFO-I3FD-0000-BBA8-4AEAF7774805
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Page 13201
Email
(W11) 43EDBC00-0C0C-0000-886E- I B003ACO2D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGrxmpMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
2DDA9D304006-0000-987C-OCDSBB22F09A UUID
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemeoupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID E414F4A0-0DAA-0003-9C89-D2189E2EIF35
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-01i4F-0000-AB39-FSOF2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGrouptslember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 9D77 i I2DO- !EX • I -0300-A989-020000005400
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SyNtemOnoupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DA97490-I I86-0C00-974D-D02E22850878
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 028 I 7A50- I•102-00C04309B•BCAADF980A9I
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
till D 4237CDCO-I407-0000•A820-84D2I20084D2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Sr:it:DC
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 6FECISF0-25C8-0000-13293-9E0103003SCF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID ISA6SEI0-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A6064ISCAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID or•il•-It • i 0- 132u0000-SECI.2F2I67RMDCC
Distribution Type TO
Reci 'entrry • S slen ember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Page 13202
LIVID 9F550ED0-0IDA-0000-B7F5-92775C390IBF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type inbox
Return notification Mien opened false
Return notification %shim deleted fake
Return notification %Men
completed fake
Return notification uhe n declined fake
Return notification %Mtn
accepted false
Archhe Version 5.3
Internal II) 5D3I6F9D.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I0016B6F30.I.F 405.1QULNYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.10.1®16
Source received
Class Public
Account BOP25431.POLADMI.POLDOMI
Location II) 154:042788518
Class Name (iW.MES.SAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maabox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMLI0D.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Maibox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 13203
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-07-29 23:1522 EDT Created
cn-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archived
Job.en-lebs.erGWOpenNodetn-archivitgslAgcni-
tetmai
Generated by Netrre4 Inc. [en-Archive
I -DallY Archive4Johen-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNodetn-archivinpr o
-nettnail]
2019-08-21 13:32:14 EDT Expand netmainennatnetmai Exported by netmainetrmincumil
2019-09-18 10:1027 EDT Exported netmainetmainetrrni Exported by netmainetnrailneunad
202045.1914A136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Bagged
2020-05-19 133330 EDT Tag BOP01703.NOCRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
Page 13204
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/19 07:22
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Good morning all,
Per the below list of complaints please look into the following:
Facilities - can you look into the alleged leak in his cell, no. 201-106?
Safety - can you let me know the last time 9 South had pest control?
SIS - can you follow up with FBI on his incident report? Can you also look into whether the alleged rodent
on his bed might have been his cellmate accusing him of being an snitch?
SHU - can you swap out his books? Can you check on the lights in his cell? Was his paper discovery
located? Is he claiming he is still missing any?
Thanks all,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
fria l
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
hp fni Intl a ripari rndont in hic hod Annarontiv hp arrirlontly cmnthprpri it whilo cippnino Tho liohtc in
Page 13205

Yr. I • t -... 0
the cell are frequently off during the day and on at night.
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Barket;
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
15. 2019 3:48 PM
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
; Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if  are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/201911:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
Page 13206
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the closing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
- M
Barket Epstein.com
Page 13207
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) ‹ > wrote:
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket
Sent: Frida Jul 12, 2019 3:22 PM
To: USANYS
Cc:
ton
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Jason,
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
-M
Barket Epstein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
(USANYS)< >
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal a. As a result the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket
Cc: ton >; Aida Leisenring
USANYS1
Page 13208
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Pi=
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Page 13209
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitigations specialists also waited 2 hours. Aida and I were Lucky in that we
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci NY 11530
[P1 [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review. dissemination. distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
Page 13210
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
message and all its attachments
Page 13211
Properties
Property Value
Message 1 D 5D316F9D.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.165696B.1.4 4B43.1
Message Path xmlrtsialmW5D316F9D.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .165696B.1.44843.1Jan!
From
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
; ;
;
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tunaslime
Scheduled date 201907-19072215
Creation date 2019-07-19072215
Modified date 2019-07-19075&11
Delivered date 201907-19072206
Message size 15216
Attachments size 31869
Total size 47096
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hun
Content ID
5D316F9D.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.20000A0.1.1
45681.1©45:513316F9D.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.
165696B. 1.44643.1@1:7.NYMDOMINYMADM1.10 0.0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 31869
Date 2019-07-19032158
CA 8901b844dd907bd1c865d9decb434da7
Hash 55B7D3EE9B031E61EDID733CC525B1662C2D91B7 475ADM3BCEA5421304757D5B0F7D0A46
Recipients 17
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CAD0.09CA-O000-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Systcm(iroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID tfliI39.40- I I C6-0000-53D6-FE66AT708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
1.11.111) 2B6B0E90-13FD-0000-8AF7-AE48A5168176
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID A4423FD0-0824-00004358A-448148E79444
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID AFnn5FO13FD-0000-BBABAAEAF7774805
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Page 13212
Email
(W11) 43EDBC00-0C0C-0000-886E- I B003ACO2D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGrxmpMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
2DDA9D304006-0000-987C-OCDSBB22F09A UUID
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemeoupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID E414F4A0-0DAA-0003-9C89-D2189E2EIF35
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-01i4F-0000-AB39-FSOF2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGrouptslember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 9D77 i I2DO- !EX • I -0300-A989-020000005400
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SyNtemOnoupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DA97490-I I86-0C00-974D-D02E22850878
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 028 I 7A50- I•102-00C04309B•BCAADF980A9I
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
till D 4237CDCO-I407-0000•A820-84D2I20084D2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Sr:it:DC
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 6FECISF0-25C8-0000-13293-9E0103003SCF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID ISA6SEI0-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A6064ISCAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID or•il•-It • i 0- 132u0000-SECI.2F2I67RMDCC
Distribution Type TO
Reci 'entrry • S slen ember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Page 13213
LIVID 9F550ED0-01DA-0000-B7F5-92775C3901BF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read tnie
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type inbox
Return notification Mien opened false
Return notification n he n deleted fake
Return notification Mien
completed fake
Return notification %Men declined fake
Return notification %Men
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D316F9D.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.165696B.1.4 4B43.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.I.0.1(§1
Source received
Class Public
Account
Location ID
DOMI
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder MalLox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Maher
Type Malian
System tote
Share Type NotShared
Page 13214
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-07-27 193504 EDT Created
en=Archive Agent 1-Daly Archives
Job.en-lcbs.crai/OpenNodern-archiving.O Agent-
tetmai
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [errArchive
I -DallY Archives
Jobrn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoclern-archivingo
-nctrnail]
2019-08.211022,47 EDT Exponed actor inetma anettoarl Exponcd by netmainetrnaiLnetmad
2019-08-21 102934 EDT Exported netmainetrinanetrisol Exported by netnraitnetnrail.netrroil
2019.0841 13:3031 EDT Exponcd actmainetourl Ileum II Exported by ncuminctmainetmail
2019-08-22 17:121)7 EDT Exported netmainetrisol nctinall Exported by nctmaiLneurraiLnetinail
2019.09.200632x10 EDT Exported netmaineunol. whoa II Exported by netmainetmaineton a
2020-05-26 15,7106 EDT Exponed BOP01703.MXRADXI I .MXRDOMI Exported by
ROP01703.MICRADMI.MXRDOMI
2020-05-19 153532 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.AIXRDOMI Responsive
2020-0519142136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.NIXRIX)M1 Fbgged
Page 13215
Psych Observation 7/24-30/19 (UM companion utilized) re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg.

No. 73618-054
From (Ma
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
2019/08/12 15:36
Psych Observation 7/24-30/19 (1/M companion utilized) re: Epstein,
Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
TEXT.htm, 2019 08 12 15 15 46.pdf,
Psych Observation 7/24-30/19 (I/M companion utilized)
Page 13216
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D51875F.NERDOMI.NERADM1.103.1367333.1.1 44BD.I
Message Path xmliCabinebNERCAInst - New YorlOAtig3D51875F.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.13 67333.I.144BD.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
QUID 835B5E40-I1C6-0000433D6-FF-66A77089')0
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Psych Observation 7/24-30/19 (I/M companion razed) re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Scheduled date 2019-08-12 153523
Creation date 2019-08-12 15:3523
Modified date 2019-08-22 20:4824
Delivered date 201908-121s:36m
Message size 59
Attachments silt 12407411
Total size 12407481
Attachments 3
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D51875F.NERDOMLNERADM1.200.200000D.I.E
E140. kg45:5D51875F.NERDOMI.NERADM1.100.1
367333.1.144BD.1(015D4E9C39.NEFIDOMLNERA DM 1.100.1367333.1.142FF.1@l3
Is Inline fake
Type lie
Size 352
Date 2019-08-12 1135:13
CA 5dc9M83300334f884:1766d37a66569ce
Hash 4CECB5D3EA9D4756D8ABBF9D71AF8FrBA26.5781B 7E57AAMECF8793039536C468EA43A04
Attachment 2019 08_12_15_15 46.pdf
Name 2019 08 12 15 15 46.pdf
Content ID
5D51875F.NERDOMI.NERADM1.200.200000D.I.E
E141.1@453D51875F.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.1
367333.1.144BI). 1@l3D4E9C39.NERDOM INERA DM 1.100.1367333.1.142FF.16j13
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 12406646
Date 2019-08-12 11:1703
CA 92c8ftle97Cbe91021a7310ed109d391)
Hash 665C72E8ODDB522636D382C987F097977C801C12 8507EBEC23F4551FFB58DCCA4EBD7630
Attachment
Name
Content ID
5D5I875E.NERDOM LNERADMI.200.200000D. LE
Ii142.1@)45:5D51875F.NERDOMI.NERADMI.100.1

367333. I.144BD. 1@l5D4E'9C39.NERDOM I.NERA DMI.100.1367333.1.142FF.I@I3
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 413
Date 2019-08-12 11:1739
CA 777e9e73d5910720d24764e8a23be8al
Hash A028B5683C2094000D4CF643FC573E87013344D8 1A8E76595522BF65018E17366F95DID2
Recipients 2
Recipient
Dis lay Name
Email
UN D 610E93500B4F-0000-AB39-F80F2A59A443
Distribution Type CC
Recipient f%pe User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2F682I380-14C3.00009B470F62C05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Page 13217
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type lithos
Return notification alien opened false
Return notification .hen deleted false
Return notification. hen
completed false
Return notification "hen declined false
Return notification. hen
accepted false
Archive %onion 5.3
Internal ID 5D51875F.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.1367333.1.1 44BD.1@l5D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.B
67333.1.142FT.1@l3
Source received
Class Public
Account MI
154W-13691206 Location ID
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Aug
II) 5D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERADMLIC0.1367333.1.142W.1@l3
Name Aug
Type Normal
System false
Share Type NotShared
Published 2019/823-0,4834
Page 13218
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019.11-O4 203331 EST Created
en=Arehive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archive I.cn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNode.en-archiv
ilgcs ietmail
Generated by Nelgowm Kr -Archive
Agent _2-Zero Day
Atria; Len-Jobs.en-GWOperiNolesn-archia
iigo-netinail
2020-05-19 1528:59 EDT Tag ROP01703.MXRADMI.MMIDOMI Responsive
2020-05-1915:17/36 EDT Tag BOP01703.M3CRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05.19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
Page 13219
Mail Attachment
2019 08 12 15 15 46.pdf
Page 13220
yt:Fi. OBSERVATION LOG
I NAME:
REGISTRATION:::  7V?)  - sel
OBSERVATION STARTED:   - 2017
OBSERVATION ENDED: 7
PLEASE. RETURN LOG TO PSYCHOLOGY AFTER THE
OBSERVATION HAS ENDED.
TKANK YOU.
ITEMS ALLOWED::
__Regular Clothes
Safett , Toothbrush
__Newspaper/Magazine
`__Books (softcover only);. b Safety Pen and Paper II,
Toilet Paper
Legal Mai:
Other
SW Blanket & SW Mattress must he used even on Psych
Observations.
If nothing is checked with a silver marker, only a Suicide
Smock and Suicide Blanket sue allowed.
Name of Inmate On Suicide Watch or Psych Observation:  &.'"1,-5.--6 ,40:7
Registration #:  9-6 yijr
EAT NG/SHOWER CHART
DATE BREAKFAST
LUNCH DINNER
( LIQUIDS OFFERED
SHOWER
RECEIVED
SHOWER •
Iv*
Please check the appropriate box if the person on
Suicide Watch/Psych Observation actually eats his
meal. Do not check the box if heiust received it,
but did not eat it.
Place a check in the "Liquids" box each time the
person drinks.
Thank you.
EpSian  7C3  --MI i ±.2.et-zoicr
PrE te -fei.n.
8S-44.1te War Cie F.L  LL--s-• vp
y CA- ace,4041  277  MOSZ7 v-An:44,
000 T Et c 1/4 _ekccomes- .iberpnersb Qin Psych S'/
aVery s-t -Cps]. ; -762.1 -3::(5Str -
VVon Ziff! Eps4-c-; it
ic4cfklatikiliei7isj: r
_cArtis, EPAL4  Jr  Q C (e" .^ 5 ci_b_o_kz.zsaii
q:75digif L;§Cee Ctn d ar G kaki ri  CA) 0 ;..21- Ma —
t ti In% e 1/4 12_ c;• ivt_t,
t3:1/1 -CriaLatzsle'.. 1 ct  K   ftL (1 ---
?NS- IZM E 6_e_4
Olaii); -41/"X FADsVe S• p eliUW  eefiA r L__
TbA  Cip„de.:n aippecxns 4o le Lea:
4134,24_1411__E.9_,tta_appiiegzs to e cSteepiturra
.20Licm Mi4 €p3kin i 9 c1/41.0,,,x eac ith_b_wski _121,1_1c
War -r f  I C 104.-Yin On
CIVIC(
EPA
15-1:07074re., EPSTC- Wii5Aaelp

╭────────────────── Page 772, Image 1 ──────────────────╮
│ EpSbe 1 sb763 (8-054 72 24-20/F                       │
│ 40% Epstein Eakin, AClewer                            │
│ BIS The b/c Come a Fuh bine Vp                        │
│ Iman Pacaiabs Sap Peedhad westiar, 227 56080          │
│ Siooph, Ler Enx\ sch__ascomes rerpenzabliy Qe Psy) At │
│ 77 elon ser aoa” Ce lM an TEATE= ore                  │
│ SiS ln Epstein is falkine to Unit? Recon              │
│ S20 Zn Eps} en ie dal Teng fo Um FX oltiagg S.        │
│ Spe Zn Epstein iz asking a avout sail \ife            │
│ VcGpq Lm Epstern and T ace talk: ng, about Sail (eA   │
│ Som /M Ep ste -Gsie me lreime, Cc                     │
│ sam LIM Epstein ack me abor' kta pe hese€             │
│ Veena TM Epstein is laying awake on hs bed <          │
│ [O%O Gp TI Costen Appeas Se he Sleeping; S            │
│ I2'6ou IIA Ep stein appears to be Sleeping om         │
│ em L/M Epstein aopens te be hee iy, SE                │
│ 248m THM Epstein if quote aod borshiis Ws teeth CC =  │
│ WORM Ensen 76 layine, On _his bed =                   │
│ om 7 Sud. toy = -                                     │
│ Bev | Braidsn DeChPy Ai EVCOAD OSH, SSUES             │
│ bos spews biltiGer hess Bidehpbsen@tipnr vate.        │
│ ete, ne 7e3) SOSH in call oa Tauliq                   │
│ at IPC en Bb (ye JoZe— tJ                             │
│ ie PA Aweste ESTE IQs seeping — =                     │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

30._
If sp S erttAi"
IA I.5
-)
I 5
ig S-I- COIA
a Infas-e,gps-co.) is40 , i -- la vfiects-esr it1/4\-is-5
I Vi i. . ,t.,e-ih V
- -I mbv0 -6,:(
g o--i-
I  5 1-45 i I-N 155
- 114$q
_at. .3z)
_ cal_ fej45 /,,A
12 x.
r5
'4'3
- - " - -
tkil-e-5--1-E.,b3 ;55
1:4; )315 -
I ?
-E.7 1\:-ic  3
PST I
;
AM r ni'1 415h if Iiii4
) .1\ es
ID Pak tiL.)a-

╭─────────── Page 773, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ a x eg Eestets dis See ping — -         │
│ \l* Fem || marc EPSTEWIs slee QQ        │
│ 130K oo EDs Ss — = =                    │
│ (A"Syqlamarke Epsrein is 5 sleepiog} —  │
│ Beto Count                              │
│ Xan | LEPSTEIN 6 Sloe ping—————         │
│ AMAZE. STE pissed =                     │
│                                         │
│ OM nale EPSTEDN ss rn =.                │
│ Papa Lt Row 4                           │
│                                         │
│ 2m bvrasshy; cP 1 iN- is sleepin ———— { │
│ 4 Inmehe EPSTEIN is sleep ing G         │
│ 2°9n asta EPSTEWN is slo ee ——          │
│                                         │
│ 2? am, Inte ERSTEDD is Seep             │
│ am nneje- Leste Ig                      │
│                                         │
│ 3 En ™ i Epsre. nS . Sle                │
│                                         │
│ EAN, DA are Eestei a.sleco}             │
│                                         │
│ So aw ware Epsteny is lazon             │
│ +s AM lamer Epstein iS a                │
│                                         │
│ ‘e5 AN at Ee EPSTEIN                    │
│                                         │
│ 4 4m Lacwer se career BUN               │
│                                         │
│ cee In                                  │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────╯

?ste‘f.) A_ 76 3,8-05Li
44 -fro-A-k:  --Gessrast 5,ve, .) Sosi-5-tio ,s 4-- -1-,„-„zi,4;a- PaTEN ;c 1
tuna-6 FP5.-t-Fim ;s 5
E:Pseitik €_5( cap Ail
ea5
-171: 7%_Jun
CIESL
7.±5A,.. Lu:.s Fe vw, ckz. 61.6 8-0c9 - c;SSOneS Yes
7/64,4
--t
1-1.44 c) • -ft- - 76 irs=uS-4..
a 1N ar-C
0  Sk)f, -1---
I5ten-- fe 4110.5 -6S   'et.ti_4.t44e4
IL 763(e-ogy
-to

╭────────────────────── Page 774, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ E gstew & 7% 318-084                                          │
│ 44 nate EPSTEIN 1 is i" ——                                    │
│ San Ih nso PSTE I Nisg                                        │
│ Oe ime TEPSTE! Wiss see                                       │
│ SAW Tame EPsrel                                               │
│                                                               │
│ 5 Na Sore -                                                   │
│ 5 on heoatko- ERs = [NS rested — -                            │
│ Kn Inmate Leste in is sh cep A                                │
│                                                               │
│ OM Inmate EPSTEIN i ~suale on J                               │
│ ean mec EPSTEIN js ou abou indon bed =                        │
│ OAM inate E2PSTE: INS awake 5 Sanaa eyis) ‘                   │
│                                                               │
│ 1% ie Festeinis sacked ie                                     │
│ 73M ania EDSTEIN Sawlashnt mera                               │
│ 78a Inmate Este In 15 eupte. sikinyontea!                     │
│ Piatt cad of hedge ——                                         │
│ 775ta lus Fermmmder. $7 626 8-O5Y - assumes ves pow S bj lity │
│                                                               │
│ = OE SS ei 2631809 SEE                                        │
│                                                               │
│ ts al oes ~ LE                                                │
│                                                               │
│ "2 "a ’ Ee pstein a ie                                        │
│ $3 ry wheg bo —                                               │
│                                                               │
│ [eA ns                                                        │
│                                                               │
│ Gor - Exe ot s“i¥¢ Tv — _ —«L_ fF                             │
│                                                               │
│ Iso ELC MERIC OB PE79- OFF axdumiy ee"                        │
│ ogpens telat, por Ten Cason # TENE -OF¢                       │
│                                                               │
│ og Dhee tpeatsel 5 ad nba free)                               │
│                                                               │
│ tude                                                          │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

• ts 7 67)(8 • 09-f
A44,2,actiA4,4frta:rie
ett-icaa<
1.1
get
erc
10:rz-c3W1-
/414.4.10-44-e-gy  te.k.A.44.64
T-6m- fgfrier-th -etzi:ku-t  ecet-ott-ele-ealti7 ter
- -lei ;co t-t-ce-zo
Li Ea -44.
Ticoreiathk rtidatWatcr-P14
0-14.41x4-046 _
tke-tra:-,  w arts"

╭────────── Page 775, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ Eppltew 7678-054                       │
│                                        │
│ Goo Fac tesdbas 02.) Tory chacwra: toa │
│ Gia pha Coen anal                      │
│ digeinetur,                            │
│                                        │
│ e276 Plo Pl tae a CLE                  │
│ i by a cana ef                         │
│ kama hee pepe, esse peaplioey lu       │
│                                        │
│ FAG Flew pps aa dipeg dow fa anat Coe  │
│                                        │
│ FS Rew Kk pace ce HE.                  │
│                                        │
│ 40 Th ErsToui Avilioy ee               │
│                                        │
│ ‘cam Hert pb a a cori :                │
│                                        │
│ CoO Mea egies oles hoch us H4. ee      │
│                                        │
│ oF ee ae een                           │
│ , eee hs foot, : vee                   │
│                                        │
│ oO Tees enley Az 1                     │
│                                        │
│ OruG OT abba ly dootedtel 2            │
│                                        │
│ plein Ly                               │
│ OFF Eo yea — UPA                       │
│ jDSSeut Brandon Del ape! WO =055 Cont) │
╰────────────────────────────────────────╯

aveo, —7(7-5t g -0 c_(
_ frthcaSjile .5_ P-01440  -
_ .4
e& Inman E5.__ALt5r5-I . .
I!3e)rm Foetakir rEPSIN  1.q15_ig
1\1* lAPSPSTP-11 165k) p
lApArsia
la -1544) AAJEsc<4;0-;-s-<
) Imici-erra) ;saf
L-r
-I A 14 --Einw
I itM E-Pi\)  E
attit, 14^406-innslad -
--h-ms- ratu
AC--

╭───────────── Page 776, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ Eisen # ESI ¥ -OSY                          │
│                                             │
│ (¢ andy. BIOS re psikili ore tio.           │
│ pau . h obsesvet 5 eafe JAN AR are! EPSTEIN │
│ HTGSISAO5Y In cellet on ei ab               │
│ 1072, Lp RD                                 │
│ Hes hunate EPSTEM ic “layin eu. quie— BS    │
│ I\'m Innate EPSTEIN 4s sh in :              │
│ re Pi innate EPSTEIN 1s Sle Hi              │
│ 4B, Jame LPSTEY § issl                      │
│ logit lnmakoEPstern ¢                       │
│ lak Mote TONES                              │
│ 12 xn Inmates EPSTED issleep iQ             │
│ 125814 lomate ERSTE NY 15 3/; -             │
│ een hate ERSTEIWs fe                        │
│ 1h faa eT ‘cab                              │
│                                             │
│ hy nijatecE: aoe ——                         │
│                                             │
│ 1%, Aa LT                                   │
│                                             │
│ yy cfs iss                                  │
│                                             │
│ "Be Inmate EPSTEIN 's deep                  │
│ em ipeieersre Ske 7                         │
│ 2bn lime Eest; EIN eh.                      │
│ 2a lameteEpsrein is eA                      │
│                                             │
│ Aan Estep is Sle 70g e——————                │
│ L7H, olde re of f '                         │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯

p re- int 72 r -76i2 -Usk.
:.34.-acf4"lic-CarVa_mscaRe_ma.bil\u,
--0( casc\r\ QA4 Li 754 ecAaintor3ce ,
4a)vre,  wm\c_ tp4 Vr\ \5 5\ee - 3 PWNS
3Dtr-V:\ Hp 3/4\-e. acb\eyr, ' 64.3-4\te kans \\IL 'tech .1€,
• a
ocAm Htrirnek\e- 46 \ eve\ na 4wres --SC
YorA yrcerri\e_ Cp5\reAn .5 vx5 3 PS ‘.5
-3a,,, rm, 3sire ,i)4,e.‘, \ X6  \., Sheectins
2-V2 IwY\Tritk\P Qc•rAev 5 EC, 5\eitcite
LI:efr-• wirTtAe acpk-Q-An - -. \= 5 fl c3 ---
I = 1 lrn\t e9s\e-QA.5\er?‘") 3F&
--i t:Pc,,liv.
v.)  1-cy(eck\e. tpi\e-s" • 3C6 -k,.) s\ercv na
-5 °° its .. - %Nese. id 10 _. di_ Ne. „ I. . , . I.,I.L.,..,1
S-6. r.?ne, Incr,c;cy O.O7 \h V").__4O26‘1T1 7k
S..3;a4n • LA)
. 5\229e \INGi
vv.IN0‘\ce_ 5eAv-\ _ aa __ Wu-.:cc. -45\ -CAn h 4.er(1vfloi
\CA -Sca
\*I-1-Ne.;re )C‘ evr\ k)
tiwY•ka\c_ Q?*Nr.,  .S\ C(7
nr A\e  135Xe:Vn V -5\e'e911
11/4 s\t

╭─────────────── Page 777, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ EPSTEW HEA —-USL                                │
│                                                 │
│ 08 Ff BARN                                      │
│ 3:88 te a Voeoda OSSOMES Respacschiltyy         │
│                                                 │
│ Sox _ gun cele 4 Fn Leste 293:9-090-— JG        │
│ Fem male Costera rs Sleepny, SEE                │
│ Bsa Meale Coser 15 owate Wang We Ibe Xe         │
│ eins WIM GNE Ease See SED sleep — SO)           │
│ Byam? Coster ‘S s\ecerng————_— SF6              │
│ SONA AMOS Ces\ewn S NEA, ———                    │
│                                                 │
│ B&R orale Coslen 15. sleepng                    │
│ deen Wreke Ceska \s Sleep ina,                  │
│ ABQ | inenade. Leste v3 S\eceneg ———— £6        │
│                                                 │
│ Ore AROS Boskesx is even NEG                    │
│ Seen romake fleshown wwke ap Xo ve edt 403 no 5 │
│ S: oon Rea OgsNen \>_ Skepny,                   │
│ S- Peery Dende Coser ‘Ss Secewrey               │
│ San ine Bede \3_S\@e ney                        │
│ OE samore Cesewn 15 Seeswng                     │
│ oe rreexe Cos heya ib eeQss,                    │
│ 6:3eq yarnedhe Coster 15 sleesing,              │
│ rary Wn TE Cosleia o MET IAG,                   │
│ F&A jnmac Costews 15 See pang                   │
│ Tem \Arnche Coste ib Slee ang,                  │
│ 7. oq wqnnae Qestern \S sleeqrngy               │
│ Bem Stel vouass                                 │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

P-e- c we A:x
7-Rd-I?
7:cft-friirndse. ua - P-42,8WC\ .n\,5}7--
k1/4o1)\ k'n'eruAt 4A\ \v\ atAe-
14fri Sivt)s ina s) -Z•Ni -rFtt St-Lot-Jcre.
1 54 5--r->e/HIC  SC714_4-0   1-1_s_swt-te
° 4‘  -Ps\ici-Locttstesietbws_cts,L
NA  _7.-S Stitt  _gugar-li
is   Fra-14. K, S sm oba_
V kJ -7 4 1--Cduk
Ob..1 1;,%
I pS-tf, " • Zs Zrusti.n 5  14,5 7 Ct.+ k
Cc%SettaNQ SI----1-1,ns en-4 ift")
ZS LEA vrns Luc Les/it  Vt5r#  RD_
etoad Sit to :LIM-cc ..5.41/41/4Es pes 2a-s-stit, \-3
or-Q4 opser  -cyz- s -(A4 CP5re+) Ft- 0
VIM
6%4 r-icot tb,(4it Wcy

╭───────────── Page 778, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ E pstew fe W3&-O SY                          │
│ eat amare. Loslan Recwed weateot— SEG,       │
│                                              │
│ : Mh LL BL 7-219 :                           │
│                                              │
│ AMA aL Ye Readca\ Geis) SG                   │
│ tT = \roahe s\ \n cendss\— manlicy           │
│ SU Say Dl Epsteas) ts tN nie Stews —————_ A) │
│ [ab IC DSA KOTCYOSY Assomes                  │
│                                              │
│ Risgons ton iy, fon 2psteIs 76313-054 EN     │
│                                              │
│ CECLAFAL ONS PSYCH OBRLEVA OSS ON 7-754 KD   │
│ JR 2/4 Bester Ts stun overtly es ne          │
│                                              │
│ Sows YD                                      │
│                                              │
│ Ae Sa fetes as Maya, off From His SMowte     │
│                                              │
│ a FF hl, Pad nese                            │
│                                              │
│ eee sheen nauon                              │
│                                              │
│ ONS Lee sant                                 │
│ Gil Tha fpstive IS Beasiing Hos Tete —— ae   │
│ Qi FI foes TS Siting on BLD KD               │
│ GR Fh Bester ZS Ltaving Foe Ugne Vist — KD   │
│                                              │
│ GY) OR Sua!                                  │
│ Bon Sur Bre Bir ncs Pasumes Res gee skl 47   │
│ Fok - R44 -0 BS - 9 M.-C PSTEW-4E DEBIZ=CSY. │
│ Ge TDM wee Ba, PUA ay ye                     │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Co An 'Nye() r -LA ,R kr ft ty c r -r - )
cc---_- - -
- .
.._.- ,--1--- --
- —1-
_  _
-ti -........s.
f.>
:A. . L..- . ..,
?i • IL,

╭─── Page 779, Image 1 ───╮
│ UCD om sek T Page coe y │
╰─────────────────────────╯

— -
7 -
... ...L.
" ...
— 1 -:.- 717. 1 • ' -.) ' 1 -1: -‘ `.-- cit.' - ., Jr !.7.7 7 4. 1 • n.t .?' \. - ,
. '-' ? t"",  ?c - ) - .  •
( N.0 4- : t
--...,_ ‘ ...
C231 .2 r 7: -d - I - . — -- - — ---
c......_
.  :

• Ift-I 2 ---....., c- .. . -, ,- (..: .r.-i - C. K.
. ' QC.) •-•'•-1.
4 i  •_..  .
,
' • V .
\ )- i .- \ 1"-I \. 1  7-f4: ric! -7r-G- )  .:1... L. L'.7 hp P '1
' ; •   c'e
ni$. t
L2t,.-0•CA -• Ice ' .,
'" -.4.-
dr i  • -r7,-
•-3•,- , --- , •
r., Pfri ::' .3  1 i
! , Z..-
‘: '-. -, A f w.,. 0 • p • . 4. .---) r'sei
,. r N --)  • • ,
.1 2 C*1 --J
- \
....
---......,
.....-
,. . .
(_1,4) -1 No e,y)N 0„„7‘93
575%,, -7* 76 3/ ts- -o Sy
Wao- C-P-s•TerQ nnues- - fzi3A- - ow-c- vtIrt
)5 etc TtM 60 :›ttC:t0 C'&  inn° 1-roym c--/
tivc( *iv& ticmGt firm le 'Sir Se.
•
tez."cka---
trim -CPSrcs:r k s
0:4c I ti tw. cPsG.tJ  u Pow&
Plavv-r assnTv-osc
LL -7" ) r:Ct A^ aSirizr -IS-a rectici - - vS-pers.s- mein -
$1% 5 lit ta C-,Ps"Tre.pa ss> scu, ts.,,..c eus,tass
si-v71r t riv ?‘ t•- rre c=Cgtkb cai: FCC,  L,
Y
-•
-D-ca-1 - - -G7s7 -e; -SkrgZ
S rttis C-.1;a 1b Ct:'t
%cc. Lesson's
bLas:Lcb,b.4.,
k
"2„. J 3::;(0" E.RST( r. ,NS WE —C, P.04 r -n -e s re Ith\o -i -1-
eme
S3C6-4.9 ‘CCV .7e
'cur,  02 51 e . t-) QC-tune's kt, t•-1/4-wuca f>miu
vt - -6Q -5- de-reci- -03f&%-t .- Slicsctit)
k 5 V1 A". 4: VS-te.rJ OCN, ffi •-5 Pt
ra2 o- rcim -S-prat I w  poricm- - its 6c .-.5rtizrAis
M rS 15 4^ of ic le • id AV 03125—cb itt StedPg•

╭──────────────── Page 781, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ E pster # FE 31E-OSY                               │
│                                                    │
│ PNG Boom Beste sires Gam Leone vrei                │
│ NOuS Dan €PSTeW Recess Pun Pen C/o                 │
│ (G30 Dim -EPsTe ns Du Oevrces- BoB 0-P Pobieg      │
│                                                    │
│ wel Pie LS AGE WN LESITS                           │
│                                                    │
│ oF                                                 │
│ Sag agu yw CRS wip 1S CIM                          │
│ QW vig Rew ande ——_ | eS.                          │
│ Ve 36 Tim €Pstew “is ratceswo aR Ruse rer          │
│ 2 DOMS | Sun Elsie BW Lye y Ow 77                  │
│ Qe WDM EPS Te STAVE PB VET Busi ss tes             │
│ QS Tin CPstens § Dscussng Bosess + Lise Lessons    │
│ Wie WW GRTES WRAIS WBE KG WE Sa                    │
│ Ws Din Gessews pias nm Be Stes®wQ                  │
│                                                    │
│ 2 R)S0 Clo Rounos wy                               │
│                                                    │
│ Fo Ton Siew CERES fo BE SLoaG                      │
│ ¢ = -                                              │
│ © OPNS TM EPSIES CSRTENS TORE SGSMG=               │
│                                                    │
│ ( Wdo | Tin EST ems O8H> ME Time poses ne TealoT + │
│                                                    │
│ Seusnes “Kes “TH eT ae                             │
│ TIM SUK slew Rennes & LGne Daw ;                   │
│ TSS DIV CP Ser (RRS RISE SO -PUS                   │
│ BAS Dim F Psleo Pres Wy KH SIacpnc, ———7           │
│ D330 TM BOF Ww ponorrs 10 Be S@P.ks re             │
│ DMS Dyan Cleans PMCS Ty Ae Tee                     │
│ O00 Eiwn EC OS¥.7 ~ POC Cows TU Be Slee diKG       │
│                                                    │
│ £                                                  │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

:res ce:NyL461-nrgi -Ow
CY; ts- ?sec' cr4c=r - -CtE- - Slags. lac-
( c.) <--.) 4r, 4i•C 5
-S(QaptA*—
a .. 6-("SiCnt,i eedskeS\S tis s3 t gs/s94-U
- tviy‘- - -6esier t a- - - --6e - -CL(29fai`i-
so ,yi EPsIdeir.i Pcit-ri\s • h) es& ,-562s)cus6
-
Oct€15\377:5iii\RVrCiaTPMCLS16-&--Str2O-Mt:  -
3);k5 turn  eocce s t-71 Ge..75 1/4-P Tv c-Ar4  . -
- p•VS ow-It - crc (--4;1•11-4-4- cs - - Crt.r - "Rs - - ,N.)
Lieu 9 F. c_, ti  Pt 1. T.
Ii,A  sc>sice,  r•—/f u.......vaes pea (..)._71- -n4
Ste
-or Vs pit . -.O1%-1 - tam -- M -Lt
Prravas Pt/IPip__ • •
0 a.1/445 w".• e9 -k ‘1*-f, PRRIC-e0S  e .C*4 -‘-)
Wee.0.4k •
P";:nrCiVavvSci Gisothi n5 /twos, -0 rpsjeZ el:4-263/84<4
ti t6 cts,C1 HA ee?s_leaa_ i s s ice V O
31 - a• ify -m  ,\ es \ as _ i 5
ctal ;;;•177P  • 51
e
.2.e
►_ -
4A4P.c
4-14=

╭───────────────────────── Page 782, Image 1 ──────────────────────────╮
│ EPSTE tye B32 - OSy                                                  │
│                                                                      │
│ YAS (Di Ee                                                           │
│                                                                      │
│ - TEEN POPES (UE RE Sg e.N6 re                                       │
│                                                                      │
│ Osu C(y9Sovsss - —                                                   │
│ OFS ALIN “EPS TER POPES AV--BE--SKQPUV—-                             │
│                                                                      │
│ OAed | Tier ECHew KOags fF Be Soe ——                                 │
│                                                                      │
│ OLAS-—--Tfnn---EPS ters —- OP 68S ty - Be Shoo PAG                   │
│                                                                      │
│ MZ Din EPSiew ARORA S@ORG —————re                                    │
│ MUS Tip Stews Plans “NY BES Steering                                 │
│                                                                      │
│ Ow Dim TE PORES WW Re StooP iw St                                    │
│                                                                      │
│ YDS Tim Eestesr GETs OW CWasn Caw ({ —                               │
│                                                                      │
│ —— Faces  PRoe#kt wot Caw ty - Ge TW Ste wy                          │
│ — Lieu BF Gowme mw &® UW. Ee @uwics ABUT Me. —                       │
│                                                                      │
│ a FUND Rens - SF -- VAR Coe --ONTS ice                               │
│                                                                      │
│ DD b30 F/M EPSens THe Ar mestiteve |                                 │
│                                                                      │
│ = OF“ VArCON                                                         │
│                                                                      │
│ OdMus cim, Dim eestews ates ty Be steep b |                          │
│ A ES SORT De T shee att DV SS89-05 ry —                              │
│                                                                      │
│ ae ——~ MAK                                                           │
│                                                                      │
│ JEOOAM jig Avmands Dawila _aseming vesqurss lish oA epstein 7608-080 │
│                                                                      │
│ Begun ani tt a —                                                     │
│ Sisco am Tm egstein is sleering AD Pec                               │
│ B1Sam i egeten is sleegi@q =a De                                     │
│                                                                      │
│ Ape                                                                  │
│                                                                      │
│ $:30.a% TM egstein is. sleesing                                      │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

ILK i_s, "SeseSAL
4V1 eeRin%
.24:1__Qyx 'ER ese?a:\ n
j
.14:115O), ti tA
-3:00 cin)
-O51
s artryieg s
't% aeeC&Cos
S s..\eengsr).s
e_sRiAtiim
,r\
Qee cns
+ale% ciris
taco, '11A
_94ei
n S
51.ce St‘s
A:00 cow, WI\ •(*ei
j:6%  p?sleiTi s sloe y'__
6 3 20 Ol t M e_- -tPi%O gsleerici43
-&zi5roctiA
‘,..521-1Q71_
nske: 'S -51sei_tio%
k 2 gn• -h re"--1 - Z./ f A h 7` -A-1
.4.01C
0.ac
.4"c
Lil i  040.4 "VC e it.learJ iWidezZ /455vmeg vigp.„6 trtts
tp`Mlia%i t-IG3141-83-7/  J-rJ Cti-CarcL0AL'i, 5
‘‘Yale,/ 07%,) 7 -21-13
mit -RISC st..an0 "7"exs-O4
p es -rt coktos__Goos- k-scan_D__t..' ms„-429 griositi. vc
S. -r5 n /.7 r3lar ,
Orr rearnifir  )1D
trie-____I_ra.5 Netts-% V r CV,

╭───────────── Page 783, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ SHS am                                       │
│ “dseo am                                     │
│ 4ildan                                       │
│ 4: $0 am                                     │
│ US USom                                      │
│ 2:00 am                                      │
│ SBam                                         │
│ AL 20am                                      │
│ Bs Bow                                       │
│ 6:60 aw                                      │
│ 6:18 a»                                      │
│ 6>20 Gn                                      │
│ G4 San                                       │
│                                              │
│ : LIAM De Fine fp rer                        │
│                                              │
│ 00                                           │
│ Am                                           │
│                                              │
│ ~~                                           │
│ TR                                           │
│                                              │
│ Enolein #76318 -OSY                          │
│ 7 (27/12                                     │
│ Ya egsiein ts, deegiag —=——————_ Adee.       │
│ ‘I eastdn” 1s sleegng ——_4#/e                │
│                                              │
│ TIM epelei ray \B_sleeging, ANpe             │
│ YA eortag is sleesson, AMAc                  │
│ ‘TM eastein 38 Slee ning, Anpe               │
│ YM egstein is sleegigy -__—._ 99) Ac         │
│ Va egsten 1a slewing Mec                     │
│                                              │
│ Mlm eastern \S eleg sing —__ 472             │
│ ‘LA ester is sleeging                        │
│ ‘LIN epstei n AS sleegiag,                   │
│                                              │
│ wo eVstein is__sleeging                      │
│ ‘1M epstein is_sleesiny Wee                  │
│ (fh eR shea is Sleeging AAS                  │
│ = lape Aa tate                               │
│                                              │
│ Pe Opts ane                                  │
│ Fhe Dascmes VWIL4654 Assumes LES porate hits │
│ OF 2pstTI aE 1634-54] IN Colca Y On) yen     │
│ weed on 1-27-19                              │
│ FIR CASES AaKS FR “Tole? Testue ead Toot     │
│ \20STE Which wt MuvD Ia tht Saply Dhst+— VD) │
│ SLA OPSTELA) SiS On BED wraps                │
│ Orin DO CK ERSO = i" Lae)                    │
│ Flot G25 Ht SAS ne TLD KO                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Fq9stero 763
7-27-20(9
4:4  2 /,- ri.)5. r.f.,7 s -, s ar,i  Ilse)
7.2 :1,-. 4/ 4-e 40.5--r_z..../ Srs tre-,, RCYD  -KT
VV,-, iii ,/ Cp5-re.2,. we95- Z-Ty_Srett•rp 3 trAfieosr _4_
T  - E,'".) Or Sif.o.F7--------....,
s':oor s-69-i. A-)4-.4) Sa4,(4-12(cLiovrttil ?`.(czt,- , ',fez 2175'-ios-6
Pa' 3;157!. F. - gsff in _ is ue4...;-,1 _ __AL
--9=2:1".-' - aY-e - - ecai - e). e, i a P s - Aa" ..-„ -,-,..§7-
St30B4 •• A.? Epsi-ein  _A ,s,..,,_ rzai    4::<1
gij il  A1--ela --;
?24 ( ,-( ep4k-e4-4--, -2.- 1 -9.ekcs c..1.4.6-4- ,g^ 3,  -g-{..Q.72t
___6/Q.W...—
;:30/2.-.A--T-s-;arzz;ai--i-c_ ' -.-------- --- -:-
1,0,-i -.&_ .acto  ?Ai
-----fe Ai
M
is7 cf:
• irto PP'
76 -17A4   hp
to-oPm   6Lgrpczt  sj2"f` -, 1,,X,fe___La,....Atick,r,n  2-7 7s-easo
0.*1,Bczi-joA,DZANA 4_cz

╭──────────────── Page 784, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ EPStern #763                                      │
│                                                   │
│ (ea Deg Cpt 7 Sit8 Gre BED                        │
│ (i a rt (ps ery 78 ory BED ye)                    │
│ Wie Ya Wpstes J 373 oA BED Ky)                    │
│ 0% Fa Cestetey was dot SHVD) 304 fes¢ KD)_        │
│ ee TD) oF SHzF7 ———.                              │
│ §:00 “Bese Slag Richayed A Mant: Ner 27786050     │
│ ie Epsten Su x get hock z 4                       │
│ ais" A Epstern IB Unreng, ra feat ny |            │
│ O28" We Coll Coke) the takes 25 rs? Slope         │
│ Bisel M Eostern a \uk Takkeve, ———                │
│ 86 7 Epon Ao < x4                                 │
│ fasta JH pli +o Tallec, alot Hy Lee em            │
│ win he genial paplation~ RY                       │
│ G6 J Eakin tuk Talkie RY                          │
│ 1:30 Pg Vin LS Sat Fath: .4 ———__ Rf              │
│ 1950" Za polar tse to Slay ——— Bg                 │
│ 0:00 aE Peta appeers ko te tetany ——k             │
│                                                   │
│ 01S Tn EPS tem aqypeore Me be —Ra                 │
│                                                   │
│ ial (2 Ep SHe on hye Ke be roy hh                 │
│ 145" 7 Epstein appuers Re he seeing —RM           │
│ 100 he Spon Fpapion~n ke be dg Vie                │
│                                                   │
│ Pia, the heel paladuote rs:                       │
│                                                   │
│ en | ; Besagen (DeG PUA IG52O-OSS assumes(Cot dD) │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

re:ar19:4;0 6; I cr-A4krat3 a / 1:66erYaii CA
-Car I n metie, 5;-P5 - rELL\I 4nka_ -435? in' (silt& on
- d ',  7/ 12 /fi zran): 49N
ii'?& ;IMAS-fra- cPSTE1 .15_,5  s pa  :pi
4 toit
15e:)&04pAaj-zEirSit 1 xl iS sir -do t
61  at
_ --WI  - 1-1-am: ---Eat -ED -is - - et  II    11 ri
MI
0 A i
,,.. I it  SU la, JAM I 1\)
)  hvAnko Fp5 - raiA
/ 3 % 6,4  _5±2.5m,1 ista
II 5A.tium A)
-1190-Am4Imna-feS FISTE EA)
-.  SAM tiltna-bc)_C-4 251-CII,3
cl•  lamakzliSIN ; 5 _<
r 5Ahn 6
-3172,w  -riMa& -FF<Irtt
1nrn Ps is
P  514..eppa,
S4P2rA
.It
it i  f I
-T I
lAnne3477, CPSIS  a l
_ kiis_Siedepi
A
I  { 0. I
1,4

╭────────────── Page 785, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ “Genk cesponstilhy eth ne DSiichs observation │
│ Soe Amato Epstein #763! OSE in call ¢ oN.     │
│ P/27N' 8 at ION. IG                           │
│                                               │
│ Rm Lan = aeons Ss DiA\ =                      │
│ IE fe ‘tere E PSTE —                          │
│                                               │
│ re)                                           │
│ Tein                                          │
│ fa At ar aes                                  │
│ PAN [nwo PSTEIN is Sleeping —                 │
│ =f                                            │
│                                               │
│ AmatecE STEIN ie seeping                      │
│ RR late. FpsTelN is sleep —                   │
│ Kn lamate COSTE IN if SJ mea —                │
│ |nmahe E05 STEIN iS slee G —                  │
│ ou hint: Eesreny is slezpin ————              │
│ ah Jamsshe, ERSTEW isSleepia 7 J              │
│ oO un damate EasTew is sez) i¢—= t            │
│ Bw. limate Eestes,\ \5.s skepag —~—— ;        │
│ AB lange: Epstein is Sexpagy—                 │
│ Rai Inet Lest a j                             │
│ aan inmaohe EPSTED | shape oo                 │
│ 38 AM lAmete , ESTES SSleepug———              │
│ 3 End of shift Pf ACS                         │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Lips  iecc\ 4 --16-oitii-ev1
7128)N
3:PIAJJ 1/417 94.12._,aciiat ,o269.$461144:3Y-4,1eeet
ti
4 . . 1M b. P1/4 tc$S4•0 1‘v\  aee VO,) 4
345.4A Ltd.&  SLeRS- 1% /441C>
qm_68„-±fS__)itspiel;sen s)ra
q". /5Am \HA. Pe-Q-3 j'a0V1 re„
it:1700 -  Et sletbm  ee
5An 4E\ - 04eiy.s. -s
50.6,42:111A Sieer.R`Y\
_5.!)_6, l/fv• _thee fe y, _
„E_QrAcaw3
cmriage --
44141 -
CZ4illik 'I - 91,11 tge
A 9 se4Pt n    7:00E--• 6.0o IJA -1 ,t4A
AP  s_Avuo_avxtspi cal/ ,alck
1-41,a5 cyd fbc.±16e.
2,: us -Si  s4.4/12) c 4 he zej gaic
-;:444 2c
6 6-141 Dr  X r.., r  6*  iff 74 y),
Ns_sim -
?..i _qt,- '1 t" s3e:LNcst_c-J-ins tit 4   frd&*
s ca "he- ete ;tar -
74,4% '11A R Lak,41
ff s   Akok  401-C

╭───────────────── Page 786, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ Epsde 4 163'8-094                                   │
│                                                     │
│ 7 leelia |                                          │
│ 3 ert ' Avmams Davila acura, wren hd, Br Zostera    │
│ a C8Y Récin shih Ahdbc |                            │
│ 3.30 Au * Eytetw 1s cle ay IR                       │
│ 2:49AM WA Esetein is sleeriry = Le                  │
│ 465 Aun lan ss sk eying AOAC                        │
│ 4 IS Ama SL Exped iss kepus Eiixa                   │
│                                                     │
│ 4-302 KW 7M Emsteins in sleeQug                     │
│ YUBAK UM  Eqsteins is sleegivy. ———- 4              │
│ s06D ye ‘fT W eoste: is sleeginy eee a              │
│ SBMA UM Eqstan is sleeginy ___——_ Ae                │
│ Span YM £ eda is sleegusy  ——                       │
│ S45 AM YA EQylen is sleerny ee a                    │
│ 6:00 J TM Ester tS Sleep as aye                     │
│ GISAy ‘a tpsha Is Awake and say aill dele ——— 7.22. │
│ 6:20Dn 7M Epstein is sting on the bd wire           │
│ SHS MM MM Eston 3 sttiy on the bed —— iC            │
│ TBARS Drnade Wouily end sweet MAE                   │
│ 6 Aan De Tmen h pete lop Ah titer                   │
│ Qn <Spetrein                                        │
│                                                     │
│ 21S ‘1M Foden ts S Sddny in dh bod — lie            │
│ 2200) M Eesdas \s itis ou the bd —— Like            │
│ 2 Bam ia Epstun is Lien break, 2 LAE                │
│ gid oe WE OMe 1S shank ad Welle AN ee               │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

t6-
-/Li get3A
cA.)Prio-L
kal CC-CC:i -if- -
192:01.7V___ Too
/4=-Sfa
S'-Fb o P *O cap.SM c.-spr
LTI Co -03‘4\.(t-_, '9 L.
— Loft fIcA.JA ve1a-
q7 5,;•-f % bt a 1 r\A
1 lt Se citt - - /4 ;Art, L.-- S.
Mil* c...O0%ry NsV> Bes ViSv1-
11(4 tes t zJO . iii-,
et !At-
. . qi ii ii i ; 1 - V(  If.;1-  - trY5tetteQ Mi/ ( aft 07 1/4-t e.fr
(0t3itat :51#4 rp511 17.....,./ .9& owe orp..) ifyr...._ nr -i- -0---bl* --o--  ca- laut_A_di to 3`1   r5-te7.......) 
Sin t) 0o -k- 0 NJ LT -itc-
-‘  .-104.14 ep-SkThCZNI
\V7-4,, \ •>-(1,- 1
enD stfT

╭────────── Page 787, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ PSB ha[c ances BOCA ASS cna, CS Gace   │
│ L Fo Epstein #763\8-OS4 ON Dsycd weTcr │
│ ZnS COL ef                             │
│                                        │
│ Su Fy Evateta Complerus Gout Toilet    │
│ Mb" SHteS FOS ina Se ABest FSi         │
│ $a Besterns S45 oN BED AND usneers     │
│ FoR, LY “To Cone Cee Pier Soe F LEAL   │
│                                        │
│ Vise AD                                │
│                                        │
│ cs SR a Bpyieas Lays ON Bey Musnwe     │
│                                        │
│ AT gnc2) CIR So - ————                 │
│ Qa Fa @psiéta SS a Ae                  │
│ Qi aee Zh (Tez SS BT Sips              │
│ ate 8 COSTES Was “AEN Lys              │
│ MELE LOA WIS [L2one ViSi-7r            │
│ 8 Fa ose) SWE Dx) CLLL At “Phi         │
│ ( ie                                   │
│ Oia a (PSEA Sti out ON Coghe           │
│ (Ra Af OpStesw Stu_aut—on Zi YD        │
│ [-[7 Duy ofa und                       │
│ 10. aq 27a Ppsteze Sti out on Legare   │
│ wit ei 2pSA2in Sti Ok ON Eeqne         │
│ \Wek, E74 Cpsteaas Stir ot ons Leget   │
│                                        │
│ END) OF SHTFT                          │
╰────────────────────────────────────────╯

IMP
erio
3eoni_ Ds? .
d
caterS.#  ,aef_02 22
cee°
CL -a-

╭───── Page 788, Image 1 ─────╮
│ ier, AGEL or                │
│ hin cc “Galikitn es —s      │
│ Gp ae Bi os                 │
│                             │
│ lw td pres Clo L—           │
│                             │
│ "390m Pe, Gactiie t2 PLA ee │
│ “tin fee 2 Gpilltns oo.     │
│ [Ep pe db ‘Lijutoy 2 w oe   │
│ (takes putin 2 CA           │
│                             │
│ an                          │
│ Zip OE [nln 2 AUF           │
│                             │
│ 5b ah Vine                  │
│                             │
│ ae Fi Ap (RP OF)            │
│ ee hea                      │
╰─────────────────────────────╯

C
j ea 9.,0769-
E
CND OF SHIFT
- - FlInfrre -CoMPaij  -01;913:1 5,4et -gespzrAis Mary - tot t-- -epSte-y-
C 4
3 963 cisti om PSYCH WArcii (eu..tq 07720q
-e?s-Tes-m- - evi - -0-M- Lifike - V
-.1 00 PM En -rep) 00r vilL ( immArc II oF LEGAL
-7--3; 4 5- fm--Diiiiii Te-w-ps-Terg- -7,-s- -eij-F - -ow_ LeGm, _ v_Isn.
3: 30pm Tfigigre G-PSTEX» is cwr ON LeG4c VISIT
..- 3 -; -4 5-Ptt -loyme.-ff s.revi- - -I& -00T- - am- te (or -vain- f
II: 00 PM V1511 TAM% C?S'relti IS OUT DP 1,66111. - )
T-Lit-l -fakoi-imitrre-ers-r erM-- Is -00T -OW,-  atic - Inti A
' 1:30M INMATE A C957E.V1/4) 1.5007 OK) LEGAL VI SZT
.-4:-414-Pm-umne -e-pstEl»-is - -oorokr -cean c- wrs-i -r-  1-4...
5: 00 PM I/J/444Te 6.""Tk.-2A) Is arr O0 LEGAL VItri _. /g 1
7: 5-:4-5 -Pm - -74t, Tow e-ers-rE1A-)- -is-O07 - OM - tGt4t - ii -I -trr

╭──────────────────────────── Page 789, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────╮
│ ES                                                                         │
│ Dain Arete prtein nod op LA                                                │
│ Loid —-—————— Os                                                           │
│                                                                            │
│ ERROR                                                                      │
│                                                                            │
│ = i.                                                                       │
│                                                                            │
│ — END oF SHIFT. A                                                          │
│                                                                            │
│ Zets-emy~ + Domare- Compton chal AsuMes RESPNS LBLCLTY POR INMAT € EPSTEL, │
│ FTES FOI¥-gSY on PSYCH WATCH IN CELHY B7/2H/19                             │
│ 5-PM-ANMATE-EPSTEEN- TS- Out ON- LEGAE VISIT                               │
│                                                                            │
│ iy                                                                         │
│                                                                            │
│ EPSTEIN TS OvT om LEGAL VISIT ————___                                      │
│ PSTEIN- LS.-gut --0N- LEGAL -VISTT- ———                                    │
│                                                                            │
│ INA TEE                                                                    │
│ 30PM ‘Inmate PST                                                           │
│ 35-45-94 Inmate -€esTesN---38-Ovt-on--CEGAC- VISIT. —————"#                │
│ 4: GOIN IWoATe EPSTEIN TS WT ON LEGAL VISTI. ————— J                       │
│ i 4: IS PM INMATE E*STEIN “TS “OUT ON LEGAC” -VISTT                        │
│                                                                            │
│ yy \INMA                                                                   │
│                                                                            │
│ N TS ovT ON LEG4AC VISIT ——                                                │
│                                                                            │
│ 4. BOON TumATe EPStexh TS OUT Ob Legal VISE. ——————                        │
│ 4-4 5-PN INMATE ATS -OOT-ON-EEGAC UIST T                                   │
│ 5: 9o PM Is OUT OW LEGAL VIsi7 — ——                                        │
│                                                                            │
│ ISP                                                                        │
│                                                                            │
│ Tumat€-€PStesn)- IS ouT-ow- beac VESTA ==                                  │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

5-1-7-sTeLric r7(03).?_054/
- 5-:-3-04 1 AJAMT-6- 54 -00-7- 0# lc -tin CDS76-bd - to Ti-   M C
Sr °  Afr S ----------- ___
- -SHIM - thtfiltr tint t7 Id- tS- vat - o- 7 - L. Mt - - g-Tvg.- Insn
6 : ef 0 Pi9 IgkU tPsrem is ou-r au C6-6,14. lain M C.
- - 6-: I-CPM- -TAIS-E-Pgrexa - -IS- -00T- -OM- teght -   C:-.7 - - td -STI 74
6: 30 Pm 1414ftre els-7 erM IS OUT. OM 16-6AL • V.Ts27 44 C
- 6.i 1[5-Pm- Mitre -6f- Teriid 'IS" 'et) T "OA/ -t-4671- - l-/-1--17 - MC
7: 00PM tutifrre resrew IS Wr OE Vim MC LE Cilit
• 7----- ------ t."7U E'--OF — --SgiF -7-7At -J . 6-t- - - - mc
7: oC2 ( cf,o913 ce-seaurtored--•-- dzo - lea , Sic
7:do il -  °coy .et
Too . 7 M Fe9F-P 6 K 73- 0 5 - , 6 4:(4.4.,.t psi>
,A5-9-4-pta-je r4-7 3.96‘4,--7634-eitt
g:°°-
MiFfu ttemAittoirbe 4dAtt:leY iocr
-T-fact et- .4.,,,,.,tts.„-.0- :da-  zeei ---(2:6
-cee-di
-14e- icc-fypfiezzcz-t, -  -airci-uoujcv-Ceutit . t via
1 ? - ri 9DS4- ati rottkr. 1Ir L al-v-tti e/!!/ '7
4 . tkiji-gti -
i 1 RS — -f -kli-fi l ia'S  . - 49/ 4•

╭──────────────────── Page 790, Image 1 ────────────────────╮
│ = 6? |S Pate - TM Te- EPSTEIM.— Fs OvT--ou- LEGAt~ VISITS │
│                                                           │
│ EIN FW3IE-S54  Sr/e/19                                    │
│                                                           │
│ 5 3pm TNMATE EPS LN: ca “OF OM LEGAL Vrs ps               │
│                                                           │
│ Pi ustx umane epstese £S-DUT + ECS ee                     │
│ 6:00PM | INMATE ERSTE Is Our ow Lega VISIT                │
│                                                           │
│ b: 30PH Thmate Erste2N IS ovr. On LEGAL VISIT.            │
│                                                           │
│ { -6:45Pa “Deere EPSTEEN- IS-OUT ON “CEGALVESET tt        │
│ | F:GG0M |LuntTe EPStEZO IS Odr OU LEGAL vistt —— ;       │
│                                                           │
│ zz ere LANG Da Eli                                        │
│ e: ve Flu Edin Stack fron                                 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

6047c 44  #( ‘3( g -055c
Ticti-E --crsiateck
coo 7(c44 6:004-te _
temiar
xitektceity/
_eu3  z4or
-aS5c m7;s5 75pr)Acite
In -c-dtta&74711'S11c3ifhn_at-ef_psre o3 15 51
-WA  1 3O
A
ARld

╭───────────── Page 791, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ "92%                                        │
│ PGF                                         │
│                                             │
│ 10200                                       │
│ (0-19                                       │
│ 19°70                                       │
│ 2 lOoer                                     │
│ (Ceo                                        │
│ N° Sm_                                      │
│                                             │
│ [ Fi                                        │
│ I ‘ei                                       │
│                                             │
│ fi 2                                        │
│ ea                                          │
│                                             │
│ ¢                                           │
│                                             │
│ rm lawate Eesrews ig sleepin                │
│                                             │
│ mae                                         │
│ B24                                         │
│                                             │
│ Yan lamate. Ensen                           │
│ 1322nny She Pounds.                         │
│                                             │
│ 1B                                          │
│                                             │
│ eras re raibilits Be Hiss KICK ——~          │
│                                             │
│ Eysctey 1160-054 71249                      │
│ Glen Fosbexi ne LH                          │
│                                             │
│ Tha B, (pV oskey le                         │
│ Tai £, a4 hu, Ylaeg                         │
│ ane and                                     │
│ Tha Cnplovg by ie, bof “ie                  │
│ Tle Fraptoey: J edd weer                    │
│ a pls aay Zaye Aisedlig vue                 │
│ Tle G, “IPS                                 │
│ “ SALLE fe                                  │
│ Bandon DeCAPUA 16520-0855 —                 │
│                                             │
│ obsesvation of iamtoYEPs Eat IN) FRe3IS-O84 │
│ mets On, Lfaxft9er IF mM Ve:                │
│ lamete Epstein ss                           │
│                                             │
│ ff nate EPSTEIN 1s 5162                     │
│ lamat, Epstein! seops _———                  │
│                                             │
│ lama Ep sew (S52                            │
│                                             │
│ nate. PTET Ss sleapin Te                    │
│ —— Gest s Sle                               │
│                                             │
│ ‘sep                                        │
│ la mate E PSTEINIS sleepy an                │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯

PS te r 763(8-ds/ 7-V- 20 it?
nDIJ --
/ ,
- r311_) eP5 -1-P ./M 16 de ___ _ _. ,
•
I . •a ' iL#n' -- i
ozszocz, 1 .
a /till • _im_sicr,k -Pan-J.76 rtni-Fige., srTgialo
. .
bpS -tetn a t fito-, 4  Ze S-SaaraA,14,3 PH pt
S-- Pe tv Pze •-SP-era Pr  - SAM d'ai i t n
3a..5,4311 ii-1 Lota it. ade LaiikAza-v-7, (2-tsia4ka4e-s-oloc-,-i-ein-
1  TZ-Pre-_.e.:fly et- 4
3:X)Plf
I q:Atir : it? -F peSsi::k--; -arap-izot----A5-.6€ Satcrett,r—t -tr-- .921
- --05;
t <)A frt e -do- - • 7- Pi?
- #:15• iq p 454-W 7i -1"f ir-4;givi
ti--- c_ L-_-_Sezert;,
-S—.1fg-747 ekfretw,=±_,Ltixtz ,6 S -a,

╭──── Page 792, Image 1 ─────╮
│ i dna tact                 │
│                            │
│ 1 ae Innate EPSTELN i      │
│                            │
│ Z,                         │
│                            │
│ BF Cangas oe: sce          │
│                            │
│ Ge E pate sw2-2nhe>rhewkes │
│                            │
│ ff pa oL Gpeas Uo lee.     │
╰────────────────────────────╯

gpstee ./7-"St 743(g-04i 7__:_W
-`'S'3(5 A  %-,fs Aigsfo  ,
'It(
ctrfizia" 44) A.,,4L ig4,./ 4 ,t
.,46-krici
7:004P
00 sa, 144_105,4___Assodat_L_t tZ5i tiLts___fasz.
7-2T-r7
-  k.S COT_r_ 6-01,  S l'i c' 3ZIC 1-4
ZS+
EF6-rE.a.Ki  c)15

╭─────────────── Page 793, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ “Sno au Thy Ep ste a peor. ke he Shag Ie         │
│ * 360M THE pst hon Tost got Up Al oc VY          │
│                                                  │
│ owen hE; | fo opens AD Wirt betel Ip,            │
│                                                  │
│ CISA                                             │
│                                                  │
│ en fe 42 BR Lhe tf —F                            │
│                                                  │
│ inet an YA BBiety AS Ste Ata                     │
│                                                  │
│ Epster nt 1e2l8-0s¢ FU                           │
│                                                  │
│ Tle hethisoN                                     │
│                                                  │
│ ©: 20RM Wefan s < see                            │
│ basen the je                                     │
│ Ao FC                                            │
│                                                  │
│ merely tei = Bay es P                            │
│                                                  │
│ on Paya ve                                       │
│ es ‘iin feo “stig Fe                             │
│                                                  │
│ 200 AK we out me                                 │
│                                                  │
│ es rig Reabiol? Rater 227                        │
│                                                  │
│ LG Hb TQNCAN WTCHOSY4 AsgunfS KESz0\bi. tus Farm │
│                                                  │
│ Cpstetn BK 16318-054 ON Poycd wrred Dav cece     │
│                                                  │
│ #4 ON _7-2T-1F                                   │
│                                                  │
│ ew wir) esters Deis Of (fron SHasee HE           │
│ Aust tess 5                                      │
│                                                  │
│ TPT ESSTEIN Sits ON BUD Winding Iw               │
│                                                  │
│ MONT Pao                                         │
│                                                  │
│ A                                                │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Fid4/1"-A-ti. 7C,/ - 'Pi 76/ cd(c(
sisa3dcf, 5 -tic  t_ —t-f-, ets
-*- 11  14:21.5-4:24,  _T- 5-1-, esh -r-ti et3
no, i5rn  z-r2/ 41 -S9r - i+ 1_15_es_.
?: ‘1, 4/  134-0
tfe_ ".4•
1-ck szh-) rap
\csd,:t
„ fro , vc )
virsitia4 c.4*, \‘  c\o-a-t?  vcc) -
(44 epyte i ss L45,"5  ON 9,-)
ast -,:,-1#4* -eps-tE.144  stA, cet.54 -. 1/2 rb
101-114iS-atittalSS--:--T CO5-1( Pt5\t2;)  V-)t
rv-h`rva  aiaT SItt 11-1 _
ge-terTer4  01 -1/4\k`c_
C") ) in,._\X\s___NAtnata?..Sst\s.. eff___44.s_Matfl VrlD
ra_ 72 -4 Ce..1 A:5 CJ-0s.3 t 'A _U Spa L. VI Sk+ ViD
po  Mt/ rieLacti-A  t 0 arcitzfr.tfi fred_tasid wear
cjekti,eu;  eeit•L

╭────────────── Page 794, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ Eprten (= 76318 -054% TWlreleq                │
│                                               │
│ LR; GaN ES Sti contaa AD                      │
│ Vy 27h Osa ZS sx et og — *D                   │
│                                               │
│ Tn I prez ES Psy, Rae, KD :                   │
│ 9:43, 2 Wna's on [BED YD _ |                  │
│                                               │
│ Soe Zo ZS Spohing carty DsyQd —VD_|           │
│ i — BD pe                                     │
│ VR Steam bas On BED eit Ess,                  │
│                                               │
│ Drees BeSosS a)                               │
│ GRA 27 foateans gezaes to Be SUE —— MO        │
│ W.8 W ha Costes Se San RSS FAD                │
│ 10; Boa Sha Costes ZS Lawes, ons Reo BES a AD │
│ Whe ha eestete FS soni Vestica VD             │
│ \0.%y Py Borteint = Fas Osrerp ID             │
│ 7A EPS IS Danica, waka, AT Sah AD             │
│ [ihe DNA Eat FS SAK Ag Oo A WE oe AML         │
│                                               │
│ BED “Coda AWG BENDS ay AN Daln OF US Hand VAD │
│ WH Au PoStting On WS Caen, to ® Lega vist AD  │
│ fe END OF = SAIS}                             │
│                                               │
│ aed 5                                         │
│ reg Tle tyes AIT aw this ofr thy 44%          │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────╯

:tir
Fr a„,,,- (=I' 7 "(c6 - o 5'( 7/ 67-9 le Q
ret:44.424.afafrters6_,A;ritarizt ---
-t-a4 oFeat raxacilkt --j4--ra)7 -4 ,
Otet•M €14 4, CLA
r 4t7 :77-4y--tts aatott,
Si/42414A; a°4 4/4._
ice,  :Q.L ;
-45:7‹ccr
1 45 . 1)1D
t c;  -414,-(4t
• ea°
azig
lobe,,p_s-ve4-1/2 \   40-assi
. ;A.( el ittu -42Acilit3 -nr
.x)A5
ft 337 -51A - ; ±
10 5 -FaS ;55
-1 -603—r-rfk -:
Se -EP -5 7 21.1 5_6 1
fa% )R. fisi-gt)  Is 6

╭───────── Page 795, Image 1 ─────────╮
│ Fertiwer ne-054 — Tlaglg            │
│                                     │
│ |                                   │
│                                     │
│ aire YEE pli sd Fayette             │
│                                     │
│ : 10 Tle pend a Ad yoig Hawes Ate   │
│ G4 6 Theo a alipng                  │
│                                     │
│ (0:00 Clean Cptsden jo obey .       │
│                                     │
│ | CRO Rew rr a                      │
│                                     │
│ cs 101 Then hepolee on ole          │
│                                     │
│ : b (0770--- thes Gabe ota atows    │
│                                     │
│ :                                   │
│                                     │
│ 4                                   │
│                                     │
│ |                                   │
│                                     │
│ :                                   │
│                                     │
│ i                                   │
│                                     │
│ os et iy yn enh > OF                │
│ Za ae HOA L— Cf                     │
│ aad. Seniesa eae —                  │
│ : ase POMS! bilctey foo}            │
│ : “obsosvictionl inane ens a        │
│ ‘ opi on TpaltarlO RIB              │
│                                     │
│ ale za lamarhe EPSTEIN s<eeping———} │
│ MW i anate Eestt TEIN 15 ses —      │
│ mate EPS TE 5 Slee SAG              │
│                                     │
│ t IPN                               │
│                                     │
│ “pu |                               │
│ ‘ Sou lamete EPSTEW 1s Slee         │
│ [xu lamate FASTEN | 6 Sleepic       │
│ J2Rm Sta oui (5                     │
│ 1a vimate EPSTEIN IS S eZning       │
│                                     │
│ 1236 lamateEpsTEIN 1S Sle           │
│                                     │
│ Oxy                                 │
╰─────────────────────────────────────╯

--13c*IAmait:FP -s-r-p--_-‘ ts -st -
.145kAt 1,1,43-47,EP5-T-EW i5 sl
-04Linmakasw_W:AsA
farik."6 1
3.39Cgi
ant ak L.
rvc
co, 4
casl brnea rinefte-  7---SCA\PW -1/4  cs55-x-Nes
i 5 ire"P'n5.26 \ At-4, Cs< 40‘ lava' cfsaa, dkvejr-3{-6
aky..-.1  wreat  PrkeA
3: an-, \nr"  cse  00
se,
e-vitx  cwt. dfia, ,,na Lua\ei CsorNe•-
bcoft -A-thzAeip:liaNF - -
210re‘ ltInts\e  s\egers
3: a   I veve t\e --- er,E:oce- vn \5--5\ r - P-m a
' \nret A e  t-9 5\e `n  3kee c> "
LV ? cc2"  Vr\ ICXe 4 5\ n
*tic, s s  l czoisnas

╭──────────────── Page 796, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ st Epstein is sleeping — |                         │
│ amare EPSTEIN S Slezpiig———~—— Fs |                │
│                                                    │
│ Am lamate Beste is sleepi A |                      │
│ SAM linae ESSE UNS seepin |                        │
│ Daw IamateEPsrewn is sleeping                      │
│ B29 lana este is Seen                              │
│                                                    │
│ QU lawyere EBsTEIN ssleepin |                      │
│                                                    │
│ 3AM imate Eosrem iss                               │
│ angen s                                            │
│ Bc (on, Pineda, FSA\OSA _Ossomes ———               │
│ 5 —erpansdoiiha for huh 0 Y6316-co4 wa Bh ~ SFE    │
│ SEs OS Coster \S Sleeping @                        │
│ Ha \anale Eker 13 cualke dunking uxker cn ge——_—__ │
│ pact te s\eee aOser SKA                            │
│ ‘Hen ynmete ss Opslew. 15 sleepings                │
│ am wma Epstein 15 Sleeping                         │
│ diam worale Leste 12 sleeping 7                    │
│ Vee yaradie Coster 13 Skepmg;                      │
│ 42m vomee Costes 13. sleesing                      │
│ Antex amadle Caste va \5_sleeping                  │
│                                                    │
│ rE; a ;                                            │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

5k\n  "3631? -05M  x-30-1`l
\__eccains  o 9 JE
5;_Ffm_j_i_ync,\e__Ccmeav, cm.irtk.g 5_114,,a_
• . 3aV  \c_. \.5 5  v-15
cee- vnrae-
,  61 cAbsft ‘rvr‘eAke--- QPS\--e-AN-N 15 *5\0€
.Mnie-isce NI\ See_c=vNS
/ mean cm\ m ..5_\kevn ‘a_rstoak.
isrA \\Ce
Nn_t_cot4.Sate: IA-
cO eTrn
fic( e 2-, 757-vties

╭─────────────── Page 797, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ “ SS \nme Coster 1s sleeping                    │
│ S: Seen vamade: Leskein 15_owske sitting 09 bed │
│ 2 SQa~ mate Castes \> DERM,                     │
│                                                 │
│ b                                               │
│ +b Bim_inmae Pos\en > 0000s                     │
│                                                 │
│ ¢ AA A                                          │
│ qo Stat a ned Kage Vicvarel Hawt we x 2A 2S50S8 │
│                                                 │
│ Coste 76319-0544 7-30-14 _                      │
│                                                 │
│ — SY                                            │
│                                                 │
│ S: Bon and besser \S sleeping                   │
│ SHI \nmake Ces hesn 15 S\ZCHIng                 │
│ 2. Anmete Qosvewn 6 s\ee eng Sf                 │
│ Yea mene Dostewn 8 DES, ==                      │
│ re JAREC Eps bens 15 Ja\iinay Yo ee apex        │
│ Fee wninale Lestan ts _cobes, WaeahCast 3       │
│ 2: areal Ad Seb>                                │
│                                                 │
│ od Epsterm vin bey ione lonolegot Carol adtdh—h │
│                                                 │
│ TIS Ky Epstern yo a petbirigy loo               │
│ a are                                           │
│                                                 │
│ 730 The I gine thie Thi basal ch Ale leap       │
│                                                 │
│ TAH a fyste/~ 4 lire, dow 10 bax bed —PA,       │
│                                                 │
│ 58a Dr MIB A ee en                              │
│                                                 │
│ Speen                                           │
│                                                 │
│ ya __ er mdamalen lone)                         │
│                                                 │
│ pam, My Clue BR jp bey dipertaw                 │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Mail Attachment
Page 13249
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
( Preferred Voice )
( Work Voice )
( Voice Cell )
( Preferred Internet )
Version
2.1
PRODID
-//Novell Inc//Groupwise 12.0.3
X-GWTYRe
USER
F rrtaillii m
Name
Family: M.
First:
Middle:
Prefix:
Suffix:
Electronic Mail Address ( Preferred Internet )
UID
835B5E40-1106-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Telephone Number (PrefePreferred Voice )
allpi  Voice )
Tele li  ( Voice Cell )
Title
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
Last Revision
20190812T050046Z
X-GWUDF
11 (BES User ID)981
X•GWUDF
1 0(BES Ref ID)0
Psych Observation 7/24-30/19 (UM companion utilized) re: Epstein. Jeffre Edward, Reg.
No. 73618-054
From
To
Date 2019/08/12 15:56
Psych Observation 7/24-30/19 (I/M companion utilized) re: Epstein,
Jeffrey Edward, Reg No. 73618-054
TEXT.htm, Epstein Psych Observation 7-24-30-
2019.pdf
Subject:
Attachments:
Psych Observation 7/24-30/19 (I/M companion utilized)
Page 13252
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D51808.NERDOMENERADMI.100.B67333.1.1 44C9.I
Message Path xmlCabincONEROOnst - New YordMug\5D5I8C38.NERDOMI.NERADMI.I00.1367333.1.140C9.1.xm1
From
Dis pia) Name
Email
QUID 835B5E40-1106-0000-B3D6-FF-66A77089'30
Reply To
Text
To
Cc
Subject Psych Observation 7/24-30/19 (I/M companion seized) re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Scheduled date 2019-08-12 153604
Creation date 2019-08-12 15:56.04
Modified date 2019.08.22 20:4824
Deli% e red date 2019418-12 1556A1
Message size 59
Attachments silt 12409078
Total size 1240914
Attachments 3
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name 7EXT.han
Content II)
5D5113C38.NERDOMLNERADMI.20O2000:0D.I.E
El6C.1@455D518C38.NERDOMILNERADMI.100.1
367333.1.144C9.1@l5D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERA Dhaioa1367333.1.142FF.I@l3
Is Inline false
Type lie
Size 352
Date 2019-08-12 115559
CA 5dc93483300334f884766d37a665b9ec
Hash 4CECB5D3EA9D4756D8ABBF9071AFSSrBA26.5781B 7E57A42BECF8793039536C468E443A04
Attachment
Name
Content ID
5D518C38 NERDOMLNERADM1.200.2000:47.1.E
El6D.1@45:5D518C3SNERDOMI.NERADMI.100.1
367333.1.144C9.1@l3D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERA DMI.100.1367333.1.142FF.1@l3
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 413
Date 2019-08-12 11:1759
CA 777e9c73d5910720da47b4cfsanhv8a1
!lash A028B5683C209400OD4CF643FC573E87013344D8 IA8E7. 6595522J3F65018E17366F95DI D2
Attachment Epstein Psych Observation 7-24-30-2019.pdf
Name Epstein Psych Observation 7-24-30-2019.0f
Content II)
5D518C38.NERDOMI.NERADM1.200.200000D.I.E
El6E-1@455D518C38.NESDOMI.NERADMI.100. I
367333.1.14409.1Q13D4E9C39.NERDOMI.NERA DM1.100.1367333.1.142FF.I@l3
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 12408313
Date 2019-08-12 1151:10
CA 9148cb8b603cd580752119329388146
Hash CF4DIF64D51080194BD667BC809D49EA47DDA176 EC26353F966802288D27A62SOFFCAEF_8
Recipients 2
Recipient
Uis play Name
Email
UNIX 610E9350484F-0000-4839-F8OF2A59A443
Distribution Type CC
Recipient 'fype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2E9821380-14C3.0000.9B47.43F62C05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Page 13253
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type lobos
Return notification alien opened false
Return notification .hen deleted false
Return notification y,hen
completed false
Return notification "hen declined false
Return notification ”,hen
accepted false
Archive %onion 5.3
Internal ID 5D518C313.NERDOMLNERADMLIC0.1367333.1.1440).1@h5D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.13
67333.1.142FT.1@l3
Source received
Class Public
Account MI
I 5-#XS43691206 Location ID
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Aug
II) 5D4E9C39.NERDOMLNERADMLIC0.1367333.1.142W.1@l3
Name Aug
Type Normal
System false
Share Type NotShared
Published 201MM-04834
Page 13254
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-11-042034M EST Created
cn=Arehive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archive ken-Jobssn-GWOpenNodetn-archiv
thg.ortictmail
Generated by Neigpvem len-Archive
Agent _2-Zero Day
AArchiveItn-Jobs.cn-GWOperiNolesn-archb
iigo-netniail
2020-05-19 152859 EDT Tag ROP01703.MXRADMI.M501DOMI Responsive
2020-05-1915:17/36 EDT Tag BOP01703.M3CRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05.19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
Page 13255
Mail Attachment
Page 13256
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
( Preferred Voice )
( Work Voice )
( Voice Cell )
( Preferred Internet )
Version
2.1
PRODID
-//Novell Inc//Groupwise 12.0.3
X-GWTYRe
USER
F rrtaillii m
Name
Family: M.
First:
Middle:
Prefix:
Suffix:
Electronic Mail Address ( Preferred Internet )
UID
835B5E40-1106-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Telephone Number (PrefePreferred Voice )
allpi  Voice )
Tele li  ( Voice Cell )
Title
ASSOCIATE WARDEN
Last Revision
20190812T050046Z
X-GWUDF
11 (BES User ID)981
X•GWUDF
1 0(BES Ref ID)0
Mail Attachment
Epstein Psych Observation 7-24-30-2019.pdf
Page 13259
yt:Fi. OBSERVATION LOG
I NAME:
REGISTRATION:::  7V?)  - sel
OBSERVATION STARTED:   - 2017
OBSERVATION ENDED: 7
PLEASE. RETURN LOG TO PSYCHOLOGY AFTER THE
OBSERVATION HAS ENDED.
TKANK YOU.
ITEMS ALLOWED::
__Regular Clothes
Safett , Toothbrush
__Newspaper/Magazine
`__Books (softcover only);. b Safety Pen and Paper II,
Toilet Paper
Legal Mai:
Other
SW Blanket & SW Mattress must he used even on Psych
Observations.
If nothing is checked with a silver marker, only a Suicide
Smock and Suicide Blanket sue allowed.
Name of Inmate On Suicide Watch or Psych Observation:  &.'"1,-5.--6 ,40:7
Registration #:  9-6 yijr
EAT NG/SHOWER CHART
DATE BREAKFAST
LUNCH DINNER
( LIQUIDS OFFERED
SHOWER
RECEIVED
SHOWER •
Iv*
Please check the appropriate box if the person on
Suicide Watch/Psych Observation actually eats his
meal. Do not check the box if heiust received it,
but did not eat it.
Place a check in the "Liquids" box each time the
person drinks.
Thank you.
EpSian  7C3  --MI i ±.2.et-zoicr
PrE te -fei.n.
8S-44.1te War Cie F.L  LL--s-• vp
y CA- ace,4041  277  MOSZ7 v-An:44,
000 T Et c 1/4 _ekccomes- .iberpnersb Qin Psych S'/
aVery s-t -Cps]. ; -762.1 -3::(5Str -
VVon Ziff! Eps4-c-; it
ic4cfklatikiliei7isj: r
_cArtis, EPAL4  Jr  Q C (e" .^ 5 ci_b_o_kz.zsaii
q:75digif L;§Cee Ctn d ar G kaki ri  CA) 0 ;..21- Ma —
t ti In% e 1/4 12_ c;• ivt_t,
t3:1/1 -CriaLatzsle'.. 1 ct  K   ftL (1 ---
?NS- IZM E 6_e_4
Olaii); -41/"X FADsVe S• p eliUW  eefiA r L__
TbA  Cip„de.:n aippecxns 4o le Lea:
4134,24_1411__E.9_,tta_appiiegzs to e cSteepiturra
.20Licm Mi4 €p3kin i 9 c1/41.0,,,x eac ith_b_wski _121,1_1c
War -r f  I C 104.-Yin On
CIVIC(
EPA
15-1:07074re., EPSTC- Wii5Aaelp

╭────────────────── Page 811, Image 1 ──────────────────╮
│ EpSbe 1 sb763 (8-054 72 24-20/F                       │
│ 40% Epstein Eakin, AClewer                            │
│ BIS The b/c Come a Fuh bine Vp                        │
│ Iman Pacaiabs Sap Peedhad westiar, 227 56080          │
│ Siooph, Ler Enx\ sch__ascomes rerpenzabliy Qe Psy) At │
│ 77 elon ser aoa” Ce lM an TEATE= ore                  │
│ SiS ln Epstein is falkine to Unit? Recon              │
│ S20 Zn Eps} en ie dal Teng fo Um FX oltiagg S.        │
│ Spe Zn Epstein iz asking a avout sail \ife            │
│ VcGpq Lm Epstern and T ace talk: ng, about Sail (eA   │
│ Som /M Ep ste -Gsie me lreime, Cc                     │
│ sam LIM Epstein ack me abor' kta pe hese€             │
│ Veena TM Epstein is laying awake on hs bed <          │
│ [O%O Gp TI Costen Appeas Se he Sleeping; S            │
│ I2'6ou IIA Ep stein appears to be Sleeping om         │
│ em L/M Epstein aopens te be hee iy, SE                │
│ 248m THM Epstein if quote aod borshiis Ws teeth CC =  │
│ WORM Ensen 76 layine, On _his bed =                   │
│ om 7 Sud. toy = -                                     │
│ Bev | Braidsn DeChPy Ai EVCOAD OSH, SSUES             │
│ bos spews biltiGer hess Bidehpbsen@tipnr vate.        │
│ ete, ne 7e3) SOSH in call oa Tauliq                   │
│ at IPC en Bb (ye JoZe— tJ                             │
│ ie PA Aweste ESTE IQs seeping — =                     │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

30._
If sp S erttAi"
IA I.5
-)
I 5
ig S-I- COIA
a Infas-e,gps-co.) is40 , i -- la vfiects-esr it1/4\-is-5
I Vi i. . ,t.,e-ih V
- -I mbv0 -6,:(
g o--i-
I  5 1-45 i I-N 155
- 114$q
_at. .3z)
_ cal_ fej45 /,,A
12 x.
r5
'4'3
- - " - -
tkil-e-5--1-E.,b3 ;55
1:4; )315 -
I ?
-E.7 1\:-ic  3
PST I
;
AM r ni'1 415h if Iiii4
) .1\ es
ID Pak tiL.)a-

╭─────────── Page 812, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ a x eg Eestets dis See ping — -         │
│ \l* Fem || marc EPSTEWIs slee QQ        │
│ 130K oo EDs Ss — = =                    │
│ (A"Syqlamarke Epsrein is 5 sleepiog} —  │
│ Beto Count                              │
│ Xan | LEPSTEIN 6 Sloe ping—————         │
│ AMAZE. STE pissed =                     │
│                                         │
│ OM nale EPSTEDN ss rn =.                │
│ Papa Lt Row 4                           │
│                                         │
│ 2m bvrasshy; cP 1 iN- is sleepin ———— { │
│ 4 Inmehe EPSTEIN is sleep ing G         │
│ 2°9n asta EPSTEWN is slo ee ——          │
│                                         │
│ 2? am, Inte ERSTEDD is Seep             │
│ am nneje- Leste Ig                      │
│                                         │
│ 3 En ™ i Epsre. nS . Sle                │
│                                         │
│ EAN, DA are Eestei a.sleco}             │
│                                         │
│ So aw ware Epsteny is lazon             │
│ +s AM lamer Epstein iS a                │
│                                         │
│ ‘e5 AN at Ee EPSTEIN                    │
│                                         │
│ 4 4m Lacwer se career BUN               │
│                                         │
│ cee In                                  │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────╯

?ste‘f.) A_ 76 3,8-05Li
44 -fro-A-k:  --Gessrast 5,ve, .) Sosi-5-tio ,s 4-- -1-,„-„zi,4;a- PaTEN ;c 1
tuna-6 FP5.-t-Fim ;s 5
E:Pseitik €_5( cap Ail
ea5
-171: 7%_Jun
CIESL
7.±5A,.. Lu:.s Fe vw, ckz. 61.6 8-0c9 - c;SSOneS Yes
7/64,4
--t
1-1.44 c) • -ft- - 76 irs=uS-4..
a 1N ar-C
0  Sk)f, -1---
I5ten-- fe 4110.5 -6S   'et.ti_4.t44e4
IL 763(e-ogy
-to

╭────────────────────── Page 813, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ E gstew & 7% 318-084                                          │
│ 44 nate EPSTEIN 1 is i" ——                                    │
│ San Ih nso PSTE I Nisg                                        │
│ Oe ime TEPSTE! Wiss see                                       │
│ SAW Tame EPsrel                                               │
│                                                               │
│ 5 Na Sore -                                                   │
│ 5 on heoatko- ERs = [NS rested — -                            │
│ Kn Inmate Leste in is sh cep A                                │
│                                                               │
│ OM Inmate EPSTEIN i ~suale on J                               │
│ ean mec EPSTEIN js ou abou indon bed =                        │
│ OAM inate E2PSTE: INS awake 5 Sanaa eyis) ‘                   │
│                                                               │
│ 1% ie Festeinis sacked ie                                     │
│ 73M ania EDSTEIN Sawlashnt mera                               │
│ 78a Inmate Este In 15 eupte. sikinyontea!                     │
│ Piatt cad of hedge ——                                         │
│ 775ta lus Fermmmder. $7 626 8-O5Y - assumes ves pow S bj lity │
│                                                               │
│ = OE SS ei 2631809 SEE                                        │
│                                                               │
│ ts al oes ~ LE                                                │
│                                                               │
│ "2 "a ’ Ee pstein a ie                                        │
│ $3 ry wheg bo —                                               │
│                                                               │
│ [eA ns                                                        │
│                                                               │
│ Gor - Exe ot s“i¥¢ Tv — _ —«L_ fF                             │
│                                                               │
│ Iso ELC MERIC OB PE79- OFF axdumiy ee"                        │
│ ogpens telat, por Ten Cason # TENE -OF¢                       │
│                                                               │
│ og Dhee tpeatsel 5 ad nba free)                               │
│                                                               │
│ tude                                                          │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

• ts 7 67)(8 • 09-f
A44,2,actiA4,4frta:rie
ett-icaa<
1.1
get
erc
10:rz-c3W1-
/414.4.10-44-e-gy  te.k.A.44.64
T-6m- fgfrier-th -etzi:ku-t  ecet-ott-ele-ealti7 ter
- -lei ;co t-t-ce-zo
Li Ea -44.
Ticoreiathk rtidatWatcr-P14
0-14.41x4-046 _
tke-tra:-,  w arts"

╭────────── Page 814, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ Eppltew 7678-054                       │
│                                        │
│ Goo Fac tesdbas 02.) Tory chacwra: toa │
│ Gia pha Coen anal                      │
│ digeinetur,                            │
│                                        │
│ e276 Plo Pl tae a CLE                  │
│ i by a cana ef                         │
│ kama hee pepe, esse peaplioey lu       │
│                                        │
│ FAG Flew pps aa dipeg dow fa anat Coe  │
│                                        │
│ FS Rew Kk pace ce HE.                  │
│                                        │
│ 40 Th ErsToui Avilioy ee               │
│                                        │
│ ‘cam Hert pb a a cori :                │
│                                        │
│ CoO Mea egies oles hoch us H4. ee      │
│                                        │
│ oF ee ae een                           │
│ , eee hs foot, : vee                   │
│                                        │
│ oO Tees enley Az 1                     │
│                                        │
│ OruG OT abba ly dootedtel 2            │
│                                        │
│ plein Ly                               │
│ OFF Eo yea — UPA                       │
│ jDSSeut Brandon Del ape! WO =055 Cont) │
╰────────────────────────────────────────╯

aveo, —7(7-5t g -0 c_(
_ frthcaSjile .5_ P-01440  -
_ .4
e& Inman E5.__ALt5r5-I . .
I!3e)rm Foetakir rEPSIN  1.q15_ig
1\1* lAPSPSTP-11 165k) p
lApArsia
la -1544) AAJEsc<4;0-;-s-<
) Imici-erra) ;saf
L-r
-I A 14 --Einw
I itM E-Pi\)  E
attit, 14^406-innslad -
--h-ms- ratu
AC--

╭───────────── Page 815, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ Eisen # ESI ¥ -OSY                          │
│                                             │
│ (¢ andy. BIOS re psikili ore tio.           │
│ pau . h obsesvet 5 eafe JAN AR are! EPSTEIN │
│ HTGSISAO5Y In cellet on ei ab               │
│ 1072, Lp RD                                 │
│ Hes hunate EPSTEM ic “layin eu. quie— BS    │
│ I\'m Innate EPSTEIN 4s sh in :              │
│ re Pi innate EPSTEIN 1s Sle Hi              │
│ 4B, Jame LPSTEY § issl                      │
│ logit lnmakoEPstern ¢                       │
│ lak Mote TONES                              │
│ 12 xn Inmates EPSTED issleep iQ             │
│ 125814 lomate ERSTE NY 15 3/; -             │
│ een hate ERSTEIWs fe                        │
│ 1h faa eT ‘cab                              │
│                                             │
│ hy nijatecE: aoe ——                         │
│                                             │
│ 1%, Aa LT                                   │
│                                             │
│ yy cfs iss                                  │
│                                             │
│ "Be Inmate EPSTEIN 's deep                  │
│ em ipeieersre Ske 7                         │
│ 2bn lime Eest; EIN eh.                      │
│ 2a lameteEpsrein is eA                      │
│                                             │
│ Aan Estep is Sle 70g e——————                │
│ L7H, olde re of f '                         │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯

p re- int 72 r -76i2 -Usk.
:.34.-acf4"lic-CarVa_mscaRe_ma.bil\u,
--0( casc\r\ QA4 Li 754 ecAaintor3ce ,
4a)vre,  wm\c_ tp4 Vr\ \5 5\ee - 3 PWNS
3Dtr-V:\ Hp 3/4\-e. acb\eyr, ' 64.3-4\te kans \\IL 'tech .1€,
• a
ocAm Htrirnek\e- 46 \ eve\ na 4wres --SC
YorA yrcerri\e_ Cp5\reAn .5 vx5 3 PS ‘.5
-3a,,, rm, 3sire ,i)4,e.‘, \ X6  \., Sheectins
2-V2 IwY\Tritk\P Qc•rAev 5 EC, 5\eitcite
LI:efr-• wirTtAe acpk-Q-An - -. \= 5 fl c3 ---
I = 1 lrn\t e9s\e-QA.5\er?‘") 3F&
--i t:Pc,,liv.
v.)  1-cy(eck\e. tpi\e-s" • 3C6 -k,.) s\ercv na
-5 °° its .. - %Nese. id 10 _. di_ Ne. „ I. . , . I.,I.L.,..,1
S-6. r.?ne, Incr,c;cy O.O7 \h V").__4O26‘1T1 7k
S..3;a4n • LA)
. 5\229e \INGi
vv.IN0‘\ce_ 5eAv-\ _ aa __ Wu-.:cc. -45\ -CAn h 4.er(1vfloi
\CA -Sca
\*I-1-Ne.;re )C‘ evr\ k)
tiwY•ka\c_ Q?*Nr.,  .S\ C(7
nr A\e  135Xe:Vn V -5\e'e911
11/4 s\t

╭─────────────── Page 816, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ EPSTEW HEA —-USL                                │
│                                                 │
│ 08 Ff BARN                                      │
│ 3:88 te a Voeoda OSSOMES Respacschiltyy         │
│                                                 │
│ Sox _ gun cele 4 Fn Leste 293:9-090-— JG        │
│ Fem male Costera rs Sleepny, SEE                │
│ Bsa Meale Coser 15 owate Wang We Ibe Xe         │
│ eins WIM GNE Ease See SED sleep — SO)           │
│ Byam? Coster ‘S s\ecerng————_— SF6              │
│ SONA AMOS Ces\ewn S NEA, ———                    │
│                                                 │
│ B&R orale Coslen 15. sleepng                    │
│ deen Wreke Ceska \s Sleep ina,                  │
│ ABQ | inenade. Leste v3 S\eceneg ———— £6        │
│                                                 │
│ Ore AROS Boskesx is even NEG                    │
│ Seen romake fleshown wwke ap Xo ve edt 403 no 5 │
│ S: oon Rea OgsNen \>_ Skepny,                   │
│ S- Peery Dende Coser ‘Ss Secewrey               │
│ San ine Bede \3_S\@e ney                        │
│ OE samore Cesewn 15 Seeswng                     │
│ oe rreexe Cos heya ib eeQss,                    │
│ 6:3eq yarnedhe Coster 15 sleesing,              │
│ rary Wn TE Cosleia o MET IAG,                   │
│ F&A jnmac Costews 15 See pang                   │
│ Tem \Arnche Coste ib Slee ang,                  │
│ 7. oq wqnnae Qestern \S sleeqrngy               │
│ Bem Stel vouass                                 │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

-)C, — 0
P-e- c we A:x
7-Rd-I?
7:cft-friirndse. ua - rwaaNCA an\ \4) -
kkodA kv\truAt 4A\ vc\ atAe-
%iv St-Lot-Jcre.  111.
1 54 5-4->e/HIC  mobirt4 -0S-ti  1-1_s_swt-te
itp:AtN)O , \,-kts 4_173-1c -J--i
CCCC -4t1 ° 4 ‘  17)%\ici-L011:Stifsietkis)WSSg._  7-ZS4i
1)..NH i'ES--t Ni_  Sti  _gueAcgrsi
Vib
rj-ket ti -3. r% fra.94._ Ws SMoba_
V kJ -7 4 1--Cduk
SvAks e____Ott..\ Ste> un._-k,
VIM
I ps-tf " • zs Zots14.,-.5 14, 5 7 Ct.+ k
Crc%SitaNQ ns en-4 ife)
7-$ LEA vvns Sc Les.,  vist# if(D_
etoad ta - tic- :LIM-cc ..s.Ats&Es (les 2a-s-a \-3
or-Q4 opser  s - (AA CP5re+) t$-0
6%4 r-icolic, Wcy

╭────────────── Page 817, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ E pstew fe W3l&-OSY                           │
│                                               │
│ Fen amare. Loslan Recwed wrealbes}— SK        │
│ Bh lh $L 7-24 .                               │
│ tars WRANE WLAN No ready (denis) —— SG.       │
│ PE Wnmake sk\\ Ww dendss\; = = Riice          │
│ bad ok shy = 3G                               │
│ SU Say Dl Epsteas) ts tN nie Stews —————_ A)  │
│ [ab IC DSA KOTCYOSY Assomes                   │
│ Risgons ton iy, fon 2psteIs 76313-054 EN      │
│ CECLAFAL ONS PSYCH OBRLEVA OSS ON 7-754 KD    │
│ Sn Zu 2estein As sti Boceentiy ns =the        │
│ Sows ai)                                      │
│ mre Fh SPwtCIN 3s Dargrasy OFF From Hs. Sete  │
│ 1)                                            │
│                                               │
│ 48° GMM sors rae                              │
│                                               │
│ GOR NK Ciskciw's Sh                           │
│ : AY                                          │
│                                               │
│ On A l2sau Neosat                             │
│ Gil Ths fpstive” IS Basing His Totty —— D>    │
│ 9a Phe Cotes ES Sting “ant BED KD             │
│ GB Ah, eestesy zs Liaving Fue Ugne Vist —— kD │
│ GI) oF SHY                                    │
│ Bon ST Bre TSBEE  Pssumes pesne sat y         │
│ Fok RS -0 BS. oF FIM. - EPSTEW-4E PEBIZ-CSY:  │
│ oe Delia wan Ba, PA% ay ye                    │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Co An 'Nye() r -LA ,R kr ft ty c r -r - )
cc---_- - -
- .
.._.- ,--1--- --
- —1-
_  _
-ti -........s.
f.>
:A. . L..- . ..,
?i • IL,

╭─── Page 818, Image 1 ───╮
│ UCD om sek T Page coe y │
╰─────────────────────────╯

— -
7 -
... ...L.
" ...
— 1 -:.- 717. 1 • ' -.) ' 1 -1: -‘ `.-- cit.' - ., Jr !.7.7 7 4. 1 • n.t .?' \. - ,
. '-' ? t"",  ?c - ) - .  •
( N.0 4- : t
--...,_ ‘ ...
C231 .2 r 7: -d - I - . — -- - — ---
c......_
.  :

• Ift-I 2 ---....., c- .. . -, ,- (..: .r.-i - C. K.
. ' QC.) •-•'•-1.
4 i  •_..  .
,
' • V .
\ )- i .- \ 1"-I \. 1  7-f4: ric! -7r-G- )  .:1... L. L'.7 hp P '1
' ; •   c'e
ni$. t
L2t,.-0•CA -• Ice ' .,
'" -.4.-
dr i  • -r7,-
•-3•,- , --- , •
r., Pfri ::' .3  1 i
! , Z..-
‘: '-. -, A f w.,. 0 • p • . 4. .---) r'sei
,. r N --)  • • ,
.1 2 C*1 --J
- \
....
---......,
.....-
,. . .
(_1,4) -1 No e,y)N 0„„7‘93
575%,, -7* 76 3/ ts- -o Sy
Wao- C-P-s•TerQ nnues- - fzi3A- - ow-c- vtIrt
)5 etc TtM 60 :›ttC:t0 C'&  inn° 1-roym c--/
tivc( *iv& ticmGt firm le 'Sir Se.
•
tez."cka---
trim -CPSrcs:r k s
0:4c I ti tw. cPsG.tJ  u Pow&
Plavv-r assnTv-osc
LL -7" ) r:Ct A^ aSirizr -IS-a rectici - - vS-pers.s- mein -
$1% 5 lit ta C-,Ps"Tre.pa ss> scu, ts.,,..c eus,tass
si-v71r t riv ?‘ t•- rre c=Cgtkb cai: FCC,  L,
Y
-•
-D-ca-1 - - -G7s7 -e; -SkrgZ
S rttis C-.1;a 1b Ct:'t
%cc. Lesson's
bLas:Lcb,b.4.,
k
"2„. J 3::;(0" E.RST( r. ,NS WE —C, P.04 r -n -e s re Ith\o -i -1-
eme
S3C6-4.9 ‘CCV .7e
'cur,  02 51 e . t-) QC-tune's kt, t•-1/4-wuca f>miu
vt - -6Q -5- de-reci- -03f&%-t .- Slicsctit)
k 5 V1 A". 4: VS-te.rJ OCN, ffi •-5 Pt
ra2 o- rcim -S-prat I w  poricm- - its 6c .-.5rtizrAis
M rS 15 4^ of ic le • id AV 03125—cb itt StedPg•

╭──────────────── Page 820, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ E pster # FE 31E-OSY                               │
│                                                    │
│ PNG Boom Beste sires Gam Leone vrei                │
│ NOuS Dan €PSTeW Recess Pun Pen C/o                 │
│ (G30 Dim -EPsTe ns Du Oevrces- BoB 0-P Pobieg      │
│                                                    │
│ wel Pie LS AGE WN LESITS                           │
│                                                    │
│ oF                                                 │
│ Sag agu yw CRS wip 1S CIM                          │
│ QW vig Rew ande ——_ | eS.                          │
│ Ve 36 Tim €Pstew “is ratceswo aR Ruse rer          │
│ 2 DOMS | Sun Elsie BW Lye y Ow 77                  │
│ Qe WDM EPS Te STAVE PB VET Busi ss tes             │
│ QS Tin CPstens § Dscussng Bosess + Lise Lessons    │
│ Wie WW GRTES WRAIS WBE KG WE Sa                    │
│ Ws Din Gessews pias nm Be Stes®wQ                  │
│                                                    │
│ 2 R)S0 Clo Rounos wy                               │
│                                                    │
│ Fo Ton Siew CERES fo BE SLoaG                      │
│ ¢ = -                                              │
│ © OPNS TM EPSIES CSRTENS TORE SGSMG=               │
│                                                    │
│ ( Wdo | Tin EST ems O8H> ME Time poses ne TealoT + │
│                                                    │
│ Seusnes “Kes “TH eT ae                             │
│ TIM SUK slew Rennes & LGne Daw ;                   │
│ TSS DIV CP Ser (RRS RISE SO -PUS                   │
│ BAS Dim F Psleo Pres Wy KH SIacpnc, ———7           │
│ D330 TM BOF Ww ponorrs 10 Be S@P.ks re             │
│ DMS Dyan Cleans PMCS Ty Ae Tee                     │
│ O00 Eiwn EC OS¥.7 ~ POC Cows TU Be Slee diKG       │
│                                                    │
│ £                                                  │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

:res ce:NyL461-nrgi -Ow
CY; ts- ?sec' cr4c=r - -CtE- - Slags. lac-
( c.) <--.) 4r, 4i•C 5
-S(QaptA*—
a .. 6-("SiCnt,i eedskeS\S tis s3 t gs/s94-U
- tviy‘- - -6esier t a- - - --6e - -CL(29fai`i-
so ,yi EPsIdeir.i Pcit-ri\s • h) es& ,-562s)cus6
-
Oct€15\377:5iii\RVrCiaTPMCLS16-&--Str2O-Mt:  -
3);k5 turn  eocce s t-71 Ge..75 1/4-P Tv c-Ar4  . -
- p•VS ow-It - crc (--4;1•11-4-4- cs - - Crt.r - "Rs - - ,N.)
Lieu 9 F. c_, ti  Pt 1. T.
Ii,A  sc>sice,  r•—/f u.......vaes pea (..)._71- -n4
Ste
-or Vs pit . -.O1%-1 - tam -- M -Lt
Prravas Pt/IPip__ • •
0 a.1/445 w".• e9 -k ‘1*-f, PRRIC-e0S  e .C*4 -‘-)
Wee.0.4k •
P";:nrCiVavvSci Gisothi n5 /twos, -0 rpsjeZ el:4-263/84<4
ti t6 cts,C1 HA ee?s_leaa_ i s s ice V O
31 - a• ify -m  ,\ es \ as _ i 5
ctal ;;;•177P  • 51
e
.2.e
►_ -
4A4P.c
4-14=

╭───────────────────────── Page 821, Image 1 ──────────────────────────╮
│ EPSTE tye B32 - OSy                                                  │
│                                                                      │
│ YAS (Di Ee                                                           │
│                                                                      │
│ - TEEN POPES (UE RE Sg e.N6 re                                       │
│                                                                      │
│ Osu C(y9Sovsss - —                                                   │
│ OFS ALIN “EPS TER POPES AV--BE--SKQPUV—-                             │
│                                                                      │
│ OAed | Tier ECHew KOags fF Be Soe ——                                 │
│                                                                      │
│ OLAS-—--Tfnn---EPS ters —- OP 68S ty - Be Shoo PAG                   │
│                                                                      │
│ MZ Din EPSiew ARORA S@ORG —————re                                    │
│ MUS Tip Stews Plans “NY BES Steering                                 │
│                                                                      │
│ Ow Dim TE PORES WW Re StooP iw St                                    │
│                                                                      │
│ YDS Tim Eestesr GETs OW CWasn Caw ({ —                               │
│                                                                      │
│ —— Faces  PRoe#kt wot Caw ty - Ge TW Ste wy                          │
│ — Lieu BF Gowme mw &® UW. Ee @uwics ABUT Me. —                       │
│                                                                      │
│ a FUND Rens - SF -- VAR Coe --ONTS ice                               │
│                                                                      │
│ DD b30 F/M EPSens THe Ar mestiteve |                                 │
│                                                                      │
│ = OF“ VArCON                                                         │
│                                                                      │
│ OdMus cim, Dim eestews ates ty Be steep b |                          │
│ A ES SORT De T shee att DV SS89-05 ry —                              │
│                                                                      │
│ ae ——~ MAK                                                           │
│                                                                      │
│ JEOOAM jig Avmands Dawila _aseming vesqurss lish oA epstein 7608-080 │
│                                                                      │
│ Begun ani tt a —                                                     │
│ Sisco am Tm egstein is sleering AD Pec                               │
│ B1Sam i egeten is sleegi@q =a De                                     │
│                                                                      │
│ Ape                                                                  │
│                                                                      │
│ $:30.a% TM egstein is. sleesing                                      │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

ILK i_s, "SeseSAL
4V1 eeRin%
.24:1__Qyx 'ER ese?a:\ n
j
.14:115O), ti tA
-3:00 cin)
-O51
s artryieg s
't% aeeC&Cos
S s..\eengsr).s
e_sRiAtiim
,r\
Qee cns
+ale% ciris
taco, '11A
_94ei
n S
51.ce St‘s
A:00 cow, WI\ •(*ei
j:6%  p?sleiTi s sloe y'__
6 3 20 Ol t M e_- -tPi%O gsleerici43
-&zi5roctiA
‘,..521-1Q71_
nske: 'S -51sei_tio%
k 2 gn• -h re"--1 - Z./ f A h 7` -A-1
.4.01C
0.ac
.4"c
Lil i  040.4 "VC e it.learJ iWidezZ /455vmeg vigp.„6 trtts
tp`Mlia%i t-IG3141-83-7/  J-rJ Cti-CarcL0AL'i, 5
‘‘Yale,/ 07%,) 7 -21-13
mit -RISC st..an0 "7"exs-O4
p es -rt coktos__Goos- k-scan_D__t..' ms„-429 griositi. vc
S. -r5 n /.7 r3lar ,
Orr rearnifir  )1D
trie-____I_ra.5 Netts-% V r CV,

╭───────────── Page 822, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ SHS am                                       │
│ “dseo am                                     │
│ 4ildan                                       │
│ 4: $0 am                                     │
│ US USom                                      │
│ 2:00 am                                      │
│ SBam                                         │
│ AL 20am                                      │
│ Bs Bow                                       │
│ 6:60 aw                                      │
│ 6:18 a»                                      │
│ 6>20 Gn                                      │
│ G4 San                                       │
│                                              │
│ : LIAM De Fine fp rer                        │
│                                              │
│ 00                                           │
│ Am                                           │
│                                              │
│ ~~                                           │
│ TR                                           │
│                                              │
│ Enolein #76318 -OSY                          │
│ 7 (27/12                                     │
│ Ya egsiein ts, deegiag —=——————_ Adee.       │
│ ‘I eastdn” 1s sleegng ——_4#/e                │
│                                              │
│ TIM epelei ray \B_sleeging, ANpe             │
│ YA eortag is sleesson, AMAc                  │
│ ‘TM eastein 38 Slee ning, Anpe               │
│ YM egstein is sleegigy -__—._ 99) Ac         │
│ Va egsten 1a slewing Mec                     │
│                                              │
│ Mlm eastern \S eleg sing —__ 472             │
│ ‘LA ester is sleeging                        │
│ ‘LIN epstei n AS sleegiag,                   │
│                                              │
│ wo eVstein is__sleeging                      │
│ ‘1M epstein is_sleesiny Wee                  │
│ (fh eR shea is Sleeging AAS                  │
│ = lape Aa tate                               │
│                                              │
│ Pe Opts ane                                  │
│ Fhe Dascmes VWIL4654 Assumes LES porate hits │
│ OF 2pstTI aE 1634-54] IN Colca Y On) yen     │
│ weed on 1-27-19                              │
│ FIR CASES AaKS FR “Tole? Testue ead Toot     │
│ \20STE Which wt MuvD Ia tht Saply Dhst+— VD) │
│ SLA OPSTELA) SiS On BED wraps                │
│ Orin DO CK ERSO = i" Lae)                    │
│ Flot G25 Ht SAS ne TLD KO                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Fq9stero 763
7-27-20(9
4:4  2 /,- ri.)5. r.f.,7 s -, s ar,i  Ilse)
7.2 :1,-. 4/ 4-e 40.5--r_z..../ Srs tre-,, RCYD  -KT
VV,-, iii ,/ Cp5-re.2,. we95- Z-Ty_Srett•rp 3 trAfieosr _4_
T  - E,'".) Or Sif.o.F7--------....,
s':oor s-69-i. A-)4-.4) Sa4,(4-12(cLiovrttil ?`.(czt,- , ',fez 2175'-ios-6
Pa' 3;157!. F. - gsff in _ is ue4...;-,1 _ __AL
--9=2:1".-' - aY-e - - ecai - e). e, i a P s - Aa" ..-„ -,-,..§7-
St30B4 •• A.? Epsi-ein  _A ,s,..,,_ rzai    4::<1
gij il  A1--ela --;
?24 ( ,-( ep4k-e4-4--, -2.- 1 -9.ekcs c..1.4.6-4- ,g^ 3,  -g-{..Q.72t
___6/Q.W...—
;:30/2.-.A--T-s-;arzz;ai--i-c_ ' -.-------- --- -:-
1,0,-i -.&_ .acto  ?Ai
-----fe Ai
M
is7 cf:
• irto PP'
76 -17A4   hp
to-oPm   6Lgrpczt  sj2"f` -, 1,,X,fe___La,....Atick,r,n  2-7 7s-easo
0.*1,Bczi-joA,DZANA 4_cz

╭──────────────── Page 823, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ EPStern #763                                      │
│                                                   │
│ (ea Deg Cpt 7 Sit8 Gre BED                        │
│ (i a rt (ps ery 78 ory BED ye)                    │
│ Wie Ya Wpstes J 373 oA BED Ky)                    │
│ 0% Fa Cestetey was dot SHVD) 304 fes¢ KD)_        │
│ ee TD) oF SHzF7 ———.                              │
│ §:00 “Bese Slag Richayed A Mant: Ner 27786050     │
│ ie Epsten Su x get hock z 4                       │
│ ais" A Epstern IB Unreng, ra feat ny |            │
│ O28" We Coll Coke) the takes 25 rs? Slope         │
│ Bisel M Eostern a \uk Takkeve, ———                │
│ 86 7 Epon Ao < x4                                 │
│ fasta JH pli +o Tallec, alot Hy Lee em            │
│ win he genial paplation~ RY                       │
│ G6 J Eakin tuk Talkie RY                          │
│ 1:30 Pg Vin LS Sat Fath: .4 ———__ Rf              │
│ 1950" Za polar tse to Slay ——— Bg                 │
│ 0:00 aE Peta appeers ko te tetany ——k             │
│                                                   │
│ 01S Tn EPS tem aqypeore Me be —Ra                 │
│                                                   │
│ ial (2 Ep SHe on hye Ke be roy hh                 │
│ 145" 7 Epstein appuers Re he seeing —RM           │
│ 100 he Spon Fpapion~n ke be dg Vie                │
│                                                   │
│ Pia, the heel paladuote rs:                       │
│                                                   │
│ en | ; Besagen (DeG PUA IG52O-OSS assumes(Cot dD) │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

re:ar19:4;0 6; I cr-A4krat3 a / 1:66erYaii CA
-Car I n metie, 5;-P5 - rELL\I 4nka_ -435? in' (silt& on
- d ',  7/ 12 /fi zran): 49N
ii'?& ;IMAS-fra- cPSTE1 .15_,5  s pa  :pi
4 toit
15e:)&04pAaj-zEirSit 1 xl iS sir -do t
61  at
_ --WI  - 1-1-am: ---Eat -ED -is - - et  II    11 ri
MI
0 A i
,,.. I it  SU la, JAM I 1\)
)  hvAnko Fp5 - raiA
/ 3 % 6,4  _5±2.5m,1 ista
II 5A.tium A)
-1190-Am4Imna-feS FISTE EA)
-.  SAM tiltna-bc)_C-4 251-CII,3
cl•  lamakzliSIN ; 5 _<
r 5Ahn 6
-3172,w  -riMa& -FF<Irtt
1nrn Ps is
P  514..eppa,
S4P2rA
.It
it i  f I
-T I
lAnne3477, CPSIS  a l
_ kiis_Siedepi
A
I  { 0. I
1,4

╭────────────── Page 824, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ “Genk cesponstilhy eth ne DSiichs observation │
│ Soe Amato Epstein #763! OSE in call ¢ oN.     │
│ P/27N' 8 at ION. IG                           │
│                                               │
│ Rm Lan = aeons Ss DiA\ =                      │
│ IE fe ‘tere E PSTE —                          │
│                                               │
│ re)                                           │
│ Tein                                          │
│ fa At ar aes                                  │
│ PAN [nwo PSTEIN is Sleeping —                 │
│ =f                                            │
│                                               │
│ AmatecE STEIN ie seeping                      │
│ RR late. FpsTelN is sleep —                   │
│ Kn lamate COSTE IN if SJ mea —                │
│ |nmahe E05 STEIN iS slee G —                  │
│ ou hint: Eesreny is slezpin ————              │
│ ah Jamsshe, ERSTEW isSleepia 7 J              │
│ oO un damate EasTew is sez) i¢—= t            │
│ Bw. limate Eestes,\ \5.s skepag —~—— ;        │
│ AB lange: Epstein is Sexpagy—                 │
│ Rai Inet Lest a j                             │
│ aan inmaohe EPSTED | shape oo                 │
│ 38 AM lAmete , ESTES SSleepug———              │
│ 3 End of shift Pf ACS                         │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Lips  iecc\ 4 --16-oitii-ev1
7128)N
3:PIAJJ 1/417 94.12._,aciiat ,o269.$461144:3Y-4,1eeet
ti
4 . . 1M b. P1/4 tc$S4•0 1‘v\  aee VO,) 4
345.4A Ltd.&  SLeRS- 1% /441C>
qm_68„-±fS__)itspiel;sen s)ra
q". /5Am \HA. Pe-Q-3 j'a0V1 re„
it:1700 -  Et sletbm  ee
5An 4E\ - 04eiy.s. -s
50.6,42:111A Sieer.R`Y\
_5.!)_6, l/fv• _thee fe y, _
„E_QrAcaw3
cmriage --
44141 -
CZ4illik 'I - 91,11 tge
A 9 se4Pt n    7:00E--• 6.0o IJA -1 ,t4A
AP  s_Avuo_avxtspi cal/ ,alck
1-41,a5 cyd fbc.±16e.
2,: us -Si  s4.4/12) c 4 he zej gaic
-;:444 2c
6 6-141 Dr  X r.., r  6*  iff 74 y),
Ns_sim -
?..i _qt,- '1 t" s3e:LNcst_c-J-ins tit 4   frd&*
s ca "he- ete ;tar -
74,4% '11A R Lak,41
ff s   Akok  401-C

╭───────────────── Page 825, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ Epsde 4 163'8-094                                   │
│                                                     │
│ 7 leelia |                                          │
│ 3 ert ' Avmams Davila acura, wren hd, Br Zostera    │
│ a C8Y Récin shih Ahdbc |                            │
│ 3.30 Au * Eytetw 1s cle ay IR                       │
│ 2:49AM WA Esetein is sleeriry = Le                  │
│ 465 Aun lan ss sk eying AOAC                        │
│ 4 IS Ama SL Exped iss kepus Eiixa                   │
│                                                     │
│ 4-302 KW 7M Emsteins in sleeQug                     │
│ YUBAK UM  Eqsteins is sleegivy. ———- 4              │
│ s06D ye ‘fT W eoste: is sleeginy eee a              │
│ SBMA UM Eqstan is sleeginy ___——_ Ae                │
│ Span YM £ eda is sleegusy  ——                       │
│ S45 AM YA EQylen is sleerny ee a                    │
│ 6:00 J TM Ester tS Sleep as aye                     │
│ GISAy ‘a tpsha Is Awake and say aill dele ——— 7.22. │
│ 6:20Dn 7M Epstein is sting on the bd wire           │
│ SHS MM MM Eston 3 sttiy on the bed —— iC            │
│ TBARS Drnade Wouily end sweet MAE                   │
│ 6 Aan De Tmen h pete lop Ah titer                   │
│ Qn <Spetrein                                        │
│                                                     │
│ 21S ‘1M Foden ts S Sddny in dh bod — lie            │
│ 2200) M Eesdas \s itis ou the bd —— Like            │
│ 2 Bam ia Epstun is Lien break, 2 LAE                │
│ gid oe WE OMe 1S shank ad Welle AN ee               │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

t6-
-/Li get3A
cA.)Prio-L
kal CC-CC:i -if- -
192:01.7V___ Too
/4=-Sfa
S'-Fb o P *O cap.SM c.-spr
LTI Co -03‘4\.(t-_, '9 L.
— Loft fIcA.JA ve1a-
q7 5,;•-f % bt a 1 r\A
1 lt Se citt - - /4 ;Art, L.-- S.
Mil* c...O0%ry NsV> Bes ViSv1-
11(4 tes t zJO . iii-,
et !At-
. . qi ii ii i ; 1 - V(  If.;1-  - trY5tetteQ Mi/ ( aft 07 1/4-t e.fr
(0t3itat :51#4 rp511 17.....,./ .9& owe orp..) ifyr...._ nr -i- -0---bl* --o--  ca- laut_A_di to 3`1   r5-te7.......) 
Sin t) 0o -k- 0 NJ LT -itc-
-‘  .-104.14 ep-SkThCZNI
\V7-4,, \ •>-(1,- 1
enD stfT

╭────────── Page 826, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ PSB ha[c ances BOCA ASS cna, CS Gace   │
│ L Fo Epstein #763\8-OS4 ON Dsycd weTcr │
│ ZnS COL ef                             │
│                                        │
│ Su Fy Evateta Complerus Gout Toilet    │
│ Mb" SHteS FOS ina Se ABest FSi         │
│ $a Besterns S45 oN BED AND usneers     │
│ FoR, LY “To Cone Cee Pier Soe F LEAL   │
│                                        │
│ Vise AD                                │
│                                        │
│ cs SR a Bpyieas Lays ON Bey Musnwe     │
│                                        │
│ AT gnc2) CIR So - ————                 │
│ Qa Fa @psiéta SS a Ae                  │
│ Qi aee Zh (Tez SS BT Sips              │
│ ate 8 COSTES Was “AEN Lys              │
│ MELE LOA WIS [L2one ViSi-7r            │
│ 8 Fa ose) SWE Dx) CLLL At “Phi         │
│ ( ie                                   │
│ Oia a (PSEA Sti out ON Coghe           │
│ (Ra Af OpStesw Stu_aut—on Zi YD        │
│ [-[7 Duy ofa und                       │
│ 10. aq 27a Ppsteze Sti out on Legare   │
│ wit ei 2pSA2in Sti Ok ON Eeqne         │
│ \Wek, E74 Cpsteaas Stir ot ons Leget   │
│                                        │
│ END) OF SHTFT                          │
╰────────────────────────────────────────╯

IMP
erio
3eoni_ Ds? .
d
caterS.#  ,aef_02 22
cee°
CL -a-

╭───── Page 827, Image 1 ─────╮
│ ier, AGEL or                │
│ hin cc “Galikitn es —s      │
│ Gp ae Bi os                 │
│                             │
│ lw td pres Clo L—           │
│                             │
│ "390m Pe, Gactiie t2 PLA ee │
│ “tin fee 2 Gpilltns oo.     │
│ [Ep pe db ‘Lijutoy 2 w oe   │
│ (takes putin 2 CA           │
│                             │
│ an                          │
│ Zip OE [nln 2 AUF           │
│                             │
│ 5b ah Vine                  │
│                             │
│ ae Fi Ap (RP OF)            │
│ ee hea                      │
╰─────────────────────────────╯

C
j ea 9.,0769-
E
CND OF SHIFT
- - FlInfrre -CoMPaij  -01;913:1 5,4et -gespzrAis Mary - tot t-- -epSte-y-
C 4
3 963 cisti om PSYCH WArcii (eu..tq 07720q
-e?s-Tes-m- - evi - -0-M- Lifike - V
-.1 00 PM En -rep) 00r vilL ( immArc II oF LEGAL
-7--3; 4 5- fm--Diiiiii Te-w-ps-Terg- -7,-s- -eij-F - -ow_ LeGm, _ v_Isn.
3: 30pm Tfigigre G-PSTEX» is cwr ON LeG4c VISIT
..- 3 -; -4 5-Ptt -loyme.-ff s.revi- - -I& -00T- - am- te (or -vain- f
II: 00 PM V1511 TAM% C?S'relti IS OUT DP 1,66111. - )
T-Lit-l -fakoi-imitrre-ers-r erM-- Is -00T -OW,-  atic - Inti A
' 1:30M INMATE A C957E.V1/4) 1.5007 OK) LEGAL VI SZT
.-4:-414-Pm-umne -e-pstEl»-is - -oorokr -cean c- wrs-i -r-  1-4...
5: 00 PM I/J/444Te 6.""Tk.-2A) Is arr O0 LEGAL VItri _. /g 1
7: 5-:4-5 -Pm - -74t, Tow e-ers-rE1A-)- -is-O07 - OM - tGt4t - ii -I -trr

╭──────────────────────────── Page 828, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────╮
│ ES                                                                         │
│ Dain Arete prtein nod op LA                                                │
│ Loid —-—————— Os                                                           │
│                                                                            │
│ ERROR                                                                      │
│                                                                            │
│ = i.                                                                       │
│                                                                            │
│ — END oF SHIFT. A                                                          │
│                                                                            │
│ Zets-emy~ + Domare- Compton chal AsuMes RESPNS LBLCLTY POR INMAT € EPSTEL, │
│ FTES FOI¥-gSY on PSYCH WATCH IN CELHY B7/2H/19                             │
│ 5-PM-ANMATE-EPSTEEN- TS- Out ON- LEGAE VISIT                               │
│                                                                            │
│ iy                                                                         │
│                                                                            │
│ EPSTEIN TS OvT om LEGAL VISIT ————___                                      │
│ PSTEIN- LS.-gut --0N- LEGAL -VISTT- ———                                    │
│                                                                            │
│ INA TEE                                                                    │
│ 30PM ‘Inmate PST                                                           │
│ 35-45-94 Inmate -€esTesN---38-Ovt-on--CEGAC- VISIT. —————"#                │
│ 4: GOIN IWoATe EPSTEIN TS WT ON LEGAL VISTI. ————— J                       │
│ i 4: IS PM INMATE E*STEIN “TS “OUT ON LEGAC” -VISTT                        │
│                                                                            │
│ yy \INMA                                                                   │
│                                                                            │
│ N TS ovT ON LEG4AC VISIT ——                                                │
│                                                                            │
│ 4. BOON TumATe EPStexh TS OUT Ob Legal VISE. ——————                        │
│ 4-4 5-PN INMATE ATS -OOT-ON-EEGAC UIST T                                   │
│ 5: 9o PM Is OUT OW LEGAL VIsi7 — ——                                        │
│                                                                            │
│ ISP                                                                        │
│                                                                            │
│ Tumat€-€PStesn)- IS ouT-ow- beac VESTA ==                                  │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

5-1-7-sTeLric r7(03).?_054/
- 5-:-3-04 1 AJAMT-6- 54 -00-7- 0# lc -tin CDS76-bd - to Ti-   M C
Sr °  Afr S ----------- ___
- -SHIM - thtfiltr tint t7 Id- tS- vat - o- 7 - L. Mt - - g-Tvg.- Insn
6 : ef 0 Pi9 IgkU tPsrem is ou-r au C6-6,14. lain M C.
- - 6-: I-CPM- -TAIS-E-Pgrexa - -IS- -00T- -OM- teght -   C:-.7 - - td -STI 74
6: 30 Pm 1414ftre els-7 erM IS OUT. OM 16-6AL • V.Ts27 44 C
- 6.i 1[5-Pm- Mitre -6f- Teriid 'IS" 'et) T "OA/ -t-4671- - l-/-1--17 - MC
7: 00PM tutifrre resrew IS Wr OE Vim MC LE Cilit
• 7----- ------ t."7U E'--OF — --SgiF -7-7At -J . 6-t- - - - mc
7: oC2 ( cf,o913 ce-seaurtored--•-- dzo - lea , Sic
7:do il -  °coy .et
Too . 7 M Fe9F-P 6 K 73- 0 5 - , 6 4:(4.4.,.t psi>
,A5-9-4-pta-je r4-7 3.96‘4,--7634-eitt
g:°°-
MiFfu ttemAittoirbe 4dAtt:leY iocr
-T-fact et- .4.,,,,.,tts.„-.0- :da-  zeei ---(2:6
-cee-di
-14e- icc-fypfiezzcz-t, -  -airci-uoujcv-Ceutit . t via
1 ? - ri 9DS4- ati rottkr. 1Ir L al-v-tti e/!!/ '7
4 . tkiji-gti -
i 1 RS — -f -kli-fi l ia'S  . - 49/ 4•

╭──────────────────── Page 829, Image 1 ────────────────────╮
│ = 6? |S Pate - TM Te- EPSTEIM.— Fs OvT--ou- LEGAt~ VISITS │
│                                                           │
│ EIN FW3IE-S54  Sr/e/19                                    │
│                                                           │
│ 5 3pm TNMATE EPS LN: ca “OF OM LEGAL Vrs ps               │
│                                                           │
│ Pi ustx umane epstese £S-DUT + ECS ee                     │
│ 6:00PM | INMATE ERSTE Is Our ow Lega VISIT                │
│                                                           │
│ b: 30PH Thmate Erste2N IS ovr. On LEGAL VISIT.            │
│                                                           │
│ { -6:45Pa “Deere EPSTEEN- IS-OUT ON “CEGALVESET tt        │
│ | F:GG0M |LuntTe EPStEZO IS Odr OU LEGAL vistt —— ;       │
│                                                           │
│ zz ere LANG Da Eli                                        │
│ e: ve Flu Edin Stack fron                                 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

6047c 44  #( ‘3( g -055c
Ticti-E --crsiateck
coo 7(c44 6:004-te _
temiar
xitektceity/
_eu3  z4or
-aS5c m7;s5 75pr)Acite
In -c-dtta&74711'S11c3ifhn_at-ef_psre o3 15 51
-WA  1 3O
A
ARld

╭───────────── Page 830, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ "92%                                        │
│ PGF                                         │
│                                             │
│ 10200                                       │
│ (0-19                                       │
│ 19°70                                       │
│ 2 lOoer                                     │
│ (Ceo                                        │
│ N° Sm_                                      │
│                                             │
│ [ Fi                                        │
│ I ‘ei                                       │
│                                             │
│ fi 2                                        │
│ ea                                          │
│                                             │
│ ¢                                           │
│                                             │
│ rm lawate Eesrews ig sleepin                │
│                                             │
│ mae                                         │
│ B24                                         │
│                                             │
│ Yan lamate. Ensen                           │
│ 1322nny She Pounds.                         │
│                                             │
│ 1B                                          │
│                                             │
│ eras re raibilits Be Hiss KICK ——~          │
│                                             │
│ Eysctey 1160-054 71249                      │
│ Glen Fosbexi ne LH                          │
│                                             │
│ Tha B, (pV oskey le                         │
│ Tai £, a4 hu, Ylaeg                         │
│ ane and                                     │
│ Tha Cnplovg by ie, bof “ie                  │
│ Tle Fraptoey: J edd weer                    │
│ a pls aay Zaye Aisedlig vue                 │
│ Tle G, “IPS                                 │
│ “ SALLE fe                                  │
│ Bandon DeCAPUA 16520-0855 —                 │
│                                             │
│ obsesvation of iamtoYEPs Eat IN) FRe3IS-O84 │
│ mets On, Lfaxft9er IF mM Ve:                │
│ lamete Epstein ss                           │
│                                             │
│ ff nate EPSTEIN 1s 5162                     │
│ lamat, Epstein! seops _———                  │
│                                             │
│ lama Ep sew (S52                            │
│                                             │
│ nate. PTET Ss sleapin Te                    │
│ —— Gest s Sle                               │
│                                             │
│ ‘sep                                        │
│ la mate E PSTEINIS sleepy an                │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯

PS te r 763(8-ds/ 7-V- 20 it?
nDIJ --
/ ,
- r311_) eP5 -1-P ./M 16 de ___ _ _. ,
•
I . •a ' iL#n' -- i
ozszocz, 1 .
a /till • _im_sicr,k -Pan-J.76 rtni-Fige., srTgialo
. .
bpS -tetn a t fito-, 4  Ze S-SaaraA,14,3 PH pt
S-- Pe tv Pze •-SP-era Pr  - SAM d'ai i t n
3a..5,4311 ii-1 Lota it. ade LaiikAza-v-7, (2-tsia4ka4e-s-oloc-,-i-ein-
1  TZ-Pre-_.e.:fly et- 4
3:X)Plf
I q:Atir : it? -F peSsi::k--; -arap-izot----A5-.6€ Satcrett,r—t -tr-- .921
- --05;
t <)A frt e -do- - • 7- Pi?
- #:15• iq p 454-W 7i -1"f ir-4;givi
ti--- c_ L-_-_Sezert;,
-S—.1fg-747 ekfretw,=±_,Ltixtz ,6 S -a,

╭──── Page 831, Image 1 ─────╮
│ i dna tact                 │
│                            │
│ 1 ae Innate EPSTELN i      │
│                            │
│ Z,                         │
│                            │
│ BF Cangas oe: sce          │
│                            │
│ Ge E pate sw2-2nhe>rhewkes │
│                            │
│ ff pa oL Gpeas Uo lee.     │
╰────────────────────────────╯

gpstee ./7-"St 743(g-04i 7__:_W
-`'S'3(5 A  %-,fs Aigsfo  ,
'It(
ctrfizia" 44) A.,,4L ig4,./ 4 ,t
.,46-krici
7:004P
00 sa, 144_105,4___Assodat_L_t tZ5i tiLts___fasz.
7-2T-r7
-  k.S COT_r_ 6-01,  S l'i c' 3ZIC 1-4
ZS+
EF6-rE.a.Ki  c)15

╭─────────────── Page 832, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ “Sno au Thy Ep ste a peor. ke he Shag Ie         │
│ * 360M THE pst hon Tost got Up Al oc VY          │
│                                                  │
│ owen hE; | fo opens AD Wirt betel Ip,            │
│                                                  │
│ CISA                                             │
│                                                  │
│ en fe 42 BR Lhe tf —F                            │
│                                                  │
│ inet an YA BBiety AS Ste Ata                     │
│                                                  │
│ Epster nt 1e2l8-0s¢ FU                           │
│                                                  │
│ Tle hethisoN                                     │
│                                                  │
│ ©: 20RM Wefan s < see                            │
│ basen the je                                     │
│ Ao FC                                            │
│                                                  │
│ merely tei = Bay es P                            │
│                                                  │
│ on Paya ve                                       │
│ es ‘iin feo “stig Fe                             │
│                                                  │
│ 200 AK we out me                                 │
│                                                  │
│ es rig Reabiol? Rater 227                        │
│                                                  │
│ LG Hb TQNCAN WTCHOSY4 AsgunfS KESz0\bi. tus Farm │
│                                                  │
│ Cpstetn BK 16318-054 ON Poycd wrred Dav cece     │
│                                                  │
│ #4 ON _7-2T-1F                                   │
│                                                  │
│ ew wir) esters Deis Of (fron SHasee HE           │
│ Aust tess 5                                      │
│                                                  │
│ TPT ESSTEIN Sits ON BUD Winding Iw               │
│                                                  │
│ MONT Pao                                         │
│                                                  │
│ A                                                │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

FfrA-P-4-ti-i=7C,/ - 'Pi 76/ cd(c(
5-r, it  t_ -t-f-, ets
"rim  5-/-, dah -i —t, "3
1 :1 4 5 %7   -9%—i-lrircest•-‘
Affi 's  134.;)
maser
1-ck sziN-) rat° _
-CA cs--s
„fro _ t t,
virsitia4 -3s>  sva_t?  vcc)
{44 epytel ss 1.45,"5  ON   cns-i-sc,cs
ast-,:,-*AA.-eps-tE.144  St 12-t54 -, 1/2 r b
101-114le.44-atilitalSS--1 -S-5 tam Pa Alt?
rv-h`rx%  (.4f1TeRt__RT SItt
e-terTer-1  01 -1/4\ft.
C-) a,.\\\S__NAt —elaa?..Sa_V• eg__44.S_Matn VriD
ra- 72 -4 Ce..1 A:5 6.105  t 'A t5  L. VI Si - ViD
po  Mt/ rieLacti-A t 0 arcitzfr.tfi fred_tasid wear
a_tczeJA4   eeit•L

╭─────────────── Page 833, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ Eprten (= 76318 -054% TWlreleq                   │
│                                                  │
│ LR; GaN ES Sti contaa AD                         │
│ VE 7m Bostat £S sri wert ngy ——— KD _|           │
│ Wen 7 Cpr Tez SS OS Rae —— KADY |                │
│ 9: %%. Za lass ow BED ‘KD                        │
│                                                  │
│ VE Sh east TS Spohing uty PSyQd — VD             │
│ yd | BE Yee wy |                                 │
│ VR Steam bas On BED eit Ess,                     │
│                                                  │
│ Drees BeSosS a)                                  │
│ GRA 27 foateans gezaes to Be SUE —— MO           │
│ Wie Fla tose Se Sen QEeee? AD                    │
│ Wika 2m fosters xs hayes, on BED BEStiaa— AD     │
│ Whe ha eestete FS soni Vestica vp                │
│ \0.%y Py Borteint = Fas Osrerp ID                │
│ [21a Epsom IS Deotvaa, notte, At Sah AD          │
│ [ihe DNA Eat FS SAK Ag Oo A WE oe AML            │
│                                                  │
│ SSLD_ Goin WIG MEKS Sy ART Rain oF Hs ManTsh VAD │
│ Whe Aa_tosste Roa ws tae, toe Lega vist AD       │
│ sy END OF = SAIS}                                │
│                                                  │
│ aed 5                                            │
│ reg Tle tyes AIT aw this ofr thy 44%             │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

:tir
Fr a„,,,- (=I' 7 "(c6 - o 5'( 7/ 67-9 le Q
ret:44.424.afafrters6_,A;ritarizt ---
-t-a4 oFeat raxacilkt --j4--ra)7 -4 ,
Otet•M €14 4, CLA
r 4t7 :77-4y--tts aatott,
Si/42414A; a°4 4/4._
ice,  :Q.L ;
-45:7‹ccr
1 45 . 1)1D
t c;  -414,-(4t
• ea°
azig
lobe,,p_s-ve4-1/2 \   40-assi
. ;A.( el ittu -42Acilit3 -nr
.x)A5
ft 337 -51A - ; ±
10 5 -FaS ;55
-1 -603—r-rfk -:
Se -EP -5 7 21.1 5_6 1
fa% )R. fisi-gt)  Is 6

╭───────── Page 834, Image 1 ─────────╮
│ Fertiwer ne-054 — Tlaglg            │
│                                     │
│ |                                   │
│                                     │
│ aire YEE pli sd Fayette             │
│                                     │
│ : 10 Tle pend a Ad yoig Hawes Ate   │
│ G4 6 Theo a alipng                  │
│                                     │
│ (0:00 Clean Cptsden jo obey .       │
│                                     │
│ | CRO Rew rr a                      │
│                                     │
│ cs 101 Then hepolee on ole          │
│                                     │
│ : b (0770--- thes Gabe ota atows    │
│                                     │
│ :                                   │
│                                     │
│ 4                                   │
│                                     │
│ |                                   │
│                                     │
│ :                                   │
│                                     │
│ i                                   │
│                                     │
│ os et iy yn enh > OF                │
│ Za ae HOA L— Cf                     │
│ aad. Seniesa eae —                  │
│ : ase POMS! bilctey foo}            │
│ : “obsosvictionl inane ens a        │
│ ‘ opi on TpaltarlO RIB              │
│                                     │
│ ale za lamarhe EPSTEIN s<eeping———} │
│ MW i anate Eestt TEIN 15 ses —      │
│ mate EPS TE 5 Slee SAG              │
│                                     │
│ t IPN                               │
│                                     │
│ “pu |                               │
│ ‘ Sou lamete EPSTEW 1s Slee         │
│ [xu lamate FASTEN | 6 Sleepic       │
│ J2Rm Sta oui (5                     │
│ 1a vimate EPSTEIN IS S eZning       │
│                                     │
│ 1236 lamateEpsTEIN 1S Sle           │
│                                     │
│ Oxy                                 │
╰─────────────────────────────────────╯

--13c*IAmait:FP -s-r-p--_-‘ ts -st -
.145kAt 1,1,43-47,EP5-T-EW i5 sl
-04Linmakasw_W:AsA
farik."6 1
3.39Cgi
ant ak L.
rvc
co, 4
casl brnea rinefte-  7---SCA\PW -1/4  cs55-x-Nes
i 5 ire"P'n5.26 \ At-4, Cs< 40‘ lava' cfsaa, dkvejr-3{-6
aky..-.1  wreat  PrkeA
3: an-, \nr"  cse  00
se,
e-vitx  cwt. dfia, ,,na Lua\ei CsorNe•-
bcoft -A-thzAeip:liaNF - -
210re‘ ltInts\e  s\egers
3: a   I veve t\e --- er,E:oce- vn \5--5\ r - P-m a
' \nret A e  t-9 5\e `n  3kee c> "
LV ? cc2"  Vr\ ICXe 4 5\ n
*tic, s s  l czoisnas

╭──────────────── Page 835, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ st Epstein is sleeping — |                         │
│ amare EPSTEIN S Slezpiig———~—— Fs |                │
│                                                    │
│ Am lamate Beste is sleepi A |                      │
│ SAM linae ESSE UNS seepin |                        │
│ Daw IamateEPsrewn is sleeping                      │
│ B29 lana este is Seen                              │
│                                                    │
│ QU lawyere EBsTEIN ssleepin |                      │
│                                                    │
│ 3AM imate Eosrem iss                               │
│ angen s                                            │
│ Bc (on, Pineda, FSA\OSA _Ossomes ———               │
│ 5 —erpansdoiiha for huh 0 Y6316-co4 wa Bh ~ SFE    │
│ SEs OS Coster \S Sleeping @                        │
│ Ha \anale Eker 13 cualke dunking uxker cn ge——_—__ │
│ pact te s\eee aOser SKA                            │
│ ‘Hen ynmete ss Opslew. 15 sleepings                │
│ am wma Epstein 15 Sleeping                         │
│ diam worale Leste 12 sleeping 7                    │
│ Vee yaradie Coster 13 Skepmg;                      │
│ 42m vomee Costes 13. sleesing                      │
│ Antex amadle Caste va \5_sleeping                  │
│                                                    │
│ rE; a ;                                            │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

I
apskeAn /-054k
ep5\-exn -a- \--ec-f2wIS essn  t oosit or a e a_ .51c.
lir 5 --c:fr .5
• 30.°  \c_. -a 5 k \5 5 5 _e _ _ _ -Q, 95\ c\x\ \,) 5\ -e- ‘n
:it nor\ &like_ Op S\--e-\rN 3\ee
re f\ .(Yncd\e_e v\ Seel? seNs
R-30-\c1
-41-. ,a‘eOm  vn c,
Hlet\ \\Ce
Urp oc \N\C%\i-
116nr, ga   ( Duet 2---t 7S-803*
em e

╭─────────────── Page 836, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ WSO A,                                          │
│                                                 │
│ . Som AMA Eostew \> dlecaing                    │
│ S: Seen vamade: Leskein 15_owske sitting 09 bed │
│                                                 │
│ 2 SQa~ mate Castes \> DERM,                     │
│                                                 │
│ b                                               │
│ +b Bim_inmae Pos\en > 0000s                     │
│                                                 │
│ ¢ AA A                                          │
│ qo Stat a ned Kage Vicvarel Hawt we x 2A 2S50S8 │
│                                                 │
│ lo shen 763) 5-05-44 7-30-\4_                   │
│ SK                                              │
│ — SF                                            │
│                                                 │
│ S: ay \ncd& besser \s sleeping Sf               │
│ S on wymadke Ceslew s5 Sleeping - 3             │
│ (22 vnmete Apstern 6 slee eng                   │
│                                                 │
│ eq mee. Dostewn 8 DES, ==                       │
│                                                 │
│ AE jae pars Javan, Noe Glbeds =                 │
│ Fem jamate Ledlan ats coheg, Wreahbask S        │
│                                                 │
│ Zi ad Sui}                                      │
│                                                 │
│ od Epsterm vin bey ione lonolegot Corel adtih—€ │
│                                                 │
│ TIS Ky Epstern / ina petling [ed                │
│ ieee                                            │
│ 70 he He Gye ‘the He rsa Mle lag                │
│ TKAH a fpste/~ 4 lire, dow 10 bax bed —PA,      │
│ BARD Ta be Ly                                   │
│ Speen                                           │
│ 1G Ve Ban ph OS                                 │
│ pL Fook Chere BR 4 bey dipertaw                 │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Updated Timeline -Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
From
To
Date 2019/08/10 17:35
Subject: Updated Timeline-Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Please see the attached.
Thank you
Page 13288
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.165396E.1.5 Al&I I
Message Path xmlibiaboxJ5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .165396E.1.5A182.1.xml
From
Minas Name
Email
til ID 9D77B2D0.19C1-0000-A989.0200000058D0
Reply To
Test
To tamale
Sta
Subject Updated Taneline.Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Scheduled date 2019-08-10173534
Creation date 2019-08.10173534
Modified date 2019.08.10 173554
Delis e red date 2019.08-10 173535
Message size 39
Attachments size 15171
Total size 15221
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.Iim
Name TEXT.Iihn
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOM 1.NYMADMI.200.200003& 1.9
E92E-1®455D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADM I. I . 1
65396E1.5A182.1®12.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is 'idiot false
Type file
Silt 195
Date 2019-08-10133527
CA d7972383c0.24161ad9bde 135284625(9
(lash 88FD52.5778ETHEA2A693564A702F79093B2DFCB5 ESEHE372D5I535EB222E155C7E8C818
Attachment Epsteb. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618.054_1.docx
Name Epsteir. Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-0541.docx
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000038.1.9
E92F.1®455D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1
65396E.1.5A182.1®II.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.103 .0.1.0.1Q116
Is 1nline fake
Type fde
Size 14976
Date 2019-08.10133431
CA 85d159d829a0tab9641,028028416%58
Hash CDF139C5A667C8DAC0061A1742306DFC36065E821 565F62D6AC0B72B5FAIITDEDEB99D819
Recipients 8
Recipient —
Displin Name
Email
UUID 2750CAD0-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delivered 2019-08-10173534
DoonloadedByThirdParty 2019-08-10173538
Opened 2019.08.101757:14
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 835B5E40.I1C6-0000.B3DSFE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystentircopMember
Delivered 2019.08-10 17:35:34
DownloadedByThIrdParty 2019.08-10 173535
Opened 2019-08-107, 47-55
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB000-0C0C-0000-886E-10003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delivered 2019-08.10173534
Page 13289
DownloadedByThIrdParty 2019-08-16203209
Opened 2019-08-20130900
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Ul ID 2DDA9D30-10060000-987C-OCD8BB221439A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemaroupMembet
Delivered 2019-08-101735:34
DownloadedByThIrdParty 2019-08-10179598
Recipie nt .-- Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-004F-0000-AB39-F80F2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delis ered 2019-08-10113554
DonnloadedllyThirdParty 2019-08-10173535
Opened 2019.08.101736147
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
ULM 9D77B2D0.190.0000.A989-02C0000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delivered 2019-08-10173534
DonnloadedByThirdParty 2019-08-10173536
Opened 2019-08-101735:47
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Ut ID 4237CDC01407-0000-A820-84D2120084D2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SyncmGroup
Delivered 2019-08-10173534
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
UU1D 66E64C10-B20-0000-8ECI-2F2162868DCC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroph4cmber
Delivered 2019.08-10173534
DounloadedB)ThIrdParty 2019-08-10173538
Opened 2019-08-1018:43:50
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read Mt
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbax
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted false
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification when
accepted fake
Amish e Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.165396E.1.5 A182.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1(01 6
Source received
Class Put*
Account DANADMIDANDOM1
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Page 13290
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maalox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.01.01@l6
Name Madbox
T.pe Mailbox
System true
Share Type No Shared
Page 13291
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23 17:2435 EDT Created
cn-Archive Agent 1-Daily Archive3
Jobon-Jobs.en-GiVOcienNodeon-archisitg,gent- I-DaaY
=neimai
Generated by Netmai Inc. [ciArelsive
Archive3Joison-lobstn=GWOpenNodetwarelivitgeo
=monad]
2019-09-16 1542:28 EDT Exported netmainennaineunal Exported by netnea netma a. nettnad
2020-05-19 1434:34 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.ND0IDOMI Flagged
2020-05-19 152839 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Ragged
2020.05.1915:17A5 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDO841 Responsive
Page 13292
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Page 13293
Suicide Timeline re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Friday, August 9, 2019
8:00 am inmate Reyes Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 departs for court
(WAB-USMS-SDNY) . Reyes is Epstein's cellmate.
8:30 am inmate Epstein arrives in Attorney Conference. He is
visited by several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 pm inmate Epstein departs attorney conference and returns to
SHU
7:00 pm inmate Epstein provided a social call by IDO. IDO reports
inmate Epstein was in good spirits, nothing unusual.
7:32 am PIO notified of incident by the Warden
***Inmate Reyes is released from court and does not return to the
institution.
Saturday, August 10, 2019
6:33 am body alarm activated in SHU. Staff found inmate Epstein
unresponsive in cell. Staff reported to bedside of inmate and
attempted to wake him. Control announced medical emergency. CPR
initiated
6:35 am medical staff (on duty PA) on site, CPR already in
progress medical staff continues CPR and AED applied on inmate.
Control called for ambulance
6:40 am , AW notified
6:45 am EMS arrives, paramedics continue CPR. Inmate Epstein
remains unresponsive. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three
rounds of Epinephrine, IV access started, IC) initiated. No pulse
found, no shock advised, inmate prepared for transport to local
hospital.
7:10 am EMS departs institution enroute to Beekman Hospital.
7:19 am USMS notified of incident.
7:20 am SIS Lt notified.
7:30 am , Warden arrives at institution. , AW
notified.
7:36 am official time of death reported by ER physician.
7:40 am Acting Chief Psychologist notified.
8:00 am and Captain arrive at institution.
8:10 am SIS Lt arrives at institution.
8:10 am CMC and SCSS notified.
8:34 am FBI notified.
9:00 am AUSA notified.
9:00 am arrives at institution.
9:00 am SIS Lt. reports to SHU. Interviews will be conducted with
inmates assigned to tier.
9:15 am CMC arrives at institution.
9:30 am Acting Chief Psychologist arrived to the institution.
9:50 am SCSS arrives at institution.
9:55 am CMC and IDO depart institution enroute to Beekman
Hospital.
10:00 am CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital, fingerprints and
photographs taken of inmate Epstein. Inmate clothing secured and
brought back to institution.
10:00 am Judge Berman notified.
10:15 am CMC return to institution.
10:45 am PIO arrived to the institution.
11:00 am next of kin (brother) notified by Case Management
Coordinator.
11:12 am press release is released to media.
11:15 am press release provided to Judge Berman.
11:15 am CST activated.
12:15 pm body release to Medical Examiner (ME) for autopsy
12:19 pm FBI arrives.
1:35 pm FBI arrives in Special Housing Unit.
1:40 pm OIG notified by the Warden and they will be sending an
Agent to NYM.
2:15 pm CST debrief conducted.
2:45 pm OIG arrived in Special Housing Unit (SHU) .
3:45 pm OIG and FBI departed from SHU.
5:05 pm OIG/FBI departed MCC New York.
Updated Timeline -Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
From
To
Date 2019/08/10 17:35
Subject: Updated Timeline-Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Please see the attached.
Thank you
Page 13296
Properties
Property Value
Nlessage ID 5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.165396E-1.5 AI81.1
Message Path xmVMaimx/5134F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.165396E.1.5A181.1.8m1
From
Display Name
Email
Ul ID 9D77B2D0-19C1-0000-A989.0200000058D0
Reply To
Tem
To Sts :
Subject Updated Taneline-Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Scheduled date 2019-08-10173534
Creation date 2019-08-10 17:3554
!Modified date 2019.08.2013/3853
Delis e red date 2019-08-10 173534
Message size 39
Attachments size 15171
Total size 15221
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.Iim
Name TEXT.lam
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOM 1.NYMADM1.200.200063& 1.9
E92E-1®455D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
65396E1.5A181.1®12.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type We
Silt 195
Date 2019-08-10133527
CA d7972383e024161ad9bdell5284625f9
(lash 88FD52.5778ETHEA2A693564A702F79093B2DFCB5 F5E31E372135I535EB2221:155C7E8C818
Attachment Epstel. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618.054_1.doex
Name Epsteir. Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-0541.docx
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000038.1.9
E92F. lia455D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100. I
65396E.1.5A181.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.103 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type tie
Size 14976
Date 2019-08.10133431
CA 85d159d829a0tab9646028028416%58
Hash CDF139C5A667C8DAC0061A1742306DFC36065E82I 565F62D6ACOB72B5FAIITDEDEB99D819
Recipients 8
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroopMember
Delis ered 2019-08-10173534
DownloadedByThirdParty 2019-08-10173538
Opened 2019.08.101757:14
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UU ID 835B5E40.I1C6-0000.B3DSFE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SysteinGroupMember
Delivered 2019-08-10 17:3554
DoonloadedByThlrdParty 2019-08-10 173535
Opened 2019-08-10M•77-55
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB000-0OOC-0000-886E-10003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGrouptidember
Delivered 2019-08.10173534
Page 13297
DowoloadedByThrdParly 2019-08-16203209
Opened 2019-08-20130900
Recipient
Display Name
Email
IR ID 2DDA9D30-10060000-987C-0CD8BB221439A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemaroupMembet
Delivered 2019-08-101735:34
DownloadedByThIrdParty 2019-08-101795J8
Recipie nt .-- Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-004F-0000-AB39-F8OF2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Delis ered 2019-08-10113554
DonnloadedllyThirdParty 2019-08-10173535
Opened 2019.08.101736/47
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
ULM 9D77B2D0.19O.0000.A989.62C0000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroupMcnibm
Delivered 2019-08-10173534
DoonloadedByThirdParty 2019-08-10173536
Opened 2019-08-101735:47
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Ut ID 4237CDC01407-0000-A820-84D2120084D2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroup
Delivered 2019-08-10173534
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
UU1D 66ENCI0-I320-0000-8ECI-2F2I62868DCC
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroupMember
Delivered 2019.08-10173534
DoonloadedB)ThIrdParty 2019-08-10173538
Opened 2019-08-1018:43:50
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read Mt
Deleted fake
Opened out
Completed fake
Security Nomial
Box type Sera Items
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined false
Return notification when
accepted fake
Amish e Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.165396E.I.5 A181.1@1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1(01 6
Source sent
Class Pubic
Account DANADMI.DANDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Page 13298
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maalox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.01.01@l6
Name Madbox
T.pe Mailbox
System true
Share Type No Shared
Page 13299
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23 172434 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent 1-Daily Archive3
Job.cti-Jobsen-Gii/OcenNodeararehivitg.PAgent- I-Da Y
=netmai
Generated by Netmai Inc. iciArcitive
Archive3Jolvoirslobstn=GWOpenNodetwarchivitgeo
=mutualed 2019-09-16 1542:28 EDT Exported netmainebnaineunal Export by mina ncima it nettnad
2020-05-19 14:14:34 EDT Tag ROP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM1 Flagged
2020-05-19 1528$9 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Responsive
20204549 15:1705 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Responsive
Page 13300
Mail Attachment
Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Page 13301
Suicide Timeline re: Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054
Friday, August 9, 2019
8:00 am inmate Reyes Efrain, Reg. No. 85993-054 departs for court
(WAB-USMS-SDNY) . Reyes is Epstein's cellmate.
8:30 am inmate Epstein arrives in Attorney Conference. He is
visited by several attorneys throughout the day.
6:45 pm inmate Epstein departs attorney conference and returns to
SHU
7:00 pm inmate Epstein provided a social call by IDO. IDO reports
inmate Epstein was in good spirits, nothing unusual.
7:32 am PIO notified of incident by the Warden
***Inmate Reyes is released from court and does not return to the
institution.
Saturday, August 10, 2019
6:33 am body alarm activated in SHU. Staff found inmate Epstein
unresponsive in cell. Staff reported to bedside of inmate and
attempted to wake him. Control announced medical emergency. CPR
initiated
6:35 am medical staff (on duty PA) on site, CPR already in
progress medical staff continues CPR and AED applied on inmate.
Control called for ambulance
6:40 am , AW notified
6:45 am EMS arrives, paramedics continue CPR. Inmate Epstein
remains unresponsive. Inmate Epstein is intubated, given three
rounds of Epinephrine, IV access started, IC) initiated. No pulse
found, no shock advised, inmate prepared for transport to local
hospital.
7:10 am EMS departs institution enroute to Beekman Hospital.
7:19 am USMS notified of incident.
7:20 am SIS Lt notified.
7:30 am , Warden arrives at institution. , AW
notified.
7:36 am official time of death reported by ER physician.
7:40 am Acting Chief Psychologist notified.
8:00 am and Captain arrive at institution.
8:10 am SIS Lt arrives at institution.
8:10 am CMC and SCSS notified.
8:34 am FBI notified.
9:00 am AUSA notified.
9:00 am arrives at institution.
9:00 am SIS Lt. reports to SHU. Interviews will be conducted with
inmates assigned to tier.
9:15 am CMC arrives at institution.
9:30 am Acting Chief Psychologist arrived to the institution.
9:50 am SCSS arrives at institution.
9:55 am CMC and IDO depart institution enroute to Beekman
Hospital.
10:00 am CMC and IDO arrive at Beekman Hospital, fingerprints and
photographs taken of inmate Epstein. Inmate clothing secured and
brought back to institution.
10:00 am Judge Berman notified.
10:15 am CMC return to institution.
10:45 am PIO arrived to the institution.
11:00 am next of kin (brother) notified by Case Management
Coordinator.
11:12 am press release is released to media.
11:15 am press release provided to Judge Berman.
11:15 am CST activated.
12:15 pm body release to Medical Examiner (ME) for autopsy
12:19 pm FBI arrives.
1:35 pm FBI arrives in Special Housing Unit.
1:40 pm OIG notified by the Warden and they will be sending an
Agent to NYM.
2:15 pm CST debrief conducted.
2:45 pm OIG arrived in Special Housing Unit (SHU) .
3:45 pm OIG and FBI departed from SHU.
5:05 pm OIG/FBI departed MCC New York.
Fwd: Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
From
To
Date
Subject:
Attachments:
2019/12/30 09:12
Fwd: Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
TEXT.htm, Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
■ please set up a meeting to go over these issues next week.
Thank you
> » BOP-RSD/Assistant Director- 12/27/2019 9:08 AM > »
Please see attached.
Page 13304
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5[09BF95.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.165396E1.6 2D IB. I
Message Path xmtMaillaad5E09BF95.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 165396E.1.62131B.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID F638D900-1406-0000-A820-84D2120084D2
Reply To NYM/Wardcw-gbopcgov
Text
To
Subject Fwd: Psych Reconst Response - Epsten 476318-054.pdf
Scheduled date 2019.12.3009:1233
Citation date 2019-12-30091233
Modified date 2020-01-03 07:0229
Delis e red dale 2019-12-3009:1234
Message size 154
Attachments sire 67312
Total she 67477
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID
5E09BF95.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000B1.1.B
3583.1@453E1:9BF95.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100.1
65396E.1.62131B.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00 .0.1.0.1(§16
Is Inline fake
Type 6k
She 436
Date 2019-12-3004:1232
CA 403b&d6015293f4f3f06b392.53313096
Has h 57417B53207BECCOFF8D37FBA6F2E62BE8202605 BIOAA764F70B6C5F430049BFF245B903
Attachment Psych Rccomst Response - Epstein 476318-011.pdf
Name Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
Content ID
5E09131:95.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.2C0.20000B1.1.B
3584.14455E09BF95.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1
65396E1.62DID.1®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 .0.1.0. Ifig16
Is Inline False
Type lie
She 66876
Date 2019-12-27040626
CA S1/41e9be3b67578b0d69d2ba0d5ba56071
Dash 57724DSA2505532F085BIB34728$2E599E086AD8 24CF3CA6B1B2090F6E7453F4E9690332
Recipients 7
Recipient — Display Name
Email
UUID 835B5E40- 1 I C6-0000-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 77BC0440-09D3-0300-8F07-909C8F0A 1644
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Re cipie nt
Display Name
Email
UUID 43EDB000-0C0C-0000-1386E-1B033A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2.0IM9D30- I 006-00:0-987C-OCD8BB22E09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Uscr
Page 13305
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CtilD 9D77B2D0-19C1-0000-A989-0200000058D0
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'Type User
Reciple nt
Display Name
Email
LIVID C4117510-04FF-0000-B3IC-4A46EB8DCC96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient I we User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID 661.64('1O-132O-OO(8)-SEC 1 -2F2167116.4nrc
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read nue
Deleted fake
Opened tilt
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification %Olen opened false
Return notification n he n deleted fake
Return notification sshen
completed t-ake
Return notification 'Olen declined fake
Return notification nhen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5EINBF95.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100.165396E-1.6 7D1B.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM 1.100.010.1@i
Source received
Class Pubbe
Account DANADMI.DANDOM1
Location ID 15908426831386
Class Name OW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder MalLox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Matox
Type Maibox
System true
Share Type NotSbarcd
Page 13306
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2020.01-14 083432 EST Created
en=Archive Agent _I-Daly Archive3
Job,en-lebs.en-Gi/OpenNodetn-archisingdAgent-
=netmai
Generated by Netgovem [an--Archive
I -Daily Archi.c3
Job.en-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoie.en-archivinpr o
-netma ill
2020-06-02112933 EDT Viewed B0P01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I Viewed by
801101829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM I
202006-02152954 EDT Tag BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 143537 EDT Tag Et0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Fbgged
2020-05-19152931 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020.05-19 15:I&03 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Responsive
Page 13307
Mail Attachment
Psych Reconst Response - Epstein #76318-054.pdf
Page 13308
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Reentry Services Division
Washington, DC 20534
DEC 2 7 2019
MEMORANDUM FOR , REGIONAL DIRECTOR
NORTHEAST REGION
FROM: S tant Director
Reentry Services Division
SUBJECT: Institution Response
Psychological Reconstruction
Inmate Epstein, Jeffrey (76318-054)
I have reviewed the Institution Response dated November 19, 2019, to
the Psychological Reconstruction of an inmate suicide involving
Jeffrey Epstein (76318-054) .
Some of the corrective actions and plans for implementation outlined
in the response are unclear or insufficient. Please review the
feedback provided and revise your response accordingly. An updated
Institution Response is due to me within thirty (30) days of your
receipt of this memorandum.
If you have questions or concerns, please feel free to contact me at
(202) 514-8585. I appreciate your assistance with this matter.
CC: , Warden, MCC New York
Institution Response Feedback
MCC New York
Epstein, Jeffrey (Reg. No. 76318-054)
Issue 1: Single Calling - Corrective Measure Accepted
The local guidelines provide a reasonable system of control to
monitor the single -ceiling of inmates in the Special Housing Unit.
National guidelines for single ceiling in the Special Housing Unit
have been incorporated into national policy and will soon be
released. Please reference these generally with a plan to
incorporate.
Issue 2: 30 Minute Rounds
The substance of the two hour Captain video review and six hour IDO
video review is unclear. Please clarify the requirement for the
Captain and IDO. Additionally, please identify the documentation
used to maintain accountability of the reviews.
Issue 3: Cellmate Assignments
Documentation exists reflecting the role of the local Psychology
Services department in communicating the importance of Mr. Epstein's
status as a sex offender with specific needs to the Associate
Warden. This includes consultation with the Psychology Services
Branch in Central Office. The communication chain and decision
making of Executive Staff lacks transparency as there is no
documentation of the process or staff members present when decisions
were made about the housing of Mr. Epstein. After the fact
explanations may not accurately reflect what occurred.
Psychology Services was not adequately represented in the decision
making of Executive Staff. Please establish a plan to increase the
input of a psychologist in placement decisions for vulnerable
inmates.
Issue 4: Documentation Accuracy
Professional responsibility requires taking into account multiple
descriptions of an incident as noted in your response. However,
when discrepancies exist these should be compiled and noted in
documentation to decrease the likelihood of conflicting conclusions.
As noted in the reconstruction report, an incident report must be
written within 24 hours of having the information that an inmate
likely violated BOP rules. An incident report was written for Mr.
Epstein prior to a determination of whether he engaged in self -
directed violence or was assaulted on July 23, 2019. Staff had
ample time to wait for the outcome of the SIS investigation of this
incident. The incident report presumed self-directed violence,
although SIS was not able to determine whether this incident was
self-directed violence or an assault. Generating the incident
report for self-directed violence is evidence of a local bias about
the July 23, 2019 incident that still exists amongst some staff at
MCC New York. Preconceived notions challenge the ability to remain
open about alternative explanations, and subsequent systemic changes
may be needed.
Please develop and provide local training for all staff that at a
minimum reviews the time frame for writing incident reports and
offers guidance when there is not clear evidence of an infraction.
Include an outline of the training and evidence of staff who
attended the training.
Typographical Errors - Corrective Measure Accepted
Medical Intake Screening - Response Accepted
Suicide Watch Log Book - Corrective Measure Accepted
BP 292s - Corrective Measure Accepted
Psychology Observation - Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 5: Telephone Calls
As noted in the response, there is a lack of documentation to
substantiate that a lieutenant facilitated two telephone calls to
Mr. Epstein. However, this does not address the report of two
telephone calls being provided. This response implies that the
reporting of two staff members is inaccurate.
The response neglects the documented telephone call to Mr. Epstein's
deceased mother.
Issue 6: Direct Observation
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 7: Follow -Up
Please provide documentation for the follow up training provided to
staff detailing the content of the training and to whom it was
provided.
Issue 8: Inmate Accountability and Assignment Accuracy
Periodic and unannounced checks are now conducted in SHU to
determine pp30 assignments and actual inmate placement match.
Please provide an operational definition of periodic. Please do the
same for routine, as it relates Executive Staff bed book counts in
all units. Where will the periodic and routine reviews be
documented and will they include the identity (e.g., name and title)
of staff who complete them?
Issue 9: Attorney Log Books
Please provide a copy of the log book audit.
Issue 10: Automatic External Defibrillators
The response states the reconstruction team reviewed an old and
outdated list from January 8, 2018. It is important to note this
list was provided to the reconstruction team by institution staff.
Provision of inaccurate documentation may reflect systemic issues
related to collecting, maintaining, and sharing relevant
documentation.
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 11: Post Orders & SIM Training
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 12: Staffing
Corrective Measure Accepted
Issue 13: Sex Offense Risk Factors
Psychologists are subject matter experts in sex offender risk
factors and they play a crucial role in sharing this knowledge
through traditional settings such as ICT, AT, and institutional
meetings. However, Executive Staff play a pivotal role in
establishing and addressing institutional culture and promoting and
participating in training. A lack of a broad understanding of sex
offender specific risk factors requires an intentional training
approach led by Executive Staff. They must be out front talking
about inmates with a sex offense, expressing an understanding of sex
offender dynamics, modeling agency condoned expectations for the
understanding and treatment of inmates with a sex offenses, and
assisting with institutional trainings. These practices encourage a
broader acceptance by line staff.
Re: meeting with tartaglione 8015 @; 5:00 pm
From
To , Bruce Barket
Date 2019/08/15 16:43
Subject: Re: meeting with tartaglione 8015 (q), 5:00
pm
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Hi Bruce,

Mr. Tartaglione was meeting with another member of your defense team earlier today. The plan was to have
him remain in attorney conference after that meeting so he could review his discovery through the count. (It
would also ensure he would already be down there when you arrived.) Without going into details, were
doing a special, more detailed count today at 4:00 PM for security procedures. I called attorney conference
to make sure your client was still there, but they advised me that they had to send him back upstairs for this
particular count.
I will likely still be here when count clears so I'll try to assist in getting him down to attorney conference as
quickly as possible, but I wanted to let you know that you may unfortunately have a wait tonight. If you want
to reschedule for tomorrow evening, let me know and I'll make sure things go smoother.
Thanks,
Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
f.
p:=
> » Bruce Barket < > 8/13/2019 5:02 PM > »
Good afternoon,
Can I meet with Nick on Thursday, August 15th at 5:00 p.m?
By the way, I am imagine you have seen some of my comments repeating the complaints about MCC
that I have been making for years. Please know that none of that was directed at you. You both have
been professional, courteous and responsive to me, even in the face of my numerous complaints and
emails. The press does not write about the good, but I have mentioned how much I admire the legal
staff at MCC on several occasions.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
C.arelpn City NV 115111
Page 13313
[P1 [F]
www.barketepstein.con
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 13314
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 50558BBLNYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 ACOB. I
Message Path xmi'Mailao0D558BB2.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.7AC0B.1mg
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 15A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Reply To
Text
To Bruce Basket
Subject Re: meeting with tanaglione 8015 (4 5:00 pm
Scheduled date 2019-08-15 164330
Creation date 2019-08-15 164330
Modified date 2019-08-I5 17:1249
Delivered date 2019-08-I5 16:4331
Message sine 2353
Attachments size 5023
Total size 7387
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.Inm
Content ID
5D558BB2.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000DA.1.8
AF44.1®453D558B82.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.I
373875.1.7A0DB.I@II.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 5023
Date 2019-08-15 124332
CA 7660283ae60abaelkal5a7t9bdfbl Id
Hash 171D30KBAE8BBBDB12EB88C33870750C8E9025AA 45214D4B11-16FEE67DB09E2E7456B07E
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0300-A8F4-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient Bruce Basket
Display Name Bruce Rarkei
Email
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Intox
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Wrsion 5.3
I ate mat ID 5D558BB2.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 ACOB.110A/11.NYMDOM LNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1® I
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADM I.NYMDOM I
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Page 13315
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
In 7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mail=
Type Maibox
System true
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 13316
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-23 20A31.15 EDT Created
en=Archive Agent 1-Daly Archive3
Jobsn-lebs.cn-GiVOpenNodetn-archivingdAgent-
=netmai
Generated by Netrm8 Inc. [cn=Archive
I -DailY Archive3Job.cn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNode.cn-archisinga
-nctrnail]
2019-09.16153331 EDT Exported mono inetma awned Exponed by netmainetmainctmail
2020-05-19 153531 EDT Tag BOP01703.NIXRADM I.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020-05.191531:14 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I
202005--19 13:32.02 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI
R
Roesvonsi
Responsive
202045-19 1434:34 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI I'Lly.yrd
202605-1914:4136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flakozed
Page 13317
RE: MCC conditions
From
Aida Lei
To
ce Bark
onyricco
Date 2019/08/30 10:30
Subject: RE: MCC conditions
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Good morning all,
Would 2 or 2:30 work? I am running around this morning, have a meeting at 1, and am leaving at 3.
Thanks,
>» 'a" a> 8/29/2019 7:54 PM > > >
Received.
Brucen, would you all be free for a call tomorrow afternoon to discuss?
Thanks,
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
1 St. Andrew's Plaza
New York, NY 10007
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Thursda August 29 2019 5:25 PM
To:
Subject: MCC conditions
USANYS)
>; tonyricco
: Michael Bachrach
>;
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the facility.
Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it himself on August
15th. His radio has needed batteries for several days. The guards simply refuse to provide him with the
Page 13318
batteries and new books ne believes are in nis property. several guards nave been making comments
to him such as "You're threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth his try" and similar remarks
aimed at intimidating him and conveying to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not staff in the
lobby to process legal visits. I was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't stay through the count so
I had to leave before 9:30. I know I did not make an appointment but the issue wasn't a free room, but
adequate staffing in the lobby. Yesterday I was able to see my client at 5:00 as scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden City, NY 11530
[F)
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 13319
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 6368FAB6.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.1001373875.1.7B754.1
Message Path xnuMailboOD68FABANYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.713754.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To Bruce Barret;
Ce Aida Lerenrin Michac03achrach tareneco
Subject RE: MCC coeditor
Scheduled date 2019-08-301030.14
Creation date 2019-08.301030:14
Modified date 2019-09-01 1823:12
Delis e red date 2019-08-30 1030:14
Message site 2728
Attachments sin 7636
Total sire 10375
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D68FAB6.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.200.20000A0.1.1
48A40.1®455D68FAB6.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.
1373875.1.7B754.1® 1:7.NYMDOM 1 .NYMADM 1 . 10 0.0.1A 1®16
Is Inline false
Type file
Sire 7636
Date 2019-08-30063069
('A cb8624cb8421)853fae93250697a8b173
Hash 6415FE.26097D3C50609A0FB860E403C27550F39DCF168510E0F520496CDB5B4BC0O18519
Recipients 8
Recipient Aida Lciscnring
Display Name Aida Lei-curing
Email
Distribution Type C('
Recipient Type User
Transferred 2019-08-301030:17
Recipient Bruce Barket
Display Name Bruce Barket
Email bbarkeigfibaticetepstencom
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Transferred 2019-08-301030:17
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08-30 10:32:32
Transferred 2019-08.301030:17
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID AB294985-1BAA-0000-B60A-A812D3F99FD4
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08.301031:16
Transferred 2019-08-301030.17
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 79BA4F81-399A-O000-B60A-E1B48EDIFB51
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Page 13320
Dellsercd 2019-05.30103109
Transferred 2019-08-301030:17
Recipient MichaelEtachrach
Display Name Michactiachrach
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-08.30103237
Transferred 2019-05-301030:17
Recipie nt
Display Name
Email
MID I5A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7fi5A606415CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-0&30103014
IMnuloackcIllyThirdParty 2019-09-01 I X21 LI
Recipient tonyricco
Display Name tonyrie o
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-0530103128
Transferred 2019-08-301030.17
Expire 0
Delay delis cry until 0
Delegated false
Arch's ed fake
Read mw
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Nonml
Box type Sent Items
Return notification sshen opened false
Return notification sshen deleted fake
Return notification sshen
completed false
Return notification %%hen declined false
Return notification sshen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal II) 5D613FAB6.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7B754.1@1:7.NYTADOMLNYMADM1.103.0.1.0.1@1
Source sent
Class Pubk
Account NYMADMLNYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 13321
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-06 203403 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-Jobs.crGWOpenNodern-archivingeoM
ietmai
Gerrrated by Netrred Inc. [cn=Archive
_1-Daily Archive3gcnt
Job.en-Jobsrn-GWOpenNoie.cn-archivinga
-netmad]
2020-0519153006 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADM1.61XRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19153531 EDT Tag BOP01703.frOCRADMI.N1 XRIX)Ni 1 Responsive
2020-05-191414136 EDT Tag BOP01703.1YDCRADMI.MARIXRA 1 Fbggcd
Page 13322
RE: MCC conditions
From )11
ida Lciscnrin
To ichaelBachrach
Scannellionyricco
Date 20 I 9/08/29 19:54
Subject: RE: MCC conditions
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
Bruce Barkc
Received.
Brucen, would you all be free for a call tomorrow afternoon to discuss?
Thanks,
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
1 St. Andrew's Plaza
New York, NY 10007
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Thu rsda August 29 2019 5:25 PM
To:
Subject: MCC conditions
USANYS)
>; tonyricco
Michael Bachrach
>;
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the facility.
Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it himself on
August 15th. His radio has needed batteries for several days. The guards simply refuse to provide him
with the batteries and new books he believes are in his property. Several guards have been making
comments to him such as "You're threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth his try" and similar
remarks aimed at intimidating him and conveying to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not staff in the
lobby to process legal visits. I was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't stay through the count
so I had to leave before 9:30. I know I did not make an appointment but the issue wasn't a free room,
but adequate staffing in the lobby. Yesterday I was able to see my client at 5:00 as scheduled.
Page 13323
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden City, NY 11530
[F]
www.barketeDstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have
received this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is
strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us
immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 13324
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D682D7LNYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7B711.1
Message Path xrnliMatiox5D682D71,NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100 .1373875.LT/37M I.)3111
From
Display Name I"
Email
UUID 79BA4F81-399A-00004360A-E1B48EDI FB51
Reply To
Text r To Bruce Barket;
Ce Aida Lebenr t- Alte I:Bachrach . tcayneco
Subject RE: MCC conditions
Scheduled date 2019-08-29 19:54:14
Creation date 2019-08.291954:14
Modified date 2019-08-30 10:30:14
Delis cried date 2019-08-29 195426
Message size 2549
Attachments size 22760
Total size 25320
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.hun
Content II)
5D682D7I.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200005&1.8
5456.1®455D682D7LNYMDOMLNYMADM1.1001
373875.1.711711.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Sim 7566
CA 4472218291a8cSfigff68a999aa5a5151
Hash C9432DED8696495337222EBE6E73584FF26C2FO4 CBD734E39D6B7FHIAfi5A00BBAB6F8FB3
Attachment Minc.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D682D7LNYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200005&1.8
5457.1®455D682D7LNYMDOMLNYMADM1.100. I
373875.1.7B711. I@I:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1©16
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 15194
CA 7135999c8adOac07084c106656ac5la5
Hash 3E70866D339IAFE639191255IACF4B4A026BDOC3 0129F72379E25C8E89AA5372DCD7C985
Recipients 8
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CAD0-09CA-O300-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient Aida Lcbcnrmg
Name Display
Email
Aida I..
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type Uscr
Recipient Bruce Rickel
Display Name Bruce Barkct
Email
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'ry-pe User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type Uscr
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UN D AB294985-1BAA-03004360A-A812D3F99FD4
Page 13325
Distribution Tye CI
Recipient Ty User
Recipient MichaelBaelvacb
Display Name Michacfi3achrach
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID I 5A65EI0-0C33-0000a3E7-68A6064I5CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient tonyricco
Display Name tonyricco
Email
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read WC
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification %then opened false
Return notification when deleted lobe
Return notification %%hen
completed l-alse
Return notification %%hen declined fake
Return notification %%hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D682D7LNYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7 B711.1@l(LNYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0. 41 6
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name liW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@I6
Name Maiyox
Type Mailbox
System int
Share Type NotShared
Page 13326
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-06 203434 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-lcbs.cn-GWOpenNodern-archiving.oAgent-
aetmai
Gerrrated by Netrrea Inc. [cn=Archive
I -DailY Archive3Jobrn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNok.en—archivinga
—netrnail]
2020.05-19153006 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.M7tRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 144136 EDT Tag BOP0I703.14XRADNI 1.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 13327
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13328
conditions
Thu, 29 Aug 2019 23:54:14 +0000
Received.
Bruce/N, would you all be free for a call tomorrow afternoon to discuss?
Thanks
Assistant United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
I St. Andrew's Plaza
New York. NY 10007
n eusdoi toy
From: Bruce Barket ‹ >
Sent: Thursda August 29, 2019 5:25 PM
To: ` 0 >;
Subject: MCC conditions
>; Aida Leisenring
Michael Bachrach
I am writing as I have been asked to update everyone on the continuing problems at the facility.
Mr. Tartaglione has not has books swapped out since was kind enough to do it himself on August 15". His radio has needed
batteries for several days. The guards simply refuse to provide him with the batteries and new books he believes are in 
his
property. Several guards have been making comments to him such as "You're threatening our lives" and "Give the big mouth
his
try" and similar remarks aimed at intimidating him and conveying to him their displeasure with his complaints.
As for visiting I arrived on Sunday and waited nearly 50 minutes because there was not staff in the lobby to process 
legal visits. I
was able to see my client by 9;10, but I couldn't stay through the count so I had to leave before 9:30. I know I did not
make an
appointment but the issue wasn't a free room, but adequate staffing in the lobby. Yesterday I was able to see my client 
at 5:00 as
scheduled.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[P) [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If 
it is not clear that you are
the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, 
dissemination, distribution or
copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, 
please notify us immediately
by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Fwd: RE: Signed Autopsy Request Letter
From
To
Date 2019/09/1107:22
Subject: Fwd: RE: Signed Autopsy Request Letter
Attachments: TEXT.htin
Hi M, sorry I forgot to CC you on this e-mail.
Thank ou,
CDR
(OCME)" > 9/10/201912:14 PM >> >
Thank you; we will be in touch when we are able to fulfill your request.
General Counsel
Office of Chief Medical Examiner
421 E. 26th Street
New York, NY 10016
Tel:
The information contained in this e-mail communication may be confidential and/or legally privileged and is for the use
of the intended recipient only. If you are not the intended recipient, or an authorized employee or an agent responsible
for delivering it to the intended recipient, the dissemination, distribution or reproduction of this communication or 
its
contents (including any attachments) is prohibited. If you have received this communication in error, please notify us
immediately by telephone or reply e-mail and permanently delete it and any copies from your system files.
From:
Sent: Tuesda Se tember 10, 2019 12:10 PM
To: (OCME
Cc:
Subject: Fwd: Signed Autopsy Request Letter
Hi Ms. per our conversation this morning I am sending you the Letter for requested information
involving Mr. Jeffrey Epstein. We need the following: 1. Autopsy Report,

2. Discharge Summary Report, 3. Toxicology Report and 4. Death Certificate. We need these documents to
finish our required Mortality Review and to complete our Investigation. Attached below I have included a
copy of the Certified Letter we sent to the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner. If you have any questions you
can contact myself or our Staff Attorney at:
Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
f.
Page 13331
Vely I espectimy,
CDR MSA, CCN, USPHS
Health Services Administrator
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row, New York, New York 10007
(Office) 646-836-6445
>>>
Hi
9/10/2019 9:31 AM >>>
Please see attached, which was sent certified on August 19 or 20.
Thanks,
Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
f.
Pi=
Page 13332
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5D78A0B5.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7COBLI
Message Path xnd'Maibox/5D78A0B5.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7COB1.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 5ECEI1C0-09D4-0000.BBE1-7C3A87597621
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Fwd: RE: Signed Autopsy Request Letter
Scheduled date 2019.09-11 072229
Creation date 201949-11 072229
Modified date 201949-11 0728:39
Dtlh e red date 201949-11 072230
Message size 2459
Attachments size 10344
Total size 12814
Attachments I
Attachment TF-XT.htm
Name TEXT.han
Content ID
5D78AOB5.NYMDOMI.NYMADM I.200.200000C.LE
4CE9.IQ453D78A0B5.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875. 1.7COBLI ®11.NYMDOM LNYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.I@I6
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 10344
Date 2019-09-11 0322:30
CA 8529ta4edbe89376ce27d9e796e3505
Hash 9COD746033CO3C6B48F3EFEDAF069822A4A87D79 1437E59CC62330602DBDF690DB2E5F10
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name _
Email
IAA D 275OCADO09CA-0000-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Intox
Return notification when opened false
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification when
completed fake
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification when
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID NI5D78A0B5.NYDOMLNYMADM1.100.1373875.1.7COBLIQII.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l
Source recessed
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID I 540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE-MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Madbox
Type hatbox
Page 13333
System
Share Type
UM
NotShared
Page 13334
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-20 210130 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-lebs.cn-GWOpenNodern-arc
ictmai
k" '- ^Ag ent- '- Jobrn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoietn-archivinga
Gerrrated by Netrre8 Inc. [cn=Archive
I -Daily Archive3
-neunail]
202005-19153421 EDT Tag 1301'01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag B080170334XRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 13335
hid: counsel haying difficulty meeting with client
From
naie 2019/07/07 18:22
subject: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Attachments: my' . him
I have verified Martin Weinberg is an attorney in good standing in Massachusetts. He is permitted to visit Jeffrey 
Epstein.
Sent from my Veliton. Samoans Galaxy smartphon:
- Ori messa
From:
Date: 7/7/19 6:18 PM GMT-05130
To: >,
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>>> 07/07/2019 18:18>>>
Massachusetts
From:
Sent: Sunday Ju 07
To:
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Sony MI,
just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
2019 18:18
<S>:
Sent from my Vernon, Samsung Galaxy smanphonc
Ou ri rimessa  al
From: "
To:
GMl f4511.
<maiho ' <11v1IS >>.
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>» " 07/07/2019 17:36 >>>
With apologies for the weekend email. we have a defendant. Jeffrey Epstein, who was arrested last night and is currently
being detained at MCC, and is e
of-state.
Were concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any defendant) and so I wante
s very much,
Page 13336
Wept.Res
,414141111 Woe
MeeeegelD $02.1.18$7.NVIMOMI NYMADC.11.1011373471.1.7106G I
Mn.q. ha . YNIA . . . . .
Proin
Dlepbe W!
Cali

I. L ID 27104 ADDOCCA411004.164.14CTMEA747)
R.r 74
Teel
To
i I
I I
.44 4141 14.6 camel hang dllkiay wenn at clod
4.164•11 Yee 4./...
Creston dine 311901471t2203
Moak.. dew )0
Delleteed doe 201160747 14221S
Meeseere eke $24
Anerlesesee dm 4291
Teed ger WI
Allaclunenee I
Alentbones. 11.1.1166
Here TEX/16n
Ceateme ID
ST1221367.24111111.41.NAMADMI X0 ACCOM11. 1
M53) 64.061)1241417.61141/0441 NAPAADMI 110
117)117$ I.A044) lir 11.NAMOOMI NAMADMI 1000 1.0 14 I
It lam 64
T)/ 4
Aar 4'91
CA 61444141111671ecteAt71.0446.1144
Hal 4.4141)1461814/441/41)61D). D4064- 444 1}ADT) SR. / 1 VOA 140/104762
Redplenli IS
Redienl
DSO, Ara
fall
CLAD 1144421110.04F6002041 eFRIC 'I JR/
116011441/441)pe TO
Rieke* ,  Cll. S. l"
Denten/4 2014417-07 1/122/IS
°Pew. 4214.07 07 .le
Re et
Dbyls,`"Ing
Fail
LAID SIV.604061(440:4 A 5.01.1141311)00127
01•616.41441)pe TO
R.epkr TY)* inueteleetr
De eml X.1941).07 HQ: IS
116.414•14.111214161Pare2 . ..
Dek•61 201.607.0.142504
Pined . . .
Redraw
Dip'..'. ....,
Until

1111) 011 _430.1117400111406114KAAMII0491
Dian n Tipr TO
R.elpe strip. ..4644-etre
lhl.ertd 201%07.07 111=. IS
Opt 4 2019.07.07 4.1403
Deeded 2010411.07 , 140.
Re i
Displa %am
I null
1110 II Al 10140.061.4406/106// -7.41411124A447
Deeni...6n type TO
Recipe.. Tp SyatiouphIniber
Ikk.,nd MI94O.07 14221
OnneinaledRy11641664
R4(4 641
169“.. Anne
44.4..
WO 427162.204104740:041 .
DinibutIon type TO
R114114. 4) T)P4 SIWRGeognesednx
Thelteeed 10I907Ol1R121S
(peril ml90'a22'.ITI2
RecIpkai Iw4..51tk I).n
Iliple• Name /abra4.1n.1. IAra
1646 Mo nv en DA
I III) IX I/ 101 . 4016910.6/012414444391r
Dkoillutlen Type TO
Ree e. 1)p en.......ther
Dnny» 201 07 221
0 4414e42 20190'.01(44616
Dekk4 .019.0 114 I
Recipe.,
06414, As
ran
MAD 21)04911661002-01404401741CCARB22FOM
OA 1.14•1101. Type TO
ReepY.I TI9r 64146110•464a des
Delivered 1013010X5MS
Denealenefreleyllie411.64 101947.7 Ia 216
° P. " 101907-01202916
Rt i rd .07 2044
Fleet I eell Weil
Redolent
06phy Nam
Fall
MID 11. 1241001/17.4010417(1674410911666 UT
DIatrlbsels• Type TO
14441.14//1The SW04424.4.461estrai
DeeeleT4 19.007 It —15
0114441) 10I9O1-01071QI9
Page 13337

╭─ Page 886, Image 1 ─╮
│ on                  │
│                     │
│ ae                  │
│                     │
│ Page 13337          │
╰─────────────────────╯

DHSS 20194748 073683
Dt48/8834
Dbpby Name
Dern
L'A'ID A68301000000,400
MuDunce DP 4 TO
144.64684 T‘pr lice
lkDora :0146477-07 1322115
D89•64448/1191111•91146 20140407 1322116
Or." 301'607.07 MI454:6
11486.6 3)19417.07 1/154563
19449.4 201917.107 185325
&O&M
0946447 4.4.m.
Deal
LUID ni:11033-1144.0331B127-95114:030KT
DlrlInob• Dr TO
D18/149411T/P 7 74444466445Meedty
114869886 :019117.07 182215
Deesbadedllyllin1P64) 3)1940.090:11321
019368 20194740 19OM2
De10841 b19.07.101907.
Rote/0
Mph" Arm
FANO
LIVID 02817A51314C-13034309111-DCAADP•13191
Obtribille• Type 90
Meyer Trig 44,..
Delheled 2019-07-07 182215
0 118889 1U19O)48mtl:N
Ittelpirsi
Dip* An
Fail
LIND 41Y76614.1) I IANRD11OY11
D1•310•11448 by TO
IDDI 8188 TIT 14.-1644 Soup
Dakota :0190141182215
144 mt
DS*, Na
Emil
1111D .411A 46(0010003300
Dbulbufien Tip TO
164/108 at lye 54/11466 /64972.80144•
114694441 /20194/45 I/122115
0449164141871111•11,697 b19O5.1O082I1S
041•441 bWN.08O15159
Rota..
Du4p46 %Ann
Final
611101.12.11016030111160-03¢0:030W L110
134171bmilosT)pe TO
17481 181/8 TM 544.04(1.904 -61•6
111414849.41 :014.4)7.07 14122 I5
Deviskoledlly7111.71tan, 494.1) 404746
Reelple-
Mph" Sas
Tail
LAID 91150LOODIDADUX187/.5.42145090101
061816•116•1*/ TO
Meyer TM , SyanDircupMeatre
Delbert. 3)19417-07 012115
Upemd 3)1940-011073911
Kirby 0
Dekry dellreD ISM 0
Delepted 04144
Arithed fat
Read true
Mined fat
064•641 ow
Compleled Oat
Smut Mama
Del 41847 Ant Iron
Deem •44111nelso *bet paid 064
Ratan setlicigionlit•diefre 914
Reba 11•41k8814991189
amplIDS 914
Retire DIIIIIMIIIM Nem rktimed 914
Roan ralloals• van
-tt_ 1.4
Artetee Auras l5
lalersol ID 50223157141300161.NYMADMI.10011373875.1.7 /06/119411.1411300/411 NYMADM114:00.14144 I6
San sal
Clot Pale
Amami MLAD1117513.00911
tAtlefOO 111 154014313
ass Nunt OW S119604(1) MAIL
16918•14¢ I olden 1
F•1144 Marlbco.
ID 7 NISCOMLNYMAD)511.1001110410116
Nan Malbm
I.T. Maim
*fiel• Int
ft /It bps 34610.61
Page 13338

╭─ Page 887, Image 1 ─╮
│ es                  │
│                     │
│ eco eT              │
│ ‘Spee Foca          │
│                     │
│ cri                 │
│ Teg                 │
│                     │
│ ‘on                 │
│                     │
│ aaa                 │
│                     │
│ es                  │
│                     │
│ Repette =           │
│ or [sre             │
│ eae fae             │
│ ieee                │
│                     │
│ naa aa —            │
│                     │
│ Page 13338          │
╰─────────────────────╯

AS
le A.— AS.
311.12.11 01.-Y43 FST frannl
ce-Arclne /44•1_24no Da)
44.4444144-1.444-4-(MODninenrsrtn.
Dia -nenul
Tienerstnl, Ndonn tor-Annea
41C" 24a) " 4nint344.-X+44.4-(nOpparialea-srtin
.AI.. smog
312046-19 153114 FDT I. WPMFM MNRADMI LIF:41)1,141 Itennmne
MILCD14 1412/D EDT Tag 1101101,111.1)1RADMI MX11114 RI I Itc•ponn
M11.46. IQ 03421 EDT rat 110P111 AD ‘0,11.40‘11 MD11101.1I Requann
DEPO4D-19 14,1414 FDT Tag 1.0111111111MXILNIAll DV DOM1 I bard
mo.r. 19 143711IEDr nu 110144 110 MX11.4111.11 41\1111DMI I lamed
Page 13339
Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
From
To
Date 2019/07/07 18:28
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with
client
Attachments: TEXT.htm
He's in with an attorney now (not sure which) but I cleared Mr. Weinberg to go in too.
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone
Original messa
Front ' ,,
Date: 7/7/19 6:18 PM GMT-05:00
To: <
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
>>>11 1" 07/07/2019 18:18 >»
Massachusetts
From:
Sent: Sunday, July 07, 2019 18:18
To:
Subject: Re: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
Sorry MI, just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphonc
----- Ori ' al messa
From: ' " ` .'
Date: 7/7/19 5:36 PM (GMT-05:00)
To:
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
a» lMEMM)" 07/07/2019 17:36 >»
With apologies for the weekend email, we have a defendant, Jeffrey Epstein, who was arrested last
nieht and is currently beine detained at MCC. and is expected to be presented on an indictment
Page 13340
tomorrow. His attorney, Martin Weinberg, has represented him in the past, and represents him in
connection with our case and has been in touch with us throughout the weekend. He went to MCC
today to meet with him in advance of the presentment tomorrow, but was just told he is not allowed in
because he is from out-of-state.
We're concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment
(as we would be for any defendant) and so I wanted to reach out to you—is it at all possible to address
this issue so Mr. Weinberg can meet with his client this evening? I'm available anytime at
to discuss, if that's helpful, or Mr. Weinberg can also be reached directly at 617-901-3472 if that's
easier (though if you reach out directly to him if you could please just let me know afterward I'd be
grateful).
thanks very much,
El•
Page 13341
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D2239BA.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.13738751.7 88611
Message Path xmbhiaibox3D2239BA.NYMDOMENYMADMI.100.1373875.1.78861.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Re: counsel has ng diffieuky meeting u ah chat
Scheduled date 2019-07-07 182738
Creation date 2019-07-07 182738
Modified date 2019-10-I5 14:1930
Delivered date 2019-07-07 1828:10
Message size 2493
Attachments size 7742
Total size 10246
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.Ium
Content ID
5D2239BA.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000A0.1.1
4453A.1(053D2239BA.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.
1373875.1.78861. I@I:7.NYMDOM I.NYMADM1.10 0.0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
'Ispe file
Size 7742
ef617e0573741693fdf441c6b6e8dec0
Hash 34E050B865641031A8B825197F_SE5314BAA6BED8131607BEIFF046976E8FA3E027D7AB2f0.5
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
MID 4IA952K1-121( -11111111-1460 A-1 IMEA2C9DEC56
Distribution ispe TO
Recipient 'fspe User
Tnuis ferred 2019-07-071828:12
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UAL/ I 5A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-07-071828:10
Opened 2019-07-08085852
Expire 0
Delay de liven' until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read true
Deleted false
Opened true
Completed false
Security Norrnal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification sshen opened false
Return notification sshen deleted false
Return notification when
completed false
Return notification sshen declined false
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D2239BA.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.13738751.7 8861.1@1:7.NYMDOM I.NYMADMI.100.0.1.0. l@ I 6
Source sent
Class Public
Page 13342
Account I NYMADMLNYMDOMI
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Mal=

II) 7.NYMDOMLNYMAD641.100.0.1.0.1®16
Name Muffins
Type Maibox
System tme
Share Type NotShared
Page 13343
Audits
Dale Action Auditor Note
2019-12.11062625 EST Created
en=Arehive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archive3.en-Jobs.arGwopenNedetn.atchiv
ill:Armorial
Generated by Neigpvem Kr -Archive
Agent 2-Zero Day
Archiselen-Jobs.cre-GWOpenNock.cn-archis
ing.o-netmai]
2020-05-19 15:31:14 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-191532-02 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020.05-19153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2026-05.19143434 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fhgged
2021.05.191437:18 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 13344
Fwd: conditions in SHU
From
To =II Date 2019/07/09 15:28
Subject: Fwd: conditions in SHU
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Page 13345
Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
f.
pi=
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/5/2019 1:02 PM > »
Good afternoon,
As I think you all know Nick has been placed in SHU based on an allegation that he was in possession of
a cell phone. If true, I understand that some appropriate and proportional sanction may be in order.
Leaving that aside I want to address the conditions in his cell. The toilet is leaking and the floor is wet.
As of Wednesday, he hasn't received his personal property, including his books. He has been sitting in
the cell with literally nothing to read, listen to or watch. Can we please make an effort to get him
reading material, his radio and the accompanying batteries.
Most troubling is that he tells me that the legal work he had out when he was removed from the cell
has not been returned to him. This included documents prepared for him by my office which contained
substantial and sensitive work product that falls squarely within the attorney client privilege. Nick made
notes on some of these documents to prepare for our next meeting. When I saw him Wednesday, he
had some of his legal paperwork but not the documents he was working with when he was taken from
the cell. I am very concerned that these documents have been seized by the staff at MCC. Can you
please take steps to see to that all of this material be returned to him immediately.
Lastly, I am hoping we can find time early next week to discuss the conditions of Nick's confinement
going forward.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[PI [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 13346
Properties
Property Value
Nlessage 1 D 5D2.4B28ENYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 8ABE1
Message Path xmAMaRtox15D2432.13E.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .1373875.1.78ABEI.xml
From
His pia) Name
Email
UUID 15A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Reply To
Text
To I
Cc
Subject Fwd:cotnliions in SHIJ
Scheduled date 201947-091528:14
Creation date 2019-07-09152&14
Modified date 2019.07-09 1537:45
Delis e red date 201947-091528:15
Message size 2353
Attachments sin 5028
Total size 7392
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htin
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D24B28E.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000ODA.1.8
8200.I@453D24B28ENYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
373875. 1.78ABEI(01:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type Inc
Size 5028
Date 2019-07-09 1128:14
CA 319149f69899127b66d9635806499eb3
Hash 5131D4EC0583CB5F115F03BBED8B7998805278119 5C3AD5042B5746963885688365165645
Recipients 2
Recipient
Dis pia? Name
Email
(XII) 2750( ADO IFX. A-0000a8F4-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type CC
Recipient 1 s-pe User
Recipient
Dis pies Name I
Email
UM 4A1B8282.311 7-0000-B60A-IFDDAB07B0FA
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived false
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Nomul
Box tspe Inbox
Return notification when opened fake
Return notification "hen deleted fake
Return notification "hen
completed false
Return notification "hen declined false
Return notification sshen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal I 5D24B28ENYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 8ABE.1€11:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@1
Source receked
Class Pubfic
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Page 13347
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1006
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System IllIC
Share Type NotShored
Page 13348
Audits
Dale Action Auditor Note
2019-12-11 00134 EST Created
en=Archive Agent2-Zero Day
Archive3.cn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodecn-archiv
rtiCilite  tIllai
Generated by Nei:govern Km-Archive
Agent 2-Zem Day
Archi;e3ten-Jobs.crt-GWOpenNode.cn-archis
itgo-netmai)
2020-05-19 i535:31 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responshe
2020-05-19144136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 13349
RE: conditions in SHU
From (USANYS)"
To
Date 2019/07/09 15:29
Subject: RE: conditions in SHU
Attachments: TEXT.Intri, Mime.822
Thx!
From: ‹ >
Sent: Tuesda Jul 09 2019 3:28 PM
To:
Cc:
Subject: Fwd: conditions in SHU
Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
> » Bruce Barket <
Good afternoon,
@ > 7/5/2019 1:02 PM > »
As I think you all know Nick has been placed in SHU based on an allegation that he was in possession of
a cell phone. If true, I understand that some appropriate and proportional sanction may be in order.
Leaving that aside I want to address the conditions in his cell. The toilet is leaking and the floor is wet.
As of Wednesday, he hasn't received his personal property, including his books. He has been sitting in
the cell with literally nothing to read, listen to or watch. Can we please make an effort to get him
reading material, his radio and the accompanying batteries.
Most troubling is that he tells me that the legal work he had out when he was removed from the cell
has not been returned to him. This included documents prepared for him by my office which
contained substantial and sensitive work product that falls squarely within the attorney client
privilege. Nick made notes on some of these documents to prepare for our next meeting. When I saw
him Wednesday, he had some of his legal paperwork but not the documents he was working with
when he was taken from the cell. I am very concerned that these documents have been seized by the
staff at MCC. Can you please take steps to see to that all of this material be returned to him
immediately.
Lastly, I am hoping we can find time early next week to discuss the conditions of Nick's confinement
going forward.
Page 13350
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden City, NY 11530
[P] [F]
wmtmataiketepateinsom
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 13351
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D24B2DA.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1373875.1.7 8ACO. I
Message Path imihMaixon5D2462DA.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.78AC0.1.xml
From , (USANYSr
(USANYST Display Name
Entail
VW D 4A 1B8282-31F7-0000-860A- IFDDAB07B0FA
Reply To
Text (USANYS)'
To
Cc
Subject RE: conditions in SHU
Scheduled date 201907-09152920
Creation date 2019-07-0915:2920
Modified date 201907-09 15.3747
Delivered date 201947-09 152921
Message size 2609
Attachments sin 25075
Total size 27695
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.Min
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D2432DA.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.2000048.1.6
FIAF.1(4/452D24B2DA.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.78AC0.1€81:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline fake
Type Ilk
Size 7867
CA d846891fdf06f4b9ae2f3dfMa5ae790
Hash 69606977BA46459B73D851234BE66DB3DC6DC3IC FF B893A11975568824CBC I B0455DBIB
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D24B2DA.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000048.1.6
F1B0.1(4)452D24B2DA.NYNIDOMI.NYMADMI.1001
373875.1.78AC0.1@l2.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .0.1.0.1®16
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 17208
CA ddeb0e516668a71999bc620ee3858118
Hash 514AEFD6FEA38373404CCDC6512B7CA426740155 B0405FF65E9D098640C58CCDF ntsual)
Recipients 2
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 2750CAD0-09CA-OOOOA8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
_ Recipient
Display Name
Email
WAD I5A65E10-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A606415CAD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Read tote
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Mb=
Return notification alien opened false
Return notification when deleted false
Return notification ..hen
completed fake
Page 13352
Return notification when declined fake
Return notification when
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D24B2DA.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.1373875.1.78AC0A@I:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.0.1.01@l
Source received
Class Public
Account NYMADMI.NYMDOMI
Location ID 1540642683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maim
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.I00.010.1@l6
Name Maibox
Type Hatbox
System tore
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 13353
Audits
Dale Action Auditor Note
2019-12-11 063135 EST Created
en=Archive Agent2-Zero Day
Archive3.cn-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodecn-archiv
rtiCilite  tIllai
Generated by Nei:govern Km-Archive
Agent 2-Zem Day
Archi;e3ten-Jobs.crt-GWOpenNode.cn-archis
itgo-netmai)
2020-05-19 1535:31 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responshe
2020-05-19144136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 13354
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13355
From:
To:
Cc:
Subject: RE: conditions in SHU
Sent:
Thx!
From:
Sent: Tuesday, July 09 2019 3:28 PM
To:
Cc:
Subject: Fwd: conditions in SHU
Tue, 9 Jul 2019 19:29:20 +0000
Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
If:1M
>>> Bruce Barket < > 7/5/2019 1:02 PM >> >
Good afternoon,
As I think you all know Nick has been placed in SHU based on an allegation that he was in possession of a cell phone. If
true, I
understand that some appropriate and proportional sanction may be in order.
Leaving that aside I want to address the conditions in his cell. The toilet is leaking and the floor is wet. As of 
Wednesday, he
hasn't received his personal property, including his books. He has been sitting in the cell with literally nothing to 
read, listen to
or watch. Can we please make an effort to get him reading material, his radio and the accompanying batteries.
Most troubling is that he tells me that the legal work he had out when he was removed from the cell has not been 
returned to
him. This included documents prepared for him by my office which contained substantial and sensitive work product that 
falls
squarely within the attorney client privilege. Nick made notes on some of these documents to prepare for our next 
meeting.
When I saw him Wednesday, he had some of his legal paperwork but not the documents he was working with when he was
taken from the cell. I am very concerned that these documents have been seized by the staff at MCC. Can you please take 
steps
to see to that all of this material be returned to him immediately.
Lastly, I am hoping we can find time early next week to discuss the conditions of Nick's confinement going forward.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[PI [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If 
it is not clear that you
are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, 
dissemination, distribution or
copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, 
please notify us
immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
RE: viewing tartaglione cell
From (USANYS)"
To
Date 2019/11/27 11:36
Subject: RE: viewing tartaglione cell
Attachments: TEXT.htrn, Mirnc.822
Thanks for your email and good wishes.
I believe that- is out of the office until next week. Can this wait until then?
I hope that you too have a Happy Thanksgiving.
Take care,
U
Chief, Civil Division
U.S. Attorney's Office, SDNY
86 Chambers Street, 3"I Floor
New York, NY 10007
From:
Sent: Wednesda , November 27, 2019 11:23 AM
To: (USANYS)
Cc:
Subject: Fwd: viewing tartaglione cell
Hi
We may need wall counsel again in the Tartaglione matter in relation to the below site visit request. so
excellently helped us last time in our appearance on the conditions of confinement issue, so I cc'ed her as
well.
Thank you and I wish you and yours a Happy Thanksgiving.
Best,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York. New York 10007
Page 13357
> » Bruce Barket < C > 11/27/2019 11:15 AM >»
As part of our obligations to prepare for the penalty phase (should there be one) of Mr. Tartaglione's
trial, we would like to view the cells (including SHU ) and common areas where he has been held. It's
possible that we will want to take some photographs, but initially we just want to look at the areas
where he has been housed.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[F]
www.barketepstein.corrt
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 13358
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5DDE5FBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1373875.1.8 COS& I
Message Path xmlaialsox15DDE5FBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .1373875.1.80058.1.xml
From (USANYS)"
Display Name (USANYS)"
Email
UUID MFF3224-0CIA-0000-8BBB-001438BDA527
Reply To usdoigov
Text (USANYS)"
To
Ce ' M
Subject RE: viewing tartagliene cell
Scheduled date 2019-11-27 II:36.92
Creation date 2019-11-27 11:36A2
Modified date 2019-11-27 II:4139
Delis end date 2019-11-27 11:3629
Message size 2262
Attachments sin 29508
Total size 31781
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TEXT.htm
Content ID
5DDE5FBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.2000089.1.8
9BCD.1(4)45:5DDE5FBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.IC0. 1
373875.1.80058. I@P3.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type Ile
Size 9415
CA 8d5519c492da87af7f3d0feb6b9dIa31
Rash 717BF2BC4F1I0C IC66751)DA6841DE3012353AC6AE CB169E75AB90895E99DE76F45A0FD9DC
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5DDE5FBC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200C089.1.B
9EICE.4453DDE5F13C.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
373875.1.8005a I@P3.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.103 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is lane false
Type fde
Size 20093
CA a45249d1a1762059616b6duac078769
Hash 8C3833C I ID7D949F5BB708778A6BD9DI FA57224D 0C40731284556841055F7B9DOAD6821D
Recipients 3
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID ('4I 17510-04FF-0000-133IC4A46EB8DCC96
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4A1B8282.31F7-0000.860A-IFDDAB07HOFA
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted false
Opened truc
Page 13359
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box tspe Into=
Return notification %%hen opened fake
Return notification uhen deleted false
Return notification vshen
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined false
Return notification %%hen
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
lore rnal ID 5DDE5FBC.NYMDOM l.NYMADM U00.'373875. I .8 0058. I ® I :7.NYMDOM I.NYMADM I.I 03.010. I ® I
Source received
Class
Account
Location II) 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMLIC0.0.I.0.1@l6
Name Nlaima
Type Mailbox
System !TUC
Share Type NotShared
Page 13360
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-12-06 2025:11 EST Created
en-Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive3
Jobrn-lebs.crGWOpenNodern-archiving
ietmai
Gerrrated by Netgovem [en-Archive
1-Daily Archi.c3
Jobon-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoiren-archivingr
-netrnail]
2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag 80801703.NOCRADMI.MXRDOMI Fligged
Page 13361
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13362
From:
To:
Cc:
Subject: RE: viewing tartaglione cell
Sent: Wed, 27 Nov 2019 16:36:02 +0000
(USANYS)" •c >
Thanks for your email and good wishes.
I believe that. is out of the office until next week. Can this wait until then?
I hope that you too have a Happy Thanksgiving.
Take care,
•
Chief, Civil Division
U.S. Attorney's Office, SONY
86 Chambers Street, 3"1 Floor
New York, NY 10007
From:
Sent: Wednesda November 27, 2019 11:23 AM
To: USANYS
Cc:
Subject: Fwd: viewing tartaglione cell
Hi
We may need wall counsel again in the Tartaglione matter in relation to the below site visit request. so excellently 
helped us
last time in our appearance on the conditions of confinement issue, so I cc'ed her as well.
Thank you and I wish you and yours a Happy Thanksgiving.
Best,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
p:
f:
> » Bruce Barket < > 11/27/2019 11:15 AM >>>
As part of our obligations to prepare for the penalty phase (should there be one) of Mr. Tartaglione's trial, we would 
like to view
the cells (including SHU ) and common areas where he has been held. It's possible that we will want to take some 
photographs,
but initially we just want to look at the areas where he has been housed.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden City, NY 11530
[F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. It 
it is not clear that you
are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, 
dissemination, distribution or
copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, 
please notify us
immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Fwd: Re: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/12/23 11:29
Subject: Fwd: Re: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
They were checking on three things:

1) confirming no investigation into Tartaglione re Epstein (confirmed)
2) getting video of the 7/23/19 suicide attempt (Pina took care of it)

3) checking with SIS whether they still have the rope from that attempt (still pending)
Thanks,
>>> 12/23/2019 9:07 AM >>>
Do you need me to do anything on this? Catching up on my emails now....
> » (USANYS)" < > 12/19/2019 8:13 AM > »
- can we do 10:30?
Co-Chief, Narcotics Unit
On Dec 19, 2019, at 07:55, > wrote:
I am available to chat today. What time works for you and
Thanks,
Deputy Regional Counsel
Northeast Regional Office
U.S. Customs House
2nd and Chestnut Streets
Philadel hia, PA 19106
p:
f.
>». (USANYS)" a 12/19/2019 7:52 AM > »
- any chance we can chat today? ppears to be out until next week and there are
some issues we need to close the loop on with you that we had been discussing while you were
still at MCC.
Page 13365
Co-Chief, Narcotics Unit
Begin forwarded message:
From:' (USANYS)" <
Date: December 18, 2019 at 15:40:58 EST
To:
Cc:
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
>
a following up. Can we speak tomorrow (Thursday)? Some issues came up
at the conference today and we need to address them with you.
Co-Chief, Narcotics Unit
On Dec 17, 2019, at 13:50, (USANYS) <
wrote:
HM— Right before left, we had discussed with him a
few questions from defense counsel related to Tartaglione's
penalty phase. Do you have a few minutes to jump on a call
today? Should take no more than 5 minutes, but we have a
court conference tomorrow so would be good to touch base.
Thanks!
Co-Chief, Narcotics Unit
United States Attorney's Office
Southern District of New York
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York New York 10007
Tel:
Page 13366
Properties
Property Value
MessagelD 5E00A526.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.1373875.1.4 048F. I
Message Path smiklaibox\5D00A526.NERDOMLNERADM1,100.1373875.1.4048F.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
To
Subject Fwd: Re: Tartaglione
Scheduled date 2019-12-23 1129:42
Creation date 2019-12-23 112942
Modified date 2019-12-23 11:3829
Delivered date 2019-12-23 112942
Message size 2320
Attachments size 5427
Total size 7758
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.han
Name TEXT.Nin
Content ID
5ECOA526.NERDOMLNERADMI.200.20300AO.LB
782C.1@453E00A526.NERDOMLNERADMI.100.1 373875.1.4048F.1@1:7.NERDOMLNERADMI.100
.0.1.01@l6
Is Inline fake
Type file
Size 5427
Date 2019-12-23062941
CA e lobe lac 19e76addebf6a2500d0152b2
Hash ID327065EC459FFA26AEAD76EC0199B6C0593E78 B3946A5AE5C3B3143D5AEAICA3AD5527
Recipients I
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID C4117510-04FF-0000433IC-4A46EB8DCC96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Delivered 2019-12-23112945
Opened 2019-12-23 113827
Expire o
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Sent Items
Return notification sshen opened fake
Return notification when deleted false
Return notification i.he n
completed fake
Return notification sshen declined fake
Return notification when
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5E00A526.NERDOMLNERADM1.100.1373875.1.4 048F. 1@1:7.NEFtDOMLNERADM1.100.0. 1.0.1@1 6
Source sent
Class Public
Account NYMADM LNYMDOM I
Location ID 1540842683886
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Madbox
ID 7.NERDOMI.NERADMI.I00.0.1.01@l6
Page 13367
99CE 06ed
Pam490N adi 1 antis
xui au aisis
xoqpetv adil
%Nem atuEN
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2020.01-10 183435 EST Created
cn=Archive Agent 1-Daly Archive3
Job,en-lebs.en-Gi/OpenNodegn-archisingsl Agent-
=nctmai
Generated by Netgovem [en-Archive
I -Daily Archi.c3
Job.cn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoie.cn-archisingo
-nettnail
2020-06021194:43 EDT Viewed BOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1 Viewed by
801 101829.NCRADMI.NCRDOM1
2020-05-19 15:36:06 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Revocative
2020.05-19 14,4156 EDT Tag EtOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Rigged
2020-06.02 15:34A6 EDT Tag EtOP01829.NCRADMI.NCRDOMI Responsive
Page 13369
Federal prisons chief ousted over Jeffrey Epstein suicide debacle
From New York Daily News
To nydailynews@nsl.nydailynews.com
Date 2019/08/19 14:13
Subject: Federal prisons chief ousted over Jeffrey Epstein suicide debacle
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
Page 13370
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D5AAE7B.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.170316D.I.8 nil
Message Path xmlfTrash/5D5AAE7B.NYMDOMINYMADMI.100.1 70316111.8622.1.xml
From New York Daly News
Display Name Ncw York Daly News
Email nydadynews@itsloydailynews.com
Reply to mixtalynews(Ostnydailynews.com
Test Ncw York Daly News
To nydalyncws@nstmdailyncws.com
Subject Federal prisons chief ousted over Jeffrey Epstein suicide debacle
Scheduled date 201908.1914:1232
Creation date 201948.1914:1232
Modified date 2019-08.19142507
Delivered date 201948.1914:13:16
Message sire 0
Attachments sine 68597
Total sin 68608
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TF-XT.htin
Content ID
5D5AAE7B.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200008A.1.6
EDE6.16_,145:5D5AAE7B.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
703I6D I 8E22.1(419.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.1€18
Is lane fake
Type ft
Sae 30006
CA 4d763ece897dcb893e24176173eadl9e
Hash D133C1BF9A82338ABF343289A39C7EB2621D4612 DF622AB2F97E61DBE9345A07528A856D
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
5D5AAE7B.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.200008A.1.6
EDE7.1@45:5D5AAE7B.NYNDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1
70316D 1 8E22.1@l9.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.1@l8
Is Inline fake
Type file
Sae 38591
CA 749a2d576d75729987606e38146bkbld
Hash IE77CA52734802FDB002B8AEF1344E83A0F75A89419DFE171A784C99E5001AE13D7FB732
Recipients 2
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
ULM )4:5B5F40- I IC6-0000-B3D6-FE.66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient mdailynewsia asloydailynews.com
Display Name nydadynewsUptsloydailynews.com
Email nydafiriews-IIP2,40000016cabl4a2abb5a1026 c966eble011284nstnydalyriews.com
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read fake
Deleted true
Opened fake
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification 6 hen opened fake
Return notification when deleted fake
Return notification hen
completed fake
Return notification 6he n declined fake
Return notification Mien
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Page 13371
Internal ID 5D5AAE7B.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.170316D.1.8 E22. I@ 19.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l8
Source received
Class Pub&
Account
Location ID
MI
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders 1
Folder Trash
ID 9.NYMDOMINYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1®18
Name Trash
TYlIc Trash
System (rue
Share Type NotSlated
Page 13372
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-21 014718 EDT Created
en-Archive Agent_ I-Daily Trash I
Job.en-Jobs.en-CWOpenNodecn-archising.ia
=netmai
Generated by Namai Inc. iciaArchive
Agent- I -Dad./ Trash 1
Jotscielobsen=GWOpenNodcsn=archivisgeo
-mulled]
2020-05-19 143434 EDT Tag BOPOI703.MXRADMI.MXRDOSI I Fbgged
20_20-05-19152839 CDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020-05.1915:1736 EDT Tag BOP01703.h0CRADMI.MXRDOM I Responsive
2020.05-19 153254 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Respaisive
Page 13373
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13374
Subject: Federal prisons chief ousted over Jeffrey Epstein suicide debacle
From: New York Daily News <nydailynews@nsl.nydailynews.com>
To:
Sent: Mon, 19 Aug 2019 18:12:32 +0000
BREAKING NEWS
Federal prisons chief ousted over Jeffrey Epstein
suicide debacle
The Bureau of Prisons chief was ousted Monday, just days after the jailhouse suicide of billionaire
pedophile Jeffrey Epstein shone a spotlight on mismanagement and staffing woes at the federal
agency.
Read the latest
BREAKING NEWS PRESENTED BY
UNSUBSCRISE I NEWSLETTERS I PRIVACY POLICY I TERMS OF SERVICE
Copyright * 2019 I New York Day News 14 New York Plaza. New York. NY 10004
ABOUT THIS EMAIL You received this email because you are following the Breaking News newsletter.
Noteworthy News Articles 9-11-2019
From
To
Date 2019/09/11 11:26
Subject: Noteworthy News Articles 9-11-2019
Attachments: TEXT.htm
District Of Corrections: Does D.0 Really Have The Highest Incarceration Rate In The Country?
WAMU
https://wamu.org/story/19/09/10/distrirt-of-rorrertions-does-d-c-really-have-the-highest-incarceration-
rate-in-the-country/
For a brief moment last week, D.C. was at opposite ends of a debate. One on side, criminal justice reform
advocates were saying that D.0 imprisons more people per capita than any of the 50 states. But the U.S.
Attorney for D.C., which prosecutes all violent crime in the city, said just the opposite, pointing to data
allegedly showing that the city actually sends fewer people to prison than any of the states.
Official: Arizona corrections officers vacancy rates on rise
The Tribune
https://www.sanluisobispo.conVnews/business/article234938012.html
The Arizona Department of Corrections director says vacancy rates for correctional officers have increased
across the state, a report said. Director Charles Ryan warned Republican Gov. Doug Ducey in a retirement
letter that vacancy rates at Arizona's prisons have increased from 1.7% to 19% since 2012, The Arizona
Capitol Times reported Monday.
"We failed as an agency": Texas prison officials admit violating court order on air conditioned
units for inmates
The Eagle
https://www.theeagle.com/news/texas/we-failed-as-an-agency-texas-prison-officials-admit-
violating/article 2eb7018d-ac1c-5c64-6961-c7b47e2173fe.html
Days after a federal judge threatened to jail Texas prison officials for violating a settlement agreement to put
some inmates in air conditioned housing, the top Texas Department of Criminal Justice leader admitted in
open court that the agency broke federal orders and that keeping inmates in temperatures above 100
degrees creates a serious health risk.
Middle Tennessee construction companies are giving prisoners a second chance — and a job
Spring Hill Home Page
https✓/springhi I I homepage.conVmidd le-tennessee- construction-companies-are-givi ng-prisoners-a-second-
chance-and-a-job/
The day starts early for Shane Presley, a construction worker from Antioch who works for Jone Bros. He wakes
up before 4 a.m. to eat breakfast. By sunrise he's already at his job site, where he lays pipe all day long.
During the workday he looks the same as his peers, but at the end of the day a van takes him back to the Lois
De Berry Special Needs Facility, a prison in West Nashville where Presley is incarcerated.
Jeffrey Epstein: Three victims who say they were abused by him have come forward in Paris
Herald Publicist
Page 13377
httpsliheraldpublicistronVjeffrey-epstein-three-virtims-who-say-they-were-abused-by-him-have-rome-
forward-in-paris/
Three individuals who declare they had been victims of Jeffrey Epstein have come ahead in France,
prosecutors in Paris have mentioned. The trio had been questioned in latest weeks, chief prosecutor Remy
Heitz's workplace mentioned, with out giving any additional particulars.
Does a Kansas Inmate Have a Right to Opioid Addiction Drugs? A Judge Will Decide
NY Times
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/11/us/kansas-aclu-inmate-opioids.html
The American Civil Liberties Union is suing a federal prison in Kansas to force it to provide an inmate with
buprenorphine, an opioid addiction medication, saying the man would "inevitably suffer and possibly die"
without it.
Full text of the New York Times article'
Does a Kansas Inmate Have a Right to Opioid Addiction Drugs? A Judge Will Decide
NY Times
September 11, 2019
The American Civil Liberties Union is suing a federal prison in Kansas to force it to provide an inmate with
buprenorphine, an opioid addiction medication, saying the man would "inevitably suffer and possibly die"
without it.
Officials at the Leavenworth federal penitentiary are not providing the inmate, Leaman Crews, with the
buprenorphine he needs to stay sober, Lauren Bonds, legal director of the ACLU. of Kansas, said on Tuesday.
Instead, she said, they are medicating him with codeine, an opioid, to keep him from going through a painful
withdrawal, and Tylenol.
Judge Carlos Murguia of Federal District Court for the District of Kansas will decide after an emergency
hearing Wednesday afternoon whether prison officials are obligated to provide Mr. Crews with
buprenorphine.
Before reporting to the Leavenworth prison last Wednesday to serve a three-year sentence for
embezzlement, Mr. Crews, 45, had been in recovery for 14 months with the aid of the medication, according
to Ms. Bonds.
"It is a rare feat for that long a period," she said, referring to using buprenorphine during recovery to treat
addiction. "It was kind of a success story."
The Federal Bureau of Prisons did not respond on Tuesday to questions about why buprenorphine is not
available to inmates in recovery, but is permitted for inmates in detox.
The office of the United States attorney for the District of Kansas is reviewing the A.C.LU. complaint,
according to Jim Cross, a spokesman.
The prison bureau, which incarcerates nearly 180,000 people, estimates that close to 40 percent of its
inmates enter the federal prison system with a substance abuse problem, according to a letter a bipartisan
group of eight senators sent to the Government Accountability Office last year. For federal inmates,
methadone and — much less frequently — buprenorphine are usually prescribed for detoxing, as opposed
to hedging cravings and maintaining sobriety.
Page 13378
Pregnant women, however, are allowed to take medications that suppress opioid cravings for more than just
detoxing, according to the prison bureau. By prescribing codeine to inmates, Ms. Bonds said, the federal
prison system is supporting the cycle of addiction and increasing the chance inmates have of overdosing
once they are released from custody.
"We do know that in Leavenworth they offer buprenorphine for inmates in certain situations, usually to help
people detox, as opposed to maintaining sobriety," Ms. Bonds said.
By providing Mr. Crews with codeine, the prison was "making his opioid addiction worse," Michael V.
Pantalon, a senior research scientist in the Yale School of Medicine's department of emergency medicine,
said.
"He will have codeine to reinforce his opioid addiction rather than the medications that would treat it," Dr.
Pantalon said. "I can understand why there is a lawsuit," he added.
According to the complaint, filed on Friday in the Federal District Court, federal prisons do not provide
buprenorphine to inmates even when, as with Mr. Crews, the inmate had been prescribed the medication
before being in custody.
Studies show that the success rate for staying sober is much greater when buprenorphine is made available
to the person struggling with addiction for at least a year, according to Dr. Pantalon.
"People who stay on it for one consecutive year or longer do far, far better and stay abstinent for longer," he
said.
"It is a chronic disease, so it needs chronic treatment just like people with asthma or hypertension," he added.
"We don't ask people with hypertension, 'When are you coming off the hypertension medication?"
Most professionals who treat addiction recommend a combination of therapy and medication.
"This is a brain disorder; it is not just an addiction of the body," Dr. Karan Baucom, director of the Baucom
Institute, a treatment facility in Overland Park, Kan., said on Tuesday. "The brain has been reconfigured by the
drug itself; it structurally changes the brain's response."
The cycle of opioid addiction is fueled by the body's natural response to avoiding pain, Dr. Baucom
explained. If someone in recovery does not have buprenorphine or methadone available, she said, they can
get "so sick that they have to use the narcotic to recover from the symptom." Most people addicted to
opioids get to a point where they are only using opioids to keep from getting sick, she added.
Opioid abusers have less than a 30 percent chance to stay sober without the proper medication, Dr. Baucom
said.
The chances that an inmate will survive a relapse after being released from custody plummets, while the
chances that he or she will overdose skyrockets.
"It is not life or death, like you take him off and he dies," Dr. Pantalon said. "It is life or death mainly when he
comes out," he added.
Of course, some inmates can find opioids in prison in the codeine they are prescribed. And illegal drugs can
make their way into prison as well, Ms. Bonds noted.
"I think there is a risk of relapse, and not just when he is released," she said.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/09/11/us/kansas-aclu-inmate-opioids.html
Page 13379
Page 13380
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D7XD9CB.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1AB3FD .1
Message Path xmlCabinenIPPA/5D78D9CB.BOPMSCO.PO4.10 0.1316B72.1.4B3FD.I.wil
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 737B570916FD43009BF9C-000083202C73
Reply To
Text
To
Subject
a I I I
I I
I I
Noteworthy Newt, AllICk• 9-11-21119
Scheduled date 2019.0941 1126133
Citation date 2014094i 11:26.133
Modified date 2019-09-11 1 I :4509
Delis e red date 20190941 112604
Message size 8570
Attachments size 11736
Total size 20317
Attachments I
Attachment TEXTIan
Nance TEXT.hun
Content ID 5D78D9CB.BOPMSCO.PO4.X0.2000OCB.1.2346A 7.1®45:5D78D9CB.130PMSCO.PO4. I 00.13161372.
I.4B3FD. I ®155B6ODD9 BOPMSCO.PO4.103.131 6872. I.4A. 14,, I 3
Is feline false
Type Ile
Size 11736
Date 2019-09-II 072606
CA 3f19918bd6c657c77187388bfc05c073
Hash C7D526E4 I 5CAA IBEDF7549C0420C 1531IF9D9AC4 E3D937B60666E2.B09A76F82FF38BB368
Recipients 16
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID FO9FC 101- 1656-0000-8495-000083219F58
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UU1D BDFI.457F7FF4607B
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Ulf) B2696931. /2914
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID B5927150-1653-00399291-751C62334A6C
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID B922A560-1581-0009B66C-FACF6A00A51C
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID CD0296F9044A-0309893A-39A2F22875A3
Page 13381
Distribution Tye TO
Recipient Type U cr
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID ( 9BD4C60-050D-0000-5363-DC6656I970DB
Distribution Typt TO
Recipient ly-pe User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 794B2E0I-157F-000043FB5-00)01B202C73
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4FA5FFrfU1158-0C00-83F5-C300BOOFA00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient ?vise User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
(WI D 70,185C13I - I F82-0000-8528-0000832 I 9F45
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 6951:8303-02C5-0003-95CF-8590/3232EF87
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Uscr
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 6A70A5D0-05EF-0000-A5A4-F50F8FD3CO3A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient fype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 3494D6CO-II52-0000.B502-02B05D137IF3
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Time User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID 2F982880-I4C3-OCKI0-9B47-BF62C05FIE96
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
pis plus Name
Email
LAID F55D4040- I46D-00C0-94D1C0008324673C
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 8B49E50 I -2 I A B-0030-B5CD-000000C0/300
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Page 13382
Deleted fake
Opened We
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Intros
Return notification when opened false
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed fake
Return notification %%hen declined false
Return notification alien
accepted false
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D78D9CB.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316872.1AB3FD .1@1:551360DD9.B0PMSCO.PO4.100.1316872.1.
4A.I@l3
Source received
Class Public
Account MSCO
Location ID 1540843449744
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMA1L
Enclosing Folders I
Folder IPPA
ID 55B60DD9.BOPMSCO.PO4.100.1316B72.1.4A.1® 13
Name IPPA
Type Normal
System false
Share Type NotShared
Page 13383
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-09-21 00A932 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive8
Joben-lcbs.cn-GWOpenNodeen-archivingeAgent- se mi
Generated by Netrred Inc. [crrArchive
I -Daily Archive8 Joben-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNocletn-archivinge
-naiad]
2019.11.12 1129:18 EST Exported netmainetmadneunad Exported by netmad.neunainctmail
2020-05-19 153421 EDT Tag BOP01703.NIXRADM I.MXRDOM I Resume:lye
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag BOP0I 703.MXRADM I.MXRDOM I Fbgged
Page 13384
To
RE: viewing tartaglione cell
From (USANYS)"
Jeffrey OestericherNicole
McFarland
Date 2019/12/02 11:07
Subject: RE: viewing tartaglione cell
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Mime.822
I'm back in the office and around to discuss this week at your convenience, Hope you had a
nice holiday.

From: (USANYS)
Sent: Wednesday, November 27, 2019 11:36 AM
To:
Cc: < >;
Subject: RE: viewing tartaglione cell
Thanks for your email and good wishes.
I believe that- is out of the office until next week. Can this wait until then?
I hope that you too have a Happy Thanksgiving.
Take care,
U
Chief, Civil Division
U.S. Attorney's Office, SDNY
86 Chambers Street, 3rd Floor
New York, NY 10007
From:
Sent: Wednesda , November 27, 2019 11:23 AM
To: (USANYS)
Cc:
Subject: Fwd: viewing tartaglione cell
Hi■,
We may need wall counsel again in the Tartaglione matter in relation to the below site visit request. so
excellently helped us last time in our appearance on the conditions of confinement issue, so I cc'ed her as
well.
Page 13385
Thank you and I wish you and yours a Happy Thanksgiving.
Best,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
P::f=
> » Bruce Barket < > 11/27/2019 11:15 AM > »
As part of our obligations to prepare for the penalty phase (should there be one) of Mr. Tartaglione's
trial, we would like to view the cells (including SHU ) and common areas where he has been held. It's
possible that we will want to take some photographs, but initially we just want to look at the areas
where he has been housed.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
IPI
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Page 13386
Properties
Property Value
Message ID SDE4F082.BRODOMI.BROADMI.100.B0656E.I.A 5E07.1
Message Path =hint° requestODE4F082.BRODOMLBROADMI.100.13 0656E LASE07.1.xml
From (USANYS)
Talia (USANYS)' Dis pia) Name
Email
UUID 4A 1B8282-31F7-0000.B60A- IFDDAB07B0FA
Reply To Talia.Kraemer@usdoigov
Text (USANYSr
To
Cc
Subject RE: won tanagbooe cell
Scheduled date 2019-12-02 11117:29
Creation date 2019-12-02 111)729
Modified date 2019-12-03 06:03:44
Delivered date 2019-12-02 1 I (17A7
Message sin 2772
Attachments silt 33280
Total sin 36063
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.hon
Name TF—XT.hon
Content II)
SDFAF082-BRODOMI.BROADMI.200.200002A.I.A
4B88.1(✓nASSDE4F082-BRODOMI.BROADMI.100.1
IIIMAT I.ASE07.1@1)4964B642.BRODOMI.BROA DMI.100.1VIMfiF 1.F3.1@i3
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 10654
CA I tbdd0f8fe833bb9596e80e66a69a0fe
Hach 0DI2A79D42BA871DD9DE6A248EDBD62266AF8469 19S3DCE3Et8D2CA4A0067E780D04A7535
Attachment Mine.822
Name Mine.822
Content ID
SDE4F082.BRODOMLBROADMI.X0.200002A.I.A
4889.1@451DE4F1)82.BRODOMI.BROADMI.100.1
30656E.I.ASE07.1@lY1964B642.BRODOMI.BROA D)41.100.130656E. I.F3. Igfi 13
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 22626
CA le9e3966862a7c86c801fd8Seb7ccb2f
Has h B561B810E37C32907D7611326O1B78765C19BDNE C54B7EC3A4B416DD8DAE9FEE3648B436
Recipients 3
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CAD04)9CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 84H:3224-0C] A-00n)-8BRI1-0014381IDA527
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID C4II75Iii-D4I.F-00(X)-I33IC-4A46ER8DCC96
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read truc
Deleted fake
Opened true
Page 13387
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box tspe Into=
Return notification %%hen opened fake
Return notification n he n deleted false
Return notification nhen
completed fake
Return notification hen declined fake
Return notification %%hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5DE4F082.BRODOMLBROADMI.100.B0656E.LA 5E07.1©104964B642.BRODOMLBROADMI.100.13
0656E.1.F3.1®13
Source received
Class Public
Account BROADMI.BRODOMI
Location II) 1540842508334
Class Name GW.MESSAGEMAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Info requests
ID 4964B642.BRODOMLBROADMLIC0.130656E.I.F 3.l@l3
Name Info requests
Type Normal
System fake
Share Type NotSharcd
Page 13388
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-12-09 092322 EST Created
crt=Arehive Agent3-Schedukd Zero Day
Arehive2.en-Jobs.en-GWOpenNodetn-strchis ogortictmail
Generated by Neigpvem Km-Archive
Agent 3-Scheduled Zero Day
Archh;Zen-Jobs.ensGWOpenNoiesn-archis
itgo-netmai)
2020.05-19153421 EDT Tag 8OP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Rcsponsht
2020-05-19 1437:18 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Fbgged
Page 13389
Mail Attachment
Mime.822
Page 13390
From: NYS)"
To: ANY
Cc:
Subject: RE: viewing tartaglione cell
Sent: Mon, 2 Dec 2019 16:07:29 +0000
I'm back in the office and around to discuss this week at your convenience, Hope you had a nice holiday.

From: (USANYS) c >
Sent: Wednesda November 27, 2019 11:36 AM
To:
Cc:
Subject: RE: viewing tartaglione cell
Thanks for your email and good wishes.
I believe that is out of the office until next week. Can this wait until then?
I hope that you too have a Happy Thanksgiving.
Take care,
U
Chief, Civil Division
U.S. Attorney's Office, SDNY
86 Chambers Street, 3'd Floor
New York, NY 10007
From:
Sent: Wednesda November 27, 2019 11:23 AM
To: (USANYS)
Cc:
Subject: Fwd: viewing tartaglione cell
Hi M,
We may need wall counsel again in the Tartaglione matter in relation to the below site visit request. so excellently 
helped us
last time in our appearance on the conditions of confinement issue, so I cc'ed her as well.
Thank you and I wish you and yours a Happy Thanksgiving.
Best
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
p:
f:
>> > Bruce Barket < > 11/27/2019 11:15 AM >> >
As part of our obligations to prepare for the penalty phase (should there be one) of Mr. Tartaglione's trial, we would 
like to view
the cells (including SHU ) and common areas where he has been held. It's possible that we will want to take some 
photographs,
but initially we just want to look at the areas where he has been housed.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[Pi [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or confidential. If 
it is not clear that you
are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error; any review, 
dissemination, distribution or
copying of this transmittal is strictly prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, 
please notify us
immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
Re: Fed: counsel tuning difficult) meeting with client
From -
lo
Date 2019/07/07 21:45
Subject: Re: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with
client
.tttachmenta: TEXT.htm
Thanks.
Sent Mom my Vefizon, Samsung Galaxy unattplione
• intiol e
.cFrom
Date 7/7/19 8.49 PM GMT-05.
To: -< >
Subject Re Fwd counsel having difficulty meeting with diem
>>> 07/07/20192049 >>>
Copy. I mil pass the information to the lieutenants.
Jermarne C.
Captain
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York NY 10007
Office (646)836-6448
Blackberry (646)423-0779
>>  > > 7/7/2019 6:58 PM >>
Sent from my Vertion. Samsung Galaxy scnaitphone
Front
Subject: Fwd: cocked having difficulty meeting with diet
aitalrriessacA
">> "M=" 07/07/201918:22 »>
I have verified Martin Weinberg Han attorney in good standing in Massachusetts. He is pemtitted to visit Jeffrey 
Epstein.Sent from my Venzon. Samsung Galaxy
smanphoi
</div> cdiv>
<MN> <!-- ofiginSMessage --><div> Original message </div> <div>From .e l.> <Mkt>
</dal>
>>> Or O 07/07/20191878 > »
Massachusetts
Front < >
Sentiallit
To:
Subject: Re counsel having difficulty meeting with dient
Sony. just seeing this now. Where is he barred?
Sent from my Vernon Samsung Galaxy smartphone
nt
Ori inas
From " RIPI10:a
Data6PM(GtiAl
To MIM4. .mailto.la
Subject: RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
main°
>>> r 07/07/201917:36 > > >
Page 13393
With apologies for the weekend email, we have a defendant. Jeffrey Epstein, who was arrested last night and is currently
being detained at MCC, and is expected
to be ins
of-state
Were concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any defendant) and so I wanted to reach
out to
thanks very much,
U
Page 13394
her mks
IroperD Wee
MessagelD %OWED NYAIDOMI.NYMADM1.101161.5.111 I a MR I
Deana Parh satlADDeC002126711DNYAIDOMI NYMADMI 100 140.70 1 UDR 1 ma
aeon Les Pb.*
DIspkA Na
Emil bbakloatoAsoA
ACID 9DOICDOISCI-0:00-AW.OXOCOOIDSVO
Re Te ORD,.
Teo
T.
Salto Re: ODA Drawl ling Mk* matey ath (In•
calaeleila dew 311%0107 21407
(Doan RS 31190740 20407
Medlied dile 20111074? OASIS
Morella* 20190740 214518
Renew ..In MA
Adestleam On 6536
Tod eke 10117
Alualmeme I
Asada/as Mr Mn
Reap TRALIan
Cam ID
sonvem DAMMAM! NYMADMI 30 AMMO. ID
(DIA lie14302DVED NYAIDOMI NYMADMI 1001
~V 1 I FOR. ID 1 ANTSIOODI AYMAtAll 100 01 0.11% le
le lois LM
TYRA Re
Sn A536
CA DeteDSIOADIMIDAWIebbfelekee
Hob LCXDIOLD4016A1 141A000SIVAITOR0171•11101.1111,A0A.01(DITADTIRCO011AD
Ree rlaless I
IlatiOND
DYAD Name Jan et
FARM plentne bp DA
CLAD 21/1/MOMAIDRACOADOUCTUelf103INA
Dlorliaele• Twe TO
Ilad r al  TAW Uwe
Kole 0
DOD Darn) until 0
Deflated fiDe
AreiDed (eke
Read haw
Deleted fah.
Or Red Oda
I emlaeied DM
security Nonni
0... ap hem
IDADa neealtetlentenpeaml W.
Ate Den noilkeeleawbeeebk0l Mr
at Den iremlnalas lobes
Due& a a
NM
10 Ion nealiezak• Mee Reeked Si.
ID len nosh/Rae whe•
Detpied Cabe
Ante Arnie. TA
Deem' ID !CORDED NYMOOM ANYNIADM1100 16BROO 1 A FOR CA IINTIADOIA ANTICADM11010 I A IN le
Seam reetwed
Owe Pak
Accost knot DealeSellOP25131.POLADMAPOICONII
Lorain so IS100:0110111

(ti. Nose OW MERWITWJA
raltlealeig Fenn 1
Feller 1.6100
ID 7 NAMCOMANYMADA11.1000 IA IN 16
Near Meta
1)10 Mita
&One On
Slim bp, NeDlared
Page 13395

╭─ Page 944, Image 1 ─╮
│ =                   │
│                     │
│ ms                  │
│                     │
│ oi FO F             │
│                     │
│ Page 13395          │
╰─────────────────────╯

Ma,
Dale Man Asir Noel
21/14/4015 YU IM EDT Cw.asal
arArelar Awn 1.0a4 Arclow4
Juba- lolan-/C iVillyerNmkinc1/07g/ 1"-
'mum/
rimenieil by Kam] Ix low•Aithie
I•Day Ardor/
//b.co - kb/.0 ,4110)//e•Nodetlrodinte
-Irtmail
NlIttall /LIZA EDT Expiriol lamelenutinetmel F./vanity wimulirtnimusil
mica in NOON EDT Bp0nJ virml wirrainammi Fsitrial by narnsinamobwinui

30046. la /0,01 EDT In IllOPOI NO ‘INR/tDM I MICROOM I Road
2/0/4I -I9 lell16 1 DT Ng IICI000I %/MIAMI PAXRDOM I flissed
2118M619 ISJI i51 Of In /00,00(0 MMtAfAl I 1.0100M I Roman
J4bQa19 1532 01 1 111 In 6owno.IXIIALIMI sootoomi ACSIICIIIIIt
/1/2/01”. 0 1533 30 / III In DOPOINO •IXADM I AVOUX/MI IReVant
3/306.19 0:421 I01 rig nueorox.IVAOMI 14/0/000 I Itcnernsw
30046. I. /43011111 LIg IION/IIW.SIXRADM I P4XIIIXIM I ibpN
Page 13396
Re: Fed: counsel basing difficult) meeting with client
From
To
Date 2019/07/07 20:49
Subject: Re: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting with
client
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Page 13397
Copy, I will pass the information to the lieutenants
lermame C.
Captain
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
Office (646) 836-6448
Blackberry (646)423-0779
>>> > 7/7/2019 6:58 PM »>
Sent horn my Vernon Samsung Galaxy smanpnone
Fro
a linamesas a
nt
Date: 70/19 622 PM (GMT-05:001
To: < >
Subject: Fwd: counsel having difficulty meeting wth client
>>> 07/07/2019 18:22 »>
I have verified Martin Weinberg is an attorney in good standing in Massachusetts. He is permitted to visit Jeffrey 
Epstein.Sent from my Verizort Samsung Galaxy
smartpho
</drv> sdiv>
</dile> <!-- originalMessage --> <div> Original message <idly> <thy >From
<Idly>
» > 07/07/2019 18:18 »
Massachusetts
Front
Sent . Jul 07. 2019 1&18
To: < >:a
Subject Re. counsel having difficulty meeting with diets
Sony.. just seeing this now. Where is he barred>
Sent from my %Mixon. Samsung Galaxy smanphone
Qi iri
Front < rnailtcr
Date: 70/19 5.36 PM (GMT-05:00)
To: crtmilto:a10johnson@bop.goy> >
Subject. RE: counsel having difficulty meeting with client
> > > "07/07/2019 17:36 > »
'Mr"
With apologies for the weekend email, we have a defendant, Jeffrey Epsteirt who was arrested last night and is currently
being detained at MCC, and is expected
to be pres
of-state
Were concerned about the defendant not having access to his attorney in advance of the presentment (as we would be for 
any defendant) and so I wanted to reach
out to
thanks very much,
Page 13398
hornIts
Poor Woe
Mess ID 30215ACI tiVNIDOMI NYMA IRO 168633.1.E TM I
Restate Pba ur6M. 10223A
From lama
DS*, Nam
Fell 014n1tos &pox
4 T. ID 2DDA90104101.40044161C4:0110.712104A
Rs T. *Mow 6•0•14
Tell krma
To
Salto Re 104 camel Itsto•04710D etton4 ash..Int
44104146.4 doe 3119.0107 RAMOS
Conan dale 20 MORO) 344946

M.  dike 20140740 21 I?
Delver,. 40, 20140740 401:6
Mess Mn 030
Anaillatlell fi lt SW
Tool she MN
Asta•••••R
Attaisma IVO kin
New TEXI.Ion
GESS ID
5022JACILNYMDOMINTLIA061101:17/00077 IA
JIM 7 1401350121ACINYMDOW NYMADDII MI
614410 I FEN Ii4111 1A11170141 SVMAT041 KO 0101606

I. Islet IA
T1Ps Re
Slat VW
Dar )1444/ 417 164007
CA 6011414.11117704707144446,fili 0
Halo 100010:101 AR2(T,.W111NIINMII'IBM32 DZEDOAA78207011D7111C:47017A 07
1404101.0.
Re I
04 14 ° ‘ .an
i cosi 04ordnoluppss
WO 90TIODDISC14000.A9440344010000
Dsmbutoso TO
R•cirsu big
Dan rtd :01007.07 94405
Dowalosadll) lln1Pari7 .
. I R. RS :01007.07 2161'.12
F.tllre 0
Del0 et emus. 0
DekRalsd lobe
trcilve4 robe
Meal OW
Deloed ri,
°pried ow
('on16rk6 Tar
snug*, Ncrial
se. h Cm Man
Rohe, notakalse Meo.ReoN lac
Room issisToslonte• alma Cole
Roles. noolsooso.nobt•
ormok Ito kit
Rsi..0 moist/on • dedhied A
Itsisni noillcalo• vita
Roo 44 robe
MTN* limbs S1
Semi ID SOMA(' 10064001111 NIRIADMI NO 144.14021 Di 14.1 7 NV1400 I NYMACSII IWO 1016116
Some in
Clot halo
Anon fl ee OLADMI.FIXDMII
Laude ID 1540114214011
Cl.. Nam GW.RIESSAGE.MAIL
faidolse F•114n I
Folder 61•41x4
ID 7 NY60UM I NTRIADMI.1000 10 14 16
Nas Mita
T714
tom urn
Wirt Two
Page 13399
Milts
Dale Mar Asir Noel
3/1.1015 MISS EDT (mad
arArclar Awn I.Oak Amin.'
Jubea-klaan-fiViererNukinclinv suAS " -
'mum,
ratitleil by liasi Ix Ics•Aitlit
I•Day Ardor.
Aba -kb..coralhallodetlrodinItt
-actioll
MI9.062I I 11.1.9 EDT FAitinal lemslationtinetnal Fsfuned by wintirtnaiseineil
:mum in 101034 EDT BponJ \wind rrininani 'Arty...It" re ttnisintimobwinui
3I:046. la 'OTIS EDT Lig W*OI NO ‘INR1DM I MICROOM I Road
N1D4k-I0 lell16 I Of Ng 1O1IOINO MRADMI PAXRDOMI f tined
N.70.0- I9 ISJI 0 'I Ill In IlitItOINA MMtALAII MICRLIONII Roman
N:04,649 ISM*, / Ill In 6owno.IXIIALIMI sootoomi *MOON t
.:112IMIt‘l9 IS/330 / III In DOPOINO•IVADMI NI.XIMIOMI IReVant
31204:649 IS342I I DI rig tille0I,O.I•IVADMI NIXADOMI Rocersat
332046.I.1434.111I) I lag IIIIWOI7W.SIXRADMI MICRIXIMI ibpN
Page 13400
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/22 21:38
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
I intend for him to be the first patient I see tomorrow morning.
Thanks.
>>> Ml 7/22/2019 10:43 AM > »
DHi, I wrote  about this last week and I know he intended on seeing him.
Psy.D.
Chief Psychologist
U.S. Department of Justice/
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Office:
Fax:
E-mail:
>>  > 7/19/2019 9:25 AM >>>
Can you please have him seen for his request for 7 I understand he has not expressed
an,
concerns in the past, but he is facing the death penalty and is currently in SHU facing
disciplinary c rges. Thanks!
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
p:
> » Bruce Barket <
Good morning,
> 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
rerael taut:sral tirnae dacnitcs Ivauinn nwat knnlec <ant in him haul hones tines resraintt inrlir,fines tk,t nnrr k.ae
Page 13401
1 1/4.44 O ,1..V 1/4 .14.1 11 4.1181‘..J, 8.1....11.08.A. 884V8185 8 81/4. nr 8".“01"...8 O...Ill %Ad 81818I 1YVI. 
114Y1. til 1/4 . I ,...‘ 1/4 .8t.“..)
III41l.4llll5111411V11.1. 114J
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
he found a dead rodent in his bed. Apparently he accidently smothered it while sleeping. The lights in
the cell are frequently off during the day and on at night.
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, July 15, 2019 3:48 PM
To: Bruce Bark •
Cc: tonyricco ; Aida Leisenring;
[mailto
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if ou are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/2019 11:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Page 13402
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the closing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Cit , NY 11530
-O
,cu JR7 7)Qr1 -
Page 13403
1,./ I WI LAI t ILJV IVI
Barket Epstein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) < > wrote:
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:22 PM
(USANYS)
(USANYS)
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden City, NY 11530
-
-M
Barket Epstein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
(USANYS)
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal As a result, the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to , and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket
Cc: tonyricco ) < >; Aida Leisenring
aloicpnrinoehArkotonctpin rnm>• hknfrcIntOcnpt not• cwpronlri Iacnn
Page 13404
(USANYS) < >;
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
;•.:=
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
Page 13405
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitigations specialists also waited 2 hours. Aida and I were Lucky in that we
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci NY 11530
[P1 [Fl
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
Page 13406
VLIICIWIbe ue pinmegeu VI LVIIIIVelltIdl. II II lb Ilul Uedl Uldt ylal die lilt Illte[MeV
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
message and all its attachments
Page 13407
Properties
Property Value
3lessage 1 D 5D362CDC.NYMDOMENYMADM1.100.170316D.1.6 8B3.1
Message Path xml/Maibox/50362CDC.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.17031613.1.68B3.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
QUID 6FEC15F0-25C8-0000-8293-9E01000038CF
Reply To
Text
To I i i
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tartagione
Scheduled date 2019-07-22 213836
Creation date 2019-07-22 21:38:36
Modified date 2019-07-23 063237
Delivered date 201947-22213837
Message size 15356
Attachments sizt 32151
Total size 47518
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.htrn
Name TE)Cf.htm
Content II)
5D362CDC.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.20000AA.1.4
1C97.1®455D362CDC.NYMMOMENYMADMI.100.1
7031613.1.68B3.1@la.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 32151
Date 2019-07-22 1738k0
CA 876ae9b942bad493a8.5547fa9lb09bde
Hash 9626645D50413451B89827871739646EA08198296 0412D61CFD6B43065F9759BC22ACF980
Recipients 5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UU11) 2750( \Do trx \.(X)00-A8F4-IACF3lEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 1 ype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
till D 835B5E40-I1C6-0030-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution lype CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID A4423FD0-0824-0000-B58A-448148E79444
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
t t ID 43FDBOCO-OCOC-0000-8B6E- 1 BCO3A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UU1D .51('E I IC0-0904-0000-BBEI-7C3A8759762I
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Page 13408
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened hue
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Intros
Return notification alien opened fake
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed false
Return notification alien declined fake
Return notification %%hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D362CDC.NYMDOMINYMADMI.I00.1703I6I3.1.613B3.1®I:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.I.01@i6
Source received
Class Public
Account
Location ID
MI
Class Name GW.MFSSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mabox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.I.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share 'Ewe NotShared
Page 13409
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-01 1724:43 EDT Created
cn=Archive Agent_I-Daly Archive)
Job.cn-Jcbs.orGWOpenNodetn-archiyirg.dAgcni-
. )etmai
Generated by Netrre8 Inc. [crrArchive
I -DailY ArchiveIJohen-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNode.cn-archivingn
-vermeil]
2019-08-21 093618 EDT Exponed nomainctmaancurrad Exported by netmainetrnainetman
2019-08-21 093734 EDT Exported neunainetrainetnna Exported by netnraitnetnrail.netnrail
2019-08.211336:13 EDT Exported nconainconainctrnai Exported by netmainctmail nomad
2019-09-0718:13,36 EDT Exported netraineunannetmai Exported by netmainetnnitnctmail
2020.0549 15:3531 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2021-05-1914:4136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Flagged
Page 13410
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/22 10:43
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Hi, I wrote DrIabout this last week and I know he intended on seeing him.
Psy.D.
Chief Psychologist
U.S. Department of Justice/
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Office:
Fax:
E-mail:
>» 7/19/2019 9:25 AM > »
Can ou lease have him seen for his request for 7 I understand he has not expressed
any concerns in the past, but he is facing the death penalty and is currently in SHU facing
disciplinary charges. Thanks!
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New Yor New York 10007
p:
f.
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
he found a dead rodent in his bed. Apparently he accidently smothered it while sleeping. The lights in
the cell are fre uentl off durin the day and on at ni ht. Nick has asked to be given medication to
. His
Page 13411
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[F]
www.barketeostein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Bark
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
PM
; Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if ou are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/201911:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Page 13412
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the dosing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci NY 11530
-
M
Barket Epsteinsom
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) < > wrote:
Page 13413
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
To:
Cc:
tonyricco
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:22 PM
(USANYS)
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Jason,
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
- M
Barket Fpctein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
Leisenrin
(USANYS)< >
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal I. As a result, the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to , and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket <
Cc: ton
(USANYS
>;
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
›- Aida Leisenring
Page 13414
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
f.
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
Page 13415
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitigations specialists also waited 2 hours. Aida and I were Lucky in that we
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
Page 13416
message and all its attachments
Page 13417
Properties
Property Value
Nlessage 1 D 5D359349.NYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.170316D.1.6 7EF. I
Message Path xmrslatoW5D359349.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .170316D.1.67EFlain
From
Display Name
Email
QUID 43FDBO00.OCOC-0000.8B6E-IB003A002D00
Reply To
Text
Edge
To
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tartagione
Scheduled date 2019-07-22 10:4321
Creation date 2019-07-22 1014321
Modified date 2019-07-22 122823
Delis e red date 2019-07-22104322
Message size 15237
Attachments silt 31961
Total size 47209
Attachments I
Attachment TEXI.ltn
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D359349.NYMDOMENYMADMI.200.200C051.1.F
34C6.10A)455D359349.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.1
703160.1.67EF.I@UZNYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 31961
Date 2019-07-22 06:4323
CA cbe667019e6F25d79b135a8def4531:61
Hash 0EBB02A488DEB9A2FA33673A9629FD8ED338B36C BA 10F561D8CFA I3963C9269A79092514
Recipients
Recipient
Display Name
Email
(MIX 2750( A Dn-1rKA-0000•A8F4-1ACF31FA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient I ype User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
HAD 835B5E40-I1C6-00:10-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution lype CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
ail D A4423FD0-0824-0000-B58A-448148E79444
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
I. t I D 6FECI5F0-25C8-8000-8293-9€01000038CF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID .XECI- I 1C0-091)4-0000-BBEI-7C3A87597621
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Page 13418
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened hue
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification alien opened fake
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed false
Return notification alien declined fake
Return notification %%hen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D359349.NYMDOM LNYMADM 1.1001 X0 I6D.I.6 7EF. I ® I :7.NYMDOM LNYMADM II00.0.1.0. IQ 16
Source received
Class Public
Account
Location ID
MI
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maabox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.I.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share 'Ewe NotSharcd
Page 13419
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-01 172508 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Archive)
Job.cn-lcbs.cn-GWOpenNodetn-archivingalAgcni-
ictmai
Generated by Netrrea Inc. [crrArchive
I -DallY ArchiveIJohen-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoie.cn-areliving,o
-netrnail]
2019-08.210933:10 EDT Exported neunainetma am:lurid Exposed by netmainetrnaincimaa
2119-08-21093637 EDT Exported netmainetmainetnuil Exported by netnradnettrail.netrrrail
2019-08.21093801 EDT Exported meantime:mid nenaa il Exported by neuminetmaincimail
2119-08.21139&14 EDT Exported neunai.nctinailactillai: Exported by netmainetmaiLnettnail
2019.09-0718:1306 EDT Exported neumineuna anemia:I Exported by neunainettnianctimil
2020-05-19 1535:31 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2120-05.1914x1136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 13420
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/22 10:44
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Doesn't look like he was seen yet.
Psy.D.
Chief Psychologist
U.S. Department of Justice/
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Office:
Fax:
E-mail:
>>> 7/19/2019 9:25 AM >>>
Can ou lease have him seen for his request for 7 I understand he has not expressed
any oncerns in the past, but he is facing the death penalty and is currently in SHU facing
disciplinary charges. Thanks!
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
fi
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
he found a dead rodent in his bed. Apparently he accidently smothered it while sleeping. The lights in
the cell are fre uentl off durin the day and on at ni ht. Nick has asked to be given medication to
. His
Page 13421
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci , NY 11530
[F]
www.barketeostein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Bark
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
PM
; Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if ou are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/201911:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Page 13422
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the dosing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci NY 11530
-
M
Barket Epsteinsom
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) < > wrote:
Page 13423
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
To:
Cc:
tonyricco
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket <
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:22 PM
(USANYS)
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
- M
Barket Fpctein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
>;
Leisenrin
(USANYS)< >
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal I. As a result, the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to , and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket <
Cc: ton
(USANYS
>;
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
›- Aida Leisenring
Page 13424
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
f.
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
Page 13425
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitigations specialists also waited 2 hours. Aida and I were Lucky in that we
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
Page 13426
message and all its attachments
Page 13427
Properties
Property Value
Message ID 5D35938B.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316D.1.6 7F1.1
Message Path xml7s1a3m)V5D35938B.NYMDOM 1.NYMADM 1.100 .17031€0.1.67F1.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 43FDB000-0C0C-00004B6E-1B003A002D00
Reply To
Text
1 1To
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tartagrame
Scheduled date 2019-07-22 104427
Creation date 2019-07-22 104427
Modified date 2019-07-22 122809
Delis e red date 2019-07-22104428
Message size 15192
Attachments size 31906
Total size 47109
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.hun
Name TEXT.htm
Content II)
5D35938B.NYMDOMINYMADMI.200.2000051.1.F
34CD.1@45D35938B.NYMDOMILNYMADM1.100.1
7031613.1.67F1.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type Ede
Size 31906
Date 2019-07-22 064429
CA 8176c8.5cOdba07c2c6de7a82,829a49a
Hash A2CA2123B018360ABCPW355F28FCE4D8CDEC5F8 CA59AA74D6DDB2ADCB38E72/325CF8P4A
Recipients 5
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 275(X A Do-o9CA.0000a8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient I ype User
Reclpieni
Display Name
Email
UUID 835B5E40-I1C6-00:10-B3D6-FE66A7708950
Distribution lype CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
till D A4423FD0-0824-0000-B58A-448148E79444
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
I. l II) 6FECI5F0-25C8-0000-8293-9E01000038CF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 51,C1- I I('0.(191)4-000O-BBEI-7C3A87597621
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived false
Page 13428
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened hue
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type Intros
Return notification alien opened fake
Return notification alien deleted fake
Return notification alien
completed false
Return notification alien declined fake
Return notification Mien
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D35938B.NYMDOMLNY1s4ADMIA00.I703I6DA.67FIA@k7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.010.1@l6
Source received
Class Public
Account
Location ID
MI
Class Name GW.MFSSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder MaBbox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.I.0.1@l6
Name Mailbox
Type Mailbox
System true
Share 'Ewe NotSharcd
Page 13429
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08-01 172507 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Archive)
Job.cn-lcbs.cn-GWOpenNodetn-archivingalAgcni-
ictmai
Generated by Netrre3 Inc. [crrArchive
I -DallY ArchiveIJohen-Jobs.en-GWOpenNoie.cn-areliving.o
-netrnail]
2019-08.210933:10 EDT Exported neunainetmaanetnviii Exposed by netmainetrnaincimaa
2119-08-21093637 EDT Exported netmainetmainetnuil Exported by netnradnettrail.netrrrail
2019-08.21093801 EDT Exported neunainetinail nenna il Exported by neuminetmainetmail
2119-08.21139&14 EDT Exported neunai.nctinailnclillai: Exported by netmainetmaiLnettnail
2019.09-0718:1306 EDT Exported neuminetnuancanall Exposed by neunainettnianctimil
2020-05-19 1535:31 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2120-05.1914x1136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 13430
Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
From
To
Date 2019/07/19 07:22
Subject: Fwd: RE: Tartaglione
Attachments: TEXT.htm
Good morning all,
Per the below list of complaints please look into the following:
Facilities - can you look into the alleged leak in his cell, no. 201-106?
Safety - can you let me know the last time 9 South had pest control?
SIS - can you follow up with FBI on his incident report? Can you also look into whether the alleged rodent
on his bed might have been his cellmate accusing him of being an snitch?
SHU - can you swap out his books? Can you check on the lights in his cell? Was his paper discovery
located? Is he claiming he is still missing any?
Thanks all,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
fria l
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/19/2019 6:39 AM > »
Good morning,
I was able to see Nick last night. Thank you for arranging a room for him. He reports that he has not
had his hearing yet and the conditions in his cell remain the same. He was told by a guard that he is
going to be denied visits, phone calls and commissary for a year, in addition to being held in SHU for 90
days. Water is constantly leaking into the cell, which he now shares with another inmate. He still has
not received the updated discovery hard drive. He has only been given three short books which he
read several times, despite having new books sent to him (we have the receipts indicating that MCC has
received them). He does not have the paper discovery he had prior to being placed in SHU. Recently,
hp fni Intl a ripari rndont in hic hod Annarontiv hp arrirlontly cmnthprpri it whilo cippnino Tho liohtc in
Page 13431

Yr. I • t -... 0
the cell are frequently off during the day and on at night.
I understand that the cell phone justifies some sanction, but the troubling conditions in the cell should
be rectified. Lastly, I hope the guard who told Nick about his punishment is mistaken.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Cit , NY 11530
[P] [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may otherwise be privileged or
confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received
this transmittal in error; any review, dissemination, distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error, please notify us immediately by
telephone or email and immediately delete this message and all its attachments
From:
Sent: Monday, Jul
To: Bruce Barket;
Cc: tonyricco
[mailto
15. 2019 3:48 PM
Subject: Re: Tartaglione
Bruce,
; Aida Leisenring;
My apologies for the delay yesterday. The institution was short-staffed, and they were actively
finding personnel to process you in the lobby and to oversee the attorney conference room area. If you
experience any delays on the weekends, please ask to speak to the Duty Officer and/or the Operations
Lieutenant as they were aware of the visit and could have expedited your admission to the facility. They also
could have called me at home to resolve any issues. Likewise, if  are visiting during the week and we have
made arrangements to expedite your visits, please contact and me if there are any delays so we
can facilitate matters immediately. Please also let us know when you meet in an attorney conference room
that has a non-working computer so that we can have Computer Services fix it expeditiously. We continue to
work to address Mr. Tartaglione's complaints, so please let us know if there are outstanding issues that have
not yet been appropriately addressed.
Thank you,
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/14/201911:55 AM > »
While I do appreciate your effort, for reasons that aren't entirely clear to me, the personal seem unable to
allow Nick reasonable access to his lawyers.
Today, I arrived at the faculty at 7:56. I was told "not until 8:00" by the guard in the booth. At 8:00 I was told
"we will let you know. We are waiting for relief." I waited outside for 35 minutes.
Page 13432
(I am lucky to be healthy, as I was forced to stand because the waiting area was inexplicably locked). I finally
got to see Nick just after 9:00, less than 30 minutes before the cut off to leave before the count.
Unfortunately, this is not a recent problem. Long delays, unexpected closures of the facility and lockdowns
have all occurred frequently since Mr. Tartaglione was first arrested, over 3 years ago and have significantly
hampered our ability to communicate with our client, who is facing the death penalty.
Because the BOP has chosen to monitor emails and phone calls between Lawyers and their clients, we are
forced to meet with Nick to discuss every aspect of the case, even relatively benign things that typically
could be handled with a quick call or a short email.
As you know, I have been writing about these problems, speaking to you and bringing the issues to the
attention of Judge Karas over the course of the years of Nick's Pretrial detention.
On a personal note, this was a particularly frustrating day because I again took time away from my family on
a Sunday to drive into NYC with anticipation that would be able to leave at 9:30. Today's trip, as you know,
was necessary because Ms. Leisenring and I arrived on Thursday at 7:55 but were not permitted to see our
client until 9:30.
These obstacles to meeting with our client are systemic and do not appear to be correctable without
significant changes in how the BOP operates the faculty. The rooms for visiting have computers that are
frequently broken, there are not enough rooms to accommodate the number of lawyers attempting to see
their clients (several hours of delays are routine for any lawyer who doesn't arrive before 8:00), the staff
frequently delays the opening of legal visiting but never extends the closing time, once in a room, a lawyer
can expect to wait for their client to be produced from 10-15 minutes to hours and of course at times the
facility simply closes and refuses visits all together.
The USA's office has advised that the Marshal's have refused our request to transfer Mr. Tartaglione to
Nassau County and despite my inquiry about other options, have not offered any alternative.
The conditions under which Mr. Tartaglione Are being held continue to be problematic, to say the least.
There is again water in his cell and the other issues, which I have written about a number of times but won't
detail again here, persist.
I don't think anyone understands what it is like to be locked in a windowless box all day, everyday with
limited human contact and virtually no contact with family or friends. People can't survive like that for very
long. Cell phone or not, the conditions in SHU are deplorable. Discussing the issues surrounding his
complex death penalty case has become nearly impossible. Whether intentional or accidental, the MCC is
breaking Mr. Tartaglione's ability to defend the charges and prepare for trial.
I am open to any solution
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
- M
Barket Epstein.com
Page 13433
On Jul 12, 2019, at 4:01 PM, (USANYS) ‹ > wrote:
I just spoke with the Marshals, and they advised that it is not feasible to move him to
Nassau.
Assistant United States Attorney
From: Bruce Barket
Sent: Frida , Jul 12, 2019 3:22 PM
To: USANYS
Cc:
ton
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Thanks for the update. Any word on having him moved?
Bruce Barket
Barket, Epstein, Kearon, Aldea & LoTurco
666 Old Country road
Garden Ci , NY 11530
-
-M
Barket Epstein.com
On Jul 12, 2019, at 3:17 PM,
wrote:
(USANYS)< >
Bruce — With respect to the hard drive for Mr. Tartaglione, your office
correct) sent it to our White Plains office but addressed the package to
(instead of our paralegal As a result the security
officers in White Plains sent the hard drive downtown to and we
had to then interoffice it back up to White Plains, which is what caused the
delay. We are working on loading all of the discovery now.
Assistant United States Attorney
From:
Sent: Friday, July 12, 2019 3:13 PM
To: Bruce Barket <
Cc: ton .< >; Aida Leisenring
(USANYS) < >.
(USANYS1
Page 13434
Subject: Re: Tartaglione conditions/visits
Good afternoon Bruce,
We apologize for the delays you experienced yesterday. We have spoken to
the SHU Lieutenant and have received assurances he will have staff bring him
to attorney conference in advance of your future meetings to allow him to
review discovery until you get there. He will extend the same courtesy to the
other members of your defense team with appropriate advance notice.
The SHU Lieutenant is meeting with Mr. Tartaglione today to discuss his
personal property, including but not limited to his books and legal work, as
well as recreation and law library access. Policy ordinarily limits inmates to
having only 5 books in their possession, in both general population and in
SHU. The SHU Lieutenant reviewed his books and advised he can maintain
five in his cell and seventeen in reserve in his stored personal property, but
that the other one hundred and fifty-one books would have to be mailed
home. Mr. Tartaglione will be informed of this and given the opportunity to
choose which books to keep. The SHU Lieutenant reports that Mr.
Tartaglione was provided his legal work other than the hard drives that are
currently in the Education Department, which will be brought to SHU to be
maintained there for his review while housed there. If there is any legal work
still missing, please advise so it can be located.
Regarding recreation, I am told he has not responded in the affirmative when
recreation is offered in the morning, but the SHU Lieutenant will remind him
of those procedures. Likewise, the SHU Lieutenant will go over law library
request procedures which involve him submitted written requests to use the
SHU law library.
I will update you as soon as I get more information.
Thank you,
Supervisory Staff Attorney
CLC New York
Metropolitan Correctional Center
150 Park Row
New York, New York 10007
Pi=
> » Bruce Barket < > 7/12/2019 6:16 AM > »
Good morning,
First, thank you for the time you have devoted to both speaking to us about
these issues and the work you have put in trying to alleviate the problems.
Unfortunately, despite your efforts the problems with the conditions Nick
endures and the difficulty in visiting him persist.
Page 13435
Aida and I met with Nick yesterday, for only about 20-30 minutes. Although
we arrived at the facility at 7:55 and although was kind enough to
set up a room for us, Nick was not brought down until almost 9:30. We were
allowed upstairs at about 8:15, just when the guard for the room had just
arrived . This is a frequent problem. It seems that room is often not staffed
on time. So, when lawyers arrive at 8:00 they get a room, but have to wait
until that guard arrives. This is particularly troubling on the weekends when
there is a 10:00 count and you have to either stay until 11:00 or get out by
9:30. Yesterday the officer in the room told us it would "be a while" before
inmates from SHU would be brought down. Indeed it was "a while" as we sat
for over an hour. We left just before 10:00 and were both late for our next
appointment, mine a hearing in state court. We were not able to cover the
ground we needed to with Nick and now have to return in the next few days
when I fear the process will repeat itself.
This week several members of the defense team have waited hours to see
Nick. On Monday our investigator waited 2 hours and on Tuesday one of our
mitigations specialists also waited 2 hours. Aida and I were Lucky in that we
only waited about 75 minutes. We simply cannot effectively represent our
client with these kind of delays.
I believe we delivered a hard drive to the USA's office over a week ago. Nick
tells us that he has not yet received it. Further, when he was moved to cell
without water on the floor, the little discovery he did have, was "lost." He
has never been given the document I previously mentioned, work product
created by our office on which he made notes. It was out on his bed when
he the cell phone was seized.
Nick still hasn't been given any of the books he had nor has he received the
books recently mailed to him and received by the facility. He now has a cell
mate, someone to talk to, which has improved his emotional state, but he
should have reading material and access to his discovery and legal work.
I understand that other than visits, Nick has been locked in his cell 24 hours a
day without time for recreation or to go to the library. If this is part of his
punishment, it seems harsh.
Again, I know that Nick is in SHU because of the cell phone, but he is still
entitled to humane conditions, reading material and reasonable access to his
legal team.
Bruce A. Barket, Esq.
Barket Epstein Kearon Aldea & LoTurco, LLP
666 Old Country Road , Ste. 700
Garden Ci NY 11530
[P1 [F]
www.barketepstein.com
This transmittal may be a confidential attorney client communication or may
otherwise be privileged or confidential. If it is not clear that you are the intended
recipient, you are hereby notified that you have received this transmittal in error;
any review. dissemination. distribution or copying of this transmittal is strictly
Page 13436
prohibited. If you suspect that you have received this communication in error,
please notify us immediately by telephone or email and immediately delete this
message and all its attachments
Page 13437
Properties
Property Value
Message 1 D 5D316F9D.NYMDOM I.NYMADM1.100.170316D. 1.6 4D1.I
Message Path xmlrtsialmW5D316F9D.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.170316D.1.64D1.1.xml
From
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACF31EA7575
Reply To
Text
I I I I I
9 I I To
I
Cc
Subject Fwd: RE: Tastaglime
Scheduled date 201947-19072205
Creation date 2019-07-19072205
Modified date 2019-07-19072226
Delivered date 201907-19072206
Message sin 15216
Attachments sin 31869
Total sin 47096
Attachments I
Attachment TEXT.hon
Name TEXT.hun
Content ID
5D316F9D.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.200.20000A0.1.1
456131.1@45:5D316F9D.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.
1703103.1.64D1.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI-100 .0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 31869
Date 2019-07-19032158
CA 15ccM11:419ee49299d938142de 10219
Hash 55B7D3EE9B031E6IEDID733CC525BIB62C2D91B7 475AD3BBCEA5421304757D5B0F7D0A46
Recipients 17
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-1ACFMEA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmCiroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID tflil351.40- I I ('6.0000-53D6-FE66AT708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
1.11.111) 2B6B0E90-13FD-0000-8AF7-AE48A5168176
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID A4423FD0-0824-0000.B58A-448148E79444
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID AF0775F0-13FD-0000-BBA8-4AEAF7774805
Distribution Tspe TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Page 13438
Email
(W11) 43EDBC00-0C0C-0000-886E- I B003ACO2D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGrxmpMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
2DDA9D304006-0000-987C-OCDSBB22F09A UUID
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemeoupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID E414F4A0-0DAA-0003-9C89-D2189E2EIF35
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 610E9350-01i4F-0000-AB39-FSOF2A59A443
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGrouptslember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 9D77 i I2DO- !EX • I -0300-A989-020000005400
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SyNtemOnoupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DA97490-I I86-0C00-974D-D02E22850878
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 028 I 7A50- I•102-00C04309B•BCAADF980A9I
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
till D 4237CDCO-I407-0000•A820-84D2I20084D2
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Sr:it:DC
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 6FECISF0-25C8-0000-13293-9E0103003SCF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID ISA6SEI0-0C33-0000-A3E7-68A6064ISCAD
Distribution Type CC
Recipient Type User
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID or•il•-It • i 0- 132u0000-SECI.2F2I67RMDCC
Distribution Type TO
Reci 'entrry • S slen ember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Page 13439
LIVID 9F550ED0-0113A-0000-B7F5-92775C3901BF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type User
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated fake
Archived fake
Read true
Deleted fake
Opened true
Completed fake
Security Normal
Box type inbox
Return notification %Oen opened false
Return notification u he n deleted fake
Return notification %%hen
completed fake
Return notification uhe n declined fake
Return notification uhen
accepted fake
Archie Version 5.3
Internal II) 5D316F9D.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.170316D.1.64DIA@IILNYMDOMLNYMADM1.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Source received
Class Public
Account
Location II)
MI
Class Name CW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Maabox
ID 7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.1.0.1@l6
Name Mail=
Type Mailbox
System true
Share Type NotShared
Page 13440
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2019-08.01172635 EDT Created
en=Arehive Agent_I-Daly Archive)
Job.en-lebs.cn-GWOpenNodetn-archiyingoMgcni-
Ictmai
Generated by Netrrea Inc. [crrArchiye
I -DallY ArchiveIJohen-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNoicen-archiving,o
nictrnai]
2019-08-21 09:33:16 EDT Expand netnuinetmaanetorni Exponed by netmainctrnainctmaa
2119-08-21093&39 EDT Exported netmainettoadmetnuil Exported by netnradnetmail.netrrrail
201948-21 093802 EDT Exponed nconainennal nenaail Exponed by neuminetmainetmail
2119-08.21133&14 EDT Exported neunai.nctuval. actin:HI Exported by netmainetmaanetmail
2019.09-0718:1307 EDT Exported neumineunaanenuall Exponed by neunainonnineuma
2020-05-19 15:35:31 EDT Tag B0P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM1 Responsive
212045.1914x1136 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Flagged
Page 13441
emergency Code EPSTEIN, JEFFREY EDWARD Reg #: 76318-054
From
To
Date 2019/08/10 08:12
Subject: emergency Code EPSTEIN, JEFFREY EDWARD Reg #: 76318-054
Attachments: TEXT.htm, ClinicalEncounterFinalizeGetDocument.fac es.pdf
Respectfully,
Clinical Nurse Specialist
Department Of Justice
Bureau Of Prisons
MCC New York
150 Park Row
New York, NY 10007
Page 13442
Properties
Property Value
NlessagelD 5D4E7C68.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100.16B6F30.1.F E98. I
Message Path soli AlaiboOD4E7C68.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .16B6F30.1.FE98.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
QUID C4367090-0E73-0000-BBEI-DODC22E57I32
Reply To
Text
I I i
i To
Subject emergency Code EPSTEIN. JEFFREY EDWARD Reg It 76318-054
Scheduled date 2019-08-1008:1223
Citation date 2019-08-1008:1223
Modified date 2019-08-19 095441
Delivered date 2019-08-1008:1225
Message size 169
Attachments size 6074
Total size 6254
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.htm
Name TF—XT.him
Content ID
5D4E7C67.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.200.2000074.1.3
COC2. 1®45:5D4E7C68.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100. I
6B6F30.I.FE98.1@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100. 0.1.0.10116
Is Inline false
Type fie
Size 1771
Date 2019-08-1004:12:20
CA d009714013e8e09e2d5d8d4000731:017814
Has h 4085D472FD60CD9737688915515C1784644e4DE6 C62725323984023DD894CA9593A20F63
Attachment CinicaEncomcrFinalizeGetDoctnent.fac cs.pdf
Name CiricalEncounterFinalizreetDocunentfac es.pdf
Content ID
5D4E7C67.NYNIDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000074.1.3
COC3.1®45:5D4E7C68.NYMDOMENYMADMI.100.1
6B6F30.I.FE98. I@1:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADM Liao. oto.i@l6
Is Inline false
Type file
Size 4303
Date 2019-08.1004:1129
CA 63184dd2a3e5aee003013670bea5b8a69
Has h CE6F2494EF2EA2DEBD0578E8C78D9C98D3351BBC 3763BASEAAC270563CIFIA3E8924F4FA
Recipients 14
Recipient
Display Name
Email
QUID 8AAA2680-04F7-0000-B36E-EBIC662IE5FD
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type System( iroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CLAD 523A6DA0-05043-0000-AB45-08IFB2ODDDD7
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'type SystenglroupMeinber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
LIVID DEE72A30-131-1-0000-B09B-BCAADF980A91
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type
Recipient
innGroupMentber
Display Name
Email
UU1D I EACBC40-0394-00004306F-2AE2B12AAA87
Distribution Type TO
Page 13443
Recipient Type SystemGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
WAD 4271E520-0DA7-0000-BI00-D84E73054BF5
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
CUD DC965EE04N35-0000-9442-60DF58F6B922
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroupMcmber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
MD 2DDA9D30.1006.0000.9870.OCD8BB22F09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystcmGroupMetreer
Recipient
Display Name
Email
ill'ID 867CDEF60DA7.ODOU97CF-7AB098665147
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type Syaenairoupalentber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
Oil 0 6121 D870-OF4c-OOOO-B42F-9201000038CF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SysternGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 028 I7A504402-0000-B09B-IICAADF980A91
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SyacmCcoupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 4D7ek6E0- l7O8-00uo-977l -000000100002
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemCroup
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UM D B5C7D740-6BAA-0072-A4A9-0C0000000000
Distribution Type TO
Recipient 'iype S tcmGroupMcmber
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 863I0I404800-00C0-646D-000000000000
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SystemCanupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UCH) 9F550EDO-Ol DA-0000-B7F5-92775C390I BF
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type SysternCroupMember
Expire 0
Delay delivery until 0
Delegated false
Archived fake
Read u-uc
Deleted lake
Page 13444
Opened true
Completed false
Security Normal
Box type Inbox
Return notification ashen opened fake
Re turn notification 'then deleted fake
Return notification .hen
completed fake
Return notification 'then declined fake
Re turn notification ashen
accepted fake
Archive Version 5.3
Internal ID 5D4E7C6&NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.16B6F30.I.F E9&I®ll.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100.0.I.0.1@l6
Source received
Class Public
Account POLADMI.POLDOMI
Location ID IS.108427b85 I 8
Class Name GW.MESSAGE.MAIL
Enclosing Folders I
Folder Mailbox
ID 7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.I00.0.I.O.l@I6
Name Mains
Type Mailbox
System true
Share Type NotSlured
Page 13445
Audits
Date Action Auditor Note
2119-08.1917:4048 EDT Created
en=Archive Agent_2-Zero Day
Archive4.cn-Jobs.cn-GWOpenNode.cn-archiv
hg.o=netmail
Generated by Neinuil Inc. [crrArchive
Agent 2-Zero Day
ArchisTetlen-Jobs.arGWOpenNoie.en-archis
ingo-netritii]
2019-08.211413053 EDT Exported netimiln:timilnetmil Exported by netnii il. netim il. ninon il
2119-09-180931133 EDT Exported netmailneunailnetmail Exported by netno il.cc uni il.11etIlla a
202045-19 152839 EDT Tag 130P01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
202005.19152931 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
202045.1915:17135 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOMI Responsive
2120-05-1915:18133 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Responsive
212045-19143433 EDT Tag BOP01703.MXRADMI.MXRDOM I Eligged
Page 13446
Mail Attachment
ChnicalEncounterFinalizeGetDocument.faces.pdf
Page 13447
Bureau of Prisons
Health Services
Clinical Encounter
Inmate Name: EPSTEIN, JEFFREY EDWARD Reg #: 76318-054
Date of Birth: 01/20/1953 Sex: M R e: WHITE Facility: NYM
Encounter Date: 08/10/2019 07:25 Provider: RN Unit: Z04
Emergency Code - Resuscitation Event encounter performed at Special Housing Unit.
SUBJECTIVE:
Emergency Note Provider:
Team Members:
Provider
RN
Bole
Team/Code Leader RN
Code Events:
Type Value Date
CPR Compressions 08/10/2019 06:35
EKG/Monitor Lifepak 08/10/2019 06:39
No shock advised
CPR Compressions 08/10/2019 06:40
Oxygen 15 L 08/10/2019 06:47
IV Access Peripheral IV 08/10/2019 06:48
18 g Left AC
Airway Endotracheal Tube
ET Tube 7.5 24CM to L Lip line Placed by Paramedics
08/10/2019 07:08
Medications Epinephrine 1mg IV 08/10/2019 07:10
Epinephrine 3 doses and Sodium bicarb 2 doses administered by paramedics
CPR Compressions 08/10/2019 07:11
Medications Sodium Bicarbonate 1 mEa/kg IV 08/10/2019 07:11
IV Fluids Normal Saline 0.9% 1000 ml 08/10/2019 07:12
Medications Epinephrine 1mg IV 08/10/2019 07:13
CPR Compressions 08/10/2019 07:14
Medications Sodium Bicarbonate 1 mEa/kg IV 08/10/2019 07:14
Medications Epinephrine 1mg IV 08/10/2019 07:16
CPR Compressions 08/10/2019 07:17
Comments:
Responded to a body alarm at 0635 for medical emergency on 9S, Upon arrival Inmate was received on the floor of his
cell unresponsive with CPR in progress by correctional officers, Inmate was Cold, with circumferential Bruising around 
the
neck and posterior mottling, Pupils Fixed and dilated, No Palpable pulses, Call place for EMS, CPR Continued, AED
Placed No shock advised, CPR Continued, inmate transported to HSU treatment room with CPR in progress, 18g hep lock
to L AC, O2 15 Lt ViA BVM, Pulse Check NO SHOCK advised. EMS and Paramedics arrived 0656, Placed on cardiac
monitor asystole Resumed CPR, Inmate was intubated by Medics, 3 Rounds of Epinephrine administered, Pulse Check
asystole, Inmate was transported to Local ER with CPR in progress.
OBJECTIVE:
Exam:
General
Appearance
Yes: Unconscious
Generated 08'102019 08:10 by RN Bureau of Prisons - NYM Page 1 of 2
Inmate Name: EPSTEIN, JEFFREY EDWARD Reg #: 76318-054
Date of Birth: 01/20/1953 Sex: M R e: WHITE Facility: NYM
Encounter Date: 08/10/2019 07:25 Provider: RN Unit: Z04
Exam:
ASSESSMENT:
Cardiac Arrest
PLAN:
New Consultation Requests:
Consultation/Procedure  Target Date Scheduled Target Date Priority  Translator  Language
Emergency Room 08/10/2019 08/10/2019 Emergent No
Subtype:
AMBULANCE
Reason for Request:
Cardiac arrest with CPR in progress
Copay Required:No Cosign Required: Yes
Telephone/Verbal Order: No
Completed by RN on 08/10/2019 08:10
Requested to be cosigned by MD.
Cosign documentation will be displayed on the following page.
Generated 08/10/2019 08:10 by RN Bureau of Prisons - NYM Page 2 of 2
Updated Timeline -Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
From
To
Date 2019/08/10 17:35
Subject: Updated Timeline-Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Attachments: TEXT.htm, Epstein, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-054_1.docx
Please see the attached.
Thank you
Page 13450
Properties
Propertj Value
MessagelD 5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.100.1686F30.1.F EAE I
Message Path xn1VMabox/5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.100 .16B6F30.I.FEAE.I.xml
From
Display Name
Email
CI ID 9D77B2D0.19CI-0000.A9894200000058D0
Reply To
Tem
To
Subject Updated Trnetine-Epstein. Jeffrey Edward. Reg. No. 73618-054_1
Scheduled date 2019-08-10173534
Creation date 2019-08.10173534
Modified date 20194840 173538
Delis e red date 2019-08.10173535
Message size 39
Attachments size 15171
Total size 15221
Attachments 2
Attachment TEXT.Iim
Name TEXT.linn
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOM I.NYMADMI.200.200093& 1.9
E92E-1®45:5D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADM 1. 100. I
6B6F343.1.FEAE I ®1:7.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100. 0.1.0.1@l6
Is Inline false
TIP? ft
Silt 195
Date 2019-08-10133527
CA 8b501093b3c1a136688379d41d020dcb
(lash 88FD52.5778E7BEA2A693564A702F79093B2DFCB5 ESEHE372D5I535EB222E155C7E8C818
Attachment Epstcb. Jeffrey Edward Reg. No. 736113454_1.docx
Name Epsteir, Jeffrey Edward, Reg. No. 73618-0541.docx
Content ID
5D4F0066.NYMDOMI.NYMADM1.200.2000038.1.9
E92F.1®455D4F0066.NYMDOMLNYMADMI.100. I
6B6F30.I.FEAElgfil:7.NYMDOMI.NYMADMI.103. 0.1.0.1Q116
Is 1nline fake
Type fde
Size 14976
Date 2019-08.10133431
CA 6336229fd9335015215fda865bcdl 34
Hash CDFIII9C5A667C8DACOOMA1742306DEC36065E82I 565F62D6ACOB72B5FAIITDEDEB99D109
Recipients 8
Recipient —
Display Name
Email
UUID 2750CADO-09CA-0000-A8F4-IACF31EA7575
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S . tem(' mbar
Recipient
Displaj Name
Email
UU ID 835B5EAO-I1C6-0000-B3D6FF-66A7708950
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S mGroupMember
Recipient
Display Name
Email
U LID 43FDB000-0O0C-0000.8B6E-IB003A002D00
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S • mbcr
Recipient
Display Name
Email
UUID 2DDA9D301006-00:13-987C-OCDSBB22F09A
Distribution Type TO
Recipient Type S to Member
Recipient
Page 13451
EFTA01088484 (Jmail)
 [tech] Valar Ventures contract
(inferred date: 2026-01-07)
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
nwmc 41. 4
4161161114 vt
Table of Contents
Page
ARTICLE 1 NAME, PURPOSE AND OFFICES OF PARTNERSHIP 1
1.1 Name 1
1.2 Purpose  1
1.3 Principal Office  1
1.4 Registered Agent and Office 1
ARTICLE 2 TERM OF PARTNERSHIP 1
2.1 Term 1
2.2 Events Affecting a Member of the General Partner 2
2.3 Events Affecting a Limited Partner of the Partnership 2
2.4 Events Affecting the General Partner 2
ARTICLE 3 NAME AND ADMISSION OF PARTNERS 2
3.1 Name and Address 2
3.2 Admission of Additional Partners 2
3.3 Removal of the General Partner 3
ARTICLE 4 CAPITAL ACCOUNTS. CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS AND
NONCONTRIBUTING PARTNERS 4
4.1 Capital Accounts 4
4.2 Capital Contributions of the Limited Partners 4
4.3 Capital Contributions of the General Partner 6
4.4 Acquisition of an Additional Interest by the General Partner 6
4.5 Noncontributing Partners 6
4.6 Suspension Period 10
ARTICLE 5 PARTNERSHIP ALLOCATIONS 11
5.1 Allocation of Profit or Loss 11
5.2 Allocation of Ordinary Income and Ordinary Loss 13
5.3 Reallocation of Contingent Losses 13
5.4 Special Allocations 4-314
5.5 Regulatory Allocations 4.314
5.6 Income Tax Allocations 4415
ARTICLE 6 MANAGEMENT FEE; PARTNERSHIP EXPENSES 4415
6.1 Management Fee 4415
6.2 Expenses -1417
r.
t22a7aulvl
176116014 vl
Table of Contents (Cont'd)
Page
ARTICLE 7 WITHDRAWALS BY AND DISTRIBUTIONS TO THE PARTNERS
4318
7.1 Interest 4318
7.2 Withdrawals by the Partners 4318
73 Partners' Obligation to Repay or Restore 4-718
7A Mandatory Distributions 1-718
73 Discretionary Distributions and Rules Regarding Distributions 1819
7.6 Withholding Obligations 20
ARTICLE 8 MANAGEMENT DUTIES AND RESTRICTIONS 21
8.1 Management 21
8.2 No Control by the Limited Partners; No Withdrawal 2422
8.3 Existing Funds; Follow-On Funds; Parallel Funds un
8.4 Investment Opportunities and Conflicts of Interest 23
ARTICLE 9 INVESTMENT REPRESENTATION AND TRANSFER OF
PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS 27
9.1 Investment Representation of the Limited Partners 27
9.2 Qualifications of the Limited Partners 2228
9.3 Transfer by General Partner 2228
9A Transfer by Limited Partner 2-728
9.5 Requirements for Transfer 28
9.6 Substitution as a Limited Partner 2829
9.7 Expenses of Transfer 29
ARTICLE 10 DISSOLUTION AND LIQUIDATION OF THE PARTNERSHIP 2930
10.1 Extension of Partnership Term 2930
10.2 Early Termination of the Partnership 2.930
10.3 Winding Up Procedures 30
10.4 Payments in Liquidation 3031
10.5 Return of Excess Distributions 31
ARTICLE 11 FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING, REPORTS AND MEETINGS 3233
11.1 Financial Accounting; Fiscal Year 3233
11.2 Supervision; Inspection of Books 3233
11.3 Quarterly Reports 3233
ti2u7aulvi
1761160,
Formatted: Default Paragraph Font
Table of Contents (Cont'd)
Page
11.4 Annual Report; Financial Statements of the Partnership 4233
11.5 Website Based Reporting 1233
11.6 Annual Meeting 3334
11.7 Tax Returns 3334
11.8 Tax Matters Partner 3334
11.9 Partnership Funds 3435
ARTICLE 12 VALUATION; ADVISORY COMMITTEE 3435
12.1 Valuation 3435
12.2 Advisory Committee 3536
ARTICLE 13 PARTNERS SUBJECT TO SPECIAL REGULATION 3536
13.1 ERISA Partners 3536
13.2 Governmental Plan Partners 3637
13.3 Private Foundation Partners 3438
ARTICLE 14 CERTAIN DEFINITIONS 3438
14.1 Accounting Period 3438
14.2 Adjusted Asset Value 3438
14.3 Adjusted Capital Account Balance 38
14.4 Affiliate 3839
14.5 Capital Account 3839
14.6 Capital Commitment; Committed Capital 3839
14.7 Code 3839
14.8 Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss 3839
14.9 Reserved 39
14.10 Marketable; Marketable Securities; Marketability 39
14.11 Nonmarketable Securities 3940
14.12 Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss 31;140
14.13 Partnership Percentage 394A
14.14 Percentage in Interest; Majority in Interest 394A
14.15 Prime Rate 3940
14.16 Profit or Loss 3940
14.17 Regulated Partner 4041
Formatted: Default Paragraph Font
1220,1;1,1*i
L76116014
Table of Contents (Cont'd)
Page
14.18 Securities 4041
14.19 Securities Act 4041
14.20 Short-Term Securities 4041
14.21 Thiel Persons 4041
14.22 Treasury Regulations 4041
ARTICLE 15 OTHER PROVISIONS 4441
15.1 Governing Law 4041
15.2 Limitation of Liability of the Limited Partners 41
15.3 Exculpation 4442
15.4 Indemnification 4143
15.5 Arbitration 4344
15.6 Execution of Documents 4445
15.7 Other Instruments and Acts 4445
15.8 Binding Agreement 4445
15.9 Notices; Electronic Transmission of Report 4445
15.10 Power of Attorney 4445
15.11 Amendment 4446
15.12 Entire Agreement 4446
15.13 Titles; Subtitles 4647
15.14 Partnership Name 4647
15.15 Confidentiality 4447
EXHIBIT A: Schedule of Partners A-I
Formatted: Default Paragraph Form
iv.
$2207(661v1
L76116014 vt
INDEX OF DEFINITIONS
Term Paragraph
Accounting Period 14.1
Act Preamble
Adjusted Asset Value 14.2
Adjusted Capital Account Balance 14.3
Administrator 15.5(a)
Advisory Committee 12.2
Affected Parties 15.15(a)
Affiliate 14.4
Affiliates Fund 8.3(c)
Affiliated Party 8.4(b)
After-Tax Distribution Amount I0.5(b)
Agreement Preamble
Annual Tax Amount 7.4(a)
Arbitration I5.5(a)
Arbitrator I5.5(a)
Capital Account 14.5
Capital Commitment 14.6
Carried Interest Distributions 10.5(b)
Cashless Portion 4.3
Claim 15.5(a)
Code 14.7
Commencement Date 2.1
Commitment Period 4.2(a)
Committed Capital 14.6
Confidential Information 15.15(a)
Contingent Loss 5.3(a)
Deemed Gain 14.8
Deemed Loss 14.8
Default Notice 4.5(b)
Defaulting Limited Partner 4.5(b)
Deemed Contribution Shortfall 10.5(d)
DOL Regulations 4.2(b)
ERISA 4.2(b)
ERISA Partner 13.1(a)
Fee Adjustment 6.1(cXii)
First Allocation Hurdle 5.1(b)
General Partner Preamble
Governmental Plan Partner 13.2
Indemnified Parties 15.4
Late Admission Charce
Limited Partners Preamble
Loss 14.16
Majority in Interest 14.14
Management Company 8.1
Management Fee 6.1(a)
Management Fee Percentage 6.1(b)
Managing Member 4.6(b)
v.
12247•1634.
1,6116015
Term Paragraph
Marketable 14.10
Marketable Securities 14.10
Marketability 14.10
Nonmarketable Securities 14.11
Optionees 4.5(b)(vii)
Optionor 4.5(b)(vii)
Ordinary Income 14.12
Ordinary Loss 14.12
Paragraph 10.5 Reapplication Amount 4.2(d)(iii)
Parallel Funds 8.3(c)
Partners 3.1
Partnership Preamble
Partnership Percentage 14.13
Percentage in Interest 14.14
Pooled Vehicle Partner I5.15(e)
Prime Rate 14.15
Prior Funds 8.3(aXii)
Private Foundation Partner 13.2
Profit 14.16
Regulated Partner 14.17
Regulatory Allocations 5.5(a)
Remaining Portion 4.5(b)(vii)(2)
Reporting Site 11.5
Restricted Exchange 8,4(1)
Second Allocation Hurdle 5.1(b)
Securities 14.18
Securities Act 14.19
Short-Tenn Securities 14.20
Side Letter 15.12
Special Purpose Investment Fund 8.4(a)
Subject Reports 11.5
Successor Fund 8.3(a)(iii)
Successor Fund Eligible Date 8.3(b)
Suspension Event 4.6(b)
Suspension Period 4.6(b)
Tax Payments 7.6(a)
Termination Date 2.1
Thiel Activities 15.3(d)
Thiel Persons 14.21
Treasury Regulations 14.22
Trigger Event 3.3(c)
UBTI 8.4(g)
VCOC 4.2(b)
VCOC Notice 4.2(b)
vi.
12207056.10
1,6116014 vl
VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT
This LIMITED PARTNERSHIP AGREF.MENT (the "Agreement") of VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP
(the 'Partnership") is made and entered into as of • by and among VALAR VENTURES GP III LLC. a
Delaware limited liability company (the "Genera( Partner"), and each investor who is identified as a
limited partner on EXHIBIT A and who is admitted to the Partnership as of such date (the "Limited
Partners"), who hereby form the Partnership pursuant to the provisions of the Delaware Revised Uniform
Limited Partnership Act (the "Act"), as follows:
ARTICLE 1
NAME, PURPOSE AND OFFICES OF PARTNERSHIP
1.1 Name. The name of the Partnership is VALAR GLOBAL FUND III LP. The affairs of the
Partnership shall be conducted under the Partnership name, or such other name as the General Partner may.
in its discretion, determine.

1.2 Purpose. The primary purpose of the Partnership is to provide a limited number of select
investors with the opportunity to realize long-term appreciation. generally from venture capital investments
in earlier-stage, high-growth technology companies as a result of direct, privately negotiated investments in
equity or equity-oriented securities of private and public companies. The general purposes of the
Partnership are to buy. sell. hold, and otherwise invest in Securities of every kind and nature and rights and
options with respect thereto, including, without limitation, stock. notes. bonds, debentures, and evidence of
indebtedness: to exercise all rights, powers. privileges. and other incidents of ownership or possession with
respect to Securities held or owned by the Partnership: to enter into, make, and perform all contracts and
other undertakings: and to engage in all activities and transactions as may be necessary. advisable, or
desirable to carry out the foregoing.

1.3 Principal Office. The principal office of the Partnership shall be at 915 Broadway. Suite
1101. New York, NY 10010. or such other place or places as the General Partner may from time to time
designate. The General Partner shall provide the Limited Partners with prompt written notice of any change
in the location of the Partnership's principal office.

1.4 Registered Agent and Office. The name of the registered agent for service of process of
the Partnership and the address of the Partnership's registered office in the State of Delaware shall be The
Corporation Trust Company. 1209 Orange Street. Wilmington. Delaware 19801. or such other agent or
office in the State of Delaware as the General Partner may from time to time designate.
ARTICLE 2
TERM OF PARTNERSHIP
2.1 Term. The term of the Partnership shall commence upon the date of the filing of the
Certificate of Limited Partnership of the Partnership with the office of the Secretary of State of the State of
Delaware. The term of the Partnership shall continue until the tenth anniversary of the date on which the
initial capital contribution is due (such date of the initial capital contribution being referred to herein as the
"Commencement Date" and such tenth anniversary being referred to as the "Termination Date"). unless
extended pursuant to paragraph 10.1 or sooner dissolved as provided in paragraph 10.2.
12/1)70561*i
1.161160I v1
2.2 Events Affecting a Member of the General Partner. Except as specifically provided in
paragraph 10.2. the death, bankruptcy. withdrawal. insanity, incompetency. temporary or permanent
incapacity. expulsion. removal, liquidation, dissolution. reorganization. merger. sale of all or substantially
all the stock or assets of, or other change in the ownership or nature of any member of the General Partner
shall not dissolve the Partnership.
2.3 Events Affecting a Limited Partner of the Partnership. The death. bankruptcy.
withdrawal, insanity. incompetency, temporary or permanent incapacity. liquidation, dissolution.
reorganization. merger. sale of all or substantially all the stock or assets of. or other change in the ownership
or nature of a Limited Partner shall not dissolve the Partnership.

2.4 Events Affecting the General Partner. Except as specifically provided in paragraph 10.2.
the withdrawal. bankruptcy. expulsion. resignation. removal. liquidation. dissolution. reorganization.
merger. sale of all or substantially all the stock or assets of. or other change in the ownership or nature of the
General Partner shall not constitute an "event of withdrawal" of the General Partner under the Act. and
upon the happening of any such event, the affairs of the Partnership shall be continued without dissolution
by the General Partner or any successor entity thereto.
ARTICLE 3
NAME AND ADMISSION OF PARTNERS
3.1 Name and Address. The name and address of the General Partner and each Limited
Partner (hereinafter the General Partner and the Limited Partners shall be referred to collectively as the
"Partners" and each individually as a "Partner"). the amount of such Partner's Capital Commitment to the
Partnership. and such Partner's Partnership Percentage are set forth on a separate and confidential EXHIBIT
A hereto. marked as EXHIBIT A-1 thru EXHIBIT A4 (with a separate EXHIBIT A for each Partner). The
General Partner shall cause EXHIBIT A to be amended from time to time to re fleet the admission of any new
Partner. the withdrawal or substitution of any Partner. the transfer of interests among Partners, receipt by
the Partnership of notice of any change of address of a Partner or the change in any Partner's Capital
Commitment or Partnership Percentage. An amended EXHIBIT A shall supersede any prior EXHIBIT A and
become a part of this Agreement. A copy of the most recent amended EXHIBIT A shall be kept on file at the
principal office of the Partnership.
3.2 Admission of Additional Partners.

(a) Except as provided in paragraphs 3.2(b). 4.5(b)(vii)(4) and 9.6, an additional
person may be admitted as a Partner only with the consent of the General Partner and Eighty Percent in
Interest of the Limited Partners.

(b) Notwithstanding subparagraph (a) above. additional persons may be admitted as
Limited Partners (or existing Limited Partners may increase their Capital Commitments) with the consent
of only the General Partner on or before the date that is six (6) months after the date hereof: provided that
the aggregate capital commitments to the Partnership and the Parallel Funds shall not exceed two hundred
and fifty million dollars ($250.000.000).

(c) Each additional person admitted as a Limited Partner subsequent to the date hereof
(and each existing Limited Partner that increases its Capital Commitment) shall (i) execute and deliver to
the Partnership a counterpart of this Agreement or otherwise take such actions as the General Partner shall
deem appropriate in order for such Limited Partner to become bound by the terms of this Agreement. and-(ii)
contribute that portion of its (or such) Capital Commitment which is equal to the portion of the respective
$22070561v1
rell6014 vl
Capital Commitments contributed to date by the Partnership's previously admitted Limited Partners, and
(iii) pay to the Partnership a "Late Admission Charge" (which shall be deemed Ordinary Income of the
Partnership and not be treated as a capital contribution) equal to interest on the amount contributed by such
Partner pursuant to the preceding clause Oil at an annual interest rate that is two hundred basis points (2.0%)
higher than the Prime Rate (determined as of the close of business on the date of such admission or
increase). compounded daily, from the dates) that such Partner would have been required to contribute
such amount if it had been admitted (or had such increased Capital Commitment) at the initial closing of the
Partnership: provided that this clause (iii) shall not apply to a Limited Partner admitted to the Partnership
(or allowed to increase its Capital Commitment) within ninety (90) days from the Commencement Date.
Limited Partners admitted to the Partnership after the date hereof will not be entitled to share in or be
goggled any Ordinary Income (including without limitation Late Admission °saws) accruing on or
prior to their admission date. At the election of the General Partner. any Late Admission Charge owed to
the Partnership by a Limited Partner may be paid to the Partnership through an offsetting reduction in such
Limited Partner's Capital Account balance.

(d) Upon the admission of any additional Limited Partner pursuant to this paragraph
3.2. the General Partner may. in its sole discretion, make a special distribution of all or a portion of the
initial contribution of capital made by such additional Limited Partner. Such distribution shall be made to
all Partners in accordance with Partnership Percentages (as adjusted to reflect the admission of such
additional Limited Partner) and shall be deemed to be a return of capital to such Partners: provided.
however, that such Partners shall be deemed, for the purposes of paragraph 4.2. not to have contributed the
amount of such distribution, and the amounts of their respective unfunded Capital Commitments shall be
increased accordingly.
3.3 Removal or the General Partner.

(a) Immediately following a Trigger Event (as defined below), the General Partner
shall provide notice to the Limited Partners of the Trigger Event, and at the election of Two-Thirds in
Interest of the Limited Partners, pursuant to a vote occurring during any time during the one hundred and
eighty (180) day period following such notice to the Limited Partners. the General Partner may be removed
from its capacity as the general partner of the Partnership.

(b) In the event of the removal of the General Partner pursuant to paragraph 3.3(a). the
Limited Partners, acting by the same Percentage in Interest required of the vote to remove. shall be entitled
to appoint a replacement general partner on such economic terms and other terms as the replacement
general partner and a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners may agree. In such event: (i) the
removed General Partner shall not be entitled to retain any rights or powers of a general partner of the
Partnership and shall become a special limited partner of the Partnership with a continued interest in
allocations of Profit and Loss and distributions of Partnership cash and assets pursuant to Articles 5. 7 and
10 hereof: (ii) the removed General Partner shall no longer be required to make additional capital
contributions to the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 4.3 and the removed General Partner's Capital
Commitment shall be equal to the amount actually contributed pursuant to paragraph 4.3: (iii) the removed
General Partner shall be entitled to receive all allocations and distributions to which it would otherwise be
entitled to receive had it not been removed when. as and if such allocations and distributions are made, in
respect of all activities of and investments by the Partnership that occurred or were committed to by the
Partnership prior to the effective date of removal: provided. however. that the removed General Partner
shall he entitled to receive one hundred percent (100%) of all allocations and distributions in respect of its
capital contributions: (iv) the removed General Partner shall not be entitled to receive any payments of
management fee pursuant to paragraph 6.1 with respect to any period of time after the date of its removal: (v)
the removed General Partner and any Indemnified Party shall remain entitled to exculpation and
indemnification pursuant to paragraphs 15.3 and 15.4 with respect to any matter arising prior to or out of
3.
1220705610
1,6116014 vl
events or circumstances existing prior to the General Partner's removal: and (vi) an interest in the
Partnership equal to the General Partner's unfunded Capital Commitment and the remaining carried interest
in the Partnership shall be transferred to the replacement general partner upon its admission to the
Partnership.

(c) For purposes of this paragraph 3.3. a "Trigger Event" shall have occurred if the
General Partner or any Managing Member is (i) found by a court of competent jurisdiction or arbitration
carried out pursuant to paragraph 15.5 to have committed (or enters a plea of nolo contendere to having
committed) embezzlement, fraud or any other act involving material improper personal benefit against the
Partnership or its assets, or (ii) is convicted of a violation of federal or state securities law or a felony (but
not including a felony involving the use of a motor vehicle) in a manner that had a material adverse effect
on the Partnership: provided, however. that no Trigger Event shall be deemed to have occurred if. in the
case of acts by a Managing Member. the offending individual is removed as a managing member of the
General Partner within thirty (30) days after the court judgment or arbitration decision. or conviction. which
would otherwise have given rise to a Trigger Event under this paragraph 3.3.

(d) Notwithstanding anything in paragraph 15.11 and in the event of any election
made to remove the General Partner. the Partners agree to amend this Agreement in good faith in order to
give effect to the foregoing provisions of this paragraph 3.3. including but not limited to revising Exhibit A
to reflect changes in the Partners' identities. Capital Commitments and Partnership Percentages.

(e) The General Partner shall promptly notify the Limited Partners if the General
Partner or any Managing Member is found to have committed (or enters a plea of nolo contendere to having
committed) embezzJement, fraud or any other act involving material improper personal benefit. or is
convicted of a violation of federal or state securities law or a felony, regardless of whether any such act
relates to the Partnership or not.
ARTICLE 4
CAPITAL ACCOUNTS, CAPITAL CONTRIBUTIONS
AND NONCONTRIBUTING PARTNERS
4.1 Capital Accounts. An individual Capital Account shall be maintained for each Partner.
4.2 Capital Contributions or the Limited Partners.

(a) Each Limited Partner shall contribute capital to the Partnership as requested by the
General Partner upon ten (10) business days prior written notice (which such notice shall be given by
electronic mail or by a nationally recognized overnight courier, specifying next day delivery, in accordance
with paragraph 15.9); provided. that the initial capital contribution from each Limited Partner shall not be
due earlier than January I. 2016. The General Partner may request capital contributions from the Limited
Partners. on the terms specified in this paragraph 4.2(a) or as altered under a Side Letter. Except as set forth
in paragraphs 3.2(c) and 4.2(b). each capital contribution shall be in accordance with Partnership
Percentages: provided. however, that the capital contributions from the Limited Partners may be adjusted
by the General Partner in good faith in order to account for the fact that no Management Fee is chargeable in
respect of the General Partner's interest in the Partnership. Notwithstanding anything in the foregoing to
the contrary. no Limited Partner shall be required to contribute any capital after the fifth anniversary of the
Commencement Date (the period between the Commencement Date and the fifth anniversary thereof being
referred to herein as the "Commitment Period"), except as may be necessary for (a) Partnership expenses.
including, but not limited to. payment of any Management Fee (as defined below) due to the General
Partner: (b) completion of transactions evidenced by a written terms sheet (or other similar statement of
4.
$22Gulu)vl
L16116014 vl
intent to make an investment that has been executed by the Partnership) prior to the end of the Commitment
Period; (c) follow-on investments in the Securities of issuers in which the Partnership holds a pre-existing
interest as of the date of such proposed follow-on investment: and (d) fulfillment of such Limited Partner's
obligations pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(i). Further. each Limited Partner's obligation to contribute capital
shall also be subject to those limitations set forth in paragraph 4.6. Each capital contribution by any Limited
Partner shall be made in U.S. dollars and made in cash or by transfer of immediately-available funds.
(b) Notwithstanding paragraph 4.2(a). with respect to the Partnership's initial request
for capital contributions under this paragraph 4.2. in the event that the sum of the Capital Commitments of
all Limited Partners that are "benefit plan investors" is such as would make their "equity participation" in
the Partnership "significant." within the meaning of those terms under U.S. Department of Labor
Regulation § 2510.3-101. as modified by Section 3(42) of the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of
1974, as amended ("ERISA") (the 'VOL Regulations"), then no such Limited Partner shall be required to
contribute capital to the Partnership pursuant to this Agreement until such time as the General Partner shall
have delivered to such Limited Partner an opinion of counsel (which opinion and counsel shall be
reasonably acceptable to the Limited Partner) to the effect that the Partnership's first portfolio company
investment (other than a short-term investment of funds pending long-term commitment) has qualified or
will qualify upon the funding of each Limited Partner's initial capital contribution as a "venture capital
investment-  within the meaning of the DOL Regulations such that the Partnership will qualify as a "venture
capital operating company" (a "VCOC') within the meaning of the DOL Regulations (the "VCOC
Opinion"). In the event that such a Limited Partner has not received the VCOC Opinion prior to the date on
which any capital contribution would otherwise be due under paragraph 4.2(a). such Limited Partner shall
pay such capital contribution into an interest-bearing escrow account designated by the General Partner.
The terms of any such escrow account shall be determined by the General Partner in compliance with
ERISA (including the principles and conditions indicated in Dept. of Labor Adv. Op. 95-04A). to the extent
applicable. Upon delivery of the VCOC Opinion, all amounts in the escrow account shall be delivered to
the Partnership in fulfillment of such Limited Partner's then-outstanding obligations under paragraph
4.2(a).

(c) The General Partner may. in its sole discretion. return to the Partners all or a
portion of any capital contribution intended for a proposed investment which is not consummated as
anticipated pro rata in accordance with their respective capital contributions: provided. however. that such
returned capital shall be added back to unfunded Capital Commitments pro rata in accordance with the
percentages in which such returned capital was attributed to the Capital Commitments when such capital
was called and be subject to recall by the General Partner pursuant to this Article 4.

(d) (I) If. in the discretion of the General Partner. Partnership assets are
insufficient to fulfill any indemnification obligation of the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 15.4 prior to
the final liquidation of the Partnership. the General Partner may to the fullest extent permitted by applicable
law require each Partner to contribute capital to the Partnership in an amount up to such Partner's unfunded
Capital Commitment, if any.

(II) If. in the discretion of the General Partner. Partnership assets remain
insufficient to fulfill any indemnification obligation of the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 15.4. and
following the contribution to the Partnership of the maximum amount then permitted by paragraph 4.2(d)(i).
the General Partner may recall distributions previously made to the Partners solely for the purpose of
fulfilling or satisfying such an obligation or liability. Such distributions shall be recalled from the Partners
in the same proportions as the expense (or loss) of the indemnity obligation giving rise to such
recontribution was allocated to the Partners pursuant to Article 5. In no event shall any Partner be required
to contribute capital pursuant to this paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) in an amount in excess of the lesser of (1) all
distributions previously received by the Partner from the Partnership or (2) twenty-five percent (25%) of
5.
$22070561v1
1,6116014 vl
such Partner's Capital Commitment. In no event will the General Partner be permitted to call capital
pursuant to this paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) in connection with a certain distribution after the earlier of (A) the date
two (2) years after the Termination Date (or any subsequent date to which the Partnership term has
previously been extended pursuant to paragraph 10.1) and (II) the date three (3) years after the date of such
distribution.
(III) In the event that the Partners are required to return distributions as
provided in paragraph 4.2(dXii) following the final liquidation of the Partnership. paragraph 10.5 shall be
reapplied to account for the associated indemnification expense and. to the extent that the General Partner
would have any additional obligation to return capital pursuant to paragraph 10.5 as a result of such
reapplication (the "Paragraph 10.5 Reapplication Amount"), the proportions in which the Partners bear
the return obligation pursuant to paragraph 4.2(dXii) shall be appropriately adjusted by increasing the
General Partner's obligation to contribute capital to the Partnership pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) by the
Paragraph 10.5 Reapplication Amount, and reducing the aggregate obligation of the Limited Partners to
contribute capital pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)(ii) by a like amount. For the purpose of this paragraph
4.2(dXiii) only. the aggregate maximum amount that the General Partner may be required to return to the
Partnership pursuant to paragraph 10.5 shall not be limited to After-Tax Distribution Amount.
4.3 Capital Contributions of the General Partner. The General Partner and/or its
designated Affiliate shall contribute capital to the Partnership. and have a Capital Commitment, in an
amount equal to at least one percent (1%) of the aggregate Capital Commitments of all Partners. on the
same schedule and terms under which any Limited Partner makes a contribution. Further, the General
Partner or its Affiliates, or their respective members. may contribute additional capital to one or more
Parallel Funds. Each collective  capital contribution to be made by the General Partner shall-besmide4w‘a. chi
pwwidedrlsswe..erwthas-eaeh-afHOHR4-thas-dx•-Gentwnl-0artaepos its designated Affiliate would-0411.P14tit)-be
obligated-I0-eentribute-shall be reduced by eighty percent (80%) (such amount being the "Cashless
Portion4"),  provided, that the General Partner or its designated Affiliate may elect to contribute its
respective portion of such collective contribution obligation entirely in cash. Notwithstanding the
preceding. for purposes of applying all other provisions of this Agreement (other than this paragraph 4.3).
the General Partner or its designated Affiliate shall be treated as if it had made each capital contribution in
full without reduction for any Cashless Portion: provided, however, that the Capital Account of the General
Partner or its designated Affiliate shall not include any Cashless Portion. If a designated Affiliate of the
General Partner makes the Capital Commitment described in this paragraph 4.3. then the interest so held by
the designated Affiliate shall be a Limited Partner's interest and treated as an interest held by a Limited
Partner for all purposes under this Agreement.

4.4 Acquisition of an Additional Interest by the General Partner. In the event that the
General Partner or its designated Affiliate acquires or holds an additional interest in the Partnership with a
Capital Commitment that exceeds one percent ( I%) of the aggregate Capital Commitments of all Partners
(pursuant to a transfer from another Limited Partner or otherwise), the General Partner shall have two (2)
Partnership Percentages and two (2) Capital Account balances for purposes of making Partnership
allocations (including any reallocation of Contingent Losses pursuant to paragraph 5.3). as if such
additional excess interest were held by a separate entity which is a Limited Partner, although for all other
purposes the General Partner shall have only one Capital Account.
4.5 Noncontributing Partners.

(a) The Partnership shall be entitled to enforce the obligations of each Limited Partner
to make the contributions to capital set forth in paragraph 4.2. and the Partnership shall have all remedies
available at law or in equity in the event any such contribution is not so made. If any legal proceedings
relating to the failure of a Limited Partner to make such a contribution are commenced, such Limited
6.
tInantstvl
12016015v)
Partner shall pay all costs and expenses incurred by the Partnership. including attorneys fees and expenses.
in connection with such proceedings.

(b) Additionally, without in any way limiting any remedy which the Partnership may
pursue pursuant to paragraph 4.5(a). should any Limited Partner fail to make any of the capital
contributions required of it under this Agreement. such Limited Partner shall be in default. In the event of
such default, the General Partner may. in its sole discretion, elect to enforce one or more of the provisions of
this paragraph 4.5(b) in connection with such a default, to which each Limited Partner hereby expressly
consents, provided such default shall have continued uncured for ten (10) or more days after delivery of the
Default Notice described in the following sentence (after such ten (10)-day period, such Limited Partner
shall be deemed a "Defaulting Limited Partner"). The General Partner shall deliver written notice to such
Defaulting Limited Partner in the event that it determines to utilize one or more of the powers set forth in
this paragraph 4.5(b) (a "Default Notice"). If the default shall have continued uncured for ten (10) or more
days after delivery of the Default Notice. the Defaulting Limited Partner may not make any additional
contributions of capital against such Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Commitment (other than to fund
Management Fees and other expenses of the Partnership) without the written consent of the General Partner.
which consent may be granted or denied in the sole discretion of the General Partner. In enforcing any of
the following provisions of this paragraph 4.5(b) against a Defaulting Limited Partner, the General Partner
agrees that it shall use commercially reasonable efforts to enforce such provisions against such Defaulting
Limited Partner in a manner so as to prevent the other non-Defaulting Limited Partners from bearing a net
economic burden attributable to Management Fees that, absent such default, would be borne by the
Defaulting Limited Partner if the Defaulting Limited Partner were to retain its interest in the Partnership
and make capital contributions in respect thereof.

(I) The General Partner may waive, in whole or in part. the requirement of
payment with respect to any due and unpaid capital contributions by a Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant
to this Agreement and reduce such Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Commitment accordingly.

(II) The General Partner may extend the time of payment for a Defaulting
Limited Partner of any due and unpaid capital contributions by such Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to
this Agreement.
(III) The General Partner may declare the entire amount of a Defaulting
Limited Partner's then unfunded Capital Commitment to be immediately due and payable.

(Iv) On behalf of the Partnership. the General Partner may enforce, by
appropriate legal proceedings. the Defaulting Limited Partner's obligation to make payment on the amount
of any due and unpaid capital contributions by such Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to this Agreement
or to pay the entire amount of such Defaulting Limited Partner's then unfunded Capital Commitment.

(v) The Defaulting Limited Partner shall have no right to participate in any
vote or consent of the Partners required under this Agreement or permitted under the Act and the Capital
Commitment of such Defaulting Limited Partner shall not be included for purposes of calculating a
Majority in Interest or other Percentage in Interest of the Limited Partners for purposes of this Agreement.

(vI) Should the General Partner. in its sole discretion. elect to exercise the
provisions of this paragraph 4.5(b)(vi). such Defaulting Limited Partner shall pay all expenses to be
incurred or anticipated to be incurred by the Partnership in connection with the default and interest on the
amount of the contribution to the Partnership then due at the Prime Rate plus one hundred (100) basis points
per annum (or if less, the highest rate permitted by applicable law), such interest to accrue from the date the
contribution to the Partnership was required to be made pursuant to this Agreement until the date the
7.
1220705610
V6116014 vl
contribution is made by such Defaulting Limited Partner, unless such payment is waived by the General
Partner. The accrued interest shall be paid by the Defaulting Limited Partner to the Partnership upon
payment of such contribution. The accrued interest so paid shall not be treated as an additional contribution
to the capital of the Partnership, but shall be deemed to be income to the Partnership: provided. however.
that such income shall not be allocated to the Capital Account of the Defaulting Limited Partner. Until such
time as the unpaid contribution and accrued interest thereon shall have been paid by the Defaulting Limited
Partner. the General Partner may elect to withhold any or all distributions to be made to such Defaulting
Limited Partner pursuant to Article 7 or Article 10 and recover any such unpaid contribution and accrued
interest thereon by set off against any such distribution withheld.

(A) Should the General Partner. in its sole discretion. elect to exercise the
provisions of this paragraph 4.5(b)(vii). the General Partner and the nondefaulting Limited Partners (the
"Optionees"). shall have the right and the option. but not the obligation. to acquire the Partnership interest
of the Defaulting Limited Partner (the "Optionor"). as follows:

(1) The General Partner shall notify the Optionees of the default
within twenty (20) days of the expiration of the ten (10) day notice period commencing upon delivery of the
Default Notice. Such notice shall advise each Optionee of the portion and the price of the Optionor's
interest available to it. The portion available to each Optionee shall be a fraction, the numerator of which is
its Capital Commitment and the denominator of which is the aggregate Capital Commitments of the
Optionees. The aggregate price for the Optionor's interest shall be the lesser of fifty percent (50%) of (A)
the amount of the Optionor's Capital Account calculated as of the due date of the additional contribution
and adjusted to reflect the allocation of the appropriate proportion of the Partnership's unrealized gains and
losses as of the due date of such defaulted contribution. and (B) the aggregate amount of the Optionor's
capital contributions actually made less any distributions (valued at their fair market value on the date of
distribution in accordance with paragraph 12.1) on or prior to such due date. The price for each Optionee
shall be prorated according to the portion of the Optionor's interest purchased by each such Optionee. The
option granted hereunder shall be exercisable at any time after the date thirty (30) days following the date of
the initial notice of default from the General Partner to the Optionor by delivery to the Optionor of a notice
of exercise of option together with a nonrecourse promissory note for the purchase price and a security
agreement in accordance with subparagraph (5) below, which notice and documents the General Partner
shall promptly forward to the Optionor.

(2) Should any Optionee not exercise its option within said thirty (30)
day period provided in subparagraph (1): the General Partner shall immediately notify the other Optionees
who have elected to exercise their option. which Optionees shall have the right and option ratably among
them to acquire the portion of the Optionor's interest not so acquired (the "Remaining Portion") within
thirty (30) days of the date of the notice specified in this subparagraph (2) on the same terms as provided in
subparagraph (I).

(3) Any amount of the Remaining Portion not acquired by the
Optionees pursuant to subparagraph (2) may be acquired by the General Partner within thirty (30) days of
the expiration of the thirty (30) day period specified in subparagraph (2) on the same terms as set forth in
subparagraph (I): provided. however. that the General Partner shall not be obligated to make the additional
contributions otherwise due from the Optionor with respect to the Remaining Portion so acquired.

(4) Any amount of the Remaining Portion not acquired by the
Optionees and the General Partner pursuant to subparagraphs (2) or (3) may. if the General Partner deems it
in the best interest of the Partnership. be sold by the General Partner to any other investor. on terms not
more favorable to such parties than those applicable to the Optionees' option. and upon the consent of the
8.
S220705610
1,6116014 v1
General Partner, any such third party purchaser may become a Limited Partner to the extent of the interest
purchased hereunder.

(5) The price due from each of the General Partner and the Optionees
(and. if applicable, any third party purchaser pursuant to subparagraph (4)) shall be payable by a noninterest
bearing. nonrecourse promissory note (in such form as the General Partner shall designate) due upon final
liquidation of the Partnership. Each such note shall be secured by the portion of the Optionor's Partnership
interest so purchased by its maker pursuant to a security agreement in a tom designated by the General
Partner and shall be enforceable by the Optionor only against such security.
(6) Upon exercise of any option hereunder, each Optionee (and. if
applicable, any third party purchaser pursuant to subparagraph (4)) shall be obligated (A) to contribute to
the Partnership that portion of the additional capital then due from the Optionor equal to the percentage of
the Optionor's interest purchased by such person and (B) except as otherwise provided in subparagraph (3).
to pay the same percentage of any further contributions otherwise due from such Optionor on the date such
contributions are otherwise due. Each person who purchases a portion of the Optionor's Partnership
interest shall be deemed to have acquired such portion as of the due date of the additional capital
contribution with respect to which the Optionor defaulted, and any distributions made after the due date on
account of the Optionor's interest shall be distributed among such purchasers (and. unless the entire interest
was purchased. the Optionor) in accordance with their ultimate respective interests in the Optionor's
interest. Distributions otherwise allocable to the °phenor under the preceding sentence shall first be used
to offset any defaulted contribution of the Optionor still due to the Partnership. Upon completion of any
transaction hereunder, the General Partner shall cause EXHIBIT A to be amended to reflect all necessary
changes resulting therefrom including, without limitation, admission of a purchaser as a Limited Partner.
and adjustment of Capital Account balances. Capital Commitment amounts and Partnership Percentages as
of the date of Optionor's default to reflect the acquisition from Optionor of the appropriate pro rata portion
of each such item (including, if applicable, the reduction of aggregate Capital Commitments and resulting
adjustment of Partnership Percentages in connection with any acquisition of any Remaining Portion by the
General Partner pursuant to subparagraph (3)). The purchase and transfer of the Partnership interest of the
Optionor shall occur automatically upon exercise by any Optionee or the General Partner of its option
hereunder, or by any third-party purchaser pursuant to subparagraph (4). without any action by Optionor.

(7) Notwithstanding the sale of any portion of an Optionor's interest
pursuant to this paragraph 4.5(b)(vii). such Optionor shall not be released from its unfunded Capital
Commitment except as actually funded by the acquirer of any such portion of Optionor's interest.

(8) In the event that any amount of the Remaining Portion is not
acquired by the Optionees. the General Partner and any third party purchasers pursuant to paragraphs
4.5(b)(viiX1)-(4). then, in its sole discretion, the General Partner may apply any of the remedies described
in paragraphs 4.5(a) and (b) to such unsold portion.
(viii) The General Partner may. in its sole discretion. elect to remove such
Defaulting Limited Partner from the Partnership, in which event (I ) fifty percent (50%) of the Defaulting
Limited Partner's Capital Account balance shall be forfeited and reallocated to the Capital Accounts of the
nondefaulting Partners proportionally. based on. with respect to each such Partner, the ratio that its
Partnership Percentage immediately prior to such calculation bears to the aggregate Partnership
Percentages of all Partners (other than the Defaulting Limited Partner). (2) the remaining fifty percent (50%)
of the Defaulting Limited Partner's Capital Account balance shall be payable by the Partnership in
installments over a period of no more than three (3) years from the effective date of the removal of such
Defaulting Limited Partner pursuant to this paragraph 4.5(bXviii). and (3) the Defaulting Limited Partner's
Partnership Percentage shall be reduced to zero.
9.
17wk7a“Ivl
V6116014 vl

(Ix) The General Partner may. in its sole discretion, elect to use reasonable
efforts to assist such Defaulting Limited Partner transfer its entire interest in the Partnership.

(x) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement, each Limited
Partner ( I) agrees that it will execute any instruments or perform any other acts that are or may be necessary
to effectuate and carry out the transactions contemplated by this paragraph 4.5. and (2) designates and
appoints the General Partner its true and lawful attorney. in its name, place and stead, to make, execute, and
sign any and all instruments. documents. or certificates on behalf of any Defaulting Limited Partner in order
to give effect to any remedy against such Defaulting Limited Partner (including, but not limited to. the
remedies set forth in this paragraph 4.5(b)).

(xl) The Partners agree that the General Partner's authority and discretion to
enforce any remedy against a Defaulting Limited Partner (including but not limited to the remedies set forth
in this paragraph 4.5(b)) supersede any fiduciary duties of the General Partner to such Defaulting Limited
Partner. The Partners further agree that the remedies set forth in this paragraph 4.5(b) are fair and
reasonable in light of the difficulty in ascertaining the actual damages that would be incurred by the
Partnership and the nondefaulting Partners as a result of the Defaulting Limited Partner's failure to
contribute capital when due pursuant to the terms of this Agreement.
(x0) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this paragraph 4.5. a
Regulated Partner shall not be declared to be in default by the General Partner with respect to any due and
unpaid capital contributions in the event that such Regulated Partner is entitled to withdraw from the
Partnership (or the General Partner has requested such withdrawal) pursuant to Article 13 and the failure to
make such due and unpaid capital contributions is the consequence of or attributable to such withdrawal.
4.6 Suspension Period.

(a) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement to the contrary. no Limited
Partner shall be required to contribute capital to the Partnership in respect of its Capital Commitment during
any Suspension Period (as defined in paragraph 4.6(b)) except for:

(i) Partnership expenses. including payment of any Management Fee due to
the General Partner:
(II) follow-on investments in portfolio companies in which the Partnership
had invested prior to commencement of the Suspension Period. so long as the Advisory Committee
consents to each such follow-on investment:
(Ill) investments which the Partnership had committed to make as evidenced
by a written term sheet prior to commencement of the Suspension Period: and

(Iv) fulfillment of such Limited Partner's obligations pursuant to paragraph
4.2(d).

(b) In the event that either 0) James Fitzgerald or (ii) Andrew McCormack (each, a
"Managing Member." and together. the "Managing Members") ceases to be a managing member of the
General Partner, or otherwise ceases to participate in the management of the Partnership or fails to meet his
obligation to devote his business time to the Partnership to the extent required under paragraphs 8.3(a) or
8.3(b) (the "Suspension Event"). the Commitment Period shall automatically be suspended and a
"Suspension Period" shall begin (during which the activities described in paragraph 4.6(a) shall not be
permitted).
10.
S220703610
1,6116014 vt

(c) Upon the occurrence of a Suspension Event, the General Partner shall promptly
notify the Limited Partners of the Suspension Event. and shall promptly circulate a written ballot to the
Limited Partners which asks the Limited Partners to vote on whether the Commitment Period shall be
terminated as a result of such Suspension Event, and shall use its reasonable best efforts to have the Limited
Partners cast their vote on such ballot. If a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners do not
affirmatively vote to end the Suspension Period within one hundred eighty (180) days of the
commencement of the Suspension Period. the Commitment Period shall be automatically terminated and
the Suspension Period shall continue. If a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners do affirmatively
vote to terminate the Suspension Period within one hundred eighty (180) days of the commencement of the
Suspension Period. then the Suspension Period shall be automatically terminated and the Commitment
Period shall be reinstated. Notwithstanding the preceding or any other provision of this Agreement to the
contrary. a Suspension Period may be terminated, and the Commitment Period shall be reinstated, at any
time upon the affirmative vote of a Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners.
ARTICLE 5
PARTNERSHIP ALLOCATIONS
Si Allocation of Profit or Loss. Except as otherwise provided in this Article 5:

(a) Profit of the Partnership for each Accounting Period shall be allocated as follows:
(I) First, an amount of the Partnership's gains from the sale of Securities,
Deemed Gain allocable to the Partners in connection with a distribution or other disposition of Securities.
and Deemed Gain allocable in connection with a revaluation of Securities for any reason. in-eaoh-tase
whh_l. SN.,,,:f.e., lt. e la.,... Lid 1,, ,ht Pi,,,,,,,O1.4, f., ,a LIM oOe ,e.n. shall be allocated one hundred
percent (100%) to the General Partner until the cumulative amount allocated to the General Partner
pursuant to this paragraph 5.1(a)(i) in such Accounting Period and all prior Accounting Periods is equal to
the aggregate amount of all Fee Adjustments.

(II) Second. for so long as the "First Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is
not met, the remaining items of Profit for such Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Partners to cause
the cumulative allocations made pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) through 5.1(a)(iv) to have been made as
follows:

(1) Eighty percent (80%) of such Profit to the Capital Accounts of all
of the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages: and

(2) Twenty percent (20%) of such Profit to the Capital Accounts of all
of the Partners to the extent that such accounts were previously allocated a Contingent Loss that has not
been restored by previous allocations pursuant to this paragraph. Such Profit shall be allocated to a
Partner's Capital Account on the basis of the proportion that the unrestored Contingent Losses contained in
such Partner's Capital Account bears to the aggregate unrestored Contingent Losses contained in all
Partners' Capital Accounts. Any balance of said twenty percent (20%) of the Partnership's Profit shall be
allocated to the Capital Account of the General Partner.

(Ill) Next. after and to the extent that the First Allocation Hurdle has been met.
and until the "Second Allocation Hurdle" (as defined below) is met. the remaining items of Profit for such
Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Partners to cause the cumulative allocations made pursuant to
paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) through 5.1(aftiv) to have been made as follows:
t2201561*1
116116014v1

(1) Seventy-five percent (75%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages: and

(2) Twenty-five percent (25%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the
Partners to the extent that such accounts were previously allocated a Contingent Loss that has not been
restored by previous allocations pursuant to this paragraph. Such Profit shall be allocated to a Partner's
Capital Account on the basis of the proportion that the unrestored Contingent Losses contained in such
Partner's Capital Account bears to the aggregate unrestored Contingent Losses contained in all Partners'
Capital Accounts. Any balance of said twenty-five percent (25%) of the Partnership's Profit shall be
allocated to the Capital Account of the General Partner.

(Iv) Next, after and to the extent that the Second Allocation Hurdle is met, the
remaining items of Profit for such Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Partners to cause the
cumulative allocations made pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(ii) through 5.1(a)(iv) to have been made as
follows:

(I) Seventy percent (70%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages: and

(2) Thirty percent (30%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the Partners
to the extent that such accounts were previously allocated a Contingent Loss that has not been restored by
previous allocations pursuant to this paragraph. Such Profit shall be allocated to a Partner's Capital
Account on the basis of the proportion that the unrestored Contingent Losses contained in such Partner's
Capital Account bears to the aggregate unrestored Contingent Losses contained in all Partners' Capital
Accounts. Any balance of said thirty percent (30%) of the Partnership's Profit shall be allocated to the
Capital Account of the General Partner.

(b) Losses of the Partnership for each Accounting Period shall be allocated as follows:
(I) First, to the extent of the Profits allocated pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a)(iv)
with respect to prior Accounting Periods. items of Loss for such Accounting Period shall be allocated in
proportion to and in reverse order of such Profit allocations:

(II) Next, to the extent of the Profits allocated pursuant to paragraph 5.1(O(i ii)
with respect to prior Accounting Periods. any remaining items of Loss for such Accounting Period shall be
allocated in proportion to and in reverse order of such Profit allocations: and
(Ill) Next. any remaining items of bass for such Accounting Period shall be
allocated: (x) twenty percent (20%) to the Capital Account of the General Partner and (y) eighty percent
(80%) to the Capital Accounts of all of the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages.

For all purposes under this Agreement. the "First Allocation Hurdle" shall be determined as of the time
that any item of Profit or Loss is to be allocated pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(aXii) and 5.l(a)(iii). and shall be
deemed to have been met to the extent that each Limited Partner has been allocated net Profits pursuant to
this Article 5 in an amount equal to two hundred percent (200%) of its respective Capital Commitment (as
defined below) as of such time of determination (Le.. an amount sufficient to enable the Partnership to
distribute to such Limited Partner an amount equal to three hundred percent (300%) of such Limited
Partner's Capital Commitment).
P.
$22070561v1
1,6116014 v1
For all purposes under this Agreement. the "Second Allocation Hurdle" shall be determined as of the time
that any item of Profit or Loss is to be allocated pursuant to paragraphs 5.1(a)(iii) and 5.l(a)(iv). and shall
be deemed to have been met to the extent that each Limited Partner has been allocated net Profits pursuant
to this Article 5 in an amount equal to five hundred percent (500%) of its respective Capital Commitment as
of such time of determination (i.e.. an amount sufficient to enable the Partnership to distribute to such
Limited Partner an amount equal to six hundred percent ((100%) of such Limited Partner's Capital
Commitment).

(c) Solely in consideration of the fact that no Management Fee is chargeable in respect
of the General Partner's Partnership Percentage in the Partnership. items of Loss attributable to the
Management Fee for each Accounting Period shall not be allocated to the Capital Account of the General
Partner with respect to its Partnership Percentage.

5.2 Allocallon of Ordinary Income and Ordinary Loss. Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss
of the Partnership for each Accounting Period shall be allocated to the Capital Accounts of all of the
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages.
53 Reallocation of Contingent Losses.

(a) Except as provided in paragraph 5.3(b). if. for any Accounting Period, after the
allocations provided in this Article 5 have been made, the balance of the Adjusted Capital Account Balance
of the General Partner has been reduced to less than the product of the General Partner's Partnership
Percentage and the sum of the balances of the Adjusted Capital Account Balances of all Partners, an amount
(of the "Corth4....f,Loss?-) (the "Contingent Loss") allocated to the General Partner for such Accounting
Period  shall be reallocated from the General Partner's Capital Account to all of the Partner's Capital
Accounts (in proportion to each Partner's respective Partnership Percentage) so thailhe General Partner's
Adjusted Capital Account Balance is equal to the-prothret-of-the-General-Partheals-Parinerebr age
and eLe .1..n. of the-Adjeated-C-aprothAvesrunt-Patiams.. of all othah.i. Fa. puryvacr of ILA par tibtaph 5.3.
the-Genevel-Pretherasno less than the product of (I) the sum of the Adiusted Capital Account Balances of
all Partners and (II) the quotient of (i) the sum of (A) the amount of the General Partner's cumulative
capital contributions made in cash as of such time plus (B) the aggregate allocations of Profit to the
General Partner pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a) over (iii the sum of (X) the amount of all of the Partners
capital contributions made in cash as of such time plus (Y) aggregate allocations of Profit to the
General Partner pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a): provided, that the General Partner's Adjusted Capital
Account Balance may be less than that amount by the amount. if any, that the General Partner would be
required to contribute to the Partnership pursuant to either paragraph 10.5(a) or paragraph 10.5(d) as of
such time if all of the assets of the Partnership were sold at such time for their Adjusted Asset Values
and the proceeds thereof were distributed to the Partners pursuant to paragraph 10.4. For purposes of
this paragraph 5.3. the General Partner's Adiusted Capital Account shall not be deemed to include any
amounts attributable to a Limited Partner's interest held by the General Partner, but shall be deemed to
include any outstanding obligations by the General Partner to contribute capital to the Partnership.

(b) The amount of Contingent Loss that would otherwise be reallocated from the
General Partner's Adjusted  Capital Account under paragraph 5.3(a) shall instead be allocated to the General
Partner's Adjusted Capital Account until allocations of loss to the General Partner's  Adiusted Capital
Account pursuant to this paragraph 5.3(b) equal the amount of distributions. if any. that the General Partner
would have to return to the Partnership under paragraph 10.5 if the Partnership were then in liquidation.
5.4 Special Allocations. To the extent the Partnership has taxable interest income or expense
with respect to any promissory note between any Partner and the Partnership as holder and maker or maker
13.
S220705610
V6116015 vl
(Formatted: Font: Not Bokl. Not Italic
Formatted: Font: 11.5 pt
and holder pursuant to Section 483. Sections 1271 through 1288. or Section 7872 of the Code, such interest
income or expense shall be specially allocated to the Partner to whom such promissory note relates. and
such Partner's Capital Account adjusted if appropriate.
5.5 Regulatory Allocations.

(a) This Agreement is intended to comply with the safe harbor provisions set forth in
Treasury Regulation 1.704-1(b) and the allocations set forth in paragraph 5.5(b) (the "Regulatory
Allocations") are intended to comply with certain requirements of Treasury Regulation Section 1.704-1(b).
In the event the Regulatory Allocations result in allocations being made that are inconsistent with the
manner in which the Partners intend to divide Partnership Profit and Loss as reflected in paragraphs 5.1.5.2.
5.3 and 5.4. the General Partner shall use its reasonable best efforts to adjust subsequent allocations of any
items of gain, loss, income, deduction, or expense such that the net amount of the Regulatory Allocations
and such subsequent special adjustments to each Partner is zero.

(b) The allocations provided in this Article 5 shall be subject to the following
exceptions:
(I) Any loss or expense otherwise allocable to a Limited Partner which
exceeds the positive balance in such Limited Partner's Capital Account shall instead be allocated first to all
Partners who have positive balances in their Capital Accounts in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages. and when all Partners Capital Accounts have been reduced to zero. then to the General
Partner income shall first be allocated to reverse any loss or expense allocated under this paragraph
5.5(b)(i). in reverse order of such loss or expense allocations. until all such prior loss or expense allocations
have been reversed.

(II) In the event any Limited Partner unexpectedly receives any adjustments,
allocations, or distributions described in Treasury Regulation Section 1.704-I (b)(2)(ii)(dX4) through (d)(6).
which causes or increases a deficit balance in such Limited Partner's Capital Account. items of Partnership
income and gain shall be specially allocated to such Limited Partner in an amount and manner sufficient to
eliminate the deficit balance in its Capital Account created by such adjustments. allocations, or distributions
as quickly as possible.
(III) For purposes of this paragraph 5.5(b). the balance in a Partner's Capital
Account shall take into account the adjustments provided in Treasury Regulation Section
1.704-1(b)(2Xii)(dX4) through (d)(6).

(c) If additional persons are admitted to the Partnership as Limited Partners
subsequent to the date hereof (or existing Limited Partners increase their Capital Commitments). then
organizational costs. fees (including the Management Fee set forth in paragraph 6.1) and expenses. and
individual items of Ordinary Income. Ordinary Loss. Profit and Loss of the Partnership that are allocated to
the Partners on or after the effective date of such admission (or increase). shall be allocated first to such new
Partners (or such existing Limited Partners that increased their Capital Commitments) to the extent
necessary to cause such persons to be treated with respect to such items as if they had been Partners (or had
such increased Capital Commitments) from the date hereof.
5.6 Income Tax Allocations.

(a) Except as otherwise provided in this paragraph or as otherwise required by the
Code and the rules and Treasury Regulations promulgated thereunder, a Partner's distributive share of
14.
t7wk7a“Ivl
1,6116fIl vl
Partnership income, gain, loss, deduction, or expense for income tax purposes shall be the same as is
entered in the Partner's Capital Account pursuant to this Agreement.

(b) In accordance with Code Section 704(c) and the Treasury Regulations thereunder.
income, gain, loss, deduction, and expense with respect to any asset contributed to the capital of the
Partnership shall, solely for tax purposes. be allocated among the Partners so as to take account of any
variation between the adjusted basis of such property to the Partnership for federal income tax purposes and
its initial Adjusted Asset Value.

(c) In the event the Adjusted Asset Value of any Partnership asset is adjusted pursuant
to the terms of this Agreement. subsequent allocations of income, gain, loss, deduction, and expense with
respect to such asset shall take account of any variation between the adjusted basis of such asset for federal
income tax purposes and its Adjusted Asset Value in the same manner as under Code Section 704(c) and the
Treasury Regulations thereunder.
ARTICLE 6
MANAGEMENT FEE; PARTNERSHIP EXPENSES
6.1 Management Fee.

(a) Commencing as of the Commencement Date, the GeNeFili—Riftlief—“Of—Ift
designatedaffiliate4hat4tasmimh•-a-Capital-commitmeetrManagement Company shall be compensated on
a quarterly basis for services rendered to the Partnership by the payment in advance by the Partnership in
cash to the General Partner (or its designated Affiliate that makes the capital contributions referenced in
paragraph 4.3) on the first day of each fiscal quarter (or any applicable partial fiscal quarter. including
without limitation, a partial fiscal quarter commencing as of the Commencement Date) of a management
fee (the "Management Fee"). No Management Fee will be chargeable in respect of the interest in the
Partnership held by the General Partner or its designated Affiliate attributable to a Partnership Percentage.

(b) The Management Fee for each fiscal quarter (prior to the adjustments described in
paragraph 6.1(c)) shall be an amount equal to the aggregate Capital Commitments made by the Limited
Partners as of the first day of each such quarter multiplied by 0.625% (the percentage applicable for any
period referred to herein as the "Management Fee Percentage"): provided, that the General
RaneerManagement Company hereby irrevocably waives an aggregate amount of the Management Fee
equal to 80% of the General Partner's Capital Commitment. with reductions in the Management Fee to be
applied as set forth in paragraph 6.l(c)(ii). Notwithstanding the foregoing. (i) the Management Fee for each
of the Partnership's first and last fiscal quarters shall be proportionately reduced based upon the ratio that
the number of days in each such period bears to ninety (90). (ii) an additional Management Fee shall be
payable upon the date of admission of any Limited Partner (or increase in an existing Limited Partner's
Capital Commitment) subsequent to the date hereof to reflect the increased Capital Commitments
calculated as if such Limited Partner had been admitted to the Partnership (or had such increased Capital
Commitment) as of the date hereof. and (iii) for each fiscal year commencing on or after the fifth
anniversary of the Commencement Date, the Management Fee Percentage applicable in fiscal quarters
during such fiscal year (prior to the adjustments described in paragraph 6.1(c)) shall be equal to the greater
of (A) the quarterly Management Fee Percentage applicable in the prior fiscal year reduced by an amount
equal to 0.025% or (B) 0.375%.

(e) The Management Fee otherwise payable by the Partnership to the General Partner
neMr-itarder4gelManagement Company pursuant to paragraph 6.1(a) for a fiscal quarter shall be offset (in
the following order of application):
15.
1220705610
L16116014 vl

(I) Fast. by one hundred percent (100%) of the amount of any cash or
non-cash compensation in the form of stock. options. warrants or other similar rights (net of the amount
paid for any such stock or securities) paid as directors, consulting. management service. advisory.
consultant. transaction. commitment. breakup or broken deal fees or similar fees to the General Partner, the
Management Company. or the respective managing members or managers of such entities. during the
immediately preceding quaver by or in connection with any company in which the Partnership holds an
investment or any company in which the Partnership actively sought to invest but did not. net of any
unreimbursed expenses of the General Partner or the Management Company. or the managing members or
managers of such entities. and as adjusted for any similar reductions with respect to any Parallel Fund or
any "Prior Fund", on a pro rata basis based on the aggregate capital commitments made to the applicable
Parallel Funds and Prior Funds, to prevent double counting: provided. however, any reduction pursuant to
this paragraph 6.1(c)(i) in connection with any cash or non-cash compensation paid to any such parties by a
company in which an "Affiliated Party" (as defined below) or a member, employee or Affiliate thereof
holds an investment as of the date hereof shall be limited to the amount directly attributable to the
Partnership's actual investment in such company (taking into account of any proration due to the
investments of any Parallel Fund or Prior Fund): and

(II) Next, by an equal portion (measured over all quarterly periods during the
Partnership's Commitment Period and as adjusted for any increase in the General-Panner4s-Capital
Commitment of the General Partner or its designated Affiliate)  of the aggregate amount of the Management
Fee waived by the Genentl-PanneaManagernent Company pursuant to paragraph 6.1(b) (the amount of each
such reduction being a "Fee Adjustment').

In the event the offsets required by this paragraph 6.1(c) for a fiscal quarter exceed the Management Fee
payable for such fiscal quarter, the amount of such excess shall be offset against the Management Fee
otherwise payable in subsequent fiscal quarters until there has been a full reduction of Management Fees
with respect to amounts described in this paragraph 6.1(c). In the event that there are insufficient
Management Fees payable such that the foregoing offset amounts are unable to be completely exhausted by
the time of the Partnership's final distribution pursuant to paragraph 10.4. then the General Partner shall.
immediately prior to the Partnership's final distribution, return any such unexhausted offset amount to the
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages: provided. however. that any Limited
Partner may elect, by advance written notice to the General Partner, to refrain from being allocated. and
from having distributed to it. its portion of such returned offset amount.

(d) Solely for purposes of determining the value of any stock, options. warrants or
other similar rights that may offset the Management Fee as described in paragraph 6.1(c)(i), the following
rules shall apply:

(I) All non-cash compensation in the form of stock received by any of the
General Partner. the Management Company. or the managing members or managers of such entities shall
be valued as of the time of receipt in accordance with the rules set forth in paragraph 12.1.

(II) All non-cash compensation in the form of options. warrants or other
similar rights received by any of the parties shall be valued. in accordance with the rules set forth in
paragraph 12.1. upon the earliest to occur of (a) the distribution to the Partners of any Securities underlying
such options. warrants or other similar rights. (b) the conversion of such options. warrants or other similar
rights into cash. (c) the date on which the Securities underlying such options. warrants or other similar
rights become Marketable Securities (to the extent such options are exercisable at such time) or (d) the date
that is. in the General Partner's reasonable estimation, one year prior to the date of dissolution of the
Partnership. The value of options. warrants or other similar rights shall be. on a per share basis, the
difference, as of the valuation date, between the exercise price and the fair market value of the securities on
16.
122070561W
l'6116014
such date. No value shall be attributable to options. warrants or other similar rights if the applicable
securities are of a portfolio company that has been written off or written down to a nominal amount as of the
valuation date.
6.2 Expenses.
From the Management Fee.  the Management Company and the General Partner
shall bear all normal operating expenses incurred in connection with the management of the Partnership. the
General Partner and the Management Company. except for those expenses borne directly by the Partnership
as set forth in subparagraphs (b). (c) and (d) below and elsewhere herein. Such normal operating expenses
to be home by the General Partner (or its designee) shall include, without limitation, expenditures on
account of salaries, wages. travel, entertainment. and other expenses of employees. consultants and agents
of the Partnership (other than consultants employed with respect to investments or proposed investments).
the General Partner or the Management Company. overhead and rentals payable for space used by the
General Partner (or its designee) or the Partnership. office expenses. expenses for clerical and consulting
services, and expenses incurred in evaluating investment opportunities and managing investments of the
Partnership.

(b) The Partnership shall bear all costs and expenses incurred by the General Partner
and/or the Management Company in connection with the following:

(I) Expenses incurred in the holding. purchase. sale or exchange of Securities
(whether or not ultimately consummated), including, but not by way of limitation. private placement fees.
finder's fees, interest on borrowed money. real property or personal property taxes on investments
(including documentary. recording. stamp and transfer taxes). brokerage fees or commissions, legal fees.
expenses incurred in performing due diligence with respect to a purchase. sale or exchange of Securities
(whether or not ultimately consummated), consulting fees relating to investments or proposed investments:
and

(II) Expenses incurred in connection with the investigation, prosecution or
defense of any claims by or against the Partnership, including claims by or against a governmental authority.
audit and accounting fees, taxes applicable to the Partnership on account of its operations. fees incurred in
connection with the maintenance of bank or custodian accounts, and all expenses incurred in connection
with the registration of the Partnership's Securities under applicable securities laws or regulations.
expenses incurred by the General Partner in serving as the tax matters partner (as described in paragraph
11.6). the Management Fee. the cost of liability and other premiums for insurance protecting the
Partnership. the General Partner. its managers. and the Management Company and its managers and
employees from liability to third parties that relates to the Partnership and its activities and investments, all
out-of-pocket expenses of preparing and distributing reports to Partners, expenses associated with
Partnership communications with Partners, including preparation of annual or other reports to the Limited
Partners, out-of-pocket costs associated with Partnership meetings, all legal. audit and accounting fees
relating to the Partnership and its activities (including, without limitation, for third party bookkeeping
services), all costs and expenses arising out of the Partnership's indemnification obligation pursuant to this
Agreement. and all expenses that are not normal operating expenses.

(c) The Partnership shall bear all organizational and syndication costs. fees. and
expenses incurred by or on behalf of the General Partner in connection with the formation and organization
of the Partnership and the General Partner, including legal and accounting fees and expenses incident
thereto (but not including any private placement fees. finder's fees or other similar fees paid to an
independent third party in connection with the sale of interests in the Partnership): provided. however. that
17.
122070361v1
1,611601 vl
the amount of such costs. fees and expenses that are borne by the Partnership shall not exceed in the
aggregate five hundred thousand dollars (4500.000).

(d) The Partnership shall bear all liquidation costs. fees. and expenses incurred by the
General Partner (or its designee) in connection with the liquidation of the Partnenhip at the end of the
Partnership's term. specifically including but not limited to legal and accounting fees and expenses.

(e) Each of the Partnership and the General Partner agree to reimburse the other as
appropriate to give effect to the provisions of this paragraph 6.2 in the event that either such party pays an
obligation that is properly the responsibility of the other.
ARTICLE 7
WITHDRAWALS BY AND DISTRIBUTIONS TO THE. PARTNERS
7.1 Interest. Except as otherwise provided in this Agreement. no interest shall be paid to any
Partner on account of its interest in the capital of or on account of its investment in the Partnership.
7.2 Withdrawals by the Partners. No Partner may withdraw any amount from its Capital
Account unless such withdrawal is made pursuant to this Article 7. Article 10 or Article 13.
7.3 Partners' Obligation to Repay or Restore. Except as required by law or the terms of this
Agreement. no Limited Partner shall be obligated at any time to repay or restore to the Partnership all or any
part of any distribution made to it from the Partnership in accordance with the terms of this Article 7.
7.4 Mandatory Distributions.

(a) The General Partner may cause each Partner to be paid in cash, following the end
of each fiscal year during the term of the Partnership. an amount equal to the net taxable income allocated to
such Partner as a result of such Partner's ownership of an interest in the Partnership for the current fiscal
year multiplied by the highest blended federal, state and local marginal income tax rate then applicable to an
individual residing in any state of the United States applied by taking into account the character of the
taxable income in question (i.e.. long-term capital gains, ordinary income. etc.) (such product. such
Partner's "Annual Tax Amount"): provided, however, that the General Partner shall not be required to
make any such distribution if the total amount to be distributed to all Partners is less than one million dollars
(51.000.000): provided, further, that for each fiscal year the amount distributed to any Partner pursuant to
this paragraph 7.4(a) shall not exceed the amount by which (A) such Partner's cumulative aggregate Annual
Tax Amounts for such fiscal year and all prior fiscal years exceeds (B) the cumulative aggregate cash
distributions made to such Partner pursuant to paragraphs 7.4(a) and 7.5 through the end of such fiscal year
(and including all prior fiscal years). The provisions of this paragraph 7.4 shall apply equally to all Partners.
without regard to their tax-exempt status under the Code.

(b) Subject to the maintenance of reasonable cash reserves (as determined and
established at the discretion of the General Partner), within ninety (90) days of the end of each fiscal year.
the General Partner shall distribute. in cash. to all Partners in proportion to their Partnership Percentages. an
amount equal to the amount of net Ordinary Income, if any. allocated to each Partner's Capital Account
during such fiscal year.
18.
t2)0,7ackly1
V6116014 v 1
7.5 Discretionary Distributions and Rules Regarding Distributions.

(a) Except as otherwise provided in paragraph 7.5(g). the General Partner may make a
distribution of cash or Marketable Securities as follows.
First. to the Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages such that each such Partner has received distributions pursuant to paragraph 7.4 and this
paragraph 7.5(a)(i) in an amount equal to (but not greater than) such Partner's aggregate capital
contributions (including the amount of all Fee Adjustments in the case of the General Partner). less the net
Ordinary Losses. if any. previously allocated to such Partner pursuant to paragraph 5.2 (all measured as of
the time the distribution is to be made):

(II) Second. until the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited Partner
pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) is equal to three hundred percent (300%) of such
Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution. such distribution shall be made to
the Partners in the proportions necessary to cause cumulative distributions made pursuant to paragraph
7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) to have been
made: ( I ) eighty percent (80%) to all Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages and

(2) twenty percent (20%) to the General Partner;
(Ill) Third. to the extent that the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited
Partner pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) exceeds three hundred percent (300%) of
such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution, such distribution shall be
made one hundred percent (100%) to the General Partner until the General Partner has received aggregate
distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made
pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) equal to twenty-five percent (25%) of the cumulative distributions made
pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph
7.5(a)(i)):

(Iv) Fourth. until the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited Partner
pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) is equal to six hundred percent (600%) of such
Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution. such distribution shall be made to
the Partners in the proportions necessary to cause cumulative distributions made pursuant to paragraph
7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i)) to have been
made: (I) seventy-five percent (75%) to all Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership
Percentages and (2) twenty-five percent (25%) to the General Partner.

(v) Fifth. to the extent that the cumulative amount distributed to each Limited
Partner pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) exceeds to six hundred percent (600%) of
such Limited Partner's Capital Commitment as of the date of such distribution. such distribution shall be
made one hundred percent (100%) to the General Partner until the General Partner has received aggregate
distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made
pursuant to paragraph 7.5(0(i)) equal to thirty percent (30%) of the cumulative distributions made pursuant
to paragraph 7.4(a) and this paragraph 7.5(a) (other than distributions made pursuant to paragraph 7.5(a)(i));
and

(vI) Sixth, such distribution shall be made: (I) seventy percent (70%) to all
Partners in proportion to their respective Partnership Percentages and (2) thirty percent (30%) to the
General Partner.
19.
122070561v1
1,6116014

(b) Notwithstanding paragraph 7.5(a). the General Partner may at any time waive a
distribution of cash or Marketable Securities that would otherwise be made to it pursuant to paragraphs
7.5(a)(ii) through 7.5(a)(vi) and instead make such distribution one hundred percent (100%) to all Partners
in accordance with their respective Partnership Percentages: provided. however. that the Partnership may
make subsequent distributions of cash to the General Partner to the extent of any such waived distribution at
such times as the General Partner shall determine.

(c) Whenever more than one type of Marketable Securities is being distributed in kind
in a single distribution or whenever more than one class of Marketable Securities of a portfolio company (or
a portion of a class of such Marketable Securities having a tax basis per share or unit different from other
portions of such class) are distributed in kind by the Partnership. each Partner shall receive its ratable
portion of each type. class or portion of such class of Marketable Securities distributed in kind (except to the
extent that a disproportionate distribution is necessary to avoid distributing fractional shares).

(d) Marketable Securities distributed in kind pursuant to this paragraph 7.5. or
Securities distributed pursuant to paragraph 10.4. shall be subject to such conditions and restrictions as the
General Partner determines are legally required or appropriate. Whenever types or classes of Securities are
distributed in kind, each Partner shall receive its ratable portion of each type or class of Securities
distributed in kind.

(e) Immediately prior to any distribution in kind. the Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss of
any Marketable Securities distributed pursuant to this paragraph 7.5. or Securities distributed pursuant to
paragraph 10.4. shall be allocated to the Capital Accounts of all Partners as Profit or Loss pursuant to
Article 5.
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement. in the event the
Partnership distributes to the Partners any Marketable Securities or cash proceeds from the sale or other
disposition of Securities or other property of the Partnership within one hundred eighty (180) days of the
date the Partnership acquired the Securities of the applicable portfolio company. a portion of the distributed
capital that represents the Partnership's original cost basis of such Securities shall be added back to the
unfunded Capital Commitments of the Partners pm rata in accordance with the percentages in which the
capital contributed to purchase such Securities of the applicable portfolio company and each Partner may be
required to recontribute capital on the terms set forth in paragraph 4.2 to the Partnership an amount equal to
the product of: (x) such Partner's Partnership Percentage: and (y) the Partnership's original cost basis of the
Securities being distributed or which were sold or otherwise disposed of in connection with such
distribution.
(V Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this paragraph 7.5. no
distribution shall be made to the General Partner to the extent it would create or increase a deficit in its
Capital Account: provided. however. that the General Partner shall be entitled to receive a special
distribution in an amount equal to the amount of any distribution otherwise foregone pursuant to this
paragraph 7.5(g). to the extent that such special distribution would not create or increase a deficit in the
General Partner's Capital Account.

(h) All distributions of cash to be made by the Partnership. pursuant to paragraphs 7.4
or 7.5 or otherwise, shall be made in U.S. dollars.
7.6 Withholding Obligations.

(a) If and to the extent the Partnership is required by law (as determined in good faith
by the General Partner) to make payments flax Payments") with respect to any Partner in amounts
20.
$22670361v1
1.76116014
required to discharge any legal obligation of the Partnership or the General Partner, including any
obligation pursuant to FATCA. to make payments to any governmental authority with respect to any federal.
state or local tax liability of such Partner arising as a result of such Partner's interest in the Partnership, then
the amount of any such Tax Payments shall be deemed to be a loan by the Partnership to such Partner.
which loan shall: (i) be secured by such Partner's interest in the Partnership: (ii) bear interest at the Prime
Rate (as defined in paragraph 14.15): and (iii) be payable upon demand: provided. however, that the
General Partner shall use commercially reasonable efforts to provide the Partners notice of the amount of
any anticipated Tax Payments in advance of the Partnership's payment thereof and will, upon written
request from any Partner, allow such requesting Partner to pay the Partnership an amount of cash equal to
the amount of such Tax Payments in lieu of treating any such Tax Payment as a loan. Each Limited Partner
will. as applicable, take such actions as are required to establish to the reasonable satisfaction of the General
Partner that the Limited Partner is (i) not subject to the withholding tax obligations imposed by Section
1471 of the Code and (ii) not subject to the withholding tax obligations imposed by Section 1472 of the
Code. In addition, each Limited Partner will assist the Partnership and the General Partner with any
applicable information reporting or other obligation imposed on the Partnership. the General Partner, or
their respective Affiliates, pursuant to FATCA. For purposes of this Agreement. "FATCA" shall mean the
Foreign Account Tax Compliance provisions enacted as pan of the U.S. Hiring Incentives to Restore
Employment Act and codified in Sections 1471 through 1474 of the Code, all rules, regulations and other
guidance issued thereunder, and all administrative and judicial interpretations thereof.

(b) If and to the extent the General Partner determines that the Partnership is required
to make any Tax Payments with respect to any distribution to a Partner, (i) the General Partner shall use
commercially reasonable efforts to provide the Partner advance notice of the amount of such anticipated
Tax Payments and (ii) either (A) such Partner's proportionate share of such distribution shall be reduced by
the amount of such Tax Payments (provided. hmvever, that such Partner's Capital Account shall be adjusted
pursuant to paragraph 14.5 for such Partner's full proportionate share of the distribution). or (B) such
Partner shall pay to the Partnership prior to such distribution an amount of cash equal to such Tax Payments.
In the event a portion of a distribution in kind is retained by the Partnership pursuant to clause (A). such
retained Securities may. in the discretion of the General Partner, either (i) be distributed to the Partners in
accordance with the tenns of this Article 7 including this paragraph 7.6(b). or (ii) be sold by the Partnership
to generate the cash necessary to satisfy such Tax Payments. If the Securities are sold, then for purposes of
income tax allocations only under this Agreement. any gain or loss on such sale or exchange shall be
allocated to the Partner to whom the Tax Payments relate.

(c) If the Partnership is required to withhold taxes pursuant to this paragraph 7.6 with
respect to any Limited Partner or if any tax is required to be withheld on amounts receivable by the
Partnership (including any tax required to be withheld by another party paying proceeds to the Partnership)
and is attributable to any Limited Partner. the General Partner shall upon request by such Limited Partner
use commercially reasonable efforts to provide any Limited Partner with such information and assistance as
is reasonably necessary for such Limited Partner to obtain an exemption from or refund of such withheld
amounts.
ARTICLE 8
MANAGEMENT DUTIES AND RESTRICTIONS
8.1 Management. The General Partner shall have the sole and exclusive right to manage.
control. and conduct the affairs of the Partnership and to do any and all acts on behalf of the Partnership.
including exercise of rights to elect to adjust the tax basis of Partnership assets and to revoke such elections
and to make such other tax elections as the General Partner shall deem appropriate. The General Partner is
hereby authorized to enter. by itself or on behalf of the Partnership. into an agreement with Valar Ventures
21.
$22070.561v1
/16116015 vl
I Management LLC. a Delaware limited liability company or another entity beneficially owned by the
Managing Members and a Thiel Person (the "Management Company") for the provision of certain
management. administrative. operational and other services with the respect to the Partnership on terms to
be determined and agreed to by the General Partner. provided. however. that the General Partner shall
remain ultimately responsible for the overall management of the Partnership and for its duties and
responsibilities hereunder: provided. further- that any such agreement that the Partnership enters with an
Affiliate of the General Partner shall be on terms that are no less favorable to the Partnership than the terms
that would be obtained from an independent third-party acting at anus' length.

8.2 No Control by the Limited Partners; No Withdrawal. No Limited Partner shall take
part in the control or management of the affairs of the Partnership nor shall any Limited Partner have any
authority to act for or on behalf of the Partnership or to vote on any matter relative to the Partnership and its
affairs except as is specifically permitted by this Agreement. Except as specifically set forth in this
Agreement. no Limited Partner shall withdraw or be required to withdraw from the Partnership.
8.3 Existing Funds; Follow -On Funds; Parallel Funds.

(a) Before the Successor Fund Eligible Date (as defined in paragraph 8.3(b) below).
each of the Managing Members. for so long as they are managing members of the General Partner. shall
devote substantially all of his business time to manage the affairs of the Management Company. the
General Partner, the Partnership. the "Parallel Funds" (as defined below), and the "Prior Funds" (as defined
below), those entities formed for the purpose of managing the foregoing. or any portfolio company or
potential portfolio company of any of the foregoing or other entity invested in by the Partnership (which
may include being seconded to a portfolio company or potential portfolio company or other entity invested
in by the Partnership or a Prior Fund for such period of time as the General Partner determines, in good faith.
may benefit the Partnership or such Prior Fund, as applicable). From and after the Successor Fund Eligible
Date, each of the Managing Members, for so long as they are managing members of the General Partner.
shall only be required to devote such business time as they reasonably and in good faith deem to be
appropriate to manage the affairs of the Management Company. the General Partner. the Partnership. the
Parallel Funds and the other aforementioned entities.

Subject to the foregoing. the General Partner, the Management Company. the Managing Members, and
their respective affiliates, members and employees may:

(I) Engage in or own an interest in any other business. partnership. limited
liability company. limited liability partnership. corporation or other entity or association (including.
without limitation. buying and selling securities for their own accounts and the accounts of Prior Funds and
other investment vehicles, but subject in any event to the provisions of paragraph 8.4):

(II) Continue to act as managers. members. employees, or consultants to Valar
Global Fund I LP. Valar Global Principals Fund I LP. Valar Global Fund II LP. Valar Global Principals
Fund 11 LP. Velar Ventures LP. VV Global LP, VV Global Principals LP, Valar Co-Invest 1 LP. and VV
Xero Holdings LLC and to other entities affiliated therewith (collectively. the "Prior Funds"):
(ill) Form and operate one (I) or more successor venture capital investment
funds whose purpose is substantially the same as the Partnership's purpose (each, a "Successor Fund"),
subject to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b): and/or

(Iv) Form and operate one or more Parallel Funds (as defined in paragraph
8.3(c)).
11 .
122070561W
1,6116014 vl

(b) On or after the earlier of (i) such time as at least seventy-five percent (75%) of the
Partnership's Committed Capital has been invested, committed or reserved for investment in portfolio
companies. or applied. committed or reserved for Partnership working capital or expenses. or (ii) the end of
the Commitment Period (such earlier time, the "Successor Fund Eligible Date"). the Managing Members
shall only be required to devote such business time to the Partnership as they deem to be appropriate (acting
reasonably and in good faith) and may. at their sole and absolute discretion, form and operate one or more
Successor Funds. In addition, the General Partner, the Managing Members and/or their Affiliates may. at
any time. form. operate and devote such business time as is reasonably necessary to the management of one
or more "Special Purpose Investment Funds" described in paragraph 8.4(a).

(c) Pursuant to paragraph 8.3(a)(iv). the General Partner and the Managing Members
may form and serve as general partner (or in a similar management role) of (i) one or more entities
organized to accommodate the capital investment of the members of the General Partner and the
Management Company and their employees or consultants and their respective families, and of other
persons having strategic or other important relationships with the Partnership (each. an "Affiliates Fund").
and (ii) one or more investment partnerships or similar entities to accommodate the tax, regulatory or other
special needs of investors who otherwise would invest as Limited Partners of the Partnership (together with
any Affiliates Fund, the 'Parallel Funds"). Each Parallel Fund (other than an Affiliates Fund) shall be
governed by a limited partnership agreement (or other similar constitutive document) whose terms are
substantially the same as this Agreement (and, for the avoidance of doubt, an Affiliates Fund may have
different economic terms than the Partnership (including, without limitation, a reduced or waived
management fee and/or carried interest in profits payable to its general partner or manager)). In the event
that any Parallel Fund is formed, upon each purchase of Securities (other than short-term obligations such
as money market instruments) by the Partnership. each Parallel Fund will simultaneously invest on the
same terms as the Partnership pm raw in accordance with the remaining available capital of each such fund,
and reflecting the reserve policies for each such fund (e.g. because Affiliate Funds may not charge
management fees and thus may not reserve for them): provided. however, that a Parallel Fund shall not be
required to make any such investment in a Security if the General Partner receives from the issuer thereof a
written notice to the effect that the issuer will not permit such Parallel Fund to invest on the same terms as
the Partnership or such investment would be prohibited by the terms of the governing agreement of such
Parallel Fund. Each Parallel Fund shall also dispose of each such Security at substantially the same time
and on substantially the same terms as the Partnership: pmvided. however. that the foregoing requirement
shall not apply with respect to dispositions of Securities made in connection with the liquidation of the
Partnership or a Parallel Fund: provided. further. that a Parallel Fund shall not be required to make any such
divestment of a Security if the General Partner receives from the issuer thereof a written notice to the effect
that the issuer will not permit such Parallel Fund to dispose of such Security on the same terms as the
Partnership or such divestment would be prohibited by the terms of the governing agreement of such
Parallel Fund. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Agreement to the contrary. except as provided
in paragraph 10.3(b). in no event shall the General Partner cause or permit the Partnership. or any Parallel
Fund to make or dispose of an investment, or make a distribution of cash or property to the Partners, other
than on a pan passu basis with all other such funds based on their respective amounts of committed capital
from equityholders (determined as of all capital commitments were made at the same time). Each of the
Limited Partners hereby consents and agrees to the foregoing activities and investments and further
consents and agrees that neither the Partnership nor any of its Partners shall have any rights in or to such
activities or investments, or any profits derived therefrom.
8.4 Investment Opportunities and Conflicts of Interest.

(a) Each opportunity to invest at least one hundred fifty thousand dollars ($150.000)
into a company that is presented to the Managing Members. for so long as they are managing members of
the General Partner. and that otherwise meets the investment objectives of the Partnership (e.g.. the
23.
$22470361v1
V6116014 vl
potential investment is sufficiently large. the potential investment is not expected to require an inordinate
portion of the Partnership's capital, the company is at an appropriate sage of development, the Partnership
has sufficient capital available at the time the investment is to be made. etc.). shall be offered to the
Partnership and each Parallel Fund in proportion to their relative available capital (measured as of the time
of such presentation): provided. however. that (iLthe preceding restriction shall only apply from and after
the Commencement Date  until the earlier of the end of the Commitment Period or the time at which a
Successor Fund may be formed pursuant to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b);) and any such
opportunities may be allocated in whole to the Prior Funds. or such opportunities may be allocated partially
to the Partnership and the Parallel Funds and partially to the Prior Funds, until the Prior Funds have been
fully invested and reserved for follow-on investments and expenses. as determined by the General Partner
in its sole and absolute discretion In furtherance of the foregoing.  from and after the Commencement Date
until the earlier of the end of the Commitment Period or the time at which a Successor Fund may be formed
pursuant to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b). each of the General Partner and the Management
Company shall require that the Managing Members and managers of such entities shall promptly present to
the General Partner each investment opportunity that is presented to them and that is consistent with the
investment objectives of the Partnership as described in this paragraph 8.4(a).

Notwithstanding the preceding provisions of this paragraph 8.4(a) or any other provision of this
Agreement to the contrary. the restrictions described in this paragraph 8.4(a) shall not apply to the
participation of any Affiliated Party in any investment opportunity with respect to which: (i) the applicable
Affiliated Party's participation has been approved by the Advisory Committee: (ii) the applicable Affiliated
Party or an Affiliate thereof (in each case, other than any investment fund managed thereby) has initially
invested prior to the date hereof or pursuant to the other provisions of this paragraph 8.4(a) and/or
paragraph 8.4(c): (iii) the General Partner has determined, in good faith, does not meet the investment
objectives of the Partnership: or (iv) a Special Purpose Investment Fund has been formed. For the
avoidance of doubt, the following shall automatically be deemed not to be investment opportunities of the
Partnership (and may be invested in by the General Partner, any Affiliated Party. or any Affiliate or
employee thereof or any investment fund managed thereby notwithstanding any provision of this
Agreement to the contrary): (i) any investment opportunity in a company (including, without limitation, in
the preferred stock of such company) that the General Partner has considered and has rejected as being
unsuitable for the Partnership in accordance with the rules and procedures by which the General Partner
makes investment decisions (i.e.. because the number of Managing Members required to approve the
opportunity have considered the opportunity and rejected it as being unsuitable for the Partnership). so long
as the Managing Members who rejected the opportunity and their respective Affiliates do not then
participate in such opportunity: (ii) any investment opportunity with respect to which the Advisory
Committee is asked to approve the Partnership's participation. but which the Advisory Committee does not
so approve: (iii) any investment opportunity in a company that has a "pre-money valuation" greater than
five hundred million dollars (5500.000.000). as determined by the Management Company in its sole
discretion, as of the date of the proposed investment (other than follow-on investments in companies in
which the Partnership already holds an existing interest as of the date of such proposed follow-on
investment): and (iv) any investment opportunity to be held by a Special Purpose Investment Fund.
A "Special Purpose Investment Fund" means an investment fund created by the General Partner or any
Affiliated Party to invest in a specified investment opportunity. which meets the Partnership's investment
objectives. A Special Purpose Investment Fund must meet the following criteria: (a) each Partner is
provided the first opportunity (on at least seven (7) days advance notice) to invest in such special purpose
investment fund on a pro rata basis determined by reference to the total of (x) the Partners' respective
Capital Commitments and (y) the respective capital commitments that the constituent partners in any
Parallel Funds have made to such Parallel Funds, and (b) such special purpose investment fund charges a
carried interest and/or management fee that are no higher than those charged to the Partnership. No Special
Purpose Investment Fund with aggregate capital commitments that exceed 309E of the amount of the
24.
122070561v1
1,6116014
aggregate Capital Commitments to the Partnership shall be formed or organized without the Advisory
Committee's prior approval.

(b) The term "Affiliated Party". as used herein, means any Managing Member, the
General Partner, the Management Company. or any member, employee or Affiliate thereof: provided.
however. that for all purposes under this Agreement. no Thiel Person shall be deemed to be an Affiliated
Party. Notwithstanding paragraph 8.4(a). each Limited Partner hereby acknowledges and agrees that the
General Partner may offer to other private investors, groups. partnerships or corporations (including.
without limitation, any Limited Partner, and the Affiliates. members and employees of the foregoing parties
and any Prior Funds or Successor Funds) the right to participate in investment opportunities of the
Partnership or opportunities which may meet the investment objectives of the Partnership (as determined by
the General Partner in good faith) whenever the General Partner. in its sole and absolute discretion. so
determines: provided. however. that (i) an Affiliated Party may only take or participate in investment
opportunities meeting the investment objectives of the Partnership to the extent so provided in paragraphs
8.4(a) and 8.4(c) and (ii) such investment opportunity. if meeting the investment objectives of the
Partnership (as determined by the General Partner in good faith), shall be offered to the Partnership before it
is offered to any other party.

(c) Until the earlier of the time that the Commitment Period ends or a Successor Fund
may be formed pursuant to the first sentence of paragraph 8.3(b). each Affiliated Party or Affiliate thereof
shall not be permitted to receive and keep any preferred stock, common stock, options or other similar
instruments to purchase the same of any Partnership portfolio company without the consent of the Advisory
Committee: provided, however. that the Affiliated Parties may. collectively, invest up to one hundred fifty
thousand dollars ($150.000) into any Partnership portfolio company that are not Marketable Securities.

(d) Each Limited Partner hereby agrees that, the Partnership may invest in any
company in which a Successor Fund or Prior Fund (or any other investment fund managed by any of the
General Partner. the Affiliated Parties or their Affiliates) holds an interest. whenever the General Partner. in
its discretion. so determines that an investment in such company would be appropriate for the Partnership:
provided. however. that without the consent of the Advisory Committee, the Partnership may not make an
investment of more than fi ve million dollars (45.000.000) in any such company. In addition, without the
consent of the Advisory Committee, the Partnership shall not invest in any company in which the Managing
Members, the General Partner, the Management Company or any of their Affiliates hold a direct interest
(i.e.. an interest not held through a Successor Fund. Prior Fund or other investment fund managed by any of
the General Partner, the Affiliated Parties or their Affiliates).

(e) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee. the Partnership may not
purchase Securities from or sell Securities to the General Partner. any Parallel Fund or related entity. any
Affiliated Party. any Thiel Person or an Affiliate thereof or any investment fund managed thereby: provided.
however. that each Limited Partner hereby agrees that. following the final admission of Limited Partners
I pursuant to paragraph 3.2(b)4 the Partnership may purchase Securities from or sell Securities to one or
more Parallel Funds at cost for the purpose of allocating then-existing Securities between such entities in
proportion to their respective available capital.

(I) Each Limited Partner hereby agrees that: (i) an Affiliated Party. an Affiliate
thereof or any member or employee of any of the foregoing. or any investment fund managed thereby may
invest personally in Securities of any portfolio company where the Securities of such portfolio company are.
at the time of such investment. Marketable Securities: provided that, the aggregate amount of any such
investments in the same portfolio company may not exceed 2% of the aggregate cost basis of the
Partnership's investment(s) in such portfolio company: and (ii) any Successor Fund or Prior Fund (or other
25.
12N/705610
116116015 vl
fund described in paragraph 8.3(b) to the extent the applicable investment does not meet the investment
objectives of the Partnership) may invest in a portfolio company of the Partnership.

(g) The General Partner shall use its reasonable best efforts to operate the Partnership
in a manner that will not cause any Partner subject to Section 511 of the Code to recognize unrelated
business taxable income under Section 512 of the Code or unrelated debt-financed income under Section
514 of the Code ("UBTf"): provided, however, that the Partnership may. subject to paragraph 8.4(n).
borrow money pending the due date of a capital call so long as such borrowing would be repaid promptly
following the delivery of capital due in connection with such capital call and would not create a material
likelihood that any Limited Partner subject to Section 511 of the Code would incur UBTI.

(h) For so long as "equity participation" in the Partnership by "benefit plan investors"
is "significant" (as such terms are defined in the DOL Regulations). (i) the General Partner shall use its
reasonable best efforts to operate the Partnership such that it qualifies as a "venture capital operating
company" under the DOL Regulations, (ii) at least 30 days prior to the end of the Partnership's "annual
valuation period" (as such term is defined in the DOL Regulations). the General Partner shall deliver to
each Limited Partner a certificate, prepared in consultation with counsel to the Partnership. which confirms
that the Partnership qualifies as a venture capital operating company and will continue to qualify as a
venture capital operating company immediately following the expiration of the annual valuation period and
(iii) the General Partner shall notify each Limited Partner as promptly as practicable following any
determination by the General Partner that there is a material likelihood that the Partnership has ceased to
qualify as a venture capital operating company.

(I) The General Partner shall use its commercially reasonable efforts to: (w) avoid
causing any Limited Partner, solely as a result of such Limited Partner's status as a limited partner in the
Partnership, to be required to file income tax returns other than any return. certification or statement
necessary to obtain a refund of or reduction in tax in any jurisdiction outside of the United States in
connection with the Partnership's investment in any portfolio company organized or with its principal place
of business or primary operations in such jurisdiction: (x) operate the Partnership in a manner that will not
cause it to be engaged in a "trade or business within the United States" within the meaning of Section 864(b)
of the Code: (y) avoid the Partnership realizing income that is or is treated as being "effectively connected"
with the conduct of a trade or business in the United States for United States federal income tax purposes:
and (z) prevent the Partnership from acquiring any interest in real property located in the United States for
purposes of Section 897 of the Code or in any company that is at the time of such investment a "United
States real property holding corporation" within the meaning of Section 897(c) of the Code.
After the General Partner has used commercially reasonable efforts to avoid the Partnership realizing
income that is or is treated as being "effectively connected" with the conduct of a trade or business in the
United States, if the General Partner has actual knowledge that a particular transaction will generate income
"effectively connected" with a trade or business in the United States (within the meaning of the Code), or
similar income in another country. the General Partner shall use reasonable best efforts to provide each
Limited Partner with such information that is reasonably available to the General Partner and which such
Limited Partner reasonably requests in order to file any federal, state or local tax return in the United States
or such other country in which such income is generated.

For transactions causing any Limited Partner, solely as a result of such Limited Partner's status as a limited
partner in the Partnership. to be required to file income tax returns other than any return, certification or
statement necessary to obtain a refund of or reduction in tax in any jurisdiction outside of the United States
in connection with the Partnership's investment in any portfolio company organized or with its principal
place of business or primary operations in such jurisdiction, the General Partner shall use commercially
reasonable efforts to provide such Limited Partner with such information that is reasonably available to the
26.
122070361v1
1,6116014
General Partner and which such Limited Partner reasonably requests in order to file income tax return in
such jurisdiction.
(0 Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, the Partnership may not
invest more than five percent (5%) of the Partnership's Committed Capital in a "blind pool" investment
fund that is managed and controlled by an unaffiliated third party and that pays its manager performance
based compensation tnemhip4miy-invem-up-to-filteen-peroentaf-the
Ptioneraliiii4i-Gonnoitteil-emitalitleremtinedim-the-hothe oforepretitiomeotit-the-tit of
oar athor-st ment-fund-whieh4N-managethand-tio.ntrolled-44in4maffitiateihdrire-party,and-whieh
moy-pay4i-Mallagef-reffoftliatla.-beSed-eafflpeeSa44011:-,i0-loogoo-iitieli-lekiestmereithithspoeifieoliy-allows
ithiloresioni-toropt-in'Llorechinvooment-thot-sueliiiivesonent-fuirentakesimoninvestinein-by-iiwesonere

(k) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, no more than twenty-five
percent (25%) of the Partnership's aggregate Capital Commitments (determined on the basis of acquisition
cost at the time of investment) may be invested in the Securities of. or loaned to. any one (I) portfolio
company (including. for this purpose. the Affiliates of such portfolio company).

(I) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee, not more than fifteen
percent (15%) of the Partnership's Capital Commitments (determined on the basis of acquisition cost at the
time of investment) may be invested in Securities that are publicly traded-on-a=Restriered-foolinage;
excluding Securities issued in a private offering by an issuer who then also has outstanding publicly-traded
Securities. -For-puqinses-of-the-throgoinigraffesirireed-Eirehmige"
Elf-emal4i4k41-~r-the-600414eF-tratling-ssimein-(nn-tht 4-eintemaied-Sefeeil-based-ctueiation-and-watle
execution-system-operitted-4—The-NASDAQ-ONOC-Grouprlitia-in the United-Stittre-or-the-United
Kingdom.

(m) Without the prior approval of the Advisory Committee and subject to paragraph
8.4(g). the General Partner may not cause the Partnership to incur debt, or guaranty indebtedness of the
Partnership's portfolio companies (and including, for this purpose. their respective Affiliates), in an
aggregate amount exceeding the lesser of (A) ten percent (10%) of the Partnership's Capital Commitments
(determined on the basis of acquisition cost at the time of investment) and (B) the amount of aggregate
Capital Commitments of the Partners that have not been contributed to the Partnership as of the date of such
debt or guaranty indebtedness: provided, however, that 441-amounts borrowed by the Partnership pending
the due date of a capital call, which are due to be. and are, fully repaid promptly following the delivery of
capital from the Partners which was due in connection with such capital call and-04)-ismostmenth-in
eonvertible-note6-shall not be treated as indebtedness of the Partnership for purposes of the limitation in this
paragraph 8.4(m).

(n) The cumulative aggregate cost basis of portfolio company investments made by
the Partnership may not exceed one hundred twenty percent (120%) of the aggregate Capital Commitments
of the Partners.
ARTICLE 9
INVESTMENT REPRESENTATION AND TRANSFER
OF PARTNERSHIP INTERESTS
9.1 Investment Representation of the Limited Partners. This Agreement is made with each
of the Limited Partners in reliance upon each Limited Partner's representation to the Partnership. which by
executing this Agreement each Limited Partner hereby confirms, that its interest in the Partnership is to be
27.
122a7aCklvl
/ 76116014 vt
acquired for investment, and not with a view to the sale or distribution of any part thereof, and that it has no
present intention of selling, granting participation in. or otherwise distributing the same. and each Limited
Partner understands that its interest in the Partnership has not been registered under the Securities Act and
that any transfer or other disposition of the interest may not be made without registration under the
Securities Act or pursuant to an applicable exemption therefrom. Each Limited Partner further represents
that it does not have any contract, undertaking. agreement. or arrangement with any person to sell, transfer.
or grant participations to such person. or to any third person. with respect to its interest in the Partnership.
9.2 Qualifications of the Limited Partners. Each Limited Partner represents that it is an
"accredited investor" within the meaning of that term as defined in Regulation D promulgated under the
Securities Act.

9.3 Transfer by General Partner. The General Partner shall not sell, assign. mortgage.
pledge or otherwise dispose of its interest in the Partnership or in its capital assets or property without the
prior written consent of Two-Thirds in Interest of the Limited Partners. Admissions of new members of the
General Partner or the transfer of interests in the General Partner by its members shall not be deemed to be
a sale or other disposition of the General Partner's interest in the Partnership for purposes of this paragraph
9.3: provided. however, that without the prior consent of a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners, new
members may not be admitted to the General Partner. and interests in the General Partner may not be
transferred, to the extent that the effect of such admissions and transfers would result in fifty percent (50%)
or more of the interests in the General Partner being owned by persons who are not Managing Members.
Notwithstanding the foregoing. in no event shall the General Partner make any transfer of an interest in the
Partnership prohibited by the events described in paragraphs 9.5(a) through 9.5(h).
9.4 Transfer by Limited Partner. No Limited Partner shall sell, assign. pledge. mortgage. or
otherwise dispose of or transfer its interest in the Partnership. directly or indirectly, without the prior written
consent of the General Partner. which consent may be granted or denied in the sole discretion of the General
Partner (which consent shall not be required in the event of a transfer pursuant to the following sentence of
this paragraph 9.4). Notwithstanding the foregoing, after delivery of the opinion of counsel hereinafter
required by this Article 9 (provided. however. that the General Partner may. in its sole discretion. waive the
requirement of an opinion of counsel), a Limited Partner may sell, assign. pledge. mortgage. or otherwise
dispose of or transfer its interest in the Partnership. directly or indirectly, without such consent (a) to any
entity directly or indirectly holding eighty percent (80%) or more of the ownership interests of the Limited
Partner (including profits or other economic interests) or any entity of which eighty percent (80%) or more
of the beneficial ownership (including profits or other economic interests) are held directly or indirectly by
such entity. including any entity of which the Limited Partner holds, directly or indirectly, eighty percent
(80%) or more of the beneficial ownership (including profits or other economic interests), (b) pursuant to a
merger. plan of reorganization. sale or pledge of. or other general encumbrance on all or substantially all of
the Limited Partner's assets. (c) as may be required by any law or regulation. (d) by testamentary
disposition or intestate succession. (e) to a mi st, profit sharing plan or other entity controlled by. or for the
benefit of. such Limited Partner or one or more of its family members or (0 during the six (6) month period
immediately following its admission as a Limited Partner, to an Affiliate entity that is also a Limited Partner
where the sole purpose of such transfer is to adjust the relative holdings of such Affiliate and the original
Limited Partner. A change in any trustee or fiduciary of the Limited Partner shall not be considered to be a
transfer, sale, assignment. mortgage. pledge or other disposition under this paragraph 9.4. provided written
notice of such change is given to the General Partner within a reasonable period of time after the effective
date thereof.

9.5 Requirements for Transfer. No transfer or other disposition of the interest of the Limited
Partner shall be permitted until the General Partner shall have received an opinion of counsel satisfactory to
it (or waived such opinion requirement) that the effect of such transfer or disposition would not:
28.
S22070%10
1,6116015 v1

(a) result in the Partnership's assets, or any portion thereof, being considered, in the
opinion of counsel for the Partnership. as "plan assets" within the meaning of the DOL Regulations. or
result in a non-exempt prohibited transaction under Section 4975 of the Code:

(b) result in a violation of the Securities Act or any comparable state law:
(c) require the Partnership to register as an investment company under the Investment
Company Act of 1940. as amended:

(d) require the Partnership, the General Partner, or any member of the General Partner
to register as an investment adviser under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. as amended:

(e) result in a termination of the Partnership's status as a partnership for tax purposes:
(I) result in a violation of any law. rule. or regulation by the Limited Partner, the
Partnership. the General Partner. or any member of the General Partner:

(g) cause the Partnership to be deemed to be a ipubliely traded partnership" as such
term is defined in Section 7704(b) of the Code; or
(h) result in a violation of this Agreement.

Such legal opinion shall be provided to the General Partner by the transferring Limited Partner or the
proposed transferee. Any costs associated with such opinion shall be borne by the transferring Limited
Partner or the proposed transferee. Upon request. the General Partner will use its good faith diligent efforts
to provide any information possessed by the Partnership and reasonably requested by a transferring Limited
Partner to enable it to render the foregoing opinion. Notwithstanding any provision of this Article 9 to the
contrary. the General Partner may. in its sole discretion. waive the requirement of an opinion of counsel
provided for in this paragraph 9.5. Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein. in no event shall the
General Partner consent to any transfer of an interest in the Partnership. or waive the requirement of an
opinion of counsel with respect to any transfer for which the consent of the General Partner is not required.
if such transfer would. in the reasonable determination of the General Partner. result in any of the events
described in paragraphs 9.5(a) through 9.5(h). Any transfer of an interest in the Partnership in violation of
the requirements of paragraph 9.4 or this paragraph 9.5 shall be null and void ab initio.
9.6 Substitution as a Limited Partner. A transferee of a Limited Partner's interest pursuant
to this Article 9 shall become a substituted Limited Partner only with the consent of the General Partner
(which consent shall not be required in the event of a transfer pursuant to paragraph 9.4(0) and only if such
transferee (a) elects to become a substituted Limited Partner and (b) executes, acknowledges and delivers to
the Partnership such other instruments as the General Partner may deem necessary or advisable to effect the
admission of such transferee as a substituted Limited Partner, including, without limitation, the written
acceptance and adoption by such transferee of the provisions of this Agreement. No assignment by a
Limited Partner of its interest in the Partnership shall release the assignor from its liabilities to the
Partnership. including but not limited to those liabilities enumerated in paragraph 4.2; provided. however if
the assignee becomes a Limited Partner as provided in this paragraph 9.6. the assignor shall thereupon so be
released (in the case of a partial assignment. to the extent of such assignment).
9.7 Expenses of Transfer. Any costs or expenses (including but not limited to reasonable
attorneys' fees) incurred by the Partnership in connection with the transfer of a Partnership interest
hereunder (including any costs associated with any opinion rendered pursuant to paragraph 9.5 above) shall
be borne jointly and severally by the transferring Limited Partner and the proposed transferee.
29.
gwmcyvt
1,61/6ffii
ARTICLE 10
DISSOLUTION AND LIQUIDATION OF THE PARTNERSHIP
10.1 Extension of Partnership Term. Upon the Termination Date, or such subsequent dates to
which the Partnership term has previously been extended pursuant to this paragraph 10.1. the General
Partner in its sole discretion may extend the Partnership term for up to two (2) additional one (1) year
periods and, thereafter and with the consent of a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners. for additional
one (1) year periods thereafter. During any such one (I) year extension periods, the General Partner shall
use its reasonable efforts to convert the Partnership's Nonmarketable Securities into Marketable Securities
or cash, and all Securities that become Marketable Securities during such period or periods shall be
promptly distributed by the Partnership. The General Partner shall not purchase the Securities of any new
issuer in which the Partnership does not already hold an interest during such period: provided, however. that
the General Partner may (a) purchase additional Securities of a portfolio company if it deems such a
purchase to be in the best interests of the Partnership. and (b) exchange the Securities of a portfolio
company for other Securities. The Management Fee for each fiscal quarter during an extension period (i)
shall be an amount equal to the  product of (A) the lower of ill  the cost basis of the portfolio company
Securities held by the Partnership as of the first day of such fiscal quarter and (II) the fair market value of
such Securities  multiplied by (B) the Management Fee Percentage in effect as of the first day of such fiscal
quarter (as determined under Article 6). and (ii) shall otherwise be governed by the provisions set forth in
Article 6.
10.2 Early Termination of the Partnership.

(a) The Partnership shall dissolve, and the affairs of the Partnership shall be wound up
prior to the Termination Date (or such subsequent dates to which the Partnership term has previously been
extended pursuant to paragraph 10.1):

(i) ninety (90) days after the withdrawal. bankruptcy. or dissolution of the
General Partner. unless a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners elect to continue the Partnership
within such ninety (90) day period:

(II) upon the election of Two-Thirds in interest of the Limited Partners within
sixty days (60) days of the delivery of the notice of Trigger Event: or
(ill) at any time upon the election of Eighty Percent (80%) in Interest of the
Limited Partners.

(b) In the event that the Partnership is dissolved pursuant to the provisions of this
paragraph 10.2. a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners shall elect one or more liquidators to manage
the liquidation of the Partnership in the manner described in paragraphs 10.3. 10.4 and 10.5.
10.3 Winding Up Procedures.

(a) Promptly upon dissolution of the Partnership (unless the Partnership is continued
in accordance with this Agreement or the provisions of the Act), the affairs of the Partnership shall be
wound up and the Partnership liquidated. The closing Capital Accounts of all the Partners shall be
computed as of the date of dissolution as if the date of dissolution were the last day of an Accounting Period
in accordance with Article 5, and then adjusted in the following manner:
30.
1220705610
/ 76116014 vl

(I) All assets and liabilities of the Partnership shall be valued as of the date of
dissolution.
(II) The Partnership's assets as of the date of dissolution shall be deemed to
have been sold at their fair market values and the resulting Profit or Loss shall be allocated to the Partners'
Capital Accounts in accordance with the provisions of Article 5.

(b) Distributions during the winding up period may be made in cash or in kind or
partly in cash and partly in kind: provided. however, that the General Partner or the liquidator, as the case
may be. shall notify the Limited Partners at least ten (10) business days prior to making a distribution in
kind pursuant to this paragraph 10.3(b). The General Partner or the liquidator shall use its best judgment as
to the most advantageous time for the Partnership to sell Securities or to make distributions in kind. All
cash and each Security distributed in kind after the date of dissolution of the Partnership shall be distributed
ratably in accordance with the provisions of paragraph 4.2(d). if applicable, but otherwise in accordance
with Article 7. unless such distribution would result in a violation of a law or regulation applicable to a
Limited Partner, in which event. upon receipt by the General Partner of notice to such effect. such Limited
Partner may designate a different entity to receive the distribution, or designate. subject to the approval of
the General Partner (which may be withheld in the General Partner's sole discretion), an alternative
distribution procedure (provided, hmvever, that such alternative distribution procedure does not prejudice
any of the other Partners). Each Security so distributed shall be subject to reasonable conditions and
restrictions necessary or advisable, as determined in the reasonable discretion of the General Partner or the
liquidator, in order to preserve the value of such Security or for legal reasons.
10.4 Payments in Liquidation. The assets of the Partnership shall be distributed in final
liquidation of the Partnership in the following order:

(a) to the creditors of the Partnership. including those Partners who are creditors of the
Partnership. in the order of priority established by law, either by payment or by establishment of reserves:
and

(b) the balance, if any. to the General Partner and the Limited Partners as if such
distributions were made pursuant to paragraph 7.4(b) and paragraph 7.5(a). as applicable: provided.
however, that the General Partner shall be obligated to contribute to the Partnership an amount in cash, or
Securities (previously distributed in kind from the Partnership) with a fair market value equal to the
amounts the General Partner is obligated to pay back under paragraph 10.5(a).
10.5 Return of Excess Distributions.

(a) Notwithstanding paragraphs 7.3 and 10.4. upon liquidation of the Partnership
pursuant to this Article 10. the General Partner shall be required to pay back to the Partnership the amount
by which the Carried Interest Distributions (as defined below in paragraph 10.5(b)) exceeds (i) in the event
that the First Allocation Hurdle has not been met. 20% of the aggregate distributions made to the Partners
pursuant to paragraphs 7.5(a)(ii)-(vi). (ii) in the event that the First Allocation Hurdle has been met but the
Second Allocation Hurdle has not been met. 25% of the aggregate distributions made to the Partners
pursuant to paragraphs 7.5(a)(ii)-(vi). or (iii) in the event that the Second Allocation Hurdle has been met.
3096 of the aggregate distributions made to the Partners pursuant to paragraphs 7.5(a)(ii)-(vi).
Notwithstanding the foregoing. the General Partner's payment obligation pursuant to this paragraph 10.5(a)
shall not exceed the After-Tax Distribution Amount (as defined below in paragraph 10.5(b)).

(b) For purposes of this paragraph 10.5: (i) the "Carried Interest Distributions" shall
equal all distributions to the General Partner other than distributions made to the General Partner in respect
31.
S22670%10
1,6116014 vl
of its Partnership Percentage (excluding amounts returned to the Partnership by the General Partner
pursuant to paragraphs 4.2(d)(ii) prior to final liquidation of the Partnership): and (ii) the "After -Tax
Distribution Amount" shall be equal to the Carried Interest Distributions, less the gross tax liabilities that
the General Partner would have incurred on all allocations of taxable income (net of losses) made with
respect to the General Partner's interest in the Company (other than the portion of its interest attributable to
its Partnership Percentage) if: (x) at all times the General Partner were subject to the highest blended federal.
state and local marginal income tax rate then applicable to an individual residing in any state in the United
States, applied by taking into account the character of the taxable income in question (i.e., long-term capital
gains, ordinary income. etc.): and (y) all such allocations resulted from fully taxable transactions, plus any
tax benefit actually received by the General Partner in the year in which the General Partner is required to
make a payment pursuant to this paragraph 10.5. as reasonably determined by the General Partner, which
such tax benefit is attributable solely to the making of such payment and which benefit shall be determined
after first taking all other items of income, gain, loss. deduction or credit of the General Partner (or its direct
or indirect owners) into account.

(c) In the event that the assets of the General Partner are insufficient to satisfy the
obligation described in paragraph 10.5(b). each Managing Member and managing member of the General
Partner shall be severally liable for and shall personally guaranty his or her pro rata share of the General
Partner's remaining obligation to the Partnership under this paragraph 10.5 by executing a written guaranty
(in substantially the same form provided to the Limited Partners prior to the date first written above). The
pro rata shares described in the preceding sentence shall be based on relative distributions received by each
such Managing Member. or managing member of the General Partner, from the General Partner. The
General Partner's operating agreement shall contain a provision requiring each newly-admitted managing
member to personally guaranty his, her or its respective pro rata share of the General Partner's obligation
under this paragraph 10.5 by executing a written guaranty (in substantially the same form provided to the
Limited Partners prior to the date first written above).

(d) In addition to the amount to be contributed by the General Partner pursuant to
paragraph 10.5(a). if. upon liquidation of the Partnership. the cumulative Fee Adjustments applied against
Management Fees paid pursuant to paragraph 6.1 for all Accounting Periods. exceeds the sum of (i) the
cumulative Profits of the Partnership for all Accounting Periods less (ii) the cumulative Losses of the
Partnership for all Accounting Periods (such amount the "Deemed Contribution Shortfall"), then the
General Partner or its designated Affiliate with a capital contribution obligation  shall be required to pay
back to the Partnership. the lesser of (x) the Deemed Contribution Shortfall and (y) the distributions
received by the General Partner that are attributable to the cumulative amount of Profit allocated to the
General Partner pursuant to paragraph 5.1(a)(ikla-thoeyem-that-tht cithi-Genecal-Pactnec), in each
case less the Bross tax liabilities that the General Partner would have incurred on all allocations of taxable
income (net of losses) made with respect to the Fee Adjustments if: (x) at all times the General Partner or its
designated Affiliate were subject to the highest blended federal, state and local marginal income tax rate
then applicable to an individual residing in any state in the United States, applied by taking into account die
character of the taxable income in Question (i.e.. long-term capital tains. ordinary income. etc.): and (v) all
such allocations resulted from fully taxable transactions, plus any tax benefit actually received by the
General Partner or its designated Affiliate in the year in which the  payment is required pursuant to this
paragraph 10.5(d). as reasonably determined by the General Partner. which such tax benefit is attributable
solely to the making of such payment and which benefit shall be determined after first taking all other items
of income. gain, loss, deduction or credit of the General Partner or its designated Affiliate (or their direct or
indirect owners) into account. In the event that the assets of the General Partner or its designated Affiliate
are insufficient to satisfy the obligation described in the preceding sentence, all members of the General
Partner or its designated Affiliate  will on a several, but not joint. basis contribute capital to the General
Partner or its designated Affiliate  in an amount equal to each such member's pro rata share of theGettend
32.
12207056.1v1
176116014 vt
P-ilaReFLS remaining obligation to the Partnership (based on the member's pro rata participation in any
Cashless Portion of he Cana.' Pnane; A any capital contributions to the Partnership).
ARTICLE 11
FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING, REPORTS AND MEETINGS
11.1 Financial Accounting; Fiscal Year. The books and records of the Partnership shall be
kept in accordance with the provisions of this Agreement and otherwise in accordance with generally
accepted accounting principles consistently applied. and shall be audited at the end of each fiscal year
beginning with fiscal year 2016 by an independent public accountant selected by the General Partner. The
Partnership's fiscal year shall be the calendar year.

11.2 Supervision; Inspection of Books. Proper and complete books of account of the
Partnership. copies of the Partnership's federal, state and local tax returns for each fiscal year. the Schedule
of Partners set forth in EXHIBIT A. this Agreement and the Partnership's Certificate of Limited Partnership
shall be kept under the supervision of the General Partner at the principal office of the Partnership. Such
books and records shall be open to inspection (including by email or other electronic means) by the Limited
Partners. or their accredited representatives. at not less than three (3) business days' notice, at any
reasonable time during normal business hours.

11.3 Quarterly Reports. The General Partner shall use reasonable best efforts to transmit to
the Limited Partners, within sixty (60) days after the close of each of the first three quarters of each fiscal
year beginning with fiscal year 2016. a list of investments then held, together with a valuation of the
investments then held and unaudited financial statements of the Partnership. including a statement of capital
accounts.

11.4 Annual Report; Financial Statements of the Partnership. Beginning with fiscal year

2016. the General Partner shall use reasonable best efforts to transmit to the Limited Partners within ninety
(90) days after the close of the Partnership's fiscal year audited financial statements of the Partnership
prepared in accordance with the terms of this Agreement and otherwise in accordance with generally
accepted accounting principles. including an income statement for the year then ended and a balance sheet
as of the end of such year. a statement of changes in the Partners' Capital Accounts. and a list of
investments then held. The financial statements shall be accompanied by a report from the General Partner
to the Limited Partners. which shall include a status report on investments then held. a summary of
acquisitions and dispositions of investments made by the Partnership during the preceding quarter and a
valuation of each such investment.

11.5 Website Based Reporting. The General Partner shall be entitled. in its sole discretion, to
transmit the reports and statements described in paragraphs 11.3 and II.4 (the "Subject Reports") to one or
more Limited Partners solely by means of granting such Limited Partners access to a database or other
forum hosted on a website designated by the General Partner (the "Reporting Site"), with such parameters
regarding access and availability of information for review as the General Partner deems reasonably
necessary to protect the confidentiality and proprietary nature of the information contained therein
(including. but not limited to. establishing password protections for access to the Reporting Site and having
such Subject Reports available for review for a restricted period of time (but in no event less than thirty (30)
days from the date the Limited Partners are notified that such Subject Reports are posted on the Reporting
Site)). The General Partner shall provide each Limited Partner to which it will transmit Subject Reports
pursuant to this paragraph 11.5 notice of the first date on which a new Subject Report will be posted on the
Reporting Site for such Limited Partner's review and shall either (i) make each Subject Report printable or

(ii) upon written request by a Limited Partner, deliver a mailed copy of the Subject Report to such Limited
33.
t220,7atioAq
1,61i6mi 4 vl
Partner. Unless the General Partner exercises its discretion pursuant to and in compliance with paragraph
15.15(c) to restrict access to certain Confidential Information that may be included in a Subject Report
posted on the Reporting Site. the Subject Reports posted on the Reporting Site shall contain all of the
material information included in those Subject Reports transmitted to Limited Partners other than pursuant
to this paragraph 11.5 and shall be print-capable. The Subject Reports shall be posted on the Reporting Site
within the same number of days after the end of the applicable fiscal quarter or Fiscal Year as is required
pursuant to paragraphs 11.3 and 11.4.

11.6 Annual Meeting. A meeting of the Partners shall be held annually from the year of 2016.
Such annual meeting may be held at the principal office of the Partnership (unless otherwise designated by
the General Partner) or be held by conference call as determined by the General Partner.
11.7 Tax Returns.

(a) The General Partner shall endeavor to cause the Partnership's estimated federal.
state and local tax returns. IRS Form 1065. Schedule K-1 and any other tax information reasonably
requested by a Limited Partner to be prepared and delivered to the Limited Partners within ninety (90) days
after the close of the Partnership's fiscal year.
(b) Each Limited Partner hereby agrees and covenants that it shall not make an
election under Section 732(d) of the Code with respect to property distributed to it by the Partnership
without the prior written consent of the General Partner. The General Partner may. but shall not be
obligated to. cause the Partnership to make an election under Section 754 of the Code or an election to be
treated as an "electing investment partnership" within the meaning of Section 743(e) of the Code. If the
Partnership elects to be treated as an electing investment partnership. each Limited Partner shall (i)
reasonably cooperate with the Partnership to maintain such status. (ii) shall not take any action that would
be reasonably inconsistent with such election. (iii) provide the General Partner with any information
necessary to allow the Partnership to comply with its obligations to make tax basis adjustments under
Sections 734 or 743 of the Code and its tax reporting and other obligations as an electing investment
partnership. and (iv) provide the General Partner and any such Limited Partner's transferee (if applicable).
promptly upon request. with the information required under Section 6031(b) of the Code or otherwise to be
furnished to the Partnership or such transferee, including such information as is reasonably necessary to
enable the Partnership and such transferee to compute the amount of losses disallowed under Section 743(e)
of the Code, but in no event shall such Limited Partner be required to provide such information prior to its
receipt of its Schedule K-I for such taxable year. except to the extent of information, if any. required by the
Partnership to complete its Schedule K- Is. Whether or not the Partnership makes such election, promptly
upon request. each Limited Partner shall provide the General Partner with any information related to such
Partner reasonably necessary to allow the Partnership to comply with (i) its obligations to make tax basis
adjustments under Sections 734 or 743 of the Code and (ii) any other tax reporting obligations of the
Partnership.

11.8 Tax Matters Partner. The General Partner shall be the Partnership's tax matters partner
under the Code and under any comparable provision of state law. The General Partner shall have the right
to resign as tax matters partner by giving thirty (30) days' written notice to each Partner. Upon such
resignation a successor tax matters partner shall be selected by a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners.
The tax matters partner shall employ experienced tax counsel to represent the Partnership in connection
with any audit or investigation of the Partnership by the Internal Revenue Service and in connection with all
subsequent administrative and judicial proceedings arising out of such audit. If the tax matters partner is
required by law or regulation to incur fees and expenses in connection with tax matters not affecting all the
Partners, then the Partnership shall be entitled to reimbursement from those Partners on whose behalf such
fees and expenses were incurred. The tax matters partner shall keep the Partners informed of all
34.
122070561v1
1,6116014 vl
administrative and judicial proceedings. as required by Section 6223(g) of the Code. and shall furnish to
each Partner. if such Partner so requests in writing, a copy of each notice or other communication received
by the tax matters partner from the Internal Revenue Service, except such notices or communications as are
sent directly to such requesting Partner by the Internal Revenue Service. The relationship of the tax matters
partner to the Limited Partners is that of a fiduciary. and the tax matters partner has fiduciary obligations to
perform its duties as tax matters partner in such manner as will serve the best interests of the Partnership and
all of the Partnership's Partners. To the fullest extent permitted by law. but subject to the limitations and
exclusions of paragraph 15.4. the Partnership agrees to indemnify the tax matters partner and its agents and
save and hold them harmless. from and in respect to all (a) fees, costs and expenses in connection with or
resulting from any claim, action, or demand against the tax matters partner. the General Partner or the
Partnership that arise out of or in any way relate to the tax matters partner's status as tax matters partner for
the Partnership. and (b) all such claims. actions, and demands and any losses or damages therefrom.
including amounts paid in settlement or compromise of any such claim, action. or demand.
11.9 Partnership Funds. Cash held by the Partnership shall be promptly deposited into an
account in a reputable bank or financial institution (as determined by the General Partner in its reasonable
discretion).
ARTICLE 12
VALUATION; ADVISORY COMMITTEE
12.1 Valuation. Subject to the specific standards set forth below. the valuation of Securities
and other assets and liabilities under this Agreement shall be at fair market value. Except as may be
required under applicable Treasury Regulations. no value shall be placed on the goodwill or the name of the
Partnership in determining the value of the interest of any Partner or in any accounting among the Partners.

(a) The following criteria shall be used for determining the fair market value of
Securities:
(I) If traded on one or more securities exchanges or the NASDAQ National
Market System. the value shall be deemed to be the Securities' closing price on the principal of such
exchanges on the valuation date.

(II) If actively traded over the counter (other than on the NASDAQ National
Market System). the value shall be deemed to be the closing price of such Securities on the valuation date.
(III) If there is no active public market, the value shall be the fair market value
thereof. as determined by the General Partner. taking into consideration the purchase price of the Securities.
developments concerning the investee company subsequent to the acquisition of the Securities. any
financial data and projections of the investee company provided to the General Partner, and such other
factor or factors as the General Partner may deem relevant.

(b) If the General Partner in good faith determines that. because of special
circumstances, the valuation methods set forth in this Article 12 do not fairly determine the value of a
Security, the General Partner shall make such adjustments or use such alternative valuation method as it
deems appropriate.

(c) The General Partner shall have the power at any time to determine, for all purposes
of this Agreement. the fair market value of any assets and liabilities of the Partnership. subject to paragraph
12.1(d).
35.
tib0056Avl
116116014 vl
(d) If within thirty (30) days of receipt of a proposed valuation established by the
General Partner pursuant to this paragraph 12.1. the Advisory Committee notifies the General Partner of an
objection to such proposed valuation, then, if the General Partner and the Advisory Committee cannot
otherwise mutually agree on the valuation, the General Partner and the Advisory Committee may each
appoint an independent securities expert to render a valuation, and the average of such experts valuations
shall be adopted as the Partnership's valuation. The fees and expenses of any expert retained in accordance
with this paragraph 12.1(d) shall be borne by the Partnership.

12,2 Advisory Committee. The General Partner will appoint an Advisory Committee (the
"Advisory Comminee") that will serve as such for the Partnership and the Parallel Funds and shall consist of
no less than three (3) and no more than seven (7) representatives of the Limited Partners and constituent
limited partners of Parallel Funds selected by the General Partner from time to time in its reasonable
judgment: provided. however, that any Limited Partner that is an Affiliate of the General Partner, the
Management Company. any Managing Member or any of their respective members, employees or
Affiliates may not be appointed to be a member of the Advisory Committee: provided. further, that if the
General Partner affirmatively removes a representative of a Limited Partner from serving on the Advisory
Committee, other than for conduct that the General Partner determines in its reasonable discretion. is
harmful to the Partnership or a Parallel Fund, then such Limited Partner shall be entitled to appoint a
replacement member of the Advisory Committee who is reasonably acceptable to the General Partner. The
duties of the Advisory Committee will include: (a) consideration of any approvals sought by the General
Partner pursuant to the terms of this Agreement: (b) upon request by the General Partner, advising with
respect to all matters pertaining to conflicts of interest by the Partnership, the General Partner or any of the
members of the General Panne' and (c) such advice and counsel as is requested by the General Partner in
connection with the Partnership's investments and other Partnership matters. However. subject to
paragraph 12.1(d). the General Partner will retain ultimate responsibility for asset valuations and for
making all investment decisions. The Partnership will reimburse each member for his or her reasonable
out-of-pocket expenses. All actions, consents or approvals of the Advisory Committee shall require a
majority of its members serving at the time such action. consent or approval is taken, which actions.
consents or approvals may be carried out by telephone, facsimile or electronic mail or other means
reasonably acceptable to the General Partner.
ARTICLE 13
PARTNERS SUBJECT TO SPECIAL REGULATION
13.1 ERLSA Partners.

(a) Each Limited Partner that is. or whose equity interests are at least partially owned
by. a "benefit plan investor" within the meaning of. and subject to the provisions of. ERISA. (each, an
"ERISA Partner") hereby (i) acknowledges that it is its understanding that neither the Partnership. the
General Partner, nor any of the Affiliated Entities of the General Partner. are 'fiduciaries" of such Limited
Partner within the meaning of ERISA by reason of the Limited Partner investing its assets in. and being a
Limited Partner of. the Partnership: (ii) acknowledges that it has been informed of and understands the
investment objectives and policies of, and the investment strategies that may be pursued by. the Partnership:
(iii) acknowledges that it is aware of the provisions of Section 404 of ERISA relating to the requirements
for investment and diversification of the assets of employee benefit plans and trusts subject to ERISA: (iv)
represents that it has given appropriate consideration to the facts and circumstances relevant to the
investment by that ERISA Partner's plan in the Partnership and has determined that such investment is
reasonably designed. as part of such portfolio, to further the purposes of such plan: (v) represents that.
taking into account the other investments made with the assets of such plan. and the diversification thereof,
such plan's investment in the Partnership is consistent with the requirements of Section 404 and other
36.
$22070.561v1
126116014 v 1
provisions of ERISA; (vi) acknowledges that it understands that current income will not be a primary
objective of the Partnership; and (vii) represents that, taking into account the other investments made with
the assets of such plan. the investment of assets of such plan in the Partnership is consistent with the cash
flow requirements and funding objectives of such plan.

(b) Notwithstanding any provision contained herein to the contrary, each ERISA
Partner may elect to withdraw from the Partnership, or upon demand by the General Partner shall withdraw
from the Partnership. at the time and in the manner hereinafter provided, if either the ERISA Partner or the
General Partner shall obtain an opinion of counsel (which counsel shall be reasonably acceptable to both the
ERISA Partner and the General Partner) to the effect that. as a result of applicable statutes, regulations. case
law, administrative interpretations, or similar authority (i) the continuation of the ERISA Partner as a
Limited Partner of the Partnership or the conduct of the Partnership will result. or there is a material
likelihood the same will result, in a material violation of ERISA, or (ii) all or any portion of the assets of the
Partnership constitute assets of the ERISA Partner and are subject to the provisions of ERISA to
substantially the same extent as if owned directly by the ERISA Partner. In the event of the issuance of such
opinion of counsel, a copy of such opinion shall be given to all the ERISA Partners, together with the
written notice of the election of the ERISA Partner to withdraw or the written demand of the General
Partner for withdrawal. whichever the case may be. Thereupon. unless within ninety (90) days after receipt
of such written notice and opinion the General Partner is able to eliminate the necessity for such withdrawal
to the reasonable satisfaction of the ERISA Partner and the General Partner, whether by correction of the
condition giving rise to the necessity of the ERISA Partner's withdrawal, or the amendment of this
Agreement. or otherwise. such ERISA Partner shall withdraw its entire interest in the Partnership. such
withdrawal to be effective upon the last day of the fiscal quarter during which such ninety (90) day period
expired.

(c) The withdrawing ERISA Partner shall be entitled to receive within ninety (90)
days after the date of such withdrawal an amount equal to the amount of such Partner's Capital Account as
of the effective date of such withdrawal.

(d) Any distribution or payment to a withdrawing ERISA Partner pursuant to this
paragraph may. in the sole discretion of the General Partner. be made in cash. in securities, in the form of a
promissory note. the terms of which shall be mutually agreed upon by the General Partner and the
withdrawing ERISA Partner, or any combination thereof.

(e) Any valuation necessary for the purposes of a distribution or payment to a
withdrawing ERISA Partner pursuant to this paragraph shall be made by the General Partner in good faith
pursuant to paragraph 12.1.

13.2 Governmental Plan Partners. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the
contrary. any Limited Partner that is either a "governmental plan" as defined in Title 29. Section 1002(32)
of the United States Code or an employee benefit plan subject to Governmental Plan Regulations (a
"Governmental Plan Partner") may elect to withdraw from the Partnership. or upon demand by the
General Partner shall withdraw from the Partnership. if either the Governmental Plan Partner or the General
Partner shall obtain an opinion of counsel (which counsel shall be reasonably acceptable to both the
Governmental Plan Partner and the General Partner) to the effect that the Governmental Plan Partner, the
Partnership, or the General Partner would be in violation, or there is a material likelihood the same would
result, of any Governmental Plan Regulation. as a result of the Governmental Plan Partner continuing as a
Limited Partner, and. in the case of an opinion obtained by the General Partner, that such violation would
have a material adverse effect on the General Partner or the Partnership. In the event of the issuance of the
opinion of counsel referred to in the preceding sentence, the withdrawal of and disposition of the
Governmental Plan Partner's interest in the Partnership shall be governed by paragraph 13.1 of the
37.
$221170361v1
/16116015 v 1
Agreement. as if the Governmental Plan Partner were an ERISA Partner.

13.3 Private Foundation Partners. Notwithstanding any provision of the Agreement to the
contrary. any Limited Partner that is. or whose equity interests are at least partially owned by. a "private
foundation" as described in Section 509 of the Code (a "Private Foundation Partner"). may elect to
withdraw from the Partnership. or upon demand by the General Partner shall withdraw from the Partnership.
if either the Private Foundation Partner or the General Partner shall obtain an opinion of counsel (which
counsel shall be reasonably acceptable to both the Private Foundation Partner and the General Partner) to
the effect that such withdrawal is necessary in order for the Private Foundation Partner to avoid (a) excise
taxes imposed by Subchapter A of Chapter 42 of the Code (other than Sections 4940 and 4942 thereof). or

(b) a material breach of the fiduciary duties of its trustees under any federal or state law applicable to private
foundations or any rule or regulation adopted thereunder by any agency. commission. or authority having
jurisdiction. In the event of the issuance of the opinion of counsel referred to in the preceding sentence. the
withdrawal of and disposition of the Private Foundation Partner's interest in the Partnership shall be
governed by paragraph 13.1. as if the Private Foundation Partner were an ERISA Partner.
ARTICLE 14
CERTAIN DEFINITIONS
14.1 Accounting Period. An Accounting Period shall be (a) a calendar year if there are no
changes in the Partners' respective interests in the Profits or Losses of the Partnership during such calendar
year except on the first day thereof, or (b) any other period beginning on the first day of a calendar year. or
any other day during a calendar year upon which occurs a change in such respective interests, and ending on
the last day of a calendar year. or on the day preceding an earlier day upon which any change in such
respective interests shall occur.

14.2 Adjusted Asset Value. The Adjusted Asset Value with respect to any asset shall be the
asset's adjusted basis for federal income tax purposes. except as follows:

(a) The initial Adjusted Asset Value of any asset contributed by a Partner to the
Partnership shall be the gross fair market value of such asset at the time of contribution. as determined by
the contributing Partner and the Partnership.

(b) In the discretion of the General Partner. the Adjusted Asset Values of all
Partnership assets may be adjusted to equal their respective gross fair market values, as determined by the
General Partner, and the resulting unrealized profit or loss allocated to the Capital Accounts of the Partners
pursuant to Article 5. as of the following times: (i) upon distribution by the Partnership to a Partner of more
than a de minimis amount of Partnership assets. unless all Partners receive simultaneous distributions of
either undivided interests in the distributed property or identical Partnership assets in proportion to their
interests in Partnership distributions as provided in paragraphs 7.4. 7.5 and 7.6. and (ii) the grant of an
additional interest in the Partnership by any new or existing Partner.

(c) The Adjusted Asset Values of all Partnership assets shall be adjusted to equal their
respective gross fair market values, as determined by the General Partner, and the resulting unrealized
profit or loss allocated to the Capital Accounts of the Partners pursuant to Article 5. as of the termination of
the Partnership either by expiration of the Partnership's term or the occurrence of an event described in
paragraph 10.2.
38.
%DI/70500
V6116015 vt
14.3 Adjusted Capital Account Balance. The Adjusted Capital Account Balance for each
Partner shall be equal to the balance in the Partner's Capital Account as of the end of the relevant
Accounting Period, after giving effect to the following adjustments:

(a) Credit to such Capital Account any amounts which the Partner is obligated to
restorer (calculated as if all assets of the Partnership were sold for their Adiusted Asset Values and the
Partnership were in liquidation)  including, without limitation. amounts described in paragraph 10.5. or is
deemed to be obligated to restore pursuant to the penultimate sentence of Treasury Regulations Section
1.704-1(b)(4)(iv)(1); and
(b) Debit to such Capital Account the items described in Sections
I.704-1(b)(2XiiXd)(4). 1.704-1(b)(2)(ii)(d)(5). and 1.704-1(bX2)(ii)(d)(6) of the Treasury Regulations.
14.4 Affiliate. An Affiliate of any person shall mean (a) any person that directly. or indirectly
through one or more intermediaries. controls, or is controlled by or is under common control with the
person specified or (b) such person's family members within the same line of direct consanguinity or a first
degree of collateral consanguinity; provided. however, that for all purposes under this Agreement. no Thiel
Person shall be deemed to be an Affiliate of any Managing Member. the General Partner or the
Management Company.

14.5 Capital Account. The Capital Account of each Partner shall consist of its original capital
contribution. (a) increased by any additional capital contributions, its share of income or gain that is
allocated to it pursuant to this Agreement. and the amount of any Partnership liabilities that are assumed by
it or that are secured by any Partnership property distributed to it. and (b) decreased by the amount of any
distributions to or withdrawals by it. its share of expense or loss that is allocated to it pursuant to this
Agreement. and the amount of any of its liabilities that are assumed by the Partnership or that are secured by
any property contributed by it to the Partnership. The foregoing provision and the other provisions of this
Agreement relating to the maintenance of Capital Accounts are intended to comply with Treasury
Regulation Section 1.704-100(2)(iv). and shall be interpreted and applied in a manner consistent with such
Regulations. In the event the General Partner shall determine that it is prudent to modify the manner in
which the Capital Accounts, or any debits or credits thereto, are computed in order to comply with such
Regulations. the General Partner may make such modification. prodded. however, that it is not likely to
have more than an insignificant effect on the total amounts distributable to any Partner pursuant to Article 7
and Article 10.
14.6 Capital Commitment; Committed Capital. A Partner's Capital Commitment shall
mean the amount that such Partner has agreed to contribute to the capital of the Partnership as set forth
opposite such Partner's name on its Damn . A hereto. The Partnership's Committed Capital shall equal
the sum of the aggregate Capital Commitments of all Partners.

14.7 Code. The Code is the Internal Revenue Code of 1986. as amended from time to time (or
any corresponding provisions of succeeding law).
14.8 Deemed Gain or Deemed Less. The Deemed Gain from any in kind distribution of
Securities shall be equal to the excess. if any. of the fair market value of the Securities distributed (valued as
of the date of distribution in accordance with paragraph 12.1), over the aggregate Adjusted Asset Value of
the Securities distributed. The Deemed Loss from any in kind distribution of Securities shall be equal to the
excess, if any. of the aggregate Adjusted Asset Value of the Securities distributed over the fair market value
of the Securities distributed (valued as of the date of distribution in accordance with paragraph 12.1).
14.9 Reserved.
39.
1220703610
1,6116014 vt
14.10 Marketable; Marketable Securities; Marketability. These terms shall refer to
Securities that are (i) (A) traded on a national securities exchange or over the counter or (B) currently the
subject of an effective Securities Act registration statement. (ii) not subject to underwriter "lockup" or other
contractual restrictions and (iii) may be sold by each distributee Limited Partner without restriction under
applicable securities laws of the United States or the applicable laws of the jurisdiction of the exchange on
which such Securities are actively traded (other than volume limitations imposed under Securities and
Exchange Commission Rule 144 or similar volume limitations imposed by another jurisdiction).
Notwithstanding the foregoing, a Security shall not be deemed to be a Marketable Security if. in the good
faith judgment of the General Partner, the market on which such Security trades is not adequate to permit an
orderly sale of all shares of such Security held by the Partnership within a reasonable time period.
14.11 Nonmarketable Securities. Nonmarketable Securities are all Securities other than
Marketable Securities.

14.12 Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss. Ordinary Income or Ordinary Loss shall be an
amount computed for each Accounting Period as of the last day thereof that is equal to the sum of all
income received by the Partnership during such Accounting Period from the investment of idle funds in
Short-Term Securities.

14.13 Partnership Percentage. The Partnership Percentage for each Partner shall be equal to
the Capital Commitment of such Partner stated as a percentage of the aggregate Capital Commitments of
the Partnership. and shall be set forth opposite each Panner's name on its EXHIBIT A hereto. For the
avoidance of doubt. the Partnership Percentage of the General Partner shall not be reduced by any Fee
Adjustment amounts.

14.14 Percentage in Interest; Majority in Interest. A specified fraction or percentage in
interest of the Partners or of the Limited Partners shall mean those partners or limited partners of the
Partnership and the Parallel Funds whose Capital Commitments to the Partnership and capital  commitments
to the Parallel Funds, stated as a percentage of the aggregate capital commitments of the Partnership and all
of the Parallel Funds, equal or exceed the required fraction or percentage in interest of all such partners or
limited partners. A Majority in Interest shall mean more than fifty percent (50%) in interest. Any limited
partnership interest owned or controlled by the General Partner, the Management Company. the Managing
Members or any of their employees or Affiliates shall be deemed not to be outstanding for purposes of any
determination under this Agreement of a particular percentage in interest of the Limited Partners and shall
be excluded from voting in any vote taken or consent granted by the Limited Partners under this Agreement.
14.15 Prime Rate. The Prime Rate shall mean an interest rate equal to the floating commercial
rate of interest published in the Wall Street Journal (or its successors) as its prime rate.
14.16 Profit or Loss. Profit or Loss shall be an amount computed for each Accounting Period as
of the last day thereof that is equal to the Partnership's taxable income or loss for such Accounting Period.
determined in accordance with Section 703(a) of the Code (for this purpose. all items of income, gain, loss.
or deduction required to be stated separately pursuant to Code Section 703(a)(1) shall be included in taxable
income or loss), with the following adjustments:

(a) Any income of the Partnership that is exempt from federal income tax and not
otherwise taken into account in computing Profit or Loss pursuant to this paragraph shall be added to such
taxable income or loss:

(b) Any expenditures of the Partnership described in Code Section 705(aX2)(B) or
treated as Code Section 705(a)(2XB) expenditures pursuant to Treasury Regulation Section
40.
122070561v1
1,6116015 vt
1.704-1(b)(2divdi) and not otherwise taken into account in computing Profit or Loss pursuant to this
paragraph shall be subtracted from such taxable income or loss:

(c) Gain or loss resulting from any disposition of a Partnership asset with respect to
which gain or loss is recognized for federal income tax purposes shall be computed by reference to the
Adjusted Asset Value of the asset disposed of rather than its adjusted tax basis:

(d) The difference between the gross fair market value of all Partnership assets and
their respective Adjusted Asset Values shall be added to such taxable income or loss in the circumstances
described in paragraph 14.2:

(e) Items which are specially allocated pursuant to paragraphs 3.2(c), 4.5(b)(vi). 5.2
and 5.3 shall not be taken into account in computing Profit or Loss: and
(I) The amount of any Deemed Gain or Deemed Loss on any Securities distributed in
kind shall be added to or subtracted from (as the case may be) such taxable income or loss.
14.17 Regulated Partner. Regulated Partner shall refer to each ERISA Partner. Governmental
Plan Partner. and Private Foundation Partner.

14.18 Securities. Securities shall mean securities of every kind and nature and rights and options
with respect thereto, including stock. notes. bonds, debentures, evidences of indebtedness and other
business interests of every type. including partnerships. joint ventures. proprietorships and other business
entities.

14.19 Securities Act. Securities Act shall mean the Securities Act of 1933. as amended.
14.20 Short -Term Securities. Short-Term Securities shall mean commercial paper. certificates
of deposit. treasury bills. and other money market investments with maturities of less than twelve (12)
months.

14.21 Thiel Persons. Thiel Persons shall mean Peter Thiel. Peter Thiel's retirement accounts and
Thiel Capital LLC. a Delaware limited liability company. any wholly owned subsidiary of any of the
foregoing. and any successor in interest thereto.

14.22 Treasury Regulations. Treasury Regulations shall mean the Income Tax Regulations
promulgated under the Code, as such Regulations may be amended from time to time (including
corresponding provisions of succeeding Regulations).
ARTICLE 15
OTHER PROVLSIONS
15.1 Governing Law. This Agreement shall be governed by and construed under the laws of
the State of Delaware as such law would be applied to agreements among the residents of such state made
and to be performed entirely within such state.

15.2 Limitation of Liability of the Limited Partners. Except as required by law or by the
terenspa raeraphs 4.2 or 9.7 of this Agreement. no Limited Partner shall be bound by. nor be personally
liable for, the expenses. liabilities, or obligations of the Partnership in excess of its Capital Commitment to
the Partnership.
41.
1220705610
P6116014 vl
15.3 Exculpation.

(a) Neither the tax matters partner. the General Partner, the Management Company.
the members of the Advisory Committee nor their respective managers. members. partners. principals.
officers, employees. Affiliates or agents (including solely with respect to the conduct of any member of the
Advisory Committee. the Limited Partner responsible for the appointment of such member of the Advisory
Committee) shall be liable, responsible or accountable in damages or otherwise to the Limited Partners or
the Partnership for honest mistakes of judgment. or for action or inaction, taken in good faith and in the best
interests of the Partnership. or for losses due to such mistakes, action, or inaction. or to the negligence.
dishonesty. or bad faith of any employee. broker. or other agent of the Partnership. provided. however, that
such employee. broker, or agent was selected, engaged. and retained with reasonable care. The General
Partner and such persons may consult with counsel and accountants in respect of Partnership affairs and be
fully protected and justified in any action or inaction that is taken in accordance with the advice or opinion
of such counsel or accountants, provided. however, that (i) they shall have been selected with reasonable
care. (ii) with regard to the General Partner, such action or in action shall not constitute gross negligence or
fraud, and (iii) the General Partner or other such persons shall have relied on their advice or opinion in good
faith.

(b) Notwithstanding any contrary provision in paragraph 15.3(a) above, the provisions
of this paragraph and the immediately following paragraph shall not be construed so as to relieve (or
attempt to relieve) any personfi) member of the Advisory Committee or any Thiel Person of any liability
(i)by reason of bad faith, (ii) other person by reason of recklessness, bad faith. gross negligence or
intentionally wrongful conduct, (ii)iii)  person by reason of any material breach by the General Partner of
this Agreement or of its fiduciary duties to the Partnership that has a material advent effect upon the
economic interests of the Limited Partners in the Partnership (in addition to the expense of such indemnity
claim) and that remains uncured following ten (10) business days' written notice of such material breach to
the General Partner, or (iii)iv) person to the extent (but only to the extent) that such liability may not be
waived, modified, or limited under applicable law, but shall be construed so as to effectuate the provisions
of such paragraphs to the fullest extent permitted by law.

(c) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Agreement: (i) to the extent that.
at law or in equity. an Indemnified Party (as defined in paragraph 15.4) has duties (including fiduciary
duties) and liabilities relating thereto to the Partnership. any Partner or any other person. such Indemnified
Party acting under this Agreement shall not be liable to the Partnership. and Partner or any other person for
breach of fiduciary duty for its good faith reliance on the provisions of this Agreement (or for taking actions
that are permitted under this Agreement): and (ii) the provisions of this Agreement. to the extent that they
restrict or eliminate the duties (including fiduciary duties) and liabilities relating thereto of an Indemnified
Party otherwise existing at law or in equity. are agreed by each Partner and the Partnership to replace such
other duties and liabilities of such Indemnified Party.

(d) Each Partner acknowledges and agrees that: (i) certain Thiel Persons have
significant-interests-in -are members of the Management Company and/or the General Partner,atni4n-till
respetts,thigh-Tliiel-Petima-shall-be-gmitietkwhen-partigipating-in-anyaeettiLer-making-any-elettion-undea
thisagreementrto-plitee-primaey-tin-its-atittth-aa-a-Limited-Partnethintkits-fideeiery-deties-shaltbe4itetited
accordingly nottvith:tinding any provi::ion of thic Agreement to the contrarj; (ii) one or more Thiel Persons
and their Affiliates  are or may be involved in  or have an economic interest in, directly or indirectly, in their
capacity as managers. advisers, directors, founders, soon9ars, partners, members or otherwise. other
financial, investment and professional activities, and may engage for their own accounts and for the
accounts of others in any such ventures and activities (without regard to whether the interests of such
ventures and activities conflict with those of the Partnership): (iii) nothing in this Agreement is intended. or
shall be deemed, to restrict or in any way limit the Thiel Persons' or their Affiliates' ability to engage in any
42.
122a7aulvl
1,6116015 v1
such ventures or activities; (iv) neither the Partnership nor any Partner shall have any right by virtue of this
Agreement or the existence of the Partnership in and to such ventures or activities or to the income or profits
derived therefrom; and-(v) no Thiel Person shall have any fiduciary or other duties to any Partner or the
Partnership created as a result of. or pursuant to. this Agreement; or as a result of the Thiel Activities (as
defined below), or any duty or obligation to make any reports to any Partner or the Partnership. with respect
to any such ventures or activities: and (vi) the functions and activities of any Thiel Person with respect to
the Partnership (tlte "Thiel Activities") being limited to. as applicable. (x) being a limited partner of the
Partnership or a Parallel Fund. (v) having any ownership interest the Management Company and/or the
General Partner, and (z) taking any actions as a result of a Thiel Person's ownership interest in the
Management Company or the General Partner. (1) shall not alter or impair the limitation on liability of any
Thiel Person as a limited partner un t r e P nnership Act. (2t in no event shell the Thiel Acivities e
rise to a conclusion, under Section 17-303 of the Partnership Act or otherwise, that any Thiel Person
participates in the control of the Partnership, (3) the obligations and responsibilities of the Thiel Persons are
limited to those of a limited partner, and (4) this Agreement and the documentation contemplated hereby
shall be interpreted in accordance with the foregoing.

(e) This paragraph 15.3 is intended to apply solely for the benefit of the Limited
Partners. and in no way shall be construed or interpreted as inuring to the benefit of any other person or
entity. including, without limitation, creditors of the Partnership. of the General Partner or of the members
of the General Partner or other third parties.

15.4 Indemnification. The Partnership agrees to indemnify. out of the assets of the Partnership
only (but including amounts that the Partners may be required to contribute pursuant to paragraph 4.2(d)).
the General Partner, the Management Company. the members of the Advisory Committee (including solely
with respect to the conduct of any member of the Advisory Committee, the Limited Partner responsible for
the appointment of such member of the Advisory Committee), the tax matters partner and their respective
managers. members, partners. principals, officers. employees. Affiliates and agents (each an "Indemnified
Party" collectively the "Indemnified Parties") to the fullest extent permitted by law and to save and hold
them harmless from and in respect of all (a) reasonable fees, costs, and expenses. including legal fees, paid
in connection with or resulting from any claim action. or demand against the Indemnified Parties that arises
directly or indirectly out of or in any way relates to the Partnership. its properties. business, or affairs, or any
other enterprise that such Indemnified Party is or was serving, as a director, officer. employee or otherwise.
at the request of the Partnership. the General Partner or the Management Company. and (b) such claims.
actions. and demands described in the preceding clause (a). and any losses or damages resulting from such
claims, actions, and demands, including amounts paid in settlement or compromise (if recommended by
attorneys for the Partnership) of any such claim, action or demand: provided, however, that this indemnity
shall not extend to: (i) any claim or proceeding solely between or among the General Partner. Management
Company. the Managing Members. or any of their respective managers. members, partners. principals.
officers, employees. Affiliates or agents: or (ii) any conduct which constitutes bad faith on the part of any
Advisory Committee member or Thiel Person or any conduct which constitutes recklessness. bad faith.
gross negligence or intentionally wrongful conduct on the part of any other Indemnified Party or any claim.
action or demand that arises from any material breach by the General Partner of this Agreement or of its
fiduciary duties to the Partnership that has a material adverse effect upon the economic interests of the
Limited Partners in the Partnership (in addition to the expense of such indemnity claim) and that remains
uncured following ten (10) business days' written notice of such material breach to the General Partner.
Expenses incurred by any Indemnified Party in defending a claim or proceeding covered by this paragraph
shall be paid by the Partnership in advance of the final disposition of such claim or proceeding (regardless
of whether the claim asserts that the Indemnified Party is not entitled to such indemnification pursuant to
clause (ii) of the proviso of the preceding sentence): provided, the Indemnified Party undertakes to repay
such amount if it is ultimately determined that such Indemnified Party was not entitled to be indemnified:
provided. further. that no such advance shall be paid in the case of (A) a claim or proceeding solely between
43.
t22a7aulvl
176116014
or among the General Partner. Management Company. the Managing Members, or any of their respective
managers. members. partners. principals, officers, employees. Affiliates or agents or (B) any claim or
proceeding brought by a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners against an Indemnified Party. The
provisions of this paragraph 15.4 shall remain in effect as to each Indemnified Party whether or not such
Indemnified Party continues to serve in the capacity that entitled such person to be indemnified. In the
event that an Indemnified Party is also entitled to indemnification by a portfolio company of the Partnership.
the General Partner or the Management Company. the Partners hereby acknowledge and agree that (i) the
portfolio company shall be the indemnitor of first resort and the Partnership shall be the indemnitor of
second resort and the General Partner and the Management Company shall be the indemnitors of third
resort (i.e.. the portfolio company's obligations to such an Indemnified Party shall be primary, the
Partnership's obligations to such an Indemnified Party shall be secondary and any obligation of the General
Partner and/or the Management Company to advance expenses and/or to provide indemnification for the
same expenses or liabilities incurred by such an Indemnified Party shall be tertiary). (ii) that, to the extent
such an Indemnified Party is otherwise eligible hereunder for advancement of expenses. the Partnership
shall be required to advance the full amount of expenses incurred by such an Indemnified Party and shall be
liable for the full amount of all fees, costs and any other items described in clauses (a) and (b) of the first
sentence of this paragraph without regard to any rights such an Indemnified Party may have against the
General Partner or the Management Company and (iii) the Partnership hereby irrevocably waives.
relinquishes and retraces the General Partner and the Management Company from any and all claims
against such parties for contribution, subrogation or any other recovery of any kind in respect of the
foregoing provisions of this sentence.
15.5 Arbitration.

(a) Any claim, dispute. or controversy of whatever nature arising out of or relating to
this Agreement. including. without limitation, any action or claim based on tort. contract. or statute
(including any claims of breach). or concerning the interpretation. effect. termination. validity. performance
and/or breach of this Agreement ("Claim"). shall be resolved by final and binding confidential arbitration
("Arbitration") before a single arbitrator ("Arbitrator") selected from and administered by Judicial
Arbitration and Mediation Service Inc. (the "Administrator") in accordance with its then existing
arbitration rules or procedures regarding commercial or business disputes. The arbitration shall be held in
San Francisco. California or New York. New York. in the sole discretion of the General Partner.

(b) Depositions may be taken and full discovery may be obtained in any arbitration
commenced under this provision.

(c) The Arbitrator shall, within fi fteen (15) calendar days after the conclusion of the
Arbitration hearing, issue a written award and statement of decision describing the essential findings and
conclusions on which the award is based, including the calculation of any damages awarded. The
Arbitrator shall be authorized to award compensatory damages. but shall not be authorized (i) to award
non-economic damages. such as for emotional distress, pain and suffering or loss of consortium. (ii) to
award punitive damages. or (iii) to reform, modify or materially change this Agreement or any other
agreements contemplated hereunder, provided, however. that the damage limitations described in parts (i)
and (ii) of this sentence will not apply if such damages are statutorily imposed. The Arbitrator also shall be
authorized to grant any temporary. preliminary or permanent equitable remedy or relief he or she deems just
and equitable and within the scope of this Agreement. including, without limitation, an injunction or order
for specific performance.

(d) Each party shall bear its own attorney's fees, costs, and disbursements arising out
of the arbitration, and shall pay an equal share of the fees and costs of the Administrator and the Arbitrator:
provided. however, the Arbitrator shall be authorized to determine whether a party is substantially the
44.
tib005610
1.161160I4v1
prevailing party. and if so. to award to that substantially prevailing party reimbursement for its reasonable
attorneys' fees. costs and disbursements (including. for example. expert witness fees and expenses.
photocopy charges. travel expenses. etc.). and/or the fees and costs of the Administrator and the Arbitrator.
Absent the filing of an application to correct or vacate the arbitration award under Title 10 of the Delaware
Code sections 5713 through 5717. each party shall fully perform and satisfy the arbitration award within
fifteen (15) days of the service of the award.

(e) By agreeing to this binding arbitration provision, the parties understand that they
are waiving certain rights and protections which may otherwise be available if a Claim between the parties
were determined by litigation in court, including, without limitation, the right to seek or obtain certain types
of damages precluded by this paragraph 15.5. the right to a jury trial, certain rights of appeal. and a right to
invoke formal rules of procedure and evidence.
15.6 Execution of Documents. This Agreement may be executed in two (2) or more
counterparts. each of which shall be deemed an original but all of which together shall constitute one (I)
and the same instrument.

15.7 Other Instruments and Acts. The Partners agree to execute any other instruments or
perform any other acts that are or may be reasonably necessary to effectuate and carry on the partnership
created by this Agreement.

15.8 Binding Agreement. This Agreement shall be binding upon the transferees. successors.
assigns. and legal representatives of the Partners.

15.9 Notices; Electronic Transmission of Reports. Any notice or other communication that
one Partner desires to give to another Partner shall be in writing, and shall be deemed effectively given: (a)
upon personal delivery to the Partner to be notified. (b) upon confirmed transmission by electronic mail.
telex or facsimile if sent during normal business hours of the recipient. if not, then on the next business day.

(c) fi ve (5) days after having been sent by registered or certified mail, return receipt requested. postage
prepaid. or (d) three (3) days after deposit with a nationally recognized overnight courier, specifying next
day delivery, with written verification of receipt. All communications shall be addressed to the other
Partner at the address shown on its EXHIBIT A or at such other address as a Partner may designate by ten
(101days' advance written notice to the other Partners. In addition to the provisions of paragraph 11.5, the
General Partner shall be entitled to transmit to the Limited Partners by e-mail the reports required by
paragraphs 11.3. 11.4. and 113.

15.10 Power of Attorney. By signing this Agreement. each Limited Partner designates and
appoints the General Partner its true and lawful attorney, in its name. place. and stead to make, execute, sign.
and file the Certificate of Limited Partnership and any amendment thereto and such other instruments.
documents, or certificates that may from time to time be required of the Partnership by the laws of the
United States of America. the laws of the state of the Partnership's formation, or any other state in which the
Partnership shall conduct its affairs in order to qualify or otherwise enable the Partnership to conduct its
affairs in such jurisdictions. Such attorney is not hereby granted any authority on behalf of the Limited
Partners to amend this Agreement except that as attorney for each of the Limited Partners. the General
Partner shall have the authority to amend this Agreement and the Certificate of Limited Partnership (and to
execute any amendment to the Agreement or the Certificate of Limited Partnership on behalf of itself and as
attorney in fact for each of the Limited Partners) as may be required to effect:

(a) Admission of additional Partners pursuant to Article 3:
(b) Additional capital contributions pursuant to Article 4;
45.
$22II)705610
I.16116014 vl

(c) Transfers of Limited Partnership interests pursuant to Article 91 and
(d) Extensions of the Partnership term pursuant to Article 10.

This power of attorney and the power of attorney referenced in paragraph 4.5(bXx) granted by each Limited
Partner shall expire as to such Partner immediately after the dissolution of the Partnership or the
amendment of the Partnership's EXHIBIT A to reflect the complete withdrawal of such Partner as a Partner
of the Partnership.
15.11 Amendment.

(a) Except as provided by the immediately preceding paragraph and subject to
paragraph 15.11(b). this Agreement may be amended only with the written consent of the General Partner
and a Majority in Interest of the Limited Partners.

(b) Notwithstanding paragraph 15.11(a). no amendment to the provisions of Article 13
may be made without the consent of each ERISA Partner. Governmental Plan Partner and Private
Foundation Partner who may be materially adversely affected by such amendment. (ii) the General Partner
may amend this Agreement without the consent of the other Partners to reflect changes validly made in the
membership of the Partners and the capital contributions of the Partners, and (iii) no amendment to this
Agreement may modify any provision requiring the consent of more than a Majority in Interest of the
Limited Partners without the consent of such higher Percentage in Interest.

(c) Notwithstanding paragraphs 15.11(a) and (b). no amendment of this Agreement
may modify the method of making Partnership allocations or distributions, modify the method of
determining the Partnership Percentage of any Partner, reduce any Partner's Capital Account, increase any
Partner's Capital Commitment to the Partnership. modify any provision of this Agreement pertaining to
limitations on liability of the Limited Partners or change the restrictions contained in this paragraph
15.11(c). unless each Partner adversely affected thereby in a manner different than the other Partners has
expressly consented in writing to such amendment.  In addition, the General Partner shall not cause or
consent to the amendment of paragraphs 8.4(b), 8.4(e), 14.21, 15.2, 15.3, 15.4 or this paragraph 15.11 of
this Agreement in a manner that would adversely affect a member of the Advisory Committee or a Thiel
Person without the express written consent of each such member of the Advisory Committee or Thiel
Person that would be adversely affected thereby.

(d) The Partnership's or General Partner's (or its managers'. members' or employees')
noncompliance with any provision hereof in any single transaction or event may be waived prospectively or
retroactively in writing by the same Percentage in Interest of the Limited Partners that would be required to
amend such provision pursuant to paragraphs 15.11(a). (b) or (c). No waiver shall be deemed a waiver of
any subsequent event of noncompliance except to the extent expressly provided in such waiver.

(e) The General Partner may. without the consent of the Limited Partners, amend this
Agreement. as the General Partner determines to be advisable to address the effects (or potential effects) of
legislation that has been enacted, or regulations (whether proposed. temporary or final) that have been
issued. in either case that change (or. in the General Partner's good faith determination propose to change or
alter) the tax consequences of the operation of paragraphs 4.3. 5.1. and 6.1 or any other provision of this
Agreement related to the satisfaction of the General Partner's Capital Commitment through the waiver of
management fees and related allocations and distributions, so long as any such amendment does not result
in any material adverse effect on any Limited Partner or delay the timing or reduce the aggregate amount of
distributions to which any Limited Partner is entitled under this Agreement.
46.
12267056.1v1
1,6116014 vl
15.12 Entire Agreement. This Agreement (together with the representations and warranties of
each Limited Partner set forth in any Subscription Agreement executed by such Limited Partner) and any
Side Letter (as defined in this paragraph 15.12) constitute the full, complete and final agreement of the
Partners, and supersede all prior agreements between the Partners with respect to the Partnership.
Notwithstanding the provisions of this Agreement or any Subscription Agreement entered into by a Limited
Partner in connection with its admission to the Partnership. it is hereby acknowledged and agreed that the
Partnership and the General Partner, on its own behalf or on behalf of the Partnership or a Parallel Fund.
without the approval of any Limited Partners. may enter into a side letter or similar agreement to or with a
limited partner of the Partnership or a Parallel Fund (each a "Side Letter"), executed contemporaneously
with the admission of such limited partner to the Partnership or such Parallel Fund, which has the effect of
establishing rights with respect to the Partners or the Partnership or supplementing the terns hereof or any
Subscription Agreement in order to meet certain requirements of such Limited Partner, including, without
limitation, the Management Fee chargeable with respect to such Limited Partner. The parties hereto agree
that any terms contained in a Side Letter shall govern, for purposes of this Agreement or any Subscription
Agreement. and be valid, binding and enforceable as among the Limited Partner that is a party thereto, the
General Partner and/or the Partnership.

15.13 Titles; Subtitles. The titles and subtitles used in this Agreement are used for convenience
only and shall not be considered in the interpretation of this Agreement.

15.14 Partnership Name. The Partnership shall have the exclusive right to use the Partnership
name as long as the Partnership continues. Upon termination of the Partnership, the Partnership shall assign
whatever rights it may have in such name to the General Partner. No value shall be placed upon the name or
the goodwill attached to it for the purpose of determining the value of any Partner's Capital Account or
interest in the Partnership.
IS.IS Confidentiality.

(a) This Agreement and all financial statements. tax reports. portfolio valuations.
reviews or analyses of potential or actual investments. reports or other materials and all other documents
and information concerning the affairs of the Partnership and its investments. including, without limitation.
information about the portfolio companies of the Partnership (collectively. the "Confidential
Information"), that any Limited Partner may receive or that may be disclosed, distributed or disseminated
(whether in writing. orally. electronically or by other means) to any Limited Partner or its representatives.
including Confidential Information disclosed to members of the Advisory Committee. pursuant to or in
accordance with this Agreement. or otherwise as a result of its ownership of an interest in the Partnership.
constitute proprietary and confidential information about the Partnership, the General Partner and its
Affiliates and the Partnership's portfolio companies (the "Affected Partite). Each Limited Partner
acknowledges and agrees that the Affected Parties derive independent economic value from the
Confidential Information not being generally known and that the Confidential Information is the subject of
reasonable efforts to maintain its secrecy. Each Limited Partner further acknowledges and agrees that the
Confidential Information is a trade secret, the disclosure of which is likely to cause substantial and
irreparable competitive harm to the Affected Parties or their respective businesses.

(b) Each Limited Partner agrees to hold all Confidential Information in confidence.
and not to disclose any Confidential Information to any third party without the prior written consent of the
General Partner. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, each Limited Partner may disclose such
Confidential Information: (i) to its officers, directors, trustees. wholly-owned subsidiaries, employees and
outside experts (including but not limited to its attorneys and accountants) on a "need to know" basis, so
long as such persons are bound by the same duties of confidentiality to the Partnership as such Limited
Partner, and so long as such Limited Partner shall remain liable for any breach of this paragraph 15.15 by
47.
$22070361v1
126116014 vl
such persons: (ii) to the extent that such information is required to be disclosed in connection with any civil
or criminal proceeding: (iii) to the extent that such information is required (as determined in good faith by
the disclosing Limited Partner after consultation with counsel) to be disclosed by applicable law in
connection with any governmental. administrative or regulatory proceeding or filing (including any
inspection or examination or any disclosure necessary in connection with a request for information made
under a state or federal freedom of information act or similar law), after reasonable prior written notice to
the General Partner (except where such notice is expressly prohibited by law): (iv) to the extent that such
information was received from a third party not subject to confidentiality limitations and such Limited
Partner can establish that it rightfully received such information from such party other than as a result of the
breach of this paragraph 15.15: (v) to the extent such information was rightfully in such Limited Partner's
possession prior to the Partnership's conveyance of such information to such Limited Partner, as evidenced
by the Limited Partner's prior written records; or (vi) to the extent that the information provided by the
Partnership is otherwise available in the public domain in the absence of any improper or unlawful action
on the part of such Partner. Any Limited Partner seeking to make disclosure in reliance on the foregoing
clauses (ii) and (iii) above shall use its best efforts to claim any relevant exception under such laws or
obligations which would prevent or limit public disclosure of the Confidential Information and provide the
General Partner immediate notice upon the Limited Partner's receipt of a request for disclosure of any
Confidential Information pursuant to such laws or obligations.

(c) Each Limited Partner also agrees that any document constituting or containing, or
any other embodiment of. any Confidential Information shall be returned to the Partnership upon the
General Partner's request. Notwithstanding any provision of this Agreement to the contrary. the General
Partner may withhold disclosure of any Confidential Information (other than this Agreement or tax reports)
to any particular Limited Partner if the General Partner reasonably determines that the disclosure of such
Confidential Information to such Limited Partner may result in the general public gaining access to such
Confidential Information or that such disclosure is not in the best interests of the Partnership or its
investments: provided. however, that to the extent that any information is not delivered to a Limited Partner
based on the General Partner's exercise of its discretion under this sentence, such information shall be made
available for review, but not copying. during regular business hours at a location mutually determined by
the General Partner and such Limited Partner. In no event shall a Limited Partner be denied access to
information deliverable pursuant to paragraph 11.7 of this Agreement.

(d) With respect to each Limited Partner that is subject to any "freedom of
information." "sunshine" or other law, rule or regulation that imposes upon such Limited Partner an
obligation to make information available to the public, the Partnership hereby requests confidential
treatment of the Confidential Information, and such Limited Partner shall use commercially reasonable
efforts to take such action as necessary for such Confidential Information to he exempt from disclosure, to
the maximum extent permitted under such law. rule or regulation.

(e) With respect to each Limited Partner that is a "fund of funds" or a similar pooled
investment vehicle (but specifically excluding any pension. retirement or similar benefit plan) (a "Pooled
Vehicle Partner"). the Pooled Vehicle Partner shall. subject to paragraph 15.15(d). be permitted to make
disclosure to its direct equity owners (but not to any indirect or other beneficial owners), that are subject to
a written confidentiality agreement or obligation that provides a degree of protection to the Partnership
comparable to that provided in this paragraph 15.15. of solely the following Confidential Information: (i)
the Pooled Vehicle Partner's status as a Limited Partner of the Partnership. (ii) the amount of such Pooled
Vehicle Partner's Capital Commitment. (iii) the total amount of such Pooled Vehicle Partner's Capital
Commitment that has been drawn down pursuant to capital calls. (iv) quarterly and annual reports
summarizing the status of the Pooled Vehicle Partner's investment in the Partnership (except that any
financial information regarding the Partnership and any information concerning any portfolio company in
48.
322070561v1
L'6116015 vl
which the Partnership has invested shall not be disclosed and must be redacted). and (v) the name and
address of the Partnership.

(I) The General Partner agrees to hold the identity of each Limited Partner in
confidence if requested to do so by such Limited Partner, and not to disclose such identity to any third party
without the prior written consent of such Limited Partner: provided, however, that the General Partner may
disclose such identity (i) to its members. Affiliates. employees and outside experts (including but not
limited to its attorneys and accountants) so long as such persons have an obligation to maintain such
identity in confidence: (ii) to the extent that such information is required to be disclosed in connection with
any civil or criminal proceeding: (iii) to the extent that such information is required (as determined in good
faith by the General Partner) to be disclosed by applicable law in connection with any governmental.
administrative or regulatory proceeding or filing (including any inspection or examination or any disclosure
necessary in connection with a request for information made under a state or federal freedom of information
act or similar law): or (iv) to the extent that the information provided by the Partnership is otherwise
available in the public domain in the absence of any improper or unlawful action on the part of such Partner.

(g) Each Limited Partner agrees to notify such Limited Partner's attorneys.

accountants and other similar advisers about their obligations in connection with this paragraph 15.15 and
will further cause such advisers to abide by the aforesaid provisions of this paragraph 15.15.

(h) Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this paragraph 15.15. each Partner
(and each Affiliate and Person acting on behalf of any such Partner) agrees that each Partner (and its
attorneys, accountants and other similar advisers) may disclose to appropriate governmental authorities, the
tax treatment and tax structure of the formation and operation of the Partnership and materials (including
opinions or other tax analyses) that are provided to such Partner relating to such tax treatment and tax
structure. This authorization is not intended to permit and does not authorize the disclosure of any of the
following Confidential Information or other information relating to the Partnership: (i) any information not
related to the tax treatment or tax structure of the formation or operation of the Partnership. (ii) the identities
of Partners or potential investors in the Partnership. (iii) the identities of any portfolio companies or
potential portfolio companies of the Partnership or a Prior Fund. (iv) the existence or status of any
negotiations to which the Partnership or its Affiliate is a party. (v) any pricing or financial information
(except to the extent such pricing or financial information is related to the tax treatment or tax structure of
the formation or operation of the Partnership), or (vi) any other term or detail not relevant to the tax
treatment or the tax structure of the Partnership.
[Remainder of page intentionally left blank]
49.
t22670.561v1
P6116014 vl
IN Win:FM WHEREOF, the Partners have executed this Limited Partnership Agreement as of the
date first written above.
GENERAL PARTNER:
VALAR VENTURES GP III LLC
By:
James Fitzgerald. Managing Member
LIMITED PARTNER:
VALAR VENTURES GP III LLC
as attorney-in-fact. for and on behalf of each Limited Partner
By:
James Fitzgerald, Managing Member
"THE SECURITIES EVIDENCED BY THIS PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT HAVE NOT BEEN
REGISTERED UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933. AS AMENDED (THE "1933 ACT"). AND
MAY NOT BE SOLD. TRANSFERRED. ASSIGNED OR HYPOTHECATED UNLESS THERE IS AN
EFFECTIVE REGISTRATION STATEMENT UNDER THE 1933 ACT COVERING SUCH
SECURITIES OR THE GENERAL PARTNER RECEIVES AN OPINION OF COUNSEL FOR THE
HOLDER OF THESE SECURITIES REASONABLY SATISFACTORY TO THE GENERAL
PARTNER. STATING THAT SUCH SALE. TRANSFER. ASSIGNMENT OR HYPOTHECATION IS
EXEMPT FROM THE REGISTRATION AND PROSPECTUS DELIVERY REQUIREMENTS OF THE
1933 ACT."
VALAR GWEIAL FUND III t.P
SY:VATLIIE PAGE TO LIMITED PARMILSHIP AGREEMENT
EXHIBIT A -I
14.22°79563.6316015 v32
EFTA01731217 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI requesting INS allow Nadia Marcinko be allowed to stay in the US because of an ongoing sex-trafficking case
(inferred date: 2026-01-07)
Attachment A
CERTIFICATION FOR CONTINUED PRESENCE
BY REQUESTING LAW ENFORCEMENT AGENCY
TO: Unit Chief
Parole and Law Enforcement Programs Unit
Homeland Security Investigations
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement
FROM:
FBI, New York Field Office
RE: Request for Continued Presence fo
SAC of the FBI New York Field Office
concur in this request and certify, in accordance with the Department of Homeland Security
(DIISIs procedures for Continued Presence, that:

t. The justification and information concerning the request for Continued Presence are accurate
and complete.

2. Documentation is attached certifying that the alien is a victim of a severe form of trafficking
and may be a potential witness to that trafficking.

3. Name checks have been completed in the principle law enforcement databases on the person
named in the request (National Crime Information Center and any other databases available)
and, as appropriate, information from foreign law enforcement agencies. Criminal history
check results based on fingerprints have been received and any identification issues
resolved. [For the FBI: Coordination has also been effected with appropriate member
agencies of the Intelligence Community.]

4. Copies of all database screens on the person named above, including negative responses,
have been identified and forwarded to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement,
I lomeland Security Investigations, Parole and Law Enforcement Programs Unit.

5. No promises have been made to the Victim that he or she will remain in the United States
beyond the authorized period of Continued Presence.

6. An active investigation is underway by a law enforcement agency that requires the assistance
of this subject.
Certification for Continued Presence by Requesting Law Enforcement Agency
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY I LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
Signature [of Authorizing Official] Date
Printed Name [of Authorizing Official]
Title [of Authorizing Official]
Certification for Continued Presence by Requesting Law Enforcement Agency
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY / LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement
REQUEST FOR CONTINUED PRESENCE
Part A: Viet  m

1. Name:
(Last)
2. Date of Birth (ma, day, yr.)
5. Allas(es)
8. Passport Number
11. Social Security Number
(First)

3. Country of Birth
(Middle)
4. Country of Citizenship
Slovakia
6. Gender (check one) 7. Alien Number (A#)
O Male ❑x Female A

9. Country of Issuance 10. Expiration Date (mo., day, yr.)
Slovakia 08/04/2020 s 05/14/2025
*Note: This information must be completed in order to receive consIderadon.

1. Lead Case Agent:
(First, Last)
2. Daytime telephone number
(include area code)
Ext.
3. Fax number
2. Case Agent where the Victim resides (if the Victim resides in a jurisdiction other than that of the Lead Case Agent):
(First, Last)
Supplemental Information:

2. Daytime telephone number 3. Fax number
(include area code)
Requesting Agency: Federal Bureau of Investigation
Ext.
Group Supervisor's name (First, Last)
Daytime telephone number (including area co ct.
Fax number
Victim -Witness Specialist's/Coordinators name (First, Lali fl
Daytime telephone number (including area 0Ociact.
Fax number
Request for Continued Presence
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY t LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
ICE Form 73-031 (4/11) Page 1 of 4
Part 4:,case irifOr.Matiok,
•Note: Please complete all Information below.

1. Is the Victim currently in the United State
2. The Victim's current immigration status:
3. Is the Victim requesting Continued Presence based upon a pending civil action under 18 U.S.C. § 1595?
❑ yes ❑x No
If yes, provide details of where and when the civil action was filed, and the status of the civil action.

4. Has the Victim ever been deported/presently under deportation proceedings? ❑ Yes ❑X No
(if yes, where and when) City, State:

5. When did the Victim enter the United States? Ma
6. Through which Port of Entry did the Victim enter the United States? New York, New York

7. How did the Victim enter the United States? Flight
Part D: Specific Information Pertaining to the Victim
• Please answer each question as completely as possible (Attach additional sheet(s), it necessary.)

1. Significance and value of the Victim to this case: (Please provide a brief explanation of how the Victim meets the
definition of 'severe form of trafficking' under section 103(8), Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of
2000, Pub. L No. 106-386.)
See attached sheet.

2. The Victim's criminal Involvement in this or any other case: (Please attach or describe criminal and/or arrest
record listing ALL criminal convictions.)
No criminal convictions.

3. Risk the Victim presents to public safety and/or to national security (i.e., has the alien ever engaged in a 
terrorist
act, supported terrorist activities, or is a member of a known terrorist group? If so, explain.) List and explain
proposed security precautions if necessary: (Attach copy of risk assessment report)
No risk to public safety or national security

4. Financial responsibility for the Victim: (Please explain manner in which the Victim's living expenses will be met)

5. Acquaintance/Relatives in the United States: (Please include name(s), relationship, and current location, i.e., city
and state; attach additional sheet(s), if necessary.)
Request for Continued Presence
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY / LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
ICE Form 73-031 (4/11) Page 2 of 4

6. Is employment authorization requested? 0 Yes O No
al yes, please attach completed U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Forms I-765, Application for Employment
Authorization, and I-102, Application for Replacement/Initial Nonimmigrant Arrival/Departure Document.)
Note: Information contained in question #7 is not required fora victim to receive Continued Presence; however,
this Information Is required for a victim to be certified to receive benefits from the Department of Health and
Human Services (HHS), Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR). A response to this question will assist HHS in
ensuring the fast and efficient delivery of services to the Victim. Victims who have not attained 18 years of age
do not need to be certified to receive benefits from HHS.
7. Is the Victim willing to assist in every reasonable way in the investigation and prosecution of a severe form of
trafficking in persons? The term "investigation and prosecution" includes the: 1) identification of a person or
persons who have committed severe forms of trafficking in persons; ' pprehension of such
persons; and 3) testimony at proceedings against such persons.
Part E: Location where the Victim will reside (City and state are required ate minimum.)
Street Address
City
'Initial requests are approved for a period of time determined on a case-by-case basis. ALL extensions for
Continued Presence must be submitted to the ICE HSI Headquarters Law Enforcement Parole Unit (LEPU). Any
change in status is to be reported to the requesting agency headquarters, which in turn will notify LEPU. The
requesting agency will also notify LEPU immediately if the alien departs the United States.
State  NY
Part F: Certification of Reporting Requirements
As the requesting agency representative, I understand that, should this Continued Presence be granted, it is MY
responsibility to follow all of the policies and procedures established by LEPU, including quarterly reporting,
reporting chap es in the Victim's status i.e. departure or change in status), and requesting applicable
ex proved Continued Presence.
1/1 412020
ONUS)
If the Victim resides outside the geographic area of the lead Case Agent, a monitoring agent must be designated
in the appropriate jurisdiction.
(Monitoring Group Supervisor's Signature)
(Print Name and Title)
(Monitoring Case Agent's Signature)
(Print Name and Title)
(Date)
Request for Continued Presence
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY / LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
ICE Fenn 73-031 (4/11) Page 3 0' 4
Privacy Act Statement
Authority: 22 U.S.C. §§ 7102(8) and 7105(c)(3) authorize ICE to collect the information requested on this form.
Purpose(s): The information collected on this form will be used by ICE to: 1) clearly identify the individual for whom
Continued Presence is being requested; 2) review and determine the eligibility of the individual to receive Continued
Presence and remain in the United States; 3) grant or deny the request for Continued Presence; 4) identify and hold
accountable the requesting law enforcement officer/agent and their agency to comply with ICE's policies and procedures
for administering the Continued Presence; 5) coordinate the administration of benefits available to the individual (if
eligible); and 6) properly maintain a record of all requests for Continued Presence as well as provide oversight, 
tracking
and reporting on Continued Presence activity throughout the duration of the authorized Continued Presence.
Routine Use(s): The information collected on this form may be shared with a criminal, civil, or regulatory law
enforcement authority (whether Federal, State, local, territorial, tribal, international or foreign) where the 
information is
necessary for collaboration, coordination and de-confliction of investigative matters. The information may also be
disclosed as generally permitted under 5 U.S.C. § 552a(b) pursuant to the routine uses published in the Department of
Homeland Security system of records notice, DHS/ICE-011 Immigration and Enforcement Operational Records.
Disclosure: The disclosure of the information on this form is voluntary; however, failure to provide the information may
result in the delay or ultimate denial of the request for Continued Presence.
Request for Continued Presence
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY / LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
ICE Form 73-031 (4/11) Page 4 of 4
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY/ LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
PART D:1
Jeffrey Epstein abused MIEver several years, beginning when she was 18 years old. It was during
the course of this abuse that Epstein brought =Mao some of his massages to participate in sex
acts with other girls. Epstein controlled every aspect of fe—including her physical
appearance, her weight, and her clothing—for years. This controlling behavior took multiple abusive
forms, including forcing o have multiple plastic surgeries, forcing her to engage in BDSM,
referring to her as his "sex slave," insulting her, and physically abusing her, including by choking her and
throwing her down a set of stairs.
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY/ LAW ENFORCEMENT SENSITIVE
Application for Replacement/Initial Nonimmigrant
Arrival -Departure Document USCIS
Form I-102
OMB No. 1615-0079
Expires 10/31/2019
Department of Homeland Security
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
For
USCIS
Use
Only
Receipt Action Block
New 1-94 Number
Remarks

ar. START HERE. Type or print in black ink
Part 1. Information About You
1. Alien Registration Number (A-Number)
► A- ILII 2. USCIS Online Account Number pf
I I I 71 I]
Your Full Name
3.a. Family Name
(Last Name)
3.b. Given Name
(First Name)
3.c. Middle Name
U.S Mailing Address
4.a.
4.b. Street Number
and Name
4.c. Apt. Ste.

5. Is your cutrent U.S. mailing address
U.S.  physical address?
If you answered "No" to Item Number 5., provide your
U.S. physical address in Item Numbers 6.a. - 6.1.
U.S. Physical Address
6.a. In Care Of Name
To Be Completed by an
Attorney or Accredited
Representative,
if any.
0 Select this box if Form
G-28 is attached to
represent the applicant.
Attorney State
License Number
6.b. Street Number
and Name
6.c. Apt. O Ste.
6.d. City or Town
6.e. State
0 FIr.
6.1. ZIP Code
Other Information

7. Date of Birth (mm/dd/yyyy) ►
8. Co •
9. oun of Citizenship
I'-
10. .S. Social Security N
Entry Information

11. Date of Last Entry into the United
(mm/dd/yyyy) ►
12. tes (Ci and State)
Form 1-102 10/19/17 N Page I of 4
Part 1. Information About You (continued)
IS13. Curren ' tatus

14. Date Status Expires
(mm/dd/yyyy) ►
15.a. Form I-94,1-94W,
15.b. Passport Number
15.c. Travel Document Number
15.d. C Passport or Travel Document
15.e. Expiration Date for Passport or Travel Document
(mm/dd/yyyy) ► I
Part 2. Reason for Application
Select the box that best describes your reason for requesting an
initial or replacement document. (Select only one box)
Part 3. Processing Information
1.a. Arc you filing this application with any
application? 0 If "Yes" provide the USCIS Form Number and name of the
application or petition you are filing in Item Number I.b.
1.b. USCIS Form Number and Name
2.a. Are you now in removal proceedings? lao
If "Yes" complete Item Number 2.b.
2.b. Provide detailed information regarding the proceedings.
If you need extra space to complete any item, attach a
separate sheet of paper; type or print your name and
A-Number (if any) at the top of each sheet of paper;
indicate the Page Number, Part Number, and Item
Number to which your answer refers; and date and sign
each sheet.
If you are unable to provide the original of your Form 1-94,
I-94W, or 1-95, provide the following information:
NOTE: Provide your name exactly as it appears on Form 1-94,
I-94W, or I-95.
3.a. Family Name
(Last Name)
3.b. Given Name
(First Name)
3.c. Middle Name

4. Class of Admission at Last Entry into the United States
E2
5. Place of Last En into the United States City and State)
Form 1-102 10/19/17 N Page 2 of 4
Part 4. Statement, Certification, Signature, and
Contact Information of the Applicant
NOTE: Select the box for either Item Number 1.a. or 1.b. If
applicable. select the box for Item Number 2.
Applicant Certification
I certify, under penalty of perjury, that the foregoing is true
and correct. Copies of documents submitted are exact
photocopies of unaltered original documents, and I
understand that I may be required to submit original
documents to U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
(USCIS) at a later date. Furthermore, I authorize the release
of any information from my records that USCIS may need to
determine my eligibility for the benefit that I seek. I
furthermore authorize release of information contained in this
form, in supporting documents, and in my USCIS records, to
other entities and persons where necessary for the
administration of U.S. immigratio laws.
atu
3.b. Date of Signature (mmiddiyyyy) ►
Applicant's Contact Information

4. a Number
5. A limes Mobile Tel hone Number
6. A licant's E-mail Address
Part 5. Contact Information, Certification, and
Signature of the Interpreter
Interpreter's Full Name
Provide the following information concerning the interpreter:
1.a. Interpreter's Family Name (Last Name)
I.b. Interpreter's Given Name (First Name)

2. Interpreter's Business or Organization Name (if any)
Interpreter's Mailing Address
3.a. Street Number
and Name
3.b. Apt. ❑ Ste. ❑ FIr. ❑
3.c. City or Town
3.d. State 3.e. ZIP Code
3.f. Province
3.g. Postal Code
3.h. Country
Interpreter's Contact Information

4. Interpreter's Daytime Telephone Number
5. Interpreter's E-mail Address
Form I-102 10/19/17 N Page 3 of 4
Part 5. Contact Information, Certification, and
Signature of the Interpreter (continued)
Interpreter Certification
I certify that:
I am fluent in English and  ,which
is the same language provided in Part 4., Item Number Lb.;
I have read to this applicant every question and instruction on
this form, as well as the answer to every question, in the
language provided in Part 4., Item Number I.b.; and
The applicant has informed me that he or she understands every
instruction and question on the fonn, as well as the answer to
every question.
6.a. Interpreter's Signature
6.b. Date of Signature (mm/dd/yyyy) ► r
Part 6. Contact Information, Declaration, and
Signature of the Person Preparing this
Application, If Other than the Applicant
Preparer's Full Name
Provide the following information concerning the preparer:
l.a. Preparers Family Name (Last Name)
l.b. Name (First Name)
ill2. Pr ' usiness or Organization Name
L
Preparer's Mailing Address
3.a. Street Number
and Name
3.b. Apt. ❑ Ste.
3.c. City or Town
3.d. State
3.f. Province
3.g. Postal Code
3.6.
Preparer's Contact Information

4. Preparer's Daytime Telephone Number
5. Preparer's Fax Number
6. Preparer's E-mail Address
Preparer's Declaration
By my signature, I certify, swear, or affirm, under penalty of
perjury, that I prepared this form on behalf of, at the request of,
and with the express consent of the applicant. I completed the
form based only on responses the applicant provided to me.
After completing the form, I reviewed it and all of the
applicant's responses with the applicant, who agreed with every
answer provided for every question on the form and, when
required, supplied additional information to respond to a
question on the form.
8.a.
8.b.
NOTE: If you need extra space to provide any additional
information, attach a separate sheet of paper; type or print your
name and A-Number (if any) at the top of each sheet; indicate
the Page Number, Part Number, and Item Number to which
your answer refers; and date and sign each sheet.
Form 1402 10/19/17 N Page 4 of 4
Lc.
Application For Employment Authorization
Department of Homeland Security
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services
USCIS
Form 1-765
OMB No. 1615-0040
Expires 05/31/2020
For
USCIS
Use
Only
El Authorization/Extension
Valid From
Fee Stamp Action Block
0 Authorization/Extension ❑
Valid Through
Allen Registration Number A-L i I
Remarks
To be completed by an attorney or
Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA)-
accredited representative (if any).
O Select this box if Form G-28
is attached.
Attorney or Accredited Representative
USCIS Online Account Number (if any)

10. START HERE - Type or print in black ink.
Part 1. Reason for Applying
I am applying for (select only one box):
1.a. El Initial permission to accept employment.

Lb. O Replacement of lost, stolen, or damaged employment
authorization document, or correction of my
employment authorization document NOT DUE to
U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS)
error.
NOTE: Replacement (correction) of an employment
authorization document due to USCIS error does not
require a new Form I-765 and filing fee. Refer to
Replacement for Card Error in the What is the
Filing Fee section of the Form 1-765 Instructions for
further details.
0 Renewal of my permission to accept employment.
(Attach a copy of your previous employment
authorization document.)
Part 2. Information About You
Your Full Legal
l.a. Family Name
l.b.
1.c. Middle Name
Other Names Used
Provide all other names you have ever used, including aliases,
maiden name, and nicknames. If you need extra space to
complete this section, use the space provided in Part 6.
Additional Informati
2.a. Family Name
(Last Name)
2.b. Given Name
(First Name)
2.c. Middle Name
3.a. Family Name
(Last Name)
3.b. Given Name
(First Name)
3.c. Middle Name
4.a. Family Name
(Last Name)
4.b. Given Name
(First Name)
4.c. Middle Name
Form 1-765 12/26/19 Nr4r1PROMINSMIRRNIVitellIll Page 1 of 7
Part 2. Information About You (continued)
Your U.S. Mailing Address
5.a. In Care Of Name (if any)
5.b. Street Number
and Name
5.c. Apt. ❑ Ste.
5.d. City or Town
5.e. State ■ 51 ZIP Code

6. Is your current mailing address the same as your h sical
address?
NOTE: If you answered "No" to Item Number 6.,
provide your physical address below.
U.S. Physical Address
7.a.
7.b.
7.c.
7.d.
Other
17.a. Family Name
(Last Name)
17.b. Given Name
(First Name)
Information

8. Alien Registration Number (A-Number) (if any)
I" A- Your Country or Countries of Citizenship or
9. USCIS Online Account Number (if any) Nationality
► List all countries where you are currently a citizen or national.

10. Gender
If you need extra space to complete this item, use the space
provided in Part 6. Additional Information.

11. Marital Status 18.a.
IN Single 0 Married ❑ Divorced 0 Widowed
12. Have you previously filed Form I-765? 18.b. oun
Street Number
and Name
0 Apt. 0 Ste. 0 FIr.
City or Town
State 7.e. ZIP Code
13.b. Provide your Social Securi

14. Do you want the SSA to issue you a Social Security card?
(You must also answer "Yes" to Item Number 15.,
Consent for Disclosure, to receive a card.)
0 Yes ®No
NOTE: If you answered "No" to Item Number 14., skip
to Part 2., Item Number 18.a. If you answered "Yes" to
Item Number 14., you must also answer "Yes" to Item
Number 15.

15. Consent for Disclosure: I authorize disclosure of
information from this application to the SSA as required
for the purpose of assigning me an SSN and issuing me a
Social Security card. 0 Yes O No
NOTE: If you answered "Yes" to Item Numbers

14. - 15., provide the information requested in Item
Numbers 16.a. -17.b.
Father's Name
Provide your father's birth name.
16.a. Family Name
(Last Name)
16.b. Given Name
(First Name)
Mother's Name
Provide your mothers birth name.
13.a. Has the Social Security Administration (SSA) ever
officially issued a Social Security card to you?
0
NOTE: If you answered "No" to Item Number 13.a.,
skip to Item Number 14. If you answered "Yes" to Item
Number 13.a., provide the information requested in Item
Number 13.b.
Form 1-765 12/26/19 Page 2 of 7
Part 2. Information About You (continued)
Place of Birth
List the city/town/village, state/province, and country where
you were born.
19.a. Cit fownNilla e of Birth
19.b. State/Province of Birth
19.c. Country of Birth

20. Date of Birth (mm/dd/yyyy)
Information About Your Last Arrival in the
United States
21.a. Form I-94 Arrival-Departure Record Number (if any)
►
21.b. P Most Recently Issued Passport
21.c. Travel Document Number (if any)
21.d. Country That Issued Your Passport or Travel Document
21.e. Expiration Date for Passport or T
(mm/dd/yyyy)

22. Date of Your Last Arrival Into the '
About (mm/dd/yyyy)
23. P Into the United States
24. Immigration Status at Your Last Arrival (for example,
B-2 visitor, F-1 student, or no status)
E

25. Your Current Immigration Status or Category (for example,
B-2 visitor, F-I student, parolee, deferred action, or no
status or category)
E

26. Student and Exchange Visitor Information System
(SEVIS) Number (if any)
► N-
Information About Your Eligibility Category

27. Eligibility Category. Refer to the Who May File Form
I-765 section of the Form I-765 Instructions to determine
the appropriate eligibility category for this application.
Enter the appropriate letter and number for your eligibility
category below (for example, (a)(8). (cX17Xiii)).

28. (eX3XC) STEM OPT Eligibility Category. If you
entered the eligibility category (cX3XC) in Item Number
27., provide the information requested in Item Numbers
28.a - 28.e.
28.a. Degree
28.b. Employers Name as Listed in E-Verify
28.c. Employer's E-Verify Company Identification Number or a
Valid E-Verify Client Company Identification Number

29. (c)(26) Eligibility Category. If you entered the eligibility
category (cX26) in Item Number 27., provide the receipt
number of your H-1B spouse's most recent Form 1-797
Notice for Form 1-129, Petition for a Nonimmigrant
Worker.
►

30. (O(8) Eligibility Category. If you entered the eligibility
category (cX8) in Item Number 27., have you EVER
been arrested for and/or convicted of any crime?
EI Yes ❑No
NOTE: If you answered "Yes" to Item Number 30.,
refer to Special Filing Instructions for Those With
Pending Asylum Applications (cX8) in the Required
Documentation section of the Form 1-765 Instructions
for information about providing court dispositions.
31.a. (eX35) and (cX36) Eligibility Category. If you entered
the eligibility category (cX35) in Item Number 27., please
provide the receipt number of your Form 1-797 Notice for
Form 1-140, Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker. If you
entered the eligibility category (cX36) in Item Number
27., please provide the receipt number of your spouse's or
parent's Form 1-797 Notice for Form I-140.
31.b. If you entered the eligibility category (cX35) or (cX36) in
Item Number 27., have you EVER been arrested for
and/or convicted of any crime? ❑ Yes ON°
NOTE: If you answered "Yes" to Item Number 31.b.,
refer to Employment-Based Nonimmigrant Categories,
Items 8. - 9., in the Who May File Form I-765 section
of the Form 1-765 Instructions for information about
providing court dispositions.
Form I-765 12/26/19 Page 3 of 7
Part 3. Applicant's Statement, Contact
Information, Declaration, Certification, and
Signature
NOTE: Read the Penalties section of the Form 1-765
nstructions before completing this section. You must file
Form 1-765 while in the United States.
Applicant's Statement
NOTE: Select the box for either Item Number 1.a. or I.b. If
applicable, select the box for Item Number 2.
Information I provided or authorized.
Applicant's Contact Information

3. Ap mber
4.
5.
6. 0 Select this box if you are a Salvadoran or Guatemalan
national eligible for benefits under the ABC
settlement agreement.
Applicant's Declaration and Certification
Copies of any documents I have submitted are exact photocopies
of unaltered, original documents, and I understand that USCIS
may require that I submit original documents to USCIS at a later
date. Furthermore, I authorize the release of any information
from any and all of my records that USCIS may need to
determine my eligibility for the immigration benefit that I seek.
I furthermore authorize release of information contained in this
application, in supporting documents, and in my USCIS
records, to other entities and persons where necessary for the
administration and enforcement of U.S. immigration law.
I understand that USCIS may require me to appear for an
appointment to take my biometrics (fingerprints, photograph,
and/or signature) and, at that time, if I am required to provide
biometrics, I will be required to sign an oath reaffirming that:

1) I reviewed and understood all of the information
contained in, and submitted with, my application; and

2) All of this information was complete, true, and correct
at the time of filing.
I certify, under penalty of perjury, that all of the information in
my application and any document submitted with it were
provided or authorized by me, that I reviewed and understand
all of the information contained in, and submitted with, my
application and that all of this information is complete, true, and
correct.
Applicant's Signal
7.b. Date of Signature (mm/dd/yyyy)
NOTE TO ALL APPLICANTS: If you do not completely fill
out this application or fail to submit required documents listed
in the Instructions, USCIS may deny your application.
Part 4. Interpreter's Contact Information,
Certification, and Signature
Provide the following information about the interpreter.
Interpreter's Full Name
1.a. Interpreter's Family Name (Last Name)
1.b. Interpreter's Given Name (First Name)

2. Interpreter's Business or Organization Name (if any)
Form 1.765 12126/19 INOrelatgairaTMEINTIMINIII III Page 4 of 7
Part 4. Interpreter's Contact Information, Part 5. Contact Information, Declaration, and
Certification, and Signature Signature of the Person Preparing this
Application, If Other Than the Applicant
Interpreter's Mailing Address Provide the following information about the preparer.
3.a. Street Number
and Name Preparer's Full Name
3.b. O Apt. ❑ Ste. O Flr. l.a. Preparer's Family Name (Last Name)
3.c. City or Town
I.b. Prepares Given Name (First Name)
3.d. State 3.e. ZIP Code
3.1. Province 2. arees Business or Organization Name (if any)
3.g. Postal Code
3.h. Country Preparer's Mullin Address
Interpreter's
3.a.
3.b.
Street Number
and Name
O Apt. 0 Ste. Contact Information Flr.

4. Interpreter's Daytime Telephone Number
3.c. City or Town
5. Interpreter's Mobile Telephone Number (if any) Id. State e. ZIP Code
3.1. Province

6. Interpreter's Email Address (if any)
3.g. Postal Code
3.h.
Interpreter's Certification
I certify, under penalty of perjury, that:
I am fluent in English and
which is the same language specified in Part 3., Item Number
I.b., and I have read to this applicant in the identified language
every question and instruction on this application and his or her
answer to every question. The applicant informed me that he or
she understands every instruction, question, and answer on the
application, including the Applicant's Declaration and
Certification, and has verified the accuracy of every answer.
Interpreter's Signature
7.a. Interpreter's Signature
7.b. Date of Signature (mm/dd/yyyy)
Preparer's Contact Information
4. Preparer's Daytime Telephone Number
5. Preparer's Mobile Telephone Number (if any)
6. Pre arees Email Address if an
Form 1.765 12/26/19 ~III14 iI II I Page 5 of 7
Part 5. Contact Information, Declaration, and
Signature of the Person Preparing this
Application, If Other Than the Applicant
(continued)
Pr eparer's Statement
7.a. 81 I am not an attorney or accredited representative
but have prepared this application on behalf of
the applicant and with the applicant's consent.
7.b. ❑ lam an attorney or accredited representative and
my representation of the applicant in this case
0 extends 0 does not extend beyond the
preparation of this application.
NOTE: If you are an attorney or accredited
representative, you may need to submit a
completed Form G-28, Notice of Entry of
Appearance as Attorney or Accredited
Representative, with this application.
Preparer's Certification
By my signature, I certify, under penalty of perjury, that I
prepared this application at the request of the applicant. The
applicant then reviewed this completed application and
informed me that he or she understands all of the information
contained in, and submitted with, his or her application,
including the Applicant's Declaration and Certification, and
that all of this information is complete, true, and correct. I
completed this application based only on information that the
applicant provided to me or authorized me to obtain or use.
Preparer's Signature
8.b. Date of Signature (mm./
Form 1-765 12/26/19 Page 6 of 7
Part 6. Additional Information U
If you need extra space to provide any additional information
within this application, use the space below. If you need more
space than what is provided, you may make copies of this page
to complete and file with this application or attach a separate
sheet of paper. Type or print your name and A-Number (if any)
at the top of each sheet; indicate the Page Number, Part
Number, and Item Number to which your answer refers; and
sign and date each sheet.
1.a. Family Name
(Last Name)
Lb. Given Name
(First Name)
Lc. Middle Name
2. A-Number (if any) 10 A-
3.a. Pa e Number  3.b. Part Number 3.c. Item Number
3.d.
Item Number 4.a. Pa e Number  4.b. Part Number 4.c.
4.d.
5.a. Pa e Number 5.b. Part Number 5.c. Item Number
5.d.
6.a. Pa e Number  6.b. Part Number 6.c. Item Number
6.d.
7.a. Page Number 7.b. Part Number 7.c. Item Number
7.d.
Form 1-765 12/26/19 1111 DirfirMISKIVOMMVERNMIIIII Page 7 of 7
Additional Inquiry Response
ORI: NYFBINY00
Federal Bureau of Investigation - New York
New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services
Alfred E. Smith Building, 80 South Swan St.
Albany, New York 12210. Tell-800-262-DCJS
xecutive Deputy Commissioner of the NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services
*Federal NCIC *
WARNING: Release of any NCIC information to unauthorized individuals or agencies,including the subject of the
data, is prohibited. Please refer to section 4.2 of the CMS security policy and Title 28, Part 20 of the code of
Federal Regulations for the proper acess, use, and dissemination of the information contained in the NCIC
restricted and non-restricted files.
The following information is provided in response to your request for a search of the NCIC - Person Files
based on:
Name:
Sex:
Race:
Date of Birth:
0
A
M in
NO NCIC WANT NAM
***MESSAGE KEY Q a SZAALMZb ALL NLIL ebAbUNb wsin UT
LIMITATIONS.
Federal NCIC
WARNING: Release of any NCIC information to unauthorized individuals or agencies,including the subject of the
data, is prohibited. Please refer to section 4.2 of the CJIS security policy and Title 28, Part 20 of the code of
Federal Regulations for the proper acess, use, and dissemination of the information contained in the NCIC
restricted and non-restricted files.
The following information is provided in response to your request for a search of the NCIC - Protection
Order File based on:
Name:
Sex:
Race:
Date of Birth:
Unknown
NYFBINY00
NO NCIC PROTECTION ORDER FILE RECORD NAM/MARCINX0,NADIA DOB/19850221 RAC/U SEX/F
Additional Inquiry Response
OKI: NYFBINY00
Federal Bureau of Investigation - New York
New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services
Alfred E. Smith Building, 80 South Swan St.
Albany, New York 12210. Tell-800-262-DCJS
Michael C.Green, Executive Deputy Commissioner of the NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services
*III Information *
The follossing information is provided in response to your request fora search of the III based on:
Name:
Sex:
Race:
Date of Birth:
A
Purpose Code:
NYFBINY00 NO IDENTIFIABLE RECORD IN THE NCIC INTERSTATE IDENTIFICATION INDEX (III) FOR  DERR . ENV
Additional Inquiry Response
ORI: NYFBINY00
Federal Bureau of Investigation - New York
New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services
Alfred E. Smith Building, 80 South Swan St.
Albany, New York 12210. Tel:1-800-262-DCJS
Michael C.Green, Executive Deputy Commissioner of the NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services
*Federal NCIC *
WARNING: Release of any NCIC information to unauthorized individuals or agencies,including the subject of the
data, is prohibited. Please refer to section 4.2 of the CDS security policy and Title 28, Part 20 of the code of
Federal Regulations for the proper acess, use, and dissemination of the information contained in the NCIC
restricted and non-restricted files.
The following information is provided in response to your request fora search of the NCIC - Person Files
based on:
Name:
Sex:
Race:
Date of Birth:
NYFBINY00
1M1 5.
Additional Inquiry Response
ORI: NYFBINY00
Federal Bureau of Investigation - New York
New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services
Alfred E. Smith Building, 80 South Swan St.
Albany, New York 12210. Tell-800-262-DCJS
Michael C.Green, Executive Deputy Commissioner of the NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services
*Federal NCIC *
WARNING: Release of any NCIC information to unauthorized individuals or agencies,including the subject of the
data, is prohibited. Please refer to section 4.2 of the CJIS security policy and Title 28, Part 20 of the code of
Federal Regulations for the proper acess, use, and dissemination of the information contained in the NCIC
restricted and non-restricted files.
The following information is provided in response to your request for a search of the NCIC - Protection
Order File based on:
Name:
Sex:
Race:
Date of Birth:
NYFBINY 0 0
Additional Inquiry Response
ORI: NYFBINY00
Federal Bureau of Investigation - New York
A
New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services
Alfred E. Smith Building, 80 South Swan St.
Albany, New York 12210. Tell-800-262-DCJS
Michael C.Green, Executive Deputy Commissioner of the NYS Division of Criminal Justice Services
BIII Information *
The following information is provided in response to your request for a search of the III based on:
Name:
Sex:
Race:
Date of Birth:
Unknown
A
Purpose Code:
NYFBINY0 0
NO IDENTIFIABLE RECORD IN THE NCIC INTERSTATE IDENTIFICATION
INDEX (III)
FOR
DERK .
EFTA00006093 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury subpoena or response
EFTA00006387 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2006-06-15 to 2006-07-23
(inferred date: 2026-01-08)
phone bill covering 2006-06-15 to 2006-07-23
EFTA00008220 (Jmail)
 [book] "Massage book: Chapter 11: Putting the Moves Together"
(inferred date: 2026-01-08)
"Massage book: Chapter 11: Putting the Moves Together"
EFTA00006687 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2006-10-31 to 2006-12-25
(inferred timestamp: 2026-01-08 15:17:00)
phone bill covering 2006-10-31 to 2006-12-25
EFTA00001500 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-09)
DATE  g  1  /0.).  1  /9. CASE ID 2/.0.--40/,g0A75?/
I.;#1, s7 Zee' ..rshi
14 5. V;1-o,fr, .1;kh

╭───── Page 1, Image 1 ──────╮
│ DATE os, JA 17             │
│ caseip___ 3/6 A- 2027S? /  │
│ PHOTOGRAPHER               │
│ Location Lb Sf dames Zeled │
│ Arex A                     │
│ Us. Vikyin Elads           │
╰────────────────────────────╯
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Jem Bendell [academia] board member of Community Forge, provider of alternative currency software 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00004250 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00004348 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00004448 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00004800 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00006970 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2006-04-15 to 2006-07-16
(inferred date: 2026-01-09)
phone bill covering 2006-04-15 to 2006-07-16
EFTA00056410 (Jmail)
 [government] suicide watch log from MCC
(inferred date: 2026-01-09)
suicide watch log from MCC
EFTA00177201 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States: court docket and many filings
EFTA00211168 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jane Doe v. Donald Trump and Jeffrey Epstein: Epstein employee affidavit alleging sexual assaults
╔═════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Nili Priell Barak [israel] wife of Ehud Barak [dropsite] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00300480 (Jmail)
 [money] inventory of the contents of document binders related to financial transactions, see quote: "Sale of 727 to Qatar"
(inferred date: 2026-01-09)
GRM #004740704

407 Helicopter Operating File

1. Potential Sale
2. Aviation Insurance Review
3. Charter Possibility
4. Private/Public Partnership Agreement

JEGE, Inc. Operational File

I. Quiet Wing Purchase Agreement
2. Quiet Wing: Aux Fuel Tank Fix- Time Line and Location (email Aug. 13, 09)

3. Boeing Fuel Tank Repair
4. Gulfstream G-IV Aircraft Serial #1030 US Registration #N I WP Rejection
of Aircraft Letter, March 8, 2012

5. Sale of 727 to Qatar

JEGE, Inc. Purchase of Boeing 727-31 Aircraft
1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes

3. Memoranda
4. Memorandum of Understanding
5. Acknowledgement of Receipt of Deposit
6. Aircraft Purchase Agreement

7. Acknowledgement of Receipt and Acceptance of Aircraft
8. Evidence of Toija Beutler's Authority to Sign Documents on Behalf of Real Estate Exchange, Inc.

9. Closing Agenda
10. Gulfstream Registration & Certificate of Airworthiness
11. Boeing Bill of Sale
12. Conveyance Recordation Notice

13. Aircraft Purchase Agreement
14. Customer Service General Terms of Agreement
15. Title Service Invoice

16. Wiring Instructions
17. Aircraft Registration Application
18. UCC Lien Filing
19. Aircraft Bill of Sale

20. Certificate of Insurance
21. Declaration of International Operations
22. Termination Letter to Paramount Logistics

23. Refurbishment Specification by International Jet Interiors
24. Refurbishment Invoice
25. Interior Refurbishments Status

26. Invoice for Interior Refurbishment
27. Contact Information
28. Completion Specification
29. TIMCO
30. Drafts

31. Quiet Wing Agreement RE Auxiliary Fuel Tank
32. Aircraft Offer Letter Form of Aircraft Purchase Offer

Purchase of Bell 407 Helicopter

1. Correspondence
2. Research
3. Bill of Lading
4. Bill of Sale
5. Insurance
6. Purchase Agreement
7. Delivery Receipt

8. EA Quotation
9. Cancellation Certificate
10. Aircraft Bill of Sale
11. Wire Transfers
12. Offer
13. Shipment

14. Customs Power of Attorney
15. Vibration Test Results
16. Mortgage Details
17. Acceptance Letter
18. Tariff Duty and Entry Requirements

19. Lien and Tide Search
20. Pre-Purchase Inventory
21. Mann Aviation
22. Certificate of Registration
23. Export Certificate of Airworthiness

24. Conditions for Inspections Report
25. Discrepancies and Due Items
26. Aircraft Documents includes in Sale

27. Robard Bank Details
28. Additional Items Pricing
29. Escrow Account
30. Airworthiness Directives
31. Invoices

32. Declaration of International Operations (Feb.23, 2010);Cert. of Amendment
of Air Ghislaine to Shmitka Air;Certificate of Amendment of Certificate of
Incorporation of Air Ghislaine;Waiver of Requirement for Affidavit
Extraordinary Condition

33. Filing Fee of $150
34. Temporary Certificate of Registration-Valid Until March 25, 2010
S-76C++ Helicopter Sale 760667 Sale

I. Purchase Agreement S-76++ Helicopter
2. Letter of Intent to Purchase by Five Star Holding Company LLC (Must
Organize)

3. Helicopter Brokerage Agreement b/w Air Ghislaine and Aircraft Services
4. Aircraft Bill of Sale Information

5. S76C++ New Helicopter Sales Agreement signed 12-14-07
Sale of Boeing 727
-Aircraft Sales
Purchase of S-76C S7TD6167A
-Correspondence
-Turbomeca Warranty
-Asset Preservation 1031 does
-Air Ghislaine 1031 Exchange Correspondence (Asset Preservation)
-Like Kind Exchange Acct Statement S76C
-Amendment #1 to S-76 New Helicopter Sales Agreement (76TD6167A)
-Amendment #2 to S-76 New Helicopter Sales Agreement (76TD6167A)
- Amendment #3 to S-76 New Helicopter Sales Agreement (76TD6167A)
-Sales Agreement
-Form 1099-INT for 2009
-S76** March 9,2010 Closing, Amendment #4, Request for Funds and Sikorsky Invoice
-S76 Deposit Agreement, March 31, 2010
-Purchase of S76C++ (Signed 12/14/07 and 12/17/07)
-Proposed Sale of S76C++ w/Eric Chase
Purchase of Bell 609 (Bell 417 not being made).
Bell 609 Purchase Agreement
Bell 417
Purchase of S-76D
Correspondence
S-76D Position Agreement
Lufthansa/BBI f Boeing Business Jet) Specs
Hyperion Air Miscellaneous

I. Hyperion Air Inc. Delaware Office
2. Hyperion Air - Insurance
3. Dallas Airmotive, Inc.- 10 Year Core Inspection

4. Noise Abatement at Teterboro
5. Interior refurbishment proposals for the Gulfstream
6. Gulfstream Service January 2007

7. Hyperion Air Franchise Tax Reports
8. Attempted Purchase of GS
The Hyperion Trust Purchase of Gulfstream G650
Correspondence
Letter of Intent
Acquisition of Execujet

1. Correspondence
2. Memorandum
3. Purchase Agreement
4. Assets
S. Wire Instructions
6. Corporate Documents of Hairoun

7. Lease agreement and Amendment b/w VI Port Authority and Hairoun
8. Assignment of Lease between Port Authority and Hairoun

9. Terms of Leasehold with VIPA and Hairoun
10. Spill Prevention Plan and Addendum
11. Small Business Administration Loan Eric Williams

12. Due Diligence ( ALSO SEE BINDER)
13. Hairoun Complaint
GRM# 004740710
Robert Couturier
Dates, Meetings, Backup
Letter to Robert dated July 14, 2010
Couturier Correspondence Binder
2008 FLIGHT LOGS/2009 & 2010 FLIGHT LOGS BINDER
Hyperion Manifest 1999 & 2000
Hyperion Manifest 2001 & 2002
Hyperion Manifest 2003-2004
JEGE Manifest 2001-2002
Financial Trust Company Inc. Corporate Binder
GRM# 004740711
Financial Trust Company, Inc. Administrative File

1. Annual Reports
2. Lease
3. EDC Rules and Regs 2006 (not in redweld as of dec 30, 2010)
4. FTC IDC Documents (not in redweld as of dec 30, 2010) )

5. FTC Employee Documents
6. IRS Summons/Liston J. Thomas
7. Accounting Reports
8. Ackley Communications Customer Agreement

9. Innovative Phone System
10. Invoices
II. Computers
12. Engagement Letter - Hodge & Francois
13. Investment Advisor Issues(not in redweld as of dec 30, 2010) )

14. Leon Casey — Employment letter — Power of Attorney
15. Sprint Global MPLS VPN Sales Agreement
16. Telephone System

17. Parking at Red Hook
18. Extension Application for Economic Development Benefits (EDC) Nov.
30, 2009
19. Accepted, Executed Recommendation for Economic Development Benefits
(EDC) Dec. 15, 2009

20. EDC Signed Acceptance of Application for Economic Development
Benefits (Feb 14,2010)
21. FTC ML Hertz Co-Investor L.P.

22. FTC Office Lease- Expires Jan. 31, 2010
23. FTC/EDC Residency Opinion
BOLONGO ESTATE (FT Real Estate)

I. Minutes
2. Dave Christopher/Bolongo Bay Release of Lease & Related Does
3. Dave Christopher: FT Real Estate Closing Statement and Listing

4. Calypso Realty Listing Agreement for Bolongo Estate (Comp List
included)
5. Extension of Lease Bolongo House (new date is Oct. I, 2010)(Calypso
Realty);

6. Notice to Quit Oct. 21, 2010
7. Contract of Sale (Dec 10, 2010)
8. First Amendment Contract of Sale (Dec 19, 2010)

9. Broker Agreement (empty folder)
10. Buyer Financing Documents (empty folder)
II. Dave Christopher Letter Nov. 23, 2010

12. Certified Resolutions of Board of Directors of FT Real Estate, Inc.
13. Certificate of Incumbancy
14. First Amendment to Contract of Sale
Financial Trust Company. Inc. Administrative File 'No (IDC & Fax
Regulations)
-. Correspondence
-IDC/EDC Benefits Program
- FTC Application for Industrial Development Benefits
- FTC Industrial Development Certificate
- Residency Requirements
-IDC Compliance Memo
-IDC Eligible Supplier List
-IDC Annual Report Document in Blank
-IDC Forms
-Invoice to LHW
-EDC Audit 4/99 — 12/05
-EDC Audit Issues 2008
-FTC IDC Original Documents
-FTC Response to Determination Letter from the EDC (written by Erika Kellerhals) June
29, 2009
-FTC EDGAR Codes
-Delson Residency Opinion
EDC 2008

I. 2006 Rules and Regulations
2. EDC Renewal Application
3. Erika Kellerhals
4. Delson Letter re Federal Income Tax 2008/2009 Amended Returns and
Interest Charge (JEE and EDC)
Financial Trust Company Transaction File IV (FTC)
Highbridge Corporation File II
Highbridge Corporation File I (9/19/00)
FINRA RULE 5131, APRIL 28, 2011
Financial Trust Company (FTC), Inc. Transactions File V

1. Pinehurst Partners Plus (No Investment Made)
2. Pinehurst Plus, LP
3. Howcast
4. Highbridge Capital Corp Private Placement
FINANCIAL TRUST COMPANY TRANSACTION VI
Highbridge Long/Short Equity Fund LP
Highbridge Capital Corporation Dec. 2008 Update
Financial Trust Company, Inc. VII
-.Deerfield Triarc Capital Corp. Subscription
- Prentice Capital Partners
-Prentice Capital Partners Redemption Request Docs
-FTC Subscription Agreement with DCM Partners LLC
Highview Global Macro, L.P
-Highbridge Capital 2010 Annual Review
GRM#004740712 (PULLED FOR DARREN MAY 30. 20131
FTC Old Investment Partnership Agreements
FTC Consulting Agreement w/Highbridge Management
APPLICATION FOR ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT BENEFITS FOR FTC,
EXTENSION (DRAFT)
SECOND CITY CAPITAL PARTNERS !imam) PARTNERSHIP BINDER (CLOSING RINDFJI
FROM SECOND CITY CAPITAL PARTNERS I. LPI
-Ryder Properties Loan from Carey 16 Lending Corp. $73,200,000
June 22, 2007
GRM# 004740713
Financial Trust Company Transactions File VIII (A)
Bear Stearns High Grade Structured Credit Strategies Enhanced Leverage Fund
Bear Stearns HG Structured Credit Strategies Enhanced Leveraged (Overseas)
Financial Trust Company Transactions File VIII (B)
FTC Subscription Bear Stearns High Grade Structured Credit Strategies, LP
Bear Stearns Asset Backed Securities
FTC Bear Stearns Litigation I

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Retainer Agreement Storch Amini Munves

6. Bear Stearns Timeline
7. Storch Memorandum
8. News Articles
9. FTC Complaint ( For Settlement)
10. Letter and Draft Complaint Sent to Jim Condren on 6-18-08

II. BS Proxy
12. BS Confidentiality Agreement
13. Power of Attorney JEE to DKI
14. JP Morgan Correspondence regarding BS stock conversion
FTC Bear Stearns Litigation II

I. Estelle Weber Complaint
2. Vargo Complaint
3. Barclay Complaint
4. FIC Complaint
5. Navigator Complaint

6. Consents
7. Bear Stearns Asset Backed Securities (valuation from 6/30/07- Dec. 09
estimated balance, Letter from Bear to Investors, Email to Harry)

8. JE & FTC vs BS/JP Morgan- Fee Agreement Proposal
9. Email from Steven Storch re Election/Consent Forms

10. Arbitration Correspondence from Stacy E. Yeung
II. Joint Ltr Re Extension until Sept. 16 Submitted by FINRA (Bear Stearns
arbitration re Spector)
FTC BEAR STEARNS LITIGATION III
WORKING FILE
Bear Stearns

1. Correspondence
2. FTC Customer Agreement
3. Customer Agreement
4. Storch Invoices
Liquid Funding
-Liquid Funding Distribution and Dissolution Documents
-Indenture (Draft)
-Program Agreement (Draft)
-Commercial Paper Placement Agreement (Draft)
-Commercial Paper Depository Agreement (Draft)
-Private Placement Memorandum (Draft)
-Program Liquidity Agreement (Draft)
-Membership Interest Purchase & Sale Agreement
-Signed Seller (Jeffrey Epstein) and Purchaser (Jeffrey Lipman-Bear Stearns) Doc. Of
Liquid Funding
-Purchase and Sale Agreement with Darren's markings (Harry's analysis)
Zwirn Doc Production from Harry Susman April 21.2011 Reviewed for
Priveledge
GRM#004740714
The Haze Trust - Transactions

1. Highbridge Capital Management, LLC
2. Highbridge Capital Management, LLC Form ADV Part II
3. King Street Capital

4. Highbridge Capital Management, LLC Form ADV Part II, July 2010
5. HB MULTI STRATEGY
King Street Capital
-Correspondence
-April 2010 Amendment, Consent & 50% Withdrawal
-King Street Capital 9th Amended & Restated Agreement of Limited Partnership, May 1,
2010
-King Street Notice & Consent Request: Investor Response Required
-King Street Capital Offering Memorandum April 2010
Kine Street Capital LP
Documents
BELZBERG/SNELLBERGER TRANSACTION
Miscellaneous Files I -Jeffrey Epstein

1. Second Passport
2. Passport Copies
3. JLAC, LLC
4. Engagement Letter - Hodge & Francois
5. JEE Letter of Credit — Karin Models

6. Igor Zinoviev Personal Trainer - Statement of Employment
Responsibilities
7. The Family Foundation, document and re-typed version)

8. Palm Beach Trust Agreement
9. Termination of Palm Beach Trust (July 12, 2010)
10. DKI Letter of Representation

11. Federal Gift Tax Request for Payment
12. New York Science Foundation, Inc.
13. Nili Priell Barak
14. Summary of VI Income Tax Payments

15. Application for Tax Filing and Payment Status Report Licensing VI
16. Swan Letter to GS Re: Forwarding Address for Community and
International Charitable Interest

17. Swan Capital Management LLC Limited Liability Co. Operating
Agreement
18. MC2 MM LLC Ginta Lapina
19. Brazilian CPF ( Has old POA in it)

20. Miss Internet Search
21. Emad State Grand Jury Service
22. Release (unsigned)
23. JEE Itinerary 2007

24. Research on Capri Trademark
JEE Misc. Files III
1. Conversion to MAC Platform
2. EE & Related Entities Cost Savings Analysis

3. General Release of Claims
4. CAR ACCIDENT
5. Peggy Siegel/Martin Siegel Last Will
6. PB A t PLUS Lease Addendum as of Nov. 19th 2009)(PLUS Lease
Termination)

7. Dr. Moskowitz note stating JE needs to be in pool
8. Wackenhut Security Agreement Amendment #1
9. Land Registry and info re Eaton Square Properties & Mrs. Paula Cussi De
Azcarraga

10. To Do List for JE Dec. 2009
11. Newgrange Prof Services Agreement
12. Withers Bergman
13. Pe Sie el Peo le Lists

14. Apt
15. Global Options Group/Bode Tech
16. Sultan Letter of Reference
17. Smart Car
18. Natividad Lawsuit

19. Apartment in Florida
20. Anything Electric vs Epstein
GRM#004740715-PULLED FROM STORAGE MAY 14, 2013
MISC.
Name Change
BEACH CLUB MIAMI
CIPRIANI/REFIFI
-Lease
-Assignment of Lease
-Global Agreement
-Management Agreements
-Liquor License
-Loan Documents
-Refifi Charter Documents
-Lease of Club Space
PALM BEACH TRUST
-Appointment of Successor Trustee
-Trust Agreement
-Close Acct 044 13706
TSSW.
-Certificate of Formation
-Contract for Sale and Purchase
Jeepers, Inc. USV1

1. Articles of Incorporation/Certificate of Existence
2. S-Election
3. EIN
4. Qualified Subchapter S Subsidiary Election

5. Annual Reports
6. Franchise Tax
7. Minutes
8. Affidavit of Not Conducting Business
9. First Bank Account

10. IRS Notices
11. Jeepers Inc Stock Certificate, 1000 Shares, Aug. 18, 2003
l‘t etl±f stein  Investments

1. The Core Club 55th Street LLC
2. DCM Partners
The Florida Science Foundation. Inc.
I. Correspondence

2. Articles of Incorporation
3. Office Space
4. Lease Agreement
5. Annual Report
6. Mark Dedick- Draft Corporate Documents

7. Accounting Invoices
8. Disputed Mark Dedick Invoices
COUQ Foundation Charitable Contributions/Consulting Agreements

1. Confidentiality Agreement William Daniel Hillis
2. Edge Foundation Inc.
3. Website for COUQ
4. Offer Letter to

5. Consulting Agreement
6. Mark Lloyd Consulting Agreement
7. Rwandan Student Scholarships - City College

8. Kyle Godfrey Consulting Agreement
9. Marvin Minsky Consulting Agreement
10. David Grosof Consulting Agreement

11. Dr. Marc Hauser
12. COUQ Foundation Balance Sheet as of Dec. 22, 2003
13. National Council of Jewish Women

14. Science Dinner 2/3/98
15. The New School Contribution
MILL
1. Articles of Organization
2. Certificate of Existence

3. FSF, LLC Operating Agreement
Epstein Interests aka I. Epstein Foundation
1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes

3. Research
4. Memoranda
5. Trust Agreements and Amendments
6. EIN
7. Worker's Compensation
8. Contribution to American Agenda/Ezra Reese

9. Application for Recognition of Exemption
10. Charities Registration Form
11. Distribution Carryover
12. JP Morgan POA

13. Form 990PF Incomplete Filing Notice
14. Contribution to American Academy of Achievment , Jan. 30, 2003
Max Foundation

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research
4. Memorandum
5. Contributions
6. Trust Agreement
7. Consents of Trustees

8. Appointments of Trustees
9. Determination of Exempt Status
10. Resignation of Trustees
11. Trust Account Agreement

12. Donations 1997
13. Check for Annual Report -Charities Estates and Trusts Bureau
14. Distribution Carryover

15. 2007 990-PF
16. 2010 Tax Returns
Max Hotel Services Corm
1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research

4. Memorandum
5. Certificate of Formation
6. SS-4
7. Application for Registration as a Sales Tax Vendor

8. Resale Certificate
9. Certificate of Authority
10. Business Tax Account Update
11. NY State ID #, File #, Filing Period

12. Biennial Statement
13. Miscellaneous Purchases
14. Authorization of Electronic Filing of 2010 Tax Returns

15. 2011 Tax Return Filing Instructions
FTC $50.000.000 Line of Credit with IP Morgan
Correspondence
Attorneys Notes
Drafts
Grid Notes
Collateral Agreement
Line Letter
Form U-1
Auto Debit Letter
Secretary's Certificate
Board Resolutions
Corporate Certificate
457 Madison Avenue Corp.

I. Lease
2. Drafts of 2008 Lease Extension
3. Lease Extension
4. Second Lease Extension
5. Third Lease Renewal July 2005

6. Stipulation of Settlement and Lease Extension 2008
7. Surrender of Lease
8. Emergency Response Plan
9. Delivery of Possession Agreement May 15, 2009 (original signed and
copies)

10. Correspondence
Ghislaine Maxwell & 65th Street
I. Jury Duty
2. Sotheby's Brokerage Agreement for the Sale of her house

3. Emad's email to Diandra Douglas re damage to G's house due to construction
at
4. Letter Sent to Herb Wolman re AIG Paying for Services of Miller & Raved

5. Pot and Kettle, LLC Certificate of Formation and Certificate of Conversion
AND Pot and Kettle Assignment of Limited Partnership Interest (signed by
Ghislaine and Duke of York)

6. Dispute with Diandra Douglas
358 El Brillo Way. Palm Beach
1. Proposal for new Generator for PB house
GRM#004740716
Correspondence of ALL Cases
Witness Files:
Witness File
Witness File
Civil Litigation Witnesses
PB CIVIL LITIGATION: GENERAL
Robert Critton Attorney Correspondence
Jeffrey Herman Suspension
Civil Litigation Research
Tolling Agreement Re Josefberg Clients
Focus Group
Request for Insurance Defense from MG
Subpoena of Rich Kahn, HBRK and NYSG
Subpoena of Florida Science Foundation and The COUQ Foundation
Engagement Letter from Rubin Katz Law Firm to represent Zorro Ranch (May 26, 2010)
Bill Riley
Supervision of Bill Riley
Decision Re JE Bar Complaint Against Brad Edwards
Civil Cases
PBL Research by DKI
CASE
CASE
CASE
(Synopsis of Case, Retention to Provide Legal Services, Notice of Change of
Attorney, Consent to Change Attorney, Signed Consent to Change Attorney)
-NM Notice of Appeal Nov. 11, 2008
-Settlement Agreement and General Release
CRIME VICTIM RIGHTS ACT LITIGATION DOCS SUPPORTING
OPPOSITION TO GOVT EMAIL PRODUCTION
GRM#004740717
Four Star Aviation. Inc.
1. Lease Agreement VI Port Authority and Four Star Aviation, Inc. Cyril E. King
Airport
2. Lease Agreement VI Port Authority and Four Star Aviation, Inc.
Flight Options
-Exchange Agreement March 2009
-Comparitive Specifications of Exchanged Aircraft
-Exchange Agreement April 22, 2009 (transferred share from N787TA to N493LX)
SHMITKA AIR
-Deposit Agreement with Sikorsky
-Registration Certificate
Sale & Purchase of N722JE & N162AE
-Correspondence
-Notes
-Freedom Int'l Air Minutes
-Letter of Intent N722JE
-Letter of Intent N162AE
-Aircraft Purchase Agreement N722JE
-Aircraft Purchase Agreement N162AE
-Inspection Report & Correspondence N722JE
-Inspection Report & Correspondence N162AE
-Title Searches
-Side Letter Re: Post Closing Discrepancy Work N162AE
-Side Letter Re: Turbomeca Extension
-International Registry Documents
-Preliminary Acceptance Certificate N722JE
-Preliminary Acceptance Certificate N162AE
-Warranty Bill of Sale N162AE
-Warranty Bill of Sale N722JE
-FAA Registration, N722JE
-FAA Registration, N162AE
-Delivery Receipt N22JE
-Delivery Receipt N162AE
-Wire Transfer Instructions N722JE
-Wire Transfer Instructions N162AE
-Turbomeca Letter Issues
-PAP Transfer N1622AE
PURCHASE OF G4
-Correspondence
-Attorneys Notes
-Memoranda
-Letter of Intent
-Aircraft PurchaseAgreement
-FAA Registration
-Warranty Bill of Sale
-FAA Bill of Sale
-Delivery Receipt
-Preliminary Acceptance Certificate
-Title Searches
-Wire Transfers
SALE OF 9 EAST 71st STREET
-Correspondence
-Attorney Notes
-Research
-Memoranda
-General Ledger 9/30/98
-Purchase Agreement Drafts
-Guaranty Drafts
-Assignment & Assumption Agreement Drafts
-Promissory Note Drafts
-Vows Reviews
-Draft Contract of Sale
-Nominee Agreement
-Acknowledgement, Consent & Waiver
-NES, LLC Articles of Organization
-Lease Agreement
-Biennial Statement
-Non-Foreign Affidavit
-Purchase & Sale Agreement
-NYS TP 584
-NYC RPT
-Bill of Sale
-Lead Based Paint Disclosure Form
-Protect Your Family from Lead in Your Home
-Promissory Note
-Guaranty
-Assignment & Assumption Agreement
-Stock Power
-Stock Certificate
-Affidavit of Compliance Smoke Detector
-Certificate of Non-Foreign Status
-Miscellaneous Checks
-LHW Resignation of LHW as Director
-Minutes
-Settlement Statement
-Purchase Agreement Drafts
-Closing Documents
FLIGHT LOGS 2007
FLIGHT LOGS 2007 BOEING
-Promissory Note March 1, 2007
-Promissory Note April 27, 2007
Purchase of  Avenue

1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Memoranda
4. Research
5. Contract of Sale
6. Survey
7. Title Search

8. Sellers Mortgage
9. Deed
10. Title Insurance
11. Closing Statement
12. Transfer Taxes
13. Non Foreign Person Affidavit

14. Closing Checklist
15. Acknowledgement of Lead-based Paint
16. Home Inspection Services
17. Floor Plans

18. Oil Tank Paperwork
19. Permits/Certificates
20. Publication Notice
21. Indenture
22. Real Property Transfer Report

23. Closing Affidavit
24. Certificate of Insurance
25. Street Maintenance Report
26. Application for Star Exemption

27. Lynn And Job° LLC Biennial Statement
Joe Pagano/Curve Capital
-Private Offering Memorandum
-Subscription Agreement
ELLMAX LLC
-Ellmax LLC Employer Identificaion # (ID #)
-Ellmax LLC Articles of Incorporation
BINDER: Leslie H. Wexner Sale of Nine East 71 41 Street Corporation to NES, LLC
GRM# 004740718
4y thnuse Project
-Art House L.P.
-Fee Adjustment Letters, Trust 600, RHREI, WCTII
Crystal Island Ranch Titles (manilla folderl
Caterpillar Trust and Butterfly Trust

1. Correspondence
2. Caterpillar Trust Agreement
3. Butterfly Trust Agreement
4. Butterfly Trust EIN
5. Caterpillar EIN

6. Caterpillar K-1
7. Caterpillar TO Butterfly Assignment and Acceptance
8. Caterpillar TO Jeffrey Assignment and Acceptance

9. Butterfly Trust Addition to Beneficiaries
10. Wire Transfers
11. Caterpillar Trust Dec. 27, 2006 First Transfer to Trustees, Purposes,
Limited Power of Amendment

12. Butterfly Trust Dec. 27, 2006 JE as Grantor to Darren Indyke & Rich
Kahn as Trustees
n in B
( Two Redwelds)
-Grat Distribution
-Operating Agreement of British Sands, LLC
FTC SUBSCRIPTION BRITISH SANDS LLC, SOHO HOUSE TRANSACTIONS IX
Zorro Ranch Operational File

1. Contact Numbers 2008
2. Confidentiality Agreement and Information Release
3. Sutin, Thayer & Browne (Attorney Paul Bardacke)

4. Livestock Brand Identification Card
5. Livestock Issues
6. Reverse Osmosis System Water to the House

7. Agricultural Exemption
8. New Mexico Agricultural Land Valuation and Property Taxation
9. Business Lease Application

10. Zorro Employment/Employees
11. New Oil and Gas Drilling Executive Order
12. Estate Reports
13. Household Expenditure Procedures

14. CDW Quote on Adobe (paperless software quote)
15. Renewal of RO (Reverse Osmosis) Discharge Permit
16. Zorro Specialty Warranty Deed
SANTE FE
Closing Docs Binder
Correspondence
Palm Beach Marine Construction Litigation

1. Correspondence
2. Research
3. Attorney Notes
4. PB Marine Construction vs. Jeffrey Epstein
5. Partial Satisfaction of Lien

6. Claim of Lien
7. Notice of Appearance
8. Answer to Complaint Filed
9. Joint Scheduling Report, April , 2009 (and letter from Chester
Brewer to Alexander Lian)

10. Joint Scheduling Report, April 22, 2009 (along w/2 letters from
C.Brewer to A.Lian)
11. Notice of Taking Deposition , June 22, 2009

12. Letter from Chester Brewer to Darren, June 11, 2009
13. Chester Brewer Invoices
14. Deposition of Dan Hackman

15. Plaintiffs First Request for Production from Defendant, JE (plus note
from Chester Brewer)
16. Satisfaction of Lien
9 EAST 71ST STREET

1. Jaques Grange Original Agreement
2. Jaques Grange Revised Agreement
3. Damage to Bldg Facade by Neighbors 2008/2009

4. Construction at 12 E. 72nd Street (Letter to deny access to 9 East 718t
Street) John V. Dinan Associates

5. Construction at 12-14 East 72nd Street
6. Local Law 11 Work, 2011-2012
7. Source One Energy Solutions

8. Mutual Settlement & Release Agreement for Source One
9. Meltzer, Lippe Engagement Letter
10. McBride vs. Nine East 7P Street

11. McBride vs. Nine East 7P Street, JE & Herbert Rose, Plaintiff's Reply
Brief in Support of Order To Show Cause For a Preliminary
Injucction & Temporary Restraining Order

12. Construction Noise at 12 East 72nd Street
13. Scaffolding Litigation
14. Original Floor Plans
15. Local Law 11 Cycle 7
GRM# 004740719
1.S.1, 1.1.0 Closinv, Binder
Lease of Great St. James (GSJ)
-Correspondence
-Attorney Notes
-Research
-Memorandum
-Contract Of Sale of A Portion of GSJ
-Great St. James 2005-2006
-Great St. James Development
-Purchase of Great St. James
-J. Epstein —Other Real Property
-Drafts
-Leynard Sneed Mooring Review
-Purchase of Great St. James (GSJ)
L S LLC
Closing Binder
Correspondence
Attorney Notes
Research
Memoranda
Banking
Operating Agreement
Certificate of Formation
Certificate of Good Standing
Certificate of Registration of Trade Names
Form SS-4(never filed)
Bank Resolutions
Corporate Invoices
Tax Clearance Letter July 2006
2007 Economic Census Report
Form of Confidentiality Agreement
LSJ Contractors and Attorney Files I

1. Engagement Letter - Hodge & Francois
2. Project Solution, Globaltech and Karr Agreements that were sitting
around DKIs after pack

3. Bernardes Jacobsen Architects
4. William R. Nash AIA
5. Peter Capone Designs
6. Sanford Amerling and Associates

7. Meridian AIA Document for New Dock Construction 2002
8. Legal Invoices
9. Michael J. Glidden Electric, Inc.
J)eJnngh Group Architerti
1.Operating File: Engagement Agreement
2.Accrued Billings Mistatement

3. DeJongh Invoices
Maguire Group AIA Document
LSJ Operating File I
1. Waiver of Liability Agreement and Release

2. LSJ Staffing
3. Lance Calloway and Maren Ord Terms of Employment
4. Julie and Brinsley
5. Concerns re Purchasing Practices of Julie and Brinsley

6. Dave Christopher (includes Release of Lease Signed document & email
from Jeanie)
7. Casey Johnson Background Check

8. Employee Contract and Time Off
9. Joseph Mingolla/Immigration Issues for employees ( Removed and placed
in a redwell)

10. JEE Firearms Licensing/Guns
11. Irrigation System Proposal - Precise Irrigation
12. Dispute with Irrigation Consultant

13. Innovative Telephone Service Arrangement/Fiber Optics/Phone Service
14. Cell Tower/Tower License Agreement

15. Two Way Radio Access
16. Gensler - Screening Room construction
17. LSJ General Projects
18. Marjorie Roberts Invoices

19. Household Expenditure Procedures
20. Rampino Dispute
21. Visa Waiver, July 5, 2011
1.9 Operating File ill

1. Beach Sand
2. Wave Analysis
3. Tiki Hut
4. Property Revaluation
5. Dredging
6. Environmental Resource Inventory and Water Quality Impact
Assessment/Mike de Haas

7. Pictures sent to Amy Dempsey 6-19-2008
8. Environmental Assessment Report August 2007
9. Environmental Assessment Report April 2008

10. Environmental Assessment Report October 2008
11. Rock Crushing Operations
12. Energy Report Outline and Energy Alternatives

13. LSJ Agenda 3-27-09 (Meeting held in Palm Beach)
14. Matt Mahafey Terms of Agreement and Job Description

15. Brian Moseley Agreement (LSJ Shoreline work)
16.4 Color Detailed Map of LSJ (Drawing)
17. US Virgin Islands Port Authority Cyril E. King Airport ID Badge
Application

18. Agreement WAPA and LSJ
ENERGY ALTERNATIVES 2008/2009
1. Correspondence
2. Attorney Notes
3. Research

4. Memorandum
5. Newspaper Clippings
6. Contacts
7. Peter Branson's Island
8. WAPA
9. Wind Studies
10. Solar Photovoltaic System
11. Vendors
12. Outline of Energy Report
13. Windpower
Frir Williams-Hairoun Aviation Serviceg
-correspondence
-Demand Letter
-Check & Transmission Letter
-Litigation (Agreement)
-Re-Payment of Deposit
-Complaint
-JE vs. Eric Williams & Hairoun: Plaintiff JE's Answer to Defendants'Counterclaim
-Due Diligence
-On-Call Maintenance Services Agreement for Aircraft at STT btwn Spirit Airlines &
Hairoun Aviation dba Execujet Flight Services (Execujet)
-Two General Releases, Stipulation & Order for Dismissal (March 3 & 4, 2010)
-Notice of Entry of Order (Order of Dismissal) March 2010
WIA Conies Design Team Minutes & Notes
LSJ Construction Project
-Proposal by Curtis (Based on Gensler Schematic 2/26/09)
GRM#004740720
Alain Gifford vs. LSJ
-Correspondence
-Operating File
-Demand for Arbitration
-American Arbitration Associates
-Preliminary Hearing Schedule Order
-American Arbitration Invoices
-Complainant's First Request for Production of Documents
-Complainant's First Set of Interrogatories to Respondent
-Letter and Proposed Notice of Deposition sent to Att. Carty (March 2, 2010)
-Respondents Opposition To Claimants Motion to Dismiss
-March 1, 2010 Order
-Notice of Deposition of Alain Gifford, March 16, 2010
RIBTEC BINDER
OBM VS LSI
-Correspondence
-Amended Statement of Claim (June 30, 2010) ORIGINALS in HERE
-Ferara Kerins Retainer Agreement
-Misc. OBM vs LSJ correspondence, invoices, agreements (pulled from storage)
-OBM Limited Rich Kahn emails and invoices
- Misc. OBM vs LSJ correspondence, invoices, agreements (pulled from storage)
-OBM bound copy of Preliminary Cost Estimate
Gensler
-Correspondence
-Standard Terms & Conditions of the Agreement btwn Client & Architect
-March 3rd, March 27 AND April 13, 2009 LSJ Screening Room, Architectural Services
Proposal-Revised
-Agreement for Architectural Services, May 5, 2009 AND Sept. 28, 2009
-LSJ Screening Room Proposal REVISED April 27, 2009 and March 3, 2009
-Agreement for Architectural Services, Sept. 28, 09/ Oct. 6, 2009
Joesph Mingolla/Immigration Bond Issue
Amerling Weekly Reports
Island Grounds Inc. Employee Documents

1. Alain Gifford v. Island Grounds
2. November 2008 Job Descriptions
3. All other Employees
4. Alain Gifford vs Islands Grounds Inc (Wrongful) Discharge Letter)

5. Pierre Jules
6. Island Grounds, Inc. Employee Status
7. Copies of Permanent Resident Cards
8. Island Grounds Sick/Vacation/Personal Days

9. Termination of Dave Henry & Curdilius Monchery
GRM#0047 50673
Allen Gifford
-Allen Gifford Unemployment Insurance
-Allen Gifford vs. Islands Grounds Inc
-Motion to Dismiss or in the Alternative for Summary Judgment
-Release & Confidentiality Agreement Signed March 25, 2009
-Notice of Nonmonetary determination or Redetermination/Ltr from Lance and
other workers (etc)
FT Real Estate. Inc. Operating File

1. Purchase of Bolongo Estate
2. Bolongo Estate Insurance
3. Purchase of Fish Hawk Marina
Executors. LLC

1. Articles of Organization
2. Certificate of Existence
3. Operating Agreement
4. Invoices
Purchase of 65FT Commercial Headboat

I. Offer to Purchase Agreement
Hodge and Francois
-Invoices
Midnight Express Lawsuit
-Midnight Express -Marine Survey Report
-Kirkland and Ellis Retention to Provide Legal Services document
-Kirkland and Ellis Invoices
-Correspondence, Notes, Pictures, Copy of Certificate of Title, etc.
-Confidential Settlement Agreement & Mutual Release of All Claims (includes
Purchase & Sale Agreement, Payment Schedule, Exclusions from Trade In, Limited
Warranty)
-Verification of Complaint (signed by Jeffrey)
-New Midnight Express Powerboats Invoice
-Copy of Unsigned Agreement
-Faxed Copies of Signed Conf. Agreement & Mutual Release of All Claims (June 24,
2009)
-Copy of Signed Agreement (June 24, 2009)
-Unsigned Agreement for "The Credit" (SIDE LETTER to Agreement July 2, 2009)
-Signed and Completed Agreement by Jeffrey AND Harris Glaser
-Signed Agreement for "The Credit" (fax copy) (SIDE LETTER to Agreement, Signed
July 15, 09)
-Notice of Discontinuance
-Bill of Sale
-Midnight Express Power Boats Purchase and Sale Agreement
- Warranty Card
-Midnight Express Power Boats, Inc. Limited Warranty, Effective as of May 1, 2006
Application for Economic Development Benefits (Extension) dated Ian. 13,
2009
FTC Recommendation for Economic Development Benefits (Extension Application for
Economic Development Benefits (EDC) Nov. 30, 2009)
Renewed EDC Certificate 2010
EDC 2010 Renewal
Gary Kerney
-Lease (Calypso Realty)
-David Gott Invoices and Correspondence
- Lease Renewal Endorsement (beginning March 15, 2010 ending March 31, 2011)
-Lease Renewal Endorsement (beginning April 1, 2011 and ending Sept 30, 2011)
Water Permit -Analysis of Professional and Related Fees Paid
Great St. lames
-Offer Letter (Christian Kjaer c/o Kevin D'Amour)
-Accountant Representation Letter
Purchase of Crew Boat- Sub Quest (Subquestj
-Correspondence
-Deposit Agreement & Purchase Agreement
-General Index or Abstract of Title
-Bill of Sale (Signed and Unsigned)
-Protocol of Delivery
-Acceptance of Vessel
-Appraisal
-D&B Report of Seller
-Evidence of Deletion from US Registry (and removed from Atlantis Submarines St.
Thomas Inc. ownership)
-Funds Transfer Request
-Wire Transfer Instructions to Seller
-Executed Warranty of Title and Treasurers Certificate
-Signed Authorization of Release of Funds and Acceptance of Vessel (Jan. 26, 2010)
- Transaction Paperwork (for Darren's review on Jan. 18, 2010)
-Atlantis Submarine Minutes of Meeting
Celina's Transportation Company. LLC

1. Articles of Organization
2. Certificate of Existence
3. Operating Agreement
4. EIN
Celina's Marina. LLC
1. Articles of Organization
2. Certificate of Existence
3. EIN
4. Operating Agreement
ARMY CORPS OF ENGINEERS
Correpsondence
Meeting w/CZM Recap Notes
Sketch of Shorline Changes
Correspondence re Shorelines
Letter to Col Carpenter of Army Corps rom Fish & Wildlife Services
Beach Restoration Plan (from Darren to ACOE, Sindulfo, Rosario)
J SI DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING WATER PERMIT BINDER I
LSJ DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING WATER PERMIT BINDER II
Notice of Violation
GRM#004750674
SUSMAN'S ZWIRN ARBITRATION FILES
GRM#004750675
SUSMAN'S ZWIRN ARBITRATION FILES
GRM#004750676
SUSMAN'S ZWIRN ARBITRATION FILES
GRM#004750677
SUSMAN'S ZWIRN ARBITRATION FILES
GRM#004750678
SUSMAN'S ZWIRN ARBITRATION FILES
GRM#004750679
CHARACTER REFERENCE LETTERS
FLORIDA CLEMENCY PACKAGE
PBL-OPR COMPLAINT
OPR Complaint-Post Incarceration Criminal Matters
Notification of Identified Victims, Sept. 2, 2008
Recusal
STALKER FILE
INCARCARATION
-PB County Sheriff's Office Dept of Corrections
-PB County Stockade Directory
PALM BEACH LITIGATION
-Grand Jury Subpoena Motion
-Notice of Hearing Dates
-Police Report
-Letter from Lefcourt to & =, Feb. 1, 2007
-Letter from Lefcourt to Feb. 23, 2007
-Letter from Lefcourt to & June 25, 2007
-Letter from Lefcourt to & July 6, 2007
MISCELLANEOUS IE CASE DOCUMENTS
-Letter to Chief, Criminal Division US Attorneys Office
From Lilly Sanchez, Aug.2, 2007
-Letter To Lilly Sanchez From Alexander Acosta, Dec. 19, 2007
-Letter to Mike Tein from July 17, 2008
-Notification of Identified Victim (to Edwards from (Victim
Info 2008)
-Epstein-Responses-Confidential (Final Aug. 16. 2007)
-Compilation DVD Made by
-Video Depositions (Could use in Brad Edwards Case)
Bill Riley Investigations Sent to Mike Tein and Roy Black
MERRIE SPAETH COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
MERRIE SPAETH CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT
PBL INVOICES
CIVIL CASES
NON-PROSECUTION AGREEMENT
AMERICAN HOME ASSURANCE
VOLUMES I & II BACKUP BINDERS
PALM BEACH LITIGATION
-Non-Prosecution Agreement and Addendum
-June 12, 2008 Draft DOJ Letter
-Letter to Filip from Starr and Whitley (5-27-08)
-March 28, 2008 Letter to DOJ
-DOJ Submission (Summary)
-DOJ Submission (Attachment Letter)
-April 8, 2009 Submission to Hon. Mandelker
-April 28, 2008 Submission to Hon. Mandelker
-Letter from DOJ
-May 19, 2008 Letter to Hon. Filip
-Correspondence
-Correspondence sent to Roy Black (June 12, 2008)
-Submission to Hon. Asst. Attorney General
-Kirkland & Ellis 4-8-08 Letter to DOJ Misconduct
-Letter to Asst. US Attorney 2-23-07
-Letter to Asst US Attorney 2-1-07
-Submission To the US Dept. of Justice in the Matter of JEE
-November DOJ
-Presentation Outline August 31, 2007
-JEE Case Analysis Chart
--Mathew Freidrich Biography
-Sentence (June 30, 2008)
-Cover Sheet from re JE's Tax Returns
-Charges and Sentence
-Investigative Management Group
PB CRIMINAL LITIGATION FILE
Gun Possession
Correspondence from JEE to DKI
email to Gauger re Work Release
letter to Captain Sleeth re Work Release, Dec. II, 08
Non-Prosecution Agreement
Addendum to Non-Prosecution Agreement (MISSING WHEN DARREN RTRND
Jan.2011)
Plea Agreement
Transfer of Community Control
Kreusler-Walsh, Compiani & Vargas Signed Representation Letter
Community Control Order (in JE's Criminal Case)
Summary of Arguments Regarding Work Release (by Kirkland & Ellis)
Letter to Jay Lefkowitz from US Attorney, July 7, 2009
Kreusler-Walsh Summary of Law RE Stays Pending Appeal
Indictment
Drafts & Misc JEE Criminal Matter
Sentence
Order on Motion
Research Re Restoration of Civil Rights
Denial of Restoration of Civil Rights by PB Parole Boar
PALM BEACH LITIGATION
GRAND JURY SUBPOENA MOTION
NOTICE OF HEARING DATES
POLICE REPORT
LETTER FROM LEFCOURT TO
LETTER FROM LEFCOURT TO
FEB. 1, 2007 (& ANDRE
FEB 23,2007
LETTER FROM LEFCOURT TO ==,
JUNE 25, 2007
LETTER FROM LEFCOURT TO a
VILLAFANAJULY 6, 2007
Palm Beach Litigation Invoices

1. Critton Retainer Agreementn (DKI Summary of Critton Retainer)
2. Burman, Critton, Luther & Coleman
3. Bruce E. Reinhart

4. Firm
5. William (Bill) Riley
6. Riley Kiraly
DOCUMENT PRODUCTIONS REC'D FROM CRITTON
GRM#004750680
DB Zwirn Folder #1
Correspondence (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Organizational Chart (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Attorneys Notes
Articles Re Zwirn
Schedule & Source of Investment Funds (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Settlement Agreement
Investor Communications
Financial Statements Dec. 31, 2007
Audited 2008 Financial Statements
2004 Valuations/Investor Commentary
2005 Valuations/Investor Commentary
2006 Valuations/Investor Commentary
2007 Valuations/Investor Commentary
2008 Valuations/Investor Commentary
2009 Valuations
2010 Valuation, Capital Balances (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
7/9/04 Request for Management Fee Increases
Withdrawal Nov 13, 2006
Withdrawal Feb 14, 2007
Withdrawal Feb 13, 2008
Withdrawal Request June 30, 2008
Withdrawal Jan. 31, 2007
Analysis of Interest Calculations from April 1, 2007
Schulte 3/27/07 Denial of Withdrawal
DKI/Schulte Correspondence
HB Drafts & Notes re 11/13/2006 Withdrawal (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
DBZ Communication Re: Withdrawal Rights
3/26/2007 Report by Zwirn Re: Independent Investigation (Missing as of Jan. 28,
2010)
DB Zwirn Folder #2
Subscription May 1, 2002
Subscription Sept. 1, 2002
Subscription Dec 1, 2002
Subscription June 1, 2003
Subscription Jan 1, 2005
Subscription Jeepers Jan 2007
DR Zwirn Folder #3
Sub Docs Blank
April 2002 Offering Memo
April 2002 LPA
May 2003 Offering Memo
May 1, 2003 Amended & Restated LPA
Oct 1, 2004 Amendment to Amend & Restate LPA
Consent to 10/1/04 Amendment of ARLPA (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Nov 2004 Supp to Offering Memo
DB Zwirn Folder #4
May 2005 2nd A&R Agreement of LPA
May 2005 Offering Memo (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Consent to May 2005 Amend (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Jan 11, 2005 Amendment
Drafts re: Meeting w/Mike Carroll of Davis Polk (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Dubin Memo to DKI re: Zwirn Liquidity (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
DBZ Feb 2006 Investment Adviser Registration (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Fortress Investment Advisor Registration
California Dept of Corporations Statements of Identity & Questionnaire (Missing as
of Jan. 28, 2010)
Materials Sent to Davis Polk on 4/15/08 (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
DB Zwirn Folder #5
May 8, 2009 DBZ LP Proxy
May 5, 2009 DBZ LTD Proxy
Zwirn Folder #6
Dubin Connection (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
NYS Tax Withholding (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Withdrawal Requests Not Sent (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Complaint Against DBZ (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Subpoena April 16, 2008
FTC Assignment of DBZ to Jeepers
DBZ Name Change
Cash, Fees, Loss Analysis (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Misc. (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Schedule of Contributions by FTC (Missing as of Jan. 28, 2010)
Fortress Letter Dec. 3, 2009
Jeepers' Cancellation Declaration
Affidavit of Glen Dubin re Zwirn (Original and Faxed Copy)
Fortress VRF Advisors I LLC, Net Asset Values July - Nov. 2009
Fortress Investment Group, Form ADV Part II, Uniform Application for Investment
Advisor Registration
Press Releases
SEC Subpoena to Jeepers
Jeepers Inc Redemption Request March 27, 2007
Redlined Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund, LP 2nd Amended & Restated Agreement
of Limited Partnership dated May 2005
Jeepers 2009 K1 Estimate for VRF I LLC
Conf. Agreement w/Paul Weiss Re March 26, 2010 Meeting w/Fund (Missing as of
Jan. 28, 2010)
Fortress Value Recovery Fund (VRF) I LLC Consolidated Financial Statements Dec.
31, 2009
Fortress Value Recovery Fund I LLC Consolidated Financial Statements Dec. 31,
2010
Fortress VRF Update Sept. 2010 -March 2011
PRZ Files Folder #7
-Investor Communication (Fortress VRF Investor Letter)
-First Set of Document Requests by Fortress
-Zwim and Zwirn Entities First Request for Production
-Zwim Discovery
-CD from Kirkland & Ellis- Communications re Jeepers vs Zwirn
-Memoranda
-Settlement Agreement & Release 4-8-09
DB Zwirn Duplicates
DBZ Files
DBZ Files: Redactions for Harry Susinan Review
DBZ Files
JEEPERS V. DB ZWIRN
Zwirn Operating File-
-Correspondence
-Epstein Vs.
-Zwim Litigation-Attorney Notes
-SIGNED Settlement Agreement & Release, date April 8, 2009, between Zwim, Jeepers,
FTC and Jeffrey Epstein
-Proxy Statement Relating to Transfer of Mngt to Fortress (DB Zwim Special
Opportunities Fund, Ltd) May 5, 2009
-Kirkland and Ellis Invoices re Epstein vs. DB Zwirn
-Harry's Summary Re Proposed Transaction btwn DBZCO & Fortress
-Zwim Articles (WSJ and NY Post April 3, 2009)
-Analysis of Jeepers Capital Balance in DBZ
- DB Zwirn Special Opportunities Funds Investor Communication (Jeepers)
GRM#004750681
Jeepers. Inc. USVI

1. Articles of Incorporation/Certificate of Existence
2. S-Election
3. EIN
4. Qualified Subchapter S Subsidiary Election

5. Annual Reports
6. Franchise Tax
7. Minutes
8. Affidavit of Not Conducting Business
9. First Bank Account

10. IRS Notices
11. Jeepers Inc Stock Certificate, 1000 Shares, Aug. 18, 2003
Jeepers Inc. Transactions
1. D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund f/k/a/Highbridge/Zwim Special
Opportunities Fund I ( ASSIGNED FROM FTC)

I. D.B. Zwirn Special Opportunities Fund f/k/a/Highbridge/Zwim Special
Opportunities Fund II( ASSIGNED FROM FTC)

2. DB Zwim Special Opportunities Funds Investor Communication
3. Bear Stearns Bank Account
4. Highbridge DB Zwim Miscellaneous

a. DRAFT of Settlement Agreement
b. Fund Organization 2002 and 2005
c. Zwim Article November 2008
Zwirn Miscellaneous
-Highbridge/Zwim Settlement Agreement Draft
-Zwim Article 2008
-Fund Organization 2002 and 2005
ZWIRN ARBITRATION FILE
- -Third-Party Respondents' Response to Financial Trust Company, Inc's and Jeepers,
Inc's Statement of Counterclaim and Third Party Claim (June 25, 2010)(Fortress VRF v.
Jeepers & FTC v. Fortress VRF & DB Zwim Partners)
-Response to Counterclaims (June 25, 2010) (Fortress VRF v. Jeepers & FTC v. DB
Zwim Special Opportunities Fund & DB Zwirn Parnters)
-Judge Carpinello's Scheduling Order
-Filing Made with JAMS (by Harry Susman) May 21, 2010
-FTC & Jeepers First Request for Production of Documents
-ZWIRN ARB: Claiments Opening Statement
-Communications Regarding Jeepers/DB Zwirn 1 of 2
-Communications Regarding Jeepers/DB Zwirn 2 of 2
-Legal Pad of Darren;s: Nots of Dan Zwirn in Zwirn Arbitration JAMS
-Fortress/Zwirn Arbitration Document Chronology Binder
MATERIALS SENT TO MIKE TEIN. MAY 7. 2008 REDWELD
GRM#004750682
BEAR STEARNS ABS TRUST CERTIFICATE
Bear Stearns ABS Trust Certificate
BEAR STEARNS LITIGATION IV MISC
FTC vs. BEAR (Virgin Islands Stock Retention Action),
-Correspondence
a. Letter from Dema to Darren re the need of factual assertion and meeting
w/JE
b. US Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation General Order amending Filing
Deadlines
-Attorney Notes
-Jack Dema Retainer Agreement
-Verified Complaint, FTC vs. Bear Stearns, Filed by Jack Dema Aug. 5, 2009
-Summons in a Civil Action (FTC vs. The Bear Stearns Companies)
-Verification (Verified Complaint)Signed by Darren Indyke and Notorized July 31st,
2009
-Letter from Dema re Withdrawal as Counsel (Nov 23, 09 and Dec. 8, 09)
-Letter from Dema re transfer of case to the MDL (Multidistrict Litigation) Jan. 8,
2010
-Stipulation for Enlargement of Time for Defendant to Answer, Move or Otherwise
Respond to the Verified Complaint and proposed Order (for Darren's review)
-Order dated Feb. 1, 2010
-Substitution of Counsel (June 29, 2010)
- Bear Stearns Settlement
BEAR STEARNS VIRGIN ISLANDS MULTI DISTRICT
-Correspondence
-Attorney Notes
-Memoranda
-Research
-Pleadings
-Discovery
-Orders
BEAR STEARNS SETTLEMENT
-Correspondence
-Settlement Agreement & Release
-Susman Certification RE: No Discovery & Stipulations of Dismissal
w/Prejudice
-Wire Transfer Instructions
-W9
-Spector Release
-Stipulation of Dismissal w/Prejudice-Arbitration
-Stipulation of Dismissal -VI Action/Consolidated Action
Bear Stearns Settlement Class Action/MDL Complaint
Bear Stearns Arbitration (Harry Susman)(Finra Dispute Resolution. Inc)FTC &
COUQ vs Bear Stearns & Warren Spector
-Correspondence
-FTC and The COUQ Foundation's Amended Statement of Claim
-Statement of Answer (FTC & COUQ vs. Bear and Warren Spector) Dec. 4, 2009
-Amended Statement of Answer (Dec. 4, 2009)
-Finra Arbitration Submission Agreement
-Susman Godfrey LLP Invoices and Engagement Letter (July 31, 2009)
-Arbitrators
-Signed Agreement re Susman representing FTC in the FTC v Bear Stearns Case
-FINRA Arbitration: FTC & COUQ vs Bear Stearns & Warren Spector
-Analysis of Susman Bills
-Bear Stearns Settlement
-Susman Godrey Questionaire
THE COUQ FOUNDATION INC. ASSIGNMENT OF BEAR STEARNS ASSET BACKED
SECURITIES TO THE YLK CHARITABLE FUND
-General Correspondence
-YLK Application For Recognition of Exemption
-Due Diligence to Zeiger
-Bear Stearns Asset Backed Securities Overseas
-Irrevocable Assignment
-Grant Agreement
-COUQ Foundation Consent to Assignment and Grant Agreement
-Organizational Minutes of YLK
-Bear Stearns Global Settlement Materials Binder
COUQ Transactions
-Confidential Memorandum Relating to Tranche B Shares of Bear Stearns Asset Backed
Securities Overseas Ltd
-The Companies Law (As Amended) Company Limited By Shares Amended & Restated
Memorandum & Articles of Association of Bear Stearns Asset Backed Securities Overseas
LTD
-Bear Stearns Asset Backed Securities Overseas LTD Subscription Documents for US Tax
Exempt Investors
-COUQ Bear Stearns Asset Securities Overseas LTD
-COUQ Foundation Subscription: Second City Capital Partners I
-COUQ Goldman Sachs Account
-COUQ/JP Morgan Account
-COUQ Foundation Subscription Documents Bear Stearns Asset Backed Securities Partners,
LP
-JP Morgan POA COUQ
THE COUQ FOUNDATION INC ASSIGNMENT OF SECOND CITY
CAPITAL PARTNERS I TO THE YLK CHARITABLE FUND
-CORRESPONDENCE
-YLK AGREEMENT LTR RE THE ASIGNMENT OF THE PUT AGREEMENT
FROM COUQ
-TRANSFER AGREEMENT B/WCOUQ & YLK
-IRREVOCABLE ASSIGNMENT
-YLK BOARD RESOLUTION APPROVAL OF ENTIRE TRANSFER
DUE DILIGENCE TO JOHN ZEIGER
-GRANT AGREEMENT
-ORGANIZATIONAL MINUTES OF YLK
GRM#004750683
PALM BEACH MATTERS: Epstein Back Up Binder Volume 1 of 2
PALM BEACH MATTERS: Epstein Back Up Binder Volume 2 of 2
ATTORNEYS NOTES, RESEARCH & SUBPOENAS
Attorney Notes
Hyperion Air Subpoenas
Epstein Interests Subpoenas

J. Epstein VI Foundation Subpoenas
J. Epstein & Compamy, Inc. Subpoenas
Financial Trust Company, Inc. Subpoenas
NES Subpoenas
Mr Subpoena
JEGE Inc Subpoena
NYSG Retainer Agreement Lawrence Goldman
Investigation Invoices
JEE Connection Florida
PB Days
JEE Employee List by Entity
Summary of Giving
Florida Vehicles
Medical Records
JEE Medical
Invoices
EMAILS FROM US ATTORNEY OFFICE TO LEFKOWITZ
CONFIDENTIAL SUBMISSION TO CHILD EXPLOITATIONAND OBSCENITY
SECTION
MISC. PALM BEACH BINDER
PB Matters 2012
Chronology of Relevant Doc's in PB Matter (CD)
GRM#004750684
FORM TRUST AGREEMENTS
Wexner Miscellaneous
I. YLK Charitable Fund
2. Annual Inv for Statutory Representation for Buckeye, LLC
3. 1099-DIV for the RHREI Trust
LSW CLIPPINGS (LESLIE WEXNER)
PB MARINE CONTRACTORS
BRIAN MOSELEY PROGRESS PRINT. SEPT 28. 2005 LS(
MOLYNEUX LSJ SET OF DRAWINGS MARCH 6. 2008
MCGUIRE GROUP. APRIL 12. 2007. WATER DEMAND MATRIX,
UTILITIES MASTER PLAN REPORT JUNE 26. 2006, CONSTRUCTION
PHASE DRAWING CP1, DRAWING L1 LANDSCAPE REVISED 1/5/07,
Mech Building Sketch
ZORRO RANCH WATER RIGHST ABSTRACT REPORT BINDER, SEPT.
1.2005
ZORRO RANCH KING BROTHERS LAND STORAGE
PURCHASE OF EXECUJET
CLOSING BINDER FOR PURCHASE OF ZORRO RANCH BY ZORRO
TRUST, MARCH 8, 1993
ORGANIZATIONAL INFORMATION OF ENTITIES JEE, SEPT 15. 2008
LAUREN KWINTER'S OLD SPIRAL NOTEBOOK
CONTENT TO CHANGE ATTORNEY -RADAR MAGAZINE
GRM#004750685
LEFCOURT CRIMINAL FILES
GRM#004750686
LEFCOURT OCT. 19, 2006 PB BINDER
CORRESPONDENCE POST 6/30/08
NATHAN DERSHOWITZ APPLICABLE FEDERAL LAW BINDER
PALM BEACH MATTERS: EPSTEIN BACKUP BINDER 1 OF 2
PALM BEACH MATTERS: EPSTEIN BACKUP BINDER 2 OF2
SEX OFFENDER REGISTRY
LEFCOURT INVESTIGATION OF
CIVIL CASES CD
INDEXES OF COMPUTER FILES
GRM#004750687
LIPPER I AND II REDWELDS
GRM#004750688
LSJ MISCELLANEOUS BLUE PRINTS
GRM#004750689
HARRY BELLER DOCUMENTS
GRM#004626325
FINANCIAL TRUST COMPANY INC. ORGANIZATIONAL FILE
Tax Recovery Brochure
Tax Issue 2004
Corporate Franchise Tax
Registration Requirements for Securities Transactions in USVI 2005
Financial Report 2003 Federal Tax Return 2007
FINANCIAL TRUST COMPANY INC. TRANSACTIONS I
Balance Sheets
FTC/AIG CBO IRS Form 5471
Hambrecht & Quist
JP Morgan Account
JP Morgan POA sent 6/26/08
JP Morgan ISDA and Credit Support Annex
Morgan Stanley Dean Witter
JP Morgan Chase Account
Google SWAP Transaction FTC/JP Morgan Chase
Bear Stearns Futures Account
Bear Stearns Options Trading Account
Bear Stearns Master Repurchase Agreement 10/11/00
Bear Stearns FTC/Morgan SWAP 10/18/01
Bear Stearns Watchill Erroneous Debit 4/07
Goldman Sachs Account and Master Repurchase Agreement 1/20/00
Goldman Sachs Brokerage Account 2002
Goldman Sachs Account 2007
Goldman Sach Currency Business FTC/LHS/JEE
FTC Prime Brokerage Account Goldman Sachs
First Union
Credit Suisse
11/01/01 Purchase of Estee Lauder
June 25, 2001 Transfer of TOO, Inc LHW to FTC
FINANCIAL TRUST COMPANY INC TRANSACTION FILES II
FTC/Merrill Lynch ISDA Agreement
Merrill Lynch Capital Services Inc ISDA Agreement
AP Technology Partners LLC
Tudor Futures Fund 2/1/01
SAB Capital Partners Subscription Agreement 1/30/01
SAB Capital Partners, L.P. Subscription Document 4/24/02
Global Opportunities
Viking Global Consumer Fund Subscription Documents
FINANCIAL TRUST COMPANY INC VI (FTC).
JCK Partners Opportunity Fund
Highbridge Managed Account
FTC Consulting Agreement with Highbridge Management
FTC/Wexner Children's Trust/MBZ-Purchase of Boston Properties from
Prudential
AP SHL Investors, LLC
Viking Global Equities LP Subscription Documents/Confidential
Memorandum
Second City Capital
Bear Stearns Emerging Markets Macro Fund
FTC Consulting Agreement w/Highbridge Management
Purchase of Island Global/AYH Ownership
GRM#004740697 (Took From Storage June 13,
2013)
CMA vs. JEE and
Correspondence
Summons and Complaint EE
Summons and Complaint
Motion, Notice and Order of Dismissal
Rosenfeldt vs. Rothstein
Doe 1 Case # 6596
Doe II Case # 20614 Document Production
Doe II Case # 20614
Jane Doe 8 Case # 80802
Jane Doe 102 Case # 80656
CMA Case# 80811
AC Case # 25129
DRAWER TWO:
Josefsberg Invoices and Disc
81092
Doe 2 Case # 80119
Poe 3 Case# 80232
DRAWER THREE
Doe 4 Case # 80380
naessasp-itsoaM
DRAWER FOUR
Doe 6 Case # 80994
Poe 7 Case #
lane Doe 101 Case # 80591
FIFTH DRAWER
Jane Doe Case # 80893
Jane Doe 11 Case # 80469
im Case # 28051
LM CASE #20851PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI AND APPENDIX TO PETITION FOR WRIT OF
CERTIORARI (LOCATED IN A REDWELD ON ITS OWN!)
EDWARDS
FAV rase # 28058
atiasalL3131a
fasP # 8073€
Case# 4D09-2254
ON THE FLOOR
Video-Conferenced and Videotaped Deposition of Jane Doe 4, Tues. Oct. 27, 2009
(Volume I of Ill, Volume II of III and Volume Ill of Ill) Video-Taped Compulsory
Medical Evaluation of Jane Doe 4 Volume I and II
Video-Conferenced and Videotaped Deposition of Dec. 4, 2009
(Volume I of 11 and Volume II of II)
MJ vs EPSTEIN
-CORRESPONDENCE
-ATTORNEY'S NOTES
-DEPOSITION SUBPOENA TO JE
-PLEADINGS
-AFFIDAVIT OF RICIIARD BARNETT
-MI'S MOTION FOR A PROTECTIVE ORDER BARRING DIRECT OR INDIRECT CONTACT
BY EPSTEIN
-MJ'S MOTION FOR PRESERVATION OF EVIDENCE RELATING TO CORRESPONDENCE
WITH TILE US ATTORNEYS OFFICE
-SUPPLEMENTAL AFFIDAVIT OF RICIIARD BARNETT
-SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT & GENERAL RELEASE OF ALL CLAIMS
-CONFIDENTIALITY AGREEMENT AGAINST UNAUTHORIZED DISCLOSURE OF
SETTLEMENT
EPSTEIN VS ROTHSTEIN REDWELD #1
-REVISED PRIVILEGE LOG HILIGHTED BY JE
-DISPUTE OVER PRODUCTION OF "PRIVILEGED" DOCUMENTS
EPSTEIN VS ROTHSTEIN REDWELD #2
-CONSENT OF PLAINTIFF JE TO MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL
-INDICIES OF DOGS PRODUCED SCHERER & FARMER
-COMPLETED INDEX OF VOLUME 7 OF CONRAD SCHERER'S DOCUMENTS
-CARA HOLMES
-SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT, AUGUST 22, 2011
-HEARING ON COUNTER-PLAINTIFF/DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY
JUDGEMENT JULY 27, 2012
-CD OF ALL PLEADINGS IN ROTIISTEIN CASE UP TO FEB. ACCORDING TO LILLY
-NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF FOWLER IN BANKRUPTCY CASE
-DOCS REC'D FROM CONRAD SCHERER'S OFFICE
Rothstein Case Privelege Logs (this is it's own Redweld)
Settlement Agreements (Located on the floor next to file cabinet
#1) and Dismissals
-Video Depositions and DVD that could be used in Brad Edwards Case (SENT
THE DVD TO JAY LEFKOWITZ ON OCT. 14, 2010)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Order Adopting Stipulation &
Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of
Dismissal)]
(Stipulation of Dismissal, Order Dismissing w/Prejudice)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement)
(Settlement Agreement)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement)
I (Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement)
(.. Case # 81092) (Final Order of Dismissal, Stipulation of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Settlement Agreement)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement)
(Stipulation of Dismissal, Order Dismissing Claims and Closing Case)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement, Stipultion of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal, Order
Adopting & Entering Joint Stipulation)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of
Dismissal)
Non-N PA (Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
(Signed Settlement)
(Signed Settlement, Stipulation of Dismissal, Final Order of Dismissal)
-Compilation DVD made by
Communications Regarding Jeepers/DB Zwirn 1 of 2
Communications Regarding Jeepers/DB Zwirn 2 of 2
EFTA00604145 (Jmail)
 [reputation] letter from Michael Sitrick to Jeffrey Epstein lawsuit about unpaid bills
(inferred date: 2026-01-09)
NEMECEK COLE
Attorneys At Law
writer. Vincent S. Green

e. vgreenememecek-cole.com  file number. 2489.003

July 9, 2012
Stephen G. Rinehart, Esq.
Troutman & Sanders, LLP
The Chyrsler Building
405 Lexington Avenue
New York, NY 10174-0700

Re: Sitrick and Company v. Jeffrey Epstein
AAA Reference No. 72 147218 12 SIM

Dear Mr. Rinehart:
VIA EMAIL ONLY
As we have informed AAA, we are preparing to file a petition to compel binding
arbitration in the Los Angeles Superior Court. Attached is the complaint we plan to file to start
the process.
We would prefer to litigate this matter in the confidential setting of AAA. Please let us
know whether Mr. Epstein would be willing to voluntarily agree to attend arbitration and avoid
the need for us to file a petition to compel binding arbitration and the attached complaint.
VSG/jIch
Enclosure
Very truly yours,
CEK &FOLE
VINCENT S. GREEN
2489003L.3 Marshall
15260 Ventura Boulevard. Suite 920 Sherman Oaks. CA 91403-5344
Tel 818.788.9500 / Fax 818.601.0328 / vno.v.nemecelc-cole.com
JONATHAN B. COLE (70460)
VINCENT S. GREEN (231046)
NEMECEK & COLE APC
15260 Ventura Boulevard, Suite 920
Sherman Oaks, CA 91403
Tel: (818) 788-9500 / Fax: (818) 501-0328
Attorneys for Plaintiff SITRICK AND COMPANY,
a division of SITRICK BRINCKO GROUP, LLC
SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FOR THE COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES - CENTRAL DISTRICT
SITRICK AND COMPANY, a division of ) Case No.
SITRICK BRINCKO GROUP, LLC, )
)
Plaintiff, )
)

vs. )
)
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, an individual; and )
DOES 1 through 20, inclusive, )
)
Defendants. )
)
COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES
BASED UPON:

(1) BREACH OF CONTRACT;
(2) BREACH OF ORAL CONTRACT;
(3) COMMON COUNTS;
(4) ACCOUNT STATED;
(5) OPEN BOOK ACCOUNT; AND

(6) QUANTUM MERUIT
DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
Plaintiff, SITRICK and COMPANY, a division of SITRICK BRINCKO GROUP, LLC
("Plaintiff' or "Sitrick") complains and alleges as follows:
GENERAL ALLEGATIONS

1. Plaintiff is, and at all times herein mentioned was, a limited liability
company organized and existing under and pursuant to the laws of the State of California
and doing business in the State of California, with its principal place of business located
in Los Angeles County

2. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that defendant
2489003P.1.com COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
JEFFREY EPSTEIN ("Epstein") is, and at all times relevant hereto was, a citizen of and
residing in the State of New York.

3. Epstein has engaged in the necessary minimal contacts with the State of
California for this Court to entertain personal jurisdiction, including, but not limited to,
entering into a contract in California with a California limited liability company, phone calls
and emails to Plaintiff in California for strategy and advice, and paying for services
delivered from California.

4. The true names and capacities of Defendants DOES 1 through 20,
inclusive, whether individual, corporate, associate, or otherwise, are unknown to Plaintiff
at this time, who therefore sues said Defendants by such fictitious names, and when the
true names and capacities of such Defendants are ascertained, Plaintiff will seek leave of
Court to amend this Complaint to insert same. Plaintiff is informed and believes and
thereon alleges that each Defendant named as a DOE is responsible for each and every
act and obligation hereinafter set forth.

5. Plaintiff is informed and believes and thereon alleges that each Defendant
named in this Complaint was at all times herein mentioned and now is the agent, servant
and employee of the other Defendants herein, and was at all such times acting within the
course and scope of said agency and employment and with the consent and permission
of each of the other co-Defendants, and each of the Defendants herein ratified each of
the acts of each of the other co-Defendants, and each of them.

6. The obligation sued upon herein was incurred in and is payable in the
County of Los Angeles, State of California.

7. The obligation is commercial in nature, not based upon a retail installment
sales contract or a conditional sales contract, and not subject to the provisions of Civil
Code §§1812.10 and 2984.4.
BACKGROUND FACTS

8. On or about November 4, 2005, Epstein entered into a written contract
(the "Contract") with Plaintiff to provide advice and public relations services to counter
2489003P.1.00m COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
;a, :1' LL
z -IL;
0 Pi
Ug
yU~LLc't3
LI
“N) Ce O ul :
Z clg
zz
iw
allegations that Epstein had improper sexual relations with a fourteen-year-old girl whom
he hired to perform a massage. The Contract provides it may be terminated with 30 days
written notice by either party. The Contract has never been terminated. A true and
correct copy of the contract is attached hereto as Exhibit 1.

9. On or about March 11, 2011, Epstein entered into an oral contract with
Plaintiff (the "Oral Contract") to provide consulting advice and public relations services to
work with his various attorneys to help counteract the media and public reaction to a
photograph of Prince Andrew, Duke of York, and Epstein walking in Central Park. News
articles were published in the United Kingdom and the United States entitled: "The Prince
and The Pedophile," "Duchess of York Got Loan from Wealthy US Pedophile," "Meet
Manhattan's Raunchy New Odd Couple - The Prince and the Pervert."

10. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that a literal tsunami
of stories were published citing Prince Andrew's friendship with Epstein, nearly all of
them detailing Epstein's prior 2008 conviction in state court for "procuring a person under
age 18 for prostitution." The media dredged up old stories from 2006, based on a police
affidavit that described the sworn statements of five alleged victims, including a fourteen-
year-old girl who stated that a naked Epstein masturbated himself and touched her
vaginal area with a purple vibrator while she massaged him wearing only a bra and thong
underwear.

11. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that the Daily Mail
newspaper led a resurgence of media coverage in 2011 based on an interview with a
woman named ("Ms. "), who said Epstein "trained her to be a
prostitute" for him and his friends, had sexual relations with her when she was under
eighteen, and transported her across state lines and international borders for sexual
purposes. Ms. told the Daily Mail that Epstein had introduced her when she was
seventeen to Prince Andrew, Duke of York, at Epstein's Florida mansion.

12. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that at the time
Epstein entered into the Oral Contract, he had already reportedly been sued in civil
2489003P. taxn COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
courts by as many as 40 separate plaintiffs who claimed he had sexually assaulted them
when they were minors. The media covering the Prince Andrew story were also actively
seeking the civil court complaints and interviews with the plaintiffs and their attorneys.
Ten days after Epstein entered into the Oral Contract with Sitrick, attorneys Brad
Edwards ("Edwards") and Paul Cassell ("Cassell"), representing two of the alleged
victims, filed papers in federal court in Palm Beach, Florida asking that Epstein's 2008
plea agreement be invalidated because, as part of the agreement, federal prosecutors
had secretly agreed not to prosecute Epstein for federal offenses, thereby violating their
clients' rights under the federal Crime Victim Rights Act.

13. Plaintiff is informed and believes and thereon alleges, that Edwards and
Cassell, who had named the Department of Justice as the defendant, were also seeking
to unseal federal documents that would lead to further embarrassing and damaging
stories about Epstein. Epstein expressed his concern to Sitrick that the media not obtain
the confidential federal documents. (The victims were granted limited discovery of federal
prosecutors' investigative documents in a September 23, 2011 ruling by U.S. District
Judge Kenneth A. Marra.)

14. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that Epstein was
very concerned that the confidential investigative documents that federal prosecutors
indicated could support charges against him on federal offenses not come to light in the
media. Despite being significantly handicapped by the facts surrounding the case, and
even beyond that, access to all information necessary to do its job, Sitrick was able to
dramatically mitigate the public relations damage to Epstein. Most frustrating was when
Sitrick was told one thing by Epstein, with respect to what the facts were, and something
else by Epstein's lawyers. One example of this was Epstein's plea that Sitrick help get
the media to stop calling him a pedophile, asserting that the girl identified as the
underage victim in his guilty plea was 17 years old, just days from her 18th birthday.

15. Sitrick recommended to Epstein that they seek retractions of all media uses
of the term "pedophile" and seek to place opinion pieces admonishing the media for using
2489003P.1.com COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
KrO tali 11
4-1 zons- 12
iow
U EP 13
03 O(-) - 14
won,C..)v)w 15
WLLNm
<0
_ak 17
g 18
the term inaccurately, arguing that the Mayo Clinic defines pedophilia as "an individual
who fantasizes about, is sexually aroused by, or experiences sexual urges toward
prepubescent children (generally less than 13 years of age) for a period of at least 6
months."

16. Sitrick even drafted a sample of what an opinion piece would say. Epstein's
attorneys, however, stated that what Epstein told Sitrick was not accurate. It was believed
that one or more of Epstein's alleged victims was so young as to be arguably in or near
that age range for Epstein to be considered a pedophile.
FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
(Breach of Written Contract as Against Epstein
and Does 1 through 20, and Each of Them)

17. Plaintiff repeats, realleges and incorporates herein by reference the
allegations of paragraphs 1 through 8, inclusive, as though set forth at length.

18. Pursuant to the terms of said Contract, entered into by and between
Plaintiff and Epstein on or about November 4, 2005, Plaintiff agreed to provide advice
and public relations services to Epstein, and Epstein agreed to pay for these services.

19. Plaintiff has sent written statements of account to Epstein listing the
amount of its indebtedness to Plaintiff and requesting payment thereof from Epstein.

20. On or about July 8, 2011, Epstein breached the Contract by failing to pay
Plaintiff for the advice and public relations services rendered.

21. Plaintiff has performed all conditions, covenants and promises required on
its part to be performed in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Contract
except as excused by the breach of Epstein

22. Pursuant to the terms of said Contract, and as a result of Epstein's breach
of said Contract, Plaintiff has been damaged in the sum of $103,517.82, together with
interest thereon at the legal rate from the date the obligations were due, and said sum is
now due and owing.
2489003P. icon COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
g oo
z 12
(C:iFew
C)20 13
figq (au. 14
c.1) O pE§ it 15
Op4 cc d e.. 16
Z4
ouj
r 18
SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION
(Breach Of Oral Contract as Against Epstein
and Does 1 through 20, and Each of Them)

23. Plaintiff repeats, realleges and incorporates herein by reference the
allegations of paragraphs 1 through 8, 9 inclusive, as though set forth at length.

24. Pursuant to the terms of said Oral Contract, entered into by and between
Plaintiff and Epstein on or about March 11, 2011, Plaintiff agreed to provide advice and
public relations services to Epstein, and Epstein agreed to pay for these services.

25. Plaintiff has sent written statements of account to Epstein listing the
amount of its indebtedness to the Plaintiff and requesting payment thereof from Epstein.

26. On or about July 8, 2011, Epstein breached the Oral Contract by failing to
pay Plaintiff for the advice and public relations services rendered.

27. Plaintiff has performed all conditions, covenants and promises required on
its part to be performed in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Oral Contract
except as excused by the breach of Epstein.

28. Pursuant to the terms of said Oral Contract, and as a result of Epstein's
breach of said Oral Contract, Plaintiff has been damaged in the sum of $103,517.82,
together with interest thereon at the legal rate from the date the obligations were due,
and said sum is now due and owing.
THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION
(Open Book Account For Reasonable Value Of Services Rendered as Against
Epstein, and Does 1 through 20, and Each of Them)

29. Plaintiff repeats, realleges and incorporates herein by reference the
allegations of paragraphs 1 through 8, inclusive, as though fully set forth at length herein.

30. Within the last four years, at Los Angeles County, California, Epstein
became indebted to Plaintiff in the sum of $103,517.82 as and for the balance due upon
an open book account for advice and public relations services provided by Plaintiff to
Epstein based upon the Contract and Oral Contract. Pursuant to the Contract and Oral
2480003P.1.com COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
Contract, payment was promised and agreed by Epstein to be made. Billing records of
legal fees and costs incurred by Epstein, including debits and credits, were kept in the
regular course of business by Plaintiff and kept in a reasonably permanent form reflecting
an open book account in the aggregate reasonable value of $103,517.82.

31. No part of said sum has been paid, although demand therefore has been
made, and there remains due, owing and unpaid from Epstein to Plaintiff the sum of
$103,517.82, together with interest thereon at the legal rate from the date the obligations
were due.
FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION
(Open Book Account, For Agreed Value of Services as Against Epstein, and Does 1
through 20, and Each of Them)

32. Plaintiff repeats, realleges and incorporates herein by reference the
allegations of paragraphs 1 through 8, inclusive, as though fully set forth at length herein.

33. Within the last four years, at Los Angeles County, California, Epstein
became indebted to Plaintiff for legal services provided by Plaintiff to Epstein at its
specific instance on an open book account in the agreed value of $103,517.82.

34. No part of said sum has been paid, although demand therefore has been
made, and there remains due, owing and unpaid from Epstein to Plaintiff the sum of
$103,517.82, together with interest thereon at the legal rate from the date the obligations
were due.
FIFTH CAUSE OF ACTION
(Account Stated Against Epstein and Does 1 through 20, and Each of Them)

35. Plaintiff repeats, realleges and incorporates herein by reference the
allegations of paragraphs 1 through 8, inclusive, as though fully set forth at length herein.

36. Within the last four years, at Los Angeles County, California, an account
was stated by and between Plaintiff and Epstein, wherein and whereby it was agreed that
2489003P.1 tom COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
Epstein was indebted to Plaintiff in the sum of $103,517.82, which sum Epstein agreed
and promised to pay, and that no part of the same has been paid.

37. No part of said sum has been paid, although demand therefore has been
made, and there remains due, owing and unpaid from Epstein to Plaintiff the sum of
$103,517.82, together with interest thereon at the legal rate from the date the obligations
were due.
SIXTH CAUSE OF ACTION
(Quantum Meruit Against Epstein and Does 1 through 20, and Each of Them)

38. Plaintiff repeats, realleges and incorporates herein by reference the
allegations of paragraphs 1 through 16, inclusive, as though fully set forth at length
herein.

39. Between on or about November 2005 through June 2011, Plaintiff
performed legal services on behalf of Epstein for which Epstein promised to pay Plaintiff
at its fair and reasonable value.

40. Demand for payment for these services has been made by Plaintiff to
Epstein, but Plaintiff has not been paid.

41. The fair and reasonable value of said services equals not less than
$103,517.82 or an amount to be proven at trial.

42. Epstein has failed and refused, and continues to fail and refuse, to pay
Plaintiff for said services, leaving a balance immediately due to Plaintiff according to
proof, but in no event less than $103,517.82, together with interest thereon at the rate of
10% per annum from the date said sum became due.
///
///
2489003P.1 COM COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff prays judgment against Epstein, and Does 1 through 20,
and each of them, as follows:

1. For damages in the sum of $103,517.82, together with interest thereon at
the legal rate from the date the obligations were due;

2. For reasonable attorneys' fees as provided for by the Contract;
3. For costs of suit incurred herein; and,

4. For such other relief as the Court deems just and proper.
Dated: July 2012 NEMECEK & COLE
By:
JONATHAN B. COLE
VINCENT S. GREEN
Attorneys for Plaintiff
SITRICK AND COMPANY,
a division of SITRICK BRINCKO GROUP, LLC
2489003P.1.com COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
Plaintiff SITRICK and COMPANY, a division of SITRICK BRINCKO GROUP, LLC,
demands a trial by jury on all claims.
Dated: July 2012 NEMECEK & COLE
By:
JONATHAN B. COLE
VINCENT S. GREEN
Attorneys for Plaintiff
SITRICK AND COMPANY,
a division of SITRICK BRINCKO GROUP, LLC
2489003P.1.com COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
EFTA00007091 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-10)
One Cleadake Centre, Suite 1400
250Austratian Avenue South West Pain, Beach. FL 33401
e eral Bureau of Investigation
est a m Beach, FL 33401
•
KEST PUN SE0tIl
* CoAe 33401 *
* go? $0.410 $0.410 to.clo
$0.410 IrtanR *
MM 17 07 3845479
OPENED AND INSPECTED
334O1$SSA4 CO3i hdhuflnhdil hhhhhuhJanhAAJJAIJ

╭─────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ One Cleake Centre Site 100                            │
│ 250 Australian Avenwe South West Palm Beach, FL 33401 │
│                                                       │
│ = = m1 ——                                             │
│                                                       │
│ fest Palm Beach, FL 33401                             │
│                                                       │
│ SSA0iSES44 COS Vallall                                │
│                                                       │
│ nest pan seacn 3                                      │
│ FL_33401                                              │
│                                                       │
│ Mir" 40.610 40,410 $0,610                             │
│                                                       │
│ $9.410 ze nena!                                       │
│ Alar 7 07 38379                                       │
│                                                       │
│ bath                                                  │
│                                                       │
│ ces css.                                              │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

• JOSEPH R.ATTERBURY
• t JACK A GOLDBERGER
JASON S.WEISS
• Board Certified Criminal Trial Attorney
t Member et New jersey & 'Florida Ban
May 17, 2007
Esq.
ssistwi.P.ut tates Attorney
Office of the United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
RE: ,JEGE, Inc. ("JEGE') and Hyperion Air, Inc. ("Hyperion')
Dear
Thank you very much for your letter dated May 15, 2007 concerning the subpoenas issued to
JEGE, Inc. and Hyperion Air, Inc., along with your agreement to extend compliance deadlines
until May 29, 2007. I apologize for any confusion concerning representation created by my
letter to you of May 10, 2007 on behalf of the corporations, and the subsequent telephone call
you received from Lilly Ann Sanchez, also on behalf of the corporations.
Please be advised that I am working with Lily Ann Sanchez and Gerald B. Lefcourt in regard to
these subpoenas. Accordingly, please feel free to speak to or communicate with myself, Ms.
Sanchez and/or Mr. Lefcourt concerning matters related to thelfubpoenas.
Very tr ly yours,
Lily
cc: SA , Federal Bureau of Inve ation
nn
Gerald B. Lefeourt, Esq.
GOLDBERGER
West Palm Bach, FL 33401
warwagwpa.com
AUDIOTAPE INVENTORY
\ 5
(PART 11) - , .c.,Ltakit ] kv-c"'"
CONTROLLED CALL
kstax (SIDE A ONLY) -
-SD
\ 6 IMM -00 66t'U"A
\ • 7 MM.. 5o -So
TELEPHONE CALL -
\\ "1 10.
N 11
I12.
\ N 13.
\ 14.
N 115.
N 16.
S3 -Sb
— attycA.di
=M. Phetd-
rd
—04 (Ji
cr o'lmmm. (FOLLOW-UP) p4t)

╭──────── Page 3, Image 1 ────────╮
│ AUDIOTAPE INVENTORY             │
│                                 │
│ HE PRT) — Lube ty Weer          │
│ HE GE Con TROLLED CALL          │
│                                 │
│ GE (SIDE A ONLY) - facut ts Vor │
│ : Pp - iff cul h hor            │
│                                 │
│ \ 5. SR ~ sv -S0                │
│                                 │
│ \o | ~Aeffvent fo troy          │
│                                 │
│ oS TELEPHONE CALL -(            │
│                                 │
│ SS MM Lifer                     │
│                                 │
│ \\ 10. es -S°                   │
│                                 │
│ i ns ime to eo»                 │
│ \o i - Pretty, so?              │
│                                 │
│ Nin. SN ooo!                    │
│ \ 4 i — Lf cult fo              │
│ 16 i GS coutow-vr) - pdygnd     │
╰─────────────────────────────────╯

eloktus,O nc•Aflti  mati.,,_csegs
si./Aseitedkao ficitno
Here is the call breakdown I used for the chart. This is
what is on my spread sheets. I am going to double check
all of the calls, using only 'lilts records
for the final numbers, but this is pretty close for what
you guys are doing. I messed up my math on the big chart
for and but I fixed all of the small
handouts. If you guys could just do a little creative cut
and paste for the big chart, it will be good.
Calls to
30AF from
25 from Epstein Residencel
7 from •
79
Calls from
31 to
7 to Epstein Residence
1 to
Calls to
60 from
20 from Epstein Residence
1 from
Calls from
40 to
7 to Epstein Residence
Calls to
5 from ■
M ill
Calls frcm
3 to
Calls to
83 from
Calls from
139 to (240
21' 29 to Epstein Residence
3 3 to
1 to
t.,, I r-rfril
k-Ditc69:sa
(9@)(iratsy,,
-;),_0Oa1)(9
C-a0
q5a,„.
%
i
.4

╭──── Page 6, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00039978 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-10)
Post
OPS LT
ACT LT
Split Shift 2 00:00 - 08:00
SHU LT
SIS TECH #1
PHONE MONITOR
SEARCH OFFICER
LOBBY
CONTROL #1
CONTROL #2
INTERNAL
INTERNAL #2
ATTY CONF
UNIT 2
UNIT 3
5 NORTH
5 SOUTH
7 NORTH
7 SOUTH
9 NORTH
SHU #1
SHU #2
SHU #3
SHU #4
10 SOUTH #1
10 SOUTH #2
11 NORTH
11 SOUTH
11 SOUTH #2
OSP #1
SANITATION OFF
VISIT #1
VISIT #2
VISIT #3
""Special Assignments ••• '
LOBBY #2
MCC NEW YORK
NEW YORK, NY
Daily Assignment Roster
3 06:00 - 14:00
6 07:00 - 15:00
8 08:00 - 16:00
9 12:00 - 20:00
10 14:00 - 22:00
Saturday July 27, 2019
Page 1
12 16:00 - 00:00
26/2019 11:58:18 PM
Saturday July 27, 2019
Page 2
PHONE RM
STAFF SEARCH
MELENDEZ 1
MELENDEZ 2
""Back Page Categories""
DAY OFF
SICK LEAVE
╔════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Qarmin [finance] high frequency trading operation (???) 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00556664 (Jmail)
 [finance] Qarmin high frequency trading pitch deck
(inferred date: 2026-01-10)
Wit II contact@qarmin.net
June 2012
Confidential

╭─────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────╮
│ QARMIN                        │
│                               │
│ i Business Seoul              │
│                               │
│ June 2012                     │
│ FO EME Ratlfinet Confidential │
╰───────────────────────────────╯

Table of Contents
Introduction
Executive Summary
Competitive Advantages
Investment Process
Strategies Description
Performance
Appendix
4ARMIN
Introduction
Founded in October 2010, QARMIN is a small Paris-based Prop Trading House
that specializes in quantitative systematic fully automatized strategies with a
focus on listed and highly liquid instruments (Europe and US) and medium
frequency strategies.
First stage of development was dedicated to development and live-testing of our
proprietary trading platform including automated strategies, backtesting tools,
risk management engine and execution algorithms.
We have gone live with the founders' private funds and are now looking for a
business partner to operate on a larger scale.
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential
Executive Summary
J Primary objective is to achieve consistent risk-adjusted returns throughout different market
cycles, taking advantage of a flexible dynamic allocation process relying on 3 largely
uncorrelated investment axes: multi -asset directional, market neutral and volatility
arbitrage.
We typically target a minimum Sharpe Ratio of 2, with an annualized Return to Max
Drawdown of 3.
J Custom trading platform: Research and Development, backtesting and deployment run on a
unified platform, hence making possible process streamlining.
We're maintaining an extensive historical database of prices and fundamentals for 6000+
instruments listed on US and European exchanges, going back more than 15 years.
QARMIN is a team of experienced prop traders and developers who have committed a
significant amount of their wealth in the project, and have worked extensively together in the
past. Each team member has a strong academic background in mathematical finance and has
extensive experience in the derivatives market.
A diversified strategy portfolio with high pre-leverage target returns
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential itARMIN
Competitive Advantages
❑ Strong methodology and flexible platform allow industrialization of idea generation and
testing: time to market from R&D to production is low
❑ Capacity to create and manage several uncorrelated bets by creating nonstandard coherent
underlyings (basket, synthetic instruments)
❑ Large existing (and growing) library of uncorrelated single models/strategies displaying low
pairwise correlation (-5% average correlation over 10yr period) within each investment axis
Extensive menu of allotment between each of those models benefiting from our proprietary
allocation model therefore increasing Sharpe Ratio compared to any given single strategy's
Sharpe
Total liberty to switch off strategies with low prospective returns
❑ Active hedging method for tail risks via quantitative process involving long only cheap OTM
long-term options; focus on macro picture, top down approach and exogenous stimuli
analysis therefore departing from the historical bias and enhancing the capital preservation
capacity of the portfolio
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential
Investment Process
77Strategy
i Development I Alpha Discovery
Historical Validation
Expected Returns
Portfolio
Allocation
Bottom -Up
Top•Down
Strategy Development (cf. Appendix p15)

• Underlying idea stemming from market experience
(risk premium location)
• Historical validation (backtesting, choice of relevant
parameters, observed returns)

• Data-mining bias correction (reality check, expected
returns, coherence with market fundamentals — is the
edge still in place?)
Portfolio Allocation (cf. Appendix p16)

• Bottom-up approach using customized allocation
algorithms at each allocation step
• Top-Down approach adjusting marginal weights of single
models and investment axes via our own proprietary risk
index
Risk Management (cf. Appendix p18)

• Single model dedicated risk management (stop-loss,
volatility/VaR adjusted size by instrument)
• Specific risk manager for each investment style (directional,
market neutral, volatility arbitrage)

• Global aggregation for ultimate capital preservation
constraint
Execution Management (cf. Appendix p21)

• Specific algorithms for each investment style
• Transaction costs analysis (brokerage, slippage,
rebates) for best execution algorithm selection and
trades/performance reconciliation
Identification of alpha at each step of the process
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential ARMIN
Strategies Description
Overview
• 3 Investment axes whose relative weights are controlled via a proprietary portfolio
allocation model; directional, market neutral and volatility arbitrage are effectively
uncorrelated through different market cycles
Investment Axis Description
Technical and fundamental short/medium
term pattern
finance, market macro/micro structure and
directional events
Asset Class
Equities, Equity Index, Fixed Income, Commodity,
Currency Futures and ETFs. Options on these asset coherent with behavioural From 2 hours to classes.
Geographic positioning: Europe, US and Emerging
Markets (via ETF)
Horizon
several weeks Directional
Market Neutral
Adaptive statistical analysis to capitalize on
local divergence and mean reversion nature
of risk neutral baskets
Equities, Equity Index, Fixed Income Futures
Geographic positioning: Europe, US
From 10 minutes
to 2 weeks
Volatility
Arbitrage
Arbitrage of the volatility curve mispricing
(local vol, skew, kurtosis, term structure) of
an underlying compared to its peers, both
using fundamental and statistical approach
Equities: main indices and their stock components, VIX,
V2X, Main Currencies, Commodities, ETF Volatilities
VXX, VXZ, Listed vanilla options
Geographic positioning: Europe, US and Emerging
Markets (via ETF)
From 1 week to
1 month
ARMIN
Strategies Description
Directional
Directional
Strategy Sample*
Mean Reversion
Strategy Description
Take advantage of short term negative
autocorrelation using specific volatility analysis
Underlyings
Large Cap Equities
Equity Futures
Horizon
1 to 5 days
Trend Following
Exploit long term trend following nature of capital
markets; overlay via tactical options writing
Equity Index Futures
Commodity Futures
FX Futures
Fixed Income Futures
Emerging Market ETFs
5 days to
several weeks
Macro Events
Capitalize on over/under-reaction of various indices
around macroeconomic announcements
Equity Index Futures
Fixed Income Futures
2 to 10 hours
Gap
Exploit statistical patterns of gaps at open Equity Index Futures 2 to 10 hours
Seasonality
Benefit from intraday and extraday seasonality due
to structural imbalances
Equities
Equity Index Futures
2 hours to 5
days
non-exhaustive list of currently available live strategies
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential '')QARMIN
Strategies Description
Market Neutral
Market Neutral
Strategy Sample*
Equity vs. Volatility
Arbitrage
Strategy Description
Exploit local relative mispricing of equities and
volatility as an asset class
Underlyings
Volatility Index Futures
Equity Index Futures
Horizon
10 minutes to
1 day
Equity Statistical Arbitrage
Take advantage of temporary divergence within a
bespoke basket constructed via various statistical
methods
Equities 1 day to 2
weeks
Cross Asset Futures
Arbitrage
Take advantage of temporary divergence within a
bespoke basket of instruments from different asset
classes constructed via adequate statistical methods
Equity Index Futures
Commodity Futures
FX Futures
Fixed Income Futures
2 hours to 3
days
' non-exhaustive list of currently available live strategies
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential ARMIN
Strategies Description
Volatility Arbitrage
Volatility Arbitrage
Strategy Sample*
Single Stocks Relative
Value
Short term options
expiration effect
Event Driven
Strategy Description
Benefit from implied volatility curve mispricing of an
underlying compared to its peers (L/S volatility,
Dispersion)
Take advantage of large time decay effect for short
term options around expiration; identify behaviours of
underlyings on expiration date deriving from large
options positions hedging
Exploit volatility curve dislocation around idiosyncratic
events
Underlyings
Equity Options
Equity Index Options
Equity Options
Equity Options
Horizon
1 week to 1
month
1 day to 1
week
1 week to 1
month
• non-exhaustive list of currently available live strategies
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential 4ARMIN
Performance
1/2
Consistent risk-adjusted returns over a 10yr backtest period with no sign of abating in the recent past
Sharpe 3.92
Yearly Return to Max DD 5.34
Avg Yearly Return 22.8%
Profitable Days % 59%
Avg Daily Return 0.08%
StDev Daily Return 0.37%
Best Daily Return 2.91%
Worst Daily Return -2.24%
Worst DD -4.27%
Max DD Duration 136 days
Avg Worst 10 DD Duration 62.9 days
Directional/Market Neutral Historical Drawdown
Directional/Market Neutral Equity Curve
e e
CtARMIN
Performance
2/2
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
Badctested Yearly Returns (Post-Transaction Costs, Unleyeraged) •
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
Yearly Returns — — — Average Backtested Returns 23.5% — — — Target Return 15%
Y2012 performance has been frozen as of May 31,1 and extrapolated for the remainder
of the calendar year
The backtest is presented with an equal-weighted allocation method; live allocation will
tweak the relative weights of each strategies and each investment style, hence
improving the risk profile of the portfolio; weight of any given axis will never represent
more than 50% at any given time with the exception of Volatility Arbitrage which will be
limited to 25% relative weight
Volatility Arbitrage investment axis is not represented on this chart as backtesting
remains difficult to achieve; however the expected performance is in line with the
above-presented result and should add an extra layer of diversification, therefore
improving the overall profile of the portfolio
1 Margin of safety built into
target performance has
the last 10; it is a large 7.8%
target return expectations
average over the entire period
moving forward; 15% yearly
been reached 9 years out of
(or 0.85 std dev) below
15% target return is coherent
with 4.27% max backtested
drawdown, hence allowing us
to construct a portfolio with
an expected Return to max
drawdown higher than 3
Strategy can be leveraged up
to 5 times (margin to equity <
100%) to achieve an iso
return-to-max-drawdown
couple with no significant
foreseeable loss of
performance (besides
marginal funding costs)
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential
Appendix
14 Team Bio
Strategy Development 15
16 Portfolio Allocation
17 Risk Management
20 Execution Management
21 Technical Platform
28 Performance Details
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential 4ARMIN
Team Bio
Li Bertrand LOUVARD, Founding Partner
Bertrand joined Societe Generale in 2000 as a trader on the US Indices Derivatives Trading Book in NY. In 2003, he 
became
Head of the US Indices Flow Business Trading Book before being appointed Head of the US Equity Flow Business Trading 
Book
in 2005. He expanded the Hedge Fund Client Business in the US for vanilla derivatives products. He then joined the Lyxor
Structured Product Solutions team in 2009 to develop the structured products active management offer within the 
Quantitative
Asset Management team of Lyxor.
Bertrand Louvard is a graduate of the tcole Centrale Paris and has a Master's degree in Mathematics, Probability and 
Statistics
from the University of Jussieu (Paris VI).
Li Francois-Charles SCAPULA, Founding Partner
Francois-Charles was a fellow associate at the CEREG between 2001 and 2004 and a professor of Econometrics and 
Quantitative Techniques at
University Paris IX Dauphine. He has spent the last 7 years as a prop trader for Fortis and Societe Generale focusing on
quant equity derivatives
strategies, where he traded listed and OTC stock and index options, variance swaps, futures from all asset classes. He 
was also responsible for
setting up the trading platform at Lyxor for the quant asset management department.
Francois-Charles is a graduate of the Ecole Normale Superieure and ESSEC. He has an « Agregation » in Economics, a 
Master's degree in Applied
Mathematics and a Master's degree in Finance from Paris IX Dauphine. He was a PhD candidate in Mathematical Finance at 
the University of
Paris IX Dauphine.
Sylvain Rey, Founding Partner
As a graduate of Telecom SudParis with a specialty in parallel and distributed system, Sylvain has been a Software 
Consultant in the San Francisco
Bay Area from 2000, then in Paris, France from 2003. As a seasoned Application and Systems Architect, he has designed 
and developed many
solutions for various banking and financial institutions such as BNP Paribas, AXA Investment Managers, Banque de France 
and the European
System of Central Banks.
Each Partner has committed a substantial amount of his personal wealth to the venture.
Sylvain and Bertrand have known each other for more than 15 years. Bertrand and Francois Charles were working together 
at Societe Generale.
Sylvain, Bertrand and Francois Charles have founded QARMIN in October 2010 and have worked extensively since then to 
build
a cutting edge systematic platform.
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential
Strategy
Development
Top-down process
IDEA GENERATION
Risk Premium Intuited
Asset Class/Universe/Instruments defined
Systematic Rule Formulated

1. Entry / Exit
2. Specific Risk Management (Size, Stop Loss, Overlay)
Database
1. Prices
2. Volumes
3. Fundamentals

4. Derivatives
5. Proprietary Data
uputrun parameters set dnu
weights
Data
Mining
Correction
Yes
Config
8acktesting Data-Mining
Engine Engine
Observed
performance set
satisfactory?
Yes
Are observed results
coherent with
market experience?
Selection Criterion
1 Average Return
2 Sharpe
3 Ret on drawdown

4. Ret. on VaR
sys emauc rule ITOM
observed data sets.
Yes
SINGLE STRATEGY READY
Bottom -up process
Integrate Strategy In Library
° IQ ARMIN
STEPWISE
PROCESS
INITIAL STEP 0
STEP 1
INTERMEDIATE
RESULT 1
STEP 2
BOTTOM UP CONTROL
Single Strategy Generation Process
CI Strategy Development
STATISTICAL EQUITY CURVES ANALYSIS
Including:

1. Mean Variance Optimization over
various horizons
2. Maximum diversification under
performance constraint

3. Maximization of various performance
measures in walk forward process
STATISTICAL EQUITY CURVES ANALYSIS
Kelly Criterion, Markowitz Portfolio
Allocation
INTERMEDIATE
RESULT 2
DIRECTIONAL LIBRARY
Direct. I Direct.
i
Alloc.
Directional
n
Direct.
virec:Lionai
aggregation
PORTFOLIO ALLOCATION
MARKET NEUTRAL LIBRARY
Neut.
Alloc.
Market Neutral
Allocation
aggregation
VOL ARB UBRARY
Alloc.
volatility mroitrage
aggregation
TOP DOWN CONTROL
Single Strategy Generation Process

q. Strategy Development
EXOGENEOUS CRITERIA ANALYSIS
Including:
1. Strength of Risk Premia underlying
each of the single strategies (e.g. IV
%Ile vs. RV, frequency of channel
borders crossing, high volume in bear
market, etc.)

2. Liquidity of traded instruments
EXOGENEOUS CRITERIA ANALYSIS
Including:
1. Macro/Flow Environment (e.g.
Economic Indicators)
2. Volatility/Credit Conditions (VIX,
iTraxx)
3. Fear/Greed Index, Deal Index
(Proprietary index)
4. Crowding out trades (recent HF
performance vs. LT mean)
Decision to tilt allocation towards better
historically performing strategies in
identified conditions
Risk Management
1/2 Ex-ante and ex-post approaches
Ex-ante approach
❑ Portfolio allocation taking decisions based on past performance analysis under risk constraints

• Variance minimization of the portfolio for a given performance target via Var-Covar matrix for strategies equity
curves and underlyings historical return

• Minimum ex-ante diversification required for inclusion of a given strategy in the meta-portfolio
❑ Sentiment Index adjusting notional at risk based on fundamental and technical data keeping the
margin to equity relatively constant (and targeting stable risk return profile)
❑ Hedging macro picture with "long-only" cheap long term OTM options via fundamental and
quantitative screening of underlyings with available derivative markets (see focus)
Ex-post approach
❑ Single position aggregation and real-time dedicated risk metrics for each business line...

• Multi Directional: Tenor notional exposure (via Var-Covar Matrix for underlying return)
• Market Neutral: Notional Replication, Spread Risks

• Volatility Arbitrage: Volatility, Kurtosis/Skew Exposure (Tail Risks)
❑ ...and at the global level for ultimate risk control and capital preservation

• Greeks, beta-adjusted notional exposure, dispersion risks
❑ Stress-testing of all positions via adverse relevant / historical
scenarios, VaR, etc.
QARMIN Ju 2012 - nfidential
Risk Management
2/2 Macro Picture - Options
❑ « Buy only» long dated out-of-the-money options
❑ For a wide variety of asset classes and instruments, identify cheap options in terms of current implied
volatility vs. universe (universe-relative cheapness at a given time) and long term average (self-relative
cheapness over time)
❑ Analyze technicals, fundamentals and sentiments, leveraging our platform and proprietary database via a
quantitative process that allows us to screen hundreds of assets
Come up with a list of instruments in a position to capitalize on high potential global macro situations
❑ « Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful » (W. Buffet)

• Market psychology is the motor of the performance: we try and benefit from fear, greed, hysteria and mania

• Options are often mispriced during periods of irrationality hence providing great risk/reward opportunities
❑ Actively manage options

• Long term only options in order to reduce adverse time decay impact: we do not keep options with time to maturity 
lower
than 1 year

• Profit-taking/Stop-loss methodology: we seek to return 5/10 times the original investment on any given bet; as soon as
intermediary targets are reached, we deleverage part of the bet
❑ Risk management/performance enhancement process

• Our general investment philosophy is to look for statistical anomalies and capitalize on it by designing systematic 
strategies;
although an adaptive process, it is bound to be historically biased
• These strategies are often - not always- based on cashing in risk premia (implicit or explicit)
• Buying cheap OTM options allows us to hedge both biases (historical and short risk/premium)
via a deductive approach that covers any unpredictable events that June fall out
of historical scope
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential
STEPWISE
PROCESS
INTERMEDIATE
RESULT 2
STEP 3
INTERMEDIATE
RESULT 3
STEP 4
INTERMEDIATE
RESULT 4
BOTTOM UP CONTROL RISK MANAGEMENT
NO CONTROL
Risk ex-ante has been measured and
calibrated at STEP 2
NO CONTROL
Risk ex-ante has been measured and
allocated at STEP 2
Directional
Risk Engine
Market Neutral
aggregation
Market Neutral
Risk Engine
Volatility Arbitrage
aggregation
Volatility Arbitrage
Risk Engine
Global Aggregation
Global Risk Engine
Throat Dacitinne
TOP DOWN CONTROL
RISK CONTROL BASED ON CALCULATED
MEASURES
Including:

1. VaR, Capital at risk under adverse
scenarios
2. Greeks
3. Notional replication, spread risks
4. Tenor Notional on uncorrelated
instruments
Each axis is managed separately as they
are incurring different types of risk
RISK CONTROL BASED ON CALCULATED
MEASURES
Risks are aggregated at the top level to
ensure global capital preservation
STEPWISE
PROCESS
INTERMEDIATE
RESULT 4
STEP 5
FINAL ORDERS
BOTTOM UP CONTROL
SLIPPAGE & TCA FOR ALL EXECUTIONS
METHODS

1. Simulated
2. Real
We allocate more to the best recent
execution method while keeping
minimum diversification.
Those measures give us a hint as to what
the street is doing in regards to our
trading signals.
EXECUTION MANAGEMENT
Target Positions
Directional
library
Execution Algorithm Library
Market Neutral
library
Volatility Arbitrage
library
Combination of algorithmic orders for single instruments
Pair trading and basket algorithms
Aggressive vs. passive algorithm for directional trades
TOP DOWN CONTROL
LIQUIDITY, LEVEL 2, BOOK ANALYSIS
Analysis of book order, market
microstructure, number of trades at the
bid/offer over last relevant bar
Technical Platform
Architecture and flows overview
Monitoring and Reporting
tools
Q
Reporting Database
L-I IIIICLIdSt
Pricing, Corporate Actions and
Fundamental Data Aggregator
I QARMIN
Custom indicators
I Bloomberg
Pricing
Fundamental data
Corporate Actions
fi
Real-time Data Aggregator
Activ Financials
Real-time data
I
Custom API / FIX
Prime Broker
FIX
UHF Trader Engine
Strategy Packages
QARMIN Trading
Framework
Additional Providers
Real-time data
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential ARMIN
Technical Platform
Features 1/2
❑ Custom integrated Platform

• Fully mastered internally
• Modern software methodologies
• Every team member is a developer
• Code base is managed, factorized and peer reviewed

• Fast development cycles using agile methodologies
❑ Based on QuantServer / QuantOffice from Deltix La•
•
•
Well renown software, powering various Institutionals, Funds and Proprietary Trading Houses
Complex Event Processing architecture
Heavily parallelized, high performance system
C

a) a

• Modern foundation with highly optimized, managed processes
• Tight technical partnership with Deltix
❑ Modern tools for business development

• Instrument / Universe / Calendar Managers
• Strategy Manager
• Integrated Development Environment based on Microsoft Visual Studio

• Visual Alpha tool for fast prototyping
• Strategy Runner for backtesting
• Database administration tools
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential
Technical Platform
Features 2/2
❑ QARMIN interoperability layer

• Flexible architecture allowing us to plug-in within various environments
• Real-time data connectors

• Pricing, corporate actions and fundamental data connectors
• Proprietary engine for index and scoring indicators generation
❑ QARMIN Trading Framework

• Extensive financial and mathematical library La
•
• Integrated with well established Econometry, Statistical, Financial and Solver libraries.

• QARMIN own library with custom indicators
Signal Instrument facility, providing directly usable meta instruments for signal processing (chain
management, corporate action adjustment, pairs, baskets)
C

a) a a

• State-of-the-art Meta Models facility for static and dynamic discovery/aggregation/allocation of strategies

• Real-time Risk Engines, enabling proactive decisions
• Order Processors, with custom execution algorithms and operational costs management
❑ Monitoring / Reporting tools

• Integrated within Hyperic HQ monitoring suite / alert center
• Real-time Trading Console
• Reporting engine with realtime charts

• Audit trails / logs
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential
Technical Platform
Database Features • a• . o • if •• !tan • OOOOO MOO 0.111S1
.1 .
an.
s.e..••••• ,.•fie
~~~~¢~~4~44#~~i~#~~~4~~49~~
0n. kora

Wm. ••••11•1 no •••••1110.1 %PA. CS Oa S
SU. 41.0 MOM In •••••••••• ann. ••
am .....• 40 C... MN) SI•C MMUS Q.
SC ba a MW ••••••abn, atnall.PD arl. lienem
AMA ateil•t tab 0.01•01.10) 1••••••af ntall kti. Ill yea
••••• WO 0.01.1a MI •14.1.•••• 001.21.... M... 'VOW
M...... In .11111an la.01.4a USSR ha Ma. ALS.I.
S W Swat UM a a Ya a MS al449.14•1•••••• Jana .."1

W. ta 0.014aa SM. allaa! Ss
SS all0440 n no ilia Man C..3210. at Inn
Mk. In $.61•411•01 MINIM kha na. la
MOM ln •••••••000 Maw. Gann WIC ........
ION In *Anal MI O. alga 4/ 4 , i..
41401 IM30.1•11•11 in ......1.1. ann. ain... Inn
a aNNISS kA• sea.) ram wan a
a aria I. COI Ian Winn. anon MY
Su In WHIM ail.. Ml
a manninn la &Una ale. nal.. Mil
Min ASSY la 44140• 4 00 Waal A/ 0. /4,14
ath Y.MIIaO. In sena nano Cana ea .IMF
leete• atOIL I/ .... 4.41/4 SI art 00 tea, SSO. a:ON MS
AS N MAYO •V.a. tar allS21 GSA as Ian" in ninblia) Ian. W non atO ant >On
.0 . n.f. MO 0.0144•1•Jt. in Pa. Plan Pa POI-.
Oa. KS 10 la SOS  a 4 PS•
WO/ Nal MIS Snap /044Sen Sa4 •,..nr•
401,11 N 4.41.•••0 aNM 40•0•4101 0:11.40 na al

• 61.0 3.0• Mina piaa 00.6.08.11
lin.04
Ian In natl. Manny niela
n,
IBM,
ASA Oa. NallaS SOWS Saa at•
ISSOIDISOS %I< . AWN (.C:6 , 0 Lo-X, x
III•e•011in
Timohaeo nriminietratnr
❑ High performance, hybrid database system

• Very fast, polymorphic, NOSQL database system optimized for Time Series data (TimeBase)
• Object relational database system optimized for reporting data (MS SQL Server)
U Time Series scope

• Daily, Intraday, Tick, Level 2 and Order Book Data
• Fundamental data streams
• 6000+ instruments (Index, Currencies, Equities, Futures, Options) over 35 markets

• Span from 17+ years (intraday) and 12+ years (tick)
• TeraBytes of data
QARMIN hi 2012 - Confidential 4ARMIN
Technical
Platform
Development tools
anI eJe.t 7)esak.
. .e. .... .c...wi.taatrao woos Ma. e. oz.....
-MM1.LJ 0 eJ •••••••• — sno.njOJIA/dnA.I.
.ffialuf e-
tat 1St •••••
a . a I •••••• =suer
SMOOMSIM

• •
• • seems. tem. •••••••••• caiti S./4M. ••••••••••••
,
wr—a •
Visual Alpha
O
•
Yams
. ••••••••••••aalalla
:a a a Iltatal••••
ana•••
sineanim,
..0•••▪ ▪• •••••••••
Sas
aal••••••••••••••••am • mama ialastatadat
a a artaitan .
awe o. crime
seetemeeeehe eeme eseseeeeneCL
sensameeee
+mama lamatmesmatammas .
•••••
mar •••••••••••:~
Cana I i • maim
••••
Strategy Designer
•••••••••••IiMmtamtum, • :pa.
Imi•••••••••••••••••••••la 1••••);
Iota
i • am • a.... 0 •I• •••• •mm a a ••• `area • Ina. Ma ttlegt
tmelealea • 0
••••••••••••taallatita.I. r %atonal...a alai. •
<O••••••••••••••••• ••••Ietf • mI • •••••••••••••••••gaata•l• M.) 0.
, ate.. •IlarnlatItal). 0):
••••••
memmaa
••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
•••(•••••••••••••••

• ...a...m..0
-.ea lama,
•••••••••• ..•••• 4••••••1 la • ber••••••• •••••••
a•Mtamitilat
wain lies. 4. sassesea~seMe/ easelonor
lemon
Steal:
....amnia tat Man imattaatt eilleesAL•ver.054le etestfetertow eifIlItere eall -NWZFP. bug. [Fet weefee

• ••••••••••••••••••••• • 01.. .. - •••• •••••••• • ••• ••••-• ••• •••• •••• • •• ••• • •••• • • •••••••••••fit . 1
*a net. Wag ....••••••••••••••••••••••••• at•••• I- a deo .v
....mpsalat sea. eeeeleeneseeeteeneetnewace.......00.eaemeesee.yesieeneella••••••••••....e. ••-elee tam. Oa 
•••••••••••••••••••••• • • ••••

• :-• :Mal • • • mai. I ...v.. •••••••••••••••••••••• • I Na••••••••••••• tn.* •••/ ..... *rem 
“•••••esemeseeeesior,iftwearse.sefreeeereaue
••••••••••••••••••••_•••• al
.00 am• •••••• •••••••••••••••••••••••• C•••••••• m. arm
aemmatast.Mt.•00• • • alimmal.••••• ital. •••••••••Cm•••••••••••••••••••••t.0...Wommataatmrent.••••• ell
ad sat ta•mg. am,taveamta. oratm m.•,,, E•m•

• • . :i..na• • •••••••1•••••••• ••••••••• MI
MOM l•••••••• 0•••••••••• ewv
Visual Studio integration
C

a) a
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential ARMIN
Onanntee
l'inasiOank
eniFirenetes
undietring
adacatneeiod
°Vale
metalodelnines•
t5tude-eSelectioa
garilenopati 4.4
annatennen.... Trin
Technical Platform
Backtesting tools
J Streteedy 'CTA_Ixtrialoy stiadociehjatruntentSplit_O ge_PROW.Con•guiabon  Sue
It winclo.
Repeat
& X

T. 5 • X Trades: gbiD
boon • Convolsibia • P•••••t•
J CTSfatead,T}4MONli_V6ert Rena -4.0a
TOtes Prat
Tot. tap
Cat% None
Broke. Feet
Opeens Pre
once Adeisarat
Can4ate0 hat %
Cl.O  Allegation

• •I• Banztraen
pg 41. Br0a.o0
II • l• Dra.dcra
• •1. Cinutions
• a. Oskts
43 •:. nerlermanc•
•1. bodes R. °taboo ,

p) (vet Log vn Peraclonn %
r__,Chaets insa Ornaloia Date
▪ •1. 4% (b5 Iniengetamor RetaniOnadern Rabe

• 1. 4% MOO • II0101/24( Dreacra Oars %
41. Risk by Tenor Salta! Ornaloa Petition
•:. Trading (lORJ2004
biaoltdated Rao% CARR
le er0wtroment &sae Rao
CateOrante areall:ed VOiMllh
Seta). 0abo
upl
Worn:aeon Rao
Pane:
an Triode. •
Rya/table Trades Rno
viinnng leans a
Laing ban •
a erne Trade :(10131/703}31/03/2014
Anna winking
goat  R- Ararat tang Tree.
wee Avg. Lois ROO
itechieKevi; On 1 5,5.59* Mai pa
:00
0.75
Kix COnie0. VIInnerS
MaKCOn0N.L005M
(-3 40, I3 Ali Wan tong Trades Snort Trades
3 624 44934 3 702 523.10 161 393.96
:5 007 35440 11 542 673.46 4 264445.44

• II 943 •41.• 4 8.30 330.14 -4 103 Oa.%
.234 94741
330 40732
-n 3.42.63
101 42229
2790.59 % 2.30.31 % 424.45%
.170 328.74 .231 048.14 :422 327.71
4.57%
29/W2012 36/05/23/0 10107/2411
21.24 1402 0.14
7349% 76.27% 94.34%
41 65 310
302.0% 31047% .14.04%
5.47 4.47 040
5529 63.63 4455.61
1149 1243 -On
476 $.0.3 -OAS
1.49 249 -047
9.90 7.66 040
41677 21402 15673
0.50 451 0.47
20650 13291 7359
21427 12111 4316
46.98 :42.39 1030
76549 86147 570.49
46401 45642 493A0
1.35 1.41 1.17
0.17 027 042
29 32 SS
29 53
Performance overview
_. wain ant....... awe.: ......aaaeca:aar  n00 ans.... ...a a Inane 0440.a.  _I
1'.: 4:::: Si :4 ..
Qrs....a
.. ,i Ct. - ...... •.... . na sunicaknin itai 44 s.... 0
ra•  ......
-.4...................
n a ea...
•Ial~ pokes
nismanawa—in. fay S.--
papa, Tlicgdersa••••••10.10p0M10‘0040••••••J•00.
a••••
r NI •

• • 0.••••
a
•.sste.wd re m„
• 4
nuw :
Ha I
.94: •PAI4P•• ••
••••••••• IMO 00s a In
•••••• SO gala t• at) Oel iore el a
a PitailI Pa tkagm , r• • PPS
IL senrar pin •••••
ti i 0 ••••••• -is
0 NI ISM 00 to MOW. WI
Ill WACON ••
alai ;MS Sin
PP WAWA= Mt
IIevalaio
••••••%•• St
Pa
OP WO It WORM al OS IS
A •—•.*.nor.—.--ml •••••
p•-•••••••••,.....•

• 45 banal
014:4:15.
s t 'erf
a.. a: U04 Oa. • re tel v
fo.aosa., .
saw
me
114,4
la %flea
OP-1,a Pada
y,/••••••••
Yto•
yk.• yy,
•••• &am
Pea Pave.
••••••••••
li•Pee C•••••••
OYU Dada..
a•••••••••
11•••• ••••••••
••••lin.1/10.
•YY•lii. Fab.
tyylOORRYNA.
day
ARMIN
Technical Platform
Monitoring tools
•••••••••••
IIIII•a••••••••••••0
Ina
••
•••••••••
II•m•m.••••••••••
•••
wisp. 0.••
0000.42••••••••••
•••••••••••••
.....••••••••
•IIIIIS••••••••••
. „
Alert Center
•- .• • • •••••••• •••
I•••• ..... ••••:••• III Ole ••••• ••••• Imm• •••••••• na. ••• nom. ••••••• ITN
,.  .....'...-.........., ,...... .....--,--..........-, — .......—......—. — —....- -.. -,... —.--...... .
Audit trail
Trading Console

• •••••• •••
I" I-
, •
..1-n . I  •
A .r•
w.rklm-a.+YJ•• , •
..•
/IA.,. W... COWI. •• ••••• ••••IO ••••••••I Ilepflegiell• r ft,rnat_.........)-o.5
atoren,x rt P., CSC „,.......„.„,.), .,..I ROOOSakrotelp • eadoe....”.1,K00..
Iwo. KO Obaker4001 • a . egole1.48 it .V1,10,...0
,, . Nutec.c"I III .1; ZIX amid ..‘,...............> ...n IS OloceatiNIO .....****J*3> A
. :I.a.:Ili:O .  (NIlla..toy In? i i pkeake .d•le '‘.........vaPainilluell .....
llefenoioiroC.. PM
i . ._.. ._ , . . :s,.. _.4.sw 0.4 ,000
7.7 ... ,.........Kale(6 ik.n.) lipi.gcase.1110 “traJmndmv.KAJ0004.5
.4n.....1 101,~41/00/• I., nahl.for..tonpfttlioll WM:.

• air *vow. • I•1•0!•••••
I...liars:See Mel .- 6f.• -•••.••
0.49.. in Mal*
fr ; IMO %Wet.
I r•ZiaIX
ES( • OAKUM •
-Jr Juus.cters.va_003016
Pe auto,
IW° M e r

et. etke.
• eI
,..:.tert apse Yw
• I
cowl.  I j (awe • Stag*., It) • e in.. • •
•Ot
tIIIt  =I' Id
(AY
INipl•••••• III•••••••
11....at  s —N Teul Path., In *Meld wrtudnIMS //MA mune:4V iX
Realtime charts
Is
ARMIN

╭─────── Page 27, Image 1 ────────╮
│ Technical Platform              │
│ Monitoring tools                │
│                                 │
│ Trading Console                 │
│                                 │
│ Appendix                        │
│                                 │
│ QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential │
╰─────────────────────────────────╯

Backtested Performance
Directional Focus 1/2
Sharpe 3.22
Yearly Return to Max DD 3.18
Avg Yearly Return 28.90%
Profitable Days % 57%
Avg Daily Return 0.10%
StDev Daily Return 0.57%
Best Daily Return 5.85%
Worst Daily Return -4.62%
Worst DD -9.08%
Max DD Duration 136 days
Avg Worst 10 DD Duration 75.6 days
Performance measurement reflects how the directional
pocket of the model portfolio would have performed.
Projected performance is likely to be slightly degraded as
part of the data-mining bias is bound to remain in the
backtested performance.
Expected out-sample performance is expected to come in
20-25% lower than the presented observed performance
(while keeping volatility constant).
14(0)
NOM
Directional Historical Drawdown
Ot  4e 4/ 4e 0t 4P 0# 4r 0° de 4/ -se / 4I 4/ 4*.s. ./ i s 409
Directional Equity Curve
1.0)1130
WOW
3011CCO
#1 0°' it' it 4, 40, 4' 4' / -P 4i, 4, 1 4' 40c• -P  00G
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential
X
-o C
a)
a
414ARMIN
Backtested Performance
Directional Focus 2/2
Directional Strategy Benchmark
Yearly Performance*
HFR
Macro/CTA
Index
S&P 500
2003 24.67% 14.61% 26.38%
2004 17.22% -0.32% 8.99%
2005 33.99% 6.67% 3.00%
2006 44.24% 5.61% 13.62%
2007 27.07% 3.19% 3.53%
2008 27.60% 5.61% -38.49%
2009 35.64% -8.78% 23.45%
2010 37.84% -1.73% 12.78%
2011 15.95% -4.88% 0.00%
2012 24.30% -1.25%* 3.94%*
Average
Std. Dev.
28.85% 1.87% 5.72%
9.04% 6.68% 17.85%
Key Points
U Average Net Return of 28.85% per year in the past 10
years (assuming margins to equity 15-20%)
U 100% of years with positive return
U Daily returns correlation of 19.0% with S&P 500 since
backtesting inception
U Strategies pairwise correlation of 7.30% since
backtesting inception
LI Outperformed HFR Macro/CTA Index by an average of
19.5% per year when reduced to similar volatility
* Y2012 performance has been frozen as of May 31" and
extrapolated for the remainder of the calendar year
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential ARMIN
Backtested Performance
Market Neutral Focus 1/2
Sharpe 3.82
Yearly Return to Max DD 6.41
Avg Yearly Return 30.20%
Profitable Days % 59%
Avg Daily Return 0.10%
StDev Daily Return 0.50%
Best Daily Return 3.76%
Worst Daily Return -2.62%
Worst DD -4.63%
Max DD Duration 125 days
Avg Worst 10 DD Duration 47.3 days
Performance measurement reflects how the market
neutral pocket of the model portfolio would have
performed.
Projected performance is likely to be slightly degraded as
part of the data-mining bias is bound to remain in the
backtested performance.
Expected out-sample performance is expected to come in
20-25% lower than the presented observed performance
(while keeping volatility constant).
Market Neutral Historical Drawdown
Market Neutral Equity Curve
PA0 04/ 10 1011-10 MW ll Lp.l 111.0.1.1
QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential ARMIN
Backtested Performance
Market Neutral Focus 2/2
Market Neutral
Strategy
Benchmark
Quarterly Performance*
HFR Equity
Market
Neutral Index
S&P 500
Q2 - 2009 3.10% -1.01% 15.25%
Q3 - 2009 2.88% -2.93% 14.98%
Q4 - 2009 8.51% 0.79% 5.49%
Q1— 2010 17.06% 1.01% 4.87%
Q2 - 2010 -0.94% 0.91% -11.86%
Q3 - 2010 3.96% -1.96% 10.72%
O4 - 2010 5.21% 2.70% 10.20%
Q1- 2011 0.88% 2.81% 5.42%
Q2 - 2011 14.53% -0.09% -0.39%
Q3 - 2011 13.87% -6.05% -14.33%
Q4 - 2011 8.81% 0.60% 11.15%
C11 - 2012 12.45% -1.63% 12.00%
Q2 — 2012 7.64% -2.81%* -9.93%*
Average
Std. Dev.
7.54%
5.64%
-0.59%
2.49%
4.12%
10.21%
Key Points
U Average Net Return of 7.54% per quarter
(i.e. 30.15% per year) in the past 3 years (assuming
margin to equity 15-20%)
U 12 out of 13 quarters with positive return
U Daily returns correlation of 2.2% with S&P 500 since
backtesting inception
U Strategies pairwise correlation of -2% since
backtesting inception
U Outperformed HFR Equity Market Neutral Index by an
average of 3.90% per quarter (i.e. 15.60% per year)
when reduced to similar volatility
" O2-2012 performance has been frozen as of May 31" and
extrapolated for the remainder of the period
ARMIN
Expected Performance
Volatility Arbitrage - Relative Value Focus
Relative Value - Long/Short Equity Volatility
U 6 months or less ATM options
U Expected Performance: 2 volatility points on a standardized reference
volatility at 25 locked in via delta hedging and adequate rebalancing
when implied volatilities have converged
U Keeping margin to equity — 15-20%, expected performance translates
into 20% ann. performance with 15% realized volatility
ICS INDUSUIT
HANE
LLY US Equity Health Care
PERLIS Equity Financials
ACE VS faulty Financials
EXPECTED
REAL VOL ALL
MODELS
20.04%
26.55%
25,21
NORMAUZED
VOL PTS
DIFFERENTIAL
6.5
0.6
POTENTIAL
REAUZEDVS
UNIVERSE%
84%
60%
COMPOSITE
SCORE
BLK US Equ, lnancwis 38,26% 2,6 9112,
ORCl US Eray TNhnol 05 81%
CO US EgWry Tcc 1,72 25 2
COY OS EAL ty licAlchCArc 28.6% 2I 95>i
04 US Equity Industrials 3077% L2 47% 201E
AGN US Equity Health Caro 17.52% 53 1% 218E
DES US Sq.. r, rtnarCials 32.63%. I3 43% 23%
CELL r Ec uLty 're Oin010.,-, 33.2]>: 23 28% 22%
WAPSAUS Equity onsumer Servla 39.610E L6 39%
M US Equity onsumer Sonia 36.01% L2 46%
BA US Equity Industrials 26.57E 2.3 26% 284
ALT US Equity Health Care 3018% 2.5 24%
HST US &awry :consumer Good: 16.53% 34 12% 1 3:
I.I.N. US El. n Gozd. 23 <0 24%
SEE US Equity :consumer Good: 20.49% 2.0 33%
CBS US (quay alumnae Service 36.75% 0.6 61%
WUS US Equity D16 Gat 29.79% 2.0 31% 23%
MSI US Equity Technology 27.85% 0.2 69% 2234
KO US Equity :assigner Gooch 13.67% 4.1 606 1604
US Equity :on um* Goo& 0 81
MIVM US (*MY

• WM 61m .Nm.00M • VOMHw • 41".11101, •4•0 14•10• • rit‘•011.• • •)(•• KIK • ?fa. wo• noll•nalt mania
ite
—Snap Ilestelt• wltrl imilled 'IMMO%
mmm US tomftv
.1 WI Ow Mgt* la ••••••Pwconei• 11•4 Der lingo ler grown ••••••d Fore Amor*
41.91 001 • c.r•el Pmf•me Vol
32 QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential QARMIN
Contact Information
QARMIN
25 rue Balzac
75008 Paris, France
Email: contact@qarmin.net
Telephone: +33 (0)1 70 99 52 62 (office)
+33 (0)6 77 20 82 95 (Bertrand)
+33 (0)6 08 94 53 62 (Francois-Charles)
Fax: +33 (0)1 70 99 52 91
33 QARMIN June 2012 - Confidential
EFTA00605996 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Wedbush BUY rating on Digital Currency Group GBTC
(inferred date: 2026-01-10)
WEDBUSH Equity
Research
Financial Technology
i ll\ 55(. 1 1. '5 SI.N 1.,(55( IS( '0 \IV. NORk ItOSION II II %I.° I SI I I A I' 0 I. I 5 I %I II 5% I I, I. I.
Bitcoin Investment Trust (GBTC)
Renewed Interest by Large Financial Institutions and Media;
Reiterating OUTPERFORM and Raising BTC Price Target to
$600

• We believe bitcoin and its associated blockchain technology have the
potential to disrupt the existing financial infrastructure over the next several
years, and believe the value of the bitcoin currency (BTC) will benefit from
this trend. Please see our GBTC initiation report here.

• We believe the value of bitcoin has started moving up recently as broad
positive media coverage (page 3) has started to sway sentiment.

• Large financial institutions continue to invest and investigate uses of bitcoin
and its underlying technologies (e.g. Blockchain) at an increasing pace (p4).

• We believe that Blockchain is to Bitcoin as Intranet is to Internet. We believe
there may be some applications that narrowly use a distributed ledger without a
valuable native token, but those will end up being a small part of the solutions the
technology creates. We believe the reason financial institutions are insisting on
-Blockchain not Bitcoin" is for internal and regulatory compliance. We expect that
even the narrow solutions leveraging only a distributed ledger will end up being
anchored on the bitcoin blockchain sooner or later.

• We continue to observe consistent transaction growth, especially from
applications such as remittance and multi -signature (pages 5.6). We are also
witnessing an increase in payment fees over time, which should help supplant
bitcoin issuing as the revenue source for the transaction processors running the
bitcoin network.

• We detail our valuation framework on pages 7-9 to arrive at our target of
$600/BTC ($60/GBTC) - we employ a supply/demand methodology based on
utilization of future applications. With bitcoin supply mostly predetermined, we
estimate bitcoin applications' large and growing addressable market, anticipate an
inflection point of bitcoin application adoption 5-10 years out and apply a high
discount rate to account for uncertainty.

• Reiterate OUTPERFORM rating and raising our GBTC price target to $60
(equivalent to $600/BTC) from $40 based on less conservative supply
assumptions. The main change to our model is a higher proportion of dormant or
held-for-investment bitcoin.

• Risks to our price target include the fact that BTC could very well go to zero due to
lack of cash flow, increased government regulations, lack of consumer adoption,
rise of superior alternative crypto currency, failure of the protocol, and cyber hacks.
November 4, 2015
Price
$52.00
Rating
OUTPERFORM
12-Month Price Target
$60
Gil Luria
(from $40)
s LAI I I. E
Company Information
Shares Outst (M)
Market Cap (B)
52-Wk Range
1.382.0
$71.8
$21.22 - $55.00
Shares Oust - BTC(M) 14,800
Market Cap - BTC (B) $7,152
Company Description
The Bitcoin Investment Trust (BIT) is a
private, open-ended trust that is invested
exclusively in bitcoin and derives its value
solely from the price of bitcoin. BIT was
launched in 2013 by Grayscale
Investments, a wholly-owned subsidiary of
Digital Currency Group.
Source: Thomson Reuters
Wedbush Securities does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports. Thus, investors
should be aware that the firm may have a conflict of interest that could affect the objectivity of this report. 
Investors
should consider this report as only a single factor in making their investment decision. Please see page 10 of this
report for analyst certification and important disclosure information.
WEDBUSH
Risks to Bitcoin
Future risks that may face bitcoins, the Shares' underlying asset. may be:

• Bitcoin does not generate any cash flow.
• Changes in global bitcoin demand, by changing levels of acceptance by merchants and consumers, may adversely affect
market pricing of bitcoins.

• Cyber theft of bitcoins by or from online bitcoin wallet providers, or theft from individual bitcoin wallets.

• Monetary policies of central banks and governments may impose risk by trade restriction or currency revaluation, 
possibly
having adverse effects on bitcoin market pricing.

• Increased competition from other payment technologies, services, or forms of crypto currency.
• The maintenance and development of the open-source software protocol of the Bitcoin Network.
Risks to GBTC Shares
Future risks that may face the Trust, and its Shares. may be:

• Regulatory changes that may change the way BIT operates in regards to the way the Shares are traded on its designated
exchange.

• Countries curtailing or outlawing trading and/or ownership of bitcoins.
• Additional expenses incurred by the Trust due to possible future regulatory compliance changes, though the Trust holds
the
ability to terminate should these expenses be disadvantageous to investors.

• Due to the Shares' direct relationship to historically volatile bitcoin market prices, the value of the shares may 
fluctuate.
• BIT is a passive investment vehicle: therefore it is not actively managed and is susceptible to losses that may have 
been
mitigated by active trading.
Disclosures
At the time of publication, Wedbush Securities owns a nominal amount of BTC and has invested in bitcoin-related 
companies.
Other mandatory disclosures appear in the back of the report.
Gil Luria Bitcoln Investment Trust 12
WEDBUSH
Figure 1: The Economist Print Edition
9610(.: A 124AGESIICIAL RE:PORTON (POMBA
The
Economist
03>and twins0 Males pail
twin %Silo the and el bent
These ever-aeathe aCCOuntiniS
MiSka Lan tIN ISM b
Ceriottec She am typerwedaw
The trust machine How the technology behind bitcoin
could change the world
e a  a ft` 4144%
k
st,
Ai err.r / 4
Source: Wedbush Securities. Inc.
Figure 2: Recent Coverage
Bloomberg
Forbes lkslaliestot -
red:sake
.SmIerirthidlaallimimilartirwaliei,•—
nen
ro•
pos....4 sass,. trees..
w.m....,../..... ..wawsamnsw.m
_ T _ 4 - -• µ _ •
^
rata --
Oa V_ a' -a
U.- -
Source: Wedbush Securities, Inc.
[21
WORLD
CONOfrAtt FoRuni
R
AGENDA
E
%DI qt,11 truth IUD
011V11% ilk 10 SEIM
111M
mir Why Bitet4iilk 3/441 Be Midi
Slue Then • tromp'
•••=ommisammt
!be ;Nein Nark Ziwit5 I-WM' UPI ‘. W e
Gil Luria Ellteoln Investment Trust 13
WEDBUSH
Figure 3: Financial Institutions and Other Corporate Adoption of Bitcoin and Blockchain
Companies inventing in Blockchain Technole
Andreessen tionossiu
043VA
Satiety Ventures
Greylock Patinas
Capital One
Gamma Catalyst Partners
Mosta Ventures
USAA
Visa
Bain Capital %/animas
CIBC
Firstftbrk Capital
Mastercard
New York Lite
Novel TNT
Oak HCIFT
RRE Ventures
Solon Mack Captal
Transamerica Ventures
Goldman Sachs
NYSE
NASDAQ
UBS
Cid
Barclays
Wecturh
CME
Investigating Blockchain Use Cases
BNY !Arlon
IBM
US Federal Re
Samsung
Santander
PayPal/Bnuntree
Stripe
NCR
Square
Intuit
First Data
Global Payments
Toshiba. VisualTouch
Companies scceptmq Sitcom') payments
Microsoft
Del
Untied Way
Wikipedia
WoMpress
Expodia
Dish
Overstock
American Red Cross
Time Magazine
Monila
Nenvegg
Redd,
Soundcloud
Zynga
Subway (very few)
Vrgh Galactic
Sacramenlo Kings
Tiger Direct
Chicago Sun-limes
OKCupid
Rakuferi (via SLOSicliasy Rakmen Super Lo9stics)
OpenSSL
Khan Academy
Source: Wedbush Securities, Inc.
Gil Luria Bitcoin Investment Trust i 4
WEDBUSH
Figure 4: Monthly Bitcoin Transactions
5,000,000.00
4,000,000.00
3,000,000.00
2,000,000.00
1,000,000.00
0.00 uni 11)11111111111 I Ill U1 Ill Ill Ill
ct 2. O c m ct ,t k i c —ogc—O-c-O
Source: BIockchain.info, Wedbush Securities, Inc.
Figure 5:
Pantera Capital Portfolio Companies Growth Rates
Blockchaln Cross-Border Payments Volume 7x VTD,
BM Payments II x YTD
2,000
1.600
1.200
800
400
0
C mpa y  — Company 2 Company 3 Index (Companies 1-3)
Source: Pantera Capital, Wedbush Securities, Inc.
Gil Luria BIteoln Investment Trust 15
WEDBUSH
Figure 6: BitGo Transaction Volume
BitGo's Transaction Volume
IS in MTh
2,000
:1,600
:1,200
0 800
u 400
0
I
Q2'15
Source: BitGo. Wedbush Securities. Inc.
Figure 7: Average Fee per Transaction
I 0.0003
0.00025
0.0002
0.00015
0.0001
0.00005
0
Average Fee per Transaction - 7 day average
t• la S \\. %.t. V.. S \N \yerS s$ est,
0' 4°  9 19 1s tg2 e 7
P.2
Source: Wedbush Securities. Inc.
Gil Luria ITheoln Investment Trust 16
WEDBUSH
Valuation
Our approach is to use a commodity-like valuation that values each BTC as a 'packet' in limited supply that fuels the 
bitcoin network.
The more the bitcoin network is utilized for current and future applications, the more demand for the packet. By 
aggregating the
utilization of the various applications (Figure 1) we arrive at our $600 BTC price target which translates to $60 per 
share of GBTC.
We start with the supply which is predetermined by the bitcoin software to create new 'shares" in order to compensate 
the network
node operators (i.e. miners). Of those, the relevant portion is the portion neither dormant nor held for investment. 
Those bitcoin cannot
support economic activity and are therefore excluded from the relevant supply. We expect that proportion to fall in 
proportion as
economic activity picks up and the number of bitcoin available to support applications to grow.
We then look at the four current applications for bitcoin — online payments, remittance, micro transactions and 
"banking" for the
unbanked — as well as a catch all other category that includes black market activity and any other future application 
such as machine to
machine (Internet of Things) and anchoring other blockchains.
For each of these applications we attempt to forecast demand by looking at the total addressable volumes and potential 
share bitcoin
can achieve over the next 10 years. For micro transactions we use the total intemet advertising market as a proxy for 
the size of the
opportunity, considering the possibility direct monetization of content will help supplant the intemet advertising 
model. We assume in
our forecasts 10.20% bitcoin penetration for all these various opportunities by 2025.
In order to assess the amount of bitcoin required to support this level of activity we apply different levels of 
velocity. For example, if a
consumer replenishes their bitcoin wallet every month that would equate to 12x annual velocity for their bitcoin. We 
apply velocity levels
ranging from 5.5 for unbanked and other applications (current velocity of bitcoin) and 12 times for payments and 
remittance.
The ultimate calculation takes the total bitcoin required to support these applications in 2025 divided by the number of
bitcoin available
for economic activity discounted to the current period by a discount rate. We use a very high 40% discount rate to 
illustrate the
uncertainty regarding these outcomes ten years out.
Figure 8: Bitcoin Supply Largely Predetermined
2014A 2015E 2020E 2025E
Total Bitcoin in Circulation (End of Year) 13.125.000 15.000.000 18.410,000 20.343.750
% of total 71.43% 87.67% 96.88%
Held for investment or Dormant % 50% 50% 41% 33%
Held as Working Capital % 50% 50% 60% 67%
Bitcoin Available for Transactions 6.562.500 7.500.000 10.953,950 Ifr1=111
Source: Wedbush Securities. Inc.
Figure 9: Large and Growing Addressable Market
S Billion
2014A 2015E 2020E 2025E
Online Payments 1.500 1.725 3,379 5.955
Remittances 435 457 583 744
Micro Transactions 540 567 724 924
Unbanked 4,305 4.435 5,141 5.960
Other 1.829 1.902 2.314 2.816
Total 8,609 9.086 12,141 16.398
Growth Rates
Online Payments 15% 12% 12%
Remittances 5% 5% 5%
Micro Transactions 5% 5% 5%
Unbanked 3% 3% 3%
Other 4% 4% 4%
Source: Wedbush Securities. Inc.
Bitcoin Investment Trust 7 Gil Luria
WEDBUSH
Figure 10: Expect Market Share "Hockey Stick" 5-10 Years Out
Bitcoin Share
Online Payments 0.02% 0.04% 1.35% 10.00%
Remittances 0.01% 0.03% 2.16% 20.00%
Micro Transactions 0.01% 0.03% 2.16% 20.00%
Unbanked 0.001% 0.003% 0.73% 10.00%
Other 0.01% 0.02% 0.64% 10.00%
Capacity Supported by Bitcoin
Online Payments $ 0.32 S 0.7 $ 45.6 $ 595.5
Remittances $ 0.04 $ 0.1 $ 12.6 $ 148.8
Micro Transactions $ 0.05 $ 0.2 $ 15.6 $ 184.7
Unbanked $ 0.04 $ 0.1 $ 37.5 $ 596.0
Other $ 0.18 $ 0.4 $ 14.8 $ 281.6
Total $ 0.64 $ 1.5 $ 126.1 $ 1.806.6
Assumed Annual Velocity
Online Payments 12 12 12 12
Remittances 12 12 12 12
Micro Transactions 12 12 12 12
Unbanked 6 6 6 6
Other 6 6 6 6
Bitcoin Monetray Base Required
Online Payments $ 0.03 $ 0.06 $ 3.80 $ 49.63
Remittances $ 0.00 $ 0.01 $ 1.05 $ 12.40
Micro Transactions $ 0.00 $ 0.01 $ 1.30 $ 15.39
Unbanked $ 0.01 S 0.02 $ 6.81 $ 108.36
Other $ 0.03 S 0.07 $ 2.69 S 51.19
Total BTC Monetary Base Required S 0.08 S 0.18 S 15.66 S 236.97
Source: Wedbush Securities. Inc.
Figure 11: High Discount Rate to Account for Uncertainty
Year 0 5 10
Bitcoin S Monetary Base Required
Bltcolns Available for Transactions $12 $24 $1,429 S17.473
BTC Price $462 11/4/2015
Excess Value Based on Future Demand $450
PV SUSI:VE(7C $604
Discount Rate 40%
Source: Wedbush Securities. Inc.
Gil Luria Bitcoin Investment Trust 18
WEDBUSH
Figure 12: Full Valuation Framework
2014A 2015E 2016E 2017E 2016E 20196 2020E 2021E 2022E 2023E 202E 2025E
rønt Atcan in Orculmixn <End 01 Yeorl I 12$ COO 1 ,, . , . 18.025400 10656.022 17237.030 17.916000 18.410.022 18.725.003
19.041600 19.357.002 1907.6® 20.343.760
5.00081 7143% 78.31% 79.31% 8232% 8532% 0737% 89.13% 9087% 92.18% 93.75% 9688%
Hee br kneetmeol og Conner4% 50% 50% 45% K% 44% 42% 41% 39% 38% 36% 35% 33%
Heem Workeg Cephil % 50% .9'./., 52% 51% 56% 69% EO% 01% 63% 64% 06% 07%
°kon kabelt , b Tricesarre 8.582.500 7.500.00 0.333.000 8.994240 9080.720 14392.400 10.9531150 11.422.250 11.900.625 
12.388.480 12936.313 13.562563
811on
0011n4 Po)~4.
Eend
Micro Transactons
unbanho4
Other
C62/9329~
Onno PaIngis
gemme-ces
tam Tronsocions
Vnben144
On.r
2014A mee 20141 20111 201$8 20105 20201 20211 202211 2023E 202E 20261
1.500 1.725 1.964 2.261 2.024 3.017 3.379 3.765 4239 4,747 5.317 5.956
435 467 480 5:4 520 565 563 612 643 675 709 744
540 567 545 825 656 en 724 760 796 830 880 924
4.305 4835 4.568 9766 41156 4.9* 5.141 5295 5.454 5.618 5.795 5360
1.829 1$02 1.978 2.067 2.140 2225 2.314 2407 2.503 2.803 2.707 2.818
15% 15% 15% 15% 15% 12% 12% 12% 12% 12% 12%
5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5%
5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5% 5%
3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3%
4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4%
20C4103bar$
OrdnePareres 0.02% 901% 900% 0.17% 0.34% 0.67% 1.35% 2.70% 5.39% 7.0D% 9.00% 1000%
Reennwscos 401% 0.03% 0.09% 0.27% 0.54% 1.08% 2.16% 4.32% 6.64% 1728% 18.50% 2000%
1.8go Trernations 0.01% 00% 0.09% 017% 0.54% 1.08% 2.14% 4.32% AM% 17.28% 18.50% 200%
uraan1.44 0401% 0.003% 0.01% 0.03% 0.08% 024% 0.73% 1.46% 2.92% 5.83% 7.50% 1000%
OP/. 0.01% 902% 0.04% 0.08% 0.16% 032% 0.64% 1.28% 156% 5.12% 7.50% 1000%
C/99011. Suppol9:00/ &kon
oranoPaynents $ 0.32 $ 0.7 $ 1.7 $ 38 5 88 $ 20.3 $ 456 5 102.1 $ 2236 $ 3323 $ 478.5 $ 5968
Remiltrces $ 0.04 $ «1 3 0.4 5 14 5 20 5 00 5 126 5 28,4 S 654 5 1166 5 131.1 S 148,8
Nicn> Tramacions $ 0.05 5 02 5 0.5 $ 1.7 $ 3.5 $ 7.4 $ 15.6 5 328 $ 669 $ 14413 $ 142.7 $ 184.2
Vrbetand $ 0.01 $ 0.1 $ 0.4 5 13 5 3$ 5 121 5 376 5 772 5 1500 5 3276 5 4340 5 330.0
OM« $ 018  s 0.4 f ).13 f .6 $ 4 f i.t 6 15 $ 0.8 6 111 1 8.3 Lse3.1 0,10$ 0.40 0,0$ 1,65 34 $ 14.85 30,0$ 64,5$ 133,3$ 
203,1 $

TM. $ 044 $ 1.5 5 3,8 5 98 5 22.8 5 S1.0 5 1281 5 2892 5 6711.2 5 1.0546 5 1.409.4 5 124:11.11
Amurnm Arno,' Velwti
CvanoPaynals. 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12
Renenes 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 11
Mao itamacions 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12 12
1.kben1.4.4 6 4 6 4 6 6 6 6 6 4 6 6
CM« 6 6 6 4 6 6 6 6 6 6 6 6
ercøn  lltaxaQv Base ~0
«nl ne Parri8
ficinnino5
48,0 TiernacIons
trbonted
0166.
Total BTC 116/01ory Ba* R4.244140
0.03 f 006
0.00 001
0.00 5 001
0.01 f 002
0.03 3 007
008 $ 0.18
014 f 032
004 $ «11
0.04 5 014
0.07 $ 023
014 $ 030
0.44 $ 1.10
014
024
0.80
0.71
002
2.61
1.59 $ 389 8.Ø 1905 5 2709 39.88 4963
050 $ 1115 2.20 463 S 972 10.92 12.40
0.62 5 120 2.74 674 $ 12* 13.56 1639
221 $ 681 54.61 2692 S 5987 78.90 10826
1.29 5 209 51/0 1165 5 2423 38.92 51.19
6.31 $ 15.5 33.00 69.99 5 13121 180.18 23637
2 3 4 6 8 9 10
Bacoln 5 Morwary Base RttrIlf4.71
114coins Anaal» br Tramaakon5 512 524 553 5123 $269 5608 51829 $2896 $5.811 510.758 $13.973
BTC Pno6 5462 11140015
E744,34 Wit., 0490 0,  4440JeCronti $450
PV 54.160.11TC C. present vaiun of Se poce pre 131C requmed 10 support the expert«. level el econonvA acermy in 7023
1:44444•4 Rát0 40%
Source: Wedbush Securities, Inc.
M!!!
Gil Lucia Blteoln Investment Trust i 9
WEDBUSH
Analyst Biography
Gil Luria is a Managing Director, Equity Research. covering Financial Technology stocks at Wedbush Securities. He joined
Wedbush in
2005 and was previously at Sanford C. Bernstein covering large U.S. telecommunications companies. Prior to that he was a
Manager
with Deloitte Consulting focused on telecommunications companies.

Mr. Luria holds a B.A. in Economics from Hebrew University and an M.B.A. from Columbia Business School.
Gil's Edge: Gil relies on bottom -up fundamental analysis building on his deep understanding of technology and its 
implications for his
companies.
Analyst Certification
I. Gil Luria, Aaron Turner, certify that the views expressed in this report accurately reflect my personal opinion and 
that I have not and will not,
directly or indirectly, receive compensation or other payments in connection with my specific recommendations or views 
contained in this report.
Disclosure intonation regarding historical ratings and price targets is available at
Investment Rating System:
Outperform: Expect the total return of the stock to outperform relative to the median total return of the analyst's (or 
the analysts team) coverage
universe over the next 6-12 months.
Neutral: Expect the total retum of the stock to perform in-line with the median total retum of the analysts (or the 
analysts team) coverage
universe over the next 6-12 months.
Underperform: Expect the total retum of the stock to underperform relative to the median total retum of the analysts (or
the analyst's team)
coverage universe over the next 6.12 months.
The Investment Ratings are based on the expected performance of a stock (based on anticipated total retum to price 
target) relative to the
other stocks in the analysts coverage universe (or the analysts team coverage).*
Rating Distribution
(as of September 30, 2015)
Investment Banking Relationships
(as of September 30. 2015)
Outperform: 55%
Neutral: 43%
Underperform: 2%
Outperform:24%
Neutral: 3%
Underperform: 0%
The Distribution of Ratings is required by FINRA rules: however WS' stock ratings of Outperform. Neutral, and 
Underperform most closely
conform to Buy, Hold, and Sell, respectively. Please note, however, the definitions are not the same as WS' stock 
ratings are on a relative
basis.
The analysts responsible for preparing research reports do not receive compensation based on specific investment banking
activity. The
analysts receive compensation that is based upon various factors including WS' total revenues, a portion of which are 
generated by WS'
investment banking activities.
Wedbush Equity Research Disclosures as of November 4, 2015
Company Disclosure
Bitcoin Investment Trust 1
Research Disclosure Legend

1. WS makes a market in the securities of the subject company.
2. WS managed a public offering of securities within the last 12 months.

3. WS co-managed a public offering of securities within the last 12 months.
4. WS has received compensation for investment banking services within the last 12 months.

5. WS provided investment banking services within the last 12 months.
6. WS is acting as financial advisor.

7. WS expects to receive compensation for investment banking services within the next 3 months.
8. WS provided non-investment banking securities-related services within the past 12 months.

9. WS has received compensation for products and services other than investment banking services within the past 12 
months.

10. The research analyst, a member of the research analysts household, any associate of the research analyst, or any 
individual
directly involved in the preparation of this report has a long position in the common stocks.
11. WS or one of its affiliates beneficially own 1% or more of the common equity securities.
12. The analyst maintains Contingent Value Rights that enables him/her to receive payments of cash upon the company's 
meeting
certain clinical and regulatory milestones.
Gil Luria Bltcoln Investment Trust 1 10
WEDBUSH
Price Charts
Wedbush disclosure price charts are updated within the first fifteen days of each new calendar quarter per FINRA 
regulations. Price charts for
companies initiated upon in the current quarter, and rating and target price changes occurring in the current quarter, 
will not be displayed until
the following quarter. Additional information on recommended securities is available on request.
GBTC
1)07/09/15
OUTPERFORM $40
60 -
rh
re e, 40-= a.
cn
're 30
0
20
03 2013 01 02 03 2014 01 02 03 2015 01 02 03
WS changed its rating system from (Strong Buy/Buy/Hold/Sell) to (Out erform/ Neutral/Under erforrn on Jul 14. 2009.
Please access the attached hyperlink for WS' Coverage Universe:
research Applicable disclosure information is also available upon request by contactin Noeth Hin in the Research 
Department at MM
by  email to or You may also submit a written request
to the following: Business Conduct Department.
OTHER DISCLOSURES
The information herein is based on sources that we consider reliable, but its accuracy is not guaranteed. The 
information contained herein is not a
representation by this corporation. nor is any recommendation made herein based on any privileged information. This 
information is not intended to be
nor should it be relied upon as a complete record or analysis; neither is it an offer nor a solicitation of an offer to 
sell or buy any security mentioned
herein. This firm, Wedbush Securities, its officers, employees, and members of their families, or any one or more of 
them, and its discretionary and
advisory accounts. may have a position in any security discussed herein or in related securities and may make, from time
to time. purchases or sales
thereof in the open market or otherwise. The information and expressions of opinion contained herein are subject to 
change without further notice. The
herein mentioned securities may be sold to or bought from customers on a principal basis by this firm. Additional 
information with respect to the
information contained herein may be obtained upon request.
Gil Luria Blteoln Investment Trust 111
WEDBUSH
EQUITY RESEARCH DEPARTMENT
DIRECTOR OF RESEARCH
Mark D. Benson (~
RETAIL AND CONSUMER TECHNOLOGY. INTERNET. MEDIA & SOCIAL MEDIA HEALTHCARE
Healthy Lifestyles Enterprise Software BlotechnologyiNopharmaceutiesis
Phil TerpoNil Steve Koenig David M. Nerengarten. Ph.D.
Domnc Ruccella Jae Cho Dip Joseph
Robert Driscoll. Ph.D.
Leisure Entertainment Retail
James Hartliman. CFA CPA Michael Pechter Heather Behanna. Ph.D.
Sean Wagner Alicia Reese
Nick McKay Emerging Pharmaceuticals
Restaurants Liana Mcussatos. Ph.D.
Nick Setyan Entertainment Software Kelechi Chikere. Ph.D.
Cohn Radke Michael Pechter
Nick McKay Healthcare Services -Managed Care &Hospitals
Specialty Retail: Hardlines Sarah James
Seth Basham. CFA Financial Technology
John Carrell. CFA Gd B. Luna Medical Devices
Aaron Turner Tao Lew
Specialty Retail: Softlines Matthew Wm
Mary Brown. CFA Internet: Ecomrnerce and Payments
Taryn Kukla Gd B. Una Medical Diagnostics and Life Sciences Tools
Aaron Turner Zarak Khurshid
RETAIL CHANNEL CHECKING GROUP
Internet Media and Gaming
Lupine Skelly Michael Pechter
Nick McKay
INDUSTRIAL GROWTH TECHNOLOGY Alicia Reese
Environmental Services! Building Products Internet Social Media. Advertising and Tecnnolociv
Al Kaschalk Michael Pechter
Mishit Lmentai Nick McKay
Alicia Reese
Water and Renewable Ener Solutions
Cisnid Rose. CFA Media
James Kim James Oix. CFA
Ana &Wax)
Movies and Entertainment
Michael Pachter
Alicia Reese
Nick McKay
Semiconductors
Betsy Van Hees
EQUITY SALES IS:WRYTRADING
Los Angeles
San Francisco
New York
Boston
Minneapolis
Chicago
Los Angeles
San Francisco
New York
Boston
frilwaukee
CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS
EFTA02731341 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-10)
tag The Jailer
My night sweats grease his breakfast plate. The same placard of blue fog is wheeled into position With the same trees 
and headstones. Is that all he can come up with, The rattler of
keys?
1 have been drujged and raped. Seven-hours -knocked out of my right mind Into a black sack
What I relax, foetus or cat, Lever of his wet dreams.
Something is gone.
My sleeping capsule, my red and blue zeppelin Drops me from a terrible altitude. Carapace smashed,
I spread to the beaks of birds.
0 little gimlets—
What holes this papery day is already full of! C) He has been burnin me with rettes, retendmg am a negress ty pt paws. I
tun myself. That is not e ug
The fever trickles and sti6ats in ml hair.
t ribs show. What have I ea n. and smiles.
Surely the sky b not tha lor, Surely the grass should ling.
MI day, gluing my church of burnt matchsticks, I dream of someone else entirely. And he, filth ubversion,
Hurts me
(fakery,
liotHis I masks of amnesia.
Tnili—teiriflena criminal,
I cue with variety—
Hung, starved, burned, hooked.
I imagine him
Impotent as distant thunder,
In whose shadow I have eaten my ghost ration. I wish him dead or away.
That, it scans, is the impossibility.
That being free. What would the dark to without fevers to eat? "Nat would thaar
Do without eyes to knife, what would he Do, do, do without me?
17 October 196z
We, your blood family, will do all we can...
G Vu ICI 9 hree
, L100,0,4 aaelil orie, il(n4riluitscqnd
vl
ccu e4a cio\ALYI)e4a

╭────────────── Page 2, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ We, your blood family, will do all we can... │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────╯

1S n'0 `f Ka Q yk) i j 11( 1 5i tihr&e
()t,400.4. 63aeV`i orie. iKnoinwts oind
SAilsnWi st est filosn4y h o lcon 0 co tytt y .
cc ueAd avt\ALlibeig \Ce
vohr. akt\ Yr hit. Iko lc hV V e
a% Ok iN 1OGS ZI- oti frivekft utt eft ft .

╭─── Page 3, Image 1 ───╮
│ (IT VTUVVeeeeeeeP ee. │
╰───────────────────────╯

hkzk `i Gthrti Fa
di)ttrte
o‘vrel Zn -
re5t.
bt (Oegt ) owatAVcioso
f•A\a‘k•ki4VhF s Wieact / °Pe / o4
‘1,1vc0 z s i\ i-nc l a c o 4/ • %/e
s
rc( cVe s• (/4,
ko • c241
494
)c (IV Qs Are
k ikeycibhe
4474c/ cte
s
03
= 1
O
C
g
rt
co
c . co
cra cn
Far or all
the Bills
out
there
worrying
about
their
Chelseas.
Harvard.
d
1-
0
Even from a
thousan
miles away, old, men and
children.
‘knaa 4 yvr 1.c4f-ehw
r o f rw\) aci o atro
nit ( e. vOri rsan 1-e St-
-Li k\ii sit t pne4-t 1/4IN me,
iVengdat edThnI ckilde Go sin ?cre di
o OacesQ`. rs ►aIna
0,O1 .1 1,1i b a i- cicae. thi l n i P( P4h
IckyoN,nciih vnly01esoknorttc
kdentAkt, D.ruktpscu m n 01\O a
k sf a tr. sit l° Doc•e.
M cej t,sc\e,e,mt 1vnit vfc ptal li-ClIsehot; bsont

f. conrcOnnrsawihriuse ' I I; °
si 6

╭─ Page 5, Image 1 ─╮
│ WRAAARA A         │
│                   │
│ z Eve 1). from a  │
│                   │
│ E... th musan     │
│                   │
│ the Bills         │
│                   │
│ out               │
│ there             │
│ worrying          │
│ about             │
│ their             │
│ Chelseas.         │
│                   │
│ Harvard.          │
╰───────────────────╯

tears
'I've got
myself a
winner'
never imagined the
vittNr and tears
her future held
red out an ocean of tears.
PAIN
k t 1)ut cl.a Steig 4C00tClalaSe rnouvAN
A.( 4,0Asi0Or itd ac" at ,-; k e 1,.*%S tidviie .yrk.4.
cvijoht , scineok00 , 0,
or,sc,rt ioati tilkoapt

╭────────── Page 7, Image 1 ──────────╮
│ One minute Iwas a                   │
│ nobody, the next...’                │
│                                     │
│ HE vane y vouns Girls ] EEBY blonde │
│ beauty                              │
│ SHE WANTED hildhood back            │
│                                     │
│ NS men she trusted                  │
│                                     │
│ the painful moment                  │
│                                     │
│ 3 matruth betrayed                  │
╰─────────────────────────────────────╯

╭─ Page 8, Image 1 ─╮
│ gORDg             │
│                   │
│ GRADUATE          │
│ S                 │
╰───────────────────╯

4..:z AMP Pifie 4 tr  •
n  ad 461111/
WZO alifed 7fr dee Ora- 4:t'l
die 2'2 er- ( V
(1. Adar,
ikix
da 10.0- hj, sea  akot„
(idelle'll9S47441

╭──── Page 9, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

weeping t na girl in the small dark hours just/ before dawn.
Balancing act
BATTLE
Beauty Dies
shattered
dreams
her tragic end
ATTACK
And it was a long,
tragic trail of tears.
PICTURE
PERFECT giggly, nail]
kindheartal ms, 13,3
intelligeze
sim y
'born humble
(</ 4 ,._ small
generous
OCL\.\
little
trait s
1-wieS
For the person
who has everything
The Fearful
This man makes a pseudonym
And crawls behind it like a worm.
This woman on the telephone
Says she is a man, not a woman.
The mask increases, eats the worm,
Stripes for mouth and eyes and nose,
The voice of the woman hollows—
More and more like a dead one, \
Worms in the glottal stops._`k
She hates
The thought of a baby
Stealer of cells, stealer of beaut
*/ 4. ( :)%
She would rather be deatt,
Dead and perfect, like T ,
Hearing the fierce mask magnify
The silver Iin bo each eye
Where t Ian never swigt,
Whe s only tam and him.
16 November 1962
ICeiS lflctitsted4} n ti oa k
hSP43%46 meviMeadaten
opt:Ric wrehnviMi s• ,11 v a e bot gee
urea+ OS4Aa i as Te mica a AK-Fr
al as•s4 °kJ\ 3c µStita4ry vrt4c
rttililtAtci 9 iX'. t.a tr viCaS at h
eftrinisIrloStite401“rfrr
VarAnicae rsh 4 I S PoSel tt
NvicA4w5S. (toted* ta ytueShoia
fo i Kt Ctiltss eft101 - beS e.v 0 gsc ooso r
deu
cllaf4Po PS04
od13 4', 3
•te, tri erS0
till Ic4ahl
0 0 al .
LEASE BEHAVE LIKE TOE EVOLVED Horth SiiPIEN YOU ARE
tND KINDLY REFFMN FROM LICKING.
what if you didn't have to worry about
cribilV t
0.10-04a4tae:
h0TIP0P
stical island
the unexpected visit from
Photos
ci rly'fitoeiliat
s !; Ty1/4t .tn
toStklf, ;it') Llei t ayn ct i se i kre19 i t J oey
H1c ho dntrsn a rik 10 hs ni - 0 at
ett n egoleSnist i ttadhvie l
inicil\Psicc i i ehl tine aergii.3S
ZAf i lel\IU14)tifiV)3 j
Palo. Son -1y G
DI hi/AU-CIO I 40 i rt i v
"yueen r yr
bvbeaev. 0
Naughty Girl
thn rgort -t- beY' iwk Adso
ki 14 (1 e)i“ , taw yo e'
W reid w; 4-; IC W‘f Of h
1 0 14Lontii . h 10 54."(kAt
)1# If ;had at Vciol. gsboe
cn gtz. d 11 tf04 i e morgn
cob 2.0eut spl r lib °cake
1O- it ctcarw 3 a atiu i da ivr
, }ehes Lib?", *9 rfA., n a4 GC.
fl tek(- ari l lo 3 a C "sr I
1- aKhsan I rep•inaca
6 3Cri t i tch1 10 ‘inci\
t c<K 1st i df, WSO(rd
ael'iv4 0 thvirs e lisae
bctiegto 11c nw5 ti.gnu0 Cyr
c•asiosscalabti 5V ihet
sg 1*(6 f e zn cl 3G Ictlahs!
1/1 r) Gocibkiir(cntArt
A LOT OF COLD SHOWERS MRiS ntm Erl
000 SSiecick
r 4i 4 dr. ' Blood on Their Hands ode)frin
ono mn 6
r. adsn.rowY
ti vaebr &di (
3 r;c neln 8I 5'
-eh ALthrnhancr
Lotewd d
iti
~lis  4 A P
NO doctor
damage.
TALK TO NO
DOCTOR
"If you don't know you can't help!"

╭─────── Page 15, Image 1 ───────╮
│ Perfectly functional           │
│                                │
│ Even if they aren't            │
│                                │
│ Looking for help?              │
│                                │
│ The solution is                │
│                                │
│ emergency                      │
│                                │
│ spontaneous                    │
│ outpouring of                  │
│                                │
│ Andl                           │
│ Am the arrow,                  │
│                                │
│ The dew that fies              │
│                                │
│ Suicidal, atone with the drive │
│ Intothered                     │
│                                │
│ Eye, the cauldron of morning   │
│ —from Ariel, by Sylvia Plath   │
│                                │
│ A DEEP, DEEP SLEEP             │
│                                │
│ loneliness                     │
│                                │
│ one little child.              │
╰────────────────────────────────╯

Itact - re bt p i a x Ihkii1 I intaeo
VI 3 SO p nrJ 1 + 0 5,1-.drA ibv 4_5
ki4k aIntCpSTrNnnvenGi l ieri9I A
intoe xe. 4cfeQ4 3 hol `n31r, do 1 n't
bCuecinVvc el 4 w1- act)/ en Crans i ad
to 5 1OC ottuies ihb *Ictecti
Inoloo 0'nOhnk ie.hs-4.nf roe e 3 no I nat3e,
atg‘ kcaact lyi;AclastAracnV tvo6 A
(ndhcveeostaI Q0euenSe05nI me H
ckee.aYnntownancdrHx7%,,iteoicka cr .“,1
i tit Ci iatthio Ti 91.d nwn+b+e
et/J(1 a 5+01  0}0.fle) ,.i
Get more of what you want, when you want
it with America Online.

• Easy to install and even easier to get started
• Stay connected to friends & family with convenient,
easy-to-use e-mail, Buddy List® and AOL• Instant
Messenger' features
• Parental Controls help safeguard your kids online
STAY ALERT •
•
WE LIVE WHERE YOU LIVE
- cnct o
o Podt nPockiS:
Teveloi 45',n Fe 4c
kos ikkfioA 3111e
an S'ae,`.
Ifveet, cnotcp
a Fatal Attraction to
= just little You
*40 0 ≥ f Vie. t vn 4-e n
> i(•Y\rsoforfp a linticto
. ICrgoi t oeflNis,:di
oa o3tSnohloSnkoe ago
InSOnuda?, lob, w1AotHsan
etoS 6 1 k)V a all. hi buS-1 112:
iri\ Niusp't)i tot w/Sondi i
6 ()nod 14locs,'. w10e0t‘
e -t. ej.
k, i‘
n oknea)dt.6 -1( athii
cinw
ct
n t o:t
h s
WinaCncocki ?ot,ust, 0+4A-tiv.
k k pcd rb-l-cip‘opti
Genes
YOU KNOW.
D:0: 4.T HAVE A CHOICE.
little plan

╭────────────────── Page 16, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ acohbBhmsrehs nfroeese                                │
│                                                       │
│ ha spens                                              │
│ alyyiAdosmra?                                         │
│                                                       │
│ tate                                                  │
│ nwnarcd                                               │
│                                                       │
│ ty tmcit Ne                                           │
│ were the eN®                                          │
│                                                       │
│ Get more of what you want, when you want ~            │
│ it with America Online.                               │
│                                                       │
│ + Easy to install and even easier to get started      │
│                                                       │
│ + Stay connected to friends & family with convenient, │
│ easy-to-use e-mail, Buddy List® and AOL? Instant      │
│ ‘Messenger™ features                                  │
│                                                       │
│ « Parental Controls help safeguard your kids online   │
│                                                       │
│ To V0S                                                │
│ whroPpnae                                             │
│                                                       │
│ ceyuzutot                                             │
│                                                       │
│ drotanwt                                              │
│                                                       │
│ Fatal Attraction to                                   │
│                                                       │
│ ewe YoU KNOW.                                         │
│                                                       │
│ just littl Y YOU'HAVE A CHOICE.                       │
│ : = aay little plan                                   │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

41
C.
DARED
TO SEARCH
FOR
MEANING.
I understand,
how they feel,
what they're
going through
because I've
gone through
it too,
s=
o WITHOUT
_2003 lo loop A
19i3"'"
Pll fight t., rill- eml
I want to make
people's lives better &
change the world
C
YOU somigri
.O. was e.... ce
absolutely
.S* you dilie!-
‘',W he

╭─ Page 19, Image 1 ─╮
│ —                  │
│                    │
│ —                  │
│                    │
│ =—                 │
│ ——4                │
│                    │
│ W.                 │
│                    │
│ ae!                │
│                    │
│ TSP                │
│                    │
│ lik                │
│                    │
│ ae                 │
╰────────────────────╯

ire ' (111 !g 10 to) (o) r. (P 11 i ins ni ii I 4111
lith.I i as   I& its Mini nth a

╭───────────────────── Page 20, Image 1 ─────────────────────╮
│ na be                                                      │
│                                                            │
│ i ot bot Yor oe you fol Wey Moy Mev fal oy yi yt yoy uy ya │
│                                                            │
│ ii                                                         │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003936 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003939 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007893 (Jmail)
 [government] Palm Beach Police receipts, notes, bank statements of Ghislaine Maxwell
(inferred date: 2026-01-11)
- 1 •
j
ORS 023076 Town of Palm Beach efklcsA
Police Department
EVIDENCE
CASE i/0 5 .3(02  PROPERTY # O 2cRl t—
CONTENTS / S3 2
Suspect: ips 4- teen ji
Officer: 'yet . ..
Lab 0:
Date: Of -0610  6
KL-231
G

tgli7V) rt-)
cOgR
S P-7---21 53:74 cffrX
O
ick\( %oh
s‘&64-01011.1.1.11

(0 a G. Maxwell's Mercedes key needs a new battery,
o Telephone in G. Maxwell's bathroom has not been speed dial,
programmed. Have ETC come to program that. (../
o The Green guest bedroom needs a phone. (GM to send from NY)
o The phone by the couch in the upstairs hallway needs to be replaced.
(GM to send phone from NY)
o The bike shed's floor needs to be repainted; paint either in a grey or Oa
black.
C
o The ground behind the cabana needs to be tiled. 0 Clos e --
o G. Maxwell's office needs wall paper.
o AA batteries are need. Other sizes of batteries may also need to be 100 0......
stocked. Reminder always check stock of these essential items
o Buy & keep stocked English/Danish butter. - it can be bought from C'est t oe
si bon
o Electrical switch plate missing in G. Maxwell's bathroom. 400/ ...
o The leak in the pantry needs to be fixed. (Speak to=re best way t one
forward)
o Printing paper is low. Purchase more plain papas.......
o Uni-ball pen stock is low. Purchase moreillo ot"AG- 1
o oming for maintenance a/
o Buy more plain small sized envelope
o Stationary needs to be stocked in guest bedrooms with pens.../ ...
0  o CDs & CD cases are to be put away./.9
o Keep pencils sharpened.
o Hang the picture in the Master bedroom corridor •
0  o Check the tire pressures on all the bikes and pump up as needed
o Lock Ms Maxwell's closet
law.044-tvowero

• N-3.1 ,213
•
-xe
* vim
tkow, 690-1"/
SL:m .pe, u -S
4,0 o G. Maxwell's Mercedes key needs a new battery, "
o Telephone in G. Maxwell's bathroom has not been  dial,
programmed. Have ETC come to program that.
o The Green guest bedroom needs a phone. (GM to send from NY)
o The phone by the couch in the upstairs hallway needs to be replaced.
(GM to send phone from NY)
o The bike shed's floor needs to be repainted; paint either in a grey or 0 soole---
black.
o The ground behind the cabana needs to be tiled. 0 16.00 ..--
o G. Maxwell's office needs wall paper. Sti ,le
o AA batteries are need. Other sizes of batteries may also need to be
stocked. Reminder always check stock of these essential items
o Buy & keep stocked English/Danish butter. — it can be bought from C'est t 000e
si bon
o Electrical switch plate missing in G. Maxwell's bathroom. 4000 e
o The leak in the pantry needs to be fixed. (Speak to Se best way 40,0 •00"
forward)
o Printing paper is low. Purchase more plain papeilso.......
0 o Uni-ball pen stock is low. Purchase more.Ii i)4V AG.I 1
o laVoming for maintenance a/ Wed „edva-ot Utea—
o Buy more plain small sized envelope
o Stationary needs to be stocked in guest bedrooms with pens./ .."
0  o CDs & CD cases are to be put away.
o Keep pencils sharpened. #
o Hang the picture in the Master bedroom corridor
o Check the tire pressures on all the bikes and pump up as needed
o Lock Ms Maxwell's closet
o I mef t•Mtvcrciace6
• ANti tx,k-u/Ae, 21.3
6.A — Gz,as N./
S.S,o‘nDe.
—
M 1St -LAKE WORTH CORPORATION • D/B/A TED'S SHEDS OF LAKE WORTH P.O. BOX 50929
Fax
Sold to: JEFFERY EPSTEIN
358 EI.BRILLO WAY
H:
Pins sum_
Building Style/Size: CLASSIC — 10W x 10L Wall Color/Material: PINK/ALUMINUM Trim Color/Material: WHITE/ALUMINUM
Roof Color/Matefial: WHITE/ALUMINUM
Door Color/Material: WHITEJALUMINUM Skid: 2 - Double 2" x 4"'s
Floor. P.T. 2" x 4"'s On 24" Centers
Frame: T x 4"'s On 24" Centers
OPTION DESCRIPTION
72'W X BON Mobile Home Door
White 16'W x 4"H Vent
22"W X 27"H Sml White Window w/Grid
L10
QTY
ND
V
~nNCowl
DO R
W10
CON1RAC:T OF SALE
Dated: 12/16/2004
Contract ti: 6200-2053
Sales Rep:
Specified Wind Speed: 150 IAPI1
Building Use: Outdoor Equlpme Tt
Serial Number - CUSTOM ORDEI
EsomaIedSNpDale01O1,2005
SUBTOTAL 62,046.06
SALES TAX S122.76 •
CONNECT LABOR $440.00
TOTAL PRICE $2,608.82
DEPOSIT RECEIVE D $1,300.00
CK 2528
BALANCE DUE $1,308.82
I have reviewed the adjacent cli.tg real and approve the
door locatio tiler options end their
locations (Initial hetet
TERMS or  CONTACT
MSRARTING DIOtReRSIES AU. OF Tit TERRA COMM & AGREEien PROWL S. uNourrnAGS. AND RernsiNTATteiS Of Re PARTIES NC 'MU. 
COMM! ME IMRE
AGSBOXf MO% THE FAXES MATH RESPECT 707491MR MITER HERETO P3ASSERTEOFEPRESEMASOs EMMERT. CAECA COURSE Cc 06.2146. COURSE 
OF CCS1XCE OR
CAPER MATTER NOT Fri:ESSE( PROVCEO MERCK SNAU CONSTITUTE Any PART OFTHE AC:RENEW OF INF PARTIESMITHRE,GECT TOME WUXI NAT
BI HEREOF. RD EMOYEEOF
MATERSIWL NAVE RIGN HINTSCEVERTOALTER. NJENDACOPT.R.RY.ACOTO TAKE FRO4 OR OTICRMSC CRAAGE RIC TCRUS 'oar. CXOPTIII.MTNG 
SGNCD BY A OILY
strniCeSED VASES T (ai drew bsa,)INDMPtNBEo TO TNSWRTNONO SUOI PURPORTED °Ma MRS BE EINCAVG (XI AYY CE TEM SCII3 (Rs So 
'RN W.) OR KRA MI FORCE OR EFFECT VilAISOivElt Fa was
t*A.mbuttibblmtbe inub Tai lbw ebeetidottlel cb Beta* pcoscIVisl0romet aed ON* !ma Ito nattianir. TEO'S •
FNEFF. IIY.. aRMS. motto CTS0. TSI MAL. NC Pc613 copxalca rilebn. a airy NW fed tau et TR et Rai Pea TD, ard ANN a t 
mina bcciNtnN alet
1.431..OnteRe 0411,04044 0NR d+, TAN 0 `t017.3,7 perea,a Nnocati, iingd Dis Anatol a Caeca/. aw•AatawwCN.0 
rreant0Ownr.01 IR:s. 0 0.,na TAX ;ming), Rai 03 Want,. Le lot abve b ot >IN
a tancisetNA,101mei Oesei ins nd b wqa ad b lot ary :de cal m Pah test lour/Fab! ri e ',restyle. wee zarcparn: cmainfli
Ottieveroneviztwornalsinlit liQatorelOsevirlebnikterciA1" 1" 4261 d se , TWO (2: wNicRR6I.Ottb-H1131p0 WIN aide &YE, FEN
ll90r I Pr remiss Ponrp0 tam:" Emden to teterddsyseoR6Ip lldl
NON, towareti On He dOdddwryd tonal bOatord tont:11ot'. dak "xh Uwe is pit Ha 'HI :nlonnaHby 01.'6 TV s praw.4 inYoy 
goat/ irt6eili ,  WdbitChtlii rA ab com Ommecti pwaty peasz'en d
OWN. TR. 0: MC. Casket( b MOWS* be (0 et0tarc ten Ruts rs.7.ifel to ritithasidtte Sala:  CO censers) we eviNe4R.40s 
Seta-la We Rcutte.t1Sol My arskath ;ass/NOS tursaS Sitarplaxo
WO'NRWR rINtRA RHORnt tigH4411. et C',4, Wiff,61 Cr Ina* HMIs, rclicooials.Hel icy piss ossitrac elCu:cces poprtalsikil 
restidapottH Olney et use d ten 4rat rd (v) arty elais RaRRRRAN
fr4 0410110 Qb ONYMICnyhoso00.00.doa....DRAInwiC0t. teNtalFccorts plan irclervord 417. bb owil lNtand Ns .sreeve a by 
Ccarter. Yes Media NataIRRActi tip tuch ictolontres aN gni be
elyAd b y  *Tett daX4t ar4 bats 83 rry be N01N0 by Wads RINiSo N. TN Pgatnentshil b cotWR d Ks M troft d RS tin Rata 
CUSTONER SWAM NOT BE ROMEO TOA REFUND ac AWOF THE CEPOSTTEET
FORITIAEOVE :CRAW Y PFAFF,' ONFR OM ER'S MUSE' 3 ft ‘T ER NOWAY CF THE UXIT WTHNT OOWEEKSAilER 116 APPF•OXIRATE MYER ,' 
DATE SET MYRON THE RRONT0c THIS WYCEUEtrt, DELAYS CAUSED VI
swam, LOCRaf E. IA KR TROuelES.INASUW TO PISSOJRE MATEFIRLE FAILURE OF KURR etstacrot 00VERMIEWOLIAWSCRREGULATIONS, 
PKITS. ciaRRECTION. En* OR Ointli REA.SNOP AI SE HAI URE NOT
DEALERSFAULT. SPAU.EXIINDTHE APPROXIVATE CaNERT DATE KR TIC PEI= CF THE CEAVINS ACREIAENT ISNOT Sta.ECT TO RESCISSION. 
REVO;ADON. CARIUJ TIM OR WW2:ATKA FOR REASCHWRAISOErsit nen
SNAIL BE NO THREE DI DAY OR OVER RESC&RON PERCo Mu RESPECT TO TRSAGREEWENT. Etch, ,me dial 4 in ea wcta cl Lea Cant. 
F1/4tUA bl
WI Walk°NNca,aaaut*YehagemN&a•»pwd. WS% cr hcc't'a-eda"ta tit ASRWrot. NTT tatNton pflaii IawNa His Airetersin mon or 
a', l.iscac!a ~0 tencli CaRev Gni or linutoja carterplad pesseled
• anieci3o mb D6AglwroR cane doolltd. coma cleoulp OWER4ILINr013 (00.?• Ruhr I, wee,;La noon all pry, *mho trtLeNty 
Coner. arid Nab Tess Rica, et av rot lb *atm telaltbik
dpnbrgbNalbwtONInayfdsta CitSf MIA ..04 tun/. F•as T0 mowo.'adec4L.CanI. FbMflc ititerizel etNegfkif isibfloRaukal 
0950:0<les0TN4 h as f•TI'A01 beamtad W Ganz. Roi•R &RR:IWO tut+x I
non )0sdacn lettRiawy Lps, Ntrub bin &Row., utestwka boOl b tot cons pecexa. EACH OAKUM HEREBY 
KNOIVRO.Y.VOLLPqTARItY.ANONIENI1ONAUY WKS lie FIGHT IVA TRAt 6Y .1)RE 14 REESE ICE A N
UOGATION BASED OHMS AGREEWEKT, OR SEISMS CUF CF.UsDER. OR IN CYNECnON YAM SsEAGREEMENT, MY TRANSACSON PUMA/0 10 WHEN PIS
SWEEMENT IS IASI 0RMIRISTRINENT CR ASSERTED ACREWENT
0Y41HERCRAL OR N WRING; COMENpUTEDN WraT,CTION wmi miSAGRIENENt. n+2/ts  of ectipuermouns( cc Deng, 
AssE•rmosATEwNrseiRchacRA LOR IN RaTIRI). OR ACTOG BY ANT NAM Ins PROvSION IS A
Malt ft:MENEM FOR MAUR TO ENTER ROO THE ACREENENT OUSTOYERHCR, OYACINCHAECall TNT CUSTCRTEAMSACAD RhpuNOPSSIOCO IA% 
1ERUS CF CONIRACT.AGREES TO BE DOM THERFJW.AND HAS NM
REUEOONASY0,01 OR ri PITIEWIER0 EfttAllONORSTAIIRET0 OF ))4Y FlObbltE OF DEMI
Sates Person Cunt/won rN ‘it I,  at •0.1

TED'S SHEDS DELIVERY SITE INFORMATION
Sold to:
JEFFERY EPSTEIN
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH FL 33480-
Your Street
BbS
Your
House
Dated: 12/16t.2004
Contract ft: 62004' 053
Building/Size: CLA3SIC — 10W x 101.
Product: SHED
kite: Your shed will be delivered on a trailer that Is 8 112W x 21'L x 3'H towed by a pickup truck.

1. Draw an "X" for the location of the shed relative to the house. Note where the shed door(s) should be.

2. Draw an arrowed line to show the route for delivery onto the property.
3. Is there minimum 14 feet of clearance from the ground all along the access? El Yes E No
If No, explain BOS

4. Are there any electric power wires within the 14 feet of ground clearance? Ej Yes E No
5. Is there an extra 2' wider than your shed all along the access? El Yes E No
If No, explain BOS

6. Will the driver pull straight in or will he back in? E Straight In El Back In Crane
7. If shed must be rolled on pipe to reach site, how far is it?

8. If going through a gate ro reach the site, what is the size of the gate opening?
9. Is there a fence obstructing access to the shed site? El Yes El No Crane
If yes, explain removal for access REAR OF HOME ON WATERWAY

0. Are there any trees, branches, stumps, bushes, mailbox, or other object(s) obstructing access? Yes pg If yes, explain
removal of

1. What is the surface condition of the drop off site? ElAsphalt El Grass p Grass/Dirt El Sand [ J Oilier
Explain CONCRETE

2. Would the ground conditions be unsuitable after heavy rain? EI Yes E No
3. Tolyour knowledge, are there underground utilities (such as Electric, Water. Phone, etc.). Septic or sprinkler he 
acistipes anywhere in
th4 delivery area on your property or in the area of the shed site? El Yes E No
If )es, please locate these Utility lines on the sketch above.
i. Is there access to electricity for our crew to anchor the shed using power tools? E Yes No
5. Other special instructions
ie site discussed above must be prepared to accept delivery of the ordered shed. Customer is liable for any dela"s 
incurred if the site is
)t properly prepared at the time of delivery.
Z R -0044mbita./4
USTOM SI SALESPERSON SIGNATURE DATE
istomer must fill out this form if they have selected ' NO Inspection needed' on the TSI Delivery Agreement. (Sales to 
assist) 5 slesoorson must fill out when ing the site inspection
of Customers property if Customer requested a site inspection and fax in when completed. (Sales shoutil also use this 
form along th the required Home Delivery Form when doing the site
Inspection for sheds lamer than 12' x 24').
TED'S SHEDS DELIVERY AGREEMENT
Sold to:
JEFFERY EPSTEIN
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH FL 33480-
H:
Dated: 12/16/2004
Contract #: 6 2004
Building/Size: CLASSIC — 10W x 10L
Product: SHED
Ztongratulations on your purchase of your Ted's Sheds product! Your Ted's Sheds product was constructed to thr highest 
quality standards. red's Sheds offers free delivery,
installation, blocking, and anchoring of your product; provided, however, that, at Ile time of delivery, there is 
sufficient legal access to the site.
ro assist you in your enjoyment of your product, Ted's Sheds offers free site inspection to inspect your property for 
proper access. If land access is not available, Ted's Sheds
offers a free estimate for crane service.
(Please choose one and Initial below.)
Ej Yes, I do want Ted's Sheds to inspect my property for proper access.  initial here.
E No, I do not want Ted's Sheds o r service estimate to inspect my property and understand thi charges forAdditional
service described below. initial here.
the dimensions of the product you have purchased are 10 feet wide x 10 feet long. You agree to provide , at the time of 
delivery, clear
:ontinual, unrestricted, and legal access, free and clear of any obstables whatsoever, 12 feet wide commencing at the 
street,
righway, or other public access and terminating at the precise location where you instruct us to place your produc'.
red's Sheds will not be responsible for clearing any obstacle in order to deliver your product. You indemnify and hold 
Tad's Sheds harmless
rom and against any damage sustained to your property or by any person whomsoever with respect to the delivery, 
installation, blocking, and
inchoring of your product to the precise location where you instruct us to place your product.
'ed's Sheds also shall not be responsible for compliance with any zoning, building, housing, environmental, fire, 
sufety, health, or other
povemmental law, statute, ordinance, regulation, order, requirement, or other authority, federal, state, county, 
municipal. special district, or
ithenvise. Ted's Sheds shall not be responsible for compliance with any private land use restriction, such as restr 
ctive covenants,
esements, rights-of-way, architectural review, building restriction, condominium, homeowner, master, or other 
asi.ociaton rules or
egulations. You shall obtain any permits, approvals, and consents by any person whomsoever required for the in.:tall 
alion of your product.
UI such governmental authorities, private land use restrictions, permits, aprovals and consents, collectively, the 
"Pestic lion."
ed's Sheds will rely upon your instructions as to placement of the product on your site in relation to setbacks and 
3ther restrictions. You
rill be at the installation site at the time of delivery of the product and will pay any balance owing on the purchase 
-*Mulct at that time.
he anchors to secure your product are driven approximately 3 feet into the ground. You must inform us whether l ero are 
any underground
tilities near the precise location where your product will be located. At your request, Ted's Sheds will contact the 
limper utilities marking
ervice at no charge to you.
'ed's Sheds standard delivery hours of operation are Monday - Saturday. 8:00 AM to 3:00 PM.
ed's Sheds may need to reschedule the delivery of your building when an unexpected circumstance arises. You igree that 
any
ascheduling of your delivery will not void the sales agreement or cause any discount to the total sales pr
CHARGES FOR ADDITIONAL SERVICE
ou shall pay Ted's Sheds a minimum charge of $250.00 to revisit any installation site to move or re-anchor your product 
to comply with any
lestriction. You shall pay Ted's Sheds $250.00 for each subsequent installation attempt and each revisit to the silia fo
• any reason
thalsoever. If you refuse delivery of your product for non-accessibility or because of any Restriction, your deposit 's 
roil -refundable.
ed's Sheds acts soley as liaison between you and any crane service provider. Coordinating the scheduling of crane 
service and installation
f your new product will be done by Ted's Sheds as a courtesy to you. You will contract with the crane service provider 
directly at no cost to
ed's Sheds. Ted's Sheds shall not be responsible for any damage done by the crane service provider to any person, your 
property, or any
her property.
he words "you" and "your used herein shall mean the undersigned customer. You have read and understand thi:. Delivery 
Agreement
nd agree to be bound by the terms hereof.
Sc-94 Iva --aN USTOMER1$ SIGN4Tunc DATE
TSI-LAKE WORTH CORPORATION
D/B/A TED'S SHEDS OF LAKE WORTH P.O. BOX 50929
Phone:

FT. ne: MYERS FL
Sold to: JEFFERY EPSTEIN
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM B 33480-
Building Style/Size:
Wall Color/Material:
Trim Color/Material:
Roof Color/Material:
Door Color/Material:
Skid:
Floor:
Frame:
Fax
CLASSIC -- low x 10L
PINK/ALUMINUM
WHITE/ALUMINUM
WHITE/ALUMINUM
WHITE/ALUMINUM
2- Double 2" x 4" 's
P.T. 2" x 4" 's On 24" Centers
2" x 4" 's On 24" Centers
Dated: 12/16/2004
Contract At: 6200-2053
Sales F:ep:
Your signature below will confirm that this building you have ordered will be manufactured at your request without a 
Florida
Department of Community Affairs approval or state insignia affixed or assigned to it.
Due to the "Build On Site" requirement, this building is not approved for permitting by the State of Florida. This 
building
does not include the Ted's Sheds Manufacturer Limited Lifetime Warranty.
Accepted by:
Customer Signature
Printed Customer Name
Dated
R?forVevatA
Mailing Address: P.O. Box 50929, Fort Myers FL 33994 — Phone:
Physical Address: 9350 Laredo Avenue, Fort Myers FL 33905 — Fax:
SHEDS Thank you for your business!
Ted's Sheds Call Center will now be assisting you
with all aspects of your purchase.
A representative from Ted's Sheds will be contacting you
within 3 days after your purchase.
Please contact Ted's Sheds
for all future inquiries by calling -
East Coast Delivery Schedule - Ext.
West Coast Delivery Schedule -
Customer Service - Ext.
Operations Manager - Ext.
Grocery List May 10, 2004
Dairy Products Carmines
•
•
•
Whole milk gallon
Skim milk gallon
Half & Half carton
y.

• Non fat Plain Yogurt quart 1
• Eggs 24
• Danish Butter 6
• Low fat cottage Cheese 1
• Cream Cheese whipped 1 pack

• Fresh monarella 1 pack
• Parmesan I wedge
• Mild Cheddar 1 pound
Juices  all organic  Carmines
• Orange juice

• Mango Juice
Syrups
• Nesquik chocolate
• Hershey's chocolate
Sodas & Power aid
• Power Aide 24
• Sprite 12

• Diet Coke 12
• Coke 12
• Diet Pepsi 12
Salad dressing
• Bellmans
• Dijon mustard 1
On' foods Carmines

• Dark Brown Sugar
• Skippy Peanut butter 2
• Multi Grain Bread 2
• Fresh Bread Carmines 2
Cereals Small boxes
Frosted Flakes, Froot Loop,
Sugar milk. Cheerios, Honey cheerios 6 of each
Corn pops, special K
Fruits (organic) Carmines PJ
Basket of Figs
Avocados
Bananas hunches 2
Oranges
Mangot.
Pineapples
Papaya
Lemon
Lime
Raspberries baskets
Strawberries
Grapes Red/ Green baskets
Cherries bags
Nectarines
Melons
Cantaloupe
Vegetables all organic Carmines

• Red Pepper
• Green Pepper
• Celery bag
• Carrots bag 1
• Tomatoes
• Cucumber
• Peeled Garlic bottle
• White onion

• Broccoli heads 2
• Romaine lettuce hags
• Mixed greens boxes
Meats & Sausages all organic Carmines
• Ham pounds 1

• Bacon pounds 1
• Chicken Breast pounds 3
• Sliced Salmon Tnn Js 2
• Fresh Fish 2 poundS
Newspapers Daily in Residence u.30 AM
Main Street News open at 6.30 AM
• New York Times (daily)
• PB daily news (shingle sheet)
• Wall street Journal (111-17)
• Daily Mail (daily) (Ms Maxwell)
Saturday
with others
purchases all Cleaning supplies from Pub:
(
Jeffrey E. Epstein
I
I
I I
JAN -19-2005 12:55
Colords! Net Research Request Item Copies
P.01
Request Info:
Request ID
45ubmitter
Slats
Plashrec
SamIter Phone
Pending Reason
32 2rj
Submit's MX
Account Number Account Two
11)13A
Account Title
IJE/PREY E EPSTEIN OR GHISLAINE MAXWELL OR A
Office Location
‘Ari1st Check it t Posting Date I at Amount $
I---  12/0/2005 ej 2000.00
2nd Check/SAW Postl Date 2nd Amount S
7 - 1 iverzoos j 1000.00
3rd Check/ 3rd Posting Dale 3rd Amount S
1 -----  7 --  j
4th Check a 4th Posting Date 4th Amount S
I _-_J Additional Details
Hone
Return by:
No
Cost Center
Region of Account
32 2:1
i lit Item Batch ard Sequence
Jirr3eieze
nd Item Betth and Sequence
if803427518
3rd Item Batch and Sequence
4th Item Batdi and Sequence
Charge Customer
Interoffice Address
Send Email
Email Address
Comments
I
Account to Charge
Research Dept Info:
Research Group  Assigned To
I Research General Orland. zi Jfl
Bank Error Comments
Assigned Date
Completed Date Create Date
J11181/2-.005 aaj
Last Moaned By
A
Regent Coats
Minutes S Per Minute
0.418667
Copts S Per Ccpy
12.00
Statements 5 Per Statement Copy
13.00
Add Coats I
Total Cod Time
Total Cost Copies
Total Cost Statement
Combined Total Cost
JAN-19-2005 12:56 P.02
JAN-19-2005 12:56 P.03
P JAN-I9-2005 12:56 F.04

co.d 99:3I 9003-6I-NYC
pr
vicA-
FeCIEX, US Airbill
Express
Fnm Amanersont
titilt.4  $14 CPI  J4CCI VItildiel etter
SOWS
PATS_ _
'35)5 a
43:PAcLidt tPOr
2 Your hong Bar Mama
3 T: /WOW Nun. - -
Cofterl
Pa ns
146nit
BC (-to ta.) OwAmilaaa
te e
Pacts Unice/
Roll&PratIry(Swright FedfxS•andardOrimight
••••••••••••.-asse
n Ferff.t2Ny
E .t eEspionalmic
••-• Fidpfe~2tato.••••••••......6,,,,y,,~4,..
a Express Fria& Sonia
fraPst" •CSI•Cat -az
PaclasetpLISMa
redEffiTtOwitigIn isin••••flar.en. man.. NS roe
Lf =Sr
5 Packaging
sin  3814&a  , OM& Fexto, Par El Wet
•
Eweb:**  txeclirtFot1,1 14 SOX
xo trxXxX 240 TatyPOI
y•-•V  th 11)
Add=
es HD Bp
weaneolidella
0 Nab 0 Wet
5 WM It sang
IMVISIINOWerg f(OW) MOST
wlia•Mr.
attofkbtata)
toill.lktr.”1.7..treg.. frmsomee Nos
°WA et" i•ae hIrn agi. " al
' tie 0 lat 4.0 V recirs•
“.... nobarmakigone•npu.40kohationes
7 Paymout ea* hetA4IlastratitistIbilita
Dat e ro Rao., mishits anted
Tear chfon
hat ••••tnnenr•
fveativissiviefts
0 a lt baCO 0 ,3•4114 •
CargoNectelte*
heilate
cleectsk
altar laviciraduc
tonspenomeuass•was wasinnonroanwainhts.
'
MalitiOrtimsfaer areewidkarget‘kteliiika
8 Sato Alacca Dana Nita 50088
Panto oesbeasaliertisarsonweatem•Ant.
tideameasity soros timiskaiseiminiela
lantear-silwart.ranetserIMINCAII*4017!

125 Wain Avenue Ste 100
Palm Asia",
Fax
Fax
4!7ra
To: 4/
Colonial Bank, N.A.
Fax: Data )oth /
Phone: Pages:
Re: CC!
O urgent or Ravin* 0 Mean Comnnt O Plane Ripply °Plume Recycle
991 '0N Wd£I:I I OM .51.34
IMII 12/10/04
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
GHISLAINE MAXWELL
HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNT
DDA STATEMENT HISTORY 10.02.11 PAGE 1
OR ACCOUNT
OR ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
ipplopplimplimp
DATE LAST
DATE THIS STATEMENT 12/10/04
DDA TRANSACTIONS
BEGINNING
BALANCE
0.00
DATE CK NBR
10/14
10/25 934
16/25
10/27
CHECKS/OTHER DEBITS DEPOSITS/OTHER CREDITS
NBR TOTAL AMOUNT NBR TOTAL AMOUNT
10 4006.36 2 7439.80
AMOUNT TP TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION
7439.56 DP DEPOSIT
450.00 CK TELLER CASHED CHECK
0.24 CR IOD INTEREST PAID
69.38 EB CLARKE AMERICAN CHK ORD
ENDING
BALANCE
3433.44
BALANCE
7439.56
6989.56
6989.80
6920.42
11/01 25004, 1150.00 CK TELLER CASHED CHECK 5770.42
11/08 25041 340.00 CK CHECK 5430.42
11/09 2502e 684.87 CK CHECK 4745.55
11/09 25050 415.86 CK CHECK 4329.69
11/09 25030 406.25 CK CHECK 3923.44
11/15 25110 360.00 CK CHECK 3563.44
11/15 25120 80.00 CK CHECK 3483.44
11/15 2501 50.00 CK CHECK 3433.44
PF1 - PAGE FWD
ESC-CLEAR SCREEN. ALT-F2-PRINT SCREEN
■
ALT -X=EXIT
/ Et9I NEI :I 10001 '01 •no
IMII 12/10/04 DDA STATEMENT HISTORY
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN OR ACCOUNT 1.1
GHISLAINE MAXWELL OR ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ DATE LAS srArEmbw.1
HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNT DATE THIS STATEMENT
DDA TRANSACTIONS
10.02.11 PAGE 2
11/23/U4
12/10/04
BEGINNING CHECKS/OTHER DEBITS DEPOSITS/OTHER CREDITS
BALANCE NBR TOTAL AMOUNT NBR TOTAL AMOUNT
0.00 19 11614.78 4 17440.24
DATE CK NBR AMOUNT TP TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION
ENDING
BALANCE
5825.46
BALANCE
11/16 25O74, 1135.03 CK CHECK 2298.41
11/16 2509/ 803.24 CK CHECK 1495.17
11/16 25064, 344.91 CK CHECK 1150.26
11/16 250840, 125.24 CK CHECK 1025.02
11/16 2510e 110.00 CK CHECK 915.02
11/17 2514 40 80.00 CK TELLER CASHED CHECK 835.02
11/18 10000.00 CR INCOMING WIRE CREDIT 10835.02
11/18
11/18"
10.00 DB INCOMING WIRE FEE el f
402500.00 CK TELLER CASHED CHECK
10825.02
8325.02
11/22 2513 tool 2500.00 CK CHECK 5825.02
11/23 0.44 CR IOD INTEREST PAID 5825.46
LAST PAGE
ESC-CLEAR SCREEN
PF2 - PAGE BKWD
ALT-F2=PRINT SCREEN ALT-X=EXIT E 7
E 'd WVEI:ll pOol
. •
IMI3 12/10/04
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN OR
GHISLAINE MAXWELL OR ALFREDO
HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNT
DDA STATEMENT INQUIRY
ACCOUNT I
10.02.31 PAGE 1
RODRIGUEZ DATE THIS STATEMENT 22/10/04
DATE LAST STATEMENT 11/23/04
DDA TRANSACTIONS*****
BALANCE CHECKS/OTHER DEBITS DEPOSITS/OTHER CREDITS BALANCE
LAST STATEMENT NMI TOTAL AMOUNT NBR TOTAL AMOUNT THIS STATEMENT
5825.46 10 9038.14 1 10000.00 6787.32
DATE CX NEM AMOUNT TY TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION BALANCE
11/30 2515 4" 125.00 CHECK 5700.46
12/03 251640 1600.00 CHECK
12/03 2517 or 549.29 CHECK 3551.17
12/06 10000.00 INCOMING WIRE CREDIT
12/06 10.00 INCOMING WIRE FEE
12/06 02000.00 TELLER CASHED CHECK 11541.17
12/07 25210P 517.74 CHECK
12/07 25224. 210.00 CHECK
12/07 2518e 101.03 CHECK 10712.40
12/08 2519 er 2925.08 CHECK
12/08 • 1000.00 TELLER CASHED CHECK (CO Avg 1.",) 6787.32
ESCCLEAR SCREEN ALT-F2-PRINT SCREEN ALT -X-EXIT E 7
6 '4 f 491 *oN MAI :II 6002
es a
Fay
The Oldest and Largest Shed Manufacturer on Florida

Demand the Best.
Proven Quality. As the industry leader, TED'S SHEDS has
been establishing the standards for the manufacture of strong,
durable portable storage buildings since 1970.

• The Oldest and Largest Portable Building Manufacturer
in Florida.
• The Home of the Lifetime Warranty — the industry's only
limited lifetime warranty against corrosion, termites, and
decay.

• The first trademarked product in the industry — and the
first to provide written warranty and registered serial
number for each building.
S SHEDS Storage Systems
and Solutions
Custom designed, 100,000 sq. ft manufacturing center in Fort Myers includes
corporate offices, design and engineering, state-of-the-art manufacturing plant,
and fleet services.
Your Best Value. All TED'S SHEDS locations deal
directly with the manufacturer. The close working
relationships with the manufacturer enable TED'S
SHEDS to provide:

• The Best Price — of any comparable product.
• Total Quality Control — every step of the way.
• Personal Attention — including quick response to
special requests and custom designed buildings.
Professional Service. TED'S SHEDS is dedicated
to providing long term service to their individual
customers... past, present and future.

• All TED'S SHEDS are delivered and installed by
competent, trained crews — at no extra charge.
• Company owned fleet of trucks assures timely
delivery of all models, sizes and colors to your
local Ted's Sheds store.
• We are committed to providing practical
solutions through knowledgeable sales, repair,
rental and relocation services.
SKU 210-889
The Everlast Storage Shed WM
WALL #2
WAL #1
Ii
5 WALL #3
m
dagraw ah ira.#
Width of base (W)
NOTE: Applies to 12' wide models only.
Width measurement (W) is from outside eave to outside save.
Floor base measurement is reduced by 1'.
e•ae.r.e.•  emir Our
Decide where you
want the door
and windows:
DOOR in wall # kig)
WINDOW in wall # # # #
We'll
slivered and professionally installe
experienced crews.
Vtmake it easy for you!
CALL TOLL FREE 1-800-79-DEPOT and we'll
answer your questions and guide you through the
ordering of your custom storage building. Visit the
SPECIAL SERVICES counter for information on
permitting. Not intended for commercial use.
Select the size you need:
8'W x 8'L = $1,449.00
8W x 10'L = $1,599.00
8'W x 12'L = 1,799.00
10'W x 8'L = 1,639.00
700'W x 10'L = 1,839.00
10'W x 12'L = 2,049.00
SHED (BASE PRICE FROM ABOVE) / 1(
includes one door (48"W x 72"H), one window
(22"W x 27"H), and two vents (16"W x 4"H).
ADDITIONAL WINDOWS (22"W x 27"H) $50.00 ea.
RAMP (4'W x 8"H x 4'L—buildings 10' x 12' and under)  $70.00
RAMP (4'W x 12"H x 6'L—buildings over 10' x 12')  $95.00
RAMP (6'W x 8"H x 4'L—buildings 10' x 12' and under)   $85.00
RAMP (6'W x 12"H x 6'L—buildings over 10'x 12') $125.00
UPGRADE TO DOUBLE DOORS (72"W x 72"H) .a130.0O)
NOTE: Total price is subject to Florida sales tax.
State Certified by the State of Florida Department of
Community Affairs (DCA), certifying that it complies with
the new 2001 Florida Building Code.
10'W x 16'L = 2,699.00
10'W x 20'L= 3,099.00
12'W x 121. = 2,389.00
12'W x 16'L = 2,999.00
12'W x 20'L= 3,449.00
Choose your colors:
(Select one color from each column)
COLOR WALLS TRIM ROOF POOR
Aqua O O O N/A
Black O O O N/A
Buckskin O O O O
Burgundy O O O N/A
Brown O O O N/A
Cream O O O O
Dark Gray O O O N/A
Evergreen O O O N/A
Hickory Moss O O O N/A
Ivy Green O O O N/A
Lagoon Blue O O O N/A
Light Gray O O O O
Medallion Blue O O O N/A
Mill Finish O O O N/A
Peach O O O N/A
Pink a o o N/A
Red o o o N/A
Royal Blue o o o N/A
Sage o o O N/A
Taupe o o o N/A
Terracotta  O O O N/A
Timbertone o o o N/A
White O I2 LTI IB
Yellow o O o N/A
SHUTTER color matches trim color.
Florida's oldest and largest manufacturer of portable storage buildings, since 1970.
/6P3
AT-HOME SERVICE* MARKETS 2. 4. 25. 30 SHEDS

• Ideal for workshop; garden shed, or all kinds of storage!
Shown with buckskin walls, buckskin roof, cream trim and cream door.
ATTRACTIVE.
Color coordinated trim, lap-style
siding, and decorative window
shutters for enduring beauty.
PRACTICAL.
Window with screen provides
light and ventilation.
FAST!
Usually delivers in 2-3 weeks.
1 YEAR WARRANTY
DURABLE.
Aluminum roof, siding and trim
will not rust. Sturdy door will not
rot or warp. Lumber selected and
treated to resist rot and termites.
LOW MAINTENANCE.
Roof, siding and trim never need
painting.
BUILT FOR LASTING ENJOYMENT
AND VALUE.
CALL 1-800-79-DEPOT FOR ALL THE DETAILS!
Florida's oldest and largest manufacturer of portable storage buildings, since 1970. AT-HOME SERVICEI SHEDS
Choose from a wide range of wall,
trim and roof colors, in solid and
wood grain patterns. Available on
all aluminum models.
L Tuffy
Quality and versatility make this model
a favorite for residential settings plus a
wide range of commercial applications.
Available in single or double-wide
configurations, with your choice of
door styles and many design options.

• Basic single-wide plan is
available from 4'W x 4'L up
to 14W x 50'L
• Single or double doors
• Single hung windows in a
variety of sizes and styles
Classic
Decorative shutters, eaves, and colonial style windows combine
to create the appearance of a permanent building, custom
designed to complement your home. The door and window
options provide the access, light and ventilation suitable for
workshops, utility buildings and all manner of storage.

• From 6W x 4'L up to 14W x 50'L
TED'S SHEDS
WAITED
LIFETIME WARRANTY
44tr?ritl .,Yet
ALL SIZES ARE NOMINAL
.S . 4-
g••••4•''' •
Ige.,45.4;
, • TROD SHEDS . LIMITED e"
LIFETIME WARRANTY
Many door and window styles,
sizes and trim options allow you
to customize your TED'S SHEDS
to your specific needs — and
your site.
Big on style and on space, the Double
Wide model accommodates cars,
boats, trailers, — you name it, and is a
permanent attractive addition to any
home or business.

• From 16W x 10'L up to 28'W x 1001
• Steel garage doors available in
widths from 6W up to 16'W
Shingle Roofs, in a variety of
colors, are available on most
models!
The gambrel roof provides greater ceiling height along the side
walls, while having the exterior appearance of a traditional
American barn. The style is further expressed in the decorative
double doors, louvered air vent, wood grain siding, and colonial
style windows with decorative shutters. The Deluxe Barn is ideal
for workshops, lawn equipment, recreational gear, and a variety
of agricultural and commercial uses.

• From 4'W x 4'L up to 14W x 50'L
• Flexible door and window placement
ALL SIZES ARE NOMINAL
The simple design of the Cape model assures
maximum storage area in a compact plan,
making it a popular choice in many residential
settings, including manufactured home
communities and RV parks.
The Cape is available with the roof pitched
down to the rear, providing maximum headroom
at the front... or with the roof pitched down to
the front, for maximum storage height at the rear.
.

• -.„.4 - ..2 TEO'S SHEDS I;ki k:
"" tIMITELI '
LIFETIME WARRANTY
The choice of roof pitch, with the wide range of
color combinations available, allows the Cape
to blend easily with existing walls and buildings.

• From 6' wide x 4' deep up to
50' wide x 14' deep
• Door may be centered or offset to side
• Decorative shutters and choice of
window sizes available
Built-in shelving and workbenches are
popular options - available on all
TED'S SHEDS!
Built to the same rugged standards
as all other TED'S SHEDS, the
Doghouse provides a durable, low
maintenance, well ventilated home
for man's best friend.

• From 2'W x 3'L up to 6'W x 6'L
ALL SIZES ARE NOMINAL.
In addition to long-lasting aluminum siding, TED'S SHEDS also offers
models with solid wood or vinyl siding. These attractive storage buildings
are all constructed with the same high quality wood flooring, wall and roof
framing that has made TED'S SHEDS the most enduring name in portable
storage buildings.
Allwood TM
The Allwoodul model, with genuine, solid wood
siding, looks right at home in the country or in a
suburban landscape.

• From 4'W x 4'L up to 14'W x 501_
• Aluminum or fiberglass shingle roof
• Reverse board and batten (RB & B) or T1-11

• Available unfinished, so you can stain or
paint to exactly match your home
it
ALL SIZES ARE NOMINAL.
Avalon
The Avalon model features durable vinyl siding.
With a wide choice of siding colors and
coordinated aluminum trim packages, this model
may appear as a custom addition to your home.

• From 4'W x 4'L up to 14W x 50'L
• Aluminum or fiberglass shingle roofing
• Door may be centered or offset to the side

• Decorative shutters and choice of window
sizes available
Property improvements the whole family will enjoy!
TED'S SHEDS produces beautiful, custom gazebos and children's playsets.
A wide range of sizes, styles and optional features are available and are all
built, io na ly installed by our experienced crews. Call
toll -free for brochures or visit the nearest showcase location.
Why is TED'S SHEDS your best value?
Direct questions from customers help explain the importance of quality
in the selection of your portable storage building.
"What should l look for in a quality shed?"
Integrated construction, using the most durable materials and
engineered fasteners, will satisfy the State of Florida Department
of Community Affairs (DCA) building code and provide the
greatest strength and long lasting service. TED'S SHEDS feature:

• Framed construction of #2 grade
Southern Yellow Pine, not light
weight Spruce or Fir.
• Framing spaced in 16" or 24"
increments, per customer preference.

• Heavy duty 4" x 6" corner post
constructed of 3 — 2" x 4" studs
with 1/2 " plywood spacer for
maximum strength and rigidity.

• Inside of siding coated white — for
cleaner, brighter interior appearance
(with most colors).
"How will my shed
hold up in Florida's
climate?"
TED'S SHEDS most popular
sheds are specifically
designed for Florida's
demanding environment.
Key factors include:

• Aluminum siding is installed with stainless steel
screws and WILL NOT RUST'
• Exclusive ridge vent, available to release heat through
the roof.

• Mobile Home Door for a secure fit, — that will not rot
or warp.
• Weather-seal around door and foam-seal around the
sides and roof, to keep out bugs and blowing rain.

• Pressure treated sill plate, flooring, joists and skids
to resist bugs and rot.
rr
Wall &
Truss Tie
'Does my shed meet Florida's
hurricane codes?"
YES! TED'S SHEDS are engineered to comply with the
State of Florida Department of Community Affairs (DCA)
regulations. The sheds are engineered to withstand wind
loads up to 150 m.p.h.!

• Installation includes heavy-duty "mobile home type"
anchors.
• Skids are connected with hurricane clips to the
floor joists.

• Wall studs are
connected with
galvanized steel
straps to the floor
and roof trusses.
• Galvanized steel truss
plates are hydraulically
installed.
"Will my shed require much maintenance?"
Years of rigorous testing and field experience have led
to TED'S SHEDS insistence on low maintenance
construction details:

• Concrete foundation blocks, so skids don't contact
the ground.
• 3/4" pressure treated, tongue and groove "Sturdi-
Floor" plywood, not untreated, poor quality wood
covered with paint or copper fox.
• Pressure treated 2" x 4" sill plates. • • Nails, not staples, are used to fasten the wood
together.
• Maintenance free aluminum siding and roofs, with
baked enamel paint available in more than 25 colors!
What is covered by the warranty?
As the oldest portable building manufacturer in Florida,
TED'S SHEDS understands the importance of standing
behind the product... and puts that commitment in writing.
Most importantly, the company has the experience, the
resources, and the willing attitude to keep that commitment,
and to provide exemplary service, long after delivery and
installation of every high quality TED'S SHEDS building.
Serial
Number
SHEDS
Fort Myers
Florida
Building Registration
A metal registration plate, inscribed with the serial
number that corresponds to your original purchase
documents, is installed on your TED'S SHEDS
building, certifying that it is an authentic, quality
built TED'S SHEDS product.
Manufacturer's Limited
Lifetime Warranty
TED'S SHEDS guarantees its workmanship
to be free of defects and its aluminum and
paint against corrosion for a lifetime. It is the
only limited lifetime warranty in the industry
against corrosion, termites, and decay.
Confidence in the quality of the product
and the desire to maintain customer
satisfaction and loyalty allow TED'S SHEDS
to offer the most complete warranty in the business.
Certificate of Origin
This certificate documents the original purchase of
an authentic TED'S SHEDS building and includes
written confirmation of the manufacturer's serial
number.
STATE OF FLORIDA
Department of Community Affairs
Manufactured Buildings Program
Residential Lawn Storage Buildings
Number RLS-0 11284
This imignia certifies that this structure is in compliance with the
Manufactured Buildings Act
(Pan ly Cattalo 553. FS.)
Do Nor Remove This Insignia
State Certification
This insignia is issued by the State of Florida Department
of Community Affairs (DCA) and certifies that your
TED'S SHEDS building complies with the new Florida
Building Code. Manufactured storage buildings that
do not bear this insignia cannot be permitted by
any Florida building department.
a tregueOzeact  .
ate reente  2: 4  afer Ce
nrpgrft sq
.Zu:`‘tw• P"%fmt: rd°4 1At  r1, ‘ *.rw ,tu r, ,*4tft•
t, . 1/4 •ftu:ut _. nft
w•et• wr3/4" awa w
4 u1 '.:‘ rtww,
, -z.
4441 :m . ". " ,tw ri.^wr utft4.• . '" •••.*
•••*.'°•• : 4w a • S ' i.C.:un --ft - •.r. s'ea .1/4 tu -
.
a rts u 4.,
ct-Ctw
cc
Sao
Pode
4 3/4 41, 4• r•r•
b.1/4
4'W7 . 1%.0
7714t "4 " 41 .4 t gai
ITh.r e net“."c ti nft.
The
rEggrettb
%net
neo kIr211yji  OA?S t  LIDINGs
TeDis
MANIJESHEbs CeRript  Acrimi INC.
poiiittst4 e tirre or  oft
tleteoboofpre rh,.
l'ebe*.1‘8.,, #cettigys
r
1.424, VD8 so  'Tee gymvertt it aiw
Alen* Ca Gaff ECis 4.4  OF
ra: E4S7144800R ork ,P4.12°WSan "wise 1/4  _ 2349684; Ft  338100000 areAvevue
Sedarrt.
Sized  legges

SW. 72
on.  V4 MaNgft tunt, C<Agsge
March •a z.,
7 4"414inftuactwern. 2003
sZilwaieen sresru cerreass _. ener, wi ThertUrp aure -ren ep  -wig*
ournpreem_notae wept amain_ secrag„Instnauerp
ofsaro ** en,
pes,Thanu6eC7llardrporintSe -" Defter/ 04h marrogamv-well'a6.2"Eicar es 7"lortorne gawp e (kluenrag oki thar4 enanYoSZI
Th3/4 4 elut otherwthe
Egg.
SHEDS www.tedssheds.com
Call for the locatingial store:
Toll Free
TED'S SHEDS is a federally registered trademark,
No. 1152115, Apra 28, 1991.
t • •t• • ••• • • e• • ••• • • • • • • • • • •• • s, • • • • ...... • • • •
PAY 70
boost
WK
ifitAL
antler
nu MOCK
MATSU
Mgt
=UMW
biteCaet2Mi etZte.W •are t44.I•L"WiL
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
HOUSENQI-D ACCOUNT
358 EL erlILLO WAY -
PALM BEACH. FL 33 480
Pay to the
Order of •
For
Date
"""" • •  • • . .3z01.1
$
24ccotaNIAL HANK" pw„, Beath. Hula COB'S Connection 14177-b02•2205
Dollars 8 rar ..
8 )3 VIA% M to UMMA S° 6 3 "3  2 2 211: 2 5 64 -adve-craeon-esztiowastrarer.,,S
2  . . • •••• ,• .. • fir ••••••••.•.• .6. • ••••... .e• • • • • •
•••••...•••••••••
•M • 2065

• •
) Dag
• •- • ••AYTO
FOR
mucerr
—akar .
a TVS MC.
OW*
0 sew mamma I I COKW4,01 --
RAIAntY
• frorearforranneakaorsomosissitals
JEFFREY E. 'EPSTEIN
HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNT • •
• •
444II:tintkOSAY I "•:<"•••“:11 •••••,•.: • ov. -.1.. PALS! 8EACH. FL wine
-Pay tothe— . . $, Order of  •• . 4.•••••• • •
Dollard El rtia:
COLONIAL BANICK. Pon Beach. Florkta
24 I ♦ Colonial COnnociion 14177-5C0-2266
For
1:0631, 32221:
••c4A1Atia$0:....:44>4•erail..A .
2565 ^•3•TS-IWCOn.tadatirertar'aV. tbiCi an at ti
4t•unanntu. rup.,f2

JEJan. IE. 20)5..n1 :20AlloR
aBISLAINE MAXWELL OR ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNT
4 BEGINNING
BALANCE
5825.46
OVA STATEMENT HISTORY
ACCOUNT
DATE LAS
DATE THIS STATEMENT  DDA TRANSACTIONS
CHECKS/OTHER DEBITS DEPOSITS/OTHER CREDITS NBA TOTAL AMOUNT NOR TOTAL AMOUNT 11 9438.14 1 10000.00
DA TE OUNT TP 11/30 125.00 CK 12/03 1600.00 CR 12/03 549.29 CK 12/06 10000.00 CR 12/06 10.00 DB 12/06
12/07
12/07
12/07
12/08
12/08
12/13
PP1 - PAGE PWD
CK NBR
V-0e0cic 2000.00
2521 517.74
2522 210.00
2518 101.03
2519 2925.08
'?;.-v.k!•Ct.r.ockc 1000.00
2524 400.00
CX
CX
CX
CX
CI
CX
CZ
TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION
CHECK
CHECK
CHECK
INCOMING WIRE
INCOMING WIRE
TELLER CASHED
CHECK
CHECK
CHECK
CHECK
TELLER CASHED
CHECK
CREDIT
PEE
CHECK
CHECK (T-
GE
01/18/05
ENDING
BALANCE
6387.32
BALANCE
5700.46
4100.46
3551.17
13551.17
13541.17
Cnh 11541.17
11023.43
10813.43
10712.40
7787.32
6787.32
6387.32
JEJan. 15. 20054.1 I: 2000R GHIBLAINE MAXWELL OR ALFREDO 'HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNT
ULJA HISTORY
ACCOUNT RODRIGUEZ DATE LAS TEmENT
DATE THIS STATEMENT  DDA TRANSACTIONS
No.325P.2._LE8GE
01/18/05
*BEGINNING
BALANCE
5825.46
DATE CK NBR 12/14 2526
CHECKS/OTHER DEBITS DEPOSITS/OTHER CREDITS ENDING NBR TOTAL AMOUNT NBR TOTAL AMOUNT BALANCE 22 18829.20 2 20000.00 
6996.26
AMOUNT TP TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION -k /BALANCE 5000.00 CK TELLER CASHED CHECK. „, ' 4- 1387.32 12/14
12/15
12/15
12/15
12/15
12/16
12/17
12/20
12/20
12/21,
12/21
PF1 - PAGE
FWD PF2
1000.00 cx TELLER CASHED CHECK 74A17 Lem, 10000.00 CR INCOMING WIRE CREDIT 600.00 DB FORCE PAY DEBIT
30.00 DB NSF CHARGE
10.00 DB INCOMING HIRE FEE
503.50 CIE CHECK
113.42 DB TIRES PLUS FT LA EFT 1300.00 Cx CHECK
420.00 CI CHECK
260.44 CX CHECK
153.70 CX CHECK
— PAGE B D
387.32
10387.32
9787.32
9757.32
9747.32
9243.82
9130.40
7830.40
7410.40
7149.96
6996.26
JEJan. IE. ?Willi:20O . J.ittik.N.J. 0R ACCOUNTHISTORYORISLAINE MAXWELL OR ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ DATE LAST EMENT 'HqusExoLD 
ACCOUNT DATE THIS STATEMENT  DDA TRANSACTIONS
BEGINNING CHECKS/OTHER DEBITS DEPOSITS/OTHER CREDITS BALANCE NBR TOTAL AMOUNT NBR TOTAL AMOUNT 5825.46 23 19561.72 3 
20000.53
01/18/05
.P PAGE
ENDING
BALANCE
6264.27
DATE CK NBR AMOUNT TP TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION BALANCE 12/22 2520 732.52 CX CRICK 6263.74 12/22 0.53 CR IOD INTEREST PAID
6264.27
LAST'PAGE PF2 - PAGE BKWD
Js.Jan. It 2005il 1:200 0R OHISLAINR MAXWELL OR ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNT
LAJA slATEMENT INQUIRY
ACCOUNT
DATE THIS STATEMENT
DATE LAST STATEMENT DDA TRANSACTIONS
' BALANCE CHECKS/OTHER DEBITS DEPOSITS/OTHER CREDITS LAST STATEMENT NBR TOTAL AMOUNT NBR TOTAL AMOUNT 6264.27 11 7650.65
1 10000.00
DATE CK NBR 12/23 2534
12/24 2532
12/30
12/30
12/31 02(41,) 2535
01/03 ` 2538
01/04 2541
01/04 2537
01/06 2540
01/07 til04,)2542
01/10A , 2539
01/11 2543
PF1 - PAGE FWD
AMOUNT TY
160.00
495.71
10000.00
10.00
2000.00
2100.00
166.99
132.29
65.00
2000.00
180.50
340.16
o E s
01 18 05
12/22/04
BALANCE
THIS STATEMENT
8613.62
TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION
CHECK
CHECK
INCOMING WIRE CREDIT
TELLER CASHED CHECK* IleerRyereAlt
INCOMING WIRE PEE
TELLER CASHED CHECK o ZNekoma.
CHECK
CHECK
CHECK
TELLIR'CKSRED CHECK
CHECK
CHECK
BALANCE
6104.27
5608.56
15598.56
13598.56
11498.56
11199.28
letit11134.28
CA 9134.28
8953.78
8613.62

• •
JEJan.O. 2005;i11:20AMDR . . GHISLAINE MAXWELL OR
HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNT
BALANCE
.LAST STATEMENT • 6264.27
UVA bilii.GMtNT INQUIRY
ACCOUNT
DATE THIS
DATE LAST STATEMENT *****DDA TRANSACTIONS*****
CHECKS/OTHER DEBITS DEPOSITS/OTHER CREDITS NBR TOTAL AMOUNT NBR TOTAL AMOUNT 16 11995.76 1. 10000.00
ALFREDO RODRIGUEZ
12/22/04
E 2
BALANCE
THIS STATEMENT
4268.51
DATE CK NBR AMOUNT TY TRANSACTION DESCRIPTION BALANCE 01/12 2547 1349.36 CHECK 01/12 2545 1243.32 CHECK 01/12 2546 
423.87 CHECK 01/12 2544 370.06 CHECK 5227.01 01/13 2548 958.50 CHECK
4268.51
LAST PAGE
.#4.4
PF2 - PAGE BKWD
6-ere,/ Cam)
(04 fro -c c2, 2
l2lr72e,A
Jeffrey E. Epstein

->e-frA-m a on
/ma/714

•
-1kk)
FIN. W≥L / -
too
Address / Telephone Sheet
# 358 El Grillo Way, Palm Beach Fl, 33480
Name Address
ReAt
Telephone/Fs=

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein (NYSG LLC ) Office
457, Madison Avenue 4th Floor
New York, NY 10021. Email
Ms. Ghislaine Maxwell Email
Accountants
(st-ater • Bella Klein-Accountan Email
(Pe Ay Ces "Rev)
Assistants
E Sec) Email
Email
Email
Keith Blumberg Email
KEZINCSI
la tLIAtt•tAl
Mark Lumberg
Residences of Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
9 East 71a  Street,
New York NY 10021

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
Ms. Ghislaine Maxwell
Staff
House Manager Jojo
House Manger Lynn
Staff Phone
Chef Brent Tindall
a
F.
0)
r
) -7 f‘A- iviSeivi4c4e2
P)
(F)
(P)
F)
C)
C)
H)
P)
F)
C)
H)
a itio k COI LO 02 6
116 East 65i°.Strcet
New York NY 10021
Ms Ghislaine Maxwell Email
Staff
r House Managers
358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach
Florida 33080
Email
Email
(P)
(F)

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein I P)
F)
Ms Ghislaine Maxwell P)
F)
P)
P)
C)
C)
(Gardner) M- F H)
C)
Landscape designer, Checks the garden O)
and
Pilots
House cleaning service
handles all cleaning/laundry
H)
II)
C)
C)
arc well versed in supervising and shopping fora when necessary
fifties_
Black Mercedes 600
Black Suburban
Mercedes Sports Convertible
Front
Back
•
H)
C)
Residences
Zorro Ranch
49, Zorro Ranch Road,
Stanley, New Mexico 87056

Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
Ms Chislaine Maxwell
Staff
Office
Home
=M ime = MT) Home
Manolito aPager)
Little St. James
O0 Financial Trust Company
6100, Red Hook Quarters, Suite B3,

St. Thomas, USVI 00802.
Mr. Jeffrey Epstein
Ms. Chislaine Maxwell
Staff
at
22 Avenue, Foch, Apt 2DD,
Paris. France 75116.
Tel:
Fax:
Staff
London
44 Kinnerton Street
London SW1X8ES
Tel:
Fax:
Sta
e C)
(H)
(C)
(F)
Palm Beach Contractors
General Plumbing
Customer Service representative
Electrical
Reel Power Inc (electrician)
Gates
Samco Systems (owner)
Service gate switch: above garage door contriplhen round light is on
Front gate switch: just above the telephone outlet kitchen area
Garage doors
The Door Smith Inc
Telephones
Southern Bell (repairs)
Internal Phone system ( NEC)
Repair and Programming
Alarm System
Benham Industries Inc
Locksmith
Wilson & Rowan
MEI
•
A/C Maintenance
John C Cassidy 24 hr service
Handyman
Carlos (ca/penter) 4vikol Contact=
reinta.
Landscape
Alan Stopeck Garden maintenance
x Pest Control
Palm Beach Exterminator
Irrigation
Dolphin Sprinkle
Pool Heating
National Pool Service
Pool Maintenance
Hack Pool Service
Tree 'minims
Country Wide Trees
t2
When needed
Monday/ Thursday
Twice, summer/winter "Ma
Carpet Cleaners
Stanley Steamers wall to wall
Merry Rug area rug
A\arts-, - 151 •
post - ocC; • •
Cable
Adelphia cable
Bottled Water.
Bishop water company
Upholsterer
Cable TV
Avion water
as
Gas Energy Inc (Joe Di Giovanni) all gas repairs)
Laund ui ment
am er
l irrage
Storage USA
5580, Okeechobee Blvd
Unit 6218
Grocery & General Household items
General Grocery
Publix
265, Sunset Ave
Gourmet food
C' est si bon
289, Sunset Blvd
es
2401 PGA Blvd Take 95 North to PGA Blvd
Too Jays Gravelox/ Nova sliced salmon
Green Pharmacy
151., N County Road
Flowers
ExtraloughElowers
Hardware
Home Depot
Sewell Hardware
528, Clematis Street
Newspapers
Main Street News
255, Royal Poinciana Way
Post Office
401, South County Road,
Car Detailing
Taxi Service/Limo
FedEx (Monday & Thursday)
Recycling Every ursday 6AM to 5PM
Trash collection M-F once a day Early Morning
Cars
Mercedes of Palm Beach
Chevrolet
Auto Repairs Gray Sunoco 340 South County
Nestor Auto 2600, Florida Avenue
GasolineCrray Sunoco
Contact
Ameglow si‘driE-Rs
■
Ntav%
.50114-
- trrk -
_ Ace
62641?Ah4

524Y) CO. ;A.M.
S all?‘
Electrician Energ Efficient Electric
Tel:
ciAm1/4.0%.0.4rs_s2i .
Exterminator Palm Beach Exterminating
Tel:
Contact isp
First Mon ay of every month at 10:30am
Also use for termite tent
Garden Service
Efflorescence
e ington,
Tel:
.
Tel:
Part-time help. Billed through
In residence: Daily from 6.30am
Not in residence: Mon - Fri from 2pm - 5pm
Also maintains Mrs Epstein's property on
Saturday mornings.
Garage Doors The D mi .
a aton, FL 33431
Tel:
Gates Reich Metal Fabricato
Tel:
Back door gate switch - above garage door
controls. When open, round red light is on.
Front door gate switch - In telephone outlet
above the kitchen telephone
Irrigation • Dolphin Sprinkler Inc
Tel:
Landscape Spraying Academy Services
Tel:
Arrange through.
Locksmith Wilson R wan L k mi hs
West  a m eac , L 33401
Tel:
Painter Tel: Bill
MAIL & DELIVERY SERVICES
FedEx a Account No:
Drop-off box is next to Palm Beach National
Bank on Worth Avenue
Post Office
West Palm Beac ,
Tel:
MAINTENANCE
Air Conditioning Cassi Air Conditioning
est am each, F
Tel: 5 z
Monthly service contract Pm., P.m-
First Monday of every mogp ft k I `-: •
c\eciN VACAR")
.c\ \\eV SO NOAC)
Awnings American Awnin. Corhpany
West Palm Beach, FL 33405
Tel:
61 It. .  I)
'
Cable Service Adel • hia Cable
West Palm Beach, FL 33407
Tel:
cc_ 4
Carpenter Tel C et- n•
Carpet Cleaners
"Nj
Stanley Steamers
Tel:
0 — Wall to wall C44 LA
Merry Ru s
Tel: IIII
Loose rugs
Computers
New  NY 10022
Tel:
Palm Beach consuttanls
Tel:
Ch 1/44 ‘ ...41/4I21
TRAVEL
Pilots S
Cell)
Home)
Mr Epstein's planes Jet Aviation
Procedure for leaving cars at the airport:
Leave car at Jet Aviation landing strip
Leave the keys in the car
Advise Jet Aviation
Tail #909JE or Tail #908JE
They will tag and pull car to plane upon arrival
Ms Maxwell's plane Raytheon On2te5orl Vo',
'0 1  DT V\c3k,
S
Contract No: .Air 4 7O  a 2
Tail # ...TA
Always a Beech Jet or Hawker
Commercial Airlines Air France
American
British Airways
Continental
Delta
South African Airways
United
US Air
‘v ,Ay Men" @6%)
a\L /work),  (Li.
BICYCLES
BANKING
Account No:
Send to or reconciliation
$1,000 etty as Float
Mongoose Crossway 450
Raleigh Aluminium 300
Mercedes Benz
Cignal Sports Bike
Schwinn World
Huffy Santa Fe
Raleilat
BOOKSTORES
Newspapers Publix Su. -r Market
'aim Beach, FL 33480
Tel:
Magazines Main Street News
'atm Beach, FL 33480
Tel:
ouse Cleaning Services
CLEANING SERVICE
1.11 Every Tuesday and Wednesday
Coil. I. 8:00am - 4:00pm
' Is (NM
AINMENT
The Breakers
Palm Reach, FL 33480
Tel:
Renew car park stickers every September
Comedy Corner
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Tel
The Mar-a-Lago Club
Palm Beach, FL 33480
Tel:
EMERGENCY 911
ALARM SYSTEM Benham
cc clow• A
FIRE RESCUE
HOSPITAL Good Samaritan Hos •ital
T est Palm Beach, FL 33401
a
POISON
POLICE
VETERINARIAN Island Animal Hos ital
a m ach, FL 33480
=MB
Neighbouring House Manager
who can be called in emergencies tt9‘s.00,03.tc‘a
MS MAXWELL Portable
Home
Port
rL Itoi:"SZ YIN . \
VEHICLES '
Mercedes Benz 600
2001 Black 4 6
40„.... Licence: f p/
Li Q. 0 i O
Rear
t
.0- Y.
k\.......c
Mercedes Benz of Palm Beach
4000 Okeechobee Boulevard
West Palm Be ch FL 33409
Att:
Tel:
Mercedes Benz 600
1997 Black
Licence:
Rear
Front
Mercedes Benz 600 Cony
1998 Silver
Licence: C-"°
4/rifr Afee,
' One 4
n c I
Rod?' 54
Suburban N-O
2001 Black 9
P Licence: 4 4/
..Tel:
R er Dean Chevrolet
West Pam each, FL 33409
Crysler Mini Van
1996 'White
Licence: M Ge
Nestor Auto Re irs
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Tel:
1993 Green
c\s„......„........bra Grand
= West Palm Beach, FL 33401
Tel:
Volvo
1998 Gold
Mrs pstein
.'
.-
.7"
/
Volvo Palm Beach
West Palm Beach, FL 33417
,--
Tel.Ma
•
Oil Well
West Palm Beach, FL 33405
Tel:
Oil change every 3 000 milei
Registration, insurance and yearly inspection papers to be kept in the glove compartment of each vehicle
Spare keys are kept in the key box in the office
Muvico Parisian Ci Place
es am eac , FL 33401
Tel:
STORES
Bishop Water Co
f
Tel:
-Ccaiar- .._V 'y C.: • g ' :•• .
Ukbottled water (large and small). • • ..-
Carmine Giardini's
Palm Beach Gardens, FL 33410
Tel:
Fish, meat, gourmet foods
C'est Si Bon
emit.. .1.3480
Tel:
Gourmet foods
Publix Super Market
Palm Beach, FL 33.480
Tel:
General, cleaning, toiletries
Wild Oath
West Palm Beach, FL 33405
Tel:
Health Foods
HEALTH & BEAUTY
Pharmacy Greens Pharmac
Palm each. FL 33480
Tel:
Lewis Pharmac
Palm Beach, FL 33480
Tel: 1.1)
UTILITIES
Water Ci of West Palm Beach
a m prings, 33461
Tel:
Water shut-off for entire property is located
next to the mailbox on the sidewalk.
Electricity Florida Power and Light
General Mailing Facility
Miami, FL 33188-0001
Tel:
Gas Florida Gas Com an
est a m Beach, 33401
Tel:
Sewer Ci of West Palm Beach
am prings, 33461
Tel:
Trash Removal C' of West Palm Beach
am prings, 33461
Tel: - tikibe+ :91?
•Wre-3/CCI Ve^CsAk
Daily (Monday -Frida
1Z.ecy c ykrl&S
)
liftuv.i loot }'loo()
Telephone ETC -
TT est Palm Beach, F 33407
Tel:
.- •
I
Bell South
Tel:
Plumber
Crfiern/
1111S
Foster Plumbin
IIIIIIIIIII.409
Tel:IIII
General plumbing repairs
Roto Rooter
fort 1.t.11.11.
Tel:
Blocked drains
Pool Hackl Pools
1 .11.10
h'\CCPC# Tel: \
Monday and Thursday at 10:30am
Clean pool, filter, add salt t../
Tree Trimming
r ,- -
County Wide Tree Service
Tel:
First Monday in May and November
STORAGE
Storage USA 5580 Okeechobee Boulevard
West Palm Beach, FL 33417
Tel:
10 ft x 20 ft unit available
VEHICLES
Car Detailing
Odern tcri? SeRI4 C-C.5
la/
°Mt', 8e,CA
337x 6 tor-A0v.3co2A,PC
a
-
r
, 47. Jeffrey E. Epstein
0 0

JEFFREYE EiSTEIN 2613 HOUSEHOLD ACCOUNT 998 EL IRMO WAY / 0 19.1329/811. :
PALM BEACK PL SSW Oa
.
ord of Tq.Ci.t lin Si'Melnkssyn4 1 $ 2 r5C0Pay to the AOa
itt01147 11 Ye' )Avn (.1)' "leo -  Dollars .8 gm
4as

191416.40 141C" T4'vt#q 1" 651'
3 tron.e.c.voroonia _......... ....A a. sa  .
1.0'631,.1,322 0: 251,3 • , ' , : • .
(41(0
v' 434 you t-0 f C-ov0),-
-‘1\Vt C-6c1.4,4' LvAg 14 \1e. Ltya,As
k\e\it\sfrkn \-0 s tf .“If f6246; 2A.20
27 v‘eacl
1, 0, rnewTemci

Grocery List May 10, 2004
Dairy Products Carmines

• Whole milk gallon
• Skim milk gallon
• Half & Half carton
• Non fat Plain Yogurt
• Eggs
a Danish Butter 6
a  Lost fat cottage Cheese 1
a Cream Cheese whipped 1 pack

• Fresh mozzarella 1 pack
• Parmesan 1 wedge
• Mild Cheddar 1 pound
Juices  all  organic  Carmines
quart 1
- Orange juice

• Mango Juice
Synips
• Nesquik chocolate
• Ilershe3's chocolate
, Sodas & Power aid
- Power Aide 24
• Sprite 12
Diet Coke 12

• Coke 12
Diet Pepsi 12
• Salad dressing
1 a  Hillmans
• Dijon mustard
Dry foods Cm -mines
• Dark Brown Sugar 1
Skippy Peanut butter 2

• Multi Grain Bread 2
• Fresh Bread Carmines 2
Cereals Small boxes
Frosted Flakes, Froot Loop,
Sugar milk, Cheerios, Honey cheerios 6 of each
Corn pops, special K
Fruits (organic) Carmines FJ
z
•
Basket of Figs
Avocados
Bananas bunches2
Oranges
Mangoes
Pineapples
Papaya
Lemon
Lime
Raspberries baskets
Strawberries
Grapes Red! Green baskets
Cherries bags
Nectarines
Melons
Cantaloupe
Vegetables all organic Carmines

• Red Pepper •
• Green Pepper
Celery bag
Carrots bag 1
Tomatoes
Cucumber •
Peeled Garlic bottle
White onion
Broccoli heads 2
Romaine lettuce bags 2
Mixed greens boxes
•
•
•
Meats & Sausages all organic Carmines

• Ham pounds 1
a Bacon pounds 1
• Chicken Breast pounds 3
• • Sliced Salmon Too Js 2
• Fresh Fish 2 pounds
Newspapers Daily in Residence 6.30 AM
Main Street News open at 6.30 AM

• New York Times (daily)
• PB daily news (shingle sheet)
• Wall street Journal (M-F)
• Daily Mail (daily) (Ms Maxwell)
Saturd
others
purchases all Cleaning supplies from Pohl
Grocery List May 10, 2004
Dairy Products Carmines
•
a
•
Whole milk gallon 2
Slim milk gallon
Half & Half carton
Non fat Plain Yogurt quart 1
Eggs
Danish Butter 6
Low fat cottage Cheese 1
Cream Cheese whipped 1 pack
Fresh mozzarella 1 pack
Parmesan 1 wedge
Mild Cheddar 1 pound
Juices  all  organic  Carmines

• Orange juice
• Mango Juice
Simms
• Nesqulk chocolate
c Hershey's chocolate
, Sodas & Power aid
• Power Aide 24

• Sprite 12
• Diet Coke 12
• Coke 12
• Diet Pepsi 12
Salad dressing
1 Nelimans
• Dijon mustard
Div foods Cannines

• Dark Brown Sugar 1
• Skippy Peanut butter 2
c Multi Grain Bread 2
• Fresh Bread Carmines 2
Cereals  Small  boxes
Frosted Flakes, Froot Loop,
Sugar milk, Cheerio; Honey cheerios 6 of each
Corn pops, special K
Fruits (organic) Carmincs PJ
a
•
a IP
a

• a
• •
lk •
•
•
• •
•
Basket of Figs
Avocados
Bananas buncbes2
Oranges
Mangoes
Pineapples
Papaya
Lemon
Lime
Raspberries baskets
Strawberries
Grapes Red/ Green baskets
Cherries bags
Nectarines
Melons
Cantaloupe
Vegetables all organic Carmines

• Red Pepper
• Green Pepper
• Celery bag
• Carrots bag 1
•. Tomatoes
a Cucumber
• Peeled Garlic bottle

• White onion
Broccoli heads 2
• Romaine lettuce bags 2
• Mixed greens boxes
a
Meats & Sausages all organic Carmines
a Ham pounds 1
••  Bacon pounds

• • Chicken Breast pounds 3
• * Sliced Salmon Too Js 2
a Fresh Fish 2 pounds
Newspapers Daily in Residence d.30 AM
Main Street News open at 6.30 AM  •

• New York Times (daily)
• PB daily news (shingle sheet)
a Wall street Journal (M-F)
• Daily Mail (daily) (Ms Maxwell)
Saturdi,
with others
purchases all Cleaning supplies from Pubi
SHEDS Thank you for your business!
Ted's Sheds Call Center will now be assisting
with all aspects of your purchase.
A representative from Ted's Sheds will be contacting yct'
within 3 days after your purchase.
Please contact Ted's
for all future inquiries by calling
East Coast Delivery Schedule Ext. #
West Coast Delivery Schedule -
Customer Service - Ext.
Operations Manager - Ext.
0 6 6
c4-
,, ,2"( ,-7 0 r 1
2.'-'c) Cc/00k 01 7----obkie..7
EFTA00008599 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-11)
United States v. Jeffrey Epstein
June 18, 2019 Presentation
GM_GLSDNY_00000001
9 East 71st Street, New York, New York
GM_GLSDNY_00000002

╭─────────── Page 2, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ 9 East 718‘ Street, New York, New York │
│                                        │
│ os ee Pp ae S                          │
│                                        │
│ GM_GJ_SDNY_00000002                    │
╰────────────────────────────────────────╯

358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida
GM_Gl_SDNY_00000003
4
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000004
5
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000005
6
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000006
7
GM_GLSDNY_00000007
IMPORTANT MESSAGE i,
FOR i dt ? ' -i  • le-  •
DATE St 3 0/ 0 TIME S_G2tel
M.
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN -ii
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CAU- SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
t
St \a ,  II\ 23 er -carniej
t Kn i • t
at SIGNED ma
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000008
IMPORTANT
{
MESSAGE
FOR V. T •
DATE It 04 06 TIME
A.M.
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED ■ PLEASE CALL ■
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH ■
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION ■
MESSAGE
--C VI WO ) -CGYrril c,
SIGNED 1
IS
184
GM_GLSDNY_00000009
a
a a
a a a a
a a a
L.
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
ONE  IIj ILI:41  mum4),Caff
leS
co
TOLIPWCRIPI
Can Its, vett
VONell 10 all 1W
Aran YOJICALL I
Mal CALL
PAIL CALL AGAIN
RUSH
OPIOALonotral
Or& , ?L Arke.
Tir.e4c Call ;Ai ra
M
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
• 1 PAL
ar
TUAO,OMM M =MESON WITCO= VW • r .-nrn
t=Enin L:cse a em
em a
TILDIONID
IMPORTANT MESSAGE I
mini"
oxe lag"
RINI CALL
NIL OALL YAM
MAlm
VIM MUMMY
CMAI PO NO MI
VILMAL10 MN YOU
NIMAMIDITAAIGML
Lieu ou.k.f (r,24i0
4 vi,f
10
GM_GLSDNY_000000 10

╭────────── Page 10, Image 1 ──────────╮
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE [IMPORTANT MESSAGE │
│                                      │
│ nee,                                 │
│                                      │
│ fe Danes                             │
│                                      │
│ woe                                  │
│                                      │
│ Tie er We                            │
│ leet call Lie                        │
│                                      │
│ soe SN                               │
│                                      │
│ WoovovOvLEE                          │
│                                      │
│ PL Piri                              │
│                                      │
│ 3 | [aportant messace.               │
│ 2                                    │
│                                      │
│ 3                                    │
│                                      │
│ 3                                    │
│                                      │
│ Is                                   │
│                                      │
│ [>                                   │
│                                      │
│ la                                   │
│                                      │
│ ae | fs                              │
│                                      │
│ 1? [wars To see vou | — Fre —_       │
│ ee |e a                              │
│ a                                    │
│                                      │
│ fe lees                              │
│ 13 ze =| seem                        │
│                                      │
│ 13 Sri ERE! bees (S a                │
│ | pt AS = a= EP 2                    │
│                                      │
│ GM_GJ_SDNY_00000010                  │
╰──────────────────────────────────────╯

IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR ---- \. T
DATE R nc TIME .._.1 . 1
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU
l_.
WILL CALL AGAIN i
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
\A(' ->pi G ca. In 6 —
a S^-N=0 iI84
GM_GLSDNY_0000001 I
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR -31.-S , ---
DATE I -2- la / TIME er 10 Ag iL,
M
OF
PHONE
MOBILE
TELEPHONED I PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU I WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL I  SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
f .1 ...— ket WC, ?
I
we.' 6
1
C ---- / )\ ----a — a SIGNED 1184 12
GM_GLSDNY_000000 1 2
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR
A.M.
DATE TIME - PM _ .
--
OF
PHONE
MOBILE
TELEPHONED I PLEASE CALL ,-".
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
itSIGNED 1184
GM_GLSDNY_000000 B

╭─ Page 13, Image 1 ──╮
│ | IMPORTANT MESSAGE │
│                     │
│ rm                  │
│ DAT PM.             │
│ ||                  │
│                     │
│ MOBI                │
│                     │
│ GM_GJ_SDNY_00000013 │
╰─────────────────────╯

IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR f r e
DA 9  ° r  TIME //: 50  PM :
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
...-
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL ec
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH I
RETURNED YOUR CALL i SPECIAL ATTENTION
-5/- -t A./ a 6e,MESSAGE
Ac r e fro?
-Sine ;lc ii
,7 Off/ /e
i),.../.  (-or ( a.
,
Ac-I & VA.
ag SIGNED 1184
GM_GLSDNY_000000I4
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR
DA TIME
0 g )
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL _ SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
Her new phone 4,
SIGNED 11fld
GM_GLSDNY_000000 15
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR ..  C •
DATE /d C2-5- TIME 7'  --•c
M
OF
PHO
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
7/reeve / ( 'Cider
SIGNED 1184
GM_GLSDNY_000000 16
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR 7 / f  C
DATE -3  if TIME
/ trA p.mM.
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
-Ar (c.A el g;
O/774 -7o rc-"4., he i C 717/c)kri
X 2,/k2 /reo /v4C,- -e 'tit •
IN SIGNED 1184
GM_GLSDNY_000000 17
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOP
A f,' lisi 'TIME I'M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE \CV \ i -1, ' *•.1 I I
1 ill /
SIGNED a
GNI_GLSDNY_000000 IS

╭──────────── Page 18, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                        │
│                                          │
│ For__/¢ Tt                               │
│                                          │
│ PHONE/                                   │
│ MOBILE                                   │
│                                          │
│ TELEPHONED |X] PLEASE Call               │
│ CAME TO SEE YOU | — [WILLCALLAGAN        │
│ WANTS TO SEEVOU | [ruse]                 │
│ [RETURNED YOUR GauL| | SPECIAL ATTENTION │
│                                          │
│ MESSAGE.                                 │
│                                          │
│ SIGNED___                                │
│                                          │
│ GM_GJ_SDNY_00000018                      │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────╯

IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR i E • i © DATE 5 4 0; TIME ' 7
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED >i< PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE Cr  CI I'l C eirci
She uvotAlellikp 0 sFeak
--},9 y am . .1 behive dLoui
colleAt -
__Shaul I schedule O17
o11 else ?

at. SIGNED.T 1184
GM_GLSDNY_000000 19
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR 4/1, 1 j E.psfet,
,i U 0 r DATE TIME 9: n a M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED V PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
-s:
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE .
-7A) a iti (, Itir Walt k
....A. ( a...A., i v\ . r
a SIGNED 1184 20
GM_GLSDNY_00000020
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR t e LI
2 O 5- 4 / A.M.
DAT TIME cega
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
/'(-  d if
al
(-1---e" 3 rte- 7
a SIGNED 1184
21
GM_GLS DN Y_00000021
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR  C Frit gird
DATE  A •
D o _ 42a-  TIME _ /7 c  ‘A.
I.
;
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
GM_GLSDNY_00000022

╭────────── Page 22, Image 1 ──────────╮
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                    │
│                                      │
│ JEFFREY                              │
│                                      │
│ MOBILE.                              │
│                                      │
│ TELEPHONED VAPLEASE CALL             │
│                                      │
│ WILLCALLAGAIN |                      │
│ [                                    │
│ [                                    │
│                                      │
│ CAME TO SEE YOU                      │
│                                      │
│ |                                    │
│                                      │
│ |                                    │
│ RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION │
│ messace_JHEY ARE                     │
│ AVAILABLE Att WEEK FAL               │
│ AND Piers May ae                     │
│                                      │
│ WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH                │
│                                      │
│ GM_GJ_SDNY_00000022                  │
╰──────────────────────────────────────╯

23
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000023
24
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000024
October 12, 2004 Deposit
10 1.: o.
1^•.r
DE
00 in ts
00
Driver ,c Number
Other 1 D.
r iember s Signature
NCUA
Check depo,, , nro to your
25
GM_GLSDNY_00000025
November 9, 2004 Deposit
kiemsER'S COPY
GOiDORSI

• !Mint
(56 )965.1000
Drivers License Number
Other I.D.
Members Signature
NCUA
Check deposits are subject to your
Credit Union check hold policy.
26
CiNl_al_SDNYJXXXXX)26
Financially Liable Party
Name: JEFFREY E EPSTEIN %
Credit Address: 457 MADISON AVE, NEW YORK NY 16022-6843
Customer Since: 04/03/2004
Photo ID Type:
Photo ID Number:
DOB: 05/05/1950
Contact Name:
Contact Nome Phone:
Contact Home Email:
Account Number:
Name:
Billing Address:
JEFFREY E EPSTEIN
'pato ID State:
4
48N:
irontact Work Phone:
poncact Work Email:
A
Billincri!Party
;;.
457 MADISON AVE. NEW YORK NV:10022-6843
Account Status: Active
MSISDN:
MSISDN Active:
Name:
User Address:
7
••
Billing Cycle: 2
User Infdimation
IMSI:
a IMEI/ESN
457 MADISON AVE , NEW YORK Ni 10022-6843
•
GM_GLSDNY_00000027
January 3, 2004 Calls
952 01103 11:33A NEW YORK NY 1 MIN •Citi Ciao BIN' asibibiL
953 01103 11:34A INCOMING 1 MIN INCLUDED MINUTES
954 01/03 11:49A BOYNTONBCH FL 1 MIN INCLUDED MINUTES
955 01/03 12:19P BOYNTONBCH FL 1 MIN INCLUDED MINUTES
956 01103 1221P WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL
957 01/03 12:24P WPALMBEACH FL 1 MIN INCLUDED MINUTES
958 01103 12:24P BOYNTONBCH FL 1 MIN INCLUDED MINUTES
959 01103 12:27P BOYNTONBCH FL 1 MIN INCLUDED MINUT S
960 01/03 12:45P INCOMING 6MIN INCLUDED MINUTES
961 01/03 12:53P BOYNTONBCH FL 1 MIN INCLUDED MINUTES
962 011O3 12:54P INCOMING 1 MIN INCLUDED MINUTES
963 01103 01.0% • NEW YORK NY 1 MIN UNUM MOBL TO thOBL
964 011O3 02:26P WPALMBEACH FL 1, MIN4. I.IIII.I.Al tt42ELLeT, 914913,L
GM_GLSDN Y_00000028
January 4, 2005 Deposit
MEMBER'S COPY
Pal[D caul'
HUM
\MIND"
(56 ) 965.1000
Driver's License Number
Other I.D.
Member's Signature
NCUA
Check deposits are subject to your
Credit Union check hold policy.
29
GM_GLSDNY_00000029
September 16, 2004 Calls
VOICE USAGE FOR Continued
Qnty Charge Number
Item Date Time Calls To Used Rate Description
125 09115 08:45P WPALMBEACH FL OWN 300 ADD'L ANYTME MN
126 09115 08:52P WPALMBEACH FL 2MI II 300 ADD'L ANYTME MN
127 09/1$ 09:04e
128 09/15 09:32P
INCOMING
INCOMING
1MIN
1 MN
UNLIMITED N/WKNG MN UNLIMITED NAWKND MN
129 09115 10:39P INCOMING 1 MN UNLIMITED NANKND MN
130 09/16 11:14A INCOMING 1MIN 300 ADD,. ANYTME MIN
131 09/18 02:07P WPALMBEACH FL 1MIN UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL
1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL
132 01'16 02-05P NEW YORK Ni' 1MIN UN UM MOBL TO MOBL
133 09/16 02:44P LAKE WORTH FL 1MIN 300 ADD'L ANYTME MN
134 09/16 02:45P WPALMBEACH FL 2MIN 300 ADM ANYTME MN
135 09/16 02:46P INCOMING 2 MIN 300 A001. ANYTME MIN
136 09/16 02:48P WPALMBEACH FL 4 MIN 300 ADM. ANYTME MIN
131 09/16 02:54P BOYNTONBCH FL 1MN UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL
138 09/16 02:55P BOYNTON BCH FL 3/AIN 300 ADO'L ANYTME MIN
139 09/16 03:44P INCOMING 1 MN UNUM MOBL TO MOBL
140 09/16 07:46P WPALMBEACH FL VAIN UNLIM MOBL TO MOBL
1 EVT MESSAGE RETRIEVAL
141 09/16 09:55P INCOMING 1 MIN UNLIMITED N/WKND MIN
142 09/17 07:21A WPALMBEACH FL 1MAN 300 AMYL ANYTME MIN
143 09/17 12:21 INCOMING 2 A4IN 300 ADD'L ANYTME MN
144 09/17 03:16P WPALMBEACH FL 1 MN 300API111-#1,11T,APON
30
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000030
September 16, 2004 Flight
Cele
..4.-.
2 OC,{
MOit Mile
rid %IWO
Masi
Idlingkerco HMI
Paints of %Waft & Mini Ms
Fban
FIFO
Ph
Renbarks, Preooduns,
Illaeowo, Eadoromooto
Fos To
42.6
Vit1 , 3 10 r.; cibvs& L f)07_ 1 vir It%7434 #v,P,^ i I. , .
m
6 L +. AV..t. L1.3
c.
b I, " 7151. 0 31 ola.,
,,k) " %. Pn IfY, iii)
13 t i l ‘ ICY. pl•K li sti 3 I/ 4 )i
0
l c!, 1110 Vi‘N .2i.w.16.,,/A z. H ol t Lr.
V"
1`1 t• ,, \IN'? !'ti 9.11
2.81-T76,x.Pirro
I CITAC.I4 '1, ST- fl" t li123A4
TA v L QaL seko do—
,-_
,7x ,, ,, se:Go ‘O5 :10)s,c-tA0/7,1111 TD /.2.14 .6... i
9 t• it 9 flt -.“Si 2ifis al -co Lv4-Lfik
2 G-1\116 Neloil(= efi. -1-1.3 Ilr LV
5 fOri -3 .1N10 %-r& 'TM ZSc.y. 1.:0 ....v ,NA4 kAx
lb 'A .. - .
"
, 4t1tiltIV
V\ (- Or.
C)13L iii ..1414J .it ,oNurmAkA4., L
GM_GLSDNY_00000)3 I
September 16, 2004 Flight
JEGE, INC.
PASSENGER MANIFEST
Rogisuntion ~nor N90RJE Typo E.727-31 Pik« Din*Rodos, Lai« %mkt
Flight ~se« Larrylles~
DATE: _9 . (‘;. 2004
1):04'
ij?g)
PROM
Arrnal
Timc
TO  P13.2"
Ao_isitgb ‹.29/PASSENGERS
MON ««ener «IL«
on  A/E43 yoiz

my. 4
Sate Q Country
TO kkiriffirr Defined
City  LUESr
Scare ix Cottony
Nnuncal nfiles 893
32
GM_GJ_SDNY_00000032
EFTA00009428 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-11)
E (TRUNK
COURT
REPORTING
if
'I
j.\
LAS
LOG
SI
ATE
V.
CASE
NO.
•
Page
of
/
DATE
ST or DFS
WITNESS
DIRECT
CROSS
REDIRECT
RE
-CROSS
REDIRECT CONTINUED
RE
-CROSS
CONTINUED
END
/0
7/M
IS.
it
...
,
•
/0
:OA:
2
I:a
' 0
—
:•7.
,
//
•
'
/
.
.
.
.
-7/
/q/
ff
)
I I
34'
ill
I1:54-:
4
,/
.
•
.4
-
SA
'r.'
/
• /7:22
/
• 34:5/
B:
Bench
Conference
•:
Motion
to
Strike
reincin
'elect
Io
• 20
Defense
Attorncs
Asst.
State
Atty
si:
4Lisimag
eatimmsr
Aidasfeksanssur
CONFIDENTIAL
MM16-31E.MM-108062-GJ-1A
SEC
003
SER
1A9
-1A16.000264
3501.055-083 Page
1 of
11

╭────────────────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────────────────────╮
│ L101 38%                                                                    │
│ eR0-S50'105E                                                                │
│                                                                             │
│ WILN3GI4NOD                                                                 │
│                                                                             │
│ {792000-91WI-6Vi USS C00 93S VI-TO-Z9080L-WH-3LE-SLWW                       │
│                                                                             │
│ errant                                                                      │
│                                                                             │
│ NVORNNYASYY AVIA VII ‘Isley 2008 vy                                         │
│                                                                             │
│ 901 SSINLIM ONLLMOATE LENO IINOULIATA                                       │
│                                                                             │
│ — {Nouony emp — BENIN PEA                                                   │
│ EGET 7 eT                                                                   │
│ be rar ed tb                                                                │
│ se E                                                                        │
│ TOD #                                                                       │
│ FEY                                                                         │
│ TET SIT ayy er2|                                                            │
│ Fi WOBET aE TOG: OT ITE EPH ETE                                             │
│ aganunoo | azanttnoo 7a                                                     │
│ ws | ava_|“sooraw | wormazy | ssoxrsu |sgamar| sso | _sogura sania as | ava │
│ wea . “ON ASV — “AaLVAS                                                     │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

i5e4 -7406 4.ei.ei
•
/1:16
CONFIDENTIAL
..fi r
AL L-dee/4Z
hay aleateeaZ
MM16.31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000265
3501.055-083
Page 2 of 11

╭─────────────────── Page 2, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ lig Wiifoe out Ue                                     │
│ Cntpeed agesseed. lide Savisilifalig)                 │
│ Monte Altace:                                         │
│                                                       │
│ Lub12 peeps.                                          │
│ LUGE OT dhe ll)                                       │
│                                                       │
│ Sanne                                                 │
│                                                       │
│ 2 Cheth Chippe 2.                                     │
│                                                       │
│ 4 Ain)                                                │
│ 3 06: wofegt                                          │
│                                                       │
│ “beak Ok,                                             │
│                                                       │
│ » Bee <. ‘att. Leite Lil pee td hich ie.              │
│ Med Ul yout. wi                                       │
│                                                       │
│ bd/                                                   │
│                                                       │
│ MN116-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000265 │
│ 3501.055.083                                          │
│                                                       │
│ CONFIDENTIAL Page 2 of 11                             │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

441 -7/4/D4
Lff_eideze(44-ge,-;) •
_13: /6_4_ ,eefizfeeeseei2r_49-
.__aeEt22.;! 7'11 Jab 46.
4414.1.Zzoki —leizor.442se,J
2."&e
eti(&._At._4.4ap,
_._4(6, ze_..._
4.5 5,e,'
. /!,"-z.diate_ reed ",I .e.../.,/upy71=1-  _ -_-_.
_,ctrl .
4¢ /9 _ c Ze7z?
...41:57._
.__46.:_4.7..:da :(4,44(S.14e,44v..e.ecer.X.1_.. ..
...48;z2k_.a&

• 50:15... Oft
CONFIDENTIAL
MM16-31E-MM-108062 GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000266
3501.055-083
Page 3 of 11

╭────────────────── Page 3, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ tiga 7/ghe                                           │
│                                                      │
│ MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000266 │
│ 3501.055-083                                         │
│                                                      │
│ CONFIDENTIAL Page 3 of 11                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

4043 il if/O6
„xthiece .
•
96ty
zV : 7  4- 7 Zre-.. 1-e direl:e_aldie2 l4rze.e;91.d
05p 4* .#4 1.
w.:0_6ze Cr4getze_e__
0503* ailSge
05.: 43 .__ Joi&/.0 jarsadiz sso iz de/4
CONFIDENTIAL
MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER1A9-1A16-000267
3501.055-083
Page 4 of 11

╭──────────────────── Page 4, Image 1 ────────────────────╮
│ lips WiGfoe                                             │
│                                                         │
│ L212 Mhay bid D0 dalle, Moe.                            │
│ anys o> a” a                                            │
│                                                         │
│ 92:26... kihe. Upyatte. lt 200.                         │
│                                                         │
│ | £6. _                                                 │
│                                                         │
│ LL ll. lis. Ze _                                        │
│ t02. {We inting std b25),20d. ZB pL pike)               │
│                                                         │
│ 5 ser Mh                                                │
│                                                         │
│ 99.20. Kiteg cy, Githe) |                               │
│ O42. 10[2l05 Utathe puulld fare Gof ays Mtetae          │
│ 7 MMI16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000267 │
│ 3501,055-083                                            │
│                                                         │
│ CONFIDENTIAL Page 4 of 11                               │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

22:5¢.
,Weededogyak____
ee.Z_Igefz.izzexe_zilfedp_f&4/zefie
Ito  49_
04/4204t-WMML
ofifr_i_deetZ A ./2,4,644e,
, .
&At. th  91014 1,1141X,_
dt4 /7 d5e • •
MM16.31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9 -1A16-000268
3501.055-083
CONFIDENTIAL Page 5 of 11
CONFIDENTIAL
/vim/4d ree fitA2rxe of/ .
‘fi gifiey (
MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000269
3501.055-083
Page 6 of II

╭────────────────── Page 6, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ | tg lee                                             │
│                                                      │
│ MM16-31€-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1416-000269 │
│ 3501.055-083                                         │
│                                                      │
│ CONFIDENTIAL Page 6 of 11                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

(0 749/04.
27deieceaseike..:)
___,5Liao_..__9ay.oe •
6-ee—b9m;etegy4ea_z___
__A1,524!
_45:
fc59-zo
_.L4'  &,1101.a..00ce
todred._
_SL447._ dt.Z.
JeAdee,-.../cos_ _ lateiezez),Ar
_ ZaeL40d),41/1-ic
20:
CONFIDENTIAL
MM16.31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9 -1A16-000270
3501.055-083
Page 7 of 11

╭────────────────── Page 7, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ Higee 7/r4/os                                        │
│ — arabe “Ohlhen >                                    │
│ 10D. 0b |                                            │
│ 5044. Uy                                             │
│                                                      │
│ LOL Yin M                                            │
│                                                      │
│ LD: Flite                                            │
│                                                      │
│ Mell LO.                                             │
│                                                      │
│ 43. dl. atyaeldette $eaon slp                        │
│ 2 46 fo ee                                           │
│                                                      │
│ - J}                                                 │
│ MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000270 │
│ 3501.055-083                                         │
│                                                      │
│ CONFIDENTIAL Page 7 of 11                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

if 7 7/10//96 •
77:64it& ekree„_. 11_:4122
. .20 cki - -
CONFIDENTIAL
MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000271
3501.055-083
Page 8 of 11

╭────────────────── Page 8, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ lig? 7/9 ob                                          │
│                                                      │
│ — A title) a                                         │
│ kth)                                                 │
│                                                      │
│ “ “                                                  │
│                                                      │
│ LO Alddtep bid, ie, allcabgililite sia A.            │
│ Teel Me Mee le -                                     │
│                                                      │
│ ~Z2ELE MYldllied -                                   │
│ 3613S. All tae WE Fopey- __                          │
│ 37146 Mead Db, Tig Mel Tepe)                         │
│                                                      │
│ 28.086. Ue Lb.get ld Godibele ee |                   │
│ B34 Set dita pete et Sopa te. \                      │
│ 24 20 Dy fftey Gace #220, . - .                      │
│                                                      │
│ MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1416-000271 │
│ 3501.055-083                                         │
│                                                      │
│ CONFIDENTIAL Page 8 of 11                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

4 ,9 „kg/06
I
11410-25_110 .
4/ :.2.0±
47 : 4 4 1d
46./r,
_4-314.62
44:z74.g/Iiikow/Aiced.,/iefekeaVw.&4.___
:5.,6 .04,000-2z.
45:0
4_2:42 _diy2deie  7 z5-
d7;
*4:
_ors
47  _Vizegyie •
*44: •
.03 . Al lege
otaved-yee,y.i.ivie
1.11._te.eAtelisea-.4-x7
4-
9-e,ated- ),0eit
CONFIDEN I IAI
MM16-31E-MM-109062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9 -1A16-000272
3501.055-083
Page 9 all

╭────────────────── Page 9, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ liga Wiafoe                                          │
│                                                      │
│ “443 27. Chen                                        │
│ POPPY:                                               │
│                                                      │
│ 4EL0. Ge                                             │
│ #2. 07.                                              │
│                                                      │
│ MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000272 │
│                                                      │
│ 3501.055-083,                                        │
│ CONFIDENTIAL Page 9 of 11                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

CONFIDENTIAL
4 q -7//,06, .
az2:4,4 . _032.34. DtLogii___0i.Z.zeddz _eddy.e_e_-_-_-_ekeZ 4 7 ! 2.42. .M42V-h-blete . 1:1 4 .0.ArAre:0_.4- IreelleAr 
.
0_8:2 4 j._ .. 904: •
—245-:5 - 7 : "7 ---e .1
-- ,e2LO I! 9J/r- 17--4:— esede-cig114.Ati&Zel
—..__IllAe/Zti de fr eif/A4/
zda ii)  I .19
X4.:.20.4_C 1 .__,e.L.az.ingez/a/  •
_clithr4-;- __ _ ::
__43: 51 ': 0/4/ 4_:_ .
ill: 45__L_,*ze/ 4';
Z741: 5711 <dged__
. _i_ft_z ielede‘e_ — _s_. ___,_„T.,••-.;   _ ,,_4_______ .
_52:_e-6_27.41;
_.6Z . 3.4   -,-44.1,
' il ia -7_ _frit
/;/7;,22_ 77: ee )
MM16.31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000273
3501.055-083
Page 10 of 11

╭────────────────── Page 10, Image 1 ──────────────────╮
│ hy. 9 yale                                           │
│                                                      │
│ 0b 24; wn Y                                          │
│ 02:20. dee                                           │
│                                                      │
│ MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000273 │
│ 3501.055-083                                         │
│                                                      │
│ CONFIDENTIAL Page 10 of 11                           │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

gelid s)
_
_ 2t...zA4_/ealth_
2310_
5 2  *W24...leae
aL_es.d_go-22 4.ek___Ara.4,4•MU&I.4:a421
_ _3A 47
_ 3g
6-471,4
z.5...adeeg-/ 7dyks‘•
/. _ _ .
„Is/ ... fed IR.
CONFIDENTIAL
MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9 -1A16-000274
3501.055-083
Pagc I I of I I

╭────────────────── Page 11, Image 1 ──────────────────╮
│ ge 0 whale                                           │
│                                                      │
│ LB.00. leno                                          │
│                                                      │
│ 204...                                               │
│ 5.28.                                                │
│                                                      │
│ : LT.                                                │
│ on Biro =                                            │
│                                                      │
│ (24, 3/ i (ited                                      │
│                                                      │
│ MM16-31E-MM-108062-GJ-1A SEC 003 SER 1A9-1A16-000274 │
│ 3501.055-083,                                        │
│                                                      │
│ CONFIDENTIAL Page Il of 11                           │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

(
(
(
EFTA00039383 (Jmail)
 [legal] legal filing in US v. Jeffrey Epstein
EFTA00159321 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of (unknown), covers Paolo Zampolli, Epstein, and the possibility Epstein introduced Melania to Donald Trump
(inferred date: 2026-01-11)
YEI-RD(Ret—(440) -1 -4 1: -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Omouv._Reeees
Darden  11/26/2019
date of birth (DOB) was interviewed
pursuant to a proffer agreement at west Palm Beach,
Florida. Present for the interview was a orney
along with AUSA III, AUSA , apecial Agent
M, and Detective IIII After being advised of the identity
of the interviewing Agents and the nature of the interview, provided
the following information:
left modeling when she took a job offered by JEFFREY EPSTEIN.
started working for EPSTEIN in approximately 2005 and left in early

2006. traveled on trips with EPSTEIN to help as his assistant. A
lawmpeamet ofil: /2c Y a weer Palm m.arll, unir.d stereg (In percon)
Meg 315-NY^ 3027571 Datilgafial 07/22/:015
by
mm document yob= .albs recanaxotancen nw =COSMIC et the MN kit tbe ropey of tbe l'131 and is (galley= limey. ±1 aid ea 
C0171011Satt
wtr thstalaed Dade Ma agency
3524-009
Page 1 of 11
FD-302a (Rev 5-S-10)
31E —NY-3027571
(U) Proffer of
ContimationaFOJOof Interview 41 ,O„ 07/12/2019 m g, 2 of 11
trip to Paris in approximately early 2006 was her last assignment.
IIII put in contact with an agent named PAOLO ZEMPOLI who worked
with "ID Models".
ZEMPOLI was trying to buy Elite Models
with EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN introduced MELANIA TRUMP to DONALD TRUMP.
EPSTEIN was visiting ZEMPOLI at the agency when there were casting
auditions for models. EPSTEIN was looking through portfolios and saw
photograph of her wearing only swim bottoms.
and ZEMPOLI were at a night club with EPSTEIN, who was there with
a woman who believed was took
phone number.
Someone called, either a girl or EPSTEIN, and invited to dinner.
went to EPSTEIN's residence on 71st Street in Manhattan. This was
the first one on one interaction had with EPSTEIN. EPSTEIN made her
wait; she heard him playing the piano. did not recall if she went
upstairs. and EPSTEIN had dinner in the dining room. This room was
straight ahead when you walked into his home. EPSTEIN asked what she
liked to do. told EPSTEIN that she liked studying and that she was a
good student. They talked about travels and having a model contract
in Japan and South Korea. mentioned that she thought there was a lot
of Russian prostitution. EPSTEIN told her, "That's what I like best."
recalled EPSTEIN saying something that made her uncomfortable.
EPSTEIN gave a tour of the house, took her to the massage room and
had her lay down, took a "vibrating thing" and rubbed it on her.
told him to stop.
room on the same floor as the master bedroom. A driver took home and
she remembered being tearful in the car.
described the massage room as a small, very dark
The next morning or a day later, recalled that EPSTEIN called
her. was unsure how everything progressed from there. EPSTEIN may
have offered her an English class, which attended. EPSTEIN offered
3524-009
Page2ofil
FD-302e (Rev 54-10)
31E—NY-3027571

(V) Proffer of
Contimmionar0.302of Interview 41 ,o, 07/12/2019 Mgt 3 of 11
her a job approximately at the end of 2004. EPSTEIN offered an
apartment in New York on 66th Street in Manhattan. EPSTEIN offered
job with Victoria's Secret, which was a photo shoot. EPSTEIN told
that she needed to work out to be a model and told her to go to a specific
gym.
had traveled to Florida with EPSTEIN on his plane. did
not have a driver's license.
went with
organized by EPSTEIN.
to the floor of Wall Street on a trip
met GHISLAINE MAXWELL at her house around the end of 2004.
MAXWELL told to purchase items like toiletries prior to getting
offered the job. The job responsibilities included running errands, and
helping who was EPSTEIN's personal assistant. was
immediate supervisor. MAXWELL gave direction.
had intimate relations with EPSTEIN, but did not have
intercourse. EPSTEIN had multiple sexual encounters with
felt this was personal.
a
described as having big brown eyes and chin length blonde
hair. helped with errands, traveled with them, called pilots,
and purchased things for EPSTEIN's plane. In Palm Beach, answered
calls and confirmed massage appointments. was given this
responsibility shortly after beginning to work for EPSTEIN. mainly
stayed in Palm Beach, while home was in Miami. WHen stayed
in Palm Beach, she slept in EPSTEIN's house in one of the bedrooms.
Typically, had to travel with EPSTEIN. When they traveled to
EPSTEIN's island, stayed with him on the island. They traveled a lot
to Boston, specifically visiting Harvard. They met with MARTIN NOVACK and
ALAN DERSHOWITZ. traveled to New Mexico and Paris with EPSTEIN.
spent the most time in the Virgin Islands with EPSTEIN so EPSTEIN
could count his time in the island to establish for tax residency.
Other people that traveled regularly with EPSTEIN besides MAXWELL,
3524-009
Page3of11
FD.302e (Rev $4,10)
31E —NY-3027571

(V) Proffer of
ContimationaF0J02of Interview 41
and were
BRUNEL, IGOR, and a chef.
a casual relationship with EPSTEIN. was introduced by
. IGOR was EPSTEIN's personal trainer.
.on 07/12/2019 ,per 4 of 11
was EPSTEIN's girlfriend.
In New York,
, JEAN LUC
had
ran errands, bought things, went to EPSTEIN's house
and sat in on meetings. worked in MAXWELL's house on the ground
floor in New York. was given an apartment in the same building as
MAXWELL. spent most of her time in New York at MAXWELL's home.
did not recall if she had made phone calls from New York.
LESLIE GROFF was EPSTEIN's assistant in EPSTEIN's Madison Avenue office
who scheduled his appointments for people coming to his house, including
massage appointments. GROFF made those phone calls to schedule appointments.
Fairly early on after working for EPSTEIN, began helping schedule
massage appointments. In reference to knowing what occurred during the
massages, stated, "It happened to me in the Virgin Islands, so I
assumed that was happening to everyone else during their massages."
saw women in his New York house that she understood were there to
give massages.
other girls. Another girl named would also bring other girls.
brought two girls who were dancers/ballerinas, who stated that they were 16
years old. and
he would buy them dancing shoes.
was at his New York residence a lot and would bring
may have been there. EPSTEIN told them that
At the time, was not sure if the girls who massaged EPSTEIN were
underage but it seemed consensual and knew it was a sexual massage.
had research girls on Twitter. One girl named IIII was 17
in New York.
was approximately 21 years old. EPSTEIN's massages were
approximately twice a day everyday in New York and Palm Beach. In New York,
EPSTEIN also had a lot of meetings.
met in approximately 2004.
roommate who may have assisted.
was
3524-009
Page4ofil
FD-302a (Rev $4,10)
31E—NY-3027571
(V) Proffer of
Contimmionar0.302of Interview 41 ,o, 07/12/2019 .p.,g, 5 of 11
In Palm Beach, was responsible for answering phones and
confirming massage appointments if wasn't around. EPSTEIN, as well as
would ask to do this. showed girls to the massage
room and set up the table for them. also bought tickets for comedy
clubs for EPSTEIN. was also responsible for researching things for
EPSTEIN and running errands.
When traveling from New York to Palm Beach, set up the schedule
for massages or gave a list of people to call for appointments.
may have called from New York to make appointments for Palm Beach,
but mostly made those calls.
Part of the regular routine for was to check in with EPSTEIN in
the morning. EPSTEIN would be in his office, gym, or by the pool.
would see who EPSTEIN wanted her to call; EPSTEIN gave her a list.
was someone EPSTEIN commented on. EPSTEIN commented on
SAT score massaged EPSTEIN and hung out at the Palm Beach
house, then went to New York. EPSTEIN helped get an internship.
was told how to make calls and told what to say. When
called to confirm appointments she said, "This is calling on behalf
of Jeffrey Epstein...calling to confirm the massage appointment." EPSTEIN
was upset when she used his name when confirming massage appointments.
EPSTEIN told her to never use his name when calling people. On the calls,
discussed what time
confirm appointments.
appointments.
appointments.
EPSTEIN wanted
they would come. EPSTEIN pushed her to call and
had to call multiple times to confirm
did not remember ever calling men to confirm massage
to put eye cream on him. EPSTEIN became upset with
her if she missed a day. If missed a phone call for a massage
appointment, EPSTEIN became very upset and left her a nasty voincemail.
EPSTEIN raised his voice to
thought that EPSTEIN was originally going to teach her about
finance. EPSTEIN sent her to one to two business meetings but then was
different after she started working for him. EPSTEIN became stressed with
her, asking her, "Do you want to work?" when referring to her calling girls.
3524-009
Page5ofil
FD-302a(tev $4, 10)
31E-NY-3027571
(U) Proffer of
ContinuationofF0.302of Interview 411 .O, 07/12/2019 .p.,g, 6 of 11
often called and asked the girls about another girl. asked
her to do this. recalled calling and asked her to bring
another girl. called and asked her to bring another girl.
was upset with because called home where her
parents lived. Girls had mentioned to that they could not come
because they had school.
The girls would come in from the rear of the house, near the kitchen.
offered them water. told them to go upstairs. The massage
room was attached to his master bathroom with sauna, steam room, and closet,
with the massage table inside the closet. may have put a towel on
the table. EPSTEIN told to give the girls a hair band.
was present one time when a girl massaged EPSTEIN.
massaged EPSTEIN in Palm Beach. left during most massages, going
about her tasks around the house. The massages took approximately an hour.
Sometimes EPSTEIN called downstairs and sometimes during the massage he
would call other people. knew the massage was done when the girl
would come downstairs. EPSTEIN paid the girls; he always had a huge amount
of money in his bag. He paid the girls approximately $200.
and typically stayed a bit longer after the massage.
If a girl brought another girl, one would go upstairs while the one who
brought the girl hung out downstairs. brought girls. EPSTEIN may have
asked to pay the girls for him. was instructed to bring
girls from Miami to Palm Beach; these girls were associated with Ideal
Models. talked about a time where one girl was sitting on the couch
visibly upset and EPSTEIN had a friend who was a doctor there who told them
that the girl did not feel well. EPSTEIN had a car service take the girl
home.
Palm Beach massages happened twice a day everyday. typed up a
list of girls to call in Palm Beach and printed a few copies. threw
these away. This list was specific to massages.
were ■
recalled one girl calling and talking about college. The girls
women. did not know their exact age. Thinking back on it,
felt that she should have had the impression that they were
3524-009
Page6ofil
FD-302a(Rtv 54,10)
31E-NY-3027571
(U) Proffer of
ContinuolionofFOJ02of Interview 411 ,o, 07/12/2019 .p.,g, 7 of 11
underage. She was used to women being around older men in the modeling
industry.
recalled IIII, and traveling on EPSTEIN's plane
from New York to Palm Beach. recalled other girls names that were at
EPSTEIN's house, including , and
. There were more girls but could not recall all of their
names. The girls were students, not models. Some may have been in a horse
back riding club. The girls asked for assistance to go to college.
may have had a personal relationship in the past with EPSTEIN but
had not heard anything. assumed because EPSTEIN was always
with a girl.
took a lot of photographs. took photographs of in
the Virgin Islands. EPSTEIN had told that it was ok to undress.
There were a lot of nude photographs in EPSTEIN's home. There were also nude
photographs in the gym in the New York house.
In Palm Beach, was in the living room and started stripping when
started taking photographs. kept the photographs in binders in
MAXWEL1's house.
felt that took advantage of her because she had do
"nasty tasks" and had her constantly running. felt that made
her do the heavy lifting. and were friendly with each other
but did not like how treated her.
When called to confirm appointments, she sometimes left a
voicemail with her cell number for a call back.
could not remember if she and talked about what happened
with the massages or if made comments about the girls.
In the Virgin Islands, they would travel to the island by boat.
had to give EPSTEIN massages. A girl named would come to the island
to give EPSTEIN massages. In the morning, would go to his office.
There were different beach huts on the island. EPSTEIN would take a golf
cart around the island. EPSTEIN worked out a lot on the island. When they
3524-009
Page7ofil
FD.3C0.2 (Rev 54.10)
31E—NY-3027571
(UI Proffer of
CaminumionofFD)02d Interview Al .o n 07/12/2019 ,Peer 8 of 11
were on the island, it was more leisure time. There was a room by the
kitchen where they all watched TV. Some of tasks included
researching things online and making online purchases. There was a house
manager who would ask people about allergies and they would have to fill out
a card.
Other tasks was responsible for were buying furniture.
was also instructed to buy sex toys from a sex shop in New York, but could
not recall who had told her to buy them. thought the sex toys she
had to buy were vibrators. recalled having to go to some building
with an upstairs.
In Palm Beach, ordered books for a girl. The books were not sent
in time and EPSTEIN was upset with thought the books may
have been for IIII. IIII stayed more in the house. DAVID COPPERFIELD was at
the house one time and IIII may have met him. IIII was one of the girls who
came for massages. told to get IIII a tutor. EPSTEIN wanted
to give IIII more. IIII may have brought a picture of her artwork.
and brought girls.
baby. thought
was.
purchased a lot of gifts for
was older but was unsure how old
When traveled with EPSTEIN to New Mexico, it was a long drive to
the house. It was a big house with a guest house. felt that she was
likely doing the to do list from New York. had to give EPSTEIN
facials. There was horse back riding with disclaimers. recalled that
they barely traveled to New Mexico; they were maybe there twice.
Somtimes there was a chiropractor who came after the massages and girls
would get adjustments.
was paid every two weeks. Her starting salary was $36,000 and
eventually was paid approximately $40,000 - $41,000.
The individuals who traveled with EPSTEIN, including and
were given massages. ALAN DERSHOWITZ received a massage from - she
had a tattoo. and gave massages.
understood these massages to be more professional massages. These massages
3524-009
Page8of II
FD-302a(tev $4, 10)
31E—NY-3027571
(U) Proffer of
ContinuationofF0.302of Interview 411 .O, 07/12/2019 9 of 11
were different than the massages the girls gave. did not think the
girls were professional masseuses.
was EPSTEIN's girlfriend. heard them exchange "I love
you". was a model. was associated with Karin Models and/or
MC2. was under the impression that EPSTEIN was a co-owner.
traveled with EPSTEIN and did not model. slept in the bedroom with
EPSTEIN. went back to modeling when she needed to renew her visa.
and had an intimate relationship. talked about a
time where LARRY SUMMERS was sitting in the waiting room and having a
lengthy meeting with EPSTEIN. saw , who looked like she came
from an event, and told her that she had been looking for girls.
described and EPSTEIN's relationship as a strong love relationship.
stated there was no alcohol around unless a guest wanted it.
resigned from working for EPSTEIN. did not want to be
around EPSTEIN anymore. felt that there was something weird going on
with the complete situation. It took a while to make the decision to
quit.
stated they used a citrix based system. LESLIE GROFF put messages
in the system. These were messages that were on the computer in New York.
They eventually stopped using this system. There were small directory books.
Phone books were outdated. There were print outs of messages.
In approximately October 2005, , and EPSTEIN flew
to Miami. , along with her dog she traveled with, went to
house. EPSTEIN went with and later met up with them at
Soho House in Miami Beach. dropped off and was told to go to
Palm Beach to meet with someone. EPSTEIN told that something was
stolen and had to travel to give computers to be examined. The
person met was alone. This happened the day before
birthday. EPSTEIN and told to take the books, which were
personal contact phonebooks - the black ones were MAXWELL's and the colorful
ones were EPSTEIN's. could not remember if she took both. There were
a lot of books by each phone. These were copy pads that people would put
messages on and tear out to give to EPSTEIN. There were also white pads with
3524-009
Page9of11
FD-302e(Rev 54.10)
31E—NY-3027571
(V) Proffer of
ContinuationofF0.302of Interview 411 .O, 07/12/2019 .p.,g, 10 of 11
EPSTEIN and MAXWELL's names throughout the houses. JANUSZ BANASIAK helped
gather the items together. There was a computer that and
used, EPSTEIN's computer, and potentially MAXWELL's computer that they
collected. turned these items over to a person that seemed to be a
law enforcement type person. She took an inventory of things that she gave
to this individual, who she believed to be
There was a specific computer that and used in Palm Beach.
recalled a girl saying something about social profiles.
also asked to bring books from the Virgin Islands and meet
her in MAXWELL's office. told to shred an updated list of
names of girls. had a notebook with the investigative agency sticker
on it.
EPSTEIN told that there was an investigation and that it had
something to do with visas. EPSTEIN told that they were asking about
her parents. EPSTEIN had surprised with a visit from her parents.
knew that EPSTEIN was lying about how her parents got their visas.
recalled a time where she was on the island and EPSTEIN told her,
"Do you see the camera? They're watching me".
did not recall how she had learned about the actual reason for
the initial investigation. EPSTEIN's counsel DARREN INDYKE called her into
his office and told her not to talk to law enforcement.
In approximately October 2005, resigned to took it
as a joke. had called her about an issue with MAXWELL; cried
and told that she did not want to be there. gave notice, but
still worked for EPSTEIN until early 2006.
EPSTEIN promised a car. told him to cancel giving her the
car. EPSTEIN gave a car, which she kept and it stayed in her name.
felt that she had to stay in contact with EPSTEIN because the car
was in his name and was under his insurance. In Early 2008,
contacted either GROFF or someone else and asked to return the car.
and her husband drove to Palm Beach to return the car.
3524-009
Page 10 of I 1
FD.302a (Rev 34.10)
31E —NY-3027571

(U) Proffer of
comm,"„r FD.302 or Interview f1 .Do 07/12/2019 .p no  11 of 11
After left, approached her at Club Monaco and asked her if
she wanted to come to the Virgin Islands to work. told her no.
Attorneys reached out to asking questions. There was a woman in
New York named that reached out, and told her that her
attorney called the office asking if she could
speak to thought FBI agents may want to talk with her.
spoke with an FBI agent and she told the agent to call her attorney.
later hired her own attorney.
saw EPSTEIN looking at pornography on the computer that she and
used. EPSTEIN said that porn websites have the best poses for models.
EPSTEIN said that he did not have an email address but he did. Email
addresses that EPSTEIN used were jepstein@yahoo.com and jeepstein@yahoo.com.
saw an email of pictures of girls that EPSTEIN said were ugly.
told to send photographs of girls to JEAN LUC BRUNEL for
the purposes of casting/scouting for his agency.
EPSTEIN did not carry a cell phone. EPSTEIN would take one of their cell
phones and dial who he wanted.
has received random calls and texts from New York numbers. When
she left EPSTEIN's employment, she felt fearful that someone was following
her.
Not all details were covered during this interview. agreed to
meet again at another date.
3524-009
PageIlof11
EFTA00593276 (Jmail)
 [finance] Edmond de Rothschild org chart
(inferred date: 2026-01-11)
EDMOND
DE ROTHSCHILD
Situation au 30 juln 2014
0—
Edmond de Rothschild
Holding SA
55 49%   Rothschild Asset
Edmond de
Edmond de 1 100%
Rothschild Client
Nominees (UK) Ltd.
London
N._
fiManagement
Suilg./~1 11(00.,
1734%
1734%
100%
gdmond de Rothschl
Securities (UK)
Limited, London
Edmond de
Rothschild
(Lugano) SA,
ifer 1/4. Lugano
81 44%
Edmond de Rothschild
(Suisse) SA, Genève
EdR Private sag 6244 i Edmond de i 80%
Merchant Banking „— Rothschild (UK)
LLP. London
20% f Edmond de
Rothschild
Services Ltd.
London
100%
43%
...Limited. London
100%
21\----99.99%
---) LCH Investments Edmond de \cp 5% Rothschild Asset NV. Antilles
neerlandaises
0.5%
10%
Edmond de 0.44%
Rothschild ,
(France), Parts
.1 41%
EDRRIT Ltd,
London
Management (UK)
Limited, London
22.68%
4 ..01%
10094
Edmond de
Rothschild
(Europe),
Luxe bourg
_
(Priadvisory Holding ISA, Geneve
100%
LPriglobal Advisory
Ltd, Iles CaimansEdmond
de  7.4
Rothschild Capital(1
99.99%
I-99 92%
68%
--,,
( LCF EdR Conseil SA.
Luxembourg
t
0.01% 0,08%
(
4
Edmond de Rothschild
Asset Management ,,
(Luxembourg),
Luxembourg
1 0.37%
4
(-
Edmond de Rothschild
Assurances et C01180118
(Europe), Luxembourg
(LCF EdR Nikko Cordial 1 Co Limited. Tokyo 11
100%
100%
Holdings, London  K 9.92%  E.C.H. Invesenents Ltd.
100% 10%
Cayman islands
ACH Managernialit t_____,27%
SA, Luxembourg
2.5%
14.75, ‘  I . 3225%
K
EdR Intl Fund Ltd,
Bermuda
31.25%
2.25% 225%
‘it
\‘,....._151,‘ Banque de (
Gestlon Edmond
42.77% de Rothschild,
992%
Edmond de
Rothschild Gastion
(Monaco). Monaco
Monaco
(99 5%
f Edmond de Rothschild
Assurances et Conseils
(Monaco). Monaco
998%
/- 4 99%
Priveco Family Office ."
SA.
Geneve
✓
K99 99%
14 75%
52 %
Incentive
Management SAM,
Monaco
Edmond de
Rothschild
(Bahamas) Ltd,
Nassau
K
Copri Ill,
Luxembourg
Prifund Conseil. 1
1 Luxembourg )
) l00% r Prifund Conseil
(Bahamas) SA,
Nassau
Iberian Renewable 1
Energie GP Sad.
Luxembourg
(L'immobilière Baldauff

SA. Luxembourg
100%  es Conseiiiers du Léman
Associés, Genève
"-Edmond de Rothschild
Family Advisory (Hong
100% `Kong) Ltd. Hong Kong
EdR (C.I.)Ltd.
Guernsey
100%
K1CO% Compagnie Pnvee de 1  EdR Hold ngs 100%
nnence. Jersey J I Ltd, Guernsey
1009
(Edmond de Rothschild
(Suisse) SA,
Representación
Uruguay,
Montevideo
Orox Asset
Management SA,
Geneve
EdR Asset -)
Management (C.I.)
Ltd, Guernsey
05/09/2014
EFTA02730996 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-11)
EX-99.1 2 d118102dex991.htm EX-99.1
Exhibit 99.1
DecheLLPrt
MEMORANDUM
DATE January 22, 2021
TO Apollo Conflicts Committee
FROM Dechen LLP
RE Investigation Of Epstein/Black Relationship And Any Relationship Between Epstein and Apollo Global Management, Inc.
In October 2020, the Conflicts Committee of Apollo Global Management, Inc. ("Apollo") retained Dechert LLP ("Dechert") 
as
independent counsel to conduct a thorough investigation into (1) the relationship between Leon Black ("Black") and 
Jeffrey Epstein ("Epstein"),
including any financial, business or personal dealings between Black and any Black affiliate, on the one hand, and 
Epstein and any Epstein affiliate on
the other; (2) any work performed for, or services rendered to, Black or any Black affiliate by Epstein or any Epstein 
affiliate; (3) the financial or other
relationship, if any, between Apollo or any Apollo affiliate, and Epstein and any Epstein affiliate, including without 
limitation, any financial or other
dealings between them; and (4) any statements made by or on behalf of Black or Apollo referring, relating to or 
characterizing either Black's or Apollo's
relationship with Epstein. The Committee placed no restriction on Dechert's investigation. This memorandum summarizes 
Dechen's findings.
I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Over the past three months, Dechen has reviewed over 60,000 documents obtained from Black, Apollo, Elysium Management 
LLC
(Black's "Family Office"), and Paul, Weiss, Rilkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP, outside legal counsel to Black and the 
Family Office ("Paul Weiss").
Such documents include emails, text messages, banking statements, and other forms of communication. Potentially relevant
documents were collected
from Apollo for current and former employees of Apollo dating back to 1998 as well as for all current and former 
employees of the Family Office,
including from the inception of the Family Office and prior to implementation of the separate Family Office (Elysium) 
email address. Text messages
were also collected from Black's cell phone.
DecheLLPrt Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 2
Dechen was assisted in its document collection efforts by Paul Weiss, as well as by Apollo's legal counsel for the 
purpose of this
investigation, Milbank LIP ("Milbank"),I Both Paul Weiss and Milbank fully cooperated in the investigation and agreed to
provide every category of
documents that Dechen requested. Paul Weiss and Milbank also assisted Dechert in providing access to not only materials 
but also various witnesses
thought to be relevant to the investigation.

Specifically, Dechert interviewed more than 20 witnesses (some more than once), including Black, current and former 
Apollo employees,
the co-founders of Apollo, current and former Family Office employees, and current and former legal counsel to obtain 
their recollection of events that
may have been relevant to Dechert's investigation. With only one exception, Dechen interviewed every witness that it had
requested; that witness, a
former employee of the Family Office, declined to participate in the investigation but is not believed to have any 
additional information likely to be
material to the investigation. Based on Dechen's thorough review of the documents and witness testimony, Dechert has 
made the following findings,
each of which is set out in more detail below:

1. Dechert has seen no evidence that Black or any employee of the Family Office or Apollo was involved in any way with 
Epstein's criminal
activities at any time. There is no evidence that Epstein ever introduced Black, or offered to introduce Black, to any 
underage woman.

2. Black and others at Apollo and the Family Office were aware that Epstein had been convicted in 2008 for the charges 
of solicitation of
prostitution and procuring a person under 18 for prostitution. There is no evidence suggesting knowledge of any other of
Epstein's
criminal activity or the scope and details of such activity, at any time prior to such activities being publicly
Paul Weiss has previously served as outside legal counsel to Apollo but did not do so for the purposes of this 
investigation.
DecheLLPrt Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 3
reported in late 2018 and culminating with Epstein's arrest in July 2019. When Black first retained Epstein, he believed
that Epstein had
served his time for the originally charged offenses and believed that it was not inappropriate to give Epstein a second 
chance, as many
other prominent figures in business, science, politics and academia had done.

3. From approximately the mid-1990's to 2018, Black had a social relationship with Epstein, and from 2012 to 2017, 
Epstein provided
professional services to Black as well. There is no evidence that Black paid Epstein for any services after April 2017, 
although the two
men did continue to communicate until October 2018. Professionally, Black retained Epstein to advise Black and the 
Family Office on a
variety of topics related to trust and estate planning, tax issues, philanthropic endeavors, and the operation of the 
Family Office. Socially,
Black was friendly with Epstein and confided in Epstein regarding personal matters. Epstein would, at times, allude to 
their personal
relationship when attempting to negotiate aspects of their business relationship, but Dechert has seen no evidence 
suggesting that either
their professional or personal relationships ever touched upon Epstein's criminal activities or any other illegal 
activity.

4. Epstein regularly advised Black on a variety of issues related to trust and estate planning, tax, philanthropy, and 
the operation of the
Family Office. Although witnesses agreed that: (a) not all of Epstein's advice was useful and (b) Epstein was generally 
a disruptive and
caustic force within the Family Office, many witnesses believed that Epstein had creative ideas that no other advisor 
had proposed and
would push Family Office employees to achieve greater performance than they might have achieved on their own. As a 
result of Epstein's
work, Black believed, and witnesses generally agreed, that Epstein provided advice that conferred more than SI billion 
and as much as
$2 billion or more in value to Black.
DecheLrt L P
Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 4

5. Black compensated Epstein for his work in amounts that were intended to be proportional to the value provided by 
Epstein. Those
payments for work performed over the period 2012 through 2017 totaled $158 million. In 2013, payments were memorialized 
in signed
and unsigned agreements. After that point, payments were made on an ad hoc basis based on Black's perceived value of 
Epstein's work.
Dechert has seen no evidence suggesting that Black ever compensated Epstein for any service other than Epstein's 
legitimate advice on
trust and estate planning, tax issues, issues relating to artwork, Black's airplane, Black's yacht, and other similar 
matters, philanthropic
issues, and the operation of the Family Office. Moreover, such advice was vetted consistently by Black's other advisors,
including Family
Office employees, Paul Weiss, and other outside legal, accounting and tax professionals.

6. Beginning in 2016, Black and Epstein's professional and personal relationship deteriorated over a payment dispute 
that had long been
brewing, with Black refusing to pay Epstein tens of millions of dollars that Epstein believed he had earned. Black's 
last payment to
Epstein was made in April 2017; in 2018, Epstein repaid a portion of two loans that were outstanding to Black but never 
repaid the
balance. Black and Epstein ceased communications in or around the fall of 2018, prior to the renewed public revelations 
of Epstein's
conduct and Epstein's arrest and suicide.

7. Epstein and his entities did not invest in any Apollo-managed funds. However, in 2011, one of Epstein's entities, 
Financial Trust Company,
purchased 263,257 shares of Apollo's stock in its initial public offering. Those shares appear to have later been 
transferred to a second
Epstein entity, Southern Financial LLC, and appear to have been held through at least September 2019. Aside from this 
stock purchase,
and the tangential matters described below, Dechert has seen no evidence of Epstein or any Epstein entity having any 
relationship with
Apollo or any Apollo-managed fund.

8. Epstein made repeated efforts to ingratiate himself with other senior executives at Apollo and appears to have relied
on Black to help him
make those introductions. Despite these efforts, Dechert has seen no evidence of any other Apollo executive ever 
retaining Epstein for his
services.
DecheLLPrt Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 5
11. BLACK AND EPSTEIN DEVELOP A
PERSONAL AND THEN A BUSINESS RELATIONSHIP
Black was introduced to Epstein in the mid-1990's by a mutual friend. Following the introduction, they grew to know each
other better and
developed a personal relationship. While Black and Epstein discussed estate planning, philanthropy, and related issues 
over the years, Black did not
engage Epstein to provide him with any services until 2012. Initially, Black viewed Epstein as someone who was very 
intelligent and knowledgeable
regarding issues relating to estate planning and taxation. Black also was impressed by Epstein's connections to many 
prominent figures in business,
politics, and science. Epstein spoke knowledgeably about scientific innovation and technology. He introduced Black to 
well-regarded researchers at
Harvard University and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and encouraged Black to donate to charitable causes 
that supported scientific
development. In 1997, Black appointed Epstein as one of the initial directors of the Black Family Foundation, which was 
established for the purpose of
facilitating contributions by Black and his family to philanthropic endeavors. Black was further impressed when he 
learned that David Rockefeller had
appointed Epstein as a director to the Board of Rockefeller University. This appointment was consistent with Black's 
understanding that Epstein was
extremely knowledgeable about science and technology, as well as a strong proponent of scientific research and 
development.
In the mid-I 990's, Black's business and net worth were growing and his children were young so Black was less focused on
matters related
to estate planning. Although he may have discussed such matters with Epstein, such discussions were peripheral at the 
beginning of their relationship.
As the importance to Black of effective tax and estate planning grew over time in the 2000's, Epstein eventually 
recommended that Black retain the
services of a particular trusts and estate attorney from a prominent law firm. That attorney was primarily responsible 
for Black's trust and estate
planning until approximately 2012 or 2013, when Epstein started to take a more active role.
DecheLLPrt Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 6
In mid-2007, Epstein resigned from the Black Family Foundation. However, due to an oversight, the IRS Form 990s filed 
for the Black
Family Foundation during the period 2008-2012 failed to reflect his resignation. Following discovery of the error in or 
around 2013, the Black Family
Foundation issued a confirmation of his earlier resignation.

In 2008, Epstein pled guilty in Florida to two felony offenses: procuring a person under the age of 18 for prostitution 
and solicitation of
prostitution. As a result, he received a I3-month sentence, the majority of which was spent on work release, and one 
year of house arrest before being
released in August 2010. Black was aware of Epstein's guilty plea and understood from Epstein that these offenses arose 
out of a single instance in
which Epstein had received a massage from a 17 year old prostitute. According to Black, Epstein had told him that the 
woman had shown Epstein false
identification suggesting that she was not underage. Black had no client relationship with Epstein at the time.
Black formed the Family Office in 2008 to better manage his finances, trusts, and estate planning. At its inception, the
Family Office
included only a single employee, but it gradually grew over time as Black hired additional management, legal counsel, 
and staff. By 2014, the Family
Office had approximately 10 employees.

Following Epstein's prison sentence, Black believed that Epstein had served his time and that it would not be 
inappropriate to maintain a
personal and professional relationship with Epstein. This decision appears to have been informed by at least three 
factors. First, Black believed that the
severity of Epstein's offenses was limited to a single instance of soliciting a 17 year old prostitute that Black 
believed Epstein had mistakenly
understood was older. Second, numerous prominent figures, including CEOs, banking institutions, leading figures in 
technology, science and business,
diplomats, and Nobel Laureates, continued to maintain social and business relationships with Epstein. Third, Black 
describes himself as someone who
believes in rehabilitation, and in giving people second chances. Based on this belief, he has maintained relationships 
with other notable figures in the
business world, such as Michael Milken and Martha Stewart, who have spent time in prison.
DecheLLPrt Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 7
Black agrees, in hindsight, that he should not have given Epstein a second chance and that he would not have done so if 
he had known
more about Epstein's criminal activity. Dechert has not found any evidence to suggest that Black, during the period of 
their relationship, knew anything
about Epstein's criminal activity aside from the one instance described above, to which Epstein had admitted when he 
pleaded guilty in 2008.
In 2012, Epstein and Black began to discuss a business arrangement pursuant to which Epstein would advise Black and the 
Family Office
on trust and estate planning, tax issues, philanthropic issues, and the operation of the Family Office. The terms of 
this arrangement, a description of the
work provided, and a summary of the payments for this work are set forth below. Black and Epstein's relationship 
deteriorated between 2016 and 2018
over a dispute that had long been simmering regarding payment for Epstein's work, which also is described in more detail
below. Black severed all ties
with Epstein in approximately October 2018.

Throughout Epstein and Black's relationship, Black viewed Epstein as a friend worthy of his trust. They attended social 
events together,
Black confided in Epstein on personal matters, and Black introduced Epstein to his family. Black regularly visited 
Epstein's townhouse in New York to
either discuss business or to meet other prominent guests who were visiting Epstein, including well known businessmen, 
political figures, diplomats,
scientists and celebrities. In general, one-on-one breakfast meetings between Black and Epstein would be more common for
business meetings, whereas
afternoon meetings with other guests would be more common for social visits.
DecheLLPrt Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 8
Regarding travel, Black and his wife briefly visited Epstein at his residence in Paris for drinks on a single occasion. 
Black and his wife
also visited Epstein at his property in Santa Fe on a single occasion, while Black and his wife were on their way to 
California on Black's personal
airplane.2 Black also briefly visited Epstein in Florida on one or two occasions. Black recalls visiting Epstein's 
island in the Caribbean on two occasions
and was accompanied by his wife and one or more of his children on both. Black never spent the night at any property 
owned by Epstein. Black only
recalls flying on Epstein's private airplane on a single occasion, when he and one or more of his children went to meet 
with professors at academic
institutions in the Boston area.

Black viewed Epstein as a confirmed bachelor with eclectic tastes, who often employed attractive women. However, Black 
did not believe
that any of the women in Epstein's employ were underage. Black has no recollection of ever seeing Epstein with an 
underage woman at any time.
Black stated that he was repulsed by the details of Epstein's crimes that were published in late 2018 and regretted ever
having worked with
Epstein. Other witnesses agreed that Black was shocked when the allegations became public. Some witnesses noted 
specifically that they did not believe
Black would have allowed Epstein to be introduced to Black's wife and children if Black had had any suspicion that 
Epstein had done anything
inappropriate or illegal with girls or young women.
III. EPSTEIN PROVIDED SUBSTANTIAL
VALUE TO BLACK AND THE FANIHN OFFICE
Many witnesses believed Epstein provided significant value to Black and the Family Office in the areas of estate and tax
planning.
Although witnesses had different opinions about the extent of Epstein's value on specific projects, it was generally 
agreed that Epstein was an active
participant who provided unique solutions to several issues raised in the Family Office. Dechert found support for this 
in its document review: Epstein
communicated often with members of the Family Office, proposed distinct solutions to issues raised, and provided 
specific feedback with regard to
works in progress. Other Black
2 At Epstein's request, Black and his wife provided transportation from Santa Fe to California on Black's plane to two 
or more of Epstein's adult
guests in Santa Fe.
Dechert LLP
Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 9
advisors, including employees of the Family Office, Paul Weiss, and other outside accountants, lawyers and tax 
professionals would vet his ideas, and he
would regularly challenge them to think outside the box as well as to defend their positions from both a legal and 
pragmatic standpoint. In short, there is
no question that Epstein performed substantive work for Black and that Black genuinely believed that Epstein was 
extremely smart, capable, and saved
him substantial amounts of money.

In addition, Epstein helped manage, and provided oversight to, the Family Office between late 2012 and 2017. In that 
capacity, he worked
on a variety of projects. Witnesses described the following as being the most significant projects during Epstein's 
tenure, although there were a number
of other estate and tax-related projects and issues with which Epstein was involved during this time period.
A. 2006 Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (-GRAT")
There was a consensus among witnesses that Epstein offered a unique solution to a potential estate planning problem that
arose out of a
trust known as the 2006 Grantor Retained Annuity Trust ("2006 GRAT"). Many witnesses opined that this solution — which 
Epstein offered in the
beginning of Black and Epstein's working relationship in late 2012 — was the most valuable piece of work Epstein 
provided Black.
A GRAT is an estate planning mechanism that allows a grantor of a trust to transfer to his or her beneficiaries that 
portion of the assets
contributed to the trust that have appreciated in excess of an assumed growth rate set by the Internal Revenue Service 
("IRS"). If done properly, the
assets should be transferred out of the estate without gift or estate tax liability. The grantor retains the right to 
receive a series of annuity payments from
the GRAT for a specified period of time. Each annuity payment is based on a percentage of the fair market value of the 
assets transferred to the GRAT at
the time of transfer.
DecheLLPrt Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 10
Black was interested in establishing GRATs because they would allow him to transfer certain assets outside of his 
taxable estate as well as
to accomplish other financial and estate planning objectives. Originally, the 2006 GRAT was established by Black's 
former trusts and estates attorney
who had been recommended to Black by Epstein. However, it appears that because of the way the 2006 GRAT had been 
stnictured,3 there was a serious
risk that, absent additional action, the GRAT would carry a future risk of a large estate tax assessment and thus would 
not perform as Black understood it
would. Both a former Family Office employee and outside counsel agreed that, at the time the issue was identified, the 
estate tax would have been
around $500 million. Witnesses differed on what the value of the estate tax would have been today or in the future if 
the issues had not been resolved,
but they believed the estate tax liability could have been as much as $1 billion or more.

Once the potential issues were identified, Black and his advisors attempted to find a way to resolve them. Although 
Family Office
employees and outside counsel offered various solutions, all witnesses agreed that Epstein proposed the best and most 
creative solution to the problem.
Epstein approached Black with his solution — which Epstein asserted was proprietary — and Black agreed to pay Epstein to
implement this solution.
Outside legal counsel described the solution as a "grand slam" and one that met all of Black's financial and estate 
planning goals.
By solving an estate tax problem potentially worth at least $500 million, and possibly substantially more, Epstein 
contributed significant
value to Black and his estate. This was the first project that Epstein worked on for Black and Epstein's success on this
project appears to have validated
Black's trust in him and strongly influenced Black's decision to continue to use Epstein's services going forward.

B. itg Up  Basis Transaction
Beginning in fall 2015, Epstein also appears to have provided significant value to a subsequent transaction that 
addressed certain loans
between Black and certain family trusts for the purpose of achieving a potential tax benefit for Black's children. 
Although witnesses were less certain of
the specific
3 Witnesses differ as to whether an issue with the GRAT had been discussed at the outset, or was only later appreciated 
or identified; regardless, the
issue became apparent to Black, Epstein, and Black's other advisors at or around the time Epstein first began providing 
his services to Black.
DecheLrt L P
Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page II
value of this transaction because the extent of savings was not likely to be known until the future, witnesses agreed 
that this transaction provided
significant value. Epstein estimated that this transaction had saved $600 million in value and Black appears to have 
agreed with that estimate. Outside
counsel stated that this was a complicated transaction that took approximately nine months to plan and execute.
Witnesses noted that there was a dispute following this transaction over whether Epstein had come up with the idea for 
this transaction on
his own or if the transaction had first been proposed by outside counsel. Outside counsel stated that this transaction 
did not originate from Epstein but
that Epstein had nevertheless played an instrumental role in completing it. The extent of Epstein's role in this 
transaction led to a dispute over Epstein's
fees, which is described more fully below.
C. Other Estate Planning Advice
Leveraging his success on the GRAT issue, Epstein continued to provide ongoing advice on a variety of issues regarding 
Black's estate.
This general estate planning advice touched on many different subjects, including providing further advice and planning 
with respect to various trusts,
generation planning, establishing additional GRATs, tax planning, enhancing the Family Office (which, until that time 
was, by all accounts, inadequate
to handle Black's growing estate), and preparing detailed "fire drill" plans that would test how Black's estate would be
treated in multiple different
scenarios based on a variety of assumptions regarding timing of death, price of Apollo stock and other variables. 
Witnesses, including outside counsel,
remarked that, despite Epstein's lack of formal training in law or accounting, his fire drill plans were more detailed 
and comprehensive than any similar
plans they had seen prepared for other clients.

In describing Epstein's contributions to Black's estate planning and other advice, witnesses had varying opinions on the
value of Epstein's
work. Epstein put forth a variety of ideas on many different tasks by circulating lengthy lists of ideas that he thought
should be pursued. Many of those
ideas would appear plausible at face value, but did not hold up under scrutiny. Witnesses, including Black, believed 
that part of the challenge of working
with Epstein was separating the good ideas from the bad ones. There was a general consensus that some of Epstein's ideas
were uniquely creative and
useful, while others were unremarkable or not viable.
DecheLrt L P
Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 12
One area where witnesses believed Epstein provided value to Black's estate included being able to motivate Black to 
concentrate on
certain Family Office issues in a way that others could not. Epstein played an active role in convincing Black to bring 
Black's family members into the
conversation about estate planning, trust formation, and philanthropy. As confirmed by both witnesses and the 
documentary evidence, Epstein played a
central role in meeting with Black's family and explaining to them how Black's estate was organized and to encourage 
them to be more engaged in the
planning process and philanthropy.

D. Tax Planning, Compliance And Audit Advice
Although Epstein had no formal tax training, witnesses agreed that he was very knowledgeable on a variety of issues 
relating to tax
planning, tax compliance, and managing and responding to audit inquiries from taxing authorities. Both witness testimony
and the documentary record
confirm that Epstein played an important role in resolving a number of potentially significant tax-related issues for 
Black during the time period 2013
through 2017, which included, among others: (1) addressing an IRS audit letter relating to the 2013 tax year; (2) 
planning and coordinating the
submission of statements of reasonable cause for a series of tax years to address an apparent failure to file certain 
tax forms, including IRS Forms 8865,
relating to Black's interests in BRH Holdings L.P., a partnership through which Black and the other Apollo co-founders 
hold their ownership interests in
Apollo and related foreign partnerships; (3) addressing an IRS audit letter regarding Black's 2012 tax filings, 
including interfacing with the IRS to
achieve a positive resolution; and (4) advising on tax matters related to Phaidon, a UK publishing entity that Black had
acquired and that had a
particularly complex organizational structure. Epstein would not draft materials related to tax issues on his own, but 
he would make suggestions, provide
criticism, and generally manage the process for addressing tax concerns as they arose.
Dechert Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
L L P Page 13

E. Epstein's Other General Advice
Epstein also appears to have provided substantive advice to the Family Office on myriad esoteric issues, which included 
(i) managing
Black's artwork, (ii) advising on issues relating to Black's yacht, and (iii) advising on issues relating to Black's 
airplane. While witnesses had differing
opinions on the precise value added, there was general consensus that Epstein would get into the weeds on obscure issues
about which otherwise highly
competent Family Office employees were not knowledgeable, such as aspects of specific regulations governing airplane 
usage, and frequently provided
valuable assistance.

1. Managing  Black's Artwork
Family Office witnesses generally agreed that Epstein advised Black in a few areas related to Black's artwork, 
including: (i) the formation
of a new art partnership, (ii) the contested ownership of a Picasso sculpture, (iii) Black's art loans, (iv) like-kind 
exchanges, and (v) obtaining a potential
advisory opinion from the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance regarding a contemplated transaction 
involving Black's art. The value
provided from each project differed depending on the project. Although Family Office employees generally agreed that 
Epstein was not an expert in art
management or art law, witnesses also opined that he was helpful in the formation of the art partnership and was fairly 
involved in assisting Black in
connection with the sale of certain pieces of artwork.

2. Advice Regarding Black's Yacht
Witnesses confirmed that Epstein advised Black on the management of Black's yacht. One witness said that Epstein was 
involved with
Black's initial purchase of his yacht, which involved assisting in structuring the entity that owned the vessel and 
moving it. Mother witness recalled
Epstein advising Black on how to charter the vessel. A third witness said Epstein generally flagged issues regarding the
vessel, but Epstein did not get
into the nuances of managing and advising on tax structuring relating to the vessel. As such, it appears Epstein's 
involvement in yacht-related items
varied depending on the specific project.
DecheLLPrt

3. Advice Regaftilftft-ififtdnillgang
Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 14
Family Office employees opined that Epstein was very knowledgeable about selling and purchasing airplanes, the 
organization of airplane
entities, and the relatively complex and obscure regulations and requirements applicable to airplane usage. Witnesses 
confirmed that Epstein added
value in the restructuring of airplane entities and advising on the certification of the airplane. One Family Office 
employee recalled that an airplane
broker was not pleased when Epstein got involved in the negotiation for an airplane purchase because the broker knew 
Epstein was sophisticated when it
came to airplanes and that it would be hard to negotiate against Epstein. Although the Family Office regularly vetted 
Epstein's views and advice with
outside counsel, Family Office employees agreed that Epstein often pointed Black in the right direction regarding 
airplanes. There thus appears to be a
general consensus that Epstein's input regarding a range of issues pertaining to airplanes was valuable to Black.
F. Improving  The Family Office
In addition to assisting on specific projects, Epstein also played an important role in developing, managing and 
improving the Family
Office, improving recordkeeping, and locating misplaced assets. Witnesses agreed that in 2012, when Epstein began 
working for Black, the Family
Office was ill-equipped to manage Black's growing estate at the sophisticated and expert level that Black expected and 
needed. Epstein appears to have
taken the reins in developing the Family Office by extensively reviewing its operations, advising on personnel changes, 
including interviewing
candidates for employment and recommending terminations of those he felt were inadequate performers, and consistently 
pushing the employees to
improve the quality of their work. Family Office employees were instructed to run most decisions relating to tax and 
estate planning by Epstein so that
he could provide comments and criticism. Several contemporaneous emails from Epstein describe an effort to develop the 
Family Office to a point
where it could operate autonomously. Epstein would liken the Family Office to a house, for which he would play the role 
of architect.
DecheLrt L P
Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 15
By all accounts, Epstein was a strict taskmaster who could be difficult to work with. Epstein was often quick to 
criticize Family Office
employees and had a habit of overdramatizing even minor perceived errors. At the same time, Epstein would seek to take 
credit for good ideas,
regardless of his level of involvement, which likely was intended to bolster his perceived value to Black. As a result 
of these actions, some witnesses
described a toxic and destructive work environment under Epstein. That being said, several witnesses agreed that the 
pressure that Epstein exerted upon
the employees did drive an improvement in their performance.

Black also found Epstein difficult to work with and would often grow frustrated with the frequency and length of 
Epstein's
communications, in which he would identify long lists of perceived issues and problems within the Family Office. Black 
knew Epstein was greedy and a
self-promoter and was likely attempting to prove his own value. At the same time, Black also felt that Epstein was 
identifying genuine issues that needed
to be resolved. As their business relationship continued, Black wanted to "wean" the Family Office off Epstein so that 
he was less reliant on Epstein's
services, but Black found it difficult to do so because, from Black's perspective, Epstein was identifying and solving 
significant issues that were not
being addressed by other employees or advisors. As Black explained, he was annoyed by how often Epstein would complain 
about the "cavities" that
Epstein was finding in Black's "mouth" (the Family Office), but, at the same time, they were all "real cavities" that 
needed to be filled.
Thus, although Epstein's management style made him difficult to work with, and in many ways an overly demanding overseer
of the
Family Office, there appears to be general agreement that Epstein played an important role in driving excellence and 
developing the Family Office in the
period from 2012 to 2017.
DecheLLPrt Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 16

IV. RI .ACK COMPENSATED EPSTEIN BETWEEN 2013 AND 2017 FOR EPSTEIN'S BONA
1,11E PROVISION OF TAX, ESTATE PLANNING AND OTHER RELATED SERVICES
With the assistance of legal counsel, Epstein and Black negotiated a written service agreement that was drafted by 
Black's counsel and
signed on February 13, 2013. Under this agreement, which was entered into between Black and Southern Trust Company, 
Inc., an Epstein affiliate,
Epstein agreed to provide "services deemed appropriate by [Epstein] and Mr. Black in connection with" "estate planning 
matters in respect of

Mr. Black's assets and estate." Those services included Epstein's work on the resolution of the complex 2006 GRAT issue 
starting in 2012. Although
Epstein represented to Black that he generally charged clients $40 million per year for his advice, Epstein agreed to 
provide this initial work for
$23.5 million, which was expected to be made in two installment payments occurring in 2013. Both of these payments were 
made to Southern Trust
Company, Inc.: the first payment of $15 million was made on February 15, 2013, and the second payment of $8.5 million 
was made on October 15,
2013.

Given Epstein's success on the GRAT issue, Black and Epstein appear to have reached agreement on a second service 
contract in around
May 2013 containing a similar description of the scope of services to be rendered. It was also negotiated by legal 
counsel and multiple drafts were
exchanged. Although this agreement appears never to have been signed, both Black and Epstein appear to have largely 
abided by the negotiated terms in
2013. Pursuant to this agreement, Epstein continued to provide additional advice to Black and the Family Office in 2013 
and 2014. In exchange, Black
agreed to pay Epstein $56.5 million in five installment payments over 2013 and 2014. Black made the first two 
installment payments in 2013, totaling
$26.5 million, but the agreement appears to have been renegotiated in early 2014 to cover the outstanding balance plus 
additional amounts. The total
amount paid in 2013 was $50 million.

Starting in 2014, Black began to pay Epstein for his ongoing services on an ad hoc basis, without negotiating written 
service agreements.
In total, Black paid Epstein $70 million in 2014 and $30 million in 2015. Of these amounts, Black attributed $20 million
to Epstein's work on the
step-up basis transaction and attributed the remainder to the various other matters including his advice about estate, 
tax planning, tax audits, and filings,
managing Black's artwork, Family Office management, and advice regarding Black's yacht and airplane as set forth above.
DecheLrt L P
Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 17
Black did not pay Epstein in 2016. In April 2017, he made a final payment to Epstein of $8 million, which appears to be 
attributable to
certain tax advisory and compliance services provided by Epstein. From 2013 through 2017, Black was under the 
misconception that his payments to
Epstein would be tax deductible ("sixty cent dollars") because this is what Epstein had told Black. Thus, Black 
erroneously believed that all of the
amounts he was paying to Epstein would be fully deductible on his tax returns.

Although Black appears to have paid Epstein specific amounts for Epstein's work on the GRAT issue and the basis 
transaction, Black did
not generally view the payments he was making to Epstein as compensation for specific tasks. Instead, Black viewed the 
payments as compensation for
the overall value he believed Epstein was providing to him through Epstein's advice on trust and estate planning, tax 
issues, philanthropic issues, and the
operation of the Family Office. In this context, although not every one of Epstein's ideas produced substantial value to
Black, Black, as well as a number
of witnesses, agreed that the value provided by Epstein to Black and the Family Office substantially exceeded the total 
compensation that Black paid to
him. However, it is clear that the compensation paid by Black to Epstein far exceeded any amounts Black paid to his 
other professional advisors.

V. 01.ACR' LOANED $30.5 MILLION TO EPSTEIN
Separate from the payments made to Epstein or his entities between 2013 and 2017 for services rendered, Black made two 
loans to
Epstein, for $22.5 million and $8 million, respectively, in early 2017. These two loans were negotiated and documented 
by legal counsel. The loans were
structured as being made by BV70 LLC, an entity owned by Black, to Plan D LLC, an entity owned by Epstein. These loans 
were payable on demand
from BV 70 LLC, were intended to be short-term loans and were made in connection with an art transaction involving 
Epstein.
IDechert Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
L L P Page 18
Black demanded repayment of the loans in full in early 2018. In response, Epstein repaid only $10 million of the 
outstanding amount. The
remaining balance of the loans remained unpaid at the time of Epstein's death, despite Black's repeated demands for 
repayment in full during 2018.
VI. BLACK AND EPSTEIN MADE CHARITABLE DONATIONS AT EACH OTHERS' REQUESTS
Throughout their relationship, Black and Epstein each donated to charitable causes and encouraged each other to donate 
to charitable
causes. For example, on at least two occasions, Epstein made significant donations to the Melanoma Research Alliance, a 
charitable foundation
established by Black and his wife, at Black's request. Similarly, Black made donations at Epstein's request to various 
scientific and charitable
organizations, including the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Harvard University, the Arizona State University 
Origins Project, and the Peace
Initiative Foundation. Black also made a $10 million donation to Gratitude America in October 2015, which was a 
charitable organization affiliated with
Epstein.4 Black felt comfortable making this donation because he understood that Epstein was a strong proponent of 
scientific innovation.
VII. BLACK CUT TIES WITH EPSTEIN IN 2018 OVER A FEE DISPUTE
Black and Epstein's relationship deteriorated between 2016 and 2018, largely as a result of a dispute over payment 
regarding the step-up
basis transaction. There appears to have been an understanding between Black and Epstein that Epstein would be 
compensated for some portion of the
value conferred from any idea that originated from Epstein. However, although witnesses agreed that Epstein had played 
an integral role in completing
that transaction, there was a dispute over whether the idea for the transaction had originated with Epstein. Epstein 
claimed full credit for the transaction
and demanded payment of $60 million, which would have been 10% of a perceived benefit of $600 million
4 Separate from this $10 million donation, Dechert's investigation also found a letter from Gratitude America to Black 
on August 21, 2015 in which
Gratitude America thanks Black for a $5 million donation. It was also confirmed in an email from Epstein to Black. 
However, Dechert did not find
any document prepared by Black or the Family Office confirming this donation or any bank record reflecting such payment.
DecheLrt L P
Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 19
that Epstein asserted the basis transaction had provided. Black's legal counsel disputed Epstein's assertions both that 
the idea had originated with
Epstein and that the perceived savings could accurately be measured and quantified in advance. As discussed previously, 
Black agreed to pay Epstein
820 million rather than the $60 million demanded by Epstein.

Following that payment, Epstein sent numerous emails in 2016 and 2017 in which Epstein complained about the lack of 
further payment
and attempted to pressure Black to provide greater compensation. Epstein's communications on these issues were lengthy 
and often included
unsubstantiated assertions regarding work Epstein had purportedly performed for Black, the value of that work, and 
agreements that had purportedly
been made relating to compensation. Epstein's communications also included extended warnings about a number of perceived
issues affecting the
Family Office and Black's estate planning, coupled with assertions that Epstein no longer wished to play any role in 
resolving those issues. Epstein also
would invoke his friendship with Black in those emails, including by referencing personal matters that Black had shared 
with Epstein in confidence,
although there is no evidence that those matters had any relationship to any of Epstein's criminal activity or to any of
Black's payments to Epstein.
Epstein's efforts to push Black for additional compensation proved unsuccessful, with Black refusing to provide any 
additional payment in
2016 and agreeing to pay 88 million in 2017 to compensate Epstein for what appears to be work Epstein had performed 
relating to certain tax advisory
and compliance advice. Both Epstein and Black repeatedly suggested throughout 2016 and 2017 that they should meet with 
legal counsel from Paul
Weiss to address their payment dispute but such meeting did not occur until April 2018 largely because of delay caused 
by Epstein. The April 2018
meeting was demanded by Black after growing tired of Epstein's constant pleas for additional compensation. At the 
meeting, Black gave his legal
counsel and Epstein each an opportunity to demonstrate who had first come up with the idea for the step-up basis 
transaction; it appears that while
Epstein had been instrumental in implementing and consummating the transaction, the idea was in fact originated by one 
of Black's outside lawyers, and
not Epstein. Black made no additional payments to Epstein following this meeting.
Dechert Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
L L P Page 20
Due to the above fee dispute, the difficulty of dealing with Epstein, Epstein's failure to repay $20 million in loans 
and the realization that
Epstein had mischaracterized his fees as being fully tax deductible, Black severed relations with Epstein by October 
2018.
viii. PUBLIC STATEMENTS BY BLACK AND APOLLO
Black and Apollo have made several public statements about their relationship or lack thereof with Epstein. For example,
following
Epstein's July 2019 arrest, on July 31, 2019, Black sent a letter to Apollo's limited partners (the "July 31 Letter'. 
Black also made several statements to
investors in quarterly calls. As part of Dechert's review, Dechert sought to verify the accuracy of these public 
statements. Dechert has determined that
the public messaging from Black and Apollo has been substantially accurate but, in two instances, may warrant additional
context or clarification.
In the July 3I Letter, Black stated that "From time to time, Mr. Epstein provided professional services to my family 
partnership and related
family entities, involving tax, estate planning, and philanthropic advice."5 And in an Apollo earnings call on October 
29, 2020, Mr. Black reiterated that
Epstein provided "professional services to my family partnership and related family entities, involving [estate] 
planning, tax, structuring of art entities
and philanthropic advice." He further stated that Epstein's "work extended over a period of six years from 2012 to 2017 
and I paid him millions of
dollars annually for that work." Black further asserted that "There exists substantial documentary support for the 
services provided. All of Epstein['s]
advice was vetted by the leading law firms, accounting firms and other professional advisors."6 As detailed above, 
Dechert's investigation has confirmed
these statements to be true, based on both documentary support and the testimony of wimesses.7
5 This statement in sum and substance also appears in Black's statement to Apollo employees, dated July 26, 2019, and in
Apollo's Q2 earnings call
on July 31, 2019.
6 Transcript of October 29, 2020 Apollo Earnings Call at 7.

7 Black also stated in the July 31 Letter and elsewhere that on occasion, he had donated money to certain charitable 
organizations with which
Mr. Epstein was affiliated, and that Epstein had made contributions to certain charitable organizations that were 
meaningful to Black. As detailed
above, these statements are substantially consistent with Dechert's findings.
DecheLrt L P
Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 21
In the July 31 Letter, Black further stated that he "was completely unaware of, and am deeply troubled by, the conduct 
that is now the
subject of the federal criminal charges brought against Mr. Epstein."8 As detailed above, Dechert's investigation has 
found nothing to contradict this
statement. While Mr. Black was aware of Epstein's guilty plea in 2008, he was unaware of the scope and extent of the 
criminal offenses that later
surfaced publicly through media reports in 2018, and that culminated in Epstein's arrest in July 2019, and suicide 
shortly thereafter.
In the July 31 Letter, Black also stated in pertinent part that: "Apollo never did any business with Mr. Epstein at any 
point in time9 [and]
[n]either Mr. Epstein nor any company controlled by him has ever invested in any funds managed by Apollo."10 He also 
stated that "Apollo does not
have, and never has had, any relationship with Mr. Epstein." Dechert has found no indication that Apollo ever retained 
Epstein for his services or that
Epstein ever invested in an Apollo-managed fund, and thus Dechert's review can confirm that these statements are 
accurate. That said, the phrases
"never did any business with" and "does not have, and never has had any relationship with" are quite broad in scope. 
Dechert's investigation has
determined that Financial Trust Company, a company owned by Epstein, purchased 263,257 shares in Apollo during its 
initial public offering pursuant
to a directed share offering program
8 See also Transcript of July 31, 2019 Apollo Earnings Call; Black statement to Apollo employees dated July 26, 2019.
9 See also Transcript of July 31, 2019 Apollo Earnings Call at 14; Black statement to Apollo employees dated July 26, 
2019; Transcript of
October 29, 2020 Apollo Earnings Call at 7.
10 See also Transcript of October 29.2020 Apollo Earnings Call at 7.
DecheLLPrt Apollo Conflicts Committee
January 22, 2021
Page 22
managed by the lead broker-dealer in March, 2011.11 Black did not recall that transaction almost a decade later. Dechert
has further determined that in
the early 2000's, Financial Trust Company invested in two other entities, AP SHL Investors LLC and AP Technology 
Partners LLC, which are not
Apollo funds and do not have any formal relationship with Apollo, but were formed by certain Apollo executives to 
explore investment opportunities
that Apollo chose not to pursue.12 In addition, in 2011, Epstein, through Financial Trust Company, appears to have 
invested in Environmental Solutions
World Wide ("ESWW"), a small emissions control company, alongside Black and certain Black family members. Dechert has 
also determined that
Epstein unsuccessfully sought to pitch business opportunities to certain Apollo senior executives, none of which were 
pursued by Apollo or those
executives. While these facts do not render any prior statements false or misleading, it is clear that the facts 
informing what it means to "do business
with" or have a "relationship with" are perhaps more nuanced than might appear at first glance.

Regarding Epstein's efforts to solicit business from Apollo or Apollo senior executives, Black stated in the July 31 
Letter that he "never promoted

Mr. Epstein's services to other Apollo senior executives . ..." Dechert's investigation reflects that while Black did 
not try to pressure his co-founders to
use Epstein, he did positively comment on the substantial value of Epstein's services and, at Epstein's repeated 
request, did try to introduce Epstein to
his co-founders. In the end, neither co-founder hired Epstein or consulted with him on their personal matters. In light 
of these facts, the statement that
Black "never promoted" Epstein is not false but could have been more precise. And it is clear that no Apollo employee 
other than Black ever seriously
considered hiring Epstein, much less actually retained him.

The documentary record suggests that shares were transferred in 2013 to Southern Financial LLC, another entity 
affiliated with Epstein, where
they remained through at least September 2019. It is unknown whether these shares continue to be held, directly or 
indirectly, by Epstein's estate
today.

12 Certain Apollo employees assisted with respect to the operational functions of these entities, such as assisting in 
the preparation of tax returns for
the investors of the entities. However, witnesses agreed that these entities are not Apollo entities and Dechert has not
reviewed any evidence that
suggests Epstein had any role in these investments other than as a passive investor.
EFTA02731393 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-11)
rM
So sorry Jeffrey these things happen when your body had never been given time to properly heal!
So it came out in the toilet and I didnt know what to do so I just flushed the tiny little fetus.
You have made me numb and I hate you for this!
I hope I never have to see you again!
I am not your personal incubator!
where is the baby!
where is Ghislaine!!!
SSR'1EFE.TEERNSAPNNNoR
00RJ FR1V18TI C)HP \,,,JE\iu
lk•L-2
4
g
s &\ \li foliPRvEL
31 0 1N* . Il 1 EljAtpiiLHA
. .., „. , `0 ,
•. 1 - .
'"..-ii  1 Clk0:4 - \J \-V 'r - \ .E A b T
, -1 Tsi I\ rm..-it', 1 o L To \-..q.,ut it 141
gE4--11 .4.
_,,, • ''
TbS 1%,4,1„- C t 1  i_ ItiT SN
000,1s iAJI-It. ITEtliyV e,4% v.V.
4 . 0` 110P:
V\VMDPc :
A p, E t dyR H i i l* °P
NVR E0 ) 1 No ;\.I P IU A
t E 'el \1411S 0 AAA V14 il T .9 ES1,11—.r .
1 t OT 'K. NUT i A i4i4 IK 1 G—‘1. 1 f!!'
\OP01,1 E t S IA '3 b\W- E E HSAO .
0

╭──── Page 4, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

BLEND IN!
HATE THIS CITY!
On Misery's Trail The toll of reporting on human anguish_
1961
I blamed her for everything, but she didn't answer.
I couldn't understand her stupid behavior!
When I hit her she held still, like a true pacifist.
Then I realized what she wanted was for me to love her:
She began to warm up, and I saw her advantages.
Without me, she wouldn't exist, so of course she was grateful.
I gave her a soul, I bloomed out of her as a rose
Blooms out of a vase of not very valuable porcelain,
And it was I who attracted everybody's attention,
Not her whiteness and beauty, as I had at first supposed.
I patronized her a little, and she lapped it up—
You could tell almost at once she had a slave vality. etgel,
I didn't mind her waiting on me, and sh it. O
In the morning she woke me early, re in he
From her amazingly white torso, a ldn' fte ut notice
Her tidiness and her calmness
She humored my weakness 1
Holding my bones in plat d properly.
In time our relationshi
She stopped fitti os  and seemed offish.
I felt her criti • e in o herself,
As if my hab• o ende. some way.
She let in the fts me more and more absent-minded.
And my skin itch aked away in soft pieces
Simply beca
Then I saw t trouble was: she thought she was immortal.
;t  ed after me so badly.
She wa t leave me, she thought she was superior,
And I'd Xeen keeping her in the dark, and she was resentful—
Wasting her days waiting on a half-corpse!
And secretly she began to hope I'd die.
Then she could cover my mouth and eyes, cover me entirely,
And wear my painted face the way a mummy-case
Wears the face of a pharaoh, though it's made of mud and water.
I wasn't in any position to get rid of her.
She'd supported me for so long I was quite limp —
I had even forgotten how to walk or sit,
Background photo of a courtroom with words (and you should never be here alone"
HE SHOULD!
OUR STAND

╭─ Page 9, Image 1 ─╮
│ OUR STAND         │
╰───────────────────╯

Through a Child's Eyes
"What I wanted was . . .
a place where dreams
did not stop at dawn."
PROTECT THE
VANISHING tH11-hRtN
Flashback s
I won't let pain keep me fronkt104
\/- -
O "In the Danger Zone -C° o \_\
•°
Background photos of New York City and quote "Who could have predicted this?"
I should have!
So sad this city could be beautiful if it werent filled with monsters.
The blood from Leon is no longer there.
[clipping: National Geographic June 2004]
SSa\Q5.‘10V0bo“ --ir
0Qkk. ckc, C.. O\ 1.\“
Y(?\1,1\c(“\kO"-e,\0Lo vno,
'‘\\"(\oSQS \'`00(Wf\ S'2'05C
1/2-te. vtr
NAT. -MAE OGRAPIII! • JUNF
Cm rk balts the northward match of a rchllectural glads. Setting Ms camera at er
. 4:ed Central Park West. the photographer made this riek, talmen) lookIng to the southeast.
the el pholographed at night (below), the pad, night ligfits dance and trombi° like
profs Fire. Betond tbc park, etched In lire against noem., skie, tisel the great city.

J. ed Me a sultan's palace oe a gata nipt.
Tomorrow is the halfway ultrasound for Jeffrey.
This one stuck.
After they took the first baby who survived and the early miscarriage I think it was called I
no longer feel like a person but a vessel.
Will they take this one too?
Who has the first one?
Where did Ghislaine go.
She is never around.
I cant let myself get attached.
I am not old or mature enough or even in the place to have baby thetS4Id be responsible for.
I am not even able to focus on anything other than hi ifirSt; agao i c
I had to go to eating disorder treatment prior to bee si thOtion again and missed the entire
fall semester of school.
A 0 t - k I am so very exhausted. IN/ , /
Will I ever be free?
O  70
My body feels so tired.
%...,
0 (/
decC5
t „.„..."‘
T -
en(' o .,?,(11 a u+ a -) re -ri o e rhy
0 orvish,n 001 I f  3u60 3 fry. 11S ns u K. fe-fe.
tottisblowouvvdn-i
- ea I msQrcle,HKI- cle i s
o101ffia hsrieadtler y i c r181
\,0e,S'e11(ae)sokk oe a e h 5 hf r4.
r3 CtI . (0'00 vSew tie+K4 t oeOw 0 ctle.1 1
Irm)acIfsquenu111 , \Inr\
anilom-Vreo
ote')<\
pa
4
11 ikS/C U y yl no h r n 1 9
(‘ S 0 S'a e, Imo *!Z  nn -4 cs-Ve hcin
on
n' +'
Y‘S%\

e. e1 + l'' ort. V) ' gt 111113
Sktlif\%1 ‘ ad
f Smst s chott
. a pi t,
olockar seie nit°, e. e4r oo m
ehuk \ a
sosetAbd e 5 0.1 e i t e,e,‘6ce,
OCY1Cs CkthStinq SeStZ(100 ► al . er f t c0
C\Ntit
et ect -t' - `-
, --k
Qayh wuae

╭──── Page 14, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

I am such a... monster.
I DIDNT CONSOLE HER!
I CANT UNHEAR HER SCREAMS!
THEY HAUNT ME!
I couldnt even bring myself to look at her.
I am a monster.
I deserve to be haunted by her screams.
I AM SO SORRY
I AM S[ ] BROKEN.
IreIv o
USDA. ..
Monster
11N cNoE E 1A-1- k\IER E RAS'OANry
DDT Os L ti CI\l k) I-1 A EROTE!
10Ineebi g \jefooKte I olniAk.e. ci rece,
c kdi npnmS1 -fi ocihr. a a 0 eev+ i3
\lu+dye sraS. r :,ce f
.4
MO OR 111O30 E
s S A
Aft
EFTA02731433 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-11)
O,1,M145,2K1MticitaAMMSMLIMMklq,

Old enough
to drive._
too youncl
to io anyWk , r,  f, ,n1

3
1
sr
FUNERAL FUNERAL
FUNERAL
watches and weeps
FUNERAL
FUNERAL
lays to rest
THERE'S A illtLEVOIT
(<1
(</
tgmmmi
O oNrLtti e.
l e.aok
Sticibuot41 01.ts.Duti\cia 6dbuc
hIttot- bktPiko4 i tOrt. s, Ot t
kt1 ‘.1 k \Ntrca".
o Nwa se,a0 ^cosh
o h i detail b *. tt, 4.
Ocadot f ( o l tk
a tt• w 4 ( o 11 o
ae 4 ,4 t
•

11 t 111)11'1)1)1'n"
c; ??0,77/77A 7i
/-Y4P- 9 ,-, 7,,,,p .6,,p - WOW(' .?7(,) () 1
yp ;4PGY et . ? ,  gp, ,,7p7/7 51-7- ,„, gin''
.1‘.7;r Vi :j77 -
' 4, 0,Z" 1967 7/frili 1/2 716. 7-frt 6 --(
,,9' 01" 72i0 ' to.,, - ,i- ,p(T- RE
((c,77a7r11/ ) 7 / At 2 7 7 P 7PI (1?; ')6V1 X 7171- Z,1-4 ' • R!,/1? icc, or -(q0-9 2, , , 0.97,41 • Aw("22/77-
27205 //-Arwit9- ?"3,47i "077a c‹-; /??- 77-1 7 <0 ,71,h -  / XvIir mom/  / .1To V7/7017
式-
躍鰓控…郡讓轻饔笋彝歹 +轧曬滕攀鑠#巽駑
引审
yo tot -Wee 44-1.1.44,1 Yk<ed
\g-
we". How ort, you?. rketese, IS sopekt),3
Wive ko ;c1N your! use..\\ To •ke.Al
SIrCe
cu,AzakVeci, lam::-0 c,t5SS.
woneuerty-li C yOtA
LUOUk o ti-ke an nnenor \oe 1- -9
u.kek‘ eV 1\ \e,-‘ youTrwlv-
vg
Sinc,erey
H•yht

IN\
always felt very detached from everyone else. Home I um,
going somewhere different, that I was in the o I ow .1, 11
Computer technology
THE SISTER
V) 17 .2
Po-\, s\LN'tHARGE 4, A
N UNDERSTANDING 4),
SEEKER of SOULS
=i

R
a
a

'Very relaxed
STRICTM
CONFID

S
S cat
10.4h5
p i a
inne.
4%11\l'ika)r rIn \stve. oohs
t}0 p rli snS us o Stmc. t i rrin
ma r.
e
Kist ecti pel• seic 1 1 T t i c Xdki i1144
ekni15 1 +1 1 e. i I. h 4pc. 44 ( 4-5 1 4
vas hr S q - 40 e t n
(li ce. <r at f MA 1 i
lyt i C fAt h r t atfre CO id 6 C C(11 14
eaarar l f61 $ 1 4 14ft e
R ear
T ‘)V w tir ma l el.
0 eA4 (Omf CAN SHE HELP?

Her if you can fill out the sexiest oclksdot bikin•
and your Game Boy* Color. Guys dig Wario, a
GET INTO
why are th
,sO
roe tc... NA
moments
of humor,
compassion
and warmth
t‘ • • •
Red Light 0 'Cli
ID el: ,
=
cID
f=f-f
acs with Wanoland
irn, they'l dig you.
Game and Game Bcy sold seper
o many questions?
t tr, kek 1)
} ► v-rny e
t a
51\ t4O'.

THE WAY SHE WAS
Does it matter?
BB=
MEMORY

ON HER
OW\ An Old Lady and a Young Lady
'You always think you're prepared for everything,
and Ku think you hove the knoWedge of what's
coming ahead,' Diana (at Prince Charles's Highg(
esfotilipagare BB
OC 49G 4 tof r I-15 S1k.v.dkc. , G ok. h ci ci f.
0 t\CIN(pf Yu o l- i S 1 1no viol )41 i K
a a e, OAT'. e -40 K IM pt -a roci - ad
o lefiii 3 4 (1( 4s e4'5 1'f? tY
‘4 , tt dions es clApoct q y suis a 5 i C 5
‘nniNcGiaehjuit i 9 n e‘r i 3 S 4b4hirta
(ft lAm-o CruseiNctieu ti ttncirs rg'. r
1 0 t i <k\s/ncbt - aS \Itict i p
gr5 1 e(tic
hOhr I IV l 5fttk r e
Ai env knkarte t n.
Ici fci l aarac .
NI DROWSY SIDE EFFECTS.
b+ t ge! v)h+
Suddenly the insignificant
ugly duckling
was obviously going
to be a swan-
(hrt\...
Oie
NEW YORK
c, • f., Pr risi lick
Wrs C-ciI 4  t tftt
cog f  4 o V.fle -t qoae ra I ct
CP•obt i gc. ce I f INA• I rt tAtn
VI el en q sct ,I. ohcn i-rvymcgt.
c‘plov) s c t 3 4 hc, qi nes r ....\
4C I i4Stc3i, Opnr)+ t--r4,)!
v nasv 1\/ oc ocg' , e1/46 re
1 ,...
i 4!
G4 What a very jolly and sing and attractive 16-
x/ --k
year-old she was ... g•
rekun and bouncy. II
luS% s Til\Art G e tkf\i 41 1. C i Bohr
„Roresk s. r S p d o I- I (le
t 4. S ( r\ kt qta0 -4‘41sQI`i"N •
nhs \luck° 'Da ‘ocue 0 1' 1.
bet i \ay6 vvair ct e,I\
OS"C") tV4 OcIA \tki ail n~
teft i lrli I rogliNsit%t OtSi4-e.
0\1 1›e`t4tNy0. .0 t e oe,.nlY.4 1s
Ivana Trump
Entrepreneur: She once asked me
how h handled the press during
my divorce. She said, "You came
out of your divorce with dignity
and pride, and that's how
would like to come out of mine."

People come to your party for two reasons.
One because they like you.
The other because they like to

conrOPININIM problem NAUSEA
a sea of
grief ...
'HIS IS
you know our name S
Bet
\No, a ehsb
hkr k C, test>Wya
V\i sr \\i , voo M. ct
4t ht s`.  co y.
NkVor \1/4'\ 5 M i d c tA t  V\ Goti-e-,r.t isc

t. a k- r. u, knig, r. ( oa. c. Odai tat( A Kr‘CI—
hte s u v. I;‘
()Maw aff LAW peaa
41
4
a
a
I
ophe clea/IGN
1P-i-yr"
IS THERE A
WAY
BREAK FREE
smile.
wikl iv\
Incredible
Exceptional
Outstanding
Performance.
car
CHILD.
But it doesn't
stop there.
It NIE\J-EK
ToNyour
TABLETS
how I survived
STOP I I FR011
A PERSONAL
nothing gets remembered
MEW I kin
(121(
nigh
3 You had to either sink or swim, and you had to learn
2 that very fast ...I swam.
2
1
3
3
3
3
3
3
2.
rjr/ ci (7.7. 20/ or' Sint (71
40- down MADISON AVENUE
tAtit chs
I OVI leas sht kct g ici.
uvn rnn
4-k14 nOntil bcv e r t c
-to llsi -
NEW YORK
• • v u VA h n r t & Me a d 4 s3c
i 1 i pra 4o s mtno (Ye o i:AZe 0 t castte ct;cs o til dA-ne( 0 eesnkir
mhott i• ate •FS.onk so li\
o t
okaaivkJekaf tv (rnitchv\ht
oa l ff i4 Crta2 C woh 5-Es oe ,Sc i
I ( eve s apty* v, st e \i ve.l t! inoe. 1Y.
No sklk mo-h) ad ena 4
0t‘k proAnto cn c
was
crying
out for
help...
hate pain,
1 4?‘/- t t e r rpntm
gi t urd hi ti clout
---1/4wenh fo(noi toa)
ett ()It l oad Obodi
Raging
Pc hntef I•i‘ g b t
„ V
really sick.
you lshould cal 911. TEARS
OF
RAGE

187 Stopped Dead Lo go 14efi IC
A squeal of brakes.
Or is it a birth cry?
And here we are, hung out over the dead drop
Uncle, pants factory Fats°, millionaire.
And you out cold beside me m your chair.
The wheels, two rubber grubs, bite their sweet tails.
Is that Spain down there?
Red and yellow, two passionate hot metals
Writhing and sighing, what sort of a scenery is it?
It isn't England, it isn't France, it isn't Ireland.
ft's violent. We're here on a visit,
With a goddam baby screaming off somewhere.
There's always a bloody baby in the air.
I'd call it a sunset, but
Whoever heard a sunset yowl like that?
I Goo SI
in 2
VI 0
No
1 0
••C '" 1/4
X
a
.... e-
lan a
You arc sunk in your seven chins, still as a ham.
Who do you think I am,
Uncle, uncle?
Sad Hamlet, with a knife?
Where do you stash your lif
Is it a penny, a pearls0 41 ea&
Your soul, your s‘ t
I'll any it off pret gi
Simply open r and sjyyt of the car
r ort o r. And live i
r  4O N...,
19 October 102
And ne matter tt,t,
with, gives you
the power to be btrd

S
a
1
3
3
3
3
3
3
z 1/4
r i Co /
‘Ma l  c at\
t o soti oE tArAci4a
ninehl)S,Nvnt\ t e, A b oiNk
4-C 6. tve coiwr (“aea %tie os)?eectl. ;epo INuSNInue, odtbct i el)Cewo litn

ANXIETY IS.FIN DING
?t•C7(5-e,
1? \AA(7-6 c-i.e36,-
tI \e-nolk)
-ra IV- at70,-La-
could still
make her
laugh
AlaxeoII Shoe i ..
HER MAGIC
V
How much do you need to s1
to know i"i beauti'
s3ht',5
1\10 011
picks up more
dirt than
o one
4,1\'\ k.'`\
will ever be able to fill them.
AAS
SAM &LIBBY

a
a
survive
YOU HAVE tternimrc TO LOSE
fVEtz`
th sensitivity and grace
never forget where real beauty comes from.
Beauty is insid
•
I
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
I
I
theorie: -7or every Jibe progem
aere's a
.Cosa . nisokiion.
best
e.0 e, eifIbct te,v4e.
hckdsn Vot kei-Ni rrhn
Stvhf act o
hp} t sfONSV
pcueeogf
clith0
Soi l
hod
TEARS OF RAGE
riVtesel be
tehS0ke, n...
Murders
Ilitilevilutti
lytkpla
t.)cInc; c?
KILLER'
Flights of €ancy horror
The more you pay, the more you et.
Is this: A) False B) Untrue Crazy?
who knows how many times •••
more times than I can count.
z"‘ Te N ihefe , ,t4 oS
V1 ea as 19 1.< , kvo riwtIff y et\
MCs,MSy r. o9nrnbi gorwa
c.ue r. 11 cc) 'HAc laco e tn beo e ba
.‘ 9 `i 0 fe era v. r e- 0 d v t\ e d, s L. Sro A d
trn'Avtiot dr l o ( rI ee, rnQ i
rt i csierA l tAt o ccl y ti ck-ignpo ( Vu
o ‘nAia i s e, s. a s cnkke$etsinnet ot ePe 6
e, c sz, got t t 0 e. cl e, er e, ic h Olt\
lceE 06 .l e Y\ S 114 r t ic.Ga thtWo dki
v~lhluo.(n?Qeq IA )(14\t d rne Avic5 ccoi!tli
'i e 6661/4 r"r. i 51 3 C6gicl.haSeiC.rzi cos t.
A
Flights of fancy nocror
The more you pay, the more you et.
Is this: A) False B) Untrue Crazy?
more times than I can count.
Te c‘z,10 is6otere:tV e is
V1 ra As Ivc if\r-1.Wf y r. ett
\--\' CS,h targb e, er_ki• 5 r. ognrnbi gorway
c.at t. 11(9711.k.N.,NeY,ACI ctoc e znbcoe bta
4q ." st.‘9`1 00\-e a wr e, a dI v n el - cl,fs I...hro Ad
t ti\ INI 'lot ar t o l( rnee , rne, i i ft L. t- r. n
n~ i 9cSteMl n, 0 0frdVqr - i 3 npo i YU
0y\Aia i S ,•,, s. a s coikeb e, e,shna ot eP e 6
e,vck qp I t ocie, cMiter e, ic 11`1Oin
l( tk o e, adieu Y\ I 3 n -f r ItGo Vst khtvio ati
VJAh \V- 0.( (\P (leg M\(oA d rne tvir5 Ca0‘ 1.
e,ie l;a0t o, tbe. r. i 513 C&Scl.hasekc.rzi al

we understand that
It takes more than days or weeks or months. It takes years and even decades. To grow and nurture and
to grow up big and strong
develop into something that stands proud and magnificent Pay tribute to the determinatior. required
and stable takes a really,
to produce such hearty roots. And let us all live by its simple creed: grow, blossom and flourish.
really, reall& at time.
"THAT THE FUTURE c...14AY
LEARN FROM THE PAST"
EFTA01618440 (Jmail)
(inferred timestamp: 2026-01-11 22:19:34)
Platform: iMessage Timezone: UTC+0000

• 1212 5333739
+1 (212) 533-3739
2017/06/24
Sneaky!!! How are you?
10:13:44 pin
10:13:55 pin
My new shoes bought with on a big sale but still $800
10:14:32 pin
To wear with my costume to work
10:14:44 pin
Do you like it?
10:15:07 pin
Spent my last money didn't mean to buy two pairs 41.ibut s0000 happy t:
10:15:48 pin
10:16:03 pm
White one are a replacement for the one you bought me 5-6yrs ago
10:16:34 pm
Couldn't find anything closer
10:16:56 pm

• Thank you so much 1,11/
10:19:34 pm
• Yay! Thank you!
11:38:17 pm
1212 5333739
ys great
10:48:18 pm
2017/06/27
Sneaky tried to call you
12:22:56 am
Thank you so much!!!,
12:23:06 am
Did you hear from Manything else. I am confused were those final election
results?
12:24:30 am

• Ah ok I see. No decisive winner... second round run-off
12:27:48 am
2017/07/01
09:06:43 am
2017/07/05
Sent an attachment
Filename: IMG_0017.MOV.mov
Path: IMG_0017.MOV.mov
Size: 19 MB
Type: video/quicktime
07:18:45 pm
•
•
07:18:52 pm
2017/07/06
2017/07/12
Sneaky sorry just woke up! Yes I can get dressed and come?
01:54:01 pm
2017/07/13
Sneaky, one question —
1212 5333739
Wow
06:51:57 am
06:38:57 pm

• • w
1212 5333739
Ok
07:04:13 pm
Sent
Sent! Safe flight sneaky, miss you already! '11
07:41:06 pin
And thank you so so much for all your help and support! You are the best
07:41:30 pm
Read
EFTA00003067 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
(inferred date: 2026-01-12)
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel:
Date: NI 1/12
Employee Name: Randy Amparo
Address:
Phone:
Title / Position: Boat Captain
imergency Information:
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood Type:
Emergency Contact Form
Cell:
Start Date:
Date of Birth:
Marital Status: Single License:
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name: Phone:
Doctor's Name: Phone:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact:
Relationship
AlitJame Relationship
Father
Mother
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003945 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00008863 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Ghislaine Maxwell
╔════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Cynthia Rodriguez [bank] Deutsche Bank employee 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01402630 (Jmail)
 [money] transactions by Epstein's Southern Financial LLC
(inferred date: 2026-01-12)
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 1 of 12
U Close Window
W Print This Page
g Expand All I Collapse All
Southern Financial LLC
Customer Record
Type
Client
Customer Name Southern Financial LLC
Relationship SOUTHERN FINANCIAL
RELATIONSHIP
* Type
SSN
Organization
Federal Tax ID # 66-0799192
Referral Source
Name of Referral
Source
Third Party Referral
Source
Customer Owner Paul Morris
German PO
Created By Komal Shahani, 5/28/2013 10:27 AM
Last Modified By Relational Junction, 9/28/2015 2:13 PM
GCIS Customer
Number
Bank 1
* Moderate Risk
* High Risk
Risk Reason KYC1195100
Risk Rating: .521
C 02
KYC 1082293
Status
Client Since Date
Former Client?
Portfolio
Management Team
Covenant Contact
Preference
* Booking Location
Switzerland
Form K
Custom Links
View DB Accounts and Revenue Client/Assets At Risk
Request Customer Deletion
Request Primary Officer Change Import Documents
Request New Relationship
Launch NAO Wizard
Launch Due Diligence
Classification
Potential New
Revenue
Client
Satisfaction
Industry
Unconfirmed
Investor Status
Investor Status
Definitions
* DB is
Trustee/CoTrustee
http://pwm.intranet.db.com/new/filehandler.php?
getFile=us/docs/InvestorStatusAddendum 10_24_07.pd
Export
Documents
View Documents From
Repository
Log Client Complaint
Create Annual Client Update
Request ACU Contact Exemption
View Exemption Guidelines
Generate Key Relationship
Report
Launch ALAT Process
View Loan Covenant Details
Active
8/26/2013
Risk Type
Volcker Covered
Fund?
Will Appointment
Gross Estate
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 2 of 12
Revenue Tier D (< $25K)
Forbes
Ranking
* DB
Employee?
* DB managed
PIC
* Bearer
Shares?
Segment
Financial Profile (KYC Information)
* Net Worth
(Individual)
* Investable Assets <$1 MM
*Estimated Annual
Income (Individual)
*Estimated Annual
Gross Income
(Entity)
*Estimated Annual
Net Profit (Entity)
$2,000,000.00
$1,500,000.00
Investment Objective
Risk Tolerance
Sophistication
Source Of Income
* Source of Wealth
(Individual)
* Description of
Wealth/Entity Assets
The initial funding in February 2013
was $1,000 from the sole shareholder
of the sole managing member (Jeffrey
Epstein).
Assets Held Elsewhere (KYC Information)
* Institution 1 JPMorgan
* Institution 2
* Institution 3
Additional Information (Entities Only)
* Nature of business
* Est. AUM 1
* Est. AUM 2
* Est. AUM 3
$1,000,000
This business is funded by Jeffrey
Epstein's wealth. This company was
formed to hold Mr. Epstein's personal
wealth and invest in different
ventures. This company invests in
real estate, equities, commodities, etc
and gets its revenue from the gains it
makes in these investments. It is a
company formed to invest the assets
of Mr. Epstein
* Country of Incorporation
Registration
* Date of
Incorporation/Registration
* Countries where
business is transacted
* Number of Employees 3
US Virgin Islands
2/25/2013
US Virgin Islands
* Type of Entity Company
* Type of Entity
Other (specify)
* Purpose of Entity: Private Investment
* Purpose of Entity
Other (specify)
*Description of
Organizational
Ownership
Southern Trust Company Inc is the
sole member of Southern Financial
LLC. Jeffrey Epstein is the sole
shareholder of Southern Trust
Company Inc
Biography
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 3 of 12
Description
Investment Guidelines
Initial Financial
Review
High Risk Updates/ACU Exemptions
Exemption Status
Auto Exempt Reason
Exemption Reason
Other (describe
reason)
Birthdate
ACU held in
Customer
ACU on this
Customer also Cover
Contacts
Southern Financial LLC
Salutation
Primary
Main Contact
Phone
Primary Phone Type
Email
Fax
Mobile
Description
DB Accounts
N4G023804 - SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
Account Id N4G023804
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Product Name Brokerage Advisory
Market Value $108,959,911.00
Date Opened 8/26/2013
Active
Balance As Of 9/25/2015
Description
N4G025080 - SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
Account Id N4G025080
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Product Name Brokerage Advisory
Market Value $0.00
Date Opened 10/8/2013
Active
Balance As Of 9/25/2015
42952771 - SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
Account Id 42952771
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Product Name Deposit Transactions
Market Value $2,212,470.13
Date Opened 9/5/2013
Active
Balance As Of 9/25/2015
Description
N4G026161 - SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
Account Id N4G026161
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Product Name Brokerage Advisory
Market Value $8,554,181.00
Date Opened 11/4/2013
Active
Balance As Of 9/25/2015
Annual Client Update
Due Date
Past-Due Explanation
High Risk InPerson
Meeting Due Year
Lending Review Due
Date
8/25/2016
Overdue (1=Yes) 0
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 4 of 12
Description
PIC483882 - Southern Financial LLC
Account Id PIC483882
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Product Name PIC DESK
Market Value
Date Opened 2/9/2015
Active
Balance As Of
Description
N4G025403 - SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
Account Id N4G025403
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Product Name Brokerage Advisory
Market Value $0.00
Date Opened 11/4/2013
Active
Balance As Of 9/25/2015
Description
Opportunities
Suntex
Product Family Brokerage
Stage Developed
Close Date 12/31/2015
Total Assets $5,000,000.00
Total Estimated Revenue $0.00
Probability (%) 25
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q1-2015
Next Step
Type New Product - Existing Client
Last Modified Date 9/1/2015
Description
Structured Credit
Product Family Global Lending
Stage Proposal
Close Date 9/30/2015
Total Assets $50,000,000.00
Total Estimated Revenue $1,500,000.00
Probability (%) 50
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q4-2014
Next Step
44129252 - SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
Description
Account Id 44129252
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Product Name Money Market Business Account
Market Value $0.00
Date Opened 9/5/2013
Active
Balance As Of 12/4/2013
Description
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 5 of 12
Type New Product - Existing Client
Last Modified Date 5/27/2015
Description
Additional Brokerage
Product Family Brokerage
Stage Business Committed-Not Funded
Close Date 3/31/2015
Total Assets $75,000,000.00
Total Estimated Revenue $2,000,000.00
Probability (%) 75
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q2-2014
Next Step
Type Additional Assets - Existing Product
Last Modified Date 1/7/2015
Description
More Brokerage
Product Family Brokerage
Stage Business Awarded
Close Date 12/13/2013
Total Assets $15,000,000.00
Total Estimated Revenue $0.00
Probability (%) 100
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q1-2013
Next Step
Type Additional Assets - Existing Product
Last Modified Date 12/13/2013
Description
Additional Funds
Product Family Brokerage
Stage Business Awarded
Close Date 12/12/2013
Total Assets $11,000,000.00
Total Estimated Revenue $0.00
Probability (%) 100
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q1-2013
Next Step
Type Additional Assets - Existing Product
Last Modified Date 12/12/2013
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 6 of 12
Description
Additional Brokerage
Product Family Brokerage
Stage Business Awarded
Close Date 12/5/2013
Total Assets $10,000,000.00
Total Estimated Revenue $0.00
Probability (%) 100
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q1-2013
Next Step
Type Additional Assets - Existing Product
Last Modified Date 12/9/2013
Description
Brokerage Funds
Product Family Brokerage
Stage Business Awarded
Close Date 11/26/2013
Total Assets $5,992,414.75
Total Estimated Revenue $0.00
Probability (%) 100
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q4-2012
Next Step
Type Additional Assets - Existing Product
Last Modified Date 11/26/2013
Description
Brokerage #2
Product Family Brokerage
Stage Business Awarded
Close Date 10/18/2013
Total Assets $14,500,000.00
Total Estimated Revenue $0.00
Probability (%) 100
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q4-2012
Next Step
Type New Product - Existing Client
Last Modified Date 10/18/2013
Description
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015

╭──────────────────────────────── Page 12, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────────╮
│ https: //dbforcepb.my.sales force. com/0016000000qaNVw/p? retURL=/0016000000qaNVW │
│ 9/28/2015                                                                         │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 7 of 12
Brokerage
Product Family Brokerage
Stage Business Awarded
Close Date 10/14/2013
Total Assets $45,367,567.00
Total Estimated Revenue $0.00
Probability (%) 100
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q4-2012
Next Step
Type New Product - Existing Client
Last Modified Date 10/15/2013
Description
Southern Financial LLCProduct
Family Banking Products
Stage Business Awarded
Close Date 10/10/2013
Total Assets $330,000.00
Total Estimated Revenue $1,320.00
Probability (%) 100
Expected Revenue
Lead Source
Owner Full Name Paul Morris
Won
Fiscal Period Q4-2012
Next Step
Type New Product - New Client
Last Modified Date 10/10/2013
Description
Customer Team
Amanda Kirby
Team Role Banking Officer
Cases
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire USD Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 9/28/2015
Status New
Owner Jj Litchford
Description
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD Banking
Type
Case Subject
Cynthia Rodriguez
Team Role Private Banker Support
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 8 of 12
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 7/28/2015
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 6/30/2015
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 5/29/2015
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 4/13/2015
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 3/12/2015
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description
Case Record Type Internal Cash Transfer - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 2/9/2015
Status Verified
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 9 of 12
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 9/9/2014
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description subcr to Kyara Investment III, LLC to fund Blockstream Investment
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 7/2/2014
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description subcr to Kyara Investment II, LLC to fund Wearality Investment
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 5/14/2014
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description
Case Record Type Case
Type Customer Request
Case Subject Service Issue- Banking
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 5/12/2014
Status Closed
Owner Kathryn Stanfield
Description
Margaux Mcgrath [12:21 PM]:
Hi Kathryn! Is there a way to rush wire transfer case 01229660? Client
requested Fed ref ASAP and I
want to ensure it goes through
Kathryn J Stanfield [12:22 PM]:
let me get them to approve it
Margaux Mcgrath [12:22 PM]:
Thanks so much!
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Transfer from 42952771 - SOUTHERN FINANCIAL LLC
Transfer to 42959017
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 10 of 12
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 5/12/2014
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description
Case Record Type Cash Disbursement - Wire - USD - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 5/2/2014
Status Verified
Owner Banking STP Processing
Description
Case Record Type Checkbook Order - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 10/29/2013
Status Verified
Owner GTO - Banking (Financial)
Description DLT103-1. Please Rush. Address on checks previously ordered
wasn't correct
Case Record Type Checkbook Order - Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 10/23/2013
Status Verified
Owner GTO - Banking (Financial)
Description DLT103-3. 3 to a page
Case Record Type Misc Client Instructions -Banking
Type
Case Subject
Contact Name Southern Financial LLC
Date Opened 10/18/2013
Status Verified
Owner GTO - Banking (Non-Financial)
Description Please link this account and account #42952771 to Online Banking
ID: 1030850
Case Record Type Case
Type Internal Request
Case Subject New Account Opening
Contact Name
Date Opened 8/20/2013
Status Closed
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 11 of 12
Owner DBOI Account Opening Review
ABR- Please vett the signing authorities & review this account with W-9 for
approval (Attn: Pema
Sherpa).
Description
New Banking
KYC#: 01082293
NAO#: 648057
Open Activities
REMINDER: KYC Update required for this Customer. Click on "Related To" link.
Type Call
Task
Task/Event Record Type Task
Due Date 9/5/2014
Status In Progress
Priority Normal
Assigned To Paul Morris
Comments Please change the Staus of this task to 'Completed' when the KYC
Update is Submitted
Notes & Attachments
0858 001.pdf
Type Attachment
Owner Jj Litchford
Description
View file
Related To 01467139
W-9.pdf
Type Attachment
Owner Kusam Saini
Description
View file
Related To 01115898
SF Account Opening Docs Signed.pdf
Type Attachment
Owner Amanda Kirby
Description
View file
Related To 01115898
Annual Client Updates
Meeting/Call Date 8/25/2015
Meeting/Call Type Phone Call
Created By Amanda Kirby, 9/2/2015 3:32 PM
Meeting/Call Date 9/3/2014
Meeting/Call Type Phone Call
Created By Amanda Kirby, 9/5/2014 11:53 AM
AIS Requests
AIS-00003326
revised first page of application.pdf
Type Attachment
Owner Kusam Saini
Description
View file
Related To 01115898
W-9 ST and SF.pdf
Type Attachment
Owner Amanda Kirby
Description
View file
Related To 01115898
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
Southern Financial LLC salesforce.com - Unlimited Edition
Page 12 of 12
Requestor Paul Morris
Product: Secondary Opportunities Fund III LP MASTER FUND
Request Status Fulfilled
Request Date: 1/17/2014
AIS-00003346
Requestor Paul Morris
Product: Secondary Opportunities Fund III LP - U.S Taxable
Request Status Fulfilled
Request Date: 1/21/2014
Audit Trail
Copyright 0 2000-2015 salesforce.com, inc. All rights reserved.
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/0016000000qaNVw/p?retURL=/0016000000qaNVw
9/28/2015
EFTA00007543 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00009448 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-13)
Page 1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
IN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR
Federal Grand Jury, 07-103
West Palm Beach, Florida
February 27, 2007
APPEARANCES:
, ESQUIRE
Assistant United States Attorney
Foreperson
TESTIMONY
OF
•
ORIGINAL
Cam I (9617
(
Page 2
The sworn testimony of
2 was taken before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm
3 Beach Division, West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County,
State of Florida, on the 27th day of February, 2007.
, Court Reporter, was authorized to
and did report the sworn testimony.
Page 3
1 (The witness entered the grand jury room.)
3 having been duly sworn by the grand jury foreperson,
4 was examined and testified on her oath as follows:
5 EXAMINATION
6 By
7 Q Good morning, special agent Could
8 you restate and spell your name for the record.
9 A It'S
11 Q Can you remind the grand jury who you are
12 employed by?
13 A The FBI.
14 Q I know that you testified here a few weeks ago.
15 Was there anything from that testimony that you wanted to
16 correct?
17 A I did. I was asked by one of you Mr. Epstein's
18 age, and I confused him with another individual in another
19 one of my cases. His birthdate is January 20, 1953. We
20 are looking at the time period of 2004 and 2005. So
21 Mr. Epstein would have been about 51 or 52-years-old, and
22 I believe I told you he was 45. So at the time we're
23 looking during this investigation, he is 51 or 52.
24 Q Agent how did this case first come
25 to the attention of the police?
Co-h f01, 13
Page 4
1 A In March of 2005, our youngest
5 the town of Palm Beach.
7 A
9 identity, correct?
20 A lives in the
21 area here in Palm Beach County.
22 Q At the time, in 2005, what school was she
23 attending?
24 A
25 Q What year was she in school?
identified victim -- her called the Palm Beach
police department and reported that she believed that her
stepdaughter had been molested by a male that resided in
So today we are going to talk about IP
Yes.
And we are using her initial to protect her
A Yes.
Q Can you tell the grand jury III date of
birth?
A birthday is
Q And you mentioned that the call came in from
in March of 2005, correct?
A Yes.
Q So how old was at that time?
A She was 14.
Q Where does live?
(
Page 5
a
1.1
A She was a ninth-grader there.
Q You mentioned that her called the
Palm Beach police department. What did the police
department do in response to that call?
A They wanted to interview
the next day they went out to where
school at that time, which I think was
. I believe it was
was attending
. They
interviewed at and wanted to get her side
of what took place.
Q Because we'll be referring to this throughout,
what was the name of the detective who conducted that
first interview?
A Detective=
So in March of 2005, detective talked with
. Was ever interviewed at any other times?
A Yes. She was interviewed -- they talked to her
again. She placed some controlled calls for them later
that month, we will talk about that later. As well as
she was interviewed about a year later in July of 2006.
Not interviewed, but she testified before the grand jury
for the State of Florida. So she was interviewed by
detective in March of 2005, and then about a year or
three or four months later, in July of 2006, she testified
before a grand jury with the State of Florida.
25 Q In preparation for your appearance today, did
(Ertl (06(3
1 you have a chance to interview ?
2 A Yes, I did.
3 Q And when was that?
4 A Last night.
s Q Back in March of 2005, you mentioned that
6 detective met with on or more than one
7 occasion?
8 A Yes.
9 Q If you could give us sort of an overview of what
10 reported during these interviews, and then if there
11 are specific discrepancies or differences, we will return
12 to those later.
13 A All right. On February 5, 2005, it was a
14 Saturday, and I. was at house, I. She
15 was there with her boyfriend, I. And because these
16 are minors, we'll refer to them without using their last
17 names, so I'll use those initials.
18 They were at residence, and I. is
19 boyfriend, which is also cousin. So they
20 were all at house, and was on the phone with
21 an individual that refers to as the assistant.
22 described the assistant as a tall blonde.
23 So throughout I'll refer to her as the blonde lady, if
24 that's okay. was unable to recall her name. So
25 is on the phone with the assistant for Jeffrey
Page 61i
Page 7
1 Epstein.
2 and overhear on the phone
3 describing describing to the lady on
4 the phone. So when gets off the phone, and
5 both want to know why was being described to
6 this lady on the phone. becomes upset when
7 asks if she would like to go to Palm Beach and give a
8 man a massage that she knows. agrees, and this
9 upsets , and an argument ensues where and
10 go into the bathroom and they argue outside the presence
11 of
12 Q Let me stop you there. Was supposed to be
13 paid for giving this massage?
14 A Yes. told that she would be paid
15  $200 or $300, I believe.
22 have known what was doing for this man and the work
23 that did for Mr. Epstein, and that is why was
24 so upset.
25 0 So knew that this wasn't just a regular
You mentioned that is , and
is also correct?
A Yes.
Q What was idea about why they were
arguing?
A She has told us that she believed that must
CArei  ( (3
Page 8
massage that was going to take place?
A Yes.
Q So and have this argument. What does
decide to do?
A decides to go.
Q Because she wanted to make the $200 or $300?
A Yes.
Q So tell us then what happened after that
meeting?
A The next day, February 6 -- they discussed that
evening about going the next day. We do have on
phone records two calls that were placed. One was placed
to cell phone, and the other was placed to
Jeffrey Epstein's residence the night of February 5.
The next day is contacted a couple of times
before arrives. Each time prior to being
contacted by a call is placed by to
cell phone. , I should tell you, is
Jeffrey's assistant.
So on Sunday a call was placed to
and then shortly after that a call was made to . That
same series occurs again, but this time places a
call to Mr. Epstein's residence, and then is called
again.
Eventually, comes to residence with
Page 9
1 another girl in the car, I* So the two of them
2 arrive at residence, and they continue over to
3 Mr. Epstein's house.
4 Q is driving with and . Do you
5 know how they were sitting?
6 A You know, I'm not sure how they were sitting,
7 but I know that it was a pickup truck that drove,
8 and was the driver. I'm not sure exactly the
9 placement of the other two girls, but they were in the
10 truck.
11 Q And was able to describe how they travelled
12 to the island of Palm Beach?
13 A Yes. She gave directions -- you know, the best
14 that she could on how she was able to come to
15 Mr. Epstein's residence.
16 Q Once they arrived at the residence, what
17 happened?
18 A I should have mentioned that either the night
19 before or the day of, there were some things that
20 tells . One, she tells that she is to tell, if
21 asked, that she is 18-years -of-age, that she attends high
22 school, that she's in the 12th grade, and I believe it was
23 that she was to say that she went
24 to.
25 Talking to ■ last night, told us that
Celt- ) (l b 13
Page 10
once she arrived at the residence tells her that she
may possibly be asked to take her clothes off. She also
tells her that she can stay in her bra, but she may be
asked to take her clothes off. And told us last
night that that's when she knew for the first time that
she might have to possibly remove her clothes.
At this point they proceed to enter the
residence. describes him as a security person. He
approached and asked what they were doing there, and
said they were there to see Mr. Epstein, or see Jeffrey.
He allowed them entry into the kitchen area by the pool,
and describes that area. So now and
are all sitting in the kitchen. A short time goes
by and Mr. Epstein, as well as the assistant, enter the
kitchen.
Q And I know that you mentioned that did not
know the name of the lady who was there in the kitchen,
correct?
A Right.
Q She just described her as a blonde, tall lady?
A Yes.
Q Was also interviewed about what happened
that day?
A She was interviewed by the Palm Beach police
department.
Page 11
1 Q Did IM identify the person who was on the
2 phone with her as IIIII
3 A Yes, she did.
So even though IIII doesn't know her name, IIIII
5 knew name?
6 A Yes.
7 Q So you mentioned that the three girls are in the
8 kitchen, along with Jeffrey and the person calls the
9 blonde lady?
10 A Yes.
11 Q What happened then?
12 A follows the blonde lady upstairs to
13 Mr. Epstein's bedroom. The blonde lady proceeds to take
la out a massage table and set it up, prepare it. She also
15 takes out some lotions to be used during the massage.
16 told me last night that the blonde lady asked her to
17 remove her clothing, and then left the room and said that
18 Mr. Epstein would be in shortly.
19 Q What happened after she left the room?
20 A Shortly after that, Mr. Epstein does come into
21 the room and shakes hand. told us last night
22 that Mr. Epstein told her to remove her clothing. He
23 leaves the room and comes back in just a towel, and he
24 tells her again to -- she is at that point -- when he
25 walked in the first time she had on her bra and her pants.
ct 3
Page 12
When he comes back in, he tells her that she needs to take
2 her pants off. So she took her pants off. So now she's
4 Q At some point did tell any of the people
who interviewed her what was running through her mind?
6 A She stated at one point that she was upstairs
7 with him, with the man, and that was downstairs. I
8 guess she says, "What could do? She's downstairs,
23 laying on the table, he has a towel covering his bottom,
24 and she is straddling him with her bottom touching the
25 towel and some skin touching his lower back. She was kind
in her bra and underwear.
I'm upstairs." So she did what she was asked to do.
Q So now you mention that Mr. Epstein is here
wearing just a towel, and has removed both her shirt
and her pants, is that correct?
A Yes.
Q Tell us what happens then?
A Mr. Epstein gets on the massage table lying on
his stomach and instructs how to do the massage. He
tells her to put some lotion on her hand and instructs her
on how to actually perform the massage. At one point
during the massage he tells that she would be more
comfortable to get on top of him, so gets on top of
him and straddles Mr. Epstein's back.
The way describes it is Mr. Epstein is
I
Page 13
of sitting -- it sounds like sitting on his rear end, but
2 with part of her skin touching him -- the front of him,
3 but he had a towel across his bottom.
4 Q What happens as she is providing the massage to
5 his back?
6 A The massage goes on. She said the entire
7 massage lasted anywhere from 30 to 45 minutes. At one
8 point Mr. Epstein excuses himself for a few minutes, one
9 or two minutes briefly. states that she can hear
10 Mr. Epstein , and states that she
11 believes he was, in her words,
12 She didn't say she said .
13 I am going to use that she believes he was
15 Then he returns. At this point he gets back on
16 the table lying on his back and asks her to start
17 massaging his chest. So she begins to massage his chest.
18 Q Does he keep the towel on?
19 A No, at this point the towel is removed. when he
20 comes back and he gets back on the table, the towel is
21 removed and she is massaging his chest.
22 Q What does he do as she is massaging his chest?
23 A He . So he
24 on the table. He asked , at
25 some point during this time, if she would like to make an
Page 14
1 extra $100. He tells her that it would not involve doing
2 a massage. IM agrees. He asked her if he could
3 and she does agree. describes it as
o a
5 said this goes on for about ten minutes.
6 At some point during that massage
and she
describes hinIMMM
Q What did she say happened when Mr. Epstein
IMMMEB
A The . At some point he does
12 . And these are her words. She
13 looks at him kind of funny, and he sarcastically -- which
14 is her word -- he sarcastically says, 'What's the matter?"
15 And she at that point just kind of looks away, and he
16 continues on with . In the last
17 three to four minutes of that, he
19 At the conclusion of the sexual activity,
20 Mr. Epstein was
21 asked if She
22 but saw him
23 Q Was able to provide a physical description
24 of Mr. Epstein?
25 A Yes.
Page 15
1 Q Including of ?
2 A Yes.
3 Q Was she also able to provide a description of
4 her surroundings in that massage area?
5 A Yes.
6 Q Was that description accurate?
7 A Yes. According to other testimony we have
8 gotten from other victims, yes.
9 Q And a search was performed on Mr. Epstein's
10 house?
11 A Yes. The Palm Beach police department did
12 perform a search, and several of the items that were
13 described were found in the house.
14 Q After Mr. Epstein what
15 happened?
16 A He told that she was getting the extra
17 hundred dollars because he was allowed
18 . The massage had been
19 concluded, the sexual activity had been concluded. He
20 gets up and leaves for a brief moment of time and comes
21 back with $300 and pays the $300. I believe he told
22 that she could see herself out.
23 Q Before we leave that room, when was either
24 being directed to the room or was inside that room where
25 the massage took place, was there anything in particular
Ceerti, I 0-6
Page 16
that she noted seeing?
A She noted seeing several naked pictures of girls
in the room, a mural or pictures of naked girls either
exposing their breasts or completely naked.
Q While the massage was going on, did Mr. Epstein
talk to
A Yes, he did.
Q And did he talk about sexual conquests with
girls?
A Yes, he did.
Q Once Mr. Epstein has provided with the
$300, what did she do?
A She went back downstairs and she, and
leave the residence. In the car they ask how
much money she has made, and she tells them $300.
wants to see the money. She shows the money to , and
asks what did she do. At that point tells her
that he
Q When they left the house, where did they go?
A When they left the house, they were on their way
to a mall to go shopping with the money that they had
received from Mr. Epstein. had told the night
before that she needed some shoes and wanted to go to the
mall, and she was going to Mr. Epstein's to pick up some
money. That was another reason that she had for going to
Page 17
1 Mr. Epstein's house that day, and that they were going to
2 go shopping after she got her money, and that MI could
3 make some money.
4 Q During that ride, did realize that ME
5 received money from Mr. Epstein?
6 A Yes. At some point knows that
7 received $200, but is unsure that ever gave a
8 massage. So at that particular time did not know why
9 she had gotten the S200, because she didn't think that
3.0 had had time to give a massage.
11 interview, did she explain what:she
12 got the $200 for?
13 A told the Palm Beach police department in
14 her interview that she received her $200 for bringing
15 to the house.
16 Q You mentioned that there were these three
17 different time periods that was interviewed: Shortly
18 after the events, at the time of the state grand jury
19 proceedings, and when you met with her, correct?
20 A Yes.
21 Q And there were some discrepancies between the
22 different interviews. Can you explain some of those to
23 the grand jury.
24 A Before we go and get to that, I want to make
25 sure that -- when we discussed what was told in the
e.er-72-t, (rat -3
Page 18
1 car byllill, that we learned from ME interview with
2 the Palm Beach police department. So I don't know if I
3 said that, but I want to make sure you know that we first
4 learned that= by listening to the
interview that was conducted between the Palm Beach police
6 department andillill, not fromilill. When I talk later, I
just want to make sure you realize that that had not
8 initially come out in interview, but through the
9 interview with
10 So going back. I'm sorry, discrepancies?
11 Q Yes.
12 A I met with last night to discuss some of
13 the discrepancies when looking at what she had talked to
14 detective about in March of 2005 and what she had
15 testified to in the grand jury in July of 2006. Reading
16 the testimony and listening to the tapes, or reading the.
17 transcript, there were a few discrepancies.
18 One of the first ones we talked about was what
19 had told her about going to Mr. Epstein's house.
20 She tells detective that she was told about the
21 massage, told about getting $200, but that she was not
22 told that she would have to take her clothes off. She
23 didn't know she would have to perform the massage naked.
24 when I asked her last night that question, she
25 told me that when she got to the house prior to going into
alaNCI2WINCII
Page 19
1 Mr. Epstein's residence, that I= did tell her that she
2 may be asked to take off her clothes. She also did state
3 that told her she could stay in her bra.
4 So I wanted you to know that there was a
5 discrepancy in what she originally had told detective
6 MI and what she told me last night. That would be one.
7 The second discrepancy i wanted to touch on with
8 her was going upstairs and taking off her clothing. When
9 she is in that room, she states to detective that
10 asked her to remove her clothing, and she took off
11 her shirt. Then Mr. Epstein came in the room, shook her
12 hand and told her to take off her clothes. He leaves, he
13 comes back in a towel. He tells her again. tells
14 detective in a stern voice, 'Mr. Epstein told me to
15 take off my pants." Because she hadn't taken off her
16 pants from the first time that she met him.
17 In her testimony with the grand jury with the
18 state, she tells the grand jury that it was who
19 asked her to remove her clothing. So last night we went
20 over with her who told her to remove what. She had a very
21 hard time recalling exactly. She knew she had gotten down
22 to her bra and underwear. And then at some point, when
23 we're going through the sexual activity, she actually
24 tells me that her underwear was off when he was
&API") N't O
1.
Page 20
Later in the interview, we tell her about what
2 we have in her testimony to the grand jury and her
3 statements made to detective And she really is
4 having a difficult time trying to remember who told her to
5 take off her clothes and her pants. As we are walking
6 through the sexual activity, she does recall and states.
7 that it was Mr. Epstein who told. her to take off her
8 pants.
9 I guess I'll go to the third discrepancy. Is
10 there anything I left off with that?
11 Q Well, does she report that when the assistant
12 leads -- or the blonde lady leads her upstairs, that the
13 blonde lady also said, "Get undressed," but that
14 didn't get fully undressed?
15 A That's what she said in her statement to the
16 detective, when she gives her first statement. She tells
17 us again last night that that's what she recalled.
18 Q That the lady said first, "Get undressed," but
19 she doesn't get fully undressed. And when Jeffrey comes
20 back, he said, "Take your pants off."?
21 A Yes. And again, like I said, when we started
22 interviewing her and asking her about this, she did have a
23 hard time. But when we were walking through the sexual
24 activity, that's when she recalls who told her to take off
25 her pants.
Page 21
And I'll tell you, when we talked about the
sexual activity, and it comes out that she wasn't wearing
her underwear when
, she does not recall how they came off.
She cannot remember removing her underwear. She doesn't
remember if Mr. Epstein removed her underwear. She knows
her underwear was off, but she cannot tell you exactly at
what point her underwear was removed.
Q Let's talk about the third discrepancy.
A The third is the sexual activity, when she was
originally interviewed by detective about the
When detective
comes and sees her again a few weeks later, she does
tell her at that time that
She also says that to the grand jury, she talks about the
Last night she told us about
When we asked her about hiM
and that had told the police
department that she told us last
night that she by Mr. Epstein, but that she
thought only her and knew about this and that she
did not want her father to know that
She didn't want anybody to know, but she especially didn't
25 want her father to know, that that was her business. That
C-c-yit? 66( 3
Page 22
she did not know that had told anybody, she thought
2 it was only her and that knew. She was embarrassed
3 and didn't want anybody to know that.
4 Q Did she become visually upset?
5 A Yes, she began crying when we asked her about
6 . when she realized that we
7 knew about that, she became very upset and concerned about
8 her father. She mentioned that her father has read a lot
9 of the reports in the State of Florida, and has followed
10 the state's case. She was concerned about even telling
11 us, afraid that he would be able to read in our reports
12 about this.
13 We explained to her that the FBI's reporting is
14 a little bit different than the way the state -- those are
15 public records, and ours is part of our case file.
16 Q In addition to the fact that she had these
17 concerns about her father and she was embarrassed, in your
18 experience of interviewing victims of sexual abuse, is it
19 typical for them to not disclose all of the sexual
20 activity?
21 A Yes, it's very typical. And young girls, they
22 don't want to talk about it. This is just another case of
23 her not wanting to tell exactly what took place.
24 Q After that first visit to Mr. Epstein's house,
25 and the interviews with detective , did detective
Page 25
1 Q On April 1, the following day, did illilmake
2 calls to
3 A From the Palm Beach police department, they were
4 able to take voice mail messages left by Mon
5 phone stating that could come and work on Saturday
6 around 11:00.
7 Q I think you mentioned this 'last time, but in
8 case you didn't, did the Palm Beach police department do
9 trash pulls at Mr. Epstein's house?
10 A Yes, they did.
11 Q Was there anything of value related to this
12 series of calls that were recovered?
13 A Yes. There was a trash pull done in the
14 beginning of April, and in the trash there was a piece of
15 paper that on it had name, name, and I
16 believe it was 10:30 listed on the piece of paper.
17 Q It said with on Saturday at 10:30?
18 A Yes, it did.
19 Q In addition to the actual recordings of those
20 phone calls and voice mail messages, do you also have
21 telephone records from both cell phone and
22 cell phone that match up?
23 A Yes.
24 Q Just to go back to something that you mentioned.
25 Who actually gave the $300 cash to at the day she was
(„9-21 iqt)
Page 26
1 at Mr. Epstein's house?
2 A Mr. Epstein.
3 Q You mentioned a girl named
4 A Yes.
5 Q Was also interviewed?
6 A Yes, she was.
7 Q Was she asked about going With to take
8 girls to Mr. Epstein's house?
9 A Yes.
10 0 Was she asked who the youngest -looking girl was?
11 A Yes.
12 Q What did she say?
13 A She discussed looking young in her
14 interview with the Palm Beach police department.
15 Those are all of my questions
16 for you now. If you could please step outside, I'll
17 see if the grand jurors have any.
18 (Witness excused, and then returned.)
19 BY■
20 Q Agent , we have just a few questions.
21 One relates to the conversation between Mr. Epstein and
22 about his exploits with other girls. Did Mr. Epstein
23 say anything about the age of those girls?
24 A He said that -- in particular on one case he
25 talked about a young girl that he was in the back seat
Page 23
NM ask MI to make what are called controlled calls?
A Yes.
Q Can you explain to the grand jury what a
controlled call is?
A A controlled call is where we actually have a
listening device, where we have an individual place a call
to somebody and we are able to record the other person's
voice and the conversation that takes place between the
person that we're having make the call and the person that
they are calling.
Q Who did detective ask to call?
A was asked to call on the phone.
Q And did she do so?
A Yes, she did.
Q Can you tell the grand jury when the calls were?
A I believe the first call was made towards the
end of March, I believe it was March 30. called
at the Olive Garden where works. was
concerned that father had found out somehow and
that they knew about it. And she refers to him as
Jeffrey, but Mr. Epstein.
told her that they did not know about
Mr. Epstein. Later in the conversation tells her
that Mr. Epstein would like her to come back and work for
him, and that maybe she could work for him tomorrow. So
koly3
Page 24
1 they agreed that there would be a call between and
2 tomorrow, that will call tomorrow.
3 Q were there calls also made on March 31 of 2006?
4 A There were two calls made on March 31. The
5 first one she doesn't connect to . The second call
6 that was made a short time later, answers the phone.
7 Again, there is a discussion about coming to work for
8 Mr. Epstein. tells -- one of the comments that
9 is made is, "The more you do, the more you make." is
10 asking her how much can I make.
11 Again, detective is there, and is
12 , how much can I make.asking is telling
13 that she'll have to ask Mr. Epstein that, that she is
14 going to see Mr. Epstein tomorrow and that she'll talk to
15 Mr. Epstein. There is conversation about and her
16 twin sister possibly coming to Mr. Epstein's house. There
17 is some discussion about her coming to work for
18 Mr. Epstein.
19 Q Just so it's clear, because there were a lot of
20 shes, is telling that is going to see
21 Epstein the following day?
22 A Yes.
23 Q And that is going to set up a schedule
24 with Mr. Epstein for and her sister to work for him?
25 A Yes.
Page 27
1 with, and her parents were in the front seat. He told
2 that they were having sex in the back seat were
3 doing sexual things in the back seat while he was carrying
4 on a conversation with the parents in the front seat. I
5 guess they were on their way home from a business party.
6 This was one of the stories that he had talked about.
7 Q But at no time did he provide any specific ages
8 about any of those girls?
9 A No.
10 Q what was age at the time she took
11 to Mr. Epstein's house?
12 A She was 18.
13 Q Did Mr. Epstein ask anything about her age?
14 A He did. He asked her how old she was, she said
15 she was 18. He asked her what grade she was in, she said
16 she was in the 12th grade. He asked her where she went to
17 school, and she said she went to
18 Q I know we will be doing a lot more discussion
19 about later. But could you tell us briefly how
20 was recruited to go to Mr. Epstein's house?
21 A was at the beach, and two individuals
22 approached her about making money and giving a massage to
23 Mr. Epstein.
24 Q How old was
25 Mr. Epstein's house?
when she first went to
Page 28
1 A Through phone records, we have contact between
2 and starting at age 17.
3 : Those are all the questions.
4 Thank you.
(Witness excused, and then returned. )
BY
7 Q The question was, was there any particular
evidence to suggest that Mr. Epstein knew that was
9 under the age of 18?
10 A I would say through the interviews of the
11 multiple girls that went to Mr. Epstein's house -- the way
12 that having seen last night, and now she's 16 -- this
13 was two years ago -- that age and behavior -- and
14 again, is that more circumstantial evidence? As far as
15 concrete evidence, no. But just by her appearance and her

16. mannerisms and how I observed her last night at age 16.
17 Q And that's consistent with what said
18 during her statement; correct?
19 A Yes, it is.
20 MS. : Any other questions?
21 JUROR: Did she look 18?
22 THE WITNESS: Does look 18? Not in my
23 opinion, sir.
24 MS. : All right. Any other questions?
25 Okay, thank you, very much.
Page 29
(Witness excused.)
CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
I CERTIFY pages 1 to 28 is a true transcript of
my shorthand notes of the testimony of
before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm
Beach, Florida, on the 27th day of February, 2007.
Dated at West Palm Beach, Florida this 18th day
of March, 2007.
Philip W. May, Court Reporter
Urriit9g(7
r
(
(
EFTA00009478 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-13)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR
ORIGINAL
TESTIMONY
SPECIAL AGENT.
APPEARANCES:
OF
Federal Grand Jury 07-103
Federal Building
U.S. Courthouse
West Palm Beach, Florida
Tuesday, March 20, 2007
d States Attorney
HELENA JOSETTE JONES -PARSONS,
Foreperson
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8201
Copy 1 of 13
S
The sworn testimony of SPECIAL AGENT E.
was taken before the Federal
Grand Jury, West Palm Beach Division, Federal
Building, U.S. Courthouse, Palm Beach County,
State of Florida, on Tuesday, March 20, 2007.
Certified Court
Reporter and Notary Public, State of Florida,
Official Reporting Service, LLC, 524 South Andrews
Avenue, Suite 302N, Fort Lauderdale, Florida,
33301 , was authorized to and did report the sworn
testimony.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
(Witness enters the Grand Jury Room.)
THE FOREPERSON: You do solemnly swear
that the testimony you give will be the
truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the
truth, so help you God?
6 THE WITNESS: I do.
7 THE FOREPERSON: Thank you. Please he
8 seated.
9 EXAMINATION
10 BY
11 Q Special could you Agent
12 please state and spell your name for the record?
13 A It's. It's
15 Q Now Special Agent , last week
16 or the last time that we met, we discussed two
17 girls, correct?
18 A Yes.
19 Q Who visited Mr. Epstein's home?
20 A Yes.
21 Q And those were and
22 A Yes.
23 Q Did you obtain photographs of those
24 girls?
25 A Yes, I did.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467 8204
cLvil 413
Q And do you know approximately when those
photographs were taken?
A They were taken during the same time
period that we are investigating, '04 and '05.
There may have been a few in '03, but it was
within a year's time of six months within the
activity that we are investigating.
Q All right. Let me show you what has
been marked as Grand Jury Exhibits 1 and 2, and
can you tell us what Exhibit 1 is?
A Exhibit 1 is and it's a
photograph of her with her date of birth listed.
Q And what is Exhibit 2?
A A photograph of I. with her date
of birth as well on it.

MS. : And I will just pass
those to the grand jury.
BY MS.
Q Now the last time that we were here, you
had described how had brought
to Mr. Epstein's home?
A Yes.
Q Did I. bring other girls to the
Epstein house?
A Yes, she did.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Q And is one of those girls
A Yes.
Q And what is the date of birth of
.?
A She was born
Q And where did . go to high
school?
. A
Q And is that the same school that
went to?
A Yes.
Q And was . ever a student at that
school?
A Yes, she was.
Q Tell us a little bit about -- well,
first of all, did the Palm Beach Police Department
have a chance to interview .?
A Yes, they did.
Q And what about yourself?
A And I did as well.
Q Okay. Tell us, if you will, how

II. started going to Mr. Epstein's house?
A was the one who brought to
Mr. Epstein's house. told that she
may have to remove her clothing and that she could
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
S
makes $200 if she performed a massage for Mr.
Epstein.
She also was told by that he may
try to touch you, but if you are uncomfortable,
just tell him no, and she also said that if
Epstein asked her age, she was to say she was 18.
Q Now that information that you just
relayed, who provided that information?
A
Q And what did
A I'm sorry. provided in the
interview to me that information.
Q Did also admit that she brought
to Mr. Epstein's home?
A Yes.
Q When did this first occur?
A This occurred in -- we believe the first
time period was when was 16.
Q And is there any telephone records that
show communications between and
and and
A Yes.
Q And when are those phone records?
A Those phone records show up in March of
'04 when would be 16.
OFFICIAL. REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
.4
Q Let me show what has been marked as
Grand Jury Exhibit Number 3, and what is Exhibit
3?
A This is a photograph of IF with
her date of birth,
Q Now you mentioned that in March of 2004
and April of 2004, there are these records of
phone calls and did say how old she was
when she first went to Mr. Epstein's house?
A I'm sorry. Did say how old she
was?
Q Did she tell you or the police officers
how old she was?
A Yes. I'm sorry. I thought your
question was did she tell Mr. Epstein.
She told me that she was 16 when she
went to Mr. Epstein's house.
Q Okay. That is consistent with those
phones calls?
A Yes, it is.
Q Okay. Now during her first visit with

Mr. Epstein, what happened?
A She went to Mr. Epstein's house.
took her there. told her she didn't have
her driver's license at that time, which she told
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Cep ( 06 (3
her she got her driver's license when she was 17.
So drove her to Mr. Epstein's
house. She provided Mr. Epstein with a few
massages. She remained clothed both times that
she gave him a massage. At this time, she kept
her clothes on.
I think one time she was wearing shorts
and a T-shirt, maybe the second time she was
wearing jeans and a T-shirt. That he constantly
grabbed and pulled at her during the massage
trying to draw her closer to him, but at that
time, you know, there was no sexual activity other
than the grabbing and pulling.
There was no sexual activity that took
place on those first couple of massages, and she
remained clothed at that time.
Q Now after those first few massages, was
there a break in time before returns to
the Epstein house?
A told us that she and had
had some kind of a , a
so there was a time
period where she did not go back to Mr. Epstein's
house.
Q And when -- did there then come a time
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
when she returned to the Epstein house?
A Yes. We have phone activity between
and II. beginning in December
of '04.
Q And how old was I. in December
of '04?
A She had turned 17 at that time. In
fact, through the course of the phone records
beginning in December of '04 to October of 2005,
we have over 150 phone calls between Z.
and , Mr. Epstein's assistant.
Q What did Z. tell you about the
activity that occurred when she started returning
in late '04?
A When she started giving Mr. Epstein
massages after that break, the massages became
much more sexual in nature. Mr. Epstein continued
to push and there were many times when
would perform massages completely nude.
Several times, she would stay in her
underwear with no bra on, but stated to me that
many occasions she performed the massages to Mr.
Epstein in the nude.
Q In addition to being unclothed, was
there other sexual activity?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Copt. ) c(3
A Yes, there was. , during my
interview with she became very upset when
discussing the sexual activity that took place at
that time.
She stated that Mr. Epstein had
her. It began first by
and then
on more than one occasion actually
He would request her to pinch his
He rubbed her
stated that there was a
as well. She
as well, did not penetrate her, but
that she described the
that was
, and several of the
other victims have said the same thing, described
it similar to that.
Q And just before I forget, when you
testified about II, did ■also report
having a
A Yes.
Q And, again, so the record is clear, when
you are talking about these they are
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
A We have had some girls just describe
them as a We have had some girls just
describe them as a and then we also
had girls describe them as both, because of the
of it, I think some girls are more aware of
what a would look like due to their ages.
You know, I don't know that everybody
knew exactly what a looked like,
but they all , and we have actually had
that described, and described it as both,
a
know, in nature.
saying that it was, you
Q Okay. Now in addition to using that
, was
there other sexual activity?
A Yes. Several times during the massages,

Mr. Epstein would have straddle him while
he laid on his stomach and then he would reach
and
occasionally --
Q And this is when he was laying on his
back not his stomach?
A I'm sorry. Did I say that?
Q You said on his stomach.
A He is laying on his back. She's on top
of him straddled, and he is reaching
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
L 1 3
, but
that was what was described to us by
• Now when was first interviewed
by the Palm Beach Police?
A She was interviewed October 6th of 2005.
Q And at that time, did she say when her
last visit was to Mr. Epstein's house?
A Yes, she said October 1st, 2005, was the
last massage that she had given Mr. Epstein.
Q Is there any other evidence that was
recovered from Mr. Epstein's or his household
items that would confirm that statement?
A We have a message pad. During the
search warrant, several of the message pads -- I
don't know if we referred to them at this stage.
We may not have.
We recovered -- well, I shouldn't say
we, the Palm Beach Police Department recovered
several message pads. They were carbon copy
message pads.
So we have several of those books from
their search warrant and in there, there is a
message on October 1st confirming
appointment for the massage as well as another
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
1 girl,
2 Q And is there also evidence that
3 and actually spoke on October 1st
4 before that message?
5 A We have cell phone calls between
6 and as well as the message which
7 was from to Jeffrey regarding -- confirming
8 the appointment for , but we have a cell
9 phone call I believe it was a little bit earlier
10 from to or maybe it was to
11 , but it is definitely between the two of
12 them on that same day.
13 Q All right. When was interviewed
14 by the Palm Beach Police Department, did she
15 describe all of the sexual activity?
16 A No, she did not. She did not tell them
17 about the or the - she didn't tell them
18 about the
19 Q And, again, you said that when you
20 brought up -- did you sort of confront her with
21 the idea that more had occurred?
22 A I did, and she was very embarrassed
23 about the I asked her at one point if
24 Mr. Epstein had given her any gifts and she got
25 very red in the face and began to tear up and you
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
C&pt ( 0-6
could see that she was very embarrassed.
So we took a little bit of a break, but
then she was able to say that Mr. Epstein had
provided her as a birthday present a . So
not only was there a used
on her, but at this time and I think that's
kind of what got talking about the sexual
activity that she was able to tell me that, and
she was very, very embarrassed, but that Mr.
Epstein had given her for her eighteenth birthday
a
Q Now you mentioned that that happened on
her eighteenth birthday?
A Yes.
Q And was she able to tell you whether Mr.
Epstein knew it was her eighteenth birthday?
A She stated that Mr. Epstein provided to
her on her eighteenth birthday the and
shortly -- well --
Q So before you had said that had
instructed to tell everyone that she was
18; do you remember that?
A Yes.
Q But at some point, the people in the
Epstein household learned that she hadn't turned
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
18 yet and her birthday was coming up?
A Her birthday was coming up.
Q And at some point, was a car provided
for
A Yes. In October of '05, was
having asked Mr. Epstein is she could
borrow one of his cars to go to Orlando and he
stated that -- at first he said yes, and then he
said he would get her a rental car.
So contacted a few days
later and said that a car had been rented for
and that the house manager used the
company credit card and picked up that
car, and actually when the police interviewed her
on October 6th, which was five or six days after
the last massage, they were able to see that that
Nissan Sentra that had been rented by Mr. Epstein,
had that in her possession for at least
through January 1st of 2006 and that car was
rented by Mr. Epstein for at least that amount of
time.
Q Did describe how the massage
appointments would be made?
A Yes, she did.
Q And how was that?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
c-&-en (4 (3
A She stated that that
, Jeffrey's assistant, would call her and set
up appointments, and that sometimes she would call
her on her cell phone from New York, from the
Islands, and say that they were coming into town,
was she available.
She would also call while they
were in town to see if she was available for
massages, to give massages to Mr. Epstein, and
stated that , who we have identified as
-• called her a few times as well to set
appointments up.
Q And when those appointments were made
how would reach
A By phone.
Q All right. And whether she was in town
or out of town, she would call cell
phone?
A Yes.
Q All right. Now was there any -- during
the interview with the police department, did the
police department ask about what she
discussed with Jeffrey Epstein during the
massages?
A I would have to check the police reports
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
to give specifics on that.
Q All right.
A My answer to your question is yes.
Q Okay. And what did she say were some of
the topics of discussion?
A Mr. Epstein asked her questions about
herself, asked her if she was a or
that -- Jeffrey knew that she was a
and asked questions about her college, about where
she was going to school.
is currently going to
, and she had advised Mr. Epstein that
she would be attending college at
Q So that was a - but that was her future
plan?
A Yes.
Q So in other words, did Mr. Epstein know
that she was in high school at the time?
A Yes, he did. And the Palm Beach Police
asked if Jeffrey knew her age and
told the Palm Beach Police Department, he didn't
care what my age was.
Q Now did describe either to you
or to the police department how she would be paid
for these massages?
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Cetro 14 (3
A She stated she was paid $200 and that
she received anywhere from two to $300.
Q With every visit?
A With each visit.
Q Okay. Did she say who would provide her
with that money?
A She said that Jeffrey paid her at the
end of the massage.
Q All right. You mentioned the gift of
the vibrator. Were there other gifts that were
given to
A Yes. The time period is unclear, but
the was given to her for her eighteenth
birthday. There were three sets of bra and
underwear, panties, Victoria Secret bra and
underwear sets that were also given to as
gifts from Mr. Epstein.
Q Now I know that we talked earlier about
the fact that is the person who brought
to Mr. Epstein's house. Did ever
bring anyone to Mr. Epstein's house?
A brought a female by the name of
and that was a friend of
And let me show you what has been marked
as Grand Jury Exhibit 4, and what is Grand Jury
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Exhibit 4?
A It's a photograph of with a
3 date of birth of
4 Q How old was when took
5 her to Mr. Epstein's house?
6 A took her there in the spring of
7 2005 and was 18 at that time.
8 Q Now can you tell us now went
9 about bringing to the house?
10 A told that she could make
11 some money giving a massage to Mr. Epstein and
12 and went to Mr. Epstein's house
13 together.
14 The first time that went there,
15 she did not go upstairs and give him a massage.
16 was working that day. But in talking to
17 further, stated that she probably
18 over the period of time between the spring of '05
19 and October of '05, performed around five to ten
20 massages for Mr. Epstein.
21 The first few of those he did not do
22 anything as far as no no sexual
23 activity. She would just perform a massage.
24 Q And did that change over time?
25 A Yes, it did. She stated that she
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
cfret, tot 13
performed two to three massages out of those five
or ten and in her underwear and bra only, and
that he would push her each time.
He would just push her to do more and on
the third -- I believe she stated the third or
fourth massage, he told her that she could make
more money if she removed her clothing, because
she stayed clothed during the first few massages,
and she was paid $200 for each of those massages.
On the third or fourth massage, Mr.
Epstein said that she could make more money if she
removed her clothing. So around the fourth or
fifth time, she did start taking off her clothing
down to her underwear and bra only.
Q And then what happened when she was at
that point of being unclothed?
A She would perform the massage. He
attempted to touch her, but she always would say

no. At one point, her bra does get undone by Mr.
Epstein, but she does keep it up.
Q Now that was the extent of his touching
At some point, did he
in front of her?
A Yes, he did. Not in the very beginning,
but throughout this he did. Now I should tell you
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
that stated to us that because she was kind
of reserved or held back as he made advances
towards her, she was able to see Mr. Epstein's
and that he but that he
, that he . She did
not feel that Mr. Epstein liked her very much.
Q But just to sort of compare what
said with what said, they both said that
at the beginning they remained clothed?
A Yes.
Q And that Mr. Epstein progressively
pushed and pushed and pushed for more sexual
activity?
A Yes.
Q Now what was the period of time that
went to Mr. Epstein's home?
A March of I'm sorry, spring of '05 is
when said that she went there and around,
you know, the investigation is heating up with
Palm Beach, so we know that in September of '05,
there was a trash pull done, and in that trash
pull there was a message and that was found and it
stated -- it had phone number on it and
it stated, for a good time call and
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
6-Ptis cl
Q And whose stationery was that?
A It was on Jeffrey Epstein's stationery.
Q And had Jeffrey Epstein been in a Palm
Beach resident close to those dates?
A Yes.
Q Now is there evidence of telephone calls
between and
A Yes.
Q And how many phone calls have you been
able to identify?
A At this time, there have been 14 phone
calls.

• All right. And just to compare that to
the number of phone calls with
A With , there was over 150 phone
calls between and
Q And that is sort of consistent with the
number of massages that did versus the
number of massages that did?
A It is consistent with especially the
activity that was providing Mr. Epstein
compared to the activity that would
provide.
(Thereupon, knocking is heard at the
Grand Jury door. )
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Let me just step out for
one moment.
exits the Grand Jury
4 Room. )
5 enters the Grand Jury
6 Room. )
7 Ladies and gentlemen, I
8 am going to have to take a break now and we
9 will be back either next week or the
10 following week. Thank you very much. You
11 are done for the day.
12 (Witness was excused.)
15 CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
17 , Certified Court
18 Reporter and Notary Public, do certify that the
19 transcript is a true and correct transcription of
20 my stenotype notes of the testimony of
21 SPECIAL AGENT ■ -, taken before
22 the Federal Grand J” ,..1, Wnef Dalm
24 Certified CotYrt Reporter
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC
(954) 467-8204
CS l3
(
(
EFTA00009502 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-13)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
1 1
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
COPY RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR
TESTIMONY
OF
SPECIAL AGENT
Federal Grand Jury 07-103
Federal Building
U.S. Courthouse
West Palm Beach, Florida
Tuesday, April 24, 2007
APPEARANCES:
Assistant Unite States Attorney
Foreperson
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-A .,AA
Copy 1 of 13
The sworn testimony of SPECIAL AGENT
was taken before the
Federal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach Division,
Federal Building, U.S. Courthouse, Palm Beach
County, State of Florida, on Tuesday, April 24,
2007.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Paula E. Angelocci, Certified Court
Reporter and Notary Public, State of Florida,
Official Reporting Service, LLC,
Fort Lauderdale, Florida,
33301 , was authorized to and did report the sworn
testimony.
(Witness enters the Grand Jury Room. )
THE FOREPERSON: You do solemnly swear
that the testimony you give will be the
truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the
truth, so help you God?
THE WITNESS: I do.
THE FOREPERSON: Thank you. Please be
BY
seated.
EXAMINATION
Agent would you Q Special
just remind the grand jurors who you are and who
you work for?
A My name is and I am
a special agent with the FBI and I work here in
Palm Beach.
Special Agent , can you tell
the grand jurors who will be appearing before them
this afternoon?
A One of our victims, , who was a
minor at the time that she met Mr. Epstein.
Q And have you previously testified about
A Yes, I have.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
(O0
Q Did you attempt to interview her? She's
going to be coming in, and she is not a minor
anymore, so what is her full name?
A Her name is and I did
attempt to interview , and was
interviewed by Palm Beach Police Department and
because of the statements she provided to the
police department, she felt as if she needed a
lawyer. So when I attempted to interview her, we
ended up going through her lawyer.
Q And just so the grand jury has a little
bit of background, the interview with the Palm
Beach Police Department was quite some time ago?
A Yes, it was, in the fall of '05.
Q And when Ms. started that
conversation with the police, she was very
forthcoming?
A Yes, she was.
Q Fully cooperative?
A Yes.
Q And what happened in the middle of that
interview with the police?
A The police just let know that she
could be charged because brought some of the
girls to Mr. Epstein and the police -- she was
I
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
very cooperative, but the police at that point had
to let know that what she had done that she
could be facing charges.
Q And that was after they had told her
earlier that she didn't need an attorney present,
correct?
A Exactly.
Q Okay. So this happens to her with the
Palm Beach Police Department and did the Palm
Beach Police actually present or propose charging
A They did get a probable cause affidavit
against
Q And is that why Ms. and her
attorney were concerned about her testimony here?
A Yes.
Q Now was a subpoena issued for Ms.
on behalf of this grand jury?
A Yes, it was.
Q And before Ms. would comply with
that, did she -- did her attorney request some
sort of order?
A Yes.
Q And what did he ask for?
A He asked for immunity for
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
et (3
Q And let me show you the order, that is a
sealed order in these grand jury proceedings. Now
the immunity that has been provided for Ms.
keeps her statements that are made here from being
used against her?
A Yes, it does.
Q It doesn't -- if she commits perjury and
she lies to the grand jury, can she still be
charged?
A Yes, she can.
Q Okay. Could you read that? I know it
is only two pages.
A Sealed order, on application of the
United States Attorneys for the Southern District
of Florida and it appearing to the satisfaction of
the court that has been called to
testify and to provide other information before
the United States District Court, the Southern
District of Florida, including a grand jury
impaneled therein.
And number two, that in a judgment of
the said United States Attorneys, has
refused to testify and provide other information
on the basis of her privilege against self
incrimination.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
And that number three, in the judgment
of the United States Attorneys, the testimony and
other information from made necessary
to the public interest.
And number four, that the aforesaid
application has been made with the approval of the
Assistant Attorney General in charge of the
criminal division of the Department of Justice or
a duly designated acting Assistant Attorney
General pursuant to the authority vested in him by
Title 18, United States Code, Section 6003, and
Title 28, Code of Federal Regulations, Section
0.175 and 0.132, small e.
Now, therefore, it is ordered pursuant
to Title 18, United States Code, Section 6002,
that give testimony and provide other
information which she refuses to give or to
provide on the basis of her privilege against self
incrimination as to all matters about which she
may be interrogated before said United States
District Court including a grand jury impaneled
therein as well as any subsequent proceeding or
trial.
However, no testimony or other
information compelled under this order or any
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Got-i (cr6 (3
information directly or indirectly derived from
such testimony or other information may be used
against in any criminal case except a
prosecution for perjury giving a false statement
or otherwise failing to comply with this order.
It is further ordered that this order
shall be sealed in accordance with said Federal
Regulations Criminal.
BY
Q Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure.
A Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure, it's
abbreviated, 6, little e, 6, except that a copy of
this order shall be provided to counsel for the
United States who may disclose the existence of
the order to members of the grand jury, to the
witness, to the counsel for the witness, and to
law enforcement officers engaged in the
investigation pending before the grand jury.
Those persons may review the order, but
may not retain a copy of the order nor may it
disclose the existence of the order to any others.
Done and ordered the 16th day of April 2007, at
West Palm Beach, Florida. The United States
District Judge Donald M. Middlebrook,
AUSA.
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
Q All right. So has a copy or
document been shown to counsel for Ms.
A
Q
A
Q
afternoon?
A
Q
A
Q
Yes, it has.
And to Ms
Yes.
And will Ms. be
Yes, she will.
Have you had a chance
Yes,
And
we
she
have.
has been very
has this
here this
to sit with her?
forthcoming?
A She's very cooperative.
Q Okay.
MS.
questions
questions?
you are excused and I think that right now
you are set to come back at 1:15. How does
1:30 sound? Is that all right?
THE FOREPERSON: Fine.
(Witness was excused. )
: I don't have any further
for the witness. Do you have any
All right. Seeing no questions,
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC

(954) 467-8204
OFFICIAL REPORTING SERVICE, LLC
(954) 467-8204
CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
I, Paula E. Angelocci, Certified Court
Reporter and Notary Public, do certify that the
transcript is a true and correct transcription of
my stenotype notes of the testimony of
SPECIAL AGENT , taken before
the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm Beach, Florida.
PAULA . ANG OCCI, CSR #4869
Certified Co t Reporter
EFTA00039227 (Jmail)
 [government] Inmate Discipline Program Statement
(inferred date: 2026-01-14)
Inmate Discipline Program Statement
╔═══════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Anil Ambani [india] billionaire chairman of Reliance Group 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00509584 (Jmail)
 multiple counterparties, see quote: "each girl knew why she was coming to the house massage with extra , hardly coercion"
(inferred date: 2026-01-14)
• Menu
o Overview
o Device Details
■ NYC024328.aff4
(Evidence ID: NYC024328.aff4 - 001)
o Case Data
■ Calendar Items
■ Calls
■ Contacts
■ Messages
■ Top Contacts
■ User Accounts
Case
Data:
Messages
(8801-
8900 of
14749)
iMessage
2019-04-04 22:48:57 (UTC) 1
Sender:
Participants:
Can come by after 8 pm if that works
iMessage
[1] 2019-04-04 22:57:58 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-04-04 23:10:22 (UTC) [2]
Sender: Woody Allen (
Participants: Woody Allen (a, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
https://vvww.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/04/03/magazine/rupert-murdoch-fox-news-
trump.html?smid—nytcore-ios-share
iMessage
2019-04-04 23:25:15 (UTC) [1]
Sender:
Participants:
Cool
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Yup
iMessage
2019-04-04 23:47:14 (UTC 3
Sender: Anil Ambani (
Participants: Anil Ambani ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Yes. Thanks
iMessage
[1] 2019-04-05 00:26:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes mail.com
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Eta?
iMessage
2019-04-05 00:27:17 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
5 to 10 minutes
iMessage
[1] 2019-04-05 00:29:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
K
iMessage
2019-04-05 00:33:04 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants:
Can u get your guy ® the door
iMessage
2019-04-05 00:34:09 UTC 1
Sender:
Participants:
Is somebody outside your place?
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-04-05 06:01:23 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants:  Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Good morning Jeffrey. Our other client has gone to 5.75 E in the meantime, although he
didn't want to go higher than 5.5. He is a famous and tough parisian investor who never
overpays. This means that below 6 this is great value for money. We had green light from
the owner for 5.79 yesterday afternoon. I suggest you make a written offer of 5.8 and we
close it today fast before the auction goes further up. What would you like to do?
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 09:40:48 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:*eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Pass
iMessage
2019-04-05 09:41:24 UTC 5
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Need the list from the attorney today
iMessage
2019-04-05 09:41:45 UTC 5
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Let me know how oliver goes
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 09:46:21 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )

Ok. Thx appreciate it . As numbers go i guess my 38 is still worse than your 1.7
iMessage
2019-04-05 09:46:23 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Hi. Just to make sure: That means you are not interested in offering more than 5.7 mio,
right?
iMessage
2019-04-05 09:49:39 (UTC) 5
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
We need to work around your 38--first we need to push back on the lies ; then crush the
pedo/trafficking narrative ; then rebuild your image as philanthropist
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 10:02:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:'eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
in any bar where drinking age is 18 i guess that 10 percent of patrons are under 18. . they
sneak in, they have fake id. their friends bring them in.. and that is with guards at the
door, the owner gets a fine.. every bar in florida. there is no intercourse
iMessage
[6] 2019-04-05 10:07:45 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: Woody Allen , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
bannon michael kathy will also be here around 3 , what food would you like
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:13:56 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( ejeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
9
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:17:23 UTC 7
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( ejeeitunes®gmail.com )
I didn't forget, I just live with a friend and it will be weird if she sees what I do
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:17:40 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
sorry I thought you were home
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:18:21 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:"eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
how do you feel ?
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:18:34 UTC 7
Sender:
Participants: , Self( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Pm in Moscow now
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:18:46 (UTC) [7]
Sender:
Participants: , Self( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Much better
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:19:21 (UTC) [7]
Sender:
Participants:
But still with big checks
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:20:00 (UTC)
Sender:
Participants:
7
), Self( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Yesterday the doctor checked and said that everything is fine
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:22:53 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:*eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: ), Self( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
GREAT by xmas , new teeth should be all done
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:23:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
or at least much better with no pain , you just have to be disciplined and put it in every day
. I think you will be thrilled with results.
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 10:24:36 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( ejeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
the reports that said they lied when asked re their ages undercuts the argument that i
sought young girls. think of the bar
iMessage
2019-04-0.5 10:25:31 (1.1TC) [7]
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
I also think so, can't wait to see myself with not breaking smile
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 10:25:32 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( cjeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
yes , thx for your help.. I m certain we will do biz in the future ,
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:25:54 (UTC) 7
Sender:
Participants: i , Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
By Xmas it will be awesome!
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:27:05 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( cjeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
yes , and you must be sure before flying that the swelling is gone. airplane travel makes
the swelling worse. just like your water bottles. ,
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:27:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:'eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
now that you are in moscow , maybe you can find a friend for me
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:28:05 UTC 5
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Who did they lie too?
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:28:34 (UTC) [7]
Sender:
Participants: Self ( cjeeitunes®gmail.com )
Oh, I didn't know that
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:29:04 (UTC) [7]
Sender:
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Thanks for warning
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:29:37 (UTC) [7]
Sender:
Participants:
I'll try
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 10:30:00 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
Participants:
Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
they told the police that they were told by the friend of theirs that brought them if asked
make sure you say you are 18. .
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:30:24 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( ejeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
no one is better than you. so i know it is difficult .
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:31:15 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
you should be using your time to learn things driving english, . you prefer concerts and
fun , ok with me . your life . not mine
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:32:20 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:'eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
caring for you , does not allow me to say , just do what makes you happy , that sentence is
for stupid people . I say you have potential don't waste it
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 10:33:25 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:'eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
exactly the opposite of sting results were guys are looking for underage girls.. they alway
always want UNDER and are explicit
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 10:33:40 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:'eeitunes® mail.com )
Participants Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
but I get it ,
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 10:34:56 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( ejeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
and each girl knew why she was coming to the house massage with extra , hardly coercion
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:35:14 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Ok. Thx for the clarification. Pls send me your email adress to send you interesting
properties.
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 10:35:35 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:'eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
jeevacation@gmail.com
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:36:14 (UTC) [7]
Sender:
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
But I also do learn, driving and English, I didn't forget about it
And I love that you saying it to me
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:37:37 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
yes but you are not taking classes in english you need classes and practice in a GROUP.
serious hard work not online when you feel like it sorry
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:38:43 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Would you be interested in one of the most outstanding properties in the world in Cap
Ferrat? Villa „Les Cedres" built by the king of Belgium in 1870. price is 350 mio E.
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:39:45 UTC 7
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
yes need to fly to London for this
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:40:41 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: a, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:40:41 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 10:40:47 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
i know the property . more of a headache than a work of art
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:41:42 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: Self ( ejeeitunes®gmail.com )
no, there are classes everywhere , if you look , london ultimate goal but don't waste your
time , it passes quicker than you think, you can go into the bathroom and send a mirror
photo
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 10:44:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
i need something that is not a multi year project. . my ranch in new mexico sits on 10, 000
acres.. I intend to sell it ( best house in america ) , and find something in europe I can
move into within 9 months
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:46:56 (UTC)
Sender: Self eeeitunes ail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
just to remind me what i am missing
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:48:00 (UTC) [7]
Sender:
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
gEiMill do a better one in a little bit
iMessage
[8] 2019-04-05 10:48:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes® ail.com
Participants: Anil Ambani ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
family friends a strange biological concept.
iMessage
[7] 2019-04-05 10:48:57 (UTC)
Sender: Self eeeitunes rnail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
your cheeks are as big as your tits
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:49:34 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
What would you be interested in down there? Historic, modem minimalist, first line to the
sea, close to the coast but a bit inland with lot's of acres? How many m2 and how many
bedrooms? Price idea?
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:49:52 (UTC) [7]
Sender:
Participants:
Right haha
), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 10:52:41 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I prefer to do as little work as possible as both permits and workers a nightmare in france.
30- - 70 m. sea close but not windy , as you know i live on my two islands in the caribean .
house needs to sing
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 10:54:42 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Participants:
i have tumed down 75 m for my ranch.
advantageous for tax purposes
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
. I would also be willing to do a swap as
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 10:55:09 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:56:48 UTC 4
Sender:
Participants:
you can go on google earth zorro ranch in santa fe new mexico
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Will have a look now. Can we help you with the sales process in the US or are you happy
with the current service?
iMessage
2019-04-05 10:59:28 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Swap doesn't seem to be realistic. Finding an owner of a property you like that by chance
wants a ranch in Santa Fe...
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 11:01:22 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
sorry , the way it is done is a third party buys the house i want . and then swaps it for santa

fe. or. as buyers of great houses are few like art work we swap all the time.
iMessage
2019-04-05 11:04:51 (UTC 8
Sender: Anil Ambani (
Participants: Anil Ambani ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Yes
iMessage
[8] 2019-04-05 11:06:31 UTC
Sender: Self
Participants: Anil Ambani ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
cant choose those that share your past genes and though friends share none , they are often
more aligned . weird
iMessage
2019-04-05 11:06:48 (UTC 8
Sender: Anil Ambani (
Participants: Anil Ambani ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
Yup
iMessage
2019-04-05 11:16:47 UTC 4
Sender:
Participants: i ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I just sent you 2 mails with villas between 10 and 120 mio E on the french riviera.
iMessage
[4] 2019-04-05 11:16:52 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
BTW the thing that intrigued me the most were the books in cedres library on plants
iMessage
[9] 2019-04-05 11:25:46 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
Participants:
iMessage
2019-04-05 11:37:03 (UTC) [6]
Sender: Woody Allen (
Participants: Woody Allen
I. Self ( e:jeeitunes®gmail.com )
ill try to find them something its a busy time
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Very sweet of you to ask but remember I'm not coming so I don't care what anyone else is
eating. :-)
iMessage
[6] 2019-04-05 11:37:14 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes® ail.com
Participants: Woody Allen Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
ok
iMessage
2019-04-05 11:39:17 (UTC 6
Sender: Woody Allen (
Participants: Woody Allen ( , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Woody: May or May not be able to come as there is budget meeting called for as we are
now over budget on new film. Will know how badly later.
iMessage
[6] 2019-04-05 11:40:59 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes® il.com
Participants: Woody Allen ( ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
no worry, he can stop by at any time even for a few minutes it would be fun
iMessage
2019-04
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
No worries at all, they already found something. I just asked in case you were interested
and had an option for them to stay.
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 12:52:48 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes mail.com
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
reminder , I am not delusional , no ego , not my skill set
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 12:56:52 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:'eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: ), Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
[9] 2019-04-05 13:56:14 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Participants:
re kathy documents paramount . . re kazans same
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
your friend is welcome to stop by for a coffee
iMessage
2019-04-05 13:56:41 (UTC) 9
Sender:
Participants , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I will tell her, which day?
iMessage
[9] 2019-04-05 13:57:31 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:'eeitunes mail.com )
Participants: , Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
sat
iMessage
2019-04-05 14:16:31 (UTC) 10
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Hey sorry I now have to leave for Boston early as they cancelled the later flight
iMessage
2019-04-0514:16:41 UTC 10
Sender:
Participants:
It's my 30th law school reunion
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
[10] 2019-04-05 14:16:58 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( ejeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
2019-04-05 14:16:59 UTC 10
Sender:
Participants:
Are you around tomorrow night
iMessage
2019-04-05 14:17:08 (UTC) 10
Sender:
Participants:
Or next week?
no worry , at all. nothing urgent
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
iMessage
[10] 2019-04-05 14:17:15 (UTC)
Sender: Self ( e:*eeitunes@ mail.com )
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
yes tomorrow night works i leave sunday morning early
iMessage
2019-04i 05 15 A.m t )(1 .. 14JTC)5 il l
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Kirscher blows this case out of the water-- why have u never had him come forward now
that he is retired
iMessage
2019-04-05 15:47:57 (UTC) [11]
Sender:
Participants: a, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Jeff - dan here - saw you in Paris last week - Steve wants to start the shoot at 3:00 - can we
get in at about 2:00 to set up?
iMessage
[11] 2019-04-05 15:48:13 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:"eeitunes mail.com
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Yes
iMessage
2019-04-05 15:48:33 (UTC) [11]
Sender:
Participants:  Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Great. We'll be there at 2:00
iMessage
[5] 2019-04-05 15:48:44 (UTC)
Sender: Self e:*eeitunes mail.com
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Face to face
iMessage
2019-04-05 15:49:30 (UTC) [9]
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
She said her flight lands late night on Saturday
iMessage
2019-04-05 17:56:00 UTC 11
Sender:
Participants: Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Myself and one of my guys are en mute. Steve will follow later
iMessage
2019-04-05 18:28:00 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: , Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
Well, it has impressive botanical gardens and green houses. So someone had to read a lot
of books on how to manage that...
iMessage
2019-04-05 18:30:15 (UTC) [4]
Sender:
Participants: n, Self ( e:jeeitunes@gmail.com )
I have something very different - ultra modem - very close to Le Cedres. It's under
construction and absolutely not in the market yet. 50 mio E. I will forward some pictures
of the construction and a description send by one of my agents in Cap Ferrat.
Notes
[1] Source
Device
[1] Source File
[2] Source
Device
[2] Source File
[3] Source
Device
[3] Source File
[4] Source
Device
[4] Source File
[5] Source
Device
[5] Source File
[6] Source
Device
[6] Source File
[7] Source
Device
[7] Source File
[8] Source
Device
[8] Source File
[9] Source
Device
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-04-04/ on 2019-04-04 at 10.0
5.38.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jeelLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-04-04/Woody Allen on 2019-04-03 at 05.42.48.ic
hat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jeelLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-04-04/Anil Ambani on 2019-03-21 at 05.36.59.ic
hat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-04-05/ on 2019-04-05 at 02.01.
23.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-04-05/ on 2019-04-05 at 05.4
1.24.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jeelLibrary/Messages/Archive/2019-04-05/Woody Allen on 2019-04-05 at 06.07.45.ic
hat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-04-05/ on 2019-04-05 at 06.1
3.56.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-04-05/Anil Ambani on 2019-04-05 at 06.48.13.ic
hat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
[9] Source File
[10] Source
Device
[10] Source File
[11] Source
Device
[11] Source File
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-04-05/I
46.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-04-05/
4.12.ichat
NYCO24328.aff4/Macintosh HD
/Users/jee/Library/Messages/Archive/2019-04-05/-
8.49.ichat
on 2019-04-05 at 07.25.
on 2019-04-03 at 05.4
on 2019-04-05 at 12.0
Case Data: Messages (8701-8800 of 14749) Case Data: Messages (8901-9000 of 14749)
EFTA00004070 (Jmail)
 [misc] photos of Epstein with handwritten caption that didn't OCR well
(inferred date: 2026-01-15)
photos of Epstein with handwritten caption that didn't OCR well
EFTA00007550 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-15)
. :• 44 . 'Teti • •
0, •
"4; .,141;•-•
e • 0. • • . • . . . • 'tlevPit
. . . .
•
. 14•
11:::•fs.. • •
: . . • -
.
•%*.
Nie..tel e 4 %.

• • •
.4•31-
•
• • S . - %kr OP
• • ;SA • • . •
•fre..4),,
— • J.:: • •••• it• •••• • tr
t..
.71 0. • • • . •
i
; ' . • V

• • i• •••
.. t i• • Z1 .."'•;
s• I!. • .•:• • • • i4P:. • •
•
• .,.•:.,;te • . . •
1B1 -15a
••••:: Ke• reJ.1 , •
A tScA_ I\oi C-
\ I? )  \
\ \Mae_ --i.cjuA,LA 0(\ -
Q._03-3Con_O-

╭─ Page 2, Image 1 ─╮
│ xe { 5 a,lo,%     │
│ Gia. Comed oe     │
│ Colsana           │
╰───────────────────╯

31 1St-A) Z10
tikalu) Pwros
iotEANA

╭─ Page 3, Image 1 ─╮
│ 1 BL (s-a8¢)      │
│                   │
│ > ganmed Puoros   │
│ CABANA            │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00023557 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of victim who says Ghislaine Maxwell and Epstein pay for nudes
(inferred date: 2026-01-15)
1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
CASE NO. 08-CIV-80119
4 JANE DOE NO. 2,
6 -vs- VOLUME II OF II
7 JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
8 Defendant.
10 Related cases:
11 08-80232, 08-08380, 08-80381, 08-80994
08-80993, 08-80811, 08-80893, 09-80469
12 09-80591, 09-80656, 09-80802, 09-81092
15 VIDEO- NFEREN ED AND VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF
18 December 4, 2009
10:25 - 5:00 p.m.
23 Reported B :
24 Notary Public, State of Florida
Prose Court Reporting
1 APPEARAN
2 On behalf of •
3 JACK SCAROLA, ESQUIRE
SEARCY, DENNEY, SCAROLA,
4 BARNHART HIPLEY P.A.
Phone:
8 On behalf of the Defendant, Jeffrey Epstein:
9 ROBERT D. CRITTON, JR., ESQUIRE
MARK T. LUTTIER, ESQUIRE
10 BURMAN RITT N, LUTTIER & COLEMAN, LLP
I I
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop c.'420Vol../.20I1.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
12 Phone:
15 ALSO PRESENT:
16 efiSe Epstein, via video conference
17 Danchuk, Paralegal,
Richard H. Willits, P.A.
19 Stan Sanders, Videographer
Visual Evidence, Incorporated
2 INDEX VOLUME II
5 WITNESS: DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS
7 CONTINUED
8 BY MR. LUTTIER 170
12 E 11 TB I T S
15 EXHIBIT DESCRIPTION PAGE
16 DEFENDANT'S NO. 1 11
17 Plaintiffs Notice of Serving Second
Amended Answers to Interrogatories
DEFENDANT'S NO. 2
19 Answers of Interrogatories
20 DEFENDANT'S NO. 3
First Amended Complaint
DEFENDANT'S NO. 4 254
22 Plaintiffs Notice of Serving Third
Amended Answers to Defendant's First
23 Interrogatories
2 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: We're going back on the
3 record at 2:42.
4 BY MR. LUTTIER:
5 Q. Mom -- ma'am, at the break we had just
file:///CIADocuments%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop -c:420Vol.°4208.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
mie6 i n discussing your relationship with a
. You used the phrase in your testimony
8 earlier, you used the phrase "eat out." Could you
9 describe what that phrase means in the context that
10 you were using it?
11 MR. SCAROLA: We will stipulate that what
12 it means is cunnilingus.
13 BY MR. LUTTIER:
14 Q. Okay. Do you know what a sex toy is?
15 MR. SCAROLA: Could you explain what
16 relevance or materiality your understanding of
17 that line --
18 MR. LUTTIER: Sure. It was --
19 MR. SCAROLA: -- of questioning might have
20 since there is no allegation that sex toys were
21 ever employed in encounters between and
22 Mr. Epstein?
23 MR. LUTTIER: Well, I dispute that for
24 sure. I just tell you if you read the record
25 carefully, you will find out that is not at all
1 true, and that's why it is relevant. Come up
2 many a time.
3 MR. SCAROLA: In connection with
4 allegations from ?
5 MR. LUTTIER: There and in the IME.
6 MR. SCAROLA: Okay. Well, if you
7 represent, if you represent that that's the
8 case, then proceed.
9 BY MR. LUTTIER:
10 Q. Do you know what a sex toy is?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. Okay. And what is your understanding of
13 that term so that we are understanding each other
14 when I ask you these questions?
15 A. I guess toys used doing sexual things.
16 Q. Okay. And that would include, for
17 example, vibrators?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. Dildos?
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. Have you used sex toys in the past?
22 A. No.
23 Q. Never?
24 A. Never.
25 Q. Either -- how about with ?
1 A. No.
2 Q. Did you ever tell anybody you had?
3 A. No.
4 Q. Did you, did you ever use any sex toy with
5 Jeffrey Epstein?
6 A. He tried to use a massage thing and I told him
7 no.
file:///CIADocuments%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop -c:420Vol.°4208.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
8 Q. What did you mean by "massage thing"?
9 A. Whatever it was in the hell that he had.
10 Q. Well, what -- describe what you are
11 talking about.
12 A. I just told you.
13 Q. Well, massage thing doesn't tell me
14 anything. What are you talking about?
15 A. I don't know what it was called. I don't know
16 what it is.
17 Q. What did it look like?
18 A. It looked -- it was -- I don't know. It
19 vibrated. It looked like it was a neck massager.
20 Q. But do you know, do you know -- can you
21 describe, physically describe how big it was, what
22 color it was, what it looked like? Can you describe
23 anything about it?
24 A. It was gray and do you want me to draw you a
25 picture because I don't know how to describe what it
1 looked like.
2 Q. How large was it?
3 A. It was like this big (indicating).
4 Q. Okay.
5 A. It was like a neck massager.
6 Q. You know like -- you know what Brookstone
7 is, a store?
8 A. Yeah.
9 Q. Have you ever been in there and they have
10 these massages that, like you can reach behind your
11 back and stuff like that. Are we talking about
12 something you know, like that?
13 A. Yeah, but it didn't have a wire, an electrical
14 wire.
15 Q. Okay.
16 A. It was like battery operated.
17 Q. And you say that Mr. Epstein tried to use
18 this on you and you said no?
19 A. Yeah.
20 Q. And then he --
21 A. That was the end of that.
22 Q. -- didn't use it?
23 A. He did not, and he's never, it never was
24 brought up again.
25 Q. Have you ever desired to use any kind of
1 sex toy?
2 A. No.
3 Q. And, and then not done it for some reason?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Okay. Back to . How many
6 sexual encounters would you estimate you had with
8 A. I don't know.
9 Q. What's your best estimate with what degree
file:///CVDocuments%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktor cY020Vol.cY0208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
10 of frequency did you and she have a sexual
11 relationship?
12 MR. SCAROLA: Those are two different
13 questions, compound.
14 THE WITNESS: What does this --
15 MR. LUTTIER: With what --
16 THE WITNESS: What does this have to do
17 with me and Mr. Epstein?
18 BY MR. LUTTIER:
19 grWith what degree of frequency did you and
20 have sexual relations?
21 MR. SCAROLA: That's the second part of
22 the question that you asked.
23 MR. LUTTIER: That's the question. I will
24 break it up then.
1 BY MR. LUTTIER:
2 . You've testified earlier that you and ■
3 had sexual relations?
4 MR. SCAROLA: We'll stipulate that that
5 occurred on multiple occasions.
6 BY MR. LUTTIER:
7 Q. All right. Tell me with what degree --
8 MR. SCAROLA: And beyond that an inquiry
9 is intended for no other purpose except to
10 annoy, harass, and embarrass.
I 1 MR. LUTTIER: With all due respect, I
12 disagree. So, I am going to ask my question.
13 MR. SCAROLA: And I disagree with your
14 disagreement. And I will instruct her not to
15 answer.
16 MR. LUTTIER: Okay. Let me get the
17 question out.
18 BY MR. LUTTIER:
19 Q. On how many occasions did you and
20 have sexual relations?
21 MR. SCAROLA: And the stipulation is that
22 it occurred on multiple occasions and beyond
23 that no relevant inquiry can be made.
24 BY MR. LUTTIER:
25 Q. And when, when your lawyer stipulates that
1 it's multiple occasions, if you had a relationship
2 with her for 12 months, can you estimate how many
3 times it was?
4 A. I refuse --
5 MR. SCAROLA: Don't answer that question.
6 THE WITNESS: -- to answer.
7 MR. LUTTIER: And you refuse to answer --
8 MR. SCAROLA: Because her lawyer has
9 instructed her not to answer because the
10 question is obviously intended, after the
11 stipulation, for no other purpose except to
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop "120Vol.%208.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
12 annoy, embarrass, and harass the witness.
13 MR. LUTTIER: It's, it's not intended to
14 be annoying. I believe the degree of frequency
15 is absolutely relevant in the case.
16 MR. SCAROLA: To what -- to which element?
17 MR. LUTTIER: Arguable -- well --
18 MR. SCAROLA: To which element?
19 MR. LUTTIER: I don't want to --
20 MR. SCAROLA: To which element of the
21 offense?
22 MR. LUTTIER: I am not going to argue my
23 case to you, but it absolutely has an effect on
24 the alleged claim of damages. Beyond that I
25 don't need to tell you the theory of my case
1 but --
2 MR. SCAROLA: I disagree.
3 MR. LUTTIER: Okay.
4 BY MR. LUTTIER:
5 Q. Do you, do ou -- how did your
6 relationship with end?
7 A. I met m son's father.
8 Q. Who is
9 A. Yeah.
10 Q. Did your relationship wit
11 end on an amicable basis?
12 A. What does that mean?
13 Q. Well, did you she and she both agree you
14 were going to go your separate ways --
15 A. Yeah.
16 Q. -- or did you just cut it off?
17 A. We agreed wegsddo separate ways.
18 Q. Did you have name or any
19 portion of her name tattooed on your body?
20 A. Yes, I did.
21 Q. And what did you have tattooed on your
22 body?
23 A. M.
24 Q. And when did you have that done?
25 A. While we were -- when I turned 18.
1 Q. So, it would have been about six years,
2 five years after your relationship ended?
3 A. Yeah.
4 Q. And why did you have her name tattooed on
5 your body five years after you ended your
6 relationship with her?
7 A. Because I felt like it.
8 . Did ou ever rekindle your relationship
9 wit
10 A. No.
11 Q. -- after you, after your 13th birthday?
12 A. No.
13 Q. Did you maintain contact with
file:///CIADocuments%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop -%20Vol.%208.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
14 after you and she broke off your relationship when
15 you met
16 A. No.
17 Q. With respect to the incident that you were
18 describing earlier when you were at Mr. Epstein's
19 house and you said there was another woman present
20 who was nude, do you recall that testimony?
21 A. Yeah.
22 Q. And was there any di inbtw n you
23 and she before she began to on you?
24 A. And I told you no.
25 Q. No words at all exchanged?
1 A. No.
2 Q. So you were just standing there and
3 this --
4 A. Yeah.
5 Q. And what, if an thin did ou say when
6 this person began to on you?
7 A. I didn't say anything. I just felt really
8 weird and I just stood there.
9 Q. And this is a person you had never seen
10 before?
11 A. Yes.
12 . And f r how long a period did this person
13 on you?
14 A. I don't know.
15 Q. And this is while you were standing?
16 A. Yeah.
17 Q. Did, did it, when you say you don't know,
18 are we talking about this went on for 15 or 20
19 minutes or this went on for three minutes?
20 A. Like 15, 20 minutes.
21 Q. Okay. Did you, did you move from where
22 you were standing to some other location while she
23 was doing this?
24 A. I just said no.
25 Q. Did you have an a-
1 A. No.
2 Q. -- as a result of her performing? Did you
3 at an time durin the 15 or 20 minutes that she was
4 on you say anything to her?
5 A. Yeah, I told her to stop.
6 Q. And when did you tell her to stop?
7 A. After like 15 minutes, I told her to stop and
8 that I felt uncomfortable.
9 Q. And what did she do?
10 A. She stopped. And I told Jeffrey I wanted to
11 leave, and he gave me $300 and I left.
12 Q. So, the first time you told this lady to
13 stop, she stopped?
14 A. Yeah.
15 Q. And you told Jeff you wanted to leave and
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktor "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
16 he didn't try to stop you?
17 A. No.
18 Q. Did you perform any sexual act on this
19 woman?
20 A. No.
21 Q. Did you touch her in any way?
22 A. No.
23 Q. And at the time that ou were standing
24 there and this lady wa n you,
25 I assume she was kneeling or something?
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. And where was Mr. Epstein during this?
3 A. Behind her having sex with her.
4 Q. While she was kneeling?
5 A. Yeah.
6 Q. Did you say anything to Mr. Epstein?
7 A. Besides that I wanted to leave, no.
8 Q. Which you said after 15 minutes, right?
9 A. Yeah.
10 Q. How about during the first 15 minutes, did
11 you say anything at all?
12 A. No.
13 Q. Did you say, you know, I am uncomfortable
14 with the set-up; I want to leave?
15 A. I just said no.
16 (Interruption at the door.)
17 MR. LUTTIER: At the time --
18 THE WITNESS: Can you not ask me questions
19 with somebody in the room?
20 BY MR. LUTTIER:
21 Q. What do you mean not ask you questions --
22 A. That man was in here.
23 Q. Had you had any sexual relationship
24 between any other woman other than ■ before this
25 incident that you have described that occurred at
1 Mr. Epstein's?
2 A. No.
3 Q. Have you since the incident that occurred
4 at Mr. E stein's that ou've described, where this
5 lad on you, had any sexual
6 contact with any other female?
7 A. No.
8 Q. Did you ever have any discussion with
9 anyone else at an time with respect to your sexual
10 relationship wit
11 A. What?
12 Q. Did you ever have any discussion with
13 anyone i time about your sexual relationship
14 with
15 A. My mother.
16 Q. And when did you discuss it with your
17 mother?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, Ve20Volte2011.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
18 A. When I was with What does
19 have to do with Mr. Epstein? This is why I am here,
20 because of Mr. Epstein.
21 Q. So, if I understand your testimony
22 correct, you would have discussions with your mother
23 about your relationship with sometime while
24 you were 12 years of age; is that right?
25 A. Yes.
1 Q. What was your mother's reaction?
2 A. She didn't have one.
3 Q. Did she say anything at all to you about
4 it?
5 A. No.
6 Q. Did you ever seek any type of counseling
7 with respect to your relationship with
8 A. For what?
9 Q. For anything. Did you ever discuss --
10 A. No.
11 Q. Did you ever tell any of your mental
12 health counselors about your relationship with
14 A. No.
15 Q. Is there any reason why you didn't tell
16 your mental health counselors?
17 A. Because it --
18 Q. About your relationship with 9
19 A. Because it, it wasn't a problem. What is a
20 problem is you asking me about when I am here
21 about what Mr. Epstein did to me. So, I refuse to
22 answer any more questions that you have about
23 M. So, move on, please.
24 Q. What is the most traumatic event that
25 occurred in your life prior to late May or June of
1 2002 when you met Mr. Epstein?
2 A. There wasn't one.
3 Q. So, if I recall your testimony this
4 morning, you were raped before you met Mr. Epstein?
5 A. I have no recollection of it so if --
6 Q. Wait. You were raped before you met
7 Mr. Epstein?
8 A. Yes, but I don't remember it happening, so I
9 mean --
10 Q. Were you molested by a relative --
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. -- before you met Mr. Epstein?
13 A. Yes.
14 Q. And that was your grandfather?
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. And over what period of time were you
17 molested by your grandfather?
18 A. I was a kid, a child, a baby child.
19 Q. Roughly over what period of time?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop4 9120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
20 A. I don't know the period of time. I was under
21 the age of six.
22 Q. And it went on for an extended period of
23 time?
24 A. I don't know how long it went on for.
25 Q. Was that a disturbing event to you?
1 A. A disturbing, yes.
2 Q. Did you talk to your mental health
3 counselors and advisers about it?
4 A. I told when I was 13.
5 Q. Were you molested by another relative of
6 yours --
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. -- at any time? And who else were you
9 molested by?
10 A. My cousin.
11 Q. And approximately how old were you when
12 that occurred?
13 A. I don't know.
14 Q. Did you bring any, or was any action
15 brought on your behalf, lawsuit, against your
16 grandfather --
17 A. No.
18 Q. -- as a result of him molesting you?
19 A. No.
20 Q. Did you sue the individual that raped you?
21 A. I don't know who iri ndme.
22 Q. Well, did you tell in your
23 meeting with him that you called the police after
24 the rape and had the individual arrested?
25 A. No, I did not. So if he wrote that, then he
1 lied.
2 Q. Okay. Well, fortunately it is videotaped.
3 MR. SCAROLA: Fortunately it is, because
4 ottil itave not accurately reflected what is in
5 notes.
6 BY MR. LUTTIER:
7 Q. Okay. Did, did you bring a lawsuit
8 against anyone as a result of your rape?
9 A. No. How can you sue somebody for raping you
10 if you don't know who did it?
11 Q. Well, presumably at some point you went to
12 the beach with this male, correct?
13 A. Yeah.
14 Q. You got there under your own power; that
15 is you walked out there?
16 A. Yes, but I don't remember the person's name.
17 Q. And when you walked down there with this
18 person, you knew who that person was at that time?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. And you went there with a girlfriend of
21 yours as well, did you not?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, Ve20Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
1 of this person --
2 A. Yes.
1 Q. 2

A. Yes.
Q. And she had somebody with her?
A. Yes. They were her friend.
Q. So, you had a girlfriend who knew the name

Q. -- that went with you?
A. But I don't know where that friend is now.
Q. And the day or the time that you woke up
after this rape, the girlfriend that you went to the
beach with was there?

A. Yes.
Q. And presumably you could have asked her
what the name of this boy was?
A. Well, I was scared.

Q. Did you ask her what the name of the boy
was?
A.
Q. A.
Q. A.
Q. You represented earlier, I believe, that
you were in some type of car accident?

A. Yes.
Q. How many car accidents have you been in?
A. One.
Q. And in what year was that?
A. '08.
No, I didn't. I was scared. I was confused.
Did she call the police?
I don't know what she did.
But in your presence at no time --
She did not.
And did, did you bring a claim against
anyone as a result of any injury you suffered in
that accident?

A. I think my, I think my mom, we did, yeah.
Q. Well, if you did it in '08, it would have
been when you were an adult. You were already 18
years of age?

A. Yeah, I had just had my daughter.
Q. Okay. Then if, if you were an adult, you
would have been the one to bring the claim?

A. Well, my mom did it. We were at a dead stop
and somebody hit us and then we were hit again.
Q. Okay. Did you, did, did you and your mom
assert a claim against an insurance company or the
person that hit you?

A. Yeah.
Q. Did that result in getting some kind of
settlement?
A. I don't know.
Q. Did --
A. I think my case is still pending with it.
Q. Did you, did you have a lawyer
representing you in that action?
file:///CIADocuments%20and%20Settings/Production/Desktop: V.:20Vol."1208.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. Who was the lawyer?
1 A. John Carroll I think.
2 Q. And your recollection is you think there
3 is currently a lawsuit pending?
4 A. Yeah. I am not sure.
5 Q. In your answers to interrogatories you
6 were asked if you had ever been a party to a lawsuit
7 and you responded no. Has the lawsuit --
8 A. Because my mom is the one that is doing it. I
9 was a passenger in her car, so I don't understand. I
10 don't know.
11 Q. Other than this lawsuit arising out of the
12 automobile accident, is there any other lawsuit in
13 which --
14 A. No.
15 Q. -- you have ever been a party?
16 A. No.
17 Q. Was your deposition taken in the lawsuit
18 arising out of the car accident?
19 A. Something like this?
20 Q. Yes.
21 A. No.
22 Q. And is the lawsuit pending in Palm Beach
23 County?
24 A. I guess.
25 Q. In this case you've got a couple of
1 lawyers. One is Mr. Willits?
2 A. Right.
3 Q. Let me see if I have got right here.
4 Yeah, Willits. And how did you get to Mr. Willits?
5 Did you know him before this action?
6 A. No.
7 Q. How was it that you got to Mr. kVillits?
8 A. I looked him up.
9 Q. Where did you look him up?
10 A. In the phone book.
11 Q. Yellow Pages?
12 A. Yes, I did.
13 Q. And you were looking up what? What
14 subject matter were you looking up?
15 A. Civil attorneys.
16 Q. Had you ever met Mr. Willits before you
17 employed him to undertake your representation in
18 this matter?
19 A. Wouldn't that still fall under if I have known
20 him before this?
21 Q. I don't know. So, the first time you ever
22 laid eyes on him or communicated with him is with
23 respect to this suit?
24 A. Obviously, yes.
25 Q. Do you know an individual by the name of
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
1 Brad Edwards?
2 A. No.
3 Q. Have you ever heard his name before?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Do you know other women that have brought
6 claims against Mr. Epstein?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. What other women do you know that have
9 brought claims against Mr. Epstein?
10 A. That's not my information to give you.
11 Q. My question stands.
12 A. I don't feel comfortable telling him.
13 MR. SCAROLA: Well, if you know the names
14 of other women who you know have brought
15 claims.
16 THE WITNESS: I know-. has. I don't
17 know her last name. And I found out after I
18 filed my suit.
19 BY MR. LUTTIER:
20 Q. Anyone else?
21 A. Not that I know of, that are my friends.
22 Q. Well, masestion --
23 A. Me and=. haven't talked since this accident
24 just for the record.
25 Q. My question wasn't limited to your
1 friends. My question was did you know other women,
2 do you know other women that have brought claims to,
3 against Mr. Epstein?
4 A. Personally, no.
5 Q. Well, how would you know them if you
6 didn't know them personally?
7 A. I said no.
8 Q. Well, I'm, I'm getting the impression that
9 you're, al being --
10 A. is the only person that I know that has.
11 Q. And what did you mean when you answered
12 earlier to my question when I asked you if you knew
13 other women that had brought claims against
14 Mr. Epstein, you answered yes?
15 A. And you wrote down M., did you not?
16 Q. That's the only person that you were
17 referring to?
18 A. Yes.
19 . Have you ever heard of a lady by name of
20 .?
21 A. No.
22 Q. Jane Doe?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Who -- all right. This person, M., how
25 do you know this person, M.?
1 A. She was a friend of mine.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: V.:20Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
2 Q. And she was a friend of yours commencing
3 when? When did you first meet her?
4 A. I don't remember. Years ago.
5 Q. Before you went to see Mr. Epstein?
6 A. No. She, I met her through my friend
7 Q. Who -- what's name?
8 A.
9 Q. Do you know any other girls that claim to
10 have gone to Mr. Epstein's house to perform massages
11 on him?
12 A. Do what?
13 Q. Do you know any other girls that have gone
14 to Mr. Epstein's house and claimed to have performed
I 5 massages on him?
16 A. Me, .., and .., those are the only girls
17 that I know.
18 And how is it that you met through
19 M.?
20 A. How do you meet your friends through friends?
21 Q. I have no idea. I mean, were you guys at
22 a party together, did you get on the phone with each
23 other? What did you do?
24 A. We were hanging out.
25 Q. "Hanging out," what's that mean?
1 A. When you hang out.
2 Q. Were you at a function and all three of
3 you were there, for example?
4 A. Obviously we were at something hanging out.
5 Q. And did there come a time that you took
6 anyone to Mr. Epstein's house?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. When was that?
9 A. I don't remember the times and dates but I
10 took and
11 Q. And which did you take first?
12 A.
13 Q. And in respect to when you went to
14 Mr. Epstein's between May and June of '02 and August
15 of '03, when was it that you took
16 A. Bro, I don't know. I just told you I don't
17 know times and dates.
18 Q. I realize you don't know the exact time.
19 But was it in '02 or was it in '03?
20 A. If I, if you know that I don't know the dates,
21 how would you ask me if it was in '02 or '03?
22 Q. Well, what's your best estimate of how
23 many Sits you had made to Mr. Epstein's before you
24 took M.?
25 A. I have no idea.
1 Q. More than ten?
2 A. Probably.
3 Q. How long had you known before you
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktop "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
4 took her to Mr. Epstein's?
5 A. I have known M. for years. I met M., I
6 don't know. Ask me the question ig& , please.
7 Q. How long had you known M. before you
8 took her to Mr. Epstein's?
9 A. For about a year.
10 Q. And how did you meet M.?
11 A. She lived down the street from me.
12 Q. Was she a close friend?
13 A. Yes, she was. She was my best.
14 Q. You wouldn't do anything to harm her,
15 correct?
16 A. Correct.
17 Q. By the time you took M. to
18 Mr. Epstein's, you had performed massages for
19 Mr. Epstein in the total nude; is that correct?
20 A. Uh-huh.
21 THE COURT REPORTER: Is that a yes?
22 THE WITNESS: Yes.
23 BY MR. LUTTIER:
24 Q. You had already had this sexual
25 relationship with this woman that you described
1 earlier at Mr. Epstein's?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. You mentioned earlier that on these
4 occasions when you gave Mr. Epstein a massage, he
5 would masturbate I believe you said; is that right?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Did that occur, that is Mr. Epstein
8 masturbating, on each and every occasion when you
9 went to Mr. Epstein's from the first occasion to the
10 last occasion?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. Did you physically see him masturbating?
13 A. Yes.
14 Q. That is there was no towel covering his
15 genitalia or anything like that?
16 A. No.
17 Q. Before you went to Mr. Epstein's for the
18 first time, you had had sexual relations with other
19 males, had you not?
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. And you'd had sexual relations with how
22 many males before you went to Mr. Epstein's for the
23 first time?
24 A. Three.
25 Q. And what did those sexual relationships
1 consist of that you had had before you went
2 Mr. Epstein's?
3 A. Intercourse.
4 Q. Did -- had you, other than with M,
5 had you had any oral sex with any individual
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktop "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
6 other --
7 A. No.
8 Q. -- than before you went to
9 Mr. Epstein's for the first time?
10 A. No.
11 Q. Before you went to Mr. Epstein's for the
12 first time, had you seen any, either these males
13 that you had previous relationships with or any
14 other male masturbate?
15 A. No.
16 Q. Had you seen any pornographic materials
17 before you went to Mr. Epstein's for the first time?
18 A. No. I don't watch porn.
19 Q. Had, have you ever been photographed in
20 the nude?
21 A. No. At Mr. Epstein's, yes.
22 Q. How about any place other than
23 Mr. Epstein's?
24 A. No.
25 Q. And who photographed you in the nude at
1 Epsteins?
2 A.
3 Q. 4 A.
5 Q. And when in this time period that you went
6 to Mr. Epstein's did photograph you in the
7 nude?
8 A. It had to have been in the summer. It was in
9 the summer.
10 Q. And why do you know it was in the summer?
11 A. Because it was summertime.
12 Q. And where did this photographing occur?
13 A. In Mr. Epstein's house.
14 Q. Where in the house?
15 A. Everywhere in the house, outside by the pool,
16 and outside off the dock by the Intracoastal.
17 Q. Were you photographed on more than one
18 occasion?
19 A. No.
20 Q. Let me rephrase the question. You
21 mentioned that you were photographed everywhere in
22 the house?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. Was there --
25 A. It was in the same day.
1 Q. But more than one picture was taken?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. All right. And what type of, do you know
4 what type of camera was used? Was it a digital
5 camera or a --
6 A. A digital camera.
7 Q. All right.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
8 A. It was digital -- it wasn't like a digital
9 camera like, it was like a photography digital camera
10 like a professional camera, a professional digital
11 photography camera.
12 Q. Are you, are you --
13 A. Not like one you buy at Wal-Mart.
14 Q. When you're describing it as a
15 professional digital camera, are you talking about a
16 camera that's got a big lens on it?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. And did this --
19 A. And there, and there was a regular digital
20 camera. She used two different cameras.
21 Q. And you say this was, in addition to being
22 in the house, was that on a dock?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. And, and were you completely nude for all
25 of these photographs?
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. So this happened in the daytime?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. I assume the dock is out somewhere near
5 the Intracoastal?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Out in plain view?
8 A. But there was nobody outside. I made sure
9 there was nobody that could see me.
10 Q. Had anyone before that occasion ever
11 photographed you in the complete nude?
12 A. And I already said no.
13 Q. And how many photographs would you
14 estimate were taken?
15 A. I don't know. At least ten.
16 Q. Did you -- how, how is it that it -- well,
17 strike that.
18 Did, did ask you if she could take
19 photographs of you in the nude?
20 A. She called me and told me that Mr. Epstein
21 would pay me $500 if there could be nude pictures taken
22 of me. And my words to her were only if you take them;
23 I will not let Mr. Epstein take them of me.
24 Q. All right. So you set the conditions
25 under which the photographs were to be taken?
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. And the photographs were taken with your
3 knowledge and consent, correct?
4 A. (Witness nods head.)
5 Q. Did you ever see the photographs?
6 A. Since that day, no. I saw them on the camera.
7 I've never seen the actual photographs.
8 Q. Did you make any comment to about
9 the photographs?
file:///CVDocuments%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Deslaop, cY020Volte2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
10 A. Yeah, I asked them what would happen with
11 them, and she told me that they were for Mr. Epstein's
12 personal enjoyment.
13 Q. Was Mr. Epstein present when these
14 photographs were taken?
15 A. No, not to my awareness.
16 Q. You -- that is on the occasion that you
17 went to the house when these photographs were taken,
18 you never saw Mr. Epstein?
19 A. Yes, I didn't see Mr. Epstein. No.
20 Q. Have you ever been photographed in any
21 kind of sexual act?
22 A. No.
23 Q. Have you ever been filmed in the nude --
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. -- as supposed to still pictures. When
1 were you filmed in the nude?
2 A. With one of my boyfriends.
3 Q. And which ne was that?
4 A.
5 Q. And when was he your boyfriend?
6 A. I was 13.
7 Q. Excuse me?
8 A. When I was 13.
9 Q. And how did you know
10 A. He was my boyfriend.
11 Q. Did you, what did you grow up in the
12 community with you?
13 A. We went to school together.
14 Q. Was this before or after the Stime
15 that you had your relationship with
16 A. It was after. Well, it was before. I
17 don't -- it was like during type of thing. Even though
18 she was my girlfriend, we still had boyfriends if that
19 helps you.
20 Q. Who -- was anyone filmed with you in the
21 nude?
22 A. No, just me and him.
23 Q. But the film was of the two of you
24 together as supposed to just you alone?
25 A. Yes.
1 Q. And what were you and he doing in the
2 film?
3 A. Having sex.
4 Q. Just intercourse?
5 A. Yeah.
6 Q. And who was doing the filming?
7 A. The camera.
8 Q. So, it was placed on a tripod or
9 something?
10 A. Yeah.
11 Q. And where did the filming take place?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop cX:20Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
12 A. In the privacy of our bedroom.
13 Q. At you house?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. And when I say your house, I mean the
16 house that you were living in at the time.
17 A. No, it was his house.
18 Q. And did, obviously you were aware of the
19 fact you were being filmed?
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. Did, did (phonetic) ask you --
22 A. His name is
23 Q. Did
24 beforehand?
25 A. Yes.
1 Q. Did you indicate to him that you had any
2 reservations about it?
3 A. Did I indicate --
4 Q. Did you tell him it was okay to do it?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. Did you guys watch the film after you did
7 it?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. Was the film --
10 A. And we laughed about it.
11 Q. Was the film ever shown to anyone else?
12 A. No. The tape was destroyed.
13 Q. For what period of time did u have a
14 sexual relationship with
I 5 A. I don't know. For as long as we dated.
16 Q. Are we talking about a year?
17 A. No. Less than that. Couple of months.
18 Q. Less than a year. How, roughly on how
19 man ccasions would you estimate you had sex with
21 A. I don't know.
22 Q. Did you have it with any degree of
23 regularity? I mean, once a week, twice a week?
24 A. Once or twice a week.
25 Q. Did -- when you had sex with
1 when you were 13 once or twice a week, did you take
2 any precautions about getting pregnant?
3 A. Yeah.
4 Q. And what precautions did you use?
5 A. A condom.
6 Q. Have you ever had any abortions?
7 A. No.
8 Q. You have two children?
9 A. Yes, I do.
10 Q. And when was your first child born?
11 A. When I was 17.
Q. Do you know our child's birthday?
A. Yeah,
ask you if he could do that
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktor "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
14 Q. And that's the child with
15 A. Yes.
16 . And then you had a daughter with
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. And what's our daughter's birthdate?
20 A.
21 Q. And where was your child with
22 born?
23 A. Good Samaritan Hospital.
24 Q. Where was the child with
25 A. Good Samaritan hospital.
1 I planned both my children.
2 Q. Did you, have you at any time lost a
3 pregnancy; that is been pregnant --
4 A. Yes, I have.
5 Q. Okay. And when did that occur?
6 A. April of '08.
7 Q. Literally a month, less than a month after
8 you had --
9 A. Before.
10 Q. Your child -- okay. Let's go back because
11 you, if I got your testimony right --
12 A. Oh, not '08. I'm sorry.
13 Q. Yeah.
14 A. My daughter was born in. It was '07.
15 Q. Okay. April of '07 is when you lost a
16 child?
17 A. Uh-huh.
18 Q. And who was the father of that child?
19 A. That's irrelevant.
20 Q. Was it someone other than
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. Was it
23 A. No, it was not.
24 Q. Was it
25 A. Yes.
1 Q. Had, had that been a planned pregnancy?
2 A. No.
3 Q. Was that, that is the loss of the child
4 that you had with a traumatic event to
5 you?
6 A. No.
7 Q. And by traumatic I mean were you upset
8 about it?
9 A. No.
10 Q. And do you know why you weren't upset
11 about it?
12 A. Because it obviously wasn't meant to happen
13 because I didn't do anything for my child to die. It
14 just died inside me, so obviously it wasn't meant to be.
15 Q. And where were you at the time that that
file:///CIADocuments%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktop: 9120Vol.91208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
16 occurred?
17 A. That, that I was hospitalized for?
18 Q. No, when you first lost the child.
19 A. I was in New Jersey.
20 Q. Were you living in New Jersey at sometime?
21 A. Yes, I was.
22 Q. When did you live in New Jersey?
23 A. Earlier that year in 2007.
24 Q. And obviously then there had come a time
25 sometime in early 2007 when you changed your
1 residency from Florida and moved to New Jersey?
2 A. Yes. And then I moved back to Florida and
3 started having a miscarriage. And I had to have an
4 operation. And the baby was dead inside me, and I was
5 five months pregnant.
6 Q. When ou moved to New Jersey, did you move
7 with this
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. And when did you first meet
10 A. In '06.
11 Q. When?
12 A. '06.
13 Q. Had -- how w uld ou characterize your
14 relationship with
15 A. Great.
16 Q. Any domestic violence?
17 A. Nope.
18 Q. Had he ever threatened you?
19 A. Nope.
20 Q. When did you first meet
21 A. When I was 13.
22 Q. Did you, did you meet him before you first
23 went to Mr. Epstein's?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. Had you had a sexual relationship with
1 obviously?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. Had you had sex with before you
4 went to Mr. Epstein's the first time?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. And what sexual acts had you engaged in
7 with before you went to Mr. Epstein's?
8 A. Intercourse.
9 Q. And did you consider to be your
10 boyfriend?
11 A. Yeah.
12 Q. And were you dating him during the entire
13 period of time that you went to Mr. Epstein's?
14 A. Yeah.
15 Q. And did ever physically bring
16 you to Mr. Epstein's house?
17 A. Yes.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, °420Volte2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
18 Q. Did you ever pay any money for
19 bringing you to Mr. Epstein's house?
20 A. No.
21 Q. Did ever bring anyone else to
22 Mr. Epstein's house?
23 A. My brother came with us but he didn't bring
24 any other females, to
25 Q. How about M.?
1 A. Oh, M. and M., when I went with them. He
2 didn't bring them there by themselves.
3 Q. Let me go back and make sure my question
4 is cl . Was there, was there ever an occasion
5 that drove a vehicle in which there were
6 other girls that were delivered to Mr. Epstein's
7 house other than just yourself?
8 A. You say delivered like we're a bunch of
9 flowers for him.
10 Q. Pick whatever, what word would you prefer,
11 dropped off?
12 A. Yes, that sounds a lot more better than
13 delivered.
14 Q. Fine. Whatever ou want. Ever any
15 occasion where brought any females that
16 he dropped off at Mr. E stein's other than --
17 A. Yes rite and ., and me and
18 Q. Did M. or . ever pay any
19 money for bringing them?
20 A. No.
21 Q. Did you ever receive any money from
22 Mr. Epstein for bringing ■.?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. How much did you get?
25 A. An extra $100.
1 Q. And did you tell M. that you were paid
2 $100 by Mr. Epstein to bring her to him?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. And what was her response?
5 A. I want half.
6 Q. And what did you say to that?
7 A. Okay.
8 Q. So, you gave her 50 of the $100?
9 A. Yeah.
10 Q. And everybody was happy?
11 A. Yeah.
12 Q. Did you bring M. on more than one
13 occasion?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. Did you get paid $100 on each occasion --
16 A. Yes.
17 . -- that you brought M.? Did you tell
18 . on each occasion when you got paid $100 to
19 bring her?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, Ve20Volte2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. And did you give her half the 100 or $50
every time --

A. Yes.
Q. -- that you were aid? On how many
occasions did bring M. and get paid $100?
1 Q. Did you tell her you
2 first discussed it with her everything that you had
3 experienced in going to Mr. Epstein's?
4 A. No.

A. Three or four times.
Q. How much did M. get paid to come to
Mr. Epstein's?
A. 200, sometimes three. Ism not sure which
times. Probabl the times when she went there herself.

Q. Did M. go to Mr. Epstein's on occasions
other than when she went with you?
A. Yes.
Q. But she had never been there until you
took her the first time?

A. Yes.
Q. Were st the individual that first
suggested to M. that she go to Mr. Epstein's?
A. Obviously if I'm the one who brought her there
for the first time.

Q. Well, it would be possible that she could
have heard of Mr. Epstein from someplace else.
A. No.
Q. So the first time she heard the name
Jeffrey Epstein was from you?

A. Yes.
And on the first occasion when you told
M. about Jeffrey Epstein, what did you tell her?
A. That we would go there and give him a massage
and he might ask you to get topless.

Q. A.
Q. A.
Q. A.
Q. to it?
A. Because I knew that I felt uncomfortable with
the thing with the girl. And I told Jeffrey if he did
it to my friends, I would not bring them.

Q. Okay.
A. So I knew that she wouldn't have been exposed
to it.
Q. So, in your, you had some conversation at
some point in time with Jeffrey Epstein about --
A. I took -- when he asked me to bring some girls
at the time that
Why not?
Because I knew she wouldn't be exposed to it.
And this was your best friend?
Yes.
And you say you knew what?
I knew that she wouldn't be exposed to it.
What do you mean she wouldn't be exposed
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktor "120Vol."120Ilixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
22 my age, I told him that I would not bring my friend if,
23 if that situation was to occur with her because I didn't
24 like it. I felt uncomfortable, and I would not subject
25 my friend to it.
1 Q. Is that the only thing that had occurred
2 when you were at Mr. Epstein's that you did not tell
3 M. about?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. So, you had told M. that Mr. Epstein
6 might masturbate while she was there?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. Did you tell her that he might ejaculate
9 while she was there?
10 A. Not on her but yes.
11 Q. Well, did Mr. Epstein ever ejaculate on
12 you?
13 A. No.
14 Q. All right. What did you tell M. before
15 you took her there for the first time about what the
16 state of dress that she would be in?
17 A. I just told her to wear clothes.
18 Q. Did you tell her that she may be asked to
19 be totally nude?
20 A. I said that she, she might ask to take off
21 some of her clothes. I didn't specifically say you're
22 going to have to get naked.
23 Q. But you had been, at that point in time
24 that you first took M. there, you had been totally
25 nude for months while performing massages for
1 Mr. Epstein, correct?
2 A. So.
3 Q. Correct?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. But you didn't tell your best friend that?
6 A. No, because if he was going ask her, that
7 would be him asking her and that would be her own
8 decision.
9 Q. You didn't consider there to be anything
10 dangerous about going to Mr. Epstein, did you?
11 A. No.
12 Q. I mean, you never felt like you were in
13 danger when you went to Mr. Epstein's did you?
14 A. No.
I 5 Q. You never felt that any harm was going to
16 come to you?
17 A. No.
18 Q. And you really never had any fear about
19 going there, correct?
20 A. Correct. May I take a break to go to the
21 bathroom?
22 MR. LUTTIER: Sure.
23 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the record at 3:30.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop "120Vol.%208.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
24 (A brief recess was held.)
25 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: We're back on the
1 record at 3:43.
2 BY MR. LUTTIER:
3 SYou mentioned earlier that you had seen a
4 . Is that
5 A. Yes,
6 Q. Have you consulted with any other, what we
7 call expert witness in this case, that is someone
8 that's been hired to assist you in your case, not
9 your lawyers but --
10 A. No.
11 Q. Okay. Do you, have you spoken with anyone
12 else about the possibility of testifying in this
13 case?
14 A. Like who?
15 Q. Anybody.
16 A. No. Probably my son's father because he took
17 me there.
18 Q. That would be --
19 A. Mnysther.
20 Q. a? 21 A. Yes. And my mother.
22 . And and when did your relationship with
23 end, if it ended?
24 A. When I was 18.
25 Q. That's '05?
1 A. Yeah.
2 Q. So you were with him from what did you
3 tell me, 0 --
4 A. '01.
5 Q. '01 to '05, correct?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Did there -- there obviousl came a time
8 that you got pregnant with
9 A. Obviously.
10 Q. Did you and leave the State of
11 Florida together at some point in time?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. And approximately when was that?
14 A. It was in July when I was 16.
15 Q. '03?
16 A. Yeah.
17 Q. Is that the same time that you stopped
18 going to Mr. Epstein's?
19 A. Uh-huh.
20 Q. And is that, in fact --
21 MR. LUTTIER: Did you get that answer?
22 THE COURT REPORTER: Uh-huh.
23 BY MR. LUTTIER:
24 Q. -- is that in fact why you st in
25 to Mr. Epstein's, because you and were
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, (.420Volte2011.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
1 leaving?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. And where did you and go?
4 A. To Rome, Georgia.
5 Q. And when I said, when I say that you went
6 there, did you physically move your residency to
7 start living there?
8 A. Obviously.
9 Q. And did you live with some relatives or
10 friends or something in Rome?
11 A. His relatives.
12 Q. And who would that have been?
13 A. His father and his aunt and uncle.
14 . Wh n you left to go to Rome, Georgia, with
I 5 in July of '03, did you know you were
16 pregnant?
17 A. No.
18 Q. When did you first learn you were
19 pregnant?
20 A. In August.
21 Q. Of '03?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. And when you learned you were pregnant in
24 August of '03 for how long had you been pregnant?
25 A. I, actually I think we left in June because in
1 August I had already been three months pregnant.
2 Q. Had you and Mr., not Mr. -- had you used
3 any drugs, nonprescription drugs between June of '03
4 and August of '03?
5 A. No.
6 Q. When was the last time you had used any
7 drug for which you didn't have a prescription?
8 That's a bad question.
9 A. I don't know.
10 Q. Starting in August of '03 and going back
11 in time, when was the last time?
12 A. Probably in the beginning of '03.
13 Q. Beginning of '03--
14 A. We left, we left --
15 Q. You mean January of '03?
16 A. No, if you would let me finish. We left the
17 State of Florida because we had a bad cocaine habit by
18 that point. With all the money that I received from
19 Mr. Epstein I could afford it. So, we had made a
20 decision to leave the State of Florida and I had been
21 clean for about a month and we couldn't handle it. So
22 we decided to leave the State of Florida so we wouldn't
23 have to worry about it anymore.
24 Q. So, if you left in June of '03 that means
25 your last use of cocaine would have been in May of
1 '03?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
2 A. May, June, yeah.
3 Q. And at that point in time, that is in May
4 of '03, what form of cocaine were you using?
5 A. Powder.
6 Q. As of May of 03, had you, had you ever
7 used crack cocaine?
8 A. No.
9 Q. From May of '03, or I should say after May
10 of '03, when you became aware that you were pregnant
11 in August of '03, did you use any drugs at all
12 during your pregnancy?
13 A. No. Other than nicotine.
14 Q. Say what?
15 A. Other than nicotine.
16 . And you had a healthy child born
18 A. Yes, I did.
19 Q. Born where, at what state, Florida or
20 Georgia?
21 A. In Florida.
22 . Was there a point in time that you and
23 returned to Florida?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. When was that?
1 A. When I was eight months pregnant. So, in
2 February.
3 Q. Of '04?
4 A. Yeah.
5 Q. And, and why did you return to Florida?
6 A. Because it was too cold for my mother.
7 Q. And what did your mother have do with it?
8 A. My mother moved to Georgia with me when she
9 found out I was pregnant.
10 Q. And that would have been when?
11 A. Obviously --
12 Q. You, you found out you were pregnant in
13 August?
14 A. I was pregnant in August.
15 Q. Did you tell her that?
16 A. Yes. And she moved up there immediately. My
17 mom had moved up there because I thought I was pregnant
18 and she was there the day I took the pregnancy test.
19 O. And did she live, literally live with you
20 and or live in a separate place?
21 A. She had boughten (sic) her own place.
22 Q. And she stayed there from August of '03 to
23 February of '04 --
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. -- continuously?
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. Were you, after did you
3 remain -- strike that. Did you use any drugs,
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, (.420Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
4 illegal drugs after
5 A. Yes, I did.
6 Q. When was the first time you used an
7 illegal drug after March of '04?
8 A. When I turned 18.
9 Q. Which would have been --
10 A. January.
11 Q. January of --
12 A. '05.
13 Q. So, you were absolutely drug free, that is
14 you didn't use any illegal drug whatsoever from May
15 of '03 to January of '05?
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. Did you, during that period from May of
18 '03 to January '05 go to any kind of a drug
19 rehabilitation --
20 A. No.
21 Q. -- clinic? Did you have to seek any kind
22 of --
23 A. No.
24 Q. -- medical assistance to stop using drugs?
25 A. No.
1 Q. Did you, did you use anything, patches or
2 any of the products that are available in the
3 general public to try to get off of drugs?
4 A. No.
5 Q. So, you were able on just strictly on your
6 own will --
7 A. Yeah.
8 Q. -- to stop using all drugs from May of '03
9 to January of '05?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. How would you describe your life from July
12 of '03 when you, approximately when you moved to
13 Georgia through February of '04?
14 A. Frustrating.
15 Q. And why was it frustrating?
16 A. Because I had a lot of secrets that I had held
17 from about Mr. Epstein, and I was just felt like I
18 was losing my mind.
19 Q. Did you seek any medical attention through
20 the period from July 3rd to February '04. July of
21 '03 to February '04?
22 A. Yes, when I was pregnant, yes, I did. I went
23 to a baby doctor.
24 Q. Did you seek any mental health treatment?
25 A. No.
1 Q. You say you held secrets from . What
2 secrets did you hold from
3 A. What exactly was happening at Mr. Epstein's
4 house.
5 Q. Well, you indicated that took you to
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktop c:420Vol.°420II.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
6 Mr. Epstein's on more than one occasion?
7 A. But he didn't know what ,doing.
8 Q. When was the first time took you to
9 Mr. Epstein's?
10 A. I don't know.
11 Q. But we know it wasn't the first or second
12 time, right?
13 A. Yeah.
14 Q. Because on those occasions you went with
15 Jane Doe No. 102?
16 A. He only, he only took me sometimes because
17 Mr. Epstein paid for either his drivers to pick me up
18 and drop me off or a Yellow Cab.
19 Q. Well, do you recall the first, the
20 incident the first time took you?
21 A. What do you mean the incident?
22 Q. Well, do you recall what you told him
23 first time when you had him take you?
A. That I was goiiiiilean his house.
Q. And what did say in response?
1 A. Okay.
2 Q. Did you, the next time that he took you,
3 did you tell him anything different?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Did there ever come a time that when
6 took you to Mr. Epstein's you told him anything
7 other than you were going there to clean the house?
8 A. No.
9 Q. Did ever ask you -- or, or strike
10 that. When took you to Mr. Epstein's, did he
11 wait for you or did he come back?
12 A. He waited for me.
13 Q. And where did he wait?
14 A. Outside by the Intracoastal. It was in front
15 of the house the FBI was at.
16 Q. So, he didn't come in the house?
17 A. No.
18 Q. Did he ever meet Mr. Epstein?
19 A. Yes, he has.
20 Q. Did he ever have any discussions with
21 Mr. Epstein?
22 A. Yeah, about the Shelby Cobra that Mr. Epstein
23 has. My wires --
24 THE COURT REPORTER: The what?
25 THE WITNESS: Shelby Cobra. My wire is
1 stuck in this chair.
2 MR. DANCHUK: Hold on.
3 MR. SCAROLA: Let's go off the record for
4 just a second, please.
5 (A brief recess was held.)
6 BY MR. LUTTIER:
7 Q. Were you present for any discussions
file:///CVDocuments%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktopi Ve20Vol.cY0208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
8 between and Mr. Epstein?
9 A. Yes, I was.
10 Q. And where did they take place?
11 A. Outside in the driveway in front of the garage
12 that had all the cars.
13 Q. When was the last time you had contact
14 with
15 A. Thanksgiving.
16 Q. Of this year?
17 A. Yeah.
18 Q. And what did that contact consist of?
19 A. Eating turkey.
20 Q. Did you-all celebrate Thanksgiving
21 together?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. You do.
24 A. We do. We celebrate every holiday together.
25 Q. And where was that?
1 A. At my mother's house.
2 Q. Did you discuss with this case?
3 A. Absoh,not.
4 Q. Has ever discussed with you his
5 contact or discussions with Mr. Epstein?
6 A. Yes. He told me that you guys tried to hire
7 him.
8 Q. Who do you mean by "you guys"?
9 A. Mr. Epstein's law firms.
10 Q. Which firms are you talking about?
11 A. The ones that defend Mr. Epstein.
12 Q. Did you know how many law firms that is?
13 A. I have no idea. All I know is that his law
14 firms tried to hire my son's father.
15 Q. And when did he tell you that?
16 A. Last year.
17 Q. Meaning calendar year '08?
18 A. Yep.
19 Q. And was incarcerated recently?
20 A. Yes, he was.
21 Q. And when was he incarcerated?
22 A. I believe it was -- was it -- I think it was
23 last year.
24 Q. That would be '08?
25 A. Yes.
1 Q. When did he get released from
2 incarceration?
3 A. I don't know the date.
4 Q. So, did these lawyers that were trying to
5 hire him go meet him in jail? Is that what you are
6 saying?
7 A. I don't know. Mr. Epstein was in jail with
8 him.
9 Q. So, Mr. Epstein and met each
file:///CVDocuments%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop Ve20Vol.cY0208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
10 other while they were both incarcerated in the same
11 institution?
12 A. No. Mr. and Mr. Epstein, or
13 and Mr. Epstein met each other while I was still going
14 to Mr. Epstein's house, but then again met while they
15 were incarcerated together.
16 Q. Did ever share with you what he told
17 Mr. Epstein about you?
18 A. No.
19 Q. Did he ever tell you that he discussed you
20 with Mr. Epstein?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. But he didn't tell you what he said?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Did he ever tell you what he said about
25 what information you knew about Mr. Epstein before
1 you went --
2 A. No.
3 Q. -- to see him the first time? Did he ever
4 tell you about what you told the other girls before
5 you took them to Mr. Epstein's?
6 A. No.
7 Q. Did he ever tell you that he attempted to
8 get employment from Mr. Epstein?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And what did he tell you Mr. Epstein said
11 in response to that?
12 A. I have no idea. But if you would like to let
13 me know, o ahead.
14 Q. Is as far as you know, an
15 honest person?
16 A. No.
17 Q. He is not honest?
18 A. Absolutely not.
19 Q. So you wouldn't believe what he says?
20 A. No. Would you?
21 Q. No meaning that my statement is correct,
22 you would not believe what he says?
23 A. That's what I am saying.
24 Q. So, you don't really believe the statement
25 he made to you that, what somebody tried to hire --
1 A. No, I believe that you guys tried to hire him.
2 Q. How do you decide which statements he
3 makes you believe and which you don't?
4 A. He showed me the address.
5 Q. The address of what?
6 A. Your guys's law firm.
7 Q. Well, you keep saying, you guys. What
8 firm is that?
9 A. The attorneys on Mr. Epstein's side off of
10 Flagler Drive.
11 Q. And did he tell you, did tell
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: cY020Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
12 you that he came to meet with those lawyers?
13 A. Yes, he did.
14 Q. Did he tell you whether or not every
15 single word he said had been recorded?
16 A. I have no idea. He didn't tell me anything
17 about it.
18 Q. Did he tell you who-all was present at the
19 meeting?
20 A. No, he didn't.
21 Q. He didn't tell you anything about what he
22 said at that meeting, did he?
23 A. No.
24 Q. And in particular he didn't say what he
25 said about you, did he?
1 A. No.
2 Q. You didn't ask him either, did you?
3 A. I did and he wouldn't tell me.
4 Q. Did you wonder why he wouldn't tell you
5 what he had told Mr. Epstein's lawyers about you?
6 A. No, and I could really care less because he
7 didn't go through half the traumatic things I did with
8 Mr. Epstein.
9 Q. Well, what traumatic things did you go
10 through?
11 A. Well, being that I was an underage girl with
12 an old man masturbating in front of me and bribing me
13 with hundreds and hundreds of dollars --
14 Q. And how did that, how did that result in
15 any injury to you?
16 A. Well, my mental stability is nothing like it
17 used to be before I met Mr. Epstein.
18 Q. What do you mean by mental stability?
19 A. I'm scared to go places by myself. I have
20 trust issues with people now. I don't like when older
21 guys stare at me.
22 Q. Well, after you worked -- anything else?
23 A. Oh, no, you can go ahead.
24 Q. No, I want to get all your injuries that
25 you claim you have suffered as a result of going to
1 Mr. Epstein's. Anything else?
2 A. You may continue.
3 Q. Is there anything else or have you now
4 told me everything and I will go back and ask you
5 about it?
6 A. You can continue asking me questions.
7 Q. Is there any other way you suffered any
8 damage as a result of going to Mr. Epstein other
9 than your mental stability is not the same, you're
10 scared to go places by yourself, that older guys,
11 you don't like it when older guys stare at you.
12 A. I have trust issues.
13 Q. Trust issues. Anything else?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktop: c:420Vol.°420II.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
14 A. I don't know right now.
15 Q. Do you know of any way you suffered any
16 damage?
17 A. What?
18 MR. SCAROLA: Well, you have already heard
19 repeatedly --
20 MR. LUTTIER: No speaking -- Other than
21 what you have told me in this deposition.
22 MR. SCAROLA: That's fine.
23 BY MR. LUTTIER:
24 Q. Okay. Is that it?
25 A. Yeah, that's it.
1 Q. Okay. Now, what do you mean when you say
2 you have trust issues.
3 A. Exactly what I said.
4 Q. Well, I don't understand that. Explain
5 that. Explain that to me. What do you mean you
6 have trust issues?
7 A. I have trust issues with people.
8 Q. Meaning what, you can't trust people?
9 A. No, I can't.
10 Q. Anybody?
11 A. Guys particularly.
12 Q. Males?
13 A. Males, older males.
14 Q. Any males, older males?
15 A. Yes.
16 Q. What age male does it have to be for you
17 not to be able trust them?
18 A. Older than myself.
19 Q. So, any man that is older than you, you
20 don't feel like you can trust him?
21 A. No.
22 Q. How has that impacted you in your daily
23 life?
24 A. Well, I go outside and there is men
25 everywhere.
1 Q. Okay. So, what effect does that have on
2 you? You can't trust the people --
3 A. Exactly --
4 Q. -- according to you?
5 A. -- it. I can't trust nobody.
6 Q. So, you're not asking them to do anything
7 or do anything for you, are you?
8 A. No, because I don't want them to.
9 Q. Okay. So, help me understand how has this
10 impacted you at all that you claim you can't trust
11 men that are older than you?
12 A. Because I can't trust them. What else do you
13 want me to say?
14 Q. Well, I want you to describe how --
15 A. I can't --
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: €420Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
16 Q. How your damage -- what is it that you
17 want these men to do --
18 A. Nothing, I don't want them to do anything.
19 Q. -- that -- wait a minute.
20 A. I want them all to leave me alone.
21 Q. What is it that you want these men to do
22 that you can't trust them to do?
23 A. There is nothing that I don't want, that I
24 want them to do.
25 Q. Have you ever asked a man older than you
1 to do something?
2 A. Other than my attorneys, no.
3 Q. All right.
4 A. No offense to you guys.
5 Q. So, there has never been an occasion since
6 you last went to Mr. Epstein where you asked a man
7 that was older than you to do something and you
8 counted on trusting them?
9 A. I counted -- well, my attorneys, but that's
10 it.
11 Q. Okay. But there has never been a time
12 that you've placed your trust --
13 A. I refuse --
14 Q. Wait a minute.
15 A. No, I don't let them, allow them.
16 Q. Now, so, you haven't even attempted to,
17 quote, to use your words, trust a man that's older
18 than you since you last saw Mr. Epstein; is that
19 correct?
20 A. Yes. That's correct.
21 Q. Now, when you say trust, do you mean you
22 don't want to be in their physical presence?
23 A. I don't, no, I don't want to be in their
24 physical presence.
25 Q. But in fact as you testified earlier, you
1 worked for at least two escort services where you
2 have gone out and been paid to be in the presence of
3 men older than you, correct?
4 A. Correct.
5 Q. Didn't feel like you were in any kind of
6 danger, right?
7 A. No, sometimes I did. And I already told you
8 those times.
9 Q. Well, you wouldn't have gone if you
10 thought you were in any danger, would you?
11 A. Exactly.
12 Q. Okay. So there were many occasions that
13 the driver came and got you, and you were going out
14 with somebody at the escort services where they were
15 older than you and you had no fear of anything;
16 isn't that right?
17 A. Yes.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
18 Q. By the way, when you worked for these
19 escort services, would they call you up and tell you
20 on such-and-such a day there is somebody that wants
21 to go out with you? Is that how it was done?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. What would they tell you about the person
24 that wanted to go out with you, if anything?
25 A. They would tell me where, what the occasion
1 was, what I would be doing, what kind of wear I would
2 have to wear, formal, outside, the type of dress I
3 needed to wear.
4 Q. Did they -- well, what specifically did
5 they tell you about what you had to wear? Did they
6 tell you, describe what kind of clothes or just--
7 A. I just said formal.
8 Q. But did they say, for example, wear
9 something that's low cut or don't wear a bra or, you
10 know, wear this or wear that?
11 A. No.
12 Q. Or this is just a formal or this is a
13 semi-formal occasion?
14 A. It's a formal or semi-formal for the fourth
15 time now I am telling you. So I am done answering
16 questions about that.
17 Q. What else did they tell you other than
18 what to wear?
19 A. Nothing.
20 Q. Did they tell you anything at all about
21 the person with whom you would be going out?
22 A. Sometimes.
23 Q. And with what degree of frequency would
24 they tell you about the person that you were going
25 out with? Did they always do that?
1 A. Sometimes. I just said sometimes.
2 Q. More than half the time?
3 A. Sometimes. If it was --
4 Q. More than half --
5 A. -- more than half the time, I would have said
6 more than half the time, but it's sometimes.
7 Q. So that was --
8 A. Sometimes yes and sometimes no, sometimes.
9 Q. Would you estimate that it was less than
10 half the time?
11 A. I'm not answering that question seriously
12 because I have said sometimes.
13 Q. Describe sometimes to me by percentage.
14 A. I don't know the percentage of sometimes.
15 Sometimes.
16 Q. Well, let's -- we all know what 50 percent
17 is, right?
18 A. So 50 percent. There you go. There is your
19 sometimes.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, Ve20Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
20 Q. Don't let me put words in your mouth,
21 ma'am. You were there, not me.
22 A. I said sometimes.
23 Q. If you could just tell me if it was more
24 or less than 50 percent of the time?
25 MR. SCAROLA: And you have been told
1 repeatedly that she is unable to do that for
2 you.
3 BY MR. LUTTIER:
4 Q. So, how can you quantify for me by
5 definition your phrase sometimes?
6 MR. SCAROLA: And the answer to that
7 question is she's been unable to. So we're
8 sorry that we can't give you more specific
9 information. But "sometimes" obviously means
10 more than once and less than always.
11 THE WITNESS: So you figure it out.
12 BY MR. LUTTIER:
13 Q. Well, now, ma'am, it would be hard for me
14 to do that. I wasn't there. So, it could have been
15 as much, according to your definition, as 99 percent
16 of the time, right?
17 MR. SCAROLA: At this point those
18 questions are annoying, embarrassing, and
19 harassing, and I will instruct the witness not
20 to answer.
21 BY MR. LUTTIER:
22 Q. What else, if anything, were you told
23 about the individuals that you were going to be
24 going out with when you were working for the escort
25 services?
1 A. What does this have to do with the original
2 question at hand?
3 Q. If you can just answer my question now.
4 A. And I already told you what they would tell
5 me.
6 Q. Were you told anything else?
7 A. No.
8 Q. Were you told the person's name?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. All right. Were you told the person's
11 name each time?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. All right. So there's a piece of
14 information that you got every time. Were you told
I 5 the person's age?
16 A. No.
17 Q. Ever?
18 A. No.
19 Q. Did you tell the people at the escort
20 service that you only wanted to go out with people
21 of a certain age bracket?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, Ve20Vol.%2011.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
22 A. No.
23 Q. You had to -- it was like a come and take
24 all? You had to go out with whoever they said?
25 A. Yes.
1 Q. Did you have the right to say no to
2 somebody?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. Did you ever, did they ever call you and
5 say they had someone for you to go out with and you
6 said, no, I don't want to go out with them?
7 A. No.
8 Q. So everybody that was ever, I will say
9 offered to you, you accepted?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. What's your best estimate about how many
12 escorts you had between these two escort services?
13 A. I don't know.
14 Q. More than 50?
15 A. No.
16 Q. More than 25?
17 A. No. About 25 people.
18 Q. Were you told the person's race?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Did you give the escort service any
21 criteria about the type of person you would agree to
22 go out with?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. What criteria did you give them?
25 A. I wouldn't go out with black guys because
1 black people are abusive and controlling. And I have, I
2 just felt unsafe. And I would only go out with people
3 that didn't want sex or anything sexual.
4 Q. So you said no black guys and you said no
5 one that wants anything, sex or anything that's
6 sexual?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. Did you have to describe for the escort
9 service --
10 A. No, I didn't.
11 Q. -- what you meant by sexual?
12 A. Anybody in their right mind what know what
I 3 sexual and sexual things are.
14 Q. So, you didn't give them any age bracket,
15 right?
16 A. No.
17 Q. You didn't give them a weight bracket,
18 correct?
19 A. No.
20 Q. And on how many occasions did you have men
21 that you went out with that were older than you?
22 A. Every time.
23 Q. Did you ever have to seek any kind of
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop cX:20Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
24 medical care or attention after going out with one
25 of these individuals that was provided through an
1 escort service?
2 A. No.
3 Q. Did you ever seek any kind of mental
4 health counseling?
5 A. No.
6 Q. Or mental health services as a result of
7 having gone out with anyone through the escort
8 service?
9 A. No.
10 Q. Were you ever physically hurt in any
11 manner whatsoever as a result of going out with
12 anyone through one of these escort services?
13 A. Would that qualify under me having to seek
14 medical attention?
15 Q. No. Were you ever hurt in any manner as a
16 result of going out with anyone through any of these
17 escort services?
18 A. No.
19 Q. After you quit going to Mr. Epstein's, did
20 you work at one or more topless bars or
21 establishments?
22 A. No.
23 Q. Have you ever worked at a topless
24 establishment?
25 A. I was a stripper for one night.
1 Q. And where?
2 A. For three hours, not even.
3 Q. Where was that?
4 A. I don't remember the name. I think it was
5 Platinum Showgirls or something.
6 Q. And when was that?
7 A. I don't remember the year.
8 Q. Was it after Mr. Epstein?
9 A. Yes. I left because I felt degraded.
10 Q. During the time that after you left --
11 strike that. After you last went to Mr. Epstein
12 which you say is in August of'03. did you have a
13 normal sexual relationship with
14 A. No.
15 Q. Were you having sex with him as frequently
16 as twice a day?
17 A. No.
18 Q. Have you ever told anyone that that's what
19 you did?
20 A. No.
21 Q. Was there ever a time that you had sex
22 with twice a day?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. When was that?
25 A. Before Mr. Epstein.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: V.:20Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
1 Q. And when did it change?
2 A. When I started going to Mr. Epstein's.
3 Q. And what did it change to?
4 A. To once or twice a week.
5 Q. And why did it change?
6 A. Because I felt disgusting.
7 Q. Did there ever come a time after you went
8 to Mr. Epstein's that you resumed having sexual
9 relationships with the same degree of frequency with
10 or anyone else?
11 A. With what?
12 Q. With
13 A. What do you mean?
14 Q. Did there ever come a time --
15 A. That I went back to the same --
16 Q. Right.
17 A. No.
18 . Did ou have sexual relationships with
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. And you met him after Mr. Epstein, right?
22 A. (Witness nods head.)
23 Q. Did you have a normal sexual relationship
24 with him?
25 A. Yes.
1 Q. With what degree of frequency did you have
2 sex with him?
3 A. Once, twice, or three times a week.
4 Q. As often as you wanted it?
5 A. As often as I could stand it.
6 Q. Did you have it as often as he wanted it?
7 A. No.
8 Q. Did you have a baby with him as well?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And the baby that you had with that
11 baby's name is what?
12 A.
13 Q. And have you what  as relinquished
14 your parental rights for
15 A. No, but I see my son as often as I would like.
16 And as fast as I get out of here is as fast as I can go
17 pick him up.
18 Q. You say you did not relinquish your
19 parental rights?
20 A. I did not.
21 Q. Was that is your son, ever taken
22 away from you?
23 A. I signed my parental rights over to his
24 aunt --
25 Q. Okay. Well, that's what I meant by the
1 word--
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: V.:20Vol."1208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
2 A. -- for his financial stability.
3 Q. Maybe you didn't understand what I meant
4 by the word relinquished. Did you ever givem
5 sign away your parental rights to your son,
6 A. Yes, I did.
7 Q. Would you explain the facts and
8 circumstances surrounding you doing that?
9 A. I was not financially stable enough to take
10 care of him.
11 Q. And how about your boyfriend, the
12 father of your son?
13 A. He doesn't have rights to him either.
14 Q. And was there a legal proceeding brought
I 5 to get that accomplished?
16 A. Yes, there was.
17 Q. And who brought that legal proceeding?
18 A. What do you mean who brought that?
19 Q. Who, who filed, who was the moving party?
20 Did DCF bring that proceeding?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. And as part of that proceeding, did DCF
23 tell you that they were going to take away your
24 parental rights if you didn't sign them off?
25 A. No.
1 Q. And was that action brought here in Palm
2 Beach County?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. And isn't it true that you, that DCF told
5 you you had no choice but to either voluntarily sign
6 over your rights, or they were going to take your
7 son?
8 A. No.
9 Q. What did they tell you about what your
10 choices were?
11 A. They told me I had to go through classes and
12 all kinds of things. But I still, whether I did the
13 class or not, I wouldn't have been financially stable
14 enough to take care of my son. So, I signed my rights
15 over to his aunt who was financially able to take care
16 of my child.
17 Q. And you, in fact, had gone to court and
18 gotten a child support award from had you
19 not?
20 A. A child support order?
21 . An award of child support from, from
22 . You filed a judicial action and made a
23 complaint against him said you wanted child support?
24 A. That's when I still had my son, yes.
25 Q. All right. So, so, and the court entered
1 an order that said he had to pay you a certain
2 amount of child support, right?
3 A. Which he never did.
file:///q/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, V.:20Vol.°4208.1412/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
4 Q. Did that child support ever come to your
5 mother, for example?
6 A. We never got child support from
7 Q. Did you ever have a complaint that your
8 mother was taking your child support?
9 A. No.
10 Q. Did you ever complain to anyone that your
11 mother was taking your child support?
12 A. No.
13 Q. And  daughter's name is what?
14 A.
15 Q. Well is it is it --
16 A.
17 Q. Does it cause you any kind of upset that
18 you have signed over your parental rights to your
19 son
20 A. Of course I am upset about it, but I did what
21 was best for him.
22 Q. DiAave parental rights for your
23 daughter
24 A. No, I do not. I signed my rights over to her
25 grandmother.
1 Q. And did DCF bring an action to take away
2 your parental rights in that case?
3 A. They tried.
4 Q. And as a result of that did you
5 voluntarily relinquish your rights?
6 A. Yes, I did.
7 Q. And again did DCF insist that in order for
8 you to see your child, you would have to do certain
9 things?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. And did you decide that what you would do
12 is sign over parental rights rather than do those
13 things?
14 A. No, I, I did some of the things that I was
15 supposed to do.
16 Q. Do you know what a performance agreement
17 is?
18 A. No.
19 Q. Did you do all the things that DCF said
20 you had to do?
21 A. Everything except for domestic violence class.
22 Q. And did DCF say that as a result of you
23 not doing everything, they were going to take your
24 child away?
25 A. They said they were going to terminate my
1 n hts so I signed my parental rights over to
3 Q. So, in both the situation involving your
4 son and your daughter, DCF had told you --
5 A. Yes.
file:///CVDocuments%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktor "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
6 Q. -- before you signed over your rights that
7 they were going to terminate your rights?
A. Yes.
9 Q. And is it also distressing to you that you
10 had to relinquish your rights to your daughter
12 A. Of course it's dist.i.
13 Q. And where does live?
14 A. In Texas.
I 5 Q. How often do you see her?
16 A. Once a month.
17 Q. And how is it that you see her?
18 A. Her grandmother brings her here.
19 . And father is a guy name
21 A. No. His first name is
22 Q. What's his last name?
23 A.
24 Q. Now, has ever been
25 violent to you?
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. When was he violent to you?
3 A. When I was pregnant.
4 Q. What did he do?
5 A. He slapped me.
6 Q. And where were you when that happened?
7 A. At a restaurant.
8 Q. Was that distressful to you?
9 A. Yeah.
10 Q. Upset you at the time?
11 A. Obviously.
12 Q. Was, was that the first time a man had
13 been physically violent towards you?
14 A. No.
15 Q. Who was the first person --
16 A.
17 If.hat was physically violent? And what
18 did do to you that was vio -- physically
19 violent?
20 A. He held a gun to my head.
21 Q. And when was that?
22 A. I don't remember the time and day.
23 Q. Was that before you went to Georgia?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And was that while you were going to
1 Mr. Epstein?
2 A. Yep, it was while I was going to
3 Mr. Epstein's.
4 Q. And was, did he hold a gun to your head
5 because he thought you had been cheating on him?
6 A. Yeah, but not with Mr. Epstein.
7 Q. And had you, in fact, been cheating on
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop V.:20Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
8 him?
9 A. No. He was cheating on me with
10 Q. That is he had sexual relations with .,
11 your best friend?
12 A. Yes, yes.
13 Q. And when did that happen?
14 A. I don't know the time and date.
15 Q. While you were going to Mr. Epstein?
16 A. Yes.
17 Did ou know that your then boyfriend,
18 had had sexual relations with your
19 best friend,  before you took her to
20 Mr. Epstein's?
21 A. No.
22 Q. Did you ever discuss with M. the fact
23 that she had had sex with your boyfriend?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And what was her response?
1 A. She was sorry.
2 Q. And have you two mended your ways since
3 then?
4 A. Absolutely not.
5 Q. You no longer associate with her?
6 A. Hell, no.
7 Q. And is it because that ou're upset that
8 she had sex with while you were dating
9 him?
10 A. Yeah.
11 Q. Is there any other reason? Was there any
12 other rift between the two of you?
13 A. No.
14 Q. Did, did you and she have this
15 confrontation before you stopped going to see
16 Mr. Epstein?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. And as a result oi having
19 sexual relations with M., did you have sexual
20 relations with somebody else?
21 A. Yes, I did.
22 Q. WISI you have sex with?
23 A. best friend.
24 Q. Sort of like as they say, what's good for
25 the goose is good for the gander?
1 A. A tit for a tat. Yes it was.
2 Q. And who was best friend.
3 A.
4 Q. What's last name?
5 A. I don't remember.
6 Q. Is the person you had sex with you, you
7 can't remember his last name?
8 A. I can't remember his last name. I'm sorry.
9 Q. Did you have -- have you had sex with more
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
10 than one person whose name you can't remember?
11 A.
12 Q. the only person?
13 A. I can't remember his last name.
14 Q. Well, you recently filed some answers,
15 some amended answers to interrogatories. Let me --
16 MR. LUTTIER: What number are we on?
17 THE COURT REPORTER: Four.
18 THE WITNESS: Exhibit 4.
19 MR. LUTTIER: These are, I think, Jack,
20 are the ones I was talking about.
21 BY MR. LUTTIER:
22 Q. Let me show you what's been marked as
23 Exhibit 4 which purport to be your Third Amended
24 Answers to Defendant's Interrogatories. These do
25 not contain a signature by you. So I would like you
1 to look at those, and tell me if the answers are
2 true and correct and complete.
3 A. Yeah, those are the people that I have had sex
4 with in my life.
5 Q. Okay. Wellialave answered --
6 A. I didn't put name. Would you like me
7 to reapply it?
8 Q. You actually answered one, two, three.
9 You have three answers that you have amended here.
10 So, I want you to look at all three, and now while
11 you're under oath, I am going to ask you if these
12 answers are true and correct and if they are
13 complete.
14 So, if you need to take some time, fine.
I 5 When you're done, let me know and I'll --
16 A. Yeah, they're all right.
17 Q. Okay. With, with the following exception,
18 right, in 18, in answer to 18 there should be
19 another person's name, somebody?
20 A. Yep.
21 Q. And where would he fit in in terms of the
22 chronology here?
23 A. Between and
24 Q. Now, you said that you dated --
25 don't know where it is -- from 2001 to 2005. In
1 your answers to interrogatories, ou indicate that
2 you had sexual intercourse with when
3 you were 15 to 16 years old?
4 A. So --
5 . d s this mean that you had sex with
6 while you were dating
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. Did know about that?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. Did you tell him about it before it
11 happened?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Deslaop Ve20Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
12 A. No.
13 H w did it happen that you had sex with
14 while you were dating
15 A. went to Georgia.
16 Q. Oka --
17 A. So,
.
went to Georgia.
18 Q. He went to Georgia without you?
19 A. Obviously.
20 Q. When did he go to Georgia in relationship
21 to the testimony --
22 A. To see-
23 Q. -- you gave me earlier --
24 A. To see --
25 Q. -- that you went there in June of '03?
1 A. He went with his family when we first started
2 dating like, well, towards the first year we were
3 dating.
4 Q. Before you went and saw Mr. Epstein?
5 A. Yeah.
6 . All ri ht. So the sex that you had with
7 is sex that you had prior to the
8 time that you first met Mr. Epstein?
9 A. No.
10 Q. When you say that you dated from
11 January, from '01 to '05 and that that was
12 continuous --
13 A. Right.
14 Q. Was he living in Georgia part of the time?
I 5 A. No. He went there on vacation.
16 Q. Okay. So how long was he gone for this
17 vacation?
18 A. I don't remember. Like a week.
19 Q. All right. So, while he was gone on
20 vacation for a week during the period of time that
21 you were dating him between 2001 and 2005, you had
22 sexual relations with
23 A. Yes, I did.
24 Q. And, and did you tell about it after
25 the fact?
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. And that wasn't any probl m f r ? You
3 didn't have any trust issues with at the
4 time?
5 A. No, I didn't have trust issues with
6 Q. So, by, by your acknowledgment in these
7 answers to interrogatories before you ever went to
8 Mr. Epstein's house the first time ou had had
9 sexual relations with
10 , and somebody whose last name you
11 can't remember, and --
12 A. And that's it.
13 Q. And
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: V.:20Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
14 A. No.
15 Q. Not but up through
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. And, and the, the relationship you
18 testified about earlier with . N w, during this
19 period of time with between '01 and
20 '05, tell me about what the facts and circumstances
21 were surrounding him holding um n to your head?
22 A. He cheated on me with M. and I suppose he
23 felt guilty about it. So, he tried to say I was
24 cheating on him and I wasn't cheating on him. He was
25 cheating on me and felt guilty, and then decided he was
1 going to try to kill me.
2 Q. And you were afraid -- where were you when
3 this gun was held to your head?
4 A. In the middle of a field.
5 Q. Where?
6 A. In West Palm Beach.
7 Q. And you were fearful at that time that he
8 might shoot you?
9 A. Obviously.
10 Q. Well, can -- would you agree that it was a
11 traumatic event to you to have somebody hold a gun
12 to your head?
13 A. Wouldn't it be for you?
14 Q. I would assume so.
15 A. Yeah.
16 Q. As they say you see your life flash before
17 your eyes?
18 A. I guess.
19 Q. Did you ever seek any kind of counseling
20 or treatment for that traumatic event?
21 A. No.
22 Q. Had an one else ever threatened your life
23 other than as of that time?
24 A. No.
25 Q. Has anyone ever threatened your life since
1 that event?
2 A. No.
3 Q. Have you ever been affiliated with a gang?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Have any of the individuals that you have
6 dated ever been affiliated with a gang?
7 A. No.
8 Q. Have you been present when
9 claimed that he was affiliated with a gang?
10 A. Nope.
11 Q. Have you told others that you cannot
12 answer the question about whether you're affiliated
13 with a gang because if you did, it would risk
14 personal harm to you?
15 A. No. I said I can't speak for anybody else if
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
16 they're in a gang because I don't know about it. And if
17 they were in a gang, it's none of my business to let
18 anybody else know about it. I can't tell somebody
19 something about somebody else if I don't know if it's
20 true or not.
21 Q. Have you ever participated in any gang
22 membership ritual?
23 A. No.
24 Q. For approximately how long did the event
25 take place that held a gun to your head?
1 A. Like five minutes and then we kissed and made
2 up and had sex.
3 Q. In the field?
4 A. Yep.
5 Q. Isn't it a fact that you told_
6 that he held a gun on your head for a good hour?
7 A. No. We were arguing for an hour. He didn't
8 hold the gun to my head for an hour. That doctor is on
9 some other shit.
10 Q. And you genuinely feared that you were
11 going to die on that occasion, did you not?
12 A. Well, somebody holds a gun to your head, I am
13 pretty sure that anybody would feel that they are going
14 to die.
15 . Was there another occasion that
16 was physically violent towards you?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. When was that?
19 A. When he tried to drown me in a canal.
20 Q. When was that?
21 A. I don't recall.
22 Q. Was it before you went to Georgia or
23 after?
24 A. Before.
25 Q. Was it while you were going to
1 Mr. Epstein's?
2 A. Yep.
3 Q. Did you tell Mr. Epstein about it?
4 A. Yes, I did.
5 Q. And when did you tell Mr. Epstein about
6 it?
7 A. On one of the occasions I went to his house.
8 Q. And what did he say?
9 A. I don't know. He talked to me about it.
10 Q. Was he sympathetic toward you?
11 A. A little bit.
12 Q. Did you tell you you ought to get away
13 from this guy?
14 A. Yeah.
15 Q. Did you pay attention to what he said?
16 A. Obviously not, if I had a kid with him some
17 years later.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, cY020Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
18 Q. Y u elected not to sever your relationship
19 with correct?
20 A. What? I wasn't going to leave
21 Q. Voluntmlecision on your part, right?
22 A. I love
23 Q. Nobody --
24 A. I still love
25 Q. Nobody forced you into it.
1 Big girl, you made your own decision, correct?
2 A. And I had stayed with = yes.
3 Q. And let's talk a little bit more about it.
4 When you say he tried to drown you, exactly what did
5 he do?
6 A. Stuck my head in canal water.
7 Q. And where was this canal?
8 A. On the street where any canal would be.
9 Q. Where, in, in West Palm Beach?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. And what was the event that led to him
12 sticking your head in canal water?
13 A. I have absolutely no idea.
14 Q. And were you terrified?
15 A. A little.
16 Q. How long did he hold your head under
17 water?
18 A. I'm -- I wasn't looking at my watch.
19 Q. Were you running out of breath?
20 A. No. He was lifting me back up. I caught my
21 breath.
22 Q. So, he was dunking you in and out of
23 water?
24 A. Yeah.
25 Q. So, you didn't ever have to fight to get
1 up and get your head out of water?
2 A. While I was trying to fight to get my head out
3 of the water, the whole time he was trying to drown me.
4 Q. Were you fighting with him at the time?
5 A. We were in an argument.
6 Q. Was it a traumatic event to you?
7 A. Kind of.
8 Q. Did you seek any type of counseling or --
9 A. No.
10 Q. -- medical care.
11 THE WITNESS: What time is it?
12 MR. SCAROLA: We're getting close.
13 MR. LUTTIER: 4:32.
14 MR. SCAROLA: Less than a half hour.
15 THE WITNESS: Thank God. 30 more minutes
16 of this crap. These things are really good.
17 BY MR. LUTTIER:
18 Q. When you met with the FBI and the U.S.
19 Attorney --
file:///q/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, cX:20Vol.°4208.1412/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. -- did you tell them that you had worked
22 for escort services?
23 A. I don't think so. I don't remember.
24 Q. Did you tell them that you had been
25 sexually active prior to the time that you went to
1 Mr. Epstein's?
2 A. I don't remember.
3 Q. Did you tell them that you had been raped
4 before you went to Mr. Epstein's?
5 A. I don't remember.
6 Q. Did you tell them that you had been
7 molested by your grandfather?
8 A. I don't remember.
9 Q. Tell them that you had been molested by
10 your cousin?
11 A. I don't remember.
12 Q. Did  tell them about your relationship
13 with
14 A. I don't remember.
15 Q. Did you tell them about physical violence
16 that had been inflicted upon you by or by
18 A. I don't remember. They more wanted to know
19 about what happened with the child molester.
20 Q. Other than the occasion when
21 sla ed ou while you were pregnant, was
22 ever physically violent with you?
23 A. Nope.
24 Q. Was there ever an occasion that the police
25 came to visit you and when you had
1 your child with you?
2 A. Other than the time you mean that my child was
3 born?
4 Q. No. When they came to where you were
5 living and your child was there with you.
6 A. We had gotten in a fight with my brother and
7 his girlfriend. And after the fight was over, I went a
8 got my daughter from the neighbor's house.
9 Q. Did the police come?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. Was there ever a time that the police came
12 when your child was there and they found drug
13 ara hemalia or drugs on either you or
15 A. Drug paraphernalia?
16 Q. Or drugs.
17 A. No.
18 Q. Was there ever a time that
19 was arrested in your presence because he had drugs
20 on his possession.
21 A. I have no idea.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktor V.:20Vol.91208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
22 Q. Were you ever present when
23 was arrested?
24 A. Yeah.
25 Q. How many times?
1 A. I don't recall.
2 Q. More than once?
3 A. I don't remember.
4 . And what is your current relationship with
6 A. I don't talk to him. He is incarcerated.
7 Q. And why is he incarcerated?
8 A. Because he beat up his pregnant girlfriend.
9 Q. And, and the pregnant girlfriend would be
10 who.
11 A. I don't know her name and I could care less
12 about the bitch.
13 Q. You say what? You could careless about
14 what?
15 A. About the bitch.
16 Q. Okay. Did you know the girl?
17 A. I have no idea who she is.
18 Q. You mentioned the name earlier in the
19 deposition,
20 A. Uh-huh. That was the missing Jane Doe No.
21 102's, whatever Jeffrey did with her bo friend.
22 Q. When did you first meet
23 A. A couple of weeks before I saw Mr. Epstein for
24 the first time. That was Jane Doe No. 102's boyfriend.
25 Q. When was the last time you spoke with
2 A. A couple of days after Jane Doe No. 102 went
3 missing.
4 Q. Now, earlier you were making reference to
5 injecting drugs and I asked you a question about, I
6 don't remember if I asked you about a needle or a
7 syringe, so I need to go back and clarify. Was it
8 your testimony that you were able to go to a drug
9 store without a prescription and purchase a syringe
10 with a needle on it?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. And what drug store was that?
13 A. One that sells them.
14 Q. Would that be a drug store here in Palm
I 5 Beach County?
16 A. It's a drug store in every county.
17 Q. Did you purchase a syringe with a needle
18 here in Palm Beach County --
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. -- without a prescription?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. Do you have any prescription that allows
23 you to, specifically for hypodermic needles?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktor (.420Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
24 A. You don't need one.
25 Q. Are you diabetic or anything like that?
1 A. No.
2 Q. Have you ever used a needle that had been
3 used before?
4 A. Not by anybody else, no.
5 Q. Not my question?
6 A. No, I have never shared a needle, no.
7 Q. Did you ever use --
8 A. No.
9 Q. You need to listen to my question.
10 A. I heard you. You asked me if I ever used a
11 needle that's been used before and I said no.
12 Q. And what you said was, not one that had
13 been used by somebody else. So, which leaves open
14 the possibility, have you ever used a needle that
15 had been used before, even if it was used on you?
16 A. Even if it was used on me?
17 Q. Yes.
18 A. Well, then the answer would be yes, because I
19 had always, I had always used my own needle.
20 Q. You used a needle on yourself which you
21 had used before?
22 MR. SCAROLA: How about this: Have you
23 used the same needle more than once?
24 MR. LUTTIER: Fine.
25 THE WITNESS: Yes.
1 BY MR. LUTTIER:
2 Q. Okay. And when was it that you did that?
3 A. I don't know.
4 Q. When was the last time you used a needle?
5 A. Back in July when I gave myself a staph
6 infection.
7 Q. And the needle that you used in July, had
8 you used it before?
9 A. Obviously if I gave myself staph with it.
10 Q. And when had you used it before July?
11 A. In the same day or two. I don't remember.
12 Q. And for what reason had you used it in the
13 same day or two?
14 A. Because it was the last one I had.
15 Q. But what did you use it for in the same
16 day or two?
17 A. To inject my prescription Roxicodone.
18 Q. So, in July you had injected yourself at
19 lease three times with Roxicodone?
20 A. I told you two.
21 Q. So, the needle that you used in July, when
22 you injected Roxicodone, you had used either same
23 time day or the day before to inject yourself with
24 Roxies?
25 A. Uh-huh.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: "120Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
1 Q. Which would mean that would be the second
2 time you used it, right?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. Had you used it at any time before that?
5 A. No.
6 Q. So this needle you only used twice?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. Were there other needles that you had used
9 in the past on yourself that you had used on
10 yourself more than once?
11 A. No. It's raining.
12 MR. SCAROLA: Uh-huh.
13 BY MR. LUTTIER:
14 Q. Isn't it, is it true at that Wellington
5 Regional would not discharge you because they deemed
16 you to be an IV drug user?
17 A. That's not true.
18 Q. Did you give them a history that you were
19 an IV drug user?
20 A. I led them, I told them I was an IV drug user.
21 Q. What exactly did you tell them about your
22 IV drug usage?
23 A. That I am an IV drug user.
24 Q. And did you give them anything, any more
25 detail than that?
1 A. I told them that I shot Roxies.
2 Q. Did you tell them that you, that you shot
3 Roxi pursuant to a prescription?
4 A. Pursumed (phonetic).
5 Q. Pursuant to a prescription.
6 A. What does that mean?
7 Q. That the reason that you did it was you
8 had a prescription to do it?
9 A. Yeah.
10 Q. You are sure that you told them it was
11 pursuant to a prescription?
12 A. I told them. They asked me. I told them I
13 had a prescription. I no longer have that prescription,
14 and I no longer go to that doctor.
I 5 Q. When did you, when did that prescription
16 expire?
17 A. Earlier this year or last year.
18 Q. Being '08?
19 A. Yeah.
20 Q. And when you say the prescription expired,
21 what do you mean?
22 A. Well, it didn't really expire. I mean, I
23 never went and got a new prescription.
24 Q. When you say the prescription expired, do
25 you mean you ran out of the pills that you had
1 purchased?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, Ve20Volte2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
2 A. Yeah.
3 Q. And that happened in '08?
4 A. Yeah.
5 Q. So, in July of '09 when you were shooting
6 up Roxicodone, where did you get those Roxicodone?
7 A. Oh, no. I still had the prescription but I
8 never went back to the doctor to get a new one. I had
9 the same prescription from '08 in '09.
10 Q. And you got it refilled?
11 A. No.
12 Q. Okay. Let's go back.
13 A. No. I saved the Roxie pills.
14 Q. I thought you told me a minute ago that
I 5 your prescription had expired and by definition --
16 A. I meant as --
17 Q. And by definition that you had used up all
18 of the pills that you gotten initially?
19 A. No. I misunderstood you. That's why I was
20 trying to --
21 Q. So, you still had pills left?
22 A. Yes. I never went back to the doctor to get a
23 new prescription, so I still had some in the bottle from
24 last year.
25 Q. When did you first use cocaine?
1 A. During the time I met Mr. Epstein. I was
2 going Mr. Epstein's.
3 Q. And you never, prior to that had you used
4 it in any form, powder or crack?
5 A. No.
6 Q. Had you told anyone that you had used
7 cocaine prior to the time that you went to
8 Mr. Epstein's?
9 A. No.
10 Q. When did you first use marijuana?
11 A. Prior to the time I went to Mr. Epstein's.
12 That was the only drug I ever used before I met
13 Mr. Epstein.
14 Q. And you started using marijuana at age
15 what?
16 A. Thirteen.
17 Q. And you used it with what degree of
18 frequency?
19 A. I don't know, every day.
20 Q. And you were able to purchase that?
21 A. Yeah.
22 Q. At 13?
23 A. Yeah.
24 Q. Where did you get the money to buy that
25 marijuana?
1 A. Allowance, about all I could --
2 Q. Did you get the allowance from your
3 mother?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, Ve20Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
4 A. Yeah, or cleaning people's houses or yard
5 work, stupid stuff kids do.
6 Q. And have you ever had a sexually
7 transmitted disease?
8 A. If you want to -- pelvic inflammatory disease,
9 but I got it from a tampon.
10 Q. Other than Roxicodone, have you ever
11 obtained -- well, strike that.
12 Have you ever obtained any type of pill
13 from any source whatsoever other than through a
14 prescription issued by a doctor?
15 A. What do you mean like have I gotten a pill --
16 Q. Yep.
17 A. -- from anywhere else?
18 Q. Yep. Somebody gave you pills. You bought
19 the pills. Anything like that?
20 A. Yeah.
21 Q. And what kind of pills had you taken that
22 you didn't have a prescription for?
23 A. Percocet.
24 Q. And with what degree of frequency?
25 A. Like I took one one time.
1 Q. At what age did you start taking pills
2 that you didn't have prescriptions for?
3 A. Twenty-two.
4 Q. You said you took Ms. M. to
5 Mr. Epstein's as well, correct?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. What did you tell Ms. M. before you took
8 her there the first time?
9 A. I told her what was going to happen.
10 Q. What exactly did you tell --
11 A. But she did more things willingly than I even
12 told her.
13 Q. How do you know that?
14 A. Because I was there and I left the room.
15 Q. What did you see M. do?
16 A. She was offering information and Mr. Epstein
17 asked me to leave the room, and I was leaving the room.
18 Q. Offering information on what?
19 A. On things that her and her mother did.
20 Q. Like what?
21 A. I have no idea. I don't remember. I just
22 remember her saying things that her and her mother did
23 and I felt uncomfortable. And her and Mr. Epstein were
24 laughing and he asked me to leave the room and I left
25 the room.
1 Q. Well, if you have a recollection that she
2 said something about --
3 A. I said I don't have the recollection of
4 exactly what she said. I remember --
5 Q. What's your best recollection of the
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop4 "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
6 subject matter about which she was talking?
7 A. That her and her mom have had, her mom does
8 things and has prices for things. Something of that
9 matter. I don't --
10 Q. Sexual nature?
11 A. Yeah.
12 Q. What kinds of things?
13 A. I don't remember.
14 Q. And when you, before you took M. to
15 Mr. Epstein the first time, what you did you tell
16 her was going to happen?
17 A. I told her that he might ask her to get nude.
18 And I told her that you were just going to massage him.
19 Q. Did you tell her anything about your
20 experience with the other woman?
21 A. I didn't tell anybody that experience about,
22 with that other woman like I told you before.
23 Q. When you took the first time did you
24 go with her?
25 A. Yes.
1 Q. Did you get paid?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. How much?
4 A. $400.
5 Q. Just for taking her.
6 A. Well, 300 that I always get and an extra 100
7 for taking her.
8 Q. On the time that you took ■. the first
9 time, did you go in with her and Mr. Epstein?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. Did you take M. a second time.
12 A. Yes, and that's when I was asked to leave the
13 room.
14 Q. Did you take her a third time?
15 A. No.
16 Q. After the second time did she go back
17 herself?
18 A. I don't know. Ask her.
19 Q. Did you tell her that you were getting
20 paid to take her?
21 A. No.
22 Q. Did you share that money that you got for
23 bringing her with her?
24 A. No.
25 Q. After you took her the first time, were
you present in the room with Mr. Epstein the entire
time when she was there?
3 A. Other than the what --
4 Q. When you went the first time --
5 A. The first time --
6 Q. With M. --
7 A. -- yes, I was there the whole time.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: V.:20Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
8 OWhat occurred at the first meeting of you
9 and M. and Mr. Epstein?
10 A. We gave him a massage. She played with one
11 nipple. I played with the other, and he masturbated.
12 9. And was the state of dress for you and
13 M.?
14 A. We were naked.
15 Q. Totally?
16 A. Uh-huh.
17 Q. And when, and when you left did you and
18 she discuss your encounter?
19 A. No.
20 Q. Did she have any complaints about it when
21 you left?
22 A. No.
23 Q. Did she --
24 A. All she said was that was easy.
25 Q. Did she ask you if you, if you could take
1 her back?
2 A. No.
3 Q. Were you present the second time she went?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. That's the second time is when you
6 eventually walked out?
7 A. Yes. That's when I walked out.
8 Q. What occurred before you walked out?
9 A. They were joking and laughing. She was
10 telling him about some stuff that her mom and her did
11 sexually for money or some stuff like that. I don't
12 really remember the whole conversation word for word.
13 I need a drink. I have the hiccups really
14 bad. I am getting antsy.
15 MR. SCAROLA: Countdown is to about ten
16 minutes.
17 THE WITNESS: Good.
18 BY MR. LUTTIER:
19 Q. When was the first time you did acid?
20 A. When I was 19.
21 Q. And when you say acid, what specific drug
22 were you doing?
23 A. Acid.
24 Q. And in what form was it?
25 A. Paper.
1 Q. And you swallowed it?
2 A. No, it dissolves on your tongue.
3 Q. And did you do it more than once?
4 A. I only did it once.
5 Q. And were you with anyone else?
6 A. Yeah, my friends.
7 Q. Who?
8 A. I'm not giving you their names. It's
9 irrelevant.
file:///CVDocuments%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop, cY020Vol.%2011.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
10 Q. Okay. You're refusing to answer that
11 question?
12 A. Yes, yes, I am.
13 Q. Who provided the acid?
14 A. That's irrelevant and I refuse to answer that
15 one too.
16 Q. Was this after you got back from Georgia?
17 A. Yeah.
18 Q. So, there came a point in time after you
19 had been drug free --
20 A. Yes.
21 Q. -- from Georgia that you decided to take
22 it up again, right?
23 A. Yep.
24 Q. When was the first time you started doing
25 drugs again after you had been drug free until
1 January of '05?
2 A. When I was 18. When I was 18.
3 Q. Do you remember the event?
4 A. Do I remember the event that I did the drug?
5 Q. Yeah.
6 A. Yeah.
7 Q. And was it, was it on your birthday?
8 A. No.
9 Q. All right. Was it in January of '05?
10 A. No.
11 Q. When was it?
12 A. I was 18 but I don't remember the direct
13 month.
14 Q. Okay.
15 A. I know it was not by my birthday.
16 Q. Okay. And can you describe the event?
17 A. Some other people were doing it, so I did it.
18 Q. What drug?
19 A. Crack.
20 Q. And where were you?
21 A. Ina house.
22 Q. First time you had done it?
23 A. Yeah.
24 Q. And who was with you?
25 A. People. Not giving you their names because
1 it's irrelevant.
2 Q. And what house?
3 A. One that somebody lived in.
4 Q. And who supplied the crack?
5 A. I don't know.
6 Q. And after having been drug free from May
7 of '03 to January '05, why did you decide to do
8 crack?
9 A. I was going through a lot of things in my
10 brain. I had lost my boyfriend due to Mr. Epstein. I
11 lost my kid due to his stupid father. So, I was going
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop (.420Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
12 through a lot. Why does anybody take up using drugs
13 or --
14 Q. What boyfriend are you referring to,
15 saying Mt your boyfriend?
16 A.
17 Q. Now, why do you say you lost because
18 of Mr. Epstein?
19 A. Because he found out finally we got into an
20 argument and I just told him everything that had
21 happened and --
22 Q. And when did you do that?
23 A. After I had my son.
24 Q. While you were in Georgia?
25 A. No, while we were in Florida. I had my son in
1 Florida.
2 Q. And that's the first time you told
3 everything?
4 A. Yeah.
5 Q. And what was his reaction?
6 A. Obviously it wasn't good if I am not with him.
7 Q. Well, did he, on that particular occasion
8 leave and say he didn't want anything to do with
9 you?
10 A. No. We argued for a while. We tried to make
11 it work and it just wouldn't work.
12 • Okay. Other than the fact that you and
13 had broken up and you had lost your kid, and
14 the kid that you're talking about there, is that
16 A.
17 Q. Anything else that caused you to use crack
18 in January of '05?
19 A. I was depressed about my whole life. And I
20 felt disgusted by Mr. Epstein.
21 Q. Well, actually the sexual encounters that
22 you had with others were far more extensive than
23 anything --
24 A. What are you talking about--
25 Q. -- anything you had ever done with
1 Mr. Epstein, right?
2 A. -- sexual encounters?
3 Q. I mean you, you had done, you had engaged
4 in sex with others, you engaged in sex with both
5 sexes. You had done all sorts of things that
6 Mr. Epstein never did with you, hadn't you?
7 A. So, what does that have to do with
8 Mr. Epstein, my sex life.
9 Q. When you talk about being disgusted --
10 A. Why don't you get naked in front of an old man
11 and play with his nipples while he masturbates. You do
12 that and then you tell me if you feel good.
13 Q. And as you mentioned earlier, you did that
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
14 to get money?
15 A. So? It still doesn't make it right.
16 Q. And any other reason why you decided to go
17 back and start using crack cocaine?
18 A. What do you mean go back and start using it?
19 Q. Any other reason why you started to go
20 back to drugs and in particular crack co, start
21 using crack cocaine in January of '05?
22 A. I never heard of it and it was the first time
23 so I tried it.
24 Q. Had you ever seen your mother use crack
25 cocaine?
1 A. No.
2 Q. Had you ever been present when your
3 mothers was arrested for using crack cocaine?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Did you tell anybody your mother used
6 crack cocaine ever?
7 A. My mom used to be an alcoholic, whether she
8 used --
9 Q. That's not my question. Did you ever tell
10 anybody ever --
11 A. No.
12 Q. -- that your mother used crack cocaine?
13 A. No.
14 Q. Not not anybody else?
15 A. No.
16 Q. Did you ever prostitute yourself for
17 drugs?
18 A. No.
19 Q. Did you do acid on more than one occasion?
20 A. No.
21 Q. When did you first use Ecstasy?
22 A. I think when I was 14.
23 Q. Before you met Mr. Epstein?
24 A. No, during, meeting Mr. Epstein.
25 Q. What?
1 A. After I had met Mr. Epstein.
2 Q. Well, you didn't meet him until you were
3 15.
4 A. I don't think that's right. I met him when I
5 was 14. I think I saw him for longer than just that
6 year.
7 Q. Well, according to your complaint the
8 first time you meet him was when you were 15?
9 A. I don't -- that, I don't know.
10 MR. SCAROLA: That may be an error.
11 THE WITNESS: Yeah, I think that's an
12 error.
13 BY MR. LUTTIER:
14 Q. When did you -- what were the
15 circumstances surrounding, surrounding you first
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktop Ve20Vol.%2011.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
16 using Ecstasy.
17 A. I was at a party.
18 Q. Where?
19 A. In West Palm Beach. Who was there, I don't
20 know. A bunch of people.
21 Q. And who provided the drug?
22 A. I don't know.
23 Q. Mr. Epstein certainly wasn't there, right?
24 A. No, Mr. Epstein was not there.
25 Q. Okay. Did somebody give you the drug or
1 did you purchase the drug?
2 A. Somebody gave it to me.
3 Q. Had you ever used it before?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Did you ever use it again?
6 A. No.
7 Q. Did you enjoy it?
8 A. No. It was kind of weird.
9 Q. When was the first time you used heroin?
10 A. When I was 21.
11 Q. And what were the circumstances
12 surrounding you using heroin?
13 A. I was just trying it to try to escape my
14 problems.
15 Q. And where were you?
16 A. In my house.
17 Q. Where your mother lives?
18 A. No. In mine and house.
19 Q. Did use it with you?
20 A. Yeah.
21 Q. Who provided the heroin?
22 A. I don't know. Some dude.
23 . Was there more people there than just you
24 and ?
25 A. Yep.
1 Q. And how did you take the heroin?
2 A. I snorted it.
3 Q. And did you use it again?
4 A. No.
5 Q. No one forced you to do it?
6 A. Donny did.
7 Q. How did he force you to do it?
8 A. He told me to do it.
9 Q. So he --
10 A. And I didn't want to. And he didn't like grab
11 me and tell me to do it, but I didn't want to and he
12 argued with me about it, so I just did it to stop
13 arguing.
14 Q. When was the first time you used crystal
15 meth?
16 A. I was, I was like 18.
17 Q. And where did you use that?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktor "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
18 A. Ina house.
19 Q. With, who were you living with at the
20 time?
21 A. I was living with myself. Some people were
22 doing it. I snorted it.
23 Q. People you invited over?
24 A. People I invited over. People other people
25 invited over.
1 Q. Was it given to you or did you buy it?
2 A. It was given to me.
3 Q. And why did you do it?
4 A. Something new to do.
5 Q. Have you ever gone through detox?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. How many times?
8 A. Twice.
9 Q. When was the first time?
10 A. Earlier this year.
11 Q. That is earlier of '09?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. Do you remember what month?
14 A. No.
15 Q. And where did you go through detox the
16 first time?
17 A. In my living room. I went --
18 Q. And you were detoxing yourself?
19 A. Yes. And also I detoxed at CARP.
20 Q. Both, is that the, this is what you have
21 indicated is the first time both in your living room
22 and at CARP?
23 A. (Witness nods head.)
24 THE COURT REPORTER: Is that a yes?
25 THE WITNESS: Yes.
1 BY MR. LUTTIER:
2 Q. And the second time when did you detox?
3 A. At CARP.
4 Q. When?
5 A. I don't know.
6 Q. Well, you said the first was early '09.
7 Does that mean the second was sometime after that?
8 A. Yeah.
9 Q. How long --
10 A. It was all in '09.
11 Q. How long after the first time?
12 A. Like a month or two later.
13 Q. And what were you detoxing yourself from
14 the first time in '09?
15 A. Roxies.
16 Q. Well, that was the drug that you were
17 taking pursuant to your prescription?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. When did you become addicted to it?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktopi "120Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
20 A. While I was being prescribed it.
21 Q. Did you tell the doctor you had been
22 become addicted to it?
23 A. Yes, this is why I no longer get a
24 prescription for it.
25 Q. And what were you getting detoxed from the
1 second time at CARP?
2 A. Roxies.
3 Q. So you had to be detoxed twice from
4 Roxies?
5 A. Well, yes, because I detoxed the first time
6 and then I went back to using them again because of my
7 back pain.
8 Q. Did you report to the physician that was
9 giving you the prescription that you had been
10 detoxed one time before you went back to using?
11 A. No. Because if you recall in your notes, I
12 saved the prescription to the next year after I had
13 stopped going to that doctor.
14 Q. So, you continued to take the drug even
15 though you had detoxed from the drug?
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. You knew you were addicted to it in the
18 past?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Opted, by your own choice, to do it again?
21 A. Yes. So, if that makes me a criminal, then
22 sobeit. How much time do we have left? I want to go
23 get my son.
24 MR. SCAROLA: About two minutes.
25 THE WITNESS: Good. Yeah. I really want
1 to go get my kid; the kid that I signed my
2 rights over to by the way.
3 BY MR. LUTTIER:
4 Q. What was the last grade you completed in
5 school?
6 A. Seventh.
7 Q. And what school were you attending?
8 A. Bear Lakes. Actually, yeah, actually the last
9 year I completed was seventh. I started eighth grade
10 and they kicked me out of school because I was too
11 physically developed.
12 Q. What do you mean by that?
13 A. My boobs were too big and I got sexually
14 harassed by the kids in school. So they called my mom
15 and told her she needed to sign me out. And if you
16 don't believe me, you take it up with Bear Lakes.
17 Q. So, did you enroll in another school?
18 A. No.
19 Q. Why not?
20 A. Because I didn't feel like it at the time.
21 Q. And you were, then you were what they call
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop "120Vol.%208.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
22 a truant at that point?
23 A. I wasn't truant. At 16 years of age, you
24 don't have to go to school anymore. It's legal.
25 Q. So, you opted by your own free will to
1 quit going to school at that time?
2 A. Yes. I got pregnant and now have a
3 six-year-old son.
4 Q. You, did you get pregnant before you had
5 dropped out of school?
6 A. No. I got pregnant after.
7 Q. What did you do during the days after you
8 dropped out of school?
9 A. Watched TV.
10 Q. Had you had run-in's with the law prior to
11 that?
12 A. When I was 18 years old, I did.
13 Q. Had you had an incident while you were a
14 juvenile where you were arrested for throwing a
15 knife at your brother or something?
16 A. Yeah, he tried to kill my cat, and then he
17 tried to kill me, so I threw a knife at him.
18 Q. Had you and your brothers been removed
19 from your mom's care on an occasion --
20 A. Never.
21 Q. -- when your mom was arrested?
22 A. Never.
23 Q. Do you remember being placed with some
24 neighbors and the neighbors calling the authorities
25 and saying they wanted someone to come pick you-all
1 up?
2 A. No. We have never been removed out of my
3 mother's care or custody.
4 Q. Do you remember you and your brothers
5 being present on an occasion when your mother was
6 arrested and taken away?
7 A. No, I have never watched my mom be arrested.
8 Q. Do you remember any occasion where she was
9 arrested for possession of drug paraphernalia?
10 A. Yes. And if you look the DNA, the court did
11 DNA, and my mother's DNA was not on that paraphernalia.
12 So that charge was dropped.
13 Q. Were you present when these charges were
14 made?
I 5 A. I was present but I wasn't in the presence of
16 it happening.
17 Q. What do you mean by you were present but
18 you weren't?
19 A. I wasn't in the presence of it happening.
20 Q. Did you mean --
21 A. I know about it.
22 Q. Okay. Well, where were you in
23 geographical proximity to this event?
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop4 "120Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
24 A. I was at my house.
25 Q. And was your mother at the house?
1 A. No. I know two minutes is up.
2 MR. SCAROLA: Yeah, do you want to get to.
3 I mean, you set a 5:00 time limit.
4 MR. LUTTIER: Yeah, I do, I've got to go.
5 MR. SCAROLA: And we're there so --
6 MR. LUTTIER: All right. We'll just break
7 now.
8 THE WITNESS: Break to what? I thought
9 5:00 was at the end. I've got to go pick up my
10 kid.
11 MR. SCAROLA: Yes.
12 MR. LUTTIER: We'll reconvene you
13 deposition. I will put it on hold for right
14 now until we can get a new day.
15 THE WITNESS: Peace out.
16 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the record at 5:00.
17 (A discussion was held off the record.)
18 THE COURT REPORTER: Do you want to order
19 this?
20 MR. LUTTIER: Yes.
21 THE COURT REPORTER: Do you want a copy?
22 MR. SCAROLA: Yes.
23 (Witness excused.)
24 (Deposition was adjourned.)
1 CERTIFICATE OF OATH
2 THE STATE OF FLORIDA
3 COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
6 I the undersi ned authority, certify that
7 personally appeared before me
8 and was duly sworn on the 4th day of December, 2009.
11 Dated this 11th day of December, 2009.
17 Notary Public - State of Florida
My Commission Expires: February 25, 2011
18 My Commission No.: DD 643788
file:///CVDocuments%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: V.:20Vol."1208.ixt[12/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
1 CERTIFICATE
2 THE STATE OF FLORIDA
3 COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
5 I, Registered Professional
Reporter, Florida Professional Reporter and Notary
6 Public in and for the State of Florida at large, do
hereby certify that I was authorized to and did
7 report said deposition in stenotype; and that the
foregoing pages are a true and correct transcription
8 of my shorthand notes of said deposition.
9 I further certify that said deposition was
taken at the time and place hereinabove set forth
10 and that the taking of said deposition was commenced
and completed as hereinabove set out.
I further certify that I am not attorney or
12 counsel of any of the parties, nor am I a relative
or employee of any attorney or counsel of party
13 connected with the action, nor am I financially
interested in the action.
The foregoing certification of this transcript
15 does not apply to any reproduction of the same by
any means unless under the direct control and/or
16 direction of the certifying reporter.
17 Dated this 11th day of December, 2009.
1 DATE: December 11th 2009
2 TO:
c/o Jack Scarola, Esquire
3 SEARCY, DENNEY, SCAROLA,
BARNHART & SHIPLEY.P.A.
IN RE: Jane Doe No. 2 vs. Epstein
CASE NO.: 08-CIV-80119
Please take notice that on Friday, the 4th of
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProductionMesktor (.420Vol.%2011.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
8 December, 2009, you gave your deposition in the
above -referred matter. At that time, you did not
9 waive signature. It is now necessary that you sign
your deposition.
10 As previously agreed to, the transcript will be
furnished to you through your counsel. Please read
11 the following instructions carefully:
At the end of the transcript you will find an
12 errata sheet. As you read your deposition, any
changes or corrections that you wish to make should
13 be noted on the errata sheet, citing page and line
number of said change. DO NOT write on the
14 transcript itself. Once you have read the
transcript and noted any changes, be sure to sign
15 and date the errata sheet and return these pages to
me.
16 If you do not read and sign the deposition
within a reasonable time, the original, which has
17 already been forwarded to the ordering attorney, may
be filed with the Clerk of the Court. If you wish
18 to waive your signature, sign your name in the blank
at the bottom of this letter and return it to us.
Very truly yours,
23 I do hereby waive my signature.
1 CERTIFICATE
3 THE STATE OF FLORIDA
4 COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
5 I hereby certify that I have read the foregoing
6 deposition by me given, and that the statements
7 contained herein are true and correct to the best of
8 my knowledge and belief, with the exception of any
9 corrections or notations made on the errata sheet,
10 if one was executed.
12 Dated this day of
13 2009.
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: V.:20Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
2 IN RE: JANE DOE NO. 2 VS. EPSTEIN
CR:
3 DEPOSITION OF:
TAKEN: December 4th, 2009
ERRATA SHEET
5 DO NOT WRITE ON TRANSCRIPT - ENTER CHANGES HERE
PAGE # LINE # CHANGE REASON
I5
I6
17 Please forward the original signed errata sheet to
this office so that copies may be distributed to all
18 parties.
19 Under penalty of perjury, I declare that I have read
my deposition and that it is true and correct
20 subject to any changes in form or substance entered
here.
22 DATE:
24 SIGNATURE OF
DEPONENT:
file:///Cl/Documents%20and%20SettingsfProduction/Desktop: V.:20Vol.%208.ixt[ 1 2/11/2009 6:15:58 PM]
EFTA00040089 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-15)
Exhibit F
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 1 of 15
COMPOSITE EXHIBIT A
NON-PROSECUTION AGREEMENT AND
ADDENDUM
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 2 of 15
IN RE:
INVESTIGATION OF
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
NON-PROSECUTION AGREEMENT
IT APPEARING that the City of Palm Beach Police Department and the State
Attorney's Office for the 15th Judicial Circuit in and for Palm Beach County (hereinafter,
the "State Attorney's Office") have conducted an investigation into the conduct of Jeffrey
Epstein (hereinafter "Epstein");
IT APPEARING that the State Attorney's Office has charged Epstein by indictment
µith solicitation of prostitution, in violation of Florida Statutes Section 796.07;
IT APPEARING that the United States Attorney's Office and the Federal Bureau of
Investigation have conducted their own investigation into Epstein's background and any
offenses that may have been committed by Epstein against the United States from in or
around 2001 through in or around September 2007, including:
(I ) knowingly and willfully conspiring with others known and unknown to
commit an offense against the United States, that is, to use a facility or mews
of interstate or foreign commerce to knowingly persuade, induce, or entice
minor females to engage in prostitution, in violation of Title 18, United States
Code, Section 2422(b); all in violation ofTitle 18, United States Code, Section
371;

(2) knowingly and willfully conspiring with others known and unknown to travel
in interstate commerce for the purpose of engaging in illicit sexual conduct, as
defined in 18 U.S.C. § 2423(1), with minor females, in violation of Title 18,
United States Code, Section 2423(b); all in violation of Title 18, United States
Code, Section 2423(e);

(3) using a facility or means of interstate or foreign commerce to knowingly
persuade, induce, or entice minor females to engage in prostitution; in
violation of Title 18, United States Code, Sections 2422(b) and 2;

(4) traveling in interstate commerce for the purpose of engaging in illicit sexual
conduct, as defined in 18 U.S.C. § 2423(O, with minor females; in violation
Page I of 7
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 3 of 15
of Title 18, United States Code, Section 2423(b); and
(5) knowingly, in and affecting interstate and foreign commerce, recruiting,
enticing, and obtaining by any means a person, knowing that the person had
not attained the age of 18 years and would be caused to engage in a
commercial sex act as defined in 18 U.S.C. § 1591(eX1); in violation of Title
18, United States Code, Sections 1591(a)(1) and 2; and
IT APPEARING that Epstein seeks to resolve globally his state and federal criminal
liability and Epstein understands and acknowledges that, in exchange for the benefits
provided by this agreement, he agrees to comply with its tams, including undertaking certain
actions with the State Attorney's Office;
IT APPEARING, after an investigation of the offenses and Epstein's background by
both State and Federal law enforcement agencies, and after due consultation with the State
Attorney's Office, that the interests of the United States, the State of Florida, and the
Defendant will be served by the following procedure;
THEREFORE, on the authority of It Alexander Acosta, United States Attorney for
the Southern District of Florida, prosecution in this District for these offenses shall be
deferred in favor of prosecution by the State of Florida, provided that Epstein abides by the
following conditions and the requirements of this Agreement set forth below,
If the United States Attorney should determine, based on reliable evidence, that,
during the period of the Agreement, Epstein willfully violated any of the conditions of this
Agreement, then the United States Attorney may, within ninety (90) days following the
expiration of the term of home confinement discussed below, provide Epstein with timely
notice specifying the conditicm(s) of the Agreement that be has violated, and shall initiate its
prosecution on any offense within sixty (60) days' of giving notice of the violation. Any
notice provided to Epstein pursuant to this paragraph shall be provided within 60 days of the
United States learning of facts which may provide a basis for a determination of a breach of
the Agreement.
After timely fulfilling all the terms and conditions of the Agreement, no prosecution
for the offenses set out on pages 1 and 2 of this Agreement, nor any other offenses that have
been the subject of the joint investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the
United States Attorney's Office, nor any offenses that arose from the Federal Grand Jury
investigation will be instituted in this District, end the charges against Epstein if any, will be
dismissed.
Page 2 of 7
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 4 of 15
Terms of the Agreement

I. Epstein shall plead guilty (not nolo contendere) to the indictment as
currently pending against him in the 15th Judicial Circuit in and for
Palm Beach County (Case No. 2006-cf•009495A)OCCMB) charging
one (1) count of solicitation of prostitution, in violation of FL Stat §
796.07. In addition, Epstein shall plead guilty to an Information filed
by the State Attorney's Office charging Epstein with an offense that
requires him to register as a sex offender, that is, the solicitation of
minors to engage in prostitution, in violation ofFlorida Statutes Section
796.03;

2. Epstein shall make a binding recommendation that the Court impose a
thirty (30) month sentence to be divided as follows:
(a)
(b)
Epstein shall be sentenced to consecutive terms of twelve (12)
months and six (6) months in county jail for all charges, without
any opportunity for withholding adjudication or sentencing, and
without probation or community control in lieu of
imprisonment and
Epstein shall be sentenced to a term of twelve (12) months of
community control consecutive to his two terms in county jail
as described in Term 2(a), supra.

3. This agreement is contingent upon a Judge of the 15th Judicial Circuit
accepting and executing the sentence agreed upon between the State
Attorney's Office and Epstein, the details of which are set forth in this
agreement

4. The terms contained in paragraphs 1 and 2, supra, do not foreclose
Epstein and the State Atorneys Office from agreeing to recommend
any additional charge(s) or any additional tenn(s) of probation and/or
incarceration.

5. Epstein shall waive all challenges to the Information filed by the State
Attorney's Office and shall waive the right to appeal his conviction and
sentence, except a sentence that exceeds what is set forth in paragraph
(2), supra.

6. Epstein shall provide to the U.S. Attorney's Office copies of all
Page 3 of 7
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 5 of 15
proposed agreements with the State Attorney's Office prior to entering
into those agreements.

7. The United States shall provide Epstein's attorneys with a list of
individuals whom it has identified as victims, as defined in 18 U.S.C.
§ 2255, after Epstein has signed this agreement and been sentenced.
Upon the execution of this agreement, the United States, in consultation
with and subject to the good faith approval of Epstein's counsel, shall
select an attorney representative for these persons, who shall bepaid for
by Epstein. Epstein's counsel may contact the identified individuals
through that representative.

8. If any of the individuals referred to in paragraph (7), supra, elects to
file suit pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2255, Epstein will not contest the
jurisdiction of the United States District Court for the Southern District
of Florida over his person and/or the subject matter, and Epstein waives
his right to contest liability and also waives his right to contest damages
up to an amount as agreed to between the identified individual and
Epstein, so long as the identified individual elects to proceed
exclusively under 18 U.S.C. § 2255, and agrees to waive any other
claim for damages, whether pursuant to state, federal, or common law.
Notwithstanding this waiver, as to those individuals whose names
appear on the list provided by the United States, Epstein's signature on
this agreement, his waivers and failures to contest liability and such
damages in any suit are not to be construed as an admission of any
criminal or civil liability.

9. Epstein's signature on this agreement also is not to be construed as an
admission of civil or criminal liability or a waiver of any jurisdictional
or other defense as to any person whose name does not appear on the
list provided by the United States.

10. Except as to those individuals who elect to proceed exclusively under
18 U.S.C. § 2255, as set forth in paragraph (8), supra, neither Epstein's
signature on this agreement, nor its tents, nor any resulting waivers or
settlements by Epstein arc to be construed as admissions or evidence of
civil or criminal liability or a waiver of any jurisdictional or other
defense as to any person, whether or not her name appears on the list
provided by the United States.

11. Epstein shall use his best efforts to enter his guilty plea and be
Page 4 of 7
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 6 of 15
sentenced not later than October 26, 2007. The United States has no
objection to Epstein self-reporting to begin serving his sentence not
later than January 4, 2008.

12. Epstein agrees that he will not be afforded any benefits with respect to
gain time, other than the rights, opportunities, and benefits as any other
inmate, including but not limited to, eligibility for gain time credit
based on standard rules and regulations that apply in the State of
Florida. At the United States' request, Epstein agrees to provide an
accounting of the gain time he earned during his period of
incarceration.
13. The parties anticipate that this agreement will not be made part of any
public record. If the United States receives a Freedom of Information
Act request or any compulsory process commanding the disclosure of
the agreement, it will provide notice to Epstein before making that
disclosure.
Epstein understands that the United States Attorney has no authority to require the
State Attorney's Office to abide by any terms of this agreement. Epstein understands that
it is his obligation to undertake discussions with the State Attorney's Office and to use his
best efforts to ensure compliance with these procedures, which compliance will be necessary
to satisfy the United States' interest. Epstein also understands that it is his obligation to use
his best efforts to convince the Judge of the 15th Judicial Circuit to accept Epstein's binding
recommendation regarding the sentence to be imposed, and understands that the failure to
do so will be a breach of the agreement.
In consideration of Epstein's agreement to plead guilty and to provide compensation
in the manner described above, if Epstein successfully fulfills all of the terms and conditions
of this agreement, the United States also agrees that it will not institute any criminal charges
against any potential co-conspirators of Epstein, including but not limited to Sarah Kellen,
Adriana Ross, Lesley Groff, or Nadia Martinkova. Further, upon execution of this
agreement and a plea agreement with the State Attorney's Office, the federal Grand Jury
investigation will be suspended, and all pending federal Grand Jury subpoenas will be held
in abeyance unless and until the defendant violates any term of this agreement The
defendant likewise agrees to withdraw his pending motion to intervene and to quash certain
grand jury subpoenas. Both parties agree to maintain their evidence, specifically evidence
requested by or directly related to the grand jury subpoenas that have been issued, and
including certain computer equipment, inviolate until all of the terms of this agreement have
been satisfied. Upon the successful completion of the terms of this agreement, all
outstanding grand jury subpoenas shall be deemed withdrawn.
Page 5 of 7
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 7 of 15
By signing this agreement, Epstein asserts and certifies that each of these terms is
material to this agreement and is supported by independent consideration and that a breach
of any one of these conditions allows the United States to elect to terminate the agreement
and to investigate and prosecute Epstein and any other individual or entity for any and all
federal offenses.
By signing this agreement, Epstein asserts and certifies that he is aware of the fact that
the Sixth Amendment to the Constitution of the United States provides that in all criminal
prosecutions the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial. Epstein farther
is aware that Rule 48(b) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure provides that the Court
may dismiss an indictment, information, or complaint for =necessary delay in presenting
a charge to the Grand Jury, filing an information, or in bringing a defendant to trial. Epstein
hereby requests that the United States Attorney for the Southern District ofFlorida defer such
prosecution. Epstein agrees and consents that any delay from the date of this Agreement :o
the date of initiation of prosecution, as provided for in the terms expressed herein, shall be
deemed to be a necessary delay at his own request, and be hereby waives any defense to such
prosecution on the ground that such delay operated to deny him rights under Rule 48(b) of
the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure and the Sixth Amendment to the Constitution of the
United States to a speedy trial or to bar the prosecution by reason of the running of the statute
of limitations for a period of months equal to the period between the signing of this
agreement and the breach of this agreement as to those offenses that were the subject of the
grand jury's investigation. Epstein further asserts and certifies that he understands that the
Fifth Amendment and Rule 7(a) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure provide that all
felonies must be charged in an indictment presented to a grand jury. Epstein hereby agrees
and consents that, if a prosecution against him is instituted for any offense that was the
subject of the grand jury's investigation, it may be by way of an Information signed and filed
by the United States Attorney, and hereby waives his right to be indicted by a grand jury as
to any such offense.
II/
//I
/II
Page 6 of 7
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 8 of 15
By signing this agreement, Epstein asserts and certifies that the above has been read
and explained to him. Epstein hereby states that he understands the conditions of this Non-
Prosecution Agreement and agrees to comply with them.

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
Dated:  By:
Dated:
Dated:
Dated:
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
GERALD LEFCOURT, ESQ.
COUNSEL TO JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LILLY ANN SANCHEZ, ESQ.
ATTORNEY FOR JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Page 7 of 7
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 9 of 15
By signing this agreement, Epstein asserts and certifies that the above has been read
and explained to him. Epstein hereby states that he understands the conditions of this Non-
Prosecution Agreement end agrees to comply with them.
IL ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
Dated:  By:
Dated;
Dated:  7/2-41°7
Dared:
A MARIE vILLAPARA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
OUNSEL TO IF •Y EPSTEIN
LILLY ANN SANCHEZ, ESQ.
ATTORNEY FOR JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Page 7 of 7
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 10 of 15
By signing this agreement, Epstein asserts and certifies that the above has been read
and explained to him. Epstein hereby states that he undergo-Ands  the conditions of this Non-
Prosecution Agreement end agrees to comply with than.
R ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
Dated:  By:
A. MARIE VaLAFANA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
Dated:
D3FFREY EPSTEIN
Dated:
Dated:1-A14-a?--
GERALD LEFCOURT, ESQ.
ANN ESQ.
ATTORNEY FOR JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Page 7 of 7
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 11 of 15
EC RE:
INVESTIGATION OF
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
ADDENDUM TO THE NON-PROSECUTION AGREEMENT
IT APPEARING that the parties seek to clarify certain provisions of page 4, paragraph 7
of the Non-Prosecution Agreement (hereinafter "paragraph 7"), that agreement is modified as
follows:
7A. The United States has the right to assign to an independent third-party the responsibility
for consulting with and, subject to the good faith approval of Epstein's counsel, selecting
the attorney representative for the individuals identified under the Agreement. If the
United States elects to assign this responsibility to an independent third-party, both the
United States and Epstein retain the right to make good faith objections to the attorney
representative suggested by the independent third-patty prior to the final designation of
the attorney representative.
7B. The panics will jointly prepare a short written submission to the independent third-party
regarding the role of the attorney representative and regarding Epstein's Agreement to
pay such attorney representative his or her regular customary hourly rate for representing
such victims subject to the provisions of paragraph C, infra.
7C. Pursuant to additional paragraph 7A, Epstein has agreed to pay the fees of the attorney
representative selected by the independent third party. This provision, however, shall not
obligate Epstein to pay the fees and costs of contested litigation filed against him. Thus,
If after consideration of potential settlements, an attorney representative elects to file a
contested lawsuit pursuant to 18 U.S.C. s 2255 or elects to pursue any other contested
remedy, the paragraph 7 obligation of the Agreement to pay the costs of the attorney
representative, as opposed to any statutory or other obligations to pay reasonable
attorneys fees and costs such as those contained ins 2255 to bear the costs of the attorney
representative, shall cease.
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 12 of 15
By signing this Addendum, Epstein asserts and certifies that the above has been read and
explained to him. Epstein hereby, states that he understands the clarifications to the Non-
Prosecution.Agreernent and agrees to comply with them.

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
Dated:  /Oh b /07
Dated:  / t r / (4"
Dated:
Dated:
By:
A. MARIE WI I A RANA
ASSISTANT G.S. ATTORNEY
GERALD LEFCOURT, ESQ.
COUNSEL TO JEFFREY EPSTELN
LILLY ANN SANCHEZ, ESQ.
ATTORNEY FOR JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLED Docket 05/17/2010 Page 13 of 15
By signing this Addendum, Epstein asserts and certifies that the above has been read and
explained to him. Epstein hereby states that he understands the clarifications to the Non-
Prosccution Agreement and agrees to comply with them.

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
Dated:  /V h 047
Dated:
Dated:
By:
att A. MARIE VILLAYANA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
--HERALD LEFCM/RTIESQ.
COUNSEL TO JEFFREY EPSTEIN
LILLY ANN SANCHEZ, ESQ.
ATTORNEY FOR JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 14 of 15
1
By signing this Addendum, Epstein assats and testifies that the above has been read and
explained to him. Epstein hereby states that he understands the clarifications to the Non-
Prosecution Agreement and agrees to comply with them.

R. ALEXANDER ACOSTA
UNITED STATES ATTORNEY
Dated: /D /30101
Dated:
Dated:
Dated: er—ta711-
By
A. WIAALG V U,LACAIMA
ASSISTANT U.S. ATTORNEY
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
GERALD LEFCOURT, ESQ.
LILLY AN/NANCIIEZ,
ATTORNEY FOR JEFFREY EPSTEIN
Case 1:10-cv-21586-ASG Document 1-3 Entered on FLSD Docket 05/17/2010 Page 15 of 15
Doc-t1-e? 24:65pa Froa-Fowlar -Milts Burnet
•
2057222221
Affirmation
7-666 P.221/024 F-276
I, Jeffrey EL Epstein do hereby ro-offoznIhr Noo-Psoscouion Agreczaent and Addict= to
sari dared Octutox 30, 2007.
p-A
EFTA00159483 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Lawrance Visoski
(inferred date: 2026-01-15)
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE NO. 50200BCA028051XXXXMB AD
Plaintiff,
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Defendant.
DEPOSITION OF LARRY VISOSKI
Thursday, October 15, 2009
10:18 - 3:37 p.m.
515 N. Flagler Drive
Suite P200
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
Reported By:
Wendy Beath Anderson, RPR, CRR, FPR
Notary Public, State of Florida
Esquire Deposition Services
West Palm Beach Office Job 8127542
3527-003
Page 1 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
APPEARANCES:
On behalf of the Plaintiff:
BRADLEY J. EDWARDS, ESQUIRE
ROTHSTEIN, ROSENFELDT, ADLER
401 East Las Olas Boulevard
Suite 1650
Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33394
On behalf of the Defendant:
ROBERT D. CRITTON, JR., ESQUIRE
BURMAN, CRITTON & LUTTIER
303 Banyan Boulevard, Suite 400
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
On behalf of the Witness:
BRUCE REINHART, ESQUIRE
250 South Australian Avenue
Suite 1400
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
ALSO PRESENT:
CARA L. HOLMES, ESQUIRE
1220 N.W. 157th Avenue
Pembroke Pines, Florida 33028
ADAM D. HOROWITZ, ESQUIRE
MERMELSTEIN & HOROWITZ, P.A.
18205 Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 2218
Miami, Florida 33160
RICHARD H. WILLITS, ESQUIRE (VIA TELEPHONE)
RICHARD H. WILLITS, P.A.
2290 10th Avenue North, Suite 404
Lake Worth, Florida 33461
3527-003
Page 2 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
WITNESS:
LARRY VISOSKI
BY MR. EDWARDS:
BY MR. CRITTON:
BY MR. EDWARDS:
BY MR. CRITTON:
I NDEX
DIRECT CROSS
EXH IB ITS
REDIRECT RECROSS
NUMBER DESCRIPTION PAGE
PLAINTIFF'S EX. 1 FLIGHT LOG BOOK
(MARKED IN PREVIOUS DEPO)
PLAINTIFF'S EX. 2 MESSAGE PAD 119
PLAINTIFF'S EX. 3 MESSAGE PAD 119
PLAINTIFF'S EX. 4 COMPLAINT 139
PLAINTIFF'S EX. 5 INMATE VISITOR LOG 161
3527-003
Page 3 of 227
EFFA_00009678
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
PROCEED I NGS
Deposition taken before Wendy Beath Anderson,
Certified Realtime Reporter and Notary Public in and for
the State of Florida at Large, in the above cause.
- - -

MR. EDWARDS: We're going to put something on
the record about -- well, we'll do it this way --
MR. REINHART: Do it at the end, after we get
him -- whatever you want. It's your show

MR. EDWARDS: Okay. There were don't
even think Mr. Willits is aware of this. There was
a subpoena duces tecum for this witness, as well as
the previous witness, which was another pilot, Dave
Rogers, and that duces tecum was to bring the
flight logs related from 1998 through 2005. What
was produced at the previous deposition were flight
logs from 2002 through 2005, and now Mr. Reinhart
has agreed to produce the remainder of the flight
logs requested, those going from 1998 through 2002.

MR. REINHART: Correct. They're pilot logs,
not flight logs. There are other records we
indicated are corporate records, and with those you
have to deal with Mr. Critton.

MR. CRITTON: However, with the proviso, too,
3527-003
Page 4 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
that we're going to work out that these records are
to be used within the confines of this litigation
and not to be spread to the press or anyone else,
because they do contain confidential information as
to who may have been on the plane and other records
of Mr. Rogers, which but for the subpoena would
have been only available to the FAA or some other
law enforcement agencies.

MR. EDWARDS: Okay. Is that all you want to
put on?
MR. CRITTON: Yes.
MR. EDWARDS: I'm not saying I necessarily
agree or disagree with you. That's something that
we'll deal with some other day.

MR. CRITTON: Bruce, you'd better produce
these records, but there has to be some sort of
understanding before --

MR. REINHART: Correct.
MR. EDWARDS: I won't do anything until you
file whatever you until we work whatever it is
out in court. I'll say that on the record, that
I'm not doing anything with the records outside of
my office until some judge deals with it.

MR. REINHART: And for the record, I'll adopt
what Mr. Critton said on this one limited occasion.
3527-003
Page 5 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

MR. EDWARDS: All right.
Thereupon,
(LARRY VISOSKI)
having been first duly sworn or affirmed, was examined
and testified as follows:
THE WITNESS: Yes, I do.
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Can you tell us your name for the record.
A. Lawrence Visoski, Jr.
Q. And Mr. Visoski, have you ever had your
deposition taken before?

A. No.
Q. Okay. Here's the process: I'm going to ask
you questions. You're going to give us answers. Try to
give us answers that we all understand and that the
court reporter can take down, such as yes, no, or some
other verbal answer that we can understand. It's easy
when we get in a casual conversation to nod or shake
your head, and the court reporter is not writing
pictures or anything else.

A. I understand.
Q. The other thing is, and I've been accused of
this in other depositions -- I don't know if it's true
or not -- but I need to wait until you finish answering
3527-003
Page 6 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
the question and you need to wait until I finish asking
the question.

A. So you're not allowed to interrupt me?
Q. And you're not allowed to interrupt me.
A. Like I just did?

Q. Right.
MR. CRITTON: Cara just snickered when you
said you've been accused because she recognizes
it's true.

MR. EDWARDS: I don't know what the meaning of
her snickering was.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. But for what it's worth, if you don't
understand the question or I've asked a bad question, I
don't want you to guess. Give me the best answer to the
best of your knowledge and if you need me to rephrase
it, I will.

A. Okay.
Q.
A.
Okay. Tell me your current address.
Q. How long have you lived there?
A. Approximately nine years.

Q. Okay. Who do you live there with?
A.
3527-003
Page 7 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
S
Q.
A.
Q • Who's your employer right now?

A. NES, LLC.
Q. How long has NES, LLC been your employer?
A. I'm guessing. I'd say back 1991. I have to
do the math, but 17, 18 years.

Q. Has that been your only employer since 1991?
A. Yes.
Q. And has that been your only source of income
since 1991?

A. Yes.
Q. And what is NES, LLC?
A. I don't really know. I mean, it's the company
that my check comes from.

Q. What do you do for NES, LLC that results in
them paying you?
A. I am chief pilot for the aircraft and
3527-003
Page 8 of 227
EFFA_00009683
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
helicopters.

Q. And do you have a specific boss or somebody
you answer to at NES, LLC?
A. Several people would call to schedule flights
from the office, being it either Mr. Epstein or, you
<now, I would just get a phone call and they would
schedule a trip.

Q. Okay. Aside from Mr. Epstein, who else would
there be that would call to schedule flights?
A. Leslie.

Q. Leslie who?
A. Leslie Gruff.
Q. When's the last time you talked to Leslie
Gruff?
A. Probably two weeks ago, three weeks ago.

Q. And where is she currently?
A. I believe in New York, is where I spoke to her
on the phone last.
Q. What's the telephone number you call to reach
Leslie Gruff?
A.

Q. And what address is Leslie Gruff at?
A. Do you mean where the office is located?
Q. Correct.
A.
3527-003
Page 9 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. And it's my understanding from other
depositions that there are also apartments in that
building?
A. Yes.

Q. And Mr. Epstein either owns or leases or rents
certain of those apartments. Is that your
understanding?

MR. CRITTON: Form; speculation.
THE WITNESS: I'm only speculating. I
don't -- to my understanding, I don't know.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Do you know other people that live in that
building?
A. Well, it would be myself, Dave Rogers -- well,
when you say "live,' explain.

Q. When you're saying yourself and Dave Rogers --
A. See, we don't live there. I mean, we have --
we would stay there when we would have a trip.

Q. Okay. When you would fly up to New York and
land in New York, the place where you would stay, is
that

A. Yes, that's correct.
Q. That's also a location you've indicated in
this deposition that is the office for NES, LLC?

A. Yes.
3527-003
Page 10 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
S
Q. What floor or suite number is NES, LLC in?

A. I believe -- well, I don't know that NES, LLC
has an office there. I know that's where Leslie has the
phone number where I call. So I don't know for a fact
If NES, LLC has an office there.

Q. And what suite number, then, would Leslie
:ruff sit in to answer that telephone number at
A. I think it's III.

Q. And when you stay at
what suite number or what apartment number do you stay
in?
A.
Q. And how about Dave Rogers, where does he stay?

A. I'm guessing, because it's been some time
since we've been there, 10B, but don't quote me on it.
Q. Who are the other people in that building that
you know to stay there on a regular -- fairly regular
basis?

A. I've seen people in the elevator that, you
know, have been on the airplane. Case in point, maybe
-• but I don't know for a fact that she lives
there, or anybody else for that matter.

Q. Okay. When you say you've seen
on the elevator --
3527-003
Page II of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. I only assume she lives there. I don't know
.or a fact. I'm trying to be honest and factual for
So I couldn't honestly say if I knew she lived
- here or not.

O. Where do you think lives?
A. I would think she lives there.
Q. You don't have a better location?
A. I don't have another location.

Q. Anybody else?
A. Not to my knowledge. I mean, I'd only be
guessing that people live in that building that -- you
know, I don't have any facts to prove that they actually
live there. I mean, I don't think you want me to guess.

Q. Well, NES, LLC, would you say that the owner
or controller of that company is Jeffrey Epstein?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't know that for a fact.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Jeffrey Epstein is somebody you've indicated
that you've worked for for 17 or 18 years, right?
A. Yes.

Q. And over the 17 or 18 years you've become
personally close with him as well, correct?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't understand how you mean
3527-003
Page 12 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
•close." Define that.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Well, more so than just a pilot that takes him
from Point A to Point B?
A. That is my job.
Q. Right. But you know him on a personal level
and that you've had personal conversations that don't
necessarily deal with flying from Point A to Point B;
isn't that right?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: More specific, meaning we talk
about cars. I mean, does that make you a personal
friends?
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Have you ever gone to his house to eat?
A. No.
Q. Have you been to his New York home?
A. Yes.
Q. How many occasions have you been to his New
York home?

MR. CRITTON: Object to form.
THE WITNESS: We normally pick up luggage in
the lobby, so it would probably be quite often.
Any time we depart out of New York, we stop by the
house and pick up luggage and head to the aircraft.
3527-003
Page 13 of 227
EFFA_00009688
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Other than picking up luggage, have you been
to his home to visit or socialize with him?
A. Not to socialize, no.

Q. Have you been to his Palm Beach home?
A. To?
Q. To Mr. Epstein's Palm Beach house?
A. Right.
Q. Have you been there?

A. Yes.
Q. Have you been inside?
A. Yes.
Q. And how many occasions have you been inside
that home?
A. The same, as far as picking up luggage, and
that would be on a regular basis, you know, for a
Aeparture. We wouldn't always go to the house to pick
up luggage, but it made it easier for loading the
aircraft, getting it done prior to departure.

Q. Is that the only reason that you have ever
gone to the Palm Beach home over the last 18 years, is
to pick up luggage?

A. No.
Q. What other reasons have you gone there?
A. I've set up several home theater equipments,
3527-003
Page 14 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
you know, televisions and such.

Q. Is that another hobby or job or something of
yours?
A. Both.
Q. Does he pay you for that?
A. Not any more than my salary.

Q. What's your current salary?
A. At this time, 180,000.
Q. And what are you paid $180,000 to do?
A. To manage his aircraft.

Q. What does that entail?
A. Scheduling maintenance. Anything that has to
do with any flight, whether it be weather, flight
planning, time and distance to and from a location, any
logistics involved in running an operation that has
aircraft.

Q. In addition to the 180,000, does he give you
bonuses as well?
A. There have been Christmas bonuses.
Q. Over the years, you mean, there have been
Christmas bonuses?
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
Yes.
Is 180,000 the most he's ever paid you?
No.
All right. Were you making -- when was the
3527-003
Page 15 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
last time that you were making an amount different than
180,000?

A. Last year.
Q. That would be 2008?
A. That would be correct. Yeah, we all took a
salary cut, I don't know the exact date. It might have
been 2008, last year. It was last Christmas we all took
a 10 percent salary cut.

Q. Do you know why?
A. Economic reasons.
Q. And who told you that you were going to have
to take the salary cut?

A. Darren Indyke.
Q. And did you ask for an explanation?
A. He explained it was due to economic reasons
throughout the country.

Q. Okay. So in 2008, how much was -- were you
being paid by NES, LLC?
A. 200,000.
Q. And is 200,000 the most that you've ever made
from NES, LLC?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. And on top of that $200,000, did you get a
bonus that year as well?
MR. REINHART: Which year are you talking
3527-003
Page 16 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
about?

MR. EDWARDS: 2008.
THE WITNESS: That year, I think we skipped
Christmas bonuses that year. The last bonus might
have been 2007.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. If you ever got a bonus from Mr. Epstein
and I'm only deriving this from you using the term
"Christmas bonus."

A. Holiday bonus.
Q. -- am I correct to assume sorry. Am I
correct to assume that if you got a bonus, there was
only one and it was at the end of the year, around the
holidays?

A. Yes.
Q. Okay. And how much was the 2007 holiday
bonus?
A. I'd have to ask my wife, to be honest. I
haven't seen my paycheck in 27 years, so I believe it
was $10,000.

Q. And in 2007 you also made $200,000?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay.
A. With a question mark. I'm trying to be as
accurate as I can, but yes.
3527-003
Page 17 of 227
EFFA_00009692
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Something pretty close to that?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Okay. So with the bonus it was 210,000,
roughly?
A. Right.

Q. Okay. And how long were you making that
salary?
A. Probably -- he was very religious about giving
annual increases, so I would probably say 2006, you
know, it was -- we would get increment -- increases of
five or $10,000 each year. So I would say 2006. So it
graduated, you know, progressive.

Q. Okay. Do you remember the progression if we
start at 1991? Do you remember roughly what the
progression was up through 2007/2008, when you were
making $200,000?

A. No, I wouldn't know the progression.
Q. Okay. Do you remember what you were making
from and was NES, LLC the company paying you back in
1991?

A. I don't know. I don't remember. Let me say
it that way. I don't remember.
Q. Okay. When -- how long do you remember NES,
LLC being the payer of your check?

A. Personally, two years, because I've never seen
3527-003
Page 18 of 227
EFFA_00009693
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
my paycheck. So I don't even know what's written on the
top of it.

Q. That would be something that only your wife
would see, I'm assuming?
A. You're right, since she probably wouldn't know
the answer either, because she's looking at the right
column and not the top column.

Q. Right. When is the first time that you had
heard the name NES, LLC, that company?
A. Five, six years, and even questioned what it
stood for. And I think to this day I couldn't answer
that honestly, what it stands for.

Q. Okay. But it's your understanding that the
NES, LLC is paying you for the work that you do as a
pilot or maintain the planes for Jeffrey Epstein?

A. To my understanding, yes.
Q. And back in 1991, do you know if it was a
different company that was paying you or if it was
Jeffrey Epstein directly paying you?

A. I don't remember. I mean, I don't.
Q. Okay. Throughout your career with -- as a
pilot for Jeffrey Epstein, since 1991, has there ever
been a time when you believe you were paid directly from
Jeffrey Epstein personally versus some company?

A. Not to my knowledge, no.
3527-003
Page 19 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. Okay. So whether it was NES, LLC or some
other company, it was all of a sudden a company name, to
the best of your knowledge?

A. Exactly, yes.
Q. And back in 1991, do you remember
approximately how much you were being paid that year?

A. Fifty-five or 60,000, is maybe what I started.
Q. Okay.
A. You're going back a long ways.
Q. Yes.
A. I'm trying.

Q. Your relationship goes back that far. That's
why I chose that year.
A. Right.
Q • Okay. Did you get bonuses even back that far?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. And do you remember what your bonuses were
approximately?
A. 5,000. I mean, that was kind of the -- the
starting point.

Q. Okay. In addition to monitary bonuses, were
- here ever gifts or any other type of compensation that
NES, LLC or Jeffrey Epstein provided you?

A. Yes.
Q. And is that over the span of the 18 years?
3527-003
Page 20 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Tell me what some of those items are.
A. I remember one specifically was a pool heater.

Q. Excuse me?
A. A pool heater.
Q. When was that?
A. 1995-ish.
Q. Okay. Why did you get that?
A. I had built a pool and I didn't have a heater
and he kind of laughed at me saying, "How can you have a
pool without a heater?" So he says, "You ought to get a
heater.•

Q. Where were you when you had that conversation?
A. In the airplane.
O. How did he know that you had built a pool?

A. Just in general conversation.
Q. You were having a conversation with Jeffrey
Epstein?
A. Yes.
Q. And this is something that was happening on
the airplane, this conversation?

A. During the flight. Yeah, it would have been
like on cruise or something.
Q. Okay. When you say •during the flight," does
that --
3527-003
Page 21 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Again, you're going back a long ways.
Q. I understand. We're talking about 1995 right
now.
A. Yes.
Q. You're having a conversation with Jeffrey
Epstein. Who is flying the airplane?

A. The auto pilot and there's two crew.
Q. Okay. So are you back in the back portion or
is he up in the cockpit?

A. Up in the cockpit.
Q. Okay. Jeffrey Epstein sometimes comes up
there?
A. Just, yeah, in between the two pilot seats.

Q. All right. Is that something that was
typical, to have conversations like that?
A. Mm-hmm.
Q. Yes?
A. Yes. No nodding.

Q. And would those conversations be directed
mainly with you or with the other pilots as well?
A. Mainly with me.

Q. I mean, you've kind of been described as the
main guy or the main pilot. Wouldn't you consider that
pretty much your role, right?

A. Well, that's chief pilot.
3527-003
Page 22 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. But more so than that, if there's going to be
a casual conversation about a pool or a pool heater or
whatever, it's going to be with you most likely if he's
going to be talking to pilots, right?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Right.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Okay. And you feel like over the years your
relationship with Jeffrey Epstein has been pretty good?

A. Yes.
Q. And you have been closer to him over the years
as you've grown to know him?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: The same throughout the same
year. We never got any closer than 1991 than I am
with him now. I'm very professional at what I do
and know the line between being professional and
thinking you're somebody's buddy.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. So that's not something that you think
you are? You don't think you're his buddy?
A. No, sir.
Q. Do you consider yourself his friend?

A. I believe so.
Q. Do you think he considers you his friend?
3527-003
Page 23 of 227
EFFA_00009698
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. I think so.
Q. All right. What makes you think that?
MR. CRITTON: Speculation.
THE WITNESS: He's always been kind and
respectful.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Ever invited you to dinner?
A. No, sir.
Q. Have you ever associated or socialized with
him during the day at any of his homes?

A. Only during a business reason.
Q. Okay. What are the other -- are the places
that you believe that Mr. Epstein owns? I know we've
talked about this Manhattan -- the Manhattan house.
I've read the articles about it, the Palm Beach mansion.
But what other places are you familiar with that

Mr. Epstein owns?
MR. CRITTON: Form; predicate, speculation.
THE WITNESS: To answer it honestly, I don't
know specifically that he owns any of the
residences, to be honest. I would only assume that
he owns. So if you want me to answer honestly, I
don't know that he owns any of the other.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. Well, what would be the basis for your
3527-003
Page 24 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
assumption that he owns the home in Palm Beach?

A. He goes there, but I don't assume -- you don't
have to own a house to go to it.
Q. And not only does he go there, you're aware
that he spends the night there; he resides there
sometimes, correct?

A. Yes.
Q. When he's in Palm Beach, that's where he
A. He sleeps.
Q. -- sleeps? Right. When he's in New York, do
you know where he sleeps?

A. No.
Q • But you've been to a particular house in New
York that's a very large house that we've all read about
that you picked up luggage at, right?

A. Yes, sir.
MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
O. And that home, do you know that -- I know that
you're saying that you haven't done a public record
search to make sure that Jeffrey Epstein owns it.

A. Yeah.
Q. But you assume that he does?
A. Assuming.
Q. That's where he sleeps when he's in New York?
3527-003
Page 25 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I assume.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. That's where his luggage is when you pick it
up?

A. Doesn't mean he owns it.
Q. Right. But that's where it is?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know of anybody else who owns that home
in New York?

A. No.
Q. Okay. Have you been to his ranch in New
Mexico?
A. Yes.
MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. How many times have you been to his ranch in
New Mexico?

MR. CRITTON: Form; predicate.
THE WITNESS: A guesstimate, fifty times, only
due to the fact that we would fly there.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. And where would you land?
A. Depending upon the aircraft, either
Albuquerque or Santa Fe.
3527-003
Page 26 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Are those private airports?
A. Public.
Q. Public, okay. Are there any private landing
places where you would land any airplanes in New Mexico?

A. There are.
Q. That you have landed --
A. That I have.
Q. -- his airplane?
A. Yes.
Q. Where?
A. We have a 4500 -foot strip on the ranch.

Q. When you say "we," yourself and somebody?
A. The company.
Q. What company?
A. Well, I should say -- I see where you're going
with that. The ranch owns -- whoever owns the ranch.
The ranch has a runway on it.

Q. Okay. And you've landed an airplane on that
runway?
A. That ranch, yes.
Q. How many times do you think you've landed
there?

A. Ten.
Q. All right. And have you been inside his
ranch?
3527-003
Page 27 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Yes.
MR. CRITTON: Form to the last question.
MR. REINHART: Can you clarify, the physical
ranch or the residences or the structures on the
ranch?

MR. EDWARDS: I don't have a good visual
appreciation for it.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Why don't you describe it in your words what
this ranch that we are talking about looks like. And
I've heard it referred to as the 2orro Ranch. Have you
heard that?

A. I've heard that.
Q. That's the ranch we're all familiar with,
we're talking about where the runway is and everything
else?

A. Yes.
Q. Describe it in your own words, the landscaping
of this ranch. What do we have on it?
A. There is a house up on the hill, a large
house.

Q. How big?
A. Big. I've read 40,000 square feet in the
paper.
Q. Have you been to it?
3527-003
Page 28 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Yes.
Q. Does that seem like it's feasible,
approximately 40,000 --
A. I think so, yes.
Q. What else do we have on it?

A. There is a compound that has kind of motel
room type -- they call it bunkhouse.
Q. Where's the bunkhouse located?

A. At the entrance to the ranch.
Q. Okay. And what is that primarily used for?
A. For the people that work on the ranch, they
reside there. It's also a place where anybody that
traveled on the airplane would stay. It's kind of like,
you know, a hotel room.
Q • And how far is that from the first house that
you described, the 40,000 square foot house?

A. It's probably 4 miles.
Q. Okay. So the Zorro Ranch is a rather large
area of property?
A. Yes.
Q. And how many times -- I know we just talked
about how many times you've been in the house, but how
many times have you been on that ranch in New Mexico,
the Zorro Ranch?

A. Thirty to fifty times over the years. That's
3527-003
Page 29 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
a guesstimate.

Q. Is that over -- when was the first time that
you went to that ranch?
A. A guess, I don't know when it was, actually,
our first trip, but 1995/'94.

Q. Okay. And do you believe Jeffrey Epstein
and/or a corporation owned or controlled by him to be
the sole owner of that ranch?

A. I don't know any of those details.
Q. Have you ever talked to Jeffrey Epstein about
who owns that ranch?

A. No.
Q. Do you know of anybody else who may own that
ranch?
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Other than Jeffrey Epstein, do you know of
anybody else who regularly stays there when they're in
New Mexico?

A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Does Jeffrey Epstein stay there when you're in
New Mexico?
A. He has.
Q. And he has a key to the place?

A. I don't know if there's a key.
Q. One way or another, he gets in, right?
3527-003
Page 30 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Yes, sir.
Q. And he sleeps there?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay.
A. I assume he does.
Q. You assume he sleeps?
A. I do. I think.

Q. Okay.
MR. CRITTON: This is really --
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Other than the pool heater in 1995, have you
ever received any other gifts on top of the compensation
from Mr. Epstein?

A. I did get land on the ranch to build a house.
0. What do you mean you got land on the ranch?
A. He deeded me land to build a home.

Q. When was that?
A. Ten years ago at least.
Q. Do you know if he's ever deeded anyone else in
this world land on the ranch to build a home?

A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Why did he do that?
A. We would vacation out there and my wife fell
in love with New Mexico and we were looking for
property.
3527-003
Page 31 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q • And did you talk to him about that?

A. Yes. He knew I -- he was aware I was looking
for a home and he says, "Well, I have so much land, I
could give you a spot to build a home on.' So I built a
house.

Q. So how long has a home actually been on that
property?
A. Nine years.
Q. And that's a home that you own?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that's a home that was -- when I say "you
own it,' is there a mortgage on it or did he give it to
you free and clear?

A. No, no, I paid for the house. I made payments
on it.
Q. All right. So what did he actually give you?

A. 40 -acres of land.
Q. That you did not have to pay for?
A. You know, I'd have to go back and look. I
think it was -- I had to pay something for it. I don't
remember.

Q. How often have you visited that piece -- that
home that you own?
A. My wife would spend summers out there with the
kids.
3527-003
Page 32 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Okay. But that's on the Zorro Ranch?
A. Yes.
Q. So in addition to the 50 or so times you've
been to the Zorro Ranch, you've been to your property
that's on the Zorro Ranch?

A. Yes, which over the years, it's once -a -year
visits. So I mean, it is included in the 50 times that
I've been there.

Q. Okay. And did you have a conversation with
him that led to him giving you or gifting you 40 -acres
of land?

A. We talked about it because he knew I was
looking for a home out there.
Q. Okay. In gifting you that land, did you
consider yourself at that point in time to be more than
just his pilot, as more of a friend?

A. No. You're using the word "gifting." I paid
for the land. I don't recall what it was. But you use
the word "friend." I don't know that a -- sure, he was
a friend. I mean. ..

Q. Well, did he give Dave Rogers any land out on
the New Mexico ranch?
A. No.
Q. Okay. When you say you paid for it, I thought
that I asked that question, "Did you pay for the
3527-003
Page 33 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
40 -acres?" I thought your answer was, "I don't know,
I'd have to go back and look."
Are you saying now that you did pay for that
land?

A. I don't remember. If there was a sum of
money, it was just for, you know, the legal purpose of a
transfer of ownership of the land.

Q. Okay. If it was a substantial amount of
money, that's something that you would have remembered?
A. Oh, exactly. No, it was not a substantial
amount.

Q. Okay. Do you remember approximately how much
money you had to give Jeffrey Epstein for that land?
A. I would only be guessing. It might have been
five dollars. To my knowledge, I don't remember.

Q. Okay. So when I'm saying he gave you the
land, he may have actually given you the land?
A. Sure.
Q. Okay. And to the best of your knowledge, he's
never given anyone else land out there?

A. Not to my knowledge.
MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. All right. How big is this house that you
built on the ranch?
3527-003
Page 34 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. 1800 square feet.
Q. Were you ever at that house at the same time
when he's at his house that's on that Zorro Ranch?

A. Yes.
Q. All right. We started back in 1991 with you
making around $55,000 a year and that has progressed
over time to a point where in 2007 you were making
$200,000 a year. I don't want to go through every
single year; that would take a really long time. But
the progression, was that on a yearly basis normally or
after two years or three years?

A. Yearly basis.
Q. Okay. And would that normally be in
increments of?
A. $5,000.
Q. Okay. You've talked about a couple other
gifts that have been given to you from Jeffrey Epstein
over the years; one is a pool heater in 1995 and now
some 40 acres of land on his New Mexico ranch. Any
other gifts you can think about?

A. No other gifts.
Q. Okay. I don't want to split hairs with you.
You obviously thought about that answer before giving

it. What other items are you thinking about that he's
given to you or cut you a discount on or otherwise that
3527-003
Page 35 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
you feel was compensation for you working for him?

A. I drive a company car. I mean. . .
Q. Okay. What kind of car?
A. A Hummer.
L LC?
Q. You say 'a company car." That's owned by NES,

A. No, I think the registration has Zorro
Development on it.
Q. What is Zorro Development?
A. I believe that's the ranch, or at least it has
the name of the ranch. I don't know what the entity is.

Q. And it's your understanding that that's a
company vehicle?
A. Yes.
Q. And where is that vehicle primarily garaged?

A. At my home.
Q. In or in the Zorro Ranch?
A. No, here in
Q. All right. And is there only one company
vehicle that you're issued?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. And is that something that was -- that you did
not have to pay for?
A. No, it's just something I drive. I mean, it's
not titled to me or anything like that. It's just a car
3527-003
Page 36 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
that I drive.

Q. All right. You've worked for him for 18
years. I don't even know how long the Hummer would
last, but presumably, that's not the car you've had over
the entire 18 years. Have you always had a company car?

A. No, I haven't, no.
Q. When did you get the Hummer?
A. Probably three years ago.
Q. Do any other members of Mr. Epstein's piloting
team have company cars?

A. No.
Q. Only you?
A. Yes.
Q. And do you know how that decision was made to
get you a company vehicle?

A. No.
Q. What do you use that vehicle for?
A. To and from the airport.
also?
Q. All right. Do you use it for personal reasons

A. I guess, yes.
Q. I mean, that's your primary vehicle?
A. Yes, or I drive my wife's car.
Q. Which is?

A. Type of car?
3527-003
Page 37 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. Yes.
A. A Mercedes.
Q. And is that something that was also a gift
from Mr. Epstein?

A. No, sir.
Q. What type of Mercedes is that?
A. A ML 430, ten years old.
Q. All right. Are there any other items
company car, the land in New Mexico, the pool heater
any other items that Mr. Epstein has given you over time
as compensation or reward or anything else?

A. No, sir.
Q. And your only income is from Mr. Epstein or
his companies?
A. Correct.
Q. Okay. And it's been that way since 1991?

A. Yes.
Q. How did you meet Mr. Epstein or become
involved with him in 1991?
A. We heard at the airport that Mr. Epstein was
purchasing an airplane when Dave Rogers and myself were
living in Columbus, and we had the opportunity to
interview with him, and we did and got the job.

Q. And this is before he owned the airplane?
A. Yes.
3527-003
Page 38 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. And which airplane was that?
A. The Hawker.
Q. Does he still have the Hawker?
A. No.
Q • How long did he have that plane?

A. Five years, guesstimate; four or five years.
Q. So sometime in the mid '90s?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you keep any type of logs or documentation
as to who would have been flying on that airplane if you
transported any individuals?

A. The same logs as you possess now are the
flight logs.
Q. Okay.
A. That's the standard for the industry.

Q. So that's something that you kept, or that
Dave Rogers kept?
A. Dave Rogers.
Q. Okay. If there are any documents out there
with names of passengers on any of the flights involving
planes owned or controlled by Jeffrey Epstein and/or his
companies, those would be documents in the possession of
Dave Rogers and not yourself?

A. Oh, the corporation actually, they belong to.
Q. Okay.
3527-003
Page 39 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

MR. REINHART: That was a compound question.
You might want to split it in half.
MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. What documents do you believe exist that
indicate names of individuals that have been passengers
on Mr. Epstein's airplanes?

MR. REINHART: Are we going back all the way
from '91 to the present?
MR. EDWARDS: Sure.
THE WITNESS: You're talking about the Hawker?
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Any airplanes. What documents would there be?
A. There would be the same: Flight logs and
passenger manifests would exist.

Q. And are either of those required?
A. The flight log is required for the aircraft to
- rack times and landings.

Q. And in the flight log, is it required that you
designate the names of the passengers?
A. No.
Q. That's just something that Dave Rogers did on
his own?

A. Everybody does that. It's more for Internal
Revenue.
3527-003
Page 40 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
.7

Q. Okay. If something happens, they know who is
on the plane?
A. Exactly, weight and balance.
Q. Have you ever kept any flight logs that have
names of people on the airplane?

A. When you say "kept,' I have filled out flight
logs or the passenger manifest, yes.
Q. By "kept' I meant maintained to where they're
in your possession either on paper or computer?

A. We keep --
MR. REINHART: Can you differentiate a flight
log from the pilot's log that we showed you
earlier?

MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. I'm talking about -- I don't know that it's
called a flight log, a pilot's log or any kind of log.

A. They are different, yes.
Q. Yeah. I'm asking about, have you kept or do
you have any documentation that would indicate the names
of passengers that have flown on any of Jeffrey
Epstein's planes?

A. No.
Q. Either in the form of paper or on a computer?
A. No.
3527-003
Page 41 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Makes that easy.
A. Okay.
Q. In 1991, were you the chief pilot?
A. No.
Q. Somebody else was the chief pilot?

A. Yes.
Q. Who's that?
A. Dave Rogers.
Q. All right. At what point in time did you
become chief pilot and switched with Dave Rogers?

A. Six years ago; five, six years ago.
Q. Why?
A. Professionalism, technique.
Q. What do you mean by that?

A. The way Dave would operate an aircraft,
Jeffrey knew the difference when I was flying and when
Dave was flying.

Q. How do you know he knew the difference?
A. Just --
Q. He told you?
A. Yes. He knew the difference that if he never
came up front, he knew who was flying, who landed.

Q. And what was the conversation that he had with
you that resulted in you becoming chief pilot, switching
positions with Dave Rogers?
3527-003
Page 42 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Jeffrey would always critique Dave's flying
capabilities, and I tried to help Dave and explain to
him what Jeffrey likes and doesn't like. And Jeffrey's
also conveyed these likes and dislikes. And Dave
maintained continuing with certain piloting techniques
that were just not comfortable to passengers. And this
went on through the years, and Jeffrey just got tired of
it one day.

Q. What specifically were Jeffrey Epstein's likes
and dislikes with respect to the flight of the plane?

MR. CRITTON: Let me put in a form here. But
I don't know what this has to do with anything in
this case.

MR. EDWARDS: I understand that, Bob.
MR. CRITTON: I want to use this for some
other depositions where we -- we've gone beyond the
scope.
THE WITNESS: The case in point, the last
straw was there was a technique called quiet flying
where you would retard the throttles well short of
the runway and pretty much glide the airplane in.
Well, if you don't do that correctly, you have to
spool the engines up just prior to touching down
that -- because you're losing air speed and it's an
uncomfortable sound and feeling for the passengers
3527-003
Page 43 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
thinking that you're not going to make the runway.
And it was a continuous practice of Dave doing that
to be neighbor friendly as opposed to being
passenger -comfort friendly.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay.
A. Hence, the transfer of power.
Q. Has he ever discussed with you where he wants
you to be, whether that is "stay in the cockpit when I
have people on the airplane," or don't intermingle with
the passengers or anything else?

A. He's never stated that to us.
MR. REINHART: Could you clarify which "he"
you're talking about?
MR. EDWARDS: I'm talking about Jeffrey
Epstein.

MR. REINHART: Okay.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. You understood that?
A. Yes.
Q. It's my understanding that in the -- well,
tell me other than the Hawker, what other airplanes have
you flown for Jeffrey Epstein?

A. A Gulfstream.
Q. Does he still have that plane?
3527-003
Page 44 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Yes, sir.
Q. How big of a plane is that?
A. Large corporate jet.
Q. How long has he had it?
A. Fourteen years; 13, 14 years.

Q. And other than the Gulfstream, what other
airplanes does he have?
A. When you say 'he," obviously, these are
company -owned --

Q. Jeffrey Epstein or his companies.
A. A Boeing 727.
Q. Well, I know that's a very large airplane.
think that's been described by other people, so I'm not
going to have you do that. But there's partitions in
that airplane -- in the back rooms of that airplane,
right?

A. Yes.
Q. Several different partitions to where if the
pilot comes out of the cockpit, you don't necessarily
see all the passengers?

A. Yes.
Q. That's true?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay.
MR. REINHART: Keep your voice up so she can
3527-003
Page 45 of 227
EFFA_00009720
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
hear you.
THE WITNESS: Oh.

MR. REINHART: And so Mr. Willits can hear
you.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Other than the Gulfstream and the Boeing and
the Hawker, what other airplanes has Jeffrey Epstein
owned over the years?

A. That is it.
Q. And currently still owns -- or the companies
associated with him own the Gulfstream and the Boeing?

A. Yes.
Q. And in the past two years, have you flown
those two airplanes?
A. Just for routine flights to keep them loose
or, you know -- you know what I mean.

Q. Have those two airplanes been flown by anyone
else in the last two years?
A. No.
Q. Have those two airplanes been flown in the
last two years for any reason other than routine
maintenance -type flights?

A. We've had one -- two flights I think in the
past two years.
Q. And what were the purposes of those flights
3527-003
Page 46 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
and who was on the flights?

A. One flight I believe we went to Sebring and
another flight we went to Nassau, Bahamas.
Q. And who did you go to Nassau, Bahamas with?

A. I'd have to look at the flight log, but I
think it was , I believe. I think
that was the three passengers, to the best of my
knowledge.

Q. And it's my understanding that little
St. James is an island that Jeffrey Epstein owns or
controls?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't know that he owns it.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

O. Has he ever been to an island called Little
St. James?
A. Yes.
Q. And have you been there with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I've been there when he was there.
Q. Have you flown on an airplane with him to that
destination?
A. No.

Q. All right. When you say you've been there
when he was there, how did that come about?
A. We flew into St. Thomas and then we flew to
3527-003
Page 47 of 227
EFFA_00009722
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Little St. James in a helicopter.

Q. And do you fly the helicopter as well?
A. Yes.
Q. How many helicopters are owned or controlled
by Jeffrey Epstein and/or corporations associated with
him?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: At this time, one.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. And has that helicopter been flown in the last
two years?

A. Just for routine maintenance.
Q. And when you and -- let's say when
and and flew to Nassau, do
you know the purpose of that trip?

A. No.
Q. How long did you stay?
A. Five hours.
Q. Did you pick anybody up there?
A. No. Meaning passengers?

Q. Yes.
A. No.
Q. What happened? You landed the airplane and
then what?
A. The passengers left. Dave and I went and had
3527-003
Page 48 of 227
EFFA_00009723
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
lunch. The passengers showed up and we came back.

Q. Have you ever stayed at the home that is on
Little St. James?
A. No.
Q.
home?
Have you known Jeffrey Epstein to stay at that

A. I don't know that for a fact.
Q. Okay. Do you believe that he is the owner or
controller or has some interest in the home or the
island of Little St. James?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I have no knowledge of that
being a fact.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. And you have no belief that that is a fact?

A. Exactly.
Q. When you say you've been there when he was
there, how many times has that occurred?
A. Estimating, a hundred times.

Q. Okay.
A. Trying to give an honest answer.
Q. Okay. And in the approximate -- I'm not going
to hold you to a hundred times, but in the approximately
hundred times --

A. Sure.
3527-003
Page 49 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. -- for what period of time are we talking
about?

A. During what period of time?
Q. Right.
A. Let's see, when did all this happen? What,
2007? So eight years prior to whenever he stopped
flying.

Q. '98/'99?
A. Yeah, I guess, yes.
Q. I mean, that sounds like a right
A. Sounds about right, yeah. Don't hold me to it
again.

Q. All right.
A. You're going back a long way.
Q. So from approximately the '98/'99 time frame
when Jeffrey Epstein would fly to Little St. James,
would you be the pilot?

A. Yes.
Q. Okay. And you say that you've been there -- I
thought that you just told me that you've been there the
same time he was there, but then I thought the
subsequent question was well, were you on the flight
with him, and I thought your answer was no. Maybe I
misunderstood that.

A. No, you said the question "Have you ever flown
3527-003
Page 50 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
to his island?" We never landed on his island. We
landed in St. Thomas.

Q. Got it.
A. I was just trying to be exact.
Q. Thank you.
A. It's a small island.
Q. Okay. So how is it that when Mr. Epstein
"ants to go to Little St. James, what is the path that
take to get actually to the island of Little

St. James?
A. I don't understand the question.
Q. Well, you just told me you fly the airplane to
St. Thomas?

A. Right.
Q. And then what?
A. Then sometimes I would go get the helicopter
or he could also take a boat to the island. But
normally the helicopter's located on St. Thomas. I'd
fire up the helicopter, come pick him up, drop him at
the island and I come back to St. Thomas.

Q. And when he stays on St. James, you drop him
off on St. James. I suppose you're going to tell me you
don't know if he stays there or not?

A. Exactly.
Q. But do you stay --
3527-003
Page 51 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
A. I don't. I mean --

Q. Well, he either stays there or someone else
picks him up in a helicopter or he swims away?
A. Correct.

Q. Okay. You stay on St. Thomas?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Is there a place that you've stayed on
St. James, ever?

A. No, I've never.
Q. So in the hundred or more times that you've
been to the island, is it my understanding that each of
those times you've been there to drop off Jeffrey
Epstein and/or any passengers and you've immediately
left and gone to St. Thomas?

A. Yes, sir.
Q•
You never been inside that home that's located
on St. James?
A. Yes, I've been inside the home.

Q. How many times have you been inside the home?
A. I mean, ten, fifteen times.
Q. And for what occasion?

A. I've set up the theater system that's in the
living room.
Q. Okay.
A. So it would be there to work to hook up a TV
3527-003
Page 52 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
or a stereo.
Q • And do you know Les Wexler?

A. No, I don't.
Q. Have you ever met him before?
A. I have met him.
Q. Do you know of any relationship between Les
Wexler and Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I don't know what -- to what extent they have
a relationship, no.
Q • Do you know if they know one another?

A. I don't know that for a fact. They talk to
one another, so I would assume. But I don't know to --
Q • How do you know they talk to one another?

A. I've seen them speak to one another at the
foot of the airplane.
Q. All right. Have you ever flown the
airplane any of the airplanes with Les Wexler as a
passenger?

A. No.
Q. Have you ever flown the airplanes with -
as a passenger?
A. Yes.
Q. And do you know
A. Yes.
Q. And for how long have you known
3527-003
Page 53 of 227
EFFA_00009728
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. I'm guessing, six years. I mean, don't hold
me to it. I'm not the greatest on length of times, but
six, seven years, I think.

Q. How did you meet her?
A. I guess I was introduced. She was on a flight
of ours
Q. You were introduced to her by whom?

A. She may have introduced herself. I mean,
you're going back a ways. I don't know the official
introduction, how it went.

Q. And to your knowledge, what is her -- is she
associated or affiliated in some way with Jeffrey
Epstein?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I would assume so. I don't know
to what level or what actually her job description
is
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. All right. Well, how many flights have you
flown where she and Jeffrey Epstein have been passengers
together on one of the airplanes that we've been
discussing?

A. I'd only be guessing again.
Q. We're talking hundreds of flights, though?
A. Sure, sure, a lot of flights.
3527-003
Page 54 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. It seems to be -- I mean, you seem like
somebody who has common sense. It seems like somebody
that knows Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Correct,
A. Yes.
Q. All right. And do you believe that there is a
business relationship there or a personal relationship
there, from your observations?

A. I'd only be speculating. When they get on the
airplane, my focus is forward and flying safely. So I
don't -- you know, I'd only be guessing at either one of
those two.

Q. Okay. Have you ever socialized with
A. No.
Q. Other than speaking with her on the airplane,
have you spoken with her elsewhere?

A. Over the phone, in passing, I mean, walking
down the street in New York. I mean, yes.
Q. Why would you call or why would
she call you?

A. She would call me to schedule the aircraft for
a departure.
3527-003
Page 55 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. And have you ever called her?
A. Yes.
O. When's the last time you talked to
A. A week ago.
O. What was the occasion?

A. We were discussing carpet for one of the
aircraft.
Q. And where was she when you were talking with
her?
for?

A. I don't know. It was over the phone.
Q. Did she call you or you call her?
A. No, I called her on her cell.

Q. Okay. And that's a New York number?
A. I don't know. It's on speed dial.
Q. Do you have your phone with you?

A. Yes.
Q. Could you tell me what that number is?
A. Sure.
Q. Thanks.
A. Sure.
Q. Which airplane were you discussing carpeting

A. Was actually -- actually, it was for the
helicopter. Now that I'm thinking about it, the
3527-003
Page 56 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
helicopter.

Q. In the last two years, did you tell me the
helicopter has flown?
A. Yes.
O. And where to?
A. I have flown the helicopter to Fort Lauderdale
on several occasions for maintenance. I've flown it to
Miami. And I try to fly the helicopter at least every
two weeks just either by myself to run it up to its --
it's important that it keeps moving.

Q. Other than maintenance -type flights, have you
flown the helicopter in the last couple of years?
A. Yes.

Q. And who was on the helicopter?
A. I flew to Miami with Mr. Epstein.
Q. When was that?
A. It was a couple weeks ago or a month ago, I
think.

Q. For what?
A. Sorry?
Q. For what occasion?
A. I think he had a meeting with his attorneys in
Miami.
Q • Today is October the 15th. Is this during the
month of October that you had this flight in the
3527-003
Page 57 of 227
EFFA_00009732
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
helicopter with Mr. Epstein?
you.

A. I'd have to look at the book to be exact for
Q.
Okay. But it's either the end of September or
the beginning of October?

A. Yeah.
Q. How do you know that he was meeting with his
attorneys?
A. I believe that he had mentioned that he was
meeting his attorneys.

Q. Did he tell you why?
A. No.
Q. Why did he tell you he was meeting with his
attorneys? Did you ask him?

A. No.
Q. Okay. That's just something that he said to
you in conversation?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was there anyone else on the airplane besides
you and Mr. Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. Who was that?
A.
Q. who?
A.
3527-003
Page 58 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. How long have you known

A. I don't know, five years. A guess again,
four, five years.
Q. Do you know what her relationship is, if any,
with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I do not know.
Q. Do you know if she knows Jeffrey Epstein?
A. I would assume so. They talk. I would
imagine she knows him.

Q. And how many times has she been on the
airplane or the helicopter on flights at the same time
as a passenger with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Many. I'd have to look at the logs.
Q. Hundreds of times?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Sure.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. If you were going to, as somebody who has been
Jeffrey Epstein's pilot for 18 years, tell me today who
the five closest people are to Jeffrey Epstein, would
be one of them?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I'd only be guessing and
speculating. I have no idea.
3527-003
Page 59 of 227
EFFA_00009734
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. Well, as his pilot and the person who
travels with Jeffrey Epstein on the majority of his
flights, who are the people who travel most frequently
with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I'd have to look at the logs.
MR. REINHART: Can we get a time period?
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. In the last ten years, which people travel
most frequently with him?

A. I'd have to look at the flight logs to give
you an accurate answer.
Q. You can't give me one single name of somebody
who you would say is a frequent flyer?
A.
Q.

A. Yes.
Q. Anybody else?
A.
Q.
A. Yeah.
Q. Okay. Anybody else?
A. Just mainly those two.
Q. How about Ghislaine Maxwell?

A. Not for some time.
3527-003
Page 60 of 227
EFFA_00009735
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. What's your understanding between the
relationship of Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I don't really know.
Q. All right. So when you say you're guessing
that and know or are
associated with Jeffrey Epstein, that guess is being
made on the -- with the observation that they have been
frequent flyers with Jeffrey Epstein on more than
hundreds of flights on his private plane?

A. Yes, that's what I'm basing it on.
Q. And do you know where is
staying these days?
A. No.
Q. Do you know what car she's driving these days?

A. No, I don't.
Q. Okay. Do you know if she's living with
Jeffrey Epstein these days?
A. I don't know that.

Q. Do you know how met Jeffrey
Epstein?
A. I don't.
Q. Were you on an international flight bringing
her into the country from some other country at any
time?

A. I don't know.
3527-003
Page 61 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
MR. REINHART: Can we clarify? You mean with

Mr. Epstein or --
MR. EDWARDS: No.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
0. Did you ever bring from some
foreign country into the United States?

A. I'd have to look at the log books, honestly.
Q. That's not something you remember?
A. No. I mean, she -- I think she's been on
Europe trips with us, and I think she's returned from
Europe with us, but I could not say that honestly.

Q. On this recent helicopter flight with
and Jeffrey Epstein, did you talk with them
during that flight?

A. No.
Q. Where did the flight go from? And obviously,
it landed in Miami, but where did you leave from?

A. West Palm Beach.
Q. And did and Jeffrey Epstein arrive
together?
A. You know, I don't remember. I was out at the
helicopter and I think they both started walking up. So
I don't know if they came separately or not. I was
already at the helicopter.

Q. How long is that flight from Palm Beach to
3527-003
Page 62 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Miami?

A. Twenty-five minutes.
Q. And did they talk to one another during that
flight?
A. No.
Q. They were both completely silent during that
flight?

A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Is that typical when they are on
flights together, especially with the helicopter, where
you're in pretty close quarters, that they would abstain
from speaking to one another?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Yeah, it would be typical. It's
very noisy and communicating in a helicopter is,
you know, not that comfortable.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Over the last five or six years that you have
known or been familiar with , have you
heard her and Jeffrey Epstein conversing with one
another?

A. I've heard them conversing, but if you ask me
what they had said, I could say it -- I wouldn't even
know what they had said to each other. I've seen them
talking to each other.
3527-003
Page 63 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. But you don't remember a single specific
conversation between Jeffrey Epstein and
A. An honest answer, no.

Q. Okay. And the same for ; have you
seen or have you seen Jeffrey Epstein speak with
A. I've seen him speak with her, yes.

Q. Can you tell me a single specific conversation
that you have overheard between Jeffrey Epstein and
A. One thing that comes to mind would be make
sure we have Oreo cookies on the airplane. It would be
something completely nonchalant.
Q • Okay. And do you know or have reason to know
of any employment relationship between and
Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I have no knowledge of any of that.
Q. Do you know if works for Jeffrey
Epstein?
A. I do not know.
Q. Do you know if schedules massages
for Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I have no idea.
Q • Has Jeffrey Epstein ever indicated to you that
3527-003
Page 64 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
he is fascinated or infatuated or appreciates or loves
or likes massages?

A. I have no knowledge of that.
Q. All right. How about Ghislaine Maxwell, has
she ever talked to you about massage therapy or have you
ever overheard her talking about that?

A. No.
Q. You certainly read the papers over the last
couple of years, correct?
A. Not on my top ten list. I mean, I've read a
couple articles, but I'm not one to focus on that so
much as some people would.

Q. Okay. When the investigation about Jeffrey
Epstein came about, the criminal investigation -- you're
aware that's what I'm talking about, right?

A. That was last year?
Q. Well, it was a couple years ago.
A. Right, okay.
Q. Did you speak with Jeffrey Epstein about that
investigation?

A. No.
Q. Were you told not to speak with him about that
investigation?
A. I think we knew ourselves that we weren't --
it wouldn't be proper to even bring it up.
3527-003
Page 65 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. All right. When you read in the newspapers
ehe allegations that Mr. Epstein was involved with
numerous underage girls for sexual reasons, were you
surprised?

A. I didn't believe it.
Q. Do you believe it today?
A. I don't believe it.
Q. You don't believe that Jeffrey Epstein was
involved with underage girls in a sexual way?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: You're asking for my opinion,
and I don't think my opinion is relevant in that
matter.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. I think it's relevant. Can you just tell me
whether today you believe that Jeffrey Epstein has
engaged in sex with underage girls?

MR. CRITTON: Form; speculation, irrelevant,
always.
THE WITNESS: It's irrelevant.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. I need an answer.

A. I don't believe he had sex with underage
women.
Q. Or engaged in any sexual acts with underage
3527-003
Page 66 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
women?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: No.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. You think that this is just a story that a
bunch of underage women have made up?

A. Speculation.
MR. CRITTON: Objection. Now it's
argumentative. Who gives a darn what he thinks one
way or another? If he has personal knowledge --

MR. EDWARDS: You're objecting to the form?
MR. CRITTON: It's argumentative.
MR. EDWARDS: You're objecting to the form?

MR. CRITTON: Yes.
MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Is that something that you believe that a
bunch of women -- some of which know each other, some
don't, some of which have been on the airplane and some
which haven't -- made this up, that Jeffrey Epstein
engaged in some sexual conduct with them?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: What I believe doesn't matter in
this case, does it?
3527-003
Page 67 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. I need an answer. Do you believe it? Do you
believe these girls made this up?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
MR. REINHART: I'm going to instruct him not
to answer. Move on.

MR. EDWARDS: Is there a privilege that we're
asserting?
MR. REINHART: No, it's irrelevant. It's
harassment and not likely to lead to discoverable
evidence.

MR. EDWARDS: I'm going to put on the record
right now that it is -- we are allowed discovery
into a RICO count. We are also allowed discovery
into the intent of Mr. Epstein in developing a
criminal enterprise designed to sexually exploit
and sexually abuse underage girls. We believe that
in doing so, he associated intentionally with
people of similar beliefs that sex with underage
girls is okay, and that there have been many
discussions with this witness, as well as many
other witnesses with -- to insure his protection
from law enforcement that they not answer these
specific questions. And thus, the opinions and
beliefs of all of these witnesses that we are
3527-003
Page 68 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
alleging associated with this criminal enterprise
are certainly reasonably calculated to lead to the
discovery of admissible evidence. And if you're
still instructing the witness, based on that
proffer, not to answer any of these questions, I'm
going to continue to ask the questions and you can
instruct him not to answer and we can go to the
Court.

MR. REINHART: My response is to his opinion
whether people making allegations in this case are
colluding or making up a story is irrelevant to
what you just said. So I am going to instruct him
not to answer any question that goes to his opinion
of someone else's motivation or the truth of facts
to which he has no knowledge.
So yes, I'm instructing him not to answer.

MR. CRITTON: Let me add in my part, is that I
think -- you're certainly not only capable to ask
questions with regard to what his personal
knowledge is, and if he knows something or he has
reasonable basis for it; certainly you are entitled
to that information. I think you've asked those
questions and he's given you straightforward
answers as to what he knew or what he didn't know
under those circumstances. And as to what his
3527-003
Page 69 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
thoughts are on something which he has no factual
basis or even an assumption to know one way or
another is irrelevant. That's ultimately for a
fact -finder in this case.
While it's interesting, it's argumentative and
I don't think he's -- I mean, do it on a
question -by -question basis. If he has knowledge,
that's great, but to argue your case with this
witness or any other witness doesn't serve a
purpose and I think is, you know -- I think it's
not a good use of our time, I'll put it that way.
But you know, you can go ahead and ask.

MR. EDWARDS: I can ask the question and if
the witness is being instructed not to answer,
we'll let a judge decide whether he needs to answer
the question and whether it's discoverable or not.

MR. REINHART: Absolutely. Make your record.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Do you have any reason to believe that Jeffrey
Epstein engaged in sexual activity with underage women?

A. I have no reason to believe.
Q. Okay. So as you sit here today, based on your
18 years of knowledge, experience and observation of
Jeffrey Epstein, is it your belief that he has not had
sex or engaged in sexual activity with underage women?
3527-003
Page 70 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. It's an opinion, and I believe that he has
not.
Q. Okay. Isn't it true that at some point in
time you learned that Jeffrey Epstein has -- strike
that.

MR. CRITTON: When you ultimately get to a
good place to break, will you let us know?
MR. EDWARDS: Let's break now.
(A break was had at 11:28 a.m.)
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. All right. Eighteen years of being a pilot
for Jeffrey Epstein and in terms of being able to name
somebody that you would say you've observed with Jeffrey
Epstein and would classify that person as Jeffrey
Epstein's friend, can you name anybody?

A. ; just people that we see
routinely on the airplane.
Q. That's people you see routinely in the last
five to ten years, right?

A. Yes.
Q. Prior to that time, anybody that you've
noticed as Jeffrey Epstein's friend may be Ghislaine
Maxwell?

A. What time frame?
Q. Is that a person that at some point in time
3527-003
Page 71 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
would classify as Jeffrey Epstein's friend?

A. I would classify it. I don't know if it's
true.
Q. But that's only because they were on the
airplane together?
6 I A. Yes.
7I Q. Do you know what Jeffrey Epstein does for a
8 living in your 18 years of observing and talking with
9 Jeffrey Epstein?
10 A. No.
11 Q. No idea?
12 A. No.
13 Q. Ever asked him?
14 A. No, actually.
15 0. Ever been curious?
16 A. Sure.
17 Q. Ever done anything to satisfy that curiosity?
18 A. If you mean Google it, not really, actually.
19 I mean, I really have not.
20 Q. Okay. So in 18 years of traveling and being
21 the pilot and driving -- and taking this person, Jeffrey
22 Epstein, from one property in New York to New Mexico and
23 Florida and around the world, you have no idea what he
24 does in terms of how he makes money?
25 A. No, sir.
3527-003
Page 72 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. I was produced this flight log -- tell me if
I'm using the wrong term. What is this called, this
book that I've been provided by Dave Rogers?

A. I've never seen that book.
Q. I'll let you see it. I don't know that it was
always in a book, so maybe that's why you haven't seen

it. Tell me what we're looking at.
A. Well, judging with the name at the bottom, I
believe this is Dave's flight log, log book.

Q. I didn't know if it was called a flight log.
A. Pilot log book, how's that? That's the
appropriate name.

Q. It was marked as Composite Exhibit 1 in
Roger's deposition, as indicated by the exhibit sticker.
We'll mark it the same in your deposition as well.

MR. CRITTON: Why don't you refer to it as
his?
MR. EDWARDS: Fine.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. It's the pilot log book of Dave Rogers?

A. Yes.
Q. And the years provided in this book are 2002
through 2005; I can represent that to you. I'm going to
ask you about certain people that David Rogers wrote
down as being on the airplane and I want to ask you if
3527-003
Page 73 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
you know who they are. This person right here is
It seems like she flew on numerous flights. Do
you know who that is?

A. No. I heard the name, but I don't know who
that is.
Q. All right. Is that somebody that you remember
seeing on any of the flights that you were on?

A. What year are we talking about here? I don't
remember.
Q. Well, this is January 2002. You'd probably
know how to read this book a little bit better than me,
so I don't know.

A. He keeps his a lot more current, so I know the
name. If she walked in here right now, I would probably
look right through her, to be honest.

Q. Do you know what affiliation or relationship
she had with Jeffrey Epstein?
A. No.
Q. Okay. There are various -- each row I'm told
by David Rogers is a different flight and it indicates
where it takes off from and where it lands, et cetera.
There's a lot of other information, especially over on
this side of the page that I'm not familiar with, nor do
I need to be.

A. Right.
3527-003
Page 74 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. But it's evident that the plane is being used,
at least for this time period, January of 2002 through
2005, on a fairly regular basis. I mean, we're looking
at January 6th, 11th, 13th, 13th, 14th, right?

A. Uh-huh.
Q. I mean, is that something that you would say
accurately reflects the amount of use of Jeffrey
Epstein's planes?

A. Yes.
Q. So he travels quite frequently?
A. Yes.
Q.
right?
And he travels with many different people,

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
MR. CRITTON: Can I ask one question? I was
wondering what happened, who has possession of now
what's the original Exhibit No. 1 of Mr. Rogers'
deposition? Did you retain it?

MR. REINHART: The actual book itself?
MR. EDWARDS: The court reporter took it,
right?
MR. CRITTON: The one marked as an exhibit,
did you keep that?

MR. REINHART: This is it.
3527-003
Page 75 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
$
MR. EDWARDS: This is it?

MR. CRITTON: Who took it from the deposition
the other day?
MR. EDWARDS: I have this one right now.
MR. REINHART: That's the only copy?

MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
MR. CRITTON: So you took the original?
MR. EDWARDS: Apparently. It has the original
sticker.

MR. CRITTON: When I say "the original," the
original copy. Would you have someone recreate
what you've got and send it to us so we have it?

MR. EDWARDS: Sure. In fact, why don't I wait
until I get the whole thing and I'll copy all the
pages and send it to you instead of piecemeal.

MR. HOROWITZ: You mean before the transcript
comes?
MR. EDWARDS: We can copy it.
MR. CRITTON: If you give it to me, I'll copy
it and send it back to you.

MR. REINHART: I have a copy. It just doesn't
have the exhibit sticker on.
MR. EDWARDS: That's what was told to me the
other day, that's why I took it.

MR. CRITTON: I want something -- I just don't
3527-003
Page 76 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
want to -- if you give me a copy, I'll put a
sticker on it.

MR. REINHART: Or just copy the page that has
the exhibit sticker on it.
MR. CRITTON: Sorry.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Like on this flight, we have "JE." I'm
assuming that's Jeffrey Epstein, correct?
A. Yes, I'll assume.

Q. "GM," Ghislaine Maxwell, right?
A. Yes.
Q. ,
A. I would assume.
Q. I mean -- okay. And then this name, do you
recognize that person,

A. Never heard it.
Q. And then
A. Yes.
Q. You've heard that name?
A. I've heard the name.
Q. Not sure who that is, though?

A. No.
O. There's only one, two, three, four, five, six
people on that flight?
A. Uh-huh.
3527-003
Page 77 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. That's pretty typical of the amount of
passengers that you would have on a flight?
A. It varied, sure.

Q. Okay. But it varied between -- if we look a
few lines down, Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell
were the only two passengers. Certainly there were
flights like that as well, right?

A. Mm-hmm.
Q. And so it varied from having one or two people
to six or seven people, right?
A. Yes.
Q. What's the most people that you remember
traveling on any of Jeffrey Epstein's airplanes?

A. Twenty-five.
Q. Okay. That would be a rarity, wouldn't you
say?
A. Oh, yeah.
Q. Because I've looked through this log. I
haven't seen any place where there were 25, but there
are lines that have maybe eight or nine people listed.

A. Right.
Q. Let's see. There's a flight from
January 15th sorry, January 17th, January 20th and
January 22nd of 2002 that all had . That
doesn't serve to refresh your recollection as to who
3527-003
Page 78 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
that is, does it?

A. No.
Q. Okay. Do you know what the purpose of her
being on the airplane flight along with Jeffrey Epstein,
Ghislaine Maxwell and would be?

A. No.
Q. Okay. Do you know how it comes about that
gets on that flight? How does she even know
there's a flight available?

A. I don't know.
Q. All right. Well, let's go down to somebody
that we may all know a little bit better. February 9th,
2002, there's a flight that has Bill Clinton, four
Secret Service agents and then instead of listing names
or initials or anything else, it's just listed as two
males, one female, Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell,
and I forget who Dave Rogers told me "AP"

is. Do you remember who that is?
A. No.
Q. Okay. Either way, how is it that someone like
Bill Clinton gets on a Jeffrey Epstein flight?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't know.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Do you know before the flight takes off that
3527-003
Page 79 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Bill Clinton's going to be a passenger on the flight?

A. Yes.
Q. And how do you know? How do you get that
information?
A. The day before I'd get a phone call from, say,
saying we're leaving tomorrow going to wherever,
and sometimes she'll say who's going, sometimes she
won't. On a case where President Clinton would be on
board, we would put a little extra catering on board or
do that little extra TLC to the aircraft.

Q. If it's leaving -- this says it's leaving from
MIA and where is it landing?
A. HPN I believe is White Plains.

Q. Okay. Do you remember that flight?
A. I remember being on it.
Q. Well, I mean, if you look through here,
obviously you had Bill Clinton on the airplane ten or
twenty times, right?

A. Yeah. He's my main focus. I remember him
being on the aircraft, sure.
Q. Do you remember him being on the airplane with
younger girls?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: No.
3527-003
Page 80 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. Do you know what his relationship was
with Jeffrey Epstein?
A. No.
Q. Do you know if they were friends?

A. Assuming.
Q. But you're assuming why? Just because he's on
his plane?
A. Yeah.
Q. Okay. So you assume that the people that are
listed on here are friends of Jeffrey Epstein's and
that's why they are riding on his plane?

A. I'm speculating.
Q. I'm just not familiar with the -- because I've
never been on a private flight -- with the manner in
which you go about getting on one of these flights. I
mean, you have to, I guess, know that Jeffrey Epstein
has a plane, that it's going from a destination that you
are at and want to go to, and that it's available and
those kind of things. Can you tell me, enlighten me --

A. Well, it's not publicly offered, no. It would
be no different than you jumping in your car and knowing
you're going to the mall. I mean, it's not public
information, you know, where planes are coming to and
from, and you don't put your name out there to get
3527-003
Page 81 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
onboard a flight.

Q. Does Jeffrey Epstein charge these people as
passengers?
A. I don't know.
Q. Okay. Are these people such as Bill Clinton,
does that mean that Bill Clinton called or
somebody affiliated with Jeffrey Epstein to get on the
plane or that Jeffrey Epstein called Bill Clinton and
asked do you want a ride?

MR. CRITTON: Form; predicate.
THE WITNESS: I have no idea.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. No idea?
A. No idea whatsoever.

Q. Joe Pagano, do you know who that is?
A. Yes.
Q. What's his relationship with Jeffrey Epstein,
or what was it back in February -- sorry, March 17th of
2002, when he and and Jeffrey Epstein and
Todd and one female were on this flight?

A. I don't know to what extent or what his
relationship is. He just was a passenger on the
airplane.
Q. Okay. And the next day -- sorry, two days
later on the 19th of March, Bill Clinton flies again,
3527-003
Page 82 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
this time with Doug Band, three Secret Service agents,
Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell and . Do
3 you remember that flight?
4 A. Where did we go?
5 0. Starts in JFK.
6 A. Right.
7 Q. Where is that?
8 MR. CRITTON: Do you have a date?
9 MR. EDWARDS: March 19th, 2002.
10 THE WITNESS: EGGW I believe is Luton,
11 England.
12 BY MR. EDWARDS:
13 Q. Okay. Do you remember flying to England?
14 A. I do remember flying to England. I just don't
15 remember that trip. What airplane were we in? We were
16 in the Boeing.
17 Q. Do you remember the purpose of the trip?
18 A. No.
19 Q. Do you know who Doug Band is?
20 A. I heard he's Clinton's, how would you say,
21 assistant. I mean, I've seen that in the newspaper,
22 seen it on CNN.
23 Q. Okay. Did you ever hear that Doug Band and
24 Ghislaine Maxwell were together, even for a day or a
25 night?
3527-003
Page 83 of 227
EFFA_00009758
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
.7

A. No.
Q. Did you ever hear that Doug Band and Ghislaine
Maxwell were the people attributed to introducing Bill
Clinton and Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't know.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. All right. There's another flight here on
January -- I can't read this upside down. Maybe it says
May

A. Looks like.
Q. 22nd, 2002. Again, with President Bill
Clinton, Can you tell me who
and are?
A. I don't remember.

Q. Would you know them if you saw them?
A. Probably not because the names don't even ring
a bell.
Q. All right. And then there are plenty of
flights, many of flights where Jeffrey Epstein,
Ghislaine Maxwell and are the primary
passengers, or at least are some of the passengers on
the flights, correct?

A. Mm-hmm, yes.
Q. And still, as you sit here, you being the
3527-003
Page 84 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
pilot of these flights, you're not sure what their
relationship is or whether any of them were socially
connected in any real way?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: No. When you're flying the
airplane, there's a lot more going on than
passengers' relations.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q • All right. You remember this person,
, are you familiar with her at all?

A. I remember the name, that's it.
Q. What do you think her relationship is to
Jeffrey Epstein?
A. No idea.

MR. CRITTON: What date are you on, Brad?
MR. EDWARDS: Oh, sorry. I am at June 21st,
2002.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. That's not somebody that you specifically
remember?
A. Mm -mm, no.
Q. No? Is that somebody that you think was a
regular flyer for any period of time in Jeffrey
Epstein's life?

A. Not a regular.
3527-003
Page 85 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. Okay. Jean Luc Brunel, is that a name that
you know?

A. Yes.
Q. How do you know that name?
A. Only because it's a unique name and his attire
is very unique. So you remember certain things. So I
know he who that is.

Q. Do you know what he does?
A. No.
Q. Do you know his association with Jeffrey
Epstein, if any?
A. No, I don't know what the relationship is.

Q. Have you ever heard of him owning or running
or managing a modeling company?
A. I have seen that in the paper a few years
back.

Q. Okay. Other than seeing it in the paper, have
you ever talked to Jean Luc Brunel or Jeffrey Epstein
about owning or running or managing a modeling company?

A. No.
Q. Do you know if Jeffrey Epstein's affiliated
with the modeling company that's owned, run or managed
by Jean Luc Brunel?

A. No, I have no idea.
Q. And seeing that this is a flight now, that
3527-003
Page 86 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
we're referring to the same flight on June 21st of 2002,
that includes Jean Luc Brunel, , Jeffrey
Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, -• those are the
passengers of this flight, does that serve to jog your
memory as to who is?

A. No. I mean, you see how frequently we fly. I
mean, it's -- the passengers in the back are so far
removed from an operation of commanding an airplane like
that, it's nothing that sticks in your head.

Q. And you as the pilot, is there any way that
you would know what's going on in the back of the
airplane?

A. No. My concerns are all on the cockpit.
MR. CRITTON: Brad, the last one that you
mentioned, was that the same date, June 21st, '02?

MR. EDWARDS: Yes.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. There's another name here that I was going to
ask you do you know. June 23rd, 2002,
are you familiar with that name?

A. No.
Q. Also on the same flight with Jean Luc Brunel.
That doesn't help to jog your memory either, right?

A. No.
Q. That's somebody that you remember as a
3527-003
Page 87 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
frequent passenger?

A. Who are you referring to?
Q.
A. No.
Q. Dr. Jarecki, is that somebody that you
remember flying?
A. I know the name. He may have been on the
airplane once or twice. I'm guessing only.

Q. Do you remember meeting him?
A. Yes, I have met him.
Q. Do you remember his purpose for being on the
airplane?

A. No, sir.
Q. Amanda Venaro, do you remember her purpose for
being on the airplane?
A. No.
MR. REINHART: Can we get a date?

MR. EDWARDS: I was asking him if he
remembered Amanda Venaro. I wasn't referring to a
specific flight.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. You don't remember her being on the flight?
A. I don't remember the name.
Q. Me showing you the flight isn't going to jog
the memory?
3527-003
Page 88 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. No. The name that would launch it first --
MR. CRITTON: Could I ask you a question? You
have the original exhibit marked at the deposition.
It looks like it's been highlighted.

MR. EDWARDS: I highlighted it.
MR. CRITTON: Oh, okay. So you've highlighted
the original exhibit that's marked for the
deposition? I just want the record to reflect
that.

MR. EDWARDS: Yeah.
MR. CRITTON: Okay. Thank you.
MR. EDWARDS: At the time I highlighted it I
didn't realize I was holding on to the original
exhibit. I didn't realize that until you just
pointed that out.

MR. CRITTON: I've noticed that.
MR. EDWARDS: So now when I give it to you,
I'm giving you my work product as well. I don't
see how this works against you, but anyway.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Melissa Stall, is that a name that you
remember?
A. No.
Q. Okay. And then Jean Luc Brunel is somebody
who I noticed flew relatively frequently, so is that why
3527-003
Page 89 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
you -- that name jogs your memory a little better than
some of these other people?

A. He dresses uniquely.
Q. In what way?
A. Just loud clothes, so something that you would
remember, that's all.

Q. Do you know his role in Jeffrey's life?
A. No.
Q. Ever heard that he is affiliated with Jeffrey
Epstein because they both have a sexual attraction to
underage girls?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: You're making an assumption on
that.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Have you ever heard that?

MR. REINHART: He's asked you if you ever
heard that.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. If your answer is no, it's no.
A. I'm sorry, I thought you said they did. No, I
have not.

Q. Okay. I keep highlighting this name,
, just because it looks like somebody that's
regularly flying on the airplane. But the more that you
3527-003
Page 90 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
see her name, that doesn't change your opinion as to
whether or not you remember her or what --

A. I remember the name, you know, that's all.
Q. Do you remember about what age she was when
she was flying on the airplane?

A. No.
Q. This could be somebody who is 50 years old or
ten years old, for all you know?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay.
A. I mean, I would only be guessing at an age.
Q. Yeah, but I mean, you don't remember her at
all. So you don't --

A. I remember the name, exactly.
Q. Other than the name?
A. Right, yes, sir.
Q. But you can't even come close to putting a
face with that name?

A. I mean, no. I mean, if you said draw her
picture with -- I couldn't come close to even getting
it.
Q. Okay. You remember this flight where
President Clinton, Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker,
3527-003
Page 91 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell?

A. Yes.
Q. From JFK to what is this, LPAZ?
A. LPAZ, that is --
Q • South Africa or something?
A. No, it's the Azores Islands, Santa Maria.

Q. Do you know the purpose of that trip?
A. That was a fuel stop.
Q. Okay. And do you know why Chris Tucker and
Kevin Spacey were on that airplane?

A. No.
Q. Did you talk to them?
A. They came up in the cockpit and said hello.
So they conversed, nothing more.

Q. Another name that is on here a few times, I'm
specifically referring right now to the dates of
September 23rd and 24th of 2002, is Ron Burkle. Do you
<now who that is, Ron Burkle?

A. I know what that is, yes. I didn't realize he
was on our airplane.
Q. Right now that is the first time that you
remember Ron Burkle being on your airplane?

A. Yeah.
Q. You don't know the purpose for him being on
that airplane?
3527-003
Page 92 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. No. Granted, I'm seeing this for the first
time, so I'm trying to --
Q. Let me ask you that. Because this was given
to me at a deposition of Dave Rogers, who I understand
was the chief pilot for Mr. Epstein, and now you're the
cheap pilot, but you always kind of worked in tandem,
correct?

A. Sure; we complemented each other.
Q. And you both worked for the same company that
flies Jeffrey Epstein's airplanes, right?

A. Yes.
Q. So I was of the presumption, which may have
been -- I may have been misled here, or I may have, you
know, misunderstood the purpose behind this book or how
it was created. I thought that you had probably seen
this before at some point in time?

A. Oh, no.
Q. Did you know that Dave Rogers was keeping this
book?
A. No. I know he keeps a pilot log book.

Q. Okay. But you didn't know he was keeping the
names of the people who were on the airplane?
A. No. It's not required, so I mean, it's. ..

Q. So today is the first time that you are
learning that the names of the people that are on the
3527-003
Page 93 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
airplane was kept by Dave Rogers?

A. Yes, in his log book.
Q. Okay. And it's my understanding when you fly
back into the country through Customs, you have to
report the people that are on the airplane, right?

A. Yes.
Q. And who would create that document or call
that information into Customs?
A. Whoever the captain was for the day.

Q. At times would that be you?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. And at times when you would come into
the country with passengers -- well, not at times.
Didn't you also have to report their date of birth?

A. Sure.
Q. At times weren't there also people that you
would bring in from other countries into the United
States that were under the age of 18?

A. Yes.
Q. And at some times those were flights that
included Jean Luc Brunel and girls that were under the
age of 18, right?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't remember those flights.
3527-003
Page 94 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. You don't remember which flights it
would have been where there would have been girls under
the age of 18?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Well, I would have to look at
the flight logs.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. It's not illegal to have somebody under the
age of 18 on a flight anyway, right?

A. No, not at all.
Q. Were you ever aware that you, as pilot, were
transporting girls under the age of 18 who were supposed
to be models?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I had no knowledge.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Okay. You never knew who the people on the
airplane were, what their purpose was, their role with
Jeffrey
A.
Q.
A.
Q.
A.
Epstein or Jean Luc Brunel?
No.
All right. Do you know
No, I don't remember that name.
I remember the name.
3527-003
Page 95 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. She flew frequently at least for a period of
time. Do you remember that?
A. Yes.
Q. Is that somebody that you thought was familiar
with the modeling industry or related to the modeling
industry?

A. No.
Q. Okay. And these people, did Jeffrey Epstein
ever tell you how he was associated with any of them?

A. No.
Q. Did you ever wonder how he was associated with
any of them?
A. No, never interested.
Q. And on several of these -- on most of these,
the names or initials of the people that are on the
flight are listed. Do you know on the occasions where
it lists generically two females or three females or six
females, do you know why that was done?

A. Just because we didn't know our -- the
person's name. We tried to do the best we could to keep
the records.

Q. When you say "we tried to do the best that we
could" --
A. Dave and I.
Q. Okay. But the first time that you learned
3527-003
Page 96 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
that he kept anybody's names was today, right?

A. Well, I didn't know he kept them in his log
book. We would fill out the passenger manifest as
we're -- having passengers' names in your pilot log
book, he's probably the only person in the world that
does that.

Q. Okay.
A. So when you were mentioning putting the names
down, when you said female or male, you know, I was
referring to the passenger manifest.

Q. For each of these same flights, then, that
we're referring to out of this log book that was marked
as Composite Exhibit 1 in Dave Rogers' deposition, am I
understanding you correctly, then, there would also be a
passenger manifest for each of these flights?

A. Yes.
Q. Now, where would I find the passenger
manifest? Who keeps that documentation?
A. Corporate -- our corporate office.

Q. Which is whom?
A. Up in New York, Darren Indyke.
Q. At what corporation is that, though?
A. NES, LLC, I guess.

MR. REINHART: Do you know for sure?
THE WITNESS: I don't know for sure. I mean,
3527-003
Page 97 of 227
EFFA_00009772
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
when you say -- we would just send them up to New
York.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Did you ever keep a copy of them?
A. No.
Q. Why did you keep a passenger manifest?
A. Just for tracking of -- to have the times on
there for --

MR. REINHART: Can I confer with him on one
thing before you ask a question?
MR. EDWARDS: Yeah, yeah.
(Off the record discussion.)

MR. REINHART: Mr. Edwards, let him amend his
prior answer. I think he misunderstood the
question.
MR. EDWARDS: I don't know what question we're
amounting the answer to.

MR. REINHART: Let me clarify this way: As
the passenger manifests, they are corporate
documents of either JEGE or Hyperion Air, whatever
company owns the plane. Mr. Visoski has physical
custody of them. He retains them but they're not
his documents. They're the corporate documents.
So they're not in New York.
THE WITNESS: Those are the ones that I have
3527-003
Page 98 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
at the airport office that I had turned into
counsel that has the passenger names on them.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay.
A. It's called a passenger manifest.
Q. Okay.
MR. REINHART: Right.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. The passenger manifest, just so I understand
exactly what that is, tell me. Tell me in your own
words.

A. It's departure time, the city, the landing
time exactly and the passengers that would have been on
that flight.

Q. And at times on that passenger manifest would
you list also generically female or male?
A. Yes. That was the document I was referring to
stating that if we didn't know a person, we did not go
out of our way to find out a name. We just put in to
account for how many people were on the aircraft at that
time.

Q. Who is currently in the custody or control --
sorry. Who currently maintains or has possession of the
passenger manifest from 1998 through the present,
through today for those airplanes that you flew related
3527-003
Page 99 of 227
EFFA_00009774
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
to Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I currently have, which counsel has now, 2005,
I believe, until the present time. And the records
previous to that I believe were turned into counsel with
the previous investigation with Jack Goldberger's
office, I believe. I believe they maintain those
records.

Q. When you say "turned into counsel," there are
a lot of counsel involved here.
A. Jack Goldberger's office, I believe.

Q. When you say "the previous investigation,"
you're talking about the criminal investigation?
A. Exactly, yes, sir.

Q. And you're aware in that criminal
investigation, obviously, that Jeffrey Epstein pled
guilty to certain charges, correct?

A. From what I read, yes.
Q. Well, you did visit him in jail, right?
A. Yes. We didn't talk about that.

Q. Okay. You know in order to go to jail,
though, you have to be convicted of some crime, right?
MR. CRITTON: Form; argumentative.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. It wasn't like he was visiting the jail and
3527-003
Page 100 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
you were visiting and you happened to bump into each
other. You actually went to see him while he was an
inmate in jail?

A. Right, yes.
Q• Okay. So when we're talking about the
criminal investigation, we're talking about the criminal
investigation revolving around the allegations of
Jeffrey Epstein engaging in sex acts with minors?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. That's the criminal investigation you're
talking about, right?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't know the full definition
of really what happened there. I know that it was
something to do with solicitation of prostitution.
That's all I read.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. Were you aware that the allegations
revolved around underage girls or girls under the age of
18?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I was aware it revolved around
it, yes.
3527-003
Page 101 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Who first made you aware of that?
A. The newspaper.
Q. Were you ever questioned by the police?
A. I don't know who questioned me, actually. I
did have a questioning session, but I don't even
remember who questioned me.

Q. Where did that take place?
A. I don't remember.
Q. At your house?
A. No. I'm thinking it was Jack Goldberger's
office, or it may have been downtown at the Palm Beach
County Courthouse or something in that area there.

Q. Okay. So it either happened at an attorney's
office that represented --
A. Exactly, yeah, I think so.

Q. -- Jeffrey Epstein or the other side?
A. Yeah.
Q. And during that questioning, is that when you
turned over the passenger manifest from prior to 2005?

A. Yes.
Q. And you turned those manifests directly over
to Jack Goldberger?
A. Yes. Actually, I believe Dave Rogers did
that. I wasn't in possession of those records.
3527-003
Page 102 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. And for the passenger manifest prior to 2005,
how far do those passenger manifests go back in time?
A. They should go back, I guess, to 1991 or
whenever we started existence.

Q. And did you turn them over from 1991 all the
way through to 2005?
A. I don't know. I didn't turn them in. Dave
Rogers did.

Q. Are you in possession of a copy of any of
those materials?
A. No.
Q. I thought that, you know, ten minutes ago when
we were talking about this you said you had them back at
an office or --

A. That was the office, the airplane office,
which I've given to Bruce, which is the current log. He
is in possession of them now. I had possession of them.

Q. Okay. What he's in possession of -- just so I
know what documents are where, he's in possession of the
passenger manifests from 2005 through the present?

A. Correct.
Q. If I want to obtain the passenger manifests
from 1998 through 2005, that's something that I would
request from whom?
THE WITNESS: Help me out. That's --
3527-003
Page 103 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

MR. REINHART: If you know.
THE WITNESS: I don't know who possesses them
right now. They were turned into Jack Goldberger's
office a year and a half or two years ago.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. You started out by indicating that you sent
these passenger manifests, or a copy thereof, to Darren
Indyke or someone at NES, LLC; is that correct?

A. Correct.
Q. If I requested them from NES, LLC, that's
somebody at some point in time was in possession of all
the passenger manifests?

A. Sure.
Q. And NES, LLC's address is the one you gave me
at
A. I believe so. I don't know what address
they're using for that. I know that --

Q. But Darren Indyke's the attorney that I would
call --
A. Yes, sir.
Q. -- and he could probably steer me in the right
direction?

A. Yes.
MR. CRITTON: Form.
3527-003
Page 104 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Do you know

A. Yes.
Q. How do you know her?
A. She was on the airplane.
Q. How old is she?
A. I have no idea.
Q. Age range?

A. Twenty-eight.
Q. Now?
A. Yeah, 28, or maybe if not older now. She was
probably 28 probably, I guess. She was somebody in her
late 20s.

Q. So we're talking about 2003? That's what I'm
trying to understand.
A. I'm guessing.
Q. We're talking 2009 now. We're saying 28. By
that do you mean in 2003 she was 23 or 24 years old?

A. You're having me guess on her age.
Q. Yeah.
A. I mean, I can't be accurate.
Q. Somebody between 18 and 25?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. At the time you were seeing her back in --
3527-003
Page 105 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. If you want me to guess --
Q. No, I don't want you to guess.
A. I don't know then.
Q. Well, if I say between ten and fifty?

A. That's a range.
Q. If I say between ten and fifty, you're not
guessing there anymore. You know she's in there, right?

A. She's in the middle there, yeah.
Q • Okay. How can we narrow that down? We're
talking about somebody in her 20s?

A. In her 20s.
Q. At least that's what you believed?
A. Yes.
Q. All right. Is that somebody that you know to
be associated or friendly with Ghislaine Maxwell?

A. I don't know.
Q. Do you know what her relationship was to
Jeffrey Epstein or Ghislaine Maxwell?
A. No.

Q. Do you know where she is now?
A. No idea.
Q. When's the last time you talked to her?
A. I don't know. What date do you have on there?

Q. February 2003.
A. So, probably that long ago. I may have said
3527-003
Page 106 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
hello.

Q. That's somebody who was on the airplane
multiple times?
A. More than once. I mean, I have no account for
how many times.

Q. Well, I've asked you about a bunch of names,
most of which you don't really remember, but that's one
name you do remember.

A. Yeah, I remember the name, yeah.
Q. Okay. And that's somebody who you actually --
you would remember the face too?

A. I might remember Amy's face.
Q. All right. Do you remember why she would have
ever been on your airplane?

A. No idea.
Q. President Andres Postrana, at the time I guess
that was the president of Colombia back in February --
sorry, March 20th of 2003. Do you know who that is?

A. I don't remember him being on the airplane,
but I know who that is.
Q. Okay. He's on the airplane with Jeffrey
Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell, and Jean Luc
Brunel?

A. Where did we go?
Q. I'll let you look at it. I'm talking about
3527-003
Page 107 of 227
EFFA_00009782
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
this line, PEI, left out of Palm Beach?

A. Palm Beach to Nassau. I'm sorry, I don't
remember that one.
Q. When we're saying we're going down to Nassau,
is that a place that you frequently went to with the
airplane?

A. No, not at all.
Q. And is that a route that you would take for
the ultimate destination to be Little St. James?

A. No.
Q. If the ultimate destination was Little
St. James -- show me a flight where the ultimate
destination was Little St. James.

A. Yeah, right here. TIST, that's St. Thomas.
O. Okay. So on that flight that you just pointed
to, March 27th, 2003, we have Jeffrey Epstein,
again, Brent Tyndall -- do you know
who Brent Tyndall is?

A. Yes.
Q. And who is that?
A. I believe he was the chef.
Q. And (phonetic), is that
somebody you know to be a model these days?

A. I have no idea.
Q. Do you remember that flight?
3527-003
Page 108 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. No.
Q. Do you remember Naomi Campbell, picking her up
from St. Thomas along with Jean Luc Brunel?
A. I remember her being on board. I don't
remember the flight.

Q. Do you know Joel Pashcow?
A. Yes.
Q. How do you know him?
A. He was on the airplane.
Q. And is that somebody you knew at one point in
time to be a friend of Jeffrey Epstein's?

A. He was on the airplane. I don't know what the
relationship was.
Q. Do you know what the relationship is today?

A. No idea.
Q. How about Todd Mister, do you know what that
relationship is or was today?
A. No.
Q. Do you remember him?

A. No.
Q. Not at all?
A. I mean, I know the name. I don't know.
Q. Paula Epstein, do you know who that is?

A. Yes.
Q. Who is that?
3527-003
Page 109 of 227
EFFA_00009784
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
A. That's Jeffrey's mom.

Q. She's passed away?
A. Yes.
Q. At least that's your understanding, right?
A. That's what I heard, yes.

Q. Okay. , do you know her?
A. I know the name.
Q. Somebody who flew on the airplane with some
regularity?

A. Yes.
Q. And do you know her to be friends of Ghislaine
Maxwell or or Jeffrey Epstein?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I have no idea who she was
friends with.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. All right. Do you know what role she ever
played, if she played one, in Jeffrey Epstein's life?
A. No.

Q. All right. Glenn Dubin, are you familiar with
him?
A. Yes.
Q. How do you know Glenn Dubin?
A. I met him on the airplane.

Q. Outside of the airplane, have you ever seen
3527-003
Page 110 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
him around Jeffrey Epstein?

A. No.
4• All right.
A. No.
O. , do you know that name?
A. No.
O. She was on several flights. You don't
remember seeing her?

A. No.
Q. All right. And how about Alan Dershowitz, I'm
sure you know who that is?
A. Sure. He's famous.

Q. What was your understanding of Alan
Dershowitz's relationship with Jeffrey Epstein?
A. Never talked about it.

Q. Forrest Sawyer, do you know why he was on your
airplane?
A. Never heard the name, actually.
Q. Really?

A. No.
Q. Larry Summers?
A. I know the name. I don't remember flying him.
Q. Have you ever talked to Joe Fontanela?

A. Yes.
Q. How do you know him?
3527-003
Page III of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
A. He usually drops Jeffrey off at the airport.

Q. In fact, you've called him directly before,
right?
A. Yes.
Q. You still have his number?
A. I haven't -- yes, I think I still got it in my
memory.

Q. Okay. What is it?
A. It's been a few years. . It's
kind of an easy one.
MR. CRITTON: 917 is the first
THE WITNESS: Yes.

MR. CRITTON: Who was this for?
MR. REINHART: Joe, Joe Fontanela.
MR. EDWARDS: Fontanela.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Do you know his address, where he resides?
A. No, I don't.
Q. Do you know if he -- what his role is in
Jeffrey Epstein's life?

A. Not really. He just -- he drove the car.
Q. He drove what car?
A. The car up in New York.
Q. Okay. Do you know if he's a housekeeper up at
that house up in New York?
3527-003
Page 112 of 227
EFFA_00009787
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. I don't know what his role is.
Q. Have you ever worked for a company called Air
Ghislaine? Do you know that company?

A. Yes.
Q. Do you know what that company does?
A. No.
Q. Have you ever been an employee of that
company?

A. No.
Q. Do you know who runs that company?
A. No.
Q. Is Jeffrey Epstein associated with that
company?

A. I don't know.
Q. How have you heard of that company?
A. It's the company name that our registration
for the helicopters is under, Air Ghislaine.

Q. Is that somebody who's ever paid you, a
company who's ever paid you?
A. No.
Q. Do you know Igor Zinoviev?

A. Yes.
Q. How do you know him?
A. Met him on the airplane.
Q. What is your understanding of his affiliation
3527-003
Page 113 of 227
EFFA_00009788
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I don't know. He doesn't talk much.
Q. Okay. And Sandy Berger, do you know who that
is?
A. I don't know.

Q. Do you know any reason why you would have
flown him on the airplane?
A. I don't even know the name.
Q.

A. I know the name
Q. Somebody who flew on the plane pretty
regularly?
A. I would have to look at the logs. I think
we've had that name on several -- it's a common first
name. I'm not familiar really on who that is.

Q. What about , do you know who is?
Is that a name you ever heard?
A. Yes.
Q. Works up in the New York office or something?

A. Yes.
Q. Have you ever spoken with personally?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you know what she does for Jeffrey Epstein,
if anything?

A. I don't know exactly what her role is.
3527-003
Page 114 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. Do you know -- did you tell me, do you know
what Leslie Gruff does for Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I don't know her exact title.
Q. You talked to all of these individuals at some
point in time, either on the phone or in person, right?

A. Yes.
Q. And you don't know whether they play a role in
Jeffrey Epstein's life, or if they do, what they do?

A. Exactly.
Q. And how do you decide who you're going to call
for what reason?
A. For example? Can you be more specific?

Q. If you're going to make a telephone call and
you're going to talk to let's say Leslie Gruff, why
would you choose to call her?

A. I don't know. You're having me make the phone
call. I don't know why I would call her.
Q • Have you ever called her?

A. I think, yes, I've called her, sure.
Q. Why? What would be the reason that you would
call her? Somebody told you to call her? Here, call
this number?

A. I may have called her maybe to find out if we
had a departure time for any specific trip. I mean,
that would be. ..
3527-003
Page 115 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Okay. So you're calling her related to
Jeffrey Epstein?
A. Sure.
Q. Okay. So you know that she plays some role in
some aspect of Jeffrey Epstein's life, whatever that is?

A. Right.
Q. Okay. So when I'm asking these questions
about these people, and I feel like I'm getting answers
that I'm not really not sure that these people have any
role in their life, that's not -- that's not completely
accurate, right?

MR. CRITTON: Form; argumentative.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. I mean, you do know that these people are
somehow involved with him, whether socially or
business -wise or otherwise, and during the course of
your years, you've made telephone calls on his behalf or
to coordinate things with them right?

A. Right.
MR. CRITTON: Object to the form. You said
'these people.'
BY MR. EDWARDS:
O. I'm talking about . That's
somebody you called before, right?

A. Sure.
3527-003
Page 116 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. What would be a reason you called
MR. CRITTON: Object to form. Probably the
same reasons he said two hours ago, for scheduling
purposes. But you've covered that. Go ahead and
answer it again.
THE WITNESS: For scheduling purposes, would
be my only reason to call her.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. That's funny that you used the exact same
words that Mr. Critton wants you to use.
MR. CRITTON: It's what he said two hours ago.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. What would be the reason why you would call
Ms. Maxwell, Ghislaine Maxwell?
A. Same reason.
Q. That's not somebody you call these days,
though, right?

A. I haven't seen her in some time.
Q. What made you stop calling Ghislaine Maxwell
where you thought at one point in time you thought she
was a person to call related to your job?

A. Just was no reason to.
Q. Is that somebody who you think is still
affiliated or associated with Jeffrey Epstein or his --
3527-003
Page 117 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
whatever he does?

A. I'd only can speculating. I don't know.
Q. All right. Do you know the number
MR. CRITTON: Could you say it slowly. III?

MR. EDWARDS: . Thank you. And just
in case you didn't get it, I'm going to mark these
as an exhibit so that we can read them later.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Do you know that number?
A. Yes.
Q. What is that number?
A. That's my cell phone.
Q. Okay. Is that still your cell phone?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. All right. I'm going to show you two
documents here or pieces of paper. We'll mark them as
Exhibit 2 and Exhibit 3. The first one is dated
March 5th, 2005. Do you remember making this telephone
call? And just for the record, this looks like a
message that's being taken relative to a phone call that
you made.

MR. REINHART: So the question is does he
remember making the phone call?
3527-003
Page 118 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Do you remember making that phone call after
reading the message?
A. Let me look at the date here. Okay. March.

MR. REINHART: The question is, do you
remember making the call?
THE WITNESS: Okay, let me. "Person for the
car will be here in 15 minutes to drop off foam and
papers." I don't know.

MR. EDWARDS: BY
Q. That doesn't mean anything to you?
A. That doesn't -- I mean, you're talking four
years ago. I can't answer that accurately. I mean. . .

MR. REINHART: So the answer is you don't
recall?
THE WITNESS: Yeah, I don't recall.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. If you don't remember, that's fine.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit Nos. 2 AND 3 were marked
for identification.)
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. So I'll show you Exhibit 3, the same type of
document, and I can make the representation that this
was message pads provided by the state attorney's office
relative to the criminal investigation revolving around
3527-003
Page 119 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Jeffrey Epstein. So that's how I have these documents.
I'm not trying to pull out old documents.

MR. CRITTON: What's the date?
MR. EDWARDS: March 19th.
MR. REINHART: The question is, do you
remember the call?
THE WITNESS: "Tom from Midnight Express is
at" -- help me out -- "convention center with new
boat. They are two points -- two parts of this."
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. "Show"?
A. "Show up the water"
MR. REINHART: "On the water."
THE WITNESS: "On the water and at the
center."
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Do you remember making that call?
A. No. I mean, "Tom from Midnight Express is at
convention center with new boat. They are two parts
of" -- I mean

Q. But as Jeffrey Epstein's pilot, why would you
be leaving such a message about Tom from Midnight
Express relative to boats and a boat show?

A. I help out with boat purchases or, you know,
anything to do with, you know, that moves. So I mean,
3527-003
Page 120 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Okay. When you say "you help out with boat
purchases," what do you mean?
A. Give my opinion, whether or not whether to buy
a certain boat. It's just a hobby. I have knowledge on
boats. Not only just airplanes but, you know.

Q. You give your opinion to whom?
A. To Jeffrey.
Q. Okay. And Jeffrey Epstein obviously, at least
in your mind, you believe he wants your opinion?

A. Yes.
Q. Okay. So boats is another thing that the two
of you have discussed?
A. Yes.
Q. All right. And so this a conversation or at
least some evidence that a conversation existed between
yourself and Jeffrey Epstein relative to a boat or a
boat show?

A. Correct.
Q. Do you remember having that conversation?
A. We've had many conversations about boats and
different boat shows. If you're referring to this one
in '05, I don't recall this one.

Q. Okay. So aside from being a pilot -- which
throughout this entire deposition I believe your
3527-003
Page 121 of 227
EFFA_00009796
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
testimony has been, you know, you're just the pilot for
him -- it looks like there's some other role that you're
playing here in his life. I'm not suggesting that you
are or you are not. I'm just saying from the appearance
of this, it looks that way. Is there anything else that
you want to tell me or that you want to clarify in terms
of the role that you play in Jeffrey Epstein's life
outside of being just his pilot?

MR. REINHART: Let me object to form. He also
told you he installs the audio and video equipment
before.
MR. EDWARDS: Correct.
THE WITNESS: I have an interest in boats.
You know, with the island, I don't think I bought
any boats, you know, for the company, but he
appreciates my opinion on boat purchases.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay.
A. Having the knowledge of aviation and things
that move quite fast. So I have consulted with him on
boat items.

Q. How many boat purchases are you aware of
Jeffrey Epstein making in the time period that you've
known him?

A. Two or three.
3527-003
Page 122 of 227
EFFA_00009797
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. And has he consulted with you on each of those
purchases?

A. Not every one of them, no.
Q. Does he own any boats now that you're aware
of?
A. I don't know if he owns them or not.

Q. Okay. Do you know of any boats that he
controls or maintains?
A. Himself or?
Q. How about this -- I'll ask you this way. I
don't want to split hairs with you here: I know we've
been talking about corporations and things like that.

A. Yes he.
Q. Do you know of any boats that he is the person
with the most control over?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Where would those boats be located and
what kind of boat are we talking about?

A. St. Thomas is the location. It would be a
34 -foot inflatable boat. I know that one specifically.
Q. Okay. Do you know when he made that purchase?

A. Eight years ago, seven years ago. It was a
while ago.
Q. Is that something you had had input in?
A. Not on that one specifically, no.
3527-003
Page 123 of 227
EFFA_00009798
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Is there any other boat that you know of
Jeffrey Epstein being the primary user of or the primary
controller of?

A. I mean, there's boats in St. Thomas. I mean,
it's not part of my job, you know, what goes on with the
boats or who controlled them. It's more of an opinion
of what horsepower should be on the back of the boat,
hull designs. It's out of my area.

Q. But your sole responsibility or your sole
obligation that you have ever had with Jeffrey Epstein
relative to boats is just giving some opinions about the
boat?

A. Mm-hmm.
Q. Is that yes?
A. Yes, yes.
Q. Okay. All right. Has he ever given you his
opinions about boats?

A. Sure. We've discussed it back and forth.
Q. Other than boat conversations, have you ever
talked other conversations, such as

A. Cars.
Q. Okay. How about such as -- have you ever
known Jeffrey Epstein to have a girlfriend, somebody you
consider a girlfriend?

A. No.
3527-003
Page 124 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q.
In the 18 years and all the travels you had
with him, do you know anything about Jeffrey Epstein's
sex life?

A. No.
Q. Do you know who he has sex with?
A. No.
Q. Do you know if he has sex with anybody?
A. I don't know.

Q. Do you know if he's ever had sex on the
airplane while you've been piloting it?
A. I have no idea.
Q. That's something that you just wouldn't know
because you're up in the cockpit?

A. That is correct.
THE WITNESS: Could I take a two -minute
bathroom break just to lose my coffee?
MR. EDWARDS: Sure.
(A break was had at 12:35 p.m.)
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. All right. We're back on the record. Over
the years you've indicated that the -- any gifts or
other items or things given to you by Jeffrey Epstein
exclusively are the pool heater, the 40 -acres of land
and the --

A. Use of a company --
3527-003
Page 125 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. -- and the use of a company car?

A. Yes.
Q. That's it?
A. (Nodding.)
Q. Okay.
A. Yes, I'm sorry, yes.
Q. And the flight to Miami that was recently
taken, other than Jeffrey Epstein and
was there anybody else on that flight?

A. No.
Q • How long -- did you also fly them back from
Miami to Palm Beach?
A. No. He drove back.
Q. When you say 'he drove back,• who drove back?

A. Well, I assume he drove back. I did not fly
him back.
Q. When's the next time you saw him again?
A. I would only be guessing. A week later, I
mean.

Q. Okay. And was that in Palm Beach County when
you saw him the next time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know of him leaving Palm Beach County
in the last two years on any other occasion?

A. No.
3527-003
Page 126 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. Did he ever fly anywhere else with you either
by helicopter or airplane in the last two years?

A. We flew one time to the Sikorsky plant.
Q. What's the Sikorsky plant?
A. That's where they build the Sikorsky
helicopters. It's in Palm Beach County.

Q. And when was that?
A. Probably a month ago, I'm guessing.
Q. For what purpose?
A. They gave us a tour at a facility.

Q. Who's they?
A. Sikorsky.
Q. And who requested the tour of the facility?
A. They offered it to our flight department.

Q. And who went?
A. Jeffrey, myself, and Igor.
Q. And if I wanted documentation of either of
those trips, the trip to Miami or the trip to the
Sikorsky plant, who would have that documentation?

A. I would.
Q. So I could request it from your attorney to
get it from you?
MR. REINHART: Let me just check.
(Off the record discussion

MR. REINHART: Okay. He has custody of it,
3527-003
Page 127 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
but they're corporate documents. So you'd have to
request it from Mr. Critton, who I understand
represents all the corporations.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. What's the corporation that the document was
prepared for?
A. Meaning who -- what, like Air Ghislaine, the
owner of the helicopter? Yes, Air Ghislaine.

Q. Air Ghislaine?
A. That's the helicopter.
Q. And the name Ghislaine is obviously not that
typical of a name. Is that reference or related to
Ghislaine Maxwell?

A. I would assume. I have no knowledge.
Q. Nobody's ever told you that?
A. Nobody's brought it up.
Q. Okay. And how long were you at the Sikorsky
facility?

A. Three hours, four hours.
Q. And what time of day was this?
A. Nine in the morning. Nine, I think, and we
returned at one, something like that.

Q. And was the purpose to buy or purchase
anything?
3527-003
Page 128 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. They have a new helicopter being developed
there, so they're trying to look for investors in it.
So they were just kind of pushing their product.

Q. Do you know what Jeffrey Epstein does for a
living for business today, these days?
A. No.
Q. Do you know or have you ever been to the
Florida Science Foundation?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. And do you know what the Florida Science
Foundation does?
A. Not exactly.
Q. Well, generally?

A. No, I don't. I mean, really, I don't.
Q. Okay. Is it your understanding that Jeffrey
Epstein is somehow affiliated with the Florida Science
Foundation?

A. It's my understanding that, yes.
Q. I mean, did you just by happenstance stumble
into the Florida Science Foundation, or was it related
to your relationship with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I've heard that's where his office was. I
mean, I have no other
Q. Why did you go there?
A. Talk about airplanes.
3527-003
Page 129 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Talk to who?
A. Jeffrey.
Q. Jeffrey just happened to be at the Florida
Science Foundation?
A. Yes.
Q. How did you know that he was going to be at
the Florida Science Foundation?

A. He called me and told me.
Q. And he said come to the Florida Science
Foundation to talk to me about what?

A. Maintenance on the airplanes, upcoming. It's
an ongoing.
Q. And did he have an office there?
A. Yes.

Q. So this is -- when you walked in, this is the
place that's right next to Jack Goldberger's office?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. And you walk in and there's a reception desk
right there?
A. Yes.
Q. Is that where you talked or did you talk
somewhere behind that reception desk?

A. Behind the reception area.
3527-003
Page 130 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. Back in his office?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was that conversation?
A. Give me a time frame. I mean, I've been there
several times.

Q. Okay. How many times do you think you've been
to the Florida Science Foundation?
A. Twenty, thirty. I mean. ..

Q. Well, the Florida Science Foundation's only
been around since late 2007; is that right?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Something around that?
A. I don't know exactly.
O. All right. So in the last 20 years -- in the
last couple of years you've been there 20 or 30 times,
approximately?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. And during those times when you've been there,
without having to go through each conversation, did you
ever talk to him about the fact that he was on probation
or that he was

A. No.
Q. -- any part of the criminal investigation?
A. No, not at all.
3527-003
Page 131 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. What was the purpose of the conversation?
A. We were sometimes talking about TVs, you know,
the latest plasma that's out there, LCD, you know,
setting up a stereo systems, you know, in the Palm Beach
house. That's usually the main thrust of our
conversations these days.

Q. How would you know to go to the Florida
Science Foundation on each of those occasions? Would he
just call you?

A. Yeah, he would call me and say come on by or I
got a brochure on a new Samsung.
Q. With each time you were at the Florida Science
Foundation, how long would you stay typically?

A. Ten, fifteen minutes. Not much more than
chat.
Q. You would go there for ten or fifteen minutes,
have a conversation about a TV and leave?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. Why couldn't you have that conversation over
the phone? What was it about?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: If it was pertaining to a TV and
I'd have a brochure, a picture of the TV -- one
particular TV we looked at it was the size of a
like five foot diagonal, so I had a photo of myself
3527-003
Page 132 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
standing next to it or the salesperson. So I mean,
there's a reason to visually show him something
reference to that.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Did you ever communicate with Jeffrey
Epstein -- you can send him an e-mail, right? You could
have done that?

A. Yes.
Q. To send him the picture or something like
that, that was an option?
A. Right.
Q. And what's Jeffrey Epstein's e-mail address
that you use?

A. I have to do it on my computer, you know,
with -- I have to type in the prompts for it because
it's a long e-mail address.

Q. Okay. How long have you e-mail corresponded
with Jeffrey Epstein?
A. Probably two years. A year to two years. I
mean, it's fairly -- something we just started doing. I
mean, we'd never done that in the past.

Q. Well, in the past he was in jail or have some
restrictions?
A. The restrictions, yes.
Q. So you you'd see him on the airplane
3527-003
Page 133 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
frequently?

A. Exactly.
Q. So when you didn't see him on the airplane
frequently, then some of your correspondence was by
e-mail, other times by telephone?

A. Mm-hmm.
Q. And other times in person?
A. Yes.
Q. And what was your e-mail -- what was the
substance of the e-mail correspondence that you would
have with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. It would have to be related. I mean, you have
to give me a topic. I mean, whether it be a car --
Q. Never about the criminal investigation?

A. Oh, no, no, never.
Q. Do you know what his intention is or his plans
are for when he is off probation?

A. No idea.
Q. Or off community control?
A. I have no idea.
Q. Has he ever indicated to you he wants you to
fly him to some other location outside the United States
to live permanently?

A. Oh, no.
Q. Have you ever flown to his place in Paris?
3527-003
Page 134 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. We've landed in Paris.
Q. You're aware that he has some control over
another piece of property over there?

A. I know we've picked up luggage at a residence.
I don't know to what extent his ownership is, if any.

Q. All right.
A. Right.
Q. And are you aware that he has some employees
that listen to what he says that work in that house?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: In Paris, yes, there is one
person there.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. What's his name?

A. Voltzan. Because I always thought there was
nobody there.
up.
Q• Vultzan Cauldron (phonetic)?
A. I don't know exactly. I would have to look it

Q. Have you talked to him before?
A. No.
Q. When you've been in Paris
A. You're not going to ask why?
Q. Well, I'm assuming he doesn't speak English.

A. There you go, okay.
3527-003
Page 135 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. So I thought there was no need for that?

A. Okay. I just wanted to see.
Q. Where do you stay when Jeffrey Epstein is in
Paris?
A. A hotel.
Q. Okay. And in New Mexico, when you land there,
you stay on the ranch somewhere, but at your place?

A. I stay at my place.
Q. And in New York, you have an apartment that he
sets you up at, right, the 301?

A. Yes, I have a place I could stay.
Q. And in St. Thomas?
A. Hotel.
Q. And in Paris you stay at a home?

A. (Nodding.)
Q. Are there any other properties such as what we
were talking about today -- I'm not saying Jeffrey
Epstein is the sole owner or direct owner, but any other
properties that you're familiar with that Jeffrey
Epstein is -- has direct access to and at least it gives
the appearance to you that he is the owner or controller
of that property?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Name the list that you've
stated.
3527-003
Page 136 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. The Manhattan house.
A. Yes.
Q. Mansion or whatever we want to call it, the
Zorro Ranch, the island of St. James, the Palm Beach
house.

A. Mm-hmm.
Q. And the Paris place.
A. That's all I'm aware of.
Q. And have you ever at any of those five places
hung around him and stayed around him for during the
daytime for the course of an entire day?

A. No.
Q. All right. So do you know what he does during
his days while he's there?
A. No.
Q. Are you aware of a list of underage girls that
is kept to come over and service him each of those days?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Absolutely not.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. I'm the first person to ever even imply that
to you, right?

A. A list, yes, you are.
Q. Okay. Have you ever been made aware that
3527-003
Page 137 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
keeps a list of underage girls to service
Jeffrey Epstein for sexual purposes?

A. I am not aware of them.
MR. CRITTON: Form to the last question
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Have you ever been made aware that Ghislaine
Maxwell keeps a list of girls in the nearby areas of
each of -- at Jeffrey Epstein's residences to service
him sexually?

A. No.
MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
O. Okay. Have you ever read some of the
complaints that have been filed against him in the
various courts, whether state court or federal court,
against Jeffrey Epstein?

A. No, I have not.
Q. All right. So this Jane Doe 102 versus
Jeffrey Epstein, you're not familiar with who that
person is?

A. No idea.
Q. Okay. I'm going to mark Jane Doe, one of the
22, versus Epstein as Exhibit No. 4 to this deposition.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 4 was marked for
identification. )
3527-003
Page 138 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. And ask you about some of the allegations in
here and see if you know anything about them. It
indicates he owns a flight of aircraft that includes a
Gulfstream, a helicopter, and a Boeing 727. True?

MR. CRITTON: What's the question?
THE WITNESS: Please repeat.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Are you aware of him owning a Gulfstream IV
aircraft, a helicopter and a Boeing 727? I think we
talked about it, right?

A. Right.
Q. Okay. And it indicates a fleet of motor
vehicles?
MR. CRITTON: Wait a minute. He said right,
is that we talked about it, as distinct from him
knowing one way or another.
THE WITNESS: What's the question?
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Do you know that he owns those things?
A. I do not know that he owns them.
Q. Do you believe that he owns those things?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I would be guessing, so. ..
3527-003
Page 139 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. What does the company NES, LLC, do to your
knowledge?
A. I have no idea.
Q.
know?
How does that company generate profit, if you

A. I have no idea.
Q. That's the company that pays your paycheck,
but you have absolutely no clue what they do to generate
money?

A. No, sir.
Q. If anything?
A. Correct.
Q. Have you ever heard that that company
generates money through sex trafficking of young girls?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: Absolutely not.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Never, okay. Have you ever heard that Jeffrey
Epstein has a sexual preference for underage girls?
Other than what you've read in the newspaper, have you
heard that from any other individuals before?

A. No.
Q. Ever heard that he has had sex or sexual
relationships with many minor girls, some as young as 12
3527-003
Page 140 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
years old?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: No.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
O. Never?
A. Never.
Q. Have you ever seen any photographs in any of
his homes depicting young -looking girls engaging in sex
acts?

A. No.
Q. Or reading directly from the complaint,
"engaged in lewd acts"?
A. No, absolutely not.
Q. Have you looked around the walls of his
various homes when you're in there picking up luggage?

A. I mean, not any more than I walked in here and
not looking at the walls over there, I couldn't tell you
what those are; so nothing specific.

Q. Sometimes we're talking about a 50,000 square
:Mot house?
A. Exactly.
Q. In Manhattan?
A. It's pretty big.

Q. Okay. Have you ever looked at any of his
computers for any reason?
3527-003
Page 141 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. No.
Q. I know that you helped set up some of the --
A. Computers are not my expertise.
Q. All right. Have you ever been told that

Mr. Epstein committed sex acts against underage girls on
a literal daily basis, that's what he does?
A. I've never been told that.

Q. Have you ever read the complaints against him
that indicate that's what he does on a daily basis?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: No.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. So in your mind, you never believed that you
were transporting around somebody whose sole goal in
life is to get -- have sex with little girls?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I never believed that, no.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Okay. Have you ever been told that he
conspired with others, including assistants and/or his
drivers and/or pilots and his friend Ghislaine Maxwell,
to further these sex acts and to avoid police detection?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Have you ever -- anybody ever questioned you
3527-003
Page 142 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
about that?

MR. REINHART: Hold on. The question is have
you ever been told that fact that he just read to
you?
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Right.
A. I have never been told that fact.
Q. Has anybody ever questioned you about your
possible involvement with helping to facilitate

Mr. Epstein have sex with underage girls?
A. No.
Q. When you were questioned by either the police
or the -- whoever the investigative resource that was
being used at the time?

A. Right.
Q. Do you remember who that person was that was
questioning you?
A. No, I don't remember.
Q. I know you don't know the location where it
was, but do you remember who they were affiliated with?

A. No.
Q. Was it only one time?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you also have to testify before a grand
jury proceeding?
3527-003
Page 143 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. No, I did not.
Q. Have you ever known Mr. Epstein to get a
massage while on an airplane?
PHONE ATTORNEY: This is everybody in Boone,
Charles and the witness is here and the court
reporter and the videographer.

MR. EDWARDS: Fantastic, but I think that you
may have the wrong room.
PHONE ATTORNEY: I was told to ask for 856.

MR. EDWARDS: Let's go off the record.
(Off the record discussion.)
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. All right. In the complaint, I'm going to
tell you what it alleges and I'm going to ask if this
helps to refresh your recollection about any of Jeffrey
Epstein's activities. The defendant, Jeffrey Epstein,
transported the plaintiff to another state in order to
engage in sex acts with her. And this occurred when she
was merely 15 years old.
Do you remember transporting somebody that
looked like they were 15 years old on your airplane?

A. No, sir.
Q. You never remember taking a 15 -year -old, or
somebody that looks around that approximate age, on your
airplane?
3527-003
Page 144 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Can you be more specific?
Q. Well, I know that you've indicated earlier in
the deposition that you remember some girls under the
age of 18 on the airplane. And so let me ask, before I
get back into this, whether all those individuals you
were talking about were accompanied by a parent or some
of those people were on the airplane for some other
purpose, modeling, or you don't know why they were
there? I'm going to let you elaborate on who these
people are that you believe may have been under the age
of 18 and why you think they were on the airplane?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: We've had younger people on the
airplane that have been, you know, with their
family members, like you said. I don't remember
transporting anybody that was of questionable age.
I'm not -- I'd only be guessing at somebody's age
if I didn't ID them at the foot of the airplane.
So I can't guess to their age.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. All right. 'Mr. Epstein used his private jet
to transport the minor plaintiff to Manhattan where he
provided her spending money and accommodations with him
at his mansion."
Do you have any idea who that might be
3527-003
Page 145 of 227
EFFA_00009820
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
referring to?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: No, sir.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. And you don't remember being a pilot of an
airplane where he was transporting a 15 -year -old to
Manhattan from Miami or Palm Beach?

A. No. I'd be guessing at somebody's age and I
can't guess.
Q. "Defendant transported plaintiff in his
private jet to locations that included Palm Beach, New
York City, Santa Fe, Los Angeles, San Francisco,

St. Louis."
Do you remember ever piloting his airplane to
those destinations that I just mentioned?
MR. REINHART: Can we break them down?
Objection; compound.

MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Have you ever flown his airplane to Palm
Beach?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Okay. Have you ever flown it to New York
City?

A. Yes.
3527-003
Page 146 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. To Santa Fe?
A. Yes.
Q. To Los Angeles?

A. Yes.
Q. To San Francisco?
A. Yes.
Q. To St. Louis?
A. Yes.
Q. All right. Continuing to international
destinations, including Europe, have you ever flown it
to Europe?

A. Yes.
Q. The Caribbean?
A. Yes.
Q. And Africa?
A. Yes.
Q. On those flights to those various places, is
it your -- to the best of your knowledge, you were
unaware of Jeffrey Epstein engaging in sex with underage
girls on his airplane?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I have no knowledge of any of
that.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. "He provided accommodations with him in order
3527-003
Page 147 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
to have her available to him at all times whenever he
wanted, including while transporting the minor plaintiff
on his private jet.•
That's something that you had no knowledge of?

A. (Witness shakes head.)
Q. You have to a yes or no.
A. I'm sorry, no.
Q. "Each time they would travel to one of these
destinations, the same pattern of sexual abuse would
occur, often with a vast array of aspiring models,
actresses, celebrities, and/or other females, including
minors from all over the world."
Again, that's something you have no personal
knowledge of?

A. No.
Q. Has anybody ever indicated that if you did
have personal knowledge of some of these things, then
you could also have been implicated in some form of a
crime? Has any law enforcement or anybody ever
indicated that to you?

A. No.
Q. Okay. Is that something you've ever worried
about?
A. No.
Q. All right. "Upon information and belief,
3527-003
Page 148 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
defendant transported minor girls from Turkey." Did you
ever leave in one of his airplanes out of Turkey?

A. I'd have to look at the records. I don't
recall Turkey.
O. Do you ever remember taking any minor girls
out of Turkey?

A. No, I don't remember.
Q. What records would you have to look at to see
if you took people out or left out of Turkey?

A. I'd have to look at the flight logs, but I
personally don't remember flying into Turkey.
Q. And would the flight logs coming into the
United States from Turkey indicate the names of the
people on the plane?

A. They might.
Q. Okay. Where would I get those particular
flight logs that would have that information?

A. Depended upon what year you're talking.
Q. We're talking in this particular complaint
between 1998 and 2002.

A. I'm not -- I don't possess those passenger
manifests.
Q. Do you know who would possess those?
A. That would be I guess --

MR. REINHART: Do you know who has them today?
3527-003
Page 149 of 227
EFFA_00009824
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
THE WITNESS: I do not know who has them
today.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Who did you give them to?
A. Actually, I didn't give them to anybody. Dave
Rogers was in possession of those logs. So I don't know
where they are right now.

Q. You're still thinking that the best evidence
of that, any flight that may have left out of Turkey,
would be in the flight logs that's marked as Composite
Exhibit 1, or are we talking about the manifests that
we've been referring to?

A. I don't know how accurate that log book is or
even how accurate the passenger manifest is.
Q. Okay. So there may be no actual documentation
indicating a flight leaving out of Turkey when, in fact,
a flight may have left out of Turkey?

A. Correct.
Q. Okay. The Czech Republic is the next place
listed. Is that a place you've flown to or from in a
Jeffrey Epstein airplane?

A. More specific, could you name the city?
Q. I can't name the city, at least the complaint
doesn't name the city. But I've been to the Czech
Republic before. Anywhere within that country, have you
3527-003
Page 150 of 227
EFFA_00009825
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
ever flown to or from in a Jeffrey Epstein airplane?

A. We have flown to Prague.
Q. Okay. Have you picked people up in Prague and
flown out of Prague?
A. I don't remember.

Q. I'm not saying no, you didn't, but --
A. Best of my knowledge.
Q. -- you don't remember?
A. Exactly. Best of my knowledge, I don't
remember.

Q. Do you remember the reason for going to Turkey
or to Prague?
A. No.
Q. This also says Asia. Have you ever flown to
or from Asia with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. Or on a Jeffrey Epstein airplane?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you know the purpose of those flights to
and from Asia?

A. No.
Q. Did it ever occur to you that maybe it was to
pick up minor girls for him to have sex with on the back
of the airplane?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
3527-003
Page 151 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
THE WITNESS: Never occurred to me.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Did you ever hear that he maintained some of
these underage girls as sex slaves --
A. Never heard of such a thing.

Q. -- from the age of 12 through the age of 16?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: No knowledge of that.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Ever picked up girls that looked young, many
of whom who spoke no English? Do you ever remember
that?

A. Zero, do not.
Q. All right. The complaint goes on to say,
"Plaintiff was required to be sexually exploited by
defendant's adult male peers, including royalty." So
I'm going to talk, do you have any familiarity with
Prince Andrew?

A. I know who he is.
Q. Was he ever on the airplane?
A. He may have been on the airplane.
Q. Do you remember him on the airplane with young
girls?

A. No, I do not.
Q. Do you remember Jeffrey Epstein flying in to
3527-003
Page 152 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
meet with Prince Andrew?

A. I don't remember. I know that happened, but I
couldn't be accurate.
Q. Has Prince Andrew ever been on the airplane at
the same time as a young girl, to the best of your
memory and knowledge?

A. To the best of my knowledge, no.
Q. This also says politicians, talking about
local or U.S. politicians. Do you remember certain
politicians being on the airplane?

A. No -- I mean yes, I do.
Q. What politicians would that be?
A. President Clinton.
Q. Okay. Who else?
A. Former president of Israel -- help me out with
the name, Barak?

Q. Ehud Barak?
A. Yes, those are the two that I remember.
Q. How many times was Ehud Barak on the airplane
that you piloted for Mr. Epstein?

A. Maybe once.
Q. And where did that flight pick up and where
did it go to, to the best of your memory?

A. Best of my memory, it was Palm Beach to
Teterboro.
3527-003
Page 153 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Where is Teterboro?
A. In New Jersey.
Q. And what was the purpose of that flight, do
you know?
A. I don't know.

Q. Was Jeffrey Epstein on the flight?
A. I'd have to look at the flight logs to
guarantee.
Q. Anything about that flight stick out in your
mind?

A. None.
Q • Such as a fine needing to be paid because it
left after 10:00 p.m.?
A. For that was the flight, yes.

Q. You remember that?
A. It's coming back to me.
Q. And do you remember young girls being on that
flight?

A. No.
Q. All right.
A. I remember the fine.
Q. Do you remember who paid the fine?
MR. CRITTON: Hold on. Let me object to form
of the question. 'Do you remember' it suggests
that there were. So form, predicate.
3527-003
Page 154 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. Do you remember who else was on that
flight that left after 10 p.m.?
A. No, I do not.
0. Do you remember why it left after 10 p.m.?

A. No, I do not.
Q. Do you remember Jeffrey Epstein instructing
you to wait until after 10 p.m. to leave?

A. No.
Q. Would you have listened to him if he had told
you -- if he had instructed you to do that?
A. I don't understand the question.

Q. Well, if he told you wait until after 10 p.m.,
I realize there's going to be a fine, but wait until
after 10 p.m. to leave, intentionally leaving
after 10 p.m., do you remember that instruction ever --

A. No, I don't remember that instruction.
Q. Okay.
A. I mean, it just happened to be departing
after 10 and there is a penalty for leaving after 10 for
noise. So there was no intention to. ..

Q. All right. This also talks about this
particular person 15 years old being sexually exploited
by businessmen and/or other professional or personal
acquaintances. Are you aware of other personal or
3527-003
Page 155 of 227
EFFA_00009830
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
professional acquaintances of Jeffrey Epstein also
sexually abusing or exploiting little kids or underage
girls on your airplane?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: No.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. If you had been aware that Mr. Epstein was --
and by this -- this is more in the form of a
hypothetical, and that I'm not going to suggest to you
it's a fact that he was. But if you had been aware that
every single day Jeffrey Epstein's goal was to locate
underage girls for the purposes of sex, and either have
sex with them on the airplane or at some other
designation that you were destination that you were
traveling him to, would you have continued to pilot
those planes?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: You said it was hypothetical?
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Right, it is a hypothetical.

A. Why would I want to answer that? Because
you're being hypothetical. I mean, it would obviously
be wrong.

Q. Sure. Well, a hypothetical question is a
legal question that I'm allowed to ask.
3527-003
Page 156 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Okay.
Q. And I'm just asking you if you did have
knowledge that Jeffrey Epstein was having sex with
little girls either on the plane or at a place that you
were taking him to or from on a daily basis, that's what
he did, would you have continued to be his pilot?

MR. CRITTON: Let me object. Object to the
form. It's argumentative. It has no more value
than assuming he was chopping up bodies or anybody
was chopping up bodies in the plane you're flying.
What difference does it make? Form.

MR. EDWARDS: What difference does it make in
a case about him having sex with little girls? I'm
not going to argue with you about it. You've
stated your objection.

MR. CRITTON: Exactly. It's an argumentative
question.
MR. EDWARDS: I'm not going to argue with you
about it.

MR. CRITTON: You're arguing with him about
now.
MR. EDWARDS: No, I'm asking him the
hypothetical.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Can you answer that? Would you have continued
3527-003
Page 157 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
to be a pilot for somebody who's traveling to and from
destinations with the goal of having sex with underage
girls?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: It could be any person. It
doesn't have to be Jeffrey Epstein, then, right?
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q • True.

A. No, I wouldn't pilot an airplane if there was
wrongdoing going on.
Q. That you knew about?
A. That I knew you about, sure.

Q. Me reading this complaint to you, is this the
first time you've heard these allegations --
A. Yes.
Q. -- against Mr. Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. It goes on to say, "On one of Epstein's
birthdays, a friend of Epstein sent him three
12 -year -old girls from France who spoke no English for
the purpose of -- for defendant to sexually exploit and
abuse. After doing so, they were sent back to France
the next day."
Are you familiar with that occasion?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
3527-003
Page 158 of 227
EFFA_00009833
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
THE WITNESS: Never heard of such a thing.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Do you know of any friends that he has in
France that would send him birthday -- a birthday
present?

A. No.
Q. Do you know of him receiving any birthday
gifts or birthday people from anyone?
A. Never.
Q. This particular person that filed this
complaint, Jane Doe 102, indicates "Defendant and
Ghislaine Maxwell acknowledged and celebrated
plaintiff's 16th birthday."
Do you remember them celebrating somebody who
you flew on the airplane's 16th birthday?

A. I don't recall.
Q. Any of this jog your memory as to who
is?
A. No.
Q. "From the age of 15, plaintiff" -- this Jane
Doe 102 -- "was sexually exploited and abused by
defendant on a daily basis and often multiple times each
day."
So going back, was there ever a day where you
were with Jeffrey Epstein where you could observe him
3527-003
Page 159 of 227
EFFA_00009834
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
and during an entire day?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't remember
, so I couldn't answer the question.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. "In September 2002, Defendant Epstein
purchased a commercial round-trip airline ticket and
provided a passport, U.S. currency and accommodations
for plaintiff to fly to Thailand."
Do you remember him doing that for anybody
around that time period?

A. No, sir.
MR. CRITTON: What was the date?
MR. EDWARDS: September 2002.
MR. CRITTON: Okay, thanks.
MR. EDWARDS: I have here -- and this is
actually my only copy, so I don't mind marking it
as a composite exhibit, but we'll either have to
copy this while thing or we'll have an agreement of
counsel. It's the visitor inmate log from when

Mr. Epstein was in jail in Palm Beach.
MR. CRITTON: Well, before we get started, it
is now 1:15. We started at 10:00.

MR. EDWARDS: We didn't really start at 10:00.
MR. CRITTON: Shortly thereafter. I was here
3527-003
Page 160 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
pretty much after 10. But we've been here since
10:00. I want to take a lunch break.

MR. EDWARDS: Let's do it.
MR. CRITTON: For an hour?
MR. EDWARDS: Sure.
(A break was had at 1:15 p.m.)
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. All right. I looked through the inmate log of
the visitors who visited Jeffrey Epstein and your name
appears one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight
times.

A. Okay.
Q. Seem to be accurate in terms of how many times
you went to visit him?
A. I thought six, but yes, that's. ..

Q. I'll let you review the records and tell me if
you dispute any of that record. And I'll go ahead and
mark that as Composite Exhibit 5.
(Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 5 was marked for
identification.)

MR. REINHART: It's two pages.
MR. EDWARDS: Two pages.
MR. REINHART: Okay.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Seem accurate?
3527-003
Page 161 of 227
EFFA_00009836
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Yes.
Q.
Okay. Jeffrey Epstein's plea, I believe, was
June 30th, 2008. I think that's when he was taken in
custody from there. Your first visit is July 3rd, 2008.
And the other name on that visit is Igor 2inoviev. Did
you go with Igor to visit Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Yes.
Q. Why did you go with Igor?
A. It just happened he wanted to see us both at
the same time. There was no apparent reason.
Q.
you?
How did you know that Jeffrey wanted to see

A. I don't recall who called and told me that he
wanted to see me. I couldn't give you an accurate name,
whether it was, you know, his attorney, Darren. And
actually, I would put a lot weight to I think it was
Darren, his attorney
said

Q. That would have made a phone call to you that
A. Yeah, to
Q.
go.
And what did you talk about with Jeffrey
Epstein four days after he pled guilty to offenses that
landed him in jail?

A. I think the first visit was how disappointed
or how scared he was, you know, being inside there. We
3527-003
Page 162 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
just talked about general happenings that go on in
there.

Q. What did he say?
A. It's terrible; it's cold; he can't sleep.
They wake him up every two hours. You know, just items
like that, uncomfortable things. We talked about the
airplanes a great deal. You know, we got major
maintenance on the big airplane, so we discussed that a
little bit. And then it was really just how
uncomfortable he was there.

Q. How long did you visit with him on that first
visit, July 3rd?
A. I think we stayed the full hour.
was?

Q. All right. Is that what the time allotment
A. I believe it is, yeah. I don't think you
could leave early, or I'm not aware that you could leave
early, until later on we found out you could stay for
five minutes or longer. But I don't think any of us
knew that was -- once you got in there, you stayed there
for the hour.

Q. Okay. So you talked to him for an hour and
for the most part it was just about the conditions and
his disappointment with the conditions?

A. Sure, yeah, absolutely.
3527-003
Page 163 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. And did Igor talk to him as well?

A. Briefly. I mean, not that much. You're going
back a little ways again to remember exactly what was
discussed. You know, he asked how his family was doing.
I guess Igor's got a son, I think he asked how his son
was doing. You know, just general questions like that.

Q. Did you ride to the jail that day with Igor?
A. I believe we did. I believe I met Igor
probably at Jeffrey's house and picked him up, or if
not, we may have met at the airport and drove together.
But we did drive together on that occasion.

Q. In what vehicle did you drive?
A. The Hummer.
Q. That's the vehicle you described earlier as
the company vehicle?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is that a vehicle paid for by Jeffrey Epstein?
A. Meaning?
Q. Well, is that a vehicle paid for by you?

A. What do you mean "paid for"?
Q. Did you purchase the vehicle with your money?
A. I didn't purchase that one, no.

Q. Do you know if it was purchased by Jeffrey
Epstein or a corporation of Jeffrey Epstein's?
A. Probably a corporation.
3527-003
Page 164 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

MR. CRITTON: Form; move to strike. Sounds
like a guess.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. To the best of your knowledge, that's how most
of the items that you've discussed -- that being the
Boeing and the Gulfstream -- they were usually held in
corporate names, to your knowledge?

A. To my knowledge, exactly, yes.
Q. And so when you're saying the -- when you're
calking about the Hummer vehicle and you're stating that
it's likely a corporate entity, is that just something
that you're guessing about, or do you have knowledge?

A. No, I'm just guessing.
Q. Okay.
A. I have no proof --
Q. -- of ownership of who it's registered to or
anything like that?

A. Exactly.
Q. Is it registered to you?
A. No, no.
Q. So it's registered to somebody other than you?
A. Exactly.

Q. Okay.
A. I just drive it, I guess.
Q. Okay. So on July 5th, 2008, you go back to
3527-003
Page 165 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
see him in jail again, and again, Igor Zinoviev is
listed as a visitor. Did you go with him together on
that occasion?

A. I didn't even realize it was two days after
the first visit.
Q. Well, I mean, you see where this is going?

A. Yeah, I do. It gets further apart, yeah.
Q. Do you remember what the discussion was on
7/5/DS?
A. No, because it's probably similar to the first
one. I mean, we talked -- actually, one of the visits
we talked about fishing and just trying to -- you know,
we were talking about things that would just occupy his
mind with intelligent conversation that he probably
wasn't getting there. So for that hour of the day, I
tried to give my best of intelligent conversation to
him.

Q. Okay. On his visitor log you were the first
one to go visit him. Did you know that?
A. I did not know that. I wasn't aware of that.

MR. CRITTON: Let me just object to form to
the last question.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Well, at least if these records are accurate,
which are the records that were provided to us by the
3527-003
Page 166 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
.7
facility that was holding Jeffrey Epstein, they're
accurate, your name is the first one listed on the top
of the sheet?

A. Right. There may have been earlier dates. I
have no idea.
Q. Well, you know, the first date that he could
have been in there it looks like was 7/1/08 and then,
you know, so I guess somebody could have seen him 7/1 or
1/2, but those records were never provided to us. You
see we were provided a whole big stack.

A. I understand.
Q. The next date I'm going to talk to you about
is 7/12/08.
A. Uh-huh.
O. It looks, again, like it's yourself and Igor
Zinoviev?

A. Mm-hmm.
Q. And that's something we talked about in this
deposition. I'm going to ask you again, I don't know
that you elaborated last time, what is your
understanding of his relationship with Jeffrey Epstein?
Is that a friend of his?

A. I don't know his job description. I mean,
he's somebody that's around a lot, but I don't know his
exact job description. His English is, to say, not
3527-003
Page 167 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
100 percent, so conversation with somebody that doesn't
fully understand you, you know, you get lost in
translation a little bit. So I don't

Q. So on these three visits to the jail, the
first three that we're talking about that we've talked
about so far, each of those times you traveled to and
from the jail with Igor?

A. Mm-hmm.
Q. Yes?
A. Yes, yes.
Q. And each of those time, is it fair to say you
had some form of communication either on the way to the
jail or

A. Sure.
Q. -- to the jail?
A. Yeah.
Q. Since you're going to see an inmate in the
jail, is it a safe assumption a portion of that
conversation was about the person that you're going to
see and possibly the crime that was committed?

A. Yes, that would be a good assumption.
Q. Okay. And what was the form -- what was the
substance of that conversation that you can remember
related to Jeffrey Epstein and the location you were
going to visit him?
3527-003
Page 168 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. I think Igor and I discussed on trying to be
upbeat and not look at the position that he's in sitting
across the table from us, to be upbeat and uplift his
spirits.

Q. Did you and Igor discuss whether or not you
were going to talk to him about his plea of guilty or
the fact that he's not registered as a sex offender?

A. No.
Q. Or whether you were going to stay away from
those topics?
MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: We never -- we don't discuss
that amongst ourselves and/or with Jeffrey in any
way, form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. But that's not -- I realize you didn't
discuss that. You've told me that.
A. Right, but we didn't discuss that even prior
to going in, as you asked.

Q. Okay. So your discussion was mainly hey,
let's be upbeat?
A. Yes.
Q. And that was to, in essence, maintain his
spirits or raise his spirits?

A. Exactly.
3527-003
Page 169 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. Okay. And you were doing that as a friend of
his, not just his pilot, right?

A. I felt honored that he asked me to come and
give support like that, because prior to him going away,
it was known to us that there was going to be no
visitors, because I had offered to him that I would be
happy to come and visit him if he deemed it necessary,
and he says no, I'm not going to have anybody.

Q. So --
A. I guess it was so bad there, that he may have
changed his mind and wanted to have some visitors.

Q. When did you have this conversation with him
where he indicated he was not going to have visitors
while he was in jail?

A. I don't exactly remember. It may have been on
the trip heading to Palm Beach, the last flight.
Q. From his island, from St. Thomas I guess it
would be from?

A. I forgot where it started from. It might have
been New York or the island, one of the two. I don't
remember the last flight.

Q. And I mean, did at least the fact come up that
hey, this a person who you're is going to be in jail
for some time?

A. Mm-hmm, yes.
3527-003
Page 170 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. And in the course of that conversation, again,
the allegations and the unusual I'll call it case
against him, that didn't come up between you and

Mr. Epstein?
A. I never talked about it with him.
Q. And at that point in time, what were you aware
of in terms of the number of girls that he was alleged
to have had sexual some sort of sexual relationship
with him at his Palm Beach house?

A. What was the question? How many girls?
Q. Yeah, how many girls were you --
A. Aware of?
Q. -- aware of?

A. None. I wasn't aware of any, to be honest.
O. The next visit is on 7/17/08 and it's Igor
Zinoviev and somebody named Jean Rene and then yourself.
Do you know who Jean Rene is?

A. No.
Q. Do you think that that visit, that you visited
him at the same time that Jean Rene visited?
MR. CRITTON: What's the date?

MR. EDWARDS: It's 7/17/08.
THE WITNESS: No, I don't know a Jean Rene,
unless somebody came after. I mean, I don't -- I
don't know a Jean Rene.
3527-003
Page 171 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. And then before you visited him again,
the visitors are listed as or
A. Mm-hmm.
Q. Mainly those two individuals. And they list
as addresses,

A. Uh-huh.
as their residence?
Q. Given your previous testimony, does that
surprise you that they list those that address as
their residence?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I've seen them there, so I mean,
I'm not surprised.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Okay. Did you know that they were visiting
him in jail?

A. No, I didn't know who was scheduled to see him
or whatever.
Q. Did Jeffrey talk to you at any point in time
about or

A. No, not at all.
MR. REINHART: Can we get a time frame for
that? Ever?
MR. EDWARDS: Oh, no, well, I was talking --
3527-003
Page 172 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
I'm sorry.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. I was talking right now about in the
conversations that you had with him that we've discussed
with you and him in the jail facility. Did he discuss
with you

A. No, no.
Q•
or
Did he talk to you about whether or not you
should talk to anybody about his criminal investigation
or possible litigation?

A. No, not at all.
Q. The next time you see him is on August 9th,
2008, at the jail. In that occasion it mentions as his
visitors that day and
Larry Visolli. Did you go to the jail with and
that time?

A. No. Who was on there? Which one are you
referring to?
Q. The next one, I tried to highlight them just
that

A. Right, that one.
MR. REINHART: 8/9.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. 8/9/08?
A. One of those two we all drove together. I
3527-003
Page 173 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
don't remember which one it was. It was either the 9 or
the 16, and then the other one I met everybody there.
So I can't be accurate on which time we all drove
together.

Q. How did you coordinate driving together?
A. I don't exactly remember now. I mean, I think
and I may have conversed on the phone and said do
you want to meet at Jeffrey's house and we all drive
together? Does it make sense to get together and drive
one car.

Q. Is that jail visit the result of Jeffrey
Epstein requesting your presence there, or is that the
result of you wanting to go see him as a friend in jail?

A. A combination of both. I'm sure if I said,
Hey, I'd like to come to jail and visit you, that he
would either say yea or nay.

Q. Okay. And you said at least on one of those
occasions you rode to and from the jail with and
A. Yes.

Q. And during any of obviously, when you're in
the car together -- well, who's driving the car?
A. I was driving, I believe.
Q • And that's the Hummer again?

A. Actually, I think we take one of the suburbans
3527-003
Page 174 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
at the house.

Q. Those are cars that Jeffrey Epstein owns, to
your knowledge?
A. I don't know who owns them.
Q. What cars are there that -- I know with this
case we're dealing with a lot of corporations and it's
not like asking me, Hey, what car do you own? But what
cars are you aware that are -- that you believe are used
primarily by Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Used primarily by Jeffrey Epstein, a Mercedes
S500 sedan. I don't remember the year on that one.
Q. Okay.

A. There's a Cadillac Escalade.
Q. Okay.
A. Those are his two main cars that he would be
driven in
Q. What are the other cars that you regularly see
parked at his Palm Beach mansion, if there are any?

A. It would be a whole array. Half the time the
parking lot is full because of construction workers,
yards keepers.

Q. Okay. Fair enough. What vehicle does
drive or drive when they're down
here, if you know?
A. I mean, anybody has a choice to pick out a car
3527-003
Page 175 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
or whatever there. I've seen driving a Mercedes
convertible.

Q. Is that different than the Mercedes S500
sedan?
A. Yes, I think it's different.
Q. When you say they have basically a choice of
cars to drive --

A. Well, there's cars in the lot there.
Q. Obviously, they can't get in one of the
construction workers' cars?

A. No.
MR. REINHART: Let him finish his question.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. So that's kind of what I'm getting at. What
other cars do you think that Jeffrey Epstein has --
whether it's titled, I don't know --

A. Right.
Q. but he is the person in control of that
vehicle?
A. Right.
Q. What other vehicles do you think he's
controlling in Palm Beach?

A. In Palm Beach?
Q. We've named the Mercedes S500 sedan, Cadillac
Escalade?
3527-003
Page 176 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Right.
Q. And I've identified a Mercedes convertible?
A. Right.
Q. In addition to that, are there any others that
you're aware of?

A. That he's in control of?
Q. Yes.
A. No.
Q. And does the conversation come up between
and and yourself about the reason why
Jeffrey Epstein is in jail?

MR. REINHART: Can we get a time frame?
MR. EDWARDS: At any time.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. At any time have you ever had that exact
conversation ever come up?

A. No, we didn't talk about that among ourselves
really.
Q. And have you ever been told that
provides the role of a sex slave to Jeffrey
Epstein? That's just her role in life?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
MR. REINHART: That's just have you been told
that.
THE WITNESS: No.
3527-003
Page 177 of 227
EFFA_00009852
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Have you been led to believe that by anybody?
A. No.
MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Do you have any -- based on your observations,
do you have any other opinion as to what role she plays
in Jeffrey Epstein's life, if any?

A. I don't have an opinion on what the role is.
Q. Do you agree with the criminal statutes that
are in place to protect young children from sexual
predators? Do you agree with those statutes?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
MR. REINHART: I'm going to direct him not to
answer the question. It's irrelevant and it's not
likely to lead to discoverable evidence what his
opinion is on a law that's been passed by the
legislature of Florida.

MR. EDWARDS: Just so the record is clear, I
don't know that we did this last time, but it's
been alleged in the complaint it has been
alleged in several complaints that Jeffrey Epstein
particularly prays on vulnerable disadvantaged
females, underage females, and that in order to
gain access to the multitude of underage females,
3527-003
Page 178 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
he utilizes various people, schedulers, pilots,
handlers and other associates and co-conspirators
that have a similar mentality; that is, people that
do not agree with laws related to sex abuse and
abuse of children. And that's why this line of
questioning regarding whether or not this witness
has a motive or a bias or was involved in
conversations related to his motive or bias, to
continue to work for Jeffrey Epstein or believed
the same beliefs of Jeffrey Epstein, is at least
reasonably calculated to the lead the discovery of
admissible evidence, and that is the argument at
least along those lines being made to the judge
regarding these questions.

MR. CRITTON: Can we talk for just one minute?
Because maybe -- can I talk with -- well, I know I
can talk with Bruce. Let's just take a break.
(A break was had at 2:45 p.m.)

MR. EDWARDS: We're back on the record. Do
you have the same position?
MR. REINHART: Let me say this: He previously
said he would have never allowed anything on the
plane to be done illegally. If you want to ask if
he agrees with the law applied by the
legislature -- do you agree the law passed by the
3527-003
Page 179 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
state of Florida should be complied with?
THE WITNESS: I don't know what the law is.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. The laws in place to protect children
under the age of 18 from being sexually touched,
fondled, molested by people over the age of 24, do you
agree with those laws?

A. Yes.
Q. And you agree that persons who commit a
violation of those laws should be prosecuted?
A. Persons that do that.

MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Yes, persons that do that.
A. Persons that do that, absolutely.
Q. And if you were to receive confirmed -- what
you would perceive as confirmed information that Jeffrey
Epstein was one of those persons, would you continue to
be employed by or alongside of Jeffrey Epstein?

MR. CRITTON: Form; speculation.
THE WITNESS: You're assuming that there's
quilt.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. No. I'm saying, hypothetically, if you were
convinced that Jeffrey Epstein was guilty of those acts
3527-003
Page 180 of 227
EFFA_00009855
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
which he pled guilty to

MR. CRITTON: Form.
MR. REINHART: Can we -- for purposes of your
hypothetical, what facts do you want him to assume
are true? You said the facts to which he pled
guilty, but the witness already said he doesn't
know what he pled guilty to. He knows the charge
he doesn't know the facts.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Solicitation of prostitution of a minor,
somebody under the age of 18.
MR. EDWARDS: That's the charge, right,
solicitation of prostitution of a minor?

MR. CRITTON: No. I think you've got it
wrong. I'll object to the form.
MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Then we'll handle the question this way: If
you were to believe based on information and evidence
that Mr. Epstein engaged in sex or some form of sex acts
with people of the age range of 12, 13, 14, 15 years
old, would you continue your employment with

Mr. Epstein?
MR. CRITTON: Form; speculation.
THE WITNESS: I would certainly be speculating
3527-003
Page 181 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
and I have to discuss it with my wife long and
hard. I don't think I could give you a correct and
honest answer at this time.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

O. Okay. Given the allegations that have been
made in this case, is this something that you have
discussed with anyone other than your attorney?

A. No, not really. Only from the fact that
they're allegations and there's still a lot more work,
I'm sure, to be discovered.

MR. CRITTON: Let me put on there, for the --
if this deposition is not typed -- and we request
it -- I'd like at least this portion where

Mr. Edwards' last question back about five pages
worth, so just if you could mark it from this
page back about five pages.
If nobody requests the deposition, I'd just
like those five pages.

MR. EDWARDS: I'm going to request the
deposition, so. . .
MR. CRITTON: Okay. We'll mark this then, so
you could tell me where it is, approximately.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Is there a reason why you have not discussed
with Jeffrey Epstein the allegations that have been made
3527-003
Page 182 of 227
EFFA_00009857
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
against him and the allegations contained within many of
these civil complaints on behalf of girls who were under
the age of 18? Is there any reason why you haven't
discussed that?

MR. REINHART: If that's based on
conversations you had with your lawyer, then don't
disclose what you and your lawyer talked about.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Correct.
A. I have not spoken to Jeffrey about any of
this, and it was my understanding that is illegal to
have conversation about this. So I've never presented
any questions to him reference this case or any others.

Q. It was your understanding that it was illegal
to talk to Jeffrey Epstein about the allegations made
against Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Yes, or anything to do with the case. That's
why we never discussed any portions of it.
Q. Okay. So --

A. I may be wrong in that assumption, but I
don't --
Q. So the reason why you haven't discussed this
with Jeffrey Epstein is you believed it was illegal?

A. Correct, yes.
Q. Who led you to believe that it was illegal?
3527-003
Page 183 of 227
EFFA_00009858
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

MR. REINHART: Again, if it was a discussion
you had with any lawyer, then you can just give a
name, don't give a discussion of the conversation
you had.
THE WITNESS: It was my own assumption.
mean, just basic criminal knowledge of knowing
you're not supposed to -- you know, if somebody's
in trial or in a deposition or whatever, I don't --
I didn't think it was appropriate to discuss the
matter with them.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay. So the next two visits and I think the
last two visits we'll talk about are on 9/6/2008.
Actually, it looks like you visited him twice in one
day; is that right?

A. I don't think that's possible. I mean, that
will show how accurate the court record is. There's no
way.

Q. You wouldn't have visited him twice in one
day?
A. No. I think there's only one visitation per
day.
Q. Okay. And it looks like the same visitors
each time, except that it says for period three and then
the next one's for period four. So there are two
3527-003
Page 184 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
different periods. Was there ever a time when they
allowed you to stay for more than an hour?

A. No, not to my knowledge.
Q. Okay. So again, it's and
, same questions: Did you ever ask them their
involvement with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Absolutely not.
Q. And again, what was the discussion with
Jeffrey Epstein along with and
A. On the last visits, it was mainly airplane
stuff and later on in the visitations, we were advised
that you could leave early, so I would only stay for
maybe 30 minutes and then, you know, Jeffrey would
continue his conversations with them and then I would
just wait outside.

Q. Okay.
A. So I would do my business with him talking
about airplanes or whatever I had coming up and then
exit.

Q. And then why did you stop visiting him in jail
after that September 6th, 2008, visit?
A. I was never called back to visit.

Q. Okay. Well, shortly after that then he was on
work release?
3527-003
Page 185 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
$

A. Well, that's true.
Q. Right?
A. Yeah.
Q. So the next times you would have gone to see
him would have been at the Florida Science Foundation,
where we talked about earlier?

A. I've seen him there, yes.
Q. Okay. And in fact, I think you said you saw
him 20 or 30 times --
A. Sure.

Q. -- over the last two years, last year and a
half or so?
A. Yes.
Q. And how long would you stay each time at the
Florida Science Foundation and talk to him?

A. Like my original answer, ten, fifteen minutes.
Q. Okay. And how frequently would you talk to
Jeffrey Epstein while he was at the Florida Science
Foundation?

MR. REINHART: I'm sorry, you're talking in
person or all conversations? Because he testified
he had phone conversations and personal visits.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. I was actually talking about phone
conversations. So when you would call him on the
3527-003
Page 186 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
telephone, how frequently would you talk to him?

A. How frequently during a given week?
O. Yeah.
A. More specific?
D. Sure.
A. Depends upon what's going on that week.

O. I mean, is it somebody you would talk to him
every day?
A. No.
O. All right. Well, at that point in time, he's
going from the jail to the Florida Science Foundation
and back, and if you're not going to see him in person,
and you're not corresponding by e-mail, then would you
correspond by telephone, that either being you call him
or he called you?

A. Yes.
O. And, you know, in any given week, what was the
typical week like? I mean --
A. How many times?

O. Yes.
A. Maybe once in a week, sometimes twice in a
day. I mean, it would vary. There was no routine.

O. And what would the conversation be?
A. Mostly we discussed audio and video, TVs, home
theaters. It's a niche of his and we're constantly
3527-003
Page 187 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
looking at new items that are out there, you know,
what's the biggest LCD flat screen out there.

Q. Okay. And since he's been out of jail and on
community control or house arrest or whatever it is,
where he's located at his home now, have you visited him
at his home?

A. I have been to the home. I haven't visited,
but I have had work to do there.
Q. And have you called him on the telephone
there?

A. Once I think I've called the house. Normally
he calls me because it's usually he needs me to do
something.

Q. And what have those conversations been about
since he's been out of jail?
A. Let's put a stereo in the gym, let's put a TV
in the living room, let's put a bigger stereo in the
gym, let's put a bigger, bigger stereo in the gym, let's
go redo what we've done. It's always audio. He's a
very audio file person.

Q. Do you know of any other modifications that
he's made to the house at 358 El Brillo since the time
that he went into jail?

MR. CRITTON: Form; predicate.
THE WITNESS: Meaning? Be more specific.
3527-003
Page 188 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Structural modifications, architectural
modifications?
A. Starting what date?
Q. June 30th, 2008.
MR. REINHART: I think the question on the
table was have you observed any structural changes
to the house at El Brillo since Mr. Epstein went to
jail?
THE WITNESS: Structural changes?
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Structural, architectural, anything like that,
changes to the house, to the interior of the house since
he went to jail?

A. No. I mean, if you could be more specific.
mean, you're talking furniture or?
Q. I've never been in the house, so I can't be
much more specific. Have you noticed any changes from
before he went to jail to after he went to jail, the
inside of the house, that you could be specific about?

A. No, I can't be specific.
MR. REINHART: Can I talk to Mr. Visoski for a
second?
MR. EDWARDS: Sure.
(Off the record discussion.)
3527-003
Page 189 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

MR. REINHART: I think Mr. Visoski can expand
on his previous answer. Why don't you expand.
THE WITNESS: Can we go back to that one?
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Sure. The question dealt with the structural
architectural changes you're aware of.
A. There has been a kitchen extension, but when
you asked the question, I was unaware of when that
actually took place. So to be accurately answering your
question, I know there's been a kitchen extension.
don't exactly know when that transpired, but. ..

Q. How do you know about the extension? How do
you know this happened?
A. I knew what the kitchen looked like before and
after the extension and I don't -- I thought it was
during the hurricane season when they actually did that
extension.

Q. Who made you aware of it?
A. Nobody. I just walked in the kitchen and
noticed a bigger room than what it was.

Q. All right. Do you know who Martin Nowack is?
A. No.
Q. Do you ever remember him being on your
airplane, or that name of somebody being on your
airplane?
3527-003
Page 190 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. No, I don't. It's not my airplane.
Q. We still don't know whose airplane it is yet.
The time when you took Mr. Epstein to Miami in the last
month, do you know which attorney he was going to see?

A. No, I do not.
Q. And do you know whether it was related to
civil cases or criminal cases or anything else?

A. No idea.
Q. Do you know where the location was in Miami
that he was going to?
A. No, I do not.
Q. Other than yourself visiting Mr. Epstein at
the Florida Science Foundation, are you aware of any
other visitors, people that visited him?

A. No, I'm not. Just whoever was there during my
visit.
Q. Okay. Are you aware of a corporation named
the Zorro Trust?

A. I've heard the name.
Q. And is that something that you've heard
relative to your involvement with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Yes. I mean, I don't even remember where I
heard Zorro Trust. I have no definition of it, but I
know the name is out there.

Q. Okay. Is that a company that you believe is
3527-003
Page 191 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
affiliated or related to Jeffrey Epstein in some way?

A. I have no definition. I don't know who it is.
Q. Do you know how you heard about it?
A. I don't remember. That's going back in the
early days of when Zorro existed.

Q. Who was at the Florida Science Foundation when
you would meet with Jeffrey Epstein on these meetings?

A. would be there.
Q. Anybody else?
A. Story would be there on occasion. That's
pretty much it.
Q. And would they be in the same room with
yourself and Jeffrey Epstein when you had conversations
with him?

A. No, not really. Not particularly.
Q. They would just be at the location?
A. Sure, yes.
Q. Anybody else that worked there or was
affiliated with the Florida Science Foundation that you
know of?

A. Not to my knowledge. I mean, I do my business
and get in and get out.
Q. Can anybody other than Jeffrey Epstein have an
office at the Florida Science Foundation?

A. Not that I know of.
3527-003
Page 192 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
O. All right. And were you deeded the property
that we spoke about earlier on the New Mexico ranch? Is
that deeded to you?

A. Yes.
O. And has it been since back in, I think you
said 1998 or 1999 or whenever it was?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. And do you know -- and did you build a
house on it then?

A. Yes, I did.
Q. Okay. And that's a property that I think you
said you have a mortgage on it, that's a property that
you pay mortgaged that property?

A. Yes, sir.
Q. All right. And as well, the home you own
here, you have a mortgage on that property as well?

A. That is correct.
Q. All right. Are you familiar with a vehicle, a
Chevy Suburban 1500, year 1999?
A. Do you have a color?

Q. No. I can tell you the plate. I could tell
you the VIN. Chevy Suburban -- Chevy Suburban 1500,
registered to Larry Visoski?

A. That would be mine. That's a white one, then.
Q. Okay. When did you get it?
3527-003
Page 193 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. I'm guessing. It was probably two years old
when I got it. Maybe '99. Maybe '01, '02.
Q. Something you still drive?

A. Occasionally. It's kind of a beat up car now,
so it's kind of a knock around.
Q. Best of your knowledge, it stays parked at
your house?

A. Recently it's been in Jeffrey's driveway,
but. ..
Q. Why?
A. Just for an extra car to use.
Q. For Jeffrey to use?

A. No. I mean, for anybody that would come to
the house to help out. Igor I think has driven the car
before.

Q. How did it come about that you began to park
the Chevy Suburban, the 1999 car that we're talking
about, at Jeffrey's house?

A. When there was more activity here in West Palm
Beach. We were never usually coming here that often,
and now with all this going on, with Jeffrey being in
town longer, we needed more cars and transportation. So
my car was just sitting in the driveway at home while I
was driving the Hummer. So I decided to let them use
the Hummer at the house.
3527-003
Page 194 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Well, we've just described this wide array of
cars that Jeffrey had for people to use --
A. Well, you said for him to use.

MR. CRITTON: Hold it.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Is there a reason why?
MR. CRITTON: Wait. You guys are both talking
over one another. You need to let him wait and
finish his question because if I want to assert an
objection, neither one of you gives me a chance,
which may be the plan. Form.

MR. EDWARDS: Yeah, we have a conspiracy
against you.
MR. CRITTON: I knew it. I'll take that as an
admission.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Is there any reason -- did Jeffrey say that he
wanted that vehicle to use or to be parked at his house?

A. No.
Q. Then how did it come about that you started
parking that vehicle at his home?
A. I think the origination of that came when I
started using the Hummer, that the Suburban was parked
in my driveway and I wanted to get it out of my driveway
as an eyesore. So hence, I decided to let people at the
3527-003
Page 195 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
house drive it as a grocery shopping car or something,
or just as extra transportation.

Q. Okay. But when you go to park the car at
somebody else's house, you have to let them know, Hey,
I'm giving you the keys?

A. Mm-hmm.
Q. Who did you give the keys to?
A. I don't know if I gave the keys to anybody. I
may have just left them on the counter there and told
Yanush this is an extra car if you guys needed it to run
around because it was an eyesore at my driveway.

Q. Are you familiar with a Mercedes-Benz SUV
1999?
now?
A. Say that again.
Q. Mercedes SUV, 1999 registered in your name?

A. Yes.
Q. And what car is that?
A. That's my car -- my wife's car.
Q. Does that stay at your house?
A. Yes.

Q. And that's the car that's parked at your house
A. Yes.
Q • Are you familiar with a Land Rover, Range
Rover Sport 2008?
3527-003
Page 196 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Yes.
Q. Registered in your name?
A. Yes.
Q. And whose car is that?
A. That's another extra car for the household to
use at Jeffrey's house.

Q. And when was that car purchased?
A. Last year.
Q. And who purchased that car?
A. It was purchased in my name.

Q. By whom? Who purchased the car in your name?
A. Well, I put the car in my name, but the funds
came from -- they were wired to my account from New
York.
Q • From whom, though? A mysterious source just
sent funds? We know that didn't happen, so I'm just
trying to elaborate here.

A. Jeffrey had paid for the car.
Q. Okay. And why did Jeffrey pay for a car and
put it in your name?
A. I don't know.

Q. I mean, you had to agree for this to happen.
So what was the conversation between you and Jeffrey
that resulted in Jeffrey paying for a Land Rover, a 2008
Land Rover and putting it in your name?
3527-003
Page 197 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. I don't recall exactly how the conversation
came about. He just says we want to buy an '08 Land
Rover and put it in my name. So we did. I didn't ask
any further questions.

Q. Did this conversation happen when he was in
jail or after he was out?
A. Meaning out on house arrest?

Q. Right.
A. When you say "out" I think of the Science
Foundation. On work release, so you have to be more
specific.

Q. You tell me what happened, when the
conversation happened relative to where Jeffrey was at
the time.

A. I'd only be guessing again. I would say this
probably happened a year ago, maybe less than a year
ago. I'd have to look. I don't remember exactly the --

Q. So it was either at a time when he's at the
Florida Science Foundation or possibly on house arrest?
A. It was -- no, it was definitely before house
arrest. It was probably during the time of the Florida
Science Foundation, to be accurate.

Q. Okay. Are you aware --
A. About eight or nine months ago.
Q. Okay. Are you aware of a Mercedes-Benz CLK
3527-003
Page 198 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
2005 registered in your name?

A. Yes.
Q. And whose car is that?
A. That car also is a Palm Beach house car to be
used at the house.
Q. What does that mean, 'a Palm Beach house car'?

A. It's a car that we park in Jeffrey's driveway
for people to use. Anybody that comes to the house can
select a car to go anywhere. I mean, run errands, go
shopping, do whatever they need to do. And that was
purchased the same way. It was in my name.

Q. And the funds came from Jeffrey Epstein?
A. They were wired to my account. I don't know
exactly what account they came from.

O. Again, that's a conversation that has to take
place before -- that you have to agree to put a car in
your name?

A. Yes, yes.
Q. And is that a conversation between yourself
and Jeffrey Epstein that takes place?
A. Yes.

Q. And what is the substance of that conversation
that results in a Mercedes-Benz 2005 being placed in
your name?

A. He just said we need a fun car for the house
3527-003
Page 199 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
in Palm Beach.
Q • But why put it in your name?

A. I don't know.
Q. You didn't ask any questions about that?
A. No, I didn't.
Q. Okay. Are you aware of a Jaguar X-Type 2005
registered in your name?

A. I forgot about that one, yes.
Q. Whose car is that?
A. That's a Palm Beach car.
Q. What do you mean "a Palm Beach car"?

A. It's the Palm Beach house car, another run
around for people to use.
Q. And again, that's a conversation that has to
take place that results in a car being placed --
registered in your name?

A. Yes.
Q.
here?
Okay. Now we're talking about several cars
A. Yes.
Q. That are all being placed in your name?

A. Yes.
Q. You never at any time ask any questions to
Jeffrey Epstein why are you placing these cars in my
name?
3527-003
Page 200 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. I did not.
Q. So your suspicions were never -- your
curiosity was never piqued at all as to why these cars
are being placed in your name?

A. My curiosity was piqued.
Q • You never asked him the question, you just
agreed to do it?
A. That's correct.

Q. That goes for the Jaguar X-Type?
A. Yes.
Q. Are you familiar with a motorcycle, Big Dog
Chopper Motorcycle, 2003?

A. That is mine.
Q. Yours?
A. Yes.
Q. Registered in your name for a good purpose,
right?
A. Yes, it is.

Q. At your house?
A. Yes.
Q. You use it?
A. Absolutely.
Q. All right. Ford F-250, 2008, registered in
your name, are you familiar with that?

A. It's not registered in my name.
3527-003
Page 201 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Q. Okay. So if that's registered in your name,
that would be a shock to you? That would be a surprise
to you?

A. Yes, it would be.
Q. There should be no documentation from you
where you would be the registered owner of the Ford
F-250?

A. What year?
Q. 2008.
A. I remember buying that car. I just -- that
shouldn't be in my name.
Q. What do you mean you remember buying that car?

A. I do a lot -- I do all the car purchases for
Mr. Epstein. I'm a car fanatic, so for years I've been
the car -shopper. I'm the car fanatic.

Q. Okay. But these cars aren't classic vehicles.
These are vehicles that are not being refurbished or
anything, they're being driven around town?

A. No, but they're fun. The new Range Rover is a
nice car.
Q. This Ford F250, that's a car also that's Palm
Beach -- as you would say a Palm Beach car?

A. No.
Q. That's a car that stays at your house?
A. No.
3527-003
Page 202 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
LLC.

Q. Who drives that car, Ford F-250?
A. That was shipped to St. Thomas.
Q. For who to use and for what purpose?

A. Well, that car should have been put under LSJ,
Q. What's LSJ, LLC?
A. Little St. James.
Q. And that's a corporation?

A. Yes.
Q. Your understanding is that's a corporation
affiliated with Jeffrey Epstein?
A. I know it's a corporation. I don't know its
affiliation to Jeffrey.

Q. At this point in time, the way that this car
comes about is through a conversation with yourself and
Jeffrey Epstein?

A. Yes, yes.
Q. So to make some representation that this --
that this corporation LSJ, LLC, you're not sure if that
has any affiliation with Jeffrey Epstein?

A. I don't have any facts to tie the two
together.
Q. Common sense would dictate?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay.
3527-003
Page 203 of 227
EFFA_00009878
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

MR. CRITTON: Form.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Again, that's not a car that you use, the Ford
F-250?
A. No, it's not even here.

Q. And when you say on St. Thomas, is it on
actual St. Thomas, or is it on Little St. James?
A. No, it's on St. Thomas. It's a work vehicle.

Q. For whom?
A. For the workers, for the island.
MR. REINHART: Be careful to answer his
question. I think his question is, is it on

St. Thomas or Little St. James island? Where
physically is the car, if you know.
THE WITNESS: I don't know for a fact.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. It's your understanding it's on St. Thomas?
A. Yes.
Q. And when you say "the workers," what's going
on on St. Thomas to where there's workers that need an
F-250?

A. Just moving sand. I don't know the exact
detail for it.
Q. What were you told about the need for this car
to be on St. Thomas?
3527-003
Page 204 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. They need a work truck.
Q. To do what?
A. I don't know what the detail or the -- you
know, what the job detail was for the truck. They just
needed a work truck.

Q. So Jeffrey Epstein tells you they need a work
truck on St. Thomas and that's the only description that
you're given?

A. Yes, to go purchase and get the best deal I
can on a pickup truck, and that's what I did and for
some reason it got put in my name.
(Off the record discussion.)
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Whose money was used to purchase the truck.
You say you purchased the truck. I want the record to
be clear whether you're purchasing it with your money?

A. No, this was wire -transferred. It was a -- I
don't remember how that -- I think it was a wire
transfer or a check was FedExed from the New York office
to pay for that. That should not be in my name, is what
I'm getting at. I'll certainly change that, but I
thought you were --

Q. I understand that.
A. No, I'm being -- yeah, I didn't.
MR. REINHART: There's no question.
3527-003
Page 205 of 227
EFFA_00009880
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. 34 -foot JVC Powerboat, 2000, owner LSJ, LLC,
registered to Larry Visoski. Do you know that?
A. Yes.
name?
Q.
You knew that that boat was registered in your

A. It's registered to LSJ. It's Jeffrey's boat
that we keep here in West Palm Beach.
Q. And do you keep it at your home?

A. No.
Q. Do you know that the registration is to your
home?
A. It's used in my home address, yes.
Q. Why was that done?

A. We were eventually going to ship it out to
St. Thomas for it to live, but since Jeffrey's here,
we're keeping it in Florida, and when we ship the boat
over, we will change title to the Little St. James
address.

Q. What do you mean "since Jeffrey's here we're
keeping it in Florida"? What does Jeffrey being here
have to do with keeping a boat that's registered in your
name and to your address --

A. Well, I have access to use the boat, you know,
here in Florida, but it's Jeffrey's boat.
3527-003
Page 206 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

Q. Okay. And by "Jeffrey's boat," it was
purchased with Jeffrey's money?
A. That is correct.
cost?
Q • Do you know how much that cost?

A. I think it was 60,000.
Q • Do you know how much the Ford F-250 cost?
A. Twenty-five, I'm guessing, ballpark.
Q •
Do you know how much the Jaguar X-Type cost?

A. 11,000.
Q. Do you know how much the Mercedes-Benz CLK
A. 35,000.
Q. Do you know how much the Land Rover cost?

A. 68,000.
Q. Do you know how much the Mercedes-Benz SUV
cost, that's yours, right? The Chevy Suburban is yours
as well?

A. Yes, I remember how much those cost too.
Q. Is there another boat, 35 -foot Donzi
powerboat, 1999?
A. That's the one I thought you were talking
about originally.
Q • That's the same boat?

A. That's the same boat.
Q • Is there any other boat that's registered in
3527-003
Page 207 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
your name?

A. No.
Q. Did you know that in let me ask you this:
Do you have a 2003 Ferrari F75 -M?
A. No.
Q. Any reason why the car is registered in your
name and the asking price is $159,000 being sold in New
York?

A. That car is not registered in my name.
Q. If it's registered --
A. The ad is in my name.
Q. Why is the ad in your name?

A. Because I was trying to sell it.
Q. Why were you trying to sell it?
A. It was Jeffrey's car and we didn't want it
anymore.

Q. Why would he put his pilot in charge of
selling his Ferrari?
A. Because I bought it.
Q. How much did you buy it for?

A. 179,000. Now, when I say "I bought it," it
was his money. I was the one that negotiated it, to be
clear. It was his car for use in New York.

Q. Are you aware of the Zorro Trust winning an
85 million -dollar Power Ball lottery in 2008?
3527-003
Page 208 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. No.
MR. CRITTON: Say that again.
MR. EDWARDS: The 2orro Trust winning an
85 million -dollar -- claiming the ticket for
85 million -dollar Power Ball ticket in 2008.
THE WITNESS: No.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Have you ever listed your employer as
Ghislaine Air in making political contributions?
A. I may have.

Q. Did you know that you had made political
contributions --
A. Yes, I have.
Q. -- listing your --
A. I needed a company name for that event, and I
had put Air Ghislaine.

Q. And NES, LLC wouldn't do?
A. I didn't think of it at the time.
Q. Did somebody tell you to use Air Ghislaine
rather than the company that has been paying you?

A. No.
Q. You just chose to use an employer that isn't
actually your employer, nor have they ever been?

A. I represent Air Ghislaine, JEGE and Hyperion
as chief pilot, so I consider those really the companies
3527-003
Page 209 of 227
EFFA_00009884
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
that I work for and never really associated myself with
NES, LLC as my realistic employer. So when I go to a
convention, an aviation convention, and somebody says
who do you work for, I use the name JEGE because that's
the name of the Boeing company.

Q. But when I sit here and ask you who you work
for, you give me a different answer.
A. You're asking for the absolute correct answer,
which is where my paycheck comes from, which is NES,
LLC. I probably have used that twice in 17 or 18 years
as my employer.

Q. Do you know
A. I know the name, yes.
Q. How do you know her?
A. I've seen her on the airplane a couple times.

Q. Somebody that you know to be involved
romantically or sexually with Jeffrey Epstein at any
time?
A. I don't know that.

Q. Are there any other cars, vehicles, items,
other things that are registered in your name that are
actually Jeffrey Epstein's?

A. No. You've actually covered them all and
actually shed light on some that I did not realize, like
that Ford.
3527-003
Page 210 of 227
EFFA_00009885
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

MR. REINHART: Mr. Edwards, he needs to expand
upon one earlier answer he gave when you asked him
if he knew anybody else who worked at the Florida
Science Foundation.
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Okay.
A. My wife worked there. When you used the words
"worked there" -- or not referring to her as a past
tense, but she worked there when it first opened
answering the phones.

Q. What's your wife's name?
A. Eileen.
Q. How does she spell that?
A. E-I -L -E -E -N.
Q. Same last name as you?

A. Yes.
Q. How long did she work there?
A. A month, maybe.
Q. And she was answering the phones for the
Florida Science Foundation?

A. Yes.
Q. Do you have a good relationship with your
wife?
A. I think so.
Q. You still don't know what the Florida Science
3527-003
Page 211 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
Foundation does?

A. No, because she doesn't.
Q. She doesn't know what it does either?
A. We never talked about it.
Q. You never talked to your wife about what she
did?

A. No.
MR. CRITTON: He knew she was answering
phones.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q. Do you know of any other employees, friends,
agents, relatives of Jeffrey Epstein who he places his
property in their names, registers them in his names or
anybody else?

A. Not to my knowledge. I don't know.
Q. To your knowledge, you're the only person?
A. I'm the only one I'm aware of.

Q. And with respect to minor girls being on the
airplane, that being under the age of IS, how many times
would you say that you have flown girls into the
country, into the United States where you have given a
date of birth to Customs of somebody on the airplane
that is under the age of 18?

A. I'd have to look at flight records to verify
or give you a correct answer. I don't know any to my
3527-003
Page 212 of 227
EFFA_00009887
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
knowledge at this point.

Q. What flight records would you have to look at?
A. The passenger manifests.
Q. Passenger manifests would have the date of
birth on it?

A. No. It would have a name, but I don't have --
Q. But at some point in time you remember people,
minor date of births, coming into the country and that
being turned over to Customs?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't remember anybody
transporting on the airplane from the country back
into the U.S. that was a minor, to my knowledge.
BY MR. EDWARDS:
Q • Okay. Within the country, minors flying

A. I don't know.
Q. -- on a plane?
A. I don't know dates of birth.
Q. And any people that you knew to be minors on
the airplane, were they always accompanied by parents or
were there minors on the airplane that you're aware of
that were not accompanied by parents?

A. I didn't know either way. I mean, people
would get on the airplane and get off the airplane.
could tell you there were times people would get on that
3527-003
Page 213 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
I didn't even know were on the airplane. Our focus is
up front.

Q. Was there a massage table on the airplane?
A. Which aircraft?
Q. On any of them?
A. The Boeing used to have a table on there, but
it stayed in the same spot and appeared to be never
used.

Q. Okay. So to the best of your knowledge, you
have no knowledge of that massage table on the airplane
ever being used?

A. Correct.
MR. EDWARDS: I don't have anything else.
CROSS (LARRY VISOSKI)
BY MR. CRITTON:
Q. Mr. Visoski, I have just a few questions. You
were just asked about a massage table on the -- any of

Mr. Epstein's airplanes and you said there was a massage
- able on the Boeing?
A. Yes.
Q. Okay. Was there always a massage table on the
Boeing or just for a period of time?

A. Just for a period of time.
Q. All right. And who's responsible for cleaning
up the airplane after Mr. Epstein and/or the guests
3527-003
Page 214 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
leave?

A. Us as the crew.
Q. Okay. So if a massage table had ever been
used, it would have been you and the crew who would have
been responsible for either taking towels or doing
something with the massage table?

A. Absolutely.
Q. And if I understood your testimony, you never
saw a circumstance where it appeared to you that the
massage table had been used in any manner; is that
correct?

A. That is correct. It stayed in the same
location since the day it was put on there.
Q. You were asked a bunch -- a number of
questions about Mr. Epstein, I'll use this --

Mr. Epstein is the person who directed you generally
unless one of -- someone else who worked on his behalf
called you and asked you to, say, set up a time to leave
or pick up luggage, et cetera. My question to you is
this: Have you flown in the past for other private
individuals like Mr. Epstein, i.e., as distinct from a
commercial?

A. Yes, I have.
Q. And approximately have you flown for four,
five, six other private individuals over the years?
3527-003
Page 215 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. Three. I had a short career as far as
transferring of owners.
Q. In terms of transferring to the other owners,
separate and apart from Mr. Epstein, again, every
individual is different, but was your relationship
really any different with any of those other
individuals? That is, you were in essence -- you were
hired to perform a specific task: Fly an airplane to
get from Point A to Point B and get the people there
safely?

A. My first job, corporate -wise, was for an owner
in Miami and I was hired as a pilot, but yet, I would go
to his house and maintain a boat that was in the back of
his house above and beyond my call of duty because I had
an interest in boats. It's just something I like to do.
But I always treated Mr. Epstein like any of the other
prior clients that I had as owners. I knew that I was
not afraid to work for a living, and they understood
that.

Q. And it sounds like at least the first owner
that you worked for asked you to do similar things that
you've done for Mr. Epstein, such as take care of a boat
or purchase a boat or maintain the boat?

A. Sure, absolutely.
Q. So your relationship with Mr. Epstein with
3527-003
Page 216 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
regard to if you bought boats or you bought cars on his
behalf, that's very similar to your prior experience
with working with another private individual?

A. That is correct
Q • In terms of the records, the manner in which
you flew the plane or I don't want to say flew the
plane, but in which you operated and maintained the
plane for Mr. Epstein are substantially the same you've
done with other private individuals?

A. Right, exactly the same. We wouldn't treat
Mr. Epstein any different than any prior -- previous
jobs that I had. It's the same routine we carry over
and that's why we're good at what we do. We take care
of the airplanes to the best of our ability.

Q. Is your focus as the pilot, as the captain of
both of the airplanes when you took over that
responsibility a number of years ago, is it your
obligation to get the passengers there safely -- onboard
and safely to the destination and then return?

A. Yes, that was always job number one.
Q. And most of us have had I'd say a much more
substantial experience in flying commercial planes and I
rarely see -- in fact, I can't remember the last time
particularly after 2001 I saw the pilots coming back
into the cabin shaking hands and helping distribute the
3527-003
Page 217 of 227
EFFA_00009892
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
snacks or liquids. Maybe I'm not on the same flights
that some of the other lawyers here are, but I assume
you fly commercial from time to time?

A. Sure.
Q. Do you ever see the pilots interacting with
the people who are in the back of the airplane?

A. No, not at all. They stay at their station up
front.
Q. You got -- as the captain of the planes, when
you're flying, you have substantial responsibilities not
only to the people on the plane, but as well to the air
space which you're flying?

A. Yes.
Q. Okay. By the way, we've been here about
for about an hour and ten -- we started about ten. It's
now 3:30. Did you ever hear the name L.M.? Has

Mr. Edwards ever asked you one question about
MR. EDWARDS: Is the question have you ever
heard of her or did I ask any questions about her,
or did you ask both questions and give the same
answer?

MR. CRITTON: I'll break them down.
MR. EDWARDS: It doesn't matter to me.
BY MR. CRITTON:
Q. Did you ever meet an individual by the name of
3527-003
Page 218 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. No, I have not.
D. Did Mr. Edwards, in approximately four hours,
little over four hours of questioning, ever ask you one
question about that you can recall?

A. Not that I recall.
Q. Have you ever heard the name III.? Did you
ever know someone named
A. Never heard that name.

Q. In approximately four -and -a -half hours of
questioning by Mr. Edwards, did he ever ask you about
A. No, he did not.

Q. In approximately the -- are you familiar with
an individual by the name of Jane Doe(
A. I never heard that name.

Q. In approximately four -and -a -half hours of
questioning by Mr. Edwards, did he ever ask you
questions about Jane Doe(_)?

A. No, he did not.
MR. CRITTON: That's all I have.
MR. EDWARDS: I only have two questions based
on what your testimony just was to Mr. Critton.
3527-003
Page 219 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
REDIRECT (LARRY VISOSKI)
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. You said you had three other people that
you've flown for?
A. Three other previous jobs. I'm trying to be
as accurate.

Q. Those are private individuals?
A. That is correct.
Q. And who are those people?
A. Herb Glimpsure in Columbus, Ohio, and Edward
Seltzer in Miami. And then the other was Tom Boyd, and
that was more of a Learjet charter, but he was the owner
of five Learjets. Those are my only three jobs in my
life.
(1 • Also wealthy individuals?

A. Big time.
Q. And did you know what they did for a living?
A. Those I did, yes.
Q. And did you ever go visit any of those people
in jail?

MR. CRITTON: Form.
THE WITNESS: I know my first individual had
trouble with the law after I had left. I don't
remember what it was pertaining to; but no, I never
visited any of them in jail, no, sir.
3527-003
Page 220 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
BY MR. EDWARDS:

Q. Even the one who had trouble with the law, you
didn't go visit him in jail?
A. No, I did not.
Q. And did any of them put vehicles or other
boats or anything else in your name?

A. No.
Q. Okay. Any of those people ever deed any
property or acres or anything like that to you?
A. No.

Q. Did any of those people ever hire your wife
for employment?
A. No.
Q. And your attorney, is that your attorney paid
for by you, or is this somebody that's hired by Jeffrey
Epstein?

A. It is somebody that is hired by Jeffrey
Epstein.
MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
MR. CRITTON: One follow-up to your question.
RECROSS (LARRY VISOSKI)
BY MR. CRITTON:

Q. With regard to the private individuals that
you worked for prior to Mr. Epstein, what was the
longest period of time that you worked for those?
3527-003
Page 221 of 227
EFFA_00009896
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009

A. The longest period of time was five years and
the shortest being two years.
MR. CRITTON: Thank you.
MR. EDWARDS: We'll order.

MR. REINHART: We'll read.
MR. CRITTON: We'll take a copy, front page,
mini with index.
(Witness excused.)
(Deposition was concluded at 3:37 p.m. )
3527-003
Page 222 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
$
CERTIFICATE OF OATH
THE STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
I, the undersigned authority, certify that
LARRY VISOSKI personally appeared before me and was duly
sworn on the 15th day of October, 2009.
Dated this 22nd day of October, 2009.
Wendy Beath Anderson, RPR, CRR, FPR
Notary Public State of Florida
My Commission Expires: 9/20/2013
My Commission No. : DD 906647
Job #127542
3527-003
Page 223 of 227
EFFA_00009898
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
CERT I F I CATE
THE STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
I, Wendy Beath Anderson, Certified Realtime
Reporter and Notary Public in and for the State of
Florida at large, do hereby certify that I was
authorized to and did report said deposition in
stenotype; and that the foregoing pages are a true and
correct transcription of my shorthand notes of said
deposition.
I further certify that said deposition was
taken at the time and place hereinabove set forth and
that the taking of said deposition was commenced and
completed as hereinabove set out.
I further certify that I am not attorney or
counsel of any of the parties, nor am I a relative or
employee of any attorney or counsel of party connected
with the action, nor am I financially interested in the
action.
The foregoing certification of this transcript
does not apply to any reproduction of the same by any
means unless under the direct control and/or direction
of the certifying reporter.
Dated this 22nd day of October, 2009.
Wendy Beath Anderson, RPR, CRR, FPR
Job #127542
3527-003
Page 224 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
DATE:
TO:
IN RE:
October 22, 2009
LARRY VISOSKI Job #127542
c/o Robert D. Critton, Jr.
via transcript

vs. Epstein
Please take notice that on Thursday, the 15th
of October, 2009, you gave your deposition in the
above -referred matter. At that time, you did not waive
signature. It is now necessary that you sign your
deposition.
As previously agreed to, the transcript will
be furnished to you through your counsel. Please read
the following instructions carefully:
At the end of the transcript you will find an
errata sheet. As you read your deposition, any changes
or corrections that you wish to make should be noted on
the errata sheet, citing page and line number of said
change. DO NOT write on the transcript itself. Once
you have read the transcript and noted any changes, be
sure to sign and date the errata sheet and return these
pages to me.
If you do not read and sign the deposition
within a reasonable time (i.e., 30 days unless otherwise
directed) the original, which has already been forwarded
to the ordering attorney, may be filed with the Clerk of
the Court. If you wish to waive your signature, sign
your name in the blank at the bottom of this letter and
return it to us.
Very truly yours,
Wendy Beath Anderson, RPR, CRR, FPR
ESQUIRE DEPOSITION SERVICES, INC.
515 North Flagler Drive, P-200
West Palm Beach, Florida 33401
I do hereby waive my signature.
LARRY VISOSKI
3527-003
Page 225 of 227
EFFA_00009900
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
CERT I F I CATE
THE STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
I hereby certify that I have read the
foregoing deposition by me given, and that the
statements contained herein are true and correct to the
best of my knowledge and belief, with the exception of
any corrections or notations made on the errata sheet,
if one was executed.
Dated this ____ day of
2009.
LARRY VISOSKI
Job #127542
3527-003
Page 226 of 227
Larry Visoski October 15, 2009
ERRATA SHEET
IN RE: VS. EPSTEIN CR: WMB
DEPOSITION OF: LARRY VISOSKI
TAKEN: 10.15.09 JOB NO. : 127542
DO NOT WRITE ON TRANSCRIPT - ENTER CHANGES HERE
PAGE f LINE I CHANGE REASON
Please forward the original signed errata sheet to this
office so that copies may be distributed to all parties.
Under penalty of perjury, I declare that I have read my
deposition and that it is true and correct subject to
any changes in form or substance entered here.
DATE:
SIGNATURE OF DEPONENT:
3527-003
Page 227 of 227
EFTA00305998 (Jmail)
 [misc] inventory and TODO list
(inferred date: 2026-01-15)
6/23
Organized by place:
9 E. 71st St
Rich Barnett:
Sarah will need to review the large list from Rich
Sarah:
-Finish going through 6'h, 5th and basement storage
-Photo for balcony of stockade
Rich Kahn:
-Find new office space — JE gave Rich ok to look at 1-15 office spaces. Will forward info after
Shelley:
.bathroom rugs - Shelley has samples to show JE
-entry way carpet — Shelley has samples to show JE
-two arm chairs for living room — Shelley is still looking
-arrange for movers to re-arrange furniture - postponed
-put up scaffolding in living room to paint ceiling — Shelley said if JE wants to paint the ceiling
and move the furniture she is more than happy to coordinate over the next 2 weeks
-Will get marble finishes for entry office - Shelley went to the place JE and Sarah suggested in
NYC but they discontinued that stock so Shelley ordered it from Paris and it will be here next
week. Shelley has selected other sample finishes as well.
LSJ
-List of things to allocate
.Library ceiling
Brice and Karen:
Items in storage — Sarah will go through storage and decide what stays and what goes
VEHICLE PURCHASES
JEE Fleet: 4 x ATV 360/400, 2-x side by sides Polaris Ranger 2 passenger plus cargo deck
MARINE PURCHASES:
.Wave runner storage/lifts - Brice said the old lifts could not handle the weight of the current
wave runners — one lift is still in the box and the other one has a cracked base but could be
repaired. Carlos confirmed with Boat Lift US that the lifts should hold 1200Ibs and the current
wave runners are about 9501bs with fuel. Waiting on response from Carlos and Brice as to how
this makes sense.
-Fishing gear (Igor and Larry are working on this together)
-Pool equipment, unsure of requirement
TIKI HOUSE
-New Roof
-New Lanterns
-New covers for bench seat and cushions
Review Furniture
NEW OFFICE
Purchase new printers for JEE and Sarah
Emad: (Emad added June 23 rd )
Nana Engines — looking into getting Nana refitted with 300 HP engines
gita:

1. Gary is coordinating with Luis Felix (DR stone quarry rep.) and will be going to the DR
sometime between 6-28-10 and 7-6-1
Status of projects and outstanding issues for Jeffrey underlined
LIBRARY
Status interior
I.interiors complete by construction
Outstanding issues
I.ceiling treatment — Shelley said that Ion is to visit in 2 weeks to start painting, which
should take 2-3 weeks to complete giving an estimated finish date of July 8th
2.cabinet finishes - Shipped and waiting delivery
3.floor finishes - Shelley claims that JE is to decide on next trip to island (decision
made by July 1)
Status exterior
1.courtyard paving underway complete by the July 31
Outstanding issues
1.1andscape plans

a. plants - Shelley said that Igala is to fill in an area behind the tiki hut
with plants she and JE chose and Shelley is awaiting new images from
Igala

b. irrigation plans
c. lighting — Shelley said she will send sample lighting options via
email this week
2.Igala has trees tagged ready for delivery as soon as barge is ready
MASTER SUITE
Status interior
I.Construction under way, subject to decisions being made should finish by Oct 31
Outstanding issues
1.steam bench
2.out side shower
3.lites over bed
4.lighting in bedroom
5.electrical in bath area
6.tub deck and surround
7.selection of  wood floor
8.sourcing thassos slabs
9.powderroom vanity plan
I 0.shop drawings for stone
Status exterior
I. Wall under way, complete by Aug 31
Outstanding issues
I. Landscape plans,.lighting in.
KITCHEN
Status
Outstanding issues
I.kitchen design
2.stair and wall design to master
LAUNDRY
I.assume we get permit July 1 should complete by Oct 31
COTTAGES
I.const underway should complete by Sept 30
Outstanding issues
1.shower design
MECHINICAL ELECTRICAL
Status under way should complete by Sept 30
MECHANICAL DESAL
Status under way should complete by Nov 30
Dock House/floating dock
Hanger
CZM
Status submitting by July 1
Plans go in the 20th
Assume approval by September 30
Construction plans by November 31
Permits by January 30
Pool by June 30
Cottage by August 3I
Music room by June 30
Tennis by April 30
Shelley:
To get:
exterior lighting for courtyard
outdoor furniture
To Do:
Revisit the idea to build another guest cottage in current complex on next visit
Bill Murphy:
-Need to coordinate with LSJ to finish wiring for telephone upgrade. Office, Pavilion, Gym,
Boat Captains office all need to be ready to go by 7/12.
-Fax lines need to be terminated and identified (putting new ones in next visit)
-Follow-up trip with Steve Bisby is tentatively scheduled for 7/12/2010.
-We have quotes for increased bandwidth at LSJ. Meet with Wes at Choice week of 7/12 for
details.
Jennaine has an RMA for the Cell Backup units. These need to be returned
-Do we need AppleTV (bandwidth is a problem)
FTC:
-VolP Switch was RMA'd end of May and is installed and ready for phones.
Doug:
-Doug is working on various layouts for the steam room, especially the larger slab that JE asked
for.
-Working on layout of the exterior shower, bench and planters
-Work out the stone wall panel sizes inside and out for electrical layouts
-Working on tub layout for drain and piping
Zorro
Brice and Karen:
.Well problem
.Ponderosa pines at main entrance are in bad shape — What would you like to do
EMPLOYEES:
-Staff Cottage at the Main House requires to be furnished.
-Need to employ new couple or 2 individuals
MAIN HOUSE:
-Stucco Repair - Estimate is for $100,000JE would like to speak to Gary about this on 6/28
.Fountain redo — If the center column was removed the distance from waterline to the top of bowl
would be 31 inches. If the center column and a 7"lower portion of the bowl was removed, the
distance from waterline to top of bowl would be 24 inches. Brice has concerns if center column
and a portion of the bowl was removed then the bowl would be to close to the edge of the lower
basin, water may hit the edge of the basin, instead of directly going into the basin. It would take
JJ 3 - 4 days to complete work. How do you wish to proceed?
.Terrace Tile Repair - received bid would like to review other options
.Plant Mortality - considerable loss last winter. Proposal from Aspen landscaping for replacement
of plant material to bring back to original state quoted at $18,820.68. In addition the bed in front
of the great room window needs to be replanted (it has been 2 years since we did replacement of
this nature)
VEHICLES:
-1995 Tahoe with 158,000 miles and 2003 F250 with 126,000 miles. Both vehicles have
maintenance issues. Brice recommends that both vehicles be sold and the purchase of a dodge
1500 truck to replace them
Recommend purchase of new ranch truck — Larry getting new suburban
Purchase 2 x ATV
BED AND BATH
Already purchasing in preparation for July visit.
Igor:

I. Small fins
2. Swimming goggles
3. Swimming board
4. Swimming trunks
5. Water dumbbells (hydro tone) — Sarah purchased
Bill Murphy:
-Cell reception is poor to none (Boatz is looking into options)
-Wifi needs to be tuned (will research solutions and see if he can fix remotely)
-Only I network plug for master office (researching putting another one in)
Palm Beach
Janusz:
Go over furniture in the storage room with Sarah
Larry:
Will trade Rover, Mere and Jag for 3 Suburbans — Larry will negotiate Wednesday evening and
brief JE on trip to LSJ (Thursday)
Financial Department
Rich Kahn:
-Ion Nicola — outstanding invoices totaling 10,000 (3,333.33(50% of March 24 — April 23) and
6,666.66 (100% of April 24 — May 23)
-Roy Black — May invoice 24,777.50
Critton — May invoice 157,988.55
-Robert Couturier invoice 42,483.54 (they claim they deducted 25K only as other 25K was for
work on the interior package and nonrefundable)
-Gensler — upon new agreement pay 66,263.78
-LSJ Slip C10 — paying 0.91 per foot vs 1.16 that Brice agreed to
-Pinto still owes JE 40K Euro for decoration belts
l'atyana — Promissory Notes (33.950 and 20,000)
Paris:
Bill: (Hill added June 23rd)
-iMac computers are ordered. Anticipated delivery date 6/28/2010.
-Cisco 1811 router ordered for JEE Office. CDW is shipping to 66th street with French power
cord. Per Cisco website, this item is classified as unrestricted and can be brought out of the
country without filing any additional paperwork.
-Need to setup intemet access with a static IP address. (6/29)
-Review existing printers and find acceptable alternative for JEE office and Second Office.
EFTA00005284 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007998 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00074744 (Jmail)
 [legal] USVI court filing about Epstein will and estate
╔════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Yoonsun Chung [bank] Anti-Money Laundering at Deutsche Bank 
╚═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00167059 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank KYC showing Caroline Lang co-ownership with Epstein (?)
(inferred date: 2026-01-16)
KYC Print Page 1 of 16
DB PWM GLOBAL KYC/NCA: PART A rA
KYC Case p : 01704382 Status : 6. Apprond
One sheet must be established per relationship list all accounts included in the relationshi -. .

1. Relationship Details
Relationship Name: SOUTHERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP: BoDkog (enter New York
Relationship Manager. Stewart OldAeld
O New PWM Relationship RI Existing RAM Relationship
Relationship to MYR
If existing, please indicate since when gene rniatonshio exnb, provide reason for new profile and attach old profile:
EZ Client Referral O RN Prospect 0 Intennediary/EIM 0 Other Source (CIB, etc.)
How Was the Chengs)
Introduced' How long has the
RM personally known the client?
please provide details (e.g. ame of referral source, how many years RN personaly has known client, etc.): /envy Epstein
(President of Gratitude /unerka) is a current client of the bank. He and Darren lodyke reached out to Stew Oktheld on 
12/23/2016 to
open a checking account for its newest entity, Prytanee LLC
Does Deutsche Bank pay a
retrocession a similar
O Yes 19 No
compensation to a third party
for the introduction of this
relationship'
Mt Yes, *sate"
List all existing and new accounts involved n this relationship
Legal Entity
Account(%)
Account Name / Number Opening Date (intended/actual)
1 9 Prytanee, LIG - Depose 1/6/2017
who is he primary contact
PerSSII or the RIS' (Pk" : Thisperson eeds to have signatory
rights and/or Information right
for the ccounts.):
Darren Indyke Referred method of contact
(indicate phone no., fax no.,
e-rildi address, etc.):
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di8ce... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002833
KYC Print Page 2 of 16
One sheet must be established for each account to be opened
2. Account Ownership Summary
Account Name: itylanee, /LC • Deposit ACct. Number (1 avalablel.
Account Manager: stewart °Weld
What is the purpose of the account (e.g. portfolio management, advisory account, custody services, longterm investment, 
payment/expeme account)' the purpose of
this account is to managing the monthly expenses ol the company
Indicate from where the assets are expected to arrive
O DB Group: Same Booking Center (indicate account number):
O DB Group: Other Booking Center (indicate C43 bcation and account detain):
0 Other Institution - (Indicate name & location):
O Physical Deposits (specify cash, securities, cheques, ...):
What Is the expected size and frequency of regular Slows and outflow for the account (Indicate estimated number and 
volume per month)': OS inflows/outflows
between 100k to 500k on a monthly basis
What Is the expetted volume of assets and currency for the account approx. 90 days after opening? I 1000000 I CurtenCY I
usd
What is the expected volume of assets and currency for the account approx. one year after opening> 11000000 I Currency 
load
Doesiwin the client have MSS Under Management (AuM) within DB under Eur. 3M> OYes 0  No
nesse list alt parties related to the wont. For each patty:

• Check d a source of wealth description is remind for the party. • heck the appropriate box t describe the relationship
of the party to this account (> 1 can
be selected). • f none of the check boxes pply, desert* the party's relation to the account In the -Other column. • Amy 
describe the relationship between the
parties in the List column.
• Please dril down o the ultirnate/undWifing Beneficial Ovmer(s).
.egal Entkycf Description Source of Weakh required Parties
related to
this
ccount
Sccount>1C Holder ISerrior >timeliest
of :
r01111(5.,' of
- 0 ,J14.1Zi01/
ithmare Semen: cal
h'il,l'r
3ignatory_knledFlnanclal M Ful
'DA
POA Intennedlarraharelsolder
(EDI)
.%)
Signifkant
(>.25%)
Pion-PIE
MANY
Indicate
ownetship
.egal lepresentative
atantorjbettksiscundnq
Donor
Myr (pirase
mess ink other
des and; or
indicate
iSitionship
setween pants)
1 0 0 Prytanee,
tic D 2 O U O 0 0 O 0 0
2 0 O
„trustPant
Southern
r.
n 1--1 0 • 0 0 0 O so O O O
3 la 2
the
! erre
Trust O O • O • O O 50 O O O
4 O 0 /effrey
❑Epstein O O O 0 0 O O O O O
sole shareholder of Southern Trust Company, Inc.;000 of Southern Trust ompany, Inc. Which owns 50% of account holder,
s O O Darr en Indyke O • • O O O O al O O
6 O 0
Carcine
S°PheCamille V ng O • O 0 0 O O O O O
Grantor/Trustee of The Pierre Trust;Grantor/U al The Fleur Trull
nhkh owns 50% of the account molder;
7 O O
Etknne
Rene
lean Blunt
E I O 2 0 D O O O
hops://dbforcepb.my. sal esforce.com/serdet/servl et. Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) OB-SDNY-0002834
KYC Print Page 3 of 16
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002835
KYC Print Page 4 of 16
One sheet meet be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY In Section 2. Account Ownership Samna
3A. Individual Details (for all pubes)
Individual's Name: Jeffrey Epstein - Date of Birth: V20/1953
Country of Residence: USVI Country of Cittenship: USA
Address of primary residence: Ler Saint James Saint Thomas 00807
MS cheat resided outside of
his/her country of nationally for
5 years or may?
O yet Fa NG
Profession/Occupation: Sell Ernpolyed Tax ID / SSN:
Current Employer: Southern Financial LLD Position/Me/Rank: President
Address of employer 6100 Red Hook Quarter 83 St. Thomas United States 00802
Does the person work as senior executive of a DO-recognized regulated entity in the financial
industry? or an entity Isted on a OB-recognised exchange' (Not applicable for operating entities Dyes 2 No
Is the indwdual a Pokkally Exposed Person (PEP)?(/Yes, Yes, describe) ❑°Yes ON°
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual related to an employee of the DB group?(r FarneV
or Friends/no, describe)
Li  Family O Friendship Relent
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual party to a non-banking relalloinhip with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or wrvices))(rf
res,desettbe)
o yes o w
If applicable, indicate which bank officers have met the person: Indicate where and when the dent meetIng(s) took place:
Bank Officer fames) Bank Office: Client Private
Donnie:
(lent Place of
Business: Other Location (specify): Date:
O O O
O O O
O O O
O Wealth Details for this individual are not filled in, because they are the same as for the fon:ming person:
3B. Wealth Detain (Only for parties requiring source of wealth description as indicated in Section 2)
Nature of the Individual's Business: Private investments
Primary Country of source of weakh/source of Funds?
Primary Industry of source of Wealth/Source of Funds?
Summarize Source of Wealth: R Business Owner O Salary/Earnings g Investment O Inheritance/Gifts O Other:
Further Describe Source of Wealth /Detail the history of wealth lot ach of the sources: (e.g. For trusts, how did senior
accumulate wealth? For mho: Rance, how
did
family accumulate wealth?For business owners, how long In business, how many employees, level of profitability? Indicate
type of business, countries of major
activities, important business partners.) Epstein began his !Mantle career in 1976 as an options trader at Bear Stearns 
and became a partner n 1980. In [987,
Epstein founded his own finance management firm, 1. Epstein & Co., managing the assets of clients with more than a 
bigkin in net worth. In 1996, Epstein changed
the name of his lam to The [ma cal Trust Company and based it on the island of St. Thomas in the US Virgin Islands. AN 
of his clients were anonymous except for
the
very weathy businessman Leslie Wexner. His wealth has come from his days at Bear Stearns and his financial management 
firms
Estimated Annual Income(S): 10,000,000.00 Estimated amount of investable assets(S): 550 MM , 100 MM
[signaled Net Worth($): 5500 Mal + Amount of assets planned to Invest with PWM($):
Other Known Financial Institutions:
Institution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
InsUtution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution: County: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforee.cornhervlet/servlet.Integration?lid-0IN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002836
KYC Print Page 5 of 16
IPlease indicate the ramify situation of the Individual (marital status, other family members, etc.):
I
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002837
KYC Print Page 6 of 16
One 'beet meet be establisbeci for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY in Section 2. Account Ownership Samna
3A. Individual Details(fct all pubes)
Indreiduars Name: Darren IndyIt* - Date of El-th:
Country of Residence: USA Country crICIttenstdp: USA
Address of primary residence:
Has client resided outside el
hisflier country of nationally for
5 years or man ,
0 yes fa No
Profession/Occupation: lawyer Tax ID / SSIF:
Current Employer: Southern Financial tLC Position/Me/Rank:
Address of employer: 575 Lexington Ave, 0th Fl Livingston NY United States 10022
Does the person work as senior executive of a DB-recognized regulated entry in the Financial
ndusny7 or an entity listed on a DiSrecocintsed exchange? (Not applicable for operating entities D ees 2 No
Is the indiedual a Politically Exposed Person (PEP)?(/ Yes, describe) 0 Yes OM
To the best of your knowledge, is the indoildual related to an employee of the DB 'VOW(/' Pan*
or Friends/I* describe)
El Family (OHM. • Friendship
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual party to a non-banking relationship with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or wrvices)(tf
Yes/describe)
o yes E640
It applicable, indicate which bank officers have met the person: Indicate where and when the tient meetIngfs) took 
plate:
Bank Officer Plaine(%) Bank Office: Client Private
Domicile:
(lent Plied
Business: Other Location (specify): Date:
stewart oldfield El 0 0 12/23/2016
0 0 0
0 0 •
0Wealth Details for this individual are not filled in, because they are the same as for the following person:
3B. Wealth Detail (Only for parties requiting source of wealth description as indicated in Section 2)
Nature of the Individual's Business:
Primary Country of source of wealth/source of Funds?
Primary Industry of source of Weakh/Source of Funds'
Summarize Source of Wealth: 0 Business Owner 0 SalarylEamings 0 Investment 0 Inheritance/Gifts 0 Other:
Further Descriae Source of Wealth /Detail the history of wealth la ach of the sources: (e.g. For trusts, how did settlor
accumulate weakh,  For inheritance, how
did
family accumulate meakh7for business owners, how long in business, how many employees, level of profitability') Indicate
type of business, countries of motor
activities, important business partners.)
Estimated Annual Income(S): Estimated amount of investable assetH$):
Estimated net Worth(S): Amount of assets planned to Invest with PWM(S):
Other Known Financial Institutions:
Institution: Country: Esl. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution: Country: Eq. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution. Country. Eq. Assets Under Mgt:
Please indcate he fa nib, situation of the individual (marital status, other family members, etc.).
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforee.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002838
KYC Print Page 7 of 16
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002839
KYC Print Page 8 of 16
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY In Section 2. Account Ownership Summary
lk Individual Details (for all parties)
Ind/Musts Name: Calcine Sophie Comae Lang . Date of Bath:
Country of Residence: France Country of Citizenship: France
Address of primary residence:
Has client resided outside of
his/her country of nationality for
5 years or more?
No • Yes
PrattIon/Occupation: Contemporary Art Tax ID / SSN:
Current Employer: Sotheby% Position/Title/Rant Chairman
Address of employer United States
Does the person work as senior executive of a DO-recognized regulated entity in the Mandril
dusts? or an entity ksted on a Off recognised exchange? (Nor applicable for operating entities • Yet R No
Is the indralual a Pokically Exposed Pena (PEP)?(Y Yes, describe) Ei Yes No 121
To the best of your knowledge, is the aidividual related W an employee of the 08 groutP(dParneV
or Thenciship, describe)
O Family O Friendship 2 None
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual party to a non-banking relationship with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, wppier of goods a services), (d
Yes,desalbe)
O  yes o we
If applicable, indicate which bank officers have met the person: Indicate where and when the client meeting(%) took 
place:
Bank Officer Name Bank Office: Clientent Place of (bent
. Business: Other location (speedy): Date:
O Ei O
0 0 O
O O II
O1Yealth Oda& for this Individual are not filed in because they are the same as for the following person:
38. Wealth Details (Onty for parties requiring source of wealth description as radiated in Section 2)
Nature of the Individual's Business: Attorney
Primary Country of source of wealth/source of Fonds?
Primary industry of source of Weath/Souree of Funds?
Summarize Source of Wealth: Diuskiess Owner 2 Salary/Earnings 2 Investment O Inheritance/Gas O Other
Further Describe Source of Wealth /Detail the history of wealth fa each of the sources: (eq. For trusts, how did settler
accumulate wealth? For inheritance, how
did
family accumulate wealth?For business owners, how long in business, how many employees, level of profitability? Indicate
type of business, countries of major
activities, important business partners.) The source of wealth for Caroline Lang derives from her employment as Chairman
of Sothebys Switzerland. Caroline Lang
is
internationally recognized for her in-depth knowledge of the art market and her longstanding expertise in Impressionist,
Modern and Contemporary art. Appointed
Chairman of the Swiss Department of Impressicoist, Modem & Contemporary Art in 2012, this consummate polyglot has 
advised some of the most important collectors
in Switzerland and worldwide. In November 2011, she played a decisive role In the New York sale of 
AbstractIon.Figurathon, an exceptional private collection of
abstract
works by Gerhard Richter and Max Emst which realized a world auction record for a work by Richter at the tine. Caroline 
Lang has also conducted inapt marathon
auctions in Switzedand, the UK and Germany, including the historic week-long coin el works of art from Monrepos Castle 
in Ludrrigsburg In 2000 and the Royal
House
of Hanover in 2005. Ms Lang also serves as an executive for Warner Brothers Dickler annual income is appra. 950k.
Estimated Annual Income($): 450,000.00 Estimated amount of Investable assets(El $1 MM - 2 MM
Estimated Net Worth($): $1 MM - 2 MM Amount of assets planned to invest with PWM(g):
Other Known Financial Institutions:
Institution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt: I
Institution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
https://dbforcepb.my. sal esforce.com/seMet/servl et. Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di &e 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002840
KYC Print Page 9 of 16
Institution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
Please indicate he IansM situation of the indrviclual (marital status, other I and  members, etc.):
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002841
KYC Print Page 10 of 16
One sheet must be established for EACH INDIVIDUAL PARTY in Section 2. Account Ownership Summon
3k Individual Details (fm all parties)
Individual's Plaine: Etienne Pierre lean Binant • ()ate of Birth:
Country of Reskience: France Country of Citizenship: France
Address of primary residence:
Has client resided outside of
his/her country of natIonalty for
5 years or mo'
• Yes 21 No
Profession/Occupation: Finance Tax ID / SSN:
Current Emilio/iv: Prytanee LLC Position/tele/Rank: Manager
Address of employer 6100 Red Hook Quarter B3 St IlioniasUSVI United States
Does the person work as senior xecutrve of a 06-recognized regulated entity in the financial
dustry> or an entity ksted on a 06 recognised exchang' (Not applicable for operating entities Dyes @No
Is the indwklual a Politically Exposed Person (PEP]?(/ Yes, describe) ages ®No
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual related to an employee of the DB 'VOW(/' Pan*
or Friendslia describe)
El Family (Orient U FrIendshiP
To the best of your knowledge, is the individual party to a non:banking relationship with Deutsche
Bank (e.g., external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods our servicesflf
Yes/describe)
o yes o w
If applicable, indicate which bank officers have met the person: Indicate where and when the client meeting(s) took 
place:
Bank Officer flame(%) Bank Office: Client Private
Donate:
(Bent Plated
Business: Other Location (specify): Date:
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0Wealth Details for this individual are not flied in, because they are the same as for the frikming person:
3B. Wealth Detail (Only for parties requiting source of swath description as indicated in Section 2)
Nature of the Individual's Business:
Primary Country of source of wealth/source of Funds?
Primary Industry or source of Weakh/Sourte of Funds"
Summarize Source of Wealth: 0 Business Owner 0 SalarylEamings 0 Investment 0 Inheritance/Gifts CI Other:
Further Descrize Source of Wealth /Detail the history of wealth No ach of the sources: (eq. For trusts, how did settlor 
accumulate weakh,  For inheritance, how
did
family accumulate rnealitlitFor business owners, how long in business, how many employees, level of prolltability? 
Indicate type of business, countries of motor
activities, important business partners.)
Estimated Annual Imome(S): Estimated amount or investable asseti($):
Estimated Net Worth(S): Amount of assets planned to invest with PWM(S):
Other Known Financial Institutions:
Institution: Country: Est. Assets tinder Mgt:
Institution: Country: Eq. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution. Country. Fid. Assets Under Mgt:
Please indicate he lankly situation of the indhodual (marital status, other family members, etc.).
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforee.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002842
KYC Print Page 11 of 16
One
3C. Legal Entity Details (for all Legal Entities)
Legal Entity Name. PryUnee, LLC -
Type of Entity: OFoundation/Assocution l..., I
O Partnership
rust 5 company O Estate Fbrpose of Entity: WIPrivate Investment O
Philanthropic/Charitable • Commercial
Type of Entity Other (specify): ITC Purpose of Entity Other
(SPetifY):
COMM of
Incorporation/registration:
USW Date of incorperatkin /
registration:
7/22/2016
Vdcker Status: Determination Required Volcker Hag: No
Address (city, street, post
code):
6100 Red Hook Quarter B3 St Thomas 00602 United States U.S. TH(/EIN:
Provide a description of the entity's organizational structure, its ownership structure and its Top Management. For 
trusts/foundations, include information
about
revocablllty,settlor and beneficiartes,etc.:
This entity is owned 50/50 by Southern Trust Caimans , Inc owned by Jeffrey Epstein and The Pierre Trust in whk h 
Caroline Lang is the grantor. Etienne absent
is the
manager al the company. Jeffrey and Caroline share the same affinity for art and decided to become partners iwestiw in 
artwork from up and coming artists
together.
They both Invest equally in the purchases of the artwork.
The signatories on this account will be:
Jeffrey Epstein
Darien Indyke
Carolne Lang
Etienne Binant
Please Indicate how ownership of the legal entity Is reflected: MC Agreement
O Special attention: Bearer Shares - Indicate where shares are custodied:
Descrte the chain from the direct owner of the entity to the ultimate beneficial owner Of not Me same persons,. This 
entity is owned 50/50 by Southern Trust
Company Inc owned by Jeffrey Epstein and The Rene Trust In which Carolne Lang Is the grantor. Etienne Milani Is the 
manager of the company. Jeffrey and Carolne
share the same affinity lot art and decided to become partners investing in artwork from up and coming artists together.
They both invest equally in the
purchases of
the artwork.
The signatories on this account will be:
Jeffrey Epstein
Darren Indite
Caroline Lang
Etienne Binant
To the hest of your knowledge, is the entity party toe non-banking midland* with Deutsche Bank
(e.g. external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or services)): Yes O No
Describe Nature of Entity's Primary easiness and Investment Activities
Nature ol the business: investment in artwork of up and coming artists
Countries where business is transacted: t6VI;Clobal
Number of employees: 3+
eet must be established for EACH LEGAL ENTITY in Section 2. Account Summa
3D. Wealth Profile (Only for parties requiring source of wealth description as Indicated in Section 2)
Primary Country of source of iveafth/source of Funds'
Primary industry of source of VlealtIVSource of Funds,
Provide Evidence of Corporate Assets (e.g. balance Meet a eq ivalent summary of assets/babdibes):
I he source of wealth for this entity prima* comes from Jeffrey Epstein and Caroline Lang. Please revert to their 
individual sources of wealth for more details.
Eurnated gross receipts p.a.($): 1,000,00000
Estimated net profit pa. ($): 1,000,000.00
Estimated Investable assets (ST $1 Nil . 2 MM
Potential Amount to be invested with WM ($):
Other Known Financial Insututions:
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-0IN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002843
KYC Print Page 12 of 16
institution: County: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
Instilldorm Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
One sheet must be established for EACH LEGAL ENTITY in Section 2 Account Summary
3C. Legal Entity Details (For all Legal Entities)
legal Entity Plaine: Southern Trust Company, Inc. -
Type d (MO: I:: foundation/Associationtion 0 Trust RI Company 0 Estate
El Partnership
purposed Entity: ®Private Investment O
Banthrock/Cheritable OCeemnerclal
Type of Entity Other (specify): Pu
(sPecify
of Entity Other rpose
):
Country of
incorporabooffregistratIon:
US Virgin islands Dated incorporation /
registration:
11/18/2011
Vokker Status: Detenninatico Required Vokker Flag: Ito
Address (city, street, pmt
code):
6100 Red Hook Quarter 83 St Thomas, USV100807 United States U.S. TINT IN:
Provide a description of the entity'S organizational structure, its ownership structure and its Top Management. for 
tnith/lOu ndations, include informalico
about
revocabllity,settlor and benefklarles,etc.:
Jeffrey Epstein Is the sole shareholder of Southern Trust
Flease indicate how ownership of the legal entity is reflected:
O Special attendon: Bearer Shares • Indicate where shares are custodied.
Describe the chain from the direct °sorer of the entity to the ultimate beneficial owner Minot the same persons). 
Jeffrey Epstein es the sole shareholder of
Southern
Trust
To the best d your knowledge, is the entity party to a non-banking relationship with Deutsche Bank
(e.g. external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods a serservices)': yesL..J.— No
Describe Nature of Entity's Primary Business and Investment Activities
Nature of the business: Consult and invest dent funds and gain revenue based on lees and returns
Countries where business Is transacted: US Virgin Islands
Number of employees: 4
3D. Wealth Profile (Only Ica parties requiring source of wealth description as indicated in Section 2)
Primary Country of source of weakh/source of Funds?
Primary Industry of source of Weakh/Source of Funds?
Provide Evidence of Corporate Assets (e.g. balance sheet a eq ivalent summary of assetsrliabities):
Consulting Services relying on Financial and Ellornedkal algorithms. Southern Trust is a private consulting company that
invests the assets of their clients and
gets thew
revenue from the return of these investments. Southern Trust invests in different pordolbs catered to their clients and 
makes they revenue based on the returns
and
he lees associated with managing their clients assets
Estimated gross receipts p.a.(1): 2,000,010.00
Estimated net profit p.a. (5): 1500,030.00
Estimated investable assets (5): 52 MM - 5 MM
Potential Amount to be Invested with PWM (5):
Other Known Financial institutions:
Institution: db Country: usa Est. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution: Country: Est. Mitts Under Mgt:
Institution: Country: 1st. Assets Under Mgt:
One street mast be established for EACH LEGAL ENTITY in Section 2 Account Summary
3C. Legal Entity Details (for all legal Entities)
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforee.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-0IN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0002844
KYC Print Page 13 of 16
Legal Entry Name: Be Pierre Trust -
Tyne of Entity: OFoundaboo/Associabon 0 Trust O Company O Estate
O Partnership
Purpose or Entity:
Purpose rd Entity Other
(sPecitr):
EOprivate Investment O
philanthropic/Charitable O COMMff(Pal
Type of Entity Other (specify):
Country of
Incorporation/regIstration:
USVI Date of incorporation /
registration:
11/21/2016
Volcker Status: Determination Required Vdcker Hag: No
Address (city, street, post
code):
U.S. TINAIN
Provide a description of the entitys organizational structure, as ownership structure and its Top Management. For 
trusts/foundations, include information about
revocability,settlor and beneficianes,etc.:
Grantor•trustreMenefkrary: Car line fang residing at
her death, her children become the benHkaries rod both residing
it
Please indicate haw ownership of the legal entity is reflected: trust agreement
O Special attention: Bearer Shares • Indicate where shares are custodled:
..........11 er et entity to the ultimate beneficial owner Of not We same pecsonsf. Grantor/trustee/beneficiary: 
Caroline Lang resider/ at
Cn her death, her children become the benelklarie bath residing
at
To the best of your knowledge, Is the entity party to a nom banking relationship with Deutsche Sank
(e.g. external legal counsel, client referral source, supplier of goods or sertkes)':
.---.
yes U No121
Describe Nature of Entity's Primary Business and Investment Activities
Nature of the business: OW
Countries where business is transacted: VSVI,6lobal
Number of employees- 0
3D. Wealth Profile (Only for parties regunig source of wealth description as indicated in Sectkm 2)
Primary Country of source of weaRNsource of Funds.>
Primary industry of source of Weath/Source of Funds,
Provide Evidence of Corporate Assets (e.g. balance sheet or eq Nalent summary of assets/liabitties):
The source of weal, for this trust deities from Caroline Lang. Please revert to her source of wealth for more detads.
Estimated gross receipts pea): 1,000,000.00
Estimated net profs p.a. (5) 1,003,000.00
Estimated Investable assets (5): 31 NM - 2 MM
Potential Amount to be invested with PWM (5):
Other Known Financial Institutions:
Institution: Country: Bt. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
Institution: Country: Est. Assets Under Mgt:
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/serdet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9Di&e 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SONY-0002845
KYC Print Page 14 of 16
DB PWM GLOBAL KYC/NCA: US/LatAnairl PART B rA
Relationship Name SOUINERN FINANCIAL RELATIONSHIP
Risk Ratirig Comments:
Booking Center 0 KY ID NY/Offshore 00ffshore IROiskModerate O CJ S High Risk Yoonsun Chung
(Compliance Signature)
O D8 Employee ODD Managed PlC O 08 s Trustee/Co-Trustee ID Bearer Shares

4. Attaehmemb
A Type of Photo ID Provided O Drivers License .4 Passport • National/Slate ID 00ther
8. Checklist of names (indniduals and/or entitles) that were submkted for database searches is attached Oyes El No

C. Please indicate the results of the database searches performed
ROC searches complete @Yes 0 flo negatrre results found OYes @No
PCR checks complete ayes ONO negative results found Ora Eno
OFAC chece. complete @ you Ono negative results found Ores Eno
INS searches complete (teitis/Nexis, Factna, Reuters. Dow Jones, DAB) @Yes O No negative results found O 'fa El no
Denial Orders checks complete ayes O No negative results found Ores @No
Martindale Hubbell searched (LawyerifLaw Firms onN) Oyes Eno negative results found 0 Yes Ono

D. Please from database summarize any negative results the searches indicated above:
E. To the best of your knowledge, has the client ever been convicted of a criminal offense' O Yes Eno
F
To the best el your knowledge, has the customer ever been invoked in any past litigation agaest
Deutsche Bank AG or any of es subsidiaries or is the customer threatening litigation against Deutsche
Bank AG or any of its subsidiaries> (If Yes, pews* obtails actor and contact Quaky Mgt. (tatinVIAt7) ElYeS  2IN°
or me Regulus 10y COMM/ GI0140 and not& COMPCJI7CC nnedatek)
Does the client or related party have any financial or ether association / interactions within countries or
by Office Foreign Assets Control • Yes @No regimes sanctioned the of (OPAL),
H Does the client arelated party have any financial or other association/ interactions Ishii high risk
countries' Ores Eno

I. Corporate Documentation Attached (Legal Entries Only) ®Yes 0 No 0 Not Applicable
3. Undisclosed Principal Form Complete (Intermediaries Only) Oyes Os J  Not Applicable

K. If Lexk/Nexis Search Resuks, Corporate Documents or Other Supporting Documentation is not In English, please provide 
an Engksh summary of the
nature/contents of the non.English Documentation:

L. Special Risk Factors
Does the account have Nexus to Special Risk Countries' O Yes 2 No
Is the account structure unusually complex? 0 yes 0 No
for Is there any indication the client set up a non operating company expressly • Yes ® No the purpose of transferring 
shares to third parties'
Is there any indkation this could be a prattled business relationship? 0 Yes 12 No
Are the bearer shares identified subject to acceptable controls' • Yes E No
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/serviet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9DiSce... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002846
KYC Print Page 15 of 16

M. Case Comments
Created By Date Comments
Cynthia Rodriguez L 10/117 1:12 PM Southern Trust Company nan existing client  DB. Thew entity documents can be found n 
approved case
01007793.
Cynthia Rodriguez 1/10/117 1:01 PM The Rene Trust was incorporated in USVI but the graMoutrinteelbene is a foreign 
national. Therefore there is no
tax ID.
Cynthia Rodriguez 1718/117 4:59 PM Per 08  Internal Pierre Trust ID because has foreign lax team, the would not require 
a tax this trust a grantor owner.
See attached email from Rich lams'.
Cynthia Rodriguez 1/10/117 12:01 AM Recent research for Darren Indite and Jeffrey Epstein can be round in use 01651789.
Cynthia Rodriguez 1/10/117 1:03 RI Resolutbn for signing authority has been attached.
Cynthia Rodriguez 1/10/117 3:55 PM See attached response Iron Darren Indyke regarding the 71N on the trust.
ONSHORE APPROVALS
Cient Facing Prolessignal (CFP): tern sohrab Signature)
era sohrab
Lcli/701/
Office Director/BusMess Head: Armen Brash ,Signature)
Armen brash
1/6/2017
Regional Off ke Director: ;Signature)
AML Business Risk:
(Signature)
AMI Compliance
linen Mill
Yoorisan churn)
(Signature)
Gatri Hill
Yoonsun Chung
1/191/011
1/19/2017
LATAM/INTERNATIONAL APPROVALS
( bent I a( mg IYolessegnal (CI P): (sr:nature)
Account Manager: (Srp.ituri.)
Global Market Tearn Head (GM11:1)/Sub-
Market Team Head (SPITH):
rsinnatuto
AML Business Risk:
(c.rAtilt.)
AML Compliance.
(sugmtum)
PRIVATE WEALTH MANAGEMENT POLICY STATEMENT: Deutsche Bank Private Wealth Management (PIII0
worldwide is committed to professionally serve the interests of its clients. To do so. Client Facing Professionals1(1) 
(CFP's)
should establish and maintain business relationships only with pylons who satisfy our high standards of suitability.
background and character. Due diligence obtained on the client must be appropriately documented by the CFP. U is the
responsibility ofCFP's to demonstinte that they know their client both at the inception of a relationship and on an 
ongoing
basis.
DECLARATION FOR ALL SIGNERS OF THIS FORM: To the best of my knowledge and belief the above information is
Imps://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid-OIN30000000D9Di&e... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) D B-SD NY-0002847
KYC Print Page 16 of 16
correct and up to date. I confirm that I have no suspicions relating to the money laundering or unethical activities on 
the
pan of the therm(s) and that I have followed all the procedures relating to account opening as described in the PIM
Americas Procedures and the PWM Global KYC Policy

(I) Client Facing Professionals (CFP 's) include: Relationship Managers, Wealth Advisors, Product Officers, Brokers. 
Client
Managers. etc.
Deutsche Bank Americas New York rA
https://dbforcepb.my.salesforce.com/servlet/servlet.Integration?lid=01N30000000D9DiSce... 7/30/2019
CONFIDENTIAL — PURSUANT TO FED. R. GRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0002846
EFTA02731023 (Jmail)
 [politics] letter from Senator Ron Wyden to Leon Black
(inferred date: 2026-01-16)
RON WAVY OREGON. (MAIRMAN
DEW STARENDLY.NIONGAPI MIKE CRAP°. IDAHO
MARIA CANTWELL WASHINGTON MUCK GRASSIER. IOWA
ROBERT MENTNITRZ RIEW ARMY ANN comenE TEXAS
DE IMAMIN L. CAR IN. MPAYLANO
SHERK0 MOWN ONO
MICNAEL F. RELINE T. COLORADO
POSER! P CASEY. Ai PE ANSYLVANTA
MARK WARNER %TRONA
SHFLOON WHITOCUSE. RHODE ISLAND
MAGGIE HASSAN. NEW HAMPSEIRE
WIEST( COOTIE MASTO. NEVADA
ELIZABETH WARREN MASSAORKE YTS
JOHN IDIU.C. SOUTH DAKOTA
DM SCOTT. SOUTH CAROLINA
pµ CASSIDY. LOUISIANA
JAWS LANKFORD. OKLAHOMA
SIEVE PONES. MONTANA
TODD YOUNG INOIANA
JOHN PARRASSO WYOMING
RON JOHNSONAMSGONSIN
TOM flint NORTH CAROLINA
MARSHA SIACKLIMIN TERM SSE t
JOSHUA SENNEMAN. STAFF ORION:RI
GREGG PICNAPO. REPLItuCAN STAIR Oat MA
lamed *tatcs *mate
July 24, 2023
Leon D. Black
do Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck LLP
410 Seventeeth Street
Suite 2200
Denver, Colorado 80202-4432
Dear Mr. Black,
COMMITTEE ON FINANCE
WASHINGTON, DC 20510-6200
As Chairman of the Senate Finance Committee ("the Committee"), I write regarding the
Committee's investigation into your financial dealings with Jeffrey Epstein. This effort is part of
an ongoing set of investigations by the Committee into the means by which ultra-high net worth
persons avoid or evade paying federal taxes, including gift and estate taxes. These investigations
include the avoidance of billions of dollars in income, gift and estate taxes through the use of tax
shelters such as Private Placement Life Insurance; the possible circumvention of laws related to
gift taxes and deductions involving the complementary use of private aircraft/superyachts by
public officials; and the use of Swiss banks by wealthy taxpayers to expatriate from the United
States and evade gift taxes while concealing offshore accounts from the Internal Revenue
Service (IRS).

As you are aware, the Committee is investigating the $158 million in payments you made
to Epstein for services related to a variety of tax and estate planning matters. In particular, the
Committee seeks information on Epstein's participation in structuring trusts and other complex
transactions designed to avoid federal gift and estate taxes on as much as $2 billion in wealth
transferred to your children. The Committee also seeks information regarding Epstein's
extraordinary compensation scheme, which involved amounts that far exceeded those paid to
other professional advisors involved in your tax and estate planning.

Unfortunately, the inadequate responses you have provided the Committee only raise
more questions than answers, and fail to address a number of tax issues my staff has uncovered
over the course of this investigation. This includes understanding the amount by which you were
overpaid income from assets placed in a trust while devising a scheme to ensure that those assets,
worth billions of dollars, would remain outside your taxable estate. Additionally, you have
refused to answer questions or provide documents related to payments you made to Epstein or
substantiate how such payments were calculated or were compensation for services. Your failure
to substantiate Epstein's compensation scheme has heightened the Committee's concerns about
whether such payments were properly characterized as income or gifts for tax purposes.
Background
As you know, on June 22, 2022, the Committee initiated an investigation into your
business arrangement with Epstein. As part of the Committee's investigation, the Committee sent
a letter to Apollo Global Management ("Apollo") with detailed requests for information
regarding the findings of a review commissioned by Apollo's Board of Directors into your
financial ties to Epstein.' The Board's review was initiated in response to Epstein's indictment in
federal court on sex trafficking charges involving the exploitation and abuse of dozens of
underage girls.2 The findings of the Apollo board's review, compiled in a report prepared by the
law firm Dechert LLP ("the Dechert report"), were published in a filing by Apollo with the U.S.
Securities and Exchange Commission!
The Dechert report indicated that you paid Epstein $158 million between 2012 and 2017
for his advice on several tax and estate planning matters.' These transactions included a
"proprietary" solution Epstein devised to help you resolve issues with a grantor trust you created
in 2006 to transfer assets to your children while avoiding approximately $1 billion in gift and
estate taxes.' The Dechert report also claimed that Epstein assisted you with a "step-up-basis
transaction" ("the step-up-basis transaction") designed to save you an additional $600 million in
taxes.`
The Committee's initial letter, a copy of which is attached, asked detailed questions on
the nature of Epstein's tax and estate planning services as well as details regarding payments to
'Letter from Senator Ron Wyden, Chairman, Senate Finance Committee to Apollo Global Management, Jun. 2,
2022.

'Jere)  Epstein Charged in Manhattan Federal Court With Sex Trafficking Of Minors, U.S. Department of Justice,
Jul. 8, 2019, https:/Avwwjustice.goviusao-sdny/pr/jeffrey-epstein-chargcd-manhattan-federal-court-sex-trafficking-
Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation of Epstein/Black Relationship and Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
tutpc-//www sec gov/Archivesledgaddata/1411494/000119312521016405/d11810/dex991 htlli

Id. at pg. 3: "Epstein regularly advised [Leon] Black on a variety of issues related to trust and estate planning, tax,
philanthropy, and the operation of the Family Office" and at pg. 4: "[Leon] Black compensated Epstein for his work
in amounts that were intended to be proportional to the value provided by Epstein. Those payments for work
performed over the period 2012 through 2017 totaled $158 million."
51d. at pg. 9: "There was a consensus among witnesses that Epstein offered a unique solution to a potential estate
planning problem that arose out of a trust known as the 2006 Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (2006 GRAT)" and at
pg. 10: "Witnesses differed on what the value of the estate tax would have been today or in the future if the issues
had not been resolved, but they believed the estate tax liability could have been as much as $1 billion or more...
Epstein approached Black with his solution — which Epstein asserted was proprietary — and Black agreed to pay
Epstein to implement this solution. Outside legal counsel described the solution as a "grand slam" and one that met
all of Black's financial and estate planning goals."
'Id. at pg. 10: "Epstein appears to have provided significant value to a subsequent transaction that addressed certain
loans between [Leon] Black and certain family trusts for the purpose of achieving a tax benefit for his children" and
at pg. 11: "Epstein estimated that this transaction had saved 5600 million in value and Black appears to have agreed
with that estimate."
Epstein. Payments to Epstein, at an annualized rate of $23 to $26 million per year, was higher
than the median CEO pay for Fortune 500 companies, which Fortune calculated at $15.9 million
for 20217 The Dechert report indicated that the amounts paid to Epstein far exceeded those
which you paid to other professional advisors.'
Since then, members of my staff held several meetings with your outside counsel at Paul,
Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP ("Paul Weiss") and Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck
LLP ("Brownstein") to discuss your cooperation with the Committee's investigation. In those
meetings, your outside counsel indicated that you were unwilling to answer questions regarding
details of payments to Epstein. However, your counsel indicated you were willing to provide the
Committee information related to tax issues involving the 2006 Grantor Retained Annuity Trusts
("the 2006 GRATs"), the remainder trust into which the assets from the 2006 GRATs flowed
into ("the remainder trust"), and the step-up-basis transaction. The Committee subsequently
directed follow up requests for information to you on January 1r, 2023 and February 6ih, 2023,
which you responded to on January 16'" and February 21, 2023, respectively.'
While the Committee appreciates the information you have provided, the responses
declined to answer several questions related to important tax issues concerning the assets held in
the remainder trust, claiming that these requests were "outside the scope of the Committee's
purview.i 1' This claim is without merit, as the Senate Finance Committee has jurisdiction over
all matters related to federal tax laws. Investigations into matters pertaining to the operation and
enforcement of internal revenue laws are squarely within the Committee's legislative purview.
Among the issues you refused to address were the extent to which you received excess
distributions of income from the assets held in the remainder trust, important details on the
mutual release of claims strategy that Epstein may have devised, and the degree to which you
retained voting powers with respect to assets held in the remainder trust." This information is
essential for the Committee to evaluate the means by which you retained income from your
ownership of Apollo holdings while avoiding gift and estate taxes on the transfer of enormous
wealth to your children.

The Committee also remains concerned by your continued refusal to answer questions
related to payments to Epstein and how such amounts were calculated in relation to any services
provided. To date, the Committee has not received a sufficient explanation as to why Epstein
was paid amounts vastly exceeding that paid to other attorneys and accountants involved in these
7 The top 10 highest paid CEOs of the Fortune 500, Fortune, May 28, 2022, https-//fortune com//022/05/28/highest-
paid-ccos-in-america-202 I/.

' Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation of Epstein/Black Relationship and Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
https:/Avww.sec.gov/Archiv&edgar/data/14 11494/000 I 193 I 2521016405/dI I 8102dex99 I .htm- (at pg. 17: "It is
clear that the compensation paid by [Leon] Black to Epstein far exceeded any amounts Black paid to his other
professional advisors.")
9 Letter from Senator Ron Wyden, Chairman, Senate Finance Committee to Leon D. Black, Jan. 13, 2023; Email
from Majority Staff, Senate Finance Committee to outside Counsel to Leon Black at Paul, Weiss, Rifkind Wharton
& Garrison LLP, Feb. 6, 2023.

10 Memorandum submitted on behalf of Leon Black by Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP to Senator
Ron Wyden, Chairman, Senate Finance Committee, Feb. 2I, 2023.
"Id
transactions, and why you were willing to pay Epstein over $100 million without a written
services agreement or contract.
Overpayments of income and other issues arising from trust tax avoidance scheme
A central focus of the Committee's investigation is understanding what role Epstein
played in solving an estate tax issue involving the 2006 GRATs. The Dechert report first
described this issue as an estate tax "problem" that if left unresolved would lead to a potential
estate tax liability for your children of $1 billion or more. 12 The Dechert report also claimed that
Epstein offered a "proprietary" solution that helped address this problem and allowed you to
keep the assets in the 2006 GRATs outside of your taxable estate. In order to better understand
this transaction, the Committee sent several requests for information related to tax issues arising
from the 2006 GRATs, the assets held in the 2006 GRATs, and the solution Epstein proposed to
ensure the assets would not be subject to gift and estate taxes.

In response to the Committee's investigation, you indicated that there were no issues or
problems with the 2006 GRATs themselves. Instead, you clarified that there was a tax-related
concern with the remainder trust which the assets held in the 2006 GRATs were to be transferred
into upon the expiration of the 2006 GRATs." It appears that because you were receiving
income from assets held in the remainder trust, there was concern that the assets held in the trust
would be included in your taxable estate.14 Under Internal Revenue Code Section 2036(a)(1), if a
taxpayer gives away assets to a third party while retaining the right to income from those assets,
those assets are included in the taxpayer's gross estate at the taxpayer's death. A related tax
provision under Section 2035(a) provides that gifts of property made within three years of the
donor's death would be included in the decedent's taxable estate. 15
12 Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation of Epstein/Black Relationship and Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
klips-/Avww gee gov/Archiveciedgaridata/1411494/0001193125210164051d11810/dex99 him; (at pg. 9: "There
was a consensus among witnesses that Epstein offered a unique solution to a potential estate planning problem that
arose out of a trust known as the 2006 Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (2006 GRAT)" and at pg. 10: "Witnesses
differed on what the value of the estate tax would have been today or in the future if the issues had not been
resolved, but they believed the estate tax liability could have been as much as $1 billion or more."
11 Memorandum submitted on behalf of Leon Black by Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP to Senator
Ron Wyden, Chairman, Senate Finance Committee, Jan. 16, 2023 (at pgs. I & 2: "The memorandum respectfully
proceeds on the belief that the premise of the question — that them were `issues with the 2006 GRAT' is based on a
misunderstanding. Them were no issues or problems associated with the 2006 GRATs themselves. The 2006
GRATs functioned as intended, and were in no way out of the ordinary for such instruments, nor were they
problematic. Instead, there was a potential tax-related concern with the trust ('the remainder trust') into which the
assets held in the 2006 GRATs were to be transferred into upon the expiration of the GRATs.")
" Id. at pg. 2: "Under the terms of the remainder trust, the trustees were to distribute to Mr. Black income generated
by certain specified assets. The trustees had a right to terminate Mr. Black's income interest. Under Internal
Revenue Code Section 2036(a)(1), if a taxpayer gives away assets to a third party while retaining the right to income
from those assets, those assets am included in the taxpayer's gross estate at the taxpayer's death."
111d. at pg. 2: "A related estate tax issue involved Section 2035(a), which provides that if the decedent relinquished
a power with respect to transferred property (which would include relinquishing an income interest of this nature)
during the three-year period ending on his date of death, that property would also be included in his gross estate.
Despite the fact that, as noted above, the trustees, rather than Mr. Black, would be terminating Mr. Black's income
interest, and therefore Section 2035(a) would not be implicated, out of an abundance of caution, and given Mr.
Black's age, all parties wanted to act promptly to resolve this issue (without a potential three-year tail)."
At the time the 2006 GRATs were funded, the assets in the remainder trust had an
appraised value of approximately $585 million. 16 The assets in the remainder trust comprised of
your interest in various Apollo partnerships prior to Apollo's initial public offering, which your
advisors believed could reasonably be expected to increase in value over time to an amount
exceeding $2 billion." Operating on the basis of a tax rate of 40% to 50% for net federal and
state estate taxes, the estimated tax liability resulting from these assets being included in your
estate at time of death could have exceeded $1 billion. 18
In order to prevent the Apollo assets in the remainder trust from being subject to gift and
estate taxes, you consulted with Epstein and retained established trust and estate lawyers from
Weil Gotshal and Paul Weiss to devise a solution. Epstein proposed that the trustees of the trust
prepare an accounting to ascertain the amount of income that was distributable to you under the
remainder trust agreement compared to the amounts that were in fact distributed to you.1° That
accounting revealed that you had been over-distributed income by the trustees of the remainder
trust?' This review also revealed that the trustees distributed income to you from assets other
than those identified in the remainder trust agreement.' As a result of these overpayments, your
advisors believed that the trustees of the remainder trust agreement had a claim against you to
claw back excess distributions.' Conversely, had the trustees removed you as a beneficiary of
the remainder trust, you could have alleged a claim for breach of fiduciary duty."
16 Id. at pg. 4: "The 2006 GRATs were funded with: a 30.35% interest in Apollo Management III, LP, with an
appraised value as of funding of $460,000; a 30.35% interest in Apollo Management IV, LP, with an appraised
value as of funding of $1,420,000; a 30.35% interest in Apollo Management V, LP, with an appraised value as of
funding of $3,690,000; a 30.35% interest in Apollo Management VI, LP, with an appraised value as of funding of
$45,600,000; a 26.8% interest in Apollo Investment Management, LP, with an appraised value as of funding of
$227,000,000; a 26.9% interest in Apollo Value Management, LP, with an appraised value as of funding of
$9,600,000; a 44% interest in Apollo SVF Management, LP, with an appraised value as of funding of $87,000,000;
a 44% interest in Apollo Asia Management, LP, with an appraised value as of funding of $20,800,000; a 44%
interest in Apollo Europe Management, LP, with an appraised value as of funding of $98,800,000; a 44% interest in
Apollo Alternative Assets, LP, with an appraised value as of funding of $80,500,000; and 142 points of each of
Apollo Advisors VI, LP and Apollo Advisors VI (EH), with an appraised value as of funding of $10,535,335."
17 Memorandum submitted on behalf of Leon Black by Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP to Senator
Ron Wyden, Chairman, Senate Finance Committee, Feb. 21, 2023 (at pg. 5: "the values of the assets held in the
remainder trust could reasonably be expected to increase to an amount exceeding $2 billion by the time of Mr.
Black's death.")
"Id. at pg. 5: "Operating on the basis of an assumed tax rate of 40% to 50% for net federal and state taxes,
the estimated tax liability savings as a result of those assets no longer being included in his estate was estimated to
exceed $1 billion."
19 Memorandum submitted on behalf of Leon Black by Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP to Senator
Ron Wyden, Chairman, Senate Finance Committee, Jan. 16, 2023 (at pg. 3: "Mr. Epstein proposed that the trustees
prepare an accounting to ascertain the amount of income distributable to Mr. Black under the trust agreement and
the amounts that were in fact distributed to him.")
2° Id. at pg. 3: "That accounting revealed that the trustees had inadvertently over-distributed income to Mr. Black."
21 Id. at pg. 3: "Specifically, the trustees distributed to Mr. Black income attributable to assets other than those
identified in the trust agreement as the source of Mr. Black's income interest."
22 Id. at pg. 3: "For that reason, the trustees of the remainder trust had a claim against Mr. Black to claw back the
excess distributions."
n Id. at pg. 3: "On the other hand, had the trustees removed Mr. Black as a beneficiary of the remainder trust, Mr.
Black might have alleged a claim for breach of fiduciary duty."
According to your attorneys, it was at this point that Epstein allegedly proposed a
solution, which involved a mutual release of claims by and between you and the trustees of the
remainder trust. The settlement and mutual release provided that you would lose your right to
income from the remainder trust while confirming that you would not assert any claim for being
removed as a beneficiary of the trust, in exchange for the trustees agreeing to not seek to claw
back any excess distributions of income.24 You confirmed to the Committee that you and the
trustees both formally agreed to a mutual release of claims, with each side "receiving
consideration." 25 As a result of this scheme reportedly devised by Epstein, your tax advisors took
the position that you no longer had the income rights from the remainder trust that would have
caused the trust's assets to be included in your taxable estate (as outlined in Section 2036(a)
(1)).26 Your tax advisors also took the position that this solution eliminated any potential risks of
inclusion of the assets in your taxable estate arising from the three-year tail caused by Section
2035(a).

In order to fully understand the tax implications of the trust scheme devised with
Epstein's assistance, Committee staff sent a set of follow up questions on the matter to your
counsel on February 6, 2023. Unfortunately, you have refused to answer or provide information
regarding several important tax-related questions arising from this transaction, including the
following:
■ First, you have refused to answer questions regarding the amount by which you were
overpaid income by the trustees of the remainder trust. You have also refused to answer
questions on the period in which these distributions occurred and how the amount of
income that was over-distributed was calculated. The Committee is concerned by the
possibility that you may have received impermissible distributions of income worth
millions of dollars beyond that allowable by the terms of the remainder trust.

■ Second, you have refused to answer questions related to the consideration provided to the
trustees or the consideration provided by the trustees as part of the mutual release of
claims. As such, the Committee has no idea what financial exchange or other
consideration was provided in order to keep assets worth billions of dollars out of your
taxable estate. It is possible that, if your release of a right to income from the remainder
trust was for less than full and adequate consideration, such release of claims could
constitute an additional taxable gift.

■ Third, you have refused to answer questions on the extent to which you retained voting
control of shares in Apollo and its partnerships while shifting those assets into the
Z' Id. at pg. 3: "Mr. Epstein's solution contemplated a mutual release of these claims by and between Mr. Black, on
the one hand, and the trustees of the remainder trust, on the other. The settlement and mutual release provided that
Mr. Black would lose his income right, while confirming that he would not assert any claim for his removal as a
beneficiary, in exchange for the trustees not pursuing claims to claw back the excess distributions."
n Id. at pg. 3: "Both sides thus agreed to a formal release of these potential claims, with each side receiving
consideration."
16 Id. at pg. 3: "The ultimate result was that Mr. Black no longer had the income rights that would have potentially
caused the trust's assets to be included in his estate at death, without risking estate inclusion under Section
2035(a) (if he were to die within three years of the mutual releases)."
remainder trust to avoid gift and estate taxes. As you may be aware, under the principles
of Section 2036 of the Internal Revenue Code, property transferred to a trust with respect
to which the transferor retains enjoyment or retains certain voting rights may be
includable in the transferor's taxable estate under certain circumstances.

■ Lastly, you have refused to answer questions as to whether you borrowed heavily against
the assets held in the remainder trust. The Committee requested information on whether
you, or any entities you are affiliated with, including your family office (Elysium
Management LLC), have taken out any loans against the value of the assets held in the
remainder trust. This request included questions on the value of these loans as well as any
powers you, the trustees or any other parties held with respect to the loans from the
remainder trust.

This arrangement raises serious concerns that, in spite of significant violations of the
terms of the remainder trust, you were potentially paid millions of dollars in excess income while
keeping enormous amounts of wealth outside of your taxable estate. The Committee needs
further information to assess how this scheme essentially served as a workaround to federal tax
laws which clearly state that such distributions of income would cause the assets held in the
remainder trust to be subject to gift and estate taxes.

Further, questions surrounding retained voting rights of business interests held in trust
and the potential to borrow against those assets raises significant public policy concerns. Even if
retained voting rights with respect to business interests fall outside of the scope of Section
2036(b), the possibility that wealthy individuals might assert to the IRS that they do not own
business interests held in trust for gift and estate tax purposes, while simultaneously borrowing
against those interests and retaining voting power, raise serious questions about the integrity of
our gift and estate tax system.
You have confirmed to the Committee that the IRS has not reviewed the 2006 GRATs,
the remainder trust or the mutual release of claims scheme as part of an audit, raising yet more
concerns about the IRS's visibility into such transactions and the agency's compliance efforts.
Epstein's role in the step-up-basis transaction lacks substantiation
The Committee submitted detailed requests for information related to Epstein's role in a
step-up-basis transaction involving certain family trusts created for the purpose of avoiding tax.
According to the Dechert report, Epstein allegedly provided "significant value" to the step-up-
basis transaction, which will apparently save you approximately $600 million in future gift and
estate taxes." The Dechert report also stated that while the idea for the complex transaction did
not originate with Epstein, Epstein "played an instrumental role in completing it."28
However, responses you provided to the Committee minimized Epstein's involvement in
the transaction, stating that "the idea was in the public domain and originated with Black's other
legal advisors. Nevertheless, Epstein tried to take credit for the idea and secure compensation."29
Your attorneys further added that the dispute over compensation for the step-up-basis transaction
contributed to your decision to terminate your professional relationship with Mr. Epstein." The
Committee is concerned that these responses are at odds with the Dechert report's claim that
Epstein's role in the transaction was "significant" or "instrumental." In fact, your responses did
not provide any information clarifying how Epstein contributed any value to the transaction
outside of that provided by other legal advisors.

The responses you provided the Committee did not substantiate Epstein's services related
to the step-up-basis transaction and cast further doubt on whether his efforts merited the payment
of $20 million. Based on the information you have provided thus far, this is an extraordinary
amount to pay any consultant or attorney, particularly without a formal services agreement or
contract, written or otherwise. According to the Dechert report, there was an "understanding"
between you and Epstein that Epstein would be compensated for some portion of the value
conferred from any idea that "originated" from Epstein." However, your responses made clear
that the idea for the step-up-basis transaction did not originate with Epstein, but instead
originated with other legal advisors.

Despite Epstein's limited and heavily disputed role in the step-up-basis transaction,
Epstein demanded payment of $60 million.92 The Committee still does not know how or why you
settled on a payment of $20 million instead of the $60 million Epstein demanded for the
"Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation of Epstein/Black Relationship and Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
htips:/Avww.sec.gov/Archivestedgar/data/1411494/0001 I 93 I 2521016405/d118102dex99l.htm - (at pg. 10: "Epstein
appears to have provided significant value to a subsequent transaction that addressed certain loans between [Leon]
Black and certain family trusts for the purpose of achieving a tax benefit for his children" and at pg. 11: "Epstein
estimated that this transaction had saved $600 million in value and Black appears to have agreed with that
estimate.")
a Id. at pg. I I: "Outside counsel stated that this transaction did not originate from Epstein but that Epstein had
nevertheless played an instrumental role in completing it."
" Memorandum submitted on behalf of Leon Black by Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP to Senator
Ron Wyden, Chairman, Senate Finance Committee, Jan. 16, 2023 (at pg. 5: "Finally, the question assumes that Mr.
Epstein formulated this proposal. This idea was in the public domain and originated with his other legal advisors.
Nevertheless, Mr. Epstein tried to take credit for the idea and secure compensation.")
90 Id. at pg. 5: "The resulting dispute, including over Mr. Epstein's compensation for his advice on this proposal,
contributed to Mr. Black's decision to terminate his professional relationship with Mr. Epstein."
31 Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation of Epstein/Black Relationship and Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
blips'//www crc gov/Archivestragar/data/1411494/000119317571016405/d 118 I 024-lex99I titur (at pg. 18: "Them
appears to have been an understanding between Black and Epstein that Epstein would be compensated for some
portion of the value conferred from any idea that originated from Epstein.")
r  Id. at pg. 18: "Epstein claimed full credit for the transaction and demanded payment of $60 million, which would
have been 10% of a perceived benefit of $600 million that Epstein asserted the basis transaction provided."
transaction." To date, you have not provided any explanation as to how payments to Epstein
with respect to the step-up-basis transaction were determined and whether any statements of
work or other documents properly substantiating Epstein's role in the transaction even exist.
The Committee believes that payments to Epstein with respect to the step-up-basis
transaction merit further investigation. Compensation at these amounts in an estate and tax
planning matter is irregular and unusually high, particularly since Epstein's contributions to the
transaction relied on the guidance of other legal advisors. In this case, Epstein's compensation
with respect to the transaction was documented to have been significantly higher than your other
advisors on these matters.
Refusal to provide information regarding Epstein's compensation scheme
The Committee remains concerned about the payments to Epstein in amounts that would
represent a highly unusual compensation scheme. Unfortunately, you have refused to cooperate
with inquiries into payments to Epstein, raising serious concerns regarding the lack of
substantiation for the extraordinary amounts of such payments.

According to the Dechert report, you paid Epstein $158 million between 2012 and 2017,
an amount that seems inexplicably high based on currently available information. This
compensation scheme, which averaged approximately $25 million per year, appears to be well in
excess of expected compensation for tax and estate planning services — particularly in a case
where Epstein's work was required to be vetted by other legal and accounting professionals, at
times was not viewed as useful, and included instances of substantial misrepresentations of tax
laws!' Despite not being a certified public accountant or licensed tax attorney, Epstein was paid
amounts that far exceeded what you paid other professional advisors, including some of the most
high-priced legal counsel in the nation.'
In order to better understand Epstein's compensation scheme, the Committee submitted a
detailed set of questions and document requests. These requests included copies of any signed or
unsigned agreements with Epstein, the written service agreement you entered into with Epstein
on February 13, 2013 and documents related to payments made to Epstein as part of these
agreements. This request specified that these documents should include any statements of work
or descriptions of the services rendered by Epstein for which he was compensated as part of
these agreements.

331d. at 19: "As discussed previously, Black agreed to pay Epstein $20 million rather than the $60 million demanded
by Epstein."
3' Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation Of Epstein/Black Relationship And Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
https://www.sec.gov/ArchivSedgar/data/1411494/0001 I 93 I 25210I6405/d I 18102dex99l.htm (At page 3, "not all
of Epstein's advice was useful"; at page 4, "such advice was vetted consistently by Blacks' other advisors, including
Family Office employees, Paul Weiss, and other outside legal, accounting, and tax professionals"; at page 11, "[Mr.
Epstein's] ideas would appear plausible at face value, but did not hold up under scrutiny"; at page 17, "Black was
under the misconception that his payments to Epstein would be tax deductible ('sixty cent dollars') because this is
what Epstein had told Black." )
n Id. at pg. 17: "It is clear that the compensation paid by [Leon] Black to Epstein far exceeded any amounts Black
paid to his other professional advisors."
Additionally, the Committee requested information and documents on subsequent
payments that were made to Epstein after 2013 on an ad hoc basis, without negotiating written
services agreements. m This request asked for documents related to the $70 million Epstein was
paid in 2014 and the $30 million was paid in 2015, and asked for statements of work or
descriptions of services rendered by Epstein related to his work on the step-up-basis transaction
and estate, tax planning, tax audits and filings, or any other work provided by Epstein. The
Committee also requested an explanation of how compensation amounts for Epstein were
decided in payments made on an ad hoc basis where no formal services agreement was
negotiated.
At every stage of the Committee's investigation, you have refused to answer these
questions or provide any documents related to how Epstein's compensation was determined or
justified. First, you refused to answer the questions regarding Epstein's compensation included in
the Committee's letter submitted on June 22, 2022. Following a briefing with Committee staff
and your outside counsel on August 1, 2022, Committee staff submitted a second set of questions
regarding Epstein's compensation scheme." These questions also inquired about advice Epstein
provided in relation to your private art collection, which your outside counsel confirmed in a
briefing has a value of more than $1 billion. Again, you refused to provide answers to those
questions.
Subsequently, Committee staff met with your outside counsel at Paul Weiss and
Brownstein at the Finance Committee's offices, where your counsel again reiterated your
unwillingness to cooperate with any requests related to Epstein's compensation scheme,
including information on how Epstein's compensation was determined and evidence
substantiating the services he provided on tax and estate planning matters. They also reiterated
that you were unwilling to describe to the Committee how these payments were categorized for
tax purposes.

Arrangement with Epstein raises concerns of whether such amounts represented services
income or a gift
The Committee remains deeply concerned by your continued refusal to substantiate and
explain Epstein's compensation scheme. The lack of transparency surrounding payments to
Epstein, the extraordinary amount of such payments, the apparent lack of a formal services
agreement, and the fact that you apparently did not claim such compensation as a tax-deductible
expense raises questions about whether such payments would be properly characterized as a
taxable gift, or as payment for services rendered. The Dechert report states that you retained
36 Id. at pg. 16: "Starting in 2014, Black began to pay Epstein for his ongoing services on an ad hoc basis, without
negotiating written service agreements. In total, Black paid Epstein $70 million in 2014 and $30 million in 2015. Of
these amounts, Black attributed $20 million to Epstein's work on the step-up basis transaction and attributed the
remainder to the various other matters including his advice about estate, tax planning, tax audits, and filings,
managing Black's artwork, Family Office management, and advice regarding Black's yacht and airplane as set forth
above."
r  Email from Majority Staff, Senate Finance Committee to outside counsel to Leon Black at Paul, Weiss, Rifkind
Wharton & Garrison LLP, Sep. 20, 2022.

Epstein to advise you and your Family Office on a "variety of topics related to trust and estate
planning, tax issues, philanthropic endeavors, and the operation of the Family Office." 38
As noted previously, the amounts paid to Epstein were shown to be far in excess of
payments to your other advisors, and even customary compensation of Fortune 500 CEOs. Based
on what is known about the services Epstein performed, payments to Epstein, which equated to
an average annualized amount of $25 million, would likely represent payments well in excess of
reasonable compensation. IRS audit guidance indicates that questions around reasonable
compensation typically arise in family businesses and closely-held business arrangements, in
which the firm pays compensation in amounts determined to exceed what would reasonably be
charged for those services." The guidance states that such cases may also implicate gift and
estate tax avoidance.

According to IRS guidance, factors considered in determining reasonable compensation
include: possible conflicts of interest and relationships to the company, an individual's role at the
company, internal consistency in the company's compensation to other individuals, and external
comparisons of compensation with that of similar companies for similar services, among others.
In addition, the IRS defines a "gift" as any transfer to an individual, either directly or
indirectly, where full consideration (measured in money or moneys worth) is not received in
return." IRS regulations further provide that transfers made in the ordinary course of business
are not considered gifts, provided the transaction is "bona fide, at arm's length, and free from
any donative intent?""
Generally, business payments to an employee or contractor are deductible as reasonable
and necessary expenses under Section 162. While personal expenses are generally not tax-
deductible, certain expenses involving a family office may be deductible under Sections 162 or
212. In addition, the Internal Revenue Code specifically denies deductions for amounts not
representing reasonable compensation."
The Internal Revenue Code also denies deductions of any amount treated as a gift.'
Gifts in excess of the annual exclusion amount reduce any remaining amount of a taxpayers'
lifetime unified exclusion against the gift and estate tax, and are subject to the 40% gift tax to the
extent such gifts exceed that exclusion amount.'
38 Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation Of Epstein/Black Relationship And Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
klips -/AvIvw sec gov/Archivcdedgar/data/1411494/0001193125210164051d11810'dex99I hum (At  page 3, "Black
retained Epstein to advise Black and the Family Office on a variety of topics related to trust and estate planning, tax
issues, philanthropic endeavors, and the operation of the Family Office.." )
Reasonable Compensation Job Aid for IRS Valuation Professionals*, Internal Revenue Service, Oct. 29, 2014;
available online at https:/Avww.irs.gov/pubtirs-utl/Reasonable%20Compensation%20Job%20Aid%20for%201RS
0.420Valuation%/0Professionals pill
1p Frequently Asked Questions on Gift Tares, Internal Revenue Service,
https://www.irs.govibusinesses/smallbusinesses-self-employed/frequently-asked-questions-on-gift-taxes
"Trees. Reg. § 25.2512-8.
I.R.C. § 162.
C I.R.C. § 274 (b).
The Dechert report states that from 2013 through 2017, you were under the
misconception that your payments to Epstein would be tax-deductible, based on advice from
Epstein.09 During that same period, you paid Epstein $158 million. It appears that you
determined at some point that such amounts were not tax-deductible, however, the Dechert
report does not provide any details on when that determination was made, why you determined
those payments were not tax-deductible, or how such payments were characterized for tax
purposes. The Committee requested information and documents to determine how such
deductions were treated on previously-filed tax returns or whether any payments to Epstein were
characterized as gifts.

As Chairman of the Senate Finance Committee I have long been concerned that ultra-
high net worth individuals frequently employ sophisticated tax avoidance schemes to circumvent
federal gift and estate tax laws. With the assistance of sophisticated advisors, the wealthiest one
percent of Americans often exploit estate planning and loopholes in the tax code to avoid paying
hundreds of millions, or billions, of dollars in gift and estate taxes. As a result, this select group
of Americans is able to use trusts and other structures to transfer enormous untaxed sums of
wealth to their children.

I am also concerned that the decimation of IRS enforcement resources over the last
decade has led to a decline in compliance with federal gift tax filing requirements. As IRS audits
of gift tax returns have plummeted, the Committee's investigations have identified several
instances where gifts far exceeding the annual gift tax exclusion may not have been properly
reported on federal tax filings.

The Committee is conducting several investigations into the means by which ultra-high
net worth persons avoid or evade paying federal taxes, including gift taxes. These investigations
will help inform legislation to address loopholes in the tax code. For example, the Committee has
been investigating the growing use of Private Placement Life Insurance by the wealthiest
Americans as a tax shelter to avoid paying billions of dollars in income, gift and estate taxes. The
Committee's investigations into offshore tax evasion schemes involving individuals with dual
citizenship have also uncovered other challenges related to the enforcement of gift tax laws. For
example, the Committee's investigation into Credit Suisse identified several situations where
expatriating from the United States was part of a strategy to evade gift taxes while concealing
offshore accounts from the IRS.

The facts and circumstances surrounding your business arrangement with Epstein present
a variety of novel issues as they relate to circumventing gift and estate tax laws. Due to the
limited information you have provided the Committee, a significant number of open questions
remain regarding the tax avoidance scheme you implemented with Epstein's assistance,
" For 2013 to 2017 the annual gift tax exclusion was $14,000 and the lifetime exclusion amount was approximately
$5 million.

45 Apollo Global Management, Inc. Investigation Of Epstein/Black Relationship And Any Relationship Between
Epstein and Apollo Global Management, available online at
httns://www.see.gov/Arehives/edgar/data/14I1494/0001 I 93 I 2521016405/d118102dex99l.htm (At page 17, "Black
was under the misconception that his payments to Epstein would be tax deductible ('sixty cent dollars') because this
is what Epstein had told Black." )
including whether the exorbitant amounts paid to Epstein should have been classified as a gift for
federal tax purposes. The Committee also needs more information to assess whether billions of
dollars in assets are being improperly kept out of your taxable estate. In order to better
understand your business arrangement with Epstein, please provide answers to the following
questions no later than September I, 2023:

1. The response provided on January 16, 2023 indicated that the trustees of the remainder
trust prepared an accounting to ascertain the amount of income distributable to Mr. Black
under the trust agreement and the amounts that were in fact distributed to him. Please
provide the total amount that was distributed to Mr. Black from the remainder trust, as
well as the amount that was intended to be distributed to him under the terms of the trust
agreement. Please also provide the period in which these distributions occurred and
describe how the amount over-distributed was calculated.

2. The response provided on January 16, 2023 indicated that the mutual release of claims
resulted in both sides receiving consideration. Please describe the value and nature of the
consideration involved in the mutual release.

3. The response provided on January 16, 2023 indicated that the 2006 GRATs were funded
with a 30.35% interest in Apollo Management III LP; a 30.35% interest in Apollo
Management IV, LP; a 30.35% interest in Apollo Management V, LP; a 30.35% interest
in Apollo Management VI, LP; a 26.8% interest in Apollo Investment Management, LP;
a 26.9% interest in Apollo Value Management, LP; a 44% interest in Apollo SVF
Management, LP; a 44% interest in Apollo Asia Management, LP; a 44% interest in
Apollo Europe Management, LP; a 44% interest in Apollo Alternative Assets, LP; and
142 points of each of Apollo Advisors VI, LP and Apollo Advisors VI (EH). Please
answer the follow questions related to the interests that funded the 2006 GRATs:

a. Are any of these assets still held by the remainder trust? If so, please provide an
up to date accounting of the capital and/or profit ownership percentage and
estimated dollar value of the interest held by the remainder trust in Apollo
Management III LP, Apollo Management IV, LP Apollo Management V, LP;
Apollo Management VI, LP; Apollo Investment Management, LP; Apollo Value
Management, LP; Apollo SVF Management, LP; Apollo Asia Management, LP;
Apollo Europe Management, LP; Apollo Alternative Assets, LP; Apollo Advisors
VI, LP and Apollo Advisors VI (EH).

b. Please provide the most recent appraisal of the remainder trust's interest in Apollo
Management III LP, Apollo Management IV, LP Apollo Management V, LP;
Apollo Management VI, LP; Apollo Investment Management, LP; Apollo Value
Management, LP; Apollo SVF Management, LP; Apollo Asia Management, LP;
Apollo Europe Management, LP; Apollo Alternative Assets, LP; Apollo Advisors
VI, LP and Apollo Advisors VI (EH).

4. Have you, or any entities you are affiliated with, including Elysium Management LLC,
taken out any loans against the value of the assets held in the remainder trust (whether
held directly or indirectly through ownership of partnerships)? If so, please provide the
dollar value of those loans, as well as any loan terms (including interest rates, security,
and amounts repaid), and please describe any powers you, the trustees or any other
parties have held or exercised with respect to loans from the remainder trust. Do you have
a share of recourse debt or guarantee any debt of the entities described in question 3?

5. How many shares of Apollo Global Management, Inc. stock are held by the remainder
trust? Please describe the number, value, and class of these shares.

6. Please describe whether you have retained (or previously retained) any voting powers
with respect to the assets in the remainder trust. If so, please describe the percentage of
voting power you have retained for each of the funds described in question 3, and any
other voting powers you have retained with respect to the assets in the remainder trust.
Please also describe what percentage of voting power you have retained related to assets
held in the remainder trust with respect to Apollo Global Management, Inc., calculated
under the principles of IRC 2036(b)(2) as of today or the most recent accounting. Please
also confirm whether you are, or previously were, a general partner of, or member of the
management company for, any of the funds described in question 3.

7. The Dechert report claims that "in 2013, payments (to Epstein) were memorialized in
signed and unsigned agreements." Please provide copies of any compensation agreements
you signed with Epstein. Please also describe any "unsigned agreements" between you
and Epstein where Epstein was compensated for work related to trust and estate planning,
tax issues, issues relating to artwork, your airplane, your yacht, and other similar matters.

8. The Dechert report claims that you and Epstein negotiated a "written service agreement"
that was signed on February 13, 2013. Please provide a copy of this agreement, as well as
any documents related to payments made to Epstein as a result of this agreement. These
documents should include any statements of work or descriptions of the services rendered
by Epstein related to payments made under the agreement.

9. The Dechert report claims that Epstein was paid $56.5 million in five installment
payments over 2013 and 2014 as part of an agreement that was never signed. The
agreement was apparently renegotiated and the total amount paid was apparently $50
million. Please provide all documents related to payments you made to Epstein resulting
from this unsigned agreement, including any statements of work or descriptions of the
services rendered by Epstein as part of the agreement.

10. The Dechert report claims that starting in 2014, you began to pay Epstein for his ongoing
services on an ad hoc basis, without negotiating written service agreements. As part of
this, Epstein was paid $70 million in 2014 and $30 million in 2015. Please provide all
documents related to payments made to Epstein in 2014 and 2015, including any
statements of work or descriptions of services rendered by Epstein related to his work on
the step-up-basis transaction and estate, tax planning, tax audits and filings, or any other
advice provided to you and your family office.

11. The Dechert report claims that "it is clear the compensation paid by Black to Epstein far
exceeded any amounts Black paid to his other professional advisors." Please explain how
Dechert LLP made this assessment. Please also provide documents showing how
Epstein's compensation compared to other professional advisors, including attorneys
providing tax, trust and estate planning services and certified public accountants who
assisted you with tax matters.

12. The Dechert report claims that "after 2013 payments were made by Mr. Black to Mr.
Epstein on an ad hoc basis based on Black's perceived value of Epstein's work." Please
provide a detailed description of how compensation amounts were decided for Epstein,
including any documentation of trust and estate planning and tax consulting services
rendered by Epstein for you or your family office.

13. In a briefing with the Committee on August 1, 2022, your outside counsel indicated that
Epstein would often demand compensation from Black that far exceeded what you were
initially willing to pay for his services. Despite the absence of a written services
agreement or other contract, it appears that you made large payments to Mr. Epstein in
2014, 2015, and 2017. Please provide a detailed written description of the amounts
Epstein initially requested he be paid during those years, the process by which you and
Epstein negotiated and agreed to a payment amount, and why you agreed to pay such
substantial sums to Epstein despite the absence of a written service agreement. Please
also provide copies any relevant documents related to decisions regarding how much
Epstein was paid for his services.

14. The Dechert report claims that from 2013 through 2017, you were under the
misconception that your payments to Epstein would be tax-deductible, based on advice
from Epstein.

a. Please describe whether you claimed income tax deductions for payments to
Epstein for any taxable year during this period, as well as when and why you
determined that such payments were nondeductible.

b. Please describe whether you amended your tax returns after learning that the
payments to Epstein were not tax-deductible.

c. Please include all substantiation documents with respect to any income tax
deductions you previously claimed.

d. Please describe whether any payments you made to Epstein were characterized as
gifts for tax purposes, and please provide any documents, including tax returns,
related to any reportable gifts made to Epstein.

15. In a briefing with the Committee on August 1, 2022, your outside counsel indicated that
Epstein provided substantial advice related to your private art collection, which is worth
over $1 billion. This advice reportedly included helping you form a new art partnership
as well as assistance in connection with the sale of certain pieces of artwork. Please
provide detailed answers in writing for the following items:

a. What was the purpose of the new art partnership you formed with Epstein's
assistance? How did Epstein assist in the formation of that partnership?

b. Please provide more details regarding any art loans that involved Epstein,
including Epstein's role related to those loans.

c. Please provide a list of any like-kind exchange transactions Epstein helped
execute for any pieces you owned valued at over $1 million, including a detailed
description of the tax benefits obtained through the execution of these
transactions.

d. Please provide a list of art sales valued at over $1 million Epstein assisted you
with.
Thank you for your attention to this important matter.
Sincerely,
14ThnRon Wyden
United States Senator
Chairman, Committee on
Finance
EFTA00008870 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-17)
Messages Page I o(4
•
•
Records Listed For: JEFFREY EPSTEIN from 04/11/2005 to 04/11/2005
From
reminders
7:43AM
Message
1. Call Gabriel Perahla
Gowen
Thursday 4. Pinto in Pans this week
er
2. Call William
an e son in Paris on
Just j i lt info: end me Jetblue 623 arriving 12.20pm
WPB. 678 jetblue, leaving WPB 11.10 am, arriving JFK
1.45pm. Citicar picking up
Cecilia UN for Emad to talk to Paul Gandy re phone system and electric
9:35AM distribution.
Cecilia
9:35AM
Mlles
9:37AM
Jean Luc
9:55AM
10:13AM
warren
Elsenstein
10:17AM
Yanush is picking upMend
Will email photos of beach house floor.
I lost my cell phone, but will be in the office after 10:30.
You had wanted me to put the tiles on the Midnight express for
the cabana - the midnight express has not left yet as you know -
should I wait for the boat to come to FLA or orgnalse for the tiles
o be sent to PB
Where should I mall the DVD7
'm available all week except for Thum, if you're around.
Ira
Zicherman Bought 50 000 CELL at $437.068
10:22AM
Pis call.
Looking In a realestate magazine - there are 2
w/ direct ocean front - Christine COndon in PB
10:27AM another Carole Koeppel they w re in
times realestate mag
Cecilia
10:33AM
Ira
Zicherman
10:35AM
Cecilia
10:49AM
Lm for G to just send the tiles.
Stock is trading at 36.79. I understand there are some
additional shares, sou blocks available in this area. Do you
have any interest?
Jean bought bought the two vases (6.500 Euros) and the large
11:06AM  console 4.200 Euros - nice surprise).
ii
http://domsrv0lgoichaven/wc.dinGmax—MsgAisplay
Phone
4/11/2005
GM_GLSDNY_00000342
Meisager Pagc 2 of 4
•
•
lean Luc
11:07AM Call me at the office (I tried to connect you).
Prof. Camhi
11:16AM Pis call
Miles
Schnitman
11:24AM
Just calling to see where we stand.
Eric
11:34AM Dr. Landon's $25k quartly payment is due, please approve.
Den
Sperber;
11:38AM
Collin• re meetin I'm in NY until Mon. Pis email your reply.
George
Reenstra
11:40AM
Via email re photos of other 7G s: That Is on temp hold,
apparently we are now painting all black with a camel stripe
Cecilia
12:17PM
Naomi
Campbell
12:18PM
LM for
back?
re is any of her friends
Via email: Hello, naorn1 here would like to know when I can
speak with Jeffery, regarding my swimsuit line.For a meeting
with VS to see,I have pia and some of the sults with me.. Hope
IS well
Cecilia
12:26PM LM and emeiled Dan Sperberg to call.
Bill Karr
12:27PM I will email the plans later today.

Dr. Jerecki
12:33PM Please call.
Cecilia LM for Jerry Goldsmith re has lawyer letter been sent out yet, 12:43PM
Amy Evans
12:50PM
Calling for Congressman Tom Reynolds regarding the lune 14th
annual dinner with Bush. NRCC Business Advisory.
G
12:51PM
Spoke to Miles re sending the blue tiles for the cabana to PB -
you sd to him last week to keep them for the Tiki house kitchen
- plse advise
Kenneth
Cole
12:51PM
:4 PM
Melanie From Dr. MoskovItz' office. We're trying to find some place in NY
2:04PM  wherellecan have her heart test done.
2:29PM IS  back.
Returning your call.
I'm back in NY.
Call me re what we talked about.
http://domsrv0 lifoxhaveniwc.di I7Gmaz—MseDisplay
1
4111/2005
GM_GLSDNY_00000343
Messages Page 3 of 4
•
•
I2:38PM
C.
Fiona
2:39PM From Dr. Jareckrs. P15 call.
Melanie
2:43PM
From Dr. Moskowitz's office. n get the heart test done
on Fri in NV. Appt at 3.30pm, ec -In 3.15pm. Faculty practice
stave, G elevator to 13th floor, $1656 total,
Is there a check for me? C
Eric
2:54PM
Please confirm that I am wiring S3mm from your account to MJ
Lit.
' Can Danielle and I work this week?
Jerry
Goldsmith
2:57PM
Gowdy was out of town, but the letter will be delivered today.
G
3:02PM
Leighton Chandler doesn't know if she can organize for me to
see the mansion this week as it Is just getting on the market.
She will check to see if she get me in tomorrow. If not, it will
have to De the next time I'm in town. nt Copied From
GHISLAINE MAXWELL *** Original Date and Time: 04/11/2005
at 2:19P
r
Greg Hersch
3:08PM
via my email: Please let Jeffrey know that If he intends to
participate in the Emerging Market Special Opportunities fund
that the deadline for subscription dots is next Wednesday, April
20 for May 1 trading. Thanks'
G
km--iCecilla
3:11PM Jed° will pick up■s prescription. WHere should 1 fedex it, r
Eric
3:11PM
FYI: on the Dr. Landon quarterly payments, we (NYSG) billed
LHW/Abigall In advance as we have In prior years.
Pis call.
Larry
Newman
3:39PM
I just need a few more minutes If you have time.
4:17PM Just calling to check in.
G
4:21PM ----..
The Tel Aviv ticket was not a fraud. It was to get a renewal for your 2nd valid passport. We're getting a refund for It.
manu
4:26PM
The pool specialist can't come tomorrow in P8. He can only come on WedneSday morning if it's ok for you. Pls advice r
Cecile
4:27PM
Fro the power symposium, we are looking at 4 days between January 6, 2006 and January 17th or 18t.h. The participants 
working on their schedules and need to
know ASAP We also need to let the hotel so we don't lose our $20000 deposit.
C
ICecilia

• http://dotastvOlifoxhaven/we.diremluc—MsgDisplay
4/11/2005
GM_GLSDNY_00000344
--1
•
Messages Page 4 of 4

• I4:27PM I had on the line for you.

Dr. victor
4:28PM Pls call. I 0
can work tomorrow at 4pm.
Cecilia
4:41PM
I had Dan Sperberg on the line for you. He will call back since he
has no reception In the library. r;
Cecilia
4:45PM
I forwarded helicopter pictures from George Reenstra to your
yahoo.
r
Cecilia
4:47PM I had Dr. larecki on the line. r
G
4:50PM Lydia got her aesthetician license and can not do facials. F
menu
4:54PM
GYM works In Paris: 3 weeks 1/2 to finish. Pinto waiting for a
starting date ( possibly 8 days of advance to organize It). IT
Bill Karr
4:55PM
The mail server Is down, but I will email the plans as soon as I
can. n
Outstanding did not can bac 4:56PM ri
Callers Prof. Camhi, Miles Schnitmen,
4:56PM Dr. Victor. n

• WirK 4* -Crl<dae tigl.8.acces in 471
tiwrgion t_rFPJ. SI  NSFlia iz MA I g!L'tW.
Copyright (c) 2000-2004, Postern interests, Inc. Al Rights Reserved
• http://domsrvOi/foxhaverilwc.d=max—Msgbisplay 4/1172005
GM_GLSDNY_00000345
EFTA00009550 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-17)
Page 1
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
IN RE: OPERATION LEAP YEAR
APPEARANCES:
, ESQUIRE
Federal Grand Jury, 07-103
West Palm Beach, Florida
Nay 8, 2007
Assistant United States Attorney
, Foreperson
TESTIMONY
OF
Copy 1 of 13
Page 2
The sworn testimony of E.
was taken before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm
Beach Division, West Palm Beach, Palm Beach County,
State of Florida, on the 8th day of may, 2007.
Philip W. may, Court Reporter, was authorized to
and did report the sworn testimony.
Page 3
6 BY
8 where you're employed.
9 A
(The witness entered the grand jury room. )
■
having been duly sworn by the grand jury foreperson,
was examined and testified on her oath as follows:
EXAMINATION
Q Could you start by reminding us of your name and
I work for the FBI here in West
Palm Beach on their violent crimes squad.
Q And you are one of the case agents in Operation
Leap Year?
A Yes, I am.
Q Did you recently participate in an interview of
A Yes.
Q Can you tell us date of birth?
A was born on
Q And you spoke with her recently?
A Yes, we did.
Q So she was 18 at the time of the interview?
A Yes, I believe she was.
Who is
A was identified by the Palm Beach
I
Copy 1 of 13
Page 4
Police Department as one of the girls who had frequented

Mr. Epstein's house.
Q How exactly did the Palm Beach Police Department
determine that she was one of those girls?
A When they did their search warrant at
Mr. Epstein's residence, some message pads were obtained
at his residence, and they had several calls from a girl
named , and phone numbers. So they were able to
track back those messages back to
Q Did the Palm Beach Police Department try to
interview Miss
A They did.
• Did she agree to speak with them?
A No. She stated that she loved Jeffrey Epstein,
and that she would not say anything positive or negative
about what occurred.
Q After the FBI became involved in this
investigation, did you try to interview Miss
A We did, as well, with no such luck, as well.
Q How long ago was it that you first made contact
with Miss
A It was back in November of '06.
Q Did you try to serve her with a subpoena issued
on behalf of this grand jury?
A Yes, we did.
Page 5
3 But she was notified of when her appearance was expected
Q What happened?
A She refused service of the grand jury subpoena.
here, and a subpoena was left with her.
Q After that, did she obtain an attorney?
A Yes, she did.
Q Who was that?
A Jim Eisenberg. He's a well-known defense
attorney here in West Palm Beach.
Q Who paid for that attorney?
A Mr. Epstein is paying for attorney.
Q Now once Miss secured the attorney, did
she agree to be interviewed?
A Yes, she did, after she was granted 6001
immunity. She requested immunity.
Q Did the justice department authorize that grant
of immunity?
A Yes, they did.
Q After that, did she agree to be interviewed?
A Yeah. It was only after she was given that
immunity that she would talk with us.
Q When did the interview take place?
A It took place at the end of April of this year,
so just a few weeks ago.
Q Who was present at that interview?
Copy 1 of 13
Page 6
1 A Myself; my partner, agent ; the AUSA,
2 her attorney, Jim Eisenberg, and his
3 investigator; as well as
4 Q what did Miss tell you about Jeffrey
5 Epstein?
6 A She stated that she had met an individual by the
7 name of at a party who had asked her if she
8 wanted to make a few bucks by giving a man a massage. She
9 was told that Mr. Epstein preferred them to be topless,
10 and she agreed to go to his house to give him a massage.
11 Q How old did Miss tell you she was at that
12 time?
13 A She stated she was 16 when she first started
14 giving Mr. Epstein massages.
15 Q Based upon your review of the evidence, is that
16 correct?
17 A No. We have phone records where
18 (phonetic), Mr. Epstein's assistant, is contacting
19 on her cell phone, or using her cell phone to call
20 cell phone starting in April of 2004, which makes
21 15.
22 Q So she said that she was 16, but your evidence
23 shows that she was 15, and she said that she was told she
24 could make a few bucks giving a topless massage?
25 A Yes.
Page 7
Q What else did Miss MN tell you?
A That she went to Mr. Epstein's residence, that
took her there the first time, that when she went
upstairs she was paid $200 when she first got there by
Then she goes upstairs, and Mr. Epstein
comes in, he disrobes, puts on a towel, lays down on the
massage table and she begins to massage him.
She tells Epstein that she heard he likes
topless massages, and he told her that he did. And she
10 said, 'who wouldn't?• And she ended up taking off her top
11 during the first massage. But is clear that Mr.
12 Epstein did not at any point touch her during the massage.
13 Q But does she admit that he
14 A Yes. On the second massage, Mr. Epstein asked
15 her to leave her phone number with . Her phone number
16 was left there. On the second massage, she returned the
17 very next day and gave him another massage. This time,
18 Mr. Epstein
19 Q Did Miss admit that
21 A Yes, . And I think her term was that
22 meaning that
23 Q How long of a period of time did Miss
24 tell you that she performed massages?
25 A She wasn't able to give us a number of massages, 'Mk
Page 8
but just said that it was a lot, and that she had been
giving him massages for a year.
Q You mentioned to the grand jury that Miss
said that Mr. Epstein never touched her, correct?
A Yes.
Q And she was very adamant about that?
A Yes, she was.
Q Were there other things that she was adamant
about in her interview with you?
A Well, she talked about what she would tell the
girls that -- and that she told Mr. Epstein that she was
18. I'm sorry, I take that back. She was told to say
that she was 18, and she told us that she had a fake I.D.
showing that she was 18.
So she passed that information along to the
other girls when she brought -- eventually she brought
other girls to perform massages, and that was one of the
things that she told -- she told us first that she brought
18- to 20-year old girls. And then she stated that if the
girls lied, and they were underage, she told them that
they needed to tell Epstein that they were 18.
Q Have you been able to identify some of the girls
that Miss brought to Mr. Epstein's home?
A Yes.
Q Were any of those girls over 18?
Page 9
1 A No, not that we found so far.
3 what Mr. Epstein knew about their ages?
4 A I'm sorry, say that again.
5 0 Have any of the girls who came through
6 been interviewed about what Mr. Epstein knew about
7 their ages?
9 not sure if he asked them. They were all told to say they
10 were 18, but not on every occasion would Mr. Epstein
11 inquire about their age.
18 under 18.
20 really the case?
23 it's clear.
25 to say she was 18, and she also told you that she had a
Q Have any of the girls told investigators about
A we did interview them regarding that, and I'm
Q Do you want to check your records on that?
A Yes, could I do that?
• Yes, please do.
A I can tell you that one of the girls that she
brought -- this girl told Mr. Epstein that she was in high
school, and actually told him her true age, which was
Q So what told you about, that wasn't
A No, that wasn't. Sorry.
Q That's all right, I just wanted to make sure
So Miss told you that she had been told
Copy 1 of 13
Page 10
1 fake I.D.?
2 A Yes.
3 Q Did she ever say that Mr. Epstein either asked
4 for her age or asked to see her I.D.?
5 A No, the topic never came up.
6 Q Did you also ask her about how appointments were
7 made?
8 A Yes. She was very clear in the fact that
9 would call her to arrange the appointments, but
that would call her once Jeffrey was in town.
11 Q So she was adamant that the calls only happened
12 when she was already here?
13 A Yes.
14 Q. Were you made aware that Epstein's counsel was
15 informed that he was being investigated for traveling to
16 engage in prostitution, which means that the appointments
1/ would have been made before the traveling?
18 A Yes.
19 Q Was there anything else, besides the issue of
20 age and the issue of when the appointments were made, that
21 sounded coached or that she was especially adamant about?
22 A No, I wouldn't say coached. I mean, we talked
23 about the preferences that Jeffrey discussed, as far as
24 which girls he would like to bring.
25 Once started giving massages to Epstein,
Page 11
told us that he liked different faces, so he would
ask her to bring other girls. We asked her if he ever
gave any preferences of what he preferred, and her
response was that Epstein liked girls like her, which is
thin and blond and attractive.
Q And how old was she at the time?
A She was 15.
Q So thin, blonde, attractive and --
A Young, girls like her. I guess we asked if she
ever made a mistake, or ever brought somebody that Mr.
Epstein didn't take to. She said that she had screwed up
and that she had brought a black girl to Mr. Epstein, and
that Epstein was not interested in black girls. But he
did pay her, and said that he wasn't a racist. He paid
her the $200 for her time, but did not want her to perform
a massage for him.
Q And he didn't allow that girl to perform a
massage?
A No.
Was there anything else that Miss talked
about in the interview that you want to share with the
grand jury?
A I did ask her at the end of the interview if she
was in love with Mr. Epstein. She looked into the camera
and said that she loved him like a friend. But then she
Copyl of13
Page 12
1 kind of looked into the camera and gave a wink and a smile
2 and said, "But with your money, I'd marry you any time,
3 Jeffrey."
4 Q Did she also say that she considered him to be
5 an •awesome guy'?
6 A Several times she referred to him as an "awesome
7 guy° • She said that the girls begged her to come and that
8 the girls didn't have a complaint, and the girls would
9 share with her everything that happened after the massage,
and that Jeffrey never touched any of the girls. But as I
informed you, we did interview some of the girls that she
took, and he has touched them.
13 Q In preparation for your testimony today, did you
14 also speak with someone who is considered to be an expert
15 in these cases?
16 A YeS.
17 Q And what is that person's name?
18 A
19 Q Has Mr. been qualified to testify as an
20 expert in federal and state courts in cases that involve
21 what he calls "compliant victims"?
22 A Yes.
23 Q what does he mean by the term "compliant
24 victims"?
25 A A compliant victim is when a victim is not
Page 13
necessarily forced into the conduct that the offender
wants them to engage into, that they actually consent to
that kind of activity.
Q So that would include minors who are subjected
to sexual activity but weren't necessarily kidnapped or
forced at gunpoint, or something like that?
A Exactly.
Q Did he discuss with you the difficulties that
exist when you interview those types of victims?
A Yes. He stated that a compliant victim is often
times embarrassed that they went along with the behavior.
They are also likely to deny the behavior, especially when
being interviewed by investigators, that they'll deny it
or they'll minimize it. Sometimes it takes two, three or
multiple interviews to get compliant victims to either
trust their interviewer or realize that their interviewer
is not going to be judgemental.
Q In this case, have you found that to be the case
with some of the interviews?
A Yes, I have.
Q In addition to being embarrassed, sometimes
these victims feel guilty about the fact that they were
involved in this type of activity?
A Oh, yes.
Q Does Mr. also have expertise in sexual
Copy 1 of 13
Page 14
1 preference of offenders?
2 A Yes, he does.
3 Q Did he explain why an offender would select the
4 types of victims that are involved in this case, girls
5 between 14 and 17-years-old?
6 A This type of offender, the sexual preference he
7 has is for post-pubescent females that are physically
8 developed but not necessarily mentally matured. The girls
9 ranging in this age are sometimes inexperienced, they are
10 possibly naive, not as worldly.
11 An offender of this type could also maybe not
12 feel sexually adequate or feel competent dealing with his
13 own age group. So knowing that these girls are less
14 experienced, may focus on them as well.
15 Q In addition to their emotional immaturity, did
16 Mr. talk about whether or not younger girls are
17 easier to manipulate than grown women?
18 A Yes.
19 Q Did he talk to you about "grooming"?
20 A Yeah. That's what an offender will use with a
21 compliant victim. He told us that grooming is a technique
22 where you gain the cooperation of those victims by
23 focusing on their interests and playing up to those
lled it. That 24 interests. It's a type of seduction, he ca
25 was his words for it. And we actually see this in this
I
Page 15
case.
Can you give us an example of some of the types
of grooming that Mr. Epstein used?
A With one of the girls we're going to talk about
today, , it's very apparent interviewing her how
Epstein groomed her. She only went to three or four
massages at this time, that she's admitted to. We feel
that due to her phone conversations, the multiple calls,
that there may be more there. At this point she has
stated to us that she has performed three or four massages
for Mr. Epstein.
what he did is when she first went there he
played upon -- she was very shy, and he would play upon
that shyness. He told her that she was pretty. He asked
her to remove her clothing, and she would not. So he kind
of kidded around with her shyness and complimented her,
showed interest in her, talked about her boyfriend and
different interests she had.
At the end of that interview, because she did
not take off her clothes, he tells her that if she's
willing to do more, she will make more. He also tells her
that he would pay her if she would bring other girls. As
the massages increased, you can see that the next time she
comes he plays again to that shyness, but he gets a little
bit more -- I guess he sees that it's not working. This
Copy 1 of 13
Page 16
time she does comply and takes off her -- he asked her to
disrobe on the second massage. She takes off her blouse,
but she refuses to take off the bra after Mr. Epstein
asked her to.
So you can see that he tries through showing
interest. And then he actually -- when he sees that this
isn't working, he takes a more authoritative role with her
in the last massage. She said that throughout all of
these massages he was very nice, and then at the end he
was much more frustrated and irritated. She does get down
to her bra and panties on that one, he's just much
more authoritative.
So he started with the grooming process, tried
to get her interest, tried to use that to get her to
comply with removing her clothes. But as often happens,
at the end of this, he took over and was much more
forceful with his requests.
Q Have other girls described that same situation
where every time they went back, he tried to push it one
step further and one step further?
A Yes. Several of the girls have said that he
would always push for more and more.
Q Did Mr. explain why it is that a
compliant child victim cannot legally consent to the
sexual conduct?
Page 17
1 A Yeah. He stated that -- you know, we talked
2 about how the law protects children, and stated that we
3 hold adults accountable. When it comes to adolescents,
4 they go through normal tendencies that mature offenders
5 may try to take advantage of. But the law is in place for
6 that reason, to protect -- in the federal law, to protect
7 those individuals under the age of 18.
8 Q And that's because of the different maturity
9 levels of the --
10 A The offender versus the victims, exactly.
11 Q Did you put together the photographs of the
12 defendants in this case?
13 A Yes, I did.
14 Q Are these photographs of the four human
15  defendants who are named in the proposed indictment?
16 A Yes.
17 Q With their names underneath them?
18 A Yes.
19 Q Agent, who is in the top left-hand corner?
20 A That's Jeffrey Epstein.
21 Q when was this photograph taken?
22 A Recently. There was an article that just came
23 out regarding Mr. Epstein and his connection, or his
24 personal relationship with Prince Andrew, and that was a
25 picture that was in that article.
Copy 1 of 13
Page 18
Q Who is in the top right-hand corner?
A That's
Q Again, this is a relatively recent photograph?
A Yes, that's his personal assistant.
Q And the bottom left-hand corner?
A Again, that is one of Mr. Epstein's personal
assistants, that's (phonetic) .
Q Has Miss since gotten married?
A Yes, her name now is
Q And the bottom right-hand corner?
A That is . She is, again, a
personal assistant to Mr. Epstein. There has been some
talk that she is also romantically -- or I should say
sexually involved with Mr. Epstein.
Q How old are the defendants?
A Jeffrey is in his mid-fifties, and the three
girls are in their early twenties.
Q Do you have a copy of the draft indictment in
front of you?
A Yes, I do.
Q You mentioned when we were looking at the
photographs that the three females work as personal
assistants for Mr. Epstein, is that correct?
A Yes.
Q So he is their employer?
Page 19
1 A Yes.
2 Q Are you familiar with the property located at
3 3S8 El Brillo Way in Palm Beach?
4 A That's Mr. Epstein residence.
Q And he owns that residence?
A Yes, he does.
Q Are you familiar with Defendant J.E.G.E., Inc.?
A Yes. J.E.G.E., Inc. is owned by Jeffrey
Epstein. He is the president, the owner, the sole
director. It's a business that is solely used for the
activities of one of Mr. Epstein's airplanes, which is his
Boeing 727. Its tail number is N908JE.
And you mentioned that he is the president and
the sole director. Is he also the sole shareholder?
A Yes, he is.
0 Are you familiar with Hyperion Air, Inc.?
A Yes. Hyperion Air, Inc. is also a business
owned by Mr. Epstein. He is also the president, the
director and the sole shareholder of that company as well.
That company solely does business with his other aircraft,
which is a Gulf Stream G-1159B. It bears a tail number
N909JE.
Q Is that a smaller aircraft than the Boeing?
A Yes.
Just to briefly remind the grand jury about
Copy 1 of 13
Page 20
where the evidence has been collected in this case, was
the start of your investigation information that you
received from the Palm Beach Police Department?
A Yes, it was.
Q And that included evidence seized during a
search of Mr. Epstein's home at El Brillo Way?
A Yes.
Q Also controlled calls that the Palm Beach Police
Department placed?
A Yes.
Q And interviews of girls and other people by the
Palm Beach Police Department?
A Yes, as well as trash pulls that the Palm Beach
Police Department conducted on Mr. Epstein's residence.
Q Then when the FBI became involved, the FBI did
additional interviews of girls and of recruiters?
17 A Yes.
18 Q They obtained phone records?
19 A Yes, we have.
20 Q And records of payments?
21 A Yes.
22 Q Did this grand jury also subpoena travel
23 records?
24 A Yes.
25 Q Including the flight manifests of the planes
Page 21
1 owned by Hyperion and J.E.G.E.?
9 pattern of activity by the defendants?
10 A Yes, we did.
11 Q So you have a series of phone calls coming from
12 these three assistants who were on the board, the two
A Yes.
Q Did you also get corporate documents related to
those two planes?
A Yes, we have.
Q Once you had obtained all of this information,
did the FBI analyze the data, specifically the call
information and the flight information to put together a
girls who have been identified through this investigation?
A Yes.
Q When you spoke with those girls, did any of them
tell you that they had developed some sort of a personal
relationship with the assistants so that they were just
chatting over the telephone?
A No, not at all.
Q All of them said what about the phone calls?
A Said that the phone calls were made to set up
appointments for Mr. Epstein.
Q And the girls referred to it as appointments to
work, is that right?
A Yes, they were appointments to work. There is
Copy 1 of 13
Page 22
1 one exception, we're going to talk about her
2 probably next week. She did say on one or two occasions
3 that had called her when she had gone out
to California on a trip, I believe. But that is the only
time that that was ever mentioned. In fact, we asked, and
6 those phone calls were made for the purpose of setting up
7 appointments for Mr. Epstein.
8 Q Is the investigation continuing?
9 A Yes, it is.
10 Q Are you still trying to locate and interview
11 more girls?
12 A Yes.
13 Q Let's turn to the specific evidence reporting
14 the overt acts and offenses relating to Jane Doe's 1
15 through 5. I know that every member of the grand jury has
16 a copy of the draft indictment before them, and also a
17 chart.
18 Do you have a copy of that chart as well?
19 A I do.
20 Q Do you have photographs of the five girls that
21 we are going to talk about today?
22 A Yes.
23 Q And these are photographs of the people that we
24 are calling Jane Doe's 1 through 5?
25 A Yes.
s
Page 23
Q And Jane Doe Number 1, you have previously
testified about her?
A Yes, I have, that's .
Q Jane Doe Number 2?
A That is
6 Q Jane Doe Number 3?
7 A That is
8 Q Jane Doe Number 4?
9 A
10 Q And Jane Doe Number 5?
11 A That is
12 JUROR: The purpose of Epstein's business with
his planes, did he transport?
THE WITNESS: To travel around.
JUROR: So it wasn't like a business of
transporting other people?
THE WITNESS: He flew other guests, sometimes
unaccompanied, sometimes accompanied.
JUROR: and do you have
any evidence that they started young, like the rest
of the recruits?
THE WITNESS: We have evidence that they are his
personal assistants employed by him, not that it was
anything like what we were discussing.
JUROR: There was an allegation that was made
Copy 1 of 13
Page 24
1 earlier, back in February, during one of these
3 Can I ask about that? We were told back in February
12 BY MS.
13 Q So turning to Jane Doe Number 1, 1. You
14 testified about her earlier before this grand jury,
15 correct?
16 A Yes, I did.
17 Q And she also testified before this grand jury,
18 correct?
19 A Yes.
20 Q Can you remind us of her date of birth?
21 A She was born on
22 Q Could you briefly refresh the grand jury's
23 recollection of how she was recruited?
24 A She was approached on a beach by
discussions, about a specific act that was performed.
that one of the girls when interviewed had alleged
rape, and I hadn't heard about that allegation
recently.
THE WITNESS: That's probably Jane Doe Number 6.
We're going to talk about her, that he forcibly put
her on the table and Yeah, she will
be coming up. We're going to do her probably next
week. She'll be the first one we'll talk about.
and
(phonetic). They approached her on a beach
Page 25
and asked her if she wanted to perform massages for
Mr. Epstein and make some money.
Q From the review of the phone records that you
4 have received, were you able to identify a telephone
5 number associated with
6 A Yes. '
7 Q In fact, has been interviewed?
8 A Yes, he has.
9 Q And has he admitted to being a recruiter for Mr.
10 Epstein?
11 A Yes, recruiter and driver.
12 Q If you could take a look at Overt Act Number 2,
13 which appears on page five. That states, °On or about
14 March 12, 2004, defendants Jeffrey Epstein and
15 caused Jane Doe Number 1 to travel to 358 Brillo Way of
16 Palm Beach, Florida..
17 Can you tell us what evidence you have regarding
18 that?
19 A We have reviewed phone records for and
20 that indicate the calls took place, as well as phone
21 records for and and calls that took
22 place on or about those dates. We've also looked at a
23 flight manifest, and were able to show that Mr. Epstein
24 arrived the day before, on the 11th. We also have
25 statement where she describes the sexual activity that
Copy 1 of 13
Page 26
1 took place.
2 Q On that date, March 12 of 2004, described
3 going to Mr. Epstein's house and performing a sexual
4 massage?
5 A Yes, on or about that day.
6 Q On or about that date, what did state
7 about being paid?
A She was paid $200.
9 Q And that relates to Overt Act Number 3?
10 A Yes.
11 Q And she stated that Mr. Epstein is the person
12 who gave her that?
13 A She told us that in her statement.
14 Q If you could take a look at Overt Act Number 95,
15 which is on page 17. On or about February 6, 2005,
16 Epstein had Jane Doe Number 1 to make one or more
17 telephone calls to Jane Doe Number 2.
18 First of all, who is Jane Doe Number 2?
19 A That would be , our youngest victim.
20 Q Can you tell us what evidence you have related
21 to that overt act?
22 A We have the girl's statements that calls were
23 made. We also reviewed the phone records that indicated
24 that there was telephonic contact between the numbers
25 belonging to and
Page 27
1 Q And in the statement of both girls, did they
2 describe that is the person who called
3 looking for someone to come and work at Mr. Epstein's
4 house?
5 A Yes.
6 Q Looking at Overt Act Number 96. On or about
7 February 6, 2005, Epstein caused Jane Doe Number 1 to
8 transport Jane Doe Number 2 to 358 El Brillo way.
9 What is the evidence related to that?
10 A Again, the statements of and support
11 that as further evidence, and also reviewing the phone •
1 2 records they indicate that there was telephonic contact
13 between and and and
14 Q Overt Act Number 97, on or about February 6,
15 2005, Epstein made a payment of $300 to Jane Doe Number 2
16 and a payment of $200 to Jane Doe Number 1.
17 what was the evidence of that?
18 A Both and stated in their statements
19  that was paid $300, and was paid $200 for
20 bringing
21 Q Did explain why she was paid $300?
22 A Yes, she was paid $300 because she performed her
23 massage. Mr. Epstein and a
24 on
25 Q After this date, after February 6, 2005, was
Copy 1 of 13
Page 28
$300 found in purse when it was searched at her
school?
A Yes, it was, by a school administrator.
Q If you could look at Overt Act Number 117, which
is on page 19, and that states that on or about March 30,
2005, caused one or more calls to be made to a
telephone used by Jane Doe Number 1.
what evidence do you have related to that?
A We reviewed the phone records of and
that indicate this.
Q And Overt Act 120, on or about March 31,
caused one or more calls to be made to a telephone used by
Jane Doe Number 1.
A Again, we reviewed the phone records that
indicated there was telephonic contact between the numbers
belonging to and
Q Then we have Overt Act Number 122, which is also
March 31, that Epstein and caused Jane Doe Number 1
to make a call to a telephone used by Jane Doe Number 2.
What evidence do you have related to that?
A We have phone records that we have reviewed
belonging to and . In this case, we also have a
voice mail that was provided to us by the Palm Beach
Police Department, a voice mail of
mail message on phone.
leaving a voice
Page 29
And Overt Act Number 123 refers to April 1st.
what evidence do you have related to that?
A we have reviewed the phone records of and
that indicate telephonic contact was made on this
day. We also again have another recorded voice mail by
, left on phone.
• These later calls, the March-April calls, are
those the controlled calls that the Palm Beach Police
Department was involved in?
A There was controlled calls placed to
cell phone and to place of work by under the
supervision of the Palm Beach Police Department.
Q And the voice mail message that you referred to
of calling , what information was leaving
in that voice mail message?
A was asking for to get back in touch,
that she had set up an appointment for at Epstein's
house on the following day, on that Saturday at around
10:30 or 11:00.
Q In addition to the phone records, was there
anything that the Palm Beach Police Department found that
also confirmed that this appointment actually was made.
A As I mentioned earlier, the Palm Beach Police
Department was doing trash pulls on Mr. Epstein's
25 residence. In there, there were two messages or notes in
Copy 1 of 13
Page 30
there on Epstein's personalized stationary. On it it
said, " with on Saturday at 10:30, and on
Saturday with at 10:30." That's the exact message on
the two notes that were found in his trash when they
retrieved it on April 8.
Q If I could direct your attention to Count Number
Five, which appears on page 26. That is the charge of
enticement of a minor, referring to Jane Doe Number 1, and
Mr. Epstein and are charged.
I know that you talked about the telephone
traffic. The calls between and , did
they fall within that March 7 through March 11 time
period?
A A review of their telephone records do indicate
that there were phone calls made during that time.
Q And Jane Doe Number 1 actually went to Mr.
Epstein's home?
A Yes, and performed a massage for him in the
nude.
Q And she was paid for that?
A Yes, she was paid $200.
Q And he , correct?
A Yes, he did. I would like to include that
took upstairs for that massage, and she also
set up the massage table and arranged the oil and lotions
Page 31
1 for IIIII to do that massage.
2 Q And also, just so it's clear, how old was
3 at that time?
4 A She was 17.
: Are there any questions about
6 either how that evidence was presented or about the
7 charges related to Jane Doe Number 1? Seeing no
8 questions, we'll turn to Jane Doe Number 2.
9 BY.
10 Q You previously mentioned that that was 112
11 A Yes.
12 Q Let's turn to Count Number Six, which is on page
13 26, which is the enticement of ■ If you could tell
14 the grand jury about the evidence related to that.
15 A date of birth is
16 Q So during this period of February 5, 2005 to the
17 6th, how old was she?
18 A She was 14.
19 Q Can you remind the grand jury about the evidence
20 related to the enticement of
21 A As we stated earlier, we talked about the
22 telephone calls. We have shown that the facility of
23 interstate commerce was used by the telephone calls made
24 by their cell phones. We examined specifically
25 and . Those calls were made to
Copy 1 of13
(
Page 32
1 set up and arrange appointments for Mr. Epstein to have
2 his massages.
3 Pertaining to , during the massage that
4 occurred on those dates, February 6, in particular, I
5 think I have discussed with you before what occurred on
6 that, that he
7 it -- and that he
8 He did
-- and that was his term for
during that massage, and she
10 . She was paid $300, and we know that she was 14
at the time.
Q If we could turn to Count Number 43, which
appears on page 31. Count 43 is one of the travel counts.
14 If you could tell the grand jury, did a trip occur on
15 March 31, 2005?
16 A Yes, we have flight records that indicate a
17 flight occurred on that date.
18 Q what type of plane was used?
19 A I'm going to refer to the J.E.G.E. , Incorporated
20 aircraft as just the Boeing 727. If we talk about the
21 Hyperion Air, Incorporated aircraft, which is the Gulf
22 Stream, I will just say the Gulf Stream. So on that date
23 he did travel on his Boeing 727, on 3-31.
24 Q And Mr. Epstein was aboard the plane on that
25 day?
I.
Page 33
1 A Yes, he was.
2 Q With respect to the March 31st trip, was there
3 evidence of him setting up the appointment with prior
4 to that trip?
5 A we do have telephonic contact between illilland
6 EMI as well as and on the day before
7 and the day of travel.
8 Q And even though that appointment was never kept,
9 that never went to that appointment, you have the
10 notes that were retrieved from the garbage that showed
11 that Mr. Epstein was expecting to show up for that
12 appointment?
13 A Yes.
14 Q Anything else with respect to that particular
15  count?
16 A We also have the controlled calls and the voice
17  mails.
18 Q Turning to Count Number 60, which appears on
19 page 34, that is the attempted enticement of
20 during the period of March 30 to April 1.
21 Again, at that point, ■was how old?
22 A She was 14.
23 Q And we had talked about the telephone calls that
24 were used. One Of the things that is relevant to this
25 particular count was that in addition to the fact that
Copy 1 of 13
Page 34
was 14, did you interview a girl who went with
2 when she went to Mr. Epstein's house back in
3 February?
4 A Yes, we did, that would be
5 Q And was interviewed?
6 A Yes, she was interviewed by the Palm Beach
7 Police Department.
8 Q What did say about appearance?
9 A That she was the youngest looking girl that
10 came.
11 Q When you talked with , did talk about
12 girls that Mr. Epstein liked in particular?
13 A Yes.
14 Q And was one of those girls?
15 A Yes, she was one of his preferences. also
16 told us that Mr. Epstein said to her on one occasion, "The
17 younger, the better."
18 Q And there was never any attempt to get
19 I.D. or to confirm her actual age?
20 A NO.
21 Q As we discussed before, never actually went
22 to that point, right, so that is just an attempt?
23 A Yes.
24 ■ : Are there any questions from the
25 grand jury? Seeing no questions, we'll see you next
Page 35
week. Thank you.
(Witness excused.)
CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
I CERTIFY pages 1 to 35 is a true transcript of
my shorthand notes of the testimony ofIll
before the Federal Grand Jury, West Palm
Beach, Florida, on the 8th day of May, 2007.
Dated at West Palm Beach, Florida this 23rd day
of May, 2007.
Philip W. May, Court Reporter
Copy 1 of 13
(
(
EFTA00024275 (Jmail)
 [misc] large Wexner funded payments to OB-GYN
(inferred date: 2026-01-17)
Messages Page 1 of 4
Records Listed For: JEFFREY EPSTEIN from 04/11/2005 to 04/11/2005
G
10:13AM
Warren Elsenstein
10:17AM
From Miles
9:37AM
10:20AM
Ira Zlcherman
10:22AM
Ira Zicherman
10:35AM

L. :06AM
Message
11r . Call <REDACTED> 2. Call William
Gowen w) 3. Peter Mendelson in Paris on
hursd y in o in ans this week
Just FYI fli ht info: 'Mend me Jetblue 623 arriving 12.20pm
WPB. 678 jetinreavin B 11.10 am, arriving JFK
1.45p car picking up
LM for Emad to talk to Paul Gandy re phone system and electric
distribution.
Yanush is picking up and
Will email photos of beach house floor.
I lost my cell phone, but will be in the office after 10:30.
You had wanted me to put the tiles on the Midnight express for
the cabana - the midnight express has not left yet as you know -
should I wait for the boat to come to FLA or orgnaise for the tiles
to be sent  to PB
Where should I mall the DVD?
I'm available all week except for Thurs, if you're around.
Bought 50 000 CELG at $437.068
Pis call.
Looking In a realestate magazine - there are 2 hses for sale PB
w/ direct ocean front - Christine COndon in PB - +
another Carole Koeppel they w
times realestate mag
Lm for G to just send the tiles.
Stock is trading at 36.79. I understand there are some
additional shares, soil' blocks available in this area. Do you
have any interest?
LM for o call.
bought bought the two vases (6.500 Euros) and the large
console (4.200 Euros - nice surprise).
Ill http://domsfv03/foxhaven/wc.dil?Gmex—NisgDisplay
Donel
r.
r
4/11/2005
Messages Page 2 of 4
11:07AM
Prof. Camhi
11:16AM  an
Mlles
Schnitman
11:24AM
Eric
11:34AM
Dan
Sperberg
11:3BAM
George
Reenstra
11:40AM
Call me at the office (I tried to connect you).
Pis call
Just calling to see where we stand

Dr. Landon's $25k quartly payment is due, please approve.
Calling re meeting. I'm in NY until Mon. Pis email your reply.
Via email re photos of other 76 s: That is on temp hold,
apparently we are now painting all black with a camel stripe
12 17PM
Naomi
Campbell
12:18PM
12:26PM
LM for
back?
re is any of her friends
r
les
Via email: Hello, naorni here would like to know when I can
speak with Jeffery, regarding my swimsuit line.For a meeting
with VS to see,I have pia and some of the sults with me.. Hope
is well
LM and emailed Dan Sperberg to call.
Bill Karr
12:27PM I will email the plans later today.
Dr. Jarecki
12:33PM
12:43PM
Please call.
LM for Jerry Goldsmith re has lawyer letter been sent out yet'
12:51PM
!Kenneth
Cole
12:51PM
1 45PM
l2!04PM
I2:29PM
M - 1
Calling for Congressman Tom Reynolds regarding the June 14th
annual dinner with Bush. NRCC Business Advisory.
Spoke to Miles re sending the blue tiles for the cabana to PB -
you sd to him last week to keep them for the Tiki house kitchen
- plse advise
r
I7i
O
Returning your call.
I'm back In NY.
From
where
kovitz' office. We're trying to find some place in NY
an have her heart test done.
is back.
Call me re what we talked about.
http://domsrvO I /foxhaven/wc.d.I17Gmax—MsgDisplay
r
lcIr
4/11/2005
Messages
2:38PM
Fiona
2:39PM
2:43PM
Eric
2:54PM
Jerry
Goldsmith
2:57PM
Eric
3:11PM
Larry
Newman
3:39PM
4:17PM
From Dr. Jarecki's. Pis call.
From Dr. Moskowitz's office can get the heart test done
on Fri in NY. Appt at 3.30pm, check-In 3.15pm. Faculty practice
radiology, 530 1st aye, G elevator to 13th floor, $1656 total,
Is there a check for me?
Please confirm that I am wiring $3mm from your account to MJ
LLC.
Page 3 of 4
Can and I work this week?
Gowdy was out of town, but the letter will be delivered today.
Leighton Chandler doesn't know if she can organize for me to
see the mansion this week as it is just getting on the market.
She will check to see if she get me in tomorrow. If not, it will
have to be the next time I'm in town. *** Copied From
GHISLAINE MAXWELL ••• Original Date and Time: 04/11/2005
at 2:19P
via my email: Please let Jeffrey know that If he intends to
participate in the Emerging Market Special Opportunities fund
that the deadline for subscription does is next Wednesday, April
20 for May 1 trading. Thanks!
will pick u prescription. WHere should I fedex it?
FYI: on the Dr. Landon quarterly payments, we (NYSG) billed
LHW/Abigail In advance as we have In prior years.
Pis call.
I just need a few more minutes if you have time.
Just calling to check in.
G
4:21PM
4:26PM
4:27PM
The Tel Aviv ticket was not a fraud. It was to get a renewal for 1
your 2nd valid passport. We're getting a refund for it.
The pool specialist can't come tomorrow in PB. He can only come
on wednesday morning If it's ok for you. Pls advice
Fro the power symposium, we are looking at 4 days between
January 6, 2006 and January 17th or 18th. The participants
working on their schedules and need to know ASAP. We also
need to let the hotel so we don't lose our $20,000 deposit.
11
Ill http://domsrvOl/foxhaven/wc.cfirGmax—MsgDisplay
LT,
r
❑
4/11/2005
•
Messages Page 4 of 44:27PM HI had •n the line for you. _I
1

Dr. Victor I PCs call. 4:28PM
l an work tomorrow at 4pm. 4:29PM I had Dan Sperberg on the line for you. He will call back since he
4:41PM has no reception In the library.

• I forwarded helicopter pictures from George Reenstra to your
yahoo. r
r 4:47PM I had Dr. Jarecki on the line.
G
4:50PM got her aesthetician license and can not do facials. F
manu
4:54PM
GYM works in Pads: 3 weeks 1/2 to finish. Pinto waiting for a
starting date ( possibly 8 days of advance to organize it) r
Bill Karr
4:55PM
The mail server Is down, but I will email the plans as soon as I
can. r
Outstanding
4:56PM did not call back r
Callers Prof. Camhi, Miles Schnitman n 4:56PM Dr. Victor.
S,‘1.4 11.1AarketleCkeTcleSPekeTeS Reird .T9

•   (*WO 031PATTBS
•
Copyright (c) 2000-2004, Epstein Interests, Inc. All Rights Reserved
http://domsrvOlifoxhaven/wc.d117Gmax—MsgDisplay 4/l1/2005
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Luke D. Thorburn [government] informant, ex-Goldman Sachs, Paraguay [nyt] 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00174375 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of Luke D. Thorburn, lots of takes on Epstein, China, and Steve Bannon
(inferred date: 2026-01-17)
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
DO NOT DISSEMINATE — Parkhouse, Tebet, and US Employee #1 are being harassed and threatened.
Any information released will be used directly to further the harassment of Parkhouse, Tebet, and US
Employee #1. Even the smallest detail can be maliciously used against all three individuals.
The purpose of the below account is my security intelligence concern related to Luke D. Thorburn and
Addison Basurto and multiple harassing communications to me on multiple platforms. (Note: Basurto
is possibly a representative of the media. It is unclear what relationship Thorburn has with media.)
Key concerns: Escalating threats against Parkhouse and Tebet by Thorburn, Online Stalking, Online
Harassment, Slander/Defamation
On Friday, November 18, 2022, at approximately 5:30pm, U.S. Employee #1 invited me to a happy hour
gathering at Dobe General Store (Address: Asa Sul CLS 112 BL A Loja 21 —Asa Sul, Brasilia — DF 70375-
510). I arrived at Dobe at approximately 6:15pm. U.S. Employee #1 introduced me to Renato Tebet.
Believing Tebet was a U.S. Embassy Employee, I introduced myself as Kristen Parkhouse Legat/FBI. I later
learned he was not but has close affiliations with many individuals at the U.S. Embassy.
Tebet is the owner of two bars, Dobe and the Jungle Bar (Asa Norte CLN 408 C 48 — Asa Norte, Brasilia —
DF 70856-530). For background purposes, the Jungle Bar is known as an embassy bar. While I live only a
block away, I have never gone to the Jungle Bar. Additionally, other than going to dinner with a few
girlfriends from the embassy and one local friend, in the year I have been in Brazil, I have not gone to a
happy hour other than those organized by CLO (embassy community liaison organization).
After making introductions, a U.S. Employee Dependent arrived (his father is a U.S. Employee at the
embassy and was not present). U.S. Employee Dependent joined us at the table. U.S. Employee
Dependent is approximately 21 years old, is here living with his parents, and DJs at Tebet's bars. U.S.
Employee Dependent was meeting up with a young lady for their first date. For background purposes,
U.S. Employee Dependent's date also brought her female friend along. At the Dobe bar, U.S. Employee
Dependent left the table several times to socialize.
Tebet and I had an enjoyable conversation. From the time I arrived until at least 7:45 pm, Tebet shared
with me the following:

1. Tebet's aunt is Brazilian Senator Simone Tebet. Simone ran for president here in Brazil and
placed third. After the first election, Bolsonaro did not reach out to her, but Lula did. It is
believed by some that because seven million people voted for her, those votes went to Lula
during the second election due to Bolsonaro's inaction to appeal to those that voted for her.

2. Along with owning two bars, Tebet owns a solar company. Currently he is focusing on rural
farming. Additionally, he won the contract to provide solar power to the stadium here in
Brasilia. The stadium, I believe, is the Arena BRB Mane Garrincha.

3. Tebet grew up in the USA in Rockville, MD until the age of thirteen years old. Tebet's dad was
with IDB (Inter-American Development Bank), part of the World Bank from my understanding,
which is a cooperative bank that helps support the economic and social development of Latin
America and Caribbean countries. They moved back to Brazil because his dad needed to be
closer to his parents.

4. We also talked about his girlfriend of five years, the engagement ring she wanted, and life in
Brazil compared to the United States.
Page 1 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED/IFOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department

5. About me, we talked about my truck (Toyota Tacoma) which I brought with me, diesel vs regular
gasoline. Food. Specifically, Michelin Star restaurants in Rio. My parents are coming to Brazil,
and we are going to Rio. Tebet had some ideas of places we could go that were not Michelin
Star but better. I gave him my person WhatsApp/email not my work so he could send me ideas.
Note: U.S. Employee #1 had already reported Tebet as a foreign contact and the two were
friends. U.S. Employee Dependent also worked for Tebet with the approval of his father, also a
U.S. Employee. Therefore, I felt comfortable providing my contact information with Tebet.
6. Tebet mentioned he organized an interview for someone he knew and that they would be
showing up soon and that the interview would take place at a table under the patio. He did not
mention the nature of the interview.
At approximately 8:00 pm. Luke D. Thorburn arrived and sat down next to me.

• Managing Director - Birdwood
• Cell & Signal +595-992-317181 Cell & Signal
• www.birdwoodcap.com
• luke@birdwoodcap.com

• lukethorburn@protonmail.com
• Ithorburn87@gmailcom
• Juan de Salazar 657, Asuncion, Paraguay.
• Google: Luke D. Thorburn and Goldman Sachs (NYT article for more background information.)
Between approximately 8:30 pm and 9:00 pm two younger gentlemen arrive who were Brazilian and
spoke Portuguese. They sat down next to U.S. Employee #1 and spoke with U.S. Employee #1 and
Tebet. I learned later that the two young gentlemen were in some way employed or connected to
Brazilian politics.
Between approximately 9:00 pm and 9:30 pm Addison Basurto arrived. Basurto later identified himself
as a reporter from the National File:

• Twitter: Addy Adds — OneAddyAdds
• National File: Addison Basurto
• Facebook: Addy Adds
https://m.facebook.com/daddvaddvadds?eav=AfbAzGeULzPXo0pBI0cP alvFULdKGbalSvTkOpG
qFuh9dTMaoLl3j4 vXNvASzVvillAtsid=0.7109277584360073&source=result

• YouTube: https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCiWkFn6s2uMhfxS-lsWI9A)
• BuyMeACoffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/addyadds

• Substack: https://www.addyadds.substack.com
• Website: https://www.addvadds.one/
• Telegram: https://www.t.me/oneaddvadds

• Rokfin: https://rokfin.com/addyaddsCashApp: https://cash.aPP/SAddyAdds
• Venmo: HTTPS:HVENMO.COWADDYADDS

• Patreon: HTTPS://WWW.PATREON.COM/ADDYADDSTwitter: HTTPS://TWITTER.COM/ONEADDYADDSETHEREUM: Oxl8d83c60d3b933960c5ff5Cbb9S96f49SeBa0d99
Page 2 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED/IFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State DepartmentBITCOIN: 3MNbWXUdjFf9uokVItSysllSovV8FIr8Nqw
When Basurto arrived, Tebet introduced me and mentioned that I worked at the FBI. While my fellow
FBI colleagues and I are declared overseas, I typically do not mention where I work to keep things
simple. Addison asked what I did at the FBI, and I responded that we provide training to overseas law
enforcement agencies, which is true and is on our FBI.gov website. I also said I was not an agent. When
asked how I got to Brazil, I mentioned that I was looking for new opportunities and I even took a pay cut
to come down because I wanted to see what else was out there in terms of career opportunities and
that I loved Brazil. Addison and Thorburn asked if I knew anything about certain geopolitical topics, and I
responded that while I have worked cases, it tended to be really in the weeds, so I often do not see the
bigger picture. My response was successful, and they did not ask me any additional questions about my
work.
Between about 9:45 pm to 10:00 pm Basurto unexpectedly began conducting an interview at the table.
Basurto switched seats with U.S. Employee #1. The interview began in Portuguese and Tebet began to
interpret. I was under the impression from Tebet that the interview he planned was to be at another
table and I was confused why U.S. Employee #1 was staying. Bausto is American and knew that U.S.
Employee #1 and I worked for the federal government, so I was surprised when the interview topic was
about Brazilian politics, specifically Bolsonaro, Lula, China's influence, members in the Brazilian
government, and two assassinations. The interview was incredibly short, less than fifteen minutes and
only about publicly knows topics. I was confused and if anything ventured into something more
sensitive, I was prepared to leave regardless of U.S Employee #1 who had invited me. After the
interview, I knew I had to repot the encounter, so I asked Thorburn for his business card and in
exchange, Thorburn gave me his cellphone for me to put in my contact information in return. At this
point, U.S. Employee #1 had already given his business card to Thorburn and U.S Employee #1 seemed
to know about Thorburn previously. Additionally, Thorburn and Basurto already knew my name and
where I worked from Tebet.
As I mentioned above, Thorburn spoke to me at length twice at the Dobe bar. Everyone was at the
table, Thorburn was speaking to me, while the others were speaking to each other in a mix of
Portuguesa and English; it was very loud. The following are topics he spoke about pertaining to his life,
the majority of which he told me between 10:00 pm and 11:00 pm:

1. Thorburn told me that he used to work for Goldman Sachs. During that time, he sold hats with
his then girlfriend (the Trump red hats and similar hats with a Christian logo). He was
subsequently fired from Goldman Sachs because he was in breech of his visa (you are not
allowed to have a side business on the visa he had). Thorburn said the business was in his
girlfriend's name, which he tried to argue, but the government liked his excuse even less. Later
he found out from a friend who worked with US passports, that he was deemed a threat to
national security and was not allowed back in the country (not just for the overreach of his visa).
Thorburn said being marked as a threat to national security was absurd. He did markets
coverage at Goldman Sachs/securities. He said he was going to marry the woman he had the
side business with, she was his fiancé, but that eventually the relationship came to an end
because of what happened to him. He said he was front page in the New York Times.

2. Thorburn then mentioned that he has been traveling between Brazil and Paraguay. Thorburn
said he has a consulting visa for Brazil. He travels and stays in Brazil three months at a time and
Page 3 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED/NOW) - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PH
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
returns to Paraguay. He was working on a coconut water project in northern Brazil. He was
originally traveling between Brazil, Argentina, Columbia, Bahamas and back home (Australia). He
then went to Paraguay. While he heard Paraguay was a pretty dangerous place, when he got
there it seemed pretty normal and he thought this would be a good place to start again.
Paraguay had international capital, there was lots to be done, and no one was really doing
anything in Paraguay. Forestry is Paraguay's competitive advantage. However, through his
experiences he does believe there is a deep state in Paraguay. This is influenced by him being
marked a national threat in the United States, which he believes is absurd, but as a result has
learned that deep states do exit. Having been persecuted and with cancel culture as well, he
learned that maybe there is a movement against people like him.

3. Thorburn mentioned Narco drug trafficking that he witnessed.
4. Thorburn mentioned his involvement with the Moonies in Paraguay. (Rise Of The 'Moonies:' Is
The Unification Church A Cult? (groovyhistory.com) https://groovvhistorv.com/unification-
church-moonie-cult/6

5. Thornburn mentioned Wikileaks Julian Paul Assange.
6. Thorburns's lawyer is one of the top lawyers in Paraguay and associated with the Zukalula
Family (phonetically spelled).

7. Thorburn went to Paraguay as a normal person and met his mentor "Shakespeare" via
Shakespeare's nephew who is one of the top hackers in Paraguay. Shakespeare is in his 60's
now. Because the nephew is more "techie" Shakespeare got a long more with Thorburn and
developed a friendship via talking about sports and things of the like. They met at a Christmas
party. Thoburn mentioned that there really are no Americans in Paraguay, so they stand out. I
am not sure who the American he was speaking of. Thorburn said that Shakespeare trained him
unofficially and gave him guidance on his life. Additionally, he said that Shakespeare shared
things with him that he probably shouldn't have.

8. Thorburn talked extensively and in depth about the Epstein case and his research. Thorburn has
Steve Bannon's personal cellphone in his phone and said that Bannon had blocked him.
However, what they do (Thorburn and someone else) is call and make recordings. Additionally,
they put read receipts on all emails to show that Bannon knew about certain aspects of the
Epstein case as it related to CCP (China) and was covering it up. Thorburn has built a huge file
with everyone that knew about Epstein and did nothing and when the case is fully exposed, he
will be able to expose those that knew and did nothing. For example, Bannon deleted one of
Thorburn's tweets which Thorburn took a screen shot. Thorburn reached out and showed
Bannon the screenshot and as a result Bannon ran the story. Thorburn also mentioned
something about Operation Mockingbird.
9. At this point I could see the emotional toll Thorburn was experiencing and the subsequent
rabbit hole he was going down, both by the people he was allegedly associating with and activity
he was engaging in, most likely because of the traumatic experience of being exiled from his
former career, not allowed into the United States, the loss of his reputation, friends, and loved
ones and potentially a preexisting personality for such things. I asked if he had any brothers or
sisters to see if he had any support outside of the people he was currently interacting with
(religious cult leaders with heavy financial ties, narco drug traffickers, a potential former
intelligence officer, a hacker, and questionable journalists). He said he has two younger sisters
and that his brother had died of an accidental heroine overdoes. Thorburn then expressed that
Page 4 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED/NOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
seeing the Narco drug trafficking in Paraguay and the role the CIA played in support of those
drug activities really affected him. He mentioned the Golden Triangle and the numerous Aussie
kids that were killed because of drugs. I talked about the epic lives we all live and keep secret in
our hearts and asked if he still spoke to his mom. He said yes, he talks to her almost every day,
but that he has been away a long time. The Trump election wasn't that long along. Thorburn
said he was in the USA from 2009 to about 2016 and he has lived many lives since then. I shared
that I used to work violent crimes against children and these things can take a toll on you and
that I knew someone who was witness to the Lehman Brothers situation the night it happened
and the toll it took on him. I said that his life has taken him down this path, from Australia to the
United States is one thing, but to Brazil and now Paraguay, how does he see a path out of this
for himself. Thorburn responded he is keeping the financial work/business going and that his
interest in news reporting is ancillary. He is realizing he cannot do both. Opposition journalists
are trying to link him to the National File and Paraguay because he has been aggressive to them.
He said though that he might buy a stake in a media outlet. Thorburn also mentioned that he
was independently wealthy.
Note: Thorburn appeared to be supporting and leading Basurto who is a reporter for the
National File. Thorburn asked questions during the interview. However, Basurto will later claim
in his news reporting that Thorburn was his bodyguard and from Texas.

10. I brought up AP and Reuters and asked why he felt those trustworthy news outlets would not be
the best place to forward stories and if he did come across something why he did not just inform
those news outlets or his own federal government in Australia. Thorburn then said he cannot
trust his own government and spoke about the CFP and that the Australian Army was being
advised by the Chinese and specifically mentioned one guy who he has a picture of.

11. Thorburn then returned to the topic of Epstein. He showed me a photo of a massive and
complex matrix involving CCP, Epstein, congressmen, etc. He mentioned that he forwarded it to
U.S. Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Green. I asked why he would choose her. He said because
of her megaphone (access to a large audience) but that she was a POS. Thorburn then
mentioned his interactions with her staffer a young male. He said he threatened the staffer by
saying he was going to run a negative story about him to get him to respond by playing into the
staffers narcissistic tendencies. It apparently worked, and the staffer responded to Thorburn
and gave Thorburn what he needed regarding Epstein.
12. Thorburn shared a lot with me. Specifically, Thorburn also shared that he felt threatened for his
life and was concerned about returning to Paraguay. While we all open up to people we feel
connected to, I was not sure why Thorburn told me all of this about himself, so I asked. I wasn't
quite sure how to word it, so I said that I typically keep my personal life and my work life
separate and was he telling me all of this because he wanted to be my friend or because he
wanted me to tell someone where I worked (i.e. was he reaching out for help). It was then that
he went into detail about feeling unsafe returning to Paraguay, but didn't want to seem overly
paranoid. Our conversation was cut off because the group started to head out.
At approximately 11:00 pm the group decided to head to the Jungle Bar. U.S. Employee #1 drove
Thorburn and Basurto to the Jungle Bar. While being polite, I said I would meet up with them there.
However, once I was able to step away, and collect my thoughts, I did not want to join them. I live next
to the Jungle Bar. I did not want U.S. Employee #1 to think something happened to me, so when I got
home, I took Tilly (my dog) out and walked to the bar to let them know I was not going to stay.
Page 5 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
I believe I got to the bar sometime after midnight. When I arrived, Thorburn was at the other end of the
table; I did not interact with him. U.S. Employee Dependent, his date, and her friend arrived minutes
after me. I enjoy talking to U.S. Employee Dependent and know his father well. U.S. Employee
Dependent and I were talking when Basurto started to pepper U.S. Embassy Dependent with questions.
The first few questions were benign, but then Basurto directly asked U.S. Embassy Dependent if he knew
anyone at the embassy that works for the "CIA". I told U.S. Employee Dependent to stop speaking and
advised him Basurto was with the media. U.S. Employee Dependent immediately stop talking. Basurto
left the table.
Meanwhile, a redhead Brazilian female had shown interest in Thorburn and gave him her phone
number, which U.S. Employee #1 delivered to Thorburn. Thorburn did not seem interested, so the
redhead female asked U.S. Employee #1 to wrangle Thorburn and get him to come over to her table.
She was at a large table with many people, celebrating someone's birthday from my understanding. U.S.
Employee #1 went over to talk to Thorburn and brought him to the redhead female's table. U.S.
Employee #1 also stayed at the table where the birthday was taking place. Note: The redhead was not
Tebet's girlfriend as Basurto will later allege.
While my intention was not to stay, Tebet came over and sat with me to talk and U.S. Employee
Dependent's two female friends started talking to me. All were enjoying having a fun time with Tilly (my
dog). The two female friends were nice, and we talked about the course they were taking in college,
career plans, saving for retirement. I stayed and chatted with them. Moreover, I also subconsciously
stayed because I noticed that U.S. Employee #1 was showing signs of being drunk. I had been at a family
party of another embassy employee where U.S. Employee #1 became intoxicated. Additionally, I felt
protective of U.S. Employee Dependent, and something felt off about the evening. In recently years we
all have interacted with people who have extreme views, but this felt different.
While I was speaking to the two female friends of U.S. Employee Dependent, I suddenly heard Basurto,
who was sitting at the other end of the table, say to a gentleman with a beard, accent, and black and
white shirt, "She works for the FBI." I turned my head and looked in the direction of Basurto thinking to
myself, what the heck. Then the man responded, "No she doesn't." I thought to myself, great problem
solved he does not believe him. I also heard Basurto say that they have confirmed reports that the CIA
was involved in the election (Brazilian). Then, I saw Basurto begin to record me while asking the man if I
work for the CIA. I responded and said I do not work there and do not film me. The two female friends
informed me that the man with the beard had purchased all the food and drinks in the bar for everyone.
I told the two females that we were leaving. I got up, found a waiter, and just gave him cash (there was
no bill, but I wanted to make sure that the one beer I had and the young ladies' beer each was covered.)
I gave the waiter the money and then suddenly Thorburn came up to me and said he was sick. He was
shaking through his whole body. I asked him if he was allergic to something he might have eaten and he
said no. He appeared to be really sick. I said there was a hospital right around the corner, did he need to
be taken there. He said no. I then said, "This might not be the most opportune time, but your colleague
just recorded me saying I work somewhere I don't." Thorburn then said he would delete the video.
I went up to U.S. Employee #1 to talk about Thorburn being sick. Basurto also came up to U.S. Employee
#1. We briefly discussed the video and Basurto said he would delete it, but his demeanor had
completely changed, and I did not believe him. I believe I then stepped away for a minute. When I came
back to U.S. Employee #1, Basurto was in U.S. Employee #1's face asking to get his bags out of U.S.
Page 6 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
Employee #1's car. U.S. Employee #1 was under the influence of alcohol. Basurto then turned to me and
asked if I would get their bags out. I said I could. U.S. Employee #1 said to Basurto to not talk to me, that
I was his friend and to talk only to him. At that moment, because of Basurto 's movement and
Thorburn's behavior behind him, I moved away quickly. As soon as I moved away, I turned around and
saw U.S. Employee #1 laying on the ground not moving. I could not see U.S. Employee #1's face, only his
shoulders to his feet. I thought U.S. Employee #1 might be knocked out or dead. I saw a man holding
Thorburn back (later I learned it was Tebet holding Thorburn back). Thorburn was screaming at U.S.
Employee #1, "Why is the CIA after mel" U.S. Employee #1 started to move. Note: U.S. Employee #1 had
multiple bruises on his stomach afterwards. I immediately went to get U.S. Employee Dependent and his
two friends. The two friends had already ordered separate Ubers (because I had told them previously
that we were leaving). I made sure the two friends got into their Ubers. I then told U.S. Employee
Dependent I was taking him home. My phones had died so I could not call Legat Marco Gonzalez, Jr. So, I
told U.S. Employee Dependent to call his dad who I believe was in the United States on travel because
we needed to report this right away. I spoke to U.S. Employee Dependent's dad and told him what
happened as U.S. Employee Dependent, Tilly (my dog), and I walked safely around the block. Things
cooled off, I quickly returned to the bar to make sure U.S. Employee #1 was okay. Thorburn and Basurto
were not at the bar. Note: The Jungle Bar is outside. I told Tebet that I could not stay and would he
please make sure U.S. Employee #1 made it home okay. As U.S. Employee Dependent and I left the bar,
we passed the Civil Police as they arrived and were walking towards the bar. I took U.S. Employee
Dependent back to my apartment, got my truck and drove him home. When I got back to my apartment,
I charged my phone and sent Legat Marco Gonzalez, Jr. a message at about 4 am that I needed to speak
to him as soon as he woke up. I went to bed, woke up early, drove to Marco's apartment at about 7:30
am and waited for him to get my message. He got my message, came down to get me at 7:52 am. I
explained to Marco what took place. Marco then immediately called Regional Security Officer Roberto
Bernardo and briefed him on the situation.
On the evening of Friday, December 1, 2022, I ran into Tebet and U.S. Employee #1. I was eating dinner
in a nearby restaurant on my way home. Tebet shared with me that he was receiving the same
threating communications and that while carrying a firearm in Brazil is legal, he has never done so, but
now he did even when he walked his dog (he felt that threatened). Additionally, the threatening
communications he received included videos accusing his girlfriend of being a CIA asset along with him
and he had not told her yet, because he did not want to worry her. He then said that the guy with the
beard did not pay for everyone and skipped out on the bill. Tebet said he reported the incident to State
Department RSO who had a member of their team reach out to Tebet. Tebet had the CCTV footage from
that night and in addition shared with the RSO team member that he was being stalked online. He used
those exact words he said "stalked" because identifiable information about him was realized (I also
experienced that same). Tebet also wondered if Thorburn had left the country because even after
blocking Thorburn, he received messages from a Brazilian area code.
Below are the threating messages I received to include links to videos on YouTube, Twitter, and
Rumble/National File. Note: Messages were set to disappear so I was not able to capture all of them, but
was able to capture several. Basurto has many platforms, which were listed above. I only went to the
platforms that were sent directly to me. I assume he has posted not only on his other platforms, but on
the websites of the reporters that interviewed him. I did not look at any other sites other that those I
was threated with. Moreover, Thorburn used the term "KP" and "Parky" to describe me in messages
Page 7 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDWOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
which is something my friends call me and most likely he found on Facebook. When I went to block
Basurto, I saw he posted this message on Facebook: Agent Orange: are you on Facebook? He also
posted the same message on Twitter:
Posts
Addy Adds •e •
Agent Orange: are you on Facebook?
If so, please send me a Direct
Message.
comm...? evN sha,
0  Addy Adds @OneAddyAdds • 3h
Agent Orange: are you on Twitter?
If so, please send me a Direct Message.
0
In addition to the numerous videos already posted on the internet, in which Tebet, U.S. Employee #1,
and Parkhouse are tagged, Thorburn is using the same technique he used on Steve Bannon and the
Congressional Staffer. He is trying to intimidate us by threating to ruin our professional reputations
with false information. We are all tagged in a news article posted by the National File which is an
American right-wing blog and news website. National File - Wikipedia  Moreover, while U.S. Employee
#1 has a common name, Tebet and I have unique names and when you Google us, these videos come
up in the first few entries. This will continue to cause harm to Parkhouse and Tebet. This is especially
egregious because we did literally nothing wrong to Thorburn and Basurto, in fact we were both very
professional to both men. Moreover, I offered to help Thorburn get to a hospital when he said he was
sick, and I said I would get their bags out of U.S. Employee #1's car.
Signal Messages: Unknown number to Parkhouse's State Department Cellphone
Monday, 21 November
Unknown set disappearing message time to 1 hour
Note: I was unable to save or capture this message because it was set to disappear. However,
the message alerted me to information that Basurto had posted on the internet. Note: The
profile picture of the Signal sender was a chess piece. It was later changed to U.S. Employee #1's
image from video taken that night. (See below for the YouTube videos which were mentioned in
the message.)
Page 8 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
eM
•
all NI
No WO.* in Cannon. Anise
Meant, Caratay.
Lodnalso•
Nark 21 nag
0 Unknownset Onappeanna
mdettallo tirno tot now
Today
In tar message you and share your
note and photo with them> They won,
know you've aeon thew message unta yen
YouTube Videos posted by Basurto
Monday, 21 November
hups://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3ZDsmmyDkNU
"Time To Go" - Why We Had To Leave Brazil My bodyguard and I were attacked by intelligence
agents on Saturday. A U.S. State Department employee verbally\physically attacked us. The
asset told me I would wind up "at a (CIA) blacksite in the middle of the ocean."
" Wag cz
Tarn To ce Way We Mad To lawn irlaail
~agarrto 6n 9 ham. rote
Page 9 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PH
UNCLASSIFIED/IFOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
Monday, 21 November
https://www.youtube.comiwatch?v=IINbipxNU-s
American Journalist Speaks Out After Fleeing Brazil
Moab 4
ADDY ADDS SHARES WHY HE
"WENT DARK" ON TWITTER
AuERKAN WtrowitiST Willa OUT AFT  FLEEING Ma
-- CID
Wednesday, 23 November
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCIEN3slhi4
Fear & Loathing in Brazil
abate
6 3. 9 A
t 4
4:ek Th•OuIs
— —
how i tine. lin emu
• trn CID
Page 10 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED/fFOU0 - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PII
UNCLASSIFIED/IFOUO - FBI
SBU - Legal - State Department
Signal Messages: Unknown number to Parkhouse's State Department Cellphone
Friday, 25 November 8:00pm (approximate based on when I took a screen shot)
KP, wassup bae?
Note: One of my concerns is that "KP" is being used which is a nickname my friends call me,
which means Thorburn/Addison were looking me up online.
fie
<
MIIMP F
.4 30
No groups in common. Resler/I
requests Caretuty.
Learn More
Mon, 21 Nov
UnknOVel Set desappeatmg
message time t01 how
Today
New Massages
KP, wastupbn?
tel id MT message you and share your
name and photo with them? They won't
knew you're seen thew message until you
Iccept
Twitter: Addy Adds (@OneAddyAdds) - https://twitter.com/OneAddvAdds
Sunday, 27 November
I Thread
2  Ado,.
.7.ate Department employee. Miguel Contreras.
a: ti cked my bodyguard and I in Brasilia. Brasil.
I was told by an asset. 'The Beard.' that I would end
up in a "shy to the middle of the ring ocean in a
blacksite."
Kristin Parkhouse. an 'FBI agent: was present.
SSS • nee"! Oen* *sae° •••1••• .te tee hi,  *S 1.11•Se. artSt h0 te PINS
is tan ea the eel hre
e each Nub Mete eie mane gaw
iat ea. tmn We. -w to gamed d
ea be crane. 0 ww eid lease Teed
>Y. SISS ern
Page 11 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED/IFOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
S Addy Adds tcOneAddyAddS • Nov 27
Replying to CcOneAddyAddS
The owner of the bars Dobe and Jungle Bar. Renato Tebet. 33. is a cousin
Of Simone Tibet, the presidential candidate who placed 3rd in Brazil's 2022
eleCtion.
He told me he stands to "make a lot of money" If Lula takes power.
His girlfriend. Nataly Ribeiro. is another asset.
O 2 0 16 O 33
n POIS10114,TIAL
NP.4
O TOAD ANY
HE Will
'AIME A
TUlf Of
MONET'
WHEN MR
TAKES
POWER.
S Mdy Adds 00neAddyAdds • Nan 27 ..• Notice the end when my bodyguard approaches and I am in Dominic's lace.
Chest breathing.
Shallow breathing.
This is associated with a he:ghtened conisol response from the body.
derived from the part of the brain cased the arnygdala.
In colloquial terms. it's cased 'fear:

• Addy Adds POneAddyAdds Nov 2?
US State Department employee. Miguel Contreras. attacked my
bodyguard and I in Brasile. Braa.
I was told by an asset. 'The Beard: that I would end up in a 'snip in the
middle of the f —ing ocean in a becksite:
Kristin Rarkhouse. an 'FBI agent.' was present.
Show this thread
O 2 la 4 Q to
Page 12 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
S Addy Adds @OneAddyAcids • Nov 27
Nataly Ribeiro told me her name was 'Bianca' and that she was 22 years
•••
old.
rl 9 O
Monday, 28 November
Addy kids I:IO.O43~ • No, >I
Aral ne LUC ?MS to tet me to trove sore cents...1~0Lnc ute , !OP
me 15. 1,41 ~etc* *env,. n both hp and Mosnitun
He acceart to 'Mx eye comae: wen 'gel suotrvw: Kr$Cn
afro NCI exn us. State Deue~t enbis.
C O
YouTube Videos posted by Basurto
Monday, 28 November
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JUVqqw6C6rU
Coffee Talk Ep19 Addy discusses his travel to Brazil by Dr Paul Cottrell
Page 13 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR Pll
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
Monday, 28 November
https://www.voutube.comiwatch?v=IFKMc5K17gl
Addy & Bodyguard Attacked in Brazil
puma set/
a umpiesmente • -
-St the 7 -rty — As II antio. ?e ; — !)ust anti +pot lot
ammo j y isTa4 dam
Setae ad dea 4  •
y •
ag kw ratt° a' a  1 re rt.:1,s ia lP effe  tcf
saw 'Ogg cuetlpatcu el IAA Me
' -
Addy L 00•09.6.1 AttdCkdd
WhatsApp Messages from: +595-992-317181 to Parkhouse's State Department
Cellphone (Thorburn's cellphone number from the business card he gave me.)
Monday, 28 November 1:01 pm
Porky!
Who is your bearded friend in your video?
httos://www.voutube.conilwatchThao=desktoo&v=XmOdBWIq
"Parencen Americans."
< P •••••••nre.
• WSW. a al IV WWI
a alp..
IN. Lit
T.WWW•
<•o  rIml an •
oudanowndonwo.
waspewla...20.6a..
SAY
%to a wou tonne frond n
now twin.
myna ...no onetdo toot
nun ,
oandooktegar•rorPrIOV
Page 14 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PH
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU - Legal - State Department
Monday, 28 November 4:26 pm
???
Monday, 28 November 8:10 pm
Addy Adds on Twitter
"US State Deportment employee, Miguel Contreras, attacked my bodyguard and 1 in Brasilia,
Brasil. I was told by on asset, 'The Beard" that I would end up in a "ship in the middle of the
f****ing ocean in a blacksite." Kristin Porkhouse, an "FBI Agent," was present." Twitter.com
httos://twittercom/oneaddvadds/status/1596950498610847750?s=46&t=5cSZMOAficID8FYSw
Qgleq
Monday, 28 November 8:11 pm
Who is your bearded friend?
Monday, 28 November 8:21 pm
Missed voice call
.595 992 317181
Who 8 yo.4 bextled Inendhl
'our vkleo?
https://brafttersom,
aleaddyaddsistatusi
1596950498610847750?
s=4681=ScSZMCVLII0D8FY
SwOcileg
Who is your bearded friend?
/..2 oil 21 821 P1.1
Email Communication from Thorburn to Parkhouse and U.S. State Department
Employee #1
From: Luke Thorburn <lukethorburn@protonmail.com>
Sent: Tuesday, November 29, 2022 5:19 PM
To: Parkhouse, Kristen A <ParkhouseKA@stote.gov>; kaparkhouse@fbi.gov; Contreras, Miguel
<ContrerosM@state.gov>
Subject: Miguel Contreras' Assault on US Journalist
Y'all can't assault and threaten journalists. Doesn't matter who the phuck you think you ore.
https://nationalfile.com/watch-omerican-journalist-ottacked-by-us-state-deportment-employee-in-
brazil-forced-to-flee-the-country/
Sent from Proton Moil for iOS
Note: Below is the article, there is also a video.
Page 15 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
WATCH: American Journalist Attacked By US State
Department Employee In Brazil, Forced To Flee The Country
An investigative reporter for The National File was set up in an apparent
intelligence operation and he and his bodyguard were forced to leave the
country under the protection of an armed escort.
ADDISON BASURTO
November 29, 2022
in International News News
MI
terminar en un barco
en medio de la puta
ocean° en un sitio negro".
"Yeah, and then you
end up in a ship
in the middle of the fucking
ocean in a blacksite."
hare on FacebookShare on Twitte
Last Updated on November 29, 2022
On Friday November 18th, Addison Basurto, an American journalist for The National
File, along his bodyguard, were attacked by Miguel Contreras, Second Secretary at the
Embassy of the United States of America in Brasilia, Brazil while FBI Agent, Kristin
Parkhouse, was present during their investigation and reportage on the largest pro-
liberty demonstrations in the history of the Federative Republic of Brazil.
Page 16 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEWFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PII
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
MIGUEL CONTRERAS
Segundo Secretario
Second Secretary
Embalxada dos Estados Unidos da America SFS - Av. das Napes, Qd. 801, It. 3 Brasilia - OF, Brasil 70403-900
tel: +55.61-3312-7104 cel: +55.61-98265-0191
contrerasm@state.gov
RelatedPosts
RINO Reps. Threaten Moderate RINO or Even Dem Speaker if Conservatives Don't Back FTX Scandal-
Plagued McCarthy
Kevin McCarthy o Stock' Ban in 2017
Biden Calls on Congress to Force Through Railroad Labor Deal Despite Rejection by Key Unions
The attack occurred after the journalist requested to have his backpack returned, which
was in the diplomatic -plated vehicle in which Contreras drove the duo to the "jungle
Bar," an establishment owned by Renato Tebet, 33, the cousin of Simone Tebet, an ally
of Luiz Inacio "Lula" Da Silva, who placed third in the 2022 Brazilian presidential
election.
The car driven by Miguel Contreras had diplomatic plates, and the State Department
employee boasted to Basurto and his security officer that diplomatic immunity made
them untouchable by Brazilian law enforcement authorities.
FBI Agent, Kristin Parkhouse, sat idly by as Contreras attacked Basurto multiple times,
even after she was asked to intervene. After Basurto requested the return of his
backpack, which contained all of his electronics, notes and laptop, Contreras became
belligerent, verbally and physically assaulting the American journalist.
The bar owner who facilitated the meeting of all people present, Renato Tebet, is a
cousin of Simone Tebet, who placed 3rd in the 2022 Brazilian Presidential election.
Renato Tebet told Basurto he stands to "make a lot of money" if Lula takes power on
January 1st, 2023.
Page 17 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED/N .OU° - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR Pll
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
After a young red-headed woman, Roberta Caho, along with several other patrons at
the bar, succeeded in getting the writer's bodyguard to leave the table and speak with
the young lady, a bearded man who had been buying drinks for all of the patrons of the
bar sat across the table from the young writer and began to attempt intimidate him.
"HELLO, I FIND YOU VERY
HANDSOME [CUTE]. IF
YOU WANT TO SEND ME
A MESSAGE: 99988363.
-RI;
umu.,
- RtIBERTA"
E ERES
Y GUAPO. SI QUIERA
88363 ENVIARME UN MENSAJE:
9998833
-ROBERTA"
"Hello, I find you very handsome. If you want to send me a message: 9998833 —
Roberta"
The bearded man, who claimed his name was "Dominic," appeared to be an ally of
Renato Tebet and sat down at the table across from the National File writer.
Dominic told Basurto that "we are reading every text, every [cell phone] ping, every
article you write." He told the American reporter that "the election has already been
decided, and there is nothing you can do about it."
Page 18 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR Pll
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
He repeatedly asked the journalist to "go for a walk" with him, to which the American
replied, "I'm not going for a walk with you." Dominic, who has bought drinks for the
entire bar, also attempted to get the National File reporter to consume more and more
alcohol.
He also told Basurto had experience working in both Iraq and Afghanistan.
"Dominic" told Basurto that the redheaded woman sitting next to his security officer
was with his group. "She's with us," Dominic said.
After Basurto notified his security officer that they had walked into an intelligence trap,
the pair attempted a counterespionage attack, with the bodyguard recording the
interactions between "Dominic" and Basurto.
Dominic then attempted to mock the journalist for notifying his bodyguard what was
happening.
"Sit the fuck down and act like a professional journalist. just act like a professional
journalist. Calling your big friend [the bodyguard] to protect you is just damn," Dominic
said.
"You know I'm smarter than you, right?" the journalist told the man who called himself
Dominic.
The man, who appeared to speak French and had a noticeable accent, told the
journalist "Yeah, and then you [will] end up in a ship in the middle of the fucking ocean
in a black-site."
Dominic admitted that he was "at work."
"You keep making videos of me. You want to make a video of me drinking at work?" the
man asked the journalist.
"You know her, don't you?" the journalist asked.
"No," the man called Dominic replied.
"Don't film me," the FBI Agent, Kristin Parkhouse said. "Don't film me."
Both FBI Agent Parkhouse and the "State Department" employee, Contreras, gave their
official work contact information to Basurto's bodyguard, a British Texan who his client
calls "Big Tex."
Page 19 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR Pll
UNCLASSIFIED/NOU0 — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Depanment
After the investigative reporter, Basurto, requested for the return of his backpack,
which included all of his electronics and notes, Contreras, the U.S. State Department
employee, turned on a dime and became belligerent towards both him and his security
officer.
OUSIN OF PRESIDENTIAL CANOIDATI, ORION.  . AN At1V 01
LULA WHO ENDORSED HIM.
O TOLD ADDY
HE WILL
"MAKE A
LOT OF
MONEY"
WHEN LULA
TAKES
POWER.
He then verbally abused Basurto and physically attacked him multiple times, after
which the reporter's bodyguard put Contreras on the ground before the guard was held
back by the owner of the bar, Renato Tebet.
Basurto held the attacker on the ground but did not strike him. After several seconds
Contreras relented and said he would return the backpack.
After he did, he told Basurto, "If I ever see you again, I'm going to r"ing kill you."
Earlier in the evening, Renato Tebet, the owner of both the "jungle Bar" and "Dobe,"
the first locale where at the reporter interviewed a local conservative campaign
manager and a lawyer, told Basurto that he stood to "make a lot of money" if Lula took
power on January 1st, 2023.
It was after this comment was made that Parkhouse, the alleged FBI supervisor, told the
investigator that he would "make a good CIA agent."
Stay tuned to National File for more updates on the political unrest in Brazil.
Page 20 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR Pll
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
Tags: addy addsBrazilBrazil ElectionKristin ParkhouseMiguel ContrerasRenato TebetSimene tebetU.S.
State Department
Note: Above is where we are all tagged.
Twitter: Addy Adds (@OneAddyAdds) - https://twitter.com/OneAddvAdds
Tuesday, November 29
Addy Adds @OneAddyAdds Nov 29
BECOMING BRAZIL! I The Prather Brief Ep. 15
rumble.com
BECOMING BRAZIL! I The Prather Brief Ep. 15
FBI & CIA Sabotaging Brazil Elections! Chinese Rebel Against XII
Maricopa Protest Steal! Cochise County Refuses to Certify! Want To ...
01 ta I O 4
Page 21 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEWFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PII
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
0  Addy Adds CiOneAddyAdds - Nov 29
Addy's Newsletter: Election Special; Arizona and Brazil
addyadds.substack.com
Election Special: Arizona and Brazil
with Pasta Jardula.
ELECtIRN SPECIAL
ARIZONA S BRAZIL
0 t1 a O 12
t1 Addy Adds Retweeted
National File @Nationaliiie • Nov 29
The U.S. Govt is working actively IN SUPPORT of Lula's Commie Coup in
aBrdz.l.
, • • • • •
terminar en un barco
en medic de la puta
oceanci'en un sitio negro".
"Yeah, and then you
end up in a ship
in the middle of the fucking
ocean in a blacksite."
nationalfile.com
WATCH: American Journalist Attacked By US State Department Empl...
On Friday November 18th. Addison Basun°, an American journalist for
The National File, along his bodyguard, were attacked by Miguel _.
O t1 17 Q 14
Page 22 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEEV/FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PII
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
Addy Adds @OneAddyAdds Nov 29
Addy's Newsletter -- WATCH: American Journalist Attacked By US State
Department Employee In Brazil. Forced To Flee The Country
terminar en un barco
en medio de la puta
oceancfen un sitio negro".
"Yeah, and then you
end up in a ship
in the middle of the fucking
ocean in a blacksite."
addyadds.SubStaCk.c0m
WATCH: American Journalist Attacked By US State Department Empl...
A investigative reporter for The National File was set up in an apparent
intelligence operation and he and his bodyguard were forced to leave ...
O t1 6 C2 7
ill Addy Adds :"e:OneAddyAdds • Nov 29
I just published a new post on my g)buymeacof fee!
WATCH: American Journalist Attacked By US State Department Envloyee
In Braid. Faced To Pee The Country
terminar en un barco
en medio de la puta
oceaneen un sitio negro".
"Yeah, and then you
end up in a ship
in the middle of the fucking
ocean in a blacksite."
buyrneaooffee.com
WATCH: American Journalist Attacked By US State Department Ernol_
A Investigative reporter for The National File was set up In an apparent
intelligence operation and he and his bodyguard were forced to leay...
o 0 02
Page 23 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEWFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PII
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department

• Addy Adds @OneAddyAdds • Nov 29
State Department Official Assaults National File Reporter In Brazil
rumble.com
State Department Official Assaults National File Reporter in Brazil
https://twiffer.com/OneAdffyAdds/status/1596950498610847750?
s‘20&tzivwFMSEzYcpT9tKOHMCOog
0 2 LI 7 O 8
40 Addy Adds POrreAddyAdds Nov 29
Miguel Contreras sated his uniiecon account.
• Addy Adds CTOncAddyAdds • Nov 27
us State Denaelteent ennateee. Miguel Contreras. attacked my
bodyguard and I in Brava, (Oast
I was toed by an asset. 'The Beard: that I would end up in a 'ship in the
middle of the f ocean in a Macksite."
Wittin Parkno45e. 'FBI:Bent' was present.
0 5 n
Page 24 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PII
O
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
40 Addy Adds @OneAddyAdds . Nov 29
I just published a new post on my @buymeacolfeel
BECOMING BRAZIL! The Prather Brief Ep 15 (subscribe to him please)
BECOMING BRAZIL! The
Prather Brief Ep 15 (subscribe
to him...
buymeacottee.com
BECOMING BRAZIL! The Prather Brief Ep 15 (subscribe to him please).-
https://www.youtube.comAvatchW=61n/_-Ked5U
O t1 O
40 Addy Adds @OneAddyAdds • Nov 29
BECOMING BRAZIL! The Prather Brief Ep 15 (subscribe to him please)
youtube.com
BECOMING BRAZIL! The Prather Brief Ep 15 (subs...
https://rumble.com/v1xpmt0-becoming-brazil-the-
prather-brief-ep.-15.html
L1 :3
YouTube Videos posted by Basurto
Tuesday, 29 November
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMqYnSQS63E
"Iraq and Afghanistan" (last 20 seconds) - YouTube
4
Page 25 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR Pll
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
- OS*
tan' (lad 10 w(onclt:
co
Email Communication from Thorburn to Parkhouse and U.S. State Department
Employee #1
From: Luke Thorburn clukethorburn@protonmaiLcorn>
Sent: Wednesday, November 30, 2022 12:56 AM
To: Parkhouse, Kristen A <ParkhouseKA@stote.gov>; kaparkhouse@fbi.gov
Cc: Contreras, Miguel <ContrerasM@stote.gov>
Subject: OFFICIAL COMPLAINT — MIGUEL CONTRERAS' ASSAULT ON USA JOURNALIST IN
BRASILIA
Ms. Kristen Porkhouse,
Please advise next steps for Addison and Ito lodge an official Complaint - including the
names of your supervisors and/or other State Dept. whistleblower channels available to us — for
the repeated and sustained assaults on Addison and I by Miguel Contreras that occurred on
Saturday morning of November 20, 2022, much of which was captured on our personal camera
phones, as well as on Renato Tebet's Jungle Bar' CCTV cameras.
https://nationalfile.com/watch-american-joumalist-attacked-by-us-state-
department-employee-in-brazil-forced-to-flee-the-country
I note that this email is going to your official government email addresses and hope it is treated
with prompt attention.
Resisting the lodgment of our Complaint will not work in your favor, believe me.
Luke Thorburn
Sent from Proton Mail for iOS
Page 26 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR Pll
UNCLASSIFIED/IFOUO - FBI
SBU - Legal - State Department
YouTube Videos posted by Basurto
Wednesday, 30 November
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6ftV -KedSU
BECOMING BRAZIL! The Prather Brief Ep 15 (subscribe to him please) — YouTube
PRATHER
BRIEF cKar Monday. Tuesday. Thursday. Friday di 7PM EST. Prather Briet nion
BECOFI MC Bilotti' Me 'till... 11,0 fp IS ban4 ,4*...." 0. 1.0
0 CID
Wednesday, 30 November
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z_Xzlj_Mhak
State Department Official Assaults National File Reporter in Brazil - YouTube
6a ce ,o re. To
NATFILE REPORTER FORCED TO FLEE BRAZIL
ig the bogus Russian collusion allegations. Headlines at NationalFile.com...R44.
S441 PIOMMISNIOrlizial Assaults Nataaig IA* Ripon. geoid
• 'AWAY! IQ ab
Page 27 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
WhatsApp Messages from: +595-992-317181 to Kristen Parkhouse's State
Department Cellphone
Wednesday, 30 November 3:53 pm
Parky?
Wednesday, 30 November 4:00 pm
Did you get our request via your State Deportment and FBI emoils to escalate our Complaint
against you and especially Contreras for Nov 20's physical assaults on a US journalist?
Wednesday, 30 November 4:00 pm
Will be a FOIA oll that if need be later
Wednesday, 30 November 4:01 pm
WATCH: American Journalist Attacked by US State Deport...
On Friday November 18the, Addison...
Nationolfile.com
https:finationalfile.com/watch-omerican-journalist-ottacked-by-us-state-departement-
employee-in-brazil-forced-to-f lee-the-country/
Wednesday, 30 November 4:01 pm
Who is your bearded friend, "Domininc," who threatened to kill us on the tope that you are also
in?
a a
<Q -•sea ern arnin
Did you get our request va
your State Dept and FBI
snails to escalate our
Complaint apiarist you and
especially Contreras for Nov
20's phytacal assaults r a
USjournalist?
Will be FOIA all that if need
b later
https:/frotionelfie-COnsi
wetch•anterlcerrnournelnt-
attacked-try-us-state-
department-empkwee-at-
breill-lorced-to.ltee-the-
country/
Who is you bearded friend
'Dominic: who ltreatened to
kel us on the tape that you
en also in?
Thursday, 1 December 2:41 pm
Page 28 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR PH
UNCLASSIFIED/IFOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
Parky?
Yesterday
Party?
Missed Call: (062) 3931-1799 to Parkhouse's State Department Cellphone
Thursday, 1 December 9:14 am
4'.•1 m •
< Is

(062) 3931-1799
U,
1 December 2022
9.14 AM Mined Cal
Email Communication from Thorburn to Parkhouse and U.S. State Department
Employee #1
Friday, December 2
From: Luke Thorburn <Ithorburn87@qmoil.com>
Sent: Friday, December 2, 2022 8:34 AM
To: Parkhouse, Kristen A <ParkhouseKAPstate.aov> . kaparkhousePfbi.gov•  Contreras, Miguel
ContrerasMastate.00v>
Cc: Luke Thorburn <lukethorburn@protonmaitcom>
Subject: Re: US STATE DEPT. OFFICIAL COMPLAINT — MIGUEL CONTRERAS' ASSAULT ON USA
JOURNALIST IN BRASILIA
For recording/documentation purposes, re-sending the below to Porkhouse and Contreras of US
State Deportment in Brasilia to circumvent the possibility of Parkhouse and Contreras having
"blocked" my other email account (lukethorburn@protonmaitcom  in Cc on this email) to avoid
facing this serious Complaint and ongoing situation.
Regards,
Luke Thorburn
Twitter: Addy Adds (@OneAddyAdds) - https://twitter.com/OneAddvAdds
Sunday, December 4
Page 29 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEDHFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED/NOUO — FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department

• Addy Adds JCYCACICy•MIS Ore •
I PO 0.014 . 40 r new CCM On my aleninteen rieel
On Vette dor American Om:4W. moony it ikui
CIA shakes down American
investigative reporter In
Brazil
error borne .1•
barnwoocifte cam
CA mein awn Aosta, Aveittailw repo tee 4n ban —acopoa
HIPS/Pcnittli COmNlyeriaraciiiimefirairomincreneaninnealfarece•
revMer in AS /incite. ConlYin U. 4.4 nintr 40 0 "
O I s O s
trim coo,
CIA moms Omm Amerces inmerIptIre repent , c Oar
kylay bad MblY Mile alio way thrralabb0 bY VS oN044 sYk7c,
bopyrYng on Ile etre+ pioltrils In Mai Crary cure tim er
O U > O e
aillAddy Adds 60neAddyAdds - Oro 4 •••
Coffee Talk Ep22 (Addy discusses this week in news) by Dr. Paul Cottrell
youtu.beptir5livrolQ via bpd! Cottrell
youtube.com
Coffee Talk Ep22 (Addy discusses this week in ne_

Dr. Paul COttrellWeb$iIeht0:/hwiw.the-sIud;O-
reykjayik.comPatreonhttpS://WWiV.patreOn.COi'rI/P...
O Ll V 4
Page 30 of 31
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
UNCLASSIFIED//FOUO - FBI
SBU — Legal — State Department
tl Awry mot Retweettef
Op, Many tockdown w/ Clint Russel* telberlytccidted . Doc a
PS
Many or my eltttOdes MOvInerywaro MITI be too condo co be on Yairute
Just tnis week I had on Dr. Robert kleIcae. ttOreaddrAtidt on Brats
tecellon/CIA on the grand and DetesTmerlent.On an the unredacte0 CDC
betas
rumde.com
Otagnotffie a Glottal Psycg with Cr. Robert ma ice.
Pan 1 i am jdnezi br the man whO blew the lid oft coNd/lockdown
narrative. Rln dscuseon was wind biowne You can PV4 VD his book ..
O i tl e O 02
Page 31 of 31
UNCLASSIFIEWFOUO - FBI
SBU -PRIVACY OR P11
EFTA00006072 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-18)
ItOW VI oeD tatiantri
1
CE
I, the undersigned,
employed by/associated with'
position of
ORDS
, declare that I am:
-1AA1S2---O in the
and by reason of my
position am authorized and qualified to make this declaration.
In my employment with the above-named bank/company I am familiar with the
business records it maintains. The above-named bank/company maintains records of its
business which are:

1. made at or near the time of the occurrence of the matters set forth therein, by,
or from information transmitted by, a person with knowledge of those matters;
2. kept in the course of regularly conducted business activity; and
3. made by the regularly conducted activity as a regular practice.
Among the records so maintained are the attached records itemized in Appendix A,
Inventory of Documents.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Date of execution:
Place of4 t."=. 1. 18.$
Signatur
ADULT VIDEO WAREHOUS '
501 NORTHLAKE BLVD.
e
07/23/05 EmpN:jill! InvN: 679654
5:07:38 pm Store .
NOVELTY 12.99
NOVELTY 12.99
NOVELTY 19.99
NOVE . LTY 6999
NOVELTY 7.99
NOVELTY 6.99
NOVELTY 19.99
NOVELTY 5.99
NOVELTY 21.99
NOVELTY 21.99.
Sub: 280.90
Tax: 13.06
Tot: 213.96
Tendered: MasterCard/Visa 213.96
NO NOVELTY RETURNS, NO REFUNDS,
LINGERIE MUST HAVE TAGS ATTACHED.
I

• lt

╭──── Page 5, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

ADULT VIDEO WAREHOUS
501 NORTHLAKE BLUE.
MSS
07123/85 Empi: IIII Inv#: 679654
5:07:50 pm Store e!
NOVELTY 12.99
NOVELTY 12.'19
NOVELTY 19.99
NOVELTY E9.99
NOVELTY 7.99
NOVELTY 6.99
NOVELTY 19.99
NOVELTY 5.99
NOVELTY 21.99
NOVELTY 21.99
Sub: 208.98
Tax: 13.56
Tot: 213.96
Tendered: MasterCard/Visa 213.96
NO NOVELTY RETURNS, NO REFUNDS,
LINGERIE MUST HAVE TAGS ATTACHED.
ec.r. ' 4"
n(i
si!,kt :6
ADULT VIDEO WAREHOUS
Si1 NORTNLAVE BLVD.
e
SIM
07/23/05 Emph: IllE Invii: 679654
5:07:50 pi Storek 1
NOVELTY 12.99
NOVELTY 12.99
NOVELTY 19.9?
NOVELTY 69.99
NOVELTY 7.99
NOVELTY 6.99
NOVELTY 19.99
NOVELTY 5.99
NOVELTY 21.99
NOVELTY 21.99
Sib: 200.90
Tax: 13.06
Tot: 213.96
Tendered: MasterCard/Visa 213.96
NO NOVELTY RETURNS, NO REFUNDS,
LINGERIE MUST HAVE TAGS ATTACHED.
MIA:
IIU:
67'23,05
fetch A: 99
I
•
. . •
IFHOUSi.

• •L ill
:Th.. •
Sale
17:47:4!
:XP'
S3ie
•t..;
ale
• ••
ADULT VIDEO WAREHOUS
501 NORTHLAKE BLVD.
e
07/23/0S Emoh: nod: 679634
S:07:50 pm Store .
NOVELTY 12.99
NOVELTY 12.99
NOVELTY 19.99
NOVELTY 69.99
NOVELTY 7.99
NOVELTY o.99
NOVELTY 19.99
NOVELTY 5.99
NOVELTY 21.99
NOVELTY 21.99
Sub: 200.90
Tax: 13.06
Tot: 213.96
Tendered: MasterCard/Visa 213.96
NO NOVELTY RETURNS, NO REFUNDS.
LINGERIE hal HAVE TAGS ATTACHED.
,,,/,ADULT' VIDE LUB :77 N0.
al 1-L - LON
VIIIthm eATE  /4- M (9 )  CLERK 'MILS
"" LL4ARIE   6,-( -/---6,. --1. ---
ADDRESS  X 7  5-  /i2,r,t9,00kii ii, e a) Lq.
hY/STATEAIP  r (/,ofe / /7 4.14mE pHotediti l CI Are e   WORK PHONE
D.L# DEPOSIT HELD BY ffi  1M kg
CARD 1 EXP
the toolorgeol 00 Mx., mr an, sown 04 Lowe oleo nolou tapes soda ecuOrnent 104 Wee to pay a separated tor W. Monk. and 
pry ett take tare or al Said W. NO a otoOrntnt and to use loon
in NOPs manor en! no• 0. 0 M 0. oat. . 4 oared OP. er. or oluerourni ere Ott destoye0 or Wen Wore toy are Mame& 10 
O,OOOlly toy 40 1.Ofte Sow alutiatoetera no the tul Cash mato Of red
0014 repory in earn sna. trooped or :lona in airy .ay, o pay an mount *qua at Oo War a repo:Ina our same of Meter booby 
exorrenae. Went* and we nernaars ate osopcototo bon ea MO  Or
damage or toss o ary ODOM persenS. or PoCony ti  any toy worry woof bong Our tart 04
SIGNATURE
99:jlt d DIU ant"..•
Srri mo.
u
Aut h. n l",
i ••Ie
3i;tt•C k e1. rt.

╭──── Page 12, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

i.nlY

• s
ukt •k[b11 ONIV

╭──── Page 13, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007824 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-18)
II ' III 1,11111
/0Q5--
1 z

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

18E 10 0018
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
Employee Number.
Department Number.
Socal Security Number
Mental Staus:
Number Of Allowances:
Rate:
10
SINGLE
01
18E Earnings Statement
Pay Period: 5/14/2005 to 5/27/2005
Pay Date: 5262005
PALM BEACH. FL 33480
WAY
Taxes and Deductions Hours and Earnings
Nettleton This Period Year-To-Date Description , Hours ; This Pened Year-To-Date
FICA
FED HT
162.48
350.01
1461.64
3147.96
SALARY
6 T L
2115.39
8.49
19038.49
Gross Pay Year To We Gross Pay This Ftriod Total Dodustions This Period NH Pay This Period
$19,038.49 $2,11k5.39 $512.49 $1,602.90
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
14ARANOT.SiLLRLIELbtliEfl'il448.8441' 073 115/61110/rnm  !cir
DEPOSIT
Check Date: 5/26/2005rt.
74nekt
01,602.90 DEPOSIT TO BANK* 1MM CHK ACCT8
I :y To c4The
PALM BEACH, F

• ****VOID0*******VOID****
18E
33480
is
s =
nika—Si•fl
da- tiG -1r#
$1602.90 1[1
.0:1Z •rn: ttttt  waltrus, VOUCHE ONLY - NON-NEGOTIABLE ”OlVetilaretIONt1dOMOMOWMMlirnaM
18E - 10 00.18
-MN; ;"JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN

• -858 EL BRILLO WAY
„• , PALM BEACH, FL 33480
Employee Number.
Department Number: 1 0 .
Social Security Number:
Marital Status: SINGLE
Number Or Allowances: 01
Rate:
18E Earnings Statement , 187 7

• r 4 40 tEAsipAi 1 I:
Pay Period: 3/05/2006V° 0/1.04201::
••
• •
Pay Date: 3/17/2005 ••-.••• i **•-••• h•-•'
Check d: 20194162
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
•
Hours and Earnings • . Taxes and Deductions
Dosed Hours is Period V ar-To-Date Description This Period Year-To-Oeb
SALARY
G T L
2115.39
8.49
I
I(
1
1
c
..,
i
,
8461.54
.
•
FICA
FED WT
,
. ..„..„ . .... _
162.48
350.01
.
.
- •
,
,
649.26
1397.91
. .
- —
-
Gross PayYear To Date Gross Pay This Period Total Deductions This Period Not Pay Thb Period
.-0•8_,A.6,1...54-- - --- 1151.-474 -4- $1,602.90' - - - • • -$2-4.-1-5-:31
I ..  ;--•,.. • l .• 1 V./ 4 4 It I, I I
.. a I t • A ! i i V f
1 i tl
,
fl '''..-•°' • \ .: I.,...../ t1 .1.13 .1 I
...V,. VI,  1 1 I. k
% , 1...• .0. 1 t ..• 1
.•••••••• N•Pir 'VT 4.
I t ". • i1 • Nti ,
a • , ,• , ct i ../: ; , ,. , .4 t •
a  .. It t $ $ $ tr  art c ", F
•
l 1.• t. 1 XI 0 • a. * **.a i a„. ...... aa * k 1 f

• ..9 .. • "/ f. 1 . ...../ ....... .......-
lr
18E 10 0018
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH. FL 33480
Employee Number.
Department Number
Social Security Nurrter
Marital Status:
Number Of Allowances:
Rate:
10
SINGLE
01
18E Earnings Statement
Pay Period: 4/30/2005 to 5/13/2005
Pay Date: 5/12/2005
PALM BEACH. FL 33480
Egiby
Taxes and Deductions Hours and Earnings
Description This Period Year-To-Date Desaiption Hours This Period Year-To-Date
FICA
FED WT
162.47
350.01
1299.16
2797.95
SALARY
G T L
2115.39
8.49
16923.10
Gross Pay TAN Period Total Deductions TAN Period Nal Pay This Period Gross Pay Year To Dale
*2,115.39 *512.48 *1,602.91 *16,923.10
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
1
PALM BEACH, FL 33480\
**VOID*****nn*V0 ID****
18E
PPNLITTiffi, .
Check Date: 5/12/2005
CHK ACCT#
a  —
_ a =
•1 —TB
a *a s=
:maths
AIL th
Negri& Amthytth±
•s•-
,aa
$1602.91
VOUCHER ONLY -k NON-NEGOTIABLE • 1•141r.tir.e , v1:1•4 Cad dt rrrr t r r dAldOrt
men
us, r  r 10 0038
;••••, %; I •,! :JEFFREY E.:EPSTEIN • I I
V * St. 358 EL BRILLO WAY

• 't `--#: A PALM BEACH, FL 33480
Employee Number.
Departrrent Number: 10
Social Security Number.
Marital Status: SINGLE
Number a Allowances: 01
Rate:
18E Earnings Statement
Pay Period: 2/19/2005
Pay Date: 3/03/2005
Check/: 20189373
19‘,2z046P5.
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
gab
Hours and Earnings _ Taxes and Deductions
DescripOon Hours This Period - Year -To- e Desairtion This Period Year -To-Date
SALARY
C T L
•
'
. .
•
'2115.39
8.49
63f.6.15
i.
t • t 1
rt
i
i
•
FICA'
FED WT
. .
•
. 162.48
.. ...
350.01
•
486.78
1047.90
-

• .
Gross Pay Year To Date Gross Pay This Pedal Total Deductions This Nobel Net Pay This Period
S6,346..15__, ---8.24 1-1-5-5*-- 90 ' 85f2.4y S1 , 602 .
, or it If • ,I .S 1 \ S $ i $  it  s ;1 4
ye, ..--• . t% AP,  :. ....
-1 Vt.:•ft• at Y. • * 01 or -v

• • • .
, r r
* +, e I. ay v '‘, I .... 4,,. • N , 4 i
A 4*-  '14 • J 4 'I S b y
1
18E 10 0018
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
Employee Number.
Department Nuriter.
Social Security Number:
Marital Status: SINGLE
Number Ot Allowances: 01
Rate:
10
18E Earnings Statement
Pay Period: 4/16/2005 to 4/29/2005
Pay Cate: 4/29/2005
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
aft
Hours and Earnings Taxes and Deductbns
Description Hours This Period Year-To-Date Description This Period Year-To-Date
SALARY
G T L -
2115.39
8.49
•
14807.71 FICA
FED MT
•
162.48
350 . 0 1
1136.69
244 7 . 94
Gross Pay Year To Dab Grans Pay This Period Total Deductions This Period Net Pay This Period
62,115.59 I $512.49 51,602.90 *14,807.71
)F.:-afjtekZaa r$TA9fil ..
Cr.:er 0/
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH. FL 33480
10 0018
PALM BEACH. FL 3:480
****•0110********V0 IDes
18E
t tine
=—
a. — w
4. .-
Check Date: 4.'28/2005
Noe. A497
ass  4 g -
er
e. re
•
el
DEPOSIT
$1602.90
VOUCHER ONLY - NON-NEGOTIABLE ......

╭──────────────────────────────────────── Page 6, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 18E 10 0018 18E Earnings Statement                                                               │
│ JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN EASY Ni                                                                       │
│ 358 EL BRILLO WAY                                                                                │
│ PALM BEACH, FL $3480 Pay Period: 4/1872005 to azgzo05                                            │
│ Pey Date: 4/28/2005                                                                              │
│                                                                                                  │
│ Employee Number: T |                                                                             │
│ Department Number:                                                                               │
│ Social Securty Number:                                                                           │
│                                                                                                  │
│ ‘Marizal Statue: SINGLE PALM BEACH, FL 33480                                                     │
│ Number OtAllowances: 01                                                                          │
│ Rate:                                                                                            │
│ Hours and Earnings = “Taxes and Deductions                                                       │
│ Description Bure ‘This Perisd | Vear-To-Date: Deasripiion This Period rear Te Dale               │
│ SALARY | 2115.39| 14807.71|||FIcA 162.48 1136.69                                                 │
│ le TL | 8.49 FED WT | 350.01 2447.94                                                             │
│ | |                                                                                              │
│ | .                                                                                              │
│ | | q                                                                                            │
│ L | Fl                                                                                           │
│ q                                                                                                │
│ ‘Gross Pay Year To Date ‘Gross Pay This Period "Total Deductions This Period Wot Pay This Period │
│ $14,807.71 $2,115.39 | $512.49 21,602.90 |}                                                      │
│                                                                                                  │
│ 5 CHANGE INTONE GRADUAUD BAK AT IOP SO LIGHTENY                                                  │
│ EIN DEPOSIT —                                                                                    │
│ 358 EL BRILLO WAY                                                                                │
│                                                                                                  │
│ PALM BEACH, FL 33480 Check Date: 4/22/2005                                                       │
│                                                                                                  │
│ $1,602.90 DEPOSIT To BANK* i CHK                                                                 │
│                                                                                                  │
│ Pay ToT 100018 18E                                                                               │
│                                                                                                  │
│ $1602.90                                                                                         │
│                                                                                                  │
│ PALM BEACH, FL 3°'480                                                                            │
│                                                                                                  │
│ A HHVOI Dex #4 4% xVOID EE HH                                                                    │
│                                                                                                  │
│ smssnuseueuusnesaesa QUCHER ONLY - NON-NEGOTIABLE                                                │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

C OLONIAL BANK. Questions about your
Cotonial Connection:
www.colonialbank.com
PALM BEACH FL 33480
Account Summary
Page I of 2
Ogle Checking
ACCOUNT NUMBER
STATEMENT PERIOD February 23, 2005 - March 10, 2006
Great news! Colonial has
improved the overall look
and feel of your statement
to give you added flexibility
and control in managing
your finances. Colonial
Bank values your
relationship and would like
to thank you for allowing us
to serve you.
Previous Balance $ 0.00 Avorage Collected Balance $ 1.407.61
Total Credit(s) + 4,836.74 Fe/33 This Period S 13 01
Total Debit(s) - 1,559.28
Service Charge - 0.00
Ending Balance $ 3,277.46
*•I
Account Details
Deposits and Other Credits
DATE DESCRIPTION
2/24 DEPOSIT
3/9 DEPOSIT
AMOUNT
Checks Paid • inoleates chock missing in sequence
3,233.84
1,602.90
CIII CK EWE AMOUNT (HECK
93 3/3 1,546.27
DATE AMOUNT
Other Delius
DATE DESCRIPTION AMOUNT
3/2 PRINTED CHECK CHARGE
CLARKE AMERICAN CHK ORDER
13.01
Daily Balance Summary
DATE BALANCE DATE
2/23
2/24 3,233.84 3/3
BALANCE DATE BAU1NCE
0.00 3/2 3220.83  3/9 3,277.46
1.67456
COLONIAL BANK, N.A. FINANCIAL STRENGTH fAl LOCAL HANDS
MEMBER FDIC s2
a ST
COLONIAL BANK Questions about your ~own call
Colonial Connection
www.co!onialbank. corn
Ligle Checking
COUNT NUMBER
Page 2 of 2
SIATEMENT PERIOD February 23,2005 - March 14. 2005
I
IMPORTANT INFORMATION
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR STATEMNT
It you funk you, bark statement IS interred. w if you reed more Inlonnabon about a:transaction on y(.r statement, tall 
877-502-2265 or writs us at PO Box 1887.
Birmingham. Alabama 35201-1887 as sou, as pospble You may also contact us by going to Tram COlonlaMank coon and clocking
on 'Contact Us' II you use our Onine
Banking se lace you can use the e-massagmg feature Click on 'Serra :tenter Peel 'General Request' We must receive noace 
Porn rou no later ran 30 drys atter the
mailing date ol Yam firSt statement or Mich the error or problem appeared You Ilay telephore us. but (tong so enl not 
preServe your light% and we may ask to. you to put
your complaint Or Notation in wrinng In your 'env. please monde Me following Voluntarily):
1.Your name and account number
2.1M collar amount end the date of the suspected error
3 A descripinon or the error and an exclamation as to why you beim inere is an error.
You do not ham to pay any amount In questlor valve we are investigating. but yOu are still obilgated to pay tne parts of
your aCCOunt Mat are not in (Wen On White em
wattle:de. we cannot report you u delinquent or lake any action to swim dna armour' you here questioned
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR ELECTRONIC TRANSFERS (Consumer - Non -Business Accounts)
II you think you' statement is wrong. of yOU need more ritOrnatien about eleelos‘c tuna transfers (automated relies 
pansactions, direct deposits. pre-authorzed denos. Online
Banking trasacbons. deDot card transacbons cr toes smear iransaCtiOns). or do you need ZO verify a transaction. call or 
mite us using the methods shown Mow We mutt
hear horn you ro leers than 60 days ales we sent you the FIRST statement on.Mnon we problem or erns appeared. You nay 
telephone us but doing se will net On/Serve yOu'
Ischia It you lea us prey. we may rewire that you send us your complant or question in writing within 10 business days 
Pease preside the lollowing Inlormaten

• YOU, name ar d account number
• A description of the eror cc transfer you are unsure about $',t why yOu tette }I is an error. or wry you need more 
inlormanon
• Rue doilw amount and date of the suspected error
We MI make every :Non to 'ell you the results of cur i rvesil panto within 10 bushess days aNtr we hear Isom you and wit
correct any error PramPIN However. it em need
more tme. we may :eke up to /Scale odor days to oveSti gam your COmPlell et spestion II we decide to do this. we wit 
pronistonzity credit your account within 10 Witness
days for the amount you think ism eror. sO that yOu wet had Ire USe ofth money during the addtional hoe if takes us 'o 
complete our it-vesication if ow ask VDU to Pit
your Comparator pot StlOn w wribn g. and we dO not receive it Whin 10 nu stress days. we may not creed your axoont I NF 
deode Mere was no error. we will send you a
winen explanation of our Wings whin 3 business dais aim roe csnclver nos of our iwestigat on it we out provis onaly 
credited your atoms we yrs charge tne amount
tin to your accourt yen may ask for COOPS Cl me docurrents that we sseot in cur nyestriation
REAM NOTE: deNotice Gloms hwelves ae elective's And treader dal we:MIME le a foreign location. or was a po,nt-t I-sale 
*basalt tranatfiOn. the tiny
peed anew* tor ear eeesngarrcafs PO Cana:WOW. Or. IT . IMP a tianeen 'moans a fransachon that accarrarl manta AT lays 
all,, me lint napes',
ee mew arrowd. we pelt bare PO baleen rays to amid tee $ diner or perlslonally earn you accoust and PC calendar ears to 
/flatbed,.
To report a lost or stolen ATM or Check Card, 24 hegiraa day. seven days l 'seek - please tar I77 507.71€5
How to balance your Colonial Bank statement
List any checks. payments, debit card transactions, transfers . service charges, or
automated teller withdrawals from your account that are nob on this statement
farce WOW CneiCK NO arSOuST
S   $
'07a
DATE March 14, 2006
ENDING BALANCE
SHOWN ON
THIS STATEMENT 53,277.96
ADO (n)
DEPOSITS NOT
CREDITED DN
THIS STATEMEN I $
(IF ANY)
S
$
$
$
TOTAL
SUBTRACT
TOTAL
OUTSTANDING
ITEMS S
PRFSFAFT IAIANCF
COLONIAL BANK. N.A.
MEMBER FDIC
18E 10 0018 18F Earnings Statement
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480 Pay Period. 3/19/2005 to 4/01/2005
Pay Date: 3/31/2005
Employee NJrnber.
Departrrent Number
Social Security Number
Marital Sates:
Number Of Allowances:
Rate:
10
SINGLE
01
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
Hon and Ea ming* Taxes and Deductions
Descdpdon Marrs This Period Yea-To-Date Description This Pend YeanTo-Date
SALARY
G I I.
2115.39
ll .49
10576.93 FICA
FED WY
'
R2.47
350.01
.
811.73
1747.92
•
does PayYear To Date dosePayMs Petted Total Doduotlons TN! Ported Not Pay This Parted
*2,115.39 $512.48 *1,602.91 *10,576.95
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
358 EL GRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
*1,602.91 DEPOSIT TO BANK*
litt Viialifalialfab7410
Choc< Cate: 3:31 2:11;5
a lie
CHK ACCT# =aLa ilalr'  ‘ M#
Ne Ts The
Oder 01
10 0018 /PALM BEACH, FL 33480 ****VOID********VOID****
IIIIIMEMMWM If •
Amair_titk -a•- 18E a- L---sr o r 51,_ 1 r
Ai IR Mir
$1602.91
to.
a
VOUCHER ONLY - MON-NEGOTIABLE ,AonfOl;:r:: ,
:iarAfligAWMW!AMVM

╭──────────────────────────────────────── Page 9, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 18E 10 0018 18E Earnings Statement ABD,                                                          │
│ JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN EASYPAY                                                                       │
│ 358 EL BRILLO WAY                                                                                │
│ PALM BEACH, FL33480 PayPerod: 971972005  aniz0s                                                  │
│ Pay Date: 3131/2005                                                                              │
│ Employes Numter                                                                                  │
│ Social Securty Number                                                                            │
│ arts ale SINGLE PALM BEACH, FL 33480                                                             │
│ Number Ot Allowerces: 01                                                                         │
│ ate:                                                                                             │
│ Toure and Earnings ——] “Taxes and Deductions                                                     │
│ Furs This Period YeaTo-Daie—|||—~“Dseciition | Thie Period | —VearTo-Daio                        │
│ sALARy | 2115.39] 10576.93|||Fica 162.67, ——«1l.73                                               │
│ erL | 8.49 FED WT 350.01) 1747.92                                                                │
│ | |                                                                                              │
│ | |                                                                                              │
│ | |                                                                                              │
│ | |                                                                                              │
│ |                                                                                                │
│ “Gross Pay Year To Date ‘Gross Pay This Pera ‘Tolal Dedvolione This Period | Nel Pay This Period │
│ $10,576.93 $2,115.39 $512.48 $1,602.91                                                           │
│ JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN                                                                               │
│                                                                                                  │
│ t 958 EL BRILLO WAY                                                                              │
│ PALM BEACH, FL $3480                                                                             │
│                                                                                                  │
│ ‘Check Date:                                                                                     │
│                                                                                                  │
│ 9781/2005                                                                                        │
│                                                                                                  │
│ 100018                                                                                           │
│                                                                                                  │
│ 2 xEVOI DEX Xe x XVOD HH                                                                         │
│                                                                                                  │
│ PALM BEACH, FL 33480                                                                             │
│                                                                                                  │
│ VOUCHER ONLY - NON-NEGOTIABLE                                                                    │
│                                                                                                  │
│ $1602.91 |                                                                                       │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

18E 10 0018 18E Earnings Statement JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
Employee Number:
Department Number:
Social Security Number:
Marital Status:
Number Of Allowances:
Rate:

• 10
SINGLE
01
Pay Period 5/28/2005 to 6/10/2005
Pay Date: 3/09/2005
Eirmy
Hours and Earnings Taxes and Deductions
Description
SALARY
6 T L
Hours This Period Year -To-Date Description_
FICA
FED WI
•
This Period
162.48
350.01
Year -To-Date
1624.12
3497.97
f
2115.39
8.49
21153.88
Gross Pay Year To Data Gross Pay This Period Total Deductions This Period Net Pay This Period
*2,115.39 *51 .49 *1,602.90 *21,153.88
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480 Cnecx Date: 5/09/2005
01,602.90 DEPOSIT TO BANK* CHK ACCTit
ord.°.
****VOID*** ****VOI 0**** -
ft,Tor,
PALM BEACI I. L 33480
-
. ;.•
8E $1602.90
.: . rt _a r
(ra-  - a%las &mares "-a -
--;----t
a T-,=,.$ 7•11MP
Va -.
_ - r a a
fl :MOMIIIIMO view.”Li7
VOUCHER ONLY - NON-NEGOTIABLE
COLONIAL BANK. Questions about your
Colonial ConnwAion:
wintoolonialbanksoin
ALM BEACH FL 33480
Account Summary
Eagle Checking
ACCOUNT NUMBER
FeyC 10t 2
STATEMENT PERIOD April 15, 2006 - May 13, 2005
VColonial Rank Appreciates
your business. Thank you
for being our Customer.
Previous Balance S 4.47.56 Average Collected Ralance S 5,32556
Total Credit(s) 3,20S(S.81 Fees This Period S 0.00
Total Debit(s) - 4,400.00
Service Charge 6T00
Ending Balance $3,744.37
Account Details
Deposits and Other Credits
CATE DESCRIPTION
4/28 ACH DEPOSIT
JEFFREY EPSTEIN PAYROLL
5/12 ACH DEPOSIT
JEFFREY EPSTEIN PAYRO
AMOUNT
1,602.90
1,602.91
Checks Paid • indicates chock missing in squint
CHECK DATE •(NIT CHECK DATE
103 4/20 4••.00 105 • 5/12
AMOUNT
Daily Balance Summary
DATE BALANCE DATE BALANCE DATE BALANCE
4/14 4,937.56 4/28 6,140.46
4/20 4,537.56 5/12 3,743.37
4,000.00
-
COLONIAL BANK NA FINANCIAL S.
MEMBER FDIC
NGTH IN LOCAL HANDS
CCOLONIAL BANK. Questions about your account call
Colonial ConnectionlIMM
www.cofonialbanlccom STATEMENT PERIOD amass, nos - May 13, 2005
Riot t 2 012
Eagle Checking
ACCOUNT NUMBER
IMPORTANT INFORMATION
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR STATEMENT
11 you Mink you' bank statement .5 incorrect. or d you need mot on'orrrallon about a Par saceon on your statement. cal 
Sir -5C2-2265 or welts es at P.0 Boa leaf,
Birmingham. Alabama 3520'-1807 as soon as posabb. You may also oontsct us by going to wemverolonialbok corn li d ciclueg
on 'Contact Us • II you use our Online
Ranking seam. you car use the e-rnessaolne feature. Click Oa 'Service Center' Men 'Genera Reeved We trust eCerie setae 
froin you nc later Mtn 30 days aft tie
meting date of your first statement os vAlidi em error or problem appeared. Yon may telephone us, but doing so we not 
preterite your lights and we may ask for you to put
your comps it or clueStOn n wrung In your letter. pease grease the tolloMng
I Your name and account number
2.1he dollar amount and the date of the suspected errs.
3A descripoon of tto error and en exdanation as to ray you believe theft u an error
You do not here to atry any smartt in question weeo wo am imosti pang, bit you an set obligated IC Play the Darn of YOUr
aCCouri tenet are not in outsbon While we
investigate we cannot roped you as delinquent or take any acban to coiled to moult you have questioned.
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR OUEST1ONS ABOUT YOUR ELECTRONIC TRANSFERS (Consumer - Non -Business Accounts)
II you mink you statement 3 wrong, it you need more information about electronic lend transfers iattonneled teller 
oars:coons. claret deposits. pro authonzad debits Onbno
Banking transacts ans. debit card transactions or other similar transacacns3 or it you need to verify a transaction. 
Call Or Write US using the methocs SrOwin above We must
hear Iran you DO 'ter than 60 days after we sent you The FIRST statement en vandl the erotism or error appeared You may 
teeph)ne uS. tut doing so will rot preserve your
rlghtS. II you Ite us Orally. we may require that you send us your complaint or q Aston in wrong within 1D business 
days. Please provide the Month; it formes on

• Your name and exount ninnber.
• A descrlgoor of li e error Dr transfer you are unsure abOut and w'ry you believe A 3 an Mt Ot wily you need more 
information.
• The dollar amount and dale of the suspected error
We will make everyanal to tee you the results of our trweshcation within 10 business dll), Inlir we hear from you and 
will correct any error promptly However. I' we need
more lime. WI may take up 10 45 calendar days to investigate vour comdaint or Question II we decide to do this. we wit 
prsvlsbnalte Credit (our account *lain 1) business
days for ea amount you Mink is in error. SO Rat you will hive tie VW CI the money during the additional ems it LUIS us 
to Correlate our investigate. It we ask you le put
your COmPlefil Or Question ri wasteland we do not recent it within IC business darS. we nay not Credit your account II 
we decide there vas no error. we we and you a
wntten exslanitionol our towlines whin 3 business days alter the cordusion or our . inyettlpitiOr we rave 
DrOYSIOCanYererredY0tif account. wt we charge the amount
back to your amount. You may ask for copes of Te O0Cumen'S that we used in our investigeran
Pt EASE NOTE: its asks of snot Inches an electronic last trustsr that was radiate illatOteirrOOnien. • was a  !Wm 
-offal. debt cent trna•CtiOn. ma DIM
indo Stewed w ow  mrestigi elea is ea cien da, dap . Or . "ft grep.didentrorquoloilrmoryet a Transaction ttat a:cured 
withLn SC daps are, to hist deposit
tosser rettostit we will hare 20 bashriessdays Spondee sanded error orprerisiodallt matt par  sac ma and 90 calendar 
lays to neesliCtafe.
To report a lost or stolen ATV or celery Card ?e !ours a ay. seven oars a week - pease oar
How to balance your Colonial Bank statement
List any checks, payments, debit card transactions, transfers, service charges. Or
automated teller withdrawals from your account Mat are not on this statement.
Cnl. CK 'IC AMOUIIT Cr-'C'( '10 AVCIPa
DATE May 13, 2005
ENDING BALAPa
SHOWN ON
DU STATEMENT S 3,743.37
S ADD (.)
DEP3SI1SPOT
CREDI1E0 ON
THIS STATEMEMT S
$   (IF ANY)
$
$
S  TOTAL S
SUBTRACT (-)
TOTAL
OUTSTANDING
ITEMS
TOTAL
PRESENT BALANCE $
COLONIAL BANK NA
MEMBER FDIC 0170:4 ag
•
18E 10 0018 18E Earnings Statement JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480 Fay Pericd: 4/02/2005 to 4/15/2005
Fay Date 4/14/2005
Employee Hunter.
Department Number
Social Security Number.
Mortal Status:
Number Of Allawances:
Rate:
10
SINGLE
01
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
CSYPAI
Taxes and Deductions Hours and Earnings
Description Hours This Period Year-To-Date Dascliption This Period Year-To-Date
SALARY
C T 1
2115.39
8.49
12692.32 FICA
FED NT
162.48
350 . 0 1
974.21
2097.93
Grose Pay War To Dab Grass Pay Thia Period Total Deductions This Period Net Pay This Period
$12,692.32 $2,115.39 $512.49 $1,602.90
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN 358 EL BRILLO WAY
PALM BEACH, FL 33480
1****VOID#*******V0ID****
*1 602 .90 DEPOSIT TO BANK# CHK ACCT#
1 0 0018  18E WRA  4  -1-1 " rscall. I
r7,
=--
'PALM BEACH, FL 33480
o_
UIr
4.14,0E,fonsti..,Froutionimimmutv.w.i.ung.taffiammitts„anti.tAt.pt
Check Date: 4/1412005
7 PgRctsrr
$1602.90
_11
VOUCHER ONLY - NON-NEGO1FIABLE
COLONIAL BANK. Questions about your
Colonial Connection:
www.colonlalbankcorn
Pegs Sot3 r1
angle Checking
ACCOUNTNUMBER
S EATEMENT PERIOD March IS, 2005 — April 14,2005
How to balance your Colonial Bank statement
st any checks. payments. debit card transacbons, transfers• sery ce charges, or
automated :eller withdrawals from your account that are not on this staternert.
ma NO AMOUNT CFECK NO AMOUNT
IOWA
$
•
$
DATE April 14, 2005
ENOIN6BALiV4CE
SHOWN CA
THIS STATEMENT $ 037.56
ADO DI
DEPORTS NOT
• CREDITED CM
THIS STATTAIENT
(SNP) $
$
$
$
$
TOTAL $
SUBTRA:T )
TOTAL
OUISIANDING
ITEMS S
PRESENT BALANCE S
COLONIAL BANK NA
MEMBER FDIC
C OLONIAL BANK. Cagle Checking
auditions about your
Colonial Connection:
www.colonialbankcom STATEMENT PERIOD Mardi IS, 2005 - Awn 14,2005
Pegg I of 3
ACCOUNT NUMBER
0  Colonial Bank appreciates
your business. Thank you
/or being our Customer.
PALM BEACH FL 33480
Account Summary
Previous Balance 63277.46 Average Collected Balance 5.337.66
Total Credit(s) + 6,542.99 Fees This Period $ 0.00
Total Debt(s) — 4,882.89
Service Charge — 0.00
Ending Balance 64,937.56
Account Details
DepositsandOlherCredits
DATE DESCRIPTION MOON I
3/15 ACH DEPOSIT
ADP TX/FINCL SVC PAYROLL
0.00
3/18 DEPOSIT 1,734.28
3/21 DEPOSIT 1,602.90
3/31 ACH DEPOSIT
JEFFREY EPSTEIN PAYROLL
f 1,602.91
4/14 ACH DEPOSIT
JEFFREY EPSTEIN PAYROLL
1,602.90
Checks Paid • incicates dux./ missing h nquenoe
CHEEK DATE AMOUNT CHECK DATE
94 4/6 600.00 102 4/7
101A 3/17 282.89
Daily Balance Summary
DATE / BALANCE DATE BALANCE DATE BALANCE
3/14 3,277.46 3/17 2,994.57 3/21 6,331.75
3/15 3,277.48 3/18 4,728.85 3/31 7,934.66
AMOUNT
4.000.00
tl
COLONALENW(NA. FINANCMLSTREMOTWAILOCALHANDS
MEMBER FDIC Jt
CCOLONIAL BANK. Questions about your
Colonial Connection:
isnvw.colonfalbank.com
Eagle Checking
ACCOUNT NUMBER
Pogo 2 of 3
STATEMENT PERIOD March 15, 2005 — April 14, 2005
Daily Balance Summary (continued)
DATE FM MICE DATE BALANCE DATE BALANCE
4,6 7.334 66 4i7 3,334.66 4/14 4,937.56
IMPORTANT INFORMATION
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR OUE ST1ONS ABOUT YOUR STATEMENT
II you link your balk 'amen! is incorrect. or it you need mow treormation abeut a Iran ismer on your ttatemeM. call 
877-502-2265 or v. Me is e P.0 Box 1857.
fhtturqhen. Alabama 35201-1867 es soon as possible You nay 4,30 conteel LS by goi dlo ownycolccualbanle con and clicking
cn *Contact U1 II you use our Online
Banking Se vice. you Can use the e-rressaging feature Click on •SerVeCt Center Men tiehers Request We mutt receive robot
Iron you no later Man 30 days alter nn
mailing date Cl your first statement on with li e error or roblem aoceared You may letsphece us. but thing so will rat 
preserve your tights and we may este for you to pit
your comPaint Or psestion in wrtdlg in your lener, pease provide tine !glowing InfOrmatlitin
your name and account nsmber • 2.7he dollar amount and the date of Vie suspected error.
3A description of tie eror and an exPlanatior as to My you believe there/is an error.
You de net have to Day any amount in Ouestion while we am imesbeattro, bet you are ktit °Plated to pay the parts of your
account that are nor n question. 'While we
IMIStilate vin :enrol moor YOU SS deli nouert or lake any aCtbn to col eel Ine amount you hive cuesnoned
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR ELECTRONIC TBANSFERS (Consumer — Non —Business Accounts)
II you wink your statement n wrong, it you need more inlOrnallOrl abOtit eltetrOnC fund transfers (automated teller true
sections. direct deposits. pre-autrornd debits, °nine
Balking transactions. debit card transactions or Oder s4n1lar transactions). Dr it you ivied to vent/ a tiansectlay caul
or wn re us using rive methods showr atcye We must
hear Iron you no leer than 60 days after vie sent you tie FIRST statement on wtich t g Orohem Or error appeared You may 
taephone us. tut doing so wilt rot preserve your
rigaits you tell us orally. we may require that you send us your complaint or q taboo in writing witrin 10 business 
days. Please provide the folowng inlormaDow

• Your nom. Old OrCOUnl number
• A deStrirdlOri 01 Mt rot Or tranSler you are Unsure about aid why YOU believe it is an error or very yoc need more 
lotormation

• The loiter err ount and eat of the suspettel error.
we me make very effort Iota you tne results ol our inyestigauon won 0 tiusineri?drfs Wet we Mar !rpm you ana will 
Gerrie( any error Of erPnY- However. II we mel
mere tme. we may lake up b d5 candy days to investtoate your corntAaint or genieco dere decide to so this. we wil 
promsonar,/ credit your :count within 10 business
days for the amount you think is In wet so that you wit have he use of thornOnel luring the additional tine t tales us 
to complete our iMieSt1WitiCe. lives ask yen tD pit
your complaint or question in venting ant vin do rot mom it won 10 ousness dAys. we may not credit your account. If re 
decide tire vas no eror, to re sand you a
wntten owsanation of our Ireton; within 3 business drys arbor the conclusion of Du invesnothor II we Pave 
provisionallycmcited you• account. we vnll charge be amount
back to your account you may ask lOr copies of rob documents that we used in our investigation
PLEASE NOTE: !fa notice of 'nor Inches an electionlc hind truster that was Initiated In a tcreIgn TocarIcn, or was a 
FOIIII-Ot-said deal, end tansactlin, ne haw
period allorreli for our invothydtart is 90 edge:dor dirs. Or, iI tee seepeded error or quitted,' hiccups a Inantecnon 
teal oCCurrert feline 30 Oats aro, De on? wort
to a new nowt. we will here 20 besieges days to cement the stspecred error or morisionalle credit pone attend and 90 
calendar days to rerestigste.
IC report a lost or stcen Mit or Check Card. 24 revs a dry. sever ricks a seek - prase cal 871-532-2:65
COLONIAL BANK N.A.
MEMBER FDIC
Odd
Pla
•
1st col 18E Earnings Statennentc: t t." -it*-Fiky t. EPSTEIN
If * • . • •
MB EL BRILLO WAY S
‘*".. 'PALM .8 EACH , FL 33480 a'
Pay Period: 2/05/2005 ctikusttlidt/D5 •
.4•4 4
Pay Date: 2/17/2005 ""----"
Chad( ft 20183456
Employee NurnbeG
Department Number. 10
Social Security Number.
MaritalStatus: SINGLE
Number Of Arowancos: 01
Rate:

• • Grass Pay Year To DMs Gross PaLThls  Period
EASYPAY '—
-•
Tax and Deductions
ear- *-
FICA .324.30 324.30
FED WT 697.89 697.89
.
. %
. %
- •
-14 . /6

• s• -4 4. s
f ..X• N
Total Deductions This Period
84 ,-23 . . . • al ,.022_at_
Period Pay
03,298;5d
Net  This
• -. v•altS
F " Ns. '0 if' SYS Si X s •P I` X X . S
a x. r Y a t • ..0"" =s p
• 4-• J• • •••••• • ♦* r. s vier -
ex
^ - •

╭────────────────────────────────── Page 17, Image 1 ──────────────────────────────────╮
│ ae                                                                                   │
│                                                                                      │
│ 18E. » ~~1.0.0018 18E { Earnings Statement BBP                                       │
│ ? ‘ JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN \ on SY Vg                                                    │
│ » *358 EL BRILLO WAY \ H eee L                                                       │
│ ye PALM BEACH, FL 33480 Pay Period: 2/05/2008 ‘to...2/18%2008. 1)                    │
│ ~ ~ ~ / Pay Date: 2/17/2005 ~—                                                       │
│ { Checke: 20188486                                                                   │
│ Employee Number: |                                                                   │
│ Department Nurber: 10                                                                │
│ Socal Secuty ner TT                                                                  │
│ Masta Sttue: SINGLE                                                                  │
│ Number Of Aowances: 02                                                               │
│ to: {                                                                                │
│ Hours and Earnings "Taxes and Deductions                                             │
│ escripiion [Hours This Period ‘YeaTo-Daie —|||"~Deseription [This Period VearTe-Daio │
│ [SALARY ] 4230.76, | 4230.76|||FICA 324.30 324.30                                    │
│ iG TL ~ 8.49 { . FED WT . 697.89) 697.89                                             │
│ - i                                                                                  │
│ ~_GrossPay This Period | _ Total Deduotions This Porlod [| Not Pay This Period       │
│ $47230.76-|-— $1,022.19 _ $3,208.57                                                  │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

C OLONIAL BANK. Questions about yes
Colonial Connoctio
www.colonialbank.com
PALM BEACH FL 33480
Account Summary
t
Eagle Checking
ACCOUNT NUMBER
Rage f o12
STATEMENT 'PERIOD June 15, 2005 -July 15, 2005
Ank. ver Colonial Bank appreciates
your business. Thank you
for being our Customer
Previous Balance S 5.779 17 Average Collected Balance $ 5,869.56
Total Credit(s) 3205.81 Fees This Period $ 0.00
Total Debit(s) - 2253.95
Service Charge - 0.00
Ending Balance $ 6,731.03
Account Details
Deposits and Other Credits
DATE DESCRIPTION
6/23 ACH DEPOSIT
JEFFREY EPSTEIN PAYROLL
7/7 ACH DEPOSIT
JEFFREY EPSTEIN PAYROLL
AAAOUN I
1,602.91
1,602.90
Checks Paid • ildeafes chink rilMakey in sequence
CHECK DATE MIOLDIT CHECK DATE AMOUNT
110 7/1 300.00 113 6/23 503.95
111 6/24 100.00 114 6/23 500.00
•1:? 6/24 850.00 •
Daily Balance Summary
DATE BALANCE DATE BALANCE DATE BAUM
6/14 5,779.17 6/24 5428.13 7/7 6,731.03
6/23 6,378.13 7/1 5128.13
o
COLONIAL BANK. N.A. FINANCIAL STRENGTH IN LOCH HANDS
MEMBER FDIC 92
(COLONIAL BANK.
Outshone about
Colonial Connection
vnnew.colonialbank.com
( Eagle Checking
Pa. 2 of 1 11
ACCOUNT NUMBER
STATEMENT PERIOD June 15, 2005 - July 15,2005
IMPORTANT INFORMATION
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR STATEMENT
II you Turk your balk aliment Is IrCorrect. or If you need more WOmacro about a transaction on your statement. Cal 
877-502-2265 or write us at P.0 Box 1887.
Berningharn. /Marna 35201-1837 a soon a possible. You may alsoconWI us by gong to www oxicnetbank corn end clicking oo 
twat Us' If you use our Onliri
°inkling Inc). you can use enee-rassaging filature Click on leaks Center then 'General Request' We must roans rotor from
you no later than 30 days afoot the
netting dale of your first statement on which lie error or prObiern appeared. You may telephone us. out doing so wit hat
premise your rights entire may ask for you 'o put
your complaint or Weston n writing. In your letter. please amide Uw folloeing Inlormaton
1.Your nano end wont number.
2.Tne lolly amount and the date of the rapated error.
3A description of the error and an exploration as to We you brews there is an error.
You do not hate to pay any amount ii  puettitn white we aro IMosnwang, but you are sill aloha to pay the pans or your 
account that are not n question While we
wasters. we cannot moon you as delinquell or lake any idiot to oohed he *moont you nave questioned.
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR ELECTRONIC TRANSFERS (Consumer - Non -Business Accounts)
If you think your statements wrong. Il you need more intercom on about eleCtrOT IC IMO resisters catcomated tiler 
transactions. direct OepoOts. pre-autnoriced dons Online
aware transactors. debit card Karam -tons or other senior transactions). Of d you need to yen!), a transtcliay. call Or 
writ ususirg ins methods shown above. We must
hear horn you no later man 60 days after we lent you the FIRST statement on which the problem or error appeared You may 
telephone n. tut doing so all not pesenre your
rights If you tell us bray, we may require that you semi us your compant or gaston to wrung arm 10 business days. Please
proves me forowiog rtornmacn.
• Your Arne end tocoont number.
• A desorption oldie error or Inflater nu are unsure about and WV Wu Whew it is an error. or wily you need more 
information.
erne dollar amour and date of the suspected error.
We WA mate every elicit to tell you me results of OLT inyestealSon within 10 trusInaiS days &Wan hear from you end wet 
correct wry error promptly However. linseed
MOM tin,.. we may take up to 45 calends: days to Wester, your complain' or question If we decide to do Pis. we wit 
proyisenely credit your account within 10 business
days for ore amour' you think Is In error. so eat yoi yell have the use of the maw du nog the 'Maims tme .1 tales us to 
COmPlete our Myesteator If we ask you to put
your complain:0f fueSIOn in wIllne. and we do lit teen It walls 16 bulkiest days. we mey not credit your account Pia *CM
there was manor. we ta send you a
mitten explanation°, our flydInes within 2 Disarms: dayt liter the conclusion or our Invetepabon if we Cave Drawsi way 
credited your account se sin dune the amount
back to your meant You hay ask for copes of thr documents that we used In Our investigation
Pt EASE NOTE: ll a no:Ics al snot WrOtrIS an Macsionic fawn , mat wAS Indlated la a Weir *AVM. Or was a pOlit4-0I-Salf 
aid cam fransactleek die OM
'mod allortol for our IfteeltipitiO• is 10 colonial Coy:. Of, if lee s imported errs, or quottion involver a Inntatton 
fraroccurrod wilt,. ID days air IS first tapata
te a ne w account. WI tall hare 20 kusisess days ri corncribs seen:fed error or prOriSIOSAllf Credit Mar account RIM! PO
calendar days to trtroshgatt
To moon a lost or stolen ATM or Check Card 24 heirs a cay. seven days a weal. - pease cal 877-502-2265
How to balance your Colvnial Bank statement
" List any checks. payments, debt card Vat sections, transfers, service charges, or
automated teller withdrawals from your account that are not on this statement.
DATE July 15. 2005
dydNO /MOM MCA NO AMOUNT
S   S
s
$   3
S     S
IOTA'
ENDING BALANCE
SHOWN ON
THIS STATEMENT S 6,731.03
ADO (s)
DEPOSITS N31
CREDITED ON
THIS STATEMENT $
(1 MY) $
$
S
TOTAL S
Su9TMCT (-)
TOTAL
OUTSTANDING
OEMS S
PRESENT BALANCE $
COLONIAL BANK N.A.
MEMBER FDIC 32
C OLONIAL BANK. Eagle Checking
Questions about your eccount, cd t
Colonial Connection ACCOUNT NUMBER
Pogo I of 2
www.colonialbank.com STATEMENT PERIOD July 16, 2005 - August 12, 2006
Coloniai Bank appreciates
your business Thank you
for being our Customer
111111.11.
Account Summary
Previous Balance $ 6,731.03 A4rage Collected Balance 8,485.C9
Total Credit(s) + 5,57322 Feq,s This Period $ 0.00
Total Debit(s) — 3,909.14
Service Charge — 0.00
Ending Balance $ 8,395.11
Account Details
Deposits and Other Credits
DATE DESCRIPTION
7/19 DEPOSIT
7/21 ACH DEPOSIT
JEFFREY EPSTEIN PAYROLL
7/25 DEPOSIT
8/4 ACH 'EPOSIT
- JEFF EY EPSTEIN PAYROLL
( AMOUNT
1,256.00
1.685.65
977.00
1,654.57
Checks Paid a incknos chock missing in soquonco
CHECK TE AMOUNT
115 7/21 100.14
116 8/1 1256.00
117 8/1 2.158.00
Daily Balance Summary
DAT [ BALANCE
7/15 6,731.03
7/19 7,987.03
7/21 9,572.54
COLONIAL BANK. N.A.
MEMBER FDIC
CHECK DATE AMOUNT
118 8/1 375.00
119 8/11 20.00
DATE BALANCE DATE BALANCE
7/25 10,549.54 8111 8,395.11
8/1 6,760.54
8/4 8,415.11
FINANCI . STRENGTH IN LOCAL HANDS
32
C OLONIAL BANK Eagle Chsking
Questions about your accou
Colonial Connection.
wwwcolanialbarilscom STATEMEN' PERIOD July 16, 2005 — August 12, 2005
Page 2 of 2
ACCOUNT NE ABER
IMPORTANT INFORMATION
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR STATEMEN
If you elk your bard statement is incorrect or if you riled more info/moon show a War ;Wr§aa On you' statement. Call 
877-S02-726S or write us at P.O. Box 1887.
Bimerigham. Alabama 35701-1887 as soc• as Possible you may alSO anted us by go al) 10 /AVM colenSaltenk corn ridding on 
'Contact Us A you use our Ontne
Barking semen, you can use me e- roeSSagill0 'elk re ark on Se nice center ten •p.anerai Request' We must receive notioe
born you ro fuer Iran 30 days after the
manna date ol your arsl statement on whim the error or problem appeared You may Piet:hone us. but doing so MI not 
preserve your fights and we may ace lm you to put
your competent cr question in wrung In your letter, please provide ire lollowtng tarot ThatiO1
1 Your came and account number
2 The dollar amount and tie dile of the suspected toot
3 A description d the error anion exptanaion as to why yeti bee. oe here is al error
You do lot mate to pay any smart in question whih we are .rwestiging, but you an nil obligated to pry Ite parts al your 
ac curt mat are not In goeston While we
investigate. we Oland moon you as delinquent or take sly a IM SO COMO mn ormounl you have questioned
IN CASE OF ERRORS OR QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR ElgCTRONIC TRANSFERS (Consular — Non—Eausinere Accounts)
If you Oink your statement Is wrens. it you need mat Information about elecr'Onld fund tmders (automated telhr 
transactions. cared &POWs. pre-Bunion:ea Debts. Orline
Banking transactOnS. debt Card tnnszcgars or other similar transaCIOnE. of it you need Overfly a Venison:el, all or 
write us usng hie methods mown above. We must
hear from you nc later than 60 days alter we seat you the FIRST statement gel ithkh the problem or error appeared You 
nay *krona us. but doing so will lot preserve your
rights. d you tel us orally, we may require Melva Send us Your COMPland or ineSSOOO In writing within 10 tusineSS days 
Please toNde The Meowed Rfornabdo.

• Your name and account number
• A desdriphon of the error or tram ler you are unsure mod mild * by you believe it is an error. or why you need more 
information.
• The dollar amount and dale of Me suspected error
We Yell make every efloit to tell you the resits of our inyestryageryembry to p :Press lays alle• we hea: Iron you and 
MI correct any error PralIPTN However. T we need
more lime. we may tee uo tO 45 Men& days 10 IfflosTqaM your CCMIAant Widen II we decide to do Tts. we wilt swooned./ 
omen your accourt when 10 business
days for der arriosnt you mink is in error, so that you will have the use of the money during Caw addreonal tune It 
takes us to complete our inyest•atIon h we ask you ie pea
your comptant or question In wane and we do not receive rt within • 0 Duane ss drys we may not :red yoyr account P we 
decde there was 10 error. we MA send you a
written eXplanallOn of OurMONS MOM 3 gualleSs days after the sysksuyinn of our toms t gallon 3 we have provisionally 
cryditot your account vrt sit charge the mount
back to your account You me( est for copes d the documents fiat we used ,,n our investigation
PLEASE NOTE: Ifs sifts of tiros hwohlas as disdroair hod frailty tan ias liasted In a fordtre locators Of was avulse-al 
-saki debit aid transaction. li e Wine
pined Mooed tweet Inntebgenei b JO parry days 04; dm. yowayly d error et ameba Imams a trapsardon dial otterrad gratin X
days star rte first *posit
to a no novae:. we eelli bars it hastiest On es ganef ate mann) our rot or jeforlifonaly crw0ll year amine and 90 
calendar days ro la ree flyers.
To mood a lost or stolen ATM or Geed' Cart 74 hours a day seven drys a week - please 507-' 265
How to balance your Colonial Bank strement
List any chocks, payments, debit card tnansoctions, transfers. sonic* charges, or
automated teller withdrawals from your account that are not on this statement.
CHECK NO ASsOrltlr CIAO( NO I AlIourd
DATE August 12, 2005
ENDING BALANCE
SHOWN ON
s THIS STATEMENT S 8,306.11
ADO (Q
CtoOSHSNOI
CREATE ON
THIS STATEMENT
S   Eta ANY)
TOLE
COLONIAL BANK N.A.
MEMBER FDIC
$
$
orAL 3
SUBTRACT (-)
TOTAL
OUTSTAND NG
ITEMS $
PRESENT BALANCE S
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Jeffrey E. Epstein

╭─ Page 23, Image 1 ─╮
│ Om                 │
│                    │
│ -.                 │
│ * nae              │
│ a                  │
│                    │
│ Jeffrey E. Epstein │
╰────────────────────╯

THS IS
YOUR
RECEIPT
Thank
You!
CO_LONIAL
BANK wassccdcrataisaccfn ~eft OC
LATE TRANSACTIONS Transact ons accepted on Satuiday
ater 2 pm cars, may he pcstnii
the following business day.
The transaction indicated below is accepted in accordance with the terms and
conditions specified on the signature card or in the account rules and regulations.
Bank Synital. Transaction Number, Dato and Amount Are Shown Below.
F-0060 (Rev. 405) C8G Panting
DDA CHECK DEPOSIT
.
09:58 25Jul.05 Aft
mds3201
r'ifitIN AVENUE 2022 $977.00
THIS IS
YOUR
RECEIPT
Thånk You!
CCOLONIAL
BANK:NA nneciorselnantoms Una MIC
LATE TRANSACTIONS Transactions accepted on Saturday
or alter 2 p.m. daily may be posted
the following business day.
The transaction indicated below is accepted in aCCOrdance with the terms and
xi -Idioms specified on the sigrature card or in tne account nits and regtlaticos.
Bank Syrrool, Transaction Number. Date and Amount Are Shone Below
F-0060 (Rev. i CEG Pnnting
12C DDA CHECK DEPOSIT
12:43 19Jul.05 AM
2 2 116 ads3201
2C22 $1,258.00
THIS IS
YOUR
RECEIPT
Thank
You!
CCOLONIAL
BANK: N.A.
war Coknalfink men Mambo FM
LATE TRANSACTIONS Transactions accepted on Saturday
or after 2 p.m. daily may be posted
the following business day.
The transaction indicated below is accepted in accordance with the terms and
condtions specified on the signature card or in tho account rules ard regulations.
Bank Symbol, Tnuisactitai Nunier, Dale: aid Amount Are Shown Below.
DDA CHECK DEPOSIT
11:55 23Aug.05 AN
2 4 mels3201
WORTH AVNE 21,27 $5,670.T1
F-006ø (net 405) COG Prmosg
OO
O.O  sr-in:Mitre
4 th y  • ....„ _ • sr ......_ _ ...
Items br wean Arrtigisistinnttociale mint ars sualgelit =Mina me. the Federal
Resew Baal Incite damn; Kaska arta Mbar cern casioarot the US ate not 0Masafed ;
earl, *wham* & tolabaity of to row sans a • collectIOn
Mal or by . 40eaed Is at Mk %YIN Ma Ord
Credited 0 U.iDcilite. Al return lle$90.14fili 04,44. :6 401eewnit It you. lbOOOLn at t o /0409 1
exchanos nte in *ea set data el room ac4 not he ;Re sume .4n ineelly mated Cara Sank manse the right
to dame your anoeue at a a ass be (1) arse returned to user Mr Sol reason and (2) any tree assasaeO by
COONS Bak. the Faint Nara Bank and/Or the aging agar/ tw he  cdecaon or ream o' sad Ilene
sasoastosn Benton GOutien Payments made prime:, 2 ern at a Carlon* Bank tAn Pea Par the lebtretrta
bona day psernents fade Ow pec rat Pen In Ica bailees daft
hem to. lath yd.' Worm mredige Crs61 see subjeCt lot Me payment with evelataty in arWrd.ns ah 4e Forbear
nears Bones ends the paying saint camp schedule. tans dam on teas Overdo of the U.S. are not cataared
case ma and ars acCata kv deban Only at the bad* al It* tasersaor Colon0 stem dear then Marrs et a ca ecton
[err or by prig Ordered cad Ity ee rtern Manta expressed Strap currencies are =mad at thew byte rale and
coaled n Dolan Al ahem wens aseeleed in tags (aurae( on  be antged tO your account al the Ionia ,
twangs rate re eat cel Re dale d Mum and ro t ale nits uSedeten May crecated. COONS Bank manes the nays
to ear's par easter a a la dab for II)  Mere re tuned toss be ant 60 reason and (2) arm tees Ataead by
Carat Aare. the Fear* Rosen.* Dart sneer ea paying agent the natiehoe or awn of said Man
AnCeseter Sermon Coons, Daman undo pna In >pm al a Coone ace once ens pat the naortg
business day Payment made Afar 2 Pre as pee in two tuseresee dark
here tor watt you Mahe IMadate Credit era subject lot teal payment will PotaNdYnactOniMe  with the Fenn;
Reserve Bens tale the peeing was sawn weals. Mrs dawn on bana (meta ot yr U.S. use not contiodered
cash tea and are acCeMed tor depot Oray at to kabMy of es emniew NMwI nary tsar mete en es a canon
oat or by erring defect Cent IOC The reT sandal eareseed in bier amerces are mean.< at new buwg rate an1
credited In U.S. Dams. N alum items expressed Si Weir currefoes sin be aortal to your tic:OcunT Si the torsion
=dance rate in *Gat on the date of Mum arid not sr nee Med One inlay mita Cann, Rank onann In via
to sharpy yea amore at elae( date ter Warts reload to us to  any *pal reason and (2) any tees assessed by
Crobnia Bert. ii10 Fenra Reserve BM bu n Me Payag eget to ew Cd0(AM Or rear Of said Can.
Asaoraoon Nervosa Coupon Payments made pram to 2 pm. st e Colonel Bank arks eel post as tearing
business day. Bernina Inn OW 2 Pm wit pat n two bosons Bart
Whatever Your
Trees Need, We've
Got The Solution!
True, we're arborists, we grew up loving trees, learned how to
care for them, and we practice our craft everyday. That's only a
few of the reasons to call Zimmerman Tree Service to prune
your trees. Here are a few more:
We're in...We're out...We're fast...We're clean.
We can spot problems and take care of them before they
become major. And...We're PRICED RIGHT. For your next
pruning...or any tree, shrub or landscape need, call:
Zimmerman Tree Service
difit4660 71st Court South
Lake Worth, FL 33463
20 years service to South Florida
West Palm Beach: Boca Raton: Southern Martin County:
561-968-1045 561-338-3533 772-546-0811
www.zimmermantreeservice.com
etar1/2,.."-v>
We're In,
we're out,
.;.; we're quick,
<5;i , we're clean A:, A. I ' vo n
t sft e4
1
Zimmerman Tree Service
web: www.zimmermantreeservice.com
Palm Beach
County
561-968-1045
Southern Martin
County
772-546-0811
Boca Raton/
Delray
561-338-3533
Zimmerman Tree Service
4660 71st Court South
Lake Worth, FL 33463
AUTOCR * • CO10
PRESORTED STANDARD
U.S. POSTAGE
PAD
DUNNE-RITE MARKETING
SYSTEMS N.
WEST PALM BEACH Fl
33405
3062 3
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
OR CURRENT FAMILY RESIDING AT:
358 EL BAILED WAY
PALM BEACH FL 33480-4730
i • Mil
Yahoo! Mail -I @yahoo.com
Signed Rich As Hell and Free!
Deter%) Reply
- Forward - I Spam I Move...
previous I Next i Back to Messages
Check Mail I Compose J Search Mail
Page 3 of 3
Search the Web
Copyright C fosa.20tis yahoo Inc Aft rights IPSOnted. Ten t.c. of Servico - CopyrightriP Prissy - Guidelines - Ad 
roodback
NOTICE: We c011eci personal Information on this site
To learn more about now we use your mew-Matron see ow  privacy pet t y
10/6/2005
( IN COLONIAL
BANK N.A.

• wrerecionatereccet tenter FDIC
THIS IS The transaction indicated below is accepted in accordance with the terms and
YOUR conditions specified on the signature card or in the account ales and regulations.
RECEIPT  Bank Symbol, Tranwtion Number. Dale and Amount Are Shown Below.
Thank
You!
LATE TRANSACTIONS Transactions accepted on Satteday
Or atter 2 p.m. daily may be posted
the following business day.
F-0003 (Rev. 405) COG Preeng
OfeIC "09;15 %POSIT 203u'i .05 All
mds,1201
2 2 .26 2022 S5,670.00
EFTA00811948 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Valar Ventures requesting money previously promised by Epstein to invest in a new opportunity
(inferred date: 2026-01-18)
Valuation Report
1/31/2019
SUMMARY OF ASSETS - JANUARY 31, 2019
12/31/18 1/31/19 $
Asset Value Value Change
Cash 75,798,977 64,386,774 (11,412,203)
Fixed Income 47,239,211 48,504,739 1,265,528
Equities 109,277,812 115,692,726 6,414,914
Hedge Funds 103,213,747 105,853,201 2,639,454
Investments 52,625,224 56,643,626 4,018,402
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats 18,350,000 18,350,000 -
Loans Receivable 17,459,472 17,359,472 (100,000)
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 9,900,000 9,900,000 -
Loan Payable - BJAV (20,500,000) (20,500,000)
Total Assets 413,364,443 416,190,539 2,826,096
Cash Activity - Items over 50,000
STC IB - Sold 8000 AVGO @ 265.75 2,125,667
Dividends, Interest Income & Other Distributions 136,500
Enhanced DB Sold 2,400 BMY @ 47.50 114,000
David Mitchell Loan Repayment 100,000
Connie Goldberger (50,000)
LSJE - 2 Light Towers & 2 Electric cars (55,411)
SFL Loans: Larry Visoski 57k (boeing proceeds 29 & loan interest 28) (57,000)
Bell Helicopter - Battery, Starter Generator & Pitch Links (62,821)
Dave Rodgers Additional Payout of Time from 2018 vs 50,000 salary (92,000)
LSJE -JLG 600A Boom Lift (97,676)
LSJE -John Deere 6130 Tractor and Loader (112,585)
Insurance Premiums (homeowners and car) Zorro, Neptune & NES (117,998)
LSJE -Genie 1256 Lull / Telehandler (167,491)
Legal Fees-Scott Link (300,000)
Miscellaneous (356,986)
STC funding of Prytanne LLC (art partnership) (500,000)
Seaford Avenue Capital - PB Investment - Auto Debt (1,018,402)
Monthly Spending (1,400,000)
Valar III Capital Call (2,500,000)
Edwards Settlement (7,000,000)
Total Cash Activity - Items over 0 NCI (11,412,203)
1 6-
Deutsche First Banco Pop Wells Morgan ImamIvo TO
Asset Description Bank Bank GNP Paribas Fargo Merrill Stanley &nos Aintitriclo Totals
Cash
Southern Trust Company Inc. 3,994,064 537,857 299,452 3,079,596 8.384.084 16,295.053
The 2017 Catearer Trust 13.653.978 13.653.978
Haze Trust 12,869,961 12,869.961
Southern Financial LLC 3,333.108 100.838 2.262.901 5,696,847
JEE 3,679,006 222,701 7,027 3,908,734
Gratitude America, Ltd. 2.233,088 131.406 1615,043 3,879,536
.03001146 Inc. 3.275,394 7009 3,282,403
LSJE LLC 399.049 326.721 101.102 826.872
FT Real Estate 800.970 800,970
Plan O LLC 563.476 563.476
NES LLC 425,793 425.793
Zorro Management LLC 369.340 369,340
Neptune LLC 363,748 363,748
Southern Country International LT 381,849 361,849
Butterfly Trust 357.420 357.420
Hyperion Air LLC 249,348 249,348
Enhanced Education 1.423 112.016 113,439
JEGE LLC 83,144 83,144
Thomas World Air LLC 64,144 64,144
Nautlus Inc. 53.837 53,837
Great St Jim LLC 46,502 46,502
Madras Transportation Co LLC 23.907 23,907
Freedom Air Petroleum 22,512 22,512
Maple Inc. 21.625 21,625
Laurel Inc. 20,155 20,155
Cypress Inc. 18.825 18.825
JEE • Parts (US Si 7,574 7,574
LSJ LLC 5,150 5,150
FSF LLC 337 337
The JEE life Ins Trust #3 206 206
IGO Company LLC 90 90
Total Cash 45,851,545 2,777,612 314,053 101,102 3,079,596 1,515,043 8,484,922 2,262,901 64,386,774
Purchase Quantity 12/31/18 1131119 Unrealized
Asset Description Symbo Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
FIXED INCOME
Haze Trust - Fixed income (DB)
Citibank Preferred Ser K 6.875% 2/3/14 79,000 1,999.419 2.071,380 2,054,000 54,581
JP Morgan Chase 7.9% Pfd 4/30/2049 05/10/11 2,160.000 2,395,200 2 52 584 2 173 319 -221,881
Total Haze Trust - Fixed Income (DB) 4,394,619 4,223,964 4,227,319 -167,299
Gratitude America - Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley)
GM Financial 6.5% fixed to 9/30/18 Floats thereafter 9/24/18 250,000 250,000 215,628 226.983 -23,017
Frontier Communications 7.125% Matures 3/15/2019 10/02/17 1,000,000 997.322 993 479 1 011 917 14 595
Total Gratitude America -Fixed Income (Morgan Stanley) 1,247,322 1,209,107 1,238,900 -8,422
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed income (DB)
Buckeye Partners Fixed to Boat 6.375% Callable 1/22/23 1/25/18 1,000,000 1,018,741 840,626 871,594 -147,147
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (DB) 1,018,741 840,626 871,594 -147,147
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill)
Bank of America 5.88% Pfd 12-31-2049 03/08/18 1,000,000 1,000,000 927.299 972,600 -27 400
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Merrill) 1,000,000 927,299 972,600 -27,400
Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (Interactive Brokers)
Capital One 5.55% Faced to 9.1.2020 then 380 over 3 no libor 5/14115 3,000,000 3,009,819 3,007,500 3,020,160 10,342
Charles Schwab 6.0% Preferred 525 par 7/27/15 40,000 1,000,000 1,015,600 1,048,800 48,800
Etrade Financial 5.875% fixed to 9-15-2026 then floats 10/11/16 3.000,000 3,123,122 2,785,200 3,000,000 -123,122
Goldman Sachs 5.375% Fixed to 5-10-2020 then 392.2 over 3 no libor 6/4/15 5,000,000 5,034,346 4,867,250 5,006,250 
-28,096
NGL Energy Partners 9%525 par 6/6/17 40,000 1,000.000 846,000 920.800 -79 200
Total Southern Trust Co. - Fixed Income (interactive Brokers) 13,167,287 12,521,550 12,996,010 .1 71,277
Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB)
Assurant Fixed to Float 7% March 2048 3/29/18 2,000,000 2,039,653 1,936,556 1,948,222 -91,431
Citigroup Inc - Series 0 5.95% 8/6/15 3,000,000 3,000,006 2,962,433 3,108,558 108,552
Citizens Communications 7.125% Mar 15 2019 10/3/17 1,000,000 1,000,095 993,479 1,011,917 11,822
COFP 4.407 8/2019 Euro Bond 9/12/18 2,500,000 2,921,428 2,967,039 2,990,360 68,932
Deutsche Bank AG 4.875% exp 12/1/2032 6/1/18 1,000,000 868,256 781,603 851,125 -17,131
Deutsche Bank AG 4.296% exp 5/24/2028 6/1/18 1,000,000 917,776 850,215 895,935 -21,841
Exetsinter LLC 10% July 15 2023 10/24/17 2,000,000 1,940,506 2,002,222 2,008,889 68,383
Exelainter LLC 10% July 15 2023 7/9/18 1,000,000 1,026,197 1,001,111 1,004,445 -21,753
General Electric Co GTD Fixed to Float 4.0% Dec 15 2065 12/3/15 2,469,000 2,175,016 1,582,080 1,689,070 485,946
SMAC Cap TR I GTD Pfd Sec Ser 2 8 2/22/12 80,000 1,882,774 2,028,000 2,088,800 206,026
JIGS Investments 7.25% Apd 3 2024 10/31/17 2,000,000 1,981,300 2,051,062 2,115,265 133,965
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6/15/11 1,100,000 1,179,898 1,096,223 1,106,783 -73,115
JP Morgan Chase & Co Pfd 7.9% April 30 2049 6(15/11 2,500,000 2,669,524 2,491,417 2,515,416 -154,108
Joyds Banking Group Capital 7.5% 12129/49 5/21/13 1,903,000 1,948,500 1,837,600 1,949,782 1,282
Southern Cal Edison 6.25% Dec 31 2049 1/30/12 3,000,000 2.997.261 2.935.625 2.913.750 -83.511
Total Southern Financial LLC - Fixed Income (DB) 28,548,190 27,516,666 28,198,316 -349,873
TOTAL FIXED INCOME 49.376,158 47,239,211 48,504,739 -871,419
EQUITIES
Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB)
kmazon AMZN 4/2/18 1.000 1,395,441 1,501,970 1,718,730 323.289
ibaba Group BABA 6/10/15 5.000 444,749 685,350 842,450 397,701.
Vole Inc AAPL 12/7/17 314,000 53,321,627 49.530.360 52,262,160 -1,059,467
VP* Inc AAPL 6/20/18 50,000 9,339,691 7,887,000 8,322,000 -1,017,691
apple Inc AAPL 10/15/18 40,000 8,760,702 6,309,600 6,657,600 -2,103,102
%polo Global Management APO 3/31/11 263.157 4,999,983 6,457,873 7,705,237 2,705,254
3logen Idec Inc BIIB 2/14/12 2,095 250,455 630,427 699,269 448,814
;entene Corp _ CNC 9/8/14 15,550 986,497 1,792,915 2,030,364 1,043,867
Caryopharm Therapeutics Inc KPTI 7/12/18 25.000 467.106 234.250 211.750 -255.356
rota: Southern Financial LLC - Equities (DB) 79,966,251 75,029,745 80,449,560 483,309
Purchase Quantity 12/31/18 1/31/19 Unrealized
Asset Description Symbol Date Cost Value Value Gain (Loss)
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill)
KBW Regional Bank ETF KRE 11/16/17 9,000 503,167 421,110 476,640 -26527
Carvana CVNA 9/4/18 125,000 8.255,075 4,088.750 4,643,750 -3,611,325
Exxon Mobil XOM 10/15/18 10,000 813,881 681,900 732,800 -81,081
Facebook FB 7/26/18 20,000 3,559,596 2,621,800 3.333,800 , -225,796
0IH Od Services ETF 0111 5/16/18 17,000 490,376 238,510 286,790 -203,586
Euro Stu 50 edex due 3/27019 ssanirg Sus 39390kveside evestad 71570 9/25/17 ref price 3555 2,500,000 2,394,675 2.473,375
-26,625
Japan Banks Capped rote Exp Feb 1 2019175% barrier) 1/25/18 3,000,000 2,280,000 2,200,000 -800,000
Vortex Linked Note (sting S&P put spreads and buying MX calls) exp 4/9/201 3/8/18 3,000,000 2,745,637 2.962,279 -37,721
SVE market Plus Note Exp 4/26/2019 (72% barrier) 10/24/17 3 000.000 1.968 900 2121.03Q -878.979
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Merrill) 25,122,095 17,441,282 19,230,464 -5,891,631
Southern Trust Co. - Equities (Interactive Brokers)
Broadcom AVGO 4/17/18 4,000 1,002,093 1,017,120 - -
Broadcom AVGO 5/17/18 4,000 1,000,000 1,017,120 - -
Goklman Sachs GS 1/25/18 1,850 499,873 309,043 366,319 -133.554
General Dynamics GD 2(7/18 2,300 501,381 361,583 393,691 -107,690
General Dynamics GD 3/27/08 3,450 773,056 542,375 590,537 -182,520
General Dynamics GD 5/7/08 2.500 491,250 393,025 427,925 -63.325
Lockheed Marlin LMT 2/7/18 1,400 489,300 366,576 405,566 -83,734
Lockheed Martin LMT 3/20/18 2,100 707,676 549,864 608,349 -99,327
Lockheed Martin LMT 5/7/18 1,500 472,500 392,760 434,535 -37,965
Northtrop Grumman NOC 2/7/18 1,470 493,920 360,003 405,059 -88,862
Northtrop Grumman NOC 3/28/18 2,195 760,159 537,556 604,832 -155,327
Nerthfrop Grumman NOC 5/7/18 1,500 475,800 367,350 413,325 -62,475
OM Oil Services ETF OIH 5/17/08 17,000 504,839 238,510 286,790 -218,049
Raytheon RTN 2/7/18 2,400 498,840 368,040 395,424 -103,416
Raytheon RTN 3/20/18 3,600 763,284 552,060 593,136 -170.148
Raytheon RTN 5/7/18 2,400 491,880 368,040 395,424 -96,456
KBW Regional Bank ETF KRE 3/26/18 20,000 1.210.847 935.800 1.059.200 -151,647
Total Southern Trust Co. - Equities (interactive Brokers 11,136,698 8,676,825 7,380,111 4,754,494
Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley)
General Electric GE 10/23/17 22,000 491,068 166,540 223,520 -267,548
Microsoft MSFT 9/6/18 10,000 1,113,704 1,015,700 1,044,300 -69,404
Century Link CTL 9/6/18 10,000 212,233 151,500 153,200 -59,033
World Acceptance Group WRLD 8/9/18 10,000 1,111,107 1 022 600 1 036 900 -74 207
total Gratitude America, LTD - Equities (Morgan Stanley) 2,928,112 2,356,340 2,457,920 -470,192
Haze Trust - Equities (DB)
Carvana CVNA 6/21/18 25,000 1,086,102 817,750 928,750 -157,352
GOogle GOOG 2/2/18 2,000 2,222,173 2,071,220 2,232,740 10,567
Google GOOD 12/5/17 1,000 1,014,015 1,035,610 1,116,370 102,355
United Technologies UTX 6/21/18 15,000 1.882.944 1.597.200 1.771,093 -111.894
Haze Trust- Total Equities (DES) 6,205,234 5,521,780 6,048,910 -156,324
J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB)
3ristol Myers Squibb 8MY 10/30/15 1,000 227,604 176,732 49,370 -178,234
Disney DIS 10/30/15 685 78.100 75.110 76.391 -1.709
Total J Epstein VI Foundation - Equities (DB) 305,704 251,842 125,761 -179,943
TOTAL EQUITIES 125,664,094 109,277,814 115,692,726 -7,969,275
12/31/18 1/31/19 MTD YTD
Asset Description Value Value Return Return Notes
Hedge Funds- Southern Financla (SFLLC) Omit 50mrs • > Onm
Boothbay Multi-Strategy Fund 46,082,499 46,718A37 1.38% 1.38% withdrew, aim warn
Boothbay Enhanced Fund 7 678 772 7 840 794 2.11% 2.11% Enh Fob f2018statt
Total Hedge Funds-SFLLC 53,761,271 54,559,232 2016 Mum 3.77%
2017 Mum 15.5%
Hedge Funds - Haze 2013 mum 44 WIRRIL 7017 velum of milli% 2616117 rolanotinfts psi
King Street - Illiquid Special Investment 2,194.432 2,1cI9 A89--.,...-- 2/13/2018 54.303 4/15 2WW03 4/27116 %%7.954 paid
Hedge Funds -Haze 2,194,432 2,192,862 3/14/3016 ILorr 6115 113,564 7127716 9%2.924 paid
4/31216 37.263 W13 2.738 10/27/16 6.116.961 paid
2guanducLaLcanlis icrunoie 675.469 41161201937%2W 'W121%370 1/27117 398044 paid
1/11/2019 1.570 11/1612018 22.933 6/7/2013 67.976 11/9 %OW 2316 Mum 4.68%
12/13/2016 00.116 7/161201$ 435
Hedge Funds - STC InIttal Inv Xmm 431/111
Honeycomb 47.258_044 49.101.108 3.90% 3.90% added 15nm 6121118
Total Hedge Funds - STC 47,258,044 49,101,108 Mad lAwn9/2111/13
201601 0 4I% (0 mod)
Total Hedge Funds 103,213,747 105,853,201 277 /Mum 21.0%
SFL
Mort Southern Grat FT
Asset Description Inc. JEE Trust IGO LLC Real Estate
Investments SFL
Kyara II (investment amount) marked to $0 in Sep 2018 0
Kyara IV (investment amount) 250,000
Neoteny 3 (investment amount less 30k distribution 4/20/18) 970,000
Plytanee LLC (art partnership) 1,500,000
Jawbone Investment (prat) 1,000,000
AYH Marina (value per jee) 3,000,000 sic
Seaford Avenue Capital - PB Investment - Auto Debt (total comm 2.6mm) 2,318,126
Adfin Solutions (investment amoun ) 875,000 butterfly trust
Park Partners LLC - 320 East 82nd Street (investment amount) 3,480,000
Paid Contract to Purchase 2 Kean Court Livingston, NJ i 3,000,000
Coinbase via Grat (50% sold for $15mm Feb 2018) sic 1,500,500
Reporty via Ergo Ltd (investment amount) 1,000,000
Valar Global Fund II (amount funded vs 15mm convniument) 14,250,000
W30/2018FMV21,165,482 FFMV as of 12-31-2018 40,750,000 cunwlat• IRR thru 940.2013 313%
Valar Global Fund III (amount funded vs 25mm comrnittment) 23,500,000
, r. 930/2018 F mV 33,165,591 FMV as of 12-31 2018 49,690.000 CV millathes IRR lbw S-30-2014 542%
Totals 1,000,000 3,000,000 44,663,126 1,500,500 6,480,000
Total Investments 56,643,626
I
Hyperion JEGE Plan D
Asset Description Air LLC LLC LLC Various Totals
Aviation, Automobiles & Boats
2001 Bell 430 N331JE 1,000.000 1,000,000
1988 Gulfstream G-IV N212JE 2.900,000 2.900,000
2008 G550 14,000,000 14,000,000
Automobiles 250,000 250,000
Boats 200,000 200,000
Total Aviation, Automobile & Boats 1,000,000 2,900,000 14,000,000 450,000 18,350,000
Asset Description JEE SFL JEGE Inc. FIRE Totals
Loans Receivable
Nina Keita rensztow on re joo sae 15CK) 150,000 150,000
Mark Lloyd 100,000 100,000
Nick Ribis 150,000 150,000
Johnny O'Sullivan 22,446 22,446
David Mitchell 243,700 660,000 903,700
Osboume Lane Capital (Paul B) 1,000,000 1,000.000
20,000 303,262 323,262
Harlequin Dane, LLC 7,750,000 7,750,000
Coatue Enterprises LLC 3,000,000 3,000,000
Bella Klein 115,000 115,000
Lesley 410,000 410.000
David Rodgers 60,000 60,000
Mervin 10,000
ome 133,000 133,000
Darren Indyke 475,000 475.000
Richard Kahn 475,000 475,000
LV Home & Other 1,457,000 175,000 1,632,000
650,064 650,064
Total Loans Receivable 2,793,210 11,520,000 950,000 2,096,262 17,359,472
Enhanced
Asset Description Education JEE JEE Various Totals
Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry
Cello 175,000 175,000
Pagano Diamonds 500,000 500,000
2.73 Carrot Emerald Cut Diarmad - insurance value 5,400,000 5,400,000
Watches, Earring & Other 775,000 775,000
Fine Arts Schedule 3,050,000 3,050,000
Total Fine Arts, Antiques & Jewelry 175,000 5,900,000 775,000 3,050,000 9,900,000
Loan Payable to BJAV LLC (PLAN D LLC) (20,500,000) (20,500,000)
EFTA00812016 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-18)
Generated by PitchBook for Richard Kahn, HBRK
Associates
Stash Invest I Private Company Profile
Last Updated: 08-Oct-2018
General Information pbiD: 119115-19
Description
Provider of an investment application designed to simplify investing. The company's application provide access to
financial education, technology, advice, guidance that helps users to help pick an investment strategy that reflects 
their
interests, beliefs and goals, enabling users to get access to financial opportunity that help them achieve their life 
goals.
Most Recent Financing Status (as of 05.Oct-2018)
The company raised $37.50 million of Series D venture funding in a deal led by Union Square Ventures on February 12,
2018, putting the company's pre -money valuation at $312.5 million. Breyer Capital, Goodwater Capital, Valar Ventures,
Entrée Capital and Coatue Management also participated in the round. The funds will be used to continue to accelerate
product innovation. Previously, the company raised $42 million of Series C venture funding in a deal led by Coatue
Management on July 10, 2017, putting the company's pre -money valuation at $223 million. Breyer Capital, Goodwater
Capital and Valar Ventures also participated in the round.
Entity Type Private Company Year Founded 2015
Website Universe Venture Capital
Also Known As Stash Primary Application Software
Legal Name Stash Investments LLC Industry
Business Status Generating Revenue Other Financial Software, Other Financial
Industries Services
Ownership Status Privately Held (backing) Verticals FinTech, Mobile, SaaS
Financing Status Venture Capital -Backed Employees 100
Contact Information
Primary Contact
Brandon Krieg
Co-Founder. Chief Executive Officer and Board Member
Phone: +1 (800) 205-5164
Primary Office
19 West 22nd Street
12th Floor
New York, NY 10010
United States
Phone: +1 (800) 205-5164
Top 5 Similar Companies
S Name Competitor Financing Status HQ Growth Size Last Last Financing
Location Rate Multiple Financing
Date/Type
Amount
1 SigFig 1 Venture Capital- San 0.10% 35.68x 2018/Series E $50.75M
Backed Francisco,
CA
2 FutureAdvisor 1 Accelerator/Incubator San -0.75% 44.79x 2015 $152.00M
Backed Francisco,
CA
I of 25 2/26/19, 5:38 PM
3 Motif Venture Capital- Rancho 5.36% 40.36x 2015/Series E 540.00M
(Financial
Software)
Backed Cordova,
CA
4 Personal Venture Capital- Redwood 0.45% 183.41x 2019/Series F 550.00M
Capital Backed City, CA
S PayActiv 1 Private Equity- San Jose. -0.16% 4.67x 2018/PE 520.00M
Backed CA Growth
Comparisons
Description
Primary Industry
HQ Location
Employees
Total Raised
Post Valuation
Last Financing
Details
Os Stash Invest
Provider of an
investment application
designed to simplify
investing.
Application Software
New York, NY
100 I 2018
5116.75M
SigFig
Developer of a wealth
management platform
designed to offer
investment advisory
services.
Financial Software
San Francisco. CA
50 12015
5117.80M
le FutureAdvisor
Provider of an
automated wealth
management and
financial advisory
platform intended to
make wealth
management experience
accessible to everyone.
"-"" Motif (Financial
Software)
Provider of an
investment trading
platform designed to
empower customers to
meet their investment
goals.
Financial Software Financial Software
San Francisco, CA
85 I 2015
521.80M
Rancho Cordova, CA
164 12015
5126.00M
5350.00M 112 -Feb-2018 $470.75M 13 -Jun-2018 5152.00M 102 -Sep-2015 5436.43M 120 -Jan-2015
537.50M 12018/Later
Stage VC (Series D)
550.75M 2018/Later
Stage VC (Series E)
5152.00M 12015/Merger 540.0014 12015/Later
/Acquisition Stage VC (Series El
Current Executives (12)
Name Title Board Office Phone Email
Seats
Brandon Krieg Co-Founder, Chief 1 New York, NY +1 (800)
Executive Officer
and Board Member
205.5164
Ed Robinson President, Co. 1 New York, NY +1 (800)
Founder and Board 205.5164
Member
Peter Kalmakis Chief Technology New York, NY +1 (800)
Officer 205.5164
Dale Sperling Chief Marketing New York, NY +1 (800)
Officer 205.5164
Adrien Pesa Deputy CCO New York, NY +1 (800)
205.5164
Dougal Weir Research Analyst New York, NY +1 (917)
733.4010
2 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
Shiv Kaushal Software Engineer New York, NY +1 (917)
733.4010
Ryan Burke Vice President, New York, NY +1 (800)
Brokerage & 205.5164
Compliance
Cliff Hazelton Vice President, New York, NY +1 (800)
Engineering 205.5164
Garrett Wright Vice President, New York, NY +1 (800)
Finance 205.5164
Natalie Vice President of New York, NY +1 (800)
Ledbetter People 205.5164
Gifford Carter JD Chief Revenue New York, NY +1 (800)
Officer 205.5164
Current Board Members (4)
Name Title Representing Role Since Phone Email
Andrew Co-Founding Velar Ventures Board Feb
McCormack Partner & Member 2016
General Partner
Brandon Krieg Co-Founder, Stash Invest Co- Jun +1 (800)
Chief Executive
Officer and
Founder,
Chief
2015 205.5164
Board Member Executive
Officer
and
Board
Member
Chi-Hua Chien Co-Founder & Goodwater Capital Board Feb
Managing Member 2016 Partner
Ed Robinson President, Co. Stash Invest President, Jul 2015 +1 (800)
Founder and Co- 205.5164
Board Member Founder
and
Board
Member
Deal History (5)
# Deal Type Date Amount Raised to Pre -Val Post -Val Status Stage
Date

5. Later Stage VC 12- S37.50M $116.75M S312.50M $350.00M Completed Generating
(Series D) Feb-2018 Revenue

4. Later Stage VC 10-Jul-2017 S42.00M 479.25M S223.00M $265.0014 Completed Generating
(Series C) Revenue

3. Early Stage VC 14- S25.00M 437.25M S75.00M $100.0014 Completed Generating
(Series B) Dec-2016 Revenue
30125 2/26/19. 5:38 PM
2. Early Stage VC 17- $9.25M 412.24M 523.89M $33.14M Completed Startup
(Series A) Aug-2016
1. Seed Round 08- $3.00M 43.00M 412.75M 415.75M Completed Startup
Feb-2016
t Indicates an Add-On
E Estimated
CAP TABLE HISTORY (as of 12-Feb-2018)
Stock # Of Shares Par Dividend Original Liquidation Liquidation Conversion %
Authorized Value Rate S Issue Pref. Price Owned
Price Multiple
Series 2,542,475 $0.000010 $0.89 $14.75 $14.75 lx $14.75 10.71%
Series 3,392,568 $0.000010 $0.74 $12.38 $12.38 lx $12.38 14.30%
C
Series 4,018,574 $0.000010 $0.37 $6.19 $6.19 lx $6.19 16.93%
B
Series 3,310,188 $0.000010 $0.17 $2.79 $2.79 lx $2.79 13.95%
A
Seed 1,628,291 $0.000010 $0.11 $1.84 $1.84 lx $1.84 6.86%
Seed 1,147,725 $0.000010 $0.07 $1.15 $1.15 lx $1.15 4.84%
Series Terms for: A, B, C, D, Seed 1, Seed 2 (as of 12-Feb-2018)
Liquidation Preferences Pad Passu Cumulative/Non-cumulative Non-Cumulative
Participating vs. Non-
participating
Non-participating Anti -dilution Provisions Weighted
Average
Dividend Rights Yes Redemption Rights No
Board Voting Rights Yes
General Voting Rights Yes
Deal #5: Later Stage VC (Series D), $37.5M, Completed; 12-Feb-2018
VC Round 5 Round Financing Venture Capital - Total $37.50M
Deal Types Later Stage VC, Series Status Backed Invested
D Financing Venture Capital Capital
Deal $37.50M Source Pre -money $312.50M
Amount Raised to Date $116.75M Valuation
Deal Status Completed Total Invested $37.50M Post $350.00M
Deal Date 12-Feb-2018 Equity Valuation
% Acquired 10.71% Investor
Ownership
67.59% CEO/Lead
Mgt
Brandon Krieg
Stock Split 1 : 1 Site New York, NY
Business Generating
Status Revenue
Deal Synopsis
The company raised $37.50 million of Series D venture funding in a deal led by Union Square Ventures on February 12,
2018, putting the company's pre -money valuation at $312.5 million. Breyer Capital, Goodwater Capital, Valar Ventures,
Entrée Capital and Coatue Management also participated in the round. The funds will be used to continue to accelerate
product innovation.
4 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
t Not necessarily a summation of individual debt figures
" Does not include grant funding
E Estimated
Stock Info + Cap Table History
Type of Stock
Series of Stock
Shares Sought
Price Per Share
Preferred
D
2,542,475
$14.75
# of Shares Acquired
Conversion Ratio 1
2,542,475
E Shares Sought and Price Per Share calculated using the Weighted Average Method
SERIES D TERMS
Participating vs. Non-
participating
Dividend Rights
CAP TABLE HISTORY
Non-participating
Yes
Cumulative/Non-cumulative
Anti -dilution Provisions
Redemption Rights
Board Voting Rights
General Voting Rights
Non-Cumulative
Weighted
Average
No
Yes
Yes
Stock # Of Shares
Authorized
Par
Value
Dividend
Rate S
Original
Issue
Price
Liquidation Liquidation
Pref.
Multiple
Conversion
Price Owned
Series 2,542,475 $0.000010 $0.89 $14.75 514.75 lx $14.75 10.71%
D
Series 3,392,568 $0.000010 $0.74 $12.38 512.38 lx $12.38 14.30%
C
Series 4,018,574 $0.000010 $0.37 56.19 $6.19 lx $6.19 16.93%
B
Series 3,310,188 $0.000010 $0.17 52.79 $2.79 lx $2.79 13.95%
A
Seed 1,628,291 $0.000010 $0.11 51.84 $1.84 lx $1.84 6.86%
Seed 1,147,725 $0.000010 $0.07 $1.15 $1.15 lx $1.15 4.84%
Investors (6)
Investor Name Status Lead/Sole Comments

1. Breyer Capital Follow -On No Lead Partner: James Breyer
Investor Form of Payment: Cash
Fund 1: IDG China Capital Fund
II

2. Coatue Management Follow -On No Lead Partner: Philippe Laffont
Investor Form of Payment: Cash
Fund 1: Coatue CT XIII
5 of 25 2/26119.5:38 PM

3. Entree Capital
4. Goodwater Capital
5. Union Square Ventures
6. Valar Ventures
E Estimated
Advisors (6)
Follow -On
Investor
Follow -On
Investor
New Investor
Follow -On
Investor
No Form of Payment: Cash
No Lead Partner: Chi-Hua Chien
Form of Payment: Cash
Fund 1: Goodwater Capital II
Yes Lead Partner: Rebecca Kaden
Form of Payment: Cash
Fund 1: USV 2016
No Lead Partner: Andrew McCormack
Form of Payment: Cash
Fund 1: Valar Global Fund II
# Advisor Name Service Type Hired By Comments

1. Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe Legal Advisor Coatue Management
2. Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe Legal Advisor Goodwater Capital

3. McCarter & English Legal Advisor Stash Invest Lead Partner: David
4. WilmerHale Legal Advisor Stash Invest
Sorin JD
5. Gunderson Dettmer Legal Advisor Union Square
6. Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe Legal Advisor
Ventures
Valar Ventures
Deal #4: Later Stage VC (Series C), $42M, Completed; 10-Jul-2017
VC Round
Deal Types
Deal Amount
Deal Status
Deal Date
Announced
Date
% Acquired
4 Round
Later Stage VC,
Series C
$42.00M
Completed
10•Jul-2017
28-Jun-2017
15.85%
Financing
Status
Financing
Source
Raised to Date
Total Invested
Equity
Investor
Ownership
Stock Split
Venture Capital -
Backed
Venture Capital
879.25M —
$.42.00M
63.90%
1 : 1
Total
Invested
Capital
Pre -money
Valuation
Post
Valuation
CEO/Lead
Mgt
Site
Business
Status
542.OOM
5223.OOM
5265.OOM
Brandon Krieg
New York, NY
Generating
Revenue
6 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
Deal Synopsis
The company raised $42 million of Series C venture funding in a deal led by Coatue Management on July 10, 2017, putting
the company's pre -money valuation at 5223 million. Breyer Capital, Goodwater Capital and Valar Ventures also
participated in the round. The fund will be used to accelerate the company's investments in technology and data 
analytics,
to better serve its growing community of investors with more personalization, educational tools, and new products.
t Not necessarily a summation of individual debt figures
" Does not include grant funding
E Estimated
Stock Info + Cap Table History
Type of Stock
Series of Stock
Shares Sought
Price Per Share
Preferred # of Shares Acquired 3,392,568
C Conversion Ratio 1
3,392,568
$12.38
S Shares Sought and Price Per Share calculated using the Weighted Average Method
SERIES C TERMS
Liquidation Preferences Pari Passu Cumulative/Non-cumulative Non-Cumulative
Participating vs. Non-
participating
Non-participating Anti -dilution Provisions Weighted
Average
Dividend Rights Yes Redemption Rights No
Board Voting Rights Yes
General Voting Rights Yes
CAP TABLE HISTORY
Stock # Of Shares
Authorized
Par
Value
Dividend
Rate S
Original
Issue
Price
Liquidation Liquidation
Pref.
Multiple
Conversion
Price Owned
Series 3,392,568 $0.000010 $0.74 $12.38 512.38 lx $12.38 15.85%
C
Series 4,038,772 $0.000010 $0.37 56.19 $6.19 lx $6.19 18.87%
B
Series 3,310,188 $0.000010 $0.17 52.79 $2.79 lx $2.79 15.46%
A
Seed 1,628,291 $0.000010 $0.11 51.84 $1.84 lx $1.84 7.61%
Seed 1,309,277 $0.000010 $0.07 $1.15 $1.15 lx $1.15 6.12%
Investors (4)
Investor Name Status Lead/Sole Comments

1. Breyer Capital Follow -On No Lead Partner: James Breyer
Investor Form of Payment: Cash
Fund 1: IDG China Capital Fund

2. Coatue Management New Investor Yes Lead Partner: Philippe Laffont
7 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
3. Goodwater Capital

4. Valar Ventures
E Estimated
Advisors (3)
# Advisor Name
1. Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe
2. WilmerHale
3. Gunderson Dettmer
Form of Payment:
Fund 1:
Follow•On No Lead Partner:
Investor Form of Payment:
Fund 1:
Follow•On No Lead Partner:
Investor Form of Payment:
Fund 1:
Service Type Hired By Comments
Legal Advisor Coatue Management Lead Partner:
Legal Advisor Stash Invest
Legal Advisor Valar Ventures
Cash
Coatue CT XIII
Chi•Hua Chien
Cash
Goodwater Capital I
Andrew McCormack
Cash
Valar Global Fund II
John
Bautista
Deal #3: Early Stage VC (Series B), $25M, Completed; 14-Dec-2016
VC Round 3 Round Financing Venture Capital - Total 525.OOM
Deal Types Early Stage VC, Series Status Backed Invested
B Financing Venture Capital Capital
Deal 525.OOM Source Pre -money 575.OOM
Amount Raised to Date 537.25M — Valuation
Deal Status Completed Total Invested $25.00M Post 5100.OOM
Deal Date 14-Dec-2016 Equity Valuation
% Acquired 25.00% Investor
Ownership
63.67% CEO/Lead
Mgt
Brandon Krieg
Stock Split 1 : 1 Site New York, NY
Business Generating
Status Revenue
Deal Synopsis
The company raised 525 million of Series B venture funding in a deal led by Valar Ventures on December 14, 2016, putting
the pre•money valuation at $75 million. Goodwater Capital, Entrée Capital and Breyer Capital also participated in the
round. The funds will be used to continue to develop new features, services and products; including its free educational
hub, Learn.
* Not necessarily a summation of individual debt figures
•• Does not include grant funding
E Estimated
Stock Info + Cap Table History
8 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
Type of Stock Preferred # of Shares Acquired 4,038,772
Sehlictsdtalttotod Price Per Sharelitalculatecl using the Weighted ACISMeatiffitnciRatio 1
sPeeissirileirms 4.038,772
Price Per Share $6.19
Liquidation Preferences
Participating vs. Non-
participating
Dividend Rights
Pad Passu
Non-participating
Yes
Cumulative/Non-cumulative
Anti -dilution Provisions
Redemption Rights
Board Voting Rights
General Voting Rights
Non-Cumulative
Weighted
Average
No
Yes
Yes
CAP TABLE HISTORY
Stock # Of Shares
Authorized
Par
Value
Dividend
Rate S
Original
Issue
Price
Liquidation Liquidation
Pref.
Multiple
Conversion
Price Owned
Series 4.038,772 $0.000010 50.37 $6.19 $6.19 lx $6.19 25.00%
B
Series 3,310,188 $0.000010 50.17 52.79 $2.79 lx $2.79 20.49%
A
Seed 1,628,291 $0.000010 50.11 51.84 $1.84 lx $1.84 10.08%
Seed 1,309,277 $0.000010 50.07 $1.15 $1.15 lx $1.15 8.10%
Investors (4)
Investor Name Status Lead/Sole Comments

1. Breyer Capital New Investor No Lead Partner: James Breyer
Form of Payment: Cash
2. Entree Capital Follow -On No Form of Payment: Cash
Investor

3. Goodwater Capital Follow -On No Lead Partner: Chi-Hua Chien
Investor Form of Payment: Cash
Fund 1: Goodwater Capital I

4. Velar Ventures Follow -On Yes Lead Partner: Andrew McCormack
Investor Form of Payment: Cash
E Estimated
Advisors (2)
# Advisor Name

1. McCarter & English
Service Type Hired By Comments
Legal Advisor Stash Invest Lead Partner: David
Sorin JD
9 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
2. Gunderson Dettmer Legal Advisor Valar Ventures
Deal #2: Early Stage VC (Series A), $9.25M, Completed; 17-Aug-2016
VC Round 2 Round Financing Venture Capital - Total Invested $9.25M
Deal Types Early Stage VC, Series Status Backed Capital
A Financing Venture Capital Pre -money $23.89M
Deal $9.25M Source Valuation
Amount Raised to Date $12.25M Post Valuation $33.14M
Deal Status Completed Total Invested $9.25M CEO/Lead Mgt Brandon
Deal Date 17-Aug-2016 Equity Krieg
% Acquired 28.57% Investor
Ownership
53.92% Site New York,
NY
Stock Split 1 : 1 Business Status Startup
Deal Synopsis
The company raised 59.25 million of Series A venture funding from lead investor Goodwater Capital on August 17, 2016,
putting the company's pre -money valuation at 523.89 million. Valar Ventures and Entree Capital also participated. The
company intends to use the funds to accelerate user growth and to build out its technology platform.
* Not necessarily a summation of individual debt figures
•• Does not include grant funding
E Estimated
Stock Info + Cap Table History
Type of Stock
Series of Stock
Shares Sought
Price Per Share
Preferred
A
3,310,192
$2.79
# of Shares Acquired 3,310,192
Conversion Ratio 1
E Shares Sought and Price Per Share calculated using the Weighted Average Method
SERIES A TERMS
Liquidation Preferences Pad Passu Cumulative/Non-cumulative Non-Cumulative
Participating vs. Non-
participating
Non. participating Anti -dilution Provisions Weighted
Average
Dividend Rights Yes Redemption Rights No
Board Voting Rights Yes
General Voting Rights Yes
CAP TABLE HISTORY
Stock # Of Shares Par Dividend Original Liquidation Liquidation Conversion
Authorized Value Rate S Issue Pref. Price Owned
Price Multiple
Series 3.310,192 $0.000010 $0.17 52.79 $2.79 lx $2.79 28.57%
A
Seed 1.628,311 $0.000010 $0.11 51.84 $1.84 lx $1.84 14.05%
Seed 1.309,277 $0.000010 $0.07 51.15 $1.15 lx $1.15 11.30%
Investors (3)
10 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
Investor Name Status Lead/Sole Comments

1. Entree Capital Follow -On No Form of Payment: Cash
Investor
2. Goodwater Capital Follow -On Yes Lead Partner: Chi•Hua Chien
Investor
Form of Payment: Cash
Fund 1: Goodwater Capital I

3. Valar Ventures Follow -On No Lead Partner: Andrew McCormack
Investor Form of Payment: Cash
E Estimated
Advisors (7)
# Advisor Name Service Type Hired By Comments

1. Red Oak Compliance Solutions Consulting Stash Invest
2. JPMorgan Chase General Stash Invest
Business
Banking

3. Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe Legal Advisor Goodwater Capital Lead Partner: Harold Yu
4. Haynes and Boone Legal Advisor Stash Invest

5. Lowenstein Sandler Legal Advisor Stash Invest
6. McCarter & English Legal Advisor Stash Invest Lead Partner: David

7. Gunderson Dettmer Legal Advisor Valar Ventures
Sorin JD
Initial Deal Preferences
Target Open Date
Target Low
Amount Committed
12-Aug•2016 Stock Type
$9.25M
$9.07M
Preferred
Deal #1: Seed Round, $3M, Completed; 08-Feb-203.6
VC Round 1 Round Financing Venture Capital - Total Invested $3.00M
Deal Types Seed Round Status Backed Capital
Deal Amount $3.00M Financing Venture Capital Pre -money $12.75M
Source Valuation
Deal Status Completed
Raised to Date 53.OOM " Post Valuation $15.75M
Deal Date 08-Feb-2016
Total invested $3.OOM CEO/Lead Mgt David
`Ye Acquired 16.39% Equity Ronick
11 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
Stock Split 1 : 1 Site New York,
NY
Business Status Startup
Deal Synopsis
The company raised $3 million of seed funding from lead investor Goodwater Capital on February 8, 2016, putting the pre 
-
money valuation at $12.75 million. Valar Ventures and Entree Capital also participated. The company will use the funding
to support the continued growth and development of the app, including new product features and expansion to the Android
platform.
t Not necessarily a summation of individual debt figures
•• Does not include grant funding
E Estimated
Stock Info + Cap Table History
Shares Sought 1,628,311 # of Shares Acquired 1,356,926
Price Per Share $1.84 Conversion Ratio 1

E. Shares Sought and Price Per Share calculated using the Weighted Average Method
SEED 2 TERMS
Liquidation Preferences Pad Passu Cumulative/Non-cumulative Non•Cumulative
Participating vs. Non-
participating
Non-participating Anti -dilution Provisions Weighted
Average
Dividend Rights Yes Redemption Rights No
Board Voting Rights Yes
General Voting Rights Yes
CAP TABLE HISTORY
Stock # Of Par Dividend Original Liquidation Liquidation Conversion %
Shares Value Rate $ Issue Pref. Price Owned
Authorized Price Multiple
Seed 1,628.311 50.000010 $0.11 $1.84 51.84 lx 51.84 -500.00%
Seed 1,309.285 50.000010 $0.07 $1.15 51.15 lx 51.15 -482.45%
Investors (3)
Investor Name Status Lead/Sole Comments

1. Entrée Capital New Investor No Form of Payment: Cash
2. Goodwater Capital New Investor Yes Lead Partner: Chi-Hua Chien
Form of Payment: Cash
Fund 1: Goodwater Capital I

3. Valar Ventures New Investor No Lead Partner: Andrew McCormack
Form of Payment: Cash
E Estimated
Advisors (1)
1.2of25 2/26/19, 5:38 PM
# Advisor Name Service Type Hired By
1. McCarter & English
Tranches (1)
Tranche Date
1. 12•Aug•2015
Amount
$1.51M
Legal Advisor Stash Invest
Financing Type Comments
Bridge
Comments
Lead Partner:
Stock Type: Promissory Notes
Tranche Size Actual
Status:
Conversion Yes
Status:
David
Sorin JD
Investors (6)
Active Investors (6)
Name Investor Type Holding Investor Board Related Deals
Since
Union Square Ventures Venture Capital Minority Feb 2018
Coatue Management Hedge Fund
Breyer Capital
Entrée Capital
PE/Buyout
Minority Jul 2017
Minority Dec 2016
Venture Capital Minority Feb 2016
#5. Later Stage VC (Series D): New
Investor, Feb 2018, Rebecca Kaden,
$37.50M
#4. Later Stage VC (Series C): New
Investor, Jul 2017, Philippe Laffont,
$42.00M
#5. Later Stage VC (Series D): Follow-
on, Feb 2018, Philippe Laffont,
$37.50M
#3. Early Stage VC (Series B): New
Investor, Dec 2016, James Breyer,
$25.00M
#4. Later Stage VC (Series C):
on, Jul 2017, James Breyer, $42.00M
#5. Later Stage VC (Series D): Follow-
on, Feb 2018, James Breyer, $37.50M
#1. Seed Round: New Investor, Feb
2016, $3.00M
#2. Early Stage VC (Series A): Follow-
on, Aug 2016, $9.25M
#3. Early Stage VC (Series B): Follow-
on, Dec 2016, $25.00M
#5. Later Stage VC (Series DI: Follow-
on, Feb 2018, $37.50M
Goodwater Capital Venture Capital Minority Feb 2016 V #1. Seed Round: New Investor, Feb
2016, Chi-Hua Chien, $3.00M
13 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
#2. Early Stage VC (Series A): Follow-
on, Aug 2016, Chi-Hua Chien, $9.25M
#3. Early Stage VC (Series B): Follow-
on, Dec 2016, Chi•Hua Chien, 525.00M
#4. Later Stage VC (Series C): Follow-
on, Jul 2017, Chi•Hua Chien, $42.00M
#5. Later Stage VC (Series D): Follow-
on, Feb 2018, Chi-Hua Chien, $37.SOM
Valar Ventures Venture Capital Minority Feb 2016 vi #1. Seed Round: New Investor, Feb
2016, Andrew McCormack, 53.00M
#2. Early Stage VC (Series A): Follow-
on, Aug 2016, Andrew McCormack,
$9.25M
#3. Early Stage VC (Series B): Follow-
on, Dec 2016, Andrew McCormack,
$25.00M
#4. later Stage VC (Series C): Follow-
on, Jul 2017, Andrew McCorrnack,
$42.00M
#5. Later Stage VC (Series D): Follow-
on, Feb 2018, Andrew McCormack,
$37.50M
Service Providers
General Service (4)
Service Provider Name
Haynes and Boone
IPMorgan Chase
Lowenstein Sandler
Red Oak Compliance Solutions
Service on a Deal (19)
Service Provider
Name
Gunderson Dettmer
McCarter & English
Orrick, Herrington &
Sutcliffe
Orrick, Herrington &
Sutcliffe
Service Provided Comments
Legal Advisor Contact:
General Business
Banking
Legal Advisor
Consulting
Service Provided Service To
Legal Advisor
Legal Advisor
Legal Advisor
Legal Advisor
Kit Addleman JO
Deal Date Deal # Comments
Union Square 12- 5
Ventures Feb-2018
Stash Invest 12- 5
Feb-2018
Goodwater 12- 5
Capital Feb-2018
Coatue 12- 5
Management Feb-2018
14of25 2/26/19, 5:38 PM
Orrick, Herrington & Legal Advisor Valar Ventures 12• 5
Sutcliffe Feb•2018
WilmerHale Legal Advisor Stash Invest 12• 5 Contact: Stephanie Evans
Gunderson Dettmer
Orrick, Herrington &
Sutcliffe
Legal Advisor
Legal Advisor
Valar Ventures
Coatue
Management
Feb•2018
10•Jul•2017
WilmerHale Legal Advisor Stash Invest 10•Jul•2017 4 Contact: Stephanie Evans
Gunderson Dettmer Legal Advisor Valar Ventures 14• 3
McCarter & English Legal Advisor Stash Invest
Dec•2016
14• 3
Gunderson Dettmer Legal Advisor Valar Ventures
Dec•2016
17- 2
Aug•2016
Haynes and Boone Legal Advisor Stash Invest 17- 2 Contact: Kit Addleman JD
JPMorgan Chase General Business Stash Invest
Aug•2016
17- 2
Lowenstein Sandler
Banking
Legal Advisor Stash Invest
Aug•2016
17- 2
McCarter & English Legal Advisor Stash Invest
Aug•2016
17- 2
Orrick, Herrington & Legal Advisor Goodwater
Aug•2016
17• 2
Sutcliffe
Red Oak Compliance Consulting
Capital
Stash Invest
Aug•2016
17- 2
Solutions
McCarter & English Legal Advisor Stash Invest
Aug•2016
08• 1
Feb•2016
Former General Service (2)
Service Provider Name
McCarter & English
Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe
Service Provided Comments
Legal Advisor
Legal Advisor
Lead Partners on Deals (22)
Investors (16)
Name All Title
Deals
Representing Deals Phone Email
15 425 2/26/19.5:38 PM
Andrew McCormack
Chl-Hua Chien
James Breyer
Philippe Laffont
Rebecca Kaden
Andrew McCormack
Chl-Hua Chien
James Breyer
Philippe Laffont
Andrew McCormack
Chl-Hua Chien
James Breyer
Andrew 'McCormack
Chl-Hua Chien
Andrew McCormack
12 Co-Founding Valor Ventures
Partner & General
Partner
37 Co-Founder &
Managing Partner
Goodwater Capital
94 Founder & Chief Breyer Capital
Executive Officer
3 Founder & Chief
Executive Officer
5 Partner
#5. Later Stage VC
(series 0): Feb
2018, $37.50M,
Completed
#5. Later Stage VC
(Series 13): Feb
2018, $37.50M,
Completed
#5. Later Stage VC +1 (415)
(Series D): Feb 310-6790
2018, $37.50M,
Completed
Coatue Management 05. Later Stage VC +1 (212)
(Series D): Feb 715-5100
2018, $37.50M,
Completed
Union Square
Ventures
12 Co-Founding Valor Ventures
Partner & General
Partner
37 Co-Founder &
Managing Partner
Goodwater Capital
94 Founder & Chief Breyer Capital
Executive Officer
3 Founder & Chief
Executive Officer
#5. Later Stage VC +1 (212)
(Series D): Feb 990-7880
2018, $37.50M,
Completed
#4. Later Stage VC
(Series C): Jul
2017, $42.00M,
Completed
*4. Later Stage VC
(Series C): Jul
2017, $42.00M,
Completed
*4. Later Stage VC +1 (415)
(Series C): Jul 310-6790
2017, 502.00M,
Completed
Coatue Management MC Later Stage VC +1 (212)
(Series C): Jul 715-5100
2017, S42.00M,
Completed
12 Co.Founding valet Ventures
Partner & General
Panne,
37 Co.Founder
Managing Partner
#3. Early Stage VC
(Series B): Dec
2016, $25.00M,
Completed
Goodwater Capital #3. Early Stage VC
(Series 8): Dec
2016, $25.00M,
Completed
94 Founder & Chief Breyer Capital
Executive Officer
12 Co-Founding Valor Ventures
Partner & General
Partner
37 Co-Founder &
Managing Partner
Goodwater Capital
12 Co-Founding Velar Ventures
Partner & General
Partner
#3. Early Stage VC
(Series B): Dec 310-6790
2016, $25.00M,
Completed
#2. Early Stage VC
(Series A): Aug
2016, $9.25M,
Completed

02. Early Stage VC
(Series A): Aug
2016, $9.25M,
Completed
#1. Seed Round:
Feb 2016, 53.00M,
Completed
+1 (415)
16 of 25 2/26/19,5:38 PM
Chl-Hua Chien 37 Co.Founder &
Managing Banner
Service Providers - Sell Side (4)
Goodwater Capital 91. Seed Round:
Feb 2016, S3.OOM,
competed
Name All Title Representing Deals Phone Email
Deals
David &DM JD 230 Partner & Co- McCarter & English 95. Later Stage VC +11732)
chairman, Venture (Series Di: Feb B67-9742
Capital & Emerging
Growth Companies
2018, 537.50M,
completed
David Sorin JD 230 Partner & Co- McCarter & English 93. Early Stage VC +11732)
chairman, Venture (Series B): Dec B67-9742
Capital & Emerging
Growth Companies
2016, S25.OOM,
completed
David Sorin JD 230 Partner & co- McCarter & English 92. Early Stage VC +1 (732)
chairman, Venture (Series A): Aug 867-9742
Capital & Emerging
Growth Companies
2016, 59.25M,
completed
David Sarin JD 230 hanner& co- McCarter & English at. Seed Round: +1 (732)
chairman, Venture
Capital & Emerging
Feb 2016. S3.OOM,
completed
867-9742
Growth Companies
Service Providers - Buy Side (2)
Name
John Bautista
Harold Yu
All Title
Deals
196 Partner
53 Rattner
Representing Deals Phone Email
OniCk. Herrington & 94. Later Stage VC +1 (212)
Sutcliffe 'Series C): Jul 2017. 506-5000
142.OOM, completes
OniCk. Herrington & 92. Early Stage VC +1 (212)
Sutcliffe 'Series A): Aug 506-5000
2016. 59.25M,
completed
Market Information
Competition
The company's competitors include Oapital, Digit, Motif (Financial Software), Personal Capital, FutureAdvisor, SigFig,
PayActiv
Signals Summary
This company has a weekly growth rate of 0.58%, placing it in the 95th percentile of all growth rates tracked within
PitchBook. Its underlying data points generate a size multiple that is 523x times larger than the median of all size
multiples tracked within PitchBook, placing it in the 100th percentile of all size multiples tracked within PitchBook.
17 of 25 2/26/19. 5:38 PM
Growth Rate Summary (Weekly)
Twitter Followers
29,753
Similar Web Unique
Visitors
103,667
Majestic Referring
Domains
1,586
Mobile App Reviews
83,775
Social
0.78%
Web 0.58% GIO•th SUM
4 '8"  95th ptICOntilo
Mobile
1.79%
Size Multiple Summary (x Median)
Twitter Followers
29,753
Similar Web Unique
Visitors
103,667
Majestic Referring
Domains
1.586
Mobile App Reviews
83,775
Social
83.0x
Web 523x Sin Multiple
ICON pore...8M 96.3x
Mobile
1.39Kx
Signals History
Growth Rate History
10.0
7.5
5.0
2.5
0.0
23 I I I
Sep '18 Oct 18 Nov'18 Dec 18 Jan '19 Feb '19
Growthes  Rate es Web Growth Rata
Social Growth Rate Mobile Growth Rate
Size Multiple History
Laic
I.6K
I.AK
I.2K
I.OK
200 I
Sap '18 Oct 18 Nov '18 Doc '18 Jan '19 Fab '19
Sze Molople Web Size Multiple
Es Social Size Mu It pie Mobile Stze Multiple
Social Media Signals
Twitter Followers 29,753
18 of 25 2/26/19,5:38 PM
31.0K
28.8K
26.7K
24.5K
Sep'18 Oct 1 8 Nov 1 8 Doc '18 Jan '19 Feb19
Twitter Folbvters Calculation Range 0
Metric Stash Invest All
Companies
Average
Twitter Followers 29.753 11,958
Growth Rate 0.78% 0.10%
Growth Rate 98th 44th
Percentile
Size Multiple 83.0x 34.0x
Size Multiple 98th 50th
Percentile
Web Signals
SimilarWeb Unique Visitors 103,667
170K
140K
110K
80K
Seia'18 Oa 18 Nov 1 8 Doc 18 Jan19 Fob 19
UniqueMstors Cakulation Range 0
Metric Stash Invest All
Companies
Average
SimIlarWeb Unique 103,667 21,451
Visitors
Growth Rate -2.13% -0.55%
Growth Rate 20th 39th
Percentile
Size Multiple 146x 39.2x
Size Multiple 98th 50th
Percentile
Majestic Referring Domains 1,586
1.65K
156K
147K
1.38K
Sop'18 Oct 1 8 Nov18 Dec18 Jan '19 Fab 19
Referring Dynan, Cakulation Range 0
Metric Stash invest All
Companies
Average
Majestic Referring 1,586 365
Domains
Growth Rate 0.45% -0.01%
Growth Rate 93rd 23rd
Percentile
Size Multiple 46.9x 10.8x
Size Multiple 98th 50th
Percentile
Ranking And Distribution
Weekly Growth 0.58%, 95th %ile
19 of 25 2/26/19,5:38 PM
a '0 50 90 100
ALL Decline/Flat ❑ Steady
Percentile

• Growing
Min Rate
Fast Rapid
Max Rate
I Stefli Invest
Avg. Rate
0.10 -44.0% -0.16% -1.34%
10-20 -0.15% 0.00% -0.01%
20-30 -
30.40 - -
40.50 - -
50.60 - -
60.70 - -
70.80 0.01% 0.03% 0.02%
»4o 0.04% 0.26% 0.13%
90.100 0.27% 497% 1.21%
Size Multiple 523; 100th %ile
0 10 SC
0.00x Ao. 4L 131Kx
• %Small ■ Small
Percentile
ø Average
Min Size
01 Large • %Large
Max Size
I Stash Invest
Avg. Size
0.10 0.00x 0.12x 0.07x
10.20 0.13x 0.26x 0.20x
20.30 0.27x 0.44x 0.36x
30.40 0.45x 0.65x 0.55x
40.50 0.66x 0.99x 0.81x
50.60 1.00x 1.49x 1.22x
60.70 1.50x 2.35x 1.88x
70.80 2.36x 4.15x 3.12x
»4o 4.16x 10.7x 6.59x
90.100 10.7x 131Kx 117x
Employee Signals
Company Employee Growth Rate Growth Size Multiple Size
20 of 25 2/26/19, 5:38 PM
Stash Invest
All Companies Average
Count
2,626 0.28%
Percentile
49th 22.6x
Percentile
50th
Mobile Signals
Primary Mobile App
Stash: Invest. Learn. Save. ***tit
Category: Finance, Education Price: Free
Stash is a personal finance and investment app that helps you save money and Invest In
select individual stocks and curated funds (ETFs), starting with just $5. What's New? Banking
Is coming to STASH! Were offering a debit account with zero set-up, monthly, minimum
balance, or overdraft fees. -- STASH for your life with:* Personal investment accounts *
Retirement accounts with Roth and Traditional IRAs * Custodial accounts to invest for and
with your children -- Every STASH subscription includes:* Coach - Personalized savings and
investment advice* Learn - Financial education, guidance, and curated investment news*
Auto -Stash - Save and invest automatically-- Safety & Security -- 256 -bit encryption and
Secure Sockets Layer (SSL)-to keep your money, identity, and personal information safe.
Stash is an SEC registered investment adviser. While such registration does not imply a
certain level of skill, it does require us to follow federal regulations that protect you - the
investor. Our custodian is an SEC registered broker -dealer and a member of FINRA, NYSE, and
SIPC. Securities in your account are protected up to $500,000 (including $250,000 for claims
for cash). For details, please visit www.sipc.org.-- Investment account pricingEach account
has one simple advisory fee. Invest and Custodial accounts cost $1 per month for balances
under 55k. Retire accounts cost $2 per month for balances under $5k. All accounts with
balances of 55k or more only cost 0.25% per year (Just $12.50 per year for a balance of 55k).
We NEVER charge for deposits or withdrawals, and there are no add-on trading commissions.
Disclosurel Other fees may apply.Banking services provided by Green Dot Bank and Stash
Visa Debit card issued by Green Dot Bank, Member FDIC, pursuant to a license from Visa
U.S.A. Inc. Visa is a registered trademark of Visa International Service Association. Green Dot
Bank operates under the following registered trade names: GoBank, Green Dot Bank and
Bonneville Bank. All of the registered trade names are used by, and refer to a single FDIC -
insured bank, Green Dot Bank. Deposits under any of these trade names are deposits with
Green Dot Bank and are aggregated for deposit insurance coverage. Green Dot is a registered
trademark of Green Dot Corporation. O2018 Green Dot Bank. All rights reserved.Investment
products and services are offered by Stash Investments LLC, not Green Dot Bank, and are Not
FDIC Insured, Not Bank Guaranteed, and May Lose Value. Securities offered through Apex
Clearing Corporation, Member FINRA/SIPC.Investing Involves Risk. Listed Investments
currently available on Stash but not necessarily representative of all Investments. A full list of
available investments on Stash can be found here: learn.stashinvest.com/stash-inv...
Information shown is strictly for illustrative and educational purposes only and should not be
considered a solicitation to buy, an offer to sell, or a recommendation for any security In any
jurisdiction where such an offer, solicitation or recommendation would be unlawful or
unauthorized. All product and company names are trademarks'" or registered® trademarks of
their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by
them. Any preliminary information provided to prospective clients prior to Stash accepting a
signed advisory agreement does not constitute investment advice and should not be relied on
as such. Stash Investments LLC ("Stash") is an SEC registered investment adviser. In order to
open a Stash account, you must be at least 18 years of age and Stash Is only available to US
citizens, permanent residents and select visa types. See www.stashinvest.com/disclosur... for
more Info. 1. Clients may incur ancillary fees that are not part of wrap-fee.lf you receive a
bonus offer, you agree to and accept the terms and conditions here:
www.stashinvest.com/terms-and...
21 of 25 2/26/19,5:38 PM
Mobile Reviews 83,775
MK
34K
76K
38K
Sep '18 Oct '18 Nov '18 Dec'18 Jan '19 Feb '19
Mobile Reviews ■ Calculation Range
Mobile Rating
Sep '18 Oct '18 Nov '18 Dec'18 Jan '19 Feb '19
iOS Rating
Company Mobile Growth Rate Growth Size Multiple Size
Reviews Percentile Percentile
Stash Invest 83,775 1.79% 85th 1.39Kx 99th
All Companies Average 12,446 1.20% 46th 228x 51st
Today's Chart Ranking
Fl
(Top Free Applications) 33rd
Sep 18 Oct '18 Nov '18 Dec'18 Jan '19 Feb '19
Mobile Ranking
Company signals data was calculated against 843696 companies within all companies.
22 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
Company Signals Population: Company Signals data is tracked for active companies (i.e. have not gone out of business)
that haven't been exited from VC, PE, or Incubator/Accelerator. Social media presence is tracked only for companies that
have a Twitter account; web presence is tracked only for companies whose websites are tracked by SimilarWeb and
Majestic.
News
Breaking Banks: One robo-advisor's approach to simplifying wealth management
Brandon Krieg, co-founder and CEO of StashInvest, shares what his company is doing to create a comfortable, 
"frictionless"
point of entry for investing.
American Banker I 13-Feb-2018
Tagged entities: Stash Invest,  Brandon Krieg
Stash Raises $37.5M in Series D
NEW YORK, NY, Financial platform revolutionizing how millions of Americans invest and save, today announced it has
raised $37.5 million in Series D funding.
VC News Daily I 12-Feb-2018
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Microinvesting app Stash raises $40M
The micro -investing app allows users, many of them first-time investors, to get started for as little as 55.
American Banker 113 -Jul-2017
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Stash raises $40 million Series C to make investing more approachable
Stash raises 540 million Series C to make investing more approachable
TechCrunch 113 -Jul-2017
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Stash Secures $40M Series C Financing
NEW YORK, NY, Stash, the financial technology platform that's revolutionizing investment and education for all 
Americans,
announced today that it has raised $40 million in Series C funding. Click here for more funding data on Stash To export
Stash...
VC News Daily I 13-Jul-2017
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Stash Secures $40M in Series C Funding to Meet Massive Demand for Its Investing and
Financial Education Platform
Stash Secures $40M in Series C Funding to Meet Massive Demand for Its Investing and Financial
PR NewsWire 113 -Jul-2017
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Millennial -focused micro investment platform Stash raises US$25 million Series B round
Millennial•focused micro investment platform Stash raises US$25 million Series B round New York-based mobile
investment startup Stash, cofounded by Australian Ed Robinson, has today announced the closing of a US$25 million Series
B round led by...
23 of 25 2/26/19. 5:38 PM
StartupSmart 23-Dec-2016
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Stash Secures $25 mm in Series B Financing Led by Valar Ventures
Stash Secures 525 mm in Series B Financing Led by Velar Ventures Target Overview Transaction Details SUGGEST
TRANSACTION UPDATE Stash Invest http://www.stashinvest.com 27 W 24th Street New York, NY 10010 United States
FinTech Sector:...
FT Partners 14-Dec-2016
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Micro -investing aim Stash raises $25 million Series B
Micro -investing app Stash raises $25 million Series B Stash, a mobile application that aims to make investing easier 
for
those who aren't as financially experienced, has raised 525 million in Series B funding, the company announced today.
The...
TechCrunch 114•Dec-2016
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Mobile Investing App Stash Closes $25 Million Series B: Startup enables consumers to
invest as little as $5
Mobile investing service Stash has raised $25 million four months after closing its Series A round.Valar Ventures led 
the
Series B investment, joined by Breyer Capital, Goodwater Capital and Entrée Capital.
VentureWire 14-Dec•2016
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Stash Raises $25M In Series B Funding
By FinSMEs Stash , a NYC-based mobile investing app, raised $25M in Series B funding. The round was led by Velar
Ventures, with participation from Breyer Capital, Goodwater Capital, and Entrée Capital. The company, which has raised
$9.25m in...
FinSMEs 114-Dec•2016
Tagged entities: Stach Invest
Mobile Investing App Stash Raises $25 Million In Series B Funding
Mobile Investing App Stash Raises 525 Million In Series B Funding Velar Ventures Leads Round; Platform Reaches 300,000
Users News provided by Dec 14, 2016, 06:30 ET Share this article NEW YORK, Dec. 14, 2016 /PRNewswire/ •• Stash makes
investing...
PR NewsWire 14-Dec•2016
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Stash Invest Secures $9.3 mm in Series A Financing Led by Goodwater Capital and Valar
Ventures
Stash Invest Secures $9.3 mm in Series A Financing Led by Goodwater Capital and Velar Ventures Target Overview
Transaction Details SUGGEST TRANSACTION UPDATE Stash Invest http www.stashinvest.com 27 W 24th Street New York,
NY 10010 United...
FT Partners IS -Aug-2016
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Stash Raises $3M Seed Round for App for Novices to Stock Investing
Stash Raises 53M Seed Round for App for Novices to Stock Investing Joo-Pierre S. Ruth February 9th, 2016 @jpruth
@xconomy Like Us Share Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Linkedln Email Reprints The stock market might be cruel
24 of 25 2/26/19.5:38 PM
and unforgiving...
Xconomy I 09•Feb•2016
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
Stash. the Investment Apo for MillenniaIs. Secures S3 Million in Seed Funding
Stash, the Investment App for MillenniaIs, Secures $3 Million in Seed Funding Goodwater Capital, Valar Ventures, and 
Entre
Capital Invest to Accelerate Stashs Growth February 09, 2016 0900 AM Eastern Standard Time NEW YORK—(BUSINESS...
BusinessWire I 09-Feb-2016
Tagged entities: Stash Invest
SEC Filings (8)
Type Date Title OK
D 22-Feb-2019 Notice of Exempt Offering of Securities 1647051
12-Feb-2018 Notice of Exempt Offering of Securities: 1647051
13•Jul•2017 Notice of Exempt Offering of Securities 1647051
14-Dec-2016 Notice of Exempt Offering of Securities 1647051
16•Aug•2016 Notice of Exempt Offering of Securities 1647051
08-Feb-2016 Notice of Exempt Offering of Securities 1647051
LvA 12•Aug•2015 Notice of Exempt Offering of Securities(Amend] 1647051
D 02•Jul•2015 Notice of Exempt Offering of Securities 1647051
Copyright t 2019 PitchBook Data, Inc. All rights reserved.
Provided under contract for the exclusive use of subscriber Richard Kahn, HBRK Associates .
25 of 25 2/26/19, 5:38 PM
EFTA00078311 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of <REDACTED> v. Estate of Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell Boies Schiller filing about sexual abuse of their client
(inferred date: 2026-01-19)
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Plaintiff, CASE NO:
v.
DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN,
in their capacities as the executors of the
ESTATE OF JEFFREY EDWARD EPSTEIN, and
GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
Defendants.
COMPLAINT
BOIES $CHILLER FLEXNER LLP
1
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 19
Plaintiffs by her attorneys Boies Schiller Flexner LLP, for her Complaint
against Defendants, Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn in their capacities as the executors of
the Estate of Jeffrey Edward Epstein ("Epstein") and Ghislaine Maxwell ("Maxwell")
(collectively, "Defendants"), avers upon personal knowledge as to her own acts and status and
upon information and belief and to all other matters as follows:
NATURE OF THE ACTION

I. This suit arises out of Defendants' sexual abuse of Plaintiff beginning when Plaintiff was
16 years old.

2. When Plaintiff was 16, she was sexually trafficked by Defendants as part of Epstein and
Maxwell's organized ring of procuring young women and girls for sex.

3. Epstein's trafficking scheme involved recruiting young women and girls by making false
promises and using his wealth, power and threats to intimidate the females into submission to his
demands. This same pattern was repeated numerous times with numerous young women and
girls.

4. As United States District Judge Kenneth Marra found, "From between about 1999 and
2007, Jeffrey Epstein sexually abused more than 30 minor girls . . . at his mansion in Palm
Beach, Florida, and elsewhere in the United States and overseas. . . . In addition to his own
sexual abuse of the victims, Epstein directed other persons to abuse the girls sexually. Epstein
used paid employees to find and bring minor girls to him. Epstein worked in concert with others
to obtain minors not only for his own sexual gratification, but also for the sexual gratification of
others." Doe 1 v. United States, 359 F. Supp. 3d 1201, 1204 (S.D. Fla. 2019) (internal citations
omitted).
2
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 19

5. Epstein organized this sex trafficking network to obtain hundreds of young girls for
himself for sex, and also lent these girls out to other powerful and wealthy individuals to be
sexually abused.

6. Despite his significant criminal activity, in 2008 Epstein received a shockingly minimal
charge pleading guilty to a single Florida state law charge of procuring a minor for prostitution
and a non-prosecution agreement (a "NPA") with the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of
Florida. Unknown to the public and the victims at the time, Epstein's lawyers were pressuring
the Government to commit to the NPA without informing the victims. Epstein's multiple
victims were kept in the dark and told to be "patient" while Epstein's lawyers worked to protect
him and other potential co-conspirators from prosecution. Epstein served one year in jail, but
was afforded the privilege of being able to leave the jail to go to work for twelve hours per day,
six days per week.

7. The NPA allowed Epstein to escape proportionate punishment for his actions and to
continue operating his sex trafficking enterprise with liberty.

8. A few years later, Epstein flippantly referred to his sexual abuse of multiple young
women and girls, and the slap on the wrist he had received for it, in a 2011 interview with the
New York Post: "Billionaire pervert Jeffrey Epstein is back in New York City — and making
wisecracks about his just-ended jail stint for having sex with an underage girl. `I am not a sexual
predator, I'm an offender,' the financier told The Post yesterday. `It's the difference between a
murderer and a person who steals a bagel,' said Epstein." Amber Sutherland, Billionaire Jeffrey
Epstein: I'm a Sex Offender Not a Predator, N.Y. Post (Feb. 25, 2011),
https://nypost.com/2011/02/25/billionaire-jeffrey-epstein-im-a-sex-offender-not-a-predatort
3
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 19

9. In August 2018, just one year before his death, Epstein told a New York Times reporter
"that criminalizing sex with teenage girls was a cultural aberration and that at times in history it
was perfectly acceptable." James B. Stewart, The Day Jeffrey Epstein Told Me He Had Dirt on
Powerful People, N.Y. Times (Aug. 12, 2019),
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/12/business/jeffity-epstein-interview.html.

10. Maxwell spent years overseeing and managing Epstein's sex trafficking network, and
actively recruited underage girls to provide to Epstein and others for sex.

11. Epstein and Maxwell conspired with friends and hired staff to maintain and keep secret
this network of sexual abuse for years, which sprawled throughout Epstein's residences in New
York, Florida, New Mexico, the United States Virgin Islands, and Paris. Epstein's preference
was to have three different girls a day for his sexual pleasure and Maxwell was in charge of
recruiting the girls.

12. Maxwell facilitated Epstein's sexual trafficking ring by activities including, but not
limited to: (1) identifying and recruiting girls, including several minors, for Epstein's sexual
pleasure and that of his co-conspirators, including herself; (2) identifying and hiring individuals
to recruit underage girls; (3) scheduling appointments between the trafficked girls, many of
whom were minors, and Epstein; (4) administering Epstein's sex trafficking organization and
hiding it from criminal repercussions; and (5) intimidating girls, many of whom were minors,
who attempted to escape or report Epstein's sex trafficking operation.

13. Epstein and Maxwell committed sexual assault and battery upon Plaintiff when she was
16 years old. As such, the Defendants are responsible for battery, unlawful imprisonment, and
intentional infliction of emotional distress pursuant to New York common law. The damage to
Plaintiff has been severe and lasting.
4
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 19

14. This action has been timely filed pursuant to the Child Victims Act, N.Y. C.P.L.R.
§ 214-g. The actions described herein constitute sexual offenses by Defendants under New York
Penal Law Article 130, and were committed against Plaintiff when she was a child less than
eighteen years of age, for which she suffered physical, psychological, and other injuries as a
result.

15. This action has been timely filed pursuant to N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a), which provides
that a plaintiff shall have at least one year from the termination of a criminal action against the
same defendant to commence an action with respect to the event or occurrence from which the
criminal action arose. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking
enterprise from which Plaintiff's claims arise was terminated on August 29, 2019.

16. Any statute of limitations applicable to Plaintiff's claims, if any, is tolled due to the
continuous and active deception, duress, threats of retaliation, and other forms of misconduct that
Defendants used to silence their many victims, including Plaintiff. Defendants' actions deprived
Plaintiff of the opportunity to commence this lawsuit before Epstein's death. Until his death,
Plaintiff feared that Epstein and his co-conspirators, including Maxwell, would harm her or her
family, or ruin her life, if she came forward.

17. Defendants are equitably estopped from asserting a statute of limitations defense.
Allowing Defendants to do so would be unjust. Defendants intimidated each of their victims into
silence by threatening their lives and their livelihoods. They therefore prevented Plaintiff from
commencing this lawsuit before Epstein's death. By using threats, along with his wealth and
power, Epstein was able to escape punishment for his intolerable and brutal crimes against
countless young women and underage girls for the duration of his life.
5
Case 1 19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 6 of 19
PARTIES

18. Plaintiff is a citizen and resident of Texas.
19. Defendant Darren K. Indyke is sued in his capacity as an appointed executor of the Estate
of Jeffrey E. Epstein.

20. Defendant Richard D. Kahn is sued in his capacity as an appointed executor of the Estate
of Jeffrey E. Epstein.

21. Defendant Ghislaine Maxwell is a New York citizen and is domiciled in the Southern
District of New York.
JURISDICTION AND VENUE

22. Jeffrey Epstein was a citizen of the United States domiciled in the U.S. Virgin Islands at
the time of his death. Jeffrey Epstein maintained a residence in the Southern District of New
York. As the legal representatives of the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein, Darren K. Indyke and
Richard D. Kahn are deemed citizens of the U.S. Virgin Islands.

23. Defendant Maxwell is a citizen of both the United States and the United Kingdom and is
domiciled in the Southern District of New York.

24. The amount in controversy in this action exceeds the sum or value of $75,000.00
excluding interests and costs and is between citizens of different states. Accordingly, jurisdiction
is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1332.

25. Venue is proper in this Court as the sexual abuse of Plaintiff by Defendants Epstein and
Maxwell began and occurred in New York, New York, where they recruited her at the age of 16,
physically molested her, and began grooming her for sex in their organized sex trafficking ring.
6
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 7 of 19

26. Many of the events giving rise to these causes of action occurred in the Southern District
of New York, where a substantial amount of Epstein's property is located. Thus, venue in this
district is proper. 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(2).
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS

A. Epstein's Sex Trafficking Enter➢rise
27. Jeffrey Epstein was widely renowned as a billionaire who used his vast connections to
powerful individuals, and seemingly unlimited wealth and resources, to create a web of
transcontinental sex trafficking that served himself, his coconspirators, and some of the most
powerful people in the world.

28. Epstein owned multiple residences and frequently travelled between them, including at 9
East 71' Street, New York, New York 10021, and at 49 Zorro Ranch Road, Stanley, New
Mexico 87056, where the illegal sexual crimes against Plaintiff occurred. Epstein conservatively
valued his New York townhome at $55,931,000.00. Epstein conservatively valued his New
Mexico ranch at $17,246,208.00. In addition, Epstein owned residences in the Virgin Islands,
Florida, France, and even on his own island, Great St. James Island, where his transcontinental
sex trafficking of hundreds of young girls servicing him, his co-conspirators, and wealthy and
powerful individuals around the world occurred.

29. The allegations herein concern Epstein's and Maxwell's tortious acts against Plaintiff
while in New York, where Epstein was staying at his 71' Street mansion, and at his ranch in
New Mexico.

30. At all times material to this cause of action, Jeffrey Epstein utilized his seemingly
unlimited power, wealth, and resources, as well as his deep connections to powerful and
politically connected individuals to intimidate and manipulate his victims of sexual abuse.
7
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 8 of 19

31. Epstein and Maxwell had perfected a scheme for manipulation and abuse of young
females. As part of the scheme, Maxwell or another female would approach a young female and
strike up a conversation in an effort to quickly learn about the young female's background and
any vulnerabilities they could expose. Maxwell would then manipulate the young female into
coming back to one of Epstein's residences by offering the young female something she needed.
At times Maxwell's lure would be a modeling opportunity, money for education, help for the
young female's family, and a whole host of other related offers depending on their target's
situation. Once in the residence, Maxwell and Epstein would work in concert to impress and
intimidate the young female with displays of vast wealth, including having employees that were
butlers and maids formally dressed around the house. They would also strategically place
photographs of very powerful political and social figures amongst photographs and art displaying
nude females in an effort to normalize the sexual abuse. They would also normalize the sexual
abuse by placing a massage table and spa related products around the massage area in an effort to
legitimize the area where the abuse was set to occur. Once abused, Epstein and Maxwell
continued to manipulate the victims, using their financial power, promises, and threats to ensure
that the victim returned as directed and remained compliant with their demands.

B. The Arrest, Prosecution, and Death of Epstein
32. The sexual trafficking ring described herein started at least as early as 1995 and
continued up until at least July 2, 2019, when the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of New York ("SDNY") charged Epstein with sex trafficking conspiracy and sex trafficking in
violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591. He was arrested on July 8, 2019, pursuant to the SDNY's Sealed
Two Count Indictment, which is attached as Exhibit A.
8
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 9 of 19

33. The Indictment described Epstein's conduct and his abuse and trafficking of females in
the same trafficking operation he used to abuse and traffic Plaintiff.

34. Epstein's last will and testament (the "Will") was executed on August 8, 2019, at the
Metropolitan Correctional Center. The witnesses were Martel Colon Miro and Gulnora Tali. The
Will included affidavits from Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn, in which they swear an
"Oath of Willingness to Serve as Executor and Appointment of Local Counsel."

35. Epstein was found dead in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center on August 10,
2019.
36. Epstein's last will and testament was filed on August 15, 2019, in the Probate Division of
the Superior Court of the Virgin Islands.

37. Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn filed a Certificate of Trust in the Superior Court
of the Virgin Islands for Epstein's 1953 Trust on August 26, 2019. See Certificate of Trust, In
the Matter of the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein, Probate No. ST-19-PB-80 (Super. Ct. V.I. Aug. 26,
2019).

38. Epstein's will was entered into probate on September 6, 2019, and the Superior Court of
the Virgin Islands accordingly authorized Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn to administer
Epstein's estate. See Order for Probate, In the Matter of the Estate opeey E. Epstein, Probate

No. ST-19-PB-80 (Super. Ct. V.I. Sept. 6, 2019); Letters Testamentary, In the Matter of the
Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein, Probate No. ST-19-PB-80 (Super. Ct. V.I. Sept. 6, 2019).

39. The Will's first article directs Epstein's executors "to pay from my estate all expenses of
my last illness, my funeral and burial expenses, the administration expenses of my estate and all
of my debts duly proven and allowed against my estate." The Will further directs that "after the
9
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 10 of 19
payments and distributions provided in Article FIRST," Epstein "give[s] all of my property, real
and personal, wherever situated ... to the then acting Trustees of The 1953 Trust."

40. Following Epstein's death, SDNY submitted a proposed nolle prosequi order in the
criminal matter against him because it was required by law to do so after Epstein was deceased.
On August 29, 2019, U.S. District Judge Richard Berman formally dismissed SDNY's
indictment against Epstein, terminating the criminal action against him.
C.

41. was born on parents divorced when she was
young, and her mother struggled financially to support and her siblings.

42. In 1995 and 1996, was a high school student at Xavier College Preparatory in
Phoenix, Arizona. She was a top performing student with the goal of going to college.

43. In approximately 1995, sister, was an artist and a graduate student
in New York. She met Epstein and Maxwell at an art show. Epstein noticed her artwork.
Epstein offered to help her in her art career if she sold Epstein some of her artwork.

44. Epstein asked if she had a father. He also asked her personal questions about her
family situation, including about her younger sister, explained that her parents
were divorced, and that she and her family were financially struggling.

45. accepted a job offer from Epstein to purchase art for him.
46. Her role later included keeping records of people who entered Epstein's New York
mansion. observed that Defendant Maxwell was regularly bringing over school-aged girls
to the New York mansion. Maxwell told that these girls were interviewing for Victoria's
Secret modeling positions.
10
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 11 of 19

47. Maxwell described her role to as recruiting Victoria's Secret models for Epstein.
witnessed Maxwell spotting girls and talking to them outside of the mansion, which
Maxwell claimed was for recruiting purposes. Maxwell would leave the mansion claiming she
had "to go get girls for Jeffrey."

48. At the time, was unaware of the sex trafficking conspiracy and believed the girls
were being recruited for modeling positions.

49. understood her older sister, = to be working for a billionaire in New York.
50. Epstein began taking an interest in He asked questions about her younger
sister in Arizona. He presented this interest to in a friendly and fatherly manner.
was very proud of strong academic record, and supported goal of going to a
good college after high school.

51. Epstein offered ideas on how he could help get into college. He used this as
a ruse to get to come to New York so that he could abuse her. Epstein purchased
plane tickets, and she flew to New York.

52. Epstein gave money to buy a dress. He paid for a limousine to pick up the
sisters and take them to Epstein's townhome. He talked to about going to college and
potential schools before sending them to see a Broadway show.

53. During stay in New York, Epstein asked and to go to the movie
theater with him. This is where he began initiating non-consensual physical contact with
in an attempt to groom for sexual activity and normalize sexual behavior with him.

54. At the movie, Epstein intentionally positioned himself between the sisters to ensure they
were separated, and to prevent from seeing that he was touching Epstein began
caressing and petting on various parts of her body against her will. He would repeatedly
11
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 12 of 19
touch only when was unaware and looking away. was distressed, frightened,
and confused.

55. then left to go back home to Arizona.
56. Epstein began calling and her mother from New York under the false pretense of
discussing education and plans for college. He offered to send on an international
trip to help with her college applications.

57. As part of his plan to recruit for sexual purposes, Epstein explained to
mother that he sponsored educational trips for high school students, and was sponsoring an event
in New Mexico at his ranch called Zorro Ranch. He invited . He explained that Maxwell
would be a host or chaperone for at the event. Under these false pretenses,
mother agreed to send to Epstein's program for high school students.

58. Epstein and Maxwell, who were in New York at the time, arranged and paid for to
fly to New Mexico in the spring of 1996. Epstein mailed her airline tickets from New York to
her mother in Arizona. When arrived in New Mexico, Epstein had a driver take her to his
ranch. Epstein's Zorro Ranch sits on over 10,000 acres and is very remote. Upon arriving at the
ranch, learned that Epstein had not invited any other students. She was the only person at
the massive ranch in a different state, away from her family in Arizona, her sister in New York,
and anyone she knew. She was alone with Maxwell and Epstein.

59. Maxwell appeared charming and friendly to Upon arriving, Maxwell and Epstein
took shopping and lavished her with gifts, including beauty products and a pair of brand
new cowboy boots. After returning to the ranch, Maxwell began pressuring to touch
Epstein and give him a foot massage. was very scared and did not want to touch Epstein,
but Maxwell was relentless and demanded that massage Epstein. Both adults explained to
12
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 13 of 19
that it was just a massage, and attempted to normalize this sexual behavior with an adult to
her.

60. Epstein and Maxwell took to a movie theater. While in line for the movie,
Maxwell pulled down Epstein's sweatpants, exposing part of his buttocks. Both Epstein and
Maxwell repeatedly fondled each other in front ofd trying to normalize sexual behavior to
, a child.

61. In the movie theater in New Mexico, Epstein caressed and petted various parts of
body against her will. was incredibly scared, and did not know how to escape because she
was a child alone with Epstein and Maxwell. did not have a phone or any other means of
communication without Epstein or Maxwell knowing.

62. Epstein, Maxwell, and returned to Epstein's ranch. Upon returning from the
movie, Maxwell repeatedly told that she wanted to give her a massage. was very
uncomfortable with the idea of Maxwell touching her, but realized that she was completely alone
with Epstein and Maxwell. feared what would happen if she did not comply with their
demands. said that she had never had a massage and tried to avoid having Maxwell touch
her body, but Maxwell continued to pressure her. Maxwell directed to take off all of her
clothes and lay on the massage table. was extremely scared to be naked in front of
Epstein and Maxwell.

63. Maxwell left the door open so that Epstein could view naked body during the
massage.
64. Maxwell touched intimate parts of body against her will for the sexual benefit of
Maxwell and Epstein.

65. Maxwell exposed breasts and groped her.
13
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 14 of 19

66. was extremely distressed and afraid. She was a child in a massive ranch in New
Mexico, away from her family in Arizona, and isolated from any source of help. She was alone
with Epstein and Maxwell. She had no way to access a phone or other method of
communication without Epstein or Maxwell knowing. She had no way of leaving.

67. woke up the next morning to find Epstein entering her room. He climbed into the
bed with her and announced, "I want to cuddle." Without her consent, Epstein got into the bed
with =, physically restrained her with his arms and proceeded to press his body (including
his genitals) against was frozen in fear. She was sixteen years old.

68. knew she had no way of escaping Epstein's massive estate, and attempted to
escape by saying she needed to use the restroom. She was in shock, and frightened by what she
was experiencing. She feared for her safety, knowing she was alone in Epstein's ranch in
another state and that Maxwell and Epstein were closely monitoring her activity.

69. escaped to Epstein's bathroom. She was in extreme fear and emotional distress,
not knowing how to escape Epstein's ranch in New Mexico, where these two adults were
groping her, a child, against her will.

70. Epstein and Maxwell eventually allowed to fly back home to Arizona and they
returned to New York. Out of fear of what could happen to her and her family because of
Epstein and Maxwell's great power, wealth, and connections that they had displayed to her,
did not tell anyone about Epstein and Maxwell touching her against her will.

71. Devastatingly, was not the only family member that Epstein and Maxwell
sexually abused. During that summer, was lured into an "artist in residence" position by
Epstein at billionaire Les Wexner's Ohio estate on which Epstein owned a guest house. There,
Epstein and Maxwell both sexually assaulted . Wexner's security personnel did not allow
14
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 15 of 19
to exit his estate, even after she pleaded with them and told them about her assault. There
was only one entrance with a guard house to Wexner's estate.

72. After sexual assault in Ohio, Maxwell called on behalf of Epstein and threatened
in order to keep her quiet: "We're going to burn all your art. And I just want you to know
that anything you ever make will be burned. Your career is burned."

73. Instead of letting Maxwell's words silence her, reported her assault to the Sixth
Precinct of the New York City Police Department ("NYPD"). The NYPD referred to the
Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI"). followed the instruction and called the FBI to
make a report of the abuse. To the extreme detriment of and II. —and also countless
other victims who came after them—authorities ignored reporting efforts and took no
action.

74. also called = who was overseas studying at an educational seminar for high
performing high school students. During the call, shared with her own assaults in
New York and New Mexico, as well as her false imprisonment at Epstein's New Mexico ranch.

75. Frustrated that authorities did not appear to be taking any action and in the hopes of
exposing the crimes that Maxwell and Epstein were committing, and decided to
share their stories with Vanity Fair magazine. Tragically for and =, Epstein threatened
and intimidated the magazine and Vanity Fair bent to those threats and ultimately published a
profile of Epstein without mentioning the sisters or their allegations.

76. Once Maxwell and Epstein learned that had revealed the abuse to Vanity Fair, they
embarked on a campaign to destroy reputation and art career. Afraid for her safety,
having informed the NYPD, FBI, and media to no avail, left New York and moved
15
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 16 of 19
to Alaska. and fear of Epstein's power was exacerbated by the fact that state and
federal authorities, as well as the media, were not taking action against Epstein.

77. was deeply affected by her harrowing experiences at the hands of Epstein and
Maxwell as a child. She suffers severe emotional distress from an experience that has affected
her for her entire life.

78. The Defendants' sexual assault, battery, and false imprisonment of continue to
cause her significant distress and harm.
FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
(Battery)

79. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges the allegations stated above in paragraphs 1-78 as if fully
set forth herein.

80. Epstein and Maxwell intentionally committed battery by sexually assaulting Plaintiff
when she was a young girl. As described above, on multiple occasions Epstein and Maxwell
intentionally touched Plaintiff in an offensive and sexual manner without her consent.

81. Epstein and Maxwell's actions constitute sexual offenses as defined in New York Penal
Law Article 130, including but not limited to forcible touching as defined in Article 130.52,
inasmuch as Epstein and Maxwell intentionally and forcibly touched sexual and intimate parts of
Plaintiff's body for their own sexual gratification on multiple occasions. See N.Y. C.P.L.R.
§ 214-g.

82. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking enterprise from
which Plaintiff's first cause of action arises was terminated on August 29, 2019, less than one
year prior to the filing of this Complaint. See N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a).
16
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 17 of 19

83. As a direct and proximate result of Epstein's and Maxwell's criminal acts, Plaintiff has in
the past and will in the future continue to suffer extreme emotional distress, humiliation, fear,
psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self-esteem, and invasion of her privacy.
SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION
(False Imprisonment)

84. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges the allegations stated above in paragraphs 1-78 as if fully
set forth herein.

85. As a direct result of these allegations as stated, Defendants falsely imprisoned Plaintiff at
Epstein's New Mexico residence while Plaintiff was a young girl for the purpose of degrading
her, abusing her, or gratifying their sexual desires.

86. Epstein and Maxwell brought Plaintiff to Epstein's New Mexico Ranch with the intent to
confine her in that location so that they could sexually abuse her. Plaintiff was conscious of her
confinement and did not consent that confinement. Epstein and Maxwell prevented Plaintiff, a
child with no way to communicate with anyone other than Epstein and Maxwell and with no
access to a car or other means of transportation, from leaving the premises, Epstein's remote
10,000 acre Zorro Ranch in New Mexico.

87. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking enterprise from
which Plaintiff's second cause of action arises was terminated on August 29, 2019, less than one
year prior to the filing of this Complaint. See N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a).

88. As a direct and proximate result of Epstein and Maxwell's criminal acts, Plaintiff has in
the past and will in the future continue to suffer extreme emotional distress, humiliation, fear,
psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self-esteem, and invasion of her privacy.
17
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 18 of 19
THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION
(Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress)

89. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges the allegations stated above in paragraphs 1-78 as if fully
set forth herein.

90. As a direct result of these allegations as stated, Defendants committed intentional
infliction of emotional distress against Plaintiff

91. Defendants' actions, described above, constitute extreme and outrageous conduct that
shocks the conscience. Epstein and Maxwell's plan to recruit, entice, and assault Plaintiff, a
sixteen-year-old child, on multiple occasions, goes beyond all possible bounds of decency and is
intolerable in a civilized community.

92. Defendants knew or disregarded the substantial likelihood that these actions would cause
Plaintiff severe emotional distress.

93. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking enterprise from
which Plaintiff's third cause of action arises was terminated on August 29,2019, less than one
year prior to the filing of this Complaint. See N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a).

94. As a direct and proximate result of Epstein and Maxwell's criminal acts, Plaintiff has in
the past and will in the future continue to suffer extreme emotional distress, humiliation, fear,
psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self-esteem, and invasion of her privacy.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests judgment against Defendants, awarding
compensatory, consequential, exemplary, and punitive damages in an amount to be determined at
trial; costs of suit; attorneys' fees; and such other and further relief as the Court may deem just
and proper.
18
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 19 of 19
JURY DEMAND
Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury on all causes of action asserted within this
pleading.
Dated: November 12, 2019.
Is/ Joshua I. Schiller
David Boies
Bows $CHILLER FLEXNER LLP
Joshua I. Schiller
BNB $CHILLER FLEXNER LLP
Sigrid McCawley
(Pro Hac Vice Pending)
BOLES $CHILLER FLEXNER LLP
19
EFTA00105975 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of <REDACTED> v. Estate of Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell "was relentless"
(inferred date: 2026-01-19)
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Plaintiff, CASE NO:
v.
DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN,
in their capacities as the executors of the
ESTATE OF JEFFREY EDWARD EPSTEIN, and
GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
Defendants.
COMPLAINT
BOIES $CHILLER FLEXNER LLP
1
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 19
Plaintiff by her attorneys Boies Schiller Flexner LLP, for her Complaint
against Defendants, Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn in their capacities as the executors of
the Estate of Jeffrey Edward Epstein ("Epstein") and Ghislaine Maxwell ("Maxwell")
(collectively, "Defendants"), avers upon personal knowledge as to her own acts and status and
upon information and belief and to all other matters as follows:
NATURE OF THE ACTION

I. This suit arises out of Defendants' sexual abuse of Plaintiff beginning when Plaintiff was
16 years old.

2. When Plaintiff was 16, she was sexually trafficked by Defendants as part of Epstein and
Maxwell's organized ring of procuring young women and girls for sex.

3. Epstein's trafficking scheme involved recruiting young women and girls by making false
promises and using his wealth, power and threats to intimidate the females into submission to his
demands. This same pattern was repeated numerous times with numerous young women and
girls.

4. As United States District Judge Kenneth Marra found, "From between about 1999 and
2007, Jeffrey Epstein sexually abused more than 30 minor girls . . . at his mansion in Palm
Beach, Florida, and elsewhere in the United States and overseas. . . . In addition to his own
sexual abuse of the victims, Epstein directed other persons to abuse the girls sexually. Epstein
used paid employees to find and bring minor girls to him. Epstein worked in concert with others
to obtain minors not only for his own sexual gratification, but also for the sexual gratification of
others." Doe 1 v. United States, 359 F. Supp. 3d 1201, 1204 (S.D. Fla. 2019) (internal citations
omitted).
2
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 19

5. Epstein organized this sex trafficking network to obtain hundreds of young girls for
himself for sex, and also lent these girls out to other powerful and wealthy individuals to be
sexually abused.

6. Despite his significant criminal activity, in 2008 Epstein received a shockingly minimal
charge pleading guilty to a single Florida state law charge of procuring a minor for prostitution
and a non-prosecution agreement (a "NPA") with the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of
Florida. Unknown to the public and the victims at the time, Epstein's lawyers were pressuring
the Government to commit to the NPA without informing the victims. Epstein's multiple
victims were kept in the dark and told to be "patient" while Epstein's lawyers worked to protect
him and other potential co-conspirators from prosecution. Epstein served one year in jail, but
was afforded the privilege of being able to leave the jail to go to work for twelve hours per day,
six days per week.

7. The NPA allowed Epstein to escape proportionate punishment for his actions and to
continue operating his sex trafficking enterprise with liberty.

8. A few years later, Epstein flippantly referred to his sexual abuse of multiple young
women and girls, and the slap on the wrist he had received for it, in a 2011 interview with the
New York Post: "Billionaire pervert Jeffrey Epstein is back in New York City — and making
wisecracks about his just-ended jail stint for having sex with an underage girl. 'I am not a sexual
predator, I'm an offender,' the financier told The Post yesterday. `It's the difference between a
murderer and a person who steals a bagel,' said Epstein." Amber Sutherland, Billionaire Jeffrey
Epstein: I'm a Sex Offender Not a Predator, N.Y. Post (Feb. 25, 2011),
https://nypost.com/2011/02/25/billionaire-jeffrey-epstein-im-a-sex-offender-not-a-predatort
3
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 19

9. In August 2018, just one year before his death, Epstein told a New York Times reporter
"that criminalizing sex with teenage girls was a cultural aberration and that at times in history it
was perfectly acceptable." James B. Stewart, The Day Jeffrey Epstein Told Me He Had Dirt on
Powerful People, N.Y. Times (Aug. 12, 2019),
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/12/business/jeffity-epstein-interview.html.

10. Maxwell spent years overseeing and managing Epstein's sex trafficking network, and
actively recruited underage girls to provide to Epstein and others for sex.

11. Epstein and Maxwell conspired with friends and hired staff to maintain and keep secret
this network of sexual abuse for years, which sprawled throughout Epstein's residences in New
York, Florida, New Mexico, the United States Virgin Islands, and Paris. Epstein's preference
was to have three different girls a day for his sexual pleasure and Maxwell was in charge of
recruiting the girls.

12. Maxwell facilitated Epstein's sexual trafficking ring by activities including, but not
limited to: (1) identifying and recruiting girls, including several minors, for Epstein's sexual
pleasure and that of his co-conspirators, including herself; (2) identifying and hiring individuals
to recruit underage girls; (3) scheduling appointments between the trafficked girls, many of
whom were minors, and Epstein; (4) administering Epstein's sex trafficking organization and
hiding it from criminal repercussions; and (5) intimidating girls, many of whom were minors,
who attempted to escape or report Epstein's sex trafficking operation.

13. Epstein and Maxwell committed sexual assault and battery upon Plaintiff when she was
16 years old. As such, the Defendants are responsible for battery, unlawful imprisonment, and
intentional infliction of emotional distress pursuant to New York common law. The damage to
Plaintiff has been severe and lasting.
4
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 19

14. This action has been timely filed pursuant to the Child Victims Act, N.Y. C.P.L.R.
§ 214-g. The actions described herein constitute sexual offenses by Defendants under New York
Penal Law Article 130, and were committed against Plaintiff when she was a child less than
eighteen years of age, for which she suffered physical, psychological, and other injuries as a
result.

15. This action has been timely filed pursuant to N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a), which provides
that a plaintiff shall have at least one year from the termination of a criminal action against the
same defendant to commence an action with respect to the event or occurrence from which the
criminal action arose. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking
enterprise from which Plaintiff's claims arise was terminated on August 29, 2019.

16. Any statute of limitations applicable to Plaintiff's claims, if any, is tolled due to the
continuous and active deception, duress, threats of retaliation, and other forms of misconduct that
Defendants used to silence their many victims, including Plaintiff. Defendants' actions deprived
Plaintiff of the opportunity to commence this lawsuit before Epstein's death. Until his death,
Plaintiff feared that Epstein and his co-conspirators, including Maxwell, would harm her or her
family, or ruin her life, if she came forward.

17. Defendants are equitably estopped from asserting a statute of limitations defense.
Allowing Defendants to do so would be unjust. Defendants intimidated each of their victims into
silence by threatening their lives and their livelihoods. They therefore prevented Plaintiff from
commencing this lawsuit before Epstein's death. By using threats, along with his wealth and
power, Epstein was able to escape punishment for his intolerable and brutal crimes against
countless young women and underage girls for the duration of his life.
5
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 6 of 19
PARTIES

18. Plaintiff is a citizen and resident of
19. Defendant Darren K. Indyke is sued in his capacity as an appointed executor of the Estate
of Jeffrey E. Epstein.

20. Defendant Richard D. Kahn is sued in his capacity as an appointed executor of the Estate
of Jeffrey E. Epstein.

21. Defendant Ghislaine Maxwell is a New York citizen and is domiciled in the Southern
District of New York.
JURISDICTION AND VENUE

22. Jeffrey Epstein was a citizen of the United States domiciled in the U.S. Virgin Islands at
the time of his death. Jeffrey Epstein maintained a residence in the Southern District of New
York. As the legal representatives of the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein, Darren K. Indyke and
Richard D. Kahn are deemed citizens of the U.S. Virgin Islands.

23. Defendant Maxwell is a citizen of both the United States and the United Kingdom and is
domiciled in the Southern District of New York.

24. The amount in controversy in this action exceeds the sum or value of $75,000.00
excluding interests and costs and is between citizens of different states. Accordingly, jurisdiction
is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1332.

25. Venue is proper in this Court as the sexual abuse of Plaintiff by Defendants Epstein and
Maxwell began and occurred in New York, New York, where they recruited her at the age of 16,
physically molested her, and began grooming her for sex in their organized sex trafficking ring.
6
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 7 of 19

26. Many of the events giving rise to these causes of action occurred in the Southern District
of New York, where a substantial amount of Epstein's property is located. Thus, venue in this
district is proper. 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(2).
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS

A. Epstein's Sex Trafficking Enterprise
27. Jeffrey Epstein was widely renowned as a billionaire who used his vast connections to
powerful individuals, and seemingly unlimited wealth and resources, to create a web of
transcontinental sex trafficking that served himself, his coconspirators, and some of the most
powerful people in the world.

28. Epstein owned multiple residences and frequently travelled between them, including at 9
East 71' Street, New York, New York 10021, and at 49 Zorro Ranch Road, Stanley, New
Mexico 87056, where the illegal sexual crimes against Plaintiff occurred. Epstein conservatively
valued his New York townhome at $55,931,000.00. Epstein conservatively valued his New
Mexico ranch at $17,246,208.00. In addition, Epstein owned residences in the Virgin Islands,
Florida, France, and even on his own island, Great St. James Island, where his transcontinental
sex trafficking of hundreds of young girls servicing him, his co-conspirators, and wealthy and
powerful individuals around the world occurred.

29. The allegations herein concern Epstein's and Maxwell's tortious acts against Plaintiff
while in New York, where Epstein was staying at his 71' Street mansion, and at his ranch in
New Mexico.

30. At all times material to this cause of action, Jeffrey Epstein utilized his seemingly
unlimited power, wealth, and resources, as well as his deep connections to powerful and
politically connected individuals to intimidate and manipulate his victims of sexual abuse.
7
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 8 of 19

31. Epstein and Maxwell had perfected a scheme for manipulation and abuse of young
females. As part of the scheme, Maxwell or another female would approach a young female and
strike up a conversation in an effort to quickly learn about the young female's background and
any vulnerabilities they could expose. Maxwell would then manipulate the young female into
coming back to one of Epstein's residences by offering the young female something she needed.
At times Maxwell's lure would be a modeling opportunity, money for education, help for the
young female's family, and a whole host of other related offers depending on their target's
situation. Once in the residence, Maxwell and Epstein would work in concert to impress and
intimidate the young female with displays of vast wealth, including having employees that were
butlers and maids formally dressed around the house. They would also strategically place
photographs of very powerful political and social figures amongst photographs and art displaying
nude females in an effort to normalize the sexual abuse. They would also normalize the sexual
abuse by placing a massage table and spa related products around the massage area in an effort to
legitimize the area where the abuse was set to occur. Once abused, Epstein and Maxwell
continued to manipulate the victims, using their financial power, promises, and threats to ensure
that the victim returned as directed and remained compliant with their demands.

B. The Arrest, Prosecution, and Death of Epstein
32. The sexual trafficking ring described herein started at least as early as 1995 and
continued up until at least July 2, 2019, when the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of New York ("SDNY") charged Epstein with sex trafficking conspiracy and sex trafficking in
violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591. He was arrested on July 8, 2019, pursuant to the SDNY's Sealed
Two Count Indictment, which is attached as Exhibit A.
8
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 9 of 19

33. The Indictment described Epstein's conduct and his abuse and trafficking of females in
the same trafficking operation he used to abuse and traffic Plaintiff.

34. Epstein's last will and testament (the "Will") was executed on August 8, 2019, at the
Metropolitan Correctional Center. The witnesses were Martel Colon Miro and Gulnora Tali. The
Will included affidavits from Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn, in which they swear an
"Oath of Willingness to Serve as Executor and Appointment of Local Counsel."

35. Epstein was found dead in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center on August 10,
2019.
36. Epstein's last will and testament was filed on August 15, 2019, in the Probate Division of
the Superior Court of the Virgin Islands.

37. Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn filed a Certificate of Trust in the Superior Court
of the Virgin Islands for Epstein's 1953 Trust on August 26, 2019. See Certificate of Trust, In
the Matter of the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein, Probate No. ST-19-PB-80 (Super. Ct. V.I. Aug. 26,
2019).

38. Epstein's will was entered into probate on September 6, 2019, and the Superior Court of
the Virgin Islands accordingly authorized Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn to administer
Epstein's estate. See Order for Probate, In the Matter of the Estate opeey E. Epstein, Probate

No. ST-19-PB-80 (Super. Ct. V.I. Sept. 6, 2019); Letters Testamentary, In the Matter of the
Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein, Probate No. ST-19-PB-80 (Super. Ct. V.I. Sept. 6, 2019).

39. The Will's first article directs Epstein's executors "to pay from my estate all expenses of
my last illness, my funeral and burial expenses, the administration expenses of my estate and all
of my debts duly proven and allowed against my estate." The Will further directs that "after the
9
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 10 of 19
payments and distributions provided in Article FIRST," Epstein "give[s] all of my property, real
and personal, wherever situated ... to the then acting Trustees of The 1953 Trust."

40. Following Epstein's death, SDNY submitted a proposed nolle prosequi order in the
criminal matter against him because it was required by law to do so after Epstein was deceased.
On August 29, 2019, U.S. District Judge Richard Berman formally dismissed SDNY's
indictment against Epstein, terminating the criminal action against him.
C.

41. was born on Ms parents divorced when she was
young, and her mother struggled financially to support and her siblings.

42. In was a high school student at
She was a top performing student with the goal of going to college.
43. In approximately
in
was an artist and a graduate student
in New York. She met Epstein and Maxwell at an art show. Epstein noticed her artwork.
Epstein offered to help her in her art career if she sold Epstein some of her artwork.

44. Epstein asked if she had a father. He also asked her personal questions about her
family situation, including about her younger sister explained that her parents
were divorced, and that she and her family were financially struggling.

45. accepted a job offer from Epstein to purchase art for him.
46. Her role later included keeping records of people who entered Epstein's New York
mansion. =observed that Defendant Maxwell was regularly bringing over school -aged girls
to the New York mansion. Maxwell told that these girls were interviewing for Victoria's
Secret modeling positions.
10
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 11 of 19

47. Maxwell described her role to as recruiting Victoria's Secret models for Epstein.
witnessed Maxwell spotting girls and talking to them outside of the mansion, which
Maxwell claimed was for recruiting purposes. Maxwell would leave the mansion claiming she
had "to go get girls for Jeffrey."

48. At the time,nras unaware of the sex trafficking conspiracy and believed the girls
were being recruited for modeling positions.

49. understood her older sister. to be working for a billionaire in New York.
50. Epstein began taking an interest in
sister in
was very proud of
He asked questions about her younger
He presented this interest to in a friendly and fatherly manner.
strong academic record, and supported goal of going to a
good college after high school.

51. Epstein offered ideas on how he could help get into college. He used this as
a ruse to get _to come to New York so that he could abuse her. Epstein purchased
plane tickets, and she flew to New York.

52. Epstein gave money to buy-a dress. He paid for a limousine to pick up the
sisters and take them to Epstein's townhome. He talked to about going to college and
potential schools before sending them to see a Broadway show.

53. During stay in New York, Epstein asked to go to the movie
theater with him. This is where he began initiating non-consensual physical contact with
in an attempt to groom for sexual activity and normalize sexual behavior with him.

54. At the movie, Epstein intentionally positioned himself between the sisters to ensure they
were separated, and to prevent from seeing that he was touching Epstein began
caressing and petting on various parts of her body against her will. He would repeatedly
11
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 12 of 19
touch only when was unaware and looking away. was distressed, frightened,
and confused.

55. then left to go back home to
56. Epstein began calling and her mother from New York under the false pretense of
discussing education and plans for college. He offered to send on an international
trip to help with her college applications.

57. As part of his plan to recruit for sexual purposes, Epstein explained to
mother that he sponsored educational trips for high school students, and was sponsoring an event
in New Mexico at his ranch called Zorro Ranch. He invited He explained that Maxwell
would be a host or chaperone fort the event. Under these false pretenses,
mother agreed to send to Epstein's program for high school students.

58. Epstein and Maxwell, who were in New York at the time, arranged and paid forMito
fly to New Mexico in the spring of 1996. Epstein mailed her airline tickets from New York to
her mother in Arizona. When  arrived in New Mexico, Epstein had a driver take her to his
ranch. Epstein's Zorro Ranch sits on over 10,000 acres and is very remote. Upon arriving at the
ranch, learned that Epstein had not invited any other students. She was the only person at
the massive ranch in a different state, away from her family in her sister in
and anyone she knew. She was alone with Maxwell and Epstein.

59. Maxwell appeared charming and friendly to Upon arriving, Maxwell and Epstein
took shopping and lavished her with gifts, including beauty products and a pair of brand
new cowboy boots. After returning to the ranch, Maxwell began pressuring to touch
Epstein and give him a foot massage. =was very scared and did not want to touch Epstein,
but Maxwell was relentless and demanded tha massage Epstein. Both adults explained to
12
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 13 of 19
that it was just a massage, and attempted to normalize this sexual behavior with an adult to
her.

60. Epstein and Maxwell took to a movie theater. While in line for the movie,
Maxwell pulled down Epstein's sweatpants, exposing part of his buttocks. Both Epstein and
Maxwell repeatedly fondled each other in front of= trying to normalize sexual behavior to
a child.

61. In the movie theater in New Mexico, Epstein caressed and petted various parts of
body against her will. was incredibly scared, and did not know how to escape because she
was a child alone with Epstein and Maxwell. did not have a phone or any other means of
communication without Epstein or Maxwell knowing.

62. Epstein, Maxwell, and returned to Epstein's ranch. Upon returning from the
movie, Maxwell repeatedly told that she wanted to give her a massage. was very
uncomfortable with the idea of Maxwell touching her, but realized that she was completely alone
with Epstein and Maxwell. =feared what would happen if she did not comply with their
demands. said that she had never had a massage and tried to avoid having Maxwell touch
her body, but Maxwell continued to pressure her. Maxwell directed to take off all of her
clothes and lay on the massage table. was extremely scared to be naked in front of
Epstein and Maxwell.

63. Maxwell left the door open so that Epstein could view naked hod). during the
massage.
64. Maxwell touched intimate parts of body against her will for the sexual benefit of
Maxwell and Epstein.

65. Maxwell exposed breasts and groped her.
13
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 14 of 19

66. was extremely distressed and afraid. She was a child in a massive ranch in New
Mexico, away from her family in and isolated from any source of help. She was alone
with Epstein and Maxwell. She had no way to access a phone or other method of
communication without Epstein or Maxwell knowing. She had no way of leaving.

67. woke up the next morning to find Epstein entering her room. He climbed into the
bed with her and announced, "I want to cuddle." Without her consent, Epstein got into the bed
with physically restrained her with his arms and proceeded to press his body (including
his genitals) against Iwas frozen in fear. She was sixteen years old.

68. knew she had no way of escaping Epstein's massive estate, and attempted to
escape by saying she needed to use the restroom. She was in shock, and frightened by what she
was experiencing. She feared for her safety, knowing she was alone in Epstein's ranch in
another state and that Maxwell and Epstein were closely monitoring her activity.

69. escaped to Epstein's bathroom. She was in extreme fear and emotional distress,
not knowing how to escape Epstein's ranch in New Mexico, where these two adults were
groping her, a child, against her will.

70. Epstein and Maxwell eventually allowed and they
returned to New York. Out of fear of what could happen to her and her family because of
Epstein and Maxwell's great power, wealth, and connections that they had displayed to her,
S id not tell anyone about Epstein and Maxwell touching her against her will.

71. Devastatingly, was not the only hat Epstein and Maxwell
sexually abused. During that summer, was lured into an "artist in residence" position by
Epstein at billionaire Les Wexner's Ohio estate on which Epstein owned a guest house. There,
Epstein and Maxwell both sexually assaulted Wexner's security personnel did not allow
14
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 15 of 19
M o exit his estate, even after she pleaded with them and told them about her assault. There
was only one entrance with a guard house to Wexner's estate.

72. After=sexual assault in Ohio, Maxwell called on behalf of Epstein and threatened
in order to keep her quiet: "We're going to burn all your art. And I just want you to know
that anything you ever make will be burned. Your career is burned."

73. Instead of letting Maxwell's words silence her, reported her assault to the Sixth
Precinct of the New York City Police Department ("NYPD"). The NYPD referred to the
Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI"). followed the instruction and called the FBI to
make a report of the abuse. To the extreme detriment of
other victims who came after them—authorities ignored
action.
74.
—and also countless
reporting efforts and took no
who was overseas studying at an educational seminar for high
performing high school students. During the call her own assaults in
New York and New Mexico, as well as her false imprisonment at Epstein's New Mexico ranch.

75. Frustrated that authorities did not appear to be taking any action and in the hopes of
exposing the crimes that Maxwell and Epstein were committing, decided to
share their stories with Vanity Fair magazine. Tragically for Epstein threatened
and intimidated the magazine and Vanity Fair bent to those threats and ultimately published a
profile of Epstein without mentioning the sisters or their allegations.

76. Once Maxwell and Epstein learned thatMlhad revealed the abuse to Vanity Fair, they
embarked on a campaign to destroy reputation and art career. Afraid for her safety,
having informed the NYPD, FBI, and media to no avail,
15
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 16 of 19
to Alaska. fear of Epstein's power was exacerbated by the fact that state and
federal authorities, as well as the media, were not taking action against Epstein.

77. .vas deeply affected by her harrowing experiences at the hands of Epstein and
Maxwell as a child. She suffers severe emotional distress from an experience that has affected
her for her entire life.

78. The Defendants' sexual assault, battery, and false imprisonment of continue to
cause her significant distress and harm.
FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
(Battery)

79. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges the allegations stated above in paragraphs 1-78 as if fully
set forth herein.

80. Epstein and Maxwell intentionally committed battery by sexually assaulting Plaintiff
when she was a young girl. As described above, on multiple occasions Epstein and Maxwell
intentionally touched Plaintiff in an offensive and sexual manner without her consent.

81. Epstein and Maxwell's actions constitute sexual offenses as defined in New York Penal
Law Article 130, including but not limited to forcible touching as defined in Article 130.52,
inasmuch as Epstein and Maxwell intentionally and forcibly touched sexual and intimate parts of
Plaintiff's body for their own sexual gratification on multiple occasions. See N.Y. C.P.L.R.
§ 214-g.

82. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking enterprise from
which Plaintiff's first cause of action arises was terminated on August 29, 2019, less than one
year prior to the filing of this Complaint. See N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a).
16
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 17 of 19

83. As a direct and proximate result of Epstein's and Maxwell's criminal acts, Plaintiff has in
the past and will in the future continue to suffer extreme emotional distress, humiliation, fear,
psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self-esteem, and invasion of her privacy.
SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION
(False Imprisonment)

84. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges the allegations stated above in paragraphs 1-78 as if fully
set forth herein.

85. As a direct result of these allegations as stated, Defendants falsely imprisoned Plaintiff at
Epstein's New Mexico residence while Plaintiff was a young girl for the purpose of degrading
her, abusing her, or gratifying their sexual desires.

86. Epstein and Maxwell brought Plaintiff to Epstein's New Mexico Ranch with the intent to
confine her in that location so that they could sexually abuse her. Plaintiff was conscious of her
confinement and did not consent that confinement. Epstein and Maxwell prevented Plaintiff, a
child with no way to communicate with anyone other than Epstein and Maxwell and with no
access to a car or other means of transportation, from leaving the premises, Epstein's remote
10,000 acre Zorro Ranch in New Mexico.

87. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking enterprise from
which Plaintiff's second cause of action arises was terminated on August 29, 2019, less than one
year prior to the filing of this Complaint. See N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a).

88. As a direct and proximate result of Epstein and Maxwell's criminal acts, Plaintiff has in
the past and will in the future continue to suffer extreme emotional distress, humiliation, fear,
psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self-esteem, and invasion of her privacy.
17
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 18 of 19
THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION
(Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress)

89. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges the allegations stated above in paragraphs 1-78 as if fully
set forth herein.

90. As a direct result of these allegations as stated, Defendants committed intentional
infliction of emotional distress against Plaintiff

91. Defendants' actions, described above, constitute extreme and outrageous conduct that
shocks the conscience. Epstein and Maxwell's plan to recruit, entice, and assault Plaintiff, a
sixteen-year-old child, on multiple occasions, goes beyond all possible bounds of decency and is
intolerable in a civilized community.

92. Defendants knew or disregarded the substantial likelihood that these actions would cause
Plaintiff severe emotional distress.

93. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking enterprise from
which Plaintiff's third cause of action arises was terminated on August 29,2019, less than one
year prior to the filing of this Complaint. See N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a).

94. As a direct and proximate result of Epstein and Maxwell's criminal acts, Plaintiff has in
the past and will in the future continue to suffer extreme emotional distress, humiliation, fear,
psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self-esteem, and invasion of her privacy.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests judgment against Defendants, awarding
compensatory, consequential, exemplary, and punitive damages in an amount to be determined at
trial; costs of suit; attorneys' fees; and such other and further relief as the Court may deem just
and proper.
18
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 19 of 19
JURY DEMAND
Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury on all causes of action asserted within this
pleading.
Dated: November 12, 2019.
Is/Joshua I. Schiller
David Boies
BOIES $CHILLER FLEXNER LLP
333 Main Street
Armonk, NY 10504

(914) 749-8200
Joshua I. Schiller
BOIES $CHILLER FLEXNER LLP
55 Hudson Yards
New York, NY 10001
(212) 446-2300
Sigrid McCawley
(Pro Hac Vice Pending)
BOIES $CHILLER FLEXNER LLP
401 E. Las Olas Blvd., Suite 1200
Ft. Lauderdale, FL 33301
(954) 356-0011
19
EFTA00158752 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of <REDACTED> v. Estate of Jeffrey Epstein, Ghislaine Maxwell Ghislaine Maxwell "was relentless"
(inferred date: 2026-01-19)
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 1 of 19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Plaintiff CASE NO:
v.
DARREN K. INDYKE and RICHARD D. KAHN, i
in their capacities as the executors of the
ESTATE OF JEFFREY EDWARD EPSTEIN, and
GHISLAINE MAXWELL,
Defendants.
COMPLAINT
3514.011
Page 1 of 19
EFFA_00007677
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 2 of 19
Plaintiff, by her attorneys for her Complaint
against Defendants, Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn in their capacities as the executors of
the Estate of Jeffrey Edward Epstein ("Epstein") and Ghislaine Maxwell ("Maxwell")
(collectively, "Defendants"), avers upon personal knowledge as to her own acts and status and
upon information and belief and to all other matters as follows:
NATURE OF THE ACTION

1. This suit arises out of Defendants' sexual abuse of Plaintiff beginning when Plaintiff was
16 years old.

2. When Plaintiff was 16, she was sexually trafficked by Defendants as part of Epstein and
Maxwell's organized ring of procuring young women and girls for sex.

3. Epstein's trafficking scheme involved recruiting young women and girls by making false
promises and using his wealth, power and threats to intimidate the females into submission to his
demands. This same pattern was repeated numerous times with numerous young women and
girls.

4. As United States District Judge Kenneth Marra found, "From between about 1999 and
2007, Jeffrey Epstein sexually abused more than 30 minor girls . .. at his mansion in Palm
Beach, Florida, and elsewhere in the United States and overseas.... In addition to his own
sexual abuse of the victims, Epstein directed other persons to abuse the girls sexually. Epstein
used paid employees to find and bring minor girls to him. Epstein worked in concert with others
to obtain minors not only for his own sexual gratification, but also for the sexual gratification of
others." Doe 1 v. United States, 359 F. Supp. 3d 1201, 1204 (S.D. Fla. 2019) (internal citations
omitted).
3514.011
Page 2 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 3 of 19

5. Epstein organized this sex trafficking network to obtain hundreds of young girls for
himself for sex, and also lent these girls out to other powerful and wealthy individuals to be
sexually abused.

6. Despite his significant criminal activity, in 2008 Epstein received a shockingly minimal
charge pleading guilty to a single Florida state law charge of procuring a minor for prostitution
and a non-prosecution agreement (a "NPA") with the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of
Florida. Unknown to the public and the victims at the time, Epstein's lawyers were pressuring
the Government to commit to the NPA without informing the victims. Epstein's multiple
victims were kept in the dark and told to be "patient" while Epstein's lawyers worked to protect
him and other potential co-conspirators from prosecution. Epstein served one year in jail, but
was afforded the privilege of being able to leave the jail to go to work for twelve hours per day,
six days per week.

7. The NPA allowed Epstein to escape proportionate punishment for his actions and to
continue operating his sex trafficking enterprise with liberty.

8. A few years later, Epstein flippantly referred to his sexual abuse of multiple young
women and girls, and the slap on the wrist he had received for it, in a 2011 interview with the
New York Post: "Billionaire pervert Jeffrey Epstein is back in New York City — and making
wisecracks about his just-ended jail stint for having sex with an underage girl. `I am not a sexual
predator, I'm an offender,' the financier told The Post yesterday. it's the difference between a
murderer and a person who steals a bagel,' said Epstein." Amber Sutherland, Billionaire Jeffrey
Epstein: I'm a Sex Offender Not a Predator, N.Y. Post (Feb. 25, 2011),
https://nypost.cont/2011/02/25/billionaire-jeffrey-cpstein-im-a-sex-offender-not-a-predatort
3
3514.011
Page 3 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 4 of 19

9. In August 2018, just one year before his death, Epstein told a New York Times reporter
"that criminalizing sex with teenage girls was a cultural aberration and that at times in history it
was perfectly acceptable." James B. Stewart, The Day Jefrey Epstein Told Me He Had Dirt on
Powerful People, N.Y. Times (Aug. 12, 2019),
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/ 2/businessijeffrey-cpstein-interview.html.

10. Maxwell spent years overseeing and managing Epstein's sex trafficking network, and
actively recruited underage girls to provide to Epstein and others for sex.

11. Epstein and Maxwell conspired with friends and hired staff to maintain and keep secret
this network of sexual abuse for years, which sprawled throughout Epstein's residences in New
York, Florida, New Mexico, the United States Virgin Islands, and Paris. Epstein's preference
was to have three different girls a day for his sexual pleasure and Maxwell was in charge of
recruiting the girls.

12. Maxwell facilitated Epstein's sexual trafficking ring by activities including, but not
limited to: (I) identifying and recruiting girls, including several minors, for Epstein's sexual
pleasure and that of his co-conspirators, including herself; (2) identifying and hiring individuals
to recruit underage girls; (3) scheduling appointments between the trafficked girls, many of
whom were minors, and Epstein; (4) administering Epstein's sex trafficking organization and
hiding it from criminal repercussions; and (5) intimidating girls, many of whom were minors,
who attempted to escape or report Epstein's sex trafficking operation.

13. Epstein and Maxwell committed sexual assault and battery upon Plaintiff when she was
16 years old. As such, the Defendants arc responsible for battery, unlawful imprisonment, and
intentional infliction of emotional distress pursuant to New York common law. The damage to
Plaintiff has been severe and lasting.
4
3514.011
Page 4 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 5 of 19

14. This action has been timely filed pursuant to the Child Victims Act, N.Y. C.P.L.R.
§ 214-g. The actions described herein constitute sexual offenses by Defendants under Ncw York
Penal Law Article 130, and were committed against Plaintiff when she was a child less than
eighteen years of age, for which she suffered physical, psychological, and other injuries as a
result.

15. This action has been timely filed pursuant to N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8Xa), which provides
that a plaintiff shall have at least one year from the termination of a criminal action against the
same defendant to commence an action with respect to the event or occurrence from which the
criminal action arose. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking
enterprise from which Plaintiff's claims arise was terminated on August 29, 2019.

16. Any statute of limitations applicable to Plaintiff's claims, if any, is tolled due to the
continuous and active deception, duress, threats of retaliation, and other forms of misconduct that
Defendants used to silence their many victims, including Plaintiff. Defendants' actions deprived
Plaintiff of the opportunity to commence this lawsuit before Epstein's death. Until his death,
Plaintiff feared that Epstein and his co-conspirators, including Maxwell, would harm her or her
family, or ruin her life, if she came forward.

17. Defendants arc equitably estopped from asserting a statute of limitations defense.
Allowing Defendants to do so would be unjust. Defendants intimidated each of their victims into
silence by threatening their lives and their livelihoods. They therefore prevented Plaintiff from
commencing this lawsuit before Epstein's death. By using threats, along with his wealth and
power, Epstein was able to escape punishment for his intolerable and brutal crimes against
countless young women and underage girls for the duration of his life.
5
3514.011
Page 5 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 6 of 19
PARTIES

18. Plaintiff is a citizen and resident of
19. Defendant Darren K. Indyke is sued in his capacity as an appointed executor of the Estate
of Jeffrey E. Epstein.

20. Defendant Richard D. Kahn is sued in his capacity as an appointed executor of the Estate
of Jeffrey E. Epstein.

21. Defendant Ghislainc Maxwell is a New York citizen and is domiciled in the Southern
District of New York.
JURISDICTION AND VENUE

22. Jeffrey Epstein was a citizen of the United States domiciled in the U.S. Virgin Islands at
the time of his death. Jeffrey Epstein maintained a residence in the Southern District of New
York. As the legal representatives of the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein, Darren K. Indyke and
Richard D. Kahn arc deemed citizens of the U.S. Virgin Islands.

23. Defendant Maxwell is a citizen of both the United States and the United Kingdom and is
domiciled in the Southern District of New York.

24. The amount in controversy in this action exceeds the sum or value of $75,000.00
excluding interests and costs and is between citizens of different states. Accordingly, jurisdiction
is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1332.

25. Venue is proper in this Court as the sexual abuse of Plaintiff by Defendants Epstein and
Maxwell began and occurred in New York, New York, where they recruited her at the age of 16,
physically molested her, and began grooming her for sex in their organized sex trafficking ring.
6
3514.011
Page 6 of 19
EFFA_00007682
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 7 of 19

26. Many of the events giving rise to these causes of action occurred in the Southern District
of New York, where a substantial amount of Epstein's property is located. Thus, venue in this
district is proper. 28 U.S.C. § 1391(b)(2).
FACTUAL ALLEGATIONS

A. Epstein's Sex Trafficking Enterprise
27. Jeffrey Epstein was widely renowned as a billionaire who used his vast connections to
powerful individuals, and seemingly unlimited wealth and resources, to create a web of
transcontinental sex trafficking that served himself, his coconspirators, and some of the most
powerful people in the world.

28. Epstein owned multiple residences and frequently travelled between them, including at 9
East 7P Street, New York, New York 10021, and at 49 Zorro Ranch Road, Stanley, New
Mexico 87056, where the illegal sexual crimes against Plaintiff occurred. Epstein conservatively
valued his New York townhomc at $55,931,000.00. Epstein conservatively valued his New
Mexico ranch at $17,246,208.00. In addition, Epstein owned residences in the Virgin Islands,
Florida, France, and even on his own island, Great St. James Island, where his transcontinental
sex trafficking of hundreds of young girls servicing him, his co-conspirators, and wealthy and
powerful individuals around the world occurred.

29. The allegations herein concern Epstcin's and Maxwell's tortious acts against Plaintiff
while in New York, where Epstein was staying at his 71' Street mansion, and at his ranch in
New Mexico.

30. At all times material to this cause of action, Jeffrey Epstein utilized his seemingly
unlimited power, wealth, and resources, as well as his deep connections to powerful and
politically connected individuals to intimidate and manipulate his victims of sexual abuse.
7
3514.011
Page 7 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 8 of 19

31. Epstein and Maxwell had perfected a scheme for manipulation and abuse of young
females. As part of the scheme, Maxwell or another female would approach a young female and
strike up a conversation in an effort to quickly learn about the young female's background and
any vulnerabilities they could expose. Maxwell would then manipulate the young female into
coming back to one of Epstein's residences by offering the young female something she needed.
At times Maxwell's lure would be a modeling opportunity, money for education, help for the
young female's family, and a whole host of other related offers depending on their target's
situation. Once in the residence, Maxwell and Epstein would work in concert to impress and
intimidate the young female with displays of vast wealth, including having employees that were
butlers and maids formally dressed around the house. They would also strategically place
photographs of very powerful political and social figures amongst photographs and art displaying
nude females in an effort to normalize the sexual abuse. They would also normalize the sexual
abuse by placing a massage table and spa related products around the massage area in an effort to
legitimize the area where the abuse was set to occur. Once abused, Epstein and Maxwell
continued to manipulate the victims, using their financial power, promises, and threats to ensure
that the victim returned as directed and remained compliant with their demands.

B. The Arrest, Prosecution, and Death of Epstein
32. The sexual trafficking ring described herein started at least as early as 1995 and
continued up until at least July 2, 2019, when the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of New York ("SDNY") charged Epstein with sex trafficking conspiracy and sex trafficking in
violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1591. He was arrested on July 8, 2019, pursuant to the SDNY's Sealed
Two Count Indictment, which is attached as Exhibit A.
8
3514.011
Page 8 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 9 of 19

33. The Indictment described Epstein's conduct and his abuse and trafficking of females in
the same trafficking operation he used to abuse and traffic Plaintiff.

34. Epstein's last will and testament (the "Will") was executed on August 8, 2019, at the
Metropolitan Correctional Center. The witnesses were Martel Colon Miro and Gulnora Tali. The
Will included affidavits from Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn, in which they swear an
"Oath of Willingness to Serve as Executor and Appointment of Local Counsel."

35. Epstein was found dead in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center on August 10,
2019.
36. Epstein's last will and testament was filed on August 15, 2019, in the Probate Division of
the Superior Court of the Virgin Islands.

37. Darren K. Indykc and Richard D. Kahn filed a Certificate of Trust in the Superior Court
of the Virgin Islands for Epstein's 1953 Trust on August 26, 2019. See Certificate of Trust, In
the Matter of the Estate of Jeffrey E. Epstein, Probate No. ST-19-PB-80 (Super. Ct. V.I. Aug. 26,
2019).

38. Epstein's will was entered into probate on September 6, 2019, and the Superior Court of
the Virgin Islands accordingly authorized Darren K. Indyke and Richard D. Kahn to administer
Epstein's estate. See Order for Probate, In the Matter of the Estate ofJeffrey E. Epstein, Probate

No. ST-19-PB-80 (Super. Ct. V.I. Sept. 6, 2019); Letters Testamentary, In the Matter of the
Estate ofJeffrey E. Epstein, Probate No. ST-19-PB-80 (Super. Ct. V.I. Sept. 6, 2019).

39. The Will's first article directs Epstein's executors "to pay from my estate all expenses of
my last illness, my funeral and burial expenses, the administration expenses of my estate and all
of my debts duly proven and allowed against my estate." The Will further directs that "after the
9
3514.011
Page 9 of 19
EFFA_00007685
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 10 of 19
payments and distributions provided in Article FIRST," Epstein "give[s] all of my property, real
and personal, wherever situated . to the thcn acting Trustees of The 1953 Trust."

40. Following Epstcin's death, SDNY submitted a proposed nolle prosequi order in the
criminal matter against him because it was required by law to do so after Epstein was deceased.
On August 29, 2019, U.S. District Judge Richard Berman formally dismissed SDNY's
indictment against Epstein, terminating the criminal action against him.
to the New York mansion. Maxwell told that these girls were interviewing for Victoria's
observed that Defendant Maxwell was regularly bringing over school-aged girls
Secret modeling positions.
I0
3514.011
Page 10 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 11 of 19

47. Maxwell described her role tia■ as recruiting Victoria's Secret models for Epstein.
witnessed Maxwell spotting girls and talking to them outside of the mansion, which
Maxwell claimed was for recruiting purposes. Maxwell would leave the mansion claiming she
had "to go get girls for Jeffrey."

48. At the time was unaware of the sex trafficking conspiracy and believed the girls
were being recruited for modeling positions.

49. to be working for a billionaire in Ncw York.
50. Epstein began taking an interest in
51. Epstein He used this as
a ruse to ge to come to New York so that he could abuse her. Epstein purchased
plane tickets, and she flew to Ncw York.

52. Epstein gave ■ money to buy a dress. He paid for a limousine to pick up the
sisters and take them to Epstein's townhome. He talked to about going to college and
potential schools before sending them to see a Broadway show.

53. During stay in New York, Epstein asked to go to the movie
theater with him. This is where he began initiating non-consensual physical contact with
in an attempt to groom for sexual activity and normalize sexual behavior with him.

54. At the movie, Epstein intentionally positioned himself between the sisters to ensure they
were separated, and to prevent MTOM seeing that he was touching Epstein began
caressing and petting on various parts of her body against her will. He would repeatedly
11
3514.011
Page 11 of 19
EFFA_00007687
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 12 of 19
touch only when was unaware and looking away. was distressed, frightened,
and confused.

55. =then left to go back home to
56. Epstein began calling from New York under the false pretense of
discussing He offered to send

57. As part of his plan to recruit for sexual purposes, Epstein explained to -
mother that he sponsored educational trips for high school students, and was sponsoring an event
in New Mexico at his ranch called Zorro Ranch. He invited He explained that Maxwell
would be a host or chaperone for at the event. Under these false pretenses=
mother agreed to send to Epstein's program for high school students.

58. Epstein and Maxwell, who were in New York at the time, arranged and paid for. to
fly to New Mexico in the spring of 1996. Epstein mailed her airline tickets from New York to
her mother in When arrived in New Mexico, Epstein had a driver take her to his
ranch. Epstein's Zorro Ranch sits on over 10,000 acres and is very remote. Upon arriving at the
ranch, learned that Epstein had not invited any other students. Shc was the only person at
the massive ranch in a different state, away from her family in
and anyone she knew. She was alone with Maxwell and Epstein.

59. Maxwell appeared charming and friendly to Upon arriving, Maxwell and Epstein
took Whopping and lavished her with gifts, including beauty products and a pair of brand
new cowboy boots. After returning to the ranch, Maxwell began pressuring Mto touch
Epstein and give him a foot massage. was very scared and did not want to touch Epstein,
but Maxwell was relentless and demanded that massage Epstein. Both adults explained to
12
3514.011
Page 12 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 13 of 19
that it was just a massage, and attempted to normalize this sexual behavior with an adult to
her.

60. Epstein and Maxwell took to a movie theater. While in line for the movie,
Maxwell pulled down Epstein's sweatpants, exposing part of his buttocks. Both Epstein and
Maxwell repeatedly fondled each other in front of trying to normalize sexual behavior to
a child.

61. In the movie theater in Ncw Mexico, Epstein caressed and petted various parts of_
body against her will. was incredibly scared, and did not know how to escape because she
was a child alone with Epstein and Maxwell. did not have a phone or any other means of
communication without Epstein or Maxwell knowing.

62. Epstein, Maxwell, and returned to Epstcin's ranch. Upon returning from the
movie, Maxwell repeatedly told that she wanted to give her a massage. was very
uncomfortable with the idea of Maxwell touching her, but realized that she was completely alone
M fwith Epstein and Maxwell. eared what would happen if she did not comply with their
demands. said that she had never had a massage and tried to avoid having Maxwell touch
her body, but Maxwell continued to pressure her. Maxwell directed =to take off all of her
clothes and lay on the massage table. was extremely scared to be naked in front of
Epstein and Maxwell.

63. Maxwell left the door open so that Epstein could view naked body during the
massage.
64. Maxwell touched intimate parts of■ body against her will for the sexual benefit of
Maxwell and Epstein.

65. Maxwell exposed breasts and groped her.
13
3514.011
Page 13 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 14 of 19

66. was extremely distressed and afraid. She was a child in a massive ranch in New
Mexico, away from her family and isolated from any source of help. She was alone
with Epstein and Maxwell. She had no way to access a phone or other method of
communication without Epstein or Maxwell knowing. She had no way of leaving.

67. woke up the next morning to find Epstein entering her room. He climbed into the
bed with her and announced, "I want to cuddle." Without her consent, Epstein got into the bed
with physically restrained her with his arms and proceeded to press his body (including
his genitals) against was frozen in fear. She was sixteen years old.

68. kncw she had no way of escaping Epstein's massive estate, and attempted to
escape by saying she needed to use the restroom. She was in shock, and frightened by what she
was experiencing. She feared for her safety, knowing she was alone in Epstein's ranch in
another state and that Maxwell and Epstein were closely monitoring her activity.

69. escaped to Epstein's bathroom. She was in extreme fear and emotional distress,
not knowing how to escape Epstein's ranch in New Mexico, where these two adults were
groping her, a child, against her will.

70. Epstein and Maxwell eventually allowed ■ to fly back homc and they
returned to Ncw York. Out of fear of what could happen to her and her family because of
Epstein and Maxwell's great power, wealth, and connections that they had displayed to her,
did not tell anyone about Epstein and Maxwell touching her against her will.
14
3514.011
Page 14 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 15 of 19

73. Instead of letting Maxwell's words silence her, reported her assault to the Sixth
Precinct of the New York City Police Department ("NYPD"). The NYPD referred o the
Federal Bureau of Investigation ("FBI"). followed the instruction and called the FBI to
make a report of the abuse. To the extreme detriment of —and also countless
other victims who came after them—authorities ignored=reporting efforts and took no
action.

74. =also called
During the call shared with her own assaults in
New York and New Mexico, as well as her false imprisonment at Epstein's New Mexico ranch.

75. Frustrated that authorities did not appear to be taking any action and in the hopes of
exposing the crimes that Maxwell and Epstein were committing,
share their stories with Vanity Fair magazine. Tragically for
decided to
Epstein threatened
and intimidated the magazine and Vanity Fair bent to those threats and ultimately published a
profile of Epstein without mentioning -their allegations.

76. Once Maxwell and Epstein learned that had revealed the abuse to Vanity Fair, they
embarked on a campaign to dcstroy reputation and M. Afraid for her safety,
having informed the NYPD, FBI, and media to no avail, left New York and moved
15
3514.011
Page 15 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 16 of 19
to fear of Epstcin's power was exacerbated by the fact that state and
federal authorities, as well as the media, were not taking action against Epstein.

77. .vas deeply affected by her harrowing experiences at the hands of Epstein and
Maxwell as a child. She suffers severe emotional distress from an experience that has affected
her for her entire life.

78. The Defendants' sexual assault, battery, and false imprisonment of■ continue to
cause her significant distress and harm.
FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
(Battery)

79. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges the allegations stated above in paragraphs 1-78 as if fully
set forth herein.

80. Epstein and Maxwell intentionally committed battery by sexually assaulting Plaintiff
when she was a young girl. As described above, on multiple occasions Epstein and Maxwell
intentionally touched Plaintiff in an offensive and sexual manner without her consent.

81. Epstein and Maxwell's actions constitute sexual offenses as defined in New York Penal
Law Article 130, including but not limited to forcible touching as defined in Article 130.52,
inasmuch as Epstein and Maxwell intentionally and forcibly touched sexual and intimate parts of
Plaintiff's body for their own sexual gratification on multiple occasions. See N.Y. C.P.L.R.
§ 214-g.

82. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking enterprise from
which Plaintiff's first cause of action arises was terminated on August 29, 2019, less than one
year prior to the filing of this Complaint. See N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a).
16
3514.011
Page 16 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 17 of 19

83. As a direct and proximate result of Epstein's and Maxwell's criminal acts, Plaintiff has in
the past and will in the future continue to suffer extreme emotional distress, humiliation, fear,
psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self-esteem, and invasion of her privacy.
SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION
(False Imprisonment)

84. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges the allegations stated above in paragraphs 1-78 as if fully
set forth herein.

85. As a direct result of these allegations as stated, Defendants falsely imprisoned Plaintiff at
Epstcin's New Mexico residence while Plaintiff was a young girl for the purpose of degrading
her, abusing her, or gratifying their sexual desires.

86. Epstein and Maxwell brought Plaintiff to Epstein's New Mexico Ranch with the intent to
confine her in that location so that they could sexually abuse her. Plaintiff was conscious of her
confinement and did not consent that confinement. Epstein and Maxwell prevented Plaintiff, a
child with no way to communicate with anyone other than Epstein and Maxwell and with no
access to a car or other means of transportation, from leaving the premises, Epstein's remote
10,000 acre Zorro Ranch in Ncw Mexico.

87. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking enterprise from
which Plaintiff's second cause of action arises was terminated on August 29, 2019, less than one
year prior to the filing of this Complaint. See N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a).

88. As a direct and proximate result of Epstein and Maxwell's criminal acts, Plaintiff has in
the past and will in the future continue to suffer extreme emotional distress, humiliation, fear,
psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self-esteem, and invasion of her privacy.
17
3514.011
Page 17 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 18 of 19
THIRD CAUSE OF ACTION
(Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress)

89. Plaintiff repeats and re-alleges the allegations stated above in paragraphs 1-78 as if fully
set forth herein.

90. As a direct result of these allegations as stated, Defendants committed intentional
infliction of emotional distress against Plaintiff.

91. Defendants' actions, described above, constitute extreme and outrageous conduct that
shocks the conscience. Epstein and Maxwell's plan to recruit, entice, and assault Plaintiff, a
sixteen-year-old child, on multiple occasions, goes beyond all possible bounds of decency and is
intolerable in a civilized community.

92. Defendants knew or disregarded the substantial likelihood that these actions would cause
Plaintiff severe emotional distress.

93. A criminal action against Epstein with respect to the same sex trafficking enterprise from
which Plaintiff's third cause of action arises was terminated on August 29, 2019, less than one
year prior to the filing of this Complaint. See N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 215(8)(a).

94. As a direct and proximate result of Epstein and Maxwell's criminal acts, Plaintiff has in
the past and will in the future continue to suffer extreme emotional distress, humiliation, fear,
psychological trauma, loss of dignity and self-esteem, and invasion of her privacy.
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests judgment against Defendants, awarding
compensatory, consequential, exemplary, and punitive damages in an amount to be determined at
trial; costs of suit; attorneys' fees; and such other and further relief as the Court may deem just
and proper.
18
3514.011
Page 18 of 19
Case 1:19-cv-10475-LGS-DCF Document 1 Filed 11/12/19 Page 19 of 19
JURY DEMAND
Plaintiff hereby demands a trial by jury on all causes of action asserted within this
pleading.
Dated: November 12, 2019.
19
3514.011
Page 19 of 19
EFFA_00007695
EFTA00008998 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Ghislaine Maxwell
EFTA00081226 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI interview of minor victim
(inferred date: 2026-01-20)
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 1 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 1 of 20
EXHIBIT 'I
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 2 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 2 of 20
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
CASE NO. 08-80736-CIV-MARRA
JANE DOE #1 and JANE DOE #2,
Petitioners,
vs.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Respondent.
DECLARATION OF

1. My name is and I was born in August, 1983.
2. I am currently 31 years old.
3. I grew up in Palm Beach, Florida. When I was little, I loved animals and wanted
to be a veterinarian. But my life took a very different turn when adults began to be interested in
having sex with me.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 3 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 3 of 20

6. I came back for several days following and did the same sorts of sexual things for
Epstein.
8. So I started "working" exclusively for Epstein. He took me to Ncw York on his
big, private jet. We went to his mansion in Ncw York City. I was shown to my room, a very
luxurious room. The mansion was huge. I got scared because it was so big. Epstein brought me
to a room with a massage parlor. To me, it looked like an S&M parlor. Epstein made me engage
in sexual activities with him there.

9. You can see how young I looked in the photograph below.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 4 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 4 of 20

10. Epstein took me on a ferry boat on one of the trips to New York City and there he
took the picture above. I was approximately IS or 16 years old at the time.

12. I was trained to be "everything a man wanted me to be." It wasn't just sexual
training - they wanted me to be able to cater to all the needs of the men they were going to send
me to. They said that they loved that I was very compliant and knew how to keep my mouth
shut.

14. From very early on I was fearful of Epstein. Epstein told me he was a billionaire.
I told my mother that I was working for this rich guy, and she said "go, go far away." Epstein
had promised me a lot, and 1 knew if I left I would be in big trouble. I also knew that I was a
witness to a lot of illegal and very bad behavior by Epstein and his friends. If I left Epstein, he
knew all kinds of powerful people. He could have had me killed or abducted, and I always knew
he was capable of that if I did not obey him. He let me know that he knew many people in high
places. Speaking about himself, he said "I can get away" with things. I was very scared,
particularly since I was a teenager.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 5 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 5 of 20

16. To illustrate my connection to these places, I include four photographs taken of
me in New Mexico (shown below). The first one is a museum in Santa Fe, New Mexico. We
had gone sightseeing for the day. Epstein took this picture of me. I was approximately 17 at the
time, judging from the looks of it. At the end of the day we returned to Epstein's Zorro Ranch.
The second picture is me on one of Epstein's horses on the ranch in New Mexico. The following
two are from wintertime in New Mexico.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 6 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 6 of 20
IL.

17. When I was with him, Epstein had sex with underage girls on a daily basis. His
interest in this kind of sex was obvious to the people around him. The activities were so obvious
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 7 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 7 of 20
and bold that anyone spending any significant time at one of Epstein's residences would have
clearly been aware of what was going on.

18. Epstein's code word for sexual encounters was that it was a "massage". At times
the interaction between Epstein and the girls would start in a massage room setting, it was
always a sexual encounter and never just a massage.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 8 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 8 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 9 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 9 of 20
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 10 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 10 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 11 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 11 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 12 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 12 of
II
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 13 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 &red on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 13 of

54. I now understand that Epstein reached a non-prosecution agreement with the
federal government in 2007 and pled guilty to two state crimes in June 2008. I now know that I
was identified by the federal government as one of Epstcin's and his co-conspirator's sexually
abused victims. However, no one told me about those events until after they happened.

55. On September 3, 2008, the FBI sent a victim notification letter to me. This was
the first written communication I had received from the FBI. The letter is attached as Exhibit I.
The letter describes an agreement in which compensation would be made victims of Epstein's
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 14 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 14 of
sexual abuse. The letter also said that the federal government was going to "defer federal
prosecution." No one had told me about deferring federal prosecution before this.

56. In 2011, two FBI agents, called me in Australia and then came to meet me. They
met me at the U.S. Consulate in Sidney. They seemed to be very professional and hard working.
I thought to myself, "Wow, these people will do the right thing against the bad guys and protect
me."

57. The agents wcrc mainly focused on Epstein but while there I provided them some
information about others who wcrc involved in illegal acts as well. I was aware that a false
statement to these law enforcement officers was a crime and I told the truth — giving them the
information that I could recall about the individuals they inquired about.

58. Epstein also trafficked me for sexual purposes to many other powerful men,
including politicians and powerful business executives. Epstein required me to describe the
sexual events that I had with these men presumably so that he could potentially blackmail them.
I am still very fearful of these men today.

60. In this affidavit, I have tried to focus on how I was trafficked for sexual purposes.
I have not described all of the details of the sexual activities Epstein forced me to have. Also, I
have not described all of the details of the other events discussed here. If a judge wants me to
Case 9 08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 15 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 15 of
present my information in more detail, including more specific descriptions of the sexual
activities with the men Epstein sent me to, I could do so.

61. I have directed my attorneys, Bradley Edwards and Paul G. Cassell, to pursue
all reasonable and legitimate means to have criminal charges brought against these powerful
people for the crimes they have committed against me and other girls. They are representing me
in this case pro bono.

62. Since I filed my motion in this case. my credibility has been attacked. I am telling
the truth and will not let these attacks prevent me from exposing the truth of how I was trafficked
for sex to many powerful people. These powerful people seem to think that they don't have to
follow the same rules as everyone else. That is wrong. I hope that by coming forward, I can
help expose the problem of sex trafficking and prevent the same sort of abuse and degradation
that happened to me from happening to other girls.

63. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed this fsday oflanuary, 2015.
(Location of signature left undisclosed for security reasons)
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 16 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 16 of
EXHIBIT 1
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 17 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 17 of 20

US. Department otjustice
United SiotesAttorney
Southern District of Florida
300 South Australian Ave.. Suite 400
Wert Palm Brach, FL 33401
(560 820-8711
Facsimile: (561)8204777
September 3, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 18 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 18 of
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave., Suite 400
Wart Pam Beach, FL 33401
(S61) 8304711
Facsimile. (561)820-8777
September 3, 2008
VIA COURIER
Re: Jeffrey Epstein/ NOTIFICATION OF
IDENTIFIED VICTIM
Dear
By virtue of this letter, the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of Florida provides you with the following notice because you are an identified victim of a federal offense.
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea of guilty to violations of 
Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony
solicitation of prostitution) and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution). in the 15th Judicial Circuit
in and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos.
2006-cf-009454AXXXMB and 2008-cf-00938 IAXXXIAB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be 
followed by an additional six months'
imprisonment, followed by twelve months of Community Control I, with conditions of community confinement imposed by the 
Court.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to defer federal prosecution in 
favor of this state plea and sentence,
subject to certain conditions, including the following:

1. An independent Special Master was assigned the task of selecting an
attorney representative to represent the victims, including you, in
connection with civil actions between the victims and Mr. Epstein. The
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 19 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 19 of
NOTIFICATION Or IDENTIFIED V 'Glib,
SEPTEMBER 3,2008
PAGE 2 Ora
Special Master selected Robert Josefsberg, Esq. of the firm Podhurst
Orseck, PA., a highly-respected and experienced attorney. You are not
obligated to use Mr. Josefsberg as your civil attorney, but, as explained
in greater detail below, Mr. Josefsberg's services will be provided at no
cost to you because Mr. Epstein is obligated to pay the costs and fees
of the attorney-representative. Also, Mr. Epstein and his attorneys can
only contact you via Mr. Josefsberg, assuming that you would like Mr.
Josefsberg to serve as your attorney.

2. If you elect to fi le suit against Mr. Epstein pursuant to Title 18, United
States Code, Section 2255, Mr. Epstein will not contest the jurisdiction
of the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida
over his person and/or the subject matter, and Mr. Epstein waives his
right to contest liability and also waives his right to contest damages up
to an amount as agreed to between you and Mr. Epstein, so long as you
elect to proceed exclusively under I8 U.S.C. § 2255, and you waive any
other claim for damages, whether pursuant to state, federal, or common
law. Notwithstanding this waiver, Epstein's agreement with the United
States, his waivers and failure to contest liability and such damages in
any suit are not to be construed as an admission of any criminal or civil
liability.

3. As stated above, Mr. Epstein has agreed to pay the fees of the attorney
representative selected by the independent third party. This provision,
however, shall not obligate Epstein to pay the fees and costs of
contested litigation filed against him. Thus, if after consideration of
potential settlements, you and Mr. Josefsberg elect to file a contested
lawsuit pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2255 or you elect to pursue any other contested remedy, the obligation to pay the costs 
of the attorney
representative, as opposed to any statutory or other obligations to pay
reasonable attorneys fees and costs such as those contained in Section
2255, shall cease.
Please contact either myself at or Justice Department Victim-Witness Specialist Twi ler Smith at with a good telephone 
number andior e-mail address, so that we
may provide Mr. Josefsberg with a timely means of communicating with you. If you would like to contact Mr. Josefsberg
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 341-2 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/23/2015 Page 20 of
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 20 of
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
SEPTEMBER 3, 2008
PACE 3 OF 3
directly, he can be reached at +1 305 358.2800.
If you have already selected other counsel to represent you, or if you do so in the
future, and you decide to file a claim against Jeffrey Epstein, Mr. Epstein's attorney, Jack
Goldberger, asks that you have your attorney contact Mr. Goldberger at Atterbury Goldberger
and Weiss, 250 Australian Avenue South, Suite 1400, West Palm Beach, FL 33401, (561)
659-8300.
In addition, there has been litigation between the United States and two other victims
regarding the disclosure of the entire agreement between the United States and Mr. Epstein.

Mr. Josefsberg can provide further guidance on this issue, or if you select another attorney
to represent you, that attorney can review the Court's order in the matter of In re Jane Does
1 and 2, United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida Court File No. 08-
80736-CIV-MARRA.
Please understand that neither the U.S. Attorney's Office nor the Federal Bureau of
Investigation can take part in or otherwise assist in civil litigation. Thank you for all of your
assistance during the course of the federal and state investigations and please accept the
heartfelt regards of myself and Special Agents Kuyrkendall, Slater, and Richards for your
health and well-being.
Sincerely,

R. Alexander Acosta
United States Attorney
By:
cc: Robert losefsberg, Esq.
Jack Goldberger, Esq.
A. Marie Villafafia
Assistant United States Attorney
EFTA00590940 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States: interview with minor victim
EFTA00803459 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Honeycomb Asset Management January 2019 report
(inferred date: 2026-01-20)
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
January 15, 2019
Dear Rich,
Below please find Honeycomb's 4O 2018, Full Year 2018, and Inception To Date Fund performance.
Performance — Gross and Netl
4O 2018 Full Year 2018 Inception To Date
(July'16-Dec'18)
Honeycomb Class A (gross) -8.3% 6.5% 39.9%
Honeycomb Class A (net) -6.8% 5.2% 31.4%
Honeycomb Class B (gross) -8.2% 7.0% 41.5%
Honeycomb Class B (net) -6.7% 5.6% 32.6%
Internal capital anchored our June 2016 soft launch which also ricluded select friends and family capital. The Fund's 
June 2016 net performance was
-3.4% and -3.3% for classes A and B. respectively. Past performance is not ridicative or a guarantee of future results.
4Q 2018 Performance Review
Exposures for 4O averaged approximately 144% gross and 54% net, which compares to 184% gross and
65% net for 3Q. For comparison, gross and net exposures since inception have averaged approximately
191% and 57%, respectively.

At Honeycomb, we often talk about being flexible in our mindset and open to utilizing the different playbooks
accumulated over time through bull and bear markets. For example, in 2008 as the markets became more
volatile, I reduced exposure to protect positive performance and manage risk. Ten years later, we took
elements of that 2008 playbook and proactively reduced both gross and net exposures as the 500
dropped almost 15% in 4Q.

Drawdowns will inevitably occur. We seek to mitigate their impact so our partners can benefit from
compounding returns. While preservation of capital was an important objective in the fourth quarter, we
remain a fundamentally-based manager always on the hunt for new investment opportunities. Our overall
net long exposure did result in 4O losses, but our risk management-based mindset preserved overall
positive performance for the fund in 2018, in a year that was challenging across most asset classes.
Based on our research, we disagreed with the market seeming to price in deteriorating business conditions
for many of the names in our long book. As a result, we occasionally bought market dips when risk/reward
looked most beneficial to us. As expected, our short book delivered positive MEI and offset some of the
losses on the long side. In addition, we benefited significantly from the hard work our analysts did in
recommending new ideas in an effort to offset losses from existing names where we had negative alpha. It
is velocity of idea flow that helps Honeycomb generate alpha in changing market conditions.
Honeycomb's culture of collaboration encourages us to examine our performance, make improvements as
a team, and look for learning opportunities in successes and failures.
645 Mating ANNinue. 1 Floor. New York. NY 10022
Calk - Not for Disinbuton
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
Gross Long and Short Security Selection Contribution — 4O2018 and Full Year 2018*
4Q 2018
10%
8.9%
-16.7%
-7.8%
0%
Long Short Total
Full Year 2018
4.9%
Long
3.7%
Short
8.7%
Total
'The security elrbution above deers from the 2018 perfermance table as it does not wisider management fee. inn:trove 
a/motion. lanyards or Fund expenses. Past
performances not indicative or a guarantee of Inhere results.

For the year, we finished with roughly equal positive contributions from the long and short book. Software
and large cap internet provided positive performance that was offset by steep losses in Chinese intemet
and technology, an idiosyncratic data privacy scandal, and social gaming. On the short side, we generated
gains from our research that highlighted secular headwinds impacting beer and soda beverage companies
as well as the hyper competitive food delivery business.
Investment Themes for 2019 — 5G Wireless
We believe 50 will become a "megatrend- that will create a global capex cycle independent of GDP growth.
While this cycle will not be as revolutionary as the transition from analog to digital, we think the evolution to
SG will create new industries to serve consumers and businesses and create investable opportunities
across industries. Over the next decade, Wi-Fi and super high-speed networks will be an increasingly
important part of daily life. Consumers will have subscriptions to autonomous vehicles, drone delivery of
goods, reimagined kitchen appliances and virtual reality shopping (just envision the benefits of seeing on
an augmented reality headset what a sofa looks like in your home before you buy it!).
One of the more interesting implications of 5O is the software layer being added to devices sold by telecom
equipment providers. This new software layer will be required to optimize the efficiency of next-gen 50
networks and the sales of such technology solutions could generate significant new revenue streams with
higher margins. This will come not just from the greater incremental cost of the equipment itself, but also
from software maintenance revenue that we believe will be valued at a higher multiple than traditional
telecom equipment sales. The potential impact of this new business mix led us to build a new position in
Nokia which will deploy increasingly more software on top of radio and optical equipment for 50 networks.
Our research leads us to believe this will be a more investable area as we get closer to 2H19 but our work
is being done now to prepare for it.

After years of stagnant growth, we also believe that telecoms are inexpensive on a global basis because
valuations are not accurately pricing in potential new revenue streams resulting from 5O. With its super-
fast connectivity, 50 will set the stage for innovation. New use cases will continue to develop in fields such
as healthcare, smart vehicles, robotics, machine learning and long-haul transport. The importance of
communications in our everyday lives will also be enhanced as more and more devices are connected to
2
Ccrifderbai Not foe 0$:int:Lion
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
the Internet and the 'Internet of Things' becomes more commonplace. The new devices, equipment and
use cases that emerge will require more and more data which we believe could meaningfully and positively
impact telecom companies across the globe. Telecom is an area of increased focus and a core expertise
for Honeycomb, where upon gaining conviction we could deploy significant capital.
Co-Investment Update
Tencent Music Entertainment was publicly listed in December in a difficult environment. While the market
conditions for Chinese companies are currently challenging, we believe TME remains a terrific long-term
investment opportunity despite its current low valuation compared to our entry point. TME is the market
share leader in streaming music in China, capturing the secular growth of the music market in China and
benefitting from the transition to paid subscriptions. We also believe TME's ownership of the large social
network platform called WeSing is underappreciated by the market and is a differentiator for the company.
WeSing takes the popular past time of Karaoke from offline parlors to an online experience. We expect
2019 to be a breakout year for Tencent Music and look forward to its bright future.
Business Update
2018 was an important and successful year for growing our partnership with high quality and strategic
investors, expanding the team, and launching new products. I am pleased to report we have thrived and
built a strong business that isn't satisfied with its legacy track record and doesn't rest on any laurels.
Our business reputation is solid and we continue to grow. We are in a busy recruiting season and seeing
some of the best talent eager for an opportunity to become part of our current team of 11 employees. Our
total firm assets are over $750M, excluding co-investment distributions of +590M in exits of successful
private investments. We continue to be very measured in our pace of AUM growth and despite this
challenging fundraising environment over the past 2.5 years for the industry, we have seen 30 consecutive
months of capital inflows. We have repeatedly shared that Honeycomb intends to be a boutique firm and
our team is proud that we continue to execute on this vision.
Closing Remarks
This summer will mark our 3'd anniversary. Our firm was launched during the Brexit vote and this past
quarter provided the challenging environment that is helpful to reinforce our culture of taking nothing for
granted. Great firms are often built during difficult times while easy times can distort luck for talent. We are
grateful for the opportunity to work for you. Our scalable and repeatable process to invest in the future and
short the past makes Honeycomb an exciting place to work. Thank you for your partnership and I hope you
have a very happy and healthy 2019!
Best Regards,
3
Cad -denim, Not foe Omintvon
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
PARTNERSHIP CONTACT INFORMATION:
Dominique Ahumada
Head of Capital Partnerships & Talent
(646)883-1128
Ccrobionlial - Na for Distributim
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT
grxInotes & Important Legal Disclosure
Honeycomb Master Fund LP (the 'Master Fund') includes all or substantially as investible assets from as feeder Mids. 
Honeycomb Partners LP ('Domestic Fun!).
Honeycomb intermediate Fund LP and Honeycomb Offshore Fund Ltd. (collectively. the 'Funds'). However. investors are 
expected to invest at the feeder fund not
at the Master Fund level. The reflected returns assume a representative investor invested in the Domestic Fund in each 
of (1) the Class A interests that are
subject
to a management fee of 2% and incentive allocation 01 20% and (II) the Class B Interests that are subject to a 
management fee of 1.5% and an incentive alocation
of 20%. 'Net' reflects the performance of the Domestic Find net of management lee. expenses and incentive allocation, 
'Gross' reflects the performance of the
Domestic Fund net of management lee and expenses. but gross of incentive allocation. Returns assume the reinvestment of 
all dividends. interest. Income and
profits. The management fee and expense tires used for performance calculations are pro-rated for the performance 
period, and incentive allocation calailabions
reneci an investment since the Domestic Funds Ally 1.2016 institutional launch date. The reflected rainsassume 
participation by the Class A and B representatwe
investor in new issue' investments and no participation in side pockets. Individual results will vary (potentially 
considerably) depending on. among other
things.

investing al the offshore feeder fund rather than the Domestic Fund level, new issue eligibility. side pocket 
participation, the tiri ng of
contributions/subscription and
wandrawalsfredemptions. different fee arrangements and any accisnLiated loss carry-forwards. This performance 
information is estimated and Honeycomb Asset
Management LP (the -Investment Manage() makes no representations as to the accuracy or completeness thereof. an such 
information should not be relied upon
for investment related or other purposes. The performance inficanniat is based on unaudited information as of the date 
hereof and e subject to change as actual
performance for the relevant period is finalized. Past performance is not indicative of future results.
This investor letter is confidential, is intended only for the person to whom it has been provided and under no 
circumstances may a copy  be shown, copied.
transmitted. or otherwise given to any person other than the authorized recipient without the prior written consent of 
the Investment Manager. Except as
otherwee
specifically set forth herein, the information in this letter is as 01 the dale hereof. Notwithstanding anything to the 
contrary heron. each recipient to this
document
(and each emp4oyee, representative, or recipient) may disclose to any and all persons, without limitation of any kind, 
the lax treatment and tax structure 01
the Funds
any of the/ transactions, and all materials of any kind (including opinions or other lax analyses) relating to such tax 
treatment and tax structure, it being
understood
that lax treatment' and 'tax structure' do not Include the name or identifying information of a Fund or a transaction.
The distribution of the information contained herein may be restricted in certain jurisdictions. accordingly. it is the 
responsibility of any prospective
investor to satisfy
itself as to compliance with relevant laws and regulations. The recipient and its professional advisors, by accepting 
delivery of this docanent. agree to keep
confidential all matters herein and to return this document promptly upon the request of the Investment Manager.
The information contained herein is preliminary and is provided for discussion proses only. This information e any a 
summary of key information. it is not
complete
and does not contain certain material information about the Funds. including important conflict 0l litres's disclosures 
and risk factors associated with an
investment
in the Funds and is subject to change without notice.

TM document has been suppled for discussion purposes only, and therefore no representation or warranty is made. whether 
expressed or titled, by the Funds
or the Investment Manager or any 01 their partners. employees, members, or agents as to the accuracy or completeness of 
the information provided herein. This
document may be amended at any time. There is no express or implied obligation to update you of any changes to the 
information set forth herein. The information
contained herein should not be relied upon as the basis of any investment decision or for any other purpose.
TM document is not intended to be. nor should it be construed or used as an offer to set or a solicitation of any offer 
to buy, interests or shares in the
Funds. No
offer or solicitation may be made prior to the delivery of a definithe offering rnenorandLen (the 'Memorandum') Much MI 
contain additional information about the
Finds. including disclosures relating to risk factors and conficts 01 interest. The information contained herein does 
not consider the particular investment
objectives
or financial circumstances of any specific person who may receive it and is qualified in its entirety by the 
Memoranclion. In the event of any disorepancies
between
the information contained herein and the Memorandum, the Memorandum will control. The information herein is n0t intended
to provide, and should not De relied
upon for, accounting, and legal or tax advice or investment recommendations. Each recipient of this document should make
an independent investigation as to al
matters concerning an investment in the Faids or otherwise described herein. including consulting with its own tax, 
legal, accounting or other advisors about
the
matters concerning an investment in the Funds or otherwise discussed herein. In making an investment decision. investors
must rely upon their own examnabon 01
the Funds and the terms of the offering. inclining the merits and risks involved.

An investment in the Funds may not be &Watts for al investors. An investment in the Funds will be suitable only for 
certain financially
sophisticated investors who meet certain eligibility requirements, have no need for immediate bauidity in their 
investment, and can bear the risk of an
investment in
the Funds for an extended period of time.

Investing in financial markets involves a substantial degree of risk. There can be no assurance that the investment 
objectives described herein will be
achieved.

Investment looses may occur, and investors could lose some or all their investment. No guarantee or representation is 
made that the Finds' investment program.
including. without Mutation. its investment objeattes. diversification Urategies. or risk monitoring goals, will be 
successful, and investment results may vary
substantially over ans. Nothing herein is intended to imply that the Finds investment methodology may be considered 
"conservative". 'safe', 'risk tree' or 'risk
averse'. Economic, market and other conditions could also cause the Funds to alter their investment objectives, 
guidelines and restrictions.
Certain information contained in the document (including, n particular, the discussion of investment themes contained 
herein) constitutes lavaud.looking
statements'. which can be identified using forward-looking terminology such as 'may'. 'Will; "shouir. 'expect'. 
'anticipate". 'target, "project. 'estimate",
"intend'.

'continue' or 'believe' or the negatives thereof or other variations thereon or comparable temsiology. Due to various 
risks and uncertainties and assumptions
made
by the Investment Manager. actual events or results or the actual performance of the Funds may differ materially from 
those reflected or contemplated in such
forward-looking statements.

The esbmates, investment strategies, investment themes, and views expressed in this document are based upon past or 
current market conditions and/or data and
information provided by unaffiliated third parties (which has not been independently verified) and is subject to change 
without notice. In addition, many ol the
views
expressed herein are stkpctIve andror reflect the Investment Manager's estimates or keecasts on future performance and 
market events. Such statements should
not be aiderstood to be predictions or guarantees of any particular outcome, or of the Investment Manager's commitment 
to invest in any pa/beam industry,
sector.

region, or cottony. In particular. you should be snare that any new technologies or products discussed herein are 
unproven, may never develop as the Investment
Manager anticipates, could be superseded by other technologies, and are subject to significant investment risks.
Past performance is not indcative nor a guarantee of line reams. Each issuer discussed as a longlshon contnbutor or 
detractor from performance was one of the
top 10 liongfshort contributors or detractors from performance for the quarter and was selected based on being a 
representative driver of performance for the
quarter.

Honeycomb Offshore Fund Ltd. (the 'Offshore Fund') has not been approved for distribution in or from Switzerland by the 
Swiss Financial Market Supervisory
Authority. Asa result. the Offshore Fund's shares may ally be offered or distributed to qualdled Investors within the 
meaning of Swiss law. The Representatwe 01
the Offshore Fund in Sw0zertand is Bastions Partners Office SA with registered office at Route de Chore 61A. 1208 
Geneva. Switzerland. The Paying Agent in
Switzerland is Banque Heritage SA. with registered office al Route de Chene 61, 1208 Geneva, Switzerland. The place of 
performance and judsdicticri for shares
of
the Offshore Fund 6siributed in or from Switzerland are at the registered office of the RepeeSentatrve.
5
Conrcential - Not For Distribution
EFTA01081391 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jane Doe #1 and Jane Doe #2 v. United States: interview with minor victim
EFTA01292412 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank checks including $51,736 check to Insurance Office of Central Ohio
(inferred date: 2026-01-20)
JEFFREY EPSTEIN                     DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICAS          1175
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, 83           NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10154                 1/30/2018

ST. THOMAS, USVI 00802-1348         1-103/210

PAY TO THE ORDER OF             Insurance Office of Central Ohio            $51,736.00
Fifty-One Thousand Seven Hundred Thirty-Six and 00/100 ***********             DOLLARS

MEMO
Insurance Office of Central Ohio
165 W. Main Street
PO Box 780
New Albany, OH 43054-0780
Policy 0021940015
invoice# 233037

JEFFREY EPSTEIN                     DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST COMPANY AMERICAS          1173
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, 83           NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10154                 1/17/2018

ST. THOMAS, USVI 00802-1348         1-103/210

PAY TO THE ORDER OF             Antilles School                              $8,688.00
Eight Thousand Six Hundred Eighty-Eight and 00/100 ***********                 DOLLARS

MEMO
Antilles School
7280 Frenchman's Bay #16-1

St. Thomas, VI 00802

Lucas Rodriguez

t avn NOI1n 1115 N1 YIGNVNI I UC U3/.23S3H
31111 SINl MO139 HOPS NO eltiVIS '31.18M ION 00
10c;00.0- -ZCL '133V
TA 13 mil s. 'IS •oui 130 DO S€jjfu`e
iAluo ii ooao Job
USN 3SUO0N3 O
1.•
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QP .NE I DENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050401
DB-SDNY-0013225
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER.
ST.
THOMAS.
USVI
00802-13O
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK.
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
1/16/2018
ORDER
OF
PAY
TO
THE
AF
EX
$
"8,778.00
Eight
Thousand
Seven
Hundred
Seventy
-Eight
and
00/100""""""""*""""""""*""'"""""*"""""
DOLLARS
AFEX
MEMO
I 8
A t 0,
<0 tNa O > - z C ch C
p C w
I 10I9I00-V1.43
LZZCLOO-ANOS-80
toPOSODOINOANOS
0 ENDORSE HERE
FOR DEPOSIT ONLY
1VIINSCIINOoel Oad 011NVCISHIld -1VI1N3OldN00
Associated Foreign Exchange Inc.
00 NOT WRITE. STAMP OR SIGN BELOW THIS LINE
RESERVED Chorl I:NANG:At iNST•!ulturi USE * . .
Co,
01 • • • •
41/ •11C /— C./

V) CO CO
F., -.1. :Rev At.
C1‘1.10 :‘ 4'M:• .1 I: .1 •• aN fil•-•$e
nut• en't..N.tais• : I .:v q. . • lah•S
• c•- rett.:;9 t of a. r -: at
• AY • : •n • a
• '1, .Z7. • • ...PI" .4
• ' . r: • 1

╭────────────────── Page 6, Image 1 ──────────────────╮
│ g                                                   │
│                                                     │
│ awosyoer:sdi? LO51M                                 │
│                                                     │
│ SEE-SAN D8 AeMpeosg pul YILS:98                     │
│                                                     │
│ zg tbas                                             │
│                                                     │
│ 81/b2/TO ard                                        │
│ erases sured                                        │
│                                                     │
│ sash uo Loiignt Wyionyins wos O2neas Ty             │
│ NIT SIHL MO13G NDIS UO dWYLS “3LiwM LON OO          │
│                                                     │
│ T18S97%6SP100                                       │
│ “Ouy oBtyoxg UBIalog porersossy                     │
│ XINO LISOdad YOs                                    │
│                                                     │
│ auan asuoons @                                      │
│                                                     │
│ SNY_GM_ 00050403,                                   │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. aGaON Gl DENTIAL st │
│                                                     │
│ DB-SDNY-0013227                                     │
│ EFTA_00161011                                       │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00802-1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
1/8/2018
S
ORDER
OF

Lesley
Groff
$
a-481.95
PAY
TO
THE
Four
Hundred
Eighty
-One
and
95/100

DOLLARS
t
Lesley
Groff
Oenoke
Ridge
New
Canaan,
CT
MEMO
SONY_GM_00050404

╭──────────────────────────────────────────── Page 7, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 1157                                                                                                    │
│ JEFFREY EPSTI DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST                                                                       │
│                                                                                                         │
│ onpeione Suri NenCOMPANY AMERICAS                                                                       │
│ ST. THOMAS, USVI 00802-1348 K, NEW YC 4/8/2018 4                                                        │
│ $                                                                                                       │
│ q                                                                                                       │
│ PAY TO THE os, &                                                                                        │
│ Orpen oF Lesley Groff g 7481.95 i                                                                       │
│ Four Hundred Eighty-One and 95/100**++++tsereseveeeconvesensnensessnsensenunsascenaeentenen eters ana i │
│ :                                                                                                       │
│ Lesley Groff &                                                                                          │
│ 159 Oenoke Ridge a                                                                                      │
│                                                                                                         │
│ MEMO                                                                                                    │
│                                                                                                         │
│ New Canaan, CT 06840                                                                                    │
│                                                                                                         │
│ Daren                                                                                                   │
│                                                                                                         │
│ "AUTHORIZED SIGN                                                                                        │
│                                                                                                         │
│ bre                                                                                                     │
│                                                                                                         │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050404                                                                                      │
│ DB-SDNY-0013228                                                                                         │
│                                                                                                         │
│ connoenmat pursuant ro Feo. 6a IDEN TIAL                                                                │
│                                                                                                         │
│ EFTA_0016101                                                                                            │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

:•' •:' . • . .•
• : V: • ,
r.t.! 7.• '''/
.1: • . • • !; al •
• ...Pg .` La.
tr
Car,
C.:.
cc.
Cl•
tr.•
:0
• is.r. :i01O1..1S;11 VP!ejir„..3c3 t,
atQJ
ill Sitii gillOfolog V.LS •3' 1"" 'O n  Oa
9U3H 3S800?:3
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QP .NEIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050405
DB-SDNY-00 13229

╭──────────────────────── Page 8, Image 1 ─────────────────────────╮
│ boa $40                                                          │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050405                                               │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GONE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013229 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161013                                                    │
│                                                                  │
│ aus asuoows OC)                                                  │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

╭────────────────────────────────────────────────────── Page 9, Image 1 
───────────────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ ee,                                                                                                                   
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ 1169 7}                                                                                                               
│
│ JEFFREY EPSTEIN DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST                                                                                   
│
│ 6100 REO HOOK QUARTER, 63 COMPANY AMERICAS                                                                            
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ ST. THOMAS, USVI 00802-1348 newyons ao tor2s/2017 i                                                                   
│
│ $                                                                                                                     
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ PAYTOTHE — AFEX                                                                                                       
│
│ ‘ORDER OF g 8.491.00                                                                                                  
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ Eight Thousand Four Hundred Ninety-One and 00/1 00***tessrrsseerescetsecanesetnsestcanetneenterennesanenervscstncetey 
nouans │
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ AFEX i                                                                                                                
│
│ a                                                                                                                     
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050406                                                                                                    
│
│ DB-SDNY-0013230                                                                                                       
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ conroenmat pursuant ro Feo. 6a IDEN TIAL                                                                              
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ EFTA_00161014                                                                                                         
│
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
───────╯

SIOI9I0O-V.L.43
1.00-ANas-ea
/0409000-HOANOS _IVIINSCI IN()in8 03A 01 iNVI1GLIfld -1VIIN301ANOO
0 ENDORSE HERE
FOR DEPOSIT ONLY Associated Foreign Exchange Inc.
001459265811 DO NOT WRITE. STAMP OR SIGN BELOW THIS LINE
RESERVED FON FINANCIAL INS t u I ION USE - -
'I al
N • _
0 IN
CO
-c
•-• iv as (13 v.) co 0
. AS, A•
TP-1 ;`'e . tbose
eie• s. ,c e. ercibLiti .e. • -s.
^.'1 a V F•.•;,.ivs. n•-•-•. flirt
• ') • `.' • • - ".• • •P

╭──────────────────────── Page 10, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ Use SL ByO pres Sag Mat                                          │
│                                                                  │
│ BSOUY SE ye                                                      │
│                                                                  │
│ =                                                                │
│                                                                  │
│ Li/62/21 98ebe=bas                                               │
│                                                                  │
│ vosyrersdit L                                                    │
│                                                                  │
│ 860890GL80:99 LZLere sve                                         │
│                                                                  │
│ =                                                                │
│ s                                                                │
│ z                                                                │
│                                                                  │
│ i eu                                                             │
│ Pes                                                              │
│ RRA                                                              │
│ 2s                                                               │
│ HO                                                               │
│ Boe                                                              │
│                                                                  │
│ ! Sg                                                             │
│ N                                                                │
│                                                                  │
│ i 5                                                              │
│ By                                                               │
│                                                                  │
│ ¥ 25n MOLINIHIONL wioNgMts Hea Caneasaa                          │
│ ANIT SIH, M0138 NOIS HO aWris LON 00                             │
│                                                                  │
│ II8S9Z6S¢100                                                     │
│ “ou eBaeyory uBias0 pareioossy                                   │
│ XTNO LSOdad wod                                                  │
│                                                                  │
│ usw asuoona                                                      │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050407                                               │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GONE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013231 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161015                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY EPSTEIN
8100 A@ NOOK QUARTER, R3

ST. THOMAS, USVI 00802.1348
PAY TO THE United HealthCare ORDER OF
Three Hundred Forty and 00/100
DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST
COMPANY AMERICAS NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10154
1-103/210
12/14/2017
$ "340.00
MEMO
Greensboro Small Group
PO Box 740800
Atlanta, GA 30374-0800
Account # 3699018M
DOLLARS
I
I
I
z L1.1
CC
a.CC
a.
tr_
O
0 O)
U)
0 -4
>
-- I CI)
mO

• O --• C.4
N
n.) -4
N.) O
-UNA -1 ogwatiniltIAM „ Lox ou 0-, - MAW? 03WVN NIVIDA 40 ANn000v 01 03110,•“!. VN )4NV8 O9tNd STI3A4 AlN0 JJS0d3Q 807)
383K 3StI0CIN3
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQN(F IDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050409
DB-SDNY-0013233

╭─────────────────── Page 12, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ LbO7ZZZ/ ‘ALWA LISOd                                   │
│ LvE009SEL1 1S9 -N”                                     │
│                                                        │
│ un enn ova                                             │
│ oat ata “0°: BUAVd GHINUN Mire FO oo                   │
│ i 40 LNNOOSV OL G3.iGe«:,                              │
│ ‘WN UINVE Ou STIS «                                    │
│ XINO USOd3d HOS                                        │
│                                                        │
│ auan 3suoans C)                                        │
│                                                        │
│ connoenmat pursuant ro Fe0.n 6a IDEN TIAL ve sow201309 │
│                                                        │
│ EFTA_00161017                                          │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00602-1348
PAY
TO
THE
Woody
Allen
ORDER
OF
Three
Thousand
One
Hundred
Forty
-Three
and
50/100"*"
Julie
Braunshteyn
Geller
&
Co
3rd
Avenue

• New
York,
NY
MEMO
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
11/21/2017
$
"3,143.50
it*********************4-1.********
•ilr********111
•
*****
•111
I I I
nouAns
'9# S
E
§,
9z
w
O
O CO
z
OS O
F
31i 11 SU. M O I 7OIS .._ .4 00
KOK )999
heTW AOOC1M
COW N3MY AC
1P0312130d30 110:1
MC OBB0
TINOLIVN ALIO
unto 3H101 AVd
3t13N 3S1:100N3 •
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QP AKE I DENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050411
DB-SDNY-0013235
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
ST.
THOMAS,
USV1
00602-1348
PAY
TO
THE
York
Ave
Realty
Co
ORDER
OF
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
10/27/2017
$
"2,445.00
Two
Thousand
Four
Hundred
Forty
-Five
and
00/100

*******************tt*
*****
nou.ARs
AP I
York
Ave
Realty
Co
MEMO
TZW
SIG
C CA
W
C•1
Cg
Or •
el
;
§ ,•
z w
0i
z
c6
0 < p z w C ci
cd w -O zrn cc z 0 E: z
TZ0P999L9P00000
LI0Z/8/ZT
00SE0SI80
Ames suoTbau
Auedwoo AqTeau any NIOX lilt
ATuO iTsodau zb •
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.ctailE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013237
╭─────────────────────────────────────────── Page 17, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 1155 °                                                                                                  │
│ JEFFREY EPSTEIN DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST                                                                     │
│ 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, 83 NevCONPANY AMERICAS,                                                          │
│                                                                                                         │
│ ST. THOMAS, USVI 00802-1348 71037210 1416/2017 i                                                        │
│ é                                                                                                       │
│                                                                                                         │
│ PAY TO THE ”                                                                                            │
│ ORDER OF Florida Department of Revenue $ 1,347.24 |                                                     │
│ One Thousand Three Hundred Forty-Seven and 24/100t*r+e+eeeeeeeeeasessanessesssnssarsnnvannwnonnneee val │
│ Florida Department of Revenue i                                                                         │
│ Tallahassee Central Service Center a                                                                    │
│                                                                                                         │
│ PO Box 6417                                                                                             │
│                                                                                                         │
│ Tallahassee, FL 3314-6417 Rp                                                                            │
│ MEMO                                                                                                    │
│                                                                                                         │
│ Case No: 400089637 Tax period 9/01/16-03/31/17                                                          │
│                                                                                                         │
│ "AFTHORCED SYGNATU                                                                                      │
│                                                                                                         │
│ DB-SDNY-0013238                                                                                         │
│                                                                                                         │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050414                                                                                      │
│                                                                                                         │
│ conrivenmia. pursuant ro reo. ncaleMG IDENTIAL                                                          │
│                                                                                                         │
│ EFTA_0016102                                                                                            │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

€7.019100-V1.43
6CZCLoa-ANas-sa
Stv0S0001A19ANOS 1VI_LNJOIA ( Noy .03i onnivnsand -1VII.N30ldNO0
VD :20171129
BT :SALES
BN :06624
SUB :24
RJN :11
RTN :02'001033
ONUS:05.35269691/
AJX :00'155
Coupons
0600 0 20170331 0001003187 7 6400089637 0000 3
_
FLA Dept
of Revenue-TAL
STATE TREASURER
CONCENTRATION
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER.
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00802-1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
PAY
TO
THE
AFEX
ORDER
OF
10/31/2017
Eight
Thousand
Three
Hundred
Fifty
-Three
and
80/100*****""'""*"'*"*""*"*"'"*""'
""'
AFEX
MEMO
Nyolgan-359

╭────────────────────────────────────────────────── Page 19, Image 1 
───────────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 1151}                                                                                                                 
│
│ JEFFREY EPSTEIN DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST                                                                                   
│
│ 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, 83                                                                                             
│
│ ST. THOMAS, USVI 008021948 newvons gaz (oS 1031/2017                                                                  
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ PAY TO THE oy                                                                                                         
│
│ onven or___AFEX $ 8.953.80                                                                                            
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ Eight Thousand Three Hundred Fifty-Three and 80/100****"**reresresenseesteevartscnssssascsecucenrencenennensensenc ts 
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ DOLLARS                                                                                                               
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ AFEX                                                                                                                  
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ ED Secure tose. Deets on back                                                                                         
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ weno WYOURIUF 359                                                                                                     
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ DB-SDNY-0013240                                                                                                       
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050416                                                                                                    
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ conrivenmia. pursuant ro reo. 2 cabo MG IDENTIAL                                                                      
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ EFTA_00161024                                                                                                         
│
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
╯

5ZOI9100-V1.43
1.17ZCLOO-ANOS-90
/140C000-INDANOS 1VIINSCIINOin...agi O11NVfS21ld -1V1.1.N3OWNOO
O ENDORSE HERE
FOR DEPOSIT ONLY
Associated Foreign Exchange Inc.
001459265811 •
DO NOT WRITE. STAMP OR SIGN 6ELOW THIS LINE
RESERVED FOR •IN‘NCIAL. INS1 VI ION USE • . .
Date: 11/27/17
an
4' 4) co — cO
—
P.. CO C
▪ ••••• 0 0 N.. 00 set
O .0 0
CV • • (.1 A-
(...A CO

• AN C
0 0 O. 0,
a> 0 .10.0 .-- P..
a;
co co ; tO
FS St (Nov. A.:
T"? srecti •t; fea:tr.-• I -' c1 n5 OM Zs those
flof itSZP-1. t.•• feed in.. ••••fyg::i rn4 S.
4. :N. thrift: Fs• ty :ANS Ile-. • of dc.et Twig pue• l•nn:
• . - r "-err
••• 0 C • 1.1A

╭──────────────────────── Page 20, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ 2ssy                                                             │
│ asfs                                                             │
│ f3sn                                                             │
│ Ses                                                              │
│ =                                                                │
│                                                                  │
│ 66 ‘bas                                                          │
│                                                                  │
│ 21/22/11 eG                                                      │
│ 692260 :4yrleg                                                   │
│                                                                  │
│ : + Sgn NoILALiLgML TyIONeNIS Hoa GAURS aH                       │
│ BNIT SIHL MO139 NOIS HO dWYLS “3L1BM LON OG                      │
│                                                                  │
│ TI8S9%6Sb100                                                     │
│ “Duy oSueyoxg UBta104 poyeIoossy                                 │
│ XTINO LiSOddd Yor                                                │
│                                                                  │
│ auan asuoona @                                                   │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050417                                               │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GONE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013241 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161025                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
ST.
THOMAS.
USVI
00802-1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
PAY
TO
THE
Lesley
Groff
ORDER
OF
Four
Hundred
Forty
and
49/100
11/14/2017
$
"440.49
Lesley
Groff
MEMO
PM I 3
DOLLARS
I
SDNY_GM_00050418 p
CACA -
NVI
o:
Tn -ch O

╭─────────────────────────────────────── Page 21, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ ~ 1154                                                                                          │
│ DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST                                                                             │
│ JEFFREY EPSTEIN COMPANY AMERICAS                                                                │
│ 6100 RED Hi QUARTER, BS NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10154 i                                              │
│ ST. THOMAS, USVI 00802-1348 41037210 14/14/2017 iL                                              │
│ PAY TO THE “ 4 a                                                                                │
│ OADER OF _Lesley Groff _ _ __ $ 440.49 t                                                        │
│ Four Hundred Forty and 49/10Q"tssstservesrenenttntnestnennsntnetetsntntanintanentanceenntaees : │
│ a 8                                                                                             │
│ if                                                                                              │
│ a                                                                                               │
│                                                                                                 │
│ Memo                                                                                            │
│                                                                                                 │
│ “AUTROREED SIGNATURE U                                                                          │
│                                                                                                 │
│ DB-SDNY-0013242                                                                                 │
│                                                                                                 │
│ SSDNY_GM_ 00050418                                                                              │
│                                                                                                 │
│ conrivenmia. pursuant To reo. kcal MG IDENTIAL                                                  │
│                                                                                                 │
│ EFTA_00161026                                                                                   │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

.• ...powwow •••••••••• 4  rota.. rqj r• w,ow • • •••• • • •••••••••• ••••••••••1
vat%) jo %mg uo seem
jueum..loa jeui6uO, jo aouusly •
uolleafte len) a
own Jeod:.3 Audi s:o412 Jo Stot..3 •
paldopoicgd awn oug ve
sieuOUL DJ11 w CKJA$ news a •
:uoutuage juawnoop jo sunsad
ueaOS 4111(08S
;acted OMICtIOS AWX•110.0,
Otli'l ithI cf):DIN
:sat:mead Aumaas
*sou:iamb (orate paana poise jou
aspen se ficoM se moiaq palsy gamma/ ifipttaas- eqi
•mial
—ihs•
••
WONWV
W OO o
ctiOH
O HJ H
W
NHMH
HNHHW
NO. IPM
OJKI M
0-404Ws)
OA
IV 0
H
3sn Noun tp.sui /Vt3NYNIA H04 03A/13•33t1
aNn SIHI. M0138  NOIS jl0 dflY1S 'MUM ION  00
31:13H 3SUOON3
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QP .NEIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050419
DB-SDNY-00 13243
Al
JEFFREY EPSTEIN DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST
6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, B3 COMPANY AMERICAS
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10154 ST. THOMAS, USVI 001302-1348 1-103/210 10/25/2017 1 S
PAY TO
ORDER OFTHE JTCC $ "2,800.00 1
Two Thousand Eight Hundred and 00/100""" ********** """ ****** r" ********* "•••"••""*"—******   I _not.LARs I
MEMO
JTCC
do Vijay Paul 8 5200 Campus Drive
College Park, MD 20740
Invoice: 09/01/17 4 tickets US Open AUTHORVID SIONA
•
•
`r
I 44
is I ,  IN '1 I" SNI 'VIONVNId !gni 03 4N3S-ill
3811 SIHi N,0139 NDiS 80 totaVLS 3 litIM ION 00
'3N11/3.1113SNOTldtitVHO SINNal sowine
l  Lsocoa liOd
deli 00950
LLSMI
dO
L 'V ONIMNVe HONVI:18) 189838
LI3080 314101 AVd
3831.13580083 •
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QQ111F IDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050421
DB-SDNY-00 13245

╭─────────────────── Page 24, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ 4 BSN SWE IONE Hod QIAHaS aH                           │
│ ANIT StHa M0138 NDIS HO dMVLS “BLUM LON OG             │
│                                                        │
│ ke: p3¥L8 S000 a                                       │
│ “Ont SNOIdvEVHO SINNAL BOINNE                          │
│ ‘waIN9O ND L:s0da0 HOS                                 │
│                                                        │
│ “Bone009s0                                             │
│ NINE HONWHE) LEGS                                      │
│ snus Patty BHLOL AVG                                   │
│                                                        │
│ ‘                                                      │
│ 3u3H 3suoons @                                         │
│                                                        │
│ connoenmat pursuant ro Feo. ew IDEN TIAL ve sow 201305 │
│                                                        │
│ EFTA_00161029                                          │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
OUARTER,
ST.
THOMAS,
USYI
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
PAY
TO
THE
AFEX
ORDER
OF
Seven
Thousand
Two
Hundred
and
00/100'"""""*'"""*""""
AFEX
MEMO
t 1.20
-
EUR.
travel
to
Paris
10/6/2017
$
"7,200.00
•••••••••••
MIPOIThennelminikeen

6 1 I
nOLLARS
SONY_GM_00050422

╭──────────────────────────────────────────────── Page 25, Image 1 ─────────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ JEFFREY EPSTEIN                                                                                                   │
│ 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, 83                                                                                         │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ ST. THOMAS, USVI 00802:1348                                                                                       │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ PAY TO THE                                                                                                        │
│ orpen of___AFEX                                                                                                   │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ 1147-7                                                                                                            │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST                                                                                               │
│ COMPANY AMERICAS                                                                                                  │
│ NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10154                                                                                          │
│ Sess 10/6/2017                                                                                                    │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ $ *7,200.00                                                                                                       │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ Seven Thousand Two Hundred and 00/100*r*+#+#+eresensesnnoeseesesecensetnseseesnsnneenesesntressttncensnenneonsere │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ AFEX                                                                                                              │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ MEMO                                                                                                              │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ 11.20- 6000 EUR. travel to Paris                                                                                  │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ Davee Ohler                                                                                                       │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ DOLLARS                                                                                                           │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ ROTOREED SRATURE                                                                                                  │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ i                                                                                                                 │
│ i                                                                                                                 │
│ i                                                                                                                 │
│ i                                                                                                                 │
│ a                                                                                                                 │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050422                                                                                                │
│ DB-SDNY-0013246                                                                                                   │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ conrivenmia. pursuant To reo. kcal MG IDENTIAL                                                                    │
│                                                                                                                   │
│ EFTA_00161030                                                                                                     │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

.• • ••O

• ; ‘..' : •
. .
• .
•r W.,. it • t •i.• It • t,  %••t. ,:•O
T 1. •%•: •I 046.: , • a I'0• 104)
2 4041 ?I) A.: c••• s
. .v
•
03 ors co
CI -I a
• • • •
at a • • •
•Z•
sq.
-Iw.r 0
is '0 a V
• Vo 10
a • • C) 1/20
co Cs
•••
O
• ?S11 9citnLasmi Wlantl i e WolQattVjS10 . . .
3NI1 SINS M013$ NOIS b0 dflY1S '31ItIA% ION 00
I T8S9Z607100
alitratial afttod pospossv
* NINO IISO433(1 )10.4
383k 3S8O0N3 0
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QP .NE I DENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050423
DB-SDNY-0013247
EFFA_00161031

╭──────────────────────── Page 26, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ Te:                                                              │
│                                                                  │
│ LAsees bt CSLes- bos                                             │
│                                                                  │
│ eeeegeerer:o9 Eseiez ive                                         │
│                                                                  │
│ Dipeawesnzercs,                                                  │
│                                                                  │
│ 69S-SAN 98 KeMDgosg pue Uay                                      │
│                                                                  │
│ a                                                                │
│ - Fs                                                             │
│ | RRS                                                            │
│ i 2s                                                             │
│ ae:                                                              │
│ Sn                                                               │
│ Spy                                                              │
│ eat                                                              │
│ Nw                                                               │
│  @                                                               │
│ =8                                                               │
│ ‘                                                                │
│ anit Sin NEIae BIS Vo Uaers” SEluae LON oo                       │
│ T1s9z6st100                                                      │
│ 2 -puy a8ueqaeg wStaioy paeioossy                                │
│                                                                  │
│ XINO LISOddd YOd                                                 │
│                                                                  │
│ \ 3uan asuoons                                                   │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050423,                                              │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GQNE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013247 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161031                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

0 z m z -t rr -o CC zC h Cm_ r- OZVOS000-019-ANOS
podssed
IaneJl
OW31
,11
S
IN7100
00'00Z..
1 3
$
004/00
pue
paipumg
onni,
Ole/EON
VSLOL
NEIOA
MaN
111:I0A
M3N
SVOI83INV
ANIMWOO
.t.snas
>IWO
amosinaa
JO
H3431:10
3H101
AYd
ant-zosoo
insn
'email
-1S
'Heisvno
NOOK
CI au
oot9
NIMLSd3
ASEISA3r
1.1.03/8110t.
taloa

╭──────────────────────────────────────────────────────── Page 27, Image 1 
─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 1150                                                                                                                  
│
│ JEFFREY EPSTEIN DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST                                                                                   
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, 83 MPANY AMERICAS:                                                                             
│
│ ST. THOMAS, USVI 09802-1348 NEW YORK, NEW YORI 10164 40/18/2017 i                                                     
│
│ 5                                                                                                                     
│
│ PAY TO THE i” i                                                                                                       
│
│ ORDER oo g “200.00 :                                                                                                  
│
│ :                                                                                                                     
│
│ Two Hundred and 
00/100**#*###ss+sstssnssernesntnsnnunsadionenntenenenenennansnsnsneenenenaeaeeneaenantennnanaunennannens powans i │
│ 4                                                                                                                     
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ SDeuie a                                                                                                              
│
│ MEMO                                                                                                                  
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ ‘AUTHORED SGHATURE                                                                                                    
│
│ Travel passport                                                                                                       
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050424                                                                                                    
│
│ DB-SDNY-0013248                                                                                                       
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ conrioenmia. pursuant ro reo. x Gabo MG IDEN TIAL                                                                     
│
│                                                                                                                       
│
│ EFTA_0016103:                                                                                                         
│
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
────────────╯

3SA tiOil. rfril i I.o
31411 SINS MO13 • tIDIS i30 dWVSS '311k1M ION 00
983113SUO0N3
CONFIDENTIAL -PURSUANT TO FED R.CONE IDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050425
DB-SDNY-0013249

╭─────────────────── Page 28, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ 17 Sil MOS HDIS BO JHVLS 3LIUM LON OO                  │
│                                                        │
│ fed                                                    │
│                                                        │
│ auan asuoana g                                         │
│                                                        │
│ connoenmat pursuant ro Feo. 6a IDEN TIAL oe son 201309 │
│                                                        │
│ EFTA_00161033                                          │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00802.1348
1.1031210

10/13/2017
PAY
TO
THE
ORDER
Seven
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
OF
$
"706.00
I
DOLLARS
S
Hundred
Six
and
00/100

*******
**11-***•********IHS
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
W.
Main
Street
PO
Box
New
Albany,
OH
43054-0780
MEMO
Policy
invoice
#
Avu2A,A_
cOs4
Z, L1.1 C
C671 1
2  2
EtE.?4
to m
(c.
(§1
C4
66PM/00 IN11003V •
OHO lal1133 40 31440 EDNV$CISN'
VINO %WORT 110:i
Nt4Vfl MAL MAW
40 $300 3Nd, n
38:411 3.141OCN3 •
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED_ R.QPNE I DENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013251
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER.
B3
ST.
THOMAS.
USVI
00602.1349
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK.
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
PAY
TO
THE
AFEX
ORDER
OF
Ten
Thousand
and
00/100"*"
MEMO
AFEX
1.20672
-
8,290
EUR
for
1.142
e
9/25/2017
$
"10,000.00
DOLLARS
I 8
riarsORIZED
StallArURE
SDNY_GM_00050428 z uJ 0 Liz
cd ci O rn tr a.a. O
a .a •
•

• • 7•• : • 11. 1 •
ill, 4 • It: • • .d i
1niti
PSO.1; a' 1's. .n.; 4..44 : •••• ij •ira.:a i a „1
q•
••
te co Cl —1 t• •• •• 41> • • • •
.•••• N OP
r•• a OP
40 ha
• VP N a
• VP a
a • • ••••• Cl• ••• a a •
0 1Ir
0. 0 +a
a = O
•••• Oh
ch.O
CO ••••
n ae
CP.
SJ
CO
%Win ei, C•4i lviaNgraii30103iAlneil
3411 SIKI N.0110 NJI$ 110 clINVLS '3LIUM ION 00
I I8S9Z6gt I 00
•atii aumpr3 ugpsoj palepossy
NINO .LISOd3C1 NOd
3H314 3%100143 0
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED_ R.Q0 AKE I DENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050429
DB-SDNY-0013253

╭──────────────── Page 32, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ 2p peawosyrer:sdit t                             │
│ 1D L26R2L                                        │
│ CH/Li ZL SS eb— 508s                             │
│                                                  │
│ G8E-SAN DB AeMpecdg pue UiL                      │
│ seeegeacsr:                                      │
│                                                  │
│ gen                                              │
│ ze                                               │
│ Raa                                              │
│ SS                                               │
│ tu                                               │
│ onu                                              │
│ as                                               │
│ reo                                              │
│ =                                                │
│ BN                                               │
│                                                  │
│ #558 NOrLO NIN GH WIDNYels bod OJaNae as         │
│ NIT SIHL W.O13H NDIS HO dWVLS “341M LON OG       │
│                                                  │
│ TI8S976S¢T00                                     │
│ “ou aBuryoxy uBio104 poreisossy                  │
│ XINO LSOd1d YOA                                  │
│                                                  │
│ auan asuoona @                                   │
│                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050429                               │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GONE IDENTIAL │
│                                                  │
│ DB-SDNY-0013253                                  │
│ EFTA_00161037                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00802.1348
PAY
TO
THE
ORDER
OF

Jordan
Josephson
One
Thousand
Four
Hundred
Forty
-Five
and
00/100
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
9/20/2017
**********
******
Int*
**A
**A
tintr•ilr****
Int
MEMO
Jordan
Josephson
Madison
Avenue,
9th
Floor
New
York,
NY
Jeffrey
Epstein
Account
# 0028147
PA
,
SONY_GM_00050430
oc
l7
C
z
w
thC

╭─────────────────────────────────────────────── Page 33, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ 1141                                                                                                            │
│ JEFFREY EPSTEIN DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST                                                                             │
│ 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, 63 coupaty AMERICAS                                                                      │
│ ST. THOMAS, USVI 00802-1348 EN ORK er 10154 9/20/2017                                                           │
│ 1E                                                                                                              │
│ AGES bee __ Jordan Josephson $ 71-445.00                                                                        │
│ One Thousand Four Hundred Forty-Five and 00/100***te-srwesssesessansessenseerasessteneeananseseseaeeceneeneeate │
│ DOLLARS:                                                                                                        │
│ Jordan Josephson                                                                                                │
│ 425 Madison Avenue, 9th Floor                                                                                   │
│                                                                                                                 │
│ New York, NY 10017                                                                                              │
│ MEMO ED                                                                                                         │
│ Jeffrey Epstein Account # 0028147                                                                               │
│                                                                                                                 │
│ ED seouty toate Dette on bank.                                                                                  │
│                                                                                                                 │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050430                                                                                              │
│ DB-SDNY-0013254                                                                                                 │
│                                                                                                                 │
│ conrioenmat pursuant ro Feo. 6a IDEN TIAL                                                                       │
│                                                                                                                 │
│ EFTA_00161038                                                                                                   │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

I., I 114O111. "Ni 'VC3NVN b :••• 01:54.41
VOISIN, m0139 t,019 HO dfVlS •3illim LON 00
LOZ.14:1.1
13 3114 tvQ. • le :or s Nvouor
A.:, 1.0 .
•
3914 9900N3 •
CONFIDENTIAL -PURSUANT TO FED_ R.QPNE I DENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050431
DB-SDNY-0013255

╭──────────────────────── Page 34, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ Peon Sy IVOONYN $y 24 OTA tH                                     │
│ 3NIT SIN, MOTAG ROIS YO GWW1S “BLUR LON OG                       │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050431                                               │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GQNE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013255 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161039                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00802-1348
PAY
TO
THE
J
ORDER
OF

Jordan
Josephson
Four
Hundred
Seventy
and
00/100
MEMO
Jordan
Josephson
Madison
Avenue,
9th
Floor
New
York,
NY
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
$
9/14/2017
*****
*****
kit
•
dr*********************•
OH
• ***it
***********4t****************************
Jeffrey
Epstein
Account
# 0028147
LI
ALINORIZED
SIGNATURE
C -t
to
c -
0.1
"I
o
w
DS C
4 •4011IIOLSill WION410- ISO, 03(i.0. itl -
31441 SIN a M0139 ttOIS S0 dINVIS '311tIM ION 00
‘00:.* JY
Did a! ;•.Del -L' nvcdor
Atei . • '1...;1103
292/4 35900N3 •
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QP .NE I DENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050433
DB-SDNY-0013257

╭─────────────────── Page 36, Image 1 ────────────────────╮
│ “                                                       │
│                                                         │
│ 430 NOLLULLSML TWIN BRI HO G32 Has a                    │
│ AN.7 SIH: MOT3G NOIS BO dwVEs “31iBmM LON OO            │
│                                                         │
│ yodor                                                   │
│                                                         │
│ sua asvoona @                                           │
│                                                         │
│ conroenmat pursuant ro Feo. ew IDEN TIAL ve soN 2013087 │
│                                                         │
│ EFTA_00161041                                           │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

PAY
TO
THE
ORDER
OF
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER.
ST.
THOMAS,
US
VI
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
840/sofa
$ %,554
x)c
EIGHT
TI-kal
t\li)
71\ir
I-RINZQF
1---1 FT
I
FOl
DOLLARS
MEMO
%AO
c1.405
AP
SONY_GM_00050434 p z w C LIZ
O rn

╭────────────── Page 37, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ 102i |                                        │
│ JEFFREY EPSTEIN DEUTSCHE BANK TRUST           │
│ 6100 RED HOOK QUARTER, 83 COMPANY AMERICAS /  │
│ {HO0RED HOOK QUARTER NEW TOR HEWN se LAE      │
│                                               │
│ ¥-103210                                      │
│ PAY TO THE                                    │
│ ORDER OF. Afex $ g SS ie                      │
│                                               │
│ EIGHT THOUSAND ETE HUNQDE DLE TY FOUR, Be ins │
│                                               │
│ ED secur secures. Ona on back,                │
│                                               │
│ Daten                                         │
│                                               │
│ "ATIGRZED SHONATURE                           │
│                                               │
│ MEMO ooo €ulos                                │
│                                               │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050434                            │
│ DB-SDNY-0013258                               │
│                                               │
│ conroenmat pursuant ro Feo. 6a IDEN TIAL      │
│                                               │
│ EFTA_0016104:                                 │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────╯

•
AICORCPI. • -a. %Fp 1..••••••J ";
A ' ''' .soner..P; .110 • 7.71: :. ' 11.21
•°snit; ; t. ' •• s' 41 n' i .1
•Y ?I z•-•
tri *RfN
h-4 X`•
O :le
Co in DP
a.
* r a, •C
0.1
C >n an,
or
LI/VI/60 :alECI
Jr 3Sr. ,;()IinujcNi IY IDNY Pe 4 LW! 1:13:r3Sitf
3NI1 SIFil M0138 NO'S SO drIVIS 3.11t1AS ION 00
II8S9ZGStI00
•Dui athimpri u5!aled porepossy
/VINO 'Bona 11O,4
383H 3S800N3 0
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.WN(E IDENTIAL SIDNY_GM_00050435
DB-SDNY-0013259

╭──────────────────────── Page 38, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ $99 cerrse                                                       │
│                                                                  │
│ iv                                                               │
│                                                                  │
│ Sy peauosyaerssdid t                                             │
│ L                                                                │
│                                                                  │
│ GRE-SAN DQ Aempcoug pue yay                                      │
│ eseeges                                                          │
│                                                                  │
│ ey                                                               │
│ Sie                                                              │
│ gaan                                                             │
│ Son                                                              │
│ £en                                                              │
│ ge                                                               │
│ RE                                                               │
│ =s                                                               │
│ S                                                                │
│ ga                                                               │
│                                                                  │
│ #3sh Nona LIsME WioNyNe) wos aaseasae                            │
│ BNIT SIHL MOI3G NOIS HO dWVLS 3LIUM LON OG                       │
│                                                                  │
│ IT8S9Z6SP100                                                     │
│                                                                  │
│ “uy aSuryoxg UBto104 poreroossy                                  │
│                                                                  │
│ XINO LISOd3d YOA                                                 │
│                                                                  │
│ auan asuoona @                                                   │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050435,                                              │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GQNE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013259 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161043                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER.
ST.
THOMAS.
USVI
00602-1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
PAY
TO
THE
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
ORDER
OF
Forty
-Four
Thousand
Nine
Hundred
Sixty
-Eight
and
42/100
8/2/2017 "44,968.42
MEMO
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
W.
Main
Street
PO
Box
New
Albany,
OH
43054-0780
Policy
invoice
#
1 I I
naljas
SONY_GM_00050436
ca /h
?? 0z
is,
thC
p z w LL2—,
u_ rn O
V!)13 1. 1•••• • 00 4rJV 1'; 1.011 (la
66S ItiSLOO 11411033V
-Atio1V)111433 ao 331.4A0 3omnsru
,k1R01180d3G 1103
NNYS OHL RIAU
AO 113(110 gsuoaN3 •
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QP AKE I DENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050437
DB-SDNY-0013261
EF1'A_00161045

╭──────────────────────── Page 40, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ he SPU kes oo UVES TEMA Lon 0G                                   │
│                                                                  │
│ Gos tzssiu0 INTODOY                                              │
│ saya TYINO 40 TOHIO FONVBASNT                                    │
│ KINO 18040 HOA                                                   │
│ NVA GUIHL HAM                                                    │
│ 40 YAGYO ABLOLAVEL ssuo0ns @                                     │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_00050437                                                │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GONE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013261 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161045                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

• JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
MOO
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00802-1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
•
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
.
•
718/2017
PAY
TO
THE
ORDER
OF

Seton
Hal
University
•
$
"17,060.00
.
sonmseminintinumwas..."•.,
*****
•
/
nouARS
'
Seventeen
Thousand
Sixty
and
00/100
.
.
Seton
Hall
Unive
,p
40-$
1.94/777y
H
.ea/Z
P
t
. . Fall
and
Snrina
201R
Shia/
PC(72glee
t
MEMO
•
I 5
47:(w H 0 O 0 0_ LLl
909:13 JO 902Q uo efiev
1.;t4tustar.,a istneva, JO a out
ucgekTiie n230.
tom teortle 4etu r.ndorx•intid uatim dap Oi1IL: •
knetssit• Zi.wt
:hoiswinge watanoop Jos
.; -Saupprip6.41s. 11
:; r301/1 90 Haus SE '440eafj 08;5
lite '440 49•Ssi
—
Viii SINS N.0138 LAOIS
:Loons AN.c.-.415 !,1•

• r.g.ted its sic:140Q
•
'd
L790JAS 'POISE JOU a 7 ,
nig* iiptoe; ;ha •„.4,
CJ" uudo,•?e  41:sositeed Apinocfrs;
o Q (ne
24..a . 1:!
O O a
V 0
VJ
t/.I' 0
. 0-
V •
dPIWAS '3111tItit ION 00
• ...•• --.Aq.pairadag
!sianlun IIEH uolaS
isnAlury ileirturas
Aluoaliseifigag30
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.QP .NE I DENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050439
DB-SDNY-0013263
EF1'A_00161047
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST.
THOMAS,
Mel
00802-1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
PAY
TO
THE
ORDER
OF

Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
Fifty
-One
Thousand
Seven
Hundred
Thirty
-Six
and
tint
7/26/2017
*1151,736.00
MEMO
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
W.
Main
Street
PO
Box
New
Albany,
OH
43054-0780
Policy
invoice
# 226253
_bouARs
tia
r; • '1 " 66
Cacc100iNn033V
7VILIAZ dO 3311i0 33NtinSi 7NO itSOd70 NOd NNVU (1111111 Had dO if3GUO 3H1. %Alit
"PAH 3SLIOON3
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.cOFNE IDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050441
DB-SDNY-0013265

╭──────────────────────── Page 44, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ tne unGOSICSSLW NOY                                              │
│ HO WINGS Jo DINO sony                                            │
│ ANowsouaG yoy                                                    │
│ NYS CMIHL isang                                                  │
│ 40 83040 3H OL Ag                                                │
│                                                                  │
│ saan ssuoona @                                                   │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050441                                               │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GONE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013265 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161049                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST,
THOMAS,
USVI
00802-1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
7/13/2017
PAY
TOTE
HE
German
International
School
Boston

$
"14,260.00
ORDER
Fourteen
Thousand
Two
Hundred
Eighty
and
00/100""
***
*****
""""""""""*"*""'"
*****
.1" ****
"'
are
"
MEMO
German
International
School
Boston
attn:
Paula
Spencer
Holton
Street
Boston,
MA
AUTHORIZED
SIGNATURE
Taiyo
Bach
and
Aino
Bach
school
bill
Invoice
#3135
I
DOLLARS
_I < p z C ra a ci
U-0 I-z rn z ILI z a:
C 7
ti
•
LO.
•-•
aw t-•
0 0 a%
I+
.8 G tp.
-4
-4 N
.1S0 NC. I Li.1 1 ' 0 • r :.. V: .1
/AC 1L .I.OM CAI
Our UO1 gOS IOC 14.1
05fT0E170
06i6PL5
v.req Axelluop
AUTO lisociPU loi
2unoray filmrtkasio
TPL10#14010.544 Raligeo
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QPN(E IDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050443
DB-SDNY-00 13267

╭──────────────────────── Page 46, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ ogetoett                                                         │
│                                                                  │
│ 102                                                              │
│ 920 OT aN                                                        │
│                                                                  │
│ BMI ORE foe                                                      │
│ Ceara WOON en                                                    │
│                                                                  │
│ aseroerto}                                                       │
│ osterss                                                          │
│                                                                  │
│ ued genenss|                                                     │
│                                                                  │
│ Aquo yts0dag a                                                   │
│                                                                  │
│ qunoaz¥ bu rietado|                                              │
│                                                                  │
│ pur gory Tocuas Truc ARAHASUQONE,                                │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050443,                                              │
│ CONFIDENTIAL ~ PURSUANT TO FED. R. GONE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013267 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161051                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00802.1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1.103/210
5/30/2017
PAY
TO
THE

AFEX
$
'117,497.60
ORDER
OF
Seven
Thousand
Four
Hundred
Ninety
-Seven
and
60/100""*"*"*"'""mn'e
nt
"
AFEX
I
LIARS
la
MEMO
Euros
1.136
rate
8 0 H z w
•
it.'.'•8 11:;'Wo )C1" 'U AV:e.t.a
.Q nj  •• • r .iir  in I
,) .• a... ,..9 • ii.. u..;j
• •• A•••41
tY) * 10 VI
CI
-.1 a —•
a m
a ION
C. 'V tO
= N to
--• cs) t's
o r a cr.
Y w• :•> 0.0 • .4 •-•
GI
C in
Ip
— tp
Cl • . 0
a n.
••:
VI
U./
LT
/90!L0
:aleCI
3Sfu rici tnit LS. t4I HOd
;Nil Slid MO139 NOIS 80 dVIVLS ION CI
11859Z6Ci7100
•oui 321ISq3X3 0213103 paMpOSSV
KINIO 11S0d3(1 1104
I
383H 3SH00N3
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.ctO .NEIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050445
DB-SDNY-00 13269

╭──────────────────────── Page 48, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ weap yes                                                         │
│                                                                  │
│ BeLbL ive                                                        │
│                                                                  │
│ fr                                                               │
│                                                                  │
│ 3                                                                │
│ LI/9O/18 75108 Das                                               │
│                                                                  │
│ pervades                                                         │
│                                                                  │
│ zst :bas                                                         │
│                                                                  │
│ 21/90/20 :aeG                                                    │
│ 6802b2 sure”                                                     │
│                                                                  │
│ “og BSF NOIEAUI SNL TYIONYN'y HOS O9AHaS Ie                      │
│ ANIT SiH MOTIE NOIS UO awLs “SLUM LON                            │
│                                                                  │
│ ' 11gS9Z6SP100                                                   │
│                                                                  │
│ uy aBtreqoxg UBi910J paretoossV                                  │
│ NINO Lsodda wor                                                  │
│                                                                  │
│ auan asuo0ns @                                                   │
│                                                                  │
│ ‘SDNY_GM_ 00050445                                               │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GONE IDENTIAL DB-SDNY-0013269 │
│                                                                  │
│ EFTA_00161053                                                    │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER.
ST.
THOMAS.
USVI
00802.1348
PAY
TO
THE
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
ORDER
OF
Forty
-Four
and
31/100
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
6127/2017
$
"44.31
MEMO
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
W.
Main
Street
PO
Box
New
Albany,
OH
43054-0780
Policy
001949408-05
invoice
# 225596
NIMORIZED
SKINAIURE
I S I I
_DOLLARS
•
N ' 1•I 3'1 1. 'W. 110 .1:': 3. • . 1 11... 1 1..113 3/0
66S1ZSSL00 314(1033V
011101VILIN33 30 331d30 33NVW1St%
/1110 11S0d30
NNVEl ab1H1111413
40 )111010 3H.1.01O4 I i3H 3SU0GN3 •
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED R.CON(F IDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050447
DB-SDNY-0013271
EFFA_00161055
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00802-1348
PAY
TO
THE
ORDER
OF

Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
One
Thousand
Three
Hundred
Fifty
-Five
and
40/100'
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
W.
Main
Street
PO
Box
New
Albany,
OH
43054-0780
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
6/16/2017
VP 5
$
"1,355.40
I
.4...
,........

I
-DOUARS
i 8
SDNY_GM_00050448 p z
MEMO
Policy0009202711
AUTriOACED
invoice
#
SPAGNA
11.1 C Ze.t.C,16
ci O rn
•• • ell •-•t. !• . i • 11 " I. •
,••';• r•
•1 • • ; re' I 'iv i• i• L'
I ZI.,1 AI B A. .74  • ° I t
* ihn :n ens -tvianerra I n 4Att
3 101 SIHI /1.01 3P NOES 80 dLVVLS I lilkiPA ION 00
66S I ZgLOO 11411003V
011101VILLN33 AO gOlE0 aDNVIIIISNI KINOIISOBG 1101
NNW! RUH
JO II3G110 3111 01 Mil, 3SUOON3 0
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QP .NEIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050449
DB-SDNY-00 13273
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST.
THOMAS.
USVI
00802-1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-1031210
PAY
TO
THE
Metropolitan
Painting
Interiors
ORDER
OF
8/7/2017
$
"508.59
Five
Hundred
Eight
and
5wioo
*****
4****************•***********.nts**************••••••••••••••••***********************••**
Metropolitan
Painting
Interiors
Broadway,
3rd
FL
New
York
NY
MEMO
balance
TV
Room
painting
1 I I
°aim's
SONY_GM_00050450
•• '.s'^ Outs' 013.....• —4.. •
:•
I-J. /p..1PP All
d
. .

• 3S11 NOisfp .i.:—.SN. iV
3Nil SIMI M0138 LAOIS H
'‘ 7 NO4 03AV?citi
'31ItIA ION 0
GPOI
tiOdOlitert
NJ 8Od
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.ctON(E IDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050451
DB-SDNY-0013275

╭──────────────────── Page 54, Image 1 ────────────────────╮
│ “9 aS) NOrafai SN. IW oe                                 │
│ BNIT SIHL MOT38 NOIS UE 1ON 6                            │
│                                                          │
│ conioenmat pursuant ro Feo. Ge IDEN TIAL ve sor -2010075 │
│                                                          │
│ EFTA_00161059                                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
B3
ST.
THOMAS,
USVI
00802.1348
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
5/16/2017
ORDER
0FE
Kellerhals
Ferguson
Kroblin
PLLC
$
**911.19
PAY
TO
TH
Nine
Hundred
Eleven
and
19/100**********
n****
44****************************
*******""*"*"
MEMO
Kellerhals
Ferguson
Kroblin
PLLC
Royal
Palma
Professional
Building
Estate
Thomas,
Suite
St
Thomas,
VI
00802-3602
noLLARS
M` S
Invoice
#
AUTISORCIZO
MONA
JCL-
. .

• /Lola , aD JIM -4A .JtI CIO
291.90001
11111003V BNUNS3dO
ond inineoam N0SR9213i SWH83113),
LINO 1190430 NO.4
let7L909 Z0•
MNV9 WIDB3VOINO0 SINVH383141
AO 443080 344101 ad
3U3H 7iSt100143 •
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.QO .NEIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050453
DB-SDNY-00 13277
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
ST.
THOMAS.
USVI
00802-1348
PAY
TO
THE
Metropolitan
Painting
Interiors
ORDER
OF
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK.
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
6/1/2017
$
"508.59
Five
Hundred
Eight
and
****•****************InIneiter********6••*••••************I******
Metropolitan
Painting
Interiors
Broadway,
3rd
FL
New
York
NY
MEMO
50%
deposit
TV
Room
painting
S I
DOLLARS
t A 8
eI .e co
_
,.... <4 ,t
A
a
z
'
3 9
,
m
I
I
>-z
is,
1 0
> z
as
• 3SA lri) r.13 tQa Ont1/393::
3t411 emamoias Idols SO vvels ILIUM .I.0N 00
IN V*
Ole WOM
£41111$1,44 W
ONO
NI LI
OU33 -
e03
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.CON(F IDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050455
DB-SDNY-0013279
EFFA_00161063
JEFFREY
EPSTEIN
RED
HOOK
QUARTER,
ST,
THOMAS,
USVI
00802-1348
PAY
TO
THE
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
ORDER
OF
Two
Thousand
Six
Hundred
Seventy
-Four
and
00/100
DEUTSCHE
BANK
TRUST
COMPANY
AMERICAS
NEW
YORK,
NEW
YORK
1-103/210
MEMO
Insurance
Office
of
Central
Ohio
W.
Main
Street
PO
Box
New
Albany,
OH
43054-0780
Policy
invoice
#
5/16/2017
$
"2,674.00

__DOLLARS
fa
SONY_GM_00050456
'.I it .:O1 0O .2.4 VI • 1LIII i•'N ' ICI
66S1ML00 iNc1033V
ntho TIMJKA3 AO ' IA AO 33NYTISNI
A1t10 IlSc )O0
(1111tii RUH
AO INCIE0 31110s ma 3SUOON3 •
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R.Q;;;)N(F IDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00050457
DB-SDNY-0013281

╭────────────────────── Page 60, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ i                                                            │
│                                                              │
│ 4                                                            │
│ fs)                                                          │
│ BS                                                           │
│ ty                                                           │
│ cet                                                          │
│ 2                                                            │
│ o                                                            │
│ a                                                            │
│ is                                                           │
│ FS                                                           │
│ ¥'                                                           │
│                                                              │
│ Furus oN 08                                                  │
│                                                              │
│ InEt aber eb VE! wots ao                                     │
│                                                              │
│ G6S1ZSSLUV LN}OIOY                                           │
│                                                              │
│ THO TVHINGO 40 901430 FONVUNSNS                              │
│ KINO LUSi4a0 WOd                                             │
│ INVES GUTH Hal                                               │
│                                                              │
│ 40 WACNO BHI. OL AVA                                         │
│                                                              │
│ iw ssu0083 @                                                 │
│                                                              │
│ CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. GONE IDENTIAL esoiraoisst │
│                                                              │
│ EFTA_00161065                                                │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00004046 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-21)
1B1-21)
1
\

╭──── Page 2, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007501 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2005
(inferred date: 2026-01-21)
phone bill covering 2005
EFTA00008892 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Ghislaine Maxwell
EFTA00004043 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-22)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ 1B1-22a           │
╰───────────────────╯

I rate
EFTA00004179 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-22)
1 12
Date Received
From

• FD-340c(4-11-03)
File Number  - 3D27571
Field Office Acquiring Evidence  Nkiin
Serial it of Originating Document
5 /2/9
•
. (Nana
(Address)
icy and State)
By
ToBeReturned ❑ Yes Q No
RecciptGiven ❑ Yes Q No. •
Grand Stay Material - Disseminate Only Pursuant to Rule 6 (e)
Federal Rules of Criminal Pmcedure
0 yes [21 No
Federal ellopayer Information (PTO
0 Yes
Titles \11.-1'eXview
El No
Reference:
(Communication Enclosing Material)
Descri Von: Oxi * notes re interview of
51 /4
rAtet,L. ,
Saw "ex OR
LIVIA ( mad have moved *o R. OADA-ht, 16
- IN ieli,e24,d4.J.,
0
4
AM
kee it-D W-
° 1.-N R lam makt mow- beta.- toarazIt I
Still in 1..n., . icr
fr. C Is VS, jyt 10.w- Cturrustsk
- hot Su.2.- 1.1-- tt70V-
0
4 IA*
L hat 1/31 .5 e DE ?arta irt3 4
_ o " LAte. ..
P4 A. 0 ( .49.)2415a.U.A4.4 I \-• alki
- Not %u-.re (-.c. -tb o  lc  a_tnAosb so-re.
o Liu  -I-AnS n"Y_ syle .1 deny eoi 9
IR c not stf_c_IP_ 17ro Vir t- bt.,
81 II Scieeet Want now 4 -ring moved r•L to W5
rou.ld ha herr R ciI
Agra e'ri a-- 6 C s
Oil boinal Ition'r ip Se
9 %rep+ b pos<b1A4
0
- -friends og . •PrierbeiS - 6 is 15 ray' I tiox, p
IN V01- 1)1
@rou
-- boievu'iro ca.- n darker sk:trm,4 - totes &maze ri ;aft
- -
- via -41x I - 2 ii r n !dice, Out stA_re.)
- fitspn.rat< -him, r it. n n rns 0 Ft+ of r lc 9i
- -Fr is (met s tA) I S kilt.. -C/ir rids
- -1.6 4 ; dyi ti- °van+ Spanish or dark. /itY I
- cy) In, to wA i -4-  in t2owl ‘forc.144 - kno -kni took her .
r~a
4-_ P -,1
)r
-ocsn -now kJ tio
0-tin
00 \-1 . was iii-O1-  ha pc9 vj kice.
r IP tf
- ■ SELL/ " I don-l- know w at
m 0 ViceP -'-b "whakdn'ne) , wilt/ hvi'nei K5 Akc dark 3} r I od?mmx. yk, , - gi2nr-r Cris yaw, j ir I 10° ,, \‘''-. ort
\fet l y+ lint flare"
I 4 - tb±4_h &r bs Sktstk tia an:Lfr:i -o hca
- d-D-esn -1- f twIts , 14 kve i4 hie ()aid Wok lie Wash t4
44-fri
- St paid Net
— bath tom
onc. itrSO lin nas 4 boobs nca r fzeth-Fub raffriitei 91
- - he crt m SH.awere fnld lithe (etAri dust- bring
Girls h-r ApeCal 11 i: let
_iviet n °AH al . took in 'Mr Sit -Is
. .
wi or? 90 to* h Yvl asr-i not far lb. -In slid
etink-eal rviake Sur -e maw hear 18 bit hi- lilAcen -I-
J 10 c acts.,15ze_Adsr  txt Ion no t nq 12-€.1iPtiornA -th e-rn
mon. Dian 3) re,
11.12/151- Ruspl,e, ■
WDYirtek. t P ■ MT 1-al LS in 56 -
Cat a-lond- Matt n3 tivtonael
tiviA.5 - km Mate_ Yoh-al sb .1.1 I i v ins inn Mom
WI MIMI 'ilrIZA.i rent*eel oat eMS (LI 13
moved auk eseal' °Ate -C-mon trazi I
at 14 -I. was ma6W -olcite than
- .- have SO Atte bile that.' I VI 0-IN he S nal- go Inc, to
so -Pi m- 1-1,v-r thatA lAj O- he 1 orha. hew? Ipt -fro . Less
-PA) ilth fl ipteleS,
- Won* upc,tairs \hi
rani- faun - c-1-1-5 reiala in ave. WI heit
if had wriainisegr - tvartk iiviaxi!zte said do Satr-h/pairvh`nri of
or tvri-ivvit- - ■ -tpok- -cycnirini`ns hfC (via lc, a ) net •e.64
ra,i, - -St aprvbaxittel Ino-nol to cticct
1011 bvt. ale - 4nesn-l- t- < f c EA v o h OA- 1t -e. sasi
se c v- in V' Y1 trivuturof <s+
hand Move kiet.nd atm./4N laz2k
had ho reyorr---e- .5o fi e. thaaCiacci_
iatik:/ cu43_1).1_s_ hard i-sroi hair of
- raid let-P4-30-F i
- -k<AA '9 c*fltn' i irts tb A 4.AI 111w. l'-e (AnCon -Fox-1-0301,
IA ilok Akiar.\-in -k-o -i-ake aff updaruaccu-4.
- cIair k cenciukuvo Vie \i‘N mcvn.0 ti wuzs \do tint (4 Mai be S )
boo d-e. - .-<€. initoclu_ceel her is
colrl .s\--  laSt -1-ivor t• , -
riot Stkrte.
at-hcr -Km/Ls Kcal it ei pat Se 1-inru_ to
Se refeak-eAlui rot( acticic -Cur hell.)
to AI — .1.6 (AA, 6 -to captc. in. w
- Thom ADDV_. of* c,t&tws
- aielm vuturi- 1-z Mk. in i-irryaf -up

tA) 5e.

╭──── Page 6, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

0
WO 1-11-0st- 1`n bertin.12.ivsina -ica1 12 in5
-Ih i ri k. ',R ad told he.
■
ma...g.o-e t-
t  11' 6"  \Wm- non ,u  to LA cif\ h. Cs gut-!$ 11/O14i
rvippl es 1

ne. how bad. is (-I-
., rut mat barn 1 a ft-er 1/22- Il ;4-s ci-onx
wat friends lir
— ■ itile. 01 oter +10 Yi
- k- 2.x hAnsgpo Immo,
-
n eft, at hex
met Ai lict.v.t. jotrin4VIA- her 1st iiskAft, - 11O-11 suS _
I
w
T1Eb__TOS
ovtai4b, ISA to
7 ( HI* & in -Penney 42_0)
la AA p Yiria,\I \nave_ \t 5ive ,n \ou It
iNak-e_d , --k-riin.k VAAi. k1of hA-Cv 2 4 up IaMps (se lbrawoman tamp`
3,)
+yt his %Acme ( Witt Si- in 1c_il-c_h en)
ISA. Lo 0

14. 61 9.  k4 an I- to 4to ) sank/vat-1-
het Lust Vilest 3ra.kre_n
Sa ( in. tSi6x1e-9 1`) elm tkeccrS )
11 \it)
Sirocco wo ,r‘tios at club Th en sell -flovueic
%,
etke ) ( In g ioChtsite 12 i nv4.erl bitee3 * .I.k w ar te_ca cck cltab
rouip"pe
I C, b g /04- date on bock_ t
et: t_j3r ali \ is a n pet cod 0 )

16) scia4ers on tux; d A.( p‘ncto l ( ra,nyt -N-nn -Rim& )
tinint ,510,tinscsMR64_ nsl
bn1 tn3
I -2X -I-1Vrtk vkken1- tke %1/4.)‘ tur\
004 &Arne gy p.
11) (NIS# Sva Gee t n pie)
‘2* nn ex-lime- )
13. (same -141p as i-oto
14 -) l b' -1c- 1 (n+ de -b nit)
(newer wen+ -to ;.cf-,)
\CIM -Fr or\A. 5F.
Vo - • 041sT 9 - )
itme, 0-F i st pies on 1k\ knIVAX\ 1\Abthesi *a

╭──────────────── Page 8, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ PHOTos                                          │
│                                                 │
│ Cyst St_itn former apt)                         │
│                                                 │
│ ome nay ave been aiven lay 36 —                 │
│                                                 │
│ ~nink Yaniger Wived up lamps (SE Wad onan lamp) │
│ We Wis Nor                                      │
│ QM i sin vitenen)                               │
│                                                 │
│ \6Ateyo                                         │
│                                                 │
│ } | (fF Yankee game went +o)                    │
│                                                 │
│ ot Sure When soken                              │
│                                                 │
│ | Cin Disney New Ueers )                        │
│                                                 │
│ sl                                              │
│ yo                                              │
│ (|) Mt syo                                      │
│ Sirocto wor a chun then. ow.                    │
│ 2 aye i                                         │
│ 8 Gis eechestee invited Loy orouereonie )       │
│ lohalou ote on \oack worked ak tes              │
│ a) RN cota cacade)                              │
│                                                 │
│ Some person widde phot 1 (Bn'gitton Reach)      │
│                                                 │
│ | twink she was SEDs elena                      │
│ Rowember byt nging,                             │
│                                                 │
│ w                                               │
│ 12x. 2 an went up wl av)                        │
│                                                 │
│ __\)] BBB Mn sere ase m gic)                    │
│                                                 │
│ —_____12)| anmey tine. )                        │
│ (same trip as pote 8)                           │
│                                                 │
│ is bday __(oext cle tp 4%) |                    │
│ ex Went to Te) |                                │
│                                                 │
│ \amios From sé                                  │
│                                                 │
│ GM ss)                                          │
│                                                 │
│ one of 1 pics on Y\SF When Wbved tneee          │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

( eDthe.Si-
Stst-er 1-il st Sk- -c-rbYlk
A ftcoe  -Wet 1123 raC
Same aot as 11.0
Soin ou-1-- ta Br4zilian pm--Iti

A. 6/c042. 6-z lis peom 261 8 `f V2 I' zip
Ap I I
D. )
tin V. tams pot& 614 1315 LA n , , ,
unk , cl 'd O
Orincp golf to cLu-bs
r. Ca unk neif.,ical ,

╭─────────── Page 9, Image 1 ───────────╮
│ 17)| (2ocne —                         │
│ 18. ister ae Sk_frovt                 │
│ e.                                    │
│                                       │
│ \4 | Game dey af ie)                  │
│                                       │
│ an z                                  │
│ |____ oina our 42 Brazilvan pacty     │
│                                       │
│ all Sle/o2 ye tte peom BD (esi ae? x) │
│                                       │
│ | i                                   │
│                                       │
│ oe i                                  │
│                                       │
│ Groupe gving to Clubs                 │
│                                       │
│ é am i                                │
╰───────────────────────────────────────╯

I/ (SO- /15-t I'Vt 423-C (IS V.3 \ FRI
- doebn- 3/4- p avtelutlae..e.. eAton Om ftlei S a ic-I
- too O'er i CILLS e-r-H navous t v
- et& -E41 Laallanecal8alailes---_
- v seared
rslayi 4- Kneym> l'.-P coon ho, oho it 3a.; \ 10101 Clsk-Pel
Cf LleSitonc.
- agalt5 Hirt “ritndlt{ 44-ian 0,7( oce Cato ci-n*Aie.
- Star-PS to pl-ess St , pa-als on (a )
- he 111-49,z4 her  - vvein-l- hart I:71i cgi-4 no+ uts I
- can4- roil/I-014176g. but think 2ret -41186e- e-SY-ed it ftt kg.
Pants on ( n o hat 1st' -El mi.-)
- 2-"A -I-iNnitc, hr rn 1-)12.9 ei bv--easts 1
- rod -tsS 11) IASI/ r
us4.. Oh
-SU FUT p le Mal —1±4-_thA -C.
S0.W - smagitioas....sni_iitarie ?cm en,L  \1/4) I - us-ed when nak-gd
- r.euvt- ahnovikin- ‘`c
- 1g ima.k.t, oral, no 1st.
- dt ask. "dn you 1 ik.e_ i-b cyr nro \ la & .enic lmirt i
- would 1,onk a+ her verb visual,
look. at breas-k a to-l-
- s+ctndira wp Go hal u ce._.
- I -lx laid hue cm* w( got to uthil
el cc1.44- wan+ SD lit rtittet detail at hits 1-7- Atte.
CutvLotioned)
A-614 ed iF nentan ba- &fraitan en-I- nelecde. i-D 1 owtinc s
"you knotty vvlituf Lhke it what etre ‘445u. etoln5
ft ft -c2 , hc 4-old hee That kilt3141 Loht e l...you
"you know vu had - I vvt trett b
ULA CULIS -kmria• -t-Nurk- '-k-r) me ar.
4 \I outms pe_I-Ci.e. lAncluctee_
doesn+ r-e&tsi i-r Icravt leL-1-- an woe age. t%
•
-. (ailed hem bark th en
- -Peas sh I wtsuint reach ou+ to 3E.
- -E404.4,5 s'Yve no-c <-1,O(ns  right- khkinss Whim
LN.irks il inv;A-;nt ELL,...As ov.e„te. _ ,----.
"Broacivocui  31-0t- cor no- o-P res4-attrani-
"Ad 12.1- Otter resi-rui ran+
e 4,5
- \Nes w` -e-co-rtek
- WAVIcsi Jake. 11AnneAi "9-00Yvk irts brnazIn-1- R 1442..
\top* 9nr\- 4` -i-v-ieir Rha09-
-el\ ends died -it hocks() L1/4_AZI)C
*hink  took,. -1-t) 114.
41intilC t +DU U +ha+
ski U. \nun Dui- \41
as t.,R a

╭──────────── Page 12, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ ~ Bnew Hom iz                             │
│ - €viends until she tried ~ look we wl be │
│ -Wwink rt) bh 34                          │
│                                           │
│ —                                         │
│                                           │
│ Yarn Mola MB toot usted Pe                │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────╯

51.1A $.0
-----TwrwS:av)TTrcrh—drjhrinuc—I3ToTrrug
Th-ol_ o_A. o)v w1 PPS v v% vm Toll --Firm i-N
'?-.)-i)-a__C—INIF a-A ads k- V oci f',1 r b)
-17vicn 17Pd ti,--1.5 PpoS NS 1 ti,ii.t.f-
.)1A1 i per..4 it.) ..-3.2 -F4-17 + , ):::, _
(-MI+, 7goa
57(411")
-Pvt.) h_nrna it2n507 rOd'Cv) 4Srl . 517N4 Aird•N1 _fruc 1,, .51A.t V fl'?-F -
7 Li up aI -4-7 6 I --a .11 i Ire) V ?LI -
5 CA) J RA- 71 (14-t• -4,--dx?-u --
s-Ayv4.5kt CvlSJ F ¢4. scl-e+5 19174 at oop -1- xa u ,
567.r3 --7,
1.irvta49 Jo pan .mAL61.4, snoop ?6-ylui .%c51 .
43 As IL UO ,raot'vvra, uvralli -

(To) -v~6 n ucNALT 1 mtm -
u-po...44. *0(24 ..rd A )- ,fl II Or) d..4 A-LA50'0 p
9.' (24- Gin) c2-1- -
CnteL5
.
40
C
•
r\ , + Lan NI
M‘k tOWtyvi eni-
o-k-t‘\ -teo -
Sow les-Imes
I GI
D
a
11
hex.e. I `44 -1.0 irk , I Co - w
ICA ,Ni
14 ho 1 t.
on 1(-I
N a Ann -l- r_12.0 Ili{ +nil( -k-o 1
e a 104 I (li
\-1
GI
-
I
I.
a
NA OCt4A0N2 NNN 0 4136
<No. 7A> 33821
-

╭── Page 20, Image 1 ───╮
│ NA GANAGN2 NNN @ 4136 │
│                       │
│ <No. 1 1D 33817       │
╰───────────────────────╯

NA OANAON2 NNN 0 8273
<No. 1 CI> 6467
S
News
to
ft
NA 0ANA0N2 NNN 0 7403
0863958, imase004
Eckerds, 5529, 10/29/04
%C)
NA 0ANA0N2 NNN 0 55/S

(No. GA) 72263
It
J
: • •

╭──── Page 38, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

NA OANAON2 NNN 0 9523
<No.25544> 44527

╭──── Page 42, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

NA 0ANAC*42 htsiN 0 413E
Mc.. 41 20 33824

╭──── Page 44, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

l
NP MIAOW? 144W 0 9523
<Ho. 2C 1) 4462E.
FADE
SKIN FADE
OR FAD
NUSNRO
CEASAR
FLAT TOP
TAPE LJP
"LEAN -'SHAVE
V- 00 0.191 FIV
Go
NO OANA0N2 NNN 0 E1963
'Mo.:2E5PO 93697
NA 0ANA0t12 RV 0 7404
61
EFTA00004663 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00005091 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00006770 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2006-02-01 to 2006-06-16
(inferred date: 2026-01-22)
phone bill covering 2006-02-01 to 2006-06-16
EFTA00008716 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings in U.S. v. Ghislaine Maxwell
EFTA01103374 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Jeffrey Epstein taken as part of Jane Doe #2 v. Jeffrey Epstein
(inferred date: 2026-01-22)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
CASE NO. 08-CV-80893-CIV-MARRA/JOHNSON
JANE DOE,
Plaintiff,
vs.
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, et al.,
Defendants.
Related Cases:
08-80119, 08-80232, 08-80380, 08-80381,
08-80994, 08-80811, 08-80893, 09-80469,
09-8-591, 09-80656, 09-80802, 09-81092
VOLUME III
CONTINUED VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF
JEFFREY EPSTEIN
TAKEN ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF
DATE: April 14, 2010
U.S. Legal Support
April 14,2010
APPEARANCES (CONTINUED)
2 INDEX 2
3 WITNESS DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS PODHURST, ORSECK
Attorneys for Jane Does I and 3 4 JEFFREY EPSTEIN City National Bank Building, Suite 88
5 BY MR. HOROWrTZ 340 4 25 West Flagier Street
BY MR. EDWARDS 418
BY MS. EZELL 531 5 Tel
B : . ELL, ESQ.
8 6
9 7
EXHIBITS BURMAN, CRrETON, LUTHER & COLEMAN, LLP
10 a Attorneys for Defendant Jeffrey Epstein
303 Baryon Boulevard,
PLAINTIFF'S 9 Suite 400
11 FOR IDENTIFICATION PAGE W 33401
12 2 Multi-page document. 341 10 Tel.
BY: ESQ. 13 3 Multi-page document. 349 11
14 4 Multi-page document. 359 12
15 5 Multi page document. 369 13
16 6 Multi-page document. 378 14
AL-SO PRESENT:
17 7 Multi-page document. 384 JOE ROVNER, Videographer
18 8 Multi-page document. 391 15 (US. Legal)
19 9 Order form from Arnazon.com, 16
listing three books. 507 17
18 20 19
21 20
22 21
23 22
24 24
25 25
338 340
Tie continued videotaped deposition of 1 THEREUPON,
2 JEFFREY EPSTEIN in the above-entitled and 2 JEFFREY EPSTEIN 3 numbered cause, was taken before one, TERRI
4 BECKER, a Registered Professional Reporter and 3 being by Terri Becker first duly sworn to tell
5 Notary Public for the State of Florida at Large, 4 the whole truth, as hereinafter certified,
6 at 444 West Railroad Avenue, in the City of West 5 testified as follows: 7 Palm Beach, Palm Beach County, in the State
of
a Florida, beginning at the hour of 10:22 o'clock 6 CONTINUED DIRECT EXAMINATION
9 a.m., pursuant to the Notice and Adjournment in 7 BY MR. HOROWITZ:
10 said cause for the taking of said deposition, on 8 Q Mr. Epstein, you understand we are
11 behalf of the PLAINTIFF in the above-entitled
12 action pending in the above-named court. continuing your deposition from Part One which
13 The appearances at said time and place 10 was taken on March 8, 2010?
14 were as follows: 11 A Yes.
15 FARMER, JAFFE, WEISSR4G, EDWARDS,
FISTOS & LEHRMAN, PL 12 Q When we were together on March 8th, you
16 Attorneys for Plaintiffs Jane Does, 13 told us at that time that you were on probation
LN. and E.W. 14 in the State of Florida. Is that still the
17 425 North Andrews Avenue
Suite 2 15 case?
18 Fort 33301 16 A Yes.
Tel:
ION
17 Q I believe you also told as part of the
19 BY: BRADLEY J. EDWARDS, ESQ. 18 term of your sentence was that you were not 20
MERMELSTEIN & HOROWITZ, P.A. 19 allowed unsupervised contact with anyone under
21 Attorneys for Plaintiffs Jane Does, 20 the age of 18. Is that still the case?
numbers 2 through 8 21 A Yes. 22 18205 Biscayne Boulevard
Suite 2218 22 Q At that time, you told us that you're
Mi
Tel:
BY: ADAM D. HOROWITZ, ESQ.
restricted from possessing pornographic
material. Is that still the case?
A Yes.
2 (Pages 33? to 34 0)
U.S. Legal Support
341 343
Q At that time you told us you were a
registered sex offender in the State of Florida.
Is that still the ease?
A Yes.
Q At that time you told us you lived at
358 El Brills Way. Is that still the ease?
A On advice of counsel, sir, I'm going to
have to invoke my Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment rights.
Q I'm going to hand you a document which
we will mark as Exhibit 2. We had marked Exhibit
I at our first session.
(Multi -page document was marked as
Plaintiffs Exhibit number 2 for
identification, as of this date.)
Q (Handing.)
I'm going to ask you to please turn to
page 6. Turn to where it says "Affirmative
Defenses." Do you see where we are?
A Yes.
Q Paragraph one, under the words
"Affirmative Defenses" says "As to all counts,
plaintiff actually consented to and was a willing
participant in the acts alleged, and therefore
her claims are barred or her damages are required
1 Fifth Amendment
2 Q Isn't It try neither you or anyone you
3 know has facts to support your contention that
4 =consented to and was a willing participant
5 in the acts alleged?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A As you know I would orally like to
8 answer that question, but at least today, I
cannot I am going to have to invoke my rights
on advice of counsel under the Fifth, Fourteenth
and Sixth Amendment.
Q Okay, moving down to paragraph two, it
says, in Part, "as to all counts alleged
plaintiff =actually consented to and
participated in conduct similar and/or identical
to the acts alleged with other persons, which
were the sole or contributing cause of
plaintiff's alleged damages."
My question for you is, what facts are
you aware of to support your contention that=
consented to and participated in conduct similar
to and/or identical to the acts alleged in this
lawsuit?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Unfortunately I would like to answer
to be reduced accordin " This I'll tell you
2 was filed  in the case o : do you understand
3 that?
1 A Yes.
3 Q Have you seen this document before?
6 A Not to my recollection, no.
Q This statement that plaintiff
actually consented to and was a willing
9 participant in the acts alleged; is that a true
statement?
A Sir, at least today I would like to
answer each one of your questions, but I'm going
to have to, on advice of counsel, invoke my
rights of the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q What facts do you have to support this
contention here that plaintiff■ actually
consented to and was a willing participant in the
acts alleged?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer each and
every one of your questions hat today, Mr.
Horowitz, unfortunately today on the advice of
counsel, I will have to refuse to answer and
invoke my rights under the Sixth, Fourteenth and
1 each of your questions here today, Mr. Horowitz,
2 but on advice of counsel, at least today, I have
3 to assert my rights under the Fourth, Fifth and
4 Sixth Amendment.
5 Q Isn't It true, sir, that you that this
6 contention that  consented to or participated
In conduct similar to the acts alleged in this
lawsuit with other persons? That's a false
statement; isn't that true?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Mr. Horowitz, I believe you already know
the answer to most of these questions. I would
like to give them, but however, at least today on
advice of my counsel I have to assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fourteenth and Fifth Amendment.
Q Isn't it true, sir, you're not aware of
who has facts anyone to support the statement
that consented to and participated In
similar or identical acts with other persons?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer that
question, as I would like to answer all of your
questions, at least today my counsel has advised
me that I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.
3 (Pages 341 to 344)
U.S. Le al Su ort
345 347
Q Sir, please turn to paragraph three of
defendant Epstein's first Amended Answer and
3 Affirmative Defenses.
4 A Same page?
5 Q Yes, paragraph three.
A Okay.
7 Q Do you see it says "As to all counts
8 plaintiff impliedly consented to the acts alleged
9 by not objecting."
1.0 My question for you is, what facts do
11 you have to support your contention that
12 plaintiff= impliedly consented to the acts
13 alleged by not objecting?
14 MR. PIKE: Fenn. And all of these
15 questions call for a legal conclusion, as
16 well.
17 A Though I would like to answer that
18 question, as I would like to answer all of your
19 questions here today, on advice of my counsel.
20 I'm going to have to assert my rights today of
21 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
22 Q Isn't it true, sir, that you're not
23 aware of any facts to support your contention
24 that the plaintiff= consented to the acts
25 alleged by not objecting; isn't that true, sir?
was not 18 years old at the time of the alleged
acts?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer that
question, as I would like to answer every
one of your questions here today, on advice of
counsel I'm going to have to assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment,
sir.
Q Mr. Epstein, what facts arc you aware of
to support your contention thatM had attained
the age of 18 years old at the time of the
alleged acts?

MR. PIKE: Same objection.
A Though I would like to answer that
question, Mr. Horowitz, I'm going to have to
respond the same way I've responded to all of
your questions here today; by asserting my rights
on advice of counsel under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Isn't it true, sir, you had no reason to
bane that was 18 or older at the time of
the acts alleged?

MR. PIKE. F0111).
A Unfortunately, though I would like to
1 MR. PIKE: Form?
2 A Can you repeat the question, I'm sorry?
3 Q Isn't it true you're not aware of any
4 facts to support this contention that
5 consented to the acts alleged by not objecting?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A At least today, Mr. Horowitz, I'm going
8 to have to assert my rights under the Sixth,
9 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment not to answer that
10 question, though I would like to.
11 Q Isn't it true, sir, you're not aware of
12 anyone who has facts to support the contention
13 thaI consented to the acts alleged by not
14 objecting?
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 A Mr. Horowitz, I would like to answer
17 your question but at last today, under advice of
18 counsel, l have to assert my rights under the
19 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
20 Q Turning to paragraph four, immediately
21 following the paragraph... It says "Defendant
22 reasonably believed or was told that plaintiff
23 had attained the age of 18 years old at the time
24 of the alleged acts"? Isn't it true, sir, that's
25 not a true statement, is it? You knew that-
a
answer that question, Mr. Horowitz, on advice of
my counsel I'm going to have to assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
Q Turning to paragraph five of your
Amended Answer toM's lawsuit, it says: "As
to all counts, plaintiffs claims are barred, as
she said she was 18 years or older at the time."
Now, Mr. Epstein, that's not a true
statement, is it?

MR. PUCE: Form.
A I would like to answer every one of your
questions with respect to however, at least
today, Mr. Horowitz, I'm going to have to assert
my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment on advice of my counsel.
Q Mr. Epstein, 5 never told you she was
18 years of age or older; isn't that true?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every
question regarding., at least today I have to
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment, sir, under advice of
counsel.
Q Mr. Epstein, you've had a chance now to
review the Affirmative Defenses one through five,
4 (Pages 345 to 348)
U.S. Legal Support
349 351
1 which were filed on your behalf in this lawsuit. 1 paragraph one it says, "As to all counts,
2 Do you have any facts to support the contentions 2 plaintiff actually consented to and was a willing
3 in any of those Affirmative Defenses? 3 participant in the acts alleged." Do you see
4 MR. PIKE: Form. 4 that portion of paragraph one?
5 A At least today I'm going to have to 5 A Yes, sir.
6 respond by asserting my rights under the Sixth, 6 Q The statement here that the plaintiff,
7 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment, on advice of 7 Jane Doe number 3 consented to and was a willing
8 counsel. 8 participant in the acts alleged: that's not a
9 Q I will take back Exhibit I -- pardon me, 9 true statement, is it?
10 Exhibit 2, and I'm going to hand you what we will 10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 mark as Exhibit 3. 11 A Who is lane Doc 3?
12 (Multi -page document was marked as 12 Q You don't know who Jane Doe 3 is?
13 Plaintiff's Exhibit number 3 for 13 A I do not. Don't you?
14 identification, as of this date.) 14 Q I do, I'll pull up the list here. There
15 Q I'm going to hand you and your 15 are a number of cases, as you're aware.
16 attorney -- 16 Off the record for a second.)
17 MR. HOROWITZ: I have extras. 17 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the video record
18 Q -. defendant Epstein's First Amended 18 at 10:35 a.m.
19 Answer and the Affirmative Defenses to 19 (Pause in the proceedings.)
20 plaintiff's Second Amended Complaint. Do you see 0 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
21 that in front of you? 1 record 10:40 a.m.
22 A Yes, sir. 2 Q Mr. EpsteinSis Jane Doe 3. You
23 Q Have you seen that before? 3 have in front of you the Amended Answer and
24 A No, sir. 4 Affirmative Defenses filed in response to Jane
25 Q I'm going to ask you to turn to page 6, 5 Doe 3's lawsuit?
350 352
the page numbers are at the top, and do you see 1 A Yes, sir.
2 the words "Affirmative Defenses"? 2 Q We marked that as Exhibit 3. Turning to
3 A Yes. sir. 3 affirmative defense paragraph number one, do you
4 Q Paragraph one includes the following 4 see where it says "Plaintiff actually consented
5 statements -- 5 to and was a willing participant in the acts
6 MR. PIKE: Can we -- it appears that 6 alleged" in paragraph one; do you see that?
7 paragraphs one through five are the same. 7 MR. PIKE: Form. The document speaks
8 Would that be correct, as the ones you just 8 for itself.
9 previously read? 9 Q Do you see where I'm pointing you to? I
10 MR. HOROWITZ: Yes. 10 want to make sure we are on the same page.
11 MR. PIKE: Do you want to stipulate that 1 A Yes, I do.
12 the answers would be the same and the 12 Q The statement that Jane Doe number 3,
13 invocations of the Fifth, Sixth and 3 consented to and was a willing participant
14 Fourteenth would be the same, as well as my 14 in the acts alleged; is that a true statement?
15 form objections? 5 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 MR. HOROWITZ: Well, I need to ask the 6 A Mr. Horowitz, I would like to answer
17 questions as to each client. 17 every question about■ here today, however on
18 MR. PIKE: So, you do not want to 18 advice of counsel they've instructed me to Men
19 stipulate to that? 19 my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
20 MR. HOROWITZ: I'll stipulate that you 0 Amendment.
21 have a standing objection, but I need to ask 21 Q Mr. Epstein, what facts d v u know of
22 the questions and get them on record. 22 to support the statements that dually
23 , MR. PIKE: All right, we will just go 23 consented to and was a willing participant in the
24 through it. Okay. 24 facts alleged?
25 Q As to Jane Doe 3, do you see In 25 MR. PIKE. Form.
5 (Pages 349 to 352)
U.S. Legal Support
1 Q The acts alleged.
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A I would like to answer every question
4 about. however, at least today on advice of
5 counsel, they've instructed me that I must assert
6 my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
7 Amendment.
8 Q Isn't it true, sir, you are not aware of
anyone who has facts to support the statement
thm. consented to and was a willing
participant in the acts alleged?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer every question
about= however, today under advice of
counsel, I cannot. They've instructed me to
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Turnip  paragraph two, ft says:
"Plaintiff actually consented to and
participated to conduct similar and/or identical
to acts alleged with other persons, which were
the sole or contributing cause of plaintiff's
alleged damages." Sir, that's not a true
statement, is it?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer every question
2 abou=uxillY. Mr. Horowitz, however, on
3 advice of counsel, they've instructed me I must
4 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Mr. Epstein, what facts do you know of
to support the statement that actually
consented to and participated in conduct similar
and/or identical to the acts alleged with other
persons?

MR. PIKE: Form, and once again this
line of questioning calls fora legal
conclusions, as well as work product
information.
A Though I would like to answer each and
every question abouModay unfortunately my
counsel has advised me I must assert my rights
under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
Q Isn't it true, sir, you're not aware of
anyone who has facts to support the contention
thatMconsented to and participated in
conduct similar and/or identical to the acts
alleged with other persons?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every
1 question you have here today, Mr. Horowitz,
2 regarding your client,. on advise of my
3 counsel, at least today I must assert my rights
4 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
5 Q Turning to paragraph three of your
6 Affirmative Defenses, It says "Plaintiff.,
7 impliedly consented to the acts alleged by not
8 objecting." Do you see that?
9 A Yes.
Q The first part of that sentence?
A Yes, sir.
Q That's not a true statement, is it,
sir?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every
question aboutM every single question,
unfortunately today my counsel has advised me
that I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Sir, what factsrSxon have to support
your contention that= Impliedly consented to
the acts alleged by not objecting?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every
question about .hat you pose here today, Mr.
1 Horowitz, at least today, unfortunately my
2 counsel advised me that I must assert my rights
3 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
4 Q Isn't It true, sir, you're not aware of
5 anyone who has facts to support your statement
6 thaMI lmpliedly consented to the acts alleged
7 by not objecting?
8 MR. PIKE: Form?
9 A Mr. Horowitz, I would like to answer
10 every question aboutM, I really would.
11 However, today my counsel has advised me that 1
12 must assert my Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
13 Amendment rights.
14 Q Turning to paragraph four of your
15 Affirmative Defenses, Mr. Epstein, it says "As to
16 all counts, defendant reasonably believed or was
17 told that the plaintiff had attained the age of
18 18 years old at the time of the alleged acts."
19 That's not a true statement, is it, sir?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A I would like to answer every question
22 about. that you've posed here today.
23 However, on advice of my counsel, I must assert
24 my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
25 Amendment, at least today.
6 (Pages 353 to 356)
U.S. Legal Support
357 359
11.
Q Isn't it true, sir, isn't it true that
you knew that•was under the age of 18 when
she came to your home; isn't that true, sir?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer every question
aboutIMI However, at least today my counsel
has advised me I must assert my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Isn't it true, sir, that you had no
reason to believe that■ was under lit?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Can you repeat that question?
Q Glad you asked. Isn't it true, sir, yon
had no reason to believe that Ewes 18 years
old or older?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer every question
about In and her — the question you just
asked, however at least today, my counsel has
advised me that I must assert my rights under the
Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Isn't it true, sir, that ■ never told
you that she was under the age of 18?
A Form.

MR. PIKE: Form.
containing markings in Exhibit number 3.)
Q I'm going to band to you the answer and
Affirmative Defenses, Amended Answer and
Affirmative Defenses that you filed in the
lawsuit filed by do you have that in front
of you? Jane Doe number 4.
A Yes, sir.
Q I'll ask you to turn to page 6 where
you'll see the words "Affirmative Defenses" near
the top of the page?

MR. PIKE: This is Exhibit 4?
MR. HOROWITZ: Correct, Exhibit 4.
(Multi-page document was marked as
Plaintiffs Exhibit number 4 for
identification, as of this date.)
THE WITNESS: Can we take a two-second
break??

MR. HOROWITZ: Sum.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the video record
at 10:48 a.m.
(Pause in the proceedings.)
MR. HOROWITZ: Back on the record.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
record 10:49 a.m.
Q Do you have the Affirmative Defenses in
1 MR. HOROWITZ: Strike that.
2 . Q Isn't It true, sir.. never told you
3 she was 18 years or older? Isn't that true,
4 sir?
5 A I would like to answer every question
6 you have today regarding. and what she told
7 me. However, today my counsel has advised me I
8 must suet my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Okay, paragraph five says the
plaintiffs claims are barred as she said she was
18 years or older at the time.
Sir, that's not a true statement, is
It?

MR. PIKE: Form.
I would like to tell you exactly what
said, however, my counsel has advised me to
say that I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
MR. PIKE: I wrote on your exhibit, page
3,
MR. HOROWITZ: We will substitute a
different one.
MR. PIKE: Yes, it is just checkmarks.
(Clew copy was substituted for the page
I front of you, and the answer you filed In the
2 Meese, correct?
3 A That's correct.
4 Q Paragraph one includes the followin
5 statement: "As to all counts, plaintiff
6 actually consented to and was a willing
7 participant In the acts alleged." That's not a
8 true statement, is it, sir?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
0 A I believe her deposition espeaks
1 to this issue.
2 Q Do you agree with es testimony that
3 she was at your home?
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A Unfortunately today, Mr. Horowitz,
[16 though I would like to answer every question
17 about., I think her deposition speaks quite a
I1.8 well with some of those issues, but at least,
9 with respect to my answering these questions
0 today with regard toMand these issues, my
counsel has advised me I must assert my rights
2 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
23 Amendments.
4 Q Are you telling us that. in your
P 5 opinion, was truthful in her deposition?
7 (Pages 357 to 360)
U.S. Legal Support
361 363
1 MR. PIKE: Form, misconstrues the
2 witness's testimony. Move to strike.
3 A I believe, sir, that though I would
4 o answer that question with respect to Ms.
5 s deposition, my counsel has advised me at
6 least today I must assert my rights under the
7 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.
8 Q Sir, what did you mean when you said
9 Ms testimony speaks to this issue"?
10 MR. PIKE: Asked and answered.
11 A I believe I said "deposition testimony'
12 Q Yes, what did you mean by that, when you
13 said "Her deposition testimony speaks to the
14 issue"?
15 MR. PIKE: Asked and answered, form.
16 A On advice of counsel, I have to assert
17 my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
18 Amendment, sir.
19 Q What facts do you know of to support the
20 statement thaMactually consented to and was
21 a willing participant In the acts alleged?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A I believe her deposition spoke to that
24 directly, but however, myself, Pm going to have
25 to assert my Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
1 however, with respect to my own issues today, I
2 am going to have to assert my rights on the
3 advice of counsel, under the Sixth, Filth and
4 Fourteenth Amendments.
5 Q Paragraph two in the Affirmative
6 Defenses As to all counts alleged
7 plaintiff, actually consented to and
8 participated in similar conduct and/or identical
9 to the acts alleged with other persons which were
10 the sole or contributing cause to plaintiff's
11 damages."
12 Sir, you know that's not correct; is
13 that correct?
14 MR. PIKE: Font.
15 A I believe her deposition, in her own
16 words sp.aks to this issue, but as far as today
17 my to that question answer unfortunately will
18 have to be that I assert my rights under the
19 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment on advice
20 of counsel.
21 Q Sir, isn't it true you're not aware of
22 any facts to support your contention in this
23 answer to the amended complaint that.'
24 consented to and participated in conduct similar
25 and/or identical to the acts alleged with other
1 Amendment rights under advice of counsel, sir.
2 Q You read her deposition, correct?
3 A No.
4 Q You have not read her deposition?
5 A No.
6 Q But you believe her deposition testimony
7 correctly speaks to the issue of the fact that
8 she was a willing participant in the nets alleged
9 with you?
10 A That's not what I said.
11 Q Why don't you tell me what you meant
12 when you said, "Her deposition testimony speaks
13 to the issue."
14 A The deposition speaks for itself. Any
15 other questions I'm sorry, Mr. Horowitz, but
16 today I have to assert my rights under the Sixth.
17 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments.
18 Q Isn't it true, sir, that you are not
19 aware of anyone who has facts that support the
20 statement that=consented to and was a
21 willing participant in the acts alleged in her
22 lawsuit?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A My understanding of her own testimony in
25 her deposition speaks to that matter, but,
1.0
1 persons?
2 MR. PIKE: Form?
3 A I believe her deposition in her own
4 words speaks to this exact question, but however,
5 with respect to my answers today, unfortunately
6 with respect toM though I would like to
7 answer every question with respect tcM on
8 advice of counsel I have to assert my rights
under the Fourteenth, Sixth and Fifth Amendment.
Q Sir, my question was: What facts do you
know to be true? Clarify for me. Are you saying
that you are adopting what-rays as true?

MR. PIKE: Form, misconstrues the
witness's testimony, and that is not exactly
what your last question was, so I'm going to
move —

MR. HOROWITZ: Just to form --
MR. PIKE: No, no, I'm not going to let
the witness answer a question that's going
to potentially waive any Constitutional
privileges here, so it will not be just
"form"
Now. having said that, if you can repeat
the question --
MR. HOROWITZ: Can you repeat the
8 (Pages 361 to 364)
U.S. Legal Support
365 367
1 question? 1 read that correctly?
2 (Discussion off the record.) 2 MR. PIKE: Form. I'm going to instruct
3 Q Are you suggesting to us you are 3 him not to answer that question. Did you
4 adopting what- says is true in her 4 read that correctly?
5 deposition? 5 Q Do you see where I am? Do you see where
6 MR. PIKE: Form. 6 l am, paragraph four?
7 A Sir, I would like to answer every 7 MR. PIKE: You can answer that question
8 question with respect to■ However, today on 8 as to whether or not you see where he is
9 advice of counsel, I have to assert my rights 9 identifying paragraph four in the document
10 under the Fourteenth, Sixth and Fifth Amendment. 10 in front of you.
11 Q In paragraph three of your Affirmative 11 A I don't think you read it completely,
12 Defenses, it says "As to all counts, plaintiff 12 did you?
13 impliedly consented to the acts alleged by 13 Q "As to all counts defendant reasonably
14 not objecting." 14 believed or was told the plaintiff had attained
15 Sir, that's not true, is it? 15 the age of 18 years old at the time of the
16 MR. PIKE: Form. 16 alleged acts." Did I read that correctly now?
17 A I believe her own testimony in her 17 MR. PIKE: I instruct you not to answer
18 deposition speaks to that, however, at least 18 that question. It is not formed right. Did
19 today, Mr. Horowitz, I have to assert my rights 19 you read it correctly connotates an implied
20 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment. 20 potential waiver, did you read it correctly,
21 Q What information do you have to support 21 is it correct?
22 your assertion that plaintiff impliedly 22 Q Did I accurately read the statement in
23 consented to the acts alleged by not objecting? 23 your Affirmative Defenses?
24 MR. PIKE: Form. 24 MR. PIKE: That is — you can answer
25 A Information separate from her own 25 that question.
366 368
1 testimony? 1-- with respect to any other 1 A Yes.
2 question, I'm going to have to assert my rights 2 Q Okay. Isn't it true, sir, that you
3 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment 3 knew, you knew, that . was not 18 years old
4 upon advice of counsel. 4 before May of 2005; isn't that true?
5 Q Let's make sore we are on the same page, 5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 then. 6 A Though I would like to answer every
7 A Please. 7 question regarding■ and what she said, at
8 Q Separate from her deposition 8 least today upon advice of counsel, I have to
9 testimony — 9 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
10 A Yes? 10 Fourteenth Amendment, sir.
11 Q -- my question Is: Do you have any 11 Q Isn't it true, sir, you had no reason to
12 facts to support your assertion that 12 believe up until May 2005 that M. was 18 years
13 impliedly consented to the acts alleged by not 13 old or older?
14 objecting? 14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 MR. PIKE: Form. 15 A Separate and apart from her own
16 A Separate from her own testimony with 16 testimony I believe on the subject, at least with
17 respect to her consenting, at least today, though 17 respect to today, to answer these questions I'm
18 I would like to answer that question, I'm going 18 going to have to assert my rights under the
19 to have to assert my rights under the Sixth, 19 Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment on advice
20 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment upon advice of 20 of counsel.
21 counsel, sir. 21 Q Isn't it true, sir, that prior to May of
22 Q Okay, paragraph four of the Affirmative 22 2005, never told you she wns 18 years old or
23 Defenses says, "As to all counts, defendant 23 older.
24 reasonably believed or was told that plaintiff 24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 had attained the age of 18 years old." Did I 25 A Though I would like to answer that
9 (Pages 365 to 368)
U.S. Le al Su ort
1 question with respect to what told me, at 1 witness's testimony?
2 least today I'm going to have to assert my rights 2 A I would like to answer every single
3 under the Fourteenth, Sixth and Fifth Amendment 3 question regarding ■'s claims, every single
4 upon advice of counsel. 4 one, however, today, upon advice of counsel, at
5 Q As to paragraph five, states the 5 least today, theyve instructed me to assert my
6 following: "Plaintiff's claims are barred as she 6 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
7 said she was 18 yean or older at the time." 7 Amendment.
8 Sir, you know that's not true. That 8 Q Sir, what facts do you know of to
9 never happened before May of 2005; isn't that 9 support the statement that consented to and
10 correct? 10 was a willing participant In the acts alleged?
11 MR. PIKE: form. 11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 A Though I would like to answer every 12 A Separate and apart from her own
13 question with respect to whatMsaid and did, 13 deposition testimony. I'm sorry, but I would like
14 1, unfortunately today, have to assert my rights 14 to answer every question with respect to her
15 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment 15 behavior — can you repeat the question, sir?
16 upon advice of counsel. 16 Q Sure. What facts do you know of to
17 Q I'm going to hand you what will be 17 support the statement that plaintiff,E,
18 marked as Exhibit 5, Defendant Epstein's First 18 consented to, and was a willing participant in
19 Amended Answer in the Affirmative Defenses to 19 the acts alleged?
20 Plaintiff's Second Amended Complaint in the 20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 lawsuit filed by ■ 21 A Separate and apart from her own
22 (Handing.) 22 testimony on the subject, I cannot answer today
23 (Multi-page document was marked as 23 that question, though I would like to. And upon
24 Plaintiffs Exhibit number 5 for 24 advice of counsel, I must assert my rights under
25 identification, as of this date.) 25 the Sixth, Filth and Fourteenth Amendment.
370 372
1 Q I'm going to ask you again to turn to 1 Q Isn't it true, sir, you're not aware of
2 page 6 where it says "Affirmative Defenses." 2 anyone who has facts to support the statement
3 Do you see where it says "Affirmative 3 that A.C. consented to and was a willing
4 Defenses"? 4 participant in the acts alleged?
S A Urn-hum. 5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 Q Paragraph one includes the following 6 A Unfortunately — I would like to answer
7 statements: "As to all counts plaintiff actually 7 every question about Es alleged participation
8 consented to and was a willing participant in the 8 in any event. However, today, upon advice of
9 acts alleged, and therefore her claims are barred 9 counsel I have been instructed that I must assert
10 or her damages are required to be reduced 10 my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
11 accordingly." 11 Amendment.
12 Sir, this statement that =consented 12 Q Sir. paragraph two of the Affirmative
13 to and was a willing participant in the acts 13 Defenses says: "As to all counts alleged
14 alleged; that's not true, is it? 19 plaintiff actually consented to and participated
15 MR. PIKE: Form, 15 in conduct similar and/or Identical to the acts
16 A I believe her own deposition speaks to 16 alleged with other persons which were the sole or
17 that exact question, but at least as far as my 17 contributing cause to plaintiffs alleged
18 answers are concerned today, Mr. Horowitz, 18 damages."
19 unfortunately upon advice of my own counsel, I 19 Now, sir, that's not a true statement
20 have to assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth 20 that plaintiff consented to and participated in
21 and Fourteenth Amendment 21 similar acts with other persons, is it?
22 Q Do you agree with s statements with 22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 regard to her activity at your home as stated in 23 A I would love to respond to every
24 her deposition testimony? 24 question with respect to similar acts performed
25 MR. PIKE: Form, misconstrues the 25 by with other people. However, at least
10 (Pages 369 to 372)
U.S. Legal Support
373 375
today upon advice of counsel I must assert my
2 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
3 Amendment.
4 Q Sir, what facts do you have to support
5 the assertion that articipated in conduct
6 similar and/or identkal to the acts alleged In
7 her lawsuit against you, with other people?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A Separate and apart from her own
0 deposition, her own testimony, I would like to
give all the facts with respect tows
behavior with other people. However, today my
counsel has advised me that I must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Have you read her deposition testimony?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A No.
Q Have you listened to her deposition
testimony?
A I don't recall.
Q Am I accurate then, whatever you know
about her lawsuit is something your attorneys
have shared with you?

MR. PIKE: Form.
1 information you have about. testimony came
2 from your lawyers, or did you hear here it from
3 some other source?
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
S Pm going to instruct you not to answer
6 that question.
7 Q Have you heard frond source other
8 than your attorneys what estified about?
9 MR. PIKE: You can answer that
10 question.
11 A No.
12 Q Sir, paragraph three of your Affirmative
13 Defenses to as lawsuit says, "As to all
14 counts plaintiff impliedly consented to the acts
15 alleged by not objecting." Do you see that?
16 A Yes, sir.
17 Q Sir, you know that's not a true
18 statement, isn't it?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A I would like to answer every question
21 with respect tr..M and what she did or alleged
22 to have done. However, today I have to assert my
23 rights under the, Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
24 Amendment, upon advice of counsel.
25 Q Sir, what facts do you have to support
Q Or do you have it from another source?

MR. PIKE: One second.
MR. HOROWITZ: You have to wait for the
question --
MR. PIKE: No.
MR. HOROWITZ: That's the way the rules
worked.

MR. PIKE: You're asking a question,
then you're pausing to elicit a response to
waive attorney/client privilege, okay? Then
you're jumping into another question. If
you would like me to sit in your chair and
teach you how to ask the questions, I will
be happy to do so.

MR. HOROWITZ: You couldn't teach me a
single thing.
MR. PIKE: However, today we're here for
you. We're here for you to ask your
questions. If you would like to break up
your questions, you can do so. But as to
that last question, I'm going to instruct
you not to answer, because, as you know, it
is attorney/client information. If you want
to try again, we're here all day.
Q Sir, is it accurate to say that an
1 your assertion that =consented to the acts
2 alleged by not objecting?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A Unfortunately any facts I might have, my
5 attorneys have counseled me I must assert my
6 lights under the Sixth, Fourteenth and Fifth
7 Amendment, so I must assert those rights today,
8 sir.
9 Q Sir, isn't it true you're not aware of
10 anyone who has facts to support the statement
11 that A.C. consented to the acts alleged by not
12 objecting?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A Though I would like to answer those
15 questions with respect to the facts about
16 at least today my counsel has advised me I must
17 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
18 Fourteenth Amendment.
19 Q Turning to paragraph four of the
Affirmative Defenses, isn't it true, sir, that
you knew that-.vas IS years, was under 18
years old when she came to your home?
MR. PIKE: Form?
A Though I would like to answer every
question about Ms. `I cannot, on advice of
11 (Pages 373 to 376)
U.S. Legal Su ort
377 379
counsel today, and they've asked me to assert my 1 today advised me I must assert my rights under
2 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth 2 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
3 Amendment. 3 Q Isn't it true, sir, there are no facts
4 Q Isn't it true, sir that you had no 4 that you're aware of to support the statement
5 reason to believe that vas Ift years or older 5 that■ consented to and was a willing
6 when she was at your home? 6 participant in the acts alleged?
7 MR. PIKE: Form. 7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A Though I would like to answer every 8 A Though, the question of whether she was
9 question about •today, Mr. Horowitz.,, my 9 a willing participant in the acts alleged, I
10 counsel has advised me I must at least today 10 would real • like to answer those questions with
11 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and 11 respect t However, at least today my
12 Fourteenth Amendment. 12 counsel has advised me f must assert my rights
13 Q Isn't it true, sir, never told you 13 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
14 she was IS years old or older? 14 Q Turning to paragraph two of the
15 MR. PIKE: Form. 15 Affirmative Defenses, what facts do you have to
16 A Though I would like to answer that 16 support your assertion that consented to and
17 question regarding what Ms. ■ told me, my 17 participated in conduct similar and/or identical
18 counsel has advised me that today I must assert 18 to the acts alleged with other persons?
19 my rights under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth 19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 Amendment 20 A Thoughlwould like to answer the
21 Q Isn't it true, sir, no one ever told you 21 question about the acts that sties performed with
22 that was 18 years old or older when she was 22 other persons similar to the ones alleged here,
23 at your home? 23 at least today under advice of counsel. I have
24 MR. PIKE: n=orm. 24 been instructed to assert my rights under the
25 A Though I would like to answer that 25 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
378 380
question, with respect to what people told me how 1 Q Sir, you know that= never consented
2 old she was or what she told me how old she was, 2 to or participated in similar or identical acts
3 sorry, but my counsel advised me today i must 3 with other persons; isn't that right?
4 assert my rights under Sixth, Fifth and 4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 Fourteenth Amendment. 5 A I would very much like to answer that
6 Q Okay. 6 question, very much. However, sir, at least
7 (Multi page document was marked as 7 today my counsel has advised me I must assert my
8 Plaintiff's Exhibit number 6 for 8 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
9 identification, as of this date.) 9 Amendment.
10 Q Moving on to Exhibit 6, Epstein's First 10 Q Sir, isn't it true you're not aware of
11 Amended Answer in Affirmative Defense is to make 11 anyone who has facts to support your assertion
12 his First Amended Complaint in the Jane Doe 12 that M ons ented to or participated in similar
13 number 6 case, and I'll hand you a copy of that 13 or identical acts with other persons?
14 and represent to you that Jane Doe 6 ie., 1.4 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 okay? task you to turn to page 6 — I see 15 A I'm sorry, can you read that question
16 you've already done that, of the Affirmative 16 back?
17 Defenses. 17 Q Sir, Isn't it true you're not aware of
18 What facts do you have to support the 18 anyone who has facts to support your assertion
19 contention in paragraph one tha consented 19 that consented to and participated to
20 to and was a willing participant in the acts 0 similar or identical acts with other people?
21 alleged? 1 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 MR. PIKE: Form? 2 A Though I would like to answer that
23 A Though I would like to answer the 23 question regarding does anyone else have
24 question regarding what consented to and how 24 information with respec to participating
25 she was a participant in the events, my counsel 25 with other people in similar acts as your
12 (Pages 377 to 380)
U.S. Legal Support
381 383
question posed, tmfortunately, today, sir, I'm
going to have to assert my rights upon advice of
3 counsel under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
1 Amendment.
Q Turning to paragraph three of your
Affirmative Defenses, sir, it is not a true
7 statement that■ impliedly consented to the
acts alleged by not objecting. is it, sir?
9 MR. PIKE: Foam
10 A The question regarding. implied

11. consent that you've just posed. I would like to
12 answer that question. I would like to answer all
13 the questions with respect walla' you've
14 posed here today. However, upon advice of
15 counsel I have to assert my rights under the
16 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
17 Q Slr, what facts do ou have to support
18 your contention that consented to the acts
19 alleged by not objecting?
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A Though I would like to answer that
22 question regarding the facts that I have
23 regarding =s consent, my attorneys have
24 advised me that today I have to assert — at
25 least today, I have to assert my rights under the
1 to the question of whalMold me, I would
2 like to respond to every question regarding.
3 my counsel has advised me that today at least, I
4 must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
5 Fourteenth Amendment.
6 Q Isn't it true, sir, t u could
7 plainly tell by looking at that she was not
8 18 years old?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A Sir,1 would like to answer that
11 question, as I would like to answer every other
12 question regarding your plaintiff= However
13 today on advice of counsel, they've Instructed me
14 I must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth
15 and Fourteenth Amendment.
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A Isn't it true, sir, no one told you MI
18 was 18 years old or older.
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A Though I would like to answer ev
21 question of what people told me regarding.
22 allegedly, my counsel has instructed me I must
23 respond by asserting my Sixth, Fifth and
24 Fourteenth Amendment rights, sir.
25 Q Sir, I'm going to hand you what we will

1. Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Sure, turning to paragraph four. it says
"As to all counts" — strike that.
4 Isn't it true, sir, that you knew when
5 =was at your home that she was not 18 years
6 old?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A I would like to answer the question
9 about., every question abouMtere today
10 that you've posed. However, upon advice of my
11 counsel they've advised me that I must assert my
12 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
13 Amendment.
14 Q Isn't It true, sir, you had no reason to
15 believe that. was 18 years of age or older?
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A The question regarding my reason to
18 believe MVOs 18 or over? I would really like
19 to answer that question, but however, today my
20 counsel has advised me I must assert my rights

21. under the Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth Amendment,
22 sir.
23 Q Isn't it true never told you she
24 was 18 or older?
25 A Though I would very much like to respond
1 mark ax Exhibit 7. It is Defeodant Epstein's
2 First Amended Answer and Affirmative Defenses to
3 Plaintiffs First Amended Complaint in Jane Doe 7
4 ease filed by ■
S (Multi-page document was marked as
6 Plaintiffs Exhibit number 7 for
7 identifkation, as of this date.)
8 Q I ask you to take a look at that,
9 please, and turn to page 6, of the Affirmative
10 Defenses.
11 THE WITNESS: Take a five-minute break/
12 MR. HOROWITZ: Sure.
13 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the record at
14 11:13 am.
15 (Pause in the proceedings.)
16 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
17 record 11:21 a.m.
10 Q Mr. Epstein, do you have in front of you
19 the Affirmative Defenses filed in your behalf in
20 M.'s lawsuit?
21 A Yes.
22 Q What facts do you have to support your
23 contention that consented to and was a
24 willing participant in the acts alleged?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
13 (Pages 381 to 384)
U.S. Legal Support
385 387
1 A Separate and open from her own
2 statements with regard to these issues, I would
3 like to answer every question here today with
4 respect to• However upon advice of counsel,
5 at least today, I have to assert my rights under
6 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
7 Q And is it your position that, well, tell
8 its if it is your position that admitted to
consenting to and being a willing participant in
the acts alkged.

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Can you repeat the question?
Q Is it your position that tdmitted
in her deposition testimony to having consented
to, and having been a wining participant in the
acts alleged?
A I think her deposition speaks for
itself, but anything beyond that, at least today,

Mr. Horowitz, I'm going to have to assert my
rights upon advice of counsel under the Sixth,
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Do you believe thatMwas accurate
when she, according to you, testified that she
consented to and was a willing participant in the
acts alleged?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like nothing more than to
respond to everything.has to say. However,
at least today, upon advice of my counsel, I'm
going to have to assert my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Mr. Epstein, you know the statement that
M onsen( ed to and was a willing participant
in the acts alleged if not a true statement;
isn't that right?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would very much like to respond to
whether■ was a willing participant in any
alleged act. However, at least today, Mr.
Horowitz, my counsel has advised me that I must
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Sir, what facts do you know of to
support the statement 160Mconsented to and
was a willing participant in the acts alleged?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to respell: dry
question regarding the facts regarding
what she consented to and what she did not
consent to, I'm afraid that at least today my
counsel has advised me I must assert my rights
under the Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Turning to paragraph two of your
Affirmative Defenses, what facts are you aware of
to support your contention that= consented
to and participated in similar or identical acts
with other persons?

MR. PIKE: Fenn.
A Though I would very much like to respond
to similar acts the■ participated in with
respect to your question, sir, at least today my
counsel has advised me thatl must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Filth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q isn't it true, sir, you know of no facts
to support your contention in the Affirmative
Defenses thaesartkipated in similar or
identical acts with other persons?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A As I said previously, l would like to
testify, I would like to answer your questions
with respect to. However, today my counsel
has advised me that at !cast today I would have
to assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
1 Q Isn't it true, sir, you're not aware of
2 anyone who has facts to support the contention
3 that■ participated or consented to similar or
4 identical acts with other people?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A The issue of whethernarticipated
7 with other people in similar alleged acts, I
8 would very much like to answer. However, today my
counsel has advised me I may not, and have
advised me I must assert my Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment rights.
Q Turning to paragraph three, what facts
do you have to support your contention that-
consented to the acts alleged by not objecting?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every
question here today regardingMity counsel
has advised me that at least today I have to
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Isn't it true, sir, you know of no facts
to support your contention thaeconsented to
the acts alleged by not objecting?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every
14 (Pages 385 to 388)
U.S. Legal Support
389 391
question you pose regarding., Mr. Horowitz.
2 at least today my counsel has advised me I must
3 assert my rights to the Sixth, Fifth and
4 Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Is it true, sir, you're not aware of
anyone who has facts to support the statement
that-consented to the acts alleged by not
objecting?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer the question with
respect to Es consent a not consent.
However, today my counsel has advised me I must
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment, though I would very much
like to answer that question.
Q Turning to paragraph four of the
Affirmative Defenset you did not believe in
your own mind tha=was 18 years or older
before May of 2005; isn't that true?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Would you repeat the question, Mr.
Horowitz?
Q You didn't believe prior to May 2005 in
your mind that was 18 years old or older,
isn't that true?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A What I believed in my mind,
unfortunately I would like to answer every
question with regard tc  that you posed here
today, very much would like to answer every
question with respect to■ However, at least
today I have to assert my rights on advice of
counsel under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
jwSir, before May of 2005, you knew that
as under the age of 18; Isn't that right?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Sir, I would like to answer every
question with respect tc=that you've posed
here today. However, my counsel has advised me
that at least today I may not, and must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Sir, prior to May 2005.never told
you she was 18 or older; isn't that true?
MR. PIKE: Form?
A I would very much like to answer
questions, every question with respect
that you've posed here today, Mr. Horowitz.
However, upon advice of my counsel, they've
1 advised me that I must assert my rights under the
2 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
3 Prior to May 2005. no one told you that
4 •was under the age of 18; isn't that right?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A I would very much like to answer every
7 question with respect to what. and what
8 everyone — other people said about.
However, at least today my counsel advised me
that I may not. They've advised me that I must
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
(Multi•page document was marked as
Plaintiffs Exhibit number 8 for
identification, as of this date.)
Q Sir, I've just handed you defendant
Jeffrey Epstein's Answer and Affirmative Defenses
to plaintiff's Amended Complaints in the Jane
Does number 8 lawsuit, filed by  Do you have
that in front of you?
A Yes.
Q I'll ask you to turn, please, to page 6,
which is the Affirmative Defenses.
With regard to paragraph one, what facts
do you have to support your contention that ME
1 consented to and was a willing participant in the
2 acts alleged?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A I would like to answer every question
5 about J.M. here today. However, my counsel has
6 advised me that at least today — I must assert
7 my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
8 Amendment, though I would ve mt like to
9 answer every question regardin
10 Q Sir, what facts do you know of to
11 support the statement thateonsented to and
12 was a willing participant in the acts alleged?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A Though I would like to answer every
15 question about any alleged incident with mh-
16 counsel has advised me that at least today I must
17 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
18 Fourteenth Amendment.
19 Q Isn't it true, sir, you're not aware of
20 anyone who has facts to support your assertion
21 that  consented to and was a willing
22 participant in the acts alleged?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A I would like to answer every question
25 regarding■ and her claims, and these alleged
15 (Pages 389 to 392)
U.S. Legal Support
393 395
incidents. However, today, at least today, my 1 question that you've posed regarding your client,
2 counsel has advised me that I must assert my 2 =However, my counsel here today has advised
3 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth 3 me that 1 must assert my rights under the Sixth,
4 Amendment. . 4 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment, at least today.
Q Okay, turning to paragraph two, what 5 Q Turning to paragraph four of the
6 fact a aware of to support your contention 6 Affirmative Defenses, It is on the following page
7 that consented to and participated in 7 If you want to follow along; what facts do you
8 similar or identical acts with other people? 8 have to support your contention that you believed
9 MR. PIKE: Form. 9 attained the age of 18 at the time of the
10 A With respect to acts with similar other 10 alleged acts?
11 people, I would very much like to answer that 11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 question. However, at least today my counsel has 12 A I would very much like to answer every
13 advised me that I must assert my rights under the 13 question with respect to and her claims.
14 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment. 14 However, today, at least today, my attorneys have
15 Isn't it true, sir, that this assertion 15 advised me that I must assert my rights under the
16 that consented to and participated in 16 Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
17 similar or identical acts with other persons; 17 Q Isn't it true, sir, you knew that
18 that's not a true statement, is it? 18 was under the age of IS at the time of the
19 MR. PIKE: Form. 19 alleged acts?
20 A I would very much like to answer every 20 . MR. PIKE: Form.
21 single question with respect t c. and her 21 A I would very much like to answer every
22 alleged claims of alleged incidents. However, 22 question with respect to. claims. However,
23 today, my counsel has advised me I must assert my 23 my counsel today has advised me I must assert my
24 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth 24 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
25 Amendment. 25 Amendment.
394 396
1 Q Isn't it true, sir, you're not aware of 1 Q kill it true, sir, you had no reason to
2 anyone who has facts to support your assertion 2 believe that ■Win IS years old or older at
3 that-consented to and participated in 3 the time of the alleged acts?
4 similar or identical acts with other people? 4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 MR. PIKE: Form. 5 A I would like to answer every single
6 A I would like to answer every question 6 question regardingns claims, sir. However,
7 with respect to her alleged claims and 7 at least today my counsel has advised me I must
8 alleged incidents. However, today my counsel 8 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
9 has advised me that I must assert my rights under 9 Fourteenth Amendment
10 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment, sir. 10 Q Isn't It true, sir, ever told you
11 Q Turning to paragraph three, what facts 11 she was 18 or older?
12 do you have to support your assertion that 12 MR. PIKE: Form.
13 consented to the acts alleged by not objecting? 13 A I would very much like to answer every
14 MR. PIKE: F0(111. 14 question regarding claims. However, today
15 A I would like to answer every question 15 my counsel has advised me that I must assert my
16 with respect to= claims and alleged 6 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
17 incidents. However, today my counsel has advised 7 Amendment.
18 me I must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth 8 Q Isn't It true, sir, no one ever told you
19 and Fourteenth Amendment. 9 that was 18 or older?
20 Q Isn't it true, sir, you're not aware of 0 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 anyone who has facts to support your assertion 1 A I would like to answer every question
22 that consented to the facts alleged by not 2 with respect to claims. However, at least
23 objecting? 3 today my counsel has advised me that I may not,
24 MR. PIKE: Form. 4 and though I would like to, they told me I must
25 A I would very much like to answer every 5 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
16 (Pages 393 to 396)
U.S. Le al Su ort
397 399
i Fourteenth Amendment.
2 Q Sir did on ever pay for a telephone
3 numb. pay the phone bill?
4 A I would have to assert my rights under
5 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment, sir.
6 Q Between 2001 and 2006, did you use the
7 telephone number • to get kids to
8 come to your home for your sexual pleasure?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer all these
questions regarding phone numbers, I'm sorry but
I may not on advice of counsel, so I must assert
my rights under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Did you direct one or more people to use
the telephone number a order to
get kids, girls, to come to your home for your
sexual pleasure?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every one
of your questions today regarding phone numbers,
on advice of counsel. I may not, because it may
be relevant to other lawsuits or this lawsuit,
and they've instructed me that I must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
1 age of 18 to come to your home for your sexual
2 pleasure?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A I would like to answer every one of your
5 questions regarding these phone numbers and
6 allegations. However, today, my counsel has
7 advised me that I may not and must assert my
B rights under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth
9 Amendment.
10 Q slave you ever paid the telephone bill or
11 had registered in your name the phone number
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A Mr. Horowitz, l would like to answer
15 each one of your questions regarding phone
16 numbers here today, but on advice of counsel
17 they've told melmust assert my rights under the
18 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
19 Q Is -a  telephone number you
20 used between 2001 and 2006 to get girls under the

21. age of 18 to come to your home for your sexual
22 pleasure?
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A Though I would like to answer every one
25 of your questions regarding telephone numbers, my
Amendment.
Q Have you ever either paid or had
re istered to you the telephone number=
MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer every question
7 regarding phone numbers, Mr. Horowitz. My
8 attorneys have asked me to respond to most of
9 your questions here today by asserting my rights
10 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment I
11 will have to do so with respect to that question.
12 Q Between the years 2001 and 2006, did you
13 use the telephone number in order
14 to arrange for girls under the age of IS to come
15 to your home for your sexual pleasure?
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A I would like to answer every one of your
18 questions regarding phone numbers here today, Mr.
19 Horowitz. However, on advice of counsel, at
20 least today, they've instructed me that I must
21 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
22 Fourteenth Amendment.
23 Q Between 2001 and 2006. did you direct
24 one or more people to use the telephone number
25 In order to get girls under the
398 400
1 counsel has advised me that at least today I may
2 not, because it may be relevant to this lawsuit
3 or another lawsuit, and they've instructed me
4 that I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
5 Fifth an dment.
6 Q I a telephone number
7 that you directed to other people to use in order
8 to gel kids to come to your home for your sexual
9 pleasure?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A I would like to answer every one of your
12 questions regarding phone numbers allegedly used
13 for these types of purposes. However, my counsel
14 today has advised me l may not and have
15 instructed me I must assert my rights under the
16 Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
17 Q Sir, have you ever paid the phone bill
18 or had registered In your name the phone number
20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 A Though I would like to answer that
22 question as I would like to answer every one of
23 your questions here today, my counsel has advised
24 me that at least today, I must assert my rights
25 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment,
17 (Pages 397 to 400)
U.S. Legal Support
sir.
Q Is the tekphonc number i
a telephone number you used between 2001 and 2006
hi order to get girls under the age of 18 to come
to your home for your sexual pleasure?

MR. PIKE: Form
A I would like to mower evay one of your
questions with respect to these telephone
numbers. However, my counsel today has advised
me that I must assert, at least today, my rights
under the Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Sir, is telephone
number that you directed other people to use in
order to get girls under the age of Itt to come to
your home for your sexual pleasure?

MR. PIKE: Form
A I would like to answer every question
regarding these telephone numbers. However, my
counsel has advised me that at least today, that
I may not and they've instructed me I must assert
my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment
Q Sir, have you ever registered in your
same or paid the phone bill for telephone number
phone numbers. However, upon advice of my
counsel, they've instructed me that I must assert
my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Sir, have you ever paid the phone bill
or had the phone number registered
in your name?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would very much like to answer every
question regarding phone numbers that you've
posed here today, Mr. Horowitz. However, my
counsel has advised me that at least today I must
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q SIr, is the telephone number Ie
a telephone number you used between 2001
and 2004 to get underage girls to come to your
home for your sexual pleasure?

MR. PIKE Form.
A I would very much like to ensues' even'
one of your questions posed here today with
regard to telephone numbers or anything else.
However, my counsel has advised me at least today
that I may not, and must assort my rights under
the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
402 404
1 MR. PIKE: Form. 1 Sir, is the telephone number
2 A I would like  answer each one of your 2 a telephone number you directed others
3 questions today, Mr. Horowitz, regarding these 3 to use in order to get underage girls to come to
4 telephone numbers. My counsel has advised me 4 your home for your sexual pleasure?
5 that at least today I may not, and must assert my 5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth 6 A I would like to answer every one of your
7 Amendment. 7 questions regarding phone numbers, Mr. Horowitz.
8 Q Is a telephone number you 8 However, today my counsel has advised me that I
9 used between 2001 and 2006 to get girls under the 9 must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
10 age of 18 to come to your home for your sexual 10 Fourteenth Amendment.

11. pleasure? 11 Q Sir, have you ever paid the phone bill
12 MR. PIKE: Form. 12 or had the phone number registered
13 A Though I would very much like to answer 13 in your name?
14 every question regarding — that you've posed 14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 here today regarding phone numbers, on advice of 15 A Sir, I would like to answer every one of
16 cbunsel, I may not. They've instructed me I must 16 your questions regarding phone numbers. However,
17 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and 17 my counsel has advised me that at least today I
18 Fourteen 18 must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
19 Q Is a telephone number you 19 Fourteenth Amendment.
20 directed other people to use in order to get 20 Q Is the telephone number a
21 girls under the age of 18 to come to your home 21 telephone number that you used between 2101 and
22 for your sexual pleasure? 22 2006 in order to get kids to conic to your home
23 MR. PIKE: Form. 23 for your sexual pleasure?
24 A I would like to answer every one of your 24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 questions posed here today regarding various 25 A Though I would Tike to answer every one
18 (Pages 401 to 404)
U.S. Le al Su ort
405 407
/5
of your questions regarding phone numbers here
today, Mr. Horowitz, my counsel has advised me
that I may not and must assert my rights under
the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Sir, is telephone number
a telephone number that you directed others to
use In order to get underage girls to come to
your home for your sexual pleasure?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every one
of your questions regarding phone numbers, Mr.
Horowitz, the various phone numbers you've now
put on the table, my counsel has advised me at
least today I may not. I must assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Sir, have you ever paid the phone bill
or had registered In your name the telephone
number

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Mr. Horowitz, I would like to answer
every one of your questions regarding phone
numbers that you've posed here today. However,
upon advice of counsel, they've instructed me I
must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
regarding these various phone numbers you've
thrown out today, my counsel have advised me that
I may not, and must assert my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Sir, have you ever paid the phone bill
for telephone number

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Mr. Horowitz. ) would very much like to
answer all your questions regarding all the
various phone numbers you've thrown out here
today. However, on advice of counsel they've
asked me to assert my Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment right.
is the telephone number
a telephone number that you used between
2001 and 2006 in order to get underage girls to
come to your home for your sexual pleasure?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Mr. Horowitz, with respect to all these
phone numbers you keep throwing out, I have to
unfortunately answer the question the same way as
rye answered all your other questions here
today, which is I'm going to have to assert my
rights upon the advice of counsel under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
1 Q Is a telephone number
2 that you used between 2001 and 2006 in order to
3 get girls under the age of 18 to come to your
4 home for your sexual pleasure?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A Mr. Horowitz, I would very much like to
7 answer every one of your questions regarding
various numbers you've thrown out here today. I
have to answer that question like I've answered
all your other questions here today, which is on
advice of counsel I may not answer these
questions as they may not be relevant to another
lawsuit --
Q Sir — go ahead, sorry.
A though I would like to, I am going to
have to assert my rights as instructed by
counsel, under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Sir, is the telephone number
a telephone number that you directed
others to use In order to bring girls to your
home for your sexual pleasure?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer each and
every one of your questions, Mr. Horowitz,
S
Q Sir, a telephone
numberitrh
k
at you directed other people to use in
order to get girls to come to your home for your
sexual pleasure?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Although I would like to answer every
one of your questions regarding the various phone
numbers that you've thrown out today, at least
today. upon advice of counsel, I have to assert
my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Have you ever paid the phone bill for
telephone number

MR. PIKE: Form?
A With respect to all the phone numbers
you've thrown out here today and asked questions
with regard to today, my counsel has advised me
must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Is the telephone number
telephone number you directed other people to use
in order to bring girls under the age of IA to
your home for your sexual pleasure?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I have to answer that question as I've
19 (Pages 405 to 408)
U.S. Legal Support
409 411
answered most of your other questions here today,

Mr. Horowitz, which is upon advice of counsel I
have to assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth
end Fourteenth Amendment
Q Sir, have you ever paid the phone bill
for telephone number

MR. PIKE: Form.
A You've asked me many telephone numbers
here today, Mr. Horowitz. I'm going to have to
respond to that telephone number as I have to
each and every one of your other phone numbers
you've thrown out today, which is upon advice of
counsel, they've instructed me to assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment although I would like to answer every
one of your questions
Q Is the number S a
telephone number that you directed other people
to use in order to bring underage girls to your
home for your sexual pleasure?
MR. PIKE: Fenn.
A Though I would like to answer every
question regarding phone numbers that you've
posed here today, Mr. Horowitz, unfortunately my
counsel advised me I must assert my rights under
1 interest in a business entity known as Zorro
2 Ranch?
3 A Though I would like to answer every one
4 of your questions, I would have to answer that
S one as I've answered all your other questions
6 here today, which is upon advice of counsel today
7 they've asked me -- instructed me to assert my
8 rights under the Sixth, Filth and Fourteenth
9 Amendment.
10 Q Sir, have you ever owned or had a
11 beneficial interest, been a director or officer
12 of New York Strategy Group, LLC?
13 A Mr. Horowitz. I would like to answer all
14 of your questions here today, but unfortunately
15 my counsel has asked me — instructed me to
16 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
17 Fourteenth Amendment.
18 Q Have you ever owned or had a beneficial
19 interest in or been an officer or director or
20 founder of the COUQ Foundation?
21 A Though I would like to answer every one
22 of your questions, Mr. Horowitz, I have to
23 respond to that question as I have responded to
24 almost all of your other questions here today,
25 which is that upon advice of counsel, they've
1 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
2 Q Sir, have you ever owned or had a
3 beneficial interest in a corporation known as
4 Nine East 71st Street Corporation?
S A I would like to answer every one of your
6 questions here today, Mr. Horowitz, but on advice
7 of counsel, at least today, I'm going to have to
8 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
9 Fourteenth Amendment.
10 Q Sir, have you ever owned or had a
beneficial Interest in .1. Epstein & Company?
12 A Sir, at least today with respect to most
13 of your questions, like — I've answered almost
14 all of your questions here today, upon advice of
15 counsel, they've asked me to assert my rights
16 under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
17 Q Have you ever owned or had a beneficial
18 interest or been nn officer of Zorro Development
19 Corporation?
20 A I would like to answer every one of your
21 questions here today, Mr. Horowitz. However,
22 upon advice of counsel at least today, they've
23 asked me to assert my rights under the Sixth,
24 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
25 Q Have you ever owned or had a beneficial
1 instructed me I must assert my rights under the
2 Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
3 Q Have you ever been an owner, shareholder
4 or had a beneficial interest in Financial
5 Strategy Group, Inc.?
6 A I would like to answer that question, as
7 well as every other question you've posed here
8 today. However, my counsel has advised me that
9 at least today I must assert my rights under the
10 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
11 Q Have you ever owned or had a beneficial
12 interest or been a shareholder in Financial
13 Trustees, Inc.?
14 A Though I would like to answer every one
15 of your questions here, that you've posed here
16 today, Mr. Horowitz, I have to unfortunately
17 answer that question the same way as I've
18 answered almost all of your other questions here
19 today. Upon advice of my counsel they've
20 instructed me to assert my Sixth, Fifth and
21 Fourteenth Amendment right.
22 Q Sir, have you ever been an owner,
23 shareholder, officer or director of the Gislaine
24 Corporation?
25 A Can you spell that?
20 (Pages 409 to 412)
U.S. Legal Support
413 415
1 Q am I mispronouncing?
2 A Yes,
3 Q How would you pronounce It?
4 A Gislaine.
5 Q Okay.
6 A I'm sorry, but today at least I have to
7 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
8 Fourteenth Amendment upon advice of counsel.
9 Q Sir, have you ever been an
10 owner/shareholder or director of the LAW
11 Plantation Management Corporation?
12 A I would like to answer every one of your
13 questions here today, Mr. Horowitz, with respect
14 to that one, as well as all the others, I have to
15 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
16 Fourteenth Amendment.
17 Q Sir, have you ever been an owner,
18 shareholder or director of a business entity
19 known as Epstein Interests?
20 A With respect to that question, as well
21 as all of your other questions here today, my
22 counsel advised me I may only answer the
23 questions by asserting my rights under the Sixth,
24 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
25 Q Sir, have you ever been officer,
1 THE WITNESS: Take a quick..
2 (Indicating counsel.)
3 711E VIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the video
4 record 1:53 a.m.
5 (Pause in the proceedings.)
6 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the record
7 I I:56 a.m.
8 (The record was read.)
9 A Yes.
10 Q Are you an owner of the Florida Science
11 Foundation?
12 A On advice of counsel, at least today,
13 sir, I have been instructed to assert my rights
14 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
15 Q Are you an employee of Florida Science
16 Foundation?
17 A Yes.
18 Q What do you do in your role as an
19 employee of Florida Science Foundation?
0 A Though 1 would like to answer all of
1 your questions here today, Mr. Horowitz, upon
22 advice of counsel, they've instructed me I must
r 3 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
4 Fourteenth Amendment.
5 Q What kind of work is the Florida Science
1 director, shareholder or employee of the Wexner
2 Investment Group?
3 A I have to respond to that question as I
have responded to all your other questions here
5 today, Mr. Horowitz. Upon advice of counsel
6 they've instructed me to assert my rights under
7 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
8 Q Sir, have you ever been a shareholder or
9 owner of MC Squared Modeling?
10 A With respect to that question, as all
11 the other questions you've posed here today, my
12 counsel has advised me I must assert my rights
13 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
14 Q Sir, do you have an ownership or
15 beneficial interest in a business entity known as
16 JEGE?
17 A I'm going to have to respond to that
18 question as I responded to all of your other
19 questions here today, Mr. Horowitz, which is, on
20 advice of counsel they've asked me to assert my
21 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
22 Amendment.
23 Q Sir, do you have an ownership or
24 beneficial interest or even an employee of an
25 entity known as the Florida Science Foundation?
1 Foundation involved in, if any?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A Though I would very much like to answer
4 all of your questions here today, Mr. Horowitz,
5 upon advice of counsel, they've instructed me to
6 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
7 Fourteenth Amendment.
8 Q Where do you work for the Florida
9 Science Foundation?
0 MR. PIKE: Form.
1 A At 250 South Australian. That's the
2 offices.
Q Is that the City of West Palm Beach?
A Yes, sir.
5 Q During what hours do you work at the
Florida Science Foundation?
instructed me to assert my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
0 Q How long have you been working at the
Florida Science Foundation?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
A Upon advice of counsel, sir, they've
A I would like to answer all of your
i24 questions here today, Mr. Horowitz. However,
upon advice of counsel, at least today, they've 125 21 ( Pages 413 to 416)
U.S. Legal Support
417 419
instructed me to assert my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q On what days do you work for the Florida
Science Foundation?

MR. PIKE: Forth.
A Though I would like to answer each one
of your questions hue today, my counsel has
advised me that at least today I must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Who else, if anyone, works for the
Florida Science Foundation?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to --
MR. PIKE: You know that's standard
Fifth Amendment, anyway.
A Though I would like to answer each and
every one of your questions today, Mr. Horowitz,
my counsel has advised me with respect to that
question, I must assert my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
Q is the Florida Science Foundation a
for-profit or nonprofit corporation?
A Upon advice of counsel, sir, with
respect to that question, I'm going to have to
1 MR. PIKE: To the extent you can answer
2 that question without divulging my
3 communications with you, you can answer that
4 question.
5 ANo.
6 Q Did you review any materials, such as
7 depositions, police reports, anything else in
8 preparation for your deposition today?
9 ANo.
10 Q Did you review any notes or any
11 handwritten materials in preparation for your
12 deposition today?
13 A No.
14 Q You have notes on a piece of paper, art
15 those notes that you have made or reviewed in
16 preparation for your continuation of this
17 deposition here today?
18 A No.
19 Q In the past you've told me that some
0 time ago at another deposition, that you did not
1 like Jane Doe; is that right?
2 A I don't believe — I have no
3 recollection of that.
24 Q To be more specific, and hopefully to
25 Jog your memory, do you remember telling me you
1 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
2 Fourteenth Amendment.
3 MR. HOROWITZ: Sir, at this moment in
4 time, I don't have further questions. There
may be some other questions that arise from
6 other people's questions.
7 THE WITNESS: All right.
8 MR. PIKE: Thank you, Mr. Horowitz.
9 MR. EDWARDS: Does anybody want to
10 address what we are going to do for lunch?
11 MR. HOROWITZ: You don't have to type
12 this.
13 (Discussion off the record.)
14 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the video record
15 at 12:00 o'clock noon.
16 (Pause in the proceedings.)
17 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Rack on the video
18 record 12:11 p.m.
19 MR. EDWARDS: Ready?
20 MR. PIKE: Yes, thank you.
21 THE WITNESS: Yes.
22 Q I represent Jane Doe inn case against
23 you and she is one of like ten representative
24 plaintiffs here today. Did you do anything to
25 prepare for your deposition today?
like L.M., but don't like my other two, one of
those clients being Jane Doe; do you recall that?
A I would like to answer every one of your
questions, Mr. Edwards, but today at least, my
counsel advised me I must assert my rights under
the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Why don't you like Jane Doe?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer every one of your
questions, Mr. Edwards. However, today my
counsel has advised me that I measures assert my
rights under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Did you sexually molest Jane Doe when
she was 14 and I5 years old?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer all of your
22 (Pages 417 to 420)
U.S. Legal Support
421 423
1 questions with respect to Jane Doe. However my
2 counsel here today advised me I may not and must
3 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
4 Fourteenth Amendment.
5 MR. EDWARDS: Move to strike as
6 nonresponsive.
7 Q When you say you would like to answer
B the questions, but your counsel has instructed
you that you must invoke your Fifth, Sixth and
Fourteenth Amendment rights, are you saying that
you disagree with the advice of your counsel?

MR. PIKE: I instruct you not to answer
that question.
MR. EDWARDS: On what ground?
MR. PIKE: I don't need to give you
grounds.

MR. EDWARDS: It is not a privilege,
just something you're instructing him not to
answer?
MR. PIKE: Absolutely it is a
privilege. You heard him, what he said. He
22 is invoking his Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
23 Amendment in and as a result of his advice
24 of counsel. Your question elicits
25 attorney/client communications as well as
Q Have you read the statute or been
instructed upon the Florida statute related to
lewd and lascivious molestation?

MR. PIKE: Form, instruct you not to
answer that question, attorney/client work
product, as worded.
Q Other than your attorney telling you
about the statute, or reading that statute to
you, I certainly do not want and am not entitled
to communications between you and your attorney,
but have you otherwise familiarized yourself,
either by way of reading the statute or being
told by somebody other than your attorneys,
regarding the statute lewd and lascivious
molestation?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every one
of you ever questions here today, Mr. Edwards,
most of your questions I have to respond by
asserting on advice of counsel my Sixth, Fifth
and Fourteenth Amendment right.
Q Lewd and lascivious molestation is
defined in Florida as a person who intentionally
touches In a lewd or lascivious manner, the
breasts, genitals, general area, or buttocks, or
1 work product.
2 Q So, attorney/client work product is the
3 basis for your objection? I understand.
4 MR. PIKE: Yeah.
5 Q Mr. Epstein, are you going to follow
6 your advice of counsel and invoke your Fifth
7 Amendment right against self-incritnination and
not answer that question?
A I'm going to follow my advice of
counsel.
Q Mr. Epstein, are you familiar with the
laws in Florida on lewd and lascivious
molestation?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A On advice of counsel I have to assert my
rights with the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Do you understand my question in that
I'm not asking you whether you committed any
crimes related to the statute, only whether or
not you are familiar with the Florida statute on
lewd and lascivious molestation; do you
understand that question?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A What does "familiar" mean.
(20
1 the clothing covering them, of a person less than
2 I6 years of age, or forces or entices a person
3 under 16 years of age to so touch the
4 perpetrator."
5 Having read that, isn't that a statute
6 that you violated on numerous occasions against
7 Jane Doe when she was a minor?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A I would -- have to assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
upon advice of counsel, Mr. Edwards.
Q Subchapter six of that statute involves
a crime of lewd and lascivious conduct that in
Florida is defined as a person who intentionally
touches a person under 16 years of age in a lewd
6 and lascivious manner, or a person who
intentionally masturbates in the presence of a
victim under 16 years of age." Those are also
sections of that Florida statute that you
violated against the then minor. Jane Doe; is
that true?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer all of your
questions with respect to Jane Doe, Mr. Edwards.
However, today my counsel has advised me that I
23 (Pages 421 to 424)
U.S. Legal Support
425 427
am to assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.

MR. EDWARDS: Move to strike the
nonresponsive portion of that answer.
MR. PIKE: What's nonresponsive?
MR. EDWARDS: What you would like to do
is not responsive to the question related to
his course of conduct. "Did you molest
ha," is either "yes" or "no" or "invoked."
I don't really care and I don't think it is
relevant, what he would like to do. That's
the part I would move to strike.

MR. PIKE: If that's the part you're
moving to strike, it is duly noted in the
record.
MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
MR. PIKE: I object to that. For the
record, based upon your comment, there have
been several depositions in these
consolidated cases and there has been
implied arguments from the plaintiffs side
relative to the Fifth Amendment waiver and
why Mr. Epstein is invoking the Sixth, Fifth
and Fourteenth Amendment Constitutional
privileges and there are various adverse
1 molestation statutes against Jane Doe?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A Upon advice of counsel, Mr. Edwards, I
4 have to respond to that question as I responded
5 to most of your other questions here today, by
6 asserting my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
7 Fourteenth Amendment.
8 I prefer to, in fact, respond to your
9 partner who helped file this lawsuit, but he is
10 currently in jail. You might want to strike that
11 as nonresponsive, but the ladies and gentlemen of
12 the jury will eventually know that most of these
13 cases have been brought by your finn, your
14 partner who sits in a jail for fabricating cases
15 of sexual nature against people like me and
16 others.
17 Q Okay. Let's talk about that, then.
18 You're talking about Scott Rothstein? Is that
19 right? You're saying my former partner. Is that
0 who you're referring to that sits in jail?
1 A Correct.
2 Q Okay, what about anything that Scott
3 Rothstein did, affects your answer to my question
4 as to whether or not you molested Jane Doe back
5 in 2003 and 2004?
1 inferences that I'm sure the plaintiffs will
2 attempt to gain.
3 There have been arguments made relative
to the Fifth Amendment and I think that you
5 have, in particular, Mr. Edwards. have
6 attempted to balance what Mr. Epstein would
7 like to do, versus what if he did that,
whether or not there would be a waiver of
the Fifth, the Sixth and the Fourteenth. So,
I understand your motion to strike and it is
noted on the record, but I have to make
clear for the record that there have been
those arguments made and there is a balance
as to what someone would like to do versus
what someone can do, and the resulting
consequences of that being waiver.
Q Given what your attorney just said, my
understanding that... You have been instructed
that if you answer these questions, as you would
0 like to, that it would incriminate you?
1 MR. PIKE: Mischaracterizes my
objection; and I instruct you not to
answer.
Q Why is it that you would like to answer
questions about whether or not you violated
1 MR. PIKE: Form?
2 A I would like to answer that question
3 with respect to Scott Rothstein, his fabricated
4 cases and the reason he sits in jail. However,
5 today, at least today, my counsel has advised me
6 I must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth
7 and Fourteenth Amendment.
8 Q Yon say "at least today," but that's
9 something we have gone through with you day after
10 day, after day, and you say "at least today," and
11 we wait for the next deposition and again there
12 is assertion of a Firth Amendment right. Is
13 there ever going to be a day where you do answer
14 the questions?
15 MR. PIKE: Form. Move to strike.
16 A On advice of counsel, as I've answered
17 most of your other questions here today, be them
18 argumentative or not, meant for other purposes or
19 not, my answer is going to be that my counsel has
20 advised me that at least today I must Men my
21 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
22 Amendment.
23 Q You indicated in your previous answer
24 that most of the eases were brought by me or my
25 former partner, Scott Rothstein. My
24 (Pages 425 to 428)
U.S. Le al Su ort
429 431
1 understanding is that there were more than 20
2 cases brought against you alleging you sexually
3 abused minors, and I have personally only filed
4 three. How many are you aware of in addition to
the three that Scott Rothstein filed, or brought,
as you say?
7 MR. PIKE: Form, mischaracterizcs the
8 witness's testimony.
9 MR. EDWARDS: Do you want the previous
10 answer read back related to that?
11 MR. PIKE: No, I think his answer will
12 be the same.
13 A At least today I have to respond to that
14 question as I've responded to most of your other
15 questions here today, Mr. Edwards, which is, at
16 least today I have to assert my rights under the
17 Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth Amendment.
18 Q In a portion of your answer, you
19 indicated that Scott Rothstein fabricated cases.
20 Are you alleging that the case of Jane Doe
21 against Jeffrey Epstein Is a fabricated case?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A I would like to answer each one of your
24 questions here today, Mr. Edwards, especially
25 with respect to Jane Doe. However, my counsel
1 other questions, which is, that upon advice of
2 counsel, at least today, they've instructed me
3 that I must assert my rights under the Sixth.
4 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
5 Q Isn't it also true that through the
6 years he has sent you as, quote, unquote,
7 "gifts," underage females, as young as I2 years
8 old for you to illegally engage in sex with?

MR. PIKE: Fonn.
A I'm going to respond to that question as
I responded to most of your other questions,
which is, upon advice ofcounsel, at least today,
though I would like to answer the question,
they've instructed me I must assert my rights
under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q In fact, you know that we served Mr.
Brunel for deposition In this case. Are you
aware of that?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I'm going to have to respond to that
question as I respond to all your other questions
here today, Mr. Edwards, which is by asserting my
rights under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q He has been a house guest at your house
1 has instructed me I must assert my rights under
2 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
3 Q Mr. Epstein, do you know a gentleman
4 named Jean Luc Brunel and the last name is
5 spelled 13-r-u-n-e-l.
6 MR.. PIKE: Form.
7 A My counsel has advised meat least
8 today, Mr. Edwards, as I've responded to most of
9 your other questions, I have to assert my right
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Mr. Brunel is somebody that you know to
be a child molester; is that right?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer every one of your
questions here today, Mr. Edwards. However, on
advice of counsel, they've instructed me I must
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Mr. Brunel has been a close friend of
yours for years and is still a close friend of
yours today; is that right?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every one
of your questions posed here today, I have to
answer that one as I've answered most of your
1 on numerous occasions this year; isn't that
2 true?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A Though I would like to answer every one
5 of your questions here today, Mr. Edwards, I have
6 to respond to that question on advice of counsel
7 the same way as I've responded to all of your
8 other questions, which is, I must assert my
9 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
10 Amendment.
11 Q I've asked you simply, if Mr. Brunel has
12 been a house guest of yours during the year 2010,
13 and you're choosing to invoke your Fifth
14 Amendment right against self-incrimination and
15 basing that on your counsel's advice.
16 Does your counsel know that you made
17 that representation to Probation already this
18 year?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 Q Do you understand the question?
21 A Are you asking me what my counsel
22 knows?
23 Q No.
24 A I think you just asked what my counsel
25 knows.
25 (Pages 429 to 432)
U.S. Legal Support
433 435
1 MR. PIKE: That's exactly what
2 A You should ask my counsel.
3 Q Here is my point: You've indicated to
4 your Probation Officer this year, in fact, I'll
5 ask it this way: Have you indicated to your
6 Probation Officer that Jean Luc Brunel has bees a
7 house guest of yours during the year 2010?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I have been insuumed by my counsel to
answer that question, as I have been instructed
to answer most of your other questions here
today, which is by asserting my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Do you know an attorney named Tama
Kudman?

MR. PIKE: Form -- actually that's not
"form." I withdraw that.
A No.
Q Did Mr. Brunel ten you that Tama Kudman
was an attorney that was hired to repre)ent him
in this ease?

MR. PIKE: I'm sorry, hold on.
MR. EDWARDS: Did Mr. Brunel tell him.
MR. PIKE: Dicey, tam.
A I'm going to have to answer that
21.

MR. EDWARDS: Agreed.
MIL PIKE: His response is his verbal
response.
MR. EDWARDS: I understand that, but
certainly if a witness is on the witness
stand we both know they are allowed to
observe the demeanor of the witness and part
of that demeanor is the nodding or shaking
of the head, which are common responses that
is we all know and understand. I just want
to make sure we are on the same page, the
jury can ignore those body movements?

MR. PIKE: Asa matter of fact, and as
you know, since you tried several cases,
there is a patterned jury instruction from
the judge that says the jury can, in fact,
take it into consideration.

MR. HOROWITZ: That's the point.
MR. PIKE: I cannot instruct the jury in
this video deposition to ignore anything
that occurs on this video.

MR. EDWARDS: That's why I wanted to
engage so I would make sure -- we are a
little inconsistent obviously as to what the
Jury should be observing, what they can,
1 question as I've answered most of your other
2 questions here today, Mr. Edwards, which is by
3 asserting my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
4 Fourteenth Amendment.
5 Q And did you or some entity that you own
6 or control pay for the services of Tama Kudman to
represent Jean Luc Brunel, in this matter?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A ... I'm going to have to assert my rights
10 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
11 upon advice of counsel.
12 Q I certainly don't want to get into this
13 too often during this deposition but it is
14 visibly noticed on the video that prior to the
15 invocation of the Fifth Amendment, there is a
16 shaking of the head which commonly indicates that
17 the answer Is "No," and I just want to make sure
18 we are all on the same page, that that was not
19 your indication and that we can ignore those
20 types of body movements, as Mr. Pike instructed
21 me that was the case last time.
22 MR. PIKE: I think that the record is
23 clear. The court reporter does not
24 understand nods of the head, shakes of the
25 head, "um-hum" --
versus his response. I guess for this time
we will get into it.
Q In that last question that I asked you,
related to you or some entity that you control
paying for the services of Ms. Kudman, is the
answer "no" or is the answer that you are
invoking your Fifth Amendment right to remain
silent?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A With respect to that question, as with
respect to all your other questions here today,

Mr. Edwards, upon advice of counsel I have to
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Isn't it true that you have specifically
instructed Mr. Brunel to avoid his deposition in
this case?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Upon advice of counsel, as with respect
to most of your other questions here today, I'm
going to answer that the same way by invoking my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment, sir.
Q Mr. Epstein, can you describe for the
jury your various schemes that you have devised
26 (Pages 433 to 436)
U.S. Le al Su ort
437 439
1 to access underage minor females for sex?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A Though I would like to respond to all
4 these questions that you've posed here today, Mr.
5 Edwards, I'm going to have to assert my rights
6 under advice of counsel under the Sixth, Fifth
7 and Fourteenth Amendment.
8 Q I think the video will reflect that
9 prior to your invocation at that time there was a
smile that I would characterize as a smirk, prior
to that answer, and I would like to understand,
was there any intention on your part to convey a
message by that smile, prior to your invocation?

MR. PIKE: First of all, this line of
questioning is not only argumentative, but
it is harassing, okay?
MR. EDWARDS: We can play the video for
whether or not it is harassing.

MR. PIKE: You can play the video, but
if someone raises an eyebrow, blinks, does
something, it is... it is... for you to
follow up with a harassing question is not
only improper, but it is a waste of time, of
attorney resources as well as judicial
resources. I'm going to let you proceed, I
1 of my counsel, he's instructcd me that 1 may
2 not. I must invoke my rights under the Sixth,
3 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
4 Q Mr. Epstein, is it true that you have
5 sexually molested underage minors in every
6 community where you have homes or houses?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A Though I would like to answer each one
9 of your questions here today, Mr. Edwards, I
10 would like to answer that question, to you and

11. your partner, who sits in jail for fabricating
12 cases of a sexual nature against people like me
13 and others in South Florida, but today, upon
14 advice of my counsel, they've instructed mel
15 must assert my rights under the Fifth, Sixth and
16 Fourteenth Amendment.
17 THE WITNESS: Before you go to the
18 bathroom?
19 MR. EDWARDS: Move to strike the portion
0 of the answer that was nonresponsive.
1 MR. PIKE: One second.
2 MR. EDWARDS: Move to strike the portion
3 of the answer nonresponsive.
4 MR. PIKE: Move to strike your motion to
5 strike.
S
mean, but... come on.

MR. EDWARDS: With all due respect, I'm
interpreting it as an intentional act
designed to dilute the invocation of the
Fifth Amendment and any adverse inference
that we may be entitled to, and I think that
you acknowledged previously that a jury will
have or could have the ability to view this
video, and I'm assuming a jury could make
that same inference, so I want to make sure
the record is just crystal clear. if the
answer is one answer and there is no body
movement, then I'll move on. If there is
body movement, I'm probably going to address
it.

MR. PIKE: Fm going to move to strike
your last narrative.
MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
Q What individuals other titan yourself
helped you to devise your various schemes for
accessing large numbers of minor females for
sex?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every one
of your questions today, Mr. Edwards, upon advice
1 MR. EDWARDS: Based on the fact that it
2 was responsive? You feel it was
3 responsive?
4 MR. PIKE: Absolute — listen --
5 MR. EDWARDS: It is fine if you do.
6 MR. PIKE: You're harassing the witness,
7 you're talking about heads and nod shakes.
8 If you want to be clear for the record,1
9 think, and Fm I think -- I think the
10 witness is nodding and shaking his head in a
1 manner because your questions are
12 argumentative. 'Please tell me the scheme
3 that you devised?
4 "Please tell me who you molested," all
S of these are argumentative questions --
6 MR. EDWARDS: If it wasn't true, it
7 would be argumentative.
8 MR. PIKE: They are just not formed
9 right. You are sitting here subjecting the
0 witness to questions that -- that are just
1 argumentative. They are not structured
2 appropriately, and you're taking that and
3 you're implying something else for the jury
4 on the record, and quite frankly, I don't
appreciate that. So, yes, to answer your
27 (Pages 437 to 440)
U.S. Le al Su ort
441 443
question, it 100 percent is responsive. He
is invoking his Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth.
THE WITNESS: Bathroom break now?

MR. EDWARD$: That's fine.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the video record
12:35 pm.
(Pause in the proceedings.)
MR. EDWARDS: twill be asking you to
read back the lost question and answer, so
you're ready.
THE COURT REPORTER: Certainly.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
record 1:16 p.m.

MR. EDWARDS: Madam Court Reporter, if
you could read back the last question, as
well as the last answer which I have been •
told was responsive.
THE COURT REPORTER: Certainly.
(The record was mad.)
Q Mr. Epstein, why is it that you would
like to tell Scott Rothstein whether you have
sexually molested underage minors in the various
communities where you have homes?

MR. PIKE: Form. Mischaraaerizes the
1 that one, however, upon advice of counsel they've
2 instructed me that I must assert my rights under
3 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment, and if
4 I don't do so, I risk losing that representation.
5 Q What is special about the question of
6 you molesting children on a daily basis for the
7 better part of two decades, that you would
8 especially like to answer that question?
9 MR. PIKE: I'm sorry?
10 MR. EDWARDS: His answer was that he
11 would especially like to answer that
12 previous question and the question posed to
13 him was...
14 Q Isn't it true for the better part of two
15 decades you have molested children on an every
16 day basis. And Pro asking now, what is it about
27 that question that makes you especially want to
18 respond to that one?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A Though I would like to answer that
21 question as well as your other questions here
22 today. Mr. Edwards, upon advice of counsel,
23 they've told me I must assert my rights under the
24 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment, or risk
25 losing my representation.
witness's testimony.
2 A I would like to answer that question, as
3 well as all of your other questions, Mr. Edwards,
4 however today my counsel has advised me) must
5 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
6 Fourteenth Amendment.
7 Q Can you tell the jury what, if anything,
Scott Rothstein has to do with the allegations of
you molesting underage children?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I think the jury will find out
what Scott Rothstein has to do with all these
cases, I hope that's the case. I have been
instructed by my counsel to respond to all of
your questions, most of your questions here
today, but I have to assert my Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.

MR. EDWARDS: More to strike the portion
of nonresponsive related to Scott Rothstein.
Q Is it true for the better part of two
decades you have interacted sexually with
underage minors on a daily basis?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer every one of your
questions here today, Mr. Edwards, especially
1 Q Is it true that you have intentionally
2 preyed on vulnerable children as young as 12
3 years old on an every day basis, for sexual
4 purposes for the last decade?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A Though I would like to respond to that
7 question, as well as other questions posed by
8 you„ and I would prefer to respond to both you
9 and your partner, Scott Rothstein, who sits in
10 jail for fabricating questions of a sexual
11 nature, cases of a sexual nature against people
12 like me and others in South Florida. You were
13 part of a law firm that the U.S. Attorney refers
14 to as one of the largest criminal enterprises in
15 South Florida's history, so though I would like
16 to answer, and you will probably mark my question
17 as nonresponsive, my counsel has told me today I
18 must not answer that question and must assert my
19 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment right.
20 MR. EDWARDS: Move to strike the answer
21 as nonresponsive. All other portions
22 portion of the answer, all but the
23 invocation of the Fifth Amendment.
24 Q Please describe for the jury the plan or
25 scheme that you employed to access the underage
28 (Pages 441 to 444)
U.S. Legal Support
445 447
minor females of Palm Beach County, including
Jane Doe.

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer that question as
would like to have answered most of your other
questions here today, especially with respect to
Jane Doe, as she is your client, but on advice of
counsel they've instructed me that I must, must
assert my Sixth Amendment, Fifth Amendment and
Fourteenth Amendment right, so therefore that's
what I'm going to do.
Q Despite your preference you're going to
listen to your counsel.

MR. PIKE: Form, I'm going to Instruct
you not to answer that question.
MR. EDWARDS: As to whether or not he is
going to listen to counsel?

MR. PIKE: He's already invoked on
advice of counsel.
MR. EDWARDS: That last question was
taken right out of Bob Critton's play book.

MR. PIKE: Take it up with the Court.
Bob Critton is not here, I am.
Q Isn't it true as part of the plan to
access young girls between 12 and 17 years old In
A Though I would like to answer that
question, as well as all the other questions
you've posed here today, Mr. Edwards, upon advice
of counsel, they've instructed me i must assert
my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q With each and every underage minor
female that arrived at your house under the idea
they were to give you a massage, they were tint
led up and left alone in your bedroom with you;
is that correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Again? Repeat the question.
Q This is a scheme that you've employed
for years and years, and years, and somehow
you're having a hard time grasping how a scheme
that you devised worked?

MR. PIKE: No. Move to strike. You
don't have a question on the table.
Actually your previous question prior to
what you just stated did not involve any
word, quote, -seismic," end quote. If you
want to repeat the question, go ahead.
Q Isn't this how it worked, that an
underage minor female would come to your house
Palm Beach County, that you would send a message
2 that you would be willing to pay those females
3 for them providing you a massage at your house?

MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A You have to repeat the question.
6 Q Sure. The initiation, the manner in
7 which you gained access to underage girls between
8 the ages of 12 and 17 in Palm Beach, is that you
9 would initially have somebody tell them that they
10 could tome to your house and give you a massage
11 and you would pay them for their time.
12 MR. PIKE: Form.
13 THE WITNESS: It is not a question.
14 A You didn't ask me a question. You made
15 a statement.
16 THE WITNESS: Ifyou want to repeat it
17 back.
18 (Indicating the court reporter.)
19 Q I'll make it clearer for you.
20 A Thank you.
21 Q Did you send a message to various
22 underage minor females, that you would pay for
23 those underage minor females to provide you a
24 massage at your house?
25 MR. PIKE: NMI.
1 and you instructed or did you instruct
2 or one of your other assistants to lead
3 that minor female up to your bedroom to be left
4 alone with you?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A Though i would like to answer that
7 question as well as all the other questions
8 you've posed here today, Mr. Edwards, upon advice
9 of my counsel they've instructed me I must assert
my rights under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Once that underage minor female,
normally between the ages.of 12 and 17 would
arrive in your bedroom, you would then appear
naked or wearing only a towel each time; is that
correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer each one of your
questions, Mr. Edwards. However, today my
counsel has advised me that I must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment,
Q After appearing naked or wearing only a
towel, then wouldn't you instruct the underage
minor female to get naked herself?
29 (Pages 445 to 448)
U.S. Legal Support
449 451
2L
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A Though I would like to answer all of
3 your questions here today, I'm going to have to
4 respond to that question as I've responded to
5 most of your others here today, which is by my
6 counsel's instructing me that I must assert my
7 rights under the Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth
8 Amendment.
9 Q Then, once the underage minor female was
10 naked, you would attempt various lewd or
11 lascivious improper sexual acts against that
12 underage minor female, correct?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A Though I would like to respond to all of
75 your questions, Mr. Edwards, I have to respond to
16 that as I responded to all of the other questions
17 here today that you've posed, which is that my
18 counsel, at kast today, has instructed me I must
19 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
20 Fourteenth Amendment.
21 Q And you would always pay cash money to
22 the underage minor female after you improperly
23 and/or illegally sexually abused that underage
24 minor female, correct?
25 MR. PIKE: Form.
F22
I 425
1 rights under the Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth
2 Amendment or, in fact, potentially lose my right
3 to representation.
4 Q What you're saying with that answer is
5 that your counsel will not represent you anymore
if you choose to waive your Fifth Amendment
rights and begin to answer these questions?

MR. PIKE: No, not at all, On the
advice of counsel, if you know what the
Sixth Amendment is and how it reads, you
would understand what the invocation is, in
full. So move to strike your —

MR. EDWARDS: Question?
MR. PIKE: -- last question, and it
mischaracterkes the witness's testimony.
Do you know what the Sixth Amendment is, Mr.
Edwards?

MR. EDWARDS: Yes, and it is not my
deposition and I'm not sure your client
knows about the effective assistance of
counsel or any amendment --

MR. PIKE: Do you know how due process
clause affects the 6th Amendment?
Never mind, just go ahead. I'm sorry.

MR. EDWARDS: However, the statement was
A Though I would like to answer each and
2 every one of your questions here today, Mr.
3 Edwards, my counsel has advised me I must assert
my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
5 Amendment.
6 Q Each of these sessions or sexual
7 interactions between you and underage minor
8 females ended, when you had ejaculated, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer that question, as
I would like to answer all of your other
questions here today. However, today at least.
my counsel has instructed me that I must assert
my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q After paying the underage minor female
for being sexually molested, you would ask the
underage minor female to leave her telephone
number with one of your assistants; is that
correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer that question. I
would like to answer most of your other questions
here today; however, at least today my counsel
has advised me that I may not, and must assert my
1 made if he answers the questions, as he
2 would prefer to do, which seems remarkable
3 and incredible, then he would be fired or
4 you would be fired from him, and I want to
5 understand what it...
Q Why is it that your attorneys will no
longer represent you if you choose to do what you
want to do, which is answer these questions?

MR. PIKE: Move to strike.
Do you want to ask a question? Because
I'm not quite sure he even testified to
that. We have been through several
depositions and you are implying something
from the invocation of the Fifth, Sixth and
Fourteenth that does not exist. There has
been no mention of firing, there's been no
mention of withdrawing, there's been no
mention of anything of the sort.

MR. EDWARDS: Can we go back to the
question and response that ended with
risk losing my..."
THE COURT REPORTER: Certainly.

MR. PIKE: Once again, do you know that
the Sixth Amendment is?
MR. EDWARDS: Yes.
30 (Pages 449 to 452)
MSS
453 455

MR. PIKE: Would you like to Google it?
Because that Sixth Amendment --
MR. EDWARDS: She will have a hard time
going back, if you continue talking. She
has to type while you talk.

MR. PIKE: The Sixth Amendment, as
incorporated into the due process clause,
which is the Fourteenth Amendment is the
right to effective assistance of counsel.

MR. EDWARDS: I understand.
MR. PIKE: If you read it in full, it
will kind of shed light and you can probably
glean the invocation and the meaning of it
from his response.
Is there a question?

MR. EDWARDS: Go back, please.
(The record was read.)
Q So your counsel told you that you must
invoke your Fifth Amendment right to remain
silent, otherwise you will lose your right to
their representation; is that what you're
saying?

MR. PIKE: Move to strike.
Mischaracterizes the witness's testimony,
and invocation... misconstrues and
1 A Though I would like to answer that
2 question as well as all the other questions
3 you've posed here today, Mr. Edwards, I'm afraid
4 that upon advice of counsel they've instructed me
5 that I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
6 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
7 Q And a separate offer was made to each
8 underage minor female as well. That is, if she
9 brings you other underage minor females so that
10 you can sexually abuse, then you would pay a
11 finder's fee for each underage minor female
12 brought to you; is that correct?
13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 A I would like to answer every one of the
15 questions you've posed here today, Mr. Edwards.
16 However, today at least, upon advice of counsel,
17 they have instructed me I must assert my rights
18 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
19 was a female that brought
20 you multiple underage minor females; is that
21 correct?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A Though I would like to answer every one
24 of your questions that you've posed here today,
25 my counsel has instructed me I must assert my
misinterprets the Fifth, Sixth and
Fourteenth Amendments.
I'm going to instruct you not to answer
that question, because I don't understand

it. It was not your response, and
because --
MR. EDWARDS: I wrote down the response.
MR. PIKE: -- and because, ill
understand, your question, you phrased it
as, "So if I understand you, your attorney
told you," so I'm going to instruct you not
to answer that question because it will,
apparently, it would disclose my
communications with you, so there you go.

MR. EDWARDS: In his answer he said, "My
counsel said I can't respond," so he is
telling me already what --

MR. PIKE: That's not what he said. He
said "On the advice of counsel."
MR. EDWARDS: All right.
Q The offer was then made to each underage
minor female that each time she returned to you■
home and you sexually molest her, she will then
be paid cash; is that correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q -was an underage minor female that
you first abused when she was 13 years old; Is
that correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every
question you have regarding L.M. here today, my
counsel has instructed me that I must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q While -was a minor, she brought you
more than 50 underage minor females that you
sexually abuse, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer all the questions
you have regarding L.M., here today. However, at
least today my counsel has instructed me I may
not. I must assert my right under my Sixth,
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q One of the underage minor females
brought to you b3=was Jane Doe, when .lane
Doe was age 14; is that correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer the questions
31 ( Pages 453 to 456)
U.S. Legal Support
457 459
regarding Jane Doe andn Mr. Edwards.
However, at least today my counsel has instructed
me I must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth
and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Looking at the operative complaint in
Jane Doe versus Jeffrey Epstein ease 80893,
referring to the plaintiff Jane Doe, first
indicates this is an action for damages in an
amount in excess of 50 million dollars.
Is that a number that you would agree
would fairly compensate her, as well as punish
you for the conduct you committed against Jane
Doe?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer that question.
would like to answer all of your other questions
that you've posed here today, Mr. Edwards.
However, at least today, on advice of counsel
they've instructed me that I may not and have
instructed me that I must assert my rights under
the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q One of the allegations Jane Doe makes is
that Jeffrey Epstein demonstrated sexual
preference and obsession for minor girls. Is it
true that you have a sexual preference and
1 MR. EDWARDS: No, I'm asking if your
2 client agrees with the assertion that's
3 stated in the complaint, or if he has a
4 defense that is going to defeat such
5 assertion or evidence that is going to
6 defeat such assertion. So I'm simply asking
7 your client...
8 Q Is that a true statement?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A I would like to answer all of your
11 questions about Jane Doe and your other clients.
12 However, today my counsel has told me that I may
13 not. I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
14 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
15 Q You did personally call Jane Doe on the
16 telephone on at least one occasion; isn't that
17 true?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A I would like to answer your questions
20 regarding calling Jane Doc, or contacting Jane
21 Doe. However, my counsel has instructed me that
22 today, at least, I may not. I must assert my
23 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
24 Amendment.
25 Q And of the time when you contacted Jane
1 obsession for minor girls?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A I would like to answer the question with
4 respect to what Jane Doe said, however, my
5 counsel today has instructed me that I must
6 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
7 Fourteenth Amendment
8 Q Another allegation is that defendant
9 Epstein's planned scheme and enterprise included
10 an elaborate system wherein the then minor
11 plaintiff and other minor iris were contacted by
12 telephone by Epstein or other
13 unknown employees or assistants working for
14 Epstein, and were then persuaded to come over to
15 Epstein's house for the purposes of engaging in
16 prostitution.
17 Is that a true statement?
18 MR. PIKE: First, I'm going to object to
19 the form and second, I believe you're
20 working from a portion of a complaint
21 especially with your reference to scheme and
22 the RICO allegations that were dismissed
23 with prejudice. So, I just want to be
24 clear, are you doing discovery on a count
25 that no longer exists?
1 Doe, was the purpose to have ber come to your
2 house and interact with you sexually?
3 MR. PIKE. Form.
4 A Con you repeat the question?
5 Q Yes, the time that you called Jane Doe,
6 was the purpose of your call to have her come to
7 your house and interact with you sexually?
8 MR. PIKE Form.
9 A I would like to answer that question as
10 1 would like to answer all of your other
11. questions with respect to Jane Doe, your client.
12 However, today at least, my counsel has
13 instructed me I must assert my rights under the
14 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
15 MR. EDWARDS: Move to strike a portion
16 of the answer that's nonresponsive.
17 was one of your assistants
18 back in the years 2003, 2004 and 2005, correct?
19 A I would like to answer each one of your
20 questions, Mr. Edwards, here today; however, on
21 advice of counsel, at least today Pm going to
22 have to assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth
23 and Fourteenth Amendment.
24 called by telephone Jane
25 Doe when Jane Doe was a minor child, on more than
32 (Pages 457 to 460)
U.S. Legal Support
461 463
1 15 occasions; isn't that true? 1 of your private airplane to Palm Beach for the
2 MR. PIKE: Form. 2 specific purpose of luring minor girls to your
3 A Mr. Edwards, I would like to answer 3 mansion for the purposes of sexually abusing
4 every one of your questions regarding Jane Doe 4 them?
S that you've posed here today. However, at least 5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 today, on advice of counsel I'm going to have to 6 A I would like to answer that question,
7 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and 7 Mr. Edwards„ but today at least, on advice of
8 Fourteenth Amendment. 8 counsel, they've instructed me to assert my
9 Q The purpose or contacting 9 Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment rights.
10 the minor child Jane Doe back in 2003,2004 and 10 Q Isn't it true that you conspired with
11 2005, was always to get her to come to your house 11 others to contact minor females including Jane
12 to interact with you sexually; is that correct? 12 Doe, for the purposes of sexually abusing Jane
13 MR. PIKE: Poem. 13 Doe?
14 A I would like to answer that question as 14 MR. PIKE: Form.
15 well as all your other questions you've posed 15 A I would like to answer that question,
16 here today regarding your client, Jane Doe. 16 Mr. Edwards, as well as every other question
17 However, at least today, my counsel has advised 17 you've posed here today. However, at least today
18 me I must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth 18 upon advice of counsel they've instructed me to
19 and Fourteenth Amendment. 19 assert my Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
20 Q Did you or or any of your 20 right
21 other assistants contact Jane Doe for some other 21 Q Isn't It true that your sexual
22 purpose than to have her come to your house for 22 interaction with Jane Doe occurred specifically
23 you to sexually molest her? 23 during the time period. February 2003 through
24 MR. PIKE: Form. 24 June 2005?
25 A Though I would like to answer every • 25 MR. PIKE: Form.
462 4&1
question that you've posed here today regarding 1 A I'm going to have to respond to that,
2 Jane Doe, Mr. Edwards, my counsel has advised me, 2 Mr. Edwards, as I've responded to all your other
3 3 questions, which is that today at least on advice at least today, that I may not and must assert my
4 rights under the Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth 4 of counsel I must assert my rights under the
S Amendment. 5 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
6 Q Each call that was made by you or on 6 Q During the time Jane Doe was under the
7 your behalf to Jane Doe, was made at a time when 7 age of 16, isn't it true that you digitally
8 Jane Doe was a minor child, true? 8 penetrated her vagina?
9 MR. PIKE: Form. 9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A I would like to answer that question as 10 A I would like to answer that question, as
11 well as all your other questions with regard to 11 well as your other questions. However, at least
12 Jane Doe, Mr. Edwards. However, today my counsel 2 today my counsel has advised me I must assert my
13 has advised me I may not and must assert my 13 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
14 rights under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth 14 Amendment.
15 Amendment. 15 Q Immediately following that question, you
16 () In addition to your Palm Beach home, 6 clearly smiled and rolled your eyes. Is there
17 isn't it true that you own a, what has been 7 anything that we should read or the jury should
18 called a mansion in New York, a ranch in New 18 read into that body language?
19 Mexico, a home in France, as well as an island in 19 MR. PIKE: I'm going to instruct you not
20 the Virgin Islands? 0 to answer the question.
21 MR. PIKE: Font. 1 I move to strike it as harassing.
22 A I'm sorry, but today at least, on advice 2 MR. EDWARDS: Move to strike what as
23 of counsel I have to assert my rights to the 3 harassing? It is something that everybody
24 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment. 4 is going to be able to see and I want to
25 Q Isn't It true that you traveled by way 5 know what it means, if anything.
33 (Pages 461 to 464)
U.S. Legal Support
21.
. 23

MR. PIKE: I'm instructing him not to
answer.
MR. EDWARDS: How are you instructing
not to answer a question?

MR. PIKE: Because I am.
MR. EDWARDS: Based on what?
MR. PIKE: Because it is harassing.
MR. EDWARDS: I'm not harassing. I want
to know why he did what he did.

MR. PIKE: You are harassing him. I
mean, it is an argumentative question --
MR. EDWARDS: He harassed my clients.

MR. PIKE: — he has been here since
10:00 o'clock. He's given several
depositions. This is Volume III of a
continuation, okay? He's sitting here
waiting for your questions but not waiting
to be harassed.
Q There is a way to prevent those
questions, and that's not do that type of rolling
your eyes.

MR. PIKE: You're not going to instruct
the witness on how to the witness is here
behaving professionally --

MR. EDWARDS: In your mind.
1 going to let it happen, not on my watch, not
2 today. You can take it up with the Court.
3 MR. EDWARDS: I will.
4 MR. PIKE: Mali( the record. If you
5 will.
6 MR. EDWARDS: It is marked. I'm just
7 wondering whether there is going to be a
privilege asserted or it is just going to be
a blanket, I'm telling the witness not to
answer," related to something that the jury
is going to view and should be entitled to
know what it means.

MR. PIKE: (Counsel shrugs.)
MR. EDWARDS: You just don't like that
your client is giving those body language
responses.

MR. PIKE: No. Move to strike. It has
nothing do with that. It has to do with a
significant fact, that on a legal basis
you're attempting to badger and harass the
witness, based upon what you believe are
some sort of facial expressions and you're
attempting to get an adverse inference from
an answer. I'm not going to let him answer
a harassing question, so you can then get an
a

MR. PIKE: — Answering your questions,
invoking his Constitutional rights under the
United States Constitution. And I'm sorry
that that doesn't make you happy, but I'm
not here —

MR. EDWARDS: It doesn't make him happy
either, apparently.
MR. PIKE: - I'm not here to dispute
and debate with you what privileges are
being invoked and whether you feel it is
right or wrong. If you have a question, ask
the witness a question.
Q Why did you roll your eyes when I asked
you If you digitally penetrated Jane Doe when she
was 14 and 15 years old?

MR. PIKE: I'm instructing you not to
answer that question.
MR. EDWARDS: Your reason for the
instruction is based on some privilege?

MR. PIKE: My reason for the instruction
is that you are attempting to play fast and
loose with the Fifth Amendment and adverse
inference.

MR. EDWARDS: I'm not.
MR_ PIKE: Yes, you are, and I'm not
1 adverse inference relative to some gesture.
2 MR. EDWARDS: We will take it up, fine.
3 MR. PIKE: Take it up.
4 Q Mr. Epstein, Isn't it also true that you
5 used a vibrator or vibrating device on Jane Doe's
6 vagina when she was under the age of 16?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A I would like to answer all of your
9 questions, Mr. Edwards. However, today on advice
10 of counsel, theyve advised me that I may not and
11 must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
12 Fourteenth Amendment.
13 Q Isn't it also true when Jane Doe was a
14 minor child, that you masturbated on multiple
15 occasions in her presence?
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A I would like to answer all of your
18 questions regarding Jane Doe. However, today my
19 counsel has advised me that I may not, and have
0 instructed me to assort my rights under the
1 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
2 Q In June of 2008, isn't it true, sir,
23 that you entered pleas of guilty to various
24 felony -- to two felony charges in Palm Reach
25 County?
34 (Pages 465 to 468)

U. S . Le Sie. Support
469 471
3. MR. PIKE: Asked and answered within
2 this deposition.
3 A Yes.
4 Q And as a result of those guilty pleas
5 you were sentenced to 18 months incarceration in
6 Palm Beach County jail; Is that correct?
7 MR. PIKE: Asked and answered.
8 A Yes.
Q In addition to the sentence related to
those felony charges, isn't It also true that you
entered into an agreement known as the
"Nonprosecution Agreement," with the federal
government?

MR. PIKE: I'm sorry, would you read
that back, Madam Court Reporter?
(The record was read.)
MR. PIKE: Can you reword the question?

MR. EDWARDS: Sure.
Q Did you enter into an agreement with the
federal government that is entitled
"Nonprosecution Agreement"?
A Yes.
Q And that Nonprosecution Agreement at
paragraph 7 Indicates that "The United States
shall provide Epstein's attorneys with a list of
S
S
liability"?
Are you familiar with that section of
the agreement?

MR. PIKE: Form, and the document speaks
for itself.
A The document speaks for itself.
Q Are you familiar with that portion of
the document?
A I'm not sure what you mean by "familiar
with," sir.
Q Have you read it?
A Yes.
Q So, if Jane Doe were to bring a claim
exclusively under 18 USC 2255, then you already
contractually agreed to waive your right to
contest liability to that claim; is that true?
MR.. PIKE: Form, and calls for a legal
conclusion.
A Upon advice of counsel, though I would
like to answer all of your questions here today,
they've Instructed me I must assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
THE WITNESS: Five minutes?

MR. EDWARDS: Whatever you need.
THE WITNESS: Okay.
1 individuals whom it has identified as victims, as
2 defined in 18 USC 2255, after Epstein has signed
3 this agreement, and been sentenced." Have you
4 seen the names of the identified victims that
5 were supplied by the U.S. Attorney's office?
6 A I would like to answer that question as
7 I would like to answer most of your other
8 questions here today, Mr. Edwards. However, upon
9 advice of counsel they've instructed me that I
10 must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
11 Fourteenth Amendment.
12 Q And isn't it true that Jane Doe was on
13 that list of victims that was supplied to you by
14 the United States?
15 A I would like to answer that question.
16 However, at least today my attorneys have advised
17 me that I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
18 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
19 Q In paragraph eight of the Nonprosecution
20 Agreement between you, Mr. Epstein, and the
21 United States Attorney's Office, it Indicates,
22 "If any of the individuals, referred to In
23 paragraph 7," referring to the list of victims,
24 "elects to file a lawsuit pursuant to 18 USC
25 2255, Epstein waives his right to contest
ro 1
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the video
record 1.51 pm.
(Pause in the proceedings.)
TFIE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
record 1:57 p.m.
Q The specific federal statute that is
incorporated In the Nonprosecution Agreement, IS
USC 2255. states -- rather than do it that way,
let me just ask the question.

Mr. Epstein, did you knowingly conspire
with others to use a telephone to persuade,
induce or entice minor females, including Jane
Doe, to engage in prostitution?

MR. PIKE: Foam
A Though I would like to answer that
question, as most of your other questions, I have
to respond by telling you that my attorneys have
told me, at least today, that I must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Mr. Epstein, did you knowingly and
willfully conspire with others to travel
interstate for the purpose of engaging in illicit
sexual conduct with minors, including Jane Doe?
MR. PIKE: Form.
35 (Pages 469 to 472)
U.S. Legal Support
473 475
1 A Though I would like to answer that 1 exclusively under 18 USC 2255, that you waived
2 question, as well as most of your other questions 2 your right to contest liability?
3 3 MR. PIKE Form. Also, could call for here today, Mr. Edwards, in fact, all of the
4 other questions here today, my counsel has 4 the disclosure of attorney/client
5 instructed me at least today, I must assert my 5 communications and work product, and is
rights under the Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth 6 protected under the Federal Rule of Evidence
7 Amendment. 7 502408, as well as 410?
8 Q Mr. Epstein, did you use a tekphone to 8 A Though I would like to answer that
9 knowingly persuade, induce or entice minor 9 question, Mr. Edwards, I have to invoke my rights
10 females, including Jane Doe, to engage In 10 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
11 prostitution? 11 Q In a recent motion for summary judgment
12 MR. PIKE: Form. 12 filed on your behalf, a statement is made,
13 A Though I would like to answer that 13 "Epstein never using a facility or means of
14 question, as well as your other questions today, 14 interstate commerce, knowingly persuaded, induced
15 Mr. Edwards, at least today, my counsel has 15 or enticed Jane Doe when she was under the age of
16 instructed me that I must assert my rights under 16 18 years, to engage in prostitution or sexual
17 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment. 17 activity for whkh any person can be charged with
18 Q Mr. Epstein, did you travel, interstate 18 a criminal offense or attempted to do so." That
19 commerce for the purpose of engaging in illicit 19 is a false statement, true?
20 sexual conduct with minor females, including Jane 20 MR. PIKE: Form.
21 Doe? 21 A Though I would like to answer that
22 MR. PIKE: Form. 22 question, on advice of counsel I have been
23 A Though I would like to answer that 23 instructed to assert my rights under the Sixth,
24 question, as well as the other questions you've 24 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
25 posed hoe today, Mr. Edwards, fen afraid that my 25 Q The statement was also made on your
474 476
1 counsel has instructed me that I must assert my 1 behalf, "Epstein never attempted to or conspired
2 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth 2 to knowingly transport Jane Doe in interstate or
3 Amendment. 3 foreign commerce or In any Commonwealth territory
1 Q Isn't It true that you agreed with the 4 or possession of the United Stales, with Intent
5 federal government that if Jane Doe brought S that Jane Doe engage in prostitution or in any
5 claims exclusively alleging those sections of I8 6 sexual activity for which any person can be
7 USC 2255 that I've read in the preceding, four 7 charged with a criminal offense."
a paragraphs, that you would admit liability unto 8 That is also a false statement; isn't
9 her as an identified victim? 9 that right?
10 MR. PIKE: Form. 10 MR. PIKE: Fonn.
11 A I don't believe that's what the document 11 A You said "lime Doc."
12 says. 12 Q Jane Doe is Jane Doe in this case.
13 Q The document says, "If any of the 13 MR. PIKE: Form.
14 Individuals referred to In paragraph 7 elects to 19 A I believe her deposition speaks to
15 file suit pursuant to IS USC 2255, Epstein waives 15 that. With respect to anything else, I have to
16 his right to contest liability, and also waives 16 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
17 his right to contest damages up to an amount as 17 Fourteenth Amendment.
18 agreed to between the identified individual and 18 Q You believe that Jane Doe's deposition
19 Epstein, so long as the identified individual 19 speaks to whether you attempted or conspired to
20 elects to proceed exclusively under 18 USC 20 knowingly transfer Jane Doe in interstate
21 2255." 21 commerce, correct?
22 That's the provision. I'll ask you then 22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 the question: Didn't you agree with the federal 23 Q You believe her deposition speaks to
24 government that if Jane Doe, an identified 24 that?
25 victim, proceeds in a case against you, 25 A That's my belief, yes.
36 (Pages 473 to 476)
U.
477 479
Q And then would you adopt her deposition
2 testimony as true and as your support for that
3 assertion?
4 MR. PIKE: Form.
5 A You're asking her entire deposition
6 testimony?
7 Q The deposition as it relates to whether
8 or not you knowingly transported her in
interstate commerce.
A Well, I would like to answer that
question, but on advice of counsel, at least
today, I have been instructed to assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q A statement that Epstein never attempted
to or conspired to travel in interstate commerce
or travel into the United States or travel in
foreign commerce for the purpose of engaging In
illicit sexual conduct with Jane Doe," is also a
false statement, isn't it?

MR. PIKE: Form?
A I would like to answer that question ns
well as your other questions, Mr. Edwards.
However, today my counsel has instructed me that
I must assert my Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth
Amendment right.
Q The statement that Epstein never
2 attempted to or conspired to travel in foreign
3 commerce and engage in any illicit sexual conduct
4 with Jane Doe, is also a fake statement; isn't
that right?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to that question as well as
9 the other questions posed today, Mr. Edwards.
9 However, on the advice of counsel they've
10 instructed me to assert my Sixth. Fifth and

11. Fourteenth Amendment right.
12 Q In fact, you did contact Jane Doe when
13 she was a minor child as well as conspired to use
14 a telephone to contact Jane Doe when she was a
15 minor child, specifically for the purposes of
16 engaging in illicit sexual conduct with Jane Doe,
17 true?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A Though I would like to answer that
20 question as well as your other questions posed
21 here today, Mr. Edwards, l have been instructed
22 by my counsel that I must assert my rights under
23 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
24 Q Did you intentionally touch Jane Doe on
25 her person and against her will or without her
1 legal consent?
2 MR. PIKE: One second... Form.
3 A Without her legal consent?
4 Q Yes.
5 A Can you tell me what that means?
6 Q In order to answer that question, I need
7 to explain to you what legal consent means?
8 A Yes, sir.
Q Let's start with this question —
A Can you explain it to me?
Q Do you believe that a 14-year old child
can legally consent to sexual interaction with a
man like you that was over the age of 50?

MR. PIKE: Form.
THE WITNESS: Asking for a legal...
MR. PIKE: Go ahead and invoke?
A I would like to answer that question, if
I understood it correctly. However, my attorneys
have advised me today at least to invoke my
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment right.

MR. PIKE: And I think you skipped over
a question because you went from the first
question, and the witness was —

MR. EDWARDS: Asking for a definition?
MR. PIKE: Asking for a definition, so
1 he could properly interpret your question
2 and attempt to answer it.
3 Q I'm understanding that, based on your
4 answer, that my question, "Did you intentionally.
5 touch Jane Doe without her legal consent?" And
6 your response, depends on the definition of
7 "legal consent:" Is that true?
8 MR. PIKE: I think that the witness --
as people regularly do as deponents, ask for
clarification of a question, and Mr. Epstein
asked you to clarify what, legal consent'
was. If you wish to do that, then I guess
he could potentially understand your
question. However, if you don't want to do
that, then I guess we can just move on.
Q This will provide the answer: How old
was Jane Doe when you touched her?

MR. PIKE: Form. Assumes facts not in
evidence.
A I — I -- I don't know how to answer
that question. I'll have to assert my Fifth
Amendment, Sixth Amendment and Fourteenth
Amendment right.
Q Tell me why you're having trouble
answering the question and I'll clarify the
37 (Pages 477 to 480)
U.S. Legal Support
481 483
1 question for you so it will be easier for you to
2 answer.
3 MR. PIKE: You've answered the
4 question.
S MR. EDWARDS: His response was he
6 doesn't know how to answer the question. I
7 want to help him. I want to make sure that
8 the jury understands the question and the
answer.

MR. PIKE: He invoked the Fifth, Sixth
and Fourteenth.
Q Mr. Epstein, did you touch Jane Doe in
intimate areas of her body when she was a minor
child?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer that question,
all your questions with respect to Jane Doe, Mr.
Edwards. However, today at least, my counsel has
advised me that I must assert my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q In fact, didn't you touch Jane Doe in
intimate areas of her body, including her vagina,
her breasts, and her buttocks on dozens of
occasions between February 2003 and June 2005?

MR. PIKE: Form.
1 However, at least today, my counsel has
2 . instructed melmust assert my rights under the
3 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
4 Q Do you see yourself, Mr. Epstein, as a
5 danger to the middle school and high school
6 children in the Palm Beach community?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
B A Though I would like to answer that
question, as well as the other questions that
you've posed here today, Mr. Edwards, my counsel
has instructed me I must respond by asserting my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q When you engaged in illegal sexual
conduct with Jane Doe, was it your intent to
cause her severe emotional distress?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer every
question with respect to Jane Doe, Mr. Edwards„
at least today my counsel has advised me that I
MUM assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
(..? When you engaged in sexual conduct with
Jane Doe when she was a minor child, age 14, 15,
16 and 17, would you agree that you showed
1 A Though I would like to answer every
2 question about Jane Doe that you've posed here
3 today, Mr. Edwards, upon advice of counsel, at
4 least today, they've instructed me I must assert
5 my rights under the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth
6 Amendment
7 Q Do you agree that the inappropriate
8 sexual conduct, that your inappropriate sexual
9 conduct towards Jane Doe, was both extreme and
outrageous?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer all of your
questions with respect to Jane Doe that you've
posed here today, Mr. Edwards. However, upon
advice of counsel, they've instructed me that I
must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment
Q Do you also agree that your sexual
interaction with Jane Doe when she was a minor
child was outrageous and so extreme in degree
that it should not be tolerated In a civilized
community?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to respond to all your
questions with respect to your client, Jane Doe.
1 reckless disregard with the high probability of
2 causing severe emotional distress to Jane Doe?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A Though I would like to answer all your
5 questions that you've posed here today regarding
6 Jane Doe, on advice of counsel, at least today,
they've instructed me I must assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Mr. Epstein, did you coerce Jane Doe
into prostitution?
A ... Again?
Q Did you coerce Jane Doe into
prostitution?
A Can you tell me what you mean by
"coerce," please?
Q Tell me, how did you --
A I've asked you a simple question. Can
you tell me what "coerce" means, please?
Q The definition or the word "coerce" will
allow to you answer that question?
A I'm trying to understand the question.
MR. PIKE: You're using.. for the
record, you're using legal terms.
-Consent," 'coerce." Those are the terms
you're utilizing in your question. Mr.
38 (Pages 481 to 484)
U.S. Le al Su ort
485 487
1 Epstein is simply asking you what those 1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 terms mean in order to facilitate a response 2 A I would like to answer every one of your
3 or a response coupled with the invocations. 3 questions with respect to Jane Doc, Mr. Edwards.
4 He doesn't — he is not a lawyer. He 4 However, today, my counsel has instructed me that
5 doesn't understand these legal terms, and he S I must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth
6 is asking you for clarification. If you 6 and Fourteenth Amendment.
7 want to take those legal terms out of your 7 Q If you answer that question for me, then
8 questions and simplify them, then go ahead 8 I can tell you whether that falls under the
9 and do that, but it is fair that he ask what 9 definition of coercing her into prostitution.
10 certain words mean. 10 A Is that a question?
11 MR. EDWARDS: I absolutely agree and 11 Q Sure. Can you provide an answer to the
12 want to make sure before I give him the 12 previous question, so I can categorize that as
13 definition, that this question is being 13 coercion or noncoercion?
14 asked because the definition will help him 14 MR. PIKE: No, he cannot, because I
15 to accurately answer the question, assuming 15 don't know what question is on the table,
16 that would be the only reason he would ask 16 and it is as simple as that. I don't know
17 me a question. 17 what question is on the table.
18 MR. PIKE: As his lawyer, I think that 18 MR. EDWARDS: Sure.
19 the definition of the word would assist him 19 Q Didn't you interact with Jane Doe in a
20 in understanding the question a little bit 0 sexual manner when she was under the age of 18?
21 better, because, as you know, "coerce" and 1 MR. PIKE: Object to the form. This
22 "consent" have several meanings, whether or 2 question has been asked no less than twice
23 not it be in State court, under the Florida 3 during your deposition —
24 State statutes or under federal statutes 4 MR. EDWARDS: I'll agree with that.
25 under 2255. I think that any sort of 5 MR. PIKE: -- relative to lane Doe and
486 488
1 response could, you know... tiptoe into the 1 I'll object to the form.
2 Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth, and I think Mr. 2 A I would like to answer all of your
3 Epstein is attempting to... understand your 3 questions, Mr. Edwards, especially that
4 questions. 4 question. However, today, my counsel has advised
5 MR. EDWARDS: I appreciate that. I feel 5 me that I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
6 like we're getting closer to an answer than 6 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
7 we have received during this entire 7 Q Did you persuade, induce or entke Jane
8 litigation, so Fm certainly going to help 8 Doe to engage in prostitution when she was an
9 him out here. 9 underage minor child?
10 Q Mr. Epstein, do you then at least agree 10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 that you paid Jane Doe money in exchange for 11 A I would like to answer that question but
12 sexual services when she was under the age of 12 my counsel has advised me I must respond by
13 18? 13 invoking my Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
14 MR. PIKE: Form, mischaniezenzes the 14 right
15 witness's testimony, and move to strike. 15 Q Can you tell the jury how it is that
16 A Unfortunately I have to answer that 16 Jane Doe engaged in an act of prostitution with
17 question as I've answered most of your other 17 you?
18 questions here today, Mr. Edwards, which is that 18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 my attorneys, at least today, have advised me 19 A On advice of counsel. I'm going to have
20 that I must assert my rights under the Sixth, 20 to invoke my Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
21 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment. 21 Amendment right
22 Q Mr. Epstein, how did you, meaning what 22 Q While you were interacting with Jane Doe
23 process did you go through, to get Jane Doe to 23 in a sexual manner when she was 14 and IS years
24 exchange your money for her sexual services when 24 old, did you consider that molestation?
25 she was under the age of 18? 25 MR. PIKE: RCM
39 (Pages 485 to 4881
U.S. L 1
489 491
1 A I would like to answer all of your
2 questions, Mr. Edwards, with respect to Jane Doe
3 and her complaint. However, at least today my
4 counsel has advised me that I must assert my
5 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
6 Amendment.
7 Q While, at the same time you were
8 molesting Jane Doe, didn't you tell her that you
liked the way her young body looked?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to respond to all your
questions regarding Jane Doe, is the point, Mr.
Edwards. However today at least my counsel has
advised me I must assert my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Counsel.
(Indicating five minutes left on tape.)
MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
Q Mr. Epstein do you know George Rush?
MR. PIKE: Form — I'll withdraw the
form. Pm sorry. It is not a proper form
objection.
A I'm sorry, on advice of counsel I have
to assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
1 MR. PIKE: One second... Form.
2 A On advice of counsel, I'm going to have
3 to respectfully assert my Sixth, Fifth and
4 Fourteenth Amendment right.
5 Q During that conversation that you had
6 with George Rush from The New York Daily News,
7 didn't you express to him that you felt you were
8 punished criminally for no reason?
9 MR. PIKE: Form.
10 A Though I would like to answer all of
11 your questions, Mr. Edwards, my counsel has
12 advised me I must assert my rights under the
13 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
14 Q Didn't you also telt George Rush that a
15 more appropriate punishment for your actions with
16 these underage minor children would have been a
17 100 or 5200 fine?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A On advice of counsel I have to assert my
20 rights under the Sixth, Filth and Fourteenth
21 Amendment.
2 Q Tell the jury what you feel would be an
3 appropriate penalty for you, for the acts that
24 you committed against Jane Doe.
25 MR. PIKE Form.
Q Did you talk to George Rush in the year
2 2009 about the allegations of improper sexual
3 conduct between you and underage minor children?
4 MR. PIKE: Can you repeat the question,
5 for me, Madam Court Reporter/
6 MR. EDWARDS: Ian ask it again.
7 MR. PIKE: Sure-
8 Q Did you speak with George Rush in 2009
9 specifically about allegations of your
10 Interaction with underage minor children in a
11 sexual manner?
12 A On advice of counsel. I'm going to have
13 to assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
14 Fourteenth Amendment.
15 Q Did you know that the conversation
16 between you and New York Daily News reporter
17 George Rush was recorded?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A On advice of counsel, I'm going to have
20 to assert my right under the Sixth. Fifth and
21 Fourteenth Amendment
22 Q At the time when you spoke with George
23 Rush from The New York Daily News in 2009, did he
24 tell you that he was recording your statements to
25 him?
1 A Though I would like to very much answer
2 that question, on advice of my counsel today, Mr.
3 Edwards, I have to Invoke my Sixth, Fifth and
4 Fourteenth Amendment right.
5 Q In your Affirmative Defenses in the
6 complaint of Jane Doe versus Jeffrey Epstein,
7 which b Jane Doe, affirmative defense number one
8 indicates that Jane Doe consented to and was a
willing participant in the acts alleged.
What evidence did you have that Jane Doe
consented to or was a willing participant in the
acts that were alleged by Jane Doe against you?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to describe the
evidence that Jane Doc was a willing participant,
on advice of counsel today, they've instructed me
I must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth
and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q At that point in time you're at least
admitting that there was an interaction between
you and Jane Doe, correct?

MR. PIKE Form. Move to strike.
A On advice of counsel, Pm going to have
to assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
40 (Pages 489 to 492)
U.S. Legal Support
493 495
1 Q Two answers ago I believe that you just 1 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
2 told us that you would like to tell the jury 2 record 2:30 p.m.
3 about the evidence that exists, that shows that 3 CROSS EXAMINATION (CONTINUED)
4 Jane Doe consented to or was a willing 4 BY MR. EDWARDS:
5 participant in the acts alleged. So, is there 5 Q Mr. Epstein, are you ready?
6 any evidence that you're aware of in existence in 6 A Yes.
7 this world that shows that Jane Doe consented to 7 Q The second affirmative defense indicates
8 the acts she alleged against you? 8 or says that Jane Doe "actually consented to and
9 MR. PIKE: Fenn. Also calls for work 9 participated in conduct similar and/or idealise]
10 product information? 10 to the acts alleged with other persons, which
11 A Unfortunately today I have to respond by 11 were the sole or contributing cause of Jane Doe's
12. asserting my rights of Sixth, Fifth and 12 alleged damages."
13 Fourteenth Amendment. 13 What facts or information do you have to
14 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Counsel? 14 support that affirmative defense?
15 MR. EDWARDS: Okay. 15 MR. PIKE: Form, May also call for work
16 THE VIDEOGRA.PHER: Going off the video 16 product information.
17 record 2:34 p.m. 7 A Though I would like to answer all your
18 (Pause in the proceedings.) 18 questions, Mr. Edwards, at least today counsel
19 (The deposition of Jeffrey Epstein is 19 advised me I must assert my rights under the
20 continued in Volume IV.) 0 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
21 1 Q And when you say as an affirmative
22 2 defense Jane Doe consented to and participated in
23 3 conduct similar and/or identical to the acts
24 4 alleged, are you saying that at some other time
25 5 Jane Doe was sexually molested by somebody of
494 496
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 1 similar or identical age to yourself?
SDI:THE-RN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
2 2 MR. PIKE: Form.
CASE NO. 04-CV-80.393-CIV-MARRAIJOHNSON 3 A I would like to answer all of your
4 4 questions with respect to Jane Doe and her
JANE DOE. 5 complaints. However, at least today my counsel
5 6 has advised me I must assert my rights under the Derma.
6 7 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
vs 8 Q The second part of that affirmative
JEFFREY EPSTEIN. et al.. 9 defense indicates that that similar or identical
a 10 conduct that Jane Doe allegedly participated in,
Defendants 11 was the sole or contributing cause of Jane Does
/ 12 alleged damages.
to
Related Cases. 13 Are you acknowledging that that conduct
11 0&80119.08-80232,08-80380, 0s-80381, 14 is likely to cause damages to a minor child such
08-80994, 08-80811.08.80893.09.80469. 15 as Jane Doe? 12 094591.09-80656,09-80802.09-81092
13 VOLUME IV 16 MR, PIKE: Form.
14 CONTINUED VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF 17 A I would like to answer all of your
JEFFREY EPSTEIN TAKEN ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFF
1 5 18 questions with respect to Jane Doe and her
16 19 complaints... complaint. However, at least today
ita 20 my counsel has advised me I must assert my rights
19 21 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
20 22 Q Are you taking the position that Jane 21 DATE: April M.2010
22 23 Doe's alleged damages were actually caused by a
23 24 separate or other child molester? 24
25 25 MR. PIKE: One second... object to the
41 (Pages 493 to 4 96)
U.S. Legal Support
497 499
font I think you need to reword the
question.

MR. EDWARDS: Okay. I'll ask it again.
Q Is it your position, or do you have
facts or information that Jane Doe was molested
ti by a separate or different child molester?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A I would like to answer all your
9 questions that you posed here today, Mr. Edwards.
every last one of them. However, at least today
under advice of counsel, I have been instructed I
must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q The next affirmative defense indicates
that Jane Doe impliedly consented to the ads
alleged by not objecting.
What do you mean by that affirmative
defense?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like it answer all your
questions regarding Jane Doe, and her complaint.
However, today my attorneys have advised me that
I must assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth
and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Do you moan —
belies ed or was told that the plaintiff, Jane
2 Doe, had attained the age of IS years old at the
3 time of the alleged acts." That is a false
4 statement, isn't it, Mr. Epstein?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A I would like to answer every question
7 you posed today, Mr. Edwards, about Jane Doe and
8 her complaint. However, at least today my
9 attorneys have advised me I must assert my rights
10 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q What gave you the reasonable belief that
Jane Doe was 18 years of age or older when you
touched her In a sexual manner?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer all of your
questions with respect to Jane Doe, Mr. Edwards,
every one of them. However, today, as you're
aware, my counsel has advised me I must assert my
9 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
0 Amendment.
1 Q Didn't Jane Doe tell you when you asked
2 her age that she was 15 years old?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A I would like to answer that question
5 because I've answered most of your other

MR. PIKE: May also call for work
2 product information. Sony.
Q Do you mean that, for instance, when you
4 would Insert your fingers Into her vagina when
5 she was 14 or 15 years old, that because she
6 didn't object that she impliedly consented to
7 that conduct?
8 MR. PIKE: Form.
9 A What's the question?
10 Q Do you mean by —I'll read your
11 affirmative defense that you have stated.
12 "PlaintiffJane Doe impliedly consented
13 to the acts alleged by not objecting," and I'm
14 asking: By that, do you mean that when you
15 inserted your fingers into her vagina when she
16 was age 14 or IS, that by her not verbally
17 objecting, then in your mind she consented?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A I would like to answer all your
20 questions Mr. Edwards. However, at least today,
21 at least today, my counsel instructed me I must
22 assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
23 Fourteenth Amendment.
24 Q Your next affirmative defense states
25 that "Defendant," that being you, "reasonably
1 questions here today. Unfortunately my counsel
2 here today said I must invoke my rights under the
3 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q The second portion of that affirmative
defense is that you reasonably believed or you
6 were told that Jane Doe attained the age of 18.
Tell the jury, who told you that Jane
Doe had attained the age of 18 years old when you
9 engaged in sexual conduct with her?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A Though I would like very much to answer
12 that question, as most of your other questions
13 here today, as you're aware my counsel has
14 advised me I must assert my rights under the
15 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
16 Q In fact, if you learned that she had
17 attained the age of 18 years old, you would not
18 have engaged in sexual conduct with her, would
19 you?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A 1 would hire to answer all of your
questions with respect to lane Doe, Mr. FAwards.
However, at least today, my counsel advised me
that I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
S
42 (Pages 497 to 500)
U.S. Le al Su ort
501 503
Q In fact, there were several times when
girls were brought to you by other underage minor
3 females and these girls were over the age of 18
4 and you turned them away, as being too old for
you; isn't that true?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A Again, I would like to answer all your
questions here today. I would like to answer
9 that question. However, my counsel has advised
10 me that at least today I may not and must assen
11 my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
12 Amendment.
13 Q In fact, your target age group for
14 sexual activity is between 12 rind 17 years old;
15 is that Inset
16 MR. PIKE: Form.
17 A Mr. Edwards, I would like to answer that
18 question, as well as your other questions here
19 today. However, my counsel has advised me that I
20 must not, may not, must assert my rights under
21 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
22 Q You know a person named V.R., don't
23 you?
24 A Though I would like to answer all of
25 your questions Mr. Edwards, on advice of counsel
1 Q Isn't it true during that period of time
2 when V.R. was your underage sex slave, that she
3 observed you to have sexual intercourse and
4 sexual activity with several females, as young as
5 12 years old?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A I would like to respond to all of these
8 questions. And I prefer that your partner. Scott
9 Rothstein, who currently sits in jail for
10 fabricating cases of a sexual nature against
11 people like me and others, were here to hear some
12 of these answers. However, with respect to any
3 other question, at least today, my counsel has
14 advised me that I must assert my rights under the
15 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
16 Q Why would you prefer that Scott
17 Rothstein bear an answer from you about whether
18 or not you had sex with multiple 12 year olds?
19 MR. PIKE: Form. Move to strike, and
r 0 mischaracterizes the witness's testimony.
r 1 A At least today, Mr. Edwards, my counsel
2 has advised me that I must respond to these
3 questions by asserting my rights under the Sixth,
4 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
5 Q V.R. is somebody who has filed a lawsuit
today at least, they've instructed me that I must
2 respond by asserting my rights under the Sixth,
3 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
4 Q V.R. is somebody who served as your sex
5 slave when she was between the ages of 15 and 18
6 years old; isn't that true?
7 MIL PIKE: Form.
8 A I would like to respond to all of your
9 questions with respect to V.R. However, on
10 advice of counsel today at least, they've
11 instructed me that I must assert my rights under
12 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
13 Q Do you know Emmy Taylor?
14 A Though I would like to respond to all of
15 your questions here today, Mr. Edwards, under
16 advice of counsel I must assert my rights under
17 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
18 Q Is that somebody who served as the sex
19 slave for Cislaine Maxwell at the same time or
20 about the same time that V.R. was your sex slave?
21 MR. PIKE: Form.
22 A I would like to answer all of your
23 questions, Mr. Edwards. However today my counsel
24 has advised me I must assert my rights under the
25 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
1 against you under the pseudonym Jane Doe number
2 102; isn't that correct?
3 MR. PIKE: I'm sorry. Can you repeat
4 it?
5 MR. EDWARDS: Sure.
6 Q V.R. is somebody that filed a lawsuit
7 against yon under the pseudonym Jane Doe number
8 102?
9 A Though I would like to respond to your
0 questions today, Mr. Edwards, with respect to
1 these lawsuits, my counsel has advised me that I
2 may not, and must assert my rights under the
3 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
Q In that complaint, the allegation is
made that a friend of Jeffrey Epstein sent him
three 12-year old girls from France, who spoke no
English, for defendant Epstein to sexually
exploit and abuse. After doing so, they were
sent back to France the next day.
That's a true statement, isn't it?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to respond to all of these
questions... However, at least today, my counsel
has advised me that I must assert my rights under
the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
43 (Pages 501 to 504)
U.S. Legal Support
505 507
1 Q In the complaint filed on behalf of Jane
2 Doc number 102 also known as V.R., was filed by
3 an attorney named Bob Josefsberg with Podhurst.
4 Orseck; isn't that right?
5 MR. PIKE: Can you reread that specific
6 question for me?
7 THE COURT REPORTER: Sure.
8 (Ile record was read.)

MR. PIKE: To the extent you know the
answer to that question, you can answer.
A I think -- I'm going to assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q And when I asked you a few questions
back about your sexual Interaction and
intercourse with I2-year old girls and derived
that from this complaint, your answer — into
your answer was injected some response related to
Scott Rothstein, and so my question is, what do
you believe, if anything, Scott Rothstein had to
do with the complaints or assertions that are
made in the Jane Doe 102 versus Epstein
complaint?

MR. PIKE: Form, move to strike.
Mischaracterizes the witness's testimony.
A I would like to answer that question.
S
Amendment right.

MR. EDWARDS: Mark this.
(Order form from Amazon.com, listing
three books, was marked as Plaintiff's
Exhibit number 9 for identification, as of
this date.)

MR. PIKE: (Handing to the witness.)
Q Do you recognize that document that's
been marked for identification purposes as
Exhibit 9?
A No. I do not.
Q Did you indeed order the three books
from Amazon.com that are listed on that order
form that's been marked as Exhibit 9?
A No.
Q Have you read the three books that are
on that order form, Exhibit number 9?
A No.
Q Do you know why it is, can you explain
how that document came to exist?
A No.
Q Do you know where that document that
you're holding marked as Exhibit number 9 came
from?
A No.
However, at least today they have instructed me 1 1.
must respond to that question by asserting my 2
Sixth, Filth and Fourteenth Amendment right. 3
Q Mr. Epstein, for at least the passed 4
decade you have consistently kept at least one 5
sex slave at all times. Is that true? 6

MR. PIKE: Form. 7
A I would like to respond to these 8
sexually charged questions. However, upon advice 9
of counsel, I must respond simply by asserting my r 0
Sixth Amendment, Fifth Amendment and Fourteenth 1
Amendment right. s 2
Q And you have an Amazon.com account, r 3
right? 4
have to assert my right to the Sixth Amendment,
Fifth Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q On or about September 4.2005 you

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Upon advice of counsel, I'm going to 6
ordered and received -- and later received three
books from Amazon.com; is that true?

MR. PIKE: Form. Um... Books?
... Form.
A On advice of counsel I have to assert my
Sixth Amendment, Filth Amendment and Fourteenth 125
Q Would you be surprised if it was taken
from your trash by police or law enforcement?
A Would I be surprised? I don't
understand the question.
Q Would it surprise you if the police
pulled that from your trash, outside your house,
in 2005?

MR. PIKE: Object to the form. There,
because... quite frankly, I don't know where
this document came from. There has been no
predicate laid as to its origination. Now
you're talking about a question relative to.
would it surprise you if the police pulled
it... I don't think that you've laid the
proper foundation, so I'm going to object to
the form.

MR. EDWARDS: Okay. At trial I'll enter
it in through another witness. I just want
him to deny him ever seeing it before I do
that. It is fine, I'll lay the predicate —
MR PIKE: He's already said that,1
believe, he never -- you asked him if he
recognized the document and he said "No."

MR. EDWARDS: I appreciate that.
Q Would It surprise you if that was
44 (Pages 505 to 508)
U.S. Le al Su ort
509 511
1 obtained from a trash pull at your house?
2 A You're asking me a hypothetical
3 question. I have no idea.
4 Q What is the name and address of the
5 purported purchaser of those books? According to
6 Exhibit number 9?
7 A I don't know.

MR. PIKE: Form.
Q Looking at that document you cannot tell
what address those books were shipped to?
A It says "billing address.'
Q What's the billing address?
A It says what the document says.
Q What is that?
A h says Jeffrey Epstein.
Q What's the address?
A 358 El Grillo Way.
Q That address at 358 El Brill° Way is
your address, correct?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A On advice of counsel. I'm going to have
to assert my Fifth Amendment, Sixth Amendment and
Fourteenth Amendment right.
Q Jeffrey Epstein, that's your name,
correct?
1 A I don't know.
2 Q Is there anybody else that lives in your
3 house, besides yourself, that has sex slaves?
4 MR. PIKE: I'm sorry... Mr. Horowitz, I
5 believe, interrupted you, I think he gave
6 you another exhibit, I think it's Exhibit 9,
7 which I think he wants you to follow up with
B a question.

MR. EDWARDS: It is just placed on the
table. I'm waiting for an answer.
MR. PIKE: I'm not being smarter. I'm
just saying, are you going to follow through
with the question that's currently on the
table or the one that —

MR. EDWARDS: I asked a question and
many waiting for an answer.
MR. PIKE: Seriously, I'm not trying to
be rude or smart. You put an exhibit in
front of him and --

MR. HOROWITZ: I wanted to give the
court reporter the exhibits. She gets the
exhibits.
MR. PIKE: I've got to know what
question is on the table, that's all.

MR. HOROWITZ: I didn't interrupt you,
1 A Correct.
2 Q Can I see the document?
3 A (Handing to counsel.)
4 Q Mr. Epstein, the person whose deposition
was taken yesterday and has been wkaile orted
in the newspapers as your sex slave
7 is she indeed your sex slave?
8 . E: Form.
A On advice of counsel, I'm going to
0 respond by asserting my Sixth Amendment, Fifth
Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment right.
Q Does anybody other than yourself have
access to your Amazon.com account?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I don't know.
Q You have never read "Slave Craft,
Roadmaps for Erotic Servitude, Principles, Skills
and Tools"?

MR. PIKE: Asked and answered. He was
already asked these questions -- I'm sorry,
answered.
A I've answered the question "No."
Q Why was it ordered to your house, the
shipping address and billing address both being
358 El Brine Way?
1 did l?
2 MR. EDWARDS: No, it is asked on --I
3 asked a question, it is still on the table.
4 A Ask the question.
S Q Anybody else in your house have sex
6 slaves?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A I have to respond to that question as I
9 did to most of your other questions today, which
0 is l have to assert my rights to the Sixth, Fifth
1 and Fourteenth Amendment.
2 Q Art you familiar with the various
3 messages that are — that were taken from your
4 home at 358 El Brill° Way?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A I'm going to have to assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Have you read the messages that were
taken and placed In the State Attorney's Office
file related to the criminal charges against
you?

MR. PIKE: Fonn.
A I don't recall.
Q Why is it that underage minor females
were calling your home in 2004 and 2005 for, In
45 (Pages 509 to 512) •
U.S. Legal Support
5/.3 515
quotes, "work"?

MR. PIKE: Wait a second. Form, lacks
predicate, foundation, and for the record,
you're referring to a stack of documents
that have not been marked —

MR. EDWARDS: Not referring to anything.
just so that your objection is clear.
MR. PIKE: You're referring to what I
see as a stack of documents that look like
message pads. You're clarifying and...
making a prelude into your question as to
why were underage girls calling your home
for work?

MR. EDWARDS; Right.
MR. PIKE: You're not allowing the
witness to see the exhibits to which you
refer, and I think it is an improper
question and lacks predicate and
foundation.

MR. EDWARDS: No matter what I show the
witness, any answer he gives is going to
incriminate him, so he is going to invoke
his Fifth Amendment rights, which is why
right now, he is not going to see these. At
trial he will see all of these things.

MR. PIKE: I'm glad you said that. I
2 think that's a false statement. I move to
3 strike it. Mr. Edwards, you provided a
4 document to Mr. Epstein not two minutes ago
5 and he answered questions without invoking
the Fifth Amendment right.

MR. EDWARDS: And it incriminated him.
MR. PIKE: If the Fifth Amendment comes
into play.
MR. EDWARDS: It should have.

MR. PIKE: Thank you. If the Fifth
Amendment comes into play, he will invoke
the Fifth. He does not know certain
information. Not knowing something, my
friend, is not a waiver. Follow? So he is
trying to --

MR. EDWARDS: It is —
MR. PIKE: -- trying to actually work
with you on your questions. Maybe if you
show him what you're talking about he can
answer your question.
Q Why were underage minor females calling
your house to, quote, unquote. "work"?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Unfortunately, I have to answer that
11.
question, as I've answered most of your other
questions here today, Mr. Edwards, which is that
my attorneys advised me to assert my Sixth
Amendment, Fifth Amendment and Fourteenth
Amendment right.
i t Do you know
A As Eve answered most of your other
questions hem today, I'm going to have to
respond that my attorneys have instructed me to
assert my rights to the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q That's somebody who is listed in the
agreement between yourself and the United States
of America as a coconspirator of yours. Does
that help refresh your recollection as to who Ms.
a s?

MR. PIKE: Fr.
A I'm going to have to respond by
asserting my rights to the Sbcth, Fifth and
Founeenth Amendment.
Q Do you remember receiving messages from
Adrian that would read something like, "I left a
mesas e for to confirm for 11:00 o'clock
and or 4:30," many messages like that?
1 MR. PIKE: I'm sorry, but before he
2 answers, I'm just curious, you're again
3 referring to a stack of documents that's
4 about an inch thick. Do you want to mark
5 anything as an exhibit?
6 MR. EDWARDS: No, I really don't, Mike,
7 but appreciate all the help you're
8 providing. Thanks.
9 MR. PIKE: Yeah. You're welcome. Do
0 you know where these documents came from?
1 MR. EDWARDS: Yes.
2 MR. PIKE: Where did you obtain that
3 them from?
4 MR. EDWARDS: It is not my deposition.
5 You had that chance already.
6 MR. PIKE: No, I asked the right -- no,
7 that's not really part of my case over
8 there. Critton took your deposition, not
9 me. That's a case separate and distinct
0 from these cases, so my question to you is:
1 Pin just curious, you have a stack of
2 documents, I think you said earlier they
3 came from the State Attorney's Office file?
4 MR. EDWARDS: It is not my deposition.
I'm asking questions. Your client is going
46 (Pages 513 to 516)
U.S. Legal Support
517 519
left message for
o'clock and Mfor 4:30"?
A I don't recall.
Q And when a message such as that is left,
is that Indicating .= is going to come to
your house for you to molest her at 11:00 and
will come for you to molest her at 4:30?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I'm going to have to respond by
asserting my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Why would underage minor females call
your home and leave messages like, "I have a girl
for him." Do you know?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A On advice of my counsel, today at least,
to give answers or not give answers.
MR. PIKE: Okay.

MR. EDWARDS: These will come in with
the appropriate person at trial, period.
MR. PIKE: Okay.
A Question? Sony.
Q Sure.
Do you remember receiving a message from
, such as, "I
to confirm for I1:00
Q In a newspaper article dated October 30,
2006 entitled, "The Return Of A," In quotes,
'Very Passionate' end quote, "Jeffrey Epstein,"
there is a quote from somebody that is called in
this article "A Friend," and the quote is:
"Speaking about Jeffrey Epstein, his life Is
about making money and living an erotic life and
his escape isn't alcohol or drugs, it is sex."
Is that a true statement?
MR. PIKE: Form.
A Is it a true statement that that's what
the article says?
Q No, is it a true statement that your
life is about making money and living an erotic
life and your escape is not alcohol or drugs, it
Is sex?
MIL PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer that
question, as well as all your other questions
posed here today, Mr. Edwards, on advice of my
counsel, he has instructed me I must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Another article entitled "The
Fanaticist," from New York Magazine dated
1 they've advised me I must assert my right under
2 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
3 Q Did you ever employ any underage minor
1 females for any legitimate purpose at your home,
5 358 El Brillo Way?
6 MIL PIKE: Form.
7 A At least today, Mr. Edwards, though I
8 would like to answer every one of your...
questions, my counsel has advised me I must
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Isn't it true, Mr. Epstein, that each
underage minor female that contacted — that
called your home or was called from your home,
was called for the purposes of coming to your
house to satisfy you sexually?
MIL PIKE: Form.
THE WITNESS: I think Eve answered that
question before.
A I will answer it unfortunately the same
way, which is although I would like to answer
each and every one of the questions you've posed
here today, on advice of my counsel they've
instructed me I must assert my rights under the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
December 10, 2007, a quote or several quotes arc
attributed to you, and it reads: "I told
Epstein," this is the author "and Rubenstein the
sort of story New York Magazine wanted to do, and
Epstein seemed to find ironic delight in every
word. A secretive genius, I said," a statement
from the author. "She indicates you corrected
her saying "Not secretive, private," and the next
quote, which I will ask you about, is that you
stated "And If I was a genius, l wouldn't be
sitting here, a gay with sex issues;" do you
remember saying that?

MR. PIKE: Form.
Q to a reporter In New York?
MR. PIKE: Form. Move to strike.
A Though I would like to answer every
question you've posed here today, Mr. Edwards, on
advice of counsel I have to assert my Sixth
Amendment, Fifth Amendment and Fourteenth
Amendment right.

MR. PIKE: Mr. Edwards, if you would, I
know you —
THE WITNESS: Take a break?
MR. PIKE: Actually one second.
You provided the title of the second
47 (Pages 517 to 520)
U.S. Legal Support
521 523
25•
article that you just questioned him. Could
2 you please, for the record, provide the
title to the first article.

MR. EDWARDS: I did.
MR. PIKE: I didn't hear it.
MR. EDWARDS: I will do it again. "A
Rehm, Of A 'Very Passionate Jeffrey
Epstein.'
MR. PIKE: Thank you.
MR. EDWARDS: "Very passionate" is in
quotes, as I said the first time.
MR. PIKE: Thank you.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the video
record 3:02 p.m.
(Pause in the proceedings.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
record at 3:15 p.m.
Q In the same ankle, "The Fanaticist,"
there is a quote by "Michael Wolff." Do you know
Michael Wolff, the columnist?
A I have to respond the same way I've
responded to most of your questions here today,
which is, I must assert my rights under the
Sixth, Filth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Mr. Wolff says in a quote In this
1 to be ridiculous. You can't read —
2 MR. EDWARDS: What
3 MR. PIKE: You can't read someone else's
4 quote and say "Are you admitting something
5 from someone else's quote.' He didn't make
6 the quote, so how can it be an admission,
7 despite who it is.
8 MR. HOROWITZ: That's a form objection.
9 MR. PIKE: You're right, form.
10 Q Your attorney, Jack Goldberger, made the
1 statement, "Jeffrey Epstein never denied the
12 girls came to the house." This was related to
13 the criminal investigation of you.
14 Do you admit thnt the girls,
15 specifically Jane Doe, came to your house?
16 A Mr. Edwards, l would like to respond to
17 that question as I responded to most of the other
18 questions today, but unfortunately my counsel has
19 advised me I must assert my rights under the
20 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
21 Q Mr. Epstein, can you tell the jury who
22 MEMMIMMW
23 MR. PIKE: Form.
24 A Unfortunately, Mr. Edwards, I have to
25 respond to that question as I responded to moat
1 article, "Ile has never," speaking about Mr.
2 Epstein, "been secretive about the girls. At one
3 point when his troubles began he was talking to
4 me and said, 'What can I say? I like young
o girls." Is that a comment or statement that you
6 made to Michael Wolff?
7 MR. PIKE: Form.
8 A Unfortunately I have to respond to that
question as I did to most of your questions
today, which is I must assert my rights under
advice of counsel, under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q On several occasions your attorney or
one of your attorneys, Jack Goldberger, has made
the statement "Jeffrey Epstein has never denied
that the girls came to the house." Arc you
admitting that the girls that are now plaintiffs,
at least came to your house?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer that question
you've just quoted an attorney's statement?
Q Right, Jack Goldberger's statement.
A So what's the question?

MR. PIKE: You can't — hold on right
there. This is ridicubus. This Ls getting
1 of your other questions today, because on advice
2 of counsel they've instructed me to assert my
3 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
4 Amendment.
5 Q You're aware that she is somebody listed
6 as a eo-conspirator of yours related to your
criminal activity in the Nonprosecution
Agreement, correct?

MR. PIKE: Fenn.
A With respect to that question as most of
your other questions here today, on advice of
counsel I have been instructed to assert my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Isn't it true that you paid her to have
underage minor females brought to your house, at
specific times, as you directed?

MR. PIKE: Form, asked and answered.
A As I've answered most of your questions
here today, unfortunately my counsel has advised
me that I must assert my rights under the Sixth,
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Another co-conspirator of yours, as she
Is labeled in the Nooprosecution Agreement, is
Lesley Groff. What role did she play or what did
48 (Pages 521 to 524)
U.S. Legal Support
525 527
1 she conspire with you to do?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A Mr. Edwards, I have to respond to that
4 question as I did to most of your other questions
5 here today, which is, on advice of counsel,
6 they've instructed me to assert my rights under
7 the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
8 Q Today what role does Story Cowles play
in your life?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer all your
questions, Mr. Edwards. However, at least today,
my counsel has advised me that I must assert my
rights under the Sixth, Filth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Is Story Cowles your personal
assistant?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Mr. Edwards, I would like to answer all
your questions here today. However, upon advice
of counsel, they've instructed me that I must
assert my Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth Amendment
rights to that question.
Q And Story Cowles, in addition to being
21.
25 your personal assistant,
underage minor females in the communities
surrounding each of your homes?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer each and
every one of your questions, Mr. Edwards, my
attorneys have advised me at least today, at
least today, that I may not. I must assert my
rights as provided by the Sixth. Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Isn't it true that within that computer
system were the names and telephone numbers of
hundreds of underage minor females that you
sexually molested?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to answer every one of your
questions today, Mr. Edwards. However, upon
advice of counsel I must assert my rights as
protected by the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Can you explain to the jury what
Gislaine Maxwell's role was in helping you to
access underage minors?

MR. PIKE: Form, assumes facts not in
evidence.
A You know I would like to answer each and
1 boyfriend; is that true?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A Though I would like to answer all your
4 questions, Mr. Edwards, on advice of counsel
5 they've instructed me that I must assert my
6 rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
7 Amendment.
8 Q Prior to the police executing, the Palm
Beach police executing a search warrant on your
house in October of 2005, did you direct
to remove at least three computers from
your home?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer all your
questions, Mr. Edwards, my attorneys at least
today have advised me I must assert my rights
under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Where arc those computers today?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer all your
questions, my attorneys have advised me I must
assert my rights under the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Isn't it true that those computers
contain the names and telephone numbers of
every one of your questions posed here today, Mr.
Edwards. Unfortunately I have to answer that
question on advice of counsel by invoking my
rights under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Do you have any remorse for sexually
molesting Jane Doe?

MR. PIKE: Form, argumentative.
A I would like to answer every one of your
questions regarding Jane Doe. However, at least
today, my counsel has instructed me to assert my
rights as protected by the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q When is the last time that you visited
your island, Little St. James?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer all your
questions, Mr. Edwards, my counsel advised me I
must assert my rights as protected by the Sixth,
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Has any court given you permission to go
to your island or the Virgin Islands while you
have been on house arrest?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Mr. Edwards, though I would like to
49 (Pages 525 to 528)
U.S. Le al Su ort
529 531
answer all your questions, my counsel has advised
2 me that I must assert my rights protected by the
3 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
4 Q Have you interacted sexually with
S underage minors since beginning your house arrest
6 or community control?
7 MR. PIKE: Fonn.
8 A Though I would like to answer each and
every one of your questions posed here today, my
counsel has advised me that I must assert my
rights protected by the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q Mr. Epstein, is it your intention to
testify in the trial of Jane Doe versus Jeffrey
Epstein?

MR. PIKE: Object to the form. It may
disclose attorney/client work product
information. I instruct him not to answer.
Q Does Story Cowles work for you at
Florida Science Foundation?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer each and
every one of your questions, Mr. Edwards, at
least today my counsel has advised melmust
Essen my rights as protected by the Sixth, Fifth

MS. EZELL: Okay. I can begin. Are we
ending at 4:00?
MR. PIKE: Yes, we we ending at 4:00.
CROSS EXAMINATION
BY MS. FIN I"
MS Fin I • Let the mond reflect that
I have 3:22 right now.
Q Mr. Epstein. good afternoon.
A Good afternoon.
Q You were previously deposed by Mr.
Horowitz on Monday, March 8th of this year. You
were asked with respect to Jane Doe 103. "Do you
acknowledge that she's been to your home?" There
was a form objection and your answer was, "Again
I would like to answer most of your questions.
However, today as Fre answered most, almost all
of your questions and will continue to answer on
advice of counsel, I believe, this question, I
have to assert my Fifth Amendment, Fourteenth
Amendment and Sixth Amendment rights under the
U.S. Constitution."
If you were asked the same question
today, what would your answer be? That question
was: "Do you acknowledge that Jane Doe 103 has
been to your home"?
and Fourteenth Amendment.
2 Q Is it your intent in the future to
3 engage In sexual activity with underage minor
children?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A I would like to answer each one of those
7 questions, Mr. Edwards. However, today my
8 counsel has advised me I must assert my rights
9 protected by the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q When you give that answer, that you
would like to respond to each one of my
questions, would it then be your preference to
explain to the jury why it is that you feel
entitled to sexually molest underage minor
children?

MR. PIKE: Form, move to strike.
Miseharacterizes the witness's testimony.
A Unfortunately I would like to answer
that question as well, but my counsel has advised
me that I must assert my rights as protected by
the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
MR. EDWARDS: I don't have anything
Amber.
MR. PIKE: Ms. Ezell?
1 A Please tell me who lane Doe 103 is.
2 Q Jane Doe 103 is Jane Doe 103.
3 A I would like to answer the question so
4 the answer would be the same.
5 MR. PIKE: By "answering that question,"
6 you're invoking Fifth. Sixth and
7 Fourteenth?
B THE WITNESS: Yes.
9 MR. PIKE: Please do so.
10 A I'm invoking my Sixth Amendment, Fifth
11 Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment right.
12 Q You were then asked "Do you acknowledge
13 that Jane Doe 103 came to your home for sexual
14 contact during her childhood and that you paid
15 her for those services?"
16 Mr. Pike said "Form, predicate,
17 foundation, argumentative," and your response was
18 "I would like to answer that question. I think
19 those questions will all have obvious answers.
20 and not -- however, today I'm going to have to
21 assert my Filth Amendment, Sixth Amendment and
22 Fourteenth Amendment rights under the U.S.
23 Constitution, because I would like to answer that
24 question, my attorneys have advised me that I
25 cannot today, cannot answer any question that may
50 (Pages 529 to 532)
U.S. Legal Support
533 535
1 be relevant to this lawsuit."
2 If you were asked that same question
3 today, would your answer be the same?
4 MR. PIKE: I'm going to object. Form.
5 and I instruct you if your answer is the
6 same, please tell Ms. Ezell that.
7 A My answer is the same, invoking my right
8 under the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
9 Q So, it wasn't just that that day you
10 were Instructed not to answer the question, but
11 here, five weeks later, today, you also, today,
12 can't answer those questions, correct?
13 MR. PIKE: Asked and answered.
14 A I'm going to, on advice of counsel, Ms.
15 Ezell, respectfully assert my rights as protected
16 by the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
17 Q Later Mr. Horowitz said, "Sir, are you
18 asserting your Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
19 Amendment privileges because you're innocent? Is
20 that what you're telling us?"
21 You said "Today on advice of counsel 1
22 cannot answer your questions, any of your
23 questions that may be relevant to this lawsuit"
24 MR. PIKE: Form.
25 Q What would your answer be today to that
1 could answer those questions."
2 can you answer that question today?
3 MR. PIKE: Form.
4 A Ma'am, unfortunately In going to have
5 to invoke my Sixth Amendment, Fifth and
6 Fourteenth Amendment right to that question.
7 Q Then you were asked --
8 THE WITNESS: Can we go off the record
for a second?
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Off the video record
3:32 p.m.
THE WITNESS: Just two minutes.

MR. EDWARDS: For what? We are all
going to have a discussion off the record?
MR. PIKE: I think my client wants to
speak with me.

MR. EDWARDS: Okay.
MR. PIKE: Are you okay with that Ms.
Ezell?
MS. EZELL: Yes.
MR. PIKE: Off the record.
(Pause in the proceedings.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: --
THE WITNESS: Sony, go ahead.
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
1 question?
2 MR. PIKE: Same objection.
3 A On advice of counsel, with respect to
4 that question, going to have to assert my
5 rights as protected by the Sixth, Fifth and
6 Fourteenth Amendment
7 Q So again, your answer wasn't just that
8 answer then, five weeks ago, but today, you again
9 cannot answer on advice of counsel, correct?

MR. PIKE: Move to strike.
Mischaracterization. Plaintiff has
invoked — sorry, defendant has invoked
Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth. That's his
answer.

MS. EZELL: So he invokes them today, as
well?
MR. PIKE: Yes, ma'am.
Q Mr. Horowitz asked "Between 2005 and
2006, did your sexual interests include digitally
penetrating the vaginas of girls between the ages
of 12 and 17?"
Mr. Pike objected "Form," and you said,
"1 find these questions — I would like to
answer every one of those questions. However, my
counsel has told me I may not today. I wish I
1 record 3:33 pm
2 Q Later in that same deposition, Mr.
3 Horowitz asked "Did you have surveillance cameras
4 la either the interior or exterior of your home
5 at El Brillo Way between 2001 and 2006?"
6 You answered, "Mr. Horowitz, I'm going
7 to answer that question the same way as I've
8 answered most of your other questions here
9 today. I would like to answer each one of your
10 questions regarding your clients with great
11 specificity, however my counsel has advised me
12 that I may not today, and therefore have to
13 invoke my Fourteenth Amendment rights, my Sixth
14 Amendment rights and my Fifth Amendment rights as
15 provided by the U.S. Constitution."
16 So what about today? Can you answer
17 that question form today?
18 MR. PIKE: Object to the form.
19 A Unfortunately, Ms. Ezell Mrs. Ezell,
20 I'm sorry.
21 Q Ms. Is fine.
22 A Okay. Ms. Ezell. Unfortunately on
23 advise of counsel, I have to amen my rights as
24 protected by the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
25 Amendment
51 (Pages 533 to 536)
U.S. Legal Support
1 MR. PIKE: And Ms. Ezell, let me caution
2 you that I've listened to several of your
3 questions. The first one being a repetition
4 of Mr. Horowitz's question approximately
four weeks ago dealing with your client 103,
6 so I did not have a problem with that
7 background information being repeated.
8 However, it seems that the questions that
9 you're discussing now and going over are
10 just a repetition of Mr. Horowitz's
11 background information, which has already
12 been established and really has no relation,
13 in my opinion, to your particular clients.
14 Given the fact we arc here today, Mr.
15 Horowitz has taken the liberty of concluding
16 his deposition, obviously with rebuttal
17 available, same with Mr. Edwards, I would
18 ask, rather than to have to seek assistance
19 of the Court, that your questions be
20 tailored toward your client.
21 MS. EZELL: Mr. Pike, I would beg to
22 differ with you. Questions regarding his
23 sexual interests, including digitally
24 penetrating vaginas of girls between ages of
25 12 and 17 certainly pertain to my client.

MR. HOROWITZ: I join in Ms. Ezell's
comments.
MR. EDWARDS: Agreed.
MR. PIKE: Thank you. Three against
one. Nonetheless, again, I hold steadfast
the same argument. It is repetitious and
whether or not — he is not going to waive
Fifth, Sixth and Fourteenth yesterday and he
is not going to waive it today, so...

MS. EZELL: That's fine. My objection
to that is that it is misleading for him to
say that "Today I have been instructed not
to answer it," because then I come here
hoping five weeks later I may get an answer,
and unfortunately that's not been the case.
We have had the same invocation of the
privileges today, only today, just for
today.

MR. PIKE: Well, I --
MS. EZELL: I'm done with that line of
questioning.
MR. PIKE: Okay.
MS. EZELL: But I think I had the right
to ask.

MR. PIKE: Thank you.
1 MR. PIKE: Ms. Ezell, you were at that
2 deposition. You cross-noticed that
3 deposition and these cases have been
4 consolidated for discovery, and you have not
5 formed, with the exception of one question,
6 since you commenced your portion of the
7 depo, you have not formed one question
8 relative to your particular client.
You just asked a general question that
had already been asked by Mr. Horowitz who
commenced the Volume I of this Volume III or
IV continuation of the deposition. If you
want to tailor these questions to your
client, I have no problem with that, but to
ask the same exact question Mr. Horowitz
asked who commenced the deposition is a
waste of time.

MS. EZELL: That may be your opinion,
Mr. Pike, but I believe I have, particularly
in the way these questions were answered
five weeks ago, that today, that day he was
unable to answer because of advice of
counsel. I certainly have the right to ask
him whether this day, five weeks later, he
can answer that question.

MS. EZELL: Thank you.
Q Mr. Epstein, are you a citizen of the
United States?
A Yes.
Q And are you a citizen of the United
States Virgin Islands?
A I don't know what that means.
Q Of what State or territory of the United
States are you a citizen?
A I'm a citizen of the United States.
Q And of what State or territory in the
United States do you claim to be a citizen?
A I'm a citizen of the United States.
Q Where do you vote?
A I vote in the Virgin Islands.
Q Where do you pay your taxes?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A On advice of counsel, I'm going to have
to assert my rights as protected by the Sixth,
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
Q And I would Just note that your tax
returns are public documents available to the
government, and there is no -- no risk of
incriminating yourself with such a document. Do
you still maintain the same objection?
52 (Pages 537 to 540)
U.S. Legal Support
541 543

MR. PIKE: He does, and that calls for a
2 legal conclusion, which currently is, I
3 think, under -- it was under appeal and now
4 it is back under appeal.
5 Q Before serving your jail time in Palm
6 Beach County, followed by your community control
7 time, was your principal place of residence the
dwelling in Manhattan?
9 A The what?
10 Q Your mansion in Manhattan?
11 MR. PIKE: Form.
12 A Pm sorry, but at least today, I would
13 like to answer all your questions, Ms. Ezell.
14 However, on advice of counsel I will have to
15 respond by invoking my Sixth, Fifth and
16 Fourteenth Amendment
17 Q I won't repeat the same questions
18 regarding the plan or scheme. I'll try not to,
19 that have already been covered today. To the
20 extent that they didn't just apply to that one
21 plaintiff, in most instances, I believe that Mr.
22 Edwards said, "young women" or "young girls like
23 or including Jane Doe," but there were a few
24 additional questions in that area I wanted to
25 ask.
1 who came to your home to provide massages and
2 other sexual gratification for you, were they
3 often transported by other
4 assistants that you employed?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 A Though 1 would like to answer each and
7 every one of your questions, Ms. Ezell, I
8 respectfully must decline. On advice of counsel
they've instructed me I must assert my rights
protected by the Sixth. Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Would you acknowledge, Mr. Epstein. that
once the girls were there, beginning with their
first experience, their first visit, there was a
sort of a ritual that was followed in regard to
how they were treated, what they were asked to do
and what occurred?

MR. PIKE: I'm sorry, I didn't know if
that was the question.
MS. EZELL: It is a question.
THE WITNESS: What's the question?
MR. PIKE: What is the question?
Q From the first visit a girl might make
to your home, was there a ritual or routine that
was followed with regard to what happened during
Within that arrangement whereby girls
2 would come or be brought to your home to provide
3 massages and other sexual gratification for you,
4 were they often brought by taxis that were paid
5 for by you or by someone on your behalf?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
A Though I would like to answer all your
questions today, Ms. Ezell, Ism going to have to
9 respond to that question as I've responded to
10 most of your other questions, which is, on advice
11 of counsel, at least today, they've instructed me
12 to assert my rights as protected by the Sixth,
13 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment
14 Q Also, within that same scheme, were
15 these girls sometimes transported to or from your
16 house by the current houseman employed by you at
17 that time?
18 MR. PIKE: Form.
19 A Though I would like to answer all your
20 questions, Ms. Ezell, that question as well as
21 the others, I must unfortunately at least today,
22 on advice of counsel, invoke my Sixth Amendment,
23 Fifth Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment right.
24 Q And again following with that plan as
25 discussed previously, were those same young women
1 that visit?
2 MR. PIKE: Form.
3 A Ms. Ezell, I would like it answer all
4 your questions that you posed here today, but I
5 will have to respond unfortunately, as I've
6 responded to most of the others which is, my
7 counsel advised me I must respond by invoking my
8 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
9 Q For instance, in addition to the other
10 things that Mr. Edwards and Mr. Horowitz asked
11 about, within the same area, would Ms. Or
12 one of your other assistants usually go up and
13 lay out the towels and particular massage oils
14 that you like?
15 MR. PIKE: Form.
16 A Ms. Ezell. unfortunately I have to
17 answer that question as I've answered most of
18 your other questions here today, respectfully
19 decline to answer on advice of counsel who's
20 asked me to invoke my Sixth Amendment, Fifth
21 Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment right.
22 Q Was it more or less routine that when a
23 girl would come for the first time, that she
24 would be accompanied to the massage area by
25 another woman or girl?
53 (Pages 541 to 544)
U.S. Legal Support
545 547
1 MR. PIKE: Form.
2 A Ms. Ezell, I have to answer that
3 question as I answered most of your other
4 questions today, which is on advice of counsel, I
5 have to asses my rights as protected by the
6 Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment.
7 Q Did it occur quite often that
8 would lead the girl up and introduce you
9 to her and then quietly leave?
10 MR. PIKE: Form.
11 A Ma'am, I'm going to respectfully have to
12 decline to answer that question today on advice
13 of counsel. They've asked me to assert my rights
14 as protected by the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
15 Amendment. I would like to answer each and every
16 one of your questions.
17 Q Dld it also occur sometime that the girl
18 would be accompanied by the girl who brought her,
19 and the girl who brought her would go up to your
20 bedroom and massage am with her, on her initial
21 visit?
22 MR. PIKE: Form.
23 A Again? Can you -- what's the question?
24 Q I'm asking about whether or not there
25 was a sort of routine that was followed when the
1 girls would come to your home to provide the
2 massages and other sexual gratification for you.
3 I'm asking whether or not part of that routine
4 was that they would be accompanied by the girl
5 who brought them?
6 MR. PIKE: Form.
7 A I'm going to have to, on advice of
8 counsel, answer that question by asserting my
rights as protected by the Sixth, Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
Q If they were accompanied by the girl who
brought them, would it be your usual practice to
allow them to start the massage and then excuse
the girl who had brought the second girl for her
first visit?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I'm going to do my best to respond to
these questions, but my counsel has advised me
that I must assert my rights as protected by the
Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment. Ms. Ezell,
so I respectfully must decline.
Q Did you have a routine way that you
liked the massage itself to be conducted?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Ms. Ezell, I'm going to have to
1 respectfully decline to answer that question, on
2 advice of counsel, they've asked me to assert my
3 rights as protected by the Sixth. Fifth and
4 Fourteenth Amendment.
5 Q Did either Ms. or you, or the
6 girl who perhaps had been there before Instruct
7 the new girl to begin by massaging the back of
8 your legs and your back?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A I would like to respond to all your
questions. but unfortunately at least today, my
counsel has advised me I must assert my rights as
protected by the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q And did you or Ms,Mgenerally ask
the girls or instruct the girls to remove their
clothing?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Unfortunately, Ms. Ezell I have to
respectfully decline to answer that question
today. On advice of counsel, they've asked me to
assert my Sixth Amendment, Fifth Amendment and
Fourteenth Amendment right.
Q After having the back of your legs —
the feet, the back of your legs and your back
S
massaged, would you then typically turn over,
exposing yourself, laying on your back?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Ms. Ezell, I'm going to respectfully
have to decline to answer that question today,
because my counsel has asked me to assert my
Sixth Amendment, Fifth Amendment and Fourteenth
Amendment right, though I would like to answer
every one of your questions.
Q Would it be your practice at that point,
depending on the skittishness of the girl to
begin trying to fondle her breasts or rub her
vagina?
MIL. PIKE: Form.
A Ma'am, I respectfully have to decline to
answer that today, though I would like to answer
each one of these questions. My counsel has
instructed me to assert my Sixth Amendment, Fifth
Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment right.
Q Assuming the girl was ill at ease, would
it be your practice to then talk with her to try
to elicit from her, her interests, her goals, the
things that were important to her in her life?

MR. PIKE: Form.
Q Was that part of your routine?
54 (Pages 545 to 548)
U.S. Legal Support
549 551
MR. PIKE: Sony. Form.
A Ma'am, though I would like to answer
every one of your questions today, unfortunately
my counsel has advised me I must assert my rights
as protected by the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth
Amendment.
Q Would it generally be your practice, if
the girl was skittish, to perhaps wait until the
second visit to introduce a vibrator into the
routine?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Ms. Ezell. unfortunately I have to
answer that question the same way as I've
answered every one of your questions today, which
is, I would have to assert my rights protected by
the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment on
advice of counsel.
Q Would you try to calm the girl by
telling her to relax, that there was nothing
wrong with what was going on?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Ma'am, unfortunately I have to respond
to that question as I've responded to most of
your other questions here today, which is by
invoking my Sixth Amendment, Fifth Amendment and
another girl, was it your practice to pay the
procuring girl at least $200 for bringing the new
girl?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Again? Sony. Can you repeat the
question?
Q Sure. Maybe I can state it a little
better.
Did you tell the girls that you would
pay them $200 every time they brought a new
girl?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Unfortunately, Ms. Ezell, I'm going to
have to respond to that question the same way as
I've responded to most of your other questions
today. On advice of counsel, they've instructed
me to assert my Sixth Amendment, Fifth Amendment
and Fourteenth Amendment right.
Q And indeed, did you keep that promise
and either pay them directly or have Ms.
pay the procurer $200 for each new girl that she
brought?

MR. PIKE: Form.
A Unfortunately, Ms. Ezell, I have to
respond to that question respectfully the same as
1 Fourteenth Amendment right.
2 Q Assuming that the girl made it through
3 the first session, would you generally wait until
4 you had reached climax before dismissing her?
5 MR. PIKE: Form.
6 THE WITNESS: Earthquake?
7 MR. PIKE: Train. For the record a
8 train is going by.
9 A Ms. Ezell, unfortunately I have to
10 respJlgl to that question as I've responded to
11 most of the other questions here today, which is
12 I must assert my rights protected by the Sixth,
13 Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment on advice of my
14 counsel.
15 Q Would you generally pay the new girl
16 $200 for the massage, either by telling her that
17 the money was on the counter or by telling her
18 that Ms. would pay her downstairs?
19 MR. PIKE: Form.
20 A Unfortunately, Ms. Ezell, today I have
21 to respond to that question the same way I've
22 responded to all your other questions, which is
23 by invoking my Sixth Amendment, Fifth Amendment
24 and Fourteenth Amendment right.
25 Q And If that girl had been brought by
B
I responded to most of your other questions here
today. My counsel has advised me I must assert
my rights as protected by the Sixth. Fifth and
Fourteenth Amendment.
THE WITNESS: Can we take a two-minute
break?
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the video
record 3:54 p.m.
(Pause in the proceedings.)
THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Back on the video
record 3:56 p.m.
Q Did you let the girls know that the more
they let you do, the more they would be paid?

MR. PIKE: Form. Again, I'm really
trying to work with you, Ms. Ezell, but that
is... is an exact question that Mr. Horowitz
asked at the commencement of the
deposition. We are back in generalities
again, and it is repetitious. If you could,
let's try to narrow it to your client.
MS. EZELL: I'm certainly entitled to
see how my client fits into the big picture
or my clients, and whether this was part of
a pattern and whether they indeed were
treated according to a pattern or scheme or
55 (Pages 549 to 552)
U.S. Legal Support
553 555
routine. 1 pre-existing obligation beginning at 4:00
2 MR. PIKE: Okay. I just don't hear any 2 o'clock. Hold on a second, guys. So this
3 questions regarding your clients. Titers 3 deposition will be continued consistent with
4 what Pm saying. 4 various court orders.
5 Q Do you recall that the first time 5 MS. EZELL: Okay, thank you.
6 came to provide you a massage, you told her to 6 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Going off the video
7 take off her clothing, which she refused to do? 7 record 4:00 p.m.
8 MR. PIKE: Form. 8 THECOURT REPORTER: Thank you all.
9 A A.H. -- can we use names so there is no 9 Same orders as yesterday?
10 confusion here? 10 MR. EDWARDS: Yes.
11 Q A.H. Is ' " She is Jane Doe 103. 11 MR. HOROWITZ: Yes.
12 A I'm going to have to respond to that 12 MR. PIKE: Yes.
13 question, as I responded to all your other 13 MS. F7F-11 • Yes, please.
14 questions, Ms. Ezell, respectfully, and on advice 14 THE COURT REPORTER: Thank you all.
15 of counsel I have to assert my rights as 15 (Whereupon, the deposition was adjourned
16 protected by the Sixth, Fifth and Fourteenth 16 at 4:05 o'clock, p.m., sine die.)
17 Amendment. 17
18 Q And when she did refuse to do that, did 18
19 you begin to try to touch her and paw at her and 19
20 remove some of her clothing? 20
21 MIL PIKE: Form. 21
22 A Ma'am, I would respectfully -- I would 22
23 like to answer that question, as I would like to 23
24 answer most of the questions you've posed here 24
25 today. Respectfully, I'm going to have to 25
554 556
decline on advice of counsel and invoke my Sixth 1. THE STATE OF FLORIDA)
2 Amendment, Fifth Amendment and Fourteenth 2 COUNTY OF PALM BEACH)
3 Amendment right. 3 I, TERRI BECKER, a Registered
4 Over the approximately 17 months that 4 Professional Reporter and Notary Public for the
erne to your borne, did you or your agents
afrequently call her at her home number or her
State of Florida at Large, do hereby certify that
I reported the videotaped continued deposition of
JEFFREY EPSTEIN, the DEFENDANT, called by the 7 cell number arranging for encounters, arranging 8 PLAINTIFF in the 
above.enntied action; that the
8 for her to come to your home to provide the 9 witness was duly sworn by me; that the foregoing
9 massage and sexual favors, sometimes as much as 10 pages, numbered from 336 to 560, inclusive,
10 twice a day? 11 constitute a we record of the deposition by
11 MR. PIKE: Form. 12 said witness.
12 Q Let's break it up. 13 I further certify that I am not attorney
13 During the 17 months that she came to 14 or counsel of any of the panics, nor a relative
14 your home, did It frequently happen that you or 15 or employee of any attorney or counsel connected
with the action, nor financially interested in 15 one of your agents would call ahead of time to 17 the action. 16 tell 
her that you would be coming to town? 18
WITNESS MY HAND and official seal in the
17 MR. PIKE: Form. 19 City of West Rahn Beach, County of Palm Beach,
18 A Ma'am, I'm going to respectfully have to 20 State of Florida, this 19th day of Apra2010. -..a. 19 decline to answer
that question on advice of 21 _ $
20 counsel. Theyve instructed me to assert my
21 Sixth Amendment, Fifth Amendment and Fourteenth 22 TERRI BECKER, Registere
22 Amendment right. Professional Reporter and
23 MR. PIKE: Ms. Ezell, as you know we've 23 Notary Public, State of Florida
24 discussed this at the commencement of 24
at Large. My Commission expires
March 13,2011.
25 today's deposition, that we had a 25
56 (Pages 553 to 556)
U.S. Legal Support
557 559
1 THE STATE OF FLORIDA) 1 ERRATA SHEET
2 COUNTY OF PALM BEACH) 2 In Re: JANE DOE V. EPSTEIN
3 3 DO NOT WRITE ON TRANSCRIPT
ENTER CHANGES HERE.
4 4
5 The foregoing certificate was 5 PAGE LINE CHANGE REASON
6 acknowledged before me this 6
7 day of 2010. 7
8 8
9 9
10 10
11 12
12 13
13 14
14 15
Notary Public, State of Florida. JEFFREY EPSTEIN
15 My commission No. 16
Expires March 13, 2011. 18
16 THE STATE. OF FLORIDA)
17 19 COUNTY OF PALM BEACH)
18 20 I DO HEREBY CERTIFY THAT JEFFREY EPSTEIN
19 appeared before me and gated that he has mad
21 his deposition; further, ant this Errata Sheet
vas signed in my presence on this day
of 2010. 22
22 23
24 24
25 25
558 560
1, JEFFREY EPSTEIN, do hereby U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
Resestercel Professional Reporters
2 certify that I have read the foregoing transcript 2 444 West Railroad Avant
3 of my deposition given on April 14,2010, that 3
Suits 300

• COI
4 together with the correction page attached hereto
S noting changes in form or substance, if any, it April
6 is true and correct. 6 SURMA/I.CR.1770N LUTT1ER & COLEMAN
7 Senyzn Bou4•aed
Stet 400
West Pales Bea* DON& 33401
B
JEFFREY EPSTEIN ATTENTION: M/CHAEL MKS. ESQ.
9 9
In Re. JANE DOE V. EPSTEIN
10 10
Deposition of. IFJPREY EPSTEIN
11 11
12 12
Dear Mr Pikes
13 13
Slaw would haw avoid thm yeti may
I do hereby certify that the deposition
of JEFFREY EPSTEIN was submitted to the witness
hew the mottos mad ad ri per:or copy of dm
depotitiort for to comenioeue enclosed
herewith you wIE find Si Ernes Shea for the
16 for reading and signing; that after he had stated 16
wecesf use in emend any changes to the
**Call*
17 to the undersigned Notary Public that he had read 17 Thank see for seat lameoPt OINNIOn
16 Carnally yours.
18 and examined his deposition, he signed the same U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
19 in the presence of the undersigned authority on 19
20 the day of 2010. 21
TERRI BECKER, ROOM:rid
Nofetsiond Rammer. Nosey
21 Pubic. State of Florida at
22 22 term. My carreistrion maims
Mott 1).1011.
23 23
24 24
CC Admit Itorowila,
Bradley Edwin* EM
Kedierine Fall, Hap 25 25
57 (Pages 557 to 560)
U.S. Le al Su ort
EFTA00003116 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-23)
SEE iNSTAILATION INSTRUCTIONS
CONNECTING TO NE~ SWAY.
u 1YtI@.ii•7ii}1lFN34Ik₹91
iffitr,Pligefl4T.fFf..
CONNECT CMY TO GROUNCED OUTLET.
APPARATET A1A TRXCPIES JOIRTe STIKKONTAKT
APPARATEN SKAM ANSIUTAS iNl >MAT
NATIu TAG
WEE CH WIEN AVA SUOIAKOSKEMMILA
RARUSTETTWN nstOR RIAAN
APPARATETS STIKPROP SKAL TILSWITES EN
STPICNTAX1 NED JORD, SOM GIVER
fORRITCRISE fit STKPROPPENS 1010
iritfiliffP±}11 0t3Fli3f»
J1,1Æ.-.1911ø2.10,3IM ,A
8205824TV
91111W : w ~km.
Noutarerr mOOCUM
INNwIll eRsvet 4.61A
«AMU / Merit**
~X IN ~VS.» /*MS& CAN KES-3 ~TN OMIT 10 20160/1509
CO.."4 imesser 16 [ (4ye
jg g*""• 0401511 «two 08 WI. - -"Fe e 451/1340~2016 01 ])41
CE 191.73 ~Sap., allrahlS” (146401   arm mr_
5115 351 0510) 0011
Ara."
@
~v.
ø HP Slimline 260-a010 DT PC US
Serial No. CNV7160050
Product No. V8P51AA#ABA
Model No. 260-a010 Limited Warranty: ly/ly/Oy
(V3T9SAV)
BID= 16VVW3RS7607t$SABA4DABA
FeatureByte= 3E3K3N3Q4C4h6J6Z6b7B7K7P777W
aBapaqasauazb7bhbpbzebdUclpdqe
Jegey.TE
BU IDS UMA Pent J3710
ammatana 3/54.1 RT1.15, 23BE/S
~WM reCIO' Tx2•RTUTPTSE
IC 6317A-NTaT23sE
SOT RCPRERT/3-0V6
PIC C.120/7
QfrA IIP!AMITEL
C40.014•111,111
IDA81100•10s
00105202
«eccAr•aNNNT

5. ..11C1Ibl... :ea »RE' t
&
CE ,cl<7.035.,2YASM
NOS S
ISIP.CR/. 1.111'15RiLt723BENP
352 555AD1 C.034
9 www.hp.comlgolsupportassistant
EFTA00003858 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007558 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007070 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2006
(inferred timestamp: 2026-01-23 12:53:05)
phone bill covering 2006
EFTA00007097 (Jmail)
 [legal] grand jury proceedings
EFTA00159250 (Jmail)
 [legal] Jane Doe #2 v. Jeffrey Epstein: deposition of witness
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 WeWork [tech] infamously stupid failed temporary office space company [guardian] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00810510 (Jmail)
 [tech] Valar Ventures Fall 2016 Update
(inferred date: 2026-01-24)
VALAR Summer 2017 Update
VALAR SUMMER 2017 UPDATE
Fund 1 Review
FUND I PORTFOLIO UPDATE
Fund 1 continues to perform well, with a 3.5x net multiple and 34.4% net IRR as of
June 30, 2017. As is our practice, the best investments - Transfenvise and Xero -
account for over 50% of the Fund's deployed capital (and the lionshare of its gains).
In the second half of 2016, we began selling down our position in Xero, and we
accelerated that in 2017. While we continue to be bullish on Xero's prospects, our
initial investment was made nearly seven years ago, and we felt it was time to start
returning capital to ow investors. We have now exited over 90% of our position,
with the only remaining piece being the final investment we made into the company
in October 2013.
Valar Fund 1 invested $31.4M in Xero. Gross distributions to date are $119M with
a remaining stake of $5.5M.
Transfenvise is now a $145M annual revenue business, with monthly volumes
across the network in excess of $1.58, growing nearly 100% year over year, and
profitable. They are set to be the global leader for consumer money transfer in the
coming years. The company predicts they will hit >20% EBITDA margin in 2019,
generating $80M+ in cash.
Over the past 7 years, Transfenvise has built the infrastructure to solve money
transfer for consumers. Now they are well positioned to use that infrastructure to
address the same problem for businesses and banks across a $200B revenue market,
essentially replacing the correspondent banking model. Larger customers, including
some banks (such as N26), have started moving to that new infrastructure. So
really, they are just getting started.
The most recent financing news is that the company has accepted a Series E term
sheet to raise $65M led by Institutional Venture Partners (IVP) at a $1.6 billion pre-
money valuation. The purpose of this fundraise is to bring the company's balance
sheet to the level where they have enough cash to cover nine months of operating
expenses. The total transaction size (including secondaries) may end up being quite
a bit larger, as there is significant interest from many other large buyers. This
transaction is expected to close within the next month.
Valar Fund I has invested $22.2M in Transfenvise, which is now valued at
$252.7M.
Fund 1 Highlights
Inception: October 2010
Capital Commitments: $100.0M
Current FMV: $411.8M
Multiple (Gross & Net): 4.33x / 3.36x
IRR (Gross & Net): 43.7% / 36.3%
% of Fund Invested / Reserved: 100%
DPI: 1.2x
I I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR SUMMER 2017 UPDATE
Fund 2 Review
FUND 2 PORTFOLIO UPDATE
Fund 2 is now approximately 90% called and deployed, with a significant majority
of that amount invested in three companies - Breather, N26 and Kalo (formerly
Lystable). An update on these major investments — and a few notes on some of the
Fund's smaller investments - follows.
In our last update, we announced that Breather had raised a Series C round led by
Venky Ganesan of Menlo Ventures in November 2016. Google Ventures
subsequently invested $5 million at the beginning of 2017 as part of an extension of
that round, bringing the companies post-money valuation to $252M. In the
following seven months (through June 2017), revenue has nearly doubled and they
have opened 143 more spaces, bringing the total number of Breathers worldwide to
433. Most of these new spaces were opened in their existing core cities of New
York, San Francisco, London, Toronto and Los Angeles.
Since reorienting around B4B (Breather for Business) and implementing
commercial space utilization standards (starting Q1 2016), they have opened larger
spaces that allow them to serve bigger groups and a broader range of use cases. This
approach has more than doubled company-wide square footage since September of
last year. In addition, since January 2017, user cohorts have had larger than ever
initial reservations and consistent repurchase pattern. The initial transaction of a
new customer is now $320 and second and third month cumulative spend levels are
at record-highs. With both first booking value continuing to rise along with six
month retention rates, projected LTV has continued to grow. Q1 LTV averaged
$1,014 which was a 12% increase over Q4.
While Breather has an extremely high NPS score (north of 70), which drives
significant organic demand, its CEO felt that their brand marketing and demand
generation capabilities needed upgrading. To address this, over the first six months
of 2017 the company has revamped its marketing program and hired a new VP of
Marketing to further build the demand side and amplify Breather's brand with both
consumers and businesses. We expect the results of this initiative to dramatically
decrease the time a new unit takes to ramp up to full utilization, even when the
company is adding units at a high rate.
Breather should continue to grow well through the Summer and be positioned for
another strong fundraise in the Fall. Their Series D valuation will be above the point
at which the main funds would participate (and Fund 2 is already at its
concentration limit). We plan to make our pro-rata available to ow investors
through an SPV, similar to those we have put together for Transferwise and Stash in
the past.
Valar Fund 2 has invested $25.5M in Breather, which is now valued at $42.3M.
Fund 2 Highlights
Inception: January 2015
Capital Commitments: $102.3M
Current FMV: $139.5M
Multiple (Gross & Net): I.57x 11.34x
IRR (Gross & Net): 36.2% 127.9%
% of Fund Invested / Reserved: 100%
2 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR SUMMER 2017 UPDATE
Fund 2 Review
At the end of 2016, N26 received its full banking license from BaFin (the German
banking regulator) and transitioned all of its customers off of their partner,
Wirecard's, platform and onto their own. The focus since the start of 2017 has been
on building out their internal systems and the customer-facing product suite,
through internal development as well as through integrations with other startups
(e.g., N26 customers make foreign currency transfers using Transferwise inside the
N26 app).
Offering its customers a wide range of financial products allows N26 to capture a
greater share of wallet, and unit economics have improved rapidly as a result. In Q4
2016, the company was earning approximately E29 per customer; that has risen to
E50 per customer in May 2017, roughly the current level where a customer is
profitable for N26. As the company scales, they will breakeven at a lower point by
driving down variable costs (e.g., negotiating a better deal with MasterCard on
interchange fees). N26 believes it can drive revenue per customer into the high E50s
by the end of 2017, and projects monetization per user in the high €70s by the end
of 2018. As a result of its rapid acquisition of customers, N26 has seen a revenue
ramp of nearly 3X in the first six months of this year. We have seen breakout
revenue acceleration like this before (with Transferwise) and believe N26 has
similar potential to become a fintech giant.
In addition to improving unit economics, N26 has been expanding its geographic
reach. The company now has over 400,000 customers (-200,000 financially active)
and operates in 17 EU countries with plans to expand into the UK in the near term.
Planning is also underway for a potential US launch in 2018. While the UK and
USA are competitive and enormous markets, we believe N26 is well positioned to
compete in these markets; it has a huge head start on all the other European
neobanks and offers a superior product experience and cost structure to incumbent
banks in all geographies.
Given N26's ambitions to grow quickly and expand into the UK and USA, we
expect N26 will raise a Series C round in Q4 this year at a valuation that is above
the level where it makes sense for Valar main funds to participate. Again, the plan
is to make ow pro-rata available to our investors through an SPV.
Including the most recent financing round, which has been agreed to and is
expected to close later this quarter as soon as regulatory approval is received, Valar
Fund 2 will have invested $ I 5.0M in N26, which will be valued at $40.6M.
Between Funds 2 and 3, Valar will own approximately 16.3% of N26 and be the
company's largest shareholder.
Lystable formally changed its name to Kalo earlier this year. The rebranding takes
care of a trademark dispute with a UK company and better aligns the company's
brand and product.
The big win for Kalo since our last update is that, after a year of Airbnb using Kalo
across 10 of its teams, Kalo has secured a global deal to roll out its product to every
team at Airbnb. This is particularly notable given that, while Airbnb has a large
number of employees (around 3500), it has an even larger number of freelancers
(approximately 4200). Moreover, Airbnb spends $15-25 million per year on
freelancers who manage over 2500 tasks per month.
Once Kalo has been fully rolled out across Airbnb, the only way someone can
freelance with Airbnb is through Kalo, Kalo will be the system of record for all
Airbnb freelancers and more than half of Airbnb's workforce will be reliant on the
Kalo platform. In short, Kalo will be critical to Airbnb's day-to-day operations.
This global deal is a big step forward for the company and Kalo has a substantial
pipeline of smaller and larger size deals it hopes to close this year.
3 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR SUMMER 2017 UPDATE
Fund 2 Review
Granify has continued to solidify its enterprise sales team and revenue has started
showing the results of the effort to improve their sales capability that began in late
2016. Revenue in May was —$250k and the company feels they can double that by
October. If they are able to hit their targets, Granify should be profitable by year-
end.
Valar Fund 2 has invested $6.3M in Granify, which is being held at cost.
EyeEm operates in a difficult and shrinking market for paid stock photography. The
company has been unable to achieve sufficient scale in its own photo marketplace
to warrant further investment in the business. The positive news is that the
computer vision technology the team has built to automatically classify photos has
been the subject of considerable interest from larger companies. EyeEm and its
board have determined that a trade sale may be the best outcome at this point and
that process is evolving.
Valar Fund 2 has invested $10.4M in EyeEm which is now valued at 11.2M
(change due to FX).
Even is still heavily in product development — they are building a bank app for
hourly workers that can use machine learning to automatically budget for its users
and provide short term loans to smooth income. The company's first customer is
Walmart, who pays them a fee per user per month. Even plans on rolling out with
Walmart nationwide in the Fall.
Valar Fund 2 has invested $4.5M in Even, which is being held at cost.
Tradelt is in the process of signing Master Services Agreements with Fidelity and
several other massive financial institutions. These deals would put Tradelt in the
position of managing all API access for these clients. Once implemented, if a
developer wants to build something on top of a Fidelity API, they will have to go
through Tradelt to do it. This is a huge opportunity for the company.
Valar Fund 2 has invested $3.7M in Tradelt, which is now valued at 4.6M.
Since our last update, Homie has become licensed as both a mortgage broker and a
real estate broker, in order to more fully facilitate its for-sale-by-owner customer
wedge and begin to increase monetization. Now, whenever buyers and sellers use
Homie's software to transact, they can seamlessly find a mortgage through the
service as well. This provides a substantial revenue stream for the company.
Revenues have begun ramping nicely, and the company should be well positioned
to raise a sizeable Series A this Fall.
Valar Fund 2 has invested $2.8M in Homie, which is being held at cost.
4 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR SUMMER 2017 UPDATE
Fund 3 Review
FUND 3 PORTFOLIO UPDATE
Fund 3 is now 60% called and deployed into six major investments and a handful of
smaller, seed stage companies. We expect that the substantial majority, if not all, of
the remaining capital will be invested in follow-on financings in these existing
portfolio companies.
So far, Stash has commanded the largest share of Fund 3, with just over 20% of the
Fund invested in the company's Series A, Series B, and Series C financings.
The big news for Stash is they just raised S40M at a $200M pm-money valuation in
a Series C funding led by Coatue Management, with participation from Valar,
Goodwater and Jim Breyer. The company has now raised a total of $78 million in
less than two years. Coatue has been following the company's progress for some
time and wanted to be sure they would win the deal before it hit the open market.
"Stash is disrupting the financial services industry by removing bathers and making
investing more approachable and accessible to the 100 million-plus Americans on
the sidelines," said Coatue's Founder and Portfolio Manager Philippe Laffont. "Its
rapid growth in a short period of time shows that Stash has found a way to
transform how Americans manage their money and gain financial independence.-
Stash has continued to grow extremely quickly. It currently serves over 865,000
customers; adding more than 25,000 per week while keeping its blended CAC
under $16. In our last update we shared the company's audacious goal of reaching
1,000,000 users by the end of September 2017. We are pleased to report that the
company is in fad ahead of schedule and should hit that figure six weeks early,
around mid-August. We believe they are growing faster than any competitor while
maintaining engagement metrics that are the best in the market.
The following graph (excerpted from Stash's marketing materials) helps illustrate
the company's traction vis-i-vis other well-known players in the space:
Adoption Curve
Speed of Erna/NA and a kite lAM hos sowed us to goh tro0NA 0NI0Ny.
Omit App Downloads since twitch
STASH
robinhccd
digit A Betterment
Fund 3 Highlights
Inception: July 2016
Capital Commitments: $103.9M
Current FMV: 894.8M
Multiple (Gross & Net): 1.41x / 1.26x
IRR (Gross & Net): 208.5%/ 146.8%
% of Fund Invested / Reserved: 90%
5 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR SUMMER 2017 UPDATE
Fund 3 Review
Stash is planning on quickly rolling out new products to its customers. Stash Retire,
which allows users to save and invest their money in an IRA, is already in beta and
will be fully released this summer. And a checking account and debit card product
are on the roadmap for the end of this year.
In terms of customer growth and fundraising velocity, Stash is reminiscent of
Transferwise and N26. We have high hopes that the opportunity in front of them is
as big.
Valar Fund 3 has invested approximately $21.8M in Stash, which is now valued at
$46.6M.
Octane Lending is the second largest position in Fund 3 at this point. Octane is a
technology-enabled lender focused on secured consumer lending markets,
beginning with powersports (motorcycles, ATVs, UTVs, etc).
Octane initially launched as a marketplace for powersports loans, similar to what
Dealertrack does for the automobile industry. Octane observed that there was
limited competition to provide loans to buyers who had near-prime credit scores
(550-650 FICO) and if they built their own underwriting model they could
efficiently generate high volumes of attractive loans. Octane launched Roadrunner
Financial in June 2016 to be a direct lender and has been ramping up origination
volume over the last few months.
We met the company through a referral from Wes Barton and Keith Hamlin of
Third Prime Ventures, old friends of lames' from their days as lawyers at Skadden
Arps. We immediately felt that Jason Guss, the CEO, is a special entrepreneur.
Andrew affectionately refers to him as a "Terminator Robot sent from SkyNet."
He is one of the most detail obsessed and knowledgeable entrepreneurs we have
met in our career.
Although Octane is currently exploiting a profitable niche within secured lending,
we believe Jason can build the company into a diversified giant over the coming
years.
Octane Lending has raised -428M in equity capital from VCs, including $12.5M
from Valar, and $95M in warehouse lines from Macquarie Group and other
financial institutions.
We are pleased to be working on Octane with Roger Ehrenberg from IA Ventures,
who sits on the board of Octane as well as the Transferwise board with us.
Valar Fund 3 has invested $13.2M in Octane Lending, which is now valued at
13.5M (the change in valuation is due to the small amount of secondary shares we
purchased from an early investor at a minor discount).
One of Fund 3's first investments was a seed check into Qonto, an SME focused
neobank based in Paris. The company was founded by Alexander Prot (whose
father was formerly the Chairman of BNP Paribas) and Steve Anavi, repeat
entrepreneurs and co-founders who grew up together and have previously exited a
company together.
They started Qonto out of the belief that banking for startups and small businesses
in France is hopelessly broken. Dominated by Credit Agicole and BNP, the
customer experience is even worse than with consumer banking. Every time they
needed to ask for something from their bank, it was costing them a lot of money and
was a slow and analog process. Qonto is conceptually similar to N26, but
specifically geared to the needs of SMEs.
6 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR SUMMER 2017 UPDATE
Fund 3 Review
We believe the environment in Europe is quite good for new banks if they can get
started quickly and build a head start on the competition. The regulators are in favor
of increasing competition and will grant a de novo license. The local incumbents
are large and unfocused, and a lack of competition over many decades has left them
with a customer experience that is inefficient and expensive.
We were impressed by the level of execution we saw from the Qonto team and led
their Series A round in January. They launched to the public in June and the initial
response is promising.
Valar Fund 3 has invested $8.4M in Qonto, which is now valued at I0.6M
Recent Insurance Investments
"Formula for startup success: Find large highly fragmented industry with low NPS;
vertically integrate a solution to simplify value product" - Keith Rabois (our good
friend and a co-investor in Even).
The insurance market is huge, insurance premiums are roughly $2.4 trillion dollars
per year in the U.S. and Europe. However, it is still dominated by paper processes,
structural inhibition to innovation and incentives to cut costs by downgrading the
customer experience (for example, by making claims a hassle). Entrepreneurs that
manage to navigate the massive regulatory complexity and build the skill set
required to operate at a high level in the industry, combined with investors patient
enough to support the companies over the long-haul, will create huge businesses.
The insurance industry is too large and built on systems too archaic for any result
other than massive change.
We have been thinking about insurance and talking to entrepreneurs in the space for
several years, without finding an investment that made it all the way through our
process. As it happens, after years of turning down good opportunities, we found
two compelling companies almost simultaneously, Jetty and Coya. In the business
of insurance, the most difficult and valuable thing to achieve is effective
distribution and customer acquisition. There are many paths to reach these goals,
starting with the way the company is structured.
Coya is based in Berlin. We met the company through an introduction from Max
Levchin's firm, SciFi Ventures. SciFi was doing a deep dive on the insurance
industry and wanted our help from our European network in reference checking the
entrepreneurs. Andrew Shaw, the CEO, was previously the original data science
employee at Kreditech, a well-known European consumer loan business. His
partner, Peter Hagen, was previously the CEO of Vienna Insurance Group.
Together they have the magic fintech combo of one person who can write beautiful
code and the other person who deeply understands how this complex industry
actually functions. Andrew and Peter decided that in the German market, there is an
opportunity to capture more value by becoming a fully licensed new carrier. Once
licensed, Coya will build, sell, and service several insurance products, beginning
with rental P&C policies and expanding to various specialty add-ons (e.g., bicycles,
jewelry). They will operate in-house a number of departments: product
development, underwriting, sales, marketing, claims, and finance/investment. They
should have structurally higher margins through cutting out most traditional brokers
from their distribution funnel and applying the sophisticated analysis learned at
Kreditech to their own underwriting models. The license is issued by BaFin, the
same German regulator that granted N26 its banking license. BaFin's familiarity
with Valar was a significant advantage in our winning the Series A lead.
7 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR SUMMER 2017 UPDATE
Fund 3 Review
Jetty is based in New York City, and we met the entrepreneurs through
introductions from our friends at SV Angel and BoxGroup. Mike Rudoy and Luke
Cohler have had careers in technology and consulting and saw an opportunity to
apply their backgrounds in design and marketing to the P&C market in the United
States. The company is set up as a Managing General Agency or MGA. An MGA is
an insurance business set up through a fronting program with another carrier that
lends its license and regulatory reserves to the MGA for a fee. Jetty has complete
responsibility for product design and pricing, similar to a full carrier. The company
underwrites, quotes, binds, and services policies up to a specific amount. Jetty's
launch suite includes two traditional insurance products, Renters & Condo/Co-op,
as well as Jetty Passport, a pair of revolutionary renter services that help tenants get
in the door and help landlords drive occupancy. Jetty Passport is a pair of credit-
based-underwriting surety bonds which replace traditional security deposits and
lease guaranty, indemnifying the landlord and preserving Jetty's right to recover.
They have negotiated distribution agreements with several large residential property
portfolios owned by Blackrock.
Both Jetty and Coya are in the very earliest stages, so there aren't a lot of metrics to
evaluate yet. They are innovating on the sales channel for distributing insurance
products first, by utilizing mobile and point of sale channels (instead of through
agents in-person or over the phone) as well as offering shorter duration and more
granular products (e.g., Jetty Passport). Over time they can collect far more data on
their customers and utilize big data and machine learning techniques to improve
underwriting models far above what incumbents are able to. We're excited to work
with these teams as they transform the insurance business.
Velar Fund 3 has invested SRAM in Jetty and $6.3M in Coya, both of which are
being held at cost.
This document is confidential, trade secret, and not for further circulation. This document is informational and is not 
an offer or solicitation to buy, sell or
hold any securities. Except where otherwise indicated,
"Fund I" refers to all funds and investment vehicles managed by Valar Ventures Management LLC prior to the formation of 
Valar Global Fund II LP, on an aggregate
basis, "Fund 2" refers to Valar Global Fund II
LP and Velar Global Principals Fund II LP, on an aggregate basis, and "Fund 3" refers to Velar Global Fund III LP and 
Valar Global Principals Fund Ill LP, on an
aggregate basis. Figures presented are unaudited
estimates in USD as of 68012017, including signed deals that are expected to close in Q3. Gross figures do not include 
the impact of fees, expenses and carry,
and net figures are calculated by reducing gross
investment profits by a flat 25% for hypothetical management fees, expenses, and carry.
S I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR SUMMER 2017 UPDATE
Fund 4 Preview
FUND 4 FUNDRAISING
As Fund 3 is largely invested and reserved for, we are formally entering the market
for Valar Fund 4. We are currently preparing the marketing materials, data room
and legal documents (pitch deck, PPM, LPA, DDQ, etc.) and will be making those
documents available over the next month. Our intention is to have conversations
with each of you starting after Labor Day and close on our existing investor&
commitments in December of this year. Consistent with our past practice, the
official time stamp for the new fund will be in January, making Fund 4 a vintage
2018 fund. Our expectation is that the Fund will be between $100M and $150M in
capital commitments.
We appreciate your continuing support and partnership in Valar. We hope you all
have an enjoyable summer and we look forward to speaking with each of you in the
coming weeks and months.
Fund 4 Terms:
Target Capital Commitments: $100M - $150MM
Anticipated Deployment Period: 2018 - 2020
Target Fund Return: 4x - 6x
Due Date for Signed Sub Does: December 2017
Anticipated Closing: January 2018
9 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR FALL 2016 UPDATE
Fund 1 Key Drivers
'l TransferWise
Headquarters:
Securities Held:
Initial Investment Date:
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Multiple:
Headquarters:
Security Held:
London
Series A Preferred Shares
Series B Preferred Shares
Series C Preferred Shares
1/8/2013
$22.2M
$252.7M
11.4x
Wellington
Ordinary Shares
Initial Investment Date: 10/28/2010
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
$31.4M
$124.3M
Multiple: 4.0x
Company Description:
TransferWise is a peer-to-peer currency exchange service that brings institutional pricing to
retail customers by coordinating transfer needs within countries across a large user base.
Recent Financing History:
TransferWise recently signed a term sheet for a $65M Series E financing round led by
Institutional Ventures Partners (IVP). Previously, the company closed on a $58M Series C
financing round led by Andreessen Horowitz in December 2014, and a $26M Series D
financing round led by Baillie Gifford in February 2016.
Company Description:
Xero is the leading cloud-based accounting software provider globally for SMBs.
Recent Financing History:
Fund 1 initially invested in Xero in October 2010 at a $98M valuation, with significant
follow-on investments by the Fund in February 2012, November 2012 and October 2013.
Over the past year, Fund I exited over 90% of its position at a blended $2B valuation for
aggregate proceeds of $118.8M, including through a $30 million block trade with
Technology Crossover Ventures (TCV).
10 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR FALL 2016 UPDATE
Fund 2 Core Investments
® breather
Headquarters:
Securities Held:
Initial Investment Date:
Valar Cost Basis:
Valar Current FMV:
Multiple:
N26
Headquarters:
Securities Held:
Initial Investment Date:
Valar Cost Basis:
Valar Current FMV:
Multiple:
Montreal and New York
Series B Preferred Shares
Series C Preferred Shares
9/10/2015
$25.5M
$42.3M
1.7x
Berlin
Preferred A Shares
Preferred B Shares
4/24/2015
$14.9M
$40.6M
2.7x
Company Description:
Breather provides a network of private, professional meeting rooms designed for work,
meetings and to focus.
Recent Financing History:
Breather completed a $42M Series C financing in October 2016 at a $210M pre-money
valuation led by Menlo Ventures, with participation from Google Ventures, Valar, RRE,
Real Ventures, Slow Ventures and others. Prior to that, Valar led the company's Series B
financing round, investing a total of $17M in two tranches that closed in September 2015
and April 2016 at a pre-money valuation of $80M.
Company Description:
N26is a new European bank focused on building an innovative mobile-first banking
experience.
Recent Financing History:
Currently, N26 has agreed to a E 15M Series B extension round at a E250M pre-money
valuation led by Valar Ventures and Hedosophia. In June 2016, N26 completed a €35M
Series B financing at a €120M pre-money valuation, led by Horizons Ventures, with
participation from Valar, Earlybird and others. Previously, Valar led the company's Series
A financing in April 2015 at a E38M pregnancy valuation.
II I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR FALL 2016 UPDATE
Fund 2 Core Investments
kalo Headquarters:
Security Held:
Initial Investment Date:
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Nlultiple:
EyeEm
Headquarters:
Securities Held:
London and San Francisco
Series A Preferred Stock
5/6/2015
$12.4M
$16.5M
1.3x
Berlin
Series B Preferred Shares
Convertible Notes
Initial Investment Date: 4/14/2015
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Multiple:
$10.4M
$11.1M (change due to FX)
1.1x
Company Description:
Businesses increasingly rely on external workforces of freelancers and contractors, often
without an effective way to keep track of them. Kalo (formerly Lystable) provides an
elegant platform to simplify every step of these workers — from onboarding to internal
reviews to payment.
Recent Financing History:
In March 2017, Kalo closed on a $10 million Series A extension round led by Valar
Ventures, with participation from Goldcrest Investments, Kindred, Max Levchin and others.
Kalo had previously closed on an $1 I.3M Series A financing round in June 2016 also led by
Valar. The convertible notes held by Fund 2 from Kalo's prior seed financing rounds were
convened into Series A Preferred Shares in the round, at a blended 2.3x multiple.
Company Description:
EyeEm is a marketplace for commercial photography. The company's highly engaged user
base and machine-curated image library provide a more valuable sourcing channel for
commercial clients than traditional stock photography databases.
Recent Financing History:
In April 2015, EyeEm closed on an El IM Series B round led by Valar Ventures, alongside
Earlybird and Wellington Partners, among others. Existing investors have since collectively
added E5.9M in bridge financing rounds.
12 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR FALL 2016 UPDATE
Fund 2 Core Investments
Even
Headquarters: Oakland
Security Held: Series A Preferred Stock
Investment Date: 3/11/2016
Valar Cost Basis: $4.5M
Current FMV: $4.5M
Nlultiple: 1.0x
granify
Headquarters: Edmonton
Security Held: Series A Preferred Shares
Convertible Note
Investment Date: 3/2/2015
Valar Cost Basis: $6.3M
Current FMV: $6.3M
Multiple: 1.0x
Company Description:
Even is a financial app that ensures hourly workers always get at least their average pay. By
offering consistency, Even helps its customers save more and use expensive payday lenders
less.
Recent Financing History:
In March 2016, Even closed on a $9M Series A financing round, led by Valar Ventures,
with participation from Khosla Ventures, Box Group, Allen & Company and others.
Company Description:
Granify maximizes revenue for online retailers by identifying shoppers that aren't going to
buy and changing their mind — while they're still on the site — by harnessing the power of
real-time data analytics and machine learning.
Recent Financing History:
Granify closed on a $7M Series A financing round in March 2015 led by Valar Ventures.
The convertible notes held by Valar Ventures prior to the Series A financing were convened
into Series A Preferred Shares in the round, at a 3.7x multiple. Existing investors have since
added $800k in bridge financing to the company.
13 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR FALL 2016 UPDATE
Fund 2 Core Investments
TRADEITIN
Headquarters:
Security Held:
Initial Investment Date:
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Multiple:
homie
Headquarters:
Security Held:
Initial Investment Date:
New York
Common Stock
Series Seed Preferred Stock
4/2/2015
$3.7M
$4.6M
1.2x
Salt Lake City
Series Seed Preferred Stock
Convertible Note
3/17/2016
Valar Cost Basis: $2.8M
Current FMV: $2.8M
Multiple: 1.0x
Company Description:
Trading Ticket (dba Tradelt) facilitates quick and secure online stock trading through
any website or app.
Recent Financing History:
After participating in Tradelt's $1M pre-seed round in 2015, Valar has led two Series Seed
rounds totaling $7M, with participation from Citi Ventures, Sandy Robertson, Point72 and
others.
Company Description:
Homie is a peer-to-peer marketplace for buying and selling homes. By leveraging
technology and taking the transaction process online, Homie saves buyers and sellers
thousands in broker commissions.
Recent Financing History:
Valar led Homie's $3.8M Series Seed round in March 2016, with participation from Peak
Ventures and others. Most recently, Valar participated in a $3M convertible note round in
March 2017.
14 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR FALL 2016 UPDATE
Fund 3 Core Investments
STASH Headquarters:
Securities Held:
Initial Investment Date:
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Multiple:
New York
Series A Preferred Shares
Series B Preferred Shares
Series C Preferred Shares
8/5/2016
$21.8M
$46.6M
2.1x
Octane Lending
Headquarters:
Security Held:
Initial Investment Date:
Valar Cost Basis:
Current FMV:
Multiple:
New York
Series A Preferred Stock
4/7/17
$13.2M
$13.5M
1.0x
Company Description:
Stash is a community for people who want to start investing and who don't want to rely on a
black box service to do it for them. It's a platform to help people take ownership and
become confident investors. Starting with as little as $5, Stash investors build a portfolio of
investments that aligns with their interests, beliefs and goals.
Recent Financing History:
Stash recently closed on a $40M Series C financing, at a $200M pre-money valuation, led
by Coatue Management, with participation by Valar Ventures, Goodwater Capital, Jim
Breyer and others. Valar also led Stash's $25M Series B Preferred financing round in
November 2016, and co-led the company's $9M Series A Preferred financing round in
August 2016.
Company Description:
Octane Lending is a technology-enabled lender focused on secured consumer lending
markets starting with powersports.
Recent Financing History:
In April 2017, Valar led a $15M Series A extension round with participation from several
existing investors, including IA Ventures, Contour and Third Prime.
IS I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR FALL 2016 UPDATE
Fund 3 Core Investments
X qonto
Headquarters: Paris Company Description:
Security Held: Series Seed Ordinary Shares Qonto aims to become the next generation bank for entrepreneurs, SMEs and 
startups by
Series A Ordinary Shares providing an online service that will allow them to create an account in less than five
Initial Investment Date: 9/30/2016 minutes.
Valar Cost Basis: $8.4M Recent Financing History:
Current FMV: $10.6M in March 2017, Valar led Qonto's E10M Series A financing with participation from Alven
Multiple: 1.3x Capital, after Valar co-led the Series Seed round with Alven Capital in September 2016.
Jetty
Headquarters: New York
Securities Held: Series A Preferred Stock
Initial Investment Date: 7/17/17
Valar Cost Basis: $8.1M
Current FMV: $8.1M
Multiple: 1.0x
Company Description:
Jetty is a new kind of insurance company designed to help people in cities reach their goals
faster by removing obstacles and risks. Its mission is to protect its customers against
setbacks of all kinds, from fire and theft to wasted time and money.
Recent Financing History:
In July 2017, Valar Ventures led Jetty's $11.5M Series A financing, with participation from
Ribbit Capital, BoxGroup, SV Angel and others.
16 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
VALAR FALL 2016 UPDATE
Fund 3 Core Investments
COYA Headquarters: Berlin
Security Held: Series A Preferred Shares
Investment Date: July 2017
Valar Cost Basis: $6.3M
Current FMV: $6.3M
Nlultiple: 1.0x
Company Description:
The insurance industry is broken with its legacy infrastructure, organizational design and
products built for brokers rather than around the customer. Coya is a fiillstack European
insurance challenger that has redesigned the insurance value chain working backwards from
the customer to offer scalable protection at the point of need with personalized predictive
risk management and simple, transparent, personal insurance designed to manage life's risks
and join the customer's journey.
Recent Financing History:
Valar Ventures led Coya's €7.25M Series A financing in July 2017, with participation from
Ribbit, E.ventures and others.
17 I CONFIDENTIAL & TRADE SECRET VALAR
Interview with Brandon Krieg. founder of Stash app that lets you invest in the stock market for $5 - Business Insider
BUSINESS
INSIDER
Stash, now valued at $240 million, lets
anyone start investing in the stock market
with just $5
AVERY HARTMANS
JUL. 13, 2017, 2:35 PM
Brandon Krieg spent more than 15 years working as
a trader on Wall Street. But he left his career for the
startup world after being asked a simple question
from a financially savvy friend: "Where should I put
my money?"
Krieg and his coworker, Ed Robinson, had
something of an "aha moment."
"We said, 'If that's happening with a person who
knows about this stuff, what is everybody else going
through?'" Krieg told Business Insider.
Krieg and Robinson started asking around, gauging
how people were saving their money. But the
answer to the question "Do you invest?" was always
a "no," with the reason being that people just didn't
know how or they thought it was something only
rich people could do.
Krieg and Robinson realized then that they had an
opportunity to help.
Brandon Krieg, cofounder and CEO of Stash.
SfUSII
They founded Stash, an app that lets you build a portfolio and start investing with only $5, plus it teaches you the
ins and outs of the stock market.
The company launched in October 2015 and just closed on a $40 million Series C led by Coatue Management.
That brings Stash's total funding to $78 million and values the New York-based startup at $240 million,
according to a person familiar with the company.
Stash makes money by charging a subscription fee of $1 per month for accounts with less than $5,000. When an
account has more than $5,000, Stash charges a fee of 0.25% fee.
And the company is growing quickly: Stash now has about 850,000 customers nationwide.
So how does it work?
Krieg and Robinson knew that in order for Stash to catch on, they'd need to make the barrier of entry low — very
low. Getting started with Stash requires only $5 and about five minutes to set up an account.
hfip://www.businessinsider.com/stash-brandon-krieg-interview-investing-stock-market-2017-7
7/1812017 Interview with Brandon Krieg. founder of Stash app that lets you invest in the stock market for SS - Business 
Insider
Invest in your beliefs
Clean & Green
Make your money even greener.
Invest in the power of clean energy
sources like solar and wind.
Defending America
Aerospace and defense companies
that provide the weapons our
troops need to fend off threats...
"The biggest problem I see right now is people doing nothing," Krieg said.
"People just want the chance
to start," Krieg said. "Our
customers are typically
starting with around $20 to
$40, and they're turning on
our feature called Autostash,
which helps them invest either
weekly or biweekly."
Once you get started with
Stash, the app evaluates how
much risk you should be
taking based on factors like
your income and your assets.
Then, it recommends
investments based on what
you've told the app about your
finances.
You can also choose between a
handful of packages based on
what you're passionate about,
like companies that supply parts to the military (Boeing, Lockheed Martin), companies that champion LGBTQ
rights (Twitter, Gap, Time), or clean-energy companies (First Solar, Vestas Wind Systems).
There's also an education component of the app, which Stash hopes to expand with its latest round of funding.
The "Learn" tab will teach you things like the difference between index funds and mutual funds, or provide a
glossary of investing terms.
"People just need to understand that this stuff isn't that hard to understand," Krieg said. "We make it
relatable and understandable."
"There's this misconception, we believe, that because people don't understand it and never learned it that they're
never going to learn it," Krieg said. "But we think that everybody should have an opportunity to start putting
money away when they're young."
Krieg said Stash's average customer is around the age of 29 and make about $45,000 per year, typically someone
who's "hitting those critical life points" like starting a family or buying a house.
While 29 falls firmly in the millennial generation — which is often critiqued for being bad at saving and investing
— Krieg says the app is proof millennials do care, and that they shouldn't get all the blame.
"[Saving] is not just a generational problem, it's an American problem," Krieg said. "My big competitor, I believe,
is a checking account."
hnp://www.businessinsider.com/stash-brandon-krieg-interview-investing-stock-market-20I7-7 2/3
Qonto launches its digital bank accounts for small companies I TcchCrunch
TC News Video Events Crunchbase Ct
()onto launches its digital bank accounts for small companies Posted Jul 5, 2077 by Romoin Dillet (@romaindillet)
f tf in 8+ Ir
French startup Qonto has raised another $11.3 million (El 0 million) from existing investors
Valar Ventures and Alven Capital. The company is now also open for business. You can now
create a French business bank account on the company's website.
Qonto wants to become the N26 of business accounts. While retail banking hasn't changed
quickly enough over the past few years, it feels like business banking is even worse and has
been stuck in the past. Everything is too expensive and it takes too much time to tell your
bank to do something.
Qonto wants to put you in charge of your account. It's a web and mobile service like the ones
you're using every day, and you remain in control. So for €9 per month, you get a
MasterCard, a French current account with an IBAN to receive payments and the ability to
manage transfers and debits.
But that's just the beginning as you can order new cards for €5 per month or create virtual
cards for €2 per month. Qonto lets you manage your user base. If you hire a new sales
hups.fi techcrunch.com/2017,07A15/qonto-launches-its-digital-bank-accounts-for-snudl-companies/ 1/7
7/18/2017 Qonto launches its digital bank accounts for small companies I TechCrunch
You can block and unblock your card from the app, change the PIN code and get real-time
notifications for each transaction. Administrators can adjust card limits and share transaction
information with accountants.
Other features are coming soon, such as an easy workflow to upload receipts and attach
them to a particular expense — accountants are going to love this. Qonto will also make it
easier to handle transfers in multiple currencies.
In the future, you'll be able to connect your Qonto account with various fintech services you
might also be using, such as Stripe, PayPal and GoCardless. This way, you'll be able to
monitor and manage payments on all sorts of platforms from a single, unified interface.
Behind the scene, Qonto partnered with Treezor for the back end. Treezor is the company
that is actually managing your money. It generates current accounts and debit cards for
Qonto. On the other side of the equation, Qonto tailors the experience and handles the
relationship with its own customers.
Other companies, such as iBanFirst in France, Seed in the U.S. and Tide in the U.K. are
working on similar services with a few differences here and there — Tide just announced a
$14 million funding round yesterday. While the market seems fragmented, those big funding
rounds indicate that there seems to be a big opportunity to replace those expensive and
ineffective business bank accounts.
f tr in 8+ Jt, r
hups://techcamch.com/2017/071O5/qonto-launches-its-digital-bank-accounts-for-snudl-companies/ 2/7
= Forbes MAR 23. 2017 rµ 06:14 AM 3.636
Peter Thiel And Max Levchin Bet
On Freelance Economy
Peter Johnston, founder and CEO of Lystable
Peter Thiel's venture capital firm Valar Ventures has led a $10 million investment
round in Lystable, an app for collaborating with freelancers, Lystable announced
this morning.
The round includes earlier investors such as Max Levchin's fund SciFi VC,
Kindred Capital and Goldcrest Capital, as well as new backers Glynn Capital
Management and Wilmont Ventures. Thiel and Levchin were co-founders of
PayPal.
Lystable, which was founded in London and has an office in San Francisco,
enables companies to onboard freelancers, create profiles for them, assign work
to them, track invoices and make payments. Freelancers can also use the
platform for functions such as checking the status of invoices.
"We are growing rapidly," says Peter Johnston, founder and CEO, a former
designer at Google and alum of the prestigious Techstars accelerator. "Our plan is
to hire people to cope with that growth."
Lystable plans to use the money it raised to introduce a new payments product,
ideally by the end of the year, and hire senior executives to help that part of the
business scale, says Johnston.
Target clients are companies in the media and tech sector that rely heavily on
freelance talent, according to John
Lystable is SciFi VC's "first investment focused squarely on the freelance space,"
said Eric Scott, partner in SciFi VC, based in San Francisco.
Scott said the firm sees the data Lystable is collecting on freelance talent to be
"enormously valuable." While it is relatively easy for small firms to hire
freelancers, it can be trickier for multinationals to find freelancers who work well
with their team and fit into their culture, he noted.
"They address a problem no one else does," he says.
Lystable raised $11 million in Series A financing in June 2016, bringing the total
raised to $25 million since its founding in 2014, according to the company.
Lystable says its users include celebrity and style site POPSUGAR, the NY Daily
News, Airbnb, ESPN, CNBC, IDEO, and Google.
Using Lystable's basic platform is free but companies that pay their freelancers
through the platform incur a processing fee. Paying through the platform is an
alternative to direct bank transfers, which can be costly and, in some cases,
impossible --presenting challenges as multinationals tap into an increasingly
global talent base, says Johnston.
"The future of work is becoming more international," says Johnston. "It's going to
be more important to get these freelancers paid, wherever they are on the earth."
Lystable's 2016 revenue was in the $1 million-$3 million dollar range, according
to Johnston. The company employs 4o people.
There is significant competition in the freelance management space, with
platforms such as Work Market and Upwork going after enterprise clients. Some
companies, such as the Washington Post, have developed private talent clouds to
manage freelancers.
"I think there will always be companies that decide to build vs. buy, but in most
cases it's still going to make sense to buy," says Scott.
N26 founder Maximilian Tayenthal: Growth. redundant banks, profits - Business Insider
BUSINESS
INSIDER
App-only bank N26 doesn't care about
'short-term profits' — it wants to build a
European bank that will make rivals
'redundant'
I OSCAR WILLIAMS-GRUT
JUN. 29, 2017, 2:00 AM
COPENHAGEN, Denmark — App-only startup bank
N26 is one of Europe's hottest startups — and it's
moving very fast.
The Berlin-headquartered bank announced on
Monday that it has partnered with fellow startup
Clark to offer insurance through its app.
It's one of a number of new products that N26 has
launched this year, either built in-house or
conceived through partnerships. Other launches
include an overdraft you can apply for through your
smartphone and a partnership with German
investment platform Raisin.
"Right now it's about making traditional banks
redundant, in that we offer a product for every
financial need of our customers," cofounder and
CFO Maximilian Tayenthal told Business Insider at
the Money2020 conference in Copenhagen this
week.
N26 cofounder and CFO Maximilian Tayenthal.
Numbenth
"Today, if you're a customer and you want to use a savings product you still have an excuse to use something
other than N26. In the next 6 months, we want to bring one product and what we see as the best product in every
category."
http://www.businessinsider.com/n26-founder-maximilian-tayenthal-gmwth-banks-redundant-profits-2017-6 1/3
7/18/2017 N26 founder Maximilian Tayenthal: Growth. redundant banks. profits - Business Insider
ING's head of fintech Benoit Legrand told Business
Insider last year: "Frankly, if you look at the
neobank [as app-only banks are known] space —
they're flourishing everywhere but we're still waiting
for the business model to show up. Where is the
money? Where is the return?"
Tayenthal says: "We used to get people saying you
don't have a business model. It's not true. We
always had a clear monetization strategy.
He adds: "What is true is that no one at N26 has a
single monetary KPI in the first year after our
launch. We were working on our customer base, on
the branding, on launching products, building up
the team. We didn't work on short-term
monetization. We want to be an app that customers
open once a day.
•
826
40.00
4- sew. •• ••••(“d I
N26's insurance partnership with Clark.
N26 is "not focused on short-term profits," he says.
For now, it's all growth, growth, growth.
"We have positive unit economics which is cool, so every customer we add to the platform is making the business
less negative," Tayenthal says. "When it comes to our revenue model, one has to understand that we operate at a
very low cost. We acquire customers at a much lower cost. Secondly, we have much lower overheads. We have
lower IT costs, everything is automated. We don't have branches."
N26 is working on building more credit products and also has plans to expand its current product range across all
the markets it is in. There are no immediate plans to get into business banking space but "in the long run we will
launch a product there as well," Tayenthal says.
One notable market where N26 is absent is the UK. The Times reported in April that N26 was set to launch in
Britain by the end of the year, but Tayenthal is coy.
He says: "It's a really interesting market and we are thoroughly looking at it," before adding: "I don't want to
commit to any timeline."
hnp://www.businessinsider.com/n26-founder-maximilian-tayenthal-gmwth-banks-redundant-profits-2017-6 2/3
If You Can't Real 'Em. Join Em: Landlords Embracing. Investing In Disruptive Forces - O113cc
If You Can't Beat 'Em, Join 'Em: Landlords
Embracing, Investing In Disruptive Forces May 04, 2017 I Ethan Rothstein, East Coast Editor
Despite the real estate industry's reputation for adapting to technology at a
glacial pace, Manhattan landlords have made a rapid about-face in the last
few years. Pressed to stand out in the most competitive office market in the
country, they have begun welcoming disruptive forces into their buildings and
into their investment portfolios.
Montreal-based on-demand meeting space provider
Breather is a prime example of the rapid shift in
mindset. Last year, Breather signed 50 leases totaling
8oK SF in New York City. Breather operates almost i4o
spaces in 15OK to 175K SF here at the moment, but vice
president of real estate Maggie Burns said the firm is
planning to have more than 200 locations by the end of 2017.
Breather, which also operates in Toronto; Los Angeles; San Francisco;
Washington, DC; Denver; and London, leases spaces of up to 4K SF and
provides full-services meeting spaces by the hour or the day. The firm started
its Manhattan journey in Midtown South catering to tech tenants, but its
growth potential reaches far beyond.
Burns considers some of the firm's most recent deals — at 183 Madison Ave.,
the first in a Tishman Speyer building, and at 594 Broadway in SoHo, its first
with Newmark Holdings — achievements because of the caliber of landlord
that has recognized the company's potential.
"Two and a half years ago, the best-case scenario for us to sit down with a
Class-A institutional owner was for them to say, 'Seems interesting, let us
know how it's going in six months,'" Burns said. "Now the level of excitement
is palpable. We're getting a lot of inbound requests from landlords."
Just as important as the landlords who recognize the firm's potential — which
Burns called "massive" numerous times in a telephone interview Thursday
morning — is the volume of major, multinational companies seeing a need for
its service. Breather is now the official small meeting space provider for Estee
Lauder worldwide, Burns said.
"We are serving more clients than ever before, and I think we're just
scratching the surface," Burns said. "We're now very focused on serving
[major institutional] clients, but also thinking about how can we meet the
hnps://www.bisnow.cornincw-yorkfnewsktffice/lareather-wework-rfr-realty-manhattan-74I19 1/3
If You Can't Beat 'Ern, Join 'Em: Landlords Embracing. Investing In Disruptive Forces - Office
needs of these massive occupiers globally as they think about their real estate
footprint? We see a really massive opportunity there."
If that business model sounds familiar, that is because it
is reminiscent of what the office market's biggest
disruptor is also striving for.
When WeWork struck a deal to manage nearly an entire
building, 7oK SF, on behalf of IBM near Greenwich
Village, it effectively sent a message to brokerage giants like CBRE and JLL
that it is not content to simply serve as a landing spot for some companies.
WeWork and Breather launched effectively as middlemen between landlords
and tenants. Firms of their ilk now see offering real estate as a service —
managing spaces directly on behalf of major clients — rather than short-term
deals for freelancers and entrepreneurs — as the business model that has the
best potential to scale.
"From Day One, we wanted to be both B-to-C and B-to-B," Burns said,
referencing platforms facing small consumers and large enterprise clients.
"But two years ago, we started reorganizing around B-to-B, because the
opportunity was just so massive."
Likewise, landlords are not waiting for tech firms to come to them. Canadian
giant Brookfield just invested tens of millions of dollars in Convene, another
on-demand workspace company. On Tuesday, CBRE, Hines, Lennar,
Macerich and Equity Residential were among the founding investors in Fifth
Wall Ventures, an investment fund that raised $212M to invest in real estate
startups contributing to the "Built World."
"We're in the early innings of one of the single biggest shifts in the history of
the U.S. economy," Fifth Wall's launch announcement reads. "The 'Built
World' encompasses much more than buildings: it represents an entire
ecosystem of the companies who own and operate physical space, and the
innovative startups developing technologies that will transform, optimize and
democratize access to these spaces. This ecosystem hasn't yet fully been
realized."
While technology was bound to change the way the real
estate industry operates eventually, the acceptance of
the change at every level of the industry in New York
City has been significant, especially over the last year.
And it is not just the technology itself, but the ethos and
environment that technology inspires.
"Fried Frank, which is one of the most prominent real estate law firms in New
https:1/www.bisnow.cominew-yorkinews/office/breadier-wework-rfr-realty-manhattan-74119 2/3
If You Can't Beat 'Em. Join Em: Landlords Embracing. Investing In Disruptive Forces - Office
York, in their office downtown, they put in a pool table," RFR senior vice
president and director of leasing AJ Camhi said. "Law firms are usually about
efficiency and offices, and in a million years you wouldn't think they'd
encourage downtime. Park Avenue buildings are now putting in ping pong
tables and open tenant lounges. It spreads the gamut now. It's pretty wild."
For landlords like RFR, which owns the Seagram Building, attracting the right
employees to the right project is more important than checking the hip,
trendy boxes.
"[The building] is an architectural masterpiece," Camhi said. "We are never
going to redo that building to attract tech tenants. We were one of the first
buildings to offer an executive lounge and a 7K SF terrace, but we're not going
to put in pool tables."
But the area where WeWork and Breather really succeed — personalized
touches, service, programming — have landlords taking note.
"We view our tenants as our partners, we want them to do very well. If they
do well and we treat them well, then they grow within our building," Camhi
said. "What WeWork has done has raised the bar for a lot of other landlords.
A lot [of] amenities that are now springing up have a little to do with what
WeWork provides. It's showing that level of service works."
hap If/www.bisnow.cominew-yorklnewsioffice/breather-wewmic-rfr-realty-manhattan-74119 3/3
Fintech unicorn TransferWise reaches profitability. planning 'new financial services I TechCrunch
Ts: News Video Events Crunchbase Ct
Fintech unicorn TransferWise reaches profitability, planning
`new financial services'
Posted May 16. 2077 by Steve °Wear (@sohear)
mi f VP in 3' d
YOUR BANK IS OVERCHA RGING YOU Or. YOUR OVERSEAS most' IRAHSEERS
V TronsisEvENNEENE,
What's more mythical than a unicorn? A unicorn that is profitable. Six years after launch,
TransferWise, the London-headquartered international money transfer startup, which was
most recently valued at a reported $1.1 billion, has announced that it has finally reached
profitability this calendar year and is "cash-generating".
Breaking this down a little, the company says it's currently seeing £8 million per month in
revenue, which extrapolates to a £100 million revenue run-rate, and is growing 150 per cent
year-on-year and expecting to do the same this year. It also says over £1 billion is being
moved every month, saving its customers what it claims to be over £1.5 million per day in
foreign exchange fees.
For reference, the most recent regulatory filing for the tax year ending March 2016, shows
that TransferWise generated around £27.8 million in revenue and made a pre-tax loss of
£17.4 million. It is yet to file its accounts for the year ending March 2017, but based on
htipsWiechcninch.comt20I7i05/I6/finiech-unicorn-transienvise-reaches-profitability-planning-new-financial-seniees!
Fintcch unicorn TransfcrWisc reaches pmlitability. planning 'new financial scrviccs' I TcchCninch
Meanwhile, the startup has raised around $117 million in total (which is roughly £91 million
at today's exchange rate). Top tier backers include Andreessen Horowitz, Peter Thiel's Valar
Ventures, Sir Richard Branson, and most recently Baillie Gifford.
"To have hit break-even just six years on from launch shows how strong the foundations of
our business are," says TransferWise co-founder and CEO Taavet Hinrikus in a statement.
"This is just the starting point. With the unique platform we've built, we're looking forward to
creating a new kind of financial services for the future."
Note the "new kind of financial services" part of the canned quote? That's because I
understand the company is eyeing up additional customer pain-points that could also be
solved under the TransferWise brand with functionality or services beyond helping you send
money from one country to another.
In a call with Hinrikus, he wouldn't be drawn on what they may be. However, when pressed
he did say there were "no plans" to apply for a full banking license, for example, which would
bring with it considerable further capital and regulatory requirements. In other words, we
probably shouldn't expect a TransferWise challenger bank any time soon.
With that said, let me speculate on what products I think the company could quite easily
move into, should it choose to do so. Friend-to-friend or P2P payments within the same
country, along the lines of Paypal's Venmo or Barclays Pingit, doesn't seem a stretch, given
that TransferWise already has much of that infrastructure already in place. It also seems odd
that the company doesn't offer its own debit card with low cost currency exchange when
spending abroad, for example.
Were TransferWise to do the latter, that would see it go up against Revolut, and a ton of
other much more recent fintech startups that utilise MasterCard's low exchange rate,
including all-your-cards-in-one app Curve, of which Hinrikus himself is an investor.
What the TransferWise founder would say, however, is that having built a strong and trusted
brand and now with a 1 million plus customer base, the company is in a great position to
help its customers solve further problems adjacent to (or perhaps around the edges of) what
it already offers. And it's true, the startup has, right from the get go, spent a lot of time and
money on building the TransferWise brand and what is undoubtedly a great product.
hupsfitcchcrunch.com/20I7J115/I6/finicch-unicorn-transicnvisc-reachcs-prolnability-planning-ncw-financial-scnices!
Fintech unicorn TransferWise reaches profitability. planning 'new financial services' I TechCninch
success over the last six years, its brand or product? "A billion dollar question," he replied,
before pausing for thought and choosing his words in a carefully considered manner, as he is
wont to do. "A product actually builds your brand. It's hard to have a great product which
does not end up standing on its own two feet as a brand".
To that end, I'm told TransferWise now claims 10 per cent of the international money transfer
market in the U.K., a market still dominated by the major four banks who account for about
80 per cent by some estimates. Or, put over simply, the company is now the size of half a
bank in international money transfer terms, something that hasn't gone entirely unnoticed by
those incumbent banks.
"If you look around there are a lot of other fintech companies but they are often selling their
own product through a bank," adds Hinrikus. "In the fintech space, I believe we will only see a
couple of new global brands being built, and I'm pretty sure we are going to be one of them".
Lastly, here's a bit of fun. The TransferWise founder recently tweeted a copy of his first ever
pitch email to TechCrunch, more than six years ago, which resulted in the fintech unicorn's
first wave of coverage and revenue. The 700 person-strong and now profitable company has
come a long way since then.
Steve O'Hear @sohear 24 Jan
I'm pretty sure I was first major tech pub to cover TransferWise
and, I'm told, my story resulted in startup's first £1,000 transfer.
twitter.comitaaveUstatus/...
taavet hinrikus
@taavet CFollow
you were the first. always thankful. see pitch email below. cc
@andruspurde pic.twitter.com/OzNfURZpXR
11:45 AM - 24 Jan 2017 • Palo Alto, CA
hupsfitechcninch.com/20I7J115/I6/finiech-unicorn-transrenvise-reaches-prolnability-planning-new-financial-senices!
US venture capital firm Technology Crossover Ventures buys Xem stake I afr.com
FINANCIAL REVIEW
Home News Business Markets Street Talk Real Estate Opinion Technology Personal Finance Leadership Life
Ibme / Technology
A01 182017 81 11 08 AM 1.10,141441A4. 18 2017 at 4 59 PM
US venture capital firm Technology Crossover Ventures buys
Xero stake
..cs44 Marlow
by John hicDuling
the NZX and ASX
A giant US venture capital firm that has backed Facebook. Spotify
and Netfiix has emerged with a small stake in Kiwi cloud
accounting provider Xero.
Technology Crossover Ventures (TCV) spent SNZ28.5 million ($26
million) to pick up a 1.3 per cent stake in Xero. according to a
filing to the New Zealand Stock Exchange. Xero is listed on both
TCV. which raised $U525 billion for its ninth fund last year. bought its shares from
fellow US venture firm Matrix Partners. which has reduced its stake in the business to
8.5 per cent from 9.8 previously. TCV declined to comment. citing its policy for listed
investments.
While TCVs Xero stake is small. It represents the fund's first investment in the
Australasian region in over three years and is another sign of growing interest among
top-tier US venture capital firms for exposure to technology companies from this pan
of the world.
In 2014.TCV led a $30 million funding round for SiteMinder. a Sydney based hotel
booking platform.
Strong support
The Indian arm of vaunted Silicon Valley fund Sequoia Capital has made a handful of
investments on both sides of the Tasman over the past year. Other respected US VC
hnp://www.afrromitechnologyfus-venturc-eapital-firm-tochnology-crossover-ventures-buys-xero-stakc-20170418-gymnn0 113
7/18/2017 US venture capital firm Technology Crossover Ventures buys Xero stake I afrrom
firms actively investing in this region include Accel Partners (an Investor in Xero and
Campaign Monitor. and an early backer of Atlassian) and Index Ventures (an investor
in SafetyCulture and Culture Amp).
Xero's ASX listing Ls up about 10 per cent this year. outpacing a 3 per cent rLse for the
broader market. However, the stock has fallen about 55 per cent from its mid-2014
peak.
"it Is routine that some earty-stage investors will rebalance their portfolios and we're
thrilled to receive strong support from new investors who are ready to Join Xero for its
next phase of growth." the company's chief financial and operating officer. Sankar
Narayan. said in an emailed statement
TCV's share purchase - and Matrix's sale - continues the intrigue on Xero's
shareholder register. Earlier thLs month the powerful Silicon Valley billionaire and
Donald Trump adviser Peter Thiel sold shares worth about 323 million in the
company. taking his stake below the 5 per cent threshold at which it must be publicly
disclosed.
The sale followed reports that Mr Thiel had been secretly granted New Zealand
citizenship in 2011. stoking fierce debate in both the US and New Zealand. Mr Thiel's
application had been strongly supported by Xero founder Rod Drury. while Xero's
former chairman Chris Liddell recently quit the company to take up a White House
advisory role in the 'Dump Administration.
New Zealand's emerging technology scene has been attracting significant global
attention lately. Last week. The New York Times wrote a glowing article on the
country's ability to lure top tech talent to its shores.
bnp://www.atbcomitechnologyfus-venture-capital-limmechnology-crossover-ventures-buys-xero-stake-201704 I 8-gymnn0 2/3
EFTA00298214 (Jmail)
 [deposition] deposition of Joseph Recarey
(inferred date: 2026-01-25)
Page 320
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
IN AND FOR PALM BEACH COUNTY, FLORIDA
CASE No.50200SCA0373193000CMB AB
Page 322
APPEARANCES:
On behalf °flaw Dora 1 through 8:
JESSICA ARBOURESQUIRE
utatmusitirt & P.A.
1820513ismne Boulevard
B.B. Susie 2218
Plaintiff
Miami,
Phone
S 1,
6 ws- VOLUME al OF IV 7
Oa behalf of the Plaintiff, Jame Doe No. IL
ISIDRO MAKIJEI. GARCIA, ESQUIRE
GARCIA, MAINS& BOO-RINGER
9 224 Dan Awnuo Suite 90)
West 33401
Dcfaxlinta. 10
tilde
Phan(
9 11 ind
10 12 TARA A. MORGAN. ESQUIRE.
TARA A. P124141GAN. PA 11 13 224 Datum SEM
12 DEPOSITION OF SAW 900
DETECTIVE JOSEPH RECAREY 14 West ids 33401
13 Plan.
Tuesday, April 27, 2010
1003 - 5:23 p.m.
Is
Oo bd./gelthe De /W. Setiney Epsiesn:
MEI IAN PIKE. 18QUIRE 16 505 South Hagler Drive BURMAN, CRUTCH, Lunrout COLEMAN, LIP
Suite 1100 14 303 Rearm nadorsrel
17 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 Sage 400
18 19 West Pligarida 33401
19 Phone
20 20 and 21 21
22 Reported By: mTI:PON 0. WITINRF.R.G. mot BRE
Jena Riociuti, RPR, PPR, CLR 22 LAW OFFICE OF MILTON G. WEINBERG
23 Notary Public. Siam of Florida 20 Park Plant
Prose Court Reporting
Job No.: 1509
Suite 1008.
Bea Mir 02116
Thaw
25 25
Page 321 Page 323
1 1 Appearances continued... 2 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 2 On behalf of the Witness:
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OP FLORIDA 3 JOANNE M. O'CONNOR, ESQUIRE
CASE NO. 10-80309 JONES, FOSTER, JOHNSON & STUBBS, P.A.
4 505 South Flagler Drive, Suite 1100
5 JANE DOE NO. 103. West Pa rida 33401 Pkbdiff; Phone: 7 VOLUME DI OFIV
JEFFREY EPSTEIN,
Degltlallt 7
Also Present: Jeffrey Epstein
10 9
11 10
12 DEPOSITION OP 11
DETECTIVE JOSEPH RECAREY 12 13
14 Tuesday, April 27,2010 13
15 10:03 - 5:23 p.m. 14
16 505 South Hagler Drive 15
Suite 1100 16
17 West Palm Beach, Florida 33401 17 18 18 19

20. 19
,21 20
22 Reported By. 21
Jeana Rkciuti, RPR, IFPR, CLR 22
23 Notary Public, State of Florida 23
Prose Court Reporting 24
25 25
2 (Pages 320 to 323)
• PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricclutl
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricci utl (4082837-a bal-482e4836-be014441447a
Page 324
PROCEEDINGS
Deposition taken before Jeana Ricciuti, Registered
Professional Reporter and Notary Public in and for the
State of I•lorida at Large, in the above cause.
Thereupon,
(JOSEPH RECAREY)
having been fast duly sworn or affirmed, was examined
and testified as follows:
THE WITNESS: I do.
CROSS (JOSEPH RECAREY)
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. Good morning, Detective.
A. Good morning.
Q. You've been a detective for the Palm Beach
Police Department for how long?

A. Approximately, 15 years.
Q. Some of it is as a detective and some of it in
another capacity, or always as a detective?

A. I've been with the Town for 19 yews, but I
did time on the road and then moved up to the detective
bureau.

Q. And do they have a written practice in teams
of whether or not you're required to preserve rough
Page 326
1 Q. And you would type the report into a computer?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. And that would be essentially signed by you,
4 that would be your personal summary of the interview
5 that you were conducting with one of the many people
6 that gave you information about Mr. Epstein?

A. Correct.
8 Q. And it was always your practice in this case
9 to then destroy the notes that you used as a basis for
10 that typed summary; is that correct?

A. Correct.
12 Q. And on other cases, is it always your practice
13 to destroy the notes that you would take during the
14 interviews?
15 A. Correct.
16 Q. So you have no notes of any case that you've
17 ever memorialized into a computer or a typed summary; is
18 that correct?
19 A. That is correct.
20 Q. And is that a practice that you've discussed
21 with other detectives in the Palm Beach Police
22 Department?
23 A. Ifs just a practice that I've done all along.
24 Q. And what is the purpose of your destroying the
25 rough notes?
Page 325
1 notes or interview notes of different witnesses?
2 A. No policies, no practice.
3 Q. Do you have personal practice as to whether or
4 not you would retain rough notes that you are
5 contemporaneously taking of interviews with the
6 witnesses?
7 A. I take my notes, transcribe them into my
8 supplements and then shred them.
9 Q. So that you have no rough notes or no
10 handwritten notes —
11 A. Correct.
12 Q. of any of the many interviews you took
13 during your investigation of Jeffrey Epstein?
14 A. Correct.
15 Q. It was your practice to take notes while you
16 were interviewing people?
17 A. On occasion, 1 did, yes.
18 Q. Would you take notes even if you were tape
19 recording the people with whom you were conducting an
20 interview?
21 A. On occasion.
22 Q. And at some point thereafter, you would use
23 those notes as a basis of writing a report; is that
24 correct?
25 A. Correct.
Page 327
1 A. There's no need to keep them once you've
2 transcribed than into your supplemental.
3 Q. And again, the transcription into the
4' supplemental is done X number of days after the

5. interview?
6 A. If not the same day.
7 Q. Sometimes a week after, sometimes the same
8 day?
9 A. I wouldn't say a week after. I would say
10 either the same day or the day after.
11 Q. So within 24 hours, you would have a typed
12 summary of the interview, is that correct?
13 A. Approximately.
14 Q. And would you just type your rough notes or
15 would you summarize from your rough notes when you
16 • engaged in the process of —
17 A. Summarize.
18. Q. — your report?
19 So the notes would have more than a summary?
20 A. Obviously, if it was taped, everything would
21 be on the tape recorder. As fir as my note-taking
22 concerns, I would jot down things that sparked my
23 curiosity or things I wanted to go back and reinterview
24 the person - and go back and reinterview the person.
25 Q. So the summary that you typed into a computer
PROSE COURT
3 (Pages 324 to 327)
REPORTING. AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601 c6062637-abel-452c-a836-bc614e314d7a
Page 328 Page 330
1 would be, in part, your notes, part in memory of 1 surveillances of Mr. Epstein's residence as El Brillo on
2 different statements made to you based on the jottings 2 Palm Beach, correct?
3 in your notes? 3 A. Correct
4 A. I would basically go over what the interview 4 Q. And who made that assignment, if you know?
5 transcribed, you know, into my supplement. S A. I can't recalL That was back when
6 Q. But the basis of the supplemental, and I don't 6 Officer Pagan had the case. But they were also
7 mean to torture the subject, but the basis of the 7 utilizing it for various functions. They were primarily
8 supplement would be, in part, your memory, correct? 8 the surveillance units used.
9 A. Correct 9 Q. And did they surveille residences to try to
10 Q. And then, in part, what your notes refreshed 10 stop burglaries as well as stuveilling Mr. Epstein,
11 your memory into recalling from the interview that was 11 right?
12 conducted either at that time, the same day or the day 12 A. And other fractions as well.
13 before? 13 Q. Sure. And in 2005, there was not any kind of
14 A. Correct 14 burglary investigation dealing with his residence; is
15 Q. Did you listen to the tape before you wrote a 15 that correct?
16 supplemental report into a computer? 16 A. Correct.
17 A. Are you saying every time or arc you just 17 Q. So to the extent the Burglary Task Force was
18 saying — 18 involved in investigating Mr. Epstein prior to your
19 Q. Asa regular practice, would you, at the time 19 first involvement in September, it was simply an
20 that you typed in your supplemental report into a 20 assignment made of them to assist Officer Pagan,
21 computer, have the tape recording going? 21 correct?
22 A. See, I have done that on other cases, 22 A. Correct.
23 especially lengthy interviews, interviews that last 23 Q. And if you know, did the Burglary Task Force
24 several hours. 24 use video surveillance in investigating Mr. Epstein?
25 Q. But it's not a standard practice, it's 25 A. I know that there were some videos taken, but
Page 329 Page 331
1 something you would do on an occasional basis; is that 1 I don't believe from the video — from the Burglary
2 correct? 2 Strike Force.
3 A. Correct 3 Q. Was there videos taken by others in the Palm
4 Q. Now, let me ask you in particular, on your 4 Beach Police Department of Mr. Epstein's residence?
5 incident report, in essence, is a combination of all the 5 A. There was. There were several tapes. Yes,
6 different supplemental reports that you typed; is that 6 there was.
7 correct? 7 Q. Did you ever direct video surveillance of
8 A. I typed, and other officers as well. 8 Mr. Epstein's residence?
9 Q. Because you came to this investigation at 9 A. What do you mean "direct"?
10 least six months after it began; is that right? 10 Q. In other words, was there any video
11 A. Approximately, yes. 11 surveillance of Mr. Epstein's residence on or after the
12 Q. Again, March of 2005? 12 time that you became the ease agent in the 2005
13 A. Yes. 13 investigation?
14 Q. And it began with Officer Michele Pagan being 14 A. I can't recall. If I did, it would be in the
15 the case agent, if I could call her that? 15 incident report.
16 A. Correct. 16 • Q. But you know that there was such video
17 Q. And it began with surveillances that were 17 surveillance of Mr. Epstein's residence before you
18 conducted by the Burglary Task Force? 18 became the case agent in charge of the investigation?
19 A. Correct 19 ' A. I can't recall if it was before I took over
20 Q. And the Burglary Task Force was a component of 20 the case or after I took over the case. I know that
21 the Palm Beach Police Department designed to try to 21 there was tapes, but i don't know the exact time frame.
22 prevent citizens from being the victims of burglaries; 22 Q. Let me ask you and — let me ask Mr. Pike for
23 . is that correct? 23 one second.
24 A. Correct. 24 MR. WEINBERG: Do we need to use the real
25 Q. And yet, they were assigned the task of doing 25 names?
4 (Pages 328 to 331)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana RIcciuti (801
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (801 c6062637-abol-462c-a836-bc614.314d7a
Page 332
1 MR. PIKE: Yes, pursuant to the agreement that
2 was entered last time, the real names can be used.
3 MR. WEINBERG: Chuck is not going to be in
4 agreement, but i can use the real names, and then
5 they will be convened in the transcript to the
6 applicable abbreviations.
7 BY MR. WEINBERG:
8 Q. Jane Doe, do you know that name?
9 A. Not that I recall.
10 Q. So that it's fair that as you sit here today,
11 in 2010, you have no recollection of ever interviewing a
1.2 woman, a young woman at the time named Jane Doe?
13 A. i don't recall, no.
14 Q. n, d: er ciu have any recollection of ever
15 interviewing M.?
16 A. I went to her home.
17 Q. And what do you recall of going to her home?
18 A. She did not ward to speak to me.
19 Q. And did she tell you why she didn't want to
20 speak to you?
21 A. She was in love with Mr. Epstein and she was
22 not going to speak to me.
23 Q. And how did you come to go to her home? Do
24 you wall, you lawny, what led you to M.?
25 A. Her name came up in the investigation either
Page 334
1 yoinself?
2 A. NO, sir.
3 Q. Did you ever discuss with anyone the fact that
4 there was such a victim list that had been generated out
5 of the United States Attorneys Office?
6 A. There was a list, I believe, that was given to
7 chief — former Chief Reiter. I never got to actually
8 physically hold it and look at it i mean, it was one
9 of those things where he showed me the list, but I never
10 got a chance to...
11 Q. Did the Chief represent to you that that list
12 originated with the United States Attorneys Office?
13 A. I believe so.
14 Q. Did he explain that he had received it from
15 them?
16 A. I believe so.
17 Q. And did he explain ho received it from them
18 with the directive that it should be reviewed and then
19 destroyed?
20 A. I recall the destroying part I'm sure he
21 reviewed it
22 Q. What do you recall of the destroying part?
23 A. I remember him telling me that he was given
24 the copy but it must be destroyed immediately
25 thereafter.
Page 333
by interviews or — I believe it was interviews.

Q. And do you recall who was interviewed, who
would have given you for the first time the name of
M.?
A. There were so many interviews then. I would
have documented it in the incident of who supplied what
name.

Q. So independent of what's documented in an
incident report that was largely authored, what's now
five years ago, you have no otrecollection of who
would have first toM you about ?

A. Lilco I said, it would be documented in the
incident report You know, we're talking five years
ago. You know, tons of interviews.

Q. And with Jane Doe, similarly, do you you
don't remember interviewing her. Do you remember
interviewing anybody else about Jane Doe?

A. Jane Doe does not ring a bell.
Q. Did you ever see her name on any report?
A. No, I don't remember.
Q. Did you ever see her name on any list of
different complainants, victims, witnesses?
A. No.
Q. Did you eva sec a list of victims or
witnesses that was prepared by someone other than
Page 335
1 Q. And did he tell you who directed him to
2 destroy it?
3 A. No.
4 Q. Did he tell you whether or not that directive
5 was in writing or verbal?
6 A. No.
7 Q. Have you ever seen — other than seeing him in
8 the physical possession of the list, have you ever seen
9 it again?
10 A. No.
11 Q. Do you have any reason to believe that he
12 didn't destroy it?
13 A. No. If he says he was going to destroy it, he
14 would destroy it.
15 Q. And do you recall when that was in terms of
16 the evolution of the State case?
17 A. It would have been around December or January
18 time Same of like '06,107.
19 Q. So either the end of '06, beginning of '07?
20 A. I believe so.
21 Q. Or at the time period that would be after the
22 State grand jury met and returned charges against
23 Mr. Epstein?
24 A. It would have been, yes, much after.
25 Q. Would it have bear before there was
5 (Pages 332 to 335)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana FtIcclutl (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Moduli (601 c6062637-abel-452c-a836-bc6144/314d7a
Page 336
1 sum-ceding information that brought in the charges?
2 A. It would have been — again, I'm going off of
recollection here.
4 Q. And again, I understand this is four years ago
5 and we're just trying to get your best unrefreshed
recollection.
7 A I'm trying to think back. It would have
8 been — it would have been — see, I would be guessing.
9 Q. We don't want you to guess.
10 A That's the thing, I would be guessing.
11 Q. Did the Chief ask you to come to his office?
12 A Yes, he did ask me. He said the — the list
13 was not going to leave his office, most assured, and
14 I — at that point, I was like, you know, don't even
15 show me. Liman, it was for your eyes only, that's
16 fine.
17 Q. And did he explain to you why he was directed
18 to destroy the list?
19 A. No.
20 Q. Has the Chief ever before invited you to his
21 office to discuss a document that he thereafter told you
22 he was directed to destroy?
23 A. I mean, I've been many times at the Chiefs
24 office —
25 Q. Sure.
Page 338
1 Q. And you certainly don't recall him ever saying
2. that on any other occasion that he had been directed by
3 any Federal or State prosecutor -
4. A. Not with me, no.
5 Q. — to destroy a document?
6 A. Not with me.
7 Q. And just so we're clear, this docwnent was
8 being destroyed, not in the regular course of business,
9 but as a result of the directive from the Federal
10 prosecutor, correct, according to —
11 A. I would assume so, yeah.
12 Q. And there was no other copy that you knew of
13 this document?
14 A. No.
15 Q. And you have never seen one thereafter?
16 A. N sir.
17 Q. M. ,
you went to ha house; is that correct?
18 A. Correct
19 Q. Did you speak to either of her parents?
20 A. No, I did not.
21 Q. Was she 18 at the time you went to her house?
22 A. I believe so.
23 Q. Was your practice that when somebody was over
24 18, you would feel Otte it was appropriate to interview
25 them directly, but if somebody was under It, you would
Page 337
1 A. — but not — leant recall if there was ever
2 a time that he showed me a document that he must
3 destroy.
4 Q. And have you ever been, yourself, directed by
5 either a State attorney or a US attorney to destroy your
6 document?
7 A. No.
8 Q. And has the Chief ever told you, on any other
9 occasion that you currently recall, that he was directed
10 by a Federal or State prosecutor to destroy a document?
11 • A. I don't know.
12 Q. And other than destroying documents in the.
13 regular course of business, you don't recall the Chief
14 ever before or ever after saying he had been directed by
15 any third party to destroy a document that was relevant
16 to the investigation, correct?
17 A. Fro sorry, can you ask the question again?
18 Q. Oh, sure. Fm sorry. Other than this
19 occasion when the Chief invited you to his office and
20 specifically said that he was in possession of a
21 document, relevant to the Epstein investigation that he
22 had been directed to destroy, do you recall any other
23 occasion where the Chief told you that he was destroying
24 a document relevant to an investigation?
25- A. No.
Page 339
1 try to give some parental notification?
2 A. Correct.
3 Q. And your best recollection with is she
4 was over 18 and, therefore, you went directly to her?
5 A. Correct
6 Q. What would you have told her when you rang on
7 her doorbell and she answered the door?
8 A. I would have identified who I am, my purpose
9 for being there.
10 Q. And what would you have said your purpose for
11.. being there was?
12 A. I was conducting an investigation.
13 Q. And wonld.you tell her of who?
14 A. Yes.
3.5 Q. And would you tell her the subject matter of
16 the investigation?
17 A. Yes, absolutely.
18 Q. And her answer was that she did not wish to
19 cooperate with you?
20 A. I never got to the point to explain to her my
21' purpose of being there. Obviously, she knew why I was
22 .- . there. Once I identified myself, l told her I was a . •
23 police officer from Palm Beach and I was here to speak
24- to her in regards to Jeffrey Epstein. At that point,

25. • . she stopped me and said, I have nothing to say about
6 (Pages 336 to 339)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY,..INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Fticciuti (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601 c5062637-abol-452c-a836-bc6140140a
Page 34C
1 him, nothing negative to say about him. She is in love
2 with the man, and...
3 Q. So that was literally a 30-second
4 conversation?

5. A. Pretty much. Pretty much.
6 Q. Were you with anyone?
7 A. Yes, I was.

• 8 Q. Who were you with?
9 A. I want to say either Sergeant Dawson, who was
10 a detective at the time.
11 Q. Did you follow that tip at all by attempting to
1.2 reinterview her on any other occasion?
13 A. No.
14 Q. So your sum total experience with was
15 essentially a 30-second conversation at her house where
16 she declined your invitation to disci KS Jeffrey Epstein
17 with her?
18 A. Correct.
19 Q. Okay. And you do recall her saying, "fin in
20 love with him*?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. And you're assuming but don't know that she
23 • had been essentially tipped off that this investigation
24 was ongoing; is that correct?
25 A. Pretty much. I mean, she didn't know why I —
2.
Page 342

Q. Do you recall who that was?
• A. Yes, I do.
Q. Who was that?
A.
Q. And tell me what you remember of that
attempted interview.

A. I went up to interview her with Detective
Caristo, at her boyfriend's place of employment was
where she was at. And she didn't wish to speak to me at
that point.

Q. And did she tell you why?
- A. If l can refer to it.
Q. Sure, go ahead.
A. She said that she knew there was an
investigation and that 1 had spoken to other people and,
therefore, I should know what had happened at

Mr. Epstein's house.
Q. And did she make any other further explanation
for her declining your request for an interview?

A. No.
Q. Did she tell you that she, like M., had
positive regard for Mr. Epstein?
A. I don't recall any positive regard.
ti.3icylou take notes of your conversation with
Ms.
Page 341
1 allegedly why 1 was there, but yet she...
2 Q. Well, you told her why you were there, and she
3 then said, I'm in love with Jeffrey Epstein and have
4 nothing negative to say about him?

A. Correct.
6 Q. And so am I correct that she didn't say that
7 she knew why you were there, that you're assuming that,
8 because of the timing of that interview, that she had
9 discussed the investigation with others?
10 A. It's possible.
11 Q. You don't recall anybody telling you —
12 . A. No.
13 Q. — at this time, that they had talked to M.
14 about your investigation?
15 A. No.
16 Q. Was there more than one such person, meaning
17 did anybody else that you attempted to interview about .

18. Jeffrey Epstein decline to be interviewed, to your
19 current recollection?
20 A. No. I believe she's the only one.
21 Q. Can I ask you to look at page 81, paragraph 1
22 of your incident report, and ask whether or not that • .
23 refreshes your recollection about the events of • .
24 February 15, 2006.
25 A. Yes.
Page 343
1 A. No.
2 O fild you take notes of your conversation with
3 Ms. M.?
4 A. No.
5 Q. Did you write any supplemental report
6 regarding your interview attempts with Ms. 5? 7 A. I believe I did. •
8 Q. And likewise, you have before you a
9 supplemental 1.1 that reflects your attempts to
10 interview Ms.
11 A. Yes.

12. Q. Did you ever attempt to interview a woman
13 nulled a?
14 A. Yes, I did?
15 Q. What do you recall of that interview?
16 A. She was a masseuse. I remember going to her
17 home and interviewing her at her home. And If I recall
18 correctly, she stated that what happened betwom her and
19 Mr. Epstein were between consenting adults, that she was
20 over 18 at that time.
21 Q. And did you write a report on that inns-view
22 attempt? •
23 A. I believe so.

24. Q. And in fact, you interviewed a writs of women
25 - who were over 18 years old,not only at the time of the
7 (Pages 390 to 343)
PROSE COURT 'REPORTING. AGENCY, ,INC. . . • (-
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricclutl (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciu0 (601 a062637-abel-452c-a836-13c614e314d7a
Page 344
1 interview, but also at the time of the events between
2 them and Mr. Epstein, correct?
3 A. Correct.

Q. And you would incorporate those interviews
within the overall 87-page incident report is that
correct?
A Correct
8 Q. So that the focus of this broad investigation
9 was not restricted to women under 18 and also included
10 women who were over IS; is that correct?
11 A. Correct
12 Q. Now, some of the girls that you interviewed, I
13 don't mean to be disrespectful, but some of the minors
14' you interviewed were emotional at the time of your
15 interview, is that correct?
16 A. Correct
17 Q. And if they were under 18 at the time of their
18 interview, it WAS your practice to precede that
19 • interview with some notification to their parents; is
20 that correct?
21 A. Correct
22 Q. And what would that notification be? In other
23 words, what would you tell the mother or father of a
24 minor?
25 A. That their daughter was a possible victim
Page 346
THE WITNESS: Right. Some girls wart under n
different ruse. They thought they were going to
either model or get a chance to be in Victoria
Secrets or that kind of thing, but...
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. That was the exception to the rule.
A. Nobody was bound and gagged to go to the
house.
Q. And those that told you that they thought they
were going there for some other purpose were the
exception to the rule that was disclosure by whoever
invited them, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Object to the fonn.
THE WITNESS: Some girls, again, told me that
they were going there to give massages, and some
girls went there for other reasons.
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. Well, let's take one of them who claimed to
have gone there for another reason. Do  recall
interviewing n young woman named M.?

A. Yes.
Q. And when did you interview her? Would the
date of January 9, 2006 be consistent with your memory
as to when you interviewed

A. It would have been, yeah, about that time. 1
-17
25.
Page 345
and/or witness in a police investigation involving a
gentleman that lives in the Town of Palm Beach.

Q. And had you, at the time of say by October of
2005, within 30 days of your commencing of your
responsibilities in this investigation, concluded that,
as to these minors, that they would not be prosecuted;
that they were either victims or witnesses but not
targets?

A. Rephrase your question one more time, Tm
sorry.
Q. Sure. Let me give you a predicate. Many, if
not all, of the people you interviewed were paid sums of
money to give Mr. Epstein a massage at the bottom level,
correct?

A. Correct
Q. And that they went to his house, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And that they went to his house voluntarily;
is that era met?

MS. ARBOUR Object to the form.
311E WITNESS: Yes.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. In other words, they weren't kidnapped or .
coerced into going to his house.
MS. ARBOUR: Object to the form.
Page 347
1 know 1 attempted it once before and she was emotional
2 and, plus, I needed to get her father's consent because
3 she was still underage.
4 Q. When you went to visit with her father, her
S father talked to you, did he not?
6 A. Either 1 telephoned him or spoke to him
7 directly. I believe I might have tel oned him.
8 Q. And the father told you that M. had told him
9 that she had been hired to model lingerie; is that
10 correct?
11 A. 1 believe so. Pm not 100 percent certain on
12 that one. I know I recall the modeling part. I don't
13 know if it was exactly lingerie or...
14 Q. Okay. The father had communicated to you that
15 his daughter had told him that her connection to Jeffrey
16 Epstein was that she went to see him as a model?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. In other words, what you took from talking to
19 the father is that M. had likely lied to him regarding
20 her experiences with Mr. Epstein, correct?
21 A. I wouldn't say "lied to him," because that's
22 what she claimed to me, that that was the purpose of her
23 going to the house.
24 Q. But the father said that that's what she said
25 was the relationship between him [sic] and Mr. Epstein,
8 (Pages 344 to 347)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana RIccluti (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601 c6062637-abo1-452c-a836-bc6141,314d7a
Page 348
1 that she went there as a model.
2 A I recall that that's what the father knew of
3 her going over there.
4 Q. Sure. And this isn't the first parent that
5 you interviewed that didn't know what his daughter would
6 later claim occurred to you; is that right?
7 A. What do you mem?
8 Q. In other words, many of the parents that you
9 sought permission to interview their daughters did not
10 know the details of what had transpired between their
11 daughters and Mr. Epstein, correct?
12 A. Correct.
13 Q. And in fact, no parent called you up
14 uninvited, uninitiated and said, I want to complain
15 about something that's happening in Palm Beach regarding
16 Mr. Epstein?
17 A. That's how the case first became originated,
18 but not me directly.
19 Q. Not you.
20 A. Not me directly.
21 Q. So of all of the witnesses that you
22 interviewed, there wasn't a single parent that came to
23 you as contrasted to you going to them?
24 A. No, not tome. I know that
25 Q. I understand and —
Page 350
came tome and said that something bad happened to her
in relation to Jeffrey Epstein.

A. No.
Q. And no teacher ever came to you and said, my
God, I have a student who is saying that something bad
or improper happened in relation to her and Jeffrey
Epstein, correct?

A. Correct.
Q. And no religious figure ever came to you and
asked you to investigate Mr. Epstein as a result of some
confessional or some complaint that he received from
either a minor or from a parent of a minor?

A. Correct.
Q. And from that, you concluded that — strike
that.
No doctor ever came to you and said that they
had a patient that had been harmed by Jeffrey Epstein
during the time period of your 2005/'6 investigation,
correct?

A. Correct.
Q. No psychiatrist or social worker or mental
health professional ever came to you and said, I have a
patient or client that claims to have been banned by

Mr. Epstein?
A. Correct
.25
Page 349
A. -- Officer Pagan —
Q. -- we'll get there. Because you never
yourself interviewed .., is that correct?

A. No, I did not
Q. So any testimony that you have given about
was derived from your reading reports that were
authored by Officer Pagan and others, correct?

A. Correct.
Q. And amongst those reports was some indication
that one of the parental figures in life had made
a proactive phone call to the Palm Beach Police
Department in March of 2005, correct?

A. Coned. • •
Q. And they had overheard some conversation about
what .. claimed to have done at Jeffrey Epstein's
house, correct? •

A. Correct.
Q. And that they were not saying, my daughter
came to me and said, please call the police, something
happened to me; they were claiming that they had
overheard a conversation, correct?
A. I believe so, yes.
Q. So no parent said to you or — and there's no
report that reflects a parent saying to Officer Pagan or
anyone else in the Palm Beach Police Department, my kid
Page 351
1 Q. And no minor ever came herself to the Palm
2 Beach Policy Department and claimed to have been alnico('
3 or harmed by Jeffrey Epstein?
4 A. Well, after the arrest of Mr. Epstein, we did
5 have people telephone In, but...
6 Q. But not before the arrest and in fact, the --
7 not before the grand jury returned its charge in the
8 summa of 2006, correct?
9 A. Correct.
10 Q. And then you had occasional calls from people
11 who you reported their allegations, correct?
12 A. Correct. Actually, it's Dawson —
13 Q. One was from New York and California —
14 A. — Sergeant Dawson, right.
15 Q. — and they had — they were kind of jumping
16 on the Internet train that resulted from the publicity
17 of Mr. Epstein's charge.
18 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
19 THE WITNESS: I don't know if you want to call
20 that as a publicity train, but some of these
21 victims were legitimate, you know. I mean, we did
22 have people call in as adults, but we had
23 legitimate victims calling in.
24 . BY MR. WEINBERG:
25 Q. And you call them legitimate victims, but just
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY,
Electronically signed by Jeana !Melon (601
Electronically signed by Joana Ricciutl (601
-1"1""•- ', "
9 (Pages 348 to 351)
INC.
c5062637-aba1.462c.a8341-bc6144414d7a
Page 352
so the record is clear, you were not present at
Page 354
trying to initiate an investigation against Mr. Epstein
7 Mr. Epstein's home on any occasion when he had a with the sole exception of the n. broad family and the
3 one-to-one or contact with any of the so-called phone call that came into the police department six
1 complainants, correct? , months before you became case agent, correct?
5 A. No. 5 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
6 Q. So this is not something you — you were not 6 THE WITNESS: Coned.
/ an eyewitness to any of the events, correct? 7 BY MR. WEINBERG:
8 A. Correct. 8 Q. So let's, if we can, go back to and try
9 Q. There was no video surveillance of what did or 9 to at least focus on one of the interviewees.
10 did not occur in the massage room on the second floor on 10 She told you that she had originally gone to
11 El Brillo; is that correct? 11 the house believing that she was going there for the
12 ' A. 'Correct. 12 purpose of modeling; is that comet?
13 Q. There was no audio surveillance of any 13 A. Correct.
14 conversations that Mr. Epstein participated in with any 14 Q. And somebody must have told her that, correct?
15 of the witnesses or complainants; is that correct? 15 A. I believe the person that took her.
16 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form. 16 Q. And do you recall who took her? Would.
17 THE WITNESS: Correct. 17 ring a bell?
18 BY ta NVIIIIIBBRO: 18 A. I believe, yes, I believe it was M. that
19 Q. You're relying on, A, what you were told and, 19 took her.
20 B, what your investigation derived? 20 Q. Do you recall writing — and this comes from,
21 A. During the sworn taped statement. 21 what I believe, is Exhibit 1 of the Palm Beach Police
22 Q. So going back to the period before he was 22 Department affidavit that "On January 9.1_20306,1
23 arrested and before there was this kind of outflow of 23 located and interviewed another victim, s date of
24 media or attention, there was not any of the different 24 birth April 29, 1988. was identified as a potent .1
25 minors that, who reside in Palm Beach, ever came to 25 victim witness from infonnation obtained during tia.‘,1
Page 353 Page 355
1 their local police department or to the Palm Beach 1 pulls from Epstein's residence."
2 Police Department and made a complaint against 2 And I represent to you I'm reading this
3 Jeffrey Epstein; is that correct? 3 accurate.
4 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form. 4 Does that refresh your memory about the going
5 TIM WITNESS: Are you limiting your 5 ton.?
6 questioning to just the persons that lived within 6 A. Yes.
7 the Town of Palm Beach limits? 7 Q. And during what period of time would they have
8 BY MR. WEIN13ERO: • a these trash pulls?
9 Q. Let me start with the people within this 9 A. That would have been documented in the report.
10 region. Did any minor ever initiate a complaint with 10 Q. Any of them after the search of October 20th?
11 you against Mr. Epstein before you had gone to them? 11 A. It might have been.
12 A. Not that I can recall, no. 12 Q. And by trash pull, we're referencing the
13 Q. And likewise, you don't know that any minor in 13 attempts by the Palm Beach Police Department to derive
14 14 investigatory material by searching the garbage that this region, before the publicity, ever went to their
15 local police department, be it in West Palm Beach or 15 came from Mr. Epstein's residence; is that correct?
16 • Daytona Beach or wherever, and said, I want to report 16 A. That is correct.
17 that I have been injured, harmed, compromised by 17 Q. And the conversations engaged in between you
18 Jeffrey Epstein. 18 and others working for you and different representatives
19 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form. 19 of the Palm Beach Sanitation Department?
20 THE WITNESS: If there was, I wouldn't be . 20 A. The Sanitation Department didn't go through
21 aware of it. ' 21 the trash; all they did was pull it for us.
22 BY Mit. WEINBERG: 22 Q. But there were conversations between the
23 Q. Your 87-page report does not reflect any 23 - police and Sanitation asking Sanitation to have a clean
24 initiative taken by any minor or any parent of a minor 24 and empty truck; is that correct?
25 ' or any professional who is associated with a minor in 25 A. Correct
10 (Pages 352 to 355)
'PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (801
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (801 C6062637-abol-452c-a336-bc614•314eila
Page 356
1 Q. To drive the truck to a certain location,
2 correct?
3 A. Correct

Q. To collect the trash on certain days from
5 Mr. Epstein's house, correct?
6 A. Correct.
Q. You knew that Mr. Epstein's house was enclosed
8 by security gates from your surveillances there, did you
9 not?
10 A. Correct
11 Q. And that one would need to buzz in to come in?
12 A. Not necessarily. I mean, the gates leading to
13 the garage were always left unsecured, opened.
14 Q. Did you not know that the Sanitation people
15 . would buzz in and ask — tell them that they were there
16 to get the trash?
17 A. In the many, many times that I've driven by,
18 I've always seen that gate open to the garage.
19 Q. But when the Sanitation people went to
20 Mr. Epstein's house, they were there pursuant to an
21 agreement with you, that they would bring the trash to a
22 predestined location where it would be made available to
23 Palm Beach --
24 A. Well, they were watched.
25 Q. They were watched?
Page 358
1 A. Correct
2 Q. And that they would go in and you would
3 surveille them going in?
4 A. Correct.
5 Q. They would come out with the trash, correct?
6 A. Correct
7 Q. They would put it in their truck, correct?
8 A. Correct.
9 Q. They wouldn't open it and mix it with the

10. trash?
11 A. No.
12 Q. They would take special care of it —
13 A. Absolutely.
14 Q. - so that it was preserved for search?
15 A. Absolutely.
16 Q. They would drive it to a place where the
17 target wouldn't observe the transfer?
18 • A. Correct.
19. • Q. They would hand over the trash to the polio
20 officer, correct?
21 A. Correct.
22 Q. And the purpose of this trash seizure would be
23 to search the trash for investigative evidence, correct?
24 A. Correct.
25 Q. And to your understanding, that was done
Page 357
1 A. They were watched.
2 Q. So you knew when they were going?
3 A. Correct.
4 Q. There was a predestined time tlx:? they worn•
5 going to go; is that correct?
6 A. Correct. Correct.
7 Q. And you saw them go onto Mr. Epstein's
a property.
9 A. Correct.
10 Q. You saw them walk into, through the gates,
11 • whether they were opened or whether they were opened for
12 the people; is that correct?
13 A. Correct.
14 Q. You'd see them walk through the driveway
15 area —
16 A. Correct
17 Q. — Into the garage or near the garage, or was
18 there a point in which they disappeared from your sight?
19 A. I wasn't the one that was watching them.
20 There was other representatives of the Police
21 Department. I'm just telling you how I have always done
22 my trash pulls.
23 Q. So standard practice would be to have an
24 agreement on a time that you would meet the trash people
25 outside the target's residence. • •
Page 359
1 before you commenced your responsibilities m this
2 investigation?
3 A. Before and during.
4 Q. And there was always cooperation by the Palm
5 Beach Sanitation Department, correct?
6 A. Correct
7 Q. They were, in fact, directed not to disclose
8 to Mr. Epstein that they were seizing his trash, not
9 just to bring it to the dump, but to bring it to the
10 officers, correct?
11 A. Correct.
12 Q. And again, this was done not under your watch,
13 but under your supervision while you were case agent on
14 the 2005 fall Epstein investigation, correct?
15 A. Correct.
16 Q. And from the trash, different leads were
17 found; is that right?
38 A. Correct.
19 Q. Leads that might not have been found had you
20 not gone through the trash?
21 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
22 THE WITNESS: I would say some, but not all.
23 BY MR. WEINBERG:
24 • Q. And you saw some message pads?
25 • A. Copies of the messages, yes.

• PROSE COURT 'REPORTING AGENCY
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601
11 (Pages 356 to 359)
INC.. (
c6062637-abo1462c-a836-bc614.314d7a
Page 360

Q. And you later teamed what they were as a
result of your having gone to Mr. Epstein's home on
October 20th, pursuant to a warrant, and seized large
numbers of message pads, correct?

A. Correct
Q. And there were also notes that weren't on
message pads, correct, that were seized from the
garbage?

A. Correct
Q. Notes that were on Mr. Epstein's own pad with
his own name on it, correct?
A. Correct
Q. And some of those notes related to his
business, if you know?
• A. I don't believe so.

Q. But some of the messages led you to phone
numbers and the names of different people, such as
correct?

A. Correct.
Q. And since Ms. M. was first interviewed on
January 9,2006, is it fair to say that the trash pull
from which her identity was first revealed, occurred in
the fall 2005 period while you were case agent?
A. I don't know. Without seeing the actual •
message, I can't commit to that kind of answer.
Page 362
1 Q. Was it your understanding that Ms. M. had
2 been there months before January 9, '06 as contrasted
3 two years?
4 A. As far as, I'm sorry?
5 Q. When you interviewed her on January 9,'06
6 A. Right.
7 Q. — was she telling you of events that occurred
8 years before or months before, if you recall?
9 A. I can't recall.
10 Q. But you do meal! M. was her contact; she
11 was the person who invited her to go to Mr. Epstein's
12 home?
13 A. I believe so.
14 Q. And M. was currently in love with
15 Mr. Epstein in or around the same time period?
16 A. That's what she claimed to me.
17 Q. And did your investigation disclose whether
18 Ms. M. was currently seeing Mr. Epstein in the fall of
19 2005 into the early 2006?
20 A. I can't recall if she was still going to the
21 residence.
22 Q. Ms. ■ told you she was originally told she
23 would be able to model lingerie for a wealthy Palm
24 Beecher, is that correct?
25 A. That's what I documented. That's what she
Page 361
1 Q. Did Ms... tell you when, in relation to
2 January 9, 2006, she had last been to Mr. Epstein's
3 home?
4 A. I can't recall.
5 Q. Did you ask these witnesses, whom you were
6 interviewing, what time period they recall being at his
7 house?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. And if there is nothing in the report, would
10 that reflect —
II A. Well, you're looking at the probable cause
12 affidavit The report will reflect more.
13 .Q. The incident report was — the probable cause
14 affidavit was a subset of the affidavit — strike that.
15 The affidavit is a subset of the incident
16 teport.
17 A. Correct
18 Q. If it's not in the incident report, then does
19 that reflect that you did not ask that question of .?
20 A. I would have asked regardless.
21 Q. Did it inflect that she didn't give you an •
22 answer?
23 A. Some witnesses were able to recall specifics;
24 others were not able to recall exactly when, pinpoint
25 what time.
Page 363
1 told me.
2 Q. And that she was taken to Mr. Epstein's home
3 at El Brillo Way by Ms. M.; is that consistent with
4 your memory?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. And Ms... introduced her to Mr. Epstein; is
7 that correct?
8 A. Yes.
9 lIl And you have no independent memory that
10. Ms. M. ever said that she had any conversation with
11 Mr. ein prior to her being introduced to him by
12 Ms. M.; is that correct?
13 . A. If she had prior conversations with —
14 Q. Yes, with Mr. Epstein before sbe was brought
15 to the house and introduced —
16 A. I can't recall whether she said that or not.
17 I don't believe so.
18 Q. Let me broaden it. Most of the people, if not
19 all of people who you interviewed, were introduced to
20 Mr. Epstein by some other young woman; is that correct?
21 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
22 THE WITNESS: Correct.
23 BY MR. WE114BERO:
24 . Q. Whether Ms... was one,.., correct?
25 • A. Right. •
12 (Pages 360 Lo 363)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY INC. (
Electronically signed by Jeana Rlcciuti (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Rlcciuti (601 c5062637abe1.452c-aS3Sbe814a314d/a
Page 364 Page 366
'1 Q. M. was the second; is that correct, that 1 BY MR. WEINBERG:
2 brought people to his house? 2 Q. Or make phone calls to people that she was not
3 A. (Non-verbal response). 3 introduced to, correct?
4 Q. The routine and practice was for the pimple 4 MS. ARBOUR: Object to fonn.
5 that were introduced to him not to have had any prior 5 THE WITNESS: I knew she made several phone
6 conversations with him until they were introduced by an 6 calls, but it was to people that she knew that had
7 intermediary lace Ms. ■ or Ms. M.; is that correct? 7 been to the house previously.
8 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form. 8 BY MR. WEINBERG:
9 THE WITNESS: I believe so. 9 Q. Sure. So let me take it one step back then.
10 BY MR. WEINBERG: 10 The routine and practice was for one — let's focus on
11 Q. And in fact, there were no exceptions to that 11 — for a woman such as Ms. M., to introduce
12 rule as fares you currently remember? 12 Mr. Epstein to people that she had met or who were her
13 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form. 13 friends, correct?
14 THE WITNESS: As far as I can recall. 14 A. Uh-huh.
15 BY MR. WEINBERG: 15 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
16 Q. I mean, you have no — you don't recall any 16 BY MR. WEINBERG:
17 information that Mr. Epstein was out himself personally 17 Q. And likewise, the.. introduction of..
18 trying to connect with young strange women. 18 fa that standard practice of one woman taking a second
19 A. No. 19 woman to Mr. Epstein and introducing them, correct?
20 Q. And likewise, you have no evidence that 20 MS. ARBOUR Object to form.
21 Mr. Epstein was e-mailing people that he didn't know 21 THE WITNESS: Correct.
22 attempting to ask than or invite than or recruit than to 22 BY MR. WEINBERG:
23 come to his home. 23 Q. And Ms. IIR, at least, told you during your
24 A. No. 24 interview with her in the first week of October 2005,
25 Q. And you have no evidence that Mr. Epstein, 25 that all of the young women that she introduced to
Page 365 Page 367
1 himself; personally was on a telephone trying to connect 1 Jeffrey Epstein knew exactly why they were going to
2 with people to whom he had not previously been 2 . Mr. Epstein's home.
3 introduced, correct? 3 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
4 A. People not known to him? 4 MS. FINNIGAN: Joined.
5 Q. Yes. 5 THE WITNESS: That is what I recall during the
6 A. No, not that I'm aware of. 6 interview.
Q. And so that an one — let me ask the same 7 BY MR. WEINBERG:
8 questions for Ms. You're familiar with 8 Q. And that was corroborated by your reading the
9 her, are you not? 9 report that M. said that she knew what she was doing
10 A. Yes. 10 before she went to Mr. Epstein's home, correct?
11 Q. And you have no evidence that she was out 11 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
12 driving around the Palm Beach area looking to meet some 12 • TIME WITNESS: I believe so, yes.
13 young woman who she, herself, could go and introduce to 13 BY MR. WEINBERG:
14 Mr. Epstein, correct? 14 Q. It was corroborated by others who were
15 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form. 15 identified by M. and thereafter interviewed by you and
16 BY MR.. WEINBERG: 16 others working with you, correct?
17 Q. People that she had never previously met? 17 • MS. ARBOUR: Fenn.
18 MS. ARBOUR: Same objection. .18 THE WITNESS: I believe so.
19 THE WITNESS: Not that I'm aware of. 19 BY MR. WEINBERG:
20 BY MR. WEINBERG: 20 • Q. So that at least for the.. group, if I can
21 Q. And likewise, no evidence that she would 21 • • confine than to by definition the people introduced to
22 e-mail people who she was not introduced to? 22 Mr. Epstein by Ms. M., none of them ever informed you
23 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form. 23 that they had gone there under a misapprehension as to
24 THE WITNESS: Not that Im aware of. 24 what was expected of them, correct?
25 25 • MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
13 (Pages 364 to 367)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. . •
Electronically signed by Jeans RIccliM (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601 c60626374b01412c4836-bc614•3144ffis
Page 368
1 TIM WITNESS: Under the ■ group we're
2 taring about?
3 BY MR. WEINBERG:
4 Q. Yes. Let me break it down. Ms...
5 identified approximately six people that she had
6 introduced to Mr. Epstein.
7 A. Correct.
8 Q. And each of them was invited by Ms... to go
9 to Mr. Epstein's residence, correct?
10 A. Correct.
11 Q. And Mr. Epstein did not know any of these six
12 yotmnvomen prior to being introduced to them by
13 Ms. M., correct?
14 MS. ARBOUR: Fonn.
15 THE WITNESS: As far as I 'mow, yes.
16 BY MR. WEINBERG:
17 Q. And you have no knowledge that IMI=,
18 or anyone else that resided at Mr. Epstein's home on
19 El Brillo had any prior or independent relation with any
20 of the six girls that was being introduced to
21 Mr. Epstein by Ms. M.; is that correct?
22 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
23 THE WITNESS: As far as I know.
24 BY MR. WEINBERG:
25 Q. Ms. H.R. was asked by you and told you that
Recto 370
1 BY MR. WEINBERG:
2 Q. And they came from her pool of friends or
3 associates or people that she made an independent
4 decision to sec whether or not they wanted to go and
5 meet Mr. Epstein, correct?
6 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
7 ME WITNESS: Correct
8 BY MR. WEINBERG:
9 Q. And the people that she invited to
10 Mr. Epstein's house had a choice; they could go to
11 Mr. Epstein's house, give him a massage and be paid or
12 decline to go to Mr. Epstein's house and not give him a
13 massage and not be paid, correct?
14 MS. ARBOUR: FORM
15 THE WITNESS: Correct
16 BY MR. WEINBERG:
17 Q. And did Ms... tell you there wine people
18 that she talked to who decided they didn't want to go to
19 Mr. Epstein's home?
20 A. I can't recall if she actually gave me names
21 of people that she offered to take there and declined.
22 Q. But if you take age out of the equation,
23 you'll agree there arc other residents in Palm Beach
24 that invite people to their homes to engage in paid
25 massages?
Page 369
1 she had a practice of telling each and every one of the
2 people she invited to Mr. Epstein's home, that they were
3 to give Mr. Epstein a massage?
4 A. Correct.
5 Q. And that they could set their own limits while
6 giving Mr. Epstein a massage?
7 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: I recall her saying the more you
9 do, the more you get paid.
10 BY MR. WEINBERG:
11 Q. But do you recall her also saying that you
12 don't have to do anything you don't want to do?
13 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
14 THE WITNESS: I believe so.
15 BY MR. WEINBERG:
16 Q. And she told each and every one of the people
17 she invited that they would be paid for the massage,
18 correct?
19 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
20 THE WITNESS: Correct
21 BY MR. WEINBERG:
22 Q. And she chose the people that she invited to
23 introduce to Mr. Epstein, coned?
24 MS. ARBOUR: Font
25 THE WITNESS: As far as I know, yes.
Page 371
1 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
2 THE WITNESS: What do you mean?
3 BY MR. WEINBERG:
4 Q. I mean, in your history with the Palm Beach
5 Police Department, that have been residents of Palm
6 Beach that have called massage services or escort
7 services and utilized their services, correct?
8 MS. ARBOUR: Same objection.
9 THE WITNESS: I know there are legitimate
10 masseuses that come to the residences and provide
11 massages, if that's what you're trying to claim,
12 yes.
13 BY MR. WEINBERG:
14 Q. I'm not trying to claim anything.
15 A. No, no, no. But I mean, if that's what you're
16 trying to get at, absolutely, if that was your question.
17 Q. And there were also, to your knowledge as an
18 experienced professional officer, there are some not so
19 legitimate escort and massage services that have clients
20 in the Palm Beach area, correct?
21 A. Oh, I'm sure, yeah.
22 Q. And that this is not a prosecutorial target
23 for the Palm Beach Police to go and target at least
24 adult massages, even if they include a sexual element;
25 is that correct?
14 (Pages 368 Lo 371)
PROSE COURT. REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601M
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601 c5062637-abet452c-a836-bc614e314d7a
Page 372 Page 374
1 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
2 THE WITNESS: If there is a crime that's being
3 committed in the Town of Palm Beach, we'll follow
4 upon it.
5 BY MILWEINBERG:
6 Q. But you don't go and look for it
7 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
8 THE WITNESS: When I say that we would solicit
9 it?
10 BY MR. WEINBERG:
11 Q. Yes.
12 A. Probably not. Once we start to see a pattern,
13 especially in the hotels, yes, we would because we have
14 done stings in the past
15 Q. Can you recall in the last fwe years any
16 resident of Palm Beach, a person with a house there,
17 getting arrested for having the paid services of
18 masseuse in their home?
19 A. Are you talking a legitimate masseuse?
20 Q. Any masseuse, legitimate or illegitimate.
21 A. I mean, there's no crime against having a
22 massage at your house.
23 Q. I low about a paid massage that you had a basis
24 to believe was sexual as well as pwfiasional, is there
25 any resident of that island that's —
an escort or a masseuse into their own private
residence, at least over the last five years, correct?

A. I'm trying to think back I know we did make
an arrest off an escort service whae a subject
telephoned an escort service for sexual favors, and we
ended up soliciting an arrest warrant for the individual
for solicitation of prostitution.

Q. And that resulted from your investigation of
the escort service, correct?
A. Based on the interview conducted with him and
believe the escort herself. .

Q. So one in five years? This is not an everyday
investigatory priority of the Palm Beach Police,
correct?

A. No. We have other cases that we follow up on,
but..
Q. And as you sit here now, you remember one
'event, one such arrest in five years?

A. That I can recall. I man...
Q. Fair enough. Let's go back to II.
THE WITNESS: Can we take a five-minute break?
MS. O'CONNOlt: Sure. We need a five-minute
break.
(A brief recess was taken.)
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Page 373
1 A. We have followed up on eases.
2 Q. Is there anyone that you remember in the lest
3 five years that lives in Palm Beach, owns a house on
4 Palm Beach, had a escort or masseuse come to their home
5 and got prosecuted?
6 MS. ARBOUR: Fenn.
7 THE WIINESS: We have had instances where
8 officers have encountered escorts leaving the
9 residences of certain residents in the Town of Palm
10 Beach. They were documented on an intelligence
11 report and we would follow up on it the following
12 day or the day after. We go to their house and
13 identify what escort services, and we have done
14 stings, reverse stings where we contact the escort
15 services.
16 BY MR. WEINBERG:
17 Q. But in those cases, you would be investigating
18 the escorts, not the escortee or not the john? I'm not
19 trying to be difficult
20 A. No, no, no. Pm just —
21 Q. The fact is that in the last five years —
22 A. Pm eying to give you, you 'mow, examples.
23 Q. You've investigated for businesses that have
24 engaged in prostitution, but you have not, to your
25 memory, arrested any citizen of Palm Beach for inviting
Page 375
1 Q. Go back to several areas that we didn't
2 complete. Back to this witness list that you saw in
3 Chief Reiter's office and that Chief Reiter represented
4 to you he was under a directive to destroy, do you know
5 whether or not a copy of that list was made so that it
6 would be available in the event there was a public
7 records request?
8 A. I don't believe so.
9 Q. Do you know whether or not the directive to
10 destroy was given in anticipation of the public records
11: request?
12 A. That, I don't 'mow.
13 Q. Would that document have been within the
14 response to a public records request?
15 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
16 BY MR. WEINBERG:
17 Q. If you know.
18 A. I have no idea.
19 Q. And if that document became part of the case
20 file of the investigation or prosecution of Epstein, it
21 would be suhjcct to a public records request, at least
22 according to what you know about public records,
23 correct?
24 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
25 THE WITNESS: If it was submitted into AC•••••.•
15 (Pages 372 to 375)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY,' INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ftictletl (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciutl (601 c60626374130-46264130-bc814•314d7a
Page 376 , Page 378
I evidence or the attachment file. 1 Q. Yes, for sexual conduct occurring between two
2 BY MR. WEINBERG: • 2 consenting human beings at a restaurant — at a
3 Q In terms of your memory dating back five 3. residence. •
4 years, I asked you about whether you recalled any  4 MS. ARBOUR: Fenn.
5 resident of Palm Beach being arrested for the we or the 5 THE WITNESS: That I can recall.
6 misuse of an escort or massage service, correct? 6 BY MR. WEINBERG:
7 A. Correct. 7 . Back to Ms... She was invited there by
8 Q. And your best manory was that you recall there 8 M., correct?
9 was one such incident, correct? 9 A. I believe so, yes.
10 A. Correct. 10 Q. If you believe Ms..., Ms... deceived her
11 Q. And you do recall investigations of 11 as to the purpose of her going there, correct?
12 prostitution businesses, do you not? 12 A. She was going to go there to model is what I
13 A. Yes. 13 recall.
14 Q. And investigations and escort or massage 14 Q. And.., to your knowledge, had previously
15 businesses that you expected or had reason to believe 15 gone to Mr. Epstein's residence with other people?
16 were prostitution businesses, correct? 16 A. I believe so.
17 A. Correct. 17 Q. And those other people ended up giving a
18 Q. AM those investigations would be oriented 18 massage to Mr. Epstein?
19 towards targeting the people that made money from the 19 A. I believe so.
20 sale of sex, correct? 20 Q. And none of those people that M. brought to
21 A. Correct 21 Mr. Epstein's residence later represented to you that
22 Q. On the flip side, when I asked you about 22 M. said that the only object of the visit was to
23 residents of Palm Beach, twos asking you about people 23 model; is that correct?
24 that would be known as johns, correct? In other 24 A. Repeat that one more time.
25 words — 25 Q. The other people that you interviewed who said
Page 377 Page 379
1 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 1 that Ms... brought them to Mr. Epstein's residence,
2 BY MR. WEINBERG: 2 did not also tell you that they had gone there under a
3 Q. — the customers of a prostitution business. 3 false impression, correct?
4 MS. ARBOUR: Same. 4 A. Ica& recall.
5 771E WITNESS: Correct. 5 Q. If it's in your incident report —
6 BY MR. WEINBERG: 6 A. It would be in there.
7 Q. And the same question, you recall only one 7 Q. — they told you, and if its not in there,
8 person who resides in Palm Beach who was prosecuted for 8 then these different individuals were representing to
9 being a customer of a prostitution business using them 9 you that they knew that they were going there to give
10 to come to his borne, correct? 10 Mr. Epstein a massage?
11 A. I believe so. 11 A. Right, it would have been in the re
12 Q. Do you recall the name of that person? 12 Q. Now, none of the women that Ms. M. invited
13 A. Not off the top of my head. 13 to meet Mr. Epstein ever told you that they went there
14 Q. Take it back ten years, do you recall any 14 for any purpose other than to give him a massage,
15 second such prosecution of a residence of Palm Beach for 15 correct?
16 ming the services of a prostitution or massage or 16 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
17 escort business? 17 THE WITNESS: I believe so.
18 A. Again, we do hold stings in certain hotels, 18 BY MR. WEINBERG:
19 the Breakers, the Four Seasons, the Marriott, where 19 Q. And Ms. El. to Mr. Epstein
20 women and men both go to the bars and solicit. 20.
%introduced
according to what told you on January 9, 2006,
21 Q. But in terms of private residences, in your 21 correct?
22 entire professional life on the Palm Beach Police 22 • A. Correct
23 Department, you only recall one such arrest and 23 lil?And Ms. • told  that Mr. Epstein,
24 prosecution, correct? 24 Ms. M. and Mr. [sic] M. had a conversation at
25 A. At a residence? 25. ' Mr. Epstein's house, correct?.
16 (Pages 376 to 379)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, 'INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Riccluti (601
Electronically signed by Jeans Riccluti (601 65012637-abel-4624-4834-bc014•314474
Page 380 Page 382
1 A. I believe so. 1 A. Yes.
2 Q. And then Ms... told you that both Ms. 2 Q. And Ms... removed her pants and blouse,
3 and Mr. Epstein brought her upstairs into a master 3 correct?
4 bedroom area, correct? 4 A. Correct.
5 A. Yes, if it's in the report, that's... 5 Q. And she didn't say that she tried to run out
6 Q. And then Ms. M. observed a large massage 6 and couldn't get away or anything like that; is that
7 table with a sheet on it; is that your memory that 7 right?
8 Ms. M. told you that she, after meeting Mr. Epstein, A. Correct.
9 she went upstairs to an area of Mr. Epstein's home where Q. Otherwise, those kind of statements would be
10 there was a massage table? 10 clearly incorporated into this probable cause affidavit,
11 A. I believe so. 11 right?
12 Q. And did she tell you that Mr. Epstein came 12 A. Correct.
13 into that area wearing a towel, and that Ms. 13 Q. Because the affidavit was designed to persuade
14 informed Ms. M. they were going to provide Mr. Epstein 14 a judge that there was sufficient evidence to charge
15 with a massage? 15 Mr. Epstein and others with criminal offenses against
16 A. I believe so. 16 the State of Florida.
17 Q. And that when asked M. why they were 17 A. I wouldn't say persuade, but I would state the
18 doing this, explained to that they were going 18 facts.
19 to rub Ins calves and feet? 19 Q. And the purpose of stating the facts was to
20 A. I believe so. 20 fill out what you concluded was probable cause to
21 Q. And that Ms. M. didn't leave the massage 21 warrant the State Attorney from prosecuting Mr. Epstein
22. area at this time, according to her statement to you; is .22 fora criminal offense?
23 that right? 23 A. Correct.
24 A. Right. 24 Q. And this was done by you on May I, 2006,
25 Q. Then Ms. M. told you that she began to 25 correct?
Page 381 Page 383
1 partiate in this massage with Mr. Epstein and 1 A. Correct.
2 Ms. MI, correct? 2 Q. When matters were relatively fresh as
3 A. I believe so. 3 contrasted to how they are in April of 2010?
4 Q. And that Mr. Epstein asked her to get 4 A. Yes.
5 comfortable, do you recall that? 5 Q. And when you prepared this problem cause
6 A. I believe so. 6 affidavit, you were largely relying on your supplemental
7 Q. And that Nis... elected to take off her 7- reports in the omnibus Palm Beach incident report,
clothes leaving on only her pants; is that correct or 8 correct?
9 panties? 9 A. Correct
10 Do you want to read this? 10 Q. And you were not relying to your current
11 A. If you don't mint 11 memory on any tape recording of this statement on
12 Q. This is page 20 of E:dtibit I, which is 12 January 9th with Ms. M., were you?
13 Detective Reearey's — 13 A. A tape recording?
14 MR. PIKE: If you would, could you please turn 14 Q. Yes.
15 to that page because there's some writing on this 15 A. Like I said, I have reviewed tape recordings
16 one and I don't want to — 16 that I've conducted on interviews.
17 MR. WEINBERG: This is not the incident 17 Q. Which ones did you listen to before you
18 report This is the probable cause affidavit 18 executed an affidavit on May I st?
19 MS. ARBOUR: I have an extra one, I think. 19. A. I couldn't tell you.
20 MR. WEINBERG: Thank you. 20 Q. Would you have a note, record, diary,
21 BY MR. WEINBERG: 21 reference —
22 Q. Were on page 20, about five or six lines 22 A. No.
23 down. In paragraph I, Epstein told Ms. M. to get 23 Q. — any way to construct which ones you
24 comfortable. Actually, its seven lines down on the 24 listened to?
25 left side, page 20. 25 A. No.
17 (Pages 380 to 383)
( 561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY,
Electronically signed by Jeana Medea (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601
INC.
c50626374the1452e-0364n6144414d7a
Page 384
1 Q. Tape recordings would, of course, be the most
2 reliable predicate for what, in fact, a witness told
3 you, correct?
4 MS. ARBOUR: Object to form.
5 BY MR. WEINBERG:
6 Q. But they are also longest to wade through.
correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form
9 BY MR. WEINBERG:
10 Q. In other words, they take more time to hear
11 than reading a summary would take to read?
12 MS. ARBOUR: Same objection.
13 THE WITNESS: As far as, like, if you heard
14 it?
15 BY MR. WEINBERG:
16 Q. Yes. It would take you however many hours —
17 A. Right, depending on the length of the
18 interview. I mean, some could have been an hour, some
19 could have been two hours.
20 Q. How long  was the lengthy one, if you remember?.
21 A. I believe it was — it would have been over an
22 hour. She was still in high school and she had to get
23 back.
24 Q. But you have no memory that you, in fact,
25 listened to Ms. tape at or before the time you
Page 386

A. I may have listened to Ms. Jane Doc 103's
interview while I was doing the supplement.
Q. But you have no memory as you sit here now
that you listened to it in the last days of April or
around May 1, 2006, before summarizing the recitation by

Ms. Jane Doe 103 into this probable cause affidavit,
correct?
A. If I listened to it prior to writing the PC?
is that what you're asking me —

Q. Yes. Yes.
A. — if I listened to it prior to writing the
Q. Yes, prior to.
A. No, I can't recall if I did or didn't.

Q. And I'll ask the same questions regarding your
preparation of the search warrant affidavit. You had
tape recordings available to you, did you not?

A. Yes, I did.
Q. This investigation generated approximately 22
tapes?
A. Approximately.
Q. Most of which were generated before
October 18, 2005 when you authored an affidavit setting
to search Mr. Epstein's private residence, correct?

A. Correct
Page 385
1 summarized your memory of your conversations with her
2 into this affidavit on May 1st, correct?
3 A. I can't say if I did or didn't.
4 Q. And the same thing with do you recall
5 whether or not that was one of the tapes you listened to
6 before summarizing what she had said to you in October
7 of 2005 into this probable cause affidavit?
8 A. M.'s was different. M.'s was a videotape
9 conducted at the Palm Beach Police Department.
10 02Did you watch and listen to the videotape of
11 the M. interview?
12 A. I may have.
13 . Q. But you don't recall which ones you didn't or •
14 did, correct?

15. A. Correct.
16 Q. And same with Jane Doe 103, October II, 2005,
17 interview in Tallahassee, that was tape recorded, was it
16 not?
19 A. Yes, it was.
20 Q. The telephone call the day before was not tape
21 recorded; is that correct? '
22 A. I may have recorded that one.
.23 . Q. .Do you recall whedier.you listened to either •

24. • or both of those tape recordings prior to executing the
25 May 1, 2006 affidavit?
Page 387
1 Q Did you listen to all of those tape recordings
2 prior to drafting an affidavit that was intended to
3 result in the judicial authorization of a search and
4 seizure of Mr. Epstein's residence?
A. I may have, as I was doing my supplements.
6 Q. Pm directing myself towards the time period
7 when you were drafting the affidavit that was going to
8 be filed with the judge to ask for permission to search
9 Mr. Epstein's residence.
10 Did you listen to those tapes contemporaneous
11 • with your authoring the search warrant affidavit?
12 A. I can't recall if f did or didn't.
13 Q. If you did, would there be any note, report,
14 log entry that you did?
15 A. Not that I've kept am, no.
16 Q. You don't have a current memory of being at a
17 typewriter typing in your affidavit fora search
18 warrant --
19 A. We don't utilize a typewriter, but —
20 Q. A computer?
21 A. A computer.
22 Q. It shows my age.
23 You typed into a computer the affidavit that
24 ultimately went to a judge to --
25 A. Correct
(561)—832-7.500
18 (Pages 384 to 387)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, 'INC. • S
Electronically signed by Jeana Rice-lug (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Riccluti (601 c5062637-abet -452c-a836-bc614e314d7a
Page 388
1 Q. seek authority to search Mr. Epstein's
2 home?
3 A. Correct.
4 Q. And you did that in your office?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. And in your office, is there a tape recorder?
7 A. Yes, we do have tape recorders. We have —
8 Q. And you had access to the tape recordings of
9 the witness interviews, did you not, at the time?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. And you don't recall today whether or not you
12 listened to any or. all of them at or around the time
13 that you drafted the search warrant affidavit?
14 A. I can't recall if I did or didn't
15 . Q. Your best memory is that you relied on the
16 supplemental reports authored by you as the predicate
17 for what you represented to 'judge warranted his •
18 authorizing a search and seizure of Mr. Epstein's
19 property, correct?
20 A. Correct
21 Q. Back to Ms... This is the first time she
22 was at Mr. Epstein's home that she was telling you about
23 on January 9th, correct?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And she ultimately told you about two
Page 390
1 Q. And Ms. M. said she started to nib
2 Mr. Epstein's 'chest; is that correct?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. AM that's in addition to what she had been .
5 told, which is that she and Ms. M. were going to rub
6. his calls and feet; is that right?
7 A. Correct.
8 Q. And she didn't say at this time that she in
9 any way was being forced or coerced into giving
10 Mr. Epstein a massage, correct?
11 A. Correct.
12 Q. Mr. Epstein, according to her recollection,
13 began to masturbate; is that right?
14 A. Yes, as he stroked her vagina.
15 Q. But she told you that Mr. Epstein was touching
16 her breast and touching her vagina; is that correct?
17 A. Correct.
18 Q. And she didn't tell yon she protested or
19 objected to such touching, did she?
20 A. No.
21 Q. Because it would be in your report?
22 A. It would be in the report if it did.
23 Q. And she then told you that she was paid $200
24 for the massage, correct?
25 A. Correct.
Page 389
1 occasions that she went there; is that correct?
2 A. I believe so.
3 Q. And she, in fact, went back a third time, did
4 she not? Did she not?
5 A. I can't recall whether she — how many times
6 she went without looking at it.
7 Q. Let's first look at what's in front of you,
8 which is the probable cause aflidaviL She removed her
9 pants and blouse, correct?
10 A. Correct.
11 Q. And that was a voluntarily act on her part in
12 response to Mr. Epstein telling her to getting
13 comfortable, correct?
14 A. Correct.
15 Q. And that she stayed only in panties because
16 she didn't have a bra on that evening, correct?
7 A. Correct.
18 Q. So she took off her shirt and, therefore, was
19 naked froni the waist up; is that right? •
20 A. Correct
21 Q. AM Ms... was still there; is that right?
22 A. (Non-verbal response).
23 Q. And the two of them were massaging
24 Mr. Epstein?
25 A. Yes.
Page 391
1 Q. And she was tearful, at least during parts of
2 this interview; is that correct?
3 A. Correct.
4 Q. But she didn't tell you that she refused the
5 $200, correct?
6 A. Right.
7 Q. And she didn't tell you that she was so
8 tranwiatizni injured or damaged by this incident that
9 she didn't voltmtarily return several days later,
10 coned?
11 A. I'm sorry, one more time.
12 Q. She didn't tell you that she was traumatized
13 by this event at the time it occurred, did she?
14 A. I don't recall her saying that she was
15 traumatized.
16 Q. Or in any way injured because she, infect,
17 was Invited to return and did return several days later
18 alone; is that right?
19 A. I believe so.

20. . In other words, she told you, if you recall,
21 that she received several days later a telephone call
22 from la is that correct?
23. . A. Correct. .
24 Q. And who essentially invited for to conic back,
25 correct?
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY,
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricclutl (MI
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricdutl (401
19 (Pages 388 to 391
INC.
c5062637.abol-462c-a836-bc614e31ed7a
Page 392 Page 394
1 A. Right, to work.
2 Q. And this time, she wasn't with M. ?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. AM she elected to return to Mr. Epstein's
5 house, this time knowing that it was not to model
6 lingerie?
7 A. Correct.
8 Q. And in fad,  went back on her own as a
9 response to Ms. inviting her to give Mr. Epstein
10 a second massage?
11 A. Correct.
12 Q. And again, Mr. Epstein — she went upstair to
13 Mr. Epstein's bedroom area and gave Mr. Epstein a
14 massage, correct?
15 A. Correct.
16 Q. And again, she was paid for that massage,
17 correct?
18 A. Correct.
19 Q. And she didn't, between the dates of these tvio
20 massages and the date you went to her house on
21 January 9, 2006, or went to her school, she didn't call
22 you or didn't ask her parents to call you to complain
23 about the conduct that occurred at El Brillo, correct?
24 A. Correct.
25 Q. Now, if we switch for a second from your
1 If we start on 73 since it's redacted, I
2 want to assure you I'm talking about what I believe to
3 be the same interview on January 9, 2006. Paragraph 3
4 is. telling you she was told she could model
5 lingerie, and then much of the same right up to the last
6 sentence where she stated she went to Mr. Epstein's
7 house three or four times total.
8 - A. Right.
9 Q. And then on the next paragraph, she was
10 telling you that she once brought a friend?
11 A. Correct.
12 Q. Some of the young women told you they were
13 terribly upset while talking to you; is that correct?
14 A. Correct.
15 Q. And they had a variety of reasons to be upset,
16 didn't they?
17 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
18 BY MR. WEINBERG:
19 Q. To your knowledge.
20 A. To my knowledge, yeah, absolutely.
21 Q. One thing is that some of the women yawere
22 interviewing, for instance Ms... and Ms. M., twit:
23 actively bringing third parties to visit Mr. Epstein; k
24 that correct?
25 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
8.
Page 393
affidavit to your incident report, do you recall that
she went back a third time and brought a friend a third
time?

A. I believe — I believe she may have brought
someone.
Q. AM do you recall who she brought?
A. Not off the top of my head, no.

Q. AM do you recall writing on page 74 of your
incident report that she once brought a friend, and she
said that she didn't know the last name, to give

Mr. Epstein a massage and that she was paid $200 for .
bringing a friend?
A. !can't readL
Q. Perhaps you can read page 74 and see if that
refreshes your recollection.

A. Page 74?
Q. Yes.
Just to orient you, it's her interviews with
you start on page 73. The first of January 9, 2006.
There's some redactions, but if you refer to
paragraph 3, you'll sec that she was the person who told
you she could model lingerie and then it continues.

A. I think your 74 is different than this 74.
Q. We have different reports? May I sec yours
for a second?
1 THE WITNESS: Correct.
2 BY MR. WEINBERG:
3 Q. And being paid for it?
4 MS. ARBOUR: Fa
5 TIIE WITNESS: Yes.
6 BY MR. WEINBERG:
7 Q. And that constitutes a violation of the
8 Florida statutes, does it not?
9 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
10 THE WITNESS: For unlicensed massages or...
11 BY MR. WEINBERG:
12 Q. For any and — I mean, did you believe that
13 you threatened Ms... with a criminal prosecution, did
14 you not, when she was videotaped on October 5, 2005
15 being interviewed?
16 MS. ARBOUR Form.
17 • THE WITNESS: I didn't threaten Ms..., but
18 I did explain to her that what she did was illegal.
19 BY MR. WEINBERG:
20 Q. Was illegal?
21 A. Right
.22 Q. And similarly, what Ms... did was illegal?
23 • MS. ARBOUR: Fain..
24 • BY MR. WEINBERG:
25 Q. In your mind.
20 (Pages 392 to 395)
PROSE. COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC."
Electronically signed by Jeans Medlin (601
Electronically signed by Jeans Riccluti (601 e6082637-abel-48204836-be614•314dra
Page 396

MS. ARDOUR: Same objection.
2 THE WITNESS: Pretty much. I mean, you
4 BY MR. WEINBERG:
5 Q. Did you ever conduct a criminal investigation
6 of Ms. M.?
7 A. No.
8 Q. Did you ever conduct any followup
9 investigation of Ms... when she declined to speak to
10 you?
11 A. No.
12 Q. To your knowledge, did you or anyone else in
13 the Palm Beach Police Department have any contact with
14 Ms. M. during the time period of this investigation
15 which began in March of '05 and ended in December of
16 '06?
17 A. I spoke to her that one time and didn't speak
18 to her again.
19 Q. Eva seen a report from anyone else in Palm
20 Beach that ever spoke to her?
21 A. I don't believe anyone else spoke with her.'
22 Q. And you did no background on her to your best
23 recollection in terms of her character, her reputation,
24 her credibility, correct?
25 A. No.
Page 398
1 to her and her father that she had lied to her father
2 about her visit with Mr. Epstein, correct?
3 A. Again, I don't know if she lied to her father.
4 I know she went there originally with the intentions to
5 model.
6 Q. But she never told her father she had been
7 paid for topless massages, comet?
8 A. Not to my knowledge.
9 Q. And her father told you what he knew of what
10 she had done or not done with Mr. Epstein, collect?
11 A. As far as he knew, yes.
12 Q. And clearly, there was at least a lie by
13 omission from Ms. M. to the father or the father to
14 you, correct, because Ms.. was telling you she did
15 far more than her father told you she did?
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. And she was not the only minor that you
18 interviewed, correct?
19 A. Correct.
20 Q. And therefore, Mr. I was not the only parent
21 • that you had occasion to say that you were doing an
22 investigation in which their daughter was either a
23 witness or a victim, coned?
24 A. Correct.
25 • Q. And you know, from having conducted followup
1/
.24
Page 397

Q. Likewise, Ms. did you do any background
to determine whether she was a credible, trustworthy,
reliable source of information about Mr. Epstein?

A. Based on the sworn taped statement that I took
of Ms. M., I mean, she had specific knowledge as to
persons within the home, descriptions of the home,
within the home, within the bath — you know, the
bedroom, the bathroom area.

Q. But she was telling you, was she not, that she
was emotionally — had emotional consequences to what
she did; is that right? She was crying at different
times she was talking to you; is that right?

A. Absolutely.
Q. And several of the girls did; is that right?
A. Absolutely.
Q. And one of the realities were that their
parents were fording out what happened, correct?

A. Yes, in some of the victims, yes, the parents
did find out.
Q. And that was traumatizing to them, was it not?
MS. ARBOUR: Fonn.
THE WITNESS: I'm sure it was embarrassing for
than, yes.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. In fact, with it was becoming clear
Page 399
1 and interviews, that parents learned a lot more as a
2 result of your visits than they had learned beforehand
3 regarding what had occurred between their daughters and
4 Mr. Epstein, correct?
5 MS. ARBOUR: Pam.
6 THE WITNESS: Right.
7 BY MR. WEINBERG:
8 Q. And that you also knew that sane of the tears
9 that were being shed were being shed by the girls
10 because suddenly their parents were involved, correct?
11 MS. ARBOUR Form
12 THE WITNESS: I don't know if the tears were
13 because the parents were involved. I know that
14 there was a lot of shame, a lot of embarrassment
15 BY MR. WEINBERG:
16 Q. A lot of fear, fear of school?
17 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
18 THE WITNESS: I know, in Ms. case,
19 she was in fear of Mr. Epstein.
20 BY MR. WEINBERG:
21 Q. And do you know in Ms. case she was
22 also in fear of her school friend in that which she had
23 done?
24 Let's step back a step. What she had done is
25 she had gotten money for a sexual massage, correct?
21 (Pages 396 to 399)
PROSE COURT' REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronic/By signed by Jeans Rleekel PM= Electrote signed by Jeans Rlcdutl (401 c6062637,41301-462e4a136-bc614•31467a
Page 400
1 A. She got money for providing a massage while
2 Mr. Epstein touched her breasts and fondled her vagina
3 Q. Would you consider that this fans within the
4 broad ambit of prostitution?
5 MS. ARBOUR: Form
6 THE WETNESS: Prostitution would be for sex
7 for money.
8 BY MR. WEINBERG:
9 Q. So Ms. M. did not engage in prostitution,
10 but others did, during the course of the investigation?
11 MS. ARBOUR: Form
12 • THE WITNESS: I wouldn't say others did. Ifs
13 a negotiation. If you're paying for a sex act,
14 it's a negotiation. You get X for Y.
15 BY MR. WEINBERG:
16 Q. So that if the negotiation was purely for a
17 topless massage, then there was no prostitution?
18 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
19 THE WITNESS: Not in my eyes, no.
20 BY MR. WEINBERG:
21 Q. So in your eyes, were any of the so-called
22 victim/witnesses, did any of them engage in
23 prostitution?
24 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
25 THE WITNESS: Do you mean since that time,
I0
Page 402
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. Correct?
MS. ARBOUR: Same objection.
THE WITNESS: The negotiation part, X for Y.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. So absent the negotiation, there is no
prostitution?

MS. ARBOUR: Fonn.
THE WITNESS: No.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. And therefore, in your opinion, the women
going to see Mr. Epstein were not going there pursuant
to a prostitution agreement, correct?

A. Coned.
Q. They were going there as consenting adults or
even consenting minors to do something other than
prostitution?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: They were going there to provide
the manage but, you're right, it wasn't
prostitution.
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. And in fact, had some of these girls that went
there who were under 18, had they been over 18, then
this entire case would have been a consenting massage
Page 401
or —
2 BY MR. WEINBERG:
3 Q. Well, let's start with that time, when
4 Mr. Epstein was the customer. Were any of the women
5 going to his house engaging in prostitution, in your
6 opinion?
7 MS. ARBOUR: Form
8 THE WITNESS: In my opinion?
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. Yes.
A. No.
Q. And that included those who were going to his
house who were above 18 as well as below 18, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: Like I was told, people that I
interviewed that were above 18, what happened
between them were between two consenting adults.
BY MR. WEINBIRO:

Q. And so to your mind, it's not the giving of
money, it's the negotiated agreement that constitutes
the essential element that distinguishes prostitution
from simply a consensual act as long as the people who
engaged in it were both over 18?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
Page 403
case, correct?
MS. ARBOUR: Form.
MS. FINNIGAN: Form.
THE WITNESS: If they axle over 18?
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. Yes.
A. That it would have just been what, a massage
ease, you mid?
Q. It would have been a case between two
consenting adults, other than prostitution.

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: Unless we got a complaint.
BY MR. WEINBERG
Which you didn't get in this case, other than
the parent Mmeh '05 complaint as a result of
overhearing a discussion?

MS. FINNIGAN: Form.
THE WITNESS: Right.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. Ms... certainly, although emotional during
her interview, never said that anybody forced her to
return to Mr. Epstein's house on the second occasion
when she gave a second massage, correct?

A. Coned.
Q. And she never said anybody forced her to bring
22 (Pages 400 to 403)
.( 561) 832-750.0 • PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricclull (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciutf (601 c6062637-abo1-462c-a836-be614e314d7a
Page 404
a friend over fora third visit, correct?

A. Correct. .
Q. And at most, your evidence reflected that
there were many young women that, in fact, called

Mr. Epstein's house seeking to come over to give him
massages, correct?
. 6
7 A. Yes, there were messages from various people 7
8 that called. 8
9 Q. And that when someone in Mr. Epstein's 9
10 residence called out to any of these young people, it 10
11 was, at most, to schedule a visit, correct? • 11

12. MS. ARBOUR: Form. 12
13 THE WITNESS: Correct. 13
14 BY MR. WEINBERG: 14
15 S None of these girls complained that MI 15
16 or anyone else threatened them to come over? 16
17 A. No, there was no threats to come over, no. 17
18 Q. No coercion to come over? • 18
19 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 19
20 MS. FINNIGAN: Form. 20
21 BY MR. WEINBERG: 21
22 Q. Is that correct? 22
23 A. Not thatim aware of. 23
24 Q. None of the As ever told you that their 24
25 calls with were anything more than an 25
Page 405
1 visitation to come over? 1
2 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 2
3 BY MR. WEINBERG: 3
4 Q. A scheduling call? 4
5 MS. ARBOUR: Same objection. 5
6 BY MR. WEINBERG: 6
7 Q. Correct? 7
8 A. As far as l know, yes. 8
9 Q. And the same with anyone else in Mr. Epstein's 9
10 household, no one ever said they got a phone call from 10
11 anyone who lived at El Brillo doing anything roore than 11
12 seeing if they wanted to schedule a visit, correct? 12
13 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 13
14 THE WITNESS: I believe so. 14
15 BY MR. WEINBERG: 15
16 Q. No one ever said they negotiated amounts of 16
17 money on the phone; is that correct? 17
18 A. Not that I recall, no. 18
19 Q. No one ever said that they were required to . 19
20 make promises of sexual performance on the phone as a .20
21 condition of being invited to come over? 21
22 MS. ARBOUR: Form. • 22.
23 . THE WITNESS: No, I don't believe so. 23
24 ' BY MR. WEINBERG: 24
25 so thophone part of it was simply a 25
Page 406
scheduling communication, to the best of your knowledge,
based on all of your many conversations with your many
witnesses?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: Right
BY MR. WEINBERG:.
Q. And once they are at his house, none of the
girls claimed that he violently forced them to do
anything they didn't want; is that correct?

MS. ARBOUR Form.
MS. FINNIGAN: Form.
THE WITNESS: There was an instance where
that was a vaginal penetration.
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. And you recall, as soon as the person
protested, Mr. Epstein apologized and stopped that act;
is that right?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: I believe so, yes.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. And that was Ms. Jane Doe 103?
A. Yes.

Q. And she was — turned 18 in December of 2004,
correct?
MS. FINNIGAN: Form.
Page 407
THE WITNESS: I'm not sure of the time frame
where she turned la.
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. Let me see if I can find this for you. At the
bottom of page 10 of that affidavit, on September I1,
2005, WFAH, DOB, 12/30/1986 was arrested by the Palm
Beach Police Department That's the same Jane Doe 103
that we're talking about, correct? It's the very last
line. I'm only pointing out the date of birth.

A. Yes.
Q. So she was 18 as of
correct? •
A. What page was that, I'm sorry?
Q. This is the bottom of page 10.

A. She would have been 18, yes, in 2004.
Q. And she didn't • you a date on this one.
• A.
Q. 2004. And when you interviewed Ms. Jane Doe
103 on October 10th and October 11th, and she told you
about this one event where there was momentary
penetration, she protested, Mr. Epstein immediately
apologized and ended that sex act, that she didn't give
you a date that that occurred, did she?

A. I can't recall if she did or she didn't.
Q. If she gave you a date, it would be in the
(561) 832-7500 PROSE COURT. REPORTING .AGENCY INC.
23 (Pages 404 to 407)
: ..(561) 832-75OS.
Electronically signed by Jeanie Ricciutl (601
Electronically signed by Jeans Ricciutl (601 a0828374ball-4112o-e8364:614.3• 14dfa • •
Page 408
1 report-
2 A. Yes, sir.
3 Q. -- and if she didn't, either the didn't
4 remember or she wasn't asked; is that right?
5 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
6 THE WITNESS: No, I know that I would have
7 asked ha..
8 BY MR. WEINBERG:
9 Q. So if we don't have a date in the report as to
10 how long before October 10 and 11, 2005 that single
11 event occurred, then she didn't remember; is that right?
12 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
13 THE WITNESS: Can you ask that question one
14 more time?
15 BY MR. WEINBERG:
16 Q. Sure If there's no date for that —
17 A. Then she did not recall that specific date.
18 Q. And therefore, since she was seeing
19 Mr. Epstein, according to what she told you, over some .
20 extensive period of tiro it could have occurred while
21 she was — before or it could have
22 occurred after we just have no way of
23 knowing?
24 A. It would have been before because one of the
25 last times that she met with him was when she provided
Page 410
1 about five or six-month period after she turned 18 on
3 A. I'm trying to recall, because I do remember
4 her stating that she was going less and less. I'm
5 trying to recall, because I know she was going less and
6 less to his residence.
7 Q. Do you recall writing in this probable cause
8 affidavit that events that Jane Doe 103 advised you
9 . that her relationship continued to escalate during the
10 . period she saw Mr. Epstein?
11 A. From the beginning, yes.
12 Q. Yes, and we can — and this event where she
13 said no and Epstein stopped, was an escalation of their
14 contact in an earlier appearance, correct?

A. I'm trying to recall. She had gone to his
16 house — she had been going to his house for several
17 years, and I think that was the escalation, what you .
18 meant.
19 Q. And it's fair to say that some subset of those •
20 couple of years occurred after she turned IS, and a
21 significant part of it was before she turned 18,
22 coned?
23 A. The significant part, I would say --
24 Q. If there was two years and she graduated high
25 school in the spring of 2005, then she saw him — part
Page 409
1 her high school transcript because he was going to
2 assist her in getting her into a college.
3 Q. And when was that; a high school transcript?
4 The high school year ends in the spring?
5 A. It would have been, yes.
6 Q. And not in December?
7 A. Cornet
8 Q. And so if she turned 18 in December, that
9 would have been in the middle of her senior year in high
10 school?
11 A. Correct
12 Q. And therefore, she continued to see
13 Mr. Epstein after she was 18 and up to the period
14 immediately before her graduation in the spring of 2005,
15 cornea?
16 Let me date it another way. She was a •
17 freshman at college when you went to see her in October
18 of 2005?
19 A. Correct. ' •
20 • . Q. Therefore, she was a senior in high school up • •
21 through the spring of 2005?
22 A. Correct.
23 Q. And therefore, since she gave Mr. Epstein her
24 transcript, shortly before or at the time of her.
25 graduation, she was still seeing Mr. Epstein for this
Page 411
1 of it when she was 18, after she tamed 18 on
2 and part of it was before she walla,
3 correct?
4 A. I would assume so.
5 Q. And she didn't give you a date when the single
6 act, where she said no and Mr. Epstein stopped occurred,

7. it's not in your report and you don't have an
8 independent memory, correct?
9 A. Correct. '
1.0 Q. How many times have you personally interviewed
11 Ms. Jane Doe 103?
12 A. !vane to say two.
13 Q. October in Tallahassee and then again in the
14 March period in Tallahassee again?
15 A. One was in Jacksonville, one was in
16 ' Tallahassee.
1.7 Q. And you have not personally seen her or
18 interviewed her since 2006?
19 A. I delivered a grand jury subpoena.
.20 Q. To her in April 2006?
21 • A, I believe so.
22 Q. And have you ever seen her since then?
23 _. , A. • No.
24 Q. Have you ever spoken to her since the grand
25 jury returned an indictment against Mr. Epstein?
.(561) .832-7;500 PROSE COURT
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricclutl (601
Electronically signed by Jeans 'Melon (601
24 (Pages 408 to 411)
REPORTING AGENCY,...INC. ..(561). 832-7506.
e15062687-abe1-452c-a834143c8140314d7a
Page 412
1 A. I don't believe so.
2 Q. Have you had any e-mails or text messages or
3 any communication with Ms. Jane Doe 103 in the last
4 three and a half years? .
5 A. No.
6 Q. So with Ms. M., just so I'm clear, there was
7 no intercourse between her and Mr. Epstein, correct?
8 A. I don't believe so.
9 Q. No oral sex that she complained of to you?
10 A. No.
11 Q. No forced sex she complained of to you?
12 A. • No.
13 Q. She never said that she had seen Mr. Epstein
14 anywhere outside of his residence, correct?
15 A. What do you mean?
16 Q. She never claimed that Mr. Epstein took her on
17 his airplane awhere?
18 A. Ms. IS?
19 Q. Yes.
20 A. Not that I'm aware of.
21 Q. And she never claimed that Mr. Epstein took
22 her on any trips outside of his private residence,
23 correct?
24 A. Not that I'm aware of.
25 Q. So the three or four times she and Mr. Epstein
Page 414
1 Q. In other words, Mr. Epstein in now way
2 generated personal profits from any of his massages or

3. contacts with any of the witnesses that were involved in
4 your case, correct?
5 MS. ARBOUR; Form.
6 • THE WITNESS: Not that Fm aware of.
7 BY MR. WEINBERG:
8 Q. You have no evidence that M. ever gave
9 Mr. Epstein money or that ■ ever gave Mr. Epstein
10 money as part of his share of these incidents, correct?
11 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
12 THE WITNESS: Not that I'm aware of.
13 BY MR. WEINBERG:
14 Q. M. told you that she had met Mr. Epstein
15 about a year before pa 2005 interview; do
16 you remember that?
17 A. Uh-huh.
18 Q. And her birth dater on
19 page 15 of your affidavit,
20 A. Yes, sit
21 ' Q. So therefore, she was 18 in of 200s,
22 correct?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. So there she was 18 when you interviewed
25 her on 2005; is that right?
Page 413
/ were physically in the same location, according to her,
2 occurred exclusively on El Drilla; is that right?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. Let me switch to another person
5 interviewed, M.  Do you remember
6 A. Yes.
7 And do you remember interviewing her in
8 of 2005?
9 A. That would have been around that time.
10 Q. By the way, just let me step back one second.
11 When Ms... brought another girl to Mr. Epstein's
12 home, she told you she, Ms. was paid for that; is
13 that right? She was paid —
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. You have no evidence in this case that any of
16 the girls who gave Mr. Epstein massages ever paid money
17 to Mr. Epstein?
18 A. What do you mean?
19 Q. There is no money flowing back to Mr. Epstein,
20 or to any of the people employed by Mr. Epstein, from

21. any of the young women that gave him massages at his •
22 house, correct?
23 A. That money went back to Mr. Epstein?
24 Q. Yes.
25 A. Not that fm aware of.
Page 415
1 • • A. Yes.
2 Q. And if she met Mr. Epstein one year before
3 your interview, then she met him when she was 17?
4 A. Or depending on the date when she met him, she
5 could have been on the edge of 16, beginning of 17.
6 Q. And do you recall who introduced her to
7 Mr. Epstein?
8 A. 1 believe it was
9 Q. And if your report reflects
10 lime Doe 103?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. And she, like the others, was introduced to
13 Mr. Epstein by a third party, one of their friends; is
14 that right?
15 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
16 . • THE WITNESS: rm sorry?

17. BY MR. WEINBERG:
18 Q. Like others, she, M. was introduced to
19 Mr. ein by another young girl that was friends with
20.. Ms. M., correct?
21 A. Yes.
22 . Q. And that, in this case, was Ms. Jane Doe 103,
23 correct?
24 A. Yes.

25. Q. And Ms. Jane Doe 103 took her to Mr. Epstein's
, maybe.
would that be
25 (Pages 412 to 415)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY,".INC.. :
Electronically signed by Jeana RIcciuti (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Rlcciuti (601 660624337-abirt-462o-a836441114•314Ca
Page 416
house, correct?

A. Yes.
Q. And does your report affidavit reflect a
had heard that several girls were making money by
providing massages to Epstein and she agreed and was
taken to the house by Ms. Jane Doe 103?

A. Yes.
Q. So Ms. Jane Doe 103, like Ms. would tell
Page 418
THE WITNESS: What do you mean "profited"?
BYMR. WEINBERG:

Q. He didn't make any money by seeing.,
correct?
MS. ARBOUR: Same objection.
THE WITNESS: Not that Tin aware of.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. He, at most, paid for the massages he
9 people, you know, that if they went to see Mr. Epstein, 9 received, correct?
10 they were expected to give him a massage, correct? 10 MS. ARBOUR. Form.
11 MS. ARBOUR Form. 11 BY MR. WEINBERG:
12 THE WITNESS: Possibly, yes. 12 Q. That's what Ms... represented to you?
13 BY MR. WEINBERG: 13 A. Yes.
14 Q. And in this case, at least, Ms. a. went 14 Q. And on one occasion, she said when she was 17,
15 there with her eyes open? In other words, she 15 she consensually agreed to engage in sex with
16 volunteered to go there and try to make money by giving 16 Mr. Epstein, correct?
17 Mr. Epstein a massage just like she understood several 17 A. Yes.
18 other girls in her community had done? 18 Q. Nobody threatened her, right?
19 A. Correct. 19 A. Not that I'm aware of.
20 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 20 Q. She seemed like a relatively mature
21 BYMR. WEINBERG: 21 18-year-old when you spoke to her?
22 Q. And Ms. like others, never complained to 22 A. Yes.
23 you, she never wont to you herself before you went to 23 Q. And this occurred just shortly before her
24 her; is that right? 24 interview with you, correct?
25 A. Correct. 25 A. What do you mean "shortly before"?
Page 417 Page 419
1 Q. And she didn't initiate any complaints through 1 Q. Meaning that her recollection that on one
2 any parent, teacher, medical professional, law 2' occasion she had had sex with Mr. Epstein, consensual
3 enforcement officer or anybody else to your knowledge? 3 sex occurred shortly before she was interviewed by you
.4 A. Not to my knowledge. 4 in of 2005, correct? .
5 Q. And be went directly to her because she was S A. Right.
6 18 in correct? 6 Q. She, too, introduced others to Mr. Epstein.
7 A. Correct 7 did she not? .
8 Q. And she told you that she, in fact, during the 8. A. Yes, I believe so.
9 first time, wearing thong panties, gave Mr. Epstein a Q. And do you ranentber interviewing her — within
10 massage, coual? 10 a week of your interview with Ms. a., you interviewed
11 A. Yes. 11 someone with the initials.? We can find this on
12 Q. And that she received money for that, correct? 12 page 16?
13 A. Yes. 13 A. Yes.
14 Q. And there was no prior arrangement of money 14 Q. At the bottom of page 16 of the affidavit,
15 for sex, so this, too, was not prostitution, correct? 15 Detective Samut (phonetic) and you on November 15th, met
16 A. Correct. 16 and during the sworn statement said she had met
17 Q. And she returned 15 times to Mr. Epstein's 17 Mr. Epstein a year . And she was — her date of
18 residence, correct? 18 birth on this report i Do you see that
19 A. A total of, yes, that's what she recalled. 19 four lines up on the bottom of  16?
20 Q. On at least one of the occasions, she was with 20 A. It would have been M. Is that the one
21 Ms. Jane Doe 103 who was also was paid $200, correct? 21 you're talking about?
22 A. Correa. 22 Q. This is on the bottom of page 16,
23 Q. And Mr. Epstein, in no way financially 23 . "November 15th, Detective Samut and I met with a.
24 profited from his relationship with correct? 24 A. You're on — yeah.
25 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 25 Q. I'm probably on a different-page than you. Do

(561) 832-7500.
26 (Pages 416 to 419)
PROSE COURT -REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciull (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciutl (601 c6062637-abe1-452c-a836-bc614e314d7a
Page 420
1 you see the four lines from the bottom, short paragraph?
2 A. Yeah, right.
3 Q. "f, date of birth, n
4 Correct?
5 A. Right.
6 Q. So she said she met Mr. Epstein though •
7 correct?
8 A. I believe so.
9 Q. And Ms.. was accurate with her in saying
10 to her that she could make 5200 giving Mr. Epstein a
11 massage?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. And Ms... said the massage would have to be
14 topless, correct?
15 A. I believe so, yes.
16 Q. And.. returned several times to
17 Mr. Epstein's horn; voluntarily, correct?
18 A. I believe so.
19 Q. Meaning, she agreed to go with Ms.. the
20 first time and meet Mr. Epstein and give him what she
21 knew would be a topless massage?
22 A. I don't know if the word "topless" came in,
23 but I know it was a massage.
24 Q. Take a look at the second — top of the
25 sentence of the next page. Ifs at the very top, the
Page 422
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. Well, it could even be M.?
A. It could have been the person who actually
brought than.
Q. And that any massage that occurred always
occurred on the second floor of Mr. Epstein's El Brillo
residence, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Earn.
TILE WITNESS: I believe so.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. By *always,' I mean of all of the witnesses
that were interviewed by them, they told you that they
went upstairs with someone and entered a room where
there was a massage table when Mr. Epstein came into the
room, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: Correct.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. Now, in 2003 you conducted a very different
kind of criminal investigation that related to the same
residence at El Brillo on Palm Beach, correct?

A. Arc you talking about the burglary case?
Q. Yes.
A. That wasn't my case, but I assisted.
Page 421
1 top two words.
2 A. "Massage topless," okay.
3 Q. And again, she was, like WI of the other
4 girls had no prior communication with Mr. Epstein,
5 Ms. or anyone at the El Brillo home before she
6 arrived there physically the first time, correct?
7 A. Correct.
8 Q. And there were no negotiations that you knew
9 of, you know, where prices were discussed, correct?
10 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
11 THE WITNESS: Not that I'm aware ot yes.
12 BY MR. WEINBERG:
13 Q. And what these girls repeatedly told you is
14 that they went to Mr. Epstein's home, invited by one of
15 their friends?
16 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
17 THE WITNESS: They were invited by one of
18 their friends or associates.
19 BY MR. WEINBERG:

20. Q. Came into the first floor and were taken by
21 somebody up to the second floor, correct?
22 A. Correct
23 Q. And that somebody was usually-?
24 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
25. THE. WITNESS: or, on occasion, it was a
Page 423
1 Q. You were a participant in the investigation
2 burglary when Mr. Epstein was the victim, correct?
3 A. Correct.
4 Q. As part of your assistance, you brought
5 certain cameras into Mr. Epstein's home; is that
6 correct?
7 A- Correct
8 Q. And do you recall that Mr. Epstein shared with
9 you that he, himself, attempting to identify who was
10 stealing money from him, had gone out and for the
11 purpose of making that identification, had purchased
12 certain cameras himself?
13 A. I believe so, yes.
14 Q. And that he installed them so that the camera
15 was poking out of a camera on the first floor of his
16 residence, directed towards his desk area where he left
17 a bag that commonly had United States currency, correct?
18 A. I wasn't sure if it was the bag or the drawer,
19 but it was focused on the desk area.
20 Q. Camera, first floor directed to the desk area?
21 A. Yes. It was a bookshelf behind. It was like
22 an L bookshelf.
23 Q. And that you came in and supplemented those
24 cameras to try to help Mr. Epstein identify this thief,
25 correct?
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY,
27 (Pages 420 to 423)
INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Medal (601.280.428-9381)
Electronically signed by Jeans RIccluti (601-280428.9381) O5062637-abel-452c-a8364x614e314d7a
Page 424
1 A. Correct.
2 Q. And you, thereafter, took out your cameras
3 when the thief was identified by Mr. Epstein, correct?
4 A. Correct.
5 Q. And the thief was identified through
6 photographs of this desk area on the first floor of
7 Mr. Epstein's residence, correct?
8 A. I believe so, yes.
9 Q. And you never saw a camera in the massage room
10 on the second floor of Mr. Epstein's residence during
11 this 2003 period, correct?
12 A. I never went upstairs.
13 Q. None of the girls said that the massages was a
14 videoed or a photographed event, did they?
15 A. One of the girls recalled having their
16 photograph taken while in a tub.
17 But no, I never went upstairs during that
18 investigation, so I don't know if there was any covert
19 cameras up there, so...
20 Q. You don't know that there was one, correct?
21 A. Correct
22 Q. And the only covert camera you knew of was the
23 one that Mr. Epstein disclosed to you, correct?
24 A. Correct
25 Q. And he disclosed it to you in saying he
Pogo 426
1 A. I know that was some of their concerns, but I
2 don't believe anyone specifically came out and said, "I
3 was videotaped".
4 Q. Right. Nobody told you that the massage was
5 videoed, to their knowledge?
6 A. To their knowledge, no.
7 Q. And nobody told you that they had seen a
8 camera in the massage room on the second floor of
9 Mr. Epstein's residence.
10 A. I don't recall, because like I said, I know
11. that was one of the concerns.
12 Q. I want to separate out a concern from what
13 they told you they saw. No one ever told you they saw a
14 camera on the second floor of Mr. Epstein's residence?
15 A. I don't recall. I don't recall someone saying
16 that they saw a camera. I know that there was concerns
17 that the incident was videotaped.
18 Q. And they expressed to you that was just a
19 speculative subjective concern, but that they did not
20 see a camera videotaping any massage; is that correct?
21 MS. ARBOUR: Fonn.
22 THE WITNESS: Not that I can recall.
23 BY MR. WEINBERG:
24 Q. You interviewed roughly 30 different women
25 that had been to Mr. Epstein's home, correct?
Page 425
• 1 purchased it, correct?
. 2 A. Yes.
3 Q. And he purchased it from a spy store, a store
4 that sold such covert cameras, correct?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. And he told you, you as a law enforcement
7 officer, that he had done so for a specific purpose,
8 correct?
9 A. It was for that case, yes.
10 Q. Right. To identify someone who was
11 responsible for the theft of currency from the desk area
12 on the first floor?
13 A. I believe it was currency and a gun, if Fm
14 not mistaken.
15 Q. And he neva told you he had ever, on any
16 other occasion, purchased a covert camera, correct?
17 A. Not that I'm aware og no.
18 Q. And with the exception of this one girl who
19 said she was photographed in a tub, no other girl told
20 you that they were photographed, correct?
21 A. I don't believe so.
22 Q. No girl told you that they were videoed,
23 correct? And by "no girl," I mean none of the girls
24 that you interviewed in connection to your 2005
25 investigation of Mr. Epstein.
Page 427
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. Some over 18 and some under 18, correct?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q Some over 18 when you interviewed than, some
5 said that they had been there when they were under 18,
6 correct?
7 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
8 THE WITNESS: Correct.
9 13Y MR. WEINBERG:
10 Q. And not a single one of those 30 people told
11 you that they saw a camera on the second floor of
12 Mr. Epstein's residence, correct?
13 MS. ARBOUR Form, asked and answered.
14 THE WITNESS: I can't recall if anybody
15 specifically crime out and said that they saw a
16 camera or not
17 BY MR. WEINBERG:
18 Q. Nobody, to your current recollection, told you
19 that they saw videotaping of any massage that occurred
20 in Mr. Epstein's residence or any sexual contact that
21 occurred in Mr. Epstein's residence, cored?
22 MS. ARBOUR: Form. .
23 THE WITNESS: Not that I can recall.
24 BY MR. WEINBERG:
25 Q. And nobody said that they had ever seen a
28 (Pages 424 to 427)
' PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY INC.. (561) 832-7506 '
Bectronlcally signed by Jeans RIcclutl (601 .
Electronically signed by Jeans RIcclud (601 c6062637-abel-452c-a836-bc614e31467a
Page 428
1 photograph of themselves in Mr. Epstein's residence with
2 one exception, that being Jane Doe 103, who claimed that
3 a photo was taken of ha in a tub, correct?
4 A. I believe it was just Jane Doe 103.
5 Q. Right. Not any of the other 29 or so
6 witnesses that you interviewed, correct?
7 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
8 THE WITNESS: Right.
9 BY MR. WEINBERG:
10 Q. And when you enteral Mr. Epstein's home,
11 pursuant to judicial authorization on October 20th, you
12 were looking for photographs, were you not?
13 A. Yes.
14 Q. And you did not fmd the photo of Ms. Jane Doe
15 103 that she said was taken of her in a tub, correct?
16 A. Carat.
17 Q. And Ms. Jane Doe 103 didn't tell you how many
18 months before October 10 and 11, 2005, the dates of your
19 interview with her, that photo was taken, correct?
20 A. She did not give a specific date, no.
21 . So once a in remembering back, she turned 18
22 on The photo could have been taken
23 after she was 18, before she was 18, correct?
24 A. It could have been either one.
25 Q. And she never claimed that Mr. Epstein was in
1 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
2 THE WITNESS: Yeah Yes.
3 BY MR. WEINBERG:
4 Q. Jennifer Doe 4, do you recall her?
5 A. Do you mean Jane Doe 4?
6 Q. I'm sorry, Jane Doe 4.

A. Yes.
8 Q. Do you recall interviewing her in or around
9 October 6, 2005?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. And do you recall reciting to a judge in a
12 probable cause affidavit certain statements that
13 Ms. Jane Doe 4 made to you?
14 A. 'recall! put in — I put in a lot of
15 information that had been gathered during the
16 investigation for the search warrant.
17 Q. And is it fair to say that — and I want to
18 focus you on the probable cause affidavit rather than
19 the search warrant affidavit, because that's the one
20 that's in evidence as Exhibit 1, that you said
21 therein — it's on page 9 if you want to work through
22 Ms. Jane Doe 4 with me — that you interviewed her on
23 October 6, 2005? That's the bottom paragraph.
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And that her date of birth was
Page 429
1 the tub with ha, did she?
2 A. No. I believe was with her.
3 Q. At the time of the photo?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. You're certain she said that?
6 A. I believe so.
7 Q. Is there any reason that you didn't say that
8 in your report?
9 MS. ARBOUR; Form.
10 THE WITNESS: Again, I'm going off

11. recollection.
12 BY MR. WEINBERG:
13 • Q. Okay.
14 A. I believe that's what she said tome.
15 Q. And I'll go back. Is them any reason —1
16 represent to you that's not in your 87-page incident
17 report Is there any reason you would have omitted such
18 a description of the type of photo that Ms. Jane Doe 103
19 was claiming to you was taken of her in the tub?
20 A. No, I would have not omitted anything from the
21 report.
22 Q. So, therefore, that would have been the kind
23 of detail that you would have included in the report if,
24 • in fact, you recalled it happening at or around the time
25 you wrote the report, correct?
Page 431
1 is that correct?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. So at the time you interviewed her, she was
4 over 18, correct?
S MS. ARBOUR: Fonn.
6 THE WITNESS: I believe so, yes.
7 BY MR. WEINBERG:
8 Q. And you interviewed her at University?
9 A. Yes.
10 • Q. And you explained to her why you were there,
11 cared?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. Which is, that you were conducting a criminal
14 investigation of Jeffrey Epstein?
15 A. That is correct.
16 Q. And that's a practice you used when you were
17 introducing yourself to either the adult witnesses who
18 had turned 18 or the parents of the minor witnesses,
19 correct? •
20 MS. ARBOUR: Form. •
21 THE WITNESS. Correct.
22 BY MR. WEINBERG:
23 Q. And Ms. Jane Doe 4 told you that she was aware
24 of the ongoing investigation; is that correct?
25 A. Yes. •
29 (Pages 428 Lo 43].}
PROSE COURT REPORTING. AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601
Electronically signed by Jeann Ricciuti (601 c5062637-abo1-452c-a836-hc614e314d7a
Page 432

Q. And neverthelms, she agreed that she would
Page 434
1 Q. And she told you that she was comfortable with
2 Speak to you; is that right? 2 what she was doing?
3 A. Correct 3 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
• 4 Q. And she told you that she had known..? 4 BY MR. WEINBERG:
5 A. Yes. ' . 5 Q. Let me put it another way: That if she was
6.. Q. And that IMI. was the person who introduced 6 uncomfortable, she would not do what she was
7 her to Jeffrey Epstein? 7 uncomfortable in doing, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form • 8 MS. ARBOUR: Same objection.
9 THE WITNESS: I believe so. 9 THE WITNESS: • Right.
10. BY MR. WEINBERG: 10 BY MR. WEINBERG:

11. Q. And again, this was not a meeting that was — 11 Q. In other words —
12 . the introduction of Jane Doe 4 to Epstein by IMI. was 12 A. It was actually even stated in the — that if
13 not preceded by — 13 she felt uncomfortable, to say so and Mr. Epstein would
14 ' (Ms. O'Connor exits the proceedings.) 14 stop pushing the issue.

15. MR. PIKE: Go ahead and finish the question, 15 Q. And she wasn't the tint person that told you
16 • but then don't answer until your attorney returns, 16 this; is that correct?
17 okay? 17 MS. ARBOUR: Fenn.
18 MR. WEINBERG: Well, we can withdraw that 18 THE WITNESS: I believe so. I believe she
19 question and take a five-minute break. Let's take 19 wasn't the only one.
20 a break. 20 BY MR. WEINBERG:
21 (A brief recess was taken.) 21 Q. And you interviewed a number of people that
22 (Ms. O'Connor re-joins the proceedings.) 22 told you that Mr. Epstein would ask them to take off all
23 BY MR. WEINBERG: • 23 thek clothes, and they would take off as much clothes
24 • Q. Page 9 on So Ms. Jane Doe 4's 24 as they felt comfortable with and we re not forced to
25 .
aaffidavit. date of birth is and she was 18 at the time of 25 take off any remaining clothes, correct?
Page 433 Page 435
1 your interview, correct? 1. A. I know that there were, I believe., one or two
2 A. I believe so. 2 that went down to their bra and panties when he told
3 Q. And since your interview was in October and 3 . them to get comfortable. And during the interviews,
4 her birthday was in she had been 18 for 4 Mr. Epstein stated to take off either their bra and/or
5 months? 5 panties.
is A. (Non-verbal response). 6 Q. And they would either do it or not do it,
7 Q. Is that correct? 7 depending on their choice, correct?
8 . MS. ARBOUR Form. 8 MS. ARBOUR: Fon.
9 THE WITNESS: I believe so. 9 THE WITNESS: Correct
10 . BY MR. WEINBERG: 10 BY MR. WEINBERG:
11 Q. And she toldott that she had been introduced 11 Q. I mean, none of them said Mr. Epstein tore
12 to Jeff Epstein by M., correct? 12. their clothes off —

13. A. Correct. • 13 A. No.
14 Q. And that she, like others who Ms... brought 14 Q. — over their objection?
15 to Mr. Epstein's house, knew that the purpose for which 15 A. No.
16 she was going was to give a massage and receive some 16 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
.17 . money, correct? 17 BY MR. WEINBERG:
18 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 18 Q. And all of them told you that he respected the
19 THE WITNESS: I believe so, yes. 19 limits that they set; he didn't physically overcome
20 BY MR. WEINBERG: 20 their limits, correct?
21 Q. • And she told you that she had been there lots 21 . MS. ARBOUR: Form:
22 of times over two years, correct? 22 THE WITNESS: There was one girl in
23 .. MS: ARBOUR: Form.. 23 .particular, I can recall, where he was massaging
24 THE WITNESS: Yes. Yes. 24 her vagina and told her to relax, I'm not going
25 BY MR. WEINBERG: 25 inside. And she claimed that during the massage,
30 (Pages 432 to 435)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciutl (601
Electronically signed by Jeans Riccluti (601 c5662637-abet-452c-a836-bc614e314d7a
Page 436 Page 438
1 he did go inside digitally, but — not force
2 himself it was just the incident we talked about.
3 BY 'MR. WEINBERG:
4 Q. And then she said no and he stopped, coned?
5 MS. ARBOUR: Form. '
6 THE WITNESS: i think she pulled back.
7 BY MR. WEINBERG:
8 • Q. And he didn't try it again?
9 • MS. ARBOUR: Fonn.
10 THE WITNESS: He withdrew his forgers, yes.
.11 . BY MR. WEINBERG:
12 Q. And with the exception of that girl, you
13 interviewed girl after girl after girl that said that
14 limits were set and respected?
15 - MS. ARBOUR: Form.
16 THE WITNESS: Aside from the — Ms. Jane Doe
17 103's.
18 BY MR. WEINBERG:

19. Q. Yes, taking aside Ms. Jane Doe 103 and the one
20 other girl you just mentioned, you interviewed 20 or 30
21 others who made no similar complaint to you, correct?
22 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
23 THE WITNESS: Correct.
24 BY MR. WEINBERG:
25 Q. And they instead said that limits were set by
4,
make similar allegations, correct —

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: Right
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. — who told you that Mr. Epstein deferred to
.the limits they set, to the massage and to whatever
occurred in connection with the massage?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: Yes.
BY Mk W13INBERG:
Q. Ms. Jane Doe 4 was one of those people who
told you that she told Mr. Epstein she had a boyfriend
and would not go beyond certain limits, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
-THE WITNESS: I believe so.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. And that she told you that she went to

Mr. Epstein's house on a number of occasions and that
she provided massages to Mr. Epstein, correct?
A. Yes.

Q. And that when she expressed feeling
uncomfortable, Mr. Epstein would stop pushing whatever
was the issue that caused her to say she felt
uncomfortable, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
Page 437
1 themselves and then Mr. Epstein deferred to those
2 limits?
3 MS: ARBOUR Form.
4 THE WITNESS: As I recall -- see, I recall, .
5 like, interviewing Ms. Jane Doe 103 where she said
.6 things became escalating, so I don't know what
limits you're referring to.
8 BY MR. WEINBERG:
9 Q. With the limit set by It Jane Doe 103 wherein
10 on one occasion you said Ms. Jane Doe 103 objected and
11 Mr. Epstein stopped. There was no other indication from
12 Ms. Jane Doe 103 that she objected, correct?
13 A. That was the time where —
14 Q. Right. But for that time, Ms. Jane Doe 103
15 never told you that she told Mr. Epstein, don't do that, .
16 and he did anyway?
17 A.- And that other incident involving the other
18 girl, which I believe was Jane Doe 2, where the
19 insertion of the fingers.
20 Q. And she pulled away and that ended the •. •
21 incident, correct?
22 . MS. ARBOUR: Form.
23 THE WITNESS: Yeaklbelieve that was —
24 BY MR. WEINBERG:
25 Q. 'You interviewed 28 Other people who didn't
itv=est
1.
. 4
16.
18: •
22 :
24 •
Page 439
THE WITNESS: I believe that's what Ms..
told her.

• BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q, And that's what she said was her experience,
too?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: Yeah.'
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. In other words, Ms... told her, you set the
limits, you know, and those limits were being respected,
correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: I believe so.
'BY MR. WEINBERG: •
Q. And that Ms. Jane Doc 4 corroborated that, in
fact, when she set limits, Mr. Epstein respected them?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
. THE WITNESS: I believe so.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. And Ms. Jane Doe 4.said that during the period
that she was going there, that it was not until, quote,
recently, that Jane Doe 4 even began removing her •
clothes and staying in her thong underwear to provide a
massage, correct?

A. Correct.
31 (Pages 436 to 439)
PROSE. COURT REPORTING 'AGENCY, ('561)"832-75O.6
Electronically signed by Jeana Rlcciutl (601
Electronically signed by Jeana RicciutI (601 00526.37413•1452e-s836-be614•314d7a
Page 440
1 Q. In other worth, through the vast majority of
2 the period she was seeing Mr. Epstein, she was giving
3 Mr. Epstein massages that she represented to you were
4 given with most of her clothes on?
5 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
6 THE WITNESS: That's what 1— that's what she
7 claimed, yes.
8 BY MR. WEINBERG:
9 Q. And that Ms. Jane Doe 4, like others, said
10 that she was driven over by the person that introduced
11 her, in this case, Ms. M.?
12 MS. ARBOUR: Form.

13. THE WITNESS: Right.
14 BY MR. WEINBERG:
15 !,I ; That she would be met on the first floor by
16 = correct?
17 A. Correct.
18 Q. That she would voluntarily accompany
19 upstairs, correct?
20 MS. ARBOUR: Foam.
21 THE WITNESS: Correct.
22 BY MR. WEINBERG:
23 Q. And that the massage was always in the
24 upstairs area, correct?
25 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
2.
8"
13.
17.
Page 442

Q. So certainly, with Ms. Jane Doe 4, that was
• no indication that Mr. Epstein ever did anything except
defer to the limits that she set on her massage,
correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Fenn.
THE WITI•IFSS: She did state that he would try
to get away with more and more on each massage,
which was quoted in the PC, but...
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. Right. All sbe had to do was say no, and he
stopped.
•• MS. ARBOUR: Form. '
THE WITNESS: That's pretty much what she
stated.
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. With all of the women you interviewed, they
were brought to the house by somebody else who was one
of their friends: is that correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
. Q. Or associates?
MS. ARBOUR: Same objection.
THE WITNESS: Pretty much.
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. And it was common practice during these events
Page 441
1 THE WITNESS: Correct.
2 BY MR. WEINBERG:
3 Q. And nobody ever told you that they had engaged
4 in any sexual activity with Mr. Epstein in his lust
5 floor office, did they?
6 A. Not that I can recall, no.
7 Q. Or that he ever received a massage in his
8, first floor office, cornea? And by "office," I mean
9 that area that that theft of money from his bag a
10 • drawer occurred two years before. • .
11 A. Not that I can recall. • .
12 Q. And Ms. Jane Doe 4 continued to tell you that
13 as she described her massages, that on one occasion,
14 Mr. Epstein grabbed her buttocks and when he tried to
15 touch her breasts, she would pull away, tell him to stop
16 and he would stop, correct?
17 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
18 Tim WITNESS: Yes.
19 BY MR. WEINBERG:
20 Q. And that, likewise, she said that she set . 20
21'. limits and would not permit Mr. Epstein to in any way 21
22 we a vibrator, correct? 22
23 . MS. ARBOUR: Form. 23
24 WITNESS: Correct 24
25 BY MR. WEINBERG: 25
1.
'3
13'
15 •
Page 443
for the person who brought them to stay at the house
during at least the first of the massages, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: Correct.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. So that, for instance, Ms. M. stayed at the
house while Ms Jane Doe 4gave Mr. Epstein a massage
for the first time, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Font
INE.WITNESS. 'believe so.
BY MR. WEINBERG: .
er And Ms. M. stayed at the house while
Ms. M. gave Mr. Epstein a massage for the first time,
correct?

A. Correct.
Q. When you interviewed Ms. M., she never told
you that she heard anybody scream or complain or object
or protest the massage while she was in the house,
correa?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: I did recall an incident
involving a girl by the name of U. -
BY MR. WEINBERG: • •
Q. Risk.
A., where.r think the* was a disagreement
32 (Pages 440 to 443)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY; . • 1561) 832-7 5 0 6
Electronically signed by Jeana Mcclull (801M
Electronically signed by Jeana Moduli (601 c6062637-abut -452c-a836-bc614e314d7a
19 .
Page 444
1 between Mr. Epstein and Ms. M. and there was --
2 Q. She was upset —
3 A. — she was upset, and I think she left and no
4 moneys were paid.
5 Q. Right. And didn't she come back a second time
6 even though she was upset the first time?
7 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
8 THE WITNESS: Yes, she did.
9 BY MR. WEINBERG:
10 Q. And with that exception, there was no other
11 representation made to you by any of the friends of the
12 masseuses or the people that introduced them to
13 Mr. Epstein, that any of the people that gave him a
14 massage ever had a conflict that they complained about
15 verbally or screamed or yelled in the house, correct?
16 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
17 THE WITNESS: Not that fm aware of, no.
18 BY MR. WEINBERG:
19 Q. And there were occasions, were there not,
20 where some of these girls that went to Mr. Epstein's
21 house to give massages had boyfriends?
22 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
23 THE WITNESS: I believe so.
24 BY MR. WEINBERG:
25 Q. And on occasion, the guys took the girds to
Page 446
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. How long before the prior deposition was that
3 meeting?
4 A. It was actually documented in the report. I
5 did a supplement to that nature. I want to say a month,
6 a month before, a month and a half prior.
7 Q. So this is in 2010?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. And this was shortly before the fu•st day of
10 the current deposition?
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. And you wrote a report about meeting with
13 Mr. Kuvin?
19 A. Ult•hult
15 Q. And that tt.po. t is available to us as a public
16 record?
17 A. Yes. It's with the case number.
18 Q. And the case number being the '06 number or
19 the '05 number?
20 A. Thc '05 — well, ifs cross referenced back
21 and forth, so...
22 Q. And do you recall what the content of the
23 conversation between you and Mr. Kuvin were?
24 A. It really wasn't much. I mean, I told him —
25 he asked about certain things within the report; I
Page 445
1 the house —
2 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
3 BY MR. WEINBERG:
4 Q. — since someof them didn't drive?
5 A. I'm trying to think. I know some took taxis,
6 I know — I wouldn't know if the boyfriends took them ():
7 not.
8 Q. Let me ask you some different kind of
questions as we work our way to the lunch break.
• Have you discussed your testimony with any of
the Plaintiffs' lawyers before corning to the first
deposition last month?

A. I spoke with Mr. KUVI11.
Q. Yes.
A. I met with him at Starbueks in West Palm prior
to the depo.
Q. And did he ask you to meet with him or did you
ask to meet with him?

A. He had called me and asked to meet with me.
Q. And did he tell you the purpose of meeting
with you was to try to talk to you about the Epstein
case?
A. I believe so.
Q. And you agreed and went and met with him,
correct?
Page 44"/
1 referred him to the report That was basically it.
2 Q. Was there any discussion of the subjects that
3 he intended to ask you about during the deposition?
4 A. No. He bad asked me some certain things
regarding the report, and I just referred him to the
6 report. I was like, no, it's documented.
7 Q. Did he al you whether there was any current
8 investigation ongoing regarding Mr. Epstein?
9 A. I don't believe so.
10 Q. Did he tell you that he was aware of an
11 ongoing investigation being conducted by another agency?
12 A. I daft believe so.
13 Q. Did he discuss with you any knowledge that he
14 possessed regarding any ongoing Federal investigation?
15 A. No, not that i was aware of.
1.6 Q. Did he try to motivate you to recommence a
17 criminal investigation of Mr. Epstein?
18 A. No.
19 Q. Are you engaged in any ongoing criminal
20 investigation of Mr. Epstein?
21 A. No, I am not, and...
22 Q. Do you know whether anyone else in your
23 • department is?
24 A. Nopc.
25 Q. Same questions for Mr. Edwards: Did you ever
33 (Pages 444 to 447)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (801
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601 c6062637-abe1-462c-a836-bc614o314d7a
Page 448
1 have any communications with Mr. Edwards prior to the
2 start of the deposition that was on March 19, 2010?
3 A. I did speak with Mr. Edwards by telephone some
4 time ago. It might even bo documented in the report us
5 well.
6 Q. What's your memory of that conversation? Who
7 called who?
8 A. He called me. There was some reference to a
9 girl that was, what he claimed, was not on the part of
10 the original investigation; that he has a client. I
11 referred him to the FBI, because everything had been
12 turned over to the FBI, so...
13 Q. So he called you to see whether or not his
14 client was in any way included in your prior
15 investigation? What exactly do you recall him saying?
16 A. It was he has or had a client, I'm not
17 really sum.
18 Q. Did he name the client?
19 A. No.
20 Q. How would you know whether or not his client
21 was included?
22 A. We have nothing at the police department.
23 Everything was referred over to the FBI, so it was easy
24 for me to say contact the FBI because we have nothing
25 here.
1 Q. And Mr. Garcia?
2 A. No.
3 Q. And anyone from Mr. Josefsberg or anybody fro
4 his law firm?
5 A. No.
6 Q. How about investigators, did you know a man
7 nano listen?
8 A. No.
9 . Q. Fandrey?
10 A. No.
11 Q. Jenne?
12 A. No.
13 Q.' Has any private investigator ever attempted to
14 interview you regarding Jeffrey Epstein?
15 A. No.
16 Q. Has any private investigator ever informed you
17 that they were conducting surveillance on Jeffrey
18 Epstein's residence?
19 A. No.
20 Q. Did you have occasion to learn that any
21 private investigator was ever conducting a nighttime
22 surveillance of Jeffrey Epstein's residence during the

23. past 12 months?
24 A. No. My — no. My only involvement with
25 private investigators were the ones that were following
Page 449
1 Q. And do you have any other recollection of the
2 conversation with Mr. Edwards?
3 A. Not that I'm aware of, no.
4 Q. Do you recall what in the incident report
5 Mr. Kevin was asking you about?
6 A. No. I know I documented it, but...

Q. So whatever the report that you documented
would be your best memory of your conversation with him?
A. Yes.

Q. Now, after the start of the deposition, did
you have any further conversations with Mr. Kuvin or
Mr. Edwards regarding Mr. Epstein or regarding these
proceedings other than the ones that were on the record
during the deposition?

A. Since the dopers started?
Q. Yes.
A. No.
Q. And during the deposition, during any of the
breaks in the deposition, did either of the two
Plaintiffs' lawyers have any conversations with you of
A. Nothing case-related. It was just...
Q. Same questions regarding Mr. Mermelsteln and
24 Mr. Horowitz flaw you ever spoken to them?
25 A. No.
Page 451
1 me and pulling my trash. But other than that, that's
2 it.
3 Q. Whoever they were, whatever they did, let's
4 put that aside. You've had no direct communication with
5 any person who represented themselves to be working with
6 any of the Plaintiffs' lawyers in this case?
7 A. No.
8 Q. And do you know whether or not Chief Reiter
9, had any communications with any investigator working on
10 the Epstein investigation?
11 A. Not that I'm aware of.
12 Q. Did he ever tell you that he had any
13 communications with Mr. Jenne, or Mr. Fandrey or
14 Mr. Fisten?
15 A. Not that fin aware of.
16 Q. And have you ever seen any note, report,
17 document, memorandum, e-mail or log entry in the Palm
18 Beach records that anyone had been observed
19 surveillance — surveying Mr. Epstein's residence in the
20 past 24 months?
21 A. Not that I'm aware of.
22 Q. Would investigators, in a normal course of
23 business, if they were conducting an investigation in a
24 private area of Palm Beath, notify the police that they
25 intended to be parked in a certain area and watching a
34 (Pages 448 Lo 451)
PROSE COURT REPORTING:AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Riceititi (601
Electronically signed by Jeans nicciuti (601 650624374b01-462c-a8364x614•314d7a
Page 452 Page 454
1 certain residence? 1 regarding investigations. I mean, I usually
2 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 2' forward e-mails to the woman who inputted the
3 THE.WITNESS: Some do, some don't In my 3 supplements into the report. I utilin'd the
• 4 years of experience, I've encountered private 4 e-mails for communication with other agencies,
s investigators that informed the police department, 5 researching information.
6' and there's investigators that don't. 6 BY MR. WEINBERG:
7 BY MR. WEINBERG: 7 Q. Were there any other agencies involved in the
8 Q. Media. The media: Have you, yourself, ever 8 investigation of Jeffrey Epstein when you began it in
9 talked to a media representative/reporter  named Connolly 9 the fall of 2005?
10 who was doing an article for Vanity Fair? 10 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
11 . A. He did telephone me several times and left me 11 THE WITNESS: Not that I'm — no, not that I'm
12 voice mails. I believe I called him once and referred 12 aware of.
13 him to our media person, which was Janet Consuelo. I 13 BY MR. WEINBERG:
14 said, you know, if you have — want anything media 14 Q. And with the exception of Federal agencies,
15 related, dst's the person you need to speak to. I 15 were there any other agencies involved at any time in
16 don't speak to media. But other than that... 16 the investigation of Jeffrey Epstein? Putting aside the
17 Q. Any other media representative attempt to 17 FBI and the Federal authorities.
18 speak to you? 18 A. Not that I'm aware of.
19 A. Local reporters, they sent me e-mails, but 1 19 Q. And did you use your e-mail to communicate
20 just referred those to Janet. 20 with any Federal authority regarding Jeffrey Epstein?
21 Q. Sure. And how would they — did you have 21 A. I don't believe so.
22 e-mail addresses that are ace assible to members of the 22 Q. Do you have the e-mail addresses of the
23 media and the public? 23. various FBI agents who was involved in the Federal
24 A. I mean, they're on my business card, you know, 24 investigation of Mr. Epstein?
25 my e-mail address, so... 25 MS. ARBOUR: Form..
Page 453 Page 455
Q. What e-mail address is that on your business 1 BY MR. WEINBERG:
2 card? 2 Q. For instance, Ms. Kizitendahl is the case
3 A. 3 Cent -
4 Q. And is that an e-mail that you would use to 4 MS. ARBOUR: Same objection.
5 conduct electronic communications with other police 5 TIE WITNESS: I don't believe so. I don't
6 offiects on an investigation? 6 believe so.
7 A. It's the e-mail that I use for work, yeah. 7 BY MR. WEINBERG:
8 Q. When did you start using that e-mail? 8 Q. Do you know Whellwr or not you ever sent a
9 A. When we rust got it. I mean... 9 communication to the FBI from your office in jrecarey
10 Q. How many years ago? Do you recall when you 10 e-mail?
11 first got an e-mail system or a personal e-mail for 11 A. I can't recall, but I don't believe so.
12 yourself? 12 Q. How about the media?
13 A. I don't know. I would venture to say back in 13 A. I don't speak to the media, so...
14 like 2003,2002. 14 Q. How about Chief Reiter?
15 Q. So before the beginning of the investigation 15 A. Within the agency, yeah, I sent e-mails all
16 of Mr. Epstein? 16 the time within the agency to different detectives,
17 A. (Igen-verbal response). 17 secretarial staff, Chief.
18 Q. And before the beginning of Ms. Pagan's 18 Q. Was there a decision that was discussed
19 investigation of Mr. Epstein; is that correct? 19 between you and Chief Reiter as to whether or not to
20 A. I believe so. 20 make available the incident report to the media, the
21 Q. And what is your practice in terms of using 21 Epstein 87-page incident report?
22 e-mail to communicate with other officers or other 22 A. I know I wasn't consulted with that. I mean,
23 detectives engaged in a common investigation? 23 that was decisions made.
24 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 24 Q. Who made that decision?
25 THE WITNESS: Generally, I don't send e-mails 25 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
35 (Pages 452 Lo 4 5 5)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC."
Electronically signed by Jeana Medial (601
Electronically signed by Jeans Moduli (601 c50126374brI-4520-4835-bc614•314dre
Page 456
1 BY MR. WEINBERG:
2 Q. To the best of your knowledge.
3 A. You'd have to ask Chief Reiter on that one.
4 Q. Is it ordinary practice of the Palm Beach
5 Police to disseminate incident reports to the media?
6 MS. ARBOUR Form.
7 THE WITNESS: Once they're filed, they become
8 public record, so you can go into the police agency
9 and ask for any report.
10 BY MR. WEINBERG:
11 Q. And the media has access to the incident
12 reports?
13 A. That's correct.
14 MS. ARBOUR Fortn.
15 BY MR. WEINBERG:
16 Q. And was there anything unusual, from your
17 perspective, regarding how this incident report was
18 handled vis-a-vis the media?
19 A. I don't believe so.
20 Q. But if there was, that would have been a
21 decision made by Chief Reiter and not yourself, correct?
22 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
23 THE WITNESS: Correct.
24 BY MR. WEINBERG:
25 Q. This case, this investigation began in March
Page 458
1 interviewed by the Palm Beach Police between March of
2 2005 and your beginnings of the investigation in late
3 September of 2005?
. 4 A. That would have been documented in the report.
5 Q. Do you recall any other woman interviewed
6 during that six-month period?
7 A. I can't recall.
8 Q. Do you recall that trash pulls were occurring
9 during this March and April of 2005 period?
10 A. I did read that, yes.
11 Q. Do you recall that within the trash pulls,
12 there was some references to a belief amongst the
13 officers that there were sex utensils or sex objects
14 that were being identified and pulled out of the trash?
15 A. Yes.
16 MS. ARBOUR Form.
17 THE WITNESS: I recall the incident, the thing
18 you're talking about, which was later turned out to
19 be a handle of a — utensils.
20 BY MR. WEINBERG:
21 Q. Of an eating utensil?
22 A. Yeah.
23 Q. And do you recall within the incident report
24 there was a reference to this so-called object as one
25 that was consistent with use of anal sex?
Page 457
1 of 2005, correct?
2 A. Correct.
3 Q. With a phone call from someone connected to
4 ..'s family into the police department?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
6 BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. Is that right?
8 A. I believe so.
9 And you read n report regarding a debriefing
10 of M., correct?
11 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
12 THE WITNESS: I believe so, yes.
13 BY MR. WEN:BERG:
14 Q. But you had no ability to reach your own
15 aulibility determinations because you, yourself, never
16 reinterviewed Ms. M., correct?
17 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
18 THE WITNESS: Correct.
19 . BY MR. WEINBERG:
20 Q. And those interviews were exclusively done by
21 others; is that right?
22 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
23 THE WITNESS: Correct.
24 BY MR. WEINBERG:
25 O. And Were there any other young women who were
Page 459
1 A. Yes. They thought originally it was an anal •
2 wand.
3 (Mr. Garcia entered the room.)
4 BY MR. WEINBERG:
5 • Q. And do you recall that, even after your search
6 on October 20. 2005, wherein you saw lots of similar
7 utensils in the kitchen that clearly were designed for
8 eating; that there was no amendment to the Incident
9 report that reflected the discoveries of October 20 in
10 that the believed sex toys were, in fact, kitchen
11 Menai?
12 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
13 (Ms. Finnigan exits the proceedings.)
14 BY MR. WEINBERG:
15 Q. That was a terribly-worded question.
16 A. I was just going to say.
17 Q. Let me reword it.
18 The incident report contained the beliefs of
19 the officers, that what they were picking out of the
20 garbage were sexual mechanisms that --
21 A. Right, they thought they were anal wands.
22 Q. — they thought were anal wands.
23 A. Right
24 Q. That on October 20th, when you went to
25 Mr. Epstein's residence, you realized as a professional
36 (Pages 456 to 459)

(561) .832-750.0 . . PROSE COURT 'REPORTING 'AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana Medlin (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Riccluti (601 c6002637413•1452e48384=614•31447a
Page 460
1 law enforcement officer that that conclusion was
2 mistaken.
3 A. Correct.
4 Q. Putt these objects taken out of the garbage
5 were, in fact, pans of eating utensils, correct?
6 A. Correct.
7 Q. Was there ever an amendment to the incident
8 report that reflected the knowledge that what had
9 previously believed to have been a sex utensil was, in
10 fact, an eating utensil?
11 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
12 THE WITNESS: It might have been referenced in
13 the report I'm net 100 percent certain on that.
14 BY MR. WEINBERG:
15 Q. If it wasn't in the 'two t, then there wasn't
16 an amendment to the report, fair to say?

17. MS. ARBOUR: Form.
18 THE WITNESS: Fair to say.
19 BY MR. WEINBERG:
20 Q. I want to go back to September, when you first
21 got involved. You asked Ms. Pagan and others to send
22 you any tape recordings that had been conducted during
23 the beginning days of the investigation; is that
24 correct?
25 A. Correct
Page 462

A. l wanted to familiarize myself completely with
2 the case.
3 Q. And the best way to do it, you concluded as a
4 professional officer, was to listen to the verbatim tape
5 recordings?
6 MS. ARBOUR: Fort.
7 THE WITNI3SS: As I would on any other case.
• 8 BY MR. WEINBERG:
9 Q. And you wrote a report, an incident report
10 that is dated September 26, 2005. Let Inc just show you
11 this and ask you then to give it back because it's full
12 of notes, but I want to ask you a couple of questions
13 from there. Do you recognize this kind of document?
14 A. Yes. That was a supplement that I had
15 submitted to the secretary to be inputted into the
16 report.
17 Q. And in that supplement, you had referenced in
18 this middle paragraph, "On September 22, I was informed
19 by Sergeant Szarszewski —
20 A. Szarszcwski, yes.
21 Q. — that there would be no trash pickup as it
22 was recycled pickup day." And then you sent a request
23 for copies of the micro and standard-sized cassettes,
24 were requested from Crime Scene to familiarize myself

25. with the interviews conducted.
Page 461
1 Q. And you wanted to hear the tape recordings,
2 did you not?
3 A. Yes.'
4 Q. And even one of the tapes was kind of — it
5 was broken during the copying for you, correct?
6 A. Correct
7 Q. And you wanted to hear the tapes because you
8 knew that listening to the tapes would give you the best
9 source of knowledge as to whth witnesses were telling
10 police officers in your absence, correct?
11 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
12 ' THE WITNESS: I wanted to get the perspective
13 of the victim, yes.
14 BY MR. WEINBERG:
15 Q. And the perspective of the victim is more
16 accurately disclosed through a contemporaneous tape
17 recording than through note taking, correct?
18 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
19 THE WITNESS: I believe so.
20 BY MR. WEINBERG: .
21 Q. And therefore, the source that you wanted to
22 got was the tape recordings, correct?
23 A. Correct.
24 Q. Rather than just relying on the narrative that
25 was incorporated into an incident report, correct?
S
17.
'18
25.
Page 463
And the crime scene, the crime scene in this
investigation was Mr. Epstein's residence, correct?

A. No, from the Crime Scene Unit
Q. From the Crime Scene Unit?
A. Yes, who holds all evidence from the Palm
Beach Police Department.

Q. So the word "Crime Scene" refers to a unit
within the Palm Beach Police Department?
A. The Crime Scene Unit, yes.

Q. And they're the evidence custodians?
A. Yes.
Q. And they have logs of evidence going in and
out?
A. Correct.

Q. Just like you kept logs when different items
. seized on October 20th were reviewed by you, correct?

A. What logs are you referring to?
Q. You kept different property logs.
A. Oh, the property receipts? Yes. That's done
with every piece of evidence Nat gets submitted into
Crime Scene.

Q. So therefore, the Crime Scene has a log that
would contain an identification of each item of evidence
that was maintained by the Palm Beach Police as of
September 22,2005, correct? '
0 PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601:11/11
37 (Pages 460 to 463)
INC.
c6062637-0•1-462e48364x614•314d7a
19.
Page 464

A. They have property receipts, yes, copies of
the property receipts. .
Q. So they would have the receipts for the videos
that reflected surveillance before September 22nd,
correct?
A- Correct.

Q. They would have property receipts for the
results of the bash pulls before September 22nd.
• A. Correct.

Q. And the had the tape recording of their
debriefing ofM., correct?
. A. Correct.
Q. Wherein M. said that she went to

Mr. Epstein's house on one occasion, correct?
A. I believe so, yes.
Q. With M., correct?
A. Yes.
Q. Knew what she was going there for?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: So she claims, yes.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. Represented herself to be 18 to Mr. Epstein?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: That, I don't recall. •
Page 466
1 Q. Now, also told you that immediately after
2 • leaving Mr. Epstein's house with the $200 or $300 she
3 received that day, she and.. went shopping, correct?
4 A. She told Detective Pagan.

5. Q. Right. And she was inolthe only different
6 women told you that they went shopping with the money
7 they got from Mr. Epstein following their massages,
8 correct?
9 MR. GARCIA: Object to the form.
10 THE WITNESS: I can't recall if they told me
11 they weat specifically shopping, but.:
12 BY MR. WEINBERG: •
13 Q. Did you ever ask them what they did with the
14 $200 they received?
15 A. I might have. I can't recall at this time if
16 I did or didn't.
17 Q. Did you ever ask lane Doe 103 — strike that.
18 • • Jane Doe I.03 told you that she had received a
19 significant amount of money because she said she bad
20 • gone to Mr. Epstein's home on many occasions, correct?

21. MS. ARBOUR: Form.
22 • THE WITNESS: Yes.
n BY MR. WEINBERG: •
24 Q. And that it totaled thousands, rather than
25 hundreds, correct?
Page 465
BY MR. WEINBERG:
2 Q. If it's in the incident report, you wouldn't
3 believe that's inconsistent with your memory, correct?
4 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
5 BY MR. WEINBERG:
6 Q. In other words, if it's in your incident

7. report, you have no reason to doubt that she said that?
8 A. Correct.
9 • Q. If it was said, it was said to someone else,
10 correct?
11 MS. ARBOUR: Font
12 . THE WITNESS: Correct.
13 BY MR. WEINBERG:
14 Q. Your recollection is that, as you testified to
15 last time, that took her upstairs, correct?
16 . A. Who, ?
17.
18 A. She is the ono who was interviewed by
19 Detective Paw, but...
20 Q. . Right. But she described it that some other
21: woman took hefupstairs, correct?
22 A. Some other woman, yes.
23 Q. But she didn't give the name or or
24 any third party, correct?
25 A. I believe so.
Page 467
1 A. I would believe so. .
2 Q. And did you ever ask her what she did with her
3 money?
4 A. I can't recall if I did or didn't.
5 Q. Do you recall ha declining or reflising to
6 tell you what happened to the money that she made with
7 Mr. Epstein?
8 • A. I can't recall.
9 Q. When you drafted the search warrant
10 affidavit —
11 A. Yes, sir.
12 Q. — this was less than a month into the
13 investigation that was being led by you, correct?
14 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
15 THE WITNESS. Uh-huh.
16 - . BY MR. WEINBERG:
It Q. You took it over in the third week of
18 September of 2005?
19 A. Towards the end of September, yes.
20 Q. There had — and you one of the first things
21 you did was to interview correct?
22 A. That was in October.
23 . Q. The first week in October, correct?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And you went to Ms...'s house, did you not?
PROSE COURT
38 (Pages 464 to 467)
REPORTING. AGENCY, INC.•
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601
Electronically signed by Jeans Ricciuti (601 06042837-ebet-452c-a834-bc814•314d7a
Page 468 Page 470
1 A. Yes, I did.
2 • Q. Ms... lived out of Palm Beach, did she not?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. And the decision was made that you could
5 interview her without the presence of an officer from a
6 different department if she elected to come back to the
7 headquarters, correct?
8 A. Correct.
9 Q. And you asked her to come back to the
10 headquarters, correct?
11 A. Yes, I did.
12 Q. And she agreed to corns back to the
13 headquarters, did she not?
14 A. Yes, she did
15 Q. And at that point in time, when she was at her
16 house and you were asking her to be cooperative, she
17 agreed to be cooperative; is that right?
18 A. Well, she agreed to come back to the Police
19' Department for further questioning.
20 Q. And she agreed essentially to cooperate with
21 your investigation of the interview, right?
22 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
23 THE S: Correct. I mean, she answered
24 the questions, if that's what you mean.
25 BY MR. WEINBERG:
18-
.19
telephones that you use to call out, correct?

A. Yes.
Q. And are tape recorders which would permit you
to tape record an outgoing phone call, correct?

A. Yes.
Q. And Ms... certainly told ou that she had
spoken on occasion on the phone to
A. Yea
Q. And that she had spoken to for the
purpose of scheduling certain visits to Mr. Epstein's
home, correct?

A. Yes.
Q. And that she had Ms. phone number?
A. Uh-huh.
Q. And that she could have called Ms.
while she was at the Police headquarters, correct?

A. Yes.
Q. And did you decide whether or not you would
ask her to make such a call?
A. It was within her statement where she claimed
she wanted nothing to do with or Mr. Epstein, that
she had stopped communicating with so it would
have been out of the norm for her to call.
Q. You have asked cooperating witnesses to place
tape recorded telephone calls to targets of your
Page 469
1 Q. And she answered them by identifying to you at
2 least six other people that she had brought and
3 introduced to Mr. Epstein, correct?
4 A. Correct.
5 Q. And she agreed to talk to you abort.; is
6 that right?
7 A. I believe so, yes.
8 Q. And she answered any questions you asked her;
9 is that right?
10 A. Yes. •
11 Q. Mr. Epstein was in town at the time; is that
12 right?
13 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
14 BY MR. WEINBERG:
15 Q. 'Do you recall that your incident report
16 reflects that his —
17 A. Yes, that his plane was in town, yes.
18 Q. And that Ms is at the Police Department
19 with you; is that right?
20 A. Ub-huh.
21 Q. She is being interviewed behind a one-way
22 glass so that the content of the interview was being
.23 observed by others?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And within the Police Department are
Page 471
1 investigation on other occasions, have you not?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. And that was certainly an investigative
4 technique that you considered employing in this case?
5 A. Considered it.
6 Q. And then you made a decision as the case agent
7 not to request that Ms... lace a recorded phone call
8 to either Mr. Epstein or Ms. =, correct?
'9 A. Correct. •
10 Q. And not to ref= to Mr. Epstein's house
11 . wearing a recorder wherein the events that transpired
12 • there and the conversations that occulted there could be
13 recorded and transmitted to some — to law enforcement,
14 correct?
15 A. Correct.
16 Q. Back to the search warrant affidavit. You've
17 authored other search warrant affidavits, have you not?
18 A. Uh-huh.
19 Q. And your goal when you authored them is to be
20 complete and accurate, is it not?
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. You understand that the magistrate — strike
23 that — that the judge that's going to review the .
24 al£davit ordinarily has no other independent bases to
25 know whether or not to authorize a search of a residence
39 (Pages 468 to 471 )
. PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY,. INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana RIcciutl (601
Electronically signed by Jeana RIcciuti (601 c5062637-abel-452c-a836-bc614.314d7a
Page 472
1 .crept the information that's being provided to him by
2 the affiant, correct?
3 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
4 'THE WITNESS: Correct.
5 BY MR. WEINBERG:
6 Q. And these affidavits are under oath, correct?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. And they're designed to be accurate and
9 complete, are they not?
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. Because you understand that omissions can be

12. as deceiving as misrepresentations, correct?
13 A. Correct.
14 Q. In this case, you were seeking authority to
15 conduct a search of Mr. Epstein's private residence,
16 coil
17 A. Correct.
18 Q. And you sought that permission based on an
19 affidavit that reported to the judge the results of
20 certain interviews you conducted?
21 A. Uh-huh.
22 Q. And certain blowup investigations, such as
23 the results of trash pulls and phone records; is that
24 right?
25 A. Correa
Page 474
1 BY MR. WEINBERG:
2 Q. When you searched the Dell computer taken from
3 the second residence, did you conduct the search or did
4 a forensic expert conduct it?
5 A. It was sent to the Sheriffs office for
6 imaging, and then the imaging itself was looked at.
7 Q. Not one of your witnesses ever said that they
8 saw Mr. Epstein use a computer; is that correct?
9 A. I'm trying to recall. Not that I can recall.
10 Q. Not one of your witnesses said they ever
11 received an e-mail from Mr. Epstein, correct?
12 A. I can't recall at fills time.
13 Q. Not one of your witnesses ever said that when
14 they were at Mr. Epstein's house, they had ever looked
15 at anything on a computer at Mr. Epstein's house or ever
16 seen anything on a computer at Mr. Epstein's house?
17 A. I ain't recall.
18 Q. Not one of your witnesses ever said that they
19 had received an e-mail from anyone other than
20 Mr: Epstein who resided at Mr. Epstein's house, coned?
21 A. I can't recall if.. claimed that she got an

22. e-mail. That's why I'm not 100 percent certain on the
23 email.
24 Q. If it's not in the incident report, you have
25 no independent memory of anyone telling you that they
Page 473
1 Q. Within the affidavit, you asked for permission
2 to search any DVDs, any CDs, any computer discs, any
3 media that you could find in Mr. Epstein's residence; is
4 that correct?
5 A. Correct.
6 Q. And in het, you did seize such CDs, DVDs and
7 various media discs, did you not?
A. We seized some.
9 Q. And you searched them --
10 A. Yes.
11 Q. — not knowing what was on them?
12 A. Correct.
13 Q. And likewise, you seized a Dell computer from
14 a guest house that was a separate and detached residence
15 on the Epstein property, is that correct?
16 A. Correct
17 Q. And you ultimately gave back anything seized
18 from that separate residence, understanding that it, in
19 essence, was the home of another individual, correct?
20 A. Because it was returned back to the innocent
21 party who had no evidence on his computer us to the
22 items that we were searching, yes.
23 Q. And when you searched these computers, you
24 were looking for anything; is that correct?
25 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
Page 475
1 ever received an e-mail from or
2 anyone else that resided at Mr. Epstein's home, caret
3 A. Fin trying to recall. I can't recall.
4 Q. You do recall that the scheduling was done as
5 a routine practice by phone, correct?
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. And that largely, the conversations, to the
8 extent they were explained to you, were simply phone
9 calls to and from picking a time, picking a date
10 . when they would go to Mr. Epstein's home, correct?
11 . MS. ARBOUR: Form
12 THE WITNESS' I believe so.
13 BY MR. WEINBERG:
14 . Q. And you saw message pads that confirmed El
15 the message was generally limited to, Pm availalco.
16 call me, Icon come, messages that were reflective of
17 scheduling and an openness to going to Mr. Epstein's
18 home, correct?
19 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
20 BY MR. WEINBERG:
21 Q. We can go through a lot of the messages this
22 . afternoon, but...
23 A. I believe so.
24 Q. The investigation you conducted, that included
25 the search on October 20th, continued into November and
or
40 (Pages 472 to 475)
• PROSE COURT REPORTING .AGENCY,' INC.
Electronically aligned by Joana Fticclutt (601
Electronically signed by Joana Rlcciuti (601 c5062637-abol-462c-a836-bc614e314d7a
Page 476 Page 478
1 December of 2005, correct? 1 it a fivocount charge against Mr. Epstein, two counts
2 ' A. Uh-huh. 2 with five allegations, if you recall?
3 Q. So it began in Much and it continued through 3 A. I can't recall.
4 December of 2005, correct? 4 • Q. There was ono count for lewd and lascivious,
5 A. Yes. 5 and one count for unlawful sex act that was returned by
6 Q. The first time you formalized a probable cause 6 a Palm Beach grand jury in and around June of 2006.
7 affidavit was May 1, 2006, correct? 7 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
8 A. Uh-huh. 8 BY MR. WEINBERG:
9 Q. And that probable cause affidavit resulted 9 Q. Let me go back. There was a grand jury
10 several months later when the State Attorney was 10 indictment, correct?
11 presenting a case to the grand jury? 11 A. Yes.
12 A. That was — that whole fiasco with the State 12 Q. Thereafter, there was information?
13 Attorney's office where originally we were going to go 13 A. Yes.
14 to the grand jury, then we postponed it, and then we 14 Q. The grand jury indictment charged
15 were going to go back to the grand jury, then we 15 solicitation, correct?
16 postponed it, and then they said no, we want a probable 16 A. I believe so.
17 cause affidavit. So I submitted it as a probable cause 17 Q. And that came about on either the end of Juno
18 affidavit, and they came back and said no, we want to go 18 or July of 2006, correct? And we can go back —
19 back to the grand jury — 19 A. I believe you're right I'm not 100 percent
20 Q. To cut through it, there was some, to put it 20 certain, but I believe you're right.
21 mildly, niscommunication between the State Attorneys 21 Q. And before the grand jury acted, did you and
22 office and the Palm Beach Police Department? 22 Chief Reiter discuss going to the Federal authorities
23 MR. GARCIA: Object to the form. 23 and bypassing the State Attorney?
24 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 24 A. I can't recall. I believe it might have been
25 MR. GARCIA: Mischaracterizes his testimony. 25 after, but I'm not 100 percent certain.
Page 477 Page 479
1 BY MR. WEINBERG: 1 Q. Do you have any records, notes, reports that
2 Q. Let me go back and start again. In April, 2 would refresh your memory as to the first time that
3 they told you they were going to conduct a grand jury 3 either you or Chief— or to your knowledge,

4. and subpoenas went out to certain people, okay? 4 Chief Reiter communicated with the Federal authorities
5 A. It was prior to April, I believe. I think we 5 and asked them to commence or initiate an investigation
6 were in March. 6 of Mr. Epstein?
7 Q. So in March, the grand jury subpoenas were 7. MS. ARBOUR: Form.
8 served for an April appearance. Does that chronology 8 THE WITNESS: No, Ideal have any records.
9 make sense? 9 BY MR. WEINBERG:
10 A. I think that's when the discussions were back 143• Q. And do you know whether or not — was it you
11 and forth about grand jury. 11 that made that initiation to the Federal government?
12 Q. And Ms. Jane Doe 103 was served with a gland 12 A. I believe so.
13 jury subpoena? 13 ' Q. And do you recall just how you did that? Did
14 A. I drove up and I served her with a grand jury 14 you drive over to the Federal — to the US Attorneys
15 subpoena. 15 office? Did you call the FBI? How was the initiation?
16 Q. And that grand jury was postponed or canceled; 16 A. I am also assigned to the Joint Terrorism Task
17 correct? 17 Force, so I have daily communication with people at the
18 A. Yes. 18 FBI, if not every other day. Iliad the clearance, you
19 Q. And a second grand jury was thereafter 3 9 to  in and out of the office. But Fm trying to
20 convened during the summer of 2006, correct, months 20 recall. I believe it might have been me.
21 after the first one? 21 Q. And what's your best recollection as to how
22 A. Yes. 22 this occurred as to, did you go to the FBI, were you

23. Q. And taking that timeline, between the grand 23 talking to them in any way at a Joint Task Force
24 jury for which you subpoenaed Ms. Jane Doe 103 the first 24 meeting? Did you make it a point to bring this matter
25 time and the grand jury that ultimately returned — was 25 to their attention? What's your best recollection of
41 (Pages 476 to 479)
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC. .(561) 832-7506
Bactronicaily signed by Jeans Rlcdutl 1601=
Electronically signed by Jeans flicciuti (601 61012637-atirl-461:483843414414dra
Page 480
1 how the dialogue commenced?
2 A. I don't recall. I can't recall.
3 Q. But you do recall at least one conversation
4 with the Federal authorities regarding Mr. Epstein?
5 A. Yes.
6 Q. Do you recall more than one conversation with
7 them?

A. I recall a meeting with Junior Ortiz, who was
9 the supervisor, the local supervisor. He was present,
10 Chief Reiter was present, 'was present. That would
11 have been in the summer.
12 Q. Do you recall where that meeting occurred? •
13 A. It was at the FBI office because it was in
14 Junior's office.
15 Q. Was this before or after the Federal subpoena
16 went out to the Palm Beach P1) for the production of
17 their records regarding the State investigation?
18 A. This would have been before.
19 Q. And this is the first meeting you recall
20 wherein Mr. Epstein was discussed with the Federal
21 authorities in your presence?
22 A. Yes, I believe so.
23 Q. And do you recall whether it was you or
24 Chief Reiter that invited —that initiated this
25 meeting?
Page 482

A. -- that they wanted everything pertaining to
the case, and everything that was pertaining to the case
went with them.

Q. Do you have any logs, diaries, calendars,
notes that would provide you with the basis to know the
date of this meeting?

A. Of the Federal subpoena, or —
Q. No, of the meeting between you and Chief —
A. No, there were no logs.

Q. — Reiter that met with the special agents.
Was there any follovrup that you engaged in?
A. Not that I can recall. !mean, once they came
in and took over the stag that was it.

Q. How long did this meeting occur?
A. About an hour or so. I wouldn't — I believe.
Q. And do you recall questions that were asked of
you during this hour?

A. No.
Q. And do you recall information that you
cornmtmicated during this hour?
A. No.
Q. And do you recall any questions asked of
Chief Reiter during this hour?

A. No.
Q. Do you recall anything said by Chief Reiter to
Page 481
1 A. I can't recall. I'm trying to think back.
2 Q. So, who else was at this meeting?
3 A. I know Junior was there, I believe the Chief
4 was there, I was there.
5 Q. And do you recall whether or not you took any
6 notes that were memorialized in any report regarding the
7 content of this meeting?
8 A. No.
9 Q. And was the purpose of you and Chief Reiter
10 going to the FBI and having this meeting to request that
11. they take over the criminal investigation of
12 Mr. Epstein?
13 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
14 THE WITNESS: It wasn't to take over. I
15 believe it was to determine if there was any
16 Federal nexus or any Federal violation, but it
17 wasn't to take over, although subsequently that's
18 what happened, but...
19 BY MR. WEINBERG:
20 Q. And did you and Chief Reiter provide the
21 Federal authorities with whatever information was
22 available to you?
23 A. We didn't have a choice. They came in with a
24 Federal subpoena --
25 Q. Following this meeting?
Page 483
1 the FBI?
2 A. No, I'm sorry.
3 Q. Who first raised the issue of nexus, of
4 whether there was any Federal nexus to what had been, up
5 to this day, a purely local investigation of activities
6 being conducted of Mr. Epstein's private residence?
7 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
8 THE WITNESS: I can't recall whether it was me
9 or former Chief Reiter.
10 BY MR. WEINBERG:
11 Q. And those conversations occurred before this
12 meeting?
13 A. Either at the meeting or just before the
14 meeting.
15 Q. And did this meeting occur at or around the
16 time that Chief Reiter was writing letters expressing
17 his displeasure with the State and State Attorney's
18 investigation?
19 MS. ARBOUR: Object to f01111.
20 ME WITNESS: I believe it was after the
21 letters.
22 BY MR. WEINBERG:
23 Q. Do you remember those letters?
24 A. Yea
25 Q. And those letters were written or drafted and
42 (Pages 480 to 483
PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY, INC.
Electronically signed by Jeana RitrJult (801
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601 cS062637-abol-452c-ati36-bc614e314d7a
Page 484 Page 486
1 1 written by Chief Reiter and sent to whom? 1 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
2 . A. They were sent to some of the parents of the 2 • THE WITNESS: I wouldn't consider what she did
3.. victims. 3 her investigation. I think she just looked at
.4 Q. If I represent to you that at least some of 4 these girls' MySpace accounts. I wouldn't consider
- 5 , - - those letters were dated in May of 2006, would that jog s that an investigation.
6 your memory as to when this meeting.with Special Agent 6 BY MR. WEINBERG:
7 Ortiz occurred? 7 Q. But she had in her possession at this time
8 A. I believe it would have been after those 8 your incident report?
9 letters. 9 MS. ARBOUR: Fenn.
10 Q. But before the return of the State grand jury 10 THE WITNESS: Yes.
11 indictment? 11 BY MR. WEINBERG:
12 A. I don't believe it was before the grand jury. 12 • Q. Your probable cause affidavit?
13 I believe it was after the sand jury. 13 • MS. ARBOUR: Form.
14 Q. So your best memory, therefore, would be that 14 THE WITNESS: I don't know if it was drafted
15 it would be after both the letters and the grand jury? 15 yet.
16 A. Comet. 16 BY MR. WEINBERG:
17 Q. You had different conversations with the State 17 Q. But she had the raw materials of your many
18 Attorney during this period, with one or more of the 18 interviews over many months, correct?
19 State attorneys? 19 MS. ARBOUR: Fenn.
20 A. Yeah, Assistant State attorneys. 20 THE WITNESS: Yes.
21 Q. Which Assistant State attorney do you recall 21 BY MR. WEINBERG:
22 talking to? 22 Q. She had the results of the search, did she
23 A. 23 not?
24 Q.64 recall any conversation with 24 A. Yes.
25 Ms. wherein you discussed whether or not your 25 Q. She had the message pads available to her, did
Page 485 Page 487
1 witnesses were or were not victims? 1 she not?
2 MS. ARBOUR: Form. 2 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
3 THE WITNESS. I recall her picking and 3 THE WITNESS: I don't believe she had the
4 choosing who she wanted to refer to as a victim. 4 message pads. They were in our evidence.
5 Most of my conversations with her I know were 5 BY MR. WEINBERG:
6 documented in the report. 6 Q. But she could if -
7 BY MR. WEINBERG: 7 A. She had, I think, certain copies of certain
8 Q. 13o you recall words to the effect that you 8 pages of than. •
9 were frustrated with her because one of ha opinions 9 Q. She had a file as an Assistant State Attorney
10 were that there was no victims in this case? 10 in charge of a criminal' investigation of Mr. Epstein
11 - MS. ARBOUR: Fonn. 11 that was being conducted by your department, correct?
12 THE WITNESS: I did recall that conversation, 12 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
13 ' Yes- ' 13 THE YoTINESS: I believe she did have a file,
14 BY MR. WEINBERG: 14 yes, of items that were given to ha by us.
15 Q. And what do you recall of that conversation? 15 BY MR. WEINEIF.RO:
16 A. I recall her, after viewing some of the 16 Q. She didn't only have that which was provided
17 materials that were supplied to her by Dershowitz, she '17 by the Defense,
18 started to claim that the victims were not victims based 18 MS. ARBOUR; No.
19 on the materials that were supplied by the MySpaces. 19 THE WITNESS: No. She had items that we had
20 Q. The victims were not victims? 20 provided.
21 A. That's what she was claiming. 21 BY MR. WEINBERG:
22 Q. And this is the State Attorney's statements to 22 Q. And putting aside what you believe was the
23 you based on her investigation which included her review 23 more important evidence to her, which was her review of
24 of materials provided to her by Defense Counsel 24 the MySpace pages of certain of your witnesses, she did
.25 Professor Alan Dersb3witr2 25 . communicate to you, the case agent, ha belief that
43 (Pages 484 to 487)
' . PROSE COURT REPORTING AGENCY; INC.
Electronically signed by Juana Ricciuti (601
Electronically signed by Jeana Ricciuti (601 c5062637-abel-462c-a836-bc614e314d7a
Page 488
1 there was no victims i n this case?

A. Based on what she was observing on those
3. pages. At least that's my opinion:
4 Q. But what her statement to you was: There are
5 no victims in this case?

MS. ARBOUR: Forni
THE WITNESS: I believe so.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
Q. And that was made after she reviewed the
MySpace pages, comet?

MS. ARBOUR: Form .. •
114E WITNESS: I believe so.
BY MR. WEINBERG:
O. But also after she had in her possession a
very substantial investigative incident report that .
reflected many interviews with many witnesses conducted
both by you and others working with you and by others
before you, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
ME WITNESS: In my opinion, once
Mr. Dershowitz became involved, her demeanor on
this case was completely different.
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. And let me go back to square one so we can
finish this area and then have lunch.
. ff
10 .
12 •
13.
14 •
15 .
17 ••
18.

20. .
25 .
Page 49C
Q. And she was the proseCutor in charge of the
case? •
MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: She was one of the prosecutors
that was assisting in this case.
-BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. AM when did she make the statement to you,
. "There are no victims here"?
A. This is when we were debating we go to the
grand jury, not to go to the grand jury, write me a PC,
don't write me a PC, we're going back to the grand jury.

Q. Late spring of 2006?
A. Like I said, this was ongoing from in the
investigative stage. This was prior to the arrest
. Q. And she was talking to you about going to the
grand jury, correct?

A. Whether we were going to go to the grand jury,
then we weren't going to go to the grand jury.
Q. But the first grand jury, which was scheduled
in March or April, different witnesses were subpoenaed
to that grand jury, correct?

A. Correct.
Q. Amongst them was Ms. Jane Doe 103, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. Amongst them was Ms. M., correct?
Page 489
1 A. Okay.
2 Q. Okay? Before Mr. Dershowitz got involved, she
3 had an incident report, did she not?
4 A. IJh-hub.
5 Q. She had a probable cause — a search
6 warrant-
7 A. I take that back. Prior to Mr. Dershowitz
8 being involved, I don't believe she had the incident
9 report as of yet. It was still in the investigative
10 stage. The search had been conducted, interviews bad
11 been conducted, I had been providing her with copies of
12 the interviews, but I don't believe that she had a copy
13 of the incident report as of yet:
14 Q. Right. And she had copies of certain portions:
15 of what ultimately was incorporated into the incident '
16 report, correct?
17 MS. ARBOUR: Form. .
18 THE WITNESS. I don't believe so.
19 BY MR. WEINBERG:.
20 Q. She had — did she not have copies of mulls
21 of-
22- A. When the case is under investigation, were
23 not going to release the incident report. She may have
24 had the face sheet and the — involving Mr. Epstein's
25 name on it,.but that's basically it.
2.
.4. •
11 •
12 .
16..

18. .
21..
22.:
.25 . .
Page 491
A. Yes.
Q. Was amongst them Ms. M.?
A. Yes.
Q. Who else?
A. I believe this was it. I think that was the
initial — they were going to do it in sections, and
they were going to pick those girls to go first.

Q. And the criminal offense that she was
investigating at the time was felony solicitation?
MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: I don't know what she was
looking into. I know what f was seeking.
•BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. You and her had disagreements about witnesses
and charges, correct?
A. Yes.
Q. -And you had disagreements about whether or not
the witnesses that you denominated victims and she said
weren't victims, you had disagreements over their
credibility, did you not?

A. Not over their credibility. It Was over,
like, the MySpace pages I bad the feeling that she was
1134118 to —
• Q. I don't mean to interrupt, but I want to stick
to conversations and evidence and not feelings, so
44 (Pages 488 to 491)
PROSE COURT 'REPORTING AGENCY, ':.:.•: :":(561)' -832-7506
Electronically signed by Jeana RIccluti (601M(
Electronically signed by Jeana Rlccluti (601 c15062637-abe14620-68364x:614•314d7a
21.
Page 492

MR. GARCIA: Cm ahead and finish your answer,
sir. Don't let him interrupt you. You can finish
your answer.
THE WITNESS: I had the feeling that she was
trying to brush this case under the carpet. That
was my —
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. You believed that she was minimizing the CIL%
correct? .
A. (Non-vabal response).
Q. And you believed that one of the reasons she
was minimizing the case was her review of the MySpace
pages of some of your witnesses, correct?

A. I know that the attitude of the State
Attorney's office was very pro-assisting us from the
very beginning. Once Mr. Dersbowitz became involved in
the investigative stage, everything changed.

Q. So let's talk about these MySpace pages for a
minute. MySpace pages are an Internet site where the
witnesses herself would put information out there that
was available to whoever accessed the site, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
TIIE WITNESS: MySpacc is a social network that
you can basically create anything that you want to
create on a MySpace page.
Page 494
1 BY MR. WEINBERG:
2 Q. And the State Attorney was weighing the
3 -.MySpace information with the information that they were
4 ,. receiving from the Palm Beach Police Department; is that
5 correct?
6 MS. ARBOUR: Form.
7 . . THE WITNESS: Well, the information and the
8 meetings that Mr. Dershowitz had with Barry
9 Krisher.
10 BY MR. WEINBERG:
11 - Q. And you were not present at some of these
12 meetings?
13 - A. Correct.
14 Q. So you don't know the full scope of the
15'• presentation being made by attorneys, including
16 Professor Dershowitt, on Mr. Epstein's behalf, correct?
17 A. I just found it odd that during the
18 investigative stage, we were already discussing
19 strategies on whether to prosecute or not to prosecute,
20 and this was still in the investigative stage of it.
21 • Q. Putting aside your feeltngs, you were not
22 present at these presentations?
23 A. Some I were.
24 Q. Some you were. You don't know the full scope
25 of the arguments and the evidence that was being
Page 493
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. And you understood that certain of your
witnesses created their own MySpace page, correct?
A. It's possible.

Q. And did you ever, in order to determine any of
the background of your witnesses, go on their MySpace
Pages?

A. I did view some of their MySpace pages, and I
did view sane of the items that Mr. Dersbowitz provided
to Mr. Krisher, but we're talking about teenagers who
put -- this is information that's put on a site that's
not checked for any validity. I can create a site using
your information.
. Q. Did you ever ask Ms. lane Doe 103 in any
followup interview, is there anything on your site that
doesn't depict you?

A. Actually, I never spoke to any of the victims •
about — .
Q. Did you ever do an independent investigation
to determine whether any of the information provided by
Professor Dershowilz to the State Attorney was
fabricated or falsified or externally placed there by ' • .
some third party?

MS. ARBOUR: Pam.
THE WITNESS. No
.7
8,
9-
10 .
11 .•
13'
17• •
IR: .
20: .
22 .
23 -
2.4
25..
Page 495
provided to the State Attorney by the Defense lawyers,
correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Form.
THE WITNESS: The ones that I chose to go to,
'just — I was privy to some of the information
but not all.
BY MR. WEINBERG:

Q. And the fact is that
A. .Yesh.: .
Q. — came to separate conclusions from case
chief Detective Joe Recarey, regarding the gravity of

Mr. Epstein's conduct, correct?

• . MS. ARBOUR: Form. •
. -THE WITNESS: Pm sorry?
BY MR. WEINBERG:
• Q. You and the State Attorney's office came to
different conclusions in this case, correct?

MS. ARBOUR: Porni.
THE WITNESS: We had our disagreements, yes.

• BY MR WEINBERG:
Q. And those disagrectrients led to you and
Chief Reiter inviting the FBI agent intothis
investigation, correct?
• . • •MS. ARBOUR: Pam. •
• THE WITNESS: Not the disagreements. The faet
45 (Pages 492 to 495)
PROSE COURT REPORTING -AGENCY, INC.. '4561) $32-7506 .
Electronically signed by Jeana Rlectutl (601
Electronically signed by Joana Rlcciull (601 c5062637-abo1452c-a836-bc8146.314d7a
Page 496 Page 4981
1. that the case wasn't— it wasn't-- in my eyes, it 1 CERTIFICAT3
2 SIATROP FLORIDA 2 wasn't any justice served. 3 COUN1Y OF PALM REACH
3 BY MR. WEINBERG: ' 4
4 Q. Your disagreanents with the State Attorneys $ LkamRieciuri. Registered Professional
Reporter and Notary Public in and for the State of
5 charge decision led you to go outside the State law 6 Florida a Lana, do hereby certify that the
6 enforcement community and transmit information about aforemanional witness was by me lint duly mom to
7 testify the whole truth; that I was unbolt() to and
7 Mr. Epstein to Federal authorities? did moon said deposition in stenotype; and that the
0 MS. ARBOUR: Form, asked and answered. 8 foregoing pages numbered 319 to 495 are a true and
cartel transcription of my shorthand into of said 9 THE WITNESS: And also to see if there was any a deposition.
10 Federal nexus pertaining to the case. 10 I further certify that aid deposition vein
taken at the time and place hereinabove set forth and 1 1 BY MR. WEINBERG: it that the taking of sad deposition was 
commenced and
12 Q. But you sought to determine if there was a completed as haeinabove set out.
13 Federal nexus relating to this case as a result of your 12
1 further certify that I am not an attorney or
14 disagreements with the charge decisions that were being 13 counsel crony of the parties, nee am I a relative a
15 made by.your State Attorney, correct? employee of any attorney a counsel of party connected
14 with the action, nor an I &mei* interested in the 16 MS. ARBOUR: Form. action.
17 • THE WITNESS: I believe so. 15
The icaton of this transcript
Lanny 18 MR WEINBERG: Why don't we Igo a break and 16 does not apply to reproduction of die same by any
19 have lunch. means unless under the direct °retro] and/or direction
20 17
:u
of the catifying reporter.
21 MR. WEINBERG: as Dated this lath ft , of May, 2010.
22 (A luncheon recess was taken.) 20 C.__ ../
21.
earn Rleciutl, FPR, CLR
24 23
4 25 25
Page 497
1 CERTIFICATE OF OATH
2 STATE OF FLORIDA
3 COUNTY OF PALM BEACH
6 I, the undersigned authority, certify that
7 JOSEPH RECAREY pctsonally appeared before Inc and was
8 duly sworn on the 27th day of April, 2010.
10 Witness my hand and official seal this 27th
11 day of April, 2010.
13.
C ---j..40
Jeana Ricciuti, RPR, PPR,te r
17 Notary Public - State of Florida
My Commission Expires: 2/17/2013
18 My Commission Na: DD 854778
4.6 (Pages 496 to 498)
PROSE COURT REPORTING 'AGENCY, INC. '
Electronically signed by Jeans Ricciuti(601M)
Electronically signed by Jeana RIcclutl (601
c5062637-abel-452c-a836-bc614e31447a
EFTA01688746 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI report about Epstein investigation
(inferred date: 2026-01-25)
• FD-302a (Rev. 104-95)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD•302 of   .On  11/27/2006  .Page  3
monies in cash and later clarified the bonuses came by company
check. Visoski stated he had only had two disagreements with
Epstein and both were over maintenance for the aircrafts.
Visoski provided Epstein's cellular telephone, (646) 541-
1751, and email, JEEPROJECT@Yahoo.com.
The below list of current and past employees were
provided by Visoski:
- Personal Assistant (Black Berry, T
Mobi e), email - net
Lesley LNU - Secretary in New York Office
Miles Alexander - Island Manager (U.S.V.I.)
Bryce LNU - Ranch Manager (New Mexico)
Ghislaine Maxwell - Business Manager/Best Friend
Bruce White - Boat Captain (U.S.V.I.)
s - House Staff (PB)
Egor Zinoview - Russian fitness instructor
Lance Callaway - Current Chef
Roberto LNU - Prior Chef
David Mullen - Prior Chef
- Prior Chef
Adam Perrylang - Prior Chef
- Personal Assistant
- Personal Assistant
FD-302a (Rev. 10-695)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of  .0611/27/2006  .Page  _I_
1E-MM-108062
Pursuant to a federal egarding the
sexual exploitation of m. a victim, was
interviewed by the FBI. i en i ying nformation is
recorded below:
Name
Race
Sex
DOB
SSAN
Home Address
Residence telephone
Cellular telephone
Parents telephone
(Phoenix)
White
Female
"It n, Texas
210 -b-1,4"..1°8.66 42  -4
1E-MM-108062
1.
Pursuant to a federa
sexual exploitation of m'
interviewed by the FBI.
recorded below:
104S
Name
Race
Sex
DOB
SSAN
Home Address
Residence telephone
Cellular telephone
Parents telephone
(Phoenix)
White
egarding the
a victim, was
identifying information is
Female
AUStin. Texas
•
1/4 3 /E- wim --/08.06,2- its?'
(Rev. l-M400” • •
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: PRIORITY
To: Albuquerque
Jacksonville
San Juan
From: Miami
Squad PB-2 PBCRA
Contact:
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
(Pending)
GHISLAINE N. MAXWELL
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Date: 12/06/2006
Santa Fe RA
Pensacola RA
St. Thomas RA
Synopsis: To set leads for captioned investigation.
Details: On 07/24/2006 the Federal Bureau of Investigation
(FBI), Palm Beach County Resident Agency (PBCRA), began
investigating Jeffrey Epstein, a part-time resident of Palm
Beach, along with his personal assistants,
and Ghislaine Maxwell. PBCRA obta ne n orma on from
e y of Palm Beach Police Department (PBPD) that a fourteen -
year-old girl who lives in Loxahatchee Florida, in the Southern
District of Florida, and who attended
Mlt, provided Epstein "sexual massages . e our een-year-
rl informed PBPD that she had been paid $300.00 by Jeffrey
Epstein to perform a "sexual massage", which entailed providing a
massage to Epstein while he was naked and the
. During the massa
Following the receipt of the case
PBCRA began interviewing a series of girls,
fourteen through mid to early twenties, who
series of events. In particular, the gi
was made via telephone, primarily with
files from the PBPD,
ranging in age from
reported a similar
how contact
Epstein's
, g-toef.se_ zie- KR-  i0800.2-

To: Albuquerque AIM: Miami
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 12/06/2006
•
assistant, to arrange times for the girls to "work" at Epstein's
home in Palm Beach. The girls would travel to Epstein's
residence, usually in the company of another girl. The girls
would enter Epstein's home via the kitchen, where they would be
met by Epstein and/or The girls would be escorted up to
Epstein's bedroom where a massage table was accessible. The girls
were told to undress - some undressed only partially and some
undressed completely. Epstein would enter the room partially
dressed, usually wearing only a towel. He would get onto the
massage table face down. While lying face down, Epstein
instructed the girl how to massage him. After a period of time
when the girl massaged Epstein's back, he would turn over and lie
face up. While lying face up, Epstein would continue to instruct
the •irl on how to conduct the massage. Epstein also would
and occasionall
n most
an
e "massage was
over an• t e g r was nstruc e• to get •ressed and to return to
the downstairs area of the residence. The girls received between
$200 and $300 for the sexual massages.
In addition to these sexual massages, some of the girls
were paid additional sums to perform more sexual activity, for
example, engaging in sexual activity with another female Epstein
employee, while Epstein watched.
During the course of PBPD's investigation, a search
warrant for Epstein's home was obtained and executed. Many of
Epstein's belongings were removed from the home prior to the
execution of the search warrant - for example, the computer
processing units (CPUs) were removed from the house but the
computer screens, keyboards, cords, etc. were left behind. The
missing CPU's were never recovered.
During the search, several telephone message pads were
recovered. These message pads show messages taken from several of
the girls who were interviewed and admitted to engaging in sexual
massages or other sexual activity with Epstein. The messages
contained text such as "I have a female for him" and "has girl
for tonight." Some of the messages from the irls were addressed
to Epstein and others were addressed to Epstein's
assistant. Additional messages recovered ur ng e search
contained text confirming appointment times.
that
Durin the PBCRA's investigation, the 21L12 related
would contact the girls while IIIIII and

• ,
To: Albuquerque Atm: Miami
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 12/06/2006Epstein were still in New York or elsewhere, in order to arrange
"massage" times upon his arrival in Palm Beach. The PBCRA's
investigation has collected the flight manifest for Epstein's two
private planes during the period of January 2004 through December
2005 as well as cellular phone records for Epstein, and
the majority of girls. The igation revea e that prior to
the flights to Palm Beach, would contact some of the girls
via cell phone. The massage pa s show evidence that the girls
responded to those telephone calls and in some instances
appointment confirmations were left for Epstein.
In addition to the home in Palm Beach, Epstein also
maintains a residence in the U.S. Virgin Islands, New York and
New Mexico.
To date, the PBCRA continues-to develop witnesses and
victims from across the United States. Due to the media coverage,
unknown status of the state investigation, vulnerability of the
young female victims, and political influences, the AUSAs and
Case.Agents have a target date of January 2007 for indictment.
Based on the ongoing criminal investigation, the PBCRA
is requesting the assistance in establishing Epstein's criminal
activity utilizing interstate commerce and the travel in
interstate commerce to engage in illicit sexual conduct and
prostitution. Prior to conducting captioned leads it is
requested that the lead a ent s contact SA
4 e 1 or
for investigative ion and
questions.

• 1
To: Albuquerque At: Miami
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 12/06/2006
LEAD(s):
Set Lead 1: (Action)
ALBUOUEROUE
AT SANTA FE , NM
•
Interview , ranch manager for Jeffrey
Epstein's, Zorro Ranc , orro Ranch Road, Stanley, New Mexico.
Set Lead 2: (Action)
SAN JUAN
AT ST. THOMAS, U.S.V.I.
rview IIIIIIIIIIIIII, cellul leohone number of
, residence e ep one number , house
manager rey Epstein located on the s an o i le St.
James. was born in Capetown, South Africa.
Set Lead 3: (Action)
SAN JUAN
AT ST. THOMAS. U.S.V.I.
Locate a n , boat captain,
telephone number ( is is he only information FBI
Miami currently has on
Set Lead 4: (Discretionary)
JACKSONVILLE
AT PENSACOLA, FL
Intervi housekeeper, W/F, DOB
, SSAN , , Milton,
Set Lead 5: (Action)
To; Albuquerque Fiom: Miami
.Se: 31E-MM-108062, 12/06/2006
•
JACKSONVILLE
AT PENSACOLA, FL
TritArvii= housekeeper, W/F, DOB
SSAN , Cantonment,
.•
r (Rev. 01.313003) • • FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To: Miami
From: Miami
FIG-5
Contact: Ia
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 41E -MM-108062 (Pending)
800A-MM-C102437-AS34 (Pending)
Date: 12/20/2006
Title: CREATION OF i2 ANALYST NOTEBOOK CHARTS
Synopsis: To document assistance provided to Intelligence
Analyst (IA) in the creation of i2 Analyst
Notebook Charts.
Details: Intelligence Assistant (Ia) provided
assistance in the creation of i2 Analyst Notebook Charts for the
above -mentioned case. The charts were produced according to the
specifications of Special Agent and did
not require any research or analysis on the part of Ia . The
charts depicted the arrival and departure dates of the target and
included the phone calls that were made the day prior to his
arrival, during his stay and the day after his departure. Ia
created a total of 16 charts. The charts ranged in
date from 02/10/2005 through 10/06/2005.
44.
31E--mm- logt)(00-SD
FD-302 (Rev. 10-6-95) •
- I -
FEDERAL BUREAU O1? INVESTIGATION
Date of transcription 08/22/2006
was interviewed at her residence in West
Palm Beach, Florida regarding a federal investigation involving the
sexual exploitation of minors. After being advised of the identity
of the interviewing agents and the nature of the interview,
provided the following information:
was employed as the House Manager for JEFFREY
EPSTEIN's rest ence on the island of Palm Beach, Florida. She
began working for EPSTEIN approximate , ree years ago.
stated GHISLAINE MAXWELL(believed by to be EPSTEIN's
girlfrie he time)
ill
e nwohired her. It was
through sister, and her association with
WMAXWELL an TEIN that came o be emp at the EPSTEIN
residence. According to
iiilif the salons lm eac she met both MAXWELL and EPSTEIN.
stated that provided massages to EPSTEIN.
While employed at the EPSTEIN residence, primary
responsibilities were to have the house ready t e arrival of
either EPSTEIN or MAXWELL and their guests. ensured ta m
house was stocked with food, beverages, and res flowers.
would also help in the arrangement of transportation to and !!!!' the airport.
it was while was working at
stated that there was a high rate of turnover among
the staff employed at the EPSTEIN residence because EPSTEIN
MAXWELL, and others were not very nice to the hired help.
stated EPSTEIN was nice in the beginning but became
believed she was fired because she got married. was given
$3000.00 in severance pay.
was never at the residence when EPSTEIN was having
a massage. — r stated she had taken many messages from girls
who wanted to work for EPSTEIN. The girls would want to know when
to take a
would leave the
ve in from
was asked
EPSTEIN was coming to town and they would want
message, so EPSTEIN could return their call.
messages on the counter so that when EPSTEIN wou
out of town he could review them. One Christmas,
to call 5 or 6 of EPSTEIN's "massage girls" and redo them that
they could stop to pick up their Christmas gift. Although not
Investigation on  08/17/2006  at  West Palm Beach, Florida
Fike -10
by
Due didWd 08/17/2006

are- Hit - a9062
.‘„,
FDxtuatev.m..6-9* • •
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of .0n08/17/2006  .Page  2
positive, believed she was asked to do this task around
Christmas 004.
told the interviewing agent of an incident that
occurre t t c EPSTEIN's residence either late summer or early
fall. was unsure of the year but • must have been in
2003 2 or 2005. The cleaning crew, AND
were working at the time of the inci ent as ewlt
uni entified female(UF), who looked under the age of eighteen,
entered the residence dema money. She had arrived at the
residence in i cab. described her as trashy and
desperate. told the she was unaware of any money that had
been left for t e UF, but that ld call the New York Office.
The UF stated that she thought was going to be at the
residence toda . contacte t e New York Office and they
instructed to pay the UF. The New York Office stated that
.
coul Ina $200.00 in EPSTEIN's desk draw and she was to use
that to pay the Once the UF received the money she departed
the residence. stated to the interviewing agents, that at
one point she to e UP she was going to call the police if the
UP did not leave, but the UF responded that she would call the
police if she did not get her money.
it big in Illilodeling industry.
believed that EPSTEI w sign to help girls
sister, told
that EPSTEIN would give money to o. lr t !!Trhem go to college
or get them started in modeling. stated that she may have
been naive but she thought he was rying to help these girls.
W he residence even when MAXWELL was not there.
tated that she knew EPSTEIN liked women and that n would
believed there were naked photographs of women throughout t e
residence.
following:
tele hone nu er
Accor ing
ce u ar e ephone number
ct information as the
, Jupiter, Florida,
ephone number
mbers are
also provided to the interviewing agents a copy of
some of the our he worked at residence as some
notes made by at her time o emp-oyment with Those
ldocuments have een placed in a FD-340, a 1-A envelope, an are I'li
maintained with the case file.
FD-302(Rev.10-6-95) • •
-1-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
DMoftmiscription 08/22/2006
was interviewed at her residence in West
Palm Beach, Florida regarding a federal investigation involving the
sexual exploitation of minors. After being advised of the identity
of the interviewing agents and the nature of the interview,
provided the following information:
was employed as the House Manager for JEFFREY
EPSTEIN's rest ence on the island of Palm Beach, Florida. She
began working for EPSTEIN approximate) three years ago.
stated GHISLAINE MAXWELL(believed by to be EPSTEIN's
girlfrie he time) ' e nwohired her. It was
through sister, and her association with
MAXWELL an THIN that came o be emp at the EPSTEIN
residence. According to it was while was working at
f the salons lm eac she met both LL and EPSTEIN.
stated that provided massages to EPSTEIN.
While employed at the EPSTEIN residence, primary
responsibilities were to have the house ready f t e arrival of
either EPSTEIN or MAXWELL and their guests. ensured t'
house was stocked with food, beverages, and res flowers.
would also help in the arrangement of transportation to and rom
the airport.
stated that there was a high rate of turnover among
the staff emp oyed at the EPSTEIN residence because EPSTE:N
MAXWELL, and others were not very nice to the hired help.
stated EPSTEIN was nice in the beginning but beca ilean."
believed she was fired because she got married. was given
$3000.00 in severance pay.
was never at the residence when EPSTEIN was having
a massage. stated she had taken many messages from girls
who wanted to work for EPSTEIN. The girls would want to know when
EPSTEIN was i to town and they would want to take a
message, so could return thei would leave the
messages on t e counter so that when wou arrive in from
out of town he could review them. One ristmas, "III was asked
to call 5 or 6 of EPSTEIN's "massage girls" and re ay to them that
they could stop to pick up their Christmas gift. Although not
Investigation on  08/17/2006
Files 3
by S
at West Palm Beach, Florida
Date dictated 08/17/2006
Lac, ,302_

A:3,c:rt.H._ ,o,,,,,,z, ,
FD-302o (Rev. 10-6.95)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of
• •
.On  08/17/2006
positive, Will believed she was asked to do this task around
Christmas 4.
told the interviewing agent of an incident that
occurre a EPSTEIN's residence either late summer or early
fall. was unsure of the year but knew it must have been in
2863 2 or 2005. The cleaning crew,
, were working at the-time of-the
entified female(UF), who looked under the age of eighteen,
entered the residence dema
residence in i cab.
desperate. told the
been left for the UF, but that she would call the New York Office.
The UF stated that she thought EPSTEIN was going to be at the
residence t contacted the New York Office and they
instructed to pay the UF. The New York Office stated that
could find $200.00 in EPSTEIN's desk draw and she was to use
to pay the Once the UF received the money she departed
the residence. stated to the interviewing agents, that at
one point she to e UF she was going to call the police if the
UF did not leave, but the UF responded that she would call the
police if she did not get her money.
money. She had arrived at the
described her as trashy and
she was unaware of any money that had
believed that EPST
it big in Illilodeling industry.
to help girls
sister, told
that EPSTEIN would give money to to e p them go t ollege
or get them started in modeling. stated that she have
been naive but she thought he was rying to help these gir s.
stated that she knew EPSTEIN liked women and that n would
visa the residence even when MAXWELL was not there.
believed there were naked photographs of women throughout t e
residence.
following:
tel hone n r.
According
eglarair telephone number
some of J.
notes made by
documents have
maintained with
t information as the
Jupiter, Florida,
splesirturralar--
--- •eta are
- • •---- -
also provided to the interviewing agents a copy of
he worked at EPSTEIN's residence as well as some
at her time of employment with EPSTEIN. Those
een placed in a FD-340, a 1-A envelope, and are
the case file.
t A
FD-302(Rev.10495) •
-1-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Damoftransthpaan 12/13/2006
Pursuant to a federal investigation regarding the sexual
exploitation of minors, David Richard Mullen, was interviewed by
the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). After being advised of
the identity of the interviewing agents and purpose of the
interview, Mullen voluntarily provided the following information:
Mullen was formerly employed as a chef at Daniel, a four
star restaurant in New York, New York. He was also formerly
employed as a chef by Jeffrey Epstein. Mullen was seeking
employment and obtained the opportunity for employment with Epstein
from a headhunter. Mullen's pre-employment interview for the
position was conducted by Epstein and Ghislaine.Maxwell
.approximately three years ago. Mullen was employed by Epstein for
approximately one year and five months before he sought employment
elsewhere. Mullen signed a confidentiality clause at the
termination of his employment with Epstein.
Mullen worked at Epstein's New York residence and was on
stand-by to travel at request. He prepared meals for Epstein's
guests more frequently than he prepared meals for Epstein.
Epstein's favorite food item was a toasted peanut butter and jelly
sandwich. Mullen was responsible for keeping food available on the
various properties where Epstein traveled. One item that Mullen
was required to have available at all times was Eli's seven grain
bread purchased from 63rd or 65th Street in New York. Mullen used
Epstein's vehicles, including a Mercedes Benz and a Chevrolet
Suburban, to obtain food as needed for preparation at Epstein's
Palm Beach, Florida r ' ence v. P en with a
residence located at , New York,
New York, as a component o u en s sa ary.
Mullen traveled frequently with Epstein to his properties
in Palm Beach, Florida, the U.S. Virgin Islands (USVI), New Mexico
and New York. Mullen also traveled to Paris, France with Epstein.
Epstein owned a Gulfstream aircraft and a larger Boeing 727
aircraft. The Boeing 727 had a kitchen onboard that Mullen used to
prepare food for Epstein and his guests. During Mullen's travels,
the most notable guests to travel on Epstein's aircraft were John
Kerry and Aaron Barak. Epstein instructed Mullen to refrain from
socializing with any guests on the aircraft.
Investigation on. 12/13/2006 m West Palm Beach, Florida
Filets 31E- M-10806   Das dictated 12/13/2006
SA
by  SA

3/6 - tiff - /080L0-4.0.-
.•
FD-302a (Rev. 10-695)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of  David Richard Mullen  .0;112/13/2006  .Page 2
Young females frequently traveled on the two private
aircraft with Epstein. Mullen believed most of the females were
from Spain or Russia and were 18 years of age or older, although
some of their ages were questionable. les lived
in the apartment building located at , New
York, New York. Mullen believed the ema es trave e with Epstein
so they could be associated with a person of wealth. The majority
of the females were aspiring models who met Epstein through Jean
Luc and his modeling agency. Epstein was controlling toward the
females and would not allow them to associate with other
individuals. Mullen described the women as "not very bright"
referring to their intelligence.
Mullen believed w ersonal assistant to
Maxwell and Epstein. Mu escri e as an attractive,
nice girl in her 20's. was response e for preparing
Epstein's travel arrangemen s.
III Last Name Unknown (LNU) was another individual who
worked as an assistant to Maxwell. Mullen believed Maxwell and
Epstein's relationship was nothing more than friendship. Mullen
believed Epstein had feelings for Maxwell but they frequently did
not get along. Mullen provided Maxwell's contact information
stored in his cellular telephone: email comaxlemindsorinct.com, work
telephone 212-750-9895, home telephone 212-879-9366, mobile
telephone 917-520-3106 and PIN 202268F98. Mullen was unaware of
what the PIN represented.
One unknown male, 20's in age, frequently brought local
teenaged females to Epstein's residence in Palm Beach, Florida.
Mullen believed the unknown male drove a red Honda Accord. Mullen
estimated that approximately four or five teenaged females would
visit Epstein's Palm Beach residence daily. Sometimes the females
at the residence would go upstairs with Epstein and sometimes they
would gather and talk in the living room area.
Mullen was aware that Epstein received massages every
day. In addition to massages provided by massage therapists
(masseuses), local teenaged females also gave Epstein massages.
Mullen explained that it was easy to distinguish between the
masseuses and the local teenaged females based on their appearance
and demeanor. Mullen was unaware of what occurred between the
teenaged females and Epstein behind closed doors, but opined that
Epstein was receiving more than just massages based on the number
of teenaged females that were going upstairs with him. Mullen did
L
1:
FD-3024 (Rev. 10-6-95)
31E-MM-108062
onwiwthmam-02or  David Richard _Mullen  on 12L1312006  ,rase  -3_
not know of the local teens to ever stay at Epstein's Palm Beach
residence overnight. Mullen did not have conversations with the
teenaged females beyond being polite and asking if they needed
anything. Mullen did not engage in relationships with the females
associated with Epstein.
Mullen reviewed a series of images and was asked if he
reco nized the individuals depicted. He recognized
an assistant to Eps in who is married man in Mi mi,
on a He also recognized and
believed to be Epstein s gir ,_rien .
IIIIIIIIIIIIII, owner of a barbeque restaurant in New
iew
was emp oye as a chef for Epstein prior to Mullen. Y r '
was a former line cook at Daniel Restaurant, New York,
or i Mullen was aware that Epstein had other chefs before and
after his employment but he was unable to recall their names.
manages Epstein's St. Thomas, USVI
property. Eistein raves to St. Thomas on his private aircraft
and then takes a helicopter to his property. He also owns a four-
engine speed boat he purchased at auction. The boat is used as a
pleasure craft and is also used as a shuttle for Epstein's staff.
New York residence.. and IIII may reside in the
III LNU and LNU. a Filipino couple, m 's
apartment buil ing.
is'responsib security at Epstein's
New York rest ence. n one occasion, gave Mullen a tour of
Epstein's New York residence which Mul en e ieved was a former
high school.
LNU and
Epstein's illilexico
a Russian man named
Palm Beach residence.
Palm Beach residence but
names.
ililiLNU are the property managers of
cated near Santa Fe. Mullen recalled
(phonetic) LNU who worked at Epstein's
stein also had a cleaning crew for the
Mullen was unaware of the crew member's
Mullen heard stories of girls who attempted to steal
items from Epstein's residence and were sent home and not allowed
to return. Mullen did not observe or hear any disturbances during
his employment for Epstein.
A
FD-302 (Rev. I0-6-95)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
2. 302.
Date of transcription 12113/2006
Pursuant to a federal investigation regarding the sexual
exploitation of minors, David Richard Mullen, was interviewed by
the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI). After being advised of
the identity of the interviewing agents and purpose of the
interview, Mullen voluntarily provided the following information:
Mullen was formerly employed as a chef at Daniel, a four
star restaurant in New York, New York. He was also formerly
employed as a chef by Jeffrey Epstein. Mullen was seeking
employment and obtained the opportunity for employment with Epstein
from a headhunter. Mullen's pre-employment interview for the
position was conducted by Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell
approximately three years ago. Mullen was employed by Epstein for
approximately one year and five months before he sought employment
elsewhere. Mullen signed a confidentiality clause at the
termination of his employment with Epstein.
Mullen worked at Epstein's New York residence and was on
stand-by to travel at request. He prepared meals for Epstein's
guests more frequently than he prepared meals for Epstein.
Epstein's favorite food item was a toasted peanut butter and jelly
sandwich. Mullen was responsible for keeping food available on the
various properties where Epstein traveled. One item that Mullen
was required to have available at all times was Eli's seven grain
bread purchased from 63rd or 65th Street in New York. Mullen used
Epstein's vehicles, including a Mercedes Benz and a Chevrolet
Suburban, to obtain food as needed for preparation at Epstein's
Palm Beach, Florida r ' " 'th a
residence located at New York,
New York, as a componen o u en s sa ary.

• Mullen traveled frequently with Epstein to his properties
in Palm Beach, Florida, the U.S. Virgin Islands (USVI), New Mexico
and New York. Mullen also traveled to Paris, France with Epstein.
Epstein owned a Gulfstream aircraft and a larger Boeing 727
aircraft. The Boeing 727 had a kitchen onboard that Mullen used to
prepare food for Epstein and his guests. During Mullen's travels,
the most notable guests to travel on Epstein's aircraft were John
Kerry and Aaron Barak. Epstein instructed Mullen to refrain from
socializing with any guests on the aircraft.
Investigation on  12/13/2006  at  West Palm Beach, Florida
HON 31E- -1 2   Datedictated 12/13/2006
SA
by SA

3/e- HH- to &bp - Sa
• FD-302a (Rev. 10-6-95)
31E-MM-108062
• •
ContelvatamoataX0of  David Richard Mullen  .0'132/13/2006  Jar  2
Young females frequently traveled on the two private
aircraft with Epstein. Mullen believed most of the females were
from Spain or Russia and were 18 years of age or older, although
some of their ages were questionable. Several of the f males lived
in the apartment building located at , New
York, New York. Mullen believed the ema es rave e wi h Epstein
so they could be associated with a person of wealth. The majority
of the females were aspiring models who met Epstein through Jean
Luc and his modeling agency. Epstein was controlling toward the
females and would not allow them to associate with other
individuals. Mullen described the women as "not very bright"
referring to their intelligence.
Mullen believed
Maxwell and Epstein. Mu
nice girl in her 20's.
Epstein's travel arrangements.
ersonal assistant to
escr e as an attractive,
was response e for preparing
III Last Name Unknown (LNU) was another individual who
worked as an assistant to Maxwell. Mullen believed Maxwell and
Epstein's relationship was nothing more than friendship. Mullen
believed Epstein had feelings for Maxwell but they frequently did
not get along. Mullen provided exc./O11's contact ' rmatio
stored in his cell ar tel
en was unaware of
represen e
One unknown male, 20's in age, frequently brought local
teenaged females to Epstein's residence in Palm Beach, Florida.
Mullen believed the unknown male drove a red Honda Accord. Mullen
estimated that approximately four or five teenaged females would
visit Epstein's Palm Beach residence daily. Sometimes the females
at the residence would go upstairs with Epstein and sometimes they
would gather and talk in the living room area.
Mullen was aware that Epstein received massages every
day. In addition to massages provided by massage therapists
(masseuses), local teenaged females also gave Epstein massages.
Mullen explained that it was easy to distinguish between the
masseuses and the local teenaged females based on their appearance
and demeanor. Mullen was unaware of what occurred between the
teenaged females and Epstein behind closed doors, but opined that
Epstein was receiving more than just massages based on the number
of teenaged females that were going upstairs with him. Mullen did
ea
Epstein's Mexici lioll
a Russian man named
Palm Beach residence.
LNU and
Palm Beach residence but
names.
FD-302a (Rev. 10445)
31E-MM-108062
ComlusWonolltand  David Richard Mullen  .0:112/13/2006  .Pagea l,
not know of the local teens to ever stay at Epstein's Palm Beach
residence overnight. Mullen did not have conversations with the
teenaged females beyond being polite and asking if they needed
anything. Mullen did not engage in relationships with the females
associated with Epstein.
Mullen reviewed a series of images and was asked if he
rec ized the individuals depicted. He recognized
an assistant to spsi iiimiimwa an
e also recognized and
believed to be Epstein's !!!!!!rien .
after his
, owner of a barbeque restaurant in New
was emp oye as a chef for Epstein prior to Mullen.
was a former line cook at Daniel Restaurant, New York,
Mullen was aware that Epstein had other chefs before and
employment but he was unable to recall their names.
manages Epstein's St. Thomas, USVI
property. s ein rave s to St. Thomas on his private aircraft
and then takes a helicopter to his property. He also owns a four-
engine speed boat he purchased at auction. The boat is used as a
pleasure craft and is also used as a shuttle for Epstein's staff.
III LNU and Filipino couple,
iiiiiirk residence. and may reside in the
apartment buil ing.
il
is responsib security at Epstein's
New York rest ence. n one occasion, gave Mullen a tour of
Epstein's New York residence which Mul O en e lilieved was a former
high school.
IlliLNU are the property managers of
cated near Santa Fe. Mullen recalled
(phonetic) LNU who worked at Epstein's
stein also had a cleaning crew for the
Mullen was unaware of the crew member's
Mullen heard stories of girls who attempted to steal
items from Epstein's residence and were sent home and not allowed
to return. Mullen did not observe or hear any disturbances during
his employment for Epstein.
31E-MM-108062
a
Pursuant to a federal investigation regarding the sexual
exploitation of minors, David Richard Mullen was interviewed by
the FBI. Mullen's identifying information is recorded below:
Name:
Race:
Sex:
DOB
Home Address:
Cellular Telephone:
Employment:
David Richard Mullen
White
Male
Lantana Florida
C arlton
Mana apan Florida
Phone:
Fax:
3/6- tiff -
"Jr 02 . ec
IIP
31E-MM-108062
Pursuant to a federal investigation regarding the sexual
exploitation of minors, David Richard Mullen was interviewed by
the FBI. Mullen's identifying information is recorded below:
Name:
Race:
Sex:
DOB
Home Address:
Cellular Telephone:
Employment:
David Richard •ullen
White
Male
Lantana rs a
Chef Ritz Carlton
Mann apan F ors a
Phone:
Fax: 561-540-4821
/08ob)
Automated Serial Permanent Charge -Out
FD-5a (1-5-94)
Date: 06/21/07 Time: 13:39
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062 Serial: 54
Description of Document:
Type : FD909
Date : 01/04/07
To : T-MOBIL USA INC
From : MIAMI
Topic: REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
Reason for Permanent Charge -Out:
transfer to subpoena sub
Transferred to:
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serial: 57
Employee:
e -mem - /0$10692S,
• Automated Serial Permanent Charge -Out
FD-5a (1-5-94)
Date: 06/21/07 Time: 13:41
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062 Serial: 55
Description of Document:
Type : FD909
Date : 01/15/07
To : T-MOBILE USA INC
From : MIAMI
Topic: REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
Reason for Permanent Charge -Out:
transfer to subpoena sub
Transferred to:
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serial: 58
Employee:
3 /12-  t4-14-1 -105(04,2SS
Automated Serial Permanent Charge -Out
FD-5a (1-5-94)
Date: 06/21/07 Time: 13:44
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062 Serial: 56
Description of Document:
Type : FD909
Date : 01/15/07
To : CINGULAR WIRELESS
From : MIAMI
Topic: REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
Reason for Permanent Charge -Out:
transfer to subpoena sub
Transferred to:
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062-SBP
Employee:
Serial: 59
.3/E- gm -4280
I -
(Rev. 01.31-1003) • • FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To: Miami
From: Miami
Squad PB-2
Contact:
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108067" (Pending)
Date: 01/25/2007
Attn: Third Party Draft
Title: IN;
WELL
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Synopsis: To request funds for expenses associated to the
above captioned case.
Enclosure(s): Enclosed for Miami Third Party Draft: Original
Sprint bill with associated FD-794 and Original Washington
Mutual bill with associated FD-794.
Details: SA requests Third Party Draft provide
payment in the amount o 5205.00 to Sprint for Detail Call
Reports that provided pertinent information on individuals of
interest in the ongoing federal investigation. This expense
incurred due to the extensive record search requested by the
case agent. It should be• noted that the Detail Call Reports
are not verbatim to for authorization was
obtained from ASAC
SA requests Third Party Draft provide
payment in the amount o $18.25 to Washington Mutual for
administrative fees incurred while providing bank and credit
card records pertaining to individuals of interest in the
ongoing federal investigation.
3/e- /Vie_ /otsobaz_sy
To:
Re:
Miami From: ilami
31E-MM-1C8062, 01/25/2007
LEAD(s) :
Set Lead 1: (Info)
•
MIAMI.
AT MIAMI
Third Party Draft shall issue and submit payment in
the amount of $205.00 to Sprint and $18.25 to Washington
Mutual to pay expenses associated with the captioned case.
FD302(Rev.10445)
- -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Dateonramciptim 08/18/2006
DAVID ROGERS, dob IIIIIIIIII, residin at
orth, Florida, te ep one number(s) an
(cellular), was interviewed at  the FED EAU OF
, PALM BEACH COUNTY RESIDENT AGENCY's Office, West
Palm Beac so present e ew was ROGERS'
y, of
33304, telephone nu
and (cellular). After being advised of
e entity of the intery awing agents and the nature of the
interview, ROGERS provided the following information:
ROGERS has been employed as a pilot for JEFFREY EPSTEIN
since July 1991. His current salary is $165,000.00 plus benefits.
PriOr to his employment with EPSTEIN, ROGERS sold aircraft for
GLIMCHER, a company located near THE LIMITED Flight Department.
ROGERS was employed there from 1987 to 1991. According to R,QCERS,
EPSTEIN has two other full time pilots, LARRY VISOSKI, an
EPSTEIN also has a full time flight engineer,
On occasion, in 2004 and 2005, a contracted pi o ,
was required to assist with flying EPSTEIN to differen
ions.
ROGERS was the Chief Captain for EPSTEIN until January
2005. LARRY VISOSKI took over the responsibilities of Chief Pilot
after a continual disagreement between EPSTEIN and ROGERS on
landing techniques. This was a demotion and a decrease in pay for
ROGERS. ROGERS stated that EPSTEIN was unhappy with the method in
which ROGERS landed the aircraft when arriving at Palm Beach
International Airport.
ROGERS provided the interviewing agents, via a Grand Jury
Subpoena, a copy of his 2004 and 2005 personal aircraft log book
and passenger manifest forms. The passenger manifest forms were
for all flights during 2004 and 2005 for a Boeing 727, tail number
N908JE„ and a Gulfstream, tail number N909JE. According to
ROGERS, the passenger manifest forms were filled out by the Captain
or Co-pilot every time either aircraft was used for travel. If
ROGERS or the other pilots were unable to obtain the names of the
individuals traveling with EPSTEIN, they would list the individuals
on the passenger manifest form by gender, "male" or "female", or
"passenger" or "pax". ROGERS stated that it was seldom that he
Investigation on  08/15/2006  at  West Palm Beach, Florida
Filet 31 M-108062 Due dictated 08/15/2006
by SA
This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI. It is the property of the FBI and is loaned 
to your natty -,
n and its contents are not to be distnbuted outside your agency. 3/E A.? -o' a-a
t
FD-302a (Rev. 10-6-95)
31E —MM-108062
cominua6manowa  David RoaPrs  'On  08/15/2006  Page  2
would pilot either aircraft without EPSTEIN being a passenger on
the planes.
The Boeing 727, tail number N908JE, is owned by a
subsidiary company of EPSTEIN, JEGE, INCORPORATED, and can fly up
to 26 passengers. The Gulf stream, tail number N909JE, is owned and
operated by another of EPSTEIN's subsidiary companies, HYPERION
AIR, INCORPORATED, and can fly up to 12 passengers. ROGERS
believes EPSTEIN has separate entities for each plane for liability
reasons. ROGERS stated that EPSTEIN also owned a six passenger
Helicopter, Bel 407, tail number 491GM.
RODGERS stated that he would usually receive notification
from VISOSKI or from EPSTEIN's office when flight arrangements were
being made. Lead time or a tri most commonly was between eight
to twenty-four hours. EPSTEIN's personal assistant,
was responsible for c ating travel arrangements for EPSTEIN.
ROGERS believed that took over primary duties as EPSTEIN's
personal assistant from GHISLAINE MAXWELL in late 2001.
would handle setting up the staff for EPSTEIN's visits to ulti
residences as well as transportation needs to and from the
airports.
ROGERS advised that he had never witnessed any underage
females aboard the aircrafts. However ROGERS did state that there
had been to many to count when it came to females ranging in age
from 21 to 23. ROGERS also said that he had never observed any sex
toys aboard either of EPSTEIN's aircraft.
When the interviewing agents asked ROGERS for specific
telephone numbers for several individuals, ROGERS provided the
information from a personal digital assistant(PDA) . The below list
of individuals, primarily, current and past employees of EPSTEIN,
were provided by ROGERS:
JEFFREY EPSTEIN - New York Residence, telephone number (212)772-
9416; London residence, telephone number 0044767785771552; cellular
telephone number (917)601-4143; Columbus, Ohio residence telephone
numbers (614)371-4444 and (614)371-1213; Cambridge, Massachusetts
(617)496-4667
- Property Manager foraillasidence in the
. . irgin s an number and cellular
telephone number
-
R}XAtflitim104-95)
31E-MM-108062
•
OrtimudionaMMad  David Rogers ,On  08/15/2006.  ,Page  3
BRYCE GORDON - Ranch Mana er or EPSTEIN's residence in New Mexico,
telephone number
JANUSZ BANASIAK - House manager for EPSTEIN's residence in Palm
Beach, BANASIAK employed for possibly a year or lon er telephone
number , cellular telephone number
ALFREDO Last Name Unknown(LNU) - Prior House Manager for EPSTEIN's
residence in Palm Beach, Florida
LNU and LNU - prior House Managers for EPSTEIN's
rest ence in Palm each, Florida
LESLIE GROFF - Executive Assistant to EPSTEIN,
- nal Assistant to EPSTEIN, cellul
nu er , old cellular telephone number
- trlfriend of EPSTEIN, cellular 1 h n
tiler , believed to be residing at
ew or c, ew York.
- possible Assistant to EPSTEIN '
cons ruc on projects, cellular telephone number
- possible em Lo ee to ither EPSTEIN or GHILISINE
Illiglissistant to associate for the last two
years
personal assistant (ROGERS has not
seen in aw ile)
- Possible employee
JEAN BRUNEL - associated to an Italian Modeling Agency
IGOR ZINOVIEW - Personal trainer to EPSTEIN
LANCE CALLOWAY - EPSTEIN's chef for the last year
DAVID MULLEN - EPSTEIN's chef prior to CALLOWAY
BRENT TINDALL - EPSTEIN's chef in 2004
- t • FD-302 (Rev. 10-6-95)
-1-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Dote of transcription 08/18/2006
DAVIDAGERS,
clattalone
ets.i.d;Ln at
Lake Woreh---MiDa j e ep numbers)
(cellular), was interviewed —art U OF
,--PALM —BEACH COUNTY RESIDENT AGENCY's Office, West
so th- in ervi w was ROGERS ,
of
au•er  e ep,onen er,s
. and, (cellular): After being advised of
t e entity of the interviewing agents and the nature of the
interview, ROGERS provided the following information:
ROGERS has been employed as a pilot for JEFFREY EPSTEIN
since July 1991. His current salary is $165,000.00 plus benefits.
Prior to his employment with EPSTEIN, ROGERS sold aircraft for
GLIMCHER, a company located near THE LIMITED Flight Department.
ROGERS was employed there from 1987 to 1991. According to ROGERS,
EPSTEIN has two other full time pilots, LARRY VISOSKI, and
EPSTEIN also has a full time flight engineer,
On occasion, in 2004 and 2005, a contracted pint,
was required to assist with flying EPSTEIN to differen
oca ions.
ROGERS was the Chief Captain for EPSTEIN until January
2005. LARRY VISOSKI took over the responsibilities of Chief Pilot
after a continual disagreement between EPSTEIN and ROGERS on
landing techniques. This was a demotion and a decrease in pay for
ROGERS. ROGERS stated that EPSTEIN was unhappy with the method in
which ROGERS landed the aircraft when arriving at Palm Beach
International Airport.
ROGERS provided the interviewing agents, via a Grand Jury
Subpoena, a copy of his 2004 and 2005 personal aircraft log book
and passenger manifest forms. The passenger manifest forms were
for all flights during 2004 and 2005 for a Boeing 727, tail number
N908JE„ and a Gulfstream, tail number N909JE. According to
ROGERS, the passenger manifest forms were filled out by the Captain
or Co-pilot every time either aircraft was used for travel. If
ROGERS or the other pilots were unable to obtain the names of the
individuals traveling with EPSTEIN, they would list the individuals
on the passenger manifest form by gender, "male" or "female", or
"passenger" or "pax". ROGERS stated that it was seldom that he
investigation on  08/15/2006  m  West Palm Beach, Florida
mu 3 t -108062 Date dictated 08/15/2006
by S CM:).A. • ?CZ —
This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI. It is the property or the FBI and is loaned 
to your agency;
3/e. —ME /UffaCog _a it said its contents arc not to be distributed outside your agency.
• I.
FD-302a (Acv. 106-95)
31E—MM-1O8O62
Continuation offD-302of  David Rocers  .O1O8/15/2OO6  ,Pagc  2
would pilot either aircraft without EPSTEIN being a passenger on
the planes.
The Boeing 727, tail number S .08JE, is owned by a
subsisliary_company..ot EPSYEIN.,_413GEEINcoRpoRATwo,,. and can fly up
to 26 passengers. The Gulfstrean, lall -nuMber:N909JE, is owned and
operated by another 31- EPBTEIMis subsidiary companies, JYPERION
AIR, INCORPORATED, and cdri-flk-UP to 12 passengers. ROGERS
believes EPSTEIN has separate entities for each plane for liability
reasons. ROGERS stated that EPSTEIN also owned a six passenger
Helicopter, Bel 407, tail number 491GM.
RODGERS stated that he would usually receive notification
from VISOSKI or from EPSTEIN's office when flight arrangements were
being made. Lead time
r
st commonly was between eight
to twenty-four hours. EPSTEIN's personal assistant,
was responsible for c atang travel arrangements for EPSTEIN.
ROGERS believed that took over primary duties as E 's
personal assistant from SLAINE MAXWELL in late 2001.
would handle setting up the staff for EPSTEIN's visits to is multi
residences as well as transportation needs to and from the
airports.
ROGERS advised that he had never witnessed any underage
females aboard the aircra£ts. However ROGERS did state that there
had been to many to count when it came to females ranging in age
.from 21 to 23. ROGERS also said that he had never observed any sex
toys aboard either of EPSTEIN's aircraft.
When the interviewing agents asked ROGERS for specific
telephone numbers for several individuals, ROGERS provided the
information from a personal digital assistant(PDA) . The below list
of individuals, primarily, current and past employees of EPSTEIN,
were provided by ROGERS:
JEFFREY PSTEIN - New York Residence, telephone number (212)772-
9416; London residence, telephone number OO44767785771552; cellular
telephone number (917)6O1-4143; Columbus, Ohio residence telephone
numbers (614)371-4444 and (614)371-1213; Cambridge, Massachusetts
(617)496-4667
irg
- Property Manager. for residence in the
"' number and cellular
gglephone
J im
FD-302a (Rev. 10-6-95)
31E-MM-108062

• •
ContimmicmdSID-Mor  David Rogers ,On  08/15/2006  .Pate  3
SEXCE— RDON - Ran r for. EPSTZIN1s_tep.idauce_4n_litx_MAKj.p.O,
telephone number_
JANUpASIAIC - House manager for EPSTEIN's residence in Palm
Beach, BANASIAK m Toyed for possibly a year or lon er tele hone
number , cellular, telephone number
ALFREDO Last Name Unknown(LNU) - Prior House Manager for EPSTEIN'S
residence in Palm Beach, Florida
LNU and LNU - prior House Managers for EPSTEIN's
rest ence in Palm each, Florida
LESLIE GROFF - Executive Assistant to EPSTEIN,
- Personal Assistant to EPSTEIN, cellul -
old cellular telephone number:
lfriend of EPSTEIN, cellular tele hone -
believed to be resiang at
- possible Assistant to EPSTEIN
construction projeatiar telephone nUmber
"
IIIII,Issistant to
- possible either EPSTEIN or GHILISINE
associate for the last two
years
personal assistant (ROGERS has not
seen in aw Ile)
- Possible employee
JEAN BRUNEL - associated to an Italian Modeling Agency
IGOR ZINOVIEW - Personal trainer to EPSTEIN
LANCE CALLOWAY - EPSTEIN's chef for the last year
DAVID MULLEN - EPSTEIN's chef prior to CALLOWAY
BRENT TINDALL - EPSTEIN's chef in 2004
4_ .-.
FD-302 (Rev. 10-6-95)
•
' I "
•
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
d
Columbus,
Florida 33411, hom u •er
telephone numbers and
at the FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVE IGATI
RESIDENT AGENCY (PBCRA), located at
Lori' a
of
Orl•a 04,
(cellular) a
to en one nu
GOLDBERGER & WEISS, P.A.,
Beach, Florida 33401, telep one nu
advised of the ide f the interviewing agents and the nature
of the interview, provided the following information:
is currently a full time pilot employ
JEFFREY EP as a captain for EPSTEIN's airplanes. has
been employed by EPSTEIN since January 2005. Prior emp oylid m,en
included piloting as a captain for The Limited Brands, specifically
r
er
mdeatrumthom 12/01/2006
er s
place of birth
al Palm Beach,
cellular
, was interviewed
BEACH COUNTY
, We lm
rney
Ft.
and
o A ERBURY
, West Palm
After being
tnere un
to advance and took a piloting job,flying executives for the
Venetian Hotels, Las V -vada. Due to difficulties with the
Chairman i lioard, was ikecember 2004.
Through asso th EPSTEIN's
airplan r and contac wit EIN whi ing
for was o urrent employment.
state na w e piloting for

he had not seen any young
females passengers.
He began working f
e Spring of 2004.
in 1985 and remained
was offered an opportunity
stated his current salary is $150,000 - $155,000.
was pal a Christmas bonus of $5000.00, gross income.
stated that EPSTEIN has three ful captains with one
eangthe chief captain, LARRY VI stated that in his
position he would be "on call." continued explaining that
VISOSKI would contact him providing short notice, usually a days
notice, when EPSTEIN would need him to pilot an aircraft.
When piloting an aircraft for EPSTEIN, or the co-
pilot would always complete two forms. The firstill.required by
the FAA, was a maintenance log, which would record the date of
Investigation on
Pile 3
by
at West Palm Beach, Florida
Datediamoi 12/01/2006

E -rya --/oret
FD-302a (Rcv. 10-6-95)
31E-MM-108062
centinwtiono[FD-302of .0n11/27/2046  .Page  2
flight, as well as; air time for the aircraft. The other form was
a flight manifest which, among other items, listed number of
passengers, in some cases identity of passengers, departure and
arrival destinations as well as date and time of flight. The
flight manifest is not required by law; however, both forms are
completed by the designated captain of the flight. These
responsibilities are rotated amongst the pilots. The forms are
sent to the office on a monthly basis.
has never observed un girls (under twenty)
as passengers on EPSTEIN's airplanes. did state that once
or twice children accompanied by adults were passengers on the
airplanes.
stated that h s strictly a business
relationship wi EPSTEIN. believed that EPSTEIN is a
financial money manager as never socially been to any of
EPSTEIN's residences. Interviewed for his current job at
EPSTEIN's Palm Beach rest ence.
cellular tilPe number as
provided, EPSTEIN's as istant,
provided the following address as a past
residence:
es ervi io 43082
s
• FD-302 (Rev. 10-6-95)
-1-
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date du -inscription 12/01/2006
Columbus,  O io, r si
leiorida
telephone numbers .
at -the FEDERAL BUR
RESIDENT AGENCY (PBCRA),
Beach, Florid
WEISS, P.A.
Beach, Florida 33401, to
advised of the Edell,
of the interview,
of
al orica a ep one nu er p and •14÷ -11.
(cellular) and Attorney JACKaiLDBERGER 0 TERBURY
250 Australia
Ft
place,of birth
al Palm Beach,
was interviewed
ACH COUNTY
W m
rney
00, West -Palm :J.
lephone.number . After being
f the interviewing agents and the nature
provided the following information:
is currently a full time pilot
JEFFREY EP as a captain for EPSTEIN's
airplaneemploy
s. has
.
been employed by EPSTEIN since January 2005. Prior emp-oymen
in 1 ed piloting as a captain for Th 'ted Brands, specifically
He began working in 1985 and remained
t ere until the Spring of 2004. was offered an opportunity
to advance and took a piloting jo , ying executives for the
Venetian Hotels, 'Las Ve vada. Due to difficulties with the
Chairman of the Board, was ' ecember 2004.
th EPSTEIN's Through
airp
for
statInTra w
assoc
and con act wi EIN whi ing
was o ere urrent employment.
e piloting for he had not seen any young
females passengers.
stated his current salary is $150,000 - $155,000.
was pal a Christmas bonus of $5000.00, gross income.
stated that EPSTEIN has three ful im captains with one
ing he chief captain, LARRY VI stated that in his
position he would be "on call." con inued explaining that
V/SOSKI would contact him providing s ort notice, usually a days
notice, when EPSTEIN would need him to pilot an aircraft.
When piloting an aircraft for EPSTEIN, or the co-
pilot would always complete two forms. The firstitEl irequired by
the FAA, was a maintenance log, which would record the date of
Weestigaticoon 11/27/2006 as West Palm Beach, Florida
File I
by
Da:edit:WM 12/01/2006
Oz (01MO?..
This document oontaim neither recommendatioes nor conelmions of the FBL It Is the property of the FBI and is loaned to 
your agency,
it and its contents are not to be distributed outside your agency.
- :gm -tote-06a -0
MOMAOUIPACI-6-98
31E-MM-108062
• •
UntinnWnaN}Kaa .0n  11/27/2006  ,Page 2
flight, as well as; air time for the aircraft. The other form was
a flight manifest which, among other items, listed number of
passengers, in some cases identity of passengers, departure and
arrival destinations as well as date and time of flight. The
flight manifest is not required by law; however, both forms are
completed by the designated captain of the flight. These
responsibilities are rotated amongst the pilots. The forms are
sent to the office on a monthly basis.
has never observed un girls (under twenty)
as passengers on EPSTEIN's airplanes. did state that once
or twice children accompanied by adults were passengers on the
airplanes.
stated tha
relationship  EPSTEIN.
financial money manager
EPSTEIN's residences.
EPSTEIN's Palm Beach rest ence
s strictly a business
believed that EPSTEIN is a
as never socially been to any of
interviewed for his current job at
istant
cellular to ep one number as
provided, EPSTEIN' a ,
MO provided the following address as
residence:
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
a past
FD-302 (Rev. 10-6-95)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
mkawansa 11/01/2006
was interviewed near her residence in
West Palm eac , F ori a regarding a federal investigation
involving the sexual exploitation of minors. After being advised
of the iden the interviewing agents and the nature of the
interview, provided the following information:
believed she first began providing massages to
EPSTEIN at is residence in Palm Beach, Florida in June 2004. She
was sixteen years old and thought she would'be providin EPSTEIN
with a massage or possibly modeling lingerie for him.
irst traveled to EPSTEIN's Palm Beach residence by Yel ow ,
, with anoth
massy e, BIN touched
. After the massage was over, s emp oyee, escribed
as aving darker d looking f , took the two girls back
to their homes. con once they were home and
wanted to call ce. was upset and did not
understand why would a e er to EPSTEIN's residence if she
knew it inv more than pro • • a massage or modeling
lingerie. discouraged from reporting EPSTEIN to the
authorities.
believed she went to EPSTEIN's residence on at
least three occasions, all visits were made over approximately a
one month time neri d. On the second visit she took a friend,
LNU. did not disrobe completely, she
in her
ir• vis , s e wen o
visit, EPSTEIN instructed
He told her a
massage, 4.4 EIN
was told by EPSTEIN that she w of to tell
anyone whallig ilappened during the massages. began
v ' phone calls from EPSTEIN and EPSTE s assistant,
e
n
On this
ff
stated that on each of th .-s to EPSTEIN's
residence s IM taken a Xanax. However, stated that she
Investigation on 10/30/2006
Files 3 -108062
by
s West Palm Beach, Florida
Date dictated 10/30/2006
A A 2 -40 S ic _ K., -
FD-3022 (Rev. 10-645)
31E -MM -108062
Continianon of f-0-302 of

• •
.O110/30/2006  ,Pagc  2
knows clearly what EPSTEIN did to her in retards to him touching
her inappropriately.
II1
FD-302 (Rev. 10-5-95)

• •
- I -
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Data of trans.:6 01bn 11/01/2006
was interviewed near her residence in
West Palm each, Florida regarding a federal investigation
involving the sexual exploitation of minors. After being advised
of the iden the interviewing agents and the nature of the
interview, provided the following information:
believed she first began providing massages to
EPSTEIN at is residence in Palm Beach, Florida in June 2004. She
was sixteen years old and thought she would be providin• EPSTEIN
with a massage or possibly modeling lingerie for him.
first traveled to EPSTEIN's Palm Bea by Y
, with another female
TEIN touched
After the massage was over, P TEI s emp oyee, •escribed
as having darker d looking f , took the two girls back
to their homes. con once they were home and
wanted to call ice. as upset and did not
understand why would tae .er to EPSTEIN's residence if she
knew it involy
lingerie.
authorities.
more than prow ." a massage or modeling
discouraged from reporting EPSTEIN to the
believed she went to EPSTEIN's residence on at
least three occasions, all visits were made over approximately a
nth ti d. On the second visit she took a friend,
LNU. did not disrobe completely, '
, s e wen
visit, EPSTEIN instructed
He told her that she wa h
massage,
t e
On this
was told by EPSTEIN that she to tell
anyone whaillilliappened during the massages. began
avoid in tel phone calls from EPSTEIN and EPSTE s assistant,
•
stated that on each of th • ' s to EPSTEIN's
residence s.e a taken a Xanax. However, stated that she
Investigation On
File 0
by
10/30/2006 m West Palm Beach, Florida
Date dictated 10/30/2006
e Mug --`47ef o CO2- 40
This document contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the
FM. It is the property of the PSI and is loaned CO your agency;
it and its contents are not to be distributed cut:side your agency.
FD-302a (Ftcv. ID-6-95)
31E-MM-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of
•
,On  10/30/2006  ,Page  2
knows clearly what EPSTEIN did to her in regards to him touching
her inappropriately.
IIIIII. - - 08062
Pursuant to a federal investigation regarding the se tion of minors,
a victim, was interviewed by the FBI. identifying
orma on is recor e elow:
Name:
Race.
Sex:
DOB:
Home Address:
Telephone:
Cellular Telephone:
White
Female

• West mii,.•Florida 33415
\Sic - A.0.4 p re -
•
fol -/rA
PursuantPursuattt a federal investigation regarding the se ' tion of minors,
a victim, was interviewed by the FBI. identifying
i orma ion is recor e ow:
Name:
Race: White
Sex: Female
DOB:
Home Address:
es m eac , Florida 33415
Telephone:
Cellular Telephone:
31E-
xi/ v.
/
05'6
-4/
31E-MM-108062
Pursuant to a federal ding the
sexual exploitation of was
interviewed by the FBI. i en ying n ormation is
recorded below:
Name:
Race:
Sex:
DOB:
SSAN:
Address:
Cellular telephone:
Miscellaneous: a
The captioned identifying information is current to
date and replaces previously serialized insert #22.
3/6- Art-i-loroten2-4A,
•
31E-MM-108062
40 /1/247
Pursuant to a federal .nvesti ation re arding the
sexual exploitation of m' was
interviewed by the FBI. i en i ying in ormation is
recorded below:
Name:
Race:
Sex:
DOB:
SSAN:
Address:
Cellular telephone:
Miscellaneous:
Florida, 33470
udent at
The captioned identifying information is current to
date and replaces previously serialized insert #22.
Automated Serial Permanent Charge -Out
FD-5a (1-5-94)
Date: 02/06/07 Time: 14:34
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062 Serial: 63
Description of Document:
Type :
Date : 01/23/07
To
Prom :
Topic: EXECUTIVE FGJ SUBPOENA POR
Reason for Permanent Charge -Out:
transfer to the sub sbp
Transferred to:
Case ID: 318-MM-108062-SEP Serial: 3
Employee:
US DISR COURT
Automated Serial Permanent Charge -Out
FD-5a (1-5-94)
Date: 02/06/07 Time: 14:35
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062 Serial: 64
Description of Document:
Type : I.NLET
Date : 01 24 07
To
From :
Topic: FGa SUBPOENA FOR
Reason for Permanent Charge -Out:
transfer to sub sbp
Transferred to:
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serial: 4
Employee:
3/E-btm-fora4a-k,
• • Automated Serial Permanent Charge -Out
FD-5a (1-5-94)
Date: 02/06/07 Time: 14:36
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062 Serial: 65
Description of Document:
Type : OTHER
Date : 01 23 07
To
From : DIST COURT
Topic: EXECUTIVE FGJ SUBPOENA FOR
Reason for Permanent Charge -Out:
transfer to sbp sub
Transferred to:
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serial: 5
Employee:
31-e- MM -tonn-2-sie
Automated Serial Permanent Charge -Out
FD-5a (1-5-94)
Date: 02/06/07 Time: 14:37
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062 Serial: 66
Description of Document:
Type : INLET
Date : 01 24 07
To
From : US ATTORNEY
Topic: RE: FGJ SUBPOENA SERVED ON
Reason for Permanent Charge -Out:
transfer to sbp sub
Transferred to:
Case ID: 31E-MM-108062-SBP Serial: 6
Employee:
3/6- Nig- /0104a-64
rr-  -r
Y- • • 0ini.01-314003)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To: Miami
From: Albuquerque
Squad 13/ Santa Fe RA
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafte By:
ID : 31E-MM-108062 (Pending)
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
Date: 02/15/2007
Attn: PaliB girsi iara
SA
GHISLAt. WELL
WSTA-CHILD PROSTITUTION
-1,1
Synopsis: To report results of covered lead.
Enclosure(s): re the original and one copy of FD-302'
interview of and agent's original notes.
Details: An i was conducted on
02/08/2007 at an ey, New Mexico. Results
of the interview are contained in the enclosed FD-302.
Pending further direction from Miami, Santa Fe RA
considers this lead covered.
ale- -iore&2-47
FD-791 (Rev. 2-7-O0) itlassification
Draft Request

3. Request for: ( ) Advance (Expense
(AC) Criminate
FCI Case
(AD) Crirrinal OCDETF Case
F)
(BC) InforrnangCW

CF) Asset
(E) Growl
DC) Grow U UCO
(00) OCDETF Grow II (GC) Air Operaleo
(GA) BOG
(GB) OPS
(A
(H) SSG
(BD) InforrnanetW Provkling Drug Info. (r) FCI UCO   4.1) FCI Lookout

2. Date I .... I f I / I r.- /
4. Social Security No
5. Payee Name:
16. Cat Item No 7.
6. File No: I II i- I ‘1% 'I l i I J•
Description 8. Amount

9. Total $
10. Justification:
Asset/Informant Ale No. Symbol No.
Payment/Code Name Period Covered
One Time Non-symbol Source Payment:
True Name: DOB: / / SSAN:
Date of Waiver: / /
to

11. Payment for reimbursable expense - forfeiture or drug related? Yes  No
12. Requested by:
14. Approval
Supervisor Initials:
SAC/ ASAC / AO / SAS Approval.
Supply Technician Approval.
Draft Approval Officer:
Procurement Authorization:

13. Telephone NO: I I I
No.
15. Vendor No, Group , 17
18. Cost Center: 19. Squad/RA: 20.
I I I I { I I I
21 Document No.

23. Draft NO: 24. bi"tte
t
Date
OtgigatI0n No.
FO11OW-Up Date:
22. CONF COMM
I _I
25. Cashier
26. Settlement of Advance: Prior month Advance Balance: $ tr.
This Advance: $
$ f f. .2Less: Receipts:
Funds Returned and/ or Cash on Hand' $
. Amount to be ReirnbursedS
27. Document-Noll_ 11-  v j li t .4 I n) i)
29. Date: _)/..)// eA, 28. Draft No:
Shaded areas for draft office use only
Blue Copy - AdmitistratiVc/Creec File
Classification:
Classified By:
Declassify on:
/ rti te 2
DRAFT REQUEST FORM INSTRUCTIONS
REQUESTING EMPLOYEE - Complete blocks 1 to 13 as follows:
1 - Enter Budget Category Classification to which expenses will be charged.
2 - Current date.
3 - Cheek the box to indicate if this request is for an advance of funds or for payment of an expense,
4 - Your Social Security Account Number.
5 - The name of the person or company that should appear on the check.
6 - The substantive file number, or the file number of the case benefitted by a payment to an informant, asset or
cooperative witness. (If more than one case, see No. 10 below)
7 - Brief description of the type of expense to be paid.
8 - Amount requested for each type of expense.
9 - Total amount requested.
10 - Enter a brief justification for expense or advance requested. Indicate multiple cases benefitted by
asset/inforrnation/CW payment if applicable. For Field Office Use Only: A justification
electronic communication must be completed for informant/asset/CV,' expenses and placed in the applicable
informant/asset/CW file, maintained in the field office
II - Check the proper answer to indicate if the requested expense is reimbursable as asset forfeiture related or as a
payment for drug information.
12 - YOUT name.
13 - Your telephone number or extension.
.APPROVAL:
Id - Each request should be reviewed by the employee's direct supervisor, who should initial the form to
indicate review. Confidential expenses must be approved by signature of an ASAC or above. Expense/Advance
requests for the purchase of supplies or equipment must be approved by the Supply Technician prior to
payment Commercial expenses must be approved by signature of an AOSM or above prior to payment. The
Draft Approval Officer may approve commercial expenses under $50.00. Indicate the name of the FBIHQ
procurement officer and telephonic authorization number (T- number), if appropriate. All advances and
expenses must be approved by the Draft Approval Officer, who will complete the following parts of this form:
APPROVAL OFFICER:
15 - Vendor Number and Vendor Group Number.
16 - Classify the expense using Catalog Number (CAT) and Item Number.
17 - Obligation number if an advance is issued.
18 - Your cost center.
19 - SquacVRA code, if applicable.
20 - Follow-up date for advance liquidation.
DRAFT CASHIER:
21 - Document Number assigned to this transaction.
22 - Cheek if this transaction is confidential (CONF) or cormnoreial (COMM). .
23 • Draft Number.
24 - Date issued.
25 - Cater initials.
26 - Eater advance settlement information when receipts are presented and the matching expense
transaction is entered. If a supplemental draft is issued, complete blocks 27 to 30.
27 - Document Number issued to this transaction.
28 - Draft Number
29 - Date issued.
30 - Cashier initials.
••

1. Classification FD-194 (Rey. 24.00 ,
(Cqg granenal OCI;EIF CueHIAF FCI Cale
[IL lirrnstrU Ca Pr ONO into
0 ---
((DEC4)) aro:pi n UCO
r(
OCOETF GrouP ti
ar NO
" it
=
in; tin GO) Air Operation

PA) ttrloolopur
Draft Request 2. Date — i / 3 1 I I n 3  I r i G 7
3. Request for: Advance Ex ens 4. Social Security No:

5. Payee Name:
i  .
. File No: i ''' I LC ) Ty‘t ley\ i I III  Oi C., i.a l
16. Cat Item No 7. Description 8. Amount
01 1 - ` 31 (Ltc.r-l - sAi.,,, 1, ty- c oo÷ gss t y..7_s

9. Total $ I cr. aS .
10. Justification: ---?"e-Nle„, if,„ osti ft ci-:.. .€ • 4 - 0 e,_S StTa+
, ^1 A\O - C ri j k Ink-, \tin M \S
Asset/IntormaM File No. Symbol No.
Payment/Code Name • Period Covered to
One Time Non-symbol Source
True Name:
... Payment:
DOB: / / SSAN:
Date of Waiver: i /

n. Pa nent for reimbursabt expense - forfeiture or drug related? --/C No _Yes
cc Requested by: i I L__ 1 3. Telephone N

14. Approval Date
Supervisor Initials:
SAC tr.S.:Vet AO / SAS Approval' I 113407? Supply Technician Approval
Draft Approval Officer ii. 0 4
Procurement Authorization No.

18. Vendor Ne.i Av.) m 11 0 lSC416 101G41%u•PPIAIN
17 Obligation No. cl o g cs-,
18. Cost Centeno (g'il  cp111

19. Squad/RA, itr Zi 20. Follow.up Date: „0 - 0  i Q .,
Ma ,'
21 Document No. I ol MM ko 14- i o oi I Oil 23. Draft No: 24. Date I 9 ) (..67 25. Cash

26. Settlement of Advarefe: Prior month Advance Balance:
This Advance' $
Less:Receipts' $
Funds Returned and/ or Cash on Hands $
Atnount to be ReimburSed:$
27. Document N°'ill 1 :110Plirg . iii/ ri-4-1' r. .6 .)- i ' i 4 t i f
28. Draft No: 129. Date: .-:-.) /...-)/ h. 4 ._
3=1 Snarled areas for drall office use only
Classitication:
Classified By:
While Ozlg Ina] - Submiitod to Cnt.lident;s1
IKm.OI.3I.2003)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE Date: 01/25/2007
To: Miami Attn: Third Party Draft'
From: Miami
Squad PB-2
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafted By: Kuyrkendall E Nesbitt
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062 ' (Pending)
Title: EIN;
GEISLAINE N. ,WELL
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Synopsis: To request funds for expenses associated to the
above captioned case.
Enclosure(s): Enclosed for Miami Third Party Draft: Original
Sprint bill with associated FD-794 and Original Washington
Mutual bill with associated FD-794.
Details: SA requests Third Party Draft provide
payment in the amount o $205.00 to Sprint for Detail Call
Reports that provided pertinent information on individuals of
interest in the ongoing federal investigation. This expense
incurred due to the extensive record search requested by the
case agent. It should be noted that the Detail Call Reports
are not verbatim to l records. Prior authorization was
obtained from ASAC
SA requests Third Party Draft provide
payment in the amount o $18.25 to Washington Mutual for
administrative fees incurred while providing bank and credit
card records pertaining to individuals of interest in the
ongoing federal investigation.
Y
To: Miami From: Miami '
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 01/25/2007
LEAD(s):
Set Lead 1: (Info)
MIAMI
AT MIAMI
Third Party Draft shall issue and submit payment in
the amount of $205.00 to Sprint and $18.25 to Washington
Mutual to pay expenses associated with the captioned case.

• •
IPA Washington Mutual
08/182005 14332 N/A
U-
• 4 . Washington Mutual Bank
c/a Sub oena Compliance Rolneval
West Pairs Beach, FL 33401
12..)in.ni
IlabAt. •Int• II•not, t . Ike. in dl
11,..11.814
ni Pir• r:
Duncil 054988857
•a. ol lit hi • tic.......; e„.
an,
lay Oh Pli
\a......• ( pk. I
6096-9613
Ile:
Olt/31/2006 09673 No P 1 0.25 0.25 14332
08/312006 08674 NO H 1 11.00 11.00 14332
1 I ' 11.25
P t• • 0.00
tax-ID: 02.0115519
limn:et Whin; l: 11.25
Unpaid Total: 511.25
Ship cost: $7.00
Total Due: $18.25
"PAYMENT DUE UPON RECEIPT"
• ,
U.S. Department of Justice Request for Financial emotion (Authorisation,
Washington, D.C. 20530  Pgrcjase Order, Receivingtgportl
ITMS.F.D.RharCIST_RF Fitifin OILTSILLREZURal
Thu formskull wily ba wed wan. requests Roe odd words of budvidirals ice parteentisps Nave or fewer itedvideals.
I Purchase Order Number: 2 Date Order Prepared.
4 Name and Addleas or Financial trunnion:
il (diNin RONA &AL
5 Deltver To:
7 Reerarks:
Ple
S Woo A- MichGaudin' and Purchase Order
Dm
rni.-112mo-cizsis
6 Return Data:
Sect - Financial Institution Invoice
No Payment Shall Be Made Unless Expenses Are Itemized Below Or On Your Form To Be Attached.
Service/Financial Records Provided: Quantity Unit Price
Cost Pa Amount
I hereby certify that the services provided below were not performed relative D any corporation,
(checking, savings, share, loan, or credit card) of individual(s) or partnership(s) of five cr
joint ventures,
fewer partners.
etc., and pertain only to accounts
THE TAX IDENTIFICATION NUMBER FOR Turzom MUST BE INCLUDED HERE BEFOrE PAYtvIENT CAN BE
MADE. TAX IDENTIFICATION NUMBER:
SEARCH & PROCESSING
RP-PRODUCTION COST
MAIL COST
Section C - Receiving Report
14 1 certify that the ankle, and services listed were received: • IS Dam Received:
18 Right to Financial Privacy Act - Pubtie Law 95-610
(12 U.S.0 3401.3422) Request Pursuant To: (Check One Only)
SECTION
3404 Customer Authorization
OBJECT
CLASS
O 3405 Administrative Subpoena or Sunvnoru 2541
O 3406 Search Warne; 2542
0 3407 Judicial Subpoena 2543
O 3402 Formal Written Request 2544
O 3411 I Grand Jury Subpoena 2545
O 3414 Special Procedures 2546
22 Remarks
Total Amount Claimed
By Financial Institution
16 Disallowance
(See Attached)
I? Nei to
Financial
Institution
lEa5
19 Signature of Approving Official:
70 Accounting Classification Code
FY FC 2 PRO!
21 Schedule and Voucher Number
DC$
FORM 090-Ill • - —
UNITED STATES
POST4L Seintlee
KURTH*
RECEIPT FOR
YOUR RECORDS
1003t 4aq932
•
%IES1 PALM BEACH DONNTOWN STA
WEST PALM BEACH, Florida
1169180101 -0095
02/15/2007 (561)833-0929 09:49:09 AN
Sales Receipt
Product Sale Unit
Description Oty Price
Final
Price
Dom. Money Order
Domestic Money Order Fee
Sub 1.
Dom. Honey Order
Domestic Honey O.
Subtotal:
Total:
Paid by:
Cash
Change Due:
$205.00
$0.95
$205.95
$18.25
$0.95
$19.20 a=13.1==1111=1
$225.15
$225.25
-$0.10
61110: 1000501318041
Clerk: 19
All sales final on steeps end postage.
Refunds for guaranteed services only.
Thank you for your business.
Custoser Copy
CUSTOMER'S RECEIPT
e •
•
SEcEl.c.c...b.sRscstio
FoRlupoDocre.mu
ksonta.,
Mar NEGOTIABLE
C UNITEDSTATES POSTALSERIACEe

• •
CUSTOMER'S RECEIPT
WESI PALM BEACH 0010170MM STA
HEST PALM BEACH, Florida
1169180101 -0095
02/15/2007 (561)833-0929 09:49;08 AM
Product
Description
Sales Receipt
Sale Unit Qty
Final
Price
Dom. Honey Orderin.
Donestic Money 0
Sub
Dom. Money Order
Domestic Money 0
Subtotal.:
Total:
Paid by:
Cash
Change Due:
61110: 1000501318041
Clerk: 19
$205.00
$0.95
$$18.25
$0.95
$19.20
$225.15
$225.25
-$0.10
All sates final on stamps and postago.
Refunds for guaranteed services only.
Thank you for your business.
rostmar Loov
•
PIM% daihClassification (lta. 2-740)
g g;;;;Inna.:17:EgrF Case (AF) FCI Case
i (BC)
Int`fr:ricwprovIcling Drug Inks. 9 am
rial
iSt'l Ir t I
UCO
1 1 ?°113141F10 Group ii
.
go
MI"

GA) SOO
GB) OPS
MGO1 AirECI°LookPeraoultic°
Draft Request 2 / .. _ /
3. Request for: ( ) Advance ( expense 4. Social Security No:

5. Payee Name: 6. File No: I.. i I IL- i  I"! • " 1 1 . 1 I . I. I
16. Cat Item No 7. Description 8. Amount
02 *
05 4....,.. .,
0?

9. Total S
10. Justification:
Asset/Informant File No. Symbol No.
Payment/Code Name Period Covered to
One Time Non-symbol Source Payment:
True Name: DOB: / / SSAN:
Date of Waiver: / /

11. Payment for reimbursable expense - forfeiture or drug related? Yes .N No
12. Requested by: ( ' Co t, 13. Telephone No:

14. Date
Supervisor Initials: -,
SAC /ASAC'/ AO / SAS Approval: O / 7
Supply Technician Approval.
Draft Approval Officer:
Procurement Authorization: No

16. Vendor No. . • . .... • Group , ,
. - . .I • 1 ) •I ' ll'' I  e-N 'i 7 ( I No. I . III; Obligation No:.
J  • .:

18. Cost Center:
I I . I 1. 1
18. Siiti)iVRA:
I l l ,
20. Follow-up Date:
' I I I I I I
21 Document No.
A . - t r / • / • i i I I I„I \ J 22. poNF comm
23: Omit NO; •
1'-!
24...pata: 25. casitier)

28. SetdementotAdvande: Priormonth Advance Balance: S 11
This Advance. $ ' Y' ' z- /1/16
' 77. -Less: Receipts:. -8: 1 qq CA • - • . v •
Fundifiteturried.and/ or Cash on Hand: C r  £ . .. ArriouM to be Reimbureedi •
21' °G;timent14911-•11"---i)( Pl/ ii: i., i 'li04 l I  0(:) -4:1? I l i:E s/O
.' . . ....
28 ii ...:,..4...-Ji..5... Y. •;(.'io."A",' ' ''
1 -.. - • •
Sr. V:e• • IX  .
t, Shaded areas for draft office use only
Classification:
Classified By:
Blue Copy - Administrative/Case File Declassify on:
3 / -1 ni 41 -(a ro 6,02 -et
DRAFT REQUEST FORM INSTRUCTIONS
REQUESTING EMPLOYEE - Complete blocks 1 to 13 as follows:
1 Enter Budget Category Classification to which expenses will be charged.
2 - Current date.
3 - Check the box to indicate if this request is for an advance of funds or for payment of an expense.
4 - Your Social Security Account Number.
5 - The name of the person or company that should appear on the check
6 - The substantive file number, or the file number of the case benefitted by a payment to an informant, asset or
cooperative witness. (If more than ate case, see No. 10 below)
7 - Brief description of the type of expense to be paid.
8 - Amount requested for each type of expense.
9 - Total amount requested.
10 - Enka- a brief justification for expense or advance requested. Indicate multiple cases benefited by
assettinformation/CW payment if applicable. For Field Office Use Only: A justification
electronic communication must be completed for inforreantlas.set/CW expenses and placed in the applicable
informant/asseUCW file, maintained in the field office,
11 - Check the proper answer to indicate if the requested expense is reimbursable as wet forfeiture related or as a
payment for drug information.
12 - Your name.
13 - Your telephone number or extension.
APPROVAL:
14 - Each request should be reviewed by the employee's direct supervisor, who should initial the form to
indicate review. Confidential expenses must be approved by signature of an ASAC or above. Expense/Advance
requests for the purchase of supplies or equipment must be approved by the Supply Technician prior to
payment. Commercial expenses must be approved by signature of an AOSM or above prior to payment The
Draft Approval Officer may approve commercial expenses under $50.00. Indicate the name of the FBIHQ
procurement officer and telephonic authorization number (T- number), if appropriate. All advances and
expenses must be approved by the Draft Approval Officer, who will complete the following parts of this form:
APPROVAL OFFICER:
15 - Vendor Number and Vendor Group Number.
16 - Clas.sify the expense using Catalog Number (CAD and Item Number.
17 - Obligation number if an advance is issued.
18 - Your cost center.
19 - Squad/RA code, if applicable.
20 - Follow-up date for advance liquidation
DRAFT CASHIER:
21 - Document Number assigned to this transaction.
22 - Check if this transaction is confidential (CONF) or commercial (COMA).
23 - Draft Number.
24 - Date issued.
25 - Cashier initiaLs. •
26 - Enter advance settlement information when receipts are presented and the matching expense
transaction is entered. If a supplemental draft is issued, complete blocks 27 to 30.
27 - Document Number issued to this transaction.
28 - Draft Number.
29 - Date issued.
30 - Cashier initials.
-
• 1. Classification 3 ( a n FD-794 (by. 2-7-00)
- -1,AC)1
=
—C
.4:
Criminal (.. se

(AD) Criminal OCDETF Case (Al r,,Casevcw188) ling:LON Providing Drug Into.
MI
— =
kr
(20FC altipel II UCO III (DD) OCDETF Group II aIN Group II
-
S'i'31 82 Air Operation

(H) P2?Lookout s Dratt Request 2. Dale i cti l ,a, 'II /I6 7 3. Request tor: ( ) Advance ( --Trxpense 4. Social Security
No:

5. Payee Name: 6. File No: I oicia. . Iii le l— 1rni nil 1 i u icci
16. Cal Item No 7. Description 8. Amount
01 - 25W 01 Se f .A.+ +4 3 0 1/4 4 tc.s.;4-1%.„ -C6 . z<.•-• i - Z -..,5 2.05 , 01.)
02 ( c‘c..Nvt•rt -,..\.-).. )f-c. 11 V e C e• I a C.) i

9. Total $ 2pc 0-c.)
10. Justiticationt• Tot\ \record % Ni-o 4.4 J ,\e..., e‘v &A N i I can valt i sdo
c%ss‘c2c w CO-S-Q_ \Porf..s.1 s1/45R-ticIts. :-.
y
Asset/Inhprmant File No. Symbol No.
PaymonaCode Name Period Covered to
One Time Non-symbol Source Payment:
True Name: DOB: / / SSAN.
Date of Waiver: / /

11. Payment for reimbursable expense - forleiture or drug related? Yes Y No
12. Requested by: 13. Telephone No:

14.  Approval Date
...._
Supervisor Initials:
If SAC AO / SAS Approval: 4 ,
upply Technician Approval•
Draft Approval Officer: / /3(3/ 4 Procurement Authorization: No.

15. Vendor Nol, aity4 1 in Ite " r rg ( WI DI LlitOir40.Pittil
17 Obligation No 0  4 ‘, cc, D
18. Cost •
Center. i '34 19 Squad/RA:i VA 2 , 20. Follow-up De5xls < C-T -g_
21 Document No. 1 Aiki f r ik I TO C5L3 I l l Ma -

23. Draft No:(4 L_ c t
24. Date 1 al r.\ . -..) -- ki
25. Cashier
20. Settlement of Advance: Prior Advance Balance: $ month
This Advance' $ ST" • er)
Less: Receipts' $ -01.
Funds Returned and/ or Cash on Hand' $
Amount to be Heirnburted'S
27. Document No.cc i c i ?(i‘2 aittc, i tt
. .
•,---- i. . i :9-,4 5 , ,. , k t
28, Draft No: 29. Date: c /`
Shaded areas for draft office use only
Classification:
Classified By:
\Witt ,  oriulnui - garnitted In Confidential Services Unit by Drab office Dec'assitv on:
(Rev. 0(•31.3003)
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Precedence: ROUTINE
To: Miami
From: Miami
Squad PB-2
Contact: SA
Approved By:
Drafted By:
Case ID #: 31E-MM-108062 "Se lPending)
Title: JEFFREY EPSTEIN;
WELL
WSTA - CHILD PROSTITUTION
Date: 01/25/2007
Attn: Third Party Draft
Synopsis: To request funds for expenses associated to the
above captioned case.
Enclosure(s) : Enclosed for Miami Third Party Draft: Original
Sprint bill with associated FD-794 and Original Washington
Mutual bill with associated FD-794.
Details: SA requests Third Party Draft provide
payment in the amount of $205.00 to Sprint for Detail Call
Reports that provided pertinent information on individuals of
interest in the ongoing federal investigation. This expense
incurred due to the extensive record search requested by the
case agent. It should be noted that the Detail Call Reports
are not verbatim to . for authorization was
obtained from ASAC
SA requests Third Party Draft provide
payment in the amount o $18.25 to Washington Mutual for
administrative fees incurred while providing bank and credit
card records pertaining to individuals of interest in the
ongoing federal investigation.
To: Miami From: Miami
Re: 31E-MM-108062, 01/25/2007
LEAD(a):
Set Lead 1: (Info)
MIAMI
AT MIAMI
Third Party Draft shall issue and submit payment in
the amount of $205.00 to Sprint and $18.25 to Washington
Mutual to pay expenses associated with the captioned case.

• •
r
Sprint
Subpoena Compliance
Federal Bureau of Investigation
to
West Palm Beach FL 33401
• • Invoice; 2111601470
Bill Date: 11114)2006
Payment Due Date: 11129/2006
CBO: CORP
Reference
Sprint Case; 2006.149246
PLEASE MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO:
Sprht
PO Box 219061
Kansas City, MO 64121.9061
Tax ID #
Page 1 of t
Description Fiat Fee Unit Rate Units UOM Total
Bill Repriat 56161534M
Cad Delhi Report
Call Detail Report
$1500
320.00
523.00 315.00 10
lour
Itorr
Total Amount Due:
To insure proper credit• please write the invoice number on your check.
Please detach and RETURN BOTTOM PORTION with payment . . . - • '
315.00
320.00
$170.00
$205.00
Sprint.>
InvNa # 2111601470
Bill Data: 11/1412006
Reference I
Sprint
i rises City, MO 64121-9061
Amount Due
$205.00
Federal Bureau of Investigation
Attn
West Palm Beach FL 33401

• Amount Remitted
2-0 5. d'.
WEST PALM BEACH DOWHIOUN STA
VEST PALK3340 15
BEACH, florida
1 180101 -0095
02/15/2007
09:59,08 AM
Product
Description
Doe. Hone*, Orderipil.
Domestic Money 0
Sub 1
Dom. Money Order
Dosestic Honey 0 Subtotal:
Sales Receipt
Sale Unit
Oty Price
Total:
Paid by:
Cash
Change Duel
Final
Price
$205.00
$0.95
$205.95
$19.25
$0.95
$19.20
$225.15
$225.25
-$0.10
5.1114: 1000501318041
Clerk: 19
All sales final on steeps and postage.
Refunds for guaranteed services only.
Thank you for your business.
Custorer COPY
MNITERSTATES
Porrat. sank -E CUSTOMER'S RECEIPT
Merlin
RICawTFOR
YOUR SWORDS
a
" t • L O C 4 L 1t
MANIAC
f.00 14t
I :" 1.1  ) • ink:Tv„ )1 .  7,44;"(C
C1i/4
(.1
Sas Sacs o: Das Caen
lea luponroxr COCA
bC0PILOCI.
NEGOTIABLE
10 0 94331;412141 4.r..  Irs' • $3 irk; 611:1
•
a UNITED STATES
ponaLSERVICE•
b
UNITEC)STATES
1SisT44gTvrE0.
. ww.igar.;
TM 3629
O NO oft
0.07
•
CUSTOMER'S RECEIPT
iremoeT
-1-12 ; NOT •
1/24,79.-7:-)121
r „),. 1, NEGOTIABLIf
_1141COW .4,,fwo
POSTAL MONEY ORDER • .
oTroi-AT. r
• • 4,5,411;:t:
WEST PAIN BEACH DOWNT04Ai S7A
'WEST PALM BEACH, Florida
• 334015306
MS"
Sales Receipt
Product Sale Unit
Description Oty Price
Dom. Money Ordoippl
Caustic Money
$205.00
$0.95
Sub $205.95
Dom. Money Order $18.25
Domestic Money 0 e $0.95
t Subtotal: $19.20
Total: $225.15
Paid by:
Cash $225.25
Change Due: -$0.10
02/15/2007 09:49:08 All
Final
Price
8111N: 1000501318041
Clerk: 19
All sales Final on stamps and posta9o.
Refunds for guaranteed services only.
Thank you for your business.
Custonor Copy
.9?4,49,..trgpIT6 . .
82214#11 ,f 7 " at
4444. /4
poicAte
ia
FD-302 (Rev. 10-6-95) •
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
nftormmthow 02/13/2007
date of birth Social
Security Acco tntu r of
Stanley, New Mexico wasinterviewed at t e gues ouse o ORRO
RANCH, Stanley, New Mexico. After being advised of the identity of
the interviewing agents, and the nature of the interview,
provided the following information:
managing
Piknd his wife,  have been
RANCH for JEFFREY IN or approximately 4
a
years. There are 5 to 6 full-time staff at the ranch as well as
some seasonal employees. EPSTEIN spends approximately fifty(50)
days a year at the ranch during his down time, mostly in the
summer. In the summer, EPSTEIN generally spends 2 to 3 weeks at a
time at the ranch and is shuttled around by helicopter. The last
time EPSTEIN was at the ranch was Thanksgiving 2006. EPSTEIN
normally flies into either Albuquerque or Santa Fe and is driven to
the ranch. Very little notice is given before EPSTEIN flies to the
ranch, usuall 24 to 48 hours. EPSTEIN usually brings his personal
assistant, his bodyguard, friends, personal trainer,
and sometimes is masseuses.
The masseuses iiiiirt normally flown to the ranch, but
are hired by and . keeps the financial records
and usually arranges the massages. The names of the masseuses are
obtained from TEN THOUSAND WAVES DAY SPA or by referrals.
said that the masseuses are all checked out and that they are
professionals who are licensed massage therapists. There have been
approximately 5 different therapists used in the past.
said pill could provide the names of the
therapists use , and t e amounts paid to them, but that we needed
to go to the office to meet with her. Upon arriving at the office
and greeting III. received a phone call from the "main
office" that told him t ey were no longer allowed to speak with us.
The interview was immediately ended.
Investigation on 02/08/2007 at Stanley, New Mexico
Hiatt 31E-MM-108062 - Date dictated 02/13/2007
by SA

It is the roomy of the FBI and is loaned to your agency;
31e-  MM-io?e,t/callo
P FD-302a (Rev. 10.6-95)
31E -FY-108062
Continuation of FD-302 of
•
m:102/08/2007  .page  2
A records check of provided the following
information:
Race: White
Sex: maFemale
Date of birth:
Social Security Number:
"=1=• •••
.4 FD-302 (Rev. 10-6-95)
0. •
-1-
• a qOa 137
FEDERAL BUREAU OF INVESTIGATION
Date of traracripdon 02/13/2007
date of birth So ial
Securitvsccount 1.-r
,Stanley, New Mexico  was interviewee at t e gues souse o ORRO
RANCH, Stanley, New Mexico. After being advised of the iden
the interviewing agents, and the nature of the interview,
provided the following information:
and his wife, have been
managing t RANCH for oximately 4
_years. There are 5 to 6 full-time staff at the.ranch as well as
some seasonal employees. EPSTEIN spends approximately fifty(50)
days a year at the ranch during his down time, mostly in the
summer. In the summer, EPSTEIN generally spends 2 to 3 weeks at a
time at the ranch and is shuttled around by helicopter. The last
time EPSTEIN was at the ranch was Thanksgiving 2006. EPSTEIN
normally flies into either Albuquerque or Santa Fe and is driven to
the ranch. Very little notice is given before EPSTEIN flies to the
ranch, usuall 24 to 48 hours. EPSTEIN usually brings his personal
assistant, his bodyguard, friends, personal trainer,
and sometimes is masseuses.
of
The masseuses are not normally flown to the ranch, but
are hired by and M. Ilikkeeps the financial records
and usually arranges the massages. e names of the masseuses are
obtained from TEN THOUSAND WAVES DAY SPA or by referrals.
said that the masseuses are all checked out and that they are
professionals who are licensed massage therapists. There have been
approximately 5 different therapists used in the past.
said ill could provide the names of the
therapists use , and t e amounts paid to them, but that we needed
to go to the office to meet with her. Upon arriving at the office
and greeting III. received a phone call from the "main
office" that 11111Lim t ey were no longer allowed to speak with us.
The interview was immediately ended.
Mviesdigallionim  02/08/2007  at  Stanley, New Mexico
Fik# 31E-MM-108062 - Date dictated 02/13/2007
A
by  SA
This docunstit contains neither recommendations nor conclusions of the FBI. It is the property of the FBI and is loaned 
to your agency;
It and its contains are not to be distributed outside your agency.
31 (.73 - -R4 /4- /orot ) -70 •
FD-Ma(ltn00.5.95)
318-MM-108062
Coldnuadonan)-302d
I
,On  02/08/2007  ,Page  2
M illIMIS A records check of provided the following
information:
Race:
_Sex:
Date girth:
Social Security Number:
White
EFTA00803491 (Jmail)
 [crypto] Honeycomb Asset Management deck
(inferred date: 2026-01-26)
I
ik/ C r VO4IP•Ves 'WPM 40 Ati\W _dile - ' 41  1.•-•
veZek\ bk. Nitmkra„i
NV-2i\ "e7ixICA. 4.••
Ns\vs,wrortrtleV•46.0.7.:fra,Afingi . v ir
Nett\ vivezoL Nuts- -054
-44e-  fr74;77APAW_
erir-47 411$ P tit " -as !ale its,--amiliyt pp--, ;:aterett,S("ftSts. ' 011:1,las
p NTittn 44\\
Pr.-data:Mt\ February 28, 2O19 /jet o
►r  nit

╭── Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ Confidential        │
│                     │
│ O HONEYCOMB         │
│                     │
│ ASSET MANAGEMENT LP │
│                     │
│ February 28, 2019   │
╰─────────────────────╯

Important Legal Considerations
his document is conficential. is intended only for the person to whom it has been provided and under no
circumstance may a copy be shown, copied, transmitted, or otherwise given to any person other than the authorized
recipient without the prior written consent of Honeycomb Asset Management LP (the "Investment Manager").
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary herein, each recipient of this document may disclose to any and all persons.
without limitation of any kind. the tax treatment and tax structure of: (i) Honeycomb Master Fund LP (the "Master
Fund"). Honeycomb Intermediate Fund LP (the "Intermediate Fund"), Honeycomb Offshore Fund Ltd. (the "Offshore
Fund"). Honeycomb Partners LP. (the "U.S. Partnership", and collectively, the "Funds") and (ii) any of their
transactions. and all materials of any kind (including opinions or other tax analyses) relating to such tax treatment 
and
tax structure, it being understood that "tax treatment" and "tax structure" do not include the name or identifying
information of a Fund or a transaction.
Please note that Honeycomb Master Fund LP includes all or substantially all investible assets from its feeder funds,
Honeycomb Partners LP, Honeycomb Intermediate Fund LP and Honeycomb Offshore Fund Ltd. However. investors
are expected to invest at the feeder fund not at the master fund level. The reflected returns provided herein assume a
representative investor invested in the U.S. Partnership in each of (i) the Class A interests that are subject to a
management fee of 2% and incentive allocation of 2O% per annum and (ii) the Class B interests that are subject to a
management fee of 1.5% and an incentive allocation of 2O% per annum. "Net Return" reflects the performance of the
U.S. Partnership net of management fee. U.S. Partnership expenses and incentive allocation. "Gross Return" reflects
the performance of the U.S. Partnership net of management fee and U.S. Partnership expenses. but gross of incentive
allocation. The management fee and U.S. Partnership expense figures used for performance calculations are pro-
rated for the performance period. and incentive allocation calculations reflect an investment in the U.S. Partnership
since its July 1, 2O16 institutional launch date. The reflected returns assume participation by the Class A and B
representative investor in the U.S. Partnership's "new issue" investments and the reinvestment of dividends and other
earnings. Individual results will vary (potentially considerably) depending on. among other things, investing at the
feeder fund rather than the U.S. Partnership level, new issue eligibility, the timing of subscriptions and redemptions,
different fee arrangements and any accumulated loss carry-forwards. This performance information is estimated and
the Investment Manager makes no representations as to the accuracy or completeness thereof, and such information
should not be relied upon as the basis of an investment. The performance information provided herein is based on
unaudited information as of the date hereof and is subject to change as actual performance for the relevant period is
finalized.
The distribution of the information contained herein may be restricted in certain jurisdictions: accordingly. it is the
responsibility of any prospective investor to satisfy itself as to compliance with relevant laws and regulations. The
recipient and its professional advisors. by accepting delivery of this document. agree to keep confidential all matters
herein and to return this document promptly upon the request of the Investment Manager.
The information contained herein is preliminary and is provided for discussion purposes only. This information is only a
summary of key information; it is not complete and does not contain certain material information about the Funds.
including important conflicts of interest and risk factor disclosures associated with an investment in the Funds. The
information contained herein is as of the date hereof and is subject to change without notice.
This document has been supplied for discussion purposes only. and therefore no representation or warranty is
made, whether expressed or implied. by the Funds or the Investment Manager or any of their partners. employees,
members. or agents as to the accuracy or completeness of the information provided herein. The information
contained herein should not be relied upon in making any investment decisions. This document may be amended at
any t. There is no express or implied obligation to update you of any changes to the information set forth herein.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
Confidential
This document is not intended to be. nor should it be construed or used as an offer to sell, or a solicitation of any 
offer
to buy, interests or shares in the Funds. No offer or solicitation may be made prior to the delivery of a definitive
offering memorandum (the "Memorandum") which will contain additional information about the Funds, including
disclosures relating to risk factors and conflicts of interest. The information contained herein does not take into
account the particular investment objectives or financial circumstances of any specific person who may receive it and
is qualified in its entirety by the Memorandum. In the event of any discrepancies between the information contained
herein and the Memorandum. the Memorandum will control. The information herein is not intended to provide, and
should not be relied upon for. accounting, legal or tax advice or investment recommendations. Each recipient of this
document should make an independent investigation as to all matters concerning an investment in the Funds or
otherwise described herein. including consulting with its own tax. legal, accounting or other advisors about such
matters. In making an investment decision, investors must rely upon their own examination of the Funds and I the
terms of the offering. including the merits and risks involved.
An investment in the Funds may not be suitable for all investors. An investment in the Funds will be suitable only for
certain financially sophisticated investors who meet certain eligibility requirements, have no need for immediate
liquidity in their investment, and can bear the risk of an investment in the Funds for an extended period of time.
Investing in financial markets involves a substantial degree of risk. There can be no assurance that the investment
objectives or target returns described herein will be achieved. Investment losses may occur. and investors could lose
some or all of their investment. No guarantee or representation is made that the Funds' investment program.
including, without limitation. its investment objectives, diversification strategies. or risk monitoring goals. will be
successful. and investment results may vary substantially over time. Nothing herein is intended to imply that the
Funds' investment methodology may be considered "conservative". "safe". "risk free" or "risk averse". Economic.
market and other conditions could also cause the Funds to alter their investment objectives, guidelines and
restrictions.
Certain information contained in this document constitutes "forward -looking statements", which can be identified by
the use of forward -looking terminology such as "may", "will", "should". "expect". -anticipate". "target", "project".
"estimate". "intend". "continue" or "believe" or the negatives thereof or other variations thereon or comparable
terminology. Due to various risks and uncertainties, actual events or results or the actual performance of the Funds
may differ materially from those reflected or contemplated in such forward -looking statements.
The estimates. investment strategies. and views expressed in this document are based upon past or current
market conditions and/or data and information provided by unaffiliated third parties (which has not been
independently verified) and is subject to change without notice. In addition. many of the responses herein are
subjective and/or reflect the Investment Manager's best estimates or forecasts on future events. Such statements
should not be understood to be predictions or guarantees of any particular outcome.
Past performance and target returns are not indicative nor a guarantee of future returns. Any returns are presented
net of all fees and expenses and include the reinvestment of all dividends. interest. income and profits.
Honeycomb Offshore Fund Ltd. has not been approved for distribution in or from Switzerland by the Swiss Financial
Market Supervisory Authority. As a result. the Offshore Fund's shares may only be offered or distributed to qualified
investors within the meaning of Swiss law. The Representative of the Offshore Fund in Switzerland is Bastions
Partners Office SA with registered office at Route de Chene 61A.12O8 Geneva, Switzerland. The Paying Agent in
Switzerland is Banque Heritage SA. with registered office at Route de Chene 61.12O8 Geneva. Switzerland. The place
of performance and jurisdiction for shares of the Offshore Fund distributed in or from Switzerland are at the
registered office of the Representative.
2
Confidential
We Invest in the Future
and
Short the Past
Honeycomb: Our
Origin Story

• The honeycomb is one of nature's
best examples of a scalable and
repeatable process driven by a
common purpose - this serves as
the inspiration to our business.

• Strong culture founded upon
creativity, intellectual honesty,
goodwi ll and compl iance.
• We look for secular growth
opportunities as the foundation
of our portfol io.

• A symbiotic relationship between
our team and our capital partners
is critical to our success.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
Confidential
4
Honeycomb:
Growth, Creativity
and Scalability
Honeycomb seeks innovation, new total addressable
markets, transformational stories led by exceptional
leaders, growing markets and businesses in
transition.
We seek to generate alpha through a flexible long/short
strategy that invests in opportunities that are driving and
disrupting the future, while shorting opportunities that
are not keeping pace with innovation.

• HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LA
o yco
sterpie •
,engfrie
abSolut
in econorni
labc4 and rn
ring
y.
b is
e of
that i
erfec
ng
eri
- Charles Darwin
Is.
Confidential
Executive Summary
Strategy

• Long/short equity fund targeting
mid -teens returns
• Focus on growth investments balanced with value
positions with attractive risk/reward

• Optional private co-investment opportunities
Philosophy
• Invest in the future, short the past
• Creative idea generation with flexible mindset

• Scalable and repeatable research process
• Concentrated, high -conviction ideas
• Tactical risk management

• Fundamental price target discipline
Aligned Interests
• David Fiszel is the second-largest investor in the Fund

• Firm assets $7OO+mm
'Target returns are provided as general guidance only and there can be no guarantee that such returns will be achieved 
or that an investment
in the fund will be profitable.
(1) HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
Leadership

• Led by David Fiszel, former Senior Portfolio
Manager at Point72 — one of the longest -
tenured PMs with one of the largest, most
successful public/private portfolios.

• Partner at Omega
• 2O+ years experience
Risk Management
• Stay disciplined: seek to cut losses and let
winners run

• When the fact pattern changes, stay
intellectually honest
• Dynamic gross exposure used as an offensive
and defensive tool
Established Capital Partnership

• July 2O16 institutional launch with high
qual ity and diverse partners
• Honeycomb's capital partners span the globe
and include sovereign wealth funds and
endowments
6
Stable core, with commitment to
constant learning
Skills honed during both bul l and bear
markets. Honeycomb seeks to attract
the best and brightest.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
Mental flexibility,
intellectual honesty
Develop a key thesis and look out for
changes. We look beyond our sector
focus for inspiration. We are constantly
challenging ourselves and our theses.
Holistic approach to public
market investments
We think far beyond the next earnings
cycle. Our goal is to achieve a holistic
view and seek alpha over the near,
medium and long term.
7
Confidential
David J. Fiszel:
Career Overview
SAC Capital Rhombus SAC/Point72 Asset Management
Omega Advisors Advisors Capital Portfolio Manager Added exposure to Honeycomb
Partner, Financial Analyst Portfolio Manager Founder, CIO Publ ic Investments Venture Capital Founder, CIO
(1996-2000) (2000-2004) (2004-2007) (2008-2015) (2011-2015) (July 2016 launch)
I I I 1 I
2000 1 2001 I 2002 I 2003 I 2004 I 2005 I 2006 I 2007 I 2008 I 2009 I 2010 I 2011 I 2012 I 2013 I 2014 I 2015 I 2016 I 
2017 I 2018

• Youngest Partner • Managed $150mm
• Head of Media & Telecom Gross Market Value
portfolio
• $200mm AUM

• No down years
• Institutional
Investor's 20 Rising
Stars of Hedge
Funds of 2007
• Rejoined SAC
to run $400mm
portfolio,
which he grew
to $1.6B

• Private investments,
including in Palantir,
Facebook and
Twitter
' Past performance is not indicative of future results. The portfolios of the Honeycomb funds differ from the portfolios
of vehicles previously managed by Mr.
Fiszel, including, without limitation, with respect to the use of
leverage and the scope of permitted investment activity.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 8
Confidential
A Hive of Ideation,
Thought Leadership
Collaborative, results -oriented organizational structure
David J. Fiszel
Investment Team
Founder &
Chief Investment Officer Business Team
S S S Joyce Jen Josh Resnick Vick Sandhu Dominique Ahumada
Investment Head of Chief Operating Head of Capital
Partner & Trading & Risk Officer, General Partnerships & Talent
Head of Research Management Counsel & Chief
S Andrew Ruben Allan Yang Nan Li
Investment Investment China
Analyst Analyst Research
Associate
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
Compliance Officer
S
Ken Chan
Chief Financial Officer

• Dana Shakked
Control ler
• Dana Procope
Office Manager &
Executive
Assistant
9
Confidential
Investment Framework
Employ our established and
repeatable fundamental process in
an effort to generate alpha
Identify the key fulcrum points that
impact future value
Leverage private company
research to inform public market
decision making
Calculate the risk/reward investment profile

• Use precision analysis underpinned by
fundamental approach
Flexible investment "playbooks"
• Experience across different market
environments
Maintain active and disciplined risk
management at portfolio and position -level
' This is a high-level overview of a complex process. In actual trading and investment decision -making, steps may be 
reordered, substituted, modified or
omitted. There can be no guarantee that Honeycomb's investment
framework will be successful.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 10
Confidential
Portfolio Construction
Guidelines
Number Of Positions Longs: generally 25 to 35
Shorts: generally 25 to 35
Utilize customized basket, equity option and ETF hedges when appropriate
Concentration Targets Top 1O long positions: typically 6O% to 8O% of capital
Top 1O short positions: typical ly 3O% to 5O% of capital
Representative Gross Expected range of 15O% to 275%
Exposure
Representative Net Flexible, and generally, 3O% to 6O% in normalized market environments
Exposure
Market Cap Portfolio will be primarily mid, large and mega cap stocks
Geographic Focus
Sector Focus
Global
TMT and Consumer with a portion of the portfolio focusing on generalist positions
The general guidelines above are based on current portfolio projections and are subject to change without notice. These 
guidelines are not firm limits and are
presented for informational purposes only and should not be
relied upon. Honeycomb's funds are not subject to formal concentration or exposure limits.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 11
Confidential
Investment Process
Scalable, repeatable, organic and collaborative

• Ongoing mining of sector coverage
and new companies
• Analyze opportunistic events
(earnings, mergers, spin-offs,
restructurings, etc.)
Research and
Due Diligence

• Proactively review theses
• Identify potential catalytic events
• Seek to hedge unwanted risks (market,
industry, currency, factor, etc.) and monitor
correlation metrics
2
Idea
Generation
\./

• Assess business and industry
fundamentals using data -
driven and qualitative tactics
• 300+ interconnected models
provide depth of analysis
with room for bespoke inputs
Ongoing Analysis
of Portfolio
Construction
4
Structured
Interaction

• Gain real-time perspective of
target potential risk/reward
• Seek to rotate capital into
the highest and best use at
all times

• Engage in active dialogue
• Daily portfolio review: current
positions, sizing, new ideas
• Weekly = meetings: discuss
emerging themes and high-
level trends
Toolkit: Real-time
Dashboard of
Investable Universe
' This is a high-level overview of a complex process. In actual trading and investment decision -making, steps may be 
reordered, substituted, modified or
omitted. There can be no guarantee that Honeycomb's investment
process will be successful.
I."---..---
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 12
Price Target and
Risk/Reward Discipline
When do we initiate a position?

• Risk/reward target should be better than 2:1
• Attractive price target/expected return
• High conviction level

• Key investment criteria are met
• Detailed diligence checklist is complete
Why would we change position sizing?

• New information changes our view
• Price target or risk/reward changes
• Better risk/reward in other names (better use of capital)

• Portfolio re-balancing/risk management
• Conviction level changes
' This is a high-level overview of a complex process. In actual trading and investment decision -making, steps
may be substituted, modified or omitted. There can be no guarantee that Honeycomb's investment process will
be successful.
"------.''' HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
Confidential
Risk Management Core to Honeycomb
Focused on booking = on both winners and losers
Position
Risk/Reward
Portfolio
Level Review
Nimble
Gross Exposure
Tactical
Risk Management

• Reassess long/short ideas • Portfolio level 5% • During drawdowns • Opportunistically trade
at 1O% peak to trough drawdown generally use gross exposure around core positions

• Reevaluate trading/ triggers mandatory management as a based on fundamental
opportunistic situations portfolio review tool to lessen risk by price targets to seek
at material catalyst • No single sub sector cutting long and alpha generation during
expected to represent short exposures market dislocations and
more than 5O% of portfolio
(measured at cost)
• Use daily profit and loss
as a tool for monitoring
volatility
non -fundamental volatility
• Seek to play offense
and use dry powder
opportunistically
' The risk management techniques above are general guidelines and may not be used in all instances or be effective.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 14
Confidential
Historical Performance of Long/Short Book
Class A - 2/20 (%)
(as of February 28. 2019)
Gross
Jan
4.9
Feb
5.8
Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec YTD
10.9%
ITD
55.2%
2019
Net 3.9 4.6 8.7% 42.9%
Gross 8.7 (4.0) (1.8) 4.3 2.4 1.7 1.5 1.5 1.3 (7.0) 2.6 (3.9) 6.5%
2018
Net 7.0 (3.3) (1.4) 3.4 2.0 1.4 1.2 1.2 1.1 (5.8) 2.1 (3.1) 5.2%
Gross 10.1 (1.7) 3.2 4.8 (1.7) 0.2 6.0 1.6 (1.2) 5.5 (4.0) 1.6 26.2%
2017
Net 8.1 (1.4) 2.6 4.0 (1.4) 0.2 4.9 1.3 (1.0) 4.6 (3.4) 1.3 21.0%
Gross 0.5 6.2 3.3 (0.5) (5.1) 0.0 4.1%
2016
Net 4.9 2.6 (0.4) (4.2) 0.0 3.3%
Class B - 1.5/20 (%)
(as of February 28. 2019)
Jan
Gross 4.9
Feb
5.8
Mar Apr
.SL
•C6'
Dec YTD
11.0%
ITD
57.1%
May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov
2019
Net 4.0 4.7 8.8% 44.3%
Gross 8.8 (4.0) (1.7) 4.3 2.5 1.7 1.6 1.5 1.3 (7.0) 2.6 (3.8) 7.0%
2018
Net 7.0 (3.2) (1.4) 3.5 2.0 1.4 1.3 1.3 1.1 (5.8) 2.1 (3.1) 5.6%
Gross 10.1 (1.7) 3.2 4.9 (1.7) 0.2 6.1 1.6 (1.1) 5.5 (4.0) 1.6 26.7%
2017
Net 8.1 (1.4) 2.6 4.0 (1.4) 0.2 5.0 1.4 (1.0) 4.6 (3.3) 1.3 21.4%
Gross 0.5 6.2 3.3 (0.4) (5.1) 0.1 4.3%
2016
Net 0.4 5.0 2.7 (0.3) (4.1) 0.1 3.5%
'Estimated performance results are as of Honeycomb Master Fund LP's July 1, 2016 institutional launch date. Internal 
capital anchored our June 2016 soft launch
which also included select friends and family capital. For a
representative Class A investor in the Fund since June 2016. net performance for June 2016 was -3.4%. Please see 
"Important Legal Considerations" on page 2
hereof for additional information regarding the above returns.
HONEYCOMB
AGGET MANAGEMENT LP 15
Summary of Fund Terms
and Service Providers
Class A
Class B
2.0% Management fee
20% Incentive allocation
Soft -lock: 12 months (4% early withdrawal fee)
Liquidity: Quarterly liquidity with 60 days' notice
Privates Optional
Prime Brokers
Legal Counsel
Admin and Auditor
1.5% Management fee
20% Incentive allocation
Soft -lock: 12 months (4% early withdrawal fee)
Liquidity: Quarterly liquidity with 60 days' notice
Gate: 25% Investor -Level Gate
Opt-in/out side-pocket (max 10% of
investment)
Goldman Sachs
Morgan Stanley
Schulte Roth & Zabel LLP
Administrator: Morgan Stanley Fund Services
Auditor: PwC LLP
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
Confidential
For those who elect to participate in the side pocket, here is our private portfolio:
Evolving Beyond
Our Public Portfolio
Private Investments Timeline
Start-ups are staying
private for longer. We
allow investors to
access private
strategies, including
late -stage "crossover"
opportunities before
companies go public.
O David's Private
Investing History

• 2O1O: Started private company
research and VC network at SAC
• 2O11: First late -stage, pre-IPO
private investment was
Facebook

• Later invested in Twitter and
Palantir, among others
OPrivate Investments
Target Returns
• Target IRR: 25% minimum
including for late -stage
private companies

• The investment date for private investments set forth above is the date of the initial investment only.
HONEYCOMB
First realization
achieved in May
2018: 75% net return
z‘ if Late -stage Crossover
Opportunity Criteria

• Generally $1OOmm in revenue
• High growth rate
• Visibility to public company
within 36 months
• Consumer or B2B secular
growth trends
Q2 2018
AT u
FINNANcIAL
03 2018
MMTENCENT MUSIC
ENTERTAINMENT
Combined Research
11 Across Public and Private
• Our team of analysts research both
public and private companies. These
research insights benefit our
portfolios
Target IRRs are provided as general guidelines only and there can be no guarantee that such IRRs will be achieved.
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 17
Conf.e.,
Team Biographies

╭─ Page 18, Image 1 ──╮
│ Team Biographies    │
│                     │
│ HONEYCOMB           │
│                     │
│ ASSET MANAGEMENT LP │
│                     │
│ Confidential        │
╰─────────────────────╯

Confidential
Investment Team
Biographies
David Fiszel
Founder &
Chief Investment Officer
Joyce Jen
Investment Partner &
Head of Research
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
David is the Founder and Chief Investment Officer of Honeycomb Asset Management LP, a New York -
based investment management firm focusing on public equities and select private investments.
Prior to establishing Honeycomb, David was a Portfolio Manager at Point72 Asset Management and its
predecessor and affiliate entities for a combined 12 years. David was the Founding Partner of Rhombus
Capital Management, a long/short equity hedge fund, and began his career as a financial analyst at
Omega Advisors.
David graduated from the University of Texas at Austin with a BBA in Finance and from Stuyvesant High
School in New York City. David serves on the advisory board of the NYU Langone Orthopedic Hospital.
He and his wife, Sarah, are both from New York City, where they reside with their four children.
Prior to joining Honeycomb in January 2O16, Joyce Jen was a Senior Investment Analyst at Engle
Capital Management overseeing the fund's investments in the Consumer sector. From 2O12-2O15 Joyce
was a Managing Director at Tiger Consumer Management (TCM) where she was responsible for
coverage of companies in the Technology, Media, & Telecommunications and Consumer sectors as a
Sector Head. In this senior role, she also worked closely with TCM's data analysts to develop monitoring
capabilities for companies in the firm's investment universe. Prior to joining Tiger Consumer, Joyce was
a Principal at Matrix Capital Management, where she led the firm's investments in the Global Consumer
sector, as well as Asia/Emerging Markets. Joyce began her career as a private equity investor. She was
an Associate at Hellman & Friedman where she worked on transactions in the Consumer and Internet/
Software verticals. Prior to that, she was an Analyst in the Private Equity Group at Goldman, Sachs & Co.
Joyce earned an MBA from Harvard Business School and an AB in Economics, graduating magna cum
laude with High Honors, from Harvard College.
19
Confidential
Investment Team
Biographies
Josh Resnick
Head of Trading
& Risk Management
Andrew Ruben
Investment Analyst
Prior to joining Honeycomb in October 2015, Josh Resnick was a Trader at EverPoint Asset
Management, a family office and division of Point72 Asset Management based in New York City. He
joined EverPoint in 2008 where he traded multiple asset classes across several portfolios covering the
Technology, Media, Telecommunications, Consumer Products and Financial Technology sectors. Prior
to joining Point72, Josh was a Partner and Head Trader at Rhombus Capital Management, a long/short
hedge fund focused on Technology, Media and Telecommunications. Josh started his career at S.A.C.
Capital in 2001 as an Execution Trader on the Global Media and Telecom team.
Josh graduated from the University of Wisconsin with a BBA in Finance, Investments and Banking.
Josh resides in Manhattan with his wife and two daughters.
Prior to joining Honeycomb in 2018, Andrew Ruben was an Investment Analyst at Hutchin Hill Capital,
a multi -strategy hedge fund, where he focused on the Consumer sector. From 2014-2017 Andrew
worked in Morgan Stanley's Equity Research division, serving as a Vice President on the Institutional
Investor -ranked Food Retail team. From 2012-2014 Andrew was an Associate at LSV Advisors, an
investment firm focused on illiquid and distressed assets. Andrew began his career as an Analyst in
Deutsche Bank's equity proprietary trading division.
Andrew graduated magna cum laude from the University of Pennsylvania in 2009, earning a Bachelor
of Science in Economics from The Wharton School and a Bachelor of Science in Engineering from
Penn's School of Engineering and Applied Science.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 20
Confidential
Investment Team
Biographies
Allan Yang
Investment Analyst
Nan Li
China Research
Associate
Prior to joining Honeycomb in 2018, Allan Yang was an Investment Analyst at Quentec Asset
Management, a technology -focused long/short equity hedge fund, which he joined in 2016. Prior to his
role at Quentec, Allan served as an Investment Associate at Lexington Partners, an investment
manager focused on secondary private equity and co-investment funds, from 2012-2014 before
pursuing his MBA. Allan began his career as an Investment Banking Analyst in San Francisco at GCA
Savvian Advisors in 2010.
Allan earned an MBA from The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania in 2016 from where he
also graduated magna cum laude with a Bachelor of Science in Economics in 2010.
Prior to joining Honeycomb in 2017, Nan was a graduate student at Cornell University studying
Economic and Financial Policy. In her second year at Cornell, Nan completed a 6-month externship at
BHR Capital, a long/short equity hedge fund, where she supported equity research in the Technology,
Media & Telecommunications verticals. Prior to that, Nan worked at China Securities in the Investment
Banking Division as a research Intern.
Nan earned an MPA from Cornell University in 2017, and a B.S. in Economics from Jilin University in
2014. Nan was born and raised in China before she came to the United States in 2015.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 21
Confidential
Business Team
Biographies
Vick Sandhu
Chief Operating Officer,
General Counsel &
Chief Compliance Officer
Ken Chan
Chief Financial
Officer
Prior to joining Honeycomb in February 2016, Vick Sandhu was General Counsel & Chief Compliance
Officer for P. Schoenfeld Asset Management 11. (PSAM), an event -driven investment firm. At PSAM,
Vick was responsible for all legal and compliance matters, and advised the other members of the
senior management team on strategic issues. Prior to joining PSAM in 2013, Vick was Associate
General Counsel for over 7 years at Silver Point Capital, M., an investment firm focused on credit and
credit -related investments. Vick began his career at Cleary Gottlieb Steen & Hamilton LLP in 2001.
Vick received a B.A. from Yale University graduating magna cum laude and a M. from NYU Law
School. He resides in Greenwich, CT with his wife and three children.
Prior to joining Honeycomb in September 2018, Ken Chan served as the Chief Financial Officer of
Blockhouse Capital Management LP, a multi -strategy hedge fund that invested across the capital
structure, from 2016-2018. Prior to Blockhouse, from 2014-2016, Ken was the Chief Financial Officer
at Seven Harbour Global LP, a global long/short TMT and Consumer focused hedge fund. From
2008-2014, Ken was the Controller at Owl Creek Asset Management LP, an event driven hedge
fund. Prior to Owl Creek, Ken was the Assistant Controller at Octavian Advisors LP, a distressed
credit hedge fund. Ken began his career at PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP where he provided audit
services to alternative asset, banking and capital markets clients.
Ken received a B.S. in Accounting from Binghamton University graduating magna cum laude in
2002 and is a Certified Public Accountant in New York. He was born and raised in New York City
and currently resides in Long Island with his wife and two children.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 22
Confidential
Business Team
Biographies
Dominique
Ahumada
Head of Capital
Partnerships & Talent
Dana Shakked
Controller
Prior to joining Honeycomb in January 2016, Dominique Ahumada was the Director of Investor
Relations at Coatue Management, a global investment firm focused on investments in TMT, from 2012-

2015. Prior to Coatue, Dominique was an Investor Relations Principal at TPG-Axon, a global long/short
investment firm, where she worked from 2008-2012. Dominique began her career at Citigroup where
she held various positions as an Analyst and Associate in capital markets and loan syndication from
2004-2008.
Dominique was raised in Pasadena, CA and graduated from Duke University in 2004 where she
competed on the Varsity Division I Swim Team. Dominique resides in lower Manhattan with her
husband and two children.
Prior to joining Honeycomb in May 2018, Dana spent five years at King Street Capital Management,
LP, a global long/short credit and event -driven hedge fund. At King Street, she was responsible
for building out accounting and reporting functions for the foreign entities group in addition
to maintaining the books for two of the firm's investment funds. Dana began her career at
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP as an associate in the Alternative Investments sector.
Dana received a B.S. in Business and Economics from Lehigh University in 2011 and is a Certified
Public Accountant in New York. She was born and raised in central New Jersey and currently
resides in Jersey City.
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP 23
Office Location
Thank You
Honeycomb Asset Management LP
645 Madison Avenue, 16TH Floor
New York, NY 10022
Contact Dominique Ahumada
Head of Capital Partnerships & Talent
(646) 883-1128
HONEYCOMB
ASSET MANAGEMENT LP
EFTA00006870 (Jmail)
 [phone] phone bill covering 2006-02-09 to 2006-07
(inferred timestamp: 2026-01-26 22:33:29)
phone bill covering 2006-02-09 to 2006-07
EFTA00008120 (Jmail)
 [book] "Part II: The Art of Receiving a Massage"
(inferred date: 2026-01-28)
"Part II: The Art of Receiving a Massage"
EFTA00098456 (Jmail)
 [government] letter from Paul G. Cassell to Scotland Yard International Sex Trafficking by Jeffrey Epstein, contains court filings
(inferred date: 2026-01-28)
Ul
S.J. QUINNEY
COLLEGE OF LAW
TI IC UNIVERSITY OF UTAH
Metropolitan Police Service
New Scotland Yard
8-10 Broadway
London SW1H 0BG
United Kingdom
PAUL G. CASSELL
Ronald N. Boyce Presidential Professor of Criminal Law
May 4, 2015
Re: International Sex Trafficking by Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell
Dear Metropolitan Police:
I write on behalf of my client — . She is the victim of an
international sex trafficking crime in London shortly before March 13, 2001. In the following
weeks (and much earlier), the crimes also continued into the United States, specifically New
York City, New York, and the U.S. Virgin Islands. The perpetrators of these crimes include: (1)
Jeffrey Epstein, a billionaire (and convicted sex offender) who is a citizen of the United States
residing in New York City; (2) Ghislaine Maxwell, a well-to-do citizen of the United Kingdom
who moved to the United States after the death of her father, Robert Maxwell; and (3) others
known and unknown. would like for Scotland Yard and/or Metropolitan Police to
investigate these crimes and prosecute those res onsible. The purpose of this letter is to provide
background about the crimes and to offer assistance in any investigation and
prosecution.
has described the relevant facts surrounding these crimes in the attached
sworn affidavit. Rather than repeat all the details recounted there I offer 'ust a quick summary.
In approximately the summer of 1999 in Palm Beach, Florida, was approached by
Ghislaine Maxwell to be a "masseuse" for Jeffrey Epstein. Epstein was a billionaire with a
mansion in the area. When went to the mansion, Epstein (and Maxwell) sexually
abused her. was 15 at the time of the first sexual abuse. She became Epstein's "sex
slave" over the next few years, and Epstein and Maxwell groomed her to perform sexual acts for
their powerful friends.
A little over two years later, in around March 2013, Epstein and Maxwell flew
to London on Epstein's private et. While in London, Epstein had sex with
Epstein and Maxwell also "lent" to one of their powerful friends — Mr. Andrew
Albert Christian Edward (a/k/a Prince Andrew, the Duke of York). The details of the sexual acts
are described in the attached affidavit. Of importance here is the fact that had a
photograph taken of her that evening. The photograph (the original of which I have access to)
was taken by Jeffrey Epstein and de icts the inside of Maxwell's apartment — along with
Maxwell, Prince Andrew, and . The date on the photograph shows that it was
developed on March 13, 2001, which was shortly after the relevant events. Following this sexual
act, returned with Epstein and Maxwell to New York City. Other events of a similar
nature took place in New York and the U.S. Virgin Islands.
It is my understanding that the activities of Epstein and Maxwell outlined above would be
a violation of American criminal laws, including the American prohibition of transporting
minors internationally for sexual purposes contained in 18 U.S. Code § 1591. I am not an expert
on the applicable laws in the United Kingdom, but it seems like the same type of criminal
offenses may exist there as well.
In America, there is no statute of limitations for sexual offenses involving minors. It is
possible that the law there in the United Kingdom is similar on this point as well.
In 2002, to escape Epstein, moved to In 2011, agents from the
Federal Bureau of Investigation's Office in the Southern District of Florida interviewed her, and
she recounted this information, as she described both in the first attached affidavit as well as in a
second attached affidavit. The status of the FBI's investigation into her allegations is uncertain at
this time. It may be the case that the Southern District of Florida is disabled from prosecuting
Epstein and Maxwell because of a "non -prosecution agreement" (NPA) that the U.S.
Government has entered into with Epstein. Along with attorney Brad Edwards, I am
representing and three other women who are trying to have that agreement set aside.
Litigation on that subject continues.
I should note that the attached affidavit was recently filed in the case attempting to set
aside the NPA. The judge struck the affidavit from the record on grounds that it was not relevant
at that stage of the proceedings. The judge made no findings regarding the accuracy of the
allegations in the affidavit and said that the affidavit could be refiled at a later point in the
proceedings if it became relevant and otherwise admissible in evidence.
I represent , along with co-counsel, Florida attorneys Brad Edwards and
Sigrid McCawley. We would like to discuss this matter with you at your earliest convenience. I
believe the Metropolitan Police possess jurisdiction in this matter but, if not, please advise as to
who would have jurisdiction. I have also attempted to send this communication via on-line
means.
While I am a professor at the University of Utah, I write in my own individual capacity as
a pro bono attorney representing , rather than on behalf of the University itself. I
look forward to further discussions with you in an effort to bring to justice Epstein, Maxwell, and
any others criminally culpable in these serious trafficking crimes.
Sincerely,
2111med. '". •
Cc: Brad Edwards, Esq.
Sigrid McCawley, Esq.
Jack Scarola, Esq.
Enclosures
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 1 of 20
EXHIBIT 1
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 2 of 20
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
CASE NO. 08-80736-CIV-MARRA
JANE DOE #1 and JANE DOE #2,
Petitioners,
VS.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Respondent.
DECLARATION OF

1. My name is and I was born in August, 1983.
2. I am currently 31 years old.
3. I grew up in When I was little, I loved animals and wanted
to be a veterinarian. But my life took a very different turn when adults began to be interested in
having sex with me.

4. In approximately 1999, when I was 15 years old, I met Ghislaine Maxwell. She is
the daughter of Robert Maxwell, who had been a wealthy publisher in Britain. Maxwell asked
that I come with her to Jeffrey Epstein's mansion for the purposes of teaching me how to
perform "massages" and to train me professionally in that area. Soon after that I went to
Epstein's home in Palm Beach on El Brillo Way.

5. From the first time I was taken to Epstein's mansion that day, his motivations and
actions were sexual, as were Maxwell's. My father was not allowed inside. I was brought up
some stairs. There was a naked guy, Epstein, on the table in the room. Epstein and Maxwell
forced me into sexual activity with Epstein. I was 15 years old at the time. He seemed to be in
his 40s or 50s. I was paid $200. I was driven home by one of Epstein's employees.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 3 of 20

6. I came back for several days following and did the same sorts of sexual things for
Epstein.
7. After I did those things for Epstein, he and Maxwell said they were going to have
me travel and were going to get an education for me. They were promising me the world, that I
would travel with Epstein on his private jet and have a well-paid profession. Epstein said he
would eventually match me up with a wealthy person so that I would be "set up" for life.

8. So I started "working" exclusively for Epstein. He took me to New York on his
big, private jet. We went to his mansion in New York City. I was shown to my room, a very
luxurious room. The mansion was huge. I got scared because it was so big. Epstein brought me
to a room with a massage parlor. To me, it looked like an S&M parlor. Epstein made me engage
in sexual activities with him there.

9. You can see how young I looked in the photograph below.
Aet
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 4 of 20

10. Epstein took me on a ferry boat on one of the trips to New York City and there he
took the picture above. I was approximately 15 or 16 years old at the time.

11. Over the next few weeks, Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell trained me to do
what they wanted, including sexual activities and the use of sexual toys. The training was in
New York and Florida, at Epstein's mansions. It was basically every day and was like going to
school. I also had to have sex with Epstein many times.

12. I was trained to be "everything a man wanted me to be." It wasn't just sexual
training - they wanted me to be able to cater to all the needs of the men they were going to send
me to. They said that they loved that I was very compliant and knew how to keep my mouth
shut.

13. Epstein and Maxwell also told me that they wanted me to produce things for them
in addition to performing sex on the men. They told to me to pay attention to the details about
what the men wanted, so I could report back to them.

14. From very early on I was fearful of Epstein. Epstein told me he was a billionaire.
I told my mother that I was working for this rich guy, and she said "go, go far away." Epstein
had promised me a lot, and I knew if I left I would be in big trouble. I also knew that I was a
witness to a lot of illegal and very bad behavior by Epstein and his friends. If I left Epstein, he
knew all kinds of powerful people. He could have had me killed or abducted, and I always knew
he was capable of that if I did not obey him. He let me know that he knew many people in high
places. Speaking about himself, he said "I can get away" with things. I was very scared,
particularly since I was a teenager.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 5 of 20

15. I visited and traveled with Jeffrey Epstein from 1999 through the summer of
2002, and during that time I stayed with him, as his sex slave, at each of his houses (really more
like mansions) in locations including New York City, New York; the area of Santa Fe, New
Mexico; Palm Beach, Florida; an island in the U.S. Virgin Islands; and Paris, France. I had sex
with him often in these places and also with the various people he demanded that I have sex
with. Epstein paid me for many of these sexual encounters. In fact, my only purpose for
Epstein, Maxwell and their friends was to be used for sex.

16. To illustrate my connection to these places, I include four photographs taken of
me in New Mexico (shown below). The first one is a museum in Santa Fe, New Mexico. We
had gone sightseeing for the day. Epstein took this picture of me. I was approximately 17 at the
time, judging from the looks of it. At the end of the day we returned to Epstein's ZO/TO Ranch.
The second picture is me on one of Epstein's horses on the ranch in New Mexico. The following
two are from wintertime in New Mexico.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 6 of 20

17. When I was with him, Epstein had sex with underage girls on a daily basis. His
interest in this kind of sex was obvious to the people around him. The activities were so obvious
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 7 of 20
and bold that anyone spending any significant time at one of Epstein's residences would have
clearly been aware of what was going on.

18. Epstein's code word for sexual encounters was that it was a "massage". At times
the interaction between Epstein and the girls would start in a massage room setting, it was
always a sexual encounter and never just a massage.

19. In addition to constantly finding underage girls to satisfy their personal desires,
Epstein and Maxwell also got girls for Epstein's friends and acquaintances. Epstein specifically
told me that the reason for him doing this was so that they would "owe him," they would "be in
his pocket," and he would "have something on them." I understood him to mean that when
someone was in his pocket, they owed him favors. I also understood that Epstein thought he
could get leniency if he was ever caught doing anything illegal, or more so that he could escape
trouble altogether.

20. Ghislaine Maxwell was heavily involved in the illegal sex. I understood her to be
a very powerful person. She used Epstein's money and he used her name and connections to
gain power and prestige.

21. One way to describe Maxwell's role was as the "madame." She assumed a
position of trust for all the girls, including me. She got me to trust her and Epstein. It turned out
that Maxwell was all about sex all the time. She had sex with underage girls virtually every day
when I was around her, and she was very forceful.

22. I first had sexual activities with her when I was approximately 15 at the Palm
Beach mansion. I had many sexual activities with her over the next several years in Epstein's
various residences plus other exotic locations. I had sex with Maxwell in the Virgin Islands,
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 8 of 20
New Mexico, New York, as well as France and many other locations. I also observed Maxwell
have sex with dozens of underage girls.

23. Maxwell took pictures of many of the underage girls. These pictures were
sexually explicit. Maxwell kept the pictures on the computers in the various houses. She also
made hard copies of these images and displayed them in the various houses. Maxwell had large
amounts of child pornography that she personally made. Many times she made me sleep with
other girls, some of whom were very young, for purposes of taking sexual pictures.

24. Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz was around Epstein frequently.
Dershowitz was so comfortable with the sex that was going on that he would even come and chat
with Epstein while I was giving oral sex to Epstein.

25. I had sexual intercourse with Dershowitz at least six times. The first time was
when I was about 16, early on in my servitude to Epstein, and it continued until I was 19.

26. The first time we had sex took place in New York in Epstein's home. It was in
Epstein's room (not the massage room). I was approximately 16 years old at the time. I called
Dershowitz "Alan." I knew he was a famous professor.

27. The second time that I had sex with Dershowitz was at Epstein's house in Palm
Beach. During this encounter, Dershowitz instructed me to both perform oral sex and have
sexual intercourse.

28. I also had sex with Dershowitz at Epstein's Zorro Ranch in New Mexico in the
massage room off of the indoor pool area, which was still being painted.

29. We also had sex at Little Saint James Island in the U.S. Virgin Islands. I was
asked to give Dershowitz a massage on the beach. Dershowitz then asked me to take him
somewhere more private, where we proceeded to have intercourse.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 9 of 20

30. Another sexual encounter between me and Dershowitz happened on Epstein's
airplane. Another girl was present on the plane with us.

31. I have recently seen a former Harvard law professor identified as Alan
Dershowitz on television calling me a "liar." He is lying by denying that he had sex with me.
That man is the same man that I had sex with at least six times.

32. Epstein made me have sex with Prince Andrew several times. Prince Andrew,
Maxwell, and I are shown in the photograph below. I had sex with him three times, including
one orgy. I knew he was a member of the British Royal Family, but I just called him "Andy."

33. One day when I was in London (specifically in a townhouse that is under
Maxwell's name), I got news from Maxwell that I would be meeting a prince. Later that day,
Epstein told me I was meeting a "major prince." Epstein told me "to exceed" everything I had
been taught. He emphasized that whatever Prince Andrew wanted, I was to make sure he got.

34. Eventually Prince Andrew arrived, along with his security guards. The guards
then went out of the house and stayed out front in their car. It was just Epstein, Maxwell, and me
inside alone with Andy. I was introduced to the Prince, and we kissed formally, cheek to cheek.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 10 of
There was a lot of legal discussion about Andy and his ex-wife ("Fergie"). Then the discussion
turned to me. Maxwell said "guess how old she is." Prince Andrew guessed 17.

35. Then we all went to a Chinese restaurant for dinner and then to Club Tramp, a
fancy "members only" night club in central London. Andy arranged for alcohol to be provided
to me at the club. Eventually we left. I rode with Epstein and Maxwell back to the townhouse.
On the way there, Epstein and Maxwell informed me that the Prince wanted to see "more of me"
that night. Andy traveled in a separate car with his guards.

36. We all arrived back at the townhome and went upstairs. Epstein took a picture of
me and Andy with my own camera. The picture above is that picture, which has been widely
circulated on the intemet. Andy has his left arm around my waist and is smiling. The picture was
developed on March 13, 2001, and was taken sometime shortly before I had it developed. I was
17 years old at the time.

37. I wanted a picture with the prince because I was keeping in contact with my
family. I had told my mom and my grandma that I was meeting Prince Andrew and that I'd take
a picture for them. They told me to "be careful."

38. After the picture, Epstein and Maxwell kissed me and said to "have fun." They
left Andy and me alone upstairs. We went to the bathroom and bedroom, which were just steps
away from where the picture was taken. We engaged in sexual activities there. Afterwards,
Andy left quickly with his security.

39. I chatted with Epstein about this the next day. I told him, "it went great." Epstein
said something to the effect of, "You did well. The Prince had fun." I felt like I was being
graded. It was horrible to have to recount all these events and have to try to meet all these needs
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 11 of
and wants. I told Epstein about Andy's sexual interests in feet. Epstein thought it was very
funny. Epstein appeared to be collecting private information about Andy.

40. When I got back from my trip, Epstein paid me more than he had paid me to be
with anyone else — approximately $15,000. That money was for what I had done and to keep my
mouth shut about "working" with the Prince.

41. The second time I had sex with Prince Andrew was in Epstein's New York
mansion in spring 2001. I was 17 at time. Epstein called me down to his office. When I got
there, Epstein was there, along with Maxwell, and Andy. I was very surprised
to see him again. Epstein and Maxwell were making lewd jokes about "Randy Andy".

42. I had the impression that Andy had come there to see Epstein and to me
with. There was no other apparent purpose for Andy to be there.

43. I was told to go upstairs with Andy and to go to the room I thought of as the
"dungeon" (the massage room, but it is really scary looking). I with Andy there. I was
only paid $400 from Epstein for servicing Andy that time.

44. The third time I had sex with Andy was in an orgy on Epstein's private island in
the U.S. Virgin Islands. I was around 18 at the time. Epstein, Andy, approximately eight other
young girls, and I had sex together. The other girls all seemed and appeared to be under the age
of 18 and didn't really speak English. Epstein laughed about the fact they couldn't really
communicate, saying that they are the "easiest" girls to get along with. My assumption was that
Jean Luc Brunel got the girls from Eastern Europe (as he procured many young foreign girls for
Epstein). They were young and European looking and sounding.

45. Afterwards we all had dinner by the cabanas. The other girls were chatting away
among themselves, and Epstein and the Prince chatted together. I felt disgusted, and went
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 12 of
quickly to my own cabana that night and went to sleep. Prince Andrew must have flown out
early the next morning, as I did not see him when I got up.

46. I have seen Buckingham Palace's recent "emphatic" denial that Prince Andrew
had sexual contact with me. That denial is false and hurtful to me. I did have sexual contact
with him as I have described here — under oath. Given what he knows and has seen, I was
hoping that he would simply voluntarily tell the truth about everything. I hope my attorneys can
interview Prince Andrew under oath about the contacts and that he will tell the truth.

47. I also had sexual intercourse with Jean Luc Brunel many times when I was 16
through 19 years old. He was another of Epstein's powerful friends who had many contacts with
young girls throughout the world. In fact, his only similarity with Epstein and the only link to
their friendship appeared to be that Brunel could get dozens of underage girls and feed Epstein's
(and Maxwell's) strong appetite for sex with minors.

48. Brunel ran some kind of modeling agency and appeared to have an arrangement
with the U.S. Government where he could get passports or other travel documents for young
girls. He would then bring these young girls (girls ranging in age from 12 to 24) to the United
States for sexual purposes and farm them out to his friends, including Epstein.

49. Brunel would offer the girls "modeling" jobs. A lot of the girls came from poor
countries or poor backgrounds, and he lured them in with a promise of making good money.

50. I had to have sex with Brunel at Little St. James (orgies), Palm Beach, New York
City, New Mexico, Paris, the south of France, and California. He did not care about
conversation, just sex.

51. Jeffrey Epstein has told me that he has slept with over 1,000 of Brunel's girls, and
everything that I have seen confirms this claim. Epstein, Brunel, and Maxwell loved orgies with
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 13 of
kids — that is, having sexual interactions with many young teenagers at the same time.
Sometimes as many as ten underage girls would participate in a single orgy with them. I
personally observed dozens of these orgies. The orgies happened on Epstein's island in the U.S.
Virgin Islands, in New Mexico, Palm Beach, and many other places. Most of the girls did not
speak English. It was my understanding that the girls had been persuaded to come by Brunel
offering them illegal drugs or a career in modeling. Brunel was one of the main procurers of
girls.

52. In addition to Ghislaine Maxwell, and were also
involved in the orgies. At this stage, I am hopeful that these other women will come forward and
tell the truth about everything because that will help prevent future similar abuse.

53. I have seen reports saying or implying that I had sex with former President Bill
Clinton on Little Saint James Island. Former President Bill Clinton was present on the Island at
a time when I was also present on the Island, but I have never had sexual relations with Clinton,
nor have I ever claimed to have had such relations. I have never seen him have sexual relations
with anyone.

54. I now understand that Epstein reached a non-prosecution agreement with the
federal government in 2007 and pled guilty to two state crimes in June 2008. 1 now know that I
was identified by the federal government as one of Epstein's and his co-conspirator's sexually
abused victims. However, no one told me about those events until after they happened.

55. On September 3, 2008, the FBI sent a victim notification letter to me. This was
the first written communication I had received from the FBI. The letter is attached as Exhibit I.
The letter describes an agreement in which compensation would be made victims of Epstein's
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 14 of
sexual abuse. The letter also said that the federal government was going to "defer federal
prosecution." No one had told me about deferring federal prosecution before this.

56. In 2011, two FBI agents, called m
met me at the
nd then came to meet me. They
They seemed to be very professional and hard working.
I thought to myself, "Wow, these people will do the right thing against the bad guys and protect
me."

57. The agents were mainly focused on Epstein but while there I provided them some
information about others who were involved in illegal acts as well. I was aware that a false
statement to these law enforcement officers was a crime and I told the truth — giving them the
information that I could recall about the individuals they inquired about.

58. Epstein also trafficked me for sexual purposes to many other powerful men,
including politicians and powerful business executives. Epstein required me to describe the
sexual events that I had with these men presumably so that he could potentially blackmail them.
I am still very fearful of these men today.

59. I will continue to cooperate fully in the investigation and prosecution of Epstein,
Maxwell, or any of their friends who participated in the sexual abuse of minors. I also hope that
this information is treated in a way that will keep me safe from Epstein and others criminals
identified here so as to encourage more victims of similar crimes to come forward. If these
crimes are not prosecuted, despite my volunteering this information and cooperation, then it may
deter other similar victims from coming forward.

60. In this affidavit, I have tried to focus on how I was trafficked for sexual purposes.
I have not described all of the details of the sexual activities Epstein forced me to have. Also, I
have not described all of the details of the other events discussed here. If a judge wants me to
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 15 of
present my information in more detail, including more specific descriptions of the sexual
activities with the men Epstein sent me to. I could do so.

61. I have directed my attorneys. Bradley J. Edwards and Paul G. Cassell, to pursue
all reasonable and legitimate means to have criminal charges brought against these powerful
people for the crimes they have committed against me and other girls. They are representing me
in this case pro bono.

62. Since I filed my motion in this case. my credibility has been attacked. I am telling
the truth and will not let these attacks prevent me from exposing the truth of how I was trafficked
for sex to many powerful people. These powerful people seem to think that they don't have to
follow the same rules as everyone else. That is wrong. I hope that by coming forward, I can
help expose the problem of sex trafficking and prevent the same sort of abuse and degradation
that happened to me from happening to other girls.

63. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed this  (l ily  of January. 2015.
(Location of signature left undisclosed for security reasons)
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 16 of
EXHIBIT 1
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 17 of
U.S. Departme:ral oCatistice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
300 South Australian Ave.. Suite 400
West Point Reach, FL 33401
(561)8204711
Facsimile: (561) 820-8777
September 3, 2008
NOTIFICATION OF *IDENTIFIED VICTIM
NOTICE: IN ACCORDANCE WITH TITLE 18, UNITED
STATES CODE, SECTION 3509(d) AND FLORIDA LAW,
THE ATTACHED DOCUMENT IS TO BE TREATED AS
CONFIDENTIAL AND SHALL NOT BE DISCLOSED
EXCEPT IN CONNECTION WITH A LEGAL
PROCEEDING.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 18 of
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of Florida
500 South Australian Ave, Suite 400
Walt Pdm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 820-8711
Facsimile: (560 820-8777
September 3, 2008
VIA COURIER
Re: Jeffrey Epstein/ NOTIFICATION OF
IDENTIFIED VICTIM
Dear
•
By virtue of this letter, the United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District
of Florida provides you with the following notice because you are an identified victim of a
federal offense.
On June 30, 2008, Jeffrey Epstein (hereinafter referred to as "Epstein) entered a plea
of guilty to violations of Florida Statutes Sections 796.07 (felony solicitation of prostitution)
and 796.03 (procurement of minors to engage in prostitution). in the 15th Judicial Circuit in
and for Palm Beach County (Case Nos. 2006-cf-009454A7OO(MB and 2008-cf-
00938 lAXXXMB) and was sentenced to a term of twelve months' imprisonment to be
followed by an additional six months' imprisonment, followed by twelve months of
Community Control 1, with conditions of community confinement imposed by the Court.
In light of the entry of the guilty plea and sentence, the United States has agreed to
defer federal prosecution in favor of this state plea and sentence, subject to certain
conditions, including the following:
I . An independent Special Master was assigned the task of selecting an
attorney representative to represent the victims, including you, in
connection with civil actions between the victims and Mr. Epstein. The
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 19 of
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
SEPTEMBER 3, 2008
PAGE 2 OF 3
Special Master selected Robert Josefsberg, Esq. of the firm Podhurst
Orseck, P.A., a highly-respected and experienced attorney. You are not
obligated to use Mr. Josefsberg as your civil attorney, but, as explained
in greater detail below, Mr. Josefsberg's services will be provided at no
cost to you because Mr. Epstein is obligated to pay the costs and fees
of the attorney-representative. Also, Mr. Epstein and his attorneys can
only contact you via Mr. Josefsberg, assuming that you would like Mr.
Josefsberg to serve as your attorney.

2. If you elect to file suit against Mr. Epstein pursuant to Title 18, United
States Code, Section 2255, Mr. Epstein will not contest the jurisdiction
of the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida
over his person and/or the subject matter, and Mr. Epstein waives his
right to contest liability and also waives his right to contest damages up
to an amount as agreed to between you and Mr. Epstein, so long as you
elect to proceed exclusively under I8 U.S.C. § 2255, and you waive any
other claim for damages, whether pursuant to state, federal, or common
law. Notwithstanding this waiver, Epstein's agreement with the United
States, his waivers and failure to contest liability and such damages in
any suit are not to be construed as an admission of any criminal or civil
liability.

3. As stated above, Mr. Epstein has agreed to pay the fees of the attorney
representative selected by the independent third party. This provision,
however, shall not obligate Epstein to pay the fees and costs of
contested litigation filed against him. Thus, if after consideration of
potential settlements, you and Mr. Josefsberg elect to file a contested
lawsuit pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2255 or you elect to pursue any other
contested remedy, the obligation to pay the costs of the attorney
representative, as opposed to any statutory or other obligations to pay
reasonable attorneys fees and costs such as those contained in Section
2255, shall cease.
Please contact either myself at or Justice
Department Victim-Witness Specialist Twiler Smith at with a good
telephone number and/or e-mail address, so that we may provide Mr. Josefsberg with a
timely means of communicating with you. If you would like to contact Mr. Josefsberg
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 291-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 01/21/2015 Page 20 of
NOTIFICATION OF IDENTIFIED VICTIM
SEPTEMBER 3,2008
PAGE 3 OF 3
directly, he can be reached at +1 305 358-2800.
If you have already selected other counsel to represent you, or if you do so in the
future, and you decide to file a claim against Jeffrey Epstein, Mr. Epstein's attorney, Jack
Goldberger, asks that you have your attorney contact Mr. Goldberger at AtterburyGoldber er
and Weiss West Palm Beach, FL 33401,
In addition, there has been litigation between the United States and two other victims
regarding the disclosure of the entire agreement between the United States and Mr. Epstein.

Mr. Josefsberg can provide further guidance on this issue, or if you select another attorney
to represent you, that attorney can review the Court's order in the matter of In re Jane Does
l and 2, United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida Court File No. 08-
80736-CIV-MARRA.
Please understand that neither the U.S. Attorney's Office nor the Federal Bureau of
Investigation can take part in or otherwise assist in civil litigation. Thank you for all of your
assistance during the course of the federal and state investigations and please accept the
heartfelt regards of myself and Special Agents Kuyrkendall, Slater, and Richards for your
health and well-being.
Sincerely,

R. Alexander Acosta
United States Attorney
By:
cc: Robert Josefsbcrg, Esq.
Jack Goldberger, Esq.
Assistant rote United States Attorney
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 1 of 28
EXHIBIT 1
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 2 of 28
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA
CASE NO. 08-80736-CIV-MARRA
JANE DOE #1 and JANE DOE #2,
Petitioners,
vs.
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Respondent.
DECLARATION OF) JANE DOE 3

1. The Court is familiar with me from my previous declaration in this case. I am currently
and want to become a part of the case to enforce my rights and possibly allow
criminal prosecution of Jeffrey Epstein and others who abused underage girls.

2. I have seen a Government filing saying that I waited too long before trying to become a
part of this case. I don't think that the Government's position tells the full story about me. In
fact, I believe the Government is hiding some of the things that it knows about me and about
other powerful people involved in this case. I am filing this declaration so that the Court will
have more facts to make the decision about whether to let me come into the case.

3. In its latest filing, the Government seetns to be questioning why I was afraid and did not
come forward to speak more quickly. To understand my reasons, it is important that I share at
least some additional information about why I was so fearful after my abuse by Epstein and
others.

4. The Court can best understand my situation by looking at my previous declaration and
then understanding why I was afraid of Epstein, how I eventually escaped from him, and how I
was forced to hide from him and others.

5. I first met Epstein when I was 15 years old. I have told the Court about some of my
sexual and physical abuse in my earlier declaration.

6. As a result of that abuse and my considerable interactions with Epstein and his friends, I
knew that Epstein was connected to some of the most powerful people in the world, including a
member of the British Royal family, a former President of the United States, and other very
powerful lawyers, politicians and businessmen. I was afraid of what would happen if I tried to
escape from Epstein or report him to law enforcement.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 3 of 28

7. I also knew what Epstein and Maxwell had been doing the years that I was with them. In
addition to constantly finding underage girls to satisfy their personal sexual desires, Epstein and
Maxwell also got girls for Epstein's powerful friends and acquaintances. Epstein specifically
told me that the reason for him doing this was so that they would "owe him," they would "be in
his pocket," and he would "have something on them." Epstein used to brag a lot to me about the
important people that owed him favors.

8. Epstein said that he knew people that were very powerful and who were politically
involved, and that consequently he was someone you didn't want to mess with. I also knew this
to be true from my personal observations with him.

9. Epstein also apparently paid to get protection from authorities. For example, Epstein told
me that he paid a substantial "donation" to the Palm Beach police every year to "keep their
mouths shut" about his activities. I do not know if his claim is true, but it certainly added to my
fear.

10. Epstein arranged for many politically powerful, older men to have sex with underage
girls — including me. Because these were crimes — and because some of these rnen were married
— this gave Epstein the ability to blackmail these men and obtain political and other favors. I
believe that Epstein's connections and his ability to blackmail these other powerful people could
have helped Epstein seek a plea bargain from the authorities that kept him out of prison. I also
believe that these connections most likely have prevented him from being arrested in the other
locations where he has committed similar offenses.

II. I also knew that Epstein maintained videos in some rooms where I had sex with other
powerful people, and I believe that those videos could be used as further blackmail.

12. I have listed a few of the powerful people that Epstein forced me to have sex with in my
earlier declaration. There were others, though, who I continue to refrain from naming publicly
out of fear for physical repercussions.

13. Part of my fear comes from physical abuse that I suffered when Epstein forced me to
have sex with other people. Without going into the details of the sexual activities I was forced to
endure, there were times when I was physically abused to the point that I remember fearfully
thinking that I didn't know whether I was going to survive.

14. Jeffrey Epstein knew about this physical and sexual abuse because I would detail it for
him as part of my debriefing. Epstein didn't care. Epstein said things like, "You get that
sometimes." I told him how much I hated having to be with some people, but Epstein still sent
me back. I had no choice.

15. I give the Court this information so that it can better understand why I was so afraid of
Epstein and what he could do to me. I could provide more details to the Court, if the Court needs
more details on this issue. I also wanted to provide this information to the Court because I have
been accused of being a "serial prostitute." I don't think that is a fair way to describe my
situation, given that I was so young and so many powerful people were forcibly abusing me.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 4 of 28

16. Epstein let me know one of his good friends was former President Bill Clinton. While I
did not have sex with former President Clinton, Epstein clearly had access to this extremely
powerful man. Epstein also made me sexually service other very powerful people, which made
me more fearful and feeling like I had nobody to report to without putting myself in more
danger. I don't think it is fair for the Government to talk about why I didn't try to join this case
sooner without talking about these kinds of facts — facts that I believe it has been able to confirm.

17. After years of abuse and being lent out, I began to look for a way to escape. I had been
first forced into all this because I wanted to be a massage therapist. Epstein had taken me into
his clutches through promises and talk. But once he had me under his control, I felt trapped.

18. I kept asking Epstein for my promised training and education. Epstein finally got me a
plane ticket to Thailand to go to Chaing Mai to learn Thai massage. This sounded like my
chance to escape. In September 2002, I packed my bags for good. I knew this would be my only
opportunity to break away from Epstein.

19. On September 27, 2002, I flew from JFK in New York to Thailand. I
arrived around September 29 for my training. But Epstein was going to get something out of this
as well. I was supposed to interview a girl to bring back to the United States for Epstein.

20. Exhibit 1 is a list of room charges in Thailand, with the charges going to Epstein's
account. This exhibit shows Epstein's telephone numbers and is evidence that he paid for my
hotel in Thailand.

21. Exhibit 2 is a set of documents showing my itinerary and flight plans for me going to
Thailand, paid for by Epstein.

22. I did the massage training in Chiang Mai. I met a truly great and special guy and told him
honestly what I was being forced to do. He told me I should get out of it. I told him that the
people I was working for were very powerful and that I could not disobey them without risking
my life. He told me he would protect me, and I had confidence in him. I saw my opportunity to
escape and to be with someone who truly loved me and would protect me. To make a long story
short, I married him and

23. I called Epstein and told him I was not coming back He asked why? I said "I've fallen
in love." And Epstein basically just said "good luck and have a good life." I could tell he was
not happy. I was very afraid of what he was going to do to me. I thought Epstein or one of his
powerful friends might send someone to have me killed.

24. I stayed in from that point on, with my husband and away from the life I had
been forced to live as Epstein's sex slave. I was i from late 2002 to October 2013. To
be clear, I was never in the United States during se years, not even for a short trip to visit my
mother. And my absence from the United States was not voluntary — I was hiding from Epstein
out of fear of what he would do to me if I returned to the United States.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 5 of 28

25. In around 2007, after not hearing from anyone for years, out of the blue I was contacted
by someone who identified himself with a plain sounding name and claimed he was with the
FBI. It seemed very odd for someone doing an official criminal investigation to just call up on
the phone like that. I hadn't heard Epstein's name for years. I didn't know who this person was
and what it was really about. I wasn't sure what was going on.

26. This man said he was looking into Jeffrey Epstein. The man asked if I had been involved
with Epstein. My first instinct was to say nothing because I wasn't sure he was really with the
FBI or any authorities. I did answer a few basic questions, telling him that I knew Jeffrey
Epstein and met him at a young age. The whole conversation didn't feel like it was right. This
man never offered to come and meet with me in person. He instead asked me right off the bat
about Epstein's sexual practices. I thought it would be strange for a real law enforcement officer
to behave that way. I became increasingly uncomfortable and suspicious about who was actually
calling me.

27. The way the conversation was going made me doubt whether I was really talking to an
FBI agent. It did not seem very official. I became very uncomfortable, so I told him nothing
more about Epstein. The conversation probably didn't even last three minutes. The conversation
immediately triggered all of the fears of Epstein and his powerful friends that had caused me to
escape the first time. If the call accomplished anything, it only put me back in fear and told me
that I could be found quite easily and had nobody official protecting me.

28. I suspected that the man who called me was working for Epstein or one of Epstein's
powerful friends. If the man who called me was really an FBI agent and was interested in what I
knew about Epstein, I thought he would have made some effort to see me personally. I believed
that if this was really an agent who was investigating Epstein, then he knew who I was and how I
fit into Epstein's sexual crimes in many different places. Such an agent would send someone to
meet me in person (who could provide potential protection from Epstein). He never did.

29. Getting a call from this supposed FBI Agent made me very scared. I had left that old life
behind me and started a new life in a new country in hopes that the powerful people whose
illegal activities I knew all about would never find me. And now I had been tracked down by
someone and was frightened.

30. Shortly after this purported FBI call, I was contacted by someone who was clearly
working for Epstein. This person discussed an investigation into Epstein, and said that some of
the girls were saying Epstein had sexual contact with them. After they made those allegations,
they were being discredited as drug addicts and prostitutes. But, on the other hand, if I were to
keep quiet, I would "be looked after." The fact that this call came in right after the FBI call
reinforced my concern that the man I had talked to earlier was not really working for the FBI, but
was really working for Epstein. I didn't think that the FBI and Epstein would both be working
together and would both get my phone number at almost exactly the same time. I played along
and told this person that I had gotten a call from the "FBI" but that I didn't tell them anything.
The person was pleased with that.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 6 of 28

31. A short time later, one of Epstein lawyers (not Alan Dershowitz) called me, and then got
Epstein on the line at the same time. Epstein and his lawyer basically asked again if I was going
to say anything. The clear implication was that I should not say anything. The way they were
approaching me, I was afraid of what would happen if I didn't keep quiet. My thought was that if
I didn't say the right things, I might get hurt.

32. I promised Epstein and his lawyer that I would keep quiet. They seemed happy with that
and that seemed to me the way to most likely keep me and my family safe. And I did what
Epstein and his lawyer told me — I kept quiet.

33. I now understand that Epstein reached a non-prosecution agreement with the federal
government in 2007 and pled guilty to two state crimes in June 2008. No one told me anything
about those events until much later. In fact, nobody called or came to see me to explain what a
non-prosecution agreement was, what crimes Epstein could have been charged with, why he was
not being charged with the crimes he committed, or anything whatsoever about the case. I was
never offered a chance to meaningfully confer with the prosecutor for the Government, and I was
never notified of any hearing that could affect me or my rights as a crime victim to ever bring
charges.

34. On September 3, 2008, the FBI sent a victim notification letter to me. This was the first
written communication I had received from the FBI. The letter was attached as Exhibit 1 to my
earlier statement. This kind of written communication, on official FBI stationary, is the way that
I thought the FBI really communicated with people that they wanted to talk to. The fact that I got
this official letter from them made me wonder even more whether that the call I had received
earlier was really from the FBI. The letter that I got did not mention that anyone from the FBI
had ever called me before.

35. The letter started off with the sentence: "By virtue of this letter, the United States
Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Florida provides you with the following notice
because you are an identified victim of a federal offense." That sentence (among others) made it
seem like this was the first time the FBI was officially contacting me. That was the first time I
was told about my rights as a crime victim.

36. I did not know what was happening about any criminal prosecution of Epstein at this
time. I wanted him prosecuted. And given his constant illegal sexual behavior, I thought it was
obvious that he should be prosecuted. But after reading the letter, I was confused. The letter did
not explain what was actually happening or what role, if any, that I could play. In fact, the letter
thanked me for my assistance during the investigations, yet it wasn't clear what that was
referring to.

37. Also, the letter did not directly say that Epstein's crimes against me were not going to be
prosecuted. It just said that "the United States has agreed to defer federal prosecution in favor of
this state plea and sentence .. .." I did not know what that meant. The letter did not inform me
how it applied to me. The letter also said that there was "litigation between the United States
and two other victims regarding the disclosure of the entire agreement between the United States
and Mr. Epstein." Understanding more about that case now, I realize that the letter did not
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 7 of 28
explain that the real purpose of that litigation was not to get "disclosure of the entire agreement"
but instead to get criminal charges filed against Epstein and to uphold the rights of Epstein's
victims. I wish that the Government had told me that was what was really going on.

38. I saw on the letter that I could call a lawyer. The letter also mentioned Jack Goldberger,
who I knew to be Epstein's attorney, which scared me. I first got in touch with the attorneys at
the Podhurst Orseck firm. My lawyers filed a lawsuit against Epstein for me, which mentioned
that I was abused by Epstein and other powerful people. I was hoping that the information I
gave as part of my lawsuit might help to put Epstein away in prison -- where he belongs. But the
lawsuit ended up just being about money, which Epstein paid to settle.

39. I continued living and, in 2011, was contacted by a journalist, who told me
she was working for a British newspaper. She asked me if I had information about Prince
Andrew. When I said that I did, she came out o meet with me.

40. At this point, since nothing else seemed to be working to get Epstein and his associates
held accountable, I wanted to try by myself to get a message out to the public about what terrible
things Epstein and his friends had done to me and other girls. I was very disturbed about how no
one was prosecuting Epstein for these crimes. I was also very scared. It seemed that law
enforcement was not doing anything with the information they knew about rrg, which left me
and my family more vulnerable and scared.

41. The journalist printed an article using some of the information I told her. Shortly after
the article was published, I talked on the phone to Marie Villafafia, a federal prosecutor from
Florida. I had seen her name on the official letter from the FBI, so she seemed legitimate.
Villafafia seemed very interested in my case and seemed like she really wanted to do something.

42. Within a few weeks of the newspaper article being published, two FBI agents also called
me and then came to meet me. In around March 2011, they met me at the U.S.
Consulat They seemed to be very professional and hard working. I thought to myself
that I ha ma y gotten the attention of the people that I wanted to and that these people would
do the right things against Epstein and the other criminals. I also thought that they could protect
Me.

43. When I met with the agents, they mainly focused on Epstein. But while there, I provided
them some information about some of the others who were involved in illegal acts as well. I was
aware that a false statement to these law enforcement officers was a crime and I told the truth —
giving them the information that I could recall at the time about the individuals they inquired
about.

44. The agents were clearly prepared to meet me and already knew a lot about Epstein's
crimes. The agents appeared to be very good at investigating and seemed like they really knew
how to piece together the whole story. But at the same time, they seemed like they were being
blocked from doing what they wanted to do — which I thought was to arrest Epstein and his
powerful friends for all of their illegal sexual crimes.
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 8 of 28

45. During my interview with the real FBI agents, I told them about my contact from the
purported FBI agent. They did not tell me that it had been a legitimate call from the FBI.

46. The interview I did with these FBI agents was very stressful for me. My meeting lasted
for several hours. It was not easy to talk about all these difficult things, but I went through it. I
was crying at points in the interview. The interview also placed stress on my marriage, because
my husband had to listen to all the terrible things that happened to me. It was difficult for me to
have to discuss being passed around as a sex object among powerful people. It was very hard for
both of us.

47. The agents had come from Florida to meet with me and took my information
which gave me reason to believe that Epstein could still be prosecuted for the crimes he
committed against me. I was not told even at that point that he could not be prosecuted for the
crimes he committed in Florida. I was not told about the CVRA case or that there was any other
option for me to enforce my rights. In fact, by the agents meeting with me I believed I was doing
exactly what I needed to do to enforce my rights and assist in the prosecution.

48. I have seen the Government's recent brief trying to keep me from joining this case. In
that brief, the Government says about at "the Government is aware that petitioners' counsel
have been representing her [that is, me] since at least as early as March 2011." This is
completely untrue, and I think the Government knows it is untrue. I was not represented by legal
counsel in March 2011. The Government has to know that I didn't have an attorney then,
because I didn't have an attorney when I met the agents I don't understand why the
Government is giving false facts to the court.

49. In around 2011, I spoke to attorney Brad Edwards. He told me he hadbeen sued by
Jeffrey Epstein and wanted to know what I knew about Epstein and his associates' involvement
with sexually abusing underage girls. I told him about my abuse and trafficking by Epstein. I
also told him at that time that I had been sexually abused by Prince Andrew, Ghislaine Maxwell,
Jean Luc Brunel, Alan Dershowitz, and other powerful people.

50. In around April 2011, as a follow-up to my earlier call with Brad Edwards, I got a
telephone call from him and another attorney, Jack Scarola. They just wanted general
information about whether various people had information relevant to the lawsuit. They told me
that they were taping the conversation, and I had no problem with that. I cooperated with them
and gave them information about which people had information relevant about Epstein's crimes.
Because it was over the phone and we did not know each other very well, they were very polite
and did not ask me a lot of details about specifically who I had sex with and what sexual
activities I was forced to participate in. It was a general, background interview.

51. As the months following the FBI meetin••assed, I was trying to be patient but
I began wondering what was going on about prosecuting Epstein. I continued to be very
confused about what was happening. I was hoping that some kind of prosecution would come
out of it. But when nothing came of it, I got very upset. I wanted to do something to stop
Epstein and the other people he associates with from sexually abusing girls. Law enforcement
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 9 of 28
had taken my detailed statements, but nothing seemed to be happening. I wasn't sure what to do.
While I wanted to do all that I could to get justice for what had happened to me, it was very hard
for me to figure out how to get something done in the United States while I was living in a
foreign country; especially after I had already gave information to the FBI that I believed they
were using to investigate and eventually arrest Epstein.

52. In October 2013, I returned to the United States for the first time since I had left for
Thailand.
53. In April 2014, I decided to get back in touch with the FBI. the FBI had
seemed like they wanted to be helpful to me, and I have great respect for the FBI agents who met

me. It appeared to me they wanted to do the right thing in this case. But my feeling was once
the agents collected information about crimes committed against me, someone else stepped in
and blocked them from getting charges filed. I also thought that Marie Villafafta really wanted
to do the right thing and hold Epstein accountable for the horrible crimes he committed. But, it
seemed like the hands of Villafafta and the FBI were always tied by someone else with more
authority.

54. I have never been able to figure out who was (and still is) stopping a prosecution. I also
haven't been able to figure out who is trying to stop me from being able to participate in a court
case to a have a judge determine whether my rights have been violated. It doesn't seem fair to
me that the Government can argue that I don't even get the opportunity for a judge review the
issue. To me, this is further verification of Epstein's power, which continues to make me very
scared.

55. I have asked the FBI to show me the video surveillance and other pictures of me that I
believe they have in their possession. They said that I would have to go to the prosecutors to get
them. But the prosecutors will not share anything with me. I believe that the prosecutors have
lots of information that will support what I have been saying about Epstein and his associates.

56. Based on my knowledge of Epstein and his organization, as well as discussions with the
FBI, it is my belief that federal prosecutors likely possess videotapes and photographic images of
me as an underage girl having sex with Epstein and some of his powerful friends. I don't
understand why they aren't moving forward with what the FBI has given to them. I also don't
understand why these pictures haven't been given to me nor why law enforcement officers from
any other jurisdictions have never contacted me.

57. It was not until 2014 that I first understood about the way in which Jane Doe No. 1 and
Jane Doe No. 2 were trying to invalidate the non-prosecution agreement to allow prosecution of
iEpstein for crimes he committed against the and me. I had never really heard anything
iine
significant about this case while I was and it was hard to get information about what
was happening in Florida while I was e I heard about the case, I quickly wanted to
become a part of it.

58. In light of the way everything has played out, I believe that my rights as a crime victim
have been violated. It was never my choice to become the victim of crimes by Epstein and the
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 10 of
people he forced me to have sex with Epstein dragged me into his web when I was very young
and, after that, it was hard for me to escape. After I ran away it appears that Epstein
reached an agreement in 2007 with the federal prosecutors in Florida blocking him from being
prosecuted for the crimes he committed against ire.

59. When Epstein pled guilty to two low level crimes in 2008 as part of his agreement, no
one told me what was happening or that this plea had anything to do with preventing prosecution
of crimes against me or the hundreds of other girls he abused. Nobody told me that I could speak
to the Judge or that a hearing was even taking place.

60. Based on all the facts I have described here, I believe some kind of major cover-up is
going on to protect Epstein. As I look back on what Epstein and his friends have done, I see a lot
of powerful people who knew what they were doing to me and other girls was wrong. But they
also seemed to think that they were above the law and they had nothing to worry about. From
what I can see, that turned out to be true. There are less powerful people -- like the FBI agents
and Marie Villafafia — that seem like they are trying to get the right thing done. But nothing
happens.

61. Because nothing is being done, it makes me think that Epstein was right when he told me
he had so many people in his pocket. Maybe those people are still helping him escape being
prosecuted for what he did against me. The justice system doesn't seem to respond to the
victims in this case. It seems to favor those who have the most money and power and influence.

62. I am also worried that this is a very dangerous circuit. By standing up for what is right,
I'm worried that Epstein, or others named here, will come after me. I wonder where this is going
to go if the United States government is not on my side. I am intent on seeing this through so
that Epstein isn't allowed to hurt other young girls. I can't stop abuse everywhere in the world.
But if I help one victim then I have made a positive difference.

63. In April 2014, I asked two good attorneys - Brad Edwards and Paul Cassell — to see if
they could help me bring Epstein and his friends to justice. They agreed to add me to the
existing case. They explained to me that the lawsuit was not asking to get money from Epstein
or others. I understand and have always understood that the goal of the case is to simply enforce
my rights as a crime victim— rights that were wrongly taken from me.

64. I want Epstein and the others who committed crimes against me to be punished fairly —
the way other less powerful would be. I also want to be added to the suit filed by the two girls,
Jane Doe Number 1 and Jane Doe Number 2, and i want to have rights the way a victim of a less
wealthy and powerful criminal would have.

65. Epstein and his friends sexually and physically abused many other girls. They did this in
many places around the world. I personally observed this. There are also many people who
could confirm what I am saying. I hope that these people will come forward and tell the truth. I
hope that they will call my attorney in Fort Lauderdale, FloridaBrad Edwards - so that all
ofthe information can be presented to the court about what has happened to me and others.
I Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 11 of

66. Because of how often Epstein and others were having sex with young girls, and how
much it was a centerpiece of their lives, I doubt they have just stopped. It also seems to me that,
when I knew them, they believed that they were above the law — too powerful to be prosecuted.
That feeling has no doubt been reinforced by the fact Epstein has escaped real punishment with
his plea bargain, and the others with whom he traveled have completely escaped. I hope that I
can join this case and try to bring them to justice.

67. I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed this S"day of February, 2015. (Location of signature left undisclosed for
security reasons)
JANE DOE 3
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 12 of
EXHIBIT 1
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 13 of
I. H.
J.EPSTEIN
Royal Princess,
■ 188785

• Room No.
Arr. Date
: 923
: 29/09/02
Guest : 1
• Guest Name : DOE 3
• USA
DATE DESCRIPTION
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
08/10
08/10
08/10
08/10
09/10
09/10
09/10
09/10
09/10
09/10
09/10
09/10
09/10
09/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
10/10
11/10
11/10
11/10
11/10
11/10
11/10
11/10
11/10
11/10
11/10
11/10
12/10
12/10
12/10

• 16/10/02 12:51
Page No. : 1
Dept Date : 19/10/02
Cashier : 11 CHFGAGNT03
USA
ROY ESS
Sett along Ma 50100. Thai 044
iatTatliinea 41fre (inning Inuit dims dreamt 119 **Mane ...than nee,. caulud 50100 (4123)Z333 OW 2111-044
seam), 50 14 02527
inthrhiApernfrun 3 10 1 01770 2
CHARGE 1
CREDIT
Room Charges
Service charge 10%
Government Tax
Provincial Tax (Rm)
Room Charges
Service charge 10%
Government Tax
Provincial Tax (Rm)
Room Service 8/F 0923
Minibar 0923 :
Long Distance 0923 : 061923497
Overseas 0923 : 001121275098
Overseas 0923 : 001156179290
Overseas 0923 : 001121275098
Room Charges
Service charge 10%
Government Tax
Provincial Tax (Rm)
Room Service 8/F 0923 : CHECK
Local Call 0923 : 053278900
Overseas 0923 : 001121275098
Overseas 0923 : 001121275098
Room Charges
Service charge 10%
Government Tax
Provincial Tax (Rm)
Long Distance 0923 : 017462088
Long Distance 0923 : 017462088
Long Distance 0923 : 017462038
Long Distance 0923 : 017462088
Overseas 0923 : 001121275098
Overseas 0923 : 001121275098
Laundry/Valet 01699 pia
Room Charges
Service charge 10%
Government Tax
: CHECK 02098
2700.00
270.00
207.90
21.60
2700.00
270.00
207.90
21.60
376.64
120.00
45.00
384.00
177.00
177.00
2700.00
270.00
207.90
21.60
129.47
10.00
177.00
118.00
2700.00
270.00
207.90
21.60
15.00
15.00
15.00
15.00
266.00
59.00
1912.70
2700.00
270.00
207.90
GuesessimmMure
Date
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 14 of
•
•
•

• rill
•
J.EPSTEIN
Royal Princess,
188785 '
Room No. : 923
Arr. Date : 29/09/02
Guest : 1
Guest Name :
, 18/10/02 12:51
Page No. : 2
Dept Date : 19/10/02
Cashier : 11 CHFCIAGN103
IDOE 3
LISA
I USA
utin 36Oadiumn 414 °ammo 111111174147N1etin0futint 40411114
112 ols44001: 142114640: tt.tatn 0.J041:130:00
Int (055) 281-233 Imam (053) 151-044
vutGevomitutsi SO 14 01517
01101417,144111117101111 3 10 1 61770 2
•
•
•
•
DATE DESCRIPTION CHARGE
12/10
12/10
12/10
12/10
12/10
13/10
13/10
13/10
13/10
13/10
Provincial Tax (Rm)
Long Distance $923 : 019980563
Overseas #923 : 001171983648
Overseas 0923 : 001121275096
Overseas #923 : 001121275098
Room Charges
Service charge 10%
Government Tax
Provincial Tax (Rm)
Room Service 8/F 4923 CHECL # 117
21.60
30.00
913.00
30.00
89.00
2700.00
270.00
207.90
21.60
153.01 13/10 Long Distance #923 : 059156556 45.00

• 13/10
13/10
Long Distance #923 : 069156556
Long Distance 0923 : 069156556
30.00
15.00 13/10 Overseas #923 : 001156179290 30.00

• 13/10
13/10
Overseas #923 : 001156124844
Overseas #923 : 001156179045 30.00
560.00 13/10 Overseas #923 : 001156179835 30.00

• 13/10
13/10
Overseas #923 : 001121275098
Overseas #923 : 001156179290 30.00
59.00 13/10 Overseas #923 : 001156179855 384.00

• 13/10
14/10
Overseas #923 : 001156179045
Room Charges 89.00
2700.00 14/10 Service charge 10% 270.00 14/10 Government Tax 207.90 14/10 Provincial Tax (Rm) 21.60 14/10 Room Service 
8/F #923 : CHECK N 129 294.25 14/10
Minibar #923 : 290.00 14/10 Overseas #923 : 001121275098 59.00 14/10 Overseas #923 : 001156130954 59.00 14/10 Overseas 
#923 : 001121275098 59.00 14/10 Overseas
#923 : 001156179290 30.00 15/10 Room Charges 2700.00 15/10 Service charge 10% 270.00 15/10 Government Tax 207.90 15/10 
Provincial Tax (Rm) 21.60 S 15/10 Minibar
#923 : 120.00
•
or
p

100. The
CREDI1
Guest's signalize
Date
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015
Page 15 of
•
ROYAL PRINC
•
•
•
J.EPSTEIN
Royal Princess,
Room No. : 923
Arr. Date : 29/09/02
18/10/02
No. :
Date :
12:51
19/10/02
ttirio saindittten Coin (ammo)
ara737au1u3aindfvraa tit:J.31mi 112 photon; o.thoutu ingot 7+9a 101. (053) 281-033 In10,1: (053) 281 nuOrunninuts4 60 14
02327
isothrhitiabnicaim 3 II/ a 61770 2
sotoo
Page
Dept
Guest : 1 Cashier : 11 CHFGAGNT03

• Guest Name :
USA
DOE 3
• USA
DATE DESCRIPTION CHARGE CREDIT
•
•
•
15/10
15/10
15/10
16/10
16/10
16/10
16/10
16/10
Overseas #923 : 001156179290
Overseas #923 : 001156165548
Overseas #923 : 001121275098
Room Charges
Service charge 10%
Government Tax
Provincial Tax (Rm)
Poolside p.m. 092.3 : CHECK 0 621
796.00
118.00
354.00
2700.00
270.00
207.90
21.60
29.43

• 16/10
16/10
Room Service B/F #923 : CHECK # 143
Room Service 8/F #923 : CHECK a 147
282.48
918.06 16/10 Minibar 0923 : 180.00

• 16/10
16/10
Local Call #923 : 053224979
Overseas #923 : 001121275098
10.00
89.00 16/10 Overseas 0923 : 001121275098 325.00

• 16/10
16/10
Overseas #923 : 001121275098
Overseas #923 : 001121275098
148.00
116.00 16/10 Overseas #923 : 001121275098 295.00

• 16/10
16/10
Overseas 0923 : 001171983632
Overseas #923 : 001156179045
30.00
30.00 16/10 Overseas #923 : 001121275098 59.00

• 17/10
17/10
Room Charges
Service charge 108
2700.00
270.00 17/10 Government Tax 207.90 17/10 Provincial Tax (Rm) 21.60 0 17/10 Room Service 8/F #923 : CHECK #2160 306.02 
17/10 Room Service B/F #923 : CHECK # 161
94.16

• 17/10
17/10
Room Service 8/F $923 : CHECK V 162
Minibar #923 :
94.16
160.00 17/10 Overseas 0923 : 001121275098 30.00

• 17/10
17/10
Overseas #923 : 001121275098
Overseas #923 : 001161974392
148.00
30.00 17/10 Overseas #923 : 001156179045 59.00 17/10 Overseas #923 : 001171983632 471.00 • 17/10 Overseas #923 : 
001121275098 89.00 18/10 Room Charges 2700.00

• 18/10 Service charge 10% 270.00
•
so Gum's signature
Date
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 16 of
WI
It
Tin
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
J.EPSTEIN
Royal Princdts,
188786 '
Room No. : 923
Arr. Date : 29/09/02
Guest : 1
Guest Name :
18/10/02 12:51
Page No.
Dept Date
Cashier
:
: 19/10/02
: 11 CHFGAGNT03
DOE 3
USA
USA
uWn laffetrhatus 41111 (111111114)
sittits4uindadiutva
112 oirsipinv 0.i55nalU OWN 5.1geawd 50100
Int. (053)221-033 InISIE (053)101-044
rrilleigi1471014 50 14 02527
ingt47.7411001‘11,13 3 10 I 61770 2
DATE DESCRIPTION CHARGE CREDIT
18/10 Government Tax
18/10 Provincial Tax (Rm)
18/10 Room Service B/F 11923 : CHECK I 171
18/10 Room Service 8/F #923 : CHECK I 172
18/10 Overseas #923 : 001612974392
18/10 Cash PHET
207.90
21.60
294.25
188.32
207.00
Total including VAT
Total without VAT
Folio amount net
V A T 7.00%
Total
Balance
48687.46
48349.85 8aht
237.60 baht
45424.38 Baht
3163.07 Baht (48349.85)
TAX IO NO. 3 1 0 1 6 1 7 7 0 2
RD NO. 501491. 000235
TAX INVOICE NO. 13489
TAX INVOICE(ABB)
48587.45
48587.45
0.00 baht
Guest's signature
Dale
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 17 of

• ROYAL PRINCESS
XIC7), rail
O 3.EPSTEIN
koyal Princes ,
.O1:5e
u3sio sorroduten Cure (sovieu)
oloillussusa indulge sia.ama 112 nifurni •.iueam pulp. • tenalml 60100
hi: (063)281-033 Imam. (053) 381-044
otigoonmixasd 50 14 02527 ■

• Room No. : 923
Arr. Oate : 29/09/04
finest : 1
Phge No. :
Oar, 19/10/a.
immlutthsialearrGoth% 3 10 1 01770 2
Guest Name : DOE 3
•
O
[OATS
USA
Ot:SCR1PTION CHAR
2.9/0.9 Ro•:m Charges 2700.00
24/09 Service charge JO*. 270.00

• 29/09
29/09
Govermnent Tax
Provincial Tax (Rog
207.50
21.60
29/09 Overseas 8923 : 001166179290 118.00

• 90/09 Room Charges 2700.00
30/09 Service charge 10% 270.00
30/09 Oovtrnment 1Lx 207.90
30/09 Provincial Tax (Rni)
30/09 Overseas 0923 : OO11t.6O929O 732.,
30/09 Overseas 8923 : 0011/1933632 30.

• 30/09 Overseas #92a : OO11719£:30.48 922.0.!
30/09 Overseas 0923 : 0011661790.1$ 30.00
:10/09 Overseas 0923 : 001191252031 30.00

• 30/09
30/09
Overseas 0923 : 0011S617904S
Overseas 8923 : 00111.6)
30.00
326.00
01/10 Room Charges 2700.00

• 01/10 Service charge 10% 220.00
01/1.0 Government Tax 201.90
01/10 Provincial Tax (Rm) 21.60
45 01/10 Oiversii,as 0923 : 001.P.,61/)...A ?0.00
01/10 Oven.cos 0929 : 0(1111.11)/wl90 325.00
01/10 Overs•rs 0923 : 0011%119200 266.00

• 01/10 Overseas 0923 .59.00
02/10 Roca) Charges 2200.00
02/10 Service charge lot 270.00
OC/10 Government Tax 207.90
0;111.1 Provintial Tax (Exit) 11.60
02/10 Poolside s.m. 8923 5%4.9G
(7 02/10 Pool side p.m. C929
02/10 Pcolside p.m. 8923 123.3z
02/10 Kinitial 0929 : 110.00

• 01/10 Overseas 8.923 : 001156179296 30.00
03/10 Room Charges 2700.00
03/10 Saivice charge 10%
• 0j/10 Government Tax 2/7.
•

• Guest's signature
Date
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 18 of
ROYAL PRINCESS
O

• 1.EPSI:
40 Room No.
Arr. Pate
Guy-'
•
•
Guts' _
: 29/09/02
Page Mo. :
Oept Oato : 19/10/C_
Call lien : la
DOE 3

50100. ?is
1847111i/111101 tyre (rangy)
rarriTirusanotTarliuto 11 1004111a
I)? o,#wtaitt p.iwneni IMOD. tall thii 60100

(053) 211-033 bvern: (053) 251-044
nrultrontafrosit so 14 02527
Utt111:541111i0Mg5101 3 10 I 51220 2
•
DA1E fiES(:R1P1)Of
--- 03/10 Provincial Tax (Ro)
03/10 OVelftivi. 0923 : 00111.6179290
03/10 Overseas 4921 : 001156179046
03/J0 Overtea$ : 00111.G171:290
04/10 Room Charges
04/10 Service charge Jot
- -
20/.00
2/00..
270.00 04/10 Government lax
04/10 Provincial lax (k40 2.

• 04/10 Poolstde p.m. 4923 : GRECN 4 606
0.1/10 (Rh: neat. 4923 : 0011F:5179290
04/10 Overseas R923 : 0011561./92'M

• 04/10 Oversvac 491,d : 0011!.617c;:q;
OI/10 Room Charges 2700.00 05/10 StirViCf charge 10t 270.00 • nb/to Government Tax 207.90
05/10 Provincial Tax (NGO 21.60 05/10 Local Call 4923 : 10.00 • 01410
05/10
Local C011 4923
OV1I2e.?4:: 4923 : '0011604.10615
10.00
1164.00 05/10 Over.w.as 4923 : 001156179290 432.09 • 05/10 Overseas 11923 : 001156179290 1884.00 05/10 Oversett 4923 : 
1031.00 06/10 Room Charges 2700.00

• 00/10
06/10
Sc.rvice charge U):
Government Tax
270.00
207.90 06/10 Provincial *PA 21.60 • 06/10
06/10
Poolside p.m.
Poolcide t231'.2,
353.10
3/6.64 05/10 Local Call 4923 10.00
40 06/JO
07/10
OVelf.f6c. 1'19.23 : 0011E.6
Room Charges
59.00
2700.00 07/10 Service charge 1.053 v70.00
07/10 6overoment rax 207.90
07/10 Provincial *lay 21.60
07/10 Miniear 41616 pi ; 220.00 • 07/10 Long DisLanci 15.00
Guest's signature _
Date
11 I
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 19 of
et.
410 1, ROYAL PRINCESS
50100, re.;..:
ultin ladadfuraa 414 (wily)
invitneuriairnliutee dwlwJ 112 0.thalou raluntnu .Z:4 • rhillia 60200
bo: (063)211-033 bon,: (063) HI -044
raiCUunTioriat SO IT 03527
otellitimlWlionniewo 3 10 I 61770 2
GuE.tt Nam.?
f:41E
: DOE 3
tISA
Fairil
I •
•
-
07/10 Ov3rseJ".; 492..; : 20/.00 07/10 Oversca VS;r:i len:;0.00 07/10 OvuirLfll 0923
07/10 0/er5.eLs :
0'3/10 Oler.r.eat r
Guest's signature
Date
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 20 of
ROYAL PRINCESS
J.EPSTEIN
Royal Princess, , 19/10/02
Room No. : 923 Page No. :
Arr. Date : 29/09/02 Dept Date :
Guest Cashier :
Guest Name : DOE 3
USA
13:07
19/10/02
11 CHFGAGNTO3
USA
(DATE
18/10 Room Service B/F #923 : CHECK II 171
18/10 Room Service 8/F #923 : CHECK # 172
18/10 Long Distance #923 : 098181318
18/10 Long Distance #923 : 098183189
18/10 Overseas #923 : 001612974392
18/10 Overseas #923 : 001612974392
18/10 Overseas #923 : 001156184460
19/10 Room Service B/F #923 : CHECK # 163
19/10 Minibar
DESCRIPTION
:Ming Mil 501N. I1LM:a
ulna lailetButva dui,, (uwnsu)
ntailltululatraefutan
nt atheulu stilton a Oat • ,i3ealbl soma hi: (053)281-033 hum: (053) 281-044
r--LCtrunnornity4 so 14 02527
oath: iisNigarrtgaini 3 10, 81770 2
CHARGE CREUIT I
294.25
188.32
15.00
60.00
207.00
384.00
883.00
400.18
220.00
Total including VAT
Folio amount net
V A T 7.00%
TAX 10 NO. 3 1 0 1 6 1 / 7
RO NO. 5 0 1 4 9 1 0 0 .0
TAX INVOICE(A88)
t
Total
Balance
. 2
2651.75
2651.75 Bahl.
tot (2651.75)
Guest's signature
Date
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 21 of
EXHIBIT 2
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 22 of
£ 3OO
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 23 of
gs►cramRs►:raa.iP cii4i141Ingtoratoi
inn them.. snuifir win nor nen con Cm won no an norm
CHICKIN • imdinn don Naw ka an -arc Iglu a SO non nrowins t. nos
InCOKIRLI ton min w canna Son • ta Nan kr coann we 72 Pr. kr cannon 'Mn la annonera Fawn oennicni al Dann all nun rowan'
Pronnin a neon Cann Ann on*, in as Inns
OnFona

k. tons rni kr al Stat a'  cunt urn TA Y. Inn a Own nap non
DCI  CPO PROCTIONn. WU • Yr Cosner boa non ca.M onnona Ann. nrA ken. 0, ?neve one 'an. in wen ana ass, awry II *Yammer 
On. ^mon Orona
1 2W-ELT IW VMOII 1µy &arca Na' It Non so en Fri N Iv 'rS no et Frown kr ON COW role Na ON Orr.* lor inrral nano' (0 
rind day Iran try not I ran
0 IN nen. inn; nil n nen Inn, ru 'on; at .a me co a' an/can aN man Peer.
TOM • Cannes a tan nets at  C.  NVr!b ine mit IOC now or fend kir na t.  re Ia  on Mx Is nap no no IS  Cano lotanossa 
saw nand tan non
Knew on wan ovine cr oaneta, araal retina ern a OW rm. COMM rat, rat Non so, no pm en n  c an Finny 21  Pan ,Or ray non 
72 tan Inlin rat
IM0WINfIll rw an so own wow cr ran. ant to cons win nos ccronn Wan in FM tut t Miry Ill nano,
on • to col ball run ,  Dici rtu net Fun bra non `Cr ken non It lo%ccrcnr Ionaonc an a tvr ra nun ray now Saw 55 wor a 
sawn Ronan n now nen onnen ornery au to
cast lo Finn
cause" os ism • TN, *Law kw" I. anp a  wiry...an a a. nary to 'upon 1, Maw wean tenter; mormakm. rbcdfrce man* Ira an in
Senn IMard Skinn tr. Os Or arr. 1/4 10,
sonar w.Ityl, ninan% b/\ ern Wit, inn Tier Ant. nein Ma MN b mire. Inn?. C4 ern° ny inner warm, linnineerralon an pot :I
sac, Finn On roc* F
to
Pon Ono. or Ionian or re bra Cicnrannt erre. Urn Inn - Starre WO:rah, end in nit," cart lans. Pro a MSS Char. an sie not
wenn an Clupon ran Wenn ra nonncce•
7.'M Wan nanrannw Conn en bar WM ccmommennecitirm a.m. &V an SOrinoni On KV An learn n cant &ern., re Pe el mirror nntp 
prink This Inn Any Imor Or ran fon run
to Sold ran  erg slincon cr Inn wen nen anon In - wenn nit" Na. Yawn C.  RIK. , CI Infer Inn. Lan Intro o Facinon 
Connlen Conlon.. Cant< Llawnons, local Inn In
n  sr Ike Gonna.
It.
intr. Anna
WE IITWONGOCELOPPWID • on.11 rano,.

n. I SHOPPERS TRAVEL, INC. SHOPPERS:TRAVEL AGENT RS/RS BOOKING REF ZXLL07 303 5TH AVENUE
NEW YORK NY10016
212 779 8800
J EPSTEIN
457 MADISON AVE
4TH LOOR
NEWYORK NY 10027 corr. Vi I PArtrini V
ARRAN! FIT CL DATE
DATE: SEP 27 2002
DOE 3
TERMS: PAYMENT DUE UPON PRESENTATION
RECORD
FROM TO
SINGAPORE AIRLINES 27SEP NEW YORK NY SINGAPORE SQ 25 Q FRI JOHN F KENNEDY CHANGI NON SMOKING TERMINAL 1 TERMINAL
MEAL
RESERVATION CONFIRMED NEW YORK FRANKFURT
FRANKFURT SINGAPORE
AIRCRAFT: BOEINGi7477400
SINGAPORE AIRLINES 29SEP iINGAPORE BANGKOK SQ 62 Q SUN OHANGI BANGKOK INTL NON SMOKING ITERMINAL 2 TERMINAL 2
41:: IERVATION C441FIRMr-41AIRCRAFT:IDDEING 747-400.
THAI AIRWAYS INTL
DO 110
NON SMOKING
HOTEL
LV AR
945P 635A
2°SEP
1 STOP
20r50 DURATION
850A 1010A
NON STOP
2:20 DURATION
--BANOKOK CHIANG MAI 1215P 125P 8ANdkOK INTL INTERNATIONAL
c TERMINAL, BUM
NON STOP *RESERVATION CONFIRMED 1:10 DURATION AIRCRAFTs'AIRPU ," INDO5TRIE AO00-600/600C
21*EP;'RbMAL  PRINCESS GH4AWMAI
tscpc4,44,....4 ghat,
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 24 of
I.
'SHOPPERS TRAVEL, INC. SHOPPERS TRAVEL AGENT RS/RS BOOKING REF ZXLLO7
303 5TH AVENUE
NEW YORK NY1OO16
212 779 8800
J EPSTEIN
457 MADISON AVE
4TH FLOOR
NEWYORK NY 10027
DATE: SEP 27 2002
DOE 3
RECORD
TERMS: PAYMENT DUE UPON PRESENTATION
SINGAPORE AIRLINES 27SEP NEW YORK NY SINGAPORE 945P 635A
SQ 25 a FRI JOHN F KENNEDY CHANGI 29SEP
NON SMOKING TERMINAL 1 TERMINAL 2
MEAL 1 STOP
RESERVATION CONFIRMED 20150 DURATION
NEW YORK FRANKFURT
FRANKFURT SINGAPORE
AIRCRAFT' BOEING 747-400
SINGAPORE AIRLINES 29SEP SINGAPORE BANGKOK 85OA 1O1OA
SQ 62 Q SUN CHANGI BANGKOK INTL
NON SMOKING TERMINAL 2 TERMINAL 2
MEAL NON STOP
RESERVATION CONFIRMED 2:20 DURATION
AIRCRAFT: BOEING 747-400
THAI AIRWAYS INTL 29SEP BANGKOK CHIANG MAI 1215P 125P
TO 110 Y SUN BANGKOK INTL INTERNATIONAL
NON SMOKING TERMINAL DOM
AIRCRAFT:
NON STOP
RESERVATION CONFIRMED 1110 DURATION
AIRBUS INDUSTRIE ASOO-6OO/6OOC
HOTEL 29SEP ROYAL PRINCESS
19OCT
TELEX' NONE
CONFIRMATION' 102520345
REFERENCE* AO3AOO
SINGLE ROOM TWIN BED
RATES COR THB 2700.00 PER NIGHT
8IWARANTEE GIVEN
:priN C a iLrA &SON POI, Iche 1
AtIV 16OO 22SEP2OO2 LOCAL PROPERTY TIME
VISIT OUR SITE HTTPfiwwwshopperstravel.com • E-Mail: Info@shopparstravel.com
303 FIFTH AVENUE • SUITE 1007 • NEW YORK, N.Y. 10016
TEL (212) 779-8800 • FAX (212) 779-8397
NEW JERSEY TEL (732) 2874300
THANK YOU PLEASE RECOtfIRM RJOHIS AW IMES e4 CASE Di SOEDULE CHANGES
- 24 HOUR PRIOR FOR DOMES= TRAVEL- 72 HOURS PRC44 FOR HIERMATIORAL TRAVEL
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 25 of
SHOPPERS TRAVEL, INC. SHOPPERS TRAVEL AGENT RS/R$ BOOKING REF ZXLLO7
303 5TH AVENUE
NEW YORK NY1OO16
212 779 8800 IDOE 3
J EPSTEIN
457 MADISON AVE • TERMS: PAYMENT DUE UPON PRESENTATION
4TH FLOOR
NEWYORK NY 10027 RECORD A
DATE: SEP 27 2002 •
THAI AIRWAYS INTL 19OCT BANGKOK 315P 425P
TO 113 y SAT L BANGKOK INTL
NON SMOKING TERMINAL DOM
' 1 ' NON STOP
RESERVATION.CONFIRMED 1:10 DURATION
AIRCRAFT: AIRBUS INDUSTRIE A3OO-6OO/6OOC
SINGAPORE AIRLINES 19OCT BANGKOK SINGAPORE
SQ 67 Q SAT BANGKOK INTL CHANGI
NON SMOKING TERMINAL 2 TERMINAL 2
MEAL
RESERVATION CONFIRMED
AIRCRAFT: BOEING 747-400
63OP 955P
NON STOP
2:25 DURATION
SINGAPORE AIRLINES 19OCT SINGAPORE NEW YORK NY 115OP 1O4OA
SQ 26 0 SAT CHANGI JOHN F KENNEDY 2OOCT
NON SMOKING TERMINAL 2 TERMINAL 1
NEAL i STOP
-RESERVATION CONFIRMED 22:50 DURATION
SINGAPORE FRANKFURT
FRANKFURT NEW YORK
AIRCRAFT: BOEING 747-400
AMERICAN AIRLINES 2OOCT NEW YORK NY MIAMI FL
AA 1701 , -N puN JOHN F KENNEDY MIAMI INTL
'NON SMOKING TERMINAL
MISCELLANEOUS
25OP 6O4P
NON STOP
RESERVATION CONFIRMED 3:16 DURATION
AIRCRAFT: POEINO 757-200/300
27JUL CHIANG MAI
SUN SHOPPERS TRAVEL
RESERVATION NUMBER(S) AA/DFNKAZ SQ/JC5MU4 TG/L2QHI4
THIS TICKET IS NONREFUNDABLE/NONCHANGEABLE
PENALTY MAY APPLY FOR ANY CHANGE/CffNCELLAJJON
CHECKIN 2 -HOURS BEFORE SCHEDU1BED DEPARTURE
WE SUGGEST YOU C-0043 ,40040§04 RMR Weir°
velcom RECONFIRM Rumpw4.4 tloo Item,
INTERNATIONAL TRAVEL MAYTREgKRERASSRRRA1 ,5.4697
IT IS iOUR.RESPONSIBILITY TAINOMBEKTIWIPAT 300
THANK YOU
•
CASF FIECONFTR9 FUWTS NC TIMES el CASE OF SCHEDULE CHANGES,
— 24 HOUR PRIOR FOR OCNESPC TRAVEL - 72 HOURS PRIOR FOR NTERHATIONAL TRAVEL
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 26 of
SHOPPERS TRAVEL, INC. SHOPPERS TRAVEL
303 5TH AVENUE
NEW YORK
J EPSTEIN
457 MADISON AVE
424 FLOOR
NEWYORK NY 10027
NY10016
212 779 8800
DATE: SEP 27 2002
AGENT RS/RS BOOKING REF ZXLL07
I DOE 3 I
RECORD
TERMS: PAYMENT DUE UPON PRESENTATION
CONSULATE ABOUT YOUR VISA TO THE COUNTRIES YOU
ARE TRAVELLING/TRANSITTING
SHOPPERS TRAVEL,INC IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR TICKETS
LOST, OR DELAYED IN THE MAIL
***PLEASE CARRY A VALID PHOTO ID****
THANK YOU.WE KNOW THAT YOU HAVE A CHOICE AND
WE APPRECIATE YOU CHOOSING SHOPPERS TRAVEL,INC
VISIT OUR WEB SITE AT WWW.SHOPPERSTRAVEL.COM
HAVE ,`A NICE TRIP
VISIT OUR SITE HTTP.//wwwshopperstravel.com • E-Mail; InFo@shopperstravelcom
303 FIFTH AVENUE • SUITE 1007 • NEW YORK, N.Y. 10016
TEL (212) 779-8800 • FAX (212) 779-8397
NEW JERSEY TEL (732) 2874300
THANK YOU PLEASE RECONFEM RJGHTS Alt Tee PI CASE OF SCHEDULE CHANGES
- 24 HOUR PR/Cfl FCR DOMESTIC TRAWL - 72 HOURS ERICA FOR INIERNMIONAL TRAVEL
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 27 of
Please check your documents when you receive them Call us il you
have any questions
2 CHECK•IN - Minimum check-In Imo for domestic flights ei 60
minutes and for internationni flights. 2 hoofs.
3 RECONFIRMATION. - Reconfirm the use and time of flights al least
24 hours for domestic and 72 hours for international. Reconfirmation
is mardatory in Florida. Canada. Mexico, Hawaii and all international
desthations Failure to use any reservations may resift idautomatic
cancellation of all continuing and return reservations.
EXCURSION ANO PROMOTIONAL. FARES - Most discountfams
involve curtain restrictions. A change in carrier(sk Rightist. times) or
routing(s) could result in n ("Alter demanding a lull fare Obtain
agency or airtineaSeStamar before malting any changes
5 If your plans change enroute, apply the value of your betties toward
a reissued ono. It Is not necessary 10 purchase a new ticket It. a
( refund is due, obtain a receipt from the airline
6 These times, flights and tares are based on current tariffs that are
sub-Axel to change without notice

7. TICKETS - Cancelled or unused tickets must be returned forproper
credit lo your account ost, stolen or destroyed tickets must be paid
for until refund is received from the Issuing caner. subject to an
airline imposed service charge

8. HOTELS are usually confirmed on a guaranteed payment basis II
you cancel or change plans. please nobly your hotels) warm the
time period specified by that hotel
9. TOUR/PACKAGE PRICES are subject to change vnthout notice due
to currency fluctuations. tariff changes or increase in operational
costs. In addition, group tourspackages are based on a Minimum
Number of passengers travelling. if the number of passengers falls
below the minimum required. a surcharge eery be imposed on nit
passengers.
10 ItaPORTANTel II you arrive at an airline ticket or passenger check
in counter with your confirmed ticket and find that the airline shows
no reservation for you --do not leave the counter. Check your ticket.
If the statue box shows 'OK' for the eight in question, the airline must
accommodate you on thal flight. or II that is not possible. they must
either find you a substitute fight or pay you denied boarding compen
shtion. If necessary ask to speak to a supervisor.
t We newts We rile to are- i.r.kessing fees et the tivis.l or
refunds. r incellntions iir :pea: tier ,-ces
12 DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY -- Thls Travel Agency Is acting as a
mere agent for suppliers in selling travel-relaled services, or in
accepting reservations or bookings for services that are not di-
rectly supplied by this travel agency (such as air and ground
transportation, hotel accommodations, meals, tours, cruises, etc.).
This agency therefore, shall not be responsible for breach of
contract or any intentional or carolessections or omissions on pan
of such suppliers. which result in any loss, damage, delay, or injury
fo you or your travel companion-, or group members-. Unless the
term `guaranteed" Is specifically stated In writing on your tickets,
Invoice or reservation Itinerary, we do not guarantee any of such
suppliers rates, bookings,reservations, connections, scheduling,
or handling of personal effects. Travel agent shall not be respon-
sible tor any kiln Ms, damages, or losses caused to any traveler In
connection with terrorist fie-plies social or labor unrest, me-
chanical or construction failures or difficulties, diseases, local
laws Climatic conditions, criminal acts or abnormal conditions or
developments, or any other actions, omissions, or conditions
outside the travel agent's control. Traveler assumes complete and
full responsibility for. and hereby releases the agent from any duty
ol, checking and verifying any and all passport, visa, vaccination,
or other entry requirements of each destination, and all safety or
security conditions al such destinations, during the length of the
proposed travel. For Information concerning possible dangers at
International destinations, contact the Travel Advisory Section of
the U.S. Slate Deportment. For medical information, cell the Public
Health Service. By embarking upon his her travel, the traveler
voluntarily assumes all risks Involved In such travel, whether
expected or unexpected. Traveler I, hereby warned of such risks,
and is advised to obtain appropriate insurance coverage against
them. Traveler's retention of tickets, reservations, or bookings
after Issuance shall constitute a consent to the above, and an
agreement on his her part to convoy the contents hereto to hIslher
travel companions or group members.
13 Proof of Identity n requ rod rot international travel Wal mut proper
Identification, a precis:tort anti etc.0511aly vises you will not he wink
led to depart. It lc your responsinarty to verily your necessary navel
documents
WE STRONGLY RECOMM-ND I RAVEI. INSURANCE.
WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW ABOUT THE POSSIBILITY OF AIRLINE BANKRUPTCIES.
Hopefully I here will not be any more airline bankruptcies, but it has to be recognized Thal they might oc ur You Ir. 
know how they might affect you
I II an airline declares bankruptcy. it is not obligated to carry you or to
refund tickets issued before the bankruptcy
2 Travel agents are not allowed to refund tickets on airlines which have
declared bankruptcy. Money given to a travel agent mmediatoly
becomes the property of the airlines and we ere required by laws to
complywith the airlines' orders
3 If an airline °edam. b in.ruprry it might c ontinue aennce, timii
service, or stop oompict.,:y ti!lo.terettnee might errept passengers
under united circumstan, ups.yre'ute to a-x.ept tine passengers
from the defaulted one -.
4 Meanwhile there are fin- treVO: inst.rarce plan-available torpassen
gems to protect Meal In Cl/41 of trim • bankruptcies
IMPORTANT NOTICE
This agency and es agents have endeavored to secure the lowest puss Lie faro, suitable for your travel requirements, 
based on space available nt the time
of booking, accessible sources of information, and knowtedge of agents involved.
This agency cannot guarantee, in view of the deregulation of airline fares. that the fare indicated on ticket will be 
the lowest possible fare at departure
dale.
Peluso contact this agency before departure it you wish to rer.heck any newly Introduced faro. that may correspond with 
your spocilin travel requirements.
PLEASE NOTE that retention of tickets, reservations or bookings after issuance shall ronsttlute a.,,ci-mwsa of ail 
Iraprovisions in the conditions listed
hereto, as well as those terms and conditions set forth in the announcements and cinaarr of the exMpackatre, cruise of 
service
Case 9:08-cv-80736-KAM Document 310-1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/06/2015 Page 28 of
General List: Your Travel Check List His Check List: Her Chock List:
❑ Tickets ❑ First Aid supplies 0 Bathing trunks : Belts
❑ Passport O Camera and film O Beach jackets Blouses
0 Vaccination certificate
❑ Wallet
C Clock
E Clothesline and clips
❑ Cuff links, tie clasp
Gloves
n7 Coat
Casuistic supplies i t
❑ Travolors chocks C Comb Handkerchiefs, scarves Drosses .!
❑ Itinerary 0 Deodorant Hat 7: GI yes
❑ Reservations o Needles and thread Pajamas : . Handbag, dress and travel
❑ Phonu numbers ❑ Plastic bags ❑ Raincoat or topcoat r: Hats
O Prescriptions (duplicates) O Robe Hose
0 ❑ Safety pins O Scarf E jewelry
0 0 Soap, laundry and bath O Shaving supplies ❑ giver cr
0 Spot remover 0 Shirts O Rgincoat and boots
❑ Suntan lotion O Shoes socks ❑ Hate or beach coiit
❑ Tooth brush ❑ Slacks ❑ Scarf, ha datchlets
❑ ❑ Tooth paste 0 Slippers or thongs 3 Sipes, dress end walking
❑ O Umbrella C Suits (ono dark for Livening) .0 Shower cap
O
a Calling cards
❑ Business literature
Ties
Underwear
Slippers, scuffs, or beach thongs
&rim suit
a 0
O Pen and paper
Addresses and stamps
❑ Glasses C
Sweaters
Suiie
❑ Modicinos El
❑ Aspirin
Sun glasses
EFTA00186431 (Jmail)
 [money] 159 pages of documents related to finances etc.
(inferred date: 2026-01-28)
159 pages of documents related to finances etc.
EFTA02731361 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2026-01-28)
Close your eyes close your eyes close your eyes. Dont speak she doesnt talk.
I cant stop shaking and its been a week.
A decision was made but I cant tell Jeffrey.
These things happen. Why didnt I close my eyes fast enough.
The doctor was different again.
I think from Israel. He had kind eyes but didnt speak directly to me.
This was different.
A shot and those rod like things had a hook and so much pain.
Ghislaine said to push all the pain away. I don't understan 0.N ie
Blood and water all over the bed and she was right. \ (it s
1 1Like a feeling when your tummy hurts and yo puslc r (04
tiny cries.
I am so lost.
I saw between her fingers 's tiny hea
and had a tiny foot.
I closed my eyes and no more.. (ne age)
ask
She said to close my eyes and put her ha y eeit I didnt close them because of these
dy in the doctors hands. It reached its tiny arm up
I
I
I
I
■
I
■
I
I
co 0 Ns\ S y1/4i t& c,o , or S.o4 p ct octa l
I 3 )i ti e,coe or 15 Ni\)e-ebnse. .hden+1
tat-i-pmcnacit bc2, ue.K. dc,36 t e q 0+O
cl\SoS Y \ \ Qi" " A
,Scry hsfi ghpe Wyin i ts me.erseog Te
tfe-T tehnstkpr -h c ia-coe y y 501 nuti,h
dcows iCrnaGn.ti kr n1Sal. ea grit b+ in
0+ e ad{e,e4 sl I hnTo I
reHhd  d y...atucldf
Se,K; Ova e.hs a die et st .e\ l x.scin ehnsaq
podrcl 4oTivi S iirnils\rn&V•eot
hind
....-kNe .
ho ado vhart.IISQ113 <b<Gt<tps a a f Yi4neSed. 4
OKI\ MC I G 't I le \ tzej Wy. d ou rin
f oolit ‘tke toe. , (<3 vi ; 1 h s ib Lica
ck tot tse e94. it
load Ceti O/ el*
etnvr
e '19 Y1%1
4m1 via clA°Shv-i- PS SeadoIsm eeoduhr
oruPortesrat ouh.hs i 4coe y y 5 nri
hnsv  4(esQ n I inco ebineas o -ite i yre 1 01,
a joeme`eodcidt i s t e bcuerfisinciSsas
15 la b-4 n effnetsinsiY ed n bdi e rhn3
0+. 5*1 evithei3ri i In ha a ci o ynhcico$god
vohcii 4nariPn hoi +n c o t ' sd yvSnnmr
aaiyat.coeme eado 0

cries.
I dont understand.
Just say these things happen.
But he doesnt believe that.
They yelled and screamed and he said it will be the same in a couple of months and she said she
was fed up with it all.
I dont understand what is going on and no one will tell me.
I cant go to school like this.
I cant stop shaking.
Why wont anyone make it stop.
O
I know Ghislaine is trying but nothing changest < QAA
Why didnt I close my eyes?
O Ca
-
-
-「’
捌
’‘凹“・引司超燉凶些k
ン<
一
ご>
フ
G
、
~
一
・
.プー
-一--
Lノ、
-,
.
oc 一o3 っづp Q プ 功 一/ ゅ p ( 9 心
つ‘(カ 9 つ CQ ^ 十 っ レ/ 力 < 「馴f判l凵汀一・!ll ‘ー !
^ ~ ( 0 ¥ つ四u pQ ・ニ ト P 一 弋 い 厂尢 心 」一冖哂 。+ @Q 吻山
q 内 冖プ?・づ 嫩 @一弘 フ い ①3g つ プ 叨-
@(く 「 p → ^ x 《m 9 Q ( ロ @ Q 4 冖 QQ
qQ 心● つ ゆ 六 ノ っ M ① 9 〕 づ 芝 吻冖 c 毛寺 一 °
め乏く ° ヲ プ 口 9
9 。 十 「 品 ^ 9 つ
切了。
rQ 一
{、
う
{f
)一‘
瀑孩(
7 -
-4-~ Q ・→-
-o
づ
‘フ
ー’
q
-.
つ
口-
<t cv
蚕 (乃 @ <、 つ ‘渝
、命-
オ -レ
ー
丘
《
プ+
-
~ づ切3 一
す + 冖 ④ @「
一● ユコ
ー
◎+

In the ball Ghislaine said she was beautiful.
SHE WAS.
Not is.
She was a beautiful Wilt
I beard hurl
Where is she?
Why did she stop whimpering?
She was bon!
I heard the lino trip!
I cant do this anymore!
2 SQ,autklikkgellledtt
1-43buic e
vie,e5h NANlise-i -rnele:\ 91.
he 15e° hddhsaWl prn
A Short Life
fliGEDV
ra4
ImY Heart
born
These poems do not live: its a sad diagnosis.
They grew their toes and fingers well enough,
Their linleforeheads bulged with eoncentratien.
If they missed out on walking about like people
It wasn't-for any lack onnother-love.
0 I cannot understand what happened to diem!
0They are proper in shape and number and ev-gvt.
They sit so nicely in the pickling fluid!
They smile and smile and smile and N,41'".. CO And still the lungs won't fili and th w n'tzt. ,(:</
They are not pigs, they are n
Though they have a piggy
It would be better _ft
But tt..._...Thsy_Tr_LWad, a
And they stupa.A.
O.\''' '4 r.‘..
.se .../
‘....)
It ?, ci k h5a iS e
'Y\ h G i 1,z .  d 11
,tse‘ ii<RE 5.
ana  i.1. 1 IA .SA .110 i
whatIthey were}
with distraction,
k of her.
‘dri
born 1 I
had V\ k- C S.
iak•olisnolc".
(A(141 (110 e,
He was right.
A couple of months and two pink lines with a hold on being with others until after it was positive.
I want to die.
Why didnt she protect me?
As long as I am wearing what you want. There is no respect for me as a human.
I am nothing but your property and incubator!
t
.
Nal You only trust me when I am under your complete CONT N I nsI o,
I will never trust another man EVER!
I am the only one who provides and sacrifice TA
ic )I give and give out of terror and you &1/4  off
//
m ✓ a
You need me to continue...Keep
01
"I.
A promise to respect your sense of style, most of the time.
R
P. • • • :" fl U a '1",
. i 5h l Ov,/n -r
r"AaVg 1 PI : ,,nbt•cf l'?
e 8 'p 0\ rt. (., e. . . .,j 0 1 v ? 0
, A promise one clay you'll ....;40pot.. 4n. kri this trusting.? \oi ;'; t--
, . .
0 o i , „ , <,(, ,k • ; - . c 1- C
\ .1 l F. • 0 . ,. ( <0"
A promisKs, vide for you, no matter what. Gt
I fit 11 0 1 14„,....q1S. 1 ? 0 V e (Ada IN i.: c 5 V k -C . (.7 !
0, 1-e. IY740 (*vck)n, c i le E el 'di N ip .....
It ktok- Ce i'(‘Y\ \Iuctel- 0 01
c1( <1C i e. k.t04r0u d U i• 'kJ\ L .0

[clipping: Unlike drugs, a child's body can be sold over and over]
This is not surprising but there is no such thing as a child prostitute!
They are children and cannot consent!
They are missing the biggest in my own backyard and so many more!
Like Maralago and where I see Mr. Joe and Mrs. Anne.
I
I
I I a
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
our finance department - deals with all the paperwork.
Unfortunately thestiliance
department is also
Who Knew? cr
life in a P nixes
.ike drugs. a woman's body can he sold over and over
0 r-Sq' in"The slaves ic-/
Lake Placid wer
invisible.... Pe
were playa
at the rde, ent
communitrind right
behind them was
a slave camp."
t?ne U.S. shelter has rescued 10.000 chi k pl, 4.1%jltr
Sociologist Lois Lee. right. has spent 24 years working with children from II to 17 years old
who've been trafficked by pimps. One young resident. left. at her Children of the Night shelter in southern
California was forced to work as a prostitute in Oregon. Washington. Idaho. and Nevada before escaping
her captor. "The sexual exploitation of American children cuts across every economic. ethnic. and
social line.- Lee says. "This is not just a Third World problem."
Please release me from this torture and hell!
\Z S../<</C0
•
1
The headline below is not a
metaphor. This story is about
slaves. Not people living like
slaves, working hard for lousy
pay..Not people 200 years ago.
Ifg about 27 million people
worldwide who are bought and
sold, held captive, brutalized,
exploited for profit. it's about
2 NATION," r 1111 n it _0O1
release (ri-les') v. -leased, -leas•ing. 1. to set
free from confinement, restraint, or involuntary servi-
tude. 2. To set free. 3. To allow the performance, sale,
publication, or circulation of. 4. To relinquish. —n. 1.
The act of liberating, releasing. 2. A device for lock-
ing or releasing a mechanism. 1< Lat. relaxare. to
relax.] —re•leas'a•ble adj. —re4eas'er n.
Controlled ALL by Jeffrey!
All the time!
Get away from it all.
And go to New Mexico? What in the hell?
This makes no sense. What about school?
Behind the scenes.
He is now controlling EVERYTHING when it used to be Ghislaine who so
hates me.
Secrets of.. all of them.
I am tired of keeping this secret.
I know people are wondering but I can't tell!
4 I am exhausted! /
c & N1
QBroken promises...I don't understate g me on some days like Im the enemy but
then we lay in bed together and
cts like she
He makes her feel my to
Superior gene pool ?!? Wh e?
Why my hair color and eye color?
o be, warm.
and its s confusing.
es no sense.
That feels very Nazi like in 'nk[ing] about these stupid insane theories he has I guess in his V o3/4.
mind it makes sense.
The piano and omments are made to convince me this is right and will create perfect
offspring het
I dont thinkirks that way and its making me hate playing altogether.
Piano or viola. I am starting to resent them both.
I miss the person I was before I was made into what feels as a human incubator.
SPECIAL NUTRITION
superior
Gene Pool
Ea= from it all
A
(-*
BEHIND THE SCENES
= <RCO
4\-\
=
Secrets of ci
o
ni 111 0 11till
mi
My friend realized much of everything and came to get me out of Marys.
She made me leave all things of value on the bed.
She put all my belongings in trash bags.
I have maybe avoided NM.
I have been staying with friends but never more than two or three nights because my mo er is on
the war path.
have been so great but saw me changin Ttllknows about
the baby.
He said he promises to help me and we will figure out wh Nee sat t.
(t/ 4/ 0 S <<\
C) 4q-n.... t.,.../S ,x
<ig -
1
'I couldn't
stay under
the same
roof
your life les a whole new life. And here to make things a little easier is Ih
will
abl( GfcCon‘a. A roomy, versatile
minivan with front -wheel drive and hefty V6 power. I on tin 4at it's the best ally a parent can have.
So prepare yours  ady or bill never be the same.
v'n vr (In cm 4- (O etiq
at rft ott nnoCicie CIAO+
tirs.ylmcirnt ..!+' g 0 vlenhbci•hpi Imbini cCitob
pyS e o e fl..1131yos a(Ao eS e uat 180  vLs o r s
‘ae4.0106. .04• beS °  ci i‘tred b.\ ee fne Sato
ash\ltf\“ t cke• I'l+Nnvi ins vnv oe hnw
p\- c'e.O4Se o.S cArni-e iokea ()-V
ehe.x\3tlac,ve,1 rasrt hvir
e'I ns ° 9 ve,o
nigh Kosbui - ecotegcle.m S Soe p e
19ING%cinwo,o-t-Vibkol-IS 0190
e oi q uwa Gt nr,pot4Sro -4 l- oo.

I
1

My heart belonged to her.
She was so very beautiful.
She was perfect. I cant bring myself to write what happened.
I am beyond broken.
I only got 10 to 15 minutes to hold and feed her before they took her.
She is mine!
I want her back!!!
Distraught!
a
a
3
U
a
Shy
is gone
and she
won't be
coming
back
216
begxtiful
Child
Your clear eye is the one absolutely beautiful thing.
I want to fill it with co ioritid ducks;
Tie zoo of the new
Whose names you meditate—
April snowdrop, Indian pipe,
Little
< (/
heart belonged to her
28Jantiarylp63
Stalk without wrinkle,
Pool in which images
Should be grand and  classical
Wringir_aof hlk i",..  • darto O
Ceiling wi u •
Not this troubloui ste
*/ "" k
VV
Se ``` f'se‘'.1040‘ N {O
y rsiSe. tc , i 00 1 5 1 -1
1•41ehka?Ila•Cl 'OAC\t.oe
Virl (0‘pe.e‘ cc‘ t oirA fy.fi.
olqA005 \\J e ckoecie 118
1110 I t IfinnIS 0 ociRteheeoe
to hC. Iii ltAIN. 1 ate „
ot CS es •\ vJahrQK
osroh,
*1-to
HELP MD
PLEASE CANT ANYONE FIND ME,
[clipping with date, National Geographic, September 2003]
Barely (survived /ill those) procedures.
My heart is GONE.
HER PASS ION FAREWELL TO
A PRINCESS, AND
TO AN ANGEL
PROFIT left behind

April 22nd I had no choice.
I wasnt ready and she wasnt ready.
My mother had found me and it was urgent.
After so many bonding moments with Jeffrey, Ghislaine, their baby inside me with me in the
middle she wouldnt even look at me.
We said nothing to one another and I was so confused.
When we arrived at Palm Beach I was taken to a house close to Jeffreys I think ean Blvd
or St.
But it was close and I was ALONE except for a new drive Not Juar otr .
An elderly French lady whose pictures on the wall diolkINsi hetAk ei
She had a thick accent and was kind.
(e Said she had been born to deliver babies and ha(  een eso before I was born.
Similar as the last one with shot and but tt much  blood with so much water and unbearable
pain.
Ni
3/41 ....She put her hands inside of me and see ‘ ied.
I didnt understand. Something about the b by facing wrong way and putting ... (next page)
I love you
so much
joy
0

pressure on a placenta?
Things would have to be different.
She said I had to be brave and strong and listen to her directions so she could help safely get the
baby out.
I was TERRIFIED seeing so much blood on the bed and floor and started to panic.
makShe had me flip over to my hands and knees and had me push and push and it was so e iating.
iithe
a whimper
I could feel everything as she tried to guide the baby out but I was so tired.
I felt I was dying but suddenly she had caught a beautiful babyclvvho mad
but beautiful cries.
than
She let me hold her and washed her and brought herk are a
She smelled so good and showed me how to fe
But only after maybe 15 minutes Mr. M came td
and begging for more time.
41/
Clas hysterical!
He said those horrible girls were in the

car ut I wouldnt let her go.
would  nThe old woman promised me she woul e fe and I had to let go. 4 pounds 10 ounces 18.
5 inches long with beautiful long fingers.
I am dead inside.
clawLife has no meanin
I dont want gt

S
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
•
S
S
Edge
51e i
The tcomae is perfected.
Her dead
Body wears the smile of accomplishment,
The illusion of a Greek necessity
Flows in the scrolls of her toga,
Her bare
Feet seem to be saying:
We have come so far, it is over.
Each dead child coiled, a white serpent, n +svOne at each little Nei
Pitcher of milk, now empty. 1Sre
A
<<" • S` She has folded
Them back into her bo
Of a rosc close when
Stiffens and
From the s
ors bleed
Is
rt..%
IssZi deep throats of the night flower.
The moon has nothi ySad about,
Staring from her
Shc is used tot  i sort of thing.
Her blacks crackle and drag.
ne.
February 1963
Jean Luc Brunel is a disgusting pig with bad breath and I am almost positive does these disgusting
things because he is struggling with maybe being gay!
6 weeks wasnt even given before being sent back.
Punishment for trying to run.
Why can no one help me.
Ghislaine is gone.
\\' I am so lost and my heart is broken.
Is this my...destiny. O \
WHEN YOURE LEARNING ABM' LIFE, THE WORLD IS YOUR CLASSROOM. WE LIVE WHERE YOU LIVE:"
•
■
■
■
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
a
■
MODEL SEARCH
PR0TECTIL , , family firm
I need them, everyone...all to see.
I still always dream to build a better world.
She went firm being a beautiful young girl to a sad broken child...
but maybe a hope that after it all, I still truly had it within herself.
One day I aspire to be like this...
she came in like a lamb and went out like a lioness.
all to see. 1  not a political animal, but I
think the biggest disease this world
suffers from in this day and age is
the disease of peop. 1....Viing
unloved.'
en I go to sleep at
night I know I
done my hesi
dream to d a better world
:••)1k fp.mi .k Ill
v(atiau
frilly had it
within hcP,elf.
SHE CAME IN
LIKE A LAMB
AND WENT
OUT LIKE
A LIONESS
EFTA00000068 (Jmail)
frrf4
/IA ea
Itl?"t% 96 St t$ eiTP kika y - 4- •f•
Tc,3 in tttiet,
ai A   iwA a •
\,*1. Thoo C 4 ;roil
t 04 4
Thb_igabS Y.4 ‘1411 41".1:11/ s

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000077 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ay ss             │
│                   │
│ : NA ( Wy 4       │
│                   │
│ EL iy             │
│                   │
│ 5 ll WS \ an *    │
│ J tie. \)/) |     │
│                   │
│ fe! arm) ew 4     │
│ i Ale!            │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00000108 (Jmail)
0
ol
0I•
0
crA
Or
. eirstibu.
-tat --Vey- -
rti
Zbz o
Lta •-•P;
•

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000109 (Jmail)
╭────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ G                                            │
│                                              │
│ sfSiieTioMe ott oHettononoMontenToneliolche, │
│ ‘                                            │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000132 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ 2                 │
│ i                 │
│ Fe +              │
│ a                 │
│ t                 │
│ é                 │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00000233 (Jmail)
A.. ..:51-;..-Ist40e- %re
rtirat  , r -Tete
%; 3w-0a -et
alutretett"

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000345 (Jmail)
24 HOUR
VIDEO
SURVEILLANCE
M-Putpose tatcw.
CU n cam)
• JR FIEird

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000433 (Jmail)
9 EAST 71ST
NEW YOrtK. NEW Yth;l ,
;0021 MERW1N
DE LA
'71 no (MVO'

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000491 (Jmail)
anti'. . ,s(nsen,rinporariviregiurse,0 arpswicpforfolac:tprocrt,

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000650 (Jmail)
1
senaCompleted
Place X is Boa

╭── Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ Search Completed    │
│ nial ‘Pine Xin Box) │
╰─────────────────────╯
EFTA00000660 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ on                │
│ “3                │
│                   │
│ X F >             │
│ { A               │
│                   │
│ emnm Si           │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00000773 (Jmail)
9 E 71
"•-4.7rr"
Ns,
ArlAik A / 4-•
rt , t
Ant Ifia } -now.— • • as -..r.77 7 fastunreel; New ly k NY - 2A4 Firs
31,1„,-in vim .F.s,„: SA mo5rietf
A

╭─────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ────────────────╮
│ BOF tat Toa he Yond Fm 3                       │
│ HEE Suey 350959) gM: SA mungoet Girard jae kaa │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000774 (Jmail)
Date 7 ipq ',latch-on • 9106.4 Nsi- Witt 14 -3
'COX Ai: 3/s _o_3Og 73,7/ v 5 9 ; I na ra t  6://a1VI
Fka
dr47:

• 0"
ai

╭──────── Page 1, Image 1 ────────╮
│ «Date: 777g sdocation, 9 aS 7/9 │
│ CLF: seme 30R757/ -Pmpaer       │
╰─────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000775 (Jmail)
'Dile' V*? .L46O1-O, I East ireortt,Nievi px,Ny istfloor
•aau*- :34E-m-30216-fl agate, s4 tom-yrek ararA 'r E N E
ism
EFTA00000810 (Jmail)
~q

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ RA                │
│                   │
│ Cnn               │
│                   │
│ FNL NM ty         │
│ en Te A ee        │
│ Bua Bu            │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00000845 (Jmail)
A,
'so
We Deliver For Yc)
WVAV.:ISpS
EFTA00000882 (Jmail)
/111010011111

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000884 (Jmail)
warratargaaccata sa000000aooaaa ncunuaoaoaaae imanumnatitastsune wit fietaa
• • • • ta" NI St • • • % a t*  ,
4 t
EFTA00000901 (Jmail)
Illigallig.0 •
r --- - -
AntnriMil liii
Illift Ifiliti li

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Rae eh ection     │
│ Po in             │
│ en en             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00000927 (Jmail)
k;1O, sAk \IN
A
-.-- • --
••r•r•T•r••••ii rrrrrrrr tttttttttttttttt ttttttttttttt NJ ttttt r

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00000928 (Jmail)
ir

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ (65)              │
│ < a Y i           │
│ ($3 i ,           │
│ 8)|// Ny          │
│                   │
│ fs                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001008 (Jmail)
╭─── Page 1, Image 1 ───╮
│ Seater Tea eae Tea ea │
│                       │
│ ; gi                  │
│ , iw ,                │
│                       │
│ |; a +2               │
╰───────────────────────╯
EFTA00001188 (Jmail)
PHOTOS OF JE
JE AWARDS
OFFICE
SUPPLIES

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001285 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ——                │
│                   │
│ Ny                │
│ ate |             │
│ 4                 │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001339 (Jmail)
SIAM
A'S tiv.zthil
CAD
an
GOP'
MEW
ANS PAGE
11 .11 !I PAGE
DOOR
EFTA00001341 (Jmail)
ills

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ my                │
│                   │
│ Wiiitins.™        │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001346 (Jmail)
-tC- - -1.'ifly, .:hidttkfi I o
EFTA00001358 (Jmail)
%cards N•ive
Calm Number Sant camp
X ye.,
EFTA00001359 (Jmail)
╭── Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ a                   │
│ i pL LDOD IID,      │
│ mess tieg           │
│ COPLMLILLLLE HG HEE │
╰─────────────────────╯
EFTA00001361 (Jmail)
Search Persoonel Name
S:T7 741INIPMEIPMS1
AmmeY Coot. Number
Stara Completed
(Mat X Is Bo*

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001366 (Jmail)
Search Personnel Name
ilitifidtrnParde legli fr414
Agency Contact Number
Search Completed
(Place X In Box)
EFTA00001369 (Jmail)
t ;• • • •.:
',NS, " z-,.; •i • tiv • •-••••:34.:4
-a
Search Personnel Name Agency Contact Number • abfi
Search Completed
(Place X in Box)
EFTA00001372 (Jmail)
El. ;7 1-  ri t;
7 s•.n ( .„,,,kr„,
___Itl_mer N I. Bo')_  i

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001373 (Jmail)
SitSsazililti
1.1=4:::Ava
•t'titt:ttiti
sr:met:frt.
EFTA00001485 (Jmail)
•Doit y-i6119 •I Easrl (*Sweet Ntwyone., MY w Floor
•QSZie bp..1-5+1 . Ron 3A Marsdrei-Girard
Ram : ?AM • &wane: 5:15 embeirrititi
*Worthy,' 1st fthoe 9E71 NIR: YORK

╭───────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ ‘a ‘hs L                                                   │
│ Date Hef 19 Location: 4 Ease 1l*Streer, New orc, NY —) Pho │
│ Last Sey aptsH 3A Margaret Girard                          │
│                                                            │
│ Date: 7/n/!9 » Prypaner: SOS Kimbeay thaes                 │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001486 (Jmail)
'W S " . 9 Eat 11" S‘treek, I,kr/ yea, NY- hvi R$w •PI
•CaSett ilfrk11-002111 •Ffr - S4 minjora- Girard
0a/e.' in? • tNayt soseomezty /ma -
.
I I
stmt.

╭────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ [Dae He laa eat Tver Yor NY Dad Fm          │
│ Lebait SIEM 5627591 Prabwer SA marth Girard │
│ ad Dae: WW * Bagangs: 0s Kimberly Meolar    │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001488 (Jmail)
-Dme: tile' 19 • Lecti  eastntreet,nlevi yorK,Nry •O251* `31E-ni-302.16-31 ivyaner:54 ICIAryra- eiran4 "1 ‘
.13422Ate sas ,i(tmbegy Note,
won
•
NEW Y Q R K'
, ms a";:r PimecT
...••••••••••

• ir • • r • •
. .o. InIalLa . ,. gr tomo

╭───────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ [ate Aelia statin - 4 East I” Sheet New Yor. nny -Agueoor- │
│                                                            │
│ “CSE SIE-WN-3927671 spepmersh Margret Girard               │
│ | <a, y/o Aypaner: Sas Mimbo mole                          │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001489 (Jmail)
get 1-217k 7/e/ ASSIIon 's ? 719- Stnto`Nriu itiA,/194„5iti • Gait -Fr 31.Eity-5,aysy, •freCorer:  34 aretthrae
'a:0SO' PM/11"V% so.S Kim bet 4,
r
I r
I
9 WA NEW YORK
• -
5°11)2-*
't'.7 712: 3RC
Casa We Po "--•
M
—.- 7 tr i—
.. 4 /So •
EFTA00001490 (Jmail)
.Patiliiin • Location : q -fistoretipjew,tosx,xy_ 11'naor
'Mee- :31E-my-313/95-41 •v -: 54 MA nig  yet- (io n(
I eat : VA/ if • PAli(21 4W: 30S Mkt 1? Alder
' Nears')
9 E 71 NEW
YORK
w

• • • .........
1 • !or I.L,41,
st•P •• • ••••Lef•rli•if
7
'I
saTlilaCell:Rorn
YNFfq S.
lr
.1.010.4 ta-tiflt
EFTA00001491 (Jmail)
•Caset siE-,44- 39521411 •Lotetftvi. q Eau in &wet- ,NtorYorw,wy- 134 yrtent-
bait.  }Ailrq • PrerOkne  S4 ManjaPe4 -  CifdrA
• otaie: 0)//9 gig22^02r: ..SOS eimbe.,* filtdat
no Seth
I
9E
EFTA00001493 (Jmail)
io•
INS
•
its
ye-
lilitkilJUMAMILIMMUIPJUULI LULIIJULJUUlil

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001494 (Jmail)
e
•
•
S
•
♦
111
-41fr
A

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001495 (Jmail)
.•••-
a
air
Sor
a Nis
as,
EFTA00001499 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2001-11-14)
UNI I ID SIAILN DISIRI( I COCK I
,Ohal YU%
Maw Mat. tfre •••••••
11,4,...•.•••••• -•rant+
See 111.3",a1 A
See 4wew4S
19MAG 6439

S. AR( H %N0NH/Ala A %RH al
rib 10 UMW $11.14.1C.0.1c t. %Van, '59
Wb
....wasam. ••”•n
Stu *Ave Ar revenue Wee.
t.,..ry eettentrtripit tet.n ,,,, {
larded efts...........evessles• Soy 1{31
1%n:I Ile Cal. i.C11, iwIr•••‘axgrk . tit a
Oat mug dm mead
UNITED Si ATM DEPARTMENT OVJUSI10E
ITOILVAI.StiltrAt' OF WaSI1GATON
Receipt for Properly

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001504 (Jmail)
'Thrtatc,i
EFTA00001517 (Jmail)
• .sba...L .vi
"4:7•416:—•
fr 7
. • .
EFTA00001518 (Jmail)
S‘' ,;f17.

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001525 (Jmail)
# -1E1EVIS%
to
•

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001529 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ATTN              │
│                   │
│ THUUANUAANINI,    │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001543 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ a emp e, -        │
│                   │
│ \ s 4,            │
│                   │
│ f y               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001545 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ro                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001575 (Jmail)
-

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Tas               │
│                   │
│ Abe               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001576 (Jmail)
'Mitt lllllll 11111111111 llllllll lllll UN,
■
EFTA00001584 (Jmail)
THEATER 3
THEATER EOUIPMENT
a -x - 7Z,
*w.f.*I RS We
asensta. ;A; Nan siwaiite
II May•19 Contractors Weaken OTtionnster
We have rtcelae0 propOmIs Iw dernohlion 0$ the nine./ and eonstngton
of the new Tonle 5.. lames hug Pole ream Cabana %Md./ Roof There we,
Ouse • renew*. the stoops wow Rental., the &lawny lam", ohm we ...en from
the contreetor during this pr oject. 01w 'RI ut et (Wove.
I ...Pore • oTRIMII deewe•A lArteelerturall quaMy snot ihneTuTV
Genr e* condoms th at' be inchiehid es con of the Ire aeons lout soperatelA

1. PropomInhat how oncost° of wows bawl up, wimoe, hoed hely.
Oremotton of (neAmn, Root S M0003
Clere0114100 of II.T0h4 COW" S 600 CAI
Demoldpon of uthrs wmun Foolv , knf S 110006
Prond•Ournpsters tweed Al Owner ,. Cm reckon S 1.11(0 00
en' , Mr Clumpster neutsPrOvOed by None° 5
thhavate 6 Pour /1mAto/um. Fooling, S 300300
tormi Pour R New Columns S A000.00
To on 6 Ph, Bond Beam tAR keel Bean, *CCTV/Wet $ 43500)
Stop RITCPIC. All Cormncult
I rame Root with YTS' roller, 63'd (0' hip, 4/11 IMO 5 930000
.mall )1.12' 1 os0a BooedAround Roof PelpaNClirl S 950.00
Instal( One lover of 1/C" PT Plyee000 Dotting to iunen 5 33.29.00
nstelf hCe & Weer 'Weld to Plywood S Ifl®
mnJ coop., taThintiDnp Edge to Match °Along S 580.00
Ciiner etc Roof I i* 5 3.500.00
',ANA A P al.:Cf DUTOCk <Can( S 6.50000
Planer All sscoved Concrete Column* i teams S 4,34403
'enrol: New Coahl Slone TOO Per Owner's InstruCtiOni S &M00
'Noting deeming, S 7.00000
5 3300.00
,353.00
Should you have any hoettionii or require additional in! onnatean please Feel fret to contact
lilt Terry at (340)118 .64 99. RenterrIbef, this s> a lump sum contract and any th emes will hoN
to be Sired by the Contractor and Owner.
AULS
Cts; -44o
Pro
EFTA00001599 (Jmail)
re•IMMIMI M.
•Pm••••••• ••
irs•MOMI IMIMMIL
-1-•••••••••• ••
me•VIMMMI MMIL
SaNaMI .I.mMa
-•••••••• •••
glm1•16••••••401•••
—
EFTA00001623 (Jmail)
•
WEE
skit/ •
•
•
EFTA00001631 (Jmail)
t
ali6- Air
• -4717-----11_
EFTA00001640 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ YU)               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001644 (Jmail)
gi fr$ m m es4, e dipta.
EFTA00001650 (Jmail)
I

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ SSS               │
│                   │
│ BBA               │
│ =                 │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001660 (Jmail)
7.
I

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ me | = cay        │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001668 (Jmail)
*****************
I A
••• • 41 . •••••••••••••••1
••• • •• r•••••• IP/
II
•11 .1.1
OOOOOO OOOOOOOO 1•111 ( t
•Il !DIP ••• t ii.•••••••1
••• I
II•••••••••••••••••••••
•
EFTA00001678 (Jmail)
4

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ a                 │
│ al                │
│ a Woh             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001681 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ rT                │
│ 4                 │
│                   │
│ ——                │
│                   │
│ a |               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001685 (Jmail)
--'ate a r  a  —SA&a afeaslibis a Sao aaa Sa a a a -a\ - tear
EFTA00001690 (Jmail)
Li

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Hani              │
│                   │
│ rm                │
│ ey,               │
│ a?                │
│ i                 │
│ Bs                │
│ BN                │
│ Wi)               │
│                   │
│ = | Bes           │
│ Giex. |!          │
│                   │
│ hhh               │
│ ane ihn           │
│ Wy ¥              │
│ WN DN             │
│ SHH) A            │
│ aNiY) WYPYYIYD    │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001691 (Jmail)
I . •
I eiti•lrov,
• AV, • •
• "il le":"V
, 0011, 11
in
swam as en ma
ass
EFTA00001691
EFTA00001708 (Jmail)
tr\
4 tutu
rrrrtrrttr
urn,
yr
i fti'f'f,rry
urn,
EFTA00001712 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Utz               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001728 (Jmail)
Ashielle IHtieruie
Boniface I audat
(- hark. Dick
Cristobal Ilertera
Cuthbert Titre
Dale Mark
Danny Etienne
Danny Boodram
David Alves
Dupson Donissaint
Fabian John
Felito Joseph
Gael Leathern
Garth Eugene
Gem A. Titre
Gusneme Dalce
Hillan Bedminster
James Cesar
Justina De La Cruz
Keshaun Williams
Kevin Alexander
Leida Hernandez
Luckner Legner
Maurice Bedminster
Miosotis C. Mane
Nicholas Victorin
Onel Pierresaint
Oriole Joseph 1•
Patrick Cena
Philemon Alcine
Peter Elie
Peter St. Omer
Randy T. Amparo del R'
Ronald Joseph
Sheridan E. Elizee
Sylvester Gaillard
Pierre Jules
Brian Bales
Mandgernent Office:
Phone Number Department
Wreckshop
Carpenter
Plumber
Irrigation
Pools. JE bikes &
Wreckshop

MC. Electrician & Plumber
Stone Mason
Barge Mate & Extra help
Landscape Manager
Landscaper
Heavy Machines Operator
l.andscaper
Houseman & Extra help
Pools. JE bikes & Trash
Landscaper & Stone Mason
Painter
Carpentry
Housekeeping
Electrician Assistant
Houseman & Extra help
Housekeeper
Landscaper
Carpenter
Housekeeper
Landscaper
Landscaper & Stone Mason
Painter
Boat Captain
Stone Mason Helper
Construction
landscaper & HM Operator
float Captain
Landscaper
Wreckshop Manager
Housekeeper
Head Carpenter
Heavy Machinery Operator
Carpenter
EFTA00001767 (Jmail)
1.

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ a                 │
│                   │
│ |                 │
│                   │
│ j                 │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001830 (Jmail)
•••

Ft. •?..c -1',)1:A.: • ' .A,Z .0.74 tciirta • A':
#
rar -77 774. riT
711 • '

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001885 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2001-04-07)
"MMS • 0~~ Kw I I+..
1201.1.4.2=t5
F:l.•Pti OM") ,
ritt Ø ,;.• ••,- •
ItC•»• • wn.. ti.° :me,: µtpG so.,

• nr. •••• bar« Int .• . , -
een,.
OdT
py•g••~,...•.• ;..,•••‘ • o.ne Ai
/ Ni nor. wn...., •••• nor a• cyca. .... ca • •••• Oasen 4111 at ons ••••• • ,...••••...• r. • ~a...m.n..
••••••••",•••-• • Lo•-• r.• • r• • am•

a. • . -
I 1•••,•••—• I ;••• ••• ••-••• • .
".• ^"*.• " '"" *.•••-", pl.•••• I I »ron rot.. • No.* b are,. ••••• (e••••••• e 4••••• •••....e.•••••• na« • ~1~ Ca 
•••• ui Ss Me ir••••••••• • • ••• snee
lakirt• •••• ~flap • •••••••••• •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••• ••••••. •••• • lognita• Mul< baarg •••••••• 
Vaag 0.•••••••••
•••••••••4 taf Oe e as kas.. lowy 0~ *nos neem.. Ia laade< • 'aam som/tm toes .~14•5 fl  •••••••• ••••••••• cao' o.c. 
wo••••• rato • V. 4~ • MilW• wit I •••••
OSSUIN TO 00 *0 MAT /Motel TOL. TO C~Al MIROleCUTION
RIB~
~Reil
•••• er.•
YOu• NUT RIIMeT/IATIONOATZI•1•5101/4
I rti
—H?"/ W-
t••• ••••~Ica ~Pa Onfl• te aan st w ••••••••ior ~44/ / 01~11
CALII
VIRGIN ISLANS DEPARTMENT OF JUST10E OOK, eo OEI ••1101INEY taXtlita
Nv
N•tåyat<0.yM16^tCmH
'••••••••~ - Jefttegl gentIrli th, VS. " ." .:Vr• I Le, tem •aent. I•Semat.
Tont is I% .1•••••••••
I NI smage.t. h. Cnv. ss. 5« ••••172.1 09)111»áire•••o~ ~oer i•• • ••  I ••• ~vod • ~a ike Vens klm& Doe al Maa la 
m••••• ••!••••••••••• m •••••••• 1•94121
1•11~0. .i.a••46•frwitim • •••.b 1.4 k werre•inb ••,••••
1••elenpit., Ma.» • glas ••••• I abt& leip•.« Mak leala,“•• ••• :ma& • ••••••• tenwal dranoros abt ot% ave. 114.0•1.
losr•adwal Tim
p•••••• naam« u.Sweca Ina coll(41~~d %Mat•• r“.• a ad Yt1n 1••••b Pil•ar *0~ • los MMO IS 011 S.Fon • •• ~ab' Iw.t1 eu•k
d rk. brol Sta mi pwoldie ~mi ~d
.4 7 1SIS
lo'n~ 21 day intosinis missluM nlm.ni...~ • ~Ine ~wik agg~ o r dimt itiloPipeamee
tilde
he...v
i ame iq...logs sibmt••0§~•4 0 ~•~0maa • ~I. l oma ~mede bang ~es • begamem
•• Oma «trawl

ti. Pin oreined 11~ lv \Way dm& • Aam. ca, slialegion••••11~ w Pope« afbond
nl My•d•rendrol lainatka
•

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ nd nt ap ogee     │
│                   │
│ tt aman at        │
│                   │
│ ‘cmt pi ga        │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001892 (Jmail)
Arial View Rendering Color
EFTA00001893 (Jmail)
Little Saint James
EFTA00001894 (Jmail)
LITTLE ST. JAMES
MAINTENANCE AND WORKSNOP
BUILDING PROJECT
EFTA00001897 (Jmail)
vhs‘v.%‘,.%..%=;x:e

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001898 (Jmail)
ttttttt •
: em, ••••,1,
to.' II al, • f•• ..... [Wain
TI.-•$ ,  ' 74.4R oe. : vielmtthw
n.cold kaolin.",
tittot
n e r ..„mw„„,
: Iola, Of fl
ON
4,4
Olf fes.not ••I'le tenant got

• •••,:4 Jr ut y.a c fl an,. unik *did mbar ,
(lowin••0.4.1.
t It, 0 a .: ,. ??...:1114 , tb Olio:tat:4 stet . :
• Nett It tot 40., :Immo ttan pun
EFTA00001901 (Jmail)
-zr inlowmirmor
iffs..... 7 • 7 sunimink iliamIM saidiarn,laill

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001908 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ Jeffrey E. Epstein │
╰────────────────────╯
EFTA00001909 (Jmail)
PR with
4 ,
K
4-
CD
de
450 Practice
Questi
•
MASTER
the
test
with
exper
realistic
practice,
and
in•de
REINFORCE
critical
concep,
detailed
answer
explanal -•
•
IMPROVE
your
perfornta
online
analysis
and
fee
•
PREP
ON
THE
GO
with
EFTA00001910 (Jmail)
••••!, hc‘c are t he cI roynlcn for the "'mall - act:, V, hat cat.l) clink or ON I ppowd rib r he , Liter

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001912 (Jmail)
C ATTACHMENT TO
PETITION FOR ADVISORY OPINION
TC nerd up 4) iflitirlApPet\-f fictu 0 -Pin State of New York - Iknanment of Tavarion and Finance - Fonn
i. The petitioner submits the following statement of facts as the basis for the requested advisory opinion;
j acts as their...is for the Advisory Oninion
Petitioner (the -Senior) created an irrevocable trust (the - Trust") pursuant to a trust agreement (the "Trust 
Agreement") between the Trustees and the Senior.
the Senior is deemed to own the Trust property for Federal and Ncw York State r . income tax purposes as provided in 
Sections 671 to 679 of the Internal
Revenue('ode. Under the terms of the Trust Agreement. the Settlor has the right to again::
or.naacquirt trust property at any time (the "Substitution Power"). The provision
of the Trust Agreemenfcreating the,Substitution Power reads as follows:
"Reacquisition of Trust Assets. The Senior at any time or from time to
time may acquire or reacquire any portion of the Trust Fund of any Trust
In substituting therefor other property of an equivalent value, valued on
the date of substitution. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Trust
Agreement. the Senior may exercise this power without the consent of
the Trustees. Although this power is exercisable by the Settlor in a non-
fiduciary capacity without the consent of any of the Trustees. the Trustees,
if the Trustees believe that the property the Senior seeks to substitute
for trust pmperty is not in fact property of equivalent value, shall seek
a determination by a court of competent jurisdiction to assure that the
equivalent value requirement of this provision is satisfied The Senior. at
any time. may release this power with respect to • •
under this section shall be irrevocable and shall he
in %Tiling signed by the Settlor and delivered to each I : t;
ith respect to which the release applies.-
U he Settlor wishes to exercise the Substitution Power t)
personal property he owns (the "Substituted Property") kir
than tangible personal property (the "Trust posy") hat n.
to the Substituted Property (the "I: . UpooaAeittil
Substituted Property by the Settlor, the Senior paid Newq
sales tax with respect to the Substituted Property. Following the : - I rustees may allow Trust beneficiaries to use the
Substituted Prope
charge or other consideration.
anplicahle I aw and Regulations •
S
EFTA00001913 (Jmail)
.t•
vs
•
ATTOPRIV/LEGED &
CONFIDENTIAL RNEY WORK PRODUCT
DATE:
August 22. 2007 FRO1SI: Four
TO;
GBUSER/Ftle SUBJECT: Palm Beach -
inlleflOF laltAID P.B. LEE , . P.C.
MEMORANDUM

╭── Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ PRIVILEG            │
│                     │
│ 3 CONFIDENTIAL      │
│ “TTORNEY Worn pve T │
│                     │
│ MEMORANDUM          │
│ Dare                │
│                     │
│ FROM,               │
╰─────────────────────╯
EFTA00001924 (Jmail)
•
ere
— a
<

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001927 (Jmail)
m-

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ee ales           │
│ Re Rea            │
│ on                │
│                   │
│ Be oral           │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001928 (Jmail)
:29.1 3-nop J(%ZNI 1tO it 671 ; t- • -
'1 trite hti /nog 1111-v am -115 369 72c." . Dwyzo
?saw Ail/ LI Atantfh pia ?Alai 7" T.17!
-'U/17 Jo dicritopic; ) ' •
aet *1 71-111.  .73Q/0M C 1‘) x ti
#12110: 111 21.711) F 1 113 .12 , 5' 1: 7clic
: I S tr‘t ; I • Fr ; 7 Ti
I °qv z.-?‘” PUZ ,  1:7;
anu
9 14 leff .,:n2 -,t <Cr; tyi 7, ; iyt:r
:• ;.. -,..
007,c3711
..--:',.'; • pi , L-,‘: -:. ,
.,.
04 g ? 5 al!: :1,31",,LLY1i. .3'
0,71Cril .-“, 7,- c -t--;;
EFTA00001929 (Jmail)
t ShltO3/ralatibit 'as
ay271. itimr Piss-nig ;4°7 'PP acc ;741 444 Tv.itti lybiluti"iil 11131114 O 'in° ill !trig' f,2 na  awn ill -tot VIII
/fink 4nIti I  -/Itotgli aini rich ptivit114..
12/: yyzjizpu ont  lc)
: TAT dr, cl r) • '5. ,g9 air/ ) ;••
• t S•11”/ .%‘"; a. - : "
7.1
:0) &D9
EFTA00001930 (Jmail)
. • 'T.,1
- ,..`
4 t;

• - • A3-1;
- ...- .1-.i.. 0 ,.i -4„,.1.0- a•ft
rr
trip , 7 &51Y; T s L
.1.314.1 Ctit'l.tirl;1 CI
tieb. cic
, , , . ,. ,.. draw, without, -1,-../ ro,..•i t,..., !..:(c),?.. .: i
. inig clin.3 on Family cir ,.....thi-; I; c:..7.,.:1•,. i: ,....., - .; i ... i vet hind of yowl& halv mg it icticil 
(2i, it, ii, .i ! , ! ,
Szettl vil moniet. in ii,q twat uicacii ; ire /, T haw. F.
qoilen.lo 517Ct12 a. con szderabic a:nounI c/r 11,7; i
with_ her 56/CC' Z mcvcd out 1-{,c1,INTet; /lit ma: :' i.
wonderful thine' you have done i5 /nob ific /0 A ..
best and reellzi ihi Aft about nui le f ctjhan k !k ,,,
for everyiii..??? you hove dotty Or Vic
5
Mill

╭──────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ─────────────────╮
│ trip.and ate                                     │
│ visit me for                                     │
│ cu aparen                                        │
│ uch ebsier                                       │
│ to have                                          │
│ draw withaut                                     │
│                                                  │
│ indryding on family                              │
│ very! hirid of you te                            │
│                                                  │
│ help my fricnel ( :                              │
│ Seeing my mother it 10 was worderlul T have nob  │
│ olten to spend a considerable amount of hime     │
│ with her since t moved oud, Hawever, the mest    │
│ wonderful thin ope have done i5 pusk me bo be my │
│                                                  │
│ best and tealli think about my Ule Shank you     │
│ for everything you have done forme.              │
│                                                  │
│ =                                                │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001931 (Jmail)
II' 1"1"11 TI"Il "1"1"1"1"111111"I 'I  ImIll1"1 'ZI,199+Z.Z.00
r77001
ittoh tun 4ktion (tun
/14 24 V u°51 ? Zc 47
upisa3 OWE
≤900b va fit
EFTA00001932 (Jmail)
ear c.ff-reA; l lel
I. hope had a 1VO111/4:',.L i 1 ..Lt r1.01/-
dail season.
seni Me Zi was beauliful 111(: -
you vent rtuca. Christmas wen{ 'well will' &Mil 711
zi, Arizona will' our da,N. pertor7.: RS-kr and 5pera •,, a • on wars will lite circus in- ta. evertiiitinq 'has
bee& well anal. reali!-.. 11241 the va4,_ woui
toi have icon as qmai as was co me' 1:15cLorett
been. for your heii. acive.-ziurcsr It°
r5lands, Ve51. Palnz each, izts Vcias, and. new. ,
hove all made. a car to rentember. 1111 5i stet had
a wonderful ore rhe ,k15 Vela and flew nicxic,'
14 on flew her 0111- trip. and also when
vt;il me for the week-encl. allowinqine 10 ay
our d aparime Nankoilan mod,: my life so
much ebtsicr and leas Simssful 11 was -Very nice
lo have m 0107L space tritcpc Z could $uiet and
draw wilt la lalking to anlone nor wortiyirq a boui
jar dingy on Farah' or oilier friends.
vet hind of you to' help my friend ve nal
Seeing 'was' wonderful,
jo 5 n considerable amount or tem,-
with lter 5L CC r 711C".'ed ouL RiZt1VVCI; l[iC MC51'
wonderful flanq you. have i flush jo be az
besi and reallv lhink abo I rt3
for ever lhi al you_ /taw cionAn tar Me.
Si
...•••••••/.1.
■

╭────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────────────────╮
│ { had a wonderful holi-                              │
│ meme 0 Season.                                       │
│ ed, necklace sent me. I cautt Ay                     │
│ yeu very much pur ceg. Shea en beautiful tie         │
│ ister ard Z spent it pbk page de)                    │
│ on new years wilh the 5 thi “7 qr “|                 │
│ yell and I realize that Keerd ie 2                   │
│                                                      │
│ vat as Uf wp it not                                  │
│                                                      │
│ a4 perigee would                                     │
│ 4                                                    │
│                                                      │
│ ge IF                                                │
│                                                      │
│ have all mad year fo tefnember. My                   │
│                                                      │
│ a wonderful time on the das Vega and Jlew Mexico     │
│                                                      │
│ trip.and also when you flew her out to New or hi, te │
│ visit me for the weekend Allowing me to stay in      │
│                                                      │
│ our apartment in Mla chaltan mace my life so         │
│ uch ehsier and less stressful. Tt was very RLS       │
│ to have m re L could be quiet and!                   │
│                                                      │
│ E draw will ; fo anyone nor worrying about           │
│ 3                                                    │
│                                                      │
│ ate on family or other friends.                      │
│                                                      │
│ very hind iG fee té hel, friencl                     │
│ Seeing my in 1Q ‘was wonderlul.                      │
│ dicn to spet a considerable amount of dime           │
│ ce © moved ee Pa He era                              │
│ wonderful thing you have done i5 push me to be my    │
│ best and feall think ahout my life, Thank you        │
│ for everything you have done for me.                 │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001934 (Jmail)
ever done Ec me.
Mak' yov ytej fitc.6 /or
w ortuntry Lo ficrlie,i),:sc.
4• 5 /te. te 1/i/45 dt, .:„„,k
somellang /hdoe eshlee I 44,4-5 a 4h-,(/,(
ly earecIate so friac4 your  kindness
goard tfroudirnhess,7o ash me airail etio,/ a7
t isk% me kwy .tad e46"4 Aire Eke so me, is the eileest nil , an, on e
EFTA00001935 (Jmail)
Aro alenis / 4 4 / in Al /W.4 4  .64.4,74,5
eo , 9,o a, On lie ut' nee ,,,,,j,t, 6;41 e
an ,e / (d- lea you sr if knik,e801,5 /
kap e yau 4" - 4-71 fee the joy  in  ,,
tr ice„ ea, 404_ .4,21 eAe / ,--4i14.5eye 5
of,c.;,7 , , IAA -1g
kSyrocress ail A
Goo r '10
<
-770.3 /knit, is44.-7 oy jut, 6,,er
iot.ele7G-772:7nii "14 :97thea/ e4 : no t claire/ vke e
semveti19 ea eke u, i7eible? -ter a ≤eiov3
tOtece the r .
J
EFTA00001936 (Jmail)
re Pt? Jor.c. a a n ,..e"
Air - ' derby., 44.44, .6.4e
•nstithiiies .8,1 a' bif hippos ;n -/he
tuAAP.r .ts you. ea-77 see in 44.y
eyes i/ telt kiwi/ xcived a~cl Gary v,

╭──────── Page 1, Image 1 ────────╮
│ e is were vicy smal and /¢      │
│ Pelé a bt Aargerovy withe the   │
│                                 │
│ trivdile, and the hippos in tHe │
│ water bet as                    │
│                                 │
│ sda Gov can 522 in Uy           │
│ e405 l felt Wry excited ant hay │
╰─────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001938 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ aa aa Ue          │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001939 (Jmail)
tidualauillt

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001942 (Jmail)
.ekto
O.6. wine
with vi
_ _ e %for ite„JS aiste cchonAtt-6,eff -bolt S14-6 picture b se Ot t-tn --;er a..12
h/24.0 frecid rstuch breeettioe you c.a.-s/pc oto  "t,tu d 4
ap-iilocf) 6e4f,'
(
bejind laie and cofiee Ltd/eh sc ones e,;- #( frt,v b/A-nitte €4,1•117 ene Mtn? e.le,&a„,/ hoe #C bre441456 ;p7 ficet 
n-t.)d4i/e cl bosh, and lete ad /74019.
EFTA00001950 (Jmail)
j* *....7- tar
C
EFTA00001974 (Jmail)
nu
THE ORIGINAL
Swim -EAR

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ simuuiiiit        │
│                   │
│ vsoK]Hteq\        │
│ ay.               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001977 (Jmail)
-"Ile Li. ER II
ter_ _
ir it !HRH t I I tff St tie'
6
=_=
8 . • e . or 0 . •
e s s s e • •.• •
•.•
. • .
1
--DT,
EFTA00001978 (Jmail)
S SUt -
1

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00001980 (Jmail)
:14 C._ aar
- --••••••
— _ =tire"' .
4ierr•
_ •
ade -te
•••••
--...-e."-s•••••••••• a ble ra rr-
ego
EFTA00001982 (Jmail)
losaiitteri I

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ee eS!            │
│                   │
│ —=                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001984 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ /                 │
│                   │
│ A bid             │
│ Bon ply Mose hex. │
│ a ne 7 Mobs       │
│ Fe Dghen Pier tne │
│ f = fe Dem mwacks │
│ tu u | Vere = y   │
│ a Bee pape        │
│ * Dal bay         │
│                   │
│ Vue devia         │
│ Poh               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00001987 (Jmail)
ta••• •
OOAVAis
EFTA00001988 (Jmail)
NQBPOBLOI 13 t14 t
CPElHEH A3114
H33 COBPEIHJ7I COCTEIBelEHHEI 10
A.A.SO1 -O(11f )hOliblIvrA
TA PISSEWLES
EASIE CENTIK-Al_sE FOIS6NT PEIFME DE LEI COLLECTION
REUNIE PE1R_
A.BOGOLUBOW

C. flETEPBYPI3
aitcnEanup 3611-0TOB. 5Vineira
1908
ST. PETER§BOUFk.
McillURICTUft DES Pe9PIEFkS DE L ET6T
1908
EFTA00001998 (Jmail)
• 3,4•A.-  .r, ',41% 'IrtA• -" • if , ' I,
741...:111,1 4.0 e r-x, axe .:
.10C e • r•C‘;,..., .?" cartr
4 - tql
kt- j • •
. .

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002003 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ (7                │
│                   │
│ had               │
│                   │
│ PS                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002008 (Jmail)
╭── Page 1, Image 1 ───╮
│ LMM bh — \'\ VA [The │
│ WO a ft ="           │
│                      │
│ A SNE                │
│                      │
│ EUAN) PO             │
│                      │
│ |                    │
╰──────────────────────╯
EFTA00002015 (Jmail)
I I I I I

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002016 (Jmail)
anal
PINS
• l• • a
• OLP • as
• *a
•
NI •
I ENIIIIN 40001V
• • . I
.4
EFTA00002018 (Jmail)
r - i f i t f 1 I
/ 7
;mot
EFTA00002024 (Jmail)
1
oe
, / :
> / j ,•
1.•/*- s'rf •
JP, - It P4t ye,/ • .1 • 'AV&-• Altefr.:1 I\ its \
_leo
rTh
EFTA00002039 (Jmail)
,,,,,,
teetonti
/1O11/it
wmuo
• •
EFTA00002042 (Jmail)
,0O
I VIC :era
/
EFTA00002047 (Jmail)
Please do not
Use this
BATHROOM 1111
EFTA00002062 (Jmail)
T
(
+• 4 .
••• • e

• •
*: 4 •I s. 7;1
•
. •
• V •

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ 4                 │
│                   │
│ Zh "              │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002066 (Jmail)
UNI .1) N 'FATES DISTRICT Coup I
ale
District of Vigia Inds
In tha Man or Mt Smith of
Menennom Mennen ty nano/
...eat...Ans.‚ • sa ,ße Menu
%Met Memo ea Inb SAM Ann keen& UAW an, My Bungs. Senna Cann. >anon
SEARCH AND SEIZURE WARRAN1
Tec Ay nennaeon law telmennt anon
Aß appenanam e • federal law penmen onnee or an annoy Is tin r.,, tTinem icV1n 1,` a.. at ,orate kelkeeriam COM 
IngnnpNapNnIM Myna ote Me Yip' i rm pins
%We« Kan Ml Dec ruse a) LITTLE SAINT JAWS ISLAND, LIS Mateary iSYNaD5 ‚ton no, Ittlidel‚t
Samoa/Si Common Tampon. and Any Inane« Ckeed Cortimemenerm Czseeanam ye-me re lamarapoon 0l lien,
I Ns)
(Mae Mien)  Gifir !ea
4:n1 ILS.  J;igin ¢slYaJdt
I And due oftaMmaill or any emend leszuncnmsublesA pe>tlet.likee etart! end rue 2s pee, e%,., pr. snr, dasrabrd Mots W 
OM of swat wall need (sane 4.0 Ian. 4, a
mom ‚Armament. neme
YOU ARE COMMANDO> to sterol. the %%NADI on or teroar Mapan 24.2019
O in Um dayttme SOO aao. lo JO 00 pm. Ws any lima n Me day oe nine bean Creed Clint hm Ono e
Wks *Wad metes is melamine' braass you an gar • topyollMwanwa sea • att.'' , nee nea reeler , ene eo e pence rue atom or
fromwhore pnresse Us MoreareY wan Ian
re Ma« atY and en,  M eel eac Pena ‚net ere
P'operga es Cates
The ear accatiqg this %vs or an taffies ;mom duinR tbc mmutoen >flew wanam.
nephat bylawofpronely non de ~eat sea inflames to ehoesameame
..v.s •
O pumas is la use JI03.0), I liad that inunstame nohfirstion may him ao ridtery rma hnol : • U S C
f 2703 (awl Jr dee of St and memo the pinta cuxulme *Ana Miktay comae M min Mince shoat
PCPS et be redid or orizetdrediesersram sas
Ob 30 in fr o» awe» mtil, factsjustifying the Las re due
A L e
Pb  It M.
feu /41
Riele ;PaA5
EFTA00002067 (Jmail)
PHOTOGRAPHER
LOCATION  LI* e5/. ZuNeJ jar/
ne" 4- *A'
a .5. 1/1.1-4 -157411

╭──────── Page 1, Image 1 ────────╮
│ DATE me, /A, 771                │
│ CASE ID 316 —Wr- 2027571        │
│                                 │
│ PHOTOGRAPHER                    │
│                                 │
│ Ny \tocation 244 Sf Same: Zehod │
│                                 │
│ Aye A + AY                      │
│                                 │
│ Pipe Vip Flats                  │
╰─────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002084 (Jmail)
Ir"(71., Ars:.

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002097 (Jmail)
t.

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ a Sn |            │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002098 (Jmail)
moan-- :toe-
EFTA00002104 (Jmail)
-.1.1 411111 Lt_
-
\\4tibt ,

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002117 (Jmail)
rifirkb;P"..eAg: si; •
II • I
1 I • I,
. / dt

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002118 (Jmail)
IMP"
-auk_

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002127 (Jmail)
•
OP
•
•
•
•

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002130 (Jmail)
ladasAgiii IL- 1
EFTA00002135 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ SA fUiyyii)ii\\\\\ │
│                    │
│ \\\ \\\\ oS        │
╰────────────────────╯
EFTA00002139 (Jmail)
-
-7._
- - -

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002144 (Jmail)
-!.111.1
flllii4ila
Wife( 1.1 ,
"" -Dv \‘ • ,
''

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002149 (Jmail)
.4
-....lialliftb.

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002163 (Jmail)
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . : . . . . .. .. . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. II • h . 
. . . .. . ... . .. .. .. ..... .. . ...
. . . . . .... . . . . . . . .
A 11 943
AA 4 09p 34
118001 40934
7:" ZAMYLA LACS
VAiSels:e7LTA LACS

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ i                 │
│                   │
│ | i ’             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002168 (Jmail)
1‘17k b- .1•tits. —111
COO J l )
EFTA00002171 (Jmail)
iwitiwalas
EFTA00002173 (Jmail)
Jun...raw
est) r IS IN NUT Arlon %Nor
r7. " .
WA :f t .
' •••• ekamo,
TOo!taa_
s, suss
IIPIO4P4J4moudmil
=tee= PS Me
cmg...4t.•
!.o l io: Fa '
. t. ±,
Dtca.ennty
Aro TS. P
4v1/4.44, MAGRI* S KRUM FTC %lbw SalecniCeililiSclesiel
nentaillolesktalr
EFTA00002181 (Jmail)
_

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ss                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002189 (Jmail)
-••••••••••••••13.11••
ay
41,

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002198 (Jmail)
emiwiajlnins
Agri I rh.
4
1

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002204 (Jmail)
11
DATE
CASE ID _
PHOTOGRAPHER
LOCATION
EFTA00002205 (Jmail)
o

╭────── Page 1, Image 1 ───────╮
│ i                            │
│ CASE ID _.4|E- AY - 302.7571 │
│                              │
│ DATE (_ 2s]                  │
│                              │
│ FBI                          │
│                              │
│ LOCATION __Zone &            │
╰──────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002210 (Jmail)
• • i•-ifrti
Afre)A-'
• -f
EFTA00002212 (Jmail)
,-,..- •
. . •
or
".7frktP7-4:;:314.retiCs- terle- 41.
Pio „

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002221 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ —                 │
│ —_——              │
│ \                 │
│ a                 │
│                   │
│ ” DS)             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002239 (Jmail)
,11 111111 MIMI 0 Ill III
WPM
Ill' ,„I
1111111111111 feu , 'Ili II
I IIII II 1
I ", :4 .111
1 111111111111r1
frIIIIIIIiiil
I 1.1111111mill
11111111111111
(111111111111
smiiiiimit
ttnnnnnn I 1111111111111
I II
try.l,!;ttcyV7
4
11
44
helt.o•
IIIIIIIIIIIIIII
tIIIIIIIIIIIIII
Ilillllllltlll
iltilliIIIIII
EFTA00002255 (Jmail)
tip  L:T. •Lo H?Cr.
PO'
CH"
Fx. 7%K:' caw ‘,1
11 1marathfli
8,20"5
92j 735
IOW BYO 735
EFTA00002261 (Jmail)
UFETIAt WartaMy Iledlif Vfahr Healer
P...0•••%,

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002264 (Jmail)
FOCUS INDUSTRIES'
22 22 00000 OPlat .tAllt tons!. CA
1.4••••••• tttttt (en • Ill Ill MO

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002266 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2001-04-01)
..-
I it fro
t /4Ot41 it e
rI I rJ , f.
4.4.g/ ftfi ry  0 104,1; 14, / Sia)444' 014(4 0 r, 4 1,

1. ? Pr. ;
I fit  46- tom`. 4;;;P • • 1040Il
f Psi ti i rp t 'A y
0) t " • #11(1;P Sit $4 ), 0;.°04140i'jP11 ,0 % ( vv(, A{„.jt1;4:;0#ii ii, / • ectTs•ce,' ns. • ' 44:frit'i •• t utt t 
sr •
70 v\ VA" ri i/ feW •P pit
••••••••••11m-

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002277 (Jmail)
a. smiNskr "N"
NIS n
gq, be ‘`
Vti
ONC IO"\ .%A. •
Xee.
S
_41”,11“,II,MI6VIPICa
_ a •• :O. ••:•••• •••••ALNAL ' \" : 1111: 1"• A ltilar li tillilAt " i lli nelq ' I/O.
-  %%tanlieli.n.. a I Thik am In
.116,01•Wal0\ \WIMilliNkaaallia tananniegennor NU.
, facnVilipoalicailla. ••• • 11••••• • ••••••••It INS ea La I bin IS t la VIM Irwin M194Wit .,
..••••••
EFTA00002279 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ‘im               │
│                   │
│ a                 │
│ a                 │
│ 5                 │
│ =                 │
│ pe                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002280 (Jmail)
r

• •ISIPaq4III•fla
spaut• .17, 4.
•••• • • MO AVOW le ea Is din It
" .........
4
- a."
lir 16i 4,,
VtliMACIMI MIRKA n  ra
KU AMIGOS

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002285 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ id                │
│ ay                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002313 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ *                 │
│                   │
│ ve |              │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002327 (Jmail)
Work Smarter
EFTA00002329 (Jmail)
no74660
001411
1 STT
EFTA00002365 (Jmail)
10•N BIM
AiDIESEL
FUEL
EFTA00002381 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ‘wilh             │
│                   │
│ Gs                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002382 (Jmail)
• I I
teNtYti..
eta`..
" •

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002394 (Jmail)
• 4#4411. 1.1%
' • P• CS
'e v e , i t l e: 72 ,4 •••<. '••C
4  .141 1• • • •  •tveirr"-t
• ' t hi ;cif:4 '4%97 ':`} f ee.'.
- ''‘. ' --• 'CC. ' 'im„..i
r.
-....... . • 47-•*:-- . • • - .
• • -.
• ' r 4; i t t .:: 4 ?;,..,
EFTA00002424 (Jmail)
F
, ,NSULT V.I.H AU LYILFILIY
.RiSOiCrION PRIOR TO NS TALLATiou
---.. .---_..
r-S_-ErnW-w -- "
EFTA00002434 (Jmail)
DANGER
HIGH
VOLTAGE
0
EFTA00002441 (Jmail)
up
a.
a
Inn
nub
'NI/
tat

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002442 (Jmail)
r
/

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ WS                │
│ WY.               │
│                   │
│ WV                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002453 (Jmail)
as'; c f..- It • • . e"t ek ..•  4 ".  •
;pi -41 1. 4 0 ';' (•  • ' - to,; -ea... jet..
tire .••• -Az. • • .••• • k r • r
' •.
••••••• `, • • •
--, •.•NA-•;* •
'4 0 e a: c%'At
EFTA00002454 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ee We             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002456 (Jmail)
or,Pr Mr!

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002457 (Jmail)
rIF I vir.

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002460 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ae                │
│                   │
│ XB d49>           │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002465 (Jmail)
I .. N
Ltk
EFTA00002470 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ =: Ta eee eee     │
│                   │
│ FL                │
│                   │
│ ao                │
│ E-                │
│ a !               │
│                   │
│ J Lined. ' =      │
│ ee -              │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002483 (Jmail)
...$1.0#/$.1
AWeetWoreei
EFTA00002489 (Jmail)
1"`"Wift ,, ,+- 0
pe'es 4,A,,A401.
:,,c L,.*.:1 1:2.1.711  . .
!ill
„, ,. , ..
0:7;; ;;;;;:"" ' •
I .‘14,,..,••
.; •_...a....- ii. , ,„,,,,,,,,,,‘„,„,,,,,,,,,,.„. ,
a ram ',L., & ' • .:44.€0,44,e,•,,,  ..., •
•p•••74,"'JIL4t043.04...ar46t:444e.*::#111.).....".•-'2

• -
P F. X• to4,4:44.,+•%;:14....4....- ••• ,
. _.
.re.-....otAat-4'.4.<,..;:.-tai:...-:-..;,-...-.. , , ,

9. :::.!...fivffr.•leir.2.2..,•.::::71:::.::
,..... .; ..1„ ,... ,' .
re t-2... e f;,,),:t . -;,..tte:;:••••/... ,  .• , .... , ,, .. , .
EFTA00002508 (Jmail)
IFi
.$3
Y
---4.16411
EFTA00002510 (Jmail)
ILO Default Network Settings
Serial Number:MXQ3220187
I III II HMI II III
User Name: Administrator
DNS Name: ILOMXQ3220187
} IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
Password: SOS BR DON
I ill 3

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ────╮
│ ath                     │
│ jo Detault Network      │
│ | Number: wxaa220187    │
│                         │
│ na Tis                  │
│ 1 ue nae ‘Administrator │
│ ftomxas220187           │
│                         │
│ il nam NNN              │
│ Paar ret                │
╰─────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002511 (Jmail)
' • • •
•
0 0
0 Serial NO. MXQ3220187
Product NO. 668665-001 1111101111111111
•

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002513 (Jmail)
 [misc] photo of a hard drive
1
I r
jr
..r.,4,
-At
I
).
ba4 "111. 111_1_1_1111Inty
.
Western Digital'
www.westerndigital.com
cc.
WD5003ABYX
WD
RE4
III IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII SIN
: WMAYP6203926
500GB
IIIIII
II
IIII
II
IIII
IIIII
III
II
II
II
CT:
2CEHE00311483FI
trill
III
II II III
I !I
II1'1I'lIIII'
Ili
P/N
658083
— 00'
Mir
H I
GPN:
857753-008
BATA
INTRAtilt
7200RPM
FAN:
HPOI
MOOS
805000CENE
WO
MIN..
Wa003ABYX-70C21)10
Product
warranty
will
be
void
II
sttl
Oo
not
cover
label
or
cover
is
removed
or
damaged
any
dnve
holes.
WWN:50014EE003985271
18A
: 976773168
DATE:
02
JUN
2013
5VDC
: 0.65A
OCM
: HGRNHTJCG
12VDC
: 0.50A
tl
DCX
: 00O22621.3
R/N

• 771702
U
S.
Patents
6178056.
5956196.6289494.
6263459
SERIJU.
T
Product
al
Malaysia
Canada
ICES
-003
Class
8/
It
I *CIL(
NM8
- 003
Classe
B
ROHS
KM-
REM-
=
M6
(;;Pel)Illoig!1!
al "4
-Ira
Sere
'''
:
;
to
N.
B v , ...erNe
r; 2
A,-"'3
CS
Seir:
-1.,
:
StrA
Enterprise
Storage
7INIF3
Watt
DP
SN:2Y5325I0X2
A

╭── Page 1, Image 1 ───╮
│ Woo"eyBipwiaysammnmn │
│ [ex16iq              │
│ UWlE\sayy,           │
╰──────────────────────╯
EFTA00002514 (Jmail)
 [misc] photo of a hard drive
S
Western

Digital
.
www.westerndigital
com
WD5003ABYX
wo RE4
III
II IIII
II I III
IIIIIIIIIIII111111IIIIII11
11111
SIN
: WMAYP6101653
500GB
III
IIIHIIII
II
IIII
IIII
IIII
IIII
II
DIP
CT
2CEHE003H409.1C
HOW
II 0
II
P/N:
658083—
DOI
11
11
n111
11 110
II II
11
OPN
657153—
008
HATA
IN
HI II IIII tit
720ORPM
F7W.
HPG1
MDLi
14805006CM
WD
MOS
WD5003ABYX-70C2sA0
Product
warranty
will
be
void
i1 seal.
Do
sot
cover
label
or
cover
is
removed
or
damaged
any
dove
Mies
WWN:50014EEOAEO4FD28
LBA
: 976773168
DATE:
26
MAY
2013
5VDC
: 0.65A
Vet,
DCM
: HGRNHTJCG
12VDC:
0.50A
DCX
: 0005266L1
FUN
: 711702
U S
Palents
6178056.
5956196
6289484.
6263459
Product
of
Malaysia
Canada
ICES
-003
Class
Br
NMB-
DO3
Close
8
RoHS
?X • *Cod
KM
-IO-
W-
002
onois
E
14,63
4.!tqkt
'el ate
m Cep
la
M..
By..
Lupo
a;

2. nL
-111:
3
k'i
DIV
-2.
%Enterprise
Storage
OD
-765;13
EU=
.1
-
illiinlifilliiillilil DP
SN:2t532510P8
EFTA00002515 (Jmail)
 [misc] photo of a hard drive
Western Digital'
www.westerndigital
com
WD5003ABYX
WO
RE4
SIN
: WMAYP5976261
50068
11111111
1111
111
III IN
111111111111111
t"
CT:
2C€HE003H40ABJ
11011
1• 11111110.111101111111151101 P/N:
858089
— 001
1111111'111
11111111111fruill1011111111i
0
GPN:
657753-008
BATA 7200RPM
sl91,1WARE
HPGO
MOS:
M80500GCEHE
WO
MOS:
WD5003ABYX-70CTLAO
Producl
winery
will
be
void
rt seal.
Do
not
cover
label
or
cover
is
removed
or
damaged.
my
drive
holes
WWN:50014EE058EA6EF5
LBA
: 976773168
DATE:
26
MAY
2013
5VDC
: 0.65A
ktb.
54;
DCM
: HGRNHTJCH
12VDC
: 0.50A
DCX
: 7C06Z5WL6
RIN
: 771702
U.S.
Patents:
6178056.
5956196
6289484,
6263459
Product
of
Malaysia
Canada
ICES
—DOS
Class
8!
NMB—
003
Class*
B
FloHS
GC-
faMI5*
.0 k3f65
033016
*Enterprise
Storage
Ognenni3
*tfiGEd
OP
SN:2Y5325404
EFTA00002516 (Jmail)
 [misc] photo of a hard drive
Western Digital`
www.westerndigital
com
WD5003ABYX
WO
AM
1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 S/N
: WMAYP6107485
500G8
p"
CT:
2CENE003840A80
lilllllllfillhl

II I1.1:
11
P/N:
858083—
001
OPN:
857753-008
BATA
11
II
II
7200FIPM MU:
M80500GCEHE
WD
MCC
WD5003ABYX-70CZIA0
Product
vonenty
will
be
void
it seal.
Do
nol
cover
label
or
cover
is
removed
or
damaged.
any
drive
Soles
WWN:50014EE058E8707F
LBA
: 976773168
DATE:
26
MAY
2013
5VDC
: 0.65A
DCM
: HHNNHTJCH
12VDC
: 0.50A
DCX
: OCO8Z6WL7
R/N
: 771702
U.S.
Patents:
6178056.
5956196
8289484.
6263459
HMO—
003
Clone
B
RoH8
T7R2071!
FRAGILE
Product
of
Malaysia
Canada
ICES
-009
Class
IN
GC
?
C ial
1 I
NOT-
OM
11
l(CC-110A-
s•vsso

gltketlia
0'33ei
PtIrri6 ..'1
..)
I‘.
'
,
.-r

• :
?
N.
-
—
18
es so
V•of
-2:.
: kitS
*Enterprise
Storage
1;;;;;;
lanta
DP
SN:2Y5325IORB

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ 1m9z8000 : x90    │
│ HOPLHNNHH : WOO   │
│                   │
│ muah XAgved0saM   │
│                   │
│ r LPL             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002517 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ He                │
│                   │
│ \/ iz             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002521 (Jmail)
iL0 2 Default Network Sittings •
Server Soria! Number: MX0824A1RJ
1 III 11111111 11111111'111
User Name: Administrator
DNS Name: ILOMX0824A1RJ
1111 1111111111111111 1111111111111 Password: 5U5CNHGG
1111 1 1 11111
EFTA00002534 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ UF ex             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002536 (Jmail)
 [misc] photo of a hard drive
2.OTB WO Gold SATA 1128MB Cache
WD2005FBYZ
II II111111 IIIIII HUI MIMI IIIIIIII 1111 III SIN : WMC6NOF5WLPM
MM.: W02005f8YZ-01YCB81
Product warranty will be void it seal. Do not CONN
label or cover is removed or damaged any drive boles.
WWN:600148E059A1F 140 LBA : 3907029168
DATE: 30 DEC 2016 5VDC : 0.68A
DCM : HHRNNTJCH 12VDC : 0.55A
DCX : 501PA0W6W RIN : 800032

U. S. Patents 6178056. 5956196.6289484. 6263459
WO M. B.V. Taurusmienue 5. 2132 LS itoolddorp NL
wdcom
CAN ICES - 3 my NMEI -3(8)
Product of Malaysia
R®5133016 ealleC MICCe>3\ ;RAGLE "1569 MSIP-ROA-T-11132
EFTA00002537 (Jmail)
2.0TB
WD
Gold
SATA
/ 128MB
Cache
WD2005FBYZ
INC
IIII
I I IIIIII
IIIII
I IIIIII
III IIIIII
III I I III
SIN
: WMCSN0F1TWPA
MIX
WD2005FBYZ
-01YCBB1 III
Atilt
Id
Ill
Madrid
warranty
will
be
void
it
seal.
Do
nor
cover
label
or
cover
is
removed
or
damaged.
any
drive
notes
WWN:5001dEE0AEF7941A
LBA
: 3907029168
DATE:
30
DEC
2016
5VDC
: 0.68A
[g...
t.
DCM
: HHANNTJCH
12VDC
: 0.55A
.tc
DCX
: 1D1PA0T6T
RIN
:800032
U.S.
Patents.
6178056,
5956195,6289484.
6263459
WO
NL
8.1r.
Taunisavenae
S.
2132
LS
Noorddorp
NL
:42.11
:22.420f11'014:21
wd
corn
CAN
ICES
-3
(81.
, NM8
- 3(81
Product
of
Malaysia
ed
:I
C
E
ttrep)
ROW
(133015
Et
-1
-
MVP-
REM-
WDI
- OLM2
FIAStE
EFTA00002544 (Jmail)
I
nvent
146G8
10K
SAS
HP
MODEL:
DGIASSI1978
Hon
rs
11,041021”
111111111HININIMIIIMIIIIIMat HP
RN:
438265-003
PRODUCT
OF
SINGAPORE
1
CT:
28978026CWSDAIT
we
SP/PS
CSC
LO.
PART
NUMBER:
•srsees-e35.
es
1.9
NUMBER
*12
0.3
IIIYTILOT
NUMBER:
0R-01-0920-6*
FIRMWARE
PiPpc
IJON
16000C5000E
SERIAL
NUMBER:
4131011331•90
sig146002$
29sCF7E
GPN:
375863-010
100422661

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002546 (Jmail)
L
nyent
146GB
10K
ISAR
HP
MODEL:
DC14688976
122-2,.4.27:28
2
titeS$4
HP
P/N:
43•165-103
•
?WOW
Cf
SIN;;APcgE
Ititonitt
°`.
F41
9,ea
T
ART
•
+12
0.3
int
FIRMWARE
HP=
'
L.LN:seeatseeens,ese
46
v

• • ST914680216

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002548 (Jmail)
,146CS
10K
SAS
01
HP
MODEL:
DC1
.1688976
ignitt$1
HP
911&
4301G11
003
ERGGGCT
OF
SINGAPORE
NIMIlItIURIBIIw
II I IiII
II II
CT:
21975026CWSOKS
Ill*
V0.
gMPs
NC
Sji
eLOT
PART
NUMBER:
ERWS066-035*
.12
i:
3
LOT
NUMBER:
EA
-01-0920-6
11
F I
PEPOC
:IIBIGUIIIMIIIpINkNIIICIIIuts
WWP
1' See
19
04.
30
SERIAL
NUMBER:
• 3Nrescos.
ST9TABBOS
::.II
III hl

II
GPN:
375863-010
IA04226
EFTA00002549 (Jmail)
ilifiltilligliiigIVII IN-IIMIIMIll
HP pm: 43B:65-003 • PROr...C:.'1 tritinAPORE •

t. IIIIIIIIIIIVIIIIIIIIIIIIIMIIIIIIIIIIIIIVIIIIII. . 70021CWBOLG

• NIMBER: ser6068-035s
BER:
IUIIIIIIIININ sitt-81-0920-6.
wee NUMBER:834186ms'
'N: 375663— 010
vDC AMPS CSO LO'
+5 1.0 NUMBER
•12 0.3
FIRMWARE MRD:
seeecsesermooe
ST914680288

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002554 (Jmail)
'N
't 'N
'.

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002572 (Jmail)
•
- - "ss ". ..
, '3.
•A A, Ma, ...4 C ti; Lt...•V iit
- • - -
•tairr-- : - • fot et-
sear, t-s,- .3ark.,.
EFTA00002582 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ —— =              │
│ — —— Ee =         │
│ LN                │
│                   │
│ a (i *            │
│                   │
│ = ill             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002583 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ L TL              │
│                   │
│ Pe                │
│                   │
│ tie |             │
│ nea rl!           │
│                   │
│ Fi ail            │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002587 (Jmail)
PiII. MIDI   0,
•

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Hi                │
│                   │
│ Se                │
│                   │
│ LLL               │
│                   │
│ TILL i            │
│                   │
│ LTT) i            │
│                   │
│ |                 │
│                   │
│ SS                │
│                   │
│ |                 │
│                   │
│ | 3               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002588 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Ne WEN. |         │
│                   │
│ = a me. ee =      │
│                   │
│ fT eee            │
│ = TA BT           │
│                   │
│ | 4 |             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002611 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Ly ve) 7:         │
│                   │
│ a. eA -_          │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002613 (Jmail)
rOtn Ova Wat.1•, lierf riot Mt
EFTA00002615 (Jmail)
ell

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ 4.0               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002640 (Jmail)
UniFi
.
eV
Ka
eft
NC
40:t
C
0.604CCI
d
UBIQUITI*
T-
evillan
?St$
gOoralke
—bte...01
I--OHM
erne
ea
set
casiamed
arlinier
see
0
sw.
miartin
Wahlweirtenteneaell NIMINOSSO.CPas sea
apOS
f
e
CE
EFTA00002641 (Jmail)
KS•TOEI00

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002642 (Jmail)
Panasonic
L1 No. PSLPI433
:der Supply Unit
100- i3OV/200-240V‘.
2 5A/I .4A 50/60Hz
•40V=2.4 A •15V =3.2A
•30V =0.73A +15V07=3.84A
+40V =0.4A (BATTERY)
140.4W/156W
. • toomaadoituskoskettimilla
i.tmaan.
. ,•itlespidet stikkontakt

• slut's till   iittag.
THIS SLOT
NOT USED
Cl CO

OT) ‘2I  >
n caw
O SD rn 55 3 _
DI ° go5 b. 0
CDn=w0Z .A.
5 S t.it
=
co ci; =to
ID ° Top 3— a -
C)F O< cn
moo
—o 3 no co  Ov
•C
(4 0
Cu
C
co • CA
O
Z.
PHI 23

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002643 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ LITTLEST. JAMES   │
╰───────────────────╯
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 TCR [government] Tip Complaint or Referral, form used for whistleblower tips 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00002655 (Jmail)
2
a
v )
(44^-td Amint..-a
on Ow
hrea.--t #1.42.we
I41. O1 •"so o 'U
A4
■
Tcr.}~cC
14.2_tra int4 a VS IHOf ••••
‘4A
Salk

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002657 (Jmail)
, , J ft' IJ

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ a ee              │
│                   │
│ hl                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002678 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ View pron daok    │
│ ae a              │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002695 (Jmail)
uNorosi Pan
rAx IND ,  I in I I.• NI
NM, km ...v.ritt it. No so
EFTA00002697 (Jmail)
-5<bernini. racau.. „
-Revised Screening Reom fi i .•

╭───────────── Page 1, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ Little St. James Island                   │
│                                           │
│ Cabanas, Pavilions, Pool & Screening Room │
│                                           │
│ (06/08/2009 80% Design Development Fr     │
│                                           │
│ “hevised 34 views                         │
│ TSthematie Landscape plant selection &    │
│ TReviged Sereening Room finishes          │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002701 (Jmail)
I ITTLt SAINT JAMES' S ViitC. iN IStANDS

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002714 (Jmail)
".4 1.4. .7•12+1

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002718 (Jmail)
I

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ hn all }          │
│                   │
│ i! BLA '          │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002721 (Jmail)
''''''''---_---7

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002735 (Jmail)
NO
SMOKING
EFTA00002737 (Jmail)
10 s
•
d iso t ra 41
f U E

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002763 (Jmail)
.•
te.
-3/4 :446-P:cry'

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ pee               │
│                   │
│ “ :               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002768 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ /                 │
│ 1 A               │
│                   │
│ ry fa             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002771 (Jmail)
41 WI I lo w
r
eh%

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002778 (Jmail)
-- .,inaILMEM
EFTA00002788 (Jmail)
3
\K-
S vo?.; :* A'
ti FP. r.e.- •

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002801 (Jmail)
re
Pct .•-•0.•7-7.- • yr
41-
a _ . • • 4.4 a • • . •

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002802 (Jmail)
'et 't•E.
.igik;A?
---1• 77 7 r
-1t4s
vI
EFTA00002803 (Jmail)
_ ___;_ 4
. airo.h.-
c
-
EFTA00002815 (Jmail)
sissiscu--
EFTA00002827 (Jmail)
fie 04‘
Atein
EFTA00002835 (Jmail)
,sttifiquek ,•
r
l
W 1

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ~_"               │
│                   │
│ HS aa             │
│                   │
│ 2                 │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002855 (Jmail)
%
LOCATION  Si-. Tames T-.5 Nana USVL
•
•
rhirsv",eftatizadvallararry

4. •-• • it

╭───────────── Page 1, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ Lo) Somme Sy an a                         │
│                                           │
│ CASE ID _31E - My-_3029                   │
│ FBI                                       │
│                                           │
│ pHoTocRAPH ri                             │
│ LOCATION __Littie St. Tames Ts\and , USVE │
│                                           │
│ Zones ¢ + D                               │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002856 (Jmail)
•
".• •
,
adl
. ir •
I I  ^to •

• • , •
POOL_ 400SE
• • yr.q , trr ai-
'r , .•
• a"
' 4 *-•
4 V,
tfr
• • • •
• f" ' '
co?
• CC 4:*
• t

• :
' • .11. I
•-.

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ lo                │
│ ry)               │
│ 2                 │
│ (6)               │
│ cele              │
│ ay                │
│ 0                 │
│ (e)               │
│ (Qe               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002873 (Jmail)
‘44 40 .1 4

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002882 (Jmail)
ollIP!!!!'"fl
k
EFTA00002907 (Jmail)
t)i\orcc k nu
bar to throne
says Prince
Old
EFTA00002924 (Jmail)
,t?+••• f
• r .

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002931 (Jmail)
•
saw.' 1.40I
).-
A‘ • ", ft
•/•"-. A 'I f • 2 1 '‘ Ant:
q:;„ . t •-• . . • , • Asst.* ' v"

• ••:• <  at
r r ;` ; , • .!.:1‘..e". • • e - r• 1..i rr•n!..-re• !A, .. _ ft : . 4. • ' •
rt;
; . r ; 7: :•;,),;12 1,i ?it,
°‘ I. . 4 k....•..,„::..or4.:;.,,, • 44.„,-, , . '..s., • , N: `• -•:`C";.4;4;1‘..t•Y` . . .f..t'll@';t',...4: 
•`;'':,,VQ;i i:7 . 4te.... • '
..\4.-,;:h ,V

• 1. • Z.` _ _

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002934 (Jmail)
isi"Wr
ma x,• * ?sr*
F e
-qv
„et
Ls‘.,

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002936 (Jmail)
Y. t
-
a.
sity
" :4," 1
EFTA00002937 (Jmail)
•
4
c ' • p -
-Tr • ,
44 "‘ : 4!tin••
• c i f
•
EFTA00002939 (Jmail)
0 \
1
ti•frA" Wlie
w .
-)e
V
s k
4, 4., le-
4.ktitC:16
l „III
NIt
„,:i
t: P SI P #
c<IC

ae. r
Vk tPti- CIA it las_  +
4.t:fr ator .i f iedr ca t
,P 41:4Cdr. -411r ..1". '

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002949 (Jmail)
;i

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ 9                 │
│ \                 │
│ \\ \              │
│                   │
│ 4 pa Kh be        │
│                   │
│ a ae              │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002953 (Jmail)
USG•DUROC.K
•
Cement
Board
I,
CAP,
nu
•tf•ILVVIt

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ USG DUROCK ses    │
│ Cement Board      │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002960 (Jmail)
Jai 1sae

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ fi                │
│                   │
│ Ss i              │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002963 (Jmail)
•
‘..
--""Tim " w

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002964 (Jmail)
42k
Mr-
•
.4
•

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ q                 │
│ qv                │
│ ¢<                │
│ =>                │
│ =                 │
│ Oo                │
│ Q                 │
│ =                 │
│ Vv                │
│ 3                 │
│ (c                │
│                   │
│ wSyT              │
│                   │
│ D                 │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002984 (Jmail)
r 14
rs
e

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00002987 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ =~ 7              │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00002993 (Jmail)
•
I IMO
SP E
EFTA00002994 (Jmail)
/

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ 4                 │
│                   │
│ cag               │
│                   │
│ \\                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00003001 (Jmail)
1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
OOOOOO , oo
dr -. 4•-..°-, 4flel 00.-..•.s..;...... 1,14:40.4•0_4.4t4t. wea. 000000000000000000 00000000000000000000 
4,1,4•4•4•4•4•4• : ...:..p..1 i • ••• 0000000000000 4
i0 14 0 01.0 .0 0 0 1
i.
"11:21141 11111":11 .......I:Iii
Og o Al 0000000 II
%
't., . 4 , 4.  0000 0 0 0 00 0 0 0  0
i fiifrt:••••••:••••••trit:;::

1. o  0:40:00• 4 p:
.
II •
I O W .1.4r .
k il.4 I  oo CS
);14,70 •NI: • 000000000
•
ll
1. 0 1. 4 14  • Niel
"D e e • I •••••• • ° O•••  II
.410 . 0 4 • ND a
We gie t in: ..1
EFTA00003002 (Jmail)
-mgmlie ..
EFTA00003007 (Jmail)
ft"
0 4.
senr••••••TtInfirr41111nanm•eoreeteeel
Winir"
lin

-
S,
.1
I
1
•

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ eal               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00003009 (Jmail)
a
-air.
‘
-
EFTA00003011 (Jmail)
(7rwirrieF7'
r.
- Pr

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003024 (Jmail)
rum, I
11111111'11Iff111111iiiir lees tttttttttt
EFTA00003026 (Jmail)
t• .9 e 1 V I a x*
n
Hitt.. i r4p:1 I I \
•
EFTA00003027 (Jmail)
Cr.:E %PIECE
7
te
15 -"\-- 16 17
44 e,v-\c"Artie
N ........._
21 122 23 24 25 Is
t?' ,,Th DJ .
F.WIT Sfirtlati% is aria&
Miminagrainv
t.fctum its Dar
1

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003028 (Jmail)
.31,_ 0%0PS
Nebii &mai
Turks - Ca ree^
EFTA00003030 (Jmail)
FCCE Designed by Apple in California Assembled in China Complies with the Canadian ICES-003 Class B specifications. 
Apparaten skall anslutas till jordat
nätpttag. MOdel Number: A1311 100-240V—, 50-60Hz 4.0A. Contains FCC ID: QDS-BRCM1029 and IC: 4324A-BRCM1029 and FCC ID: 
PPD-ARSBXB92 and IC: 4104A-AR5I8X(392
Ill 11llllllllllllllilllfll HI Ill Seri zd No.: W804736DDAS EMC No.: 2389
EFTA00003031 (Jmail)
Service Tag: 8G LM0Q2
Express
Service Code: 18418016810
EFTA00003032 (Jmail)
Reg Model: D19M
Reg Type: D19M005
Assembled in Mexico
DP DP/N- K41DX ADO JSD2
EFTA00003033 (Jmail)
OCNFA335 CS, FCC 0: PPOOCNFAM ,

IC. 4104AGCNFA135
NIC CMAteaStop, 081 04 31odaros
Typo
sixesailiunc 02124000010
TRCAP0,2013/219 1070 _
t ercz,FMACTI944.54 11/01P.CRWATN-OCNIA335
814R Vettlure. ES S
ctic cum &IL eL 7raNDI 21 CPC NOIN0Y0  by PTA. yw  203 DPN NACT A00
Reg Model: D19M
Reg Type: 019M005
Assembled in Mexico
CAN ICES-3 (B)/NMI3-3 (B)
DP
V: 100-240 V-
A: 5.4A
Hz: 5040 Hz
USTED I TE 1105106
www.dell.com
DP/N: K41DX A00 JSD2
EFTA00003034 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters,
Suite
B-3,
St.
Thomas.
VI
00802-1348
Phone:
E-mail:
thesaintjames.group@email.com
Emergency
Contact
Form
Today's
Date:
Employee
Name:
Physical
Address:
Mailing
Address:
Cell
Phone:
E-mail: Title/Position:
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:
[IStimn
We\
6.11‘tv.tss
0,..b
€)0
40
-
Phone
(other):
Marital
Status:
Drivers
License
No:
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
AJ
gU
Blood
type:
A-
Di
A+
D
AB-
D
AB+
O
B-
B+
D
o-
Current
Medications:
Doctor's
Name:
Doctor's
Name:
0
O+
0
Unknown
N/A
In
case
of
emergency,
please
contact:
Name: Name:
Relationship: Relationship:
Doctors
Phone:
Doctors
Phone:
J
Phone: Phone:
This
information
is for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003035 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
•
F
Today s Date:
LSJE, LLC 6100 Red Hook Quarters, Suite B-3. St. Thomas. VI 00802-1348
Phone E-mail: thesaintjames.group@umaii.com
Emergency Contact Form
Employee Name: IC4:1/44eLT&S D tor._
Physical Address:
Mailing Address:
Cell Phone:
E-mail:
Title/Position:
Start Date:
Date of Birth:
07
5T H-OMA S 1 (x)SOa-i
Phone (other):
Marital Status:
Driver's License No:
'sr 1-ti-zpv\AS Octs.c4.
I -Si na) k
Allergies or Health Concerns:
NIA Blood type:
❑A- El A+ DAB- AB+ El 84- D O. O 0+ Errelnknown
Current Medications: I N' Ac
Doctor's Name: N
Doctor's Name:
Doctor's Phone:
Doctor's Phone:
in case of emergency, piease contact:
Name:
Name:
Relationship:
Relationship:
ENS
tvkalltEC—
Phone:
Phone:
This information is for your safety and the safety of others.
EFTA00003036 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
r
iDecl tleC'
All
Cul
Do
Do
In C
Nan
Today's Date:
GDYVNe le-I-R
LSJE, LLC
6100 ook uarters, Suite B-3, St Thomas. VI 00802-1348
Phone E-mail: thesaintjames.grouregmail.com
Emergency Contact Form
041D In
Employee Name: Dale Mirk
Physical Address:
Mailing Address:
Cell Phone:
E-mail:
Title/Position:
Start Oate:
Date of Birth: {
j
Phone (other):
Marital Status:
Drivers License No:
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood type:
A- O A+ O AB- ❑ AB+ B- 0 8+ D 0- O o+ O Unknown
Current Medications: !
Doctor's Name:
Doctor's Name:
Doctor's Phone:
Doctor's Phone: [.
in case of emergency, please contact:
Name: I Relationship:
Name: I Relationship:
fl
Phone:
Phone:
This information is for your safety and the safety of others.
EFTA00003037 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters,
Suite
B-3,
St.
Thomas.
VI
00802.1348
Phone:
-E-mail:
thesaintjames.eroup@gmail.com
Emergency
Contact
Form
PI
Today's
Date:
Employee
Name:
Physical
Addres1
Mailing
Address
Cell
Phone:
E-mail: Title/Position:
Aohd
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:
7t.
Th
en
h
VI
°Or°
Sit
I-0/
-M.9"
MOM),VS

00F02
-
Phone
(other):
Marital
Status:
Drivers
License
No:
Th
ritried
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
N/A
-
At: Ste Cur Do Do In Nan
Blood
type:
M
A-
E
A,
❑
AB-
AB+
O
8-
O
8+
O
0-
O
0+
'Unknown
Current
Medications:
Doctors
Phone:
Doctor's
Phone:
Doctor's
Name:
pisj
m,
rry-z
Doctors
Name:
n case
of
emergency,
please
contact:
Name'
ICheill
A
itfti
i
Relationship:
%L45t
Phone:
Name:
Relationship:
Phone:
an
This
information
is for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ elias              │
│                    │
│ a                  │
│ y) AdUSST:         │
│                    │
│ Arapos aya pun hap │
│ THO JOeIUO,        │
╰────────────────────╯
EFTA00003039 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
N•R C Al Cu Dc Dc In
(
Nar
;Aar
-D
ec
40
Coyvtle
e
Today's
Date:
Employee
Name:
Physical
Address:
Mailing
Address:
Cell
Phone:
E-mail: Title/Position:
LSJE,
LLC
6100
ers,
Suite
8-3,
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802-1348
Phone:
E-mail:
thesaintjames.group@gmail.com
Emergency
Contact
Form
Aiicitoias
Vir4vitt
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:
Phone
(other):
Marital
Status:
Driver's
License
No:
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
type:
A-
D
A+
❑
AB-
O
AB+
❑
B-
O
El+
D
0-
E
0+
D
Unknown
Current
Medications:
Doctors
Name:
Doctor's
Name:
Doctor's
Phone:
Doctor's
Phone:
in
case
of
emergency,
please
contact:
Name, Name:
Rclationahip. Relationship:
Phone: Phone:
This
information
is for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others.
EFTA00003040 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
011
:ut
)o.
.1) tclz AAP 40
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook uarters, Suite B-3. St. Thomas. VI 00802-1348
Phone: E-mail: thesaintjames.grop@gmail.com
Emergency Contact Form
Today's Date:
Employee Name:
Physical Address:
Mailing Address:
Cell Phone:
E-mail:
Title/Position:
Start Date:
Date of Birth:
Phone (other):
Marital Status:
Driver's License No:
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood type:
A- O A+ O AB- D AB+ E B- 0 Br. C 0- O O4- O Unknown
Current Medications: I
Doctor's Name:
Doctor's Name:
Doctors Phone:
Doctors Phone:
In case of emergency, please contact
Name:
Name:
Relationship:
Relationship:
Phone:
Phone:
This information is for your safety and the safety of others.
EFTA00003041 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters, Suite B-3. St. Thomas. VI 00802-1348
Phone: E-mail: thesaintjames.group@gmaii.com
Emergency Contact Form
••••••••••
:y I
He;
r.
dl at
lam
lam
an E
i Lou
kie X
Today's Date: -z - 9,e /9
Employee Name: I )9/e, R‘ks-isisTe
Physical Address:
Mailing Address:
Cell Phone:
Tide/Position:
Start Date:
Date of Birth:
,s0/4 5 or? ov-,2(
rho/m.16 -1/
Phone (other):
Marital Status:
Drivers license No:
Allergies or Health Concerns:
I , Unitnc,,yr
Current Medications: i
Doctors Name: i
Doctor's Name:
Doctors Phone:
Doctors Phone:
In case of emergency, please contact.
Name: I Relationship:
Name: 7) etity
)3>ovi c)-
Relationship:
Phone:
This information is for your safety and the safety of others.

╭──────── Page 1, Image 1 ─────────╮
│ safety and the safety of others. │
╰──────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003043 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. I homes, VI 00802 Tell Fax: ."
Date: 03/22/18
Employee Name: fivrilare Lot;da!
•
Emergency Contact Form
Start Date: 03/22/18
Date of Birth:
E-Mail:
Marital Status: Married License:
ergency Information:
None
Allergies or Health Concerns: Blood type unspecified
Blood Type:
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name: Dodglas
Doctor's Name: Dodglas
Phone:
Phone:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact :
Relationship Wife
..Memo Relationship In Law
Phone
Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003044 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
•
1 sok
uarters,
Suite
B-3,
St.
Thomas.
VI
00802-1348
Phone:
E-mail:
thesaintjames.group@gmail.com
Emergency
Contact
Form
Today's
Date:
110/17/18
Employee
Name:
Brian
Bates
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:
Physic3!
Address:
Mailing
Address:
Cell
Plior
E-mail. Title/Position:
IGOntrader
Phone
(other):
Marital
Status:
Driver's
License
No:
Single
IM
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
type:
El
A-
O
A+
lE
AB-
El
AB+
El
8-
lit
O
O.
El
O+
Unknown
Current
Medications:
h
ne
Doctors
Name:
Doctor's
Name:
Jamie
Reed
None
Doctors
Phone:
Doctor's
Phone:
In
case
of
emergency,
please
contact:
Name: Name:
Relationship: Relationship:
Girlfriend
Phone: Phone:
This
information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others.
EFTA00003046 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite 8-3 St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel: 340-775-8100 Fax: 340-775-8108
Emergency Contact Form
Date: OS is Start Date:
Employee Name: Cristobal Hidalgo Herrera
Address: Date of Birth:
Phone
Title / Position:
Millikt.nergency Information:
Cell: E-Mail:
Marital Status Licen,
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood Type:
Current Medication
Doctor's Name:
Doctor's Name:
Sone
8:..xio type unspecified
Phone:
Phone:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact :
Relationship &other Phone
Relationship Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003047 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel: 340-775-8100 Fax: 340-775-8108
Emergency Contact Form
Date:
Employee Name: Cuthbert F Titre
Start Date:
ema V1 00602 Address: St Th Date of Birth:
Phone: Cell: E-Mail:
itle / Position: Marital Status: Single License:
^-•_____ •
---mergency Information.
Allergies or Health Concerns.
Blood Type:
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name: mono Juelle
Doctor's Name:
Phone:
Phone:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact :
Relationship Sister Phone
Relationship soother Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003048 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
[look
Quarters
Suite
B-3
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802
Tel:
ax:
Date:
)4'10/18
Employee
Name:
Deice
Gusneme
Address: Phone:
le
/ Position
-
..—
L:41. ZIF.mergeocy
Informal
it
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
Type:
Current
Medication:
Emergency
Contact
Form
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:!
E-Mail:
Marital
Status:
Married
License:
Blood
type
not
specified
Doctor's
Name:
Pho►re:
Doctor's
Name:
Phone:
In
case
of
an
Emergency,
Please
contact
:
Relationship
Sister
Phone
Relationship
Phone
This
Information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others
EFTA00003049 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel: 340-775-8100 Fax: 340-775-8108
'H"
Emergency Contact Form
Date: 06/04/18
Employee Name: Danny Etienne
Address:
'tvititE
Title / Posit.:'i.: Ma •
Start Date:
Date of Birth:
C tit E-Mail:
Marital Status: Single License:
Emergency Information:
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood Type: L
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name: Dodglas Phone:
Doctor's Name: Dodglas Phone:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact:
Name Maria Relationship
ame Relationship
Etienne Phone
Girlfriend Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003051 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters
Suite
B-3
St.
Thomas.
VI
00802
Tel:
Fax:
Emergency
Contact
Form
Date:
04:10/18
Employee
Name:
Dorn
B.
Donissaint
Address:
Tomas.
VI
00802
Phone.
Scslt‘Oi
nereency Allergies
or
Health
COMIKIll%
Blood
Type:
Current
Medication:
Doctor's
Name:
Doctor's
Name:
Start
Date:
04/10/18
Date
of
Birth:
E-Mail:
Marital
Status:
Married
License:
8;cod
type
not
specified
Phone: Phone:
In
case
of
an
Emergency,
Please
contact
:
Relationship Relationship
Phone Phone
This
Information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others
EFTA00003052 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters
Suite
B-3
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802
Tel:
340-775-8100
Fax:
340-775-8108
Emergency
Contact
Form
Stmergenqi
is
r.
Date:
06/14118
Start
Date:
Employee
Name:
Feta°
Joseph
Address: Dnoni, Allergies
or
Health
Corcerns:
Blood
Type:
Current
Medication:
Doctor's
Name:
Doctor's
Name:
Ces::
Date
of
Birth:
E-Mail:
Marital
Status:
Single
License:
Phone: Phone:
In
case
of
an
Emergency,
Please
contact:
Name
Jennifer
Relationship
a
ilName
Fay
Girlfriend
Phone
Relationship
sister
Phone
This
Information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others
EFTA00003053 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel ax:
Date: 03/19/18
Employee Name: GaSJ Leatham
Address:
Phone:
Title / Position: Landscapi"g
Emergency Contact Form
Start Date:
Date of Birth:
E-Mail:
Marital Status: Single License:
/4
4Thergency Informatioi,
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood Type:
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name:
Doctor's Name:
Phone:
Phone:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact:
Name
),me
Relationship Girlfriend Phone
Relationship Sister Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003054 (Jmail)
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red I look Quarters Suite B-S St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel:
(:ontact urm
Date: 03/20/18
Employee Name: (Amy litre
Address: :A !homes VI 00802 Date of Birth:
Start Date:
Phone: Cell E-Mail: n/a
Title / Position: Mathtenat.ce Marital Status: Married License:
Illr4nergency Information:
Allergies or Health Concerns.
Blood Type:
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name: itc.: Il,,s I aiiiily Phone:
Doctor's Name: Phone:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact:
Navin Valerie Relationship wife Phone
/Sane Cierrycia Relationship Daughter Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003055 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas. VI 00802 Tel: Fax:
Date: 03/19118
Employee Name: Hihan Bedminster
Address:
I nit? Positior:
Emergency Infornw
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood Type
SNOinD
Emergency Contact Form
Marital Status
Start Date:
Date of Birth:
E-Mail
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name: Phone:
Doctor's Name: Phone:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact :
Relationship Mother Phone Name
me Ann Relationship Amy Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003056 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
•
a
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel: ax
Date: : • -
Employee Name: Cesar
Address:
Thone:
Emergency Contact Form
Start Date: 05/04/17
Date of Birth:
E-Mail:
Title / Position: Ca,,.- Marital Status: Married License:
.. Cergency Info• •
Allergies or Healt
Blood Type:
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name:
Doctor's Name:
Phone:
Phone:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact:
Relationship
Relationship
Phone
Phone
This information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003057 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters
Suite
B-3
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802
Tel:
340-775-8100
Fax:
340.775-8108
Date: Employee
Name:
James
Cesar
Address: Phone:
Emergency
Contact
Form
Start
Date:
05/04/17
Date
of
Birth:
Cell:
E-Mail:
Title
/ Position:
Carpenter
Marital
Status:
Marne::
W
mergency
Info!
n:
Blood
Type:
!
Current
Medication:
Doctors
Name:
Doctor's
Name:
Phone: Phone:
In
case
of
an
Emergency,
Please
contact
:
Relationship Relationship
Phone
This
Information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others
EFTA00003058 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas. VI 00802 Tel: 340-775-8100 Fax: 340-775-8108
Date: 03/16/1B
Employee Name: Justina de Is Cruz
Emergency Contact Form
Start Date:
Address: Date of Birth:
Phone: Cad E-Mail:
Title / Position: Housekeeper Marital Status: Marred License:
nergency Information:
v.
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood Type:
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name:
Doctor's Name:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact:
Name Feliz de la Cruz
eaame Bembenido Gedeno
Relationship
Phone:
Phone:
Husband Phone
Relationship Brother Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003061 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
V 3
LSJE,
LLC
00
Red
Hook
Quarters
Suite
B-3
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802
Tel:
Fax:
Date:
C6'4'18
Employee
Name:
Michae
J G,caen
Emergency
Contact
Form
Start
Date:
04/20/18
Address:
rSJ
Date
of
Birth:
Phonc.
Cell:
E-Mail:
Title
/ Position:
Engineer
Marital
Status:
Divorce
License:
ergency
Information:
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
Type:
Current
Medication:
Doctor's
Name:
Phone:
Doctor's
Name:
Phone:
In
case
of
an
Emergency,
Please
contact:
Maine
Relationship Relationship
Son
Phone
Brother
Phone
This
Information
is
for
your
sofety
and
the
safety
of
others
EFTA00003062 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters
Suite
B-3
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802
Tel:
ay.
Emergency
Contact
Form
Date:
04
09
18
Start
Date:
Employee
Name:
Onel
Pierresaint
Address:
Date
of
Birth:
Phone:
Cell:
E-Mail:
Title
/ Position:
Marital
Status:
Married
License:
)nergency
Information:
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
type
uw.pe
Blood
Type:
Current
Medication:

Doctor's
Name:
Rosa'
Josemp
Phone:
Doctor's
Name:
Phone:
In
case
of
an
Emergency,
Please
contact
:
Relationship
SI'
Relationship
Wife
Phone
Friend
Phone
This
Information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others
EFTA00003063 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters
Suite
B-3
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802
Tel:
340-775-8100
Fax:
340-775-8108
Date:
03/19/18
Employee
Name:
Oriole
Joseph
Address: Phon Title/
Position:
Maintenance
limergency
Information:
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
Type:
Current
Medication:
Doctor's
Name:
Doctor's
Name:
Emergency
Contact
Form
Blood
type
unspecified
Start
Date:
10/01/16
Date
of
Birth
E-Mail:
Marital
Status:
Single
License:
Phone: Phone:
In
case
of
an
Emergency,
Please
contact
:
Relationship
Phone
Relationship
Co
usin
Phone
This
Information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others
EFTA00003064 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
L
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel:
3
Date: 03 19:8
Employee Name: Pd rick L. Cena
Address:
Phone
Title / Position: Captain
imergency Information:
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood Type:
Current Medication:
Doctor's Name:
Doctor's Name:
Emergency Contact Form
Fax
Start Date: 02t05/18
S.€ x 1 s vi 00802 Date of Birth:
Cell:
No blood type spectfied
In case of an Emergency, Please contact :
Name
ante
E-Mail:
Marital Status: Divorce License:
Relationship
Phone:
Phone:
Father/Stepmother Phone
Relationship Fnend Phone
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003065 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
as
Today's
Date:
Employee
Name:
Physical
Address:
Mailing
Address:
Cell
Phone:
E-mail: Title/Position:
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
I look
Quarters,
Suite
13-3,
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802-1348
Phone:
E-mail:
thesaintjames.group@gmail.com
110/21/18 Peter
St
Omer
Operator
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
type:
Current
Medications:
Doctor's
Name:
Doctors
Name:
N/A
In
case
of
emergency,
please
contact
Name: Name:
kishma 'Demers
Emergency
Contact
Form
Relationship: Relationship:
Friend !Son
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth:
Phone
(other):
Marital
Status:
Driver's
license
No:
Doctors
Phone:
Doctor's
Phone:
!Married
Phone: Phone:
This
information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others
Unknown
EFTA00003066 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
3
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters
Suite
B-3
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802
Tcl:
Fax:
Date:
03/25/18
Employee
Name:
Pierre
Jules
Address: Phone Title
/ Position:
Emergency
Contact
Form
Start
Date:
Date
of
Birth
E-Mail:
n
limergency
Information:
n a
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Bloo0
type
unspecified
Blood
Type:
I
_
Current
Medication:
Doctor's
Name:
rVa
Doctor's
Name:
n/a
Phone:
n/a
Phone:
we
In
case
of
an
Emergency,
Please
contact:
Relationship
Brother
Phone
Relationship
Friend
Phone
This
Information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others
EFTA00003068 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters
Suite
B-3
St.
Thomas,
VI
00802
Tel
Fax:
Date:
04/09/18
Emergency
Contact
Form
Start
Date:
Employee
Name:
Date
of
Birth:
Address: Phone:
E-Mail:
Title
/ Position:
Marital
Status:
License:
lmergency
Information:
Allergies
or
Health
Concerns:
Blood
Type:
Current
Medication:
Doctor's
Name:
Phone:
Doctor's
Name:
Phone:
In
case
of
an
Emergency,
Please
contact:
Relationship
Phone
Relationship
Pastor
phone
This
Information
is
for
your
safety
and
the
safety
of
others
EFTA00003069 (Jmail)
 [business] emergency contact form for employee of Epstein's LSJE
LSJE, LLC
6100 Red Hook Quarters Suite B-3 St. Thomas, VI 00802 Tel: 340-775-8100 Fax: 340-775-8108
Emergency Contact Form
Date: 09/10/18
Start Date: 08/26/2018
Employee Name: Stephanie Remington
Address:
Phone:
Title / Position: Asst to Manager
Slergency Information:
Allergies or Health Concerns:
Blood Type:
Current Medication:
18-1-3 Estate Smith Bey 00002
Cell: E-Mail:
Marital Statu,, single License:
Doctor's Name: Island Health 8, Wellness Center Phone
Doctor's Name:
In case of an Emergency, Please contact:
Relationship
Relationship
Phone:
Enema ''hone
l'none
This Information is for your safety and the safety of others
EFTA00003073 (Jmail)
•-essirassellolso
EFTA00003075 (Jmail)
••• Sri. •
"waft "
EFTA00003080 (Jmail)
`Yr"'" •••,•‘C ;-;

•  lir Yr •w-
- • 4-

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ee PERtLOLA +     │
│                   │
│ Srorave Area      │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00003085 (Jmail)
(TR- OTTO
c(4.3411

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003092 (Jmail)
4
1 7,
4

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ P                 │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00003096 (Jmail)
DATE
CASE ID
LOCATION PREPARER/PHOTOGRAPIIER REMARKS
PHOTOS
DESCRIPTION
OF
PHOTOGRAPHIC
SUBJECT
/ MISCELLANEOUS
COMMENTS

╭───────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────────────╮
│ NTS                                                        │
│                                                            │
│ PHOTO #                                                    │
│                                                            │
│ SESCRIPTION OF PHOTOGRAPHIC SUBJECT / MISCELLANEOUS COMME! │
│                                                            │
│ Couet Sheek Frada Hear = Zoo C                             │
│ Putrto bench Hawes = Zane ©                                │
│ Exhcia beach Meumeue Zane C                                │
│ feria Bench lean - 2o~8 C                                  │
│ ch hase = Zone C Bt                                        │
│ fy Sic al tual > Beach brace — au Gd                       │
│ Sk B42 ldantiting Musaloers—- Braletuse - Zone ©           │
│ Ennee ety Conte ato Pouch thase = Cane ©                   │
│ Exit roils Beash Haase ~ Zone ©                            │
│                                                            │
│ Cour sheok dilly bumble = Cons C                           │
│                                                            │
│ UAL buentbeg= Dasa                                         │
│                                                            │
│ es A ecg * Ttacagg Ato - Zyre C                            │
│                                                            │
│ Desuss 2 Sracung Men = Zora                                │
│                                                            │
│ Groxto - dere C                                            │
│ heck Sword Zan C                                           │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003097 (Jmail)
╭───────────── Page 1, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ DATE __©__/_!2_/ Zou                      │
│                                           │
│ CASE ID B\E- BY -307454)                  │
│                                           │
│ |                                         │
│                                           │
│ LOCATION __L-rrrce St. Janes Tsravp, USVI │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003099 (Jmail)
tf.

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ‘ Sees            │
│                   │
│ hoe Eh            │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00003102 (Jmail)
╭───── Page 1, Image 1 ──────╮
│ i                          │
│ =e                         │
│ L Lt                       │
│                            │
│ GA NWA NEA NGANSA NERA ANS │
╰────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003109 (Jmail)
Fart) €1. th e •
tarty of e -e 1..•
rant. sell. “cvey colt•
escceasca• and ataten• of te bee
•LePle ahnlot••
ea that e•ttitlis plot. s•L‘
Irpreneest• thereat that say F.,••.•^ 11, ••, •
s;/ -r-2/
il l/
MITI) PT. JIMS ISLUID

so. 60 ha d Hoot Quarter
0.5. virile lislead•
?COMO" trith th e sdputtenanota thatnnto tetert9n9 andell led
000000 0 inn and rtaht• of the party Of the   Pert In and to nld
premien.
Prettelft. to  being reesuletleee. to orisot . metrical.,
ant *este of record. to Virile Island§ Laos sol to Unite. tttttt laws.
yo yet l  IC Web the prealsee herein greeted tote the pent
of the been. part. the Mire. rett .4140028 and •••.9e of the Pant of the
secord tort Careen. M fee Staple neOlUte•
tab LS piety of the tint part Oineente and WIIITIPM4 as fellow.

1. ?St eald petty of the fleet part la aslant of tie said
fl ier In fee simple, and Ida sped gar to Many nip

2. TIM th e Pelt Of Um mama pert shall quietly enjoy th e
Sit premiSest
1. Oat the Meld peOadea an feed las essedtrances. tug '
Se efarlealt
WIF4/Ct. I Ipirvint0 wet my bard cod of f Ic1.1 N
of  61/4
Arnrio  *A4S
MAL)
Arige2eldieSeder
PPRRIPOPY Cr In SlOdfil MAWS
/ tem
Olitnef CI ST. TIMM a Pr. JOBS
On this the ji toy Of Ingest  . personally appearedfl  CaltOCIP. Pe•OlOnt of Cnerto• Rnet tea•• hone tO atoto he fa•  In
n" .teat nee is entnertbsd ati
prooldent of Cretan tante. lea.. Wotan la part for yelsPIR Circe PfatAtt innfor2. Ain.% CPSOUE. *MUM CIttOCE LaCtIfft.
rit • y 37,110.S. IrriT a ) • ..41 r E,1.0711 t . no -r n • • . • . .
pidafil. (3! ,bs .11 t•n • .1 bald Prt
for the Forione tParelp. ontalnel.
due
*MDR III MOM nomorsterre
4allaiNctfluarzw.mnawiterts jvfralLancatartalli6.-
fOR ,a
su347iic1. au•
ti
et
! N IA,
ygte- e
"
EFTA00003113 (Jmail)
S CLEM
F.PLACE
TOOLS!!

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003114 (Jmail)
a.k_Sck t IC.: fl-77474-12*-iat
EFTA00003115 (Jmail)
Virkit
W.443 lalt,MSRMitfff:
Chis!al
CONNECT ONLY TO GROUNDED OUTLET.
APPARATET MA 11IXOFIES JORDET STIKKONTAKT.
APPARATEN SKALL ANSLUTAS TRL JORDET
NATTUTAG
MITE ON LITTETTAVA SUOJAKOSKETTINIUA
VARUSTETTUUN PISTOILASLAAN.
APPARATETS STIKPROP SKAI TILSLUTTES EN
STIKKONTAKT MED JORD. SOM GWER
FORRINDELSE 11. STIKPROPPENS JORD.
liftfq*ttkt~iffilf.?64
820582-OW
,.
OS ICES-3163/444-8-3181 .114494, Isaac •3311~1,, CMI1T 1O 2016011509 - -• Conwmo de &new" 16 VII. ffif (4, En rnocin 44 
4-43644 0 8 3141-,
451 83/5.01:11112 0 i 4 Eli ; Fe & 9 *'.)
2141
CE CC)RS WM
LTE
non 44~44, •4144448p4*- F14643  C...ceny TK.W034.14
( KT
SISS :157 0', 0? 0042
ø HP Slimline 260-a010 DT PC US
38E
BMWS RT1.8723BERF
II FCC 10: TX2-137O37238E
6317A-RIL)3733BE
CT RCPRERT13-0876
CRC C-12047
(end
.625
CE Compbn 4r.
10A stand.. ds
04105382
(e( cc. r•
-,4j;w1ft )1EtE
•
Serial No. CNV7160050
III Product No. V8P51AAIMBA • 11111111111110 Model No. 260-a010 Limited Warranty: lytty/Oy
(V3T95AV)
BID= 16VVW3RST607#SABA#DABA
FeatureByte= 3E3K3N3Q4C4h6J6Z6b7B7K7P7T7W
a Bapagasa Ua2b7bhbptucbdUdpdge
Jegey.TE
BU IDS UMA Pent J3710
1111ANATEL
01P74401/62304446
MOM mElp-CRM-RTX-RTLE72311ENF
352.06801.0004
r i.M*?.""» .
www.hp.comlgolsupportassistant • 'TIK
EFTA00003117 (Jmail)
5ff raPPOATCH encore IEFME
CaNICYPO 10 Mt POY42 SUPPLY
&ft VINIORIPA flt
WlelltatTIOMPfrit
..14=t •-•L-e;
canCl env TO GIOJCED CUTLET
OPADAYFT Alt waits otv swortua
*nage. , SJ1i *MUMS np Jaw
parmAs
Unf Cta ;SEWN.% SUOAXOSIOTTIMLA
v4u$11MULN nstnisa*AN
aunts SraltOr SaAT nswnts f.
SrlaattuCT m101010. SCIA GNTR
1011114%.LSI m SIK/r1101S 1010
ItITIVAttaiitttitti*.
1205St<0,

• IrK
mut, re16.6.0.1epoK
itCOLATOIM 1•000 4•Xiike*IS :Mt Viteali orowthArlaA or mar tar 47A
PAO WI 0••••••4
CAN 105-3
••
CSIMNitte• CAC JO 20,6011,00
M.
ERE* FC & 0 @ 4,16.1130/•/1014. 2141
C E E 00-m.  ;Eit9[Ma/ Mt Nat. Tins •••••••• tww •••••.i. 11.4 If 2 WO. CO.)
0a
RE)
HP Sllmline 260,3010 DT PC US
Serial No. CNV716004Y
Product No. V8P61AAAABA
Limited Warranty ty/ly/Oy
IV3ISSAVI
Model No. 260-a010
BID. 16WW3RST6071SAIMADABA
Featuretlytta 3E3K3N3Q4C4h6J6Z601B7K7P7T7W
aEtapadasataz07trhbotocOdUdOdde
Jegey.TE
BU IDS UMA Pent J3710
Reseieee faunae
vow enslave met edflalef
AIYIS0411TIMMI
*Va. eepreerimem
teen min
OA Illardnis
0.4•06262
It Uar ',Whet
bit U. &tilt at: t•
N••••0MSs 141•0•JAIKA nleew
312 MAW ION
www.hp.comlgolsupportassistant
•
EFTA00003140 (Jmail)
•
IMOMOOVUIPOWIXIMOX
:u mini

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ISSSOGGZUMIXEKGX  │
│ 18 1 A 1          │
│                   │
│ wn                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00003142 (Jmail)
Lenovo. Neu
= AIM MI MI6 WOO Imo IOWA NY -N AN nomo/ %Wm TIN NM • NIONIIIIM
MILIMON/
how PM" Mom*. INA • NMI tN IINo6 3 /HINSON. IN • - WO II N006 OWN
WMMIww Moo rompl Is ammo Om* Mb blame Om MP NNW ■
w-INr••
ININve
Mori Nom
Nov66 Moo
OM MI6 • V • IP
1 1111 I 1 11 11 11 11 11 1111111111 11 11 1111111 1 11 111 11 1 1 MILPINIOU IMMOttlIN
CE r *MOW
MOO loombove limb*
[ -IN'" IP CAN MN -Y till CAN NOON -3 IIII
A
E3
ES it.. out

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003146 (Jmail)
4.744 400
#11_, ea ,
*
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
CC=
111111111 'ain4.29m3

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003147 (Jmail)
╭─── Page 1, Image 1 ────╮
│ LITTLE st JAMES ISLAND │
│                        │
│ > Staff Manual” &      │
╰────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003148 (Jmail)
Principal
Residence
N
LSJE,
LLC
6100
Red
Hook
Quarters
Suite
B3
mas,
VI
00802-1348
Phone
/
Fax
New
York
Estate
9 East
71st
Street
v
rk,
New
Phone/
■
Zorro
Ranch
49
Zorro
Ranch
Road
Stanley.
New
M

hone/
Palm
Beach
Estate
358
Elbrilo
Way
Beach,
FL
33480
Phone
/
56
Paris
Apartment
22
Avenue
Foch,
Apt
2DD
75116
Paris,
France
'hone
/
Fax Fax  Fax Fax
A
EFTA00003150 (Jmail)
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Principle
TWA Head Pilot:
Assistant Pilot:
LSJE Manager:
Assistant Manager:
Head Boat Captain:
Boat Captain:
Barge Assistant:
(lead Housekeeper:
Housekeeper:
Housekeeper:
Landscaper Manager:
Landscaper Supervisor:
Landscaper:
Landscaper:
Landscaper:
Maintenance Supervisor:
Painter:
Painter:
Mechanical & Truck Driver:
Pool & RO Plant:
Heti Pad:
VI Port Authority:
Jet Center:
Airport:
TWA Piolot(s):
Larry Visoski
William Di Mauro
LSJE Employees
Larry Visoski
William Di Mauro
Ann M. Rodriquez
Danny Vicars
Carlos Rodriquez
Ramon Linderman
Guy Vicars
Basillia Morales-Mercado
Carmen Rodgers
Reyna Amparo
Christopher Sheehan
Peter St. Omar
Dupson Donissaint
Gusneme Dalce
Onel Pierressaint
Danny Vicars
Gerry Francis
Hilian Bedminister
Sheridan Elizee
Cuthbert Titre
TWA Employees & Flight Escorts
LSJE

St. Thomas Jet Center FBO (Fix Base Operation)
Thomas World Air Hanger - Jet Center STT
Cyril E. King Airport - St. Thomas
LSJE Escort(s):
Carlos Rodriguez
Jermaine Ruan
Ramon Linderman
Manager(s):
Roy Romney - VIPAA Ann Rodriquez - LSJE
EFTA00003153 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2001-10-01)
EmplOyeeS Nshielle
Etienne
IttiniEnee (lurte.
()lek
ri.4.4).il
I ICrIel.1
uthh:ri
I lue
\I.itt
I Linn).
\I‘C
,
\aini
i
10/1,1
CIII0
111,Crl,
( ;ad
CailLIM
lian))
i ngen):
()ert>
N.
hire
in.neine I filial)
Itedinin.ier
tame.
te..t: Ete
i a Etui
Ke‘liatin
NN
KCI:111
Ale‘antler

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003157 (Jmail)
sumeni
ALWAYSdCLEAN
&k REPLACE
TOOLS!!
EFTA00003862 (Jmail)
T A
r
i
I
I

╭──── Page 2, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

1
i

╭──── Page 5, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00003919 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003921 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003923 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003925 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003927 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003929 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003933 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003948 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00003951 (Jmail)
╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

burlwood
Collection
L70117 PHOTO FRAMES
8" x 10" in.
20x 25 cm.
Mantra.. ITALIAN MOULDING
MOULURE DALIENNE
Its-kasa•Mf,:s.gemigr.

╭──── Page 8, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 9, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

i
S
A

╭──── Page 14, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

I

╭──── Page 16, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 17, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

..••••
I
I
I
I
~/
i~
r-
I
A

╭──── Page 31, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

I
4

╭──── Page 43, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 45, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

•
!
_
I
AR V
PIONEWERS
P.O 110% 401431 • ORLANDO. Pl 32160 • (107) 1144100
-oral 41 —STYLE NO. 110.01
•

╭──── Page 51, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

e w 11, a ■
it
4
,OM 1.111
a 'MI
%\\-- 7 t.. s--)
=I
TI4MtlIONUA
•••/MaN ,  •••••• • PI \ OMNI llm••••••
LITAO

╭──── Page 53, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

11V-Aralt
AROMAS Pniarvss

ow. Sus armee • 1010.AIMMA n Meg • III•1311411410r
DAM ASS/ON/AVM
L
NOW VAILSION ROI DOWN MU MO. ISIS
.1r 379 7/8 Pli NO t
LifignalC nlit .MICHAIM PlOWIMISS
MI
■
z /ph I LC OW -II
..,
ON 11I
1 IA QS •11.0

A. nit, r,li111C OW HMI/ sel   '4 MIM,4It • III tine vng fl# filiknraircry,
Town of Palm Beach it -, es
Police Department its 1' . 01'?
EVIDENCE
CASE SCCike PROPERTY onnY
CONTENTS
Item Quantity Description
Susp ct:
Officer:

IA) it:
6I. -23I
eht ft 04140
Date:

╭──── Page 61, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00004051 (Jmail)
1B3-6

╭──── Page 2, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

---
1 2
4 4
0
3
6
CASE #
YOU WILL BE ASKED TO LOOK AT A GROUP OF PHOTOGRAPHS. THE FACT
THAT THE PHOTOGRAPHS ARE SHOWN TO YOU SHOULD NCT INFLUENCE YOUR
JUDGEMENT. YOU SHOULD NOT CONCLUDE OR GUESS THAT THE PHOTO-
GRAPHS CONTAIN THE PICTURE OF THE PERSON WHO commrrtro THE CRIME.
YOU ARE NOT OBLIGED TO IDENTIFY ANYONE IT IS JUST AS IMPORTANT TO
FREE INNOCENT PERSONS FROM SUSPICION AS TO IDENTIFY GUILTY PARTIES.
PLEASE DO NOT DISCUSS THE CASE WITH OTHER WITNESSES NOR INDICATE
IN ANY WAY THAT YOU HAVE IDENTIFIED SOMEONE.
SIGNED 6e` 14-4,i.J SIGNED
DATECOkTIME  a 40  OFFICER'S INI DATE TIME OFFICER'S INIT _
SIGNED SIGNED
DATE TIME OFFICER'S INIT. DATE TIME OFFICER'S IN I"
SIGNED SIGNED
DATE TIME OFFICER'S INIT. DATE TIME OFFICER'S INIT -
1-805-934.4224
FAX 1-805-934-4991
FILING SPECIALTIES
P.O. BOX 562
SANTA MARIA, CA 93456
STOCK NO. 134214-A
EFTA00004057 (Jmail)
SW Corner of 1-95 & Hallandale Bch Blvd 954-455-8318
Fri•
Mil
01.1
ADULT,
OM,/
NIMITI • We • 'haw rJ Sagai
et /A-tit read
viw.adaltst"
1$4.95
Al at nilassi g# I  g Pet
eW
Uji,aitif tilijiiwitilititak”init
''a<o- l2a
EFTA00004100 (Jmail)
╭──── Page 2, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

.ik
EFTA00004157 (Jmail)
1
i
CO.of.S0 69 8e6 0122+1-2-3+1-06 2
I
CO.of.S0 72 685 6122+1-2-3+1 FIN 2
i
I
O3.of.SD 66 605 0122+i-2-3+1-138 2
1
CO•of.SO 75 035 e122+1-2-3+1-13 2
co•of-SD 81 @GS 8122+1-2-3+1-15 2
CO.of.S0 84 995 01220-2-3+1-12 2
00.0f-SO 87 ON& I3122+1 -2-3+1 -11 2
U
•
CO.of.80 78 805 8122+1-2-3+1-05 2
CO.of.E* 82 @8Z 9122+1-2-3+1-87 2
CO.of.SD 943 OM 0122+1-2-3+1-16 2
CO•oi• SD 93 Ne e122+1-2-3+1-20 2
EFTA00004243 (Jmail)
╭──── Page 2, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00004245 (Jmail)
A

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

a
6
EFTA00005075 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00005381 (Jmail)
╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭─ Page 2, Image 1 ─╮
│ Corpen |          │
│                   │
│ x                 │
╰───────────────────╯

╭──── Page 4, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

a
EFTA00005486 (Jmail)
╭─────────── Page 1, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ IMG_2352.JPG IMG_2353.JPG IMG_2354.JPG │
│                                        │
│ IMG_2355.JPG IMG_2356.JPG              │
│                                        │
│ IMG_2358.JPG 2359.JPG IMG_2360 JPG     │
╰────────────────────────────────────────╯

╭─────────── Page 2, Image 1 ────────────╮
│ IMG_1520.JPG IMG_1521.JPG 522.JPG      │
│                                        │
│ aia IL                                 │
│                                        │
│ IMG_1523.JPG IMG_1525.JPG IMG_1526.JPG │
│                                        │
│ IMG_1527.JPG IMG_1533.JPG IMG_1537 JPG │
╰────────────────────────────────────────╯

╭─────── Page 3, Image 1 ────────╮
│ IMG_1540.JPG IMG_1541.JPG IMG. │
│                                │
│ faskah                         │
│                                │
│ IMG_1548.JPG                   │
╰────────────────────────────────╯

IMG_4726.JPG
IMG_4731.JPG
IMG_4736.JPG
IMG_4741.JPG
IMG_4746.JPG
Photographer:
I MG_4787.1PG IMG_4780.JPG
IMG, 4732.JPG IMG_4792..IPC;
IMG_4737.JPG IMG_4738.JPG
IM6_4742.JPG IMG_4743.JPG
IMG_4759.JPG IMG_4781.JPG
IMG_47S8.JPG IMG_4730.JPG
IMG_4734.JPG IMG_4735.JPG
IMG_4739.JPG IMG_4740.JPG
IMG_4744.JPG IM6_4745.JPG
IMG_4762.JPG IMG_4763.JPG

╭─ Page 4, Image 1 ─╮
│ AVERY®c           │
│ PVi19             │
╰───────────────────╯

IMG_4764.JPG
IMG_4756.JPG
IMG_4786.JPG
IMG_4775.JPG
imG_4794.JPG
Photographer:
IMG_4752.JPG IMG_4753.JPG
IMG_4766.JPG IMG_4783.JPG
946_4771 .JPG IMG_4793.JPG
IMG_4776.JPG IMG_4777.JPG
IMG_4795.JPG
IMG_4754.JPG IMG_4782.JPG
IMG_4784.JPG IMG_4785.JPG
IMG_4773.JPG IMG_4774.JPG
IMG_4778.JPG IMG_4779.JPG
Ct
JE 50 B-day
TIF P1010043%20
Macintosh HD:Ima w pics: TIF Macintosh HD:Ima w pics  TIF Macintosh HD:Imag...3%2
P1010041%2 4in
rée)
rite
Diner iP9
jpg
JE 50 B-day 07 TIF
iP9
Macintosh HD:linen. ..1%2a jpg Macintosh HIllmag. .. jpg Macintosh HD:Ima. ..E 50 B-day 07 TIF
JE 50 B -day 08.TIF JE 50 B -day 09.TIF JE 50 B-day 10 TIF
Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 08.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 09.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 10.TIF
Macintosh HD:Imag... pic- tt.TIF Macintosh HD:Imag... picsS.TIF Macintosh HD:Imag... picsIM6.111-
Macintosh HD:Imag... picsIM7.TIF Macintosh HD:Imag... picsing8.TIF Macintosh HD:Imag... picsIM9.TIF

╭──────────────────────────────────────── Page 7, Image 1 ────────────────────────────────────────╮
│ ate aetr err                                                                                    │
│                                                                                                 │
│ Macntosh HO:imag... lof. TIF Macintosh HOimag... pesfp-TIF Macintosh HO:imag... poffe-TF        │
│                                                                                                 │
│ Mier otr                                                                                        │
│                                                                                                 │
│ Macintosh HD:Imeg... pics7.TIF Macintosh HO:imag... picsfJe.TIF Macintosh HO:Imax... pics o.T1F │
│                                                                                                 │
│ Macintosh HO:Ima...w pics p-TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...w picdIH.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...w pics TIF   │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

JE 50 B-da
I
4
JE 50 B-day 17.TIF
JE 50 B-day 11.TIF JE 50 B-day 12.TIF JE 50 8-day 13.TIF
Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 11.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 12.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 13.TIF
JE 50 B-day 14.TIF JE 50 B-day 15.TIF JE 50 B-day 16.TIF
Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 14.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 15.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 16.TIF
DSCF0359_1.TIF DSCF0360_1.TIF
Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 17.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...:IDSCF0359_1.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...:DSCF0360_1.TIF
I
I
S
JE 50 B-day
Sit,
JE 50 B-day 18.TIF JE 50 B-day 19.TIF JE 50 B-day 20.TIF
Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 18.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 19.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 20.TIF
JE 50 B-day 21.TIF 17.TIF M8.TIF
Macintosh HD:Ima...E 50 B-day 21.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...ffrey:
)9.TIF
7.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...ffreyM8.TIF
M O.TIF 0 T1F
Macintosh HD:Ima...ffrey.9.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...tfrey:M10.TIF Macintosh HD:Ima...rey:M1 0.7 IF
1 I
EFTA00005536 (Jmail)
Looking
For a
Way Out
•
•
•
•
•
•
EFTA00005538 (Jmail)
ONCE VPON th, •••
TrIAER.E WAS A CLVELS $5
LITTLE GIRL ...
HOW L o ,
I Look. 2 1
----M7A01)
THEN... WHAT t5
He 0004014
,
W
wiz n
‘ 1\ LITTLE GIRL se.

╭─ Page 9, Image 1 ─╮
│ 15 MY COVER       │
│ BLOWN %           │
╰───────────────────╯

╭──── Page 11, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 12, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 13, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 14, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 15, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭─ Page 16, Image 1 ─╮
│ ST.SARTHS          │
╰────────────────────╯

Its-

╭──── Page 17, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 20, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

I• •
EFTA00005563 (Jmail)
CSAM
NOT
SCANNED
CSAM
NOT
SCANNED
11.114011 n MOM. 'Willi it WIIAdW
a.
."." IMAM ZZ "(IAN LZ
1 1 1 1 1 5
YdlhdW OZ YdIAdW •
"
•
WUhdW ^ YdIAdW tt
S t
ilillnelli n imam -- %Pm
timaingur
41 w•
el i 1: . 4-I' * I A' •404.. ,  ' 1 •
-
- Ililleow ,, iiiii4iimi --- iiiiimiliN 0, mama+ iiiii4IIW • minima -- ihmow • miiini
011
II I 1
t • •

╭─── Page 4, Image 1 ────╮
│ ‘ wan TD Rea Ue ee Ree │
│                        │
│ Pn ee ee ee            │
│                        │
│ Pn ee en eC er ce      │
│                        │
│ ws See j i 4 -         │
│                        │
│ Se RO Ree TL RO en Re  │
╰────────────────────────╯
EFTA00005586 (Jmail)
 [legal] completely redacted 69 pages labeled "Grand Jury - NY"
EFTA00005763 (Jmail)
╭── Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ [lam 4/31 [29!7     │
│                     │
│ Ctarbacks std B® Ae │
╰─────────────────────╯

x m WoR i4PfzeD
Ny
S S-
/7,ageaf, •
CA/ Arys DL.
/1147ie 7-•••
(.?cleo!A745-4e-geo
1-e-1
tin*. psi, Mole-
alAstroct)
ISM mew i TIAN P-  rvettaiy.
51\flrak - St ; 'vied YN.SIN
cardiei +6-adv1"9 koila rct4tkr -
vvcoeAir4 vtity-L)46
(Vertu a Lanit

╭────────────── Page 3, Image 1 ───────────────╮
│ a(o\\\r                                      │
│ (30am                                        │
│                                              │
│ Wee invited 4 ary.                           │
│ york ey Sy} hie — irtoresled ?               │
│                                              │
│ Balhimeart)                                  │
│                                              │
│ \Wiolw crew - in Prete Rico, Nvtlivey filmed │
│                                              │
│ Sprapped ak - Je, added tan                  │
│ Girl pak Qarkes frgehatv, lalla, fiiacer     │
│ \nareed in YAS clus Caawhaylan).             │
│                                              │
│ [By                                          │
│ = az                                         │
│                                              │
│ Nery ale / lim,                              │
╰──────────────────────────────────────────────╯

eJusticeNY Integrated Justice Portal Page I of I
rH•tteekt eJusticeNYINTEGRATED JUSTICE PORTAI.
. Peocle • DMV Photo STStera • prif Photo Request V Feedback
IDMV Photo Request
Sub act Information
ClientID:
Case Number:
DMV Transaction Number:
2019-06-06 14:49:54:870 DMV Transaction Date/Time:
Bach
Ft) 0 ta Site 'iliac> S to June 6, 2019 2:49 PM EDT
.. 6/6/2019
EFTA00005774 (Jmail)
Nys c 22r Atanny ve.4
1- 117‘
at-f -
Aimecss-
e7y) /A17/
N s
.5SAL' a um .

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

DMV Photo
Subject Information
Name:
ClientiD:
Case Number: SI
DMV Transaction Number: 1069006
DMV Transaction Date/Time: 2019-06-05 18:36:18:690
Last updated: 01108/2017
Request for NYS DMV P OTO IMAGE
To: New York Ops Center (NYOC)
[office: 212-384-2921; fax: 212-384-4073 or 4074)
Requestor Email: Sq t ad: e--;

1) Name & Rank of Requestor.
MUST be Special Agent or other 3,
2) Name & Rank of Supervisor:
MUST be Supervisory Special Agent or of

3) Subject Name:
4) DMV Client ID # (Nine Digits):
If nn Client ID available, include Subject's D rB
role one):
ant Investigation Witness Investigation

6) Exigent Circums ances (if applicable)*:
Comments
Ir***sh*******—Ir
--n.freevisac e support personnel
Missing Person Investigation

7) Case number:
8) Phone number of Requestor:
The requestor acknowledges that the mquested image cannot be used as filjgg in a phot
in an any if the subject of the DMV photo is the subject in the photo array. A new request
unrelated criminal investigation. The digital image obtained will not be saved in a database
subsequent use unrelated to the original investigation.
I hereby certify that the above-requested DMV Photo Image b relevant to as a
my knowledge, the subject of interest possesses a driver's II e, learner's permit or non
New York State DA J and acknowledge hat I r oat was for an hope
ature) Date
*When the exigent circumstances exception applies, the "Comments" section must identify the t
urgency. In addition, the "Request for DNS/ Photo Imago — Exigent Cncwmtances" form must
requesting agency.
1' it.
Investigation and that, to the best of
;river identtlleatIon card issued  the
1 ... Me jurrpose I may be subject to
y, the OW photo may only be used
r a photo image must be made for any
stored in any manner for secondary or
/,
f investigation and explain the
pitted and retained by the
EFTA00005878 (Jmail)
‘,,s\
•Q
EMS
Aec.ehy-ec7 r//y Ogr cic r &At Mssimi
EFTA00005910 (Jmail)
[
I
Cat
Viffiett /6 Svi/beadvAlec)
ssN
/Mears. '
az.9,e‘v/ex; Ai/ /070
(Oertle en!)

╭───────────── Page 2, Image 1 ─────────────╮
│ « nee E——_—_—_—_                          │
│                                           │
│ VILLE: Ib Su byeu(whitey M4CMICK NY 10990 │
│ wy ( ORANGE C7)                           │
│ d oy                                      │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────╯

l'ab-e I of I
s~JTP2 (fi r
https://www.ejustice.ny.gov/wps/PA_DMVPhotoService/FetchlmageServiet?imageld=4790... 6/5/2019
EFTA00005946 (Jmail)
c\kko‘f nut
I
I
i
)
ii
EFTA00006025 (Jmail)
Attendence List
Check in Victim Full Name (SORT)
Attorney
Guest Name
Victim
Victim pending
Attorney
Contact Information
Victim Full Name Guest Name

╭────── Page 3, Image 1 ──────╮
│ Contact Information         │
│ Victim Full Name Guest Name │
│ Victim                      │
╰─────────────────────────────╯

Contact Information
Victim hill Name Guest Name
Victim
Attorney
Attorney
V•(tim
Therpot
V Own
VCtern
Victim
Attorney
Allot tie
V cttm
Email Address Phone Maribor Address 1 Address 2 City State Zip
Lai Vegas NV Fenn,
Calabasas CA 91302
Ashevile NC 28803
Fletcher NC 28732
Altadana CA 91001
Vero Beach FL 32962
Vero Beads FL 32962
Fort Lauderdale FL 33301
North Palm Beech FL 33403
North Palm Mach FL 11409
Fort Lauderdale FL 33301
West Palm Beach FL 33409
Royal Palm Beach FL 33411
Oakland Park FL 33311
Phoenix AZ 85014
New York NY 10002
West Palm Beach FL 33412
West Palm Beach FL 33409
Patchogue NY 11772
New York NY 10028
Lowahatchee FL 33470
Salt Lake City UT 84108
Fort Lauderdale FL 33316
Palm Springs FL 33461
Stall Breakdown
ODAG
Agents
TF0
VS
VS0- NQ
Therapist
2
1
I
4
2
Staff Total
Updated: 11/11 ga 400  PM
Mileage Reimbursement
Ground Transport Reim.
Mr
lodging
4
15
9 9
7 7
55,164 30
$000
Ft
UT
NY
CA
AZ
NV
NC
12
2
2
1
1
2
total: $5,164.30
21
Cancelled 11/11 • row grade fever, couldnt board flight
rt
Canceled didn't feel comfortable driving from Tampa
sit  RSVP vas on 11/11
RSVP yes on 11/11
•
Travel Arrangements
Victim Full Name Guest Full Name Mode of Airport/Station of
Transportation Origin
Mileage ReimbursemE N/A
Locator Origin Airport Date
Number
MP=
S
Air New York, NY - JFK
Air Bangor, ME
Mileage Reimburseme N/A
New York, NY 11-Nov
Bangor, ME 11-Nov
Air Asheville, NC  Ashville, NC 10-Nov
(female) Air Asheville, NC
Air
Air
Phoenix - PHX Sky
Harbor Air
()fit; Nand. NY ISP
Macarthur Airport
Las Vegas, NV -
McCarran
Las Vegas, NV -
McCarran
Ashville, NC 10-Nov

in. NY : 1
Las Vegas, NV 11-Nov
Las Vegas, NV 11-Nov
Phoenix, AZ 11-Nov
Air New York, NY - JFK New York, NY 11-Nov
Mileage Reimburseme N/A
Departing Arrival Time Arrival
Time Airport
Date Flight Home Home Hotel Hotel Conf. Check in Check
Time Arrival time Name out
3:07 PM 5:59 PM Ft. Laud( 43-Nev 4:30 PM 4+10-PM Residenc 99058633 11-Nov 13-Nov
12:40 PM 6:59 PM Ft. Laud( 13-Nov 1:28 PM 7:07 PM Residenc 99058928 11-Nov 13-Nov
5:20 PM 9:40 PM Ft. Laud( 14-Nov 12:30 PM 4:30 PM Residenc 99059426 Nov-20 13-Nov
5:20 PM 9:40 PM Ft. Laud( 14-Nov 12:30 PM 4:30 PM Residence Inn by Marri Nov-20 13-Nov
8:50 AM 5:00 PM Ft. Laud( 13-Nov 10:00 AM 4:35 PM Resident 99059576 11-Nov 13-No‘.
3:42 PM 11:03 PM Ft. Laud( 13-Nov 5:16 PM 9:54 PM Residenc 99059735 11-Nov 13-Nov
3:42 PM 11:03 PM Ft. Laud( 13-Nov 5:16 PM 9:54 PM Residence Inn by Marri 11-Nov 13-Nov
Residence Inn by Marc 1 i Nov 13-Nov
8:13 AM 4:25 PM Ft. Laud( 13-Nov 5:16 PM 10:48 PM Residenc 99059234 11-Nov 13-Nov
12:00 PM 2:57 PM Ft. Laud( 13-Nov 4:30 PM 7:10 PM Residence Inn by Marri 11-Nov 13-Nov
Residenc 99514330 11-Nov 12-Nov
Notes
Ms. IM decided to book her flight to
Dubai from Miami and would like a one-
way ticket to Miami.
Flight cost is from original reservation
confirmed she will
cover the costs for the two extra nights.
=11 cover the costs for the two extra nights.
confirmed she will
11.11 Missed flight due to low grade fever
11.10 Cancelled due to Trop. Storm Erma
Sat the 14 fly out
Conf. U reused from
Sup:wrt Staff
Name Rah Office Cell
ODAG
ODAG
FBI- VSD
FBI-VSO
FBI - NY
FBI - NY
FBI-NV
FleMM
PerScildi Arrival Odle Arrival Tillie Departure Date Depd1 Ti net
Victim Specialist
Special Agent
TFO (NYPD)
Victim Specialist
11-Nov 12PM Yes
10-Nov
10-Nov
10-Nov
11-Nov
11-Nov
Victim Specialist
(Victim Services
Coordinator)
Victim Specialist
FBI - MM
FBI - MM
8.30PM
4PM
4PM
10AM
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
12-Nov
12-Nov
12-Nov
13-Nov
7PM
7PM
7PM
8PM
Therapist
FBI Victim Specialist
Attorney
=UM
MIME MM. Survivor Guest
Guest

╭── Page 10, Image 1 ───╮
│ FBI Victim Specialist │
│ Therapist _ “Attorney │
│                       │
│ Survivor Guest        │
│                       │
│ Guest                 │
╰───────────────────────╯

EXEMPTION CERTIFICATE
TO BE USED BY FEDERAL EMPLOYEES
DATE
SELLING DEALER'S NAME
SELLING DEALER'S ADDRESS
I, the undersigned am an employee of the federal agency identified below. The purchase or
lease of tangible personal property or services or the rental of living quarters or sleeping
accommodations on or after (DATE[S]) from the business identified
above is in pursuit of my employer's affairs. The Government of the United States either will
pay the seller directly or will provide reimbursement to the employee for the actual cost of the
purchase or lease of tangible personal property, services, or living quarters or sleeping
accommodations made on this date(s).
Under penalties of perjury, I declare that I have read the foregoing and the facts stated in it
are true.
SIGNATURE OF EMPLOYEE
NAME OF FEDERAL AGENCY
ADDRESS OF FEDERAL AGENCY
THIS CERTIFICATE MAY NOT BE USED TO MAKE EXEMPT PURCHASES OR
LEASES OF TANGIBLE PERSONAL PROPERTY OR SERVICES OR RENTAL OF
LIVING ACCOMMODATIONS FOR THE PERSONAL USE OF ANY INDIVIDUAL
EMPLOYED BY A UNITED STATES GOVERNMENTAL AGENCY. PROPER
IDENTIFICATION IS REQUIRED BEFORE THIS CERTIFICATE MAY BE ACCEPTED
BY THE SELLER.
Florida Administrative Code Rule 12A-1.038(4)(c)
EFTA00006039 (Jmail)
CSAM
NOT
SCANNED
•• •
•
Mtvu 5
..•••!••••
I
4.

╭─ Page 2, Image 1 ─╮
│ MMIs              │
╰───────────────────╯

MM 03
MM k5
EFTA00006043 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00006049 (Jmail)
SCENE2GO
Instructions for FARO SCENE Pointcloud Interactive
You MUST retain the entire folder WebShare/SCENE2Go if transferred off on external harddrive,
thumbdrive, or DVD/CD. This is a self-executable package so the entire contents of the folder need to
stay together.

• Locate and open the WebShare/SCENE2Go folder
•
♦ • aa OC . 0••••• • Fans -AN ••••
Da ...mho Cos
• Oman
am •••••
.1 an
IIOa
Pan • • Dem*
0•••••••••• ' IN•ICD•
▪ It•0110 COMPONNI 1•••••••••• Warn and •••••••••••.
▪• ••••• Pop
ah >Ea..

• tel(
If using a PC, double click on Start SCENE 2Go on Windows
If using a MAC, double click on Start SCENE 2Go on Mac.command
Once opened this is your Home page.
Click on the image to open the job. It may or may not populate with a map view shown on the
right. The toggle on map click the globe icon in the upper right corner. Location will only be
accurate if GPS coordinates were collected and retained in scan data.
0
00

• •
c▪ -
•
•
• When the job is loaded, you will have a screen with a top down view of the scene. You can use
your mouse scroll to zoom in or out.
•
0
tra_inalgilai ll1=1 •
BEFORE selecting a scan, set up your measuring and viewing preferences
Click once on Settings located on the right side navigation bar
Click once on General
Select the units you prefer (normally Imperial inches or ft, and ft2)
Click once on OK
/AL JIIEN-atrialia

• • •
ALSO under Settings
Click once on Scan View
Under Visibility. Check Scan Position- Limit visibility to.
This reduces the number of scan positions in your view (can clutter) to only the ones
closest to you. You can navigate from one scan position to another by clicking on each of
the visible scan position markers. You can always return to this setting to make
adjustments.
Good Starting Settings- Large Exterior Scene 100-150ft, Small Exterior or Structure
Interiors 25-35ft, Vehicles 10-15ft.
Under Visibility you also have the option to control the viewing of scan names, annotations
and other detail items.
Under Panorama Image you have the option to Combine Color & Intensity.
This makes your image views a hybrid of your color planar image and black/white scan
point data.
Click OK to return to the loaded job
a
Return to Overview Map using the right column to navigate. Click on the scan markers to
choose scan viewing options. Panorama View (spherical photo). 3D View (pointcloud).
Properties (data details)
Once in a Panorama or 3D View you can "hop" between scan position, rotate and zoom
using your mouse.
'Era CN IlrallELS1 I Nn s_,_~
Properties PointCloud

• To pull a measurement:
After selecting a scan position marker select
Panorama (photo)
Once inside the spherical image, click
once on the Measure Distance located
in the right side navigation bar
Select a point to begin the measurement
and a point to end the measurement

• Then click once on the OK button at the
bottom right hand corner of your screen
▪ The distance should appear annotated on
the measured line

• To clear, click once on Cancel
• This measurement will be stored in your
Project Content
The gear in the lower left corner has more in-
depth tools. The color wheel tool allows you to
shift between your color image and
black/white scan data points.
To navigate between scans:

• When in a scan view you will see other scan locations within your visibility distance.
• After selecting a scan position marker it becomes highlighted. You can select to view the
Panorama (spherical photo), 3D (Point Cloud), Scan Properties or Overview Map. Once
in a view you can use the box in the upper right corner to switch between 2D and 3D.

• ALSO under Project Content in the right navigation column you can view a list of all scans
within the project and select viewing options from the drop down menu. This is a great tool if
you are having difficulty finding a specific scan.
IIIIIIKIIMIltta
r Click once on Scan Properties and you can view the planar image and additional recorded
data from the raw scan. You are brought to this same screen if you select Scan Properties
off a scan icon while in a view.
Click once on Overview Map in the drop down and that scan position will be highlighted in
the Overview Map.
•
Contact the FBI Laboratory / Operational Projects Unit at any time if you have additional questions.
TDDP supervisor
(office)
(cell)
(office)
(cell)
(office)
(cell)
(office)
(cell)
EFTA00006104 (Jmail)
Serial Report for Case:
Serial #
31E-MM-108062-SBP
Titl
87 (U//FOUO) PROVIDE PHONE AND TOLL RECORDS
86 (UHFOUO) PROVIDE TOLL RECORDS AND SUBSCRIBER INFORMATION
85 (U//FOUO) PROVIDE BILLING AND TOLL INFORMATION
84 (W/FOUO) PROVIDE SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION
83 (U//FOLIO) SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION FOR 561-790-5475
82 (U//FOUO) SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION FOR 561-676-5619
81 (U//FOUO) PROVIDE SUBSCRIBER AND BILLING INFORMATION
80 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
79 (U//FOLIO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
78 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
77 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
76 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
75 (UHFOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
74 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
73 (UHFOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
72 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
71 (UHFOUO) RE:SUBPOENA
70 (UHFOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
69 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
68 (UHFOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
2 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
66 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
65 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
64 (UHFOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
63 (UHFOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
62 (LWFOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
61 (UHFOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
60 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
59 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
58 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
57 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
56 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
55 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
54 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
53 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
52 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
51 (UHFOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
50 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
49 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
48 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
47 (U//FOLIO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
46 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
45 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
Serial # Title
44 (U//FOLIO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
43 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
42 (UHFOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
41. (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
40 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
39 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
38 (U//FOLIO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
37 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
36 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
35 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
34 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
33 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
32 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
31 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
30 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
29 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
28 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
27 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
26 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
25 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
24 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNTING AND BILLING INFORMATION
23 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
22 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
21 (U//FOLIO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
20 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
19 (U//FOUO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
18 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
17 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
16 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
15 (U//FOLIO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
14 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
13 (U//FOLIO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
12 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
11 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
10 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
9 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
8 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
7 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
6 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
5 (UHFOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
4 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
3 (U//FOUO) AUTOMATED SERIAL PERMANENT CHARGE-OUT
2 (U//FOLIO) REQUEST FOR ALL ACCOUNT AND BILLING INFORMATION
1 (U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB-FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
Serial Report for Case:
Serial #
31E-MM-108062-FF
Titl
9 (U//FOUO) REQUEST CLOSING OF FORFEITURE SUBFILE FF.
8 (U//FOUO) REPORT STATUS OF FORFEITURE INVESTIGATION.
7 (U//FOUO) DRAFT $340.00 CERTIFIED COPY OF CORPORATE RECORDS
6 (U//FOUO) DRAFT $946.00 CERTIFIED COPY OF CORPORATE RECORDS
4 (U//FOUO) DRAFT $150.00 TITLE SEARCH
5 (U//FOUO) UPDATED OWNERSHIP/ENCUMBRANCE REPORT FOR 358 EL BRILLO WAY
3 (U//FOUO) TO UPDATE STATUS OF FORFEITURE INVESTIGATION.
2 (U//FOUO) TO UPDATE STATUS OF FORFEITURE INVESTIGATION.
1 (U//FOUO) TO REQUEST THE OPENING OF SUB-FILES IN CAPTIONED CASE.
EFTA00006109 (Jmail)
╭──── Page 3, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 4, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 6, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 19, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 20, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 44, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00006209 (Jmail)
╭──── Page 10, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 17, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

╭──── Page 68, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00006364 (Jmail)
i lit- t* I 0

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ aa lO 4           │
╰───────────────────╯

.c),4)(r1
Jeffrey E. E 410 -he
(013°.
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
2 FOR
DATE -•  ma . ... • • .. .
OA ' . , • .* -
OF'"
PHONE!
MOBILE
. .
.
ir4-gPFIQN • • • pteAsicAu; . . H
pAmito sEe iott : WILL GALL AGAIN  •   ',
wAyfs-ro GEE You • ..- iiusR .. .:  ... -
•RETURNkio YoUR CAli SPECIAI-AtiOMtION -'
. -
g2.) •
.
.4 /
.•
%S.SI bit 1 • i

• • . jt;
1 • Sc_hadU ;I:e_ct, • : .
• : r :
•••• lt.‘rflo (955 •
: -
• i
•

╭────────────── Page 3, Image 1 ──────────────╮
│ OM. &/                                      │
│                                             │
│ TELEPHONED PLEASE CALE                      │
│                                             │
│ | caME 70 SEE You 2s CALL AGAIN             │
│                                             │
│ |. |HwavisTosee vou |, [ruse                │
│ + | Faerunnes vour calt| [specu artennion [ │
╰─────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00006371 (Jmail)
.0
l

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

°Atli
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR E. .
DATE / 12
.4.-- / JA9 .5.-- TIME M..' • ..,,:c M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED X PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH .
RETURNEDYOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
' -
SIGNED_T
. 26
1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR t r  - . .0-
D
M
OF
PHON
MOBIL:
TELEPHONED v\ PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN -1
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
•
•
SIGNED at -r- 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR
DAT 1STIME .9.
M
-4 00
OF
PHONE/ .
MOBILE
TELEPHONED. PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE you RUSK
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESS
fl
reW i e/t14/4/
ence/  - 4Por
. .
,...— as • SIGNED-1., 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR -E
DATiiii l °  / C  TIME a ' /-5- A.
M
OF
PHONE/
MOBILE
TELEPHONED X PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE
SIGNED • --r: 1184
(0,5°
Jeffrey E. E 4040.h.
EFTA00006383 (Jmail)
4. SCA" IL  I
r
Iro
UJ
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
PHONE/ MOBILE
TELEPHONED ,PLEASE CALL A CAME TO SEE YOU WILLCALL AGAIN .
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH •
RETURNEDYOUR CALL SPECIAL, ATTENTION
SIGNED a:1 '84
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR  MR' Eft/CAM
DATE  7.1 l it I WI. • r  Pen.
TIME eta:
M
OF
PHON MOBI
TELEPHONED in  PAPS DALE.
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALLAGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU' RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE 1\1 E
(CM MOTOR RMA) /21 N.4
xi ME. ALONE
Ctik
SIGNED a. 1184
IMPORTANT MESSAGE.
DAT1t {t Li4
M  •
TIME ° kik PM
TELEPHONED PLEASE CPU.
CAME TO SEE YOU . WILL CALLAGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE  AIM Jeri' - Litt AND
N 0 Dbi tVis Of . 3uSt
6kLIED
SIGNED
IMPORTANT MESSAGE.
ro a 0 4Z tvlit. b7511. N
07111( eu TIME AS DATE PM.
M
OF
PH MOBILE
TELEPHONED PLEASE CALL I
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN I
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH . I i
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION I j
WAS im A C MESSAGE
ACC D€Nri. Crc HER. 1titri :
'5o C-AN NCI Com E •
SNP Jtisi 6C1 Li< 4S
SIGNED 114

╭─────────────────────────────── Page 2, Image 1 ───────────────────────────────╮
│ ‘ain                                                                          │
│                                                                               │
│ PHESSSFSPFEHHHKTOOV VOOE                                                      │
│                                                                               │
│ SESSEGER OE SEL SE                                                            │
│                                                                               │
│ se                                                                            │
│                                                                               │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                             │
│                                                                               │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                             │
│                                                                               │
│ om                                                                            │
│ eS: oo Bt                                                                     │
│                                                                               │
│ Prone! PHONE)                                                                 │
│                                                                               │
│ neat. Roa                                                                     │
│                                                                               │
│ TELEPHONED menscoan LA] TELEPHONED [Resse oat                                 │
│                                                                               │
│ CANE TO-SEEYOU | [wu caLLAGAN CAME TO See vou "| [wut caLLAGIN                │
│ Wants To Se= You | Rusu WANTS 70 58E YOU | | musH                             │
│                                                                               │
│ RETURNED YOURCALL| | SPECIAL ATTENTION RETURNED YOUR GAL| | SPEGIAL ATTENTION │
│ MESSAGE. message 2 Atm JEL, Awe                                               │
│                                                                               │
│ NO ppt fF. Jus srt                                                            │
│                                                                               │
│ ic                                                                            │
│                                                                               │
│ SIGNED, 2                                                                     │
│                                                                               │
│ a                                                                             │
│ tee,                                                                          │
│                                                                               │
│ Es                                                                            │
│ SIGNED. &                                                                     │
│                                                                               │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE                                                             │
│                                                                               │
│ IMPORTANT MESSAGE |                                                           │
│                                                                               │
│ rorMA EPOTEIN                                                                 │
│                                                                               │
│ og MR Este                                                                    │
│                                                                               │
│ alli L5G Aah                                                                  │
│                                                                               │
│ ome 1117 bon nme: 55 5m                                                       │
│                                                                               │
│ ™ ~                                                                           │
│                                                                               │
│ oF.                                                                           │
│                                                                               │
│ PHONE                                                                         │
│                                                                               │
│ wos                                                                           │
│                                                                               │
│ TELEPHONED [Pisce oa TELEPHONED | [Rease ca]                                  │
│ CAME TO S== YOU | [wu cals naan Cane 6 Sz YOU | |W cnsacan—}                  │
│ WANs T0 See You'| [RUSH WANTS TOSEEVOU | | RUSH co                            │
│ serum YOURCAL| | SrEOAL TENTION ‘eve wancar| [aso mamoe[—|                    │
│                                                                               │
│ MESSAGE.                                                                      │
│ COMME                                                                         │
│                                                                               │
│ Vwrs in A CAR                                                                 │
│                                                                               │
│ ENT                                                                           │
│                                                                               │
│ SO CAN RCT Com                                                                │
│                                                                               │
│ Aust Ger                                                                      │
│                                                                               │
│ || a                                                                          │
│ SIGNED. see                                                                   │
╰───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00006385 (Jmail)
aca.s.A. vbO c.s l— 1q
FOLDER
EMPTY

╭─ Page 2, Image 1 ─╮
│ FOLDER            │
│ EMPTY             │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00007086 (Jmail)
Pursuant to a federal investi•ation regarding the sexual exploitation of m'.• a victim, was interviewed by the FBI. i•en
z yang information ;is xecorded below:
Name:
Race:
Sex:
DOB:
Husband:
Home Address:
Cellular Telephone:
Cellular Telephone:
Work:
Female
Loxahatchee, Florida 33470
aMi husband)
EFTA00007553 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007563 (Jmail)
1B2-31
) E 2 - 71
0 t1/4.1 C 6-ace Ni 64 A-t 5-46-6 -Fe  LC
Cr [AL ti)
EFTA00007565 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007609 (Jmail)
 [misc] letter to Alberto Pinto
Alberto,
I received your short letter with great disappointment. Unfortunately, today, I cannot
accept your "resignation". I'm sorry. but it is not that simple to abandon a "family member", no
matter how frustrating or good-looking he may be.

If my appreciation for both you and your talent has not been adequately expressed as you
and I have not spoken directly, I apologize.

I am sure you have forgotten, but you had initially assured me that the island project
would be done for last Christmas. I have Sways been both gracious and generous in forgiving
the dates that have slipped by. You and I have, I thought, a unique understanding.

Jean, who assured me the project would be complete by the end of July, when in fact, for
example, till this day there are still wooden packing crates for side tables in the living room, has
yet to contact me. Furniture was opposed to arrive, but even until today, I have not been told
what and when to expect the balance.

Alberto, it is your right to take on only jobs you want. It is both unfair, unfriendly and
unprofessint to simply leave a job undone in the middle. This is not your way. I don't believe
that you would treat a less friendly client with the same disregard.

I would hope that you will reconsider the big house Island project. As you know, we
have bought many things for the interior and have incurred great expense to get permits and
drawings in a Moroccan style, but if you choose not to move forward, I think at a minimum, my
house should not be left in the state of disrepair in which it currently sits and should be brought
to completion as soon as possible. If Jean, who I have great respect for, does not want to
complete it as I believe he is only an employee and as I have my total relationship not with Jean,
but with Cabinet Pinto, the obligation falls on you personally. This is only right, you know it is.
As you are aware, I was told repeatedly that you would call me upon return from your vacation
and both visit and finish the project. You and I have more of a friendship than my receiving, in a
frankly impolite way, only a letter and not even the phone call I was repeatedly promised.
(However, I know you don't like tension) Please call me at your earliest convenience.
I remain your friend
EFTA00007612 (Jmail)
Ap
TO
Q
(9 1Dact
51-1 c_e_(41-e
Jeffrey E. Epstein
17%

╭──── Page 2, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007616 (Jmail)
.1(.11 ( •• in
ni !Tat

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Stein             │
│                   │
│ ol a              │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00007617 (Jmail)
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Jeffrey E. Epstein
(..R (12'1—
Ghislaine Maxwell
utaisda •a Saanaf
- G
12,1
Jeffrey E. Epstein
c
Ghislaine Maxwell
Ghislaine Maxwell
GHISLAINE MAXWELL
Jeffrey E. Epstein
u1/41>s

╭──── Page 10, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯

Jeffrey E. Epstein
Jeffrey E. Epstein
Jeffrey E. Epstein
c --
0
Jeffrey E. Epstein
'
N 14 ' .
.! • r • 'A
rY •t:
e: •

• • a •
—• • • e •
. • 1,
*/-
4.1 4' 14 .
• •
-.r1}.KA
;'
e tY.
i sle•M e 0  e. " c.. 7
•••••• 1' •
•
re';--, • •

• • ' • •
•Ilt„ 0.. • duo • r
• • • lc' '• • 'at .q • 4•11. • • r. , • •
•-• ; ' , •
;

╭──── Page 15, Image 1 ────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007632 (Jmail)
Li CST AINE MPXVJ[I

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007634 (Jmail)
TELEPHONED A I PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CAll SPECIAL ATTENTION

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007635 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 2, Image 1 ─╮
│ ~                 │
│                   │
│ 43?               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00007639 (Jmail)
SHOP OUR STQMES:
THE SARDENS IN PALM BEACH
SALLERIA AT FT LAUDERDALE ',A,
TOWN CENTER AT BOCA RATON
SANGRASS MILLS OUTLET
THE MALL AT NELLIH6TCH GREEN

╭───────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────────────────╮
│ W334 WOLONITISM 18 716 SHI                         │
│ 1371N0 STM ssvaanes                                │
│                                                    │
│ - * O88 14 HOVIG Wid                               │
│ NOLVS ¥I08 1¥ Y31N3D NMOL ZS0b2 $ AM OTN49 13 BSE  │
│                                                    │
│ Ge Twos] 14 1v wlaIT WS ShloL * 4N3q 4 a           │
│ HOW3E WI¥d NI SNIGHWS HL | OBIId 100 a             │
│ *S3ND1S 4nd dOKS ogres I Gaiaeth LITTUTTITrrrriiyy │
│ * J                                                │
│                                                    │
│ LEE 122 BZ1d8 =                                    │
│                                                    │
│ Eos. 45                                            │
│ 129S4%                                             │
│ cd                                                 │
│                                                    │
│ s                                                  │
│ Description                                        │
│                                                    │
│ Town of Palm Beach |                               │
│ Police Department                                  │
│ CONTENT:                                           │
│                                                    │
│ EVIDENC                                            │
│                                                    │
│ se 499- 2E® rnovenry #2                            │
│                                                    │
│ cas                                                │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯

I'•': 'WHOM mia”" 38)41Fictici:I; Al iAC ,3(d‘
•
p4
4
old
.14002 $99,95 <20
; Sr -Foam'
?Silver
rmt.oles Are NiestOnoliy,-
lhaold. Ann.tvcrobo
de your feet
roam- Silver.
is — such as adhesive "silver"
atural anti-mite, anti-mold "and
if style. •
le makes it easy to step into and
it having-to bend over to slip them
cplor and soft feet of natural

• it wear and stain resistance. (lust- VI
Inside, the soft chenille lining
d dry. The outer soles are mold-
rethane; you can wear these
h pair comes in its own mesh

v. Specify 5, M, I. or XL:5mag
Sm (wemen's 9-10i men's 8-
'1)o? k-Large (then's
549.95
_pro. I ea '
A
S
iIJ
EFTA00007643 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007682 (Jmail)
nti I icla
I ivy
EFTA00007684 (Jmail)
,ea
war
1 a egg
sesr:U sio's; 1 I
WOOD TECHNOLOGY
METAL TECHNOLOGY
DUST. NO.
SHIPPED
PEASE RET.Ii- TO
WOOD TECHNOLOGY, INC.
BACK
ORDERED
P.O. BOX 130
CONOVER, NC 28613
PHONE (828) 464-8049
FAX (828) 464-8046
DATE SHIPPED SHIPPED WI SALESMAN
DESCRIPTION
Vt
Air -•••••Megolem"
INVOICE
PRICE I AMOUNT
—C7t
't st :••1 •

╭─────── Page 1, Image 1 ────────╮
│ Woop TECHNOLOGY |              │
│ Mi                             │
│                                │
│ WOOD TECHNOLOGY, INC.          │
│ P.0. BOX 130                   │
│ CONOVER, Nc 28613              │
│ PHONE (828) 454-8049           │
│ FAX (628) 464-8045             │
│                                │
│ GUSTIN. | _AGENO. | DATE SAPED │
│                                │
│ |                              │
│                                │
│ ‘SHPPED WA [SALES              │
│ } ma                           │
│                                │
│ DESCRIPTION                    │
╰────────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007688 (Jmail)
TELEPHONED I PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU i WILL CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU u RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL i SPECIAL ATTENTION

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007689 (Jmail)
it i t a, '111111110 i k9 •
I 4, $1
IMPORTANT MESSAGE
FOR
A4 if DATE TIME ' /
m 7001
OF
PHONE/
MC 3ILE
...0"
TELEPHONED C PLEASE CALL
CAME TO SEE YOU WILL. CALL AGAIN
WANTS TO SEE YOU RUSH
RETURNED YOUR CALL SPECIAL ATTENTION
MESSAGE fi e 442k?_752 Ce_______
rirniar abotAi - oaf \cygi at y
,7#1-c A raoinIci(air rt,v, Vciscsi_ _
if COW) ic cured _ba• yd'
have 1-o move- 1st cen
u$31- intrat to lid- 17 4 ai
A,A14.4 tan ~ aort ic n
SIGNED r /• a
1184
'

╭────── Page 1, Image 1 ──────╮
│ +                           │
│                             │
│ He sr0ke to he              │
│                             │
│ olaitat about youl Symptom, │
│                             │
│ Acs bredosdl ap ran Singous │
│ Fcon be cuted bat you       │
│ have to move. Hear          │
│                             │
│ wast imyaoths of th 2 tush  │
│                             │
│ whith Lan est? chor fen     │
│ eO'YOU SCX r                │
╰─────────────────────────────╯
EFTA00007692 (Jmail)
╭─── Page 1, Image 1 ───╮
│ PEQEVENE ES EAMUEINES │
│                       │
│ Jeffrey E. Epstein    │
╰───────────────────────╯
EFTA00007703 (Jmail)
Shelf One
All Vitamins
Shelf Two
Pain Relief
■ Advil

• Aleve
■ Aspirin
• Motrin
■ Excedrin
■ Sintutab
■ Tylenol
Colds, Cough, Flu, Sore throat
■ Cepacol -
• Advil cold & sinus
■ Contac
■ Children's Dimetapp syrup

• Dimetapp
■ Halls cough sweets
• Sucrets throat lozenges
■ Robitussin (Guaifenesiai
syrup)
• Robitussin CF cough syrup

• Robitussin cough sweets
• Theraflu flu, cold & cough
• Tylenol cold severe
congestion capsules
• Tylenol flu gel caps

• Sucrets
■ Sudafed
■ Vicks chloraseptic (sore
throat)
• Vicks Day quill
• Vicks Nyquil
Stomach
. . ■ Acidil
■ Exlax

• Gas X
• lmodium
• Laxative table
• Pepto-Bism
• Philips Mi
■ iRolaids
•
• ■ Pe
■ Fl
Various Modica ona
■ Anti bacte solution
■ Antifungal cream
■ Blistex
■ Douche

• Dramamine
• Calendula
■ Fungus cream
• Lamisil
■ Nytol (difficulty in sleeping)
■ Mouth sore medication
■ Monostat 7
■ Mycelex 3
■ Temporary tooth saver
■ Vadisil
■ Visene eye wash

• Zinc oxide ointment
Shelf Three
Pain/Antibiotic/Foot medication
external
• Arnica gel
• Bactine Antiseptic cream

• Bengay
• Bio Freeze
▪ Vicks VapoRub
• Fungus cream
■ Lamisil (athletes foot)
• Lotrimin (foot cream)

• Neosgorin antibiotic ointment
Shelf Four
First Aid/Itch treatment
• Breath Right
■ Calamine lotion
• First aid spray

• Insect repellant
▪ Insect repellant wrist bands
▪ Itch cream
■ Alcohol wipes
■ Band aids
■ Cotton balls
• Support
■ Surgi
EFTA00007735 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007769 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007853 (Jmail)
NEW YORK crnr 10025
lk
ARCHI III IMI
NEW YORK CITY 10025
(FT
riviA cycn N4Ir,e 10,0(9
EPSTEIN
RESIDENCE
F2(90L NiorE..s
NLvi.ge.I .K„or...Tat5hE.
•fk- rterT.pgrer7 _
Cc:7\61'41bl NEW pool --Q,6-1-
oUAIZE. c,PP fa97L, A6xhir)0i.1
ol.t7 5TH FILL covEg.
CorcAE-TE,
p,64,/irly 17, VIATc-14,
bTepc,
gemovE. T.LE.
WATER L ,
FL-E LF.A.K.
1.112-FArE ENITIZE.
ATeiziorz.
358 El Brillo Way
Palm Beach, Florida
ARCHITECT •
NEW YORK, NEW YORK
1 0 0 2 1
IF I •
,P5-'Et Nt
DENica,
56 5  61. fbeLl-o
194.1..t1 E,EA.CA-4
ARCHITECT
NEW YORK, NEW YORK
1 0 0 2 1
I
TEL:
FAX:
EPSTEIN
RESIDENCE
358 El Brillo Way
Palm Beach, Florida
NEW YORK, NEW YORK
1 0 0 2 1
TEL:
F A X:
ASSOCIATED ARCHITECT
WEST PALM BEACH, FLA.
5-Z81
EFTA00007881 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007887 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007956 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007959 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007971 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007978 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007982 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007984 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007987 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007990 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00007993 (Jmail)
 [legal] photos of collected evidence
EFTA00008409 (Jmail)
PHOTOGRAPHER
LOCATION /14.0
EFTA00008416 (Jmail)
•y
'a In 10•

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ Pee eg? her eg    │
│ te eke ae         │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00008418 (Jmail)
╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ es.               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00008419 (Jmail)
SMEAD•
Mw 741St
UPC TIM
almiliam••AsaaSibi•Mak•
EFTA00008423 (Jmail)
cioNe 40/4,
EFTA00008425 (Jmail)
ea.
LISA *el
TIMM ••
ISIV9P4131 I
.IP*
• 41.
EFTA00008430 (Jmail)
-iliftr`‘J\
agt

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ 900               │
│ Tynes             │
│                   │
│ | yepbees:        │
│                   │
│ cial              │
│                   │
│ iil)              │
│                   │
│ Jer               │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00008433 (Jmail)
4
•
.
v.
•-
‘t•
1
_ •

X. ‘••7 • • I
.• •
4
•
•
r •

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ er,               │
│                   │
│ es 7              │
│ on                │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00008434 (Jmail)
• 00,1••••

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008437 (Jmail)
• • Or •
•
• • ' • • r -11 . a
I,
a
•
•
'A
• • • •
IL .
•
•

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008438 (Jmail)
BOA NY-3t5t227 Reqoest ID 112043 1833
08/12/2019 NPC02'=t1,
PC 111,11V3(A
One (I) Western tNottet 1000Gt4 '!'
WD1003FZEK
0CSIK2A;) Sirr -- Ontainflig
Cloy ,  C,((( '-f !

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008440 (Jmail)
' Jr n 4; •
) •
4 • Irsr ♦ • • v e 1Pb. • _ St $
4  ' •..• 1 • .
a. • 1 r , a
# .  4• . ••• .
1
' •. • •,!."
z miv , ii , • . It
EFTA00008442 (Jmail)
90A
-NY
4151227
1B42
08/2112019
NYC023597
PC
MASTER
CC°Y
One
FEllaaned
Meade
218
Mara
Drat
0i
lo3i
IJPK3EADP09.
Sm
S9GMOPIF
Parsons;
the
veined
E01
maces
NYC023589
t1812)
tr/C02359311816)
NYC023594
!SIN
Ana
NrC0235g5,
letat
EFTA00008444 (Jmail)
lel , Na,i;
. :r
,AiU4t3 MLA/ JTWOL.ft.krii •.[ •
vm
EFTA00008448 (Jmail)
•

• •
„. •
•aro
11, • .

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008449 (Jmail)
i0
Nun
be, ___
"•".0-
-
Hq90
,840
3
r
tz7z=n3t
,
M00019135
-
.001,33
,
-
N.01.53

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008452 (Jmail)
90A-NY-3151227 1 B43
08/21/2019 NYCO23594 PC MASTER COPY
One (1) FBI-owned WV Black 3T8 'lard drive
VVD3003FZEX-0024SAO, SIN MiCC13LZR5 (9P.
coNaming the vented E01 images NYCO23578
(181). NYCO23579 (182). NYCO23580 (183.
NYCO23581 (184) NYCO23583 (160).
NYC023584 (187) NYCO235851188).
)00O23566 (199) NYCO23587 (1.101,
NYCO23588 (1911). and NYCO235' 2 (1815'

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008454 (Jmail)
SOW mos
u••••••
EFTA00008457 (Jmail)
• • •
• • • lit AP • •
It
•
•W
4
. *1'
t .
EFTA00008462 (Jmail)
NYCO25654
Digital VVn. D2500 mow
Wit
WisIMAIWOWM
dab. T In • 9f00 GI
III IWIIIBMIILII!III:IIII~IIIII
o
!L to,c4c5654 Au« IN im"" - 40.10

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008464 (Jmail)
MOM Oda
liMNII 'ft
OV31151 .• ///
EFTA00008468 (Jmail)
gg0iL'oN 0 3ZIWY080 I1OA ONId33)(
CONTENTS:
Master Copt. Arcnive Of OVR Main
Controller Images
l
2.0TB sAl.tea. crepe
W
I 1110 111,1111M
M020EARS
INK
&so wcsfiolesotis

• —in—. tnn
Nip III t il•
aiqQ026637

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008470 (Jmail)
OA-.3c-co6
SSO L 'ON
0 V' 3 INS /il
ea oNTINTS:
a”CONtlICOM MO'•
fPnOtE 111.
/Intl 04111611
'r.l• ' ,I  %.0
HI I /I I a' Irr
I A IPPP411
Oil r
NA% 1:Wi
sematelm
`tarter CAW: Asynot lod./e ,
Lob HQQ190•111001
UC'N: 90A -A .3151227
Examiner:
SPECIMEN: 2111311
RI
EFTA00008471 (Jmail)
•44 • .tea-
ic". ' • •

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008477 (Jmail)
• , • •
• SA, ' I'S
•• 9 • J .  •
4P
1 - • • F..-% •
• • a •
• .
• V-,

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ ‘ CT eos ay cy Dy rey eS │
│ “vgs                     │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008478 (Jmail)
• • -
• . .
Yr =0 ••••••••.• ••••••••••
OKANNO e VIVO COW
EFTA00008479 (Jmail)
╭── Page 1, Image 1 ──╮
│ Joan - NY - 3151227 │
│ - [A envecores      │
│ — case Ele Cows     │
│                     │
│ Jac - NN - 3154599  │
│ = ELSOR ENvELoPE    │
│ — Case FUE Cove)    │
│                     │
│ QA - NY- 31447491   │
│ - CASE FILE Cove    │
│                     │
│ 2928- NY - 3156749  │
│ - CASE FILE Cove)   │
╰─────────────────────╯
EFTA00008483 (Jmail)
tiole alOsody
ED-5041(Rev.
Case File
Poen
ELSUR Erudesx PAWN. Rorie Ender
831.20171
Hz 9 ID n:
m aCo mew=
o ism=. cn
omem, smut
Total
eof Discs /
Case Agent/Task
Evidence
Enclosure:
Media Type:
Intercept
Download
Title IIIICM
Force
Type:
Date(s): CM
Officer:
O Title III O Consensual FISA
la -Video Surveillance muff
Non-Custodial - Oven interview
O Non-Custodial - Surreptitious Interview
ig Original Cji Enhanced Original
O CD/DVD.13lue Ray O Hard Drive
I ,N_LinCL -Ar Location:
Monitoring O Computer Trespasser
❑ Aerial Surveillance O Object Tracker
I . Custodial - Interview
rig Other \t,
O SD Card O Other
S-L_QCRI.9")
Timc: Date: CIA i;\-\ 3k7km- Download
Intercepters - 4) Listed Below or O See Attached
rc.. or eA"-N--\\.
Accepted Custody Rely:Iwit Custody
Print Nam
Signature:
Date: ?)it
Print Name:
SignatuF:
Date: 1,111
Reason: Reason.
Tracking Tracking u.
Print Nam:
Signature:
Date: _
Print Name:
Signature:
Ti • €1.334/1 Date: Time: Reason: arc 1 Reason: Tracking tt: Tracking #:
Print Name:
Signature: Print Name:
30'
Signature: Ehte:
Isom Timc: Date:
Reason: icking ft:
AO nv Tracking
EFTA00008484 (Jmail)
Chain of Custody-ELSUR Evidence Envelope
FB-504b (Rev. 547.01)
Enclosure:
Medium:
Case Filen: 33?--7
Case Agt.:
Agt. Supervising Title III Intercepts:
O Court Authorized Intercept - Source/Symbolii:
J2f Consensual Monitoring Intercept - CM# (if assigned):
O Telephonic (TCM) Nontelephonic (NTCM)
If NTCM Specify Device Used:  f:13/fi
Ng Original
O Magnetic Tape
O Duplicate
O Computer Disk
O Enhanced Original
O Printed Material
I DU:
Tapc/Diskft:
Gm 56-41
O Recording of an Interview
O Volunteered/Subpoenaed Medium - Not FBI ELSUR
O Other Type of Recording/Interception, Specify:
Intercept Date:  0/ 103/D9  Place:  ADV., Ak ebh
Data Transferred for Permanent Storage - Date:  I t /03/0 1  Time:
O Consensual: List Intercept= Below O Court Authorized: Enter " See Log" Below

• tirtdo fiodrisuet
Ac
Released  to
Signature:
Signature:
Date:  0 0  Time:  Date:
Reason:  /
Reason:
Signatu
Date:   sen : .4
Re.1501)
.
an L.
VE
Signature.
Date:
Reason:
Signature
Date:
Reason:
40 nuEing
Signature:
Date:
Reason:
Signature:
Date:
Reason:
Signatu
Date:
I in milli
kill
E02782875
TIG1i
EFTA00008485 (Jmail)
lain
of
Custody-
ELSUR
Evidence
Envelope
(Rev.
$.17A1)
•
Enclosure:
k Original
O
Duplicate
O
Enhanced
Original
Medium:
O
Magnetic
Tape
O
Computer
Disk
O
Printed
Material
Case
Ei
RN:
7d-Mtif\--It3311

ION:

/D
---C2
'
Case
Agt.:
Tape/Disk/1:
Av.
Supervising
Title
III
Intercepts:

O
Court
Authorized
Intercept-
Source/Symbota:
re,
Consensual
Monitoring
Intercept
- CM#
(if
assigned):
O
Telephonic
(TCM)
pa
Nontelephonic
(NTCM)
If
NTCM
Specify
Device
Used:

CC.,r
v
O
Recording
of
an
Interview
❑
Volunteered/Subpoenaed
Medium
- Not
FBI
ELSUR
O
Other
Type
of
Recording/Interception,
Specify:

friga
5644
Intercept
Date:
iiiO3/01
Place:
Data
Transferred
for
Pemument
Storage
-
Date:
/30ca.
44-inn
Fi-
n/0
3/191
Time.
LI:406pm,
04
Consensual:
List
Interceptees
Below
O
Court
Authorized:
Enter"
See
Log"
Below
IfainsieeAdS.
AMQ
VAlictdo
Aorirty(C7-
Signatu Date:

Reason:

F v t r
f.Lot
Signature: Date: Reason:

Time:
J-
Time:
Signature:ac Date:

itt
frokro
zp
bt
) cnyk
Date:SignatureigtHav•y
Time:
Reason:

Signature:

Date:
Time:

Reason:
E P
S.gnature:

-‘r
Date:
Time:

P
Reason:
Signature: Da

Signature: Date
--
Reason:
jlti .113 II

╭── Page 1, Image 1 ───╮
│ DENCE Evinassendili. │
╰──────────────────────╯
EFTA00008489 (Jmail)
of
Custody-ELSUR
Evidence
Envelope
(Rev
847-00
513
Original
0
Magnetic
Tape
Enclosure: Medium: Case
File/:
Case
Agt.:
Agt.
Supervising
Title
III
Intercepts:

O
Court
Authorized
Intercept
- Souree/Symbolti:
54
Consensual
Monitoring
Intercept
- CM#
(if
assigned):
pg
Telephonic
(TCM)
0
Nontelephonic
(NTCM)
If
NTCM
Specify
Device
Used:

O
Recording
of
an
Interview
O
Volunteered/Subpoenaed
Medium
- Not
FBI
ELSUR
O
Other
Type
of
Recording/Interception,
Specify:

Intercept
Date:
/0/Th
.
0
CI
Place:
ki
51
Pc,lin
AtA(.‘t
i FL
Data
Transferred
for
Permanent
Storage
-
Date:
/0
a-6"/o
9
Time:
9
:apt",
O
Consensual:
List
Intereeptces
Below
0
Court
Authorized:
Enter
" See
Log"
Below
O
Duplicate
O
Computer
Disk
O
Enhanced
Original
O
Printed
Material
ID#:

1D-6
Tape/Disk#:
(4
441-
_97fii
e
_iew
kiet
r

6 a.
ei ley
echourch
VA/ire,
Afm1
u C
8118
1VEIT •
Signature:
Signature:
Date:
f
Time:
t
Date:
Reason:

rSvi'dtAGC

Reason:

Signatu
Signatur
,e:
r
Date:

t
ime:
-
Date:
a

I ime:
Reason:

_124.1-4:1
44-e
,

Reason:

.-c2rceAwye:
lam
_
Time:
AgS,1
is
.6
Signature Date: Reason:
Signature:

Signature:

Date:

Time:

Date:

Time:
_
Reason:

Reason:
tflt(ii
so
Jo
ntrauttnitmad
ttilaine
inn(
IA
It
I MO
1111g71811,11
EFTA00008490 (Jmail)
JESUS
mrs
jovqiif .4 EVES

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008491 (Jmail)
ri ;: 'R S;

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008492 (Jmail)
\TIEN:1OH S: 'R
FME ‘4:Ns!il;c: 4: 1Or.
Dill ITEM FOE DISni%'ElIZY 501:-.NV.34127C;!
IICKLEtLZIrsig

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ────╮
│ Case IO No Man NASHTST: │
│                         │
│ Contributor No.         │
╰─────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008499 (Jmail)
N.. Y,ah CANT I at,
iffin Pion i NYC024373
OFy< 3:47571
Item 33 S/17-
31E-N9- WriS", I
Lithe St•94 Acmes U it
VI 1h, iclaKtIS ) b* Pees(
in %Ivey YAM vosoWer 19
tAhtt-i Sarver
Nit ID: Ile. 4131.A11$44
3214-1AW.A.
1.°e ID: t O
SA

• , 1 , • • • — •
• . ,
-41 11,  4.
• • As- IIP .11. • C. '
•` • li ' IP II et II .. •
it • i s"... •
f.. . .
20. eV •
•
1
.(°. S • •
'S • ., •
• ;4,v a
4 • • '
EFTA00008507 (Jmail)
ley

╭─ Page 1, Image 1 ─╮
│ ne                │
│                   │
│ or                │
│                   │
│ 3                 │
│ oi                │
│                   │
│ See Tas eee       │
│ ease              │
╰───────────────────╯
EFTA00008515 (Jmail)
MY PASSPORT

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008516 (Jmail)
FRAGILE . ' HANDLE
WITH CARE
EFTA00008518 (Jmail)
•• • 0
•

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008521 (Jmail)
I tAVIIII IV IV,I
EFTA00008522 (Jmail)
•
•
•
•
•
°Pc%
I 4- F'IIeI$
506- lijk/-3O:27571
-. •
•••
. •,
'Sr
. • ,
, st • s
=••:, - • .4
•
•
. • . • - •
• •
- •
I. •
•
P. - • • •
• -
a_Fc•
•
(3c, ,P4(7
•
•
oct kii 7; 7511
•
• • 1..
• • -
•
EFTA00008525 (Jmail)
II MVIKMMMW
affiCnalefT°
•

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00008526 (Jmail)
t it!e
441
•
a-06•
•-T.
ito Nc, P.i-n
M44-• 1e -'c

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA00020832 (Jmail)
 [government] FBI subpoena of Experian
Experian Information Solutions, Inc.
701 Experian Parkway
Allen, Tx 75013
Attn: Subpoena Compliance Dept.

Please provide any and all credit reports, fraud alerts, and related documents pertaining to the following
individuals listed, including all known accounts and lines of credit, addresses and personal identifying
information, and all credit inquiries regarding the individuals and the addresses provide at the time of
said inquiry regardless of whether accounts were open.

Please utilize the identifiers below:
NAMES/ENTITIES      <REDACTED>
DOB                 <REDACTED>
SSN                 <REDACTED>
ADDRESS             <REDACTED>
PHONE               <REDACTED>
EMAIL               <REDACTED>

If you have any questions, please contact Forensic Accountant at or Special
Agent at . Please forward the results in an electronic format to Special
Agent M, Federal Bureau of Investigation, 26 Federal Plaza, New York, NY 10278, telephone

The Government hereby requests that you voluntarily refrain from disclosing the existence of the
subpoena to any third party. While you are under no obligation to comply with our request, we are
requesting you not to make any disclosure in order to preserve the confidentiality of the investigation
and because disclosure of the existence of this investigation might interfere with and impede the
investigation. If you intend to disclose the existence of this subpoena to a third party, please let a Special
Agent know before making any such disclosure.
EFTA00029538 (Jmail)
 [misc] Ghislaine Maxwell investigation, see quote: "the defendant provided Minor Victim-3 with a schoolgirl uniform"
The Government expects Minor Victim-3 to testify, in substance and in part, that she met
the defendant when she was approximately 17 years old. Within a few weeks of meeting the
defendant, at the defendant's invitation, Minor Victim-3 went to the defendant's townhouse in
London for tea. The defendant expressed an interest in Minor Victim-3, talked with Minor Victim -
3 about Minor Victim-3's life and interests, and told Minor Victim -3 about her boyfriend Jeffrey
Epstein, who she wanted Minor Victim-3 to meet. Shortly after, the defendant invited Minor
Victim-3 to her home. During that first visit, the defendant introduced Minor Victim-3 to Epstein
and encouraged her to give Epstein a foot massage. Epstein instructed Minor Victim -3 to massage
his shoulders. Minor Victim-3 left the townhouse after she was excused.

Shortly thereafter, the defendant invited Minor Victim-3 to her home again and encouraged
Minor Victim-3 to provide Epstein with a massage. The defendant showed Minor Victim-3 to a
room in which a massage table was set up. Epstein was in the room. Epstein removed his robe
and was naked. The defendant handed Minor Victim-3 oil and closed the door. After the massage,
the defendant was outside the room and asked if Minor Victim-3 had fun and whether Epstein
liked the massage. The defendant subsequently told Minor Victim-3 that Epstein was impressed
with her and asked her to come back to her townhouse. The defendant encouraged Minor Victim -
3 to provide a massage to Epstein. The defendant thanked Minor Victim-3, indicating that if it
wasn't Minor Victim -3 or someone else, it would all fall to her (the defendant). The defendant
again showed Minor Victim-3 to a room with a massage table where Epstein was naked. Both
massages involved at least one sex act with Minor Victim -3.
Following those two encounters, the defendant and Epstein invited Minor Victim-3 to
travel with them to Florida, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and New York. Minor Victim-3 eventually
accepted these invitations, but she does not recall whether she was 17 or 18 when she took her first
trip at Epstein and the defendant's invitation. Minor Victim-3 traveled to visit the defendant and
Epstein in New York, Palm Beach, and Little Saint James. When Minor Victim-3 met the
defendant and Epstein in these locations, she provided additional massages to Epstein, during
which he engaged in sex acts with Minor Victim -3. Over the course of their interactions, the
defendant made multiple statements to Minor Victim -3 reflecting the defendant's awareness that
Epstein engaged in sex acts with Minor Victim-3. On at least one occasion, the defendant asked
Minor Victim-3 if she knew any other young females to bring to Epstein and made comments to
Minor Victim-3 about Epstein's significant sexual needs.
On one occasion in Palm Beach, the defendant provided Minor Victim-3 with a schoolgirl
uniform and told Minor Victim-3, in substance and in part, that she should bring Epstein his tea in
the uniform. After Minor Victim -3 brought Epstein tea that had been provided by the defendant,
Epstein raped Minor Victim-3.
EFTA00029805 (Jmail)
 [government] DOJ policy doc
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Bureau of Prisons
Program
Statement
OPI: OGC
NUMBER: 1210.21
DATE: 3/9/2000
SUBJECT: Boards of Inquiry and
Inquiry Teams

1. PURPOSE AND SCOPE. To establish procedures for the creation
and operations of Boards of Inquiry and Inquiry Teams to
investigate the facts and circumstances of any incident or
situation for such purposes as:
# ascertaining and reporting facts and circumstances,
# gathering and preserving evidence and records,
# determining the cause or causes, and
# recommending corrective steps as may be indicated in policy,
regulation, and practice.
Only the Director may create a Board of Inquiry, and only a
Regional Director or Warden (with Regional Director approval) may
create an Inquiry Team. The focus of a Board of Inquiry is to
determine the facts of an incident the Director deems significant
or unusual enough to warrant a special and higher level of
review.
When employee misconduct may have occurred, clearance must be
received from the Chief, Office of Internal Affairs (OIA), prior
to the appointment of any regional or local Inquiry Team. OIA
must investigate any incident when employee misconduct may have
occurred to ensure protection of employee rights and preservation
of evidence. To accomplish this objective, an OIA staff member
is to serve as a member of a Board of Inquiry when staff
misconduct may be involved.
Any allegations of violations of law must be reported by the
Bureau's Office of Internal Affairs, to the Department of
Justice, Office of the Inspector General (OIG) prior to the
creation of a Board of Inquiry or Inquiry Team.
PS 1210.21
3/9/2000
Page 2

2. SUMMARY OF CHANGES. To include the requirement that Board of
Inquiry reports, or portions thereof, may have to be released
pursuant to a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request or
subpoena or produced in litigation.

3. PROGRAM OBJECTIVES. The expected results of this program
are:
a. Serious incidents, allegations of significant and far-
reaching breaches of policy, and allegations of misconduct will
be formally investigated.

b. Recommendations for corrective measures to improve
operations or avoid future incidents will be made.

c. The purpose, scope, and duration of each Board or Team will
be defined by the appointing authority.
d. A written report containing all pertinent findings and
recommendations will be made.

e. Appropriate records from each Board or Team will be
preserved.
4. STANDARDS REFERENCED
a. American Correctional Association 3rd Edition Standards for
Adult Correctional Institutions: None.

b. American Correctional Association 3rd Edition Standards for
Adult Local Detention Facilities: None.
c. American Correctional Association 2nd Edition Standards for
Administration of Correctional Agencies: None.

d. American Correctional Association Standards for Adult
Correctional Boot Camp Programs: None.
5. DIRECTIVES AFFECTED

a. Directive Rescinded
PS 1210.16 Boards of Inquiry and Inquiry Teams
(5/7/97)
PS 1210.21
3/9/2000
Page 3

b. Directives Referenced
PS 1210.17
PS 1380.05
PS 1600.08
6. RESPONSIBILITIES
Internal Affairs, Office of (8/4/97)
Special Investigative Supervisors Manual
(8/1/95)
Occupational Safety and Environmental Health
Manual (8/16/99)

a. Boards of Inquiry. The Director may appoint Boards of
Inquiry to investigate appropriate significant incidents in the
Bureau including, but not limited to:
allegations of significant breaches of policy, or
any other matter which reflects in a significant way
upon the Bureau's ability to carry out its mission.
The General Counsel may request that the Director appoint a
Board of Inquiry to investigate incidents or allegations that are
likely to result in litigation against the United States, the
Bureau, or one of its employees.

b. Regional Inquiry Teams. Regional Directors may appoint
Inquiry Teams to investigate incidents or allegations of
significant departure from policy or regulation within their
jurisdictions, or in any other instance when it would be in the
Bureau's best interest. An exception is a matter which is to be
investigated by a Board or Team appointed at a higher level.
Regional Counsel may request that the Regional Director appoint
an Inquiry Team to investigate incidents or allegations that are
likely to result in litigation against a Bureau institution or
employee under regional jurisdiction.

c. Local Inquiry Teams. Wardens, with the approval of the
Regional Director, may appoint a local Inquiry Team to
investigate incidents or allegations of significant departure
from policy or regulation at only that institution. For more
routine incidents requiring investigation, the Warden may not
appoint an Inquiry Team, but should assign staff such as an
Associate Warden, appropriate department head, or investigative
officer to investigate routine matters.

7. APPOINTMENT OF BOARDS AND TEAMS. The Director, Regional
Director, or Warden will notify in writing each person appointed
to serve as a member of the Board or Team as to:
PS 1210.21
3/9/2000
Page 4
# the purpose and scope of the inquiry,
# the date the inquiry is to begin, and
# if appropriate, the date that a completed report is to be
furnished to the appointing official.
The written notification will indicate which member is to chair
the Board or Team.
The General Counsel or Regional Counsel will be consulted prior
to the creation of a Board or Team to determine whether the
appropriate legal office should initiate a request that a Board
or Team be appointed. Boards and Teams appointed at the request
of the General Counsel or Regional Counsel will include at least
one legal staff member.

a. Boards of Inquiry. In addition to Bureau staff, a Board of
Inquiry may also include non-Bureau personnel with expertise
relevant to the scope and purpose of the inquiry. An OIA staff
member is to serve as a member of a Board of Inquiry when staff
misconduct may be involved. The OIA will pay all expenses
incidental and necessary to the work of a Board of Inquiry.

b. Regional Inquiry Teams. To ensure objectivity, a regional
Inquiry Team should not consist of staff from only one
institution. The Team must be composed of personnel at the
department head level or above from any institution, any regional
office, or the Central Office. The regional office will bear all
expenses incurred (such as for travel).

c. Local Teams. A local Inquiry Team may consist of staff of
that institution at the Associate Warden and/or department head
levels. The institution will bear any expenses incurred.

d. ()IA Assistance. When requested by a Regional Director,
Warden, or Inquiry Team Chair, the OIA will provide consultation
and other assistance to Boards and Teams as is necessary.

8. INSTRUCTIONS FOR ALL BOARDS AND TEAMS
a. Members must become familiar with Bureau directives
applicable to the matter being reviewed.

b. Members must review all written records, including
investigative reports, medical records, or other records
pertaining to the subject of the inquiry.
PS 1210.21
3/9/2000
Page 5

c. Members must visit the scene of an incident, reconstruct
the chain of events, and record their observations by notes,
photographs, audio or visual recordings, or other appropriate
means.

d. If, at any point during the inquiry, it becomes apparent
that serious criminal or administrative misconduct is involved,
OIA will be consulted to determine whether a referral to the
Office of the Inspector General or Civil Rights Division is
appropriate. If an OIA representative is not present, members
will contact the Chief, OIA, for advice before proceeding
further.

e. Members must interview witnesses or other persons having
knowledge of the incident, using the following procedures:

(1) Advise any person being interviewed of the purpose of
the interview, including the nature of the inquiry, and fully
identify all members present. An individual's right to
representation, if any, must be determined prior to the
interview. For bargaining unit members, union representational
rights will apply (see Employee Rights Article of Master
Agreement) .
During the inquiry, witnesses or other persons having
knowledge of the incident must be instructed to keep all
information strictly confidential and instructed not to disclose
any information concerning the nature of the inquiry or the
information he or she has provided to anyone other than the Board
or Team, or to an appropriate union representative.

(2) If the inquiry develops information which focuses on
the person being questioned, or about to be questioned, as a
suspect in possible criminal misconduct, questioning of that
person may not proceed until the local U.S. Attorney:
# declines prosecution,
# grants use immunity, or
# recommends the interviewee be advised of his or her
Miranda Rights.
One of these conditions must be satisfied before questioning
a person suspected of possible criminal misconduct. These
contacts with the local U.S. Attorney will be coordinated through
OIA.
PS 1210.21
3/9/2000
Page 6

c. Members must visit the scene of an incident, reconstruct
statement. The witness will be permitted a reasonable
opportunity to prepare and review the statement before swearing
or affirming the truth of the statement. The Chair and members
will have authority to administer oaths or affirmations to
witnesses in accordance with 5 U.S.C. 303.
# For a written statement.
"I hereby declare (or certify, verify, or state) under
penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and
correct."
# For an oral statement:
"I swear (or affirm) under penalty of perjury that the
statement I am about to make is true and correct."

(4) All employees may be required by Boards of Inquiry,
Regional Inquiry Teams, and local Inquiry Teams to answer
questions regarding their employment, even though their answers
may lead to disciplinary action up to and including removal;
however, in criminal cases, employees retain their constitutional
rights regarding avoidance of self-incrimination and may not be
disciplined for properly exercising these rights.

(5) Any visual or oral recordings made of interviews and
other proceedings will be preserved to allow a reasonable
opportunity for the resolution of any administrative review or
appeal related to the inquiry.

9. REPORTS
a. General. The Board or Team will prepare a detailed report
of its findings, including, if appropriate, recommendations. The
report must include all documents or records (or copies of them)
pertinent to the findings and recommendations. Any member of a
Board or Team may submit a separate or dissenting report.

b. Submission. The completed report, along with all working
notes and other personal records created by members as a result
of the inquiry, will be submitted to the official who appointed
the Board or Team, unless the appointing official had done so at
the request of the General Counsel or Regional Counsel. If the
Board or Team was appointed at the request of the General Counsel
or Regional Counsel, the completed report will be submitted
directly to the requesting Counsel.
PS 1210.21
3/9/2000
Page 7
If a report is submitted to an appointing official (rather than
to a requesting Counsel), three copies of the report will be
submitted through OIA for filing in the Director's Office, in the
Office of General Counsel, and in OIA.

c. Release of Findings or Reports. Findings or reports of all
Boards of Inquiry or Inquiry Teams will be released only upon the
Director's authorization in consultation with the General
Counsel. A Board of Inquiry report may be required to be
produced in connection with civil or criminal proceedings or a
FOIA request. A Board of Inquiry report may also be released in
connection with a Congressional inquiry.
If a subpoena or request for discovery is received in
connection with any civil or criminal proceeding that demands, or
reasonably could be construed as to demand, the production of a
Board of Inquiry report, and/or any working notes or personal
records created by members as a result of an inquiry, the
subpoena should be forwarded to the Regional Counsel who, after
consultation with the General Counsel and the Director, as
necessary, will coordinate the production of the documents or
assertion of any evidentiary privilege as appropriate with the
local U.S. Attorney's Office.
Findings or reports from Boards of Inquiry or Inquiry Teams
appointed at the request of the General Counsel or a Regional
Counsel prepared in anticipation of litigation or trial are to be
reviewed by the General Counsel before any release, since these
documents may be privileged documents protected from disclosure
by the attorney work-product privilege. The General Counsel will
make the determination of whether to assert this privilege.
/s/
Kathleen Hawk Sawyer
Director
EFTA00034181 (Jmail)
No Images Produced
EFTA00034346 (Jmail)
No Images Produced
EFTA00034367 (Jmail)
No Images Produced
EFTA00039880 (Jmail)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Silvio J. Mollo Building
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York, New York 10007
November 18, 2020
BY HAND & EMAIL
MDCMetropolitan Detention Center
Legal Department
80 29'h Street
Brooklyn, NY 11232
Re: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
Enclosed is discovery pertinent to the following inmate:

• Ghislaine Maxwell -
Please allow her access to the materials enclosed.
Very truly yours,
AUDREY STRAUSS
Enclosure
Assistant United States Attorneys
EFTA00039881 (Jmail)
U.S. Department of .1 ustice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Silvio J. Mollo Building
One Saint Andrew's Pla:a
New York, New York 10007
November 18, 2020
BY HAND & EMAIL
MDCMetropolitan Detention Center
Legal Department
80 29th Street
Brooklyn, NY 11232
Re: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
word for the drive containing discovery materials pertinent to Ghislaine Maxwell
is and the password for the CD containing discovery materials
pertinent to Ghislaine Maxwell is
Very truly yours,
AUDREY STRAUSS
Acting United States Attorney
Assistant United States Attorneys
EFTA00039882 (Jmail)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Silvio J. Mono Building
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York. New York 10007
November 9, 2020
BY FEDERAL EXPRESS
MDCMetropolitan Detention Center
Legal Department
80 29th Street
Brooklyn, NY 11232
Re: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (AJN)
Enclosed is discovery pertinent to the following inmate:

• Ghislaine Maxwell:
Please allow her access to the materials enclosed.
Very truly yours,
AUDREY STRAUSS
A
Enclosure
Assistant United States Attorneys
EFTA00039883 (Jmail)
U.S. Department of Justice
United States Attorney
Southern District of New York
The Silvio J. Motto Building
One Saint Andrew's Plaza
New York. New York 10007
November 9, 2020
BY FEDERAL EXPRESS
MDCMetropolitan Detention Center
Legal Department
80 29th Street
Brooklyn, NY 11232
Re: United States v. Ghislaine Maxwell, 20 Cr. 330 (MN)
ils word for the drive containing discovery materials pertinent to Ghislaine Maxwell
is
Very truly yours,
AUDREY STRAUSS
Acti
Assistant United States Attorneys
EFTA00039963 (Jmail)
From
To
Cc
Subject: OPR - Epstein
Date: Thu, 06 Aug 2020 20:08:31 +0000
— We just got the draft report from OPR. For reasons I don't fully understand, Outlook is not allowing me to forward
the report itself. But assuming I resole that, any reason I can't share with the team?
Thanks,
U.S. Attorney's Office for the
Southern District of New York
EFTA00040082 (Jmail)
(inferred date: 2001-01-01)
4 ileAR? ) a i
e /8 33--
444 t et-4 raj___5 Ad 0„.11-___
A— a-, conveal:a- eitel‘40^ iv 0( aver
_11, .t _ 140-- 11",t_____13-e. re 4. itsi:`1/42 ,114/
4 eg‘j s k4s e 3 a_ro 61 or as ii 2)
..ti-- 04.451, .00±,._.5 e vt g4 c 4 e`.. /* ,,ty_
ra Ss_ A F.- site s in es ..,,__4,, en G0
cfri i has r 4/0C44•••• trig ky ____hu _Plat
te..% Ills Doth_n____ ue al'i iiiimsnCe., _ties
I
3521-004
Page 1 01 1

╭─────────────────────── Page 1, Image 1 ────────────────────────╮
│ 3521-004                                                       │
│ Page | of |                                                    │
│                                                                │
│ SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER PARAGRAPHS 7, 8, 9, 10, 15, and 17 │
╰────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────╯
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ted Serure [finance] Enhanced Education account manager at Deutsche Bank 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00101280 (Jmail)
 [money] Deutsche Bank Epstein's Deutsche Bank accounts
Account Openings at Deutsche Bank

.                           Approximate
Company                     account values    Type of asset         Account Type    Managed by
JE Epstein                  $667,000.         Cash                  Brokerage       Managed by Ted Serure

Enhanced Education          $4,600,000        Cash                  Brokerage       Managed by Ted Serure

Southern Trust Company Inc  $380,000.         Cash                  Checking.       Checking
Southern Trust Company Inc  $5,500,000.       Cash and Securities   Asset trading   Managed by Paul Barret
Southern Trust Company Inc  $18,750,000.      Cash                  Money market
Southern Trust Company Inc  $5,000,000        Securities            Asset Trading   Managed by Laurie Cameron

Southern Financial LLC      $71,000,000       Derivative trading    Asset trading   Managed by Paul Barret
Southern Financial LLC      $24,000,000       Cash and securities   Asset
Southern Financial LLC      $330,000          Cash and securities   Checking

Jeepers, Inc.               $25,000,000.      Cash and securities   Asset

Butterfly Trust             $8,000.           cash                  Brokerage       Managed by Ted Serure

Haze Trust                  $22,000,000       Derivative Trading    Asset Trading   Manageed by Paul Barret
Haze Trust                  $28,000           Cash                  Money market
EFTA00143492 (Jmail)
 [legal] court filing in which a victim calls Giuffre lawyer Stanley Pottinger an abuser
EFTA00165515 (Jmail)
 [misc] contractor describes Epstein's gun safes
In the second floor library there is a large fireplace. A source who worked
on the stone and marble in the 90's says behind the fireplace was a hidden
staircase. The fireplace and mantle rotated 90 degrees on a center point and
the stairs could be accessed through one side. There was a concealed push
button to rotate it open and close. Source could not remember where the
stairs led. Also contractor at the time purchased a half dozen gun cases,
about the size of a shoebox that could hold guns. The boxes were installed
at the request of Epstein in large piece of furniture around the house
couches, coffee tables. The could open with quick release button.
EFTA00179446 (Jmail)
Native Placeholder
No Images Produced
EFTA00182656 (Jmail)
Native Placeholder
No Images Produced
EFTA00182657 (Jmail)
Native Placeholder
No Images Produced
EFTA00217257 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2001-12-31)
invoice
EFTA00219491 (Jmail)
 [misc] invoice
(date: 2001-04-30)
invoice
EFTA00221072 (Jmail)
 [misc] Operation Leap Year contact list
OPERATION LEAP YEAR/CONTACT LIST

1) Counsel for Jeffrey Epstein
Lilly Ann Sanchez, Esq.
Fowler, White and Burnett
Miami, FL 33131-3300
(phone)
(fax)
Gerald Bernard Lefcourt, Esq.
New York, NY 10021-0406
(phone)
fax)
Roy Black, Esq.
Black. Srebnick. Koms an & Stumpk, P.A.
Miami, FL 33131-4311
(phone)
(fax)

Op. Leap Year Contact List Page 2
Jack Alan Goldberger, Esq.
Atterbury Goldberger et al
West Palm Beach, FL 334015-5015
(phone)
(fax)

2. Counsel for
Bruce M. Lyons, Esq.
Lyons and Sanders
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33304
David Rogers, Larry  Visoski and William Hammond

3. Counsel for Janusz Banasiak
Michael Salnick, Esq.
One Clearlake Centre
West Palm Beach, FL 33401-5014
(phone)
(fax)

Op. Leap Year Contact List Page 3
4. Counsel fo
Michael E. Dutko, Esq.
Bo enschutz & Dutko
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301-2802
M phone)
cell)
fax)
Private Detective: Larry Malanga

5. Counsel for
James L. Eisenberg. Es
West Palm Beach, FL 33401-5007
(phone)
(fax)
Analyst
Federal Bureau of Investigation
(phone)

Op. Leap Year Contact List Page 4
Chiropractor
Perry Bard, DC
Health First Chiropractic Center
West Palm Beach, FL 33409
(phone)
EFTA00238499 (Jmail)
 [money] wire transfer to Signature Bank account
Wire Instructions: Signature Bank Wire ABA:
Swift Code "International": IMMO. Acct:
CONFIDENTIAL UBSTERFtAMAR00003109
EFTA00239787 (Jmail)
Native Placeholder
No Images Produced
EFTA00306981 (Jmail)
 [reputation] 
(inferred date: 2001-10-03)
Formatted Name
Matthew Hiltzik
Email • Internet, Work, Pref
Email • Internet, Work
Name
Matthew Hiltzik
Organization
Michael Wolff's friend
Program ID
-//Apple Inc.//iPhone OS 10.3.1//EN
Telephone Number • Cell, Voice, Pref
Telephone Number  • Work, Voice
VCard Version
3.0
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
                 Victoria Stodden [academia] professor of statistics at University of Southern California [h-its] 
                                                                             Val Kilmer [arts] famous movie actor 
                                                                  Noah Tepperberg [business] nightclub owner [vf] 
 Tina Brown [journalist] editor of The New Yorker, Vanity Fair, Daily Beast, declined Epstein's invitations [nyp] 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00309068 (Jmail)
 [misc] personal cell phone and email address list
PEOPLE LIST

Cell # (unless otherwise stated) and Personal Email (unless otherwise stated)

George Mitchell: GM cell Julia Reed assistant: Janice Neal assistant: Maher Bitar:
Jimmy Cayne: ; Suzette assistant
Noah Tepperberg:
Vera Wang: VW office; Dawn West assistant:
Avi
Faith Kates: <REDACTED>
<REDACTED>: <REDACTED>
Tommy Mottola: <REDACTED>
Verw (I think this is a repeat of Vera Wang with a typo)
Bark
Jennie Saunders:
Olya:
John Brockman:
Barbro Ehnbom:
Jess Banks:

Dr. Richard Axel:
Columbia
Guiseppi Cipriani:
Barry Jospehson:
Ramsey Elkholy:
Regina
Leon Black:
Henry Rosovsky: HOME
Lawrence Krauss:
Andrew Farkas:
Joe Pagano: <REDACTED>; Kasia assistant
JP Molyneux:
Ace Greenberg: Office
Peggy Siegel:
Lily Sanchez:
Marty Weinberg:
Alan Dershowitz:
Bill Riley:
Steve Kosslyn:
Wilson
Glasses-trapp
Martin Nowak:
Harvard
Vanessa Modely:
Tom Barrack:
<REDACTED>
Lana:
Daniel from Paris:
Dasha Grupman:
Valdson Cotrin:
<REDACTED>
Dick Merkin: Office
Doug Schoettle:
Kevin Law:
Marvin Minsky:
Eduardo Teodorani:
Al
Bill Richardson: <REDACTED>; Janis Assistant:
Tina Brown: Office <REDACTED>; Lena Assistant
Boris Nikolic:
Melz
<REDACTED>
Mark Zeff:
Reid Weingarten:
Jean Luc Brunel:
Nicole Junkermann:
Teddy Forstman:
Jason
Marshall Rose: Office
Schertzman
Glenn Dubin:
tudor
ffi  Assistant:
Jes Staley:
Terje Roed Larsen:
Richard Johnson: Office
Warwick Wicksman:
Naomi Campbell:
Tom Pritzker:
Mottola:
Michael Ovitz:
<REDACTED>
Nathan:
Peter Mandelson:
David Mitchell:
Jeff Matusow: Office
Barnaby Marsh:
George Church:
Roger Schank:
Charles Harper:
Set
Val Kilmer: Office
Harvey Weinstein:
Len Blavatnik:
Eva Dubin:
Koch
Sultan
David Tang
Michael Milken:
Larry Summers:
Jay Lefkowitz:
Frederic Fekkai:
Victoria Stodden:
Duke of York: 44
Adam Bly:
Pablos Holman:
Galertner
EFTA00313981 (Jmail)
 [misc] architectural plans for chateau on Great St. James island
GSJ

1. Great St. James - Bui:dings overall location:

• Chateau is correct in the Center but align center with existing beach stars.
• Helicopter landing site is correct on North-East point of GSJ.

• Office site is correct on East point of GSJ.
• Pending roads. service roads. landscape, and connection from the Dock.

2. Beach level Entry/Approach:

• Need two (2) entrances. One directly from Dock up the stairs into the house.
Second one covered next to security where bikes can be pulled up to/park and walk directly into the house. (Back 
entrance)

• 20'-25' Promenade at beach level with transition spaces (BBQ, Firepit, water
feature) Promenade runs along the beach approximately where existing TikiBar
is.
Chateau Main Floor (1s Floor)

• Huge Living area. Approx. 30'x60'. On the center overlooking the pool/water.
• Large Kitchen to one side. With a great view. Approx. 30x40'. With a Pantry approx. 12'x15'. Storage closet + Freezer 
Area. Large room for storage & cleaning
equipment.

• Covered Terrace outside kitchen tc eat when weather allows. Breakfast area inside kitchen.
• Three small (3) staff rooms. Approx. 10'x141.

• Private sitting room-separate from Living area. Approx. 14'x16'.
• Sitting room looking into the water (Occasionally and when weather allows
doors/windows will be open).

• Private TV Room-For Karyna and her friends. Her TV Room.
• Piano Room, Approx. 30'x20'.

4. Chateau Pool deck (l s Floor)

• Located approx.15' above beach level.
• 100' long pool.
• Areas for sunbathing.
• Outdoor covered terraces for relaxing.

• Underneath pool deck: Area for security personnel in the evening (wall to left of model by the trees) With video 
cameras.
EFTA00315184 (Jmail)
 [misc] pre-printed welcome cards for Epstein's apartments
Welcome to Apartment 10B
Your Apartment Door Code Is:
The WiFI Code for your apartment is:
User Name:
If you require assistance please do not hesitate to
contact us via the office or our cell phones:
Office
Lesley cell:
Our Apartments are SMOKE FREE. Thank you
for your Cooperation.
EFTA00432804 (Jmail)
 [misc] recorded conversation of Epstein, see quote: "Katie Couric, I thought, was going to start to vomit"
Richard: Here's your power supply, which I borrowed.
Jeffrey Epstein: Terrific.
So far with the mice, what are seeing about learning? There was an article saying that each neuron n
ow, as opposed to like a switch, its it's own little computer. Do you have the sense there's lots of
different inputs?
Richard: You can say that, but I'm not sure...
Jeffrey: That's useful?
Richard: That it's useful to think about the function of the nerve system as reflecting the function
of any individual neuron.
Jeffrey: Most systems don't...
Richard: You can play with the system and get a neuron to do something, but that's not how it works.
You need the reserve. So its own source.
Jeffrey: Most of the work in viruses and stuff that you do has almost no energy component, right?
Richard: I don't know what that means. Energy, if you were going there or wanted to go, that convers
ation never...
Jeffrey: Took off?
Richard: Never took off.
Jeffrey: In biology there's no driving factor. No physical driving factor.
Richard: No, there must be. That is systems will move to a state. You know this better than I. Syste
ms have to move to a state of some sort.
Jeffrey: But they - yes.
Richard: You can call it a equilibrium. Then you ask yourself what's driving it to that equilibrium.
Is it energy? I don't know. No.
Jeffrey: Usually things, under the second law, are running themselves down. They're not increasing t
heir energy.
Richard: But if you want to talk about physical energy, real.. .
Jeffrey: Yeah, I'm not talking about the growth type of bioenergy.
Richard: Then the energy sources in neurons, to my knowledge - and there are a lot of people who wou
Id disagree with me intensely. But to my knowledge energy, ATP, is not rate limited.
Jeffrey: What do you mean?
Richard: That a neuron generates enough energy from the hydrolysis of ATP to carry out all of its fu
nations without ATP every limiting, without energy ever limiting those functions.
And that's because the cell is set up - in an internal equilibrium, the cell is set up not to need m
ore than it can have. And it's set up in such a way that when it is called upon, it always has the A
TP it needs.
Jeffrey: It got it from the environment, from sugars.
Richard: Yeah. It's oxygen.
Jeffrey: Yes, but you have to define the system. That's always the problem. Does the system you just
described include the oxygen in the environment? If the neuron is the system, it's very different.
The neuron as the environment of the system is a different equation, right?
Richard: Well, it's the whole organism that we're talking about here. Because it's the organism that
's generating...
Jeffrey: Fine. But where's the boundary of the organism? Is it the cell wall? In your calculation -
what?
Richard: You're great. Well, obviously I can bound the organism by its skin. Because it needs to tak
e in sources of energy and oxygen.
Jeffrey: OK. Yeah. So I don't know what you mean by - when you're defining...
Richard: But glucose and oxygen are never rate limiting, right?
Jeffrey: That's fine. But the amount of glucose is, in the environment.
Richard: Not to you and I.
Jeffrey: Yes, I understand. But it's not infinite.
Richard: It's not infinite. It could be limiting to some.
Jeffrey: So it's a fact that's interesting, when you define the organism, even the cell, does it inc
lude its membrane and the surrounding part of it? How do you define. ..
Richard: These are semantic issues. They're philosophic at some level. I mean, can I define a neural
network without all of its connections? No. Can I define a cell without an understanding of the way
it has to communicate with its environment? No.
Jeffrey:
Richard:
Jeffrey:
Richard:
Jeffrey:
Does a virus need energy to survive, for example? I'm unclear.
Do you mean to survive outside of a cell?
Yes.
You call that survival?
So Jewish. Right. The mother of the virus. Unless it was a doctor, it hasn't doesn't well.
Richard: You call that survival? Yes. You can desiccate it, put it into a vacuum, and you can take i
t back up as a virus. So you tell me what energy is in that circumstance.
Jessica: But it wouldn't be operating as a virus then, as its function.
Jeffrey: It's a virus, but a non-operating virus? I'm trying first to define my terms, before I whac
k you.
Richard: I want to define "survive." If you wanted to remain in a replicatively competent state, if
at the a first approximation the only thing a virus wants to do is replicate... OK, we can question
that too.
Jeffrey: A virus wants to replicate?
Richard: Yeah. The evolutionary forces put on the virus are designed largely to enhance its rate of
replication up to a point where it does not replicate so much that it diminishes its potential for r
eplication. Right?
Interviewer Right.
Richard: That's why HIV doesn't immediately kill its host, perhaps.
Jeffrey: Perhaps. A question from your view. What advantage does replication have? It's not a simple
question.
Richard: There's no advantage. There's selection. So you do the following experiment. If there's no
advantage, you're adding value judgments to all of this.
Jeffrey: There's a cost.
Richard: It's all a function of
test tube, which as the ability
icate? OK? You make many copies
rgue is a million bases.
Jeffrey: Sure.
selection from randomness. That is, if you take
to replicate, can you add the enzymes necessary
of this piece of DNA, which I'm going to begin,
Richard: And if you know let it replicate and take the DNA
the DNA out, and take the DNA out and feed it more enzyme,
e experiments, you will get back out a piece of DNA that's
Jeffrey: Really?
Richard: And all it is designed to do is replicate. Great.
will occur and those mutations which afford a more rapid
at the end. Do you understand what I'm saying?
a piece of DNA in a
for that DNA to repl
hypothetically, to a
out and feed it more enzyme and take out
after about 20 of these serial replicativ
about 100 bases long.
What will have happened is that mutations
replication rate will be all that you see
There is not want. Because the number of organisms is a function of the replication, if you can make
something that replicated more efficiently and something is limiting, then at the end all you will
see is those molecules.
So it's not an issue of want.
Jeffrey: But in your example you had an unlimited supply of enzymes.
Richard: No. If it was unlimited, you'll see this even more quickly.
Jeffrey: Well, if you only had one time...
Richard: If you only have one time, you're not going to have any replication. If you only have one r
ound, you're not going to see anything.
Jeffrey: So with your enzyme and consistently replicating, do you view it as there's a cost to the r
eplication?
Richard: Of course there's a cost to the replication. Each time you do this you essentially require
ATP. When a base goes into DNA it's XTP. It's a triphosphate, it a high-energy bond that's broken wh
en it polymerizes.
But what I'm trying to say is we can't try and anthropomorphize...
Jeffrey: I'm not wanting anything.
Richard: Good.
Jeffrey: You're going to end up with more things just by definition...
Richard: Only a random process of change and selection from that randomness.
Jeffrey: You say selection. Selection sort of suggests there's conflict. Are you saying there's comp
etition, when you're talking about selection?
Richard: Yeah.
Jeffrey: Where'
Richard: Well,
ou're going to
s the competition?
if you don't have a lot of enzyme then - well, even if you do have a lot of enzyme, y
end up with this small molecule. But competition simply exaggerates that ratio.
Jeffrey: But then if you look at living systems, the system... Because the system you just defined t
ends towards many small, simplified pieces virtually being the same.
Richard: Yes.
Jeffrey: So where does the complexity start for organisms? Because based on what you just said, most
systems just degenerate in their smallest, most highly replicable pieces without a direction.
Richard: Yeah. That's DNA in a dish. When you're in an organism, the requirements for survival are r
eally quite different. So need to build up - you need a minimum level of complexity to accommodate s
urvival, but at the same time maximize reproductive capability.
Jeffrey: You keep saying "survival."
Richard: No, I just introduced survival. I started with selection.
Jeffrey: Right. How do you define survival?
Richard: The ability to live through your reproductive period.
Jeffrey: The full lifecycle?
Richard: We're beyond that.
Jeffrey: Speak for yourself.
Richard: You're right. I can't speak for you.
Jeffrey: I meant for her.
Richard: Have you reproduced?
Jessica: No.
Richard: We're not going there.
[laughter]
Richard: That was over 20 years ago, that conversation.
Jeffrey: Correct. OK. So now you have your cell. Now the cells are reproducing as well. Not only the
DNA.
Richard: Yeah. The cells are reproducing. See, the virus has to reproduce also. You can view it... T
here are three things going on.
Jeffrey: At least.
Richard: There's survival, reproduction, and random mutations. And selection from those random mutat
ions so as to enhance survival and reproduction.
Jeffrey: You can't enhance survival.
Richard: Sure you can.
Jeffrey: But not based on your definition.
Richard: Sure you can select for survival. You select both for survival and reproduction.
Jeffrey: You select. But I'm saying you can't enhance. If your survival...
Richard: You don't enhance anything. You make random changes and selection pulls out the mutations w
ith changes that afford an enhancement.
Jeffrey: So your enhancement is defined by time?
Richard: You mean for survival or reproduction?
Jeffrey: Well, survival, you've defined survival by living through your reproductive cycle.
Richard: You can survive, yes, that's enough. That's enough. If you expand your reproductive time th
at will afford selection. Because you will expand the number of offspring.
Jeffrey: I think you'd say things that live longer, that survive longer...
Richard: Have I been through my argument about the woman's pelvis impeding intellectual development?
Jeffrey: I've already known that, because I can't focus on anything else.
Jessica: I hear this "duh" from Jeffrey.
(laughter]
Jeffrey: Because she was wearing her pelvis in her bra?
Richard: I think that the only thing that correlates with intelligence is brain-to-body size, if you
go through species. It's the relative size of the brain with respect to the body. And the relative
size of the human brain is most restricted, I think, by the size of the vaginal vault.
Jeffrey: I have keys to that vault.
Jessica: That's compelling.
Richard: Why do I find it requires a combination and you find it requires keys?
Jessica: Or a finger scan or something.
Jeffrey: That's disgusting.
Jessica: I crossed the line.
Jeffrey: Or you meant the retinal scan. Would a retinal scan do?
Richard: A retinal scan?
Jeffrey: As opposed to keys or combinations.
Richard: No. That's the wrong eye.
Jeffrey: Yes.
(laughter]
Jeffrey: There is an argument that...
Richard: Cephalo-pelvic diproportion is what impedes brain development. It's a good thing Katie Cour
is isn't here.
Jeffrey: Correct.
Richard: I had images that the clones on channel whatever....
Jeffrey: She didn't like that very much.
Richard: She wasn't here for the no arms.
Jeffrey: Right. Katie Couric was here and we were talking about... I think we should, I want to star
t cloning things, me. And with certain people, Prince Andrew got upset because he was all, "If it ha
d a conscience, could you kill it for spare parts." And I said, "I'll make it without a head, would
that make you feel better?" And Katie Couric, I thought, was going to start to vomit.
Richard: That they may evolve with a head or arms or feet, so it couldn't get up and walk away.
Jeffrey: And did dishes.
Richard: What?
Jeffrey: Did the dishes too. But you'd argue over a long period of time, a pressure like the limitin
g of the pelvic canal would make the brain more efficient. Not necessarily a limiting factor.
Richard: You think so?
Jeffrey: That's what you would assume by the eye? The eye is taking up a great part of the brain?
Richard: If I tell you that the major determinant of intelligence is brain-to-body size, you say, OK
, I'm going to make it more efficient. I say, OK, make it more efficient, make it bigger. Then you'v
e really got it. Then you're countering the argument.
Jeffrey: For example women who have 10% less - well, they have 10% less neurons in the brain, virtua
Ily.
Richard: Right.
(phone rings)
Richard: Sorry, I have a very sick friend.
Jessica: So if someone really wanted to start a new race of superiorly intelligent people, they woul
d prefer to have only cesareans, right?
Jeffrey: Is he still alive?
Richard: That's the problem. He would be much better off dead.
Jeffrey: Does he get a vote?
Richard: As close as Joe.
Jeffrey: Oh, really?
Richard: Yeah, really serious.
Jeffrey: One of those walking down the street and then boom? An aneurysm.
Richard: In bed.
Jessica: How old.
Richard: My age.
Jeffrey: So he's old already.
Richard: Old.
Jeffrey: He's already lived a full life.
Richard: Gone beyond his reproductive stage. In fact, his prostate...
Jeffrey: Did he?
Richard: That's not why.
Jeffrey: Let me digress for a second.
Richard: As if you haven't been digressing?
Jeffrey: Yes. I've been regressing.
Richard: That's not possible.
Jeffrey: Yes, that's true. I'd have to turn into a virus.
Jessica: You laughed at yourself, so there.
Jeffrey: That's disgusting. If I could, I would.
Jessica: You were talking about again?
Richard: Talking about regression.
Jeffrey: Suggesting - he's likes the idea of testosterone replacement.
Richard: Replacement? That's not the issue.
Jeffrey: But we were talking Viagra and he said he's a much bigger fan of testosterone. Jerry Edlema
n says if you fuck with nature you're going to end up doing something bad to yourself. And if you wa
nt to play with that curve, that curve does weird things to you. Nature seems to have a way of getti
ng back to you.
Boris's retort was, "Well, nature gives you diseases, we can figure out how to cure diseases. If you
do things carefully, it's probably better than letting nature take its course."
Richard: The argument against testosterone - I'm hardly an expert on this or anything. It's remarkab
le how well I've done, given my ignorance. It's outstanding to me at times.
Jeffrey: And other's around you.
Richard: Yeah, I reinforces this...
Jeffrey: Amazement.
Richard: Yeah. If you take testosterone, what you do is you turn off the cells in the hypothalamic -p
ituitary axis. So those cells are basically shut down.
Jeffrey: It's that FSH/LSH deal, right?
Richard: Exactly. And it's not clear what other effects those hormones might be having that aren't r
eplaced by testosterone. And so the advantage to taking testosterone, there are two different things
You can have high testosterone and still have a need for Viagra, because you don't have a prostate,
right?
Jeffrey: Correct.
Richard: So that's an extreme example. There are actually two examples...
Jeffrey: I was actually going to try and move up one level of sort of drug-enhancing life. You don't
mind it. He doesn't mind it. Am I sort of outer -space thinking that it's better to have no drugs?
Richard: Yeah.
Jessica: To clarify, you mean the intervention of drugs.
Jeffrey: It's better to have no drugs?
Richard: Yes. I don't take anything else. I don't like drugs.
Jeffrey: But is that because you grew up...
Richard: Because I went to medical school.
Jeffrey: (laughs) OK. But you like statins, no?
Richard: No, I don't take them.
Jessica: Statins? What's that?
Jeffrey: They reduce your cholesterol. You don't take any of those things?
Richard: No.
Jeffrey: Is it because your diet's healthy enough.
Richard: And my cholesterol is not...
Jeffrey: So you're against drugs. You're like me.
Richard: Yeah. I'm against drugs, but there are some overriding concerns.
Jeffrey: Yes, I understand that. But why are you against drugs? Unintended consequences.
Richard: And the fact that I,
like a lot of it. You're not
Jeffrey: If a little is good,
Richard: Yes, exactly. I'm of
fit, I'm going to take it ...
unlike you, I have an addictive personality. So if I like something, I
like this.
more is better. That philosophy.
that philosophy. So that means if the drug is going to do me some bene
Jeffrey: Up to the boundary, and probably above.
Richard: Up to the boundary and probably far longer than any clinical trail has taken it. Because th
e amount of time that I plan to experience joy is far greater than the amount of time that Pfizer is
going to put into a clinical trail. Got it? You know what I'm talking about.
Jeffrey: Yes. But that's a personal explanation. I don't want ice cream because I'll eat the whole
allon. I don't to splurge.
Richard: No, I didn't say I don't want ice cream.
Jeffrey: No, I'm saying I think ice cream is compare to drugs. I can't stop myself, so I don't want
to take the first bite.
Richard: I told you, there are some things...
Jeffrey: No, I understand how the other...
Richard: There's no reason... This again is a philosophic issue. If you can enhance your life meanin
gfully with drugs, I would take them. But I don't see any arenas other than sex where that's true. U
nless you're like Joe and you have a pharmacopoeia. His entire house if filled with bottles or rice
extract.
But what
Jeffrey:
Richard:
Jeffrey:
Richard:
Jeffrey:
Richard:
Jeffrey:
Richard:
Jeffrey:
Richard:
9
other aspects of your life, short of...
How about sleep?
What about sleep?
Simple sleep.
I love sleep.
So would you take a sleeping pill?
Very rarely.
Wouldn't it enhance - as opposed to sex, which we both agree on.
Sleep is of no value. I don't really...
I agree with you.
It's of no value. MacBeth had murdered sleep. So you tell me, other than mind enhancing dru
Jeffrey: Well, you can't say •other than,• because...
Richard: Is that what you're talking about?
Jeffrey: At least mind-enhancing drugs. You would go for insulin if you were diabetic. If you had a
deficiency.
Richard: Oh, yeah.
Jessica: If you were sick.
Jeffrey: If you had a deficiency, you'd make up a deficiency.
Richard: If I had a deficiency, I'd make up a deficiency. If I don't have to take antibiotics, I don
't take them prophylactically. I don't take a Z-pack unless I have a bacteria. Many people do.
Jeffrey: But if you had a lack of dopamine, would you take antidepressants? Tell why it would be dif
ferent than taking insulin?
Richard: Didn't I tell you about my antidepressant experience?
Jeffrey: No, I don't think so.
Richard: I got extremely depressed, much more so than my usual dulled state, 15 years ago. And I wen
t to a psychiatrist and he prescribed Prozac. I don't like Prozac, but I was feeling pretty bad. I t
old you this.
Jeffrey: I don't think so. See, if I had a memory -enhancing drug, I'd be able to answer that questio
n more effectively.
Richard: So there we don't have to go.
Jeffrey: I would remember the story if you told me.
Richard: So I told him if I was going to take an antidepressant, I wanted it in liquid form and I wa
nted it green. So whenever I felt bad I could swig. So he gave me Prozac in a bottle. This huge bott
le of Prozac, it was green. They can make it any color you want, and I wanted green.
So I has this green Prozac in a large bottle like this, and the bottle was supposed to last a month.
By the end of three days, I went down - I drank about half the bottle. It was in East Hampton. And
I felt better, and then I dropped the bottle on the lawn and it spilled out. Six hours later there w
as an eight -foot circle of grass that died.
Jeffrey: Of dead grass? Right.
Richard: I stopped taking it.
Jeffrey: Is that it?
Richard: Yeah. Anti-depressants work, at some level. They don't make the problem go away, they make
the problem less impacting.
Jeffrey: So are you free of...
Richard: I'll deal with the problem. But what about enhancing drugs? If there really were drugs. ..
Jeffrey: Well, nicotine.
Richard: Yeah. I'm thinking now it's just an addiction.
Jeffrey: But don't people think that there's a neurotransmitter booster?
Richard: Yeah. You know, age-adjusted smokers have a far lower incidence of Alzheimer's disease.
Jeffrey: Is that true?
Richard: Yeah. Far lower. Really prevents Alzheimer's disease.
Jeffrey: That's interesting.
Richard: Yeah.
Jessica: Or are they dying before?
Richard: One of those age adjusted. That's all taken care of.
Jessica: I see, age adjusted.
Jeffrey: It could be self-selected, right?
Richard: It could be self-selected.
Jeffrey: If you're a smoker.
Richard: Yeah.
Jeffrey: You're thinking about cause of things.
Richard: It's possible. Except, if you look at the -- no, no.
Jeffrey: Have they taken...
Richard: Too many people smoke.
Jeffrey: Do they take nicotine as opposed to smokers?
Richard: No, there's not enough data there.
Jeffrey: That's OK. Back to our virus.
Richard: OK. Are we going to robots?
Jeffrey: Not yet.
Jessica: Are we definitely recording, by the way?
Jeffrey: Yes.
Jessica: OK.
Richard: Are you recording this?
Jeffrey: Of course. Robots, no, viruses. They're not all alive. Or, are they alive? Your definition?
Jessica: I'm dying to hear this.
Richard: They're not capable of replicating outside of a unit that we would call alive.
Jeffrey: OK.
Richard: We accept that, right?
Jeffrey: Yeah, it's like software with no hardware. Is that fair?
Richard: Yes.
Jeffrey: There's no program. Theoretically it can run a program, but it needs hardware on which to r
un. Is that a decent analogy or no?
Richard: We can go there.
Jeffrey: Why are you hesitating? Because it's a software and hardware form?
Richard: Well, because it carries some hardware. It's software in hardware form, yes.
Jeffrey: Right? But most software isn't actually in hardware form.
Richard: Yes.
Jeffrey: Right?
Richard: Yes.
Jeffrey: It's not an idea.
Richard: Yes, it needs a delivery mechanism and right.
Jeffrey: Right.
Richard: So you need a way for the software to exploit a hardware.
Jeffrey: I'm sorry.
Jessica: May I ask a question?
Richard: Yeah.
Jessica: Is that the same as RNA/DNA though? If the virus can't replicate without some other living
house, could the same thing be said about DNA?
Richard: Absolutely.
Jessica: So then, the differentiation there between
Richard: All the virus is, is an encapsulated mechanism to maximize the efficiency in which its DNA
can enter a cell and replicate.
Jessica: OK, so using that as the differentiation.
Richard: You can take a piece of DNA or RNA and infect a cell and get a virus back out, or get that
DNA back out.
Jeffrey: Right, so it's simply programs, isn't it?
Richard: The DNA is programs.
Jeffrey: So it's a virus.
Richard: A virus is more... It's got the machinery to enhance the ability of those programs to find
itself in a minuet capable of being read.
Jeffrey: Yes, it's a program with a specific goal.
Richard: Yes.
Jeffrey: It's a specific program.
Richard: Yes.
Jeffrey: Not very much different than any other program. DNA is simply a different type of program,
maybe more complicated. The virus tries to in fact hack into the DNA's program, right?
Richard: Yes, absolutely.
Jeffrey: And with your views, it's so that it enabled not enabled. You have to help me with these wo
rds that are anthropomorphized. It has the result that it replicates.
Richard: Yes.
Jeffrey: So now, the DNA arguably will try to... If there's a barrel, where does the competition bet
ween two things that replicate begin?
So let's assume we have a virus that replicates and a DNA that replicates.
Richard: A virus is often DNA. What's inside a virus? DNA.
Jeffrey: OK.
Richard: Irony.
Jeffrey: Where does the competition begin? Because you need selection.
Richard: Between two viruses?
Jeffrey: Yes. Now we start to get into science.
Richard: This all gets rather mundane and beneath your mind.
Jeffrey: No, no, it doesn't. It doesn't. This, I believe, is the essence of it.
Richard: OK, so the first step, if you look at the steps in a viral lifecycle, the first thing that
has to happen is the virus has to bind to a cell surface.
Jeffrey: OK.
Richard: Then it needs a mechanism of entry into the cell.
Jeffrey: Right.
Richard: Then it needs to uncoat the nucleic acid to make it available for the replicative enzymes,
and then it needs to replicate. And then it needs to fold up again into a viral particle. That's an
abbreviated viral lifecycle. Each one of those steps is potentially a competitive event.
Jeffrey: Competitive with?
Richard: With other viruses in the population. In a population of viruses of the same strain, they'r
e all different.
Jeffrey: OK.
Richard: Right? They're all different. They all have some changes in their DNA. Those changes in the
DNA can affect the efficacy of every step from binding to the receptor on the surface to the ultima
to repackaging and release of virus.
Jeffrey: Right. So therefore, then cells that were able to protect themselves from the virus - that'
s another part of the competition, right?
Richard: Cells will have - yeah. That's a different plate. That's a different plate.
Jeffrey: But I said it wasn't beneath
Richard: Are you writing a book?
Jeffrey: No. Beneath...
Richard: Are you?
Jeffrey: No.
Jessica: No.
Jeffrey: When I say it's beneath my level, you have two viruses, and now you have a cell. So you fir
st started out your competition with the two viruses. Where does a cell fit into that competition?
Richard: Firstly, the cell is trying to avoid being infected by that virus.
Jeffrey: We're both doing the same thing. That is trying to avoid, right?
Richard: Yeah, sorry. Right. So let's leave the cell. You do have a cell. I don't know what you're a
sking.
Jeffrey: Where's the competition? Because you talked about competition.
Richard: Right.
Jeffrey: First of all, are you competing for a goal? Are you competing for survival? I want you to d
efine these.
Richard:
Jeffrey:
Richard:
Jeffrey:
Richard:
A virus is competing largely on the basis of...
Its efficacy to attack a cell. Yes, sorry.
The ultimate selector is the number of viruses that emerge after this process.
The number of the same virus?
The same virus that will emerge after this process.
Jeffrey: OK. So therefore, since it needs the cell, the cell has to be in competition with the virus
es as well.
Richard:
Jeffrey:
Richard:
Jeffrey:
e cells.
That logic I don't follow. Since it needs the cell...
If the cell's not there, you can't do it.
Yes, but that doesn't mean the cell's in competition with the virus.
We now have a system. It's not one cell we're really talking about. We're talking about fiv
Richard: Let's talk about cell and then we'll go to five.
Jeffrey: I knew you would do that. OK. If the viruses can't break into the cell, if the cell is more
antiviral, then the cell survives and the viruses die. So in our system of cell and two viruses, th
e competition for survival, cell wins.
Richard: Now you're talking about a competition between the virus and the cell. That of course occur
s, but it's a separate phenomenon that has to be considered when one thinks about competition betwee
n viruses.
Jeffrey: This is where a game theory and all of these problems first starts breaking down. When you
start having the three components -- this is the part where there's a three body problem.
Richard: Right.
Jeffrey: Because really I have two viruses that are competing to attack the cell, and the cell...
Richard: Competing with each of those viruses.
Jeffrey: Competing -- this is a tricky word -- because I'm not sure if you don't want to say coordin
ating as well. You could argue in any type of game theory - instead of talking viruses and cells, yo
u could talk about two red players and a blue player - right? The jobs of the players are to circumv
ent takeover of the blue - get the blue flag.
At some point, it might make sense for the cooperation between one of the viruses and the blue playe
r. A red and a blue to knock out this one, which is already fairly stronger.
Richard: That could be. You could imagine a scenario where if you have two cells and two viruses, th
at an infected cell would involve a competitive advantage over an uninfected cell, unquestionably. T
hat is why viruses can cause cancer.
Jeffrey: Whoa! Now that was a good leap. That was like a Jeffrey type of leap. Explain.
Richard: It's true. That is, there are viruses which when they infect a cell, alter the replicative
processes of the cell such that those cells divide more rapidly. Now, you can see why that virus wou
Id be very happy to do that.
Jeffrey: No question.
Richard: So I don't need to explain?
Jeffrey: No, it got hijacked.
Richard: Right. So the virus has hijacked the cellular machinery, and in the most simplistic format,
it has inserted itself into the genome rather than residing free. There is a selection for making m
ore copies of the virus, and the only way you can make more copies of the virus is by making more ce
Ils.
Jeffrey: Is by making more copies of the cells. Right.
Richard: Those cells lose the restraints on division that their uninfected counterparts would exhibi
t, and you end up with a tumor.
Jessica: Is that HPV?
Richard: No, HPV is papillomavirus virus. That's something else.
Jessica: It doesn't cause cancer?
Richard: It does ultimately cause cancer, yes. Absolutely.
Jessica: OK.
Richard: The best example of this is a virus that probably doesn't cause cancer in humans, but can
n animals and in a dish. It's SV40. You've heard of it. It's the most studied DNA tumor virus. The s
imian virus.
Jeffrey: Yeah, but what you're saying though, it's interesting, is that...
Richard: I have to leave in about 15-20 minutes.
Jeffrey: OK, so the cancer cell has won the game, right? It's figured out a mechanism to survive.
Richard: Yes.
Jeffrey: Under the original definition.
Richard: Right. Survive and replicate, yes.
Jeffrey: So the cells win, but the organism loses.
Richard: Yes.
Jeffrey: So we start off with the same process with the viruses. Virus, cell, cell, organism. So you
have this competition, because now it's the organism that basically it's in the organism's interest
to turn down the survivability of the replicating cell. It's not in the cell's interest.
Richard: Right. And the remarkable thing... I don't want to get too teleologic. At a first approxima
tion, all tumors appear after reproductive life. So you can either allocate. That's because it take
a really long time for a tumor to develop.
Or you could argue that there are mechanism to prevent tumor formation...
Jeffrey: Until it's too late.
Richard: Yes. So you see, the organism, at a first approximation, doesn't give a damn if it -- more
anthropomorphizing again. But it's of no selective advantage to an organism, and we can argue about
this, but there's not selective advantage for an organism to live beyond its reproductive life. And
therefore it has evolved mechanisms to prevent tumors from occurring early in life, but had not both
ered to eradicate them or prevent their occurrence late in life.
Jeffrey: If you go back to our first conversation with respect to Alexa, and general relativity, and
frames of reference, you've come full circle. I think what happens is while you might argue that th
ere's no advantage to sort of stay alive past your reproductive cycle, as long as that...
Richard: I'm not sure I believe that.
Jeffrey: I'm saying even as a hypothesis. You'd have to then decide in what frame are you going to e
mbed that answer. So if you're only thinking about cell life, yes, it probably makes little sense th
at once her ovaries are finished for her to stay alive, in fact.
Unless the organism which you're describing is the society or the larger group in which she's embedd

ed. She ends up being food. She can be eaten by others. So the longer there's food around... If she'
s prey, not necessarily if she's a predator, but if she's only prey, you want the prey to stay food
for others. You want prey to stay alive.
Richard: That's a much more... That's the same with cannibalizing. Stay within a species and don't g
o outside the species for a moment. If there's cannibalism, then there may be some advantage for her
to grow beyond her reproductive life.
Jeffrey: But not because what species, but if in fact the young -- like the grandmothers. The idea o
f why they have grandmothers in the first place. If the idea that the women, the middle-aged women,
are going to have to leave and get some food. And the young are still in danger, then you have the g
randmothers who keep the young going. So they're not necessarily for...
I think the argument is, again, which frame of reference.
Richard: Right. So that's a societal selection. That's a population selection. And your friends thin
k about this a lot.
Jeffrey: I don't know if you can separate it. The whole thing with the idea about cancer. Is there a
benefit?
Richard: Right. That just shifts my thinking, but it doesn't shift my logic. If you want the organis
Jeffrey: Suicide bombers, by the way, are my example. Of a suicide bomber... When I first met Presid
ent Bush the first time - old Bush, 41 - he came to me and said he was on his way to present the med
al to a hero. "Really," I said. "Where is he?" Well, he's dead. He's presenting the medal to his par
ents. He was a hero, he saved his whole platoon because he jumped on a grenade.
And that sort of starts the thinking of, well, he's a hero, but probably not to him. He didn't do ve
ry well as the cell, as the piece of the organism, he's dead. He probably didn't do himself a good j
ob.
Richard: Yeah, he's nothing. But that's, again, a philosophical argument. He's not even dead to hims
elf.
Jeffrey: Correct. However, for the benefit of the group, you would certainly argue that the group be
nefited by him killing himself. So you then have to figure out, just like the cells and the organism
, the organism survived but he died.
Richard: Yeah. This argument has been addressed by your friend - what's his name, the evolutionary b
ehaviorist.
Jeffrey: Nowak?
Richard: Nowak, right. In some detail. And he really doubts the existence of altruistic genes that e
nhance the survival of a population.
Jeffrey: But that's not specifically altruism.
Richard: Well, this is altruism. He went to his own... This is a perfect example of it?
Jeffrey: Of killing yourself?
Richard: Yeah.
Jessica: For the benefit of others.
Jeffrey: Hmm?
Jessica: For the benefit of other essentially.
Richard: He knows a lot about this. I'm not sure I agree with everything he says, but he knows a lot
about this.
Jeffrey: See, altruism is usually much more about the interaction. You're giving away something for
free. As opposed to...
Richard: This is the ultimate.
Jeffrey: For the benefit of - OK. Is your method of - basically if you think about the cells and the
organism, could you argue it makes sense for his family for him to kill himself. Would you want to
argue that point? It seems to be a pretty good deal, right?
And the question is, how many things do you do...
Richard: Do you really think there are 70 virgins in heaven?
Jeffrey: No. 69. No.
Richard: So no value.
Jeffrey: But I think a great deal of what people do, Richard, is unknowing behave the exact same way
as the guy who threw himself on the hand grenade. He would probably tell you... His parents were pr
oud of him, by the way, that he did this.
But when they say that people want to make a difference, it seems to be a big thing now, the behavio
r of -- especially women. What do you want to do with your life? I want to make a difference.
It seems to have the same benefit of the organism and opposed to their own benefit.
Richard: Say that again? This is a concept I'm not fairly familiar with?
Jeffrey: Making a difference?
Richard: Making a difference. But I want to get up tomorrow morning. But go on.
Jeffrey: But why are you working so hard?
Richard: Because I love it.
Jessica: To make a difference is so relative.
Jeffrey: People want to do things for the benefit of the group, I think, and they don't know that's
why they're doing it.
(laughter]
Jessica: Versus their own ego?
Richard: I'm glad.
Jeffrey: That they don't' know.
Richard: No, that they do want to do something for my benefit.
Jeffrey: So what's your winning strategy? You winning strategy should not be doing something for the
benefit of the group, necessarily. It's not necessarily in your interest.
Richard: I'm Beckett-ian. I don't have any of these views. They're not biologic. It's not a biologic
issue.
Jeffrey: Behavior is not?
Richard: Well, of course my behavior is biological. But you're making the argument that my behavior
has a purpose.
Jeffrey: Yes.
Richard: Good.
Jeffrey: But for the group purpose, not yours.
Richard: Let's consider your behavior.
Jeffrey: You sound like my mother. That's such a horrible thought. You would argue that my behavior
is for the benefit of the group.
Richard: I'm trying to think that through.
Jeffrey: Probably of not what to do.
Jessica: But that's interesting though, as a teacher. That's the same thing as humans living longer
and getting more experience being valuable as a teacher to the group as well.
Richard: I'm very selfish and I work harder than most people. It's because I take real joy in it. An
d if it happens to help the group, that's good.
Jeffrey: OK. That's fair. I know your time is limited, but I want you one funny story.
Richard: Go ahead.
Jeffrey: Not funny. It's a horrible story. I am trying to get a pardon. So Obama cannot pardon me, e
ven though he would, he says. Because I didn't commit a federal crime.
Richard: (laughs] Just go on. I'm not going to comment.
Jeffrey: It's so horrible. This is just today, which has been part of the whole thing. If I want to
get a pardon, it has to be done by the governor of the state because I pled guilty to a state crime.
Richard: And we've been through this. He lost. So you have two weeks, right?
Jeffrey: Yes. So he called. He, Crist, called the prosecutor this morning.
Richard: Maria?
Jeffrey: No, Krisher. The actual guy at the state who filed the indictment. And said, "Can you tell
me, I have to think about this, because there'll be tremendous political heat if you I do this. Can
you tell me your summary of what Epstein did?" Oh, shit, right? Here's what came back.
He said, "I've been doing this for 26 years, I was a state prosecuting attorney. Epstein's behavior
was inappropriate but not criminal."
I said, "What?" What? He said, "Yeah, he just got fucked." This is what he said to the governor. The
governor called me - this is what he called me for. He said, "This is the guy, Jeffrey, who signed
off..."
Richard: He's the one who put you into solitary.
Jeffrey: Yes. He said, "This is inappropriate but not criminal." He said," But I don't know what we'
re going to be able to do."
I said, "You can't say that." I wanted him to say, "Actually, he's a scumbag. This is really bad. He
did a horrible thing." You can't tell me not it's...
Richard: No, there are layers here. Does this make is easier for Crist to make a decision?
Jeffrey: No.
Richard: It can't make it harder. It can't make it harder.
Jeffrey: It does to some extent. This is the conversation I had. He said, "No one is going to believ
e that you haven't gotten to this guy." He said, "They're going to figure out you paid him some mone
y."
Richard: The prosecutor said that?
Jeffrey: Crist said it.
Richard: Crist did.
Jeffrey: Yeah. He talked to somebody else. He said, "You can't have a prosecutor say what he did was
n't really criminal."
Richard: The prosecutor will never say that in public. Forget it.
Jeffrey: So you ask me whether it's easier or more difficult. (sighs]
Richard: So Crist is deciding?
Jeffrey: Yes. And I don't think he's going to go for it. The political heat is... He said, "I think
you'd have to wait." He said, "I'm leaving."
Richard: Wait for what?
Jeffrey: The next guy.
Richard: The new governor is not going to pardon you, because the new governor wants to be governor
again. You don't pardon. The notion that this is not going to enhance the probability that he's goin
g to be reelected.
Jeffrey: I can't think of any way around it.
Richard: No. You've got to really - well, you have. Crist is your ticket.
Jeffrey: That's not such an easy ticket now. He said it's just so hot.
Richard: He's making it hot. It's not hot. There were those foolish article's in - what was her name
? Tina Brown's thing. I mean, they dissipated. It's not hot. It's dead.
Jeffrey: He's going to call me in an hour.
Richard: Am I wrong?
Jeffrey: I don't' know.
Richard: It's dead. Don't let him keep believing it's hot
Jeffrey: I've said - no one's heard anything.
Richard: It's over. The only impact is on you.
Jeffrey: Well, he said, "If you do nothing, what's the big deal? Do you really want me to reopen the
whole thing?" [pounds table]
Richard: It's just a cover. What's your answer to that?
Jeffrey: I said I would talk to him later. I wanted to have a thoughtful response. My knee-jerk resp
onse was, "Don't pussy out on me. Just do it."
Richard: My gut reaction, given the way it has quieted -- much to my pleasure, and yours - is how me
aningful is a pardon to you?
Jessica: That's what I was wondering, in my ignorance of the whole situation, why a pardon now?
Jeffrey: It would get rid of my sex offender status.
Richard: Right.
Jeffrey: Even thought some of the women keep saying, "It's so exciting. I've never actually been wit
h a sex offender before."
Jessica: You can still tell women that if you need to. [laughs]
Richard: They're lying.
Jeffrey: They have been with a sex offender before? Do you think sex offender lingerie would sell? I
f I had a new line and it came out...
Richard: They're just being dishonest. Joe's great story about he takes this 20-year -old woman. ..
Jeffrey: Have you met Olgi?
Richard: Of course I've met Olgi.
Jeffrey: Because I just met her for the first time.
Richard: She's stayed at my house. So he takes this 20-year -old woman upstairs and she takes off her
dress and she's the most exquisite he's seen. And he takes off his clothes and there's his 66-year -
old frame. And in an inimitable fashion says, "Look at you, you're so beautiful. Look at me. When wa
s the last time you were with a 66-year -old?" She said, "An hour ago."
[laughter]
Jeffrey: That sums it up.
Richard: Yeah.
Jeffrey: Before you go. The work you're doing now is what?
Richard: Well, you know, are you just trying to get it on tape?
Jeffrey: No, in terms of getting for the next session.
Richard: We can talk about that if you want.
Jeffrey: Yeah.
Richard: It's basically I think that the brain - this relates to selection. That there are two basic
circuits in the brain. One that deals with the enactment of innate behavioral responses to the worl
d. And those, the cues that elicit those responses are cues that have existed over a long time and h
ave predictive value for the organism. And therefore the organism responds in an stereotyped and inn
ate way.
Jeffrey: So aversive smells.
Richard: Yes. And those pathways, those innate pathways, are developmentally programmed into your DN
A by virtue of selection - Darwinian selection over evolutionary time.
And then you have a much larger set of brain mechanisms that involve behaviors and thoughts that are
dependent on experience, and experience acts only over real time. And it is individual. It differs
given the circumstance.
And those neural circuits also need to be built or strengthened, and they are strengthened over real
time by mechanisms with at some level resemble the mechanisms which are used over evolutionary time
Jeffrey: So let me tell where
Richard: So in both instances you're selecting over randomness, and I think there's a random ensembl
e of neurons from which you select.
Jeffrey: So let me tell you where I want to overlay for this next session. I believe what you've des
cribed leaves out a piece. Which is because you talk about the "you" as an individual as opposed as
a member of a group again.
Because I thought a lot about the mice, the images. In fact if you assume that the aversive chemical
odor causes an aversive response, I would posture that the ensembles in each mouse would be differe
nt, totally different ensembles of excitatory patterns. But the response would be the same, virtuall
y the same, because what you would have is a single key encryption that every individual should take
that ensemble, de-encrypt it, and the output should be the same.
Richard: For an innate thing.
Jeffrey: Yes. But in fact that key, why should everyone have their own? Why should every mouse have
the exact same piece.
Richard: We can discuss that.
Jeffrey: Because if you go to back to the virus and cell issue, in the competition between the two m
ice, if I can read your pattern, you and I become vulnerable to me. So you have an encrypted system
to pass that - and I think there's probably some basis, whether on learning how to de-encrypt it.
And I think in the second piece of the real-time learning, it mirrors to some extent that fact that
these algorithms are set for the innate behavior.
Richard: You're getting complicated, and you're right. All you care about is that the input leads to
an innate output. And the processes in between...
Jeffrey: Who's the "you"?
Richard: All the organism cares about. ..
Jeffrey: No.
Richard: Sorry.
Jeffrey: I agree, but there's a piece missing, I believe. Which is, yes, that input leads to the out
put, with the additional caveat that it can't be seen from the outside. That's the piece. That's, I
think, the trick. You have encrypted that signal to protect yourself from your competition, your imm
ediate competition.
So that deceptive quality, deception - sorry.
Richard: You're right. We'll have to talk about this another time. There is deception. There's biolo
gical deception.
Jeffrey: Yes, but I'm talking about just on the signal itself. The signal cannot be broken from the
outside. So everyone's signal is different.
Richard: Yeah, but even if it were the same, there's not apparent way that you can break that signal
when it's all encoded in the brain.
Jeffrey: But then you can.
Richard: I don't know how you do it. I've got to go.
Jeffrey: OK.
Richard: I don't know how you do it.
Jeffrey: No.
Richard: Are you around? When am I going to hear about robots?
Jessica: Whenever you like. I have so many other questions I still want to ask you about. Is a virus
alive? I still have this whole smell thing to ask you. I'm addicted to smells.
Richard: Are you around or are you going off?
Jeffrey: I'm here till Saturday.
Richard: And then?
Jeffrey: I'm going to the islands.
Richard: For a week.
Jeffrey: Two.
Richard: I'm going to Egypt?
Jeffrey: You are?
Richard: Yeah.
Jeffrey: When?
Richard: After Christmas.
Jeffrey: Do you know which days? Leon is going.
Richard: Who?
Jeffrey: Leon is going right after Christmas.
Richard: I'll be on the 30th or the 31st.
Jeffrey: Something in particular?
Richard: I'm going to pick out a tomb.
Jeffrey: For you?
Richard: Yeah.
Jeffrey: Again.
Richard: My people built them, shouldn't they allow me access?
Jeffrey: So your mother was like King Tut?
Richard: When is he going?
Jeffrey: I'm going to find out.
Richard: We're both going to the same - I mean, there's only one hotel in Luxor. Like the Winter Pal
ace or the Summer Palace.
Jeffrey: Right. Send me the dates when you're going.
Richard: Yeah. Five days.
Jeffrey: With the wife?
Richard: Yeah.
Jessica: Thank you. It was very interesting.
Richard: You can catch me again. I exist. I haven't...
(background noise)
Jessica: It's hard to disagree with you, that doesn't mean you're right.
(background noise)
Jessica: Jeffrey, are you still recording? Here are my thoughts. You just walked out.
Well, that was an interesting conversation, and I think it is - my gut feeling is that it is very ha
rd to disagree with you, but I'm not sure it makes you necessarily right or wrong in some statements
. This seems strange to say, perhaps.
Because there are so many concepts on the table, and there seems to be this continuum of ideas that
are being exchanged, probably in your... (laughs) I was leaving a message.
Jeffrey: What?
Jessica: I was leaving you a message.
Jeffrey: Did you like it?
Jessica: Yeah. It was a lot of stuff going back and forth. And a lot of different concepts.
Jeffrey: Always is.
Woman 2: There's this one, the Concept Two. There's about a $500 price difference.
Jeffrey: It's not the money. Do you have anything smaller?
Woman 2: I called both Sports Authoritys, we can order them.
Jeffrey: Go to Sports Authority. Have you met Jessica?
Woman 2: Yes. In Boston.
(background noise)
Jeffrey: Thank you.
Woman 2: Bye now.
Jessica: You know how it blended? This is very challenging.
Jeffrey: You could have swallowed first and then jumped up and down.
Woman 3: Can I get you anything else?
Jessica: Maybe some warm water or something?
Jeffrey: Warm water?
Jessica: I'm chilly.
Jeffrey: You want some coffee? Tea? Tea is $10.
Woman 3: If you would like to try our new recipe iced coffee?
Jessica: Just something. Warm tea is fine. I'm a little cold. Thank you.
I brought these because I wanted to ask him a question too about smells.
(background noise)
Jeffrey: I can't believe you have so much fun (indecipherable 1:13:50] .
Woman 2: Is this the church one?
Jeffrey: No. Hotel Mandarin.
Woman 2: Where's that?
Jeffrey: The Mandarin Hotel at Columbus Circle.
Woman 2: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. I went this George one time and spent the weekend there. I think I we
nt in the pool too.
Jeffrey: So it's the health club and all the stuff and everybody's just super -nice to me.
Woman 2: Good.
Jessica: So you prefer that over the church?
Jeffrey: I was just there by myself. I can listen to music. I can do anything else. It's a church. ..
And it's cleaner. The church is a little dirty. Priests are dirty people.
Woman 2: Are there other ones that are a little...
Jeffrey: I'm trying to think.... Go back. Maybe it has to do with bench space. Because he doesn't ha
ve a lot of space.
Woman 2: There are just straight ones like these.
Jeffrey: Go back a page.
Woman 2: These are the different...
Jeffrey: No, that's the page we were on. Go back. Those are the ones.
Woman 2: This is?
Jeffrey: The dumbbells. Yeah. Go back again. Don't touch it.
Woman 2: OK. It's more upwards than...
Jeffrey: Yeah. Go back to rowing.
(whispering]
Jeffrey: What? Oh, he is? Do you know who he is?
(whispering; background noise)
Jeffrey: Get him this one.
Woman 2: That one?
Jeffrey: Mm-hmm.
Woman 2: OK. Here's how it looks with the...
Jeffrey: Just get it. You know Gartners, the history of it?
Jessica: Some of it. Some major parts of it.
Jeffrey: The Unabomber.
Jessica: (laughs) I heard - that's someone I was referring to in particular.
Jeffrey: Do you remember the Unabomber?
Woman 2: Yes.
Jeffrey: Who was sending out mail bombs and blowing people up. On of the guys who's hand blew up was
this guy.
Woman 2: Oh, really?
Jeffrey: Yeah, because Ted Kaczynski believed that technology was ruining the world. So he wanted to
kill people who were involved with technologies.
Woman 2: Oh, my god.
Jessica: And I think my old advisor was like one of the next people in line, and then they caught hi
m.
Jeffrey: Really.
Jessica: Yeah. And actually I think I saw him speak, and his wife would always come with him a lot o
f places for a while, something like that. He spoke at MIT.
Jeffrey: Right.
Woman 2: So can I have it delivered?
Jeffrey: Just find out what size the box is And take the Suburban.
Woman 2: They don't have any in stock.
Jeffrey: They don't have that one in stock?
Woman 2: Any. I called both Sports Authoritys, and they don't carry it.
Jeffrey: Is there more Sports Authoritys? There must be one in Long Island or New Jersey or someplac
e.
Woman 2: I can try.
Jeffrey: There's one around, I'm sure. Just have the car.
Woman 2: Got it.
Jeffrey: What have you got, Terri? You finished with your problem?
(child speaks off-mike)
Jeffrey: What?
(off -mike conversation)
Jeffrey: Good. Keep putting it in? It took all day?
Woman 2: To get it. It was in the city.
Jeffrey: Oh, right?
Woman 2: I can get it deliverd.
Jeffrey: Tell them - send people home. Send Larry home tonight, and then if he wants to install it o
n Saturday when it comes back.
Woman 2: OK.
(overlapping voices]
Jeffrey: I don't want him to stay home, because he had to stay in Santa Fe because the plane broke.
Bring Gertman, but tell Larry to go home. Aren't we having fun?
Jessica: Who's Olgi?
Jeffrey: What?
Jessica: Who's Olgi?
Jeffrey: A hooker. Yes. (whispers something] That's a pretty funny line. She just saw another 66-yea
r-old.
Jessica: So, yeah, that thing about why - what does the pardon get you?
Jeffrey: What?
Jessica: The pardon now. When you don't have the sex offender registry, so that means you don't show
up on those things.
Jeffrey: I don't show up anywhere. I just don't like to tell people. It's just one of those things.
Jessica: I feel like it's going to...
Jeffrey: How are you?
David: OK.
Jeffrey: Come on in. I'm glad you came. Jessica, David.
David: How are you doing?
Jessica: Hi.
David: Hi there.
Jessica: How are you?
David: Good times.
Jessica: Nice to meet you.
Jeffrey: Take a seat. You want some coffee, tea? What do you want?
David: I'm OK, thanks.
Jeffrey: The doctor's not here yet.
David: Nice place.
Jeffrey: It's OK. It'll do for today.
David: Got another one for tomorrow?
Jeffrey: Yes.
David: I imagine so. (laughs]
Jeffrey: Yes. That's the idea.
David: You're convenient to the Frick, I see. Not such a bad place to be. Nice tablecloth.
Jeffrey: Well, the question is, in case you want to go bowling.
David: Is that a problem?
Jeffrey: Because there's a bowling alley in the basement.
David: Don't you have one? Oh. I was going to guess.
Jeffrey: At the Frick.
David: Oh, at the Frick. You don't have your own?
Jeffrey: No. There's a bowling alley that Mr. Frick had,
d beautiful mahogany bowling balls, ebony bowling balls.
David: Mahogany bowling balls. Oh, my god.
Jeffrey: And little black boys to set the pins, I'm afraid.
David: Well, you know, that was the style. I've been there
bowling alley.
Jeffrey: Correct. No one has. My two great secrets are the
y office has been at 51st and Madison Avenue for 18 years,
o did I find out that there's a swimming poop a block away
David: From 51 and Madison.
Jeffrey: Yes. It's on 51st and Park. You say, well, where's that? What's 51st and Park?
David: I give up.
Jeffrey: St. Bartholomew's Church.
David: Ah-ha.
Jeffrey: That's what I said.
David: They don't have a swimming pool.
Jeffrey: They have a gigantic swimming pool. It's salt water. Two stories. In the basement of the ch
urch.
David: I knew it was a fancy church.
Jeffrey: Correct. So I think somehow you baptize the little boys in the salt water and you take them
upstairs.
David: Yeah. A really big baptismal font, I see.
Jeffrey: Yes, you could do it as a group.
David: Sure.
Jeffrey: You could do a whole troop of Boy Scouts all at once, I think, is the idea.
David: It's a nice church. I've passed that church a million times and admired it. I don't think I'v
e ever been in there. But I would have suspected a two-story, salt water swimming pool.
Jeffrey: Yeah, it's beautiful.
David: So you know the city pretty well.
Jeffrey: No, I don't, but I'm trying to - I'm experimenting. Actually I know the world much better t
han I know New York.
David: It's an interesting position to be in.
Jeffrey: I've decided that with my jail experience, I should think about different types of micro -en
vironments.
David: Fair enough. What cities do you prefer to New York?
Jeffrey: The question is...
David: Lots and lots of cities?
Jeffrey: No, no, no. It depends on what day
. I am driven by aesthetic pleasure.
David: That's the way to do it. That's the way to do science and the way to do art. The way to do ev
erything. It's the way to write.
Jeffrey: But if you look at, it's like the book... I think if the defining - not the defining. I thi
nk if the compass is pointing towards elegance and beauty, you're probably moving in the right direc
tion.
David: Yeah. That's like a sentence I wrote at the beginning of a book called "Machine Beauty.• I co
uld not agree with you more. It's something that Fineman says again and again in his famous intro ph
that very few people know about. That he ha
a million times. I never heard about the
bowling alley at the Frick, and, David, m
at the Helmsley Palace, only two weeks ag
from me that I could use.
and what mood, what food and which girl. I am consistent
ysics textbook. You are guided by beauty in the sense of the physical world. If you don't get where
you're going, you'll still be moving in the right direction.
Which distinguishes good work in software and engineering, or course, from...
Jeffrey: Come on in, Max.
Max: Nice to see you. Haven't seen you in ages.
David: Yes, it's been a long time. It's good to see you, Max.
Jeffrey: Jessica.
Jessica: Hey, Max. I know you.
Max: Yeah. How's it going.
Jeffrey: I take it from your cheeks it's fairly cold out?
Max: Yeah, it's pretty...
Jessica: It's ridiculous out.
Max: It's impossible out there. Surprisingly.
Jeffrey: So can you then - can computers pick out beautiful things? They should be able to.
David: Computers cannot pick out beautiful things at the moment. But... Software will never create c
onsciousness, awareness, per se.
EFTA00728783 (Jmail)
 [misc] list of names and phone numbers
PEOPLE LIST
Cell # (unless otherwise stated) and Personal Email (unless otherwise stated)
George Mitchell: Julia Reed assistant: ianice
Neal assistant: Maller Bitar:
Jimmy Cayne:
Noah Tepperberg
Vera Wang: VW office
Avi
Faith Kates:
Suzette assistant
; Dawn West assistant
Tommy Mottola:
Verw (I think this isa repeat of Vera Wang with a typo)
Bark
Jennie Saunders:
Olya:
John Brockman:
Barbro Ehnbom:
Jess Banks:

Dr. Richard Axel:
Columbia
Guiseppi Cipriani:
Barry Jospehson:
Ramsey Elkholy:
Regina
Leon Black:
Henry Rosovsky:
Lawrence Krauss:
Andrew Farkas:
Joe Pagano:
JP Molyneux:
Ace Greenberg: Office
Peggy Siegel:
Lily Sanchez:
Marty Weinberg:
Alan Dershowitz:
Bill Riley:
Steve Kosslyn:
Wilson
Glasses-trapp
Martin Nowak:
Harvard
Vanessa Modely:
loin Barrack:
Kasia assistan
Lana
Daniel from Paris:
Dasha Grupman:
Valdson Cotrin:
e
Dick Merkin: Office
Doug Schoettle:
Kevin Law:
Marvin Minsky:
Eduardo Teodorani:
Al
Bill Richardson:■
Tina Brown: Office
Boris Nikolic:
Melz
Janis Assistant:
Lena Assistan
Mark ZetT:
Reid Weingarten:
Jean Luc Brunel:
Nicole Jumkermann:
Teddy Forstman:
Jason
Marshall Rose:
Schertzman
Glenn Dubin:
tudor
Jane Assistant:
Jes Staley:
Terje Roed Larsen:
Richard Johnson: Office
Warwick Wicksman:
Naomi Campbell:
Tom Pritzker:
Mottola:
Michael Ovitz:
Nathan:
Peter Mandelson:
David Mitchell:
Jeff Matusow: Office
Barnaby Marsh:
George Church:
Roger Schank:
Charles Harper:
Set
Val Kilmer: Office
Harvey Weinstein:
Len Blavatnik:
Eva Dubin:
Koch
Sultan
David Tang
Michael Milken:
Larry Summers:
Jay Lefkowit2:
Frederic Feldcai:
Victoria Stodden:
Duke of York:
Adam Bly
Pablos Holman
Galertner
EFTA00728864 (Jmail)
 [misc] security orders for 358 El Brillo Way showing Igor Zinoviev had door power
Post orders for 358 el brillo way

Officer shall remain at the property unless instructed by Mr. Epstein.

2. there will be a list of approved people, who must show photo i.d.

3. no one is to be admitted without direct consent of mr. Epstein or Mr Zinoviev

4. the officer will travel with mr. Epstein, as per his directions.
A cell phone number will be provided to contact mr Epstein staff and or security

6. the officer must provide at least two contact numbers per shift his cell and a main
number

7. rounds of the outside must be done , on a 30 minute basis , from 10 p. m. until
7am including the dock area.

8. a vehicle will be provided

9. a log belonging to the attorneys for Epstein will be used for sign in of all people
that enter the property„ no exceptions„ handymaen, gardners, fed ex , no exceptions

10. mr jack Goldberger will be the first call of contact his numbers are 561 346
8973, or 561 659 8300..

11.
╔═════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Lisa Randall [harvard] theoretical physicist 
           Nathan Wolfe [academia] virologist 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA00729992 (Jmail)
 [academia] "Science" contact list
Science

1. Ed Wilson
2. Martin novak , corrina
3. Roger shank
4. Seth Lloyd
5. Marvin minsky
6. Hauser
7. Kosslyn

8. Richard axel
9. Victoria stodden
10. Boris nikolic
11. Lisa randall
12. Caippo
13. Staone
14. Melz
15. Galernter

16. Demasio
17. Krauss
18. Smolin
19. Martin
20. Murray
21. West
22. Edelman
23. trivers
24. hill
25. s
26. Barnaby

27. Nathan wolfe
28. Harper
29. Tramo
30. Churc
31. Randall
32. Pablos
33. Dubno
34. Wilson
John deitch, john hammersay, norm Augustine, maha david, george heilman. Samir
bramashira„ Henrietta fore. John rogers. Adam and Joel cohen , jim simon ibm ,1,/
Samir Brahmashari
George Heilmeyer

35. SCIENCE FINDER harper barnably, stone, al,
greene„stodden,axel,Melanie boris
36. fances Arnold seckel, cristph koch, george whiteside.
EFTA00804855 (Jmail)
 [academia] Human Germline Genetic Modification References
Key references for human germline genetic editing
Narrative outline of our project: Human Germline Genetic Modification
Reviews
Nucleic acids delivery methods for genome editing in zygotes and embryos Recent (2016)
review of the methods available - see Table 1 and Figure 1 for an overview of methods. Limited
consideration of CRISPR and/or sperm selection to enhance efficiency. Refs 67-74 in that paper
are also relevant for our project.
In vivo Gene Transfer into Testis and Sperm: Developments and Future Application
Another good review, it references e.g. In vivo transfection of testicular germ cells and
testis-mediated gene transfer which succeeded in generating transgenic sperm.
Gene transfer to sperm and testis also does not consider the impact of CRISPR or cell sorting
and only deems methods viable if the mice can produce transgenic progeny from natural mating
(no IVF), but is otherwise a good review.
Cell Sorting
Single Cell Isolation and Analysis Summary of cell sorting techniques
(FACS/MACS/microfluidics), specific example here: A method for high purity sorting of rare cell
subsets applied to TDC. Allows us to extract transgenic sperm even if they are a tiny fraction of
the total. Sperm selection using magnetic activated cell sortinq has been investigated as well.
CRISPR
Efficient precise knockin with a double cut HDR donor after CRISPR/Cas9-mediated
double-stranded DNA cleavage Much-improved method for CRISPR-based gene knock-in,
another related technique is MMEJ-assisted gene knock-in. Both allow the insertion of
transgenes at specific locations in the genome.
Base Editing
Correction of the Marfan Syndrome Pathogenic FBN1 Mutation by Base Editing in Human Cells
and Heterozygous Embryos Base editing in human embryos; has limited utility for now but it's a
good option for single point mutations.
Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD)
1
Technical Update: Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis and Screening Recent review of PGD
technology, used in our case to confirm transgene integration in the embryo.
Graphical overview of main approaches, from literature (1st reference above, Figure 1)
Note: Our approach is testis-mediated gene transfer (transfection of sperm stem cells).
Additional techniques can be explored but our focus is on testis-mediated:
I( 'Sl-M "1r
r!al
vas
deference
lia cauda
efiditt‘
r le vivo
deliver, to
mark:,
[Mated Female
Llsolate Fertilized Eggs/Embryos)
KO/hl TG
Viral vectors
Receptor
mediated
uptake,
ILtransrectio
ilipasomalj
Gene-manipulated Fertilized Eggs
ES cells injection
into blastoeysts " Wronurlear injection 1
transfer to recipient fount
'0 4  0
c
%
Genotspe offsprin ta  1
et . -) 4fr 1 ti --on-depende le ,
t 4°16 fern  IA 914i4 11% "°n-independ e t c"
tk e
hi vitro
leetroporation
"ably° handing
Key: TG = transgenic, ICSI-MGT = intracytoplasmic sperm injection-mediated gene transfer, ST
= seminiferous tubules, TMGT = testis-mediated gene transfer, KO/Kl = knock-out/knock-in, ES
= embryonic stem (cells]
2
Future Directions: In vitro gametogenesis
Generation of human oogonia from induced pluripotent stem cells in vitro for egg cells.
Robust in vitro induction of human germ cell fate from pluripotent stem cells for sperm.
In both cases, deriving germ cells from induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) allows us to make
far larger modifications to the genome since the iPSCs can be grown and expanded in a dish.
After modifications are added and the genome is sequenced, they can be differentiated into
germ stem cells and transplanted into their respective tissues.
Primary risks are pre-existing genomic damage in the iPSCs (can be mitigated with sequencing)
and aberrant differentiation once in the body (will require non-human research to assess).
Transplanting into the body, rather than in vitro culture, is likely to allow more natural
differentiation into germ-cell-producing cells, but is not being actively researched due to
potential risks involved.
Human cloning
Cloning Mice and Men: Prohibiting the Use of iPS Cells for Human Reproductive Cloning Paper
calling for tetraploid complementation to be banned in humans, because it can be used for
cloning, e.g. iPS cells produce viable mice through tetraploid complementation. This is a method
we are interested in using.
A highly efficient method for generation of therapeutic quality human pluripotent stem cells by
using naive induced pluripotent stem cells nucleus for nuclear transfer Theoretical approach
using iPSCs for nuclear transfer, sadly not researched further since there's no true "medical"
need to do it. But we will try it out.
Cloning of Macaque Monkeys by Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer Monkey cloning using SCNT,
however they had to use fetal cells for the nuclear donor.
Human Embryonic Stem Cells Derived by Somatic Cell Nuclear Transfer SCNT with human
cells, again needing fetal tissue for the donor.
In vitro gametogenesis (progress towards)
Efficient generation of functional haploid spermatids from human germline stem cells by
three-dimensional-induced system
Metaphase II oocytes from human unilaminar follicles grown in a multi-step culture system
3
Primary research questions

1) Is it possible to reduce potential toxicity of testis-mediated gene transfer, while
maintaining efficiency?

2) Can a small quantity of transformed sperm cells be sorted out of millions of cells?
3) Is it more practical to target sperm stem cells in the testis, or better to invest in R&D on
in vitro spermatogenesis or in vitro oocyte genesis (which has not yet been achieved for
human)?
4
EFTA01086449 (Jmail)
 [girls] letter from Ariane de Rothschild to INS recommending "genius" visa for Svetlana Pozhidaeva
[Please insert on your letterhead]

[Please insert the date here]

US DHS CIS
Vermont Service Center
30 Houghton Street
St. Albans, VT 05478
Re: Ms. Visa Application

Dear Sir or Madam:

I am writing this letter on behalf of Ms. <REDACTED>
a communications and public relations
pro essional of extraordinary ability.

My name is Ariane de Rothschild and I am president
of the executive commiteeof the Edmond de Rothschild
Holding SA. I also lead the Edmond de Rothschild
Foundations, dedicated to arts and culture, health and
research, environment, social entrepreneurship and
intercultural dialogue.

I chair the Ariane de Rothschild Foundation, which
sponsors the annual Ariane de Rothschild Art Prize, a
contemporary art prize. The Ariane de Rothschild Fellows
Program, in partnership with Columbia Business School,
University of Cambridge and ESSEC, aims to develop a
network of social entrepreneurs with an interest in
fostering a culture of mutual respect and dialogue among
Jewish and Muslim communities.

Edmond de Rothschild Foundations hosts a very
important and very selective seminar for future
philanthropists. Our Next Generation seminar is a unique
event that brings together a small number of young and
select participants from around the world. Hosted by
Edmond de Rothschild, it takes place at an exclusive
Rothschild family setting.

The aim of the seminar is to raise participants'
awareness regarding the challenges and opportunities
related to generational change. Key issues such as family
governance, asset diversification, entrepreneurship and
philanthropy are addressed by our Group's experts and
renowned global leaders.

Participants have the opportunity to learn, share
and brainstorm with their peers. In this privileged and
protected environment, they naturally make new friends
and network with potential business partners.
This year, our very selective seminar invitees
included Ms. <REDACTED>. Ms. <REDACTED> came to
our seminar <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED> and I am
confident that she left the seminar with many more
skills. I am familiar with the high quality of work she
did <REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>.
And I know that the Economic Forum is relying on her
outstanding abilities for this year's organization as
well. I believe our Seminar made Ms. <REDACTED> more
efficient and influential and I will watch her career
closely.

The world needs more philanthropy and fundraising
participants like Ms. <REDACTED>. Therefore, I support
her professional visa application to the United States
and I endorse her fully.
Sincerely yours,
Ariane de Rothschild
[Please insert your appropriate
title here]
EFTA01110729 (Jmail)
 [money] letter to Les Wexner see quote: 'You and I had " gang stuff " for over 15 years'
Les,
I am truly sorry to hear that you have been the target of an extortion attempt by
the same girl that has tried to extort Ehud Barak , Alan dershowitz and prince
Andrew. I guess that she is either using bottom feeder , or she is being used by
them.
I am certain that John Zeiger has transmitted my suggestion that you and I sit down
together. I was tol that that family had no interest in a meeting. As I did not ask
for meeting with family, I find that answer unsatisfactory.
I have never once, not once, done anything , but protect your interests. I owe a great
debt to you , as frankly you owe to me. I was not surprised by your reticence to sit
with me when my bad judgement with women became a cause celebre. As Im sure
you recall, you didn't sit with your mother or sister or sharon , when a conflict
arose. as I did it for you. you didn't sit with Jack Kessler , Stanley or stanleys son. I
did it for you. I never asked to see you , I never sent you a request Abigail and I
sat, she asked many questions. She made many unfair, aggressive and false
accusations. None of which could have been fully answered without violating a
confidence with you. Many of which I did not answer. Some that I did. You and I
had " gang stuff " for over 15 years. A great deal of it, that she was unaware of. I
had no intention of divulging any confidence of ours , no matter what accusations
she made. And she made quite a few. As Im sure she told you , I didn't argue with
her , threaten her, or you, or in any way did not behave as I had always. Putting
your interests first I always told you I would never under any circumstances give it
up, or put you in harms way , no matter who , what or when. I would guess that if
things have not changed much as I know you well that you will find a need to show
this letter to Abigail. If so. I would ask that you not raise your shoulders purse
your lips and tell her I have no idea what he means. Is Jeffrey asking for something,
" there must be more to it" we don't know what we don't know.
EFTA01143800 (Jmail)
 [girls] letter to INS recommending "genius" visa for Svetlana Pozhidaeva
[Please insert on your letterhead]
[Please insert the date here]
US DHS CIS
Vermont Service Center
Re: Ms. 0-1 Visa Application
Dear Sir or Madam:
I am writing this letter on behalf of
a communications and public relations
professional of extraordinary ability.
My name is [please include a short bio and the info
on the organization here, name dropping if possible]
I had the distinct pleasure of working with Ms.
benefitting from her extraordinary abilities.
A my staff who have worked closely with Svetlana
appreciate her skills, command of languages and her
always warm and amicable personality.
[as a third paragraph, would be great to include a few
sentences about the Central Asia trip and activities, as
well as the upcoming Ebola conference]
Sincerely yours,
EFTA01248315 (Jmail)
 [government] list of persons of interest in the Epstein investigation with photos
UNCLASSIFIED//F0U0
No. Name DOB Source P
1 <REDACTED>
2 Leslie Groff x
3 <REDACTED>
4 <REDACTED>
5 Ghlslaine Maxwell x
6 Jean Luc Brunel x
7 <REDACTED>
8 <REDACTED>
9 <REDACTED>
10 Leslie Wexner x
11 Merwin Delacruz x
12 Peter Osterman x
13 Daniel Siad (RED)
14 <REDACTED>
15 Juan Alessi x
16 Maria Alessi x
17 Natividad Ruperez (RED)
18 Richard Barnett x
19 <REDACTED>
20 Rinaldo Rizzo x
21 David Richard Mullen (RED)
22 David Rodgers x
23 Larry Visoski x
24 Shullak, Karyna x
25 <REDACTED>
26 <REDACTED>
27 <REDACTED>
28 <REDACTED>
29 <REDACTED>
30 <REDACTED>
31 <REDACTED>
32 <REDACTED>
33 <REDACTED>
UNCLASSIFIED//F0U0
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 1 of 88
34 <REDACTED>
3S <REDACTED>
36 <REDACTED>
37 <REDACTED>
38 <REDACTED>
39 <REDACTED>
40 <REDACTED>
41 <REDACTED>
42 <REDACTED>
43 <REDACTED>
44 <REDACTED>
45 <REDACTED>
46 <REDACTED>
47 <REDACTED>
48 <REDACTED>
49 <REDACTED>
50 <REDACTED>
51 <REDACTED>
52 <REDACTED>
53 <REDACTED>
54 <REDACTED>
SS <REDACTED>
56 <REDACTED>
57 <REDACTED>
58 <REDACTED>
59 <REDACTED>
60 <REDACTED>
61 <REDACTED>
62 <REDACTED>
63 <REDACTED>
64 <REDACTED>
65 <REDACTED>
66 <REDACTED>
67 <REDACTED>
68 <REDACTED>
69 <REDACTED>
70 <REDACTED>
71 <REDACTED>
72 <REDACTED>
73 <REDACTED>
74 <REDACTED>
75 <REDACTED>
76 <REDACTED>
77 <REDACTED>
78 <REDACTED>
79 <REDACTED>
80 <REDACTED>
81 <REDACTED>
82 <REDACTED>
83 <REDACTED>
84 <REDACTED>
85 <REDACTED>
86 <REDACTED>
87 <REDACTED>
88 <REDACTED>
89 <REDACTED>
90 <REDACTED>
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 3 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 4 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 5 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 6 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 7 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
S
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 8 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 9 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 10 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 11 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 12 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 13 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 14 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 15 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 16 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 17 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 18 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 19 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 20 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 21 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 22 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 23 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 24 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 25 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 26 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 27 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 28 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 29 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 30 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 31 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 32 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 33 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 34 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 35 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 36 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 37 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 38 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 39 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 40 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 41 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 42 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL I 3501.191-006
Page 43 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 44 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 45 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 46 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 47 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 48 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 49 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 50 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 51 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 52 of 88
SO
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 53 of 88
Si
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 54 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 55 of 88
S3
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 56 of 88
S4
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 57 of 88
SS
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 58 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
S6
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 59 of 88
S7
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 60 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
S8
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 61 of 88
s9
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 62 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 63 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 64 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 65 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 66 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 67 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 68 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 69 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 70 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 71 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 72 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 73 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 74 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 75 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 76 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 77 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 78 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 79 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 80 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 81 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 82 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 83 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 84 of 88
UNCLASSIFIED//F000
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 85 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 86 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 87 of 88
CONFIDENTIAL 3501.191-006
Page 88 of 88
EFTA01282282 (Jmail)
 [money] Butterfly Trust almost completely redacted list of beneficiaries
Butterfly Trust
List of Beneficiaries

<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED>66th          30<REDACTED><REDACTED>      <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>

<REDACTED>daeva         Louella Rabuyo              <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        License ID

<REDACTED><REDACTED>    Darren Indyke               Karyna Shuliak
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>

Richard Kahn            <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED>    <REDACTED><REDACTED>        <REDACTED><REDACTED>

CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000509

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000510

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. ORIM. P. 6(e) OB-SONT-.0511
EFT,001.296

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000512

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000513

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000514

<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>
<REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED><REDACTED>

CONFIDENTIAL CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000515

NEW YORK STATEDRIVER L I CENSE
C.D
SHULIAK
KARYNA
301 E 66TH ST APT 8H
NEW YORK. NY 10065
Sex F
1)08
Fxpr
F NONE
H NONE
St

CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0000517
r.nmpinpm-rhai CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R GRIM. P. 60) OB-SONT-0000618
EFTA01340296 (Jmail)
GREETINGS
From the Bjorlin's
╔══════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 UAB Fors Projektai [europe] Valdas Petreikis organization 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01365119 (Jmail)
J. Epstein Virgin Islands Foundation Inc.
MEMORANDUM

To:               Vahe
From:             Darren Indyke
Value Date:       January 20, 2017
Debit Account # : N4G024950
************************************************************************

Please wire Seventy Five Thousand Euros ($ 75,000) from the above account to:
Receiving SWIFT: CBVILT2X
Receiving Bank Name: SEB Bank
VILNUS, LITHUANIA

Beneficiary account #: <REDACTED>
Beneficiary Name: UAB Fors Projektai
Vilnius, Lithuania

Please call Bella Klein if you have any question.
Ref. No
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0055765
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00201949
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Lasma Kuhtarska [russian girl] Latvian co-founder of Dubai based fintech company Noda [medium] 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA01366011 (Jmail)
 [money] Darren Indyke memo about $3,000 expense reimbursement for Lasma Kuhtarska
JEFFREY E. EPSTEIN
MEMORANDUM

To: Marjorie
From: Darren K Indyke
Value Date: April 10, 2017
Debit Account # : <REDACTED>

**********************************************************************

Please wire Three Thousand Euros (EUR3,000) from the above account to:

Receiving SWIFT: <REDACTED>
Receiving Bank Name: AS"SEB Banka
Address: Valnu iela 11, Riga, LV-1050, Latvia
Receiving IBAN #:
Beneficiary account #:
Beneficiary Name: Lasma Kuhtarsk

Reference: expense reimbursement
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0057510
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY_GM_00203694
EFTA01387770 (Jmail)
Deutsche Bank
Private Wealth Management
Authorization for Asset Movement
For Non-Retirement Accounts The uzadloared hotabYeOthOteMS and threat  nti*Ste  Blink Albl. &Own (tentscht Bank Alm 
Brown- a 0BAS") to follow the neiow Mel
moverrert intstrecioder
If you vadi to request multiple wires corks. Sweets or fee adheres. pleam use me tong fan.
AgAcCOurn Name Southern Trust Company Inc
Account t
VIIte
fa Inn federal Ivan in rho amount of S 2 500,000
To Sank Name Silicon Valley Bank
City! S'ale
ABA e 121140399
Further credit to Intermediary Financial Institution (Optional)
Account a.
Kerb
urines eaWry Seat
eghtlA, VIVI‘ln YAW  Global Fund Ill LP
Ponca r  3301520427
Aftkish-chwera k:pithmanatQpnitaRi tt,Ic
Capital Call
aback
❑ in;10 a check in Pot *mourn a s MOO es
Peoperitt Hews
Reopenehlailrig Address
Journal
CI Journal Funds In the amount of t
la Journal Holdings.
0lyaymboraocunty
owisonbasecurity
Ll Jaunty AN Holdings
To OMB Account a.
Account Nemec
Free Delwin
ID Please deliver the unarm indented teen tor
DTCCa'
Name of Reaming Fent
Account Name  -
Account Nurneer.
OtylSymbordecunty.
Otyttyrnberanutity:
at Receiving Fun
Slanting Authericelec
Q The utorierStaeO hereby requests that ENS autheAV31.0e act 03 a standing authouraten The urderegnad understand* and 
agrees that this mho/eat/on will
remain in enact until Deutsch, Bent Ales Brown requests a new au:non:anon The undersigned auterveas Deutsche Bank Alex. 
Brown to issue me wire.
check or journal on the  dkya  lot a term of
lj filo underspred bother euthenics Deutsche Bank Al ea Blotto to accept vector instructions born the undersogned to 
vire runes, issue checks tc 'currier
funds Belton the above tend accounts The undersigned wA FONide verbal rota when, os to the dale and the amount of the 
wilt check or joioriaz If the
undersigned decrees to vary other the date oe the amount of the wiz*, check a 101,01141. the unaerr.gred Weill 
authorises Newts Bank Alex fr OWII to
sant the verbal insentons from the rthelaboned regarding the change or charges. The undersigned further undeatarOS and 
agrees to corn* with the
Weaken a Deutsche Soak Alex. Brown to verify the ludledatian and accuracy of verbal 913MIC6003
To undorsianocl hereby acknowledges that ti) the informabon contained in this teem R complete and accurate to the best 
knowledge of the meters/owe and hi) the
under seined is responsible for the method of Uhr,STISt0,161 any lAttlUttiOet issued pursuant to tin authoreation. If 
the undersigned elects to transmit any
such
instructions we fax (eiduchng desktop lax). va email a as an image attachment to email reg.. n a PDF. TIF e. other image
of such instructions). the unstersignoc
endemic/4s and berm that the aidenzgned beers the FOX a loss arising from such method of transnnsicc in the event of 
transmission amts, misundestendings.
innersonetiors. transmission by unauthorized parsons. forgery or intercepts. For trusts or other entrees. the 
undersigned further acknowreelges that the
undersigned 83
authorised to issue the above 05301 movement instructions under the tarns of the goner sng documents and any applicable 
rent The undersigned hereby relearn and
holds hornless Deutsche Bank Alex. Brown from and against loss ban any action. claim or demand ef any person as a mull 
of Deutsche Bank Mex. Brown's recital of
a compliance olth rids autliorizatiOn anctror any instructions that may be given to Deutsche Bank Aka Brawn pursuant to 
this authorization Including any
standing
authonzation)
The undersigned understands that COUttalt Sank Alex Brown mat out et not required to, seek yentiomon of the 
undersigned's inductions by cad beck end mat
Deutsche Bea Alex Brown may in its sat dettetiOn reuse to execute such ma:ructions iinelvding standing mstructions) 
given pursuant to this euthariatenn without
incurring area feedix if Deutsche Bonk Alec Brown has reason by haw* such instructions lor standing instractleost have 
not been provided by the undessaned The
undersigned nether understands that Dent k Alex. Blown retains the right to refuse to execute any instrustans to 
transfer funds or securities to am account/el
sum to this ainhcenaten vei beefing telpher sgnaturels) or the undersigned.
l
Darren Indyke 0444-2017
orate Fin: - Date
Bigneture PWRarne "Per
LOA
10.FWM-0177t Il2(1g)
CONFIDENTIAL - PURSUANT TO FED. R. CRIM. P. 6(e) DB-SDNY-0090917
CONFIDENTIAL SDNY GM_00237101
EFTA01480663 (Jmail)
Confidential Due Diligence Report
Shaffer, Tha E

• SSN:
• DOB: Age 51)
Shears, Richard C
SSN
• DOB
Shears, Therese J
(Age 55)
Falco, Charlene M M
SSN:
• DOB: (Age 47)
Third Degree Relatives
Falco, Joseph A
•

• SSN:
• DOB:
• ADeceased
Shaffer, Brian Stev
•
•
(Age 55)
Indyke, Bernard W
SSN
DOB (Age 79)Deceased
Second Degree Relatives
Confidential - This report is not to be disseminated or photocopied to any third party without the
express consent of Global Security .SZ Investigations.
7864595138 19
Confidential Treatment Requested by
JPMorgan Chase
CONFIDENTIAL
JPM-SDNY-00002875
EFTA01583819 (Jmail)
 [money] Epstein had control of James Cayne's assets
Relationship List
Party Name: E EPSTEIN 1405152
Party PCN: 1435152
Mkt Vahrel
C 0 U 0 FOUNDATION INC 5356614 (THE C 0 U 0 FOUNDATION INC 0122516406)
Owed 014552003 ASSET THE C 0 U 0. FOUNDATION, WC
00090150!9)1566 DOA THE C 0 u 0 FOLNOATION INC 114.291 20
SPNICAS Markel Value '14266 20
E THE JAMES E CAYNE TRUST NO S UAD 12/275D4 JEFFREY EPSTEIN TRUSTEE 7777914 (THE JAMES E
C.AYNE TRUST NO S UA012r27,04 JEFFREY EPSTEN TRUSTEE 0220495944)
Purged 0:0000rJ9501071 ODA JNJES E CAYN TRU
E ..TRUST 100 1636995 (TRUST I Oa 9702671903)
000
000
SPNCAS Market Value 0 00
MO000000115001 DOA TRUST t03 C 33
SPNCAS Market Value 0 CO
E ZORRO TRUST 1612332 (ZORRO TRUST 97020630e)
0000030:D14024 004 EOM'S TRUST 7.95571
SPWCAS Market Value 7.955 71
PCN Markel. Value
I
V
1
0
lae
G
nad ruj
157,807,170 75
Goremted April T 2009. 10 11 14 AM (EDT) Page 5 015
Confidential Treatment Requested by JPMorgan Chase JPM-SDNY-00063540
EFTA01611042 (Jmail)
 [crypto] iMessage from Ed Boyle to (unknown), Maria Prusakova screenshot(s)
Bill T-Mobile LTE 2:16 PM
Ed Boyle
introduction
To:
3 Messages
group
& 3 more...
& Masha,
9(• ).
2:03 PM C)
Details
By way of cc, I introduce you to
Prince Lorenzo de' Medici, my
business partner/co-founder. I am
using both personal and work
emails as we have just setup the
work email and, since Lorenzo is
traveling, IDK if he has that working
fully yet. Please make the
introduction to Jeffrey.
Also, you may recall Jeffrey and I
arguing over FX rates on cross-
border payments...where big-
money movements would be low
cost but typical small business
EFTA01611898 (Jmail)
 [misc] screenshot of recent contacts in an iPhone
9:12 i
All
Recents
Sneaky Dog
Sneaky Dog (2)
Sneaky Dog (2)
mobile
,
Missed
+1 (646) 358-4718
New York, NY
New York, NY
Karyna (2)
mobile
Karyna
mobile
Rihanna
mobile
Albany, GA
(3)
New York NY
9:09 PM
3:18 PM
1:53 PM
Yesterday
Yesterday
Thursday
Wednesday
Tuesday
Tuesday
Monday
* 0 31 ••• ••• ••• Favorites Recents Contacts Keypad Voicemail
o
o
lo
o
lo
ci
o
lo
lo
0
QD
EFTA01628970 (Jmail)
 [misc] redacted pictures of naked women
redacted pictures of naked women
EFTA01689016 (Jmail)
 [article] article about Virginia Giuffre's former trafficker Ronald Eppinger and other Giuffre
(date: 2001-11-01)
, prince Andrew and girl, 17, who sex offender friend flew to Britain to meet him I Mail... Page 15 of 17
•
•
Is another matter. NO thanks.
- RJ, NW, 27/2/2011 16:12
Click to rate Rating 79
Report abuse
Andrew needs to be investigated and if found guilty of impropriety banished as Persona non Grata. He will lose his right
as
fourth in line to the throne and all the benefits that come with that, including his extravagant and worthless lifestyle
being
funded by public money.
-Julia Larsen. London UK, 27/2/2011 16:09
Click to rate .. Rating 450
Report abuse
Why do we find the lives of these people? REPUBLIC NOW!
- Newell Fisher, Lancing West Sussex, 27/2/2011 15:42
Click to rate .. Rating 260
Report abuse
I was truly disgusted having read this article. Although sadly not surprised, I wonder why people idolize any kind of 
celebrity or
other such 'influential" people, most of whom seem to surround themselves with depraved "friends" & whom can turn a band
eye to anything where status, fame & wealth are concerned (seemingly typical of our •anything goes" society where 
everything
Is justifiable). That aside. I am more disgusted that out of the 24 comments on this article so far, people are either 
talking about
what a pretty piece of tot she is, how she should have basically kept her mouth shut, how we can't be judged by the 
actions of
our friends, whether the royal family has any validity (as if it ever had a clean past), & most astonishingly arguments 
about
whether Fergie has more right to a royal wedding invite than Andrew! Absolutely disgusting, looking forward to further
comments on her weight, whether she looks good for her age, & scrutiny over whether she's had any work done soon.
- Fiona, Stop the world I wanna get off, 27/2/2011 14:55
Click to rate.. Rating 356
Report abuse
The views expressed In the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily ref ect the views of MailOnline.
Today's headlines
Most Read

• They've lost control': French claim Japan is hiding full scale of nuclear disaster
• Pictured necking shots. the teen footballer who 'died after downing two pints of neat vodka

• Mothers fury over 'no reviver policy after seeing 22-week-old son die despite 46min battle to live
• 120 suspected British paedophiles arrested after police smash biggest worldwide ring

• 60 police officers in 30-hour siege to round up two dangerous dogs
• Thug rapes 30-Year-old virgin on town centre pavement In full view of passing motorists

• Taxes must soar to raise extra £82bn a year. says Osborne
• Councils to give struggling first-time buyers 20% deposits on homes

• Youth unemployment highest since records began as total without lobs jumps to 2.53m
•
• Tchenguiz brothers win right to bring Et bn lawsuit against failed Icelandic bank

• One in three women retiring this year will be forced to survive on basic State pension
• Wootton Bassett to be given 'Rover prefix

• Dov who suffered severe brain damage after birth receives £7mMarried police officer howls in anguish as he's failed for having sex on the beat

• Two men shot dead after violence erupts in caravan park
• CIA agent charged with murder in Pakistan is freed after U.S. pays family 'blood money'

• Retreat to Benghazi: Gaddafi threatens to crush 'Mad Max' rebel any as it flees to last stronnhoirl
http://www.dailymail.coiuk/news/atticle-1361039/Prince-Andrew-girl- I 7-sex-offender-frie... 3/16/2011
, prince Andrew and girl, 17, who sex offender friend flew to Britain to meet him I Mail... Page 16 of 17
•
•

• Protester shot point blank in the head as five are killed in violent dashes in Bahrain
•
• Thomton's worker, 25, murdered in woodland

• One in three NHS workers would NOT recommend their own hospital for treatment
• Dabv girl who didn't breathe for 17 minutes escapes brain damage after doctors put her in a 'fridge' for three days

• Two policemen 'hashed drink-driver's Mitsubishi on joyride after pulling him over
• Absorbing chlorinated water while swimming is a 'cancer risk'

• Sex with 33 women in two months? 'That's too many. even for me; says Berlusconi
• Teacher who murdered husband and dentist lovers wife 20 years ago sentenced to minimum of 18 years in jail

• Nine-year-old girl being treated for cancer has mobile phone stolen from hospital room
• Splashdown: Shallow diver breaks world record with 36ft leap into paddling pool containing lust 12 inches of water

• MORE HEADLINES
• 'We're not afraid to die': Extraordinary courage of the Fukushima Fifty as they return to stricken power plant to 
fight
nuclear disaster

• Thug rapes 30-year-old virgin on town centre pavement in full view of passing motorists
• A very selfless British hero: This young teacher whose first thought when tsunami warning sounded was how he could
save terrified pupils

• VERY compact and bijou: At iust 7ft wide. one of Britain's tiniest homes goes on sale
• Don't give up! Japanese Emperor makes a rare TV appearance to urge his people on. But now they must face a new
torture, the snow

• Eighties reggae star Smile,/ Culture 'stabs himself to death' during police raid at his home
• RICHARD KAY: Cameron aide has Hazel Blears moment walking along Downing Street in her Louboutins

• 'I'm a love rat!' Cheating man parades around city wearing 'confession' sandwich board in bid to win his girlfriend 
back

• The million-pound mutt: Red Tibetan Mastiff becomes world's most expensive dog
• Married police officer howls in anguish as he's jailed for having sex on the beat

• Poes it really take 60 police officers (including a lion vet) 30 hours to round up two dangerous dogs?

• Pictured necking shots. the teen footballer who 'died after downing two pints of vodka'
• Thorntoris worker. 25. found murdered in woodland three days after vanishing on way home

• Afghan asylum seeker who lived in £1.2.million house faces jail over £30,000 benefit fraudEngland football star at centre of village uproar over plans to replace bungalow with sprawling six-bed mansion

• 'She's probably kicking herself: Self-confessed Mr Boring who won £17m on the lottery... and the former girlfriend
who's very, very pleased for him (honest!)

• Bloodbath at travellers' camp: Two men shot dead after 'feud' in caravan park
• 'I've had enough': The moment victim snaps and slams bully to the floor in wrestling move

• The daffodil police: Officers swoop on three little girls picking flowers in park
• £1.25bn in a year: How Treasury has milked drivers paving 5p a litre more VAT on petrol while prices soar

• Councils to give struggling first-time buyers 20% deposits on homes
• Two policemen 'crashed drink-driver's Mitsubishi on joyride after pulling him over

• OUENTiN LETTS: Midsomer madness and a case of political correctness that would be risible if It wasn't so sinister

• Prince Charles' golden girl to play harp at Royal Wedding
• 'Don't panic': Obama calls for calm as terrified Americans panic-buy anti-radiation drugs and Geiger counters over
nuclear fall-out fears

• MOST READ IN DETAIL
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1361039/Prince-Andrew-gir1-17-sex-offender-frie... 3/16/2011
Prince Andrew and girl, 17, who sex offender friend flew to Britain to meet him I Mail... Page 17 of 17 . • •
• •
ow to build muscle fast
hockin discovery for
relief
oint
research leads to a
im i le snorin solution
And this story at www.dailymail.co.ukinewsiarticle-1361039/Prince-Andrew-giri-17-sex-offender-friend-flew-Britain-meet-
hinhtml
Pub!ished by Associated Newspapers Ltd
Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group
GlamEnter:Lesion-tent
O Associated Newspapers Ltd
http://www.dailymail.comk/news/article-1361039/Prince-Andrew-girl-17-sex-offender-frie... 3/16/2011
i—cr—•--vW:ALaanr1• 3======.L" -_T_... 41V..._.._.-......---- •
WILTON 4/1 MORS
POLICE
DEPARTMENT
2020 Wilton Drive
Wilton Manors, Florida 33305
Telephone: (954) 390-2150
Fax: (954) 390-2169
FAX
***NOTICE OF CONFIDENTIALITY***
The documents accompanying this facsimile transmission contain Information from the Wilton
Manors Police Department which may be confidential and/or privileged. The information is
Intended for use by the Individual or entity named on this transmittal sheet. If you are not the
Intended recipient, be aware that disclosure of this transmission is prohibited. If you have
received this facsimile In error, please notify us by telephone immediately.
If you encounter problems receiving thistransmittal please contact the sender.
TO:
FIRM /AGENCY: CO
TELEir "c•
FAX:
DEPT: Wilton Manors
TELEPHONE: SS4-390-21S0
FAX: 954-390-2M
DATE: 3 NUMBER. OF PAGES INCLUDING COVER SHEET:
EJ URGENT O FOR YOUR REVIEW O REPLY ASAP
COMMENTS:
O PLEASE COMMENT
CU/
j
W 1,LA.) fr/ile_ LK ro
see rF /9-Ay 7-71- / ice w frit  S
0.) 0ieLet) Cie_ 0 it) qt cl /
YH5 DA Tr,
S:WIASTER FORMS DEPT FORMS \ Fax Covet- Blank - W MTD-018.0 De itcv. 10/r. P:11
3I C- vvitvr- iogDe,
AGENCY OM NUMRSR
PLO 0 6 0 9 0 0
NARRATIVE CONTINUATION
0I. OFFENSE JUVENILE
1 ARREST
AGENCY NAME
WILTON MANORS POLICE DEPT.
I. ORIGINAL
2. SUPPLEMENT
AGENCY RETORT N
99004421
ORIGINAL DATE REPORTED
06111999
CASE RI:TERENCE
ASSIST O3
Wilton Manors Police Department was called by the FBI reference to a report they had received about
an underage white female that might be reported missing out of Palm Beach, Florida. They had information
that the girl might be as young as . The address they had received was in the city of Wilton Manors,
Florida. The address given was
Other members of the Wilton Manors Police Department and myself went to the listed address and met
with the resident named in this report. stated that a friend of his "RON" had asked him to do him a
favor and give the female a place to live for awhile and he agreed, t ed that he thought the girl was about
18 or 19 years old. He knew her as laNFI). Detective' and went upstairs and made
contact with the juvenile. She was later identified as and was infect. years old.
The Detectives collected her personal belongings and escorted her to their unmarked police vehicle then
transported the juvenile to Wilton Manors Police Department for a statement of fact about her whereabouts.
I cleared the residence without any further action taken.
SUN:EMMA
RMAIRD PETTMADRICITS)
concep(s)Rtrownric u, raiment) uOi :WM
OPMCIIR REVIEW/IMO IDS (MUM TO ARPSWILI TO ASPOMBCD TD ay GTE
r
Prostitution Ring Leader Sentenced To 21 Months - Sun Sentinel Page 1 of 1

• •
Advancement
taw  ,Ct mlit
yea ace here Sur•Schnnd can /. Gateman, /. Czech Republic
Ace by Cove
f Iv to Czech Republic
UP to 70% off Business
Oats to Czech Republel
Cat 077439-1199
www.wrauess.ryasatm
Verb& Fraud Protection
Protect Tour Heftily men
Freud wet AlClear l0. Sign
up for Freel
www.:410ea10.ccm
aelellie_etahLuet.
Get the Scoop from
Treats Who Knew
Prague!
tewariscititivcorn
WashInaton DC Co11
I ridiculously huge coupon
a day. les Ike doing DC al
90% of.
mmtercoccaccenWestenen• tt
Car Rental Czech
BRIBIDD9
Urilmtod kites. No Hidden
Fees. Fut Insurance. Book
Yes Car Howl
CzechRemze: Poona—oCceRe
ntalscom
Find roe snot*. bboul

• Czech Rcputbc
• Prague
FEATuREO ARTICLES
Man Malls Srmeglro
Women For Pmemulion
fteev11 n 2001
Pace Minna meet In
PrOaltulen Rine
1.by 10.2031
Wend Or Proseleicn
Smote To The Screen
MWN 26. ter
i:irrizmrifir
Prostitution Ring Leader Sentenced To n Months
November 11.2001 I Staff Fecal
A man extradited from Germany has been sentenced lo 21 menthe In prison
and fined $6.000 for recruiting Czech women to a prostitution ring with
promises of modeing week.
Ronald Epping., had faced up 10 10 years after abrading guilty this month lo
charges of alien smuggling for prostitution, Interstate travel for prostitution and
money laundering.
Epping., worked with two Czech women to get tourist visas for the future
prostitutes end kept needy half 01 their earrings from operations in Mani. Nee L°
York. Texas and the Bahamas, prosecutors saki. Women were brought to the United Stales illegally from 1997 to 1999.
As part of his plea. Eppk.ger forfeited a boat and Smooth° used le MOMOM the call 4rt service.
Eppinger learned he was under investigation In June 1999 and moved from the United States lo the Czech capital of 
Prague.
He was arrested In Germany lest December while traveling from the Cad. Republic to Spain and was sent to the United
Slates in May.
Ads ay Ocoal• Advertisement - - _
If you like saving money
jr1; "i , r , ,17
r- rig
.. •
Cea-apawaleye
Two accorroiroes. Lucie Feuben end Teen Benesova. pleaded guilty earlier b den smuggling camplreey. They also
received pad of the prostitution Ices.
Ace by boosts
Czech republic
Czech Republic travel information user experiences, hints & lips
yerey.yisiteurope.conYczech-republiC
nets by themad I index by Date I Prwacy Pam I Terms cl S•Nvite
-gietmoti-
hup://articles.sun-sentinel.com/2001-11-11/news/0111100327_1_prostitution-ring-czech-r... 3/23/2011
Highlighted Document:

• •
Page 1 of 2
This document view has been recorded (explain). Collaboration is enabled Click here to
disable.
This document contains Bank Secrecy Act (BM) information. For more details regarding use of BSA
information and/or Its re-dissemination, see the warning statement at the bottom of this document, or go to
the following FBI Intranet link:
htto://home.lbinet.fbi/ccrsb/CID/FCS/FinCEN/Paaes/BSAreDisseminationGuidelines.asox.
31E -men- log o bc,-- 0/4,
7/1/2011 '
rie Highlighted Document:

• Page 2 of 2
BSA Warning: The enclosed information was collected and disseminated under provisions of the Bank
Secrecy Act (the BSA) and U.S. Department of the Treasury regulations Implementing the BSA. See 31
U.S.C. 5311, et seq.; 31 CFR Part 103. The Information is sensitive in nature and Is to be treated
accordingly. The Information may be used only for a purpose related to a criminal, tax, or regulatory
investigation or proceeding, or in the conduct of intelligence or counterintelligence activities to protect
against international terrorism, or for a national security matter. See 31 U.S.C. 5311. The information
cannot be further released, disseminated, disclosed, or transmitted without prior approval of the Director of
the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network or his authorized delegate. Suspicious activity reports filed under
the BSA must be treated with particular care given that they contain unsubstantiated allegations of possible
criminal activity, akin to confidential informant tips. Such reports, or the fact they have been filed, may not
be disclosed by a government employee to any person involved in the transaction, 'other than as necessary
to fulfill the offidal duties of such officer or employee.' 31 U.S.C. 5318 (g)(2)(il). Unauthorized release of
information collected under the BSA may result in criminal or civil sanctions.
7/1/2011
1; Sides argue whether Jeffrey Epstein's nonprosecution deal violated alleged victims' rights
•
t„)„ f I .
CA: ii( a,d i‘ , Jd. IVNIE. ),\Aic
Page 1 of 4
Friday, August 19, 2011 Subscribe Renew CLASS( Fla
HOME I NEWS I SOCIETY I BUSINESS I ARTS I FASHION I OBITUARIES I OPINION I LIFESTYLES I HOME,
I CONTACT US
Electronic Edition Now Avail
It's the new way to read the new
Home > Palm Beach News
Sides argue whether Jeffrey Epstein's nonprosecution deal violated alleged
victims' rights
LATEST NEWS
Boys' 3-on-3 basketball
tournament set at Rosarian
Academy
Proposal to abolish airport
noise committee withdrawn
Landmarks suggests
changes to Nagler Memorial
Bridge aesthetics
Fire-Rescue puts out fire in
Breakers' roof
North End Georgian-style
house sells for S12.475 million
By DAVID ROGERS
DAILY NEWS STAFF WRITER
Updated: 7:57 p.m. Friday, Aug. 12, 2011
Posted: 7:14 p.m. Friday, Aug. 12, 2011
E-mail I Print I Share I Larger Type
U.S. District Judge Kenneth Marra is set to decide in the coming
days whether the rights of two alleged victims of Palm Beach sex
offender Jeffrey Epstein were violated when the U.S. Attorney's
Office failed to confer with them before signing a non-prosecution
agreement in September 2007.
Attorneys Brad Edwards and Paul Cassell, representing Jane Doe
No. 1 and Jane Doe No. 2, argued Friday in federal court in West
Palm Beach that the government's action violated the girls' rights
under the federal Crime Victims' Rights Act.
Edwards and Cassell want the agreement nullified and want Marra to
unseal un-redacted plea deal correspondence between the U.S.
Attorney's Office and Epstein's defense team. If he agrees, that
action could spur a federal case that might expose Epstein to a
longer incarceration if convicted.
After Palm Beach police received a complaint about Epstein in spring
2005, more than 30 young women participated in civil lawsuits that
alleged he lured them to his home for sexually charged rubdowns
and/or sex in exchange for cash when they were minors. Some
cases were dismissed, and others were settled.
Ste —Min— g Oetc2-- a- S°
http://www.paimbeachdaftynews.cominews/sides-argue-whether-jeffrey-epsteins-nonprose... 8/19/2011
ti Sides argue whether Jeffrey Epstein's nonprosecution deal violated alleged victims' rights Page 2 of 4
• •
Epstein, now 58, pleaded not guilty in August 2006 in state court.
Eventually he agreed to a state plea deal and served 13 months of
an 18-month sentence for soliciting a minor for prostitution and
soliciting prostitution — but only after his attorneys successfully
argued for the federal non-prosecution pact.
The U.S. attorneys sent letters to Jane Doe No. 1 and No. 2 twice in
2008 describing their case as being under federal investigation —
even though a non-prosecution agreement had been created the
previous year and had been kept secret from the young women,
according to Edwards. Edwards said the latter action "eviscerated the
rights' of the two women to bring Epstein to justice.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Dexter Lee told Marra that the Crime Victims'
Rights Act dictates that victim notification is triggered only after an
indictment.
Cassell disagreed. "It wasn't designed to be so narrowly
circumscribed," the Fort Lauderdale lawyer said.
Lee said requiring federal attorneys to confer with alleged victims
before they can determine whether an indictment is warranted would
impinge on prosecutorial discretion. "The government believes these
rights would attach only after a formal indictment, Lee said.
Marra questioned that assertion. "I think we wouldn't be here if your
office had conferred with the victims, heard them out,' and explained
why prosecution wasn't pursued, the judge said.
Lee countered that alleged victims have no right to confer with the
government when the government is not "In the case?
The Judge reserved ruling on the plaintiffs' motion to unseal the
federal attorneys' plea deal correspondence with Epstein's legal
team.
He gave famed criminal defense attorney Roy Black two weeks to
submit materials explaining why the letters should not be turned over
to the two young women's lawyers. The U.S. Attorney's Office will
then have two weeks to respond, then the plaintiffs' team will have a
week to respond. Black will then have a week to deliver his final reply
to the judge.
Black had argued that the correspondence was protected by attorney
-client privilege. "Any statements made in regard to plea bargaining
are immunized" whether related to statements of culpability or not,
Black said. "This is classic work product we sent to the government."
. • -
Share this article:
COMMENTS
http://www.palmbeachdailynews.com/news/sides-argue-whether-jeffrey-epsteins-nonprose... 8/19/2011
╔═══════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Michael Harrigan [usvi] St. Thomas / St. John islands school administrator 
╚════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02389172 (Jmail)
 [girls] letter from Michael Harrigan to INS recommending "genius" visa for someone
[Please insert on your letterhead]
[Please insert the date here[
US DHS CIS
Vermont Service Center
30 Houghton Street
St. Albans, VT 05478
Re: Ms.
Dear Sir or Madam:
O-IB Application
I am writing this letter on behalf of Ms. , a communications and public
relations professional of extraordinary ability.
My name is Michael Harrigan and I am the Deputy Insular Superintendent of Schools for St.
Thomas and St. John districts of the US Virgin Islands. As with the rest of the United States, we are
trying to promote STEM education in the US Virgin Islands. Ms. through the Enhanced
Education, helped create a STEM Competition for our school districts (STEM stands for Science,
Technology, Engineering, and Math). STEM Fair and is the largest student science fair in the USVI,
organized by the Virgin Islands Department of Education, and brought together hundreds of grade
school students from across the islands, to showcase their science work for awards.
The Foundation supplied more than a hundred Microsoft Surface 2 computers, Touch
keyboards and Nylon Sleeves for Microsoft Surface. The foundation also provided funds to host the
STEM Fair, and travel and accommodations funds for the winners and chaperones to attend the STEM
summer camps. The caliber of the 165 projects at the STEM fair were astounding. One II year old
prize winner, showed how to power a calculator with a penny instead of batteries.
Other projects included a solar powered speed boat and a juicer made from a garbage door motor and
recycled dishwasher parts. The top scorers in each category were given a trophy, a STEM plaque,
certificate and an iPad. Categories ranged from science research, demonstrations, math real world
problem investigations, math real world models, music technology and software programming.
The importance of promoting STEM education is crucial. The United States needs more
students studying in the STEM fields. Therefore, STEM Fairs and Camps play a very, very important
role for the US education and our future. Nevertheless, there is not much interest in STEM studies
from students. We need to change this around the country. We need to make the STEM fields
attractive to our youth. For that, we need money and people like Ms. —Ms.
through Enhanced Education, played a leading role in setting up the fair, raising the funds and making
it happen thanks to her amazing public relations and fundraising capabilities. Ms. raised
$86,000 for us through the foundation. $56,000 for 103 Microsoft Surface 2 computers, $20,000 for
the expenses for hosting the STEM Fair, and $10,000 for the travel and accommodations expenses for
the winners and chaperones to attend the US Engineering and Science Festival in Washington, DC on
April 26 and 27. $86,000 may sound like a small amount for some, but, for our students, it made a
huge difference and impact. Attracting interest in the STEM fields is a challenge and Ms.
overcame that challenge with ease and grace. Raising money for such endeavors is harder and Ms.
helped us raise more than enough to organize a world class event. Without the role she
played for us with Enhanced Education, we simply couldn't have achieved what we achieved.
Moreover, she really cares for our children and their future success. We are looking forward to
working with her in our future fairs and camps.
Therefore I wholeheartedly recommend her O-1B visa application. We need professionals
like Ms. with extraordinary skills and abilities. We need it for our children, we need it for
our future.
Sincerely yours,
Michael Harrigan
EFTA02731412 (Jmail)
School Choice Week
Navigate Schools with Ease OPEN' >
EFTA02731418 (Jmail)
I I Tifite.
1111111111111
&t.ff4c-.1.1--77
Li-J uilis
MI p a ils, • r is. •

╭──── Page 1, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
╔═════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 Ted Leonsis [tech] AOL executive, owner of Monumental Sports (Wizards, Capitals) 
╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02731420 (Jmail)
 [diary] victim diary naming Larry Summers, Prince Andrew, Dan Snyder, Leon Black, Ted Leonsis
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
That my mom lied about Mr. Glickman all the time.
She lied about work trips about Michigan and about Clearwater.
Now he is dead and I am being sent to live with her friend.
Back and forth?
For how long?
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
Went to a party at this huge house to meet this man named Mr. Robert and his pretty wife Jill.
Same exact British lady from Clearwater was there! She talked to me all night.
She wants me to come to her house in Florida so I can learn new things!
to get away from Mary?
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
THERE WERE ...
[clipping: moments of humor, compassion, and warmth],
but now....
I think I may be:
[clipping: LOST]
is this normal?
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
[Clipping: MEMORY] what is that stuff!
What is that feeling?
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
No one can prepare you for this shit.
I am so fucking lost.
Why did Mr. Colgan agree to this!
Jeffrey treats me like I'm "special" property, and when I need Ghislaine she is working and Mary
is just as bat shit crazy as my mom.
Joe Gibbs is so nice but Dan Snyder is a pig! A red skin hoggett(sp?)!
The other girls well some are nice, but 3 I hate!
Alice in fucking Wonderland?
For them .....
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
Thank God, my parents picked me up.
For being a Rockefeller that plane Mr. Dana had me on was scary!
Both he and Larry Summers are fucking disgusting!
Hope no relation to Tracy!
I guess it is a royal thing. Gross!
Andrew is like his brother in this way!
should not brag because that was yucky!
Does this lady know you can't have any dignity if you've been with him?
I know I have none. Only skittles.
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
I am very sorry little one.
What are these bets and why do I have to take photos?
I am lost. Mr. Mody. Mr. Robert. Mr. Sant. Mr. Ludwig. Mr. Cecchi. Mr. Mora.
Mr. Goodlatte. Mr. Atkins are not who they say!
Run run run!
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
Walk down Madison Avenue to 71st St.
My mother has lost her fucking mind. Even though Ghislane said it was best to take me home
because Mr. Black is so important for some reason over my health.
There is going to be hell to pay. I ruined their trip and I am dramatic when that fat fuck bit me!
He threw me on the floor and blood all over Jeffreys carpet and I am the issue?
Who the fuck bites someone? Sick!
No one is that important and Leon can go fuck himself.
I hate New York !
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
[page with a poem entitled "Stopped Dead"]
Leon Black.
Underlined words in the poem:
birth,
cry,
fatso millionaire,
it's violent,
goddamn baby screaming,
there's always a bloody baby,
your seven chins,
still as a ham.
[clipping "protected from the little girl lost"] ....me
I am so so sorry I keep failing
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
I no longer have 365, I have none.
It goes to anyone but me and I am tired.
People you think are good are bad like the CEOs who pretend!
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
[Next to sonogram photo]
I heard the heart beat even when she put her hands over my ears.
Arent pictures enough for them?
Torture!
Should I
deeply miss them?
Have these all been .... [MURDERS]?
Does this make me a [KILLER]?
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
They are always flights of horror.
Whether its with Jeffrey, Mr. Leonsis, Mr. Case, Mr. Snyder, the Gregorys, Mr. Colgan or one
being borrowed by a seemingly "good" federal worker and even rented,
it is all horror.
And nothing is as it seems.
I am so confused by everything and people you expect to be good like even old senators like
George Mitchell who you think would be good like a grandpa are bad.

Mr. Kimsey is deranged.
The answer is c. crazy!
It all is!
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
[clipping of gorillas]
CONFIDENTIAL
╔══════════════════════════════════════════════ new names in next file ═╗
 George Vradenburg [tech] AOL/Time Warner General Counsel (top lawyer) 
╚═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
EFTA02731465 (Jmail)
 [diary] victim diary naming Jes Staley, Ted Leonsis, George Vradenburg, references tinkerbell
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
turned 17 years old on I
To send you away and take away your life.
Ticking time with shortened schedules and waving all my absent days to fit the scheduling of
vile men!
Was worth it?
No do not answer that.
I know I never have been.
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
I will never be able to forgive myself for not being able to tell you what Ms. Vicki does and what
really happens in FL and CA.
I hope you dont ever meet fat pig Weinstein or the rest.
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
It doesnt matter how far away you are.
No matter how good you think they are.
Even the old president! They will get you.
He should have been thinking of Chelsea! Gross!
In a plane on a yacht in NY, in DC, at the vineyard.
On the island. In palm beach.
It doesnt matter.
Disgusting pigs like Allen Douschewitz and Mr. Caruthers and even Mr. Islam will hurt you
especially if Ghislaine is busy or not with you!
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
I feel broken and exhausted.
I am so fucking tired of this sick and twisted "game" that is causing such physical and emotional
pain!
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
These pigs who call themselves smart and talk about Harvard act worse than animals!
They make a bad name for animals!
Just fucking sick!

Mr. Sauerkraut krauss and martin minsky are gross but I felt sort of sorry for Mr. Novak.
He was as uncomfortable as me.
Ivy League schools do not equal smart or good.
It seems more like trash!
Yucky but they cant behave!
The disgusting Mr. staley if anyone ever calls me tinkerbell again I will lose my mind
He left bloody marks on my arms from his belt and thought he had had the right to call me that
when he has ears as big as a dumbo.
I should have called him that in return!
You've been a very very.... [clipping: Naughty girl]
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
I think I'm going to break!
Why would they all allow Mr. Leonsis wait this long?
Why would he bring a friend and make a video?
I am so broken and the procedure was so painful and blood all over the sheets.
I cant play this "game" anymore.
I have to ask Ghislaine for help.
If anyone can make it stop it would be her?
She was so scared because I got so sick and was burning up with a fever.
She put me in freezing cold shower!
I cant do this!

Mr. Rails and Mr. Ein [clipping: blood on their hands]
but so does Jeffrey and Mr. Jacobson. Mr. Conway
Mr. vradenberg and Bill s.
All of them who dont care if this happens!
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
The game stopped but not in a way I thought.
I did not have to go with anyone except Jeffrey and now he and Ghislaine are fighting because I
am now over 20 weeks with a baby we are certain is his and
I had to go to the Bahamas like this!
And for some reason no plan has been made because he does not want a procedure and she does
and I am certain this is time critical but they won't stop fighting!
I do not want to be tied to Jeffrey for the rest of my life!
playing the piano well is not a good reason to think someone has good genes or should have a
baby!
What about Ghislaine?
I am too young and he is too old!
Why is no one doing anything!
I dont understand!
I dont want this!
I dont want another painful procedure but I do not want this!
[under clippings of AOL, Stay Alert...]
That company does not protect kids!
They use it to find us!
And they are everywhere!
I cannot escape!
CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL FOR ATTORNEY'S EYES ONLY
DO NOT COPY
glued two photos of girls she was there with.
The white female on left side of the page -
says they talked about ballet because danced on pointe (ballet shoes) and so did this
girl. She says sometimes they called her by two names - she thinks it was but is not
absolutely certain — but she was sometimes just called Or - but is not sure
how it was spelled.
The girl on right side of the page — says "was insanely beautiful" and "exotic" looking.
Her name sounded foreign and said it was a "peculiar" name; she would not even guess
how to say/spell it. She did not believe this girl was foreign because she spoke like an average
american girl.
CONFIDENTIAL
EFTA02731521 (Jmail)
IIIIIIII111111111
/7a,//t77.1
I
I
t.---i-
1
IrP )
1 .
1 . 40 .
al I=
il
I
a
!

╭──── Page 3, Image 1 ─────╮
│ (no text found in image) │
╰──────────────────────────╯
EFTA02731525 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage from Leon Black (???) screenshot(s)
6:33
Leon >
iMessage
Thu, Mar 18, 8:18 AM
Dearer I was shocked to see
yesterday supposedly from
..I cannot
imagine that you would make these
statements...they're not true and you
must appreciate how damaging they
would be to me and my reputation.
Can you please call me and let me
know what's going on? Thank you,
Leon
CS iMessage
EFTA02731576 (Jmail)
 [girls] iMessage to Leon Black making contemporaneous accusations
12:07 LTE
O Leon>
Text Message
Mon, Oct 15, 10:06 AM

Hi. I would like to have a copy of the
NDA I signed. Can you please email
it to me to <REDACTED>
Thank you.
Tue, Oct 16, 12:59 PM
Leon. You sexually harassed me,
sex trafficked me, raped me, and
eventually blacklisted me. I don't
know for how much longer it will
take me, on my own, to process the
pain your caused to me and my
family. The least thing you can do is
to give me that document that I was
forced to sign under duress and
wasn't able to read before signing.
Unfortunately I am still tied to you...
EFTA02731704 (Jmail)
School Choice Week
D> Navigate Schools with Ease
EFTA02731712 (Jmail)
.AC‘
14.
aer
ff tw e itp. : 44 ." 4 .. a r; t
„ of 46X ,
• ‘r.".
EFTA02731726 (Jmail)
 [junk] 
From:
To:
Subject Accepted: Leon Mac ca
EFTA02731728 (Jmail)
 [junk] 
From: <REDACTED>
To: <REDACTED>; <REDACTED>
Subject: Canceled: Leon Black
Importance: High
<REDACTED> and I just spoke --I will fill you in.